Competing Equalities LAW AND THE BACKWARD CLASSES IN INDIA Marc Galanter University of California Press Berkeley Lo...
482 downloads
2703 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Competing Equalities LAW AND THE BACKWARD CLASSES IN INDIA Marc Galanter University of California Press Berkeley Los Angeles London iii University of California Press Berkeley and Los Angeles, California University of California Press, Ltd. London, England © 1984 by The Regents of the University of California Printed in the United States of America 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Galanter, Marc, 1931 Competing equalities. Bibliography: p. Includes index. 1. MinoritiesLegal status, laws, etc.India. 2. Untouchables Legal status, laws, etc.India. 3. IndiaScheduled tribesLegal status, laws, etc. 4. Civil rightsIndia. I. Title. LAW 342. 54'0873 822017 ISBN 0520042891 345. 402873 AACR2 iv TO MY FATHER JACOB GALANTER 18961972 Justice, justice you shall pursue ( Deut. 16:20)
v Contents List of Tables x Foreword by M. Hidayatullah
xiii
Preface xvii Acknowldegements xxi Note on Citations and References xxiii Note on State Names xxiv List of Abbreviations xxv Introduction 1 PART ONE: COMPENSATORY DISCRIMINATION: THE SETTING AND THE POLICIES 5 Chapter 1. The Compartmental Society 7 Chapter 2. Reform, Mobility, and Politics under British Rule 18 Chapter 3. Compensatory
Discrimination Programs and Their Implementation 41 A. Legislative reservations 44 B. Education and other schemes 55 C. Administration 64 D. Critics, costs, and benefits 72
Chapter 4. Reservations in Government Employment: A Closer Look at the Paradigm Program 84 A. The scope of reservations 86 B. The effectiveness of reservations 93 C. Assessing the costs and benefits 105
PART TWO: IDENTIFYING THE BENEFICIARIES 119
Chapter 5. The Designation of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes 121 A. The invention of the Scheduled Castes 122 B. Scheduled Castes under the Constitution 131 C. The Scheduled Tribes 147
vii Chapter 6. The Other Backward Classes: The Process of Designation 154 A. The prehistory of the backward classes category 154 B. The constitutional design 159 C. The failure to centralize policy 167 D. The varied state patterns 179
Chapter 7. The Backward Classes and the Judiciary: The
Selection of Beneficiary Classes 188 A. Castes as classes 188 B. The permissibility of noncommunal classes 204 C. The utility of communal units 209 D. Forbidden classifications and the burden of proof 215
Chapter 8. The Backward Classes and the Judiciary: The Measure of Backwardness: 222 A. Educational backwardness 223 B. Social backwardness 229 C. Cumulative backwardness 240 D. Underrepresentation 243 E. Absolute vs. relative backwardness 246 F. The sufficiency of data
249 G. Economic tests 261 H. Geographical criteria 277 I. Noninclusion claims 279
Chapter 9. Membership in Groups Entitled to Preferential Treatment 282 A. Reading the schedules 283 B. Caste and sect 290 C. Tribe 293 D. Tribe and caste 295 E. Religion 305 F. Group integrity: admission, expulsion, readmittance 326 G. Noncommunal criteria: income and occupation tests 341 H. Conclusion: pragmatic and formal solutions
348
Chapter 10. Social Identity and Judicial Action 352
PART THREE: COMPENSATORY DISCRIMINATION AND THE JUDICIAL PROCESS 361 Chapter 11. The Constitutional Scope of the Compensatory Discrimination Policy 363 A. Preferential treatment in the context of Fundamental Rights 364
viii B. The scope of the constitutional provisions for special treatment 368 C. The exceptional character of compensatory discrimination 377 D. A new constitutional vista? Thomas and after 382
Chapter 12. The Scope and Extent of Preferences: Constitutional Limits and Judicial Control 396 A. How much reservation? The minimum 396 B. How much reservation? The maximum 399 C. The intensity of preference 420 D. The wider use of the reservation device 425 E. The number of beneficiaries 437 F. Benefits other than reservations 441
Chapter 13. The Design and Operation of Compensatory Discrimination Programs: Constitutional Limits and Judicial Control
444 A. Rulefulness and discretion 444 B. Reservations as guaranteed minimums 455 C. Compartments and layers 463 D. Relations between multiple reservations 472
Chapter 14. The Setting and Incidence of Judicial Intervention 477 A. Courts and judges 477 B. Authority and precedent: formal structure and operating norms 490 C. The pattern of litigation 498 D. Lawyers 513
Chapter 15. The Uses of Judicial Action 522 A. The impact on
policy and administration 522 B. Judicial review: the doctrinal accomplishment 533 C. The limits of judicial action 541
CONCLUSION Chapter 16. "The Little Done, the Vast Undone" 547 A. A Costly Success 547 B. Fairness and History 552 C. Secularism and Continuity 559 D. Ex Orient Lux? 562
Appendix: Relevant Sections of the Indian Constitution 569 Bibliography 575 General Index 613
Index of Cases 621 ix Tables 1. Annual Per Capita Expenditure on Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes for the five FiveYear Plans 57 2. School Enrolment as a Percentage of Corresponding Age Group, by Communities, 19731974 60 3. Views of Reservation in Government Employment for Scheduled Castes: Three North Indian Localities in 1968 70 4. Alleged Benefits and Costs of Policy of Compensatory Discrimination 81 5. Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Employment in Central
Government Service, 1953 and 1975 89 6. Scheduled Castes, Scheduled Tribes, and Other Backward Classes in Government Service: Posts Reserved and Posts Held, about 1976 90 7. Approximate Effectiveness of Reservations for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes in Central Government Services over a 21½Year Period (19531975) 96 8. Comparison of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Employment in Government Service and Public Sector Undertakings, Mid1960s 102 9. Comparison of Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe Employment in
Government Service and Public Sector Undertakings, 1975 103 10. Alleged Benefits and Costs of Preferences in Government Employment 106 11. Prior Educational Performance of Successful Candidates for AllIndia Higher Nontechnical Services, 19601965 112 12. Percentage of Untouchables in British India 124 13. Estimates of Untouchable Population in British India by Various Official Bodies, 19171941 125 14. Population of Scheduled Castes in 1941 131 15. Scheduled Castes Population
(in millions) and Percentages, 1950, 1951, 1956, 1961, 1971 133 16. Scheduled Tribes Population 150 17. Scheduled Areas Population 151 18. Concessions for Other Backward Classes, 19511952 163 19. Estimates of Population of Other Backward Classes, Early 1930s 169 x 20. A Profile of Other Backward Classes in the Late 1970s 216 21. Relative Success of Selected Castes on Merit and on Selection by Incomecum Occupation Test in Mysore Engineering Colleges, 1963 271
22. Contrasting Results of Different Tests of Membership 299 23. Possible Methods of Declaring Winners in a Double Member Constituency 458 24. A Comparison of Upper and Lower Strata of Backward Classes in Tamil Nadu 464 25. Subject Matter of Reported Litigation on Compensatory Discrimination, 19501977 501 26. Initiating and Successful Parties in Compensatory Discrimination Litigation, 19501977 502 27. Regional Distribution of Litigation about (Other) Backward Classes 506 28. Subject Matter of Supreme Court
Litigation about Compensatory Discrimination 506 xi Foreword PROFESSOR MARC GALANTER has written an informative and educative treatise on the Indian experience with what he terms "compensatory discrimination," a subject which deals with the Indian Constitutional policies to safeguard the interests of the historically disadvantaged sections of the population. At the present moment there is considerable debate in India whether this compensatory discrimination is not an unfair measure, as it keeps out deserving persons and promotes others not so qualified. In fact, there is growing evidence of a confrontation between persons who have received the benefit of reservation and those who have not. The issues resemble recent cases in which the United States Supreme Court has attempted to balance preferred treatment for blacks against the claims of whites, complaining of a sort of discrimination in reverse. This book is divided into three parts. The first part describes these policies and their background. The second part deals with the problem of identifying the recipients of this discriminatory advantage. The various aspects of these problems are treated very fully, and the concluding chapter summarises "the implications of the governmental superimposition of official categories of beneficiaries in the complex process of group and personal identity for the role of the courts in implementing the compensatory discrimination policy." The third part deals with the Constitutional provisions which embody this policy and with the laws which have implemented it and the judicial decisions which apply these provisions. Finally, the Conclusion tries to assess the achievements of these programmes in India in the light of the problems that are inherent in such a policy. The problem of disadvantaged sections of the population has existed in India for centuries, but it acquired special importance after the First World War when a system of protections began to be evolved. Later that system came to be supported by the concept of human rights and fundamental freedoms in the United Nations Charter and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. In India the special position of the minorities, for a long time, has xiii been an ineluctable fact of political life. From the time of the Indian National Congress session held in Karachi in 1931 and the Nehru and Sapru Reports, it was consistently felt that in order to create a homogenous egalitarian society and to achieve national unity, balance between the various communities in India was essential. Jawaharlal Nehru posed the problem thus: "How shall we promote the unity of India and yet preserve the rich diversity of our inheritance?" The Preamble of our Constitution resolves to secure "JUSTICE, social, economic and political," to all its citizens. It further proclaims as one of its aims the promotion among them of "FRATERNITY assuring the dignity of the individual and the unity of the nation." Minorities in India enjoy the guarantees of equality before the law (Article 14), prohibition of discrimination on grounds of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth (Article 15); equality of opportunity in matters of public employment (Article 16), the wellknown rights to freedom (Article 19), the right to freedom of conscience and free profession, practice, and freedom in religion or sections thereof (Article 26). The Constitution also confers certain rights specifically on minority groups: the right to conserve a minority group's distinct language, script, or culture, and the right to establish and administer educational institutions of the group's choice (Articles 29 and 30). In
addition to religious minorities and linguistic minorities the Constitution specifically recognises Scheduled Castes (untouchables), Scheduled Tribes, and socially and educationally backward classes and guarantees to them protection. Article 17 decrees the abolition of untouchability. Article 46 requires the State to promote with special care the educational and economic interests of the backward citizens and in particular of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and imposes a duty on the State to protect them from social injustice and all forms of exploitation. The Governors have been given special responsibility in this connection. The Constitution also provides that the Commissioner for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and the Commissioner for Minorities have to submit periodic reports, which are placed before Parliament and which are open to discussion. Reports have been submitted by many commissions, making suggestions for protecting the interests of the minorites. The rights of minorities have been implemented by statutory enactments. These rights have been supported and their scope and ambit clarified by decisions of the Supreme Court and the various High Courts from time to time. In spite of the consistent commitment to minority rights, there is insufficient awareness of the laws on the subject, not only among the people directly affected, but also among some of those who are concerned with the administration of these laws. The xiv absence of discrimination and the protection of minority groups are the tests of the political and moral achievement of the society. The creation of a just social order as envisaged in our Constitution (Article 38) requires a social consciousness and active cooperation of all the sections of the society. Professor Marc Galanter has written exhaustively of the history of the disadvantages and the revolt against these disadvantages. In his account, he has mentioned all the cases decided in the different High Courts and the Supreme Court which provide valuable help in understanding the objectives embodied in our Constitution in the light of our commitments to democracy and socialism. This book will be of immense use not only to the members of the legal profession but also to those who have at heart the achievement of national integration. It will contribute to the shaping of public opinion as well as to the enhancement of discussion of these matters by professionals and policy makers. It comes none too soon, as a great debate is going on, on the various aspects of the reservation policy. Vice President's Residence M. Hidayatullah New Delhi B.A. (Nag.), M.A. (Cantab.), LL.D. 16 March 1981 Bencher, Lincoln's Inn xv Preface IN 1957, NOT LONG after graduating from law school, I went forth on a Fulbright Scholarship to study India's efforts to abolish untouchability. Ready to see these efforts through my American "civil rights" lenses, I was struck by the fact that measures to enforce civil rights of a sort familiar to me were overshadowed by programs, of preferential treatment. The principle of systematic preference in favor of historically deprived groups was incorporated into a constitutional order with a strong emphasis on evenhanded application of law. The notion that commitment to equality might entail policies of preferential treatment was at that time hardly conceivable in the American setting. A few years later, it was with a sense of familiarity, that I first encountered advocacy of compensatory preference to enable American Blacks (then Negroes) to overcome their historic handicaps. Today such special treatment is a familiar feature of
American lifealthough the legitimacy and efficacy of such programs is still highly controverted. India's long and elaborate experience with kindred policies may contain lessons for American policy. It was not the hope of extracting lessons for America that drew me to this topic, but curiosity about the course of India's pursuit of equality by group preference. Surely this concern reflected events in America, but I experienced it first as part of a challenge to understand India, then (as my perspective shifted) as an intriguing instance of using law to reshape recalcitrant social patterns. Many interruptions and digressions later, I find that this topic has over the years absorbed far more of my time and energy than I ever planned. This book has been long in the writing, and the discerning reader may find outcroppings of the understandings and perspectives that informed various stages of the work. I console myself that such disparities are the price of deepening awareness of the perplexities of the subject. The shape the book has taken over these years is not what I would project if I were to start now with my present views and interests. Were I starting now, I would undoubtedly pay more attention to politics and administration and somewhat less to the courts. As a lawyer, courts xvii were my entrèe into Indian society. The use of courts as an observation point introduces a special bias, but the cases give a texture and immediacy to the account of policy. I have tried to deal with legal materials in sufficient depth to preserve the detail and complexity that make them meaningful to the immediate participants (Indians and mostly, lawyers, judges, and government officials) while making them accessible to those at a distance. Technical legal questions, I submit, should not be dismissed as "merely" technical. It is in a host of detailed questions that the tensions among conflicting commitments must be resolvedand this includes all those commitments which are crystallized into the styles of the participants. At the same time that we see large principles illuminated by their concrete applications, we can observe the interplay of institutional routines and inventiveness that gives the law its kaleidoscopic sense of simultaneous rigidity and fluidity. The courts proved not only a convenient vantage, but interesting to observe in themselves, giving this book what became its second subject. Focussing on the intersection between courts and the compensatory discrimination policy, I use the courts as a way of learning about the policy, and the intersection as one way of learning about the function of courts in Indian society. The courts turned out to be more limited as a vantage point than I naively assumed at the outset. They act as a balance wheel channelling the compensatory policies and accommodating them to other commitments; but it is the political process that shapes the larger contours of these policies and gives them their motive force. Official doctrinejudicial pronouncement or administrative regulationproved an insufficient guide to the shape of the policies in action and the results they produced. For a time I entertained the hope of including a systematic Portrayal and appraisal of the working of each of the various programs, but it belatedly dawned on me that such an enormous undertaking would postponeperhaps permanentlythe completion of this study. So I have contented myself with sketching the lines along which an appraisal loyal to the complexities of these Multigoaled policies might proceed. I have throughout tried to identify the points at which legal arguments depend on empirical assertions, to tease out what evidence I could find relevant to such assertions, and to indicate the yawning gaps that would have to be filled to arrive at a definitive answer to many of these questions. Compensatory discrimination policies are not only an instrumental mechanism but a medium through which the Indians who devise, apply, evade, and attack them express their understanding of their own society. This book, then, may be read as a portrayal of some contemporary Indian discourse about the tensions of hierarchy and equality, group and individual, policy and social
reality. xviii To this discourse I, as an outsider, have a curious and ambivalent relation. I have been intermittently immersed in these questions, my sympathies engaged and my intellect provoked. By writing about these policies from time to time, I have become willynilly a participant in this discoursea queer sort of participant who shares neither an insider's understanding of Indian life nor the necessity of living with the consequences of my observations. Nevertheless, Indian colleagues have been generously supportive and receptive over the years, inducing the conceit that my relative detachment (and my capacity to stumble over what is obvious to the insider) may produce a contribution that usefully complements those of insiders. I do not pretend to a total and aloof neutrality. I do not refrain here from drawing conclusions and proposing interpretations of the Indian Constitution. These are advanced in the spirit of friendly argument. There are no conventional categories for organizing the discussion of this sector of Indian law. Of the alternatives that suggested themselves, I preferred to organize the chapters around logical clusters of related problems, rather than around separate constitutional provisions, specific programs of preferential treatment, or specific problems of administration. Although many sections are organized around a chronological movement, I have made no attempt to adhere to chronological sequence overall. Instead, there are successive cuts into the same deposits from different points on the surface. Since the various topics are closely interrelated, I was faced with a choice between repetition or copious crossreference. I have preferred the latter except where the repetition was small or the matter merited emphasis. This is a dynamic field which became a focus of political controversy in the late 1970s. There are bound to be new policy developments and judicial responses before this is printed; some of the things reported here are bound to be dated or proved wrong in a short time. I hope, though, that the delineation of major problems and the building of conceptual tools for approaching them will outlast some of the more detailed conclusions. In the main I have attempted to trace legal developments through materials available to me through 1978, supplemented by more selective resort to new materials through mid1980. Although the coverage of the last few years is less comprehensive than for earlier years, I believe the book pictures the major contours of policy as they stood at the replacement of the Janata Government by a resurgent Mrs. Gandhi in early 1980. Between the completion of the manuscript and the checking of the proofs in mid1983, controversy about compensatory discrimination took on a new intensity. The violent and protracted protests against xix reservations in medical colleges that racked Gujarat in early 1981 gave sanguinary expression to the widespread resentment of these policies and their beneficiaries. As conflict has mounted, the fundamentalif not wholly consistentlines of policy have remained unchanged. The courts have elaborated some lines of doctrine in the earlier caselaw. The second Backward Classes Commission (Mandal Commission) reported ( Backward Classes Commission, 1981), proposing a major extension of preferential treatment to a vastly enlarged group of beneficiaries and reviving the varna classifications dismissed by its predecessor a quarter century earlier. The report was tabled in Parliament in April, 1982, and subsequently received parliamentary endorsement, but has not yet been implemented. The scope and intensity of the compensatory policy is very much a live and open question. The Mandal Report revives for replay on the larger national stage all of the questions and perplexities traced in this book. That stage, too, has undergone change. There has been a significant enlargement of the judicial repertoire by the addition of a more proactive and innovative
style associated with the rubric of "public interest litigation." There have emerged new advocacy groups with aspirations and capacities to mobilize this kind of judicial response on behalf of constituencies of the dispossessed ( Galanter, 1984). Until now, none of this "public interest law" has been directly concerned with compensatory discrimination. The coming major round of adjudication may involve courts and litigants equipped with enhanced capabilities to address the fundamental questions of policy implicit in the commitment to the compensatory principle. xx Acknowledgments THIS BOOK HAS gone through several cycles of growth. In each it has benefitted from many stimuli and encouragements. The United States Educational Foundation in India administered the Fulbright Scholarship which gave me my first taste of Indian law and life. A year working at Stanford Law School provided the occasion to immerse myself in Indian constitutional law. A decade of participation in the vigorous South Asianist community at the University of Chicago enlarged my appreciation for the complexities of India. A Senior Fellowship ( 196566) and a travel grant ( 1978) from the American Institute of Indian Studies enabled me to explore preferential policies in the field. The Indian Law Institute provided a congenial base during my 196566 fieldwork. From time to time, opportunities for helpful exchange were afforded by a number of institutions, including notably the Faculty of Law and the Department of Sociology of the University of Delhi, and the Indian Council of Social Science Research. My studies of this cluster of problems received valuable encouragement from the Joint Committee on South Asia (of the American Council of Learned Societies and the Social Science Research Council) and from the Institute for Research on Poverty of the University of Wisconsin. Between the inception of this project and its completion there emerged a vigorous scholarly community devoted to the study of law in its social context. I have enjoyed the privilege of working at two foci of this communityat Buffalo and Madison. My involvement in this "law and society" community both delayed and enriched this book. At various times the International Legal Studies program of Stanford University, the Committee on Southern Asian Studies, the College, and the Law School of the' University of Chicago, the Research Committee of the Graduate School of the University of Wisconsin and the Ford Foundation have provided support enabling this work to reach fruition. Over the years a number of colleagues were kind enough to read various parts of the manuscript. Their comments have enriched the book and have helped eliminate some of its flaws (not without making xxi me aware of others not so readily eradicable). For this I am grateful to Phyllis Rolnick Arora, Upendra Baxi, Boris I. Bittker, Rajeev Dhavan, Clarence Dias, George H. Gadbois, Jr., John Mansfield, S. P. Sathe, R. A. Schermerhorn, and especially to M. G. Narasimha Swamy. I have been the beneficiary of many forms of kindness and fellowship from colleagues who helped me to locate materials, shared their work in progress, and gave generously of their time and intelligence to educate me. Such a list is necessarily incomplete, but I should like to take this occasion to express my thanks to Partap Aggarwal, Vimal Chandra, Suma Chitnis, P. A. Choudhary, Bhagwan Das, J. D. M. Derrett, V. V. Deshpande, Lelah Dushkin, Joseph Elder, Marcus Franda, Henry C. Hart, L. G. Havanur, B. R. L. Iyengar, S.K. Kaul, P. R. Mehendirotta, N. R. Madhava Menon, N. G. Nag, N. P. Rege, Vimal Shah, G. S. Sharma, Parmanand Singh, M. N. Srinivas,
Gregory Stanton, Richard Taub, and Eleanor Zelliott. The late Professor Max Rheinstein provided guidance and encouragement as well as his towering example in the comparative study of law. I was particularly fortunate in having access to the South Asian collections of the University of Chicago and the University of Wisconsin, and the assistance and support of Maureen L. P. Patterson and Jack Wells, who preside over those collections. At various times in the life of this project invaluable help in preparing the manuscript was provided by Betti Arnett Johnson, Doreen Blank, Cynthia Burns, Judith Frank, Eve Galanter, and Mary L. Galanter. Marge Eiseman did the final round with great skill and verve. Seth Galanter conscientiously numbered the manuscript sheets. Janet Guthrie, Catherine S. Meschievitz, and Hugh A. Ross ably provided crucial assistance. Robert Hayden was a source of encouragement and helpful criticism as he worked with me in reviving and revising the manuscript. In the arduous and seemingly endless task of reading the proofs and preparing the Index, I was fortunate to have the capable help of Susan Bissegger, Michael Macy, and Sylvan Sobel. The title of the concluding chapter is borrowed from Upendra Baxi's 1967 article. I want to thank Jean Lettofsky for the Hebrew calligraphy. My wife, Eve, and my children, Seth, Rachel and Sarah, graciously abided the protracted intrusion of this incubus. The views set forth hereeven when they contradict one anotherare my own and should not be attributed to my benefactors. xxii Note on Citations and References LAW REPORT CITATIONS of the judgments of courts are given in standard Indian legal form. Thus citations of official reports give the names of the first party on each side, the notation I.L.R. (indicating Indian Law Reports), the volume number, the title of the series (indicating the court), the page on which the case begins, and, finally the date of publication; for example Gopal v. Hanmant, I.L.R. 3 Bom. 273 (1879). Citations to the AllIndia Reporter, the most popular series of unofficial reports, follow a slightly different pattern; for example, Sunder Devi v. Jheboo Lal, A.I.R. 1957 All. 215 (names, A.I.R. series, year of publication, name of court, page on which case begins). There is a separate A.I.R. volume published each year for each court. The coverage of A.I.R. and I.L.R. is overlapping but not identical. Occasionally, cases not found in either of these series are reported in a local or specialized series. The citation of these follows a similar pattern. Articles, books, monographs, etc., cited by author and year in the notes, are listed in the bibliography. A similar style is used for government documents (except Census of India publications, which are cited in standard style in the footnotes). PreIndependence government documents are cited by the name of the committee, commission, or other government body from which they issued (identified in some cases by the name of the chairman). PostIndependence government documents, reports of commissions, study teams, committees, and other nonserial documents are cited by the name of the body (identified in some cases by the name of the chairman) and the year of publication. In some cases where such a body operated under the auspices of a Ministry, the name of the body has been added to the author listing. Other government documents are cited by the Ministry or other government body under whose auspices they are issued and the year of publication. Where a series is listed in the references under a specific agency, a citation of that body and a specific year means the report for that year. Government publications with named authors are cited by author. Some reports and series that are cited frequently are indicated by abbreviations found in the list below.
xxiii Note on State Names IN ADDITION TO the three presidencies ( Bengal, Bombay, and Madras) and the other provinces of' British India, there were hundreds of princely or native states which recognized the paramountcy of the British Crown. Most were small, but a few were the magnitude of provinces (e.g., Mysore, Hyderabad). When, at Independence, British India was partitioned into the new nations of India and Pakistan, various princely states joined the former provinces as units of the Indian federation, the smaller states being combined for this purpose. The resulting array of states included units quite disparate in scale. A surge of linguistic sentiment led to the separation of Andhra from Madras in 1953. In 1956 there was a general reorganization of states; boundaries were redrawn largely on linguistic lines, and the vestiges of the princely states were largely effaced. For example, old ("Princely") Mysore was combined with the Kannadaspeaking parts of Madras, Bombay, and Hyderabad to produce a new and large Mysore; the composite (former Princely) State of TravencoreCochin was combined with the Malabar District of Madras to form the single Malayalamspeaking State of Kerala. The 1956 changes produced the basic map of India as it is today. Subsequently, two remaining bilingual states bifurcated: Bombay divided into Maharashtra and Gujarat in 1960; Punjab divided into Punjab and Haryana in 1966. A series of small tribal states have since been established in the northeast. Two name changes should be kept in mind: Madras changed its name to Tamil Nadu in 1969; Mysore became Karnataka in 1973. xxiv List of Abbreviations A.I.R. AllIndia Reporter BC Backward Classes. BCC Report of the Backward Classes Commission ( 1955). CAD Constituent Assembly Debates ( 194750). CWSCST Reports of the Parliamentary Committee on the Welfare of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. The Reports are de signated by the number of the Lok Sabha, the number of the report (page no. if any after colon), date and the year issued. E.g., CWSCST (4th) 18: 27 ( 1970). G.O. Government Order LSD Lok Sabha Debates. Materials from these reports is cited by series, volume, number, column, and date. E.g., LSD (4th Series) Vol. 86, No. 3, Cols. 14243 (12 June 1963). [NIC] Cases so noted are not included in the computations in chapter
14 which form the basis of aggregate statements throughout the text. OBC Other Backward Classes. RCSCST Reports of the Commissioner for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. These reports are designated by the period covered by the report, rather than by the report number or by date of publication. E.g., RCSCST 195758: I, 35. RSD Rajya Sabha Debates. Material from these reports is cited vol ume, number, column, and date. E.g., RSD Vol. 102, No. 6, Cols. 11819 (14 Aug. 1970). SASTC Reports of the Scheduled Areas and Scheduled Tribes Commis sion ( 1961). SC Scheduled Caste(s). ST Scheduled Tribe(s). STTDP Report of the Study Team on Tribal Development Programs ( 1970). Lakh A unit of one hundred thousand (100,000). Crore A unit of ten million (10,000,000). xxv Introduction INDIA'S SYSTEM OF preferential treatment for historically disadvantaged sections of the population is unprecedented in scope and extent. India embraced equality as a cardinal value against a background of elaborate, valued, and clearly perceived inequalities. Her constitutional policies to offset these proceeded from an awareness of the entrenched and cumulative nature of group inequalities. The result has been an array of programs that I call, collectively, a policy of compensatory discrimination. If one reflects on the propensity of nations to neglect the claims of those at the bottom, I think it is fair to say that this policy of compensatory discrimination has been pursued with remarkable persistence and generosity (if not always with vigor and effectiveness) for the past thirty years. These compensatory discrimination policies entail systematic departures from norms of equality (such as merit, evenhandedness, and indifference to ascriptive characteristics). These departures are justified in several ways: First, preferential treatment may be viewed as needed assurance of personal fairness, a guarantee against the persistence of discrimination in subtle and indirect forms. Second, such policies are justified in terms of beneficial results that they will presumably promote: integration, use of neglected talent, more equitable distribution, etc. With these two the anti
discrimination theme and the general welfare theme is entwined a notion of historical restitution or reparation to offset the systematic and cumulative deprivations suffered by lower castes in the past. These multiple justifications point to the complexities of pursuing such a policy and of assessing its performance. Independent India firmly and explicitly embraced the compensatory discrimination principle. This book is about the way in which this commitment has been incorporated into a regime of constitutionally guraranteed rights, including notably rights to formal equality, protected by courts equipped with broad powers of judicial review. It is an account of both institutional and intellectual accommodation, of government practice, and of legal doctrine. Among the newer (and almost 1 all older) nations, India is distinctive in the major policy role played by an independent judiciary. Indian courts have been called upon both to resolve disputes among contending claimants and to provide a way of harmonizing these competing principles. The focus of this study is on the response of the courts to these unprecedented demands. This study is divided into three parts. Part One sketches the social setting and historical background of the compensatory discrimination policy, describes the major programs and their administration, and opens the question of assessing their performance. Part Two takes up questions of who: who are those people whose entitlement to equality requires departures from formal equality? Identifying the beneficiaries turns out to be a complicated and difficult process involving many intellectual perplexities. Once there is a commitment to these groups, we come to the cluster of questions addressed by Part Three: what is the scope of the commitment? what means are allowable? how much is too much? and what institutional arrangements shall be established to strike the balance? A Note on Terminology: Why "Compensatory Discrimination"? It is not obvious what these policies should be called, for names are not neutral. (Consider, for example, the contrast between "affirmative action" and "reverse discrimination" in the American setting.) Indian discussion usually refers to "special treatment," "concessions," "privileges," "special provision," or "preferential treatment" for named groups. Scholars have inclined to use "protective 1. More recently, scholarly discrimination" (which I first encountered in Alexandrowicz' 1957 book. 2. writing has adopted the term "compensatory discrimination." Common usages like "special treatment" are accurate but omit any reference to the principles that animate the policies and distinguish them from other distributive schemes. "Protective discrimination" has a paternalistic and static quality; it suggests a oneway flow of beneficence and lacks any implication that it is a policy of change. Thus, of the many unsatisfactory candidates, I prefer "compensatory discrimination" for the following reasons. By using "discrimination" it does not blink at the fact that some are left out, that we are dealing with something more than a benign process of inclusion. At least where ____________________ 1. Alexandrowicz 1957. Among candidates that have failed to gain currency are "progressive discrimination" ( Rudolph and Rudolph 1967: 54n. on analogy to the progressive income tax) and "preferential opportunity" (M. D. Nandajundaswamy in Government of Karnataka 1975, Vol. 1, Pt. II, p. 5) 2. Parmanand Singh 1976. 2 scarce resources are distributed, it employs a principle of selection that is akin to the old discrimination. But the purpose is different: it is not exclusion and relegation but inclusion and recompense both for historic deprivations and to offset present handicaps. And it carries an
implication that discrimination will cease when compensatory treatment has remedied these conditions. The drawback of the term apart from its being ten syllables is that it draws attention away from the nondiscrimination and general welfare themes in these policies. If this name would be 3. it does inappropriate in a setting where the element of historical compensation is less prominent, seem to fit the Indian situation better than the other candidates. To minimize repetition, I have freely resorted to a variety of synonyms and abbreviated forms, such as "preference policy" or simply "preference." Discussions of preferences often founder on the problem of the somewhat confusing names of the groups entitled to receive them. In common Indian usage, the generic term for the groups entitled to receive preferences is the "backward classes." ("Weaker sections" is a rough equivalent for this usage.) This group in turn may be broken down into the Scheduled Castes ("untouchables"), the Scheduled Tribes, and a diverse and less well defined residuum known as the "Other Backward Classes" or sometimes the "backward classes." To minimize confusion I have attempted to indicate which usage of "backward classes" is meant by omitting capitalization when using the term in its broad and inclusive sense and capitalizing it when it is used in the narrower sense. Thus "backward classes" = Scheduled Castes + Scheduled Tribes + Other Backward Classes; "Backward Classes" = Other Backward Classes. ____________________ 3. E.g., to describe "preferential" programs for "Oriental Jews" in Israel, where the programs are justified in terms of integrating groups with little previous contact; the more advanced are not deemed responsible for the deprivations of the less fortunate groups. 3 Part One COMPENSATORY DISCRIMINATION: THE SETTING AND THE POLICIES This is a book about a set of policies and about the role of the Indian judiciary in developing, elaborating, criticizing, effectuating, and legitimizing them. This Part begins with a sketch of the social setting that frames the policy of compensatory discrimination and is the ultimate object of it. Chapter 2 traces the political developments that link this setting to India's modern constitutional order. These broad introductory chapters are intended to make the subject accessible to those who are not specialists on modern Indian society and politics, as well as to introduce themes that recur in later detailed analysis of these policies. Chapter 3 provides a brief overview of the compensatory programs and their administration. Chapter 4 examines in more depth the most prominent of these programs (reservation of government jobs). Chapters 3 and 4 provide a sense of the scope, design, and implementation of these programs and introduce the problems of assessing their performance and of estimating their wider effects. 5 1 The Compartmental Society INDIAN SOCIETY has been described as a "compartmental" society; within it a vast number of groups maintain distinct and diverse styles of life. The system by which these groups are related and mutually accommodated is so complex as to defy general description. However, to place in their setting the legal developments we shall discuss, it is necessary to sketch some of the principal features of India's social order and its recent history. 1. Caste in One of the distinctive and pervasive features of Indian society is the division into caste. the narrower sense applies primarily to the Hindus, who make up 85% of India's population. Many features of caste are also found among nonHindu groups, and the term "caste" as used here applies
to these groups as well as to Hindus. There are exceptions to almost any statement that can be made about caste, but only the most prominent exceptions will be noted here. The term "caste" itself has a variety of meanings. It takes on different shadings in the context of village, locality, region, and nation. 2. It is in effect a set of ____________________ 1. The word "caste" is not an indigenous Indian term but a graft via English (from the Portuguese casta). It is used to correspond to several Indian terms, but has no exact equivalent in Indian languages. Serious students of Indian society regard it as suspect on grounds of both its foreignness ( Marriott and Inden 1974:983) and its ambiguity. Thus Mandelbaum ( 1970: 29) says: "It [the term 'caste'] has been pinned to too many social entities endogamous group, a category of such groups, a system of social organisation. It seems best to use the term, apart from direct quotation, as an adjective that refers to the highly stratified social system." But in the inquiry that we are embarking on there is no way to avoid it, since caste is a key element of contemporary public discourse about the past, present, and future shape of Indian society. Awareness of the ambiguities and multiple referents of the caste notion will illuminate that discourse. Its theoretical insufficiencies do not allow us to dispense with it if we are to know how Indians (especially those educated in English) see their own society any more than we could eliminate equality from a discussion of contemporary American society on grounds of multiple and contradictory meanings attached to it by the natives. 2. And, of course, it has special meanings in the setting of social scientific discourse where it is generally used to describe a system of social organization in which society comprises ranked hereditary kinship groups associated with a division of labor and organized into a unified and integrated whole. The literature is vast. Whether the caste notion is usefully employed outside the South Asian setting is a matter of controversy. 7 3. To start with, a caste may be taken to mean shifting idioms for talking about affiliation and status. a jati 4. an endogamous group bearing a common name and claiming a common origin, membership in which is hereditary, linked to one or more traditional occupations, imposing on its members certain obligations and restrictions in matters of social intercourse, and having a more or 5. It has been estimated that there are 2,000 less determinate position in a hierarchical scale of ranks. 6. The or 3,000 such castes (or subcastes, as they are sometimes called) in presentday India. population of these endogamous caste groups may range from hundreds to millions. An estimate 7. places the median size of such groups at between 5,000 and 15,000.
Membership in the caste group is ordinarily conferred by birth and is unalterable, although it may be lost by expulsion from the group. Members normally marry within the group; most social intimacy occurs within it. Ordinarily, one does not dine with those who are outside the caste. Members of the caste follow a common round of life. They have a characteristic diet, domestic routine, style of dress, and round of religious observance. The caste may have distinct forms of religious expression: a preference for certain gods, shrines, and modes of worship, its own fasts and feasts. Some cultural characteristics may be shared by all or most castes over a wide geographical area, but others may be distinctive to one or a few castes. Although most castes have a traditional occupation, in only a few especially the skilled artisans is it followed by most members today. Agriculture is in effect open to all groups and is engaged in widely by persons belonging to all groups. In many cases, caste tradition precludes entry into certain occupations, while the network of caste ties provides access to others. The caste is held together by ties of kinship, by a cycle of group observances, by bonds of mutual assistance and support, and finally by the power of the group to exact obedience to its rules. Most
castes formerly had (and many today have) councils, or panchayats, formal or informal, which adjudicate disputes among caste member's and enforce ____________________ 3. The multiplicity of usages not only is apparent to the observer but is internalized in the users who can shift categories (e.g., from gross to fine or local to regional) as the occasion requires. Cf. Mandelbaum 1970: 22. 4. Jati is a term of wide application meaning kind or genus. Jatis are seen as natural units of society, each manifesting a specific kind of human possibility. 5. The notion that hierarchic ordering is the central organizing principle of Indian civilization is expressed in the title of Dumont Homo Hierarchicus ( 1970). Kindred notions are shared by scholars who hold otherwise "disparate views of Indian societye.g., Mandelbaum 1970 and Marriott 1955. 6. Ghurye 1969: 27 (2,000); Hutton 1961: 2 (3,000). The latter figure is frequently cited. 7. Marriott and Inden 1974: 983. 8 the received etiquette of relations with other castes. (For example, they take action against those who offend against taboos on eating, drinking, smoking, or sexual intercouse with members of other castes.) Their decisions, backed by the ultimate sanction of excommunication, may involve penalties ranging from fines and expiations to one or another degree of boycott, temporary or permanent. 8. While formal caste sanctions have declined in recent years, especially among the educated, caste opinion and caste loyalty remain powerful cohesive and regulatory forces. Our compartmental image requires correction, for castes are not selfsufficient but interdependent; caste unites while it divides. Although there is a greater admixture of conflict and competition than the harmonious articulation of functions depicted in idealizations of caste, their occupational and ritual specialization does make caste groups interdependent in practice. Caste groups live not in isolation but in the midst of a set of other groups with which they have fixed and customary relationships economic, political, social, and religious. In much of India the village was organized 9. The various into a network of hereditary patronclient relations known as the jajmani system. nonlandholding castes (priests, washermen, carpenters, field laborers) provided customary services to landowners in return for fixed portions of agricultural produce. The relationship was not a mere economic exchange, but implied general duties of support and prerogatives of control. The relationships between castes are hierarchic; transactions among groups express principles of precedence, obedience, and subservience. Each group has its duties and disabilities; each, even the lowest, has its special prerogatives and privileges. The number of caste groups in a given locality may vary from a few to more than thirty from five to twenty would be typical. 10. There are no allIndia castes and there is no nationwide hierarchy of castes. In ____________________ 10. Mandelbaum 1970: 15. 8. On the mechanism of control within castes, see Mandelbaum 1970, chaps. 16, 17. Although castes have characteristically enjoyed a wide autonomy in making and applying rules for conduct of their own social life, the ruler in classical Hindu theory (and intermittently in practice until recent times) exercised a supervisory control over changes in custom and over matters of expulsion from and readmittance to caste. On medieval practice, see Derrett 1968: 171224. The requirement of royal approval of readmittance, retained by the Moghul government and in many princely states until this century, was relinquished by the British in the late 18th century ( O'Malley 1932: 5761; Hutton 1961 9397). On British control over the internal affairs of castes,
see Galanter 1968 and 1972. 9. On the Jajmani system, see Mandelbaum 1970, chap. 9; Wiser 1958; Beidelman 1959. The term jajmani was introduced into the scholarly literature by Wiser. Many other terms are current to describe regional varieties of the system e.g., the baluta, or shares from village lands given hereditary village servants in Maharashtra. 9 any local area, the relative standing of the various castes is more or less fixed, though subject to slow change, particularly in the middle ranges of the scale. Castes commonly lay claim to higher rank. Thus Marriott and Inden refer to the "mild but ubiquitous inclination of castes to improve their ranks [that] can be estimated from the finding that the average villager believes the correct rank of his caste to be about half a rank higher than what nonmembers of this caste are willing to concede." 11. There is local variation both in the number and kind of castes and in the rigidity with which the distinctions between them are maintained. Closely related castes may vary in standing from one region to another, or even within the same area. The top and bottom of the scale tend to be more easily identifiable and generally, if not invariably, accepted. Brahmins are at the top, and the "untouchables" are at the bottom, although there may be disagreement about the relative rank of various Brahmin and untouchable castes. Highness and lowness in the local hierarchy correspond roughly to the ritual purity of the several castes. However, a caste's standing also expresses its political and economic power. To the extent that these fail to correspond, there will be ambiguity in the ranking of castes, and changing economic and political power may be followed by an improvement in ritual standing. Although there are local differences, highness and lowness are expressed in a variety of interactions. Standing is commonly manifested in the willingness with which food and water are accepted by other castes, by reluctance to accept food and water from other castes, in the giving and receiving of ceremonial gifts, and in reciprocal patterns of precedence and deference. Relative positions in the local caste hierarchy are often conceptualized in terms of the theoretical division of Hindu society into four classes, or varnas. According to this theory, society is divided into Brahmins, the priestly and scholarly class; Kshatriyas, rulers and soldiers; Vaishyas, merchants and agriculturists; and Sudras, the menial and servant class. 12. The power of the varna theory is shown by the common tendency to describe the caste system as made up of four "castes" which the endogamous caste groups are merely subdivisions. 13. (Hence the usage "subcaste".) Groups seeking to better their position in the local hierarchy often phrase their claims in terms of a more prestigious varna identification by adopting names and practices associated with one of the three higher varnas. 14. Sudras are clearly ____________________ 11. Marriott and Inden 1974: 985. 12. There has not always been agreement about the relative standing of the three higher varnas. 13. The classical theory attributes multiplicity to miscegenous mixing of castes. 14. Except for Brahmins, the historical association of caste groups with particular varnas 10 accounted as inferior to the three "twiceborn" varnas, but it is misleading to think of the latter as ranked on a single ascending scale of precedence. Instead, they represent a set of divergent and incompatible social ideals around which claims for standing may be organized. 15. A caste group may cultivate its identification with one or the other, but does not progress from one to the other. Nor are all groups belonging to the same varna rated as equals.
Between the local caste (i.e., jati) hierarchies and the panIndia varna ranking lie a bewildering and irregular set of regional and subregional groupings of castes and conceptualizations of the caste hierarchy. 16. There are "caste clusters," "composed of several endogamous groups," spread over a region or subregion, sharing "a common name and functions . . . often [with] stylized interaction in commensality, hypergamy and differential status between their constituent jati groups." 17. There are what Fox calls "subregional varna categories"i.e., categories embracing several otherwise divergent jatis, or clusters, who share a claim to a common status. And there are regional versions of comprehensive varna schemes e.g., the "tripartite division into Brahmin, nonBrahmin and untouchables" in much of South India. 18. Local, regional, and panIndian schemes all draw on a common ideological fund. The notion of graded inequality is explained and justified by the traditional Hindu notions of dharma and karma. Each caste group has its own dharma the path which each of its members should follow in accordance with his nature and his station in life. The inequality of stations and the more onerous duties incumbent on some is explained and justified by the theory of karma and rebirth that is, every human action has a positive or negative worth, and the moral balance of an individual's actions in previous lives is manifested in the station into which he is reborn. Inequality is thus explained and justified as the reflection of relative spiritual merit accumulated in past existences. Hope for the future is provided, for one may progress through successive rebirths to higher positions and to the ultimate equality of absorption or reunion in Brahman, the unindividuated cosmic reality. Such spiritual betterment is the result of doing properly the things traditionally done by persons of one's station by fulfilling the dharma determined by one's caste, stage of life, and family position. Of course, this ____________________ is often doubtful. In many places there are few representatives of the Kshatriya and Vaishya varnas, while in others Kshatriyahood has tended to be conferred on those who hold temporal power. Since varnas are taxonomic categories rather than functional groups, attempts to enumerate their members have been unavailing. The 1931 Census did account as Brahmins 4.5% of the total (and 6.4% of the Hindu) population ( Schwartzberg 1978: 106) 15. Marriott 1968: 110. 16. Based on Fox 1969 and sources cited there. 17. Fox 1969: 32. 18. Id., at 33. 11 ideology is not fully accepted by all. 19. Nor does acceptance of these general notions imply agreement that one's caste has been accorded its rightful station. 20. So the ideology of hierarchy justifies claims of superiority and rationalizes resignation to inferior status; but it also provides leverage for (and incitement to) claims to higher status. In spite of the idealization of stability and fixity of social position, the compartmental society has not been static: caste groups do change their relative positions. Caste as a principle of social order has persisted over millennia, if much more disorderly and asymmetrical in practice than classical Hindu sociolegal theory depicted it. 21. Something very like the compartmental society of the recent past existed a thousand years ago. 22. Political, religious, and economic changes have all affected the caste order. The principle of a compartmental society endured while the identity of the compartments underwent many changes. Conquest, migration, emulation, isolation and segregation, occupational specialization, conversion and sectarianism, the incorporation of tribal groups all led to the additon, fission, and fusion of castes and to changes in their relative standing. Although it stressed ideals of stability and fixity, the caste society did have mechanisms for incorporating new
groups, accommodating changing practices, legitimating changes in group standing to accord with changing political economic and socioritual attainments. The compartmental society permitted some individual mobility within these communities as well as the slower movement of whole communities. 23. But what endured was a pattern of ____________________ 19. Berreman 1963: 25354. 20. Berreman 1963: 22324. Berreman observes the dilemma of the low caste person whose religion enjoins acquiescence low place but whose impulse is to improve that position: "In Sirkanda and, I believe, throughout India, this dilemma is often neatly resolved by exactly the mechanisms described above: accepting caste dharma but denying that one's apparent dharma is his real dharma. That is, the individual takes the position that a person should behave according to his caste status but that he or his kin group or jati is not really of the caste or status to which others ascribe him (or them). He is of a higher caste. He aspires to live as a member of his 'true' caste in order to fulfill his true Dharma. Therefore his mobility aspirations are legitimized and even made imperative. He rationalizes his own mobility aspirations without challenging the system." 21. In classical theory the function of political authority was to hold the balance between the groups in the compartmental society. It was the duty of the ruler to uphold the caste order. The king was enjoined to make the four varnas fulfill their particular duties and to preserve society from the evil of "confusion of castes." The confirmation (and conferring?) of varna status and control over the order of precedence among castes by Indian rulers continued until the recent past ( Hutton 1961: 49; Srinivas 1966: 41). The British eschewed such prescriptive assignments; but attempts to obtain governmental confirmation of status were channelled into the nominally descriptive arenas of the courts and the census ( Hutton 1961: 97; Srinivas 1966: 16; O'Malley 1932: 63). 22. Karve 1961, chap. 2. Nothing like jatis are described in the most ancient classical literature. 23. Silverberg 1967. 12 graded inequality of corporate groups in which differential access to life chances corresponded in large measure to membership in different communities. At the bottom of the caste hierarchies are found the "untouchables" castes with the lowest ritual standing and usually the lowest economic position and traditionally subject to onerous social and civic disabilities. Discussion of untouchability propels us into problems of nomenclature which condense intense controversies over the identity of these groups and over the characterization of their relation to the bulk of the Hindu population. 24. We shall trace the recent history of their identification in chapter 2 and take up some current controversies in chapter 6. For the moment it suffices to note that there is no other general term for the practice of setting apart a segment at a lower end of the caste order and that "untouchability" has been adopted as a salient category for public policy: the Constitution declares its abolition, and successive governments have promised to end it summarily. The origins of untouchability as practiced in recent times are unknown. Something like it has existed for at least a millennium, 25. and many of its features were present more than a millennium earlier than that. 26. Untouchability as such is not dealt with in classical Hindu learning. However, the low state of untouchables is reflected in and supported by the classical view of society as consisting of four varnas, or classes, with different natures, different functions, and correspondingly different stations in life. Rights and duties, procedures and penalties, were graded accordingly. The three higher varnas were "twiceborn" by virtue of investiture with the sacred thread, while the Sudras were subject to numerous disabilities. They were restricted to certain occupations, forbidden to learn the veda, and enjoined to be deferential and subservient to their betters.
In recent times, "untouchables" have been identified as "unclean Sudras" in some parts of India; elsewhere they are regarded as outside ____________________ 24. Current terminology includes the official term "Scheduled Castes"; also used officially is the Gandhian euphemism "Harijans" (lit., "people of god"), favored by politicians and resented as condescending by many so designated. "Dalits" (i.e., oppressed people) is favored by militants and eschewed by politicians and officials. "Backward classes" has a wider connotation (see chap. 6 below), as does "weaker sections." "Depressed classes," no longer in vogue, was the predecessor official term, replaced by Scheduled Castes in the mid1930s. "Untouchables" is regarded as callous or insulting. Isaacs' ( 1965) usage, "exuntouchables," has not achieved currency. On origins of some of these terms, see notes 21 and 46 in chap. 2 below. 25. Alberuni (c. A.D. 1020) noted certain endogamous occupational groups who lived outside villages and had limited intercourse with others ( Ghurye 1969: 316). He mentioned Dom and Chandala as "two groups not reckoned among any caste" ( Ghurye 1969: 313). A 12thcentury grammarian reports that Chandalas warn people to avoid their touch (id.). 26. R. S. Sharma 1958: 125. 13 (beneath) the four varnas. 27. Hence untouchables are often referred to as "outcastes," and there is a persistent tendency for foreign observers to describe them as people who are not members of any caste. 28. But they are members of castesthose which have the lowest ritual standing and often the most depressed economic condition. Generally, they are also lowest in income, health, education, and cultural resources. In the 1971 census those officially classed as untouchables (Scheduled Castes) by the government constituted nearly 80 million, or about 14.6% of India's total population of 548 million (or over 17% of India's 453 million Hindus). Untouchables are often associated with the most unclean and degrading occupationssweepers and scavengers, attendants at cremation grounds, hide and leather workersbut include other artisan groups such as weavers and toddy tappers. In most regions a single large caste of field servants (like the Mahars in Maharashtra, the Paraiyans in Tamil Nadu, and the Chamars in much of North India) makes up a large portion of the total untouchable population, with the remainder divided among various untouchable artisan castes. 29. The groups considered untouchables differ from locality to locality. A caste such as washermen or weavers may be considered untouchable in one part of India but not in another. Actually, only a small minority of today's untouchables practice these stigmatized occupations; most are landless agricultural laborers, often ensnared in debt. They are usually, but not invariably, associated with certain habits whch are unclean and loathsome to higher caste Hindussuch as eating beef and other forbidden food and in some cases eating carrion. The relations between castes throughout the hierarchy are expressed in terms of relative social distance and exclusiveness corresponding to the necessity of avoiding pollution (i.e., ritual uncleanliness). Pollution might derive from association with death, menstruation, childbirth, impure food, etc. But while everyone is subject to and causes temporary and expiable pollution, "untouchables" are permanently and inexorably polluted and polluting. Pollution is transmitted by contact with their persons, by food, and in some places in the south, by proximity (and historically in few cases, sight) as well. Different untouchable castes might be polluting to different degrees and subject to disabilities to varying extents. They are not a unified group, but recognize such distinctions among themselves and sometimes impose similar disabilities on each other. ____________________ 27. R. S. Sharma ( 1958: 208, 261, 279) detects comparable ambivalence in the relation of untouchables to the Sudra varna two thousand years ago. 28. "Outcaste" also means expelled from one's caste. Its use to describe untouchables flows from the
identification of castes and varnas; i.e., not being included in a varna is equated with not having a caste. 29. Patankar and Omvedt 1979: 410. 14 Untouchable groups are set off more or less distinctly below all of the other caste groups. 30. While each caste enjoys certain precedence and is subject to certain disabilities, the "untouchable" castes are subject to more extensive and severe disabilities and enjoy few privileges. Disabilities vary from place to place and in their incidence on specific castes. The imposition of disabilities is not unique to untouchables. It exists to some extentparticularly in regard to religious facilities, commensality, and intermarriagethroughout the system of castes. But it is found in a more exaggerated form for untouchables and to a lesser degree for other groups; some disabilities are peculiar to untouchables or more intense in regard to them. The following list of disabilities applied to untouchables is by no means a description of the practices in any single locality, nor is it an exhaustive listing of practices throughout India. It is instead a catalog of the disabilities which have in one place or another been typically associated with untouchability: Denial or restriction of access to public facilities, such as wells, schools, roads, post offices, and courts. Denial or restriction of access to temples where their presence might pollute the deity as well as the highercaste worshippers, and from resthouses, tanks, and shrines connected to temples. Untouchables and Sudras were ineligible to become sanyasis (holy men) and forbidden to learn the Vedas (the earliest and most sacred books of orthodox Hinduism). Exclusion from any honorable, and most profitable, employment and relegation to dirty or menial occupations. Residential segregation, typically in a more extreme form than the segregation of other groups, by requiring them to remain outside the village. Denial of access to services such as those provided by barbers, laundrymen, restaurants, shops, and theaters or requiring the use of separate utensils and facilities within such places. Restrictions on style of life, especially in the use of goods indicating comfort or luxury. Riding on horseback, use of bicycles, umbrellas, footwear, the wearing of gold and silver ornaments, the use of palanquins to carry bridegroomsall of these were forbidden in many areas. Requirements of deference in forms of address, language, sitting and standing in presence of higher castes. Restrictions on movement. Untouchables might not be allowed on roads and streets within prescribed distance of the houses or persons of higher castes. Liability to unremunerated labor for the higher castes and to the performance of menial services for them. ____________________ 30. Although untouchables might readily be identified in a given locality, considerable difficulty was experienced in devising panIndian criteria to distinguish them. See chap. 5 below. 15 Restrictions were severe and ubiquitous, but custom did not always prescribe complete exclusion. Instead, there was a complex pattern of exclusion, separation, and restricted use. For example, wells
might be entirely closed or might be used with separate buckets or only through a higher caste intermediary. Schools might be entirely closed, or untouchable children might be required to sit either outside the classroom or inside but away from other children. Untouchables might be excluded from temples, or they might be permitted to enter but required to remain a specified distance from the idols. The opportunities for group mobility within the caste system were more or less closed for them. 31. Systematically degraded, subjected to paternalistic control where not harshly victimized, the untouchables endured a kind of perpetual slavery with little hope of betterment in this world. Caste is not the only basis of affiliation in this compartmental society. Sometimes enveloping and sometimes cutting across caste are many other sorts of groupings. Indian society was and is divided into a multitude of religions, each containing its own orders, denominations, sects, and movements. The great family or cluster of religious assemblages known as Hinduism (containing some 85% of the present population of India) includes numerous "unorthodox" and "reform" sects as well as various "orthodox" Vedic and Brahmanic communions, embracing an amazing diversity of beliefs and practices. The contours of Hinduism are blurred in many areas. The line between Hinduism and tribal religions is indistinct. Major groups like Lingayats, Jains, Sikhs, and Buddhists are accounted Hindus for some purposes, but are in other respects regarded as nonHindus. The adherents of the religions that originated outside India Muslims, Christians, Parsis, and Jews are seen as distinctly outside the Hindu fold, but here too there are instances of syncretism and overlap. There are caste groupings that cut across religious lines to include adherents of several religionsJains and Hindus, Sikhs and Hindus, Christians and Hindus. The movement into nonHindu religions of members of lowranked castes, a recurrent recourse of the oppressed, has been accompanied by the development of communal distinctions in the new fold. Similarly, sects within Hinduism opposed to caste distinctions have been regularly absorbed into the compartmental order. Even where they are distinct from Hinduism, all of these religious groups form "communities" 32. ____________________ 31. Srinivas 1966. But even this is not without exception. The Nadars of southern Tamil Nadu and the Ezhuvas of Kerala provide two examples of groups that were regarded as untouchables early in this century and managed by strenuous efforts to raise their social standing as well as their political and economic position ( Hardgrave 1969, chap. 5; Aiyappan 1965: 13346.) 32. "Community" in recent Indian usage is used to refer to a section of the population 16 components of the compartmental society. They either constitute or contain endogamous castes or castelike groupings. Outside of and overlapping with both caste and religious groupings are the tribal communities, concentrated in isolated hilly regions. Some follow tribal religions, most are accounted as Hindus, and a significant minority are Christians. Thus, although the endogamous Hindu caste (jati) is the paradigmatic unit of the compartmental mosaic, in practice it includes communities which are neither Hindu nor castes. The compartmental structure of communities is crosscut by other bases of cleavage and affinity village and regional loyalties, occupational and class ties, factional and political alliances. In recent generations all of these have been overlaid by differences in exposure to and acceptance of "modern" or "Western" cultural influences. Our picture of the compartmental society is static and understates the impact of recent changes. Important qualifications must be made for settings where communal identity has declined in salience as among educated urban elites and where class formations may have eclipsed community as a basis of group mobilization. The compartmental society's notions of prestige and models of affiliation have been both enlarged and effaced by
"Western" models. 33. These and other elaborations will be introduced as we proceed. For the moment, a sense of a society comprising ranked communal compartments provides a useful base line to understand the policies whose development is described in this book. ____________________ differentiated by religion or caste or both (e.g., the Muslim community, the Brahmin community, the Agarwal Jain community). The meaning shifts according to the context (e.g., Hindu community comprises both Brahmin and nonBrahmin communities and these in turn may be divided into communities). "Communal" does not mean things held in common, but refers to any arrangement or view which emphasizes religious or caste groupings as social or political units. "Communalist" and "communalism" refer to persons or ideologies that support such arrangements, and they are ordinarily pejorative. 33. Thus in a seminal series of works, M. N. Srinivas contrasted "westernization" and as methods for achieving higher standing. See Srinivas 1966, chaps. 1 and 2. 17 2 Reform, Mobility, and Politics under British Rule EARLIER INVADERS and conquerors had accommodated and eventually been absorbed into the compartmental social order. The British came to India as traders and conquerors, not as social reformers. By the early 19th century, when they had fastened their rule over most of India, British policy was to recognize and accommodate the Indian social order a policy they termed one of noninterference. But the impact of British rule was to alter the social order profoundly, if inadvertently. Conditions of peace, new communications, new economic activities, new kinds of employment, a new legal system, a new system of property relations, and new ideas brought in their train new opportunities and new modes of mobility. Old powers and prerogatives were abolished; occupations and learning were rendered obsolete or marginal; new opportunities for gain and advancement were introduced; power and access to it were redistributed. Groups rose by association with the British Government, by trade with the British, by utilizing the new educational opportunities that the British introduced, by manipulation of the new legal facilities. Advantages gained in these ways tended to be cumulative, for utilization of these new opportunities was biased by the existing distribution of resources and by the network of kinship and community which 1. offered access to them. ____________________ 1. In addition to works specifically cited, the account in this chapter relies generally on the following sources: on social reforms, Heimsath 1964 and S. Natarajan 1959; on changes in Indian society, Ghurye 1957, Srinivas 1966, and Rudolph and Rudolph 1967 ; on the untouchables and their movements, Zelliot 1969 and Dushkin 1957; on the nonBrahmin movements, Irschick 1969 ( South India), Omvedt 1976 ( Bombay), and Dushkin 1974 ( Mysore); on Gandhi's views and activites, Gandhi 1954, Dalton 1967, and Pyarelal (Nair) 1932; on Dr. Ambedkar, Keer 1962, Zelliot 1969, and Ambedkar 1945, 1946, and 1968; on legal developments regarding caste generally, Galanter 1968, and specifically on legal enforcement of and abolition of social disabilities, Galanter 1972a; on the drafting of the Constitution, Austin 1966 and the Constituent Assembly Debates. 18 Noninterference proved elusive, for whatever the British did or refrained from doing was bound to have an impact on the social order. The paradoxical aspect of the policy of noninterference is plainly revealed if we consider the disposition of the legal system to the compartmental social order. Noninterference implied doing what rulers in India had always doze actively upholding and 2. But it also implied an aloof neutrality. The outcome was a changing supporting the caste order.
patchwork of support and aloofness, threaded by impulses of reform given intermittent and reluctant expression, all bent and reshaped in unplanned ways by forces released by the British presence. The establishment of a nationwide legal system brought a general movement of disputes from caste and village tribunals, responsive to the locally powerful, into the government's courts and spread a consciousness of rights which might be vindicated independently of local opinion. The government's courts espoused a norm of equality before the law. With few exceptions, the same rules applied to all. Outside the "personal law" fields, sastric and customary law was supplanted by a general law applicable to all. The British undertook to apply separate bodies of law in matters of family, property, and religion according to the religious affiliation of the parties. Application of these personal laws in the government's courts, with commonlaw procedure and commonlaw trained judges, introduced inadvertent changes. In the formal setting of the Britishstyle court, the classical textual element of the law was elevated to a supremacy over the customary element greater 3. (In Hindu law, for example, the salience of the varna categories was than it had enjoyed earlier. greater in the late 19th century than earlier.) The general features of the legal system were not articulated to a system of graded inequality. Legal 4. The use of caste in the general civil, criminal, and enforcement of slaver was withdrawn. commercial law was sharply restricted and soon abandoned. The British law did not recognize or try to maintain the caste order as such. The law recognized the autonomy of castes as groups. But, after an initial flirtation, the British were reluctant to provide affirmative support for their internal powers of governance. Affirmative support was confined to a narrower ambit than in the past, when Hindu rulers gave redress for grievances which the AngloIndian courts excluded as involving only social pri ____________________ 2. Derrett 1968, chap. 7; Jackson 1907 ; O'Malley 1932. 3. Derrett 1968, chaps. 8, 9; McCormack 1966 ; Rudolph and Rudolph 1967, pt. 3; Galanter 1968. 4. Legal enforcement of slavery was outlawed by the Indian Slavery Act (Act V of 1843); possession of slaves was made a criminal offense by the Indian Penal Code (Act XLV of 1860) § 370. On the way that agrestic slavery in southern India compounded the diabilities of the lowest castes, see Adam 1840: 171 ff.; Banaji ca. 1933:85; Kumar 1965. 19 vileges. Yet the British courts were more ubiquitous and accessible, more efficient and relentless in 5. operation; even their attenuated and indirect support had great impact. The British were less willing than earlier rulers to lend the civil power to uphold prerogatives claimed in intergroup relations. The assertion of precedence and the imposition of disabilities 6. Caste groups enjoyed the received limited and for the most part indirect support from the law. active support of the courts in upholding their claims for precedence and exclusiveness respecting the use of religious premises. Exclusionary practices did not enjoy the same active judicial support at least not from the higher courts in regard to "secular" public facilities such as schools, wells, and roads. However, where members of higher castes themselves undertook to "enforce" their prerogatives against lower castes, the courts were reluctant to provide remedies against such "selfhelp" including boycott and secondary boycott. In their respect for autonomy of castes, the courts were reluctant to interfere with the disciplinary powers of castes against violators of received etiquette of intercaste relations. While at the upper levels of the legal system, support for high caste dominance was mainly indirect and passive, there is some indication that at the lower levels of the legal system there was often active governmental support for the claims of the higher castes. Even where lower castes enjoyed rights that were formally enforceable, they could be vindicated
only by engaging in the expensive and uncertain process of litigation, a process only partly insulated from other sources of advantage. Surveying a range of studies, Cohn concludes: The lower castes have generally been unsuccessful when, through the use of police or of the urban courts, they have sought to redress what they believe to be the corporate wrongs done to them by upper castes. The upper castes maintain their economic position, their knowledge of the courts and the intricacies of the law and better access to officials have thwarted attempts to change the position of the lower castes in the village 7. society and economy. If in practice legal institutions often adapted themselves to prevailing patterns of disability, the lowest castes did enjoy a new equality in the ____________________ 5. Galanter 1968. 6. Anandan 1911: 529 observes that the famous proclamation of 1858 in which Queen Victoria assured Indians that none would be favored, molested, etc., by reason of their religion or observances was "tantamount to saying that the state will not interfere in the most provoking intercaste observances and the consequent illtreatment of the depressed classes. In other words, the state cares to respect only the feelings of the high caste people. . . ." 7. Cohn 1965: 108. 20 eyes of the law and had access to it, at least formally. The law opened some possibilities for advancement and change to the lower castes, as it did to others. But it did not provide any special leverage for the lowly to use these opportunities, so use of them tended to correspond to the existing distribution of resources. Just as, for example, new opportunities for advancement through education and government service were grasped largely by Brahmins and other high castes with a literate tradition, so those who were already supplied with other advantages tended to make use of the new opportunities afforded by the legal system. The law did not provide the higher castes with an instrument for aggressively suppressing their inferiors (as, e.g., Jim Crow laws did in the post Reconstruction southern United States), but the law provided another resource which higher castes could use to protect their claims to precedence (and in some instances perhaps even tighten their 8. hold on valued resources to the exclusion of lower castes). Most of the new opportunities in education and government services were grasped by those already 9. but some members of the lower castes did find new opportunities as supplied with advantages, menial government servants, in army service, and in trade and contracting (sometimes protected by their monopoly in a degraded occupation like leatherwork or sweeping). British courts declined to enforce customary service relationships. But while this meant that weaker parties could not invoke the assistance of the courts when traditional expectations were disappointed, such assistance was hardly required by dominant groups. Many artisans and village servants were displaced from their traditional callings and prerogatives by new technologies and new structures of government. 10. The problems faced by the lowest castes in utilizing these new opportunities are exemplified in their struggle to obtain schooling. In 1856 a Mahar boy, refused admission to a government school, appealed to the Bombay Education Department, but was rebuffed on the ground that it would not be right for the sake of a single individual, the only Mahar who had ever yet come forward to beg for admission into a school attended only by pupils of caste, to force him into association with them, at the probable risk of making the institution practically useless to the great mass of natives. 11. ____________________
10. Zelliott 1969: 53; Galanter 1972a: 233 and n. 41. 11. Quoted at Zeillott 1969: 47.
8. Chidambaram Pillai ( 1933) argues that British law recognized and promoted more restrictive
claims of exclusiveness regarding temples in South India than had prevailed earlier.
9. Ghurye ( 1957: 190) notes that government service was staffed by higher castes and that their
traditional attitude to lower castes carried over into government work. 21
In 1858 the Bombay Government announced that it reserved the "full right of refusing . . . support . . . to any . . . school in which the benefits of education are withheld from any class of persons on account of caste or race," and further resolved "that all schools maintained at the sole cost of Government shall be open to all classes of its subjects without distinction." 12. Nevertheless, reported the Department of Public Instruction, "the opposition of the higher castes to the admission of [Untouchable] boys to a public school was often so strong that, even with the best will in the world, the Department could do very little in the matter." 13. A few special schools were opened by reformers, by missionaries, and by the government. In regular school, the few "untouchable" children were subject to invidious segregationbeing forced to sit away from others on the veranda was a typical experience. Some concessions in primary school fees and special scholarships in secondary schools and colleges were made available in the late 19th century. But not until the 1920s was there more than a trickle of untouchable students. Thus, noninterference combined with rising aspirations and expanding opportunities to produce a complex and uneven movement; it both liberated the lower castes from official imposition of disabilities and enabled a fortunate fraction to raise themselves, while it added richly to the array of advantages of the higher groups. The law, education, government service, and the new economy carved out and defined a sphere of public life in which caste distinctions were of little import; but the thrust of British policy was to give the higher castes more resources and opportunities to enter and succeed in that sphere. The growth of a class of Indians educated on Western lines, the spread of British political and social ideas, and the insistent criticism of missionaries all contributed to an intellectual ferment which questioned many aspects of Indian life. Practices which had appeared natural and inevitable now seemed problematic. Religious reformers responded to the humanist and rationalist critique of Indian institutions with programs to reconsturct and purify Hindu society. Groups of educated Hindus devoted themselves to refashioning social institutions to accord with new notions of humaneness, justice, and equality. The great reform issues throughout most of the 19th century were the abolition of sati, remarriage of widows, education for women, and opposition to child marriageissues which reflected higher caste practices and options. Caste restrictions (like ostracism after sea voyages) were an issue, but not the system of caste itself. Reformers were not indifferent to the strictures of caste, of which they were painfully ____________________ 12. Ghurye 1957: 189. 13. Quoted at Zelliot 1969: 48.
22
aware, since the strictures often bore with fearsome force on those who outraged conservative opinion by putting into practice such reforms as widow remarriage. The currents of reform stirred others than emancipated intellectuals. The changes under British power gave new scope to the impulse to selfimprovement and advancement in many groups. In the
late 19th century, many castes organized, held conferences, published newspapers, and undertook internal reform efforts. At first they tended to seek advancement in traditional terms of ritual status, vying for prestigious entries on the census, putting forth claims to exalted varna position, and upgrading their practices in terms of received notions of respectability. (This sometimes involved changes like adopting child marriages and banning widow remarriagethe very practices opposed by reformers in the highest castes!) The interest of caste organizations turned increasingly to secular betterment: they founded hospitals, hostels, and loan funds; they sought representation, government jobs, and scholarships. Caste organization brought with it two important and related changes in the nature of castes. The salient groups grew in size from the endogamous jatis into regionwide alliances. Concomitantly, the traditional patterns of organization and leadership in the village setting were displaced by voluntary associations with officials whose delimited authority derived from elections. New forms of organization were taken up by some castes at the lower end of the spectrum. 14. Some embraced the opportunities afforded by missionaries; others were influenced by Hindu reform movements; still others developed their own organizations. The first militant action by low castes was the campaign of the Shanars (later Nadars) to enter temples in the Tinnevelly District in Madras, a demand connected to their claim to be Kshatriyas. The Ezhuvas (Iravas) of Kerala took a different tack: by the early years of the 20th century, they had developed their own system of temples and schools. The first efforts to assist the low castes had come at midcentury under the auspices of a Poona reformer, Jyotirao Phule, who united a program of education and selfhelp with a thoroughgoing attack on caste, 15. from missionaries who proffered conversion as a solution, 16. and from Hindu religious reformers like Dayananda Saraswati, founder of the Arya Samaj, who preached a purified varna and attacked caste exclusiveness (in its existing degenerate form). 17. Although anticaste associations had earlier voiced opposition to ____________________ 14. Lynch 1969: 6769; Hardgrave 1969: 13032. 15. Keer 1964; Ghurye 1957: 2001; Omvedt 1976: 10623. 16. Heimsath 1964; 5354. 17. Heimsath 1964: 321, 330; S. Natarajan 1959: 70; Ghurye 1957: 258 23 caste distinctions, it was not until the end of the century that mainstream reformers saw caste hierarchy and inequality as problems in their own right. Now reform of the caste system, rather than of the practices of individual castes, became a major plank of the reformers. (The issue derived dramatic impact from its juxtaposition with the discriminations suffered by Indians in South Africa, which had become a public issue in India in the 1880s.) In 1895, Justice M.G.Ranade of the Bombay High Court circularized social reformers regarding the claims of aboriginals and untouchables on Hindu society. In the next dozen years, missions, schools, and scholarships for Depressed Classes were founded. Not only did amelioration of the lowest castes become one of the most prominent items of reform, but it was accompanied by a shift in attitude toward the caste system. Earlier reformers sought improvement from within. At first they had concerned themselves with sastras, trying to provide textual authority for such reforms as widow remarriage and abolition of child marriage. Gradually, they had come to realize that sastric learning provided little leverage to change current custom. It was the adherence of the caste group that upheld custom, not sastric learning. And, improvement from within by caste associations engaging in selfreform, it was
discovered, cut both ways, for a caste might embrace orthodox usage as well as depart from it. This kind of piecemeal approach came to seem less inevitable as the image of Indian society changed. The notion of reforms proceeding from and directed to a single national community transcending divisions of religion, caste, and sect was not selfevident in the late 19th century. Reform of social practice was considered appropriate for each constituent group within the society. Thus, in his presidential address to the second meeting of the Indian National Congress in 1886, Dadabhai Naoroji explained his objections to making social reform part of the Congress program: How can this gathering of all classes discuss the social reforms needed in each individual class? What do any of us know of the internal home life, of the customs, traditions, feelings, prejudices of any class but our own? How could a . . . cosmopolitan gathering like this, discuss to any purpose the reform needed in any one class? Only the members of that class can effectively deal with the reforms therein needed. A National Congress must confine itself to questions in which the entire nation has a direct participation, and it must leave the adjustment of social reforms and other class questions to class Congresses. 18. But as nationalism grew, this division into "classes" seemed less natural and commendable. The caste institution itself fell into bad ____________________ 18. Naoroji n.d., p. 8
24
repute, blamed for disunity, weakness, and lack of civic spirit. Increasingly, reformers saw the caste system itself as the enemy. In the early years of the century, pleading for the relaxation of restrictions among "subcastes" was replaced by opposition to caste itself. Among the most radical, the aim was not merely to raise the conditions of the lowest castes, but to abolish the system of caste altogether. 19. The ferment within Hindu society has to be seen in the context of changing HinduMuslim relations. British rule shattered the earlier patterns of dominance and accommodation, permitting, if not fostering, open rivalry that found outlets in new political arenas. 20. The concern of Muslims over the loss of their former preeminence was compounded by the feeling that they were falling behind the Hindus in modem callings and opportunities and were being reduced to a subordinate position. As the movement toward greater Indian participation in government gathered momentum in the late 19th century, it threatened to accentuate this imbalance, compounding Muslim anxiety about being dominated. In 1906 a deputation of Muslim notables petitioned the Viceroy to safeguard Muslim interests in the forthcoming electoral regime, reserving seats to be chosen by separate Muslim electorates. The British were responsive to Muslim apprehensions. In 1909 when the MintoMorley reforms were promulgated, separate electorates were provided for Muslims. At this point, the condition of the untouchablesas they were coming to be called 21. which had become a major item of reform interest, was propelled from the realm of philanthropy and social uplift into the political arena. Rising concern about the untouchables was augmented by the first appreciation of their political significance. Eleanor Zelliot observes: ____________________ 19. K. Natarajan, a prominent Bombay reformer, first formulated the notion that untouchability was an inevitable concomitant of the caste system; to remove it, caste must itself be removed ( S. Natarajan 1959: 120). 20. Barrier 1968 ; Jones 1968. 21. In 1909 the problem of the lowest castes was for first time conceptualized under the rubric of
"untouchability"a general term which opened the possibility of visualizing the problem not as that of a congeries of depressed groups, but as a stratum of allIndia dimension with shared characteristics. The vicissitudes of the search for that stratum are detailed in chap. 5, § A, below. Use of the English term "untouchable" in print can be traced with fair precision to the year 1909. The Maharaja of Baroda in his remarks to the Depressed Classes Mission of Bombay on October 18, 1909, uses the term and provides an explanation to his audience ( Sayaji Rao 1928: 24445). The abstract form "untouchability" is used by Sridhar V. Ketkar ( 1909: 86) in a footnote to his study of the caste system; the preface of the volume is dated September 1909. Internal evidence suggests that the author did not have this term at his disposal when he wrote the text (cf. pp. 99 and 12122). The Maharaja of Baroda was the patron of Mr. Ketkar and supported him during the years at Cornell University when he wrote this book. (See Ketkar 1911: xxvi). WeitbrechtStanton ( 1920: 173) attributes the term's prominence to the Gaikwad [Maharaja]. 25 The granting of an electorate for Muslims in which they alone would vote brought the idea of communal electorates for minorities to the forefront in the minds of all communities which feared for their submersion in a government run by the dominant caste Hindu community. The granting of special electorates to the Muslim community also made numbers important. Whether thevast numbers of Untouchables were truly Hindu and to be counted as such, or not, became an important question for the first time. 22. Concern about Hindu numbers was accentuated when the Census Commissioner (for 1911) bruited the suggestion that the untouchables (then known as Depressed Classes) should be enumerated as a group separate from the Hindus, a suggestion promptly endorsed by the Muslim League. 23. Suddenly there was quickened interest in the Depressed Classes from previously indifferent Hindu leaders who were now insistent that Depressed Classes were within the Hindu fold. 24. Apprehensions about a continued Hindu majority must have been seen in the light of then current estimates that the Depressed Classes numbered 50 to 60 million 25. from a sixth to a fifth of the total population and roughly the magnitude of the plurality of Hindus in the population. 26. "Untouchability" was thus propelled into a prominent (but not central) place on the Indian political stage, which it was to occupy until after Independence. This new position was soon reflected by the reversal of the Indian National Congress's longstanding policy of excluding "social reform" from its program. At its 1917 annual meeting, the Congress for the first time passed a mild and hesitant anti disabilities resolution. 27. As Congress had avoided social reform because of its divisive potential, it now embraced it (in part) because of its unifying ____________________ 22. Zelliot 1969: 141. 23. "Since the publication of the recent Reform Measures [the MintoMorley reforms of 1909] the Mahomedans have been loud in declaring that, properly speaking, the outcastes are beyond the pale of Hinduism, and therefore their strength should not go to swell the numerical force of the Hindus. . . ." (Saint Nihal Singh [in Indian Review, September 1910, reprinted] in Anonymous ca. 1913: 89.) 24. A contemporary observer reports that "a question that is agitating Hinduism at the present moment is as to whether these [untouchable] classes should be counted as Hindus or not. Ten years ago the answer would have been emphatically in the negative. Even now the conservative feeling of the country is for their exclusion. But the conscience of the more advanced section of the educated Hindus is a little more sensitive on this point" ( Holderness 1911:1012). Cf. Tinker 1962:131, who reports that "as late as 1910, upper caste politicians were demanding that [untouchables] should be excluded from the Hindu fold in the Census."
25. On these estimates, see chap. 5, § A, below. 26. The Hindu percentage of the population had been falling slowly but steadily for decades. See
n.45 below.
27. "The Congress urges upon the people of India the necessity, justice and righteousness of
removing all disabilities imposed by custom upon the Depressed Classes, the 26
potential. From this point on, the social question was indissolubly linked to the political. At the time of Congress's first gesture of interest in the untouchables, there was only a faint scatter of political activity among untouchables themselves. There was, however, more noticeable stirring among the castes above them but below the social peaks i.e., in the middle ranges of Hindu society. Movements of the middle castes against the cultural preeminence of Brahmins had emerged in the 19th century; now, focussing on Brahmin predominance in education and government service, they took on political form. The Justice Party ( South Indian Liberal Federation), the organ of the NonBrahmin movement in Madras, was founded in 1916; the organization of the NonBrahmin party in Bombay got under way in 1917. The Princely State of Mysore instituted a system in which all communities other than Brahmins were denominated "Backward Classes;" from 1918, places were reserved for them in colleges and state services and thus was inaugurated the first modern regime of communal quotas. NonBrahmin demands for a greater share of political representation were quickly recognized by the British. The promised postwar reforms (the Government of India Act, 1919) accorded them special representation. During the 1920s, the nonBrahmin parties flourished in the Madras and Bombay presidencies, erecting a system of preferences in educational admissions and recruitment to government posts. At first, these nonBrahmin, or Backward Classes, movements undertook to speak for the lowest strata as well, but as they prospered, their voices increasingly reflected their higher echelon constituents. 28. The 1919 reforms provided only a few nominated seats for the Depressed Classes, 29. but for the first time some untouchable spokesmen were heard in political assemblies. As untouchables increased their political activity and as concern for their welfare became a plank of Congress policy, legislatures for the first time took an interest in their problems. There was a scatter of undertakings by government to provide land, housing, schooling, and government posts to the Depressed Classes. The illegality of denying access to schools, wells, and roads was declared in legislative resolutions and administrative orders which ____________________ disabilities being of a most vexatious and oppressive character, subjecting those classes to considerable hardship and inconvenience" (quoted in S. Natarajan 1969: 144). The Congress resolution omitted a crucial passage of the original, as submitted by the Depressed Classes Mission Society, which specified "disabilities imposed by religion and custom" (italics supplied). 28. On the isolation of untouchables from nonBrahmin movements, see Irschick 1969:188ff; Zelliot 1969:143 ff; Dushkin 1974:252 ff; Ramaswamy 1978:296. 29. Depressed Classes representation was increased (and extended to include a nominated member in the Central Legislative Council) following the findings of the Muddiman Committee in 1925 ( Zelliot 1969: 158). 27 were honored largely in the breach. 30. Special government officers were appointed to look after their welfare. There were fee concessions and scholarships and some pressure on schools to be accessible. School enrolments increased, and a few untouchables entered public services. 31. By the close of the 1920s, as Eleanor Zelliot observed, "the principle of special attention was firmly established." 32.
Untouchability (and the excesses of caste hierarchy) presented a problem whose solution was required to unlock India's national destiny. The question remained how this was to be done. The various answers might roughly be classified by their resemblance to two polar types that we may call the "evangelical" and the "secular." The "evangelical" approach stresses the uplift of untouchables to higher Hindu standards and the penance of caste Hindus for the injustices of untouchability, which is seen not as an integral part of Hinduism but as some external impurity. Uplifted untouchables and repentent Hindus will join together in a purified and redeemed Hinduism. At the other extreme, the secular approach stresses the denial of civil rights and economic opportunities and seeks to combat them by vigorous government intervention, and political action to obtain it. Untouchability is seen as an integral part of Hinduism. The secular approach does not seek to restore Hinduism to some original purity, but seeks instead to liberate all by dissolving the graded inequalities of caste into the common bond and common rights of citizenship in a secular state. In the "evangelical" approach, the emphasis is on moral regeneration and philanthropic uplift; in the secular approach, it is on civic and economic improvement under government auspices. These divergent approaches were present from the first stirrings of concern about the untouchables. In the 19th century, the evangelical ____________________ 30. E.g., in 1923 the Bombay Legislative Council resolved that untouchables be allowed to use all public watering places, wells, schools, dispensaries, etc. The Provincial Government did not, however, undertake direct responsibility for enforcement as to local facilities, but requested "collectors . . . to advise the local bodies in their jurisdiction to consider the desirability of accepting the recommendations made in the Resolution so far as it relates to them" ( Bombay 1930 [ Starte Committee]: 52). The flavor of enforcement activity is conveyed by the action of a District Board which, seven years later, resolved to post notices that facilities were open to untouchables "at only those villages in the district where the public opinion is favorable for such action" (quoted at Sanjana 1946: 237). At that time, the Starte Committee concluded that the policy was a "complete failure" when it could not "find a single instance where Depressed Classes are continuously using the same public well as the higher classes. There may be such wells, but if so, they must form an infinitesimal proportion of the hundreds of thousands of public wells in the Presidency" ( Bombay 1930 [ Starte Committee]: 52). 31. Ghurye 1957: 260; Hutton 1961:208. The first untouchable gazetted officer was appointed in 1927 ( Zelliot 1969: 162). 32. Zelliot 1969: 166. 28 approach was exemplified in the activities of the Arya Samaj; the secular, by Jyotirao Phule. During the 1920s, each acquired a champion of immense stature. Their individual struggles illuminate the problems inherent in these approaches; the wrestling between them cast the mold of policy about untouchability for independent India. In 1916 Mohandas K. Gandhi returned to India from South Africa and assumed leadership of the Indian National Congress. In his autobiography, Gandhi tells us that from the age of twelve he was convinced that untouchability could not be sanctioned by Hinduism. From his first public statements on the subject, he describes untouchability as a sinful excrescence upon Hinduism. He calls upon caste Hindus to do penance, to purify themselves and Hinduism, while urging the untouchables to observe cleaner habits. The problem is one for voluntary private action, not for legal coercion. While rejecting caste in its modern manifestations, Gandhi accepted varnashrama dharma as a healthy division of labor by birth. Untouchability should be removed by abolishing the unwarranted fifth division and restoring the untouchables to their rightful estate as Sudras in a purified varna
expressing not inequality but a horizontal and noninvidious division based on hereditary qualities. The notion that some are by birth polluting must be abolished, and those selfimposed restrictions on intercourse that are conducive to spiritual development should be retained. If Gandhi personified the evangelical approach, the secular approach was personified by the most gifted and wideranging spokesman to appear among the untouchables, Dr. Bhimrao Ramji Ambedkar. 33. Dr. Ambedkar (born 1890) was younger and less experienced than Gandhi when he stepped into the political stage in the early 1920s. 34. While Gandhi's appeals are directed principally to the ____________________ 33. These giants throw long shadows. Using them to illuminate the conflict over untouchability should not obscure the fact that each had rivals and critics within his own camp. The untouchables were (and are) a vast and heterogeneous collection. Dr. Ambedkar, throughout his career, received the most intense and unswerving support from his own Mahar community. Notwithstanding his subsequent veneration, his command of the allegiance of other groups of untouchables varied considerably, and there were intermittent attacks on his capacity to represent them. On other untouchable leaders and movements, see Zelliot 1969: 18385, 19394, 2067; Patankar and Omvedt 1979:415. 34. These two men shared a number of qualities but displayed a number of striking contrasts. Both hailed from the hinterlands of Bombay: Gandhi from Gujarat, Ambedkar from Maharashtra. Gandhi was a bania (merchant) by caste, while Ambedkar was a Mahar. The Mahars are a populous caste of field laborers and village servants in western India, which had a military tradition, having formed many units in the East India Company's Bombay army. Both came from families with a tradition of government service. Gandhi's elders had traditionally served as Diwans of princely states in Kathiawad, Ambedkar's as noncommissioned officers in the Indian army. Both grew 29 caste Hindus, Ambedkar addresses the untouchables and directs their attention to the potentialities of action to be taken by government. His programs express conflicting impulses between assimilation into Hindu society and separation from it, a pattern that recurs throughout his career. These conflicting impulses are displayed in two successive conferences over which he presided in 1929. At the first, the conferees were invested with the sacred thread by a Brahmin priest to the chanting of vedic hymns, in a classical instance of elevation in "sanskritic" terms. At the second, the conferees resolved to embrace "any other religion" if the Hindus continued obdurate in their mistreatment. 35. The next major round of bargaining over the future of India began in 1928. For the first time the untouchables were fullfledged participants. The negotiations began with the visit of the Simon Commission, which was empowered to make recommendations for a new round of constitutional reforms. Dr. Ambedkar, by this time recognized as an important spokesman, appeared before the Commission to demand reserved seats for the untouchables in legislative bodies, special educational concessions, and recruitment to government posts, recommendations substantially accepted in the Commission's Report. 36. When this Report proved unacceptable to the major contenders, the British Government convened a Round Table Conference in London to ____________________ up in an atmosphere of devotional religion: Vaishnavism in Gandhi's case, while Ambedkar's family were adherents of the 15thcentury poet and religious reformer Kabir who had Muslim as well as Hindu followers. Both were married young to younger and less educated wives, and both
were sent overseas to complete their education. Gandhi went to London, though the sea journey meant ostracism from his caste, to join the Bar. Ambedkar, under the patronage of the Gaikwad of Baroda, was sent to America the first prominent Indian leader to be educated there. Both returned to Bombay and joined the Bar. When Ambedkar returned to India, he joined the Baroda civil service in a responsible job under his patron, but lack of acceptance of the untouchable by his fellow officers, clerks, and landlords drove him back to Bombay. Under the patronage of another Hindu prince, the Maharajah of Kolhapur, he entered politics. Ambedkar was a scholar, who managed to earn several doctorates, and a bibliophile. Unlike Gandhi, he was an aloof, solitary, and domineering man who found sustained organizational efforts trying. His impatience with organizational detail and his unwillingness to delegate authority made each of the many organizations he founded a personal organ, run along paternalistic lines and lacking in solid leadership in the middle ranks. Unlike Gandhi, whose devotions never ended, Ambedkar was for the most of his life a mild theist or indifferent to religion. Unlike the mild Gandhi, he was given to outspoken and caustic attacks on his opponents. Gandhi's Western heroes were Ruskin, Tolstoi, and Thoreau; Ambedkar's favorite historical figure, according to his biographer ( Keer 1954: 214), was Napoleon. 35. Keer 1954: 12830. 36. Reported in Zelliot 1969: 17072.
30 which it invited delegates from all parties and prominent interest groups. The Congress, claiming that it alone represented Indian opinion, refused to participate. In the course of the Conference, Dr. Ambedkar abandoned his earlier opposition to separate electorate. 37. His demands for safeguards in a future constitution now included separate electorates as well as recruitment to government services, laws against discrimination, and a special department to look after the Depressed Classes. The Civil Disobedience Campaign, which had kept Congress aloof from the first Round Table, ended with an arrangement for a Second Round Table Conference. Gandhi, representing Congress, attacked all the other delegates as unrepresentative. In particular, he attacked Ambedkar's claim to represent the untouchables. "I claim myself in my own person to represent the vast mass of the untouchables." Opposed to separate electorates for any group, he grudgingly conceded them to Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, and AngloIndians, but the demand of the untouchables for separate electorates he termed "the unkindest cut of all" and vowed to resist it with his life. 38. When the Conference's Franchise Committee was unable to reach agreement on representation for minorities, the delegates authorized Prime Minister Ramsay MacDonald to make an award which would be binding on all parties. The Communal Award, announced on August 17, 1932, gave the untouchables regular votes in the general electorate and granted their demand for separate electorates in areas where they were concentrated in addition to the regular votes they would cast as members of the general electorate. 39. Gandhi, who was imprisoned as a result of his civil disobedience campaign, now undertook to carry out his vow by fasting until death unless the separate electorates for untouchables were revoked. His objection was that separate electorates would signify a perpetual split in Hinduism, perpetuating the stigma of untouchability and making impossible the assimilation of the untouchables into the Hindu community. It is evident that Congress opposition, if not Gandhi's personally, was inspired by fear that the great Hindu base of Congress support would be weakened and that candidates returned from separate electorates would be advocates for group interests with little concern for the Congress program. Finally, many Congressmen, including Gandhi,
____________________ 37. Dr. Ambedkar's oppsition to separate communal electorates was shaken by the stubborn attachment of other communites to this device, which was also favored by most untouchable activists. His sense of obligation to represent his constituency compounded his fears that the claims of the Depressed Classes would be submerged without their own representatives ( Zelliot 1969: 17677; Patankar and Omvedt 1979: 419). 38. Zelliot 1969: 181. 39. Zelliot 1969: 185. 31 did not have a very high regard for the political capacities of the untouchables. 40. The British Government declined to alter the Award without the consent of the affected groups i.e., without the consent of Ambedkar as the representative of the Depressed Classes. During the twentyone days of Gandhi's fast, Ambedkar was subjected to immense pressures, not least the sense of the cataclysm that might engulf the untouchables if Gandhi were to die. Wresting as much as he could from the Congress leaders who negotiated with him, Ambedkar relinquished the separate electorates in return for a system of reserved seats to be elected from "joint" or general electorates. The final agreement reached on September 28, 1932, known as the Poona (or Yeravda) Pact, set the subsequent pattern of representation for untouchables. 41. The Poona Pact provided 148 seats for untouchables, instead of the 78 separately elected members given by the Communal Award. It also provided a system of primary elections for those reserved seats; a panel of four candidates was to be chosen by electors from the Depressed Classes. In the light of the agreement, it is clearer just what was really at stake. Gandhi argued for joint electorates so that caste Hindus would be forced to seek votes from untouchables. But, of course, this was the case under the Communal Award, since untouchables also had votes in the general constituencies. Gandhi's principal objection had been to having separate rolls of untouchable voters, but this was preserved by the Poona Pact's arrangements for nomination of the candidates. 42. Whatever the motives of the fast, the political effect was to dramatize the issue of untouchability while preventing arrangements that would foster an independent political movement sufficiently strong to belie the Con ____________________ 40. After meeting Ambedkar for the first time in 1931, Gandhi told his secretary, "I did not know that he was a Harijan. I thought he was some Brahman who took deep interest in Harijans and therefore talked intemperately" (quoted by Zelliot 1969: 178). Since Ambedkar had been a prominent spokesman for several years, this suggests inattention to untouchable movements as well as an assumption that untouchables were incapable of providing their own leadership. Cf. Patankar and Omvedt 1979: 419. 41. For Ambedkar's account, see Ambedkar 1946: 32228; Zelliot 1969: 18288. For a Gandhian account, see Pyarelal (Nair) 1932: 16569, Gandhi 1954 b: f: 177, 6567; also Dushkin 1957, chap. 4. 42. The Poona Pact provided a system of primary elections in which eligible voters of the Depressed Classes would "form an electoral college" to elect "a panel of four candidates belonging to the Depressed Classes" to stand for each reserved seat. This system was to end after ten years unless terminated sooner by mutual agreement (Poona Pact, reprinted at Ambedkar 1946: 8889). Subsequent disagreement over this clause was resolved when the Hammond Committee (on construction of the constituencies) adopted Ambedkar's interpretation that "four" meant "no more than four" and that voting in multimember constituencies was to be cumulative rather than distributive ( Ambedkar 1946: 9194). In the 1937 elections, primaries were held in only 43 of the 151 reserved constituencies. Ambedkar complained that the primaries were little used
32 gress claim to represent all of India. 43. Ironically, this fast is often referred to as Gandhi's fast against untouchability. In a setting of HinduMuslim divergence, this sequence of events the Communal Award, the fast, and the Poona Pact raised concern with untouchability to new heights. 44. It was recognized as a problem that demanded a solution as part of the question of Indian nationhood. The new salience of untouchability was not unconnected with concern about political alignments. 45. As one Congress sympathizer put it: ____________________ because the double election was prohibitively expensive for Scheduled Caste (as they had come to be called) candidates. And, analyzing the elections, he argued that when primaries were held, they did not insure that those successful in the general election were genuine representatives of the Scheduled Castes ( Ambedkar 1947: 44). This displeasure was shared by other untouchable leaders. Ambedkar had earlier proposed modifying the scheme to require that candidates could stand in the general election only if they had received 25% of the Scheduled Caste vote in the primary, a suggestion rejected by Gandhi ( Zelliot 1969: 188). A proposal to continue the primary system with a 20% requirement may be found in a report to the 1945 Sapru Committee ( Sapru 1945 : lxviii), but after partition and the adoption of Article 325 barring electoral rolls on the basis of caste, the possibilities for such primaries faded from sight as well as from memory. 43. Lelah Dushkin ( 1957: 74) observes that "the basic solution (except for the panel system) was what Ambedkar had advocated in 1929, what Sapru had advised at the second R[ound] T[able] C[onference], and what Rajah and Moonje had proposed in their pact. The whole affair would not have occurred if Gandhi had not treated the D[epressed] C[lasses] delegates with such scant courtesy at the second R.T.C." 44. A conference of Hindu leaders, convened in Bombay on September 25, 1932, to ratify the Poona Pact, unanimously adopted the following resolution: "This Conference resolves henceforth, amongst Hindus no one shall be regarded as an untouchable by reason of his birth, and that those who have been so regarded hitherto will have the same right as other Hindus in regard to the use of public wells, public schools, public roads and all other public institutions. This right shall have statutory recognition at the first opportunity and shall be one of the earliest Acts of the Swaraj Parliament, if it has not received such recognition before that time. It is further agreed that it shall be the duty of all Hindu leaders to secure, by every legitimate and peaceful means, an early removal of all social disabilities now imposed by custom upon the socalled untouchable classes, including the bar in respect of admission to temples" (quoted in Rajagopalachari 1933: 1). 45. Anxiety about the departure of the untouchables should be seen against a background of the muchdiscussed, longterm decline in the Hindu proportion of the total population of India, roughly summarized in the following table: Date Percentage Source 1881 74.3 a
1891 72.3 a 1901 70.3 b 1911 69.3 b 1921 68.4 b 1931 68.2 b 1941 65.9 b Sources: a: Census of India, 1911; b: Census of India, 1941: Vol. I, Part I, 102 ff. 33 With the Harijans within the Hindu political group, 46. the future of the Hindus is safe. Without the Harijans, the destiny of the Hindus will remain uncertain. . . . We do want to have the Harijans on our side in the political struggle, and even if it were for this purpose alone, the CasteHindus must raise this curse of untouchability and bridge the gulf that divides them from their coreligionists. There is a real crisis in the political life of the Hindu community. . . . 47. Efforts to remove untouchability and help its victims proliferated in the wake of the Poona Pact. 48. Congress had earlier committed itself to a program of fundamental rights in the future republican India in which there would be no recognition of civil and social disabilities. 49. But only after Gandhi's fast were Congress leaders willing to countenance the affirmative use of the law to abolish disabilities and in particular to obtain by law the admission of untouchables to Hindu temples, thereby symbolizing their inclusion within the Hindu community. While temple entry absorbed advanced Hindu opinion, Dr. Ambedkar turned away from it to emphasize economic and educational advancement. Temple entry, he asserted, was up to the Hindus; it was through political power that the untouchables were to find their salvation, not through acceptance by the Hindus. Both Gandhi and Ambedkar, each in his own way, attacked the Hinduism of the day. In a charismatic transvaluation of Hindu ____________________ 46. One enduring product of these events was a new terminology. "Untouchable" was in general use by 1920, but "Depressed Classes" remained the official term. In 1931, Dr. Ambedkar and R. Srinivasan, (the Depressed Classes' representatives at the Round Table Conference) observed that the term "Depressed Classes" is "degrading and contemptuous" and proposed as alternatives "Noncaste Hindus," "Protestant Hindus," or "Nonconformist Hindus" (Indian Round Table
Conference 1932: 76). But events took a different course. Shortly afterwards, Gandhi began to popularize "Harijan" ( Gandhi 1954: 1617), and then the Government of India Act, 1935, denoted those who would enjoy the special electoral arrangements for untouchables as "Scheduled Castes," a term destined to remain the official designation for untouchables down to the present. Just as "Harijan" fossilizes the evangelical fervor of Gandhi's antiuntouchability campaigns, so "Scheduled Castes" summons up the bureaucratic rigidification and torpor that overtook Ambedkar's measures for secular improvement. 47. Agarwal 1934: 22. Mr. Agarwal was a Cambridgeeducated lawyer and professor in Poona. 48. These included the formation of the Harijan Sevak Sangh, an organization devoted to the uplift of the Harijans. Its board was composed entirely of nonHarijans, giving rise to reproaches from Dr. Ambedkar and others. 49. In 1931, the annual meeting of the Indian National Congress at Karachi propounded a program of fundamental rights for future republican India which included: "(vi) no disability to attach to any citizen by reason of his or her . . .caste . . .in regard to public empolyment, office of power or honors, and in the exercise of any trade or calling. (vii)equal rights of all citizens in regard to public roads, wells, schools and other places of public resort" ( AllIndia Congress Committee, n. d., p. 66). 34 practice, Gandhi dramatized his identification with Harijans, and particularly with the bhangis (sweepers), the lowest and most polluting of castes in traditional terms. 50. During his tours, he stayed in the sweepers' quarters. Calling himself a Harijan and a Bhangi, he expressed the wish to be reborn as an untouchable. Gandhi advocated a purified varnashrama dharma in which untouchables would be restored to their rightful place as Sudras. 51. But to Ambedkar, the fourvarna system is the very root of untouchability. For Hinduism to accommodate the untouchables, it must be purged of the varna system. Where Gandhi proposed to rid Hinduism of its imperfections and restore it to its ideals, Ambedkar was skeptical of these ideals themselves. To him, those who observed untouchability were not bad Hindus, but merely observant ones. The only way to change their conduct was to destroy the authority of the sastras. Thus, reform of Hinduism meant extirpating the offending doctrines and abolishing the hereditary priesthood; in their place a new standard book of doctrine should be promulgated and a licensed, certified priesthood established. 52. Dr. Ambedkar increasingly despaired of the possibilities of reform within Hinduism. He alternated proposals for radical reform of Hinduism with recommendations that untouchables convert to a religion that would guarantee them equality. In 1936 he conducted an extended flirtation with Sikhism. 53. Proposals for conversion aroused a storm of opposition. Gandhi charged that the religious feelings of the untouchables were being exploited in a political game. In a characteristic combination of genuine solicitude and uncomprehending condescension, he expressed doubt whether the untouchables could ____________________ 50. "A Bhangi does for society what a mother does for her baby. A mother washes her baby of the dirt and insures his health. Even so the Bhangi protects and safeguards the health of the entire community by maintaining sanitation for it. The Brahman's duty is to look after the sanitation of the soul, the Bhangi's that of the body of society" ( Gandhi 1954b: 21518 [from Harijan of November 28, 1936]). 51. Gandhi's program was by no means moderate in its day. C. B. Agarwal is probably closer to popular feeling among the educated when he complains that Gandhi is moving too fast. While favoring civil rights and educational help, Agarwal rejects interdining and intermarriage and would restrict temple entry to those untouchabales who give up meateating. 52. This was a program so calculated to outrage respectable Hindu sentiment that the organization
cancelled their invitation when they saw advance copies of the speech (see Ambedkar 1945). But it was not entirely without precedent; e.g., in 1928, a rural Depressed Classes Conference had called for proscription of the Manu Smrti, the preeminent Hindu law text ( Zelliot 1969: 170). 53. One interesting sidelight of these negotiations is that Ambedkar called in the Hindu Mahasabha, the foremost of the Hindu communalist parties, to seek their approval. Apparently the aim of this was to remain Hindu for purposes of the reserved seats awarded by the Poona Pact. The Hindu Mahasabha agreed on the condition that conversion was to Sikhism rather than to Christianity or Islam. Ambedkar himself 35 distinguish the relative merits of the contending religions any more than a cow could. 54. The new popular governments which took office in 1937 avowed their opposition to untouchability. Madras passed the first legislation imposing criminal penalties for denying to untouchables the use of public facilities. Temple entry had been proclaimed earlier in a few progressive princely states. In 1938, for the first time in British India, governments intervened to secure the opening of temples when Bombay and Madras passed templeentry acts. Encouragement of education for untouchables increased, and there were measures to secure them some posts in government service. The nonBrahmin movements that had emerged so dramatically a generation earlier now bifurcated, as lower castes insisted on provisions separate from those for the upper nonBrahmin groups. 55. (The former emerge as the "other backward classes," whose story we take up in chapter 6.) To a large extent, these movements were absorbed into the Congress. Congress governments continued and extended the regime of communal quotas in public services and college admissions that these movements had produced, as did nonCongress governments elsewhere. 56. In the central services, the Government of India reserved quotas for Muslims and other religious minorities. During the Second World War, when the Congress opposed cooperation with the British war effort, Dr. Ambedkar served as a member of the Viceroy's executive council, the first untouchable to attain such a lofty station. He secured for the Scheduled Castes (as they were now called) reservations of posts in central government services and various other concessions, including recruitment into the army and the police. 57. Gandhi, who was in prison along with the Congress leadership for ____________________ agreed that it would be preferable to stay within Hindu culture, thereby avoiding Muslim domination. As it happened, after the conversion of a few of his followers, bad feeling developed between Ambedkar and the Sikhs, and the matter dropped out of sight ( Zelliot 1969: 22426; Keer 1962: 288). But the issue of the untouchables enjoying special treatment after abandoning Hinduism is a persistent one that resurfaced dramatically in the 1950s and has remained unresolved. See chap. 9, §§E and F, below. 54. Gandhi's response to charges that this statement was demeaning was that neither could his wife ( Gandhi 1954b: 154 [from Harijan of March 13, 1937]). 55. The Madras Provincial Backward Classes League, consisting of the less forward nonBrahmin communities, was founded in 1934 for the purpose of securing separate treatment from "the forward nonBrahmin communities." See chap. 6 below. On the tension between the upper and lower strata within the nonBrahmin movement, see Saraswathi 1974, chap. 4; Ramaswamy 1978: 297 (Andhra districts). 56. On communal quotas in public services and educational institutions under the Unionist government in the Punjab, see Tinker 1962: 29. 57. On wartime developments, see Zelliot 1969: 26265. 36
obstructing the war effort, had undergone a radical change in his thinking about untouchability. He was now willing to countenance legal compulsion to permit untouchables to assert their rights, and envisioned a future constitution in which all forms of untouchability would be abolished by law. He no longer espoused personal exclusiveness, but opposed all caste distinctions. He no longer defended varna while denouncing caste. Untouchability could be eradicated only if Hindu society became casteless. To this end he now encouraged interdining and intermarriage, which he hoped would lead to a situation in which "finally there will be only one caste, known by the beautiful name of Bhangi, that is to say, the reformer or remover of all dirt." 58. When Independence came in 1947, caste was in bad odor. It was widely viewed as an impediment to individualism and to broad national loyalties and thus inimical to progress and democracy. The hardships inflicted on the lowest castes inspired humanitarian revulsion. It was widely accepted that caste would have no place in independent India and that efforts to ameliorate the effects of past inequalities were in order. As power passed into Indian hands, the exclusion of untouchables from public facilities and from Hindu temples were made statutory offenses throughout most of India. Reservations for untouchables were established in the central services, and a program of educational assistance was begun. Ambedkar was one of the principal architects of the Constitution that emerged from almost three years of deliberations. 59. It is a federal constitution: authority is explicitly apportioned between the center and constituent territorial units. There is a greater subordination of the units to the center than in the United States, but the states have considerable autonomy and are more than mere administrative divisions. It is a written constitution with the distinction of being the, longest in the world. It had to be written in de to be federal in order to arrange the division of powers between the center and the states. But also and this accounts for its length because there were a number of other matters which the constitutionmakers wished to put beyond the reach of temporary or narrow majorities. These include safeguards for various minorities and a large part of the fundamental ____________________ 58. On development of Gandhi's thinking on caste, see Gandhi 1954b: 7285; Dalton 1967: 17174. 59. Ambedkar's hopes of leading an independent political party in which untouchables played a central role foundered in the 1945 provincial elections as they had in the 1937 elections. Through the good offices of the Muslim League, he became a member of the Constituent Assembly, which became the governing body of India when the country was divided and given independence on August 15, 1947. In a gesture of reconciliation, Prime Minister Nehru appointed him Law Minister, and he was chosen as chairman of the Drafting Committee of the Constituent Assembly. 37 structure of the government apparatus. Thus, detailed provisions regarding the judiciary, the civil service, and the proceedings of legislatures, adopted without fundamental change from the British administration, are all entrenched in the Constitution. There is a written and enforceable set of Fundamental Rights modelled in large measure after the United States Bill of Rights. There is a set of Directive Principles of State Policy, which specify the general goals of governmental policy the right to work, higher living standards, free and compulsory education, etc. and anticipate a welfare state which was described by one skeptical observer as "Fabian socialism without the socialism." 60. Finally, judicial review is explicitly provided: the Constitution is to be interpreted and its provisions enforced by a unitary national judiciary. The chapter on Fundamental Rights contains a number of familiar features: prohibitions of governmental restriction of the freedoms of religion, speech, press, association, and movement;
minimal standards of criminal justice; protections for property all analogous to their American counterparts. The draftsmen, cognizant of the difficulties in interpretation and in application encountered in America and Australia, specified exceptions and limitations to each right. The listing of exceptions and the deliberate omission of a "due process" clause reflect an attempt to reduce the scope for judicial discretion in determining the extent of these rights. In general, the draftsmen wished to confine judicial review to the application of express principles of law and tried to avoid giving the courts a role of continuous constitutionmaking. The Fundamental Rights also contain bans on discrimination on grounds of religion, caste, sex, language, etc. The attempt to secure equality goes beyond guarantees of equal treatment by government: crucial provisions regulate not only "state action" but also the behavior of private persons and groups. Caste discrimination by government or by private individuals is banned. But it was recognized that evenhanded treatment would not suffice to overcome the cumulative disadvantages of those at the bottom of the social hierarchy. To promote the advancement of the untouchables, tribals, and other "socially and educationally backward classes," the Constitution allows protective or compensatory discrimination in their behalf. The notion of communal quotas and safeguards which had become an accepted and prominent principle of administration during the last forty years of British rule was decisively rejected as a general principle of governance. There are no safeguards for religious minorities apart from the guaranteed fundamental rights. Only for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes (and to a lesser extent, for other backward classes) are these devices ____________________ 60. Jennings 1953: 31. 38 countenanced. There is a deliberate departure from formal norms of equality in order to offset the historic inequalities of these groups. Ambedkar's role in the Constituent Assembly underlines the decisive rejection of Gandhian notions of village selfrule. While Gandhi idealized village India and its handicraft technology, Ambedkar despised Indian villages as "dens of ignorance, narrowmindedness and communalism" 61. and ardently supported machine technology which would provide leisure, cultural advancement, and finally equality. To the same end, he rejected Gandhi's ideal of trusteeship by the rich in favor of a kind of state socialism which would promote rapid industrialization. And in spite of his suspicion that India might require benevolent autocracy, he was a supporter of centralized parliamentary government rather than of village autonomy. In all of this Ambedkar stood closer to the left wing of the Congress than either stood to Gandhi. The Constitution incorporated much of the secular program he had championed, but Dr. Ambedkar was dissatisfied with the performance of the Congress government. After a bitter political disappointment in the 1952 election, he disowned his role as designer of the Constitution. 62. Throughout his career, Dr. Ambedkar had written on the historical aspects of the caste system and displayed a strong interest in Buddhism, which he considered a religion of equality and social reform. This was reinforced by his belief that the untouchables were former Buddhists who had been degraded by the Hindus for refusing to give up Buddhism and for continuing to eat beef. 63. Ambedkar's interest in Buddhism intensified after Independence, and he dedicated himself to the revival of Buddhism in India. After his political disillusionment was complete, he returned to the notion that the problems of untouchability could be solved only by the abandonment of Hinduism. In 1955, a year before his death, he launched a mass movement for conversion to Buddhism that inspired millions of untouchables to abandon Hinduism ____________________
61. VI CAD 39.
62. Dr. Ambedkar's bitter disappointment is understandable, but in retrospect and from afar, his
sense that the constitutional protections which he designed or at least concurred in were a failure seems less than fully warranted. The untouchables, unlike the Muslims, were a scattered minority with no territorial base, no unity among themselves, no rallying point in religion or historical glories, and with little capacity and fewer resources for organization. If ultimately they had little choice but to accept what they were given by the majority, their leadership did well by them in obtaining safeguards and preferences out of the independence struggle. Although their constitutional position might have been even stronger, the major shortfall has been not in constitutional protection but in organization and imagination to utilize effectively the protections and opportunities that are available. 63. Ambedkar 1948: 76, 8083. The idea that Untouchables or low castes were former Buddhists had gained popularity among a scattering of low caste groups ( Zelliot 1969: 231 and n. 83). It had been expounded earlier by Colonel Olcott of the Theosophical Society and others. 39 and embrace Buddhism. 64. A generation later, the Buddhists were a significant element of both political militancy and intellectual leadership; and Dr. Ambedkar was the venerated "patron saint" of the untouchables. 65. The wrestling of Gandhi and Ambedkar displays an ironic reversal. Gandhi, for decades the embodiment of the evangelical approach of repentance and personal growth, acknowledged the need for external controls and eventually adopted all the planks of the secular reform platform championed by Ambedkar. Dr. Ambedkar, on the other hand, lost faith in the efficacy of secular political reform without a cultural transformation with its roots in new (or restored) religious identity. What emerged was a national commitment to reduce invidious distinctions among groups, coupled with a conviction that it was permissible and perhaps necessary to employ these discredited caste notions to effectuate the equalizing policies that we survey in the following chapters. We shall then return to explore the evolution of these categories and to trace their career as instruments of the equalizing policies that we call compensatory discrimination. ____________________ 64. The number of Buddhists reported by the census increased from 180, 823 in 1951 (of whom only 2,500 were in Maharashtra) to 3,250,327 in 1961. Of these, 2,789,501 were in Maharashtra ( Census of India 1961; Paper No. 1 of 1963). Zelliot ( 1969: 239) estimates that 80% of the Mahar caste reported themselves as Buddhists in 1961. The 1971 census numbered 3,874,942 Buddhists. These figures represent a considerable understatement: many who regard themselves as Buddhists would not publicly identify themselves as such for fear of losing educational and other benefits conferred on Scheduled Castes. See chap. 9, §E, below. 65. Although respected as a "founding father," Ambedkar is the prime symbol of selfassertion by low castes. The renaming of Marathwada University in his honor in 1978 touched off widespread rioting throughout that region of Maharashtra. Resentment of reservations and concessions for untouchables was given murderous expression; Mahars were especial targets of attack ( Morkhandikar 1978 ; Abraham 1978 ). 40 3 Compensatory Discrimination Programs and Their Implementation INDIA'S POLICY OF compensatory discrimination comprises a wide array of preferential schemes. In this chapter we will survey some of the most prominent programs, consider some general features of their administration, and explore the question of how they should be assessed.
These programs are authorized by constitutional provisions that permit departure from formal equality for the purpose of favoring specified groups. We shall later examine closely the meaning of these provisions and the tensions between them and other constitutional commitments. For the present it may be helpful to identify them as the constitutional anchorage of the various policies described here. Article 46, a "Directive Principle of State Policy," declares: The State shall promote with special care the educational and economic interests of the weaker sections of the people, and, in particular, or the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes, and shall protect them from social injustice and all forms of 1. exploitation. The Constitution's ban on discrimination in government employment is qualified by Article 16(4), which permits the State to make any provision for the reservation of appointments or posts in favour of any backward class of citizens which, in the opinion of the State, is not adequately represented in the 2. services under the State. ____________________ 1. The Directive Principles of State Policy, contained in Part IV of the Constitution, are not themselves justiciable, but the Constitution prescribes it as "the duty of the State to apply these principles in making laws" (Art. 37.) The jurisprudential status of the Directive Principles is discussed below in chap. 11. 2. In addition, Article 335 provides: "The claims of the members of the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes shall be taken into consideration, consistently with the maintenance of efficiency of administration, in the making of appointments to services and posts in connection with the affairs of the Union or of a State." The relation of these provisions is discussed in chap. 11, §B, below. 41 The general provisions banning discrimination by government (Art. 15) and banning discrimination in governmentaided educational institutions (Art. 29 [2] ) are similarly qualified by Article 15(4), which provides: Nothing in Article 15 or Article 29(2) . . .shall prevent the State, from making any special provision for the advancement of any socially and educationally backward classes of citizens or for the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes. There are specific provisions that we shall encounter later. But these, along with specific provisions for reservation of seats in legislative bodies (which will be discussed shortly), are the core of the constitutional commitment to compensatory discrimination. The benefits of "compensatory discrimination" are extended to a wide array of groups. There are 3. First, there are those castes designated as Scheduled Castes (SC) on the basis three major classes. of their "untouchability." They numbered nearly 80 million (14.6% of the population) according to 4. Second, there are the Scheduled Tribes (ST), who are distinguished by their the 1971 census. tribal culture and physical isolation and many of whom are residents of specially protected 5. Third, Scheduled Areas. They numbered more than 38 million (6.9% of the population) in 1971. there are the "Backward Classes" (or, as they are sometimes called, "Other Backward Classes,") 6. a heterogeneous category, varying greatly from state to state, composed for the most part of castes (and some nonHindu communities) low in the traditional social hierarchy, but not as low as the SC. Also included among the Other Backward Classes (OBC) are a few tribal and noma
____________________ 3. Temporary preferences for yet another group, the AngloIndians, were not based on their backwardness but were designed to cushion the loss of the privileged position they had formerly enjoyed. Reserved posts in certain services and special grants to AngloIndian educational institutions were guaranteed by Arts. 336(1) and 337. These preferences were on a diminishing scale and ceased to be operative on January 26, 1960. Reservation for AngloIndians in the services has ceased. The states have, with some reductions, continued to make grants to Anglo Indian schools. Since the constitutional grants were not merely authorized but guaranteed, there was no occasion for this group to be treated under the general provisions the preferences, Arts. 15(4) and 16(4). On the limits of state power to place conditions on the recipients of these grants, see Bombay Education Society v. State of Bombay, A.I.R. 1954 S.C. 561; In re Kerala Education Bill, 1957, A.I.R. 1958 S.C. 956. The Constitution not only provides a formula for determining the amount of grants and reservations, but also defines membership in the AngloIndian community (Art. 366[2]). On the status of AngloIndians and the background and effects of the Bombay Education Society case, see Grimshaw 1959. 4. On the selection of these groups, see chap. 5, §A, below. 5. On these groups, see chap. 5 §C, below. 6. On the selection of these groups, see chaps. 6, 7, 8, below. 42 dic groups, as well as converts to nonHindu religions from the SC, and in some areas the 7. It has been estimated that there were approximately 60 million persons under Denotified Tribes. 8. roughly the magnitude of the SC population at the Other Backward Classes heading in 1961 that time (64 millions). (Today the portion of the population designated under this heading is probably larger.) For the most part, preferences have been extended on a communal basis. Members of specified communities are the beneficiaries of a given scheme, and all members of the community, however prosperous, are entitled to the benefits. However, some schemes use a means test to supplement the communal on only members of the listed communities with incomes below the specified ceiling are eligible. In a few instances, the communal test has been replaced by an economic one income or occupation or a combination of the two and a few schemes use tests neither communal nor economic. 9. Preferences are of three basic types: First, there are reservations, which allot or facilitate access to valued positions or resources. The most important instances of this type are reserved seats in legislatures, reservation of posts in government service, and reservation of places in academic institutions (especially the coveted higher technical and professional colleges). To a lesser extent, the reservation device is also used in the distribution of land allotments, housing, and other scarce resources. Second, there are programs involving expenditure or provision of services e.g., scholarships, grants, loans, land allotments, health care, legal aid to a beneficiary group beyond comparable expenditures for others. Third, there are special protections. These distributive schemes are accompanied by efforts to protect the backward classes from being exploited and victimized. Forced labor is prohibited by the Constitution, 10. and in recent years there have been strenuous efforts to release the victims of debt bondage, who are mostly Scheduled Castes and Tribes. Legislation regulating money lending, providing debt re ____________________ 10. Art. 23(1). 7. "The Denotified Trbes, or Vimukta Jatis, are the former Criminal Tribes. They became 'ex criminal' when the Criminal Tribes Act of 1924 was repealed in 1952. Their population is estimated at upwards of 40 lakhs [4 million], of whom more than half live in [Uttar Pradesh.]
Although U.P. lists several of them as Scheduled Castes, most States count them all as Other Backward Classes. They pose special psychological, social and economic problems, however, and have come to be treated as a separate fourth category for administrative and budget purposes" ( Dushkin 1961 : 1665). 8. Dushkin 1961 : 1665. 9. Economic tests are discussed in chap. 8, §G. below. For an example of a "residence" criterion, see the Home Ministry's grants for all persons in selected "undeveloped areas" (RCSCST 195960: I, 323). See chap. 8. §H, below, on geographic criteria. 43 lief, and restricting land transfers attempt to protect SC and ST from the economic oppression of their more sophisticated neighbors. Antiuntouchability propaganda and the Protection of Civil Rights Act attempt to relieve untouchables from the social disabilities under which they have suffered. 11. This legislation is not "compensatory discrimination" in the formal sense of departing from equal treatment to favor these groups; it enjoins equal treatment rather than confers preferential treatment. But in substance it is a special undertaking to remedy the disadvantaged position of the untouchables. Unlike the measures discussed above, these are regulative rather than distributive; they involve different claimants in different settings; they are implemented by different sets of officials e.g., by police and magistrates rather than by administrators. There are important connections and perhaps important parallels. But the "protections" involve a whole world of different problems and richly deserve detailed study in their own right. We shall take up these protections here only as they intersect with compensatory programs of the first two types. To make the present survey manageable we shall concentrate on several of the most prominent programsreserved seats in legislatures and preferential treatment in education (including reservations in professional colleges). Other programs and some general features of their administration will be noted briefly, and the problem of assessing their performance will be broached. The following chapter presents a more fully developed "case study" of preferential treatment in the area of government employment. A. LEGISLATIVE RESERVATIONS The most prominent of all preferential policies is the reservation of seats in elective legislative bodies. The Constitution specifically provides reserved seats in proportion to their numbers for the Scheduled Castes (SC) and the Scheduled Tribes (ST) in the Lok Sabha (lower house of Parliament) 12. and the Vidhan Sabhas (lower houses of the state legislatures). 13. No seats are reserved in the upper houses, central or state. There are no reservations in legislatures for the Other Backward Classes or for any minority goups. 14. ____________________ 11. The Protection of Civil Rights Act is the new name given to the Untouchability Offences Act (Act 22 of 1955) upon its amendment by the Untouchability (Offences) Amendment and Miscellaneous Provisions Act (Act 106 of 1976). For a review of the background of this legislation and its operation into the mid1960s, see Galanter ( 1972a). 12. Article 330. 13. Article 332. 14. The Constituent Assembly definitively rejected political safeguards for religious and other minorities. See Austin 1966 : 14656. The Constitution does, however, 44 All of the other constitutional provisions for preferences are merely authorizations empowering the State to make special provision for disadvantaged groups. But legislative reservations are specifically provided in the Constitution itself. 15. Seats are reserved in proportion to the population
of SC and ST to the total population of each state. Thus in 1976, 78 (14.4%) of the 542 seats in the Lok Sabha were reserved for SC, and 38 seats (7%) for ST. Of the 3,997 seats in the Vidhan Sabhas, 540 (13.5%) were reserved for SC, and 282 (7%) for ST. 16. These reservations do not involve "separate electorates" i.e., the representation of a particular group by legislators chosen by an electorate composed solely of members of that group. 17. The seats are "reserved" in the sense that candidates who stand for them must belong to the specified groups, but the entire electorate participates in choosing among candidates so qualified. Separate electorates for Parliament and the state legislatures are specifically outlawed by Article 325, which provides that no person shall be excluded from any electoral roll on grounds of religion, race, or caste. 18. The constitutional provision of reserved seats is complemented by statutory provisions to enhance political participation by SC and ST. Smaller election deposits are required from members of these groups, and candidates for reserved seats enjoy more permissive residence requirements. 19. ____________________ provide for nominated representatives of the AngloIndian community in the Lok Sabha (Art. 331) and in the Legislative Assemblies (Art. 333). On the implementation of these provisions, see RCSCST 197577: I, 37. 15. The Constitution contains no similar provision for representation in other political bodies. However, such political safeguards may lie within the scope of Art. 15(4), which is apparently broad enough to authorize the reservation of seats in elective bodies on a local level. 16. Election Commission 1976a: 36. 17. By separate electorates is meant the representation of religious (or other) minorities by legislators chosen by an electorate composed only of members of that minority. The provision and extent of such representation was an extremely troublesome political issue in India during the forty years preceding Independence. The Government of India Act, 1909, gave separate electorates to Muslims; the Government of India Acts of 1919 and 1935 provided separate electorates for Muslims, Sikhs, Indian Christians, and other groups. Proposals to give separate electorates to the Scheduled Castes under the 1935 Act were withdrawn after adamant resistance by Mr. Gandhi. See chap. 2 above. 18. The Supreme Court has indicated that Article 15 prohibits communal electorates in local bodies. Nain Sukh Das v. State of U.P., A.I.R. 1953 S.C. 384. 19. Representation of the People Act, 1951 (Act 43 of 1951). The smaller deposits apply in contesting nonreserved as well as reserved seats. A proposal by Dr. Punjabrao Deshmukh, leading spokesman for the Other Backward Classes, to extend the smaller deposits concession to that category elicited a gruff dismissal from Dr. Ambedkar, then the Law Minister: "this is the first time that I hear that such a concession should be extended to the Backward Classes. Hitherto the concessions that have been spoken of as 45 Unlike the general authorization of special treatment and the provision for reserved posts in government service, the reserved seats in legislatures are subject to a constitutional time limit. It was originally provided that such reservations should expire ten years after the commencement of the Constitution. 20. In 1959 these provisions were extended for another ten years, 21. in 1969 for another ten, 22. and in 1980 for yet another ten. 23. The demarcation of constituencies and designation of those reserved for SC and ST are entrusted to a Delimitation Commission. 24. The courts are constitutionally barred from intervening in the process of delimitation or allotment of seats. 25. Generally, constituencies are formed on the basis of contiguity, communications, absence of natural barriers, and cultural and ethnic homogeneity. After
they are formed, certain constituencies are selected as reserved. 26. In the case of the ____________________ being necessary for the upliftment of the Backward Classes are educational concessions and concessions in the services of the country. . . . [S]o far as the Members representing the Backward Classes in this House . . . they are capable of paying not only their own election deposits, but also the election deposits of many others." The government refused to accept the amendment and it was withdrawn. Parliamentary Debates, Vol. XIIXIII (Part II), Cols. 914149 ( 19 May 1951). 20. Article 334. 21. Constitution (Eighth Amendment) Act, 1959. 22. Constitution (Twentythird Amendment) Act, 1969. 23. Constitution (Fortyfifth Amendment) Act, 1980. 24. The Delimitation Commission consists of a retired Supreme Court judge, a sitting High Court judge, and the Chief Election Commissioner ( Delimitation Act, 1972 [Act 76 of 1972]). In each state, the Commission is assisted by ten nonvoting associate members (5 Members of Parliament and 5 Members of the Legislative Assembly) nominated by their respective Speakers (§5). The associated members from each state are consulted after tentative delimitation. After changes at this stage, the proposed delimitations are published and objections invited. Where there are objections, hearings are held. The location of reserved seats is the most frequent source of objections, but they are rarely shifted. 25. Article 329. 26. During the 1950s, most of the reserved seats were in doublemember constituencies, in which one of the seats could be filled only by a member of the "privileged" group and the other was open to general competition. Thus in 1952, all of the Scheduled Caste seats and half of the Scheduled Tribe seats in the Lok Sabha were doublemember constituencies. In 1957, 467 out of 470 SC seats in the Vidhan Sabhas and 115 of the 221 seats reserved for ST were also in double member constituencies. (On the functioning of the doublemember constituencies and their abolition, see Dushkin 1972 : 189 ff.) Doublemember constituencies were abolished in 1961 (the Two Member Constituency [Abolition] Act, 1961 [Act 1 of 1961]). This aboliton seems to have been inspired principally by the concern of politicians with the greater difficulty and expense of campaigning in a double sized district. This was compounded by some resentment of the infrequent but wellpublicized instances in which the unreserved "general" seat as well as the reserved seat was won by SC or ST candidates, who were able to compete for both seats, while their opponents could compete for only the unreserved seat. This did not happen very often. In nearly two hundred doublemember constituency contests for Lok Sabha seats in 1952 and 1957, the general seat was won by a reservedseat 46 Scheduled Tribes seats there is a single standard for selection concentration of the ST population. 27. Since typically the tribal population lives in areas of concentration, the constituencies reserved for them contain a high proportion of ST. 28. In 1962, the ST constituted more than 50% of the population in 18 of the 31 Lok Sabha constituencies reserved for them. 29. Conversely, most of the major concentrations of ST population are located in reserved constituencies. Of the 29 constituencies in which ST make up over 40% of the population, 23 are reserved. Thus the reserved seats encompass the bulk of the ST population perhaps close to 70%. These constituencies are, not surprisingly, more isolated and much less urban than are the general constituencies.
In the case of seats reserved for Scheduled Castes, the Delimitation Commission is instructed to apply two standards concentration of SC population and dispersal of reservations. The Delimitation Act instructs the Commission to locate seats reserved for SC "in different parts of the State and . . . as far as practicable, in those areas where the proportion of their population to the total is comparatively large." 30. The Delimitation Commission achieves this by first reserving the constituencies with the highest concentration of SC usually not much more than 20% and then selecting the others by the dispersal criterion. Since the SC population, unlike the ST, is rather evenly dispersed, the constituencies reserved for them contain far fewer SC members. Among the 76 Lok Sabha constituencies reserved for SC in the 1962 elections, there was ____________________ candidate in one in 1952 and in five in 1957. It was apparently even less frequent in the legislative elections, as indicated by the very small number of nonreserved seats occupied by SC and ST. A wellknown 1959 Supreme Court decision upheld the right of an ST candidate to take the unreserved seat, sealing the defeat of the Labour Minister ( V.V. Giri v. D. Sura Dora, A.I.R. 1959 S.C. 1318, discussed below in chap. 13,§ B). This decision triggered the move for abolition ( Dushkin 1972 : 192). New singlemember constituencies were designated for the 1962 elections. In most cases this was done simply by dividing the doublemember constituency and allotting the reserved seat to the one with the greatest proportion of SC or ST in its population ( Election Commission 1966 : I, 8). 27. §9(1) (d). 28. In the following pages, comparisons of the reservedseat holders in the Lok Sabha with the occupants of general seats are based on data made available to me by Professor Henry C. Hart of the University of Wisconsin. These data consisted of (1) coded cards on all 497 members of the Third Lok Sabha from 1962 to 1965 and (2) coded cards based on his interviews with 189 members of the Lok Sabha in 196364. Of the sample, 108 were a random sample (30%) of Congress members. The remaining 79 were 60% of the opposition and independent members. The sample of the latter is not random, but is weighted slightly toward those active in the affairs of the Lok Sabha. In the sequel a source given simply as "Hart Data" refers to the larger set of cards on all members; the smaller set is referred to as the " Interview Sample." The Hart data is analyzed in more detail in Galanter 1979. Other data from the Hart study are presented in Hart 1971. 29. Krishna ( 1966 : 28) reports 19. 30. § 9 (1) (c). 47 none in which they were a majority of the population and only 13 in which they were as much as 30%. 31 The bulk of SC constituencies contain be en 10% and 30% of Scheduled Castes. Thus, the vast majority of SC perhaps 75% live outside the constituencies reserved for SC. Of the 111 Lok Sabha constituencies where SC constituted more than 20% of the population in 1961, only 46 were reserved, whereas 29 constituencies with less than 20% were reserved. On the whole, constituencies reserved for SC tend to be political backwaters slightly less urban, with less newspaper circulation and a slightly greater percentage of agricultural laborers. The same pattern of concentration of Scheduled Tribes and dispersion of Scheduled Castes reappears in the reserved seats in the state legislatures. In Andhra Pradesh, for example, SC make up only 21% of the population of the constituencies reserved for them (and 13% of the population of the general constituencies). But ST make up 43% of the population of the constituencies reserved for ST and only 2% of the general constituencies. 32. Designation of a constituency as reserved usually encounters opposition.
While everyone expressed anxiety that the Scheduled Castes and the Scheduled Tribes should get their full quota of reserved seats, very rarely indeed would anybody (unless he himself belonged to any of these castes or tribes) agree to any seat being reserved for them in a constituency in which he was personally interested. 33. The selection of reserved constituencies gives rise to the bulk of the objections to the proposed delimitation. As the Election Commissioner reports, ģerally speaking the vocal sections of the public objected to their own areas becoming part of a reserved constituency and put forward ingenious suggestions for reshaping two or more constituencies so that some particular constituency would be a general constituency. 34. However, these objections rarely bring about a change. The courts will not provide any relief so long as the Delimitation Commission has taken into account the factors specified by the Deliimitation Act. 35. ____________________ 31 My figures are taken from the Hart data. Krishna ( 1966: 28) gives slightly different figures, but the overall picture is not very different. 32. Election Commission 1976b: IIA, 265. Inspection of the Election Commission tables reveals that Andhra is not atypical in this regard. 33. Election Commission 1959: I, 57. For an instance of alleged manipulation in the opposite direction, see Saberwal 1972 : 74. 34. Election Commission 1968: I, 12. 35. Mastanaiah v. Delimitation Commissioner, A.I.R. 1969 A.P. 1. The Court rejected the argument that the Delimitation Commission was required to locate a reserved constituency in an adjoining district with a slightly higher percentage of Scheduled Castes. 48 Proposals for rotation of reserved constituencies have been rejected, and their location has remained relatively stable. 36. Of course, Scheduled Caste and Tribe candidates may stand for nonreserved seats. However, they have been notably unsuccessful in winning elections to them. In the first six Lok Sabhas, only a handful of candidates from SC or ST filled unreserved seats. Five were elected in 1971 and three in 1977. 37. In the lower houses of the state legislatures, the record is no more heartening, even though the smaller constituencies mean that local concentrations of population and resources should offer more opportunities for political success. For example, in 197071, there were only three SC and two ST representatives sitting in the 2,853 nonreserved seats in the Vidhan Sabhas. 38. There is no reservation of seats in the indirectly elected upper houses at both Centre and states. The Rajya Sabha at the Centre is elected by proportional representation by the members of the state Legislative Assemblies. 39. The upper houses (Vidhan Parishads) in those state legislatures that have them are chosen by a more complicated formula, combining election by the lower house, special qualified constituencies, and governmental nomination. 40. Here, too, the number of SC and ST has remained fairly small. In 196970, there were 13 SC and 5 ST among the 228 members of the Rajya Sabha, and 18 SC and 9 ST among some 703 members of Vidhan Parishads. 41. There is no constitutional requirement or statutory provision for reservations of political appointments within the legislatures or the government, such as cabinet ministerships 42. or membership on standing committees. However, it early became a convention to have at least one SC cabinet minister at the Centre and in each of the states. The number of SC ministers at the Centre and the number of ST ministers in the states has slowly risen.
____________________ 36. The Election Commissioner characterized a proposal for rotation (on the ground that no area should be permanently burdened with a reserved seat) as "mere lip service to the principle of reservation" and concluded that the "real purpose of such reservations would be largely defeated if the proposal be adopted" ( Election Commission 1959:I, 75). In the 1969 debate preceding extension for the third tenyear period, an amendment proposing rotation and supported by a disingenuous plea to afford opportunities for election to Harijans in other localities was negatived without a division of the House (LSD (4th Series), Vol. 34, No. 17, Cols. 361, 379 [9 Dec. 1969]). 37. RCSCST 197173:244; 197577:I, 2021. 38. RCSCST 197071:122. 39. Article 80. 40. Article 171. It should be noted that in only seven of the larger states is there a second chamber (Art. 168). 41. RCSCST 196970:92. 42. Article 164(1) provides that the states of Bihar, Madhya Pradesh, and Orissa shall have a minister in charge of tribal welfare who may in addition be in charge of Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes or any other work. 49 Reservation of seats on elective bodies at the local level is not specifically provided by the Constitution, but such arrangements are allowed by Article 15(4), and nearly all the states provide such reservations by election, cooptation, or nomination in various local bodies and panchayats. Similarly, most of the states have made some provision for representation of SC and ST in panchayat bodies. There is little data available on the extent to which these reservations have been implemented, much less on how effective they are. We may safely conclude that the presence of the Scheduled Castes and Tribes in legislative bodies is accounted for largely by the provisions for reserved seats. Very few members of these groups have been successful in open competition. Even their presence in bodies where there is no reservation (upper houses, cabinets) is due largely to the political base provided by reservations. Thus reservations do provide for a substantial quantitative presence that would otherwise be lacking. We cannot infer that without reservations, representation would be reduced to the present level of success in nonreserved seats. Their geographical concentration would assure the Scheduled Tribes at least a modicum of representation even in the absence of reservations. The more dispersed Scheduled Castes would undoubtedly obtain far fewer seats than they now enjoy, but we should not conclude that they would have none at all. If there were no reservations, some of the political talent among the SC now competing for reserved seats would compete for nonreserved seats. Parties would then need appealing candidates in areas with heavy concentrations of SC; perhaps slate makers would be less moved by the sense of "they already have their share" that now seems to affect the giving of tickets. (And of course, some representation would be provided by legislators from other groups, who would be accountable to constituencies with sizable numbers of SC voters.) Perhaps the best indication of the scale of representation that might be expected in the absence of reserved seats is provided by some data on elections to local bodies where no reservations were in force. In the early 1960s local bodies in West Bengal with a total of 1,081 members contained only 41 SC members (3.8%) and 16 ST members (1.5%). 43. Among the 66 presidents and chairmen there were 3 SC members and I ST. (According to the 1960 census, 19.84% of the population of West Bengal were SC and 5.91% were ST.) 44. A similar picture is presented by some fragmentary data from Gujarat where only 35 (0.5%) of 6,863
____________________ 43. RCSCST 196364: I, 163. 44. The population figures here are somewhat overstated, since SC and ST are less urban than the general population. But offsetting this, the small territorial constituencies ought to give these groups an advantage. Also, Bengal is reputed to be less resistant to the mobility of these groups than many other areas. 50 Sarpanches were from the SC. 45. The electoral experience of India's other large and (mostly) low status minority the Muslims does not offer additional reassurance. 46. The effect of reservation of seats on the quality of representation is more difficult to assess. How well served are the residents of the reserved constituencies? And, apart from them, how well served are the members of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes a great majority of the former who reside outside the reserved on constituencies? In what sense do the reserved seat legislators represent them? Does the presence of their fellows in reserved seats assure that they are better served by their own representatives? Finally, is the nation as a whole well served by these legislators? What effect do they have on the working of the legislatures? In assessing the quality of representation afforded by these representatives, we must recall the structural constraints imposed by the arrangements for reserved seats. The reservations are designed in a way which filters and muffles the representation of the interests of the Scheduled Castes and Tribes insofar as the diverge from the interests of other groups. The reservedseat legislator especially from the SC is responsible to and dependent upon a constituency made up overwhelmingly of nonmembers of his group. To the extent that these reservedseat legislators are assumed to be responsible and prudent politicians, this arrangement serves as a filter to keep the divergent interests of these groups from being expressed too directly or forcefully. This is especially the case with the SC representatives, whose constituencies are populated overwhelmingly by others. From a handful of studies we may draw a composite portrait of the Members of Parliament who occupy reserved seats. 47. They are younger and more rural in residence than their fellow legislators; fewer have professions (other than landholding), and they have less formal education. The median age of reserved seat M.P.'s is in the early forties; that of their fellows in general seats is in the early fifties. The disparity in age has remained constant over successive Lok Sabhas, but the gap in educational attainments has narrowed appreciably. Those in reserved ____________________ 45. RCSCST 196970:51 46. The percentage of Muslims (who make up about 11% of the population of India) in legislative bodies is small and declining. Muslim membership declined from 7.2% of the Lok Sabha in 1952 to 4.6% in 1971 ( Gauba 1973:245). Muslim participation in the State Assemblies is at roughly the same level and has been undergoing a similar decline ( Gauba 1973:26265; Krishna 1967:187). 47. My account is drawn from the comparisons of the occupants of reserved and general seats found in Chauhan and Chopra 1969 ; Dutta 1969 ; Narayana 1978; Mohopatra 1978. These accounts comport with the profile of Scheduled Caste M.P.'s in Parvathamma and Jangam 1969. 51 seats are younger when they are first elected to Parliament, and, unsurprisingly, come there with less legislative experience at the state level. 48. We may surmise that similar disparities might be found in state legislatures. 49. It is widely believed that reservedseat legislators are less articulate, less assertive, and less
independent than their fellows. Data on the Third Lok Sabha collected by Professor Henry Hart supplies some evidence for the view that reservedseat holders were as a group less active and less influential parliamentarians than those elected to general seats. 50. They were less likely to hold party office, to serve on select or standing committees, to hold ministerships, to contribute to debate, and to talk to ministers. Few, compared with holders of general seats, felt that they were effective advocates of their views. 51. One may, of course, wonder whether the most important sorts of representation are captured by these measures of participation. 52. Obviously, one must be extremely cautious in extrapolating from this data about the Third Lok Sabha to more recent performance under changed conditions, much less to conditions that might prevail in the future. Since the reservedseat legislators have come to resemble their fellows in terms of education, occupation, and urban residence, there may also be a convergence in legislative behavior. Or it may be that changes in political alignments have accorded reservedseat legislators a greater voice and elicited new patterns of participation. Low rates of participation do not imply a proportionate absence of effective representation of the interests of Scheduled Castes and Tribes. Presumably the activities of reservedseat legislators are concentrated ____________________ 48. Mohopatra 1978. 49. Mohopatra ( 1973) useful study of the Orissa Legislative study in 1969 (n=85 of 139) found that SC and ST legislators were younger and less educated, came from more agricultural backgrounds, and that fewer of them had independent professions. 50. The data referred to here is that described in n. 28 above. It would of corse be illegitimate to take this picture as reflective of current conditions. And it should also be emphasized that we would be on shaky ground generalizing from data on Parliament to conclusions about the working of reserved seats in the state legislatures. Nevertheless, the data does enable us to see the legislative reservation device in action, and it may provide a useful base line for comparison with later or state data. 51. The data on which these conclusions are based are presented in Galanter 1979. 52. They provide no measure, for example, of the vision or sustained energy whose absence is marked by Saberwal ( 1972: 7) when he notes that the Harijans in the reserved constituency that he studied had "no leaders who understood the larger institutional mechanisms which underlay and renewed the current inequalities, nor any who had the stamina for changing the larger system so that its proceses would generate effective . . . equality." He does not argue that this absence is produced by the reservation of seats, but such an argument is made elsewhere in connection with criticism of the dependence of reservedseat legislators. 52 on matters that affect these groups, 53. and their effectiveness in representing the interests of these groups should be most evident in their dealing with matters that contribute directly to their welfare: (1) establishing programs of which they are the beneficiaries; (2) insuring deployment of resources to these programs; (3) pressing for better administration of these programs; (4) resisting cutbacks and premature termination of such programs. Although I have no systematic data, there is some evidence to suggest that, in the Lok Sabha at least, reservedseat legislators have been prominent and sometimes influential in matters concerning the working of the preference policy. 54. The presence of the reservedseat legislators, if not in itself likely to raise the level of benefits, does seem to serve as a warrant of the continuation of these programs at their existing levels. Furthermore, their presence in such numbers provides a quantitative basis for Scheduled Caste and Tribe participation in leadership at the cabinet level; it is unlikely that there would be many persons
from these groups in cabinets were it not for the reserved seats. It appears that the initiation and expansion of programs for these groups is associated with the presence of group members in cabinet posts. The first reservations in government service were established by the efforts of the first Scheduled Caste member of the Viceroy's cabinet. Job reservations were first extended from initial appointments to the promotion stage under the auspices of the next SC politician to become a minister. Similarly, at the state level, the first extension of reservations to the ____________________ 53. Kochanek ( 1968:48) found Harijan M.P.'s in 1960 among the strong supporters of land ceilings and urban income ceilings and generally giving "higher than average support for any process of leveling." But cf. Mohapatra ( 1973:22) finding that reservedseat holders in Orissa displayed no overwhelming concern for these groups. The pattern in state legislatures may differ sharply from that in the Lok Sabha, as suggested by Dushkin 1972:210. 54. Narayana ( 1980) describes the heavy participation on such issues by Scheduled Caste representatives in the Lok Sabha from 1962 to 1971 and their success in securing the appointment of the Elayaperumal Committee and the standing Joint Committee on Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. The reservedseat legislators demonstrated their political prowess by killing the 1965 Lokur Committee report, which called for the descheduling of some tribes and castes (see chap. 5, § B, below). The dissatisfaction of the reservedseat members was instrumental in bringing about the Government's first defeat in the Lok Sabha in 20 years, a stunning snap vote on a 1967 motion that the constitutional safeguards for SC and ST were not being fully implemented. See Dushkin 1972:2068, who notes that this new assertiveness was followed by government's repudiation of the Lokur recommendations, appointment of new deputy ministers from among the Scheduled Castes, liberalization of the rules for reserving promotion posts in government services, increasing the reservations in direct recruitment, and (after years of promises) making converts to Buddhism and Christianity eligible for postmatriculation scholarships. 53 promotion stage occurred when a Scheduled Caste politician became chief minister of Andhra; the ascension of Scheduled Caste Home Minister in Madras was followed by a dramatic increase in the vigor of prosecution under the Untouchability (Offences) Act. 55. The potential leverage enjoyed by the occupants of reserved seats varies with the balance of party power in the legislatures. The more evenly balanced the party alignment, the greater the potential impact of the reserved seats. 56. Of course, representation is not the only virtue claimed for reserved seats and misrepresentation is not the only sin attributed to them. At the end of this chapter I shall sketch out the range of claims about costs and benefits that might be made in connection with compensatory discrimination programs. For example, do these schemes produce acceptance of Scheduled Castes or do they lead to rejection of them? Do they promote or retard the selfsufficiency and selfregard of the beneficiaries? Optimally, we should like to be able to answer such questions for each preferential program. 57. The data to do this are not available. In any event, it is difficult to separate the effects of reserved seats from the other components of the compensatory discrimination policy. We shall postpone further assessment untill we have surveyed the whole preference policy. But before leaving legislative reservations, we should note their special relationship to the whole of the compensatory discrimination policy. Reservations of government posts or university admissions often operate as guaranteed minimums rather than as allotments of places over and above those gained on merit. Therefore the net amount of preference they confer automatically declines as members of the preferred groups gain places on merit. Reservations in the legislatures do not have this automatic selfliquidating feature. However,
unlike other preferences, they alone are subject to a constitutional time limit this limit has been thrice extended. Since the presence of the reservedseat legislators undoubtedly contributed to this result, these reservations are in a literal sense selfperpetuating in a way that others are not. Furthermore, their presence helps to perpetuate other forms of preference; indeed, that is their purpose. They can only perpetuate preferences to the extent that they are influential so, self perpetuation is a mark of some success in fulfilling their function of representation. Thus self perpetuation is not to be accounted a negative feature unless the whole system of com ____________________ 55. Galanter 1972a. 56. E.g., Krishna ( 1966:32) notes that in 1962, SC legislators in reserved seats supplied the entire Congress plurality in 8 of 13 state legislatures, Dushkin ( 1972:205) calculated that in March 1967, at least 9 state governments were dependent on, reservedseat legislators. 57. Galanter ( 1979) attempts to do this for the reserved legislative seats. 54 pensatory preference is thought to be unjustified or to have outlived its justification. Although there is no time limit on the constitutional authorization of other forms of special treatment for Scheduled Castes and Tribes, one of the curious and significant things about the debate preceding each extension of reserved seats has been the extent to which the public, the press, and many parliamentarians proceeded as if an end to reserved seats was the end of all benefits and concessions to these groups. There is no constitutional or legal foundation for such an equation. The political reservations seemed in many minds to encompass the entire system of compensatory preference, and their extension was tantamount to heading off expiration of all benefits. This symbolic fusion may tell us something important about the way in which political reservations function to lock into place all the other programs for Scheduled Castes and Tribes. 58. When we focus (in Parts Two and Three) on the judicial encounter with compensatory discrimination, these reserved seats retreat into the background. Election disputes about reserved seats have been the source of almost all the litigation about group membership (taken up in chap. 9) because the greatest tangible prize for asserting membership is combined there with the greatest incentive for rivals to disprove it. But with that major exception, 59. legislative reservations have remained outside the ambit of the courts. Courts do not get involved in the allocation of reserved seats or the delimitation of constituencies. They have no occasion to assess the working of reserved seats. Our discussion of' the working of' legislative reservations should remind us that the courts are not the only and perhaps not the most crucial shapers of compensatory discrimination policy. If the courts, as we shall see, act to brake and confine the preference policy, the reserved legislative seats may serve to lend it motive power. B. EDUCATION AND OTHER SCHEMES The total number of persons directly benefitted by the reservation of legislative bodies and of' government jobs constitutes only a small ____________________ 58. Of course that insurance function might be performed by other means e.g., by a constitutional guarantee of continued preferential treatment until SC and ST enjoyed specified levels of well being relative to the rest of the population. It might thus be possible to delink the assurance of continued special treatment from the reservedseat device, permitting reserved seats to be evaluated in terms of their specific benefits and costs. 59. Legislative reservations were also the arena for important litigation about the problem of the doublemember constituency. After it was settled by the courts, statutory change made this doctrine moot in the legislative representation area, although it has general implications in the
administration of preferences. See chap. 13, § B, below. 55 fraction of the backward classes. They are far outnumbered by those who benefit from a vast array of special schemes for education and economic uplift. Among educational schemes are scholarship programs, provision of meals, supplies, and hostels for Scheduled Caste (SC) and Scheduled Tribe (ST) students; and the construction and maintenance of schools intended primarily for these groups. Joined to these are a lengthy catalog of measures to improve the economic status of the SC and ST: allotments of (and subsidies to purchase) agricultural land; installation of irrigation wells; provision of livestock, seeds, and tools; encouragement of cottage industries by the provision of training, supplies, and equipment; support for agricultural and craft cooperatives. Finally, there are schemes for providing housing, roads (in tribal areas), drinkingwater wells, health clinics, legal aid, and nursery schools. The "Backward Classes Sector" of the successive Five Year Plans provides a rough measure of expenditures on special measures for the disadvantaged. Planned expenditures for all categories for backward classes rose from Rs.300 million in the First Plan ( 195156) to Rs. 794 million in the Second Plan ( 195661) to Rs. 1,139 million in the Third Plan ( 196166) to Rs. 1,403 million in the Fourth Plan ( 196974) to Rs. 3,269 million in the Fifth Plan ( 197479). 60. A breakdown of plan expenditure 61. reveals a continuing emphasis on education as the major undertaking for SC. For ST, educational expenditures, now the predominant category, were earlier overshadowed by communications and more recently by economic uplift for isolated tribal areas. The plan provisions for Other Backward Classes (OBC) have followed a more irregular course owing to the controversy about the membership of that category. 62. Expenditure on OBC was 9.84 crores in the First Plan, 2. 63. in the Second, and 17.2 in the Third Plan. The projected expenditure on OBC in the Fourth Plan was 8 crores on education, 2 crores on economic development, and 1 crore on health, housing, etc.63 There was no provision under this heading in the Fifth Plan. These special undertakings for the backward form but a small fraction of plan expenditures. India's planners have been convinced that the improvement of the conditions of these "weaker sections" would flow from overall development. The special schemes for them represent a redistributive sub theme to narrow the gap that separates them from the rest of the population. It is a distinctly minor theme. In spite of the ____________________ 60. Planning Commission 1961: 701; 1970: 415. The scheme for postmatriculation scholarships is included, except for the Fourth Plan. 61. "Planned expenditure" refers to new developmental spending and does not include spending to maintain established "regular" government programs. 62. See chap. 6, below. 63. Department of Social Welfare 1969: 162. 56 rise in absolute expenditures, the backward classes sector (including the postmatriculation scholarship expenditures of the Education Ministry) accounted for 1.63% of the planned expenditure in the First Plan period; 1.87% in the Second Plan; 1.52% in the Third Plan; 1.12% in the Fourth Plan; and 0.83% in the Fifth Plan. 64. The amounts in question area a tiny fraction of the planned expenditure, and when we consider the vast population of the groups to be benefitted, we see how thin this special treatment is spread. Table 1 shows the per capita planned expenditure for SC and ST in the successive Plan periods. TABLE 1 ANNUAL PER CAPITA EXPENDITURE ON SCHEDULED CASTES AND
SCHEDULED TRIBES THE FIVE FIVEYEAR PLANS [IN RUPEES] Scheduled Castes 195156
195661
196166
196874
197479
Education Economic Uplift
1st 0.20 0.01
2nd 0.66 0.15
3rd 0.98 0.17
4th 0.85 0.20
Health, Housing, etc.
0.10
0.39
0.25
0.33
5th 1.44 0.51 0.52
TOTALS Scheduled Tribes
0.31
1.20
1.40
1.38
2.59
Education Economic Uplift
1st 0.48 0.41
2nd 0.78 1.78
3rd 0.98 1.82
4th 1.21 2.20
Health. Housing, etc.
0.90
1.34
0.78
0.29
5th 1.83 1.45 0.75
TOTALS
1.79 3.90 3.58 3.72 4.05 RCSCST 196566: 118; RCSCST 197071: 11617; RCSCST 197577: I, Sources: 16; II, 1820. The exchange value of the rupee decreased from $ 0.21 in 1951 to $ 0.12 Note: in 1979. The multitude of schemes, the paucity of useful; information about their working, and limitations of space and energy make it impossible to undertake even a rough sketch of these programs. To avoid being swallowed up in a sea of detail, we shall concentrate on the largest single item among these distributive programseducation. It entails the highest expenditures and directly affects the largest number of indi ____________________ 64. Department of Social Welfare 1969: 162; Planning Commission 1976: 115, 159. 57 viduals. Education is widely regarded as the prime instrumentality for improving the condition of the backward; and the elevation of the backward is seen as one of the most important social products of education. 65. Independent India has undergone a remarkable educational explosion. Expenditures and enrolments have increased steadily and rapidly. Government expenditures increased from Rs. 1,143 million in 195051 to Rs. 6,000 million in 196566 to an estimated Rs. 14,500 million in 197475. 66. Enrolments increased correspondingly from a total of 18.9 million in 195051 to over 58.2 million in 196566 to over 85 million in 197374. 67. In spite of rapid population growth, the growth of educational facilities has resulted in a great increase in the proportion of the population receiving instruction at every level. For example, enrolment in the elementary grades rose from 37.8% of the corresponding age group in 195051 to 83.5% in 197374. 68. Enrolment in higher education had risen from 0.7% of the 1823 age group in 195051 to 2.1% of vastly larger group by 196566. 69. Included in this general increase is an even more pronounced increase in the portion of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes children who go to school. These groups are still far below the general
population in educational accomplishments, but this must be seen against a starting point of almost total exclusion from educational opportunities until fairly recently. By the 1920s, there were thousands of Depressed Class (as they were then called) students in the primary schools many or most of them in segregated inferior schools . 70. Few went beyond the primary level. In 1927, the Hartog Committee found that enrolment of Depressed Classes children in secondary schools was 2.6% of enrolment in primary schools. 71. Only a handful of students from these groups managed to get higher education. In 1931, only 1.9% of the "Exterior Castes" and 0.8% of the "Primitive Tribes" were literate, compared with 8% of the total population. 72. In 1961 7.4% of Scheduled Castes and 6.28% of ____________________ 65. "One of the most important social objects of education is to equalize opportunity, enabling the backward or underprivileged classes and individuals to use their education as a lever for the improvement of their condition" ( Ministry of Education 1966: 108). 66. Planning Commission 1976: 75. 67. RCSCST 197577: II, 32ff. The figure of 85 million does not include higher education, which enrolled over one million by 196566 ( Ministry of Education 1966: 300). 68. Ministry of Education 1966: 161; RCSCST 197577: II, 32. 69. Education Commission 1966: 300. 70. Indian Statutory Commission (Hartog Committee) 1929: 226. 71. Indian Statutory Commission (Hartog Committee) 1929: 220. 72. Natarajan 1972: 81, 93, 95. The 1931 and 1961 Census Reports are the only ones that give information useful in making these comparisons. "Exterior Castes," as they 58 Scheduled Tribes were literate, compared with 24.02% of the total population. 73. Thus the recent figures reflect a vast increase in educational attainments for the lowest groups, though they still lag far behind the rest of the population. 74. The expansion of educational opportunity for the general population during the decades following Independence was accompanied by a special commitment to raise the educational level of the Scheduled Castes and Tribes. While free primary education was gradually extended to larger portions of the whole population, education through the secondary level was made free to SC and ST pupils. By 1955 most states allowed full fee concessions to SC and ST students at all levels. 75. Mere exemption from fees was found insufficient. Economic distress, apathy, and reliance on schoolage children to earn or look after younger children disinclined many parents from enrolling their children in schools and encouraging them to stay in school. 76. Some states have encouraged enrolment in the first years of primary school by providing free midday meals, free books and supplies, and a clothing allowance. 77. And for a fortunate minority, the few who reach the upper primary grades, there were prematriculation scholarships. 78. Even among these, the vast majority do not recieve such scholarship help. In some states prematriculation scholarships are awarded on merit rather than as of right. And state governments have sometimes failed to spend ____________________ were called, do not correspond exactly to the laterdesignated Scheduled Castes, but they are close enough for this crude comparison. Similarly, "Primitive Tribes" are not precisely equivalent to Scheduled Tribes. The 1931 tribe figures are for those "20 years and older" and may thus understate recent improvement. 73. Nataraian 1972: 118. The gap between SC and ST and the rest of the population is understated by comparing them with a "total" of which they make up almost onequarter. 74. It should be noted that there was a change in the operational definition of literacy. In 1931 it
meant those who had completed grade 4 in primary education; in 1961 it was based on a simple test of literal for those who claim to be literate without having completed primary school. 75. RCSCST 1955: II, 106. 76. RCSCST 195891 I, 48 (on the need for incentives for attendance); RCSCST 197577: I, 8990. 77. RCSCST 196061: 16168; RCSCST 197173: 5556. 78. In about 1956, a scheme of prematriculation scholarships was introduced for the SC, ST, and OBC. Payments under these scholarships start at grade 5 or 6 (age 11) and range from 23 to 72 rupees a year, increasing with each standard so that by standard 11 they range from 32 to 150 a year ( Department of Social Welfare 1969: 19192). During the Third Plan period a total of 1.7 million prematriculation scholarships or stipends were awarded to Scheduled Castes and over one million to Scheduled Tribes ( Planning Commission 1970: 416). This is less than half a million a year a small fraction of population of these groups. Most states have extended the schemes for prematriculation scholarships to OBC. Incomplete figures for ten states show over 88.000 prematriculation scholarships for OBC in 196061. 59 the amounts allocated to prematriculation scholarships. The Elayaperumal Committee found that the governments of A. P., Bihar, Punjab, Rajasthan, and West Bengal have lapsed the amounts allocated for prematriculation scholarships, while they deny the scholarships [to applicants] on the ground that the fund is not available. . . . This is due no doubt to lack of interest on the part of these Governments. 79. Lowered barriers, a changing atmosphere, availability of schools, and government aid have contributed to a great spurt in the enrolment of SC and ST students. In the lowest grades the percentage of children from these groups trailed behind the rest of the population, and in the higher grades there were still massive disparities ( table 2 ). TABLE2 SCHOOL ENROLMENT AS A PERCENTAGE OF CORRESPONDING AGE GROUP, BY COMMUNITIES 19731974 Classes
Others
SC
IV VIVIII IX+
83.5 35.6 21.2
68.9 22.1 11.0
ST 59.3 15.7 7.7
RCSCST 197577: II, 3234. For many purposes such figures should be regarded with utmost suspicion (suspicion not allayed by the fact that a number of states report enrolments of over 100% of the relevant age groups). But for the purpose at hand there is Source: no reason to think they do not give a rough idea of the disparities among SC, ST, and the rest of the population. A slightly different set of figures is found elsewhere in the same report: RCSCST 197577: I, 88. With expanding enrolments, wastage (dropping out) and stagnation (repeating a grade) were accentuated as major problems in Indian education generally. Of 100 pupils enrolled in grade I only
half reached grade 3 in the prescribed 2 years, and only half of that half finish grade 6 on time. The rate of attrition is even more pronounced among Scheduled Castes and Tribes. 80. There is a strong correlation between social status and the proclivity to stay in school. 81. In one revealing study, comparing the influence of a multitude of factors, caste was the aspect of social structure with the strongest effect on wastage. 82. ____________________ 79. Department of Social Welfare 1969: 193. 80. Sharma and Sapra 1969: 1. 81. Sharma and Sapra 1969: 81. 82. Sharma and Sapra 1969: 96 ff. The more influential variables were behavioral (e.g. steady attendance) and attitudinal (e.g. motivation for learning from home). It 60 For those who manage to remain in school there are serious problems of the suitability and quality of the training they receive. The former policy of creating special schools for these groups has been severely criticized for perpetuating their segregation. There is some indication, too, that the standards in schools intended primarily for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes are much lower than in general schools. It is now generally agreed that mixed schools are preferable wherever possible. 83. Even where they are located in areas without special problems and enrolled in mixed schools, children from lowstatus groups tend to attend schools with the leastadequate facilities, the least qualified teachers, and the leastadvantaged fellow students. 84. Combined with lower resources and motivation in the family setting, these disadvantages cumulate as they move up the educational pyramid. Of those who survive the course, most emerge with academic records that are not prepossessing. 85. Notwithstanding these difficulties, the number of Scheduled Caste students who reach higher education increases steadily. The contrast with the situation before. Independence is stunning. In 1927, out of a total of almost 55,000 college students in all of India (excluding Bengal), there were 82 students from the Depressed Classesless than 15/100 of one percent of total enrolment. 86. By the 1961 Census, SC and ST were still only a tiny portion of the nation's graduatesa very generous estimate would be about 1.6%, a more cautious one closer to 1%. 87. Access to higher education has remained a matter of prime concern ____________________ might be thought that these things are associated with the educational attainments of the parents. But of course the parents with the lowest educational status are most likely to belong to the lower castes. D'Souza 1969 : 91. 83. The number of pupils in special schools declined from 829,000 in 195152 to 465,000 in 196061 ( Ministry of Education 1955: 111; 1968 : 135). One of the causes of low enrolments is lack of school in depressed areas, and as schools are established to meet this need, more children will in fact be receiving separate education. This is especially so for Tribals where the policy of bringing schooling to remote areas and making the first years available in tribal languages effectively separates them. 84. In a study of 21 schools in Chandigarh the schools were stratified on the basis of fees: in the highergrade schools the pupils were exclusively of the "Advanced Castes," in thirdgrade schools there were 25% "other castes" ( D'Sounza 1969 : 1005). 85. Shah and Patel 1977 : 59. 86. Indian Statutory Commission (Hartog Committee) 1929 : 128, 220.
87. There were, according to the 1961 Census, 1.147 million graduates. There were 6,307 SC and
1,087 ST graduates counted in urban areas. The rural SC and ST were listed only as "matriculation and above." If we make the unlikely assumption that the same proportion of rural as urban matriculates were graduates, we arrive at an estimated total of 16,223 SC and 2,938 ST graduatesabout 1.6% of the total. 61
to leaders of all backward class groups. A centrally funded scheme of postmatriculation scholarships for Scheduled Castes was founded in 1944. It was extended to Scheduled Tribes in 1948 and Other Backward Classes in 1949. There was an early commitment to provide a scholarship for every qualified applicant from the SC and ST. Total scholarships for these groups grew from 731 in 1948 to 37,372 in 1958, to 156,834 in 1968, and to 350,000 in 1975. Expenditures rose from Rs. 500,000 to Rs. 136 million. 88. Virtually every applicant from these groups received a scholarship. Scholarships for Other Backward Classes were more highly competitive. 89. The number of scholarships for OBC increased rapidly in the early years, but more slowly after 1955 as the whole question of special treatment for this group became controverted. Until 1961 the OBC for purposes of this scheme were lists of castes (and communities) supplied by each state. In 1961 the Center abandoned the earlier notion of drawing up an authoritative list of OBC and recommended to the states a changeover to an economic basis for determining backwardness. 90. from 196364, post matriculation scholarships were awarded on an income basis. The applicants were divided into two slabs: those with annual family incomes of less than Rs. 1,500 and those with income between Rs. 1,500 and Rs. 2,000 (except in the case of technical courses, where the upper limit is Rs. 2,400). Students from the first slab had first priority for scholarships; any remaining funds were used for those in the higher slab. Within the slabs, students from families with lower income were to be given priority, but where income was the same and there were insufficient funds available, selction was to be on merit. 91. For SC and ST applicants, there was a much higher income ceiling: scholarships were available to those whose monthly income is below Rs. 500. 92. Several states pay far less than the stipends recommended by the central governmentRs. 40 per month to hostellers and Rs. 27 to day scholars for graduate and undergraduate courses, and Rs. 75 for hostellers and Rs. 60 for day scholars in Medicine and Engineering. 93. ____________________ 88. RCSCST 197577: I. 93; RCSCST 197173 : 27475. 89. E.g., in 195859, there were 37.654 applications but only 12.590 scholarships awarded. 90. See chap. 6, below. 91. Government of Maharastra, Education and Social Welfare Dept., Resol. No. CSP 1065M(SG) Statement C, pp. 1516 ( 1966). The recipients under this new dispensation were called "Economically Backward Classes" from 1963 to 1965, when their name was changed to "Lower Income Group Students." 92. There had originally been an income ceiling, which was withdrawn in 1957 and reimposed in 196162. 93. E.g., Punjab pays Rs. 15 to intermediate students and Rs. 20 to B.A. and B.Sc. students. 62 The central government's standards were set in 195455 and have not been raised, in spite of great increases in the cost of living. As one might expect, SC and ST students are concentrated in the less prestigious, less demanding, and less potentially renumerative subjets. Students from the OBC have a much different profile of enrolmenta much larger portion are students in the highly competitive engineering and medical
fields. In 195859, 37.8% OBC students at the postmatriculate level were studying medicine or engineering; in contrast, only 6.4% of postmatriculate SC and ST students were enrolled in these subjects. 94. These students tend on the whole to be less well prepared than their fellows. As we have noted, many of them come from schools with poor facilities, as well as from families with little educational background. They tend, as might be expected, to be poor academic performers. Although little data is available, it seems that the wastage (dropout) rate among SC and ST college students is staggeringly high. For example, a survey conducted in Maharashtra found that 25% to 40% failed in their firstyear exams, about 70% failed in intermediate, 10% in their junior year, and between 40% and 60% in their final exams. Only 8% received their degrees within the prescribed four years, and about 85% left college without a degree. 95. Those who do get through tend to get low grades. 96. The policy of reservations has been widely adopted in higher education, but the general expansion of facilities has meant that there is room enough for everyone except in a few highly coveted fields. Reservations are of consequence only where opportunities are scarcenotably in institutions for professional and technical training. The Ministry of Education requested that all states and universities reserve 15% of places in these institutions for SC and 5% for ST; that the maximum age be relaxed by three years and the minimum marks for admission be reduced by 5%. Most states have provided for such reservations in at least some institutions. But although accepted in theory, they have not been fully implemented. A rough indication of the actual extent of such reservation and of its effectiveness is provided by the results of a survey of medical and engineering colleges conducted by the Elayaperumal Committee. In the 42 colleges that replied, less than 11% of seats were reserved for SC and far less than half of these were actually filled by SC candidates. 97. The general level of inclusion reflected in these figures comports with several later readings. From data available on 67 of 97 medical colleges in 197273, Dushkin computed that 6.6% of medical ____________________ 94. RCSCST 195859 : 176. 95. Department of Social Welfare 1969 : 203. 96. RCSCST 196869 : 65. 97. Department of Social Welfare 1969 : 23744. 63 students in 197273 were Scheduled Castes. 98. Available data show that 157 of 2,301 (6.8%) admitted to 22 medical colleges in 197576 were Scheduled Castes. 99. None of these estimates tells us about the percentage of SC students who graduate. Reservations in professionalschool admissions have been of great concern to OBC. Such reservations are in force in at least nine states. 100. Indeed, reservation of these highly prized medical admissions can be taken as a crude measure of state commitment to divert resources to the groups denominated as OBC. The composition of these groups differs greatly from state to state. As reservations for OBC are sometimes larger than for SC and ST and they never go unfilled, they represent a major claim on a muchcoveted and scarce opportunity. In a number of states reservations for OBC in professional colleges have become a focus of conflict between putative OBC and other groups. 101. We shall encounter these reservations frequently in the sequel, for virtually all of the litigation about the compensatory discrimination policies in education has been about reservations in medical and engineering colleges for the Backward Classes. Although it remains unclear just how much of the increase in education for the backward classes represents "special treatment" over and above what is provided for the whole population, it is clear that compensatory discrimination provisions can be credited with securing the inclusion of these groups as beneficiaries of the educational explosion. And it has enabled them to "catch up" to some
extent. If "catching up" is taken to mean greater percentages gains over a baseline period for the backward than for others, there clearly has been catching up in this sense. But "catching up" may also mean narrowing the gap (expressed, e.g., in percentages) between the backward and the rest of the population. Here, it seems, there has been substantial catching up at the lower educational levels, but not at the higher levels. C. ADMINISTRATION Limitations of space and energy do not allow even a cursory review of protective measures, of the development programs in the tribal areas, and of the many distributive schemes outside the field of education. These latter include provision of free housesites, subsidies for the ____________________ 100. See table 20, in chap. 6, below. 101. The politicization of medical admissions is apotheosized by the arrangement in Jammu and Kashmir in which the admissions list was issued directly by the Chief Minister of the State. See Subhash Mohan Jalili v. Principal, A.I.R. 1967 J. & K. 106. 98. Dushkin 1979 : 663. 99. RCSCST 197577 : II, 36. 64 construction of houses, allotments of acreage to the landless, improvement of methods of agriculture and animal husbandry; health measures such as provision of wells, mobile dispensaries, and maternity centers; encouragement of cooperatives and cottage industries. Such schemes have been mainly for the Scheduled Castes (SC) and Scheduled Tribes (ST). There has been only a small expenditure on welfare measures for Other Backward Classes (OBC). 102. A reading of the official reports suggests that such distributive schemes have on the whole been less intensive and less successful than efforts in education. Since any assessment of compensatory discrimination policies requires that we consider not only the announced schemes but the level of performance, we conclude with a very brief characterization of the administration of compensatory discrimination schemes. Our gross characterization will undoubtedly do some injustice to detail. Hidden in the dismal aggregates are some gems of devoted and effective implementation. But all accounts point in the same direction as far as the overall character of implementation is concerned. There are persistent "shortfalls" in expenditures. That is, the allocation of government moneys for these programs has been greater than the ability of the various agencies to spend it. Over and over again there are reports of failure to spend more than a fraction of the money allocated to programs for the backward classess. 103. Shortfalls in expenditure reflect lack of vigorous and imaginative leadership, inadequacy of planning, absence of coordination between agencies, and deficient arrangements for collecting data on the progress of schemes. There are delays at the Centre in making grants; states are disinclined to make sufficient matching grants where that is required. Skill, enthusiasm, and political push are in short supply. 104. How much of this spending actually represents preferential treatment for the backward classes? There is some evidence that administrators sometimes feel that it is not necessary to include Scheduled ____________________ 102. The annual reports of the Commissioner for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes provide data on central and state schemes for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. On schemes for Backward Classes it is necessary to consult reports issued by the various states. 103. Department of Social Welfare 1969 : 130, 14445. RCSCST 196364 : 27, 33. 110; RCSCST 195960 : I, 17. (The Commissiner, notes that part of the spending is only on paper. He estimates
that fully onethird of the spending reported represented transfers to other accounts to prevent lapse of appropriations.) SASTC : I, 100, observes that shortfalls are greater in economic and health programs than in education. This suggests that the money is more readily spent where the administration's job is to pass it on to interested and alert recipients to spend in existing institutions than where the administration is called upon to erect and operate programs of its own. 104. RCSCST 195960 : I, 1314; RCSCST 196061 : 66; SASTC : I, 78, 102. 65 Castes within general schemes, so that in part the budget for backward classes replaces rather than enlarges the benefits to which they are entitled under general welfare measures. 105. This is most clearly documented in the case of the Scheduled Tribes. In 1960 the Dhebar Commission pointed out that although the Centre's special provision for Scheduled Tribes were meant to supplement the general welfare programs of the states, many states had not pursued normal development programs for the ST and instead used the central funds as a substitute rather than a supplement. 106. A decade later a Study Team noted "with regret": Though the attention of State Governments has been repeatedly drawn to the fact that the special provision in the plan for S.T. and O.B.C. is not in lieu of the provision in the general development programme but is intended to supplement it . . . no conscious attempt has been made by any of the State Governments with the solitary exception of A.P. to ensure that the tribals receive a reasonable share of benefits of the general development programme to which they . . . are legitimately entitled. 107. But persistent complaints suggest that it is also true of the various distributive programs (other than education) for the Scheduled Castes. This point emerges starkly from Aggarwal and Ashraf's study of Scheduled Castes in Haryana, where we see these policies through the eyes of their beneficiaries. A majority of the 500 household heads we interviewed for our study complained that they were excluded from the general aid programme of the government. Many asserted that their applications were either not accepted or they were rejected mainly on the plea that there were special provisions for them. Some said that they were clearly told to go to the "Harijan department." We learned that the general impression among the people, including the government officials, was that "the Harijans were lucky to have all those special provisions." Most of our high caste informants, too, shared the same view. They said that Harijans should feel satisfied with the special privileges. In fact there was complete ignorance about the smallness of the budget and the myriad administrative problems. People who normally evince sympathy for the weaker sections and support the idea of special privileges know very little about the programme and feel complacent. Even the government officials were rather poorly informed on the details of the social welfare programme and therefore assumed that enough was being done by the govenment for the Scheduled Castes. . . . ____________________ 105. Dushkin 1961 : 1702. The Commissioner pointed to the need to make benefits additional rather than substitutes (RCSCST 196061 : 75; Department of Social Welfare 1969 : 166). 106. SASTC : I, 73. 107. STTDP : 13. 66 In order to get some idea of what this exclusion means for the Harijans, we may
compare just one set of figures . . . only Rs. 200,000 was provided in the 197374 budget of the Welfare Department for the Scheduled Castes and Backward Classes, for business loans. Compared to this the Haryana Government allocated over 220 million rupees in the year 197273 as takavi and crop loans to the farmers. As we can see, this figure is a thousand times the amount provided for the Harijans. Had there been no special provisions for the Harijans and they were given a proportionate share of the bigger amount they would have got 44 million rupees. That would have been 240 times the amount that they now get. 108. Sometimes the schemes turn out to be special in the sense of separate rather than additional. Programs may be administered in such a way as to perpetuate the segregation they are intended to overcome. Particularly in housing, which tends to be located away from highercaste localitiesand consequently in schools, wells and meeting hallsthe provision of special facilities has tended to perpetuate isolation. (Similarly, officials faced with "controversial" claims by Scheduled Castes for the use of facilities, are tempted to achieve a settlement by diverting development funds into provision of what are in effect separate wells, etc.) Although the total expenditure on these schemes is small, there is a great plethora of schemes. The proliferation of small schemes consumes a large portion of expenditures in their administration. 109. Benefits can be made available to only a small fraction of those who are nominally eligible under any given program. Locating programs and establishing eligibility is a demanding undertaking for wouldbe beneficiaries, made more demanding by passive and torpid administration. Those most in need of help are least likely to have the literacy, information, contacts, and skills to navigate the tortuous channels leading to inclusion. 110. These programs are administered in a routine, mechanical fashion. There is no attempt to generate feedback from those affected. Recordkeeping about actual results is fragmentary and incoherent. There is no serious attempt to monitor the effectiveness of programs. One officer in a state office that had been administering a number of schemes for fifteen years reported that the office had never discontinued any scheme on grounds of ineffectiveness. Many programs not only are adminis ____________________ 108. Aggarwal and Ashraf 1976 : 17172. 109. Thus out of a sum of Rs. 100,000 sanctioned for a Tribal Development Block, nearly three quarters was spent on staff salaries (SSTDP : 29). 110. On the problem of illiterate tribals whose applications for land allotments are rejected as improperly filled in, see STTDP : 21. Cf. the problem of securing approvals for schemes from standing committees of Panchayat Samitis and Zilla Parishads, which meet infrequently and irregularly (RCSCST 196263 : 5). 67 tered in a lackadaisical fashion but are of doubtful suitability to local conditions. 111. Lower officers enjoy little discretion to modify schemes to suit local conditions. Nor is there much enthusiasm, initiative, or inventiveness in the higher echelons. Departments dealing with backward classes attract little talent. Experienced staff tend to flee these departments, which offer few channels for promotion. Wellqualified officers move on to better prospects elsewhere. 112. The ranks are filled with rejects from other departments. 113. The listlessness of administering the means is matched by thoughtlessness about goals. The mindless, goingthroughthemotions quality of administration is nicely captured by Aggarwal and Ashraf: In our discussions with the Haryana government officials, from the State to the tehsil
level, we found that no one talked of a goal to be achieved through the special privileges programme. Outside the government, too, neither the Scheduled Caste leaders nor the high caste persons were aware of any goal. In other words nobody seemed to know what was to be achieved and by what date. The Haryana Welfare Department publishes a report each year . . . These reports are built around the previous year's budget which contains all the details about the schemes, the sources of funds, the amount, allocation for each district on the basis of its population, and even the number of cases to be served. The reports then simply mention the amount spent and the number of grants and loans given. There is no projection of what is to be achieved and by what date. If equality is the objective, which is implied, no mention is made with whom and by when it is to be achieved. All of this clearly indicates that this programme is activity centered and not goal centered. Such a goalless programme suffers from many deficiencies. One is that it is impossible to evaluate. Only activities can be listed and expenditure accounted for. Beyond that no one can say whether the programme is achieving anything because achievement can be measured only against a goal. Furthermore, it induces a false sense of accomplishment in the administrator. He feels satisfied as long as he is able to spend the money and cater to a specified number of clients. A feeling of complacency is generated which in turn kills initiative for greater efficiency and achievement. With an easily achievable target of activities already set; only an extraordinary official will strive on his own. 114 Generally, administration of these programs is a matter of low priority, which commands little attention from ministries or from legisla ____________________ 111. On the failure of housing colonization schemes for tribals, see STTDP: 8, 1617 112. RCSCST 196263 : 2. 113. RCSCST 196061:13; STTDP : I, 49. 114 Aggarwal and Ashraf 1976 : 17677. 68 tors. 115. Thus legislators have paid little attention to the reports of the Commissioner for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. State officials have been less than assiduous in responding to requests for information. There seems to be little genuine curiosity about how the schemes do work in fact. In spite of the vast quantity of paper that is generated by the administrators, there is remarkably little data about how the schemes work. For the most part the departments of social welfare or Harijan welfare found in each state Government are not independent administrative departments, but have only advising and coordinating functions in relation to the regular governmental departments which administer these programs. 116. Administration of special benefits is by the departments concerned with the general welfare programs of housing, education, agricultural loans and so forth. Government departments whose major task is dealing with the disadvantaged tend to have little prestige or influence within the government. As one M.P. observed of the Central Department of Social Welfare: Nobody takes the decisions of this department into consideration and no other department cares for this department. No department complies with the directions and promises of this department. The conditions prevalant in the State level [are] worse. 117.
This is reflected in the surprised observation of the Elayaperumal Committee that although State Ministers in charge of Welfare of B.C.s had unanimously decided that the principle of earmarking funds in the general sector for the Welfare of the SCs should be implemented this decision was not carried out. 118. One wellplaced officer offered the suggestive generalization that the minister in charge of backward classes or social welfare is usually the weakest in the state cabinet. ____________________ 115. See Schermerhorn ( 1969) for an interesting attempt to measure the priority levels of Scheduled caste programs in various states. 116. At the Centre these functions were housed in the Home Ministry until 1964, when all aspects other than government employment and the Scheduled Areas were transferred to a new Department of Social Security, later renamed the Department of Social Welfare. In a subsequent reorganization they were returned to the Ministry of Home Affairs in 1973 (RCSCST 196465 : I, 1; 197273 : I, 251). In 1978 for the first time backward classes matters became the subject of a separate wing within the Home Ministry. 117. Shri Baidhar Behara at LSD (4th Series), Vol. 16, No. 50: Col. 3152 ( 25 April 1968). This was said of the Social Welfare Department. See n. 116 above. 118. Department of Social Welfare 1969 : 166. 69 Problems in carrying out constitutional policies for these groups were not unanticipated. The Constitution established a special "watchdog" agency to monitor the working of the "safeguards" for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Article 338 provides: 1. There shall be a Special Officer for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes to be appointed by the President. 2. It shall be the duty of the Special Officer to investigate all matters relating to the safeguards provided for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes under this Constitution and report to the President upon the working of those safeguards at such intervals as the President may direct, and the President shall cause all such reports to be laid before each House of Parliament. 119. The Office of the Commissioner for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes was established pursuant to this provision. The original conception that the Commissioner would serve as an independent critic of government was gradually effaced as the office took on tasks of oversight and evaluation of programs. 120. It proved no match for the problems of resistance, low priority, poor planning, and lack of coordination that beset these programs. Its investigative potential is limited by lack of funds, inadequate staffing, and the absence of power to require testimony and records. It has no capacity to generate data of its own, and no power to induce other agencies to provide it with information. The Commissioner's annual reports are filled with accounts of the unwillingness of other agencies to supply information or even to answer specific inquiries. 121. The original aspiration to establish the Commissioner as an independent body (like the Election Commission or the Union Public Service Commission) was forgotten over the years. In 1967 the Commissioner's field organization was dismantled and replaced by a regional organization subordinate to the Central Department of Social Welfare. To the Elayaperumal Committee this was the culmination of a process in which the Commissioner's organisation was gradually . . . reduced to the position of a subordinate office of the Government of India with the result that he became powerless not only in respect of the various State Governments but even with the various Departments/Offices of the Central Government. He
____________________ 119. This provision refers only to the SC and ST. Article 338(3) says that those references "shall be construed as including references to such other backward classes as the President may, on receipt of the Commission appointed under [Art. 340(1)] . . . by order specify." The abandonment of the expectation that there would be a Presidential Order specifying the Other Backward Classes is recounted in chap, 6, §3, below. 120. CWSCST (4th) 1 (1969). 121. On the working of this officer, see Fisher 1970. 70 has been powerless even to collect the basic and requisite data for his assessment in fulfillment of his constitutional duties. His annual reports are a record of his bewailings and beseachings [sic] year after year. 122. Without any investigative capacity of his own the Commissioner was reduced, in the words of another Study Team, to [discharging] his constitutional functions through those very agencies on whose performance in certain spheres he may be called upon, by virtue of his office, to sit in judgment. 123. In 1977 the Commissioner reported that his office had "only two Research Officers and two Investigators." 124. In 1968, Parliament established its own "watchdog" institution, the Joint Parliamentary Committee on the Welfare of Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. This is a thirtymember body elected by the two houses of Parliament (20 from Lok Sabha, 10 from the Rajya Sabha) for twoyear terms. The Committee is mandated to recommend measures to implement the Commissioner's Reports, and to monitor central government programs and practices. Unlike the Commissioner's Office, the Joint Committee has investigative powers. The Committee has issued a series of detailed reports (there were 65 by early 1976), each concerned with a single agency or problem. A number of these are followup reports, tracing the response to its earlier recommendations. The Committee has focussed heavily on extending and implementing reservations in central government jobs and in public corporations, and in higherechelon educational opportunities. 125. Comparable oversight committees were established in some states in the 1970s. Rising concern over atrocities against Scheduled Castes and eagerness to allay charges of neglect, combined with dissatisfaction with the Commissioner's Office, led to the establishment of yet a third central "watchdog" institution in 1978. A fivemember Commission for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes was appointed and empowered to investigate the implementation of safeguards (particularly job reservations) and antidisabilities laws. The functions of the new Commission were described as corresponding broadly to those entrusted to the Commissioner, and the government suggested that the Constitution would be amended to reflect this replacement. 126. ____________________ 122. Department of Social Welfare 1969: 399. 123. STTDP: 89. 124. RCSCST 197577: I, 65. 125. On the establishment of the Joint Committee and its performance during its first years, see Narayana 1980. 126. LSD (6th Series), Vol. 16, No.5: Col. 26264 ( 21 Jul. 1978). For an interpretation of this puzzling event, see Economic and Political Weekly 13: 1159 ( July 28, 1978). 71
On a daytoday basis the function of prodding the administration is performed not by these formal "watchdog" institutions but by the M.P.'s and M.L.A.'s usually the occupants of reserved seats. They intervene with the administration to champion beneficiaries' grievances, urge priority for programs, overcome inertia, and move things through channels. As one backward classes leader observed, "If reservations in the legislature are taken away, educational schemes will not work, for there will be no one to press the ministers." 127. D. CRITICS, COSTS, AND BENEFITS Few in independent India have voiced disagreement with the proposition that the disadvantaged sections of the population deserve and need "special help." But there has been considerable disagreement about exactly who is deserving of such help, about the form this help ought to take, and about the efficacy and propriety of what the government has done under this head. The major lines of criticism may conveniently be sorted into objections to what the government has not done and objections to what it has done. Critics of the first (omission) type may in turn be divided into those who criticize the Government for doing not enough and those who criticize it for doing not the right thing. Not enough criticisms include insufficiency of appropriations and expenditures, inadequacy in the extent and scope of reservation, failure to implement programs with sufficient zeal. Not the right thing criticisms point to the government's failure to do things it ought to have done e.g., to aim its educational efforts at preparing backward class students for offices rather than trades (or vice versa). Those who make these criticisms of nonperformance or omission have generally been favourable to the main lines of the government's policy of special treatment and seek to see it augmented or redirected. 128. A much more widely articulated set of criticisms has come from those who question the main lines of the Government's policy of special treatment. These (commission) critics, too, may be conveniently di ____________________ 127. Interview with G. Latchanna. Hyderabad, 1965. 128. A great deal of criticism along these lines is found in government sources, especially the topical reports of the Committee on the Welfare of the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes, and the annual reports of the Commissioner for Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. A massive compilation of such objections to government policy may be found in the report of the Elayaperumal Committee ( Department of Social Welfare 1969). All of the above deal with Scheduled Castes and Tribes. For assessment of Schemes for Backward Classes, see Government of Tamil Nadu 1971; Government of Karnataka 1975. Views along this line are also forthcoming from organizations of beneficiary groups. 72 vided into those who think the government has done too much and those who think it has done the wrong thing although many of these critics link the two. The too much view asserts that preferential treatment, especially reservations of various kinds, has been overdone and costly in terms of efficiency, utilization of talent, morale, and basic fairness. But the great focus of dissatisfaction has been the use of caste and community groups in selecting the beneficiaries. In what has become the conventional wisdom on the matter, the use of caste units has been blamed for perpetuating the caste system, accentuating caste consciousness, alienating and demoralizing the groups who are benefitted, augmenting political abuse of caste by promoting "vested interests in backwardness," impeding the development of secularism, and other sins as well. Thus it has been asserted by two sociologists that reservation on the basis of caste . . . has affected the morals, the administration and the
society adversely. The attempt to atone for the injustice perpetuated on the lower caste [sic] in times past has in effect become a tool of aggrandisement in the hands of the numerically large and hence politically dominant caste groups in majority of the states. 129. A political scientist has observed that governmental definition of backwardness in terms of caste has perpetuated and accentuated the caste consciousness. The judiciary by upholding classifications based on caste, has also helped the growth of the virus of casteism. This has undermined the foundations of the secular state