Advances in Insect Physiology
Volume 12
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in Insect Physiology edited by...
26 downloads
979 Views
17MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in Insect Physiology
Volume 12
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in Insect Physiology edited by
J. E. TREHERNE M. J. BERRIDGE and V. B. WIGGLESWORTH Department of Zoology, The University Cambridge, England
Volume 12
1976 ACADEMIC PRESS LONDON NEW Y O R K S A N FRANCISCO A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
ACADEMIC PRESS INC. (LONDON) LTD 24-28 Oval Road London NW1 US edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. 111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
Copyright @ 1976 by Academic Press I n c (London) Ltd All Rights Reserved
No part of this book may be reproduced in any form, by photostat, microfilm or any other means, without written permission from the publishers
Library of Congress Catalog Card Number: 63-14059 ISBN: 0-12-0242 12-5
Printed in Great Britain at The Spottiswoode Ballantyne Press by William Clowes & Sons Limited London, Colchester and Beccles
Contributors Fotis C. Kafatos
The Biological Laboratories Harvard University, 16 Divinity Avenue, Cambridge, Massachusetts 02138, USA, and Department o f Biology, University of Athens, Panepistemiopolis, Kouponia, Athens (621), Greece
E. David Morgan Department of Chemistry, University of Keele, Keele, Staffordshire ST5 5BG, England Colin
F. Poole’
Department of Chemistry, University of Keele, Keele, Staffordshire ST5 5BG, England Hugh Fraser Rowell
Department of Zoology, University of California, Berkeley, California 94720, USA Klaus Sander
Biologisches Institu t I ( Z ool ogie), D er Albert-Ludw igs- Universitat, Katharinenstrasse 20, 7800 Freiburg im Breisgau, Federal Republic of Germany J. E. Steele
Department of Zoology, University of Western Ontario, London 72, Ontario, Canada
Present Address: Department of Pharmacy, 7 h e University of Aston in Birmingham, Gosta Green, Birmingham 8 4 7 E T.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contents Contributors
....................
Sequential Cell Polymorphism: A Fundamental Concept in Developmental Biology FOTlS C. K A F A T O S . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
v
. .
1
The Extraction and Determination of Ecdysones in Arthropods E. DAVID M O R G A N AND C O L I N F. POOLE . . . . . .
.
17
The Cells of the Insect Neurosecretory System: Constancy, Variability, and the Concept of the Unique Identifiable Neuron HUGH FRASER R O W E L L . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
63
Specification of the Basic Body Pattern in Insect Embryogenesis K L A U S SANDER . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 125 Hormonal Control of Metabolism in Insects J. E.STEELE . . . . . . . . . . . . .
239
Subject Index
325
....... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Cumulative List of Authors
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
345
. . . . . . . . . . . .
347
Cumulative List of Chapter Titles
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Sequential Cell Polymorphism: A Fundamental Concept in D eve lo p m ent a I B io lo g y Fotis C. Kafatos The Bioiogicai Laboratories, Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts, USA, and Department of Biology, University of Athens, Athens, Greece 1 Introduction 2 Cellular metamorphosis in the saturniid labial gland . 3 The sphingid labial gland: a more complex case of cellular metamorphosis 4 The cocoonase organules of the silkmoth galea: multistage sequential polymorphism in epidermal derivatives . 5 The follicular epithelial cells of silkmoths: biochemically defined sequential polymorphism 6 General discussion Acknowledgements References
.
.
.
. .
.
1 2 4
.
5
*
.
. . .
9 11 12 12
1 Introduction Many years ago, Wigglesworth (e.g. 1954) introduced the concept of sequential cell polymorphism. The outstanding example was the production of distinct types of cuticle and of cuticular derivatives by insect epidermal cells undergoing metamorphosis in a succession of moults. For historical reasons, the concept has been primarily associated with developmental changes occurring during discrete moulting cycles, under the impetus of changing hormonal states. I believe that this formulation of the concept is only a special one, and that the concept is fundamentally applicable t o a very wide variety of developmental phenomena. I believe that developmental regulation centrally involves the programmed expression of specific gene sets in an orderly and often overlapping sequence. The programming of this sequential expression is what makes cell types fundamentally different from each other, and must ultimately be understood if we are to understand development. The actual sequential expression can be 1
2
FOTIS C. KAFATOS
described as a succession of visibly differentiated states. According to the physiological exigencies of the system, this succession may or may not be entrained by hormonal changes; sequential polymorphism may be relatively ,gradual, as well as saltatory. In this formulation, sequential polymorphism refers to a succession of distinguishable but possibly overlapping states of determination and differentiation-regardless of the physiological mechanisms which may have evolved t o control the cell's progress through the succession. The value of this concept to the developmental biologist is that it gives proper attention to the dynamic, temporal aspects of regulation, instead of placing the commonly excessive emphasis on a static end state of differentiation. In this paper, I will discuss polymorphism while reviewing the work that my colleagues and I have performed over approximately the last ten years. Many additional examples (including some that are more apt) could be adduced t o illustrate the concept of sequential polymorphism in this extended formulation.
2 Cellular metamorphosis in the saturniid labial gland The paired labial glands of larval silkworms are known as silk glands. In saturniids, as in B o m b y x (Yamanouchi, 1921), they are long tubes, ending blindly at their distal end and opening together in the spinneret on the labium. Two main parts can be distinguished. The posterior division is secretory, producing and storing the silk proteins, fibroin and sericin. The anterior division (Kafatos, 1971) is a narrower duct, which serves to conduct the liquid silk from the secretory division to the spinneret during spinning. This duct consists of approximately 1000 highly polyploid cells. Their main function appears t o be the production and maintenance of a thick (up to 20 pm) cuticle, which forms a rigid tubular channel. Shearing forces developing during the extrusion of silk through this narrow channel may serve to orient the metastable fibroin molecules, facilitating their subsequent crystallization into an insoluble thread (Lucas et al., 1958). It is also possible that the duct serves of modify the silk solution in subtle ways, by addition or removal of components. However, comparison of the abundance (relative to dry mass) of radioisotopes of CaZ+,K? and C1- in the cocoon and in stored liquid silk gives no evidence that the duct adds ions to silk. If anything, slight reabsorption of I C and C1- from liquid silk may occur during spinning. At pupation, the secretory division completely degenerates (as does the entire silk gland in B o m b y x ) . The duct, however, is preserved. The cells shed their characteristic larval cuticle and their cytoplasm regresses. The
CELLULAR POLYMORPHISM
3
nuclear branches, highly extended in the larval cell, are pulled together into a compact mass, surrounded by a thin layer of cytoplasm (Fig. 1 in Selman and Kafatos, 1974). Evidently, the pupal cells are at a developmental standstill. However, during the subsequent adult development they grow again and undergo a dramatic metamorphosis. First they secrete a thin (<1 pm), loosely fibrous cuticle, strikingly different from that in the larva. Then their mitochondria proliferate and become intimately associated with deep plasma membrane infolds which develop, first in the basal and then in the apical side of the cells. At or near the time of adult emergence, much of the cell consists of these mitochondria-membrane associations (Fig. 2 in Selman and Kafatos, 1974). This structural specialization corresponds to the new function of the cells: the gland now secretes copious amounts of essentially isotonic KHC03 solution (Kafatos, 1968). Physiological experiments suggest that active transport of K + by the cell, from the blood into the lumen, may drive the production of the secretion as a whole. The rate of secretion is very high: the volume of liquid produced per minute approaches the volume of the secretory cells. The copious secretion promotes the digestion of the cocoon by the enzyme cocoonase, in those species which lack an escape valve (Kafatos and Williams, 1964). The transformation of the larval, predominantly cuticle-producing cells into the predominantly salt-secreting cells of the adult is under hormonal control (direct or indirect). The transformation occurs during the metamorphic moults, which are triggered by ecdysone acting in the near or total absence of juvenile hormone OH). If JH is injected into the pupa at the very beginning of adult development (Hakim, 1972), the cells become pupaladult intermediates, with variable development of the mitochondriamembrane associations. A cuticle is always produced, whereas the pupal cells apparently lack a cuticle (Hakim, 1972). However, the cuticle in juvenile hormone-injected animals is usually considerably thicker than in normal adults. In fact, in some cases (including some glands forced by transplantation and J H injection to develop beyond the pupal state twice in the presence of JH), the ultrastructural appearance of the cuticle is somewhat reminiscent of that in the larval duct (Hakim, 1972). Formally, this cannot be considered a case of reversal of metamorphosis, since the pupa does not produce a cuticle. It can be argued that the information for producing a larval-type cuticle is included in the “pupal gene set”, but is normally not implemented because secretion of any cuticle is blocked by a mechanism which thereafter becomes insensitive to the presence or absence of the hormone. In any case, the abnormal cuticle and the unequal development of the adult specializations of the labial gland in different JH-injected animals (Hakim, 1972) suggest that the metamorphosis of the labial gland may not be a unitary process under all-or-none control by the
4
FOTIS C. KAFATOS
hormone. The period of JH-sensitivity is limited t o the beginning of adult development (Hakim, 1972). The cells of the labial gland are polyploid and thus do not undergo cell division. Later than the period of hormone sensitivity, and at about the time the mitochondria-membrane associations begin to appear, DNA synthesis does occur. This could be associated either with further growth of the cells which is occurring at that time, or with a necessity for new copies of the genome for “reprogramming” into the adult state of differentiation. The results of inhibitor experiments suggest that the former explanation may be correct: the DNA synthesis can apparently be inhibited without interfering with the metamorphosis of the cells (Selman and Kafatos, 1974). In conclusion, the labial gland cells of saturniids are an example of sequential cell polymorphism under hormonal control. The transformation into the adult state does not appear t o require DNA synthesis. The existence of pupal-adult intermediates suggests that several, partially dissociable processes may be involved in this transformation. Salt secretion, the function of the adult state, is certainly not unique t o these cells-but it is so extensively developed as t o constitute a state of differentiation as distinct as, say, that of the cecropia mid-gut (Anderson and Harvey, 1966), or the Malpighian tubules (Berridge and Oschman, 1969). 3 The sphingid labial gland: a more complex case of cellular metamorphosis In the sphingid, Munduca sextu, the duct of the larval labial gland again undergoes transformation during metamorphosis (Hakim, 1972; Hakim and Kafatos, 1976). In this case, the larval duct has a cuticle thinner than that of saturniids, but similar in construction. The secretory division produces a lubricant, rather than silk fibres, and the duct may play a more active role than in saturniids, since it has moderately prominent mitochondriamembrane associations (Figs 7-9 in Hakim and Kafatos, 1976). The secretory division of the larval gland degenerates during pupation, and the duct transforms into the complex salivary gland of the adult (Hakim and Kafatos, 1974, 1976). In contrast t o the uniform saturniid adult glands, each of the paired sphingid adult glands is divided into four distinct regions (Hakim and Kafatos, 1974). In a posterior t o anterior division, these are region I, which consists of cells specialized for the production of invertase; region 11, the c d s of which produce a K+-rich salt solution and are as rich in mitochondria-membrane associations as the saturniid adult gland; region 111, which contains squamous cells with sclerotized cuticle, apparently functioning in the forward conduction of the dilute invertase solution produced
CELLULAR POLYMORPHISM
5
by regions I and 11; and region IV, which appears to function in the reabsorption of salts and the concentration of the saliva. In addition to the paired glands, a short common duct (region V) exists; it appears t o be derived from the larval common duct and t o be purely conductive in function. All four cell types of the paired glands are derived from the polyploid cells of the paired larval ducts (Hakim and Kafatos, 1976). During adult development the pupal cells, which were initially uniform in appearance, begin t o be distinguishable by their cytoplasmic growth pattern. Then they secrete distinctive cuticle, different for the various gland regions. Finally, they assume the cellular morphoIogy that corresponds to their respective adult functions. The origin of the adult regions from specific areas of the larval duct has been investigated by extirpation, transection and transplantation experiments (Hakim and Kafatos, 1976). While the cells are expressing their larval differentiation, they are already programmed fo\y specific adult states. At least in the fifth larval instar, particular areas of the duct are already determined to form specific adult regions. Preliminary experiments with earlier larval stages suggest that at least some determination may exist before the fifth instar. In the sphingid gland, sequential polymorphism is again punctuated by the moults of metamorphosis. The polymorphism is more dramatic than in saturniids, in that it results in the formation of several distinct cell types from the duct cells of the caterpillar. Moreover, one of these cell types secretes a digestive enzyme, invertase, which is undetectable in the larval gland. In this system, it is clear that a number of different (adult) determination states can coexist with the same (larval) state of overt differentiation. Since determination is the first step of differentiation, the results emphasize the temporal overlap between the states of sequential polymorphism,
4 The cocoonase organules of the silkmoth galea: multistage sequential polymorphism in epidermal derivatives Cocoonase is a trypsin-like proteolytic enzyme which digests sericin, loosening the silk fibres and permitting the moth t o escape from the cocoon (Kafatos and Williams, 1964; Kafatos et al., 1967a, b ; Hruska and Law, 1970; Hixson and Laskowski, 1970; Hruska et al., 1973; Felsted et QZ., 1973; Kramer et al., 1973). It is produced in the form of a zymogen, which is activated as it appears on the surface of the animal, one to two days before adult emergence (Berger et aZ., 1971; Berger and Kafatos, 1971a; Felsted et al., 1973). The cells which produce the zymogen are
6
FOTlS C. KAFATOS
lound in epidermal organules (Lawrence, 1966), in the lateral aspects of modified mouthparts, the maxillary galeae (Kafatos and Williams, 1964; Kafatos and Feder, 1968; Kafatos, 1970; Kafatos, 1972a; Selman m d Kafatos, 1975). The galeae first appear as two conical protuberances of the epidermis during the metamorphosis of larva into pupa. At that time they consist of a seemingly uniform population of epidermal cells, indistinguishable from those found in other parts of the integument. The cells produce the thick pupal cuticle and remain otherwise inactive throughout the pupal life. This epidermal cell population gives rise t o the zymogen-producing organules (luring adult development (the pharate adult stage). Formation of the organules presupposes action of ecdysone in the absence of JH: when sufficient JH is injected at the beginning of the moult cycle, so as t o cause I he development of a “second pupa” instead of an adult, formation of the Lymogen organules is blocked and the cells remain in the state characteristic of the pupa (unpublished observations). The period of JH sensitivity does not extend beyond the first two days of adult development. In gross terms, the sequential polymorphism is punctuated by the action of devclopmental hormones, and may seem t o be saltatory (from a cuticleproducing to a zymogen-producing state). Closer attention t o the process of zymogen organule formation reveals that this description is oversimplified (Kafatos, 1970; Kafatos, 1972a; Selnian and Kafatos, 1975). The hormonal state prevalent at the beginning of adult development does not bring about in one step the characteristic adult function (zymogen production), but instead initiates an entire sequence of “adult” developmental states, one of which corresponds t o production of Lymogen during a limited time period. This is particularly evident from the ultrastructural studies (Selman and Kafatos, 1975). Sequential polymorphism is saltatory in an overall sense, but gradual or multistage in detaiI. Early in adult development, the epidermis retracts from the pupal cuticle, leaving behind the moulting gel. Some cellular growth occurs, and then mitotic figures appear in the lateral epidermis of the galea. These are presumed t o be differential divisions, because of the vertical orientation of the spindle, which contrasts with the horizontal orientation in proliferative divisions of the insect epidermis (Lawrence, 1966). By day 5 of the three-week period of adult development, the epithelium is pseudostratified and several cell types begin t o be distinguishable. The organule forms from the specific association of three cells, which are probably derived from the differential divisions. Two of these cells become polyploid and are ultimately destined to synthesize zymogen (cells Z1 and Z 2 ) , and the third (cell D) forms a unicellular cuticular “main duct” which permits extrusion IWO
CELLULAR POLYMORPHISM
7
of the zymogen from the organule to the surface of the galea. These cells surround each other' in their apical region, forming three coaxial cytoplasmic layers, with the cytoplasm of cell D outermost and that of Z1 innermost; more basally, the coaxial arrangement is disrupted and the cells a e separate. The coaxial arrangement of the apical cytoplasmic regions is related to the morphogenesis of the main duct and of an attached cuticular valve, the end apparatus. The latter regulates extrusion of the zymogen into the main duct, from a storage cavity surrounded by cells Z, and Zz . Beginning with day 6, cells Z 1 and Zz retract from the surface, but during this process the intercellular junctions between Z 1 and Zz, Zz and D, and D and normal epidermal cells, respectively, remain intact. As a result, the formerly apical surface of cell D is drawn inwards and comes to line a narrow tubular extracellular channel; this surface then secretes a thin cuticular layer, forming the hollow tubular main duct. The formerly apical surfaces of Z1 and Zz secrete cuticular material, which makes up the end apparatus; cell Zz also contributes to the most basal part of the main duct, and to the joint between main duct and end apparatus. When completed, the main duct and the joint have a continuous epicuticular lining (cuticulin), and are thus presumably impermeable. By contrast, the end apparatus lacks such a lining and consists of fibrous cuticular walls, which are presumably permeable. The end apparatus includes a round ampulla and two long collecting ductules. The lumen of the ductules is free, whereas the ampulla is occluded by two dense fibrous cones, presumably preventing premature passage of the zymogen from the ductules into the main duct and thence to the surface of the animal. The respective cuticular structures are formed by the three cells of the organule on days 7 t o 9. The cuticulin layer, which is initially secreted in contact with numerous microvilli of cell D (Locke, 1969), constitutes a continuous barrier preventing occlusion of the duct by subsequently secreted cuticular material. By contrast, the material that will form the end apparatus penetrates freely into the long invaginated space created by the retraction of cells Z1 and Z2 away from the surface. Two long, microtubule-filled processes of cell Z1 (pseudoflagella) traverse this space and prevent its total occlusion by the cuticular material. The material is first deposited as a solid tubular mass, between the formerly apical surface of cells Z1 and Zz and the axial pseudoflagella. On day 9 this mass is suddenly reorganized into the loose fibrous wall of the end apparatus. The dense cones capping the ampulla are formed somewhat earlier, at the site occupied by the pseudoflagella, as the latter begin to degenerate. Further degeneration of the pseudoflagella creates the lumen of the collecting ductules.
8
FOTIS C. KAFATOS
As the cuticular mass secreted by cells Zl and.Z, transforms into the rid apparatus, these cells retract away, leaving an extracellular cavity 1)etween their apical surface and the apparatus. This cavity is now filled by ocoonase zymogen, which is synthesized and secreted by cells Z1 and Z 2 . \s zymogen accumulates, the cavity expands tremendously, reaching a ltmgth of 200 pm by day 15. It appears that the collecting ductules may c longate in paraIlel during this time, suggesting continued cuticle pro(luction, probably by cell Z 1 . Biochemical studies have revealed more definitively the time course of lymogen synthesis (Berger and Kafatos, 197 l b ; Kafatos, 1972a). The rate ( ) f S J nthesis is very low on days 7 and 8. Once the end apparatus and the \torage cavity have been formed, the rate begins t o increase substantially, t hanging from less than 1 per cent of total protein synthesis in the galea at the end of day 8 t o approximately 60 per cent of the total at the end of ctay 14. The absolute as well as the relative rate of zymogen synthesis increases by nearly two orders of magnitude during this &day period. Then, I he rate of synthesis decreases precipitously. The stored zymogen (nearly r ~ O p sper galea, or 2 ng per zymogen cell) is extruded through the end ipparatus and the main duct, and appears at the surface of the galea as tctibe cocoonase. The enzyme is used shortly thereafter, in conjunction tvith the KHC03 solution of the libiaI gland, t o open a hole in the cocoon I t the time of adult eclosion. The organules regress and remain functionless I hroughout the brief life of the adult moth. With respect t o zymogen production, the main period of differentiation lor cells Z1 and Z2 is day 9 t o day 14. We have called this period of rapid \ynthesis “full differentiation” or phase I1 (Kafatos, 1972a). The period of linite but low zymogen synthesis preceding it is phase I and the period of \hut-off is phase I11 (protodifferentiated and modulated states, respectively, ~ccordingto Rutter et al., 1968). The mechanisms regulating the transitions 1)etween the states are unknown. However, the kinetics of change in the tat? of zymogen synthesis during phase I1 are generally consistent with a bimple transcriptional control model (Kafatos, 1972a, b; Kafatos and Gelinas, 1974). According t o this model, at the beginning of phase I1 iranscription of the zymogen gene is set at a high, nearly maximal rate, and 1 e m i n s so throughout phase 11. The zymogen mRNA produced accumulates continuously because of its high stability and is translated at a constant efficiency, thus supporting an ever-increasing rate of protein bynthesis. Although the information necessary for testing this model in detail is not available, the key postulates of the model appear t o be ;enerally valid for highly specialized cells having a proIonged phase I1 (long time constant systems: Kafatos and Gelinas, 1974). These postulates are: a ,ingle copy of the specific gene per genome, high and essentially constant t
t
CELLULAR PO LY MORPH ISM
9
transcription of this gene during phase 11, high stability of the mRNA, and constant efficiency 'of translation (polypeptides produced per mRNA molecule per minute). With respect to sequential polymorphism, it is noteworthy that zymogen production is not the only differentiated function of cells Z 1 and Z 2 . At the beginning of adult development, the cells of the galea behave like ordinary epidermal cells, undergoing apolysis and secreting moulting gel. Following the mitotic divisions, cells Z1 and Z2 become distinguishable and their apical cytoplasmic regions undergo an intricate morphogenesis. Then these cells secrete specialized cuticular products. At the same time the ceIls begin production of zymogen at a low rate (phase I). When the cuticular valve is in place, zymogen production shifts to the fully differentiated state (phase 11); a low level of cuticle production may persist, at least for cell Z 1 . The end of zymogen production coincides with unknown cellular activities, leading t o zymogen extrusion and activation and t o the regression of the cells. Except for the initial hormonal requirements, nothing is known about the mechanisms controlling the progression through this sequence of distinct, temporally overlapping functions. One suspects that the timing controls are internal t o the organule, rather than external hormonal changes. Only development of the gland in organ culture could answer this question.
5 The follicular epithelial cells of silkmoths; biochemically defined sequential polymorphism
The follicular epithelium in silkmoths consists of a single layer of cells surrounding an oocyte and the seven associated nurse cells. The entire complex is a follicle. A linear array of attached progressively more mature follicles constitutes each of the eight ovarioles in the ovaries of a developing adult. The formation and early functions of the follicle have been reviewed recently (Telfer, 1975). In response t o the hormonal conditions which trigger adult development, the follicles begin their growth, emerge in sequence from the sheath of the germarium, and enter vitellogenesis. During vitellogenesis, intercellular channels open u p among the follicular epithelial cells, permitting access of the blood proteins to the oocyte surface. There, specific uptake of vitellogenin takes place, leading t o formation of yolk spheres within the oocyte. During this period, the follicular epithelial cells appear to help vitellogenesis not only by the formation of channels, but also by secretion of a histidine-rich product, probably a glycoprotein, which finds its way through the channels into the oocyte; this product may aid the specific
10
FOTlS C. KAFATOS
upt .ike of vitellogenin (Anderson and Telfer, 1 9 6 9 ) . The epithelium also appears t o produce a thin vitelline membrane between itself and the ooc yte. ,\t the end of vitellogenesis secretion of the histidine-rich product stops, tht. intercellular channels close up, and a substantially thicker vitelline membrane is deposited by the follicular epithelial cells. During this time, thc oocyte swells considerably by uptake of water (terminal growth phase; Anderson and Telfer, 1969). It is not known what, if any, contribution the epithelium makes t o the uptake of water. Following terminal growth, the epithelium secretes the largely proteinaceous eggshell or chorion. This last tie\ elopmental stage, choriogenesis, has been studied extensively io recent ) e m (reviewed in Kafatos et al., 1976; and Kafatos, 1975). Upon its conclusion, the follicular epithelium is shed (ovulation), and the oocyte, SUI rounded b y the fully formed shell, is ready for passage into the ovidict, tei tilization, and oviposition. rhe chorion consists of four size classes of proteins (A, B, C and D, re\pectively, in order of increasing molecular weight; Paul et al., 1972). O\ erall, the proteins are unusually small and very distinctive in amino acid c o inposition (e.g. 35 per cent glycine, but essentially histidine-free; comIwye the follicular cell product synthesized during vitellogenesis). At least 1 5 to 20 chorion polypeptide species can be distinguished by electrophoresis on SDS-polyacrylamide gels, and more than double that number on isorlectric focusing gels (Regier, 1975; Kafatos et al., 1976). Within each \i/r class the individual components are closely similar to each other; valuericing studies on A proteins suggest that the similarity is due t o Iiomologous amino acid sequences (Regier, 1975). At the outset of choriogenesis, the synthesis of proteins other than c:hurion declines precipitously. The various chorion proteins then begin to I N synthesized in sequence. There are gross changes in terms of synthesis of p'trticular size classes; thus, C proteins are produced early and their \>nthcsis is soon overtaken by A and B synthesis. In addition, there are numerous changes in the synthesis of various subclasses and of individual ptllypeptides. The absolute or relative rates of synthesis of a large number o I chorion components wax and wane individually during choriogenesis. Phese temporal changes could be described by a series of overlapping curves (svnthetic rate versus time), differing in shape, height, width, and time of aiiainment of the maximum value. Based on the pattern of chorion pioteins synthesized at any one time, eighteen distinct stages of choriog( nesis can be identified in Antheraea polyphemus (Paul and Kafatos, 107 5). Each lasts approximately three hours, and thus choriogenesis rc,quires approximately two days. An important observation is that progression through this sequence of dc velopmental stages is autonomous. When follicles are placed individually
CELLULAR POLYMORPHISM
11
in organ culture, in a completely defined medium, they proceed through the normal sequence of stages at the same rate as they would in vivo (Paul and Kafatos, 1975). Moreover, follicles in terminal growth can enter choriogenesis in culture. Thus, the sequential polymorphism of choriogenesis is not under the immediate control of external hormones. An initial hormonal stimulus is necessary t o initiate the process of follicular maturation during adult development, but the programme of developmental changes which is thus set in motion becomes independent of external cues at some point. Our long-term goal is t o understand the mechanisms internally regulating the temporal sequence of stages in choriogenesis. The mRNAs for chorion proteins have been identified (Gelinas and Kafatos, 1973), and resolved electrophoretically into a number of bands, after removal of their poly(A) (Vournakis et al., 1975); the poly(A) causes smearing of the intact messages, presumably because it is variable in length (Vournakis et al., 1974). mRNA labelling and cell-free translation studies (Kafatos et al., 1976) suggest that the messages are synthesized throughout choriogenesis, and accumulate in a state suitable for cell-free translation only during this time. Higher molecular weight mRNAs appear t o be produced in the early chorionating stages, in parallel with production of the higher molecular weight C proteins. It remains t o be determined whether the detailed programme of sequential polymorphism evident at the level of chorion protein synthesis is paralleled in equal detail and is driven by a corresponding transcriptional programme. 6 General discussion In the four systems discussed in this paper, sequential polymorphism is evident at a morphological, functional, or biochemical level. Since we are dealing with insects, in all cases the hormonal conditions of metamorphosis play a role in permitting the unfolding of this polymorphism. However, the polymorphism is not a simple binary alternative under the immediate control of the hormones. Detailed studies indicate that even in the simplest case, the saturniid labial gland, the “adult state” as it develops can be distinguished into a series of phases (e.g. growth, cuticle formation, and elaboration of mitochondria-membrane associations). It is a matter of perspective whether these phases will be considered distinct stages of differentiation, or will be subsumed under a single temporal programme. The multistage or progressive nature of polymorphism is most clearly evident when this process can be defined biochemically, as in the follicular epithelium. In that case, we can ultimately look forward to understanding polymorphism not only in terms of what triggers it but also in terms of how it proceeds in detail: we can hope to understand the continuing temporal controls on the expression of identifiable genes. The
12
FOTIS C. KAFATOS
con(ro1s need not be hormonal, and in fact in the follicular system they apptbar to be internal to the system itself. *Zs we learn more about a system, our perspective shifts from the o \ ~ i a l lgated process to the continuous changes which make it up. For convenience, we may still describe the continuous changes in terms of a succession of stages. This perspective of development as sequential polymotphism, as a temporal progression through distinct states of gene qxpression, a progression which has strong elements of self-regulation, is widely applicable. One only needs to reflect on the sequential production and disappearance of specific enzymes during slime mould development, or 011 the sequence of rapid changes occurring during early embryogenesis, even in the absence of a functioning nucleus. Having used the term sequential polymorphism to make the connection with classical studies on inscct development, I should now say that i t is important to view insect deLelopment with the modern perspective of cell differentiation in all orgmisms. Once used, sequential polymorphism might best be replaced by thr term temporal programming. Insect development offers a number of opportunities for studying temporal programming a t this deeper level-and in fact offers the po5sibility of studying this process directly at the level of gene activity. An ex
Foundation, and Harvard University. I thank my secretary, Linda S. Lawton, my assistants, P. B. Moore and M. Koehler, and my students and co I leagues whose contributions are identified in the References. References Anderson, E. and Harvey, W. R. (1966). Active transport by the cecropia midgut. 11. Fine structure of the midgut epithelium.]. Cell Biol. 31, 107-134. Anderson, L. M. and Telfer, W. H. (1969). A follicle cell contribution to the yolk spheres of moth oocytes. Tissue and Cell, 1, 633-644. Ashburner, M., Chihara, C., Meltzer, P. and Richards, G. (1974). Temporal control of puffing activity in polytene chromosomes. Cold Spring Harb. S y n p . quant. BioZ. 38, 655-662.
CELLULAR POLYMORPHISM
13
Berger, E. and Kafatos, F. C. (1971a). Immunochemistry of an insect protease, cocoonase and its zymogene. Immunochemistry 8, 391-403. Berger, E. and Kafatos, F. C. (1971b). Quantitative studies of prococoonase synthesis and accumulation during development. Deul Biol. 25, 377-397. Berger, E., Kafatos, F. C., Felsted, R. L. and Law, J. H. (1971). Cocoonase 111. Purification, preliminary characterization and activation of the zymogen of an insect protease. J. biol. Chem. 246, 4131-4137. Berridge, M. J. and Oschman, J. L. (1969). A structural basis for fluid secretion by malpigian tubules. Tissue and Cell, 1 , 247-272. Felsted, R. L., Kramer, K. J., Law, J. H., Berger, E. and Kafatos, F. C. (1973). Cocoonase. IV. Mechanism of activation of prococoonase from Antheraea p o l y phemus. J. biol. Chem. 248, 3012-3020. Gelinas, R. E. and Kafatos, F. C. (1973). Purification of a family of specific messenger ribonucleic acids from moth follicular cells. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 70, 3 7 64-37 68. Hakim, R. S. (1972).The growth and differentiation of lepidopteran labial glands. Ph.D. Thesis, Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass. Hakim, R. S. and Kafatos, F. C. (1974). The structure and salivary function of the labial gland in adult Manduca sexta. Tissue and Cell, 6 , 729-750. Hakim, R. S. andKafatos, F. C. (1976). Cellular metamorphosis. 11. The larval labial gland duct andits prospective adult fates in the tobacco hornworm. Devl. Biol. 49, 369-380. Hixson, H. F. and Laskowski, M. (1970). Evidence that cocoonase and trypsin interact with soybean trypsin a t the same reactive site. Biochem. (Easton, Pa.) 9, 166-1 70. Hruska, J. F. and Law, J. H. (1070).Cocoonases. In “Methods in Enzymology” (Eds G. E. Perlmann and L. Lorant), vol. 19, pp. 221-226. Academic Press, New York andLondon. Hruska, J. F., Felsted, R. L. and Law, J. H. (1973). Cocoonase of silkworm moths: catalytic properties and biological function. Insect Biochem. 3, 31-43. Kafatos, F. C. (1968). T h e labial gland: a s a l t secreting organ of saturniid moths. J. exp. Biol. 48, 435-453. Kafatos, F. C. (1970). Cocoonase synthesis: cellular differentiation in developing silkmoths. In “Problems in Biology: RNA in development” (Ed. E. W. Hanly), pp. 111-140. University of Utah Press, Salt Lake City, Utah. Kafatos, F. C. (1971). Cellular metamorphosis. I. The labial gland of Antheraea pernyi. Endocr. Exp. 5 , 101-107. Kafatos, F. C. (1972a). The cocoonase zymogen cells of silk moths: a model of terminal cell differentiation for specific protein synthesis. In “Current Topics in Developmental Biology” (Eds A. A. Moscona and A. Monroy), vol. 7, pp. 125-191. Academic Press, New York and London. Kafatos, F. C. (1972b). mRNA stability and cellular differentiation. Acta endocr. Suppl. (Copnh), 168, 319-345. Kafatos, F. C. (1975). In “Control Mechanisms in Development: Activation, Determination and Modulation of the Genetic Program” (Eds R. Meints and E. Davies), vol. 62, 103-121. Plenum Press, New York. Kafatos, F. C. and Feder, N. (1968). Cytodifferentiation during insect metamorphosis: the galea of silkmoths. Science, N. Y. 161, 470-472. Kafatos, F. C. a n d Gelinas, R. E. (1974). In “MTP International Review of Science-
FOTIS C. KAFATOS
14
Biochemistry of Differentiation and Development” (Ed. J.,Paul). vol. 9,pp. 223-264. Medical and Technical Publishing Company, Oxford. K.iFatos, F. C. and Williams, C. M. (1964). Enzymatic mechanisms for the escape of certain moths from their cocoons. Science, 146,538-540. L f a t o s , F. C., Tartakoff, A. M. and Law, J. H. (1967a). Cocoonase I. Preliminary characterization of a proteolytic enzyme from silkmoths. J. biol. Chem. 242, 1477-
1487. k‘ifatos, F. C., Law, J. H. and Tartakoff, A. M. (1967b). Cocoonase 11. Substrate specificity, inhibitors and classification of the enzyme.J. biol. Chem. 242, 1488-1494. h‘rfatos, F. C., Regier, J. C., Mazur, G . D., Nadel, M. R., Blau, H., Petri, W. H., Wyman, A. R., Gelinas, R. E., Moore, P. B., Paul, M., Efstratiadis, A., Vournakis, J. N., Goldsmith, M. R., Hunsley, J. R., Baker, B. and Nardi, J. (1976).The eggshell of insects: differentation-specific proteins and the control of their synthesis and accumulation during development. In “Results and Problems in Cell Differentiation” (Ed. W. Beermann), Biochemical Differentiation of insect glands. In press. SpringerVerlag, Berlin, Heidelberg, New York. hramer, K. J., Felsted, R. L. and Law, J. H. (1973).Cocoonase. V. Structural studies on an insect serine protease. J. biol. Chem. 248,3021-3028. I.awrence, P. A. (1966). Development and determination of hairs and bristles in the milkweed bug, Oncopeltus fasciatus (Lygaeidae, Hemiptera). J. Cell Sci. 1, 475-498. I ocke, M. (1969). The structure of an epidermal cell during the development of the protein epicuticle and the uptake of molting fluid of an insect. J. Morph. 127,7-39. Lucas, F., Shaw, J. T. B. and Smith, S. G. (1958).The silk fibroins. Adv. Protein Chem. 13, 107-241. I’aul, M. and Kafatos, F. C. (1975).Specific protein synthesis in cellular differentiation. 11. The program of protein synthetic changes during chorion formation by silkmoth follicles, and its implementation in organ culture. Deul Biol. 42, 141-159. I’aul, M., Goldsmith, M. R., Hunsley, J. R. and Kafatos, F. C. (1972).Specific protein synthesis in cellular differentiation. Production of eggshell proteins by silkmoth follicular cells. J. Cell Biol. 55, 653-680. Kegier, J. C. (1975).Ph.D. Thesis, Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass. iiutter, W. J., Kemp, J. D., Bradshaw, W. S., Clark, W. R., Ronzio, R. A. and Sanders, T. G. (1968). Regulation of specific protein synthesis in cytodifferentiation. J. Cell. Physiol. 72, 1-18. \elm:tn, K. and Kafatos, F. C. (1974). Transdifferentiation in the labial gland of silk moths: is DNA synthesis required for cellular metamorphosis? Cell Differentiation, 3 , 81-94. Selman, K. and Kafatos, F. C. (1975). Differentiation in the cocoonase producing silkmoth galea; ultrastructural studies. Devl B i d . 46,132-150. relfer, W. H. (1975). Development and physiology of the oocyte-nurse cell syncytium. In “Advances in Insect Physiology” (Eds J . E. Treherne, M. J. Berridge and V. B. Wigglesworth), vol. 11, pp. 223-319.Academic Press, London and New York. Vournakis, J. N., Gelinas, R. E. and Kafatos, F. C. (1974). Short polyadenic acid frequencies in insect chorion messenger RNA. Cell, 3,265-273.
CE LLU LA R POLY MOR PH ISM
15
Vournakis, J. N., Efstratiadis, A. and Kafatos, F. C. (1975). Electrophoretic patterns of deadenylylated chorion and globin mRNAs. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 7 2 , 2959-2963. Wigglesworth, V. B. (1954). “The Physiology of Insect Metamorphosis”. 151 pp. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Yamanouchi, M. (1922). Morphologische Beobachtung uber die Seidensekretion bei der Seideraupe.J. Coll. A p i c . Hokkaido I m p . Univ. Sapporo, 10(4), 1-49.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Extraction and Determination of Ecdysones in Arthropods E. David Morgan and Colin F. Poole Department of Chemistry, University of Keele, Keele, Staffordshire, England
1 Introduction 2 Large-scale extraction . 2.1 Initial extraction 2.2 Concentration of material into an active fraction 2.3 Isolation of ecdysones from concentrate . 3 Microdetermination of ecdysones 3.1 Thin-layer chromatography. 3.2 Bioassay . 3.3 Optical spectroscopy. 3.4 Radioimmunoassay . 3.5 Gas-liquid chromatography . 3.6 Mass fragmentography . 3.7 High-pressure liquid chromatography 4 Summary of analytical methods. 5 Conclusion Acknowledgements References
.
.
.
. .
.
.
. . .
. . . .
.
. . .
. . . . .
17 20 24 25 26 29 29 33 35 36 38 49 50 53 56 56 56
1 Introduction
The foundations of the study of the control of moulting in insects were laid on the pioneering work of KopCc, Wigglesworth and Fraenkel before 1939. In the mid-1960s the subject advanced into a new and active stage with the identification of the first hormones controlling moulting. Ten years later the volume of research in this area has expanded many times and yet a number of important points remain unresolved or unexplored. Growth and development in arthropods (insects, arachnids and crustaceans) are dependent upon a periodic shedding of the hard exoskeleton, through a complex process of new cuticle formation, apolysis, and ecdysis, 17
18
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
and this can be further complicated by metamorphosis from juvenile to pupal or adult forms. That the initiation of moulting was under hormonal control was first suggested by KopPc (1922) and proven by the work of Wigglesworth (1934) on Rhodinus prolixus. The description of a potential bioassay 6y Fraenkel (1935) fulfilled one necessary condition for an attack o n the chemical isolation of such hormones. The systematic search for a chemical hormone was taken up by Butenandt and Karlson in the early 1940s and their work culminated in the isolation, from the pupae of the silkworm Bombyx mori, of crystalline material named ecdysone (Butenandt and Karlson, 1954) which was later identified as a pentahydroxysterol (Huber and Hoppe, 1965; Karlson et al., 1965). Within the past ten years, with the advantages of modern shemical methods for dealing with small quantities of materials, eight ecdysones from arthropods have been isolated and identified. Their structures, are given below. In a brief period of activity covering a few years, over forty ecdysone-like compounds (referred to as phytoecdysones) have been isolated from higher plants; their function there is still unknown. This part of the subject has been reviewed by Horn (1971), Nakanishi (1971) and Rees (1971).
flHf OH
HO
HO
OH
HO
H
OH
OH HO
0
H O
Ecdysone (a-ecdysone) (1)
(2) Ecdysterone (crustecdysone, Pecdysone
20-hy droxy ecdysone)
OH
OH
HO-
(3)
26-Hydroxyecdysone
I1
(4)
0
20,26-Dihydroxyecdysone
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
19
OH
A
HO
0
HO”
(5) 2-Deoxyecdysterone (2-deoxy-20-hydroxyecdysone)
0 (6) 3-Epi-ecdysterone (3-epi-20-hydroxyecdysone)
OH
(7) Inokosterone (25-deoxy-20,26-dihydroxyecdysone)
(8) Makisterone A (20-hydroxy-24-methylecdysone)
The naming of ecdysones is unsystematic and sometimes confusing. Ecdysone ( 1 ) is systematically 2P,3/3,14a,22R,25-pentahydroxy-5P-cholest7-en-6-one, though the name ecdysone provides a convenient generic name by which to name its relatives. It is also known sometimes as a-ecdysone. Compound (2) should be 20-hydroxyecdysone, but is variously known as 0-ecdysone (which suggests it is an epimer or isomer of a-ecdysone, which it is not), ecdysterone, or crustecdysone (which has the claim of primogeniture); this confusion is a legacy of being identified and described by different workers at about the same time. The name ecdysterone is used arbitrarily here as being short and less misleading than P-ecdysnne. The names inokosterone (7) and makisterone A (8) are derived from the Japanese names of the plants from which they were first isolated. The physiological role of ecdysones in insects has been reviewed recently (Gilbert and King, 1973; Burdette, 1974; Slama et al., 1974); the essential details are known but hedged with uncertainties. Prompted by unknown stimuli, a proteinaceous brain hormone activates the prothoracic gland which secretes a substance, which is converted t o ecdysone,
20
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
or is ecdysone itself., which in turn is transformed into ecdysterone
somewhere in the abdomen, probably the oenocytes, and then travels to the epithelium, possibly by direct action on chromosones t o cause “puffing’’ and synthesis of mRNA for specific proteins and enzymes for ecdysis (Karlson, 1974). However, by no means all experimental evidence leads t o the same view (cf. Vedeckis et al., 1974; Romer et al., 1974; Hsiao et al., 1975). An experiment by Carlisle (1965) showing that insect and crustacean moulting hormones were cross-active was confirmed a year later by the isolation of ecdysterone from an insect and a crustacean (Horne et al., 1966). That these hormones are apparently found not only in arthropods, but in nematodes and molluscs (see Table 1) adds t o their interest t o evolutionists as well as endocrinologists. This review is concerned with the methods employed in the isolation and dctermination of ecdysones in arthropods, where most of the work thus far has been directed. The physiological concentration of ecdysones in insects is of the order of lo-’ t o lo-’ g per g tissue, or less in crustaceans, and therefore the microdetermination of hormones presents special problems. Much of the work t o now has relied upon bioassays (see section 3.1) or the addition of exogenous radio-labelled hormone; unfortunately there is evidence that exogenous hormone can be metabolized differently from endogenous hormone (Nakanishi e t al., 1972; Clever e t al., 1973). lt‘is generally accepted that ecdysones are derived from dietary cholesterol or related phytosterols, but by no means all the steps along the biosynthetic rotite have been established. There is also a conflict of views on the ultimate excretory product of the hormones; and why ecdysones accumulate in the body of the adults of some lepidoptera remains unexplained. Yet the efforts placed in this area and the advances being made may result in this area of hormone research leading t o a more fundamental understanding of how hormones act at the molecular level than has yet been achieved by over forty years of investigation of mammalian hormones.
2 Large-scale extraction The isolation of the moulting hormone from an insect source became possible with the development of a suitable bioassay t o monitor separated fractions. Butenandt and Karlson (1954) isolated ecdysone from the pupae of the silkworm moth Bombyx mori using ligated abdomens of Calliphora erythrocephala (Karlson, 1956a) for the bioassay. Since this first extraction, eight ecdysones have been isolated and identified from thirteen arthropod species (Table 1). Of those species investigated, the amount of hormone found in crustacea is demonstrably lower than that in insecta. The
TABLE 1 The concentration of ecdysones isolated from Metazoa
Species
Stage
Weight extracted kg
Ecdysone isolated
Weight mg
rn
v)
d Concentration mg kg-'
Reference
5
0
z
n
INSECTA
Antheraea pernyi (saturniid oak silkmoth)
Pupae
31
B o m b y x mori (silkworm moth)
Pupae
500 1000 (dried) 3000*
2200t
Calliphora erythrocephala
Pupae
15
(blue blowfly)
Ecdysterone
0.2
0.006
Horn et al. (1966) Butenandt and Karlson (1954) Karlson et al. (1963) Hocks and Weicheit (1966) Hocks and Weichert (1966) Hoffmeister (1.966), Hoffmeister and Grutzmacher (1966)
Ecdysone
25
0.05
Ecdysone Ecdysone
250 206
0.25 0.068
Ecdysterone
48
0.016
Ecdysterone
9
0.004
Ecdysone Ecdysterone
0.075 0.005 Not determined
Karlson (1956b) Karlson (1956b)
Calliphora stygia (brown blowfly)
hepupae Pharate adults
1.87 1.795
Ecdysterone Ecdy sterone
0.19 0.17
0.1 0.095
Galbraith et al., (1969b) Galbraith et al. (196913)
Calliphora vicina
Prepupae
0.5
Ecdy sterone
0.043
0.11
Galbraith et al. (196913)
Egg
5
26-Hydr0~y ecdysone Ecdysterone
26.5
5.3
Kaplanis et al. (1973)
0.5
0.1
Kaplanis et al. ( 197 3)
(blue blowfly) Manducta sexta (Tobacco hornworm)
c!
N h)
TABLE 1-continued
Species
Stage
Weight extracted kg
Pupae
12.7 40.2
Meconium fluid
12.5 litres
Ecdysone isolated
Weight mg
20,26-Dihydroxyecdysone 1.5 Ecdysone 1.2 Ecdysterone 3.7 Ecdysone 4.4 20,26-Dihydroxy3.0 ecdysone 3.6 Ecdysone 3-Epi-ecdy1.7 sterone
Concentration mg kg-'
Reference
0.3 0.24 0.287 0.32
Kaplanis e t al, Kaplanis et al. Kaplanis et al. Kaplanis e t al.
0.075 0.08
Thompson et al. (1967) rn Thompson et al. (1967) . CJ D Thompson e t al. (1974) 5 CJ Morgan e t al. (1975a, b)
-
Schistocerca gregaria (desert locust)
Late 5th instar
32.0
Ecdysterone
Dociostaurus maroccanus (moroccan locust)
Adult
10
Ecdysone
11.0
1.1
Ecdysterone
13.0
1.3
1.9
0.06
(1973) (1973) (1966b) (196Gb)
Stamm (1958)
2
U
0
CRUSTACEA
Crangon vulgarti (shrimp)
5 0
Balanus balanoides (acorn barnacle)
Intermoult
1500
Ecdysterone Ecdysone
3000
Not identified
1.2 0.009
8.0 x l o 4 6.0 x lo-'
Bebbington (1975) Eebbington (1975) Karlson and Schmialek (1959)
5 0 r m
m
--3I v)
b
-I 0
Callinectes sapidus (shore crab)
PremouIt “green”
25
Inokosterone
0.125
0.005
Premoult “peeler”
25
Premoult “soft shell”
25
Inokosterone Ecdysterone Ecdyst erone Makisterone A
0.5 0.1 7.0 0.6
0.02 0.004 0.28 0.024
Faux et al. Faux et al. Faux et al. Faux e t al.
Gagosian et al. (1974)
Faux et al. (1 969) (1969) (1969) (1969) (1969)
2
$1 rn 0
0
2 2 rn v)
Homarus americanus
Post moult
5
Ecdy sterone
0.09
0.006
Intermoult
1000
Ecdysterone
2.0
0.002
3000
2-Deoxyecd ysterone
0.2
Ecdysterone
0.0045 3.0 x l o 4
(lobster) Jams lalandei (crayfish)
Hampshire and Horn (1966) 7.0 x 1 0 - ~ Galbraith et al. (1968a)
NEMATODA
Ascaris lumbricoides (parasitic nematode)
Adults
15.5
~
Hornet al. (1974)
~~
Ecdysones incompletely identified in the nematode Haemonchus contortus juveniles (approximately 0.5 pg b y bioassay in 1 g freezedried tissue, Rogers (1973)) and in the mollusc Mytilus edulis (edible mussel) (approximately 50 ng to 500 pg kg-’, Takemoto et al. (1967b)). * 2.8 tons. t 2.0 tons. N
w
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
24
concentration of ecdysones varies with the stage of the life-cycle so that the amount of hormone extracted is very much dependent on the age of the juvenile selected for study. The separation and identification of ecdysones from biological material can be considered as a three-part operation. 1. The initial extraction of polar material and partial purification by removal of less polar material (neutral lipids, sterol esters, etc.) and then removal of material of higher polarity. 2. The concentration of ecdysones into an active fraction. 3. The separation and determination of ecdysones in the active fraction.
2.1
INITIAL EXTRACTION
The initial extraction of ecdysones is achieved by blending the insect material in methanol, aqueous methanol, aqueous ethanol or acetonemethanol mixtures (2-7 cm3 g-' ). Alcoholic solvents are not only efficient in extracting ecdysones but also act as a preservative when insect samples have t o be stored (Karlson, 1956b). No special precautions are needed with the purity of solvents at this stage. The insoluble residue is removed by filtration and re-extracted with solvent. The filtration equipment used is determined by the scale of the operation. Buchner funnels (12 in. diameter) with vacuum are sufficient for kilogram amounts but hydraulic presses and process plant equipment are required for handling megagramme amounts. Solvent from extracts is removed by vacuum distillation under nitrogen at tcmperatures less than 40 "C to avoid decomposition of the hormone. The methanolic extract is reduced t o an aqueous concentrate which is partitioned with butanol and the butanol residue is redissolved in aqueous methanol and partitioned with hexane. This is the order of operations described by Butenandt and Karlson (1954) and has been followed b y most subsequent workers. However, there are advantages to be gained by extracting the aqueous concentrate with hexane first. The butanol-water partition is often made difficult by emulsion formation and during reduction of the butanol phase in uacuo it often froths badly unless lipids, etc., have been removed with hexane. The aqueous concentrate from the alcoholic extract is usually diluted with methanol (to 30% v/v) before partition with hexane t o avoid emulsion formation. The extracted phases are back-washed with the counter solvent (usually twice) and combined. The washing of the butanol phase by a series of acid and base washes as used by Karlson (1956a, b) can lead t o a serious loss of the more polar hormone ecdysterone (Horn et al., 1968). This step has generally been omitted by later workers. In the extraction of crayfish waste by Horn et al. (1968), a mixture of hexane and n-propanol (1:3 v/v) was used t o
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
25
extract the aqueous concentrate as propanol is more readily removed by low-temperature distillation. Addition of ammonium sulphate was required to promote phase separation. By the use of a series of highly efficient extraction steps, the ecdysonecontaining fraction is reduced to a size which can be conveniently handled at the laboratory bench. An indication of the purification obtained is given in Table 2. TABLE 2 Purification factors for the preliminary extraction of ecdysones and their concentration into an active fraction
taken
Weight of butanol residue
kg
g
Weight
Species
Balanus balanoides Schktocerca gregarin Manducta sexta Jasus lalandei Calliphora sty@
2.2
1500 32 12.7 1000 1.87
798 96 4.5 400 4.4
Purification factor of stage
Weight of active fraction
1880 333
2800 2500 425
g
8.5 1.47 0.074 12.0 0.049
Purification factor of stage
94 65 61 33 90
CONCENTRATION OF MATERIAL INTO AN ACTIVE FRACTION
Usudy at this stage the concentration of ecdysones is such that positive bioassay results are achieved. The choice of further techniques to purify the extract depends on the weight of material to be processed. Adsorption chromatography is the method of choice provided that the extract is not too bulky, as columns overloaded with adsorbed material give poor resolution. Associated with adsorption chromatography is the need for a large number of bioassays. If many fractions are t o be tested, then a shortage of suitable test animals can be a problem. Generally if the amount of material at this stage is large (>20 g) then further partition systems are used to reduce the bulk of the ecdysone-containing residue before chromatography. Partition procedures also require fewer bioassay tests by comparison with column chromatography as the number of fractions generated is far fewer. Suitable partitioning solvent systems are given in Table 3. With the exception of the water-butanol system the low value of the distribution coefficient means that countercurrent techniques are required for highyield separations. The addition of potassium bicarbonate to the aqueous
26
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE TABLE 3 Partition functions for ecdysones in various solvent systems* ~~
Partition coefficient Solvent system Ecdysone
Ecdysterone
~~~
0.16 0.52 0.06
Cyclohexane-butanol-water(6:4: 10) Cyclohexane-butanol-water(5:5: l o ) ? Ethyl acetate-water (1: 1) Butanol-water (1: 1) Ethyl formate-butanol-water (9: 1: 10) Chloroform-methanol-water(2: 1: 1) Chloroform-ethanol-water(1: 1: 1) ~
~
=10
0.75 2.0 -
1.27 3.54 0.32 5.3 0.2 5.0 0.7
-~
* Horn (1971).
t Partition coefficient of 26-hydroxyecdysone is 0.39 in this system (Kaplanis e t al., 1973). phase of the first tube in the system chloroform-ethanol-water (1:1:1) is a convenient method for the removal of acidic impurities (Horn, 1971). At this stage of the procedure the available material is of the order of grammes and can be conveniently purified by adsorption chromatography. Karlson (195613) used alumina for this purpose, but later workers have preferred silica, especially for the isolation of ecdysterone. The recovery of small quantities of ecdysterone from alumina is generally poor (Horn et al., 1968; Miyazaki et al., 1973). Alumina prepared a considerable time before use, or which had formed “clumps” after deactivation was destructive to the ecdysones (Kaplanis et al., 1966b). Similar problems with silica have not been observed. Columns of silica gel or silicic acid with a sample-tosupport ratio of 1:ZO-30 (normaIly deactivated with 10 per cent water w/w) are eluted with a step-wise gradient of benzene-butanol, benzenemethanol, through pure methanol to aqueous methanol (Morgan et al., 1975a, b ; Bebbington 1975) or with chloroform-ethanol mixtures (Horn et al., 1968). The ecdysones are eluted with the benzene-methanol fractions. The use of Floridin earth (a grade of magnesium silicate from FIorida) instead of siIica gave little separation of ecdysones from the bulk material obtained by extraction of the desert locust (Woodbridge, 1971).
2.3
ISOLATION OF ECDYSONES FROM CONCENTRATE
An active fraction with a high score by bioassay is obtained at this stage. Further purification by adsorption chromatography is rarely successful as the ecdysones and associated contaminants have similar adsorption proper-
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
27
ties. On occasions when a source rich in ecdysones has been extracted, simple recrystallization is all that is required by way of final purification. Separation of the active fraction by preparative layer chromatography (preparative TLC) gives higher resolution than is obtainable with columns and can give a useful further fractionation (Woodbridge, 1971; Morgan et al., 1975a, b). It has been reported that the losses of very small amounts of ecdysones on preparative layer plates can be substantial (Horn et al., 1968). The most efficient method for the further fractionation of the active fraction is reversed-phase column chromatography using cyclohexane-butanol (1:7) as stationary phase coated onto hydrophobic celite (Horn et al., 1968; Galbraith e t al., 1969b; Bebbington, 1975). Celite is the trade name of the Johns-Manville Co. for their grade of calcined diatomaceous earth. This phase allows a separation of ecdysterone and 2-deoxyecdysterone to be achieved. Horn et al. (1968) and Galbraith e t al. (1969b) used reversed-phase chromatography with further chromatography on a column of CM-Sephadex (Pharmacia AB) and final purification with silicic acid (a slightly acidic form of precipitated silica gel) in the isolation of ecdysterone from samples of Jasus hhndei and Calliphora vicina. Columns of CM-Sephadex are much superior to Sephadex G-25 for this purpose and enable the separation of inokosterone and ecdysterone to be achieved (Horn,1971). The fractionation of the active extracts by a countercurrent distribution of the material in cyclohexane-butanol-water(5:5: 10) using a Craig-Port fifty tube train enables the separation of ecdysone, ecdysterone and 20,26-diiydroxyecdysone from each other and associated contaminants (Kaplanis et al., 1966b; Thompson e t al., 1967). In this system, 26-hydroxyecdysone overlaps ecdysterone and separation of the two hormones was achieved by preparative layer chromatography on silica gel (Kaplaniqet al., 1973). The physical properties of arthropod ecdysones are summarized in Table 4. In the nuclear magnetic resonance spectra, there are significant differences in the chemical shifts of the methyl signals measured in pyridine and methanol solvents which has been used to advantage in structure elucidation (Galbraith et al., 1968a, 1973). The chemical shift of the C-19 methyl signals of ecdysones measured in pyridine are 0.3 ppm further upfield than the corresponding A/B trans fused isomer ( 5 4 , and this difference provides a useful means of determining the configuration of the A/B ring junction (Horn, 1971). Because of the large sample size (several mg) required for nmr spectroscopy, in many cases it has been impractical for arthropod ecdysones, but the Fourier transform technique, and accumulated spectra, increased instrument sensitivity and smaller sample tubes have already reduced sample size to pg for the most modern instruments, and still further reduction in sample size may be possible.
N
03
TABLE 4 Physical properties of arthropod ecdysones Ultraviolet absorp tiont Ecdysone
Optical rotation
nmr 60 MHz (perdeuteropyridine)
m.p.("C) * Emax
(EtOH)
c-18
c-19
c-2 1
C-26
C-27
C-28
[&I;' (MeOH)
r" Ecdysone Ecdysterone 3-Epi-ecdysterone 26-Hydroxyecdysone 2-Deoxyecdysterone Inokosterone Makisterone A 20,26-Dihydroxyecdysone
237-239 241-242.5 225-229 252-256 -
2 55 (decomp.) 263(decomp.) 149-153
242 242 245 245 243 243 243 245
12 400 12 400 10 800 11 600 -
12 100 12 400 10 400
0.70 1.20 1.20 0.74 1.21 1.19 1.21 1.22
1.05 1.07 1.08 1.08 1.04 1.07 1.09 1.08
1.25 1.56 1.58 1.2311.32 1.57 1.52 1.54 1.58
* Ecdysones lose water of crystallization with partial melting at lower temperatures, e.g. t Absorption maxima shifted +6 nm in water and -6 nm in hexane.
1.38 1.38 1.38 -
1.35 -
1.29 -
1.38 1.38 1.38 1.47 1.35 1.03 1.32 1.48
-
1.05 -
+67.8" +60.5' -
- . -
+74.3" -
0
2 z
%0
z
P0
., ecdysone at 160-165°C.
Pz rn
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
29
The infrared spectra (in KBr discs) are characterized by a strong absorption at 1645 cm-' ( G O ) and 1612 cm-' (C=C) for the a,P-unsaturated ketone, and at 3330-3400 cm-' for the hydroxyl groups. There are characteristic bands at 1383 cm-' , 917 cm-* and 789-843 cm-' in ecdysterone that are not present in ecdysone. The optical rotatory dispersion spectra of ecdysones in dioxane have a positive Cotton effect with an amplitude of 60-80, which is characteristic of the A/B-cis fused rings (Horn, 1971; Nakanishi, 1971). The use of ord spectroscopy for ecdysones is discussed in detail by Nakanishi (1971). The mass spectra of ecdysones show weak molecular ions with consecutive losses of 1 8 mass units due t o elimination of water. Estimation of molecular weight from the mass spectrum must therefore be cautious, unless good, reproducible spectra are obtained. The molecular weight of ecdysterone was originally underestimated because of loss of water from the molecule in the spectrometer (Hoffmeister and Grutzmacher, 1966), and that of ecdysone was in doubt (Karlson et al., 1965). Conversion t o trimethylsilyl ether derivatives (sections 3.5.1 and 3.6) for mass spectrometry has advantages, but molecular ions are still weak. Pentafluorophenyl dimethylsilyl ethers of steroid alcohols give strong molecular ions and useful f r a p e n t a t i o n patterns (Morgan and Poole, 1975; Poole and Morgan, 197513). The method has not been applied t o ecdysones. It would have the disadvantage of producing compounds of very high molecular weight. Ecdysones with a 20,22-diol show a characteristic fragmentation of the 20-22 bond which aids in their identification (Horn, 1971; Galbraith and Horn, 1969). Further details of mass spectra are contained in the references t o Table 1 and in Hoffmeister and Grutzmacher (1966), Koreeda e t a l . (1969), Nakanishi (1971), and Zatsny et al. (1975).
3 Microdetermination of ecdysones 3.1
THIN-LAYER CHROMATOGRAPHY
In thin-layer chromatography, resolution is normally greater than that achieved with packed columns, and the separated components of a mixture can be identified simultaneously on the surface of the adsorbent by a variety of visualization techniques. Iodine vapour is a quick and simple technique. Using uv light, as little as 0.5 pg of ecdysones can be observed on silica gel containing a fluorescent additive absorbing at 254 nm (Poole, 1975). Ecdysones also give characteristically coloured spots when the plate is sprayed with vanillin-sulphuric acid followed b y heating at 110 *C for fiveminutes (Stahl, 1962; Galbraith et al., 196813; Horn, 1971). Other spray
30
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
rc'igents were found less useful, including 2,4-dinitrophenylhydrazine (Izevinson and Shaaya, 1966). The vanillin-sulphuric acid reagent is very useful for relatively pure samples of ecdysones but the colour reaction is e'isily masked by the presence of other material which limits its use for the analysis of crude samples. The quantitative determination of ecdysones by a densitometric method on fluorescent TLC plates has been described (S'irdini et al., 1974). The recovery of small amounts of ecdysones from silica gel plates with methanol is often poor and extracted samples are easily contaminated with p'irticles of silica and binder (Horn et al., 1968; Schooley and Nakanishi, 1973). Thin-layer chromatography has been used to separate mixtures of ec dysones, its precursors and metabolites, which were labelled with H or 14 C. The ecdysones were determined by either radiochromatography using a 'I'LC scanner (King and Siddall, 1969; Moriyama et al., 1970; Hoffmann ct al., 1974; King and Marks, 1974; Sannasi and Karlson, 1974; Galbraith rt al., 1975) or by removing discrete bands for scintillation counting (Nakanishi et al., 1972; Romer et al., 1974; Hikino et al., 1975). Ecdysones have also been eluted from TLC plates and determined by bioassay (Willig and Keller, 1973; Hoffmann et al., 1974; King et al., 1974; Koolman et al., 1975) and radioimmunoassay (Borst and Englemann, 1974). In these ex
31
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES TABLE 5
Rf values of Arthropod ecdysones on silica gel TLC eluted with CHCIJ -95 per cent EtOH(4: 1) Ecdysone Ecdysone
Ecdysterone
2-Deoxyecdysterone 26-Hy droxy ecdy sone 3-Epi-ecdy sterone Inokosterone Makisterone A 20,26-Dihydroxyecdysone
Rf values* 0.37 0.23 0.20 0.20 0.24 0.14 0.13 0.16 0.17 0.15 0.30 0.08 0.17 0.16 0.16 0.08
References Thompson et al. (1967) Galbraith et al. (1968a) Horn (1971) Woodbridge (1971) Thompson et al. (1967) Galbraith et al. (1968a) Horn (1971) Horn (1971) Woodbridge (1971) Kaplanis et al. (1973) Galbraith et al. (1968a), Horn (1971) Kaplanis et al. (1973) Thompson et al. (1974) Horn (1971) Horn (1971) Thompson et al. (1967)
* Rf values are approximate as different methods of deactivating the silica gel are used (e.g. equilibrated over saturated brine, equilibrated with the atmosphere or oven dried and stored in a dry box). the expense of time, and continuous development for many hours is required for good separation (Borst and O'Connor, 1974). In terms of efficiency (plates per minute) the continuous flow TLC technique performs poorly by comparison with high-pressure liquid-adsorption chromatography. The formation of derivatives has been used to reduce the polarity of the ecdysones and obtain a better separation on TLC. For this purpose acetates have been most used. The steric environment of an hydroxyl group governs its rate of acetylation. Equatorial secondary ring hydroxyl groups react most rapidly and side-chain hydroxyl groups slightly faster than ring axial groups (Galbraith and Horn, 1969). For ecdysterone at 20 OC in acetic anhydride-pyridine (1:2), the order of acetylation is 2 > 3 > 22 > 25 (Galbraith and Horn, 1969; Horn, 1971). The various acetates have been separated and fully characterized (Galbraith and Horn, 1969; Canonica et al., 1975) and the pseudo first-order reaction rate constants determined (Galbraith and Horn, 1969). Thin-layer chromatography of the acetate mixture from ecdysterone produces four spots which have been used as a
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
32
TABLE 6 "lie
R f values of ecdysone and ecdysterone in various solvent systems on silica gel TLC plates
Solvent sytem
CIIC13-95% EtOH ( 7 ~ 3 ) C:IICI3-95%EtOH (13:7)* C1 IC13-EtOH (3:2) CIIC13-MeOH (9:l) ClIC13-MeOH (5:l) CIICI3-MeOH (3 :2)
Ecdysone 0.39 -
0.10 -
-
Ecdysterone 0.34 0.31 0.50 0.07 0.23 0.40 0.55
CHC13-MeOH (1:l) C1lC13-n-propanol (9:5) (:HC13-EtOH-MezCO (6:2:1) (:IICl,-MeOH-Me2CO (6: 2: l ) t CHzC12-MezCO-MeOH( 2 : l : l )
0.21 0.69
0.12 0.48 0.33 0.62
Cl-IzClz-MezCO-EtOH (16:4:5)
0.32
0.10
CHz Clz -MeOH-C6H6 (25:5:3) CHz Clz-MezCO-H20 (15: 62.5: 10)
0.65
0.19
(:H2CIz-MeOH-H20 (79: 15:1)" (:6H6-MeOH(7: 3) t.tOAc-EtOH (4:1)$ LtOAc-EtOH (4:l)S 1 tOAc-EtOH (4: 1) CHzC12-MeOH-25%NH3-H20 (77: 20: 2: 1)
0.32 0.40 0.49
0.19 -
-
-
0.47q
-
0.60 0.46 0.32 0.40q
Reference Woodbridge (1971) Kaplanis et al. (1973) Hornet al. (1968) Siddall et al. (1966) Imai et al. (1967) Borst and O'Connor (1974) Borst and O'Connor (1974) King and Siddall (1969) Imai et al. (1967) Woodbridge (1971) Levinson and Shaaya (1966) Heinrich and Hoffmeister (1967) Imai et al. (1967) Heinrich and Hoffmeister (1967) Sardini et al. (1974) Karlson et al. (1965) Takemoto et aZ. (1967a, c) Sardini e t al. (1974) Woodbridge (1971) Romer et al. (1974)
* I n this system 20,26-dihydroxyecdysone has Rf 0.22. t In the same solvent system on aluminium oxide, ecdysterone has Rf 0.16. $ In this system inokosterone has Rf 0.60.
8 In this system makisterone A has Rf 0.50. 11 In this system makisterone A has Rf 0.25. f Estimated values.
"fingerprint" to confirm the presence of the hormone in an extract ('Takernoto et al., 1967a; Galbraith et al., 1968a, 1973; King and Siddall, 1969; King, 1972; Nakanishi et al., 1972; King and Marks, 1974; King et d.,1974; Hikino et al., 1975). Brief acylation at room temperature allows the monoacetate derivative to be obtained in high yield (Galbraith and LIorn, 1969; King and Sidall, 1969; Horn, 1971). The mono-acetate is often
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
33
more amenable t o recrystallization from semi-pure samples than the ecdysone itself. With the vanillin-sulphuric acid spray reagent, the acyl esters of ecdysterone produce the characteristic olive green coloration of ecdysterone itself unless the C-22 hydroxyl group is acylated in which case the spot is a leaf-green colour (Galbraith and Horn, 1969). Formation of the 20-acetate and cleavage of the 20,22-glycol with 0.1 M sodium metaperiodate in 50 per cent aqueous methanol has been used to distinguish between ecdysone and ecdysterone (King and Siddall, 1969; King, 1972; King and Marks, 1974). The reaction can be performed o n 10 pg of material and the product, 2~-acetoxy-3~,14~-dihydroxy-5~-pregn-7-en-6,20-dione, recognized by its R f value on TLC. Other derivatives which have been used to characterize ecdysones by TLC include boronates (Galbraith et al., 1969a) and acetonides (Galbraith and Horn, 1969; Koreeda et al., 1969; King and Marks, 1974; Thompson et al., 1974). These reagents react selectively with the cis-diol functions in ecdysones. Under appropriate conditions it is possible t o prepare both the mono- and diacetonides of ecdysterone (Galbraith and Horn, 1969). The 20,22-monoacetonide is particularly resistant t o hydrolysis (Galbraith and Horn, 1969). The structural conformation of the hydroxyl groups in 3-epi-ecdysterone was decided with the help of the acetonide derivative, as the trans-2,3-diol does not form a cyclic derivative under the usual conditions (Thompson et al., 1974). 3.2
BIOASSAY
The establishment of a satisfactory bioassay is a prerequisite when seeking an unknown chemical substance which has biological activity. It indicates the biological potency of semi-pure material and is essential for monitoring fractionation and purification steps. It is possible t o use one species t o measure biological potency in another, but this presupposes that the chemical substance inducing the biological response is the same in both. Moreover the bioassay may not be specific for a single chemical substance and may give a positive response with chemical analogues. Other chemically related compounds or prohormones, of slightly different structural features, for example, bearing a 5a-hydrogen atom or a 22s-hydroxyl group, would not be detected by bioassay. The most commonly used bioassay for moulting hormone is the dipteran assay based on the work of Fraenkel (1935) and refined by Karlson (1956b), Karlson and Shaaya (1964) and others. The method has been reviewed recently by Thomson (1974); the intention here is only to assess its usefulness, in comparison with other methods in isolating and determining ecdysones. The method depends upon the induced sclerotization of the
34
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
larval cuticle of an abdomen which has been ligatured and the head removed. The most popular systems are summarized in Table 7. TABLE 7 Test species used in moulting bioassay Species
Common name
Test name
Reference
Calliphora erythrocephala
Blowfly
Calliphora
Calliphora stygia Musca dornestica Chilo suppressalis Sarcophaga peregrina
Blowfly Housefly Rice stem borer Fleshfly
Calliphora Musca Chilo Sarcophaga
Karlson (1956b), Kadson (1 963), Karlson and Shaaya (1964) Thomson et al. (1970) Kaplanis et al. (1966a) Sato et al. (1968) Ohtaki et al. (1967)
Desert locust
Locust abdomen
Morgan et al. (1975a), Morgan et al. (1975b)
Freshwater crayfish
Crayfish
Lowe and Horn (1967)
DIPTERA
ORTHOPTERA
Schistocerca gregarh CRUSTACEA
Cherax destructor*
* Strictly, this is a test for a different hormone which co-chromatographs with ecdysones. The nonspecialized larva-to-larva moult used in the locust abdomen test provides a rather different system (Morgan et al., 1975a, b). The method has the advantage of being able to distinguish between new cuticle formation and apolysis, but may suffer from the disadvantage of being less close to a complete living system. The crayfish test is really a test for dilation of the chromatophores and was used only because the chromatophore-stimulating hormone was found to accompany ecdysones through all the preliminary extractions of Jasus lulandei (Lowe and Horn, 1967). The routine use of a bioassay requires a large supply of test animals of similar age which must be ligated, injected with sample, incubated and visibly assessed for degree of sclerotization. The test abdomens are compared with a control group injected with solvent only but otherwise treated as the test group. For quantitative work a second control group injected with known amounts of hormone are required. This second group is required because of the variation in the physiological state of the test animals. The same ecdysone should be used in the control as is being
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
35
assessed in the test. If it is an unknown ecdysone, ecdysterone should be used in the control since it appears to be the most common ecdysone and has good solubility properties in aqueous ethanol. The degree of sclerotization is assessed visually and expressed as a percentage of the surviving test abdomens to give a measure of biological potency (Karlson, 1956b; Kaplanis et al., 1966a). The sensitivity of the assay is of the order of 5-50 ng ecdysterone per abdomen in the Calliphora test (Thomson e t al., 1970) and 5-6ng ecdysterone per abdomen in the Musca test (Kaplanis e t al., 1966a). The sensitivity of the locust abdomen test is similar (Morgan e t al., 1975b). For simply deciding which fractions are active from a purification step, five abdomens per fraction is sufficient, but for quantitative work 20 t o 25 abdomens are required. Thus for quantitative work the least detectable amount of ecdysterone is of the order of 0.1 pg. Bioassays are expensive of material, laborious and unspecific in that they cannot distinguish between different chemical substances with the same physiological action, but are essential in a complet'ely new area of investigation. Other problems include poor solubility of test material in the injection solvent without having to use too large a volume of liquid injected and at times a high degree of toxicity of the partially purified material resulting in a high death rate in the test. Impure barnacle fractions proved to be very toxic in the locust abdomen assay (Morgan and Bebbington, unpublished). A variation on the dipteran assay, an in vitro test using a piece of integument from a ligatured and nonpupated larva of Chilo suppressalis has been reported by Agui (1973), with a sensitivity of approximately 15 ng of hormone per test.
3.3
OPTICAL SPECTROSCOPY
The ecdysones are characterized by a strong uv absorption (em a x 10 000 to 14 000; A,, 240 to 245 nm, see Table 5) in alcoholic solvents. This means a limit of detection of 0.5 pg with an instrument reading to 0.01 optical density units, but increasing instrument accuracy will lower this considerably. The decrease in uv absorption obtained by the addition of sodium borohydride to a biological extract has been used to determine the amount of ecdysones present (Takemoto et nl., 1968). It has been shown that ecdysones in a sulphuric acid-ethanol mixture fluoresce strongly when excited by light of a suitable wavelength (Takemoto et al., 1968; Gilgan and Zinck, 1972). Also, the fluorescence intensity of inokosterone in ammonia solution increased markedly by comparison with that of ecdysterone. This difference in relative fluor-
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
36
exence output in acidic and alkaline medium enabled the composition of mixtures of ecdysterone and inokosterone t o be determined (Takemoto et al., 1968). Gilgan and Zinck (1972) have investigated the conditions for mctximum fluorescence of ecdysterone in sulphuric acid-ethanol medium and claim a detection limit of 50 ng for crystalline ecdysterone. Several ec dysones were found t o fluoresce under the same conditions indicating the gcBnerality of the response. The application of the technique t o biological m'tterial was not shown but the limiting factor of sensitivity was the blmk value. In a study of sulphuric acid-ethanol induced fluorescence of the synthetic model compound 2/3,3/3,5a-trihydroxycholest-7-en-6-one, Bc bbington (1975) has shown that blank values were generally high due to iri [erference with the fluorescence emission by Rayleigh scattering and R'tman emission of the solvent. This limited the overall sensitivity t o concentrations higher than 0.1 pg ml-' . Attempts t o identify the model cc )mpound in biological extracts containing known additions of the steroid wrre unsuccessful due t o excessive interference from other fluorescing siibstances in the extract. 3.4
KADIOIMMUNOASSAY
The specific binding proteins used in radioimmunoassay are antibodies ohtained by active immunization with the substance t o be measured. Sr eroids themselves are not immunogenic but when covalently coupled t o piotein carriers they become so, acting as haptens. Borst and O'Connor (1 372, 1974) coupled ecdysterone as its oximino-acetic acid derivative t o bovine serum albumin (see also Borst, 1973). Lauer et al. (1974) formed a hi,misuccinate derivative of ecdysterone which was coupled to human srrum albumin (see also Nakanishi et aZ., 1973). Injection of white rabbits w Lth the hapten triggers an immune response, resulting in the formation of tibodies. Not all animals exhibit an immune response o n injection and the degree of response is variable. Antibodies obtained by bleeding the a 1 imal are titred with labelled ecdysterone and those showing a relatively hiqh titre are frozen until use. To perform the assay, a limited amount of specific antibody (Ab) is w..tcted with ecdysterone (E*) labelled with a radioisotope. Upon addition 0 1 an increasing amount of the unlabelled ecdysterone (E), a corresponding &,creasing fraction of total labelled ecdysterone (*E) is bound t o the .in tibody. After separation of bound labelled ecdysterone from free labelled a dysterone by ammonium sulphate precipitation, the amount of radioa Livity in the bound protein is determined by dissolution and scintillation counting. This information is used t o construct a standard curve against which the unknown samples are compared. Blanks and control samples are
37
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
normally run with biological samples t o check on the performance of the assay. *E+Ab
r
*EAb
+ E
EAb The effectiveness of the antibodies as an analytical reagent is usually determined in terms of its specificity, affinity and sensitivity. Specificity refers t o the uniqueness of the induced antibody site when analogues of the primary antigen are presented to it. The specificity depends on the structure of the reacting hormone and similarly structured compounds may bond t o the antibodies, giving a nonspecific cross-reaction In the assay devised by Borst and O'Connor, most ecdysones compete effectively with ecdysterone for antibody binding sites and the assay has a low specificity which can be applied to determining total ecdysones (Borst and O'Connor, 1974). As ponasterone A and 22,25-dideoxy-5a-ecdysone do not react significantly with the antibody, it is likely that a side-chain terminal hydroxyl group is necessary for hapten-antibody interaction. The assay of Lauer et al. (1974) was shown t o be more specific for ecdysterone; ecdysones lacking a (2-20 hydroxyl substituent were either weakly competitive or noncompetitive in the assay. The affinity refers t o the vigour of binding displayed by an antibody and is usually expressed as a temperature-variable constant. The competitive binding phenomena is then partially controlled by this factor. Borst and O'Connor (1974) obtained a value of 2 x 10' 1 mol-' for their assay which by comparison with other steroid assay systems would be described as moderate and probably explains in part the low specificity achieved. The sensitivity refers t o the minimum amount of antigenic material that may be determined with a degree of confidence. The sensitivity * is dependent on the activity of the radiolabelled ecdysterone. Borst and O'Connor (1972) using ecdysterone of specific activity 6 Ci mmol-" could detect 200 pg of hormone, while with ecdysterone of 50 Ci mmol-', less than 100 pgcould be detected. Lauer et al. (1974) claim a detection limit of 80 pg in their assay. Some of the disadvantages of the radioimmunoassay technique are the long time required to develop the procedures for the production of good quality antisera, the rather large quantities of expensive ecdysterone needed to form the initial hapten complex and that tritiated ecdysterone of high
38
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
specific activity is required for measurement of the competitive binding process. The linear range of the calibration curve is short and the time per malysis is rather long. Its advantages are that it is a sensitive technique with some degree of \pecificity that can be applied to crude biological extracts. It determines molecules with a three-dimensional structure similar to ecdysterone. The method is potentially very useful if the antiserum could be made available commercially and is probably capable of still greater sensitivity. The radioimmunoassay of Borst and O'Connor has been used t o determine ecdysones in Drosophila melanogaster (Borst et al., 1974), Manducta sexta (Bollenbacher et al., 1975) and Leucophaea maderae (Borst and Engelmann, 1974). If the ecdysone molecule could be linked t o the protein through a less important part of its structure (e.g. the 2P-OH) a more specific mtiserum might be produced.
3.5
GAS-LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY
Gas-liquid chromatography (GLC) is widely used for the separation of organic compounds which are volatile and sufficiently thermally stable t o survive the processes of vaporization and passage through the chromatography column. The highly polar ecdysones do not meet these requirements unless converted t o less polar derivatives before analysis. The most useful form of nonpolar derivative of an hydroxyl group is the trimethylsilyl ether, made by methods which are discussed in section 3.5.1. y
ROH + CH3-Si-X
I
3
CH3
-
CH3 I RO-Si-CH3 + HX AH3 A trimethylsilyl ether
X is one of a variety of groups
The separation of the structurally similar ecdysone trimethylsilyl (TMS) cthers presents a problem in that relatively high column temperatures are necessary for their analysis and this limits considerably the number of stationary liquid phases which can be used. In essence, only the thermally stable silicone oil phases meet the requirements of low bleed at the (emperatures (260-300 "C) employed in the analysis. A comparison of the separation of a mixture of three ecdysone TMS ethers on three thermally stable silicone phases (OV-101, Dexsil 300 GC and OV-17) (Poole, 1975) is wmmarized in Table 8. Only the column of OV-101 gave a base line separation of ecdysone and ecdysterone TMS ethers. None of the liquid phases gave a base line separation of ecdysterone and inokosterone TMS
39
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES TABLE 8
The separation of ecdysone TMS ethers on 3-ft columns, 1 per cent loading on Gas ChromQ, nitrogen 60 ml min-' and temperature programmed 250-300 OC a t 6 O C min-' Ecdysone TM S ether
Retention time (min)
ov-101
A B C D
2.60 4.50 5.05 5.40
Dexsil300GC
A B C D
5.30 5.75 5.90
Stationary phase ~~
~
ov-17
A
B C D
3.30
2.90 4.65 4.90 5.35
A = 2~,3~,14&tris(trimethylsiloxy)-5~-cholest-7-en-6-one. B = 2~,3~,14~,22,25-pentakis(trimethylsiloxy)-5~-cholest-7-en-6-one (ecdysone penta-TMS* ether). C = 2~,3~,1~,20,22,25-hexakis(trimethylsiloxy)-5~-cholest-7-en-one (ecdysterone hexa-TMS ether). D = 2~,3~,1~,20,22,26-hexakis(trimethylsiloxy)-5~-cho1est-7-en-6-one (inokosterone hexa-TMS ether). * TMS = trimethylsilyl.
ethers, which differ only in the position of one side chain TMS group. The best resolution of this pair was again achieved on the OV-101 column. Recently, two thermally stable polar phases (Poly-S 179 and PZ-176) of potential use for steroid analysis have been introduced (Mathews, 1970, 1974). Their application to the separation of ecdysone TMS ethers has not been reported. Low phase loadings, typically 1-2 per cent, are used so as t o maintain good peak shape at moderate temperatures. This requires that only the best column support material should be used to avoid peak tailing and decomposition at active centres. The support should be of the diatomite type, acid washed and silylated by the manufacturer. Coating of the support with the stationary phase by the rotary evaporator technique followed by fluidized drying gives very efficient columns (Kruppa et ul., 1967). After coating and conditioning the support can be further deactiva-
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
40
Led by on-column silylation when necessary. The columns should be well onditioned before use with the electron capture detector. The useful life of tile column depends upon its treatment. With careful handling, columns I lave been used continually for 2-3 years without deterioration. The choice of GLC detector depends on the sensitivity required. The flame ionization detector (FID) will detect at maximum sensitivity 50 ng of liexaltis-TMS ecdysterone (50 pg ml-' ) and the electron capture detector (IXD), 5.0 pg (5.0 ng m1-l) of the same compound. The FID is robust and simple t o operate whereas the ECD requires more skill and gives poor I vsults when mishandled. The physiological levels of ecdysones in arthro1)oda normally require the greater sensitivity of the ECD for their t letermination. I
'i.5.1 Formation of trimethylsilyl ethers of ecdysones
'I'rimethylsilyl ethers can be prepared with one or more of the commerc ially available silylation reagents, some of which are shown below. CH3
I
0--Si( CH3 ) 3 CH3'C 'N-s~(cH,)
CH3-Si-Cl
I
CH3 (9) Trimethylchlorosilane
TMCS
(10) N,O-bis(trimethylsily1) acetamide BSA
/=N ( CH3) Si-NJ ( 1 1 ) Trimethylsilylimidazole TMSIm
With ecdysones, some or all of the hydroxy groups can be converted to \ilyl ethers t o make the molecule more volatile for gas chromatography, but I eproducible conditions are required. Katz and Lensky (1970) reported a I'MS ether of ecdysone by heating the steroid for one minute at 80 "C in V.0-bis( trimethylsi1yl)acetamide (BSA) (10) and pyridine. A single peak was obtained on gas chromatography but no evidence was given for the number o f hydroxyl groups reacted. Morgan and Woodbridge (1971) first converted (he ketone groups t o an 0-methyloxime (methoxime) and then by a Iirolonged treatment (70 h ) with BSA at room temperature converted the 2,3,22 and 25-hydroxyl groups t o silyl ethers in ecdysone and ecdysterone. I'he nature of the product was determined by mass spectrometry (Morgan xid Woodbridge, 19 74). The ecdysone derivatives were conveniently \ olatile and gave characteristic double peaks due t o incomplete separation
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
41
of the syn and anti methoxime isomers. However, the two-stage derivatization procedure was inconveniently long and the double peaks could be troublesome in complex mixtures.
a
CH,ONH,HCI
m*'
+
, H
H O
OCH~
H N CH~O'
Methoxime isomers
Galbraith et al. (196813, 1969a) and Thompson et al. (1970) have shown that the l k - h y d r o x y groups in some ecdysone analogues were incompletely silylated b y BSA in dimethylformamide at 80 "C for up t o 18 h. Thus BSA can be used selectively t o protect some hydroxyl groups but lacks the reactivity required for preparing fully trimethylsilylated derivatives. Si(CH,),Cl
* Q
OSi(CH3)3 Formation of enol silyl ether
Certain advantages are t o be gained by the use of trimethylsilylimidazole (11) for the formation of ecdysone TMS ethers. It is the strongest trimethylsilylating reagent known and the by-product of the reaction is the weakly amphoteric imidazole which does not promote enolization of the ketone group in ecdysones. The use of acid catalysis (e.g. trimethylchlorosilane, TMCS) (9) to improve the silylation strength of the reagents commonly used to form TMS ethers of steroids has t o be avoided with ecdysones due to the ready enolization of the unsaturated ketone group. Ikekawa et al. (1972) claimed that all the hydroxyl groups in ecdysterone could be quantitatively trimethylsilylated with TMSIm at 100 "C for one hour. The C-20 hydroxyl group was found t o be the slowest t o react and the extent of trimethylsilyl ether formation was confirmed by combined gas chromatography and mass spectrometry (GC-MS). Other authors have reported the use of TMSIm for the formation of ecdysterone TMS ethers (see Miyazaki et al., 1973; Lafont et al., 1974; King et al., 1974-0.5 h, 9 6 "C; Borst and O'Connor, 1974-0.25 h, 100 "C). In an attempt to repeat the work of Ikekawa et al. (1972), Poole et al. (1975) found that heating ecdysterone in TMSIm at various temperatures resulted in the formation of different products easily
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
42
separated by GLC. Heating the reaction mixture for 4 h at 100 "C gave a quantitative yield of a TMS ether which after heating overnight ,it 140 "C was converted to a derivative of shorter retention time. It was shown that the 14a-hydroxyl group was not trimethylsilylated readily at LOO OC but could be converted t o the TMS ether at the higher temperature. The order of reactivity of the hydroxyl groups in ecdysterone towards N S I m was established as 2,3,22,25 > 20 >> 14. The order of reactivity was confirmed by the use of simpler model compounds, infrared spectroscopy aid mass spectrometry (Morgan and Poole, 1976). The relative retention times on gas chromatography and Rf values on TLC of some fully and p,irtially protected TMS ethers of ecdysones are summarized in Tables 9
v11tually
TABLE 9 Rc-tention time data for some TMS ethers of ecdysones on a 3 ft x 0.25 in 0.d. column of 1 per cent OV-101 on Gas ChromQ, a t 266 O C and nitrogen 60 ml min-' Retention time min
Ecdysone TMS ether 'I etrakis-TMS ecdysone
3.90 3.10 4.60 5.30 4.10 6.20 4.50
Pvntakis-TMS ecdysone 'I ctrakis-TMS ecdysterone Pc ntakis-TMS ecdysterone Hcxakis-TMS ecdysterone Prntakis-TZIS inokosterone H exakis-TMS inokosterone
TABLE 10 'TRIS ethers of ecdysones: Rf values on silica gel TLC plates deactivated by heating at 110 OC for 1 h before use
Solvent systems Steroid
Hydroxyl groups silylated ~~
Toluene-ethyl Acetate ( 9 : l ) ~
26, 30, 1k-Trihydroxy- 20, 30 -5fl-choIest-7-en-6-one 20, 30, 1 k l k tlysone I;( tiysterone
Tolune-ethyl Acetate (7:3)
~
0.39 0.51
-
-
0.69
20,30, 22,25 2/3,30, 1401,22,25
0.58
-
20, 30, 22, 25 20, 3$, 20, 22, 2 5 20, 30, 1401, 20, 22, 25
0.22 0.69
0.54 0.67 0.75
43
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
and 10. It seems that 1kekawa.et al. failed t o recognize incomplete TMS ether formation with their reaction conditions. The conditions used in this laboratory for the formation of TMS ethers of ecdysterone are summarized in Table 11. The reactions are conveniently carried out in screw-capped reacti-vials. It should be noticed that pyridine when added t o the reaction medium leads t o an extension of the reaction time. The effect of various catalysts on the formation of TMS ethers of ecdysterone has been discussed by Morgan and Poole (1976). TABLE 11 Experimental conditions for the formation of TMS ethers of ecdysterone Reaction time with TMSIm
Hydroxyl goups
Room temperature 15 min 100 OC, 4 h 100 'C, 6 h 140 'C, 16 h
2P, 30, 22, 25 20
140 ___
Comments
~
~
___
No solvent Pyridine as solvent No solvent
___
* Time for complete reaction depends on the purity of the TMSIm reagent. Some of the confusion in reported silylation conditions is dependent upon the quality of the reagent. We have found that TMSIm freshly prepared in the laboratory is a more powerful reagent than the commercial material, but that it deteriorates considerably on contact with air. Whether or not the 14a-hydroxyl group is silylated depends upon the quality of the reagent as well as temperature and reaction time. Very unreactive hydroxyl groups can be silylated by adding trimethylchlorosilane (TMCS) t o the reaction mixture, but this can encourage partial formation of enol silyl ether. In the author's laboratory it was found that synthetic model ecdysones containing a 5a-hydroxyl group were thermally unstable unless the hydroxyl group was protected. To achieve this the ketone must first be converted t o its methoxime and then the 5a-hydroxyl group can be silylated with a mixture of BSA, TMSIm and TMCS (5:5:4). 3.5.2 Formation of trimethylsilyl heptafluorobutyrates Ikekawa et al. (1972) have described a method for formation of a mixed trimethylsilylheptafluorobutyryl (TMS-HFB) derivative of ecdysones. To the TMS ether in TMSIm was added heptafluorobutyrlimidazole (HFBIm) with a catalytic amount of heptafluorobutyric acid. The conversion was about 9 0 per cent of theoretical b y GLC after heating for 2 h at 50 'C. The reaction can be carried out with or without the 14a-hydroxyl group
44
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
protected as its TMS ether and the product can be detected at the picogram le\el with the electron capture detector (Ikekawaetul., 1972; Miyazaki e t al., 1973; Poole, 1975). Direct reaction of ecdysterone with HFBIm or hcptafluorobutyric anhydride gave a mixture of products. In the case of etdysterone it was shown that the exchange reaction allowed the introduction of one heptafluorobyrl group at the C-2 position (Miyazaki et al., 1973). The TMS ethers of ecdysones are sensitive to electron capture detection at the picogram level without resorting t o formation of the mixed II1.IS-HFB derivatives. The TMS-HFB derivatives are more volatile than the r h l S ethers on GLC and their formation is useful t o help confirm the dcntity of an ecdysone by providing further retention time data. Reactions o I this type are increasingly important in the ecdysone field due to the low IeLels of the hormone in arthropods which often precludes the collection of rn'tss spectral data. This approach was used in the confirmation of the piesence of ecdysterone in Balunus balanoides (Bebbington, 1975). Both the acetonide and n-butylboronic ester derivatives of adjacent diol groups In ecdysterone are cleaved by TMSIm, therefore acetonides or boronic esters cannot be used as alternative derivatives for confirming identity of structure. '3.5.3 The electrophore in ecdysones Steroids, as a class, do not show strong electron capturing properties, the rather poorly understood requirement for determining with the selective E(:D detector. The ecdysones are an exception in this respect in that they contain a conjugated electron capturing group which enables them to be dcterrnined at the picogram level. The centre of initial electron attachment in a molecule is described as the electrophore. The necessary structural
TMso O M T *S
TMS 0
Least detectable amount 1.0 ng R=OH 0.06ng R = OTMS 0.005 ng The electrophore of ecdysone TMS ethers
R =H
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
45
elements of the electrophore in,ecdysones were identified as the 7-en-6-one (unsaturated ketone) group, the substituent at the C-14 position with a smaller contribution from the remote trimethylsiloxy groups at C-2 and C-3 (Poole and Morgan, 1975a). Trimethylsilylation of the l4a-hydroxyl group increases the sensitivity of the ecdysone t o the detector by a power of ten. However, this extra sensitivity is not always required in the determination of ecdysones in arthropoda and in these cases the extra time required t o trimethylsilylate the l k - h y d r o x y l group is not justified. A linear response over the range 60-700 x lo-'' g was obtained for ecdysone and ecdysterone with a free 14a-hydroxyl group and 5-700 x lo-'* g for the ecdysones with a 14ol-TMS group. The response of the ecdysone derivatives t o the electron capture detector is markedly temperature dependent (Poole and Morgan, 1975a). Maximum response was obtained at low detector oven temperatures. Moderate retention times for ecdysone TMS ethers require a column oven temperature of 265-280 OC with a slightly higher temperature for the detector oven, so that the best compromise is a detector oven temperature of 300 "C. 3.5.4 Sample preparation f o r ECD To determine the very low concentrations of arthropod ecdysones with the electron capture detector requires careful sample preparation, to avoid contamination with electron-capturing impurities. Above all, chlorinated solvents must be avoided. A very efficient procedure used in the authors' laboratory for ecdysone analysis in Schistocerca gregaria is shown in scheme 1 (see p. 46). It makes use of three highly efficient partition systems followed by a further purification of the extract by thin-layer chromatography (TLC) on silica gel of the trimethylsilyl ethers. An area from R f = 0.5-0.9 is scraped from the plate and the ecdysone TMS ethers eluted with sodium-dried diethyl ether. The ether is removed with a stream of nitrogen at 30 OC and injection of the residue in an appropriate volume of toluene is made €or gas chromatography. The recovery of ecdysterone added t o the methanol extract of adult desert locusts is shown in Table 12. Scheme 1 was designed €or the efficient separation of polar ecdysones from biological material and will not be as efficient for the determination of the more hydrophobic ecdysone metabolites with only a few hydroxyl groups. The analysis of isolated tissues may not require the use of the complete scheme for acceptable results. The quality of the chromatograms obtained is illustrated for the determinations of ecdysone (A), ecdysterone (B) and an as yet unidentified compound (C) in 4th instar nymphs, day 5 of Schistocerca gfegaria (Fig. 1).
46
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE SCHEME 1
+
Ten insects homogenized in methanol
Insoluble residue
Methanol solution
1
(discard)
Residue, partition
4
4 Aqueous methanol
Hexane (discard)
4
Residue, partition
r-7 Butanol
Aqueous
&
(discard)
Residue, partition
4 Aqueous
Ethyl acetate (discard)
4
Residue
4 GLC-ECD C TLC t silylate
Borst et al. (1974) have described a sample “clean-up” procedure for the determination of ecdysones in Drosophila melanogaster by GLC-ECD, scheme 2. The ecdysones contained in the butanol are subjected t o TLC on silica gel in CHCl3 : 95 per cent EtOH (7:3). Some preliminary work in our laboratory indicated that the recovery of trace quantities of ecdysones by alcoholic elution from TLC plates gave poor recoveries and contributed t o the GLC detector solvent front by contaminating samples with impurities from the silica gel even though this had been thoroughly washed prior t o use. I t was for this reason that chromatography was confined t o TMS ethers in scheme 1 as they can be recovered more efficiently and with a weaker eluent, e.g. ether, which does not add any impurities t o the gas chromatogram. This also enabled us t o avoid the use of a water-hexane partition before GLC t o destroy excess silylating reagent. The authors also used a very high detector oven temperature (400 “C) for the final determination which, because of the temperature dependence of the detector response, would cause considerable loss in sensitivity.
47
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES TABLE 12 The recovery of ecdysterone added to the methanol extract of adult locusts
TMS ether formed
Pentakis-TMS ecdysterone
Hexakis-TMS ecdysterone
Amount of added ecdysterone I-lg
Range of recoveries % 80-90
10-1 1-0.1 0.01-0.001
75-85 70-85 90-100 80-90 70-85
10-1 0.1-0.01 0.001-0.0001
i
C
Time + Fig. 1. Gas chromatograph trace of ecdysones present on day 5 of the 4th instar of Schistocercu greguriu, using an electron capture detector. A, ecdysone; B, ecdysterone; C, unidentified polar ecdysone.
Morgan et al. (1975a) have described a simpler “clean-up” procedure which was adequate for determining methoxime-silyl ethers with the flame ionization detector. Miyazaki et al. (1973) have described a rather long
48
-
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
SCHEME 2
Larvae blend in methanol
Residue (discarded)
Methanol solution
4
Add water and CHC13
4 I
4
?
Lower phase
Upper phase
I
I
_______J
1
L
Residue
Re-extract
Rutanol
Water (discarded)
1 Silica Gel TLC
1
Elute with ethanol
1 1 Silylate
Residue
Water (discarded)
Hexane
1 GLC-ECD
extraction procedure for the analysis of ecdysones from pupae of Bombyx mori. The pupae were dried and ground with sea sand before soxhlet extraction with tetrahydrofuran for twenty-four hours. The tetrahydrofuran extract was concentrated, adsorbed onto silicic acid and lipids etc. removed by soxhlet extraction for one hour each with hexane, benzene and ether before extraction of the ecdysones with tetrahydro furan. This extract was purified by passage though a short column of silica gel followed by preparative layer TLC and the residue eluted from the plate used t o form the TMS ethers. Formation of the TMS-HFB derivative followed by preparative layer TLC was used for the final analysis by GLC-ECD.
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
3.6
49
MASS FRAGMENTOGRAPHY
The ion collector of a modern mass spectrometer is so sensitive t o small amounts of material that the mass spectrometer can be used as a specific and quantitative gas chromatograph detector. Because the mass spectrometer has t o operate at high vacuum, the gas chromatograph is coupled to the mass spectrometer through an interface (a semi-permeable membrane or jet separator) to remove the carrier gas. For efficient operation of the technique, the conditions of the gas chromatograph, interface and mass spectrometer must all be optimized. The mass spectrometer does not scan the mass range but is set t o record ions of a specific mass-charge ratio (m/e). For single ion monitoring (SIM), a single mass is selected from the mass spectrum of the compounds of interest and this ion is monitored throughout the GLC run. Thus only peaks from the GLC containing the selected ion are recorded by the mass spectrometer and the output (mass chromatogram) is in the conventional form of Gaussian peaks on a time axis, like most GLC detectors. Selectivity can be improved by the use of multiple ion detection (MID) in which several ions are sequentially brought to focus at the detector by rapid switching of the accelerating voltage using an accelerating voltage alternator and the output accumulated in different channels. Each ion has its own channel and a multipen recorder is used to display the data in the form of mass chromatograms. Under optimum conditions, l o - ' g of an organic compound can be detected. Not all mass spectrometers are suitable for the mass fragmentographic analysis of ecdysones. For compounds of low volatility a doubly pumped mass spectrometer is essential (Poole, 1975). The MID unit is only available for mass spectrometers of recent origin. The very high cost of a mass spectrometer and the expertise needed in its operation will probably limit this technique for the analysis of ecdysones to a few specialist laboratories. The mass fragmentographic analysis of the TMS ethers of ecdysones was first performed by Miyazaki et al. (1973). The fragments m/e 561 (I) for ecdysterone and m/e 564 for ecdysone TMS ethers were used as the selected masses. The limit of detection was l o - ' g (100 pg) and both ecdysone and ecdysterone were measured from pupae of Bombyx mori. This method has been used by Lafont et al. (1974) and Chino et al. (1974). It is important when using the mass fragmentographic technique to be sure of the composition of the derivative formed. For ecdysterone both the hexakis (TMS) ether and pentakis (TMS) ether have the ion m/e 561 as their base peak. Their gas chromatographic retention times are very different, and if incomplete reaction at the 14a-hydroxyl group had occurred, failure t o appreciate this point could lead t o error in the interpretation of the mass chromatogram. As the same ion m/e 561 is
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
50
obtained with both derivatives, its structure is probabh. hettcr reprrsented Iiy (13) than (12). The situation with the TMS ethers of ecdysone is difterent. The mass spectra of tetrakis (TMS) ecdysone has a strong ion at m/e 564 but in pentakis (TMS) ecdysone, the ion m/e 564 is weak with a strong ion at mfe 567 (Morgan and Poole, 1976). Thus, although either derivative is juitable for mass fragmentography, it is essential that the derivative !ormation reaction is thoroughly investigated first as this controls the \election of the ion t o be monitored. Insufficient information is available to propose structures for the ions m/e 564 and 567.
:::I::; cP
TMSO
OTMS
TMSO
*=OTMS
y
3
-+
TMSO TMSO
H O
H O m/e 561 (13)
For quantitative analysis by either SIM or MID an internal standard is iequired to permit the analyst to make allowances for losses caused by \ ariation in injected sample volume, column adsorption effects and all those variations in ion current or voltage which influence the intensity, I ocusing o r measurement of the ion beam. The plant ecdysone, cyasterone, its trimethylsilyl ether derivative was used for this purpose by Miyazaki t t al. This compound is less volatile than the insect ecdysones and unless high temperatures are used, peak shapes are very broad. The ideal ecdysone Iiiternal standard would seem t o be an isotopically labelled insect hormone \I hich could be distinguished from the natural hormone by using multiple ) n detection of the similar fragment in labelled and unlabelled compound. I(
:i. 7 HIGH-PRESSURE LIQUID CHROMATOGRAPHY
'I he very polar nature of the ecdysone molecule and the initial difficulties cuperienced in forming suitable derivatives for GLC led several groups to
investigate the possibility of ecdysone analysis using high-pressure liquid c hromatography (HPLC). As derivative fprmation is not required for aiialysis, ecdysones might be determined directly and the effluent collected f o r subsequent analysis by other physical techniques or b y bioassay. I;urthermore, the ecdysones strongly absorb ultraviolet light at 254 nm
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
51
(section 3.3) which is convenient for detection purposes. The ultraviolet detector is currently the most sensitive of all HPLC detectors available for those compounds which absorb radiation between 200 and 700 nm. A detection limit for the determination of ecdysones b y HPLC using uv detection has not been published, but theoretical calculation indicates that the detection of 10 ng of ecdysones should be possible. By the use of high pressures to force the mobile liquid phase through columns of incompressible micro-particulate stationary phase, resolution in a time compatible with that associated with GLC can be obtained. The separation of ecdysones by HPLC is conveniently considered in terms of the nature of the stationary phase employed. 3.7.1 Reversed-phase chromatography Reversed-phase chromatography has important advantages over other forms of adsorption chromatography for the analysis of water-soluble organic compounds. The separation process is based on the attraction of the hydrophobic stationary phase for hydrophobic compounds (Simpson, 1972). Hydrophilic solvents are strong eluents because they are capable of displacing the sorbed polar molecules. For ecdysones, the reversed-phase technique is specially attractive as the very polar impurities found in crude extracts (e.g. sugars and glucosides) are eluted from the column before the less polar ecdysones and the column material can be made ready for re-use by solvent recycle. Hori (1969) described the separation of ecdysones by reversed-phase chromatography using Amberlite XAD-2 with a wateralcohol eluting gradient. The Amberlite resin is not available in a particle size suitable for HPLC and had t o be ground and sieved before use. Since the resin is compressible, maximum pressures were limited, which set an upper limit on flow rates. Although the separation of structurally similar ecdysones was often quite good, the retention times were inconveniently long (ecdysterone 420 min, ecdysone 540 min). The method has been used for the separation of ecdysones from plants (Imai et al., 1968a, b; Hori, 1969) and insect material (Mnriyama et al., 1970; Schooley et al., 1972; Hikino et al., 1975). Separations on the preparative scale have been described for ecdysones from crude plant extracts (Schooley and Nakanishi, 1973). The authors caution that for this application the very polar ecdysones may not be sufficiently retained by the resin (low column capacity factor) to give an adequate separation from impurities. For this purpose, more polar Amberlite resins might be used to advantage (Simpson, 1972). The separation of ecdysones on the semi-rigid porous polymer, Poragel PN, has been described (Bombaugh, 1971; Schooley and Nakanishi, 1973). Poragel PN is a copolymer of divinylbenzene and ethylene glycol dimethacrylate with heavy cross-linking (40 per cent) compared with Amberlite XAD-2
52
E. D A V I D MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
which is a lightly cross-linked polystyrene polymer. The ester groups of the I'oragel confer a degree of polarity t o the polymer which probably explains the greater retention volume of ecdysterone on Poragel compared with .\mberlite XAD-2. The separation of milligramme quantities of ecdysones was achieved but analytical separations (sub-microgramme level) were poor, due in part t o the inherently slow mass-transfer and limited capacity factor o f the polymer, particularly at high flow rates (Bombaugh, 1971; Schooley, 1973). The reversed-phase separation of ecdysones from crude plant extracts using polyamide has been described (Jizba and Herout, 1967). Pellicular "olyamide phases suitable for HPLC are available commercially (Pellidon, Reeve Angel) but their application t o the analysis of ecdysones has not been reported. King et al. (1974) have described the analysis of ecdysones 1 n tissue culture medium using Vydac reversed-phase (CIS hydrocarbon permanently bonded to a pellicular support) and eluting with a mobile phase of 25 per cent methanol in water. This method has been used in the Identification of ecdysones in Drosophila melunogaster (Borst et al., 1974) .ind Leucaphaea maderae (King and Marks, 1974). Using Corasil CIS, and a mobile phase of 35 per cent water in methanol ZP,3&14a-trihydroxy-5$holest-7-en-6-one had a retention time of 12.0 min (1.0 ml min-' , column I m x 2.1 mm). Under these conditions ecdysterone is poorly retained and rlutes with the injection solvent (Poole, 1975). The change in capacity I x t o r for the model steroid with solvent composition can be illustrated b y I he following data: (
0.5 ml min-' 29 per cent water in methanol: R , 5.75 min, 0.5 ml min-' 25 per cent water in methanol: R t 1.40 min. i n an attempt to increase the capacity factor by using a more polar
eversed-phase column (ETH Permaphase), ecdysterone was not retained when water-alcohol mixtures were used as the mobile phase.
1
.7 .2 Liquid -1iquid part it io n chro mu tography liquid partition chromatography of ecdysones is difficult due t o a lack of permanently bonded polar stationary phases. Those separations which have I)een achieved have used polar liquid phases mechanically held on a solid jupport. To prevent stripping of the stationary phase, the mobile phase has to be pre-saturated with stationary phase. Gradient elution is not practical m d high flow rates usually sheer the stationary phase from the support. l'he most successful analysis of ecdysones have been achieved with 1 per < ent P,P'-oxydipropionitrile (BOP), on Zipax using hexane mixed with letrahydrofuran as the mobile phase (Henry et al., 1971; Schmit, 1971). A method for increasing the percentage loading of BOP on Zipax has been 'k
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
53
reported (Kirkland and Dilks, 19 73). Permanently bonded liquid phases such as Corasil CI8 and ETH Permaphase show no retention of ecdysones using hexane mixed with chlorinated hydrocarbons as the mobile phase. 3.7.3 Liquid-solid absorption chroma tograp hy From the early days of ecdysone analysis, the separation of the hormones by silica gel chromatography has been important. The extension o f this work t o HPLC using highly efficient small-particle silica1 columns was predictable. Chino et al. (1974) separated ecdysone from ecdysterone on Zorbax Sil (25 cm x 2.1 mm column, 0.3 ml min-' , dichloromethanemethanol 9: 1).Peak shapes were reasonably sharp and the separation quite good (ecdysone R , 23 min and ecdysterone R , 30 min). Nigg e t al. (1974) have described the separation of ecdysones on Corasil I1 (a high-capacity pellicular silica) using mixtures of chloroform-ethanol as the mobile phase. King and Marks (1974) have described the separation of ecdysone from tissue culture medium in which pairs of prothoracic glands of Leucophaea maderae were incubated, using Lichrosorb SI 60 (0.5 m x 2.2 mm column, 10 per cent methanol in dichloromethane, 0.4 ml min-' ). With Porasil A, an irregularly shaped porous silica (37-75 pm) and tetrahydrofuran or tetrahydrofuran mixed with methanol, ecdysterone is rapidly eluted. With 40 per cent tetrahydrofuran in dichloromethane, 2/3,3/3,14~-trihydroxy-5/3-cholest-7-en-6-one is eluted in 2.25 min (1.5 ml min-', 50 cm x 2.1 mm) but the retention time of ecdysterone is very long (Poole, 1975). The optimum mobile phase composition was tetrahydrofuran-methanol-dichloromethane (20: 1:29). The addition of a small amount of methanol as a polar phase-modifier reduced peak tailing substantially. With a flow rate of 1 ml min-', the retention time of ecdysterone was 11.O min and for 2~,3@,14a-trihydroxy-5/3-cholest-7en-6-one was 2.60 min. The still relatively broad peak for ecdysterone is probably a consequence of the effect of diffusion in the stagnant mobile phase in the pores of the support making an important contribution t o the mass transfer term. To overcome this problem the use of a more efficient silica gel adsorbent is required. High-pressure liquid chromatography is still in a state of rapid advance. With improved detection cells and new adsorbents and liquid phases we may expect t o learn of more efficient and more versatile separations for ecdysones.
4 Summary of analytical methods Seven different methods for the micro-determination of ecdysones have been described in the previous section. With the exception of the acid-
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
54
induced fluorescence method they can all be applied t o the analysis of c.cdysones in biological material. The remaining six methods are contrasted in terms of sensitivity, selectivity, ease of application to routine samples, degree of ‘skill required for their operation and relative cost per analysis. The least detectable amount of ecdysterone which can be determined by I he physical methods described in section 3 is given in Table 13. Thin-layer chromatography with uv detection, and bioassay methods are the least TABLE 1 3 The sensitivity of current analytical techniques for the analysis of ecdysterone ~
Method
Detection limit 10-~
Comments ~~
Thin -layer chromatography (IIV detection)
500
Bioassay (quantitative determination) Fluorescence spectroscopy
100
50
Radioimmunoassay
0.08
Gas-liquid chromatography (electron capture detection) Mass fragmentography High-pressure liquid chromatography (uv detection)
0.005
0.10 10
Nonspecific detection easily masked by biological material Approximately 25 for nonquantitative detection Not applicable for crude biological material Dependent upon availability of antiserum 0.06 with a free 1 k - O H group Expensive equipment Approximate value by calculation
sensitive. Thin-layer chromatography is an inexpensive technique, requiring llttle skill in its operation. Selectivity in terms of resolution of ecdysones is poor unless the time per analysis is extended as in continuous flow TLC. In 1 erms of efficiency it performs badly by comparison with high-pressure liquid chromatography but the capital cost of equipment is much less. The I)ioassay technique is simple to perform but requires large numbers of test ‘rbdomens, the upkeep of a stable insect colony and a degree of skill in handling, and scoring the test species. It should be remembered that the Iiioassay does not detect all compounds of ecdysone type, shows a variable I esponse between individual ecdysones and can give a positive response t o c.cdysone precursors. It responds to substances which induce moulting as this is the effect observed and not t o ecdysones in general. A preliminary purification step is often required before analysis and the resolution
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
55
obtained by this step controls the specificity. When TLC is used at this stage, the specificity may be poor unless conditions are optimized for the separation. Radioimmunoassay is capable of detecting ecdysones in crude biological material at trace levels. A degree of specificity is obtained in that the immunization process yields antibodies to molecules of a certain threedimensional structure. Specificity between individual ecdysones is not normally large and cross-reaction occurs. To establish the assay requires considerable time and labour with a high degree of skill. The time per assay can be inconveniently long and if counting equipment is not available, then expensive to set up. The establishment and operation of the assay requires relatively large quantities of expensive ecdysones and radiolabelled ecdysones. Availability of the required antiserum could make the method much more attractive. Gas-liquid chromatography with electron capture detection of ecdysone TMS ethers is the most sensitive of all the assay techniques and is directly applicable to those ecdysones containing 7-en-6-one and l4a-hydroxyl groups, a combination found in all arthropod ecdysones so far identified. The combination of the high resolution of the gas chromatograph and sensitivity of the electron capture detector cannot be matched by another technique for the analysis of ecdysones. Application t o biological material requires a preliminary purification procedure which extends the time per analysis. The continuous operation of an electron capture detector requires some experience and skill but, if treated with care, analyses can be carried out routinely. Variability in the conditions necessary for silyl ether formation can cause difficulties. The gas chromatograph-electron capture detector combination is not prohibitively expensive t o purchase and running costs are very low. Mass fragmentography makes use of a mass spectrometer as a gas chromatographic detector. It is a sensitive technique with probably the highest degree of specificity of all the assays. The high resolution of the gas chromatograph is coupled to the mass discriminatory power of the mass spectrometer and thus even close t o the detection limit a high degree of confidence can be placed in both the identity of the compound and its concentration in the sample. The method ties up a very expensive piece of equipment that may be serving a variety of uses. The capital cost required to establish the technique is the highest of all the assays. If the instrument is also available for general use then allowance needs to be made for the time required to re-establish the optimum conditions and stabilize the instrument each time. Some preliminary purification is also required for biological material unless the mass spectrometer is operated under high resolution conditions at an overall lower sensitivity. High-pressure liquid chromatography is a relatively new technique with
56
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
,In enormous potential for the separation of mixtures into their components. The uv detector is at present the most sensitive of all HPLC cletectors. Crude biological material tends t o contain uv absorbing impuri1 ies which mask the detector and as a consequence a preliminary extraction 1)rocedure is necessary which adds t o the time per analysis. The initial cost o f equipment is high. It is relatively easy t o operate, if the operator has c,uperience in chromatography. Depending on the mobile phase used, ic~placementof solvent can considerably add t o the operating cost of the asay.
5 Conclusion ‘1 his review has attempted to bring together a body of information that is
s( attered through the chemical and biological literature. The study of ai thropod moulting and development has excited the interest of research
orkers in a wide range of disciplines. Our own interest arises from possible means of pest control. Thus far, discoveries have provided even fewer new ideas for insect control than has the area of juvenile hormone, but the assembling of the jig-saw puzzle has c,nly begun. As the picture emerges, one can expect fundamental discoveries that will stimulate entirely new strategies for insect control. 11
Acknowledgements
Work in the authors’ laboratory has been supported by the Overseas rkvelopment Administration, the Ministry of Overseas Development, and the Science Research Council, whose help we are glad t o acknowledge. References Agui, N. (1973). Quantitative bioassay of moulting hormone in vitro. Appl. Ent. ZOOL 9, 236-238. Urbbington, P. M. (1975). A chemical investigation into the moulting hormones of the barnacle Batanus balunoides. Ph.D. Thesis, Keele University. Bollenbacher, W. E., Vedeckis, W. V., Gilbert, L. I. and O’Connor, J. D. (1975). Ecdysone titres and prothoracic gland activity during the larval-pupal development of Manduca sexta. Devl Biol. 44, 46-53. Bombaugh, K. J. (1971). A comparison of separation mechanisms for liquid chromatography applications. In “Modern Practice of Liquid Chromatography” (Ed. J. J. Kirkland). pp. 360-374. WiIey-Interscience, New York. Borst, D. W. (1973). The analysis of ecdysones in biological tissue. Ph.D. Thesis, University of California (Dissertation Abs. No. 73 32052). Borst, D. W. and Engelmann, F. (1974).In vitro secretion of u-ecdysone by prothoracic glands of a hemimetabolous insect Leucophaea muderae (Blattaria). J. ex$ ZooL 189, 415-419.
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
57
Borst, D. W. and O’Connor, J. D. (1972). Arthropod moulting hormone radioimmune assay. Science, 178, 418-419. , Borst, D. W. and O’Connor, J. D. (1974). Trace analysis of ecdysones by gas liquid chromatography, radioimmunoassay and bioassay. Steroids, 24, 637-656. Borst, D. W., Bollenbacher, W. E., O’Connor, J. D., King, D. S. and Fristrom, J. W. (1974). Ecdysone levels during metamorphosis of Drosophila melanogaster. Devt Biol. 39, 308-316. Burdette, W . J. (Ed.) (1974). “Invertebrate Endocrinology and Hormonal Heterophylly”. Springer, New York. Butenandt, A. and Karlson, P. (1954). h e r die Isolierung eines MetamorphoseHormons der Insekten in kristallisierten Form. 2. Naturf. 9b, 389-391. Canonica, L., Danieli, B., Ferrari, G., Krepinsky, J. and Weisz-Vincze, I. (1975). A novel method of isolation of phytoecdysones from Kaladana seeds. Phytochem. 14, 525-527. Carlisle, D. B. (1965). The effect of crustacean and locust ecdysones on moulting and proecdysis in juvenile shore crabs, Carcinus maenas. Gen. comp. Endocr. 5, 366-372. Chino, H., Sakurai, S., Ohtaki, T., lkekawa, N., Miyazaki, H., Ishibashi, M. and Abuki, H. (1974). Biosynthesis of a-ecdysone by prothoracic glands in vitro. Science, 183, 529-530. Clever, U., Clever, I., Storbeck, I. and Young, N. L. (1973). The apparent requirement of two hormones, (Y- and 0-ecdysone for moulting induction in insects. Devl Biol. 31, 47-60. Faux, A., Horn, D. H. S., Middleton, E. J., Fales, H. M. and Lowe, M. E. (1969). Moulting hormones of a crab during ecdysis. Chem. Commun. 175-176. Fraenkel, G. (1935). A hormone causing pupation in the blowfly Calliphora erythrocephala. Prof. R. SOC. B, 118, 1-12. Gagosian, R. B., Bourbonniere, R. A., Smith, W. B., Couch, E. F., Blanton, C. and Novak, W. (1974). Lobster moulting hormones: isolation and biosynthesis of ecdysones. Experientia, 30, 723-724. Galbraith, M. N. and Horn, D. H. S. (1969). Insect moulting hormones: crustecdysone (20-hydroxyecdysone) from Podocarpus elatus. Aust. J. Chem. 22, 1045-1057. Galbraith, M. N., Horn, D. H. S., Middleton, E. and Hackney, R. J. (1968a). Structure of deoxycrustecdysone, a second crustacean moulting hormone. Chem. Commun. 83-85. Galbraith, M. N., Horn, D. H. S., Middleton, E. J. and Hackney, R. J. (1968b). A silyl ether as a protecting group in the synthesis of an isomer of ecdysone, 2OR-hydroxy22-deoxyecdysone. Chem. Commun. 466-467. Galbraith, M. N., Horn, D. H. S., Middleton, E. J. and Hackney, R. J. (1969a). Moulting hormones of insects and crustaceans: the synthesis of 2-deoxy-3-epicrustecdysone. Aust. J. Chem. 2 2 , 1059-1067. Galbraith, M. N., Horn, D. H. S., Thomson, J. A., Neufeld, G. J. and Hackney, R. J. (1 969b). Insect moulting hormones: crustecdysone in Calliphora. J. Insect Physiol. 15, 1225-1233. Galbraith, M. N., Horn, D. H. S., Middleton, E. J., Kaplanis, J. N. and Thompson, M. J. (1973). Structure of podecdysone C, a steroid with moulting hormone activity from the bark of Podocarpus elatus R. Br. Experientia, 29, 782.
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
58
(;albl-aith, M. N., Horn, D. H. S., Middleton, E. J., Thomson, J. A. and Wilkie, J. S. (1975). Metabolism of 3~,14~-dihydr0xy-5~-(3a-~H)-chOlest-7-en-6-one in Calliphora s t y p a J. Insect Physiol. 21, 23-32. Gilbert, L. I. and King, D. S. (1973). Physiology of growth and development: Endocrine aspects. I n “The Physiology of Insecta (Ed. M. Rockstein), vol. 1, pp. 250-368. Academic Press, New York and London. Gilgan, M. W. and Zinck, M. E. (1972). Estimation of ecdysterone from sulphuric acid induced fluorescence. Steroids, 20, 95-104. IIampshire, F. and Horn, D. H. S. (1966). Structure of crustecdysone, a crustacean moulting hormone. Chem. Commun. 37-38. I leinrich, G. and Hoffmeister, H. (1967).Ecdyson als Begleitsubstanz des Ecdysterons in Polypodium vulgare L. Experienta, 23, 995. Ilenrv, R. A., Schmit, J. A. and Dieckman, J. F. (1971).The analysis of steroids and derivatized steroids by high speed liquid chromatography. J. Chromat. Sci. 9,
5 13-520. IIikino, H., Ohizumi, U. and Takemoto, T. (1975). Steroid metabolism in Bombyx mori, 1. Catabolism of ponasterone A and ecdysterone in Bombyx mori. Hopp‘peSeyler’s 2. physiol. Chem. 356,309-314. I locks, P. and Weichert, R. (1966). 2O-Hydroxy-ecdyson, isoliert aus Insekten. Tetrahedron Lett. No. 26, 2989-2993. :;offman, J. A., Koolman, J., Karlson, P. and Joly, P. (1974).Moulting hormone titre and metabolic fate of injected ecdysone during the fifth larval instar and in the adult of Locusta migratoria (Orthoptera). Gen. conp. Endocr. 2 2 , 90-97. I loffnieister, H. (1966). Isolierung eines neuen Insektenhormons aus Seidenspinnerpuppen. 2. Naturf. Zlb, 335-336. Iloffmeister, H. and Grutzmacher, H. F. (1966). Zur Chemie des Ecdysterones. Tetrahedron Lett. No. 33,4017-4023. 1 lori, M. (1969). Automatic column chromatographic method for insect moulting steroids. Steroids, 14,33-45. Ilorn, D. H. S. (1971). The ecdysones. In “Naturally Occurring Insecticides (Eds M. Jacobson and D. G . Crosby), pp. 333-459.Marcel Dekker, New York. Ilorn, D. H. S., Middleton, E. J., Wunderlich, J. A. andHampshire, F. (1966).Identity of the moulting hormones of insects and crustaceans. Chem. Commun. 339-341. Ilorn, D. H. S., Fabbri, S., Hampshire, F. and Lowe, M. E. (1968). Isolation of crustecdysone from a crayfish (Jasus lalandei). Biochem. J. 109,399-406. liorn, D. H. S., Wilkie, J. S. and Thomson, J. A. (1974). Isolation of 0-ecdysone (20-hydroxyecdysone) from the parasitic nematode Ascaris lumbricoides. Experisntia, 30, 1109-1110. Il>iao, T. H., Hsiao, C. and deWilde, J. (1975). Moulting hormone production in the isolated larval abdomen of the Colorado beetle. Nature, 255, 727-728. lIktber, R. and Hoppe, W. (1965). Zur Chemie des Ecdysons VII. Die Kristall-u. Molekiilstrukturanalyse des insektenverpuppungs-hormons Ecdyson mit der Automatisierten Faltmolekulmethode. Chem. Ber. 98, 2403-2424. ILrkawa, N., Hattori, F., Rubio-Lightbourn, J., Miyazaki, H., Ishibashi, M. and Mori, C. (1972).Gas chromatographic separation of phytoecdysones. J. Chronat. Sci. 10,
233-242.
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
59
Imai, S., Fujioka, S., Nakanishi, K., Koreeda, M. and Kurokawa, T. (1967). Extraction of ponasterone A and ecdysone from podocarpaceae and related plants. Steroids, 10, 557-565. Imai, S., Fujioka, S., Murata, E., Sasakawa, Y. and Nakanishi, K. (1968a). The structures of three additional phytoecdysones from Podocarpus macrophyllus, makisterone B, C and D. Tetrahedron Lett. No. 36, 3887-3890. Imai, S., Hori, M., Fujioka, S., Murata, E., Goto, M. and Nakanishi, K. (1968b). Isolation of four new phytoecdysones, makisterone A, B, C, D and the structure of makisterone A, a Czs steroid. Tetrahedron Lett. No. 36, 3883-3886. Jizba, J. and Herout, V. (1967). Plant Substances XXVI. Isolation of constituents of common polypody rhizomes. Colln Czech. Chem. Commun. 32,2867-2874. Kaplanis, J. N., Robbins, W. E., Thompson, M. J. and Dutky, S. R. (1973). 26-Hydroxyecdysone: new insect moulting hormone from the egg of the tobacco hornworm. Science, 180, 307-308. Kaplanis, J. N., Tabor, L. A., Thompson, M. J., Robbins, W. E. and Shortino, T. J. (1966a). Assay for ecdysone (moulting hormone) activity using the house Ely, Musca domestica. Steroids, 8, 625-631. Kaplanis, J. N., Thompson, M. J., Yamamoto, R. T., Robbins, W. E. and Louloudes, S. J. (1966b). Ecdysones from the pupa of the tobacco hornworm Manducn sexta. Steroids, 8 , 605-623, Karlson, P. (1956a). Chemical investigation of the metamorphosis hormone of insects. Ann. Sci Nut. Zoot. Biol. Animale, 18, 125-137. Karlson, P. (1956b). Biochemical studies on insect hormones. Vitamins and Hormones, 14, 227-266. Karlson, P. (1963). Chemistry and biochemistry of insect hormones. Angew, Chem. (Int. Edn.) 2, 175-183. Karlson, P. (1974). Mode of action of ecdysones. In “Invertebrate Endocrinology and Hormonal Heterophylly” (Ed. W. J. Burdette), pp. 43-54. Springer, New York. Karlson, P., and Schmialek, P. (1959). Isolation of N-phenethylmalonamide from shrimp. Hoppe-Seyler’s Z. physiol. Chem. 316, 83-88. Karlson, P. and Shaaya, E. (1964). Der Ecdysontitre wahrend der Insektentwicklung I. Eine Methode zur Bestimmung des Ecdysongehalts. J. Insect Physiol. 10, 79 7-804. Karlson, P., Hoffmeister, H., Hoppe, W. and Huber, R. (1963). Zur Chemie des Ecdysons. Liebigs Ann. Chem. 662, 1-20. Karlson, P., Hoffmeister, H., Hummel, H., Hocks, P. and Spiteller, G. (1965). Zur Chemie des Ecdysons VI. Reaktionen des Ecdysonmolekuls. Chem. Ber. 98, 2394-2402. Katz, M. and Lensky, Y. (1970). Gas chromatographic analysis of ecdysone. Experientia, 26, 1043. King, D. S. (1972). Metabolism of a-ecdysone and possible immediate precursors by insects. In uivo and in vitro. Gen. Comp. Endocr. Suppl. 3, 221-227. King, D. S. and Marks, E. P. (1974). The secretion and metabolism of a-ecdysone by cockroach (Leucophaea maderae) tissues in vitro. Life Sciences, 15, 147-154. King, D. S. and Siddall, J. B. (1969). Conversion of a-ecdysone t o b-ecdysone by crustaceans and insects. Nature, 221, 955-956. King, I). S., Bollenbacher, W. E., Borst, D. W., Vedeckis, W. V., O’Connor, J. D., Ittycheriah, P. I. and Gilbert, L. I. (1974). The secretion of a-ecdysone by the
60
E. D A V I D MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
prothoracic glands of Manduca sexta in vitro. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 71,
793-796. Kirkland, J. J. and Dilks, C. H. (1973). In situ coating of supports with stationary liquids for high-performance liquid-liquid column chromatography. Analyt. Chem.
45, 1778-1781. Koolman, J., Hoffmann, J. A. and Dreyer, M. (1975). Moulting hormone in Locusta migratoria: rate of excretion during the last larval instar. Experientia, 31, 247-249. KopCc, S. (1922). Studies on the necessity of the brain for the inception of insect metamorphosis. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole, 42, 323-342. Koreeda, M., Nakanishi, K., Imai, S., Tsuchiya, T. and Wasada, N. (1969). Mass spectrometric studies of ecdysone derivatives. Mass Spectroscopy, 17, 669-680. Kruppa, R. F., Henly, R. S. and Smead, D. L. (1967).Improved gas chromatography packings with fluidized drying. Analyt. Chem. 39, 851-853. Lafont, R., Delbecque, J. P., De Hys, L., Mauchamp, B. and Pennetier, J. L. (1974). Proportion of B-ecdysone in the hemolymph of Pieris brassicae (Lepidoptera) during the nymphal stage. C.r. hebd. S 'eanc. Acad. Sci. Ser. D . 279,1911-1814. Lauer, R. C., Solomon, P. H., Nakanishi, K. and Erlanger, B. F. (1974).Antibodies to the insect moulting hormone 0-ecdysone. Experientia, 30, 560-562. Levinson, H. Z. and Shaaya, E. (1966). Occurrence of a metabolite related to pupation of the blowfly Calliphora erythrocephala. Riv. Parassitologica, 27,203-209. Lowe, M. E. and Horn, D. H. S. (1967). Bioassay of the red chromatophore concentrating hormone of the crayfish. Nature, 213,408-410. Mathews, R. G., Schwartz, R. D., Stouffer, J. E. and Pettitt, B. C. (1970). New Polyamide liquid phases for gas chromatography. J.. Chromat. Sci. 8 , 508-512. Mathews, R. G., Schwartz, R. D., Pfaffenberger, C. D., Hen-Nan-Lin, S. and Homing, E. C. (1974). Polyphenyl ether sulphones. Thermally stable polar phases for gas chromatography. J. Chromat. 99, 51-61. Miyazaki, H., Ishibashi, M., Mori, C. and Ikekawa, N. (1973). Gas phase microanalysis of zooecdysones. Analyt. Chem. 45, 1164-1168. Morgan, E. D. and Poole, C. F. (1975). Formation of pentafluorophenyl-dimethylsilyl ethers and their use in the gas chromatography of sterols. J. Chromat. 104,351-358. Morgan, E. D. and Poole, C. F. (1976). The formation of trimethylsilyl ethers of ecdysones: a reappraisal. J. Chromat. 116,333-341. Morgan, E. D. and Woodbridge, A. P. (1971).Insect moulting hormones (ecdysones). Identification as derivatives by gas chromatography. Chem. Commun. 475-476. Morgan, E. D. and Woodbridge, A. P. (1974). Mass spectrometry of insect moulting hormones: trimethylsilyl-methoxime derivatives of ecdysone and 20-hydroxyecdysone. Org. Mass Spectrom. 9, 102-110. Morgan, E. D., Woodbridge, A. P. and Ellis, P. E. (1975a). Studies on the moulting hormones of the desert locust, Schistocerca gregaria. J. Insect Physiol. 21, 979-993. Morgan, E. D., Woodbridge, A. P. and Ellis, P. E. (1975b). Isolation of moulting hormone from the desert locust, Schistocerca gregaria (Forskal). Acrida, 4,69-81. Moriyama, H., Nakanishi, K., King, D. S., Okauchi, T., Siddall, J. B. and Hafferl, W. (1970). On the origin and metabolic fate of a-ecdysone in insects. Gen. comp. Endocr. 15, 80-87. Nakanishi, K. (1971).The ecdysones. Pure and Applied Chem. 25, 167-195. Nalaanishi, K., Moriyama, H., Okauchi, T., Fujioka, S. and Koreeda, M. (1972).
ESTIMATION OF ECDYSONES
61
Biosynthesis of (Y- and P-ecdysones from cholesterol outside the prothoracic gland in Bombyx mori. Science, 176, 51-52. Nakanishi, K., Erlanger, B. F. and Lauer, R. C. (1973). Control of insect behaviour by natural products. In “New Methods Environ. Chem. Toxicol” (Ed. F. Coulston), pp. 149-52. Int. Acad. Print. Co., Tokyo. (Chem. Abs. 1975, 83, 1 0 9 6 2 3 ~ ) . Nigg, H. N., Thompson, M. J., Kaplanis, J. N., Svoboda, J. A. and Robbins, W. E. (1974). High-pressure liquid-solid chromatography of the ecdysones-insect moulting hormones. Steroids, 23, 507-516. Ohtaki, T., Milkman, R. D. and Williams, C. M. (1967). Ecdysone and ecdysone analogues: their assay on the fleshfly Sarcophaga peregrina. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 58,981-984. Ohtaki, T., Milkman, R. D. and Williams, C. M. (1968). Dynamics of ecdysone secretion and action in the fleshfly Sarcophaga peregrina. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole, 135,322-334. Poole, C. F. (1975). An investigation into the determination of ecdysones and other steroid hormones. Ph.D. Thesis, Keele University. Poole, C. F. and Morgan, E. D. (1975a). Structural requirements for the electron capturing properties of ecdysones. J. Chromatop. 115, 587-590. Poole, C. F. and Morgan, E. D. (1975b). Electron impact fragmentation of pentafluorophenyldimethylsilyl ethers of some sterols of biological importance. Org. Mass Spectrom. 10, 537-549. Poole, C. F., Morgan, E. D. and Bebbington, P. M. (1975). Analysis of ecdysones by gas chromatography using electron capture detection. J. Chromatop. 104, 172-175. Rees, H. H. (1971). Ecdysones. In “Aspects of Terpenoid Chemistry and Biochemistry” (Ed. T. W. Goodwin), pp. 181-222. Academic Press, New York and London. Rogers, W. P. (1973). Juvenile and moulting hormones from nematodes, Parasitology, 67, 105-113. Romer, F., Emmerich, H. and Nowock, J. (1974). Biosynthesis of ecdysones in isolated prothoracic glands and oenocytes of Tenebrio molitor in vitro. J. Insect Physiol. 20, 1975-1 987. Sannasi, A. and Karlson, P. (1974). Metabolism of ecdysone: phosphate and sulphate esters as conjugates of ecdysone in Calliphora vicina. 2001. Jb. Physiol. 78, 378-386. Sardini, D. and Krepinsky, J. (1974). Densitometric determination of ecdysones. Farmaco Ed. Prat. 29, 723-731. Sato, Y., Sakai, M., Imai, S. and Fujioka, S. (1968). Ecdysone activity of plantoriginated moulting hormones applied to the body surface of lepidopterous larvae. Appl, Entomol. 2001. 3, 49-51. Schooley, D. A. and Nakanishi, K. (1973). Application of high pressure liquid chromatography to the separation of insect moulting hormones. In “Modern Methods of Steroid Analysis” (Ed. E. Heftmann), pp. 37-54. Academic Press, New York and London. Schooley, D. A., Weiss, G. and Nakanishi, K. (1972). A simple and general extraction procedure for phytoecdysones based on reversed-phase adsorption chromatography. Steroids, 19, 377-383. Schmit, J. A. (1971). Applications of high-speed liquid chromatography using controlled surface porosity support. In “Modern Practice of Liquid Chromatography” (Ed. J. J. Kirkland), pp. 375-415. Wiley-Interscience, New York.
E. DAVID MORGAN AND COLIN F. POOLE
62
Siddall, J. B., Cross, A. D. and Fried, J. H. (1966).Steroids CCXCII. Synthetic studies o n insect hormones 11. The synthesis of ecdysone. A m . chem. SOC. 88, 862-877. Simpson, R. M. (1972). “The Separation of Organic Chemicals from Water”, pp. 1-26. Rohm and Haas, Philadelphia. Slama, K., Romanuk, M. and Sonn. F. (1974).Chemistry and physiology of ecdysoids. I n “Insect Hormones and Bioanalogues”, pp. 303-387. Springer, Vienna and New York. Stahl, E. (1962).“Dunnschicht-Chromatographie”, p. 51 5. Springer, Berlin. Stamm, M. D. (1958). Isolement d’hormones de mPtamorphose dans I’orthopt6re Dociostaurus maroccanus. Rev. Esp. Fisiol. 14,263-268. Takemoto, T,, Ogawa, S. and Nishimoto, N. (1967a).Constituents of Achyranthis radix 111. Structure of inokosterone. Yakugaku Zasshi, 87, 1474-1475. Takemoto, T., Ogawa, S., Nishimoto, N. and Hoffmeister, H. (1967b).Steroide mit Hautungshormon-Aktivitat aus Tieren und Pflanzen. 2. Naturf. 22b, 681-682. Takemoto, T., Ogawa, S., Nishimoto, N. and Taniguchi, S. (1967~).Constituents of Achyranthis radix IV. Isolation of the insect moulting hormones from Formosan achyranthis. Yakugaku Zasshi, 87, 1478-1480. Takemoto, T., Ogawa, S., Morita, M., Nishimoto, N., Dome, K. and Morishima, K. (1968). Studies on the constituents of Achyranthis radix VI. Determination of insect moulting hormones. Yakugaku Zasshi, 88, 39-43. Thompson, M. J., Kaplanis, J. N., Robbins, W. E., Dutky, S. R. andNigg, H. N. (1974). 3-Epi-20-hydroxyecdysone from meconium of the tobacco hornworm. Steroids, 24,
i.
3 59-366. Thompson, M. J., Kaplanis, J. N., Robbins, W. E. and Yamamoto, R. T. (1967). 20,26-Dihydroxyecdysone, a new steroid with moulting hormone activity from the tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta. Chem. Commun. 650-653. Thompson, M. J., Robbins, W. E., Kaplanis, J. N., Cohen, C. F. and Lancaster, S. M. (1970). Synthesis of analogues of a-ecdysone. A simplified synthesis of 2/3,3/3,1&trihydroxy-7-en-6-one-5/3-steroids. Steroids, 16,85-104. Thomson, J. A. (1974). Standardization of dipteran bioassay for moulting hormones. In “Invertebrate Endocrinology and Hormonal Heterophylly” (Ed. W. J. Burdette), pp. 121-129.Springer, New York. Thomson, J. A,, Imray, F. P. and Horn, D. H. S. (1970). An improved calliphora bioassay for insect moulting hormones. Aust. J. exp. Biol. med. Sci. 48,321-328. Vedeckis, W. V., Bollenbacher, W. E. and Gilbert, L. I. (1974).Cyclic AMP as a possible mediator of prothoracic gland activation. 2001.Jb. Physiol. 78, 440-448. Wigglesworth, V. B. (1934). Factors controlling moulting and “metamorphosis” in an insect. Nature, 133, 725-726. Willig, A. and Keller, R. (1973). Moulting hormone content, cuticle growth and gastrolith growth in the moult cycle of the crayfish Orconectes Eimosus. J. Comp. Physiol, 86, 377-388. Woodbridge, A. P. (1971). Studies of the moulting hormones of the desert locust, Schistocerca gregaria. Ph.D. Thesis, Keele University. Zatsny, I. L., Gorovits, M. B., Rashkes, Ya. V. and Abubakirov, N. K. (1975).Phytoecdysonesof Serratula. 111. Mass spectrometric study of ecdysterone and viticosterone E acetates and acetonides. Khirn. Prir. Soedin. 11, 155-158.
T h e Cells of t h e Insect Neurosecretory System: Constancy, Variability, and t h e Concept o f t h e Unique Identifiable Neuron Hugh Fraser Rowell University of California, Berkeley, California, USA
.
1 Introduction 63 65 2 The anatomy of the insect neurosecretory system 65 2.1 Recognition of neurosecretory cells . 2.2 Differences between “specific” staining techniques for neurosecretory 67 . cells with light microscopy . 2.3 General results of morphological studies of neurosecretory cells 70 71 2.4 The distribution of neurosecretory ceIIs in insects 75 2.5 Diversity of neurosecretory cell complement in insects . 3 Implications of the identifiable cell concept for the insect neurosecretory 99 system. . 3.1 Anatomically significant differences between neurosecretory cells and 99 other neurons 3.2 Constancy, uniqueness, and reduplication in neurosecretory cells 100 106 4 Available techniques, research strategy, and some examples . 106 4.1 Filling of neurons with dye from severed nerve stumps . 4.2 Filling of neurons with dye through an intracellular micropipette electrode 107 107 4.3 Intensification of cobalt staining by silver precipitation . 110 4.4 Electrophysiological recording and intracellular current injection 111 Acknowledgements Abbreviations . 112 References 112
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
7 Introduction Invertebrate neurophysiology has been revolutionized in recent years by the general application of the concept of the unique identifiable neuron. Broadly stated, this concept runs as follows. In many invertebrate taxa, 63
64
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
most of the nervous system is comprised of neurons each of which has a i:li,iracteristic morphology, connectivity and function. Both the individual ni’urones and the neuronal circuits they form are effectively identical in di 1 ferent conspecific individuals. The number of neurones is fixed, within narrow limits of variation. The system is “hard-wired”, there appears t o t:sist no large pool of neurons whose connectivity is essentially plastic and which potentially show large differences between individuals as a consec pence of environmental experience. Within the central nervous system as a whole, there is very little “redundancy”, in the sense of duplication of u i i its with effectively identical function, other than that inherent in the s q n e n t a l organization of the body or in spatially organized sensory arrays such as the retina. Nervous organization of this sort is characteristic of taxa with determined growth, little plasticity of adult form, short lives, and a high degree of neural complexity combined with relatively small numbers of neurons in t h c CNS. It is most obvious in the Annelida, Arthropoda, the gastropod Mollusca, and in the Nematoda and other askhelminth groups. It is not yet dcar whether the same principles apply t o taxa with nervous systems diaracterized by very numerous cells and plastic behaviour (v-rtebrates and ce1)halopod molluscs) or with less complex nervous systems or great mor111 lological plasticity (such as echinoderms, or coelenterates). It is, however, n o t excluded that the concept of the unique identifiable neuron is applicable in these cases too; it is merely the technical difficG!tv of the proof which has discouraged investigation. ‘The foundations of the concept were laid by the early invertebrate ~ic.uroanatomistssuch as Retzius on the basis of methylene blue staining. Its rec.ent wide acceptance has come from the development of newer techiiiques: a. 1)evelopment of markers suitable for intracellular labelling of cells in both light microscopy (LM) and electron microscopy (EM). h. Axonal iontophoresis or diffusion of these markers into cells via the cut axon. c. Anatomical identification of recorded cells by injection of marker through the intracellular recording electrode. d. The ability to return repeatedly t o homologous neurons in different individual animals, and t o check the identity both by physiological characterization and by injected marker. Neuronal circuit analysis, cellular neuronal function, and genetic studies of neuronal morphology and function are now dominated by those invertebrate preparations t o which the concept of the unique identifiable neuron is currently most applicable.
NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
65
This paper seeks t o examine the applicability of the concept t o the insect neurosecretory system, and t o define areas and preparations which seem suitable for analysis by the new techniques. The physiology of the insect neurosecretory system is a very active field, and one frequently reviewed (most recently by Goldsworthy and Mordue, 1974, and by Maddrell, 1975). I will not attempt t o deal with this aspect, and have confined myself to anatomical data. I deal with anatomical identification of neurosecretory cells (NSCs), and then with their distribution in the insects. I have attempted to ascertain whether their numbers are relatively constant between individuals, in which taxa the numbers of NSCs are large or small, and where cells suitable for electrophysiological techniques are likely to be found. In the second part of the paper, I present the biological implications of the concept of the unique identifiable neuron for insect neurosecretion, and give some indication of the sorts of experiments potentially feasible, with a few recent examples.
2 The anatomy of the insect neurosecretory system
2.1
RECOGNITION OF NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
Neurosecretory areas are often initially localized by physiological work involving lesion or ligature, and in some cases the cells themselves are visible upon inspection of the living tissue, a blue coloration deriving from their vesicular contents by the Tyndall effect. In general, however, NSCs are recognized from histological preparations. There are obvious dangers in attributing neurosecretory function t o a neuron on purely morphological grounds, a point stressed for many years by Scharrer and by Bern (e.g. 1966), but experience t o date suggests that the correlation is in fact a good one. Most neurones with NSC morphology do indeed turn out t o differ from regular neurons in their functioning. As the boundary between the two types is arbitrary, there are always borderline cases, and these are especially obvious in the case of direct neurosecretory innervation, as discussed on p. 74, or in the development of neurosecretory facies in injured and regenerating regular neurons (Boulton and Rowell, 1969; Milburn, personal communication). I will in general take the position that the morphological identification of NSCs has some validity, and discuss the available data accordingly. Three distinct types o f histological display of NSCs can be recognized, using respectively (a) general purpose LM staining, (b) “specific” LM staining for NS material and (c) EM techniques. a. General purpose LM stains The original descriptions of NSCs in insects were made using orthodox general stains. Some of these fortuitously
66
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
inc luded dyes with a special affinity for neurosecretory material, such as tlic. fuchsin component of both Masson’s and Mallory’s triple stains, and tliiis presage the use of “specific” stains. The majority of accounts were, hoivever, based not on specific dye affinity but on the structural correlates of ,ecrction, and especially on the presence of numerous “granules” visible in i.he cytoplasm of soma and sometimes axon. These granules have sullsequently proven to represent aggregates of submicroscopic membraneboiind vesicles or other organelles such as lysosomes, and the aggregation is oft(m a fixation artifact (Bloch et al., 1966; Bern, 1966). b. *‘Specific” LM staining f o r NSCs Modern NSC cytology dates from the ap1)lication by Bargmann (1949) of two of Gomori’s staining procedureschi ome alum-haematoxylin phloxine and aldehyde fuchsin. These were the fir\t of many which rely on a special affinity of a dye for some compon,ent o f the NSC. The component in question is almost certainly not the h o i mone itself, but is possibly the carrier protein associated with it (see e.p. Schreiner, 1966). They are here referred t o as “specific” stains, the q u ( Itation marks stressing that their specificity is actually for certain chl.mica1 groups which have only a statistical probability of association wiih NSCs. They were first applied t o insects in the early fifties by rl’hl)msen, Scharrer, Nayar, Gabe and their co-workers. A section on the ch.rracteristics of the various techniques is given below, but basically the abicling dilemma is that no dye stains all NSCs as opposed to all other netirons. As the functional distinction between the two is of degree rather tli;in of kind, this is t o be expected. Consequently, the more chemically pr‘.cise the staining reaction the smaller the number of NSCs it reveals, and coiiversely the number of NSCs discovered is usually directly related t o the nuiiiber of staining methods utilized in the study. With any one dye, there a x usually differences between NSCs in the distribution of dye within the cc:ll, and the apparent granule size is sometimes the main distinguishing ch.iracteristic (e.g. in Lampyris, Coeloptera: Naisse, 1966a). Modern LM claysifications typically use both stain affinity and intracellular distribut ion of stain as criteria.
c. f:M techniques The most gratifying aspect of the EM examination of NS(k was to find that virtually wherever neurosecretory function had been postulated on the basis of LM staining, the cells did in fact contain a plaiisible facies of endoplasmic reticulum, ribosomes, vesicles, etc., when vielved by EM. Additionally, some cells have been discovered which have thc appearance of NSCs by EM, but which do not stain with any of the uxu.il LM procedures (Sandifer and Tombes, 1972; Chalaye, 1974a); it is no1 known how common such cells are. The morphological classification oI)i,iined from EM profiles, based on size, shape, electron density and
N EUROSECR ETO RY CELLS
67
number of vesicles, is as diverse as that obtained from LM procedures (up to 1 0 categories can be recognized by either means) and in at least some cases the two classifications conflict. That is, for example, a population of NSCs which appears homogenous after staining for LM may show a variety of vesicle types under EM (e.g. Maddrell, 1967; Unnithan et aE., 1971; Geldiay and Edwards, 1973; Musko and Novak, 1973) or vice versa (Schooneveld, 1974a). Many attempts have been made to correlate LM and EM pictures of the same populations (Ramade, 1966; Block et al., 1966; Bassurmanova and Panov, 1967; Brady and Maddrell, 1967; Cassier and Fain-Maurel, 1970; Smalley, 1970; Geldiay and Edwards, 1973; Chalaye, 1974a; Schoonveld, 1974b), but no study has been made with truly identified cells or in which the extent of correlation was the main object of the investigation. (See Note added in proof, p. 123.)
2.2
DIFFERENCES BETWEEN “SPECIFIC” STAINING TECHNIQUES FOR NEUROSECRETORY CELLS WITH LIGHT MICROSCOPY
As mentioned in the preceding section, the LM staining techniques used to demonstrate NSCs vary between two extremes. At one extreme, there are techniques which apparently stain all NSCs, but tend to stain regular neurons as well; the distinction between the two becomes subjective and tenuous, and requires much experience for consistency. The best example of such a technique is azan. At the other extreme are histochemical stains which react with a precisely defined chemical substrate, and the techniques employ chemical pretreatment to turn neurosecretory products or carrier proteins into these reactive groups. An example is the use of Red Sulfhydryl Reagent which stains sulfhydryl or disulphide groups. Type A NSCs (as defined below) are rich in cystine and cysteine; after oxidation sulphydryl and disulphide groups are formed, which appear t o be the basis for the selectivity of several basic dyes for these cells (see Schreiner, 1966, and Table 1).There are many undoubted neurosecretory cells which do not stain at all with these stains, and the same pretreatment applied t o type C and some type B cells, for instance, results in predominantly pyrrhol and indol radicals (Baudry and Baehr, 1970; Raabe and Monjo, 1970). The classification of insect NSCs by their staining properties has been the subject of much controversy. Most authors have found it convenient t o recognize, for descriptive purposes at least, four broad classes, as follows.
1. Cells staining red with the azocarmine component of azan; staining dark blue or black with chrome alum haematoxylin (CH), sometimes referred to as “Gomori positive” in the older papers; staining heavily in shades of purple with paraldehyde fuchsin (PF). These cells correspond to the type A cells of Nayar (1955).
68
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
2. Cells staining blue with the aniline blue component of azan; not stained by CH but stained shades of red with phloxin’e (P); stained weakly or not at all by PF, but often staining with one of the counterstains used with this technique, such as picroindigocarmine (PIC) or Halmi’s mixture (HMChromotrope 2R, orange G, light green, phosphotungstic acid). These cells are always more capricious and difficult t o demonstrate than A cells, and correspond t o Nayar’s (1955) type B cells. 3. Cells stained red in azan, but not stained by either CHP nor b y PF or its counterstains. These cells are called type C b y Raabe (1965, 1967, and subsequent works) and the numerous subsequent French workers who have made a study of their occurrence. 4. Finally, by exclusion, one can define a heterogeneous category comprising cells which stain differently from any of the above. They are less often described, or investigated, than the others. Classifications based on staining affinities have been endlessly proposed, subdivided, criticized, modified and acclaimed. Much of the discussion appears t o be generated by: a. A natural tendency to subdivide. b. An apparent belief that classifications should be both all embracing and also correspond t o real biological distinctions between NSCs or their products. This belief is surely unjustifiable; it is no criticism of an arbitrary morphological classification t o prove that there are intermediates (e.g. cells which stain. heavily with PF but also stain with phloxine, as described by Fletcher (1969)). All that matters is whether the diagnostic characters are stable, repeatable, and precisely definable. c. Unfamiliarity with the material used by other workers, leading t o a reluctance to use the same terminology as was applied originally t o a different species, in case it proves t o be different.
d. A simple failure t o follow precedent in nomenclature; thus the appellation “C cell” has been applied by successive workers t o distinct populations of cells t o the point where, in the absence of further description, it now means only “not A or B”. The result of all this is semantic chaos. It is impossible to compare the results of two workers without knowing not only the details of their histological procedure, but also which school (if any) of nomenclature they follow. Occasional noble attempts to rationalize the literature (e.g. Delphin, 1965) have not led to subsequent improvement. For the purposes of this section, I will use the terms A, B, and C cells in the senses indicated above, and make no value judgement. There is some histochemical evidence that the proteins elaborated by these 3 types of cells show real differences (Raabe and Monjo, 1970; Prentb, 1972).
N E U ROSECR ETORY CELLS
69
To assess the comprehensiveness of a reported investigation, it is essential to know what degree of specificity each of the “specific” staining techniques possesses. The more important facts are presented in Table 1. Note that the names refer not t o dyes but t o entire histological processes, including fixation. The text hereafter will use the abbreviations given in Table 1. This Table shows that the selection of stains from the different categories is important in making a survey of the NSCs of a nervous system. It is common to find a worker using several different stains but restricting TABLE 1 Summary of the commonest “specific” light microscope techniques for neurosecretory cells Abbreviation
Full name
i. Basic dyes with affinity f o r type A NSCs, arranged in decreasing order of selectivity RSR Red suphydryl reagent PAVB Performic acid/victoria blue AB Alcian blue Paraldehyde fuchsin, aldehyde fuchsin. The former has largely replaced PF, AF the latter. CH Chrome alum haematoxylin Paraldehyde thionin. Similar in effect to paraldehyde fuchsin, but said to PTh respond better to type B material. ii. Acid dyes with affinity f o r type B cells P Phloxine PIC Picroindigocarmine iii. Combination techniques designed to display simultaneously and differentiate between A - and 13-type cells CHP Chrome alum haematoxylin/phloxine ABP Alcian blue/phloxine PF/HM Paraldehyde fuchsin, counterstained with Halmi’s mixture (chromotrope 2R, orange G, light green, phosphotungstic acid) PF/PIC Paraldehyde fuchsin, counterstained with picroindigocarmine FTh/NY Paraldehyde thionin, counterstained with naphthol yellow iv. Wide range techniques which demonstrate a variety of NSCs, but rarely provide critical information differentiating between them. Often used to stain NSCs not stained by any of the above methods Az Azan (note that type C material, as defined in the text, can only be demonstrated by use of both azan and other techniques simultaneously) M Mallory’s triple stain M3C Masson trichrome stain PSI Pseudoisocyanin (this is a fluorescence microscopy technique)
70
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
them in such a way as t o stain oniy one of the major cell types. It is especially common that only stains for A’cells, which are readily demonstrated, are used. For this reason, the subsequent Tables, which present the results of surveys of cell numbers, include information about the staining techniques used, in order that results which are likely t o be deficient in one or more cell types can be identified. For example, an investigation that did not use Azan is not likely t o have considered C cells, which seem t o be the commonest NSCs of the ventral nerve cord (VNC) and the tritocerebrum.
2.3
GENERAL RESULTS OF MORPHOLOGICAL STUDIES OF NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
Apart from a variety of observations of relevance t o the problems of cellular secretion per se, at least three general facts of importance have emerged from the anatomical work on insect NSCs. i. The stainability of particular cells or populations of cells varies with time. To what extent this correlates with any “secretory cycle”, and whether intense staining reflects anything about the hormonal content of the cell, is debatable. It is, however, certain that the same cells stain more readily at some times than others, and may be quite invisible t o a “specific” stain at some times. Variation may be cyclical, with either a diurnal o r longer (e.g. stadial) periodicity, or merely show a long-term change with age; examples can be found in Arvy and Gabe (1952, 1953), Khan and Fraser (1962), Huignard (1964), Panov (1965), Brady (1967), Burgess (1971), Steele and Harmsen (1971), Cymborowski (1973) and Kono
(1975). ii. The stainability of the NSC is not necessarily constant throughout its length. With some cells “granules” (actually clumps of submicroscopic membrane-limited vesicles) can be stained in the somatic cytoplasm and out along the axon t o the release point. This is characteristic of A-type cells of the medial NSCs of the pars intercerebralis. In other cells, undoubtedly neurosecretory, no “ganules” are ever seen in the axon by light microscopy, and it is presumed that the secretion is transported for release in a nonstainable form (e.g. in the lateral NSCs of the pars of Orthoptera). Other cases have been reported where the dye affinity of cytoplasm or of granules changes as one nears the morphological release point, again suggesting a chemical change in hormone, carrier protein, membrane, or some other constituent of the cell (Gabe, 1972). iii. Broadly similar NSCs (as described by EM or LM practices) are found in widely different insects, and there is not an infinite range of response t o the microscopical methods. As insects can be expected t o show at least marked similarity, if not identity, in their hormones and carrier proteins, this result
N EU ROSEC R ETO R Y CELLS
71
makes one hopeful that the morphological classifications of NSCs may in fact have some relevance ‘to their biological diversity-e.g. differently staining cells may indeed secrete hormones, and possibly even vice versa.
2.4
THE DISTRIBUTION OF NEUROSECRETORY CELLS IN INSECTS
The physiological and anatomical techniques described above have led t o the description of NSC somata in the following parts of the body. a.
BRAIN
Pro tocerebrum i. Lateral cells of pars intercerebralis. ii. Median cells of pars intercerebralis. These two groups are the source of the NSC axons of the nervi corporis cardiaci I and 11, where these exist as separate nerves (Hanstrom, 1940; Cazal, 1948; Williams, 1948). In at least 2 insects with separate NCC I and 11, the “medial” cells contribute axons t o both nerves (Perzplaneta,Willey, 1961: Leptinotarsu, Schooneveld, 1974b). The median and lateral groups are well separated in some orders (e.g. the Orthoptera) but much less so in the Oligoneoptera as a whole. Usually the lateral cells are defined by exclusion of the medials, and both are probably heterogeneous categories. Optic lobe
NSCs have been described from the optic lobe of neuropterans (Arvy, 1956), saturniid moths (Mitsuhashi, 1962), calliphorid flies (Thomsen, 1965) and cockroaches (Beatty, 1971), and may be of more general occurrence. Ocellar nerue Median NSCs are often associated with the base of the ocellar nerve (e.g. in grasshoppers-Girardie and Girardie, 1972), but in Surcophugu (Diptera) and Gryllus (Orthoptera) NSC somata are found along the length of the nerve (Schlein, 1972; Loher, personal communication). The ocellar “nerve” is really an extension of the brain, containing both cell bodies and synaptic neuropil (C. Goodman, unpublished observations) so this observation is less remarkable morphologically than it at first appears. D&to cerebrum
At least some of these NCSs are the origin of the axons contained in the NCC IV (Brousse-Gaury, 1967).
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
72
rritocerebrum .Qt least some of these cell bodies are the origin of the axons of the NCC 111 (Pflugfelder, 1936, Dupont-Raabe, 1956; Willey, 1961; Raabe, 1965a, b). b. RETROCEREBRAL COMPLEX
Corpus cardiacum (CC) The essential element of the CC is the intrinsic glandular cells and their innervating neurons, derived at least largely from the brain. In many, though not all, insects the CC additionally contains a more or less complex iieurohaemal organ derived from the cerebral NSCs (above). It is not clear how many of the intrinsic secretory cells of the CC are t o be regarded as neurons, nor indeed what would be the distinguishing criteria for NSC as opposed t o some other forms of parenchymatous secretory cell of ectotlermal origin. Some authors assume without question that CC intrinsic cells Lither are or are not NSCs, and those that debate the question appear t o make the attribution of NSC on the basis of either an axon-like process, or a propagated action potential (e.g. Normann, 1975; Cazal et al., 1971). Neither of these features, however, is a necessary or sufficient definition of
c'. STOMATOGASTRIC GANGLIA
In most of the stomatogastric ganglia examined, the neurosecretory axons present derive from NSCs located in the brain or the corpus cardiacum. Jwo NSCs are found in the frontal ganglion of sphingid and saturniid inoths (Bounhiol et at., 1953; Borg et at., 1973). The hypocerebral ganglion o f Aedes (Diptera, Culicidae) was reported t o contain a few NSCs (Clements, 1956) but this has not been confirmed (Burgess and Rempel, 1966). Secretory cells, possibly not neural, occur in the hypocerebral ganglion of Oncopeltus (Hemiptera, Lygeidae) according t o Unnithan et al. (1971).
ti.
SUBOESOPHAGEAL GANGLION, GANGLIA OF THE VENTRAL NERVE CORD
NSCs have been demonstrated in the SOG and VNC of all insects iiivestigated, since they were first described by Day (1940) and Scharrer
N EU ROSEC R ETO R Y CELLS
73
(1941) from sphingids and blattids respectively. Most of them remain without clear functional attribution, though in different individual animals humoral factors controlling diapause, diuresis and antidiuresis, chromatophores, and luminescent organs have been associated with the ganglia. Most of the NSCs of the VNC are associated with the medial neurohaemal organs (see below), and they show much segmental replication. In some groups the somata of the NSCs are found within the NHOs, rather than in the ganglia. e.
EXTRAGANGLIONIC NSCS
In Phasmida and Diptera (Finlayson and Osborne, 1968) NSCs are found outside the ganglia, associated with segmental abdominal nerves. Possibly they are derived from sensory neurones. Fourteen neurosecretory somata are also found in the thorax of M y z u s (Aphidae) and their axons are part of the nerves which radiate from the CC. The cell bodies are located on the aorta, and in the thoracic musculature and tracheal system (Bowers and Johnson, 1966). Their homologies are obscure, but by analogy with the structural variety associated with the median neurohaemal organs (Raabe et al., 1974) they may be part of the corpus cardiacum. Apart from the soma position, and often the fine structure of the vesicles, remarkably little anatomical information is available about these cells. With few exceptions (Adiyodi and Bern, 1968; Highnam and West, 1971; Mason, 1973; Schoonveld, 1974b) nothing is known of any dendritic structures. Transport of neurosecretory material down the axons has been demonstrated frequently; release appears to be by exocytosis, to be associated with depolarization of the membrane, and t o be dependent on Caz+ influx (e.g. Normann, 1973, 1974) in the same way as in vertebrate chrom affin cells or in the release of transmitter substance from normal neurones. In an aphid and a chrysomelid beetle (Johnson, 1963; Schoonveld, 1974b) individual NSCs give rise t o more than one major axon, with different destinations, and this has been suggested for several other insects too. Golgi or dye injection preparations would in general be required t o substantiate this sort of anatomical claim. After transection o f the axon, the amount of stainable material in the cell proximal t o the cut increases (either b y accumulation of secretion, or as a component of the injury response) and dendritic structures then sometimes become apparent which were not previously visible (Schoonveld, 1974b). The axons of NSCs terminate in a great variety of ways. In some cases they form well-defined neurohaemal organs (NHOs). Sometimes these are associated with the aorta, especially in the Hemiptera (Junqua, 1956; Seshan and Ittycheriah, 1966, Dogra, 1967a, b; Srivastavah and Dogra, 1969; Furtago, 1971; Unnithan et al., 1971, who also give a review) but
74
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
.ilso in other groups (e.g. Normann, 1965). More commonly, however, VHOs occur at the surface of a ganglion or nerve, where they are separated from the haemolymph only by the neural lamella. Such NHOs are reported from the. CC of many insects, the CA (Kind, 1965; Tombes and Smith, 1970), the NCA I1 of crickets (Huignard, 1964; Awasthi, 1968; Weber and Gaude, 1971), the brain of Orth‘optera (Geldiay, 1973; Geldiay and Edwards, 1973) and possibly of moths (Kobayashi, 1957), the frontal connectives (Ganagarajah, 1965), the medial nerves of all orders of insects (Ra‘ibe, 1965; Brady and Maddrell, 1967; recently reviewed by Thomas and Raabe, 1974, and by Raabe et al., 1974), the ganglia of the VNC (Grillot, 1970a) and the abdominal nerves of Hemiptera (Maddrell, 19.66a). In dddition to those associated with NHOs, some NSCs appear t o innervate their target directly, or at least t o end in a very restricted space. Direct neurosecretory innervation of the gut (Willey, 1962; Johnson and BoGers, 1963; Fletcher, 1969), heart (sources reviewed by Miller and Rees, 1973), epidermis (Maddrell, 1965), skeletal muscle (Willey, 1962; Johnson and Bowers, 1963; Osborne et al., 1971), luminescent organ (Smith, 1963), pro thoracic or homologous gland (Normann, 1965; Hintze-Podufal, 1970; Thomas and Raabe, 1974) and salivary gland (Bowers and Johnson, 1966) have been reported; the neurosecretory innervation of the CA may be another similar instance. Some of these examples may be unique to a particular group of insects, and in some, at least, the evidence for the innervation being neurosecretory is not only purely morphological, but is even contradicted by the available physiological evidence. For example, Miller and Usherwood (19 71) recorded normal postsynaptic potentials from heart muscles in response t o stimulation of allegedly neurosecretory axons. If these units cannot be shown to have any additional function, which is not merely the transient alteration of subsynaptic membrane permeability to ions (the functional definition of a transmitter substance) there would be a strong case for considering them simply as motor neurons with an unusual ultrastructural morphology. If this interpretation is general, it may be that many of the apparently neurosecretory units associated with the heart and gut in insects are actually motor neurons. Brown (personal communication and 1976) has described the isolation from cockroaches of a pentapeptide which causes the contraction of gut muscle when iontophoresed in pharmacological quantity onto synaptic drc,ts. A neuron secreting a peptide transmitter substance would presumably have a morphology like that of an orthodox NSC. Anwyl and Finlayson (1974) have proposed that the same neurons function alternately as motor neurons and as NSCs, utilizing at least two different secretory products. A further blurring of the division between neurosecretory cell and a cell secreting “neurohumors” in the sense of Scharrer (1969) is seen
NEUROSEC R ETO RY CELLS
75
in the case of the neurons which appear t o bring about the plasticization of the cuticle in Rhodnius (Maddrell, 1965). The active agent appears to be 5-hydroxtryptamine (Reynolds, 1974) which is normally secreted from neurons which lack the ultrastructural morphology of a NSC. Finally, there are neurosecretory axons which appear to end in the ganglionic neuropil without innervating peripheral effector organs (e.g. the NSCs which run from the brain to the terminal abdominal ganglion in culicids (Fuller, 1960; Burgess, 1973) or from the SOG to the thoracic ganglia in acridids (Delphin, 1975; Chalaye, 1967)). Further studies are required t o determine the function and release point of these units. They may affect directly the ganglionic neurons, and a number of neurotropic factors appear t o be involved in the hormonaIly controlled release of motor activity (Truman and Riddiford, 1974a).
2.5
DIVERSITY OF NEUROSECRETORY CELL COMPLEMENT IN INSECTS
2.5.1 How conservative are the insects? The universality of the major NSC groups (e.g. of the pars intercerebralis, the corpus cardiacum, etc.) shows that at least some neurosecretory features are the same throughout the insects. To assess conservation in evolution one obviously requires knowledge of physiology, as well as anatomy. In theory, homologous groups of NSCs in different animals could have totally different products, or different functions even if they elaborated chemically identical products. In most cases, unfortunately, this physiological knowledge is not yet available. One would expect that the basic endocrine mechanism would be fairly stable within the insects, but that there would also be wide variation in the use of hormonal mechanisms for specific adaptations. Panov (1964) reviewing the distribution of type A NSCs in the VNC of various Orthoptera, has already advanced the concepts of “principal” cells, found in most taxa, and “additional” cells, peculiar to a few; together these form a statement in anatomical terms of the same hypothesis. As insects are arguably the most diverse and ecologically wide-ranging of all organisms, and as the function of the neuroendocrine system is broadly to translate environmental signals into hormonal action, one might expect to see an unparalleled radiation of NSC function within the insects. In specific cases, where both anatomical and physiological information is available, examples of both these trends (conservation and adaptive radiation) can be cited. Thus, all known insects appear t o utilize prothoraco tropic hormone (PTTH) to initiate ecdysone synthesis during growth and moulting, and the PTTH of different insects are mutually effective, suggesting closely similar chemical structures. Conversely, some very indi-
76
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
vidual neurosecretory functions are known. Only the mosquito Aedes is known t o involve a protocerebral hormone i n ' t h e later stages of vitellogenesis, and in other insects juvenile hormone alone suffices. Similarly, only in lampyrids (Coleoptera) has a gonadotropic hormone of brain origin been demonstrated; in these animals, sex at the phenotypic level is determined by cerebral neurosecretion (Naisse, 1966b, 1969). Neurosecretory control of chromatophores has been shown in phasmids (Dupont-Raabe, 1957) and in an odonatan (Veron, 1973). In the majority of cases, however, one lacks physiological knowledge of this sort, and further comparison must at present be derived from comparative anatomical data. The most basic information is the number and groupings of NSCs in the different taxa of insects. This information is summarized in Tables 2-4, which also contain the references. Good numerical data have become common only recently, and there appears t o have been no previous general review of the quantitative studies. Despite this, a number of qualitative generalizations have become current. Two of the most pervasive, for example, are that the more primitive insects have larger numbers of smaller NSCs than the more evolved, and that larvae have fewer NSCs than do adult insects. In the text that follows, these generalizations and others are examined in the light of the available data. 2.5.2 Variation between taxa: the protocerebral medial and lateral NSCs Table 2 presents most of the available information about the numbers of somata in the most intensively researched groups of NSCs, the median and lateral protocerebral groups of adult insects. Much is known of the axonal projections of these cells in the brain and retrocerebral complex, and something of their functions, and the evidence available suggests that they are functionally homologous throughout the Pterygota. They should therefore provide appropriate material t o assess conservancy of structure, or t o display any major anatomical trends in evolution. The figures given must be assessed for probable completeness in the light of the staining procedure used and Table 1. The following points emerge from the Table: i. Palaeoptera Unfortunately, no quantitative data are available for either of the existing orders. It seems that they have fairly numerous medial and lateral cells, probably more than 2 x 50 medial cells and 2 x 15 lateral cells. The true figures could be much higher.
ii. Polyneoptera This group shows a huge range in numbers of median NSCs, over nearly 2 orders of magnitude. The earwig Anisolabis has remarkably few cells, fewer than most moths or bugs. The cockroach and the primitive grylloblattid have medium numbers of cells (2 x 50-70) whereas the Orthoptera (grasshoppers, crickets and katydids) have uniquely
TABLE 2 Estimates of numbers of median and lateral protocerebral NSCs in the adults of various insects Taxonomic division
Median NSCs
Lateral NSCs
Technique
Reference
n
n rn
1. Palaeoptera
Ephemeroptera Ephemera Ecdyonurus Odonata S y mpetrum, A esc hna Caloptery x, Agrion Aeschna 2. Polyneoptera
I
Isoptera Embioptera Zor apt era Grylloblattodea Schizodactylus Orthoptera (Grylloidea) Gryllotalpa Acheta
(Acridoidea) Locusta
4
“Numerous”
2 x >25*
2x7* 2 x 3*
“Identical with Ephemeroptera” “Very numerous” 2 x >30* 2 x >40*
Present
“Numerous”
Present
Az, CHP, PF
Cazal (1948) ANY and Gabe (1953) Cazal (1948)
Present Az, Fuchsin, Methyl Green, CHP PSI
Arvy and Gabe (1952) Sterba and Hoheisel (1964) Gabe (1966)
2 x 66
2x6
CHP, PF
Khattar (1968)
2 x 300+
Not seen 2 x 12-16 Present No information
PAVB PF/PIC CHP, PF CHP, PF, PAVB Methylene blue, EM Az, AB, PF, PAVB,
Dogra (1967a) Gaude and Weber (1966) Huignard (1964) Geldiay and Edwards (1972) Girardie (1973)
Very numerous” 2 x 400 No information
2 x 8-12
per formic-acid-Schiff,
EM
5 < rn r r v)
U
a3
TABLE 2-conlinued Taxonomic division
Median NSCs
Lateral NSCs
Schistocerca
2 x c. 1000 2 x c. 400
2 x 10
2 x 604
Anacridium
“Numerous”
Melano pus
2 x 400+
2 x 12
Technique CHP, PF Cobalt Iontophoresis EM of NCC I
Reference Highnam (1961) Mason (1973)
PF, PAVB
Rowell and Mason (unpublished) Girardie and Granier
PAVB. CHP
Dogra and Ewen (1970)
PF, silver impregnation
Willey (1961)
(1973)
Dictyoptera Periplaneta “Numerous” 2 X 45-50 2xc.50
Phasmida Cliturnnus Carausius, Clitu mnus Bacillus, Eurycnema
Not seen 2 x 40, (;;h;r only
Not seen Not seen
CHP, PF CHP, PF
I
C 2 x >40* “Numerous”
Present 2 X 5-6
Az, CHP, M3C
Cazal(l948) Dupont-Raabe (1951 1956,1957)
2 x >40*
CHP
“Un g a n d nombre” Plecoptera ISOPerla
Fiiller (1960) Pipa (1962 and personal communication)
2 x >30*
Present
CHP
Herlant-Meewis and Paquet (1956) Arvy and Gabe (1954)
t)
I n I]
Rrn
R R
0 r r
D errnaptera Forficu la, Lab idu la Anisolabis
3. Paraneoptera Mallophaga Psocoptera Thysanura Anoplura Hemiptera (Gymnocerata) Reduviidae
i
z
“Numerous” 2 x 10-20
CHP, AF, M
Cazal (1948) Ozeki (1958)
m C
a
am 0
a rn
-I
0
< Present
Gabe (1966)
Present
0
rn r r v)
2 x 20* 2x65
----- -- --- 2 Adelphocoris Lygeidae Oncopeltus Stilbocoris Pyrrhocoridae Iphita Dysdercus Pentatomidae Nerara Scutellera
Present Not positively identifiedperhaps 2 x 2
No information 2 x 19-20
CHP, Az 32 total _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ - - - _ PF/HM
Wigglesworth (1940) Baehr (1968) Steel and Harmsen (1971)
2 x 12
2x3
PF, CHP, PAVB
Ewen (1962)
2x7 2 x 14-16
2x43 2x2
PF, CHP PF, PAVB, CHP, Az
Johansson (1957,1958) Furtado (1971)
2 x 16 2 x 9-10
2 x 3-4 2 X 4-6
CHP, PF PF, PAVB, PATh
Nayar (1955) Dogra (1967)
2 x 5+ 2 x 8-9+
No information PF, PAVB Not seen PF, PAVB, AF
Awasthi (1 969) Srivastava and D o p a (1969)
03 0
TARLE 2-continued Taxonomic division (Cryptocerata) Belostomatidae Belostoma Nepidae Ranatra Homoptera (Cicadoidea) Tettigia
(Aphoidea) Aphis Drepano sip hu m
Median NSCs
Lateral NSCs
2 x 8-10+
Not seen
PF, PAVB
Dogra (1969)
2 x 9-10+
2 x 3-4
PF, PAVB
Dopa (1967)
Present
Present, though not laterally situated
2 x 4-6 2 x 4-6
2x2
No information
Present
Technique
Reference
Cazal (1948)
Az, CHP, Pf
Johnson (1963)
4. Oligoneoptera (Panorpoid complex) Siphonaptera; Trichoptera: Mecoptera; Panorpa Neoptera: Euroleon
Cazal (1948)
I C GI
r n
“Numerous” 2 x >14*
Present
2 x >20*
2 x >5*
Cazal (1948) PF, CHP, F’rennants trichrome
Arvy (1956)
ID
50
Lepidoptera: (Pyraloidea) Ephestia Galleria (Sphingoidea) Herse, Sphinx (Bombicoidea) Bombyx
c
2 x 6-8 2 x 38-47
2 x 2-3 2 x 12
Az, Iron haematoxylin
Rehm (1950,1951)
n
Az, CHP, PF
Delipine (1965)
0, m
2x8
2 x 9-10
CHF, PF, PTh
Panov and Kind (1963)
rn -I 0
2 x 10 (2x8
2x7 2 x 8-10
CHP, PF CHP, PF, PATh
Kobayashi (1 95 7) Panov and Kind (1963)
0
0
n
n
<
m I-
i
Antherea Malacosoma, Eudia
v)
2x8
2 x 8-10
CHP, PF, PATh
Panov and Kind (1963)
2x5 2x 7
Not stated CHP, PF
Van der Kloot, (1961)
2x9 (2x8
2x5 2 x 8-10
CHP CHP, PF, PTh
Ichlkawa (1962) Panov and Kind (1963)
2x8
2 x 9-10
CHP, PF, PTh
Panov and Kind (1963)
PAVB,PF/HM
Burgess (1971, 1973) Meola and Lea (1972)
Hyalophora
(Noctuoidea) Dicranura, Phalaera Spiloso ma, Dasy c him, Acronycta, Dendrolimus, Lymantria, Orgya (Cossoidea)
.
Herman and Gilbert (1965)
cossus
(Papiliono idea) Vanessa, Pieris Diptera (Nematocera) Culiseta Aedes
__
__---_2 2x12
1 4 total
___________ 2x5
PF, EM
2
m
TABLE 2-continued
N
Taxonomic division
Median NSCs
Lateral NSCs
Tipula (Brachycera) Tubanus (Cyclorrapha)
2 x >15*
No information
NS
Cazal ( 1948)
2 x>5*
2 x >4*
NS
Cazal (1948)
2x3 2x3 2x3 2 x 5-7 2 x "a few" 2x3
RefIected Iight CHP, PF CHP CHP CHP PF, PAVB
E. Thomsen (1952) M. Thomsen (1965) Langley (1965) Kopf (1957) Nayar (1954) Dogra and Tandan (1966)
2x6
PF
Gawande (1968)
Not seen
CHP
M. Thomsen (1954)
Ca Ilip ho ra Glossina Drosophilu Chaetodacus Sarcop haga 5. Oligoneoptera (nonpanorpoids) S trepsip tera Hymenopt era (Formicoidea) Formica and Camponotus (09) (Vespoidea) Eumenes, Synagris (99) (Apoidea) A p i s (P)
Andrenu ( 0 )
Coleoptera (Caraboidea) Nebrio
(i
;2-13 2 x 8-10 2 X 12-16 2xc.6 2x13
Technique
Reference
N o information
2 x c. 100 2x
>loo
I
2 x c. 60* 2 x c . 65 2 x 20+
N o information Present CHP Not seen Az, CHP Molybdenum haematoxylin
Weyer (1935) Formigoni (1956) Brandenburg (1956)
5 b
I -n II
D
v)
m II SD
0
2x8
2 X 2-4
AF, CHP,'AB/P silver inpregnation
Ganargarajah (1965)
5r... r
(Hydrophiloidea) Hydrous
3
2 x 20
Aulacophora (Curculionoidea) Slaps Hypera Sitophilus
(Cantharoidea) Lampyris
X
4-6
GHP, Qiemsa, Feullgen
De Lerma (1954)
n .. 3
1
(Dermestoidea) Dermestes (Chrysomeliodea) Galeruca Leptino tarsa
2
Ern
2x5
Ladduwahetty (1962) quoted by Siew (1965)
2
0
2 x 54-64 2 x 80
2 x 8-16 2 X 6-27
2 x 8-10
2x2
2
--
X
24-26
2 x 7-12
- - --- - c. 2 x 30 total ------------
No information
2 x 11
2 x 12
Present
PF, ABQ’, CHP, Az CHP, PlF/PIC, PTh, histoochemical stains AF, CHIP
Siew (19 6 5) Schooneveld, (1970)
ABP, P:F EM of INCC PF/HM:I, CHP
Fletcher (1969) Tombes and Smith (1970) Sandifer and Tombes (1972)
AB, C m P , p F / n I C , PTh/NY, Histoochemical stains
Naisse (1966a)
rn r
r cn
Saini (1967)
Figures given without comment are derived directly from the author quoted. Those indicicated with an asterisk are minimum estimates derived by the present author from the quoted work, e.g. from pictures of histological secztions, in cases where the original author gives no numerical information. Unless otherwise stated counts are based on numbers of s o m a t a after staining. The subdass and order are routinely given along with the genus; where several genera of one order have been hvestigisated, they are additionally grouped by family or superfamily as appropriate. W
w
84
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
large numbers of medial NSCs, certainly up t o 2 x 600. In the case of the acridid Orthoptera, comparable estimates have been reached b y three different methods: counting of stained somata from sectioned material; axonal iontophoresis of cobalt up the NCC I and counting somata in whole mount and in section; and counting neurosecretory profiles in an EM transverse section of the NCC I. There is no doubt as t o the large number of cells. Figures are not available for the Phasmida (stick insects, etc.), but the qualitative descriptions suggest that they may have equally large numbers. The number of lateral cells, in contrast, extends only over a narrow range from 2 x 6 to 2 x 16 cells. Three of the orders of the Polyneoptera have not been investigated in any detail, including, surprisingly, the economically important termites. iii. Paraneoptera Only two of the six orders have been investigated, and only the Hemiptera in any detail. At first sight the Hemiptera have remarkably few median NSCs, but they may have suffered from an overly restricted range of staining techniques. It may be significant that all the really low estimates (2 x 5-10) derive from only PF and VB stains (highly specific for A cells) that investigators using CHP in addition have found more (2 x 7-16), and that those using Azan too have found still higher numbers (2 x 16-65). Estimates of lateral cells cluster mostly between 2 x 3-9. With one exception, there appears t o be no marked correlation of variation with taxon, except that the sole reduviid investigated, Rhodnius, has much the most numerous cells in both median and lateral groups and these cells are smaller than the average for the group, making it likely that the high number is indeed not a staining artifact (see p. 104ff). Two independent estimates for this animal differ by a factor of two. One of these investigations did not use azan staining and further employed a quite different method of assessment (see p. 92); the two figures are best regarded as minimum and maximum figures. The suggestion of small numbers of protocerebral cells in the Paraneoptera which is provided b y the Hemiptera is supported by what unfortunately appears to be the only quantitative account from the important order of Homoptera. Here, uniquely low counts were obtained by Johnson (1963), indicating a maximum of 7 pairs of NSCs in the entire brain, median and lateral groups combined. This figure, moreover, was obtained with a wide spectrum of stains. It is not known t o what extent the animals used (Aphidae, which are aberrant in many ways relative t o most insects) are typical of their group. If confirmed, the homopteran situation is a most intriguing one, and one of special significance t o the neurophysiologist (see also p. 103). iv. Oligoneoptera
The arbitrary division between L‘medial’’and “lateral”
NEU ROSEC R ETO R Y CELLS
85
NSCs is least useful in the ,Oligoneoptera (see for example section 4.3) and to make useful comparisons with the other groups it is probably best t o consider the total NSC complement of the brain. First consider the panorpoid complex: figures are not available for the more primitive orders, but published pictures of sections of the brains of scorpion flies and ant-lions make it clear that they have at least moderately large numbers of median NSCs, probably as many as a cockroach. Within the Lepidoptera, numerous investigations have been made, but many confine themselves to larvae or pupae, and use a restricted range of staining techniques. Estimates are available for adult representative of 6 superfamilies, and with one exception all estimates for “median” NSCs lie between 2 x 8-13, and a11 for “lateral” NSCs between 2 x 5-10. Panov and Kind (1963) have claimed a remarkable constancy in number for the A-type cells in the brains of different lepidopteran species. Unfortunately for this tidy state of affairs, the investigation which used the widest range of staining techniques (DelCpine, 1965) estimated 2 x 47 medial NSCs and 2 x 1 2 lateral NSCs in the pyralid Galleria. 2 x 20-25 of the medial cells described were C (azan only) cells. Counts from other species of this superfamily have not given such large numbers, but most did not use azan. A previous worker (Rehm, 1955) with the same animal reported being unable t o assess the number of median NSCs, which might suggest that there are more of them than usual. The remaining panorpoid order, the Diptera or true flies, have also had rather a restricted range of histological techniques applied to them. Such figures as are available, however, suggest that they tend to have rather more “medial” and rather fewer “lateral” NSCs than the Lepidoptera, but that the total number is about the same as in that group. The largest number expressly recorded is from Drosophila, which was estimated to have a total of 2 x 23 NSCs in the brain, a total comparable with many Lepidoptera. No azan preparations were made, however. There do not seem to be large differences between the different suborders. Among the three nonpanorpoid orders of the Oligoneoptera, only the Coleoptera have received much attention. As perhaps befits the taxon with the largest number of species in nature, it shows great variation in its NSC complement. Median cell estimates vary from 8-80 pairs of cells, and lateral cells from 2-27 pairs. Further, this entire range of variation has been found within the superfamily Chrysomeloidea (leaf-beetles) alone. The Hymenoptera have received surprisingly little attention, but it is obvious that the species investigated, all of which are social, have more protocerebral NSCs than any other insects, except the Orthoptera (and possibly the phasmids, dragonflies and mayflies, if hard figures are ever obtained for these groups). These figures, moreover, mostly derive from a single staining technique, either PF or CHP, and so are probably underestimates.
86
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
From these figures the following picture emerges. The lateraI NSCs of in number, though I)( cause they are few, the variation is large if expressed as a percentage. Both minimum (2-3 pairs) and maximum (15-25 pairs) occur in taxonc )mically remote groups, such as Polyneoptera and Oligoneoptera. By contrast, the medial NSCs show great absolute variation in number, but the ;ric,at majority of insect orders have between 20 and 80 pairs of cells. This i n i ludes some of the most primitive and some of the most evolved orders, f o i example the Grylloblattodea and the Diptera. A very few orders are clraracterized by medial NSC numbers well outside this range. The Hemipicra and Homoptera (and conceivably all of the Paraneoptera?) have impressively few medial cells, down t o 7 pairs in some aphids. At the other c.\treme, the Hymenoptera comfortably exceed this norm, and the Orthoptera have uniquely large numbers, up t o at least 600 pairs in some iri\tances. There is as yet no evidence worth considering that a very large number of NSCs is a primitive trait as suggested b y Gabe (1966), though it m ~y eventually turn out t o be so if it can be shown t o be shared by plrasmids and the Palaeoptera; information on the latter would be particula1 ly valuable. The argument that “large numbers” (again without quantit,ii we support) of cerebral NSCs are characteristic of other, allegedly more pi imitive, arthropod groups, such as Thysanura or of polychaete Annelida, does not seem compelling. At the present time, the large numbers of medial cc 11s of the Orthoptera seems t o be a special and isolated feature of that older. It is a tempting speculation t o equate the large number of medial N4Cs of the social Hymenoptera with the diversity of behavioural and plieromonal potential within the individual in those groups, but there is no rc 11 evidence to support this. Studies on termites, and on tenthredenid or oilier nonaculeate Hymenoptera would be an early requisite. It has been rc ported, however, that formicid queens-but not apparently honey bees (kormigoni, 1956)-have more cerebral A cells than do drones (Gawande, 1‘)68). As such a sexual dimorphism has not been reported elsewhere, it tc lids t o suggest that the role of the queen in the colony necessitates a laiger NSC complement. Even in the best investigated orders (Orthoptera, Hemiptera, Lepidoptera atid Coleoptera) the total number of species whose NSCs are known is niinute. It does seem, even so, that the Coleoptera show by far the greatest M. ithin-group diversity. The chysomelid beetles might for example be pc.rfert material t o attempt t o correlate variation in NSC number with di lferent degrees of complexity of environment, behaviour, or life history. ’Iliere is certainly no obvious gross correlation of cell number with “\uccess”, if this can be measured by species number. The most species-rich insect orders, and probably the most diverse, are in order the Coleoptera, t h v protocerebrum show little absolute variation
NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
87
Lepidoptera, Hymenoptera, Diptera, Hemiptera, Homoptera and-a long way behind-the Orthoptera ’ (Freeman, 1970). The remaining 22 orders account for only about 5 per cent of the known insect species. It will be seen that these groups with high diversity include three orders with “typical” numbers of protocerebral NSCs, and also all the extreme deviations towards both greater and smaller numbers of NSCs.
2.5.3 Variation among taxa: NSCs of the ventral nerue cord, and the total complement of NSCs Table 3 compares the numbers of NSCs found in the brain with those found elsewhere in the CNS. The available data are much fewer than for the median and lateral NSCs, and in most cases one is especially handicapped by the lack of information on the numbers of additional brain NSCs, outside of these two groups. In spite of obvious defects, Table 3 shows clearly that in all known cases there are as many, o r more, NSCs in the rest of the CNS as there are in the brain. Frequently the number in the brain is relatively insignificant. The only apparent exception derives from Johansson’s figures for Oncopeltus. His estimates for the VNC are probably much too small, however, as his stains would not be expected t o demonstrate the C cells which comprise roughly 70 per cent of the NSCs in the VNC of other insects. Of these C cells, more than half appear t o be associated with the median NHOs, at least if the phasmids (Raabe, 1965; Maddrell and Brady, 1968) and acridids (Chalaye, 1967) are typical. For the remainder, it is important t o remember the reservations expressed earlier about the identification of NSCs on morphological criteria, and the possibility that a good number of apparent NSCs innervating muscles directly may in fact be motor neurones of one sort or another. If these are discounted, the general case is more nearly one of parity between brain and VNC, in numbers of NSCs. I have attempted, on even less data, to make minimum estimates of the total number of NSCs in some insects. Here the difficulties are much greater, the move obvious being the very few numerical estimates of NSCs in the retrocerebral complex, and the uncertainty as t o how many insects possess the less commonly described NSC populations, such as those of the optic lobes. I know of no single insect in which estimates are available for all the major NSC populations, so extrapolation from the most closely related form, or often just plain guessing, is required t o supplement the data. The results are presented in Table 4. Seven orders are represented. There is enough partial data from other species of these orders t o make it at least plausible that the figures are more or less representative, though the estimates from the Coleoptera are so diverse that the example given here should not be taken as necessarily typical. It is unfortunate that there are
TABLE 3 Comparison of numbers of neurosecretory cells in the brain and in other parts of the CNS Taxonomic division Grylloblattodea Schizodacty lus Orthoptera
Acheta
Schistocerca
Medial and lateral NSCs
144
830
c. 2000 1228
Technique
Author
PF, CHP
Khattar (1968)
PF, CHP, PAVB,EM
Geldiay and Edwards (1972) Gaude and Weber (1966) Highham (1961)
1
PF, CHP EM, PF/ PIC
1
SOG
NSCs
30
VNC NSCs
Technique Reference
no information
PF, CHP
Khattar (1968)
PTh
Panov (1964)
At least A cells closely comparable to figures to Schistocerca below 134-137* 695-1143*
Rowell (unpublished)
Az, PF Delphin (1965) CHP, ABP M3C
Dictyoptera
Periplaneta
c. 120
120 optic
CHP, PF, Fuller (1960) PF, Ag impr. Willey (1961) EM, histochemical Beattie (1971)
20
209
Az, CHP PF, RSR
de Besse (1965,1967) I
C
c, I n
Hemiptera Rhodnius
Oncopeltus
a 170 64 32
Az, CHP PF/HM
Baehr (1968) Steel and
CHP, PF
Harrnsen (1971) Johansson (1957, 1958)
34
None
106
18
A,CHP
CHP, PF
Baehr(1968) Baudry(1968) Johansson (1957, 1958)
9 YJ YJ
0
%
Lepidoptera Galleria Adult
118
“Nymph”
38
“Preiiymph”
32
( Bombyx
Diptera L u c ilia Larva
Culiseta Larva, Pupa Coleoptera Leptino tarsa
36
Az, CHP, PF Az, CHP, PF Az, CHP, PF CHP, PF
[PTh
Delipine (1 965)
8
Del6pine (1965)
None
72
Delkpine (1965)
28
80
Kobayashi (1957)
80-100
129
>500t
Az, CHP, PF Az, CHP, PF Az, CHP, PF CHP, PF
DelCpine (1965) DClepine (1965) Dklepine (1965) Kobayashi (1957)
Panov and Kind (1963)
42
CHP, PF, AB
Fraser (1959a)
None
50
CHP, PF
Fraser (1956b)
28
PF/HM
Burgess (1971, 1973)
None
32-48
PF/HM PAVB
Burgess (1971)
CHP, PF
Schooneveld (1 970)
CHP, P F
Schooneveld (1970)
214
2
No information
dD .(
2r
‘
(D
0
Taxonomic divison
Blaps Adult Larva
Medial and lateral NSCs
76 114
Technique
ABP, PF ABP, PF
Authoi
Fletcher (1969) Fletcher (1969)
SOG NSCs
c. 30 c. 30
VNC NSCs
239 171
Technique
ABP, PF ABP, PF
Reference
Fletcher (1969) Fletcher (1969)
* Schktocerca Two figures are quoted from Delphin. The lower indicates the maximum of cells counted at any one time in any individual. The higher is the sum of the largest number of cells of the different staining characters ever recorded, and gives an estimate perhaps closer to the total number of cells in the ganglia, as opposed t o those active at any one time. t B o m b y x Kobayashi records “between 80 and 120 cells in all ganglia other than the brain and the SOG”. It is not clear to me whether he distinguished between segmentally distinct but morphologically fused ganglia or not, so the figure of 500 is minimal. Delphin quotes 1100 from the same source. With few exceptions the figures reported here for “brain” NSCs include only the cells of the pars intercerebralis, and those for the suboesophageal ganglion and ventral nerve cord include only those NSCs found within the major ganglia. For a discussion of other NSCs, not included in any of these categories, see pp. _ _ 71-75. In most cases the numbers of additional cells are fairly small.
I G) C
-n
30
$ rn sa
m
0
5r
r
91
NEUROSECRETORY CELLS TABLE 4 Estimates of total numbers of NSCs in some selected insects Orthoptera Schisto cerca Medial and lateral NSCs Deuto- and tritocerebral NSCs SOG NSCs VNC NSCs
cc
Dictyoptera Periplaneta Medial and lateral NSCs Optic lobes Deuto- and tritocerebral NSCs SOG NSCs VNC NSCs (Geldiay, 195 9, estimated 300-400 NSCs in SOG + VNC combined)
cc
1232 20 137 695
120 240
20
From Table 2 Raabe (1963a),Mason (1973), Brousse-Gaury (1967) From Table 3 From Table 3 18 intrinsic neurons of the storage lobe are not NSCs (Highnam and Galdsworthy, 1972; Cazal et al., 1971). The latter authors consider the intrinsic glandular cells to be nonneural
Table 2 From Beattie (1971) Raabe (1963a), Browse-Guary (1967) from Table 3
209
Guess
c. 700
Phasmida Carausius Medial and lateral NSCs
45 0
Deuto- and tritocerebral NSCs SOG + VNC NSCs
280
(Brady and Maddrell(l967) found 2 x 11+ NSC axons in a segmental medial neurohaemal organ, which extrapolates to a closely comparable figure) Peripheral NSCs
cc
loo+
Guess, based on qualitative comparison with Schistocerca Raabe (1963a) Raabe (1965) (Clitumnus, not Carausius)
Finlayson and Osborne (1968) Guess
92
HUGH FRASER ROWELL TABLE 4-continued
Hemip t era R hodinus Brain, total (Steele and Harmsen (1971) making the assumption that cell staining types were totally mutable, derived minimum estimates of 64 NSCs in the adult pars) SOG VNC
cc Stilbocoris Brain, total NSCs “A” cells of thoracic and abdominal ganglia Other NSCs of thorax and abdomen, by extrapolation
cc
170
34 106 <50 ___ <360, >254
Baehr (1968)
Baehr (1968) Baudry (1968) Guess
38
Furtado (1971)
24
Furtado (1971)
40 <40
Guess Guess
142 Homoptera aphid Brain, total NSCs VNC, other ganglia
cc Peripheral NSCs of thorax Lepidoptera Galleria Brain, total NSCs SOG VNCs VNC
cc
16 none 12
14 42
122 8 129 16
Drepanosiphum, Johnson (1963) CC intrinsic cells, M y z u s , Bowers and Johnson (1966) Bowers and Johnson (1966)
DelCpine (1965) Delipine (1965) Delipine (1965)
(Ephestiu, Rehm (1951))
275 Bombyx Medial and lateral cells Deuto- and tritocerebral NSCs
36 10
Frontal ganglion SOG
2 80
From Table 2 Larva of Manduca ( Sphingo idea), N ijhout (1975) Bounhiol et al. (1975) Kobayashi (1957)
93
NEUROSECRETORY CELLS VNC
cc
500-1000? 10-16
-Kobayashi (1957) 10 in larva of Mimas (Sphingoidea), Highnam (1958) 16 inxphestia (Pyraloidea), Rehm (1951) 1 4 in Ostrinia larva (Pyraloidea), McLeod and Beck (1963)
>644, <1144, Diptera Calliphorid Brain NSCs
SOG + VNC NSCs (Dogra and Tandan (1966) record 52 type “A” NSCs in the CNS of Sarcophaga) Additional type C cells of SOG and VNC Ocellar nerve NSCs Peripheral NSCs
CC and retrocerebral system Coleoptera Blaps Median + lateral NSCs Deuto- and tritocerebral NSCs SOG NSCs VNC NSCs
cc
40-50
50
50
40 in CaIliphora adult, Thomsen (1965) 42 in Lucilia larva, Fraser (1959a) 44 in Aedes (Culicoidea), Meola and Lee (1971) 46 in Drosophila, KGpf (1957) Lucilia larva, Fraser (1959b)
194
Guess Sarcophaga, Schlein (1972) Sarcophaga larva, Finlayson and Osborne (1968) Calliphora, Normann (1965); Thomsen (1969)
76 6+ 30 229 <50
Fletcher Fletcher Fletcher Fletcher Guess
20 2 16 -
(1969) (1969) (1969) (1969)
<390
not enough data t o make good estimates for either another homopteran or for a nonreduviid hemipteran; these are the two groups where really low totals might be expected; the figures available suggest that the two representatives chosen may have fewer than 50 and 150 NSCs respectively. The next lowest estimate is for a dipteran, probably less than 200 NSCs. A moth, a reduviid bug and a beetle all produce estimates of 300-400 cells.
94
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
The cockroaches and phasmids have prob,ably between 800 and 1000 MSCs, and by far the largest total once again comes from the Orthoptera, which seem t o have in excess of 2000 NSCs. No estimate can be made for the Hymenoptera, which are also expected t o have large numbers of cells. The aberrant figures for the silk moth Bombyx derive from Kobayashi (1957). His estimate of brain NSCs is in accord with other workers in the Lepidoptera. In the same paper he briefly refers t o 80-120 NSCs in all ganglia of the VNC, a statement which has been interpreted (e.g. by Delphin, 1965) t o mean up t o 1100 NSCs in addition t o the 36 he (Kobayashi) found in the brain. This puts a total estimate for this moth in the order of 100-1500 cells, a value approximately 5 times that obtained for the pyralid moth Galleria. It is noteworthy that Kobayashi was not using a specially wide spectrum of stains t o arrive at this large figure, and further examination of this species is needed. The larger figures for total numbers of NSCs are comparable t o similar estimates (of no greater accuracy!) which can be made for the total number of motor neurons innervating muscle in the insect. The interesting implication is that the CNS may devote as much of its integrative powers t o neurosecretory outputs as t o the more familiar motor neurons. 2.5.4 Vuriution during L$e history of the individual Table 5 compares various populations of NSCs which have been counted in comparable ways, preferably by the same worker, at different stages of the life history. For the obvious reason of the great amount of labour involved in counting and recounting a statistical sample, very few workers appear t o have assessed the variation inherent either in their own counting techniques or, more importantly, in individual animals. For this reason, Delphin’s (1965) counts of NCSs and in the VNC of Schistocercu at five-day intervals after the final moult are particularly important. The total number of cells recorded in any individual varied from 651 t o 832 cells, a fluctuation of some 30 per cent. This variation is comparable t o that obtained by GeIdiay (1959) in cockroaches. It is notable that some cell categories showed no variation at all, which provides a reassuring control as t o the accuracy of the counting technique Delphin employed, as does Chalaye’s (1967) close confirmation of his estimates in the related genus Locustu. If, however, one adopts the hypothesis that NSCs d o not change from one major staining category t o another (e.g. A celIs do not become B cells), but onIy become stainable or nonstainable, then the total figure is better derived from the sum of the maximum values obtained for each category. In Delphin’s case this would produce a total of no less than 1143 NSCs in the VNC, or 7 7 per cent more than the minimum number found in any individual at one time. This is a plausible hypothesis. The possibility. that cells change in major
2 61:
N d m w
0
NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
m
w 4
3
+ w
i
* N
0 03 0
m
W
2
v
3
; , 0 0 0N 0W 0I N
95
TABLE 5-curtlinued
(D
0,
Taxonomic division NSC population
Developmental stages Prehatch
(Sphingoidea) Manduca
Larva IV
LarvaV Pupa
Reference Adult * 6 cells (tritocerebral)
TotaI brain NS cells
shown only by cobalt, not by PF or CHP (a) Bassurmanova and Panov (1967) (b) Kobayashi (1958) (c) Panov and Kind
(Bombycoidea)
Bombyx
Median cells Lateral cells
(1963) Antherea
Median cells
Philosamia
Lateral cells Median cells
(d) Mitsuhashi (1963) (e) Ichikawa (1962) (f) Nijhout (1975)
Lateral cells (Noctuoidea) Lymantria Dendro limns
Diptera: Drosop hila Selected detail
Median cells Lateral cells
16
I C
(4 20 (4
(4
16
8 (4
t) X
26 (4 16 (4 28 (dl 20 (4 (Note: Panov and Kind (ref. c) did not describe the “posterior” cclls o f other authors, and their counts of “median” cells can therefore be increased by 4) Total brain NSCs Posterior cerebral cells
Larva (1-111) 16-20 0
Pupa 14 2
Adult 46 8
n VI
rn R
Ropf (1957%b )
Sarcophaga
Brain A cells (PAVB) Brain A cells (PF)
18 26
16 32
Dogra and Tandan (1966)
Calise ta
Hymenoptera (Apoidea) Apis (Formicoidea)
Neomyrma Leptothorax Campono tus Formica Coleoptera Blaps
larva 2x10 2x2 2x2 Larva
“Mediate” “Intermediate” “Lateral”
Median MSCs A cells of brain (PF) A cells of A cells of A cells of A cells of
brain brain brain brain
(PF) (PF) (PF) (PF)
Total NSCs Median cells Lateral cells Tritocerebral cells “Anterior” cells SOG T I, T I1 T 111 A I-A IV AV-A VII (larva) Last abdominal g. (adult)
c.
130
Larva 24 12 24 24
Pupa 2 x 10 2x2 2x2 Adult “About the same” Adult (queen) 109 60 150 136
Larva 54 60 6 5 30 15 15 18 18
Adult 52 24 6 0 30 18 27 26
340
311
z
m
Last instar Adult 2 x 10 2x2 2x2
rn 4
0 zu
<
Formigoni (1 956)
0
rn
r r v)
Gawande (1968)
Fletcher (1969)
32
Variation in NSC complement with age. The examples are selected for comparability; where possible the figures are derived by the same author, and where this is not possible variations in staining technique are noticed.
w
98
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
staining type with development or secretory ,cycle has been extensively debated, but the balance of recent opinion seems t o regard this possibility as unlikely, or at least rare (see e.g. Prent4, 1972). On the other hand, there is much evidence that cells are only stainable at certain times, and can appear and disappear in successive ages (p. 70), and have slightly different appearances at intermediate stages of this process. If cell types are so narrowly defined as t o differentiate between these intermediate stages, then it is obviously true that they change with time. Steel and Harmsen (1971) freely admitted the possibility of unrestricted transformation of cell type, adopted the most parsimonious estimates of cell number, and also used a single, though wide-range, staining technique. Their estimate of the NSC population was half that obtained b y more conventional methods (Table 2) but even so they were forced t o admit the probability that the population included two chemically distinct types of cell. The belief is frequently expressed that larval insects have fewer neurosecretory cells than do adults. Probably most workers would interpret this statement to mean “stainable” neurosecretory cells, for there is a total absence of evidence for the formation of new NSCs, presumably by cell division from undifferentiated neuroblasts at the final moult. There is clearly an increase in cell stainability which is associated with maturation of function. For example, only 9 NSCs were detected in a 42-day embryo of a cockroach, as opposed t o about 50 seen by the same workers in the adult (Khan and Fraser, 1962). This apart, the collected data do not support the generalization. It is apparently true of some animals, but not of others, and detailed analysis of subpopulations o f NSCs strongly suggests that some of them are more prominent in the larvae, some in the adult, and that the final total visualized is more o r less fortuitous and can show a change in either direction at metamorphosis. This makes intuitive sense: while adults need to reproduce, larvae need t o moult and sometimes to metamorphose; in addition, they often have different physiological and environmental requirements t o mediate. There is no good reason why one should require more or less NSCs than the other, but every reason why they should require different ones, or at least different functions for the same ones. The most dramatic increase in numbers of cells is reported among the A cells of cerebral NSCs of ants (Gawande, 1968) where larvae have only 24 and adult queens around 100 pairs. This is obviously an extreme case, for not only is the ant larva actively maintained in a very constant environment with relatively few neurosecretory demands, but also the queen could well be expected t o have unusually numerous neurosecretory requirements. Furthermore, only A cells were counted, and other cell types may well behave differently, as in other species. For comparison, the 5th instar larval brain of Munducu (Sphingidae, Lepidoptera) contains 42 NS cells (Nijhout,
NEUROSECR ETO RY CE L LS
99
1975). Panov and Kind (1963) found 36 cells in adults of the closely related general Sphinx and Herse, but their staining techniques would not be expected to reveal the 6 tritocerebral cells which stain only with azan or with cobalt via fills of the NCC IV. Correcting for this deficiency, the estimates for larva and adult are identical. Similarly, Burgess (1971) found regular changes in stain affinity as Culiseta (Diptera, Culicidae) passed from larva, through pupa, to adult, but the absolute number of bnainNSCs remained constant. 3 Implications of the identifiable cell concept for the insect neurosecretory system 3.1
ANATOMICALLY SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCES BETWEEN NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
AND OTHER NEURONS
NCSs can be grouped along a continuum between two e,xtremes, the cell which releases its secretion at a NHO and utilizes the general blood circulation to transport its product to the target organ, and the cell which directly innervates its target and releases its product in very intimate proximity. (In animals with a highly vascularized circulatory system, such as crustacea, some molluscs, or vertebrates, there is also the case of the NSC which releases its product into a capillary which transmits it to a specific target directly, but this circumstance does not arise in the open haemocoel of insects.) In the latter case, the anatomically significant differences between the NSC and a regular neuron, say a motor neuron, are likely to be minimal. It is true that, at the fine structural level, the somatic elaboration and axonal transport of secretory product must differ from the mechanisms needed to produce and recycle transmitter substance, in which all the necessary synthetic and enzymatic machinery may be localized peripherally in the terminals; and there are likely to be small differences between the classical synapse and the point of release of the NSM. However, the NSC is not freed from any of the anatomical restraints that apply to regular neurons. The NSC that ends in a NHO, in contrast, differs from the regular neuron in two important ways. First, it loses the constraint of having to approach its target closely with an axon. Provided it is in contact with the circulation, the NHO can be located almost anywhere. It is still difficult to alter the position of the input to the cell-the premotor neurones still have to make the usual synaptic connections-but the output structures can evolve much more freely. This seems t o have happened in the evolution of the median NSCs of the protocerebrum. Their position in the brain is almost constant throughout the insects, but their axons terminate in a great variety of NHOs in different species (pp. 73-74).The second consequence of
100
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
not innervating the target organ directly is that the appropriate threshold titre of secretion has t o be reached using the whole blood volume, and this in turn implies that the NSC utilizing an NHO probably has t o produce much larger quantities of secretion than either a regular neuron or a directly innervating NSC, or, alternatively, that there must be duplication of cells. This point is returned t o below.
3.2 CONSTANCY, UNIQUENESS, AND REDUPLICATION
IN NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
If NSCs are similar in their organization to other neurons of the insect CNS, they could be expected t o be constant in number and position and individual morphology, and t o display a minimum of functional reduplication, other than that associated with segmentation. To what extent do these predictions seem t o be true? And what departures from this prediction could we anticipate due t o the genuine differences between NSCs and other neurons, considered in the previous section?
Constancy The work reviewed in section 3 indicates that at the gross level insect NSCs are constant among individuals in number and in grouping, and are species-specific in these respects. A similar situation exists in at least some other invertebrate groups, e.g. pulmonate molluscs (Wendelaar-Bonga, 1970) and leeches (Hagadorn et al., 1963). In some populations of insect cells no variation at all has been detected (e.g. the A cells of the orthopteran VNC: Panov, 1964; Delphin, 1965) and in others apparent variation can plausibly be associated with variation in stainability rather than in absolute number. Few dye injections into individual neurons have yet been made (section 4) which would test the constancy of the fine morphology of the NSC, but there is no reason t o suppose that (at least at their input end) NSCs will be any less constant than other neurons-the problems of making predetermined synaptic connections are the same in both. (NSCs associated with NHOs, as noted above, may well be more variable at the output end.) There is thus every reason to believe that NSCs can in principle be characterized as individuals, and recognized as such from animal to animal. IJniqueness Before considering uniqueness and duplication of function I should declare an underlying assumption. This is that any individual neuron will normally manufacture only one major secretory product. I t is well known the neurons do release more than one substance. For example, detectable amounts of proteins are released from motor nerves, in addition to TS, and these are sometimes postulated t o be the mediators of “trophic” influences of nerve on the subsynaptic tissue; and neurophysins are released from vertebrate neurohypophysial cells. In general, however, only one
N EU ROSECR ETO R Y CELLS
101
product is liberated in quantity (though there has been a recent suggestion that a neuron in a snail may change its TS from serotonin t o acetyl choline at different seasons of the year (Hanley et al., 1974). The extension of this common assumption t o the NSC implies that each would produce large amounts of only one characteristic secretory product, probably peptide or protein. If more than one function is t o be performed by this molecule in the body, the diversity must be obtained at the targets and it should be impossible to have more neurohormones than NSCs. If, on the other hand, the assumption proves t o be incorrect, and it transpires than an individual NSC can synthesize more than one molecular species of hormone, then this constraint does not apply. So far there is no evidence arguing against the assumption, and I will make it for the remainder of this article. It is hard to see how a cell which did produce two products of hormonal significance could liberate them other than in a fixed ratio in response to depolarization, which should limit the utility of such dualism, though Anwyl and Finlayson (1974) have proposed that insect neurons may function successively as NSCs and as motor neurons. The nearest approaches t o duplication of function in regular neurons in insects are in laterally replicated sensory arrays (e.g. the optic lobe and retina) and in segmental homologues. The first category does not seem to have any direct parallel in NSC organization, but the issue of segmental reduplication is a real one. It is noteworthy that those insects with the fewest NSCs are also those which have condensed the primitive segmentally replicated ganglionic chain down t o a few large compound ganglia. Perhaps condensation has allowed them t o reduce the number of segmentally duplicated NSCs. It is possibly significant that most of these orders are also relatively small, either absolutely (Hornoptera, Hemiptera, Diptera) or in relative blood volume (Lepidoptera), and so less demanding of the large quantities of hormones that reduplicated cells could provide. Segmental reduplication might be expected t o apply especially t o those NSCs which directly innervate their target, as those utilizing NHOs are liberated from the need to have a defined relationship with their target. There is some support for this, in that at least some candidate NSCs of this type (the dorsal unpaired median neurones, for example, treated in section 4.3) are arranged segmentally down the ganglionic chain; but on the other hand, the median NHOs of the thoracic and abdominal ganglia are also segmentally replicated and can sometimes survive in their original numbers in nervous systems where there is fusion of the main VNC ganglia (Thomas and Raabe, 1974). Assuming that they produce a similar spectrum of secretions in each ganglion (each contains a large variety as judged by EM appearances (Brady and Maddrell, 1967) and at least two staining types by LM (Thomas and Raabe, 1974)) one must suppose that the absolute number of NHOs is
1a2
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
required t o maintain a titre, and that they are,synchronized to work as a unit by interconnecting premotor neural connections. Support for the distributed synthesis of a particular hormone comes also from the common finding that many parts of the CNS have some specific pharmacological activity when assayed after homogenization. There are, however, a number of objections to this argument, and even if sustained it carries no evidence that the homologous source cells in the different ganglia ever function in concert. They might have quite different afferent connections. An NSC utilizing an NHO could be unique in either (a) its secretion-i.e. only that cell secretes that compound, or (b) its input connections-i.e. it is unique in the stimulus situation which causes it to release its secretion. (A directly innervating NSC is also unique in terms of its anatomical destination, as in regular neurons.) To what extent are NSCs likely to be unique in either of these ways? a. Uniqueness of secretion, or, one pair of cells to one hormone This is an exciting and stimulating possibility. The most obvious rough test of its validity is t o compare the expected number of neurosecretions with the experimentally ascertained number of NSCs. One immediately runs into two difficulties: To what extent does the diversity of neurohormonal function reflect the diversity of neurohormones? Can the same hormones be produced in different insects by NSCs of morphologically different areas? The first question is confused by the remarkable ability of insects to use the same molecule in different functional contexts. Bursicon has been shown t o induce tanning, but also postulated to end ecdysial motor outputs (Truman and Endo, 1974) and t o have diuretic function (Mills and Whitehead, 1970). To draw a further example from nonneural endocrine systems, the many functions of ecdysone and juvenile hormone are notorious in insect physiology. An example is the use of both in the control of growth, moulting and metamorphosis of the larval stages and then again in the induction and control of vitellogenesis in the adult. (It may be, however, that these different functions are to some extent partitioned between the different chemical forms of JH which are found within the individual (Judy et al., 1973, and personal communication)). Similarly, if it could be shown that the target systems responded in different ways to precise mixtures of synergistic hormones, it would be possible t o explain a large number of hormonal functions by using only a small range of neurohormones. A further way of controlling a diversity of process with one hormone is t o make the targets susceptible t o temporal patterning. Truman and Riddiford (1974b) have explored the temporal sequence of PTTH ecdysone release in pupation, and temporal factors are important in the hormonal determination of coloration in acridids (Rowell, 1971, for review). The second question is harder t o come t o grips with. Suppose one
NEU ROSECR ETO R Y CE LLS
103
compares two animals, each with the same total number of NSCs. One has only 10 pairs of cerebral NSCs, the other 30 pairs. Does this imply that the latter averages three times as many cells per brain hormone as the former? It clearly does not if the total hormonal synthetic requirement is spread over the whole complement of NSCs, but could one not expect some conservation in evolution as t o what part of the CNS produced what sort of hormones? If the cerebral cells have well-defined roles, not replicated by those of the VNC, then the hypothesis would be justifiable. Bursicon, however, appears t o be functionally produced from NSCs of both brain and abdominal ganglia (see Goldworthy and Mordue, 1974, for review). When one reviews the numbers of NSCs in insects (section 3) and compares them with the expected numbers of hormones, it seems likely that in some species at least the one hormone/one cell pair situation will exist, especially in small individuals (see p. 104) of those groups with condensed CNS and small numbers of cells such as the Homoptera and Diptera. For example, it is hard t o believe that the brain of any insect would produce much fewer than 7 different neurosecretions. Both the crustacean X organ and the vertebrate hypothalamus are known already t o produce approximately this number, and the life of the insect is certainly as complex. Wyatt (1972) lists 1 3 neurohormones of proven occurrence, including CC hormones, and mentions that more are known from individual taxa. Minimally, one would expect prothoracotrophic hormone, bursicon, ecdysis-releasing hormone, at least one hormone associated with control of the corpus allatum, diuretic hormone, and either or possibly both a hypo- and hyperglycaemic factor, to be of general occurrence in the brain. Special cerebral neurosecretory functions include the lampyrid gonadotropic hormone (Naisse, 196613, 1969) and dipteran pupation factor (Zdarek and Fraenkel, 1969). (Other common neurosecretory functions such as control of oviposition, diapause, diuresis, and chromatophores, seem to be confined t o the SOG, or VNC, and others (adipokinetic hormone, glycaemic factors, c?rdiac accelerating factor, melanin-inducing factor) t o be associated primarily with the CC.) Yet Aphis apparently has only 7 pairs of cerebral NSCs (Table 2). Following a previous argument (p. loo), it is unlikely that this brain can produce more than 7 distinct neurosecretions. This interpretation suggests that with one or two intracellular electrodes it ought t o be possible t o monitor, abolish or control an entire neurosecretory pathway in these insects. At the other extreme, the numbers of NSCs present in the Orthoptera make it effectively certain that the same hormone is produced by many cells. It is impossible t o imagine that a locust needs 100 times as many different cerebral hormones as an aphid, for example, or ten times as many neurohormones of all sorts as a fly even if one allows for the greater effect
104
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
o f segmental reduplication in the VNC of the locust. None the less, the second type of cellular uniqueness could still be obtained by having each NSC of a certain molecular species driven by a different integrative network. This would be especially appropriate where one hormone had to be produced in response to a variety of environmental situations, say at very different times in the life history, or where sustained production over a long period of fluctuating sensory input was required. By this argument, one might expect insects with a more complicated life history, environment, or life style to split up their hormone production among more numerous NSCs, even if they did not increase the actual number of products. The data are not yet sufficient to examine this possibility, though it is of interest t o see that the social Hymenoptera have more numerous and smaller NSCs than any other Oligoneopteran group. Perhaps the Coleoptera, which show large variation in NSC number among closely related forms, would be suitable material for such an investigation. A corrolary anatomical approach would be to investigate the morphology of comparable NSCs from animals with relatively few and relatively numerous cells. The argument would suggest that NSCs from the less numerous population would have larger and more elaborate dendritic trees or a higher density of input synapses, whereas the larger population of cells would have relatively simple input structures. It is, however, hard to imagine that all the 1000 or more pairs of NSCs of some insects are unique, even in subtle details of input. The great range in abosolute numbers of NSCs in the insects is in considerable contrast to the relative constancy of number of regular motor neurons. For example, Schistocercu (Orthoptera), Bombus (Hymenoptera), and Cuhphoru (Diptera) all have about the same absolute number of flight motor neurones, despite considerable differences in the morphology of the flight apparatus. There is one obvious reason why NSCs might be more prone t o reduplication than regular neurones, and that is their frequent utilization of the blood as a carrier, coupled with the dependence of the target on concentration of hormone. The larger the animal, the more reduplication of NSC will be necessary for each NHO, in order t o keep the effective titre the same. If this hypothesis is founded in fact, there ought t o be a correlation between the size of the animal and the total volume of NSCs serving its NHOs. Taking the median NSCs as the best known example of the latter, I have calculated the total volume of their somata for a variety of insects, using published figures for number and cell size. This calculation is even more approximate than the preceding ones, because cell dimension is almost always given as a linear measure, and hence all errors are cubed when converting to volume; further, I have assumed spherical somata, and most NSCs have pear-shaped or ellipsoid somata. The circulating blood volume
N EUROSECR ETORY CELLS
105
ought t o be the best correlate of NSC volume; unfortunately, this is a difficult figure t o obtain experimentally, and I have not been able t o find enough estimates t o make a useful comparison. None the less, Table 6 TABLE 6 Estimated total volumes of medial neurosecretory cell somata in a variety of insects, arranged in orde,rof magnitude Blood volume, where known (pl)
Taxonomic divison Drosophila (fruit fly) Nebria (ground beetle) Glossina (tse-tse fly) Oncopeltus (plant bug) Apis (honeybee, worker) Ranatra (water strider) Stilbocoris (plant bug) A niso labis (earwig) Periplaneta (cockroach) Bornbyx (silkmoth) Leptinotursa (potato beetle) Zphita (shield bug) Rhodnius (predatory bug) Schistocerca (locust) Belostoma (giant water bug) Biggest Saturniid moths (composite estimate)
7 000 13 000 17 000 18 000 27 000 30 000 56 000 72 000 84 000 105 000 112 000 168 000 170 000 2 2 5 0 000 1 300 000
160 (Wheeler, 1963)
202 (Lee, 1961)
2 61 7 000 maximum
shows that when the species are listed in order of calculated NSC volume, the ranking fits quite well with that expected from the size of the animal. This result suggests that the hypothesis o f reduplication of NSCs to maintain hormone titre in large blood volumes is true. It also suggests that there is some measure of equivalence between lots of small cells and a few large ones. It is a striking example of the cube law that 1000 cells of 15 pm diameter have the same volume as only 20 cells of 55 p m diameter, and this makes the differences between, say, the medial NSCs of Orthoptera and Lepidoptera much less than appears at first sight. Both groups, it may be noted, have 2 x 3 large tritocerebral cells which give rise to the NCC 111. The cube relation may also explain why one sees little difference between the NSC array of a small and large species of one taxon (e.g. the large locust Schistocerca and the small grasshopper Melanoplus, Table 2), as large changes in blood volume can be equated with small changes in cell lineur
106
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
dimensions. For example, a 30 per cent change, in blood volume could be balanced by only about 3 per cent change in NSC soma diameter. There is also some anecdotal support for the hypothesis. Gawande (1968) reported that of a group of formicid genera the one with the largest body size had the largest number of NSCs, and Dupont-Raabe (1951) noted that the giant phasmid Euryonema had a particularly “voluminous” NSC area in the pars. In larval Schzstocerca the diameter of the individual medial NSC is half what it is in the adult (Gawande, 1969). In a system with reduplicated NSCs, there must be provision for driving them synchronously. A massive reduplication of presynaptic input is perhaps improbable, and might be expected t o be visible in the neuroanatomy, which is not obviously the case. It seems more likely that the NSC population would be coupled laterally. This could be accomplished either by extensive electrotonic coupling (it is of interest t o note that this has been found between the numerous small bag cells of the large sea slug Aplysia, where again reduplication, relative t o a hypothetical small gastropod ancestor, seems a logical necessity) or alternatively by chemical synapses. It is possible that the synaptic junctions between the axons of cerebral NSCs reported from the CC of some insects (e.g. Normann, 1965) may function in this way. If synchronous release of secretion is the only aim, there is no reason why the neurone should not have its spikes initiated near the terminal, rather than at the beginning of the axon, as long as the terminal membrane is depolarized. The frequency of firing of recorded NSCs is so low that collision and occlusion of orthodromic and antidromic spikes would be of negligible probability. It is also possible that the local post-synaptic potential could suffice t o cause release of secretory product, without regenerative spiking.
4 Available techniques, research strategy, and some examples
4 . 1 FILLING OF NEURONS WITH DYE FROM SEVERED NERVE STUMPS Mulloney (1973) has reviewed his recent synthesis of techniques by which cells are filled with dye, either by diffusion or by axonal iontophoresis, starting with a cut nerve stump. This technique can be applied in either the retrograde or prograde directions, filling either soma or the axonal terminations. Depending on the anatomical configuration (e.g. what proportion o f axons within the nerve are those of NSCs) more or less additional
N EU ROSECRETORY CELLS
107
investigation is required to, ascertain whether the cells so revealed are NSCs or not.
4.2 FILLING OF
NEURONS WITH DYE THROUGH AN INTRACELLULAR MICROPIPETTE
ELECTRODE
This technique is closely allied with the above, and gave rise t o it. Dye is injected by pressure or by electrophoresis (see Kater and Nicholson, 1973, for review of techniques). The advantages are that only a single cell is filled (most of the dyes are unable to cross even electrical synapses) and that the electrode simultaneously records electrophysiological events which help to characterize the cell. NSCs are often easy to identify electrophysiologically, because of their relatively long duration and slow rise-time action potential when recorded intracellularly. Both these intracellular dye techniques supply incontrovertible positive evidence, but only weak or meaningless negative evidence. If the structure fills, it can be assumed that it is in cellular continuity with the injection site. If a structure does not fill, it may merely indicate a technical failure. Fills are most successful with relatively thick axons of short length-the longer and the thinner, the less the probability of a complete fill, although successful fills are attainable even with axons well below five microns in diameter.
4.3 INTENSIFICATION OF COBALT STAINING BY SILVER PRECIPITATION The utility of both of the above techniques is greatly enhanced when cobalt is utilized, because trace amounts of cobalt sulphide become visible in paraffin sections after silver intensification by Timm’s technique. for the detection of heavy metal sulphides (Tyrer and Bell, 1974). Using this method, the finest dendritic processes become visible, defining structures invisible in the original preparation. To my knowledge, the dye injection techniques described above have so far been applied to only three neurosecretory systems. The neuroanatomical results are briefly summarized below. i. Mason (1973) investigated the origins and terminations of the neurones contained in the major nerves of the retrocerebral complex of Schistocerca (Orthoptera, Acrididae). Retrograde filling of the NCC I and I1 with cobalt filled the expected medial and lateral NSCs, and in both cases also filled a number of other somata not previously identified as associated with these nerves, and which are not stained with “specific” stains. They are assumed to be the somata giving rise to at least some of the 200 axons devoid of neurosecretion seen in both LM and EM sections of these nerves (Strong,
108
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
1965; Rowel1 and Mason, unpublished), and which are probably concerned with cerebral control of release of materials from the intrinsic glandular (NSC?) cells of the CC and CA. Scharrer (1963, 1964) shows EMS of Leucophaea in which presynaptic terminals onto intrinsic CC and CA cells have the appearance of regular axons, not NSCs. Other authors have since published similar findings. The extra somata filled through the NCC I1 are closely associated with the lateral NSCs, but at least some of those whose axons run in NCC I are in contrast tritocerebral, and have extensive dendritic arborizations elsewhere in the brain. The somata filled via the NCC 111 appear to correspond to the tritocerebral type C NSCs described by Raabe (196313). Prograde filling of the same nerves indicates the areas innervated directly by the somata (both NSCs and regular neurones) described above, and in general confirmed the more tentative conclusions derived from physiological and histological investigations. In addition, however, it was found that the axons of the NCC 111project almost in their entirety to the CA, which was not previously suspected. Filling of the NCA I and I1 gave similar results, including a confirmation of the projection from the suboesophageal ganglion to the corpora allata of the cells described by Chalaye (1967) as type C NSCs in Locusta from azan staining. This innervation had not been previously demonstrated in the subfamily to which Schistocerca belongs, and not confirmed in Locusta. This raises a conflict with the work of Odhiambo (1966), who reported no NSC axon profiles after an EM study of the NCA I of Schistocerca. If Chalaye correctly interpreted his Azan stains, electron-lucent vesicles would be expected in EM (see Maddrell and Brady, 1968; Smalley, 1970) (see Note added in proof, p. 123). On the other hand, Staal (1961) and Strong (1965) were unable to show any effect on CA function by cutting the NCA 11. Perhaps these neurons transmit to the SOG, and not from it, which might explain the absence of effect on the corpus allatum after the nerve is cut. ii. Axonal iontophoresis of cobalt into the brain of the hawkmoth ~lfunduca(Lepidoptera, Sphingidae) via the retrocerebral nerves has produced results interestingly comparable with the above (Nijhout, 1975). In the moths the division of the brain NSCs into median and lateral groups is almost without anatomical meaning. The cobalt staining shows that many of the same functional connections are present, even though the distribution of somata is quite different. The moth NCA I also contains neurosecretory axons derived from brain NSCs, but these somata are located contralaterally, rather than ipsilaterally as in the orthopteran, and comprise both medial and lateral cells of the pars intercerebralis. The chiasma takes place within the brain. Some of these cells may also innervate the corpus cardiacum, which they traverse to reach the NCA I, but axons which end specifically in the corpus cardiacum derive from ipsilateral cells,
NEUROSEC R ETOR Y C E L LS
109
as opposed t o contralateral cells in the orthopteran. Van der Kloot (1961) noted that in the saturriiid Hyalophora the CC was innervated from both ipsi and contralateral NSC. A number of associated nonneurosecretory cells also fill in the same area as the NSCs, as in the locust. Stumm-Zollinger (1957) had previously demonstrated that the moth NCC contained axons without neurosecretory granules. The origin of the NCC I11 appears to be identical in the two insects, three pairs of cells staining neither with A- nor B-type stains in the tritocerebrum. The distal projections of these cells was not studied. iii. The dorsal unpaired medial (DUM)neurons which occur in the thoracic and abdominal ganglia of many insects have an interesting history in research which typifies those cells of the VNC which appear to be NSCs but are largely without physiological correlate t o date. They are cells of uncommon morphology, having their somata medially and dorsally in the VNC ganglia, and sending large axons symmetrically out of one or more roots on both sides of the ganglion t o the periphery. They were first figured by the early insect neuroanatomists, such as Zawarzin, and again by Seabrook (1967) and Plotnikova (1969) in their studies of the ganglia of locusts. In Locusta they were described as Type C NSCs from azanstained preparations by Chalaye (1967), and by Fletcher (1969) from the beetle Blaps. Fortuitous microelectrode penetrations of comparable cells in the cockroach attracted attention because of the unusual characteristics of the action potential, which is of longer duration than is usual in insect neurons and which invades the soma; iontophoresis of cobalt showed these cells t o be DUM neurons (Crossman et al., 1971a, b y 1972). Up t o this point none of these authors appear t o have been aware of the others. Hoyle et al. (1974) described 7 such cells from the metathoracic ganglion of Schistocerca, showed that the largest of them sent axons bilaterally to the fast extensor tibiae muscle of the jumping leg, and that the terminal showed an EM profile of large electron-dense vesicles typical of some NSCs, thus extending the observations of Chalaye (1967). The only function so far ascribable t o this neuron is that it inhibits a slow spontaneous rhythm of contraction and relaxation, itself of unknown function, which is present in the muscle (Hoyle and O’Shea, 1974; Hoyle, 1974). No intracellular muscle recordings are yet available which would illuminate the mode of action of the neural product, and perhaps allow a distinction t o be drawn between a polypeptide transmitter substance (in the sense given o n p. 74) and some other type of neurosecretion. Four cells of similar morphology have been cobalt-filled by iontophoresis through the spermathecal nerve of Schistocerca, and again present a neurosecretory facies in EM transverse section (Okelo, 1974). These appear t o be the cells first figured by Seabrook (1967).
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
110
4.4
ELECTROPHYSIOLOGICAL
RECORDING
AND
INTRACELLULAR
CURRENT
INJECTION
When the soma position is known, either by dye injection or orthodox histology, it is in principle possible to penetrate it with a recording microelectrode. Proof of identity requires a subsequent transelectrode dye injection, at least until the physiological characteristics of the cell are so well known that positive identification can be made on electrophysiological grounds alone. Once the entire cell morphology is known, regions other than the soma can be selected as electrode targets; though harder to hit initially, much more definite information is recordable from the integrating segment of a neuron. Obviously the best chance of identifying individual cells repeatedly will come from insects with small numbers of large NSCs. Once achieved, a microelectrode penetration can be used in two basic ways: passively, to record voltage fluctuations, ionic fluxes, and (with suitable electrodes) ionic concentrations; or, by actively injecting ions, to manipulate the membrane’s potential, ionic permeability, and, indirectly, the release of the secretory product. The former techniques can be expected to have the same consequences in NSCs as they have had in regular neurons. They allow one to ascertain the connectivity of the cell, and to decide whether its activity is a consequence of presynaptic driving or whether it is endogenous. In an insect medial NSC, for example, one could ascertain directly whether the cell was influenced by ocellar input, and with more difficulty one could ascertain whether the cell was a pacemaker or showed other endogenous activity t o suggest that it could release its product without presynaptic cues. Current injection is classically utilized to establish the function of a unit by either driving it or by inhibiting its activity. In the case of most NSCs, the difficulty is likely to be the long-term nature of the response to the neurohormone, often exceeding the expected life of a neurophysiological preparation. The situation, however, is by no means irremediable. The DUM neurons, described above, show how the technique may be used t o investigate short-term effects of putative NSCs. Some classes of NSC, however, seem obviously suited for this analysis. A number of cases have been described where a complex behaviour is the result of activity in an intrinsic neural mechanism which in turn is triggered or caused to function by release of a hormone(s) (reviewed by Truman and Riddiford, 1974). For example, Truman (1973 and personal communication) considers that the release of ecdysial motor patterns in the moth pupa is probably the consequence of hormonal release from a medial NSC, and their termination t o be due to the release of bursicon from the abdominal VNC. Such cells are obvious targets for neurophysiological techniques. This hypothesis could be directly tested via microelectrode penetration of the cell in question. Apart from ecdysis,
NEU ROSECR ETO R Y CE L LS
111
there appear to be a considerable number of behaviour patterns of this class, though the source of the hormone is unknown in most cases: assembling and other mating behaviour (Riddiford and Williams, 1971), various aspects of oviposition (Nayar, 1958; Okelo, 1971; Truman and Riddiford, 1971; Rowell, unpublished), cocoon spinning and other prepupal behaviour (Truman and Riddiford, 1974b). The combination of intracellular recording and current injection simultaneously allows a number of refinements and some new capabilities, such as voltagc clamping of a single cell, and direct measurement of the degree of electrical coupling between adjacent cells which are simultaneously penetrated. The hypothesis that orthopteran rpedial NSCs may be electrotonically coupled (p. 106) is for example susceptible t o direct investigation by this means. In principle, there seems no reason why any of the various hypotheses erected or discussed in this review should not be experimentally proven b y a combination of these techniques. Many of the controversies mentioned, such as the correlation of staining type and function, or the possible transformation of an individual cell from one staining type t o another, can only ultimately be resolved when cells are characterized as individuals of known function and morphology. In practice, extremely little work has so far been carried out. A number of modern microelectrode studies of NSCs have been made (Gosbee et al., 1968; Wilkens and Mote, 1970; Cook and Milligan, 1972; Normann, 1973), but none has utilized dye injection or made any other attempt t o characterize the recorded cells as individuals; most have been concerned with establishing that NSCs follow normal neuronal procedures in their ionic and cellular mechanism, such as release of secretory product. In addition, none of these studies has used insects with unusually few, easily characterized, NSCs. Though there are obvious technical difficulties, mostly related t o lack of immediate consequences of release of the neurosecretory product, and the frequent inaccessibility of the axon t o extracellular electrodes, these do not appear insurmountable. In my opinion major advances in neuroendocrinology will be made when a suitable preparation is found t o which the concepts and techniques of the single identifiable neuron can be applied, and this review has attempted t o indicate those insect groups in which success is most likely. Acknowledgements I am deeply grateful t o the many authors who discussed with me their published or unpublished work and allowed me t o quote from it, and also to my colleagues H. A. Bern, S. B. Kater, W. Loher and C. A. Mason, who read and commented on various drafts of this manuscript. The review was written during the tenure of a Research Professorship of the Miller Institute for Basic Research in Science.
I12
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
Abbreviations
CA, corpus allatum; CC, corpus cardiacum; CNS, central nervous system; EM, electron microscope; LM, light microscope; NCA, nervis corporis allati; NCC, nervis corporis cardiaci; NHO, neurohaemal organ; NSC, neuro5ecretory cell; SOG, suboesophageal ganglion; VNC, ventral nerve cord; PTTH, prothoracotropic hormone; JH, juvenile hormone. For abbreviations of staining methods see Table 1. References 4diyodi, K. G. and Bern, H. A. (1968). Neuronal appearance of neurosecretory cells in the pars intercerebralis of Periplaneta americana (L.). Gen. comp. Endocr. 11, 88-91. 4nwy1, R. and Finlayson, L. (1974). Peripherally and centrally generated action potentials in neurons with both a motor and a neurosecretory function in the insect Rhodnius prolixus. J. comp. Physiol. 91, 135-146. k v y , L. (1956). Le systeme pars intercerebralis-corpus cardiacum-allatum chez Euroleon nostras Foucroy (Niroptireide: Plannipenne). In “Bertil Hanstrom. Zoological Papers in Honour of his 65th Birthday” (Ed. K. G. Wingstrand), pp. 47-55. Zoologica Institute, Lund. Arvy, L. and Gabe, M. (1952). DonPes histophysiologiques sur les formations endocrines rttro-c6rCbrale.s de quelques Odonates. Annls Sci. nut. (Zool.) 14, 345-374. Arvy, L. and Gabe, M. (1953). Donnies histophysiologiques sur la neurosicrition chez quelques Ephimiroptkres. Cellule, 55, 201-222. Arvy, L. and Gabe, M. (1954). The intercerebralis-cardiacum-allatum system of some Plecoptera. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole, 106, 1-14. Awasthi, V. B. (1968). The functional significance of the nervi corporis allati 1 and nervi corporis allati 2 in Gryllodes sigillatus. J. Insect Physiol. 14, 301-304. Awasthi, V. B. (1969). Effect of temperature on the neurosecretory activity in Nerara viridula Linn. (Heteroptera: Pentatomidae). Experientia, 25, 1164-1166. Baehr, J.-C. (1968). Etude histologique de la neurosicrition du cerveau et du ganglion sous-oesophagien de Rhodnius prolixus St%l (Himiptkre). C.r. hebd. Skanc. Acad. Sci. 267, 2364-2367. Baehr, J.-C. (1973). ContrBle neuroendocrine du fonctionnement du corpus allatum chez Rhodnius prolixus. J. Insect Physiol. 19, 1041-1055. Bargmann, W. (1949). ‘Ilber di neurosekretorischer Verkniipfung von Hypothalamus und Neurohypophyse. 2. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 34, 610-634. Bassurmanova, 0. K. and Panov, A. A. (1967). Structure of the neurosecretory system in Lepidoptera. Light and electron microscopy of type A neurosecretory cells in the brain of normal and starved larvae of the silkworm Bombyx mori. Gen. comp. Endocr. 9, 245-262. Baudry, N. (1968). Etude histologique de la neuroskcrition dans la chaine nerveuse ventrale de Rhodnius prolixus St%l (HCmipttre). C.r. hebd. Sbanc. Acad. Sci. 267, 2 35 6-235 8. Baudry, N. and Baehr, J.4.(1970). Etude histochimique des cellules neurosicritrices de l’ensemble du systeme nerveux central de Rhodnius prolixus St%l (HCtCroptere, Reduviidae). C.r. hebd. Skanc. Acad. Sci. 2 7 0 , 174.
N EU ROSECRETORY CELLS
113
Beattie, T. M. (1971).Histplogy, histochemistry, and ultrastructure of neurosecretory cells in the optic lobe of the cockroach, Periplaneta americana. J. Insect Physiol. 17,
1843-1855. Bern, H. A. (1966). The hormonogenic properties of neurosecretory cells. Neurosecretion: IV. International Symposium on Neurosecretion, Strasbourg, 25-27Juillet 1966. (Ed. F. Stutinsky). Springer-Verlag, Heidelberg and New York. Bessk, N. de (1965). Recherches histophysiologiques sur la neuroskcrktion dans la chaine nerveuse ventral d’une blatte, Leucophaea maderae (F.). C.r. hebd. Skanc. Acad. Sci. 260, 7014-7015. BessC, N. de (1967).NeurosicrCtion dans la chaine nerveuse ventrale de deux Blattes, Leucophaea maderae (F.) et Periplaneta americana (L.). Bull. SOC.zool. Fr. 92,
73-86. Bloch, B., Thomsen, E. and Thomsen, M. (1966).The neurosecretory system of the adult Calliphora erythrocephala. 111. Electron microscopy of the medial neurosecretory cells of the brain and some adjacent cells. 2 . Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 70,
185-208. Borg, R. M., Bell, R. A. and Picard, D. J. (1973).Ultrastructure of neurosecretory cells in the frontal ganglion of tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta. Tissue and Cell, 5,
259-267. Boulton, P. S. and Rowell, C. H. F. (1969).Degeneration and regeneration in the insect central nervous system. 11. Z. Zellforsch. microsk. Anat. 107, 119-134. Bounhiol, J. J., Gabe, M. and Arvy, L. (1953). DonnCes histophysiologiques sur la neuroskcrktion chez Bombyx mori L., et sur ses rapports avec les glandes endocrines. Bull. biol. Fr. Belg. 87, 323-333. Bowers, B. and Johnson, B. (1966). An electron microscope study of the corpora cardiaca and secretory neurons in the Aphid Myzus persicae (Sulz.). Gen. comp. Endocr. 6,213-230. Brady, J. (1967).Histological observations on circadian changes in the neurosecretory cells of cockroach suboesophogeal ganglia. J. Insect Physiol. 13, 201-213. Brady, J. and Maddrell, S. H. P. (1967). Neurohaemal organs in the medial nervous system of insects. Z. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 76, 389-404. Browse-Gaury, P. (1967). GCnCralisation, i divers insectes, de l’innervation deutoctrkbrale des corpora cardiaca, et r61e neurosicretoire des nervi corporis cardiaci IV. C.r. hebd. Sianc. Acad. Sci. 265, 2043-2046. Brown, B. E. (1976).F’roctolin: a peptide transmitter candidate in insects. Life Sciences, 17, 1241-1252. Burgess, I,. (1971). Neurosecretory cells and their axon pathways in Culiseta inornata (Williston) (Diptera: Culicidae). Can. J. Zool. 49,889-901. Burgess, L. (1973). Axon pathways of the intermediate neurosecretory cells in Culex tarsalis Coquillet (Diptera: Culicidae). Can. 1 .Zool. 51,379-382. Burgess, L. and Rempel, J. G. (1966).The standard nervous system, the neurosecretory system, and the gland complex in Aides aegypti (L.) (Diptera: Culicidae). Can. /. Zool. 44,731-765. Cassier, P. and Fain-Maurel, M.-A. (1970). Contribution B 1’Ctude infrastructurale du systkme neurosCaCteur retrocCrCbra1 chez Locusta mipatoria migratoriodes (R. et F.) 11. Le transit des neuroskcrCtions. Z. Zellforsch. Microsk. Anat. 111,
483-492.
114
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
Cazal, P. (1 948). Les glandes endocrines retroctrtbrales, des Insectes. Etude morphologique. Bull. Biol. Fr. Belg., suppl. 32, 1-228. Cazal, M., Joly, L. and Porte, A. (1971). Etude ultrastructurale des corpora cardiaca et de quelqqes formations annexes chez Locusta migratoria L. 2. Zellforsch. mikrosk. .4nat. 114, 61-72. Chalaye, D. (1967). Neurostcrttion au nivea,u de la chaine nerveuse ventrale de Locusta migratoria migratorioides R. et F. (Orthoptkre acridien). Bull. SOC. zool. Fr, 92, 87-108. Chalaye, D. (1974a). Ultrastructure de la masse ganglionnaire metathoracique de Locusta migratoria migratorioides (R. and F.) (OrthoptPre). I. Les cellules neurostcrttrices et leurs prolongements dan le neuropile. Acrida, 3,19-34. Chalaye, D. (1974b). Ultrastructure de la masse ganglionnaire metathoracique de Locusta migratoria migratorioides (R. and F.) (OrthoptPre). 11. Les organes ptrisympathiques abdominaux et thoraciques. Acrida, 3, 35-46. Clements, A. N. (1956). Hormonal control of ovary development in mosquitoes. J. e i p . Riol. 33, 211-213. Cook, D. J. and Milligan, J. V. (1972). Electrophysiology and histology of the medial neurosecretory cells in adult male cockroaches, Periplaneta americana. J. Jnsect Physiol. 18, 1197-1214. Cymborowski, B. (1973). Les variations diurnes de l’activitb des cellules neurosbcrktices du cerveau du grillon (Acheta domesticus).Acrida, 2, 299-306. Day, M. F. (1940). Neurosecretory cells in the ganglia of Lepidoptera. Nature, Lond. 145,264. de Lerma, B. (1954). Osservazioni sulla neurosecrezione in Hydrous piceus (Coleotteri). Pubbl. Staz. 2001. Napoli 24 (suppl.), 56-58. Deltpine, Y. (1965). Recherches sur la neurostcrttion dans l’ensemble du systkme nerveux central d’un lepidopthre, Galleria meflonellu. Bull. SOC. 2001. Fr. 90, 525-540. Delphin, F. (1965). The histology and possible functions of neurosecretory cells in the ventral ganglia of Schistocerca gregaria Forskhl (Orthoptera; Acrididae). Trans. R. t x t . SOC. Lond. 117, 167-214. Dogra, G. S. (1967a). Studies on the neurosecretory system of the female mole cricket Gryllotalpa africana (Orthoptera: Gryllotalpidae). J. 2001.London, 152, 173-178. Dogra, G. S. (196713). Studies on the neurosecretory system and the functional significance of neurosecretory material in the aortal wall of the bug, Dysdercus koenigii. J. Insect Physiol. 13, 1895-1906. Dogra, G. S. ( 1 9 6 7 ~ ) .Studies on the neurosecretory system of Ranatra elongata Fabricius (Hemiptera: Nepidae) with reference to the distal fate of NCC I and 11. J. Morph. 121, 223-240. Dogra, G. S. (1969). Studies in situ on the neuroendocrine system of the giant water bug, Belostoma indica (Lep. and Serv.) (Heteroptera: Belostomatidae). Acta anat. 72, 429-445. Dogra, G. S. and Ewen, A. B. (1970). Histology of the neurosecretory system and the retrocerebral endocrine glands of the adult migratory grasshopper, Melanoplus sanguinipes (Fab.) (Orthoptera: Acrididae). J . Morph. 130,45 1-465.
NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
115
Dopa, G. S. and Tandan, B. K. (1966).An in situ study of cystine and cysteine-rich neurosecretory cells in the brain of Sarcophaga ruficornis (Fabricius 117941 ) (Diptera: Cyclorrhapha).Proc. R . ent. SOC.Lond. (A), 41,57-66. Dupont-Raabe, M. (1951). Etude morphologique et cytologique du cerveau de quelques Phasmides. Bull. SOC.2001. Fr. 76, 386-397. Dupont-Raabe, M. (1956). Quelques donnkes relatives aux phinomines de neurosecrttion chez les phasmides. Annls Sci. mat. ( Z o o l ) . 18(2),293. Dupont-Raabe, M. (1957). Les mtcanismes de l’adaptation chromatique chez les insectes. Archs 2001.exp. gen. 94,61-294. Engelmann, F. and Luscher, M. (1956). Die hemmende Wirkung des Gehirns auf die Corpora Allata bei Leucophaea maderae (Orth.). Verh. d . zool. Gesell., Hamburg 1956. 2001. Anz. Suppl. 20, 215-220. Ewen, A. B. (1962). Histophysiology of the neurosecretory system and retrocerebral endocrine glands of the alfalfa plant bug, Adelphocoris lineolatus (Goeze) (Hemiptera, Miridae).J. Morph. 111, 253-273. Finlayson, L. H. and Osborne, M. P. (1968). Peripheral neurosecretory cells in the stick insect (Caransius ntorosus) and the blowfly larva (Phorrnia terra-novae). J. Insect Physiol. 14,1793-1801. Fletcher, B. S. (1969).The diversity of cell types in the neurosecretory system of the beetle Blaps mucronata. J. Insect Physiol. 15, 119-134. Formigoni, A. (1956). Neuroskcrition et organes endocrines chez Apis mellifica L. Annls Sci. nut. ( Z o o l ) . 18,283-291. Fraser, A. (1959a).Neurosecretion in the brain of the larva of the sheep blowfly Lucilia caesar (Diptera). Q. Jl microsc. Sci. 100,377-384. Fraser, A. (1959b).Neurosecretory cells in the abdominal ganglia of larvae of Lucilia caeser L. Q. J . Microsc. Sci. 100,395-399. Freeman, R. (1970).“Classification of the Animal Kingdom”, English Universities Press, London. Fiiller, H. B. (1960). Morphologisches und experimentelle Untersuchungen iiber die neurosekretische Verhaltnisse im Zentralnervensystem von Blattiden und Culiciden. Zool. Jb. A b t Allg. Zool. 69,223-250. Furtado,A. F. (1971).Etude des cellules neuroskcrktrices, de leur site de dicharge et des corpora cardiaca chez une Punaise vivipare, Stilbocoris natalensis (HCtkroptires, Lygeidis). C.r. hebd. Sbanc. Acad. Sci., Paris, 272, 2364-2367. Gabe, M. (1966).“Neurosecretion”. Pergamon Press, Oxford. Gabe, M. (1972).Donntes histochemiques sur l’tvolution du produit de neurosecrttion protockphalique des insectes pterygotes au cours de son cheminement axonal. Acta histochem. 43, 168-183. Ganagarajah, M. (1965). The neuro-endocrine complex of adult Nebria breuicollis and its relation t o reproduction. J. Insect Physiol. 11, 1377-1387. Gaude, H. and Weber, W. (1966). Untersuchungen zur Neurosekretion bei Acheta domesticus L. Experientia, 22, 396. Gawande, R. B. (1968). A histological study of neurosecretion in ants (Formicoidea). Acta ent. bohemoslou. 65,349-363.
116
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
Gawande, R. €3. (1969). Neurosecretion in the Vth ,instar nymphs of Schistocerca gregaria Forsk. Acta ent. bohemoslou. 6 6 , 70-80. Geldiay, S. (1959). Neurosecretory cells in ganglia of the roach, Blaberus cranifer. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole, 117, 267-274. Geldiay, S. (1973). Histological, cytological and autoradiographical studies on the new neurosecretory centre in the brain of three Orthoptera species (Anacridium aegyptium L., Acheta domesticus L., Melanogryllus desertus Pall.) Scient. Rep. Fac. Sci. Ege Uniu. 190, (Biyoloji 126), 19 pp. Geldiay, S. and Edwards, J. S. (1973). The protocerebral neurosecretory system and associated cerebral neurohaernal area of Acheta domesticus. 2. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 145, 1-22. Girardie, A. (1970). Mise en Cvidence, dans le protockribron de Locusta migratoria migratorioides et de Schistocerca gregaria, de nouvelles cellules neurosicrhtrices controlant le mCtabolisme hydrique. C.r. heb. S h n c . Acad. Sci., Paris, 271, 504-497. Girardie, A. and Girardie, J. (1972). Les cellules neurosicrktrices de la zone sousocellaire de Locusta migratoria migratorioides, R. & F., Ctude histologique, cytologique, autoradiographique et Cxperimentale. Acrida, 1 , 205-222. Girardie, A. and Girardie, J. (1973). Structure et fonction des cellules neurosCcrCtrices latCrales de Locusta migratoria migratorioides (Insecte Orthoptire). Conf. Eur. comp. Endocrinologists, Abtrs. 7th, Budapest, 1973, 212. Girardie, A. and Granier, S. (1973). Systkme endocrine et physiologie de la diapause imaginale chez le criquet Cgyptien, Anacridium aegyptum. J . Insect Physiol. 19, 2341-2358. Girardie, J. (1973). Aspects histologique, histochimique et ultrastructural des perikaryones neurosicrtteurs latiraux du protocCrCbron de Locusts migratoria migratorioides (Insecta: Orthopttre). Z . Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 141, 75-91. Goldsworthy, G. J. and Mordue, W. (1974). Neurosecretory hormones in insects. J. Endocr. 6 0 , 529-558. Golbard, G. A., Sauer, J. R. and Mills, R. R. (1971). Hormonal control of excretion in the American cockroach, 11. Preliminary purification of a diuretic and antidiuretic hormone. Cornp. Gen. Pharmac. 1, 82-86. Gosbee, J. L., Milligan, J. V. and Smallman, B. N. (1968). Neural properties of the protocerebral neurosecretory cells of the adult cockroach Periplaneta americana. J. Insect Physiol. 14, 1785-1792. Grillot, J.-P. (1970a). Recherches sur la localisation et la structure des organes neurohemaux mCtam6riques associbs a la chaine nerveuse ventrale chez ColCoptkres. C.r. hebd. Sianc. Acad. Sci., Paris, 270, 847-850. Grillot, J.-P. (1970b). Consid6rations sur la diversit6 des organes neurohemaux mitameriques associis a la chaine nerveuse ventrale de l’imago de Dytiscus marginalis L. (ColCopttre, Dytiscidae). C.r. hebd. Sianc. Acad. Sci., Paris, 270, 403-406. Hagadorn, I. R., Bern, H. A. and Nishioka, R. S. (1963). The fine structure of the supraoesophageal ganglion of the rhynchobdellid leech Theromyzon rude, with special reference to neurosecretion. Z . Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 58, 714-758. Hanky, M., Cottrell, G . A., Emson, P. and Fonnum, F. (1974). Enzymatic synthesis of acetylcholine by a serotonin-containing neurone from Helix. Nature, Lond. 251, 631-633. Hanstrom, B. (1940). Inkretorische Organe, Sinnesorgane und Nervensystem des Kopfes einiger niederer Insektordnungen. K. suenska Vetensk Akad. Handl. 3 ser. 18 (8),266pp.
NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
117
Herlant-Meewis, H. and Paquet, L. (1956). Neurosicrition et mue chez Carausius morosus Brdt. Annls Sci. nut. (Zool.) 18, 163-169. Herman, W. S. and Gilbert, L. I. (1965). Multiplicity of neurosecretory cell types and groups in the brain of the saturniid moth Hyalophora cecropia (L.). Nature, Lond. 205, 926-927. Highnam, K. C . (1958). Activity in the brainlcorpora cardiaca system during pupal diapause “break” in Mimas tiliae (Lepidoptera). Q. J l microsc. Sci. 99, 73. Highnam, K. C. (1961). The histology of the neurosecretory system of the adult female desert locust, Schistocerca gregaria. Q. J l microsc. Sci. 102, 27-38. Highnam, K. C. and West, M. W. (1971). The neuropilar neurosecretory reservoir of Locusta migratoria migratorioides R. and F. Gen. comp. Endocr. 16, 574-585. Hintze-Podufal, C. (1970). The innervation of the prothoracic glands of Cerura vinula L. (Lepidoptera). Experientia, 26, 1269-1271. Hoyle, G. (1974). A function for neurons (DUM) neurosecretory on skeletal muscle of insects. J. Exp. Zool. 189, 401-406. Hoyle, G., and O’Shea, M. (1974). Intrinsic rhythmic contractions in insect skeletal muscle. J. Exp. 2001. 189, 407-412. Huignard, J. (1 964). Recherches histophysiologiques sur le contrble hormonal de l’ovogintse chez Gryllus domesticus L. C.r. hebd. Sianc. Acad. Sci., Paris, 259, 1557-1560. Ichikawa, M. (1962). Brain and metamorphosis of lepidoptera. In “Progress in Comparative Endocrinology” (Ed. K. Takewaki), Gen. comp. Endocr. Suppl. 1 , 331-336. Johansson, A. S. (1957). The nervous system of the milkweed bug Oncopeltus fasciatus (Heteroptera: Lygeidae). Trans. A m . ent. SOC.83, 119-183. Johansson, A. S. (1958). Relation of nutrition to endocrine-reproductive functions in the milkweed bug Oncepeltus fasciatus (Dallas) (Heteroptera: Lygaeidae). N y t . Mag. ZOO^. 7 , 1-132. Johnson, B. (1963). A histological study of neurosecretion in aphids. J. Insect Physiol. 9 , 727-739. Johnson, B. and Bowers, B. (1963). Transport of neurohormones from the corpora cardiaca in insects. Science, N . Y. 1 4 1 , 264-266. Judy, K. J., Schooley, D. A., Dunham, L. L., Hall, M. S., Bergot, B. J. and Siddall, J. B. (1973). Isolation, structure and absolute configuration of a new natural insect juvenile hormone from Manduca sexta. Proc. nut. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 7 0 , 1509-1511. Junqua, C. ( 1 956). Etude morphologique et histophysiologique des organes endocrines de 1’Hydrocyrius columbae Spin. (Hemiptires belostomidis). Bull. biol. Fr. Belg. 90, 154-162. Khattar, N. (1968). The neurosecretory system of Schizodactylus monstrosvs (Drury) (Orthoptera). Bull. SOC. zool. Fr. 93, 225-232. Kahn, T. R. and Fraser, A. (1962). Neurosecretion in the embryo and later stages of cockroach (Periplaneta americana L.). Mem. SOC.Endocr. 12,349-369. Kind, T. V. (1965). Morphological study of the neurosecretory system of Spilosomo menthastri. Vestn. Lenigr. Univ., Ser. Biol. 3, 24-39. Kobayashi, M. (1957). Studies on the neurosecretion in the silkworm, Bombyx mori L. Bull. Seric. exptl. Sta., Tokyo, 15, 181-273. Kono, Y . (1975). Daily changes of neurosecretory type-11 cell structure of Pieris larvae entrained by short and long days. J. Insect Physiol. 21, 249-264. Kopf, H. (1957a). Zlber Neurosekretion bei Drosophila. I. Zur Topographie und
118
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
Morphologie neurosekretorischer Zentren bei der Imago von Drosophila. Biol. Zbl,
76,28-42. KSpf, H. (1957b). Beitrag zur Topographie und Histologie neurosekretorischer Zentren bei Drosophila. 11. Larven-und Puppenstadien. Verh. deutsch. zool. Ges., Graz. Zool. Anz. Suppl. 21, 439-443. Ladduwahetty, A. M. (1962).The reproductive cycle and neuroendocrine relations in Dermestes maculatus (Coleoptera: Dermestidae). University of London, Ph.D thesis. Langley, P. A. (1965).The neuroendocrine system and stomatogastric nervous system of the adult tsetse fly, Glossina morsitans. Proc. zool. SOC.Lond. 144,415-423. Lea, A. 0.and van Handel, E. (1970). Suppression of glycogen synthesis in the mosquito by a hormone from the medial neurosecretory cells. J. Insect Physiol. 16,
3 19-321. Lee, R. M. (1961). The variation of blood volume with age in the desert locust (Schistocerca gregaria Forsk.). J. Insect Physiol. 6 , 36-51. Maddrell, S. H. P. (1965).Neurosecretory supply to the epidermis of an insect. Science,
N.Y. 150,1033-1934. Maddrell, S. H. P. (1966a).The site of release of the diuretic hormone in Rhodnius-a new neurohaemal system in insects. J. exp. Biot. 45,499-508. Maddrell, S. H. P. (1966b). Nervous control of the mechanical properties of the abdominal wall at feeding in Rhodnius. J. exp. Biol. 44,59-68. Maddrell, S. H. P. (1967).Neurosecretion in insects. In “Insects and Physiology” (Eds J. W. L. Beament and J. E. Treherne), pp. 103-118. Maddrell, S. H. P. (1974). Neurosecretion. In “Insect Neurobiology” (Ed. J. E. Treherne), North-Holland, Amserdam, and Elsevier, New York. Mason, C. A. (1973). New features of the brain-retrocerebral complex of the locust, Schistocerca uaga (Scudder). Z. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 141,19-32. McLeod, D. G. R. and Beck, S. D. (1963).The anatomy of the neuroendocrine complex of the European corn borer, Ostrinia nubialis, and its relation to diapause. Ann. ent. SOC. A m . 56, 723-727. Meola, R. and Lea, A. 0. (1971).Independence of paraldehyde-fuchsin staining of the corpus cardiacum and the presence of the neurosecretory hormone required for egg development in the mosquito. Gen. comp. Endocr. 16,105-111. Meola, S. M. and Lea, A. 0. (1972). The ultrastructure of the corpus cardiacum of Aedes sollicitans and the histology of the cerebral neurosecretory system of mosquitoes. Gen. comp. Endocr. 18,210-234. Milburn, N. (personal communication). Production of neuroseaetory material by regenerating motor neurones in cockroach thoracic ganglia. Miller, T. and Rees, D. (1973).Excitatory transmission in insect neurornuscular systems. A m . Zool. 13, 299-314. Miller, T. and Usherwood, P. N. R. (1971). Studies of cardio-regulation in the cockroach, Periplaneta americana. J. exp. Biol. 54, 329-348. Mitsuhashi, J. (1963). Histological studies on the neurosecretory cells of the brain and on the corpus allatum during diapause in some lepidopterous insects. Bull. natn. Inst. agric. Sci., Ser. C, Tokyo, 16, 67-71. Mordue, W. and Goldsworthy, G. (1974). Some recent progress in acridid endocrinology. Acrida, 3, IX-XXXII.
NEU ROSECRETORY CELLS
119
Musko, I. B. and Novak, V. J. A. (1973). The structure and ultrastructure of the metameric neurohaemal organs in Gryllotalpa gryllotalpa L. In Conf. Eur. comp. Endocrinologists, Abtrs. 7th., Budapest, 1973, 223. Naisse, J. (1966a). ContrBle endocrinien de la differentiation sexuelle chez Lampyris noctiluca (Coltoptire Lampyride). 11. Phtnomines neurostcrktoires et endocrines au cours du developpement post embryonnaire chez le mile et la femelle. Gen. comp. Endocr. 7, 85-104. Naisse, J. (1966a). Controle endocrinien de la differenciation sexuelle chez Lampyris noctiluca (ColCoptire Lampyride) 111. Influence des hormones de la pars intercerebralis. Gen. comp. Endocr. 7, 105-110. Naisse, J. (1969). RBle des neurohormones dans la differenciation sexuelle de Lampyris noctiluca. J . Insect Physiol. 15, 877-892. Nayar, K. K. (1954). The neurosecretory system of the fruitfly Chaetodacus cucurbitae Cop. I. Distribution and description of the neurosecretory cells in the adult fly. Proc. Indian Acad. Sci. 40, 138-144. Nayar, K. K. (1955). Studies on the neurosecretory system of Iphita limbata Stil I. Distribution and structure of the neurosecretory cells of the nerve ring. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole, 108, 296-307. Nayar, K. K. (1958). Studies in neurosecretory system of Iphita limbata St%l V. Probable endocrine basis of oviposition in the female insect. Proc. Indian Acad. Sci. B, 47, 233-251. Nijhout, H. F. (1975). (Personal communication material in preparation for publication.) Cobalt backfills of retrocerebral nerves of Manduca sexta 5th instar larvae fill total of 42 cells in brain which appear to be NS, and a further 10-12 associated with “medial” cells which are probably not NS. Normann, T. C. (1965). The neuroseaetory system of the adult Calliphora erythrocephala. I. The fine structure of the corpus cardiacum, with some observations on adjacent organs. Z. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 67,461-501. Normann, T. C. (1973). Membrane potential of the corpus cardiacum neuroseaetory cells of the blowfly, Calliphora erythrocephala. J. Insect Physiol. 19, 303-318. Normann, T. C. (1974). Calcium-dependence of neurosecretion by exocytosis. J. exp. Bioi. 61,401-410. Normann, T. C. (1975). Neurosecretory cells in insect brain and production of hypoglycaemic hormone. Nature, Lond. 254, 259-261. Odhiambo, T. R. (1966b). The fine structure of the corpus allatum of the sexually mature male of the desert locust. J. Insect Physiol. 12, 819-828. Osborne, M. P., Finlayson, L. H. and Rice, M. J. (1971). Neurosecretory endings associated with striated muscles in three insects (Schistocerca, Carausius, and Phormia) and a frog (Rana).2. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 116, 391-404. Okelo, 0. (1971). Physiological control of oviposition in the female desert locust Schistocerca gregaria Forsk. Can. J. Zool. 49,969-974. Okelo, 0. (1974). Ph.D Thesis, University of California, Berkeley. Ozeki, K. (1958). Neurosecretion of the earwig, Anisolabis maritima. Sci. Pap. Coll. Gen. Ed. Univ. Tokyo, 8, 85-92. Panov, A. A. (1964). Neurosecretory cells of the abdominal ganglia of Orthoptera (Insecta). Entomol. Obozreniye, 43, 789-800.
120
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
Panov, A. A. (1965).The state of the protocerebral neurosecretory cells in the oak silkworm, Antheraea perneyi C u b . (Lepidoptera, Saturniidae) in the course of the larval development. Dokl. Akad. Nauk. S S S R (Biol.) 165,423-426. Panov, A. A. and Kind, P. V. (1963).The neurosecretory cell system in the lepidopteran brain (Lepid. Insecta). Dokl. Akad. Nauk S S S R . (Biol.)153, 1186-1189. Pflugfelder, 0.(1936). Vergleichendanatomische, experimentelle, und embryologische Untersuchungen iiber das Nervensystem und die Sinnesorganen der Rhynchoten. Zoologica, 34, 1-102. Pipa, R. L. (1961). Studies on the hexapod nervous system. IV. A cytological and cytochemical study of the neurones and their inclusion in the brain of a cockroach, Periplaneta americana L. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole, 121,521-534. Plotnikova, S. I. (1969).[Effector neurones with several axons in the ventral nerve cord of Locusta m i g a t o r i a ] . J. Euol. Biochem. Physiol. 5 , 339-341.(In Russian.) Prentd, P. (1972). Histochemistry of neurosecretion in the pars intercerebralis-corpus cardiacum system of the desert locust Chistocerca gregaria. Gen. comp. Endow. 18,
482-500. Raabe, M. (1963a). Mise en ividence, chez les insectes d’orders varics, d’iltments neurosicriteurs tritocCribraux. C.r. hebd. S h n c . Acad. Sci., Paris, 257, 1171-1173. Raabe, M. (1963b). Existence chez divers insectes d’une innervation tritociribrale des corpora cardiaca. C.r. hebd. Sianc. Acad. Sci., Paris, 257, 1552-1555. Raabe, M. (1965). Etude des phinomknes de neurosCcr6tion au niveau de la c h a h e nerveuse ventrals des Phasmides. Bull. SOC.2001. Fr. 90,631-654. Raabe, M. (1967). Recherches recentes sur la neurosicrition dans la chaine nerveuse ventrale des Insectes. Bull. SOC.2001. Fr. 92, 67-72. Raabe, M., Baudry, N., Grillot, J. P. and Provensal, A. (1974).The perisympathetic organs of insects. In “Neurosecretion-the Final Common Neuroendocrine Pathway” (Eds F. Knowles and L. Vollrath), pp. 60-71. VI International Symposium on Neurosecretion, London 19 73. Springer-Verlag. Heidelberg and New York. Raabe, M. and Monjo, D. (1970). Recherches histologiques et histochimiques sur la neurosiattion chez le Phasme, Clitumnus extradentatus: les neurosiaitions de type C. C.r. hebd. Sianc. Acad. Sci., Paris, 270, 2021-2024. Ramade, F. (1966). Sur l’ultrastructure de la pars intercerebralis chez Musca domestica L. C.r. hebd. Skanc. Acad. Sci., Paris, 263,271-274. Rehm, M. (1950). Sekretionsperioden neurosekretorischer Zellen im Gehirn von Ephestia kiihniella. Z. Naturf. 58, 167-169. Rehm, M. (1951). Die zeitliches Folge der Titigkeitsrythmen inkretorischer Organe von Ephestia kiihniella wahrend der Metamorphose und des Imaginallebens. Arch. EntwMech. Org. 145,205-248. Rehm, M. (1955). Morphologische und histochemische Untersuchungen an neurosekretionsche Zellen von Schmetterlingen. Z. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 42, 19-58. Riddifurd, L. M. and Williams, C. M. (1971). Role of the corpora cardiaca in the behavior of saturniiid moths. I. Release of sex pheromone. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole, 140,1-7. Rowell, C. H. F. (1971). The variable coloration of the acridoid grasshoppers. In “Advances in Insect Physiology” (Eds J. W. L. Beament, J. E. Treherne and V. B. Wigglesworth), vol. 8,pp. 146-198.Academic Press, London and New York.
NEUROSECRETORY CELLS
121
Saini, R. S. (1967). Neuroendocrine control of oocyte development in the beetle Aulacophora foveicollis Luc. J. hisect Physiol. 12, 1003-1008. Sandifer, J. B. and Tombes, A. S. (1972). Ultrastructure of the lateral neurosecretory cells during reproductive development of Sitophilus g-ranarius (L.). (Insecta: Coleoptera). Tissue and Cell, 4, 437-446. Scharrer, B. (1941). Neurosecretion. 11. Neurosecretory cells in the nervous system of cockroaches. J. comp. Neurol. 74, 93-108. Scharrer, B. (1963). Neurosecretion. XIII. The ultrastructure of the corpus cardiacum of the insect Leucophaea maderae. Z. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 60, 761-796. Scharrer, B. (1964). Histophysiological studies on the corpus allatum of Leucophaea maderae. IV. Ultrastructure during normal activity cycle. Z. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 62, 125-148. Scharrer, B. (1969). Neurohumors and neurohormones: definitions and terminology. J. Neuro- Viscer. Relat.lSupp1. IX. pp. 1-20. Schlein, Y. (1972). Post emergence growth in the fly Sarcophaga talculata initiated by neurosecretion from the ocellar nerve. Nature, New Biol. 236, 217-219. Schooneveld, H. (1970). Structural aspects of neurosecretory and corpus allatum activity in the adult colorado beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata Say, as a function of daylength. Netherlands J. 2001.20, 151-237. Schooneveld, H. (1974a). Ultrastructure of the neurosecretory system of the Colorado Potato Beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Say) 1. Characterisation of the protocerebral neurosecretory cells. Cell Tiss. Res. 154, 275-288. Schooneveld, H. (1 974b). Ultrastructure of the neurosecretory system of the colorado potato beetle, Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Say). 11. Pathways of axonal secretion transport and innervation of neurosecretory cells. Cell Tiss. Res. 154, 289-301. Schreiner, B. (1966). Histochemistry of the A cell neurosecretory material in the milkweed bug, Oncopeftusfasciatus Dallas (Heteroptera: Lygaeidae) with a discussion of the neurosecretory material/carrier problem. Gen. comp. Endocr. 6, 388-400. Seabrook, W. D. (1970). The structure of the terminal ganglionic mass of the locust Schistocerca gregaria (Forskll.) J . comp. Neurol. 138, 63-86. Seshan, K. R. and Ittycheriah, P. I. (1966). Iphita limbata St%l.: components of neurosecretory material. Science, N.Y . 153,427-428. Siew, Y. C. (1965). The endocrine control of adult reproductive diapause in the chrysomelid beetle Galeruca tanaceti (L.) I and 11.J. Insect Physiol. 11, 1-10,463-479. Smalley, K. N. (1970). Median nerve neurosecretory cells in the abdominal ganglia of the cockroach, Periplaneta americana. J. Insect Physiol. 16, 241 -250. Smith, D. S. (1963). The organisation and innervation of the luminescent organ in a firefly, Photuris pennsylvanica (Coleoptera).J. Cell. Biol. 16, 323-359. Srivastava, U. S. (1959). The prothoracic glands of some coleopteran larvae. Quart. J . micr. Sci. 100, 51-64. Srivastava, R. C. and Dogra, G. S. (1969). Studies in the neurosecretory system of the bug, Scutellera nobifis Fabr. (Heteropterd: Pentatomidae), with reference to the material in the aortal wall. Anat. Anz. 125, 525-534. Staal, G. B. (1961). Studies on the physiology of phase induction in Locusta migratoria migratorioides R and F. Publikatue Fonds Landbouw Export Bureau 1916-1918, nr. 40, 1-125.
122
HUGH FRASER ROWELL
Steel, G. G. H. and Harmsen, R. (1971). Dynamics of the neurosecretory system in the brain of an insect, Rhodnius prolixus, during growth and moulting. Gen. comp. Enclocr. 1 7 , 125-141. S ~ e r b a ,G . and Hoheisel, H. (1964). Darstellung des Neurosekretorischen Systems der Insekten mit Pseudoisocyanin. Z. mikrosk. anat. Forsch. 72, 31-48. Strong, L. (1965). The relationships between the brain, corpora allata, and oocyte growth in the central american locust, Schistocerca sp. 11. The innervation of the corporal allata, the lateral neurosecretory complex, and oocyte growth. J. Insect Physiol. 11, 271-280. S Iumm-Zollinger, E. (1957). Histological study of regenerative processes after transection of the nervi corporis cardiaci in transplanted brains of the cecropia silkworm (Platysamia cecropia L.). J . exp. Zool. 134, 315-326. Thomas, A. and Raabe, M. (1974). Les organes perisympathiques des Orthopttres. Bull. S O C . 2001. Fr. 99, 187-206. 1 homsen, E. (1952). Functional significance of the neurosecretory cells and the corpus cardiacum in the female blow-fly Calliphora erythrocephala Meig, J . exp. Biol. 29, 137-172. 1 liomsen, M. (1954). Neurosecretion in some hymenoptera. Danske Videnskaberns Selskab, Copenhagen: Biol. Skrifter. 7, 5 , l - 2 4 . rhomsen, M. (1965). The neurosecretory system of the adult Calliphora erythrocephata 11. Histology of the neurosecretory cells of the brain and some related structures. 2. ZellJorsch. mikrosk. Anat. 6 7 , 693-717. rhomsen, M. (1969). The neurosecretory system of the adult Calliphora erythrocephata. IV. A histological study of the corpus cardiacum and its connections with the nervous system. 2. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 94,205-219. rornbes, A. S. and Smith, D. S. (1970). Ultrastructural studies on the corpora cardiaca-allata complex of the adult alfalfa weevil, Hypera postica. J. Morph. 132, 137-148. ‘ri riman, J. W. (1973). How moths “turn on”; a study of the action of hormones o n the nervous system. A m . Sci. 61, 700-706. Triiman, .J. W. and Endo, P. T. (1974), Physiology of insect ecdysis: neural and hormonal factors involved in wing-spreading behaviour of moths. J. exp. Biol. 61, 47-5 6 . Truman, J. W. and Riddiford, L. M. (1971). Role of the corpora cardiaca in the behavior o f sdturniid moths. 11. Oviposition. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab., Woods Hole, 1 4 0 , 5-14. ‘l’riiman, J. W. and Riddiford, L. M. (1974a). Hormonal mechanisms underlying insect I,ehaviour.In “Advances in Insect Physiology” (Eds J. E. Treherne, M. J. Berridge and V. B. Wigglesworth), vol. 10, pp. 297-352. Academic Press, London and New York. ‘l’riiman, J. W. and Riddiford, L. M. (197413). Physiology of insect rhythms. 111. The I emporal organisation of the endocrine events underlying pupation of the tobacco hornworm. J. exp. Biol. 60, 371-382. 17iiiiithan, G. C., Bern, H. A. and Nayar, K. K. (1971). Ultrastructural analysis of the Iieuroendocrine apparatus of Oncopeltus fasciatus (Heteroptera). Acta Zool. 52, 117-143.
N EU ROSECR ETORY CELLS
123
Van der Kloot, W. G. (1961). Insect metamorphosis and its endocrine control. Am Zool. 1, 3-9. Veron, J. E. N. (1973). Physiological control of the chromatophores of Austroleste annulosus (Odonata). J. Insect Physiol. 19, 1689-1703. Weber, W. and Gaude, H. (1971). Ultrastruktur des Neurohaemalorgans in Nervus corporis allati I1 von Acheta domesticus. Z. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 121,561-572. Wendelaar Bonga, S. E. (1970).Ultrastructure and histochemistry of neurosecretory cells and neurohaemal areas in the pond snail Lymnaea stagnalis (L.). Z. Zellforsch. mikrosk. Anat. 108, 190-224. Weyer, F. (1935). Uber driisenatige Nervenzellen in Gehirn der Honigbiene, Apis mellifica L. Zool. Anz. 112, 137-141. Wheeler, R. E. (1963).Studies on the total haemocyte count and haemolymph volume in Periplaneta americana with special reference to the last moulting cycle. J. Insect Physiol. 9,223-235. Wigglesworth, V. B. (1940). The determination of characters at metamorphosis in Rhodniusprolixus (Hemiptera).]. exp. Biol. 17, 201. Wilkens, J. L. and Mote, M. I. (1970).Neuronal properties of the neurosecretory cells in the fly Sarcophaga bullata. Experientia, 26, 275-276. Willey, R. B. (1961).The morphology of the stomodeal nervous system in Periplaneta americana (L.) and other Blattaria. J. Morph. 108,219-260. Williams, C. M. (1948).The endocrinology of diapause. Biol. Bull. mar. biol. Lab. Woods Hole, Suppl. 33, 52-56. Wyatt, G. R. (1972).Insect hormones. In “Biochemical Actions of Hormones” (Ed. G. Litwack), vol. 11, pp. 385-490.Academic h e s s , New York and London. Zdarek, J. and Fraenkel, G. (1969). Correlated effects of ecdysone and neurosecretion in puparium formation (pupariation) in flies. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 64,565.
Note added in proof Chalaye (1975)has reported work which specifically compares LM and EM profiles of a wide range of neurosecretory cells, including A, B, C types as defined on pp. 67-68. The most interesting result is to show that Type C cells, as defined with Azan, are a heterogeneous population under the EM (see p. 67). Also, EM confirms the presence in the NCAII of type C neurosecretory axons, deriving from the SOG (see p. 108). References Chalaye, D. (1975). Etude ultrastructurale des cellules neuroskcrktrices du ganglion sous-oesophagien de Locusta migratoria migratorioides (R. et F.) (Orthoptkres). Acrida, 4, 19-32.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Specification of the Basic Body Pattern in Insect Embryogenesis‘ Klaus Sander Biologisches lnstitut I (Zoologic), Freiburg, i, Br. Federal Republic of Germany
1 2 3 4
. . . . .
Introduction The basic body pattern-elements and origin Modes of early insect development: from short germ-type to long germ-type Specification of the longitudinal body pattern 4.1 Fundamental concepts illustrated by experiments on cricket eggs 4.2 Dragonfly eggs-the concepts of activation and differentiation centres 4.3 The short germ-type of development: pattern specification in a growing blastema 4.4 Leaf hopper embryogenesis: transplantation of a “centre” and the gradient concept. 4.5 Beetle eggs and the increasing involvement of anterior egg regions in pattern specification . 4.6 Hymenoptera and Lepidoptera: potency regions and early organ determination challenged 4.7 Lower dipterans-mirroring heads and abdomens 4.8 Higher dipterans: no special status 4.9 Generalizations concerning longitudinal pattern specification and some data not covered by these 5 Specification of the transverse bilateral body pattern 5.1 Patterns formed by longitudinal halves of the blastoderm or germ anlage 5.2 Differences between transverse and longitudinal pattern specification 5.3 The differentiation centre revisited . 6 Genetic tools in the study of pattern specification 6.1 Mutants transforming pattern elements 6.2 Mapping of developmental foci 6.3 Clonal analysis and developmental compartmentalization 7 Cytological and molecular aspects of embryonic pattern specification in insects 7.1 Cytoarchitecture of the oocyte 7.2 Mitotic waves during blastoderm formation 7.3 Functional differentiation of nuclei 7.4 Blastodermal cell boundaries
.
.
.
. .
. .
. . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Dedicated in gratitude to Professor Gerhard Krause, Wiirzburg. 125
126 128 133 136 136 155 160 163 172 184 189 192 200 2Q8 208 212 212 216 216 219 219 220 220 221 222 223
KLAUS SANDER
126
7.5 Prospects for a molecular approach to pattern specification in the insect 223 embryo 8 Concluding remarks . 226 Acknowledgements . . 227 References 228
. .
. .
1 Introduction
The ways and means by which orders for different developmental pathways are handed out in proper spatial coordination to the parts of a developing system constitute one of the central problems of developmental biology. But despite many decades of research, most aspects of the problem must still be considered as unsolved. To quote Waddington (Counce and Waddington, 19 72): “But even though binocular microscopes, hair loops and glass needles have given way to ultracentrifuges, counters and fraction collectors, and the level of analysis is pushed down from the cellular to the molecular, the basic problem remains; what causal processes bring about the changes which we can see or otherwise detect as an egg develops into an ‘idult? The new methods of study have still to be applied to embryos if 1 hey are to provide answers to embryological problems.” In the field of pattern formation, optimal use can be made of these new methods of study only if they are applied with the proper questions in mind; starting off from the wrong hypothesis may mean years of detour. This consideration requires integrating old and new data from an animal &TOUP which, like the insects, holds much promise for the developmental biologist, especially from the genetical point of view. A special reason for writing this review was that recent evidence concerning the central problem outlined above has cast severe doubts on wme fundamental interpretations provided decades ago, and perpetuated since. It was long held that a differentiation centre associated with the 1 horacic region, and in some ways comparable to the amphibian organizer (see Haget, 1953, Seidel, 1961), conferred on the different regions of the prospective embryo specific orders for their future pathways of development. But from 1959 onwards evidence accumulated that it is the terminal rvgions of the pattern-forming system which play the ,key role in this process (Sander, 1959, 1960; Yajima, 1960). The possibility that these clifferent patterning mechanisms might be representative for different orders of insects was practically excluded by new data obtained since in a vxiety of species ranging from dragonfly to blowfly. This fact suggested reconsideration of the data on which the conflicting views are based. l‘herefore, the present review does not aim so much at providing an exhaustive source for references but rather should be considered as an
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
127
attempt to try and formulate a unifying conceptual framework from which to ask new (and hopefully, meaningful) questions. The author is well aware of the dangers involved in this type of approach and has therefore presented more original data than may be usual for a review-hoping thereby to counteract the bias necessarily involved in his line of argument. Some earlier interpretations which are doubted in the light of present knowledge, and some subsidiary aspects, are presented in smaller print in order to save space and t o enable the reader to by-pass these sections unless specially interested. Last but not least the author wishes t o apologize if he should have failed to quote correctly the source of one idea or the other. Considering the bulk of literature scanned and partly embodied (which includes some 25 research papers of between 50 and 120 pages each) it is nearly impossible to acknowledge the origins of every relevant thought. The present paper could not have been written in this style had not several recent reviews obviated the necessity for more exhaustive coverage. In this connection, particularly the two invaluable volumes of Counce and Waddington (1972) must be mentioned which tbe reader is urged to consult. Some reviews published since then will be quoted in the respective sections. With other literature, papers not included in these volumes have been quoted preferentially when there was a choice. The terminology employed requires some comment. Specification of developmental pathways is a term which has come into use rather recently (e.g. Wolpert, 1969; Bryant, 1974). Its use was prompted by the fact that previously used terms, such as determination, turned out to imply a variety of processes which should be treated (and therefore named) separately. The following processes involved in embryonic determination will be distinguished in this review:
1. Any embryonic cell or group of cells which later on will give rise t o a particular part of the body must be instructed by appropriate signals which specific pathway of development they should follow; this process will be called cellular instruction (see section 4.1.6.a). The term instruction does not imply transmission of an exhaustive set of prescriptions; it rather should be taken t o indicate signals which release appropriate programmes stored in the reacting cells.
2. Specification of a pattern occurs when different instructing signals 'are provided in a spatially coordinated manner. Pattern specification is considered t o represent the first step inpattern formation, a series of processes leading, via regionally different pathways of cell differentiation, to apparent differences between the different regions or pattern elements which together constitute the visible pattern. 3. In order to respond to a specific instructing signal by producing a
128
KLAUS SANDER
particular visible pattern element, an embryonic cell or group of cells must become committed to the developmental pathway indicated by that signal. The types of experiment reviewed here are not suitable for providing strict proof of the committed or determined state of cells or regions of the developing system; this can only be done by explantation (Gehring, 1972). Yet many experimental results described below have been interpreted to indicate a committed state, and others have possibly been misinterpreted because of failure t o distinguish between instruction and commitment as potentially separate steps in embryonic determination. Region-specific cellular commitment is thought to occur after pattern specification, and thus should fall outside the scope of this review. However, many experimental results can be interpreted to mean that specifying signals provided t o a given region of the system may change with time (e.g. Fig. 11 and Table 1); in this case the timing of commitment could decide which pathway a cell or group of cells is going to follow, and therefore cellular commitment cannot be excluded from the discussion of pattern specification. 4. Much evidence concerning pattern specification is derived from the study of egg fragments, i.e. parts of the system isolated functionally by removal (ligature, “pinching”, see section 4.6.1) or denaturation (cautery) of the remaining parts. If such fragments can produce visible pattern elements they are said to be capable of self-differentiation (independent differentiation). It is important to bear in mind that the capacity for selfdifferentiation may be lacking due t o other causes than the absence of instructing signals (section 4.4.3). The cells involved in the construction of a pattern element may be said to interpret the instructing signals which they received during pattern specification. Interpretation is yet another term proposed by Wolpert (1969) and it may be asked why 4;s stimulating concept of positional information has not been adopted, too, in this review. Actually, some results obtained in insect embryos fit in with this concept very well (Sander, 1975a), but I feel that t o some other results it could be applied only by stretching it beyond useful limits.
2 The basic body pattern-elements and origin The basic body pattern of pterygote insects, the central topic of this review, becomes visible at the late germ-band stage. This is the earliest stage where all segments and appendages of the insect body can be recognized. Incidentally, in many species it is also the last, because subsequent steps of development (e.g. head involution in higher dipterans, or specialization of
I NSECT EMB RYOG E N ESlS
129
mouth parts in hemipterans) tend to obscure the basic pattern. Stages prior to the germ band may also differ considerably (see sections 3 and 4). Therefore, the late germ band is the stage of maximum similarity between members of different insect orders and may thus be considered a hallmark of the whole taxon (KorpergrundgestaZt of Seidel, 1960). The insect germ band (Fig. l(c) and Fig. 5 ) initially is a two-layered structure corresponding to the ventral region of the larval body. The dorsal (= prospective inner) layer faces the yolk system while the ventral layer, . .
. . .
.
. .
(a 1 (b 1 (c1 (d1 Fig. 1. Some stages of embryonic development in the beetle Tenehio molitor L. (a) Fate map of the germ anlage stage as inferred by Anderson (1972) (slightly modified). The strictly embryonic territories (heavy outline) are surrounded by the prospective amnion (am). Longitudinal pattern: territories for procephalon (P), gnathocephalon (G), thorax (T) and abdomen (A). Transverse pattern: middle plate (hatched) and ectodermal material for fore-gxt and hind-gut (black), neurogenic ectoderm (outline dotted), purely epidermal ectoderm (lateral). The shape of the territories is conjectural (cf. shape of earlier germ anlage in Fig. 25(d)), but their relative positions are probably correct. (b) Invagination of the middle plate and circular constriction of the amniotic fold to cover the germ band. (c) The first segment borders appear in gnathocephalon and anterior thorax. (d) Germ band with appendage buds and f i s t signs of abdominal segmentation indicated. ((b)-(d) after Ullmann, 1964.)
which later on will furnish the whole body surface, is covered by the amnion. Yolk system and amnion are ensheathed by the serosa. This three-dimensional array of epithelia originates from a single cell layer, the blastoderm. By tracing cell movements back from germ band to blastoderm stage, a two-dimensional fate map can be constructed (Fig. l ( a ) ) which in the longitudinal as well as in the transverse direction may be considered to represent a linear series of different pattern elements. Both series are carried over t o the germ band, and in a formalized approach we may therefore view the basic body pattern as two linear patterns superimposed
130
KLAUS SANDER
on each other: a polarized antero-posterior sequence of pattern elements which will be termed the longitudinal body pattern, and the bilaterally symmetrical array of pattern elements oriented at right angles to this which will be distinguished as the transverse body pattern. These two components of the basic body pattern will be treated separately not only because of corresponding limitations in experimental approach, but also because apparently different formal principles are involved in their specification (Sander, 1971) (section 5.2). The elements of the longitudinal pattern fall into two classes: terminal structures and metameric segments. The anterior terminal structure, the procephalon, is very prominent; it consists of the head lobes including the anlagen of brain and eyes, and carries stomodeurn, labral, and antennal buds as visible landmarks. The posterior terminal structure is essentially limited to the region surrounding the proctodeum, but for simplicity the cerci in some species attached to the hindmost metameric segment (Fig. 5) will be considered terminal structures too. The metameric segments (metamers) include 3 gnathal segments (gnathocephalon), 3 thoracic segments, and between 8 and 11 abdominal segments. For identification of the metameric pattern elements, the following criteria are available: shape, position relative to other elements of the pattern, and specific appendages. With continued development, histological pecularities and specific cuticular structures may be added t o this list. Among the appendages, the different mouth parts as a rule can be identified rather early; in the abdomen, the pleuropodial glands of the first segment (considered t o be modified appendages) show early histological differentiation, while the cerci like the legs are useful mainly in connection with other landmarks. The transverse pattern as represented on the blastoderm fate map (Fig. l(a)) cannot be seen completely at the germ band stage (Fig. l(c)) because the most central pattern element, the anlage of mesoderm and mid-gut (also called middle plate), has sunk behind the lateral ectodermal parts (lateral plates) during gastrulation. The subsequent subdivision of this inner layer into different structures is probably under the control of the adjacent ectoderm (Bock, 1942; Haget, 1953; Louvet, 1964; see Krause, 1958b) and will not be treated here. The pattern elements which before gastrulation flank the middle plate laterally will later on give rise to epidermis and, from their dorsal surfaces, t o the ganglia of the ventral nerve cord. The pattern elements lateral to this neurogenic area turn into epidermis for body wall and appendage5. In the procephalic region, the middle plate fails t o form, and the ganglion-producing ectoderm covers a much greater area than in the metameric region; this is a speciality which will not be further considered. The blastodermal territories just considered are surrounded by the rather narrow anlage of the amnion, and by the rest of the blastoderm, which will
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
131
turn into the serosa (Fig. l(a)). The latter area is also referred to as the extra-embry o nic blast oderm. Development prior to the blastoderm stage is characterized by mitotic muItipIication of the original zygote nucleus. Each daughter nucleus becomes surrounded by a yolk-free island of cytoplasm. Such an aggregate is referred t o as an energid. It differs from a cleavage cell by the absence of a limiting membrane or plasmalemma. Therefore, during cleavage the egg cell instead of becoming subdivided into daughter cells turns into a multinucleate cell, here referred t o as egg plasmodium (in accordance with the terminology used in Physarum and the protozoan genus Plasmodium). Towards the end of cleavage, most energids become arranged at the surface of the egg plasmodium (plasmodial blastoderm stage). The oocyte plasmalemma thereafter extends and cuts in between the energids, and separates these from each other and finally from the yolky core of the egg plasmodium. The latter is then called yolk plasmodium (Krause and Sander, 1962), and the cells covering its surface constitute the blastoderm. It should be noted that the delay in subdivision of the ooplasm by cell borders provides physiological conditions quite different from those existing in the aggregate of blastomeres resulting from cleavage in most other animals; these conditions could permit or even require unusual modes of pattern specification during the plasmodial stages. The transition from blastoderm to germ band is initiated by changes in shape (and frequently also location) of some or most blastoderm cells. These changes lead t o subdivision of the blastoderm into germ anlage and extraembryonic region (Fig. 4). The next steps of development occur in a peculiar spatio-temporal order, starting from a focal region. This fact was first pointed out by Seidel (1924) who called the focal region differentiation centre (oifferenzierungstentrum). It is there that the processes of gastrulation and germ band segmentation are f i s t visible, and are first completed. This region according to Seidel is located somewhere in the prospective anterior thoracic region; but in other cases differentiation was observed to proceed in strict antero-posterior sequence (see Anderson, 1972). The lead taken by the differentiation centre is very conspicuous in some species (e.g. Apis) and less so in others; it is usually still manifest in later developmental processes such as histological differentiation. It should be noted that the differentiation centre was established on purely descriptive evidence and therefore represents the type of centre termed Initialbereich (initial region) by Krause and Krause (1957). The course of development just outlined must be programmed in the zygote genome and in the cytoplasm of the oocyte. The latter plays a decisive role for which the stage must be set during oogenesis. But as Mahowald (1972) put it: “The greatest lacuna in our knowledge of
KLAUS SANDER
132
oogenesis whether in insects or elsewhere is in the nature of the organization of the egg which produces normal development." So we must be content to draw conclusions concerning ooplasmic organization from observations and experiments during early embryogenesis. These indicate that considerable differences in oocyte organization must exist (see next section).
'""1
Fig. 2. The reference system used to convey topographical data. Total length of egg or embryo is set equal t o 100 per cent EL (egg length), with 0 per cent EL at the posterior egg pole (pp) (oriented towards bottom in all figures) and 100 per cent EL at the mterior egg pole (ap). Egg fragments are classified as posterior (left) or anterior (right); their size is characterized by determining the level of fragmentation on the per cent EL scale (for fragments shown, see values at the left).
(c)
(d)
( e l ( f ) (9) ( h )
( i )
Fig. 3. Various germ band patterns, and symbols used for classes of patterns in subsequent Figures. Patterns are classified as complete (f), posterior partial ((c)-(e)) or anterior partial germ bands ((g)-(i)). The individual germ bands shown represent the largest partial pattern classified under the respective symbol. The smallest partial pattern in the class would comprise one pattern element (segment) more than the neighbouring ~mallergerm band shown. With classes (c) and (i), the minimum partial pattern comprises only the terminal structures of abdomen or head. The absence of any element of the body pattern (extraembryonic development) is marked by symbol (a), patterns which could not be identified are represented by symbol (b). Rounded symbols (e.g. in Fig. 6) refer to results from uv irradiation.
133
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
The following conventions are used in this review. Developmental timing refers t o hours or days after egg deposition, unless stated otherwise. The egg side on which the germ anlage forms is considered the ventral egg side since the outer face of the germ anlage corresponds t o the ventral surface of the prospective body. With reference t o the longitudinal egg axis, locations are marked by their distance from the posterior egg pole, expressed in percentage of total egg length (per cent EL). The sire of egg fragments produced b y ligaturing etc. is characterized by indicating in per cent EL the location (level) where they were separated from the remainder of the egg; consequently, a large (long) posterior egg fragment will be characterized by a h k h value, and a large (long) anterior fragment by a low value of per cent EL (Fig. 2). Partial patterns resulting from operations will be symbolized as shown in Fig. 3 unless stated otherwise.
3 Modes of early insect development: from short germ-type to long germ-type Insect eggs display considerable variation with respect to overall size and to area of blastoderm representing the germ anlage proper (Fig. 4).However, the criterion best suited for their classification is representation of different body regions in the germ anlage (Krause, 1939). In one extreme, the short germ-type, the germ anlage represents essentially the procephalon and a budding zone which subsequent to the germ anlage stage produces the Hemimelobolo
(a1
lbl
lc)
7 Holometabo
Id1
(e)
(fl
lh) ( 1 1
lkl
IIl
Fig. 4. Some insect eggs drawn to scale, left-hand side views. Area covered by germ anlage shaded. Orthoptera: (a) Oecanthus pellucens (Scop.) (Sander, 1976); (b) Acheta domesticus L. (Seidel, 1966). Odonata: (c) Platycnemis pennipes (Pallas) (Krause, 1939). Homoptera: (d) Euscelis plebejus Fall. (Sander, 1959). Coleoptera: (e) Atrachya m a e t r i e s i Falderm. (Miya, 1965): (f) Leptinotarsa decemlineata Say ( W . Schnetter, 1965): (8) Bruchidius obtectus Say (Jung, 1966a). Diptera: (h) Smittia sp. (Kalthoff and Sander, 1968): (i) Drosophila melanogaster Meig. (Bier, 1970): (k) Calliphora erythrocephula Meig. (Alleaume, 1971). Hymenoptera: (1) A p k mellifica L. (Krause, 1939). References are to papers on which diagrams are based.
134
KLAUS SANDER
whole metameric part of the body (e.g. Tachycines, Fig. 15). In the other cxtreme, the long germ-type, the different body regions in the germ anlage ‘ire represented proportionally t o their relative dimensions in the germ band, and no differential growth occurs (e.g. Apis, Fig. 27). Between these cxtremes,’ intermediate forms exist where anterior metamers are repre\ented in proportion t o the procephalon while the remaining (posterior) inetamers originate from a budding zone (e.g. Tenebrio, Fig. 1);this mode I S referred to as the semilong germ, or intermediate type of early development. Compared to egg size, the germ anlage is usually small in the short germ-type while in the long germ-type it may reach from pole to pole; I)ut this relative length of germ anlage is not the essential criterion. Roughly correlated with these types is the extent of the peculiar movements of the embryonic blastema known as blastokinesis (Sander, 1976). In the short germ-type, the germ anlage soon after its appearance migrates around the posterior egg pole into the yolk system or to the dorsal cgg side, with head lobes trailing behind. The original antero-posterior orientation thereby becomes reverted. It is restored by another movement ,ifter visible segmentation and shortly before the flanks of the germ band ATOW out to close the body dorsally (Fig. 5 ) . In the long germ-type, a 1emporary stretching of the embryonic blastema occurs between germ anlage m d segmented germ band stages whereby the posterior tip is carried far up the dorsal side and back to the posterior pole. Although possibly a phylogenetic relic left from the movements observed in the short and intermediate germ types, this temporary elongation of the germ band must have some essential function which preserved it to this day. It could he required for gastrulation (Anderson, 1972, pp. 190, 198), or because the initial short germ anlage may not permit certain physiological differences 1 0 be set up within the blastema (Sander, 1975b). The special value of establishing these different types of development derives from their correlation with “determinateness” or cytoplasmic predetermination of early development. It had been noted by Seidel (1924) that insects on a descriptive basis may be grouped on a scale ranging from I ather “indeterminate” to most “determinate” modes of embryonic development, as exemplified by mode and timing of germ cell segregation. Krause (1939, 1961) reviewed further data relevant to this scale. He stressed the increase in cytoplasm, and particularly periplasm, as compared to yolk and lipid droplets in the oocyte, and the tendency towards nonproliferative embryogenesis with the more determinate forms. Bier (1970) traced these differences back into oogenesis and discussed their evolutionary implications (see also section 4). These may be summarized by stating that the evolutionary trend goes towards an ever-increasing degree of “prefabrication” of the embryo during oogenesis, the selective advantage
135
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
probably being an increase in number of generations per unit time, combined with reduction of the immobile stages between oviposition and hatching. Progress in this direction becomes evident when the one or two
6.5 10.5
3d
28
4d
42
50
54
62
h 70
10 d
Fig. 5. Embryogenesis in the cricket Acheta domesticus (L). (a) Cleavage and formation of the germ anlage at 23 "C. Stages: 6.5-h onset of cleavage (dots on ventral egg side (left) represent maIe pronuclei, H. W. Sauer, 1966); 10.5-h egg prior to 5th cleavage mitosis; 28-h uniform blastoderm; 42-h dorsolateral assembly of prospective germ anlage cells; 50-h germ anlage cells shifted ventrally; 54-h single-layered germ anlage; 62-h germ anlage during gastrulation; 70-h beginning of anatrepsis (see (b)) and subdivision of yolk plasmodium into large yolk cells ("yolk cleavage") (from Heinig 1967;courtesy of Dr S. Heinig, Marburg). (b) Anatrepsis and Katatrepsis. The posterior tip of germ anlage moves through the posterior egg pole and then in an anterior direction along the serosa. The remainder of the germ anlage follows suit and thereby gets immersed in the yolk system in reverted position (age 3-4 days at 23 "C). After segmentation and limb bud formation the germ band is being pulled back into its original position, mainly by contraction of the serosa (S) (age c. 10 days at 23 "C) (modified from Mahr; see Sander, 1976). A, amnion. (c) Germ bands after 44 and 61 days of development a t 23OC (drawings of G. Denger, courtesy of Prof. F. Seidel, Marburg). A, abdomen; G, gnathocephalon; H, head; P, procephalon; T, thorax.
KLAUS SANDER
136
months required until hatching in crickets, stick insects and termites are compared t o the 1-2 days required in higher dipterans (Anderson, 1972). Yet despite their high degree of prefabrication during oogenesis, even the most determinate egg types do not, with respect t o pattern specification, display the strict mosaicism that has traditionally been ascribed t o them (section 4.9).
4 Specification of the longitudinal body pattern 4.1
FUNDAMENTAL CONCEPTS ILLUSTRATED BY EXPERIMENTS ON CRICKET EGGS
Embryonic pattern formation has been studied in the cricket, Acheta domesticus (L.), by more types of experiment than in any other species or even family of insects. For this reason, and because it represents the intermediate type of development (section 3), the cricket data will be used to explain and discuss some basic concepts. These will be extended in subsequent chapters so as t o cover the short and long germ-types of early development. Some stages of normal development at 23 OC, the temperature used in all experiments reviewed here, are shown in Fig. 5. Cleavage leads to an uniform array of nuclei at the egg surface (28 h). Thereafter, streaming movements of the egg cytoplasm (H. W. Sauer, 1966; Vollmar, 1972) and mitotic divisions increase the number of nuclei per unit area in the region of the future germ anlage, so that by 42 h a large patch of closely adjacent nuclei can be observed in the as yet plasmodia1 “blastema” on each egg flank (bipartite germ anlage). These patches then merge ventrally to form the germ anlage proper (56 h) while their nuclei decrease considerably in volume (H. W. Sauer, 1966; Vollmar 1974). It must be during these changes that the prospective germ anlage nuclei become separated from each other by cell membranes, a process not clearly recognized in the cricket (Schwalm, 1965; H. W. Sauer, 1966); for practical reasons, the energids of the prospective germ anlage will here be called “cells” once they have started to assemble. Subsequently, the germ anlage becomes thicker and more clearly delineated, and shifts slowly towards the posterior pole and from there up the dorsal side. During this process, the head lobes and the anterior regions sink into the yolk; the germ anlage also stretches considerably and thereby acquires the shape of the germ band. The first segment borders make their appearance by 4 days. Their location indicates considerable growth of the prospective abdomen following the germ anlage stage (Fig. 5(c)).
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
137
4.1.1 Longitudinal patterns formed b y anterior egg fragments Anterior fragments of cricket eggs have been produced by ligature (Mahr, 1960), chemical denaturation of the posterior egg region (Mahr, 1960), and by pinching the egg transversely with a blunted razor blade (Vollmar, 1971; for technique see Sander, 1971). The following discussion will concentrate on the results of Vollmar (1971) since they were obtained with a superior fragmentation levels above curve A-A in Fig. 6(b), more than 50 per cent of germ band pattern, anterior fragments must not fall short of a certain critical length (9-13 per cent EL) irrespective of stage of separation. With fragmentation levels above curve v-v in Fig. 6(b), more than 50 per cent of the fragments fail to yield the complete pattern. Fragmentation levels above curve V-v in Fig. 6(b) in the majority of cases lead t o failure to form any germ band parts (extraembryonic development); this curve ascends rather steadily with age at fragmentation, starting from around 9 per cent EL and reaching about 30 per cent EL some time after germ anlage formation. With fragmentation levels between the two curves, incomplete germ bands are the predominant result from 45 h onward. All incomplete germ bands are anterior partial germ bands (see Fig. 3). When grouped according to the sets of pattern elements they produced, these fragments reveal three noteworthy facts: 1. For fragmentation from 47 h onward, the mean values of fragmentation level are inversely correlated to the range of pattern elements formed, i.e. long fragments form many pattern elements and shorter fragments fewer. 2. The mean values of fragmentation level for the smallest partial patterns increase steadily from 27 h t o 60 h (Fig. 6(b));a slight tendency to do so is indicated for larger partial patterns (0, 0) between 47 h and 60 h. 3. The spectrum of partial germ bands is stage dependent: the average number of pattern elements contained in incomplete germ bands increases with advance in age at which fragmentation is performed (Table 1).
(u)
4.1.2 Longitudinal patterns formed b y posterior egg fragments Posterior egg fragments have also been studied by Mahr (1960) and by Vollmar (1971) (Sander et al., 1970; Vollmar and Sander, unpublished). The results obtained clearly demonstrate that fragmentation by pinching off part of the egg is tolerated much better than fragmentation by ligature. Using the latter technique, Mahr (1960) was unable to obtain development in posterior fragments shorter than 30 per cent EL; with the pinching technique, a posterior per cent fragment as short as 16 per cent EL was
KLAUS SANDER
138
uv\......
. ..
lo0 40
t
30 J
w 20
8,
10 I
0
40
I
I
I
I
L
ic 1
3c 20 IC 7.32
51
51
50
31 I
h Fig. 6. Results from fragmentation of cricket eggs with the pinching technique (Vollmar, 1971) (diagram courtesy of H. Vollmar, Freiburg). The abscissa represents the time after oviposition when the fragmentation was performed. The point of fragmentation was varied and the ordinate indicates distance between site of fragmentation (fragmentation level) and posterior egg pole in percentage of egg length (per cent EL) (see arrows at inset). At hatching the larvae were examined and the nature of the pattern in the posterior (a) and anterior (b) fragments were examined. The various curves summarize the kind of patterns produced by fragmenting eggs at different levels. n, number of cases per age group. (a) Posterior egg fragments. When the egg was fragmented below the level represented by curve A-A, more than 50 per cent of fragments failed to produce recognizable patterns. With fragmentation above the level
139
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
TABLE 1 Frequencies of different results obtained from anterior egg fragments (6-12 per cent EL, see Fig. 5) of the cricket Acheta domesticus (L.) (Data of Vollmar, 1971, Fig. 49) Age at fragmentation Germ band terminating in 6h Head Thorax Abdomen Germ band complete
17h
28h
45-47 h
60h
16 1 0
8 1 0
7 2 2
1 4 5
0 2 6
3
11
7
11
2
found to produce a complete germ band (Sander et al., 1971). Discussion will therefore again be restricted t o results obtained by pinching off part of the egg (see Fig. 6(a)). Development of posterior egg fragments can take place only after some cleavage nuclei have reached this region. A fragment may then form either a complete germ band, a posterior partial germ band (see Fig. 3), or fail to form any recognizable germ band parts at all. In the last case, irregular aggregation of small nuclei, comparable to germ anlage nuclei, may occur (Vollmar, 1971). Failure to form any recognizable germ band parts is frequent throughout all stages tested (Table 2). The frequency of recognizable partial germ bands varies with stage. A few, lacking only parts of the head region, appear with the earliest fragmentation stage. The next two Fig. 6-continued represented by curve A-A, more than 50 per cent of fragments produced the complete pattern. Rectangular symbols indicate mean values of fragmentation level for fragments which produced the respective partial patterns (see Fig. 3). Positions of rounded symbols and dotted curves are transformed from Fig. 7(c) to comply with coordinates used here. (b) Anterior egg fragments. When fragmented a t levels below curve v-v , more than 50 per cent of the fragments produced complete patterns. Above curve v--0 there were more than 50 per cent cases of extraembryonic development. Rectangular symbols indicate mean fragmentation levels for partial patterns. For easier understanding of this frequently used type of diagram (see also Figs 7, 17, 25 and 30), the “profile” of results obtained a t 47 h will be described here. Fragments which produced nearly complete embryos lacking only parts of the abdomen were ligatured on the average at 9 per cent EL (mean value of all such fragments). Fragments producing the head and 1-3 thoracic segments averaged 13 per cent EL, and those which contained only head structures averaged 18 per cent EL. Positions of rounded symbols and dotted curves transformed from Fig. 7(b). (c) The above curves superimposed. Groups of circles indicate region of closest aggregation of nuclei (Schwalm, 1965). H, T, A, extent of the territories for head, thorax and abdomen in fate map established with small uv lesions by Kanellis (1952).
140
KLAUS SANDER
stages are charicterized by near-complete absence of partial germ bands (Table 2); therefore curves A-A and A-A in Fig. 6(a) run very close to each other between 28 and 47 h. Thereafter, the latter curve continues to rise while the former drops sharply; concomitantly, a sizeable percentage of partial germ bands appear among the results (Table 2). As in anterior fragments, the number of pattern elements produced by these posterior fragments is apparently correlated to fragment length (Fig. 6(a)). TABLE 2 Frequencies of different results obtained from posterior egg fragments (11-30 per cent EL) of the cricket Acheta domesticus (L.) (Data of Vollmar, 1971, Fig. 50) Age at fragmentation Result
17h
28 h
45-47 h
60 h
11
10 1
7 0
2 15
16
14
20
~~~~~~~
Complete germ band Posterior partial germ band N o germ band (extraembryonic development)
6*
18
* Only small defects in head lobes. 4.1.3 Patterns formed in anterior and posterior fragments of the same egg With early fragmentations including the stage 45-47 h, at best only one fiagment of a pinched egg produced pattern elements of the germ band. For stage 60 h, the situation is different. In about 30 per cent of cases an egg which formed a partial pattern in one fragment produced a recognizable partial pattern in the other fragment too. When considered together,
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
141
predominant wavelength 288 nm. If applied some time before germ anlage formation, irradiation with doses effective on later stages did not yield any germ band defects, nor did irradiation of larger areas. Even when the germ anlage had appeared, no defects could be produced by irradiating the anterior 315 of the head lobes or part of the prospective abdomen (hatched in Fig. 7(a)). However, irradiation in the intervening region frequently did yield defects, and these displayed a peculiar pattern. When defects were restricted to the larval thorax, only one segment was affected in 7 5 per cent of cases. The single segment defects dropped to roughly 50 per cent for irradiations which affected head parts, and to about 35 per cent when the damage extended into the abdomen. The other defects comprised mostly 2 segments if limited to the thorax; but defects located mainly or completely outside the thorax involved up to 4 (head) or even 7 segments (abdomen). These multiple-segment defects tended to appear in “polarized” fashion. When the uv strip was placed close to the anlage of the metathorax (as established by single-segment defects) the resulting damage as a rule was found to extend posteriorly so as to include some abdominal segments, while irradiations in the prospective gnathocephalon sometimes affected large areas of the procephalon, i.e. extended in anterior direction. Kanellis observed yet another and very interesting tendency among his results (Kanellis, 1952, Fig. 12): The correlation between irradiated region and pattern element(s) affected appears to be better when the region was determined with reference to the yolk plasmodium (distance from the posterior pole) rather than with reference to either anterior or posterior limit of the germ anlage, i.e. defects in a given pattern element appear to be due to irradiation of the cells located on a certain stretch of the yolk plasmodium rather than to irradiation of a certain stretch of germ anlage. For instance, in eggs with a particularly short germ anlage the antenna maps inside the head lobes, while in the remaining eggs it maps clearly behind the head lobes (loc. cit., pp. 453-454). If statistically significant, this difference might be of great value in recognizing the components of the developing system which carry specifying signals (see section 4.1.6.b). Using uv radiation of wavelengths around 264 nm (Baeckstroem filter), G. Sauer irradiated areas across the germ anlage which included the anterior or the posterior border and extended from there in posterior-anterior direction to various degrees (G. Sauer 1961b; Seidel, 1964) (see Fig. 7(b), (c)). With the doses used, irradiation proved ineffective with respect to the final germ band pattern if carried out before 40 h after oviposition, even if the whole prospective germ anlage was irradiated; this is not due to shielding of nuclei because these reach the egg surface before the 20th hour of development. From 40-42 h onward, a rapid change of reaction occurred. Tolerance for anterior as well as posterior irradiation became
~
KLAUS SANDER
142
00 I-
46- 50 h
80
---
a 60 0
$ 40
55- 62 h
-0------3 ---
20
0 I00
80
a 60 c3
$ 40 20
0
40
45
50
55
60
65
h
Fig. 7.(n) Shifting of germ anlage blastema and per cent GA scale with reference to per cent E L during formation of the cricket germ anlage (based on data of G. Sauer, 1961b). Small uv lesions in the hatched areas fail to produce any defects in the larval body pattern (Kanellis, 1952). (b) Results from uv irradiation of posterior regions of the germ anlage blastema (see inset). Ordinate refers t o distance indicated by arrow in inset. Irradiation up to level of unbroken curve fails in more than 50 per cent of cases to cause any pattern defects, while irradiation beyond level of broken cqrve results in extraembryonic development in more than 50 per cent of cases. Symbols indicate mean values of irradiation level for the respective partial patterns and age groups (based on data of G. Sauer, published in Seidel, 1964, Fig. 3). (c) Results from corresponding anterior uv irradiations (based on data of G. Sauer, published in Seidel, 1964, Fig. 4). (Calculdtions and diagrams courtesy of Dr H. Vollmar, Freiburg.)
strongly reduced so that less than 10 h later only the posterior 1/5 or the anterior 1/5 of the germ anlage could be irradiated without impairment to t h e final pattern (see unbroken curves in Fig. 7(b), ( c ) ) , Irradiation beyond
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
143
the limits indicated by these curves was followed by complete suppression of the germ band if carried out early. By contrast, later irradiations transgressing these curves yielded incomplete germ bands as the predominant result; with these irradiations, complete suppression of the germ band was obtained only if the irradiated area exceeded the limit indicated by broken curves in Fig. 7(b), (c). With anterior irradiations, the partial germ bands were of the posterior type, and vice versa; they can be classified according to the sets of pattern elements they represent (for symbols see Fig. 3). The mean values of length of irradiated area for these classes, as calculated for two age groups (Vollmar and Sander, unpublished), are set out in Table 3. They do not reveal any significant differences between earlier and later stages for either type of irradiation. Moreover, with the nonterminal classes (8 and @), no difference exists between corresponding mean values from anterior and posterior irradiations (Table 3). TABLE 3 Average limits of uv-irradiated area for production of different classes of partial germ bands in Acheta domesticus (L.). Mean values and standard deviations calculated from data of G . Sauer as published in Seidel, 1964, Figs 3 and 4 (For symbols see Fig. 3, for % GA see Fig. 7(a)) Posterior limit of anterior irradiation Anterior limit of posterior irradiation (see Fig. 7(c)) (see Fig. 7(b))
43-54 h
0
%GA
%EL* % GA
0
% GA
%EL
55-62 h
* 7.0
61.1 f 10.7 31
62.0
40.4 f 15.0 25
36.9 f. 8.8 17
38.6 13.5 25
24.0 f 10.0 14
% GA
23 % GA
* 41.1 * 10.8 50.7
8.7 28
53.8 f 5.6 21
25
36.5 ? 9.5 17
* % EL calculated for position of germ anlage at 50 and 60 h respectively t Based on less than 10 cases.
55-62 h
46-54 h
26.6t (14) (see Fig. 7a).
4.1.5 Irradiation of cricket eggs with X-rays The effects of X-rays on cricket eggs have been studied with a view to pattern formation by Schwalm (1965) and Heinig (1967). Schwalm (1965) was able t o show that in a germ anlage irradiated with 500 rad most of the nuclei are destroyed but the germ anlage is reconstructed by the remaining nuclei and by energids which migrate there from more anterior egg regions (Fig. 8). When the germ anlage region alone was irradiated with 1000 rad,
144
KLAUS SANDER
49h
+I0
4-16
+24
4-45 h
g .......I ::.......
.......
(a)
(b)
(cl
(d)
(el
Fig. 8. Substitution of the germ anlage in the cricket after X-irradiation of the whole egg (after Schwalm, 1965). The irradiated germ anlage (outline dotted) decays while viable cells assemble at its site to form a new germ anlage ((c)-(e)).
47h
+20
1 +26
4-42
+76h
..... ........
Fig. 9. Substitution of the cricket germ anlage after uv irradiation of the germ anlage region so that only a narrow dorsolateral strip of viable cells remains (shown black in inserted cross section) (after G. Sauer, 1962). A new germ anlage forms while the irradiated germ anlage decays (outline dotted).
all germ anlage nuclei were destroyed. Yet a new germ anlage was formed with energids which immigrated from the (shielded) anterior egg half. These had ceased to divide several hours before, as a first step in differentiating t o
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
145
form serosa cells. On arriving at the site of the germ anlage they resumed mitotic divisions, to reform the germ anlage within some 70 h after irradiation. This new germ anlage was capable of producing the complete body pattern in roughly 75 per cent of eggs irradiated between 47 and 48 h, and in about 20 per cent of eggs irradiated between 49 and 50 h. Schwalm also showed that irradiation of the posterior half of the germ anlage with a very high dose (6000 rad) at 65 h can be compensated for in some eggs. He did not study this process in detail but apparently the germ anlage retains its original position for an abnormally extended period of time (Fig. 29 in Schwalm, 1965); this might enable any cells reconstructing the posterior half t o pick u p instructions located there in the yolk plasmodium. The results which Heinig (1967) obtained by irradiation of the whole egg are even more interesting with respect to longitudinal pattern specification. He describes a variety of differential responses to LDS0 irradiations during various stages from early cleavage to the segmented germ band. Four phases characterized by different responses are of interest in our context: 1. Irradiation between 10.5 and 22 h after oviposition does not impair germ anlage formation or development, but causes defects in the serosa and in the yolk cells which subdivide the yolk system after completion of the germ anlage, i.e. about 50 h after irradiation.
2. Irradiations between 28 and 50 h produce grossly abnormal germ bands defective over many segments except in the anterior head region and in the abdomen. These germ bands cease development rather early. 3. Irradiations from 42 h onwards produce increasing percentages of germ bands defective in a single segment or at most a few segments, and capable of reaching the hatching stage. The defects depend on irradiation age in a clearcut spatio-temporal pattern (Table 4). Defects induced between 48 and 54 h are restricted to the maxillary, labial, and thoracic segments. From 58 h onwards, mandible segment and head lobes including antennae are frequently affected. Susceptibility for these defects vanishes in the time sequence of their appearance, beginning with the mesothoracic defects which cannot be induced any more after the 66th hour of development. A peculiar feature also observed by Kanellis (1952) after local uv irradiation is the occurence of duplicated appendages in the thorax with irradiations around 54 h (occasionally up t o 66 h). During the last phase, which begins around 74 h (with higher doses 70 h), the abdomen becomes involved. From the onset, localized defects may be found in any of its segments (Table 4). However, a subsequent decrease in X-ray sensitivity followed clearly an anteroposterior course, with the cerci being the last structure which still can be affected (as late as
KLAUS SANDER
146
TABLE 4 Frequencies of locally restricted pattern defects after irradiation of whole cricket eggs with X-rays (LDso) (modified from Heinig, 1967,~. 476). For stages see Fig. 5. Bold type: Median value of frequency distribution per deficient pattern element (lines), and neighbouring age class when median value fell next to it
48
Age (h)
50
54
58
62
66
70
Procephalon Eye Antenna
74
80
86
29 12 5
12 1
6 -
12 12 9 14
-
-
5 14 5 5
3 10 20 21 8
98
112
-
2
Metamers Mandibular 2 Maxillar 1 Labial 4 Thorax I 1 Thorax I1 Thorax 111 Abdomen 1-3
-
1 4 2 2
1 3 8 9 5 1
4-6 7-9 Cerci
4 1 5 6 1 -
2 - 4 3 13 6 7 2 3 1 5 2 1
7 3 2 3 1
2
-
4 29 13
8 29
112 h). With higher doses than L D S 0 ,a further class of results is obtained from irradiation between 70 and 80 h. This is characterized b y complete or nearly complete suppression of the abdomen. Near-complete suppression has a very peculiar aspect: if all but 2 abdominal segments are lacking, one of these is marked as the first abdominal segment by bulging pleuropodial glands, and the other must at least in part correspond to the last abdominal segment, because it carries a well-developed pair of cerci. With any higher number of abdominal segments up t o the normal, these 2 pairs of modified appendages are also always present. In the period immediately preceding phase (4), i.e. between 66 and 70 h, supernumerary abdomens attached t o the rhorax are occasionally obtained with LDs irradiations. 4.1.6 Some basic concepts The experimental results described in the preceding sections can be used t o illustrate some basic concepts which will be useful for subsequent discussion of data from other insect species. These concepts will first be outlined under separate headings and then summarized t o provide a model of pattern specification in cricket embryogenesis. It goes without saying that this model represents an extreme simplification of the events actually taking place. Yet the heuristic value of such a model is thought t o justify
INSECT E M B R Y O G E N E S I S
147
the attempt. The main merit of the model is seen in the clear distinction between two aspects of “determination”: the aspect of signalling t o a cell or blastema of the developing system a certain pathway of development (instruction) and the aspect of restricting the cell or blastema to that pathway so it can no longer enter another pathway (commitment; see section 1). a. Shifting of specifying instructions Anterior egg parts separated from the hindmost egg region at various stages and levels of fragmentation produce different spectra of pattern elements. Fragments too short to yield complete germ bands (mean fragmentation levels above curve v - v in Fig. 6(b)) at best produce small sets of anterior pattern elements (head parts) if separated early; if separated later in development, they yield increasing percentages of larger sets of pattern elements (Table 1). The capacity to produce the additional pattern elements which appear only after later separation (segments of gnathocephalon, thorax and abdomen) must be conferred on that particular egg region during the intervening period of development, and the influence conferring this capacity must in some form or the other come from the posterior egg region. Fragments deprived early of their connection with the posterior egg pole form only head parts or no embryonic pattern elements at all, while fragments with longer contact with the posterior pole region produce on the average considerably more pattern elements. When a region near the posterior pole (below v-v in Fig. 6(b)) is included in an anterior fragment, this will form the complete germ band pattern irrespective of the stage of separation; accordingly, the region near the posterior pole must be able t o trigger crucial changes leading t o formation of the body pattern. The data indicate that the posterior pole region does not, or not only, provide some general stimulus required for germ anlage formation, but rather appears t o be involved in providing and/or moving anteriorly prerequisites for different pattern elements to be formed. These prerequisites may be considered as instructing signals which move anteriorly and reach the prospective site of the germ anlage shortly before the germ anlage becomes visible. Their spatial distribution there would be compatible with the fate map established from small uv lesions (see Fig. 6(c)). Anterior egg fragments separated early from the posterior pole region would then fail to produce thoracic or abdominal segments because their cells were never instructed to do so. This interpretation is strongly supported b y results obtained after shifting material forward from the posterior pol? region in a leaf hopper (see section 4.4.2). b. Egg components carrying these instructions Previous reviewers have noted that in the cricket the yolk plasmodium must be crucially involved in pattern specification (e.g. Seidel, 1964; Counce, 1972). Considering the
148
KLAUS SANDER
(ontlitions under which a new, fully functional germ. adage forms after destiwtitm of the original germ anlage (section 4.1.4 and 5) this conclusion is haid t o avoid. The observations of Kanellis (1952) that small uv defects ,Lppe,tr t o map more consistently with reference t o position on the yolk plasmodium than with reference to position in the germ anlage blastema (5ectlon 4.1.4) would also favour the former as a carrier of instructing sig~i~ils. Yet the question remains open whether the apparent movements of 5pecifying instructions as described above are due to some progressive chanqe within the plasmodial part of the system, or to signalling processes between the ensuing blastoderm cells. Traditionally, there is a strong feeling that the plasmodial parts, that is the yolk system, play the essential role in piding germ anlage formation (Seidel, 1935, 1961) and in the gradual establishment of pattern (Sander, 1959, 1960). This feeling is based on the iole the yolk plasmodium possibly plays in the accumulation of the prmpectlve germ anlage cells (see section 4.2.3), and on the fact that during germ anlage formation the nuclei and/or cellular components of the system mow opposite t o the specifying instructions and therefore cannot directly transport these (Sander, 1959, 1960). However, as pointed out by Lawrence (personal communication), the apparent shifting of instructions might be due to signals spreading within the moving blastema opposite to the main direction of its movement. This possibility is in keeping with prcscnt-day beliefs on pattern specification in cell layers but would require a d d i ~ i o n dand as yet otherwise unsupported assumptions in order t o x c o u n t for some experimental results (see e.g. section 4.5.4). Therefore, for thc time being we shall assume that it is changes in the plasmodial part of thc 5ystem (egg plasmodium followed by yolk plasmodium) which become manifest as the apparent shifting of specifying instructions. c . 1)iactivation of nuclei or cells prior to instruction Until a few hours before germ anlage formation, large areas of the egg surface can be irradiated with uv light so as to eliminate all nuclei there, yet ultimately and after considerable migration of blastodermal energids a complete germ band pattern is formed in all cases; the irradiated area may be as large as one lateral half, or the posterior half, of the whole blastoderm (sections 4.1.3. and 5.1). This remarkable capacity for functional replacement of irradiated blastoderm nuclei and/or cells becomes progressively restricted fro11142 h onwards (Fig. 7 ) . Subsequent anterior or posterior uv irradiations lead to partial or complete suppression of the germ band if the irradiated area exceeds certain limits. This is somewhat surprising since elimination of the whole germ anlage by X-rays 5-6 h later, i.e. at 47-48 h, is followed in more than 50 per cent of cases by a complete germ band as the ultimate result of development (section 4.1.5). Different reactions of
INSECT EMB R YOG E N ESIS
149
cytoplasm and/or yolk to uv light and X-rays respectively, have been invoked to explain this difference (Seidel, 1964; Counce, 1972). But this possibility can be excluded because complete compensation may occur with uv irradiations up to the 52nd hour of development provided the treatment eliminates the germ anlage almost completely (Fig. 9, section 5.1). So there must be other causes for this difference, and these are not difficult to see. After X-irradiation at 47-48 h and after the type of uv irradiation just described, the decaying irradiated “blastema” is quickly overgrown by viable energids or cells from neighbouring areas (Schwalm, 42
54
42 h
1i (a 1
(b)
( C )
Fig. 10. Shifting of irradiated cells following bilateral uv irradiation of the areas indicated (data of G. Sauer, 1961b). Stippled areas mark location of defective cells and/or cell debris still integrated in the migrating germ anlage blastema (see Fig. 7(a)). Scale in 5 4 h egg indicates normal position of germ anlage. The experiments shown here are followed by formation of a complete germ band pattern, but later irradiations likely to cause accumulation of defect cells or cell debris somewhere between the two stippled areas yield defective patterns.
1965; G . Sauer, 1962); the result is an intact cell sheet located in the germ anlage region from about 65 h onward for quite some time (see Fig. 9). With anterior and posterior uv irradiations, the situation is different (G. Sauer, 1961b): the irradiated cells are not overgrown by unirradiated cells. Rather, they are being pushed along within the blastema over the yolk plasmodium of the germ anlage region (Fig. 10). After irradiation of appropriate areas, these inactivated cells will be located somewhere in the germ anlage region during the period when their intact neighbours receive (assumedly from the underlying yolk plasmodium) the signals indicating their future pathways of development. The irradiated cells cannot pick up
150
KLAUS SANDER
and/or carry out the instructions provided t o them, and this failure will cause the absence of anterior or posterior pattern elements observed after irradiation. Additionally or alternatively, the irradiated cells might constitute some kind of barrier for developmental stimuli spreading subsequently within the blastema (see sections 4.1.6.d and 4.1.6.e). The essential point in this interpretation is that cells damaged by an irradiation which causes a pattern defect need at the time of irradiation neither be determined nor even instructed t o produce the absent pattern elements, a fact first realized in principle by Seidel (1935) (cf. G . Sauer, 1961b, p. 210). This permits reconciliation of apparently conflicting results from posterior uv irradiation and from anterior egg fragments. In both cases, the same types of partial embryos may result, but it is only with experiments carried out between 55 and 62 h that the border of the irradiated area corresponds approximately, to the pinching level (cf. symbols 0 and fl in Fig. 6(b)). With the earlier stages (42-54h), the border of the irradiated area for a given class of partial germ bands is located much more anteriorly than the pinching level representative for the same class, and this applies to both anterior and posterior irradiations. This discrepancy can be understood on the basis that the irradiated cells subsequently move backwards (Fig. 7(a)) while the instructing influences move anteriorly from behind during the same period (Fig. 6(b)). Identical partial patterns would then be obtained in experiments at or before 50 h for two different reasons: uv irradiation would inactivate the as yet uncommitted energids or cells required later on for certain pattern elements, while the pinching operation would exclude from the anterior fragment the instructions needed for specification Qf these pattern elements. Finally it should be pointed out that the uv irradiations (and the pinching experiments) fail to support the notion that instructing influences spread from a differentiation centre within the germ anlage blastema (section 4.2.3): no significant differences were demonstrated between early and late irradiations with respect to defect location within the moving germ anlage blastema (Table 3). This result, on the other hand, is compatible with the interpretation proposed above: the prospective but as yet uninstructed and uncommitted blastoderm cells for various pattern elements apparently maintain their relative positions within the moving blastema throughout the period under investigation, even when irradiated.
d. Acquisition of the capacity for independent differentiation Some results obtained from posterior egg fragments require a further assumption in addition t o those made in the previous paragraphs. Apparently some regions of the prospective germ anlage initially need physical connection with others in order t o produce visible pattern elements. This will be appreciated by studying curves A-A and A-A in Fig. 6(a), which indicate an
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
151
all-or-nothing type reacti,on of posterior fragments up till at least 47 h of development. With the next stage tested (60 h), much smaller fragments than before prove capable of producing germ bands (albeit partial ones) (Table 2). The failure of comparable fragments separated earlier to yield any germ band parts cannot-under the assumptions made so far-be due to lack of instruction, for it is just these regions which become instructed very early (Fig. 6(b)). The conclusion must then be that these regions require some other stimulus in order t o translate their instructions intc visible pattern. They acquire this capacity from 47 h onwards-apparently not by receiving instructions which pattern elements to form, but by some other change. This change may be the inclusion of greater numbers of nuclei or cells in fragments separated once the germ anlage has started to form, but there might also be a specific stimulus required for cell differentiation which spreads from more anterior regions of the germ anlage subsequent to 47 h of development. This assumption is based on the suggestions of Heinig (1967) concerning determination and self-differentiation in the germ anlage (see next paragraph). The spreading of such a stimulus could also explain the “polarized” multiple segment defects observed by Kanellis (section 4.1.4). These could result from failure of the irradiated cells to pass on the stimulus required for further differentiation. The cells “leeward” to this functional barrier would then lack the stimulus, and therefore fail to carry out their instructions. Farther distally, the stimulus might spread from the unirradiated half over the mid-line and enable the cells on the other side to differentiate. One .possible type or effect of such a stimulus might be the separation of blastoderm nuclei by cell membranes.
e. Differential timing of commitment to segment-specific pathways of development At some time between germ anlage formation and the appearance of visible differences between body segments, the cells in different prospective segments must become committed to carry out different instructions, i.e. reach a status of determination at least corresponding to that revealed by in uivo culture of imaginal discs (Gehring, 1972). No direct evidence bearing on this process is available, but the period of differential X-ray sensitivity observed during germ anlage and early germ band stages (Table 4) has been considered as linked to it (Heinig, 1967). By superimposing on each other the curves shown in Fig. 7(b) and (c), G. Sauer (1961b) and Seidel (1964) concluded that from 46 h onward a process reducing the capacity for regulation spreads in both anterior and posterior directions from a “region of constitutive factors for differentiation” represented by the central 1/3 of the germ anlage. The reasoning on which this conclusion is based may be questioned, as will be pointed out on discussing the results of Alleaume (1971) (see section 4.8.2). Yet if
KLAUS SANDER
152
inferred correctly, the spatio-tempora1,aspects of this process would closely resemble those observed by Heinig with respect t o increased X-ray sensitivity (Fig. 11). The “constitutive factors for differentiation” could then trigger regional .commitment and/or confer the capacity for self differentiation on the more terminal germ anlage regions (Seidel, 1964, p. 131).
I
0
I
50
h
I
I
I00
132
Fig. 11. Diagram to illustrate pattern specification in the cricket as inferred from experimental results (see text, Figs 5 and 6-10, and Table 4). The movements of the blastema relative to the egg axes (see Fig. 5(b)) have been neglected. In the as yet plasmodia1 system, instructing signals (hatched) appear t o spread anteriorly from the posterior pole region; these are capable of releasing region-specific morphogenetic reactions in the ensuing germ anlage cells (see Fig. 6). Towards the end of this period, the blastema which meanwhile has formed loses the capacity to compensate for uv damage (dotted curves) (see Fig. 7). In the prospective embryonic region of the superficial blastema (stippled), segment-specific periods of differential X-ray sensitivity (hatched bars, see Table 4) may indicate commitment of blastema cells t o segment specific tasks originally indicated to them by plasmodial signals. In the prospective abdomen, differential X-ray sensitivity (black crescents, see l a b l e 4) appears to be linked to increased mitotic activity; it is apparently during this period that the pattern of abdominal segments becomes specified, because no segmentally restricted defects can be induced earlier in the abdomen (Table 4; Kanellis, 1952; Sauer, 1961b). Germ band drawing of G. Denger (courtesy of Prof. F. Seidel, Marburg).
Heinig ( 1967) considered the process causing increased X-ray sensitivity also to be involved in qualifying the segment anlagen for independent differentiation (section 4.1.6.d). The regions traversed by this process would then have acquired a status of developmental mosaicism at least down t o the level of segment specifity. This notion is compatible with the appearance, after fragmentation at 60 h, of the first cases where the partial
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
153
patterns from anterior v d posterior fragments of an individual egg add up to nearly the complete germ band pattern (Vollmar, 1971), and with the appearance of duplicated appendages after irradiation with X-rays and uv light (section 4.1.5). f. Pattern specification during proliferative growth According t o the uv fate map (Fig. 6(c)) the abdomen occupies proportionally less space in the germ anlage than in the segmented germ band (Fig. 5). It must therefore grow more intensely than the other prospective body regions after the germ anlage stage. This special status of the abdomen is reflected by several experimental results, particularly the fact that it always retains-or subsequently gains-perfect bilateral symmetry when more anterior body regions develop unilaterally after lateral irradiation of the germ anlage (section 5.1). The growth process, which is also indicated by strong mitotic activity after the 70th hour of development (Fig. 15 in Seidel, 1964), is accompanied by a temporary increase of X-ray sensitivity. This appears to affect simultaneously all abdominal segments from 70 h onwards, but subsides in a clear antero-posterior sequence (Table 4). The terminal structures, especially the cerci, frequently form even when a series of more anterior abdominal segments were completely eliminated by the X-rays. Heinig (1967) ascribed these results t o interference with a subterminal budding zone. The specifying processes going on there might be related to the model which Summerbell et al. (1973) have developed to interpret proximo-distal pattern specification in the chick wing. The prolonged capacity to compensate for uv damage, which was observed in the abdominal region of the germ anlage, is also found in the head lobes after anterior or locally restricted irradiations (section 4.1.4).The head lobes and the terminal structures of the abdomen' were also the only typical parts in the aberrant germ bands observed by Sander et al. (1970),and in those obtained from X-irradiation in phase 2 by Heinig (section 4.1.5). This might suggest a similar mode of pattern specification in both anterior and posterior extremities of the germ band, But the procephalon is much more resistant to several types of insult than the abdomen, as documented by formation of isolated heads or head parts following irradiation of the germ anlage (G. Sauer, 1962; Schwalm, 1965);also no phases of increased sensitivity to X-rays were observed there so far. It remains to be seen how far this special status of the most anterior germ anlage region is connected with the special possibilities for cell replacement existing there (see Fig. 10)and/or the bulk of some structures deriving from it (brain!).
4.1.7 A comprehensive model of longitudinal body pattern formation in the cricket The concepts discussed in the preceding paragraphs have been summarized in a comprehensive diagram (Fig. 11). It distinguishes between processes occurring at two different levels of structural organization, the level of
KLAUS SANDER
154
ool)lasmic (plasmodial) and the level of intrablastemic reactions (Krause, 1 9 bXb). During cleavage and subsequent plasmodia1 stages, gradual changes m ' c Iir (hatched pattern in Fig. 11) which confer on different egg regions the cap,icity to signal different courses of development t o the blastoderm cells wh1c.h move there during germ anlage formation. For reasons set out above (sec.rion 4.1.6.b)these changes are thought t o occur at the ooplasmic level. 'I'he events at the blastemic level are represented in a manner which disi c,gards the movements of the blastema relative t o the yolk plasmodium (set. Figs 4 and 7(a)). The first change probably occurring at the blastemic ievc~lis the progressive loss of the faculty to compensate for uv damage (see Fig. 7(b); (c)). This effect may be linked t o restrictions concerning mowments (and perhaps proliferation) of energids or cells while these apptoach the site where the germ anlage will form. In the germ anlage, the cells become committed to the tasks indicated t o them by instructing si,i'n.ils (assumedly from the underlying yolk plasmodium) and may qualify con urrently for independent differentiation at the level of individual segments or body regions. These processes are thought t o be linked t o a temi)orary state of increased X-ray sensitivity (hatched bars in Fig. 11) which sprc.'ids in a characteristic spatio-temporal order from the prothoracic regii )n through gnathocephalon and posterior thorax. This state of inci cased radiation sensitivity requires about 4 h t o spread from one segment t o the next, and lasts roughly 15-20 h per segment (Heinig, 1967). 'The germ anlage then begins t o move posteriorly and passes around the pos~erioregg pole to the dorsal side (see Fig. 4); during these movements its ovet ~ l llength increases, mainly because of proliferative growth of the prohpective abdomen. Abdominal growth is accompanied b y a particular pat1 cm of temporarily increased X-ray sensitivity, which may indicate pro( esses of both cellular instruction and commitment. This pattern (black bars in Fig. 11) is characterized by simultaneous onset, but sequential termination of increased X-ray sensitivity in different regions of the abdi )men-a type of reaction possibly related t o successive pattern specification by a progress zone (section 4.1.6). In the end, the basic body pattern becomes visible when the segment borders appear in a spatio-temporal ordrr rcminiscent of that observed for the decrease of specific X-ray sensitivity (cf. Fig. 5 and Table 4). l'his model can account for most data presented here. The most nott worthy exception is the observation that with increasing fragmentation age posterior fragments have t o be increasingly longer in order t o produce the complete pattern (see curve A-A in Fig. 6(a)). This is a type of result raw in longitudinal pattern formation in insects, yet commonly expected from fragments of "regulating" embryonic systems: the more time available (
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
155
for regulation, the better they should do. Perhaps this result is to be seen in connection with the forward spreading of instructing influences (Fig. 6(b) and (c)) but even then it would require some additional assumptions.
4.2 DRAGONFLY EGGS-
CONCEPTS OF ACTIVATION AND DIFFERENTIATION CENTRES
The extensive studies of Seidel (1926-1936, 1961, 1966) on the egg of the damsel fly Platycnemis pennipes (Pallas) have provided a conceptual framework which many authors have used to interpret their results. Yet the original data, however carefully .collected and interpreted, have meanwhile been surpassed in several respects by those established for the cricket and some other insects, notably leaf hoppers and beetles. In the light of new concepts derived from these I shall try to reassess the interpretations Seidel offered for his data. Time will doubtless restore both original merit and present criticism t o their deserved proportions. 4.2.1 Longitudinal patterns formed b y fragments of dragonfly eggs Anterior fragments of dragonfly eggs produced by ligature, cautery or pinching have been studied with respect t o pattern formation by Seidel (1926-1936) and by Vollmar and Sander (unpublished data); the studies of Schanz (1965) and Bergmann-Schanz (1967) were only marginally concerned with the segment pattern a germ anlage could produce. The pinching experiments performed by Vollmar and Sander (unpublished) on the egg of Aeschna cyanea L. yielded results compatible with those from the cricket shown in Fig. 6(c). Whether the spectrum of partial germ bands also varies with stage as shown in Table 1 for the cricket remains at present open, because only a single type of partial pattern (isolated head parts) has been obtained so far. Anterior egg fragments produced by cauterization of the posterior egg pole in Platycnemis display a similar range of reactions. Figure 1 2 summarizes the relevant data published by Seidel (1929a). The overall resemblance to the data obtained by pinching cricket eggs (Fig. 6(b)) is obvious. Complete germ band patterns result in Platycnemis (at 20.3 "C) independent of stage only if the level of cauterization does not exceed values between 10 and 12 per cent EL (cricket: 9-13 per cent EL). Partial germ bands are not observed at all with the earlier stages, but from 25 h onward they appear in ever shorter fragments, as in the cricket. The resulting shift from extraembryonic development to partial germ bands as the predominant result is also observed with other temperatures (see top of Fig. 12).
KLAUS SANDER
156
0 OR1
I
31 80%
20 = 5Q0/o
I = 2%
-
9 = 22%
7 = 18%
I I = 28%
9 = 2 I O/O
27 = 6l%
8 = 18%
1
0
t
I
I
I
I
17
20
30
38
h Fig. 12. Longitudinal patterns obtained after cautery of the posterior egg pole in the damsel-fly Platycnemis pennipes (data of Seidel, 1929a). The results in the diagram were obtained from eggs raised at 20.3 OC. The figures at the top represent pooled data (number of cases and percentage) from experiments at 20.3 OC, 25 OC and 17.9 OC corrected for differences in speed of development (Figs 6 4 6 6 in Seidel, 1929a). The upper curve illustrates Seidel’s “activation” effect, the lower curve (added here) marks the limit to which the egg apparently can be cauterized without causing defects to the final pattern. U = units of eye piece grid used by Seidel.
4.2.2 The activation centre concept The results summarized in Fig. 12 were originally ascribed by Seidel to influences spreading from a centre located near the posterior egg pole. A dual effect was thought t o emanate from there: the centre was not only supposed to activate the egg t o form a germ anlage, but it was also thought to influence the specific courses of development which the different parts of the system were to take. Vom Bildungszentrum der Keimanlage geht nicht nur ein aktivierender Einflufi aus, sondern es ist auch an der Bestimmung der Teile fur ihre Aufgaben beteilzgt. (Seidel, 1929a, p. 433). Accordingly, it was considered to represent a “determination centre” (Seidel, 1926, pp. 340-341). However, a few years later this centre was stripped of its influence on pattern specification and reduced to the role of activating anterior egg regions, and particularly the differentiation centre, for formation of a germ anlage blastema (e.g. Seidel, 1961, p. 127). Only recently a return to the original interpretation was indicated by Schanz (1965, p. 89).
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
157
Before deserting the idea of a determination centre, Seidel(1929a, p. 437) proposed a crucial test to demonstrate the influence of the posterior centre on pattern specification: to permit the centre to exert its influence on other egg regions than normal. Without knowledge of this proposal, such an experiment was performed almost 30 years later in the leaf hopper Euscelis and yielded the proof Seidel appears to have expected when proposing the test in 1929 (see section 4.4.2).
4.2.3 The dzjferentiation centre concept With the decline of the posterior egg region from determination centre (Seidel, 1926) to activation centre, the differentiation centre (see section 2) became invested with a physiological function-or, more probably, increasing evidence in favour of a physiological role for the differentiation centre sent the Determinierungszentrum-and the relevant data!-into oblivion. The first definite physiological role attached t o the differentiation centre was to cause, in a rather mechanical way, the blastoderm nuclei or cells to assemble so as to form the germ anlage (Seidel, 1934); in the end, the centre was invested with the function of assigning t o different regions of the germ anlage their developmental tasks or potencies (e.g. Seidel, 1961, pp. 136 and 140). How firm is the evidence in favour of this idea, which is at variance with both Seidel’s earlier interpretation and many results obtained since? As for the mechanical (“dynamic”) activities of the differentiation centre stressed by Seidel (1934), investigations on related species have failed to support his notion that local contraction of the yolk system is as such sufficient to cause formation of a germ anlage. In the damsel fly Zschnura elegans, Schanz (1965, p. 89) found that partial suppression of the activation centre by cautery did not prevent the retraction of yolk plasmodium from egg shell, yet no part of the germ band was formed. Similarly, Vollmar (1974) observed that after fragmentation of the cricket egg at 30 per cent EL during cleavage, blastoderm nuclei assemble in the anterior fragment where the head lobes should form, but fail to turn into (small) germ anlage nuclei, and no part of the germ band is produced. Apparently, in both cases an additional (probably instructing) influence from the posterior egg region is needed t o cause these cells to form parts of the embryo. The notion of the differentiation centre as a region from which 66 potencies’’ for the different elements of the germ band pattern spread in anterior and posterior directions was most clearly stated by M. Schnetter (1934a) on the basis of fragmentations of honey bee eggs (see section 4.6). Schnetter’s idea was adopted by Seidel for Platycnemis (Seidel, 1961, p. 140). The experimental evidence in the latter species has not been published but only reviewed (Seidel, 1961). It is illustrated by Fig. 13. The solid transverse lines on the egg indicate a fate map established for the late
158 Instr. BI.
KLAUS SANDER
Def.
uv+
Fig. 13. Mapping wit. regional uv-defects in Phtycnemis. Right: E-stodermal anlagen (continuous border lines) and “potency regions” (stippled) as inferred from defects due to small uv lesions inflicted at c. 49 and 43 h, respectively, after oviposition (approximately 21 “C) (after Seidel, 1961). The differences between the two maps are here interpreted as due to progressive loss of the capability to compensate uv damage. Note also the restriction of the early defects to the ventral (= median) region; this is compatible with medio-lateral progress of cellular commitment and/or loss of capability to compensate for uv damage as demonstratedby other experiments (see section 5 ) . Left and centre: Model to explain the topographic discrepancies between “anlagen” and “potency regions”. Left: Assume that a sample of small lesions (Def. +) evenly distributed over the prospective territory for a certain pattern element (D) were produced by inflicting one lesion per egg. The meanvalue (a) of location of these lesions for all eggs which developed a defect in that pattern element will then be Iocated half-way between territory borders (top figure). If part of the territory at the time of irradiation could still compensate uv damage (part not hatched in bottom figure), irradiations located in this part would produce no visible pattern defects (Def. -) and the mean value for irradiations which visibly affect the pattern element would shift accordingly (see X in bottom figure). Note that the energids or cells in the irradiated blastema need not yet be instructed t o produce that particular pattern element (see section 4.1.6.b). Centre: Assuming that the capacity to compensate uv damage is lost progressively over a series of territories (A-E) starting from a central region (C), a sample comprising the stages marked 1, 2, and 3 will yield “shifted” or nonrepresentative mean values for all but the most central pattern elements (see ‘‘X1--3’’). The degree of deviation from the mean values for segment anlagen established by “late” irradiations (at right) would increase with distance from the centre (C)-as found by Seidel. The same effect could also be obtained with several slightly different assumptions based on the same principle.
blastoderm stage by defect mapping with small uv lesions (Seidel, 1935). The shaded areas represent a map of “Potenzbereiche” for individual segments (not for body regions as defined by Schnetter) derived by the same rationale from experiments carried out during late cleavage (c. 34 h at 20.9 “C), i.e. c. 6 h earlier. Comparing both maps, a striking longitudinal
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
159
aspect is revealed: with increasing distance from the middle region of the blastoderm fate map (i.e. from Th, segment, see arrow), the shaded areas shift more and more towards the proximal border of the corresponding anlagen, but do not transgress these borders. Since the shaded areas were inferred statistically, this kind of arrangement suggests increasingly skewed distributions, with concomitant shifting of mean values. Considering the
‘J‘
t
.. <’,
?
-I
w
s -
i I
f-
Fig. 14. (a) Diagram to illustrate Seidel’s concepts of activation centre (AC) and differentiation centre (DC) in Platycnemis. Once the AC has been triggered by a cleavage energid (not shown) it activates progressively more anterior egg regions (ascending curve) so that they may autonomously produce a germ anlage. Instructions specifying the body pattern spread then (arrows) from the DC where they were assembled as “potency regions” (see Fig. 13, egg at right). Under these assumptions, anterior egg fragments endowed with an activated DC should either produce complete germ bands, or partial germ bands deficient due to lack of space for realization of the potencies present; in this case the horizontal lines in the diagram might indicate the spatial restrictions imposed on the expression of the potency t o form the respective pattern elements. With early fragmentations, when fragments have t o be long in order to include part of the already activated region, lack of space would affect only the most posterior pattern elements. Therefore the earliest partial germ bands to be obtained (arrow a t left) should comprise large sets of pattern elements. This could also be expected with mosaic-type preformation of determinants for the various pattern elements; in this case the horizontal lines would reflect the spatial arrangement of these determinants. (b) Coordinated forward spreading of instruction required for various pattern elements, as suggested by results obtained in the cricket (Figs 6(b) and 11).With this mode of pattern specification, the earliest partial germ bands to be obtained (arrow) should comprise only very few pattern elements. t , time axis. Fragments terminating in the dotted regions should contain the potency to form a complete pattern.
well-established fact that uv defects can still be compensated for in more terminal regions when this is no longer possible in between (Seidel, 1961, p. 139: Figs 7 and 2 5 ) , one may speculate how a skewed distribution of recognizable defects could result from uv lesions on a basically unaltered pattern of segmental instructions, as shown in Fig. 13. However, it must be born in mind that higher uv doses were used with the earlier stage (Seidel, personal communication), a fact which may also have influenced the results.
160
KLAUSSANDER
It may be useful to close this discussion with an attempt to grasp diagrammatically the essential differences between Seidel’s final interpretation of his Platycnemis results, and the interpretation derived above (section 4.1.6.a) from pinching experiments in the cricket. The diagrams in Fig. 1 4 permit some predictions. With an “instructing” differentiation centre, anterior fragments activated for germ anlage formation by the spreading activation centre effect (dotted in Fig. 14(a)),when isolated during early stages, must either all yield complete germ bands, or complete germ bands and partial germ bands comprising large sets of pattern elements (0, left arrow in Fig. 14(a)). With the spreading of instructing influences from the posterior pole region, on the other hand, the earliest partial germ bands to be obtained can merely comprise small sets of pattern elements (fl, arrow in Fig. 14(b)), and larger sets may only be obtained later on. The cricket results clearly fulfil the latter expectations (Table l ) , and OUT Aeschna results are compatible with it because the only type of partial germ band obtained so far comprised exclusively head parts (section 4.2.1). Seidel’s Platycnemis data (Fig. 12) appear quantitatively insufficient for any decision on this issue; the two early cases of large sets of pattern elements (0) would favour an interpretation as in Fig. 14(a), but the remaining data are also compatible with an interpretation as in Fig. 14(b\. Certainly, further results are needed t o show whether Platycnemis really differs from Aeschna and the cricket with respect to the mode of pattern specification.
4.3
THE SHORT GERM-TYPE OF DEVELOPMENT: PATTERN SPECIFICATION IN A GROWING BLASTEMA
In the examples treated so far, the germ anlage was of the intermediate type (see section 2). In a variety of forms belonging to different insect orders, the germ anlage corresponds mainly to the head lobes (short germ type); in these cases, transformation of the germ anlage into the germ band is accompanied by considerable growth not only of the prospective abdomen but also of the thoracic and gnathal regions. With some of these species, specification of the segment pattern appears to occur more or less independently of specific instructing cues from the yolk plasmodium. This is indicated by several observations. In Curuusius morosus Br. a fully functional “replacement germ anlage” may form when a well-advanced germ band, including probably the adjacent yolk cells, is caused by mechanical injury to sink into the yolk system and degenerate there (Vigneau, 1967; Cavallin, 1971). In Schistocercu greguriu ForskP1, an ectopic germ anlage may form when its prospective region had been cauterized after early cleavage (Moloo, 1971). In Kalotermes fluuicollis Fabr. the position of the germ anlage may vary in wide limits (Truckenbrodt, 1964). In the beetle Atruchya menetriesi Falderm., a single egg when chilled may form up to 4 functional germ anlagen located in different egg regions, and eggs ligatured at 35 per cent EL during blastoderm stages are capable of forming two complete germ bands, one in each fragment (Miya and Kobayashi, 1975) (see section 4.5).
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
161
In these instances the role of the yolk system can at best,be to induce cell aggregations and perhaps to convey polarity on these. Instruction with respect t o the different body segments must essentially occur within the germ anlage blastema. Since this grows considerably before turning into the germ band it is not unreasonable to assume that the processes involved in pattern specification resemble those inferred for the cricket abdomen (section 4.1.7). Very extensive investigations have been carried out by G . and J. Krause on the camel cricket Tachycines usynamorus (Adelung) (for reviews see Krause, 1958a, b). The results of cutting with a glass needle the germ anlage in various directions and at different stages are summarized and interpreted in Fig. 15. Damage t o the central, dotted iegion of the early germ anlage 6
9
12
18
21
27 h
(a 1 (b) (C) (d 1 (e 1 (f) Fig. 15. Developmental tendencies during germ band formation in the camel cricket Tachycines (after Krause, 1953). Zero time is the heart-shaped germ anlage. Fine stippling in (b)-(d) indicates gastrulation. P, procephalon; G, gnathocephalon; T, thorax. Small circles in (d) and (e) represent segment primordia thought to establish the capacity for development of the respective structures in the lateral areas (arrows).
prevents formation of any germ band parts; this region will later on invaginate to form the mesoderm. Head lobes isolated somewhat later prove to be capable of turning into procephalic parts. For the regions behind the head lobes, successive appearance of tendencies t o form gnathocephalon, thorax and abdomen is inferred. The individual segment anlagen lose the capacity for defect compensation in a spatio-temporal pattern comparable to that of the decrease of X-ray sensitivity in the cricket (see Table 4). This effect may be ascribed t o a prothoracic differentiation centre as discussed below (section 4.9.3). But an instructing role, as postulated for this centre in Platycnemis (section 4.2.3), is unlikely because in duplications of the cruciata type all metameric pattern elements, starting from right behind the head lobes, may be specified in the prospective amnion (Fig. 16). If the longitudinal anterior cut which effected duplication had reached into the prospective prothorax of the germ anlage blastema, the crossing point of the
KLAUS SANDER
162
duplication should be located in that segment: if ,the cut did not reach that far, it is difficult to see how it should have caused a prothoracic differentiation centre t o become established in the prospective amnion. Krause (1962) discussed 2 models to account for this type of duplication. One is based on the streaming of specifying agents from a differentation centre; this was considered less probable. The other model, which was not described in detail, apparently foreshadows that of Summerbell et al. (1973) (section 4.1.7) in so far as it envisages translation of a temporal sequence of functional states . andert into spatial pattern. In dem kunstlich erzeugten kreuzformigen Blastemfeld sich also der Funktionszustand aller Zellen schrittweise, d.h. nach einem zeitlichen Muster so, dap ein raumliches Muster der Segmentanlagen ,fur kreuzweise verdoppelte
..
v
a ,---*-
Fig. 16. Cruciata type duplication in Tachycines (from Krause, 1962, courtesy of Prof. G. Krause, Wiirzburg). (a) Germ anlage cut anteriorly with a glass needle. The structure shown consists actually of two layers (see cross-section in (b)) continuous at the margin:
the amnion (stippled) and the germ anlage proper. Both layers fuse along the edges of the median cut, and amniotic material is caused to turn into two additional body halves ((c) and (e); see also Fig. 36). In the uncut posterior region, the median stretch of amnion becomes induced to form a supernumerary germ band ((b), (d) and (f)). The transition from one mode of duplication to the other may occur in the body region, even immediately behind the head lobes (g). E m b y o n e n entsteht. (Krause, 1962, p. 380). As in the cricket, further investigations will have to show how far pattern specification during budding growth can be explained on this basis.
The germ band defects which Moloo (1971) obtained by ligaturing eggs of Schzitocerca appear to be due t o toxic effects of substances liberated from the yolk plasmodium under mechanical stress, and therefore may have no bearing on longitudinal pattern specification. Of greater interest are the results from centrifugation experiments (Moloo, 1971). They display an age-dependent spectrum of defects (Table 5 ) which again indicates a leading role for the gnatho-thoracic region, this time apparently in a process which enables prospective germ anlage regions to continue development after centrifugation. This process might involve an increase in cell adhesion: areas
163
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
of the prospective germ anlage where cell adhesion is strong would stay intact during centrifugation while weak cell contacts might lead t o dispersal or improper mixing of cells during or after centrifugation. However, centrifugation could of course also interfere with the progress of some other process or signal essential for germ band segments to form, particularly since the results obtained during gastrulation (see Table 5 ) do not readily fit in with the above speculation. However, if it is assumed that gastrulation temporarily weakens cell adhesion, the head lobes would not be touched by this weakness and might therefore persist intact through centrifugation (Table 5 ) . TABLE 5 Pattern elements formed (+) after centrifugation of eggs of Schistocerca gregaria (Data of Moloo, 1971, p. 291) Stage at centrifugation
Moloo’s type of defect
Blastoderm to germ anlage
Germ anlage Gastrulation
Pattern elements formed Procephalon
Gnathocephalon Thorax Abdomen
+ +
+ + + +
(+)
-
-
-
+
-
-
-
-
+
+ + +
+
-
(+) Abdomen partially present.
4.4 LEAF HOPPER EMBRYOGENESIS: TRANSPLANTATION OF A “CENTRE” AND THE GRADIENT CONCEPT
The leaf hopper Euscelis plebejus Fall. is comparable to the cricket with respect t o most descriptive aspects of early development and thus belongs to the intermediate germ type (section 2). Experimental results reveal considerable similarities in pattern specification too. But in the leaf hopper, the role of the posterior pole region in this process can be demonstrated positively by “intracellular transplantation” of posterior pole material. The results indicate that the qualitatively differing characters which distinguish different pattern elements may possibly derive from quantitative differences concerning some kind of morphogen (morphogenetic gradients) within the plasmodia1 system. A significant difference to the cricket results is obvious in the development of posterior egg fragments. Their capacity for
KLAUS SANDER
164
pattern formation points towards additional influences exerted by more anterior egg regions on pattern specification. These influences will be demonstrated more clearly in some beetles (section 4.5.1). 4.4.1 The influence of posterior pole material on pattern specification Results obtained from anterior egg fragments in Euscelis resemble those from the cricket, with the exception that instructions for the most anterior pattern elements appear to be located rather anteriorly to begin with, and
36
0
7 12
3E
h Fig. 1 7 . Results from ligaturing eggs of the leaf hopper Euscelis plebejus. Representation based on frequencies per size class of Fragments (Sander, 1959). (a) Changes in the pattern-forming capacity of anterior egg fragments between oviposition and early germ anlage stage (condensed from Fig. 41(a) in Sander, 1959). With fragmentation levels above a given curve, the pattern elements anterior t o the body region indicated at the curve will on average be formed in the anterior egg fragment. P, procephalon; G, gnathocephalon; T, thorax; A, abdomen. The broken curves separate the individual segments of the thorax. The dotted region cannot be analysed with the technique used. (b) Changes in the pattern-forming capacity of posterior egg fragments (condensed from Fig. 25(a) in Sander, 1963). With fragmentation levels below a given curve, the pattern elements posterior to the body region indicated at the curve will on average be formed in the posterior egg fragment. 0, extraembryonic development. Other signs as above. Fragments comprising only the dotted zone are incapable of independent differtntiation (see section 4.1.6.d).
do not shift much during subsequent development (top curve in Fig. 17(a)). The more posterior pattern elements frequently fail to show up in partial germ bands from earlier stages (Fig. 17(a)).These observations suggest that instructions for at least the posterior 2/3 of the body pattern are being generated and/or released from the posterior pole region subsequent to egg deposition. This notion was shown to be correct by transposition of components from the posterior egg pole into more anterior egg regions (see also section 7.5).
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
165
The posterior egg pole in Euscelis (as in most leaf hoppers) contains a globular mass of microbial symbionts which, shortly before formation of the egg shell, assemble in a cup-shaped depression at the posterior pole of the oocyte. The symbiont mass is thus originally located in the extracellular compartment of the egg, but it becomes almost completely engulfed by the egg cell. On pushing this symbiont mass and the adherent material anteriorly through the egg cell and depositing it somewhere near the egg periphery during cleavage, some most drastic effects on pattern formation can be obtained (Fig. 18) (Sander, 1960-1962). We shall consider only four results.
(a)
(b)-
(C
1
(d1
(e 1
(f,)
(f*)
Fig. 18. Diagram combining types of operation and typical results for a variety of operations performed on Euscelis eggs (after Sander, 1975a). Black disc indicates posterior pole material, horizontal bar separation by ligature. Pattern elements: X, serosa; procephalon; B, gnathocephalon; C, thorax; D, anterior region of abdomen; E, posterior region of abdomen. The symbols at the upper and lower ends of each series indicate the approximate locations of the blastodermal anlagen for the respective pattern elements; the remaining symbols have been distributed evenly in between. Body regions next to the site of fragmentation, or t o the plane of mirroring symmetry ((d) and (fz)), may lack some segments. (a) Control pattern produced by the untreated egg. (b) See Fig. 19(a), (c) See Fig. 19(b) andTable 7. (d) and (e) See Figs 20 and 21. (f) See Sander, 1962, Fig. 2d-f. Operations (b)-(fl) were performed during late cleavage, (fz) at early germ anlage stage (21 h later at 22 "C).
4,
1. Anterior fragments so short as t o form only head parts-fragmentation levels between curves R and G in Fig. 17(a)-will in 70 per cent of cases produce the complete germ band pattern when supplied with the pole material (Figs 18 and 19) (Sander, 1960). 2. By depositing the pole material in the anterior region of a posterior fragment, a partial pattern of inverted antero-posterior polarity can be produced (Figs 18, 20 and 21), again with very high yield (Sander, 1961a, b).
166
KLAUSSANDER
Fig. 19. Effects of transposition of posterior pole material in Euscelis (data of Sander, 1959, 1960). (a) Control fragmentation. a l , Egg ligatured during cleavage, with pole material (black disc) left in place. az, Typical result: synophthalmic procephalon in anterior fragment, partial germ band consisting o f metathorax and abdomen in posterior fragment; abdomen carries globular “mycetome” harbouring symbionts. (b) Fragmentation after transposition of pole material. bl, Pole material included in anterior fragment. bz, Typical result: complete and viable embryo in the anterior fragment, partial germ band consisting of two thoracic segments and the abdomen (lacking the syrnbionts) in posterior fragment.
(0) (b) (C) (d 1 (e) (f) Fig. 20. Reversal of polarity in Euscelis after transposition of posterior pole material to the anterior region of a posterior egg fragment during cleavage (see Fig. 18(e)) (from Sander, 1961b). (a) Control fragment with posterior partial germ band consisting of two gnathal segments, thorax and abdomen. (b) and (c) Reverted germ bands consisting of abdomen and two or one thoracic segment(s) respectively. Note that number of pattern elements is smaller than in control fragment although the fragments are larger. This statistically significant difference is typical; it is predicted by the two-gradient hypothesis (see Fig. 23(f). (d)-(f) Mirror-type longitudinal duplications, with transverse plane of symmetry in metathorax (d) or abdomen ((e) and (f)).
3. If the egg is not ligatured immediately after transposition of the pole material, but shortly before the germ anlage stage (21 h later at 22 “C),the anterior fragment may form a complete germ band while the posterior
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
167
fragment may produce an,inverted partial germ band (Fig. 18(f)).The germ band in the anterior fragment will be complete more frequently when the pole material (as marked by the symbiont mass) is included in this fragment, but it may als6 be complete when the symbiont mass is excluded (see Fig. 18(f 2 ), left pair of eggs).
4. With results (2) and (3) the inverted posterior partial germ band may be joined in mirror symmetry fashion to an identical part with normal polarity; the latter may lack the terminal segments of the abdomen (Figs 18, 20, and 21).
Fig. 21. Thionine-stained and mounted posterior fragments corresponding to results shown in Fig. 20(a), 20(b) and 20(d) (from Sander, 1961a).
4.4.2 The concept of pattern specification b y a morphogenetic gradient The results described in the preceding section demonstrate positively that the posterior region of the egg plasmodium plays a direct role in specifying pattern. They also provide some clues concerning the formal mechanisms involved. The simplest model to account for the results assumes some kind of morphogenetic gradient to which nuclei or cells react differently according to local level. Two results in particular suggest such a model. Firstly, the apparently perfect reversal of a large sequence of pattern elements when the pole material is located anteriorly instead of posteriorly to a certain region (Figs 18, 20 and 21). Secondly, in those cases where an anterior fragment supplied with pole material fails t o yield the complete pattern, the pole material then does not evoke formation of the hindmost abdominal segments which normally develop in its vicinity, but rather enhances the anterior partial pattern by those segments which are missing immediately adjacent to i t (Table 7, cf. Fig. 18(c) left egg, cf. Fig. 18(b)). This result shows that the pole material is not a specific “inductor” for posterior abdominal pattern elements but rather exerts some more general influence
#’
168
KLAUS SANDER
on pattern specification. How this could be accomplished by building up a morphogenetic gradient is set out in Fig. 22.
Fig. 22. Gradient interpretation of the curves in Fig. 17(a). As in other figures, the vertical axis of the diagram represents the longitudinal egg axis. In the lateral blocks, the horizontal axis refers to gradient level or t o morphogen concentration (assuming a gradient in the concentration of some morphogen). Gradient levels within the range marked p are assumed t o trigger in germ anlage cells the programmes for procephalon formation, levels in the range marked g the programmes for gnathocephalon, and so on. It is also assumed that the change in gradient shape occurring between oviposition (left box) and early germ anlage (right box) is caused by the posteriormost region of the egg (at bottom, marked by black disc) and that a stretch of gradient separated from this region by ligature does not subsequently change its shape. The model is insufficient to explain other data, e.g. those shown in Fig. 17(b). It is solely intended t o illustrate the principle of transformation of quantitative differences (e.g. in the concentration of a morphogen) into qualitative differences (as exist between different elements of the body pattern), and to demonstrate some consequences of a change in gradient shape. (b) Interpretation of the result shown in Fig. 18(fz) (right egg) in terms of a morphogenetic gradient. Posterior pole material split up (half discs).
4.4.3 Anterior instructing influences in pattern specification The influence of more anterior egg regions on pattern formation in Euscelis becomes evident when the partial patterns produced by posterior egg fragments are studied (Sander, 1959, 1963). In contrast to the cricket results (Table 2, Fig. 6(a)), posterior partial germ bands are frequent in Euscelis right from the beginning, and the minimum length required for complete germ bands decreases considerably with increasing age at fragmentation. The latter is also true for the average fragment lengths at which partial embryos representing certain sets of segments were obtained (Fig. 17(b)). From these and other results it was concluded that the formation of most pattern elements in the leaf hopper is dependent not only on posterior but also on anterior instructing influences or prerequisites, and that these shift backward by 10-15 per cent of the egg’s length (i.e. c. 113 of germ anlage length) between cleavage and germ anlage formation (Sander, 1959).
169
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
This interpretatioo so far cannot be supported with an experiment as persuasive as the transposition of posterior pole material (see above). However, it can be shown that something more than simply lack of space is involved (Sander, 1975a). Fragments isolated at 40-55 per cent EL during cleavage fail t o produce complete germ bands; the head lobes at least are always lacking (Fig. 17(b)). When, however, the eggs before being ligatured were centrifuged mildly (5 min at c. 600 g) in radial position, a high percentage of comparable posterior fragments became capable of producing complete gem bands (Table 6 ) (Sander, 1963). The centrifugation procedure, therefore, must induce or speed up some change in the system comparable t o the change occurring normally during the subsequent 24 h (see top curve in Fig. 17(b)). Whatever that change might be, it appears t o be linked to the cytoplasm and not t o the major fractions of yolk particles or lipid droplets which partly separate in the centrifuge, because this centrifugation effect can be obtained with both centrifugal and centripetal orientation of the posterior egg pole. TABLE 6 Effects of centrifugal force (600 g, 5 min) applied parallel t o the longitudinal egg axis before or after fragmentation. Leaf hopper Euscelis plebejus; data of Sander, 1965, Fig. 22(a-c). Posterior fragments of 40-55 per cent EL; for symbols see Fig. 3 Type of pattern produced Centrifugation
Cleavage stage _
_
I
~
U
0 ~~
6 19
0 12
0
7
12
0 0
7 38
12 40
Before fragmentation
Early Middle + late
18 18
After fragmentation
Middle + late
None
Early Middle + late
TABLE 7 Frequencies of different patterns produced by anterior egg fragments (21-40 per cent EL) of the leaf hopper Euscelis plebejus in the presence or absence of material from the posterior egg pole (see Fig. 18; after Sander, 1975a) Pattern formed* Posterior pole material present Posterior pole material absent
X...E
X...D
23 0
4 0
X...C 12 0
X...B
0 10
X+A
X
1 21
0 6
* Letters represent pattern elements (see Fig. 18). 4.4.4 A two-gradient hypothesis for pattern specification in Euscelis In the experiment shown in Fig. 18(c), the abdominal and thoracic pattern elements were frequently formed twice within the same egg, one set in the
170
KLAUSSANDER
Q O0o O /0 ,
0
0 0
0
0 0
0 0
iA
I I((’ I Doooooo .*@
O O 0
... *. * .
0
.
.
Fig. 23. Double gradient hypothesis for formal interpretation of the results obtained in Euscelis by egg fragpentation and by transposition of posterior pole material (after Sander, 1960, 196lb). (a)-(.) Normal development from oviposition to the germ anlage stage. The posterior gradient corresponds to that shown in Fig. 22 (increasing towards the left; see arrow at bottom). An opposite anterior gradient (upper left; increasing towards the right; see arrow at top), is thought to build up under the influence of the egg region in front of 60-65 per cent EL (open circle). The relation of anterior to posterior gradient levels ( a / p ratio), which varies continuously along the egg axis (see assumed values for this ratio in (c)), is assumed to trigger at the germ anlage stage different pathways of development in cells located in different regions. (d)-(f)Status of gradients at the germ anlage stage in different experiments; the area covered by each (disfigured) gradient is equal to that covered in (c) (= same quantity of morphogen). (d) Fragmentation during cleavage. Subsequent accumulation of “anterior” substance in the anterior, and “posterior” substance in the posterior egg fragment causes a discontinuity in the alp ratio at the level of fragmentation (transverse bar). Consequently, the alp ratios which trigger formation of some pattern elements become established neither in the anterior nor in the posterior fragment (“gap phenomenon”, see section 4.4.4, Table 8 and Fig. 18(b)). ( e ) Transposition of posterior pole material prior to fragmentation. For result see Fig. 19(b). The gradient shape in the anterior fragment results from the assumption that the region in front of 60 per cent EL somehow inactivates the effects of the posterior pole material, an assumption suggested by some experimental results (Sander, 1960, Fig. 7). (f) Transposition of posterior pole material to the anterior region of a posterior fragment. For results see Fig. 20(b) and (c). Note that the ratio alp changes here more gradually along the egg axis because both gradients slope in the same direction (albeit with differences in steepness); this would explain the formation of fewer but longer pattern elements as compared to control fragments (cf. Fig. 20(b)).
INSECT EMBRYOGENESIS
171
anterior and the qther in the posterior fragment (see right egg in Fig. 18(c)). In some instances, even the gnathal segments were duplicated this way. With specification coming exclusively via a posterior gradient, this result could be understood rather easily: However, Fig. 17(b) indicates that specification of at least the gnathal an