Dislocations in Solids Volume 14
This page intentionally left blank
Dislocations in Solids Volume 14 A Tribute to F. R. N. Nabarro
Edited by
J. P. HIRTH Hereford, AZ, USA
Amsterdam • Boston • Heidelberg • London • New York • Oxford Paris • San Diego • San Francisco • Singapore • Sidney • Tokyo North-Holland is an imprint of Elsevier
Elsevier Radarweg 29, PO Box 211, 1000 AE Amsterdam, The Netherlands Linacre House, Jordan Hill, Oxford OX2 8DP, UK
First edition 2008 Copyright ©2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier’s Science & Technology Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) (0) 1865 843830; fax (+44) (0) 1865 853333; email: permissions@elsevier. com. Alternatively you can submit your request online by visiting the Elsevier web site at http://www. elsevier.com/locate/permissions, and selecting Obtaining permission to use Elsevier material Notice No responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library ISBN: 978-0-444-53166-7 ISSN: 1572-4859 For information on all Elsevier publications visit our website at books.elsevier.com Printed and bound in Hungary 08 09 10 11 12
10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Preface This volume is dedicated as a tribute to F.R.N. Nabarro, the founder of this series. As documented in his biography,1 he made many contributions to dislocation theory in conventional materials and received a number of awards for that work. However, he was also a pioneer in applying dislocation and disclination concepts to unusual materials. This included such topics as disclinations in seashells, dislocations in liquid crystals, and dislocations in molecular crystals and viruses. His vision in these matters was reflected in the broad set of topics that has appeared in the thirteen volumes of Dislocations in Solids that he edited. The present volume continues in that spirit. The first three chapters present results of atomistic simulations at the forefront in this burgeoning area. Van Swygenhoven and Derlet discuss dislocation behavior in nanocrystals and focus on some scaling problems in such simulations. Tschopp et al. present results on dislocation nucleation at grain boundaries, including a new nucleation mechanism. Demkowicz et al. discuss interphase interfaces, with Cu–Nb as an example, providing new insight into structures extending over several planes near the interface, with dislocations spreading in the interface, and with differing local point defect concentrations. Zbib and Khraishi give results of dislocation dynamics calculations using discrete dislocation segments. They treat size effects and high velocity dislocation behavior. Bonneville et al. consider dislocations in icosahedral quasicrystals, including a new mechanism for dislocation motion in such materials. Alshits et al. present a theory for the magnetoplastic effect that explains a wide variety of such phenomena in a self-consistent manner. Vitek and Paidar treat non-planar cores in a variety of crystals, including intermetallic compounds, ionic and covalent bonded structures, and molecular crystals. Seemingly conflicting deformation trends can be explained by their models.
1 A.G. Every, S. Afr. J. Sci. 103 (2007).
v
This page intentionally left blank
Contents Volume 14
Preface
v
Contents
vii
List of Contents of Volumes 1–13
ix
81. H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials 1 82. M.A. Tschopp, D.E. Spearot and D.L. McDowell Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals 43 83. M.J. Demkowicz, J. Wang and R.G. Hoagland Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
141
84. H.M. Zbib and T.A. Khraishi Size Effects and Dislocation–Wave Interaction in Dislocation Dynamics 85. J. Bonneville, D. Caillard and P. Guyot Dislocations and Plasticity of Icosahedral Quasicrystals
207
251
86. V.I. Alshits, E.V. Darinskaya, M.V. Koldaeva and E.A. Petrzhik Magnetoplastic Effect in Nonmagnetic Crystals 333 87. V. Vitek and V. Paidar Non-planar Dislocation Cores: A Ubiquitous Phenomenon Affecting Mechanical Properties of Crystalline Materials 439 Author Index
515
Subject Index
531
vii
This page intentionally left blank
Contents of Volumes 1–13 VOLUME 1. The Elastic Theory 1979, 1st repr. 1980; ISBN 0-7204-0756-7
1. 2. 3. 4.
J. Friedel, Dislocations – an introduction 1 A.M. Kosevich, Crystal dislocations and the theory of elasticity 33 J.W. Steeds and J.R. Willis, Dislocations in anisotropic media 143 J.D. Eshelby, Boundary problems 167 B.K.D. Gairola, Nonlinear elastic problems 223
VOLUME 2. Dislocations in Crystals 1979, 1st repr. 1982; ISBN 0-444-85004-x 5. 6. 7.
R. Bullough and V.K. Tewary, Lattice theories of dislocations S. Amelinckx, Dislocations in particular structures 67 J.W. Matthews, Misfit dislocations 461
1
VOLUME 3. Moving Dislocations 1980; 2nd printing 1983; ISBN 0-444-85015-5 8. J. Weertman and J.R. Weertman, Moving dislocations 1 9. Resistance to the motion of dislocations (to be included in a supplementary volume), 10. G. Schöck, Thermodynamics and thermal activation of dislocations 63 11. J.W. Christian and A.G. Crocker, Dislocations and lattice transformations 165 12. J.C. Savage, Dislocations in seismology 251 VOLUME 4. Dislocations in Metallurgy 1979; 2nd printing 1983; ISBN 0-444-85025-2 13. R.W. Balluffi and A.V. Granato, Dislocations, vacancies and interstitials 1 14. F.C. Larché, Nucleation and precipitation on dislocations 135 15. P. Haasen, Solution hardening in f.c.c. metals 155 H. Suzuki, Solid solution hardening in body-centred cubic alloys 191 V. Gerold, Precipitation hardening 219 16. S.J. Basinski and Z.S. Basinski, Plastic deformation and work hardening 261 17. E. Smith, Dislocations and cracks 363 VOLUME 5. Other Effects of Dislocations: Disclinations 1980; 2nd printing 1983; ISBN 0-444-85050-3 18. 19. 20. 21. 22.
C.J. Humphreys, Imaging of dislocations 1 B. Mutaftschiev, Crystal growth and dislocations 57 R. Labusch and W. Schröter, Electrical properties of dislocations in semiconductors F.R.N. Nabarro and A.T. Quintanilha, Dislocations in superconductors 193 M. Kléman, The general theory of disclinations 243 ix
127
x 23. 24.
Contents of Volumes 1–13 Y. Bouligand, Defects and textures in liquid crystals 299 M. Kléman, Dislocations, disclinations and magnetism 349
VOLUME 6. Applications and Recent Advances 1983; ISBN 0-444-86490-3
25. 26. 27. 28. 29. 30. 31. 32.
J.P. Hirth and D.A. Rigney, The application of dislocation concepts in friction and wear 1 C. Laird, The application of dislocation concepts in fatigue 55 C.A.B. Ball and J.H. van der Merwe, The growth of dislocation-free layers 121 V.I. Startsev, Dislocations and strength of metals at very low temperatures 143 A.C. Anderson, The scattering of phonons by dislocations 235 J.G. Byrne, Dislocation studies with positrons 263 H. Neuhäuser, Slip-line formation and collective dislocation motion 319 J.Th.M. De Hosson, O. Kanert and A.W. Sleeswyk, Dislocations in solids investigated by means of nuclear magnetic resonance 441
VOLUME 7 1986; ISBN 0-444-87011-3
33.
G. Bertotti, A. Ferro, F. Fiorillo and P. Mazzetti, Electrical noise associated with dislocations and plastic flow in metals 1 34. V.I. Alshits and V.L. Indenbom, Mechanisms of dislocation drag 43 35. H. Alexander, Dislocations in covalent crystals 113 36. B.O. Hall, Formation and evolution of dislocation structures during irradiation 235 37 G.B. Olson and M. Cohen, Dislocation theory of martensitic transformations 295
VOLUME 8. Basic Problems and Applications 1989; ISBN 0-444-70515-5
38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43.
R.C. Pond, Line defects in interfaces 1 M.S. Duesbery, The dislocation core and plasticity 67 B.R. Watts, Conduction electron scattering in dislocated metals 175 W.A. Jesser and J.H. van der Merwe, The prediction of critical misfit and thickness in epitaxy P.J. Jackson, Microstresses and the mechanical properties of crystals 461 H. Conrad and A.F. Sprecher, The electroplastic effect in metals 497
421
VOLUME 9. Dislocations and Disclinations 1992; ISBN 0-444-89560-4
44. 45.
G.R. Anstis and J.L. Hutchison, High-resolution imaging of dislocations 1 I.G. Ritchie and G. Fantozzi, Internal friction due to the intrinsic properties of dislocations in metals: Kink relaxations 57 46. N. Narita and J.-I. Takamura, Deformation twinning in f.c.c. and b.c.c. metals 135 47. A.E. Romanov and V.I. Vladimirov, Disclinations in crystalline solids 191
Contents of Volumes 1–13
xi
VOLUME 10. Dislocations in Solids 1996; ISBN 0-444-82370-0 48. 49. 50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55.
J.H. Westbrook, Superalloys (Ni-base) and dislocations 1 Y.Q. Sun and P.M. Hazzledine, Geometry of dislocation glide in L12 γ -phase 27 D. Caillard and A. Couret, Dislocation cores and yield stress anomalies 69 V. Vitek, D.P. Pope and J.L. Bassani, Anomalous yield behaviour of compounds with L12 structure D.C. Chrzan and M.J. Mills, Dynamics of dislocation motion in L12 compounds 187 P. Veyssière and G. Saada, Microscopy and plasticity of the L12 γ phase 253 K. Maeda and S. Takeuchi, Enhancement of dislocation mobility in semiconducting crystals 443 B. Joós, The role of dislocations in melting 505
135
VOLUME 11. Dislocations in Solids 2002; ISBN 0-444-50966-6 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63.
M. Zaiser and A. Seeger, Long-range internal stress, dislocation patterning and work-hardening in crystal plasticity 1 L.P. Kubin, C. Fressengeas and G. Ananthakrishna, Collective behaviour of dislocations in plasticity 101 L.M. Brown, Linear work-hardening and secondary slip in crystals 193 D. Kuhlmann-Wilsdorf, The LES theory of solid plasticity 211 H. Mughrabi and T. Ungár, Long-range internal stresses in deformed single-phase materials: The composite model and its consequences 343 G. Saada and P. Veyssière, Work hardening of face centred cubic crystals. Dislocations intersection and cross-slip 413 B. Viguier, J.L. Martin and J. Bonneville, Work hardening in some ordered intermetallic compounds 459 T.M. Pollock and R.D. Field, Dislocations and high-temperature plastic deformation of superalloy single crystals 547
VOLUME 12. Dislocations in Solids 2004; ISBN 0-444-51483-X 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70.
W. Cai, V.V. Bulatov, J. Chang, J. Li and S. Yip, Dislocation core effects on mobility 1 G. Xu, Dislocation nucleation from crack tips and brittle to ductile transitions in cleavage fracture 81 M. Kleman, O.D. Lavrentovich and Yu.A. Nastishin, Dislocations and disclinations in mesomorphic phases 147 C. Coupeau, J.-C. Girard and J. Rabier, Scanning probe microscopy and dislocations 273 T.E. Mitchell and A.H. Heuer, Dislocations and mechanical properties of ceramics 339 R.W. Armstrong and W.L. Elban, Dislocations in energetic crystals 403 M.M. Chaudhri, Dislocations and indentations 447
VOLUME 13. Dislocations in Solids 2007; ISBN 0-444-51888-6 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77.
V.S. Deshpande, A. Needleman and E. Van der Giessen, Discrete dislocation plasticity modeling of contact and friction 1 J.P. Nowacki and V.I. Alshits, Dislocation fields in piezoelectrics 47 G. Ananthakrishna, Statistical and dynamical approaches to collective behavior of dislocations 81 R.C. Pond, X. Ma, Y.W. Chai and J.P. Hirth, Topological modelling of martensitic transformations 225 M. Niewczas, Dislocations and twinning in face centred cubic crystals 263 K. Edagawa and S. Takeuchi, Elasticity, dislocations and their motion in quasicrystals 365 J.C.H. Spence, Experimental studies of dislocation core defects 419
xii 78.
Contents of Volumes 1–13
A.M. Minor, E.A. Stach and J.W. Morris, Jr., In situ nanoindentation in a transmission electron microscope 453 79. G.E. Ice and R.I. Barabash, White beam microdiffraction and dislocations gradients 499 80. D. Shilo and E. Zolotoyabko, X-ray imaging of phonon interaction with dislocations 603
CHAPTER 81
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials H. VAN SWYGENHOVEN, P.M. DERLET Materials Science & Simulation, NUM-ASQ, Paul Scherrer Institute, CH-5232 Villigen PSI, Switzerland
Dedicated to the memory of F.R.N. Nabarro, who’s scientific excellence and dedication has been an inspiration to us
© 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved 1572-4859, DOI: 10.1016/S1572-4859(07)00001-0
Dislocations in Solids Edited by J. P. Hirth
Contents 1. Bulk nanocrystalline plasticity 3 2. Introduction to atomistic simulation 4 2.1. Methodology 4 2.2. Timescale restrictions 7 2.3. Lengthscale restrictions 9 2.4. Empirical potentials for FCC metals 10 2.5. Nanocrystalline sample construction 12 2.5.1. Geometrical construction 12 2.5.2. Cluster compaction 14 2.5.3. Quenching from the melt 14 2.6. Atomic visualization 14 2.6.1. Local energy 15 2.6.2. Atomic coordination 16 2.6.3. Common neighbor analysis 17 2.6.4. Positional disorder 18 2.6.5. Local stress and strain 18 2.6.6. Centro-symmetric parameter 19 2.6.7. Free volume 19 3. Atomistic simulations of deformation in bulk 3D nanocrystalline metals 19 3.1. The role of the generalized stacking fault energy curve 20 3.2. Case study one: dislocations in a defect free grain 24 3.3. Case study two: a grain containing twin defects 28 4. Experimental-computational synergy tools 31 4.1. X-ray diffraction 31 4.2. Phonons 34 5. Discussion and concluding remarks 36 Acknowledgements 39 References 40
1. Bulk nanocrystalline plasticity It is not an easy task to write a chapter on dislocations in FCC nanocrystalline metals for a book that is a tribute to F.R.N. Nabarro and edited by J.P. Hirth, who both are among the world experts in dislocation theory. Our current understanding of dislocations and their role in the mechanical behavior of metals still relies on the ground work performed in the 50–60’s by F.R.N. Nabarro, J.P. Hirth, J. Weertman and J.R. Weertman, A.H. Cottrell, J. Friedel and W.T. Read as is testified by the number of comprehensive books [1–6], still frequently used as reference in undergraduate and graduate courses on physical and mechanical properties of crystalline solids. What is different to those years is that contemporary times possess new techniques such as atomistic and mesoscopic computer simulation techniques allowing the investigation of the dynamical details of microstructures and their interactions with dislocations. For instance, mesoscopic simulation methods such as dislocation dynamics [7–9], a front tracking method in which dislocations are discretized into segments allowing for instance the simulation and visualization of the dynamics of Frank– Read dislocation sources and their pile-up in a finite volume [10], are now used to study the dynamics of hardening mechanisms. Given a reasonable accurate description of the atomic forces, atomistic simulations such as molecular dynamics (MD), allow the modeling of the atomistic details of the interactions of dislocation with a microstructure with atomic scale resolution. MD has not only revealed unprecedented detail of dislocation nucleation, propagation, multiplication and the interaction mechanism with its microstructural environment – often visualizing and detailing the mechanisms that were introduced in the basic works published in the 50–60’s – but has also emphasized the complexity of dislocation theories. For example, atomistic simulations are used to study the many possible interaction mechanisms between dislocations and interfaces, a field that has proven its importance in the understanding of mechanical behavior of nanocrystalline metals. Nanocrystalline (nc) metals are by definition polycrystalline structures with a mean grain size below 100 nm and therefore their microstructure contains a significant volume fraction of interfacial regions separated by nearly-perfect crystals [11]. Compared to its coarse-grain counterpart, the mechanical behavior of a fully-dense nc metal is characterized by a significantly enhanced yield stress and a limited tensile elongation [12]. From the early beginning of experimental investigations in the mechanical behavior of nc metals, it has been proposed that the small grain sizes limit the conventional operation of dislocation sources and estimations of strength were made based on simple Frank–Read sources [11,13]. This simple picture of dislocation nucleation, together with the early assumption that grain boundaries (GBs) in nc metals are highly disordered to the extent that the material could be considered as a two phase system where the grain boundaries act as a glue between perfect grains, had lead for a while to the belief that dislocations were of no importance to nc metals. However, later, several high resolution transmission electron microscopy (HR-TEM) studies have revealed that grain boundaries in pure nc metals are not
4
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
amorphous or “glue-like” [14,15]. Most TEM studies performed on undeformed and deformed nc metals confirm the idea that there is no dislocation network in the grain interiors as is the case in coarse-grained polycrystals. With the increase in computational power, one can deform three-dimensional (3D) computational nc samples containing enough grains in order to mimic an nc metal. These simulations have revealed that the deformation behavior is still to a major extent governed by dislocations: however the dislocations are not nucleated via classical Frank–Read sources situated within the grain interior, but are nucleated at GB ledges, with dislocations traveling through the grain and finally being absorbed in opposite GBs. The merit of the atomistic simulations of nc GB networks lies in the revelation of the details of such dislocation mechanisms. However it has to be mentioned that the concept of dislocation nucleation from GBs was already introduced by Hirth in 1972 [16, 17] and experimentally observed a few years later [11,18] well before the experimental era of nc metals. In this chapter the dislocation mechanisms suggested by MD during plastic deformation studies of nc FCC metals are reviewed and the existence of these mechanisms is discussed in terms of experimental observations. Although MD is a very well known technique and several reference books exist, the chapter starts with a basic introduction to MD. This approach is justified by the fact that MD contains some subtle and less subtle caveats that especially in the research of nc metals has lead to some hasty interpretations resulting in questionable conclusions concerning the deformation mechanism in nc metals. Therefore, in order to be able to fully appreciate the MD technique, Section 2 is devoted to the methodology, sample construction methods and sample analyzing methods. The main dislocation mechanism resulting from a vast number of simulations performed in the last couple of years is summarized in Section 3, including a case-study for a defect-free grain and a grain that contains twins prior to deformation. Section 4 discusses some tools that have been developed in order to be able to verify the synergy between MD simulations and experimental measurable properties. Finally the chapter concludes with a section where simulation results are evaluated within the framework of experimental results, together with an outlook mentioning some issues to be resolved. This chapter does not aim to be a comprehensive review of all data published on the deformation mechanisms in nc metals, but rather to provide the authors’ opinion on the current state-of-the-art.
2. Introduction to atomistic simulation 2.1. Methodology The MD technique involves simulating the classical motion of every atom within a chosen atomic configuration, and has been applied to systems traditionally ranging from dilute gases, liquids and condensed matter systems such as bulk metals and semi-conductors containing microstructures including GBs and layered geometries. MD has also been applied to systems characterized by finite sized length scales such as nanowires, clusters and free standing components of complex geometry. The enduring attraction of the technique, given a reasonably accurate description of the atomic forces, is that by starting from the atom, one can, in principle, model the complex stress signature and defect energetics/dynamics of all
§2.1
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
5
material structures. As with all methods, MD contains subtle and not so subtle caveats that restrict its applicability and accuracy to provide experimentally realizable material parameters. This is particularly the case when modeling mechanical properties of materials where the traditional experimental time and length scales are significantly larger than those typically seen in MD simulations. In the present section we introduce the basic computational algorithm of MD and then address its important limitations. Given the availability of a multi-atom energy function: V (˜r1 , . . . , r˜N ), where the r˜1 , . . . , r˜N constitute the 3N coordinates of the atomic configuration, the basic numerical technique of MD will involve solving the associated Newton’s equation of motion: mi r¨˜ i (t) = F (˜r1 , . . . , r˜N ) = −∇˜ i V (˜r1 , . . . , r˜N ). The numerical approach of MD generally involves approximating the double derivative associated with the atoms’ acceleration via a simple finite difference representation, giving for example [ri (t + 2t) − 2ri (t + t) + ri (t)] ˜ i V r1 (t), . . . , rN (t) . = − ∇ t 2 Thus if the configuration at times t + t and t are known, then the configuration at the latter time t + 2t can be easily calculated. The above equation represents the simplest finite difference operator and in practice is not numerically stable for reasonable values of t + t in terms of total energy conservation. As a result more stable integrators have been developed such as the Verlet and Gear predictor/corrector integrators resulting in time-steps of the order of a femto-second for a condensed matter system [19]. The actual implementation of the numerical solution of 3N equations of motion requires a starting configuration – the initial boundary condition. For the predictor/corrector algorithms, this generally involves defining the initial spatial location of each atom and its velocity. More generally for a condensed matter system this entails geometrically building the structure of interest through for example assuming a particular crystallography and then choosing the shape or morphology of these crystalline regions. Velocities are usually chosen randomly such that the total kinetic energy defines the required temperature of the system: 3N 1 ˙ ˙ mi r˜ i · r˜ i . kb T = 2 2 mi
i
With the starting configuration defined, the MD equations of motions are iterated to evolve the system through physical time until the system reaches thermal equilibrium. All thermodynamic variables can easily be measured and controlled within the framework of equilibrium MD. For example the temperature, T , for a mono-atomic system with mass m can easily be calculated using the above equation. Using this formula, one can control the temperature of the MD system by rescaling the atomic velocities by the factor √ Tactual /Tdesired every certain number of MD steps, eventually leading to an equilibrated system at the desired temperature. There exist more elaborate approaches for the control
6
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
of temperature through a fictitious damping term, the magnitude and sign of which, is controlled by the difference between the desired temperature and the actual temperature of the system [19]. Under equilibrium conditions, all such methods are expected to be equivalent. For a system where the force on a particular atom can be represented by two body terms, the instantaneous total stress of the system can be calculated via the virial stress that is given by 1 1 μ ν 1 μ μν ν σ = F (rij )rij . m˙r r˙ + 2 i i 2 i
j
For atomic configurations that are on average isotropic, the hydrostatic pressure is generally calculated and is given by one third of the trace of the stress tensor. There exist two modes of tensile deformation that have been widely used in the atomistic simulation of plastic deformation of periodic systems: that of constant strain rate and constant stress simulations. The most widely used approach is to apply a global stress to a simulation cell under full three-dimensional (3D) periodicity via the Parrinello–Rahman technique [20]. Within this framework, absolute atomic coordinates are represented via r˜i = Bˆ · s˜i , where Bˆ is a square matrix of rank 3, and s˜i are reduced dimensionless atomic coordinates ranging from −0.5 to 0.5. Thus Bˆ has units of length and under orthorhombic geometry conditions, the diagonal components of Bˆ are the periodicity lengths. Higher derivatives of the atomic coordinates are represented in a similar fashion. The dynamical MD variables are now Bˆ and s˜i , all of which follow differential equations, with the driving “force” of Bˆ being the difference between the applied global stress and the actual global stress of the simulation cell calculated via the virial theorem. The usage of such an approach produces strain versus time data, an example of which is shown in Fig. 1(a). In this example, an applied uniaxial tensile load of 1.5 GPa has been applied to a nc Al sample with a mean grain size of 10 nm. The MD was performed at 300 K [21–23]. The measured strain rate between 30 and 60 ps of simulation time is ∼5 × 107 /s and from detailed analysis of the atomic scale processes the plastic strain arises from both slip activity within the grains and GB mediated processes such as GB sliding. Previous work has shown that, for this regime when the simulation time is extended into the nanoseconds, the strain rate can reduce by an order of magnitude, indicating that the plastic response of the system as shown in Fig. 1(a) is far from being in a dynamical equilibrium [24]. Fig. 1(a) also shows the resulting strain versus time curve when the applied load is increased to 1.55 GPa where the strain rate has now increased by an order of magnitude due to increased slip activity within the grains. Increasing the stress to 1.6 GPa further (not shown) increases the strain rate by an order of magnitude resulting in all grains undergoing slip activity with the final result being the eventual destruction of the sample. Constant strain rate simulations have the advantage of producing a stress–strain curve. There are many ways in which such a simulation can be performed. Presently we consider a procedure that exploits the framework of the Parrinello–Rahman technique under an orthorhombic geometry for the simulation cell, where a strain rate is imposed along a given
§2.2
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
(a)
7
(b)
Fig. 1. (a) Strain versus simulation time curve derived from a constant uniaxial tensile load simulation and (b) stress versus strain curve derived from a constant strain rate simulation.
direction, say in the z direction, via a choice of B˙ zz . The remaining degrees of freedom, namely Bxx and Byy , then follow the normal Parrinello–Rahman equations of motions to model the lateral Poisson contraction of the simulation cell. Fig. 1(b) displays typical stress strain data for imposed strain rates covering three orders of magnitude and a strong strain rate sensitivity of the maximum stress carried by the simulated material is observed. Indeed at the strain rate of ∼1 × 109 /s a large maximum is seen followed by a reduction in the stress. This maximum has often been used as defining a yield stress [25–27], however as seen in Fig. 1(b), this common feature appears to be an artifact of the high strain rate and is reduced by ∼25% as the strain rate drops two orders of magnitude. Given that much of the published work involves simulations with strain rates between ∼1 × 108 /s and ∼1 × 109 /s this is a lucid example of the dangers of deriving quantitative material parameters such as a yield stress and relating them to experimentally derived corresponding quantities.
2.2. Timescale restrictions Any instantaneous atomic configuration can be described by its 3N spatial coordinates, thus its temporal evolution can be visualized as a trajectory in a 3N -dimensional space, the so-called phase space of the physical system. What is quite typical for equilibrated condensed matter systems is that the region of phase space that the system occupies over a period of time is generally quite localized – very little might happen during the course of a simulation. For example in an MD simulation of a perfect FCC lattice at 300 K, once equilibrated the atoms essentially oscillate about their mean FCC lattice positions. In terms of energy, the system exists in an energy minimum that generally can be well described by a multi-dimensional quadratic function – the so-called harmonic energy well. If now, one atom is removed and the equilibration is repeated, a vacancy defect has been created with the dimensionality of the phase space reducing to 3N − 3. Such a system will also remain for a significant amount of time in one region of the (3N − 3)-dimensional phase
8
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
Fig. 2. Schematic of a rare event, where initially the system oscillates in region A in phase space. At a particular time, a thermal fluctuation results in the system moving to region B of phase space. The dark curve represents the (3N − 3)-dimensional trajectory and the thicker light curve idealizes the potential energy surface.
space, until at some point, one of the twelve atoms neighboring the vacancy moves to the vacancy site, thereby shifting the vacancy to a new location. In terms of the (3N − 3)dimensional phase space, the system now moves to a new region of phase space where it remains localized in a new harmonic energy well until the next hopping event occurs. This atomic scale process corresponds to vacancy diffusion at 300 K and can be measured via a simple lattice hopping model: 1 2 d , 6 where D is the vacancy diffusion coefficient, d is the nearest neighbor FCC lattice distance and is the rate of the vacancy hopping. The rate, , is what would actually be measured in the MD simulation. From statistical mechanics, the rate of a thermally activated process at temperature T may be written as E , = 12ν exp − kb T D=
where kb is Boltzmann’s constant, E is the migration energy, and ν is the attempt frequency. The factor of 12 counts for all possible atoms that may hop to the vacancy site. The exponential factor (the so-called Boltzmann factor) represents the probability of a successful attempt at a vacancy hop and ν is the number of times per unit time that the system attempts to perform such a hop. E may be considered the effective energy barrier the system must overcome through thermal fluctuations (that are scaled by energy kb T ) to achieve the actual hop. Fig. 2 details schematically the actual process of a hop in terms of an idealized trajectory in the (3N − 3)-dimensional phase space. The system spends a long time in region A, oscillating back and forth in a small region of space at a time scale that defines ν, until at some point in time one of the neighboring atoms gains enough energy for it to migrate to the vacant site, resulting in the system moving to region B in phase space. Since such a process does not occur so often at 300 K, it usually is referred to as a rare event. Just how rare such an event is can be estimated via the attempt rate ν, which will be typically of the order of the period of oscillation of thermal atomic motion, or equivalently
§2.3
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
9
the typical frequency of a phonon in the system. The latter corresponds to ∼5 THz, and E for Al is known to be approximately 0.65 eV [28]. Thus at 300 K, is typically 700/s, or alternatively, the average time between hops is ∼1 ms. Given that the timestep per MD iteration is ∼1 fs, this constitutes a vacancy hop every ∼1012 MD iterations. With wall clock times for MD simulations being typically between 0, 1 and 1 s per MD step such a simulation becomes practically impossible. The above is a simple example of the study of a thermally activated process and since much of what goes on in the condensed matter state can be associated with such thermally activated processes it is a potent indicator of the time-scale limitations of the MD technique. A pertinent example of this in the field of nc plastic deformation simulation was already seen in Fig. 1(b), in which the stress carried by the computer generated nc material decreases as function of the applied strain rate – by reducing the strain rate slower atomic scale processes that can further relieve stress become increasingly active resulting in a reduction of the global simulation stress. There have been a number of attempts at developing modifications to the traditional MD technique, which in an autonomous way, promote the simulated atomic system to leave its local equilibrium configuration. The most well known approach is the so-called hyperdynamics in which a bias-potential is introduced when the system is within an harmonic well, and subsequently turned off as the system undergoes a transition to a new local equilibrium configuration [29,30]. An underlying problem has been that to determine whether or not a system is in local equilibrium requires information derived from the second derivatives of the total potential energy (the Hessian), which is a computationally intensive calculation. Other approaches such as temperature accelerated dynamics [31] and the parallel replica method [32], which rely on an easy way in which to identify a rare event process, have been applied successfully to wide range of material problems. In a complex atomic environment, where many atomic processes occur separately and independently such as in a GB, it remains unclear if such methods can be used effectively and efficiently. Recently, the parallel-replica method has been applied with some success to the study of stick-slip behavior of GBs in simple bi-crystal geometries [33]. An alternative approach to the study of such ‘rare event’ atomic scale processes is to employ the nudged elastic band (NEB) technique [34] to determine the minimum energy pathway between a state and end atomic configuration. This has been used in the study of atomistic crack propagation [35] and more recently slip transfer across twin boundaries [36].
2.3. Lengthscale restrictions With the advent of massively parallel computing it now becomes possible to routinely simulate tens to hundreds of millions of atoms through the spatial decomposition of the atomic configuration amongst the available processors. Despite this computing advancement, spatial limitations are always present, since even with a billion atoms, the corresponding size regime remains below a micrometer. The most common approach to reduce the number of atoms is to impose periodic boundary conditions on the sample, that is, the 3D simulation box is effectively surrounded by 26 exact copies of itself. Thus an atom close to the boundary of the simulation box will be
10
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
(a)
Ch. 81
(b)
Fig. 3. (a) Sketch of two-dimensional periodic boundary conditions, where the central atomic configuration is repeated around borders to simulate an FCC lattice of infinite size. (b) Cross-section of a computer generated nc sample under full three-dimensional periodic boundary conditions.
close to atoms that are close to the boundary on the opposite side of the simulation box. Fig. 3(a) provides a schematic 2D example of such a periodic boundary condition geometry. Such a procedure does impose restrictions on the effective bulk microstructure. For example, when constructing a grain network care must be taken in the shape and position of grains for the total configuration to be compatible with the imposed periodicity. Such issues become particularly evident in the construction of GB networks in which extended connectivity between misorientations of neighboring grains is required, or specific distributions of grain sizes and grain shape are needed. Fig. 3(b) displays a 2D cross-section of a 3D nc structure in which the simulation cell contains fifteen grains of random orientation. Under periodic boundary conditions, the effective bulk nc (super cell) structure exhibits a patterning that is far from experimental reality.
2.4. Empirical potentials for FCC metals Although the condensed matter state remains fundamentally a quantum system, the difference in masses between the atoms and the electrons, the latter of which contribute to the materials’ bonding properties, allows for a classical force to be defined between the atoms. This is, in essence, the adiabatic approximation where the atomic and electronic degrees of freedom can be decoupled from each other, allowing for the electronic degrees to be integrated out with respect to atomic motion. The precise form of the classical inter-atomic potential is thus of quantum origin. For closed shell systems, where there is not a strong electronic contribution to the bonding, a simple pair potential will suffice, which at short range will be repulsive and in the long range will be attractive. For metallic systems, the bonding originates from a combination of a screened ion–ion type interaction described by a pair term and an electronic band-energy term. For simple, s–p valent metals and d-state
§2.4
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
11
transition metals, this band term can be well represented by the width of the band of electronic states, resulting in a term that is equal to the square root of the sum of bond overlap integrals between neighboring atoms. Such an approach is referred to as the 2nd moment tight binding method [37,38]; a more general version being the so-called embedded atom method which has its theoretical origins in density functional theory [39]. For these models, the total energy is given by 1 V (rij ) , F [ρi ] + E= 2 i
j
where F [ ] is the so-called embedding function (a square-root function for 2nd moment tight binding method), ρi = j ρ(rij ) is the local “electron density” at atom i (constructed from the electron density, ρ(rij ), arising from each surrounding atom j ). For simple pair potential systems, the embedding function can either be zero or linear in the local electronic density. This method displays the essential unsaturated nature of the metallic bond, in which, if one bond is broken, the remaining bonds are strengthened. Generalizations of this approach have been applied to ferromagnetic bcc Fe in which the magnetism is modeled explicitly through a Ginzburg–Landau mean field approach [40,41]. For systems where there is strong hybridization between the electronic states of neighboring atoms, such as covalent systems and partially filled d-state systems, additional angular terms are required to describe the sensitivity of the band energy to local variations in atomic environment. For saturated sp 3 bonding systems, the three body Stillinger– Weber [42] and Tersoff [43] potentials have been used successfully for Si. More recently the bond-order method has been developed to describe in a systematic way the inter-atomic potential for a general hybridized system, by employment of the higher moments of the distribution of electronic states [44,45]. An excellent review of empirical potentials is given in Ref. [46]. The development of such empirical inter-atomic potentials for a given system generally involves searching for an optimal set of parameters for the chosen analytical interaction model, with respect to experimental and ab initio calculated material properties. Such a database of properties is generally restricted to equilibrium atomic configurations of the system such as lattice constants, cohesive energy, elastic constants, local and extended defect including vacancies, interstitials and stacking faults for the FCC, BCC and HCP phases. Performing simulations for systems not contained within in the data base used to develop a particular potential, thus involves the implicit assumption that the model is transferable. If the chosen analytical inter-atomic model captures the essential physics of the material’s bonding, then it is not unreasonable to make such an assumption. However one must always keep in mind that the theoretical models used to derive such empirical potentials contain many simplifying assumptions and therefore cannot be expected to have the same accuracy as that is seen in fully quantum mechanical calculations. The application of such analytical classical models do however allow for the extremely fast and efficient calculation of the energy and forces within an atomic system, when compared to ab initio derived energies and force. This results in large systems being able to be modeled involving millions of atoms when modern parallel computers are used.
12
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
2.5. Nanocrystalline sample construction As in experiment, the structural and mechanical properties of computer generated nc materials can be strongly dependent on the way in which the sample is constructed. For example, the issue of whether or not, the metallic nc GB is amorphous or not, can depend on the sample preparation method: more generally, the extent to which the computer generated nc state is from equilibrium will depend strongly on the preparation method, in turn affecting the nc mechanical properties [47]. 2.5.1. Geometrical construction In the modeling of nc systems, samples are often constructed by beginning with an empty simulation cell with fully 3D periodic boundary conditions, and choosing randomly a number of seed positions [48]. The number of seed positions is determined from the simulation cell size and the desired characteristic grain size. From each seed position, an FCC lattice is constructed geometrically with an orientation chosen either randomly or according to a texture [49] and/or orientation connectivity requirements [50]. At a point where atoms from one grain center are closer to the center of another grain, construction is halted. Eventually construction will cease throughout the entire sample, resulting in a three dimensional granular structure according to the Voronoi construction [51]. At this stage atom pairs, each atom originating from a different crystallite, are inspected and where there is a nearest neighbor distance of less than 0.2 nm, one atom is removed. Molecular statics is then performed to relax any local high potential energy configuration that may exist, followed by constant pressure MD at room temperature to further relax and equilibrate the structure. The constant pressure MD is performed using the Parrinello–Rahman Lagrangian with orthorhombic simulation cell geometry conditions. When the number of grains in the simulation cell is sufficiently large, such a Voronoi tessellation procedure has the advantage of producing a log-normal grain size distribution [23] – a size distribution that is commonly found in experimental bulk nc materials [52]. For computational reasons, early 3D simulation work generally employed a small number of grains and to avoid grain centers that are too close together, the grain centers where chosen to give a relatively narrow grain size distribution [53–55]. Other 3D work has chosen the grain centers to be at face-centered locations within the simulation cell resulting in identical rhombic dodecahedron grain shapes [25–27,56–58]. Such an approach has also been used in 2D nc simulation work in which the grain centers have been chosen to be at the vertices of a triangular lattice, resulting in a columnar GB with a given texture along the columns [59–62]. The advantage of such a 2D geometry is the ease with which large grain sizes can be simulated, whereas the disadvantage is that the reduced dimensionality allows for only a restricted class of GBs, a restriction in available slip systems, the preclusion of the fully 3D aspect of dislocation nucleation [47,63]. Indeed, by virtue of the imposed periodicity in the columnar direction, the dislocation cores will interact strongly with their images, producing immediately a kink-free dislocation of infinite extent along the columnar direction. Since the interaction between the propagating dislocation with the surrounding GB environment has recently been identified both experimentally [64–66] and computationally [21] as key elements of the operating slip mechanism, results obtained from 2D simulations have to be taken with special care.
§2.5
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
(a)
13
(b)
(c) Fig. 4. Atomic positions of a triple junction region for the (a) as-prepared, (b) annealed and (c) deformed samples. For both the annealed and as-prepared samples, migration of the triple junction to a more equilibrium configuration is observed. Figure is taken from Ref. [24].
The Voronoi tessellation procedure produces planar GB and triple junction geometries that are expected to be energetically unfavorable. Indeed MD simulations performed at elevated temperatures or under a uniaxial tensile load have revealed that certain triple junction geometries introduced by the Voronoi construction relax via GB/TJ migration to a more energetically favorable geometry [24]. Fig. 4 shows an example of TJ in which the starting configuration (a) is far from that containing the energetically favorable 120◦ GB plane angles, and which upon performing MD relaxes to a configuration in which the GB plane angles converge to ∼120◦ at the triple junction intersection (b). The limitations of such geometrical Voronoi constructions motivate the usage of tessellation data derived from 3D grain growth simulations in which an initially geometrical construction is allowed to evolve. Such modeling techniques involve phase field approaches [67] or vertex tracking techniques [68] producing networks that can be employed to construct more realistic atomistic nc samples. To date such an approach has not been employed to construct MD samples but offers a realistic alternative to the standard Voronoi constructure procedure. Procedures have been developed where experimental grain size and texture distributions can be used as input to develop more realistic GB networks suitable for MD simulation [69]. TEM analysis of experimental nc structures evidences the presence of many special GBs including coincidence site lattice (CSL) boundaries, perfect and general = 3 boundaries or low-angle pure tilt boundaries [70,71] suggesting possible discrepancies between the
14
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
type of GB structures incorporated in the simulations and those present in experimental samples. Recent simulation work has demonstrated that by modifying the Voronoi construction to contain clusters of grains with given configurations of coincident site lattice (CSL) and low-angle tilt boundaries, the simulated bulk deformation properties can be changed [50]. For example the low-angle cluster samples can accommodate deformation by rearrangement of their lattice dislocation network, whereas in the case of the CSL sample, the potential for strain accommodation is restricted by the high stability of the CSL boundaries with a resulting reduction in bulk plastic strain for a given load. Such clusters of special boundaries are expected to induce collective grain activity, a phenomenon that has been observed in MD simulations [72,73]. 2.5.2. Cluster compaction An experimental nc synthesis method used widely is the inert gas condensation method, in which free clusters are collected, and sintered under high pressure and temperature. At first sight such a technique can also be employed to produce nc samples. Individual crystallites can be brought together within the 3D periodic simulation cell and a hydrostatic load applied within the Parinello–Rhaman framework. MD or Monte Carlo can then be applied to allow the system to relax for a given pressure [74–76]. In the case of MD, typical simulation times are 100–200 ps. As in experiment, this often results in a porous structure existing throughout the simulation cell, the extent and degree of which can depend sensitively on the precise simulation procedure [74]. 2.5.3. Quenching from the melt Another technique used in the preparation of computer generated nc systems involves embedding small FCC crystalline configurations within a highly disordered structure above the melting point of the model material. Such seeds can be at random positions and random crystallographic orientations. The corresponding atoms are held fixed whilst the free atoms of the disordered structure evolve in position at the elevated temperature using MD. At some point the system’s temperature is cooled down, with the fixed crystallites acting as seeds for solidification, subsequently growing and meeting up at some point with those atoms of neighboring crystallites, forming a GB interface region and network [77–79]. The structure of the GB in terms of the degree of atomic order obtained in such a way will depend sensitively on the cooling rate and the pressure at which the simulation is performed. In particular since simulation cooling rates are always very high due to the short-time restriction of the MD simulation technique, the simulated cooling down procedure actually corresponds to an extremely fast quenching procedure when compared to experimental cooling rates. It is therefore likely that highly energetic interface structures are produced such as metallic amorphous grain boundary structures. The observation of such structures in metallic FCC nc structures [79] led to an early and controversial debate on the nature of GB interfaces in the nc environment. 2.6. Atomic visualization To capture the essential properties of an nc system, a large number of grains must be included within the atomic configuration. This in turn involves a large number of atoms, often
§2.6
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
15
numbering in the millions. Therefore, it is obvious that inspection at the atomic scale requires appropriate visualization methods in which filters can be applied to the atomic data. Several visualization methods have been developed providing a level of detail in the structural characterization of the GB that simply cannot be achieved through experiment. These methods facilitated the observation of atomic scale processes related to thermal processes during sample annealing or to the deformation mechanisms during plastic deformation. In addition to an atom position, a number of physical and structural properties can be calculated and assigned to it such as its medium range order, positional disorder, energy, local stress, etc. Using these quantities, one can develop a classification scheme allowing for instance the consideration of only those atoms that constitute the GB region. Of course, different classification schemes can lead to different views on the GB region [47]. For example, if atoms that are locally non-FCC are classified as GB atoms, this will portray a GB as a confined region with a thickness that is smaller than when the same GB is defined as consisting of those atoms having a local stress higher than some critical value [80]. It has been demonstrated that different patterns and degrees of order with different length scales are obtained when different visualization criteria are used for GB atoms, causing concern about fast conclusions regarding the disorder in nanosized GBs, when only one criterion such as energy is used [47,78]. This demonstrates the importance of using a variety of schemes, separately or in conjunction, to investigate the GB structure resulting from the computer synthesis methods, and to clearly state those used when quoting calculated GB properties. In what follows we summarize the main visualization methods that are currently used in the study of deformation behavior of nc metals, using an example of a dislocation that has propagated half-way across an nc grain (see Fig. 5). In Fig. 5, the viewing direction is parallel to the normal of the slip plane of the visualized full dislocation. For this example which is taken out of a simulation at 300 K the atomic visualization is greatly improved when thermal averages of the atomic positions and atomic quantities are used [81]. This is found to be particularly the case for the local stress quantities [82,83]. 2.6.1. Local energy The simplest classification scheme is to view atoms according to their local potential energy. For a second-moment tight-binding or embedded-atom potential, the local potential energy is given by Ei = F [ρi ] +
1 V (rij ). 2 j
For the nc system, GB regions can be to some extent identified by viewing only those atoms with energies greater than a certain threshold, for instance exceeding the cohesive energy by a value equaling the latent heat of melting. Such a method for the identification of the GB region must be used with caution, since one is by definition considering only those atoms in a high energy configuration, and therefore naturally biasing the probed GB structure to more disordered configurations. In the past such a criteria has been used and the calculation of the pair-distribution function of this selection of atoms has lead to the incorrect conclusion that FCC nc GB are amorphous [79].
16
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
Fig. 5. Six different methods of visualization of a dislocation segment within a nanocrystalline environment. Atoms are shaded according to (a) potential energy, (b) coordination, (c) medium range order, (d) position disorder, (e) hydrostatic pressure and (f) centro-symmetric parameter.
Fig. 5(a) displays the atomic positions of those atoms with a cohesive energy of approximately 0.1 eV higher than the FCC crystalline energy. Using this criterion the GB and partial dislocation core are visible. Close inspection of the GB and TJ regions reveals an interface thickness that contains many FCC atoms; and also a dislocation core region that is quite diffuse. Moreover, the stacking fault that remains behind the partial dislocation core cannot be identified – a more negative energy tolerance would be needed to identify those nearest neighbor coordinated HCP atoms that constitute the {111} stacking fault plane. Such a modification to the energy cutoff tolerance would in turn lead to a more extended and diffuse visualized GB network region. 2.6.2. Atomic coordination One can also identify the GB region using the coordination number of each atom. In the calculation of the coordination, the neighbor distance is generally defined as the mid-way
§2.6
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
17
Table 1 The local symmetry classification list used for the MRO visualization method PFCC GFCC PBCC GBCC PHCP GHCP OT12 OT8
FCC environment up to 4th nearest neighbor FCC environment up to 1st nearest neighbor BCC environment up to 4th nearest neighbor BCC environment up to 1st nearest neighbor HCP environment up to 4th nearest neighbor HCP environment up to 1st nearest neighbor 12 coordinated atom without the above symmetries 8 coordinated atom without the above symmetries
distance between first and second nearest neighbor distances of the appropriate crystalline structure. For example, an atom within the FCC environment has 12 nearest neighbors, and it is expected that a certain percentage of the atoms belonging to the GB region will not have a coordination of 12. An underlying problem of this method is that most atoms belonging to the GB will retain their 12 coordination, and therefore the method is biased in picturing only the less ordered highly energetic local atomic GB environments. Fig. 5(b) displays the atoms according to their coordination with light grey representing twelve coordinated atoms, and darker greys non-twelve coordinated atoms, and we see that the GB region is clearly identifiable, as well as the full dislocation. An important limitation of the atomic coordination is that it is unable to distinguish between HCP and FCC and thus unable to visualize the stacking fault defect between the leading and tailing partial dislocations. 2.6.3. Common neighbor analysis Atomic visualization of grain and GB structures has been greatly facilitated by a medium range order analysis of all atoms within the sample, which ascribes a local crystallinity class to each atom [84]. This is performed by selecting the common neighbors of a pair of atoms separated by no more than a second nearest neighbor distance, and introducing a classification scheme for the nearest-neighbor bond pathways between the two atoms. Since each crystalline symmetry has a unique topological signature, when all second nearest neighbor bond permutations are enumerated, a local symmetry label can be assigned to each atom – see Table 1. In this classification scheme, for a given crystal symmetry there are two groups: “perfect” and “good,” where “perfect” represents an atom situated in a particular crystallographic environment up to four neighbor shells away and “good” represents an atom situated in a particular crystallographic environment up to only the first nearest neighbor shell. This difference is useful in identifying those atoms within a crystalline environment close to a GB region or within the crystalline grain [85]. More commonly these two groupings have been combined to define one crystallinity in order to easily identify the entire crystalline grain regions. This local atomic classification scheme allows the GB network and structure to be easily identified. For examples of such atomic visualization of the GB we refer to Ref. [86], in which both high-angle and low-angle general GBs are shown. A significant advantage of such a local crystallinity analysis is that (111) HCP planes represent twin planes, and
18
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
two neighboring parallel (111) HCP planes represent an intrinsic stacking fault. The visualization of the twin planes has allowed for the easy identification of GBs containing structural units of a symmetric boundary [86]. In the case of stacking fault defects, this approach has given evidence for partial dislocation activity under uniaxial tensile loading conditions [87]. Fig. 5(c) demonstrates the power of this visualization technique, where the full dislocation and surrounding GBs are clearly evidenced. 2.6.4. Positional disorder An additional classification concerned with GB atoms indicates whether or not an atom is positionally disordered; an atom is regarded as positionally disordered when its location cannot be attached to a lattice site of the nearby FCC grains [48]. At first sight this may be considered a non-trivial task since in principle both the orientation and position of the neighboring FCC lattices need to be determined. However when the local crystallinity from the previous section is already known for the surrounding atoms, the task becomes straightforward. If a GB atom has at least one nearest neighbor atom that is FCC, then that GB atom must be at a lattice site of the FCC grain to which the neighboring FCC atom belongs to. If all nearest neighbor atoms are non-FCC, then that GB atom will be positionally disordered with respect to the nearby FCC lattices. Such a definition is approximate but generally appropriate for the fully dense and locally relaxed GB interfaces considered in the present work [48]. Inspection of Fig. 5(d) demonstrates that the positionally disordered atoms (black) can delineate the GB region, however it ignores much of the detail of the local GB structure and is therefore very limited. Most importantly, such a visualization method cannot resolve the dislocation core structure of the leading and trailing partial, nor the stacking fault defect connecting them. 2.6.5. Local stress and strain To calculate the global stress tensor within a computer simulation the virial theorem has been generally used, which in the thermodynamic limit of large V and N , represents the true bulk homogeneous stress. To investigate the spatial dependence of the stress field within the nc sample, one generally applies the virial theorem directly to each atom. It is however known that for such a volumetric partition, momentum is no longer conserved, leading to non-negligible artifacts such as oscillatory behavior in strongly inhomogeneous systems. A systematic approach has been developed that can represent local stress more accurately [88,89] via 1 1 μ ν 1 μ F (rij )rijν lij , mv v i + σ μν = 2 2 j
where is the volume of some representative partition element, i is unity if atom i is within the volume element and zero otherwise, and lij is the fraction of the length of the bond between atoms i and j lying within the volume element. The above equation rigorously satisfies conservation of linear momentum. In the present work we choose the volume element to be a sphere centered on each atom, and define the resulting stress of that sphere as the local stress of the central atom. The radius of the sphere is taken as 0.4 nm and contains approximately 19 atoms, which is generally less than the range of the empirical potential used. A thermal average is performed over 1 ps which typically
§3
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
19
spans a few atomic vibrational periods. Rather than the full stress tensor, the two scalar invariants of the stress tensor are directly visualized: the local hydrostatic pressure and local maximum resolved shear stress. A positive value for the hydrostatic pressure represents compression and negative dilatation. Past work has shown that on average, FCC metallic GBs are under a net tensile load although large variations between positive and negative hydrostatic pressure occur within the GB regions whereas the grain interior is under compressive load [24,83]. Fig. 5(e) displays the atoms shaded according to the local hydrostatic pressure where the darkest shades represent atoms with a tensile pressure less than −1 GPa, and the lighter shades a compressive pressure greater than 1 GPa. Fig. 5(e) demonstrates that the full dislocation structure is difficult to visualize using this shading scheme. This can be somewhat improved by changing the range of the shading scheme at the expense of visualizing the GB region. Past work has shown that the local stress measure becomes useful in identifying local regions within the GB that are under compression or tension [82,83]. Moreover, the local stress becomes a sensitive indicator of the GB structural changes that occur due to the arrival and absorption of a lattice dislocation – see Fig. 13 in Section 3.2. 2.6.6. Centro-symmetric parameter The centro-symmetric parameter is defined as |Rˆ i + Rˆ i+6 |2 , P = i=1,6
where Rˆ i and Rˆ i+6 are the vectors corresponding to the six pairs of opposite nearest neighbors in the distorted FCC lattice, giving numerical values of P that allow the identification of atoms within the crystalline lattice, stacking fault and dislocation core region environments. This visualization technique was developed to visualize the atomic scale plasticity occurring in nano-indentation MD simulations [90] and is particularly suited to visualizing the full dislocation structure as is shown in Fig. 5(f). 2.6.7. Free volume Free volume within a computer generated sample can easily be calculated by imposing a fine mesh of grid points over the simulation cell [91]. For each mesh point, the shortest distance to a nearby atom is calculated, if this distance is above a chosen value, then the grid point is defined as being associated with free volume. The threshold distance must be chosen to be at least half the nearest neighbor distance of the appropriate crystalline lattice, to avoid inclusion of free volume arising from the interstitial regions. With this information, the connectivity of the free volume regions (above a chosen threshold) leads to an easy identification of the free volume content within a GB. See Fig. 22 in Section 4.2, where free volume within a GB region has been identified.
3. Atomistic simulations of deformation in bulk 3D nanocrystalline metals The use of large scale molecular dynamics to study the mechanical properties of nc materials provides a detailed picture of the atomic-scale processes during plastic deformation at room temperature and has served as an inspiration for dedicated experiments [12],
20
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
where processes responsible for the plastic strain can be studied with an atomic resolution. Such processes have been classed as intergranular interface dominated processes such as GB sliding [53,92,93], GB migration [24,94] and GB diffusion in the form of Coble creep [56,95], and intragranular deformation processes involving dislocation activity with corresponding GB mechanisms that accommodate the associated slip [21,22,25–27,59–63, 82,96–98]. In the absence of defects within the grain interior it has been found that GBs can act as both sources and sinks for partial or full dislocations [92]. Moreover, the surrounding grain boundary environment can significantly affect the motion of a dislocation as it propagates through the grain. In particular atomistic simulation has revealed the following processes [21,92,99]: • Dislocation nucleation at the grain boundary is generally in regions where there is a high hydrostatic pressure concentration prior to the nucleation which is relieved after emission. • The nucleation and subsequent emission of the dislocation is accompanied by atomic shuffles and usually stress-assisted free volume migration within the grain boundary. • The leading and trailing partial dislocations that would constitute a full dislocation need not be nucleated in the same grain boundary region, nor for that matter, in the same grain boundary. • Nucleation and propagation are separate processes – often partials, whether leading or trailing, are nucleated but do not propagate. • Grain boundary structure such as misfit regions or ledges can hinder dislocation propagation to an extent that depends on the specific geometrical conditions and the Burgers vector. • When a dislocation is pinned, i.e. cannot pass by a grain boundary region, the depinning mechanism is thermally activated. Dislocation propagation between such pinning sites can be considered athermal. • The nature of the dislocation activity, whether it is only partial dislocation, full dislocation or twin migration can be understood in terms of an empirical potential’s generalized stacking fault energy curve.
3.1. The role of the generalized stacking fault energy curve A wide range of atomistic simulations covering both two- and three-dimensional nc configurations has revealed that depending on the type of metal, either full dislocations or partial dislocations are predominantly seen. For example, simulations for Cu and Ni exhibit only partial dislocation activity, whereas for Al full dislocation activity is seen [99]. Whether or not partial or full dislocation activity is predominant, has important consequences since the former results in the creation of a stacking fault energy defect that transects the entire grain. A “rule-of-thumb” argument that in the past has often been used to rationalize these observations is that metals with a low stacking fault energy have a tendency towards only partial dislocation activity since the cost in energy of leaving an extended stacking fault is relatively low [58,100]. Whilst consistent with Cu which has a low stacking fault energy equal to 38 mJ/m2 , it fails to explain why in Ni with a stacking fault energy equal to
§3.1
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
21
Fig. 6. General stacking fault curves for magnetic and non-magnetic Ni, Cu and Al. Figure taken from Ref. [104].
137 mJ/m2 partial dislocations are seen and in Al with a also a high stacking fault energy of 146 mJ/m2 , full dislocations are seen [21]. The stacking fault energy is part of a more general energy surface concept referred to as the generalized stacking fault energy (GSFE) curve. Formally this is defined as the energy dependency of rigidly shearing a crystal at a (111) plane along a [112] slip direction [101] and historically gives information about the shear properties of a perfect crystal and therefore insight into a material’s ideal shear strength as originally proposed by Frenkel [102] and more recently by Rice to study the nature of dislocation nucleation at a crack tip [103]. Although this quantity is not experimentally accessible, the GSFE curve has been the focus of considerable attention in the modeling of the mechanical strength of bulk crystalline materials. Fig. 6 displays such GSFE curves derived from density functional theory calculations for Cu, Ni and Al [104]. We see that as a function of rigid displacement, the energy of the system passes through a maximum that is referred to as the unstable stacking fault energy. Recent work has shown that both the stable and unstable stacking fault energies play a role in determining the nature of slip activity observed in the simulations of plasticity in nc GB networks [99]. Specifically, given the nucleation of a partial dislocation at the GB and its propagation into the grain, the likelihood that a second trailing partial is nucleated within the timeframe of a simulation depends on the ratio of the stable to unstable stacking fault surface energy density for the empirical potential used in the simulation. If this ratio is close to one, as it is in Al, then the likelihood of observing full dislocations within the nanosecond time frame of a classical molecular dynamics simulation is high. If the ratio is low as it is in Cu and Ni, the likelihood of seeing a full dislocation in a simulation is reduced. The underlying argument for this trend is that upon nucleation and propagation of a leading partial, the energy barrier that in part controls the probability of nucleating a trailing partial is a function of the difference between the unstable and stable stacking fault energy. If the ratio of these two quantities is close to one, then the barrier is small, and trailing partial dislocation nucleation is likely to be observed. We note that this does not constitute a criterion for full dislocation nucleation at a GB; rather it is a statement that can rationalize all published simulation results on the nature of slip activity within the nc environment [99]. Indeed, in addition to the applied stress, it is expected that the
22
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
Fig. 7. Idealized generalized stacking fault, twin fault and twin migration energy curves for Al. Figure is taken from Ref. [82].
detailed local conditions of the GB region will play a crucial role in whether or not partial dislocation nucleation occurs. For example, dislocation nucleation is often seen to occur in regions within the GB that contain strong local stress variations, which are relieved upon nucleation. Atomistic simulation has revealed that atomic scale GB processes such as atomic shuffling and free volume migration occur before and/or after partial dislocation nucleation and facilitating local stress relaxation [96,105]. Whether the observed stress relief is transferable to experimental conditions or whether this is related uniquely to the purity of the GBs remains an open question. The fact is that upon dislocation nucleation at a particular GB, the associated stress relief within that boundary makes it unlikely that the nucleation of the trailing partial dislocation will be seen within the timeframe of a simulation unless the ratio between an empirical potential’s unstable to stable stacking fault is very close to unity. The latter is the case for Al, for which the nucleation of the second partial is very likely within the time frame of the simulation, irrespective of the condition of the GB. With the creation of a stacking fault defect that transects the entire grain, other slip mechanisms become possible. In addition to the nucleation of a trailing partial on the same {111} slip plane as the leading partial, there is also the possibility that the trailing partial nucleates at a neighboring {111} plane resulting in the creation of a twin fault. Such a process can also be modeled using the rigid slip model resulting in a generalized twin fault energy (GTFE) curve. Fig. 7 displays the combined GSFE and GTFE curves for an Al empirical potential [106] and demonstrates that the energy barrier to twin faulting is higher than that of full dislocation activity. This gives an indication that for this model Al material, twin faulting is possible but less likely than full dislocation activity. Deformation twinning was first observed by molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of 2D Al columnar structures [60]. In simulations of 3D nc Cu twin formation was observed at larger strains as a competing process to partial dislocation activity [26]. Until here, we have considered only nc-GB networks that contain defect-free grains. Similar arguments can also be help in the understanding slip mediated plasticity in
§3.1
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
23
Fig. 8. An example of a grain in which (1) extended partial dislocation, (2) twin fault and (3) full dislocation activity was observed. Figure is taken from Ref. [97].
grains containing transecting twin faults geometrically introduced before deformation [82,97,107]. For example, if a partial dislocation is nucleated at a pre-existing twin plane, then the energy versus rigid displacement curve can be influenced significantly due to the presence of the twin. For Al (Fig. 7), the so-called unstable twin migration energy is significantly less than the unstable stacking fault energy indicating that if pre-existing twins existed, twin migration would be the dominant slip activity. Case studies of atomistic simulations of nc materials within and with out pre-existing twins will be given in detail in the next two sections. The above discussion on dislocation nucleation in terms of such rigid displacement energy curves raises a question regarding the extrapolation of the existence of extended partial dislocations as a deformation mechanism towards experiments, since the observation of extended partials might be influenced by the short time effect inherent to MD simulations. In particular, the atomistic simulations of nc Ni exhibit predominantly partial dislocation activity which, as a result, leave a dense stacking fault network throughout the nc grain structure – a prediction that is not in agreement with experiment. However, one expects that when much longer simulation times comparable to experiment could be achieved at lower strain rates, atomic scale processes could build up local stress intensities at the intersection between the stacking fault defects and the surrounding GB. This, in turn, could facilitate nucleation of a trailing partial that upon propagation would remove the stacking fault, or create a twin laminar fault that itself might grow via twin migration. Indeed it becomes plausible that the dislocation activity observed at the time scale resolution appropriate to experiment will be a mixture of the three types of slip systems represented in the generalized energy curve, the relative importance being heavily dependent also on the applied stress pattern and the GB structures. That all mechanisms are possible is shown in Fig. 8 where one particular Al grain underwent all three types of slip [97].
24
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
3.2. Case study one: dislocations in a defect free grain An important result of atomistic simulations for a variety of FCC metals and microstructural nc geometries has been that the plasticity is mainly due to propagating dislocations that have nucleated at grain boundaries [25,92]. As discussed in the previous section, the nature of the slip observed in MD is in part due to the GSFE curve of the empirical potential employed and therefore the classification according to full or partial dislocations should be taken with care. Simulations however have been important in revealing localized atomic scale GB processes that occur before, during and after dislocation nucleation, propagation and absorption. These processes are driven predominantly by a combination of the applied stress and local stress relaxation within the GBs. Moreover GB sliding which to a varying extent is always present, causes discrete atomic activity within the GB regions in the form of atomic shuffling and localized free volume migration resulting in changes in local stress, particularly at GB ledges and misfit regions that can lead to optimal conditions for the nucleation of slip within the neighboring FCC lattice. An example of the entire lifetime of a full dislocation in nc Al atomic configuration with a mean grain size of 10 nm has been documented in detail in Ref. [21]. Using the MRO atomic visualization, Figs 9–12 show the same atomic section over a period of time starting just before dislocation nucleation until absorption of the remaining lattice dislocation segment. For the central grain, the plane normal to the figures is the {111} plane in which slip occurs. Fig. 9 shows the earlier stages of the nucleation of a partial dislocation which is nucleated between 0 and 0.5 ps at a triple junction, remaining localized in this region for nearly 7 ps, at which time a second partial is nucleated (see Fig. 11 at 7.5 ps). The nucleation of such a partial dislocation is associated with pre- and/or post-cursor activity within the GB that can involve free volume migration between the nucleation region and a neighboring triple junction or region of misfit [96,105]. Between the nucleation of the leading and trailing partial, the leading partial fluctuates in size by bowing out into the grain and retracting a number of times – see Fig. 10. With the nucleation of the trailing partial at another triple junction region, the full dislocation then begins to propagate further into the grain until at 10 ps one end of the dislocation becomes pinned at the GB. Locally this region of the GB contains a step/ledge structure in an orientation relative to the leading partial dislocation’s Burger’s vector that makes it difficult to deposit the partial dislocation into the GB. As a result the dislocation bows out into the grain, via the creation of kinks piling up at both ends of the dislocation. As a result the leading partial dislocation can finally overcome the ledge structure, and deposit itself into the GB at ∼11.25 ps, resulting in a depinning and further propagation of the full dislocation into the grain. Inspection of Figs 11 and 12 reveals that the propagation and shape of the dislocation depends sensitively on where it is within the grain and the surrounding GB structure. For example the splitting distance between the leading and trailing partial is a strong function of the local stress within the grain and therefore variations in stress within a grain will lead to variations in the splitting distance along the dislocation line [108]. The type of GB influences how easily a dislocation propagates by depositing itself into the GB. For example the GB on the right in Figs 11 and 12 is under a tension, and deposition of the full dislocation into the GB occurs without any difficulty. Here, propagation appears to be
§3.2
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
25
Fig. 9. Snaps shots of the life of a full dislocation – nucleation of a leading partial dislocation.
athermal, which is not the case when pinning/depinning occurs [21]. Final absorption of the full dislocation in the GBs in the lower part of Fig. 12, after 18.25 ps, also demonstrates that the local structure of GB can result in only partial absorption, where the small dislocation segment in the lower left triple junction region at 18.25 ps remains for ∼5 ps before it is completely absorbed. Fig. 13 now displays the local hydrostatic pressure as defined in Section 2.6.5 for the same atomic configuration as in Figs 9–12, where in (a) the atomic section is taken just before nucleation of the leading partial and in (b) the atomic section is taken just after final absorption of the full dislocation. A change in the local stress can be observed as a result of the slip. For instance, the high local compressive pressure related to the pinning region has subsequently been removed, whereas the triple junction region where nucleation has occurred now contains new regions of high compressive pressure. Furthermore in other regions of the GB new compressive pressure regions have been created as a result of the dislocation activity. Similar changes can be seen in the local deviatoric or maximum resolved shear stress. Such high stress regions can themselves be catalysts for the future nucleation of dislocations and although such events have not yet been observed in the time frame of the simulation, it cannot be excluded that such structural changes might constitute mechanisms that facilitate slip transmission into neighboring grains. Due to the difference in the unstable and stable stacking fault, similar simulations performed for nc Ni [99] have, until now, only observed the nucleation of a leading partial which in the case detailed in Figs 9–12 would result in the creation of a stacking fault that transects the entire grain.
26 H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Fig. 10. Fluctuating leading partial dislocation before nucleation of trailing partial.
Ch. 81
§3.2
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
27
Fig. 11. Snaps shots of the life of a full dislocation – nucleation of a trailing partial dislocation and the creation of a full dislocation which is pinned at one end to a grain boundary ledge structure.
Fig. 12. Snaps shots of the life of a full dislocation – athermal propagation of a full dislocation through the grain until eventual complete absorption.
28
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
Fig. 13. Atomic section (a) before and (b) after the existence of a full dislocation, where atoms are shaded according to their local hydrostatic pressure.
3.3. Case study two: a grain containing twin defects Many experimental synthesis techniques produce nc FCC structures (Al, Cu, and Ni) with grown-in twin structures. The general planar fault energy curves (Fig. 14) show that nucleation of partial dislocations on planes adjacent to the pre-existing twin plane becomes energetically more likely for Al, so that twin migration can be expected to occur. For Cu the barrier for twin migration is similar to the unstable stacking fault energy, suggesting that twin migration will not dominate over partial mediated dislocation activity. The GSFE curves for Ni suggest an intermediate regime. A range of dedicated simulations on samples with pre-existing twins have been performed to test the suggestions coming from the GSFE curves [82,97,107]. Fig. 15 displays an nc sample containing fifteen grains with each grain containing a number of twin planes, identified as a dark grey HCP {111} plane transecting the entire grain. By inserting such defects one is faced with a number of new degrees of freedom such as the Schmid factor of the particular {111} plane and the number of twins per grain. In the deformation of such a sample, twin migration was indeed observed and the nucleation of the partial dislocations on the plane adjacent to the twin plane occurred in a similar way as to what was observed for defect-free grains: i.e. in regions of high local stress within the GB and atomic scale processes involving shuffling and free volume migration are seen before, during and after partial dislocation nucleation. In nc Al samples [82] twin migration was found to be the dominant process and compared to the defect free sample with the same GB network, the number of dislocation events was enhanced. Twins existing on {111} planes with a high Schmid factor contributed predominantly to the observed plastic strain. Moreover, when the number of twins was reduced, the amount of plastic strain reduced accordingly. Fig. 16 displays a cross-section in which a twin plane migrated in the central grain and a twin migration is occurring (lower right hand corner). When twin planes were along planes with a low Schmid factor, then the migration activity was reduced [82]. Similar simulations performed for nc Cu and nc Ni revealed that twin migration was not the dominant slip mechanism [82,97,107]. When all geometrically constructed twin
§3.3
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
(a)
29
(b)
(c) Fig. 14. General planar fault energy curves as predicted from empirical potentials for Al, Cu and Ni. Figure is taken from Ref. [97].
Fig. 15. The twinned nc Al sample with an average grain diameter of 12 nm. Figure is taken from Ref. [82].
30
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
Fig. 16. Cross-section of a twinned grain. The (111) planes, indicated by white, show the original position of the neighbor twin-boundary samples. Figure is taken from Ref. [82].
Fig. 17. Dislocations moving in regions constrained by twin boundaries in the nc Cu sample containing twin on low Schmid factor 111 planes. Figure is taken from Ref. [107].
planes where chosen to be on high Schmid factor planes, extended partial dislocations on planes parallel to the twin planes were observed. However, when all twins where chosen to be on low Schmid factor planes, the same loading conditions resulted in less plastic strain and extended partial dislocation activity occurred on slip planes with higher Schmid factors resulting in the dislocations intersecting the pre-existing twin plane. Thus twin planes can act as an obstacle for the propagation of extended partial dislocations across the entire grain thereby restricting the total amount of plastic strain – see Fig. 17. In these simulations, increasing the applied load eventually did result in transmission of slip across the twin faults albeit via a [100] slip system. For bi-crystalline configurations pure screw dislocations can be transmitted through coherent twin boundaries [109,110]. The geometry in these studies is however such that the impinging dislocation is a straight line, making
§4
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
31
the extrapolation towards an nc environment not obvious. More recently, MD simulations have revealed that step structures between twin planes existing in GBs with misorientations close to a pure twin boundary can act as sources for full dislocation nucleation within nc Al [23] – an important result when one considers that heavily twinned polycrystalline Cu with a mean grain size of 400 nm exhibits the high strength characteristic of nc materials but with an increased ductility [111]. In summary, the presence of grown-in twins in nc FCC metals can change the deformation mechanism, but the effect is not the same for all FCC metals and can be explained by the relative values of the extrema of the generalized planar fault energy curves. For the case of Cu and Ni, which have twin migration energy barriers that are not so different from their partial dislocation energy barriers, twin boundary migration will not become dominant. For the case of Al, where the twin migration energy barrier is considerably lower than the unstable stacking fault energy, twin migration becomes the favorable deformation mechanism for twin planes with a high Schmid factor.
4. Experimental-computational synergy tools The development of computational tools that measure experimentally accessible material properties of computer generated nc samples constitutes a powerful approach in developing more realistic atomic configurations, as well as providing a mechanism through which to interpret experimental results without the use of oversimplifying models. 4.1. X-ray diffraction X-ray diffraction (XRD) peak profile analysis has played a central role in the characterization of experimental nc microstructure, since it allows determination of the mean grain size and the root-mean-square (RMS) internal strain. Williamson and Hall demonstrated that the integral width (IW) of a 2θ diffraction peak can be decomposed into a contribution arising from a finite scattering volume and a contribution arising from local fluctuations in strain. In terms of the scattering vector, s = 2 sin θ/λ, the IW can be written as δs = δsSize + δsStrain , length that characterizes where δs = 2 cos θ δθ/λ. Here δsSize = 1/LSize , where
LSize is the
the coherent scattering volume, and δsStrain = 8 ε 2 s/5. Here ε 2 is the root-meansquare (RMS) strain. In the present context, LSize may be taken to represent the characteristic grain size of the nc system. Thus the above equation demonstrates that if the IWs are plotted as a function of their corresponding scattering angles, a linear relation is expected where the y-intercept is equal to the inverse of LSize and the gradient proportional to the RMS strain. For nc materials, experiments have revealed rather high RMS strains (particularly for the electrodeposited nc Ni samples) [52] suggesting large internal stresses exist within the microstructure. Such high internal stresses have been confirmed in stress dip-test experiments revealing an effective internal stress of 1.4 GPa in electrodeposited nc Ni [65]. To investi-
32
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
gate the possible origins of such high RMS strains, an algorithm has been created [80] to calculate two-theta X-ray diffraction profiles from computer generated nc samples. To calculate the elastic scattering intensity from a known atomic configuration, we consider the N atom sample to be immersed entirely in a monochromatic plane wave X-ray beam. Within the kinematical limit, the asymptotic scattered wave function for a given scattering vector k is given by = ψscatt (k) fi exp(i k · r i ). i
Here fi is the X-ray atomic form factor for atom i. The scattering intensity as a function of k may then be calculated from magnitude squared of the above equation. To obtain diffraction peaks of comparable quality to that of experiment, a very large number of atoms would be required. In the nc regime however, one may exploit the spherical symmetry of an non-textured nc structure and perform a spherical average of the scattering intensity of a given configuration. That is, 2 sin krij 1 2 dk fi exp(i k · r i ) = |f | N + , I (k) = 2π krij i
i,j,i =j
where k = 2π sin θ/λ and rij = | ri − r k |. In the above equation, all atoms are assumed the same type giving fi = f . The final summation over atomic pairs can be recast into a one dimensional integral weighted by the atomic configuration’s global pair-distribution function, giving finally rc sin kr sin krc rc cos krc I (k) = 1 + dr l(r) − + 4πρ kr k2 k3 0 rc sin kr rc cos krc dr l(r) , ≈1+ + 4πρ kr k2 0 where l(r) is the inter-atomic pair correlation function, rc the continuum cut-off distance which is typically slightly larger than the grain size, and ρ the bulk number density. The final approximation is valid when rc λ, which will generally be the case for the grain sizes considered. Fig. 18 shows two-theta diffraction spectra for two computer generated nc Ni samples with respective grains sizes of 5 and 12 nm, using the geometrical Voronoi construction technique outlined in Section 2.5.1. Close inspection [see Fig. 18(b)] reveals that for the small grain size, the peak width is indeed greater. Fig. 19 now shows the so-called Williamson–Hall plot for the calculated X-ray diffraction spectra and compares this to experimental data for electrodeposited nc Ni, which has a mean grain size of ∼30 nm. What becomes immediately clear is that with increasing grain size, the calculated Williamson– Hall plot becomes flat when the grain size is larger than 5 nm. Extrapolating this result to the experimental grain size of 30 nm, indicates that the geometrical approach of constructing nc samples would produce an nc structure with negligible RMS strain and no anisotropy – a result quite different from experiment. Experimentally, from the large RMS strain and the WH anisotropy a dislocation content of ∼4.9 × 1015 m−2 could be calculated [112,113], values that are not really supported by
§4.1
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
33
Fig. 18. (a) Calculated X-ray diffraction spectra of two computer generated nc Ni structures with mean grain sizes of 5 and 12 nm. (b) Blow up of the 111 and 200 peaks.
Fig. 19. A Williamson–Hall plot of the Ni5 and Ni12 samples in terms of the scattering magnitude. Figure is taken from Ref. [80].
TEM work. To check for possible sources of Williamson–Hall anisotropy, a certain lattice dislocation content has been introduced in the nc Al MD samples by deforming the configurations to large strains followed by short unloading times during which the dislocations could not all be absorbed in the GBs [114]. Fig. 20 displays the resulting Williamson–Hall plot arising from four samples (where DIS0 is the as-prepared sample and DIS1 to DIS3 contain an increasing lattice dislocation content due to the increasing amount of plastic deformation experienced by the sample). Clearly, the introduction of lattice dislocations into the grains increases the anisotropy, qualitatively reproducing the experimental anisotropy seen in Fig. 20 for electrodeposited nc Ni. Since simulations where performed for nc Al and the experimental results are for nc Ni, quantitative differences are expected due to the lower elastic anisotropy of Al.
34
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
Fig. 20. The calculated Williamson–Hall plot as a function of increasing dislocation content.
In the configuration DIS3 ∼15% of the 100 grains contained a lattice dislocation that was sitting well inside the grain, whereas the majority of the grains contained full or partial dislocations close to the GBs. The most interesting observation from these calculations was that even when the diffraction pattern is calculated from the same sample but excluding all grains with full lattice dislocations, the WH anisotropy and the RMS strain as pictured in Fig. 20 for DIS3 survived. In other words, dislocations that were incompletely absorbed in the GBs also contribute to the overall shape of the WH plot and the average RMS strain. Such an observation conforms with the TEM results on as-prepared and samples deformed at room temperature as well as with the in-situ XRD experiments. 4.2. Phonons Inelastic neutron scattering experiments have revealed that FCC nanocrystalline structures exhibit anomalous bulk phonon properties. The phonon or vibrational density of states (VDOS) can be calculated using two different approaches. In the first instance, the average VDOS for the grain interior and grain boundary regions is obtained via the Fourier transform of the velocity–velocity auto-correlation function, the latter of which is given by
1 v(0) ˜ · v(t) ˜ = v˜i (0) · v˜i (t), N i
and obtained directly from finite temperature MD simulations. In the above equation, the averages are performed separately over the grain interior and grain boundary regions to obtain the associated VDOS via the Fourier transform [85]. Although this method is relatively efficient and yields energy spectra that can be compared to experiment, it does not allow for an efficient investigation of the VDOS for one or a few atoms. To do this, the local VDOS is calculated directly from the imaginary part of the onsite Greens phonon function [115]. Fig. 21(a) displays the average VDOS for the interior of nc grains and Fig. 21(b) the average grain boundary VDOS. Fig. 21(a) confirms that the vibrational properties of the
§4.2
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
35
Fig. 21. Nanocrystalline Ni VDOS for (a) grain interior and (b) grain boundary region where the standard deviation derived from an environment ensemble is shown in grey.
Fig. 22. High-angle GB with viewing angle parallel to the GB normal where atoms are shaded according to their VDOS oscillator strength evaluated at phonon energies: (a) 44.791 meV and (b) 44.318 meV.
interior of the FCC grains differs little from that of the perfect lattice, whereas Fig. 21(b) shows that the VDOS of the GB is fundamentally different [85]. In the high frequency regime of the GB VDOS [Fig. 21(b)], a singular structure is observed in the grain boundary VDOS. Detailed inspection of the grain boundary structure reveals that such singular structure represents high-frequency localized modes at the interface region [115]. Fig. 22 displays the atomic structure of a grain boundary with atoms shaded according to their local VDOS oscillator strength at two phonon energies at which VDOS singular peaks are observed to occur. Here dark (light) shades of grey represent the maximum (minimum) oscillator strength. Inspection of Fig. 22 indicates that the corresponding vibrational modes are well localized in the grain boundary and in both cases correspond to regions of reduced coordination [115]. The present work establishes that such anomalous behavior arises from the low- and high-frequency vibrational properties of the grain boundary region [85,115], while within the grain interiors, the vibrational properties remain similar to that of bulk crystalline be-
36
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
havior. Moreover simulation has revealed that the low frequency non-quadratic behavior may arise from a reduced effective dimensionality in the grain boundaries since the VDOS is expected to scale at low frequencies as ωd−1 , where d is the spatial dimension. On the other hand, in the high-frequency regime, the anomalous behavior arises from localized vibrational modes within the grain boundary region. Knowledge of the grain boundary VDOS allows one to directly calculate the thermal mean-square-displacement (MSD) of grain boundary atoms within the harmonic approximation. Use of the VDOS displayed in Fig. 21 results in a thermal MSD of ∼85 × 10−6 nm2 . On the other hand, by calculating the XRD profile from atomic coordinates derived from both instantaneous and averaged atomic configurations one can extract bulk Debye–Waller factors and therefore bulk values for the MSD. Doing so gives ∼42 × 10−6 nm2 for the 12 nm and ∼46 × 10−6 nm2 for the 5 nm grain size sample, which are not so different from the calculated MSD (∼43 × 10−6 nm2 ) and also the experimental MSD (∼42 × 10−6 nm2 ) for bulk crystalline FCC Ni [116]. The smaller values (when compared to the grain boundary) and relative insensitivity to grain size of the XRD derived bulk MSD values reflects the fact that the Bragg peaks present in the calculated XRD patterns primarily probe the nc grain interiors, and not that of the grain boundary [80].
5. Discussion and concluding remarks The most important suggestion resulting from the many MD simulations studies that have been performed on nc FCC metals is that even in the absence of dislocation sources in the grain interior, dislocations still play an important role in the deformation mechanism. Indeed MD suggests that GBs act as dislocation sources as well as dislocation sinks, suggesting a slip mechanism that does not build up a dislocation network and does not leave dislocation debris. Using atomic scale visualization methods such as local crystallinity, local hydrostatic pressure and maximum resolved shear stress to explore discrete atomic activity, the importance of local grain boundary structure in terms of both the nucleation/propagation and absorption of the dislocation has been demonstrated. Meanwhile, many of the characteristic aspects of the suggested dislocation mechanism have been supported by experiments. Already in the early beginning of TEM investigations of nc metals, the lack of a dislocation network in the grain interior had been noticed in as-prepared as well as in deformed samples. However to observe “a dislocation mechanism without debris” in-situ investigations had to be performed. It was soon clear that due to the high internal strain typical for the experimental nc samples it was nearly impossible to follow with in-situ TEM the nucleation and propagation of a dislocation in a grain. A few in-situ experiments have been able to detect dislocation activity to some extent [117–121]. The TEM sample restrictions however did not allow the determination of where the dislocations were nucleated, which for instance could have been at the surface of the thin TEM foil instead of at a GB, neither had it been possible to determine the Burgers vector of the dislocations. More recent HR-TEM investigations have also confirmed dislocation storage at liquid nitrogen temper-
§5
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
37
ature [122] in electrodeposited nc-Ni, whereas no defect accumulation was observed at room temperature. In-situ X-ray powder diffraction performed with a special detector allowing the measurement of a diffraction pattern over 60◦ at once, allowed for the first time to demonstrate that in nc metals there is a plastic deformation mechanism operating that produces a similar amount of peak broadening as is the case for polycrystalline metals during ongoing deformation, however that upon unloading was fully recoverable [123–125]. In coarse grained structures, the permanent build up of peak broadening during deformation is related to the building up of a dislocation network. The recoverable peak broadening therefore was the first indication for the presence of a pervasive dislocation mechanism during plastic deformation and this in the absence of dislocation storage. Further in-situ experiments have demonstrated that when this experiment is performed at temperatures below 300 K, the peak broadening becomes irreversible, however when the temperature is raised back to 300 K during unloading, most of the peak broadening recovers [64]. Such an observation can be understood in terms of the suggestions from MD that not only dislocation nucleation but also dislocation propagation plays a role. Indeed, when performing MD at lower temperatures [81], it has been demonstrated that propagation can be hindered at GB ledges and that pinning–depinning is a thermally activated process. That propagation plays also an important role has been experimentally confirmed by the high values for both the internal and effective stress measured during stress reduction experiments together with the existence of negative creep [65]. Stress relaxation tests performed on electrodeposited ncNi allowed to assign an activation volume to the rate limiting deformation mechanism of the order of 10–20b3 [126], which is at least a factor of 10 lower then the usual values measured for coarse grained metals. However, MD simulations do not clarify whether the rate limiting process is nucleation or propagation, since from the atomistic aspect a similar volume could be assigned to both mechanisms [21]. In other words, the “dislocation mechanism without debris” suggested by MD simulations is quite well supported by experiments. A full extrapolation of the MD results towards the experimental regime however raises several major concerns: the first is related to the non-similarity between the experimental and computational GB network, the second is related to the temporal and spatial restrictions inherent to the simulation technique, which does not allow the determination of the rate limiting process. All computational 3D samples that have been used for deformation studies differ from the experimental samples in at least three ways: in XRD characteristics such as RMS strain and Williamson–Hall anisotropy, in impurity content and in GB network geometrical characteristics. Electrodeposited nc Ni has on average an RMS strain measured by XRD of about 0.4% and the Williamson–Hall plot exhibits a characteristic anisotropy. In-situ XRD studies have shown that only minor changes in RMS strain and Williamson– Hall anisotropy are observed between the as-prepared and plastically deformed electrodeposited nc-Ni samples [114,124], changes which are moreover predominantly related to the microplastic regime and not to the fully plastic regime. However, when calculating XRD patterns from MD samples, the RMS strain is only of the order of 0.05% with the Williamson–Hall plot being linear and therefore not exhibiting any type of anisotropy when the average grain size is above 5 nm. In other words, one has to take into account that the initial configurations considered in MD are different from the as-prepared experimental
38
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
Ch. 81
samples. Extensive calculations of XRD patterns of computational nc configurations have demonstrated that a WH anisotropy similar to that what is experimentally measured can be obtained from computational nc samples that have been deformed to large strains during which several lattice dislocations have been nucleated from, and absorbed in GBs. In other words, in order to obtain similar XRD characteristics between the experimental and the simulated samples, the GB network of the computational sample needs to have more pronounced stress intensities with a long range character extending into the grain interior. As the XRD calculations demonstrate, such stress intensities can be obtained by means of “incomplete” absorption of lattice dislocations. This in turn would mean that the GB characteristics of Voronoi constructed samples differ substantially in terms of local stress distributions. However it is not excluded that the different characteristics measured by XRD have to be related to other parameters such as for instance the lack in atomic impurities or nanoscale precipitates within the GBs, which is no doubt another major difference between experimental and MD samples. This in turn brings into question the role of the impurities in dislocation nucleation and propagation mechanisms, a topic that has until now hardly been addressed, predominantly due to the missing atomic potentials able to deal with light element impurities such as oxygen, phosphor and sulfur. It is however to be expected, as was discussed in Section 3.2, that the local relief of stress upon emission of a dislocation, or the atomic activity in the GB related to the absorption of a dislocation might be to a great extent influenced by impurity content in the GBs. Other possible sources of important differences between experimental and computational samples could be connectivity among different grain orientations, Schmid factor distributions among neighboring grains or localized textured clusters of grains. Such microstructural parameters are expected to play an important role in the nucleation and especially propagation of the dislocations. For instance, in 3D samples with general high angle GBs, slip transmission from one grain towards another is usually not observed, except for some special cases [127]. MD samples in which special grain clusters are repeated with the GB network have however demonstrated the importance of these clusters in the overall plasticity [50]. Especially in the latter case, where clusters of small angle GBs demonstrated the tendency to form larger grains, which when extrapolating towards experiments would mean the formation of a bimodal structure for which enhanced plasticity has been seen experimentally [128]. The second major concern when extrapolating MD results towards experiments is of course the timescale restriction inherent to MD. All MD simulations have been performed at very high strain rates that cannot be compared with experimental conditions, except in exceptional cases such as shock loading [129–131]. Such high strain rates are necessary in order to obtain enough plasticity during restricted simulation times, so that the characteristics of deformation mechanism can be explored. MD simulations have been used to study for instance yield or flow stress versus grain size [26] or to derive deformation maps [58]: however these results have to be taken with extreme care. As demonstrated in Section 2.1 the flow stress is clearly strain rate dependent, making extrapolation of simulation stress–strain curves towards experimental stress–strain curves a precarious domain. The same uncertainties are valid concerning the suggested deformation maps, where a critical grain size is suggested below which no dislocation activity is possible. For example, when a uniaxial tensile stress of 1.2 GPa is applied to an nc-Al sample with a mean grain
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials
39
Fig. 23. Comparison of dislocation activity in Al for two 15 grain samples with an average grain size of 5 nm under 1.2 and 1.5 GPa tensile stress. The insets show the formation of a full dislocation where (a) is a snapshot from just after the nucleation of the leading partial and (b) shows the nucleation of the trailing partial.
size of 5 nm, a strain rate of ∼1 × 108 /s is seen and no dislocations are observed. However, after the applied tensile stress is increased to a value of 1.5 GPa, the strain rate of the latter increases to ∼1 × 1010 /s and full dislocations are observed, as can be seen from Fig. 23. What has to be drawn as a conclusion from these results is that the competition between the nucleation of a leading dislocation, the nucleation barrier for a trailing dislocation, the additional amount of structural relaxation in the GBs accompanying nucleation and absorption processes is heavily influenced by the applied stress level in the simulation and therefore MD simulations alone cannot alone be used for extracting rate limiting nucleation criteria as a function of stress or grain size. This picture becomes even more complicated when one realizes that the amount of structural relaxation and atomic activity observed during nucleation/propagation and absorption of dislocations in an MD simulation might be unrealistically high, due to the lack of a realistic impurity content within the GB. The high strain rate/short time restrictions inherent to MD make it impossible to determine the true rate-limiting processes, and therefore, atomistic simulations are at present not suited for setting up a deformation map analogous to that used in constitutive plasticity for nanocrystalline structures, where the suggested mechanisms are quantified in terms of applied stress and grain size. Nevertheless, atomistic simulation has been very fruitful in, on the one hand confirming some of the earlier dislocation theories of the 50–60’s, and on the other hand, posing new questions especially concerning the interaction between dislocations and grain boundaries.
Acknowledgements The authors wish to acknowledge the financial support of the Swiss National Science Foundation and the 6th Framework European Union Program (NANOMESO).
40
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50]
F.R.N. Nabarro, Theory of Crystal Dislocations, Clarendon, 1967. J.P. Hirth, J. Lothe, Theory of Dislocations, second ed., John Wiley & Sons, 1982. J. Weertman, J.R. Weertman, Elementary Dislocation Theory, Macmillan, 1966. A.H. Cottrell, Theory of Crystal Dislocations, Gordon, 1964. J. Friedel, et al., Dislocations, Pergamon, 1964. W.T. Read, Dislocations in Crystals, McGraw–Hill, 1953. L.P. Kubin, et al., Solid State Phys. 23–24 (1992) 455–472. B. Devincre, L.P. Kubin, Mater. Sci. Eng. A (1997) 234–236. K.W. Schwarz, J. Appl. Phys. 85 (1) (1999). M.C. Fivel, available from: http://www.gpm2.inpg.fr/axes/plast/MicroPlast/ddd/. H. Gleiter, Prog. Mater. Sci. 33 (4) (1989) 223–315. H. Van Swygenhoven, J.R. Weertman, Mater. Today 9 (5) (2006) 24–31. E. Arzt, Acta Mater. 46 (16) (1998) 5611–5626. R.W. Siegel, G.J. Thomas, Ultramicroscopy 40 (3) (1992) 376–384. G.J. Thomas, R.W. Siegel, J.A. Eastman, Scripta Metall. Mater. 24 (1) (1990) 201–206. J.P. Hirth, Metall. Trans. 3 (12) (1972) 3047–3067. C.W. Price, J.P. Hirth, Mater. Sci. Eng. 9 (1) (1972) 15. R.Z. Valiev, V.Y. Gertsman, O.A. Kaibyshev, Phys. Status Solidi A Appl. Res. 97 (1) (1986) 11–56. D. Frenkel, B. Smit, Understanding Molecular Simulation, Academic, 2002. M. Parrinello, A. Rahman, J. Appl. Phys. 52 (12) (1981) 7182–7190. H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, A.G. Froseth, Acta Mater. 54 (7) (2006) 1975–1983. A.G. Froseth, P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Acta Mater. 52 (20) (2004) 5863–5870. A.G. Froseth, P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Scripta Mater. 54 (3) (2006) 477–481. A. Hasnaoui, H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, Acta Mater. 50 (15) (2002) 3927–3939. J. Schiotz, F.D. Di Tolla, K.W. Jacobsen, Nature 391 (6667) (1998) 561–563. J. Schiotz, K.W. Jacobsen, Science 301 (5638) (2003) 1357–1359. J. Schiotz, et al., Phys. Rev. B 60 (17) (1999) 11971–11983. Y. Mishin, et al., Phys. Rev. B 59 (1999) 3393–3407. A.F. Voter, J. Chem. Phys. 106 (11) (1997) 4665–4677. A.F. Voter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 78 (20) (1997) 3908–3911. M.R. Sorensen, A.F. Voter, J. Chem. Phys. 112 (21) (2000) 9599–9606. A.F. Voter, Phys. Rev. B 57 (22) (1998) 13985–13988. Y.S.A. Mishin, B.P. Uberuaga, A.F. Voter, Phys. Rev. B 75 (2007). H. Jónsson, G. Mills, W. Jacobsen, Classical and Quantum Dynamics in Condensed Phase Simulations, World, 1998. T. Zhu, J. Li, S. Yip, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93 (2004). T. Zhu, et al., Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 104 (9) (2007) 3031–3036. M.W. Finnis, J.E. Sinclair, Philos. Mag. A 50 (1) (1984) 45–55. F. Cleri, V. Rosato, Phys. Rev. B 48 (1) (1993) 22–33. M.S. Daw, M.I. Baskes, Phys. Rev. B 29 (12) (1984) 6443–6453. P.M. Derlet, S.L. Dudarev, Prog. Mater. Sci. 52 (2–3) (2007) 299–318. S.L. Dudarev, P.M. Derlet, J. Phys. Condens. Matter 17 (44) (2005) 7097–7118. F.H. Stillinger, T.A. Weber, Phys. Rev. B 31 (8) (1985) 5262–5271. J. Tersoff, Phys. Rev. B 39 (1989). D.G. Pettifor, et al., Comput. Mater. Sci. 23 (1–4) (2002) 33–37. D.G. Pettifor, I.I. Oleinik, Phys. Rev. B 65 (17) (2002). M.W. Finnis, Interatomic Forces in Condensed Matter, in: A.P. Sutton, R.E. Rudd (Eds.), Oxford Series on Materials Modeling, Oxford University Press, 2003. P.M. Derlet, A. Hasnaoui, H. Van Swygenhoven, Scripta Mater. 49 (7) (2003) 629–635. P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Phys. Rev. B 67 (1) (2003). H. Van Swygenhoven, M. Spaczer, A. Caro, Nanostruct. Mater. 10 (5) (1998) 819–828. A.G. Froseth, H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, Acta Mater. 53 (18) (2005) 4847–4856.
Atomistic Simulations of Dislocations in FCC Metallic Nanocrystalline Materials [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78] [79] [80] [81] [82] [83] [84] [85] [86] [87] [88] [89] [90] [91] [92] [93] [94] [95] [96] [97] [98] [99] [100] [101] [102] [103]
41
G. Voronoi, J. Reine Angew. Math. 134 (1908) 198–287. F. Dalla Torre, H. Van Swygenhoven, M. Victoria, Acta Mater. 50 (15) (2002) 3957–3970. H. Van Swygenhoven, P.A. Derlet, Phys. Rev. B 64 (22) (2001). H. Van Swygenhoven, M. Spaczer, A. Caro, Acta Mater. 47 (10) (1999) 3117–3126. H. Van Swygenhoven, et al., Phys. Rev. B 60 (1) (1999) 22–25. V. Yamakov, et al., Acta Mater. 50 (1) (2002) 61–73. V. Yamakov, et al., Philos. Mag. Lett. 83 (6) (2003) 385–393. V. Yamakov, et al., Nat. Mater. 3 (1) (2004) 43–47. V. Yamakov, et al., Acta Mater. 50 (20) (2002) 5005–5020. V. Yamakov, et al., Acta Mater. 51 (14) (2003) 4135–4147. V. Yamakov, et al., Acta Mater. 49 (14) (2001) 2713–2722. V. Yamakov, et al., Nat. Mater. 1 (1) (2002) 45–48. P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Scripta Mater. 47 (11) (2002) 719–724. S. Brandstetter, et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 87 (23) (2005). S. Van Petegem, et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 89 (7) (2006). Y.M. Wang, A.V. Hamza, E. Ma, Acta Mater. (2006) 2715–2726. C.E. Krill, L.Q. Chen, Acta Mater. 50 (12) (2002) 3057–3073. D. Weygand, Y. Brechet, J. Lepinoux, Philos. Mag. B Phys. Condens. Matter Statist. Mech. Electron. Opt. Magn. Prop. 78 (4) (1998) 329–352. D. Gross, M. Li, Appl. Phys. Lett. 80 (5) (2002) 746–748. K.S. Kumar, H. Van Swygenhoven, S. Suresh, Acta Mater. 51 (19) (2003) 5743–5774. W.M. Straub, et al., Nanostruct. Mater. 6 (5–8) (1995) 571–576. A. Hasnaoui, H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, Phys. Rev. B 66 (18) (2002). A. Hasnaoui, H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, Science 300 (5625) (2003) 1550–1552. R. Meyer, et al., Phys. Rev. B 68 (10) (2003). M. Hou, V.S. Kharlamov, E.E. Zhurkin, Phys. Rev. B 66 (19) (2002). Q. Hou, et al., Phys. Rev. B 62 (4) (2000) 2825–2834. P. Keblinski, et al., Nanostruct. Mater. 9 (1–8) (1997) 651–660. P. Keblinski, et al., Scripta Mater. 41 (6) (1999) 631–636. S.R. Phillpot, D. Wolf, H. Gleiter, J. Appl. Phys. 78 (2) (1995) 847–861. P.M. Derlet, S. Van Petegem, H. Van Swygenhoven, Phys. Rev. B 71 (2) (2005). H. Van Swygenhoven, Nat. Mater. 5 (11) (2006) 841. A. Froseth, H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, Acta Mater. 52 (8) (2004) 2259–2268. M. Samaras, et al., Phys. Rev. B 68 (22) (2003). J.D. Honeycutt, H.C. Andersen, J. Phys. Chem. 91 (19) (1987) 4950–4963. P.M. Derlet, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 87 (2001) 205501. H. Van Swygenhoven, D. Farkas, A. Caro, Phys. Rev. B 62 (2) (2000) 831–838. H. Van Swygenhoven, A. Caro, D. Farkas, Scripta Mater. 44 (8–9) (2001) 1513–1516. J. Cormier, J.M. Rickman, T.J. Delph, J. Appl. Phys. 89 (7) (2001) 4198. J. Cormier, J.M. Rickman, T.J. Delph, J. Appl. Phys. 89 (1) (2001) 99–104. C. Kelchner, S.J. Plimpton, J.C. Hamilton, Phys. Rev. B 58 (1998) 11085–11088. S. Van Petegem, J. Kuriplach, Acta Phys. Pol. A 107 (5) (2005) 769–775. H. Van Swygenhoven, Science 296 (5565) (2002) 66–67. H. Van Swygenhoven, A. Caro, Phys. Rev. B 58 (17) (1998) 11246–11251. A.J. Haslam, et al., Acta Mater. 52 (7) (2004) 1971–1987. D. Wolf, et al., Acta Mater. 53 (1) (2005) 1–40. H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, A. Hasnaoui, Phys. Rev. B 66 (2) (2002). A.G. Froseth, P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Adv. Eng. Mater. 7 (1–2) (2005) 16–20. P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, A. Hasnaoui, Philos. Mag. 83 (31–34) (2003) 3569–3575. H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, A.G. Froseth, Nat. Mater. 3 (6) (2004) 399–403. X.L. Wu, Q.Y. Zhu, Appl. Phys. Lett. 90 (2007). V. Vitek, Philos. Mag. 18 (1968) 773–786. J. Frenkel, Z. Phys. 37 (1926) 572. J. Rice, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 40 (1992) 239–271.
42
H. Van Swygenhoven and P.M. Derlet
[104] C. Brandl, P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Phys. Rev. B 76 (2007) 054124. [105] P.M. Derlet, H. Swygenhoven, A. Hasnaoui, Philos. Mag. 83 (2003) 3569–3575. [106] Y. Mishin, et al., Interatomic potential for Al and Ni from experimental data and ab initio calculations, in: Mat. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., Mater. Research Society, 1999, pp. 533–540. [107] A.G. Froseth, P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Appl. Phys. Lett. 85 (24) (2004) 5863–5865. [108] A.G. Froseth, P.M. Derlet, H. Swygenhoven, Acta Metall. 52 (2004). [109] Z.H. Jin, et al., Scripta Mater. 54 (6) (2006) 1163–1168. [110] J.K. Chen, G. Jr. Chen, Philos. Mag. A 78 (2) (1998) 405–422. [111] M.W. Chen, et al., Science 300 (5623) (2003) 1275–1277. [112] T. Ungar, A. Revesz, A. Borbely, J. Appl. Crystallogr. 31 (1998) 554–558. [113] T. Ungar, et al., Acta Mater. 46 (10) (1998) 3693–3699. [114] S. Branstetter, P.M. Derlet, S. Van Petegem, H. Van Swygenhoven, Acta Mater. 56 (2008) 165–176. [115] P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Phys. Rev. Lett. 92 (3) (2004). [116] L.M. Peng, et al., Acta Crystallogr. Sect. A 52 (1996) 456–470. [117] M. Dao, et al., Acta Mater. 54 (20) (2006) 5421–5432. [118] R.C. Hugo, et al., Acta Mater. 51 (7) (2003) 1937–1943. [119] C.J. Youngdahl, et al., Scripta Mater. 44 (8–9) (2001) 1475–1478. [120] M. Ke, et al., Nanostruct. Mater. 5 (6) (1995) 689–697. [121] K.S. Kumar, et al., Acta Mater. 51 (2) (2003) 387–405. [122] X.L. Wu, E. Ma, Appl. Phys. Lett. 88 (23) (2006). [123] Z. Budrovic, et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 86 (23) (2005). [124] Z. Budrovic, et al., Science 304 (5668) (2004) 273–276. [125] H. Van Swygenhoven, et al., Rev. Sci. Instrum. 77 (1) (2006). [126] Y.M. Wang, A.V. Hamza, E. Ma, Appl. Phys. Lett. 86 (24) (2005). [127] C.B.E. Brandl, P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Mechanisms of slip transfer through a general high angle grain boundary in nanocrystalline aluminum, 2007, submitted for publication. [128] Y.M. Wang, et al., Nature 419 (6910) (2002) 912–915. [129] M.A. Shehadeh, et al., Appl. Phys. Lett. 89 (17) (2006). [130] E.M. Bringa, A. Caro, E. Leveugle, Appl. Phys. Lett. 89 (2) (2006). [131] E.M. Bringa, et al., Science 309 (5742) (2005) 1838–1841.
CHAPTER 82
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals MARK A. TSCHOPP School of Materials Science and Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332-0245, USA Air Force Research Laboratory (UTC), Wright-Patterson Air Force Base, Dayton, OH 45433, USA
DOUGLAS E. SPEAROT Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of Arkansas, Fayetteville, AR 72701, USA and
DAVID L. MCDOWELL Woodruff School of Mechanical Engineering, School of Materials Science and Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology, Atlanta, GA 30332-0405, USA
© 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved 1572-4859, DOI: 10.1016/S1572-4859(07)00002-2
Dislocations in Solids Edited by J. P. Hirth
Contents 1. Introduction 46 1.1. Overview of grain boundary geometry 48 1.2. The structural unit model 50 1.3. Modeling dislocation nucleation 53 2. Atomistic simulation methodology 54 2.1. Molecular statics 55 2.2. Molecular dynamics 56 2.3. Virial stress 57 2.4. EAM potentials 58 2.5. Bicrystal simulation geometry 59 3. Structure and energy of tilt grain boundaries in Cu and Al 61 3.1. Calculation of interface energy 61 3.2. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries 62 3.2.1. Interface energy 62 3.2.2. Interface structure 63 3.3. Asymmetric tilt grain boundaries 69 3.3.1. Interface energy 71 3.3.2. Interface structure 73 3.3.2.1. Inclination angles < 70.53◦ 74 3.3.2.2. Inclination angles 70.53◦ 75 3.3.3. 3 ATGB structure and faceting 77 4. Dislocation nucleation from symmetric and asymmetric tilt boundaries in Cu and Al 79 4.1. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries 81 4.1.1. 5 (310) 36.9◦ interface 81 4.1.2. Grain boundaries with dissociated structure 85 4.1.3. Tensile stress required for dislocation nucleation 89 4.2. Asymmetric tilt grain boundaries 91 4.2.1. Stress required for dislocation nucleation 91 4.2.2. Low inclination angles ( 35.26◦ ) 93 4.2.3. Intermediate inclination angles (35.26◦ < < 70.53◦ ) 95 4.2.4. High inclination angles ( 70.53◦ ) 97 4.2.5. Preferential dislocation nucleation in Cu 99 5. Models for dislocation nucleation: single crystals and GBs 100 5.1. Homogeneous dislocation nucleation in single crystal Cu 100 5.1.1. Influence of resolved stresses 100 5.1.2. Second generation model for dislocation nucleation in single crystals 106 5.1.3. Dislocation nucleation in single crystals under uniaxial compression 108 5.1.4. Effect of lattice distortion on resolved stress components 111 5.2. Model for dislocation nucleation from tilt grain boundaries 112 5.2.1. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries 112 5.2.2. Extensions to asymmetric tilt GBs 115 6. Insights and implications 117 6.1. Grain boundary dislocation sources 118 6.2. Disconnections and the description of GB defects 120 6.3. Tension–compression asymmetry in trailing partial emission in Cu 122 6.4. Activation volumes and energies for grain boundary dislocation nucleation 125
6.5. Influence of grain boundary free volume on dislocation nucleation 127 6.6. Continuum field theory 128 7. Concluding remarks 133 Acknowledgements 135 References 135
1. Introduction According to materials scientist and philosopher Cyril Stanley Smith, the structure of materials is best described as a multilevel architecture, with “interplay of perfection and imperfection” among all length scales [1,2]. This point of view asserts that a clear understanding of material behavior at each length scale is imperative to elucidate the technological or economic value of a material [1]. However, many theories of macroscopic material behavior are not based on direct evaluation of micro- or nanoscale mechanisms. Two examples are the kinematic hardening model in continuum plasticity, which was posed to describe experimental observation of the Bauschinger effect [3], and the Hall–Petch relationship [4,5], which describes the increase in yield strength associated with the decrease in the grain size for metallic polycrystalline materials. Both Hall [4] and Petch [5] envisioned grain boundaries as obstacles to dislocation motion (resulting in dislocation pileups) and assumed that yield occurred once the stress exerted on the neighboring grain by the dislocation pile-up reached a critical value. Experimental observations of this type are of tremendous scientific importance; however, it is highly desirable to directly study the underlying material micro- and nanostructure with the aim of developing constitutive models that capture the activity and interaction of atomic-scale structure and associated mechanisms. For example, both experiments (cf. [6–8]) and simulations (cf. [9–12]) have reported that material softening occurs once the grain size is reduced below a critical grain diameter, which cannot be predicted by the classical Hall–Petch relationship. Moreover, it is understood that scale effects in plasticity occur over a range of mechanisms and scales. This work focuses on modeling the atomic level mechanisms associated with the structure and inelastic behavior of homophase grain boundaries (GBs) on the nanoscale and developing structure–property relationships that incorporate these nanoscale observations. Several experimental studies on polycrystalline metallic samples have reported that interface structure has an effect on material properties, such as grain boundary energy, mobility, corrosion, crack nucleation and ductility (cf. [13,14]). Most of the published experimental investigations indicate that there is some correlation between the occurrence of “special” coincident site lattice boundaries and material properties; however, results published in the literature do not point to a universal relationship. In nanocrystalline materials, the grain boundaries play a more profound role in material behavior due to the increased interfacial area associated with the decrease in the grain size. In addition, nanoscale confinement severely limits the operation of traditional dislocation sources, such as Frank–Read sources [15], mandating that the grain boundaries participate directly in the accommodation of the applied strain. Thus, grain boundary dislocation emission and absorption [16– 39], which may be coupled with atomic shuffling [38–40], stress assisted grain boundary sliding [38–45] and grain rotation [46], have all been observed in computational studies as potential grain boundary deformation mechanisms. Conceivably, the activation of
§1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
47
each grain boundary mechanism depends on several factors, including the electronic details of the material (intrinsic and unstable stacking fault energies), the grain size, the structure of the grain boundaries and the deformation conditions (strain state and strain rate). The objective of this work is to use atomistic simulations to examine the structure and dislocation nucleation/emission behavior of symmetric and asymmetric tilt grain boundaries in FCC copper and aluminum. Discrete atomic scale mechanisms associated with dislocation nucleation are incorporated into a first-order constitutive model for the tensile strength of tilt grain boundaries. This atomistically motivated constitutive model explicitly incorporates the orientation dependence of the opposing lattice regions and the influence of porosity within the interface region through an average measure based on coordination. Furthermore, this work provides a detailed understanding of the influence of grain boundary structure on dislocation nucleation which is critical for the advancement of grain boundary engineering concepts. Recall that the objective of grain boundary engineering [47] is to increase the percentage of “special” grain boundaries and to reduce the connectivity of “random” grain boundaries through material processing. Reducing the connectivity of random boundaries is found to be particularly important, as polycrystalline samples with a properly oriented continuous path of weak boundaries would be susceptible to failure regardless of the percentage of special interfaces [48]. Schuh et al. [14] reported that the fraction of special grain boundaries can be increased through sequential cycles of straining and annealing. As a result, enhancements in corrosion resistance, creep resistance and crack nucleation and growth resistance under various loading conditions have been observed experimentally. Of particular effectiveness is the introduction of annealing twins [49], which are essentially highly coherent GBs. Molecular dynamics simulations in this work provide a more refined definition of “special” with regard to how grain boundary structure affects dislocation nucleation. This chapter is organized as follows. The remainder of this section focuses on concepts related to grain boundary geometry and structure in metallic crystalline materials. Section 2 provides a brief overview of atomistic simulation techniques (equations of motion, interatomic potentials, etc.) and the specific simulation geometries used in this work to model grain boundary structure and dislocation nucleation. Section 3 discusses the dependence of grain boundary structure and energy on the misorientation angle/axis in the case of symmetric tilt grain boundaries and the inclination angle for asymmetric tilt grain boundaries. Section 4 investigates the relationship between interface structure and dislocation nucleation in symmetric and asymmetric tilt GBs. Section 5 presents a first-order, atomistically-inspired model designed to correlate the strength required for dislocation nucleation with interface structure via the interface free volume and the resolved stresses on the primary slip plane for uniaxial loading. To capture the influence of the lattice orientation, atomistic simulations of homogeneous dislocation nucleation in single crystals are also discussed. Section 6 discusses how atomic-level information of dislocation nucleation from grain boundaries can impact research in plasticity, micromechanics and grain boundary engineering techniques. A summary of major contributions in this work is provided in Section 7.
48
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 1. Schematic representation of the grain boundary misorientation scheme for (a) tilt boundaries and (b) general boundaries. Reprinted from [13] with permission; © 1997 Maney Publishing.
1.1. Overview of grain boundary geometry In general, solid–solid interfaces between crystalline regions may be classified into two categories: homophase and heterophase [50]. The set of homophase interfaces includes grain boundaries, twins and stacking faults in pure metals, whereas heterophase interfaces exist in binary and other material systems in which the composition and/or the Bravais lattice change across the interface plane. For homophase boundaries (such as those in this work), the degree of coherency is a function of the misorientation angle of the interface, the boundary plane orientation, and the nanoscale translations that exist to minimize the interface energy in the local neighborhood of the boundary. From a macroscopic perspective, planar interfaces between two crystal regions have five degrees of freedom [13,50, 51], i.e., an interface is fully characterized by a misorientation angle, θ, a misorientation axis vector, M, and the normal vector to the interface plane, N. Fig. 1 shows a schematic of the misorientation scheme. Boundaries for which the normal to the interface plane is perpendicular to the misorientation axis (M ⊥ N) are defined as “tilt” interfaces, as shown in Fig. 1(a). Similarly, boundaries for which the normal to the interface plane is parallel to the misorientation axis are defined as “twist” interfaces. Grain boundaries in actual polycrystalline materials may have both tilt and twist character, as shown in Fig. 1(b). From a microscopic perspective, interfaces between crystal lattices have three addition degrees of freedom associated with the mutual nanoscale translation of the opposing lattice regions parallel and perpendicular to the interface plane. These translations exist to minimize the interface energy for a given misorientation. These microscopic degrees of freedom do not need to be explicitly prescribed when modeling grain boundary structures, as they are resolved naturally during the energy minimization procedure within the framework of the atomistic simulations performed in this work.
§1.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
49
Fig. 2. Schematic of a 7 coincident site lattice (CSL) model. 1 in 7 lattice sites are coincident between the two lattice regions. Reprinted from [13] with permission; © 1997 Maney Publishing.
A small subset of interface misorientations are considered geometrically “special” in the sense that the opposing lattice regions fit more closely across the interface plane [13,50,51]. To illustrate this concept, Fig. 2 shows a two-dimensional schematic of two interpenetrating FCC lattices. The two lattice regions, A and B, are rotated relative to one another around a common misorientation axis. Specific angle/axis combinations will result in an array of coincidence lattice points. This array of lattice points is known as the coincident site lattice (CSL), while the inverse density of coincident lattice points is defined as . Specifically, in Fig. 2, lattice region B is rotated 22◦ around the 111 axis with respect to lattice region A. At this orientation, 1 in 7 lattice points is coincident between lattice regions A and B; thus, an interface with this angle/axis combination is defined as a 7 misorientation using the CSL methodology. In general, the CSL methodology may be considered as a shorthand notation used to describe specific misorientation angle/axis combinations. However, the CSL methodology does not uniquely account for each of the five macroscopic degrees of freedom, i.e., the index of the interface plane (or planes in the case of asymmetric boundaries) must also be included with to provide a complete description of the macroscopic grain boundary geometry. Furthermore, does not provide a characterization of the microscopic degrees of freedom of a grain boundary. Two grain boundaries with the same description can have very different grain boundary structures as observed in previous atomistic simulations [52,53]. This phenomenon will be discussed in greater detail in Section 3. Regardless, many authors have found that boundaries with low values of typically have special geometric characteristics and material properties [13] and hence a complete understanding of the relationship between interface structure and material behavior is critical to the advancement of constitutive models in a wide range of material systems.
50
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
1.2. The structural unit model The coherency of homophase low-angle tilt and twist grain boundaries (θ < 15◦ ) may be described through dislocation based models [15,54] in which the degree of coherency can be directly related to the spacing between misfit dislocations within the interface plane. If the misorientation angle of the interface is greater than 15◦ , the cores of the interfacial dislocations become too densely packed to accommodate individual distinction, requiring a different description of the interface structure. Sutton and Vitek [55–57] proposed that the coherency and structure of homophase high-angle boundaries in FCC metals may be described via the identification of structural units along the interface plane. This methodology became known as the structural unit model (SUM) and can be envisioned as a consequence of the CSL description, because the mathematical pattern of coincident atomic sites leads directly to a repeating periodic structure at the interface, once the boundary plane is specified. Atomistic simulations by Sutton and Vitek [55–58] using a pair-potential showed that many interfaces in FCC metals may be viewed as a linear combination of structural units. Each structural unit is associated with a “favored” boundary for a given misorientation axis. For the 001 misorientation axis, Wang et al. [58] reported that the favored boundaries are the 1 (110) (perfect lattice), 5 (210), 5 (310) and the 1 (100) (perfect lattice) interfaces. The structural units associated with each of these boundaries were denoted A–D, respectively. The 5 interface is the lowest order boundary for the 001 misorientation axis; however, Sutton and Vitek surprisingly found that favored interfaces did not always correspond to the lowest value of for a given misorientation axis. For the 110 misorientation axis, Sutton and Vitek [55] reported that favored boundaries exist at the 27 (115) and 11 (113) interfaces. Several other boundaries exist around the 110 misorientation axis that have a lower value. Rittner and Seidman [52,53] evaluated the entire range of 110 misorientations and found that the favored boundaries are the 1 (001) (perfect lattice), 27 (115), 11 (113), 3 (111), 9 (221) and the 1 (110) (perfect lattice) interfaces. The structural units associated with each of these boundaries were denoted A–E (with both 1 ‘interfaces’ defined as A structural units). Note that the 3 (112) interface is not found to be a favored boundary, even though it has a high density of coincident sites between lattice regions. This particular boundary is examined in detail in Sections 3 and 4. There are, however, several limitations to the structural unit model. First, it is difficult to identify structural units with three-dimensional character, i.e., twist boundaries. Second, the SUM has limited applicability for interfaces with mixed tilt and twist character or if a high index misorientation axis is examined [59]. While only four structural units are required to characterize 001 tilt boundaries, for high index misorientation axes the number of independent structural units becomes extremely large. Third, the SUM fails to describe interfaces with delocalized structural units. Rittner and colleagues [52,53,60] showed that for materials with low stacking fault energies, the interface dislocations tend to dissociate, leading to short intrinsic stacking fault (ISF) facets that extend from the interface plane. Rittner and Seidman also revealed that if the delocalization of the interface is severe, the structural units may not change continuously between two favored boundaries, requiring several variations of a given structural unit to describe the interface geometry. Molecular statics calculations presented in Section 3 will show several examples of each type of in-
§1.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
51
terface. Despite these limitations of the SUM, it is clear from many previous works that grain boundaries between two crystalline solids still have a repeating structure that can be identified over the length of the interface (even if it is extremely complex due to the dissociated nature of the interface structural units for example). Hence, the interface structure is not random or amorphous. Disclinations were originally conceived as rotational lattice defects to complement dislocations in the classic work of Volterra [61] and have been used as a component in the description of the structure of grain boundary interfaces in crystalline materials [62,63]. Disclinations contribute to lack of closure over a Burgers circuit manifested by gradients of lattice curvature. In contrast, closure deficiencies due to dislocations arise from the firstorder gradient of the deformation gradient. Tilt grain boundaries are closely associated with wedge disclinations because the Frank vector of the wedge disclination and the misorientation axis of the tilt boundary coincide, as shown in Fig. 3(g). Unlike dislocations, the displacement field around a disclination diverges and the stress field of a disclination dipole diverges with the separation of the dipole; thus, disclinations are commonly observed in closely spaced dipole or quadrupole configurations that effectively “screen” the divergent stress field [64]. The spacing between partial disclinations in dipole or quadrupole formations is defined as the dipole arm length. More recent work has combined the structural unit model with Li’s disclination-based description of the structure and energy of highangle grain boundaries [65–68]. The disclination-structural unit model (DSUM) [65–68] identifies the junction between neighboring dissimilar structural units as a partial wedge disclination. The DSUM theory leverages the fundamental assumption in the SUM that non-favored boundaries consist of alternating regions of different structural units, each of which has a defined misorientation angle characteristic of a specific favored boundary, as shown in Fig. 3(h). The strength of each partial wedge disclination is calculated from the misorientation angle associated with each structural unit, for example ω = ±(θ2 − θ1 ). The length of the disclination dipole arm is equivalent to the size of one of the structural units, which is related to the repeating period of the interface, Lp . Commonly, the minority structural unit (structural unit that appears less frequently) is represented as the disclination dipole, as shown in Fig. 3(i). Note that favored high-angle boundaries cannot be described in terms of disclination dipoles because the misorientation angle of the interface, θ, is equal to the misorientation angle associated with each structural unit, θ1 or θ2 . The DSUM is capable of predicting the interface energy as a function of misorientation for the complete range of 100 tilt boundaries in FCC metals [65]. Thus, it appears that the minimum energy structure of general high-angle boundaries can be described by repeating structural units associated with favored boundaries, connected by disclination dipoles to account for additional adjustments in misorientation at the boundary. Disconnections [69] may also be incorporated in the interface description to account for steps or other dislocations that create offset within the boundary. The equivalent dislocation representation of these disclination dipoles (in terms of discrete sets of Shockley partial dislocations) remains to be established, but it appears that they can be expressed in terms of general Somigliana dislocations [70]. In general, disclinations may be regarded as lattice defects that assist in accommodation of incompatibility between adjacent lattices. Results presented here show that disclination structural units deform as dislocations are nucleated, incorporating the change of the partial dislocation content of the boundary. In Section 6 we explore a more
52
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 3. Volterra’s defects: (a) reference cylinder with defect line ξ and cut surface S; (b, c) edge dislocations and (d) screw dislocation with Burgers vector b; (e, f) twist disclinations and (g) wedge disclination with Frank vector ω. A tilt grain boundary interface composed of two different structural units is shown in (h), with the disclination structural unit model representation appearing in (i); (h) and (i) reprinted from [68] with permission of the editorial board of The Physics of Metals and Metallography; © 1990 Springer.
§1.3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
53
precise concept of “disconnection” for describing general boundaries and boundaries that have experienced dislocation emission. We further comment on the issue of incorporating disclinations along with dislocations within the kinematics of defect field theory.
1.3. Modeling dislocation nucleation The homogeneous nucleation of dislocations in perfect single crystals is a result of strain localization at the elastic limit, which signifies the onset of inelastic behavior [71]. Classically, stress-based criteria have been used to define the initiation of defects in crystalline materials, such as the critical resolved shear stress (CRSS). These criteria envision the CRSS as a material property which characterizes the magnitude of the projected stress state necessary to cause slip. Although this type of approach greatly simplifies the analysis of inelastic material behavior and may be quite accurate with respect to slip of pre-existing dislocations within a crystalline lattice, recent computational evidence indicates that the classical CRSS approach is not sufficient to model dislocation nucleation in metallic crystalline materials. For example, Ogata et al. [72] used ab initio calculations to show that stress components acting on the slip plane in non-glide directions play a strong role on the critical shear stress required for dislocation nucleation. Specifically, they find that compressive stresses acting normal to the slip plane or within the slip plane perpendicular to the slip direction can increase or decrease the critical shear stress for nucleation. Complementary results have been attained by Tschopp et al. [73] who studied the homogeneous nucleation of dislocations during uniaxial tensile deformation via molecular dynamics simulations. In particular, Tschopp et al. reported that the stress normal to the slip plane plays a commanding role in the nucleation process for copper single crystals. Precise relationships between the non-glide direction stress components and the stress required for dislocation nucleation are discussed in greater detail in Section 5. Results of this ilk have motivated the development of more advanced nucleation criteria, such as that by Zhu et al. [74] which is based on bifurcation analysis of the elastic instability in FCC crystals. Zhu et al. showed that the elastic bifurcation criterion is superior with respect to the accuracy of the predicted nucleation site and the slip character of the dislocation. Molecular dynamics simulations can also serve as an effective tool to analyze heterogeneous dislocation nucleation and other related inelastic mechanisms from grain boundaries in nanocrystalline (NC) materials [9–12,20–37]. For example, molecular dynamics (MD) has been utilized to investigate the critical grain size associated with the transition between dislocation emission-mediated and GB-mediated deformation modes, which corresponds to the peak strength in FCC materials [11]. Above the critical grain size, MD simulations have shown that partial dislocation nucleation occurs at the grain boundaries and is often accompanied by atomic shuffling or other structural rearrangement within the GB plane [29,31]. For example, Schiotz [12] studied the formation of dislocation pileups at GBs in nanocrystalline Cu samples with grain sizes larger than 15–20 nm. Below the critical grain size, MD simulations have shown that GB sliding becomes the dominant deformation mechanism [10], giving rise to grain rotation. For example, Van Swygenhoven and Derlet [26] reported that GB sliding is triggered by atomic shuffling and stress-assisted
54
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
free volume migration from triple junctions. At very small grain sizes, MD simulations in their work showed that the emission of dislocations from GBs was limited. It is clear from the literature that dislocation nucleation in NC materials involves a number of complex and interrelated mechanisms. The combined tilt and twist character of grain boundaries and the inclination of the boundary plane with respect to the tensile axis complicates the analysis of the role of specific GB structures in NC simulations. In addition, different boundaries may nucleate and emit dislocations at different stresses in NC simulations; thus, it becomes very difficult to separate out the individual effects of GB structural units on dislocation nucleation. An alternative method to study the role of specific grain boundaries in dislocation nucleation is to use bicrystal simulations (cf. [16–19]). This allows precise control of the grain boundary degrees of freedom. In this work, both symmetric and asymmetric tilt grain boundaries are examined. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries facilitate the analysis of a wide range of structures for a given misorientation axis by varying the misorientation angle between the adjoining lattices. Moreover, the lattice symmetry about the grain boundary plane generates well-defined structures and simplifies the analysis of dislocation nucleation at these boundaries. Asymmetric tilt boundaries also present an interesting case for studying dislocation nucleation behavior because of the faceted structure and dissimilar adjoining crystal orientations with different Schmid factors [15]. Bicrystal atomistic simulations are a valuable tool for examining the relationship between grain boundary structure and dislocation nucleation from boundaries.
2. Atomistic simulation methodology Atomistic simulation refers to a suite of computational techniques used to model the interaction and configuration of a system of atoms. In this work, the term “atomistic simulation” will pertain to either molecular statics (MS) in which energy minimization is used to solve for a local minimum energy configuration or molecular dynamics in which Newton’s 2nd Law of Motion, which may be augmented by additional terms to control the dynamics of the system, is integrated numerically to solve for the trajectories of a set of atoms within a simulation cell. A brief overview of the atomistic simulation techniques utilized in this work is provided in this section. The reader is directed towards more detailed and comprehensive reviews in texts by Allen and Tildesley [75] and Haile [76]. In the atomistic framework, each atom is represented as a point mass in space while an interatomic potential is specified to provide a model for the potential energy of a system of atoms. Commonly, the total potential energy of the system is written solely as a function of the positions of the atomic nuclei. This simplification avoids having to specifically account for the motion and interaction of the individual electrons. Since interatomic forces are conserved, the force on a given atom, Fi , is related to the interatomic potential, U , through the gradient operator, i.e., ∂U (rN ) (1) . ∂ri Here, r is the atomic position vector. In this section, superscripts denote variables assigned to individual atoms, while subscripts denote variables associated with sets of atoms, directions or at specific time steps. Thus, rN represents the position vectors for the system of Fi = −
§2.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
55
N atoms while ri is the atomic position vector for the ith atom. The choice of the interatomic potential, U , depends on the material system of interest. For example, to study FCC transition metal systems, the embedded-atom method (EAM) is commonly employed. The details of the EAM and the accuracy of the selected interatomic potentials in this work with respect to material properties critical to the nucleation and motion of dislocations will be discussed in Section 2.4.
2.1. Molecular statics In this work, it is critical that the initial interface structures are described accurately in order to draw quantitative conclusions regarding the role of individual structural features in the deformation process. Thus, the initial bicrystal interface structures are obtained using molecular statics calculations which utilize an energy minimization technique. In general, numerical techniques, such as steepest decent or the conjugate gradient method, can be used to find a local minimum in the potential energy surface, as long as U (rN ) is continuous, contains a lower bound and the gradient U can be computed [77]. Recall from eq. (1) that the negative of the gradient of the potential energy U is the force vector. A local minimum in the potential energy surface is found by setting the gradient equal to zero and solving for the appropriate values of rN . In this work, energy minimization is achieved using a nonlinear conjugate gradient algorithm which incorporates the secant method to determine the appropriate step length and the Polak–Ribiere formulation for the search direction [77]. Unfortunately, there is no algorithm that guarantees determination of the global minimum energy configuration. Thus, this work follows previous bicrystal energy minimization calculations (cf. [52,60,78]) as a number of initial starting “positions” are used to increase the probability that the global minimum energy configuration is attained. One accomplishes this systematically by removing atomic layers at the interface or by manually translating the lattice regions normal and parallel to the interface plane and allowing the energy minimization procedure to rearrange the interface atoms as necessary (resolving the microscopic degrees of freedom of the grain boundary). For example, to access the minimum energy GB structures for the asymmetric tilt grain boundaries (ATGBs) discussed in Section 3.2, energy minimization calculations utilize over 2700 initial configurations with different in-plane rigid body translations and atom deletion criterion [79]. Tschopp and McDowell found that some asymmetric tilt grain boundaries have accessibilities [52] as low as 0.1%. To add an additional measure of certainty to the energy minimization calculations, we compare the interface structures obtained in this work to both high-resolution transmission electron microscopy images and electronic structure calculations of bicrystal configurations when available in the literature (cf. [80–85]). The methodology used in this work yields GB energies that are in agreement with both calculated and experimentally measured energies for 3 ATGBs [82,83]. Moreover, the GB structures associated with these energies are also in agreement with several experimentally observed high-resolution TEM images of 3 ATGB structures with 9R configuration (e.g., in Cu [83]). Further details of the simulation methodology used to obtain ATGB structures are given in Tschopp and McDowell [79].
56
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
2.2. Molecular dynamics In this work, molecular dynamics simulations are performed to study the tensile deformation of grain boundary interfaces on the nanoscale. In the molecular dynamics method, the evolution of atomic positions is described using Newton’s 2nd Law of Motion, p˙ i = Fi = m˙vi ,
(2)
where r˙ i =
dri pi = . dt m
(3)
Here, m is the mass, pi is the momentum and vi is the velocity of the ith atom. The “dot” signifies the first derivative with respect to time. Eqs (2) and (3) represent the equations of motion for a system of atoms that is isolated from the environment (microcanonical ensemble). Of course, the vast majority of problems in the mechanics and materials science community require that the system interact with the surrounding environment. One method to accomplish this in the MD framework is to introduce the concept of an extended system [86]. Essentially, Newton’s equations of motion are augmented and coupled to additional differential equations that characterize the relationship between the system and the environment. For example, to model the atomic trajectories within the constant pressure, constant temperature (NPT) ensemble, the following set of equations has been proposed [87], pi + η ri − R 0 , m p˙ i = Fi − (η + ζ I)pi , T ˙ζ = vT2 −1 , T0 r˙ i =
η˙ =
vP2 V (σ − P0 ), NkT0
h˙ = ηh.
(4)
Here, R0 is the center of mass of the system. The isobaric friction coefficient, η, is a function of the desired pressure or stress, P0 , Boltzmann’s constant, k, and the constant pressure damping coefficient, vP . The thermodynamic friction coefficient, ζ , is a function of the thermal reservoir temperature, T0 , and the thermostating rate, νT . The boundaries of the system are defined by a set of vectors, h, that are aligned along the edges of the periodic unit cell. Melchionna et al. [87] showed that the equations of motion in eq. (4), which are derived from earlier versions by Nose and Hoover [88,89], correctly reproduce the NPT distribution function. Further, since the Melchionna et al. equations do not require scaling of the atomic positions or velocities to reproduce the NPT ensemble, they may be easily incorporated into the standard framework of a MD code.
§2.3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
57
2.3. Virial stress The physical interpretation of stress in an atomistic system is one that has been argued from different points of view in the literature over the past thirty years [90–95]. Mathematically, the virial stress may be computed by first using the volume around a given atom, i , to form a point-wise measure of stress, i.e., 1 1 U ij ij i i r r − mv v , i = i (5) 2 r ij α β i
i =j
i
with i =
λ3 . 4
(6) ij
ij
In eq. (5), r ij is the distance between atoms i and j ; rα and rβ are the components of the total distance in the α and β directions. The “prime” denotes the first derivative with respect to atomic position. In eq. (6), λ is the lattice parameter. Eq. (6) is derived as an approximation of the volume around an atom in a FCC lattice. The point-wise measure of stress, i , does not have any physical interpretation unless it is averaged over a “representative” number of atoms, i.e., σ =
N 1 i . N
(7)
i=1
Zimmerman et al. [95] investigated the concept of a representative number of atoms using two expressions for stress in an atomistic system (one of which is the stress derived from the virial theorem). They reported that for situations of non-zero deformation at finite temperature, fluctuations exist in the virial stress calculation when the summation is performed over small volumes around an arbitrary point within the simulation cell, i.e., when the calculation is not performed within the thermodynamic limit. As the size of the averaging region increases, the fluctuations in the stress calculation decrease. They also find that the fluctuations in the stress decrease at a faster rate if both spatial and temporal averaging is performed. Several authors in the literature have attempted to develop expressions for stress in an atomistic system that are defined for a spatial point at an instant of time from the equation for balance of linear momentum for a dynamic continuum [92,94]. From this perspective, Zhou [94] showed that the virial stress expression is unable to handle simple cases of rigid body translation in atomic systems. More importantly, Zhou also showed that the pointwise virial stress expression in eq. (5) violates classical conservation of linear momentum. Zhou argued that in a dynamically deforming atomic system, the stress should be a function of only the force between particles in order to maintain equivalence with the classical definition of the Cauchy stress and asserts that the kinetic contribution to the stress is already accounted for through the force term and that the kinetic contribution to the point-wise virial stress is incorrect if stress is to be interpreted as a force interaction between material points. It is beyond the scope of this work to provide a full review and discussion of stress calculations in atomistic systems. In this work, the kinetic contribution to the virial stress is
58
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
retained, understanding that there are the possible ambiguities with regard to conservation of linear momentum if the virial expression is used to obtain highly localized measures of stress. Note that for solids, the kinetic energy term is small as compared with the interatomic force term. This observation is particularly true when calculations are performed at relatively low temperatures (10 and 300 K) and when the system is subjected to an external deformation. Furthermore, in this work, stress is averaged over a large volume around the region of interest to reduce the fluctuations in the virial stress response [95]. However, the stresses reported in this work are not time averaged, i.e., they are reported at defined instants in time during the simulation.
2.4. EAM potentials Daw and Baskes [96,97] developed the embedded-atom method to describe atomic bonding in metallic systems. In the EAM, each atom is viewed as being embedded in the background electron density provided by neighboring atoms. Thus, the potential energy of a set of atoms is taken as the summation of the pair interaction energy between nuclei of atoms i and j and the embedding energy as a function of the local background electron density around ith atom. Since the background electron density is a local quantity, the embedded-atom method is applicable for examining systems with crystalline defects, such as dislocations and grain boundaries. However, an important assumption in the derivation of the EAM expression is that the electron cloud around each atom is spherical in shape. Thus, it is assumed that bond orientation is not important in the description of the potential energy. This approximation is valid for FCC crystal structures with either nearly empty or nearly full d-bands [98]; however, the EAM struggles to accurately describe systems where directional bonding is important, such as BCC, HCP and nonmetallic materials. The Mishin et al. EAM interatomic potentials for aluminum [99] and copper [100] are utilized in this work. These potentials are numerically fit to give many correct physical properties for Cu and Al, including the equilibrium lattice parameter, the cohesive energy, elastic constants, and the vacancy formation energy. To model grain boundary structure and dislocation nucleation, Van Swygenhoven and colleagues [32,34] argued the importance of both the intrinsic and unstable stacking fault energies, γISF and γUS . The intrinsic stacking fault energy is critical for atomistic simulations of fracture and deformation because it defines the width of partial dislocation dissociation; this not only affects full and partial dislocation emission, but also the grain boundary structure in crystalline materials. The unstable stacking fault energy is related to the barrier for dislocation nucleation events [101]. For NC materials, Van Swygenhoven et al. proposed that the transition between partial and full dislocation emission can be correctly understood in terms of the generalized planar fault energy curve, which considers both the intrinsic and the unstable stacking fault energies. They find that the ratio of intrinsic to unstable stacking fault energies is a critical parameter for determining whether a trailing partial dislocation is emitted from the GB in nanocrystalline materials; as this ratio approaches unity, the energy barrier for creating a trailing partial dislocation is very low. Mishin et al. reported excellent agreement between the intrinsic stacking fault energy computed with their Cu and Al potentials as compared with experimental and ab initio calculations. Moreover, an analysis by Boyer et al. [102]
§2.5
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
59
Fig. 4. (a) Three-dimensional periodic bicrystal computational cell employed in this work. Crystal regions 1 and 2 are separated by two interfaces: one at the center of the cell and one periodic interface at the lower/upper cell bounds. The misorientation axis, M, and misorientation, θ , are also shown. (b) Schematic illustration of the excess interface energy calculation.
and Zimmerman et al. [103] of stress–displacement, atomic relaxation, and the γ -surface ¯ shear indicated that the Mishin et al. Cu and Al potentials capture the esfor {111}112 sential characteristics of deformation, including the unstable stacking fault energy, in line with ab initio electronic structure calculations. Thus, the EAM potentials utilized in this work are considered sufficient to model the structure of symmetric and asymmetric tilt grain boundaries as well as the nucleation of dislocations from these boundaries.
2.5. Bicrystal simulation geometry In this work, we develop bicrystal interface models using a combination of molecular statics (energy minimization) and molecular dynamics simulations. An example bicrystal interface model is shown in Fig. 4. For symmetric tilt grain boundaries, the interface misorientation is created by a symmetric rotation, θ , of opposing lattice regions around a misorientation axis, M. For asymmetric tilt grain boundaries, the misorientation angle remains fixed at a defined θ and the two lattices are rotated about the misorientation axis by the same angle, such that crystal region 1 and crystal region 2 (Fig. 4) are now asymmetric with respect to the boundary plane. For boundaries with a [001] misorientation axis, the interface misorientation angle is measured using the [100] direction as the reference ¯ misorientation axis, the interface misorientation angle is (0◦ ). For boundaries with a [110] measured using the [001] direction as the reference (0◦ ). One of the inherent limitations of the atomistic method is that computational resources often demand that systems are limited to relatively small numbers of atoms. While the study of nanoscale surface effects is extremely important, the goal of this work is to examine atomic scale behavior that is rep-
60
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
resentative of what would occur in a bulk sample with micro or nanoscale grain structure. Thus, periodic boundary conditions are used in all directions (X, Y and Z) to eliminate the influence of free surface effects. The bicrystal interface model dimensions are defined accordingly to properly enforce this boundary prescription. Unfortunately, while periodic boundary conditions remove the effects of free surfaces, they impart image constraints on the system which must be taken into consideration when simulating defect behavior with long-range interactions. Such long-range interactions are characteristic of dislocations and grain boundaries with asymmetric structure, as will be modeled in this work. Specifically, the use of periodic boundary conditions in the Y -direction introduces a second interface into the model, which in turn gives rise to forces on dislocations. For symmetric tilt boundaries, the stress field decreases exponentially away from the interface [15]. In the symmetric case, the spacing between interfaces, H /2, is sufficiently large to minimize effects on nucleation of the first dislocation. However, this is not case for asymmetric tilt boundaries or symmetric boundaries with asymmetric interface structure. Furthermore, as these calculations will show, the nucleation of dislocations causes distortion in the interface structure. This is particularly true in the case of dissociated interfaces, where partial dislocation emission is inherent to the interface structure. If the interface distortion is idealized as a single dislocation positioned at the nucleation point [104], the magnitude of the shear stress on the primary slip planes due to the distorted boundary at a distance H /2 away from the interface is generally less than 10% of the ideal shear strength derived from first-principles calculations [72]. Accordingly, we consider the dimensions of the periodic model suitable for the study of dislocation nucleation phenomena at early stages. Moreover, because they employ periodic boundary conditions, the present bicrystal simulations are most appropriate for studying grain boundary structure and dislocation nucleation mechanisms, leaving the study of long-range field interactions of dislocations in a lattice with a boundary to other approaches, such as the CADD method [105,106] or matching atomistics near the boundary with a quasicontinuum far-field domain [107,108]. After the minimum energy configuration is attained via molecular statics calculations as discussed in Section 2.1, isobaric–isothermal molecular dynamics simulations are used to equilibrate the bicrystal interface model to a pressure of 0 bar and a temperature of either 10 or 300 K. The nucleation of dislocations at both temperatures will be discussed in Section 4. During this thermodynamic equilibration, the Melchionna et al. isobaric– isothermal equations of motion [87] govern the dynamics of the system. Upon completion of the equilibration process, molecular dynamics simulations are used to study the deformation of each interface model in uniaxial tension, which is applied normal to the interface plane (Y -direction). A constant strain rate of 109 s−1 is introduced by decoupling the vector which describes the dimensions of the periodic cell from the equations of motion in the loading direction and extending the length of this vector during the simulation [109]. Essentially, the time rate of change of the periodic cell length is prescribed in the loading direction in accordance with a desired strain rate. The motions of the boundaries in the transverse directions (X and Z) are calculated from the current and prescribed system stresses using the Melchionna et al. equations of motion. For all simulations in this work, the boundaries perpendicular to the interface plane are specified as stress-free. The 109 s−1 strain rate was chosen for its computational efficiency vs. lower strain rates and
§3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
61
to avoid the detrimental effects (e.g., inducing shock waves within the computational cell) that are introduced at higher strain rates. Atomistic simulations of grain boundary dislocation nucleation in uniaxial tension and compression under quasistatic loading conditions (as applied in Ref. [110]) have shown similar stress–strain responses and dislocation nucleation mechanisms to those of the dynamic strain rate used here. Therefore, this strain rate is deemed sufficient for investigating dislocation nucleation from grain boundaries.
3. Structure and energy of tilt grain boundaries in Cu and Al As discussed in Sections 1 and 2, this work focuses on the nucleation of dislocations from symmetric and asymmetric tilt bicrystal interfaces with the aim of developing correlations between grain boundary structure and dislocation nucleation. Accordingly, it is critical that a thorough understanding of the underlying interface structure as a function misorientation or inclination angle is established. Of particular importance are natural connections between interface structure in symmetric and asymmetric boundaries. For example, this work reports that the asymmetry between adjoining lattice regions results in nanoscale faceting along the grain boundary plane. The structure of the facets and the structural features adjoining the facets in ATGBs can be correlated to the structural features observed in symmetric tilt grain boundaries with similar misorientation. 3.1. Calculation of interface energy Interface energy is calculated by considering the energy at the boundary between the two crystalline regions that is in excess of the intrinsic energy of the bulk lattices [111–113]. This concept is schematically illustrated in Fig. 4(b) and is mathematically expressed as y2 int γ = (8) e(y) dy − e1 (y1 − Y0 ) − e2 (Y0 − y2 ). y1
In eq. (8), e(y) is the energy profile normal to the interface, e1 is the bulk energy in region 1 (upper crystalline region) and e2 is the bulk energy in region 2 (lower crystalline region). The vertical locations Y0 , y1 and y2 are defined schematically in Fig. 4(b). This definition does not require the introduction of an interface volume or region around the bicrystal boundary as long as y1 and y2 extend beyond the region which is distorted by the planar defect. Note that this work specifically addresses homophase interfaces; thus, the bulk energies of crystal regions 1 and 2 are identical after energy minimization and a rigorous separation of the energy profile normal to the interface into two regions is not necessary. Regardless, eq. (8) is posed in the general form to emphasize that the calculation of excess interface energy can be extended to heterophase boundaries. Slight modifications are required in order to apply eq. (8) to discrete atomistic systems. Notably, the integral of the energy profile must be replaced by a summation over a set of atoms within each crystalline region, i.e., E
int
N1 N2 = [ei − e1 ] + [ei − e2 ]. i=1
i=1
(9)
62
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 5. Bicrystal interface energy for copper and aluminum tilt [001] interface models.
Here, N1 and N2 are the number of atoms in regions 1 and 2, respectively. The bulk energies, e1 and e2 , are determined by averaging the ei of a group of atoms positioned sufficiently far away from the interface such that the presence of the boundary is not detected. Using e1 and e2 , an excess energy is computed for every atom within the interface model; the sum of these excess energies is defined as the total interface energy. In this work the bulk energies of regions 1 and 2 are identical after energy minimization (e1 = e2 = e); thus, the interface energy can be computed by summing the excess energy over all atoms (with appropriate treatment of the mirror image interface), which avoids the explicit assignment of atoms to either crystal regions 1 or 2.
3.2. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries 3.2.1. Interface energy Fig. 5 shows interface energy versus misorientation angle for symmetric tilt [001] boundaries in both copper and aluminum. The energy of the aluminum 5 (310) 36.9◦ interface is calculated as 465 mJ/m2 , while the energy of the aluminum 5 (210) 53.1◦ interface is calculated as 494 mJ/m2 . Both values are very close to those reported by Mishin et al. of 467 and 495 mJ/m2 , respectively [99]. In Fig. 5, small cusps appear in the energy– misorientation angle relationship at certain misorientations, which correspond to the 5 (310) 36.9◦ and 5 (210) 53.1◦ boundaries. Note that each of these boundaries is considered favored in the structural unit model for the [001] misorientation axis [58]. Other low-order boundaries show only minor variation in the interface energy, corresponding
§3.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
63
¯ interface models. Fig. 6. Bicrystal interface energy for copper and aluminum tilt [110]
to small inflection points in the energy curve. Fig. 5 also shows a slight asymmetric character. While the interface energy appears to reach a maximum value between each of the 5 boundaries (approximately around 45◦ ), the energy–misorientation angle relationship does not possess mirror symmetry across the 45◦ centerline. Each of these observations is in agreement with those presented by Wolf [78] for other FCC metals (Cu, Ni and Au). ¯ Fig. 6 shows interface energy versus misorientation angle for symmetric tilt [110] boundaries in copper and aluminum. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries (STGBs) created ¯ axis show a more pronounced cusp behavior than boundaries by rotations around the [110] formed around the [001] misorientation axis. In both copper and aluminum, prominent cusps appear in the energy–misorientation angle relationship at the 3 (111) 109.5◦ and 11 (113) 50.5◦ boundaries. The energy of the 3 (111) 109.5◦ boundary is calculated as 22 mJ/m2 in copper and 75 mJ/m2 in aluminum. Other low-order boundaries show only small reductions in the interface energy. Furthermore, Fig. 6 shows a pronounced asymmetric character. While the 3 (111) 109.5◦ and 11 (113) 50.5◦ boundaries have very low interface energies, their reciprocal boundaries, 3 (112) 70.5◦ and 11 (332) 129.5◦ , have much larger interface energies by comparison. 3.2.2. Interface structure Fig. 7 shows a detailed view of several 5, 13 and 17a interface structures in copper after the energy minimization procedure. Each of these interfaces is created by a symmetric tilt rotation around the [001] misorientation axis. The viewing direction is along the [001] crystallographic direction (Z-axis) and atom positions are projected into the X–Y plane for clarity. Atoms are shaded by their respective {001} atomic plane in order to identify the
64
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 7. Bicrystal interface structures for copper [001] interface models. The structural unit model notation is given. Figure (c) is reprinted from [113] with permission; © 1999 Trans Tech Publications.
interface structural units. The 5 (310) 36.9◦ interface in Fig. 7(a) is composed of C type structural units along the entire length of the interface. Similarly, the 5 (210) interface in Fig. 7(b) is composed entirely of B structural units. The B structural unit is a slightly modified version of the B structural unit originally proposed by Sutton and Vitek [55] that is shown via molecular dynamics calculations to have a slightly lower energy in FCC materials [65]. The configuration of the B structure has also been confirmed experimentally in copper via high-resolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) as shown in Fig. 7(c) [114]. Bicrystal boundaries with non-favored misorientations are composed of two (or more) different types of structural units. For example, the structure of the 13 (510) boundary in Fig. 7(d) is composed of one C unit and two D units per interface period, with the SUM notation |CDD|. The vertical “bars” denote one period of the interface structure. Similarly, the 13 (320) boundary in Fig. 7(e) is composed of two A units and two B units per interface period, with the SUM notation |AB .AB |. Here, the “dot” signifies that the structural unit has shifted from the {001} lattice plane to the neighboring {002} plane. Sutton and Vitek [55] define this type of interface structure as being “centered.” The 17a (530) interface in Fig. 7(f) shows a slightly different behavior. The minimum energy configuration of this boundary is not mirror symmetric about the interface plane, as in the case with the other low-order CSL boundaries in Fig. 7. Two representations are proposed to describe the interface structure: |ABB | or |As B |, the latter of which is shown in Fig. 7(f). The As structural unit includes a step in the interface plane between B structural units. The energy of the |As B | boundary in copper is calculated as 856 mJ/m2 . This particular misorientation requires several variations of a given structural unit to describe
§3.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
65
¯ interface models. The structural unit model notation Fig. 8. Bicrystal interface structures for copper [110] is given.
the interface geometry; hence, the classical SUM is only loosely applicable. Note that by using a different initial configuration during the energy minimization procedure, a mirror symmetric 17a (530) interface may be created. This interface has an |AB B | structure, which is in agreement with the theoretical prediction using the SUM. However, the energy of this interface is calculated as 906 mJ/m2 , which is higher than that of the stepped boundary. Thus, the structure of the 17a (530) interface shown in Fig. 7(f) is considered the appropriate structure. Fig. 8 shows a detailed view of several 3, 9, 11 and 17b interface structures in copper after the energy minimization procedure. Each of these interfaces is created by ¯ misorientation axis. The viewing direction is a symmetric tilt rotation around the [110] along this same axis, which is aligned with the Z-direction. The structure of each interface is identified by shading atoms by their respective {110} atomic plane through the thickness of the interface model, while the structural units outlined are based on those proposed in the literature by Rittner and Seidman [52], who used an EAM potential for nickel for their energy minimization calculations. Three of the boundaries presented in Fig. 8 are considered favored in the structural unit model representation of interfaces [55]. For example, the 3 (111) 109.5◦ coherent twin boundary in Fig. 8(a) is composed entirely of D structural units with centered interface structure. Similarly, the 11 (113) 50.5◦ interface [Fig. 8(b)] and the 9 (221) 141.1◦ interface [Fig. 8(c)] are composed entirely of C and E structural units, respectively. Several of the bicrystal interface structures created by symmetric tilt rotations around the 110 misorientation axis can be characterized by the structural unit model, even though the interface structures are not mirror symmetric about the interface
66
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
¯ interface models. Fig. 9. Bicrystal interface structures for dissociated (a) 53.1◦ and (b) 59.0◦ copper [110] Reprinted from [17] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
plane. For example, the 11 (332) 129.5◦ interface in Fig. 8(d) is composed of two E and two D structural units per interface period. However, several 110 STGBs show a dissociated interface structure. For example, the 3 (112) interface in Fig. 8(e) is composed of both C and D type structural units. The C type structural unit is representative of the 11 (113) 50.5◦ interface. The D type structural unit is associated with the 3 (111) 109.5◦ twin boundary. The D structural unit in this interface lies at the termination of an intrinsic stacking fault that extends from the bicrystal interface. The delocalized structure occurs as a result of the asymmetric dissociation of secondary interface dislocations [60]. For other misorientations, the delocalization of the interface structure can have a more advanced form, such as that for the 17b (223) 86.6◦ interface in Fig. 8(f). Here, energy minimization predicts intrinsic stacking fault facets of various lengths and widths along the interface plane. In addition, at least three structural units are identified using the centrosymmetry parameter [115], including the A structural unit, which should not exist for this misorientation according to the SUM. Thus, the structural unit model fails to characterize boundaries with dissociated structure because the SUM is unable to predict the length, width or spacing between delocalized structural units. However, images in Fig. 8 and results in the literature clearly show that even highly delocalized interfaces in FCC metallic materials can still be defined in terms of a repeating structure. The observation of intrinsic stacking fault facets that extend from the interface plane is particularly intriguing, because these facets could potentially play a strong role in the deformation process (since they are in essence pre-nucleated partial edge dislocations). Fig. 9 shows a detailed view of the interface structures for 53.1◦ and 59.0◦ 110 misorientations in copper after energy minimization. Note that neither of these boundaries are considered favored in SUM or have a low-order CSL description. The ISF facet is formed due to the ¯ asymmetric dissociation of secondary interface dislocations and is positioned on the (111) slip plane in the lower lattice region in Figs 9(a) and 9(b). Rittner and colleagues [52, 60] define the termination of each ISF facet as the D structural unit; the remainder of the boundary is composed of C structural units, which are associated with the 11 (113) 50.5◦ favored interface [Fig. 8(b)]. To accommodate the ISF facet, the C structural units are tilted
§3.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
67
¯ interface models. Fig. 10. Bicrystal interface structures for dissociated (a) 53.1◦ and (b) 59.0◦ aluminum [110] Reprinted from [17] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
downward relative to the positive X-axis, as shown in Fig. 9(b). The spacing between ISF facets decreases as the misorientation angle of the interface is increased between 53.1◦ and 59.0◦ . Specifically, the 53.1◦ boundary has 11 C units for each dissociated D unit [the entire boundary is not shown in Fig. 9(a)], while the 59.0◦ interface has only 3 C units for each dissociated D unit. Rittner and Seidman [52] also showed that interface structures can vary significantly between materials with appreciably different intrinsic stacking fault energies. Specifically, Rittner and Seidman showed that delocalized structural units do not occur in materials with high stacking fault energies. Each of the interface structures presented in their work showed a mirror symmetric interface configuration for the high ISF energy material. As a result, they concluded that the structural unit model representation of high-angle interfaces becomes more applicable for materials with high ISF energy. Figs 10(a) and 10(b) show that the ISF facet that extends from the 53.1◦ or 59.0◦ interfaces is significantly shorter in aluminum, a material with higher stacking fault energy. Furthermore, in aluminum the dissociation of secondary interface dislocations is mirror symmetric on opposing {111} ¯ slip plane in the lower lattice region slip planes. Specifically, the facet occurs on the (111) and on the (111) slip plane on the upper lattice region. Similar to copper, the termination of the ISF facet is identified as the D structural unit, with the remainder of the boundary composed of C structural units, as shown in Fig. 10(a). The spacing between each dissociated facet decreases as the misorientation angle of the interface is increased over the range considered. The same ratio of C:D interface structural units occurs in both copper and aluminum. In aluminum, the C structural units are not distorted by the dissociation of secondary dislocations, i.e., the entire interface is mirror symmetric about the boundary plane, as shown in Fig. 10(b). Accordingly, energy minimization calculations are performed over the entire range of 001 and 110 symmetric tilt boundaries using the Mishin et al. EAM potential for aluminum [99]. All of the aluminum 100 interface structures presented in Fig. 11 are identical to those presented in Fig. 7. The higher stacking fault energy of aluminum does not appear to affect the interface structures for the low-order CSL boundaries created around the 001 misorientation axis. The 5 (310) and 5 (210) interfaces are composed entirely of C and B’ structural units, respectively. Of particular interest is the stepped 17a (530) interface in Fig. 11(e). Analogous to that in copper, this boundary does not have a mirror symmetric interface structure. The energy of the 17a (530) boundary in aluminum shown in Fig. 11(e) is calculated as 465 mJ/m2 , while supplemental energy minimization
68
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 11. Bicrystal interface structures for aluminum [001] interface models. The structural units and SUM notation are given.
calculations calculate that a 17a (530) interface with a |AB B | structure has an interface energy of 493 mJ/m2 . Thus, the appropriate structure for this boundary is again the stepped interface. Fig. 12 shows a detailed view of several 3, 9, 11 and 17b interface structures in aluminum indicating that many of 110 STGB structures in aluminum are different than those in copper (Fig. 8). This is due to the difference in intrinsic stacking fault energies between copper and aluminum. It is unclear exactly why the ISF energy affects the interface ¯ misorientation axis than for the [001] misorientation structure more severely for the [110] axis; however, we speculate that it has to do with the orientation of the interface with respect to the primary slip systems. The favored 110 STGBs in aluminum [ 3 (111), 11 (113) and 9 (221)] are identical to those presented for copper, as shown in Figs 12(a)– 12(e). For example, the 11 (113) interface is composed of C type structural units along the entire length of the interface. The 11 (113) and 9 (221) boundaries are verified via HRTEM results in the literature [116]. However, the interface structures of many other 110 symmetric tilt misorientations are notably different than those in copper. The aluminum 3 (112) interface in Fig. 12(g) shows that short stacking fault facets are nucleated between C structural units. However, the length of each of the ISF facets is much shorter in aluminum than in copper, which is in agreement with the results shown in Fig. 10. This observation is also validated by HRTEM images from Medlin et al. [80]. For the 17b (223) symmetric tilt interface misorientations, the stacking faults that are prominent in copper do not appear in aluminum. Instead, the E structural unit is observed, separated by different numbers of A structural units depending on the misorientation angle. This result quite intriguing since in copper the E structural unit does not appear until the misorientation angle of the interface is increased beyond 109.5◦ . Again, the SUM fails to describe this situation, as the structural units change discontinuously over the misorientation range.
§3.3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
69
¯ interface models. Figures (c) and Fig. 12. Bicrystal interface structures and SUM notation for aluminum [110] (e) are reprinted from [116] with permission; © 1992 Elsevier. Figure (h) is reprinted from [80] with permission; © 1993 Materials Research Society.
3.3. Asymmetric tilt grain boundaries The recent ability to experimentally measure all five grain boundary degrees of freedom [117] has shown that asymmetric tilt grain boundaries are observed in polycrystals in higher frequency than symmetric tilt grain boundaries (except the coherent twin boundary) and twist grain boundaries [118–122]. Therefore, it is possible that asymmetric tilt grain boundaries are present in high frequencies in nanocrystalline materials as well. As discussed in Section 1.1, symmetric tilt grain boundaries are formed by rotating the opposing lattice regions about a misorientation axis that lies perpendicular to the grain boundary plane normal. Asymmetric tilt grain boundaries are formed by subsequent rotations of the grain boundary plane with the misorientation angle of the opposing lattice regions held fixed, such that the adjoining lattices are asymmetric about the interface. The grain boundary rotation angle is defined as the inclination angle of the boundary. Previous studies have shown that the orientation of the grain boundary plane (inclination angle) for 3 grain boundaries can have a strong effect on material properties such as the GB energy [82], GB diffusion [123] and intergranular corrosion resistance [124]. In this section, the structure
70
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 13. Schematic showing the effect of misorientation and inclination angle for four 110 tilt grain boundaries: (a) 1 (001) θ = 0◦ STGB, (b) 3 (111) θ = 109.47◦ coherent twin boundary, (c) 3 (110)1 /(114)2 = 35.26◦ ATGB, (d) 3 (112) θ = 70.53◦ incoherent twin boundary. In this study, the inclination angles for (b–d) are 0◦ , 35.26◦ , and 90◦ , respectively.
and energy of 3 ATGBs inclined about the 110 tilt axis is presented. This understanding is vital for proper interpretation of the dislocation nucleation behavior in Section 4. Fig. 13 shows a schematic depicting the change in inclination angle from the 3 (111) = 0◦ symmetric tilt grain boundary to the 3 (110)1 /(114)2 = 35.26◦ ATGB to the 3 (112) = 90◦ STGB. The subscripts for the ATGB denote the grain boundary normal directions for the upper and lower lattices [see Fig. 13(c)]. In this work, the 3 (111) = 0◦ interface is referred to as the coherent twin boundary (CTB), while the 3 (112) = 90◦ will be referenced as the symmetric incoherent twin boundary (SITB) to
§3.3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
71
maintain consistency with the previous literature [82]. However, note that the homophase 3 (112) = 90◦ STGB is considered semi-coherent in many descriptions of interface structure due to slip system compatibility within each crystalline region. The term incoherent is often used explicitly to characterize interfaces which have a mismatch in both the orientation and the lattice structure (number and character of available slip systems) across the boundary [50]. In Fig. 13, the grain boundary plane is represented by the long dotted horizontal line, the grain boundary normals are the short vertical dotted lines, and ¯ plane of the FCC unit cell. Consequently, the lattice is shown as a rectangle for the (110) Fig. 13(a) represents the perfect single crystal since the crystal orientation of regions 1 and 2 are identical. Fig. 13(b) shows the 3 (111) = 0◦ CTB which is obtained by rotating the lattice regions in (a) by +54.74◦ and −54.74◦ . Fig. 13(c) shows the 3 (110)1 /(114)2 = 35.26◦ ATGB which is obtained by rotating both crystal lattices in (b) by 35.26◦ in the counterclockwise direction. Finally, the 3 (112) = 90◦ SITB in Fig. 13(d) is obtained by rotating both lattices in (b) by 90◦ in the counterclockwise direction. Note that all counterclockwise rotations applied to both lattices between 0◦ and 90◦ [Figs 13(b) and 13(d), respectively] result in 3 ATGBs. Thus, an alternative representation of inclination angle is to view the grain boundary as fixed and the lattice regions as rotating. 3.3.1. Interface energy Fig. 14(a) shows the calculated 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundary relative energy as a function of the inclination angle from the 3 (111) 109.5◦ coherent twin boundary. The relative 3 grain boundary energies which are calculated and measured by thermal grooving experiments are also included in Fig. 14(a) [82]. The relative energies are obtained by dividing the grain boundary energy, γGB , by the (111) surface energy, γSurface (1476 mJ/m2 for the EAM potential in this study). The error between the calculated and experimental asymmetric tilt grain boundary energies is most significant for inclination angles above 70.53◦ . This region corresponds to a different phase at the boundary in Cu, which is termed the 9R phase. The rhombohedral 9R phase is formed from an intrinsic stacking fault on every third plane in an FCC structure. The presence of the 9R phase may explain the larger difference in relative boundary energies in this region. Other potential reasons [82] for the discepancy between calculated and experimental values may be due to the temperature difference (i.e., the experimental values were 1313 K). However, while the magnitude of the calculated energies deviates slightly from experimental energies, the trend of the calculated energies agrees well with the experimental data. Fig. 14(b) shows the bicrystal interface energy versus the interface inclination angle for 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries in copper and aluminum. Two relative minimum energy grain boundary structures in Cu are observed at the coherent twin boundary [ 3 (111) = 0◦ ] and at an inclination angle approximately 5◦ to 8◦ from the incoherent twin boundary. In contrast to copper, the aluminum minimum energy configurations are associated with the coherent and incoherent twin boundaries. The low stacking fault energy of copper results in the formation of the 9R phase; however, the 9R phase is not observed in aluminum, a material with a much higher stacking fault energy. The calculated 3 ATGB energies in Fig. 14(b) are compared to a theoretical description of asymmetric tilt interface energy which is based on the decomposition of 3 asymmetric tilt boundaries into facets associated with the 3 symmetric tilt grain boundaries [82].
72
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 14. (a) Relative grain boundary energy, γGB /γSurface , as a function of inclination angle for Cu. The values calculated in this work are compared with both calculated values and experimental measurements [82]. (b) Grain boundary energy as a function of inclination angle for Cu and Al.
§3.3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
73
Note that this decomposition is possible for all asymmetric tilt grain boundaries; however, it may not always be energetically favorable [56]. First, we assume that the boundary energies of the individual facets corresponding to the coherent and incoherent twin boundaries contribute additively (i.e., no interaction energy). Next, the relation between the inclination angle () and the lengths of the coherent and incoherent twin boundary facets (LCTB and LSITB , respectively), which are perpendicular to each other, is tan = LSITB /LCTB . Therefore, the 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundary energy for an arbitrary inclination angle, γ , is given by γ = γCTB cos + γSITB sin ,
(10)
where γCTB and γSITB correspond to the coherent and incoherent twin boundary energies. Fig. 14(b) shows that the aluminum curve fits the calculated asymmetric tilt grain boundary energies very well with constants that correspond to the calculated coherent and incoherent twin boundary energies: γCTB = 75.2 mJ/m2 and γSITB = 354.4 mJ/m2 (recall Fig. 6). The copper curve correlates reasonably well with the calculated GB energies with constants that correspond to the calculated coherent twin boundary energy, γCTB = 22.2 mJ/m2 , and the hypothetical, unrelaxed incoherent twin boundary energy, γSITB = 700 mJ/m2 . The hypothetical, unrelaxed energy for Cu is utilized as a fitting parameter that corresponds to the incoherent twin boundary energy without the dissociation of grain boundary dislocations, as discussed in Schmidt et al. [125]. Of course, energy minimization shows the emission of ISF facets as shown in Fig. 8(e). The curves predicted using eq. (10) fit both the calculated asymmetric tilt grain boundary energies for Al and the calculated asymmetric tilt grain boundary energies for Cu with inclination angles < 70.53◦ very well. However, the calculated energies deviate from the predicted curve in Cu for inclination angles > 70.53◦ (the 9R phase). Additional information on the energy of 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries informed by both experiments [82,83,125,126] and atomistic calculations [79,82] can be found elsewhere. Tschopp and McDowell have also calculated the asymmetric tilt grain boundary energies for other low order CSL systems with 100 ( 5 and 13) and 110 ( 9 and 11) tilt axes as a function of grain boundary inclination [127]. They found that not all asymmetric tilt grain boundaries follow a relation based on the ideal faceting into symmetric tilt grain boundaries. In particular, the agreement with a relation similar to eq. (10) depends on the inclination angle separating two STGBs of the same CSL system (45◦ for the 100 system and 90◦ for the 110 system), the anisotropy in the STGB energies, and the stacking fault energy of the material. The 100 ATGBs followed an ideal faceting relation very well, while the 9 ATGBs about the 110 tilt axis deviated the most from a relation similar to eq. (10). 3.3.2. Interface structure To characterize the structure of ATGBs, interface atoms with a distorted local environment are identified using the centrosymmetry parameter [115]. A threshold of 0.25 is used as a guideline to delineate atoms belonging to interface structural units from those belonging to the bulk lattice. Once interface atoms are identified, structural units consistent with the coherent and incoherent twin boundaries are used to describe the 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundary structures. The presence of the 9R phase in Cu necessitates that the GB structures
74
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 15. Three 3 grain boundary structures in Cu for various inclination angles < 70.53◦ . The structures ¯ tilt axis; atoms on two consecutive (220) ¯ planes are shown as black and white. The are viewed along the [110] grain boundary normal and period vectors for the lower and upper crystal are shown in the corner boxes on the left-hand side for each grain boundary. The inclination angle is shown in the upper right corner.
for Cu should be separated into two distinct groups, those with inclination angles < 70.53◦ and those with 70.53◦ . The structures for these two groups are presented for copper. 3.3.2.1. Inclination angles < 70.53◦ Figs 15(a)–15(c) show the equilibrium 0 K GB structures in Cu for three boundaries with inclination angles < 70.53◦ . The structures ¯ tilt axis and the atoms on two consecutive (220) ¯ planes are are viewed along the [110] shown as black and white. The GB normal and period vectors for the lower and upper crystal are shown in the corner boxes on the left-hand for each GB. The two arrows in the upper right corner correspond to the ideal location of the coherent and incoherent twin boundary facets based on the inclination angle (also shown). There are two facets for each 3 ATGB: one facet corresponds to the structural units (SUs) of the CTB (D) and one facet corresponds to structural units associated with the SITB (C). Apparently, the structure of
§3.3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
75
the 3 ATGB can be described using structural features that are characteristic of those that comprise the 3 symmetric tilt grain boundaries [see Figs 8(a) and 8(e) in Cu and Figs 12(a) and 12(g) in Al]. As discussed in the previous section, the D SU is closely related to a Shockley partial dislocation and is frequently found terminating an intrinsic stacking fault [e.g., in the 3 (112) SITB] [60]. Images in Fig. 15 indicate that the number of D structural units on the coherent ¯ 1 /(558)2 twin boundary facet decreases as the inclination angle increases; the 3 (774) = 13.26◦ ATGB contains 12 D SUs on every CTB facet while the 3 (110)1 /(114)2 = 35.26◦ ATGB only contains 4 D SUs on every CTB facet. The SITB facet contains both C and D structural units. All |DC| units for ATGBs with < 70.53◦ are separated by at least one D SU on the CTB facet; i.e., a |DCDC| structure could occur on the SITB facet, but this would be a metastable atomistic configuration. Also, notice that the D SU associated with the SITB dissociates in a direction parallel to the coherent twin boundary facet. In Fig. 15(a), the D SU dissociates in a direction alongside the coherent twin facet. However, for inclinations angles 54.74◦ [Figs 15(b) and 15(c)] the D SU dissociates in the opposite direction. The transition of the dissociated D structural unit from one side of the C structural unit to the other side depends on the relative proximity of the facets. For 3 ATGBs, the spacing between the coherent and incoherent twin boundary facets determines the local strain state, which then influences the directionality of dissociation of the D structural unit. In asymmetric boundaries with inclination angles immediately below this transition, the dissociated D structural unit approaches the C structural unit on the adjacent SITB facet. The dislocation content of the C structural unit may then exert a force on the partial dislocation associated with the D structural unit, which causes the dissociation to proceed in the opposite direction. It is also interesting to note that all D structural units associated with the SITB dissociate, while none of the D structural units associated with the low energy coherent twin boundary facet dissociate. 3.3.2.2. Inclination angles 70.53◦ Figs 16(a)–16(c) show the equilibrium 0 K GB structures in Cu for three asymmetric tilt boundaries with inclination angles 70.53◦ . This particular set of boundaries has attracted a significant amount of interest due to the 9R phase transformation that occurs in several low SFE materials, e.g., Cu [82], Ag [84,85], and Au [128]. In this work, we investigate the effect of inclination angle on the GB structure by comparing numerous GB structures within the 9R region. ¯ 2 = 70.53◦ ATGB The maximum in GB energy occurs at the 3 (111)1 /(115) [Fig. 16(a)], which is a transitional GB structure for the 9R phase in the 3 system in Cu. For this structure, the number of |DC| units on the SITB is equal to the number of D units on the coherent twin boundary; all ATGBs with inclination angles greater than 70.53◦ have a larger ratio of SITB structural units than coherent twin boundary features. All D structural units for ATGBs with > 70.53◦ are separated by at least one |DC| unit on the SITB facet; i.e., only a metastable 0 K configuration contains two D units on the same coherent twin boundary facet. For each of these structures, the D structural unit on the SITB facet dissociates to the same side of the adjacent C structural unit continuing the trend shown in Fig. 15(c). The intrinsic stacking fault caused by the dissociation of the D structural unit on every third plane creates the 9R phase. The ratio of the D features on the CTB facets to the |DC| units on the SITB facets decreases as the inclination angle increases.
76
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 16. Three 3 grain boundary structures in Cu for various inclination angles 70.53◦ . The same format as Fig. 15 is used for illustrating the grain boundary structures.
All ATGBs with the 9R phase are separated by two boundaries. The misorientation change across these GBs occur along the two sub-boundaries that contain the 9R phase [viewed from upper to lower crystal of Figs 16(a)–16(c)]. The upper boundary of C structural units rotates the upper lattice to coincide with the 9R phase lattice. The dissociation of the D features from the SITB facet allows the C structural units to rearrange to minimize strain at this upper boundary; this allows only a partial rotation of the lattice to occur. The lower boundary of the 9R phase is a small angle dislocation boundary composed of the dissociated partial dislocations (D structural units). This sub-boundary provides additional lattice rotation to coincide with the given misorientation between the upper and lower crystals. The width of the 9R phase is a function of the degree of dissociation of the D structural unit on the SITB facet and this width changes as a function of the inclination angle for ATGBs with > 70.53◦ . As shown in Fig. 16, the dissociation width increases with > 70.53◦ until the 3 (223)1 /(4, 4, 11)2 = 81.95◦ ATGB and then decreases to meet the width calculated in the SITB [recall Fig. 8(e)]. All of these GBs, including the SITB, contain the correct 9R phase stacking sequence caused by the intrinsic stacking faults on
§3.3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
77
Fig. 17. Comparison of calculated 3 = 81.95◦ asymmetric tilt grain boundary structure with the 9R phase in Cu with experimental HRTEM image of the 9R phase in Ag. (a) Interface structure with structural units outlined, (b) simulated image using atom positions from (a), and (c) HRTEM image of Ernst and coworkers [84]. The white lines correspond to the {111} planes in the adjoining crystals and at the interface. Figure (c) reprinted from [84] with permission; © 1992 The American Physical Society.
every third plane. However, this 9R phase may not be present in some boundaries (e.g., the SITB), because there is an energetic penalty to dissociate the D structural unit further and expand the 9R phase. In Fig. 16(a), notice the distortion of the intrinsic stacking fault associated with the dissociated D structural units, which potentially restricts the expansion of the 9R phase. However, as the lattices and structural units are rotated with increasing inclination, the width of the dissociation and the 9R phase increase. Fig. 17 compares the calculated 3 = 81.95◦ asymmetric tilt grain boundary structure containing the 9R phase in Cu with an experimental HRTEM image of the 9R phase in Ag [84]. Although different materials, both Cu and Ag have low stacking fault energies and an FCC crystal structure, which enables the 9R phase to form. Fig. 17(a) shows the structural unit description of the ATGB used to generate a simulated image in Fig. 17(b), which is compared with the experimentally observed HRTEM image in Fig. 17(c). The 2D projected view of the {111} planes, in white, shows the agreement between the simulated and experimental images. In fact, these images also have similar widths of the 9R phase, despite the finding by Medlin and coworkers [129] that the width of the 9R phase often increases with time in the HRTEM. 3.3.3. 3 ATGB structure and faceting In a method analogous to the structural unit model, the structural units and their corresponding facets can be predicted for 3 ATGBs [130]. Fig. 18 shows how the calculated 3 ATGB structures for Cu and Al can be predicted based upon the coincidence plot [131] and the atomistic GB structures of the two 3 STGBs. In this respect, the following method used for predicting the 3 ATGB structure is very similar to the decomposition lattice
78
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 18. A model describing the structural units and faceting in 3 ATGBs. (a) Coincident plot for the 3 system ¯ tilt axis. (b) Schematic of the coincident points from (a) along with several GB planes rotated around the [110] of varying inclination angles. The GB periods of the CTB and SITB correlate to specific atomic SUs. (c) The SU description of the 3 = 64.76◦ ATGB is predicted based solely on the coincident points from (a) and the SUs from the two 3 STGBs.
method [55] or strip method of quasicrystallography [132,133]; the strip method is used to determine the structural unit sequence for rational symmetric tilt boundaries. First, as shown in Fig. 18(a), the coincidence plot is created by defining a misorientation angle (θ = 70.53◦ in this case) and allowing the two crystal lattices to overlap. In this plot, atoms from the two lattices are shown as small black and large white circles; the coincident sites are a combination of both circles. The coincidence plot visually illustrates the CSL concept for symmetric and asymmetric tilt grain boundaries; notice that one in every three points is coincident, as denoted by the solid lines in Fig. 18(a). The GB plane is then realized by connecting any two coincident points, as shown in Fig. 18(b). Several GB planes are shown: the CTB, the SITB, and some intermediate ATGBs with different inclination angles. The GB periods for the CTB and SITB can be defined from either crystal lattice; in ¯ and pSITB = a0 [111], this case, the periods for the CTB and SITB are pCTB = a0 /4[112] respectively. The relationship between the inclination angle and the GB periods is defined geometrically as −1 m |pSITB | , = tan (11) n |pCTB | where m and n are integers defining the number of CTB and SITB period vectors required to link any two coincident points. An alternative expression is that the ATGB period vector decomposes into the period vectors of the two facets, i.e., pATGB = mpSITB + npCTB . Utilizing the atomistic simulations presented in Section 3.2, we can define the structure of
§4
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
79
¯ the CTB either as a series of repeating D features with interface period pCTB = a0 /4[112] ¯ The latter description contains or as |D.D| with an interface period pCTB = a0 /2[112]. additional information about the translation of SUs with respect to each other; the dot pre¯ ceding a SU denotes a relative translation in the direction of the tilt axis by a0 /4[110]. This description requires n to be an even integer. Fig. 18(c) shows how the coincident lattice site from Fig. 18(a), the GB plane from Fig. 18(b), and the STGB structural units from ¯ 2 the previous section are combined to predict the configuration of the 3 (554)1 /(118) = 64.76◦ ATGB that agrees with the calculated structure. Moreover, the ATGB structural unit and faceting description [130] accurately predicts the GB structural unit description for all 25 3 ATGBs in this study, even with the 9R phase formed for ATGBs with 70.53◦ in Cu. This result emphasizes the well-defined ordering of structural units and facets for some low order CSL ATGB systems at the atomistic scale. Tschopp and McDowell concluded that this structural unit and faceting description for ATGBs may also apply to 5 and 13 ATGBs about the 100 tilt axis [127]. They reported that these CSL systems also facet into the structural units of the corresponding 5 and 13 STGBs. However, this description does not apply to all CSL systems. For example, in the same study, the ATGB structure of the 9 and 11 ATGBs about the 110 tilt axis deviated from this faceted description. The boundary rearranged such that a large fraction of GB atoms (identified via centrosymmetry [115]) bounding the structural units were correlated with the {111} planes, presumably due to the low energy of the {111} surfaces [134]. Additional factors included the large free volume of the E structural unit for ATGBs with inclination angles near the 9 (221) and 11 (332) STGBs and the proximity of ATGBs to the {111}/{110} ATGB.
4. Dislocation nucleation from symmetric and asymmetric tilt boundaries in Cu and Al The computational materials science community has made considerable progress towards understanding the atomic scale mechanisms associated with inelastic deformation in metallic crystalline materials via the use of atomistic simulations. In particular, atomistic simulation has been used to model the nucleation of partial dislocations from interfaces in FCC metals using bicrystal [16–19,38,39] and nanocrystalline geometries [20–37]. The work of Sansoz and Molinari [38,39] represented an important advancement because they were able to directly correlate individual failure mechanisms to the presence of certain structural units along the interface plane using the quasicontinuum method. In tension, failure of the interface occurred through partial dislocation nucleation and grain boundary cleavage. In shear, Sansoz and Molinari reported that three different failure modes could exist depending on the initial boundary configuration: grain boundary sliding by atomic shuffling, nucleation of partial dislocations from the bicrystal interface and grain boundary migration. Atomic shuffling occurred during a shear deformation only for interfaces that contained the E structural unit, which is associated with the 9 (221) interface [recall Fig. 8(c)]. Sansoz and Molinari proposed that the free volume inherent to this structural feature was responsible for triggering the atomic shuffling event during shear. Results in the literature
80
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
typically do not provide such detailed information regarding the role of individual interface features in the deformation process. Recently, there has been some debate in the literature regarding the emission of full dislocations from grain boundaries in nanocrystalline materials. Initial work by Van Swygenhoven and coworkers [25,27] in nanocrystalline pure nickel and copper with a grain size of approximately 12 nm showed that the leading (first) partial dislocation could be emitted from a grain boundary. In their work, the first partial dislocation would sweep across the nanosize grain and become absorbed into the opposing interface. The trailing (second) partial dislocation was not emitted from the grain boundary; as a result, an extended intrinsic stacking fault (which was typically longer than the equilibrium spacing between partial dislocations) remained within the grain. Through detailed analysis of the grain boundary structure [25,29,31] the nucleation of the first partial dislocation in nanocrystalline metals was shown to be assisted by local atomic shuffling within the interface and stress-assisted free volume migration. Van Swygenhoven and coworkers suggested initially that the nucleation of the first partial dislocation and the associated atomic rearrangement along the interface was sufficient to lower the grain boundary energy such that the emission of the second partial dislocation was unnecessary. MD simulations by Yamakov et al. [20–23] showed that the trailing partial dislocation may be emitted from grain boundary interfaces in aluminum. Aluminum was chosen for their simulations with the hypothesis that the higher intrinsic stacking fault energy (as compared with copper and nickel), which leads to a shorter stacking fault width, would facilitate the emission of the trailing partial dislocation. Yamakov et al. used a columnar ¯ atomic planes in order to simulate larger microstructure with a thickness of only 10 (110) nanoscale grain sizes. They identified the stacking fault width as a critical length scale parameter necessary to describe the cross-over between extended partial dislocation and full dislocation deformation regimes in nanocrystalline metals. However, more recent work by Van Swygenhoven and coworkers [32,34] has argued that interpreting the cross-over between deformation regimes in terms of only the intrinsic stacking fault energy is insufficient. They emphasized that the entire generalized stacking fault curve must be taken into consideration and proposed that the ratio of the unstable and intrinsic stacking fault energies is more appropriate to describe the observed dislocation activity in nanocrystalline samples. If this ratio is close to unity, full dislocations are anticipated during the deformation process; conversely, if this ratio is high, extended partial dislocations are expected within the nanocrystalline grains. In this work, the atomic scale mechanisms associated with dislocation nucleation from symmetric and asymmetric tilt interfaces in aluminum and copper are studied using molecular dynamics simulations. Whereas most previous MD work has used columnar and 3D nanocrystalline geometries, this work examines the nucleation of full dislocation loops from well-defined high-angle interfaces using a bicrystal configuration (recall Section 2.5). Calculations are performed on several distinct sets of symmetric and asymmetric interfaces. The primary goal of this work is to map the evolution of the interface structure during the dislocation nucleation process. We do not consider absorption of partial dislocations into an interface or dislocation–dislocation interactions after multiple nucleation events.
§4.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
81
4.1. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries 4.1.1. 5 (310) 36.9◦ interface Fig. 19 shows the uniaxial tensile deformation of a 5 (310) 36.9◦ interface in aluminum at 10 K. Figs 19(a)–19(d) are colored1 according to the centrosymmetry parameter [115]; atoms with a centrosymmetry parameter close to zero are removed to facilitate viewing of the defect structures. Figs 19(e)–19(g) show atomic positions at the same time step as Figs 19(b)–19(d) with atoms colored by the magnitude of the atomic slip vector [135]. The atomic slip vector is designed to identify atoms that have been displaced relative to their reference neighbors, even if they reside in a perfect FCC environment. This includes both stacking fault (partial slip) regions and regions of full slip. In this work, the atomic slip vector is calculated using the isobaric–isothermal equilibrium positions of the atoms as the reference configuration. In Figs 19(b)–19(d), full dislocation loops are nucleated from the bicrystal interface during uniaxial tensile deformation. Initially, partial dislocations are nucleated from the interface, indicated by arrows in Fig. 19(b). In the lower lattice region, ¯ ¯ slip occurs on the (111)[101] and (111)[101] slip systems, which are the most favorable slip systems according to a Schmid factor analysis. Likewise, the most favorable slip systems are activated in the upper lattice region. The tensile stress required to nucleate the first partial dislocation at 10 K from the 5 (310) boundary is calculated as 5.74 GPa. For the given orientation, this corresponds to a critical resolved shear stress of approximately 2.81 GPa, which is comparable to the ideal shear strength of aluminum obtained from first-principles calculations of 2.84 GPa [72]. In Fig. 19(c), the leading partial dislocations have moved further away from the interface, leaving behind an intrinsic stacking fault. The trailing partial dislocation has been emitted for the defect marked with an arrow, resulting in a dislocation loop. As deformation proceeds, several dislocation loops are emitted from each interface in Fig. 19(d). In Figs 19(c) and 19(d), the width of the stacking fault ribbon of the dislocation loops appears to be greater in one direction than the other. The thicker direction corresponds to the edge component of the dislocation loop. Byun [136] showed that at equilibrium, the stacking fault widths of edge and screw dislocations will differ, even though the intrinsic stacking fault energy is the same. Byun reported that the equilibrium intrinsic stacking fault width of an edge dislocation is approximately twice that of a screw dislocation. However, the intrinsic stacking fault width can depend on applied stresses, particularly in materials with low intrinsic stacking fault energies. Byun [136] showed that as the intrinsic stacking fault energy is increased to 100 mJ/m2 , the influence of applied stresses on the partial dislocation spacing becomes minimal. In this work, the intrinsic stacking fault energy of aluminum predicted by the interatomic potential is 146 mJ/m2 ; thus, the separation distance between partial dislocations is not expected to vary far from the equilibrium spacing. Fig. 19(d) shows that the calculations in this work are in agreement with this result. In Figs 19(e)–19(g), atoms with an atomic √ slip vector magnitude less than half of the Burgers vector for a partial dislocation, λ/ 6, are removed for clarity. Dislocations at two distinct points during the nucleation process are identified in Fig. 19(f). The dislocation 1 For interpretation of the references to color in this figure the reader is referred to the web version of this chapter.
82 M.A. Tschopp et al. Fig. 19. Nucleation of full dislocation loops during uniaxial tension of a 5 (310) 36.9◦ interface at 10 K; (a)–(d) atoms are colored by the centrosymmetry parameter and (e)–(g) atoms are colored by the atomic slip vector. Reprinted from [16] with permission; © 2005 Elsevier.
Ch. 82
§4.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
83
Fig. 20. Nucleation of full dislocation loops during uniaxial tension of a 5 (310) 36.9◦ interface at 10 K; (a)–(d) atoms are colored by the centrosymmetry parameter and (e)–(g) atoms are colored by the atomic slip vector. Reprinted from [16] with permission; © 2005 Elsevier.
within the upper lattice region shows an extended formation, as the trailing partial dislocation has not yet been emitted from the interface. Atoms that are shaded green have an atomic slip vector magnitude that ranges between 0.15 and 0.18 nm, which brackets the theoretical value for partial slip of 0.165 nm for aluminum. The dislocation within the lower lattice region has emitted the trailing partial dislocation and has formed a dislocation loop. Full slip has occurred in the wake of the trailing partial dislocation as atoms that are shaded red have an atomic slip vector magnitude between 0.28 and 0.30 nm, which again brackets the theoretical value of 0.286 nm. In Figs 19(f) and 19(g), atoms that are shaded blue and yellow indicate transitions between perfect lattice, intrinsic stacking fault and full slip regions, i.e., the positions of the leading and trailing partial dislocations. The structure of the 5 (310) 36.9◦ interface at two critical points during the dislocation nucleation process is shown in Fig. 20. Here, six {001} atomic planes are cut from
84
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
the thickness of the interface model through the dislocation loop identified in Fig. 19(c) to ¯ illustrate the dislocation nucleation process. This dislocation loops lies in the (111)[101] slip system. Atoms are colored2 by their respective {001} plane and projected into the X–Y plane. Prior to dislocation nucleation, this boundary has an ABAB stacking sequence in the Z-direction. In Fig. 20(a), only the first partial dislocation has been emitted from the interface. This is clearly identified by a shift in the atomic layers at the point of dislocation nucleation. Atoms that once aligned perfectly in an ABAB stacking sequence have been displaced relative to one another. The length of the extended partial dislocation at this time step is approximately 3.16 nm (which is longer than the equilibrium partial dislocation spacing in aluminum) and is shown with arrows in Fig. 20(a). Fig. 20(b) shows a detailed view of the dislocation nucleation point. First, notice that interface expansion during the uniaxial deformation allows some atoms to migrate in the direction of the load. However, the atom that is coincident between lattice regions remains stationary. The dislocation slip process involves atoms that were originally identified as belonging to the structural units. One of the structural units (in the second layer of atoms) is irreversibly deformed as a result of the partial dislocation slip, labeled as C∗ . The C structural units surrounding this defect unit appear to be only slightly modified to accommodate the slip process. The centerline of the interface is shown in Fig. 20(b). Even though the structural units are being deformed by the slip process, the interface still remains planar after the emission of the first partial dislocation. As deformation continues in Fig. 20(c), the second partial dislocation is emitted from the interface, creating a dislocation loop. The loop itself is not visible in this view; however, it is clear that the second partial has been emitted because the atomic layers associated with full slip have aligned on top of each other. The positions of the leading and trailing partial dislocations are marked with arrows in Fig. 20(c) with a separation of approximately 1.08 nm. Fig. 20(d) shows a detailed view of the interface after the emission of the trailing partial dislocation. Two deformed structural units are identified along the interface plane, labeled as C∗∗ . The C∗∗ deformed unit appears only after the emission of the second partial dislocation and involves a small step or ledge within the interface plane. The shape of the C∗∗ unit is similar to that of the C∗ structural unit; however, additional slip from the trailing partial dislocation has further amplified the asymmetric expansion. The ledge has a peak magnitude in the Y -direction of approximately 0.18 nm and is stable, because it involves atoms that are associated with the full slip event. The remainder of the interface accommodates the development of this ledge by smoothly shifting in opposite directions on either side of the dislocation nucleation point, as shown in Fig. 20(d). For the C∗∗ structural unit shown on the left in Fig. 20(d), the ledge occurs between the first and third atomic layers; in contrast, the ledge occurs between the third and fifth atomic layers for the C∗∗ structural unit shown on the right. This indicates that the ledge occurs at the intersection of the slip plane and the interface. The angle depends on to the orientation of the slip plane relative to the misorientation axis. Calculations in Spearot et al. [16] confirm that the ledge is formed during uniaxial tensile deformation of other boundaries in Al which contain the C structural unit, such as 109 (10 3 0) 33.4◦ and 73 (830) 41.1◦ . Thus, the formation of the ledge is not restricted to the low-order CSL boundary. Fig. 21 shows a schematic of the dislocation nucleation process and the resulting interface ledge after 2 See footnote 1.
§4.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
85
Fig. 21. Schematic of the dislocation nucleation process: (a) after emission of the first partial dislocation, (b) after emission of the trailing partial dislocation creating a dislocation loop and (c) resulting interface structure showing formation of a ledge. Reprinted from [16] with permission; © 2005 Elsevier.
the emission of the full dislocation. In Section 6, the formation and geometry of the ledge created during the dislocation nucleation process will be discussed in terms of disclinations and disconnections [69]. 4.1.2. Grain boundaries with dissociated structure Molecular dynamics simulations are used to study the process of dislocation nucleation from bicrystal interfaces with dissociated structure. Fig. 22 shows a 361 (6 6 17) 53.1◦ interface in copper at 10 and 300 K subjected to a uniaxial tensile deformation normal to the interface plane. A detailed characterization of the interface structure during the tensile deformation process is presented in Fig. 23. The specific points of interest are circled and labeled A–D in Fig. 22. When subjected to a tensile deformation, Figs 22(b) and 22(f) show that the bicrystal interface structure evolves prior to the dislocation nucleation event. Specifically, tensile deformation applied normal to the interface plane causes the ISF facet to become shorter in length. In Fig. 23(a), at an interface model strain of 5.0%, the length of the intrinsic stacking fault facet is approximately 40% of its length after energy minimization [recall Fig. 9(a)]. Additional tensile strain causes partial edge dislocations to be nucleated from the bicrystal interfaces, as shown in Figs 22(c) and 23(b). Initially, a partial edge dislocation is nucleated from the interface at the intersection of the ISF facet and the bicrystal boundary. The core of the partial dislocation is not shown in Fig. 23(b), only the extrinsic stacking fault (ESF) that extends from the partial dislocation core back to the interface. Because dislocation nucleation involves the entire slip plane through the thickness of the interface model, the ABAB stacking sequence in the Z-direction is preserved. ¯ plane, which is a secondary In the upper lattice region, slip occurs initially on the (111) slip plane according to the Schmid factor. Likewise, the secondary (111) slip plane is activated in the lower lattice region. This indicates that the ISF facet promotes slip activity on the secondary slip systems. This result is due to the configuration of the ISF facet which potentially acts as a stress riser.
86
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 22. Uniaxial tensile deformation of the 53.1◦ copper interface model at (a)–(d) 10 K and (e)–(h) 300 K. Dislocations are nucleated from the intersection of the ISF facet and the bicrystal boundary. Reprinted from [17] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
Continued tensile strain leads to the nucleation of partial edge dislocations from the ISF facet into the opposing lattice region, as shown in Figs 22(d) and 22(h). The additional dislocation nucleation is accompanied by a second decrease in the length of the ISF facet, which is shown in Fig. 23(c). As the leading partial edge dislocations glide away from the interface, Fig. 22(h) shows that the ESF will transform into an ISF. This indicates that one trailing partial dislocation is nucleated from each side of the interface during the tensile deformation process. At this point, the ISF facet has become completely absorbed by the interface to facilitate this final transition, as shown in Fig. 23(d). Although not shown in Fig. 22, this transition will occur during simulations at both 10 and 300 K. In copper, the leading partial edge dislocations remain connected to the interface by an intrinsic stacking fault. Throughout the entire deformation process, the interface structural units away from the dislocation nucleation site are largely unaffected. In Spearot et al. [17] additional calculations are presented which explore the nucleation of dislocations from other boundaries with dissociated structure. It was found that as the misorientation angle of the interface is increased from 53.1◦ to 59.0◦ , leading to a decrease in the spacing between ISF facets (recall Fig. 9), the failure mode changes from
§4.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
87
Fig. 23. Detailed examination of the 53.1◦ copper interface structure during the uniaxial tensile deformation process. Images (a)–(d) correspond to circled regions in Fig. 22. Reprinted from [17] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
one that is dominated by dislocation nucleation on secondary slip systems at the ISF facet to that which is a mixture of dislocation nucleation on both primary and secondary slip systems [17]. Specifically, for the 54.4◦ boundary the spacing between ISF facets is just barely sufficient to allow the nucleated partial dislocation to pass into the lattice region. However, this is not the case with the 59.0◦ boundary. Here, the spacing between ISF facets critically inhibits the nucleation of partial edge dislocations on the secondary slip planes; the ISF facet blocks the motion of the nucleated partial edge dislocation. Consequently, additional interface structural rearrangement is required, facilitating dislocation activity on other slip systems. Based on the molecular dynamics result presented above, Fig. 24 shows a schematic of the evolution of an asymmetrically dissociated interface under the application of a uniaxial tensile deformation. Specifically, images in Fig. 24 illustrate the positions of partial edge dislocations at critical stages during the tensile deformation process. Here, we assume that the ISF facets are sufficiently far apart that interaction effects do not play a strong role. ¯ slip plane. Fig. 24(a) shows the initial interface structure, with an ISF facet on the (111) Tensile stress applied normal to the interface planes causes the ISF to become shorter in length and promotes dislocation nucleation on the (111) slip plane, as shown in Fig. 24(b).
88
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 24. Schematic of the dislocation nucleation process during tensile deformation from an interface with an asymmetric dissociated structure. See text for additional details on the emission events at each stage of deformation. Reprinted from [17] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
Initially, the emitted dislocation is connected back to the interface via an extrinsic stacking fault. Additional tensile strain leads to dislocation nucleation on the secondary slip plane in the opposing crystal region, as shown in Fig. 24(c). Initially, dislocations in both lattices are connected back to the interface via an extrinsic stacking fault. Finally, the ISF facet is completely absorbed by the interface and the extrinsic stacking faults are transformed into intrinsic stacking faults by the emission of trailing partial dislocations from the interface. The interface transformations described above are remarkably similar to that discussed by Baskes et al. [137] concerning the stress dependence of a lock formation consisting of a stair rod dislocation in nickel. The stair rod dislocation is the sessile product of two partial edge dislocations on intersecting {111} slip planes [15]. The parallels between deformation in our simulations and those of Baskes et al. are logical due to the similarities between the stair rod dislocation and the dissociated structural unit. Specifically, Baskes et al. [137] considered a stair rod symmetrically located between two Shockley partial edge dislocations. In our work, the termination of the ISF facet accounts for one of the partial dislocations, while the other partial dislocation is initially positioned at the interface. Baskes et al. showed that the stair rod goes through several transitions, associated with the sequential nucleation of partial dislocations from the lock. First, the separation distance between each Shockley partial dislocation and the stair rod is reduced. Next, one of the Shockley partial dislocations passes through the lock to a position on the other side of the stair rod, with an extrinsic stacking fault. For increased stress, one of the partial dislocations escapes the stair rod lock, transforming the extrinsic stacking fault into an intrinsic stacking fault. Finally, the other Shockley partial dislocation passes through the stair rod resulting in a symmetric formation of extrinsic and intrinsic stacking faults in either side of the lock. While, the sequence of nucleation events is slightly different, the structural similarities between the dislocation configurations described in this work and those in Baskes et al. [137] are evident.
§4.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
89
(a)
(b) Fig. 25. (a) Stress–displacement diagram for selected 100 symmetric tilt grain boundaries, and maximum tensile strength versus misorientation angle for (b) 100 and (c) 110 interface misorientation. Single crystal data are presented for comparison. Reprinted from [18] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
4.1.3. Tensile stress required for dislocation nucleation Fig. 25(a) shows the tensile stress–displacement response for bicrystal interface models with 100 tilt axis and misorientations between 19.7◦ (23 4 0) and 41.1◦ (830). This range encompasses both 5 (310) and 13 (510) boundaries, which are two low boundaries for the 100 misorientation axis. Clearly, as the misorientation angle increases, the maximum tensile stress achieved during deformation decreases. Contrary to the experimental
90
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
(c) Fig. 25. (Continued)
evidence discussed in the introduction (cf. [13,14]), the low-order boundaries within this misorientation range do not show any special behavior with regard to maximum tensile interface strength. Visual inspection of the MD simulation results indicates that partial dislocations are nucleated from the bicrystal interface at the displacement associated with maximum tensile stress nearly simultaneously on two different slip systems for each misorientation. The activated slip systems in each case are in agreement with those predicted using a Schmid factor analysis. Trailing partial dislocations are not nucleated from the interface during deformation, in agreement with the work of Van Swygenhoven et al. [32]. Fig. 25(b) shows the maximum tensile stress achieved during the deformation process as a function of interface misorientation angle. To isolate the influence of lattice orientation on the magnitude of the peak tensile stress, single crystal (SC) calculations are also presented in Fig. 25(b) for comparison. These calculations will be discussed in greater detail in Section 5. The orientation of each SC model is identical to that of the lower lattice region of the corresponding interface model; because the interfaces are of symmetric tilt character, the same geometric slip factors apply to the upper lattice region as well. The reference single crystal orientations have the same tilt axis relative to the direction of applied stress, with the same reference values for zero misorientation as the interface models to facilitate a direct comparison. For single crystal models, MD simulations indicate that dislocations are nucleated on the primary slip systems at the uniaxial tensile deformation associated with maximum tensile stress. Fig. 25(b) indicates that the orientation of the lattice with respect to the applied uniaxial tension is important for modeling the tensile strength of tilt interfaces with a 100 misorientation axis. Note that the tensile stress required for dislocation nucleation for single crystal models is greater than that for bicrystal interface models, demonstrating the role of the interface in promoting dislocation nucleation. Fig. 25(c) shows the maximum tensile stress achieved during uniaxial tension for interface models with a 110 misorientation axis as a function of interface misorientation angle.
§4.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
91
Again, several single crystal calculations are reported to determine the role of the lattice orientation on the magnitude of the peak tensile stress. Fig. 25(c) shows that the coherent 3 boundary has the highest tensile strength as compared with the other misorientations considered. This observation may be contrasted with the case of shear in which the coherent 3 boundary showed a high propensity to migrate at low applied shear stresses [39]. An abrupt decrease is observed in the tensile strength as the misorientation angle of the interface is increased beyond 109.5◦ . Interfaces with misorientations greater than 109.5◦ are different from the other 110 boundaries in two respects: (i) boundaries in this range deform via dislocation nucleation on coplanar slip systems [138] and (ii) visual inspection indicates that boundaries in this range of 110 misorientations contain the E structural unit. Recall that Sansoz and Molinari concluded that boundaries that contained the E structural unit are prone to atomic shuffling when subjected to a shear deformation [39]. In this work, we find that symmetric tilt boundaries with a 110 misorientation axis that contain the E structural unit emit partial dislocations at low applied tensile stresses applied normal to the interface. Furthermore, the drop in tensile strength clearly is related directly to the interface structure, as the single crystal calculations do not indicate a discontinuous reduction in the stress required for dislocation emission as the misorientation angle of the interface is increased beyond 109.5◦ .
4.2. Asymmetric tilt grain boundaries A full understanding of the dislocation nucleation behavior for 3 ATGBs in Cu requires a discussion of the salient mechanisms. Three distinct mechanisms of dislocation nucleation occur for 3 ATGBs, which can be categorized by inclination angle: low inclination angles ( 35.26◦ ), intermediate inclination angles (35.26◦ 70.53◦ ), and high inclination angles ( 70.53◦ ). The dislocation nucleation mechanisms for Cu 3 ATGBs provide similar observations for temperatures of 10 and 300 K. In this work, the authors present results for 10 simulations to minimize the thermal component on the observation of dislocation nucleation and emission from these boundaries. All boundaries in Section 4.2 have identical misorientations and only the GB plane (inclination angle) is altered. The following results show that GB plane can heavily influence dislocation nucleation mechanisms. 4.2.1. Stress required for dislocation nucleation The stress–strain curves for Cu and Al under an applied uniaxial tensile strain were calculated at temperatures of 10 and 300 K for 11 3 boundaries. Fig. 26(a) shows stress–strain curves for Cu 3 ATGBs at 300 K with inclination angles < 45◦ . Since nucleation of bc , the simulations the first partial at the GB coincides with the maximum tensile stress, σmax are stopped shortly after reaching the peak stress. Several other quantitative parameters can be calculated from the stress–strain response: the elastic stiffness K bc , the maximum tenbc , the strain corresponding to that stress ε bc , and the work per unit volume sile stress σmax max required for dislocation emission W bc , where the superscript bc refers the bicrystal configuration. However, the focus of the following discussion is on the change in the dislocation nucleation stress as a function of inclination angle.
92
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
(a)
(b) Fig. 26. (a) Example of stress–strain curves for 3 grain boundaries with inclination angles below 45◦ at 300 K. (b) The change in the stress required for dislocation nucleation as a function of inclination angle for Cu and Al at 10 and 300 K. Reprinted from [19] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
Fig. 26(b) shows the peak stress values for all simulations. Recall that the peak stress bc is directly related to dislocation nucleation from the GB. First, the stress required for σmax dislocation nucleation changes as a function of inclination angle. The magnitude of the change in stress values is greater as a function of inclination angle in Cu than in Al. The bc for both Al and Cu is at the = 0◦ coherent twin boundary. The lowest highest stress σmax stress for Cu is at the = 43.31◦ GB while the lowest stress in Al is at the = 29.50◦
§4.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
93
GB; both are boundaries of intermediate inclination angles. The = 90◦ incoherent twin boundary is between these values for Cu, and is near the low value in Al. This graph also bc with increasing temperature, especially near the symmetric twin shows a decrease in σmax boundaries ( = 0◦ and = 90◦ ). The thermal component is expected to contribute to the dislocation nucleation process via the activation energy and activation volume associated with dislocation nucleation [139]. Of course, the 300 K case is overdriven in terms of kinetics, so in reality the drop of stress may be somewhat more pronounced at low strain rates (on the order of experimental strain rates). For example, at strain rate of 1 s−1 the number of atomic vibrations relative to the strain increment is 109 higher than that for a strain rate of 109 s−1 . However, MD simulations require time step increments on the order of femtoseconds, which commonly results in strain rates on the order of 109 s−1 for the calculation of dislocation nucleation phenomena. Due to the probabilistic nature of dislocation nucleation [140], when the number of dislocation nucleation attempts associated with thermal vibrations is increased, the probability of nucleating dislocations at a lower stress is increased for lower strain rates. 4.2.2. Low inclination angles ( 35.26◦ ) At low inclination angles, the boundary is composed of large coherent twin boundary facets separated by smaller incoherent twin boundary facets, as shown in Fig. 15(a). Fig. 27 shows the = 10.02◦ Cu ATGB subjected to uniaxial tensile deformation normal to the interface plane at 10 K. In these images, only atoms with a centrosymmetry value greater than 0.25 are shown (i.e., distorted GB atoms, dislocations, and stacking faults). The x-direction is along the GB normal and the direction of the applied stress, the y-direction is along the GB period tangent to the interface, and the z-direction is along the tilt axis. Recall that the crystals adjoining the ATGBs have different lattice orientations in global coordinates. For the images in Fig. 27, the two boundaries contain crystal 1 [upper crystal in Fig. 4(a)]; crystal 2 is both above and below these boundaries (periodic with respect to simulation cell bounds in the x-direction). Finally, the images below the three-dimensional views correspond to projections of the lower interface onto the xy plane, with z normal to the view. A detailed characterization of the GB structure of the upper boundary in Figs 27(a)– 27(c) is shown in Figs 28(a)–28(c). Fig. 27(a) shows an oblique view of the interface after isobaric–isothermal equilibration, but prior to deformation. Notice the ledges formed by the intersection of coherent twin facets with incoherent twin facets, as in Fig. 28(a). Figs 27(b) and 28(b) show that the interface structure evolves prior to dislocation nucleation and emission from the boundary. Specifically, the D structural unit on the incoherent twin facet (the GB Shockley partial ¯ plane, leaving an intrinsic stackdislocation) dissociates into crystal lattice 1 on the (111) ing fault. The arrows in Fig. 28(b) show the shift (slip) of atoms on the plane relative to their nearest neighbors, as visualized with the slip vector [135]. A Schmid factor analysis [138] of the slip systems in crystal 1 shows that this is a secondary slip plane for this max = SFmax crystal (SFmax ¯ = 0.148) below all other possible slip planes (SF(111) ¯ ¯ = 0.223, (111) (111) max max SF(111) = 0.371), where SF(hkl) is the maximum Schmid factor for all three slip directions on slip plane (hkl). Additional tensile strain causes partial edge dislocations to nucleate where the dissociated Shockley partial dislocation intersects the coherent and incoherent
94 M.A. Tschopp et al. Fig. 27. Uniaxial tensile deformation of the 3 = 10.02◦ asymmetric tilt grain boundary in Cu at 10 K. The different views represent (a) the faceted structure prior to deformation, (b) the dissociation of partial dislocations prior to dislocation nucleation, and (c) the nucleation of partial dislocation loops that are emitted into crystal 1. Only atoms in a non-centrosymmetric environment are shown. The top image is a three-dimensional oblique view and the bottom image is an orthonormal view from the ¯ direction. Reprinted from [19] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier. [110] Ch. 82
§4.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
95
Fig. 28. Detailed view of the evolution of structure for the 3 = 10.02◦ asymmetric tilt grain boundary in Cu at 10 K. The images correspond to the upper boundary in Figs 27(a)–27(c). The structures are viewed along ¯ direction and the atoms on two consecutive (220) ¯ planes are shown as black and white. The arrows the [110] correspond to the relative shift in atoms compared to their nearest neighbors as measured by the slip vector [135]. Notice that the dislocation nucleates on a different {111} plane than the dissociated glissile partial dislocation from the boundary. Reprinted from [19] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
twin facets, as shown in Figs 27(c) and 28(c). The partial dislocations nucleate as a dislocation loop on the (111) plane with both edge and screw character, unlike the planar dissociation of the GB partial edge dislocations in Fig. 27(b). Since the primary slip plane for dislocation nucleation is different from the dissociative plane, the change in slip planes bc required for dislocamay serve as a nucleation barrier resulting in high peak stresses σmax tion nucleation in low inclination angle 3 ATGBs [cf. Fig. 26(b)]. Further tensile strain leads to the dislocation loops merging to form a continuous dislocation line as well as propagating further into the lattice. Although not shown, this is also accompanied by a decrease in the length of the dissociated GB Shockley partial and ISF. Interestingly, upon closer examination of the dislocation nucleation mechanism for this boundary, we find that the dissociated glissile partial dislocation does not cross slip onto the high resolved shear stress slip plane. In fact, a partial dislocation loop homogeneously nucleates on the (111) slip plane near the dissociated D structural unit. This is most likely associated with a local stress concentration near the intersection of the two facets, which may act similarly to a boundary ledge in this respect. Due to the close proximity, the partial dislocation is quickly absorbed into the nearby boundary, giving the appearance of heterogeneous dislocation nucleation. However, this mechanism requires a very high stress, which may preclude most grain boundaries. The implications of this mechanism on grain boundary sources in nanocrystalline copper are discussed further in Section 6.1. 4.2.3. Intermediate inclination angles (35.26◦ < < 70.53◦ ) Fig. 29 shows dislocation nucleation and emission from the = 54.74◦ ATGB in Cu at 10 K. The images for Fig. 29 are presented in an identical manner to those in Fig. 27. The magnified view of the GB structure is also shown in Figs 30(a)–30(c). At intermediate inclination angles, the ratio of the length of the coherent twin facet to the incoherent twin facets is around unity [cf. Fig. 15(c)]. Additionally, the short length of the facets leads to
96 M.A. Tschopp et al. Fig. 29. Uniaxial tensile deformation of the 3 = 54.74◦ asymmetric tilt grain boundary in Cu at 10 K. The images are rendered the same as those in Fig. 27. Reprinted from [19] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
Ch. 82
§4.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
97
Fig. 30. Detailed view of the evolution of structure for the 3 = 54.74◦ asymmetric tilt grain boundary in Cu at 10 K. These images correspond to the upper boundary in Figs 29(a)–29(c) and are viewed as in Fig. 28. Note that the dislocation nucleates on the same {111} plane as the dissociated glissile partial dislocation from the boundary. Reprinted from [19] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
a higher number of facet intersections, or ledges, in the boundary. This is evident from the oblique view of the interface after isobaric–isothermal equilibration in Fig. 29(a). In Figs 29(b) and 30(b), prior to dislocation nucleation, the application of a tensile strain perpendicular to the boundary causes the glissile partial dislocations (i.e., D structural ¯ units) to further dissociate from the incoherent twin facet into crystal lattice 1 on the (111) plane. This is similar to the pre-nucleation behavior observed at low inclination angles for 3 ATGBs. However, for intermediate inclination angles, this is the primary slip plane for crystal 1 (SFmax ¯ = 0.408). Prior to the peak stress, the dissociation is planar, i.e., the (111) dislocations each dissociate an equal distance (approximately) from the boundary. As the stress reaches the peak tensile stress, Figs 29(c) and 30(c), the first partial dislocations are ¯ slip plane, the same slip plane onto which partial dislocations disnucleated on the (111) sociated. Notice that not all dissociated partial dislocations are emitted from the boundary; some are retained. The spacing between dissociated structural units may serve as a critical length scale that influences the number of partial dislocations nucleated on the primary slip system. As with the low inclination angle 3 ATGBs, the partial dislocations emitted into the lattice are dislocation loops with edge and screw dislocation character and the trailing partial is not observed in Cu. In addition, since the primary slip plane for dislocation nucleation is the same as the dissociative plane, the barrier for nucleation is lower which results bc required for dislocation nucleation in 3 ATGBs within this in a low peak stresses σmax inclination range [cf. Fig. 26(b)]. 4.2.4. High inclination angles ( 70.53◦ ) Fig. 31 shows dislocation nucleation for the = 79.98◦ ATGB in Cu at 10 K. Recall that at inclination angles 70.53◦ , the structure exhibits the 9R phase in Cu, as shown in Fig. 16. The 9R phase structure in Fig. 16 is identical to the 9R structure in Fig. 31(a), after isobaric–isothermal equilibration, which is rendered using the centrosymmetry parameter as in Figs 27 and 29. Fig. 31(b) shows that the 9R phase structure evolves prior to dislocation nucleation in the = 79.98◦ ATGB. Again, tensile strain perpendicular to the boundary causes the dissociation width for the glissile partial dislocations (D structural
98 M.A. Tschopp et al. Fig. 31. Uniaxial tensile deformation of the 3 = 79.98◦ asymmetric tilt grain boundary in Cu at 10 K. The images are rendered the same as those in Figs 27 and 29. Reprinted from [19] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
Ch. 82
§4.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
99
Fig. 32. Detailed images of the structure of the 3 = 79.98◦ asymmetric tilt grain boundary in Cu at 10 K. These images show the interface structure just prior to dislocation nucleation. The images are viewed similarly to ¯ planes. The magnified view (on right) Figs 15 and 16 where black and white atoms represent consecutive (220) shows the extended dissociation of the glissile partial dislocation (i.e., D structural unit), which expands the 9R phase. Reprinted from [19] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
¯ plane. This is similar to the preunits) to increase towards crystal lattice 1 on the (111) nucleation behavior observed at low and intermediate inclination angles for 3 ATGBs, but the dissociation width perpendicular to the boundary is larger due to the presence of the low energy 9R phase. Fig. 32 shows images of the 9R phase on the lower boundary just prior to dislocation nucleation in the lattice. This image is rendered similarly to Figs 15 and 16, where black ¯ planes and distorted atoms are identified using and white atoms represent successive (220) the centrosymmetry parameter. In the enlarged view of the boundary (right), the expansion of the 9R phase results from partial dislocations further dissociating from the incoherent twin facet. The 9R phase is clearly visible in this view, with an intrinsic stacking fault on ¯ plane, resulting in an ABCBCACAB stacking sequence. Unlike intermeevery third (111) diate inclination angles, the dissociation plane is not the primary slip plane for crystal 1. Schmid factor analyses shows that this is a secondary slip plane (SFmax ¯ = 0.148); the (111) max primary slip planes (SFmax = SF = 0.346) have normal vectors that are not orthogo¯ ¯ (111) (111) ¯ tilt axis, unlike boundaries with lower inclination angles (Figs 27–30). For nal to the [110] high inclination angles, partial dislocations nucleate both at the low angle boundaries and ¯ ¯ slip planes; the partials propagate as dislocation within the lattice on the (111) and (111) loops. Interestingly, the dislocations nucleate nearly simultaneously on both primary slip planes at the nucleation sites. Furthermore, the dislocation loop contains a longer intrinsic stacking fault along the direction contained by both slip planes, although this direction has a slightly lower Schmid factor (SFmax = SFmax = 0.289). ¯ ¯ (111)[110] (111)[110] 4.2.5. Preferential dislocation nucleation in Cu Partial dislocations preferentially nucleate into only one crystal lattice; this is characteristic of all 3 ATGBs. In fact, all 3 ATGBs nucleate partial dislocations into crystal 1 [see
100
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 4(a)]. This phenomenon is as expected for ATGBs with inclination angles < 25.24◦ , for which SFmax (hkl) is highest in crystal 1. However, the preferential dislocation nucleation in crystal 1 is observed for all ATGBs in this study, despite a higher SFmax (hkl) in crystal 2 for all inclination angles > 25.24◦ . This preferred nucleation is in contrast to the dislocation nucleation simulations in symmetric tilt GBs [16,17] with 100 and 110 tilt axes. With lattice orientations that are symmetric with respect to the GB plane, Spearot and coworkers showed that partial dislocations are nucleated and emitted into both lattices once the peak tensile stress is reached. For 3 ATGBs, dislocation emission into crystal 2 only occurs at high strains after excessive dislocation emission severely alters the initial GB structure. The observation of preferential dislocation nucleation depends on the arrangement of glissile partial dislocations within the boundary and their character. For all 3 ATGBs in this study, the glissile partial dislocation (dissociated D structural unit) dissociates into crystal 1 for the minimized energy grain boundary structure. These dissociated partial dislocations are integral to dislocation nucleation in 3 ATGBs. The uniaxial tensile strain merely resolves into stress components acting to overcome the stacking fault energy penalty that restricts glide of these partial dislocations into the lattice. So it appears that the preferential dislocation nucleation event can be traced back to the minimum energy structure. Perhaps the most important question is why does this partial dislocation dissociate into crystal 1 for the minimum energy grain boundary structure? Interestingly, the elastic modulus is higher in crystal 1 for all inclination angles. The local relaxation of the dislocation content of the ATGBs may result in any glissile partial dislocation content dissociating into the adjoining crystal with the higher elastic modulus. The boundary structure, particularly the dissociated glissile partial dislocation, serves as the impetus for dislocation nucleation in 3 ATGBs.
5. Models for dislocation nucleation: single crystals and GBs A simple model is proposed to correlate tensile interface strength, which is associated with the emission of partial dislocations, and certain first-order characteristics of the interface structure. The aim of the proposed model is to illustrate the impact of interfacial porosity and non-glide direction stresses on tensile interface strength. This model is developed through the following two step process. First, MD simulation results for uniaxial tensile deformation of single crystal models are used to isolate the influence of lattice orientation on the maximum tensile stress associated with homogeneous dislocation nucleation (Section 5.1). Once the effect of lattice orientation has been isolated, the second step in the development of the interface strength model is to incorporate a dependence on inherent GB properties, such as the free volume content of the interface, to predict the maximum tensile stress associated with heterogeneous dislocation nucleation (Section 5.2). 5.1. Homogeneous dislocation nucleation in single crystal Cu 5.1.1. Influence of resolved stresses Fig. 33 illustrates on a stereographic triangle the single crystal orientations which are deformed in uniaxial tension to capture the role of lattice orientation on dislocation nucleation
§5.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
101
Fig. 33. Stereographic triangle showing the uniaxial loading axis orientations investigated in the single crystal deformation simulations.
strength [18]. Several orientations along the [100]–[110], [100]–[111], and [111]–[110] boundaries (open circles) are selected, which relate directly to the orientations associated with the 100 and 110 STGBs (recall Fig. 25). Specifically, the [100]–[110] boundary of the stereographic triangle corresponds to the lattice orientations of the 100 STGBs, while the [100]–[111] and [111]–[110] boundaries correspond to the 110 STGBs. The filled-in circles in Fig. 33 refer to subsequent MD studies that examine the effect of single crystal orientation on the stress required for dislocation nucleation over a wider range of orientations [73,141], which are discussed in Section 5.1.2. Single crystal calculations by Spearot et al. [18] have clearly shown that the partial dislocation nucleation process in single crystal (SC) models shows non-Schmid character, as the critical resolved shear stress varies as a function of orientation. These observations are in agreement with ab initio calculations by Ogata et al. [72] who performed a systematic study of the effect of non-Schmid components on dislocation nucleation and reported that compressive stresses acting normal to the slip plane can affect the shear stress required for dislocation emission. To characterize the evolution of the resolved shear stress required for dislocation nucleation, non-glide direction stress components acting on the slip plane must be taken into consideration [72,142–144]. Accordingly, the relationship τideal sc = σmax (12) μs SF + μn NF + μp PF was initially proposed [18] for single crystals subjected to uniaxial tensile stress, where SF = y y x y ,
NF = 2y y ,
PF = y y z y .
(13)
Here, i ,j are the direction cosines relating a coordinate axis fixed to the slip plane (X is the slip direction, Y is normal to the slip plane and Z lies within the slip plane, perpendicular to the slip direction [138]) to a fixed specimen coordinate system (X, Y loading direction, and Z). These direction cosines pertain to the initial (undeformed) configuration of the crystal. Thus, SF projects the uniaxial applied stress into the resolved shear stress
102
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 34. Schematic showing how the uniaxial tensile stress is resolved into stress components acting upon the active slip system.
acting on the slip plane in the slip direction (the conventional Schmid factor), NF projects the uniaxial stress into the stress normal to the slip plane, and PF projects the uniaxial stress into a shear stress acting on the slip plane perpendicular to the slip direction (co-slip direction). The active slip system is defined by the maximum SF among all possible slip systems. Fig. 34 shows a schematic of how the uniaxial tensile stress is resolved onto the active slip system given the above definitions. Fig. 35 shows the change in the Schmid factor SF and the normal factor NF as a function of loading orientation within a stereographic triangle. The maximum SF = 0.5 occurs within the interior of the stereographic triangle, while the maximum NF = 0.666 occurs for the [110] loading direction. The minimum Schmid factor, SF = 0.272, and normal factor, NF = 0.111, both occur for the [111] orientation. In eq. (12), the ideal shear strength, τideal , is defined as the resolved shear stress required for partial dislocation nucleation when all other stress components acting on the slip plane are zero. Ab initio calculations by Ogata et al. [72] find that τideal = 2.16 GPa for copper. The parameters μs , μn and μp are positive scalars used to characterize the degree of nonSchmid behavior. Therefore, an increase in any of the coefficients μs , μn or μp reduces the predicted peak stress required for dislocation nucleation by increasing the weight of the corresponding stress component. If μs = 1 and μn = μp = 0, the proposed model reduces to Schmid’s law for single crystal slip, i.e., σmax = τideal /SF. Least squares regression is used to determine appropriate values for μs , μn and μp for loading axis orientations along the [100]–[110] boundary of the misorientation triangle (100 STGBs) as well as the [100]–[111] and [111]–[110] boundaries (110 STGBs). Parameters are fit separately for models with 100 and 110 misorientation axes by minimizing the sum of the squares of the residual error between the calculated peak tensile stress data and the values predicted via eq. (12). This analysis indicates that dislocation
§5.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
103
Fig. 35. Orientation dependence of the (a) Schmid factor SF and (b) normal factor NF for FCC crystals.
nucleation can be correlated to specific regions within the stereographic triangle where SF is greater than NF, or vice versa. Fig. 36 shows that the proposed relationship [eq. (12)] correlates well with the MD simulations for uniaxial tension of single crystals at various orientations along the [100]–[110], [100]–[111], and [111]–[110] boundaries. The normal factor (NF) is essential to describe dislocation nucleation in 100 single crystal models (μs = 0, μp = 0.69), while the maximum tensile stress required for dislocation nucleation in 110 single crystal models correlates more strongly with the SF parameter (μs = 0.60, μp = 0.0). This analysis for FCC Cu has shown that the co-slip factor has essentially no effect (μp = 0) on the stress required for dislocation nucleation [18]. The co-slip factor resolves the shear stress in the [112] direction on the {111} slip plane. Typically, the non-Schmid parameter PF is used to modify the driving force for cross-slip of screw dislocations in body-centered cubic metals (cf. [145]). Unfortunately, Fig. 36 indicates that the SC model presented in eq. (12) cannot capture the continuing drop in stress between the
104
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
(a)
(b) Fig. 36. Stress required for dislocation nucleation during uniaxial tensile deformation in single crystals and grain boundaries as a function of crystallographic orientation and misorientation, respectively. Single crystal data corresponds to (a) the [100]–[110] boundary (100 STGBs) as well as (b) the [100]–[111] and [111]–[110] boundaries (110 STGBs).
[221] and [110] orientations along the [111]–[110] boundary. This limitation is resolved in Section 5.1.2 [73]. To further illustrate the relative differences in the roles of SF and NF on dislocation nucleation for uniaxial tension of atomistic models with 100 and 110 misorientation axes, Figs 37(a) and 37(b) show the magnitudes of SF and NF, respectively, against the maximum tensile stress required for dislocation nucleation in single crystal samples. In general,
§5.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
105
(a)
(b) Fig. 37. Stress required for dislocation nucleation in single crystals as a function of (a) the Schmid factor parameter (SF) and (b) the normal factor (NF) parameter. Reprinted from [18] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
Fig. 37(a) shows that for small SF values (small resolved shear stress in the direction of slip) the tensile stress required for dislocation nucleation is greater than that at higher SF values. However, for some 100 orientations, the maximum tensile stress values deviate from this general trend, revealing that SF alone is incapable describing the nucleation stress for the 100 case. In Fig. 37(b), a similar trend is observed; as the NF magnitude increases, the stress required for dislocation nucleation decreases. In other words, an increase in the stress projected normal to the slip plane decreases the applied stress necessary to nucleate dislocations within the crystal lattice; this dependence on the normal stress has been
106
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 38. Tensile stresses required for homogeneous dislocation nucleation as a function of the loading axis orientation for single crystal models at 300 K. Reprinted from [141] with permission; © 2007 American Institute of Physics.
observed using ab initio simulations by Ogata et al. [72]. Interestingly, the 110 curve displays the same general trend as the 100 data, but is divided into two regions: θ < 109.5◦ and θ > 109.5◦ . The 3 coherent twin boundary (θ = 109.5◦ ) separates these two regions, delineating the transition between active slip systems for the two regions. The two active slip systems for the θ < 109.5◦ single crystal orientations occur on different slip planes while the two slip systems for θ > 109.5◦ are on the same slip plane (coplanar slip). 5.1.2. Second generation model for dislocation nucleation in single crystals To provide a more complete correlation between SF, NF and the dislocation nucleation stress for all possible loading orientations requires atomistic simulations of SC models with orientations both on the exterior (multiple active slip systems) and interior (single slip) of the stereographic triangle. Fig. 33 shows a stereographic triangle with the 49 tensile axis orientations (filled-in circles) used to investigate the orientation dependence of homogeneous dislocation nucleation for single crystal Cu [73,141]. The expected slip system ¯ [101] slip system for all tensile axis orientations on (maximum Schmid factor) is the (111) the interior of the [100]–[110]–[111] triangle. Note that all the interior tensile axis orienta¯ tions deform via single slip on the (111)[101] slip system, while all tensile axis orientations on the boundary of the stereographic triangle have at least two active slip systems. The stress required for dislocation nucleation is calculated for all tensile axis orientations examined in this work. Fig. 38 shows a contour plot of the stress required for dislocation nucleation as a function of the tensile axis orientation on the stereographic triangle at 300 K. All intermediate tensile axis orientations in the stereographic triangle are obtained through linear interpolation. The [111] axis requires the largest tensile stress for dislocation nucleation while the [110] axis requires the lowest tensile stress for dislocation nucleation. The stress along the [100]–[110] boundary is relatively unchanged near the [110] vertex of
§5.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
107
Table 1 Parameters used in the model for homogeneous dislocation nucleation stress [eq. (16)] in single crystals at both 10 and 300 K Temperature (K)
τideal (GPa)
SF-dominated region μs,1
μn,1
μs,2
μn,2
10 300
2.16 2.16
0.574 0.396
0.000 0.000
0.000 0.037
0.693 0.473
NF-dominated region
the stereographic triangle; this trend is similar to the normal factor contour in Fig. 35(b). All other regions of the contour plot in Fig. 38 appear very similar to the Schmid factor contours in Fig. 35(a). A second-generation model is proposed to correlate the stress required for dislocation nucleation using both SF and NF. The aim of this model is to isolate the influence of lattice orientation with respect to the uniaxial tensile axis on the homogeneous dislocation nucleation event. Recall that the relationship given in eq. (12) is unable to capture the effect on dislocation nucleation stress for all orientations, specifically orientations along the [111]– [110] boundary as shown in Fig. 36(b). Previous calculations of single crystal dislocation nucleation along the exterior orientations of the stereographic triangle show that the [100]– [110] boundary correlates best with NF and the [100]–[111] boundary correlates best with SF. This indicates that dislocation nucleation is driven by different resolved stresses in two regions within the stereographic triangle: a SF-dominated region and an NF-dominated region. The aforementioned model in eq. (12) is separated into a piecewise form to capture the stress required for dislocation nucleation from all orientations within the stereographic triangle as well as the transition between the NF-dominated dislocation nucleation along the [100]–[110] boundary to the SF-dominated dislocation nucleation along the [100]– [111] boundary. The following criterion is used to identify the transition between these two regions within the stereographic triangle, i.e., τideal μs,1 SF+μn,1 NF , if (μs,1 SF + μn,1 NF) (μs,2 SF + μn,2 NF), sc σmax = (14) τideal μs,2 SF+μn,2 NF , if (μs,1 SF + μn,1 NF) < (μs,2 SF + μn,2 NF), where μs,i and μn,i are fitting coefficients for the Schmid factor and normal factor; i = 1 corresponds to the SF-dominated dislocation nucleation region and i = 2 corresponds to the NF-dominated dislocation nucleation region. Eq. (14) is formulated to allow a mild dependence on NF in an SF-dominated region, and vice versa. Fitting parameters and the posed criterion act as the additional constraint [τideal /(μs,1 SF + μn,1 NF) = τideal /(μs,2 SF + μn,2 NF) when (μs,1 SF + μn,1 NF) = (μs,2 SF + μn,2 NF)] that forces a first-order transition between the SF and NF-dominated regions. Least squares regression is then used to determine the appropriate values of μs,1 , μn,1 , μs,2 , and μn,2 based on the data for homogeneous dislocation nucleation in single crystal Cu. The parameters for eq. (14) at 10 and 300 K are listed in Table 1. These parameters are obtained by minimizing the sum of squares of the residual error between the calculated stress data and the predicted values. Interestingly, by forcing μs,i 0 and μn,i 0, the
108
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
minimum sum of squares shows that the normal factor NF has no influence (μn,1 = 0 at 10 and 300 K) in the SF-dominated dislocation nucleation region, while the Schmid factor SF has minimal influence (μs,2 = 0 at 10 K and μs,2 = 0.037 at 300 K) on dislocation nucleation in the NF-dominated region. The second-generation model for 110 single crystal orientations is shown in Fig. 36(b). Dislocation nucleation for tensile axis orientations along the [100]–[110] boundary is entirely driven by resolved stress normal to the slip plane (the normal factor), while dislocation nucleation along the [100]–[111] boundary is entirely driven by the resolved shear stress in the direction of slip (the Schmid factor). This SC model is nearly identical to the SC model of Spearot et al. [18], with a slight difference in the fitting parameters for Fig. 36(b) resulting from the interior orientations of the stereographic triangle. However, the second generation single crystal dislocation nucleation model is also able to capture the transition between the SF-dominated response to NF-dominated response along the [111]–[110] boundary in Fig. 36(b), which the initial model was unable to capture. Linear regression of the calculated dislocation nucleation stress versus the predicted stresses using eq. (14) for all orientations in Fig. 33 indicates relatively good agreement and yields correlation coefficients of R 2 = 0.886 (10 K) and R 2 = 0.920 (300 K). 5.1.3. Dislocation nucleation in single crystals under uniaxial compression The stress required for dislocation nucleation is also calculated for all orientations (open circles) in Fig. 33 for uniaxial compression. Fig. 39(a) shows a contour plot of the stress required for dislocation nucleation as a function of the compressive axis orientation on the stereographic triangle at 300 K. There is a distinctly different orientation dependence of the stress required for dislocation nucleation in tension (Fig. 38) and compression [Fig. 39(a)]. For example, notice that the [110] axis requires the lowest stress for dislocation nucleation in tension and the [100] axis requires the lowest stress in compression. The difference between the calculated stresses required for homogeneous dislocation nucleation in uniaxial tension and compression may be due to how the stress is resolved normal to the active slip system. Fig. 40 shows a schematic of the differences in resolved stresses between (a) uniaxial tension and (b) uniaxial compression. The resolved normal stress to the slip plane is tensile (compressive) in uniaxial tension (compression) for the loading axis orientations. Fig. 40(c) shows that the tensile normal stress acts to increase the interplanar spacing between {111} planes, which may allow easier nucleation of the partial dislocation loop by lowering the resistance to slip on adjoining {111} planes. In addition, in uniaxial compression, the compressive normal stress on the {111} planes acts to decrease the interplanar spacing between {111} planes, which may increase the interatomic friction to slip along these planes. While this fundamental description of how the resolved normal stress affects dislocation nucleation agrees with the calculated results from most loading axis orientations, it does not agree with all orientations (specifically, near the [100] axis as described below). Fig. 39(b) shows the ratio of the stress required for homogeneous dislocation nucleation under compression to that in tension as a function of the loading axis orientation for single crystal copper. A ratio greater than unity signifies that homogeneous dislocation nucleation requires a higher stress in compression than in tension, and vice versa. Most orientations within the stereographic triangle require a higher stress in uniaxial compres-
§5.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
109
Fig. 39. (a) Compressive stresses required for homogeneous dislocation nucleation and (b) tension–compression asymmetry as a function of the loading axis orientation for single crystal models at 300 K. The tension– compression asymmetry is rendered by plotting the ratio of the stress required for homogeneous dislocation nucleation in uniaxial compression to that in uniaxial tension. Reprinted from [141] with permission; © 2007 American Institute of Physics.
sion to nucleate dislocations; the [110] axis has the largest ratio of 3.69 (15.58 GPa in compression/4.23 GPa in tension). This trend agrees with that discussed above for Fig. 40. Interestingly, not all orientations display this trend. Fig. 39(b) also shows that some axis orientations require a greater stress in uniaxial tension than uniaxial compression. Specifically, the [100] axis has the lowest ratio of 0.41 (3.71 GPa/9.12 GPa), showing a much
110
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 40. Schematic showing the differences in resolved stresses on the active slip plane for (a) uniaxial tension and (b) uniaxial compression. At the atomic scale (c), the different directionality of the resolved normal stresses results in forces acting on the spacing of {111} planes, which may prove beneficial or detrimental to dislocation loop nucleation in single crystals depending on the loading.
greater propensity for homogeneous partial dislocation nucleation under an applied uniaxial compressive stress. The asymmetry in dislocation nucleation stress between tension and compression has been of particular interest as material microstructure progresses towards nanometer scale dimensions. For example, Diao et al. [146] have shown that the yield strength asymmetry in Au nanowires for the [100] and [111] orientations are due to surface-induced internal stresses. Tomar and Zhou [147] related the yield strength asymmetry in nanocrystalline α-Fe2 O3 -fcc Al composites to differences in grain boundary sliding behavior. Lund and Schuh [148,149] have shown that nanocrystalline Ni has higher yield and flow stresses in compression than in tension (both uniaxial and biaxial simulations); these results suggest a similar atomic-level mechanism controls yield in both FCC Ni and metallic glasses [150]. Cheng et al. [151] proposed a pressure-dependent analytical model that predicts the tension/compression asymmetry of the yield strength in nanocrystalline Cu, Al, and BCC-Fe. Consequently, as the material length scale decreases to the nanoscale, tension–compression asymmetry is expected. While these studies have focused on inelastic deformation due to heterogeneities at the nanoscale, the influence of crystal orientation on dislocation nucleation in the absence of heterogeneities is also vital to a full understanding of inelasticity at the nanoscale. Therefore, the current MD simulations, which show a tension–compression asymmetry of dislocation nucleation in single crystals, agrees with previous simulations and analytical models that have shown a tension–compression asymmetry in the yield stress for nanocrystalline FCC metals [148,151], metallic glasses [150], and nanocrystalline α-Fe2 O3 -fcc Al composites [147]. Furthermore, studies of homogeneous dislocation nucleation in single crystals lend valuable insight that is complementary to modeling heterogeneous dislocation nucleation from interfaces [18].
§5.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
111
5.1.4. Effect of lattice distortion on resolved stress components The affine elastic distortion of the lattice during application of uniaxial stress prior to nucleation is significant in terms of rotation of the slip system and associated co-slip and slip plane normal directions. Here we consider how the strain to nucleation (on the order of 6–14%) can influence the resolved stress components in the current (deformed) configuration at the point of nucleation. To do this, the motion of the simulation cell boundaries was used to compute a deformation gradient tensor, F˜ij , that maps the original orthogonal triad of unit vectors in the slip, co-slip and slip plane normal directions from the undeformed to the deformed configuration. The push-forward transformation ∗ α diα = F˜im dm
(15) α∗
gives the deformed configuration components d of these three unit vectors d α , α = 1, 2, 3 in the initial (undeformed) configuration. These vectors are no longer orthogonal in the current configuration, having undergone stretch and rotation. The direction cosines ij used in eq. (13) pertain to the resolution of Cauchy stress onto slip vectors d α in the undeformed configuration. To provide a meaningful description of the resolved shear stress in the slip direction and the normal stress to the slip plane in the deformed configuration at the point of nucleation, we simply take a cross product of the deformed vectors in the slip and co-slip directions (which establish the slip plane tangent) to determine the slip plane normal direction. Then, a vector cross product of this slip plane normal direction with the deformed slip direction vector gives a modified co-slip direction, yielding an orthogonal triad which is then normalized to a set of unit vectors for defining an updated set of direction cosines in eq. (13). The slip direction and slip plane normal are preserved as primal descriptors. Several calculations are performed to compare differences between using this rotated basis and the original undeformed basis of slip, co-slip and slip plane normal directions in eq. (13). First, the evolution of the Schmid factor was calculated as a function of strain for the 12 {111}110 slip systems for the [321] orientation under uniaxial tension at 10 K. The temperature of 10 K requires the largest strains for dislocation nucleation as a function of temperature and represents the upper bound for slip system rotation. The maximum ¯ Schmid factor (111)[101] slip system in the undeformed configuration has the highest SF value throughout uniaxial loading in tension. Even for large strain deformation (10% strain), the increase in SF on an individual slip system is not enough for another slip system ¯ to become the favored slip system, i.e., a higher SF than the (111)[101] slip system. For ¯ the remaining analyses, we assume that the (111)[101] slip system remains the active slip system throughout elastic deformation. All crystal orientations around the stereographic triangle were sampled to find the approximate increase in the resolved stress parameters SF and NF at the strain associated with dislocation nucleation. In uniaxial tension at 10 K, SF and NF decreased by an average of 3% and 15%, respectively. In uniaxial compression at 10 K, SF and NF increased by an average of 2% and 20%, respectively. The changes in the resolved shear stress in the slip direction (i.e., SF) as a function of elastic deformation are minimal compared to the changes in the resolved stress normal to the slip plane (NF). Moreover, on average, the resolved stresses evolve differently in tension and compression; in tension the resolved stress components decrease and vice versa. However, while the evolution of resolved stress
112
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
components under tension and compression may partly explain the calculated tension– compression asymmetry, the magnitude of these changes are still small relative to the sign change for the resolved normal stress. For example, for the [321] orientation at 10 K, the change in the resolved shear stress due to lattice rotation is τSF = 4.7 − 4.6 = 0.1 GPa in tension and τSF = 8.4 − 8.5 = −0.1 GPa in compression. However, the difference in the resolved normal stress between tension and compression is σNF = 11.5 GPa at dislocation nucleation (σNF = 10.7 GPa based on the geometry of the undeformed lattice), considerably more pronounced than the change in the resolved shear stress. Finally, the values of SF and NF at dislocation nucleation that account for lattice rotation at that point differ somewhat from results that neglect the effects of lattice rotation. First, the data in Fig. 37 are merely shifted appropriately along the SF and NF axes. The trends remain the same. Also, the single crystal model for homogeneous dislocation nucleation can be modified to reflect the SF and NF values at dislocation nucleation. Least squares nonlinear regression to eq. (14) results in μs,1 = 0.426 and μn,2 = 0.583 with μn,1 = μs,2 = 0, which is mainly influenced by the decrease of NF under uniaxial tension. The fitting parameters for eq. (14) are in line with those based off of the initial SF and NF. While a fit to eq. (14) with the resolved stress parameters at dislocation nucleation may be more appropriate, this requires atomistic information to calculate the elastic deformation gradient, unlike the initial resolved stress parameters in Sections 5.1.1–5.1.3. In this respect, the resolved stress parameters SF and NF from the initial single crystal configuration give a relatively good approximation of the resolved stress components required for dislocation nucleation, noting that the largest change at the onset of plasticity is in the resolved stress normal to the slip plane on which the dislocation nucleates.
5.2. Model for dislocation nucleation from tilt grain boundaries 5.2.1. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries Once the effect of lattice orientation has been isolated, the second step in the development of the interface strength model is to incorporate a first-order dependence on the inherent GB nanoporosity or free volume, Dc , via the simple relation int sc = (1 − ξ Dc )σmax . σmax
(16)
Here, ξ is an amplification factor, the magnitude of which is dependent on the scale of the selected interface region which is used to compute the average free volume. This representation considers only the average porosity within a strip around the interface, without regard to its distribution along the interface plane. Here, Dc is the initial free volume [152] inherent to the interface structure. It is computed in the present case from atomistic simulations prior to imposition of tensile deformation (stress). The free volume measure is developed by examining the first-nearest neighbor coordination number of each atom, Z1i . Of course, atoms in a perfect bulk FCC crystalline arrangement have a first-order coordination number of 12. Atoms with Z1i less than that of the bulk crystal are defined as ‘damaged’ in this methodology. Previous molecular dynamics simulations on nanocrystalline samples [24] have shown that atoms at grain boundaries and triple junctions have
§5.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
113
a range of coordination numbers, implying the presence of initial porosity within the interface structure. In this work, damaged atoms may be directly attributed to porosity at the interface between crystalline regions (aside from thermal vibrations which have been found to have a negligible affect on the Dc calculation at 300 K). Using this concept, we formulate a damage parameter on a per atom basis as i Z1 − Z1,th i D =1− (17) . Z1,ref − Z1,th In eq. (17), Z1,ref is the coordination number associated with a perfect crystalline lattice and Z1,th is the threshold coordination number required for an atom to be considered completely damaged (D i = 1). This threshold value is taken as Z1,th = 8 in this work; however, Z1,th may be adjusted to make the calculation of D i sensitive to different types of interfacial damage. Eq. (17) allows the ith atom to have partial damage (0 D i 1) depending on its local environment. Angle brackets define that atoms with Z1i < Z1,th have D i = 1 and atoms with Z1i > Z1,ref have D i = 0. The free volume measure is defined as the average of the point-wise damage parameter over the interface region, N N i Z1 − Z1,th 1 i 1 Dc = (18) D = 1− . N N Z1,ref − Z1,th i=1
N
i=1
is the total number of atoms within the interface region. Numerically, eq. (18) Here, may be evaluated at each time step from the atomic positions and requires no a priori knowledge of the interface structure or the form of the porosity evolution. In summary, the proposed model for tensile interface strength requires specification of the crystal lattice geometry, the associated non-Schmid parameters μs , μn and μp , the initial interface free volume, and an amplification factor, ξ . Further development of a relationship relating the crystal lattice geometry with free volume would allow the calculation of the tensile stress required for interfacial dislocation nucleation using only continuum quantities and the aforementioned non-Schmid parameters. The interface strength model [eq. (16)] is then fit to the computed peak tensile stress values for interface models with 100 and 110 misorientation axes. The amplification factor ξ is regarded as an additional fitting parameter that is required in eq. (16) to predict the peak tensile interface stress values. The least-squares regression fit for the interface models with 100 and 110 misorientation axes uses the same non-Schmid parameters μs , μn and μp that were calculated using the single crystal data. Fig. 41 shows that the proposed relationship is capable of capturing the influence of interface structure on the maximum tensile stress for bicrystal interfaces with a 100 misorientation axis. For these boundaries, the role of the interface misorientation on dislocation nucleation is effectively captured through the averaged description of the interfacial porosity. Fig. 41 shows that the proposed relationship works well for boundaries with a 110 misorientation axis and θ < 109.5◦ . However, MD simulation results indicate that the proposed first-order model is not universally applicable, as this model is unable to capture the significant drop in the maximum tensile stress for symmetric boundaries which include the E structural unit (θ > 109.5◦ ).
114
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
(a)
(b) Fig. 41. Stress required for dislocation nucleation during uniaxial tensile deformation in single crystals and grain boundaries as a function of crystallographic orientation and misorientation, respectively. Single crystal data corresponds to (a) the [100]–[110] boundary (100 STGBs) as well as (b) the [100]–[111] and [111]–[110] boundaries (110 STGBs). Reprinted from [18] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
In order to address a greater range of interface misorientations for the 110 tilt axis, two solutions are currently being pursued to enhance the interface strength model. First, a higher-order formulation may be proposed, which includes a dependence on the gradient of free volume within the interface region. It is possible that localized ‘pockets’ of porosity, characteristic of interfaces with the E structural unit, result in high stress concen-
§5.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
115
trations that contribute to the drop in tensile strength by promoting dislocation nucleation. Subsequent simulations of the spatial distribution of grain boundary free volume and its impact on dislocation nucleation for this range of boundaries are briefly discussed in Section 6.5. Additional details concerning the correlation between boundary structure and free volume can be found in Ref. [153]. Second, the amplification factor for the free volume measure may be posed as a function of the distribution of specific structural elements. This modification acknowledges that dissimilar interface features can contribute differently to the dislocation nucleation process. For example, Van Swygenhoven et al. have observed that stress concentrations at ledges and triple junctions in nanocrystalline samples can promote dislocation nucleation [35]. In our work, the natural alignment of certain structural units with respect to the primary slip systems appears to render certain interface features particularly susceptible to dislocation nucleation. For these boundaries, the tensile interface strength computed from MD simulations is probably closer to the Peierls–Nabarro stress (the applied stress required to overcome the lattice resistance to the movement of the interfacial dislocations). 5.2.2. Extensions to asymmetric tilt GBs Several challenges arise in the formulation of an interface strength model for asymmetric tilt GBs. The ATGBs in this study contain an additional level of complexity relative to the STGBs in the aforementioned study; instead of two identical lattice orientations relative to the GB plane, the bicrystal lattice orientations relative to the ATGB mean boundary plane differ, resulting in different SF, NF, and PF values for each lattice. Also, while the free volume for ATGBs can be calculated, the faceting of ATGBs adds an additional layer of atomic level complexity because of its impact on dislocation nucleation. Finally, the preferential nucleation of dislocations from ATGBs dictates that the model parameters must have a physical basis. Obviously, using the Schmid and non-Schmid parameters of crystal 2 to predict the preferential nucleation of dislocations from the ATGB into crystal 1 is not physically appropriate. Therefore, as a first step towards an interface model for the stress required for dislocation nucleation at 3 ATGBs, the present authors investigate the prediction of preferential nucleation in this class of asymmetric boundaries. First, the Schmid and non-Schmid effects are investigated to examine their potential utility for understanding the preferential dislocation nucleation. As mentioned previously, the crystal lattices on each side of an ATGB are oriented differently relative to the applied stress direction, resulting in different Schmid and non-Schmid factors. Therefore, dislocation motion should be easiest in the lattice with the slip system associated with the highest Schmid factor, since this slip system has the highest resolved shear stress. However, dislocation nucleation from ATGBs does not necessarily occur on the highest Schmid factor slip system between the two crystals. Fig. 42(a) shows the maximum Schmid factor for both crystal lattices as a function of the inclination angle. The vertical lines at = 35.26◦ and = 54.74◦ correspond to relative minima in the maximum Schmid factor, which corresponds to a transition of active slip systems; the vertical line at = 70.53◦ delineates the region where ATGBs contain the 9R phase in Cu. However, contrary to what might be expected from Fig. 42(a) based on the Schmid factor, the partial dislocations are nucleated into crystal 1 for all 3 ATGBs examined in Ref. [19]. This observation matches the crystal predicted from the maximum Schmid factors for low inclination angles only (i.e.,
116
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
(a)
(b) Fig. 42. (a) Change in the Schmid factor (SF) as a function of the grain boundary inclination angle for both Crystal 1 and Crystal 2. (b) Comparison between the stress required for dislocation nucleation in 3 asymmetric tilt boundaries and single crystals for Cu at 300 K. Reprinted from [19] with permission; © 2007 Elsevier.
< 25.24◦ ). Similar trends are calculated for the normal and co-slip factors as well [19]; there are 3 ATGB inclination angles for which NF and PF are greater in crystal 2 than crystal 1. Consequently, neither the Schmid or non-Schmid factors are useful as a criterion to predict the lattice in which the partial dislocation nucleates. However, the Schmid factor can be used to predict which slip system the dislocation nucleates on, once the crystal is known in which nucleation occurs.
§6
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
117
Fig. 42(b) compares the stress required for dislocation nucleation in Cu 3 ATGBs at 300 K with the stress required in Cu single crystals. The Cu single crystals are oriented the same as crystal 1. The single crystal stress values were calculated using the single crystal maximum tensile stress values required for dislocation nucleation at 300 K [18]. A cubic spline was used to interpolate stress values at intermediate misorientation angles. The single crystal stresses represent the homogeneous nucleation of dislocations in a defect-free lattice. Therefore, the stress required for heterogeneous dislocation nucleation from 3 ATGBs should be less than or equal to the crystal with the lowest stress value. First, notice the good agreement between the single crystal and ATGB stress values for low inclination angles ( 35.26◦ ). Recall that the low inclination ATGB mechanism shows that the dislocation nucleates on a slip plane different from the plane of dissociation. Interestingly, this phenomenon requires stresses near the level required for homogeneous nucleation in crystal 1. Second, the stress required for nucleation in all other ATGBs ( 43.31◦ ) is much lower than the stress required for homogeneous nucleation. This difference has been captured in STGBs by considering GB characteristics, such as free volume [18]. The difference between stress values required for homogeneous (single crystal) and heterogeneous (bicrystal) dislocation nucleation may be due to a number of factors. Interface free volume and faceting were investigated in Ref. [19]. However, linear correlations to either the free volume or GB ledge density are not able to capture this difference. Dislocation nucleation in ATGBs may require more complicated nonlinear forms. In addition, the inclination of the facets with respect to the mean boundary plane may play a role in the decreased stresses required for heterogeneous nucleation of dislocations. As the inclination angle increases (decreases), a higher fraction of the uniaxial stress will resolve into a shear stress component on the CTB (SITB) facets. At = 45◦ , the uniaxial tensile stress resolves equally normal to the facets (tensile) and perpendicular to the facets (shear). Furthermore, the CTB and SITB facets will likely behave differently with respect to the applied shear; e.g., the CTB deforms by twin migration under shear while many other boundaries deform via GB shuffling and partial dislocation nucleation [39]. Moreover, Sansoz and Molinari [38] show that the 9 (221) STGB is about 4.5 times weaker in shear than in tension for Cu. Consequently, the inclination of the facets with respect to the mean boundary plane should result in an increased shear component, resulting in a lower tensile stress perpendicular to the mean boundary plane required for dislocation nucleation.
6. Insights and implications The present work on structure and nucleation of dislocations at bicrystal boundaries illuminates certain issues pertaining to fundamental understanding of the role of grain boundaries. Here, we discuss some important aspects regarding dislocation nucleation in FCC metals under uniaxial loading applied perpendicular to the boundary plane: (i) grain boundary dislocation sources, (ii) representation of defects within grain boundaries as ordered structures comprised of disclination dipoles or disconnections, (iii) tension–compression asymmetry of trailing partial emission in Cu, (iv) the activation energy and volume for grain boundary dislocation nucleation, (v) the influence of grain boundary free volume on
118
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
dislocation nucleation, and (vi) continuum field theory. This understanding may benefit understanding of behavior of nanocrystalline and polycrystalline FCC metals.
6.1. Grain boundary dislocation sources The dislocation nucleation event can be viewed as the activation of a dislocation source that lies within or nearby a boundary. The distinct structure of high-angle boundaries is best represented as a well-defined ordering of boundary dislocations. The nucleation and emission of dislocations from the boundary impacts the grain boundary dislocation content. This section briefly discusses several representative atomistic simulations to show how nucleated dislocations from activated sources interact with the high-angle grain boundary structure in the immediate vicinity. The Burgers vector content of the grain boundary is often reduced following dislocation nucleation. For example, for 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries of intermediate inclination angle, the grain boundary partial dislocation (D structural unit) is dissociated from the boundary on the maximum Schmid factor plane until it is emitted into the adjoining lattice. In this case, the Burgers vector content of the grain boundary is reduced by the emission of the partial dislocation, i.e., bGB∗ = bGB + bdislocation where bGB∗ , bGB , and bdislocation are the GB Burgers vector content before (asterisk) and after emission, and the Burgers vector of the emitted partial dislocation, respectively. For certain boundaries in this work, the Burgers vector content of the grain boundary is not reduced following dislocation nucleation. For example, in the 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundary of low inclination angle, the grain boundary dislocation is initially dissociated from the boundary on a slip plane of low resolved shear stress. However, the partial dislocation prefers nucleation on a slip plane of high resolved shear stress. Closer examination reveals that a partial dislocation loop nucleates on the maximum Schmid factor slip plane very near to the facet intersection (or GB ledge), as shown in Fig. 43. Because of the proximity to the boundary, the segment of the partial dislocation loop that glides toward the boundary is quickly absorbed, adding Burgers vector content to the boundary. The other half of the loop glides into the lattice, giving the appearance that this dislocation was emitted directly from the boundary. However, as Fig. 43 shows, the dislocation source visibly lies in the lattice near the intersection of the ATGB facets, and this ledge-like structure is the impetus for the dislocation nucleation event. This event can be thought of as the emission of a single dislocation loop within the lattice near the GB ledge. The size of simulation cell size limits our ability to discern whether these sources emit successive partial loop dislocations under further strain. Atomistic studies of this type offer details of the emission sequence that enhance our understanding of the source/sink nature of boundaries. Dislocation sources can also lie directly in the interface. Recall the discussion of dislocation nucleation from 110 symmetric tilt grain boundaries with dissociated structure in Section 4.1.2. In this example, increasing tensile strain applied perpendicular to the boundary results in constriction of the dissociated partial dislocation after which partial dislocations are emitted in another nearby site, producing extrinsic stacking faults, and later intrinsic stacking faults, in both symmetric lattices. In this case, the dislocation source lies directly in the interface, leading to the nucleation of the partial dislocations within the grain
§6.1
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
119
¯ 1 /(112)2 = Fig. 43. Dislocation loops nucleate in the lattice near the facet intersections for the 3 (552) 19.47◦ ATGB in Cu at 10 K. (a) Image of boundary at dislocation nucleation rendered via centrosymmetry. (b) Schematic showing the lattice dislocation source activated by deformation. (c) Slices of the (111) slip plane showing various stages of dislocation loop nucleation.
boundary. Several partial dislocations were emitted from the grain boundary dislocation source and the boundary accommodates their emission through local structural rearrangement near the source. These kinds of complex sequence effects in dislocation nucleation become evident using atomistic simulations. A particularly fruitful area of endeavor is the characterization of Burgers vector content in various general boundaries following nucleation of dislocations, discerning how the residual content is manifested in terms of change of boundary structure. Moreover, the impact of this evolution on continued nucleation or absorption/desorption reactions is of great interest. We must also emphasize that while the geometrically necessary dislocation density (associated net Burgers vector) contributes to lack of closure over a Burgers circuit in a crystal in the relaxed configuration, higher order gradients of the deformation gradient and gradients of lattice curvature also contribute to the lack of closure. This is discussed further in Section 6.4, and is especially important near grain boundaries that have undergone dislocation nucleation or other interactions with dislocations, as gradients of lattice curvature are pronounced in these regions. Hence, we regard that conservation of Burgers vector may be foundational in the more general setting of short range Burger circuit analyses that include a complete characterization of lattice curvature, including higher order gradients, but of course this is not usually done in constructing Burgers circuits near boundaries. Moreover, one can always assign dislocation content to the deformed grain boundary following dislocation nucleation to satisfy the balance relation, but whether or not this conforms to summation of specific configurations/reactions of a discrete set of feasible partial dislocations is another matter.
120
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
6.2. Disconnections and the description of GB defects Recall from Section 1.2 that the undeformed structure of high-angle grain boundary interfaces may be described using disclination dipoles along with the structural unit model [62– 68]. In this framework, the minority structural units are represented as wedge disclination dipoles while the strength of each wedge disclination is defined by the change in the angle between neighboring dissimilar structural units. To describe the irreversible distortion of the grain boundary structure after dislocation emission, Hurtado et al. [104] considered two theoretical models. The first model considered the creation of a disclination dipole (with opposite orientation to the dipoles within the interface) at the nucleation site. The length of the created dipole is assumed to be the same as that of the interface dipoles. The second model envisioned the creation of a dislocation at the nucleation site with the same Burgers vector and opposite orientation as the dislocation that is emitted into the lattice. Hirth and colleagues [69] provided a thorough description of grain boundary distortion caused by dislocation processes. For example, the transmission of dislocations through a tilt boundary results in the formation of a “disconnection” at the interface, which can be viewed as the superposition of a step of defined height and an edge dislocation. The emission of a dislocation from a tilt boundary results in the creation of an offset step which can be attributed the half-plane of the dislocation that has left the boundary. Depending on the local configuration in the neighborhood of the step, this offset can be described either as a grain boundary dislocation (GBD) or as a disconnection. We find this representation to be compelling; the offset associated with a disconnection is confirmed via the MD simulations presented in this work. For example, MD simulation of dislocation emission in Al resulted in a ledge at the intersection of the slip plane and the grain boundary (Fig. 20) while the emission of ISF facets in Cu introduces a small step in the interface plane (Fig. 23). Fig. 44 shows a schematic comparing the disclination dipole model and the disconnection model based on analysis of the deformed 5 (310) bicrystal interface structure. Recall that the original structure of the 5 (310) interface (without ledges) involves a uniform distribution of C structural units, i.e., no disclination dipoles or disconnections are observed in the undeformed configuration, as shown in Fig. 44(a). The proposed disclination dipole representation of the distorted interface from [16] is shown in Fig. 44(b). The nucleation of a full dislocation from the interface is accompanied by a local lattice rotation, leading to the asymmetric expansion of two C structural units. This is represented as a series of staggered disclination dipoles that span the interface ledge at the nucleation site. It is noted that the deformed configurations in Fig. 44(b) are “idealized” to show that only two structural units are deformed by the slip process. In reality, a few structural units on either side of the dislocation nucleation point are slightly modified to smoothly accommodate the created ledge at the intersection of the slip plane and the interface. The strength of the each disclination within the dipole is equal to the difference between the angle of the C and the distorted C∗∗ structural units [recall structural unit definitions in Fig. 20(d)], which is calculated from MD as approximately 10◦ –12◦ for this interface. The disclination dipole length is equal to that of two C∗∗ segments. If additional structural units existed between the C∗∗ units, such as B units in higher-order CSL boundaries [16], then two dipoles may be required to represent the interface structure, each of which is oriented at an angle to the interface plane [67].
§6.2
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
121
Fig. 44. Defect models for the distorted 5 (310) interface after dislocation emission; (a) reference (undeformed configuration), (b) disclination dipole representation from [16] and (c) disconnection representation. Disclination dipoles are represented as a set of wedge disclinations using identical notation as Fig. 3.
It is clear from Figs 20(d) and 44(b) that the centerline of the C∗∗ distorted structural units is not aligned along the interface (i.e., the lattice rotation during distortion is not symmetric about the misorientation axis). Thus, while the disclination dipole model captures the local change in lattice rotation at the defect site (the junction between C and C∗∗ units) and the essential characteristics of the long-range field associated with the grain boundary distortion, it fails to truly capture the conformation of the step that is created at the dislocation nucleation site. Hirth et al. [69] proposed that this type of defect is more appropriately classified as a grain boundary dislocation or if localized lattice rotation is to be included, as a disconnection. The disconnection representation is shown in Fig. 44(c).
122
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
The disconnection description emphasizes the ledge within the grain boundary in addition to the local rotational deformation of the neighboring structural units at a distance away from the step and thus offers a more complete characterization of the defect. Finally, Hirth et al. [69] suggested two methods for which the disconnection can be removed. First, half of the semi-infinite array of dislocations at the interface can glide to restore the symmetric boundary, which will only likely happen for low-angle interfaces. Second, the disconnection itself can glide parallel to the interface plane to restore the low-energy boundary configuration. MD simulations in this work indicate a possible third mechanism for the removal of the disconnection at the interface. Upon application of a uniaxial stress normal to the boundary plane, which is perpendicular to the Burgers vector of the dislocation that represents the ledge in the interface, the disconnection is removed through a series of partial dislocation nucleation events on compatible slip systems in each crystal region. These dislocation nucleation events effectively unlock the disconnection at the interface resulting in a perfectly planar boundary, as shown in Figs 23 and 24 [17]. In our view, the distinction between structural units and disclination dipoles is somewhat of a matter of semantics, since the former clearly also possess the requisite geometric characteristics of a wedge type disclination dipole for low index tilt misorientation axes. However, the distinction may be viewed as useful on the basis that disclination dipoles are associated with lattice curvature gradients that either do not correspond to minimum energy repeating structural units in special (CSL) boundaries, or evolve in response to dislocation reactions with the boundary. As we have seen, in the process of dislocation emission, the responsible structural units can evolve into a pair of disclination dipoles with an interface dislocation representing a step in the disconnection convention. Moreover, disclination dipoles occur frequently in general boundaries and asymmetric tilt boundaries, which often have higher energy than the special boundaries that are characterized by dominance of repeating structural units.
6.3. Tension–compression asymmetry in trailing partial emission in Cu The issue of partial dislocation versus full dislocation emission from grain boundaries has been the subject of recent interest in models for nanocrystalline materials. Recall that the mechanism of dislocation emission from the grain boundary occurs in several steps. First, a partial dislocation nucleates and is emitted from the grain boundary. Atomistic simulations have shown that stress-assisted free volume migration leads to the atomic shuffling necessary to form the Burgers vector required to nucleate a partial dislocation from the boundary region [29,31]. As the leading partial dislocation transects the grain, an intrinsic stacking fault is created behind the partial dislocation. For smaller grain sizes, the leading partial dislocation can be absorbed at the grain boundary on the opposite side of the grain prior to the emission of the trailing partial. For larger grain sizes, the trailing partial dislocation is nucleated from the boundary, restoring the order of the stacking sequence of {111} planes within the lattice and bounding the intrinsic stacking fault. Developing models or relations with physically-based parameters that give insight to partial versus full dislocation nucleation has received much attention. For example, Yamakov and coworkers [154] proposed a deformation mechanism map that described
§6.3
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
123
the transition from dislocation-mediated to grain boundary-mediated plastic deformation based on the equilibrium splitting distance for partials at σ = 0 and the grain boundary diameter, among other quantities. However, the description for the splitting distance is based solely on the intrinsic stacking fault energy, γSF , with no dependence on the unstable stacking fault energy, γUSF . Simulations of nanocrystalline deformation do not support the cross-over of dislocation-based deformation mechanisms (slip of extended partial dislocations versus perfect slip of full dislocations) based only on the value of γSF . Van Swygenhoven et al. [32] noted that extended partial dislocations are observed above and below the predicted cross-over grain size in Cu [9–11]. In addition, NC deformation simulations [29,31] with a Ni potential (higher γSF than Al) only revealed extended partial dislocations for grain sizes as large as 20 nm. In contrast to the deformation mechanism map proposed by Yamakov and coworkers, Van Swygenhoven et al. [32] proposed that extended or full dislocation activity should be understood in terms of γSF /γUSF and, more importantly, that γSF alone cannot capture the important physics of the nucleation of leading and trailing partial dislocations from grain boundaries. Along those lines, Asaro and Suresh [155] present a mechanistic model for FCC nanocrystalline metals that employs the ratio γSF /γUSF to predict the emission of the trailing partial dislocation. However, none of these arguments or models consider the effect of loading orientation (tension versus compression) or the resulting resolved normal stress on the emission of the trailing partial. Interestingly, MD simulations have shown a distinctly different behavior of the trailing partial dislocation between uniaxial tension and uniaxial compression for homogeneous and heterogeneous dislocation nucleation from single crystals and grain boundaries, respectively. For homogeneous dislocation nucleation in single crystal Cu, Fig. 45 shows that partial dislocation loops containing an intrinsic stacking fault are nucleated in tension and full dislocation loops are nucleated in compression for a single crystal with a [321] loading axis orientation. This phenomenon is commonly observed for multiple crystal orientations around the stereographic triangle. For heterogeneous dislocation from grain boundaries, symmetric tilt grain boundaries with the E structural unit were deformed under uniaxial tension and compression. Fig. 45(c) shows the emission of partial dislocations from the 171 (11, 11, 10) vicinal coherent twin boundary under uniaxial tension. Fig. 45(f) shows the emission of full dislocations from the same boundary under uniaxial compression. Interestingly, the full dislocation is emitted on the {100} slip plane, which has a higher resolved shear stress in the 110 slip direction than the {111}110 slip systems. Despite the higher resolved shear stress, dislocation emission on the {100} slip plane is only observed in compression. As with single crystals, the partial (full) dislocation behavior in uniaxial tension (compression) is observed for a wide range of boundary structures across the misorientation range that corresponds to boundaries with the E structural unit. Other grain boundaries have not yet been deformed, but are expected to display similar behavior due to the high compressive resolved normal stress. The contrast between the nucleation mechanisms under uniaxial tension and compression may shed light on our fundamental understanding of how resolved stresses affect dislocation nucleation in single crystals and grain boundaries. As discussed in Section 5 and depicted in Fig. 40, the main difference in how the applied stress is resolved for uniaxial tension and compression is the stress normal to the slip plane; in tension, this normal
124
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
Fig. 45. Dislocation nucleation behavior in uniaxial tension (a–c) and uniaxial compression (d–f) for the (a, b, d, e) [321] single crystal and (c, f) 171 (11, 11, 10) vicinal coherent twin boundary. The emission of the trailing partial dislocation is observed in compression, but not in tension. Images (b) and (e) are slices of the slip plane on which dislocations nucleate.
stress is tensile, and vice versa for compression. Full dislocation nucleation observed under uniaxial compression implies that a compressive stress normal on the active slip plane contributes to the nucleation of the trailing partial dislocation. In contrast, a tensile stress normal to the slip plane may deter the nucleation of a second partial dislocation. This may be explained with the generalized stacking fault (GSF) curve on the {111} slip plane in the 112 direction for an FCC crystal. Zimmerman et al. [103] show that the GSF is affected by deformation of the material. They biaxially stretched the lattice by 4% while calculating the GSF curves and found that the unrelaxed γUSF of 175 mJ/m2 is reduced to 99 mJ/m2 for the “deformed and relaxed” simulations. The unstable stacking fault energy (γUSF ) of the GSF curve is associated with the energy barrier for dislocation nucleation [101]. In this sense, the barrier to dislocation nucleation is reduced by the applied deformation. The GSF curve may be similarly affected by the magnitude and directionality of the resolved stress normal to the slip plane, particularly with respect to nucleation of the trailing partial dislocation. Indeed this feature of a changing potential energy landscape of grain boundaries under stress renders the prospect of characterizing the activation energies and
§6.4
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
125
transition state pathways for various dislocation nucleation events quite challenging from a unit process standpoint.
6.4. Activation volumes and energies for grain boundary dislocation nucleation The activation volume and the activation energy are important experimentally-measurable scalar quantities that can be used to model the rate and temperature sensitivity of plasticity mechanisms in constitutive relations [139,155,156]. The activation energy barrier for nucleation can be overcome with contributions from both mechanical work (applied stress) and thermal energy kB T , where kB is Boltzmann’s constant and T is temperature. The activation volume is that required for the reaction to occur. Asaro and Suresh [155] have compiled a summary of available data on the effect of grain size on the activation volume in Cu and Ni. They show that the magnitudes of the activation volumes decrease substantially as the grain size decreases to the nanoscale, in line with other calculated and experimental observations [139,157–159]. For example, Schuh et al. [140] performed nanoindentation experiments on platinum at various temperatures and found activation volumes of ∼0.5 b3 . Lu et al. [158] experimentally measured activation volumes of ∼10–20 b3 for nanotwinned copper. In addition to measurement of activation energies and activation volumes through experiments, Zhu and coworkers [156] have developed a computational methodology whereby atomistic simulations are used to calculate the activation energy and activation volume and assess the strain rate and temperature sensitivity of dislocation reactions. Here, we use MD calculations to obtain a first-order approximation of the activation energies and volumes for dislocation nucleation from 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries in Cu and Al. Calculations have shown that there is a significant drop in the stress required to nucleate dislocations from 10 to 300 K, suggesting that thermal activation plays a role in dislocation nucleation from the grain boundary. The activation volume and activation energy Q for dislocation nucleation are calculated from a first-order model of stressdependent activation energy whereby the activation energy linearly depends upon stress σ , i.e., Q(σ ) = Q∗ − σ . In this model, Q∗ corresponds to the athermal nucleation energy barrier in the absence of applied stress. The activation energy Q measures the sensitivity of nucleation rate to temperature while the activation volume measures the sensitivity of nucleation rate to stress. Zhu et al. [156] derived a form for the dislocation nucleation stress that takes into account both the temperature and strain-rate dependence. They applied this form to dislocation nucleation at surfaces under a constant strain rate. We employ the same equation to calculate the activation energy and activation volume in this study, kB T kB T Nν0 Q∗ − ln . σ = (19) E ε˙ In eq. (19), the temperature T = 300 K, N is the number of nucleation sites (N = 50,000), ν0 is the jump frequency (ν0 = 3 × 1011 s−1 ), E is the elastic modulus, and ε˙ is the applied strain rate (˙ε = 109 s−1 ). The definitions of the terms are given by Zhu and coworkers [156]. The first term Q∗ / is the athermal stress required to nucleate a dislocation from the grain boundary. The pre-factor of the second term kB T / reduces the
126
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
nucleation stress by virtue of thermal fluctuation. In the logarithmic function, the numerator is the rate of energy exchange of the system with the thermal bath and the denominator is the rate of energy delivery into the system through mechanical work; the ratio between these terms determines the relative influence of thermal fluctuations in reducing the nucleation stress. Several assumptions are made to calculate the activation volume and activation energy. First, the atomic jump frequency (ν0 ) is chosen to represent the cooperative atomic motion necessary to form a dislocation, and is on the order of the frequency of free oscillation in Cu. Second, the number of nucleation sites (N ) represents the approximate number of noncentrosymmetric atoms at the grain boundary. Since these are embedded in the logarithmic term, variation of N ν0 by several orders of magnitude results in very little change to the activation volume. Third, since the first term in eq. (19) corresponds to the athermal nucleation stress, the calculated nucleation stresses at 10 K were used as an approximate value. The nucleation stresses from all 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries shown in Fig. 26(b) were used to capture the effect of variation in boundary structure and dislocation nucleation mechanisms on the activation energy and volume. Last, the elastic stiffness of the computational cell was calculated using the theoretical values of the two adjoining lattice regions; the effect of elastic anisotropy had little effect on the calculations. Using the nucleation stress values for uniaxial tension at T = 300 K, we find that the activation volumes for dislocation nucleation are on the order of 0.5–3 b3 in both Cu and Al, where b = 0.255 nm in Cu and b = 0.286 nm in Al. Rearranging the first term in eq. (19) such that Q∗ = σ gives the athermal activation energy barrier under zero applied stress, which ranges from 0.8–2.4 eV for 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries. Also, using our first-order approximation of a linear dependence of activation energy on stress [Q(σ ) = Q∗ − σ ] we calculate the activation energy for dislocation nucleation at 300 K as approximately 0.24–0.28 eV. Interestingly, the activation energies at 300 K are roughly the same for all 3 boundaries examined, despite the wide range of boundary structures. Zhu and coworkers [139,156] have calculated activation volumes and activation energies for heterogeneous dislocation nucleation and dislocation reactions using the climbing image nudged elastic band (CINEB) method. The CINEB method allows for a direct calculation of the activation energy versus stress relationship, without relying on several of the aforementioned assumptions made in the current calculations. Even so, the calculated activation energies are on the order of those computed for side surface nucleation (Q = 0.64 eV) and corner nucleation (Q = 0.1 eV) from nanopillars [156]. Furthermore, Zhu and coworkers [139] calculated activation energies for dislocation absorption (Qabs = 0.49 eV) and dislocation direction transmission (Qtrs = 0.67 eV) at the coherent twin boundary that are similar to the present molecular dynamics calculations at a strain rate of 109 . The similarity of values suggests that the current calculations are a reasonable approximation of the activation volumes and activation energies for dislocation nucleation from 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries. The small activation volumes of 0.5–3 b3 promote enhanced temperature sensitivity of dislocation nucleation at grain boundaries and indicate that the atomic volume required for grain boundary dislocation nucleation is similar to the activation volume required for grain boundary shear events, = 1 b3 , in another FCC metal, Au [159]. The small activation volumes indicate that at the appropriate stress level, the motion of a few atoms may serve as
§6.5
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
127
the impetus for nucleating a dislocation from the boundary. In addition, the small activation volume suggests that the nucleation event is appropriately viewed as a small dislocation loop nucleating at the grain boundary, as shown by our MD calculations in Section 4. As the length scales associated with activation volumes are on the order of interatomic spacing, we anticipate that the grain boundary free volume contributes to the driving force for the dislocation nucleation reaction.
6.5. Influence of grain boundary free volume on dislocation nucleation The extent and distribution of grain boundary free volume may play a significant role in dislocation nucleation. For example, clusters of free volume on boundaries or at triple junctions are on the order of the activation volumes computed in the Section 6.4. In addition, the average free volume assists in correlation of the stress required for dislocation nucleation from 100 and 110 symmetric tilt grain boundaries, as discussed in Section 5.2. However, recall that the interface stress model in Section 5.2 was unable to capture the abrupt drop in the stresses required for dislocation nucleation in symmetric tilt grain boundaries with the E structural unit. This particular structural unit is associated with the 9 (221) STGB and contains a large amount of free volume compared to other 110 symmetric tilt grain boundaries. Bicrystal simulations can provide insight into the relationship between grain boundary structure, grain boundary free volume, and dislocation nucleation from the boundary. Previous studies have shown that both the amount of free volume within the boundary and the spatial correlation of free volume within the boundary are important factors that play a role in dislocation nucleation [153]. A number of symmetric tilt grain boundaries within the misorientation range 109.5◦ < θ < 180◦ were examined in terms of structure and free volume. The structures were generated using the methodology discussed in Section 2. The free volume was visualized and characterized with spatial correlation functions using a stereologically-based methodology, whereby a grid of points was superimposed in three dimensions over the atomic coordinates and each point was tested against a free volume criterion [153]. This methodology enabled Tschopp et al. [153] to show that both the spacing and connectivity of the free volume in the tilt direction increase with increasing misorientation angle over the range 109.5◦ < θ < 180◦ . In fact, for low angle boundaries near the 180◦ perfect single crystal, the free volume is completely connected in the tilt direction. The spatial distribution of free volume relates to dislocation nucleation because the free volume enables the cooperative atomic shuffling that triggers the emission of partial dislocations from the grain boundary. Not only is the spatial distribution important, but the spatial distribution of free volume with respect to intersecting slip planes may also affect dislocation nucleation. For dislocation nucleation to occur from the grain boundary, the cooperative motion of atoms on a {111} slip plane intersecting the grain boundary is required. It is likely that this depends on the spacing and connectivity of free volume along that slip plane. For example, an isolated free volume pocket that intersects the slip plane will only allow local atomic shuffling in the few neighboring atoms. However, a large fraction of grain boundary free volume intersecting the slip plane affects a greater number of atoms along the slip plane, enabling the cooperative atomic shuffling required to nucleate
128
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
dislocations at the boundary. Moreover, for the E structural unit boundaries [153], the two active slip systems (maximum Schmid factor analysis) occur on the same {111} slip plane (coplanar slip), which intersects the boundary along the tilt direction. Thus, the spatial correlation statistics of free volume in the tilt direction are essential to the discussion of dislocation nucleation from boundaries with the E structural unit.
6.6. Continuum field theory The foregoing implications have mainly focused on unit processes of dislocation nucleation over a wide range of grain boundary structures. We may also consider implications for framing higher scale models of inelasticity of polycrystals that might be pertinent to grain boundary engineering. Numerous studies have sought to increase the number density of certain special (CSL) boundaries by processing to assess whether fatigue and fracture resistance can be enhanced (cf. [13,14,47,48]). The assumption of superior characteristics of special boundaries has arguably outpaced fundamental understanding that can be gained by parametric study of mechanisms. Some work has been done using atomistic simulations to advance understanding. For example, Froseth et al. [160] used MD simulations to show that introducing clusters of grains with special boundaries in nanocrystalline materials results in a lower potential for strain accommodation relative to random orientation distributions. Combined with notions of percolation limits for special boundaries (cf. [161, 162]), parametric studies of symmetric and asymmetric special and general boundaries may provide a basis for a statistical approach to grain boundary engineering. This work has also clarified directions for incorporating the structure of grain boundaries into a kinematical framework that extends the original concepts of Bilby and Smith [163] to incorporate lattice distortion in the grain boundary region that accommodates the net incompatibility over the crystal volume. Incorporation of disclinations and/or disconnections related to grain boundary structure into defect field theory can facilitate continuum crystal plasticity models that account for grain boundary structure. In classical crystal plasticity, grain boundaries are treated merely as compatible surfaces, with no manifestation of structure. In advanced continuum theories that invoke the notion of geometrically necessary dislocation density, the effect of grain boundaries is interpreted solely in terms of lattice curvature induced by first-order gradients of deformation, which does not capture the full nature of the kinematics near the boundary. The exchange and interaction of dislocations between the grain boundary and the grain interior requires treatment of grain boundary structure to discern the thermodynamic driving forces and kinetics properly [164]. The methodology we envision is founded upon two major assumptions, the first being a three-term multiplicative decomposition of the average deformation gradient for a volume element of crystalline material (cf. Clayton et al. [165,166]), i.e., F = Fe Fi Fp ,
(20)
FL
with the total lattice deformation written as FL . Here, Fp accounts for the presence of line defects that leave the lattice unperturbed. The Fi term accounts for incompatibility associated with defects that affect lattice arrangement as necessary to achieve compatibility
§6.6
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
129
Fig. 46. Lattice model showing multiple configurations of a crystal volume element containing an edge dislocation.
with Fp , the deformation gradient associated with dislocations. Fig. 46 shows how the lattice incompatibility associated with Fp is accommodated by Fi within the crystalline volume element, with the elastic deformation gradient Fe representing both the recoverable lattice stretch associated with the average applied stress (long-range) acting on the element and rigid-body rotations of the lattice. Compatibility is approached at the crystal level by considering covariant differentiation of the lattice directors in the current (deformed) configuration. At the microscopic level, spatial changes in the director vectors da attached to the lattice are described by parallel transport of the directors with respect to a linear connection. The absolute change of the director vector field in the current configuration is found in terms of the covariant derivative ˆ i.e. ∇, ..c ∇ˆ b da = da,b − ˆ ba dc ,
(21)
with the subscripted comma hereafter denoting partial coordinate differentiation with respect to current coordinates x. The Christoffel symbols of the connection are defined as [167,168] L−1α¯ ..a ..a ¯ ..a ˆ cb ≡ F.La + Q..a α¯ F.b,c cb = cb + Qcb ,
(22)
..a ≡ F La F L−1α¯ = −F La F L−1α¯ are coefficients of the crystal connection of where ¯ cb .α¯ .α,c ¯ .b,c .b non-Riemannian dislocation theories [169–173], and Q..a cb are micromorphic degrees-offreedom representing contributions of spatial gradients of the lattice director field that are not incorporated in the term involving the first gradient of FL ; such gradients arise substantially from disclinations, for example. Upon assuming that ∇ˆ b da = 0 [168], the connection (eq. (22)) allows one to interpolate for the directions and magnitudes of the lattice directors between centroids of neighboring crystal volume elements. For example, in the trivial situ..a = 0, the lattice directors are spatially constant. The crystal connection () ¯ ation when ˆ cb component of eq. (22) accounts for effects of first-order spatial gradients of (the inverse of) FL , while the micromorphic variable Q of eq. (22) accounts for additional spatial variation of lattice director vectors that is not captured by the first gradient of FL . The average continuum deformation of the director vectors located at the volume element’s centroid is determined by FL , i.e., da = (F L−1 )α.a gα , where gα are basis vectors in the current configuration. The director vector motion mapped from the intermediate configuration to the current configuration is given by χ = Fe Fi 1˜ = FL 1˜ ⇒ dα = χDα , with χ T χ = 1; here, β the director triad on the reference configuration is an anholonomic basis Da = Da Gβ , with holonomic basis vectors, GA , on the reference configuration. The dual lattice vectors Dα , da are defined by the relations Da · Db = da · db = δba .
130
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
...a formed from the The components of the Riemann–Christoffel curvature tensor Rˆ bcd ..a are found using connection coefficients ˆ cb ...a ..a ..a ..a ˆ ..e ..a ˆ ..e Rˆ bcd ≡ ˆ db,c − ˆ cb,d + ˆ ce db − ˆ de cb ,
(23)
..a = ¯ ..a + Q..a , we are able to rewrite as [174] which, because ˆ cb cb cb ...a ...a ..a ..e ..a ..e ˆ ..e ..a Rˆ bcd = R¯ bcd +2∇ˆ [c Q..a d]b + Qce Qdb − Qde Qcb + Tcd Qeb ,
(24)
=0
...a , vanishes identically as shown, since where the curvature from the crystal connection, R¯ bcd ¯ is integrable. We can then express the fully covariant rendition of the curvature tensor L R ˆ ...f as [167] Rˆ abcd ≡ Caf bcd ..e Qe[ba] , Rˆ [ab]cd = 2∇ˆ [c Qd][ba] + Tˆcd
..e Rˆ (ab)cd = 2∇ˆ [c Qd](ab) + Tˆcd Qe(ab) .
(25) ˆ vanishes completely when Q = 0. The connection coeffiWe see from eq. (25) that R ..a cients ˆ cb are given by eq. (22), with the covariant components of Q assigned the following anti-symmetry property [167,168]: L Qcba ≡ Q..d cb Cda = −Qcab = Qc[ba] .
(26)
The microrotation kinematic variable Q describes spatial gradients of lattice rotation within the crystalline volume element arising from higher order gradients of net dislocation density and distributed partial disclinations. This includes the effect of partial disclination dipoles and additional boundary dislocations introduced in the disconnection characterization of Hirth et al. [69]. In the current configuration, consider a Burgers circuit c enclosing area a comprised of oriented differential elements n da. A total Burgers vector accounting for incompatibility induced by the torsion and curvature tensors may be written as [167, 175,176], ..a 1 ...a e Tˆbc − Rˆ ecb x nd da = BTa + BRa , B a ≡ ε dbc (27) 2 a ..a nd da describes the closure failure of c and 2BRa ≡ where 2BTa ≡ εdbc a Tˆbc ...a bdc e e ˆ ε a Recb x nd da measures the change in direction of position vector x upon paralˆ Eq. (27) reduces to the usual form lel transport about c with respect to the connection . a based on net dislocation density (BT only) when disclinations are absent and higher-order ..a = T¯ ..a , Q..a = 0, spatial gradients of lattice director vectors are neglected (i.e., when Tˆbc bc bc ...a = 0). and Rˆ bcc To this point we have not associated the second term involving Q..a cb in eq. (22) solely with disclinations. We may further specialize and simplify the theory by making this assertion and neglecting higher-order contributions of gradients of FL as an approximation, as done by Clayton et al. [165]. We can then re-write eq. (27) in terms of the second rank geometrically necessary dislocation tensor α (Nye tensor) and second rank geometrically
§6.6
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
necessary disclination tensor θ , each referred to the spatial configuration, i.e., ad Ba = α + C L−1af εfgb θ gd x b nd da,
131
(28)
a
where ..a 2α ad ≡ ε dbc Tˆbc ,
4θ gd ≡ ε gba ε dce Rˆ abce .
(29)
ˆ Defect density tensors α and θ contain information enabling us to fully reconstruct T ˆ and R, respectively, because of the skew-symmetric properties of these quantities: ..a ..a = Tˆ[cb] = εcbd α ad , Tˆcb
Rˆ abcd = Rˆ [ab][cd] = εbae εcdf θ ef .
(30)
The geometrically necessary defect density tensors of eq. (29) are related to the summed contributions of discrete crystal defects over a given crystal volume as ρ j bj ⊗ ξ j , θ = ηk ωk ⊗ ζ k , α= (31) j
k
with ρ j , bj , and ξ j the net scalar dislocation line density, Burgers vector, and unit tangent line, respectively, for dislocation population j , and with ηk , ωk , and ζ k the net scalar disclination line density, Frank vector, and unit tangent line, respectively, for disclination population k. All quantities in eq. (31) refer to the current (spatial) configuration B. Notice that α and θ do not account for curved defect segments and combinations of defect lines that do not contribute to a net Burgers vector (e.g., dislocation loops enclosed by a Burgers circuit). We use the qualifiers “net,” “geometrically necessary,” and “non-redundant” interchangeably to describe defect densities that contribute to incompatibility. It is perhaps instructive to consider linearized compatibility equations for the net defect density tensors of eq. (31) that follow from identities of Bianchi and Schouten (cf. [174]), expressed in Cartesian coordinates as .b ..a ...a ...a ab = Rˆ [bcd] → C L α a,b = εabc θ bc , Rˆ b[cd,e] = 0 → θ,b = 0. Tˆ[bc,d] (32) In a small-strain formulation that employs additive elastoplastic strains and rotation gradients, De Wit [177] inferred from equations analogous to eq. (32) that disclinations may act as sources/sinks for dislocations, and that disclination lines cannot end abruptly within a crystal. Also, when disclinations are absent, the first of eq. (32) depicts a divergence-free dislocation density tensor, meaning that dislocations cannot start or end within the crystal. This linearization, while physically illustrative, is not essential in our general finite strain and rotation framework, nor do its implications necessarily carry over. The second major assumption in our kinematic framework is an additive decomposition of a linear connection describing spatial gradients of the slip directions and lattice director vectors between neighboring crystalline elements (i.e., the microscopic description). Christoffel symbols of this connection, introduced formally in eq. (22), may be written as L−1α¯ ..a L−1ad = F.La Qc[bd] , ˆ cb α¯ F.b,c + C crystal connection (GNDs)
microrotation (disclinations)
(33)
132
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
where the first term on the right side describes gradients of the director vectors due to firstorder gradients in the average lattice deformation tensor FL , following Bilby et al. [169]. The micromorphic variable Q (cf. [167,177]) appears in the second term on the right of eq. (33) and, neglecting contribution of higher order gradients of FL (to Q), represents microrotation associated with disclinations. The reader is referred to Clayton et al. [165] for a more complete discussion of the implications of foregoing discussion of net dislocation and disclination defect densities over a given scale of Burgers circuit in terms of the differential geometric interpretation. Moreover, Clayton et al. [165] discuss general Somigliana dislocations [70] that can be used to characterize the displacement discontinuities attributed to most defects, including translational (dislocations), rotational (disclinations) of Volterra [61], point defects [178, 179], and interface incompatibility in multi-phase composites [180] with additional terms in eq. (33). At issue here is how to incorporate grain boundary structure into the preceding kinematic formalism for Burgers circuits that cross boundaries. The appropriate description depends on the scale of the crystal volume concerned. For Burgers circuits with size much greater than the periodic length of favored boundary structural units and disclination dipoles that comprise general boundaries, the partial dislocation content of the boundary can be lumped into a contribution to microrotation analogous to the second term in eq. (33), as is common practice in the macroscopic theory of grain boundaries based only on the dislocation description. However, at fine scales this decomposition of the crystal connection in eq. (22) becomes important since dislocations that contribute to the net dislocation density tensor of Nye [181] are associated with Fp , and the crystal connection expresses the jump of orientation of the lattice across the boundary, FL , should incorporate the incompatible distortion of the lattice due both to the partial dislocation content (or net Frank vector) of favored boundary structural units in eq. (31.1) as well as disclination dipoles in eq. (31.2). This may be accomplished by assigning the former to Fp (α) which depends on net dislocation density, and the latter to a component of F˜ i (θ ) which incorporates the net disclination content, with an additional component F˜˜ i that can be assessed to ensure local compatibility of the relation Fi Fp , assuming compatible Fe associated with the long-range elastic deformation field, i.e., F = Fe F˜˜ i F˜ i (θ ) Fp (α).
(34)
FL
This additional component F˜˜ i of course reflects the contributions of the higher order spatial gradients of lattice curvature alluded to previously. Of course, the components of this decomposition evolve during dislocation nucleation, absorption, or desorption (kinetics). The problem of elucidating the F˜˜ i F˜ i (θ )Fp (α) decomposition belongs to nanomechanics (e.g., atomistic modeling) owing to the nonlinear finite elasticity of the dislocation/disclination core regions. Both the boundary energy as well as the kinetics of dislocations can be explored. It is a fruitful area of future research.
§7
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
133
7. Concluding remarks This work has demonstrated how atomistic simulations can advance fundamental understanding of the structure and inelastic behavior (nucleation of dislocations) of symmetric and asymmetric tilt grain boundaries in fcc metals. Major findings include: • The calculated interface energies for 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries agree with experimentally measured grain boundary energies and are predicted based on an ideal faceting into the 3 (111) and 3 (112) symmetric tilt grain boundaries [79]. The minimum energy structures for Cu correspond well with HRTEM images of the 9R phase in other low stacking fault energy FCC metals. Also, the asymmetric tilt grain boundary structures ideally facet into the structural units of the two 3 symmetric tilt boundaries with a well-defined ordering of structural units and their faceting [79,130]. A thorough appreciation for the structure of asymmetric tilt grain boundaries can improve understanding of the relationship between dislocation nucleation strength and grain boundary structure. • Aside from the symmetric tilt 3 (111) boundary, no increase in tensile strength is observed at boundaries with low-order CSL character. Increased tensile strength at the coherent 3 (111) boundary can be attributed to the homogeneous nucleation of dislocations within each lattice, rather than heterogeneous nucleation from the grain boundary. For all other models, failure in uniaxial tension occurs by way of dislocation nucleation from the bicrystal interface. The dislocation nucleation event may be accompanied by structural rearrangement prior to emission (such as the evolution of short stacking fault facets) that locally improves the coherency of the interface. • MD simulations indicate that the orientation of the opposing lattice regions relative to the applied stress and the presence of certain structural units are two significant features of the interface geometry/structure that affect the tensile interface strength. Specifically, boundaries that contain the E structural unit nucleate dislocations at low applied tensile stresses. Based on the MD simulation results, a first-order model for tensile interface strength is developed which is capable of capturing the dependence of interface misorientation for many tilt boundaries [18]. Non-Schmid effects are critical when formulating a model for homogeneous [73] and heterogeneous dislocation nucleation. Specifically, the stress normal to the slip plane is found to play a significant role in dislocation nucleation for boundaries with the 100 misorientation axis. Furthermore, accounting for interfacial free volume through an average measure based on coordination number [152] is sufficient to model the tensile strength of boundaries with the 100 tilt axis and many boundaries with the 110 tilt axis. However, for 110 boundaries that contain the E structural unit, it is likely that a higher-order model must be invoked that include the effect of gradients of free volume or more detailed information concerning the relationship between structural unit configuration and slip system orientation. For example, the spacing and connectivity of free volume pockets within the boundary and their distribution along a {111} slip plane with a high resolved shear stress in the slip direction may impact the relative ease of the thermally activated dislocation nucleation event [153]. • The wide range of symmetric and asymmetric tilt grain boundaries investigated here provides insight into dislocation nucleation mechanisms and how they might impact inelastic deformation processes in higher scale nanocrystalline models. Of course, there
134
M.A. Tschopp et al.
Ch. 82
is the caveat that the energy minimized structures of this study are applicable to (near) equilibrium structures as might be obtained via electrodeposition, rather than via extensive deformation processing. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries in Al show that a ledge forms after emission of a full dislocation from a planar 100 boundary [16]. Symmetric tilt grain boundaries with dissociated structure show that the spacing between dissociated partial dislocations plays an important role in dislocation nucleation [17]. The dislocation nucleation mechanisms of 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries are greatly affected by the faceted and dissociated boundary structure [19], despite having the same misorientation angle and low-order CSL content. The dislocation organization and character may also impact dislocation nucleation. Grain boundary dislocation sources behave differently; the nucleated dislocations in some high-angle boundaries merely result in a decrease of the Burgers vector content of the boundary equal to the Burgers vector of the emitted dislocations. However, as shown for a 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundary, stress concentrations near the facet intersections for some boundaries may help activate lattice dislocation sources that nucleate dislocation loops near the boundary. The absorption of part of the dislocation loop into the boundary yields an increase in the Burgers vector content of the boundary. Additionally, dislocation sources can lie within the interface as shown for the dissociated symmetric tilt grain boundaries. • Differences in the resolved normal stress to the plane of dislocation nucleation between uniaxial tension and compression leads to a tension–compression asymmetry of dislocation nucleation [141]. For single crystals, the stress required to homogeneously nucleate dislocations has a strong dependence on loading orientation in both uniaxial tension and compression. Some orientations require a higher stress in compression than in tension (e.g., [110] and [111]), while other orientations require a higher stress in tension ([100]). In addition to the normal stress affecting the magnitude of the stresses involved in dislocation nucleation, it also affects the emission of the trailing partial dislocation. In uniaxial tension for Cu single crystals and grain boundaries, no trailing partial dislocation is observed, as expected. However, in compression, the trailing partial dislocation is observed in both Cu single crystals and grain boundaries, despite the low stacking fault energy γSF and ratio γSF /γUSF . This indicates that the resolved normal stress plays an important role in the emission of the trailing partial dislocation. • The activation energies and activation volumes for dislocation nucleation from 3 asymmetric tilt grain boundaries were calculated from a first-order model of stress-dependent activation energy. The athermal activation energies are on the order of 0.8–2.4 eV, the activation energies at 300 K are approximately 0.24–0.28 eV, and the activation volumes are on the order of 0.5–3 b3 in both Cu and Al. The small activation volumes suggest that the nucleation of dislocations from the boundaries is associated with the cooperative motion of a small group of atoms within the boundary. • The initial and distorted (post dislocation nucleation) structures of grain boundaries are discussed in terms of partial dislocations, disclination dipoles and disconnections. Symmetric tilt boundaries which obey the structural unit model can be represented as a series of repeating structural units associated with favored boundaries connected by disclination dipoles. Disconnections may also be incorporated into the description of the interface geometry if steps or ledges exist within the interface plane. More importantly, MD simulations in this work provide direct observation of the offset step that appears at the
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals
135
interface after nucleation of full dislocations in Al [16]. The geometry of the offset step may be described using disconnections, or equivalently as a series of disclination dipoles and grain boundary dislocations, in agreement with Hirth et al. [69]. Furthermore, this work identifies additional mechanisms by which a disconnection at the interface may be removed [17]. • The relation of the grain boundary structure to continuum field theory representations of dislocations and disclinations has been discussed in terms of a generalization of the decomposition of the deformation gradient that addresses both geometrically necessary dislocations and microrotations captured by disclinations originally proposed by Clayton et al. [165], and some preliminary ideas have been advanced for addressing grain boundary structure through nanomechanical boundary value problems of the BilbySmith type [163].
Acknowledgements The authors would like to thank Professor J.P. Hirth for the invitation to contribute to the Dislocations in Solids series. This work was supported in part by a National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship (M.A.T.), by the NASA Langley Research Center under grant NAG-1-02054 (D.E.S.) and by the National Center for Supercomputing Applications under contract DMR060019N (utilizing Cobalt). D.L.M. is grateful for the additional support of this work by the Carter N. Paden Jr., Distinguished Chair in Metals Processing.
References [1] G.B. Olson, Science 288 (2000) 993. [2] C.S. Smith, A Search for Structure: Selected Essays on Science, Art and History, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, 1981. [3] A.S. Khan, S. Huang, Continuum Theory of Plasticity, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1995. [4] E.O. Hall, Proc. R. Soc. London B 64 (1951) 747. [5] N.J. Petch, J. Iron Steel Ind. 174 (1953) 25. [6] Y.M. Wang, A.V. Hamza, E. Ma, Appl. Phys. Lett. 86 (2005) 241917. [7] Y.M. Wang, A.V. Hamza, E. Ma, Acta Mater. 54 (2006) 2715. [8] Y. Zhou, U. Erb, K.T. Aust, G. Palumbo, Scripta Mater. 48 (2003) 825. [9] J. Schiotz, F.D. Di Tolla, K.W. Jacobsen, Nature 391 (1998) 561. [10] J. Schiotz, T. Vegge, F.D. Di Tolla, K.W. Jacobsen, Phys. Rev. B 60 (1999) 11971. [11] J. Schiotz, K.W. Jacobsen, Science 301 (2003) 1357. [12] J. Schiotz, Scripta Mater. 51 (2004) 837. [13] V. Randle, The Role of the Coincidence Site Lattice in Grain Boundary Engineering, Institute of Materials, Maney Publishing, London, 1997. [14] C.A. Schuh, M. Kumar, W.E. King, Acta Mater. 51 (2003) 687. [15] J.P. Hirth, J. Lothe, Theory of Dislocations, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1982. [16] D.E. Spearot, K.I. Jacob, D.L. McDowell, Acta Mater. 53 (2005) 3579. [17] D.E. Spearot, K.I. Jacob, D.L. McDowell, Int. J. Plast. 23 (2007) 143. [18] D.E. Spearot, M.A. Tschopp, K.I. Jacob, D.L. McDowell, Acta Mater. 55 (2007) 705. [19] M.A. Tschopp, D.L. McDowell, Int. J. Plast. 24 (2008) 191.
136 [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70]
M.A. Tschopp et al. V. Yamakov, D. Wolf, M. Salazar, S.R. Phillpot, H. Gleiter, Acta Mater. 49 (2001) 2713. V. Yamakov, D. Wolf, S.R. Phillpot, H. Gleiter, Acta Mater. 50 (2002) 5005. V. Yamakov, D. Wolf, S.R. Phillpot, A.K. Mukherjee, H. Gleiter, Nat. Mater. 1 (2002) 45. V. Yamakov, D. Wolf, S.R. Phillpot, H. Gleiter, Acta Mater. 51 (2003) 4135. H. Van Swygenhoven, M. Spaczer, A. Caro, Acta Mater. 47 (1999) 3117. H. Van Swygenhoven, M. Spaczer, A. Caro, D. Farkas, Phys. Rev. B 60 (1999) 22. H. Van Swygenhoven, P.A. Derlet, Phys. Rev. B 64 (2001). H. Van Swygenhoven, A. Caro, D. Farkas, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 309–310 (2001) 440. H. Van Swygenhoven, Science 296 (2002) 66. H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, A. Hasnaoui, Phys. Rev. B 66 (2002). P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Scripta Mater. 47 (2002) 719. P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, A. Hasnaoui, Philos. Mag. 83 (2003) 3569. H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, A.G. Froseth, Nat. Mater. 3 (2004) 399. A. Froseth, H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, Acta Mater. 52 (2004) 2259. A.G. Froseth, P.M. Derlet, H. Van Swygenhoven, Acta Mater. 52 (2004) 5863. H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, A.G. Froseth, Acta Mater. 54 (2006) 1975. H. Van Swygenhoven, J.R. Weertman, Mater. Today 9 (2006) 24. T. Shimokawa, A. Nakatani, H. Kitagawa, Phys. Rev. B 71 (2005). F. Sansoz, J.F. Molinari, Scripta Mater. 50 (2004) 1283. F. Sansoz, J.F. Molinari, Acta Mater. 53 (2005) 1931. D.H. Warner, F. Sansoz, J.F. Molinari, Int. J. Plast. 22 (2006) 754. J.W. Cahn, Y. Mishin, A. Suzuki, Acta Mater. 54 (2006) 4953. H. Zhang, M.I. Mendelev, D.J. Srolovitz, Scripta Mater. 52 (2005) 1193. N. Chandra, Mater. Sci. Forum 304–306 (1999) 411. N. Chandra, P. Dang, J. Mater. Sci. 34 (1999) 655. S. Namilae, N. Chandra, T.G. Nieh, Scripta Mater. 46 (2002) 49. V. Yamakov, D. Wolf, S.R. Phillpot, H. Gleiter, Acta Mater. 50 (2002) 61. T. Watanabe, Res. Mech. 11 (1984) 47. T. Watanabe, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 176 (1994) 39. V.Y. Gertsman, K. Tangri, Acta Metall. Mater. 43 (1995) 2317. J.M. Howe, Interfaces in Materials: Atomic Structure, Thermodynamic and Kinetics of Solid–Vapor, Solid– Liquid and Solid–Solid Interfaces, Wiley, New York, 1997. V. Randle, The Measurement of Grain Boundary Geometry, Institute of Physics Publishing, Bristol, 1993. J.D. Rittner, D.N. Seidman, Phys. Rev. B 54 (1996) 6999. J.D. Rittner, D.N. Seidman, Mater. Sci. Forum 207–209 (1996) 333. W.T. Read, W. Shockley, Phys. Rev. 78 (1950) 275. A.P. Sutton, V. Vitek, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A 309 (1983) 1. A.P. Sutton, V. Vitek, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A 309 (1983) 37. A.P. Sutton, V. Vitek, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A 309 (1983) 55. G.J. Wang, A.P. Sutton, V. Vitek, Acta Metall. 32 (1984) 1093. A.P. Sutton, R.W. Balluffi, Philos. Mag. Lett. 61 (1990) 91. J.D. Rittner, D.N. Seidman, K.L. Merkle, Phys. Rev. B 53 (1996) 4241. V. Volterra, Ann. Ecole Norm. Super. 24 (1907) 401. J.C.M. Li, Surf. Sci. 31 (1972) 12. K.K. Shih, J.C.M. Li, Surf. Sci. 50 (1975) 109. A.E. Romanov, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 164 (1993) 58. D.V. Bachurin, R.T. Murzaev, A.A. Nazarov, Fiz. Met. Metalloved. 96 (2003) 11. V.Y. Gertsman, A.A. Nazarov, A.E. Romanov, R.Z. Valiev, V.I. Vladimirov, Philos. Mag. A 59 (1989) 1113. A.A. Nazarov, O.A. Shenderova, D.W. Brenner, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 281 (2000) 148. R.Z. Valiev, V.I. Vladimirov, V.Y. Gertsman, A.A. Nazarov, A.E. Romanov, Phys. Met. Metallography 69 (1990) 30. J.P. Hirth, R.C. Pond, J. Lothe, Acta Mater. 54 (2006) 4237. C. Somigliana, Rend. CI. Sci. Fis. Mat. Nat. 23 (1914) 463.
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78] [79] [80] [81] [82] [83] [84] [85] [86] [87] [88] [89] [90] [91] [92] [93] [94] [95] [96] [97] [98] [99] [100] [101] [102] [103] [104] [105] [106] [107] [108] [109] [110] [111] [112] [113] [114] [115] [116] [117] [118]
137
G. Xu, A.S. Argon, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 319–321 (2001) 144. S. Ogata, J. Li, S. Yip, Science 298 (2002) 807. M.A. Tschopp, D.E. Spearot, D.L. McDowell, Modell. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 15 (2007) 693. T. Zhu, J. Li, K.J. Van Vliet, S. Ogata, S. Yip, S. Suresh, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 52 (2004) 691. M.P. Allen, D.J. Tildesley, Computer Simulations of Liquids, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1987. J.M. Haile, Molecular Dynamics Simulation: Elementary Methods, Wiley, New York, 1992. J.R. Shewchuk, http://www-2.cs.cmu.edu/~jrs/jrspapers.html#cg, 1994. D. Wolf, Acta Metall. 38 (1990) 781. M.A. Tschopp, D.L. McDowell, Philos. Mag. 87 (2007) 3147. D.L. Medlin, M.J. Mills, W.M. Stobbs, M.S. Daw, F. Cosandey, Mater. Res. Soc. Sympos. Proc. 295 (1993) 91. J.M. Penisson, U. Dahmen, M.J. Mills, Philos. Mag. Lett. 64 (1991) 277. U. Wolf, F. Ernst, T. Muschik, M.W. Finnis, H.F. Fischmeister, Philos. Mag. A 66 (1992) 991. F. Ernst, M.W. Finnis, A. Koch, C. Schmidt, B. Straumal, W. Gust, Z. Metallkd. 87 (1996) 911. F. Ernst, M.W. Finnis, D. Hofmann, T. Muschik, U. Schonberger, U. Wolf, M. Methfessel, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69 (1992) 620. D. Hofmann, M.W. Finnis, Acta Metall. Mater. 42 (1994) 3555. H.C. Andersen, J. Chem. Phys. 72 (1980) 2384. S. Melchionna, G. Ciccotti, B.L. Holian, Mol. Phys. 78 (1993) 533. W.G. Hoover, Phys. Rev. A 31 (1985) 1695. S. Nose, Mol. Phys. 52 (1984) 255. K.S. Cheung, S. Yip, J. Appl. Phys. 70 (1991) 5688. J. Cormier, J.M. Rickman, T.J. Delph, J. Appl. Phys. 89 (2001) 99. J.F. Lutsko, J. Appl. Phys. 64 (1988) 1152. D.H. Tsai, J. Chem. Phys. 70 (1979) 1375. M. Zhou, Proc. R. Soc. London A 459 (2003) 2347. J.A. Zimmerman, E.B. Webb III, J.J. Hoyt, R.E. Jones, P.A. Klein, D.J. Bammann, Modell. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 12 (2004) S319. M.S. Daw, M.I. Baskes, Phys. Rev. Lett. 50 (1983) 1285. M.S. Daw, M.I. Baskes, Phys. Rev. B 29 (1984) 6443. M.S. Daw, Phys. Rev. B 39 (1989) 7441. Y. Mishin, D. Farkas, M.J. Mehl, D.A. Papaconstantopoulos, Phys. Rev. B 59 (1999) 3393. Y. Mishin, M.J. Mehl, D.A. Papaconstantopoulos, A.F. Voter, J.D. Kress, Phys. Rev. B 63 (2001) 224106. J.R. Rice, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 40 (1992) 239. R.D. Boyer, J. Li, S. Ogata, S. Yip, Modell. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 12 (2004) 1017. J.A. Zimmerman, H. Gao, F.F. Abraham, Modell. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 8 (2000) 103. J.A. Hurtado, B.R. Elliott, H.M. Shodja, D.V. Gorelikov, C.E. Campbell, H.E. Lippard, T.C. Isabell, J. Weertman, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 190 (1995) 1. L.E. Shilkrot, W.A. Curtin, R.E. Miller, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 50 (2002) 2085. L.E. Shilkrot, R.E. Miller, W.A. Curtin, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 52 (2004) 755. R. Miller, M. Ortiz, R. Phillips, V. Shenoy, E.B. Tadmor, Eng. Fract. Mech. 61 (1998) 427. R. Miller, E.B. Tadmor, R. Phillips, M. Ortiz, Modell. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 6 (1998) 607. D.E. Spearot, Atomistic Calculations of Nanoscale Interface Behavior in FCC Metals, Ph.D. dissertation, Georgia Institute of Technology, 2005. V. Tomar, M. Zhou, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 55 (2007) 1053. P. Muller, A. Saul, Surf. Sci. Rep. 54 (2004) 157. P. Nozieres, D.E. Wolf, Z. Phys. B 70 (1988) 399. D.E. Wolf, P. Nozieres, Z. Phys. B 70 (1988) 507. P. Grigoriadis, T. Karakostas, P. Komninou, V. Pontikis, Mater. Sci. Forum 294–296 (1999) 177. C.L. Kelchner, S.J. Plimpton, J.C. Hamilton, Phys. Rev. B 58 (1998) 11085. M.J. Mills, M.S. Daw, G.J. Thomas, F. Cosandey, Ultramicroscopy 40 (1992) 247. G.S. Rohrer, D.M. Saylor, B. El Dasher, B.L. Adams, A.D. Rollett, P. Wynblatt, Z. Metallkd. 95 (2004) 197. C.S. Kim, Y. Hu, G.S. Rohrer, V. Randle, Scripta Mater. 52 (2005) 633.
138
M.A. Tschopp et al.
[119] K. Barmak, J. Kim, C.S. Kim, W.E. Archibald, G.S. Rohrer, A.D. Rollett, D. Kinderlehrer, S. Ta’asan, H. Zhang, D.J. Srolovitz, Scripta Mater. 54 (2006) 1059. [120] D.M. Saylor, B. El Dasher, T. Sano, G.S. Rohrer, J. Am. Ceram. Soc. 87 (2004) 670. [121] D.M. Saylor, B.S. El Dasher, A.D. Rollett, G.S. Rohrer, Acta Mater. 52 (2004) 3649. [122] D.M. Saylor, A. Morawiec, G.S. Rohrer, Acta Mater. 51 (2003) 3663. [123] C. Minkwitz, C. Herzig, E. Rabkin, W. Gust, Acta Mater. 47 (1999) 1231. [124] H. Miyamoto, K. Ikeuchi, T. Mimaki, Scripta Mater. 50 (2004) 1417. [125] C. Schmidt, M.W. Finnis, F. Ernst, V. Vitek, Philos. Mag. A 77 (1998) 1161. [126] T. Muschik, W. Laub, U. Wolf, M.W. Finnis, W. Gust, Acta Metall. Mater. 41 (1993) 2163. [127] M.A. Tschopp, D.L. McDowell, Philos. Mag. 87 (2007) 3871. [128] U. Wolf, P. Gumbsch, H. Ichinose, H.F. Fischmeister, J. Phys. (Paris), Colloque C 1 (1990) 359. [129] D.L. Medlin, G.H. Campbell, C.R. Carter, Acta Mater. 46 (1998) 5135. [130] M.A. Tschopp, D.L. McDowell, J. Mater. Sci. 42 (2007) 7806. [131] M.L. Kronberg, F.H. Wilson, Am. Inst. Min. Metall. Eng. J. Met. 1 (1949) 501. [132] A.P. Sutton, Acta Metall. 36 (1988) 1291. [133] A.P. Sutton, Interfaces in Crystalline Materials, Clarendon Press, Oxford, 1995. [134] J.-M. Zhang, F. Ma, K.-W. Xu, Appl. Surf. Sci. 229 (2004) 34. [135] J.A. Zimmerman, C.L. Kelchner, P.A. Klein, J.C. Hamilton, S.M. Foiles, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87 (2001) 165507. [136] T.S. Byun, Acta Mater. 51 (2003) 3063. [137] M.I. Baskes, R.G. Hoagland, T. Tsuji, Modell. Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 6 (1998) 9. [138] W.F. Hosford, The Mechanics of Crystals and Textured Polycrystals, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1993. [139] T. Zhu, J. Li, A. Samanta, H.G. Kim, S. Suresh, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. 104 (2007) 3031. [140] C. Schuh, J.K. Mason, A.C. Lund, Nat. Mater. 4 (2005) 617. [141] M.A. Tschopp, D.L. McDowell, Appl. Phys. Lett. 90 (2007) 121916. [142] C.R. Krenn, D. Roundy, M.L. Cohen, D.C. Chrzan, J.W. Morris, Phys. Rev. B 65 (2002) 134111. [143] C.R. Krenn, D. Roundy, J.W. Morris Jr., M.L. Cohen, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 317 (2001) 44. [144] D. Roundy, C.R. Krenn, M.L. Cohen, J.W. Morris Jr., Phys. Rev. Lett. 82 (1999) 2713. [145] P. Steinmann, E. Kuhl, E. Stein, Int. J. Solids Struct. 35 (1998) 4437. [146] J.K. Diao, K. Gall, M.L. Dunn, Nano Lett. 4 (2004) 2431. [147] V. Tomar, M. Zhou, Appl. Phys. Lett. 88 (2006). [148] A.C. Lund, T.G. Nieh, C.A. Schuh, Phys. Rev. B 69 (2004). [149] A.C. Lund, C.A. Schuh, Acta Mater. 53 (2005) 3193. [150] A.C. Lund, C.A. Schuh, Acta Mater. 51 (2003) 5399. [151] S. Cheng, J.A. Spencer, W.W. Milligan, Acta Mater. 51 (2003) 4505. [152] D.E. Spearot, K.I. Jacob, D.L. McDowell, Mech. Mater. 36 (2004) 825. [153] M.A. Tschopp, G.J. Tucker, D.L. McDowell, Acta Mater. 55 (2007) 3959. [154] V. Yamakov, D. Wolf, S.R. Phillpot, A.K. Mukherjee, H. Gleiter, Nat. Mater. 3 (2004) 43. [155] R.J. Asaro, S. Suresh, Acta Mater. 53 (2005) 3369. [156] T. Zhu, J. Li, A. Samanta, A. Leach, K. Gall, Phys. Rev. Lett. 100 (2008) 025502. [157] Y.M. Wang, E. Ma, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 375–377 (2004) 46. [158] L. Lu, R. Schwaiger, Z.W. Shan, M. Dao, K. Lu, S. Suresh, Acta Mater. 53 (2005) 2169. [159] H. Conrad, K. Jung, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 391 (2005) 272. [160] A.G. Froseth, H. Van Swygenhoven, P.M. Derlet, Acta Mater. 53 (2005) 4847. [161] M. Frary, C.A. Schuh, Phys. Rev. B 69 (2004) 134115. [162] C.A. Schuh, R.W. Minich, M. Kumar, Philos. Mag. 83 (2003) 711. [163] B.A. Bilby, E. Smith, Proc. R. Soc. London A 236 (1956) 481. [164] L.P. Evers, D.M. Parks, W.A.M. Brekelmans, M.G.D. Geers, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 50 (2002) 2403–2424. [165] J.D. Clayton, D.J. Bammann, D.L. McDowell, Philos. Mag. 85 (2005) 3983. [166] J.D. Clayton, D.L. McDowell, Int. J. Plast. 19 (2003) 1401. [167] S. Minagawa, Arch. Mech. 31 (1979) 783. [168] S. Minagawa, Int. J. Eng. Sci. 19 (1981) 1705. [169] B.A. Bilby, R. Bullough, E. Smith, Proc. R. Soc. London A 231 (1955) 263. [170] K.C. Le, H. Stumpf, Int. J. Eng. Sci. 34 (1996) 339.
Influence of Grain Boundary Structure on Dislocation Nucleation in FCC Metals [171] [172] [173] [174] [175] [176] [177] [178] [179] [180] [181]
K.C. Le, H. Stumpf, Proc. R. Soc. London A 452 (1996) 359. W. Noll, Arch. Rat. Mech. Anal. 27 (1967) 1. P. Steinmann, Int. J. Eng. Sci. 34 (1996) 1717. J.A. Schouten, Ricci Calculus, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1954. K. Kondo, Int. J. Eng. Sci. 2 (1964) 219. R.W. Lardner, Arch. Mech. 25 (1973) 911. R. De Wit, Int. J. Eng. Sci. 19 (1981) 1475. J.D. Eshelby, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A 244 (1951) 87. J.D. Eshelby, in: F. Séitz, D. Turnbull (Eds.), Solid State Physics, Academic Press, 1956, p. 79. R.J. Asaro, Int. J. Eng. Sci. 13 (1975) 271. J.F. Nye, Acta Metall. 1 (1953) 153.
139
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 83
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids MICHAEL J. DEMKOWICZ, JIAN WANG, AND RICHARD G. HOAGLAND Materials Science and Technology Division, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87545, USA
© 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved 1572-4859, DOI: 10.1016/S1572-4859(07)00003-4
Dislocations in Solids Edited by J. P. Hirth
Contents 1. Introduction 143 2. Coherent and semicoherent interfaces in fcc/fcc bilayers 146 3. Incoherent interfaces in fcc/bcc bilayers 152 3.1. Interfaces in Cu/Nb multilayer composites 152 3.2. Interface structure: KS1 and KS2 154 3.3. Interface dislocations in KS1 161 3.4. Analytical interpretation of KS1 dislocation content 166 3.5. Interface dislocations in KS2 170 4. Vacancies and interstitials in Cu/Nb interfaces 175 4.1. Interface behavior upon atom insertion or removal 175 4.2. Interaction with interface dislocations 183 4.3. KSmin 188 5. Dislocation interaction with Cu/Nb interfaces 193 5.1. Shear strength 193 5.2. Sliding mechanism 196 5.3. Core spreading of lattice glide dislocations 199 6. Summary 203 Acknowledgements 204 References 204
1. Introduction Interfaces in heterophase and homophase crystalline solids have enormous technological importance, beneficial in some cases and detrimental in others. Precipitates derived from invariant reactions that strengthen materials, the organized combination of two or more different materials to form composites, the processing of high carbon cast iron to encourage large graphite flakes are examples of beneficial exploitation of interfaces. On the other hand, inclusions and impurities involve interfaces that impart undesirable properties, such as brittleness, poor corrosion resistance, and undesirable electrical conductivity. As a general rule, even though they often constitute only a tiny volume fraction of the material, interfaces are as important to behavior as are the much more voluminous constituents/phases on either side of the interface. Weak interfaces may be sources of cracks and sinks for impurities and point defects. Interfaces may block slip even when dislocations move easily in both of the bounding crystals. Grain boundaries, interfaces in polycrystalline single-phase, single-component materials, are quintessential examples of effective barriers to slip. The atomic structure of interfaces defines their properties and thereby the properties that they impart to polycrystalline and polyphasic materials. Atomic environments – structural units defined by the relative configuration of an atom and its neighbors – inside and in the vicinity of an interface may be distinctly different from those in the neighboring perfect crystals. Aside from various possible interfacial dislocations and point defects, the number of independent variables needed to describe the positions of M atoms in a crystalline solid containing a single interface, is, unlike a liquid, much less than 3M − 3. At a minimum, five variables are needed, the three that define the misorientation between the two crystals having the same composition, and two that define the orientation of the normal to a flat interface between the two crystals. These crystallographic orientation variables correspond to the so-called macroscopic degrees-of-freedom [1] and are important to characterizing grain boundaries. These are all that are needed, for example, to infer the most likely arrangement of atoms at a twin interface parallel to {111} planes common to some fcc metals. The twin in fcc crystals corresponds to a 3 CSL.1 In its lowest energy configuration this interface has an intuitively simple atomic structure, like that shown in Fig. 1. Other configurations of the 3 CSL have much higher energies. Most other interfaces possess atomic structures that are not so “intuitive” and may require many variables to adequately define the atomic configuration in and near the interface. Such interfaces are much more interesting than the simple twin interface, because they often possess many metastable states for a given set of macroscopic degrees-of-freedom. These various states may differ in energy, but by relatively small amounts, and may be 1 A coincident site lattice (CSL), denoted N , where N is the ratio of CSL volume to unit cell volume, is here defined as a three-dimensional lattice of coincident sites formed within two interpenetrating crystals of differing, but precisely defined, orientation. CSLs are useful when describing grain boundaries in single-component systems but less so in incommensurate, multicomponent systems.
144
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 1. A flat twin interface between two fcc crystals with 3 misorientation. The interface is parallel to {111} planes in both crystals and the direction of view is along 110. Five variables are sufficient to define this simple and intuitive structure. Other metastable configurations could be created – for example by displacing an atom into an interstitial position – but doing so would require a substantial amount of work.
separated by small energy barriers. Consequently, they may easily change state, and, therefore, configuration, in response to changes in stress, temperature, and composition. These easy configurational changes enable such multi-state interfaces to actively participate in and influence a broad array of reactions and processes. Two additional degrees of freedom for a flat interface are the two components of the in plane shear vector, the relative displacement, parallel to the interface, of one bounding crystal with respect to the other. These are called microscopical degrees of freedom. These two microscopical variables are not relevant to the simple twin interface shown in Fig. 1 or for other special interfaces, like the 11 symmetric twin interface shown in Fig. 2(a) – there is only one stable configuration (ignoring other defects) [2]. However, for the same CSL but other interface orientations, like that shown in Fig. 2(b), many other structures, with similar energies, appear as the two microscopical variables are changed. In most cases many more variables are required, i.e. multiple states exist for a well-defined set of seven variables. A periodic array of boundary unit cells (BUCs) is created by the intersection of the interface plane with a CSL. The size and shape of the BUC is defined by the five macroscopic variables, the three that determine the CSL, and the two defining the orientation of the interface. For a given lattice, multiple states with similar energies are more likely as the BUC becomes larger and this implies that more degrees of freedom are needed to define the atomic structure of interfaces with larger BUCs. In even more general situations where the bounding crystals do not have the same lattice parameter and/or do not share the same crystal structure no CSL, BUC or periodicity in the interface exists. However, even in such incommensurate systems, pseudo-periodicity, in the form of extended periodic arrays of BUC-like features may be energetically favorable. Except in special cases, direct observation of interfacial atomic structures by highresolution-transmission-electron microscopy is difficult because there are too few reflec-
§1
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
145
Fig. 2. (a) A flat twin interface between two fcc crystals with 11 misorientation. The interface is parallel to {131} planes in both grains and the direction of view is along a 110. As in Fig. 1, specifying the five microscopic variables is sufficient to define this atomic structure. (b) A flat interface between two fcc crystals with 11 orientation. The interface is parallel to a {252} plane in one grain and a {414} in the other. Many different interface configurations are possible with these five macroscopic variables and at least two more microscopic variables – the components of the in-plane shear vector – must be specified to define the atomic structure.
tions from lattice planes (or there are none at all) to permit imaging conditions that enable identification of actual atom positions. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, while often relying on empirical potentials, have proven very useful and much work has been done using such methods to study grain boundaries. In this paper we focus on the atomic structure of interfaces in incommensurate systems. Initially, in Section 2 we describe some interesting features in simple systems where the interfaces are coherent or semicoherent. In particular, we consider interfaces in composite systems where both components are fcc and oriented identically. In such systems the slip planes and slip directions are continuous across the interfaces. In Section 3 we then present some results derived from MD simulations on more complex incoherent interfaces formed between two crystallographically dissimilar metals, one fcc and the other bcc. Interfaces between such differing phases do not posses any strictly periodic structure. The atomic configurations that appear in these simulations serve to emphasize the importance of multiple states. An emergent picture, described in some detail in Section 4, is that interfaces that are capable of changing structure, with relative ease, from one metastable state to another, offer regions wherein point defects have low formation energies, high mobility, and a greatly expanded range of interaction. In Section 5 we examine another important aspect wherein the state of an interface may be changed by stress and that the shear resistance
146
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
of interfaces can be relatively low. If so, interfaces interact with sources of internal stress, such as dislocations, and the shear of interfaces may occur by a variety of possible dislocations. We show that, because of this, glide dislocations are attracted to interfaces. This interaction contributes, in part, to interfaces acting as potent barriers to slip. In addition, the core structure of dislocations changes dramatically on entering interfaces and the process of reemergence of slip becomes correspondingly complex.
2. Coherent and semicoherent interfaces in fcc/fcc bilayers The creation of a coherent interface between two crystals with differing crystal structure requires straining both crystals in order to produce the atom-to-atom matching necessary for coherency. The strains to be imposed on materials A and B to achieve coherency can be derived by solving the following equations: force equilibrium, hA σijA = hB σijB coherency conditions, A B + 1 = aiB εij +1 aiA εij
(1)
(2)
boundary conditions (for example, zero constraint normal to the layers), A B σ22 = σ22 =0
(3)
and Hooke’s law for material M, M M σijM = cij kl εkl ,
(4)
where subscripts refer to the coordinate system shown in Fig. 3, with x1 and x3 in the plane of the interface, x2 normal to the interface, aiM the lattice parameter in the ith direction in material M, and hM the total thickness of material M in the layered composite assuming the layers are flat and all of the interfaces are parallel. Eqs (1) through (4) permit a solution to the problem of determining the coherency strains but they may not be accurate for several reasons. Firstly, eq. (1) satisfies only force equilibrium but not equilibrium of moments. The net moment in the layered composite depends on whether the number of layers is odd or even, their relative thickness, and also whether the composite sheet is attached to a substrate or freestanding. Secondly, eq. (2) is accurate in the limit of very small strains but should be replaced by a finite strain expansion for cases involving large differences in lattice parameter. If the coherency strains are too large, coherent interfaces might not be possible, even in atomistic models. For example, the lattice mismatch may be so large that the strains involved in creating coherency produce stresses that exceed the theoretical tensile strength of one of the components. Additionally, large lattice misfits energetically favor the injection of misfit dislocations, making the interface semicoherent even for the thinnest possible layers. Finally, the departure from linearity in the stress–strain relation, represented by eq. (4) is significant when the stresses become large, which they may be in a coherent composite. As an example, consider a Cu/Ni layered composite. Such fcc/fcc composites when produced by physical vapor deposition (PVD), are epitaxially arranged in a cube-on-cube
§2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
147
Fig. 3. A combined schematic and TEM micrograph. The micrograph shows a cross-section from a layered Cu/Ni composite in which each layer is approximately 2.5 nm thick. This figure also serves to identify the coordinate system referred to in the text.
orientation such that adjoining Cu and Ni layers have parallel 100 directions and the interface is approximately a {100} plane (in Fig. 3 the interfaces are slightly curved; this is a commonly observed feature of PVD grown films and indicates that the interfaces are terraced). The solution of eqs (1)–(4) is greatly simplified in this case because the misfit ratio, aiB /aiA , is isotropic. The magnitude of the in-plane coherency stresses in the two materials depends on the orientation of the interface plane. When the interface plane is parallel to {100} the coherency stresses are purely biaxial, σ = Cε, where C is the c2
12 biaxial elastic constant given by C = c11 + c12 − 2 c11 . The stresses are estimated to be 2.2 GPa in Ni and −2.2 GPa in Cu [3]. Fig. 4(a) shows the two principal stresses parallel to the interface plane for other interface orientations. Clearly, an interface parallel to {100} corresponds to lowest in-plane normal stresses and that parallel to {110} corresponds to high stress. More importantly, as shown in Fig. 4(b), the strain energy
148
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
(a)
(b) Fig. 4. (a) A polar plot showing the two in-plane stresses that occur in a coherent Cu/Ni layered composite as a function of interface orientation. The normal to the interface is rotated about the z-axis as shown in the schematic. The dashed curve is the normal stress σzz (perpendicular to the page), and the solid curve the other in-plane normal stress. The units of stress are GPa and the stresses in the Cu are negative and positive in the Ni. (b) Polar plots of the dependence of the average strain energy densities [calculated as (σij εij )/2 in units of eV/Å3 ] on interface orientation, as defined in (a) except that longitudinal orientations of φ = 0◦ (z-axis normal to the page), 15◦ , 30◦ , and 45◦ are also shown. Equal thickness layers are assumed in both (a) and (b).
in the system is also dependent on interface orientation. It is highest for interfaces oriented parallel to {111} planes and lowest for interfaces parallel to the cube planes, which favors that orientation and is consistent with experimental observations. Evidently, the
§2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
149
strain energy advantage of the {100}-oriented interface tends to minimize interface curvature. As Fig. 4 shows, even for a composite layered system like Cu/Ni where the misfit between the two components is rather modest (misfit = 2.7%), the coherency stresses can be quite large. Biaxial stresses of 2.2 GPa in Cu and Ni will likely cause grown-in dislocations, so-called threaders, to glide, to the extent they are able, whether those dislocations are perfect 12 110{111} or Shockley dislocations, commonly associated with glide, or other dislocations, such as Lomer’s, 100, etc., that are able to glide conservatively. Dislocations that glide nonconservatively, such as stair rods, might also move at sufficiently high temperatures at these stress levels. Consequently, some plastic relaxation of coherency stresses by glide of grown-in dislocations is likely. Threading dislocations in layered composites are so called because they are grown in with their line oriented more-or-less perpendicular to the interface plane and, so, thread through the layers. Because the coherency stresses change sign from one layer to the next, the direction of the force vectors on each segment of threading dislocation within a layer would, if the dislocations were stationary, also change direction by about 180◦ from one layer to the next. If the segments are free to glide, each segment may, at sufficiently large applied stress, bow out and extend within its layer depositing itself along the two interfaces bounding the layer as it moves. The stress required to extend a segment confined within a layer of thickness h is proportional to ln h/ h, which is similar to that predicted by the classical Orowan expression but modified to account for the line energy of the deposited parts [4–9]. Similarly, as a new layer of, say component A, grows on a thick layer of component B, the coherency stresses in A exert a force on a threader acting to bow the threader within layer A. The critical thickness at which the threading dislocation begins to spread without limit depends on the energy to produce the step that is created on the free surface as the dislocation glides [10,11]. Fig. 5 provides a graphic example of a threading dislocation in an atomistic model of Ni on which layers of Cu are added, one at a time. The threading dislocation begins to bow out when the thickness of a surface film of coherent Cu exceeds 4 atomic layers. Further increases in thickness (exceeding about 2 nm) lead to glide without limit. In this case only 4 atomic layers (about 1 nm) are nearly sufficient to make glide energetically feasible. Even fewer layers would be needed in the rare event that a step is already available which the threading dislocation removes as it glides. Mitlin and coworkers [12] have provided indirect experimental evidence that is consistent with these ideas. They show that for Ni films growing coherently on Cu, there exists a critical thickness below which no dislocation glide is observed. For thickness greater than critical, long segments of glide dislocations on the interface are observed. These segments are a result of glide of threading dislocations, and the density of these dislocations increases with increasing thickness. Also, they observed that some of the dislocations on the interfaces are Lomer’s (with b = a/2110{100}) and that the fraction of Lomer’s increased dramatically with increasing film thickness [13]. Their observations suggest dislocation multiplication mechanisms. With regard to the Lomer dislocations on the interface, one scenario for their formation is the reaction between two a/2110{111} glide dislocations on conjugate slip planes at, or near, the interface. The trouble with this explanation is that
150
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 5. In the top figure a threading dislocation lying on a {111} slip plane in a layer of Ni emerges from the {100} nickel surface at the arrowed location. The middle figure shows that the threader has not moved after two layers of Cu were attached, coherently, to the Ni substrate. The bottom figure shows that the emerging threading dislocation has moved after 4 atomic layers of Cu have been added. These results were obtained from atomistic models and atoms are colored by excess energy. All of the low energy atoms have been rendered invisible.
such reactions ought to be rather rare and so the mechanisms responsible for the production of Lomer dislocations on the interface remain somewhat uncertain. The coherency stresses play yet another role: they define the maximum strength that coherent layered composites can achieve. The strength model suggested by Hoagland and coworkers [3] is based on the simple idea that a dislocation cannot traverse the composite unless the net forces on the dislocation in all layers are the same sign. Thus, a stress must
§2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
151
be applied that at least cancels the coherency stress in one of the two constituents. For a {100} oriented interface in a cube-on-cube fcc/fcc layered composite, this stress is given by σmax =
CACB em , CA + CB
where em is the misfit strain given by em = 2
(5) a0B −a0A , a0B +a0A
and the C M is the biaxial elastic
constant, mentioned earlier, for material M. There exist other forces acting on a dislocation that also must be overcome. These include forces due to elastic mismatch between the two constituents (Koehler forces), changes in core structure as the dislocation passes from one layer to the next (due, for example, to differences in stacking fault energy between the two constituents), and the creation of a small residual dislocation at the interface as the glide dislocation changes its Burgers’ vector on crossing the interface. From atomistic models at 0 K Hoagland and coworkers [14] found that, for coherent Cu/Ni composites, the applied stress needed to transmit a glide dislocation across the interface is 2.4 GPa, just slightly less than the 2.6 GPa predicted by eq. (5), and not very much above the 1.7 GPa peak strength measured experimentally [15]. Therefore, in this system most of the strength derives from coherency stresses. This also means that, while the net stress (applied plus coherency) in one constituent is about zero at onset of plasticity, the stress in the other has about doubled. Thus in Cu/Ni composites, an in-plane tensile stress of 2.4 GPa cancels the coherency stress in the Cu but stresses the Ni to about 5 GPa. As discussed by Hoagland and coworkers [14] this enormous stress in the Ni has several important implications, one of which is that the nonlinear elastic properties of the Ni become important. For example, the sign of the Koehler force was observed to change as the applied stress increased and approached 5 GPa. Dislocations that collect on interfaces, such as might result from glide of threading dislocations and by the creation of Lomer dislocations, tend to relax the coherency stresses at some distance away from the interface. These are called misfit dislocations and are energetically favorable if the work done in their creation is less than the elastic strain energy removed in reducing the coherency stresses, a topic that has received considerable attention [16–20]. Since the coherency energy scales as h and the dislocation self-energy scales as ln h, a critical thickness exists below which misfit dislocations are thermodynamically unstable. For larger layer thicknesses the equilibrium spacing between misfit dislocations depends upon their Burgers’ vector and the layer thickness, and, in the limit of a pair of semi-infinite bilayers, is given by λ=
bc , em
(6)
where bc is the component of the edge part of the Burgers vector parallel to the interface. Eq. (6) gives the misfit dislocation spacing that would completely remove the long-range coherency stresses. For reasons related to kinematic effects and nucleation of dislocations, predicted misfit spacing are generally smaller than observed. Importantly, misfit dislocations relax only the long-range coherency stresses and the interface between the misfit dislocations remains coherent and, therefore, a glide dislocation that intersects the coherent
152
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
segment of interface in this region still encounters very large stresses that must be overcome if the dislocation is to move through the composite. This explains why these composites have high strength even when the layer thicknesses exceed the critical thickness. Some other factors that affect to the strength of layered composites include the accumulation of steps and dislocation remnants, called disconnections, on the interface, as a dislocation glides from crystal A to crystal B, with remnant Burgers vector, b = bA −bB . These disconnections act to repel additional bA dislocations and, thus, their accumulation on the interface constitutes a form of work hardening [21]. Another potent strengthening mechanism derives from the misfit dislocation commonly observed in Cu/Ni composites, the a/2110{100} Lomer. In an unstressed fcc lattice, this dislocation can dissociate into two Shockley dislocations and a stair rod [22,23]. This dissociation is energetically favored in Cu, but in a Cu/Ni bilayer, the core of the Lomer is collapsed by the compressive coherency stresses. With the application of in-plane tension the Lomer dissociates, and, in so doing, creates sheets or polyhedral shapes of stacking faults that are very potent barriers to cutting by glide dislocations [14].
3. Incoherent interfaces in fcc/bcc bilayers Compared to fcc/fcc interfaces, the more complex geometry of fcc/bcc interfaces leads to a possible multitude of atomic configurations of differing density, but nearly degenerate energy. This behavior is demonstrated in this section for the example of interfaces between Cu and Nb.
3.1. Interfaces in Cu/Nb multilayer composites Fcc {111} and bcc {110} planes each contain three low-index atomic directions. An fcc {111} plane contains three 110 nearest neighbor directions while a bcc {110} plane contains two 111 nearest neighbor directions and one 100 direction. Two commonly observed orientation relations of interfaces between close-packed planes of neighboring fcc and bcc solids can be described. In the Kurdjumov–Sachs (KS) orientation relation one of the 110 directions in a fcc {111} plane lies parallel to one of the 111 directions in a bcc {110} plane. Meanwhile, in the Nishiyama–Wassermann (NW) orientation relation one of the 110 directions in a fcc {111} plane lies parallel to the 100 direction in a bcc {110} plane. In terraces of both KS and NW a fcc {111} plane is parallel to a bcc {110}. A coherent fcc {111}/bcc {110} interface satisfies both KS and NW. Only the introduction of interface dislocations or (martensite) disconnections distinguishes the two cases. Schematic representations of the crystallography of KS and NW fcc/bcc interfaces are shown in Fig. 6. These orientation relations differ only by a rotation of ∼5.26 degrees in the interface plane, with intermediate orientations differing by even smaller rotations. Because the difference in orientation in the interface plane between the KS and NW relations is so small, drawing an unambiguous distinction between them can be challenging in experiments. Furthermore, coexistence of these two interface types seems possible and
§3.1
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
153
Fig. 6. Schematic representation of two common orientation relations of interfaces between fcc {111} and bcc {110} close packed atomic planes: (a) Kurdjumov–Sachs, 110fcc 111bcc ; (b) Nishiyama–Wassermann, 110fcc 100bcc . These orientation relations differ by a rotation of about 5.26 degrees in the interface plane (applied to the fcc {111} plane in the visualization above). The coordinate system shown here will be used throughout this section.
there may be cases where orientations intermediate between KS and NW are also present [24,25]. Considerable attention has been given to the topology of fcc/bcc interfaces due to its importance in describing martensitic transformations in ferrous alloys, yielding insights into the structure of interface steps, terracing behavior, and mechanisms of diffusionless transformations between the neighboring phases [26–29]. By comparison, detailed understanding of the connection between atomic structure of fcc/bcc interfaces and their physical properties has been lacking. Early studies of the atomic structure of close-packed fcc/bcc interfaces have focused on the most readily apparent feature of the atomic arrangement of these interfaces, namely that despite the lack of strict periodicity in these interfaces there nevertheless exist structurally distinct patches of interface area that form a repetitive pattern [30,31]. Such patches have been variously referred to as patches of local coherency [30] or high coordination [32]. Their areal density is a continuous function of the ratio of lattice parameters of the neighboring crystals as well as of rotation of one of the neighboring crystals in the interface plane (i.e. of orientation relation), but since analytical expressions relating interface crystallography to the locations of these patches have not been available, previous studies have focused on determining such relations numerically [31]. Meanwhile, the question of whether these patches affect the physical properties of close-packed fcc/bcc interfaces has not been addressed.
154
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
In this section, the relations between structure and physical properties are studied in detail for a single specific close-packed fcc/bcc interface, namely the Kurdjumov–Sachs interface between Cu and Nb (Cu/Nb-KS). Extensive experimental study has confirmed that such interfaces are present in multilayered Cu/Nb composite coatings [33]. Moreover, their presence has been identified as the cause of numerous unusual properties of Cu/Nb multilayer composite including elastic anomalies [34], high strength and toughness [33,35], thermal stability [36,37], low susceptibility to fatigue [38], enhanced radiation damage resistance [39,40], and high He solubility and mobility [41,42]. The relations between interface structure and physical properties described in this section can be used to indicate what other fcc/bcc element pairs might exhibit properties similar to those seen in Cu/Nb multilayer composites. The work described here was performed using molecular dynamics (MD) [43] and conjugate gradient (CG) [44] potential energy minimization (PEM) atomistic simulation techniques [45]. Interatomic interactions were modeled using an empirical potential constructed using the embedded atom method (EAM) [46], which has proven successful in modeling the properties of elemental metallic systems as well as their alloys [47]. The Cu/Nb EAM potential used in this study was constructed by adopting the description of pure Cu due to Voter [48,49], that of Nb due to Johnson and Oh [50], and an inter-element interaction whose design was described elsewhere [32].
3.2. Interface structure: KS1 and KS2 Since the Cu/Nb-KS interface is aperiodic, constructing sections of it under periodic boundary conditions (PBCs) requires that interface periodicity be artificially imposed by straining the two adjoining Cu and Nb layers. Minimization of these periodicity strains is desirable as the associated stresses might influence interface behavior and affect properties such as interface energies. The magnitudes of the periodicity strains achieve minimum values for specific combinations of dimensions of the neighboring crystalline layers and generally decrease with increasing system size. In this study the interface dimensions were chosen so that the magnitudes of the imposed strains, dεxx , and dεzz , did not exceed 0.06%, 0.4%, respectively (see coordinate system in Fig. 6), while dεxz was maintained at zero. Once constructed, atomic configurations containing sections of the Cu/Nb-KS interface were relaxed using the Cu/Nb EAM potential by first allowing rigid-body translations of the neighboring Cu and Nb layers as well as homogeneous strains of the bilayer followed by independent relaxation of the all atomic positions [32]. When perfect fcc Cu is joined with bcc Nb in the Kurdjumov–Sachs orientation relation, the appearance of the resulting interface before relaxation is as shown in Fig. 7. One can discern a Moiré pattern of streaks of interface area where the locations of Cu and Nb atoms in the adjoining planes appear to line up. These streaks form a repetitive pattern and are the result of a purely geometrical Vernier-type misfit. After relaxation, the interface plane appears as shown in Fig. 8. Instead of the streaks observed in Fig. 7, this structure exhibits isolated sites of congruency between the Cu and Nb planes where a single atom in the Cu interface plane appears to be situated approximately “on top” of an atom from the Nb interface plane. The locations of these sites follow the same repetitive pattern seen in Fig. 7,
§3.2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
155
Fig. 7. Visualization of the unrelaxed KS1 interface between fcc Cu (light) and bcc Nb (dark) looking normal to the interface plane. Even though this interface itself does not posses a strict periodicity, repetitive patterns appear where the positions of neighboring Cu and Nb atoms are nearly congruent – like the one indicated by the black oval.
with approximate unit cell dimensions of 1.34 × 2.55 nm and area 3.42 nm2 . The shape and size of this pattern is a consequence of the geometry of the two lattices and of their orientation, but not of the details of bonding between Cu and Nb. The displacements of interface atoms in going from the unrelaxed structure in Fig. 7 to the relaxed one in Fig. 8 are plotted for the Cu and Nb interface planes in Figs 9(a) and 9(b). On average, the magnitudes of these displacements in the interfacial Cu plane are larger by approximately a factor of 2.5 than in the interfacial Nb plane. In Fig. 9(a) one immediately notices regions of vortical displacements. These displacements occur almost entirely in the interfacial Cu plane, in agreement with the larger magnitude of relaxationinduced displacements in this plane compared with the interfacial Nb plane. The vortical relaxations center on the locations shown in Fig. 8 where a Cu interface atom is nearly congruent with a Nb atom. The interface structure described above has been termed “KS1 ” [32]. A second metastable interface structure has been found that also obeys the Kurdjumov–Sachs orientation relation, but possesses a different arrangement of interface atoms than seen in KS1 . In this second interface structure, called “KS2 ,” the plane of Cu atoms adjacent to the
156
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 8. Visualization of the relaxed KS1 interface between fcc Cu (light) and bcc Nb (dark) looking normal to the interface plane. Compact sites of congruency between Cu and Nb planes where a Cu atom is nearly “on top” of a Nb atom – like the one indicated by the circle – form a repetitive pattern with approximate unit cell of dimensions 1.34 × 2.55 nm.
interface Nb {110} plane is not a perfect Cu {111} plane, as in KS1 , but instead is homogeneously strained and rotated. The required deformation is unique and can be determined from the crystallography of the Kurdjumov–Sachs orientation relation as well as the lattice parameters of Cu and Nb, as shown below. The geometry of the homogeneously strained Cu {111} plane found in KS2 is called the α-geometry. All remaining Cu {111} planes in KS2 are perfect Cu {111} planes. The difference between KS1 and KS2 is illustrated schematically in Fig. 10. Because the structure of the atomic plane of Cu adjacent to Nb in KS2 is distinct from the rest of the Cu layer, the KS2 configuration in fact incorporates two interfaces: Nb/Cuα between Nb and the adjacent strained Cuα plane and Cuα /Cu between the strained Cu plane and the remaining unstrained Cu layer. The remainder of the bilayer has the Kurdjumov–Sachs orientation. In experiments it may be difficult to distinguish between KS1 and KS2 if the thickness of the unstrained Cu and Nb layers greatly exceeds one atomic plane, since these layers would dominate transmission electron microscope images as well as electron or X-ray diffraction patterns.
§3.2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
157
(a)
(b) Fig. 9. The in-plane displacement vectors on relaxing from the configuration shown in Fig. 7 to the one in Fig. 8, for the interfacial (a) Cu {111} plane and (b) Nb {110} plane. For clarity, the magnitudes of the displacements shown here have been magnified by a factor of 5 in both (a) and (b).
To understand the construction of the homogeneous strain that must be imposed on a perfect Cu {111} plane to transform it into the Cuα plane present in KS2 , consider the arrangement of rows of atoms lying along low-index directions in the interface Cu and Nb
158
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 10. Comparison between KS1 and KS2 configurations. (a) KS1 is constructed by simply joining unstrained fcc Cu and bcc Nb layers in the Kurdjumov–Sachs orientation relation. (b) KS2 differs from KS1 in that the monolayer of Cu atoms immediately adjacent to the interfacial Nb {110} plane is homogeneously strained to the α-geometry (see text). The KS2 configuration therefore contains two interfaces: Nb/Cuα and Cuα /Cu.
Fig. 11. (a) The arrangement of Nb {110} and Cu {111} planes in the Kurdjumov–Sachs orientation relation. (b) The arrangement of a Nb {110} plane and Cuα plane in the α-geometry. (c) The arrangement of a Cuα plane in the α-geometry and an unstrained Cu {111} plane. The strains that must be applied to create the Cuα monolayer from a Cu {111} plane are illustrated by the dashed-line box and the thick arrows in (b) and (c).
planes of the KS1 configuration, as shown in Fig. 11(a). In the Cu {111} interface plane, Cu close-packed atom rows lie along three possible 110 directions, labeled 110Cu 1 , 1102 , Cu and 1103 in Fig. 11(a). In the Nb {110} interface plane, close-packed atom rows lie along Nb two possible 111 directions – labeled 111Nb 1 and 1112 , while the second closest packed rows of atoms lie along the 100 direction, labeled 100Nb . To strain the Cu {111} interface plane into the α-geometry, a homogeneous in-plane deformation is applied such Cu Cu that the close-packed rows 110Cu 1 , 1102 , and 1103 are transformed into a new set of rows named A, B, and C, respectively. After deformation these rows satisfy the following conditions: 1. The direction of A rows is parallel to the direction of 110Cu 1 ; 2. The direction of C rows is parallel to the direction of 100Nb ;
§3.2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
159
3. The distance d(A) between atoms along A rows is chosen such that the perpendicular spacing s(C) between C rows is equal to the perpendicular spacing s(100Nb ) between Nb 100Nb rows; 4. The distance d(C) between atoms along C rows is chosen such that the perpendicular spacing s(A) between A rows is equal to the perpendicular spacing s(110Cu 1 ) between Cu 110Cu rows. 1 As illustrated in Figs 11(b) and 11(c), the above transformation involves a uniform elongation and a simple shear along the 110Cu 1 direction. The orientations of the resulting monolayer directions A, B, and C with respect to the low-index directions in the Cu {111} and Nb {110} interface planes are also shown in Figs 11(b) and 11(c). The prescription above can be used to obtain an explicit expression for the displacement gradient (elastic stretch and rotation) relating a perfect Cu {111} plane and the Cuα plane present in the KS2 configuration. Adopting the coordinate system in Fig. 6 and restricting analysis to the interface (x, z) plane, one can express the nearest-neighbor vectors pointing Cu along directions 110Cu 1 and 1103 in a perfect Cu {111} plane as √ √ 2 1 − 3 aCu , , v 110Cu = 1 2 2 2 √ √ 2 3 1 v 110Cu = (7) aCu , , 3 2 2 2 while the nearest-neighbor vectors pointing along directions A and C in the Cuα plane are √ √ 1 − 3 v A = 30 − 12 6aNb , , 2 2 1 2 3 √ v C = ( 6 − 2)aCu (8) , . 2 3 3 The displacement gradient FCu→Cuα that deforms one set of vectors into the other obeys the relation T T T v A v CT = FCu→Cuα v 110 (9) v 110 Cu Cu 1
and equal to
⎧ ⎪ ⎪ ⎨
3
√ (aCu − aNb ) ⎫ √ √ (aCu + aNb ) ⎪ ⎪ ( 3 − 2) ( 6 − 3) ⎬ a a Cu Cu √ √ FCu→Cuα = . √ √ aNb ⎪ 6−2 6 2 − 6 aNb ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ( 6 − 2) − ( 6 − 3) +3 √ √ ⎩ ⎭ aCu aCu 2 2 (10) The determinant of FCu→Cuα √ aNb det(FCu→Cuα ) = 2(3 − 6) (11) aCu gives the change in interface area in going from a perfect Cu {111} plane to Cuα . Using aCu = 0.3615 nm and aNb = 0.3301 nm [51], one finds det(FCu→Cuα ) ≈ 1.00538, indicating a decrease of areal density in the monolayer by about 1 atom for every 186 atoms
160
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 12. The relaxed Nb/Cuα interface in the KS2 configuration looking normal to the interface plane. Nb atoms are dark and Cuα atoms are light. Rows of atoms along the Nb 100Nb and Cuα C directions are parallel to each other and have the same normal spacing.
in a perfect Cu {111} plane. The magnitudes of the uniform elongation and simple shear pictured in Figs 11(b) and 11(c) are 0.538 and 11.6%, respectively. One can create the interface structure KS2 by inserting the Cuα monolayer constructed according to the procedure described above in place of the interface Cu {111} plane of the KS1 structure. Similar to the case when the fcc Cu and bcc Nb crystal slabs are joined to create KS1 , additional strains must imposed on the Cuα monolayer to ensure periodic boundary conditions in the interface plane. The magnitudes of the required periodicity strain increments dεxx , dεzz , dεxz did not exceed 0.004%, 0.2%, 0.05%, respectively, and are comparable to the periodicity strains imposed in KS1 . Because of these periodicity strains, the final decrease of areal density in the Cuα monolayer was about 1 atom for every 139 atoms in a perfect Cu {111} plane. Figs 12 and 13 show the arrangement of atoms in the Nb/Cuα and Cuα /Cu interfaces of KS2 after relaxation. As intended, the direction and spacing of Nb 100Nb rows matche those of Cuα C rows and the direction and spacing of Cu 110Cu 1 rows matches those of Cuα A rows. Note that none of the Cuα rows A, B, or C lie parallel to the characteristic Kurdjumov–Sachs direction where Nb 111 is parallel to Cu 110: row B is most closely aligned with this direction, making an angle of approximately 5.0 degrees with it. Comparing the Nb/Cuα interface of KS2 in Fig. 12 with the relaxed KS1 interface in Fig. 8 reveals a clear difference between these two configurations. In KS1 , patches of un-
§3.3
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
161
Fig. 13. Visualization of the relaxed Cuα /Cu interface in the KS2 configuration looking normal to the interface α plane. Cuα atoms are light and bulk Cu atoms are dark. Rows of atoms along the Cu 110Cu 1 and Cu A directions are parallel to each other and have the same normal spacing.
dercoordination occur at points where a Cu and Nb atom are nearly congruent. In Nb/Cuα of KS2 , however, these features are not observed. Patches of undercoordination do not appear in Cuα /Cu in Fig. 13, either. In fact, the conditions placed on the directions and spacing of rows A and C ensure that the spacing between A monolayer rows exactly matches those of 110Cu 1 rows, causing the former to lie in the “valleys” between the latter. Similarly, C monolayer rows always lie in the “valleys” between 100Nb rows. Consequently, no patches of undercoordination are possible in the KS2 interface structures even if the model is extended infinitely in both in-plane directions. Accordingly, no vortical displacement fields appear in KS2 upon relaxation, unlike in KS1 (Fig. 9). 3.3. Interface dislocations in KS1 The vortical displacement patterns that appear in the KS1 interface (Fig. 9) perturb the locations of neighboring atoms in a way reminiscent of the creation of a defect with a well-defined elastic strain field. Numerous attempts have been made to understand these relaxations in terms of possible defect configurations, including disclinations [52,53], dislocation or disclination loops [54,55], generalized Somigliana dislocations [56–58], and solitons [59,60]. Although none of these alternatives by themselves proved suitable to de-
162
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
scribe the relaxation displacement fields in KS1 , an explanation was eventually found based on the presence of two intersecting sets of interface dislocations in the KS1 configuration. The presence of dislocations in the KS1 interface can be demonstrated by analysis of the disregistry across the interface plane upon relaxation [22]. To carry out this analysis, a reference state for the Cu/Nb bilayer must be chosen in which the interface between the neighboring elements is coherent, i.e. in which both of the adjoining interface atom planes have identical crystal structures. Because the lattice misfit between Cu and Nb is nearly 10%, either the Cu or Nb layer or both must be highly strained to construct a coherent reference configuration. The physical effect of the long-range elastic fields of any interface dislocations added to such a coherent structure is to transform the neighboring Cu and Nb crystals back into their unstrained states. For this reason, such interface dislocations are sometime referred to as misfit [14] or anticoherency [1] dislocations. The coherent reference state chosen for the disregistry analysis to be presented here is such that all Cu {111} planes are strained to have the in-plane geometry of Cuα and all Nb {110} planes are strained to have the in-plane geometry of Nbα , i.e. Nb in the αgeometry. Although many other possible coherent states could be chosen, this specific one has advantages that make it particularly suitable to disregistry analysis, as discussed in Section 3.4. As shown in Section 3.2, one can create the Cuα monolayer in KS2 by applying the displacement gradient FCu→Cuα [eq. (10)] to a perfect Cu {111} plane. For disregistry analysis of KS1 one further displacement gradient must be computed, namely FNb→Nbα which describes the homogeneous deformation that must be applied to a Nb {110} plane to transform it to the α-geometry. This displacement gradient can be computed from the relation −1 FCu→Nb = FNbα →Nb · FCu→Cuα = FNb→Nb α · FCu→Cuα −1 FNb→Nbα = FCu→Cuα · FCu→Nb ,
⇒
(12)
where FCu→Nb is the displacement gradient that must be applied to a Cu {111} plane in order to transform it into a Nb {110} plane. Given the vectors connecting nearest-neighbor Nb rows of a Nb {110} plane atoms lying along the 111Nb 1 and 100 √ √ 3 1 −2 2 aNb , , v 111Nb = 1 2 3 3 1 2 v 100Nb = aNb (13) , 3 3 as well as the vectors connecting nearest-neighbor atoms lying along the 110Cu 1 and Cu 1103 rows of a Cu {111} plane [eq. (7)], FCu→Nb immediately follows from the relation T T T T v 111Nb v 100 (14) 110Cu v 110 Nb = FCu→Nb v Cu 1
and can be written as ⎧ ⎪ ⎪ 3 aNb ⎨ 2 aCu FCu→Nb = ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ 0
1
3
√
⎫ 2aNb ⎪ ⎪ ⎬ 6aCu . 4aNb ⎪ ⎪ ⎭ 3aCu
(15)
§3.3
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
163
Eq. (12) then gives rise to the following expression for FNb→Nbα : FNb→Nbα ⎧ √ (aCu − 2aNb ) ⎫ √ √ (aCu + aNb ) ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ⎪ ( 6 − 2) ( 3 − 2) ⎨ ⎬ aNb 2aNb √ √ . = √ ⎪ 3 − 6 aCu aCu ⎪ 1√ 6−3 6 ⎪ ⎪ ⎩ ⎭ +2 6−1 (3 − 6) + √ √ aNb 2 aNb 3 3 (16) To conduct the disregistry analysis, two KS1 interface configurations are used: the asconstructed interface before relaxation and the fully relaxed KS1 configuration. The state of the Cu layer in its coherent reference state is constructed by applying the displacement gradient FCu→Cuα to the Cu side of the unrelaxed interface. A correspondence list between nearest-neighbor Cu and Nb atoms is compiled in this reference configuration. This list is used to find initial relative positions between the corresponding atoms and to determine the locations of origin for disregistry vectors, defined as the midpoint between corresponding atoms. The final relative position between corresponding atoms is computed in the fully relaxed state of the KS1 interface. Disregistry vectors r are then computed as the difference between the positions of corresponding Cu and Nb atoms in the relaxed and reference configurations. The locations of origin found in the strained reference state are used in creating a vector plot of disregistry in the interface plane, as shown in Fig. 14. The appearance of the disregistry vector plot in Fig. 14 is dominated by the homogeneous deformation FCu→Cuα used in constructing the strained reference configuration.
Fig. 14. Vector plot of disregistry computed across the Cu/Nb interface in KS1 . The shaded strips are regions where the disregistry changes most rapidly. ξˆ denotes the line direction of the strips while nˆ is the direction normal to ξˆ in the interface plane.
164
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 15. Disregistry components r · nˆ (edge) and r · ξˆ (screw) as functions of the component (x, z) · nˆ of disregistry position (nˆ is the direction normal to the line direction ξˆ of shaded strips in Fig. 14). The steps in the screw components of disregistry indicate the presence of a set of interfacial dislocations, termed “set 1” for reference.
Nevertheless, close analysis shows that the parts of the interface in which the magnitudes of the disregistry vectors undergo the fastest changes are the ones within the shaded strips shown in Fig. 14. This property of the computed disregistry vector distribution is more easily seen by examination of the plot in Fig. 15, whose abscissa is the component (x, z) · nˆ of the disregistry vector origin position that lies along the direction nˆ normal to the line of strips in Fig. 14. The quantities plotted on the ordinate are the components r · ξˆ and r · nˆ of disregistry vectors along directions parallel and normal to the line of strips (directions ξˆ and nˆ in Fig. 14, respectively). If no dislocations had been present in the interface under investigation here, the plot in Fig. 15 would simply have shown a straight line whose slope would be a constant determined by the deformation gradient FCu→Cuα that relates reference and final configurations. The steps that are actually observed in the plots of disregistry components shown in Fig. 15 are therefore the result of the tendency of the deformation to localize into compact regions and indicate the presence of a set of interface dislocations lying along directions ξˆ in the KS1 interface. This array of dislocations is termed “set 1.” The sections of steepest slope in Fig. 15 correspond to the locations of dislocation cores and coincide with the shaded strips in Fig. 14. Meanwhile, the nearly horizontal sections indicate regions of the relaxed KS1 configuration that are located in-between successive dislocations and whose structure is close to that of the unrelaxed coherent reference state. Similar reasoning has led to the detection of interface dislocations in other heterophase interfaces, such as those found in Cu/Ni and Cu/Ag multilayer composites [14]. Several important parameters characterizing dislocation set 1 can be read from the plot in Fig. 15. The difference in the levels of successive horizontal sections for disregistry component r · ξˆ equals the magnitude of the screw component bs of the Burgers vector of the
§3.3
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
165
Table 1 Physical quantities characterizing the two sets of interfacial dislocations present in the Cu/Nb interface in KS1 , stated as mean ±1 standard deviation Dislocation set
Line angle θ (deg)
Line spacing s (nm)
Edge component (nm)
Screw component (nm)
Core width we
Core width ws
1 2
−27 −68
2.17 ± 0.08 0.89 ± 0.03
0.969±0.016 0.011 ± 0.001 >0.9 NA
Burgers vector be
Burgers vector bs
0.911 ± 0.017 0.261 ± 0.005 0.423 ± 0.04 0.075 ± 0.004
Fig. 16. Disregistry components r · nˆ (edge) and r · ξˆ (screw) for interfacial dislocation set 2 (see text) as functions of the component (x, z) · nˆ of disregistry position.
dislocations. Similarly, the magnitude of the edge component be of the dislocations’ Burgers vector is the difference in levels between horizontal sections in the plot of disregistry component r · n. ˆ The spacing s between dislocations is the distance between their core centers while their core widths ws and we are the distances separating successive horizontal regions in the screw and edge components, respectively. The mean values of quantities bs , be , s, ws , and we determined from Fig. 15 are given in Table 1. The line direction of dislocations in set 1 is given as the angle θ measured counterclockwise from the interface horizontal direction in Fig. 14. One can define another set of dislocations – termed “set 2” – by performing the analysis described above, except this time applying deformation gradient FNb→Nbα to the Nb side of the unrelaxed KS1 configuration to create the strained reference state. Proceeding as before, we again find that there exist distinct strips within the interface – whose line direction differs from dislocation set 1 – where the disregistry vector magnitudes undergo the fastest changes. The plot in Fig. 16 is analogous to the one in Fig. 15 and shows the edge and
166
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
screw components of disregistry vectors for the line direction of dislocation set 2. Fig. 16 reveals that a distinct dislocation spacing, core width, and Burgers vector magnitude can be determined for the screw component of these dislocations, but not for the edge component. This observation implies either that no set of edge dislocations corresponding to the screw dislocations seen in Fig. 16 exists or that its core widths exceed the dislocation line spacing. Given that the screw component line spacing is about 0.9 nm, the assumption of overlapping edge components for dislocation set 2 seems plausible. Table 1 lists the values of θ , bs , be , s, ws , and we for dislocation set 2.
3.4. Analytical interpretation of KS1 dislocation content A coherent reference state where both the Cu {111} and Nb {110} interface planes are strained to have the α-geometry (see Section 3.2) has special properties that are convenient for the purpose of disregistry analysis. These properties can best be presented in the framework for computing the dislocation content of an interface using the Frank–Bilby formula [1,26]. This approach considers an interface between crystals with lattices A and B, as shown in Fig. 17(a) and supposes that these lattices are related by homogeneous displacement gradients F A and F B to a common coherent reference lattice, shown in Fig. 17(b). Lattice A can be obtained by operating with F A on the reference lattice while lattice B can be obtained by operating with F B on the reference lattice. Vector p is an arbitrary vector chosen in the plane of the interface between A and B and emanating from the origin O. When mapped into the coherent reference configuration, this vector can take on two different values, depending on whether it is mapped from the A lattice or from the B lattice. If mapped from the A lattice, p takes on the value F A−1 p in the common coherent reference configuration, where F A−1 is the inverse of F A . Alternatively, if mapped from the B lattice, p takes on the value F B−1 p in the common coherent reference configuration, where F B−1 is the inverse F B . Suppose the Burgers circuit in the
Fig. 17. (a) A Burgers circuit constructed across the interface between lattice A and lattice B beginning at point S. Vector p is an arbitrary interface vector from the origin O terminating at S. (b) The Burgers circuit in (a) constructed in a coherent reference lattice. If lattice A is obtained from the reference lattice through a homogeneous deformation F A and lattice B is similarly constructed using F B , then the Burgers circuit has the closure failure dashed arrow. B = (F A−1 − F B−1 )p,
§3.4
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
167
configuration shown in Fig. 17(a) is constructed beginning at the starting point S – the endpoint of vector p – and proceeding counterclockwise as shown by the arrows. Because p is mapped differently into the reference configuration depending on whether it is mapped from lattice A or lattice B, the Burgers circuit in the reference configuration shown in Using the finish-to-start convention [22], one can Fig. 17(b) contains a closure failure B. write this closure failure B = F A−1 − F B−1 p. (17) Eq. (17) is known as the Frank–Bilby equation and computes the sum B of Burgers vectors of interfacial dislocations crossed by vector p. Because this equation is based on a purely geometrical analysis of lattices A and B, it cannot provide information about properties that depend strongly on the nature of interatomic interactions in a given material. For example, it cannot say how the Burgers vector sum B is partitioned among individual interfacial dislocations. Thus, in fcc materials it does not distinguish between perfect 1 2 110 dislocations and ones that have dissociated into Shockley partials. It cannot be used to compute dislocation core widths and so does not predict if B is spread out over a wide area of the interface or concentrated into compact dislocation cores separated by regions of coherency. Instead, the Frank–Bilby equation should be regarded as defining the average Burgers vector b¯ crossed per unit length of an infinite line lying in the A–B interface along the direction specified by the unit vector p: ˆ A−1 b¯ = F (18) ˆ − F B−1 p. Another limitation of the analysis of interfacial dislocation content based on the Frank– Bilby equation is that this equation does not by itself provide a full dislocation-based model for a given pair of displacement gradients F A and F B : in general the same distribution of Burgers vector content b¯ with direction pˆ can be obtained using different combinations of line directions ξˆi , Burgers vectors b i , and normal spacings si for n sets of parallel dislocations i = 1, . . . , n. Nevertheless, under certain restricted conditions, e.g. in the case of grain boundaries formed exclusively from glide dislocations in materials with one or two slip systems [22], the number n of sets of parallel dislocations present in that interface along with their line directions ξˆi , Burgers vectors b i , and spacings si (i = 1, . . . , n) can be determined. In the case of the Kurdjumov–Sachs interface between Cu and Nb additional information is contained in the description of the α-geometry (Section 3.2). As shown below, this information is sufficient to give a full dislocation-based model of the Cu/Nb interface. The following analysis is restricted to the interface plane between Cu and Nb, so the displacement gradients F A and F B are rank-2 tensors of dimension 2. We define the Frank–Bilby operator M = (F A−1 − F B−1 ). Diagonalization of M yields a pair of eigenvalues λ1 and λ2 as well as their associated eigenvectors v 1 and v 2 (M v i = λi v i , no summation implied). If one of the eigenvalues equals zero, for example λ1 = 0, then the associated eigenvector v 1 specifies a direction of zero dislocation content (the possibility of crossing lines of dislocation dipoles is ignored). This situation implies either that the interface contains no dislocations – in which case λ2 = 0 as well – or that it contains only one set of dislocations whose line direction ξˆ is identical to the direction of
168
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 18. The arrangement of a set of parallel interfacial dislocations implied by a Frank–Bilby operator M = (F A−1 − F B−1 ) that has one eigenvalue λ1 = 0 and another λ2 = 0.
v 1 : ξˆ = vˆ1 . If the latter is the case, then the second eigenvector v 2 lies along a direction whose interface Burgers vector content also lies along that direction, i.e. v 2 specifies the direction of the Burgers vector of the dislocations whose line direction is given by v 1 . The eigenvalue λ2 associated with v 2 gives their Burgers vector content per unit distance along v 2 and therefore relates their spacing s to the magnitude of their Burgers vector b. If l is the distance that must be traveled along direction vˆ2 for the intersected interface Burgers vector content to equal b, then |λ2 |l = b. The spacing between dislocations is then the component of l vˆ2 that lies along the interface direction nˆ normal to v 1 , i.e. s = l vˆ2 · nˆ = l cos( π2 − γ ) = l sin(γ ) where γ is the angle between v 1 and v 2 , as shown in Fig. 18. The
dislocation spacing therefore can be written s = l 1 − cos2 (γ ) = l 1 − (vˆ1 · vˆ2 )2 and the following relation between |λ2 |, s, and b is obtained: |λ2 | =
b
1 − (vˆ1 · vˆ2 )2 . s
(19)
The Frank–Bilby equation does not allow s and b to be determined independently, but only as a ratio. A given value of λ2 therefore does not distinguish between a set of dislocations with spacing s and Burgers vector b and one with spacing 2s and Burgers vector 2b, for example. The above development is directly applicable to the case of the Cu/Nb-KS interface. Taking Nb to be the A lattice, Cu to be the B lattice, and using the α-geometry coherent reference configuration as in Section 3.3, we find that eq. (18) gives b¯ = (FNb→Nbα − FCu→Cuα )p. ˆ
(20)
This expression can be rewritten as ˆ b¯ = (FNb→Nbα − I )pˆ + (I − FCu→Cuα )pˆ = MNbα →Nb pˆ + MCuα →Cu p,
(21)
where MNbα →Nb = (FNb→Nbα − I ), MCuα →Cu = (I − FCu→Cuα ).
(22)
§3.4
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
169
The individual operators MCuα →Cu and MNbα →Nb describe separately the dislocation content introduced into the Cu/Nb interface when the neighboring crystalline layers are transformed from the coherent reference configuration to fcc Cu and bcc Nb, respectively. Since the dislocation content introduced by them is additive, operators MCuα →Cu and MNbα →Nb can be applied in any order. We find it convenient, therefore, to investigate their effects separately. The expression for FCu→Cuα in eq. (10) can be used in conjunction with eq. (22) to obtain the formula for the operator MCuα →Cu . Diagonalizing this operator yields the following eigenvalues and eigenvectors: √ √ 2aCu − 3aNb λ1 = 0, v 1 = 1, , aCu − aNb √ √ aNb , v 2 = [1, − 3 ]. λ2 = 1 + 2( 6 − 3) (23) aCu Next, using eq. (16) for FNb→Nbα with eq. (22), we find the operator MNbα →Nb and diagonalize it to give √ √ 2 3aNb − 2 2aCu λ1 = 0, v 1 = 1, , aCu − 2aNb √ 3 √ aCu − 1, v 2 = [1, 2 ]. λ2 = ( 6 − 2) (24) 2 aNb These two operators each have one zero and one non-zero eigenvalue. Thus, each of them describes the addition of exactly one set of parallel interfacial dislocations with line direction ξˆ = vˆ1 , Burgers vector direction bˆ = vˆ2 , and Burgers vector magnitude and disloca
b tion spacing related by |λ2 | = s 1 − (vˆ1 · vˆ2 )2 . This last equation connects b as measured in the reference configuration to s measured in the actual configuration. For comparison with disregistry analysis, it is convenient to find a relation between these quantities when both are measured in the reference configuration. Observing that the direction bˆ is invariant under the operation of the displacement gradients found in the definitions in eq. (22) but lengths along this direction are stretched by the factor λ2 = 1/(1 − |λ2 |), we obtain √ 1−(vˆ1 ·vˆ2 )2 √ where both quantities in the ratio (s/b)R are measured in the |λ2 | = 2 (s/b)R +
1−(vˆ1 ·vˆ2 )
reference configuration, as indicated by the subscript. Nb demonA comparison of the Burgers vector directions v 2 with 110Cu 1 and 100 strates that v 2 for MCuα →Cu is parallel to 110Cu 2 for MNbα →Nb is parallel to 1 while v Nb 100 . Assuming that the Burgers vector magnitudes are equal to one nearest neighbor distance along these directions, one can find the values of the dislocation spacing from the previously developed relation between |λ2 | and (s/b)R . Table 2 lists the values characterizing the sets of dislocations associated with MCuα →Cu and MNbα →Nb calculated using the analytical method described above and compares them with the values for dislocation sets 1 and 2 obtained from atomic-scale simulations, presented in Section 3.3. The quantitative agreement between MCuα →Cu and set 1 as well as MNbα →Nb and set 2 is excellent, confirming the accuracy of the analytical treatment presented here.
170
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Table 2 Comparison between values characterizing the dislocation sets predicted analytically by operators MCuα →Cu and MNbα →Nb with the values obtained from atomic scale simulations in Section 3.3 (Table 1) Quantity
Line angle θ (deg) Line spacing s (nm) Edge comp. be (nm) Screw comp. bs (nm)
MCuα →Cu = (I − FCu→Cuα ), set 1
MNbα →Nb = (FNb→Nbα − I ), set 2
Theory
Simulation
Theory
Simulation
−27.44 2.12 0.0114 0.2554
−27 2.17 ± 0.08 0.011 ± 0.001 0.261 ± 0.005
−67.95 0.907 0.3213 0.0755
−68 0.89 ± 0.03 NA 0.075 ± 0.004
The methods described above are useful not only in the analysis of the dislocation content of interfaces but also in the construction of interfaces with some desired dislocation content. This capability is used later in this study. If the operator M = (I − F −1 ) has an eigenvector v with associated eigenvalue λ, then simple algebraic manipulation shows that v is also an eigenvector of operator F with associated eigenvalue λ = 1/(1 − λ). A zero eigenvalue of M therefore corresponds to a unity eigenvalue of F , i.e. it is associated with an eigendirection v that remains unaltered by the deformation. Thus, the displacement gradient F that produces a change in interface dislocation content corresponding to a single ˆ set of dislocations with line direction ξˆ , Burgers vector magnitude and direction b and b, and spacing s is given by 1 0 ˆ −1 . ˆ ˆ [ξˆ b] F = [ξ b] 0 (25) √s 2 s−b
ˆ 1−(ξˆ ·b)
3.5. Interface dislocations in KS2 Disregistry analysis may be conducted on both of the interfaces in KS2 using the same methods as were applied to the interface in KS1 . For the Nb/Cuα interface, a coherent reference state is found by applying the displacement gradient FNb→Nbα to the Nb layer. The disregistry found between this reference state and the relaxed KS2 configuration indicates the presence of a set of dislocations with the same line directions and Burgers vectors as the ones characteristic of dislocation set 2 discussed in Section 3.3. Fig. 19 shows the screw and edge components of the calculated disregistry as a function of position normal to the dislocation line direction while Table 3 lists the properties of this dislocation set determined from Fig. 19. Because displacement gradient FNb→Nbα describes the presence of exactly one set of dislocations and no displacement gradient need be applied to the Cuα monolayer to bring it into the chosen coherent reference configuration, there can be no more interfacial dislocations in the Nb/Cuα interface of the KS2 configuration. Similarly, in the Cuα /Cu interface there can only be one set of interfacial dislocations associated with the displacement gradient FCu→Cuα with direction matching that of dislocation set 1 in KS1 . A strained reference state used for computing disregistry across the Cuα /Cu interface is created by applying the displacement gradient FCu→Cuα to the Cu layer of the unre-
§3.5
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
171
Fig. 19. Disregistry components r · nˆ (edge) and r · ξˆ (screw) for the interfacial dislocation set in the Nb/Cuα interface of KS2 as functions of the component (x, z) · nˆ of disregistry position.
Table 3 Physical quantities characterizing the interfacial dislocations present in the Nb/Cuα and Cuα /Cu interfaces in KS2 , stated as mean ±1 standard deviation KS2 interface
Line angle θ (deg)
Line spacing s (nm)
Edge component (nm)
Screw component (nm)
Core width we
Core width ws
Burgers vector bs
Cuα /Cu Nb/Cuα
−27 −68
2.18 ± 0.04 0.89 ± 0.02
0.986±0.008 0.011 ± 0.001 >0.9 NA
2.06 ± 0.33 0.404±0.015
0.248±0.003 0.074±0.002
Burgers vector be
laxed KS2 configuration. The final state of the interface is taken to be the one found in the relaxed KS2 configuration. Results of this disregistry analysis are presented in Fig. 20, showing the screw and edge disregistry components as a function of position normal to the dislocation line direction. The edge component in Fig. 20 would suggest the presence of a set of dislocations with a spacing that matches that of dislocation set 1 in KS1 (Table 1). The screw components in Fig. 20, however, are much less clear: they either do not exist or have overlapping cores. The analytical treatment of Section 3.4, however, provides a way of resolving the above dilemma. Specifying a dislocation spacing s twice as large as in set 1 (Table 1), eq. (25) can be used to construct a displacement gradient FCuα →Cuβ that introduces a single set of interface dislocations with line direction identical to set 1 but only half the Burgers vector content of set 1. A Cuβ monolayer created from a perfect Cu {111} plane using FCu→Cuβ = FCuα →Cuβ · FCu→Cuα is said to be in the β-geometry, which is intermediate between that of a Cu {111} plane and the α-geometry. In analogy to KS2 , a configuration with a Cuβ interfacial monolayer contains two interfaces: Nb/Cuβ and Cuβ /Cu. Fig. 21 shows Nb/Cuβ in its relaxed state.
172
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 20. Disregistry components r · nˆ (edge) and r · ξˆ (screw) for the interfacial dislocation set in the Cuα /Cu interface of KS2 (see text) as functions of the component (x, z) · nˆ of disregistry position.
Fig. 21. The relaxed Nb/Cuβ interface looking normal to the interface plane. Compact sites of congruency between the Cu (light) and Nb (dark) planes like the ones seen in the KS1 Cu/Nb interface (Fig. 8) are observed in this interface as well, though the unit cell of the repetitive pattern they form is twice as large as in KS1 .
§3.5
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
173
Fig. 22. Disregistry components r · nˆ (edge) and r · ξˆ (screw) for the interfacial dislocation set in the Nb/Cuβ interface as functions of the component (x, z) · nˆ of disregistry position.
Fig. 23. Disregistry components r · nˆ (edge) and r · ξˆ (screw) for the interfacial dislocation set in the Cuβ /Cu interface as functions of the component (x, z) · nˆ of disregistry position. The screw component of disregistry displays peaks and valleys not seen in Fig. 22 indicating that additional dissociation has occurred.
Disregistry computed along the line direction of dislocation set 1 for the Nb/Cuβ inter−1 face using displacement gradient FCuβ →Cuα = FCu α →Cuβ to construct the coherent referβ ence state from the unrelaxed Cu monolayer leads to the plots in Fig. 22. Comparison with Fig. 15 shows that the dislocation spacing in Nb/Cuβ is twice that seen in set 1, as expected. Furthermore, the undercoordinated patches in Nb/Cuβ (Fig. 21) are found to lie along the dislocation cores located by an analysis of Fig. 22. Disregistry analysis along the line direction of dislocation set 1 for the Cuβ /Cu interface using displacement gradient FCu→Cuβ to construct the coherent reference state from the unrelaxed fcc Cu {111} plane leads to the plots in Fig. 23. Unlike the case of the Cuα /Cu interface in KS2 (Fig. 20), these plots do confirm the presence of a distinct set of dislo-
174
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Table 4 Properties of point defects in fcc Cu. Formation energies and volumes are defined as Eform = E(N ) − N · U and Vform = V (N ) − N · . E(N ) and V (N ) are the energy and volume of a relaxed system containing a defect, N is the number of atoms in the system, and U and are the cohesive energy and volume per atom Defect Method
Cu vacancy EAM
Lowest energy Cu interstitial Exp./DFT
EAM: 100 dumbbell
1.27, Exp.a 9.21 × 10−3 , Exp.b
2.8–4.2, Exp.c 4.13 × 10−3 – 8.86 × 10−3 , Exp.c 0.55 N/A <0.45, ∼0.77 on 101 N/A
Exp./DFT: 100 dumbbell
Visualization Formation energy (eV) 1.26 Formation volume (nm3 ) 8.78 × 10−3
Core radius (nm) Critical distance for Frenkel pair annihilation (nm)
0.55 N/A <0.45, ∼0.77 on 101 N/A
3.24 12.55 × 10−3
a [61]. b [62]. c [63].
cations with screw component equal to that found for dislocation set 1. The width of the dislocation cores is comparable to the spacing of set 1 dislocations, explaining why they could not be unambiguously distinguished by direct analysis of the Cuα /Cu interface in KS2 (Fig. 20). Also, unlike the case in Fig. 22, the dislocations present in this interface have undergone additional dissociation, as evidenced by the small peaks and valleys that appear in the screw component of disregistry. The physical quantities that characterize dislocations present in the Cuα /Cu interface of KS2 – listed in Table 3 – have therefore been deduced from the Frank–Bilby operator MCuα →Cu and from disregistry analysis performed on interface Cuβ /Cu. A comparison of Tables 1 and 3 now allows a clear understanding of the relationship between KS1 and KS2 to be developed. Each of them contains two sets of dislocations. Set 2 dislocations are closely spaced, have predominantly edge character, and arise by the operation of displacement gradient FNb→Nbα on the bcc Nb {110} plane. In both KS1 and KS2 , they are found at the interface between Nb and the adjacent Cu plane. Set 1 dislocations have a larger spacing than set 2, are of predominantly screw character, and arise by the operation of displacement gradient FCu→Cuα on the fcc Cu {111} plane. In KS1 this set of dislocations resides between the interfacial Nb {110} plane and the adjacent Cu {111} plane. In KS2 , however, it is present in the Cuα /Cu interface. In the following section, we show that this difference between KS1 and KS2 has important consequences for the behavior of vacancies and interstitials near Cu/Nb-KS interfaces.
§4
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
175
Table 5 Properties of point defects in bcc Nb. Formation energies and volumes are defined as in Table 4 Defect Method
Nb vacancy
Lowest energy NB interstitial
EAM
Exp./DFT
EAM: 100 dumbbell
Exp./DFT: 100 dumbbell
Formation energy (eV)
2.75
3.11
5.25, DFTc
Formation volume (nm3 ) Core radius (nm) Critical distance for Frenkel pair annihilation (nm)
13.92 × 10−3 0.71 <0.35
2.7–3, Exp.a 2.92, DFTb N/A N/A N/A
−7.71 × 10−3 0.71 <0.35
N/A N/A N/A
Visualization
a [63]. b [64]. c [65].
4. Vacancies and interstitials in Cu/Nb interfaces 4.1. Interface behavior upon atom insertion or removal In perfect crystal fcc Cu and bcc Nb point defects are compact and well localized. Tables 4 and 5 compare point defect properties as predicted by the Cu/Nb EAM potential used in this study with experimental and first principles values, where available. Quantitative agreement among the data is mixed, but in all cases the point defects that they characterize share the common characteristic of being confined to a single well-defined location within an otherwise crystalline lattice. The effect of removing or inserting atoms in Cu/Nb interfaces differs markedly from the formation of vacancies or interstitials in Cu and Nb crystals. To reach its lowest energy state, an interface arrangement with an added or removed atom must be relaxed at finite temperature by MD – allowing individual atoms to overcome small energy barriers that trap these atoms in metastable states – followed by PEM to remove thermal agitation. A special technique was developed to perform these operations efficiently based on the observation that the insertion or removal of an interfacial atom at a given site does not alter the structure of the entire interface area enclosed in the simulation cell, but only that of a certain region or “spot” within the vicinity of that site. Annealing by MD and relaxation by PEM need therefore only be applied at that spot, while the rest of the atoms in the simulation cell remain fixed and are excluded from the energy and force calculations. After this “spot relaxation,” the composite model is relaxed by PEM. The MD part of spot relaxation was carried out at a temperature T = 300 K for 10 ps.
176
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 24. Dependence of vacancy formation energies in Cu and Nb as functions of distance normal to the Cu/Nb interface in the KS1 configuration.
While one can create a vacancy in an atomic scale simulation of a solid by simply deleting an atom, the creation of an interstitial requires some prior knowledge of the locations where a new atom could be inserted. The interstitial sites for common crystal lattices are known [63], but no such tabulation exists for complicated atomic arrangements like the ones found at aperiodic interfaces. In this study, candidate sites for atom insertion were taken to be the vertices and face centers of Voronoi polyhedra constructed around atoms in whose neighborhood we wish to create the interstitial [66]. Although there is no guarantee that this method necessarily finds all favorable insertion locations in any arbitrarily selected atom configuration, it does find all of the interstitial sites tabulated for fcc, bcc, and hcp lattices [63]. Figs 24 through 27 present the vacancy and interstitial formation energies in the Cu and Nb layers as a function of initial position normal to the Cu/Nb interface for both the KS1 and KS2 configurations. In all cases, defect formation energies away from the interface approach the formation energy of the corresponding defect in a perfect crystal (Tables 4 and 5). At 1 nm or less from the interface, however, defects interact with the interface and their formation energies decrease. At the interface, the formation energies for both vacancies and interstitials are significantly reduced compared to their perfect crystal values. Figs 25 and 27 show that the formation energies of some Cu interstitials at distances from the interface as large as 1 nm are similar to those inside the Cu/Nb interface. The reason for such low formation energy values can be found by tracking the process of PEM relaxation of the defect configuration, as shown in Fig. 28. In Fig. 28(a) the defect configuration
§4.1
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
177
Fig. 25. Dependence of interstitial formation energies in Cu and Nb as functions of distance normal to the Cu/Nb interface in the KS1 configuration.
Fig. 26. Dependence of vacancy formation energies in Cu and Nb as functions of distance normal to the Cu/Nb interface in the KS2 configuration.
178
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 27. Dependence of interstitial formation energies in Cu and Nb as functions of distance normal to the Cu/Nb interface in the KS2 configuration.
Fig. 28. The process of relaxation by potential energy minimization (PEM) of a 110 split dumbbell interstitial inserted at a distance of 1 nm away from the Cu/Nb interface in the KS1 configuration. Only atoms with high excess potential energy are shown.
is created at the desired initial location within the Cu crystal. This initial location value is used when plotting the defect formation energies in Figs 25 and 27. The relaxation progresses as shown in Figs 28(b)–28(d). Eventually [in Fig. 28(d)] the defect is absorbed into the interface, explaining the low formation energy value for such defects. Because this relaxation was conducted by PEM without any thermal agitation, the absorption of the defect into the interface is spontaneous and involves either very small or no barriers to migration. Figs 8, 12, and 13 reveal that not all atomic sites in Cu/Nb-KS interfaces are structurally equivalent and therefore the properties of vacancies and interstitials vary accordingly with location. The position-dependence of interface vacancy formation energies for KS1 and
§4.1
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
179
(a)
(b) Fig. 29. Position dependence of vacancy formation energies in KS1 configuration: (a) in interfacial Nb {110} plane, (b) in interfacial Cu {111} plane.
KS2 are shown in Figs 29 and 30, respectively. This position dependence follows the same repetitive patterns shown earlier (Fig. 8). The structure changes occurring in Cu/Nb interfaces upon atom removal or insertion reveal the origin of the low formation energies of interfacial defects. Fig. 31(a) shows the configuration of a region of the Cu {111} plane in a KS1 configuration after removal of an atom. Unlike a vacancy in a perfect fcc Cu crystal, the defect is delocalized. The insertion of an atom also leads to a delocalized formation, as shown in Fig. 31(b).
180
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
(a)
Ch. 83
(b)
(c) Fig. 30. Position dependence of vacancy formation energies in KS2 configuration: (a) in interfacial Nb {110} plane, (b) in interfacial Cuα monolayer, (c) in fcc Cu {111} plane adjacent to Cuα monolayer.
Changes in individual atomic volumes in the vicinity of sites of atom removal or insertion in the interfacial Cu plane are shown in Fig. 32. The large spatial extent of these atomic volume changes confirms that atom removal and insertion does not result in the formation of compact point defects. Rather, the local perturbation associated with atom removal or insertion spreads out in a region of the interface approximately 3 nm in diameter, considerably larger than the size of the point defect core region in perfect crystal (Table 4). Similar results are observed to accompany atom removal and insertion in the KS2 configuration. The delocalization of point defects in the Cu interface plane carries significant consequences for the annihilation of vacancy–interstitial pairs. An example of particular importance concerns Frenkel pairs that may be produced in the neighboring Cu layer by radia-
§4.1
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
181
(a)
(b) Fig. 31. (a) Relaxed Cu/Nb interface atomic arrangement after removal of an interfacial Cu atom from the KS1 configuration. (b) Relaxed Cu/Nb interface atomic arrangement after insertion of a Cu atom into the interfacial Cu {111} plane of the KS1 configuration. Light atoms are Cu and dark ones are Nb.
tion. The rate at which these defect pairs annihilate is an important factor in determining the useful lifetime of a material subject to radiation damage with higher recombination efficiency corresponding to enhanced radiation damage resistance. A comparison of the critical distance for vacancy–interstitial pair recombination in perfect fcc Cu (Table 4) with the critical distance for the analogous process to occur at Cu/Nb interfaces reflects the advantage that interfaces offer in promoting radiation resistance.
182
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
(a)
(b) Fig. 32. Changes in the volumes of atomic environments in the vicinity of atom (a) removal or (b) insertion in the interfacial Cu {111} plane of KS1 indicate the extent of delocalization of defects in the interface plane. 2 2 In these plots, red dots indicate atom sites where > 0.02 Å , blue indicate < −0.02 Å , and green 2 ∈ [−0.02, 0.02] Å . For comparison, the black circles identify the size of the volume of fcc Cu similarly affected by the presence of a vacancy or interstitial. (For interpretation of the references to color in this figure legend the reader is referred to the web version of this chapter.)
§4.2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
183
The following methodology provides a measure of the annihilation enhancement provided by interfaces relative to perfect a crystal. Let Eins be the change in energy for insertion of an atom at a given interface location r ins , Erem the change in energy for removal of an atom from some other interface location r rem , and Eins−rem the resulting change in energy if an atom is inserted at r ins and some other atom is removed at r rem . If the removal and insertion occur at locations sufficiently remote from each other then the regions affected by these perturbations will not interact with the simple result that Eins–rem = Erem + Erem .
(26)
If on the other hand insertion and removal occur at sufficiently close locations then the areas affected by the insertion and removal interact and Eins–rem = Erem + Erem + Eint ,
(27)
where Eint is the removal–insertion interaction energy. Finally, at some small enough distance between sites of removal and insertion the effects of these two perturbations will cancel, resulting in the initial undefected interface configuration. Then Eins–rem = 0,
(28)
corresponding to vacancy–interstitial recombination. Figs 33 and 34 show plots of Eint (computed from Eint = Eins−rem − Erem − Erem ) vs. r rem in the KS1 and KS2 interfacial Cu layers for atom insertion with the specified Eins value. These figures demonstrate that insertion–removal cancellation typically occurs within a region of radius 1.5 nm in the Cu interfacial plane of Cu/Nb interfaces. Because this radius is appreciably larger than the one seen in crystalline Cu, interfaces in Cu/Nb multilayer composites can reduce radiation damage in this material by acting as catalysts for enhancing vacancy–interstitial recombination efficiency. By contrast with the interfacial Cu plane, the consequences of removal or insertion of atoms in the interfacial Nb plane are different. Interfacial Nb vacancies [Fig. 35(a)] and interstitials [Fig. 35(b)] are compact and well localized and the critical distance for Frenkel pair recombination is not increased as markedly as in the Cu interface plane, as shown in Fig. 36. An atomic arrangement with an interfacial Nb vacancy may lower its energy by exchanging with an interfacial Cu atom creating a Cu vacancy as shown in Fig. 37(a), followed by delocalization of the Cu vacancy as in Fig. 31. An analogous process occurs in the case of atomic arrangements containing Nb interfacial interstitials, whereby the Nb interstitial moves to the Cu side, as shown in Fig. 37(b). The mechanisms that aid rapid recombination of radiation-induced Frenkel pairs in the Cu layer can therefore also indirectly aid recombination of Frenkel pairs formed in Nb if they migrate to the interfacial Cu plane. 4.2. Interaction with interface dislocations Fig. 38(a) shows the relaxed state of the interfacial Cu plane in KS1 after removal of an atom from a site with low Erem . Nearest neighbors in this interface plane form rings with
184
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
(a)
(b) Fig. 33. Estimates of the critical radius for vacancy–interstitial annihilation in the interfacial Cu plane in KS1 as a function of r rem for (a) Eins = 0.68 eV and (b) Eins = 2.00 eV. Black regions are sites where the cancellation condition Eint < −Erem − Erem + ε is satisfied (ε = 0.1 eV). The black circle indicates the critical distance for vacancy–interstitial annihilation in perfect fcc Cu.
5, 4, or 3 members and atoms are colored according to the size of the largest ring of which they are a part. Burgers circuits constructed around different sections of this configuration using undefected KS1 as a reference state reveal the presence of closure failures, as shown in Fig. 38(b). These closure failures suggest that the interface arrangement resulting from the removal of an atom can be described as a small dislocation loop as visualized in Fig. 39.
§4.2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
185
(a)
(b) Fig. 34. Estimates of the critical radius for vacancy–interstitial annihilation in the interfacial Cuα plane in KS2 as a function of r rem for (a) Eins = 1.27 eV and (b) Eins = 0.84 eV. Black regions are sites that satisfy the cancellation condition, as in Fig. 33.
A similar analysis can be carried out on the defected interface configuration resulting from the insertion of an atom into the interfacial Cu plane in KS1 , as shown in Fig. 40. The interface configurations in Figs 38 and 40 are represented schematically in Fig. 41. A compact point defect can be viewed as a dislocation loop of atomic dimensions, as pictured in Fig. 41(a). If two edge line sections located on opposite sides of the loop glide apart then additional lengths of screw dislocation are created, as in Fig. 41(b). For an isolated dislocation loop, such an expansion would be energetically unfavorable due to the
186
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
(a)
(b) Fig. 35. (a) Relaxed Cu/Nb interface atomic arrangement after removal of an interfacial Nb atom from the KS1 configuration. (b) Relaxed Cu/Nb interface atomic arrangement after insertion of a Nb atom into the interfacial Nb {110} plane of the KS1 configuration. Light atoms are Cu and dark ones are Nb.
creation of these extra screw segments. If, however, such dissociation were to occur in the vicinity of an existing screw dislocation (like a set 1 dislocation) with Burgers vector opposite to that of the dislocation loop – as in Fig. 41(c) – then one screw segment could annihilate with the adjacent section of the pre-existing dislocation resulting in the lower energy configuration shown in Fig. 41(d).
§4.2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
187
(a)
(b) Fig. 36. Estimates of the critical radius for vacancy–interstitial annihilation in the interfacial Nb plane as a function of r rem for (a) Eins = 2.10 eV in KS1 and (b) Eins = 0.83 eV in KS2 . Black regions are sites that satisfy the cancellation condition, as in Fig. 33.
The closure failures seen in the analyses of Figs 38 and 40 are due to the presence of extended jog pairs formed on pre-existing set 1 screw dislocations (see Section 3.3), as illustrated in Fig. 41(d). In the section of interface between the jogs, a segment of a set 1 dislocation has climbed by one atom plane. Thus, because set 1 dislocations in KS1 are located at the interface between Cu and Nb while in KS2 they are present in the Cuα /Cu interface, the section of interface between the jogs can be viewed as having been converted
188
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
(a)
(b) Fig. 37. Examples of sites for which it is energetically favorable for (a) an interfacial Cu atom to exchange with an interfacial Nb vacancy and (b) for a Nb interfacial interstitial to become an interstitial in the interfacial Cu plane. Light atoms are Cu and dark are Nb.
from KS1 to KS2 . Finally, because the spacing between jogs in a relaxed interface configuration after atom removal or insertion is approximately 0.75 nm, St. Venant’s principle indicates that the elastic fields of two such configurations would extend over a large enough distance to cause the cancellation of atom removal–insertion operations over a distance of about 1.5 nm, as described in Section 4.1.
4.3. KSmin In both KS1 and KS2 there are sites where the energy of the configuration decreases when an interfacial Cu atom is removed (Figs 24 and 26). This implies that a third, lower energy
§4.3
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
189
(a)
(b) Fig. 38. (a) Groups of nearest-neighbor atoms in the relaxed atomic arrangement of an interfacial Cu plane of KS1 after atom removal can form 5-, 4-, and 3-membered rings. Atoms are colored by the size of the largest ring of which they are a part black 5, light-gray 4, gray 3 (most atoms are gray, as would be expected for a Cu {111} plane). (b) Construction of Burgers circuits around different groups of atomic environments reveals the presence of closure failures.
(or, perhaps, lowest energy) interface structure, KSmin , can be found by removing the appropriate number of Cu atoms from either KS1 or KS2 . There is some difficulty in finding KSmin because the removal of an atom from a site changes the value of Erem for all atoms in the vicinity of that site. The information contained in Figs 29(b) and 30(b) therefore is not sufficient to construct KSmin . Instead, we employed an iterative approach where atoms
190
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 39. The closure failures found in Fig. 38(b) are indicative of the presence of a small dislocation loop like the one visualized above. The dashed arrows indicate extra atom rows.
are removed from different sites within a given interface configuration until a site with negative Erem is found. Once such a site is found, the interface configuration with the atom removed from that site is taken as the new starting point for the determination of Erem and the process is continued until an interface configuration is found where there are no sites with negative Erem . This procedure was applied using both KS1 and KS2 as starting configurations. In both cases, final interface structures were found with areal densities of Cu atoms in the interface plane that are 5% lower than in a perfect fcc Cu {111} plane, corresponding to an inplane vacancy concentration of 0.05. Using the formalism of Martin and coworkers [67], one can describe this vacancy concentration by the effective temperature Teff at which the same concentration would be present in perfect fcc Cu. With the formation energy in Table 4, Boltzmann weighting gives Teff = 4650 K ≈ 3.4TmCu , where TmCu is the melting temperature of Cu. Fig. 42 shows the atomic arrangement of the interfacial Cu plane in a KSmin configuration with atoms colored by the size of the largest ring of which they are a part, as previously. The atoms that are part of 4- and 5-membered rings are locations of excess volume associated with delocalized interface vacancies and are found to follow a repetitive pattern with a unit cell like that in the KS1 configuration (Fig. 8). The Cu interface plane shown in Fig. 42, however, does not posses a strict periodicity implying that other arrangements like it can be constructed by simply changing the order of appearance of the repetitive features seen in Fig. 42. Moreover, at elevated temperature the excess volume around atoms that are part of 4- and 5-membered rings may further delocalize due to the multitude of atomic configurations that this interface can exhibit. There is therefore no guarantee that the determination of KSmin described here finds the interface configuration with absolute lowest energy, but rather that it has given a representative member of an ensemble of interface configurations with nearly degenerate energies. The interface energies and areal densities of the interfacial Cu plane in the three Cu/Nb interface configurations KS1 , KS2 , and KSmin for the interatomic potential used in this study are summarized in Table 6.
§4.3
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
191
(a)
(b) Fig. 40. (a) Groups of nearest neighbor atoms in the relaxed atomic arrangement of an interfacial Cu plane of KS1 after atom insertion can form 5-, 4-, and 3-membered rings. Atoms are colored by size of the largest ring of which they are a part: black 5, light-gray 4, gray 3. (b) Construction of Burgers circuits around different groups of atomic environments reveals the presence of closure failures, indicating that – like the atomic arrangement shown in Fig. 38(b) – this configuration can be interpreted as a small dislocation loop.
The fact that in configurations like the one shown in Fig. 42 the interfacial Cu layer has a reduced areal density compared to a perfect fcc Cu {111} plane is very likely the reason for the high solubility of He that has been observed in Cu/Nb multilayer composites [39, 41,42]. The migration of He atoms to the high excess volume sites of KSmin should reduce
192
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 41. (a) A point defect can be viewed as a dislocation loop of atomic dimensions. (b) Two opposite edge segments of the dislocation loop in (a) can glide apart leaving behind screw segments, indicated by the dashed arrows. (c) If the dissociation pictured in (b) occurs in the vicinity of a pre-existing screw dislocation with Burgers vector opposite to that of the dislocation loop, then (d) one of the screw segments could annihilate, resulting in a screw dislocation with one kink pair and one jog pair.
Fig. 42. The interfacial Cu plane in the KSmin configuration, looking normal to the interface plane. Atoms are colored by the size of the largest ring of which they are a part: black 5, light-gray 4, gray 3. Sites that belong to 4- and 5-membered rings have high excess volume and form a repetitive pattern like the one seen in KS1 (Fig. 8).
§5
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
193
Table 6 Interface energies and areal densities of the interfacial Cu plane of Cu/Nb interface configurations KS1 (Fig. 8), KS2 (Figs 12 and 13), and KSmin (Fig. 42) Configuration
Interface energy (J/m2 )
Areal density of interfacial Cu plane (atoms/nm2 )
KS1 KS2 KSmin
0.5687 0.5675 0.5414
17.74 17.58 16.82
the misfit energy that causes these atoms to precipitate out in the form of bubbles when implanted into perfect crystals.
5. Dislocation interaction with Cu/Nb interfaces 5.1. Shear strength The shear strength of an interface is defined as the critical shear stress at which irreversible sliding of one crystal with respect to the other commences along the interface. For a simplest case of the flat planar boundary, only the two in-plane components of shear displacement need to be considered. The component normal to the interface is not treated as a variable since energies are generally minimized with respect to this variable. In addition, the shear–tension coupling effect is not considered here, although the sliding strength of an interface may depend on tensile or compression normal to the boundary plane [68]. In this section we describe the shear resistance and shear response of the two types of interfaces, KS1 and KS2 , with respect to applied shear directions. For reference we first show the interface energy surface generated by rigid body shear of one crystal over the other while minimizing energy with respect to displacements normal to the interface. This is the well-known gamma surface [69]. The gamma surface for the single interfacial plane of KS1 is shown in Fig. 43(a), and for the two interfacial planes for KS2 in Figs 43(b) and 43(c). Fig. 43(d) shows the details of the low-energy region of the KS2 gamma surface from Fig. 43(c) rescaled to remove the high-energy region. These gamma surfaces imply ¯ Cu , 111 ¯ Nb , and 100Nb , and two three preferred shear directions for KS1 , along 110 ¯ preferred shear directions for KS2 along 101Cu with respect to the translation of the Cu ¯ Cu with respect to the crystal over the interfacial strained Cu monolayer, and along 011 translation of the strained Cu monolayer over Nb crystal. In what follows we have applied homogeneous shears in 6 directions, three along 110Cu and three along 112Cu parallel ¯ Cu and 011 ¯ Cu are not exactly parallel to to Cu (111). Although the two directions, 101 ¯ Cu is 5.5 two directions of the preferred shear directions in KS1 , the offset is small, 101 degrees from 100Nb . A gradually increasing shear strain is applied homogeneously to bilayer models of Cu/Nb with, KS1 and KS2 interfaces along the 6 chosen shear directions while maintaining Cu = σ Nb and σ Cu = σ Nb . The shear stresses σ equilibrium during shearing, i.e. σyx yx and yx yz yz
194
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 43. Interface energy surfaces corresponding to two-dimensional translation of one crystal over another crystal along the interface (a) between the fcc Cu crystal and bcc Nb crystal in KS1 , (b) between the fcc Cu crystal and the strained interfacial Cuα monolayer in KS2 , and (c) between the strained interfacial Cuα monolayer and the Nb crystal in KS2 . (d) A detail of (c) with high-energy regions suppressed.
σyz parallel to the interface are generated by applying the displacement gradients, ∂u/∂y and ∂w/∂y, to the two crystals, where u and w are the displacements along x and z directions, respectively. Shearing the two crystals is achieved by incrementing the applied displacement gradients ∂u/∂y and ∂w/∂y while maintaining their ratio constant at every loading step. Because of the differences in shear moduli, the ratio of displacement gradients ∂u/∂y and ∂w/∂y to maintain equilibrium in the Nb crystal differs from that in Cu. The magnitude of the displacement gradient increments also differ. Departures from equilibrium were minimized by incrementing the displacement gradients such that the shear stress increments were less than 30 MPa at each loading step. After applying the displace-
§5.1
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
195
Fig. 44. The effective shear stress as a function of the effective shear strain along the applied shear direction ¯ Cu for KS1 . 101
ment gradients increments to the two crystals, all atomic positions were then allowed to relax fully and independently until the maximum force acting on any atom in the system did not exceed 5 pN. Fig. 44 shows an example of the effective shear stress as a function of the effective shear ¯ Cu . Initially, the strain2 when the two crystals with interface KS1 are sheared along 101 effective shear stress increases linearly up to an effective shear strain of 2.3%. Continued shear causes irreversible sliding along the interface and the effective shear stress fluctuates within a range. The average of the maximum and minimum stresses is adopted as the shear resistance, which in Fig. 44 is 1.04 GPa. The locus of points of in-plane shear resistances defined this way for both KS1 and KS2 are plotted in Fig. 45. Four important features are noted. (1) The two types of interfaces have significantly lower shear resistance than the theoretical strengths estimated for the glide planes of either Cu or Nb single crystal. (2) Shear resistance is strongly anisotropic. ¯ Cu , For KS1 , the highest shear resistance, 1.10 GPa, corresponds to the shear along 112 ¯ Cu . For KS2 , however, the highest and the lowest shear resistance of 0.40 GPa along 21¯ 1 ¯ Cu , and the lowest shear shear resistance of 0.18 GPa corresponds to the shear along 011 ¯ Cu . (3) When the shear stress reaches the critical level resistance 0.06 GPa along 101 needed to induce irreversible sliding along interfaces, sliding occurs only in the interface between Cu and Nb for KS1 , but for KS2 sliding occurs on both interfaces, between the interfacial strained Cuα monolayer and Nb crystal and between the interfacial strained Cuα monolayer and Cu crystal.
2 Here, the effective shear strain is defined as ε = ε 2 + ε 2 . With the shear directions defined by the angle xy yz eff ε ), the effective shear stress is herein defined as σ = σxy cos θ +σyz sin θ . The stress components θ = tan−1 ( εxy eff yz σxy and σyz are determined from the model.
196
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 45. Two-dimensional critical shear stress diagram for both KS1 and KS2 .
Finally, (4) shear resistance is not uniform in interfaces. Irreversible sliding occurs nonuniformly, beginning within the vortical regions in KS1 interface and the large displacement regions in KS2 interface. As sliding commences occurs, dislocations are formed separating the slipped and non-slipped regions. These features are described in more detail in the following section.
5.2. Sliding mechanism The spatially nonuniform sliding in the interface is revealed by disregistry analysis [14]. This nonuniformity suggests an interface sliding mechanism in which dislocation loops nucleate in the interface and subsequently glide. For KS1 , dislocation loops nucleate initially in vortical regions. The effective shear stress evolution is plotted as a function of the effec¯ Cu . Figs 46(a), tive shear strain in Fig. 44 when the applied shear direction is along 101 46(b), 46(c), and 46(d) show the disregistry evolution corresponding to the effective shear strains of 3.0%, 4.0%, 5.0%, and 6.0%, respectively. Disregistry vectors (arrowed lines) indicate the local shear in the interface of one crystal with respect to the other. For convenience in describing the interface sliding, dashed lines estimate the boundaries separating the slipped and non-slipped regions in the interface. The lines approximate the locations of interfacial dislocations. The dashed circles in Fig. 46(a) represent dislocation loops generated by the onset of sliding in the vortical regions. As shear continues, dislocation loops expand, coalesce, and move along interfaces [Figs 46(b)–46(d)]. Disregistry vectors are
§5.2
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
197
Fig. 46. Patterns in the vector plots of disregistry showing the extent of interface sliding in KS1 for the applied ¯ Cu , corresponding to shear strains at (a) 3.0%, (b) 4.0%, (c) 5.0%, and (d) 6.0%. Dashed shear direction [101] lines outline dislocations in the interface. Arrows are disregistry vectors.
parallel to the dashed lines in Fig. 46(c), indicating the interfacial dislocations to be screw type, and correspond to the glide of set 1 dislocations. Similar behavior is observed for KS2 , with dislocation loops nucleating, expanding and gliding across the interface with increasing applied shear strain. Fig. 47(a) shows the shear ¯ Cu . stress evolution with increasing strain when the applied shear direction is along 112 Corresponding to effective shear strains of 1.0%, 1.5%, 2.0%, and 2.5%, Figs 47(b)–47(e) show the disregistry evolution of the interface between Cu crystal and the Cuα monolayer, and Figs 47(f)–47(i) show the disregistry evolution of the interface between the Cuα monolayer and Nb crystal.
198
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
¯ Cu direction for KS2 . Patterns in the Fig. 47. (a) The shear stress with increasing shear strain applied in the 112 vector plots of disregistry showing the extent of interface sliding for KS2 , corresponding to shear strains in (b) and (f) 1.0%, (c) and (g) 1.5%, (d) and (h) 2.0%, and (e) and (i) 2.5%. Dashed lines outline dislocations in the interfaces: Cu/Cuα and Cuα /Nb.
For KS1 , sliding only operates in the interface between Cu crystal and Nb crystal. However, the sliding for KS2 operates simultaneously in the two interfaces.
§5.3
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
199
Fig. 48. Simulation cell, showing region 1 – the moveable part containing Cu in the upper half and Nb in the ¯ Cu , (001)Cu , lower half – and region 2 – the semi-rigid part (see text). Four planes are denoted as solid lines: (111) ¯ Nb , and (101)Nb . The x-axis lies along [112] ¯ Nb , y-axis along [110]Nb , and z-axis along [111] ¯ Nb . The thick(011) ness along the z-axis is about 4.86 nm. This dimension can change with temperature due to thermal expansion. The length of region 1 along the x-axis is 16.0 nm, and the height along the y-axis is 10.0 nm for each crystal.
5.3. Core spreading of lattice glide dislocations Since the shear resistance of Cu/Nb interfaces is low, non-uniform, and strongly anisotropic, core spreading is expected in interfaces when a glide lattice dislocation enters an interface. In this section we describe the interaction of glide dislocations with the two types of interfaces in a bilayer model. This bilayer model is divided into a two-part computational cell, rectangular in shape. One part, region 1, contains moveable atoms embedded in a rigid part, region 2, as shown in Fig. 48. Equilibrium structures at approximately 0 K structures are obtained via PEM. Glide dislocations are introduced in the bilayer model by the application of the fully anisotropic Barnett–Lothe solutions [70] for the displacement field of a dislocation on an interface between two elastically dissimilar materials. This field is applied to both the moveable and the fixed regions of the bilayer model. The dislocation lines were parallel to the z-axis (perpendicular to page) in all cases. Relaxations of the model containing dislocations are performed until the maximum force acting on any atom in the system does not exceed 5 pN. Disregistry analysis of interfaces is carried out to identify dislocation core structure.
200
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 49. Disregistry in the KS1 Cu/Nb interface, showing core spreading when various glide dislocations enter the interface: (a) edge Shockley partial, (b) mixed Shockley partial, (c) full screw dislocation.
Two Shockley partials are introduced in the Cu crystal of the bilayer model. The two partials connected by stacking fault are initially separated by 0.25 nm, and the leading partial is 2.0 nm from the interface. As reported by Hoagland and coworkers [71], the leading Shockley partials, no matter what their sign or whether they are edge or mixed, spontaneously enters interfaces, and the core spreads in the interfaces. Using a model in which the shear of the interface is modeled by sets of virtual dislocations, the force acting on the real dislocation due to the sheared interface was determined as the sum of the Peach– Koehler forces exerted by each of the virtual dislocations in the interface. The force on the glide dislocation provides an attractive force that increases as the distance between the interface and the real dislocation decreases. The sheared interface creates a strong attraction force for the dislocation, particularly for the screw part. Figs 49 and 50 show the disregistry plots after different dislocations enter interfaces. The arrowed lines indicate disregistry vectors, and the curves outline the boundary between slipped and non-slipped regions. Some of the more important features observed in these results are: 1. The dislocation core spreads only in the interface between Cu and Nb crystal for KS1 , but for KS2 the core spreads in both interfaces. The vector plots of disregistry
§5.3
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
201
Fig. 50. Disregistry in KS2 interfaces, showing core spreading when various glide dislocations enter the interfaces: (a) edge Shockley partial, (b) mixed Shockley partial, (c) full screw dislocation.
202
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
Ch. 83
Fig. 51. Disregistry in Cu/Nb interfaces, showing core spreading when two identical full mixed dislocations with a separation of 1.55 nm together enter (a) a KS1 interface, and (b) KS2 interfaces. The solid lines outline the region that was sheared due to core spreading.
show the interface response in Figs 49 and 50. Figs 49(a)–49(c) show the response of KS1 interface corresponding to three types of dislocations, an edge Shockley partial, a mixed Shockley partial, and a full screw dislocation. Figs 50(a)–50(c) show the response of KS2 corresponding to these three types of dislocations. Core spreading is more extensive in the Cuα /Cu interface than in the Cuα /Nb interface. 2. Core spreading is nonuniform, consistent with the spatially nonuniform shear resistance described in the previous section. 3. Two mixed Shockley partial dislocations dissociated from a full screw dislocation are both attracted into interfaces under zero applied stress. But, in the case where the trailing Shockley partial is pure edge, it stands away from interfaces due to the stronger repulsive interaction with the lead Shockley partial that was absorbed. Core spreading effectively traps the dislocation in the interface relative either to transmission into the adjacent layer or its return into the Cu crystal. Trapping is somewhat more effective in KS2 than KS1 because the interfacial shear resistance is lower for KS2 . With several dislocations within an interface, interactions can augment core spreading. Fig. 51 shows the disregistry plots for interfaces KS1 and KS2 , with the solid lines outlining
§6
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids
203
slipped regions for the case where two identical mixed dislocations entered the interface with a separation of 0.155 nm on the interface plane. Other combinations of glide dislocations entering interfaces have been examined but are not described here. The important result of this study, however, is that low interfacial shear resistance is essential for trapping dislocations, which in turn is important to providing high strength in nanolayered composites.
6. Summary In this chapter we have described some features and properties related to coherent, semicoherent, and incoherent flat interfaces between two incommensurate crystalline solids. Most of the issues were described in the context of the role played by dislocations both within the interfaces and interacting with interfaces and were derived from atomic scale models. The coherent interface is simplest of the three from the standpoint of atomic rearrangements on forming the interface. We showed that anisotropy in the elastic constants in the two stressed crystals can create a substantial dependence of the strain energy on interface orientation – a contribution in addition to the interface energy in coherent systems. The stresses associated with coherency are responsible for the very high strength of these composites even when they become semicoherent by accumulation of dislocations on the interface due to glide of threading dislocations. Coherency is much less likely when the two crystals do not have the same crystal structure. Nevertheless, even when incoherent, periodic structures are favored although the atomic rearrangements that occur are much more intricate and complex than in the case of coherent or semicoherent interfaces. Accordingly, this additional complexity creates a richness of possibilities in terms of structures and reactions that incoherent interfaces may accommodate. Three kinds of interfaces, KS1 , KS2 , and KSmin , were found in the fcc/bcc, Cu/Nb system in which the two crystals are mutually oriented according to Kurdjumov–Sachs epitaxial orientations. Far from being disordered, the atomic arrangement of these three types of interfaces could be rationalized in terms of differences in density within the planes adjacent the interface, and by interface dislocations models such as the one introduced here. A formal description of the operations, that derive from the introduction of various sets of dislocations, and that deform a reference crystal into the final, equilibrium arrangements, gave predictions of atomic configurations that were in quite good agreement with the results of atomistic models. Such operations can form the basis for predicting the atomic configurations of interfaces in other systems. The ability of such multi-state interfaces to undergo structural transitions between the metastable configurations available to them has an important effect on the behavior of crystal defects in the vicinity of these interfaces. Unlike in simple commensurate interfaces – such as the 3 twin boundary in fcc metals – interstitials and vacancies arriving at an incommensurate interface need not remain compact and well localized. Instead, they can cause a section of the interface to undergo a transformation from its initial configuration to a new one with a different density but nearly the same energy. The behavior of crystal defects in the vicinity of incommensurate interfaces may be directly tied to the unusual properties of composites containing a high volume fraction of such interfaces. The delocalization of point defects in Cu/Nb interfaces is tied to enhanced radiation damage
204
M.J. Demkowicz et al.
resistance and He solubility through the increased equilibrium concentrations and mobilities of interfacial vacancies and interstitials. Similarly, delocalization of dislocation cores at interfaces helps to explain the high strength and ductility of Cu/Nb multilayer composites. The relation of interface structure to such defect behaviors suggests the possibility of interface-driven design of nanocomposites whose properties are not determined by their individual constituents, but rather by the interfaces between them. Finally, these Cu/Nb interfaces are rather weak in shear, a property that enables them to strongly interact with nearby glide dislocations. Distinct interface configurations have markedly different shear resistances, with the effect that glide dislocations impinging on the interface undergo complex non-homogeneous and anisotropic core spreading, dramatically affecting these dislocations’ ability to pass from one of the crystal layers to the neighboring one. This interaction enables trapping of dislocations within interfaces and provides a mechanism that favors high strength in layered composites.
Acknowledgements Many useful discussions with John P. Hirth and Amit Misra are gratefully acknowledged. This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy Office of Basic Energy Sciences Division of Materials Sciences, the Los Alamos National Laboratory Directed Research and Development Program, and the Los Alamos National Laboratory Director’s Postdoctoral Fellowship Program.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21]
A.P. Sutton, R.W. Balluffi, Interfaces in Crystalline Materials, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1995. R.G. Hoagland, R.J. Kurtz, Philos. Mag. A 82 (2002) 1073. R.G. Hoagland, R.J. Kurtz, C.H. Henager, Scripta Mater. 50 (2004) 775. J.D. Embury, J.P. Hirth, Acta Metall. Mater. 42 (1994) 2051. X. Chu, S.A. Barnett, J. Appl. Phys. 77 (1995) 4403. E.R. Kreidler, P.M. Anderson, Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 434 (1996) 159. W.D. Nix, Mater. Sci. Eng. A 234/236 (1997) 37. P.M. Anderson, T. Foecke, P.M. Hazzledine, MRS Bull. 24 (1999) 27. M.F. Tambwe, D.S. Stone, A.J. Griffin, H. Kung, Y.C. Lu, M. Nastasi, J. Mater. Res. 14 (1999) 407. R.G. Hoagland, J.P. Hirth, A. Misra, D. Mitlin, Appl. Phys. Lett. 84 (2004) 5136. J.P. Hirth, R.G. Hoagland, A. Misra, Philos. Mag. 85 (2005) 3019. D. Mitlin, A. Misra, V. Radmilovic, M. Nastasi, R. Hoagland, J.D. Embury, J.P. Hirth, T.E. Mitchell, Philos. Mag. 84 (2004) 719. D. Mitlin, A. Misra, T.E. Mitchell, R.G. Hoagland, J.P. Hirth, Appl. Phys. Lett. 85 (2004) 1686. R.G. Hoagland, T.E. Mitchell, J.P. Hirth, H. Kung, Philos. Mag. A 82 (2002) 643. A. Misra, J.P. Hirth, H. Kung, Philos. Mag. A 82 (2002) 2935. F.C. Frank, J.H. van der Merwe, Proc. R. Soc. London Ser. A 198 (1949) 205. J.W. Matthews, A.E. Blakeslee, J. Cryst. Growth 27 (1974) 118. J.R. Willis, S.C. Jain, R. Bullough, Philos. Mag. A 62 (1990) 115. J.P. Hirth, X.X. Feng, J. Appl. Phys. 67 (1990) 3343. B. Shoykhet, M.A. Grinfeld, P.M. Hazzledine, Acta Mater. 46 (1998) 3761. C.H. Henager Jr, R.J. Kurtz, R.G. Hoagland, Philos. Mag. 84 (2004) 2277.
Interfaces Between Dissimilar Crystalline Solids [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71]
205
J.P. Hirth, J. Lothe, Theory of Dislocations, Wiley, New York, 1982. R.G. Hoagland, M.I. Baskes, Scripta Mater. 39 (1998) 417. U. Dahmen, Acta Metall. 30 (1982) 63. X.L. Xu, L. Wang, Z.W. Yu, Z.K. Hei, Surf. Coat. Technol. 132 (2000) 270. R.C. Pond, J.P. Hirth, in: F. Seitz, D. Turnbull (Eds.), Solid State Physics, vol. 47, Academic Press, 1994, p. 287. J.P. Hirth, R.C. Pond, J. Lothe, Acta Mater. 54 (2006) 4237. R.C. Pond, X. Ma, J.P. Hirth, in: F.R.N. Nabarro, J.P. Hirth (Eds.), Dislocations in Solids, Elsevier, 2007. R.C. Pond, X. Ma, J.P. Hirth, 2007, in press. M.G. Hall, H.I. Aaronson, K.R. Kinsma, Surf. Sci. 31 (1972) 257. J.M. Rigsbee, H.I. Aaronson, Acta Metall. 27 (1979) 351. M.J. Demkowicz, R.G. Hoagland, J. Nucl. Mater. (2007), in press. P.M. Anderson, J.F. Bingert, A. Misra, J.P. Hirth, Acta Mater. 51 (2003) 6059. A. Fartash, E.E. Fullerton, I.K. Schuller, S.E. Bobbin, J.W. Wagner, R.C. Cammarata, S. Kumar, M. Grimsditch, Phys. Rev. B 44 (1991) 13760. A. Misra, H. Kung, D. Hammon, R.G. Hoagland, M. Nastasi, Int. J. Damage Mech. 12 (2003) 365. A. Misra, R.G. Hoagland, H. Kung, Philos. Mag. 84 (2004) 1021. A. Misra, R.G. Hoagland, J. Mater. Res. 20 (2005) 2046. Y.C. Wang, A. Misra, R.G. Hoagland, Scripta Mater. 54 (2006) 1593. T. Hochbauer, A. Misra, K. Hattar, R.G. Hoagland, J. Appl. Phys. 98 (2005) 123516. A. Misra, M.J. Demkowicz, X. Zhang, R. Hoagland, J.O.M. (2007), in press. X. Zhang, N. Li, O. Anderoglu, H. Wang, J.G. Swadener, T. Hochbauer, A. Misra, R.G. Hoagland, Nucl. Instrum. Methods B 261 (2007) 1129. M.J. Demkowicz, Y.Q. Wang, R.G. Hoagland, O. Anderoglu, Nucl. Instrum. Methods B 261 (2007) 524. M.P. Allen, D.J. Tildesley, Computer Simulation of Liquids, Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1987. D.P. Bertsekas, Nonlinear Programming, Athena Scientific, Cambridge, MA, 1999. A.R. Leach, Molecular Modeling: Principles and Applications, Prentice Hall, Harlow, England, 2001. M.S. Daw, M.I. Baskes, Phys. Rev. B 29 (1984) 6443. M.S. Daw, S.M. Foiles, M.I. Baskes, Mater. Sci. Rep. 9 (1993) 251. A.F. Voter, LANL Unclassified Technical Report # LA-UR 93-3901, 1993. A.F. Voter, in: J.H. Westbrook, R.L. Fleischer (Eds.), Intermetallic Compounds: Principles and Practice, vol. 1, John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1994, p. 77. R.A. Johnson, D.J. Oh, J. Mater. Res. 4 (1989) 1195. D.E. Gray, American Institute of Physics Handbook, McGraw–Hill, New York, 1957. W. Huang, T. Mura, J. Appl. Phys. 41 (1970) 5175. N.D. Mermin, Rev. Mod. Phys. 51 (1979) 591. H.H. Kuo, T. Mura, J. Dundurs, Int. J. Eng. Sci. 11 (1973) 193. T.W. Chou, Y.C. Pan, J. Appl. Phys. 46 (1975) 528. R. Bonnet, G. Marcon, A. Ati, Philos. Mag. A 51 (1985) 429. I. Demir, J.P. Hirth, H.M. Zbib, J. Elast. 28 (1992) 223. A. Boussaid, M. Fnaiech, R. Bonnet, Comptes Rend. Phys. 6 (2005) 145. P. Bak, in: T. Schneider (Ed.), Solitons and Condensed Matter Physics, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, West Germany, 1978, p. 216. T.O. Ogurtani, Annu. Rev. Mater. Sci. 13 (1983) 67. R.W. Siegel, J. Nucl. Mater. 69/70 (1978) 117. P. Ehrhart, J. Nucl. Mater. 69/70 (1978) 200. H. Landolt, P. Ehrhart, H. Ullmaier, Atomic Defects in Metals, Springer-Verlag, 1991. T. Korhonen, M.J. Puska, R.M. Nieminen, Phys. Rev. B 51 (1995) 9526. D. Nguyen-Manh, A.P. Horsfield, S.L. Dudarev, Phys. Rev. B 73 (2006) 20101. M. Tanemura, T. Ogawa, N. Ogita, J. Comput. Phys. 51 (1983) 191. G. Martin, P. Bellon, F. Soisson, J. Nucl. Mater. 251 (1997) 86. J.R. Rice, J. Mech. Phys. Solids 40 (1992) 239. V. Vitek, Cryst. Lattice Defects 5 (1974) 1. D.M. Barnett, J. Lothe, J. Phys. F 4 (1974) 1618. R.G. Hoagland, J.P. Hirth, A. Misra, Philos. Mag. 86 (2006) 3537.
This page intentionally left blank
CHAPTER 84
Size Effects and Dislocation–Wave Interaction in Dislocation Dynamics H.M. ZBIB School of Mechanical and Materials Engineering, Washington State University, Pullman, WA 99164-2920, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
T.A. KHRAISHI Mechanical Engineering Department, University of New Mexico, MSC01-1150, Albuquerque, NM 87131, USA e-mail:
[email protected]
© 2008 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved 1572-4859, DOI: 10.1016/S1572-4859(07)00004-6
Dislocations in Solids Edited by J. P. Hirth
Contents 1. Introduction 209 2. The dislocation dynamics (DD) method 210 2.1. Kinematics and geometric aspects 210 2.2. Kinetics and interaction forces 211 2.3. Dislocation equation of motion 212 2.4. Dislocation mobility function 213 2.5. Dislocation collisions 214 2.6. Discretization of dislocation equation of motion 214 2.7. The dislocation stress and force fields 215 2.8. The stochastic force and cross-slip 217 2.9. Modifications for long-range interactions 219 2.10. Evaluation of plastic strains 219 2.11. The DD numerical solution: an implicit–explicit integration scheme 220 3. Integration of DD and continuum plasticity 221 3.1. Modifications for finite domains 222 3.1.1. Interactions with external free surfaces 222 3.1.2. Interactions with interfaces 223 4. Problems with size effects and the DD approach 224 4.1. Size effects in metal-matrix composites (MMCs) 225 4.2. Size effects when modeling free surface effects 225 4.3. Size effects when modeling grain boundaries 235 4.4. Size effects in bending of microbeams 238 5. Dislocation interaction with shock waves in small volumes 242 5.1. Strain localization and slip rotation 244 Acknowledgements 248 References 248
1. Introduction Over the past seven decades, experimental and theoretical developments have firmly established that strength in metals is strongly dependent on unit dislocation processes and on the manner in which dislocations interact with grain boundaries, interfaces and various defects. This dependence becomes more pronounced in small volumes ranging from the micrometer level down to a few nanometers. However, this fundamental understanding has not been translated into a continuum theory of crystal plasticity based on dislocation mechanisms. While classical plasticity provides a physical framework for modeling dislocation-dependent plasticity phenomena at large scales, it fails to predict size effect and related phenomena at small scales. The major difficulty in developing such a theory is the multiplicity and complexity of the mechanisms of dislocation motion and interactions that make it impossible to develop a quantitative analytical approach. The problem is further complicated by the need to trace the spatiotemporal evolution of a very large number of interacting dislocations over very long periods of time, as required for the calculation of plastic response in a representative volume element. Such practical intractability of the dislocation-based approaches, on one hand, and the developing needs of material engineering at the nano- and micro-length scales on the other, have created a situation where equations of crystal plasticity used for continuum modeling are phenomenological and largely disconnected from the physics of the underlying dislocation behavior. Recently, however, bridging the gap between crystal plasticity and dislocation physics has become possible through the emergence of multiscale models that attempt the appropriate coupling of models for each of the scales involved. In the case of deformation in small volumes, such coupling involves the continuum mesoscale and dislocation dynamics microscale models, although a further coupling to the atomic scale is theoretically possible but practically very complex. Dislocation dynamics (DD) is one of the most recent and powerful tools developed to model the behavior of metallic materials at the microscale in a more physical manner than existing plasticity models. The DD approach has been advanced considerably over the past two decades. The early DD models were two-dimensional (2D) and consisted of periodic cells containing multiple dislocations whose behavior was governed by a set of simplified rules [1–6]. These simulations, although serving as a useful conceptual framework, were limited to 2D and, consequently, could not directly account for such important features in dislocation dynamics as slip geometry, line tension effects, multiplication, certain dislocation intersections and cross-slip, all of which are crucial for the formation of dislocation patterns. In the 90’s, development of new computational approaches of dislocation dynamics (DD) in three-dimensional space (3D) generated hope for a principal breakthrough in our current understanding of dislocation mechanisms and their connection to crystal plasticity [7–10]. This progress has been further magnified by the coupling of DD with continuum mechanics analysis in association with computational algorithms such as finite
210
H.M. Zbib, T.A. Khraishi
Ch. 84
elements. This coupling has paved the way for researchers to investigate many complicated small-scale crystal plasticity phenomena that occur under a wide range of loading and boundary conditions, and cover a wide spectrum of strain rates [11,12], increasing the potential for future applications of this method in material, mechanical, structural and process engineering analyses. In the following, we present the principles of DD analysis, followed by the procedure for the measurement of local quantities such as plastic distortion and internal stresses. The incorporation of the DD technique into the three-dimensional plastic continuum mechanicsbased finite elements modeling is then described. This method is then used to investigate a number of small-scale deformation phenomena including size effects in metal-matrix composites, size effects in models for free surface effects, size effects in models for grain boundaries, and size effects in the bending of microbeams. Finally, we investigate the interaction of dislocations with shock waves when a small scale specimen is subjected to high strain rates and pressures.
2. The dislocation dynamics (DD) method In order to better describe the mathematical and numerical aspects of the DD methodology, first we identify the basic geometric conditions and kinetics that control the dynamics of dislocations. This is followed by discussions of the dislocation equation of motion, elastic interaction equations, and the discretization of these equations for numerical implementation.
2.1. Kinematics and geometric aspects A dislocation is a line defect in an otherwise perfect crystal described by its line sense vector ξ and Burgers vector b. The Burgers vector has two distinct components: edge, perpendicular to its line sense vector, and screw, parallel to its line sense vector. Under loading, dislocations glide and propagate on slip planes causing deformation and change of shape. When the local line direction becomes parallel to the Burgers vector, i.e. screw character, the dislocation may propagate into other slip planes. This switching of the slip plane, which makes the motion of dislocations three-dimensional, and is better known as cross-slip is an important recovery phenomena to be dealt with in dislocation dynamics. In addition to glide and cross-slip, dislocations can also climb in a non-conservative threedimensional motion by absorbing and/or emitting intrinsic point defects, vacancies, and interstitials. Some of these phenomena become important at high load levels or temperatures when point defects become more mobile. In summary, the 3D dislocation dynamics accounts for the following geometric aspects: • • • •
Identification of all possible slip planes for each dislocation. Dislocation topology; 3D geometry, Burgers vector and line sense. Multiplication and annihilation of dislocation segments. Changes in the dislocation topology when part of it cross-slips and or climbs to another plane.
§2.2
Size Effects and Dislocation–Wave Interaction in Dislocation Dynamics
211
• Formation of complex connections and intersections such as junctions, jogs and branching of the dislocation in multiple directions.
2.2. Kinetics and interaction forces The dynamics of the dislocation is governed by a “Newtonian” equation of motion, consisting of an inertia term, a damping term, and a driving force arising from short-range and long-range interactions. Since the strain field of the dislocation varies as the inverse of the distance from the dislocation core, dislocations interact among themselves over long distances. A moving dislocation has to overcome internal drag, and local constraints such as the Peierls stresses (i.e. lattice friction). The dislocation may encounter local obstacles such as stacking fault tetrahedra, defect clusters and vacancies that interact with the dislocation at short ranges and affect its local dynamics. Furthermore, the internal strain field of randomly distributed local obstacles gives rise to stochastic perturbations to the encountered dislocations, as compared with deterministic forces such as the applied load. This stochastic stress field also contributes to the spatial dislocation patterning in the later deformation stages. Therefore, the strain field of local obstacles adds spatially irregular uncorrelated noise to the equation of motion. In addition to the random strain fields of dislocations or local obstacles, thermal fluctuations also provide a stochastic source in dislocation dynamics. Dislocations also interact with free surfaces, cracks, and interfaces, giving rise to what is termed as image stresses or forces. In summary, the dislocation may encounter the following set of forces: • • • • • • • • •
Peierls stress F Peierls . Drag force, Bv, where B is the drag coefficient and v is the dislocation velocity. Force due to externally applied loads, F External . Dislocation–dislocation interaction force F D . Dislocation self-force F Self . Dislocation–obstacle interaction force F Obstacle . Image force F Image . Thermal force F Thermal arising from thermal fluctuations. Osmotic force F Osmotic resulting from non-conservative motion of dislocation (climb) and results in the absorption or emission of intrinsic point defects.
The DD approach attempts to incorporate all of the aforementioned kinematics and kinetics aspects into a computational traceable framework. In the numerical implementation, three-dimensional curved dislocations are treated as a set of connected segments as illustrated in Fig. 1. One can represent smooth dislocations with any desired degree of realism, provided that the discretization resolution is high enough for a specified accuracy (limited by the size of the dislocation core radius r0 , typically the size of one Burgers vector b). In such a representation, the dynamics of dislocation lines is reduced to the dynamics of discrete degrees of freedom of the dislocation nodes connecting the dislocation segments.
212
H.M. Zbib, T.A. Khraishi
Ch. 84
Fig. 1. Discretization of dislocations loops and curves into nodes, segments and collocation points.
2.3. Dislocation equation of motion The velocity v of a dislocation segment s is governed by a first-order differential equation consisting of an inertia term, a drag term and a driving force vector [13–15], such that 1 1 dW ms v˙ + v = F s with ms = , (1)1 Ms (T , p) v dv F s = F Peierls + F D + F Self + F External + F Obstacle + F Image + F Osmotic + F Thermal .
(1)2
In the above equation the subscript s stands for the segment, ms is defined as the effective dislocation segment mass density, Ms is the dislocation mobility which could depend both on the temperature T and the pressure p, and W is the total energy per unit length of a moving dislocation (elastic energy plus kinetic energy). As implied by (1)2 , the glide force vector F s per unit length arises from a variety of sources described in the previous section. The following relations for the mass per unit dislocation length have been suggested by Hirth et al. [16] for screw (ms )screw and edge (ms )edge dislocations when moving at a high
§2.4
Size Effects and Dislocation–Wave Interaction in Dislocation Dynamics
213
speed. W0 −1 −γ + γ −3 , 2 v W0 C 2 −16γl − 40γl−1 + 8γl−3 + 14γ + 50γ −1 − 22γ −3 + 6γ −5 , = 4 v (2)
(ms )screw = (ms )edge
where γl = (1 − v 2 /Cl2 )1/2 , γ = (1 − v 2 /C 2 )1/2 , Cl is the longitudinal sound velocity, C 2
is the transverse sound velocity, ν is Poisson’s ratio, W0 = Gb 4π ln(R/r0 ) is the rest energy for the screw per unit length, G is the shear modulus. The value of R is typically equal to the size of the dislocation cell (about 1000 b), or in the case of one dislocation is the shortest distance from the dislocation to the free surface [13]. In the non-relativistic regime when the dislocation velocity is small compared to the speed of sound, the above equations reduce to the familiar expression m = βρb2 ln(R/r0 ), where β is a constant dependent on the type of the dislocation, and ρ is the mass density.
2.4. Dislocation mobility function The reliability of the numerical simulation depends critically on the accuracy of the dislocation drag coefficient B (= 1/M) which is material dependent. There are a number of phenomenological relations for the dislocation glide velocity vg , including relations of power law forms and forms with an activation term in an exponential or as the argument of a sinh form. Often, however the simple power law form is adopted for expedience, e.g. vg = vs (τe /τs )m , resulting in nonlinear dependence of M on the stress. In a number of cases of pure phonon/electron damping control or of glide over the Peierls barrier a constant mobility (with m = 1), predicts the results very well. This linear form has been theoretically predicted for a number of cases as discussed by Hirth and Lothe [13]. Mechanisms to explain dislocation drag have been studied for a long time and the drag coefficients have been estimated in numerous experimental and theoretical works by atomistic simulations or quantum mechanical calculations (see, for example, the review by Alshitz [17]). The determination of each of the two components (phonon and electron drag) that constitute the drag coefficient for a specific material is not trivial, and various simplifications have been made. For example, the Debye model neglects Van Hove singularities in the phonon spectrum [18], deformation potentials are approximated as isotropic, and so on. Also the values are sensitive to various parameters such as the mean free path or core radius. Nevertheless, in typical metals, the phonon drag Bph range is 30–80 µPa s at room temperature and less than 0.1 µPa s at very low temperatures around 10 K, while for the electron drag Be the range is a few µPa s and expected to be temperature independent. Under strong magnetic fields at low temperature, macroscopic dislocation behavior can be highly sensitive to orientation relative to the field within accuracy of 1% [19]. Except for special cases such as deformation under high strain rate, weak dependences of drag on dislocation velocity are usually neglected. Examples of temperature dependence of each component of the drag coefficient can be found for the case of edge dislocation in copper [20], or in molybdenum [21]. Generally,
214
H.M. Zbib, T.A. Khraishi
Ch. 84
however, the dislocation mobility could be, among other things, a function of the angle between the Burgers vector and the dislocation line sense, i.e. dislocation character, especially at low temperatures. For example, Wasserbäch [22] observed that at low deformation temperatures (77 to 195 K) the dislocation structure in Ta single crystals consisted of primary and secondary screw dislocations and of tangles of dislocations of mixed characters, while at high temperatures (295 to 470 K) the behavior was similar to that of fcc crystals. In the work of Mason and MacDonald [23] they measured the mobility of dislocation of an unidentified type in Nb as 4.2 × 104 (Pa s)−1 near room temperature. A smaller value of 3.3 × 103 (Pa s)−1 was obtained by Urabe and Weertman [24] for the mobility of edge dislocation in Fe. The mobility for screw dislocations in Fe was found to be about a factor of two smaller than that of edge dislocations near room temperature. A theoretical model to explain this large difference in behavior is given in Hirth and Lothe [13] and is based on the observation that in bcc materials the screw dislocation has a rather complex threedimensional core structure, resulting in a high Peierls stress, leading to a relatively low mobility for screw dislocations while the mobility of mixed dislocations is higher.
2.5. Dislocation collisions When two dislocations collide, their response is dominated by their mutual interactions and becomes much less sensitive to the long-range elastic stress associated with external loads, boundary conditions, and all other dislocations present in the system. Depending on the shapes of the colliding dislocations, their approach trajectories and their Burgers vectors, two dislocations may form a dipole, or react to annihilate, or combine to form a junction, or intersect and form a jog. In the DD analysis, the dynamics of two colliding dislocations is determined by the mutual interaction force acting between them. In the case that the two dislocation segments are parallel (on the same plane and or intersecting planes) and have the same Burgers vector with opposite sign, they would annihilate if the distance between them is equal to the core size. Otherwise, the colliding dislocations would align themselves to form a dipole, a jog or a junction depending on their relative position. A comprehensive review of short-range interaction rules can be found in Rhee et al. [25].
2.6. Discretization of dislocation equation of motion Eq. (1) applies to every infinitesimal length along the dislocation line. In order to solve this equation for any arbitrary shape, the dislocation curve may be discretized into a set of dislocation segments as illustrated in Fig. 1. Then the velocity vector field over each segment may be assumed to be linear and, therefore, the problem is reduced to finding the velocity of the nodes connecting these segments. There are many numerical techniques to solve such a problem. Consider, for example, a straight dislocation segment s bounded by two nodes j and j +1 as depicted in Fig. 1. Then within the finite element formulation [26], the velocity vector field is assumed to be linear over the dislocation segment length. This linear vector field v can be expressed in terms of the velocities of the nodes such that v = [N D ]T V D where V D is the nodal velocity vector and [N D ] is the linear shape function
§2.7
Size Effects and Dislocation–Wave Interaction in Dislocation Dynamics
215
vector [26]. According to the Galerkin method, eq. (1) for each segment can be reduced to a set of six equations for the two discrete nodes (each node has three degrees of freedom). The result can be written in the following matrix-vector form D D D D M V˙ + C V = F D , (3) where
T N D N D dl is the dislocation segment 6 × 6 mass matrix, D D D T C = (1/Ms ) N N dl M
D
= ms
is the dislocation segment 6 × 6-damping matrix, and D N F s dl is the 6 × 1 nodal force vector. FD = Then, following the standard element assemblage procedure, one obtains a set of discrete equations, which can be cast in terms of a global dislocation mass matrix, a global dislocation damping matrix, and a global dislocation force vector. In the case of one dislocation loop and with ordered numbering of the nodes around the loop, one can easily show that the global matrices are banded with a half-bandwidth equal to one. However, when the system contains many loops that interact among themselves and new nodes are generated and/or annihilated continuously, the numbering of the nodes becomes random and the matrices become unbanded. To simplify the computational effort, one can employ the lumped mass and damping matrix method. In this method, the mass matrix [M D ] and damping matrix [C D ] become diagonal matrices (half-bandwidth equal to zero), and therefore the only coupling between the equations is through the nodal force vector F D . The computation of each component of the force vector is described below.
2.7. The dislocation stress and force fields The stress induced by any arbitrary dislocation loop at an arbitrary field point P can be computed by the Peach–Koehler integral equation given in Hirth and Lothe [13]. This integral equation, in turn, can be evaluated numerically over many loops of dislocations by discretizing each loop into a series of line segments. If we denote, r = distance from point P to the segment s, Nl = total number of dislocation loops, (l) Ns = number of segments of loop l, (l) (l) (l) Nn = number of nodes associated with the segments of loop l, i.e. Nn = Ns + 1, (l) Ns = total number of segments = Ns × Nl , where summation over l is implied, (l) Nn = total number of nodes = Nn × Nl , where summation over l is implied, ls = length of segment s, then the discretized form of the Peach–Koehler integral equation for the stress at any arbitrary field point P becomes
216
H.M. Zbib, T.A. Khraishi
Ch. 84
d
σ ij (p) N N s $
∂ ∂ G 2 bp ∈mpi ∇ R dxj − bp ∈mpi ∇ 2 R dxj = ∂x 8π ∂x l l m m s s l=1 s=1 % ∂ G ∂ 3R 2 − bp ∈mpk − δ ∇ R dx (4) ij k , ∂x ∂x 4π(1 − ν) ls ∂xm ∂xm i j ()
G − 8π
where ∈ij k is the permutation symbol, and R is the magnitude of the R = r − r (where r is the position vector of point P and r is the position vector of a differential line segment of the dislocation loop or curve). The integral over each segment can be explicitly carried out using the linear element approximation. Exact solution of eq. (4) for a straight dislocation segment can be found in DeWit [27] and Hirth and Lothe [13]. However, evaluation of the above integral requires careful consideration as the integrand becomes singular in cases where point P coincides with one of the nodes of the segment that integration is taken over, i.e., self-segment integration. Thus, • If P is not part of the segment s, there is no singularity since R = 0 and the ordinary integration procedure may be performed. • If P coincides with a node of the segment s where the integration should be carried out, special treatment is required due to the singular nature of the stress field as R → 0. Here, the regularization scheme developed by Zbib and co-workers has been employed. In general, the dislocation stresses can be decomposed into the following form: d
σ (p) =
N s −2
d
d
d
σ (s) + σ (p+) + σ (p−) ,
(5)
s=1 d
d
d
where σ (s) is the contribution to the stress at point P from a segment s, and σ (P +) , σ (P −) are the contributions to the stress from the two segments that are shared by a node coinciding with P which will be further discussed below. Once the dislocation stress field is computed, one can determine the forces on each dislocation segment by summing the stresses along the length of the segment. The stresses are categorized into those coming from the dislocations as formulated above and also from any other externally applied stresses plus the internal friction (if any) and the stresses induced by any other defects or micro-constituents. A model for the osmotic force F Osmotic is given in Raabe [28] and its inclusion in the total force is straightforward since it is a deterministic force. However, the treatment of the thermal force F Thermal is not trivial since this force is stochastic in nature, requiring a special consideration and algorithm leading to what is called Stochastic Dislocation Dynamics (SDD) as developed by Hiratani and Zbib [29]. Therefore, the force acting on each segment can be written as: Fs =
Ns d a d (m) a (m) σ +σ + τ s .bs × ξ s = F s + F s +F Thermal , m=1
(6)
§2.8
Size Effects and Dislocation–Wave Interaction in Dislocation Dynamics
217
d
where σ (m) is the contribution to the stresses along segment s from another segment m a (dislocation–dislocation interaction), σ (s) is the sum of all externally applied stresses, internal friction (if any) and the stresses induced by any other defects, and τ s is the thermal d
a
stress; F s , F s and F Thermal are the corresponding total Peach–Koehler (PK) forces. d
Using eq. (5), one can decompose the force F s into two parts one arising from all dislocation segments and one from the self-segment, which is better known as the self-force, that is, d
Fs =
N s −1
d
d
F s (m) + F s (self) ,
(7)
m=1 d
d
where F s (m) and F s (self) are, respectively, the contribution to the force on segment s from segment m and the self-force. In order to evaluate the self-force, one should use a special numerical treatment, as given by Zbib et al. [10] and Zbib and Diaz de la Rubia [12], in which exact expressions for the self-force are given. The direct computation of the dislocation forces discussed above requires the use of a very fine mesh, especially when dealing with problems involving dislocation–defect interaction. As a rule, to capture the effect of the very small defects, the dislocation segment size must be comparable to the size of the defect. Alternatively, one can use large dislocation segments compared to the smallest defect size, provided that the force interaction is computed over many points (Gauss points) over the segment length. In this case, the selfforce of segment s is evaluated first. Then the force contribution from other dislocations and defects is calculated from stresses determined at several Gauss points along the length of the segment. The summation as in (6) would then follow according to: F s = F self s +
N s −1 m=1
ng 1 d (m) d σ (p g ) + σ (m) (p g ) + · · · .bs × ξ s , ng
(8)
g=1
where p g is the Gauss point g and ng is the number of Gauss points along segment s. The number of Gauss points depends on the length of the segment. As a rule the shortest distance between two Gauss points should be larger or equal to 2r0 , i.e. twice the core size.
2.8. The stochastic force and cross-slip Thermal fluctuations arise from dissipation mechanism due to collision of dislocations with surrounding particles, such as phonons or electrons. Rapid collisions and momentum transfers result in random forces on dislocations. These stochastic collisions, in turn, can be regarded as time-independent noises of thermal forces acting on the dislocations. Suppose the exertion of thermal forces follows a Gaussian distribution. Then, thermal fluctuations most likely result in very small net forces due to mutual cancellations. However, the forces sometimes become large and may cause diffusive dislocation motion or thermal activation events such as overcoming obstacle barriers. Therefore, the DD simulation model should
218
H.M. Zbib, T.A. Khraishi
Ch. 84
Table 1 The stress pulse peak height for various combinations of parameters, t = 50 fs T (K)
0 50 100 300
1/M (µPa s)
2 5 10 30
τh (MPa) (l = 5 b)
(l = 10 b)
11.5 40.6 81.1 256
8.11 28.7 57.4 181
also account not only for deterministic effects but also for stochastic forces; leading to a model called “stochastic discrete dislocation dynamics” (SDD) [29]. The procedure is to include the stochastic force F Thermal in the DD model by computing the magnitude of the stress pulse (τ s ) using a Monte Carlo type analysis. Based on the assumption of the Gaussian process, the thermal stress pulse has a zero mean and no correlation [30] between any two different times. This leads to the average peak height given as [29] σs = 2kT /Ms b2 lt , (9) where k denotes Boltzmann constant, T absolute temperature of the system, b the magnitude of Burgers vector, t time step, and l is the dislocation segment length, respectively. Some values of the peak height are shown in Table 1 for typical combinations of parameters. Here, t is chosen to be 50 fs, roughly the inverse of the Debye frequency. Although l or t does not have a fixed value, such a restriction is imposed so that the system at the energetic global minima should reach thermal equilibrium. One can check the validity of these parameters by comparing the assigned system temperature (T ) with the kinetic temperature of a dislocation that has both ends fixed which should coincide on average according to the equipartition law. Although there is no unique way for choosing t or l in eq. (9), the selection is justified if the segment velocity distribution has the correct Maxwellian form and if the average kinetic energy of the segment is equivalent to kT /2 for each degree of freedom at thermal equilibrium. The size of l may also depend on the microstructure being co