1 Differential
Display
A General Protocol Peng Liang and Arthur B. Pardee 1. Introduction One of the greatest unsolved mysteries of life 1show the hundreds of thousands of genes embedded in the genome of an organism are selectively expressed mto the mRNA and protems m a temporally and spatially regulated manner that gives rise to different tissues and organs. The abnormality m this intricate regulatory cn-cuitry IS beheved to be one of the underlmmg causes of a variety of pathological alterations or disease states.The rsolation and characterization of differentially expressed genes becomes one of the first steps toward the understanding of these important biological questions. Differential display (1) and a related RAP-PCR method (2) were developed to more efficiently Identify and isolate these genes. The general strategy for differential display (Fig. 1) IS based on a combmatton of three techniques brought together by a concept: 1 Reverse transcrlptlon of mRNA from anchored primers (see Note l), 2 Choice of arbitrary primers for setting lengths of cDNAs to be amplified by the polymerase chain reaction (PCR), each corresponding to part of a mRNA (tags), 3 Sequencmg gels for high resolution of amplified cDNA
The objective IS to obtain a tag of a few hundred bases,which 1ssufficiently long to uniquely identify a mRNA and yet short enough to be separated from others by size. Given the fact that primers of nearly any length, with or without anchors, can generate cDNA fingerprints sufticrently reproducible to allow differentially expressed genes to be identified, it may be hard to define what should be a standard protocol for differential display. The followmg protocol using one-base anchored primer m combmatron with arbitrary 13-mers (3) IS given as an example to illustrate the methodology. From
Methods m Molecular Bology, Vol 8.5 D/fferenf/a/ Edlted by P Llang and A B Pardee Humana
3
Dsplay Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
Liang and Pardee
L
Reverse banswiption
5’.AAGC3’ dNTPs MMLV reverse tfanscnptase .
WAA-A~ GVGAA
4 JI.
(H-TUG)
PcRamplificatloll
AAGCTTGATECC
I
5’-AAGCTTGAITGCC-3’ (H-AP-1 Ptimer) 5’44GC3 (H-TIIG) dNTPs a-(‘“S-dATP] Ampli’lhq DNA poiymelase . GWGAA
A4GCiTGA’lTGCC
. G-GU
IIL
Denaturing polyacrylamide gel
Fig. 1. Schemattc representation of one-base anchored differentral display
2. Materials 1. 5X RT buffer: 125 mA4TrwC1, pH 8 3,188 mMKCl,7.5 dithrothretol. 2 MMLV reverse transcrrptase (100 cl/@,) 3. dNTP (250 @I) 4. 5’-AAGCTTTTTTTTTTTG-3’ (2 /.&I). 5. 5’-AAGCTTTTTTTTTTTA-3’ (2 pA4) 6 5’-AAGCTTTTTTTTTTTC-3’ (2 /&I). 7 Arbitrary 13-mers (2 pM) 8. 10X PCR buffer.
mMMgC12, and 25 ti
Differential 9 10. Il. 12. 13. 14. 15 16. 17 18. 19. 20. 2 1.
Display
5
dNTP (25 pJ4). Glycogen (10 mg/mL). Distilled water (dH,O). DEPC-treated H,O Loading dye AmphTaq DNA polymerase, Perkin-Elmer Corporation (Norwalk, CT). a-[33P]dATP (>2000 Wrnmole) or a-[35S]dATP (>l,OOO Ci/mmole) (see Note 2). RNase-free DNase I (10 U/pL). QIAEXrM DNA extraction kit (Qiagen, Chatsworth, CA). pCR-TRAPTM clonmg system (GenHunter Corporation, Nashville, TN). Thermocycler 6% denaturmg polyacrylamide gel. DNA sequencing apparatus.
Although individual components may be purchased separately from varrous suppliers, most of them can be obtained in kit forms from GenHunter Corporation. 3. Methods 3.1. DNase I Treatment of Total RNA Purification polyadenylated RNAs is neither necessary nor helpful for differential display. The major pitfalls of using the polyadenylated mRNAs are the frequent contammation of the oligo-dT primers, that give high background smearing in the display and the difficulty m assessing the integrity of the mRNAs templates (4). Total cellular RNAs can be easily purified with one-step acid-phenol extraction method (5). However, no matter what methods are used for the total RNA purification, a trace amount of chromosomal DNA contamination m the RNA sample could be amplified along with mRNAs thereby comphcating the pattern of displayed bands. Therefore removal of all contaminating chromosomal DNA from RNA samples is essential before carrying out differential display. 1. Incubate 10-100 pg of total cellular RNA with 10 U of DNase I (RNase free) in 10 mMTris-Cl, pH 8.3, 50 mMKC1, 1.5 mMMgC& for 30 mm at 37°C. 2 Inactivate DNase I by adding an equal volume of phenolchloroform (3: 1) to the
sample 3. Mix by vortexing and leave the sample on ice for 10 mm.
4 Centrifuge the samplefor 5 min at 4’C m an Eppendorf centrifuge. 5. Save the supernatant, and ethanol precipitate the RNA by adding 3 vol of ethanol in the presence of 0.3MNaOAC, and incubate at -80°C for 30 mm. 6. Pellet the RNA by centrifuging at 4°C for 10 min. 7. Rinse the RNA pellet with 0.5 mL of 70% ethanol (made with DEPC-H20) and redissolve the RNA in 20 pL of DEPC-treated HzO. 8. Measure the RNA concentration at ODS6s with a spectrophotometer by diluting 1 pL of the RNA sample in 1 mL of HzO.
Llang and Pardee
6
9 Check the integrity of the RNA samples before and after cleanmg wtth DNase I by runnmg 1-3 ~18of each RNA on a 7% formaldehyde agarose gel 10 Store the RNA sample at a concentratton htgher then 1 pg/$ at -80°C before using for differential dtsplay
3.2. Reverse
Transcription
of mRNA
1 Set up three reverse transcription reactions for each RNA sample in three microfuge tubes (0 5-mL), each contammg one of the three dtfferent anchored ohgo-dT prrmers as follows. For 20 pL final volume 9 4 p.L of dH,O, 4 pI. of 5X RT buffer, 1.6 pL of dNTP (250 I.&‘), 2 pL of DNA-free total RNA (freshly diluted to 0 1 pg/pL wtth DEPC-treated H,O), and 2 pL of AAGCT, ,M (2 $4) (M can be either G, A, or C) 2 Program your thermocycler to* 65°C for 5 mm, 37°C for 60 min, 75’C for 5 mm, 4°C (see Note 3) 3 1 pL MMLV reverse transcrlptase 1s added to each tube 10 mm after at 37°C and mix well quickly by finger tipping 4. Continue mcubation and at the end of the reverse transcription reaction, spm the tube briefly to collect condensation Set tubes on ice for PCR or store at -80°C for later use.
3.3. PCR Amplification 1 Set up PCR reacttons at room temperature as follow* 20 p.L final volume for each primer set combmation 10 pL of dH,O, 2 $ of 10X PCR buffer, 1.6 l.iL of dNTP (25 pA4), 2 pL of arbitrary 13-mer (2 CUM),2 pL of AAGCT, ,M (2 CIM), 2 pL of RT-mix from step 3 2 , 0 2 pL of a-[33P]-dATP (see Note 2), 0 2 p.L of AmpliTaq. Mix well by pipetmg up and down (see Note 4) 2. Add 25 pI.. mineral oil if needed 3 PCR as follows 94°C for 30 s, 40°C for 2 mm, 72°C for 30 s for 40 cycles, 72°C for 5 mm, 4“C (For Perkm-Elmer’s 9600 thermocycler it is recommend that the denaturanon temperature be shortened to 15 s and the rest of parameters kept the same )
3.4. 6% Denaturing 1 2 3 4
Polyacrylamide
Gel Electrophoresis
Prepare a 6% denaturmg polyacrylamide gel m TBE buffer Let it polymertze at least for more than 2 h before usmg Prerun the gel for 30 mm Mix 3.5 pL of each sample with 2 p.L of loading dye and incubate at 80°C for 2 mm immediately before loading onto a 6% DNA sequencmg gel (see Note 5) 5 Electrophorese for about 3 5 h at 60 W constant power (with voltage not to exceed 1700 V) until the xylene dye (the slower movmg dye) reaches the bottom Turn off the power supply and blot the gel onto a piece of 3M Paper Cover the gel with a plastic wrap and dry tt at 80°C for 1 h Do not fix the gel with methanol/ acetic acid (see Note 6) 6. Orient the autoradiogram and dried gel wtth radioacttve mk or needle punches before exposing to a X-ray film. Figure 2 shows a representative differential dts-
7
Differential Display H-T110
H-T110
H-TIIA
H-WA
H-TIIA
H-TIIC
H-TllC
H-AP3
H-APB
H-API
H-AP3
H-AP3
H-APl
H-AP3
Fig. 2. Differential display using one-base anchored oligo-dT primers (7). Four RNA samples from non-transformed cell line Rat 1 and H-ras transformed cell lines rat 1 (ras), T101-4 and Al-5 (lanes from left to right, respectively) were compared by differential display using three one-base anchored oligo-dT primers, AAGCT, ,G, AAGCT, ,A and AAGCT, ,C in combinations with three arbitrary 13-mers, H-API (AAGCTTGATTGCC), HAP2 (AAGCTTCGACTGT) and HAP3 (AAGC’l’l’l’GGTCAG). The mob-l (ZO) and mob-7 cDNA fragments were marked by the right and let? arrowheads, respectively. play obtained with three one-base anchored oligo-dT primers in combinations with three arbitrary 13-mers (3).
3.5. Reamplification
of cDNA Probe
1. After developing the film (overnight to 72-h exposure), orient the autoradiogram with the gel. 2. Locate bands of interest (see Note 7) either by marking with a clean pencil from underneath the film or punching through the film with a needle at the four corners
Liang and Pardee
3. 4. 5 6. 7. 8 9. 10. 11. 12 13.
14.
15
of each band of interest (Handle the dried gel with gloves and save it between two sheets of clean paper) Cut out the located band with a clean razor blade Soak the gel slice along with the 3M paper in 100 pL dH,O for 10 mm. Boil the tube with tightly closed cap (e.g., with parefilm) for 15 min. Spm for 2 mm to collect condensatron and pellet the gel and paper debris Transfer the supernatant to a new micromge tube. Add 10 pL of 3MNaOAC, 5 pL of glycogen (10 mg/mL) and 450 p.L of 100% EtOH. Let sit for 30 mm on dry ice or in a -8O’C freezer Spm for 10 mm at 4°C to pellet DNA. Remove supernatant and rinse the pellet with 200 pL we-cold 85% EtOH (you will lose your DNA if less concentrated EtOH is used!). Spm briefly and remove the resrdual ethanol. Dissolve the pellet m 10 pL of PCR H,O and use 4 pL for reamplificatron. Save the rest at -20°C in case of mishaps. Reamplification should be done using the same primer set and PCR conditions except the dNTP concentrations are at 20 piV (use 250 @4 dNTP stock) instead of 2-4 pA4 and no rsotopes added. A 40-pL reaction is recommended for each reactron: 20.4 of pL dH,O, 4 pL of 10X PCR buffer, 3.2 pL of dNTP (250 @4), 4 & of arbitrary 13-mer (2 @?), 4 $ AAGCT, ,M (2 @4) (M can be either G, C, or A), 4 pL of cDNA template from step 3.2. and 0.4 pL of AmphTaq (5 U/pL). Run 30 pL of the PCR sample on a 1.5% agarose gel stained with ethidmm bromide (More than 90% probes should be visible on the agarose gel ) Save the remaining PCR samples at -2O’C for subclomng. Check to see rf the size of your reamplified PCR products are consistent with their size on the denaturing polyacrylamide gel.
3.6. Confirmation
of Differential
Gene Expression
1. Extract the reamplified cDNA probe from the agarose gel using QIAEX kit. 2. Use the extracted cDNA as a probe for Northern blot confirmation following the standard protocol (ref. 5; see Note 8; Fig. 3) 3. Clone the cDNA probe using the pCR-TR4PTM cloning system (see Note 9). 4. Confirmation of differentially expressed cDNA probes can be also carried out more efficiently by “Reverse Northern” dot blot or differential screening of cloned cDNA probes by colony hybrtdization (ref. 6; Chapter 8 by H Zhang et al. m this book). 5. Clone the full-length cDNA by screening a cDNA library followmg the standard procedure (5).
4. Notes 1. The initial choice of usmg two-base anchored ohgo-dT primers (1) instead of one-base anchored primers (3) were owing to a historical rather than scienttfic reason. The cloned marine thymidine kmase (TK) cDNA originally used as a
Differential
9
Display
Mob-l
A H-AP2
+ AAgc~~CTGTACAAAGG~~C~~T~A~~AC~~~~~ ATATGTAAGAACGTATGTATCAATGGGTAGITAAAGTlTACATAGG CAAATGClTl-GAATGCTACATAlTACAAGATGTGlTGGATGGlllTCAMATAMAT GTACTGTATTGAATGTAGTATGAGACCAAAAAA GTAATAAAGTAATAATAACTGAC ATGAAAAAAAAAAAGC-IT 4 H-T1 I C
Mob-7
B H-AP2
* AAgcttcGAcTGTAcAAA~GcGGAAcTccfGAATGTATTTT ATAT~AAGAAClTGTGTGGTAAGTATGTATGTAfCAATGGGTAGlTAAA~ACATAGG CAAATGCllTGAATGCTACATATTACAAGATGElTGGATGGlllTCAAAATAAAAT GTACCCAAAAAAGTAATAAAGTAATAATAACTGAC ATGAAATGCAAAAAAAAAAAGCTT 4 H-T1 I G
C
1234
Mob-7
rRNA
Fig. 3. Nucleotide sequences of mob-l (A) and mob-7 (B) cDNA fragments cloned by differential display. The flanking primers are marked by arrow bars and the polyadenylation site is underlined. Mob-7 differs from mob-l only by 6 base addition at the 3’ end of the cDNA (see Note 10). Northern blot analysis with mob-7 cDNA probe (C). The 253 bp mob-7 cDNA was used as a probe to confirm the differential expression of the gene using 20 pg of total RNA from Rat 1 and three transformed derivatives Rat 1 @as), T101-4 and Al-5 cells (lanes 1 to 4, respectively). The lower panel is ethidium bromide staining of ribosomal RNAs as a control for equal sample loading.
10
2
3.
4
5 6
7.
8.
9.
Lang and Pardee control cDNA template had only 11 As m its poly(A) tall It was found that onebase anchored prrmer Tl 1C fatled to amplify the TK 3’ termmus m combmatton wtth an upstream primer specific to TK. Extension of one more base from the 3’ end instead of the 5’ end of the anchored primer was a logical. Interestingly, Tl 1CA started to work successfully m PCR to amplify the expected TK cDNA template (1) Later, longer one-base anchored primers that had mismatches at the 5’ ends of the prtmers were shown to be much more efficient for differential display m subdividing the mRNA populations mto three groups (3) One-base anchored primers have significant advantage over the two-base anchored primers m that the former cuts down the redundancy of priming, elimmates the high background smearing problem for two-base anchored pnmers ending with the 3’ “T” and reduce the number of reverse transcription reactions from 12 to 3 per RNA sample. It has been observed that 35S labeled nucleottde origmally used for differential display would leak through PCR reaction tubes (espectally when thin-walled tubes are used) and 33P labeled nucleotide was recommended as the best alternative (9). 33P is not only safer to use but also gives better sensmvtty compared to 35S. For the reverse transcrtption reaction, the mmal 65°C incubation is intended to denature the RNA secondary structure. The final incubation at 75°C for 5 minis to inactivate the reverse transcrlptase without denaturing the cDNA/mRNA duplexes Therefore “hot start “PCR is neither necessary, nor helpful for the subsequent PCR reactions using cDNAs as templates Make core mixes as much as possible to avoid ptpetmg errors (e g , aliquot RT-mix and AP-primer mdrvidually) Otherwise it would be difficult to pipet 0.2 pL of AmpliTaq. Mix well by pipetmg up and down It is crucial that the urea in the wells be completely flushed right before loading your samples For best resolution, flush every 4-6 wells each time during sample loading while trying not to disturb the samples that have been already loaded. DNA is acid labile, especially at high temperature when the gel is dried. This will affect the subsequent PCR during the reamplificatton of the cDNA fragments to be analyzed further First tentatively identify those bands that appear to be differentially expressed on the initial display gel. Then repeat the RT step and the PCR reactions for these lanes and see if these differences are reproducible before pursumg further It 1s recommended that bands bigger than 100 bp be selected. It has been generally observed that shorter cDNA probes have higher probability of failing to detect any signals on the Northern blot. It IS recommended that the standard prehybrrdrzatron and hybridrzation condttton at 42°C be used. Wash with 1X SSC, 0.1% SDS at room temperature for 15 min twice followed by washing with 0.25X SSC, 0 1% SDS at 55-6O”C for 15-30 mm. Do not go over 60°C Expose with intensifying screen at -80°C for overnight to 1 wk. pCR-TRAP cloning system is by far the most efficient cloning method for PCR products that we have tested The pCR-TRAP clonmg system utilizes the third generation cloning vector that features postttve-selection for DNA mserts Only
Different/al Display
II
the recombinant plasmtds confer the antibiotic resistance The prmclple of thts unique clonmg system 1sbased on that the phage Lambda repressor gene c1 cloned on the pCR-TRAP vector codes for a repressor protein. The repressor protein binds to the Lambda right operators Or1 to Or3 of the cro gene, thereby turning off the promoter that drives the TetR gene on the plasmtd Therefore, cloning of the PCR products dtrectly, without any post-PCR purification, into the c1 gene leads to the inactivation of the repressor gene, thus turnmg on the TetR gene The cloned PCR insert can then be readily sequenced or retrieved as a probe by PCR using primers flanking the cloning site of the vector. 10. It 1sknown that the poly(A) tail of a rnRNA is not always added at a fixed position downstream of the AATAAA polyadenylatton signal This 1s why both mob-l and mob-7 correspondmg to the same mRNA were detected by the same arbitrary primer m combmatton with different anchored primers
Acknowledgment We thank GenHunter Corporation for the permtsslon of adapting its protocols for Message CleanTMkit and RNAlmage TMkit for differential display. The work was supported m part by a Natlonal Institute of Health grant CA61232 awarded to Arthur B. Pardee and Peng Llang.
References 1 Liang, P. and Pardee, A B. (1992) Dtfferentlal display of eukaryotic messenger RNA by means of the polymerase cham reaction. Science 257, 967-97 1. 2 Welsh, J , Chada, K , Dalal, S S , Cheng, R , Ralph, D., and McClelland, M (1992) Arbitrarily primed PCR fingerprmtmg of RNA Nuclezc Aczds Res 20, 4965-4970 3 Liang, P. Zhu, W , Zhang, X., Guo, Z , O’Connell, R P., Averboukh, L , Wang, F , and Pardee A B (1994) Differenttal display usmg one-base anchored ohgo dT primers. Nucleic Acids Res 22, 5763,5764. 4 Ltang, P. Averboukh, L., and Pardee, A B (1993) Dtstrlbutton and cloning of eukaryottc mRNAs by means of differential display* refinements and optimization Nuclezc Acids Res 21, 3269-3275. 5 Ausubel, F , Brent, R , Kingston, R. E , Moore, D. D., Seidman, J. G , Smith, J A, and Struhl, K (1988) Current Protocols In Molecular Biology, Greene and Wiley-Interscience, New York 6. Zhang, H , Zhang, R., and Ltang, P. (1996) Differential screening of gene expression difference enriched by differential display. Nuclezc Acids Res 24,2454-2456. 7 Trentmann, S M , Knaap, E., Kende, H., Ltang, P., and Pardee A. B (1995) Alternatives to 35S as a label for the differential display of eukaryottc messenger RNA. Sczence 267,1186,1187
Fingerprinting
by Arbitrarily
Primed PCR
Michael McClelland, Rhonda Honeycutt, Francoise Mathieu-Daude, Thomas Vogt, and John Welsh 1. Introduction PCR using primers of arbitrary sequence can generate a reproducible tingerprint of products from DNA (1,2). Differences m the fingerprint of products generated from DNA of related organism are a result of polymorphisms. These polymorphisms proved useful markers for genetic mappmg (3-7), population biology (8-13), epidemiology (Z&19), and even the discovery of the mutator phenotype m cancer (20). When applied to RNA the method is also capable of detecting polymorphisms in expressed transcripts (21). However, more importantly, the method can detect a sample of differentially expressed genes (21,22). This chapter will concentrate on recent efforts in our laboratory to extend and improve the method and ascertain its limitations using relatively “lowtech” solutions available to most laboratories. There are three vital steps common to all RNA tingerprmting experiments: (1) the arbitrarily primed PCR amphfication of a sample of transcripts, (2) the isolation and characterization of differentially amplified products, and (3) the confirmation of differentially expressed products in the system of interest. We will discuss issues pertaining to each of these steps. When performed with the correct controls, with efficient analysis protocols, and taking into account what it cannot do efficiently, the method is suitable for identifying a sample of regulated genes m a wide variety of experimental systems. It should be noted that our protocol (RNA arbitrarily primed PCR [RAPPCR]) differs from the Liang and Pardee Differential Display protocol m that we use an arbitrary primer m both steps of the PCR reaction, rather than an anchored oligo(dT) in the first step. The use of arbitrary primers to define both ends of fingerprmt products allows internal RNA fragments to be sampled, From
Methods m Molecular Bfology, Vol 85 D/fferent/a/ Edited by P Llang and A B Pardee Humana
13
Display Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
14
McClelland et al.
including open reading frames. In addition, mRNAs that are not polyadenylated can be sampled, such as some bacterial RNAs (23). We cannot be certain that all the properties of these two protocols are the same,nevertheless, there 1sreason to believe that the issues we discuss here are equally applicable
to both protocols.
2. Materials 1. 2 3. 4 5 6 7 8. 9 10 I 1. 12 13 14 15 16 17. 18 19. 20 21. 22.
Multipipetor for 5- to 200~pL volumes RNeasy total RNA purificatton kit (QIAGEN, Chatsworth, CA) DNase stock (10 U/uL) (Boehrmger Mannhelm Biochemicals, Indianapolis, IN) RNasm RNase mhibitor, 40 II/& (BMB). 2X RT Buffer. 100 tiTris, pH 8 3, 100 mA4KC1, 8 mMMgC12 MuLV-reverse transcrtptase 1200 U/pL (Promega, Madison, WI) Stocks of all four dNTPs (5 mM) Stocks of primers (100 w (Genosys, Woodlands, TX) [a-32P] dCTP (3000 Ci/mmol; ICN, Costa Mesa, CA). 2X Tuq polymerase mixture 20 mM Tris, pH 8 3; 20 mM or 100 mA4 KCl; 8 n-&f MgC12 AmphTaq polymerase, 5 U/pL. (Perkm-Elmer-Cents, Norwalk, CT) AmphTuq polymerase Stoffel fragment, 10 U/pL (Perkm-Elmer-Cetus). GeneAmp PCR System 9600 thermocycler (Perkm-Elmer-Cetus) Formamrde dye solution. 96% formamide, 0.1% bromophenol blue, 0 1% xylene cyanol, 10 mA4 EDTA Acrylamrde stock solutrons (40% 19.1 acrylamrde.bzs-acrylamide) Urea Ammonium persulfate (fresh 10% solution) TEMED. 10X TBE buffer: 90 mM Tris-Borate, 20 mMNa2EDTA, pH 8.3. Hydrolmk MDE gel solutions (J T Baker Inc , Phillipsburg, NJ). NaOH dye solution. 96% formamide, 0 1% bromophenol blue, 0.1% xylene cyanol, 10 mM NaOH. Fluroimager or Aquasol scintillation fluid and a scinhllation counter.
3. Methods 3.1. Fingerprinting 1. Total RNA is purified usmg the RNeasy total RNA purification kit (QIAGEN, Chatsworth, CA) Typically, lo6 mammalian cells from cell culture yield 5 pg of RNA m 50 $ For bacterta, a hot phenol extraction may be used (23) This is treated with 0 08 U/pL DNase (plus 0 24 U/$ of RNasm, an RNase inhibitor) at 37°C for 40 mm m 1X RT buffer The RNA is repurtfied using the RNeasy kit The yield is estimated by spectrophotometry and the RNA is diluted to 200 ng/pL in water If sufficient RNA is available, the quality and concentration of the RNA is checked by agarose gel electrophoresis before bemg stored at -80°C (see Note 1 for comments on experrmental destgn)
Fmgerprin
ting
15
Reverse transcription 1s performed on total RNA at three concentrations per sample (500, 250, and 125 ng per reactton) using an ohgonucleotrde primer of arbitrary sequence of 10-20 nt m length (see Note 2) 5 ,LILof each RNA is mixed with the same volume of RT reaction mrxture for a 10 pL final reaction contammg 50 mA4 Tris pH 8.3, 50 mA4 KCI, 4 mA4 MgCl,, 10 n&f DTT, 0 2 mM of each dNTP, 2 @4 of first primer, and 16 U of MuLV-reverse transcrrptase (see Notes 3-6). The first strand cDNA synthesis reaction IS then ramped from room temperature to 37°C over 5 min, held at 37’C for 1 h, then heated to 94°C for 5 mm to stop the reaction Finally, the resultant first strand cDNA IS diluted fourfold by the addttion of 3 vol of water. For second strand synthesis, the diluted cDNA (10 pL) 1s mixed with the same volume of PCR mixture for a 20-pL final reaction contammg 10 mMTrts pH 8.3, 10 rnA4KC1,4 mA4MgC12, 0.2 mA4of each dNTP, 4 pA4of a second primer, 1 &I [u-~~P] dCTP, and 4 U of AmphZrq polymerase Stoffel fragment (see Note 7) Thermocyclmg 1sperformed using: 30 cycles of 94°C for 30 s, 35°C for 1 mm, 1 mm ramp to 72°C and 72°C for 2 mm. Amphficatron products (5 pL) are mixed with 15 ,rrL of formamide dye solution, denatured at 68°C for 10 mm, and 2 2 pL IS loaded onto a 5% acrylamrde-50% urea gel, prepared m 1X TBE buffer. Electrophoresis 1s performed using a sequencing apparatus at 58 W constant power (about 1500 V) until the xylene cyan01 tracking dye reaches the bottom of the gel (approx 4 h). After electrophoresrs the gel is transferred to Whatman 3MM paper, and dried under vacuum The drred gel 1s autoradrographed using Bromax film (Kodak) for 12 h-4 d. An mtensrfymg screen 1snot used because this tends to blur the fine details of closely packed PCR products. An example IS shown in Fig. 1,
3.2. Isolation
of Differentially Amplified PCR Products One of the major bottlenecks m using RAP-PCR or Differential Display is the need to isolate and characterize the PCR fragments representmg differentially amplified PCR products. The initial step employed has usually been the same as that used for AP-PCR of DNA (4), namely, cutting the band from the denaturing polyacrylamide gel and reamplifymg the resultmg product. However, there is quite often a problem with this approach. The “Cot effect” (see Note 6) preferentially amplifies the other products of a stmrlar srze that are copurified with the band of interest. Although this IS not a problem in many caseswhere the band of interest vastly predominates even after partial normalrzatton during PCR, it can lead to a lot of wasted effort for a subset of products where contaminants predominate. We have used two approaches to address this problem. One way to increase the probability of cloning the correct band from the mixture is to simply mimmrze the number of cycles of PCR, thereby limiting the mass of DNA made and thus the Cot effect. Alternatively, the
16
McClelland et al. tel
di
mes
met
622 bp
527 bp
404 bp
307 bp ’
Fig. 1. Differential gene expression in the mouse brain. The following parts of the mouse brain were dissected at 12 d postconception by Kiran Chada, UMDNJ: telencephalon, diencephalon, mesencephalon, and metencephalon. We prepared RNA from these samples and 1000, 500, and 250 ng of each were reverse transcribed with the primer Tryp 1- (S-GTGGCGTTGAT). One-fourth of the first strand synthesis was used in a second strand cDNA reaction after the addition of the primer OPN25 (S- GGGGCACCAG) and Stoffel fragment of Tuq polymerase. After PCR the products were resolved on a 5% denaturing acrylamide gel. Arrows indicate two differentially expressed genes.
fingerprinting
17
reamplified material can be separated by single-strand conformation polymorphisms (SSCP) resolved on a native polyacrylamlde gel (24). This method resolves the denatured reampllfied PCR product by virtue of secondary structure. Because the product of interest and the contaminants are of entirely different sequence, they migrate to different points on the gel. The level of contammatton can be assessed from these gels allowing problematic reampiificatlon mixtures to be rejected for further study. Finally, if enough PCR product is loaded in the initial fingerprmtmg gel then SSCP can be performed on the eluted product of interest without reamplification. For this procedure we have found a 2-4 d autoradiography with an intensifying screen is needed to vlsuahze the strands. However, this strategy entirely avoids the problems associated with reampllficatlon of the initial PCR product until the product of interest is highly purified on the SSCP gel. After removal from the SSCP gel the product(s) are reamplified for 20 cycles or less and either used directly for sequencing, or for cloning then sequencing. This latter protocol is presented here. 1. When products of Interest are identified the RAP-PCR reactions of interest and suitable control RAP-PCR reactions are loaded in multiple adJacent lanes following the fingerprinting protocol m Section 3.1 , steps 6-8. The purpose of this preparative gel is to resolve large quantities of the PCR products of interest (see Note 8). RadIoactive ink or fluorescent markers are attached to the dried gel to allow reorlentatlon of the film with the gel. 2. The band of interest IS excised from this preparative gel, and the gel re-exposed to X-ray film to reveal a clear swathe where the band was excrsed. 3 The piece of dried acrylamide containing the band of Interest IS placed in 100 & TE, and heated to 68°C for an hour then left overnight at room temperature to allow the PCR product to diffuse out. 4. The eluted material IS ethanol precipitated. The incompletely polymerized acrylamide acts as an effective carrier 5. The radioactive pellet is directly dissolved m 4 pL 10 mA4 NaOH dye solution, denatured for 2 min at 94”C, placed on ice for 5 mm, then loaded on an MDE gel for resolution of single strand conformation polymorphisms 6 After electrophoresls, the SSCP gel IS dried (see steps 6, and 7 in Section 3.1,) and autoradlographed using an intenslfymg screen. Because the band of interest IS of higher intensity than background bands, the darkest band on the SSCP gel corresponds to the desired product Frequently, this band will resolve mto two strands. Background bands, of relatively low intensity and of an entirely dlfferent sequence, will resolve to many positions on the gel, and are often not visible after short autoradiographic exposure Usually double stranded product runs much faster than the single stranded products of interest An example is shown in Frg 2 7. Once resolved by SSCP, the product can be excised and eluted from the gel, PCR amplified for 20 cycles or less, and used for direct sequencing or for cloning
18
McClelland et al.
SlS2S3S4S5S6S *rl
Fig. 2. SSCP of products isolated from a RAP-PCR gel. Products of interest were cut from the dried fingerprinting gel shown above. The products were eluted overnight, ethanol precipitated, and the entire pellet was mixed with 10 mM NaOH buffer, denatured, and loaded on a 1X MDE native acrylamide gel (JT Baker Inc., Phillipsburg, NJ). A denatured MspI digest of pBR322 was used as a marker. After electrophoresis the gel was dried and exposed to X-ray film using an intensifying screen at -80°C. Subsequently each of the single stranded products was isolated, reamplitied, cloned, sequenced, and deposited in the GenBank database.
19
Fingerprinting
3.3. Confirmation
of Differential
Expression
Not all products that are characterized from RNA fingerprmtmg gels are actually differentially expressed. The sources of false positives m&de “sporadic” PCR products generated during fingerprmtmg, although these are usually ehmmated by comparmg two RNA concentrations per sample. In addition, the wrong product may reampltfy efficiently from the excised fragment of interest, although this IS usually elrmmated by performing SSCP before reamplrficatton. Some independent method such as Northern blotting or RT-PCR must be used to confirm the product arises from a differentially expressed transcript We have developed streamlined ways to confirm differential expression One method that has proved both effective and relatively simple IS based on RT-PCR A patr of spectfic primers with melting temperatures of 60°C or more (typically 18 bases or longer) are derived from the sequence of the RAP-PCR product of interest The spectftc prtmers are both used at a concentration of 2 l&J for first strand reverse transcrtptton for each of the RNAs where differential expression needs to be examined (usmg the buffer mcubatton condtttons m Section 3 l., steps 2 and 3) PCR is performed using low stringency (35°C) annealing, m a manner similar to RAP-PCR, at two template concentrattons (typically, 100 and 200 ng). The buffer condtttons and amphficatton profile m Section 3 1 , steps 4 and 5 are used except that the primers are at a concentratton of 1 5 cul/%PCR 1sperformed m separate tubes for 15,20, and 25 cycles to ensure that the spectfic product of interest can be easrly detected, regardless of mtttal abundance. Electrophorests and autoradtography are as m Section 3.1 , steps 6-8 Thts protocol generates a product of the expected size for the transcript of mterest. However, it also generates other products from arbttrartly prtmed PCR Most of these arbitrary products are derived from RNAs that are not dtfferenttally expressed. Such products act as a convenient internal control for the level of amphfication and the quality of the PCR reaction The desired PCR products and a swathe of control products are each cut from each lane of the gel and counted m scmtillation fluid If a fluortmager is available this would be the preferred tool. When the mass of the PCR product from the gene of interest is normahzed against the mternal controls an estimate of the relative expresston of the gene m the different samples is obtained One caveat m this method IS that the Cot effect (see Note 6) causes differences observed between products to underestimate the true differences between the startmg RNA samples However, this discrepancy is reduced at lower cycle numbers so the amplificatton IS best sampled at a number of PCR cycles or at a number of starting RNA concentrations The most useful data is then derived for the lowest number of cycles or lowest RNA concentratton that 1scompatible wtth the method employed for measuring product formation.
20
McClellana et al.
4. Notes 1. Experimental design: There are multiple steps needed to detect and characterize a differentially expressed transcript and sampling is biased towards more abundant transcripts (see Note 4). Thus, for many questions regarding differential gene expression there may be other methods that are better suited, such as differential screening or subtractive hybridization. However, unlike these methods, RAP-PCR allows many RNA samples to be compared in parallel (25). If eight different RNA samples are compared and the levels of each transcript is unchanged or up- or downregulated in each RNA sample then there are almost 3* (more than 6000) possible permutations of gene expression that are surveyed. This calculation does not take into account the further division of expression profiles to account for large versus small increase or decreases in gene expression. Most of the vast number of observable regulatory categories will not exist but, nevertheless, examples of genes that fall into rather sophisticated regulatory categories can be searched for. Furthermore, genes that fall into totally unexpected categories may be found. 2. Longer primers can be used. For an 1%mer primer the annealing temperature during PCR is changed to 45°C and Tuq polymerase Stoffel fragment is replaced by AmpliTaq. One advantage of longer primers is that they can easily accommodate restriction sites for subsequent cloning or can encode “motif’ sequences that may direct priming to transcripts encoding conserved amino acid sequences (26). Even 10-mer primers can encode short motifs. An example is the Tryp 1- primer (5’-GTGGCGTTGAT) in Fig. I that is a conceptual translation of a tyrosine phosphatase conserved amino acid motif. 3. Fingerprinting multiple RNA concentrations: As is true for DNA fingerprints, a few products in each RNA fingerprint can be sensitive to RNA concentration and quality. For this reason we perform RNA fingerprints using at least two RNA concentrations that differ by twofold. This strategy allows those PCR products that are not reproducible at both RNA concentrations to be eliminated from further consideration, Fingerprinting duplicates of each RNA from each experimental condition at the same concentration is less effective because this does not necessarily control for variation that is concentration- and quality-dependent. Fingerprinting separate RNA preparations for each sample condition is also less effective because differences in RNA quality between different experimental conditions are not controlled. 4. Sampling efficiency: One of the primary limitations of arbitrarily primed RNA fingerprinting methods is the fact that the probability of being able to visualize a PCR product derived from a particular transcript is a function of both the quality of the match of the primer with two sites in the template and the abundance of the transcript. For example, if two templates have the same match and are equally efficiently amplified but differ by loo-fold in abundance, the ratio of these products will remain 100: 1 during most of the reaction. As a consequence, less abundant transcripts will be more difficult to see on a fingerprint or may not be visible at all. Calculations that assume each transcript can be sampled with equal effi-
Fingerprinting ctency do not take into account the fact that rarer transcripts will be on average much more difficult to vtsualize. Thus, a calculation of the number of fingerprints needed to sample, say, 95% of the transcripts that assumed normalized sampling and equal visibility of products derived from rare transcripts would be a considerable underestimate of the actual number of fingerprints needed One logical response to these considerations is to ensure that any expertment that is to be performed using this method does not require efficient coverage of rarer transcripts. 5. One method we have used in an attempt to improve sampling of rarer transcripts is to reamplify the RNA fingerprint with a primer that contains an extra arbitrarily selected base at the 5’ end (or more than one such base) (26). The Idea is to select a subset of the initial fingerprint for reamplification, Including PCR products, which are not visible on the initial fingerprint because they originate from the complex class of rare transcripts. When primers of 18 bases m length are used for the initial fingerprinting and nestmgs, this method can generate a new fingerprint when the “nesting” includes up to three bases However, the fingerprint becomes less reliable as the nesting length is increased, presumably because products of extension from poorer and less efficient matches are also amplified from the background of the fingerprint. Interestingly, lo-mer primers are too short for nesting presumably because annealing must take place at so low a temperature that extension occurs from all of the initial fingerprint products, regardless of the 3’ match The method is also useful if the RNA used for fingerprmtmg is so limited that the generation of further fingerprints from the first fingerprint would be desirable to conserve precious RNA. 6. The “Cot effect”: In later cycles of PCR the concentration of the more abundant PCR products is sufficiently high that there is considerable product self-annealing that occurs in the lower temperature steps of the PCR cycles. This has the effect of preferentially slowing the amplification efficiency of the more abundant PCR products. Two consequences can be expected. First, less abundant products have a chance to gain some ground and become visible. This advantage of rarer products may slightly mitigate against the fact that rarer products are otherwise less easily seen in fingerprints. Second, differences visible between different RNA samples may be partially erased, particularly for the more abundant products. Thus, surprismgly, differences visible between lanes may actually underestimate the true differences in abundances of the transcripts. We have called this phenomenon of product self-annealing the Cot effect in reference to the dependence of annealing on the initial concentration and time. It is interesting to note that intentionally increasing the Cot effect could be desirable in some circumstances. For example, if one is interested in “normahzing” a mtxture of PCR products. Possible application would include sampling the entire complexity of genotypes for an environmental sample. A class of genes of interest would be PCR amplified under conditions where homologs would rehybndize, allowing other amplified genes from rarer organisms m the sample to become relatively enriched in the sample. Another example might be the nor-
McClelland et al.
22
maltzatton of a cDNA library, although crossover PCR might be a concern In both cases the PCR reaction would be held at 60-85°C for many mmutes, or perhaps even hours, at each cycle to block amphficatton of the more abundant products 7 About 0 5 l&f of the first primer 1scarried over into the second reaction Adding 4 @4 of a second primer for the second strand syntheses results prtmartly m PCR products that have the first primer at the 3’ end of the sense strand of the transcript and the second primer at the 5’ end Thus, the sense ortentatton of the products 1sgenerally known Thts phenomenon is accentuated by the observatron that PCR products that have the same primer at each end seem to be out-competed by products that have different primers at each end (27) The use of an arbitrary primer m the RT reaction allows PCR products to be derived from internal parts of a transcript, mcludmg the protein coding region. This can help later when determinmg the nature of the transcript Also, transcripts that are not polyadenylated, such as bactertal RNAs, can be sampled by thus method. 8 If the origmal fingerprmt IS no longer radioactive then It can be made radioactive again by reamphficatron of 1 pL of the reaction for a further five PCR cycles m 10 & of fresh RAP-PCR amplification mixture
Acknowledgments Thts work was supported in part by grants A134829, NS33377, and CA68822 from the National Institutes of Health and by a generous gift from Sidney Kmnnel.
References Welsh, J and McClelland, M. (1990) Fingerprintmg genomes using PCR wtth arbttrary primers Nuclezc Aczds Res 18, 7213-72 18 Wtlltams, J G , Kubehk, A R , Ltvak, K J , Rafalskt, J. A , and Tmgey, S. V (1990) DNA polymorphtsms amplified by arbttrary primers are useful as genettc markers Nuclezc Acids Res 18, 653 l-6535 Rerter, R. S , Willrams, J. G., Feldmann, K A., Rafalskt, J A , Tingey, S. V , and Scolmk, P A. (1992) Global and local genome mappmg m Arabzdopszs thalzana by using recombinant inbred lines and random amphfied polymorphic DNAs Proc Nat1 Acad Sa USA 89,1477-1481 Welsh, J , Petersen, C , and McClelland, M (1991) Polymorphtsms generated by arbttrartly prrmed PCR in the mouse. application to strain rdenttficatton and genetic mappmg Nuclezc Aczds Res 19, 303-306 Al Janabt, S M , Honeycutt, R J , McClelland, M., and Sobral, B W. (1993) A genetic linkage map of Saccharum spontaneum L ‘SES 208’ Genetics 134, 1249-1260 Birkenmeter, E. H , Schneider, U , and Thurston, S J (1992) Fingerprmtmg genomes by use of PCR with prrmers that encode protem mottfs or contam sequences that regulate gene expression [published erratum appears m Mamm Genome 1993,4(2) 1331. Mamm Genome 3,537-545
Fingerprinting
23
7 Mlchelmore, R. W , Paran, I , and Kesseh, R V (1991) Identtficatlon of markers lmked to disease-resistance genes by bulked segregant analysts* a rapid method to detect markers m specific genomic regions by usmg segregating populattons Proc Natl Acad. Scz. USA 88,9828-9832.
8 Mathteu-Daude, F , Stevens, J., Welsh, J., Tibayrenc, M , and McClelland, M. (1995) Genetic diversity and population structure of Trypanosoma brucet clonality versus sexuality. Mol Blochem Parasltol 72, 89-101 9. O’Rourke, M. and Sprat& B. G (1994) Further evidence for the non-clonal population structure of Nezsserza gonorrhoeae extensive genettc dtverstty within ISOlates of the same electrophoretlc type Mzcrobzology 140, 1285-1290 10 Fukatsu, T and Ishtkawa, H (1994) Dtfferenttatlon of aphid clones by arbttrarlly primed polymerase cham reaction (AP-PCR) DNA fingerprmtmg Mel Ecol 3, 187-192 11. Levttan, D R. and Grosberg, R K (1993) The analysts of paternity and mater-t-my m the marme hydrozoan Hydvactznla symbzolonglcarpus usmg randomly amplltied polymorphic DNA (RAPD) markers MoZ Ecol 2,3 15-326 12 Tamate, H B., Shlbata, K , Tsuchtya, T , and Ohtalshi, N (1995) Assessment of genettc variations within populations of Sika deer m Japan by analysts of randomly amplified polymorphic DNA (RAPD) Zoolog Scz 12,669-673 13 Chapco, W., Ashton, N W , Martel, R K , Antomshyn, N., and Crosby, W L (1992) A feaslblllty study of the use of random amplified polymorphtc DNA m the population genetics and systematics of grasshoppers Genome 35, 569-574. 14 Fang, F C , McClelland, M , Gumey, D G , Jackson, M M , Hartstem, A I, Morthland, V H , Davis, C E , McPherson, D C , and Welsh, J (1993) Value of molecular epldemlologrc analysts in a nosocomtal methlclllm-resistant Staphylococcus aureus outbreak [see comments] JAMA 270, 1323-1328. 15 van Belkum, A , van Leeuwen, W , Kluytmans, J., and Verbrugh, H (1995) Molecular nosocomtal epidemiology* high speed typmg of mlcroblal pathogens by arbitrary primed polymerase chain reaction assays Infect Control Hasp Epldemzol
16,658466
16 Tang, Y. J., Houston, S T , Gumerlock, P. H , Mulhgan, M E , Gerdmg, D. N , Johnson, S , Fekety, F R., and Silva, J J. (1995) Comparison of arbitrarily primed PCR with restrmtton endonuclease and lmmunoblot analyses for typmg Clostrldlum d&f?clle isolates J Clan Mlcroblol 33, 3169-3173 17. Coelho, A., Vicente, A. C , Baptista, M A , Momen, H , Santos, F A , and Salles, C A. (1995) The distinction of pathogenic Vtbrto cholerae groups using arbltrarlly primed PCR fingerprints. Res Mlcroblol. 146, 67 l-683 18. van Belkum, A , Kluytmans, J , van Leeuwen, W., Bax, R , Qumt, W., Peters, E , Fluit, A , Vandenbroucke Grauls, C , van den Brule, A , Koeleman, H , et al (1995) Multtcenter evaluation of arbitrarily primed PCR for typmg of Staphylococcus aureus strains J Clwz. Mlcroblol 33, 1537-1547 19. Madico, G., Akopyants, N. S , and Berg, D E (1995) Arbitrarily primed PCR DNA fingerprmtmg of Escherzchza co110157.H7 strams by using templates from boiled cultures J Clrn Mzcroblol 33, 1534-1536
McClelland et al.
24
20. Perucho, M., Welsh, J., Peinado, M. A., Ionov, Y., and McClelland, M. (1995) Fingerprinting of DNA and RNA by arbitrarily primed polymerase chain reaction: apphcatlons m cancer research Methods Enzymol 254,275-290 21. Welsh, J., Chada, K., Dalal, S S., Cheng, R., Ralph, D., and McClelland, M. (1992) Arbitrarily primed PCR tingerprmting of RNA. Nucleic Acids Res 20, 4965-4970. 22 Liang, P. and Pardee, A. B. (1992) Differential drsplay of eukaryotic messenger RNA by means of the polymerase chain reaction [see comments] Science 257, 967-971. 23. Wong, K. K. and McClelland, M. (1994) Stress-inducible gene of Salmonella typhlmurlum identified by arbitrarily primed PCR of RNA Proc Natl. Acad SCL USA 91,639-643
24. Hayashi, K. and Yandell, D W. (1993) How sensitive is PCR-SSCP? Hum Mutat 2,338-346
25. McClelland, M., Ralph, D., Cheng, R., and Welsh, J. (1994) Interactions among regulators of RNA abundance characterized using RNA tingerprintmg by arbitrarily primed PCR. Nuclezc Acids Res 22,44 19-443 1 26. Ralph, D., McClelland, M., and Welsh, J. (1993) RNA fingerprmtmg usmg arbltrarlly primed PCR identifies drfferentially regulated RNAs in mink lung (Mv 1Lu) cells growth arrested by transforming growth factor beta 1 Proc Nut1 Acad Sci. USA 90, 10,71O-10,714 27. Welsh, J. and McClelland, M. (1991) Genomic tingerprmting using arbitrarily primed PCR and a matrix of painvlse combinations of primers. Nuclex Acids Res 19,5275-5279.
3 Differential Display Using Random Hexamer-Primed cDNA, Motif Primers, and Agarose Gel Electrophoresis Patrick J. Donohue, Debbie K. W. Hsu, and Jeffrey A. Winkles I, Introduction Polypeptide growth factors stimulate cellular proliferation by bmdmg to the extracellular domam of transmembrane receptors and thereby activating mtracellular signal transduction pathways. One cellular response to mitogenic stimulation is the sequential transcriptional induction of specific nuclear genes encoding proteins of diverse functions (reviewed in refs. 1 and 2). Many of these proteins are likely to be required for DNA replication and cellular division. As an approach to identify novel gene products involved in polypeptide growth factor signaling, we are studying tibroblast growth factor (FGF)- 1-inducible gene expression m murine NIH-3T3 cells. FGF-1 is a member of a family of structurally-related mitogens than can promote cellular proliferation, migration and differentiation (reviewed in refs. 3’ and 4). Its biological effects are mediated by protein tyrosine kinase cell surface receptors present on most cell types. FGF-1 is likely to be involved in the pathogenesis of several human diseases, including atherosclerosis and cancer. We reported in 1993 that a differential display approach using agarose gel electrophoresis could be used successfully to identify genes expressed following FGF-1 treatment of serum-starved NEH-3T3 fibroblasts (5). This approach is conceptually similar to the mRNA differential display and RNA fingerprmtmg methods described by other groups (reviewed in refs. 6 and 7). However, in comparison to these approaches, in our method (1) cDNA is synthesized usmg random hexamer primers; (2) polymerase chain reaction (PCR) assaysare performed using sense and antisense oligonucleotide primers, usually degenerate From
Methods m Molecular Bology, Vol 85 D/fferentral Edlted by P Llang and A B Pardee Humana
25
D/splay Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
Donohue, Hsu, and Winkles
26
m sequence, which are designed to amplify cDNA templates encoding proteins with particular structural motifs; and (3) ampllficatlon products are displayed using agarose gel electrophoresls and ethldmm bromide staining (reviewed m ref. 8). This method does not require the use of radlolsotopes nor the potent neurotoxms, acrylamlde and bu-acrylamlde. However, It is hmlted by the relatively low resolution of agarose gels and the Inability of fluorescent dye staining to detect amplification products derived from relatively rare cDNA templates. In our mltlal series of experiments, 30 cDNA fragments were isolated and 25 of these were successfully reamphfied and cloned mto a plasmld vector. When used as probes m Northern blot hybridization experiments, 15 of the 25 cDNAs detected transcripts that were expressed at an increased level m FGF- 1-stimulated cells. DNA sequence analysis revealed that 13 of the 15 cDNAs were unique and that four of the 13 cDNAs were amplified when a single ollgonucleotlde functioned as both a sense and antisense primer. Furthermore, although our initial goal was to use the motif primers to enrich for differentially expressed members of particular gene families, the majority of the FGF- l-inducible genes characterized to date do not encode protems with the targeted motifs ($9-11). This 1s because, under the PCR condltlons used, many of the motif primers were able to anneal to and prime cDNA templates with a relatively low degree of sequence identity. However, m at least one case, the targeting aspect of the approach descrtbed here was successful (12). In this report, we outline our basic differential display technique and note vanatlons performed by us and also described by others.
2. Materials 2. I. RNA Isolation
from Tissue Culture Cells
1 RNA STAT-60 (Tel-Test “B,” Friendswood, TX). This solution should be stored at 4°C up to 9 mo and 1slight-sensitive. It contains phenol and guamdlmum thlocyanate and should be handled wearing gloves and a lab coat. Avold breathmg vapor. 2 Chloroform. This should also be handled using the precautions described m item 1 3. Isopropanol. 4. Ethanol
2.2. cDNA Synthesis 1. Moloney murme leukemia virus (M-MLV) reverse transcrlptase (Life Technologies, Galthersburg, MD), 200 U/pi. Store at -20°C (not m a frost-free freezer) 2. 5X Reverse transcrlptase buffer: 250 mM Tns-HCl, pH 8.3, 375 mM KCl, 15 mMMgC1, 3. Dlthiothreltol, O.lM. 4 dNTP mix: 1 25 mM of each dNTP (Boehringer Mannhelm, Indianapolis, IN) 5 RNasm ribonuclease inhibitor (Promega, Madison, WI), 33 U/@ Store at -2O’C (not In a frost-free freezer). 6 Random hexamer (pd[N]& primers (Boehringer Mannhelm), 50 ng/&
Differential D/splay Vauatlons Table 1 Motif Oligonucleotide Motif Protein tyrosme kmase Zmc linger Leucme zipper
Src homology-2
Primers
Ammo acid sequence IHRDL DVWSFG GQKPYEC HQRIHTG LEEKATQL LEEKATQL LEEKATQL LEEKATQL FLVRESET VKHYKIR FLVRESET VKHYKIR
27 Used for PCR Amplification DNA strand
Sense Antisense Sense Antisense Sense Sense Antisense Antisense Sense Sense Antisense Antisense
Primer sequencea b CGGATCCACMGNGAYYT GGAATTCCAWAGGACCASACRTC
GGNGAGAARCCCTWYGARTG CCHGTGTGARTCCTCTGRTG CTGGAGGAGAAGGYGRCCCAGCT CTGGARGMNVAGRHSRMSMMGCT AGCTGGGYCRCCTTCTCCTCCAG AGCKKSKYSDYCTBNKCYTCCAG TTCCTGGTGCGGGAGTCTGAGACC GTGAAGCACTACAAGATCCGG GGTCTCAGACTCCCGCACCAGGAA CCGGATCTTGTAGTGCTTCAC
aPrlmer sequences are 5’ to 3’, addltlonal nucleotldes used for restrxtlon enzyme recogmtlon are m bold 6Degenerate bases m the primers are abbreviated as recommended by a nomenclature committee (21)
2.3. PCR 1. Taq DNA polymerase (Boehrmger Mannhelm), 5 U/pL. Store at -20°C (not m a frost-free freezer) 2 10X PCR buffer 100 mMTris-HCl, pH 8 3,500 mM KCI, 15 mMMgC1, 3. dNTP mix. 1 25 mA4 of each dNTP (Boehrmger Mannhelm) 4 Motif ohgonucleotide primers (Table 1); 0 5 ug/pL
2.4. Agarose
Gel EIectrophoresis
1 Agarose (Life Technologies) 2. 1OX Tris-acetate (TAE) buffer 400 mA4 Tris-acetate, 10 mM EDTA 3. 10X DNA gel loading buffer 50% glycerol, 0 2% bromophenol blue, 0.2% xylene cyan01 4. Ethtdmm bromide (Sigma, St. Louis, MO), 10 mg/mL This fluorescent dye is stored at 4°C and is light-sensitive. It is a mutagen and may be carcmogemc/ teratogemc, therefore, it should be handled wearing gloves and ethidmm bromide-contammg solutions should be disposed of properly
2.5. PCR Product Isolation,
Reamplification,
and Cloning
1 PCR and agarose gel electrophoresis reagents described above m Sections 2 3 and 2.4 2 Plasmid pCRI1 (Invitrogen, San Diego, CA), 25 ng/pL
28
Donohue, Hsu, and Winkles
3 1OX Ligation buffer 600 mM Trts-HCI, pH 7 5,600 mA4 MgCI,, 500 mM NaCf , 10 mg/mL bovine serum albumin, 700 mM P-mercaptoethanol, 10 mM ATP, 200 mM dtthtothrettol, 100 mA4 spermidme 4. T4 DNA ligase (Invitrogen), 4 UIuL Store at -20°C (not in a frost-free freezer) 5 E colz DH5a competent cells (Life Technologies) Store in ahquots at -70°C 6 SOC medra. 2% bacto-tryptone, 0 5% bacto-yeast extract, 10 mA4NaCl. 2 5 mM KCl, 10 mM MgCl,, 10 mM MgSO,, 20 mM glucose This media is prepared by first combmmg the tryptone, yeast extract, NaCl and KC1 and then autoclavmg. A glucose stock solutton (2M) and a Mg2+ stock solution (2M, comprised of 1M MgCl, and 1M MgSO,) are then prepared and sterilized by filtration through a 22-pm membrane. Finally, the media, glucose and Mg2+ are combined and sterilized by filtration. 7. Luria broth* 1% bacto-tryptone, 0 5% bacto-yeast extract, 1% NaCl Sterilize by autoclaving. 8 Bacto-agar (Dtfco, Detroit, MI) 9 Ampicillm (Sigma), 50 mg/mL. 10. 5-Bromo-4-chloro-3-mdolyl-p-n-galactopyranostde (X-gal, Boehrmger Mannhelm), 40 mg/mL in NJ-dtmethylformamtde
3. Methods 3.1. RNA Isolation
from Tissue Culture Cells
1 Lyse frozen cell pellets (-5 x lo6 cells; see Note 1) m 1 mL of RNA STAT-60 by repetmve plpeting. Incubate at room temperature for 5 mm 2 Add 0 2 mL of chloroform, mix and place samples at room temperature for 5 mm 3 Centrifuge the homogenate at 15,OOOg for 15 mm 4. Transfer 0.5 mL of the upper, colorless aqueous phase to a new tube, add 0 5 mL tsopropanol, vortex, and place samples at room temperature for 10 min 5. Centrifuge at 15,OOOg for 10 min and discard supematant 6. Wash RNA precipitate once with 1 mL 70% ethanol by vortexmg Centrifuge at 15,OOOg for 10 mm. Discard supematant. 7 Dry RNA pellet briefly for l-2 mm m Savant Speed-Vat Concentrator. 8. Dissolve RNA m 20 & autoclaved distilled H20. An mcubatlon at 55°C for 15 min may be required for complete resuspenston. 9 Determine the RNA concentration by measurmg the A260 of an ahquot using a UV spectrophotometer (1 A260 U = 40 pg/mL) 10 Store RNA samples at -70°C (see Note 2).
3.2. cDNA Synthesis 1. Combme 1 pg of total RNA and H20 to a final volume of 14.5 &. Heat at 65°C for 5 min and then cool on ice. 2. Set up the following 50 pL reactton by adding the reagents m this order 14.5 p.L RNA, 10.0 pI. 5X reverse transcriptase buffer, 5.0 pL dithlothreitol, 16.0 pL dNTP mix, 2 0 uL random hexamer primers (see Note 3), 0 5 p,L RNasm, and 2.0 pL M-MLV reverse transcriptase
Different/al Display Variations
29
3 Incubate at 37’C for 1 h. 4 Terminate reactton by heating at 95°C for 10 mm 5 Add 200 pL of dtstilled H,O and store at -20°C (see Note 4)
3.3. PCR 1 Set up the followmg 50 ~JLreaction by adding the reagents in this order: 5.0 pL cDNA, 5 0 p.L 10X PCR buffer, 8.0 pL dNTP mix, 30.5 l.tL H,O, 0.5 pL sense motif primer (see Notes 5-7), 0 5 l.tL antisense motif pnmer, and 0.5 pL Tuq DNA polymerase. 2. PCR 1sperformed using the following condittons (see Note 8) and a Perkm-Elmer Model 9600 thermocycler: 94”C, 5 mm Imtial Denaturation Stage I(8 cycles) 94°C 30 s denaturation 46°C 30 s annealing 68’C, 30 s extension Stage II (24 cycles) 94”C, 30 s denaturation 58“C, 30 s annealing 72”C, 30 s extension Final primer extension 72”C, 10 mm 3. Store samples at 4°C.
3.4. Agarose
Gel Hectrophoresis
1. Add 1.8 g agarose per 100 mL 1X TAE buffer (see Note 9). Dtssolve by heating m mmrowave oven, cool, and pour mto gel tray. 2. Prepare 1X TAE running buffer containing 1.5 pg/mL ethidium bromide. 3. An aliquot (18 pL) of each amplification mixture is then combined with 2 $ of 1OX DNA gel loading buffer and carefully pipeted into a gel lane. 4. Gel electrophorests is performed at 50-60 V constant voltage, usually for 0.5-2 h. 5. The gel is then briefly destamed by soaking in H,O with agitation and differenttal display products are visualized by UV light illumination (see Notes 10 and 11).
3.5. PCR Product Isolation,
Reamplification
and Cloning
1. DNA fragments of interest are excised from the gel using a razor blade, placed m 1.5-mL Eppendorf tubes and frozen at -7O’C for 15 min 2. Centrifuge at 15,000g for 15 mm Collect supematant and place in new tube. 3. A PCR product reampllfication step is then performed to generate a sufficient amount of DNA for subsequent cloning. The reaction is set up as described m Section 3.3 using 5 pL of the gel-recovered DNA solution and the primer pair used in the imttal PCR PCR IS performed using the same conditions as m the initial amplificatton except Stage I is omitted 4. The DNA (18 pL) is then subjected to agarose gel electrophorests and recovered as described prevtously m steps 1 and 2 (see Note 12). 5. Set up the following IO-@., reaction by adding the reagents m this order: 6.0 p.L PCR product, 2.0 pL Plasmtd (pCRI1) DNA, I 0 uL 10X ligation buffer, and 1 .O pL T4 DNA ligase.
30
Donohue, Hsu, and Winkles
6 Incubate at 12°C overnight 7 Set up the bacterial transformatton by combmmg 2-3 pL of the ligation reactton wtth 50 & of competent cells 8 Incubate on tee for 30 mm Heat shock at 42°C for 1 mm Place on ice 9 Add 450 pL of SOC media to cells Incubate at 37’C with agitation for 1 h. 10. Prepare four bactertal plates (100 x 15 mm) per transformation by combmmg 100 mL Lurla broth with 1.5 g Bacto-agar and autoclavmg 11 Place agar solution m 60°C water bath until cooled Add 150 p.L amptctllm and 100 p.L X-gal, mix and pour 25 mL per plate. Place at room temperature unttl sohdrfied 12 Spread 125 & of transformed cells per plate. Incubate at 37°C overnight 13 Blue and white colomes should be visible. Pick several white colonies, grow m Lurta broth/ampicillin media and prepare plasmid DNA by standard techniques (see Note 13)
4. Notes 1 In our specific case, we were attemptmg to tdenttfy genes that were expressed followmg FGF-1 sttmulatton of quiescent murme NIH-3T3 fibroblasts Thus, RNA was Isolated from quiescent cells as well as from cells treated with FGF- 1 for either 2 or 12 h 2 It 1simportant to confirm that the RNA is undegraded prior to its use An altquot (5-10 pg) should be subJected to electrophorests on a 1 2% agarose gel contammg 2.2M formaldehyde and then 28s and 18s rRNA integrity examined by ethtdium bromide stammg/UV light tllummatton usmg standard procedures 3. Reverse transcription with random hexamers will generate cDNA molecuies representing several regions ofmost mRNA species. However, unless poly(A)+ RNA 1sused as the template, most of the cDNA populatton wtll be copied from rRNA, which comprises the majority of the cellular RNA mass. In some cases, we have also made cDNA using the RACE ohgo d(T)-double adapter prtmer described by Frohman (13) 4. We always determme whether the cDNA synthesis reaction was successful by performmg PCR using 2% of the product and either p-actin or FGF receptor-l oligonucleotrde primers as descrtbed (14) 5 Twelve motif oltgonucleottde primers are listed m Table 1. The degenerate protem tyrosme kmase domain primers are identical to those described by Walks (15) The degenerate zmc finger and leucme zipper domam prtmers were destgned by alignmg various mouse DNA sequences and establishmg a consensus sequence The SK homology-2 domam primers were designed usmg the ammo acid sequence altgnment figure presented in Koch et al (16) and codon utiltzatton data (27) PCR assays were performed usmg one pan of primers at a time (sense and antisense) and all of the possible combmattons. As menttoned in Secton 1 , often these motif primers behaved as arbttrary primers under the PCR condtttons used in our experiments. Several examples of the primer cDNA mteractions that we have noted are shown m Ftg. 1,
Differential
Display
31
Varia Cons
1. Low sequence IdentIty between pnmer and cDNA ~'-GTGAAGC~~T~~~~I;A;~IC:~~;~~' SH2 sense FR-9 TCCTTCTACCACAAGCTCCGG 2245 PTt(antIsense 5'-G~IpATTfCAAAGF;eF~e~A~e?~3' FR-28 TGAGACCAGGGAGACCAGCCATC
2265
1349
1371
2
High sequence Identtty, but sense primer acttng as antisense primer (or we versa) i!F sense 5'-GG?F+Q?AGCCCTTCGAGTG3' 11111,1111,1 FR-1 ACAGAGATGCCCTTCGAGTG 687
666
3. Sequence Identity to mRNA 5’- or 3’-UT region. P~antlSenSe 5'-GGf\ATTC$!$ipAyGACCAGACATC-3' I I , I I I I I FR-1 TCATTAACAAGGACACAGACATC 17
39
Fig. 1. Nucleotlde sequence identity between several of the motif primers and the correspondmg regions of the FR cDNA clones DNA sequence analysis has Indicated that the majority ofthe genes that were identified using the motif primers do not encode proteins contammg the targeted structural domains Examples illustrating several of the most common explanations for this finding are shown here. In general, under the PCR conditions employed, the selectivity of the motif primers was poor and thus they were actually functlonmg m a similar manner as long arbitrary primers 6 Motif primers have also been used by two other groups attemptmg to identify differentially expressed members of known gene families Stone and Wharton (18) used several different degenerate protein kmase primers or zmc finger primers in combmation with degenerate arbitrary primers in their PCR assays They were able to identify cDNAs encodmg a novel casein kmase I lsoform and several zinc finger domain-contammg proteins. More recently, Bayarsalhan et al. (19) used inosine-containing SPChomology-2 and homeobox domain primers m combination with an arbitrary pnmer m their PCR assays.They isolated several cDNA clones but did not report whether they encoded proteins with the targeted structural mottfs 7. In those cases when cDNA samples were prepared using the RACE oligo d(T)-double adaptor primer (see Note 3), individual motif sense primers are used m combination with an antisense RACE outer adaptor primer (I 3) One of the 13 cDNAs that we ldentlfied by differential display was amplified using this RACE primer approach (5) 8 Some of our PCR assays have been performed using the followmg Stage I and II condltlons. 94”C, 30 s denaturation Stage I (8 cycles) 4O”C, 30 s annealing 68”C, 30 s extension Stage II (3@-40 cycles) 94”C, 30 s denaturatlon .54”C, 30 s annealing 72”C, 30 s extension
Donohue, Hsu, and Winkles
32 FGFM
0
’
2h
1 12h
’
ZF/PTK
Primers
- .-
281/271 234194 -
Fig. 2. Identification of an FGF- 1-inducible mRNA by differential display. RNA isolated from quiescent or FGF- 1-stimulated NIB-3T3 fibroblasts was converted to cDNA using random hexamer primers. PCR was then performed using a degenerate sense zinc finger (ZF) primer and a degenerate antisense protein tyrosine kinase (PTK) primer (top panel). As a control for the cDNA synthesis, PCR was also performed using sense and antisense FGF receptor (FGFR)- 1 primers (bottom panel). Amplification products were displayed using agarose gel electrophoresis and ethidium bromide staining. DNA size markers (M; in bp) are shown on the left. The pattern of amplified cDNAs obtained using RNA from quiescent or FGF-l-stimulated cells was similar except for an approx 700~bp DNA fragment, noted with an arrow in the top panel, that was present in the 12-h poststimulation lane. This fragment, termed FR- 1, was excised from the gel, reamplified, and cloned. 9. We have also displayed PCR amplification products on either 2% agarose gels or 4% agarose gels prepared using a 3:l ratio of NuSieve GTG low melt agarose (FMC Bioproducts, Rockland, ME) and standard agarose. 10. A photograph depicting a typical differential display gel (1.8% agarose) is shown in Fig. 2. 11. Two other laboratories have also successfully identified differentially expressed genes by differential display using agarose gel electrophoresis and ethidium bromide staining (Z9,20). 12. We have had poor success using this DNA as either a template for DNA sequence analysis or as a probe for Northern blot hybridization analysis. Therefore, we
Differential
Display Variations
33
FR-1
rRNA
Fig. 3. Northern blot hybridization analysis of FR- 1 mRNA expression in FGF- lstimulated flbroblasts. Northern blot analysis was performed to confirm the differential display results shown in Fig. 2 indicating that FR-1 mRNA levels were elevated in FGF- 1-stimulated cells. Quiescent NIH-3T3 cells were either left untreated (NT, no treatment) or treated with FGF- 1, FGF- 1 and actinomycin D (Act.D), or actinomycin D alone for 8 h. RNA was isolated and equivalent amounts of each sample, analyzed by Northern blot hybridization. The bottom panel is a photograph illustrating the relative amounts of 28s rRNA in each gel lane. FGF-1 induced FR-1 mRNA expression; furthermore, this effect is due, at least in part, to increased FR-1 gene transcription, since it does not occur if RNA synthesis is inhibited by actinomycin D.
routinely clone cDNAs isolated by differential display using the TA Cloning System (Invitrogen). 13. We always perform Northern blot hybridization analysis with purified cDNA insert as our first experiment in order to confirm that the gene under study is in fact differentially expressed. Our Northern blot hybridization protocol is described in Hsu et al. (I 1) and a representative result is shown in Fig. 3.
Acknowledgments This work was supported in part by National Institutes of Health Research Grants HL-39727 and HL-547 10. P. J. D. performed this work in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy from the Graduate Genetics Program, George Washington University, Washington, DC. D. K. W. H. was supported in part by National Institutes of Health Training Grant HL-07698. We thank W. H. Burgess for providing the FGF-1, K. Wawzinski and D. Weber for excellent secretarial assistance, and G. F. Alberts for reviewing the manuscript.
34
Donohue, Hsu, and Winkles
References 1. Willtams, G. T., Abler, A S., and Lau, L. F (1992) Regulation of gene expression by serum growth factors, m Molecular and Cellular Approaches to the Control of Prolzferation and Dtfferentzatton (Stem, G S. and Lian, J. B , eds ) Academic, Orlando, FL, pp. 115-161 2 Muller, R , Mumberg, D , and Lucibello, F C (1993) Signals and genes m the control of cell-cycle progression Brochtm Bzophys Acta 1155, 15 l-1 79 3. Burgess, W H. and Wmkles, J A (1996) The fibroblast growth factor famtly multifunctional regulators of cell proliferation, in Cell Proltferatton zn Cancer Regulatory Mechanisms ofNeoplasttc Cell Growth (Pusztai, L , Lewis, C E , and Yap, E , eds ), Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 154-2 17. 4 Fernig, D. G. and Gallagher, J T (1994) Fibroblast growth factors and their receptors: An information network controllmg tissue growth, morphogenests and repair Prog Growth Factor Rex 5, 353-317 5 Hsu, D K W , Donohue, P J., Alberts, G. F , and Winkles, J. A (1993) Fibroblast growth factor-l induces phosphofructokmase, fatty acid synthase and Ca2+-ATPase mRNA expression in NIH 3T3 cells Bzochem Bzophys. Res Commun 197,1483-1491 6 McClelland, M., Mathieu-Daude, F , and Welsh, J (1995) RNA fingerprmtmg and differential display using arbitrarily primed PCR. Trends Genet. 11,24 l-246. 7 Liang, P , and Pardee, A B. (1995) Recent advances m differential display Curr Open Immunol 7,274-280. 8. Winkles, J. A, Donohue, P J , Hsu, D K. W , Guo, Y , Alberts, G. F , andpeifley, K A. (1995) Identification of FGF-1 -mducible genes by differential display, in Cardtovascular Dtsease 2 Cellular and Molecular Mechanums, Preventton and Treatment (Gallo, L. L , ed ) Plenum, New York, pp 109-120 9. Donohue, P. J., Alberts, G. F., Hampton, B. S., and Winkles, J. A (1994) A delayed-early gene activated by tibroblast growth factor-l encodes a protein related to aldose reductase. J Biol Chem. 269,8604-8609 10 Hsu, D K W., Guo, Y., Alberts, G F., Petfley, K A , and Winkles, J A (1996) Fibroblast growth factor-l -inducible gene FR-17 encodes a nonmuscle a-actmm isoform. J Cell Physiol 167,261-268 11. Hsu, D K. W , Guo, Y., Alberts, G. F., Copeland, N G., Gilbert, D J., Jenkins, N A., Peifley, K A, and Winkles, J. A, (1996) Identification of a murme TEF1-related gene expressed after mitogemc stimulation of quiescent fibroblasts and during myogemc dtfferentiation J. Btol. Chem 271, 13,786-13,795 12 Donohue, P. J., Alberts, G F., Guo, Y , and Winkles, J A (1995) Identification by targeted differential display of an immediate-early gene encoding a putative serinelthreonine kinase J B1o1 Chem 270, 10,351-10,357. 13 Frohman, M A. (1993) Rapid amphfication of cDNA ends (RACE)* User-friendly cDNA cloning Amplzficatzons 5, 1l-l 5 14 Brogi, E., Winkles, J. A., Underwood, R , Clmton, S. K., Alberts, G F., and Libby, P (1993) Distinct patterns of expression of fibroblast growth factors and their receptors m human atheroma and non-atherosclerotic arteries. Assoctatton of
Differential
15 16
17. 18
19
Display Variations
35
acidic FGF with plaque microvessels and macrophages J Clin Invest 92, 2408-2418 Walks, A. F. (1989) Two putative protein-tyrosme kmases Identified by applrcanon of the polymerase chain reaction. Proc Nat1 Acad Scl USA 86,1603-1607 Koch, C. A., Anderson, D , Moran, M F., Ellis, C., and Pawson, T. (1991) SH2 and SH3 domains: Elements that control mteracttons of cytoplasmtc signaling protems Science 252, 668-674. Lathe, R. (1985) Synthetic oligonucleotide probes deduced from ammo acid sequence data* Theoretical and practical considerations. J Mel Bzol 183, 1-12. Stone, B and Wharton, W (1994) Targeted RNA fingerprintmg* The cloning of differentially-expressed cDNA fragments enriched for members of the zmc finger gene family. Nuclezc Acids Res 22,2612-2618 Bayarsarhan, D., Enkhmandakh, B., Farrell, C , and Lukens, L (1996) Rapid tdentrticatton of a novel chondrocyte-specific gene by RNA differential display Blochem Blophys Res Commun 220,449-452
20 Sokolov, B. P and Prockop, D J (1994) A rapid and simple PCR-based method for tsolatton of cDNAs from differentially expressed genes Nuclex Acids Res 22,4009-40 15 21 Dixon, H B F , Blelka, H , Cantor, C R , Llebecq, C , Sharon, N , Velrck, S F , and Vhegenthart, J F G (1986) Nomenclature for mcompletely specified bases m nucleic acid sequences J Bzol. Chem 261, 13-17
4 Fluorescent
Differential
Takashi Ito and Yoshiyuki
Display
Sakaki
1. Introduction Since their first mtroduction in 1992 (1,2), differential display (DD) and its relatives have been used extensively in various fields of biology where the identification of differentially expressed messagesare of particular interest and importance (for review, see ref. 3). These new techniques have several unique advantages over the conventtonal methods such as differential and/or subtractive hybrtdization-based ones. They can compare a number of samples m parallel to reveal transcripts of various behaviors, unlike subtractive hybridization techniques that essentially compare two samples unidirectionally. They can detect transcripts of low abundance as well as those showing subtle changes, that would be overlooked by conventional hybridization-based methods. Also, the techniques require only a tiny amount of RNAs to start the analysis so that they can be applied to biological samples that are difficult or impossible to prepare in large amounts. Despite these attractive features, the methods have several drawbacks. For instance, since they are essentially random sampling approaches, considerable numbers of reactions (i.e., primer combinations) have to be tested to statistically cover the complex transcript population. If one assume the sampling 1sa completely stochasticevent, the number of reactions required (N is calculated as N=ln(l
-P)lln(l
-B/E)
where P is the probability desired, E is the number of expressed transcript species, and B is the number of bands per each reaction. Therefore, if each DD reaction amplifies 100 cDNAs (B = loo), one has to perform about 450 reaction to cover all the transcript in typical mammalian cells (E = 15,000) with 95% probability (P = 0.95). From
Methods m Molecular B/ology, Vol 85 D/fferent/al E&ted by P Llang and A B Pardee Humana
37
D/splay Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
Ito and Sakakl
38
To run this scale of analyses with multiple samples, one has to Increase the speed of each analysis, m parttcular, that of electrophoresis, postrun gel processing and signal detection Furthermore, the safety problem inherent to radioactive DD would not be negligible m that scale (4). To overcome these drawbacks, we established two DD protocols compatible with fluorescent detection, termed fluorescent differential display (FDD) protocols S and L (S-7) Protocol S uses short arbitrary primers (1 0-mer) and low stringency PCR condition as the origmal DD protocol, but the design of anchor primers were modified so that one can obtain signals with enough mtensmes as well as satisfactory reproducibility The anchor primers currently used m protocol S are GT,,N (N = A, C, or G). They contam additional dGs at then S-ends, that are necessary for the generation of signals intense enough for fluorescent detection. (Addition of further nucleotides did not improve the signal anymore.) The protocol L uses primers of usual lengths (-20-mer) as upstream arbitrary primers. The anchor primers for protocol L are CCCGGATCCTt5N (N = A, C, or G). In the mittal cycle of PCR in protocol L, a low strmgency condition was used so that even a longer primer can nutlate second strand synthesis on multiple cDNAs. In the second and later cycles, the molecules tagged at their both ends with anchor and arbitrary primers are specifically amplified by means of high stringency PCR. The sequences added to the S-ends of the anchor primers are to increase their T, to be used m the high stringency PCR steps. Here we describe both FDD protocols using fluorescence image scanner, that ensure highly reliable DD analysis with much Improved speed and safety as demonstrated so far (5-7).
2. Materials 2.1. Reverse
Transcription
1 The anchor primers. FITC-GT,,N (N = A, C or G) for protocol S and FITCCCCGGATCCT1sN (N = A, C or G) for protocol L, were synthesized on ABI 392A DNA synthesizer using FluorPrime (Pharmacia, Sweden) The synthesized primers were dissolved m dtethylpyrocarbonate (DEPC)-treated water at the concentration of 50 @4. Anchor primers for PCR steps may be further purified by HPLC or PAGE
2. Preamplification
Kit (BRL, ME)* This kit contains Superscript 11reverse tran-
scriptase and other soluttons for reverse transcription
3. Thermal cycler: Since reverse transcription step uses vanous temperatures, we are using tube-type thermal cycler for the mcubatton 4 TE buffer 10 mA4 Tris-HCl, pH 8 0, and 1 mM EDTA
2.2. Polymerase 1 Arbitrary
Chain Reaction
primers: Arbitrary
lo-mers were obtained from Operon (Alameda, CA)
or synthesized in our laboratory (see Note 4), whereas various primers of 20 nt
Fiuorescent
Different/al
Display
39
long, that had been origmally designed for mdivtdual purposes m our lab, were recruited as arbitrary primers for protocol L They were adJusted to 10 fl and stored at -20°C 2. Taq DNA polymerase* We use GeneTaq DNA polymerase (Nippon Gene, Toyama, Japan), an N-terminally truncated Tuq DNA polymerase supplied with 1OX buffer and dNTP solution. To improve ampltfication of htgher mol-wt species, conventional Taq DNA polymerase from Perkm-Elmer or BRL 1sused with GeneTaq 3 Thermal cycler For a large number of PCR, those with 96-well microtiter plate format are convenient We routmely use Techne PHC-3 thermal cycler (Techne, UK) for PCR
2.3. Gel Electrophoresis 1 Gel solutton’ 6% polyacrylamide or LongRanger (FMC BtoProducts, ME) contaming 8 3M urea and 1X TBE buffer 2. Gel plates: The glass plates of low mtrmstc fluorescence are recommended. For the assembly of gel slab, we use 0 3.5-mm thick spacer and shark tooth comb 3 Image scanner We are usmg Vistra FluorImager SI (Molecular Dynamics, CA) for the scanning
3. Methods 3.7. Reverse
Transcription
1 Heat a thermal cycler to 70°C 2 Mix 8 0 l.tL of DEPC-treated water, 1 0 pL of Anchor Primer (50 CUM)and 1 0 pL of total RNA solution (2 5 pg/uL) m a 0 5-mL tube (see Note 1). 3. Place the tube m the thermocycler at 70°C for 5-10 mm 4 Durmg the mcubatton, prepare 2X RT solution by mixmg 2.0 pL of DEPC-treated water, 2.0 &of 10X PCR buffer, 2 0 pL of25 mMMgCl,, 2.0 &of 100 mMDTT, 1 0 cls, of 10 mM dNTP and 1 0 clr, of Superscript II (200 II/$) using a BRL preampltfication kit (see Note 2). Prepare enough amount, taking the pipeting loss mto account Followmg thorough but gentle mixing, place the tube on Ice 5 Place the heated tubes containing RNA and primers mto ice-water bath for a few minutes, and cool the thermal cycler to 25°C Following the brief spin, add 10 $ of 2X RT solutton mto each tube and mtx thoroughly by gentle pipetmg 6 Place the tubes m the thermal cycler, and incubate them for 10 mm at 25’C, 50 mm at 42°C and 15 mm at 70°C. 7. Following the above mcubatton, spm the tube briefly and add 80 & of TE. Store at -20°C until use
3.2. Polymerase
Chain Reaction
1 Mtx 13.0 (x N) $ ofdistilled water, 2 0 (x N) & of 10X GeneTaq buffer, 1.6 (x N) & of 2.5 mA4 dNTP, 0.2 (x N) pL o f anchor primer and 2 0 (x N) $ of cDNA solution (PCR mtx I). Calculate iV, taking into account the loss during repeated ptpetmg
Ito and Sakaki
40
2. Dispense 1.OpL of arbitrary primers ( 10 pmol) m each well of 96-well thermal plate 3. Make PCR mix II by mixmg 18.8 (x N) pL of PCR mix I, 0.1(x N) pL of GeneTaq DNA polymerase and 0 1 (x N) pL of AmphTaq DNA polymerase (see Note 3) 4. Dispense 19.0 pL of PCR mix II to each well containing 1.0 pL of arbitrary primers. 5 Overlay each well with a drop of mineral oil 6 Place the 96-well plate in thermal cycler, and run the followmg program (see Note 4). For protocol S: (94’C, 3 min + 4O”C, 5 min + 72”C, 5 mm) for 1 cycle + (95°C 15 s + 40°C, 2 mm + 72’C, 1 mm) for 20-24 cycles + 72°C 5 mm. For protocol L: (94’C, 3 min + 37°C 5 mm + 72”C, 5 min) for 1 cycle + (95°C 15 s + 55’C, 1 mm + 72’C, 1 mm) for 20-24 cycles + 72°C 5 mm.
3.3. Gel Electrophoresis 1 Prepare 6% polyacrylamide (or LongRanger) gel (200 x 330 x 0.35 mm) 2. Followmg polymerization, prerun the gel for 1 h at 1000 V. 3 Mix PCR products with isovolume of formamide dye solution, and heat at 90°C for 3 mm. 4. Load 5-6 pL of sample to each well of shark-tooth comb and run the gel at 1500 V for 1 h until bromophenol blue dye reaches to the bottom of the gel. 5 Remove the gel slab from the electrophoretic chamber, clean the glass plate and scan it by FluorImager SI using the high sensitivity mode This scan is to obtain images focusing on lower mol-wt bands (see Note 5 and Fig. 1). 6. Following the first scanning, place the gel slab to the electrophoretic chamber again and run for an additional hour until xylenecyanol dye migrates near the bottom of the gel. Scan the gel again to visualize higher mol-wt bands.
3.4. Molecular
Cloning of the Bands of Interest
1 Repeat the experiment using RNA batches different from those used m the first experiments to confirm the reproducibility of the behavior of the bands of your interest (see Note 6). 2. Run the gel of appropriate concentration and for an optimized duration to maximize the separation of the bands of interest Remove the upper glass plate, and scan the gel on FluorImager 3. Prmt the image usmg “actual size mode” and place the gel precisely onto the prmtout 4 Excise the band of your mterest using a razor blade. Following the excision, scan the gel again to see how precisely the band was excised. 5 Rinse the excised gel piece with distilled water. 6. Put the half of the gel piece mto a PCR tube, and cut tt into several smaller pieces using a flat loading tip just like a blade. 7. Add 100 pL of the PCR reaction mix II as described above except for the lower primer concentration (0.25 @4each) and subjected to the following thermal cycling
Fluorescent Differential
Display
Fig. 1. Identification of a transcript induced during the Alzheimer’s beta-peptideinduced apoptosis of neuroblastoma cells by the two step scanning procedure. Total RNAs were isolated from neuroblastoma LA-N-5 cells (lane 1) and those treated with Alzheimer’s beta-peptide for 0, 1, 6, 12,24, 30, and 48 h in lanes 2-8, respectively. The anchor primer used was GT&, and the arbitrary primers used from left to right were CTCACCGTCC, AAGCCTCGTC, GACGGATCAG and TTCCCCCCAG, respectively. While the left image was obtained following -1 h of gel running to focus on lower mol-wt species, the right one was taken from the same gel after an additional running for -1 h to put emphasis on higher mol-wt species. Note that the band shown by the arrowhead, that had been poorly resolved at the first scanning, was clearly separated in the right panel.
For protocol S: 94’C, 3 min + (94”C, 30 s + 4O”C, 2 min + 72°C 1 min) for -20 cycles + 72’C, 5 min. For protocol L: 94’C, 3 min + (94’C, 30 s + 55’C, 1 min + 72’C, 1 min) for -20 cycles + 72”C, 5 min. 8. Run a portion of reamplified product on a polyacrylamide gel to confirm the amount and purity of the product. 9. Following ethanol precipitation, clone the PCR product into the so-called T-vector.
/to and Sakakr
42 3.5. Selection
of Correct Clones
1 Suspend colomes of the transformants m 40 pL of L-broth 2. Use 1 0 pL of above suspenston m 20 pL of PCR using the same conditton described m Section 3 4 , step 7. 3 Run 0 l-l pL of the product m parallel with the ortgmal FDD reactton (“comigration test”). Select clones bearing inserts that precisely comtgrate wrth the band of Interest 4 Sequence the selected clones 5. Search restrtctron enzyme sites m the nucleottde sequences of the candidate clones. Digest the amplified mserts of the clones and the origmal FDD reaction with these restrtction enzymes, and run them m parallel to compare the digestion pattern of the target band and the mserts (“restrtctton test”) Select clones that are digested stmilarly to the band m FDD reaction for further analysrs 6 Confirm the expression pattern of the correspondmg transcrtpt by Northern blot hybndrzation, RNase protectton or quantitative RT-PCR assays 4. Notes Total RNAs prepared by various methods can be used for FDD We routinely use total RNAs prepared by a modified actd-guamdmmm-phenol-chloroform method usmg TRIzol reagents (BRL) accordmg to the supplier’s recommendatton As the contaminatron of genomtc DNA has severe effects on the DD pattern, m particular, m protocol S, we usually treated total RNA with RNase-free DNase (Promega) m the presence of placental RNase inhibttor or vanadyl-ribonuceoside complex to remove the residual contammatmg genomtc DNAs Although most RNA samples prepared by this method can be used for FDD, some may requrre further treatment. For Instance, we experrenced that RNAs from Xenopus early embryo requrres LiCl precipitation step for successful FDD (6) It should be noted that the use of RNAs of similar qualities is crtttcal for FDD We recommend to discard low quality RNA samples and re-prepare RNAs for the FDD We are using a kit from BRL for the reverse transcrtptton step, but others will give comparable results. Smce the first strand syntheses reqmres various temperatures, tt IS convement to use thermal cycler rather than preparing several water baths. Anchor primers used in protocols S and L are GT,,N and CCCGGATCCTlsN (N = A, C or G), respectively As they are incubated with RNA, special attention not to contammate with RNase has to be paid when preparing these primers We routinely use GeneTaq DNA polymerase (NIpponGene, Japan) for FDD analysis. This Tuq polymerase has a large deletron m its N-termmal portion and gives much stronger signals in lower mol-wt size range but weaker signals m higher mol-wt range than conventtonal Taq DNA polymerase. Thus, we use a cocktail of this enzyme and usual full-length Tuq polymerase to cover wider size range with higher signal mtensities We prefer 96-well plate-type thermocycler for large-number of PCR. As the fingerprmtmg pattern IS affected by the make of thermal cycler, one must not compare results obtamed by drfferent themal cyclers.
Fluorescent Dlfferentlal Display
43
4 In addition to arbitrarily chosen lo-mers, we are using novel IO-mers to mmimaze the transcripts that escape the analysis. Based on the observation that more than 90% of mammalian mRNAs seem to have at least one Mb01 (GATC) site in their 3’-end porttons (8), we prepared 32 primers that should cover all the possible Mb01 sttes as follows GGNXYZGATC N = mixture of A, C, G, and T X = R (purme) or Y (pyrimidme) Y = oneofA,C,G,orT Z = one of A, C, G, or T The positions 1 and 2 are fixed to G’s, since our data on mismatches between the arbitrary primes and correspondmg sequences on the transcripts showed less importance of these sites m annealing and priming We found that the primers with degenerate bases m posittons 3 and 4 can detect more bands than those carrying single nucleotrdes at these posmons Since we observed G-T mismatches m more 3’-end positions at the annealmg, we assume that these primers would cover not only all the possible Mb01 sites but other sequences, thereby further reducing the fraction escaping the survey. 5 The two-step scannmg procedure described allowed us to scan wider size range than conventional DD using autoradiographtc detection. Note that this 1s another advantage of FDD, mmimizmg the possibihty of mrssmg interesting bands An example of effective two-step scanning procedure is shown m Fig 1, where the band indicated by the arrow-head poorly resolved m the first scan was clearly separated m the second scanning Although we are currently using Vistra FluorImager SI, we confirmed that the other commercially available imager FMBIO-100 (Takara, Kyoto, Japan) gave comparable results when using with Texas-red or rhodamme X-labeled primers. Also, the detail for scannmg by DNA sequencer was described elsewhere (.5,7). 6. Molecular clonmg of the bands of interest is the other most crucial step for successful DD experiments Although the excised bands are occasionally pure enough to be directly used m cycle sequencing analysis, they are often contaminated with neighbormg bands and sometimes contain cDNAs that comigrate precisely with but distinct from the target species Therefore, one should pay every attention to confirm that the band of your interest, but not the comigrating ones, is really cloned. Described m Sectton 3 5 is our routine procedure to discrimmate true clones from false ones, but various other alternatives to the same purpose would be plausible, mcludmg differential screening of the clones with DD products or probing the Southern blot of the fingerprmts with candidate clones
Acknowledgments We thank A. Shlbata for providing data shown m the Fig. 1, This work was partly supported from grants from Ministry of Education, Science, Sports and Culture of Japan and those from Science and Technology
Agency of Japan.
/to and Sakaki
44
References 1 Ltang, P and Pardee, A. B (1992) Differential display of eukaryottc messenger RNA by means of the polymerase chain reactton Sczence 257,967-971 2. Welsh, J., Chada, K., Dalai, S S., Cheng, R., Ralph, D , and McClelland, M (1992) Arbitrarily primed PCR fingerprintmg of RNA Nuclezc Acid Res. 20, 4965-4970 3. McClelland
4
5.
6
7
M , Mathteu-Daude F , and Welsh, J. (1995) RNA fingerprintmg and differential display using arbitrarily primed PCR. Trends Genet 11, 242-246 Trentmann, S. M., van der Knaap, E., and Kende, H., Liang, P., and Pardee, A B. (1995) Alternattve to 35Sas a label for the differential drsplay of eukaryotic messenger RNA. Sczence 267, 1186,1187 Ito, T., Kito, K , Adati, N., Mttsui, Y., Hagtwara, H., and Sakaki, Y. (1994) Fluorescent differential display: arbitrarily primed RT-PCR tingerprmting on an automated DNA sequencer FEBS Lett 351,23 l-236 Ada&N., Ito, T., Koga, C., Kito, K., Sakaki, Y., and Shtokawa, K (1995) Differential display analysts of gene expression in developing embryos of Xenopus laevw. Blochim Blophys Acta 1262,43-5 1. Ito, T and Sakaki, Y (1996) Fluorescent differential display method for htghspeed scanning of tissue- or cell-specific transcripts Methods 4401 Genet 8,
229-245. 8 Ivanova, N B. and Belyavsky, A. V. (1995) Identification of differentially expressed
genes by restriction endonuclease-based gene expresston fingerprinting. Acids Res 23,2954--2958.
Nucleic
5 Cloning Differentially Expressed by Using Differential Display and Subtractive Hybridization
Genes
Jackson S. Wan and Mark G. Erlander 1. Introduction Differential gene expression occurs in all phases of life, includmg development, maintenance, injury, and death of an organism. Being able to identify these genes will help understand not only gene function but also the underlying molecular mechanisms of a particular biological system. Differential display (DD) (I,21 and subtractive hybridization (SH) (review see refs. 3-5) are by far the most common methods currently used by investigators for this purpose. However, do these techniques identify both abundant and rare mRNAs? Previous kinetic studies (6,7) indrcate that approx 98% of all mRNA species within the cell have a prevalence ranging from l/10,000 to l/100,000, and thus are considered rare. Furthermore, the remammg approx 2% of mRNA species (about 200-500) contribute to over 50% of the total mRNA mass (6,7). Therefore, it is relatively easy to identify a few very abundant differentially expressed mRNAs (i.e., using plus/minus screening); but if the quest is to identify the majority of differentially expressed mRNA species, then a method that is not sensitive to mRNA abundance is required. To evaluate how well DD and SH can identify abundant as well as rare differentially expressed mRNAs, we used both of these methods to find differentially expressed mRNAs within HeLa cells in response to interferon-y. Described below is a summary of our results (see ref. 8 for original report), followed by detailed protocols of DD, SH, and reverse Northern. Since the introductions of DD and SH, hundreds of reports have been published that document either successful applications or method improvements. From
Methods in Molecular Bology, Vol 85’ D/fferent/a/ Ed&d by P Llang and A B Pardee Humana
45
D/splay Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
46
Wan and Et-lander
However, some users of these technologies have experienced frustration and failure m implementmg these methods. For DD, most of the criticisms are: 1 2 3 4.
A high false posltwe rate Questioned ability of DD to identify both abundant and rare mRNAs Coding regions of mRNAs are usually not cloned Verlticatlon process IS time consummg and usually requires a fair amount of RNA (9,lO)
For SH, the most common complamt is the technical difficulty of the method; not only does one have to complete numerous tasks (2-3 wk of experiments) before one knows whether the subtraction has been successful but also if the subtractlon fails it is sometimes difficult to sort out which step went wrong. To identify differentially expressed genes m HeLa cells in response to IFNy, we surveyed via DD approx 1300 mRNA species with 72 primer sets and via SH sequenced 1000 cDNA clones from a subtracted library containing cDNAs made from IFN-y induced HeLa cells versus untreated Hela cells. In total, 33 and 23 differentially expressed genes were identified by SH and DD respectively; two of these were found by both methods. The low overlap suggest that many more differenttally expressed genes are yet to be found m this expenmental system and also that these two methods may identify different mRNA populations. The median mRNA abundance of the genes identified by both techniques was similar, approx l/20,000 and ranged from l/1000 to l/200,000 Thus, both methods were able to identify abundant and rare mRNAs. The htt rate (true positives) of DD (1 in 2) is slightly better than that of SH (1 m 5.6). However, hit rates of both methods can vary depending on the criteria for selecting clones/bands for evaluation and the biology being studied. For SH, cDNAs found multiple times m the subtracted library have a much higher hit rate than those found only once. Therefore, if numerous abundant differentially expressed mRNAs are present within the biological system under study then the hit rate ~111be high. With DD, we have observed that bands that are intense, sharp, and appear in a all-or-none fashion are more likely to be true positives. Redundancy (i.e., clonmg the same cDNA more than once) was observed m both methods. As indicated above, for SH, redundancy is mRNA abundancedependent. Consistent with this was our observation that for SH, abundant differentially expressed mRNAs were more readily identified than rare differentially expressed mRNAs. For DD, redundancy is primer sequence-dependent and can be observed m at least four ways. First, we as well as others, have shown that the four most 3’ bases of the lo-mer are the most critical m determinmg annealing specificity (8, II) By comparmg the sequence of a IO-mer with its site of annealmg on
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
47
the cDNAs, we have found that in 9 out of 10 cases,the mismatches occurred within the six bases at the 5’ end of the IO-mer and not in the four most 3’ bases. However, IO-mers identical at the last four bases do not necessarily produce similar band patterns (Fig. 1, lanes 2 and 3), indicating that although the four most 3’ bases determme annealing specificity, the 5’ end of the primer probably plays a role in stabilizmg or destabilizing a particular primer-cDNA complex. Second, redundancy can be caused by “weak” IO-mers. We define “weak” primers here as 10-mers that produce low intensity bands or blank lanes when used alone m a DD PCR (no TlzVX primer, i.e., anchor primer, is used m the reaction; see Fig. 1, lanes 6 and 9). With a weak 10-mer, one observes the same pattern of amplified cDNAs whether one uses IO-mer + anchor primer or anchor primer only (see Fig. 1, and compare lanes 1 and 4 with 5). Thus, weak lo-mers do not contribute to the amplltication process. We recommend that each anchor primer be used as a single primer m a DD PCR so that the anchor only pattern can be compared with anchor + IO-mer patterns for the process of eliminating weak primers from the lo-mer repertoire. Third, redundancy is contributed by the 3’ anchor primers as well. We have observed that the four anchor prtmers (Tt2VG, T12VA, T,,VT, TtZVC) do not completely separate the mRNA population mto four subpopulations when these anchor prtmers are used as first-strand synthesis primers for cDNA synthesis. Thus 1sillustrated m Fig. 2 (lanes 5, 10, 15, and 20), which demonstrates that a IO-mer used alone m a DD PCR amplifies stmilar cDNAs/patterns from all four first-strand synthesis preparations. Finally, the molar ratio between the lo-mer and the anchor primer plays a role m redundancy. A high lo-mer/anchor primer ratio will produce patterns simtlar to that of lo-mer alone whereas a low ratio will produce patterns similar to that of using only the anchor primer (Fig. 2). Therefore, to mmimize all types of observed redundancy we recommend the followmg: 1 The last four bases of the lo-mer should be as diverse as possrble
2, The anchorprimers shouldbe usedalone asa control to eliminate weak IO-mers. 3. A different set of IO-mers should be used for each anchor primer. 4. An equal molar ratio of lo-mers and anchor primers should be used
There are advantages and dtsadvantagesto usmg either SH or DD (see Table 1). If one has a two-way comparison in which l-5 ug of poly (A) RNA are available, we recommend doing both DD and SH because most likely different differentially expressed mRNAs will be found by the two methods. In addrtion, although SH up front is more labor intensive, once the subtractive library is made, the screening (see Section 3.3.) is straight forward and false positives are quite minimal. However, we prefer DD overall because of its versatility and sensitivity. Specifically, SH requires l-5 pg of poly(A) selected RNA, whereas DD only needs
lO,OOOcDNAs; DD
48
Wan and Erlander Anchor Primer:
T12VC
F g
10 mer only
5
6
-lolanes:
1
2
nnnn-nnnn
3
4
7
6
9
Fig. 1. Differential display redundancy may be caused by “weak” 1O-mers. The reactions were pedormed in duplicates and loaded adjacent to each other. TlzVC was used during cDNA synthesis. For the PCR, 1.25 pA4TlzVC and of each IO-mers [ 15 (TACGCAGTAC), 143 (TAACGCGTAC), 271 (AGTAGGGTAC), 399 (GATCGTGTAC)] wasused in lanes l-4, respectively; 1.25 pM T,*VC alone was used in lane 5; 1.25 pit4of each IO-mer alone was used in lanes 6-9.
Gene Cloning and Differential
WV Tl,VA
Anchor:'20125051,25 lamer: lanes:
051252.0
1 2 m-.-.-r--
3
Display
49
Tlw
Tl,VG
0'2.01.25051.25
0
1.25
4
5
051252.0
6
7
0
6
0'
'201.2505125
1.25
051252.0
9 --.-~-----10 11
12
T12W 012012505125
0
13
14
0'4
1250512520
15
16
17
16
0
1253
19 r
20:
Fig. 2. Using the same IO-mer in combination with the four anchor primer may cause redundancy in differential display. The reactions were performed in duplicates and loaded adjacent to each other. Tt2VA, Tt2VC, TIZVG, and Tt2VT was used for cDNA synthesis for lanes 1-5, 6-10, 11-15, 16-20, respectively. IO-mer #7 (CATTCAGCAC) was used in all reactions except for lanes 4, 9, 14, and 19. The primers and concentrations used for the PCR are marked above each lane. TlzVA (lane 4) and T,,VT (lane 19) alone consistently produce patterns with low intensity.
50
Wan and Erlander
Table 1 Comparison
of Differential
Display
and Subtractive
Hybridization
Differential display RNA required Prevalence of mRNA surveyed Type of differences Type of redundancy found Optimal application
Consideratrons
Subtractive hybrrdtzatron
5 pg total RNA Abundant and rare
l-5 pg poly (A) RNA Abundant and rare
2 2-fold Primer sequence dependent
All or none mRNA abundance dependent Targeting mRNAs with large (> 1OX) changes in concentration
Seeking rapid output and/or simultaneous evaluation of several experimental condrtrons Usually clone short 3’ untranslated region
Only one-way comparisons, technically dtfficult
offers the advantage of identifying both increases and decreases (22-fold) of a partrcular mRNA vs SH; and the fraction of differentially expressed mRNAs m aparticular experiment can be quickly assessedwith a few gels using DD. This is a valuable diagnostic tool for the investigator because both too many changes (>5% of cDNAs) and the failure to identify any differentially expressed mRNAs may indicate a need to redesign the current comparisons Because cDNAs obtained from DD are usually short and at the noncodmg region (3’ untranslated region), we found that the Merck EST database can be helpful
for identification
of human mRNAs
because each cDNA m the Merck
EST database is sequenced from both 5’ and 3’ orientation. Thus, a match at the 3’ end can often lead to coding information at the 5’ end. (Thus problem should eventually go away when full length cDNA contig databasesare available when all human EST sequencing have been completed.) Finally, to alleviate the problem with a limiting RNA source for verification, we have found that amplified RNA (aRNA) (1Z,12) is representative of the orrgmal mRNA population and thus can be used as template for screening putatives from sources where mRNA is limiting 2. Materials
2.1. Total RNA Purification
from Tissues or Cells
1. RNeasy Total RNA kit (Qtagen, Chatsworth, CA; cat. no. 74104). RNeasy Spin Columns 1 5-mL collection tubes.
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
2 3 4. 5
51
2-mL collectlon tubes Lysls buffer RLT (P-mercaptoethanol [P-ME] at 10 pL/mL RLT must be added before use) Wash buffer RW 1 Wash buffer RPE (supphed as a concentrate, 4 vol of ethanol [96-lOO%] must be added before use to obtain a working solution) DEPC-H,O P-mercaptoethanol (P-ME) (Sigma, St. LOUIS, MO, cat no M3 148). Ethanol (100%) and ethanol (70% in water). DNase I (amphficatlon grade) (Gibco BRL, Gaithersburg, MD, cat no 18068-015). QIAshredder (Qiagen, Chatsworth, CA, cat no 79653)
2.2. Differential Display 2.2.1. cDNA Synthesis 1 Superscript Preampllficatlon System (Gibco BRL; cat no 18089-011) 10X PCR buffer 200 mM Tris-HCI, pH 8.4, 500 mA4 KC1 25 mk’ MgCl, 10 mM dNTP mix 10 n&f each dATP, dGTP, dCTP, dTTP 0 1M DTT. SuperScrIpt II RT (200 U/$) RNaseH (2 U/pL) H,O (DEPC treated) 2. Degenerate anchor primers (1 pg/&) T,,VG, T,,VA, T,,VT, and T,,VC where V represents an equal molar mixture of G, A, and C 3 RNA template* mRNA (100 ng/pL) or total RNA (1 pg/pL)
2.2.2. Differential Display PCR 1 Degenerate anchor primers (25 @4) (see cDNA synthesis) 2. 5’ primer (lo-mer) (25 CrM) (see Note 1). 3. 10X PCR buffer 100 mMTris-HCl, pH 8 3,500 mMKC1, 15 mMMgCl,, 0.01% w/v autoclaved gelatin (Perkm Elmer, Foster City, CA, cat no N808-0006) 4. 20 pA4 dNTP mix 20 pA4 each of dATP, dGTP, dCTP, dTTP 5 200 @4 dNTP mix 200 cuz/ieach of dATP, dGTP, dCTP, dTTP 6 [cz-~~S] dATP (1000 Cl/mmol) (Amersham, Arlington Heights, IL). 7 Ampli Taq 5 U/pL (Perkm Elmer; cat no N801-0060) 8. Sequencing loading dye: 95% Formamide, 20 mM EDTA, 0 05% bromophenol blue, 0 05% xylene cyan01 FF 9. X-ray film: Kodak XAR 5. 10 TA cloning kit (Invitrogen, Carlsbad, CA, cat. no K2000-0 1): 10X ligation buffer. 60 mMTris-HCl, pH 7 5,60 mMMgC12, 50 mMNaC1, 1 mg/mL bovine serum albumin, 70 mA4 P-mercaptoethanol, 1 mM ATP, 20 mM dlthiothreltol, 10 mM spermldine. pCRTM2.1 vector (25 ng/pL). Sterile water. T4 DNA llgase (4 0 Weiss U/pL)
52
Wan and Et-lander
SOC medium 2% tryptone, 0 5% yeast extract, 10 mMNaCI2.5 mA4 KCl, 10 & MgCI,, 10 mM MgS04, 20 mM glucose (dextrose) 0 5M b-mercaptoethanol INVaF’ cells 11 LB plates containing 50 pg/mL ampictllm and spread wtth 40 pL of 40 mg/mL X-Gal
2.3. Reverse Northern 2.3 1, cDNA Probe Synthesis 1 SuperScrIpt Preampltficatton System (Gtbco BRL; cat no 18089-011) Ok0 dT,,-1, (0 5 i-&cLL) 10 X PCR buffer 200 mM Trts-HCl, pH 8 4,500 mM KC1 25 mA4 MgCl, 0 1MDTT Superscript II RT (200 U/pL) H,O (DEPC treated) 2 Random hexamers 7 4 mg/mL (Pharmacta, Alameda, CA). 3. RNA template 0 4 pg/pL mRNA or 0 4 pg/$ amplified RNA (aRNA) (13). 4 d(GAT)TP mix. 20 mA4 each of dGTP, dATP, dTTP 5 dCTP (120 l&!) 6 [u~~P] dCTP (3000 Ct/mmol) (Amersham) 7 3NNaOH (make fresh) 8 1M Trts-HCl, pH 7.4 9. 2NHCl. 10 G-50 sephadex column (Boehremger Mannhelm, Indtanapolts, IN)
2.3.2. Dot Blot 1 Nylon membranes Maximum strength nytran, 0 45 mm (Schletcher & Schuell, Keene, NH) 2. Whatman chromatography paper 3 Denaturing solutton 1 5MNaC1, 0 5MNaOH 4 Neutralizing solution. 1 5MNaC1, lMTru+HCl, pH 7 4 5 2xssc. 6 UV-Stratalmker 2400 (Stratagene, La Jolla, CA) 7 Bellco rotating hybrtdizatton oven 8 2X Southern prehybrtdizatton buffer (5 prtme- 3 pnme Inc cat no. 5302~820800)* 10X SSC, pH 7 0, 10X Denhardt’s solutton, 0 1M sodium phosphate, pH 6 8, 0 2% SDS, and 0 OlM EDTA. 9. 2X Southern hybridization buffer (5 prime- 3 prime Inc cat no. 5302-500197) 10X SSC, pH 7 0, 2X Denhardt’s solutton, 0 04M sodium phosphate, pH 6 8, 0 4% SDS, and 0.0 IM EDTA 10 Sheared salmon sperm DNA (10 mg/mL) 11. Formamide 12 Prehybrtdization solution 1 part 2X Southern prehybridtzatton buffer, 1 part formamtde, and 0 1 mg/mL salmon sperm DNA boiled for 5 mm
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
53
13. Hybridization solution: 1 part 2X Southern hybridization buffer, formamide, and 0.1 mg/mL salmon sperm DNA boiled for 5 mm. 14. Wash solution I* 2X SSC, 0.1% SDS. 15. Wash solution II* 0.2X SSC, 0 1% SDS. 16. Wash solution III: 0.1X SSC, 0 1% SDS. 17 PhosphorImager 445SI (Molecular Dynamics)
1 part
2.4. Subtractive Hybridization 2.4.1. Construction of Unidirectional cDNA Libraries 1 cDNA synthesis usmg Timesaver kit (Pharmacia; cat. no. 27-9262-01). 2. Directional cloning kit (Pharmacla; cat. no. 27-9274-01). 3. pT7T3D vector NotIIEcoRI digested and BAP treated (Pharmacia; cat no 274987-01). 4. pGEMl1Zf vector (Promega, Madison, WI; cat. no. P2421). 5. Calf-intestinal alkalme phosphatase or CIAP (Boehringer Mannheim, Indianapolis, IN, cat. no. 713023) 6 Electrocompetent cells (Stratagene; SURE cells, cat no 200227)
2.4.2. cRNA Synthesis 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
MEGAscript T7 (Ambron, Austm, TX; cat. no. 1334). CsCl purified unidirectional cDNA libraries. Not1
Protemase K (20 clg/pL). Phenol/chloroform (neutral pH-buffered). DNase I (RNase free). 7.5M Ammoma acetate 10X digest buffer: 100 mM NaCl, 50 mA4 Tris-HCl, dithiothreitol (DTT), pH 7.9, at 25°C 9. 100% ETOH and 80% ETOH. 10. RNase-free HsO.
10 mM MgC&,
1 mM
2.4.3. First Strand Synthesis 1. RNase-free H,O. 2. MMLV-reverse transcriptase (Superscript II (RNaseH negative); BRL, cat. no. 18064-o 14) plus 5X buffer. 3. Not1 dT primer (Pharmacia; cat. no. 27-9274-01). 4 0 1MDTT 5 10 mM dNTP mix: 10 mM each of dGTP, dATP, dTTP, dCTP. 6. [a32P] dCTP (3000 Cl/mmole; 10 mCi/mL). 7. 0.5M EDTA, pH 8.0. 8. 10% SDS. 9. 3NNaOH. 10. lMTris-HCl, pH 7.4. 11 2NHCl
Wan and Erlander
54 12 G-50 spun column. 13 5X buffer: 250 mMTrts-HCl,
pH 8.3, 375 mMKC1,
15 mMMgC&
2.4.4. Target and Driver Annealing 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9.
Phenol/chloroform (neutral pH buffered) RNase-free Hz0 7 5M Ammoma acetate. Annealing buffer: 125 mM HEPES, pH 7.6,5 mMEDTA, 5M NaCl. Mineral 011. 100% ETOH and 80% ETOH. Chloroform TE/NaCl. TE, pH 7.5, with 0 5MNaCl.
2.4.5. Separation with Hydroxyapatlte I. 2 3 4. 5 6. 7 8. 9 10 11, 12 13. 14 15 16 17 18 19. 20. 2 1.
pH 8.0, 0 5% SDS
(HAP)
Chloroform TEMaCl. TE, pH 7 5, with 0 5MNaCl. 1Mstock solutions of monophosphate (138 g monobasrc NaH,PO, H,O/L H20) 1M stock solution of dlbaslc phosphate (268 g Na2HP04 * 7H20/L HZO) 1M phosphate buffer (mix equal volumes of 1M stock solutrons of mono and dibasrc phosphate; should be approxrmately pH 6.5) 50 mMphosphate buffer contams 0 2% SDS. 150 mMphosphate buffer contams 0 2% SDS. 400 &phosphate buffer contains 0.2% SDS. Hydroxyapatrte (Bra-Rad, Hercules, CA, DNA Grade Blo-Gel HTP Gel cat no. 130-0520). Jacketed column (Bra-Rad Econo Column, cat. no 737-6116). Centrrcon 30s (Amicon, Beverly, MA; cat. no 4220) Fractron collector Peristaltic pump. Phenol/chloroform (neutral pH-buffered). RNase-free H20. 0 5MEDTA, pH 8.0 10% SDS 3N NaOH. lMTns-HCl, pH 7 5. 2NHCl. G-50 spun column
2.4 6. Constructron of Subtracted Library 1 10X PCR buffer 0 167M (NH&S04, 0 67M Trrs-HCl, pH 8 8, 0.1 % gelatin, 0.067M MgCl*. 2. 25 mM dNTP mix: 25 mM each of dGTP, dATP, dTTP, dCTP. 3 T7T3D 5’ primer (5’-CGAGGCCGAATTCGGCACGA-3’)
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
55
4. Not3P 3’ primer (5’-AACTGGAAGAATTCGCGG-3’). 5 Size Sep 400 column (Sepharose CL-4B, Pharmacia; cat. no 27-5105-01). 6. 1X lrgase buffer, 66 mA4Tris-HCl, pH 7.6,O.l mM sperrmdme, 6 6 mM MgCl, 10 mMDTT, 150 mMNaC1 7. Not1 (10 U/pL) and EcoRI (10 U/pL) 8. Amp11 Taq 5 U/pL (Perkin Elmer; cat no N801-0060) 9 Phenol/chloroform (neutral pH-buffered).
3. Methods 3.1. Total RNA Isolation 3.1.1. Total RNA Purification from Tissues The followmg
IS a modtfication
of the Qiagen RNeasy Total RNA kit
1. Use one RNeasy spur column per 350 pL RLT + /3ME lysis buffer per 30 mg tissue. Prepare up to 100 pg of total RNA per RNeasy spm column 2 Homogenize tissue with a Power Gen 35 Homogenizer or a baked siliconized glass tissue grinder m 350 p.L RLT + PME lysis buffer If lysate IS too thick, more lysis buffer may be added and still be able to load onto 1 RNeasy spm column m step no 5. 3. To avoid cloggmg the spm column, brtefly spm the lysate at 15,000g and discard the pellet. 4. Transfer the homogenized lysate to a new tube, add 1 volume of 70% ethanol and mix by pipetmg 5 Load onto one RNeasy spm column (about 700 pL). Microfuge at SOOOgfor 15 s. Discard flow-through. If lysate does not pass through, the speed may be increased to 15,000g. If the volume of the total lysate/ethanol exceeds 700 $, load the mixture successively onto the RNeasy spm column and microfuge as above 6 Wash with 700 pL wash buffer RWl, microfuge, and dtscard flow-through as above 7. Place spin column m a new 2-mL collection tube Wash with 500 pL wash buffer RPE Microfuge and discard flow through as above 8 Wash with 500 pL wash buffer RPE and microfuge spur column at 15,OOOg for 2 mm to dry membrane. 9. Transfer spin column to a new 1.5~mL collectton tube and elute the total RNA with 30 pL of DEPC-treated water. Ptpet the water directly onto the spm column membrane Mtcrofuge SOOOgfor 1 min and then 15,OOOgfor 15 s. If the expected yteld is above 30 ug, a second elution with 30 pL of DEPC-treated water will be needed. 10 To remove the DNA from the eluate, add 1 U DNase I/2 ,ug total RNA m a final reaction volume of 100 pL. Digest at room temperature for 15 min 11. To purify RNA after DNase digestton, add 350 pL RLT + /3ME lys~s buffer to the sample, and mix by pipeting. 12. Add 250 pL 100% ethanol to the sample and mix by ptpetmg. 13 Load sample onto one RNeasy spin column. Mtcrofuge 8000g for 15 s Discard flow-through.
Wan and &lander
56
14 Follow steps 7-9 15. Check concentration by a 260/280 OD reading on a spectrophotometer 16. Run 1 pg total RNA sample on a 1 5% TBE agarose gel to check for quality of RNA.
3.1.2. Total RNA Purification from Cells The following
is a modification
of the Qiagen RNeasy Total RNA kit.
1. Use one RNeasy spm column per 350 pL RLT + PME lysls buffer per 5 x lo6 cells. Prepare up to 100 ccg of total RNA per RNeasy spin column. 2. Homogenize cells usmg Qlagen QIAshredder. Add 350 pL, RLT + PME lysls buffer to 5 x lo6 cells, pipet cell lysate directly mto one QIAshredder column, and microfuge at 15,OOOgfor 2 mm. If lysate is too thick, more lysls buffer may be added and put through the QIAshredder 3 Follow procedure from tissue purification steps 4-16
3.2. Differential Display 3.2.1. cDNA Synthesis For each RNA condition to be compared, the followmg reaction m duplicates is performed for each of the four degenerate anchor primers. In addition, a control reaction (without Superscript II RT) is performed. Thus there 1s a total of 12 reactions per RNA condition. If more than a few bands are seen on the differential display gel from the reaction without Superscript II RT, then your RNA may be contaminated by chromosomal DNA. You may want to treat the samples with DNase I before cDNA synthesis. 1 Mix 1p.L of RNA template with 1 $ of an anchor primer and 10 & HZ0 in a 1.5-n& tube, Incubate at 70°C for 10 min, then place on ice for 1 mm. 2. Add 2 pL 10X PCR buffer, 2 pL MgCl,, 1 pL dNTP mix, and 2 pL DTT, incubate at 42’C for 5 mm to anneal, add 1 pL SuperScnpt II RT; incubate at 42°C for 50 min for cDNA synthesis, terminate the reaction at 70°C for 15 min, then place on ice 3. Add 1 & RNaseH and incubate at 37’C for 20 min. 4. The cDNAs can be store at -20°C until use. 5. Before use, dilute the cDNA to 1:20 with HZ0 (You may need to dilute more if you see a smear on the sequencing gel after differential display PCR).
3.2.2. Differential Display PCR To minimize the redundancy associated with differential display, each of the 4 degenerate anchor primers T 12VG, T12VA, T 12VT, and T 12VC is paired with only l/4 of the 256 possible lo-mers (see Note 1). 1 Mix 1 clr, cDNA template (from cDNA synthesis), 1 @ degenerate anchor primer (use the corresponding primer that was used during cDNA synthesis), 1 pL 5’ primer, 2 pL 10X PCR buffer, 2 pL 20 @4dNTP mix, 1 & [u-~~S] dATP, 0.5 p.L
Gene Cloning and Differential Display Anchor: 10 l?ler:
57
T,,‘JA OP.DDRT3
OP.DDRTI
OP-DDRTS OP-DDRTG OP-DDRT7 OP-DDRT8
OP.DDATS
hours: lanes:
t7lObp
+-630bp
+491bp
Fig. 3. An example of a differential display gel. HeLa cell was untreated (0 h) or treated with IFN-y for 48 h prior to mRNA isolation and PCR as described in the text. The reactions were performed in duplicates and loaded adjacent to each other. T,,VA was used during cDNA synthesis and in all DD PCRs. The lo-mers used are marked above the lanes. The asterisks mark some of the bands representing mRNAs with putative increase or decrease in expression after treatment. Ampli Taq, and 11.5 pL HZ0 in a 0.5-mL thin wall PCR tube. Perform PCR using the following program: (94°C for 20 s, 42°C for 20 s, 72°C for 30 s) for 40 cycles at 72°C for 10 min (we use the GeneAmp PCR system 9600 machine from Perkin Elmer). 2. Mix 1 pL PCR product with 1 p.L sequencing loading dye, heat to 80°C for Smin and load on a 6% acrylamidelXA4 urea sequencing gel (load the duplicate reactions for each RNA condition in adjacent lanes) (see Note 2). Run at 55 W for about 3.5 h. Stop the gel after the top dye (Xylene Cyanol) runs off the bottom. To determine the size of the bands, also load a molecular size marker (such as the M 13 DNA sequencing reaction control from the Sequenase DNA sequencing kit [USB; cat. no. US707701) in a separate lane (see Fig. 3 for example of DD gel).
Wan and Blander
58
paper, dry wlthout fixmg in a 3 Transfer gel onto Whatman Chromatography vacuum gel dryer for 2 h, expose to X-ray film from overmght to two mghts (be sure to use some kmd of fluorescent sticker on the gel so that you can align It to the film) 4 Align the film to the gel, use tape to secure the position, excise out the dlfferentlally expressed bands by cutting through the film, select only bands that are present m both lanes derived from the duplicate cDNA reactions (you may want to expose agam after this step to see If the correct bands were excised) 5 Add 100 $ HZ0 to the excised band m a 1 5-mL tube, sit at room temperature for 10 mm, boll for 15 mm, spin down, and transfer the liquid to a new tube, use directly as template for PCR amplification below 6. MIX 2 & template (from previous step) (don’t use more than 3 &, the urea may inhibit the reaction), 2 $ degenerate anchor primer, 2 & 5’ primer, 4 pL 10X PCR buffer, 25 6 JJL H,O, 4 & 200 WdNTP, and 0 4 & Amp11 Taq in a 0 5-mL thm wall PCR tube Perform PCR using the following program (20 s at 94’C, 20 s at 43”C, and 30 s at 72°C 7 Check the size of the PCR product by checkmg 5 pL of the reaction on a 1.5% agarose gel, then use 2 pL. of the reaction directly for cloning via the TA clonmg kit (Invitrogen; cat. no K2000-01) 8 MIX 2 4 of PCR product, 1 & 1OX llgatlon buffer, 2 PL pCRTM2.1 vector, 4 & sterile water, and 1 pL T4 DNA ligase m a 1.5-mL tube, incubate at 14°C overnight 9 Transform into INVaF’ cell followmg the Invltrogen protocol or mto equivalent cell, spread onto LB plate, incubate at 37°C overnight IO Pick and sequence 4 to 6 white colonies for each band (you need to sequence more than one because the band may be composed of multiple DNA species)
3.3. Reverse Northern Reverse Northern IS a quick and easy way to verify induced mRNAs ldentlfied by differential display or subtractive hybrldlzatlon However, the major difficulty with this technique IS the detection of low abundant mRNAs We have shown that by usmg PCR amplified fragments of cloned cDNAs instead of mmiprep DNA, mRNAs with abundance level as low as 1 m 40,000 can be detected Furthermore, amplified RNAs (aRNA) (13) can be used for probe synthesis, thus reducmg the amount of RNAs required for the verification procedure. 3.3.1. cDNA Probe Synthesis Repeat the followmg for each RNA condition to be compared: 1 Mix 5 pL mRNA and 2 $ ohgo dT,,-,s (or 5 pL aRNA and 740 ng of random hexamers in a total of 7 pL H,O) m a 1 5-mL tube, incubate at 70°C for IO mm, then place on ice for at least 1 min
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
59
2. Add 2.5 & 10X PCR buffer, 2 5 $ MgCl,, 2 5 @. DTT, 1 pL d(GAT)TP mix, 1 & dCTP (cold), and 7 5 r.lr, [a32P] dCTP (the [a32P] dCTP 1s reduced from 50 pL [500 pCt] to 7.5 pL by drymg m a speedvac Do not let tt dry completely because it will stick to the plastic side) Incubate at 42°C for 5 mm 3. Add 1 pL Superscript II RT, Incubate at 42°C for 50 mm 4. Add 3 p.L NaOH, incubate at 68°C for 30 min to remove the RNA 5. Add a mixture of 10 p.L Trts-HCl, 3 pL HCl, and 9 p.L H,O to neutralize 6 Take 1 pL out to measure counts per minute 7 Spm through a G-50 sephadex column to remove the unmcorporated nucleotrdes 8 Take l-)..tL from the flow-through to measure count per minute and compare to that from step 6 (you should get 2&O% mcorporation, on average, 10s cpm are obtained from 2 pg of mRNA)
3.3.2. Dot Blot 1 Isolate mmiprep DNA from a 1-mL overmght culture for each clone to be tested (alternatively, PCR amplify the insert from each of the clones) 2 Spot 0.5 pL DNA (l/20 of mmiprep approx 1 pg) from each clone (or 1 pg of each PCR product) in a grid-like pattern onto duplicate nylon membranes (one membrane for each RNA condition) (see Fig. 4) 3 Air dry for 2630 mm, denature for 5 min at room temperature by placing membrane (DNA side up) on Whatman paper presoaked with denaturmg solution, wash twice in neutrabzmg solution for 5 mm at room temperature, rinse in 2X SSC. 4. UV crosslmk once (Stratalmker auto crosslmk setting) 5 Place the dupltcate membranes each m a separate hybrtdtzatton tubes, add 10 mL prehybndization solutton (for a 15 x 15 cm membrane) and incubate with rotation m a Bellco rotating hybridization oven at 42°C overnight 6. For each RNA condition, replace the prehybrtdizatton solutton with a mixture of 10 mL hybridization solution and equal amount (cpm) of boiled (5 mm) probe (1 x 10’ to 2 x 10’ cpm per mL of hybridization solutton), incubate with rotation at 42°C overnight 7 Wash membrane twtce m wash solutton I for 5 mm at room temperature, wash twice m wash solution II for 15 mm at 65°C expose membrane on X-ray film (keep membrane moist) 8. You may want to wash the membrane again m wash solution III for 15-30 mm at 65’C to reduce background, then expose again
3.4. Subtractive Hybridization 3.4. I. Construction of Unidirectional cDNA Libraries A detailed protocol for library construction is not given below because many kits are available to the investigator for the lsolatlon of poly (A) RNA as well as for the construction of umdlrectlonal cDNA hbraries. However, to successfully use this subtractive protocol the mvestlgator must construct the unidrrecttonal
libraries
using the vectors described
below or make
the necessary
60
Wan and Erlander A
Fig. 4. Reverse Northern showing cDNAs induced by IFN-y treatment. 7 1 cDNA clones were spotted onto duplicate nylon membranes (A) and (B) at the same relative positions. The membranes were then probed with labeled cDNA from untreated HeLa cells (A) and from HeLa cells treated with IF%y for 48 h (B). Clones in boxes were confirmed by Northems to be IFN-y induced.
changes in the different PCR primers required to amplify the subtracted library (see Fig. 5 for flowchart of subtractive hybridization protocol). 1. Extract at least 1 pg poly(A) selected RNA from the two sources of interest (treated = TARGET and untreated or control = DRIVER). 2. Unidirectional libraries are to be constructed by using Directional Cloning kit that contains the NotIloligo dT primer, with the Timesaver cDNA synthesis. Ligate TARGET cDNA intoNotIIEcoRI/BAR pT7T3D vector and ligate DRIVER into NotI/ EcoRXLAp treated vector pGEMl1Zf and electroporate into electrocompetent cells. Both libraries need to be 21 x 1O6recombinants (if unequal, better to have DRIVER recombinant number >TARGET recombinant number to avoid false positives). Rut-itication of cDNA libraries by CsCI gradient centrifugation is recommended.
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
E(cL-iiJ’
67
E(TzJ
I
Linearize
both templates Noti dtgestlon
wtth I
Complete cRNA synthesis on both with V RNA polymerase
I Complete 2 - 1st strand syntheses with 2pg cRNA with 32p-adCTP I
t Remove GINA from cDNA with NaOH
250 fold molar excess
( -25bg
cRNA)
/I Save for HAP calibration T/ Hybndize “antlsense” target cDNA with 25pg (sense) cRNA Isolate smgle +stranded CDNA with HAP column
4
Repept
Once
+ Construct subtractive cDNA library + Screen
clones
Fig. 5. Flowchart of subtractive hybridization
protocol
3.4.2. cRNA Synthesis 1. Linearize both Target and Driver cDNA libraries by incubating 30 H of each with 100 U ofNot& 30 & 10X digest buffer m a total volume of 300 $ at 37OC for 2 h. 2. Run sample (10 pL) of digest on 0.8% agarose gel with molecular weight markers to make sure all vector-cDNA is linearized. 3. Meanwhile to digest add 0.75 pL of Proteinase K and continue to incubate at 37°C for 30 min. 4. Extract twice wtth phenol/chloroform and precipitate linearized DNA with 0.5 vol 7 SMammonia acetate and 2.5 vol of 100% ethanol. Wash pellet with 80% ethanol.
62
Wan and Erlander
5. Dry DNAs m speedvac and resuspend each DNA pellet m 20 $L of RNase-free H,O Determme OD,,, for transcription reactions as 6 Set up cRNA transcrtption reactions (we use Ambton MEGAscrtpt) described below 7. For Drover cDNA do a 3X reaction (60 pL vol) and for Target cDNA do a 1X reactron (20 pL vol) 8 For a 1X reachon add the followmg at room temperature 2 pL. 1OX transcription buffer for T7 RNA polymerase, 8 $ of 75 mMrNTP mix (ATP, CTP, GTP, and UTP), 1 c(g of lmearize cDNA, 2 & T7 RNA polymerase mix, and RNase-free H,O to 20 $I-,. Incubate at 37°C for 4 h 9 To each transcription reaction add an equal vol of 1X transcrtptton buffer (we find tt helps to dilute cRNA prior to DNase I addition for complete digestton) 10 Remove a 5-pL aliquot from each transcription for gel analysis (save and run with samples obtamed after DNase I digest) 11 Add 4 U DNase I/20 $ reaction and incubate at 37’C for 15 mm After digest remove 5 & from each reaction for gel analysis 12 Separate the cRNA reactions on a 0 8% agarose gel (before and after DNase I treatment) to confirm entire removal of cDNA template 13 Extract cRNAs once with phenol/chloroform followed by two subsequent prectpttations with 0.5 vol 7 5M ammonia acetate and 2.5 vol 100% ethanol to remove free nucleotides Wash pellet with 80% ethanol Resuspend m RNase-free H,O 14 Determine OD,,, of Target and Driver cRNAs You need at least 4 pg of target cRNA and 50 pg of driver cRNA for the followmg procedures Store cRNAs at -20°C
3.4.3. First Strand Synthesis 1 Complete two first strand syntheses of Target cRNA by domg the following m duplrcate add 2 pg of Target cRNA, 0 5 pg Not1 dT prtmer to RNase-free H,O for a total volume of 14.80 &, heat for 10 minutes at 65°C and quench on Ice. Then add 6.6 p.L of 5X buffer, 3 3 pL DTT, 1.65 p.L dNTP mtx, 5 pL [cz~~P] dCTP MIX up and down with pipet, then add 1.65 pL MMLV-reverse transcriptase Incubate at 37°C for 60 mm 2 Save one of the reactions for the calibration of the HAP column (see Sectton 3 4 5.) To the other add 1 65 & EDTA and 1.65 pL SDS Mix and then add 5 p.L NaOH and Incubate at 65’C for 60 mm to remove cRNA, then let It cool to room temperature. 3 Add 16 5 & Tris-HCl followed by 5 pL HCI. Mix up and down 4. Remove unmcorporated [a32P] dCTP from both first strand reactions with G-50 spun column. Check with Geiger counter to make sure eluent has at least 1O-fold over background m cpm Store both first strand cDNAs at -20°C
3.4.4. Target and Driver Annealmg 1. Ptpet about half of the NaOH treated cDNA into a screw-cap Eppendorf tube. Extract once with phenoVchloroform and take aqueous phase to a fresh screw-cap tube
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
63
2. Add the equivalent of 25 pg of cRNA drover Measure total vol, add 0 5 vol of 7.5 ammonia acetate and then 2.5 vol 100% ETOH Precipitate, wash (80% ethanol), and allow to dry at room temperature 3 Resuspend cDNA/cRNA pellet m 5 pL RNase-free H20, 4 p.L annealing buffer, 1 pL 5M NaCI (RNase-free) Prpet up and down to make sure cDNA/cRNA 1s totally resuspended 4. Overlay cDNA/cRNA with 50 pL of mineral 011and boil mixture for 90 s 5 Incubate at 65-68’C for 20-24 h. 6 Add 100 pL chloroform and 90 pL TE/NaCl to the mineral orl/cDNA/cRNA and vortex Save aqueous phase and add to the organic phase an addmonal 100 pL of TE/NaCl. Repeat extraction. 7. Extract the combined aqueous ahquots once with phenol/chloroform. Add 2 5 vol 100% ethanol (do not add ammonia acetate), precipitate at -7O’C for 10 min, and wash subsequent pellet with 80% ethanol 8. You can store pellets overnight at-20°C ifneeded before proceeding with separation
3.4 5. Separation on HAP Column 3.4 5.1
PREPARATION OF THE HAP COLUMN
1. Weigh out about 1 g of hydroxyapatrte (HAP) mto a 50-mL conical tube. This should be about 7 5 mL of dry HAP Add 50 mM phosphate buffer for a total volume of 45 mL and swirl gently Let HAP settle for 10 mm, then pipet off the cloudy upper layer containing the “fines,” and repeat this procedure until the buffer above the settled HAP does not appear as cloudy 2 After asprratmg off the buffer for the last time, then add an equal volume of 50 mM phosphate buffer to the HAP slurry. 3 Set up Jacketed column, peristaltic pump and fraction collector as shown on Fig 6 Circulate the Jacket with 60°C Hz0 and eqmhbrate all phosphate buffers at 60°C 4 With the set-up complete, add 2-3 mL of 50 mMphosphate buffer to an empty column and then add HAP slurry and let rt settle by gravity Ideal HAP height is about 1 5 cm above the frit after packing and this is achieved by trial and error (use long Pasteur prpet to remove HAP). It is very important to gently resuspend the HAP before removing or adding HAP so that the matrix settles evenly. Ideal flow rate 1s 0.5 ml/mm, collectmg fractions of 0.5-mL/tube 5 Once the column is packed, wash with 5 mL of 60°C 50 mA4phosphate buffer by gently adding buffer down the mstde side of the column and then turnmg on the pump Allow the memscus of the buffer to dram untilJust (approx 0.2 cm) above the HAP and then mm off the pump. Do not allow the HAP to dry’! Now you are ready to calibrate the column 3.452.
CALIBRATION OF HAP COLUMN
1 Unfortunately each batch (lot) of HAP is different and therefore we recommend you spend an afternoon calibrating your partrcular HAP with your Jacketed column for determining the optimal concentration of phosphate buffer for eluting single stranded and double stranded nucleic acid
Wan and Erlander
64 Jacketed HAP Column
k-m Peristaltic
Pump
-wEI
Fig. 6. Diagram of experimental set-up for HAP column separation. 2. Take an aliquot of the first-strand synthesis of the DRIVER that was NOT hydrolyzed with NaOH as your double stranded nucleic acid (RNA-DNA heteroduplex). Use about 2-5 x lo5 cpm of it so you can easily follow it. Followmg the identical directions as outlined below for your actual sample (1.e , add 6 mL of 50 M, then 6 mL 150 mM, then 6 mL 400 mM phosphate buffers) make sure that the majority (>80-90%) of your counts (i e., RNA-DNA) comes off when 400 mM phosphate is added. 3. Next, take an aliquot of your single stranded nucleic acid (use NaOH treated first-strand synthesis) and again add 50 mA4,150 mM, followed by 400 mMphosphate buffer; the majority (>80-90%) should come off at 50 mMand 150 mM. If not, then adjust accordingly (e.g , if 50% is elutmg at 400 mM, then you need to increase the concentration of phosphate buffer used to elute single strand nucleic acid). Our experience is that single stranded elutes at 120-150 mA4 and double stranded always at 400 m&f.
3.453. SEPARATING YOURSAMPLES ON HAP COLUMN 1. To load and run the column, first be sure that all three buffers are equilibrated to 60°C. Resuspend sample pellet m 500 pL of 50 mM phosphate buffer. Let the column buffer dram until the meniscus is just above the HAP and turn off the pump. 2 Very carefully load the sample along the side of the column wtth a Pasteur pipet, being careful not to disturb the HAP, and turn on the pump just long enough to pump as much of the sample into the matrix as possible without letting the HAP column dry out. 3. Turn off the pump, gently load 6 mL of 50 mM phosphate buffer, and turn on both the pump and the fraction collector. When the buffer is just above the HAP,
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
65
HAP Column Fractionation
r
300000
250000
200000 E 3
150000
100000
50000
0
Fig. 7. Actual example of collected fractions after HAP column separation Here Target = HeLa cells treated for 48 h with IFN-y and Driver = untreated HeLa cells Fractions 1-12 were eluted with 50 &phosphate buffer (contains 0 2% SDS), fractions 13-24 were eluted with 150 mA4 phosphate buffer (contains 0.2% SDS) and fractions 25-40 were eluted with 400 Mphosphate buffer (contams 0 2% SDS). In this experiment, fractions 17,18,19, and 20 (containing single-stranded subtracted cDNA) were pooled and subsequently processed.
4.
5.
6.
7
turn off the pump, load 6 mL of preheated 150 mMphosphate buffer and elute as before. It IS helpful to advance the collecting rack 1-2 spaces between changes of buffer (easier to keep track of tubes later). Follow the 150 mA4phosphate buffer with 6 mL of 400 mM phosphate buffer. Determine which fractions contam eluted nucleic acid, by measuring Cherenkov counts of each fraction. For each separation, select the four fractions with highest counts for each of the three eluttons (i e , 50, 150, and 400 mM) (see Fig. 7 for example). You should see three peak-the second, eluted with 150 mA4 phosphate buffer, contains the single-stranded nucleic acid. Pool the four fractions from the single-stranded peak with the highest cpm and extract twice with phenol/chloroform (this may be done m 14-mL polypropylene tubes at 3000 rpm for 5 min) Apply aqueous (upper) phase to a Centrlcon 30 and centrifuge at 5OOOg for 25 min with a fixed angle rotor. Wash three times with 1 mL of RNase Free HZ0 (same centrifuge conditions) and measure volume--lt should be about 100 +. At this point, the sample should be rehybridlzed with driver. First, do one phenol/chloroform to make sure it IS free of RNase--take supernatant and pre-
Wan and Et-lander
66 cipitate with an additional tion process
25 pg driver and repeat annealing and HAP separa-
3 4.5 4. AFTER SECOND HAP COLUMN 1 Bring up or dry down the washed eiuent (subtracted cDNA) from the Centricon 30 to a total volume of 100 pL. To the 100 pL of target cDNA add 5 pL EDTA, 5 uL SDS, 15.1 pL NaOH. Incubate at 65°C for 30 min Cool to room temperature and add 50 Ilr, Tris-HCl and 15 1 pL HCI 2 Do one phenol/chloroform extraction, bring up to 100 pL with water and apply to a G-50 spun column Store eluent at -20°C
3.4.6. Construction of Subtracted cDNA Library 1 Amplify
2 3
4
5 6 7. 8
9. 10
subtracted cDNA m a total volume of 100 u,L by addmg 10 clr, 1OX PCR buffer, 0 8 pL 25 mM dNTPs, 200 ng T7T3D5 primer, 200 ng Not3P primer and 1 pL of HAP eluent (subtracted cDNA) Do a HOT START using 0 5 p.L of Taq polymerase and complete 30 cycles (Perkm-Elmer model 9600 conditions are 94°C for 15 s, 60°C for 15 s, and 72’C for 1 mm) Run 10 p.L of the PCR products on an agarose gel Expected result is a smear from 300 to 1 kb Equilibrate three times m a Stze Sep 400 column wtth 1X hgase buffer (This IS done by drammg column but not dry, then add 2 mL of 1X hgase buffer, cap column and mvert/mix sepharose with 1X hgase buffer, dram and then repeat process two more times ) Do one phenol/chloroform extraction with amplified subtracted cDNA, then bring up to 100 p.L with 1X ligase buffer, and apply to the spun column (to prepare spun column, take 1X ligase buffer-equilibrated column and centrifuge for 2 min in swinging bucket rotor at 4OOg, then very carefully apply sample to middle of dried sepharose, then spm again at 400g for 2 min to collect eluent) Add 1 5 pL of Not1 (10 II/@,) to eluent and incubate at 37°C for 1 h Heat mactivate at 65°C for 10 min and cool to room temperature Add 1.5 pL of EcoRI and incubate 37°C for 1 h Heat macttvate as above, extract once with phenol/chloroform, bring up to 100 pL with 1X hgase buffer rf needed, and apply to a pre-equilibrated (1 X ligase buffer) Size Sep 400 spun column (as described m step 3). Ligate mto pT7T3D vector, electroporate/transform mto SURE cells, and plate 1, 0 1, and 0.01 pL onto 150 mm LB-ampicillm agar plates Should have at least 1O6recombmants Do maxiprep (of lo6 recombmants) with the remannng broth culture and store cDNA library at -20°C
3.4.7. Verification of Putative Positives Randomly pick 96 clones from your subtracted cDNA library and grow overnight followed by mml-preps to isolate DNA. Spot (by hand or with 96-well
Gene Cloning and Differential Display
67
dot blot manifold) approx 1 pg of DNA on duphcate filters and follow the reverse Northern protocol as described in Section 3.3. 4. Notes 1 These are arbitrary lo-mers with 50% GC content. Since the site of annealmg is highly depended on the 3’ end of the IO-mer, the last four bases of the oligo should be as different as possible The IO-mer performs best when the most 3’ base 1s a G or C, however, to increase the diversity, we have also used A or T with the caveat that the band intensity decreases slightly. Therefore, a total of 256 different lo-mers can be used 2. Dtfferentlal display IS a technically demanding method. In order to minimize false positlves, It IS essential that the bands are sharp and well separated on the gel. We found that standard flat well comb produces better bands than sharkstooth comb Also, the DNA should be loaded as close to the bottom of the well as possible; this ~111 produce a sharp flat band and elimmate streaks appearing m the center of the lane.
References 1 Llang, P. and Pardee, A B (1992) Dlfferentlal display of eukaryotlc messenger RNA by means of the polymerase chain reactlon. Science 257, 967-971 2 Welsh, J , Chada, K , Dalal, S S , Cheng, R , Ralph, D , and McClelland, M. (1992) Arbltrarlly primed PCR fingerprinting of RNA Nuclezc Acids Res 20,4965-4970. 3 Travis, G H , Milner, R. J , and Sutchffe, J. G. (1989) Preparation and use of subtractive cDNA hybridlzatlon probes for cDNA cloning, in Neuromethods, vol. 16, Molecular NeurobloEogzcaZ Technzques (Boulton, A A., Baker, G. B., and Campagnom, A. T., eds ) Humana, Chfton, NJ, pp. 49-78. 4 Watson, J B and Margu!ies, J. E. (1993) Differential cDNA screening strategies to Identify novel stage-specific protems m the developmg mammalian brain Developmental
Neuroscl
15,77-86.
5. Sambrook, J , Fntsch, E. F , and Maniatls, T (1989) Molecular Cloning A Laboratory Manual, Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory, Cold Sprmg Harbor, NY 6. Axel, R., Felgelson, P , and Schutz, G. (1976) Analysis of the complexity and diversity of mRNA from chlcken liver and oviduct Cell 7,247-254. 7. Bishop, J. O., Morton, J G , Rosbash, M , and Richardson, M. (1974) Three abundance classes m HeLa cell messenger RNA. Nature 250, 199-204 8. Wan, J. S., Sharp, S J., Polrier, G. M.-C., Wagaman, P C , Chambers, J., Pyati, J., Horn, Y.-L., Galmdo, J E., Huvar, A., Peterson, P. A., Jackson, M. R., and Erlander, M. G. (1996) Cloning differentially expressed mRNAs Nature Bzotechnol 14, 1685-1691. 9 Bertioh, D. J , Schhchter, U. H , Adams, M J , Burrows, P R., Steinblss, H. H., and Antomw, J. F. (1995) An analysis of differential display shows a strong bias towards high copy number mRNAs Nucleic Acids Res 23,4520-4523 10 Debouck, C (1995) Differential display or differential dismay? Cur-r Opinzon Bzotechnol 6, 597-599.
68
Wan and Erlander
11. Bauer, D., Muller, H , Retch, J , Rtedel, H., Ahrenktel, V , Warthoe, P., and Strauss, M. (1993) Identtficatton of dtfferenttally expressed mRNA spectes by an improved display technique (DDRT-PCR) ~Vucletc Aczds Res 21,4272-4280. 12 Van Gelder, R N , von Zastrow, M. E , Yool, A, Dement, W. C , Barchas, J D , and Eberwine, J. H (1990) Amplified RNA synthesized from hmrted quantttres of heterogeneous cDNA Proc Nat1 Acad Scz USA 87, 1663-1667 13. Ponier, G M -C , Pyatt, J., Wan, J S., and Erlander, M G (1997) Screening differentially expressed cDNA clones obtained by differential display usmg amplified RNA Nuclerc Aczds Res 25,9 13,9 14.
Direct Sequencing of Differential Display PCR Products Xinkang Wang and Giora 2. Feuerstein 1. Introduction The polymerase chain reactron (PCR)-based mRNA differential display (I) has become an increasingly popular alternative technique for isolating genes of interest m a variety of m vitro and m VIVOsystems (for review, see ref. 2), as compared to such conventional techruques as differential screening and subtractive hybridization. The method of mRNA drfferenttal display consists of two basic steps: (1) reverse transcrtptron (RT) using a set of 3’-anchored primers, T,,MN (M = G, A or C; N = G, A, T or C); and (2) PCR amplification of cDNA fragments using arbitrary lo-mer primers (upstream) and anchored downstream primers. One critical feature of this technique is to display most of the mRNA population on a sequencing gel after PCR. A similar technique referred to as RNA fingerprinting by arbitrary primed PCR (RAP-PCR) was introduced to identify differentially expressed genes (3). RAP-PCR uses longer primers, e.g., 18-20 mers, for both RT and PCR, that allow the annealing temperature of PCR reaction increase up to 60°C after several mitral cycles of annealing at low temperature (3,4). The use of longer primers in the RAP-PCR method not only increased the reproducibility of band display pattern but also made rt possible for direct sequencing of the PCR products. However, a potential problem of RAP-PCR IS displaying fewer bands than mRNA differential display. Since the initial introductron of mRNA differential display, rt has been extensively refined to reduce the redundancy of anchored primers and decrease the number of RT reactions, to reduce the incidence of false positives, and increase the efficiency of the technique (2). For example, the modtficatrons made based on the combination of RAP-PCR and differential display applied From
Methods In Molecular B/o/ogy, Vol 85 D/fferent/a/ Edlied by P Ltang and A B Pardee Humana
69
D/splay Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
Wang and Feuerstein
70
longer primers for differential display (5-7), which not only Increase the reproducibility of dlfferentlal display but also are possible for direct sequencmg after PCR amphficatlon. DNA sequencing analysis 1s one of the critical steps following mRNA dlfferentlal display. In the mltlal protocol (l), short primers (lo-mers arbitrary primers and T,*MN anchored primers) are used for differential display, but they are too short to prime sequencing reactions. Therefore, subclonmg is often required after differential display m order to analyze the sequence of particular genes. This chapter focuses on direct sequencing analysis after differential display using the typical (IO-mer) primers. Slmllarly, the same protocol 1s also feasible for the analysis of differential display PCR products usmg longer primers, as well as the PCR products obtained by other techniques such as RAP-PCR.
2. Materials 2.7. Differential
Display Using Short Primers
1. RNA* LPS-stimulated vs control. Stored at -70°C 2. Pruners: downstream, T&L4 primers (M = G, A, or C); upstream, S-GACCGCTTGT3’. Stored at -20°C 3 RNAmap kit (GenHunter [Nashville, TN]). Stored at -2O’C. 4. 10X PCR buffer: 100 mM Tns-HCl, pH 8.4, 500 mM KCl, 15 mM MgClz and 0 0 I % gelatin Stored at -20°C. 5 [35S]ol-dATP or [33P]a-dATP (1000-3000 Wmmol, Amersham, Arlington Hetghts, IL). 6 AmpllTaq DNA polymerase (5 U/pL, Perkm-Elmer, Norwalk, CT). Stored at -20°C 7. 6% polyacrylamldel8M urea sequencmg gel
2.2. Differential
Display Using Elongated
Primers
1 Upstream primer, S-GCGAATTCCGACCGCTTGT-3’, downstream anchored primer 5’-CGGATCCCTTTTTTTTTTTTMA-3’ These elongated primers are generated by adding extra bases (usually a restriction enzyme site) at the 5’ end Stored at -2O’C. 2 Others as hsted m Section 2 1
2.3. Preparation
of Differential
Display PCR Products
1 Six percent polyacrylamrde gel 2. DNA extraction solution (for acrylamlde gel): 500 mM NH4Ac, 1 mM EDTA. (Stored at room temperature )
2.4. Northern
Analysis
1 RNA samples. 2 GeneScreen Plus membrane (DuPont-New England Nuclear, Boston, MA) 3 Northern hybrldlzation buffer: 5X SSPE (750 mMNaC1,50 mMNaH2P04, pH 7.6, 5 mA4EDTA), 50% deionized formamide (stored at-70°C), 5X Denhardt’s solu-
Direct Sequencing
71
non (50X stock solution stored at 4”C), 2% SDS, 100 pg/ml-. polyA and 200 pg/mL boiled salmon sperm DNA Freshly make the solution prior to use 4 Random-priming DNA labelmg ktt (Boehrmger Mannhelm, Indianapolls, IN) 5 [33P]a-dATP (3000 C~/mmol, Amersham). 6. Washing solution 2X SSPE, 2% SDS. Stored at room temperature
2.5. DNA Sequencing Analysis 1, Double strand-DNA cycle sequencing system (Gibco BRL, Grand Island, NY) Stored at -2O’C. 2. [32P]y-ATP (5000 C~/mmol, Amersham) 3 PNK: T4 polynucleotide kmase at stock concentration of 10 U/pL Stored at -20°C. 4. 10X PNK buffer 700 mA4 Trts-HCl, pH 7 6, 100 mM MgC12, 50 mM dithiothrettol Stored at -2O’C 5. Blo-Spm 6-column (Bto-Rad, Hercules, CA). 6. 6% polyactylamtde/SM urea sequencmg gel
2.6. Computer Database Search Computer network to accessgenomic databases, e.g., GenBank 3. Methods
3. I. Differential Display Using Short Primers 1 Perform reverse transcription reactions in a volume of 20 j,tL, contammg 0 2 pg total cellular RNA (e g , isolated from LPS-stimulated or untreated aorta), 2 pL of 2 pA4Ti2MA primers, 4 pL of 5X RT buffer (125 flTris-HCl, pH 8 3, 188 mM KCl, 7.5 mM MgC12 and 25 mA4 DTT), 1 6 p.L of 250 @4 dNTP, 0.5 ).tL RNase inhibitor, and 1 pL MMLV reverse transcriptase Heat RNA at 65°C for 5 mm and place on me prtor to the addition of enzyme and RNase mhtbttor Incubate the RT reaction mixture at 37°C for 60 mm, and then heat at 95°C for 5 mm and place on me for PCR, or store at -20°C for later use 2. Prepare PCR reaction mixture containing 2 pL of 2 w 5’ decamer arbitrary primer (5’-GACCGCTTGT-3’) and 3’ T12MA primer, 1 pL [3sS]a-dATP (or 0.25 pL [33P]a-dATP), 2 pL 10X PCR buffer, 1 6 pL dNTP (25 @4), 2 pL RT products, and 0 2 pL Ampliraq DNA polymerase (5 U/pL). Perform PCR for 40 cycles as follows 94°C for 30 s (for denaturing), 40°C for 2 mm (for annealing), 72’C for 30 s (for extension), followed by 1 cycle for extension at 70°C for 10 min. 3. Resolve the PCR products through an 8M urea, 6% polyacrylamtde DNA sequencing gel and analyze the gene expresston by autoradiography (see Fig. 1A)
3.2. Differential Display Using Elongated Primers Following the same protocol described in Section 3.1.) but with the following exceptlons (see Note 1): 1. RT reaction is carried out with either the anchored primers of TlzMA extended prtmers, e.g , S-CGGATCCCTTTTTTTTTTTTMA-3’
or the
Wang and Feuerstein
72
A
12
3 4
4
LPS-7
B 12
34
LPS7
Fig. 1. Differential display analysis of upregulated gene expression in cultured rat aorta stimulated with LPS. (A) The differential display was carried out using RNA samples isolated from cultured rat aorta in the presence or absence of LPS. PCR products were resolved in an 8M urea, 6% polyacrylamide sequencing gel: lane 1, unstimulated; lane 2, stimulated aorta from spontaneously hypertensive rats; lane 3, unstimulated; and lane 4, stimulated aorta from Wistar-Kyoto rats. The band(s) indicated with an arrow (designated as LPS-7) shows a marked induction in response to LPS stimulation, which was generated by an upstream primer (S-GACCGCTTGT-3’) and a downstream primer (T&4). (B) Northern analysis to confirm the LPS-7 mRNA expression in cultured aorta in response to LPS stimulation. Total RNA (10 pg/lane) was loaded in the same order as in A, and resolved by electrophoresis, transferred to a nylon membrane, and hybridized to LPS-7 and ribosomal protein L32 (rpL32; a loading control) cDNA probes sequentially. The mRNA size was indicated on the right. 2. PCR is carried out using an upstream primer, 5’-GCGAATTCCGACCGCTTGT3’; and downstream primers, 5’-CGGATCCC~TTTTTTTTMA-3’. The cycle conditions are as follows: the first l-4 cycles at 94°C for 30 s, 40°C for 2 min, and 72°C for 1 min; and the following 35 cycles at 94°C for 30 s, 60°C for 2 min, and 72’C for 1 min; followed by 72°C for 7 min.
3.3. Preparation of Differential Display PCR Products 1. Localize the band of interest, cut out the band with a razor, release the DNA by boiling in 100 pL TE ( 10 nut4 Tris, pH 8.0,l mMEDTA) for 10 min, and precipi-
Direct Sequencing
73
A
Fig. 2, Comparison of the reamplitied LPS-7 band using short differential display primers with the elongated primers. (A) Schematic graph showing the reamplification of the differential display bands with initial differential display primers (primer A and B) or with the elongated primers (primer A’ and B’). (B) Electrophoresis of the reamplified DNA fragments using the initial differential display primers and the elongated primers as illustrated in A. PCR samples were resolved in a 6% polyacrylamide gel and stained with ethidium bromide. Lane 1, the amplification of LPS-7 with primers A and B; lane 2, the amplification with the modified primers A’ and B’; lane 3, DNA markers.
2.
3.
4. 5.
6.
tate with 80% ethanol plus 5 pL glycogen (10 mg/mL) for 30 min (to overnight) at -70°C. Microcentrifuge for 10 min at 4’C to pellet DNA, wash the pellet with 80% icecold ethanol by microcentrifuge at 4OC for l-2 min. Dry the pellet with speedvacuum and dissolve in 10 pL water. Reamplify the DNA using 4 pL resuspended sample, 4 pL of each elongated primers, and 3.2 pL dNTP (250 CLM)in a final volume of 40 pL. All other conditions are essentially the same as for the initial amplification. Resolve DNA bands on a 6% polyacrylamide gel (see Note 2), stain the gel with ethidium bromide (see Fig. 2). Cut out the DNA band under long UV wavelength, mince the gel slice into small pieces, and extract the DNA in 3-vol of 500 mA4N&Ac, 1 mMEDTA overnight at 37°C. Microcentrifuge the samples for 3 min at room temperature, collect the supernatant (repeat several times to remove the gel debris if necessary), extract the
Wang and Feuerstein
74
supernatant once with phenol/chloroform, and preclpltate with ethanol Resuspend m 10-20 pL TE and store at -20°C The DNA IS now ready for either direct sequencmg or probe-labeling
3.4. Northern
Analysis
Apply standard protocols
for Northern
analysis (see Note 3).
1 Resolve RNA samples (10 E/lane) m a formaldehyde-agarose slab gel and transfer to a GeneScreen Plus membrane 2. Prehybrldlze the membrane for 4 h, and add lo6 cpm/mL probe for overnight hybridization at 42°C 3. Wash the membrane m 2X SSPE at room temperature for 15 mm, followed by 2X SSPE and 2% SDS at 65OC for 30 min with 2-3 times dependmg on slgnal intensities. 4 Expose the membrane on X-ray film at -7O’C with a Cronex Lightning-Plus intensifying screen (see Fig. 1B)
3.5. DNA Sequencing
Analysis
Cycle DNA sequencing method is recommended for this analysis since it only requires a small amount of template (see Note 4). 1 Label the elongated primers (either the upstream primer or the downstream primer; see Fig 3) by mcubatlon of 100 ng ohgonucleotlde, 3 $ [32P]y-ATP, 2 $, 1OX kmase buffer, and 1 pL PNK m a final volume of 20 pL at 37°C for 60 mm Apply Blo-Spin 6 column to remove free [32P]ATP 2. Prepare a prereaction mixture containing 0.1 ~18DNA, lo-40 ng of [32P]-end labeled primer, 4 5 pL 10X Tag sequencmg buffer, and 0 5 & Taq DNA polymerase (2 5 U) in a final volume of 36 & MIX well and add 8 PL prereaction mixture to each tube contammg 2 pL of termination mix G, A, T, and C, respectively 3. Heat thermal cycler to 94’C Place reaction tubes in wells and start the follows cycle reactions. initial cycle, 94°C for 4 min, 42°C for 30 s, and 70°C for 1 mm; followed by 29 cycles of 94°C for 30 s, 42°C for 30 seconds, and 70°C for 1 min. 4. Terminate the reactlon by adding 5 pL of stop solution to each tube, and resolve the samples (2 &/well) in an 8M urea, 8% polyacrylamlde sequencing gel Dry the gel and subject to autoradlograph (see Fig. 3).
3.6. Computer
Database Search
Apply Genetxs Computer display gene products.
Group (GCG) program to analyze the dlfferentlal
1 Use SeqEd to edit the sequence (enter at least 50 nucleotldes of unambiguous sequence) 2. Use FastA for the search of nucleotlde sequence identity (see Note 5) against computer databases, e g., GenBank
Direct Sequencing
75 A’ primer /,,TC\
B’primer
* ,
Fig. 3. Direct sequencing of LPS-7 DNA amplified with the elongated primers. LPS-7 DNA was reamplified with the elongated primers (A’ and B’) and isolated from 6% polyacrylamide gel. Sequencing reaction was carried out using a cycle sequencing method in the presence of 32P-labeled primer A’ or B’. The samples were resolved by an 8M urea, 8% polyacrylamide gel, dried, and subjected to autoradiograph.
4. Notes 1. The-elongated primers are generated from the initial differential display primers (lo-mers) by adding extra-nucleotides at the S-end of the primers. These extended bases usually include a restriction enzyme site to facilitate subcloning if needed. The elongated primers can be directly used for differential display ($6) or used during the reamplification following original differential display method (8). In addition, the elongated primers are able to directly prime the sequencing reaction without subcloning of the differential display PCR products. 2. If DNA fragments are smaller than 500 bases, acrylamide gel electrophoresis is recommended to resolve and prepare the reamplified products for its advantage to resolve small nucleotides. However, if longer fragments are generated, agarose gel (152%) electrophoresis is recommended and corresponding methods for DNA isolation should be applied.
Wang and Feuerstein
76
3, Northern analysts IS a critical step that not only confirms the differential
gene expression (see Fig 1B), but may also mdrcate the purity of DNA since heterogeneous hybrldrzatlon patterns usually mdrcate the presence of multiple genes Similarly, other methods such as RNase protection assay, nuclear run-on analySISmay also be used. The posstbthty of dtrect DNA sequencing of dtfferential display products depends on the purrty of the Isolated DNA bands. The better resolutton of the sequencing gel will no doubt generate the purer DNA products If heterogeneous DNA species exist m some particular cases, these bands have to be subcloned prior to sequencing analysts The presence of a restriction enzyme site m the elongated primers will no doubt facihtate thts subclonmg process Because the anchored PCR primers of differential display are located next to the poly(A) tall, the majority of differential display products correspond to 3’ untranslated region (UTR) Therefore, a computer database search on the nucleotlde level IS recommended
References 1 Liang, P. and Pardee, A B (1992) Dtfferential display of eukaryottc messenger RNA by means of the polymerase chain reaction. Sczence 257,967-971 2. Llang, P and Pardee, A B (1995) Recent advances in differential display Curr Oplnlon Immunoi 7,274-280. 3 Welsh, J , Chada, K., Daldal, S. S , Cheng, R, Ralph, D , and McClelland, M (1992) Arbitrarily primed PCR fingerprintmg of RNA Nuclezc Acids Res 20, 4965-4970. 4. McClelland, M., Mathteu-Daude, F., and Welsh, J. (1995) RNA fingerprmtmg and drfferentral drsplay usmg arbitrarily primed PCR Trends Genet 11,242-246 5. Zhao, S., 001, S L., and Pardee, A B (1995) New primer strategy improves precision of differential display. BzoTechnzques 18, 842-850. 6 Drachenko, L B , Ledesma, J., Chenchlk, A A, and Srebert, P D (1996) Combming the techmque of RNA fingerprintmg and differentral display to obtam dlfferentrally expressed mRNA Blochem Bzophys Res Comm 219,824-828. 7. Yoshlkawa, T., Xmg, G. Q., and Detera-Wadlergh, S. D. (1995) Detection, stmultaneous display and dn-ect sequencing of multiple nuclear hormone receptor genes using btlaterally targeted RNA fingerprmtmg. Bzochzm Bzophys Acta 1264,63-7 1 8 Wang, X. K and Feuerstem, G. Z (1995) Direct sequencing of DNA isolated from mRNA differential dtsplay. BzoTechnzques 18,448-452
A Direct-Sequencing-Based Strategy for Identifying and Cloning cDNAs from Differential Display Gels Katherine
J. Martin, Chi-Pong
Kwan, and Ruth Sager
1. Introduction Thus report describes an approach to identifying and clomng messages from differentral display (DD) gels that has markedly reduced the occurrence of false positives as well as the time required for the process. Most importantly, the use of Northern blots with potentially contaminated probes is avoided and a streamlined direct sequencing protocol is used as an imtral step. The individual methods presented here are not new, but have been put together from a variety of sources in a revised order. Methods for the DD reverse transcrrptron-polymerase chain reactions (RT-PCR) and electrophoresrs conditions, for which we have used published methods (2) and the GenomyxLR DNA sequencer (see Note 1 and ref. 2), are not covered here. Conventronal strategies of identifymg and clonmg mRNAs from DD gels involve first verifying differential expression by Northern blot analysis using a probe made by PCR-amplifying cDNA cut out from the DD gel. During the PCR process, a significant amount of contaminating DNAs of the same size as the band of interest may be produced and/or amplified that cannot be removed by gel purificatron. Even what may appear to be low levels of such contaminants can cause problems for Northern blots if they hybridize efficiently to highly represented RNAs. As a result, signals from differentially expressed mRNAs may be obscured and the DD band scored as a false posmve. Even if such a mixture is not abandoned at this point, it can be time-consuming and labor-intensive to locate the differentially expressed message using conventional strategies. From
Methods m Molecular Brology, Vol 85 Dffferentral Edlted by P Llang and A B Pardee Humana
77
D/splay Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
Martin, Kwan, and Sager
78
The strategy described here, which has resulted m a low rate of false posltives (see Note 2), avolds Northern blotting prior to the availability of a pure probe. The method 1sbased on the imtlal direct sequencing of DD bands. Unlike Northern blots, DNA sequencmg is not sensitive to hybridization efficiency or cellular message representation level. In most cases,direct sequencing rapidly provides positive identification of a DD band. Followmg database verification, sequence information can be used to design ohgonucleotides with which to generate probes for Northern analysis using either of two methods: (1) small (approx 20 bp) oligonucleotide pairs allow the generation of long (>150 bp) probes by RT-PCR from total cellular RNA; and (2) a smgle oligonucleotlde 40 bp in length can be end-labeled and used directly as a probe (3) For situations where faint or crowded DD bands do not produce a legible DNA sequence or where the direct sequence cannot be verified by a database match (see Notes 3 and 4), a strategy for screening subclones 1sdescribed that employs single-base sequencing to ldenttfy unique subclones (4) followed by reverse Northern slot-blottmg (5) to Identify subclones that are differentially expressed. The overall strategy/Is shown (Fig. 1). This strategy can rapidly generate a large number of clones or tags for differentially expressed messages m a partlcular system of mvestlgation. Such mformatlon 1spotentially invaluable for the production of arrays that can be blotted by different sources of cellular RNA, yielding information on patterns of gene expression and regulation. 2. Materials 2.1. DNA Elution from DD Gel, PCR Amplification and DNA Sequencing 1 TE. 10 mM TrwCl, pH 7.4, 1 n-&? EDTA. 2 Glycogen. 10 mg/mL stock solution m dHzO. 3. DD primers: three 21 bp anchor primers LH-T,
,N, twelve 18 bp LH-AP andten
20-2 1 bp extendedOPA arbitrary primers (I). 4. Thermal cycle PCR machme
5. AmpliTaq@DNA polymerase(Perkm Elmer, Branchburg, NJ). 6 DeoxyNTPs:
stock solutions of 2 5 mM and 250 @I m dH,O
7 Taq PCR buffer 1OX stock solution* 100 m&I Tns-Cl, pH 8 4,500 mM KCl, 15 n&f MgCl*, and 0 01% gelatin 8 Mineral oil. 9. 4MNH,OAc. 10 Isopropanol
11 70% ethanol. 12 VentR@(exe-) DNA polymerase(New England BioLabs, Beverly, MA) 13. a33P-dATP,2000 Cilmrnol (DuPont NEN, Boston,MA).
A Direct-Sequencing-Based
Strategy for DD Gels Oifferentiai
display
Cut out differentially PCR-amplify
79
gel
efipressed
bands
(28 cycles)
Sequence
Unreadable
Readable
I
Known genes
EST match
No match
1 1 Use sequence to make probe for Northern or slot-blot for reuerse Northern I I
+
t Northern
~
Clone Screen subclones by reuerse Northern slot-blotting
or reuerse
Northern
Obtain full length clones for selected new genes
Fig. 1. Flowchart showing overall strategy based on mitral direct DNA sequencing for identifying and clonmg cDNAs from DD gels. 14. 15 16. 17
CircumVentTM Thermal Cycle DNA Sequencing Kit (New England BroLabs) GenomyxLR DNA sequencer (Genomyx, Foster City, CA) Access to DNA databases. Synthetic 40 bp ohgonucleotrdes complementary to appropriate region of genes of interest, which can be end-labeled and used to probe Northern blots (3) or synthetic 20-25 bp ohgonucleotrde pairs with matching melting temperatures complementary to appropriate region of genes of interest to PCR-amplify Northern probes from total cellular RNA.
80
Martin, Kwan, and Sager
2.2. Cloning, Single-Track Sequencing and Reverse Northern Slot-Blotting 1 Method of cloning PCR fragments, e g., Origmal TA cloning Kit (InVitrogen, San Diego, CA) 2 Mmi plasmid preparation method, e.g , QIAprep Spin Plasmtd Mimprep Kit (Qtagen, Chatsworth, CA) 3 Filter unit, 0.45 pm (Ultrafree-MC, Mtlhpore, Bedford, MA). 4. Nylon membrane, e g , ZetaProbe Blotting Membrane (Bto-Rad, Hercules, CA). 5 Slot-blot manifold (Schlelcher & Schuell, Keene, NH) 6. Method to synthesize 32P-labeled cDNA from total cellular RNA, e.g., SuperScrtpt Preamphfication System (Gibco BRL. Gatthersbury, MD). 7 a32P-dCTP, 3000 Ci/rnmol (NEN, Boston, MA) 8 150 x 15-mm tissue culture dishes 9 X-ray film of high sensitivny, e g., Kodak XAR 10 20X SSC: 3MNaC1,O 3MNa3citrate 2H20, pH 7.0
3. Methods 3.7. DNA Elution from DD Gel, PCR Amplification and DNA Sequencing 1, Elute DNA from cut-out DD band by boiling gel slice 10-20 mm in 100 pL TE Centrifuge briefly, transfer supernatant to a clean tube and precipitate DNA with ethanol using 3 pL glycogen as a carrier. Redissolve DNA m 20 pL ddHzO (see Note 5) 2. PCR-amplify using as few cycles as posstble (see Fig. 2). Use the same two primers as those used m the DD procedure to produce the band being sequenced (see Note 6), each at a final concentration of 400 ti. Mix primers with l-3 pL redtssolved DNA template, 0.5 U Taq polymerase and 20 @4 each dNTP m standard Tuq PCR buffer, final volume 20 pL Cover with mineral 011and perform approx 20 PCR cycles: 94°C for 45 s, 60°C for 2 min, and 72’C for 1 mm Elongate an additional 5 min at 72’C. 3 Remove primers and dNTPs by selective alcohol precipltatton (7). All reagents and incubations for this step should be at room temperature. Transfer 20 pL of the completed PCR reaction to a clean tube and add 20 pL 4MNH40Ac and 40 pL isopropanol Incubate 10 mm, then mtcrocentrifuge at 14K rpm for 10 min Remove the supernatant with a drawn-out glass ptpet. The pellet will generally not be visible. Add 100 pL 70% EtOH to the pellet and centrifuge briefly Remove supernatant with the drawn-out pipet, dry the precipitate 10-15 min m a SpeedVac Concentrator (Savant) and redissolve in 10 pL TE (see Note 8). 4. Sequence DNA using anchor or arbitrary DD primer (or extended primer; see Note 7 and 8), which should be at least approx 18 bp in length. Cycle sequence with Vent (exe-) DNA polymerase, a33P-dATP and 2 pL redissolved DNA for each band being analyzed. Perform annealing step at the same temperature as that used for DD An example of the results is shown (see Notes 1 and 3; Fig 2).
A Direct-Sequencing-Based
Strategy for DD Gels
Cycles of PCR:
15
25
Neu,
C/EBP 6
al ACH 48
15
25
81
49
15
25
E 48
8
Fig. 2. Effect on DNA sequencing tracks of increasing the number of PCR cycles. Examples, with identities indicated at top, were generated from DD bands that were seen when RT-PCR reactions were performed using RNA from the nontransformed breast cell line 76N, but not with RNA from the breast tumor cell line MDA-MB-435S (see Note 1). al ACH, a-l antichymotrypsin; C/EBP 6, CAAT-box enhancer binding protein. 5. Read DNA sequence and compare to sequences available in GenBank, EMBL and any additional DNA databases available database (e.g., BLAST network service at NCBI) (see Note 10). Also compare with sequences entered in EST database.
Martin, Kwan, and Sager
82
6. Followmg database verification of sequence (see Note 4), 20-25 bp primers with matching melting temperatures can be destgned and synthesized to generate by PCR a probe (approx 100 to 500 bp) for standard Northern analysis or reverse Northern slot-blotting (see Section 3 2 , step 5) Alternatively, a smgle synthetic ohgonucleotide of approx 40 bp can be made, end-labeled with kmase and used to probe a Northern blot (3)
3.2. Cloning, Single-Track Sequencing and Reverse Northern Slot-Blotting This sectron describes methods used to clone DD band cDNAs and select subclones representing differentially expressed messages.We have applied this strategy to DD bands that (1) drd not yield good quality direct sequences or (2) dtd not match any current database entrres (includmg ESTs). This has comprised about 30% of the DD bands that we Isolated (see Notes 3 and 4). 1 PCR-amplify 1 pL precipitated DNA from step Section 3.1 , step 1 using DD primers and PCR conditions described (l), but reduce the number of PCR cycles to 25 2 Clone PCR products by standard methods. Select about four colonies for analysis m cases where the direct sequence 1s readable or eight colonies where the sequence appears highly contaminated or no sequencing signal is detected. Isolate plasmids using mini-preparation methods 3 Perform single-track (G, A, T, or C) sequencing reactions of the selected plasmids using standard sequencing methods and compare the patterns generated (see Note 1). Restriction analysis is reported to be a useful alternative to smgletracking (4) To avoid sequence patterns that differ depending on the orientation of the insert, use a primer that anneals to the cloned DNA or a umdnectional clonmg strategy. 4 PCR-amplify inserts from the selected subclones and extract from 1% agarose gels using a spin column 5 Perform reverse Northern slot-blotting Prepare membrane for slot-blottmg according to standard methods (8) Apply 5 pL denatured PCR product onto each of two nylon membranes using a slot-blot manifold Include controls known to be differentially and similarly expressed Synthesize 32P-labeled cDNA probes from 10 pg total RNA used for DD by standard methods with 50 $1 a3*P-dCTP Prehybridize and hybridize membranes using standard Northern blotting conditions m two 150 x 15 mm tissue culture dishes sealed with parafilm. Hybridize overnight at 42°C then wash twice at moderate strmgency (2X SSC with 0.1% SDS at 50°C 15 min each). Expose membranes to film for about 5 d (see Notes 11 and 12; Fig 3)
4. Notes 1 The extended format of the programmable
GenomyxLR
sequencer is useful for
band separationand gives reproducible results both for the DD gels (2) and the single- and four-track sequencing reactions
A Direct-Sequencing-Based 76N
83
Strategy for DO Gels
MDA-MB-435 laspin :omplement
component
C3
iST A Votectin
K059)
la lb - PAIIC
!a !b !C !d - Laminin
p3
!e
Fig. 3. Reverse Northern slot-blotting used to screen subclones for differential expression. DNA fragments corresponding to the genes or subclones indicated at the right were slot-blotted in duplicate and probed with mixtures made by reverse transcribing, then 32P-labeling, total cellular RNA from the nontransformed breast cell line 76N or the breast tumor cell line MDA-MB-435s (see Note 6). Four genes known to be down-regulated in breast tumor cells lines are shown at top as controls: maspin, complement component C3, GST a, and protectin (CD59). Examples of subclones obtained from two differentially expressed DD bands are shown at bottom. Subclones la, lb, and lc were obtained from a single DD band identified by direct sequencing as plasminogen activator inhibitor 2 (PAI-2); subclone 1b was identified as differentially expressed and sequencing verified its identification as PAI-2. Similarly, subclones 2a-2e were identified as laminin 83 and the differentially expressed subclone 2d confirmed the identification. (Subclones 2a and 2c are also laminin l33; la, lc, 2b, and 2e were not examined.) 2. We have confirmed differential expression by Northern blotting or reverse Northern slot-blotting for all DD bands we have tested to date (manuscript in preparation). 3. Using the methods described, we have found that 89 (87%) of 102 differentially expressed DD bands yielded good quality DNA sequence information (i.e., 80-99% of bases could be read) allowing database searches for matching sequences. Bands that did not produce good sequencing tracks tended to be faint on the DD gel. 4. In our experience, 80% (44/55) of sequences could be verified by matching to an entry in the GenBank, EMBL, and EST DNA databases.
84
Mart/n, Kwan, and Sager
5 Though the PCR reaction of Section 3 1 , step 2 can be performed with the actual
6
7 8.
9.
10
I1 12
gel band m the tube, rather than botlmg the gel band and precipitating the eluted DNA as in Section 3 1 , step 1, these procedures provide one with a reusable DNA solutton and a higher yield of PCR product per cut-out band RNAs from two cultured breast cell lines were used, mcludmg the normal cell lme 76N, whtch was isolated from a reduction mammoplasty spectmen (9), and the transformed cell lme MDA-MB-435S, originally isolated from a metastattc ductal adenocarcmoma of the breast and obtained from the American Type Culture Collection (Rockvtlle, MD) If short primers are used for DD, extended primer sets may be used at Section 3 1 , step 2 to produce PCR products that can be directly sequenced (6) If some 011 was transferred from PCR reaction of Section 3 1 , step 2, into the prectpttatton tube It ~111 remam m the tube during drying, making the completed sample appear wet Thts ~111 not be detrimental to subsequent steps of the sequencing procedure We routinely use one of three 2 1-bp DD anchor prrmers, LH-T, ,N (4), as a primer for cycle sequencing reactions Ninety-four DD bands from which we obtained readable sequences (dnectly or from differenttally expressed subclones), represented 55 dtfferent genes AdJacent bands wtth tdenttcal expression patterns on the DD gels usually gave the same DNA sequence, apparently resulting from strands of DNA that separated on the denaturing DD gels A small number of genes have also been found many (up to 20) times with the same arbttrary prtmer 32P-labeled cDNA probes can be saved and reused to blot addmonal filters. After hybndrzmg the membrane to identify the differentially expressed subclones, both filters can be strrpped and reblotted in parallel wtth a 32P-labeled cDNA probe mtxture made from a smgle cell line, e g., the MDA-MB-435s tumor cell Ime, to verify equal loadmg of subclone DNAs onto the filters
Acknowledgments We thank S. Douglas and A Amsowlcz for helpful comments on the manu-
script, and M. Erlander for assistance with the reverse Northern protocol. References 1. Zhao, S , Ooi, S L , and Pardee, A B (1995) New primer strategy Improves the precision of differential dtsplay BloTechnrques 18, 842-850. 2. Averboukh, L., Douglas, S A, Zhao, S., Lowe, K., Maher, J., and Pardee, A B (1996) Better gel resolution and longer cDNAs increase the precision of differential display. BzoTechnzques 20,9 18-92 1 3 Lmskens, M H K , Feng, J., Andrews, W. H , Enlow, B. E., Saatt, S M., Tonkm, L. A., Funk, W D., and Vtlleponteau, B. (1995) Cataloging altered gene expression m young and senescent cells using enhanced differential display. Nuclezc Acids Res 23,3244-325
1.
A Direct-Sequencing-Based
Strategy for DD Gels
85
4. Zhao, S . 001 S L , Yang, F -C., and Pardee, A. B (1996) Three methods for identtficatton of the positive cloned cDNA fragments m differential display. BzoTechnzques 20,400-402.
5 Mou, L., Miller, H , Wang, E., and Chalifour, J. (1994) Improvements to the differential display method for gene analysis. Blochem. Bzophys Res. Commun. 199, 564-569. 6 Wang, X. and Feuerstem, G. Z. (1995) Direct sequencing of DNA isolated from mRNA differential display BloTechnzques l&448-452. 7. Brow, M. A. D. (1990) Sequencing with Taq DNA polymerase, m PCR Protocols. A Guide to Methods and Applicatzons (Inms, M A., Gelfand, D H., Sninsky, J. J , and White, T. J., eds.), Academtc, San Diego, CA, pp. 189-196. 8. Brown, T (1995) Dot and slot blotting of DNA, m Current Protocols zn Molecular Biology (Ausubel, F M , Brent, R., Kmgston, R. E., Moore, D D., Seidman, J. G., Smith, J. A., and Struhl, K., eds.), Greene Publishing Associates, and John Wiley and Sons, pp. 2.9.15-2.9.20. 9 Band, V and Sager, R (1989) Distinctive tracts of normal and tumor-derived human mammary epithelial cells expressed in a medium that supports long-term growth of both cell types Proc Nat1 Acad Set USA 738, 103-123
Differential Screening of Differential Display cDNA Products by Reverse Northern Hong Zhang, Rong Zhang, and Peng Liang 1. Introduction Differential Display (DD) is a widely used methodology for cloning differentially expressed genes. Since its inception in 1992 (I), much effort has been made to improve and optimize the technique (2,3). One major bottle-neck remains, though, in the screening step for the verification of the cDNA fragments tentatively identified by differential display. In the standard protocol, Northern blot verification was recommended, with the reamplified cDNA as a probe (4). An alternative approach is to clone the reamplified cDNA and then use it as a probe for Northern analysis. Both approaches have their drawbacks. It is known that the reamplified cDNA probes from differential display sometimes contain a mixture rather than a single cDNA species, due to the contamination of comigrating cDNA fragments. As a result, direct use of the reamplified cDNA as probes might detect multiple messenger RNA species, making the identification of the truly differentially expressed gene difficult. On the other hand, if the cDNA fragment is cloned before being used as a probe for Northern blot, the choice of which clone to use becomes a matter of luck, depending on the extent of cDNA contamination. Compounding the problem is the laborious screening by Northern blot for each and every cDNA fragment identified. It is especially difficult under circumstances where the amount of RNA samples is limited. To this end, various approaches have been tried to improve the method. Mou et al. (5) described the slot-blot approach using random labeled composite cDNA probes to screen the reamplified cDNA fragments from differential display. Although increasing the through-put of the screening, this method could characterize many cDNA From:
Methods
in Molecular
Biology,
Edited
by: P. Liang
and A. B. Pardee
Vol. 85: Differential
87
Humana
Display Methods Press
Inc., Totowa,
and Protocols NJ
Zhang, Zhang, and hang
88
fragments as false posrtives If the reamplitied cDNA consrsts of more than one species, especially when the contaminating cDNAs correspond to abundant messages. Here we describe the use of differential screening by Reverse Northern dotblot as well as colony hybridization to screen for cDNA fragments that truly represent differentially expressed mRNAs. The method takes advantage of the high cloning efficiency of the pCR-TRAP cloning system, which is based on posmve-selection for insert. After cloning the reamplified cDNA fragments of interest, cDNAs labeled by reverse transcriptron are used as probes to screen for colonies harboring differentially expressed genes. This method has the followmg advantages: (1) many filters representing different cDNA fragments can be screened at the same time and with the same set of probes; (2) the masking
effect of false positive
clones is resolved; and (3)
once a cDNA clone IS confirmed to be posmve, rt IS ready to be sequenced, checked against the databaseand, if necessary,used as a probe to screen libraries. 2. Materials 2. I. Labeling 1, 2. 3, 4. 5 6.
2.2. Subcloning 1 2. 3 4 5. 6. 7. 8. 9 10. 11. 12.
of cDNA Probes
5X RT buffer: 125 mMTns-Cl, pH 8.3,188 mMKCl,7.5 mMMgClz and 25 mA4DTT dNTP(-C) mix* 500 lJ4 of each stock (without dCTP) mixed m equal volume. Oligo-dT primer: 10 w Tzo primer (GenHunter, Nashville, TN). a[32P]dCTP* 3000 Cl/mm01 (NEN, Boston, MA) MMLV reverse transcriptase, 100 U/pL (GenHunter) Quick Spin Column (Sephadex G-50, Boehringer Mannhelm, Indtanapolis, IN).
and Reverse Northern
Dot-Blot
T4 DNA ligase: 200 U/pL (GenHunter). pCR-TRAP vector. 150 ng/pL (GenHunter). GH competent cells (GenHunter) Tetracycline plates: LB plates with 10 pg/mL tetracycline (stored in dark at 4’C) 10X PCR buffer: 100 mMTris-HCl, pH 8 4,500 mM KCl, 15 rnA4MgC12, and 0.01% gelatin. 250 l&f dNTP (GenHunter). 2 pA4 Rgh and Lgh primers: primers flanking the cloning site of the pCR-TRAP vector (GenHunter). AmpliTaq DNA polymerase: 5 U/clr, (Perkin-Elmer, Foster Ctty, CA). 2N sodmm hydroxyde solution. 3Msodium acetate, pH 5.0. 20X SSC: 3MNaCl and 0.3M sodium citrate, pH 7.2. Prehybndization solutton: 50% formamtde, 0.75MNaCJ50 mMsodmm phosphate, pH 7.4, 5 mM EDTA, 0.1% Ficoll-400, 0 1% BSA, 0.1% polyvmylpyrohdone, and 0 1% SDS Stored at -2O’C. Add freshly boiled salmon sperm DNA to 20 &nL right before use.
Differential
Screening by Reverse Northern
89
2.3. Colony Hybrid&a tion 1. Denaturing solution: 0 5N NaOH/1.5M NaCl 2 Neutralizing solution 0.5M Tns-HCl, pH 7.0, 1 5M NaCl
3. Methods 3.1. Labeling
of cDNA Probes
1. Prepare 32P-labeled cDNA Probe by reverse transcrlptlon m a 50-pL reaction To a mlcrofuge tube, add 10 pL of 5X RT buffer, 5 PL ohgo-dT primer, 8 PL dNTP(-C) mix, 5 p.L a[32P]dCTP, 10 pg RNA, and dH20 to make up to 45 @ 2. Mix well and incubate the sample at 65°C for 5 min Then shift it to 37°C for 10 mm. Add 5 & MMLV reverse transcrlptase and continue to incubate at 37 “C for 1 h 3. Use a Quick Spin column to remove the unmcorperated 32P (as instructed by the manufacturer) Count 1 pL of the probe to check the radloactlvlty, which 1stypltally m the range of lo’-10s total cpm
3.2. Subcloning
and Reverse Northern
Dot-Blot
Perform the differential display using the RNAlmage kit (GenHunter) essentially as mstructed (see also Chapter 1). Retrieve the cDNA fragments of interest (Fig. 1A) from the denaturing polyacrylamlde gel and reamphfy them with the same sets of primers as in the Initial differential display PCR reactions (Fig. 1B). 1. Ligate 5 @. of the reamphficatlon product to 2 pL of the pCR-TRAP vector, with 2 pL 10X ligation buffer, 10 p,L dH20 and 1 pL T4 DNA ligase Carry out the ligation at 16’C overnight. 2. Transform 100 pL GH competent cells with 10 pL of the ligation mix Plate onefifth of the cells onto tetracycline plates After an overnight Incubation at 37”C, 50-100 colonies are typically obtained 3. Randomly pick four colonies from each plate and stick each mto 50 mL lysis buffer. Boll for 5 mm After spm for 5 mm, save the lysates. 4. Perform the colony-PCR m 30 cycles (94°C for 15 s, 52°C 40 s, and 72’C 1 mm) in 40-K reactions, with 4-pL 10X PCR buffer, 4-a Rgh primer, 4 @, Lgh primer, 4 pL of the colony lysates, 19.6 & dH,O, and 0.4 pL Taq polymerase m each tube Followmg a 5-min chain extension at 72”C, check the size of the inserts with 5 pL of the PCR products on a 1 5% agarose gel (Fig. 2A). 5. To prepare for blotting, mrx 30 & of each colony-PCR product with 5 pL of 2N sodium hydroxide Boll the mixture for 5 min to denature the DNA, then neutralize it with 5 pL of 3M sodium acetate, pH 5.0 After bringing the total volume to 105 & with dH20, dot-blot 50 pL of each sample onto duplicate Nylon membranes using the Blo-Dot mlcrofiltration system (see Note 2) UV cross-link the membrane and rinse it m 6X SSC before prehybndization. 6 Shake and incubate the blot m 10 mL of prehybrldization solution at 42’C After 4 or more hours, boll the cDNA probes for 5 mm and add equal counts (1 06-1 0’ cpm) to the respective bottles. Hybridize overnight at 42°C.
Zhang, Zhang, and Liang
90
A Control
Mob-36
Mob-37
Mob-38
Mob-39
B MW
CaWol
Mob-36
Mob-37
Mob-36
Mob-39
Fig. 1. (A) Differential display of the messenger RNA from Rat1 cells (left lanes) and T 10 l-4 cells (right lanes) (see Note 1). cDNA fragments of interest were indicated by arrows. H-T, ,C was used as the anchor pruner in combinations with arbitrary primers H-AP18, H-AP18, H-AP29, H-AP3 1 and H-AP34 (GenHunter) to amplify the negative control, Mob-36, Mob-37, Mob-38 and Mob-39, respectively. (B) 1.5% agarose gel electrophoresis of the PCR products from the retrieved fragments. 7. Wash the blots twice at room temperature, for 15 min each, with 1X SSC and 0.1% SDS, then once at 60°C for 15 min with 0.25X SSC and 0.1% SDS. 8. Expose an X-ray film against the blot overnight at -80 “C with an intensifying screen (Fig. 2B; see Note 3).
3.3. Screening
by Colony Hybridization
(see Note 4)
1. Transfer the tetracycline-resistant colonies (obtained from Section 3.2.) by replica-plating onto duplicate nitrocellulose membrane filters laid on top of the tetracycline plates. 2. After an overnight incubation, float each filter in denaturing solution for 2 min to lyse the cells and denature the DNA, then float it in neutralizing solution for 2 min. 3. Wash the filters in 6X SSC/O.S% SDS at room temperature for 1 hr, with vigorous shaking to remove the cell debris from the tilters. 4. After crosslinking the filters by W irradiation for 2 min, hybridize them with the same set of 32P labeled cDNA probes as for the dot-blots (Fig. 3; see Note 5).
91
Differential Screening by Reverse Northern
B
Rat1 abc
TlOl-4 d
a
b
c
d
Mob-5 & Control Mob-38
Mob-37 Mob-38 Mob-39
Fig. 2. (A) 1.5% agarose gel electrophoresis of the colony-PCR products from the cloned cDNA. Two randomly picked colonies for the positive control, Mob-5 and the negative control, four randomly picked colonies each for Mob-36, Mob-37, Mob-38, and Mob-39 were amplified by PCR with a pair of primers flanking the cloning site of the pCR-TRAP cloning vector (GenHunter). (B) Reverse Northern dot-blot of the colony PCR products from Fig. 2A. The left two dots on the top row of the duplicate blots are the positive control Mob-5, while the right two dots are the negative control, which indicates the equal labeling of the two cDNA probes from the Rat1 cells (left blot) and Tl 01-4 cells (right blot). (C) Northern blot analysis of Mob-5, showing the differential expression of the gene in H-ras transformed TlO l-4 cells. The 28s and 18s rRNAs are shown at the bottom as loading control.
4. Notes 1. As part of our ongoing effort to apply differential display to identify genes that are regulated by the rus signaling pathway, the immortalized rat embryo fibroblast cell line Rat 1 and its H-rus transformed derivative, T 10 l-4 (6) were compared. The genes that are expressed at a higher level in the T 10 l-4 cell line are of great interest. 2. We recommend UV cross-linking the membrane directly after blotting the DNA, since rinsing the wells with 6X SSC would create rings instead of round spots on the blot.
Zhang, Zhang, and Liang
92 Rat1
TlOl-4
Mob-37
Rat1 ..-
TlOl-4 --
Mob-38
Fig. 3. Colony hybridization of the duplicate filters with the same set of cDNA probes used for the dot-blot in Fig. 2B. (A) Mob-37, the arrow denotes a false positive clone, later confirmed by sequencing. (B) Mob-38, arrows indicate some of the positive colonies. 3. Mob-5, a previously cloned gene expressed only in the transformed cells (Liang et al., unpublished data), was used as a positive control. As a negative control, two clones from a band equally expressed from the differential display (Fig. 1A). Except for the false positive Mob-36d and the no-signal clones Mob-37d and Mob-38b and c, all other clones represent truly differentially expressed genes (Mob-36 through Mob-39). 4. Reverse Northern dot-blotting allows simultaneous screening of multiple cDNA fragments. However, two pitfalls needs special attention. First, the method is still cumbersome since the cloned cDNA has to be either amplified or isolated before blotting. Second, only a limited number of colonies for each cDNA fragment could be analyzed, so a truly differentially expressed gene might elude detection if the contamination of false positive genes is severe. The colony hybridization method described here should be able to overcome the aforementioned pitfalls.
Differential Screening by Reverse Northern
93
5 We have smce sequenced all four positive clones. Database search results mdicate that, while three of the cloned cDNA fragments represent potentially novel genes, Mob-36 corresponds to a well-characterized gene, osteopontin, which was known to be induced by oncogenic ras and involved in many tumors (7) 6. Much of this work has been published previously (8).
References 1, Liang, P. and Pardee, A. B. (1992) Differential display of eukaryotrc mRNA by means of the polymerase chain reaction. Science 257,967-97 1. 2. Liang, P. and Pardee, A. B. (1995) Recent advances in differential display. Curr Opmion Immunol
7,2742%X
3. Liang, P., Zhu, W., Zhang, X., Guo, Z., O’Connell, R., Averboukh, L., Wang, F., and Pardee, A. B. (1994) Differential display using one-base anchored ohgo-dT primer. Nucleic Acids Res 22,5763-5764. 4. Liang, P., Averboukh, L., and Pardee, A B. (1993) Distribution and clonmg of eukaryotic mRNAs by means of differential display refinements and optimization. Nucleic Aczds Res. 21,3269-3275. 5. Mou, L., Miller, H., Li, J., Wang, E., and Chalifour, L. (1994) Improvements to the differential display method for gene analysis. Biochem Bzophys Res Comm 199,564-569
6. Liang, P., Averboukh, L., Zhu, W., and Pardee, A. B. (1994) Ras activation of novel genes Mob-l as a model Proc Nat1 Acad. Scz. USA 91, 12,515-12,519. 7. Craig, A. M , Nemn, M., MukherJee, B. B., Chambers, A F., and Denhardt, D. T. (1988) Identification of the maJor phosphoprotein secreted by many rodent cell lines as 2ar/osteopontm* enhanced expression m H-ras-transformed 3T3 cells Blochem. Blophys. Res Comm 157, 166-173. 8. Zhang, H., Zhang, R., and Liang, P. (1996) Differential screening of gene expression difference enriched by differential display Nucleic Acids Res. 24,2454-2456
9 Screening for Positive Clones Generated by Differential Display Regina V8gelbLange, Niels Biirckert, Thomas Boiler, and Andres Wiemken 1. Introduction Differential display 1sa powerful method to identify genes that are differentially expressed m different tissues or m the same tissue exposed to different treatments (1,2). The method can be performed wtth relatively little biological material, and the resultmg partial cDNAs can be cloned, sequenced, and used for subsequent expression studies. cDNA fragments derived from downregulated as well as upregulated transcripts can be detected simultaneously, and cDNAs corresponding to messages of high and low abundance are detected with similar probabtlities. One drawback of this method, however, is the relatively high number of false positives, i.e., of cloned cDNAs that give no differential hybridization pattern on Northern blots. In part, this could be attributed to exogenous factors such as bad PCR tubes (3), degraded RNA or contammatmg DNA. In addition, however, there is an intrinsic problem of the method itself. There is increasing evidence in the literature that single bands with differential appearance on gels, here called differentials, represent a mixture of several cDNA fragments of identical size but different sequence. Thus the cDNA clones obtained from one particular differential may be derived from several different mRNAs, includmg both differentially and constitutively expressed ones. It 1s of interest to select for further characterization only the clones that represent truly differentially expressed genes. For this purpose, Lt et al. (4) proposed to screen several cDNAs from one differential by Northern blot affinity capturing. This method is applicable only when large quanttties of mRNA are available. An alternattve approach consists of spotting plasmtd DNA of several individual clones From
Methods m Molecular Bology, Vol 85 D/fferenbal Edlted by P Llang and A 8 Pardee Humana
95
Display Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa. NJ
Vligeli-Lange
96
et al.
obtained from one differential onto a membrane that IS then hybridized to a portion of the orrginal differential eluted from the polyacrylamide gel (5). This method may work well if the bulk of the radioactivity m the ortgmal differential actually represents a single differentially expressed gene. However, rt will fail rf the differential represents mainly a constitutively expressed gene or rf rt is composed of several different cDNAs. To circumvent this problem, we hybridize the original 33P-labeled differential display products from both the control RNA and the RNA source of interest to duplicate samples of several individual clones obtained from one differential (6). By comparing the hybridization patterns, we can easily select clones representing sequences that were differentially amplified from the two sources of RNA. Positive clones identrtied by our new screening method (6) are then promising candidates for truly differentially expressed genes and can be used for further analysts.
2. Materials All solutions are prepared with autoclaved double-distilled or filter-purified water and should be stored at room temperature unless stated otherwise.
2.7. Differential Display and CIoning of Differen tia//y Displayed c DNA Fragments 1. 2 3 4. 5. 6.
7.
8. 9. 10 11. 12. 13. 14.
TE buffer: 10 mM Tns-HCl, pH 7.4, 1 mM EDTA. Autoclave. 3M Sodium acetate, pH 4.8-5 2 Autoclave Glycogen (10 mg/mL). Store at -20°C. 100% Ethanol 85% (v/v) Ethanol. Store at -20°C H-T1 tM and H-AP primers (GenHunter Corporation, Nashville, TN) for reamphfication of eluted drfferentials: 2-w stock solutions. Store at -20°C Use the same set of primers that has been used to generate the differentral (see Chapter 1 for details) dNTP stock: 250 @4 each of dATP, dCTP, dGTP, dTTP (Pharmacia, Uppsala, Sweden). Prepare by mrxmg equal amounts of 1-mI4 stock solutions of each of the four dNTPs. Store at -20°C DNA polymerase (5 U/pL), e g , AmphTuq (Perkm Elmer). Store at -20°C. lOXPCRbuffer* lOOmMTris-HCl,pH8 3,500mA4KCl, 15 mA4MgClB,0.01% (w/v) gelatin. Store at -2O’C Cloning vector for PCR products, e.g., pCR-TRAP (GenHunter Corporation). Store at -20°C. T4 DNA ligase (200 U/&) Store at -20°C. Competent E coli cells Store at -7O’C. LB medium: Add 10 g tryptone, 5 g yeast extract, and 9 g NaCl to 1 L HzO. Autoclave; store at 4’C. LB plates, 20 pg/mL tetracycline: LB medium supplemented with 15 g agar Autoclave, when cooled down to 60°C add 1 mL tetracycline solution (20 mg/mL in 95% ethanol). Pour plates, store at 4°C in the dark.
Screening for Positwe Clones
97
I5 Colony lys~s buffer TE buffer with 0 1% Tween-20 Store at -20°C 16 Primers flanking the cloning site, 2 M each. Store at -20°C
2.2. Slot Blot Analysis of Cloned Differentials 1 2 3 4
20X SSC stock solution 3MNaCl,0.3MNa3-citrate, pH 7 0 Autoclave 0.5M NaOH, 1 SM NaCl Autoclave. 0 5MTris-HCl, pH 7 5, 1 5MNaCl Autoclave 50X Denhardt’s stock solution Dissolve 5 g Flcoll (Type 400, Pharmacla), and 5 g polyvmylpyrrolldone, 5 g bovine serum albumin m a total volume of 500 mL H,O Store in ahquots at -2O’C 5 10% SDS. 6 Salmon sperm DNA stock 10 mg/mL m TE buffer, shear DNA by somcatlon Store in aliquots at -20°C.
3. Method 3.1. Differential Display and Cloning of Differentially Displayed cDNA Fragments The basic method for differential display 1sdescribed m detail m Chapter 1 (see also refs. I and 2) We perform differential display with one-base anchored primers flanked at the 5’-end by an Hind111 restrlctlon site (6,7) (see Note 1). For elution and cloning of bands with differential appearance on polyacrylamide gels, the differentials, we employ the modifications described below: 1 Cut out band of interest from dried gel with a new razor blade and place m a 1 5-mL Eppendorf tube (see Note 2) To check whether the appropriate band has been removed from the polyacrylamlde gel, re-expose gel to X-ray film. 2 Add 100 pL of TE buffer, seal tube with parafilm Incubate for 2 h at room temperature followed by 1 h at 37°C with occaslonal shaking. Then Incubate at 4°C for 1 h up to overmght with gentle agltatlon. 3. Centrifuge at 12,OOOg for 2 min, and transfer supernatant to a fresh tube (see Note 3) Precipitate eluted DNA by adding 10 PL 3M sodium acetate buffer, pH 4 8-5.2,5 & glycogen (10 mg/mL), and 450 $ 100% ethanol Place tube for 40 mm in a -70°C freezer 4. Centrifuge for 10 mm at 12,000g and 4°C to pellet the DNA. The glycogen carrier will produce a white pellet at the bottom of the tube Remove the supernatant and rinse the pellet with 200 pL Ice-cold 85% (v/v) ethanol. Centrifuge for 2 mm at room temperature and remove remaming llquld with a mlcroplpet tip Air dry the pellet briefly and then dissolve in 10 $ HZ0 Store at -20°C If not used dn-ectly for reamphficatlon 5 Reampllfy the eluted cDNA fragments by using 3 & of the eluate m a 30-& PCR reaction with the same set of primers used to generate the differential. Final concentrations of the primers are 0 2 cln/r,dNTPs are used each at 20 w with 0 5 U AmpllTaq polymerase (Perkm Elmer). PCR IS performed m 30 cycles of 94°C for 30 s, 40°C for 2 mm, and 72°C for 30 s with a final extension of 5 min Run
98
Vtigeli-Lange et al.
15-20 p.L of the PCR reaction mixture on a 1 3-l 5% agarose gel containing ethldmm bromide and compare the size of the reamphfied PCR products to the size of the correspondmg differential (see Note 2). For ligation, use only PCR products that give a smgle band of expected size If several bands of different size are detected on the agarose gel, prick the expected band once with a fine mlcropipet tip and use this as moculum for a fresh PCR reaction This often helps to produce a single band of expected size 6 Ligate PCR products directly mto an appropriate vector We use the pCR-TRAP clonmg vector (GenHunter Corporation) that has the advantage that only plasmlds with inserts confer tetracycline resistance to transformed E co11 cells, thus allowing direct positive selection for cDNA inserts For ligation, mix 10 & H,O, 2 pL Insert-ready pCR-TRAP vector, 2 pL 1OX hgatlon buffer, 5 & PCR product, and 1 & T4 DNA hgase (200 U/pL) Mix gently and incubate overnight at 16°C 7 Streak out all the cells from a transformation mix with 10 pL of the ligation mix and 100 pL competent E colz cells onto 1 to 2 LB plates supplemented with tetracycline (20 pg/mL) (see Note 4) 8 For each differential, screen approx 10 E colz colonies for plasmlds with inserts of correct size by colony PCR or by restrlctlon enzyme analysis of plasmld DNA For colony PCR, place a small amount of E colz cells mto a 1 5-mL Eppendorf tube contammg 50 pL of TE buffer supplemented with 0.1% Tween-20 Incubate the tubes at 95°C for 10 mm. Spm for 2 mm at 12,OOOg,and transfer 35 pL of the supernatant to a fresh tube Use the supernatant directly for PCR with primers flanking the clonmg site, or store at -20°C for f?uther use (see Note 5)
3.2. Sot Blot Analysis of Cloned Differentials A single band in the drfferential display polyacrylamide gel 1s often composed of several cDNA fragments of identical size but different sequence Therefore, It IS of importance to dlstmgulsh between cDNA fragments that are derived from truly differentially expressed genes and those derived from contaminating constitutively expressed genes. We do this by reverse RNA slot blot analysis using the original 33P-labeled PCR products as hybridization probes. When several candidate positive clones are found, DNA slot blot analysis can be employed
m a second step to determine
whether the different clones
are homologous. For each differential to be analyzed, three replicate membranes are prepared containing the cDNA inserts of several independent clones obtained by transformation of E coZi with that particular differential. Two of the replicate membranes, membranes A and B, are then used for reverse RNA slot blot analysis, the third one, membrane C, can be used subsequently for DNA slot blot analysis if desired. Our general protocol for slot blot analysis of cloned differentials IS as follows* 1 Using a primer pair flanking the cloning site, PCR amplify cDNA from 6-10 independent E co11colonies contaming inserts of correct size obtained by trans-
Screening
2.
3
4. 5
6.
7.
8
for Positive
Clones
99
formation with the differential to be tested For a 20-k PCR reaction, use 2 pL of colony lysate as DNA template, with the final primer concentratton at 0.2 pJ4 and the final concentratton of dNTPs each at 20 @4 PCR products can be used directly for slot blot analysis or stored at -20°C untrl used For slot blot analysts, float a membrane (e.g., NY 13 N, Schleicher and Schuell, Dassel, Germany) first on water, then on 6X SSC Assemble slot or dot blot machine (e.g., Gtbco-BRL). Wash each slot with 0 5 mL 1OX SSC. For each sample to be analyzed, place 19 pL PCR product into a 1 5 mL Eppendorf tube, heat for 5 min at 95°C chill on ice, and quick spm to collect condensate Add 475 pL 10X SSC, mix well. Apply this mixture m three ahquots of 156 pL to three slots or dots of the filtration manifold. Wash each slot twice with 0 5 mL 1OX SSC Disassemble filtration manifold, and float membrane for 7 mm on a solution conststmg of 0 SMNaOH, 1.SMNaCl. This is followed by 2 floatatton steps on 0.5M Tris-HCl, pH 7 5, 1.SMNaCl for 3 mm each Wash membrane briefly m 2X SSC and, with a sharp razor blade, cut mto three identical sets, A, B, and C, each containing the cDNA mserts of 6-10 E coEi colonies obtained by transformation with the differential under investigation Bake membranes for l-2 h at 80°C m a vacuum oven. Membranes A and B then can be used directly for hybridization or, wrapped in aluminum foil, stored together with membrane C at room temperature until used Use membranes A and B for reverse RNA blot analysis Prehybrrdize membranes for 14 h at 60°C in 5 mL of 6X SSC, 5X Denhardt’s solution, 0 5% SDS, and 100 pg/mL denatured salmon sperm DNA. Decant prehybridization solution, replace with 4 mL of fresh prehybridtzatton solution To membrane A, add 15 pL of the original 33P-labeled PCR products from the control tissue denatured for 5 mm at 95°C and to membrane B the corresponding 33P-labeled PCR products from the tissue under mvestigation (see Note 6). Hybridize overnight at 60°C. Remove hybridization solution, and wash membranes twice for 15 mm each at 60°C m 10 mL of 0 2X SSC, 0 2% SDS. Dry membranes briefly on Whatman 3MM paper, wrap m Saran fotl and expose for 6-48 h to a PhosphoImager high sensttivtty screen (BroRad) or, if unavailable, to X-ray film. Compare hybridizatton patterns of blot A and B (see Fig 1) cDNA mserts representing sequences that are differentially amplified, and therefore probably derived from truly up- or downregulated genes, are easily recognized by their differential hybridization pattern, whereas cDNA mserts representing sequences that are equally amplified, and therefore likely derived from contammatmg constitutlvely expressed genes, show identical hybridization patterns with membrane A and B (see Note 7). If several cDNA inserts with differential hybridization patterns are obtained from a single differential, PCR amplify one of these inserts from colony lysate usmg the ortgmal differential display primers and the PCR conditions for reamphficatton of differentials (see Note 8). Use half of the PCR product obtained from a 20 pL reaction to prepare a 33P- or 32P-labeled probe by random primed labeling
Rigeli-Lange
100
A
A
7
9
et al.
Fig. 1. Selection of clones with cDNA inserts from differentially expressed genes by reverse Northern blot analysis utilizing differential display PCR products as hybridization probes. One hundred nanograms of PCR amplified inserts of ten individual E. coli colonies obtained by transformation with the differential Myc 4 (H-T, ,C and H-AP3) were immobilized in duplicate sets onto nylon membranes and hybridized with the original 33P PCR product from control roots (A) or from mycorrhizal roots (B). The order of inserts is from left to right starting with number 1 and ending with number 10. Clones with differentially expressed cDNAs are indicated by arrows. Used with permission from ref. 6.
and, using the conditions described in step (6), hybridize the probe to membrane C. An example of this where all positive clones represent homologous sequences is shown in Fig. 2A (see Note 9). Putative positive clones then can be sequenced. To verify differential expression of putative positive clones, the other half of the PCR product can be used to prepare a 3ZP-labeled hybridization probe for RNA gel blot analysis (see Fig. 2B). So far, we have tested this approach with 50 cloned differentials and for 10
of them RNA gel blot analyses were performed. In five of these cases, differential expression was confirmed by RNA gel blot analysis, the other five probes gave no detectable signals on Northern blots with 10 ~18of total RNA. However, none of the probes tested hybridized to both RNA from control tissue and RNA from treated tissue. This indicates that our screening method is useful to eliminate false positives. The probes that produced no detectable signal on Northern blots most likely are derived from rare messages.More sensitive methods for RNA analysis, such asribonuclease protection assays(81or poly(A) RNA gel blot analysis may help detect differential expression of such messages. 4. Notes 1. A convenient way to get started on differential display is to use one of the kits distributed by GenHunter Corporation. As radioactive nucleotide we prefer 33P over 35S since it is less volatile and produces sharper bands on polyactylamide gels (9).
101
Screening for Positive Clones
Clone Number
f
1
3
5
7
9
11
control roots
13
15 17
I
3
5
7
9
11 13 15 17
3.6 kb
days
mycorrhizal roots
Fig. 2. (A) Classification of clones with cDNA inserts from differentially expressed genes. H-T1 ,C and H-AP3 PCR product of clone pMvc 4.7 was labeled with a[33P]dATP and hybridized to a membrane containing the cDNA inserts of clones piVyc 4.1 to pMyc 4.10. Hybridization signals were quantified using a Bio-Rad GS-250 Molecular Imager. (B) Northern blot analysis of the Myc 4.7 probe. Two membranes, one containing 10 pg/lane RNA from nonmycorrhizal control roots, the other one 10 mg/lane RNA from mycorrhizal roots, were hybridized simultaneously with a[32P]dATP labeled Myc 4.7 (1 x lo6 cpm/mL.). Days indicate time after inoculation with fungus or corresponding control treatment. Used with permission from ref. 6. 2. Since differential display predominantly generates cDNA fragments from the 3’-end of messenger RNAs, it is advantageous to select bands that are more than 250 bp in size. Shorter fragments often correspond to the 3’-untranslated region of a gene, and thus are less helpful for homology searches in the database. A 33P end-labeled DNA marker can be prepared from any DNA ladder with 5’ overhang in a till in reaction with the Klenow fragment of DNA polymerase. We use a Klenow fill-in kit (Stratagene) to label the @X174/ HintI DNA marker (Stratagene) resulting in a ladder of labeled bands ranging from 726 to 24 bp. 3. Store the pellet at -20°C in case of mishaps. Also, if reamplification was unsuccessful, reextracting the excised band often is more helpful than diluting the products of the first round PCR into a fresh PCR reaction.
102
Vtigeli-Lange et al.
4. Basically any tetracycline sensitive E. coli strain can be used for transformation. The strain provided with the GenHunter pCR-TRAP cloning system is not further specified. In addition to the GenHunter strain, we have been using E. coli strain DHSa. What seems however important, is that prior to plating on selective medium, the recovery period of the E. coli cells in LB medium should be extended from 1 to at least 2 h. This increases the number of tetracyline resistant colonies obtained approximately by a factor of five without affecting positive selection. 5. We do 15-pL PCR reactions with 1.5p.L colony lysate and run the entire PCR reaction mixture on an agarose gel. On average, three out of four colonies screened obtain inserts of correct size. We store the colony lysate at -20°C in 0.5-mL tubes to safe freezer space, Colony lysate is also a useful source for the amplification of cDNA to produce hybridization probes. 6. For best results, we combine PCR products from two or three reactions derived from the same primer combination. Therefore, we either run the differential display with several replicates, or we use RNA extracted from a time-course experiment and select the time points containing the differential of interest. If several differentials are obtained with the same primer combination, they can all be screened simultaneously in the same hybridization solution. 7. The whole procedure, including differential display and screening for positive clones, can be completed in a period of two weeks. When fresh 33P(200 Ci/mmol) is used in the differential display, up to 4-wk-old PCR reactions can be used as hybridization probes for the screening step. Often, cDNAs from different clones representing the same differential hybridize with different intensities to the 33P PCR products of one particular reaction (see Fig. 1A or B). As the cDNAs were amplified from colony lysate, where the input of DNA template is not strictly controlled, differential hybridization intensities within the same blot cannot be taken as an indication for the presence of clones with different sequence. 8. In this PCR reaction, do not use primers flanking the cloning site, as these will produce short stretches of DNA that will hybridize to all of the PCR products to be tested. 9. As an alternative to the DNA slot blot step, select several of the cDNAs with differential hybridization pattern directly for DNA sequencing.
Acknowledgments We thank Oxford University Press for the permission to reproduce Figs. 1 and 2 from ref. 6. References 1. Liang, P. and Pardee, A. B. (1992) Differential display of eukaryotic messenger RNA by means of the polymerase chain reaction. Science 257,967-97 1. 2. Liang, P., Averboukh, L., and Pardee A. B. (1993) Distribution and cloning of mRNAs by means of differential display: refinements and optimization. Nucleic Acids Res. 21,3269-3275.
Screening
for Positive
Clones
103
3. Chen, Z., Swisshelm, K., and Sager, R. (1994) A cautionary note on the reaction tubes for differential display and cDNA amplification in thermal cycling. BioTechniques 16, 1003-1006. 4. Li, F., Barnathan, E. S., and Kariko, K. (1994) Rapid method for screening and cloning cDNAs generated in differential mRNA display: application of Northern blot for affinity capturing of cDNAs. Nucleic Acids Rex 22, 1764,1765. 5. Callard, D., Lescure, B., and Mazzolini, L. (1994) A method for the elimination of false positives generated by the mRNA differential display technique. BioTechniques 16, 1096-l 103. 6. Vogeli-Lange, R., Btirckert, N., Boiler, T., and Wiemken, A. (1996) Rapid selection and classification of positive clones generated by mRNA differential display. Nucleic Acids Res. 24, 1385,1386. 7. Liang, P., Zhu, W., Zhang, X., Guo, Z., O’Connell, R. P., Averboukh, L., Wang, F., and Pardee, A. B (1994) Differential display using one-base anchored oligodT primers. Nucleic Acids Rex 22, 5763,5764. 8. Yeatman, T. J. and Mao, W. (1995) Identification of a differentially-expressed message associated with colon cancer liver metastasis using an improved method of differential display. Nucleic Acids Rex 23,4007,4008. 9. Trentmann, S. M., van der Knaap, E., and Kende, H. (1995) Alternatives to 35S as a label for the differential display of eukaryotic messenger RNA. Science 267, 1186.
Cloning of the 3’ Noncoding Regions from Several Members of Heat Shock Protein Gene Families by Differential Display Chandrashekhar P. Joshi and Henry T. Nguyen 1. Introduction Several structural and metabolically important proteins m eukaryotes are encoded by multigene families. For understanding the function of each member of a gene family, it is essential to isolate the representative cDNAs encodmg the protein of interest. In the past, this has been especially difficult owing to highly similar protein coding region of the cDNAs from a gene family with minute variations in then ammo acid composition. The 3’ noncoding regions from different members of a gene family, however, show sufficient heterogeneity that can be harnessed for the isolation and characterization of different members of a gene family. Higher plant genes offer a special advantage because the 3’ noncoding regions of their cDNAs are generally shorter than 300 bp m length (1). Plant cDNAs are, therefore, easily amenable to dtfferential display analysis. We are interested m understanding the functions of different heat shock proteins that belong to multigene families m crop plants (2). In response to heat stress,several heat shock protem (HSP) genes are actively transcribed and preferentially translated (3). HSPs belong to two major groups namely high-molwt HSPs (60-100 kDa) and low-mol-wt HSPs (15-30 kDa) that are further subclassified mto several HSP families depending on their observed/expected molecular masses. In most cases, each subclass of HSPs is encoded by a multigene family of 3-15 members. In general, these HSPs are proposed to perform the protective functions as molecular chaperones before, during and after heat shock treatments (4). However, the function of each of these HSP members belonging to multigene families is largely unknown From
Methods m Molecular Bology, Vol 85 D/fferenbat Edlted by P Llang and A B Pardee Humana
107
D/splay Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
Joshi and Nguyen
108 mRNA population
Tl2VA ----
T12VC T12VG Tl2VT
CH
CHCHCH I
Reverae Transcription I
(dNTPs, MMLV RT, Tl2VN
Flmt Strand
cDNA
primer)
I
I I
synthdc
I lssm
N, HSP16.9primer)
40 cycles
Loading on DNA Sequencing gel and electrophoresis *
t Autoradiography
Fig. 1. Schematicdiagram of modified differential display.
We successfully applied a simple modification of differential display technique for the isolation of 3’ noncoding regions from several members of gene families encoding HSP16.9, HSP26.6 and HSP70 in wheat (5-7). We replaced the arbitrary 5’ primer in conventional differential display (8,9) with a conserved HSP gene-family specific primer and have isolated cDNAs representing several HSP family members (see Fig. 1). In this chapter, we describe the detailed procedure used in our laboratory to isolate these cDNAs that includes: (1) growth of wheat seedlings and heat shock treatment; (2) isolation of total RNA; (3) DNase treatment of total RNA; (4) reverse transcription of m.RNAs; (5) synthesis of gene family specific primer; (6) differential display by radioactive PCR and polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis; (7) reamplification of cDNA probes; (8) cloning of cDNA probes; and (9) characterization of cDNA clones. Although the current application describes the use of modified differential display for HSP gene families in wheat, it can also be easily applied to clorie any multigene family members from other plant species (Joshi, unpublished observations). 2. Materials 2.1. Plant Material 1. Wheat (Triticum aestivum L.) cultivar “Mustang” seeds. 2. Controlled growth chamber.
3’ Noncoding Regions
109
2.2. RNA Extraction 1 Guamdme buffer (GB): 8M guamdme hydrochloride, 20 rnJ4 MES (2-[NMorpholino] ethanesulfonic acid), 20 mM EDTA, 50 mM mercaptoethanol (BME), pH 7.0 (see Note 1). Make fresh. 2 Phenol/chloroform/isoamyl alcohol (PCI) mixture (25/24/l v/v), store at 4°C 3. Chloroform/isoamyl alcohol mixture (24: 1 v/v), store at 4°C. 4. 100% Ethanol, store at -20°C . 5. IA4 Acetic acid, store at 4°C 6 3M Sodmm acetate pH 5.2, store at room temperature. 7. 70% Ethanol, store at 4°C 8. Diethyl pyrocarbonate (DEPC) treated sterile H20.
2.3. DNase Treatment All the components required for this experiment are available as a single kit (Messageclean, M60 1) from GenHunter Corporation, Nashville, TN. Individual components of the kit stored at -20°C are listed below: 1. 10X reaction buffer: 100 mM Trts-HCl, pH 8.4, 500 mA4 KCl, 15 mM MgC12, 0.01% gelatin. 2. DNase I* 10 U/pL In addition,
the following
materials
are also required.
3. 95% Ethanol store at -20°C. 4. Phenol: chloroform mixture (3: 1) store at 4°C. 5. 3M Sodium acetate, pH 5 2, store at room temperature
2.4. Reverse
Transcription
All components required for differential display experiment are available as a single kit @NAtnap, M50 1) from GenHunter Corporation, Nashville, TN, and should be stored at -20°C. Individual components of the kit in thts section are listed below: 1. 5X RT buffer: 250 mMTris-HCl, pH 8.3,375 mMKCl,l5 mMMgCl,, 25 mMDTT. 2. dNTP 250 pA4. 3. T,,VN primers (10 l.tA4)mcluding T12VA, T,,VC, T,,VG, T,,VT 4. MMLV Reverse transcrtptase (RT): 100 U/pL.
2.5. Gene Family-Specific Gene family-specific
2.6. Differential
primers:
Primer Synthesis 4-5 l..uW.Store at -20°C
until use.
Display
Individual components of the kit stored at -2O”C, RNAmap (M50 1, GenHunter) used in this section are listed below: 1. 10X PCR buffer: 100 mM Trts-HCl, pH 8.4, 500 mM KCl, 15 mM MgCl*, 0.01% gelatm.
Josh/ and Nguyen
110 2 dNTP (25 /.&!).
3. Gene family-specific primer (4 w 4. T,,VN primers (2 j.uV) In addition, the following materials are also required. 5 6. 7. 8
35S dATP (1200 Wmmole) AmpliTaq polymerase (Perkin Elmer) Mineral oil DNA loading dye 95% formamide, 10 WEDTA, pH 8.0,0.09% xylene cyanol, 0 09% bromophenol blue 9 DNA sequencing gel and electrophoresls apparatus, gel dryer 10 X-ray film
2.7. Reamplification of cDNAs Individual components of the kit, RNAmap M50 1 (GenHunter Corporation) used m this section are listed as follows* 1. 2. 3 4
Materials listed m Section 2.6. Glycogen 10 mg/mL. 3M Sodium acetate. Ice-cold ethanol.
2.8. Cloning of cDNAs PCR-Trap kit (P404) from GenHunter used for this se&on. The individual components are listed below: 1. pCR-Trap vector precut with restriction enzyme that produces blunt ends. 2 1OX Ligation buffer: 500 mA4 Tns-HCl, pH 7 8, 100 mA4 MgCl,, 100 mM DTT, 10 mMATP, 500 pg/mL BSA. 3 T4 DNA hgase (200 U/pL). 4. Competent bacterial cells. 5. LB liquid medium (10 g bacto tryptone, 5 g yeast extract, 9 g NaCI, and 15 g bactoAgar per liter) and LB-tetracycline solid medium plates 6 Colony lysis buffer TE buffer with 0.1% Tween-20 7 10X PCR buffer 100 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8 4, 500 mA4 KCl, 15 mM MgC&, 0 0 1% gelatin 8 250 MdNTP.
9 Lgh primer (2 @4), CGACAACACCGATAATC 10 Rgh primer (2 CIM), GACGCGAACGAAGCAAC 11 AmpliZ’uq Polymerase (Perkin Elmer, Foster City, CA).
2.9. Characterization
of cDNA C/ones
1 Sequenase Version 2 0 kit from United States Blochemlcals (Cleveland, OH) 2. AldSeq Kit C (cat. no P203) from GenHunter including Lseq (ATCACG-
AGGCCCTTTCG) and Rseq (GATACTGGACGCGAGCC) primers (1 @!)
3’ Noncoding Regions
111
3. Methods 3.7. Heat Shock Treatment
of Wheat Seedlings
1. Grow seedlmgs of winter wheat cultivar “Mustang” for 10 d m 50-mL pots of motst vermiculite at 22 k 2°C under a fluorescent light bank provtdmg 300 pm01 PPFD m-* s-i with a 12-h photopertod Relative humidtty should be about 30% on an average 2. Expose IO-d-old seedlings to heat stress at 37°C for l-2 h m a controlled growth chamber with 100% relative humidity. High humidity should be maintained m order to limit transptrattonal coolmg of the leaves. 3 After heat shock, excise the leaf tissue and freeze it immediately m hqutd N, and keep at -75°C for total RNA tsolatton. Leaf tissues of 10 d seedlmgs grown as described above but not heat shocked should be used as control samples
3.2. Total RNA Isolation from Control and Heat Shocked Wheat Seedlings Isolate total RNA from 5-g control and heat-shocked leaf tissues by the Guamdme
hydrochloride
extraction method described by Logematm
et al. (10)
with minor modifications as described below although other methods of RNA extraction are found to be equally successful (Joshi, unpublished observation). 1. Freeze seedling tissue of interest (approx 5 0 g) in liquid N2 and grind frozen tissue to a fine powder using precooled mortar and pestle Grind the tissue two more times with extra liquid mtrogen. 2 Add 2 vol of GB (2 mL for every gram of tissue) (approx 10 mL ) to the ground ttssue and mix it well with a sterile spatula. 3. Add 1.Ovol(2 mL for every gram of tissue) of PC1 mixture (approx 10 mL) to the mortar and mtx it well with a sterile spatula Carefully transfer the contents (green slurry) to a 50-mL Nalgene tube ( or any chloroform resistant centrifuge tube) 4. Centrifuge for 20 min at 10,OOOg 5 Collect aqueous yellowish phase and put it m a clean 50-mL Nalgene tube Use miracloth to filter the aqueous phase if floating debris is present 6. Add 1 vol of chloroform/isoamyl alcohol (24: 1 v/v) mixture and mix by inversion 7 Centrifuge the tubes for 10 min at 10,OOOg 8. Collect the aqueous phase (approx 15 mL) and place tt in a 30-mL glass tube. 9 Add 0 2 vol of 1M acetic acid (approx 3 mL) and mix the contents by inversion 10 Add 0.7 vol of precooled ethanol (approx 10.5 mL). 11 Cover the tubes with paratilm and gently mix by inverston. Total RNA 1sprecipitated and DNA/proteins stay m solution. 12. Store for 1 h or more at -70°C. If any DNA fibers are observed floating m the completely thawed solution, spool them out on a sterile glass loop and discard the DNA. 13. Pellet total RNA by centrifuging for 10 min at 10,OOOg. Thts should result in a large and white pellet. Discard the supernatant 14. Wash the RNA pellet twice with 5 mL of sterile 3M sodium acetate (pH 5.2) at room
temperature
to remove
low molecular
weight
RNAs
and contaminatmg
112
15 16 17 18
Josh/ and Nguyen polysacchartdes. Subsequently, wash the RNA pellet once wtth 70% ethanol to remove the salts After every wash, tubes must be centrifuged for 5 mm at 10,OOOg and supernatant 1s discarded. An dry the RNA pellet for approx 1O-l 5 mm at room temperature. Dissolve the pellet m stenle DEPC treated H,O (approx 400-500 pL, target 4 pg/pL) Transfer the contents to sterile 1 5-mL Eppendorf tube Check the RNA concentratron and quality by spectrophotometer. Also run a denaturing Agarose gel to check the mtegrtty and quality of RNA A Northern blot analysts may be performed followmg the method described by Joshi et al (6) to confirm that the total RNA isolated is of a best quality and free of any impurities
3.3. Removal of Genomic DNA Contamination from the Total RNA With any method of total RNA extraction there is always some possibility that traces of genomic DNA contaminants are prectpttated along wtth total RNA isolated. This genomic DNA could act as template for reverse transcrtp-
tion independent amphfication of DNA bands that may or may not be dtfferentially expressed. This contamination also increases proportions of RAPDs (random
amplified
polymorphtc
DNAs)
that are undesirable
in differential
display experiments (II). It is therefore, essential to remove this genomic DNA by using good quality
of DNase that is not contaminated
with RNase
This is
achieved in this step. (Use Message Clean kit [cat. no. M601] [GenHunter Corporation] .) 1. For DNase I Dtgestion m a 0.5-mL tube, add the following m the same order Total RNA 50 0 /.lL (-50 pg) 10X Reaction buffer 57ccc DNase I (10 U/pL) 1ociL Mix well and incubate for 30 min at 37°C. Longer incubattons are not advisable. 2 Phenol/chloroform (3 1) extraction is performed to remove proteins, Add 40 pL of phenol/chloroform mixture. Vortex for 30 s. Let the mixture sit for 10 mm at room temperature. Spin tubes in Eppendorf mtcrocentrifuge at high speed (14,000 rpm) for 5 mm Collect the top aqueous phase 3 Add 5 pL 3M sodmm acetate and 200 pL 95% ethanol (dtluted with DEPC H20) to the aqueous phase from step 2. A turbid solution 1s immediately formed. Let the mixture sit for >l h at -80°C 4 Spin tubes for 10 mm at 4°C. Remove supernatant A white pellet 1s clearly visible. Wash RNA pellet with 0 5 mL 70% ethanol (made with DEPC treated water) Spm tubes for 5 mm Remove ethanol An-dry the pellet for 10 min 5. Redtssolve RNA m 50 pL DEPC- treated H20. The pellet dissolves easily 6 Quantttate RNA at ODpGOand adjust an aliquot to 0.1 pg/pL with DEPC-Hz0 Use 2 pL (0.2 ug) of DNA-free total RNA for reverse transcrtptron. Use the diluted RNA solutton only once and discard the remaming solutton. Do not dilute more RNA than requned.
173
3’ Noncoding Regions
3.4. Reverse Transcription of mRNA Dlfferenttally expressed cDNAs from control and heat stressedRNA samples should be visualized on sequencing gels (6% denaturing polyacrylamrde) followmg the methods published by Lrang and Pardee(8), Liang et al. (9), and Josh1et al. (6) RNAmap kits from GenHunter Corporation (Brooklme, MA) can be used for this purpose followmg the manufacturer’s suggestions.The entire procedure used IS briefly described below (seeNotes 2 and 3). (Use RNAmap no. M501 kit.) Thaw out the following components and set on ice. Set up four reverse transcription reactions for each RNA sample m four PCR tubes (0.5~mL size).Each tube contains one of the four different Tt2VN asfollows (V = A/C/G; N = A/C/G/T): For 20 p.L final volume. dH,O
94$
5X RT buffer dNTP (250 pA4) Total RNA (DNA free)
40&
T12m
(10 44
Total
16cLL 2.0 Ilc 2oN-
(0 1 !%W)
19op.L
1 Program your thermocycler 65°C for 5 min, 37°C for 60 mm, 95°C for 5 mm (store at 4°C until use)
2. 1 $ MMLV reverse transcriptaseIS addedto eachtube 10mm after at 37°C 3 Mix well quickly by finger tipping 4. At the end of the reverse transcription, spm the tube bnefly to collect condensatron 5. Set tubes on ice for PCR or store at -20°C for later use
3.5. Design and Synthesis of the HSP Gene Family-Specific Primer This is the most important step in this modified application. First, all available protein sequences encoded by a gene family from same or different plants should be assembled using amino acid sequence alignment programs such as ‘pileup’ from Genetics Computer Genetics sequence analysis package allowmg possible gaps (e.g., Fig. 2). A highly conserved region near the carboxyl terminal end of the protein IS selected including a stretch of 1O-l 5 ammo acids and cDNA sequences encoding that amino acid stretch should be collected and aligned using “ptleup” routine This will clarify if any particular region has third base degeneracy or different codons coding for the same amino acids are present in this region. A DNA sequence of 14-18 bp is selected for the primer synthesis on the basis of the following criteria: 1. GC content of the potential primer sequence should be 6&70%. 2 Degeneracy 1s limtted to thud base of codon although attempt should be made to reduce the degeneracy as much as possrble. Degenerate primers also work very
114
Josh/ and Nguyen 201
Tahsp266b Tahsp266a Mzehsp26x Pshsp21 Gmhsp22 Phhsp21 Athsp21
GGDGWWKERS GGDGWWKERS DGDGWWKQRS GGEDCWSRKS GGDDSWSSRT GKDDSWG RN .SDDSWSGRS
Tahsp266b Tahsp266a Mzehsp26x Pshsp21 Gmhsp22 Phhsp21 Athsp21
251 262 VIDVQVQ* VIDVQVQ* VIDVQVQ* VIDVQIQ* VIDVQVQ* VTDVEIK* VIDVQIQ*
250 LSSYDMRLAL VSSYDMRLAL VSSYDMRLAL YSCYDTRLKL YSSYDTRLKL YSSYDTRLSL VSSYGTRLQL
PDECDKSQVR PDECDKSQVR PDECDKSKVR PDNCEKEKVK PDNCEKDKVK PDNVDKDKVK PDNCEKDKIK
AELKNGVLLV AELKNGVLLV AELKNGVLLV AELKDGVLYI AELKNGVLYI AELKNGVLLI AELKNGVLFI
SVPKRETERK SVPKRETERK TVPKTEVERX TIPKTKIERT TIPKTKVERK SIPKTKVEKK TIPKTKVERK
Fig. 2. Multiple sequence ahgnment of the carboxyl terminal region from the avatlable plasttd-localized HSPs from various higher plants. The ammo acid sequence RKVID (printed in bold letters) was selected as a possible conserved ammo acid domain to be used for destgnmggene family-specific primer * denotesthe translation stop codon Tahsp266b. wheat HSP26,6b, EMBL accession no. x67328; Tahsp266a. wheat HSP26 6a, EMBL accessionno x58280; Mzehsp26x maize HSP26, EMBL accessionno L287 12, Pshsp21 pea HSP2 1, EMBL accessionno x07 187, Gmhsp22 soybean HSP22, EMBL accession no x07188, Phhsp21 petunia HSP2 1, EMBL accessionno x54 103 and Athsp2 1 Arabidopsts HSP2 1, EMBL accessionno x.54102
well but do produce higher percentage of false positives (6) Replacement of N (any base)by Inosme residue ISalso advisable 3. Conserved DNA sequence follows the potential pnmer region that could assist m quick tdentitication ofputative sequences of interest on performmg DNA sequencing 4. The distance between primer site and putative polyadenylatton site should not generally exceed 500 bp Special modificattons may be requtred for the amp&ication of the larger size of the differentially expressedcDNA
5. Other usual constraints (e g , nonpalindromtc
sequence) that are normal for
primer selection should also be apphed
Frg. 2 shows the example of the primer selection for the plasttd-localtzed low molecular HSPs in wheat that we have used m our laboratory. Fn-st all the available HSPs from this type of gene famtltes were collected and an ammo
acid sequence RKVID (highlighted) was selected that 1spresent about 9 ammo acids upstream of the translation stop codon. Also the 4 ammo acids followmg RKVID sequence (I.e., VQVQ) were also highly conserved at DNA and ammo
3’ Noncoding
Regions
115
acid sequence levels among all plastid-localized HSPs of higher plants and could be used as a signature of this gene family. This ammo acid sequence, RKVID also fulfilled all the conditions listed above and a primer sequence of 15 bp namely, SCGC AAG GTC ATC GAC 3’ (GC 60%) was synthesized m the Core Facility of the Institute for Biotechnology, Texas Tech University. Similarly a primer was designed that was a 15-mer of S’ACC GTC ACC GTG CCC 3’ sequence (GC content 73%) for targeting the HSP16.9 family of wheat plants (5) and a 14-mer degenerate primer 5’ GGN CCN AAR ATT GA 3’ was used for cytoplasmtc HSP70 family from wheat (6) It must be mentioned that only one gene family-specific primer in combmation with appropriate Tr*VN primer should be used in each radtoacttve PCR and reamplification reactions as described below. 3.6. Radioactive PCR with HSP Gene-Family Specific Primers Use of radioactivity and PCR in this step assiststhe easy detection of amplified product that could be present in very low concentration in the original RNA samples. Primer concentration of HSP gene-family specific primer is doubled to ensure the enough amount of primer 1savailable and the annealing temperature m PCR is reduced to 37°C instead of 40°C as used in the original method of differential display (81. It also must be remembered that HSP mRNAs are abundantly expressed m response to heat shock and differential expression of cDNAs expressing HSPs is almost guaranteed. Thaw out components listed below and set them on ice. Set up the PCR reactions at room temperature asfollows: Use 20 pL of final volume for each gene family-specific primer and anchored ohgo-dT primer combination (see Note 4) dHaO 10X PCR buffer dNTP (25 p~I4) Gene-family specific primer (4 CUM) T12w (10 $0 (Must be the same T,,VN used for RT) RT-mtx from Step I 35S-dATP (1200 Ci/mole) AmpliTaq (Perkm Elmer)
92& 20/J16& 2.0 pL 20/-J-
Total 1. MIX well by pipeting up and down. 2 Add 25 pL mineral 011. 3. Program the PCR machme as follows: 94°C for 30 s, 37’C for 2 mm, 72°C for 30 s (repeat these cycles 40 times), one cycle at 72’C for 5 mm; and then store at 4°C until use. 4 Use 3 5 $ of samples plus 2 pL of loadmg dye
Joshi and Nguyen
116
5 Incubate at 80°C for 2 mm tmmedrately before loading onto a 6% DNA sequencing gel 6 Electrophorese for about 3 h at 1500 constant voltage until the xylene cyan01 dye is 5-7 cm from the bottom 7 Expose gel to X-ray film after drying. 8. The DNA sequencmg gel should be dried without fixmg with methanol/acettc acid 9. Orient the autoradiogram and dried gel with radroacttve mk or fluorescent markers.
3.7. Reamplification
of cDNA Probe
1 After developmg the film (overmght exposure), orient the autoradiogram with the gel by aligning the radloacttve mk marks or fluorescent markers spots and staple them together Locate bands of Interest by markmg wtth a clean pencil underneath the film and by cuttmg through the film with a razor blade Handle the dried gel with gloves and save It between two sheets of clean paper Cut out the located band with a clean razor blade every time and pick tt up wtth a clean forceps 2 Soak the gel slice along with the Whatman 3M paper m 100 & dHzO for 10 mm 3 Boil the tube with tightly closed cap for 15 mm 4 Spm 2 mm at highest speed m a mlcrocentrlfuge to collect condensation and pellet the gel and paper debris 5 Transfer the supernatant to a new mtcrofuge tube Add m 10 pL of 3M NaOAC, 5 pL of glycogen (10 mg/mL), and 450 & of 100% ethanol Let the mixture sit for 30 mm m a -80°C freezer 6. Spin for 10 mm at 4°C to pellet DNA A small but dtstmct white pellet should be visible at this stage Remove supernatant and rinse the pellet with 200 pL tcecold 85% ethanol Spin briefly and remove the residual ethanol Air-dry the pellet for 5-10 mm. DNA will be lost if less concentrated ethanol is used 7 Dissolve the pellet m 10 pL of dHzO and use 4 pL for reamphfication. 8 Reamphficatlon should be done using the same primer set and PCR conditions except the dNTP concentrations are at 20 w (use 250 fl dNTP stock) instead of 24 wand no tsotopes added 40 pL reactton IS recommended. Use 40 pL final Volume for each primer set combmatton dHzO 204$ 1OX PCR buffer 4.0 pL dNTP (250 @4) 3 2 l.lL Gene family specific primer (4 l&Q 40& T,zm (10 W 40$ cDNA template from step 7 4.0 /AL AmphTaq (Perkm-Elmer) 04@Total 40.0 pL 9 Check to see if the size of your reamphfied PCR products 1s consistent wrth its size on the DNA sequencing gel (see Note 5). 10 Verify the probe by Northern Blot analysis as descrtbed m Josh1 et al (6,22)
3’ Noncoding Regions
117
11 Clone the cDNA probe using the pCR-TRAPTM clonmg system from GenHunter Corporation (cat. no P404) 12. Verify the cloned cDNA probe by Northern Blot and sequence the cloned cDNA 13, Clone the full length cDNA by screening a cDNA library followmg the standard procedure (see Note 6).
3.8. Cloning
of cDNA Probe
We have found that cloning of the small cDNA fragments with pCR Trap vector (GenHunter Corporation) IS very simple to do and success rate IS remarkably high. Use: pCRTrap no. P404 kit (GenHunter). 1 Set up Ligation reaction as follows: In a OS-mL tube add the following m the same order for a 20-pL ligation reaction. dHzO 10.0 pL Insert-ready pCR-TRAP vector 2ocLL 1OX ligation buffer 2.0 pL PCR product from step 8 (Section 3.7.) 50@T4 DNA hgase (200 II/&) 1.0 pL
2.
3 4 5 6. 7. 8. 9.
Total 20.0 pL Ligate the vector and PCR product for overnight at 16°C. For transformation, thaw competent cells on ice for 10 min Aliquot 100 pL of competent cell to 1.5-mL microfuge tubes and set on ice. Immediately freeze at -8O’C the unused tubes with competent cells for future transformatton. Add 10 pL of ligation mtxture to the tube containing the competent cell and mcubate on ice for 45 min with intermittent finger ttpping Heat shock the cells for 2 mm at 42’C and then set the tube back on ice Add 0.4 mL of LB medium and incubate the cell at 37°C for 1 or 2 h Plate 200 pL of cells on each LB plate containing tetracycline (20 pg/mL) Wait until the plate surface is dry, and incubate the plate upside down overnight at 37°C. Score the TetR colonies and save the plate at 4OC before further analysis For checking the insert size, use the colony lysis PCR method. With a marker pen, number each TetR colony (4-8 colonies per clone) to be analyzed on the plate. Ahquot 50 pL of colony lysis buffer into each numbered microfuge tube.
10. 11. Pick eachcolony with a cleanpipet tip, andtransfer the cells into the colony lysls buffer m the corresponding numbered tube. Take very little bacteria on the tip avoiding touching any other colony. Mix by careful pipeting. Spin at high speed for 2 mm and vortex on low setting for 2 s. 12. Incubate the tube at 95°C for 10 mm. 13 Spm the tube for 2 mm to pellet the cell debris 14 Transfer the supernatant into a clean tube. 15. Use it directly for PCR analysis or store at -20°C for future amplification (can be stored for at least 6-10 mo).
118
Josh/ and Nguyen
16 Perform PCR Reaction as follows For each colony lysate. dH,O 10 X PCR buffer dNTP (250 luz’I Lgh primer (2 ClM) Rgh primer (2 pA4) Colony lysate AmphTaq (Perkm Elmer)
17
18.
19. 20
(see Note 7) 102 l.lL 2occL [email protected]
2.0 pL 20@-
2.0 pL
Total 20 0 pL Mix well, add 30 p.L mineral oil PCR parameters used are as follows 94’C for 30 s, 52°C for 40 s, 72°C for 60 s (repeat these cycles 30 times), one cycle at 72°C for 5 mm; and then store at 4°C until use. Analyze 15-20 pL of PCR product on a 1 5% agarose gel with ethidmm bromide stammg The plasmid with insert should easily produce visible bands that are bigger than 100 bp Verify the insert size by comparmg the molecular weight of the PCR product before and after cloning The PCR product after colony-PCR should be 100 bp larger than the original PCR insert before cloning owing to the flanking vector sequence being amphfied. Purify each band from agarose gel and use it as a probe for Northern blot hybridization or screening a library. To avoid false positives perform southern blotting using a known probe from the members of the gene family as described m Josh1 et al. (6) (see Note 8).
3.9. Sequencing
the Cloned PCR Products
1 After a plasmid has been checked to contain an appropriate sized insert, the corresponding TetR colony should be restreaked to single colonies on a new LB-Tet plate This can be done by locating on the plate the colony marked with number and pickmg it carefully with a clean pipet tip Streak the cells on a new LB-Tet plate. Change to another clean tip and streak again on the new plate m order to obtain smgle colonies 2. Incubate the plate overnight at 37°C 3 Inoculate a single TetR colony mto a 5-mL LB culture and use 3 mL for plasmid mimprep The remammg can be saved as glycerol (50%) stock at -80°C. 4. The mmipreped plasmid can be sequenced using the usual procedure with Sequenase Version 2.0 kit (USB) according to manufacturers suggestions The sequencing primers Lseq (ATCACGAGGCCCTTTCG) and Rseq (GATACTGGACGCGAGCC) (GenHunter) are to be used for this process
3.10. Examples of Use Using this modified differential display technique for the identlficatton of several members of a specific HSP gene family, we have isolated eight mdivldual members of wheat HSP 16.9 gene family that has about 12 members (5).
3’ Noncoding Regions T12VA T12"CT12"G 123456789
119
TIZW
Fig. 3. Differential display pattern of the total RNA from control (lanes 1,3,5, and 7) and heat shocked (lanes 2,4, 6, and 8) wheat seedlings using a HSP 16.9 genefamily-specific 5’ primer (ACCGTCACCGTGCCC) and four 3’ anchored oligo dT primers namely, T,,VA, T,,VC, T,,VG, and T,*VT. Note the specific amplification of radioactive cDNA fragments only in the heat shocked samples. Lane 9 was a positive control where plasmid DNA from HSP16.9a was used under the identical conditions as described above. An amplified cDNA fragment of 270 bp is shown by an arrow. Reprinted with permission from Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Figure 3 shows one example of using the modified differential display technique for the study of differentially expressed cDNAs belonging to wheat HSP16.9 gene family. There is almost no amplification of cDNAs in control reaction indicating the successof using this approach in HSP research. We have also identified a gene-specific probe belonging to plastid-localized HSP26.6 gene family that is differentially expressed during heat shock between thermotolerant and
120
Joshi and Nguyen
therrnosusceptrble wheat genotypes. We have fkrther proved that this member 1s also genetically linked to heat tolerance m wheat by doing the cosegregation analysts (7). Using a degenerate primer for the HSP70 gene family, we have tdentified three putative members of a cytoplasmtc HSP70 multigene family from wheat (6).
4. Notes 1. Warning: Guamdme hydrochloride is toxic if inhaled; avoid breathing dust Potential health hazard. 2. The success of the Differential Display technique depends on the integrity of RNA. It must be free of chromosomal DNA contamination, Total RNA is preferred over poly (A) RNA due to the cleaner background signal, and easy purification and integrity verification 3. It is recommended that core mix without RNA template be made for each anchored ohgo-dT primer if several RNA samples are to be compared. This will mmimize pipetmg errors and keep the comparison as close as possible A control reaction using all other components of reverse transcription without addition of Reverse transcriptase for all the reactions is mandatory to confirm the reversetranscription dependent amplification of mRNAs 4. Make as much of core mixes as possible to avoid pipeting errors. Make 10 times the volume of the PCR core mix (without oligodT primer, gene family-specific primer and RT samples; add these reagents separately in each tube) for each of the pair of control and heat shock treatments (2 x 4 reactions per gene familyspecific primer and minimum one negative control reaction). Otherwise, it would be difficult to pipet 0.2 pL of AmpliTuq m each reaction. 5. 20 pL of PCR samples are run on a 1.5% agarose gel and stained with Ethidmm bromide. About 95% of the probes should be visible on the agarose gel after this round of PCR Save the remainmg PCR samples (20 pL,) at -20°C for clonmg. 6 Depending on the primer design the number of false positives varies For example, HSP26.6 and HSP70 primer design gave us more false positives than HSP16.9. Rarely, RAPDs with same gene family-specific primer on both sides of the cDNA resulted. One band could have more than one sequence and same sequence may be represented at different sites but with different polyadenylation site selection, the feature that is very common m plants (I). Sometimes, 5’ and 3’ ends of the cDNA sequence had appropriate primer sequences but the in between sequence did not match with expected gene family sequence Rarely, Northern blots did not show differenttal expression of selected cDNA bands. We believe that differential display is extremely sensitive technique that brings out the minute differences existmg m the mRNA population by magnifying the difference and northern blots detect only gross quantitative changes Other sensitive means of detection should be employed to differentiate between a real false positive and a putative positive signal. 7 It is recommended that core mix containing everything except colony lysate be made so that many colony lysates can be analyzed at one time 8. Sometimes tetracyclin resistant colonies have a smaller than expected insert incorporation because PCR product purification is not done before cloning. But
3’ Noncodmg Regions
121
band purlficatlon usmg Qmaqmck column (Qutagen, Chatsworth, CA) sign% cantly affects transformation efficiency
Acknowledgments We wish to thank Jeff D. Ray for insplrmg us to use dlfferentlal display for our heat shock protem research. Our colleagues Natalya Klueva, S Kumar, and Rama Joshi are profusely thanked for the discussions, encouragement and assistance. The financral support for this work was partially
provided by a grant
from US Department of Agriculture National research Initiative Grants Program (92-37 100-7903). References 1 Josht, C P (1987) Putative polyadenylation signals m nuclear genes of higher plants: compilatton and analysis Nucleic Aczds Res 15, 9627-9640 2 Nguyen, H. T. and Joshl, C P. (1994) Molecular genetic approaches to improving heat and drought stress tolerance m crop plants, m Biochemical and Cellular Mechanzsms of Stress Tolerance zn Plants (Cherry, J. H , ed ), Springer Verlag, Berlm, pp. 279-289 3 Josht, C. P. and Nguyen, H. T. (1995) 5’ Untranslated leader sequences from eukaryotic mRNAs encoding heat shock proteins. Nucleic Acids Res 23,541-549 4 Vterlmg, E. (1990) The roles of heat shock proteins m plants. Annu Rev PI Physiol and Pl Mol Biol 42, 579420. 5. Joshi, C P and Nguyen, H. T (1996) Differential display mediated rapid tdentificatton of different members of a multigene family, HSP16 9 m wheat Plant Mol Bzol. 31,575-584 6. Joshl, C P , Kumar, S , and Nguyen, H T (1996a) Application of modified differential display technique for the clonmg and sequencing of the 3’ regions from three putative members of wheat HSP70 gene family Plant Mol Blol 30, 641-646. 7. Joshl, C. P., Klueva, N, Morrow, K. J , and Nguyen, H T (1996b) Expression of a umque plastid-localtzed heat shock protem m genetically linked to acqmred thermotolerance m wheat, m preparation. 8. Liang, P. and Pardee, A. B. (1992) Differential display of eukaryotic mRNA by means of polymerase chain reaction. Sczence 25’7,967-97 1. 9. Ltang, P, Averboukh, L., and Pardee, A. B (1993) Dtstributton and cloning of eukaryotic mRNAs by means of differential display: refinements and optimization. Nucleic Acids Res 21,3269-3275. 10. Logemann, J., Schell, J , and Willmitzer, L. (1987) Improved method for the tsolation of RNA from plant tissues. Anal Blochem 163, 16-20 11 Williams, J. G. K , Kubehk, A R , Llvak, K J., Raflaski, J A , and Tmgy, S V (1990) DNA polymorphtsms amplified by arbitrary primers are useful as genetic markers Nucleic Actds Res 18, 1585-1588 12. Josht, C. P., King, S. W., and Nguyen, H. T. (1992) Molecular cloning of cDNA encoding water stress protem (WSP23) from wheat roots Plant SCL 86,7 l-82.
RC4D-Restriction Fragment Length Polymorphism-Coupled Domain-Directed Differential Display Giinter TheiBen and Achim Fischer 1. Introduction Since many life processes, such as development and reproduction, depend on differential gene expression, the spatiotemporal pattern of gene expression is of prime biological interest Accordmgly, the concepts of the mRNA differential display (DD) and RNA fingerprintmg techniques (1,2) promised a breakthrough in molecular biology, because they circumvented some severe limitations of traditional methods, such as differential screening and subtractive hybridrzatton, during the analysts of differential gene expression. However, it is not always necessary to detect the differential expression of potentially every gene in the genome, as is intended by RNA fingerprmtmg and DD. In some cases,interests may focus on the expression of genes sharing a certain conserved sequence motif, as is often the case with members of multigene families. To allow efficient expression analysis of such genes, a technique called “RFLP-coupled domain-directed differential display” (RC4D) was developed (3). To target amplification towards all members of a gene family, RC4D uses primers directed against a conserved region, henceforth called the family specific domain (FSD). In contrast to RNA fingerprintmg and DD, in the course of an RC4D experiment generation of amplicons of gene specific size does not depend on bmdmg of short arbitrary primers, but is accomplished by mtroducing an RFLP step. Therefore, long primers can be employed, avoiding deleterious effects to reproducibility due to the bmdmg behavior of very short primers. A second advantage of employing long PCR primers is the possibility to directly sequence reamplified bands followmg the cycle sequencing protocol, From
Methods m Molecular Biology, Vof 85 Dlfferentraf Edited by P Llang and A 6 Pardee Humana
123
D/splay Methods and Protocols Press Inc , Totowa, NJ
124
The/pen and Fischer
using one of the PCR primers as sequencing prrmer, whrch obviates the need of a clonmg step. In contrast to differential display, RC4D turned out to be hrghly reproducrble, whrch makes repetrtron of experiments drspensable. Another important feature of RC4D 1sIts semrquantrtatrve character: as opposed to DD, the difference m mtensrty of a particular band between two lanes on the autoradrograph IS strongly correlated wrth the srgnal strengths seen on Northem blots (3). The working strategy of RC4D can be seen m Frg. 1 Selectrvrty for a gene family of choice IS provrded by amphfymg cDNA pools from the tissues to be compared with PCR primers directed against the respective conserved family specific domain (FSD) and against the non-T-extension of the cDNA prrmer. For the mtroduction of RFLP, the mixture of amphfied family member cDNAs is then Incubated wrth a surtable frequent cutting restrrctton enzyme. To restore a downstream primer bmdmg site for reamplrfrcatron, double-stranded linker molecules are ligated to the truncated amplrcons To get rid of nonltgated fragments and fragments not carrying a FSD, a second round of amplrficatton 1sperformed. After labelmg, the preparations are run on a sequencmg gel for srze separation. Differential bands are cut out, reamplrfied, and analyzed further. We have applied RC4D to the analysis of MADS-box gene expresslon m maize (3), but the procedure should be also quote surtable m other cases, Including expressron analyses of MADS-box genes m other species (for review, see ref 4) and of other multrgene families n-rall sorts of orgamsms, e.g., the famrlres of homeobox, steroid receptor (5), and heat-shock factor or ETS domain genes (6) in plants and ammals. Possrble applrcatrons of RC4D Include mutant analysis, whenever a certam gene family 1ssuspected to be mvolved m the observed mutant phenotype, as well as the lsolatron of new members of a known gene family Aberrant splrce products can also be detected by RC4D (our unpublished results). Another attractrve apphcatron of RC4D m developmental biology would be to record the expression pattern of a family of regulatory genes (e.g., transcrrption factors) m time. Doing so could unvetl a temporal network of gene actrvrtres, whrch might be useful to define certain stages of development more precisely by molecular events than 1s possrble by only observmg morphologrcal alterations. 2. Materials 2. I. cDNA Preparation 1 10X reverse transcrrptasebuffer (7) 500 mA4 Tns-HCl, pH 8.15 at 42”C, 60 mA4 MgClz, 400 mA4 KCI, 10 mA4 DTT, each dNTP at 10 mA4 2. RNasm RNase mhlbltor (Promega, Madison, WI, 40 U/&) 3 RQl RNase free DNase (Promega; 1 U/&)
125
Domain- Directed Differential Display lIlRNA q 1st strand cDNA
KKIAAA Reversetranscription
cDNA pool
*+ l +
TTTTTT***** TTTTTT*+*** TTTTTT*****
FSD
PCR with adapter primer (* * * * *) and FSD primer (W) 4 AAAAAA*****
FSD Mixture of amplified family member cDNAs
1. Digestion with frequent cutter (arrows) 2. Ligation to double strand4 linkers 3. PCR with linker primer and nested FSD primer Link=
1
FSD Truncated family member cDNAs
1
Linear PCR with labeled nested FSDprimcr ( l )
Labeled fragments
d Autoradiograph
Electrophoresis
1. Cutting out differential bands 2. Reamplification. direct sequencing and tiuther analysis
Fig. 1. Flowchart representing the working strategy of RC4D. With permission from ref. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8.
Phenol, saturated with TE (TE buffer is 10 mMTris-HCl, ChloroformIisoamylalcohol(24: 1). 3M sodium acetate, pH 5.2. Ethanol (absolute; E. Merck, Darmstadt, Germany). 1 mMEDTA, pH 7.5.
pH 8.0,l mMEDTA).
The&m and Fischer
126 9 10 11 12 13
Ohgo(Dynabeads plus set of buffers (Dynal, Oslo, Norway). Dtethylpyrocarbonate treated water (DEPC-water) Reverse Transcrlptase M-MuLV (Boehrmger Mannherm, Mannhelm, Germany) Hybrid dT,,-adapter primer (7) S-GAC TCG AGT CGA CAT CGA T,,-3’ TE buffer: 10 mM Trts-HCl, pH 8 0, 1 n&’ EDTA
2.2, The RC4D Protocol 1 Lmker ohgonucleotides* synthesized on an Apphed Biosystems (Foster City, CA) 392 DNA/RNA synthestzer, deprotected overmght at 50°C and purified on NAP columns (Pharmacia, Uppsala, Sweden). BLl: 5’-ACT CGA TTC TCA ACC CGA AAG TAT AGA TCC CA-3’ BL2. S-TGG GAT CTA TAC TTT CAA-3’. 2 2X Trts/magnesium 100 mM Tris-HCl, pH 7 5,20 mM MgCl, 3 10X PCR buffer 670 mMTris-HCl, pH 8.8, 170 mM(NH4)S04, 1% Tween-20, 8 mkf MgCl* 4 1 mM dNTPs: Solutton of dATP, dCTP, dGTP, and dTTP each at 1 mA4 5 Outer FSD prtmer (or mixture of FSD primers), biotinylated at tts 5’-end 6. Paraffin oil. 7 ?‘aq DNA polymerase (Boehrmger Mannheim) 8 Adapter primer (7). Y-GAC TCG AGT CGA CAT CG-3’ 9 Streptavtdm coated magnetic beads plus magnetic separator for mlcrofuge tubes (Dynal) 10. Frequent cuttmg restriction enzyme: e.g , MseI (New England Biolabs, Beverly, MA), Hi&I (Boehrmger Mannheim). 11 Phenol/chloroform/tsoamyl alcohol (25 24.1) 12 Ethanol (absolute, E Merck). 13 TE buffer 10 mM Tris-HCl, pH 8 0, 1 mA4 EDTA 14 10X end-filhng buffer 500 mMTris-HCl, pH 8.0,60 mMMgCl,, 500 mMNaC1, 100 mA4 dithioerythntol, 400 pg/mL BSA. 15 T4 DNA polymerase (Boehrmger Mannheim) 16 T4 DNA Ligase (Boehrmger Mannheim). 17. 10X Ltgatton buffer I 250 mJ4 Trts-HCl, pH 7.5, 50 mA4 MgC12, 25% (w/v) polyethylene glycol8000,5 mM DTT, 4 mA4 ATP (8). 18 QiaQuick spm columns, accompamed by PB buffer (Qtagen, Hilden, Germany) 19. Inner (nested) FSD primer (or mixture of primers) 20 T4 Polynucleottde kinase plus 1OX PNK buffer (Promega) 2 1 y[32P]dATP, 5000 Wmmol (Amersham, Braunschwetg, Germany) 22. Stop solutton (self-made [ref. 91 or from Promega’s fmol DNA sequencmg system) 23. Length standard; preferred range: approx 50 bp to > 500 bp (32P-labeled) 24 6% sequencing gel: 04 urea, acrylamide. btsacrylamide, 19.1. 25 1% acetic actd 26. X-ray film (e.g , Kodak X-Omat).
Domaln-Directed 2.3. Analysis
Differential D/splay
727
of RC4D-Products
1 Cycle sequencing mgredrents, e.g., thefmol DNA sequencing system (Promega). 2 10X PCR buffer. 670 mA4Trrs-HCl, pH 8.8, 170 mM(NH4)S04, 1% Tween-20, 8 mA4 M&l, 3. 1OX nucleotides for labeling (dATP, dGTP, and dTTP at 20 mM each) 4. Taq DNA polymerase (Boehrmger Mannhelm). 5. o[32P]dCTP, 3000 Wmmol (Amersham) 6 NICK columns (Pharmacta)
3. Methods 3.1. cDNA Preparation
(see Note 1)
Prepare total RNA from the tissues to be analyzed according to the guamdmmm chlorrde tsolatron method (9) Other methods may work equally well Determme the amount of isolated RNA spectrophotometrtcally. Check the integrity of RNA by hybrtdtzmg a Northern blot with a suitable probe hke, e g , GAPDH or Actm Dissolve 50 pg of ethanol precipitated RNA at 0.5 pg/pL m 1X reverse transcrtptase buffer For removal of residual genomrc DNA, add 5 pL RNase free DNase and 1 pL RNasm and incubate 15 mm at 37°C Extract samples once wtth TE-saturated phenol and once with chloroform/rsoamyl alcohol. Spin l-2 mm at 20,OOOg and transfer aqueous layers into fresh mtcrofuge tubes Add l/10 vol of 3M sodium acetate, pH 5 2, and 2 5 vol absolute ethanol, let stand overnight on ice For recovery, centrrfuge 30 mm at O°C and 20,OOOg Resuspend m 100 p.L 1 mMEDTA,pH75 Prepare mRNA by use of ohgo(Dynabeads (Dynal, Norway), accordmg to the manufacturer’s recommendatrons. For 50 pg of total RNA, use 200 pL of bead suspension (1 mg beads) After purrficatton, elutron of mRNA bound to the beads is done m 5 p.L Dynal elutron buffer Dilute 5 uT., of purified mRNA with 12 25 uL drethylpyrocarbonate (DEPC) treated water Secondary structures are resolved by denaturing for 3 mm at 65°C. Chill denatured mRNA on ice and add rt to 4.75 $ of an ice-cold reverse transcrtptase mixture contammg 2.2 pL 10X reverse transcrtptase buffer, 10 U RNasm, 12 U reverse transcrrptase (see Note 2) and 35 pmol of hybrid dT,7adapter primer MIX carefully and incubate the reactions at 42°C for 1 h, followed by 30 min incubatron at 52°C. Dilute cDNA preparations to 1 mL wrth TE buffer and store as “cDNA pools” at 4°C or at -20°C
3.2. The RC4D Protocol 1. For preparation of blunt ended linker molecules, combme 1 25 nmol of ohgonucleotrdes BLl and BL2 with 40 uL 2X Trrs/magnesmm in a total volume of 80 JJL and heat to 90°C for 3 min Cool down slowly to 4°C and store double stranded linkers at -20°C 2. For each cDNA preparatton, set up a linear amphficatton reaction using either a single primer bmdmg to the family specific domain (FSD), or employing a mix-
128
3
4.
5.
6 7.
8
Theipen and Ftscher ture of primers bmdmg to the same regton withm the FSD (see Note 3) Mix 5 pL 10X PCR buffer, 1 pL 1 mM dNTPs, 1 5 pmol of outer FSD primer and 1 p.L “cDNA pool” in a total volume of 50 & Overlay reactions with paraffin oil, put tubes mto a thermoblock preheated to 95”C, and add 2.5 U Taq DNA polymerase (see Note 4). After initial denaturation 3 mm at 95°C run 30 cycles with