Lecture Notes in Computational Science and Engineering Editors Timothy J. Barth Michael Griebel David E. Keyes Risto M. Nieminen Dirk Roose Tamar Schlick
48
Frank Graziani Editor
Computational Methods in Transport Granlibakken 2004
With 196 Figures and 23 Tables
ABC
Editor Frank Graziani Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory East Avenue 7000 Livermore, CA 94550, U.S.A. email:
[email protected]
Library of Congress Control Number: 2005931994 Mathematics Subject Classification: P19005, M1400X ISBN-10 3-540-28122-3 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York ISBN-13 978-3-540-28122-1 Springer Berlin Heidelberg New York This work is subject to copyright. All rights are reserved, whether the whole or part of the material is concerned, specifically the rights of translation, reprinting, reuse of illustrations, recitation, broadcasting, reproduction on microfilm or in any other way, and storage in data banks. Duplication of this publication or parts thereof is permitted only under the provisions of the German Copyright Law of September 9, 1965, in its current version, and permission for use must always be obtained from Springer. Violations are liable for prosecution under the German Copyright Law. Springer is a part of Springer Science+Business Media springeronline.com c Springer-Verlag Berlin Heidelberg 2006 Printed in The Netherlands The use of general descriptive names, registered names, trademarks, etc. in this publication does not imply, even in the absence of a specific statement, that such names are exempt from the relevant protective laws and regulations and therefore free for general use. Typesetting: by the authors and TechBooks using a Springer LATEX macro package Cover design: design & production GmbH, Heidelberg Printed on acid-free paper
SPIN: 11360605
46/TechBooks
543210
Contents
Part I Astrophysics Radiation Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics Chris L. Fryer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 1 Defining Radiation Hydrodynamics Terms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 2 Schemes Used in Astrophysics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 3 Astrophysical Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 4 SPH Radiation Transport . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 13 Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications I. Hubeny . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Description of Radiation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Absorption, Emission and Scattering Coefficients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Hierarchies of Approximations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 General Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Exact Numerical Solution . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae Anthony Mezzacappa, Matthias Liebend¨ orfer, Christian Y. Cardall, O.E. Bronson Messer, Stephen W. Bruenn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 The Core Collapse Supernova Paradigm . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 The O(v/c) Neutrino Transport Equation in Spherical Symmetry: An Illustrative Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Finite Differencing of the O(v/c) Neutrino Transport Equation in Spherical Symmetry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 The General Case: The Multidimensional Neutrino Transport Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Boltzmann Neutrino Transport: The Current State of the Art . . . . . 6 Previews of Coming Distractions: Neutrino Flavor Transformation . 7 Summary and Prospects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
15 15 16 17 20 24 26 32 32
35 35 40 42 55 59 63 65 67
VI
Contents
Discrete-Ordinates Methods for Radiative Transfer in the Non-Relativistic Stellar Regime Jim E. Morel . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 The Approximate Radiation-Hydrodynamics Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Discretization and Solution Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
69 69 69 73 80
Part II Atmospheric Science, Oceanography, and Plant Canopies Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media with Broad Spatial Correlations, Illustration with Large-Scale Transport of Solar Photons Through Cloudy Atmospheres Anthony B. Davis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction and Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Extinction and Scattering Revisited, and Some Notations Introduced . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Propagation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Multiple Scattering and Diffusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Large-Scale 3D RT Effects in Cloudy Atmospheres . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
88 96 114 122 134 136
Mathematical Simulation of the Radiative Transfer in Statistically Inhomogeneous Clouds Evgueni I. Kassianov . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Stochastic RT Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Statistically Inhomogeneous Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Ensemble Averaged Radiance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Validation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
141 141 142 143 144 146 147 148
Transport Theory for Optical Oceanography N.J. McCormick . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Aspects Requiring Special Computational Attention . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Computational Programs . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Computing Challenges . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
151 151 156 159 161 161
85 85
Contents
Perturbation Technique in 3D Cloud Optics: Theory and Results Igor N. Polonsky, Anthony B. Davis, Michael A. Box . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Definition of the Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Variational Principe to Derive the Radiative Transfer Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Perturbation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 A Toy Example . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Vegetation Canopy Reflectance Modeling with Turbid Medium Radiative Transfer Barry D. Ganapol . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Description of the LCM2 Coupled Leaf/Canopy Radiative Transfer (RT) Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 LCM2 Demonstration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Rayspread: A Virtual Laboratory for Rapid BRF Simulations Over 3-D Plant Canopies Jean-Luc Widlowski, Thomas Lavergne, Bernard Pinty, Michel Verstraete, Nadine Gobron . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Canopy Radiation Transfer Fundamentals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 The Rayspread Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
VII
165 165 165 166 167 168 170
173 173 180 196 210
211 212 219 227 228
Part III High Energy Density Physics Use of the Space Adaptive Algorithm to Solve 2D Problems of Photon Transport and Interaction with Medium A. V. Alekseyev, R. M. Shagaliev, I. M. Belyakov, A. V. Gichuk, V. V. Evdokimov, A. N. Moskvin, A. A. Nuzhdin, N. P. Pleteneva, and T. V. Shemyakina . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Statement of a 2D Transport Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Description of 2D Transport Equation Approximation Methods . . . 4 Description of the Space Adaptive Computational Algorithm for Transport Equation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Results of Computational Investigations of the Adaptive Method Performance . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
235 235 236 238 238 240 251 254
VIII
Contents
Accurate and Efficient Radiation Transport in Optically Thick Media – by Means of the Symbolic Implicit Monte Carlo Method in the Difference Formulation Abraham Sz˝ oke, Eugene D. Brooks III, Michael Scott McKinley, and Frank C. Daffin . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Radiation Transport in LTE . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 The Difference Formulation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Test Problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Summary and Directions for Further Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
255 255 258 261 268 277 280
An Evaluation of the Difference Formulation for Photon Transport in a Two Level System Frank Daffin, Michael Scott McKinley, Eugene D. Brooks III, and Abraham Sz˝ oke . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 The Equations for Line Transport . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Numerical Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Numerical Results in the Gray Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
283 283 285 289 295 304 305
Non-LTE Radiation Transport in High Radiation Plasmas Howard A. Scott . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Non-LTE Energetics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Radiation Transport . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Test Case: Radiation-driven Cylinder . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Linear Response Matrix . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
307 307 309 311 316 322 324 325
Finite-Difference Methods Implemented in SATURN Complex to Solve Multidimensional Time-Dependent Transport Problems R.M. Shagaliev, A.V. Alekseyev, A.V. Gichuk, A.A. Nuzhdin, N.P. Pleteneva, and L.P. Fedotova . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 327 1 Multiple-Group Transport Equation Approximation . . . . . . . . . . . . . 331 Implicit Solution of Non-Equilibrium Radiation Diffusion Including Reactive Heating Source in Material Energy Equation Dana E. Shumaker, Carol S. Woodward . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 353 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 353 2 Mathematical Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 354
Contents
3 Numerical Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
IX
355 359 368 369
Part IV Mathematics and Computer Science Transport Approximations in Partially Diffusive Media Guillaume Bal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Variational Formulation for Transport . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Transport-Diffusion Coupling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Generalized Diffusion Models . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A Local Second-Order Equation and Linear Corrector . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
373 373 375 389 393 398 399
High Order Finite Volume Nonlinear Schemes for the Boltzmann Transport Equation Barna L. Bihari, Peter N. Brown . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Background . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Discretization of the 3-D Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Numerical Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
401 401 403 405 410 420 421
Obtaining Identical Results on Varying Numbers of Processors in Domain Decomposed Particle Monte Carlo Simulations N.A. Gentile, Malvin Kalos, Thomas A. Brunner . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Description of the Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Ensuring the Invariance of the Pseudo-Random Number Stream Employed by Each Particle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Ensuring That Addition is Commutative . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . KM-Method of Iteration Convergence Acceleration for Solving a 2D Time-Dependent Multiple-Group Transport Equation and its Modifications A.V. Gichuk, L.P. Fedotova, R.M. Shagaliev . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Statement of a 2D Transport Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 KM-method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 MKM-method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
423 423 426 427 430 431 432
435 435 437 438
X
4 5
Contents
KM3-method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 439 Test Computation Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 440
A Regularized Boltzmann Scattering Operator for Highly Forward Peaked Scattering Anil K. Prinja, Brian C. Franke . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Generalized Fermi Expansion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Regularized Collision Operator . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Numerical Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
445 445 446 449 452 455
Implicit Riemann Solvers for the Pn Equations Ryan McClarren, James Paul Holloway, Thomas Brunner, Thomas Mehlhorn . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Pn Equations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Solving the Riemann Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 High Resolution Flux from Linear Reconstruction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Time Integration . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Implementation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
457 457 458 459 461 462 463 463 466 467
The Solution of the Time–Dependent SN Equations on Parallel Architectures F. Douglas Swesty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 A Brief Review of The Implicit Discrete Ordinates Discretization Method . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Iterative Approaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Speeding Up and Obtaining Convergence . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Parallel Implementation of the Full Linear System Approach . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Parallel Scalability of a 2-D Test Problem . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Conclusions and Future Directions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8 Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
469 469 470 472 475 481 483 484 485 485
Different Algorithms of 2D Transport Equation Parallelization on Random Non-Orthogonal Grids Shagaliev R.M., Alekseev A.V., Beliakov I.M., Gichuk A.V., Nuzhdin A.A., Rezchikov V.Yu. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 487
Contents
XI
Part V Neutron Transport Parallel Deterministic Neutron Transport with AMR C.J. Clouse . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Code Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Numerical Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Future Work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
499 499 500 508 511 512
An Overview of Neutron Transport Problems and Simulation Techniques Edward W. Larsen . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Physical and Mathematical Basics . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3 Basics of Stochastic and Deterministic Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Stochastic (Monte Carlo) Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Deterministic Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Automatic Variance Reduction (Hybrid) Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Discussion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
513 513 513 521 522 527 530 531 533
Introduction
There exist a wide range of applications where a significant fraction of the momentum and energy present in a physical problem is carried by the transport of particles. Depending on the specific application, the particles involved may be photons, neutrons, neutrinos, or charged particles. Regardless of which phenomena is being described, at the heart of each application is the fact that a Boltzmann like transport equation has to be solved. The complexity, and hence expense, involved in solving the transport problem can be understood by realizing that the general solution to the 3D Boltzmann transport equation is in fact really seven dimensional: 3 spatial coordinates, 2 angles, 1 time, and 1 for speed or energy. Low-order approximations to the transport equation are frequently used due in part to physical justification but many in cases, simply because a solution to the full transport problem is too computationally expensive. An example is the diffusion equation, which effectively drops the two angles in phase space by assuming that a linear representation in angle is adequate. Another approximation is the grey approximation, which drops the energy variable by averaging over it. If the grey approximation is applied to the diffusion equation, the expense of solving what amounts to the simplest possible description of transport is roughly equal to the cost of implicit computational fluid dynamics. It is clear therefore, that for those application areas needing some form of transport, fast, accurate and robust transport algorithms can lead to an increase in overall code performance and a decrease in time to solution. Besides the multi-dimensional nature of the transport equation, because of the coupling of particle transport to other phenomena the transport equation can in fact be non-linear. Hence, except for a few simple benchmark answers, the transport problem is solvable only via numerical methods. These numerical methods have developed and grown over the years and with the advent of massively parallel architectures, new scalable methods are being sought. Unfortunately, it is still true that in most computer codes, transport is the largest consumer of computational resources. In application areas that use transport, the computational time is usually dominated by the transport calculation. Therefore, there is a potential for great synergy; progress in transport algorithms could help quicken the time to solution for many applications.
XIV
Introduction
Consider for the moment, the details of particular applications where transport plays a role and it is clear the impact of solving the transport equation has on a variety of fields. In astrophysics, the life cycle of the stars, their formation, evolution, and death all require transport. In star formation and evolution for example, the problem is a multi-physics one involving MHD, self-gravity, chemistry, radiation transport, and a host of other phenomena. Supernova core collapse is an example where 3D, multi-group, multi-angle photon and neutrino transport are important in order to model the explosion mechanism. The spectra and light curves generated from a supernova have generated a wealth of data. In order to make a connection between simulation data and observational data and in order to remove systematic errors in supernova standard candle determinations of cosmological parameters, 3D, multi-group, multi-angle radiation transport is required. The simulation of nuclear reactor science poses a similar set of challenges. In order to move beyond the current state-of-the-art for such calculations, several requirements must be met: (1) a description based on explicit heterogeneous geometry instead of homogenized assemblies; (2) dozens of energy groups instead of two; (3) the use of 3D high-order transport instead of diffusion. These requirements would allow for accurate real-time simulations of new reactor operating characteristics, creating a virtual nuclear reactor test bed. Such a virtual reactor would enable assessments of the impact of new fuel cycles on issues like proliferation and waste repositories. With a 1000times increase in computer power, accurate virtual reactors could reduce the need to build expensive prototype reactors. In the broad area of plasma physics, ICF (Inertial Confinement Fusion) and to a lesser extent MFE (Magnetic Fusion Energy) require the accurate modeling of photon and charged particle transport. For ICF, whether one is dealing with direct drive through photon or ion beams or dealing with indirect drive via thermal photons in a hohlraum, the accurate transport of energy around and into tiny capsules requires high-order transport solutions for photons and electrons. For direct drive experiments, simple radiation treatments suffice (i.e. laser ray tracing with multi-group diffusion). Although the radiation treatment can be rather crude, direct drive experiments require sophisticated models of electron transport. In indirect drive such as at NIF, laser energy is converted into thermal x-rays via a hohlraum which in turn is used to drive some target. In order to accurately treat the radiation drive in the hohlraum and its attendant asymmetries will require a radiation transport model with NLTE opacities for the hohlraum. The ability to generate NLTE is a tremendous computational challenge. Currently, calculating such opacities in-line comes at a great cost. Typically, the difference between an LTE transport and NLTE transport calculation is a factor of 5. This fact has sparked research into alternatives such as tabulating steady state NLTE opacities or by simplifying the electron population rate equations so that
Introduction
XV
their calculation is fast. However, all of the alternatives suffer from drawbacks which inhibit their widespread use. In the coming years, simulations of NIF (National Ignition Facility) experiments will be crucial in attaining the goal of ignition. The simulations need to be predictive rather than after-experiment fits; therefore, high-order transport coupled self-consistently to other nonlinear physics is a requirement. With a 1000-fold increase in computer power, these types of simulations are feasible. In planetary atmospheres, cloud variability and radiative transfer play a key role in understanding climate. For example coupling clouds to the radiative transfer problem and representing their distribution and size accurately is a difficult problem where such methods as sub-grid scale methods are being applied. Tightly integrated to planetary atmospheres is the problem of radiative transfer and plant canopies and the oceans. For example, the 3D structure of vegetation is a key player in processes effecting carbon sequestration, landscape dynamics and the exchanges of energy, water and trace gases with the atmosphere. These examples are just a small subset of the applications where an accurate and fast determination of particle transport is required. Typically, the numerical methods used to solve the transport equation in a given discipline are communicated to other researchers in that discipline. Rarely are those methods communicated outside of that specific field. For example, nuclear engineers and astrophysicists rarely attend the same meetings. The seven-dimensional nature of transport means that factors of 100 or 1000 improvement in computer speed or memory are quickly absorbed in slightly higher resolution in space, angle, and energy. Therefore, the biggest advances in the last few years and in the next several years will be driven by algorithms. Because transport is an implicit problem requiring iteration, the biggest gains are to be made in finding faster techniques for acceleration to convergence. Some of these acceleration methods are very application specific because they are physics based; others are very general because they address the mathematics of the transport equation. In September of 2004, the Computational Methods in Transport Workshop was held at Granlibakken, California with the hope that these issues could be addressed by providing a forum where computational transport researchers in a variety of disciplines could communicate across disciplinary boundaries their methods and their methods successes and failures. The goal of the workshop was to open channels of communication and cooperation between all members of the computational transport community so that (1) existing methods used in one field can be applied to other fields (2) greater scientific resource can be brought to bear on the unsolved outstanding problems. The idea for the workshop was born at the SCaLeS (Scientific Case for Large Scale Simulation) meeting held in Washington D.C. in June of 2003
XVI
Introduction
and chaired by David Keyes. In attendance were a group of scientists, engineers, and computer scientists from a wide variety of disciplines whose charter was to demonstrate, from an applications standpoint, the need for new ultrascale computing facilities for Office of Science missions. A variety of breakout sessions were formed. One of these sessions, chaired by myself and Gordon Olson of Los Alamos National Laboratory, dealt with particle transport. The particle transport group consisted of experts from nuclear engineering, astrophysics, combustion, atmospheres, mathematics, etc. The discussions were lively and informative and it was soon realized what a wonderful opportunity this was to discuss transport issues with persons outside of specific disciplines. Conversations flowed between experts who would probably never meet in the normal course of doing research. The Computational Methods in Transport Workshop was created out of my hope that a forum could exist where researchers could discuss successes and failures of their methods across discipline boundaries in an invigorating and relaxing atmosphere that would benefit the transport community at large. Both executive and scientific organizing committees were formed with the goal of putting together a conference designed to stimulate discussion and interaction among attendees. With this goal in mind, talks were selected that gave attendees both an overview of transport issues from a wide variety of fields along with talks giving specialized detail. In addition, the workshop talks were purposefully chosen to be few in number yet fairly long in length so that speakers could communicate to the audience in a more effective fashion. The papers selected for the present volume have hopefully met both of these goals. Each author has put considerable work into writing a paper meant for an audience who although interested in transport, might not be an expert in plant canopies or supernova. My thanks to each and every author for writing papers of such high quality. The executive committee consisted of David Keyes (Columbia University), James McGraw (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory), and Stanley Osher (Institute of Pure and Applied Mathematics, UCLA). They provided invaluable advice and guidance of workshop logistics and finances and I owe them a sincere note of gratitude. The scientific committee focused on the technical issues of the meeting and it was comprised of individuals drawn from a variety of disciplines who had established themselves in the field of computational transport. My warmest thanks to Marv Adams (Texas A&M University), John Castor (Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory), Frank Evans (University of Colorado), Ivan Hubeny (University of Arizona), Tom Manteuffel (University of Colorado), and Gordon Olson (Los Alamos National Laboratory) for a job well done. A workshop like the Computational Methods in Transport Workshop would never get off the ground without financial support. In particular, because of the generous support of our sponsors, fourteen students were able to attend the meeting with all expenses paid. The workshop was jointly spon-
Introduction
XVII
sored by Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory and the Institute of Pure and Applied Mathematics at UCLA. Mark Green (IPAM, UCLA), Stanley Osher (IPAM, UCLA), Jim McGraw (LLNL), and Rob Falgout (LLNL) deserve singular thanks for their guidance and financial support. A special note of thanks goes to the administrative and support people who have made this workshop a reality. Leigh Faulk (LLNL), Anita Williams (LLNL), Linda Becker (LLNL), Janice Amar (UCLA), Karen Lee (UCLA), Linda Oribello (LLNL), Dave Parker (LLNL), Linda Null (LLNL) and Fred Allen (LLNL) performed nothing short of miracles. Finally, a word of thanks to the editors and staff at Springer-Verlag. In particular, Martin Peters and Thanh-Ha LeThi were of invaluable help and I appreciate their support and patience through this project. Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory July 2005
Frank R. Graziani
Part I
Astrophysics
Radiation Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics Chris L. Fryer1,2 1
2
Theoretical Astrophysics, T-6, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM 87545
[email protected] Physics Department, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721
1 Defining Radiation Hydrodynamics Terms Hydrodynamics codes are used to study nearly every astrophysical phenomena observed. Although coupling radiation and hydrodynamics is much less common, radiation hydrodynamics codes are being used in a growing number of astrophysics problems from energetic out flows of compact remnants such as core-collapse supernovae and active galactic nuclei to the formation of stars and planets to cosmological simulations of the first stars. In this paper, we review the current “state-of-the-art” radiation hydrodynamics techniques used in astrophysics. This review will cover both the techniques used in astrophysics (Sect. 2) and the problems that have been studied (Sect. 3). Most of the techniques are well-known in both the transport and hydrodynamics communities. The only surprises may be the rudemenatry level at which most working astrophysics codes do radiation transport. In Sect. 4, we will study in more detail the method used to do radiation hydrodynamics with smooth particle hydrodynamics, as it is less well-known and may prove a powerful tool to solve a number of astrophysics problems. What astrophysicists mean when they say they have a “radiation hydrodynamics” code varies from person to person. So before we begin this review, we must go through a few definitions. Radiation Hydrodynamics: By “radiation hydrodynamics” we restrict ourselves to those codes that, in some manner or another, solve both the Boltzmann equation and the hydrodynamics equations, coupling the results of both to determine the state of matter in a problem. By solving the Boltzmann equation, we include any technique, no matter how crude. This includes moment closure techniques as well as stochastic and direct discretization techniques. For most applications in astrophysics, this means flux-limited diffusion. By solving the hydrodynamics equations, in astrophysics this is almost entirely limited to solving the inviscid (Euler) equations. Similarly, I will loosely define “coupling these equations” to any scheme that combines the solutions of both these equations. In practice, this is generally done using operator split methods with a single or no iterations to enforce convergence. Working Astrophysics Code: By working astrophysics code, I mean codes that have been developed that have been used to solve an astrophysics
4
C.L. Fryer
problem and the results of these simulations have been published in the astrophysics literature. We do not consider codes that have only appeared in papers describing the technique without actually being run on an astrophysics problem. Parallelized Code: By parallelized code, I mean those codes that actually run on many processors, scaling reasonably well beyond 100 processors. This excludes codes that are parallelized by solving a different energy group on each processor (which for most astrophysics problems, limits the code’s use to 16-32 processors). We also exclude codes that can only be used on shared memory machines. Moment Closure vs. Direct Discretization vs. Stochastic Methods: The transport schemes in astrophysics can be loosely classified into three different categories: 1: Moment closure methods where the Boltzmann equation is represented as a series of angular moments and these moments are closed to form a solution. Both Flux-limited diffusion and variable Eddington factor techniques fit into this class. 2: Direct discretization of the Boltzmann equation. Probably the most common technique in this category used in astrophysics is the Sn method. This is often called “Boltzmann transport”. 3: Stochastic methods or Monte Carlo Methods. In astrophysics, the use of Monte Carlo techniques has, in the past, been limited to time-independent calculations (e.g. post-process).
2 Schemes Used in Astrophysics Although these definitions don’t seem restrictive, they exclude a lot of the techniques used in astrophysics: hydrodynamics schemes that put in radiation as a cooling term or use a “leakage” scheme to control the radiation transport through a dense medium (there are a number of problems, for example, in cosmology, where such schemes are sufficient to solve the current questions being addressed); and transport schemes that add in material motion, but do not actually solve the hydrodynamics equations (some very sophisticated transport techniques have been used to solve supernova spectra and stellar atmospheres where hydrodynamics plays a secondary role, and hence has been neglected in past studies). Transport Schemes coupled with hydrodynamics schemes include: 1: Pure diffusion schemes. These schemes are generally solved as 1-T calculations (one temperature describes both the radiation and matter). Although technically a simplified solution to the Boltzmann equation, we will not consider codes using these schemes further.
Radiation Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
5
2: Flux-limited diffusion schemes. These schemes are among the simplest of the moment closure techniques. A number of recipes (a.k.a. flux-limiters) are used in astrophysics to connect the diffusion and free-streaming limits of the transport equation. These schemes are generally implemented using 2-T (one temperature describing the radiation field and one temperature describing the matter) and have been solved both using single and multigroup energy discretization. This technique dominates what is used in astrophysics, especially in multi-dimension. 3: Variable Eddington factor schemes. This technique also uses moments of the Boltzmann equation, but closes at one higher moment using Eddington factors. The technique used to solve for the Eddington factors differs from code to code. Although initially used in pure transport problems, this scheme has been used in both 1-dimensional and 1.5-dimensional (transport along rays) radiation hydrodynamics schemes. 4: Sn transport. In general, most working codes using Sn techniques have been limited to 1-dimensional hydrodynamics codes, but at least 1 paper has been published showing results of a 2-dimensional simulation. For many astrophysics phenomena, pure hydrodynamics codes can provide a first order answer to a problem. Codes have been developed first modeling hydrodynamics only with transport schemes being added into these codes at a later time. Although this trend is slowly reversing (hydrodynamics schemes are now being coupled to transport codes) because the transport scheme dominates the computing time, at this time, most of the working astrophysics codes arise from hydrodynamics schemes with transport schemes added on top. The current range of hydrodynamics schemes coupled with transport techniques include most of the hydrodynamics techniques used in astrophysics: 1: Lagrangian techniques. In astrophysics, Lagrangian grid codes are used in 1-dimension, but most multi-dimensional Lagrangian codes use smooth particle hydrodynamics. A number of transport schemes have been coupled to 1-dimensional Lagrangian codes. Although coupling transport with smooth particle hydrodynamics takes some thought, it can, and has been done in (at least at the level of flux-limited diffusion). 2: Eulerian techniques. These techniques include both fixed grid and adaptive grid refinement methods.A number of transport schemes have been coupled to both 1-dimensional and 2-dimensional Eulerian codes. Fluxlimited diffusion has been coupled to 3-dimensional Eulerian codes. Astrophysicists have applied a number of these schemes in 1-dimension. In 2- and 3-dimensions, most of the work is limited to a range of hydrodynamics codes coupled to flux-limited diffusion. Below, we discuss specific codes applied to two of the current astrophysics problems best-studied using radiation-hydrodynamics codes.
6
C.L. Fryer
3 Astrophysical Applications Computational astrophysicists work using small steps, gradually increasing the level of sophistication on a given problem. Early models simulate only the most important physics to compare to broad features in the observations. But as the observations become more detailed, so must the codes. For example, early cosmological structure models modeled only the effects of gravity, focusing on the motion of the dark matter. But as observations of the baryonic matter became more detailed, hydrodynamical effects were added to the computer models. Now, to study the formation of the first stars, modelers must include the effects of radiation transport. Although most cosmological studies today can make progress with simplistic radiation routines like leakage schemes, there will come a time when the observational detail requires radiation hydrodynamics techniques. A number of astrophysical problems have already reached this coding requirement. Stellar atmosphere studies, which in the past have done some of the most sophisticated transport schemes in astrophysics using static atmospheres are now studying the effects of convection by coupling a 3dimensional hydrodynamics code with flux-limited diffusion [Stein & Nordlund 2003]. Klein and collaborators have studied a number of phenomena using radiation (usually flux-limited diffusion) hydrodynamic codes from neutron star accretion [Murray et al. (1995), Klein et al. (1996)] to molecular clouds [Sandford et al. (1982)]. However, we will focus our attention on the two fields that appear to be most actively pursuing radiation hydrodynamics in astrophysics: accretion disks and core-collapse supernovae. 3.1 Accretion Disks Many astrophysical phenomena are powered by the gravitational energy released when matter accretes onto a compact object: ranging from active galactic nuclei to X-ray bursts to gamma-ray bursts to planet and star formation. Even if the initial velocity asymmetries are small, as this matter falls down onto the compact object, centrifugal forces become increasingly important and the behavior of these phenomena is dominated by the disk of material that forms prior to the accretion phase. The wide variety of applications has led to a number of studies of disk accretion with increasing levels of sophistication. Portions of most of these disks are indeed optically thick (mean free path much less than disk scale height) and modeling the radiation transport correctly is important to many accretion disk problems. Although transport techniques ranging from leakage schemes through Monte-Carlo have been used to post-process disk calculations, the current state-of-the-art for production, radiation-hydrodynamics calculations in disks is limited to flux limited diffusion [Kley 1989, Turner & Stone (2001), Turner et al. (2003)]. These codes
Radiation Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
7
have mostly been run on shared memory machines with few nodes so it is unclear how well they scale to many processors with limited bandwidth. 3.2 Core-Collapse Supernovae In the past, the supernovae “transport experts” have worked on supernova light-curves. However, the transport schemes used in light-curve calculations are almost entirely limited to solutions of a steady state or uniformly varying medium. Only recently have radiation hydrodynamics codes (generally 1dimensional flux-limited diffusion hydrodynamics codes) been applied to this problem [H¨ oflich et al. (1993), Blinnikov et al. (2000)]. The results from these calculations are then post-processed to get detailed spectra. The supernova “radiation-hydrodynamics experts” are actually the modellers of stellar collapse (here the neutrino is the transport particle). Corecollapse supernova theorists came to radiation hydrodynamics by first focusing on hydrodynamics and including increasingly sophisticated transport techniques. These simulations have been at the cutting edge of computational astrophysics due to a boost from codes built at national laboratories in the sixties [Colgate & Johnson (1960), Colgate & White (1966)]. Core collapse supernovae are powered by the potential energy released during the collapse of the iron core of a massive star down to a ∼50 km proto-neutron star [Fryer (2003)]. This energy leaks out of the proto-neutron star in the form of neutrinos. The neutrino mean free path ranges from a few cm in the proto-neutron star to >100 km in the convective region where neutrino energy is deposited. Figure 1 shows a slice from a 3-dimensional simulation of a core-collapse supernovae. The three circles show the position where the optical depth out of the star is roughly 0.05 for the µ/τ , anti-electron and electron neutrinos (the innermost circle denotes µ/τ ; the outermost circle denotes the electron neutrinos). A number of techniques have been used to study radiation hydrodynamics in core-collapse supernovae. Tony Mezzacappa has developed some very nice diagrams that differentiate these codes. Using a simplified version of such a diagram dividing codes by spatial hydrodynamics dimension and tranpsort technique (Fig. 2), we describe some of the key codes developed and their relevant citation (recall that we limit our discussion to codes that have been applied to real problems): 1: In one dimension, a range of transport techniques have been added to both Lagrangian and Eulerian codes. Multi-group, flux-limited diffusion has long been used in stellar collapse [Bruenn et al. (1978)]. 2: Very sophisticated have been used in 1-dimensional codes. Discrete techniques (Sn method) have been around for over a decade and are said to be parallel although I have not seen scaling numbers [Mezzacappa & Bruenn (1993)]. The variable Eddington factor technique has also been used in
8
C.L. Fryer
Fig. 1. A slice in the x-z plane of the 3-dimensional collapse of a rotating (rotation axis is the z-axis) star. The shading denotes entropy and the vectors denote velocity (the vector length is the magnitude of the velocity and the direction denotes the direction of flow). The 3 circles denote the positions of roughly the τ = 0.05 surface for µ and τ neutrinos (inner circle), anti-electron neutrinos (intermediate circle) and electron neutrinos (outer circle). The neutrinos are in the diffusive limit in the proto-neutron star but pass through the transport regime into the free-streaming limit in the convective region where neutrino heating drives the explosion
1-dimension [Thompson et al. (2003)]. It has only been used in one paper, so it is not clear how well this technique truly works and it is not parallel. 3: Two-dimensional, single-energy flux-limited diffusion has been done for over a decade. The first simulation using such codes to model collapse through explosion was in 1994 [Herant et al. (1994)]. 4: Two-dimensional, multi-group, flux-limited diffusion is less common than in 1-dimension(2:). Indeed, the transport that has been done was not true 2-dimensional transport. The diffusion was followed along rays (no lateral transport) [Burrows et al. (1995)]
2
Variable Eddington Factor Discrete Methods
9
5
1.5 Variable Eddington Factor Along Rays Discrete Methods
Multi−Group, Flux−Limited Diffusion
1
4
1.5 Multi−Group Flux−Limited Diffusion Along Rays
3
Single Energy
Multi Energy
Multi Energy Multi Angle
Radiation Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
Gray Flux− Limited Diffusion
Gray Flux− Limited Diffusion
6
Fully Parallel
I
II
III
Neutrino/Spatial Dimension Fig. 2. Simplified Mezzacappa diagram of the radiation-hydrodynamics models used in core-collapse studies. The y axis shows the transport technique (singleenergy flux-limited diffusion, multi-group flux-limited diffusion, and more sophisticated techniques that include angular effects). The x axis denotes level of spatial (and purportedly neutrino dimension). Note that some 2-dimensional techniques only follow transport along rays. The numbers correspond to more detailed descriptions in the text
5: Some of the most intense research has been focused on sophisticated techniques intwo-dimensions. A variable Eddington technique has been developed [Scheck et al. (2004)] that follows transport along rays (no lateral transport). This technique is not extremely parallelizable (different nodes are given different energy groups to model). A discrete method has also been developed [Livne et al. (2004)]. Similarly, it has only been parallelized by putting different energy groups on different processors. Also, the one paper using this technique did not appear to run the simulation for many timesteps, and I suspect this technique will not be usable to do the full collapse problem (requiring 100,000 timesteps). 6: Three-dimensional, single-energy flux limited diffusion modelling the collapse through explosion was done using SNSPH [Fryer & Warren (2002)]. This code is fully parallel and has scaled nearly linearly up to 512 processors. This list of techniques far outstrips any other astrophysics field in radiationhydrodynamics codes. But the limitations are already evident. First note that there are few working codes able to model transport in more than 1 spatial
10
C.L. Fryer
dimension. Those that have passed our relaxed criterion for a “working code” are either not parallelizable, not truly multi-dimensional transport schemes or both. Indeed, the only true multi-dimensional radiation hydrodynamics code is limited to single-energy flux-limited transport. Astrophysicists have described much more sophisticated techniques (even at this meeting), but they have not put them into working codes, let alone parallelizable codes. There is a lot astrophysicists can gain from the transport community in making working codes.
4 SPH Radiation Transport One of the few working multi-dimensional radiation hydrodynamics codes in core-collaspe is a technique coupling smooth particle hydrodynamics (SPH) to flux-limited diffusion. The coupling, developed in 2-dimensions in 1994 [Herant et al. (1994)] and parallelized in 3-dimensions in 2002 [Fryer & Warren (2002)] has some twists to it and it is worth describing it in some detail. Much of this description is taken from a paper submitted to the Astrophysics Journal by Fryer, Rockefeller, and Warren (2005). 4.1 Transport Scheme In core-collapse supernovae, we model the transport of 3 neutrino species (l = νe , ν¯e , νx where νx corresponds to the τ, µ neutrinos and their antiparticles that are all treated equally). Because neutrino number is the conserved quantity, we transport neutrino number and then determine the energy transport by using the mean neutrino energies. The radiation transport scheme in our SPH code is modeled after the technique to calculate forces in SPH: we calculate symmetric interactions between all neighbor particles. Hence, our flux-limited diffusion scheme calculates the radiation diffusion in or out of a particle by summing the transport over all neighbors (the equivalent of all bordering cells in a grid calculation). The neutrino transport for particle i is given by: ij j j→i ∇W ij mj /ρj Λνl niνl bi→j − n b (1) dniνl /dt = νl νl νl j
and the corresponding energy transport is: ij j→i j j j→i ∇W ij mj /ρj Λνl iνl niνl bi→j − ξ n b deiνl /dt = νl νl νl νl
(2)
j
where niνl , eiνl are, respectively, the neutrino density and energy density in particle i for species νl, iνl is the mean neutrino energy, and ξ j→i is the redshift correction for jνl as seen by particle i.
Radiation Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
11
Λij νl is the limiter for the flux-limited transport scheme. The simplest such scheme for 3-dimensions is: ij ij Λij νl = min(c, Dνl /r )
(3)
ij j j i i = 2Dνl Dνl /(Dνl + Dνl ) is the harmonic where c is the speed of light, Dνl mean of the diffusion coefficients for the species νl of particles i and j and rij is the distance between particles i and j. This limiter was used by [Herant et al. (1994)] and, for comparison with that work, by [Fryer & Warren (2002)], but we have used a number of other flux-limiters, all of which are valid under this transport scheme [Fryer et al. (1999)]. Beyond some radius in a core-collapse simulation, neutrinos are essentially in the free-streaming regime where transport is not necessary (unless one wants to truly follow the radiation wave as it progresses through the star). We do not model transport beyond this “trapping” radius. Instead we sum up all neutrinos that transport beyond this radius and emit them using a lightbulb approximation. That is, the material beyond this radius sees a constant flux and we can determine the amount of energy a particle gains (dEi /dt) from neutrino interactions simply by using the free-streaming limit:
dEi /dt = Lν (1.0 − e−∆τi )
(4)
where Lν is the neutrino luminosity and ∆τi is the optical depth of a particle i. This assumption is only valid if the total amount of energy imparted ( i dEi /dt) from the neutrinos onto the matter is much less than the tothis, we determine this trapping radius tal neutrino flux (Lν ). To guarantee by evolving it with time such that ( i dEi /dt)/Lν is always less than some value. This value was originally set to 0.1 by Herant et al. (1994), but in recent calculations, we use 0.05. Such a scheme can be easily converted into multi-group, but such modifications have not yet been done. The scheme scales reasonably well on multiple processors (for a 5 million particle run, the code has scaled nearly linearly up to 256 processors on the Space Simulator Beowulf cluster and up to 512 processors on the ASC Q machine at Los Alamos National Laboratory). In part, this scalability is due to the explicit nature of the transport scheme. In general, explicit transport schemes strongly limits timesteps as the speed of light, not sound, constrains the duration of the timestep. In core-collapse supernovae, this constraint is not too onerous because the sound speed is nearly a third the speed of light anyway, so the explicit transport scheme leads to only a factor of 3 decrease in the timestep. But this explicit flux-limited transport scheme can be used in a much wider variety of problems where the mean free path is very short for the smallest particles. Such scenarios occur in many astrophysics problems.
12
C.L. Fryer
4.2 First Test Testing radiation transport schemes in general would, and has, comprised many papers in itself. Here we focus on a simple test comparing the SPH fluxlimited scheme to a 1-dimensional grid-based flux-limited transport scheme. This test does not prove the applicability of flux-limited diffusion to the supernova problem, but it does show that our scheme for putting flux-limited diffusion into SPH does work. For the initial conditions of this test, we use a spherically-symmetric neutron star atmosphere (material below 1014 g cm−3 ) for a neutron star roughly 130 ms after bounce. We map this structure onto our SPH particles, using the shell setup described in Fryer & Warren (2002). We make a similar setup in a 1-dimensional grid using one zone per shell of SPH particles. With this setup, we minimize the differences between the density and temperature structure of our 1- and 3-dimensional models. We determine the trapping radius to be 25 km. Below this radius, we set the electron neutrino fraction (Yνe ) to 0.15 with a mean energy of 10 MeV. Above this radius, Yνe is set to zero. Our test focuses on the neutrino transport alone; we evolve only the electron neutrino fraction with time and hold the density, temperature, and electron fraction fixed. We allow no new neutrino emission. The flux arising from
Fig. 3. Neutrino luminosity versus time for a cooling neutron star using a simple 1dimensional flux-limited diffusion scheme and the technique discussed here coupling flux-limited diffusion to smooth particle hydrodynamics. The initial discrepancy arises from the fact that diffusion occurs over all SPH neighbors, allowing transport across the effective (in a 1-dimensional case) of several radial zones (instead of 1 zone in the 1-dimensional transport scheme)
Radiation Hydrodynamics in Astrophysics
13
our neutrino trapping radius versus time for both our 1-dimensional grid simulation and our 3-dimensional SPH calculation is plotted in Fig. 3. The initial flux of the SPH calculation is higher, since the neighbors of any particle extend beyond the equivalent of an adjacent cell for the 1-dimensional calculation. In general, the luminosity for both these calculations agree to better than 3%.
References [Blinnikov et al. (2000)] Blinnikov, S., Lundqvist, P., & Bartunov, O., Nomoto, K., Iwamoto, K. Radiation Hydrodynamics of SN 1987A. I. Global Analysis of the Light Curve for the First 4 Months ApJ, 532, 1132 (2000) [Bruenn et al. (1978)] Bruenn, S.W., Buchler, J. R., & Yueh,W. R. Neutrino Transport in Supernova Models – A Multigroup, Flux-Limited diffusion Scheme Ap& SS, 59, 261–284 (1978). [Burrows et al. (1995)] Burrows, A., Hayes, J., & Fryxell, B. A. On the Nature of Core-Collapse Supernova Explosions, ApJ, 450, 830–850 (1995). [Colgate & Johnson (1960)] Colgate, S.A., Johnson, H.J., Phys Rev. Letters, 5, 573–576 (1960). [Colgate & White (1966)] Colgate, S.A., White, R.H. ApJ, 143, 626–681 (1966) [Fryer et al. (1999)] Fryer, C. L., Benz, W., Herant, M., Colgate, S.A. What Can the Accretion-induced Collapse of White Dwarfs Really Explain? ApJ, 516, 892 (1999) [Fryer & Warren (2002)] Fryer, C. L., & Warren, M. S. Modeling Core-Collapse Supernovae in Three Dimensions ApJ, 574, L65 (2002) [Fryer (2003)] Fryer, C. L. Stellar Collapse, International Journal of Modern Physics D, 12, 1795–1835 [Fryer & Warren (2004)] Fryer, C. L., & Warren, M. S. The Collapse of Rotating Massive Stars in Three Dimensions, ApJ, 601, 391–404 [Herant et al. (1994)] Herant, M., Benz, W., Hix, W. R., Fryer, C. L., & Colgate, S. A. Inside the Supernova: A Powerful Convective Engine ApJ, 435, 339 (1994) [H¨ oflich et al. (1993)] H¨ oflich, M¨ uller, E., & Khokhlov, A. Light Curve Models for Type Ia Supernovae - Physical Assumptions, their Influence and Validity A&A, 268, 570–590 (1993) [Klein et al. (1996)] Klein, R.I., Arons, J., Garrett, J., Hsu, J.J.L.: Photon bubble Oscillations in Accretion-powered Pulsars. ApJ, 457, L85–89 (1996). [Kley 1989] Kley, W. Radiation Hydrodynamics of the Boundary Layer in Accretion Disks. I- Numberical models A&A, 208, 98–110 (1989). [Livne et al. (2004)] Livne, E., Burrows, A., Walder, R., Lichtenstadt, I., & Thompson, T. A. Two-Dimension, Time-Dependent, Multigroup, Multiangle Radiation Hydrodynamics in the Core-Collapse Supernova Context, ApJ, 609, 277– 287 [Mezzacappa & Bruenn (1993)] Mezzacappa, A., & Bruenn, S. W. A Numerical Method for Solving the Neutrino Boltzmann Equation Coupled to Spherically Symmetric Stellar Core Collapse ApJ, 405, 669–684 (1993). [Murray et al. (1995)] Murray, S.D., Woods, D.T., Castor, J.I., Klein, R.I., McKee, C.F.: Radiation Hydrodynamic Models of Eclipsing Low-Mass X-ray Binaries ApJ, 454, L133–136 (1995).
14
C.L. Fryer
[Sandford et al. (1982)] Sandford, M.T., Whitaker, R.W., Klein, R.I.: RadiationDriven Implosions in Molecular Clouds ApJ 260, 183–201 (1982). [Scheck et al. (2004)] Scheck, L., Plewa, T., Janka, H.-Th., Kifonidis, K., & M¨ uller, E. Pulsar Recoil by Large-Scale Anisotropies in Supernova Explosions PRL, 92, 0111031–011034 [Stein & Nordlund 2003] Stein, R.F., Nordlund, A.: Stellar Atmosphere Modeling, ASP Conference Proceedings, Vol 288, Aug. 8–12, 2002, Hubeny, Mihalas, Werner (eds.). San Francisco: Astronomical Society of the Pacific (2003) p.519 [Thompson et al. (2003)] Thompson, T. A., Burrows, A., Pinto, P. A. Shock Breakout in Core-Collapse Supernovae and Its Neutrino Signature, ApJ, 592, 434– 456 (2003). [Turner & Stone (2001)] Turner, N. J., & Stone, J. M. 2001, A Module for Radiation Hydrodynamic Calculations with ZEUS-2D Using Flux-Limited Diffusion, ApJS, 135, 95–107 [Turner et al. (2003)] Turner, N. J., Stone, J. M., Krolik, J. H. & Sano, T. Local Three-dimensional Simulations of Magnetorotational Instability in RadiationDominated Accretion Disks ApJ, 593, 992 (2003).
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications I. Hubeny Department of Astronomy, University of Arizona, Tucson, AZ 85721, USA
1 Introduction Radiative transfer is particularly important in astrophysics. One reason is quite understandable: radiation is in most cases the only information we have (and will ever have) about distant objects (exceptions are detected neutrinos from the Sun and supernova SN1987a, and in a near future the gravitational waves). However, there is an even more compelling reason for the a need to deal with detailed radiation transport in astrophysics: In many astronomical objects the radiation is so strong that it significantly contributes to the energy and momentum budget of the medium. Therefore, radiation is not only a probe of the physical state, but is in fact an important constituent. In other words, radiation in fact determines the structure of the medium, yet the medium is probed only by this radiation. Unlike laboratory physics, where one can change a setup of the experiment in order to examine various aspects of the studied structures separately, we do not have this luxury in astrophysics: we are stuck with the observed spectrum so we should better make a very good use of it. All that puts heavy demands on proper radiation transfer techniques in astrophysics. Also, there are many different situations and physical conditions (e.g., temperature ranges from a few K to more than 109 K; there is a huge range of microscopic processes that give rise to an absorption or emission of a photon), so consequently there is a wide range of numerical techniques used for treating radiation transport in astrophysics. This paper is not aimed to provide a review of all or even the most important numerical techniques; instead it aims at outlining the outstanding problems and ideas behind recent numerical approaches. I also stress that although I talk about transport of photons, many methods can be used for treating transport of neutrinos, which is important for instance in numerical simulations of core-collapse supernovae. Typical objects for which the radiation transport is important are above all stellar atmospheres. In this field, most numerical techniques were developed that are now being used in other parts of astrophysics. Other objects are extrasolar planetary atmospheres (the solar system planets as well, but here we have a lot of direct information thanks to various planetary missions). Other important radiation-dominated objects are accretion disks of various kinds—around supermassive black holes (quasars and active galactic nuclei);
16
I. Hubeny
neutron stars (X-ray binaries); white dwarfs (cataclysmic variables), and even main-sequence close binaries. Transport of photons (and neutrinos at early stages!) is important in supernovae, and radiative transfer is important in curcumstellar structures like planetary nebulae and H II regions. Finally, radiation transport is also important in global cosmological simulations of large-scale structure of the Universe. The basic textbook of astrophysical radiative transfer is [1] but it does not cover modern and efficient numerical transport techniques. Another textbooks, with emphasis more on hydrodynamical aspect of the problems, are [2], and recent textbook [3]; both contain excellent discussions of radiation transport techniques. Recent proceedings that contains a number of review papers, and to which the reader is referred to for more information about modern methods used in astrophysical radiative transfer, is [4].
2 Description of Radiation In astrophysical formalism, the basic quantity describing the radiation field is the specific intensity of radiation, I(r, t, n, ν), defined such that it is the energy transported by radiation at position r, in a unit frequency range at the frequency ν, across a unit area perpendicular to the direction of propagation, n, into a unit solid angle, and in a unit time interval. The specific intensity provides a complete description of the unpolarized radiation field from the macroscopic point of view. The specific intensity is related to the photon distribution function, f , as I = hνc f (1) where h and c are the Planck constant and the speed of light, respectively. We note that the same quantity is called angular flux, and is usually denoted as ψ(r, t, n, ν), in the neutron transport theory. The transport (or transfer) equation is essentially the Boltzmann equation for photons, which can be generally written as Df ∂f + (v · ∇)f + (F · ∇P )f = , (2) ∂t Dt coll where v is the velocity, F is the external force, ∇P is the nabla operator in the momentum space, and the term (Df /Dt)coll is the collision term. In case of photons, v = cn, and F = 0 (in the absence of general relativistic effects). The transfer equation can then be written as 1 ∂ + n · ∇ I(ν, r, n, t) = η(ν, r, n, t) − χ(ν, r, n, t) I(ν, r, n, t) . (3) c ∂t where we write the collisional term in terms of the usual absorption coefficient χ and emission coefficient η. The equation looks simple, but this is deceiving.
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
17
The point is that χ and η generally depend on radiation intensity as well, moreover in a complex non-linear and non-local fashion. We shall return to this point in the next section. We also note that it is common in astrophysical applications to introduce the optical depth along a given direction as dτ = χds, and the source function as η (4) S≡ . χ
3 Absorption, Emission and Scattering Coefficients The absorption and emission coefficients are introduced phenomenologically, and are defined analogously to the specific intensity, namely as the energy removed or added to a beam of radiation at unit frequency range, solid angle, area, and time. It is customary to split them into two parts, χ = κth + κsc ,
(5)
η = η th + η sc ,
(6)
and where κth represents the true absorption (a process where a photon is absorbed and subsequently destroyed by a thermal process such as a collisional de-excitation); κsc is the scattering coefficient (a photon is absorbed and subsequently re-emitted). Similarly, η th is the coefficient of thermal emission (a photon is created at the expense of the thermal pool); and η sc is the scattering part of the emission coefficient, corresponding to emission of a photon following previous absorption. Scattering absorption coefficient may be written as nα σα (ν) , (7) κsc (ν) = α
where the summation extends over all species α that do scatter radiation, nα is the number density, and σα the corresponding cross-section. For instance, for hot star atmospheres (spectral types O and B), the dominant, and usually the only scattering process that is considered is the electron (Thomson) scattering, in which case nα σα (ν) = ne σe ; ne being the electron density, and σe the Thomson cross-section. For even hotter objects (e.g., hot accretion disks, T ≈ 105 K and higher), the dominant scattering process is the Compton scattering. For cooler stars (A, F, G), the Rayleigh scattering on atomic hydrogen (and helium) becomes important; for even cooler stars Rayleigh scattering on the hydrogen molecule H2 and other molecules is important, and for coolest stars and substellar mass objects (brown dwarfs and giant planets), scattering on cloud (dust) particles becomes dominant. The scattering part of the emission coefficient may be written as
18
I. Hubeny
η sc (ν) =
dν
dΩ I(ν , n )Rα (ν , n , ν, n) ,
(8)
α
where R is the redistribution function, which has the meaning of the probability density that a photon is absorbed at frequency ν and direction n (within appropriate unit intervals around these values), and re-emitted at ν and n. The scattering part of the emission coefficient is the culprit behind most of the numerical complexity of the transfer problem. It makes the problem pathologically implicit because in order to solve the transfer equation we need to know the emission efficient, but it (or at least its scattering part) is a function of the specific intensity; moreover it couples many frequencies and directions. However, although η sc is the most troubling part of the problem, we shall show that all the other coefficients do also generally depend on radiation field, and usually in a complex non-local and non-linear way. From the point of view of microscopic physics, one can write down the absorption and emission coefficients as follows (we only indicate the dependence on frequency, and omit an indication of their dependence on position and time) ni − n∗i e−hν/kT σiκ (ν) [ni − (gi /gj )nj ] σij (ν) + κth (ν) = i
j>i
+
i
ne nκ σκκ (ν, T ) 1 − e−hν/kT , (9)
κ
where the three terms represent, respectively, the contributions of boundbound transitions (i.e. spectral lines), bound-free transitions (continua), and free-free absorption (also called bremsstrahlung). Here, ni is the occupation number (population) of an atom in the energy level labeled i, gi the corresponding statistical weight, and n∗i denotes an equilibrium population of level i corresponding to temperature T , and density ρ. σ(ν) are the corresponding cross-sections; subscript κ denotes the “continuum,” and nκ the ion number density. The relation between the bound-bound cross section σij (ν) and the well-known Einstein coefficients for the for the photo-excitation is σij (ν) = (hν0 /4π)Bij φ(ν); φ(ν) is the so-called absorption profile coefficient, normalized to unity, φ(ν) dν = 1. It represents the conditional probability density that if a photon is absorbed in the transition i → j, it is absorbed in the frequency range (ν, ν + dν). Analogously, the thermal emission coefficient is given by ⎡ 3 2hν nj (gi /gj )σij (ν) + n∗i σiκ (ν)e−hν/kT η th (ν) = 2 ⎣ c i j>i i −hν/kT + ne nκ σκκ (ν, T )e . (10) κ
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
19
The three terms again describe the bound-bound, bound-free, and free-free emission processes, respectively. The absorption and emission coefficients are thus described through the corresponding cross sections—given by the atomic physics, and possibly also by the local thermodynamic parameters, temperature and density; and the atomic level populations for all the levels involved in the microscopic processes that give rise to an absorption and emission at frequency ν. Their number may be enormous. Here is the essential complication. One can either assume the Local Thermodynamic Equilibrium (LTE), in which case the level populations are given through the Saha-Boltzmann formula, i.e. ni = n∗i (T, ρ), so that the thermal absorption and emission coefficient are functions of only temperature and density. However, in many cases of interest, the LTE approximation breaks down, and one has to determine the atomic level populations by a set of statistical equilibrium (rate) equations. For a given level i, the rate equation reads (for simplicity, we consider here the time-independent form; the general form would contain additional terms (1/c)(∂ni /∂t) + ∇ · (vni )). ni (Rij + Cij ) = nj (Rji + Cji ) , (11) j=i
j=i
where Rij is the rate of radiative transition from level i to level j, Cij is the analogous collisional rate. Equation (11) thus expresses the principle of statistical equilibrium, namely that the total number of transitions out of level i is equal to the total number of transitions into level i (we note that if this is satisfied for all microscopic processes i ↔ j we recover LTE). The essential complication arises due to the fact that while the collisional rates are functions of temperature and perturber density only, the radiative rates are given by 4π σij (ν) I(ν, n) , (12) Rij = dν dΩ hν (and analogously for the downward rate); that is, the level populations that are needed for evaluating even the thermal absorption and emission coefficients are determined through the (yet unknown) radiation field, moreover in essentially all frequencies and directions. An approach where at least some important level populations are determined by a self-consistent solution of the statistical equilibrium equation and the radiative transfer equation is called in astrophysics the non-LTE (or NLTE) approach, and its elaboration was in fact the main topic of the field of stellar atmospheres theory in the last three decades. Finally, I stress that even in the case of LTE, one still has to deal with with complex non-local and non-linear coupling of radiation field and the state parameters. This is because the local temperature is determined through some form of energy balance (radiative equilibrium for hot star atmospheres; radiative + convective equilibrium in cooler stars; plus additional dissipation of mechanical energy in case of stellar chromospheres or accretion disks, etc.).
20
I. Hubeny
In the simplest case of pure radiative equilibrium, which reads ∞ [χ(ν, T )I(ν, n) − η(ν, n, T )] dν dΩ = 0 ,
(13)
0
we see that the temperature structure depends on the radiation field in a complex way.
4 Hierarchies of Approximations There is a wide range of different radiative transfer problems considered in astrophysics, depending on a degree of sophistication in treating the interaction of radiation and matter. I will briefly summarize the basic types of problems below, although the list is by no means exhaustive. 4.1 Treatment of Absorption and Emission • Formal solution This is the simplest case, in which the emission and absorption coefficients (or the optical depth and the source function) are fully known. In this case the transfer equation is a linear differential equation, and its solution is easy. The only concern is to find a sufficiently fast and efficient numerical procedure. The topic was recently reviewed for instance in [5] and [6]. The basic use of the formal solution is as an intermediate step of a global iterative method, as we shall discuss later on. • Monochromatic(coherent scattering) problems In this case, χ and S may depend on frequency ν, but there is no coupling to other frequencies ν . In other words, all the frequencies are separate, one one can solve for one frequency at a time. There is a subdivision according to various possibilities of treating the angular coupling: – anisotropic scattering Here, the source function contains a term proportional to sc S (n) ∝ σ(n) p(n , n) I(n ) dΩ , where p is the phase function. – isotropic scattering, where p = 1, and thus the scattering part of the source function is independent of direction and is given by S sc (n) = S sc ∝ I(n ) dΩ ≡ J , where J is the zero-order moment of the specific intensity, called in astrophysics the mean intensity of radiation (it is called the scalar flux, φ, in the neutron transport theory).
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
• Non-coherent scattering problems In this case, the scattering source function contains the term S sc (ν, n) ∝ R(ν , n , ν, n)I(ν , n ) dν dΩ ,
21
(14)
where R is the redistribution function. Typical examples of the situations where a complex frequency and angular redistribution of radiation is important are for instance Compton scattering in high energy astrophysics, resonance scattering in spectral lines, or Mie scattering on cloud particles for coldest stars and giant planets. Simplified cases include: – angular and frequency redistribution are separate, ¯ , ν) p(n , n) , R(ν , n , ν, n) = R(ν which is a very good approximation in most cases, and which simplifies a numerical solution considerably. – complete redistribution, in which cases the scattering is viewed as two uncorrelated process of absorption and subsequent re-emission, with the same probability densities, ¯ , ν) = φ(ν ) φ(ν) , R(ν where φ(ν) is the absorption profile coefficient. This is usually a good approximation for scattering in spectral lines except strong resonance lines when one has to deal with more general redistribution function. In astrophysical terminology, the latter situation is called partial redistribution, in contrast to the complete redistribution. – coherent scattering, which we mentioned earlier. corresponds to ¯ , ν) = φ(ν ) δ(ν − ν) , R(ν where δ is the Dirac δ-function. 4.2 Treatment of Spatial Dimensions • 1-D plane-parallel geometry In this case one assumes that the medium is composed of plane-parallel, horizontally-homogeneous layers. The problem is thus 1-dimensional, in Cartesian geometry. This approach is usually used for stellar atmospheres. Although it may seem very crude, it actually provides an excellent approximation for atmospheres whose thickness is much smaller that the stellar radius, which is the case for most stellar types except giants and supergiants with extended atmospheres. Also, such an approach is warranted because some other essential pieces of physics, such as departures from LTE, and/or a radiative/convective balance, are important, which
22
•
• • •
I. Hubeny
leads to a necessity of treating a large number of frequencies and possibly directions. This approach can be used even in the case of surface inhomogeneities, as long as the radial properties vary much faster than the horizontal properties (which, again, is usually the case). 1-D plane-parallel approach is also often being used for geometrically thin accretion disks. There are several codes for this type of problems; the most widely used are a universal stellar atmosphere and accretion disk program TLUSTY [7–9], and the package PRO2 [10, 11]. 1-D spherical geometry It is used for extended atmospheres, stellar winds, supernovae, H II regions, and others. Although it is still a one-dimensional problem, it is numerically much more demanding than the previous 1-D plane-parallel problem because one has to take into account many more angles (directions), because the radiation intensity is becoming more and more forward-peaked when going outward. The most sophisticated codes of this sort are CMFGEN [12], and PHOENIX [13]. 2-D spherical geometry It is used for rapidly rotating stars, core-collapse supernovae, etc. 2-D cylindrical geometry It is mostly used for accretion disks and core-collapse supernova simulations. A well-described code of this sort is ALTAIR [14, 15]. 3-D Cartesian geometry So far it has been used for snapshots of 3-D hydrodynamic simulations “in the box” for solar convection, modeling viscous dissipation in accretion disks, mass transfer in close binary systems, simulating large-scale cosmological structures, and others. Obviously, the problem is computationally extremely demanding, so the 3-D transfer simulation use a number of various approximations (e.g., [16]).
4.3 Treatment of frequency Ideally, one has to treat as many frequency points as to faithfully reproduce the frequency dependence of the absorption (and emission) coefficient. While the bound-free and free-free processes have relatively smooth cross-sections (although, strictly speaking, the photoionization cross-section do sometimes contain a number of resonances, so they do not be smooth after all) and thus can be reproduced by a relatively small number of discretized frequency points, the bound-bound processes (spectral lines) have very sharply peaked cross-sections. Moreover, a typical stellar spectrum contains literally milions of spectral lines, which should all be consedred explicitly in order to construct an accurate model atmosphere (essentially because the rate equations and the energy balance equation contain integrals of the radiation intensity over the whole frequency range). Model stellar atmospheres (and other astronomical radiation-dominated objects) either ignore the effects of the majority of spectral lines and treat only the most important ones; or do treat, with a varying
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
23
degree of approximation, essentially “all” spectral lines. Model atmospheres of the latter kind are called line-blanketed models. I list below several options for treating the frequency dependence of relavant quantities, ordered by increasing accuracy, and by the number of frequency points required. • Gray problem In this case, there is only one frequency; better speaking, one either assumes that the absorption and emission coefficients are frequencyindependent, or one works in terms of frequency-integrated quantities. In the context of stellar atmospheres, such an approach is being used as an interesting pedagogical tool for understanding the temperature structure, and for providing a starting solution for an iteration scheme to solve a general stellar atmosphere problem. • Multi-group/multi-gray is a generalization of the gray model. One introduces several, O(1) – O(10), frequency bins (groups), and averages all the relevant frequencydependent quantities over the individual bins/groups. Again, this approach is no longer being used in the context of stellar atmosphere models; although [17] presented a generalization this approach for NLTE model atmospheres with a treatment of many spectral lines; however, the number of bins was significantly higher – O(103 ) to O(104 ). The multi-group approach is however still being used in radiation hydrodynamic studies (or any problem which is already so computationally heavy that one cannot afford to deal with many frequencies), and, in particular, for treating neutrino transport in the core-collapse supernova simulations. In the latter case, the relevant cross-sections are relatively smooth functions of frequency/energy, so that such an approach is a very good approximation anyway. • Opacity Distribution Functions One introduces a number of frequency intervals [typically O(100) - O(103 )]; instead of simply averaging over the intervals, one resamples the opacity in the individual intervals into monotonic functions of frequency, which can then be treated by means of a small number of frequency points [typically O(10) per interval]. One can thus represent the whole frequency space in roughly O(104 ) frequency points. • Opacity Sampling This is essentially a Monte-Carlo treatment of frequency dependence. One selects a set of random frequency points that statistically reproduce a complex frequency behavior of the absorption and emission coefficient. Obviously, the larger the number of frequency points, the higher the accuracy of the solution. In typical (stellar atmosphere) applications, one thus deal has to deal with O(104 ) to few times O(105 ) frequency points. • Full frequency resolution Such an item would be missing in a similar review only a few years ago because it would have been viewed as too computationally demanding.
24
I. Hubeny
However, such approaches are possible now, at least in 1-D. Recent grids of NLTE line-blanketed model stellar atmospheres, such as the grid of O star models [18] that uses Opacity Sampling with a resolution of 0.75 fiducial Doppler widths, can be viewed as more or less “full” frequency resolution. This approach needs 2–3 ×105 frequency points; cooler star models would need up to O(106 ) frequency points, but this is becoming possible with current computers. 4.4 Treatment of angular dimensions Briefly, there are two types of approaches. One can either treat an angular dependence of specific intensity explicitly, or to use either variable Eddington factors (or Eddington tensor in more than 1 spatial dimension), or some other closure relations, and to solve the transfer equation only for the moments of specific intensity, such as the mean intensity J. The latter approach is very advantageous in the case of isotropic scattering. For the problems of general anisotropic scattering, one usually adopts the former approach and solves the transfer problem for the specific intensities. In 1-D geometries one typically considers one angular variable (the polar angle measured with respect to the normal to the surface), and assumes azimuthal symmetry of the radiation field. In that case, one works in terms of azimuthally-averaged specific intensity. In 1-D plane-parallel geometry, it is usually sufficient to consider a very small number of polar angles (3 is a typical value in stellar atmosphere models). However, model atmospheres with strong irradiation from outside (for instance for very close-in extrasolar giant planets), and moreover with strongly anisotropic scattering phase function, require at least several hundred angles (e.g., [19]). 1-D spherical models do typically require more angles that 1-D planeparallel models, usually there are roughly as many polar angles as the number of radial zones. In multi-D transfer problems the number of angles depend on actual situation; some workers in radiation hydrodynamic models for solar atmosphere use only O(10) angles (see, e.g. [16]); but most transfer studies in multi-D consider O(100) to O(103 ) angles.
5 General Problem 5.1 State Vector The state of a radiation-dominated medium, as discussed above, is fully described by the following general state vector ψ = {I(t, r, ν, n), T (t, r), ρ(t, r), v(t, r), [ni (t, r), i = 1, N L]} ,
(15)
where the state parameters are, respectively, the specific intensity of radiation, temperature, density, velocity vector, and the atomic (possibly also
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
25
molecular) level populations (occupation numbers); here N L is the total number of energy levels for which the statistical equilibrium equation is solved, and for which one thus allows departures from LTE. In some simplified situations, certain components may be missing. For instance, for static models, v ≡ 0, so that the velocity is skipped from the state vector. Similarly, in LTE, the level populations are known functions of temperature and density, and thus are skipped from the state vector. In we consider the so-called restricted NLTE problem, that is assuming that the temperature, density (and velocity in the case of dynamic models) are known, one is left only with radiation intensity and level populations to be solved for. Finally, if we assume LTE for level populations, and assuming fixed temperature, density, and velocity, the only unknown quantity is the radiation intensity. This is actually the case in many problems in the neutron transport theory and the Earth atmosphere studies. Let us first summarize typical numbers of the components of the state vector, in order to appreciate the numerical complexity of the problem. • t – many time steps, depending on the problem. However, the vast majority of astrophysical radiation transport problem is time-independent; sp.dim. ) grid points where N sp.dim. is the number of • r – typically O(100N spatial dimensions; • n – O(100 ) to O(103 ) grid points, depending on problem (see above); • ν – O(100 ) to O(106 ) points, depending on problem (see above); • N L – O(100 ) to O(104 ) levels, depending on problem. Let us now give some examples of actual numbers used in the current state of the art numerical simulations in astrophysics. We will only count the number of individual components of discretized specific intensity; the number of other components of the state vector is negligible. The total number is a product of number of spatial positions, number of angles, and number of frequencies. In the subsequent examples, we will follow this order. • 1-D static plane-parallel NLTE line-blanketed model stellar atmospheres 102 × few × (few × 105 ) ≈ 108 elements; • 1-D close-in extrasolar giant planets (with anisotropic scattering) 102 × 103 × 103 ) ≈ 108 elements; • 2-D core-collapse supernovae (neutrino transport) (few × 104 ) × 103 × (few × 101 ) ≈ 108 to 109 elements, but per time step; there are O(104 ) time steps. These are already existing simulations. In the (hopefully near) future, one hopes to achieve for instance the following: • 3-D core-collapse supernovae (neutrino transport) (few × 106 ) × 103 × (few × 101 ) ≈ 1010 to 1011 but per time step; ≈ 1015 altogether;
26
I. Hubeny
• 3-D static plane-parallel NLTE line-blanketed model stellar atmospheres 106 × 103 × 105 ≈ 1014 elements. 5.2 Methods of Solution There are several basic possibilities, which I outline below. Again, the list is far from being complete, and is meant for illustration only. The approaches are categorized by means of a degree of sophistication to which the interaction between radiation and matter is treated numerically. • not solving, really This is obviously the simplest, and therefore most popular, approach to the problem. There are several possibilities, including: – optically thin approximation—χ is essentially zero; consequently no interaction of radiation with matter. – diffusion approximation—an almost opposite approximation, valid for large optical depths. In this case, one can express the moments of specific intensity through the gradient of temperature; radiation intensity is thus eliminated from the state vector, but the results are approximate, the more so in the optically thin regime. – flux-limited diffusion—an improvement of the diffusion approximation, but still inaccurate at small optical depths; – escape probability methods—essentially assume that a photon after its emission is either re-absorbed on the spot, or escape freely from the medium; the branching ratio between these two is a function of optical distance form the nearest boundary. Again, the radiation intensity is effectively eliminated from the state vector. • Monte-Carlo methods These are powerful methods, in particular in multi-D geometries, but there are problems when treating NLTE problem (but see some contributions in this Volume for efficient generalizations of Monte-Carlo methods to NLTE situations). • “Exact” numerical solutions. This is the most important class of solutions, so the next Section will be fully devoted to it.
6 Exact Numerical Solution In astrophysical applications, there are essentially two types of problems: i) solution of a full set of structural equations, generally with a large number of frequency points and a large number of atomic level populations to be solved for—the problem is thus highly non-linear; and ii) solution of a (generally anisotropic) scattering problem with a known structure (temperature, density, and velocity are specified)—a linear problem.
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
27
The typical example of the first class of problems is a construction of NLTE (line-blanketed) model stellar atmospheres, where, because of the overall complexity, one is so far restricted to a 1-D geometry. The second class of problems is usually encountered in radiation hydrodynamics problems (stellar wind, accretion disks, supernovae), where one splits the hydrodynamics and radiation (neutrino) transport. We shall consider these two classes in turn. 6.1 Solution of Large Non-Linear Systems A general problem is formulated through a set of non-linear, integro-differential equations. As is customary, we discretize in space, angle, and frequency, and end up with a set of non-linear algebraic equations. The most straightforward method of solving such a system is a linearization, using the Newton-Raphson method. We write the set of all structural equations formally as F [ψ] = 0
(16)
We start with an educated guess of solution, ψ (0) . (In the case of stellar atmospheres the starting solution is provided either by the LTE-gray model, or by a previously generated NLTE model with slightly different basic stellar parameters). The iteration proceeds as ψ (n+1) = ψ (n) − J−1 · F [ψ (n) ] ,
(17)
where J is the Jacobi matrix of the system, Jij = ∂Fi /∂ψj . The method was first used to construct NLTE model stellar atmospheres in [20], who used the term “complete linearization”. The number of frequency points was limited to about 100, and the number of energy levels allowed to depart from LTE to about 10. The number of depth points was about 100, so the total number of unknowns was still pretty large, of the order to 104 . However, since the transfer equation couples only three neighboring depths, the overall system was of the block-triadigonal form, so the solution of (17) was reduced to ≈ 100 inversions of 100 × 100 matrices, which made the problem tractable even in the late 1960’s. However, the Jacobian for the modern problems mentioned above would be a matrix 108 × 108 or larger, whose direct inversion is completely out of question. How we deal with such a situation? There are several possibilities; here I will discuss two which are so far used most. The first possibility, which is particularly useful for a large number of frequencies and for highly non-linear systems—that is, in the case of NLTE line-blanketed model stellar atmospheres, is to use the idea of the so-called Accelerated Lambda Iteration (ALI) method (for a recent review, see e.g. [6]). The original scheme was developed for simpler, essentially linear problems. To illustrate the basic scheme, let us take a simple case of coherent (monochromatic) isotropic scattering. The source function is
28
I. Hubeny
S = (1 − )J + B ,
(18)
where = κth /χ is a probability that an absorbed photon is destroyed before it can be re-emitted; 1 − is the single-scattering albedo. B is the Planck function. We note that an analogous equation holds for the basic NLTE problem, namely transfer of radiation in a gas of two-level atoms. Here we ¯ ¯ only ∞ replace J by J, frequency-averaged mean intensity, that is given by J = J(ν)φ(ν)dν. We also stress that in typical astronomical line-formation 0 problems, is very small, ≈ 10−4 down to 10−6 , which makes the problem numerically more difficult than typical problems in other fields where ≈ 10−2 or even larger. The formal solution of the transfer equation can be written as J = Λ[S] ,
(19)
where Λ is a linear operator (or matrix, upon discretization). Equation (18) can thus be written as an equation for the source function S, namely
which has a solution
S = (1 − )Λ[S] + B ,
(20)
S = [I − (1 − )Λ]−1 (B) ,
(21)
where I is a unit matrix. Instead of solving the problem directly, one can use an iteration scheme; essentially using a suitable approximate Λ-operator, Λ∗ . Equation (19) is written as J (n+1) = Λ∗ [S (n+1) ] + (Λ − Λ∗ )[S (n) ,
(22)
which leads to the iterative scheme [I − (1 − )Λ∗ ]S (n+1) = (1 − )(Λ − Λ∗ )S (n) + B .
(23)
The operator (matrix) Λ∗ is nothing else than a suitable preconditioner (see below). It can be shown [21] that the diagonal part of exact Λ-operator is an excellent choice. The resulting method is thus equivalent to the Jacobi method. Other possibilities for Λ∗ are the tridiagonal part of exact Λ (or a higher multiband part), or a lower triangular part of Λ; the latter method is essentially the Gauss-Seidel method. One can also use the Successive Overrelaxation (SOR) method, in which the diagonal part is multiplied by 1/ω, with 1 < ω < 2 being a suitable over-relaxation parameter [22]. This method provides a full solution in the case of simple problems (pure radiative transfer without considering other structural equations). In the case of the full problem involving all structural equations, we use the relation J new = Λ∗ S new + (Λ − Λ∗ )S old ,
(24)
with a diagonal or tridiagonal Λ∗ operator, and linearize it. The “old” source function is known, and thus it does not contribute to the linearized equations.
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
29
The “new” source function is a function of temperature, density, and level populations. When linearizing, (24) effectively eliminates radiation intensities from the state vector. Actually, it turned out that it is extremely advantageous to keep the mean intensity in a few selected frequency points [centers of the strongest lines; a few points just shortward (in the wavelength space) of the photoionizations edges of the most important continua] to be linearized, while all the rest of frequency points are treated using (24). Such a scheme was developed in [9] by the name “hybrid complete linearization/accelerated Lambda iteration (CL/ALI) method”. The method has proved to be very successful for computing model stellar atmospheres and accretion disks ranging from hot disks around solar-mass black holes (T ≈ 109 K down to giant planet atmospheres with T ≈ 100 K. The second possibility is to solve the system (17) by applying the powerful idea of preconditioning. To solve iteratively a general linear system Ay = b ,
(25)
the simplest possibility is a simple relaxation method, known in astrophysical radiative transfer as “Lambda Iteration”, or as a “Source Iteration” method in the neutron transport theory. In this case one solves the system (25) as y(k+1) = y(k) + b − Ay(k) ≡ y(k) + r(k) ,
(26)
where r(k) = b − Ay (k) is the residuum vector in the k-th iteration. As is well known, the method converges extremely slowly when the largest eigenvalue of the matrix I − A is close to unity, which is usually the case in astrophysical applications. The preconditioning method consists in taking another matrix, P , which is close enough to A, and P −1 A is close to the identity matrix, so that the eigenvalues of I − P −1 A are small. The iteration process (26) is modified to y(k+1) = y(k) + P −1 r(k) ,
(27)
Obviously, the method is advantageous if the matrix P is easy and cheap to invert. A variant of this approach is the so-called double-splitting (or generally a multiple-step splitting), where one apples consecutively two or more different preconditioners, viz., y(k+1/2) = y(k) + P1−1 r(k) ,
(28)
y(k+1) = y(k+1/2) + P2−1 r(k+1/2) .
(29)
A choice of suitable preconditioner(s) depend on the problem.
30
I. Hubeny
6.2 Solution of Large Linear Systems Let us consider here a linear scattering problem, but a time-dependent one, with generally anisotropic scattering, and in several spatial dimensions, 1 ∂I(n) ˆ + D(n)I(n) = −χ I(n) + S(n) , c ∂t
(30)
ˆ where the operator D(n) is a general “spatial transport” operator, S(n) is the source term, in which we split the thermal and scattering part, S = S th +S sc . The implicit solution (with backward time differencing) is written as
c ˆ I(n) = ζ S(n) + I0 (n) , 1 + ζI D(n) (31) ∆t where ζ is given by 1 + χ. (32) c∆t where I0 (n) is the intensity at the previous time step. Although the transfer (31) is linear in the specific intensity, the fact that the source term couples all directions would mean that one needs to solve a linear system of N A × N S unknowns; N A being the total number of angles, and N S the total number of spatial positions. Since N S is typically of the order of O(104 ) to O(106 ), and N A is a few times 102 , we have to deal with a system for several millions of unknowns, which necessitates using iterative methods. There are again several possibilities. One possibility of solving the transfer equation is to adopt a two-step iteration procedure based on an application of the Accelerated Lambda Operator (ALI) technique, similarly as was recently used for 2-D radiative transfer with anisotropic scattering in the context of strongly irradiated atmospheres of extrasolar giant planets (e.g., [19]). We write the solution of the transfer equations ζ −1 =
I(n) = Λ(n)S (n) , where the total source term S is given by
c S (n) = ζ S(n) + I0 (n) , ∆t
(33)
(34)
and the “formal solution” operator, denoted in keeping with the usual astrophysical notation as Λ, is given by −1
ˆ . Λ(n) = 1 + ζI D(n) The method consists in assuming that the source term is taken as
(35)
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
31
S (n) = α(n) S¯ ,
(36)
where S¯ is an angle-averaged source term, S¯ = S (n) dΩ .
(37)
The iterative method consists of two nested iteration loops. In the inner iteration loop we assume that the “anisotropy factor” α is fixed and we solve for a specific intensity self-consistently with the averaged source term, while in the outer loop we update the anisotropy factor α. The inner loop is solved using the ALI technique, as outlined above. Another possibility is to use the idea of preconditioning. There are several possibilities to choose a suitable preconditioner for solving the system (31). Let us first rewrite (31) in a form analogous to (25), viz.
c (38) I0 , [1 + ζI D − ζI S sc ] I = ζI S th + ∆t where I is the vector composed of all the specific intensities for all directions and positions; D is the position operator that is composed of D(n) for all directions. The structure of the operators D and S is relatively simple: The operator D couples positions, but does not couple directons. That is, D is a matrix which is block-diagonal in angular space, with each block being a sparse matrix in the physical space (because of the nearest-neighbor coupling due to differentials with respect position). The operator S sc is in contrast diagonal in the physical space (no depth coupling), but the individual block matrices in the angular space are full (all directions are coupled because of the scattering). The global operator (matrix) of the system is thus A = 1 + ζI D − ζI S sc , and the right-hand side (source term) is
c b = ζI S th + I0 . ∆t
(39)
(40)
An attractive possibility is to use for P the operator which is analogous to the original operator, A, namely P = 1 + ζI D − ζI S˜sc ,
(41)
where S˜sc is the scattering part of the source term that is obtained using a lower-order quadrature over angles than that used in the case of the original S sc . For instance, one may use even an S2 quadrature for P , while using an Sn quadrature with a sufficiently large n for evaluating A. An analogous method is called “transport synthetic acceleration” in the neutron transport theory.
32
I. Hubeny
7 Conclusions Many numerical techniques that were developed in the field of astrophysical radiation transport, were also independently developed in other fields, above all in the neutron transport theory, atmospheric physics, and even in the field of plant canopies, as this meeting amply demonstrated. In astrophysics, a large emphasis is given to the problems that solve radiation transport simultaneously with other structural equations, because in many cases the radiation significantly influences the overall structure of a distant object. Thanks to the progress in the fast and efficient numerical methods, and a large increase in the computer power, one is now able to compute models of astronomical objects, such as stellar atmospheres and accretion disks, in an unprecedented degree of completeness and accuracy. However, despite of the recent progress, there is still much space for improvement, in particular by developing more sophisticated iterative methods for treating radiation transport. In this respect, a closer interaction between workers in various scientific fields that use transport methods is extremely useful. The present meeting was a first significant step toward such a goal. I would like to thank the local organizers, in particular to Frank Graziani, for organizing this truly wonderful and enornmously useful workshop.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
[6]
[7] [8]
[9]
Mihalas, D.: Stellar Atmospheres. Freeman, San Francisco (1978) Mihalas, D., Weibel–Mihalas, B: Foundations of Radiation Hydrodynamics. Oxford University Press, Oxford (1984) Castor, J.: Radiation Hydrodynamics. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (2005). Hubeny, I., Mihalas, D., Werner, K. (eds): Stellar Atmosphere Modeling. Astronomical Society of the Pacific, San Francisco (2003) Auer, L.: Formal Solution: EXPLICIT Answers. In: Hubeny, I., Mihalas, D., Werner, K. (eds) Stellar Atmosphere Modeling. Astronomical Society of the Pacific, San Francisco, 3–15 (2003) Hubeny, I.: Accelerated Lambda Iteration: An Overview. In: Hubeny, I., Mihalas, D., Werner, K. (eds) Stellar Atmosphere Modeling. Astronomical Society of the Pacific, San Francisco, 17–30 (2003) Hubeny, I.: TLUSTY: A Computer Program for non–LTE Model Stellar Atmospheres. Computer Physics Comm., 52, 103 Hubeny, I., Lanz, T.: Accelerated complete–linearization method for calculating NLTE model stellar atmospheres. Astron. & Astrophys., 262, 501–514 (1992) Hubeny, I., Lanz, T.: Non-LTE line–blanketed model atmospheres of hot stars. 1: Hybrid complete linearization/accelerated lambda iteration method. Astrophys. J., 439, 875–904 (1995)
Radiative Transfer in Astrophysical Applications
33
[10] Dreizler, S., Werner, K.: Line blanketing by iron group elements in Non–LTE model atmospheres for hot stars. Astron. & Astrophys., 278, 199–208 (1993) [11] Werner, K., Deetjen, J. L., Dreizler, S., Nagel, T., Rauch, T., Schuh, S. L.: Model Photospheres with Accelerated Lambda Iteration. In: Hubeny, I., Mihalas, D., Werner, K. (eds) Stellar Atmosphere Modeling. Astronomical Society of the Pacific, San Francisco, 31–50 (2003) [12] Hillier, D. J., Miller. D. L.: The Treatment of Non–LTE Line Blanketing in Spherically Expanding Outflows. Astrophys. J., 496, 407–427 (1998) [13] Hauschildt, P. H., Lowenthal, D. K., Baron, E.: Parallel Implementation of the PHOENIX Generalized Stellar Atmosphere Program. III. A Parallel Algorithm for Direct Opacity Sampling. Astrophys. J. Suppl., 134, 323–329 (2001) [14] Castor, J. I., Dykema, P. G., Klein, R. I.: A new scheme for multidimensional line transfer. II ETLA method in one dimension with application to iron Kalpha lines. Astrophys. J., 387, 561–571 (1992) [15] Dykema, P. G., Klein, R. I., Castor, J. I.: A New Scheme for Multidimensional Line Transfer. III. A Two-dimensional Lagrangian Variable Tensor Method with Discontinuous Finite-Element SN Transport. Astrophys. J., 457, 892– 921 (1996) [16] Stein, R., Nordlund, ˚ A.: Radiative Transfer in 3D Numerical Simulations. In: Hubeny, I., Mihalas, D., Werner, K. (eds) Stellar Atmosphere Modeling. Astronomical Society of the Pacific, San Francisco, 519–532 (2003) [17] Anderson, L.S.: Line blanketing without local thermodynamic equilibrium. I – A hydrostatic stellar atmosphere with hydrogen, helium, and carbon lines. Astrophys. J., 298, 848–858 (1985) [18] Lanz, T., Hubeny, I.: A Grid of Non-LTE Line–blanketed Model Atmospheres of O–Type Stars. Astrophys. J. Suppl., 146, 417–441 (2003) [19] Sudarsky, D., Burrows, A., Hubeny, I., Li, A.: Phase Functions and Light Curves of Wide Separation Extrasolar Giant Planets. Astrophys. J. (in press), astro–ph/0501109 [20] Auer, L.H., Mihalas, D.: Non–LTE Model Atmospheres. III. A Complete– Linearization Method. Astrophys. J., 158, 641–655 (1969) [21] Olson, G., Auer, L. H., Buchler, R.: Rapidly Convergent Iterative Solution of the non–LTE Line Radiation Transfer Problem. J. Quant. Spectrosc. Radiat. Transfer, 35, 431–442 (1986) [22] Trujillo–Bueno, J., Fabiani–Bendicho, P.: A novel iterative scheme for the very fast and accurate solution of non–LTE radiative transfer problems. Astrophys. J., 455, 646–657, (1995)
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae Anthony Mezzacappa1 , Matthias Liebend¨ orfer2 , Christian Y. Cardall1,3 , O.E. Bronson Messer4 , and Stephen W. Bruenn5 1 2 3
4
5
Physics Division, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831-6354 CITA, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, M5S 3H8, CA Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Tennessee, Knoxville, TN 37996 National Center for Computational Sciences, Oak Ridge National Laboratory, Oak Ridge, TN 37831-6354 Department of Physics, Florida Atlantic University, Boac Raton, FL 33431
1 The Core Collapse Supernova Paradigm Stars more massive than ∼10 M evolve to an onion-like configuration (Fig. 1), with an iron core surrounded by successive layers of silicon, oxygen, carbon, helium, and finally hydrogen. In addition to iron group nuclei, the core is composed of electrons, positrons, photons, and a small fraction of protons and neutrons. The pressure in the core, which supports it against the inward pull of gravity, is dominated at this stage by the electrons, and the balance between the electron pressure and gravity is only marginally stable. As a result of electron capture on the free protons and nuclei in the core and as a result of nuclear dissociation under the extreme densities and temperatures, electron and thermal pressure support are reduced, and the core becomes unstable and collapses. The velocity of infalling matter in the core increases linearly with radius, characteristic of the “homologous” collapse expected of a fluid whose pressure is dominated by relativistic, degenerate electron pressure. The sound speed, on the other hand, decreases with density and, therefore, radius. Thus, with increasing radius, the infall velocity eventually exceeds the local sound speed; i.e., the infall becomes supersonic. Consequently, during infall the core splits into an inner homologously and subsonically infalling core and an outer supersonically infalling outer core (stage 1 of Fig. 2). Beginning with central densities ∼109−10 g/cm3 , the collapse proceeds through nuclear matter densities (∼1 − 3 × 1014 g/cm3 ). The inner core undergoes a phase transition from a two-phase system of nucleons and nuclei to a one-phase system of bulk nuclear matter. One may view the inner core at this point as one giant nucleus. The pressure in the inner core increases dramatically as the result of Fermi effects and the repulsive nature of the nucleon–nucleon interaction potential at short distances. As a result of this dramatic increase in pressure, the inner core becomes incompressible and rebounds (stages 3–5 of Fig. 2).
36
A. Mezzacappa et al.
Orbit of Earth around Sun
H, He
H, He
1012cm
He 3x1013cm
He 1010cm
He 1011cm
C, O
O, Ne, Mg
Earth
O, Ne, Mg
2.2x109cm
“Si” “Fe”
Fig. 1. The structure of a core collapse supernova progenitor at the onset of stellar core collapse. The size of the iron core and star are compared with the size of the Earth and its orbit around the Sun, respectively
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
37
2
1
neutrinos
3
6
shock 5
4
7
Fig. 2. The stages of stellar core collapse, maximum compression, bounce, and shock formation. The core separates into an inner, subsonically collapsing and an outer, supersonically collapsing core. The inner core bounce launches a shock wave into the outer core. The shock wave will propagate through the outer iron core and layers above it, expelling much of the layers to produce the supernova
38
A. Mezzacappa et al.
Any information about the rebounding inner core would be conveyed to the outer core via pressure waves that propagate radially outward at the speed of sound. When these waves reach the point at which the infall is supersonic—i.e., the “sonic point”—they are swept in as fast as they attempt to propagate outward. The net result: No information about the rebounding inner core reaches the infalling outer core, which in turn sets up a density, pressure, and velocity discontinuity in the flow—i.e., a shock wave. This shock wave will ultimately be responsible for propagating outward through the star, disrupting the star in a core collapse supernova. Schematically, the shock wave is launched and energized by the rebounding inner core piston. (In Fig. 2, the shock wave is represented schematically by the orange circle in stages 5–7.) If the shock were to propagate outward without stalling, we would have what has been called a “prompt” explosion. All of the realistic models completed to date suggest that this does not occur. Because the shock loses energy in dissociating the iron nuclei that pass through it as it propagates outward, the shock is enervated. Nuclei exist in the regions shaded with a light blue in Fig. 2. The yellow regions in stages 5–7 are regions of shock- compressed and heated material in which the nuclei are dissociated into nucleons. The shock loses additional energy in the form of electron neutrinos. The copious production of electron neutrinos occurs when the core electrons capture on the newly dissociation-liberated protons. These neutrinos are initially trapped but escape when the shock moves out beyond the electron neutrinosphere. This gives rise to the “electron neutrino burst” in a core collapse supernova, which is the first of three major phases of the three-flavor neutrino emission during these events. As a result of these two enervating mechanisms, the shock stalls in the iron core. How the shock is reenergized in a “delayed shock mechanism” is currently the central question in core collapse supernova theory. At the time the shock stalls, the core configuration is composed of a central radiating object: the proto-neutron star (Fig. 3), which will go on to form a neutron star or black hole. The proto-neutron star has a relatively cold inner core, composed of unshocked bulk nuclear matter, together with a hot “mantle” of nuclear matter that has been shocked but not expelled. The ultimate source of energy in a core collapse supernova is the ∼1053 erg of gravitational binding energy associated with the formation of the neutron star. This gravitational binding energy is released after core bounce over ∼10 seconds in the form of a three-flavor neutrino “pulse.” This marks the second phase of the neutrino emission from a core collapse supernova. Electron neutrinos are produced during stellar core collapse by electron capture on protons and nuclei, but after bounce, in the hot proto-neutron star mantle, all three flavors of neutrinos and their antineutrinos are produced and are emitted as the mantle cools and contracts during its “Kelvin-Helmholtz” cooling phase. The neutrinos are emitted from their respective neutrinospheres. The neutrinospheres are defined in a way similar to the way the photosphere
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
39
ν-Luminosity Matter Flow
Shock Heating
_ν e + n → p + e-+ νe + p → n + e _ν e + n → p + e-+ νe + p → n + e
Gain Radius
Cooling
Proto-Neutron Star ν-Spheres
Fig. 3. During the shock reheating phase, the stellar core is composed of a central radiating proto-neutron star whose “surface” is defined by the neutrinospheres (represented here by a single sphere) and a region above the neutrinosphere consisting of a net cooling region and a net heating region below the stalled shock, separated by the “gain” radius at which heating and cooling balance. Heating and cooling are mediated by electron neutrino and antineutrino absorption and emission
of the Sun is defined. They are the surfaces of last scattering for each energy and flavor. Equivalently, they are at radii at which the respective neutrino depths are 2/3. In Fig. 3, the neutrinospheres are represented by one surface. The neutrino luminosities during this phase are maintained at their average values ∼1052 erg/s by mass accretion onto the proto-neutron star (the kinetic energy of infall is converted into thermal energy when the material hits the proto-neutron star surface). After explosion is initiated, the accretion luminosity decreases dramatically, and the neutrino pulse enters its third and final stage: the exponential decay of the neutrino luminosities characteristic of neutron star formation and cooling.
40
A. Mezzacappa et al.
The stalled supernova shock is thought to be revived, at least in part, by the charged-current absorption of electron neutrinos and antineutrinos that emerge from the proto-neutron star, a fraction of which are absorbed by protons and neutrons behind the shock. This is known as the “delayed shock” or “neutrino-heating” mechanism, originally proposed by Wilson and Bethe [1, 2]. While the total energy emitted in neutrinos is two orders of magnitude greater than what is required for the generation of an ∼1051 erg explosion, deciphering the precise role of this neutrino heating in the supernova mechanism is, as we will discuss, difficult. Between the neutrinosphere and the shock, the material both heats and cools by electron neutrino and antineutrino emission and absorption. The neutrino heating and cooling have different radial profiles; consequently, this region splits into a net cooling region and a net heating region, separated by a “gain” radius at which heating and cooling balance. (See Fig. 3.) We refer to the region between the gain radius and the shock as the “gain region.” The neutrino heating in the gain region can be written as 1 Xp Lν¯e 2 1 Xn Lνe 2 Eν¯e . (1) E + ¯a ˙ = a λ0 4πr2 νe F F¯ λ0 4πr2 The first (second) term corresponds to the absorption of electron neutrinos (antineutrinos). It depends linearly on the neutrino luminosity and “inverse flux factor,” which is a measure of the isotropy of the neutrino distribution, and quadratically on the neutrino spectrum. In addition to the dependence on the three key neutrino quantities in the heating rate above, the revival of the stalled supernova shock depends on a complex interplay of neutrino heating, mass accretion through the shock, and mass accretion through the gain radius [3]. It is mass accretion through the shock and gain radii that determines the amount of mass in the gain region, the former being a source of mass in the gain region and the latter being a sink. Moreover, the mass accretion through the gain radius serves to both sustain the neutrino luminosities and to undermine the pressure in the gain region, simultaneously—i.e., it serves a supporting and a detrimental role. All three quantities in the neutrino heating rate must be computed accurately [3–8], which requires that we solve the neutrino Boltzmann neutrino transport equations.
2 The O(v/c) Neutrino Transport Equation in Spherical Symmetry: An Illustrative Example To understand the problem at hand and the issues we face in developing a numerical method for neutrino transport in our application, it is for the moment sufficient to consider the O(v/c) Boltzmann equation in spherical
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
41
symmetry [9–12]. We will consider the general case later. If we include emission, absorption, isoenergetic scattering of neutrinos by nucleons and nuclei, neutrino–electron scattering, and pair emission and absorption, the Boltzmann equation is ∂(r2 ρF ) 1 ∂F + 4πµ c ∂t ∂m 1 ∂[(1 − µ2 )F ] + r ∂µ 1 ∂lnρ 3v ∂[µ(1 − µ2 )F ] + + c ∂t r ∂µ 1 2 ∂lnρ 3v v 1 ∂(E 3 F ) + + µ − c ∂t r r E 2 ∂E j ˜ = − χF ρ 1 1 2 + E dµ RIS F c h3 c3 1 1 2 − E F dµ RIS c h3 c3 1 1 in ˜ NES −F dE E 2 dµ R + 3 4 F h c ρ 1 1 2 ˜ out −F − 3 4 F dE E dµ RNES h c ρ 1 1 1 2 ˜ em ¯ + 3 4 − −F dE E dµ RPAIR h c ρ ρ 1 abs ¯ ˜ PAIR − 3 4 F dE E 2 dµ R F . h c
(2)
The Boltzmann equation is solved for each neutrino flavor independently. The electron neutrinos and antineutrinos are solved for simultaneously, as are the µ/τ neutrinos and antineutrinos, because each neutrino flavor is coupled to its corresponding antineutrino through the pair emission and absorption channel. The mass derivative term on the left-hand side of the Boltzmann equation describes the propagation of neutrinos with respect to the Lagrangian mass coordinate, m. Outwardly propagating neutrinos have µ > 0, whereas inwardly propagating neutrinos have µ < 0. The first µ-derivative term describes the rate of change of the neutrino propagation direction with respect to the outward radial direction as the neutrino propagates inward or outward in mass. The second µ-derivative term describes the aberration in the neutrino propagation direction measured by an observer who is instantaneously comoving with the fluid. Because the fluid is accelerating, two neighboring comoving observers will measure different direction cosines. The energy-derivative term
42
A. Mezzacappa et al.
describes the shift in the neutrino energy measured by comoving observers. This is a Doppler shift resulting from the change in the velocity, with time and/or radius, of an accelerated fluid; two neighboring comoving observers will measure different frequencies. On the right-hand side of (2), the first two terms describe the change in the neutrino distribution function resulting from the absorption and emission of neutrinos by nucleons and nuclei. The next two terms describe the isoenergetic inscattering and outscattering, respectively, of neutrinos by nucleons and nuclei. The fourth and fifth terms describe non-isoenergetic neutrino– electron scattering, and the last two terms describe pair emission and absorption. F¯ is the corresponding antineutrino distribution function for each neutrino species evolved with (2). The neutrino interactions included in (2) are not complete, but as far as the functional form of the emissivities and opacities is concerned, they are. For example, scattering of neutrinos on nucleons is not isoenergetic when nucleon recoil and correlations are taken into account, but the functional form of the scattering kernel in this case would then simply take on the form of the non-isoenergetic neutrino–electron scattering kernel. For a complete discussion of the state of the art in neutrino emissivities and opacities, the reader is referred to [13].
3 Finite Differencing of the O(v/c) Neutrino Transport Equation in Spherical Symmetry 3.1 Time Derivative of the Neutrino Distribution Function The finite differencing of the time derivative of the neutrino distribution function is straightforward. It is implemented in the following way: ∂F Fi ,j ,k − F i ,j ,k = . ∂t dt
(3)
The quantities with an overbar refer to the previous value of the variables. All other quantities refer to the updated values after the time step dt = t − t. In everything that follows, we adopt the convention that i ≡ i + 1/2, j ≡ j + 1/2, and k ≡ k + 1/2. 3.2 Collision Term The finite difference representation of the collision term in equation (2) is
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
43
ji ,k −χ ˜i ,k Fi ,j ,k ρi jmax 1 2 + 3 3 Ek wl (RIS )i ,j ,l ,k Fi ,l ,k ch c l=1
−
jmax 1 2 E wl (RIS )i ,j ,l ,k F i ,j ,k k 3 3 ch c l=1
+
jmax kmax 1 2 − F ) E (1/ρ ∆E wl i i ,j ,k m m 3 3 ch c m=1 l=1
˜ in ) F × (R NES i ,j ,l ,k ,m i ,l ,m −
jmax kmax 1 2 E F ∆E wl i ,j ,k m m 3 3 ch c m=1 l=1
out ˜ NES × (R )i ,j ,l ,k ,m (1/ρi − Fi ,l ,m ) jmax kmax 1 2 + 3 3 (1/ρi − Fi ,j ,k ) ∆Em Em wl ch c m=1 l=1
˜ em ) (1/ρ − F¯ ) × (R PAIR i ,j ,l ,k ,m i i ,l ,m −
jmax kmax 1 2 E F ∆E wl m m ch3 c3 i ,j ,k m=1 l=1
abs ˜ PAIR × (R )i ,j ,l ,k ,m F¯i ,l ,m
(4)
It is important to note that (a) the collision term in our approach is differenced implicitly with respect to time and (b) the scattering kernels are not approximated by a truncated Legendre expansion in cos θ. Thus, modulo discretization errors, our approach yields a solution of the original Boltzmann equation. For certain neutrino interactions, the Legendre expansion of the scattering kernels does not converge; i.e., the kernels can be infinite, although integrably finite (e.g., see [12]). Thus, expanding the kernels in this way is not generally valid. Note that the overbar in the pair creation and annihilation terms denote the antineutrino distribution function, not the value of the distribution function at the previous time step, as in (3). We continue the convention adopted in equation (3), both here and throughout the remaining sections, that quantities without an overbar are defined at the new time step. Thus, in (4) ρ, j, χ, ˜ R... , F , and F¯ are all defined at the new time step. 3.3 Neutrino Propagation in Mass The term µ∂(r2 ρF )/∂m in (2) accounts for the neutrinos that are propagating into and out of a spherical mass shell. In the free streaming limit,
44
A. Mezzacappa et al.
the advected neutrino number in a time step (as measured by a comoving observer) is large with respect to the neutrino number in the zone. Upwind differencing of the advection term is appropriate to limit destabilizing errors in the advection fluxes. For discrete direction cosines µj , the direction of the neutrino “wind” is simply given by the sign of µj . (A neutrino with µ = 0 propagates tangential to the mass shell). In diffusive conditions, however, the neutrino flux may be orders of magnitude smaller than the prevailing nearly isotropic neutrino density in the mass shell. In this situation, an asymmetric differencing can easily lead to an overestimate of the first angular moment because of improper cancellations among the contributions of the isotropic component of the neutrino field. Based on transport coefficients βi,k , we therefore interpolate between upwind differencing in free streaming regimes (βi,k = 1) and centered differencing (βi,k = 1/2) in diffusive regimes. Moreover, the equilibrium constraint (73) in [14] only holds for βi,k = 1/2. We therefore use transport coefficients defined according to 1/2 if 2dri > λi,k , βi,k = (5) −1 (2dri /λi,k + 1) otherwise . That is, the transport coefficients at zone edges depend on the ratio of the distance dri between zone centers and the neutrino angle and energy dependent mean free path λi,k . We then discretize the propagation term as: µ
µj ∂r2 ρF 2 4πri+1 = ρi+1 Fi+1,j ,k − 4πri2 ρi Fi,j ,k ∂m dmi
(6)
with ρi Fi,j ,k = βi,k ρi −1 Fi −1,j ,k + (1 − βi,k ) ρi Fi ,j ,k
(7)
for outward propagating neutrinos (µj > 0), and ρi Fi,j ,k = (1 − βi,k ) ρi −1 Fi −1,j ,k + βi,k ρi Fi ,j ,k
(8)
for inward propagating neutrinos (µj < 0). 3.4 Change in the Neutrino Direction Cosine from Spatial Propagation For any neutrino, the neutrino direction cosine increases toward unity as it propagates through space. Hence, neutrino propagation causes angular advection relative to a fixed grid of neutrino direction cosines µj . This contribution to the evolution of the neutrino distribution function is described by the term ∂[(1 − µ2 )F ]/r∂µ in (2). The finite difference representation is chosen to maintain equilibrium between the radiation field and stationary matter under conditions in which such an equilibrium would exist [14, 15]. We set
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
45
2 3 ri+1 − ri2 1 ∂[(1 − µ2 )F ] = 3 (ζj+1 Fi ,j+1,k − ζj Fi ,j,k ) . r∂µ 2 ri+1 − ri3 wj
(9)
The differencing of the coefficients, ζ = 1 − µ2 , is defined by ζj+1 − ζj = −2µj wj .
(10)
The angular integration of the term ∂[(1 − µ2 )F ]/r∂µ produces the zeroth and second angular moments of the neutrino distribution function. Its finite difference representation is therefore not as sensitive to cancellations in the diffusive limit as the differencing of the spatial advection term. Upwind differencing can be justified. The angular “wind” always points towards µ = 1. However, for reasons of completeness and consistency, we also use centered differencing in the diffusive regime. With angular transport coefficients γi ,k ≡ βi ,k , we interpolate the values of the neutrino distribution function to angular zone edges by Fi ,j,k = γi ,k Fi ,j −1,k + (1 − γi ,k ) Fi ,j ,k .
(11)
3.5 Conservation of Lepton Number and Energy In our attempt to simulate core collapse supernova explosions we are presented with a number of underlying technical challenges that will ultimately dictate the degree to which we are confident that our simulation outcomes represent reality at all. Among these is the challenge of maintaining conservation of lepton number (for massless neutrinos) and energy in any given supernova model. Conservation of lepton number and energy are no guarantee that a model is correct. Models can be constructed, for example, to conserve total energy but may not accurately model the partition of energy among kinetic energy, internal energy, gravitational energy, etc. But any model that does not conserve lepton number and energy does not satisfy arguably the most important quality control we can use to gauge a simulation’s realism. How should we interpret the prediction of a ∼1051 erg explosion in a model where the total energy varies during the course of the simulation by ∼1051 erg or more? To put matters in perspective as to why ensuring conservation presents such a great technical challenge, we simply have to recall that the ultimate source of energy in a core collapse supernova is the gravitational binding energy of the remnant neutron star. This ∼1053 erg of energy is two orders of magnitude larger than the ∼1051 erg associated with the explosion. Consequently, total energy must be conserved over the course of a simulation to better than one part in 103 . A typical simulation will be carried out over ∼105−6 time steps, which requires that energy be conserved systematically to better than one part in 108−9 per time step. This is a severe requirement, one that is very difficult to satisfy in a realistic supernova model.
46
A. Mezzacappa et al.
First, we must define an energy that is conserved. For the radiation field— modulo energy losses and gains owing to the neutrino interactions with the matter—the lab frame specific radiation energy is globally conserved. In one approach, we may begin with the comoving frame specific radiation energy and flux. In the continuum limit, the lab frame specific radiation energy conservation is guaranteed by a cancellation of terms in the equations for the comoving frame specific radiation energy and flux when these equations are added together to give the evolution (conservation) equation for the lab frame specific radiation energy (the lab frame specific radiation energy, by the Lorentz transformation, is a sum of the comoving frame specific radiation energy and flux). In the O(v/c) limit, for example, the cancelling terms arise from both the O(1) and O(v/c) (“observer corrections”: angular aberration and frequency shift) terms in the original Boltzmann equation from which the comoving frame specific energy and flux equations arise (these are the first two “moments” of the Boltzmann equation, defined in Sect. 2). We must in turn ensure that such cancellations occur in the discrete limit to ensure that energy is conserved in our simulations. This requires that we construct the discrete representation of the terms in the Boltzmann equation from which the cancelling terms arise with great care—i.e., the discrete representation of the O(1) and O(v/c) terms in the Boltzmann equation are not independent. This numerical feat has been achieved in the spherically symmetric case [14, 16–19]]. The proliferation of O[(v/c2 )] terms in the Boltzmann equation as we move from one- to three-dimensional models makes this approach increasingly difficult [19, 20]. As a result, other approaches are now being considered to achieve the same end [21]. The integration of the Boltzmann equation over momentum space, spanned by the neutrino direction cosine and energy, and mass gives the conservation laws for neutrino number and energy. We define J N and H N to represent the zeroth and first µ number moments of the distribution function: 1 ∞ F E 2 dEdµ , JN = −1 1
0
HN = −1
∞
F E 2 dEµdµ .
0
Integration of (2) over µ and E with E 2 as the measure of integration gives the following evolution equation for J N : ∂ j 2 ∂J N 2 N + 4πr ρH − E dEdµ + χF E 2 dEdµ = 0 . (12) ∂t ∂m ρ The aberration and frequency shift terms in equation (2) do not contribute because 1 − µ2 vanishes at µ = ±1 and E 3 F is zero for E = 0 and E = ∞. One more integration over rest mass m from the center of the star to its surface gives the evolution equation for the total neutrino number.
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
47
Slightly less straightforward is the derivation of total energy conservation. Define the energy moments E J = F E 3 dEdµ H E = F E 3 dEµdµ E K = F E 3 dEµ2 dµ QE = F E 3 dEµ3 dµ; , By taking the zeroth and first angular moments of the energy moment ( E 3 dE{∂F/∂t = O[F ]}) of the Boltzmann equation, the latter weighted by the fluid velocity, v,—i.e., E 3 dEdµ{∂F/∂t = O[F ]} and (v E 3 dEdµ {∂F/∂t = O[F ]}— one finds ∂lnρ 2v ∂J E ∂ v E 2 E + + 4πr ρH − J − KE KE + ∂t ∂m ∂t r r j 3 E dEdµ + χF E 3 dEdµ = 0 , (13) − ρ
v
∂ ∂H E dv E v E + K − 4πr2 vρK E − 4πr2 ρ J − KE ∂t ∂m r dm ∂lnρ 2v E 3 + −v H + v χF E dEµdµ = 0 . ∂t r
(14)
Combining, we obtain the lab frame energy conservation equation: ∂ E ∂ J + vH E + 4πr2 ρ vK E + H E ∂m ∂t j 3 E dEdµ + χF E 3 dEdµ + v χF E 3 dEµdµ − ρ 1 ∂ 4πr2 ρv H E . − 2 4πr ρ ∂t
0=
(15)
Note that J E + vH E is the lab frame neutrino energy density as expressed in terms of the comoving frame moments J E and H E . Integration of (15) over enclosed mass leads to an equation for total neutrino energy evolution. The first term on the RHS is the time evolution of the conserved energy. The second term corrects for surface effects, namely the work at the surface against radiation pressure, ρK E , and the surface luminosity, 4πr2 ρH E . The second line represents the energy exchange between radiation and matter by emission, absorption, and radiation stress. If one aims to check energy conservation to machine precision, it is important to be aware that taking
48
A. Mezzacappa et al.
the O(v/c) limit in the comoving frame does not lead to the identical physical description as taking the O(v/c) limit in the lab frame. For that reason, we keep higher order terms in the third line of (15) for compatibility with the physical description of the O(v/c) Boltzmann equation (2) in the comoving frame. These higher-order terms can become nonnegligible. We observe that the expressions (∂lnρ/∂t+2v/r)KE and K E 4πr2 ρ∂v/∂m in equations (13) and (14) cancel based on the hydrodynamic continuity equation ∂v ∂lnρ 2v + = −4πr2 ρ . (16) ∂t r ∂m Similarly, the terms involving (J E −K E )v/r cancel. As these cancelling terms are of O(v/c) and proportional to the neutrino density, they grow during a core collapse simulation and become quite large at and after bounce. Hence, it is important for a satisfactory global energy conservation to guarantee their cancellation in the finite difference representation as well. Identifying the origin of the terms (∂lnρ/∂t + 2v/r)KE and K E 4πr2 ρ∂v/∂m, we find that (∂lnρ/∂t + 2v/r)KE originates from the zeroth moment of the observer correction v ∂lnρ 2v 1 ∂ 3 + E F , (17) − 1 − µ2 µ2 ∂t r r E 2 ∂E in the Boltzmann equation (2), and K E 4πr2ρ∂v/∂m originates from the first moment of the space term, µ∂ 4πr2 ρF /∂m, in the same equa E propagation tion. The terms J − K E v/r stem from the zeroth moment of the same observer correction (17) and the first moment of the angular propagation term ∂ 1 − µ2 F / (r∂µ) in the Boltzmann equation (2). The requirement of global energy conservation in the lab frame therefore imposes interdependencies on the finite differencing of the space propagation term, the angular propagation term, and the terms describing the observer corrections [17]. In particular, to determine the “matched” finite differencing for ∂lnρ 2v + (18) A ≡ µ2 ∂t r v (19) B ≡ (1 − µ2 ) r we begin by multiplying the discrete representation of the left-hand side of the Boltzmann equation (2) (sans the terms describing the observer corrections) by 1 + µ¯ vi+1 (in what follows, unless otherwise specified the indices are i , j , and k ):
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
F − F¯ cdt 4πµ 2 [¯ r ρ¯i+1 Fi+1 − r¯i2 ρ¯i Fi ] + (1 + µ¯ vi+1 )E dm i+1 2 − r¯i2 ) 1 3(¯ ri+1 + (1 + µ¯ vi+1 )E [ζj+1 Fj+1 − ζj Fj ] 3 2(¯ ri+1 − r¯32 ) w vi+1 )E F¯ (1 + µvi+1 )EF − (1 + µ¯ = cdt vi+1 EF µvi+1 EF − µ¯ − cdt 4πµ 2 + [(1 + µ¯ vi+1 )E r¯i+1 ρ¯i+1 Fi+1 − (1 + µ¯ vi )E r¯i2 ρ¯i Fi ] dm 4πµ2 [¯ vi+1 r¯i2 ρ¯i EFi − v¯i r¯i2 ρ¯i EFi ] − dm 2 − r¯i2 ) 1 3(¯ ri+1 + [ζj+1 EFj+1 − ζj EFj ] 3 2(¯ ri+1 − r¯32 ) w (1 + µ¯ vi+1 )E
+ =
49
(20)
2 − r¯i2 ) 3(¯ ri+1 1 v¯i+1 [µζj+1 EFj+1 − µζj EFj ] 3 2 2(¯ ri+1 − r¯3 ) w vi+1 )E F¯ (1 + µvi+1 )EF − (1 + µ¯
cdt vi+1 µvi+1 − µ¯ − EF cdt 2 − r¯i2 ) 1 3(¯ ri+1 [ζj+1 EFj+1 − ζj EFj ] + 3 2(¯ ri+1 − r¯32 ) w 4πµ 2 + [(1 + µ¯ vi+1 )E r¯i+1 ρ¯i+1 Fi+1 − (1 + µ¯ vi )E r¯i2 ρ¯i Fi ] dm 4πµ2 2 − r¯ ρ¯i EFi [¯ vi+1 − v¯i ] dm i 2 − r¯i2 ) 3(¯ ri+1 1 v¯i+1 [µζj+1 EFj+1 − µζj EFj ] . + 3 2(¯ ri+1 − r¯32 ) w As noted, the total energy equation is obtained when summing equations (13) and (14) and then integrating over m (the integration in µ and E has already taken place). In this sequence of integrations, the term involving A in (13) cancels with the term −4πr2 ρK E dv/dm in equation (14). We must ensure this happens in the discrete limit. Identifying the appropriate velocity gradient term in (21) and focusing on the appropriate integration (in this case, over m), we require that (below, the term involving A comes from the zeroth moment of first term in the observer correction (17) after an integration by parts; the term involving the velocity gradient is the next to last term in (21), corresponding to the first moment of the spatial propagation term in the Boltzmann equation (2)):
50
A. Mezzacappa et al.
Ai Fi dmi
i=1,imax−1
−
4πµ2 r¯i2 ρ¯i Fi (¯ vi+1 − v¯i )
i=1,imax−1
=
Ai Fi dmi
i=1,imax−1
−
4πµ2 r¯i2 (βi ρ¯i Fi + (1 − βi )¯ ρi −1 Fi −1 )(¯ vi+1 − v¯i )
i=1,imax−1,j≤jmax/2
−
4πµ2 r¯i2 (βi ρ¯i −1 Fi −1 + (1 − βi )¯ ρi Fi )(¯ vi+1 − v¯i )
i=1,imax−1,j≥jmax/2+1
=
Ai Fi dmi
i=1,imax−1
−
4πµ2 r¯i2 (¯ vi+1 − v¯i )βi ρ¯i Fi
i=1,imax−1,j≤jmax/2
−
2 4πµ2 r¯i+1 (¯ vi+2 − v¯i+1 )(1 − βi+1 )¯ ρi Fi
i=1,imax−2,j≤jmax/2
−
4πµ2 r¯i2 (¯ vi+1 − v¯i )(1 − βi )¯ ρi Fi
i=1,imax−1,j≥jmax/2+1
−
2 4πµ2 r¯i+1 (¯ vi+2 − v¯i+1 )βi+1 )¯ ρi Fi
i=1,imax−2,j≥jmax/2+1
=0,
(21)
which gives [17] Ai = 4πµ2
ρ¯i 2 (¯ r2 (¯ vi+1 − v¯i )βi + r¯i+1 (¯ vi+2 − v¯i+1 )(1 − βi+1 )) dmi i
(22)
for j ≤ jmax/2 and Ai = 4πµ2
ρ¯i 2 (¯ r2 (¯ vi+1 − v¯i )(1 − βi ) + r¯i+1 (¯ vi+2 − v¯i+1 )βi+1 ) dmi i
(23)
for j ≥ jmax/2 + 1. Similarly, defining B according to B≡
2 − r¯i2 3 r¯i+1 v¯i+1 B , 3 3 2 r¯i+1 − r¯i
(24)
and again focusing on the appropriate integration (in this case, over µ), we require that (below, the term involving B comes from the zeroth moment of the second term in the observer correction (17), after an integration by parts; the second term is the last term in (21), corresponding to the first moment of the angular propagation term):
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
0=
51
B Fj wj
j=1,jmax
2 [µj αj+1 Fj+1 − µj αj Fj ]wj w j=1,jmax j = B Fj wj +
j=1,jmax
+
2[µj αj+1 (γFj + (1 − γ)Fj +1 )
j=1,jmax
− µj αj (γFj −1 + (1 − γ)Fj )] B Fj wj = j=1,jmax
+
2[µj αj+1 γ − µj αj (1 − γ)]Fj
j=1,jmax
+
2µj −1 αj (1 − γ)Fj
j=2,jmax
+
(−2)µj +1 αj+1 γFj
j=1,jmax−1
=
B Fj wj
j=1,jmax
+
2γαj+1 (µj − µj +1 )Fj
j=1,jmax
+
2(1 − γ)αj (µj −1 − µj )Fj ,
(25)
j=1,jmax
which gives [17] Bj
2 − r¯i2 µj +1 − µj 3 r¯i+1 v¯i+1 2γαj+1 3 3 2 r¯i+1 − r¯i wj µj − µj −1 . + 2(1 − γ)αj wj =
(26)
3.6 Frequency Shift from Observer Motion For comoving observers, we must account for the observed shift in the frequency of a neutrino measured by two neighboring observers moving with different velocities. Motivated by the definitions (18) and (19), the observer correction, (17), can be written as ∂ 3 ∂F 3 E F . + µ2 A − B E (27) 0=E ∂t E ∂E
52
A. Mezzacappa et al.
It has been found in [10] and [14] that (27) has an analytical solution. One may write [14] the prefactor in (27) as the time derivative of the quantity 2 2 Rf = r(3µ −1) ρ(µ ) : ∂lnRf = µ2 A − B . ∂t If we transform from the “Eulerian” variable, x = E, to the “Lagrangian” variable, y = E/Rf , (27) becomes ∂ 3 ∂ 3 ∂Rf E F E F 0= + 2 E × Rf ∂t R ∂t ∂E f E ∂ E3F ∂ 3 ∂ [E/Rf ] ∂ 3 E F = E F − . = ∂t ∂t ∂t E E ∂ [E/Rf ] E/Rf For a small section of energy phase space E 2 ∆E = E23 − E13 /3, this relationship leads to ∂ 2 E F ∆E =0. (28) ∂t E/Rf The validity of (28) for arbitrary neutrino distributions F leads to the following interpretation: The neutrinos initially residing in the energy interval E 2 ∆E move, according to the observer correction, along constant E/Rf in the phase space of a comoving observer. This allows us to determine the evolution of any neutrino property. For example, the neutrino specific energy in this phase space interval, d = E 3 F ∆E, evolves according to ∂E ∂ 3 ∂lnRf 2 E F ∆E d . (29) = E F ∆E = ∂t ∂t E/Rf ∂t E/Rf A finite difference representation of (28) and (29) has been given in [14]. Consider a neutrino energy group k , with neighboring groups k + dk, dk = ±1. Equation (28) tells us that the number of neutrinos before the comoving observer correction, Fi ,j ,k Ek2 dEk , is equal to the number of neutrinos after the correction. The distribution after the correction has a diminished number of neutrinos Fi ,j ,k Ek2 dEk − n− i ,j ,k in group k and an additional number + of neutrinos ni ,j ,k +dk in the neighboring group k + dk, Fi ,j ,k Ek2 dEk −
+ Fi ,j ,k Ek2 dEk − n− i ,j ,k + ni ,j ,k +dk = 0 .
(30)
Equation (29) defines a similar correction for the specific neutrino energy in group k
+ +dk n + E Fi ,j ,k Ek3 dEk − Fi ,j ,k Ek3 dEk − Ek n− k i ,j ,k i ,j ,k +dk 2 3 (31) = − µj Ai ,k − Bi ,j ,k Fi ,j ,k Ek dEk dt .
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
53
where Ai ,k and Bi ,j ,k are given by (22), (23), and (26). Equations (30) and (31) uniquely define the solution 2 n− i ,j ,k = µj Ai ,k − Bi ,j ,k
dEk E 3 Fi ,j ,k dt Ek +dk − Ek k
− n+ i ,j ,k = ni ,j ,k −dk ,
(32)
− 2 which leads, by the update Fi ,j ,k = F i ,j ,k + n+ − n i ,j ,k i ,j ,k / Ek dEk , to the following finite difference representation of the frequency shift term in the Boltzmann equation (2): 1 Ek2 dEk × µ2j Ai ,k −dk − Bi ,j ,k − µ2j Ai ,k
dEk −dk E 3 Fi ,j ,k −dk Ek − Ek −dk k −dk dEk − Bi ,j ,k Ek3 Fi ,j ,k . Ek +dk − Ek
(33)
3.7 Angular Aberration from Observer Motion We are left with the task of finding a finite difference representation for the angular aberration in (2). Because the global energy depends on (1 + ui µj ) Fi ,j ,k , any correction to the neutrino propagation direction also affects energy conservation. Therefore, it is desirable to construct a numerical implementation of angular aberration that conserves the specific neutrino luminosity µj Fi ,j ,k wj [17], much like our numerical implementation of the frequency shift preserved the specific neutrino energy. With ζ = 1 − µ2 , the angular aberration term can be rewritten as ∂F ∂ [ζµF ] . (34) = (A + B/ζ) ∂t µ ∂µ As before, we search for an analytic solution. For the quantity Ra = r3 ρ, we find dlnRa = A + B/ζ . dt It is now possible to rewrite (34) in terms of the “Lagrangian” variable y = ζ −1/2 µ/Ra instead of the “Eulerian” variable x = µ. After a multiplication by ζµ, (34) becomes:
54
A. Mezzacappa et al.
∂ [ζµF ] 0 = ζµ + α (A + B/ζ) ∂µ µ ∂ ∂ ∂Ra [ζµF ] + ζ −1/2 µ 2 × ζ 3/2 Ra [ζµF ] = ∂t Ra ∂t ∂µ µ ∂ [ζµF ] = ∂t µ −1/2 ∂ ζ µ/Ra ∂ ∂ [ζµF ] [ζµF ] − . = ∂t ∂t ∂ ζ −1/2 µ/Ra ζ −1/2 µ/Ra
∂F ∂t
µ
And once again, is clear. The neutrinos initially residing the interpretation = ζ µ − ζ1 µ1 are shifted by angular aberration in the interval 1 − 3µ2 ∆µ 2 2 √ along constant µ/ ζRa in the phase space of a comoving observer: ∂ 2 1 − 3µ F ∆µ =0. (35) ∂t ζ −1/2 µ/Ra We may now evaluate the change in other neutrino properties; for example, the specific luminosity, d = 1 − 3µ2 µF ∆µ, ∂ ∂µ 1 − 3µ2 µF ∆µ = 1 − 3µ2 F ∆µ ∂t ∂t ζ −1/2 /Ra −1/2 ζ µ/Ra =ζ
∂lnRa d . ∂t
(36)
We identify the bin size 1 − 3µ2j ∆µj = wj with our Gaussian quadrature weights. Equation (35) leads to the condition for number conservation:
+ Fi ,j ,k wj − Fi ,j ,k wj − n− i ,j ,k + ni ,j +dj,k = 0 and (36) leads to a prescription for the numerical evolution of the specific luminosity:
+ Fi ,j ,k µj wj − Fi ,j ,k µj wj − µj n− i ,j ,k + µj +dj ni ,j +dj,k = − (ζj Ai ,k + Bi ,j ,k ) Fi ,j ,k µj wj dt . where dj = ±1. The change in the neutrino distribution from angular aberration is then: − − n (37) /wj Fi ,j ,k = F i ,j ,k + n+ i ,j ,k i ,j ,k with n− i ,j ,k = (Ai ,k + Bi ,j ,k /ζj )
− n+ i ,j ,k = ni ,j −dj,k .
wj ζj µj Fi ,j ,k dt µj +dj − µj
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
55
This leads to the following finite difference representation of the angular aberration term in the Boltzmann equation (2): 1 wj −dj ζj −dj µj −dj Fi ,j −dj,k (Ai ,k + Bi ,j −dj,k /ζj −dj ) wj µj − µj −dj wj − (Ai ,k + Bi ,j ,k /ζj ) ζj µj Fi ,j ,k . (38) µj +dj − µj We apply the aberration corrections with dj = +1 for µ ≤ 0 and dj = −1 for µ > 0. This is not upwind differencing and, therefore, runs the risk of producing negative neutrino distribution functions. However, there are three reasons to accept this shortcoming: (i) The angular aberration correction is generally small, with the exception of aberration in the vicinity of strong shocks with large velocity gradients. (ii) As long as the angle-integrated neutrino density is positive, transiently negative contributions from backward directions on the Gaussian angular grid (µ < 0) allow the computer representation of strongly forward peaked neutrino fluxes that would not be representable with positive neutrino distribution functions on a grid with limited angles µmax < 1. (iii) The chosen direction of dj guarantees that no neutrinos are shifted off the grid. This is a prerequisite for number and energy conservation.
4 The General Case: The Multidimensional Neutrino Transport Equations As the previous sections illustrate, one of the greatest challenges encountered when developing the numerical methods to obtain a physically reliable solution of the neutrino transport equations in core collapse supernovae is to achieve simultaneous lepton number and energy conservation or balance, the former for massless neutrinos and Newtonian gravity, where lepton number is conserved and where the concept of a conserved energy can be defined in multiple spatial dimensions, the latter for the general relativistic case in two and three spatial dimensions. The first step in meeting this challenge is to derive the conservative lepton number and energy conservation/balance equations, which at a more fundamental level means finding the corresponding evolved variables that naturally lend themselevs to a conservative decription of the neutrino radiation field. As we will see, both the conservation/balance equations and the fundamental variables can be extracted from the underlying kinetic theory at a point in the theory where the fundamental physical laws are manifestly conservative [20]. The distribution function f represents the density of neutrinos in phase space. The phase space for neutrinos of definite mass m, Mm , is filled with ˆ trajectories xµ (λ), pi (λ) , or “states”. As a collection of neutrinos evolves, the number of neutrinos in each state changes due to collisions. If one considers a 6-dimensional hypersurface Σ in Mm , the ensemble-averaged number
56
A. Mezzacappa et al.
N [Σ] of occupied states crossing Σ is N [Σ] =
fω ,
(39)
Σ
where ω is the surface element. An equation governing the evolution of the distribution function is obtained by considering a closed 6-dimensional hypersurface ∂D bounding a region D in Mm . The net number of occupied states emerging from D is, from (39) and the generalized Stokes’ theorem, N [∂D] = fω = d(f ω) . (40) ∂D
D
This equation relates a volume integral to a surface integral and is key to obtaining conservative formulations of kinetic theory. In fact, in rushing headlong in deriving the general relativistic Boltzmann equation ∂f ρˆ ∂f = C[f ] . (41) pµˆ Λµ¯ µˆ eµ µ¯ µ − Γ νˆ ρˆ ˆµ p ∂x ∂pνˆ from (40), (40) is easily overlooked. Here Λµµ¯ is the Lorentz boost between the orthonormal lab and (fluid) comoving frames and eµµ¯ is the tetrad transformation between the coordinate basis and the orthonormal lab frame. The integrand on the right-hand side of (40), d(f ω), is in conservative form. Manipulating it just enough to bring it into the form d(f ω) = F [f ]Ω, where Ω is the volume element in phase space, yields a conservative formulation of neutrino number kinetics, and manipulating the exterior derivative d(vµ pµ f ω), for an arbitrary timelike vector vµ , yields a conservative formulation of neutrino four-momentum kinetics. Defining the specific neutrino number flux vector (42) N µ ≡ Lµ µˆ pµˆ f and the specific neutrino stress-energy tensor T µν ≡ Lµ µˆ Lν νˆ pµˆ pνˆ f ,
(43)
where Lµˆ µ = eµµ¯ Λµµ¯ is the transformation to the comoving frame, the conservative kinetic equations for neutrino number and four-momentum are: 1 ∂ √ √ −gN µ µ −g ∂x −1 ˆi ∂p ˆj ∂p ∂ ∂u 1 − E(p) det det Γ µˆνˆ pνˆ ˆj Lµˆ µ N µ ∂u ∂uˆi E(p) ∂u ∂p = C[f ] ,
(44)
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
57
∂ √ 1 √ −gT µν + Γ µ νρ T νρ ν −g ∂x −1 ˆi ∂p ˆj ∂p ∂ 1 ρˆ ∂u ν ˆ µν − E(p) det L νT det Γ νˆρˆp ∂u ∂uˆi E(p) ∂u ∂pˆj = F µ ν N ν + Lµ µˆ pµˆ C[f ] .
(45)
√
where −g is the determinant of the spacetime metric. The adjective “specific” often denotes a quantity measured per unit mass, but in this context we use it to denote the neutrino flux and stress-energy in a given invariant momentum space volume element. While the distribution function f obeys the Boltzmann equation (41), the specific neutrino number flux and stressenergy satisfy the conservative equations (44) and (45). In stating that (44) and (45) constitute conservative formulations of neutrino kinetics, we mean that the connection to the corresponding balance equations is transparent. We can use elementary calculus to form the familiar invariant momentum space volume element ∂p 3 1 d3 p = (46) det d u , E(p) E(p) ∂u ˆ where a transformation from orthonormal momentum components pi to some other set of coordinates (e.g., momentum space spherical coordinates ˆi u = {|p|, ϑ, ϕ}) has been performed. Multiplying equations (44) and (45) by (46) and integrating, the terms with momentum space derivatives are obviously transformed into vanishing surface terms. The results are the balance equations ∂ √ 1 µ √ −gN = C[f ]πm , (47) −g ∂xµ 1 ∂ √ νµ ν ρµ √ = −Γ −gT T + C[f ]Lν νˆ pνˆ πm . (48) ρµ −g ∂xµ for total neutrino number and 4-momentum, where N µ and T µν are the neutrino number current and stress-energy tensor, respectively. In the above √ equations, πm = −g0ijk dpi ∧ dpj ∧ dpk //6|p0 | is the invariant volume element on a mass shell corresponding to the mass m in the tangent space [20]. In the previous sections, we presented a detailed account of how one obtains a conservative differencing for the equation governing the evolution of the specific neutrino distribution function for spherically symmetric flows. Working with comoving frame neutrino four momenta, the conservation of total lab frame energy required a matching of the finite differencing of the radial, angular, and energy advection terms in this equation. One can, of course, take a different approach. While the use of comoving frame four momenta for the neutrinos is a prerequisite given the neutrino interactions with the stellar core, which are most naturally and most simply expressed in terms of these
58
A. Mezzacappa et al.
four momenta, the use of comoving frame neutrino densities (number, energy, . . . ) may not be the best choice. Given that the global lab frame energy is conserved, working with densities in this frame that are expressed in terms of comoving frame neutrino four momenta might be the right combination considering both local neutrino interactions and global energy conservation. Nonetheless, however natural this latter approach might seem, we are still not free of the need to match the finite difference representations for various terms in the kinetic equations, as we now show. Consider the relationship between (44) for neutrino number kinetics and the t component of (45) for neutrino 4-momentum kinetics. Specifically, we need to relate the spatial and momentum divergence terms of these equations to each other and identify terms that cancel. First we relate the spatial and momentum divergence terms of (44) and the t component of (45). Their spatial divergence terms ∂ √ 1 −gLµ µˆ pµˆ f , Nx [f ] ≡ √ µ −g ∂x t ∂ √ 1 T x [f ] ≡ √ −gLt νˆ Lµ µˆ pνˆ pµˆ f , −g ∂xµ
(49) (50)
are related by ∂ Lt νˆ pνˆ Nx [f ] = T t x [f ] − f pµˆ pνˆ Lµ µˆ µ Lt νˆ . ∂x
(51)
Their momentum divergence terms Np [f ]
−1 ˆi ∂p ∂p ˆj ∂ 1 µ ˆ ρˆ ∂u f , (52) ≡ −E(p) det det Γ µˆρˆp p ∂u ∂uˆi E(p) ∂u ∂pˆj t T p [f ] −1 ∂p ≡ −E(p) det ∂u ˆi ∂p ˆj ∂ 1 µ ˆ ρˆ ∂u t ν ˆ × L νˆ p f , (53) det Γ µˆρˆp p ∂u ∂uˆi E(p) ∂pˆj are related by ˆ ∂ui ∂pνˆ ˆ Lt νˆ pνˆ Np [f ] = T t p [f ] + f Γ j µˆρˆpµˆ pρˆ ˆ Lt νˆ . ∂pj ∂uˆi
(54)
Comparison of (51) and (54) with (44) and the t component of (45) shows that the following equation must be valid:
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
ES + EM = −Γ t µρ Lµ µˆ Lρ ρˆpµˆ pρˆ ,
59
(55)
where
∂ t L νˆ (56) ∂xµ is the “extra” term of (51) relating the spatial divergence terms of the number and energy balance equations, and ES ≡ f pµˆ pνˆ Lµ µˆ
ˆ
ˆ
EM ≡ −f Γ j µˆρˆpµˆ pρˆ
∂ui
∂pˆj
Lt νˆ
∂pνˆ ∂uˆi
(57)
is the “extra” term in (54) relating the momentum divergence terms of the number and energy balance equations. In a computational approach to transport in which a neutrino number distribution equation is solved and a neutrino energy equation is used as a consistency check, care must be taken that (55) is satisfied numerically. In particular, a given finite difference representation of the spacetime divergence Nx [f ] implies a corresponding finite difference representation of positiondependent terms in ES , and the position-dependent terms in EM that cancel with their counterparts in ES must have a matching finite difference representation. Similarly, a given finite difference representation of the momentum divergence Np [f ] implies a corresponding finite difference representation of momentum-dependent terms in EM , and the momentum-dependent terms in ES that cancel with their counterparts in EM must have a matching finite difference representation. It is important to note that (44) and (45) are general; i.e., they can be expressed in any spatial coordinate system using any neutrino four-momenta. If one specializes these equations to the comoving frame spatial coordinates and four-momenta used in the spherically symmetric case detailed herein and to the O(v/c) limit, one finds that ES + EM = 0. The finite difference matching constructed in Sect. 6.5 guarantees that this sum is satisfied numerically in this case. In the general case, the sum is not zero and the number of terms is significantly greater, but the basic task is the same. The essential point is that we now have the complete framework within which to carry it out.
5 Boltzmann Neutrino Transport: The Current State of the Art After four decades of core collapse supernova research, detailed spherically symmetric simulations that now include state of the art neutrino interactions, an industry standard equation of state, and multiangle, multifrequency, Boltzmann neutrino transport in full general relativity have finally been performed [22]. It is important to remember that we are working in phase space.
60
A. Mezzacappa et al.
Therefore, simulations that assume spherical symmetry and require a solution of the neutrino Boltzmann equation are actually simulations in three dimensions (radius or mass, direction cosine, and energy), not one dimension (radius). When cast in this light, it is not surprising that such threedimensional multiphysics simulations have taken four decades to complete. This is also an omen of what will be required to perform such simulations in three spatial dimensions (six phase space dimensions). Despite this seemingly overwhelming requirement, we must proceed in a systematic and steadfast manner. A typical result for these simulations is shown in (Fig. 4). The shock radius reaches a maximum and then recedes with time, indicating a failure of the stellar core to explode and initiate a core collapse supernova. The results shown here are for a 13 M model, an “optimistic” case owing to the small size of its iron core (1.2 M , but the outcome is the same for progenitors of 15, 20, 25, and 40 M , all of which have more massive cores). The shock trajectories for both the Newtonian and general relativistic cases are shown. In the general relativistic case, owing to the increased gravitational field, the shock radius is always deeper. However, the inclusion of general relativity does not necessarily present a more pessimistic case, as might appear by considering the shock radius results out of context [17]. In Fig. 5, a more complete picture is presented for both the Newtonian and general relativistic simulations. Shown are all of the core profiles in density, entropy, electron fraction, velocity, and composition, along with the three key neutrino quan-
Newton+O(v/c) Relativistic
3
Radius [km]
10
2
10
1
10
0
0.1
0.2 0.3 Time After Bounce [s]
0.4
0.5
Fig. 4. The shock trajectories are plotted as a function of time for both the Newtonian and fully general relativistic spherically symmetric models in the case of a 13 M progenitor [22]. The shock recedes with time in both cases, indicative of a failed explosion. This result is typical for all spherically symmetric models
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae 4
1 Velocity, u [km/s]
(b) grid points
0 −1 −2 −3 −4 −5 −6 5
10
20
Baryon Density, log10(ρ [g/cm3])
(a)
x 10
61
Newton+O(v/c) Relativistic
14 12 10 8 6
50 100 200 500 1000 2000 5000 Radius, r [km]
5
10
20
50 100 200 500 1000 2000 5000 Radius, r [km]
(c)
(d)
18 0.5
16
Electron Fraction, Ye
Entropy per Baryon, s [kB])
20
14 12 10 8 6 4
0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1
2 0 5
10
20
50 100 200 500 1000 2000 5000 Radius, r [km]
5
10
20
50 100 200 500 1000 2000 5000 Radius, r [km]
(e)
(f)
100 Xh X +X n p X
50 Mass Fraction, X
Luminosity, L [1052erg/s]
0.5
20 10 5 4 3 2 1
0.2 0.1 0.05
α
0.01
0.001
0.0001 5
10
20
50 100 200 500 1000 2000 5000 Radius, r [km]
5
10
20
(g)
(h) Neutrino Energy, Erms [MeV]
Mean Flux Factor, F
1 0.8 ν spheres 0.6 0.4 0.2 0
50 100 200 500 1000 2000 5000 Radius, r [km]
200 150
e Neutrino e Antineutrino
100 75 50 30 20 15 10 7.5 5
5
10
20
50 100 200 500 1000 2000 5000 Radius, r [km]
5
10
20
50 100 200 500 1000 2000 5000 Radius, r [km]
Fig. 5. The velocity, density, entropy, electron fraction, electron neutrino and antineutrino luminosity, composition, electron neutrino and antineutrino flux factor and rms energy profiles at 100 ms after bounce in Newtonian and general relativistic spherically symmetric models initiated from a 13 M progenitor [22]
62
A. Mezzacappa et al.
tities mentioned above—luminosity, rms energy, and mean flux factor—for both the electron neutrinos and antineutrinos. It is important to point out that, until these simulations were completed, failure to produce explosions in past models that used approximate treatments for the neutrino transport (e.g., multigroup flux-limited diffusion; see [6, 23–26]) could have resulted from either the transport approximations or from the neglect of essential physics. We could not have known a priori which of these possibilities would in fact be realized. We now know that the transport approximations were not the cause of these failures and, as a result, have crossed a threshold in supernova theory: new physics is needed. Nonetheless, the move from multigroup flux-limited diffusion to Boltzmann neutrino transport led to important quantitative changes in the spherically symmetric models, as might have been expected given the sensitivity of the neutrino heating to the neutrino luminosities, spectra, and angular distributions in the postshock region. Moreover, in spherical symmetry, the Boltzmann results have been used to tune the flux-limiters to better reproduce the Boltzmann results [18]. Thus, Boltzmann solvers for the two- and three-dimensional cases must be developed in conjunction with solvers using approximate techniques, such as two- and three-dimensional multigroup flux limited diffusion [26]. The latter, of course, must be utilized until PetaScale resources (for three-dimensional models) become available. Efforts by several groups are now underway to develop Boltzmann neutrino transport for these cases [20,21,27,28]. The simulations performed thus far have been confined to the Newtonian gravity, O(1) limit, restricted not only by Newtonian gravity but by the exclusion of the O(v/c) terms on the left-hand side of the Boltzmann equation mentioned above [28]. The observer corrections are critical in the evolution of the comoving frame neutrino distributions and in the dynamics of stellar collapse [10–12, 29]. They cannot be excluded from any realistic model, as Figs. 6–7 show. In these spherically symmetric collapses, by the time the central density reaches a value of 1×1014 g/cm3 , the maximum infall velocity, inner homologous core mass, and entropy throughout the inner core are significantly different for the collapse simulation in which the O(v/c) terms have been neglected [30]. In addition, without the O(v/c) terms, the neutrino distributions at a given energy can significantly exceed unity, which is unphysical. The O(v/c) terms are responsible for properly redistributing the neutrinos in energy (to higher energy) as the collapse proceeds. If they are neglected, some neutrinos in energy groups for which f > 1 must be discarded so that f = 1 (or handled in some other ad hoc fashion), and energy and lepton number will not be conserved. Figure 7 illustrates the extent to which the conservation breaks down. At a central density of 1 × 1014 g/cm3 , we have lost nearly 3 × 1051 erg. While discarding the neutrinos is only one ad hoc way to manage the error incurred when the O(v/c) terms are neglected, these results clearly demonstrate the impact these terms have not only on the neutrino distributions, but on the dynamics
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
63
Fig. 6. The entropy and velocity profiles as a function of enclosed mass at a central density of 1014 g/cm3 for spherically symmetric models with and without the O(v/c) “observer corrections” [30]. The differences between the two cases are striking
of stellar collapse and the conservation of total energy and lepton number. Not only can they not be neglected, they must be included with great care.
6 Previews of Coming Distractions: Neutrino Flavor Transformation It is now an experimental fact that neutrinos have mass and, therefore, mix in flavor. Observations of Solar and atmospheric neutrinos, and experiments at LSND, indicate there may be as many as three independent values of the difference in the square of the neutrino masses (δm2 ), and four mixing angles, which would require three active and at least one sterile neutrino. Although we await confirmation (or not) of the LSND findings, the data already strongly suggest that neutrino mixing should be included in core collapse supernova models. Neutrino mixing may significantly affect one or more of the following: the supernova mechanism, supernova nucleosynthesis, and terrestrial supernova neutrino detection. As we discussed earlier, all three active neutrino flavors are involved in core collapse supernova dynamics. Electron, muon, and tau neutrinos and their antineutrinos are produced primarily through thermal emission,
64
A. Mezzacappa et al.
Fig. 7. The total energy versus central density for the same models shown in Fig. 6. The model without the observer corrections has clearly lost an energy ∼3 × 1051 ergs prior to stellar core bounce
nucleon–nucleon bremsstrahlung, and neutral-current neutrino–neutrino annihilation in the hot mantle of the proto-neutron star after core bounce. Owing to the lack of charged-current interactions among the muon and tau neutrinos and antineutrinos, electron neutrino and antineutrinos decouple at lower densities given their larger total interaction cross sections. Decoupling at lower densities and, consequently, lower temperatures results in softer relative spectra for the electron flavor neutrinos [31]. Herein lies the essential relevance of neutrino mixing to the supernova mechanism: If flavor conversion between electron flavor and muon/tau flavor neutrinos were to occur below the supernova shock wave in the neutrino heating epoch after stellar core bounce, the neutrino heating behind the shock, which is mediated predominantly by the charged-current absorption of electron neutrinos and antineutrinos, could be significantly increased [32, 33]. The softer electron neutrino flavor spectra would be replaced by the harder muon/tau neutrino flavor spectra in this region. Even if neutrino flavor conversion did not occur deep in the stellar core— in or above the proto-neutron star after core bounce—and, therefore, was not a major factor in initiating the explosion, our ability to use the next Galactic supernova neutrino detection to improve supernova models, better understand the complex dynamics of core collapse supernovae, and cull fundamental nuclear and particle physics from it, would be severly compromised
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
65
if we did not have a way to predict the flavor conversion that could occur between the source supernova and terrestrial detectors. The argument to consider neutrino mixing in the core collapse supernova context, particularly with an eye toward the explosion mechanism, has been made even more compelling recently with the discovery that neutrino mixing may occur deep in the stellar core after bounce at small values of δm2 [34, 35]. This mixing may arise as a result of the neutrino background in and above the proto-neutron star, which would be fundamentally different than MSW mixing induced by the matter background, or vacuum mixing. Neutral-current neutrino–neutrino forward scattering increases the neutrino effective mass, much as charged-current electron-neutrino scattering increases the electron-neutrino effective mass in the MSW case. The net result may be near maximal mixing of neutrino flavors in the environment of the protoneutron star after bounce [34, 35], with obvious ramifications for the supernova mechanism, nucleosynthesis, and neutrino signatures. Pantaleone [36,37] was the first to recognize that a background neutrino, in a superposition of flavor states, would lead to an off-diagonal refractive index in flavor space if neutrino–neutrino interactions are taken into account. This idea was then further developed by Sigl and Raffelt [38]. Matter-enhanced neutrino mixing has been included in an approximate way in past (spherically symmetric) models of core collapse supernovae using a simple Landau-Zener prescription [32,33,39]. In such a prescription, the probability of mixing in the resonance region as a function of neutrino energy is computed, and the commensurate fraction of neutrinos is simply converted from one flavor to the other. This prescription is easily implemented in spherically symmetric models, where a resonance region is a spherical shell. While the experimental evidence for neutrino mixing is now clear, and while a number of past exploratory studies have elucidated some of the possible ramifications neutrino mixing may have for core collapse supernova dynamics, the precise impact of such flavor transformation remains to be determined. Neutrino mixing is a coherent, quantum mechanical phenomenon, unlike the incoherent collisional phenomena included in the Boltzmann kinetic equations discussed earlier. A more complete (quantum kinetic) treatment of neutrino transport in stellar cores beyond (classical) Boltzmann transport will be needed if we are to accurately and fully explore the impact of neutrino mixing on core collapse supernova dynamics.
7 Summary and Prospects Neutrino transport in core collapse supernovae is arguably the quintessential transport application. (1) The energy radiated in neutrinos in the course of a core collapse supernova is 10–100 times the supernova explosion energy. Errors in simulating the neutrino radiation field can, therefore, be catastrophic in determining the explosion characteristics etched in the turbulent stellar
66
A. Mezzacappa et al.
core fluid flow to which the neutrinos are coupled. (2) Core collapse supernovae are still believed to be powered by the intense neutrino flux emitted by the proto-neutron star, through neutrino heating of the postshock material. This neutrino heating is sensitive to the neutrino luminosities, spectra, and angular distributions—that is, to the neutrino distribution functions. (3) The gravitational fields in and around the proto-neutron star and the explosive stellar core flow deviate significantly from nonrelativistic values. This requires an extension of the discrete ordinates method to accommodate angular aberration and frequency shift owing to special and general relativistic effects. (4) Neutrinos are leptons, and for zero neutrino mass at least, lepton number is conserved. Moreover, the deleptonization of the stellar core during collapse determines the initial conditions at shock formation: the initial shock radius and the energy imparted to the shock, which set the stage for the supernova dynamics that follows. Given that both lepton number and energy must be conserved, a finite difference representation of the original continuum Boltzmann equations that conserves both must be developed, which presents a significant technical challenge, as we have demonstrated here. Despite the challenge, significant progress has been made. First, a deep and precise understanding of the above issues has been achieved. Second, a conservative (in lepton number and energy)numerical method has been developed for general relativistic spherically symmetric flows, and a clear path forward, albeit difficult from a practical perspective, has been identified for the multidimensional case. Stellar core collapse simulations in full general relativity with Boltzmann neutrino transport have been performed, marking a milestone in supernova theory. The hope is we will be able to perform twodimensional special relativistic simulations with Boltzmann neutrino transport within the next two years. Despite the significant advances made to date and the clear path forward in the case of zero neutrino masses, the experimental confirmation that neutrinos have mass fundamentally alters the game. The classical Boltzmann kinetic equations are now only half the story. Coherent quantum mechanical mixing of neutrino flavors must be included in the models along with the collisional physics included before. Thus, full quantum kinetic neutrino transport is now being developed in the spherically symmetric case and, based on the outcome of these future simulations, neutrino quantum kinetics in two- and ultimately three-dimensional simulations may need to be developed.
Acknowledgments A.M., C.Y.C., and O.E.B.M. are supported at the Oak Ridge National Laboratory, which is managed by UT-Battelle, LLC for the DOE under contract DE-AC05-00OR22725. A.M., C.Y.C., and S.W.B. are also supported in part by a DOE Scientific Discovery through Advanced Computing grant through
Neutrino Transport in Core Collapse Supernovae
67
the Office of Science Advanced Scientific Computing Research, High Energy Physics, and Nuclear Physics Programs.
References [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28]
Wilson JR. in Numerical Astrophysics, ed. JM Centrella, JM LeBlanc, RL Bowers. Boston: Jones and Bartlett (1985) Bethe HA, Wilson JR. Astrophysical Journal 295:14 (1985) Janka HT. Astronomy and Astrophysics 368:527 (2001) Burrows A, Goshy J. Astrophysical Journal Letters 416:L75 (1993) Janka HT, M¨ uller E. Astronomy and Astrophysics 306:167 (1996) Messer OEB, Mezzacappa A, Bruenn SW, Guidry MW. Astrophysical Journal 507:353 (1998) Mezzacappa A, Calder AC, Bruenn SW, Blondin JM, Guidry MW, Strayer MR, Umar AS. Astrophysical Journal 495:911 (1998) Mezzacappa A, Liebend¨ orfer M, Messer OEB, Hix WR, Thielemann FK, Bruenn SW. Physical Review Letters, 86:1935 (2001) Castor J. Astrophysical Journal 178:779 (1972) Bruenn SW. Astrophysical Journal Supplement 58:771 (1985) Mezzacappa A, Bruenn SW. Astrophysical Journal 405:637 (1993) Mezzacappa A, Bruenn SW. Astrophysical Journal 410:740 (1993) Burrows A, Thompson T. in Stellar Collapse, ed. C Fryer. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers (2004) Mezzacappa A, Bruenn SW. Astrophysical Journal 405:669 (1993) Lewis E, Miller W. in Computational Methods of Neutron Transport. New York: Wiley-Interscience (1984) Mezzacappa A, Messer OEB. Journal of Computational and Applied Mathematics109:281 (1998) Liebend¨ orfer M, Ph.D. thesis, University of Basel, Basel, Switzerland (2000) Liebend¨ orfer M, Messer OEB, Mezzacappa A, Bruenn SW, Cardall CY, Thielemann FK. Astrophysical Journal Supplement 150:263 (2004) Mezzacappa A, Liebend¨ orfer M, Cardall C, Messer O, Bruenn S. in Stellar Collapse, ed. C Fryer. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers (2004) Cardall C, Mezzacappa A. Physical Review D 68:023006 (2003) Cardall C, Lentz E, Mezzacappa A. Physical Review D submitted (2005) Liebend¨ orfer M, Mezzacappa A, Thielemann F, Messer OE, Hix WR, Bruenn SW. Physical Review D 63:103004 (2001) Wilson JR, Mayle RW. Physics Reports 227:97 (1993) Swesty F, Lattimer J. Astrophysical Journal 425:195 (1994) Bruenn SW, DeNisco KR, Mezzacappa A. Astrophysical Journal 560:326 (2001) Swesty F, Myra E. in Open Issues in Core Collapse Supernova Theory, ed. A Mezzacappa, G Fuller. Singapore: World Scientific (2005) Cardall C. in Numerical Methods for Multidimensional Radiative Transfer Problems, ed. R Rannacher, R Wehrse. Springer Publishing Company (2004) Livne E, Burrows A, Walder R, Lichtenstadt I, Thompson T. Astrophysical Journal 609:277 (2004)
68
A. Mezzacappa et al.
[29] Rampp M, Janka HT. Astronomy and Astrophysics 396:361 (2002) [30] Mezzacappa A, Messer O. Astrophysical Journal submitted (2005) [31] Burrows A, Thompson T. in Stellar Collapse, ed. C Fryer. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers (2004) [32] Fuller GM, Mayle R, Wilson JR, Schramm D. Astrophysical Journal 322:795 (1987) [33] Fuller GM, Mayle R, Meyer BS, Wilson JR. Astrophysical Journal 389:517 (1992) [34] Qian YZ, Fuller G. Physical Review D 52:656 (1995) [35] Fuller G, Qian YZ. Physical Review D submitted (2005) [36] Pantaleone J. Physics Letters B 287:128 (1992) [37] Pantaleone J. Physics Letters B 342:250 (1995) [38] Sigl G, Raffelt G. Nuclear Physics B 406:423 (1993) [39] Mezzacappa A, Bruenn SW. in The Identification of Dark Matter, ed. N Spooner, V Kudryavtsev. Singapore: World Scientific (1999)
Discrete-Ordinates Methods for Radiative Transfer in the Non-Relativistic Stellar Regime Jim E. Morel Mail Stop D413, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico 87545
[email protected]
1 Introduction The purpose of this paper is to briefly describe the application of discreteordinates methods to radiative transfer in the non-relativistic stellar regime. We consider the non-relativistic regime to be characterized by material velocities less than or equal to one percent of the speed of light. In most applications, the radiative transfer equations are coupled to the hydrodynamics equations. We first describe a radiation-hydrodynamics model that consists of the Euler equations and the radiation transport equation together with approximations for material-motion effects based upon the assumption of non-relativistic material velocities. For simplicity, we next focus on a model of radiative transfer in a static medium that is adequate for the purpose of describing numerical discretization and solution techniques for the transfer equation that can also be applied in the more general context of radiationhydrodynamics.
2 The Approximate Radiation-Hydrodynamics Model The hydrodynamics equations and the radiation moment equations can be expressed to O(v/c) as follows assuming a grey radiation transport approximation with the transfer equation cast in the Eulerian frame: • Conservation of fluid mass: ∂t ρ + ∂i (ρvi ) = 0 ,
(1)
• Conservation of fluid momentum: ∂t (ρvi ) + ∂j (ρvi vj ) + ∂i p =
σt vi F0,i − σa aT 4 − E0 , c c
(2)
70
J.E. Morel
• Conservation of total fluid energy: 1 2 1 2 ρv + ρe + ∂i ρv + ρe + p vi = ∂t 2 2 4 σt −cσa aT − E0 + vi F0,i , c
(3)
• Conservation of radiation momentum: 1 σt vi ∂t Fi + ∂j Pij = − F0,i + σa aT 4 − E0 , c2 c c
(4)
• Conservation of radiation energy: σt ∂t E + ∂i Fi = cσa aT 4 − E0 − vi F0,i , c
(5)
where ρ is the fluid density, vi is component i of the fluid velocity, c is the speed of light, p is the fluid pressure, e is the specific internal energy of the fluid, E is the radiation energy density, Fi is component i of the radiation flux, Pij is element ij of the radiation pressure tensor, E0 is the comoving-frame radiation energy density: E0 = E −
2 vi (Fi − vi E − vj Pij ) , c2
(6)
F0,i is component i of the comoving-frame radiation flux: F0,i = Fi − vi E − vj Pij ,
(7)
σt is the macroscopic total cross section, σa is the macroscopic absorption cross section, and a is the radiation constant. The source terms in (2) through (5) are expressed in terms of comoving-frame radiation variables. These comoving-frame variables are defined in terms of Eulerian-frame radiation variables by (6) and (7). When the comoving-frame variables are eliminated from (2) through (5) using (6) and (7), certain terms of O(v 2 /c2 ) will appear. Even though (2) through (5) are only correct to O(v/c), these terms are not to be neglected because they eliminate spurious equilibrium solutions [1] and maintain consistency between the Eulerian-frame and comoving-frame momentum and energy sources. We consider the nonrelativistic limit to be characterized by v/c ≤ 0.01. We next describe a very simple approximate model for radiation-hydrodynamics with multifrequency radiative transfer in the nonrelativistic limit. The goal of this approximation is to maintain accuracy in an integral sense while avoiding the complexities of the equations that are correct to O(v/c). Since v/c is very small in the nonrelativistic limit, one might be tempted to neglect material motion corrections to the radiative transfer equation entirely. However, over the course of a calculation, this can result in a significant loss of energy conservation because the kinetic energy change in the
Discrete-Ordinates Methods for Radiative Transfer
71
fluid due radiation momentum deposition is not removed from the radiation energy field. Thus we use a simple approximation for nonrelativistic radiation-hydrodynamics that has the following properties: • Total energy and momentum are conserved. • Equilibrium solutions are preserved to O( vc ). • The equilibrium diffusion limit is preserved to O( vc ). In the nonrelativistic case, there is little difference between E and E0 , but the relative difference between F0,i and Fi can be arbitrarily large. This relative difference is essentially infinite in the equilibrium state because F0,i = 0 while Fi = 43 vi E to O(v/c). Since the system is locally equilibrated in the equilibrium diffusion limit, it follows that one can expect a significant relative difference between F0,i and Fi in this limit. Hence it is generally considered important to preserve the equilibrium diffusion limit in any approximate treatment of nonrelativistic radiation-hydrodynamics. See [1] for a formal asymptotic derivation of the non-relativistic equilibrium diffusion limit. The first step in the derivation of our approximate model is modify the hydrodynamics equations and the grey radiation moment equations. Specifically, we make the following substitutions: σt vi σt F0,i − σa aT 4 − E0 ⇒ F0,i , (8a) c c c σt σt cσa aT 4 − E0 − vi F0,i ⇒ cσa aT 4 − E − vi F0,i , (8b) c c 4 F0,i = Fi − vi E − vj Pij ⇒ Fi − vi E , (8c) 3 The term neglected in (8a) is a purely relativistic term. Although the radiative transfer equation is always relativistic, the hydrodynamics equations are purely classical to O(v/c). Furthermore, this term is zero in the equilibrium diffusion limit. Thus it is reasonable to eliminate this term. In (8b) we replace E0 with E in the radiation energy source term. It can be seen from (6) that this should be a good approximation when v/c ≤ 0.01. Furthermore, E0 = E in the equilibrium diffusion limit. Finally, we substitute E/3 for Pi,j in (8c). This approximation is made simply to avoid calculating the radiation pressure tensor. This tensor plays a small role in a small term, and the substitution is exact in the equilibrium diffusion limit. The next step in the derivation is to replace the modified grey expressions with frequency-dependent expressions that are equivalent under the grey approximation. In particular, ∞ σt (ν) 4 vi σt F0,i ⇒ I(Ω, ν) Ωi − dΩ dν , (9a) c c 3 c 0 ∞4π
−→ σa (ν) B(ν) − I Ω , ν dΩ dν , cσa aT 4 − E ⇒ (9b) ∞0 4π −→ 4 vi I Ω ,ν F0,i ⇒ Ωi − dΩ dν , (9c) 3 c 0 4π
72
J.E. Morel
−→ −→ where Ω is the photon direction vector, ν is the photon frequency, I Ω , ν hν −1 3 exp kT −1 is the Planck function is the angular intensity, B = 2hν c2 and k is the Boltzmann constant. Expression (9b) represents an exact substitution, and (9c) represents a substitution that is exact to O(v/c). However, (9a) is simply incorrect unless σt is independent of frequency. The transformations between the Eulerian and co-moving frames being used here are only correct for angle-energy-integrated quantities [2]. The transformation relating the co-moving frame flux and the Eulerian frame flux is effectively being used for frequency-dependent fluxes in (9a). Accounting for all of these substitutions, our approximate hydrodynamic equations and multifrequency radiation moment equations can be expressed as follows: ∂t ρ + ∂i (ρvi ) = 0 ,
∞
0
4π
∂t (ρvi ) + ∂j (ρvi vj ) + ∂i p = σt (ν) −→ 4 vi I Ω ,ν Ωi − dΩ dν , c 3 c
1 2 1 2 ρv + ρe + ∂i ρv + ρe + p vi = 2 2 ∞
−→ − σa (ν) B(ν) − I Ω , ν dΩ dν 0 4π ∞ σt (ν) −→ 4 v2 I Ω ,ν vi Ω i − + dΩ dν , c 3 c 4π 0
(10)
(11)
∂t
∞
−
0
4π
1 ∂t Fi + ∂j Pij = c2 σt (ν) −→ 4 vi I Ω ,ν Ωi − dΩ dν , c 3 c
∂t E + ∂ i F i =
−→ σa (ν) B(ν) − I Ω , ν dΩ dν 0 4π ∞ σt (ν) −→ 4 v2 I Ω ,ν vi Ω i − − dΩ dν . c 3 c 0 4π
∞
(12)
(13)
(14)
The radiative transfer equation for static media can be made consistent with these model equations by adding a P1 -type correction term to the right side of the equation:
Discrete-Ordinates Methods for Radiative Transfer
73
1 ∂I −→ −→ 1 1 3 + Ω · ∇ I + σt I = σs φ + σa B(T ) + Ce + Cf,i Ωi , (15) c ∂t 4π 4π 4π where
I
φ=
−→
Ω ,ν
dΩ ,
(16)
4π
Ce = − 4π
σt (ν) I c
−→
Ω ,ν
Cf,i =
σt (ν)I 4π
−→
4 v2 vi Ω i − 3 c
Ω ,ν
dΩ ,
4 vi dΩ . 3 c
(17)
(18)
Note that if we multiply (15) by Ωi /c and integrate over all directions and frequencies, we obtain (13), and if simply we integrate (15) over all directions and frequencies, we obtain (14). We stress that (15) is an approximate Eulerian frame transfer equation that is consistent with the other approximations that we have made in the hydrodynamic and radiation moment equations. The Eulerian frame transfer equation that is correct to O(v/c) is considerably more complicated than (15) [2]. Our approximate radiationhydrodynamics model is completely defined by (10) through (18).
3 Discretization and Solution Techniques In this section, we discuss discretization and solution techniques for the radiative transfer equation. For simplicity, we consider only the radiative transfer equation for a static medium and neglect the hydrodynamics equations. In general, the techniques we discuss here can be applied within a radiationhydrodynamics calculation. A discussion of discretization and solution techniques for the full radiation-hydrodynamics equations is beyond the scope of this paper. The equations we consider consist of a radiative transfer equation: 1 1 ∂I −→ −→ + Ω · ∇ I + σt I = σs φ + σa B(T ) , c ∂t 4π and an equation for the material temperature T (r, t): ∞ ∂T = σa [ φ − 4πB(T ) ] dν , Cv ∂t 0
(19)
(20)
where Cv is the heat capacity and φ is defined by (16). Equations (19) and (20) are discretized in direction using the standard Sn approximation [2,3]. This is basically collocation at a set of discrete directions that correspond to quadrature points on the unit sphere. The quadrature set
74
J.E. Morel
associated with those discrete directions is also used to perform directional −→ integrations. For instance, let { Ω n , wn }M n=1 denote an M -point quadrature set, then (19) and (20) are directionally discretized as follows: 1 1 ∂In −→ −→ + Ω · ∇ In + σt In = σs φ + σa B(T ) , c ∂t 4π ∂T = Cv ∂t
∞
σa [ φ − 4πB(T ) ] dν ,
(21)
(22)
0
where In = I
−→ Ωn ,
(23)
and φ=
M
In wn .
(24)
n=1
Equations (19) and (20) are discretized in frequency using the standard multigroup method [2, 3]. The first step in this method is partition the frequency domain into G disjoint contiguous intervals or groups:
[ν 12 , ν 32 ), . . . , [νG− 12 , νG+ 12 ) where the minimum frequency is ν 12 and the maximum frequency is νG+ 12 . The g’th group refers to the interval, [νg− 12 , νg+ 12 ). Next (19) and (20) are discretized as follows: 1 ∂Ig −→ −→ 1 + Ω · ∇ Ig + σt,g Ig = σs,g φg + σa,g Bg (T ) , g = 1, G, c ∂t 4π Cv
G ∂T = σa,g [ φg − 4πBg (T ) ] , ∂t
(25)
(26)
g =1
where
νg+ 1
2
Ig =
I(ν ) dν ,
(27)
B(ν ) dν ,
(28)
νg− 1 2
νg+ 1
2
Bg = νg− 1 2
and σg denotes any desired average of σ(ν) over group g: σg = σ(ν) ν∈[νg− 1 ,νg+ 1 ) . 2
(29)
2
The physical characteristics of radiative transfer problems place severe demands upon spatial discretization schemes. In particular, such schemes must:
Discrete-Ordinates Methods for Radiative Transfer
• • • • •
75
be at least second-order accurate, be highly damped in strongly absorbing media, be accurate in optically-thin regions, possess the thick diffusion limit, behave well with unresolved spatial boundary layers.
In general, lumped discontinuous spatial discretization schemes are required for radiative transfer. These schemes are usually either finite-element based [4, 5] or finite-volume based [6]. While lumping of the removal and source terms is well defined, lumping of the gradient term is also required in multidimensional calculations [7]. There is no general procedure for gradient lumping and it must generally be performed on a case-by-case basis. Gradient lumping remains a research topic. The need to possess the thick diffusion limit places additional demands upon spatial discretization schemes. It is important to explain exactly what it means for a spatial discretization scheme to possess the thick diffusion-limit. In this limit, the transport solution is diffusive and the spatial cells can be arbitrarily thick with respect to a mean-free-path. The diffusion length is the spatial scalelength for diffusive solutions, and the diffusion length can be arbitrarily large with respect to a mean-free-path. Hence, a spatial mesh with cells that are thin with respect to a diffusion length but arbitrarily thick with respect to a mean-free-path might be intuitively expected to yield an accurate solution because the spatial variation of the exact solution is well resolved by the mesh. Indeed, a scheme that yields an accurate solution for highly diffusive problems whenever the variation of the exact diffusive solution is well resolved by the mesh is said to possess the thick diffusion limit. However, it is important to recognize that convergent schemes, i.e. schemes with truncation errors that go to zero as the mesh is refined, do not necessarily possess the thick diffusion limit. A truncation error analysis yields no information on the behavior of a scheme in this limit. Such analyses indicate that accurate solutions will be obtained if the mesh cells are thin with respect to a mean-free-path. Spatial resolution on the order of a mean-free-path is completely impracical in highly diffusive problems. For instance, as a problem is made increasingly diffusive, the characteristic width of the system approaches a fixed value when measured in diffusion lengths and becomes infinite when measured in mean-free-paths. To determine the behavior of a spatial discretization scheme in the thick diffusion limit, one must perform a discrete asymptotic analysis [4, 7–10]. Boundary layers that are a few mean-free-paths thick can exist at the transitions between non-diffusive and diffusive regions. It can be very difficult to resolve such layers. In general, an adaptive approach is required because the locations of these boundary layers usually vary dynamically. Furthermore, in a multifrequency calculation one may not be able to resolve a boundary layer on a mean-free-path basis for all frequencies. Thus it is desirable to have schemes that behave well if not highly accurately with unresolved spatial
76
J.E. Morel
boundary layers. A discrete asymptotic analysis will reveal this behavior in addition to the behavior of the scheme on the interior of a diffusive region. The diffusion limit for radiative transfer is characterized by: I = B(T ) , ∂T −→ 4acT 3 −→ − ∇· (Cv + 4aT 3 ) ∇T =0 , ∂t 3σr
(30) (31)
where σr is the Rosseland-averaged total cross section:
∞
σr = 0
1 ∂B(ν) dν σt∗ (ν) ∂T
0
∞
∂B(ν) dν ∂T
!−1 .
(32)
Equations (19) and (20) are usually solved via a modified Newton’s method. To illustrate this technique, we first implicitly difference these equations in time: −→ −→ 1 1 k+ 1 k+ 12 k+ 1 k+ 12 2 − I k− 2 I + + σ I 2 = · I Ω ∇ t c∆tk 1 1 k+ 12 k+ 1 σs φ 2 + σa B k+ 2 , (33) 4π k+ 1 ∞ 1 Cv 2 k+ 1 k+ 12 k+ 12 k+ 12 2 − T k− 2 T = φ dν . σ − 4πB a ∆tk 0
(34)
We let T ∗ denote the latest Newton iterate for the temperature. Then the linearized equations for the next Newton iteration are obtained by evaluating the material properties at T ∗ and linearly expanding the Planck function temperature dependence about T ∗ : B n+1 = B ∗ +
∂B ∗ k+ 1 T 2 − T∗ , ∂T
(35)
where a superscript “*” denotes a quantity evaluated at T ∗ . This is a modified Newton’s method because the contribution of the material properties to the Jacobian are neglected. With the expansion given in (35), the material temperature can be eliminated from the transport equation. Suppressing the temporal superscript “k + 12 ”, the linearized temporally-differenced transport equation can be expressed as: ∞ −→ −→ 1 ∗ 1 ∗ σ νχ I = φ + σa∗ (ν )φ(ν ) dν + ξ , (36) · I + σ Ω ∇ τ 4π s 4π 0 where:
Discrete-Ordinates Methods for Radiative Transfer
στ = σt + τ , 1 , τ= c∆tk ∞ ∗ ∗ σa (ν)4π ∂B∂T(ν) dν 0 ν = C∗ , ∞ ∗ v + 0 σa∗ (ν)4π ∂B∂T(ν) dν ∆tk
77
(37a) (37b) (37c)
∗
χ(ν) = ∞ 0
σa∗ (ν) ∂B∂T(ν) ∗
σa∗ (ν ) ∂B∂T(ν
)
dν
,
ξ = σa∗ B ∗ + τ ψ k− 2 − ∞ 1 1 C∗ νχ σa∗ (ν )4πB ∗ (ν ) dν + vk T k− 2 − T ∗ , 4π ∆t 0
(37d)
1
(37e)
and the material temperature is given by ∞ T k+ 2 = T ∗ + 1
0
1 C∗ σa∗ (ν) [φ(ν) − 4πB ∗ (ν)] dν + ∆tvk T k− 2 − T ∗ . (38) ∞ ∗ Cv∗ + 0 σa∗ (ν)4π ∂B∂T(ν) dν ∆tk
Equation (38) is used to calculate the temperatures after the linearized transport equation has been solved. We note that (36) has the form of the steadystate neutron transport equation with σa playing the role of the fission cross section, ν playing the role of the number of neutrons per fission, χ playing the role of the fission spectrum, and ξ playing the role of a inhomogeneous source. The basic technique for solving (36) is the source iteration technique. This method is based upon the fact that all coupling between direction and frequency occurs on the right side of the equation. The operator on the left side of (36) can be discretized in such a way that a block lower-triangular coefficient matrix is obtained for each direction and frequency group where the unknowns in each block are those associated with a single spatial cell. Such matrices are easily inverted in a direct manner. The inversion process for each discrete direction and frequency starts where radiation enters the mesh, proceeds across the mesh, and ends where radiation leaves the mesh. Hence the inversion process is referred to as a sweep. The iterative process can be represented in a simplified form as follows: ∞ −→ −→ 1 ∗ 1 +1 σs φ + νχ + στ∗ I +1 = σa∗ (ν )φ (ν ) dν + ξ , (39) Ω · ∇I 4π 4π 0 where is the iteration index. The actual iterative process is nested such that the inner iterations converge the scattering sources for each frequency group while the absoprtion rate is held fixed, and the outer iterations converge the absorption rate. The inner source iteration process for group g can be expressed as
78
J.E. Morel −→ −→
+1 ∗ +1 Ω · ∇ Igi + στ,g Igi =
G 1 ∗ i 1 ∗ σs,g φg + νχg σa,g φg + ξg , 4π 4π
(40)
g =1
where i is the inner iteration index. The outer iteration process can be expressed as follows: −→ −→
+1 ∗ +1 Ω · ∇ Igo + στ,g Igo =
G 1 ∗ o +1 1 o ∗ σs,g φg νχg + σa,g φg + ξg , g = 1, G, 4π 4π
(41)
g =1
where o is the outer iteration index. The spectral radius for the inner iteration process (the iteration on a within-group scattering source) is the usual scattering ratio, ρi = σs∗ /σt∗ , and the spectral radius for the outer iteration process (the iteration on the absorption rate) is given by ∞ χσa∗ dν . (42) ρo = ν σa∗ + τ 0 The spectral radii observed in a practical problem are the maximum values of ρi and ρo , respectively, evaluated over the problem domain. Any region in which ρ0 is close to unity will be diffusive. If desired, one can dramatically reduce the spectral radius for the inner iteration process by roughly a factor of 4 via an acceleration technique known as diffusion-synthetic acceleration [11]. −→ −→ i + 1 Ω · ∇ Ig 2
+ 12
∗ + στ,g Igi
=
G 1 ∗ i 1 ∗ σs,g φg + νχg σa,g φg + ξg , 4π 4π
(43)
g =1
−→
−∇·
1 −→ i + 12 +1 +1 + σa,g δφgi 2 = σs,g φgi 2 − φgi , ∇ δφg 3σt,g + 12
φgi +1 = φgi
+ 12
+ δφgi
.
(44)
(45)
Our experience is that acceleration of the inner iterations is not usually required. On the other hand, acceleration of the outer iterations is often essential. The spectral radius for the outer iterations is often very close to unity, making it essential to accelerate convergence of the outer iterations. The spectral radius approaches unity in the limit of strong fluid-radiation coupling, i.e., small heat capacity and large absorption cross section. The
Discrete-Ordinates Methods for Radiative Transfer
79
technique used to accelerate the outer iterations is a variation on diffusionsynthetic acceleration called the linear multifrequency-grey method [12, 13]. An accelerated outer iteration can be represented as follows: −→ −→ o + 1 Ω · ∇ Ig 2
1 ∗ σ φg 4π s,g
o + 12
−→
+
+ 12
∗ + στ,g Igo
=
1 νχg Rao + ξg , g = 1, G, 4π
(46)
−→
− ∇ ·D ∇ δΦ(o +1/2) + [τ + (1 − ν) σa ] δΦ(o +1/2) +1 = ν Rao 2 − Rao ,
(47)
Ra(o +1) = Ra(o +1/2) + σa δΦ(o +1/2) .
(48)
where G
Ra =
∗ σa,g φg ,
(49)
G 1 g , ∗ 3 στ,g
(50)
g =1
D =
g =1
σa =
G
∗ g σa,g ,
(51)
g =1
g =
χg ∗ +τ σa,g G χg g =1 σ ∗ +τ a,g
.
(52)
The linear multifrequency-grey method is generally very effective. It was thought for many years that diffusion-synthetic acceleration and its variants were unconditionally effective. However, it was eventually discovered that large spatial discontinuities in the cross sections can significantly degrade the effectiveness of diffusion-synthetic acceleration [14]. It is reasonable to assume that its variants suffer the same deficiency. It has recently been shown that solving the neutron transport equation with a preconditioned Krylov technique and recasting diffusion-synthetic acceleration as a preconditioner rather than an acceleration scheme results in an apparently unconditionally effective solution technique [15]. Krylov methods are beginning to have an enormous impact upon solution techniques for the transport equation. The traditional accelerated solution
80
J.E. Morel
techniques represent two-level or two-grid methods. As such, they require diffusion discretizations that are consistent with the transport discretizations. This generally leads to non-standard diffusion discretizations that are difficult to solve. Furthermore, high-frequency error amplification for just a single mode can destroy the effectivness of such solution techniques. Preconditioned Krylov methods with traditional acceleration techniques recast as preconditioners are far more forgiving than traditional accelerated solution techniques. We expect to see great progress made in numerical radiative transfer and radiation-hydrodynamics via Krylov methods.
References 1. Lowrie, R.B., Morel, J.E., Hittinger, J.A.: The coupling of radiation and hydrodynamics. Astrophysical J., 521, 432 (1999) 2. Mihalas, D.M., Mihalas, B.W.: Foundations of Radiation Hydrodynamics. Oxford Press (1984) 3. Lewis, E.E., Miller, W.F., Jr.: Computational Methods of Neutron Transport. American Nuclear Society, La Grange Park, Illinois (1993) 4. Morel, J.E., Wareing, T.A., Smith, K.: A linear-discontinuous spatial differencing scheme for Sn radiative transfer calculations. J. Comp. Phys., 128, 445 (1996) 5. Morel, J.E., Gonzalez-Aller, A., Warsa, J.S.: A lumped discontinuous finiteelement spatial discretization for Sn triangular-mesh calculations in R − Z geometry. To appear in the proceedings of MC2005: an International Meeting on Mathematics and Computation, Supercomputing, Reactor Physics, and Nuclear and Biological Applications, Avignon, France, September 12–15, 2005 6. Adams, M.L.: A subcell balance method for radiative transfer on arbitrary spatial grids. Transport Theory Stat. Phys., 26, Nos. 4 & 5, 385 (1997) 7. M.L. Adams: Discontinuous finite element transport solutions in thick diffusive problems. Nucl. Sci. Eng., 137, 298 (2001) 8. Larsen, E.W., Morel, J.E., Miller, W.F., Jr.: Asymptotic solutions of numerical transport problems in optically thick, diffusive regimes. J. Comp. Phys., 69, 283 (1987) 9. Larsen, E.W., Morel, J. E.: Asymptotic solutions of numerical transport problems in optically thick diffusive regimes II. J. Comp. Phys., 83, 212 (1989) 10. Adams, M.L., Nowak, P.F.: Asymptotic analysis of a computational method for time- and frequency-dependent radiative transfer. J. Comput. Phys., 146, 366 (1998) 11. Adams, M.L., Larsen, M.L.: Fast iterative methods for discrete-ordinates particle transport calculations. Prog. Nucl. Energy, 40, 3 (2002) (REVIEW) 12. Morel, J.E., Larsen, E.W., Matzen, M.K.: A Synthetic acceleration scheme for radiative diffusion calculations. J. Quant. Spectro. Radiat. Transfer, 34, 243 (1985) 13. Larsen, E.W.: A grey transport acceleration method for thermal radiative transfer problems. J. Comp. Phys., 78, 459 (1988) 14. Azmy, Y.Y.: Impossibility of unconditional stability and robustness of diffusive acceleration schemes. Proc. ANS Topical Meeting, Radiation Protection and Shielding, Nashville, TN, April 19–23, 1998, Vol. 1, p. 480 (1998)
Discrete-Ordinates Methods for Radiative Transfer
81
15. Warsa, James S., Wareing, Todd A., Morel, Jim E.: Krylov iterative methods and the degraded effectiveness of diffusion synthetic acceleration for multidimensional Sn calculations in problems with material discontinuities. Nucl. Sci. Eng., 147, 218 (2004)
Part II
Atmospheric Science, Oceanography, and Plant Canopies
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media with Broad Spatial Correlations, Illustration with Large-Scale Transport of Solar Photons Through Cloudy Atmospheres Anthony B. Davis Los Alamos National Laboratory, Space & Remote Sensing Sciences Group ISR-2, P.O. Box 1663, Los Alamos, New Mexico, USA
[email protected] Summary. It is argued that, to directly target the mean fluxes through a structured medium with spatial correlations over a significant range of scales that includes the mean-free-path, one can use an effective propagation kernel that will necessarily be sub-exponential. We come to this conclusion using both standard transport theory for variable media and a point-process approach developed recently by A. Kostinski. The ramifications of this finding for multiple scattering and effective medium theory are examined. Finally, we describe a novel one-dimensional transport theory with asymptotically power-law propagation kernels and use it to shed new light onto recent observations of solar photon pathlength in the Earth’s cloudy atmosphere.
1 Introduction and Overview We start with a compact (operator-based) formulation of the monokinetic linear transport problem in higher-dimensions of sufficient generality for our present needs. Phase-space density (times velocity c), denoted I(x, Ω), is called “specific intensity” or “radiance” in the parlance of radiative transfer (RT) theory. It is determined by a one-group linear Boltzman equation [1] LI = SI + Q
(1)
L = Ω • ∇ + σ(x)
(2)
where describes the advection and extinction of particle beams while S = σs (x) p(x, Ω → Ω)[·]dΩ
(3)
4π
describes the volume scattering process, and Q(x, Ω) is the volume source term. We will call this the “3D RT equation” (here, in its integro-differential
86
A.B. Davis
incarnation). We also need boundary conditions (BCs) which can often be taken as vacuum (no incoming radiance) or reflective (which is just like scattering but at a surface). Most numerical solutions of this problem use, in one way or another, the equivalent integral equation I = KI + I0
(4)
that naturally incorporates the BCs; here K = L−1 S
(5)
I0 = L−1 Q
(6)
is the transport kernel while
represents the uncollided particles. The integral operator L−1 is the main focus of this paper; we will call it the propagation kernel. Formally, one can write the solution of (4) as I=
∞ I0 = Kn I0 , 1 − K n=0
(7)
the well-known Neumann series. In this paper however, we are not interested in a solutions of fully specified (deterministic) 3D RT problems. Rather, we are interested in the mean and other statistical properties of solutions averaged over many realizations of the spatial variability: “mean-field” RT theory where the parameters of interest are also means, variances, covariances, correlation functions, and so on, evaluated for the optical properties of the media. Typically, assumptions are made in such a way that these ensemble averages at a point will be invariant under a relevant class of translations and rotations: statistical homogeneity and isotropy prevails. These point transformations need not be fully 3D; for instance, they can be only in the horizontal plane. So what we call here a mean-field RT solution is often thought of as a model for large-scale averages in the statistically invariant spatial dimensions. The most venerable approach to this challenging problem was pioneered1 by the regretted transport theoretician extraordinaire G. C. Pomraning (1936–1999) along with his students and coworkers. The interested reader is referred to his definitive text Linear Kinetic Theory and Particle Transport in Stochastic Mixtures [3]. In this framework, tractable problems with scattering are limited to Markovian binary media: two types of material and uniform probabilities of crossing a boundary per unit of length along any 1
This is on the US side of the Cold War. In the former USSR, parallel developments happened starting, as far as I know, with Avaste and Vainikko’s [2] investigation of broken clouds and continue to this day.
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
87
beam. There are only two structural parameters: the volume mixing ratio and the characteristic scale of the clumps of the less abundant material. One ends up here with the likes of two integro-differential equations for uniform media to solve simultaneously because they are coupled by linear exchange terms. Other statistical RT models, inspired by the phenomenology of turbulence, have been based on scale-wise expansions (as in Fourier space) and closure methods, e.g., Stephens [4]. Yet other methods simply prescribe averaging over solutions of homogeneous problems using 1-point statistics and thus foregoing any impact of spatial correlations, e.g., Barker [5]. For further examples in atmospheric science, primarily motivated by large-scale radiation budget considerations in climate studies, see the recent survey by Barker and Davis [6]. A very desirable outcome of a statistical RT model from any of the above approaches is “homogenization:” compute effective optical medium properties that can be applied to a homogeneous RT problem, but that somehow to capture the effects of the unresolved variability. For instance, Graziani and Slone [7] seek an effective mean free path dependent on structural parameters of Markovian and other media in order to treat them with a single RT equation. An example in cloud radiation is Cahalan’s [32] rescaled optical depth model which is based on straightforward 1-point/single-variable averaging of solutions of the standard 1D RT problem when cloud optical depth is positively skewed (e.g., lognormal-like). Another notable example in atmospheric science is Cairns et al.’s [9] renormalization of all local optical properties which is grounded in a sophisticated Green function analysis.2 of the 3D RT problem and also adapts powerful techniques from contemporary statistical physics. A common trait of the above methods that care at all about covariances [4] or spatial correlations [9–11] is the (often implicit) requirement that the variability scales and the averaging scales be well-separated. In cloudy atmospheres however, and probably also in many other structured media dominated by turbulent reactive flows, spatial correlations are “long-range” (typically power-law wavenumber spectra are observed). It is therefore not obvious that we can observe scales where the statistics can be deemed homogeneous and that one can really talk about variability confined to a certain range of scales. Although Cairns et al. [9] correctly averages the iterated transport kernel Kn in (7) with the spatial (L−1 ) and angular (S) aspects inherently intertwined in (L−1 S)n , the remainder of this paper is essentially an attempt at treating them separately and relating this approximation to the general idea of diffusion. There is little theoretical justification for this separation beyond connection with L´evy walks, a popular model in both statistical physics [12] 2
Uses the solutions G of (1) when Q is a roaming Dirac δ source; formally, we have G = (L − S)−1 .
88
A.B. Davis
and in stochastic processes [13]. Nonetheless, recent observations of multiply scattered sunlight in the Earth’s cloudy atmosphere [14, 15] support this approximation that we revisit further on. In the following Section, we revisit the basic physics of extinction (i.e., σ) and scattering (i.e., σs p(Ω → Ω)), introducing some useful notation in the process. We then examine in Sect. 3 the general properties of averaged freepath distributions in random but spatially-correlated 3D media as determined by L−1 where the angular brackets denote ensemble/spatial averages; we do this from two different standpoints, RT theory and point processes. This enables us to state a fundamental limitation of effective medium theory that may or may not impact practical implementations. We also look at the form of L−1 for the specific kind of variability observed in the Earth’s cloudy atmosphere. In Sect. 4, we return to multiple scattering transport by first showing, under quite general conditions, that angular diffusion makes iterates of S very close to projections onto the space of isotropic functions U (x) — physically, photon density— in finite time; it is then relatively easy to obtain the asymptotic behavior of Kn ≈ L−1 n for both infinite and finite media, assuming complete angular redistribution. In Sect. 5, we display some recently published absorption-based diagnostics of solar photon transport through real 3D clouds and propose a simple 1D RT model based on the relevant family of propagation kernels L−1 that explains these observations. We offer some concluding remarks in Sect. 6. I have already started and will continue to use the language of radiative transfer (photons, extinction, optics, etc.), and furthermore in the frame of atmospheric science. Much of the following is nonetheless applicable to neutron or neutrino transport in engineering or astrophysical systems.
2 Extinction and Scattering Revisited, and Some Notations Introduced 2.1 The Extinction Coefficient The simplest description of matter-radiation interaction is photon depletion when a narrow collimated beam crosses an optical medium, cf. left-hand side of Fig. 1 where it is assumed that δI ≥ 0. We have basically expressed here the flux-divergence theorem for an “elementary” kinetic volume of length δ. Along the horizontal cylinder the net transport is 0; to the left, there is an in-flux I; to the right, an out-flux I − δI. So the divergence integral is simply the difference from left to right. Operationally, we have δI ∝ I × δ and the proportionality constant, defined as
(8)
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
89
Fig. 1. Mechanism of optical extinction by a dilute medium of scattering/absorbing particles: (a) elementary cylindrical volume, (b) photon beam’s view down the axis of the cylinder when a variety of cloud droplet sizes are present. Adapted from Fig. 3.7 in [16]
σ = lim
δ→0
δI/I . . . in m−1 , δ
(9)
is the extinction coefficient or simply “extinction.” What is the detailed mechanism of extinction? This is about a population of streaming photons colliding with an essentially static population of massive particles. So all we have to do is estimate the number of particles in the sample volume in Fig. 1: δN = nδAδ. Multiplying this by the (mean) cross-section s and dividing by δA yields the element of probability for an interaction which, by definition (9), is σδ, and should be 1. Thus, as some position (x), we have σ(x) = n(x) × s . (10) In this sense, extinction is the interaction cross-section per unit of volume, equivalently, the probability of collision per unit of length. Note that the medium as to be sufficiently dilute (n−1/3 s1/2 ); otherwise (tightly-packed particles), it is wrong to think that a small distance δ in sn × δ makes it a small element of probability. In (10), the cross-section s is for any kind of interaction by any kind of particle. In radiative transfer, it is naturally partitioned between absorption (photon destruction) and scattering (photon re-direction).3 This partition carries over immediately to the transport coefficients: σ(x) = σa (x) + σs (x) .
(11)
In environmental and astrophysical applications, there is often a mixture of optically relevant material particles in the kinetic volume in terms of size (cf. right-hand side of Fig. 1), shape, chemistry, etc. An important quantity in the following is single-scattering albedo: 3
In neutronics, there is a third elementary process: multiplication, which is basically an “anti-absorption;” formally, we model this process with σa < 0 (an isotropic source of particles that is ∝ I). In optics, there is stimulated emission which can dominate in NTLE situations, such as in laser cavities. Because of the tight correlation between the incoming and outgoing photon’s directions, this is best modeled as a negative extinction in (9).
90
A.B. Davis 0 (x)
= σs (x)/σ(x) .
(12)
We can then express the absorption coefficient as σa (x) = [1 −
0 (x)] σ(x)
,
(13)
where 1 − 0 (x) is sometimes called the “co-albedo” for single scattering. As long as the overarching condition of weak dilution is verified, we can use the linearity of (10)–(11) to simply sum the cross-sections s(s) and s(a) (for scattering and absorption respectively) of different types of photonintercepting particles weighted by the associated densities: (a,s) si × ni (x) . (14) σa,s (x) = species i
A variation of this principle is when the “species” are defined by a continuously varying parameter such as size r: ∞ s(a,s) (r) ×
σa,s (x) =
dn (r; x) dr . dr
(15)
0
For spherical particles (such as cloud droplets) of radius r, Mie scattering theory specifies the efficiency factor Q(a,s) (2πr/λ) that appears in s(a,s) (r) = πr2 × Q(a,s) (2πr/λ) where λ is the given wavelength, cf. Deirmendjian [17] for standard size spectra dn/dr used in atmospheric optics. Interesting questions arise when a particle type or size can not be considered uniformly distributed at any scale, i.e., that it is impossible to define a density ni (x) or dn/dr(r; x). I refer to Knyazikhin et al. [18] for an investigation of more general formulations of the extinction problem that capture this case. In the next section, we will proceed to investigate spatial variability effects under the weak assumption that at least the dominant types of particles have well-defined local densities. 2.2 The Scattering Phase Function Figure 2 illustrates the redistribution of radiant energy between different beams through scattering. Our goal is to estimate the element of scattered flux δFs . It is surely proportional to the small solid angle into which the scattering occurs δΩ and to the small loss of flux δF0 incurred when the incoming photons cross the sample volume (conditional to scattering rather than absorption); the latter term is equal to the scattering coefficient times the small length δ. In summary, we have δFs ∝ δF0 δΩ = F0 σs δ × δΩ .
(16)
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
91
Fig. 2. Schematic of scattered radiance. Adapted from Fig. 3.8 in [16]
We define the scattering phase function as p(Ω0 → Ω) =
lim
δ,δΩ→0
δFs ... in sr−1 δF0 × δΩ
(17)
which will generally depend on position x as well as one or two angular variables: the scattering angle θs = cos−1 (Ω0 •Ω) and, possibly, an azimuthal scattering angle as well. As an example that we will return to latter on, consider everywhere isotropic scattering: p(x, Ω0 → Ω) ≡ 1/4π .
(18)
As for extinction, let us have a closer look at the mechanics of scattering at the individual collision level.4 To isolate the inherent property of the scattering medium, we compute lim
δs,δΩ→0
δFs /F0 ds = σs (x)p(x, Ω0 → Ω) = n(x) × (x, Ω0 → Ω) δs × δΩ dΩ
(19)
where the last expression is obtained by straightforward generalization of (10) to differential cross-sections. As for extinction in (15), differential crosssection should be averaged over the population of particles in the sample volume in terms of size and/or type. 4 In the context of RT, it is technically incorrect to think of a photon as being scattered since its identity, as an eigen-mode of the quantized EM equations, is defined in particular by its direction of propagation. However, a quantum hc/λ of radiant energy is transfered between modes at each elastic scattering, and I will continue the tradition of calling this the scattering of “a photon.” In RT per se, “photon” is in fact short for photon beam since we are in the classic limit of geometric optics where all distances of interest are much larger than the wavelength λ. Physical (wave-theoretical) optics are required only to compute transport coefficients at the individual cross-section level, which can indeed be on the order of the wavelength squared. The weak dilution requirement and the usual assumption of uncorrelated random positions then ensures that we can add intensities (energies) rather than amplitudes and phases to model the behavior of photon beams.
92
A.B. Davis
By radiant energy conservation, we have p(x, Ω0 → Ω)dΩ ≡ 1, ∀x, Ω .
(20)
4π
By optical reciprocity, we have p(x, Ω → Ω0 ) = p(x, Ω0 → Ω), hence p(x, Ω0 → Ω)dΩ0 ≡ 1, ∀x, Ω0 .
(21)
4π
In the remainder of this section, I will assume the spatial variability the phase function is implicit, and drop x from its arguments. In most atmospheric applications (high-altitude cirrus clouds made of ice-crystals being the notable exception), it is reasonable to assume that scattering is axi-symmetric around the incoming beam. Hence, p(Ω0 → Ω) ≡ p(Ω0 • Ω) = p(µs ) .
(22)
where the scattering angle θs is given by µs = cos θs = Ω0 • Ω. This enables an expansion of the phase function in spherical harmonics (eigen-functions of S) without the complication of azimuthal terms: p(µs ) =
1 (2n + 1)ηn Pn (µs ) , 4π
(23)
n≥0
where Pn (x) is th nth-order Legendre polynomial. These coefficients are computed from +1 (24) ηn = 2π Pn (µs )p(µs )dµs . −1
Specific values of the Legendre polynomials can be obtained efficiently by recursion but their analytical expressions are best derived from the generating function [19] 1 Φ(x, z) = Pn (x)z n = √ , (25) 1 − 2xz + z2 n≥0 for |x| and |z| < 1. Using 1 Pn (x) = n!
∂ ∂z
n
Φ(x, z)
,
(26)
z=0
we find P0 (x) = 1, P1 (x) = x, P2 (x) = (3x2 − 1)/2, and so on. The orthogonality of the Legendre polynomials, +1 Pn (x)Pn (x)dx = −1
δnn , n + 1/2
(27)
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
93
where δnn is the Kronecker symbol, ensures diagonalization of the scattering operator S in spherical-harmonic space. It is therefore little surprise that virtually all grid-based (non-Monte Carlo) numerical solutions of the 3D RT equation exploit spherical harmonics. We have η0 = 1 by conservation for any phase function, and the only non-vanishing coefficient for isotropic scattering in (18). Also of considerable interest is +1 (28) g = η1 = 2π µs p(µs )dµs , −1
called the “asymmetry factor” or simply the mean cosine of the scattering angle. This last description of g correctly presents the phase function as a probability density function (PDF) in direction space, and this is indeed how p(µs ) is used in Monte Carlo schemes. Any deviation of the phase function from isotropy corresponds to a directional correlation (in principle, of either sign) between incident and scattered photons. I will be introducing several kinds of averages in upcoming section. So those that concern photon scattering and propagation events deserve a special notation, which I borrow from the probability literature: E(·) which stands for (mathematical) expectation of the random variable in the argument. Thus, we can recast the asymmetry factor in (28) as (29) g = E(Ω • Ω0 ) = Ω • Ω0 dP (Ω|Ω0 ) 4π
where dP (Ω|Ω0 ) = p(Ω0 • Ω)dΩ. The “|” delimiter in a PDF separates the random variable from the given (fixed) quantities that need to be highlighted. 2.3 Henyey–Greenstein Models for the Phase Function A very popular 1-parameter model for the single-scattering process in atmospheric optics and elsewhere is the Henyey–Greenstein [20] phase function 1 1 − g2 . (30) p(µs ; g) = 4π (1 + g 2 − 2gµs )3/2 I will use the delimiter “;” to separate, as needed, variables from parameters in argument lists. I will also use subscripts, e.g., pg (µs ) in this case. In spherical harmonics, the Henyey–Greenstein model (30) yields ηn (g) = g n . (31) ∞ n Indeed, 4πp(x; z) is identical to = 2∂Φ(x, z)/∂z + n=0 (2n + 1)Pn (x)z Φ(x, z) from (25); the above coefficients then follow by comparison with (23). This Legendre decomposition is used in virtually all numerical implementations of the scattering operator S, except Monte Carlo (random quadrature)
94
A.B. Davis
schemes where the simulation of the Markov chain requires the generation of random values of µs with the probability measure implicit in (30). In the case of the Henyey–Greenstein phase function, one can use the method of inverting the cumulative probability because the running integral of (30) with respect to µs has a simple expression. Specifically, one can generate random values of µs with 1 − g2 1 µs = 1 + g2 − , |g| ≤ 1, g = 0 , (32) 2g 1 + g(1 − 2ξ) where ξ is a (pseudo-)random deviate uniformly distributed on the interval (0,1). When g → 0, L’Hˆ opital’s rule in (32) yields the expected result for isotropic scattering: µs = 1 − 2ξ. The azimuthal scattering angle is selected randomly: φs = 2πξ. Sometimes, it is useful to compute RT in reduced dimensionality. For instance, “3D” RT effects have been successfully investigated in 2D: one direction for the mean flux (z) and one other, at right angles, for the spatial variability (x). It is not necessary in this case to propagate photons in the 3rd dimension and the general representation for radiance is I(x, z, θ), where θ is still measured away from the z-axis. The small price to pay for this conceptual simplification is that all the geometrical units used so far must be adjusted: • fluxes are now in s−1 m−1 ; • radiances are fluxes/rad since solid angles and direction (θ, φ) are now reduced to regular angles and just θ; • extinction, scattering and absorption coefficients are still in m−1 but, if needed, “cross-sections” are in meters while densities are in m−2 ; and finally, • phase functions are in rad−1 . To support studies in this kind of RT in “Flatland,” Davis et al. [21] proposed a 2D version of the Henyey–Greenstein phase function: 1 δFs /F0 1 − g2 = p(µs ; g) = lim (33) δτs ,δθ→0 δτs × δθ 2π 1 + g 2 − 2gµs where τs is the element of (scattering) optical distance across the small 2D “volume” where the scattering occurs (think of a 2D version of Fig. 2). Note that the polar diagram of this 2D phase function, as a function of θs = cos−1 µs , is an ellipse of eccentricity 2g/(1 + g 2 ) with the scattering particle at a focus. The asymmetry factor g retains the same meaning in 2D it was given in 3D through (29): mean cosine of the scattering angle. The 2D analog of the spherical harmonic decomposition (23)–(24) on the 3D unit sphere Ξ is a cosine Fourier series analysis on the interval (−π, +π] where θs takes its values. Specifically,
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
p(µs ) =
1 ηn cos nθs π 1 + δ0n
95
(34)
n≥0
where
+π p(θs ) cos nθs dθs . ηn =
(35)
−π
For the 2D Henyey–Greenstein phase function in (33), it can be shown that the nth Fourier coefficient in (35) is ηn (g) = g n , just as in (31) for the 3D case. While this is useful in a numerical implementation of S in 2D for a spatiallygridded representation of the 2D radiance, a 2D Monte Carlo scheme would use
π 1−g −1 tan (1 − 2ξ) , |g| ≤ 1 , (36) θs = 2 tan 1+g 2 in lieu of (32). The ultimate dimensionality reduction in RT is when the light particles can travel only on one axis, say, up or down. Here, fluxes (and/or radiances) are simply in s−1 , the extinction coefficient (like density) is in m−1 while cross-sections and the phase-function are dimensionless. Indeed, scattering in 1D amounts to either no change of direction of travel (µs = +1) or reversed direction (µs = −1). In this case, the angular PDFs in (30) or (33) are reduced to a Bernoulli trial: δFs /F0 µs = +1, with probability (1 + g)/2 = . (37) p(µs ; g) = lim µs = −1, with probability (1 − g)/2 δτs →0 δτs In other words, p(±1; g) = (1 ± g)/2 .
(38)
This is in fact the most general phase function in 1D. As in higher dimensions, g is still the mean of µs , the cosine of the scattering angle, even though it can take only 2 values. RT in 1D is of course not a framework for investigating 3D effects. 1D RT is however an analytically tractable benchmark, at least when 0 and g are constant in the 1D medium.5 In this model, the two 1D “radiances” are readily identified with 3D hemispherical fluxes in the upper- and lower halves (Ξ± ) of Ξ. It dates back at least to Schuster’s seminal 1905 paper [22]. 1D RT has undeniable tutorial value. Amazingly, it is still used in many global climate models in one or another of its evolved but mathematically equivalent forms [23]. In 1D, 2D or 3D, the extremal values of g, +1 and −1 are only of academic interest. They indeed lead to Dirac δ-functions in the respective scattering-angle spaces: (µs , φs ) ∈ Ξ, θs ∈ (−π, +π], µs ∈ {−1, +1}. For g = +1 scattering per se is defeated and the RT problem collapses onto the pure extinction/absorption/emission problem, which is 1D (beam-by-beam). For g = −1, we obtain a somewhat pathological 1D (beam-by-beam) transport model where propagation direction is switched at every scattering event. 5
96
A.B. Davis
3 Propagation 3.1 Direct Transmission in 3D Media as a Problem in Stochastic ODEs There is an apparently elementary calculus problem posed in (9), namely, dI/I = d ln I = −σ(x)ds ,
(39)
which is easily solved by a change of variables dτ (s) = σ(x)ds. We thus define optical distance as the running integral of σ along the beam Ω0 from some starting point x0 : s τ (x0 → x = x0 + Ω0 s) = τ (s; x0 , Ω0 ) =
σ(x0 + Ω0 s )ds .
(40)
0
To address the problem of cumulative extinction, we will consider (x0 , Ω0 ) to be fixed parameters. The solution of the ordinary differential equation (ODE) in (39) is therefore I(s; x0 , Ω0 ) = I(0; x0 , Ω0 ) exp[−τ (s; x0 , Ω0 )] .
(41)
This is the well-known exponential law of direct transmission with respect to optical distance. Consider a uniform medium where optical distance is simply τ (x0 → x = x0 + Ω0 s) = σs, ∀x0 , Ω0 ;
(42)
I(s) = I0 exp(−σs) .
(43)
thus This is Beer’s law of exponential transmission with respect to physical distance. It is obviously of more limited applicability than (41). Looking back at (39) and thinking of σ(s; x0 , Ω0 ) = σ(x0 + Ω0 s) as a random variable, we see that this is a problem in stochastic ODEs with multiplicative noise. The relevant questions in stochastic ODE theory are about the statistical properties of the solutions, in this case of exp[−τ (s; x0 , Ω0 )]. Given that we will be interested in situations where the “noise” σ(s; x0 , Ω0 ) has non-trivial correlation properties, we can not draw on the classic treatments [24]. First however, we examine the transport theoretical significance of the direct transmission law as a means of predicting the specifics of particle beam propagation.
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
97
3.2 Photon Free-Path Distributions I have presented scattering as a random choice of new direction of propagation for the photon. There is also an inherent randomness in photon propagation which deserves to be re-examined from a probabilistic perspective. From (41), but dropping the “0” subscripts for simplicity, we can derive direct transmission Tdir (s; x, Ω) = exp[−τ (s; x, Ω)] = Pr{step ≥ s|x, Ω}
(44)
by taking the ratio Iout /Iin = I(s; · · · )/I(0; · · · ). This is the probability of a photon to not suffer any kind of collision in an experiment over the fixed distance s, starting at x in direction Ω. Now think of the photon’s free path or “step” to its next collision. As expressed above, Tdir (s; x, Ω) is the probability that this random variable exceeds s. So, thinking now of s as the random step length, its PDF is defined by p(s|x, Ω)ds = dP (s|x, Ω) = Pr{s ≤ step < s + ds|x, Ω} . In terms of the 3D variability of the optical medium, this leads to d P (s|x, Ω) = σ(x + Ωs) exp[−τ (s; x, Ω)] , p(s|x, Ω) = ds
(45)
(46)
using (40) and (44). Consider the case of uniform extinction σ, the only quantity required in the problem at hand. The resulting free-path distribution (FPD) is given by p(s|σ) = σe−σs
(47)
follows directly from above, or using Beer’s exponential law of direct transmission in (43). The cumulative extinction (optical distance) computation in (40) and of direct transmission in (44) is executed repetitively in many numerical solutions of the RT equation, and the Monte Carlo technique is no exception. In uniform media, the method of inverse cumulative probability follows directly from (47): the random length s > 0 of the step between two successive scattering events is given by s = − ln ξ/σ .
(48)
In 3D media, one draws randomly an optical distance to cover τ = − ln ξ > 0 and then one solves iteratively the equation in (40) for s. The power of the differential formulation in (39) is that the collision accounting is always done in the “safe” regime where interaction probability is small. Then, conditional to survival, the collision probability is again assessed, and so on. The resulting exponential free-path distribution therefore
98
A.B. Davis
follows directly from the inherent “lack-of-memory” in the course of the beam propagation. This is called a Markov property in probability theory. There is in fact another even more tutorial way of deriving the above FPDs (PDFs for s) by returning to the basic definition of extinction in (9) and exploiting the photon’s lack of memory about its past: whether it collides or not with a particle in the next instant does not depend on how far it has been traveling. So we can mentally divide s into M 1 small segments of equal length and consider the probability of a photon crossing all of them without colliding with a particle. Since the collision probabilities δI/I ≈ σδs where δs = 1/M are independent in each sub-segment, the cumulative survival probability is by definition Tdir (σs) ≈ (1 − σs/M )M .
(49)
Taking the limit M → ∞ leads back to (41), hence to the FPD in (47). This proof, used in textbooks such as [25], easily generalizes to the case where σ varies along the beam’s path, leading back to (40)–(41) hence to the FPD in (46). 3.3 Mean-Free-Path and Other Moments A fundamental quantity in transport theory, for light quanta or any other type of particle, is the mean free path (MFP) given by ∞ (x, Ω) = E(s|x, Ω) =
sdP (s|x, Ω) .
(50)
0
Other moments of the FPD are also of general interest: ∞ E(s |x, Ω) = q
sq dP (s|x, Ω) .
(51)
0
Reconsider the uniform-σ case in (47). We find (σ) = E(s) = 1/σ .
(52)
So the optical distance given in (42), τ = σs, is just physical distance s in units of MFPs. Free-path moments of arbitrary order q > −1 can be computed from the exponential distribution in (47) and we find E(sq ) = Γ (q + 1)/σ q = Γ (q + 1)(σ)q
(53)
where Γ (·) is Euler’s Gamma function: ∞ Γ (x) = 0
tx−1 e−t dt .
(54)
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
99
Recall that, for integer-valued arguments, Γ (n+1) = n!, n ∈ N. In particular, the root-mean-square (RMS) free-path is given by " √ √ E(s2 ) = 2/σ = 2 E(s) . (55) It is larger than the MFP in (52), as required by Schwartz’s inequality. Schwartz’s well-known inequality is equivalent in probability theory to the statement that variance, D(s) = E([s − E(s)]2 ) = E(s2 ) − E(s)2 ,
(56)
is non-negative. Jensen’s inequality in probability theory is less known in general. It is usually stated as E[f (X)] ≥ f [E(X)]
(57)
for any random variable X on the support of f and for any convex function f (i.e., f > 0 if f is everywhere twice differentiable on the support of the PDF of X). The “=” in (57) is obtained only in two situations: 1. f is linear in X; 2. X is sure (its variance is zero). Schwartz’s inequality is a special case of Jensen’s with f (X) = X 2 being a convex function on the real axis R. Jensen’s inequality, or its converse for concave functions, will be repeatedly invoked further on. 3.4 Enhanced, Non-Exponential Steps in Spatially Correlated Media I’ll demonstrate here that, in media with variable extinction, the MFP is always larger than in a uniform medium associated with the mean extinction, equivalently, with the same overall number of particles according to (10). I’ll also show that the effective FPD is always wider-than-exponential, even if the actual MFP is used. Detailed proofs are provided by Kostinski [26] and Davis and Marshak [27], respectively from the standpoints of non-Poissonian point processes and variable extinction fields. The importance of spatial correlations in the extinction field σ(x) is emphasized in both studies, and echoed here. Non-Uniform Extinction Field Approach Let M ⊆ R3 denote the 3D optical medium of interest. Using shorthand from probability theory, we define Pr(dσ) = Pr{x ∈ M : σ ≤ extinction at x < σ + dσ}
(58)
100
A.B. Davis
for the 1-point variability of the extinction coefficient. Technically, the bracketed entity is a sub-set of M. In the random field theory used here, we will not need to distinguish “probability” per se from the normalized measure of the set (in the sense of Lebesgue) where the values of interest occur. In a uniform medium of extinction σ0 , Pr(dσ) = δ(σ − σ0 )dσ .
(59)
As a simple example of a variable medium, take a Bernoulli (binary-value) random extinction Pr(dσ) = [f1 δ(σ − σ1 ) + f2 δ(σ − σ2 )]dσ, f1 + f2 = 1 .
(60)
We will however usually be dealing with continuous distributions of σ, hence the differential notation. “Ensemble” averages over this “disorder” in the optical medium will be denoted by angular brackets, · ; so, for instance, we have ∞ σ = q
σ q Pr(dσ) .
(61)
0
Statistical quantities of interest in photon transport are the ensemble-averaged moments of the (random) FPD, equivalently, the moments of the ensembleaverage FPD p(s) = dP (s) /ds . (62) Specifically, we may want ∞ sq dP (s)
E(s ) = q
(63)
0
where
∞ dP (s) /ds =
∞ p(s|σ) Pr(dσ) =
0
σ exp[−σs] Pr(dσ) .
(64)
0
So (63) is actually a double integral on probability measures: first on the spatial disorder, then on the propagation (as written above), or vice-versa. Thinking of τ (s) = σs (65) when extinction σ is random and distance s fixed, we are interested in the statistical properties of the mean direct transmission law e
−τ (s)
∞ =
∞ Tdir (s|σ) Pr(dσ) =
0
exp[−σs] Pr(dσ) . 0
(66)
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
101
In short, how does it differ from e−τ (s) = e−σ s ? From (66), we recover the mean FPD in (64): d −τ (s) (67) dP (s) = e ds . ds Three general results can be derived about the mean or “effective” FPD in (64) or (66)–(67). 1. It is exponential only if the medium is homogeneous, a consequence of Jensen’s inequality for f (X) = e−X . This is the converse of the result derived in (43), thus making exactly exponential transmission and homogeneity equivalent statements about an optical medium: d (68) σ(x) ≡ constant ⇐⇒ Tdir ∝ Tdir . ds An important corollary here is that effective medium (or homogenization) theory is of limited value as an approach for 3D RT in the presence of unresolved spatial variability. It is probably wise to customize the effective parameters of the uniform medium to deliver on some important aspect of the problem at hand, rather than to think of it as a truly “equivalent” medium. 2. The mean MFP is always larger than in the hypothetical homogeneous medium with an extinction equal to the mean extinction; considering (10), we are thus putting a number/mass-conservation constraint on the variability. This translates to = E(s) = 1/σ ≥ 1/σ .
(69)
The inequality follows from Jensen’s in (57) for the convex function f (X) = 1/X. The local quantity 1/σ(x) is probably not equal to the MFP defined in (50) for any direction Ω. However, it is clearly a better guess than the mean extinction σ . I will call the local quantity 1/σ(x) the pseudo-MFP. 3. The mean FPD is always wider-than-exponential in the sense that its higher-order moments are always under-estimated by assuming an exponential distribution, even if we make a judicious adjustment for item 2 by using the actual MFP: E(sq ) = Γ (q + 1)σ −q ≥ Γ (q + 1)σ −1 q = Γ (q + 1) q , q > 1 . (70) This follows from Jensen’s inequality for f (X) = X q for q > 1, which is also true for6 −1 < q < 0 (as a means of emphasizing small s values rather than large ones). For moments of order q ≤ −1, the PDF (of X = 1/σ in this case) must vanish sufficiently fast at 0. 6
102
A.B. Davis
General proofs draw on characteristic-function theory in probability [28]; see Davis and Marshak [27] for details. Figure 3 illustrates the three results with the simple Bernoulli variability model in (60), noting that no account is taken (yet) for correlation lengths as in stochastic RT in Markovian Media. The Key Role of Spatial Correlations What is the point of the mathematical exercise summarized in the previous subsection? What makes an average of the FPD over an ensemble of extinction values relevant to 3D RT? Can we dismiss the strong corollary that limits the scope of effective medium theory? These questions can only be addressed by considering the spatial correlations of the random field σ(x). Indeed, recalling that Ξ is the unit sphere, we really should have started with s Pr(dτ |s) = Pr{x ∈ M, Ω ∈ Ξ : τ ≤
σ(x + Ωs )ds < τ + dτ }
(71)
0
for the variability of optical distance over a given physical distance s, rather than (58). Implicitly, we have assumed that the development from (58) to Fig. 3 applies to s 1 σ s (x, Ω) = τ (s; x, Ω)/s = σ(x + Ωs )ds , (72) s 0
where we used the definition in (40) and introduce an over-score to denote line-averaged quantities.7 This is just the line-average of σ(x) along a finite portion of the beam {x, Ω}. Note that σ 0 (x, Ω) ≡ σ(x), ∀Ω ,
(73)
as long as σ(x) has some degree of continuity, i.e., that the local H¨ older (a.k.a. regularity) exponent h(x) in |σ(x + r) − σ(x)| ∼ rh(x)
(74)
verifies h(x) > 0 almost everywhere. Apart from somewhat heavier notations, the arguments of Sect. 3.4 leading to the inequalities in (69)–(70) carry over to σ s , as a random field with statistical properties that will generally depend parametrically on s. However, the equalities expressed in formulas (69) and (70) to the left of the “≥” carry over as good approximations only if we add one extra condition. Specifically, we require that the 1-point statistics (i.e., PDFs) of σ s depend only weakly Recall that averages over the 3D disorder are denoted · while averages over the photon transport are denoted E(·). 7
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media (a)
103
ensemble-average (or effective) FPD, its two components (equal weights), and two exponential approximations
1 ensemble-average FPD 2 1
= 1.8 (f = 1/2) 2
= 0.2 (f = 1/2) 1
Exponential FPD for < > Exponential FPD for MFP
0.1
MFP
1/ 0.01 0
(b)
3.0
2
f /f 2
MFP
8
10
1
50/50 75/25 88/12 94/6 97/3
2.5
< >
4 6 step size, s
panels (a) and (c)
2.0
1.5
uniform media
1.0 1
3
5
7 2
(c)
9
1
10.0 1
8.0
2
= 0.2 = 1.8
f = f = 1/2
q
1
2
6.0
4.0
q
E(s ) / (q+1)MFP
/
2.0 exponential laws 0.0 -1
0
1
2
3
4
5
q
Fig. 3. Remarkable inequalities for propagation in a binary mixture of extinctions, before correlations are considered. (a) The actual FPD is compared with its two exponential components for σ1 = 0.2 and σ2 = 1.8 with f1 = f2 = 1/2 in (60); the short steps are dominated by the dense half and the long ones be the tenuous half. Two exponential approximations based on σ = f1 σ1 + f2 σ2 = 1 and on the actual MFP 1/σ = f1 /σ1 +f2 /σ2 = 2.77... are also plotted. (b) The actual MFP is compared to the prediction 1/σ based on mean extinction as σ2 /σ1 increases from 1 to 10 and as the mixing ratio f2 /f1 varies; the special case used in panels (a) and (c) is highlighted. (c) Statistical moments E(sq ) of the actual FPD are compared with the exponential prediction Γ (q+1)1/σq based on the actual MFP. The underestimation of moments at both higher-order (q > 1) and negative order (q < 0) is a direct consequence of the wider-than-exponential nature of the actual FPD. Note that, although their plotted ratio is finite, both moments are in fact divergent for q ≤ −1. Adapted from Fig. 1 in [27]
104
A.B. Davis
on s over a significant range of s-values starting of course at 0. As it turns out, this mandates that the extinction field has correlations over that same range of scales, at least in its 2-point statistics such as the (2nd-order) structure function, [σ(x + r) − σ(x)]2 where r, is a given displacement vector. See the appendix in Davis and Marshak [27], with A. Benassi, for a detailed proof. This is just a formal way of making a quite natural assumption, one that all instrument designers make to some extent for the purposes of signalto-noise management. We are simply saying that a (less noisy) estimate of a spatial average is almost as good as a quasi-point-wise value, only with some tolerable (and maybe correctable) loss of extreme values. And this in turn requires that the optical medium has correlations over the range of scales for which (74) applies. As shown by Davis and Marshak, the welldocumented turbulent/fractal structure of terrestrial clouds guarantees that such correlations exist. Indeed, clouds are “scaling” in the sense that |σ(x + r) − σ(x)|p ∼ rζ(p)
(75)
over a significant range of scales r (2 to 3 orders of magnitude at least). The l.-h. side of (75) is called the “pth-order structure function” and ζ(p) is known to be a continuous concave function as long as the dependance on p of the prefactors on the r.-h. side can be neglected (yet another consequence of Jensen’s inequality). The exponents ζ(p) can in fact be obtained from the spatial/ensemble statistics of h(x) in (74), and vice-versa, using Frisch and Parisi’s [29] multifractal formalism. This kind of scaling is associated with long-range correlations and leads to a correspondingly weak dependence on s of the PDF of σ s in (72); see Fig. 4 for computations based on synthetic turbulence data. That is not the end of the story. It is important to assess the resilience or fragility of Beer’s exponential transmission law to perturbation by 3D variability. Under what conditions is the MFP significantly larger than 1/σ ? And when are the qth-order moments (q > 1) of s significantly larger than the prediction of the exponential distribution? Intuitively, this calls for two conditions: 1. that the amplitude of the 1-point variability is sufficient (cf. Fig. 3b); 2. that at least some of the scales of correlated 2-point variability are commensurate with the MFP. In item 2, we are thinking about the actual MFP and not the biased estimate 1/σ . Recall that the actual MFP can become much larger than 1/σ if there are significant regions of low extinction (consider Fig. 3b when σ1 becomes very small). Davis and Marshak call condition #2 “resonant” variability noting that it is a rather broad resonance, easily achieved in terrestrial clouds and cloud systems. So non-exponential transmission laws are expected to be the rule
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
(b)
2.5
1
2.0
(x)
1.5
1.0
0.5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
0.1
log s 2
0.01 median
PDF estimates (normalized histgram for 10 realizations)
Log-normal variability model
mode
(a)
105
0.001 0.0 0
1000
2000
3000
4000
x
5000
6000
7000
8000
0
0.5 mean±sigma
1
1.5
2 s
2.5
3
(x)
Fig. 4. Example of a transect through a random multifractal extinction field with lognormal statistics. This data is synthetic but the 1- and 2-point statistics are typical of in-cloud extinction variability [30] and such stochastic models are used routinely in 3D RT cloud studies. (a) Sample realization σ(x) with a log-normal PDF generated by exponentiating fractional Brownian motion [31] with a wavenumber spectrum in k−5/3 ; the mean (solid line) is set to unity and the std. dev. is ±1/3 (dashed lines). (b) Illustration of the “1-point scale-independence” property [27]: PDFs of segment averages σ s (x) in (72) do not depend on segment length for all but the most extreme values. Adapted from Fig. 6 in [27]
rather than the exception. Other situations can however arise, at least in theory. At a given amplitude, even quite large amplitude variability can be “too fast” or “too slow” to generate the interesting non-exponential transmission laws. To wit, • if the extinction field is varying so fast that every photon can sample essentially all the variability between almost every scattering, emission or absorption event, then surely only the ensemble-mean extinction really matters because that is (to high accuracy) the outcome of (72); • in contrast, if the extinction field varies so slowly that from its creation to its absorption, escape or detection each photon samples basically just one value of σ, then the ensemble-average transmission law is irrelevant to the transport. The former is the too-fast scenario, a.k.a. the atomistic mix (in stochastic RT theory), and the pertinent approach to assess the bulk transport is to use the mean properties in a homogeneous computation. The latter is the too-slow scenario and an average over homogeneous multiple-scattering computations weighted by the 1-point statistics of the extinction field. This procedure is known in cloud radiation studies as the Independent Pixel/Column Approximation [8, 33].
106
A.B. Davis
Non-Poissonian Point-Process Approach In this subsection, I adopt Kostinski’s [26] perspective on extinction as a point process. I’ll start with uniform optical media. Infinitesimal particles are distributed at random, uniformly in space, according to some density n. The photons in a given light beam interact with these particles simply where they are, so extinction events 1. are a statistically homogeneous process, i.e., which does not depend on position; 2. for small enough volumes, the probability of intercepting more than one photon is vanishingly small; and 3. events in non-overlapping volumes are statistically independent. These properties define a Poisson point-process [34]. So the discrete probability of obtaining exactly N ≥ 0 photon interactions (extinction events) over a given distance s is pN (s; m) = pN (m) =
mN × e−m N!
(76)
where the sole parameter is the mean of N at given s, m = E(N |s) .
(77)
The variance D(N |s), defined as in (56), of a Poisson deviate is equal to its mean.8 We also re-emphasize that, since we are averaging here over the photon transfer events, we use the notation with E(·)’s. Now, setting N = 0 (no events whatsoever over the segment of given length s), we get p0 (s) = exp(−m). By definition, this is direct transmission Tdir (s). We can therefore make the identification m = τ (s) = σs
(78)
in (43), recalling that we found σ (in this case constant) to be particle density n times the collision cross-section per particle s. This is reminiscent of the interpretation of optical distance τ (s) as distance s in units of MFPs; more precisely here, τ (s) is the average number of collisions m suffered over distance s, at the average rate of one per MFP. Of course, at the single photon level, only one such interaction is enough to remove it from the beam, however, a small number of lucky ones can travel across large (optical) distances, that is, several MFPs. We now turn to “lumpiness” in non-uniform optical media, translating to spatial correlations between the particles, hence between the extinction 8
This might sound dissonant to √ some readers on dimensional grounds. (Should that not be standard deviation = D? That is until we recall that this random variable is a pure number: we are just counting events.
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
107
events. In point process theory, correlation is defined as the deviation from Poissonian behavior in the joint probability of finding exactly one particle in each of two small volumes δV1 and δV2 at a distance r: Pr{N1 = N2 = 1; n, r} = n2 δV1 δV2 [1 + η(r)]
(79)
where n is the mean density of the particles. Because of their independence in a uniformly random medium, the Poissonian prediction is η(r) = 0 while η(r) = 0 corresponds to some kind of particle correlation in the medium. In short, we retain above properties #1 and #2 but relax #3. Another, more practical, way of defining η(r) uses the “pair correlation” N (0)N (r) . We have η(r) = N (0)N (r) /N 2 − 1
(80)
where N is the number of particles in the small9 test volume δV . We have N = nδV and we consider two such volumes at a distance r. If the events N (0) and N (r) are independent, then N (0)N (r) = N (0) N (r) = N 2 , hence η(r) = 0. Note that, as in (61), we are averaging here over the disorder of the particle distribution, hence the use of · ’s. Following Landau and Lifschitz’s [35] general analysis of fluctuations and correlations in gases and liquids near a phase transition, it can be shown that, in a small test volume δV , one has δN 2 = N + ηN 2
(81)
where δN = N − N and η is the volume average of η(r) over δV . For example, we have r 3 η(r) = 3 r2 η(r )dr (82) r 0 " 3 with r = 3δV /4π in the case of a spherical volume. Any deviation of η from 0 in (81) takes event variance δN 2 away from the Poissonian value of N . Returning to photon transport through a particulate medium, how do we now estimate pN (s) in the presence of spatial correlations? For simplicity, Kostinski proposes to use Mandel’s formula from statistical optics [36]: ∞ pN (s) = 0
1 pN (s|m) Pr(dm) = N!
∞
mN e−m Pr(dm)
(83)
0
where Pr(dm) is the element of probability that the sole parameter of the (discrete) Poissonian distribution in (76), now a (continuous) random variable, falls between m and m + dm. Accordingly, we have transmuted the “;” separator into a “|” in the argument of pN under the first integral. 9
As nδV becomes small, we have N = 0, 1 depending on whether a particle is present or not, the former becoming the dominant event as soon as nδV 1.
108
A.B. Davis
For N = 0, this is equivalent to the computation of e−τ (s) = exp(−τ ) Pr(dτ |s) in (66) since τ is also equal to m = σs, σ being the random quantity at present. So the three general properties of e−τ (s) and its derived quantities stated in Sect. 3.4 will follow from this alternative model for photon transport. The close formal analogy between (66) and (83) is traceable to the close connection between collision statistics, (direct) transmission, and FPDs. The essential difference between the continuum transport-theoretical and random point-process approaches is that, coming from the latter less-familiar perspective, the question of spatial correlations (i.e., droplet clumping tendencies) arises immediately, at any rate, before the question of how to average over the spatial disorder. In the more familiar continuum approach, we first argued for averaging the (partial) kernel and then argued that the outcome, as strikingly different as it is from an exponential, is only relevant if the optical medium has spatial correlations that overlap with the MFP. The central role of the MFP is not that obvious in the point-process framework. 3.5 Results for Gamma-Distributed Extinctions, and Point-Process Equivalents We assume here a Gamma-distribution for τ = m in (83) or, equivalently, for τ = σs in (64) at a given distance s. The two parameters of this distribution are the mean, σ s, and10 2 τ (s) 2 σ /(σ − σ )2 in the continuum approach = a= m 2 /(m − m )2 in the point-process approach (τ (s) − τ (s) )2 (84) where we recognize a variance in the denominator. So the degenerate (uniform extinction, Poissonian events) case is retrieved in the limit a → ∞: as in (59), no variance at all. The PDF for τ (s), hence for m, reads as a a 1 ×τ a−1 exp[−aτ /σ s] dτ . (85) Pr(dτ |s) = p(τ ; σ s, a) dτ = Γ (a) σ s The second argument —and first parameter— is the mean of τ (s). By writing it as σ s the given step size s appears. The Gamma-distribution has the exponential (or Laplace) law of extinction variability as a special case when a = 1: Pr(dτ |s) = p(τ ; σ s, 1)dτ = exp[−τ /σ s]dτ /σ s , (86) not to be confused with (Beer’s) exponential law of direct transmission. As another example, reconsider Figs. 4 where we see a synthetic in-cloud variability with a = 9 in (84), a reasonable amount of skewness (log-normal 10
a is the squared inverse of the standard non-dimensional variability parameter, i.e., std.-dev./mean.
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
109
PDF), and realistic 2-point correlations (associated with the prescribed k −5/3 wavenumber spectrum). The above choice of variability model for τ (s) is not arbitrary. We have adopted the convenient as well as reasonably accurate parameterization by Barker et al. [37] of the observed variability of optical depth (measured vertically) in high-resolution satellite images of a wide variety of cloud scenes. Figure 5 reproduces their evidence for Gamma-distributions for τ (s), where s is the thickness of the cloud layer using LandSat imagery with ≈30 m pixels and ≈60 km swaths. We note that Barker et al.’s determination of cloud optical depth for each LandSat pixel is based, as usual in cloud remote sensing, on a 1D RT model and this procedure is known to underestimate the variance [38]; so the inferred values of a are likely to be upper bounds. In the continuum approach from Sect. 3.4, this choice of variability model applied to (66) yields Tdir (s; σ , a) = e−τ (s) =
1 (1 + σ s/a)a
(87)
for the mean transmission law which is plotted in Fig. 6b. As expected, the exponential law exp(−σ s) is recovered (using L’Hˆ opital’s rule) in the degenerate-σ limit a → ∞. Otherwise, direct transmission is effectively power-law, with diverging moments E(sq ) for q ≥ a. Assuming a > 1, the MFP exists and is given by a (88) E(s) = σ −1 = σ −1 . a−1 Notice the excess over the standard prediction using σ −1 . It is easy to verify here the general result that E(s) = 1/σ using the PDF in (85). In the discrete point-process approach from Sect. 3.4, the same choice of variability in (85) now reads as a a 1 × ma−1 exp[−am/σ s]dm Pr(dm|s) = p(m; σ s, a)dm = Γ (a) σ s (89) where σ s = m . Applying this to (83) leads to a so-called negative binomial distribution for N . More precisely, we have pN (s) = pN (σ s, a) =
Γ (N + a) (σ s)N 1 × × . (90) N N! Γ (a)(a + σ s) (1 + σ s/a)a
The case a ∈ N − {0} = {1, 2, . . . } is known as the Pascal distribution and it arises naturally from the theory of Bernoulli processes. Specifically, the question is about the probability of having exactly a ≥ 1 successes with probability p and N ≥ 0 failures with probability q = 1 − p, ending with a
110
A.B. Davis
Fig. 5. Empirical support for Gamma-distributed extinction variability in the Earth’s cloudy atmosphere, reproduced from Figs. 1–2 in [37] with permission. (above) Cloud optical depth fields retrieved from more or less cloudy LandSat images: upper row, very cloudy (1.6 a 22.5); middle row, partially cloudy (0.4 a 1.3); lower row, sparse clouds (0.2 a 0.8). Note that optical depth is proportional to extinction averaged vertically over the thickness of the cloud layer. (below) The inferred Gamma distributions (in one-to-one correspondence with the above images) are generally in good agreement for the whole optical depth PDF: observed histograms in solid lines; Gamma-PDF predictions (based only the observed mean and variance) in dashed lines. Figure 6a illustrates in more detail the whole family of Gamma distributions
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media Gamma Probability Density Functions s = (s) = 1, a = 1/ [ (s)] with
(a)
(b)
2.0
111
Ensemble-averaged Free-Path Distributions (FPDs) for Gamma-distributed optical distances (fixed ) 10
0
1.0
p(s)/
0.5
0.0 0.0
0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
10
-1
10
-2
dir
1/2 1 3/2 2 4 8
1.5
dP/d (s)
= |(d/ds)
|/
a
10
-3
10
-4
10
-5
3.0
a 1/2 1 3/2 2 4 8
0.1
(s) = s (step s is constant)
1.0
10.0
s
Fig. 6. Gamma-distributed optical distances for a given physical distance: (a) PDFs of τ from (85) for a given s and selected variability parameters, (b) the resulting mean transmission laws from (87) plotted in log-log axes to highlight the power-law tails
success, when p = 1/(1 + σ s/a) ≤ 1. Equation (90) can thus be expressed formally as N −a σ s 1 × (91) × pN (s) = (−1)N N a + σ s (1 + σ s/a)a even if a > 0 is non-integer.11 For N = 0, we naturally find the same non-exponential transmission laws as in (87) and Fig. 6b. However, looking back at (49), where we assumed a = M 1 for a fixed value of σ s, we can interpret “success” probability p = 1/(1 + σ s/a) ≈ 1 − σ s/a as that of a particle being transmitted through the 1/ath part of s for a given σ . Thus, for N = 0 “failures” to be transmitted a successive times through that ath portion of optical distance σ s, we indeed find (87) for the direct transmission. So clearly the most interesting situation is when a ≈ σ s, i.e., when any given physical distance s is divided roughly into as many distinguishable parts or “clumps” as its (mean) value in optical units. The mean of N is still E(N ) = σ s in (90). Mimicking the form of (81) to emphasize the relation to pair-correlations, we find for the variance of N D(N ) = E(δN 2 ) = E(N ) + ηE(N )2
(92)
where δN = N − E(N ) with η = 1/a ≥ 0 . n
(93)
11 binomial coefficients i are defined by the identity (p + q)n = n usual n The n−i i p q where p + q = 1 in the well-known application to combinai=0 i torics; “negative” binomial coefficients are defined by the identity (1 − q)−r = ∞ −r i (−q) for r > 0. i=0 i
112
A.B. Davis
Accordingly, pN (s) in (90) is sometimes called the “over-dispersed” Poisson distribution. It is nonetheless remarkable that in (93) the point-process approach ties the 2-point statistical quantity η in (81) and the 1-point statistical variability parameter a from (84). In density-based stochastic modeling, one can generally choose the PDF and the correlation structure independently. The above results generalize at once the Poissonian (a = ∞, D(N ) = E(N )) case in (76) with m = σ s and the a = 1 case in (86) that was used by Kostinski [26] as a rather extreme example of sub-exponential transmission: Tdir (s; σ , 1) = p0 (σ s, 1) =
1 . 1 + σ s
(94)
This is indeed the critical value of a at which the MFP becomes (logarithmically) divergent and it hails from the special case of (90) with a = 1 known as the geometric distribution, pN (σ s, 1) =
σ s 1 + σ s
N ×
1 . 1 + σ s
(95)
That is the probability of exactly N ≥ 0 failures before one success when each Bernoulli event is a success with probability p = Tdir = (1 + σ s)−1 in (94). 3.6 From Positive to Negative Correlations Physically, what is it about the spatial correlations that is causing the systematic deviations from exponential transmission? Even if there is a single direction of propagation, we are always computing a projection of the particlelight interaction cross-sections parallel to the beam (cf. Fig. 1). There is naturally random overlap in these projections. What the spatial correlations effectively do is to cause more overlap in the projections, hence more photons are transmitted. The sub-exponential laws we found above are the statistical consequence of this clustering. From there, it is of interest to consider the possibility of negative correlations in the spatial fluctuations of the extinction field (in the continuum approach) or in the pair-correlation function (in the point-process approach). In the extinction field picture, this means that a fluctuation above the mean is more likely than not to be very quickly followed by a fluctuation below the mean, and vice versa; in a sense, this is “fast” variability with a tendency to overshoot the mean. In the pair-correlation picture, this means that the scattering/absorbing particles essentially repel each other, leading to even more uniformity in space than obtained by random (Poisson) positions. The outcome in (80) is η(r) < 0 at least for small values of point-separation distance r. From there, η(r) in (81)–(82) will also be < 0, at least for small enough δV (r) = (4π/3)r3 .
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
113
What are the consequences of negative correlations for photon transmission? Shaw et al. [39] use the pair-correlation model to show that a super-exponential (faster-than-exponential) transmission law will follow from η(r) < 0. The continuum approach has more trouble here because negative correlations are just different incarnations of the uniform-σ hypothesis. The question of how relevant negatively-correlated media are to atmospheric optics is, at present, entirely open [27]. The balance of evidence however favors further consideration of the positive correlations related to droplet or cloud clustering. The known mechanisms that cause cloud particles to repel each other, as listed by Shaw et al. [39], indeed require either very close proximity (threatening the important dilution requirement in any transport theory based on geometric optics) or else rather unusual circumstances (e.g., still air, electric charge separation). Negative correlations can occur also at macroscopic scales: certain types of cloud layers (e.g., marine stratocumulus) are systematically topped by clear layers, trains of orographic clouds downwind from a mountain range will also yield negative correlations at regular distances. However, in both these cases, any chance of occurrence of another cloud further along in the vertical or horizontal direction will restore positive correlations, which already dominate at the micro-scale. 3.7 Summary, Discussion, and Outlook On the one hand, we have established the deep non-Poissonian nature of photon transport in variable optical media and, on the other hand, we have underscored the importance of having spatial correlations over MFP scales to obtain non-exponential FPDs. An inescapable consequence of deviations from spatial uniformity of the cloud droplets is that the mean (or effective) photon transport kernel is non-exponential. More precisely it is sub-exponential in the case of positive correlations (clumping tendencies). In the atmosphere, spatial correlations in cloud structure exist over a vast range of scales horizontally as well as vertically, although clearly in qualitatively different ways. This range goes from centimeters at least up to the thickness of the troposphere (≈10 km), and often much more in the horizontal. There are both positive and negative correlations, but at scales that matter for photon transport they are overwhelmingly positive. Two-point spatial correlations, even of the right sign and over the right range of scales, are of little consequence unless extinction (and, hence, the pseudo-MFP) also vary widely enough in the sense of the 1-point statistics (i.e., the PDF). Consider the following two scenarios: • In a single dense un-broken cloud layer, the MFP is small with respect to the physical thickness of the layer. This is equivalent to saying that the layer is optically thick and that (literally) an exponentially small amount of direct sunlight gets through.
114
A.B. Davis
• Now imagine a complex situation with broken clouds and possibly also multiple layers (not necessarily all optically thick), and add to that a partially reflective surface. In this case, the optical quasi-vacuum between the clouds dominates the average 1/σ of the local pseudo-MFP. So this estimate of the overall MFP can be huge, possibly larger than the physical thickness of the whole cloudy region. In particular, abundant direct sunlight can reach the ground in spite of the presence of clouds. In the following section, we will see that • in the former case, radiation is transported by standard diffusion, each photon executes a convoluted trajectory. This path is a classical (Gaussian) random walk with an inner cut-off at the small MFP scale and an outer cut-off determined by the finite thickness of the cloud layer. • in the later case, radiation is transported by anomalous diffusion where most steps in the random walk (inside clouds) are small but some steps (between clouds and/or surface) can be huge. This is as predicted by the basic transport computations presented above in the presence of positive correlations and, in this case, the photons execute L´evy-type random walks [40] where the tail of the step distribution is power-law. Before moving on, we note that Borovoi [41] objected to Kostinski’s [26] linkage of non-Poissonian droplet distributions and sub-exponential transmission laws in the light of his previous [42] investigation that used standard transport theory and favored effective medium theory (hence modified exponential transmission laws). Kostinski’s reply [43] is worth reading in that it (1) reasserts the relevance of the spatial correlations, and hence of nonexponential transmission laws, and (2) claims that the point-process model is more general than standard transport theory because it allows for negative correlations. In [27], we agree with Kostinski on the former claim, coming from the transport theoretical perspective used by Borovoi (cf. Sects. 3.4–3.4), but we have reservations about the latter claim. First, the atmospheric scenarios for negative correlations are marginal if not implausible (as argued above); secondly, empirical evidence weighs in for sub-exponential transmission laws (cf. Sect. 5); thirdly, I have unpublished results showing that density-based computations can handle negative correlations and lead to super-exponential transmission laws (the variability of course has to violate the continuity conditions required in the above). Most importantly however, the author views this as a healthy debate on the fundamentals of 3D RT.
4 Multiple Scattering and Diffusions 4.1 Multiple Forward Scatterings Let Ω0 be the initial direction of propagation in R3 , or position on Ξ, for a particle beam in a medium with conservative ( 0 = 1) axi-symmetric
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
115
scatters. The medium may be variable but we will assume the scattering phase function is the same everywhere. By symmetry, the average direction E(Ωn ) is Ω0 for any number of scatterings n. By taking Ω0 as the polar axis (µ0 = 1), we can use θn = cos−1 (Ω0 •Ωn ) = cos−1 (µn ) to measure the (greatcircle) distance on Ξ between initial and current directions of propagation. From (29), we know that E(Ω0 • Ω1 ) = · · · = E(Ωn−1 • Ωn ) = g ∈ [−1, +1] .
(96)
I now show by induction that E(µn ) = E(Ω0 • Ωn ) = g n .
(97)
Indeed, the only component of interest is (Ωz )n = µn ; all others vanish upon averaging, by symmetry. From spherical trigonometry, " " (98) µn+1 = µn µs + 1 − µ2n 1 − µ2s cos φs where the azimuthal angle φs in the second term is uniformly distributed on [0,2π) and uncorrelated to θs and θn ; so it averages to zero. Therefore E(µn+1 ) = E(µn µs ). Like in the propagation part of particle transport, there is a (discrete) Markovian property for scattering: transition probability is independent of present state. This leads to12 E(µn+1 ) = E(µn )E(µs ) = E(µn )g, ∀n ,
(99)
and thus completes the proof. Equation (97) enables us to quantify accurately the decay of directionality in a light beam embedded deeply in a uniform turbid medium, sometimes called “blooming:” Ωn can be anywhere on Ξ with almost equal probability as soon as we have, say, E(µn ) ≈ 1/e. This happens at a critical scattering order n∗ ≈ −1/(ln g). For small enough values of (1 − g), this reads as n∗ ≈ 1/(1 − g)
(100)
which roughly defines the number of forward-peaked scattering events required for the photon to loose almost all memory of its original direction of travel. Another way of showing that directional memory is short (i.e., lost in finite time) is to view the typical great-circle distance from the origin, θn = cos−1 µn , as a discrete-time diffusion on the sphere. By identifying 12
An interesting corollary of this recursion formula is that, if the phase function is Henyey–Greenstein, then the angular distribution of n-times scattered radiance (in the absence of boundary and 3D effects) is Henyey–Greenstein with g(n) = g n . Since (under these same conditions) vectorial addition of random directions is determined by spherical convolutions of the PDFs that are phase functions, this implies that Henyey–Greenstein functions are the spherical equivalent of Gaussian PDFs: invariant, modulo scaling, under convolution.
116
A.B. Davis
E[cos θn ] ≈ 1 − E[θn2 ]/2 on the tangent plane13 of Ξ at µ = 1 and, remarking that g n = [1 − (1 − g)]n ≈ 1 − n × (1 − g) when (1 − g) 1, we obtain E[θn2 ] ≈ 2(1 − g)n .
(101)
So 2(1 − g) plays the role of a diffusivity constant. Based on (101), where do √ we expect θn to be for n = n∗ in (100)? Approximately at 2 rad (hence ≈ 90◦ ) on average, meaning almost anywhere on Ξ for a given realization. In summary, photons emanating from a collimated beam in a scattering medium with a forward-peaked phase function have a collective memory of their original direction, but it is a relatively short term memory. The higher the number of scatterings, the more isotropic the corresponding radiance, independently of spatial considerations (boundaries, internal variability). The critical number of scatterings needed to redistribute radiance in direction space is estimated to be ≈ (1−g)−1 . In a general multiple-scattering problem we can define the equivalent number of isotropic scatterings as niso = n/n∗ ≈ (1 − g)n .
(102)
4.2 Impact of Forward Scattering on Propagation: The Transport MFP (without Fick’s Law) We are now in a position to look at the spatial consequences of the shortterm memory of propagation direction due to forward-peaked but conservative ( 0 = 1) scattering, as described in Sect. 4.1. The light particles are executing directionally-correlated random walks based on a FPD that need not be specified beyond the fact that the MFP must exist. We again assume the photons all leave the origin in direction Ω0 at time n = 0. In the discrete-time picture, the particle is then displaced from position x0 = 0 to x1 = x0 + s0 Ω0 , where s0 is the initial step size. Holding Ω0 fixed, we have (103) E(x1 ) = E(s0 )Ω0 = Ω0 , using the definition of MFP in (50) or (52). From x1 , and conditional to not being absorbed, the photon moves on to x2 = x1 + s1 Ω1 . It is clear that E(x2 − x1 ) = E(s1 )E(Ω1 • Ω0 )Ω0
(104)
since the propagation and scattering are independent, another consequence of the Markovian property of transport. Now, after the first scattering and second step, it follows from (96) that E(x2 ) = [E(s0 ) + E(s1 )E(µs )]Ω0 = (1 + 13
0 g)Ω0
,
(105)
This 2nd-order (Gaussian) approximation is at the core of the “small-angle” approximation in RT theory used extensively in imaging and lidar studies [44].
Effective Propagation Kernels in Structured Media
117
where it is assumed that the 1st and 2nd FPDs have the same MFP and that an absorption may have occurred at x1 with probability 1 − 0 ≥ 0. By iteration, the independence of step-sizes and step-directions leads under the same assumption to lim E(xn ) • Ω0 =
n→∞
∞
n 0 E(µn )
=
n=0
∞
(
n 0 g)
n=0
=
1−
0g
.
(106)
So, after many scatterings, the cumulative effect of forward scattering is simply to boost the initial ballistic motion by a factor (1 − 0 g)−1 . The distance in (106) is the well-known transport MFP t =
1−
0g
.
(107)
Note that we have made no assumption about the FPD beyond the existence of a MFP; in particular, no spatial homogeneity assumption per se was made, only constancy of the MFP (in some spatial/ensemble average sense if required). The emergence of the transport MFP in (107) as the residual impact of short-term directional memory on propagation is in sharp contrast with the usual derivations which come along with the diffusion/P1 approximation to the full 3D RT problem in (1)–(3). This classic macroscopic approach to the transport problem is encapsulated in Fick’s law [45], relating particle density and current: ct ∇U (108) F=− 3 where ! ! U (t, x) 1/c = I(t, x, Ω)dΩ (109) F(t, x) Ω 4π
defines particle (in our case photon) density and current (or net vector flux), anticipating the generalization in Sect. 5.2 for time dependence. Fick’s law (108) is the constitutive relation that closes the macroscopic transport problem started with continuity equation obtained by expressing particle conservation: ∂U + ∇ • F + cσa U = 0 , ∂t
(110)
where the two last terms come from the angular integral of the steady-state 3D RT equation in (1)–(3) in the absence of sources. At least to a first approximation, the total path L of a photon is n × . Notice that (for 0 = 1) the same answer is obtained if we reckon on the actual MFP and number of scatterings, or on the effective number of isotropic scatterings niso in (102) and the transport MFP t in (107). This makes physical sense since L/c is simply the time since the photon was emitted and
118
A.B. Davis
it should not depend on whether we count actual scatterings and MFPs or effectively isotropic scatterings and transport MFPs. In summary, photons in an isotropically scattering medium (g = 0) lose track of their direction of propagation at every step (average length ), but it takes their positively Ω-correlated counterparts about (1 − g)−1 forwardpeaked scatterings to “forget” their original direction.14 In the process, this causes them to travel (on average) that much further by drifting in the original direction. So t can be interpreted as the effective MFP for obtaining one isotropic scattering. Figure 7 illustrates these results in two spatial dimensions. 4.3 Asymptotics of Standard and Anomalous Diffusion in Finite Media The overarching goal of the research program surveyed in this paper so far is to decompose ensemble-average (or large-scale) photon transport in 3D media into processes that are simpler to model, namely, diffusions. Photons diffuse in direction space and loose track of their original direction in finite time but cumulate over this time interval an extended d