Chemical Processing Ceramics edited
Burtrand I. Lee Clemson University Clemson. Carolina
Edward J. A. Pope MATECH Village, Calihrnia and
of City#
Marcel Dekker, Inc.
New York*Basel*Hong
Kong
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Chemical processing ceramics edited by Burtrand I. Lee, Edward J . A. Pope. cm.p. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-8247-9244-0 (alk. paper) 1. Ceramicmaterials. Lee,BurtrandInsung. II. Pope,Edward J . A. TP810.5.C48 1994 666-dc20 94-25396 CIP The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special SalesProfessional Marketing at the address below. book is printed on acid-free paper. Copyright 0 1994 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Neither this book nor any part may be reproducedor transmitted in any formor by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Marcel Dekker, Inc. 270 Madison Avenue, New York, New York 10016 Current printing (last digit): 10987654321 PRINTED IN T I E UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Foreword
The value of a book is not only in its contents but in the creative idea it further encourages. These are a few ideas about the past and the future that occur to me as stimulated by chapters in this book. The volume is a fine resource of references to the use of chemistry in materials and should, indeed, encourage thinking about such things. The early use of chemistry for particular compounds was usually not with materials chemistry in mind but rather was chemistry for chemistry’s sake. The very early nature of much chemistry, now rightly readdressed for materials, appears to surprise many who believe (or wish it to be believed) that their field is new. Many chemical methods are naturally revived with new materials goals in prospect. Mechanochemical studies and aerogels are in vogue at the moment, the former more than 100 years old and the latter 60 years old. Only very ocoasionally will someone, with enough time and energy to review the early literature, produce a historical perspective as Hlavacek did for thermite processing also known as fast propagating reactions. we have come to realize that although the “spin” on chemistry for materials is new, the processes often have a long and steady historical progression. Also not new are the phenomena seen in nanostructures-all sol-gel (e.g., Chapter 13 “all aerogels are nanocrystalline”) and life chemistry is nanostructural, and chemists long have been able to prepare molecular clusters and nanocrystalline powers by vaporization or, better, by decomposition of precursors (typically hydroxides, carbonates, nitrates, acetates, citrates, and on). Even the recent production of biphasic or polyphasic nanostructures from polymers had been preceded. by the decomposition of mixed crystals [e.g., CaMg(Co3)2, dolomite, to CaO and MgO]. Carbon and S i c fibers (NicalonB) are nanostructural. In this book, nanocrystalline cobalt from 1966 is mentioned (Chapter 18). Naturally, the nanostructural works of chemists could not be directly examined before the advent of electron microscopes, but more indirect iii
iv
FOREWORD
methods (sometimes forgotten today) had given us a good knowledge of what was going on. Although chemical synthesis has a long history, many new, simple syntheses are being discovered and many more are mentioned in this book, e.g., the use of alkali iodides to make the molybdenum bronzes (Chapter 3) and creative uses of electrochemistry (Chapter 15). Many new structure types, some related to known types, are yet to be found by suitable new methods as discussed by Rao in Chapter 3. For example, many regular intergrowth structures are little lower in free energy of formation than the separate-layer types standing alone and so can be quite difficult to attain. Nevertheless they may have unique and useful properties. For every rule there are exceptions, and is peculiarly true in chemistry; it seems to be taken by many as gospel that precursorsto complex ceramics, chemically mixed at the molecular level, must always be preferable to other kinds of mixtures but “it ain’t necessarily However, of all the possible methods of chemical mixing, the default recourse to the Pechini method seems curious as it is hardly the simplest or most desirable method in most cases. To elaborate: if unwanted intermediates are produced at lower temperatures on the way to the desired compounds, then the purpose of molecular mixtures may be defeated. is true in some ferroelectrics and special routes involving deliberately unstable or transient intermediates can be preferable, as mentioned in Chapter 17. It was noted early that for the P-alumindmagnetoplumbitefamily, chemical mixing, which, indeed, produced products at lower temperatures (usually desirable), also led to syntactic intergrowth problems; this has recently been seen again in the high-temperature superconductors (HTSC). (There are no new ceramic phenomena in the HTSC.) In this case also, the production of special intermediates (e.g., Pb-doped-2122 en route to Pb-doped-2223) can be beneficial. Early alkoxide work was certainly done without modem materials in mind; rather the early sol-gel chemistry was with absorbents and catalyst supports in view. Much synthetic work has been done on alkoxides, but a peculiar theoretical schizophrenia exists about them and their relation to oxides. Studies show that bond lengths and angles are very similar in alkoxide clusters to those found in oxides and polyoxyanions. This is mentioned several times in the book (e.g., Chapters 1, 2, and 21). If it looks like a duck, etc., it probably is a duck, which is to say that the bonding in alkoxides is very similar to that in oxides. Alkoxides are not covalent and oxides ionic; they are similar. Modem X-ray methods to determine actual charges on “ions” in oxides show them to be very small. While modeling Madelung potential methods, etc., often work, they are as ballet or opera is to love, merely an artistic (and often useful) imaginative representation. This will become more apparent as workers are attracted to this field and as old shibboleths fade. Even with the extensive work on alkoxides described in this book, there are
FOREWORD
V
surprising new (old!) developments worth mentioning especially the use of polyhydric alcohols to attain unusual coordination states in silicon (viz. 5-fold coordinate with glycols and 6-coordinate with catechols). New synthetic possibilities will further enhance the power of alkoxide chemistry. The area of heterometallic alkoxides (as discussed in Chapter 2) is very important and there are many cheap ways of synthesizing them, including the reactions of chlorides and similar chemicals with already formed alkoxides. People who claim that alkoxides are too expensive to be used should realize that in any real commercial process the alcohols would be recycled. Difficulties with alkoxides-sol-gel, other than the silicon cases mentioned several times in this book, suggest to me that in the future syneresis, an area that surprisingly is little studied (mentioned in Chapter 17), should pay dividends. Those who may believesthat large-scale chemical methods are unlikely to be used for ceramics should consider the following: the earliest synthesis of Si3N4 was by the chemical reaction of Sic14 with ammonia and not the, perhaps, more familiar reaction of Si plus N2 (elemental Si was not readily available in the early days). Today the largest volume of Si3N4 powder (>300 tons per year) is made by that earliest reaction route and much of it in the future seems destined for automobiles. Carbothermal nitridation of Si02 to produce Si3N4 was only later done with fertilizers in mind. As discussed in Chapter 5, an unexpected related manifestation of this is the production of S i c by pyrolysis of rice hulls. It was for the longest time believed that p-Si3N4 was the high-temperature form, or could only be produced at higher temperatures than the a-form; chemical methods have revealed otherwise, as when pSi3N4 forms from prepolymers at 1150°C (Chapter 15). This exemplifies how chemical synthesis, often designed simply with the goal of making something, serendipitously reveals results in conflict with traditional wisdom that has been acquired via a different viewpoint. In chemical processing particular methods are rarely an answer to many problems but they may address niche uses of materials (the centrifugal pipe lining use of “thermite processing” is such a use). Although much early chemistry exists in the literature, and is not difficult to find, there is also the fact that much experimentation occurred that was never published. I know of all kinds of preliminary tests that were done and not followed up in the light of their perceived limited value at the time. It is inevitable that this ground will be gone over again and while the original workers cannot take credit for unpublished work, the modem “discoverers” should recognize that the oldsters knew much more than they let on, but inevitably they could not recognize the pertinence of their knowledge to the materials problems of today. Peter E. D.Morgan
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface
Despite many recent advances in material science and engineering, the performance of ceramic components in severe conditions is still far below the ideal limits predicted by theory. Modem ceramics have been primarily the products of applied physics and parallel the developments of physical metallurgy. The emphasis on the relation between behavior and microstructure has been fruitful for ceramic scientists for several decades, It has been recently realized, however, that major advances in ceramics during the next several decades will require an emphasis on molecular-level control. Organic chemistry, once abhorred by ceramic engineers trained to define ceramics as “inorganic-nonmetallicmaterials,” has become a valuable source of new ceramics. It has recently become known that as the structural scale in ceramics is reduced from macro to micro and to nano crystalline regimes, the basic properties are drastically altered. brittle ceramic material has been shown to be partially ductile, for example. The impetus and the ultimate goal in chemical processing of ceramic materials are to control physical and chemical variability by the assemblage of uniquely homogeneous structures, nanosized second phases, controlled surface compositional gradients, and unique combinations of dissimilar materials to achieve desired properties. Significant improvements in environmental stability and performance should result from such nanoscale molecular design of materials. The unique properties of ceramics with comparable mechanical performance may be realized by the molecular level or nanoscale fabrication of the chemical building blocks of the materials. number of books are available that deal with the chemical processing aspect of ceramic materials but most of them are conference proceedings. This book is written by many authors who are actively involved in the field of chemical processing of ceramic materials. The authors are from the intemational materials community-Japan, Germany, Korea, France, India, and the United States, where they practice chemical principles in the fabrication of superior ceramic materials. vii
viii
PREFACE
This book presents current development and concepts in chemical techniques for production of state-of-the-art ceramic materials in a truly interdisciplinary fashion. The twenty-three chapters are divided into six parts reflecting topical groups. It first discusses the starting materials-how to prepare and modify them in the molecular precursor stage. Powders are the most heavily used form of starting ceramic materials. Synthesis, characterization, and behavior of ceramic powders are presented in Parts I1 and 111. In the fourth part, forming and shaping of ceramic components via sol-gel technique are discussed. Fabrication of nonoxide ceramics is covered in Part V. In the last part of this book, several specific examples of classes of ceramic materials fabricated by chemical processing including thin films, membranes, and superconductors are presented. These classes of examples are chosen on the basis of the current demand and active research. The topics of basic principles of sub-gel technique, sintering, and postsintering processing are not reviewed in volume since there are other excellent books dealing solely with these topics. Although this book is edited, it is organized to reflect the sequence of ceramic processing and the coherent theme of chemical processing for advance ceramic materials. Hence book is suitable as a supplementary textbook for advanced undergraduate and graduate courses in ceramic science and materials chemistry as well as an excellent reference book for practicing chemists and materials scientists and engineers. shown by some of the data presented in this book, the results from chemical processing are not yet up to the real applications of ceramic materials. It is evident that, through further research, the full potential of chemical processing for ceramic materials that perform up to the theoretical limit can be realized. It is the authors’ and the editors’ desire to bring the ceramist and chemist closer together to produce superior ceramic materials. Burtrand Lee Edward J. A. Pope
Contents
Foreword Peter E. D.Morgan Preface Contributors
iii vii xi
Precursor Chemistry
Molecular Design of Transition Metal Alkoxide Precursors Jacques Livage Metal Alkoxides for Electrooptical Ceramics Liliane G. Hubert-Pfalzgraf
3
II. Powder Synthesis and Characterization
3. Chemical Synthesis of Metal Oxide Powders C. N. R. Rao 4.
Multicomponent Ceramic Powders T. Mah, E. E. Hemes, and K. S. Mazdiyasni Chemical Synthesis of Nonoxides Christian Russel and Michael Seibold Techniques for Characterization of Advanced Ceramic Powders S. G. Malghan, P. S. Wang, and A. Hackley
Powder Processing
Colloid Interface Science for Ceramic Powder Processing Hyun M. Jang Ceramic Nonaqueous Particles Media in Burtrand I. Lee Synthesis and Dispersion of Barium Titanate and Related Ceramic Powders Ki Hyun Yoon and Kyung Hwa Jo
ix
CONTENTS
X
Rheology and Mixing of Ceramic Mixtures Used in Plastic Molding Beebhas C. Mutsuddy
239
W . Sol-Gel Processing Processing Monolithic Ceramics via Sol-Gel J. Phalippou 12. Bulk Optical Materials from Sol-Gel Edward J. Pope 13. Aerogel Manufacture, Structure, Properties, and Applications Jochen Fricke and Joachim Gross 14. Fractal Growth Model of Gelation Edward J. A. Pope
265 287 311 337
V. CeramicsviaPolymerChemistry 15. Nonoxide Ceramics via Polymer Chemistry Kenneth E. Gonsalves and Tongsan D. Xiao 16. Polymer Pyrolysis Masaki Narisawa and Kiyohito Okamura
359 375
VI. Processing of Specialty Ceramics 17. Processing of Lead-Based Dielectric Materials Hung C. Ling and Man F. Yan 18. Synthesis of Magnetic Particles Masataka Ozaki 19. Chemistry Processing of High-Temperature Superconductors Shin-Pei Matsuda 20. Preparation and Properties Tantalum Oxide Thin Films by Sol-Gel T. Ohishi 21. Crystalline and Amorphous Thin Films of Ferroelectric Oxides Ren Xu 22. Ceramic Membrane Processing C. Guizard, A. Julbe, A. Larbot, and L. Cot
Index
397 421
445
465
481 501
533
Contributors
L. Cot Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Montpellier, France Jochen Fricke Physikalisches Institut der Universiut, Am Hubland, Wurzburg, Germany Kenneth
Gonsalves University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut
Joachim Gross Physikalisches Institut der Universitat, Am Hubland, Wurzburg, Germany
C. Guizard Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Montpellier, France V. Hackley National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Maryland Hermes Wright Paterson Air Force Base, Ohio Liliane G. Hubert-PfalzgrafUniversitk de Nice-Sophia Antipolis, Nice, France Hyun Jang Pohang University of Science and Technology, Pohang, Republic Korea Kyung Hwa Jo* Yonsei University, Seoul, Korea Julbe Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Montpellier, France Larbot Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique, Montpellier, France Burtrand
Lee Clemson University, Clemson, South Carolina
Hung C. Ling AT&T Bell Laboratories, Princeton, New Jersey Jacques Livage Universite Pierre et Marie Curie, Paris, France *Currenr affiliation: Daewoo Corporation, Ltd.,
Seoul,
xi
xii
CONTRIBUTORS
l: Mah UES, Inc., Dayton, Ohio S. G. Malghan National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, Maryland Shin-Pei Matsuda Hitachi, Ltd., Ibaraki, Japan
K.
Mazdiyasni General Atomics, San Diego, California
P.
D. Morgan Rockwell Science Center, Thousand Oaks, California
Beebhas C. Mutsuddy Michigan Technological University, Houghton, Michigan Masaki Narisawa University of Osaka Prefecture,
Japan
T. Ohishi Hitachi, Ltd., Ibaraki, Japan Kiyohito OkamuraUniversity of Osaka Prefecture, Osaka, Japan Masataka Ozaki Yokohama City University, Yokohama, Japan
J. Phalippou Universitb de Montpellier 11, Montpellier, France Edward Pope MATECH, Westlake Village, California, and University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah C.
N.
Rao 1ndian.Instituteof Science, Bangalore, India
Christian Russel Universitat Jena, Jena, Germany Michael Seibold OSRAM GmbH, Augsburg, Germany Wang National Institute of Standards andTechnology, Gaithersburg, Maryland Tongsan D. Xiao University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut Ren Xu University of Utah, Salt Lake City, Utah Man F. Yan AT&T Bell Laboratories, Murray Hill, New Jersey Ki Hyun YoonYonsei University, Seoul, Korea
I PRECURSOR CHEMISTRY
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Molecular Design of Transition Metal Alkoxide Precursors Jacques Livage Universitk Pierre et Mane Curie Paris, France
I. INTRODUCTION Transition metal alkoxides are much more reactive toward hydrolysis and condensation than silicon alkoxides. This arises mainly from the larger size and lower ,electronegativity of transition metal elements. Coordination expansion becomes a key parameter that controls the molecular structure and chemical reactivity of these alkoxides. Hydrolysis and condensation rates of silicon alkoxides must be increased by acid or base catalysis, whereas they must be carefully controlled for the other metal alkoxides. The chemical modification of transition metal alkoxides leads to the development of a new molecular engineering. The chemical design of these new precursors allows the sol-gel synthesis of shaped materials in the form of fine powders, fibers, or films.
II. HYDROLYSIS AND CONDENSATION ALKOXIDES
METAL
Sol-gel chemistry is based on the hydrolysis and condensation of metal alkoxides M(OR),. These reactions can be described as follows [l]: M-OR M-OH
+ H20 ”-+ M OH + ROH hydrolysis + R 0 -M +M- 0 -M + ROH condensation
Condensed species are progressively formed, giving rise to oligomers, oxopolymers, colloids, gels, or precipitates.
LNAGE
Actually these reactions correspond to the nucleophilic substitution of alkoxy ligands by hydroxylated species XOH, as follows: M(OR), + AXOH _ j [M(OR),.AOX),I + xROH where X is hydrogen (hydrolysis), a metal atom (condensation), or even an organic or inorganic ligand (complexation). They can be described by a S$ mechanism [2]:
H” \ O-M-O’-R+
H
\
06+M”-OR/ X
/
X
Step 1
H” / XO-M--OXO-M+ROH \ R
Step 2
Step
1. The first step corresponds to the nucleophilic addition ofnegatively charged H06 groups onto positively charged metal atoms M&. It leads to an increase in the coordination number of the metal atom in the transition state. 2. The second step is a transfer, within the transition state, of the positively charged proton toward a negatively charged OR group. The positively charged protonated alkoxide ligand ROH is then removed.
The chemical reactivity of metal alkoxides toward hydrolysis and condensation mainly depends on the positive charge of the metal atom and its ability to increase its coordination number N [2]. Asa general rule, the electronegativity metal atoms decreases and their size increases when going down the periodic table, from the top right to the bottom left (Table 1). The chemical reactivity of the corresponding alkoxides toward hydrolysis and condensation then increases.
Table 1 Electronegativity x, PartialCharge Ionic Radius r, and Maximum Coordination NumberN of Some Metal Alkoxides
Alkoxide Si(OiPr)4 Ti(OiPr)4 Zr(0iPr)rl Ce(OiPr)4 PO(OEt)3 VO(OEt)3
X
N
0.64
MOLECULAR DESIGN
OF TRANSITION METAL ALKOXIDE
5
Silicon alkoxides are not very reactive. Gelation occurs within several days after water has been added [3]. Hydrolysis and condensation rates must be increased viaacid or base catalysis. The hydrolysis rate of Ti(OEt)4 ( h = lO-3/M/s) is about five orders of magnitude greater than that of Si(OEt)4 ( h = 5 lO-g/M/s). Cerium alkoxides are very sensitive to moisture. They must be handled with care in a dry atmosphere; otherwise, precipitation occurs as soon as water is present Alkoxides of highly electronegative elements, such as PO(OEt)3, cannot be hydrolyzed under ambient conditions [5], whereasthe corresponding vanadium derivatives VO(OEt)3 readily give gels upon hydrolysis [6].
MOLECULARSTRUCTURE OF TRANSITION METAL ALKOXIDES Silicon alkoxides have beenwidelyused for thesol-gelsynthesis of silicabased glasses andceramics. Silicon remains fourfold coordinated (N = in the precursor as well as in the oxide. All silicon alkoxides Si(OR)4 are therefore monomericandtetrahedral. Their reactivity decreases whenthe size of the alkoxy group increases; thisis mainly caused by steric hindrance factors, which play a major role during the formation of hypervalent silicon intermediates [l]. The situation is completely different with other metal alkoxides M(OR),. The coordination number N of the metal atom in the oxide M o a is usually larger than the oxidation state z. As a consequence, coordination expansion appears to be a general tendency for most metal alkoxides. Positively charged transition metal atomsMz+ tend to increase their coordination number by using theirvacant orbitals to accept electrons from nucleophilic ligands (nucleophilic addition). This currently occurs via oligomerization (OR bridges), solvation or the formation of oxoalkoxides (p-oxo bridges) [2].
A.
Oligomerization
Sharing alkoxy groups is the easiest way for metal alkoxides to increase the coordination of the metal atom without changing their stoichiometry. In pure alkoxides, coordination expansion currently occurs viathe formation ofOR bridges. Therefore oligomeric as well as monomeric molecular precursors can be found. Oligomerization depends on physical parameters (concentration and temperature) and chemical factors(solventand oxidation state of themetal atom or steric hindrance of alkoxide groups) [7]. Bulky secondary or tertiary alkoxy groups tend to prevent oligomerization, and the steric hindrance of alkoxy ligands appears to be a major parameter. Oligomeric species [Ti(0Et)4ln(n = 2 or 3) have been evidenced for titanium ethoxide whereas Ti(OiPr)4 and Ti(OtAm)4 remain monomeric (Fig. 1). X-ray absorption experiments at the Ti-K edge have been performed on the
LNAGE
'OEt
Molecular
of titanium alkoxides. (a) = TiOiPr4; (b) [Ti(oEt)4]3.
neat alkoxides in the liquid state [8]. Prepeaks can be seen in X-ray Absorption Near Edge Structure (=S) spectra just before the absorptionedge (Fig. 2a). They correspond to 1s + 3d electronic transitions and are very sensitive to the local symmetry around titanium. sharp prepeak is observed in Ti(OtAm)4, suggestingthatTi is fourfold coordinated, whereastheweakerprepeakin Ti(OEt)4 should correspondto a fivefold coordination. Moreover, two Ti-0 distances (1.82 and 2.05 A) and Ti to Ti correlations (3.12 A) can be observed in Ti(OEt)4, evidencing the oligomeric structure of this alkoxide. Such correlations are not seen in the Extended X-ray Absorption Fine Structure (EXAFS) spectrum Ti(OtAm)4, which exhibits a single Ti-0 distance (1.81 A; Fig. 2b). The chemical reactivity of metal alkoxides strongly depends on their molecular structure. Oligomeric titanium alkoxides, in which Ti has a higher coordination number, are less reactive, allowing better control of hydrolysis and condensation reactions. Monodispersed Ti02 powers are usually obtained from Ti(OEt)4 rather than Ti(OiPr)4 [9,10]. Oligomerization becomes more and more important as the N-Z difference increases, that is, as the oxidation state Mz+ decreases. Divalent metals give insoluble polymeric alkoxides [M(OR)2],, (#+ = Fe, CO, Ni, Cu, . . .). This was a real drawback for the sol-gel synthesis high-Tc superconducting ceramics, such as YBa2Cu307-~Bulky ligands, such as 2-(2-ethoxy-ethoxy)ethoxide had then to be used to prevent oligomerization and obtain soluble copper oxide molecular precursors [l l].
Metal alkoxides are not miscible with water, so that sol-gel reactions must be performed in the presence a common solvent, such as an alcohol. Coordination expansion can then also occur via solvation. Solvate formation is often
MOLECULAR DESIGN OF TRQNSITION METAL ALKOXIDE
7
Ti-0
.2 '
.¶
.6
I
.
4
.. :.
.
:i J
R
r
4.96
5.02
5
Ti-0
.9 -
1.2
-
!
-
Ti(OEtI4
.!/ i/
E
I J
4.96
I
4.98
5
5.02
2 X-ray absorption of titaniumalkoxides at the Ti-Kedge.(a) = X m S ; (b) = EXAFS (Fourier transform). observed when alkoxides are dissolved in their parent alcohol. The stability of such solvates increases with the size and the electropositive character of the metal, that is, when going down the periodic table [7]. Molecular complexity increases with the size the metal atom. Ti(IV), for instance, gives monomeric (Ti(OiPr)4 species, whereas Zr(IV) and Ce(1V) give dimeric species, [Zr(OniPr)4,iPrOnH]2and[Ce(OiPr)4(iPrOH]2. Such dimers can be crystallized from the solution. Their structure, studied byX-ray diffraction, shows that alcohol molecules are directly bonded to the metal atom to increase its coordination (Fig. 3) [12,13]. Because coordination expansion could occur either via alkoxide bridging or solvation, the molecular complexity of metal alkoxides can be tailored by an appropriate choice ofsolvent.[Zr(OnPr)41n oligomers are formed (n I4) in nonpolar solvents, such as cyclohexane, allowing slow hydrolysis rates and the formation of clear gels. Less condensed solvates are formed in propanol (n = 2); hydrolysis becomes much faster and leads to precipitation [14].
LNAGE Pro H
PrO
OPr
H OPr
Molecularstructure of [Ce(OiPr)4, PirOHIz.
C.
of Oxoalkoxides
Alkoxide groups can also bridge two different metal atoms, leading to the formation of heteroalkoxides, which are often used a precursors for the sol-gel synthesis of multicomponent ceramics [15]. Condensation can even go one step further, leading to p-oxo bridges via ether elimination. M-OR+RO-M"-0-"M+ROR This typically occurs when alkoxide solutions are heated under reflux to provide better mixing of the components. Condensation is favored by the smaller size of oxo ligands and their ability to exhibit highercoordination numbers, M"oxo ligands, for instance,havebeenbeenobservedin Na2FeaO(OCH3)18; 6CH30H [16]. Oxo bridges favor the coordination expansion of metal atoms, and oxoalkoxides are more stable thanthe corresponding alkoxides and of course less reactive toward hydrolysis and condensation [17]. Large and electropositive metals are known to give oxo-alkoxides, such as Pb40 (OEt)6. This Pb(I1) precursor undergoes complete dissolution in ethanol when Nb(OEt)5 is added, giving rise tothecrystallization of [Pb604(OEt)4][Nb(OEt)5]4.Such heterometallic alkoxides have the correct Pb/Nb stoichiometry for the sol-gel synthesis of PbMgln NbmO3 (PMN) ceramics [18]. Heterometallic alkoxides are often more soluble than their parent alkoxides, a property that can be advantageously used for the sol-gel chemistry of nonsoluble alkoxides. They also provide molecular precursors withthecorrect M I M stoichiometry inwhichsome M-0-M' bonds are already formed [15]. Alkoxide bridges are usually hydrolyzed during the sol-gel synthesis, but oxo bridges are strong enough not bebroken.CrystallineBaTiOscanbe obtained at rather low temperatures when a mixture of Ti(OiPr)4 and Ba(0iPr)z is heated under reflux before hydrolysis [19]. It was shown recently that heterometallic tetrameric species [BaTiO(OiPr)4,iPrOH]4arethen obtained in which Ti-O-Ba bonds are already formed in the solution [20].
MOLECULAR DESIGN OF TRANSITION METAL ALKOXIDE
9
W. CHEMICALMODIFICATIONOF TRANSITION METAL ALKOXIDES Most metal alkoxides are very reactive toward hydrolysis and condensation. They must be stabilized to avoid precipitation. The chemical control of these reactions is currently performed by adding complexing reagents that react with metal alkoxides at a molecular level, giving rise to new molecular precursors of different structure, reactivity, and functionality. Chemical modification is usually performed with hydroxylated nucleophilic ligands, such as carboxylic acids or P-diketones. In most cases complexation by XOH species can be described as a nucleophilic substitution, as follows: M(OR),
A.
+ xXOH +[M(OR),-AOX),I + xROH
CarboxylicAcids
Acetic acid (AcOH=CH3-COOH) is often used as an acid catalyst for the solgel synthesis of Si02. Adding a small amount of AcOH significantly decreases the gel time of silicon alkoxide systems. In similar conditions, this effect appears to be morepronouncedthan with inorganic acids, such as HCl [21]. However, the reverse effect is observed for Ti(OR)4. Adding acetic acid prevents precipitation and increases the gel time [22]. An exothermic reaction takes place when acetic acid is added to titanium alkoxide in a 1:l ratio. A clear solution is obtained. X-ray absorption experiments show that the coordination of titanium increases up to six(Fig. 4a), whereas two Ti-0 distances (1.80A and 2.06A) and Ti-Ti correlations (3.1 A) are observed on the ,Fourier transform of the EXAFS spectrum (Fig. 4b). Infrared spectroscopy can be used to study how acetate groups are bonded to tita-
(a)
Cb)
X-ray absorption at the Ti-K edge of pi(OiPr)3(OAc)]. (a) = XANES; (b) = EXAFS (Fourier transform).
WAGE
10
nium. The frequency shift between the two bands corresponding to the symmetric v, = 1450 cm" and antisymmetric v, = 1580 cm" stretching vibrations of the acetate group COO- is typical of bidentate bridging acetate groups (AV = 130 cm"). Acetate groups actually behave as complexing nucleophilic ligands and react with titanium alkoxides as follows: Ti(OiPr)4+ AcOH +[Ti(OiPr),(OAc)] + iPrOH During this stoichiometric reaction, the coordination number of Ti increases from four to six, and oligomeric species [Ti(OiPr)3(OAc)In ( n = 2 or 3 are formed (Fig. 5) Esterification occurs when more than 1 mol AcOH is added. Acetic acid in excess reacts with alcohol molecules released during complexation, providing the in situ generation ofwaterandgiving rise to more condensedspecies. Small oligomeric species are obtained in the presence of small amounts of water. Single crystals of hexameric Ti604(OiPr)~?(OAc)4,for instance, have been obtained upon aging an equimolar mixture of AcOH and Ti(OiPr)4 in a closed vessel (Fig. 6). Water, provided via esterification reactions arising from acetic acid in excess, leads to the slow hydrolysis of alkoxide groups, which are replaced by oxo bridges [23]. Most organic groups can be removed and clear transparent polymeric titanium dioxide gels are obtained in the presence of an excess of water. Upon hydroysis, alkoxy groups are removed first, whereas bidentate acetate ligands remain bonded to titanium. They prevent further condensation and increase the gelation time. The functionality of the new molecular precursor de-
5 Chemical modification = [Ti(OiPr)3(acac)].
titanium alkoxides. (a) = ri(OiPr)3
(b)
MOLECULAR DESIGN OF TRANSITION METAL ALKOXIDE
I1
0" OW Molecularstructure bridges (hatched circles).
of [Ti604(0iPT)12(OAc)4]:Ti(solidcircles);
creases, leading to the growth of anisotropic particles. TizO(0Ac)rj oxoacetates, made of chainlike polymeric species, are obtained when an excess of acetic acid is added
B.
P-Diketones
Strongly complexing P-diketones are currently employed to stabilize highly reactive metal alkoxides, such as W(OEt)6 Aluminum sec-butoxide, modified by ethylacetoacetate (etac), appears to be quite attractive as a precursor for the sol-gel synthesis of multicomponent ceramics, such as cordierite. Al(OsBu)z(etac) is more soluble and less reactive thanthe corresponding alkoxide Complexation is observed with acetylacetone (acacH=CH3-CO-CHzCO-CH3). Its enolic form contains hydroxyl groups and reacts with metal alkoxides as a chelating ligond. Oligomers are not readily formed, and for stoichiometric acacni = 1 ratio, the nucleophilic substitution leads to monomers in which Ti is only fivefold coordinated (Fig. 5b). Ti(OiPr)4+ acacH +Ti(OiP&(acac)
+ iPrOH
LWAGE Oligomeric compounds are formed only upon hydrolysis Titanium coordination becomes six as soon as water is added, whereas Ti-Ti correlations can be seen on the Fourier transform of the EXAFS spectrum. Strongly chelating acac ligands are not removed upon hydrolysis (except at low pH). Condensation is then prevented, and only small oligomers are formed [28].
V. MOLECULARENGINEERING OF METALALKOXIDE PRECURSORS Metal alkoxides react with nucleophilic complexing ligands. Two chemical parameters can then be used to design new molecular precursors. Metal alkoxides react with water molecules (hydrolysis) and nucleophilic species (complexation). The first reaction is followed by condensation and leads to the formation of larger oligomeric or polymeric species, whereas complexing ligands prevent condensation and favor the formation of smaller species. It therefore becomes possible to design sol-gel-derived materials by controlling the following two chemical parameters: the nature and amount of complexing additive XOH (x = X / M ) and the hydrolysis ratio (h = H20/M). large variety of oligomeric species can then be obtained upon hydrolysis and condensation. Molecular clusters, chain polymers, or colloidal particles can be synthesized, depending on the relative amount of hydrolysis and complexation. a general rule, more condensed species are obtained as x decreases and h increases.
A. HYDROLYSIS RATIO The hydrolysis and condensation of metal alkoxides M(OR)z leads to oligomers in which metal atoms tend to acquire their maximum coordination number. The formation of these species can be controlled by the hydrolysis ratio h = H20/M. In the presence of a large excess of water (h >> z). all alkoxide groups are removedand colloidal species are formed.Theylead to hydrous oxides MOzI2.xH20 similar to those synthesized from aqueous solutions. The adsorption and dissociation of water molecules at the oxide/water interface leads to the formation of charged particles. All alkoxide groups are not removed when h z and chain oxopolymers are formed. They can be advantageously employed for drawing fibers or making coatings. The dielectric constant of the organic solvent is rather low, the surface charge of polymeric particles is very small, and vander Waals interactions prevail. For very low hydrolyis ratios (h -c condensation is mainly governed by the formation of p o x 0 and alkoxo bridges. Solute molecular oxoalkoxides are then formed and can often be isolated as single crystals from the solution.
I3
MOLECULAR DESIGN OF T M S I T I O N METAL ALKOXIDE
Their structure appears tobe closely related to that of the corresponding polyanions formed in aqueous solutions. The first hydrolysis product ( h = 0.6) of titanium ethoxide, for instance Ti704(OEt)20, contains [Ti70241 units isostructural with MO7@& Larger species, such as Ti1008(0Et)24 ( h = 0.8) and Ti16016(OEt)32 (h = l), are formed when more water is added [30,31]. They have been obtained upon the controlled hydrolysis of Ti(OEt)4 and isolated as single crystals from the solution (Fig. 7). The molecular structure of these species in the solution has been studied by x-ray diffraction and 1 7 0 nuclear magnetic resonance using enriched water as a reagent [32]. Niobium ethoxide leads to Nb8010(OEt)20, which exhibits the same structure as the paratungstate [33]. In the presence of an organic base, NMwOH, a decamer, is obtained [Nblo028(NMe4)6*6H20], whichis isostructural with the decananadate polyanion (V10028)6- [34].
Complexation The chemical reactivity of metal alkoxides toward hydrolysis and condensation can be modified by complexation. Less electronegative alkoxide ligands are hydrolyzedpreferentially,whereasstronglybonded complexing groups are more difficult to removed. They prevent condensation, and gelation or precipitation rates decrease upon complexation. Complexing ligands behave as termination reagents. They cause the effective functionality toward condensation to be reduced, resulting in less condensed and more anisotropic polymeric species. Precipitation can then be avoided, and gelation is promoted.
b sis
7 Structure of somemolecularclustersobtained via thecontrolled hydrolyTi(OEt)4. (a) = [Ti704(0Et)20]; (b) = [Ti1008(OEt)24].
LNAGE The reaction of titanium alkoxides with acetylacetone leads to several molecular compounds.[TiO(acac)z]z is formed in the presence ofan excess of acetylacetone or upon hydrolysis of Ti(acac)2(OR)2. Single crystals have been isolated;andx-raydiffraction experiments show dimers with sixfold coordinated Ti atoms linked through oxygen atoms. Strongly complexing acac ligands cannot be hydrolyzed easily, and condensation does not go any further (Fig. 8) [35]. Lager molecular species can be obtained with smaller ainounts of acetylacetone. Single crystals of Tii8022(0Bu)26(acac)2were obtained recently [36]. They are made of 18 [Ti061 octahedra sharing edges or comers and correspond to x = 0.1. h = 1.2. Complexing acac ligands remain outside the Ti18022 core of the molecule (Fig. 9). These examples show that condensation can be tailored via complexation and hydrolysis. Gels are obtained in the presence of an excess of water and for small values of x (x I0.3, h 2 10). Clear sols are obtained when Ti(OnBu)4 is hydrolyzed in the presence of acetylacetone. The mean hydrodynamic diameter of colloidal particles was measured by quasi-elastic light scattering. It appears to increase from 2 to nm as the hydrolysis ratio increases from h = 1 to h = for x = 0.3). It decreases from to nm when the amount of acetylacetone increases from x = 0.3 to x = l (for h = [28]. Similar results have been found with zirconium alkoxides. Solvated dimeric species are formed when zirconium propoxide is dissolved in its parent alco-
OXO
Molecular of [TiO(acac)2]2 according to Ref. bridges (hatched); other atoms (C and 0) (open).
Ti (solid); p
-
MOLECULAR DESIGN OF TRANSITION METAL
Molecular structure
ALKOXIDE
15
[Ti18022(0Bu)26(acac)2](h = 1.2 and x =
hol. Tetameric Zr40(0nPr)1o(acac)4 species are obtained with acetylacetone (x = acacnr = 1) in the presence of a very small amount of water ( h = 0.2). They have been isolated as single crystals and their structure determined by x-ray diffraction (Fig. 10) [37]. Larger molecular clusters, such as [Zr1006(OH)4(0nPr)l8L6], with kallylacetoacetate, can be formed by decreasing x (x = 0.6) and increasing h (h = l) (Fig. l l ) [38]. Monodispersed zirconia powders have been prepared by Rinn and Schmidt [39] via the acid hydrolysis Zr(OiPr)4 in ethanol in the presence of hydroxypropylcellulose as a stabilizer avoid aggregation and acetylacetone as a complexing agent. Particles from about 200 to 10 nmin diameter were obtained depending on the relative amount each reagent. Dimericsolvated solute species [Cez(OiPr)s(iPrOH)z] are formed when cerium isopropoxide is dissolved in its parent alcohol. These solutions are very sensitive to moisture and can be stabilized with acetylacetone. Molecular clusters are formed when a small amount of water is added. Red crystals have been
LNAGE
16
Zr
(oxo bridge)
Molecularstructure
[Zr4PO(OPr)lo(acac)4]
=
and h =
grown from a solution in which x = acac/Ce = 2. They correspond to hexameric species [Ce604(0H)4(acac)l2] in which the oxohydroxo core (Fig. 12) is isostructuralwiththe inorganic analog [Ce604(OH)4(S04)6], whichwas observed in aqueous solutions of cerium sulfate [ 131. The hydrolysis of P-diketonate-modified cerium(IV) isopropoxide leads to the formation of colloidalsolutions or gels. The complexationratio (x = acac/Ce) appears to be the key parameter tailor the size of cerium oxide particles. Precipitation is observed when x 0.1, whereas sols are obtained when 0.1 < x 1. The mean hydrodynamicdiameter of these particles decreases from to 15 when x goes from 0.1 to 1. Only solute molecular clusters are formed when the complexing ratio becomes larger than 1 (1 Ix I2).
Organically modified silicates can be conveniently synthesized from precursors, such as R4Si(OR), which contain nonhydrolyzable Si-C bonds that organic moieties are not removed during the hydrolysis-condensation process. Organic groups R can behave as either network modifiers or network formers
MOLECULAR DESIGN
Zr
OF TRANSITION METAL
ALKOXIDE
17
0 (oxo & hydroxo bridges)
11 Molecular structure
[ZrloOs(OPr)ls(acac)6] (x = 1 and h = 0.8).
when polymerizable organic ligands are used. They allow the formation of an organic network in addition to the inorganic. The organic groups impart new properties to the organic network, such as flexibility, hydrophobicity, or refractive index The chemistry hybrid organic-inorganic gels is mainly developed around silicon-containing materials. Titanium and zirconium alkoxides are sometimes used as cross-linking reagents for the condensation of difunctional silicon precursors, such as [(CH3)2Si(OC2H5)2]. However, these alkoxides do not really behave as cross-linking agents. They lead to the formation of Poly Dimethyl Siloxane (PDMS)-Ti02 nanocomposites in which Ti02 nanoparticles are embedded in a PDMS matrix This certainty arises from the higher reactivity of these alkoxides and their well-known catalytic activity toward the condensation of siloxanes. Therefore, PDMS chains are formed on one side and Ti02 or ZrO2 nanoparticles on the other side. Si-O-Ti bonds have not yet been clearly evidenced. The catalytic role of titanium and zirconium alkoxides to-
18
LNAGE
12 Molecularstructure of [Ce604(OH)4(acac)l2].
ward the condensation of siloxanes is quite interesting for film formation. The presence of long chains in the film makes the material more flexible, allowing the deposition of crack-free transparent coatings several micrometers thick. Hybrid organic-inorganic compounds containing transition metal species were recently synthesized using organically modified polyoxometallates linked, together through W-O-Si-C bonds [42]. The organically modified precursor is obtained via thereaction of GSiW11039 witha trichlorosilane RSiCl3, R=vinyl (CH=CH2), allyl (CH2CH=CH2), or 3-methacryloxypropyl [-CH2(CH2)2OOCC(CH3)=CH2]. Each [SiW1104o(SiR)2]4- carries two binfuctional R groups, available for organic polymerization reactions performed in the presence of radical initiators. Organically modified transition metal oxide gels are difficult to synthesize. Transition metals have a lower electronegativity than silicon. The M-C bond becomes more polar and would be broken upon hydrolysis. Complexing hydroxylated organic ligands must then be used to form nonhydrolyzable M-0-C
MOLECULAR DESIGN OF TRANSITION METAL ALKOXIDE
19
bonds between the metal atom and the organic species. Complexation appears to be the only way to synthesize hybrid gels involving transition metal oxides. However, very few results have been reported so far in literature. According to the results reported previously, carboxylic acids R-COOH could be conveniently employed as complexing species. Prehydrolyzed titanium butoxide (H2013 = oligomers have been complexed with unsaturated organic acids, such as cinnamic acid(C6H5-CH=CH-COOH).Copolymerizationwasthenperformedwith styrene in the presence of benzoyl peroxide. Transparent brown polymers were thus obtained. They are very stable against water and cannot be dissolved in most organic solvents Acrylic or methacrylic acids can also be used as polymerizable complexing ligands They were recently reported for the sol-gel synthesis of zirconium oxides via the copolymerization of zirconium oxide sols and organic monomers Carboxylates are rather weak complexing ligands, however, and most of them are removed upon hydrolyis when an excess of water is added. Chelating P-diketones are stronger complexing ligands. Organically modified Ti02 gels, which exhibit photochromic properties, have been synthesized from an allyl acetylacetone-modified Ti(OnBu)4 alkoxide. A double polymerization process was initiated via the partial hydrolysis of alkoxy groups and the radical polymerization of allyl functions. The polymerization of the allyl function is slow, however, and organic polymerization is not very effective New approaches have been explored using functionalized chelates with both a strong chelating end and a highly reactive methacrylate group, such as aceto acetoxy ethyl methacrylate and methacryl amido salicylic acid (Fig. 13).
lor
HC
\
HC
I
0
13 Chelating ligands for the synthesis of Z r O 2 hybrid gels. (a) = Aceto acetoxy ethyl methacrylate (AAEM); (b) = methacyl amido salicylic acid (MASA).
LNAGE
Zirconium-oxopoly-polyAAEMcopolymers have been synthesized via the chemical modification of Zr(OnPr)4 precursors by M M . Both polymerization reactions were run simultaneously, leading to hybrid organic-inorganic polymers. The zirconium oxo core is made of oxoalkoxo AAEiM-modified species in which Zr is likely in a sevenfold coordination, as in monoclinic zirconia. Zirconium oxo species are chemically bonded to polymeric methacrylate chains via the P-diketo complexing groups The complexation ratio ( A A E W r ) seems to control the structure and texture of these hybrid gels, giving rise to more or less open structures. Organic and inorganic polymerization processes are presumably related, and such a hybrid material could be described as an interpenetrating polymer network (Fig. Both organic and inorganic polymerizations zirconium propoxide modified by methacryl amido salicylate were performed using similar procedures. This MASA ligand exhibits a stronger complexing power and a higher steric hindrance. Therefore, for equivalent complexation ratios (MASA substitutes two alkoxo groups), simultaneous polymerizations of methacryl amido salicylate-modified zirconium precursors lead to smaller zirconium oxopoly methacryl amido salicylate copolymers
14
organic-transitionmetaloxidenetwork.
MOLECULAR DESIGN OF TRANSITION METAL ALKOXIDE
21
Other routes could be used, such as the following: Copolymerizationbetweenhybridinorganic-organicsystems,zirconiumoxopoly-MM, andathirdorganicpolymerizablecomponent,suchas styrene. The complexation of zirconiumalkoxideswithligandscarryinganazobis group from which radical polymerization could be initiated Moreover,hybridorganic-inorganiccopolymerscouldbesynthesizedfrom many other metal oxide gels (rare earth, aluminum and others).
1. Brinker, C. J., and Scherer, G.W., Sol-Gel Science, Academic Press, New York, 1989. 2. Livage, J., Henry, M., and Sanchez, C. Prog. Solid Sate Chem., 259 (1988). 3. Klein, L., Annu. Rev. Muter. Sci., 15, 227 (1985). 4. Toledano, P., Ribot, F., and Sanchez, C., C.R. Acud. Sci. Fr., 311, 13 15 (1990). 5. Livage, J., Barboux, P., Vandenbore, M. T., Schmutz, C., and Taulelle,F., J. NonCryst. Solids 18 (1992). 6. Nabavi,M.,Sanchez,C.,andLivage, J., Eur. J. SolidStateInorg. Chem, 1173 (1991). 7. Bradley,D. C., Mehrotra, R. C.,andGaur,D.P. Metal Alkoxides, Academic Press,London,1978. 8. Babonneau, F., Doeuff, Leaustic, A., Sanchez, C., Cartier, C., and Verdaguer, M., Inorg. Chem., 3166 (1988). 9. Barringer, E. and Bowen, H. K., J. Am. Cerum. C-l99 (1982). 10. Barringer, E. Bowen, H. K., Langmuir, 1, 414 (1985). 11. Scozzafava, M. R., Rhine, W. E., and Cina, M. J., Better ceramics through chem697 (1990). istry, IV, Muter. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 12. Vaartstra, B. Huffman, J. C., Gradeff, P. Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L., Daran,J. C., Parraud, Yunlu, K., and Caulton, K. G.,Inorg. Chem., 3126 (1990). 1419 (1990). 13. Toledano, P., Ribot, F., and Sanchez, C., Acta Crystullogs, 14. Kundu D., and Ganguli, D., J. Muter. Sci. Lett., 5, 293 (1986). 969 (1990). 15. Caulton, K. G., and Hubert-Pfalzgraff, L., Chem. Rev., 16. Hegetschweiler, K., Schmalle, H. W., Streit, H. M., Gramlich, V., Hund, H. U., and Emi, I., Inorg. Chem., 1299 (1992). 17. Livage, J. and Sanchez, C., J. Non-Cryst. Solids 11 (1992). 18. Hubert-Pfalzgraf,L.,Papiemik, R., Massiani,M.C.,andSepte,B.,Betterceramics through chemistry, IV, Muter. Res. Symp. Proc., 393 (1990). Dolloff, R. T., and Smith, J. J. Am Cerum. Soc., 523 19. Mazdiyasni,K. (1969). 20. Yanovsky, I., Yanoskaya, M. I., Limar, V. K., Kessler, V. G., Turova, N. Y., and Struchkov, Y. T., J. Chem Chem. Cornmuc., 1605 (191). 21. Pope, E. J., and Mackenzie, J. D., J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 185 (1986). 22. Doeuff, Henry, M., Sanchez, C., and Livage, J., J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 206 (1987).
22
WAGE Doeuff,
Dromzee,Y.,Taulelle,
F., andSanchez,C.,
Znorg. Chem., 28,
Doeuff, Henry,M.,andSanchez,C., Muter. Res. Bull., 25, Unuma, H., Tokoka, T., Suzuki, Y., Furusaki, T., Kodiara, K., and Hatsushida, T., J. Mater. Sci. Lett., 5, Non-Cryst. Solids, 121, Babonneau,F.,Coury,L.,andLivage,J. Uaustic, A.,Babonneau,F.,andLivage,J., Chem. Mater., I , Uaustic, Babonneau, F., and Livage, J., Chem. Mater., I , Watenpaugh, K.,andCaughlan,C.N., Chem.Commun., Day, V. W., Eberslcher,Klemperer,W.G.,Park,C.W.,andRosenberg, F. Chemical Processing ofAdvunced Materials (L. L. Hench, and J. K. West, Wiley, New York, p. MossetA.,andGaly,J., C.R. Acad. Sci. Fr., 307, Day, V. W., Eberspacher, T. Klemperer, W. G., Park, C. W., and Rosenberg, F. J. Am. Chem. 113, Bradley, D. C., Hurthouse, M. B., and Rodesiler, P. F., J. Chem. Chem. Commun.,
Graeber, E. J. and Momson, B., Acta Crystallogr., B33, Smith,G.D.,Caughlan,C. N., andCampbell, J. Znorg. Chem., 11, Toledano,P., In, M.,andSanchez,C., C.R. Acad. Sci. Fr., 313, Toledano, P., In, M., and Sanchez, C., C.R. Acad. Sci. Fr., 31 1, Livage,J.Sanchez,C.,andToledano,P., Metaloxideclustersand colloids, Mater. Res. Symp. Proc., San Francisco 272, Rinn,G.,andSchmidt,H., CeramicTransactions (G.L.Messing,E.R.Fuller and H. Hausner, eds.), Am. Ceram. Soc., I, Schmidt,H., J. Non-Cryst.Solids, 73, Dir6, Babonneau, F., Sanchez, C., andLivage,J., J. Mater.Chem., 2, (
Judeinstein,P., Chem.Mater., 4, Suvorov,A.L.,andSpaski, Proc. Acad. Sci. USSR, 127, 44. Schubert, U., Arpac, E., Glaubitt, W., Helmerich, A., and Chau, C.,Chem. Mater., Nass, R., and Schmidt, H., Sol-Gel Optics, SPIE, 1328, Sanchez, C., Livage, J., Henry, M., and Babonneau, F., J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 100, Sanchez,C.,andIn,M.,
J. Non-Cryst. Solids 147-148,
2 Metal Alkoxides for Electrooptical Ceramics M a n e G. Hubert-Pfalzgtaf Universid de Nice-Sophia Antipolis Nice, France
INTRODUCTION Ceramics are one of the most recent classes of electrooptical materials. Table 1 summarizes the various compositions associated with transparent electrooptical ceramics [l]. These materials are mostly ferroelectric lead-containing titanates or niobates.Amongthe various types of precursors ofmetal oxides (e.g., carboxylates and nitrates), alkoxides have especially attractive features. These include high purity, the lability of the coordination sphere, which allows their tailoring according to specific applications, their easy transformation into oxides with formation of volatile by-products and their ability to form homogeneous solutions under a large variety of conditions, and, for multicomponent systems, via heterometallic alkoxides As a result of their versatility, they can meet the requirements for sol-gel as well as metal organic chemical vapor-phase deposition (MOCVD) applications This chapter deals with the synthesis and general properties of homo- and heterometallic &oxides that are or might be used in chemical routes to electrooptical ceramic materials. Some considerations concerning structure, reactivity, tailoring of their properties are also given. Emphasis is given to the most recent results.
II. HOMOMETALLICALKOXIDES For all elements involved in electrooptical ceramics, their homometallic alkoxides, of the general formula M(OR)n, or oxoalkoxides, MO(OR),, are either
on
24
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF
Table 1
Composition of ElectroopticalCeramics
Composition La)(Zr, (Pb, Ti103 PSN Ti103Nb)@ Pb(Sc, (Pb, La)(Hf, (Pb, Sr)(Zr, Ti)O3 (Pb, Ba, Sr)(Zr, Ti)@ (Pb, La, Li)(Zr, Ti)@ Ba, (Pb, Sn)(In, Zr, Ti)@ (Pb, M)(Zr, Ti)@; M = Bi, Sr (Pb, Bi)(Zr, Ti)03
PLZT M(Ta, Nb)03; M = Li, K PLHT Nb, Zr, Ti)@ PLMNZT PSZT (Pb, La)(Mg, PBSZT (Ba, BLTN Nb)@ La)(Ti, (Pb, PLLZT La)Nbz06 PBLN PSIZT (Pb, La)(Zn, Nb, Zr, Ti)@ PBLNZT PMZT (Sr. Ba)Nb206 SBN PBZT
commercially available or can readily prepared in high yield (strictly anhydrous conditions are required for theirhandling. Table 2 lists their general properties and main synthetic routes. '
A variety of synthetic pathways, depending on the starting material, are generally available for most elements. Their value can be quite different in terms of selectivity of the reaction and yield and purity of the resulting metal alkoxide. The most electropositive metals (alkaline, alkaline-earth metals, yttrium, and lanthanides) can be oxidized directly by alcohols. The rate of the reaction is largely dependent on the surface properties the metal and on the nature of the alcohol, especially its acidity and the bulkiness of the OR group. Thus the reaction proceeds easily with alkaline metals (Li, Na, and K), the primary alcohols being more reactive than the secondary or the tertiary. The same variation is observed for the alkaline-earth metals, the reaction being the least favored for magnesium In some cases, it might be necessary to catalyze the reaction by mercury or by gaseous ammonia. Ammonia was observed to be efficient toward barium when classic catalysts (Hg and 12) failed; it avoids contamination [49]. Activation of yttrium and lanthanides by trace amounts of mercury(I1) salts (chloride or acetate) is generally required, although sonochemistry can be a way to activate the metals in the absence of mercury derivatives [50]. Nonotable reaction is observed between yttrium and lanthanides and methanol, ethanol, or t-butanol, but the reaction proceeds well with isopropanol and functional alcohols, such as 2-methoxyethanol [51,52]. Synthesis of metal alkoxides directly from the metal can lead to degradation reactions either of the solvent (tetrahydrofuran, THF, for instance [ 181) or of the reactant 1131; they appear especially easy with barium. Alcoholysis reactions applied to alkoxides (alcohol interchange reactions) or to metal silylamides generally make it possible to overcome these limitations.
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
25
These reactions are generally achieved in the presence of an excess of alcohol, and thus the alkoxides might be obtained-in solution as solvates
[m.
M+ROHexcess+
M(OR)n(ROH)x+;H2
The lability of the alcohol molecules and thus the stability of the solvates is quite variable. Such formulas as Ba(OR)2 or M(OR)3 (M = In, Y, Ln) have been traditionally used to describe alkoxides of these electropositive elements. Many of these alkoxides have now been more precisely defined by x-ray diffraction studies, which have revealed quite different formulas. In fact, the removal of the alcohol molecules (under vacuum) often leads to oxoalkoxides. Pentanuclear oxo or hydroxo units seem to be a common feature for tri- and divalent metals and are illustrated by MsO(OiPr)13 (M= In, Sc; Ln = Y, Yb, . , .) and Bas(OH)(OR)s adducts [R = Ph, 3,5-tBuzCtjH3, CH(CF3)2], and even P-diketonates [53]. It is thus important to emphasize that the formulation, the properties, and the reactivity of metal alkoxides based on large elements may be different according to their “history”-used in situ or isolated [50]. Substitution reactions are another general approach to metal alkoxides, according to Eq. (2):
MG,
+ nROH +M(OR),(ROH), + nGH
(2)
G = NR2, R, H, Cl, . . . . These substitution reactions are especially attractive for obtaining a pure product when the by-product is volatile and thus the anionic ligand G, an amide group NR2, an alkyl group R, or a hydride H. Alcoholysis reactions of trimethylsilylamino derivatives M[N(SiMe3)2In are quite a versatile route to a variety of metal alkoxides, although they require the prior synthesis of the metal silylamide derivatives (commercially available only for Li and Na). This procedure is particularly attractive for metals whose alkoxides are poorly soluble, such as lead, zinc, or iron isopropoxides, since contamination with halide or alkali residues can be overcome. It also allows a large choice of R groups, and lanthanide tertiobutoxide derivatives, for instance, become accessible [39]. The use of appropriate (bulky or functional) alkoxide or aryloxide groups has also opened a way to soluble and/or volatile lead(II) and zinc derivatives [23,29]. Reactions according to Eq. (3) are generally extremely fast and may favor the formation of oxo derivatives, as observed for bismuth [U. N(SiMe3)2],
+ nROH+
M(OR),
+ nHN(SiMe3)2
(3)
Alcoholysis of metal alkyl derivatives is based on the elimination of a volatile by-product as well:
MR, + nR‘OH +M(OR’),
+ nRH
a g B
B B
B
Bm
e ....
% 8 .-
2M m
m
2m 0
8
z.. 3
x
2
.-9
c 8
28
e
d
d
- 0 -
"'-
B
29
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF
It is of practical use for metals whose alkyl derivatives commercially easily available, namely, lithium and magnesium. Metal hydrides can be used as starting material mainly for alkali and alkaline-earth metals. AlthoughZn(0R)z alkoxides derived from classic OR groups are insoluble soluble tetranuclear zinc alkyl or hydridoalkoxides [ZnX(OR’)]4 (X= R or H) can be obtained starting from zinc alkyls or hydride [30,31]. Finally, other general routes involve halides, mostly chlorides, as starting materials, according to Eq. (5):
M = alkaline metals. Substitution by alcohols in the presence of a base is the most general route to early transition metal alkoxides, especially for groups IV (Ti, Zr, and Hf) and V (Nb and Ta), and they are commercially available, at least for some R groups. Less labile halides (lead, bismuth, or lanthanide chlorides) require the use of alkali metal alkoxides to achieve substitution. Even the reaction may proceed with a poor yield and/or offer final products containing halide or alkali metals, the latter being present either as an impurity or as part of a definite product (heterometallic species). When halides are used as a starting material for metal alkoxides, contamination by chlorides can also result from a limited purification: variable amounts of Cl or Na are often found in commercial titanium isopropoxide Ti(OiPr)4. Substitution reactions applied to acetates generally result in a poor selectivity and thus a low purity of the metal alkoxides; their interest is thus limited despite the low cost of the‘acetates. Reactions between hydrated acetates and refluxing 2-methoxyethanol have been used as a way to obtain acetatoalkoxides in sol-gel processing, but most products are poorly characterized. Electrosynthesis by anodic dissolution ofthe metal in absolute alcohol appears for many elements to be a promising, inexpensive way to obtain large amounts of metal alkoxides [54]. The process goes smoothly and has good current yields Zr, for metals, such as scandium and lanthanides, and early transition metals (Ti, and Nb) using tetrabutylammonium bromide as an electrolyte. Oxo or hydroxo compounds are obtained for more electropositive metals (Mg and alkaline-earth metals), however, probably as a result of alcohol dehydration reactions. Finally, alcohol exchange reactions are a means of obtaining more appropriate precursor, starting from commercial or easily accessible metal alkoxides (see Sec. KC).
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
B.
31
PhysicalProperties and StructuralAspects
Most of the metal alkoxides of interest for electrooptical ceramics are solids (less often liquids) that can be purified by recrystallization, sublimation, or distillation. They are all moisture sensitive, and handling under an inert atmosphere and with anhydrous solvents is thus required. Their unequivocal characterization and formulation are best achieved by x-ray diffraction studies (on monocrystals). Studies on solutions (molecular weight data, nuclear magnetic resonance, NMR, with ‘H, 13C, or metal nuclei) are a means either to establish whether the solid-state structure is retained or, in the absence of x-ray data, to establish the molecular structure and eventually stereolability [48]. Mass spectrometry provides information on the stability of the oligomers or the heterometallic species in the vapor phase. The information gainedby infrared spectroscopy is limited; the technique is mostly useful for the identification of solvates M(OR)n(ROH)x (vOH absorption 3400-3100 cm-1 or of chemically modified (heteroleptic) alkoxides (probe for the vC0 stretching of P-diketonate or carboxylate ligands, for instance). The solubility and volatility of homoleptic alkoxides are mainly determined by the degree of oligomerization m,which depends on the nature of the metal (size and thus coordination number) and on the steric demand of theOR group. Methoxides are thus the least favorable. With the exception of magnesium, lead, and zinc and dn transition metals, isopropoxides are reasonably soluble for all metals of interest for electrooptical ceramics. The insolubility of the first can be overcome by addition of another metal alkoxide (see Sec. 111) or by using a more bulky ligand, such as aryloxide (2.6-di-tert-butylphenoxide)or triphenylsiloxide PhsSiO, or functional alcohols (for instance, OHC2H& with X = OR’ for alcoxyalcohols or X = NR’2 for alkanolamines), which provide intramolecular donor sites [52].Although the aryloxide or triphenylsiloxide group; generally lead to soluble species (often monomeric with a low coordination number for the metal), they might be of limited interest as a result of a low ceramic yield and high organic content of the resulting oxides. Fluorinated OR groups lead to an increase in volatility, reduce the tendency to hydrolysis, and favor the formation of adducts [19]. The bulky tert-heptyloxide groups (R = CMeEtiPr) generally represent a good means of achieving volatility [5]. The metals involved in the composition of electrooptical ceramics are large, oxophilic, and electropositive. High coordination numbers are thus generally required. Recent years have seen, as a result of x-ray studies, the reformulation of many alkoxides based on di-or trivalent large elements as oxo- or hydroxoalkoxides. It is wellknownthat M(OR)n alkoxides are often oligomersdimers, trimers, or tetramers-as a result of the OR group acting as a doublebridging (p2) or triple-bridging ligand (p3), which allows the metal to attain its usual coordination number. Oxo 02- or hydroxo OH- ligands are even more
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF versatile and can behave as p2 or ligands but can also accommodate four, five, or even six metals. As a result, oxo or hydroxo ligands appear to be a means of achieving the high coordination numbers required by the large di- or trivalent element in the absence of neutral ligands. Barium seems to be especially prone to formation of oxo or hydroxo derivatives, and this observation appears in the earlier literature as a tendency to give carbon-deficient or unstable metal alkoxides. The size effect of the mental is illustrated by comparison of Sr and Ba phenoxides: the strontium derivative is a tetranuclear nonoxo unit in which the metal is pseudooctahedral [16]; the barium derivative is a pentanuclear oxo or hydroxo aggregate, which allows Ba, which is larger than Sr, to be sevencoordinate for the basal metal atoms [ 181. Polydentate alcohols, such as triethanolamine, can encapsulate the metal and drastically improve the stability toward hydrolysis [14]. Figure 1 summarizes the basic [M(OR)& oligomers, as well as the oxo or hydroxo aggregates that are observed. Dimeric units (Fig. 1A) are illustrated by [M(OR)5]2 (M= Nb, Ta) or [M(OiPr)4(iPrOHh (M = Zr, Hf); [Pb(OtBu)2]3 and La3(OtBu)gL2 are typical examples of openand closed trinuclearunits (Fig. 1B and C), respectively; tetramers display a [Ti(OMe)4]4 type of structure (Fig. 1D); (also found for divalent or trivalent metals but with additional neutral ligands as for [Nd(OiPr)3(iPrOH)]4or Sr4(0Ph)8(PhOH)z(THF)6) or a cubanelike, (Fig. 1E) as for [K(OtBu)]4 or [ZnR(OR')]4 [S]. The structurally characterized penta- and hexanuclear aggregates are all oxo or hydroxo clusters.M4(p&o)o6 cores (Fig. 1F) havingan adamantanelike structure are found for lead and barium alkoxides. The M5(pS-o)Oy (Fig. 1G) core seems to display a special stability for large di- or trivalent metals. Hexanuclear aggregates derive from the pentanuclear by the addition of a sixth
Basicaggregates for M(OR),lm alkoxides or oxoalkoxides.
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
X = OR,R
E
G OR
OR
I
H
6R
Continued
metal (Fig. 1 H ) or by condensation of adamantane units. Oxo or hydroxo aggregates are mostly highly soluble despite their nuclearity-the OR groups ensure a lipophilic layer-and they are also sometimes volatile. NMR and mass spectrometry data have shown that these aggregates are generally retained in solution as well as in the gas phase. They result from C-0 bond cleavage reactions (with formation of alkenes) andor oxidation reactions (especially for
HUBERT-PFMZGRAF OR'
bridging-chelating
bridging P2 -
P2 - ? l 2
M
triply-bridging P3 -y'
triply- bridging P3
terminal
-q2 2
Coordination modes
2-methoxyethanol.
alkaline-earth metals) and are present before hydrolysis; in some cases pb(II)], further condensation is observed by recrystallization, especially when dialkyl ethers or siloxanes are easily formed [24,25]. 2-Methoxyethanol displays numerous coordination modes (Fig. 2) but is basically a bidentate and assembling ligand; [M(OC2H40Me)n]malkoxides are thus large oligomers (m= 9, M = Ca; m = 10, M = Y), sometimes infinite polymers [M = Bi, Pb(II)]. Despite the large values of the nuclearity, however, they are soluble (with the exception of lead) because of cyclic (M = Y) or compact structures (M = Ca) or dissociation of the polymer in solution, as observed for Bi [32]. Aryloxides are, with the exception of barium, either monomers or dimers [30,38]. Alkoxide ligands OR and to a lesser extent trialkylsiloxo R3SiO and aryloxo OAr are n donors [3]. l 7 donation is especially favored for do elements (Ti, I%,. Ta, and lanthanides). Asthe OR ligand undergoes oxygen p to metal d n'bonding, the M-0 distances can become very short for terminal OR groups (4 covalent radii); the M-0-C angles open up to nearly linear M-0-C units. The n bonding as well as the thermal stability of the M-0-C bond decreases with the metal oxidation state and by moving to the late transition metals and is illustrated by more acute M-0-C angles.
C. Chemical Modifications In addition to using bulky OR groups, reduction of the molecular complexity can also be achieved by a polar solvent. Since formation of complexes is quite
35
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
limited for metal alkoxides because of their preferred autoassociation, giving oligomers [48], one of the few appropriate ligand or polar solvents is an alcohol (6)]. This is illustrated by the fact that many metal alkoxides are obtained as solvates (the M-OHR interaction is often stabilized byH bonding with an adjacent OR group): the group IV isopropoxides (M(OiPr)4(ihOH)]z (M = Zr, Hf) are typical examples [42]. It should also be noted that since the structure may be different according to the solvent [niobium alkoxides (R = Me, Et) are dimers in toluene but are monomeric Nb(OR)s(ROH) adducts in the parent alcohol] [48], the reactivity can be modified, especially toward other metal derivatives (Fig. 3). 1 -[M(0R),lm m
+ xROH
1
[M(OR),(ROH),,],
m’ m
(6)
The electronegative alkoxo or aryloxo groups make the metal atoms highly prone to nucleophilic attack. The alkoxides easily react with the protons of a large variety of organic hydroxy compounds, such as alcohols, silanols, glycols, carboxylic acids, P-diketones (Fig. 3). These exchange reactions convert homoleptic M(OR), into heteroleptic alkoxides M(OR),-XZ, and thus reduce the functionality of the precursor (2= OR). They also illustrate the use of alkoxides as versatile starting materials and as precursors whose coordination sphere can be easily modulated for specific applications. Such modifications of the coordination sphere of the initial alkoxide are often achieved by the use of the so-called additives, which are in fact chemical modifiers [3,55a]. 1. Alcoholysis Alcoholysis reactions are generally performed to “tailor” the volatility or the rheology, to decrease the hydrolysis rates, or, finally, to increase the solubility of the metal alkoxides. As a synthetic route, alcoholysis reactions with classic alcohols are usually achieved n refluxing cyclohexane, the reactions being promoted by azeotropic distillation of the alcohol [2]. In contrast with silicon alkoxides, however, alcohol interchange reactions proceed to some extent (depending onthe OR group and on the stoichiometry) at room temperature for most elements [S]. This has been shown, for instance, by metal N M R on niobium and titanium alkoxides. “Uncontrolled” alcohol interchange reactions may thus occur when a metal alkoxide is used in an alcohol different from the parent alcohol. Such reactions lead to a modification (decrease) of the apparent functionality of the precursors, which in turn can affect the properties (morphology, porosity, and so on) of the resulting oxide. Functional alcohols, such as alcoxyalcohols-mainly 2-methoxyethanol-or alkanolamines (diethanolamine and triethanolamine), are actuallythemost commonly used to slow hydrolysis rates and thus to “stabilize” metal alkoxides. Although such exchange reactions occur at room temperature, Some heat-
36
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF
U
0
1 0
0
%
p:
0
:C:
0 E
ea
::
0 v ea
U
/-\
U E
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
37
ing may be necessary for completion of the reaction, especially if stoichiometric amounts of reactants are used. Thus the reaction between zirconium isopropoxide [Zr(OiPr)4(iPrOH)]2 and four equivalents of 2-methoxyethanol leads to Zr(OCZH40Me)3(0iPr) a room temperature. The presence offunctional alkoxo groups around the metals generally results in an increase in its coordination number, and thus hydrolysis becomes more difficult [57]. Alcoholysis reactions using 2-methoxyethanol generally also offer more soluble products [52]. already mentioned,this observation is no longer valid for lead(I1) since the methoxyethoxide derivative; are polymeric and insoluble [23]. The reactivity of a variety of glycols (CH&(OH)2 toward titanium alkoxides, zirconium isopropoxide, and niobium and tantalum ethoxides has been studied by Bradley et al.[2]. Complete substitution generally resultsinpoorly soluble products; such derivatives asM(OR),~X[O(CH~)~O]~ generally remain soluble and sometimes volatile. Further reactivity, for instance with acetylacetone, has established that the Ti-OR bond is more labile than the Ti-glycolate bond. a way of improving solubilTrialkylsilanols R3SiOH (R = Me, Et) are ity and controlling hydrolysis [58]; however, they have rarely beenused, probably as a result of their limited stability and thus commercial availability. 2. Reactions with Carboxylic Acid and P-Diketones Substitutionreactionswith carboxylic acids, such as acetic acid, or with Pdiketones, mainly acetylacetone,are other means of controlling hydrolysis rates by decreasing the functionality of the precursor. Carboxylic acids RCO2H are often added to the sol-gel system as an acid catalyst [59,60]. In fact, they are not merely a source of H+, but a chemical modifier, and carboxylate groups substitute for the OR groups. Although P-diketonate and acetate ligands both generally lead to an increase in the metal coordination number, their behavior is quite different. Carboxylates act as assembling and oxo donor ligands, and thus have a tendency to increase the nuclearity of the aggregates; diketones are chelating ligands and thus decrease the oligomerization. This behavior is well illustrated by the modification of titanium alkoxides.Reactionbetween [Ti(OEt)& and acetylacetone gives monomeric and dimeric species (according tox-ray absorption near-edge structurestudies[61], and condensation into hexanuclear oxo clusters is observed when acetic acid is used (x-ray structures of Ti6(~2-o)2(C13-o)2(oR)8(oAC)8 (R = Et. iPr, nBu) [46]. 3. Hydrolysis Hydrolysis reactions of alkoxides proceed by nucleophilic attack of the metal (7)], and polymerization occurs via the reactive hydroxoalkoxides (7b) and (7c)l. Hydrolysis-polycondensationreactions are governed by numerfactors (Table 3). The metals involved in the composition of electrooptical ceramics are electropositive and oxophilic, and thus the hydrolysis of their ho-
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF
38
Table HydrolysisParameters of Homo-andHeteroleptic Alkoxides Electronegativity of the metal and polarity of the M-0-Cbond Nature alkoxo groupR Modifies the molecular complexity Rate increases with chain lengthening Sensitive to hydrolysis TertiaryR > secondaryRprimaryR OR > OSiR3 pH (acid or basic catalysis) Solvent and dilution Temperature Degree hydrolysis h (h = [HzO]/M(OR)n) h < n: fibers, chains, coatings h 1: molecular clusters h > n: gels, tridimensional polymers Modified precursors M(OR)n-xZx(Z= OH, OAc, B-dik,...) Rate decreases with Functionality of the precursor (number the OR groups) Increase in metal coordination number Hydrolytic susceptibility OR > OAc > B-dik
moleptic alkoxides is often extremely facile and much easier than for silicon. Introduction of other ligands 2 slows hydrolysis rates and promotes anisotropic growth. M(OR),
+ H20
-
H\
0 - hf(OR),.1 H- --OR
2M(OH)(OR),-1+ (OR),-$4M(OH)(OR),-I + M(OR),*
/
> M(OH)(OR),-l(7a)
0 -M(OR),-1 + H20 (OR)n-lM- 0 “M(OR),-1 + ROH
(7b) (7C)
The early stages of the hydrolysis-condensationof [M(OR),Im can be characterized byx-ray diffraction for oxophilic metals (Table These include centrosymmetric polynuclear oxoalkoxides of titanium, zirconium, andniobium. Their structure is often related to that of polyoxoanions: Ti704(OEt)20 is isostructural with Mo70246, and Nbg010(OEt)20 has a cagelike Structure that compares well with that of the paratungstate H~W120421G.These oxoalkoxides are soluble as a result of their closo structure, and 1 7 0 NMR has been developed a technique to follow the hydrolysis of titanium(1V) alkoxides with
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF H217O. Since enrichment in 1 7 0 occurs selectively at their oxide (as opposed to alkoxide) oxygen sites, the different types of oxo ligands n= can be determined, the most encapsulated oxo ligands being the most shielded [63]. Similar types of molecular oxo clusters are observed for alkoxides modified by acetylacetone [65a,66]. Although the early stages of the hydrolysis-polycondensation are extremely rapid, removal ofall alkoxide ligands at room temperature generally requires quite a large excess of water [57]. Hydrolysis studies have also been performed on several lead(1I) alkoxides: Pb(OR)2 (R= CMefit, CHMeCH2NMe2) in THF [23]. The hydrate 3PbOeH20 was obtained at low temperature as the kinetic product; its conversion to massicot and then to litharge is catalyzed by an increase in the pH (which may be caused by alkali metal alkoxide residues). Since 3PbOeH20 is less stable than massicot and litharge, it could act as a more reactive component in ceramic oxide preparations.
D. Thermal Decomposition Thermolysis reactions have mostly been studied for group IV metal alkoxides, although metal oxide depositshavebeen obtained for many metals [5]. Oxoalkoxides are often formed asintermediates,but mechanistic studiesremain scarce [68]. The decomposition can be enhanced by hydrolysis as a result of either residual water on the surface or dehydration reactions of tertiary alcohols.
HETEROMETALLIC ALKOXIDES Another aspect of the lability of the metal alkoxide bond is the easy formation of heterometallic or mixed-metal species [4]. Such compounds have also been called “double alkoxides” in comparison with double salts; however, their description as heterometallic is more appropriate in view of their covalent character and the existence of species having three different metals. The formation of heterometallics is a means of overcoming the poor solubility of polymeric metal alkoxides (Zn and Pb), of achieving homogeneity at a molecular level for multicomponent systems, and of providing a better homogeneity of the final material. If they display a convenient volatility and stability, they can also be used as “single-source” precursors (in which the different elements are incorporated in a single molecule) for MOCVD applications and thus improve the transport of poorly volatile elements and reduce possible interdiffusion phenomena [5]. Table 5 collects the heterometallic alkoxides, associating elements present in the formulation of electrooptical ceramics, although the stoichiometry may be quite different from those required for materials.
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
41
Heterometallic alkoxides are generally obtained either by reactionbetween Lewis acids and bases or by condensation with elimination of volatile or insoluble by-products. 1. Lewis Acid-Base Reactions Formation of heterometallic alkoxides by simple mixing, often at room temperature and in nonpolar solvents, is one of the most general routes and corresponds to the "complexation" step in the sol-gel process. This general reaction [Eq. (8)] appliestonearlyallalkoxides,withthe exception thesilicon Si(OR)4:
yM'(0R')nI
+ M(0R)n +MM'y(OR)n(OR)nty
(8)
Determination of the stoichiometry of the reaction is best achieved if it is conducted in a solvent in which one of the reactants is poorly soluble. Since the heterometallic species is more soluble than the parent alkoxide, the progressive dissolution of the most insoluble species allows control of the stoichiometry between the two different metals. Metal N M R (7Li and 93Nb) may also be used as tool to follow the reaction, as shown for LiNb(OR)6 [91]. The following reactions, which all proceed at room temperature, are examples of this approach: L[Mg(OiPr)2], m M(OR)~ + "(OR)
+ 2Nb(OiPr)5 +MgNb2(OiPr)l2 250c > "'(OR)6
(9) (10)
M = Nb, Ta; M' = Li, Na, K, . . . Alkali metal alkoxides are often involved in the preparation of metal alkoxides [Eq.51; heterometallic alkoxides can thus be a side product if the stoichiometry of the reaction is poorly controlled ( o n ) . For electropositive metals, such barium, the alkoxide might be generated in situ: 2Ba + [Zr(OiPr)4(iPrOH)]2 dBa2Zr2(pOR)2(OR)18+ H2
(11)
Systematic studies the influence of the R group and the solvents on the stoichiometry of such reactions as Eq. (8) remain limited, although the Turova group has studied ternary-phase diagrams [M(OR)n, M'(OR)n, and solvent] and proposed compositions for many systems. The Ba-Ti system is one of the best characterized and has shown dependence on the R group (oxo compound with R = zW,nonoxo compound for R = Et) as well as on the stoichiometry of the reactants:
4
.. E
2
B C
z .^
e,
m C
%
52%
F? E
44
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF
[BaTi2(OEt)g(EtOH)4][H(OEt)2] +
+
Addition reactions similar to h.(8) can also be observed between anhydrous acetates and alkoxides. Such reactions can even occur at room temperature, but they may require heating (depending on the lability of the metal acetate bond) and/or be less selective and give redistribution products Fomometallic acetatoalkoxides, M(OR)n-dOAc)x] as well. Mg(0Ac)z + 2Nb(OiPr)s 250c > MgNb2(OAc)2(OiPr)lo
(14)
Although metal b-diketonates can be solubilized in the presence of a metal alkoxide and thus form heterometallic species, at least-as intermediates, most reactions are more in favor of the formation of redistribution products [M(OR)n-x(P-dik)x]as the final result [92]. 2. Elimination of Volatiles The formation of heterometallic alkoxides is sometimes driven by that of a volatile by-product, mainly a dialkyl ether. Typical examples are obtaining the oxoalkoxides Ba4Ti404(0iPr)16(iProH)~ and Pb6Nb404(0Et)24:
When acetates are involved, esters can be the volatile by-product and thus favor the formation of the mixed-metal species; approach can overcome the noncommercial availability of some alkoxides [89]: 3Pb(OAc).y3H20 + Zn(OAc)z.2HzO
> P~Zn~(OAc)4(0Cz&OMe)4 +
As a general observation, it is important to note that reaction between alkoxides and other metal derivatives, such as acetates, can be strongly dependent on the solvent and/or the addition order of the reactants [84]. Thus, no reaction is observed between anhydrous Pb(OAc)2 andNb(0Et)s in THF at room temperature, but the acetate dissolves readilyin toluene at room temperature in the presence of the niobium alkoxide with formation of a Pb-Nb species [go]. Another general feature is that in heterometallic acetatoalkoxides obtained by route, the metalintroduced as an alkoxideappearspredominant. More condensed species are obtained if the reaction is achieved at higher temperatures [93]: Pb(0Ac)z + [Zr(OiPr)4(iPrOH)]z 250c> PbZr3(~O)(~OAc)z(~OipT)5(OiPr)~ + '
(18 )
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
45
In some cases, the stoichiometry between the two metals M and M' in the isolated species is different from that of the reaction medium, suggesting that other metal species are present [Eq. (12)].
3. Elimination of an Insoluble By-product Such reactions are generally based on the elimination of an alkali salt according to (19): MCl,
+ M"M',(OR),
+ nM'C1
"+MIM'y(OR)y]n
(19)
M"= Li, Na, K, TI(I)3 Although they allow control
of the stoichiometry between the M and M', metals, they have not been much developed so far for species-associating metals involved in electrooptical ceramics. They are mostly limited totheuse of the complex alkoxide anionZrz(OiPr)s-,andLa-Zr species were recently built up by this route [87]. In contrast with the preceding synthetic routes based on mixing simple compounds, (19) implies the prior synthesis of a heterometallic alkoxide based on an alkali metal and further removal of the salt.
Mixed-metal alkoxides are generally covalent [4]. As a result, they are soluble in organic nonpolar solvents (often less in alcohols), generally more than the parent alkoxides. Some can besublimed without disproportionation, the volatility following the same variation as for the homometallic alkoxides (OtBu > OzR > OEt > OMe).Mass spectrometry, for instance, established thatheterometallic LiNb fragments were retained in the gas phase for LiNb(OEt)6. Their structure is mainly determined by the overall nuclearity of the aggregate (MxMy and derives from the basic structural moiety in which the different metals display the usual coordination numbers expected for the bulk of the OR [4]. Numerous mixed-metal homoleptic alkoxides for which the stoichiometry betweenthetwo metals is 1: 1 have a structurethat derives from that of [Ti(OMe)4]4 (Fig. 1D). &iNb(OEt)6], is an infinite polymer; this explains its poorsolubility,but it is favorable for obtaining fibers [70]. Trinuclear mixed-metal species generally display a triangular Mkf2(p3-OR)2(p-OR)3core (type Fig. IC), the coordination sphere eventually being completed by neutral ligand L as for SrTi2(0iPr)s(iPrOH)3. Association such triangular units via bridging OR groups or via incommon apex gives such compounds as [BaZr2(p-OR)4(OR)4]2(Fig. 4J) or a 1:4 stoichiometry, such as BaZr4(OR)i8' (type Fig. 4K), respectively [81]. Thestructure of the Pb-Nb oxoalkoxide, Pb6Nb404(OEt)24, derives from that of the lead, with the oxo ligands acting as donors toward Nb(OEt)5 moities (Fig. 4L), which in turn increase the lead coordination number by three double-bridged OR groups. Similarly,
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF
Ba4Ti404(0iPr)ia(iP1OH)~ (Fig. 4M) can be considered a Ba4(~-0)4tetrahedron with groups bearing Ti(OR), moeities. MgNb2(p-OAc)2(p-OiPr)4(0iPr)6 corresponds to an open polyhedron of the type shown in Fig. IB, the acetate ligands connecting the central Mg atom to the neighboring Nb ones. The presence of chelating or assembling ligands may modify the basic arrangement between the different metals, however.
Reactivity Data on the reactivity of mixed metal alkoxides are limited. Their reactivity remains dominated by the lability of the metal alkoxo bond, but a problem that needs to be addressed is that of the maintaining or not of the heterometallic unit, of the stoichiometry between the different metals, and finally of the ho-
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
47
mogeneity, at a molecular level when they are reacting. Dissociation into the parent alkoxides upon dissolution of the heterometallic species can be a spontaneous process, even in a nonpolar solvent,andoccurs, for instance, for Pb604(OEt)e[Nb(oEt)s]4, asshown by207Pb NMR [79].Suchdissociation phenomena can be promoted by a polar solvent (alcohol or depending on the nature of the metals, and thus the choice of the solvent becomes even more important than for homometallic alkoxides Common modifiers usedinthesol-gel process are functionalalcohols, acetic acid, and acetylacetone. Alcoholysis reactions are the most documented; KiNb(OEt)6Imfor instance, was converted to LiNb(OC2H40Me)rj in the presence of 2-methoxyethanol [91]. Assembling ligands, such as 2-methoxyethanol or acetic acid, seem more favorable than P-diketones for the stabilization of mixed-metal alkoxides. However, the poorly controlled addition of an additive may sometimes modify the mixed-metal species by “extracting,” at least partially, one metal as an insoluble product or as a complex. Information on the hydrolysis mixed-metal alkoxides is even scarcer than for the homometallic, Partial hydrolysis of [LiNb(OEt)6lo0leads to the dimeric heterometallic alkoxide [LiNbO(OEt)4(EtOH)]2, in whichboth the stoichiometry between the two metals and their coordination numbers are retained [93]. On the other hand, the partial hydrolysis of solutions of methoxyethoxides of Ba and Ti (1:l molar ratio) offers BwTi13018(OC2H40Me)24 (30% yield). Its structure corresponds to a tetrahedron ofBaO3unitssurimposedon a TiOs(Ti03)n core; this Ti13042 core is related to that of the aluminum salt [Al1304(0H)24(H20)]7+ [83].The important modification of the stoichiometry between the two metals illustrates the complexity the sol-gel chemistry of multimetallic systems and shows that important structural rearrangements can occur.
IV. APPLICATION TO CERAMICS
Sol-Gel Process PLZT and PNM are, with L i m o s and LiTaOs, the systems related to electrooptical ceramics that have been the most studied.Chemical low-temperature routes are particularly attractive for lead-containing materials, since lead oxide is quite volatile in comparison with other metal oxides; thus control the stoichiometry of lead-based materials is tedious. To overcome the difficulty inhandling alkoxides and their availability, commonly accessible salts, such as carboxylates (acetates or the more soluble ethylhexanoates), carbonates, nitrates, or hydroxides, have often been used in conjunction with metal alkoxides (mostly n-propoxides or n-butoxides for Ti and and ethoxides for Nb or Ta), the solvent being an alcohol. The poor re-
HUBERT-PFUGRAF activity of barium acetate is overcome by adding acetic acid [46a] or by using carbonate or, more often, barium hydroxide Ba(OH)~8Hz0[94]. Commercial ionic precursors are often available as hydrates, and this must betaken into account when speculation about the intermediates that may form is proposed. Carboxylate groups (acetates or 2-ethylhexanoates) are generally removed only at relatively high temperatures (400°C); they appear to favor porous materials and grain boundaries [95]. Additives for hydrolysis are either acids (0.1-0.2 M m03 or acetic acid) or ammonia solutions. Although leadoxide has also been used [96], acetate hydrates are the precursors most often used for the introduction of lead or lanthanum in the multimetallic systems required for PLZT materials,and they are often associated with the useof 2-methoxyethanol [97-991. This solvent appears as a way to achieve deshydratation by refluxing (boiling point 124"C), as well as condensation (elimination of organic esters as has been shown by infrared (vCOZ = 1730 cm-1) [loo]. Studies on the influence of the precursor remain limited. X-ray absorption fine structure analysis of the sol and gel precursors of PZT (lead acetate in methanol, n-propoxides of Zr and Ti, and acetic acid) have shown that an uniform composition exists in both states on a microscopic level with Ti-O-Z linkages [100a]. The choice of the titanium precursor Ti(OR)4, R = nF'r or iPr, was reported to have an effect on the microstructure development, particularly for PbTiOs films [97]. Clusters and grains were observed in the n-propoxide and were attributed to a less continuously cross-linked networks compared with films derived from the isopropoxide. Using the modified alkoxide Ti(OiPr)z(acac)z instead of Ti(OiPr)4 allowed an increase in the thickness of crack-free PbTiOs films up to 1 m under base-catalyzed conditions [loll. Using the same titanium precursor associated with lead acetate and pentane-lJ-diol instead 2of methoxyethanol permitted the production of films up to approximately in thickness by repeated coatings before fuing [ 1021. All alkoxide routes appear to be limited toobtaining PNM [88a] and lithium or potassium niobate or tantalate [102a]. For the latter, the formulation of the mixed-metal alkoxide MM'(OR)6, M = Nb, Ta, is in agreement with that of the material. Epitaxial thin films of LiNbO3 on sapphire could be obtained [103]. The useof a mixed-metal MgNbz(0R)lz species (R = Et [105], CzH40Me [104]) has been shown to promote the formation of the perovskite phase for PNM.
MOCVD Obtaining electrooptical thin films by MOCVD techniques has been less investigated, although volatile oxide precursors-alkoxides 'or p-diketonatesexist for nearly all elements. For PbTiOs films titanium isopropoxide has been
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS associated with an alkyl derivative, PbEU using argon as the carrier gas. No additional oxygenwasnecessary. The film deposited at a quartz substrate heated at 500°C was shown to be conducting and dense, with good surface morphology and strong [l001 texture direction [106]. Pb(0tBu)z was used by Trundle and Brierley as the volatile lead source with Ti(OiPr)4, giving thick PbTiOs deposited at 450"C, annealed .in air at 800-900°C [107]. Although these authors could not deposit PbSc0.5Tm.503 (PST) directly from the metal precursors, the PST perovskite phase was obtained in atwo-stage process: deposition of cubic ScTaO4 by MOCVD using Ta(0Et)s and a scandium-fluorinated P-diketonate Sc(fod)3 (fodH = heptafluorodimethyloctanedione), followed by diffusion of PbO from a surface layer The heterometallic alkoxide LiNb(0R)a has the correct stoichiometry for depositing LiNbO3. Although LiNb(0R)a is volatile, control of the deposition parameters is sometimes hampered by disproportionation reactions. The problem has been overcome by using a lithium P-diketonate Lithd and Nb(0Me)s [5]. LiNbO3 has been deposited on a variety of substrates (-45O"C), but epitaxial layers require annealing in oxygen at higher temperatures.
V.
OUTLOOK
Metal alkoxides are readily available for all elements involved in electrooptical ceramics. The selection of appropriate OR groups-bulky or functional and thus polydentate-allows adjustment of their physical properties: solubility or volatility. An almost unlimited number of mixed-metal compositions is accessible under mild conditions, often at room temperature, by mixing metal alkoxides and carboxylates or P-diketonates. The molecular composition of these lutions can be quite complex and comprise mixed-metal species with different stoichiometries. To date, 2-methoxyethanol has been used predominantly for the sol-gel processing of thin layers and thus for the chemical modification of the metalalkoxides. However, methoxyethanol is teratogenic and can cause neurological and hematological damage, even at the ppm level. Alternative solgel systems, based for instance on other difunctional and polyfunctional alcohols and on hydroxyacids, for example, should be developed to promote the sol-gel process as a practical method. More systematic studies regarding the relationship between precursors, influence of additives, and properties of the final material are also required.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author is grateful to the CNRS for financial support, and to the contributions and enthusiasm of coworkers, whose names are listed in the references.
50
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF
acacH acetylacetone (2,5-pentanedione) acetate OAc ArR R-substituted phenyl group:2,6-RzCaH3 ArR$ R-substituted phenyl group:2,6-Rz-4-MeCsH3 ArF phenylgroupsubstitutedbyCF3 2,4,6-(CF3)3C,jH2 Bz benzyl CH2C6Hs P-dikHP-diketone = (O)CRCH2C(O)R thdH 2,2,6,6-tetramethylheptane-3,5-dione
1. Haertling, G. H.,Electronic Ceramics (L. M. Levinson, ed.), Dekker, New York, 1988, Chap. 7). 2. Bradley,D.C.,Mehrotra,R.C.,andGaurD. P.,MetalAlkoxides, Academic Press, London, 1978. 3. Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., Alkoxides as molecular precursors for oxide-based inorganic materials. Opportunities for new materials, New J. Chem., 11, 663 (1987). 4. Caulton, K. G., and Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., Synthesis, structural principles, and reactivity of heterometallic alkoxides, Chem Rev., 90, 9-995 (1990). Bradley, D. C., Metal alkoxides as precursors for electronic and ceramic materials, Chem. Rev., 89, 1317 (1989). 6. N.Y. Turova, V. A., Kozunov, E. P., Turevskaya, E. P., and Novoselova, A. V., Magnesium alkoxides, Russ. J. Inorg. Chem, 188, 327-329 (1973). 7. Lutz, H. D., Infrared and powder diffraction studies of Mg(OMe)2, Ca(OMe)2, Sr(0Me)z and Ba(OMe)z, Z. Anorg. Allgem. Chem, 365, 100 (1969). 8. Purdy, A. F., George, C. F., and Callahan, J. H., New alkoxides of copper and the alkaline and alkaline metals. Crystal structure of Na2CU[OCH(CF3)2]4, Inorg. Chem., 30, 2812-2819 (1991). 9. Rees, W. and Moreno, D. A., Preparation of monomeric Ba([O(C2&0)nCH3]2 (n = 2, 3), ambient temperature liquid barium compounds, J. Chem. Chem. Commun., 1759 (1991). Calabrese, J., Cushing, M. A., and Ittel,S. D. Sterically hindered magnesium loxides, Inorg. Chem, 867 (1988). 11. Roesky, H. W., Scholz, M., and Noltemeyer, M.,Reaction between 2,4,6-tris(trifluoromethy1)phenolwithmaingroupandtransitionmetalderivatives(Li,Na, 2303-2309 (1990). Ng, Ca, Ba, Ge, Sn and Ti, W, Mn, Cd), Chem. Ber., 12. Hitchcock, P. B.,Lappert,M.F.,Lawless,G.A.,andRoyo, B., The synthesis and structure the alkaline earth metal organic compounds[M(OAr)2(thfln] (1) M = Ca, n = 3 or M = Ba, n = 4 and [Ca(NRz)(pNR2)(thf)]2 and the x-ray structure of (1) Ar = C6HztBu2-2, 6-Me4, J. Chem. Chem. Commun., 1141 (1990). 13. Caulton,K.G.,Chisholm,M. H., Drake, R.,andFolting,K.,Synthesisand
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
51
molecular structure of a mononuclear barium aryloxide-ethanolamine complex, Ba(2,6-tBu2CaH30)2(0HC2H4NMe2)4,2C7H8, exhibitingextensivehydrogen bonding, Znorg. Chem., 1500 (1991). 14. Poncelet, O., Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L.G., Toupet, L., and Daran, J. C.,Molecular precursors of alkaline structure synthesis earths: ofand [N(C2H4O)(C2H4OH)2]2Ba,2EtOH, the first structurallycharacterizedbarium alkoxide, Polyhedron, 2045-2050 (1991). R., and Streib, W. E., Synthesis and 15. Caulton, K. G., Chisholm, M. H., Drake, structure of Ba3(0SiPh3)6(THF),OSTHF, a trinuclear barium siloxide containing coordinate barium ions, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 29, 1483 (1990). Coan, P. Streib, W. E., and Caulton, K. G. A triangular heterometallic siloxide containing barium, Inorg. Chem., 5019-5023 (1991). R., and Streib, W. E., Facile syn16. Caulton, K. G., Chisholm, M.H., Drake, structural and thesis principles of strontium the phenoxide Sr4(OPh)8(PhOH)2(6, Inorg. Chem., 29, 2707 (1990). 17. Tesh, K. F., and Banusa, T. P. Formation and solid state structure of a tetranuclear oxoaryloxide cluster of barium IBa40(0C6H4CH2NMe2)3-2,4,6)6], 3toluene, J. Chem. Chem.Commun., 879-881(1991). 18. Caulton, K. G., Chisholm, M. H., Drake, R., and Huffman, J. C., Examples of molecular aggregates of barium supported by aryloxide and alkoxide ligands, J. Chem. Chem. Commun., 1498 (1990). 18a. Miele, P., Foulon, J. D., Hovnanian, N., Durand, J., and Cot, L., J. Chem. Chem. Commun., to be published. 19. Labrize, F., and Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., unpublished results. 20. Caulton, K. G., Chisholm, M. H., Drake, R., and Huffman, J. C., Preparation, crystal and molecular structureof a hydrocarbon soluble volatile oxo-alkoxide of barium, H4Ba6(~la-O)(OC2H4OMe)l4, J. Chem. Chem.Commun., 1750 (1990). 21. Cetinkaya, B., Gunriiku", I., Lappert, M.F., Atwood, J. L., Rogers, R. D., and Zaworotko, M. J., Bivalent germanium tin and lead 2,6-di-tert-butylphenoxides and the crystal and molecular structures of M(OC6H2Me-4tBu-2,6)2 (M = Ge or Sn), J. Am. Chem. 102, 2088 (1980). 22. Veith, M., and Tallner, P., Cyclic azastannylene. W Reactivity of a 1,3-diaza-2sila-4, 2-stannylene with dienes, J. Organometal. Chem., 246, 219 (1983). 23. Goel, C., Chang, M.Y., andBuhro W. E.Preparation of sixlead (n) dialkoxides. X-ray structures of [Pb(OC2H40Me)2Im and Pbs(OtBu)6 and hydrolysis studies, Inorg. Chem., 29, 46404646 (1990). 24. Papiernik, R., Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., and Massiani, M. C., Synthesis, characterization and reactivity of lead(II) alkoxides and oxoalkoxides: Condensation to oxoalkoxides as a general structural feature, Polyhedron, 10, 1657 (1991). 25. Gaffney, C., Harrison, P. G., and King, T. J., The crystal and molecular structure of adamanta-M-oxo-hexakis (p-triphenylsi1oxy)-tetralead(II), J. Chem. SOC. Chem.Commun., 1251(.1980). 26. Yanovskii, A. A., Turova, N. Ya, Turevskaya, E. P., and Struchkov,Y. T., Structure of the first hydrolysis product of lead(I1) isopropoxide. Trans. 153 (1982).
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF 27. Harrison,P.G.,Haylett, 28. 29. 30.
31. 32.
33. 34.
35.
36.
37.
B. J., andKing,T. J., X-raycrystalstructure of Sn604(OMe)4: An intermediate in the hydrolysis of tin(II) dimethoxide, J. Chem. Chem. Commun., 112 (1978). Turevskaya, E. P., Ya Turova, N., and Novoselova, A. V., Trans. IN. A M . Nuuk SSSR, Seriyu Khimicheshyu, 1667 (1968). Goel, C., Chang, M. Y., and Buhro, W. E., Preparation of soluble and volatile zinc dialkoxides. X-ray crystal structures of an (amido)zinc alkoxide and a homoleptic zinc enolate Inorg. Chem, 4646 (1990). Geerts,R. L., Huffman, J. C.,andCaulton, K. G., Soluble zinc bisaryloxides, Inorg. Chem., 1803 (1986). Neils, T. L. L., and Burlitch, J. M., A soluble alkoxyzinc hydride, [HZnOCMe3]4. Synthesis and reactions with copper(I) alkoxides,Inorg. Chem., 1607 (1989). Massiani, M. C., Papiernik, R., Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., and D m , J. C., Molecular precursors of bismuth oxide. Synthesis structure and of [B~~(OC~H~OM~)~(OC~HLIOM~)~]-, aone-dimensionalribbon-likechain, J. Chem. Chem. 301 Massiani, M.C., Papiernik, R., Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., and Daran, J. C., Molecular precursors of bismuth oxides: b-Diketonates and alkoxides. Molecular structure of [Bi2(0C2H40Me)6], and of Bi(OSiPh3)3(THF)3, Polyhedron, 10, 437 (1991). Evans, W. J., Hain, J. H., and Ziller, J. W., Synthesis and molecular structure of Bi(OCaH3tBuzh, J. Chem. Chem. Commun., 1628 (1989). Matchett, M.A., Chang, M.Y., and Buhro, W. E., Soluble and volatile alkoxides of bismuth. The first structurally characterized bismuth trialkoxide: @3i(p,nlOC2&0Me)4(0C2fiOMe)~]~,Inorg. Chem., 358 (1990). Sauer, N. N., Garcia, E., and Ryan, R., Soluble and volatile precursors for the preparation of super-conducting films, Better Ceramics throughChemistry W, Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc., 921 (1990). Bradley, D. C., Chudzynska, H., Frigo, D. M., Hursthouse, M. B., and Mazid, M. A penta-indium oxo alkoxideclusterwithacentral5-co-ordinateoxygen. Preparation and X-ray crystal structure of (InOiPr)5(p2-0iPr)4(p3-OPr)4(~1-50), J. Chem. Soc. Chem. 1258 (1988). Bradley, D. C., Chudzynska, H., Frigo, D. M., Hammond, M. E., Hursthouse, M. B., and Mazid, M. Pentanuclear oxoalkoxide clusters of scandium, yttrium, indium and ytterbium. X-ray structureof MsO(OiPr)13 (M = In, Yb), Polyhedron,
719-726 (1990). 37a. Chattejee, Bindal, R.,andMehrotra,R.C.,Indiumalkoxides, J. Indiun Chem. Soc., 53, 867 (1976). 38. Hitchcock, P. B., Lappert, M. P., and Singh, A., Three and four-co-ordinate hydrocarbon-solublearyloxides of scandium,yttriumand the lanthanides:X-ray crystal structure of tris(2,6di-t-butyl-4-methylphenoxo)scandium, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. 1499 (1983). 39. Bradley, D. C., Chudzynska, H., Hursthouse, M. B., and Motevalli, M., Volatile tris-tertiary alkoxides of yttrium and lanthanum. The X-ray structure of La3(0tBu)9(tBuOH)2, Polyhedron, 1049-1059 (1991). 40. Evans, W. J., Golden, R. E., and Ziller, J. W., A comparative synthetic and struc-
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
41. 41a. 42.
43.
44. 45. 46. 46a. 47.
50.
51. 52. 53. 54.
53
tural study of triphenylmethoxide and triphenylsiloxide complexes of the early lanthanides, including X-ray crystal structures of Laz(xPh3)a and Ce~(OSiPh3)6,Inorg. Chem., 4963-4968 (1991). McGeary, M. J., Coan, P. Folting, K., Streib, W. E., and Caulton K. G., Yttrium and lanthanum silyloxide complexes, Inorg. Chem., 1723 (1991). Mehrotra, R. C., Transition metal alkoxides, Adv. Inorg. Chem. Rudiochem., 26, 269 (1983). Vaartstra, B. A., Huffman, J. C., Gradeff, P. Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., Daran, J. C., Parraud, Yunlu K., and Caulton, K. G., Alcohol adducts of alkoxides: Intramolecular hydrogen bonding as a general structural feature, Inorg. Chem., 3126-3131(1990). Kozlova, N. I., andTurova, N. Y.,Zirconiumisopropoxide, Russ. J. Inorg. Chem., 25, 1188 (1980). Fay, R. C., Zirconium and hafnium, in Comprehensive Coordination Chemistry (G. Wilkinson, ed.), Pergamon, London, Chap. 32, 1987, p. 390. Menge,W.M.P.B.,andVerkade,J.G.,Monomericanddimerictitanatranes, Inorg. Chem, 4628 (1991). Doeuff, Dromzee, Y., Taulelle, F., and Sanchez, C., Synthesis and solid- and liquid-state characterization hexameric aof cluster titanium(IV): of Ti6(p2~)(~3-o)2(p~t-oC4H9)2(OC(4H9)6(oAc)8, Inorg. Chem., 28, 4439 (1989). Mosset,A.,Gautier-Luneau I., Galy,J.,Strehlov,P.,andSchmidt,H.,Sol-gel processed BaTi03; structural evolution from the gel to the crystalline powder,J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 100, 339 (1988). Laaziz, I., Larbot, Guizard,C.,Durand,J.Joffre,J.,andCot,L.,Crystal structure of Ti604(0iPr(g(OAc)g,Acta Crystallogr. C46, 2332 (1990). Riess, J. G., and Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., Niobium pentamethoxide, a multi-faced 481 (1976). study of an early transition metal alkoxide, Chimia, Drake, R., and Otway, D. J., The synthesis metal organic compounds of calcium,strontiumandbariumbyammoniagassaturatedetherealsolutions., J. Chem. Chem. Commun., 517-519 (1991). Caulton, K. G., Chisholm, M. H., Drake, R., and Folting, K., Inorg. Chem., 1500 (1991). Poncelet, O., Sartain, W. J., Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., Folting, K., and Caulton, K. G.,Chemistryofyttriumtriisopropoxiderevisited;characterizationandcrystal Inorg. . Chem., 28, 263 (1989). structure of Y5(p5-O)(p3-OiPr)4(p2-OiPr)4(OiPr)5 Mehrotra, R. C., Singh, A., and Tripathi, U. M., Recent advances in alkoxo and Chem. Rev., 91, aryloxochemistryofscandium,yttriumandlanthanides, 1287-1303 (1991). Poncelet, 0..Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., Daran, J. C., and Astier, R., Alkoxides with polydentatealcohols:Synthesisandstructure [Y(OCfl40Me)3]10,ahydrocarbon soluble cyclic decamer, J. Chem. Chem. Commun., 1846 (1989). Turnipseed, B., Barkley, R. M., and Sievers, R. E., Synthesis and characterization of alkaline-earth-metal P-diketonate complexes used as precursors for chemInorg. Chem, 1164 (1991). ical vapor deposition of thin-film superconductors, Shreider, Turevskaya,E. P., Kozlova, N. and Turova, N. Y., Direct electrochemical synthesis of metal alkoxides, Inorg. Chim. Acta, 53, L73 (1981).
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF 55.
Chisholm, M. H., Drake, R., Naiini, A. A., and Streib, W. E., One-dimensional ribbon chains [M(OtBu)tBuOH], and the cubane [M(OtBu)]s M = K, Rb, polyhedron, 10,
55a.Guglielmi, M., andCarturan,G.,Precursorsforsol-gelpreparations,
Non-crys-
tall. Sol., 100,
Sanchez, C., andLivage, J., Sol-gelchemistryfrommetalalkoxideprecursors, New J. Chem,
Hubert-Pfalzgraf,L.G.,Poncelet, O., andDaran, J. C.,Tailoredmolecularprecursors of yttrium oxide using functional alcohols and acetylacetone as modifiers, BetterCeramicsThroughChemistry N Mat.,Res.Soc.Symp. Proc., 180, 58.
Plouxviel, J. C., Boilot, J. P.,Poncelet, O., Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G.,Lecote,A., Dauger, A., and Beloeil,J. C., An aluminosiloxane as ceramic precursor,J. NonCryst. Sol.,
Phule, P. P., Deis, T. A., and Dindiger, D. G., Low temperature synthesis of ultrafine LiTaOs powders, J. Mater. Res., Griesmar,P.,Papin,G.,Sanchez,C.,andLivage, J., Sol-gelroutetoniobium pentoxide, Chem. Mater., Leaustic,A.,Babonneau, F., and Livage, J., Structural investigation of the hydrolysis-condensation of titanium alkoxides Ti (OR)4 (R= iPr, Et) modified by acetylacetone Studyofthealkoxidemodification, Chem. Mater., I , Schmidt, R.,Mosset, A., and Galy, J., New compounds in the chemistry of group two polytransitionmetalalkoxides.Synthesisandmolecularstructureof morphs of Ti16016(OEt)32 and refinement of Ti704(OEt)20, J. Chem. Soc., Dalton Trans.,
Day, V. W., Eberpachere, T. A., Klemperer, W. G., Park, C. W., and Rosenberg, F. Solution, structure, elucidation of early transition metal polyoxoalkoxides using 1 7 0 nuclearmagneticresonancespectroscopy, J. Am.Chem. Soc., 113, Morosin, B., CrystalstructureofZr1308(0Me)36,
Acta Crystallegr.,
Kessler, V. G.,Turova,N.Y,Yanovskii,Belokon,A.I.,andStruchkov,Structure of Nb8010(OEt)20 and nature of metal oxoalcoholates,Zh. Neorg. Khim.,
Toledano, P., In, M., and Sanchez, C., Synthesis and structure of the compound T i ~ ~ ( ~ ~ - O ) ~ ( ~ O ~ ( ~ ~ - O ~ o ( ~ ~ - O ~ ( ~ - O n B u ) R. ~ ~Acad. ( O n BSci., u)~~(acac)~,C Toledano,P., In, M., and Sanchez, C., Co. R. Acad. Sci., 5, Parraud, Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G.,andFloch, H.,Stabilizationandcharacterization of nanosize niobium and tantalum oxidesols. Optical applications for high power lasers, in Ultrastructure and Processing Ceramics, Glasses and Composites, L. Hench (ed.), Wiley, New York, Nandi,M.,Rhubright,D.,andSen,A.,Pyrolytictransformationofmetalalkox-
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
ides to oxides: Mechanistic studies. Pyrolysis of homoleptic titanium alkoxides, 3065 (1990). Mehrotra,R.C.,Agrawal,M.M.,andKapoor,P.N.,Alkali-metalhexa-alkoxides of niobium and tantalum, J. Chem. A, 2673 (1968). Eichhorst, D. J., Payne, D. A., Wilson, R., and Howard, K. E., Crystal structure of LiNb((0Et)a: A precursor for lithium niobate ceramics, Inorg. Chem., 1458-1459 (1990). Yanovskii, A. P., Turevskaya, E. P., Turova, N. Y., and Struchkov, Y., Structure of lithium ethoxo-niobate crystal and molecular structure of its partial hydrolysis product, Transl. Koord. Khim., 11, 110 (1985). Goel, Goel, A. B., and Mehrotra, R. C., Double ethoxides of niobium with alkaline earth metals, Syn. React. Inorg. Metal-Org. Chem., 251 (1976). Boulmaaz, S., and Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., to be published. Kessler, V., and Turova, N. Y., private communication. Hayes, J. H.,Gururaja,T.R.,Geoffroy,G.L.,andCross,L. E., Sol-gelproMater. Lett., 5, 396 (1987). cessing of 0.9Pb(Zn1/3Nb~3)03-0.09PbTi03, Hubert-Pfalzgraf,L.G.,Papiernik,R.,Massiani,M-C.,andSepte, B., Heterometallic alkoxides as precursors to multicomponent oxides, Bener Ceramics Through Chemistry W , Mat. Res. Symp. Proc., 180, 393 (1990). Turevskaya,E.P.,andTurova,N.Y.,Thestudyoflanthanumandscandium alkoxoniobates. Formation, polymorphism,Koord. Khim., 1357 (1984). Fukui, T., Sakurai, C., and Okuyama. Lower temperature preparation of Pb(Mg1nNbu3)03 with a perovskite structure by the complex alkoxide method, J. Non Cryst. Sol., 134, 293 (1991). Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., and Riess, J. G., Isolation of a mixed niobium-tantalum alkoxide, Inorg. Chem., 15, 1196 (1976). Hampden-Smith,M. J., Williams, D. andRheingold,A.L.,Synthesisand characterization of alkali-metal titanium alkoxide compounds MTi (Oipr)~(M = Li,Na,K):Single-crystalx-raydiffractionstructureof[(LiTi(OiPr)=&, Inorg. Chem., 40764081 (1990). Vaartstra, B. A., Huffman, J. C., Streib, W. E., and Caulton, K. G., Incorporation of barium for the synthesis of heterometallic alkoxides. Synthesis and structures of [saZr2(OiPr)10]2 and Ba[Zs(OiPr)slz, Inorg. Chem., 30, 3068 (1991). and Blendell, J. E., Alkoxide synthesis and characteriRitter, J. J., Roth, R. zation of phases in the barium-titanium oxide system, J. Am. Ceram. 155 (1986). Yanovski, A. I., Yanovskaya, M. I., Limar, V. K., Kessler, V. G., Turova, N. Y., and Struchkov, Y. T., Synthesis and crystal structure of double barium-titanium Chem. Commun., 1605 isopropoxideBwTi404(0R)16(ROH)~, J. Chem (1991). Campion, J. F., Payne, D. A., Choe, H. K., Maurin, J. K., and Wilson, R., Synthesis of bimetallic barium titanium alkoxides as precursors for electrical ceramics. Molecular structure the of new barium titanium oxide alkoxide BiLiri13012(OC2H40Me)24,Inorg. Chem., 3245 (1991).
Inorg. Chem.,
69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76. 77. 77a. 78. 80.
81. 81a. 82.
83.
55
HUBERT-PFALZGRAF Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., Papiernik, R., and Massiani, M. C., to be published. Papiernik, R., Hubert-Pfalzgraf,L. G., andChaput,F.,Molecularroutesto ternarymetaloxides:A PbTi heterometallicisopropoxideasaprecursorto PbTi03, J. Non-Cryst. Sol., (in the press) Hirano, I., and Kato, K., Adv. Cerum. Muter., 3, Tripathi, U.M., Singh, and Mehrotra, R. C., Synthesis and characterization of some heterometallic isopropoxides of lanthanum with zirconium, Polyhedron, ZO,
Sakashita, Y . , Ono, T., Segawa, H., Tominaga, K., and Okada, M., Preparation and electrical propertiesof MOCVD-deposited PZT thin films,J. Appl. Phys., 88a. Munozaguado, M. F., Gregorkiewitz, M., and Larbot, Sol-gel synthesisof the binary oxide (Zr, Ti)Oz from the alkoxides and acetic acid in alcoholic medium, Muter. Res. Bull., Laaziz, I., Larbot, Julbe, Guizard, C., and Cot, L., Hydrolysis mixed titanium and zirconium alkoxides by an esterification reaction, J. Solid Sture Chem., to be published; Laaziz, I., Larbot, A., Foulon, 1. D., and Cot, L., zr2Ti404(oiPr)8(oiPr)2( OAC),~, submitted for publication. Francis, L. F., Payne, D. and Wilson, R., Crystal structure of a new lead zinc acetate alkoxide, PbzZnz(OCzH40Me)4(0Ac)4, Chem Murer., (
Veith,M.,Hans, J., Stahl, L., May,P.,Huch,V.,andSebald, Bimetallic alkoxygermanate(II)-stannate (II) andplumbate(II), Nuturjiorsch. B, 46b, Eichorst, Howard, K. E., and Payne, D. NMR investigations of lithium alkoxide solutions, J. Non-Cryst. Sol., Sirio, C., Poncelet, O., Hubert-F'falzgraf, L. G., Daran, l. C., and Vaissermann, J., Reactions between copper P-diketonates and metal alkoxides as a route sol-to uble and volatile copper(I1) oxide precursors: Synthesis and molecular structure of Cu4(p-3,nl-OC2H40iPr)4(acac)4 and (acac)Cu(p-OSiMe~)zAl(OSiMe~)~, Polyhedron, 11, Turova N. Y., Turevskaya, E. P., Kozlova, N. I., Rogova, T. V., Kessler, V. G.,
and Kucheiko,
I., Transition metal alkoxides-precursors of oxides materials,
J. Non-cryst. Sol., in the press
Thule, P. P., Raghavan, and Risbud, H., Comparison of Ba(OH)2, BaO and Baasstartingmaterialsforthesynthesis of bariumtitanatebythealkoxide Cerum Soc., method, J. Hsueh, C. C., and McCartney, M. L., Microstructural development and electrical properties of sol-gel prepared lead zirconate-titanate thin films,J. Muter, Res., 6, Yanovskaya, M.I., Turevskaya, E. P., Turova, N. Y., Dambekalne, M. Y . , Kolganova, N. V., Ivanov, Segalla, G., Belov, V. V., Novoselova, V., andVenevtsev, Y. N., Transparentceramic(Pb, La) (Zr, Ti)03 preparedby alkoxy technology, Inorg. Muter.,
METAL ALKOXIDES FOR ELECTROOPTICAL CERAMICS
57
97.Budd,K.D.,Dey, K.,andPayne,D.A.,Sol-gelprocessing PbTiO3, PbZrO3, PZT and PLZT thin films, Br. Ceram. Proc., 107 (1985). 98.Ramamurthi, D.,andPayne,D.A.,Structuralinvestigations prehydrolized precursors used in the sol-gel processing lead titanate,J. Am. Ceram. 2547 (1990). 99.Cheng,M. J., ZhaoZ.,andQuangD.,Preparation finePbTiO3powdersby hydrolysis of alkoxide, Chem. Mater., 3, 1006 (1991). 100. Seth, V. K., Schulze, W. A., and Condrate, R. A., Sr. Vibrational spectral characterization a lead lanthanum zirconate titanate during various stages sol1299 (1991). gel processing, Specrro. Lett., 100a.AhlfAanger, R., Bertagnolli,H.,Ertel, T., Kolb, U., PeterD.,Nass,R.,and Schmidt, H., First evidence the preformation of an inorganic network in solgel processing lead zirconate titanate, obtained by EXAFS spectroscopy,Ber. Bun. Gesel. Phys. Chem., 95, 1286 (1991). 101. Milne, J., and Pyke, H., Modified sol-gel process the production lead titanate films, J. Am. Ceram. 1407 (1991). 102. Philipps, J. F., and Milne, J., Diol-based sol-gel system for the production thin films of PbTiO3, J. Muter. Chem., 1, 893 (1991). 102a.Amini,M.M.,and Sooks, M.D.,Preparation of single-phaseKNbo3using 675. (1990). bimetallic alkoxides, Better Ceramics Through Chemistry W , 103. Nashimoto, K., and Cima, M. J., Epitaxial LiNbo3 thin films prepared by a solgel process, Mater. Lett., IO, 348 (1991). 104. Francis, L. F., Oh, Y. J., and Payne, D. A., Sol-gel processing and properties leadmagnesiumniobatepowdersandthinlayers, J. Muter. Scien., 5007 (1990). 105. Chaput, F., Boilot, J. P., Lejeune, M., Papiernik, R., and Hubert-Pfalzgraf, L. G., Low-temperature route to lead magnesium niobate, J. Am. Ceram. 1355 (1989). 106. Kwak, B. Boyd, E. P., and Erbil, E., Metalorganic chemical vapor deposition 1702 (1988). PbTiOs thin films, Appl. Phys. Lett., 107. Trundle,C.,andBrierley,C. J., Precursors thinfilmsoxidesbyPhoto102 (1989). MOCVD, Appl. Surf: Sci.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
POWDER SYNTHESIS AND CHARACTERIZATION
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Chemical Synthesis of Metal Oxide Powders C. N. R. Rao Indian Institute Science Bangalore, India
INTRODUCTION Synthesis of oxide materials provides an excellent case study of the contribution of solid-state chemists to materials synthesis Although tailoring oxides of the desired structure and properties remains the main goal of solid-state chemistry and materials science, it is not always possible to do One can but there is always the evolve a rational approach to the synthesis of solids element of surprise encountered not uncommonly. A well-known example of an oxide discovered serendipitiously is NaMo,06 containing condensed MO, octahedral metal clusters This was discovered in an effort to prepare the lithium analog of NaZn2M0308. Another such serendipitous discovery is that of the phosphorus-tungsten bronze Rb$8W320112, formed by the reaction of phosphorus present in the silica of the ampule during the preparation of the RbW bronze [5]. Novel solids of the type cu$o6s8, called Chevrel phases, were also discovered accidentally. There are many examples of rational synthesis. A good example is Sialon, in which Al and oxygen were partly substituted for Si and nitrogen in silicon nitride, Si3N,. The fast Na+ ion conductor Nasicon was synthesized based on understanding the coordination preferences of cations and the nature of oxide networks formed bythem. The zero-expansion ceramic C%.5Ti2P3012,possessing the Nasicon framework, was later synthesized based on the idea that the property of zero expansion would be exhibited by two- or three-coordination polyhedra linked in to leave substantial empty space in the network
61
RA0 Traditionally, oxides have been prepared by the so-called ceramic method, which involves mixing and grinding various powders and heating them at high temperatures, with intermediate grinding when necessary. The trend nowadays is to avoid such a brute force method to obtain better control of structure, stoichiometry, and phasic purity. Some of the chemical methods of synthesis of oxides that are especially noteworthy are (1) the precursor method, (2) coprecipitation and soft chemistry routes, the sol-gel method, intercalation and ion exchange, and topochemical methods. We examine examples of synthesis by some of these methods and briefly describe the synthesis of certain novel oxide materials, including superconducting cuprates, it should be noted that a variety ofconditions, often bordering on the extreme, such as very high temperatures or pressures, very low oxygen fugacities, and rapid quenching, have been employed in oxide synthesis. The low-temperature chemical routes, however, are of greater interest.
II. PRECURSOR METHOD In the ceramic method, diffusion distances between the reacting cations are rather large. The diffusion distances are markedly reduced by incorporating the cations in the same solid precursor. Synthesis of complex oxides by the decomposition of compound precursors has been known for some time. For example, thermal decomposition of L~CO(CN)~-SH,O and LaFe(CN),.H,O in air readily yields LaCo0, and LaFeO,, respectively. BaTiO, can be prepared by the thermal decomposition of Ba[TiO(C204),], and LiCrO, can be prepared from L I [ C ~ ( C ~ O ~ ) ~ ( H , O Unfortunately, )~]. compound precursors are not always easy to find. In such instances, precursor solid solutions can be used effectively. Carbonates of such metals as Ca, Mg, Mn, Fe, CO, Zn, and Cd are all isostructural, possessing the calcite structure. We can therefore prepare a large number of carbonate solid solutions containing two or more cations in different proportions [6,7]. The rhombohedral unit cell parameter uR of the carbonate solid solutions varies systematically with the weighted mean cation radius. Carbonate solid solutions are ideal precursors for the synthesis of monoxide solid solutions of rock salt structure. The carbonates can be decomposed in vacuum or in flowing nitrogen to yield single-phase solid solutions of monoxides of the type Mnl-pxO (M = Mg, Ca, CO, or Cd) of rock salt structure. Oxide solid solutions of M = Mg, Ca, and CO would require 770-970 K for their formation; those containing cadmium are formed at even lower temperatures. The facile formation of the oxides of rock salt structure by the decomposition of calcite carbonates is a result of the close (possibly topochemical) relationship between the structures of calcite and rock salt. The monoxide solid
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF METAL. OXIDE POWDERS
63
solutions can be used as precursors for preparing spinels and other complex oxides. Besides monoxide solid solutions, a number of ternary and quaternary oxides possessing novel structures can be prepared by decomposing carbonate precursors containing the different cations in the required proportions, in air or oxygen. Thus, one can prepare Ca,Fe,O, and CaFe204 by heating the corresponding carbonate solid solutions in air at 1070 and 1270 K,respectively, for about 1 h.Ca,F%O, is a defect perovskite with ordered oxide ion vacancies and has the well-known brownmillerite structure (Fig. 1) with the Fe3+ ions in alternate octahedral (0)and tetrahedral (T) sites. Two new oxides of similar compositions, Ca$0,05 and CaCo204, have been prepared by decomposing the appropriate carbonate precursors in oxygen atmosphere around K. Unlike Ca,Fe,O,, in C%Mn,O,, anion vacancy ordering in the perovskite structure gives a square-pyramidal (SP) coordination around the transition metal ion (Fig.1). One can also synthesize complex oxides of the type Ca2FeCo05, Ca,Fe,,Mno~405, Ca3Fe2Mn08, and on, belonging to the family by the carbonate precursor route. In the Ca-Fe-0 system, there are several other oxides, such as CaFe407, CaFel2Olg, and CaFe204(FeO), (n = 1, 2, that can, in principle, be synthesized starting from the appropriate carbonate solid solutions and decomposing them in a proper atmosphere. good example a multistep solid-state synthesis achieved starting from carbonate solid solution precursors is provided by the Ca2Fez-$4nXO, series of oxides (Fig. 2). The structure of both the end members, Ca2F%0, and Ca2Mn,05, are derived from that of the perovskite (Fig. 1). Solid solutions be-
-C - L a -
b
A
-O (
Structure (a) C%F905 (brownmillerite) and (b) C%Mn,O,. Oxygen vacancies are shown by open circles.
RA0
I
JI
BM
2 Ca3F%MnOs (I) reduced topochemically to Ca2Fe4BMm05 transforms to the brownmillerite (BM) structure on annealing in
(m; (II)
tween the two oxides are expected to show oxygen vacancy ordered superstructures with Fe3+ in octahedral and tetrahedral coordinations and Mn3+ in square-pyramidal coordination, but they cannot be prepared by the ceramic method. These solid solutions have indeed been prepared starting from the carbonate solid solutions, Ca2F~-Mnx(C03),. The carbonates decompose in air around 1200-1350 K to give perovskitelike phases Ca2Fe--$fnxOcy (y < 1). The compositions of the perovskitelike oxides prepared from the carbonate precursors with x = 2/3 and 1 are Ca3Fe+4n8 and Ca3Fel,Mnl,08.,. X-ray and electron difraction patterns show that they are members of the homologous series of anion vacancy ordered superstructures with n = 3 (A3B308+J. Careful reduction of Ca3Fe2Mn08 andCa3Fe1.5Mn1.508.1in dilute hydrogen at 600 K yields Ca3Fe2Mn07.5 and Ca2FeMn05 (CagFe1.5Mn1.507.5),respectively (Fig. During this step, only Mn4+ in the parent oxides is topochemically reduced to Mn3+, and Fe3+ remains unreduced. The mostprobable superstructure of Ca3F%Mn07.5 involves SP, 0, andT polyhedra along the b direction. On heating in vacuum at 1140 K,however, it transforms to the more stable brownmillerite structure with only 0 and T coordinations (Fig. 2). A variety of complex metal oxides of perovskite and related structures can be prepared by employing hydroxide, nitrate, and cyanide solid solutions precursors as well [ 8 ] . For example, hydroxide solid solutions of the general formula Ln1-Jblx(OH)3, where Ln = La or Nd and M = Al, Cr, Fe, CO or Ni) and Lal-x-,"~"y(OH)3 (where M' = Ni and M" = CO or Cu), crystallizing in the
CHEMICAL. SYNTHESIS
OF METAL. OXIDE POWDERS
65
rare earth trihydroxide structure, can be decomposed at relatively low temperatures (-870 K) to yield LaNiO,, NdNiO,, LaNil-xCox03, LaNil-xCuxO,, and others. Anhydrousalkaline-earth metal nitrates A(N03)2 (A = Ca, Sr, Ba)and Pb(NO,), are isostructural. One can therefore readily prepare nitrate solid lutions of the formula Al+.Pbx(N03)2,which are ideal precursors for the preparation of such oxides as BaPbO,, B%PbO,, and Sr2Pb0,. Oxides of the type LaFe0.5C00.503and 5Nd&003, which cannot be madereadilyby the ceramic method, have been prepared by the decomposition of cyanide solid lutions: LaFeo,Coo.5(CN)6.5.H20 and L% 5N+.5C~(CN)6.5-H20, respectively.
LA2C0205 AND La2Ni205 BYTOPOCHEMICAL REDUCTION Both LaNiO, and LaCoO, crystallize in the rhombohedral perovskite structure, and the anion-deficient nonstoichiometry of these oxides is interesting. Occurrence of the homologous series La,Ni,O,,, on the basis of a thermogravimetric study of the decomposition of LaNiO, was proposed some time ago. It was not known, however, whether a similar series exists for cobalt. Controlled reduction of LaNiO,andLaCoO, in hydrogen shows the formation of La2Ni2O5 and L%Co205, representing the n = 2 members of the homologous series LaB,03,1 (B = CO or Ni). La2Ni205.can be prepared by the reduction of LaNiO, at 600 K in pure or dilute hydrogen [9] and La2C0205 by the reduction of LaCo0, in dilute hydrogen at 670 K. Both oxides can be oxidized back to the parent perovskites at lowtemperatures. Neither La2Ni2O5 nor La2C02O5 can be prepared by the solid-state reaction of La203 and the transitionmetaloxide.X-rayand electron diffraction data reveal that La2C0205 adopts the brownmillerite structure. The x-ray diffraction pattern of La2Ni205 is different from that of La2C0205 but could be indexed on a tetragonal cell related to cubic perovskite. The formation of La2C0205 and L%Ni205 by the reduction of LaCoO, and LaNiO,, respectively, is caused by the topochemical nature of the reduction process. The reduction of the high-temperature superconductor YB%Cu30, to YBa2Cu306 is also a topochemical reaction. Similarly, many of the reactions involving insertion of atomic species into host oxides are topochemical.
IV. MO,-xW,O,BYTOPOCHEMICALDEHYDRATION Many of the modem developments in solid-state chemistry owe much to the investigations carried out in MOO, and WO, the crystallographic shear planes being a major discovery. WO, crystallizes in a Reo3-like structure, but MOO,
66
RA0
possesses a layered structure. MOO, can be stabilized in the WO, structure by partly substituting tungsten for molybdenum. These solid solutions can be prepared by the ceramic method (by heating MOO, and WO, in sealed tubes around 870 K) or by the thermal decomposition of mixed ammonium metallates. These methods do not always yieldmonophasicproducts,however, owing to the difference in volatilities of MOO, and WO,. We therefore sought to prepare Mo1,Wx03 by the topochemical dehydration of Mol,Wx03.H20. Topochemical dehydration, it is to be noted, is a gentle process. Since Mo03-H20 and WO,.H,O are isostructural, the solid solutions between them are prepared readily by adding a solution of MOO, and WO, in ammonia to hot M HNO,. The hydrates, Mol,Wx03.H20, crystallize in the same structure as Mo03.H20 and W03.H20, with a monoclinic unit cell. The hydrate solid solutions undergo dehydration undermild conditions (around K), yielding M o ~ - ~ W ~which O ~ , crystallize in the Reo3-related structure of WO,. Thermal dehydration of W03.H20 and M o , - ~ W ~ O ~ Hgives ~ O rise to oxides of Reo, structure. MOO, obtained by the dehydration of Mo03.H20, however, has a layered structure; this reaction is reported to be topotactic. The nature of the dehydration reaction was studied by an in situ electron diffraction study in which the decomposition occurs as a result of beam heating [IO]. Electron diffraction patterns clearly show how W 0 3 - H 2 0transforms to WO, topotactically with the required orientational relationships. The mixed hydrates, M O ~ - ~ W ~ O , . H also ~ O , undergo topotactic dehydration with similar orientational relations. What is interesting is that when the dehydration of Mo03.H20 is carried out under mild conditions (e.g., electron beam heating), MOO, in the Reo, structure is formed instead of the expected layered structure. The Reo, structure of MOO, is metastable and is produced only by topotactic dehydration under mild conditions. We believe that the preparation of Reo3 like MOO, by mild chemical processing is significant.
V. BRONZES OF MO,-flxO, REACTION
BYASOLID-STATE
Oxides of the type AxW03 (A = alkali metal) are known as tungsten oxide bronzes. These are readily prepared by the insertion of the alkali metal into WO,. The corresponding molybdenum bronzes are more difficult to prepare. High pressures and electrochemical methods are generally employed to thesize some of them. A simple solid-state reaction between an alkali iodide and MOO, or Mol,WxO3 (under dry conditions) has been found to yield such molybdenum oxide bronzes [l l]. The following reaction represents a simple means of making these bronzes:
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF METAL OXIDE POWDERS
VI.
67
INTERCALATION
Intercalation chemistry has become an important aspect of solid-state chemistry, and a large variety of guest molecules are accommodated in the cavities, cages, channels, or interlayer spaces of host solids. Many oxides act as hosts, and interesting properties emerge from this property. Many of the intercalation reactions are topochemical in nature. One of the interesting intercalation reactions involving oxides is that involving chemical or electrochemical intercalation or disintercalation of alkali metal ions in oxides of the type LiMO,, where M = V or Co. When Li, for example, is removed from LiVO,, the resulting VO, remains in the metastable structure of the parent LiVO,. Other such metastable structures of oxides have been prepared by the preferential removal of intercalated species [l].
VII.
ION EXCHANGE
Ion exchange is employed effectively to synthesize new oxides [l]. Thus Na in p-alumina is readily exchanged by other cations. Such exchange reactions are well known in silicates, especially zeolites. Examples of simple ion-exchange reactions are as follows: U 1 0 2 + AgN03 p "AgA102 + KNO3 a - LiFeOz + CuCl +CuFeOz + LiCl NaCrO;! + LiN03 +LiCrOz + NaCl It has been possible to exchange Li in LiNbO, by protons to obtain HNbO,. Such alkali metal-proton exchange reactions are common in layered oxides (e.g., H2Ti307 and HLaNbO,).
VIII.
ALKALI FLUX METHOD
One of the early examples of the use of strong alkaline media for the synthesis of oxides is that of Pb2Ru2-.Pbx07y, which has the pyrochlore structure. The method stabilizes higher oxidation states of metals. Alkali carbonate fluxes have been traditionally used to prepare many oxides (e.g., LaNiO,). Recently, superconducting La,CuO, was prepared by the reaction of L%O, and CuO in a molten mixture of NaOH and KOH around K [12]. Superconducting Ba,_.K$iO, has been prepared by the use of molten KOH [13].
IX.
INTERGROWTH STRUCTURES
Several systems form chemically well-defined recurrent ordered intergrowth structure with large periodicities, rather than random solid solutions with vari-
68
RA0
able composition. However, the ordered intergrowth structures themselves frequently show the presence of wrong sequences. The presence of wrong sequences or lamellae is best revealed by a technique more suited to the study of local structure.High-resolution electron microscopy (HREM) enables direct examination of the extent to which a particular ordered arrangement repeats itself: the presence of different sequences of intergrowths, often of unit cell dimensions. Selected area electron diffraction, which forms an essential part of HREM, provides useful information (not generally provided by x-ray diffraction) regarding the presence of supercells caused by intergrowth or defect ordering. Many systems forming ordered intergrowth structures have come to be known in recent years [14]. These systems generally exhibit homology. If the perovskite structure is cut parallel to the (1 10) planes, slabs of the composition An-lBn03, are obtained; if these slabs are stacked, an extra sheet of A is introduced, giving rise to the family of oxides of the general formula A#n03n+2. Typical members of this family are Ca2Nb2O7 (n = 4) NaCa4Nb,017 ( n = 5), and Na,Ca,Nb,O, (n = 6). High-resolution electron microscopy and x-ray studies show that an ordered intergrowth structure with n = 4.5 with the composition NaCa8Nb903*corresponds to alternate stacking of n = 4 and n = 5 lamellae. In Fig. 3 we show the lattice image of the ordered intergrowth in NaCa8Nb903,. Between n = 4 and 4.5, a large number of or-
High-resolution electron microscopic image of the n = 4.5 memberinthe series.
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF METAL OXIDE POWDERS
69
dered solids are found, with the b parameter of the unit cell ranging anywhere from A in the = compound to a few thousand angstroms in longer period structures. These solids seem to belong to the class of infinitely adaptive structures. There is a family of oxides of the general formula Bi@A,1B,03,3, discovered by Aurivillius, in which the perovskite slabs, (An-1Bn03n+1)2-, octahedra thick, are interleaved by (Bi202)2+layers (Fig. Typical members of this family are Bi2W06 (n = l), Bi3Til,Wo.,0, (n = 2), Bi4Ti3CrO12(n = and Bi,Ti3Cro15 (n = andtheyhavebeeninvestigatedindetailby HREM. These oxides form intergrowth structure of the general formula Bi4Arn+&3,,, involving alternate stacking of two Aurivillius oxides with different values; the method of preparation' simply involves heating the compo-
eo
eo
Bi7M5021
Bi9M7027
"
4 The f i i t three members of a homologous series structures of Bi4Am+,&lm+f103~m+fl~4 formed by the Aurivillius family oxides, where is also takento be Bi. Bi cations are shown as filled circles and oxide ions as open circles. BO, are shown in polyhedral form.
RA0
70
nent oxides or carbonates of metals. Ordered intergrowth structures with (m,n) values of (1, 2), and (3, have been fully characterized by x-ray diffraction and HREM. What is most amazing is that such intergrowth structures with long-range order are indeed formed, although either member (mor n) can exist as a stable entity. These materials seem to be truly representative of recurrent ordered intergrowth. The periodicity found in the recurrent intergrowth solids formed by the Aurivillius family of oxides is indeed impressive. The relative ease withwhich WO, forms tetragonal, hexagonal, or perovskite-type bronzes by interaction with alkali and other metals is well known. The new family ofintergrowthtungsten bronzes (ITB) involving the intergrowth of nWO, slabs and one to three strips of the hexagonal tungsten bronze (HTB) is of relevance to our discussion here. In these intergrowth tungsten bronzes of the general formula MxW03, x is generally 0.1 or less, and depending on whether the HTB strip is one or two tunnels wide, ITB are classfied as belonging to (0, n) or (1, n) series (Fig. 5). HTB strips of two-tunnel width seem to be most stable in ITB, and many ordered sequences of the (0, n) and the (1, n) series have been identified. Recently, ITB phases of Bi have been characterized, and in this system the HTB strips are always one tunnel wide, Displacement of adjacent tunnel rows caused by the tilting of WO, octahedra often results in doubling of the long-period axis of the ITB. Evidence for the ordering of the intercalating Bi atoms in the tunnels has been found in terms of satellites around the superlattice spots in the electron diffraction patterns. Among the other systems exhibiting ordered intergrowth, special mention must be made of hexagonal barium femtes MpYq (M = BaFeI2Ol9 and Y = Ba2Me,2022, where Me is Zn, Ni, Mg, and so on). A large number of intergrowth structures of this family have been identified.
X.
SUPERCONDUCTING CUPRATES
The discovery of a superconducting cuprate with a T, above 77 K created a sensation in early 1987. Wu et al., who announced this discovery first, made measurements on a mixture of oxides containing Y, Ba, and Cu. In this laboratory, we independently worked on the Y-Ba-Cu-0 system on the basis of solid-state chemistry We knew that Y,Cu04 could not be made and that substituting Y with Ba in this cuprate was not the way to proceed (unlike in La2-€!axCu04). We therefore tried to make Y3Ba3Cu5OI4by analogy with the known La3Ba3Cu6OI4and varied the Y/Ba ratio as in Y3,rBa3+xC~6014. When x = 1, we obtained YBa2Cu3 (T, 90 K). We knew the structure had to be that of a defect perovskite from the beginning, because of the route we followed for the synthesis. We briefly examine some preparative aspects of the various types of cuprate superconductors [16]. The cuprates are ordinarily made by the traditional ce-
CHEMICAL, SYNTHESIS
OF METAL, OXIDE POWDERS
71
I I ,6)
5 The (1, n) intergrowth tungsten bronzes. Hexagonal tunnels of HTB strips separate the WO, slabs shown in polyhedral form. (After Kihlborg, 1979.)
ramic method (mix, grind, and heat), which involves thorough mixing of the various oxides and/or carbonates (or any other salt) in the desired proportion and heating the mixture (preferably in pellet form) at a high temperature. The mixture is ground again after some time and reheated until the desired product is formed, as indicated by x-ray diffraction. This method may not always yield the product with the desired structure, purity, or oxygen stoichiometry. Variof this method are often employed. For example, decomposing a mixture of nitrates has been found to yield a better product in the 123 compounds of the type YBa2Cu307 by some workers; some others prefer to use BaO, in place of BaC03 for the synthesis. The sol-gel method has been conveniently employed for the synthesis of 123 compounds, such as YBa2Cu30, and other cuprates. The sol-gel method
RA0 provides a homogeneous dispersion of the various component metals when a solution containing the metal ions is transformed into a gel by adding an organic solvent, such as glycol or an alcohol, often in the presence of other chemicals, such as organic amines. The gel is then decomposed at relatively low temperatures to obtain the desired oxide, generally in fine particulate form. Materials prepared by such low-temperature methods may need to be annealed or heated under suitable conditions to obtain the desired oxygen stoichiometry as well as the characteristic high T,. total of cuprates of the type YBa2Cu,08, lead cuprates, and bismuth cuprates have all been made by this method; the first two are particularly difficult to make by the ceramic method. Coprecipitation of all the cations in the form of a sparingly soluble salt, such as carbonate, ina proper medium, followed by thermal decomposition, has been employed by many workers to prepare cuprates. One of the problems with the bismuth cuprates is the difficulty in obtaining phasic purity (minimizing the intergrowth of the different layered phases). The glass or the melt route has been employed to obtain better samples. The method involves preparing a glass by quenching the melt; the glass is then crystallized by heating it above the crystallization temperature. Thallium cuprates are best prepared in sealed tubes (gold or silver). Heating T1203 with K) in a sealed tube a matrix the other oxides (already heated to is preferred by some workers. It is important that thalliumcuprates are not prepared in open furnaces since T1203, which readily sublimes, is highly toxic. obtain superconducting compositions corresponding to a particular copper content (number of Cu02 sheets) by the ceramic method, one often must start with various arbitrary compositions, especially with the T1 cuprates. The real composition of a bismuth or a thallium cuprate superconductor is not likely to be anywhere near the starting composition. The actual composition can be determined by analytical electron microscopy and other methods. Heating oxidic materials under high oxygen pressures or in flowing oxygen often becomesnecessary to attain the desired oxygen stoichiometry. Thus h 2 C u 0 4 and La&a,-,Sr,Cu2O6 heated under high oxygen pressure become superconducting,with T, of and K, respectively.With the compounds, one of the problems is that it loses oxygen easily. It therefore becomes necessary to heat the material in an oxygen atmosphere at an appropriate temperature below the orthorhombic-tetragonal transition temperature. Oxygen s t 6 ichiometry is not a problem with the bismuth cuprates, however. The perconductorswere first preparedunder high oxygenpressures. It was later found that heating the oxide or nitrate mixture in the presence of N%02 in flowing oxygen is sufficient to obtain compounds.Superconducting Pb cuprates, on the other hand, can only be prepared in presence of very little oxygen(N2witha small percentage of 02).For the electron superconductor Nd2-xCexCu04, it is necessary to heat the material in an oxygen-deficient at-
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF METAL OXIDE POWDERS
73
mosphere; otherwise, the electron given by Ce merely gives an oxygen-excess material. It may be best to prepare Nd2_,Ce,Cu04 by a suitable method (say, decomposition of mixed oxalates or nitrates) and then reduce it with hydrogen. Many thallium cuprates, as prepared by the sealed tube method, have excess oxygen; they become superconducting only on heating in vacuum or hydrogen. Several other novel strategies have been employed for the synthesis of perconducting cuprates. For example, a Eu-Ba-Cu alloy precursor has been oxidized to obtain EuBa$u,O, and hyponitrite precursor has been employed to prepare YBa,Cu,O, More interesting in the synthetic strategies are those in which structural and bonding considerations are involved in the synthesis. One such example is the synthesis of modulation-free superconducting bismuth cuprates Superconducting bismuth cuprates, such as Bi2CaSr2Cu208, exhibit superlattice modulation. Since such modulationhad something to do with the oxygen content in the Bi-0 layers and lattice mismatch, Bi3+ was substituted partly by Pb2+ to eliminate the modulation without losing the superconductivity.
XI.
CONCLUDINGREMARKS
The area of oxide synthesis has become trulyextensive, with newertypes of materials being prepared everyday by employing a variety of novel methods We have touched on only some of the important methods, and there are many more. For example, we have not discussed the commonly employed coprecipitation method (involving the simultaneous precipitation of the cations as carbonates and oxalates, for example) followed by decomposition or the sol-gel method. This method does not always give precursor solid solutions, but coprecipitated materials on decomposition readily give the desired oxides. Another novel method of preparing oxide powders is by the combustion method, involving the spontaneous ignition of a mixture of metal nitrates in presence of a fuel, such as urea or glycine This method can be employed to prepare powders of most oxides, including dielectrics and superconductors. The use of templatemolecules to synthesizeporous solids involving silicates andphosphates is noteworthy. The ingenuity with which properties of oxides are modified drastically by appropriate substitutions or by the modification of the structure forms an important part of synthetic strategies. Other methods of interest are those involving fine particles, vapor transport, and electrochemical methods
ACKNOWLEDGMENT The author thanks the Department of Science and Technology and the Indo-European Economic Community collaborative program for support.
74
REFERENCES 1. Rao, C. N. R., and Gopalakrishnan, J., New Directions in Solid State Chemistry, Cambridge University Press, London, 1989. 2. Rao, C. N. R., and Gopalakrishnan, J., Acc. Chem. Res., 20, 228 (1987). 3. Roy, R., Solid State lonics, 32133, 3, (1989). 3963, (1979). 4. Torardi, C. C., and McCarley, R. E.,J. Am. Chem. 5. Giroult, J. P., Goreand, M., Labbe, P. H., and Raveau B., Acta Crystallogr., 1336, 2570, (1980). . 6. Vidyasagar, K., Gopalakrishnan, J., and Rao, C.N.R., Inorg. Chem., 23, 1206, (1984). 7. Rao, C. N. R., Gopalakrishnan, J., Vidyasagar, K., Ganguli, K., and Ramanan, J. Mater. Res., 1, 280 (1986). 8. Vidyasagar, K., Gopalakrishnan, J., and Rao, C. N. R., J . Solid State Chem., 58, 29 (1985). 9. Vidyasagar, K., Reller, Gopalakrishnan, J., and Rao, C. N. R., J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun., 7 (1985). Gopalakrishnan, J., and Rao, C. N. R., J. Chem. Soc. 10. Ganapathi, L., Ramanan, Chem. Commun., 62 (1986). K., Gopalakrishnan, J., and Rao, C. N. R., J. Solid State Chem., 74, 11. Ganguli, 228 (1988). M., J . Am. Chem. 5214 12. Ham, W. K., Holland, G. F., and Stachy, (1988). 13. Schneemeyer, L. F., Thomas, J. K., and Siegrist, T., Nature, 335, 421 (1988). Rao, C.N.R., and Thomas, J. M., Acc. Chem. Res., 18, 113 (1985). and Sreed15. Rao, C. N. R., Ganguly, P., Raychaudhuri, K., Mohan Ram, R. har, K.,Nature, 326, 856 (1987). 16. Rao, C. N.R., Nagarajan, R., and Vijayaraghavan, R., Supercond. Sci. Technol., 6, 1(1992). 17. Matsuzaki, K., Inone, Kimura, H., Aoki, K., and Masumoto, K.,Jpn. J . App. Phys., 26, L1310 (1987). 18. Horowitz, H. Mclain, J., Sleight, W., Druliner, J. D., Gai, P. L.,Van Kavelaar, M. J., Wagner, J. L., Biggs, B. D., and Poon, J., Science, 243, 66 (1989). 19. Manivannan, V., Gopalakrishnan, J., and Rao, C.N.R., Phys. Rev., B.43, 8686 (1991). 20. Rao, C.N.R., Mater. Sci. Eng., in print (1992).
4 Multicomponent Ceramic Powders T. Mah UES,Inc., Dayton, Ohio
E. E. Hermes Wright Paterson Air Force Base, Ohio
K. S. Mazdiyasni General Atomics, San Diego, California
INTRODUCTION The chemical processing of ceramics, especially ceramic powder syntheses, has drawn a considerable amount of attention over the past two decades. The reason for this is the demand for reliable and advanced ceramic components for high-performance applications. This increased interest in the chemical synthesis of ceramic powders is illustrated by the vast number of publications and ongoing investigations [ 1-91. This chapter focuses only on the syntheses of oxide ceramic powders. The precursors of these powders are metal-organic compounds, mainly metal alkoxides. The different varieties of ceramic powders synthesized by mixed metal alkoxide precursors are the focal points of this chapter. Numerous references on the fundamental principles of sol-gel processing are available in the literature and within other chapters of this book [10-12]. This chapter is divided into three major sections: (1) metal alkoxide precursor synthesis methods used by the present authors, (2) silicate powder syntheses, and nonsilicate powder syntheses.
II. PRECURSOR SYNTHESIS In this section, only the following synthesis methods are described ammonia, metal/alcohol, metal halide/alcohol, ester exchange, and alcohol exchange. De75
76
MAHETAL..
tailed synthesis techniques for metal alkoxides can be found in Metal ides by Bradley et al. [ 101.
A.
Ammonia Method
The simplest andmost economic method for the large-scale productionof alkoxides involves the addition of anhydrous metal halides to a mixture anhydrous alcohol in a diluent (benzene, n-hexane, or toluene) in the presence of anhydrous ammonia [13,14]:
whereM is many of the transition metals, such as titanium, zirconium, hafnium, tantalum, and niobium, and R is the organic group. The transition metal tetrakis-isopropoxide is readily purified by fractional distillation or recrystallization. The removal of NH4Cl by filtration is always cumbersome and time consuming: the ammonia method may be carried out in the presence of amides or nitriles. For this particular method, the metal alkoxide separates out as the upper layer, and the ammonium chloride remains in the solution of the amide or nitile at the lower layer; thus, the filtration step is eliminated [13,15].
B.
Metal/Alcohol Reaction Method
The alkoxides of some metals interest, such as aluminum, yttrium, and the rare earths, can be made by reaction with alcohol using a reactioncatalyst (e.g., HgC12 and HgI2) [16-181: M + ROH
HgC12 > M(OR), exothermic
+ EH2 2
where n is the valence of metal M, and R is the organic group. Most alkali or alkaline-earth metal alkoxides can be prepared by this reaction without using reaction catalysts.
C.
Metal Halide/AlcoholReaction Method
typical example of this method is the synthesis con [19]: S i c 4 + 4ROH
exothermic
various alkoxides of sili-
'Si(OR)4 + 4HC1
where R is the ethyl, n-propyl, isopropyl, and
on, group.
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
D.
EsterExchangeReaction
valuable method for converting one alkoxide to another is an ester exchange reaction [20]. This method is particularly suited for the preparation of the tertiary butoxide from the isopropoxideand r-butyl acetate. The reaction is as follows: M(OR)4 + 4R’OOCCH3 _ _ j M(OR’)4 + 4ROOCCH3 where M is zirconium, titanium, hafnium, and thorium, for example, R is the isopropyl group, and R’ is the tert-butyl group. Since there is a large difference between the boiling points of the esters, the fractionation is simple and quite rapid. Another advantage appears to be the lower rate of oxidation of the esters compared with that of alcohol.
E.AlcoholExchangeReaction Substitution of other branched R groups with the lower straight-chain alcohols has been carried out in an alcohol interchange reaction [lo]:
M(OR)4 + 4R‘OH-
M(OR‘)4 + 4ROH
The distillation of azeotrope drives the reaction to completion. Compounds prepared by this method [21] include the secondary pentoxides, secondary hexoxides, secondary heptoxides, tertiary butoxides, tertiary heptoxides of transition metals, such as yttrium, and also rare earth elements. Increasing the molecular weight and branching of the attached organic group result in the rise in the melting point and stability toward hydrolysis and thermal decomposition. These characteristics are very important in controlling the hydrolysis of multicomponent mixed alkoxides.
ALKOXY-DERIVEDCERAMICPOWDERS The oxide ceramic powders produced through mixed-metal alkoxides have many advantages over powders prepared conventionally; some of the advantages are lower temperature processes, higher purity, more homogeneous distribution of constituents, finer particle size, and easier compositional alteration. Most metal alkoxides exposed to moisture and/or heat cause decomposition of the alkoxide and thus provide forming methods for fine ceramic powders (notable examples for decomposition are thermal decomposition and hydrolytic decomposition). Mazdiyasni[22,23] reported the direct pyrolysis of the metal alkoxides, which form very fine ceramic powders. The overall thermal decomposition of a liquid zirconium tertiary butoxide to ZrO2 is as follows: Zr(OR)4
*
ZrO2 + 2ROH + olefin
MAH ET AL.
78
The thermal decomposition method is very rapid, and the products formed are volatile olefins, alcohols, and fine ceramic powders. The hydrolytic decomposition of metal alkoxides, with subsequent dehydration, has been used to form many types of fine ceramic powders. The decomposition of the metal-organic is initiated via the hydrolytic reaction of water, with subsequent thermal dehydration of the resulting precipitates. The general decomposition is described as a two-step process:
M(OR), M(OH),
-
+ nH2O +M(OH), + nR(0H) MO,/;! + "nH 2 0 2
hydrolysis
dehydration
The hydrolysis reaction usually occurs at room temperature and dehydration occurs below 600°C. resulting in the formation of very fine ceramic particles, that is, 2-5 [22]. This method has been successfully used to make high-purity submicrometer-sized oxides from several metal alkoxides [23,24]. Focus on multicomponent oxide powder synthesis through the two-step hydrolysis and dehydration of metal alkoxides constitutes the remainder of this chapter. When mixtures of alkoxides are hydrolyzed, the different hydrolysis and polycondensation rates of each individual alkoxide can cause complications. These complications may lead to local inhomogeneities. If one species is hydrolyzed faster than the other, which is almost always the case, then differential precipitation occurs during hydrolysis, leaving the other species substantially unreacted. Examples of these are found in the following sections of this chapter. The classes of ceramic powder are divided into two categories (silicates and nonsilicates) and are discussed separately in the following sections.
Silicate Within the category of silicate powders there are two different varieties: glass and/or glass-ceramics and (2) crystalline. The first variety includes various compositions of glasses and glass-ceramics (e.g., lithium aluminosilicate and magnesium aluminosilicate), and mullite and zircon are typical examples of silicates that belong to the latter variety. 1. Multicomponent Silicate Glass and Glass-Ceramics Hydrolyses of multicomponent metal alkoxides were reported by Dislich [25,26] for silicate glass and by the present authors [27,28] for glass-ceramics. Dislich [25] synthesized the eight-component glass through a complexation of mixed alkoxides, followed by hydrolysis andcondensation. The processing flowchart for the synthesis of magnesium aluminosilicate (MAS) (with Li, Zr, and Nb) glass-ceramic oxide powder, hydroxides, and their mixtures for ce-
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
79
ramic matrix composite matrix material is shown in Fig. 1 [27]. Synthesis of the individual alkoxides was accomplished using one of the appropriate techniques previously described. The individual alkoxides combined into proportions to yield the desired oxide composition. Solid alkoxides, such as Mg(OC2H5)2 and AI(OC3H7)3,are mutually soluble in liquid alkoxide, such as Si(OCzH5)4. As the metal alkoxides are combined together and refluxed, the possibility exists that some of the alkoxides may form complex mutimetal-organic ligands distributed evenly throughout the solution. Within these mixedmetal alkoxides, the formation of double alkoxide between Mg(OCzH5)z and AI(OC3H7)3 is a strong possibility. In fact, the existence of the double alkoxide, MgA12(0R)g, is well known [10,29], indicating that the distribution of the multiple-metal hydroxides, in the solution after hydrolysis, may not be completely uniform at the molecular scale as a result of the preferential hydrolysis of some metal alkoxides and/or metal-alkoxide complexes. Although it has been documented [30] that the MgA12(OR)g double alkoxide does not break down to its constituents during hydrolysis, the resulting multicomponent metal hydroxides should have, at minimum, a uniform compositional distribution.
2. Multicomponent Crystalline Silicates There are a vast number of publications about mullite (3A1203*2Si02), ranging from synthesis and processing to its applications andproperties [31,32]. The interest and importance of mullite as a candidate material for various applications has been manifest by the number of symposiums on the topic. Hy-
1
Processingflowchart for thesynthesis of magnesiumaluminosilicate.
MAH ET AL.. drolytic decomposition of the mixed-metal alkoxide route to synthesize stoichiometric mullite powder was carried out by one of the present authors approximatelytwo decades ago [33].Aluminum tris-isopropoxide and silicon tetrakis-isopropoxide were synthesized. The mixed alkoxides were refluxed in excess isopropyl alcohol for 16 h before hydrolysis ensure thorough mixing. The hydroxyaluminosilicate was prepared by slowly adding the alkoxide solution to ammoniated triply distilled deionized water according to the reaction 6Al(OC3H7)3 + 2Si(OC3H7)4 + xH20 H20
+
NH3
> 2A13Si(OH)l3 .xHz0 + 26C3H7OH
The resulting hydroxyaluminosilicate was repeatedly washedwith propyl alcohol and dried in vacuum at 60°C for 16 h: vacuum 2A13Si(OH)13 F 3&03 60°C
*
dry iso-
2Si02 + 13H20
At this stage of preparation, the mixed oxide was amorphous to x-ray diffraction. Transmission electron microscopy ("EM) photomicrographs of the as-prepared powders, calcined at 600°C statically for 1 and 24 h and dynamically for 24 h, are shown in Fig. 2. In Fig. 2a, needlelike crystallites of the very fine asprepared particulates are evident. The crystallite growth (agglomeration of small particles followed by rapid growth) occurs during the calcination process, leading to very large but well-defined acicular or prismatic particulates [(Fig. 2b-d)l. The as-prepared powders are extremely active, with a surface area of -550 m2/g; however, the surface area is reduced to 280 m2/g when the powders are calcined at 600°C for 1 h. High-temperature x-ray diffraction (m) studies showed that the crystallization of stoichiometric mullite took place between 1185 and 1200°C. However, the previously mentioned hydrolytic reaction is very sensitive to experimental conditions, such as the presence acid or base catalysts, reaction temperature, and molar ratio of alkoxides to H2O. Three critical experimental parameters (pH, temperature, and reaction time) that affected the rate of hydrolysis were systematically studied by Paulick et al. (34). The volume ratio of 100 ml mixed alkoxide [Al(OC3H7)3 and tetraethylorthosilicate (TEOS)] solution to 500 m1of an H20/CH30H (3:l ratio) solution was used for all the experiments. It was found that in an acid environment (pH 2) the hydrolytic decomposition was completed within 7 h at room temperature. Stoichiometric mullite was the only product obtained, as evidenced by both elemental analysis and x-ray diffraction. Under alkaline conditions (pH lo), the degree of hydrolytic decomposition was both time and temperature dependent. The TEOS was only partially hydrolyzed even after heating at 70°C for 20 h. The oxide powder obtained was composed of 65% A1203 and 35% mullite. The degree of hydrolysis is only moderately affected by temperature, and it is not affected by the reaction time.
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
81
The difference between acid-versus base-catalyzed hydrolysis of mixed TEOS and Al(OC3H7)3 can be accounted for by the different reaction mechanisms of TEOS hydrolysis [l l]. Nucleophilic hydrolysis and condensation in alkaline solutions tend to produce highly cross-linked species, which may not be completely hydrolyzed. In contrast, in acid solution, the electrophilic reaction mechanism favors the production of weakly cross-linked species that tend to be completely hydrolyzed The specific surface area the as-calcined mullite powder obtained under acid hydrolysis conditions is m2/g. Clusters of particles develop during concentration of the hydroxide slurry. These particles polymerize on further drying, causing bound -OHgroups in the clusters, thereby resulting in hard agglomerates instead of fine powder. One can make a compromise through the partial hydrolysis of TEOS and then add AI(OC3H7)3 to accomplish complete hydrolysis and yet achieve fine powder sizes.
Nonsilicate few varieties of nonsilicate oxide ceramic powderssynthesizedthrough alkoxide processing are presented here. These oxide powders were developed for the use of electronic, optical, and high-temperature structural applications. For each material, we with a brief description of the synthesis, which is followed by powder characteristics (e.g., particle sizes, morphologies, and size distributions) and densification behavior andsome properties of dense material. 1. Spinel The precursor alkoxide syntheses for spinel (MgA1204) were carried out through the metal/alcohol reaction methodusing HgC12 as acatalyst. This methodwas described in the previous section. The two metal alkoxides, Al(OC3H7)3 and Mg(OC2H5)2, were mixed together and gently heated in isopropyl alcohol until solid Mg(OC2H5)2 was completely dissolved and reacted, producing a clear solution, and then allowed to cool to room temperature During the refluxing process, magnesium and aluminum double alkoxide was formed, The formation and structural characterization of the MgA12(0R)8 douThe double alkoxide was ble alkoxide can be found in references readily hydrolyzed by water, without acid or base catalyst. No differential hydrolytic decomposition mixed alkoxide was found in this system to hinder the formation of ultrafine homogenous spinel powder. The XRD analysis (Fig. 3) of the ultrafine powder, obtained after calcination at 550"C, shows amorphous characteristics. The powder was calcined at 1000°C for 1 h, and XRD analysis showed broad peaks of spinel, which is a characteristic diffraction pattern for fine particles. Distinct, sharp XRD peaks of spinel can be observed after the powder is hot pressed at 1550°C. Elemental analysis the powder calcined at 550°C gave a 1:l MgO/A1203 ratio. Emission spectrographic analysis of the as-calcined powder indicated that no measurable impurities were pre-
2 Transmissionelectronphotomicrographs of mullitepowders as-prepared, (b) calcined at for 1 h, (c) calcined for 24 h with tumbling, and (d) calcined for 24 h without tumbling.
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
83
MAH ET AL.
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
85
sent. The surface area of the as-calcined powder was 260 m2/g, which corresponds to an average particle size of 6.5 nm. The transmission electron photomicrograph of the as-calcined powder (Fig. 4) showed the particle size to be of the order of 10 nm, which is in agreement with the calculated value. The average particle size of the powder, heat treated at 1000°C for 1 h, increased to about 30 nm, and also the particles were faceted. 2. Electronic Ceramics A few multicomponent electronic ceramics, fabricated through metal alkoxide processing, are described in this section. PZT PLZT. The development of polycrystalline lead lanthanum zirconate-titanate (PLZT) electronic ceramic monoliths, which fully transmit incident light, requires methods for controlling stoichiometry, impurity content, porosity, grain size, and so on. Alkoxy-derived PLZT powders were prepared by hydrolytic decomposition of mixed-metal alkoxides [40]. The Zrand Ti alkoxides were synthesized by the ammonia method, and the lanthanum isopropoxide was synthesized by themetal/alcoholreaction method, which were described in the previous section. The Pb alkoxide was prepared by the reaction of anhydrous lead acetate, Pb(C2H302)2, with sodium isoamyloxide, NaOCsHl I [40]: Pb(C2H302)2 + 2NaOR
-
Pb(OR)2 + 2NaC2H302
where R is the isoamyl group. The solvated lead alkoxide solution was filtered to a clear, colorless solution. PLZT powder is typically prepared by dissolving the mixed-metal alkoxides in a mutual solvent, such as isoamyl alcohol, followed by hydrolytic decomposition to yield a nominal zirconate-titanate molar ratio of 65:35 containing 10atom%La. The preferred general formula of Pb1-~Lax(Zr,Ti~)1-~/403 is referred to in the literature[41,42]. The resulting hydroxide was washed repeatedly with high-purity water and then with isopropanol. The washed hydroxide was dried undervacuum at 60°C toyield white amorphous powder. The as-preparedPLZTpowderswere calcined at 500°C for 30 minutes to 1 h and then ground in a B4C mortar to break the large agglomerates. TEM photomicrographs of the powder calcined at 500°C for 15 min~tesand 1 h is shown in Fig. 5. The cubic symmetry of the material is quite evident; the electron diffraction patterns indicate a cubic structure, which is in agreement with the X R D analysis. Because of the rapid outward diffusion of PbO in this system, calcination at a higher temperature and for a longer time at 500°C invariably resulted in massive agglomeration or partial sintering of the particle. Thermograms (TG) for the as-prepared PLZT powders are shown in Fig. 6. The TG of the powders, unwashed and washed withisopropyl alcohol, was run inan ambient atmosphere from room temperature to 1000°C. Both types of
86
4 Transmission electron micrographs h. (a) 550°C and (b) 1000°C inair
MAHETAL..
dispersed spinel powder calcined at
5 Transmissionelectronmicrographs 500°C for (a) 15 minutes and (b)
of PLZT particulatescalcinedat
88
MAHETAL.
powder showed an initial 5% weight loss from 70 to 11O"C, caused mostly by the loss of alcohol. The additional weight loss observed within this temperature range is attributed to the loss of surface-absorbed water. The isopropanol washing was effective in removing this water, as evidenced by a difference of -15% in the weight loss in this region. Continued weight loss occurs as the temperature is increased and the remaining carbonaceous material is removed. The differential thermal analysis (DTA) curve for the as-prepared PLZT powder is also included in Fig. 6. Dehydration of the powder results in the endotherm observed at 110°C. The exothermic peak at -340°C is attributed to the nucleation and growth of the very fine as-prepared particles to large crystallites. No further peaks were observed while heating to 1200°C. When the ple was cooled and rerun, no additional peaks were noted, indicating retention the crystalline phase as formed. The microstructure, typical a PLZT body prepared by cold pressing and sinteringunderthestated experimental conditions, is showninFig.7a;the compact was thermally etched at 800°C for 30 minutes. The fine-grained microstructure is quite uniform, with internal and grain boundary porosity virtually nonexistent. Bodies fabricated similarly but sintered at higher temperatures
30
r
I
252 5.
-
200 . 2 v)
_"
-
I
!2
I
/ /
K L IO O -
"_"".
L
Bzz
S
O
; 0 2 b o 2('c) ;0&&4bosso I
TG
of
PLZT
TG and DTA of akoxy-derived PLZT powder.
I
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
89
(W 7 Scanning electron microscopy (SEM):typical microstructure PLZT prepared by cold pressing and sintering at (a) 1120OC for 8 h and (b) 1220°C for 4 h.
MAHETAL.
90
(<1200"C), exhibited a microstructure with a much larger grain size (Fig. 7b) and no significant improvement in optical quality. Titanates. Various types of titanate powders, both doped and undoped, were synthesized through the simultaneous hydrolytic decomposition of appropriate metal alkoxides. One of the important concerns for the development of ferroelectric materials, such as BaTiO3, are the impurities. Although the presence of such impurities may not be a priori adverse, it is important to understand their influence on the final properties or to eliminate them completely, if necessary. The metal alkoxide processing is appropriate tosatisfy these purposes by controlled doping of certain elements to ultrapure material. Stoichiometric highpurity submicrometer BaTi03 powders were prepared through a mixed-metal alkoxide process[43]. Titanium tetrakis-tertiary amyloxide wasprepared through the alcohol exchange method:
-
T i c 4 + 4C3H70H + 4NH3 Ti(OC3H7)4 + 4CsH110H
C6H6 Ti(OC3H7)4 + 4 N h C 1 5°C
reflux 24 h
Ti(OCsH11)4+ 4C3H7OH
The barium bis-isopropoxide waspreparedby the metal/alcohol reaction method. Appropriate amounts of these alkoxides were dissolved in a mutual solvent, such as isopropyl alcohol or benzene, for a barium and titanium molar ratio of :1. The solution was refluxed for 2 h with vigorous stirring before the hydrolysis reaction. Drops of deionized triply distilled water were slowly added to the solution, which was continuously stirred. The reaction was carried out in a COzfree atmosphere. The hydrated oxide was dried in vacuum or in a dry helium atmosphere at 50°C for 12 h. At this stage the oxide was a finely divided, stoichiometric titanate with 50-150 A (maximum agglomerate size
8 Transmission electron micrographs of BaTi03 powder (a) as prepared and (b) calcined at 700°C.
92
MAH
P A R T I C L E diameter,
Particle size distribution
SEM microstructure
high-purityBaTiO3.
deeplyetchedBaTi03.
ETAL.
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
93
type of material. The synthesis BaTiO3 powders doped with various rare earth oxides (e.g., La203, Nd203, and Sc2O3) has been reported The advantage of rare earth element doping to BaTiOs is that the grain size can be reduced considerably. TEiM replica photomicrograph (Fig. 11) of h 2 0 3 doped BaTiOs shows the absence of pores withinthe grains andthe grain boundaries. The microstructure shows a uniform fine grain size (1-1.5 pm). Furthermore, no segregation of a second phase or impurities are visible along the grain boundaries. However, the Sc203-doped BaTiOs specimens were relativelylowdensity g/cm3)and contained a second-phase dendritic structure with very small bubbles characteristic of a glassy phase. Yttria-Stabilized Zirconia and Hafnia XRD analysis over the temperature range upon heating the submicrometer ZrO2 powders synthesized through hydrolytic decomposition of Zr
Electronmicrograph of LazO3-doped BaTi03, cold pressedandsintered at 1300°C for 4 h in air.
MAHETAL. alkoxide, has been reported [46,47]. The following sequence of phases was observed as the temperature increased to 1200°C: amorphous, to metastable cubic, to metastable tetragonal, to tetragonal + monoclinic, to monoclinic + tetragonal, and finally to tetragonal. Calcination studies were undertaken to observe the growth of primary crystallites into large particles and the influence upon growth of tumbling in different atmospheres, such as air, oxygen, hydrogen, and vacuum [46-48]. Figures 12 and 13 are typical electron micrographs' showing, the effect of calcination at 500°C in air for 24 h without tumbling and calcination at 750°C in air for 24 h with tumbling, respectively. Tumbling is seen to be an effective method of controlling crystallite the atmospheric conditions have a negligible effect during the presintering stage of processing these powders. Similar experiments were carried out for Hf02[49], and DTA analysis showed the nucleation and growth of small crystallites at 420"C, leading to conversion to monoclinic HfO;! at 480°C. Y203-stabilized (6-7 mol%) ZIQ and HfO2 powder production and sinteringstudieshavebeencarriedout[50,51]. Zirconium, hafnium,and yttrium alkoxides were synthesized using one of the appropriate methods described previously. Hydrolytic decomposition followed by similar procedures have already been described. The typical particle size distribution of of Y2Os-stabilized (7 mol%) Hf02 after 24 h calcination at 750°C is shown in Fig. 14. The crystallite size was measured directly from the electron photomicrographs. The powder had a mean particle size of -30 nm; 90% of the particles were less than 35 nm in diameter.
air
Transmissionelectronmicrograph 24 h without tumbling.
ZrO2 powder calcined at
in
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
Am
95
,
13 Transmission electron micrograph of ZrO2powder calcined at air for 24 h with tumbling.
in
Rhodes and Haag studied the particle size distribution Y2Og-stabilized (6 mol%) ZrO2,and typical cumulative particle size distribution curves for two different batches powders are in Fig. 15, which is a common
MAHETAL..
-
I
-
-
LOT
F
90-
N t-
30-
I
IO -I -1
;r
-
5-
2I-
-
15 Particle
distribution
6.5 mol% Y203-ZrOz "zyttrite."
characteristic of most ceramic powders prepared by this technique. The effect of calcination temperature on the specific surface area (measuredby the Brunauer-Emmett-Teller (BET) method) of the Y203-stabilized Hf02 is shown in Fig. The as-prepared powders are extremely active, with surface areas of 210 m2/g. The surface area decreased rapidly up to 40O0C, mainly because
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
of the nucleation and growth of thefine particles to large crystallites. From to 750"C, the surface area decreased only slightly to 120 m2/g. Above 800"C, the surface area decreased rapidly with increasing temperature to 10 m2/g at This curve suggests that a calcination temperature of is desirable to retain a relatively highly surface-active powder for the best sintering results. Figures 17 and 18 show the microstructures of a ZrO2 with 6 mol% Y2O3 (sintered at 1500°C for h) and Hf@ with 7 mol% Y203 (sintered at for h). The electron photomicrographs show negligible internal porosity and insignificant porosity at the grain boundaries. These materials sintered to the excess of of theoretical densities in a matter of few minutes at several hundred degrees lower thannecessary for the conventional ceramic powder routes. Both materials are fine grained, and the grain sizes ranged from 2 to 5 pm. Such grain sizes and microstructures ordinarily cannot be obtained for oxides as refractory as ZrO2 or HfO2, which are typically sintered at temperatures ranging from 1800 to and firing times of 24-48 h or longer. Such a conventional sintering process makes achivement of low porosity concomitant while maintaining a fine, uniform grain size extremely difficult.
MAHETAL.
i
17
Electron micrograph (replica ' E M ) of cold-pressed and sintered
mol%
Y203-zr02.
Y3A1501-2 (Yttrium Aluminum Garnet, YAG) Numerous reports [53-62] regarding the synthesis of YAG have appeared in the literature, and in most cases the final product was either a mixture of various yttrium aluminate phases or stoichiometric YAG of undesirably large particle size. The phase inhomogeneity in the final product, through alkoxide processing, was caused by the formation a Y-A1 double alkoxide, which is a very stable compound and, hence, extremely resistant to hydrolysis [63]. For the Y and A1 isopropoxides, the two react to a stable Y-A1 double isopropoxide according to the reaction Y(OiPr)3 + 3Al(OiPr)3
-
Y[Al(OiPr)&
The formation of this double alkoxide further complicates the precursor chemistryinvolved in the synthesis. Since Y and A1 isopropoxides are initially mixed in a ratio corresponding to the stoichiometry of YAG ( 3 5 = Y/Al), the reaction between the two alkoxides results in a solution containing a mixture of Y-Al double isopropoxide (1:3) and excess Y-isopropoxide. During hydrolysis, Y-isopropoxide hydrolyzes much faster than the double alkoxide, causing precipitation of Y-(OH)x to occur, which eventually leads to inhomogeneity in the final product.
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
99
I
18 Electronmicrograph(replica "EM) of cold-pressed andsintered 7 mol% Y203-Hf02.
27Al nuclear magnetic resonance ( N M R ) studies revealed that the coordination of aluminum in the mixture of yttrium and aluminum isopropoxides was predominantly tetrahedral, suggesting the formation of a Y-AI double alkoxide avoid the double alkoxide formation, one of the isopropyl groups was replaced by ethyl acetoacetate (EAA) to reduce the reactivity of yttrium isopropoxide with aluminum isopropoxide. Equimolar quantities of yttrium isopropoxide and ethyl acetoacetate were mixed and refluxed under isopropanol for 6 h. This solution was then added to a stoichiometrically measured amount of aluminum isopropoxide. *TA1 NMR spectra of Al-isopropoxide mixed with EAA-modifiedY-isopropoxideshowed no evidence of the formation ofthe double alkoxide. Infrared spectroscopy provided convincing evidence for the substitution of the isopropyl group. Hydrolysis of the solution mixture was carried out by the dropwise addition of the alkoxide into a water (excess)-isopropanol bath at room temperature. The transparent sol was then aged for h to allow condensation to occur. Fourier transforminfraredspectroscopy showed that during hydrolysis, isopropyl groups were the first to be removed.
MAHETAL..
l00
The gel obtained was then treated to evaporate the solvent, dried at 125°C for 8 h, and calcined at 950°C for 1 h. X-ray diffraction analysis of the powder obtained showed peaks corresponding to single-phase crystalline YAG. Complementing the x-ray results, DTA analysis showed only one exothermic peak occurring at 920"C, corresponding to the formation of YAG. The resulting powder is very fine (submicrometer) and, more importantly, is a single phase.
IV. SUMMARYAND CONCLUSIONS Powder synthesis using the alkoxy precursor technique exhibits processing flexibility not available in traditional high-temperature solid-state reaction of the mechanicallymixed,andmilled oxides and/or the inorganic salt constituents. With proper process control, impurities can be reduced to very low levels, yielding the desired electrical, optical, thermal, and mechanical properties. In addition, selected elements may be purposelyadded in controlled amounts to influence these properties. The alkoxide decomposition process for the preparation of single-phase and homogeneous mixed oxides of high purity and fine grain size has been demonstrated and extended to include a variety of mixed-phase systems. Extremely high purity, in excess of 99.95%, can be obtained for a wide variety of oxides. Particle size ranges below 50 nm are easily achieved while maintaining this exceptionally high level of purity for noncrystalline glasses and crystalline oxide ceramics. Because of the high reactivity of the alkoxy-derived powders, low processing temperatures can be used to densify oxide monolith or as matrices for fibrous reinforced ceramic composites with very fine grain size. In addition to processing advantages, dopants can be added more easily in the liquid phase, resulting in a composition tailored to the user's need. The control over purity and homogeneity afforded by alkoxy-derived powderprocessing allows control of the characteristics of the grain boundaries, which are likely to be central to the issues of electrical, optical, and structural properties of ceramics at service temperatures. Finally, contrary to popular belief, chemically derived powder is an economically feasible and viable method for the production of large-volume raw material for manufacturing reliable high-performance, advanced high-technology ceramic components.
REFERENCES 1. Vincenzini, P. (ed.), Ceramic Powders. Proceedings of the 5th International Meet-
ing on Modem Ceramics Technologies, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1983. Messing, G.,Mazdiyasni, K. McCauley, J. W., andHaber, R. A. (eds.), Ceramic Powder Science, Advances in Ceramics, Vol. 21, American Ceramics ciety, Westerville, OH, 1987.
IO1
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS
Brinker, C. J., Clark, D. E., and Ulrich D.R. (eds.), Better Ceramics Through Chemistry I , M R S Symposium Proceedings, Vol. Pittsburgh, PA, Brinker, C. J., Clark, D. E., and Ulrich, D. R. (eds.), Better Ceramics Through Chemistry II, M R S Symposium Proceedings, Vol. Pittsburgh, PA, 5. Brinker, C. J., Clark, D. E., and Ulrich, D. R. (eds.), Better Ceramics Through Chemistry III, M R S Symposium Proceedings, Vol. Pittsburgh, PA, Zelinski, B. J. J., Brinker, C. J., Clark, D. E., and Ulrich, D. R. (eds.), Better CeramicsThroughChemistry N,MRSSymposiumProceedings,Vol. Pittsburgh, PA, Hench, L. L., and Ulrich, D. R., (eds.), Ultrastructure Processings of Ceramics, Glasses, and Composites, Wiley & Sons, New York, Hench, L. L., and Ulrich, D. R. (eds.), Science of Ceramic Chemical Processing, Wiley & Sons, New York, Mackenzie, J. D., and Ulrich, D. R. (eds.),Ultrastructure Processingof Advanced Ceramics, Wiley-Interscience, New York, Bradley,D.C.,Mehrotra,R.C.,andGaur,D.P., MetalAlkoxides, Academic Press, (London), Ller, R. K.,The Chemistry of Silica, Wiley & Sons, New York, Brinker, C. J., and Scherrer, G. W., Sol-Gel Science, Academic Press, San Diego, Bradley, D. C., Mehrotra, R. C., and Wardlaw, J., J . Chem. Soc., (London), Mazdiyasni, K.
Lynch, C. T., and Smith,
J.
J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 50,
Herman, D. F., U.S. Patents and Mazdiyasni, K. Lynch, C. T., and Smith, J. Inorg. Chem., 5, Brown, L. M., and Mazdiyasni, K. Inorg. Chem., Adkins, H.,and Cox, J., J. Am. Chem. Bradley, D. C., Mehrotra, R. C., and Wardlaw, J., J. Chem. Soc. (London), Mehrotra, R. C., J. Am. Chem. Soc., Lynch, C. T., Mazdiyasni, K. andSmith, J. in Decomposition of Organometallic Compounds to Refractory Ceramics, Metals and Metal Alloys(K. Mazdiyasni, ed.), University of Dayton Press, Dayton, OH, Mazdiyasni, K. Ceram. Int., Mazdiyasni, K. Lynch, C. T., and Smith, J. J. Am. Ceram. Soc., Yoldas, B. E., J. Mat. Cer. Sci., Dislich, H., Angew. Chem. Int., Ed. Engl., Dislich, H., in Transformation of Organometallics into Common and Exotic Materials (R. Laine, ed.),NATOAS1 Series E, No. Nijhof, Dordrecht, pp. Hemes, E. E.,and Mazdiyasni, K. S., in NASA Conference Publication (J. D. Buckley, d . ) , NASA, Langley, VA, pp.
MAHETAL..
102
28. Mazdiyasni, K. Paulick, L. A., and Hermes, E. E., in NASA Conference Publication 2406 (J. D. Buckley, ed.), NASA, Langley, VA, 1985, pp. 191-195. 29. Mehrotra,R. C., J . Non-Crystal. Solids, 100, 1(1988). 30. Jones, K., Davies,T.J.,Emblem, H.G., andParkes, P.,in MaterialsResearch Symp. Proceedings, Vol. 73 (C. J. Brinker, D. E. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA, 1986, pp. 11 1-1 16. 31. Somiya, Davis,R. F., andPask,J.A.(eds.), CeramicTransactions, Vol. 6, Mullite and Mullite Matrix Composites, American Ceramics Society, Westerville,
OH, 1990. 32. Symposium F MulliteProcessing,Structure,andProperties, 43rd PacificCoast Regional Meeting, Am. Cerum. Bull. 69(9), 1526 (1990). 33. Mazdiyasni, K. S., and Brown, L.M., J . Am. Cerum. 55(1l), 548(1972). 34. Paulick, L.A., Yu, Y. F., andMah, T., inAdvancesinCeramics,Vol. 21 (G. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41. 42. 43.
Messing, K. Mezdiyasni, J. W. McCauley, and R. A. Haber, eds.), American Ceramics Society, Westerville, OH, 1987, pp. 121-129. Keefer, K.D., inMaterialsResearch Symp.Proc.,Vol. 32, MaterialsResearch Society, Pittsburgh, PA, 1984, p. 15. Thomas, I. M., U.S. Patent 3,791,808(1974). Yoldas, B. E., J . Muter. Sci., 12, 1203 (1977). Yoldas, B. E., J . Muter. Sci., 1843 (1979). Brinker, C. J., and Mukerjee, P., J . Muter. Sci., 16, 1980 (1981). Brown, L. M., and Mazdiyasni, K. J . Am. Cerum. 55(1l), 541(1972). Haertling, G. H., and Land, C. E., J. Am. Cerum. %(l), 1 (1971). Haertling, G.H., J . Am. Cerum. 54(6), 303 (1971). Mazdiyasni, K. Dolloff, R. F., and Smith, J. J . Am. Cerum. 52(10),
523 (1969). 44. Mazdiyasni, K. and Brown, L. M., J. Am. Cerum. 54(1l), 539 (1971). 45. Mazdiyasni, K. and Brown, L.M., Am. Cerum. 55(12), 633 (1972). 46. Mazdiyasni, K. Lynch, C. T., and Smith, J. J. Am. Cerum. 49(5), 286 (1966). 47. Phillippi, C. M., and Mazdiyasni, K. J . Am. Cerum. 54(5), 254 (1971). 48. Mazdiyasni, K. in M R S Symposium Proceedings, Vol. 32 (C. J. Brinker, D. E. Clark,and D. R. Ulrich,eds.),MaterialsResearchSociety,Pittsburgh,PA, 1984, pp. 175-186. 49. Mazdiyasni, K. and Brown, L. M., J. Am. Cerum. 53(1), 43 (1970). 50. Mazdiyasni,K. Lynch,C.T.,andSmith,J. J . Am. Cerum. 50(10),
532 (1967). 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56.
Brown, L. M., and Mazdiyasni, K. J. Am. Cerum. 53(1l), 590 (1970). Rhodes, W. H., and Haag, R.M., Tech. Report AFML-TR-70-209(1970). Messier, D.R.,and Gazza, G. E., Am. Cerum. Bull., 51(9), 692 (1972). De With, G., and van Dijk, H.J.A., Muter. Res. Bull., 19, 1669 (1984). Takamori, T., and David, L.D. Am. Cerum. Bull., 65(9), 1282 (1986). Hardy, A.B., Gowda,G.,McMahon, T. J.,Riman,R.E., Rhine, W. E., and
I03
MULTICOMPONENT CERAMIC POWDERS Bowen, H.K., in UlwaswuctureProcessing of AdvancedCeramics MacKenzieandD. R. Ulrich,eds.),WileyandSons, NewYork,
(J.D. pp.
De With, G., Philips J. Res., Haneda, H., Watanabe, A., Matsuda, S., Sakai, T., Shirasaki, S., and Yamamura, H.,in Proc. International Symposium on Science and Technology of Sintering,Tokyo,Japan (S. Somiya, M. Shimada, M. Yoshimura,and R. Watanabe. eds.), pp. Inoue, M., Otsu, H., Kominami, H., and Inui, T.,J. Am. Ceram. Yamaguchi, O., Takeoka,K.,andHayashida,
A., J. Mater. Sci. Lett., 10, 101
Yamaguchi, O., Takeoka, K., Hirota, Takano, H., and Hayashida, A., J . Mater. Sci., Apte, P., Burke, H., and Pickup, H., J . Mater. Res., Sambasivan, S., Keller, K., Sim, S., and Mah, T., J. Mater. Sci., in press
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
5 Chemical Synthesis of Nonoxides Christian Russel Universitit Jena Jena, Germany
Michael Seibold OSRAM GmbH Augsburg, Germany
INTRODUCTION In the last two decades a great deal of interest has been focused on nonoxide ceramics (see, e.g., Refs. 1-5) that is mainly because of their potential use as high-temperature, high-strength materials. The main efforts have been conducted in the field of silicon carbide and nitride ceramics. In addition, aluminum nitride has attracted attention because of its high thermal conductivity, whichwillbecomeincreasinglyvitalin future substrate applications. Other nonoxides, such as boron carbide and various transition metal carbides, nitrides, and borides, are prospective materials for cutting tools and grinding media. All these nonoxides exhibit strong covalent bonding, high strength, and high hardness. They are extremely difficult to sinter because of low self-diffusion coefficients. Therefore, most of the nonoxide powders must be densified either by hot pressing or by using sintering additives. The fabrication of dense ceramics by hot pressing or hot isostatic pressing methods need extensive equipment. The high-temperature properties, however, are preserved. Sintering additives lead inmany cases to the presence ofglassy phases within the microstructure and hence harmed mechanical properties, such as reduced hightemperature strength. Until recently, the industrial production of nonoxide powders was predominantly based on two different high-temperature processes: carbothermal re105
106
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD
duction [6,7] and direct synthesis from the elements. In the past few years, routes via the gas phase, which are also high-temperature or even plasma reactions, have increasingly been investigated. Powders synthesized at high temperatures show low sinterability caused by large crystallite sizes. Generally they cannot be pressurelessly densified without sintering additives. Moreover, routes via tractable polymer precursors have been studied. They can be used for the production of ceramic fibers, coatings, and monoliths and also for the formation of powders with tailored morphology and hence high sinteractivity. In contrast to oxides, no common reaction path for the synthesis of nonoxide ceramics via tractable precursors is yet known. Therefore, in the past few years many different synthesis reaction schemes for both nitrides and carbides have been discussed in the literature. Although silicon carbide and nitride have been under intense investigation (e.g., Ref. l), many other reactions leading to other nonoxides, such as aluminum nitride, boron nitride, boron carbide, and some transition metal carbides and nitrides, have been reported (e.g., Refs. 1-5). Polymeric compounds even allow the pressureless densification of nonoxide powders without the use of sintering additives in some cases.
II. HIGH-TEMPERATUREROUTES TO NONOXIDES Three main processing schemes for the formation of nonoxide ceramics are known, carbothermal reaction, direct synthesis, and gas-phase synthesis, which usually require reaction temperatures well above 1200°C. Carbothermal reaction as well as the direct synthesis from the elements can be varied over a wide range byusing different carbon sources, such as graphite or other carbon sources.
A.
Carbothermal Reduction
Conventional routes are high-temperature processes that usually require temperatures ranging from 1200 to 1600°C. Oxides and carbon are used as ing compounds, and the reactions are carried out in a nitrogen or inert gas atmosphere for the formation of nitrides (e.g., Refs.6 and 7) and carbides [8-IO], respectively.
It has been mentioned that this reaction can be carried out not only using elemental carbon but also withany carbon precursor, such as phenolic resins. They provide a more intensified mixing of the starting sources. Another varia-
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
I07
tion of this method is the combined use of sol-gel technique together with complexation agents, such as furfuryl alcohol [IO], which act as the carbon source during calcination. This method has been used for the formation of TiN and favors much lower formation temperatures than usually required.
Direct Another common route for the production of both nitride and carbide powders is direct synthesis from the elements. For the formation of nitrides, the elements are heated in a nitrogen atmosphere. Me + $N2
MeNx
All nitrides suitable for potential application in the field of materials science show a highly negative Gibbs free enthalpy of reaction according to Eq. (3). Kinetic hindrances, must be considered, however. This gains importance if the metal of focus exhibits a low melting point; in this case the nitridation temperatures are usually restricted below this value. Formation of aluminum nitride, for example, using this method is difficult to achieve because at temperatures belowthe melting point the nitridation rate is far too low for a commercial process. In Ref. 12, however, an interesting pathway is shown: a thin aluminum nitride layer was formed by nitridating at temperatures below the melting point at the surfaces of very finely grained aluminum powder; the temperature was subsequently raised above the melting point, and the nitridation process was completed. Notethat nitridation is a diffusion-controlled process, and hence the temperature cannot be raised until the thickness of the nitride layer around every aluminum particle prevents joining of the aluminum particles. Nitridation of other elements, such as boron, silicon, or transition metals, can easily be achieved at temperatures below the melting point. From a kinetic point of view, the particle size should be as small as possible. The surface of each particle is covered by a thin oxide layer, however, leading to oxygen contamination. In contrast to carbothermal reactions, direct nitridation does not entail an oxygen removal mechanism. Using coarse particles, however, requires remarkably higher temperatures or soaking times. For silicon the reaction rates strongly depend on the amount of impurities To obtain carbides, the elements are heated together with elemental carbon or another carbon source in an inert gas atmosphere. Me + XC ”+ MeC, Phenolic resins or many other C-containing compounds can be used for this purpose
108
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD
C.Gas-PhaseReactions Gas-phase reactions for the formation of nonoxide powders have been known for a long time. In the last few years many of these routes were reinvestigated and other precursors have been developed. This is mainly because of their potential to yieldvery fine grained nonoxides, withmean grain sizes in the nanometer range. Routes via the gas phase have also been intensively studied for the direct formation of coatings that is, CVD (chemical vapor deposition). All reaction paths basically considered as a CVD process can be tailored for the formation of powders; the processing parameters must be optimized. Metal halides with covalent bonding, which thus can be easily evaporated, and ammonia [14,15]are used. MeX,
4n + -NI43
MeN,D
+ nNH4X
The productionofsiliconnitride [16,17]andaluminumnitride [18-211 has been extensively studied; plasma reactions [21-231 were also reported. Instead of ammonia nitrogen may be used [24,25].Hydrocarbons and metal halides for the formation of carbides are worth mentioning [26,27].
POLYMERIC ROUTES TO MAIN GROUP ELEMENT CARBIDES A.
Silicon Carbide
mentioned, the sinterability of pure silicon carbide strongly depends on the properties of the powder used. Powders made by high-temperature routes are predominantly composed of different hexagonal Sic polytypes (e.g., 2H, 4H, and 6H). Incontrast, S i c produced by polymeric routes almost exclusively consists of p-Sic. In principle, Sic can be formed by the pyrolysis of either polysilanes or polycarbosilanes. The preparation of polysilanes is described in detail in Chap. 2 and was first reported by Kipling in 1924 [28]. The concept most commonly used now was developed by Yajima et al. [29],who used dimethylchlorosilane as a starting substance.
R
I I
Cl-Si-Cl
+Me
R Alkali metals and Me (liquid Na/K alloys are frequently cited [29-321) act as reducing agents of the chlorosilanes. It has been found that the polysilane
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
109
transforms to a polycarbosilane [see Eq. (7) and Refs. 2,4, and 29-32] during thermal treatment.
In the past few years, similar reactions using numerous dichlorosilane derivatives were investigated to yield preceramic polymers. Some routes use several different types of chlorosilanes as starting materials (e.g., Refs. 33-35) Analogous to the preparation of polysilanes, polycarbosilanes can also be synthesized using a similar route. Alkyl chloroalkyl chlorosilanes are used as starting materials for this purpose [2]. R
I I
Cl"si"CH2Cl+
Na, K
(8)
R The reduction of dichlorosilanes or chloroalkyl chlorosilanes stimulates the formation of linear chains, whereas the same reaction using trichlorosilanes or similar compounds may support cross-linked products. Cross-linking can also be obtained by the use of vinyl silanes [33-351 or Si-H-modified compounds. silylation reaction occurs at higher temperatures, also leading to branched products. Routes via polysilanes or polycarbosilanes favor products with comparably low molecular weight in many cases (Fig. During calcination, high quantities silicon compounds are evaporated and subsequently low ceramic yields are obtained. A notable weight increase in the ceramic residue is sometimes found if the pyrolysis is carried out under either reflux or pressure (see, e.g., Ref. 2). High ceramic yields are derived only with highly cross-linked polymeric products, whereas high molecular weights are not a sufficient prerequisite. A high amount cross-linking can be achieved by using trichlorosilanes, chloroalkyl dichlorosilanes, and Si-H- and vinyl-modified compounds. For example, the reaction of ClCH2Si(CH3)2Cl with metallic potassium results in only traces of S i c [2]; the reaction of bothClCH2Si(CH3)2Cl and CH3SiCl3 yields ceramic residues of 30.8 wt% [34]. Coreduction of (CH3)3SiCl, (CH3)2SiCH=CH2, and (CH3)SiHClz with potassium allows a ceramic yield of 57 wt% [34]. In some cases, the use of dichlorosilanes containing aromatic substituents has led to an increase in ceramic product: for example, for the coreduction of(CH3)2SiC12 and (C&)2SiC12 with sodium, a ceramic yield was observed [2].
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD
- " a
4
2
-2
chemical shift. ppm 29Si nuclear magnetic resonance spectra of different polycarbosilane precursors (molecular weight distributions Mnranging from 320 to 1750) with respect to treatment temperatures.
The pyrolysisof polysilanes and polycarbosilanes is usually carried out using inert gas (e.g., argon) as pyrolysis atmosphere. A general problem asse ciated with the pyrolytic formation of carbides is the desired stoichiometry of the calcined products: in contrast to nitrides, excess carbon cannot be evape rated during calcining; it may therefore contaminate the powders obtained as an elemental impurity and thus influences the physical, especially mechanical and electrical, properties of the sintered ceramic bodies. The volatiles evaporated during pyrolytic treatment of carbosilanes to form a network structure are H2 and CH4, and they depend onthe structure of the polycarbosilane used (Fig.2).
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
112
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD
Silicon-containing volatile compounds are predominantly SiH4 and H3SiCH4. High cross-linking, however, suppresses the evaporation of Si compounds.
B.
Boron Carbide
Some routes for the preparation of boron carbide ceramics were investigated recently. The highest ceramic yield (80 wt%) was obtained using the thermal decomposition of boronylpyridine. Other routes, such as the pyrolysis of triphenyl boron or 1,2-C2BloH12,resulted in ceramic yields of only 2 and 4 wt%, respectively It should be said that many boron nitride precursors also yield boron carbide if calcined in an inert gas atmosphere.
W. POLYMERICROUTES TO MAIN GROUP ELEMENT NITRIDES A.Silicon
Nitride
Silicon nitride has found many applications in which structural features play an important role. Conventionally derived silicon nitride is fairly difficult to sinter, and pressureless sintering requires large amounts of sintering aids (e.g., 8% A1203 and 2% Y203). The fiist “chemical route”, which has been applied for the formation of silicon nitride at comparably low temperature, is diimid precipitation, already reported in During the reaction of silicon tetrachloride with liquid ammonia, the intermediate, Si(NH2)4 was presumed. precipitation of different polymeric products [e.g., the diimid, Si(NH)2] subsequently occurs, which finally yields silicon nitride. This reaction involves a multiple-step mechanism. Simplified chemical reactions are shown in Eqs. to (for a more detailed description, see, e.g., Refs. 37-40). Sic14 Si(NH2)4 + 8NH3
+4 m C l
Equation (9) shows that high quantities of ammonium chloride are formed during the reaction that must be evaporated during calcining. In addition, a highly exothermic reaction is much easier to control if a solvent, such as n-hexane is used. The required formation temperature of only is fairly low. Until recently, diimid precipitation has been the focused of numerous papers,
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
I13
and in principle the formation of Si3N4, with much better sintering properties than conventionally produced powders, is possible. One should take into consideration that the precipitate is completely insoluble, however, and therefore, the formation of powders with controlled morphology is difficult and must be determined by the first reaction step. The route does not enable the production of fibers or coatings. Routes via polysilazanes, in contrast, lead to soluble or fusible intermediates that are prerequisites for the formation of coatings and fibers. Although a route enabling the formation of polysilazanes was already reported by Stock in 1921 [41], numerous routes, all leading to polysilazane intermediates, have been discussed in the literature only recently [4249]. Dichlorosilanes and ammonia or alkyl amines are used as starting compounds. R
I I
Cl-Si-Cl
+ 3NH3
(12)
_j
R Inanalogy to the formation of polysilanes, products with low molecular weights are obtained, usuallya mixture of cyclomers (with n = 3-6) and oligomers (with n < 10). Pyrolysis of these products thus leads to the evaporation of silicon-containing compounds and, in many cases, to almost negligible ceramic yields. Cross-linking andhigher molecular weights in principle can be obtained by using trichlorosilanes and vinyl- or Si-H-modified starting materials. The chemical reactions that occur are summarized in Eqs. (13) and (14). These reactions, in principle, might be used to tailor the polysilazane structures, similar to the chemistry of polysiloxanes
I
I
Cl-Si-Cl
+ 3nC1-Si-C1I
c1
R
I
-m
I -Si-CH=CH2+H-SiI R
F
R
R
M12R,
-NH3RCl
I I
].
N-Si N-Si-N Si-N
-NH
l I
"Si-CH2-CH2-Si-
R
(13)
I I
114
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD
Further cross-linking reactions, leading to products of high molecular weight, have been reported by Seyferth et al. [1,50]. Thus the formation of two-dimensional linked polymers occurs if low-molecular-weight oligomers containing Si-H and N-H bonds have reacted with potassium hydride (residual potassium hydride can be removed by adding CHJ). High ceramic yields of about 85 wt% furthermore prove the necessity for cross-linked structures. Equation (15) shows the reaction mechanism proposed by Seyferth et al. The initial oligomer was synthesized byadding ammonia to chlorosilane and converted without further cross-linking into a negligible quantity of ceramic products during calcining.
Another method for the formation of cross-linked products is the catalytic dehydrogenation of Si-H and N-H bonds using Ru3(C0)12 as a catalyst [43].
R
I
H-Si-H I
H
+
x[RSiHNH],
_j
[RSiHNH],
(16)
Catalyst
I
I1
with R = phenyl, ethyl, or hexyl. The reaction mechanism was assumed as follows: first linear intermediates (I) and subsequently bridged, branched, or ring polymers (11) are formed (for a detailed discussion, see Ref. 43). Because of the high degree of cross-linking, high ceramic yields are obtained. Similar to polysilanes in terms of synthesis and calcination behavior, a large varietyof polysilazanes have already beenreported. The condensation of CH3NH2 with (CH3)2SiC12 or H2SiC12 resulted in ceramic yields of about 40% [47,51]. When HSiC13 and [Si(CH3)3]2NHwere used, the ceramic yield was in the range of 70-90% [44,49]. Using hydrazine N2H4 as a nitrogen donor and triethylamine instead of [Si(CH3)3]2NH ammonia, the ceramic yields were 72% with HCH3SiC12 as chlorosilane compound (Fig. 3) [47]. With the method of
115
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
too W &-
cc
2
40
l000 temperature, 'C
3 Thermogravirnetric analysis of a polysilylhydrazine precusor, pyrolyzed in nitrogen atmosphere. Seyferth using potassium hydride to stimulate higher degrees of cross-linking, ceramic yields of 85% could be achieved [1,51]. The pyrolysis of polysilazanes results in fairly different chemical compositions of the residue; the calcination gas is varied. Although this effect strongly depends on the type of polysilazane, some more or less general conclusions can be drawn. Calcining in an inert gas atmosphere, such as argon, results in the formation of a highly carbon-contaminatedsilicon nitride or even in SiC/Si3N4 composites or solid solutions, depending on the calcination temperature. In contrast, if the calcination is carried out in ammonia or nitrogen, the product is pure silicon nitride. The formation of oxynitrides can be achieved by calcining in nitrogen atmosphere with substantial oxygen content or by oxidizing the polysilazane before or after calcining in nitrogen (Fig. The main weight loss during calcination usually occurs in the temperature range between 200 and 6OO0C, strongly depending on the type of polysilazane used. For example, polyphenylsilazane exhibits its mainweight loss in a temperature range of 350-600"C; poly-(N-methy1)silazane loses weight in a two-stepprocess at temperatures of about 250 and 380°C (Fig. 5).
Aluminum nitride powder synthesized by high-temperature routes can be sintered to a density of more than 97% of the theoretical density by adding calcium or yttrium compounds as sintering aids Therefore, new processing routes to aluminum nitride predominantlyaim at powderswith lower quantities of cationic impurities. In addition, the formation of aluminum nitride coatings [S-581 or fibers [59] has become subject of extensive research.
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD 8OO0C " " . = . W
/
.-5 .-
1700OC
40
35
30
25
20
l5
BR4GG angle, degrees
4 X-raydiffraction ( X R D ) patterns of a polysilazane-polysiloxane polymer with respect to different pyrolysis temperatures.
The first low-temperature route for the formation of aluminum nitride was discovered in the 1950s by Wiberg with Amberger and May [60,61]. Three-dimensionallypolycondensed iminoalanes [e.g., Al(NR)l.s] are formed using aluminum hydride and ammonia or primary organic amines as starting materials. It should be added that aluminum hydride is extremely difficult to handle
I17
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
Q
5:
a temperature, 'C
5 TGA profile of a phenyl-substituted polysilazane (x) compared with hexyl groups containing polymers. because of its sensitivity to air and moisture. Nevertheless, these routes have been reinvestigated during the last few years Fairly similar reactions can be carried out using aluminum alkyls as initial compounds AIR'3
+ 3NH2R
-3RH
Al(NHR)3
-1SNH2R
'A(m)1.5
with R' and R = H or alkyl. Tractable AlN precursors cannot be produced by adding aluminum chloride to ammonia or primary amines because, in contrast to silicon chloride, a substitution does not occur and different adducts (AlCl3 with x < are formed, which can be evaporated without decomposition. If, alkali amides are used instead of ammonia or amines, however, the substitution takes place and highly polycondensed polyiminoalanes are formed
-
3KNH2
+ AlCl3
-3KCl
AI(NH2)3
-1SNH3
'Al(m)1.5
(18)
Polyiminoalanes can also be synthesized using a high-pressure route, first reported by Cucinella et al. Another, fairly different route was recently reported by Schleich condensation of the starting materials, hexamethylsilazane and aluminum chloride, resulted in the formation of the dimeric and soluble compound ClAlNHSi(CHs)3. By heating to temperatures above 20O0C,ClSi(CH3)3 is evaporated and the polymeric compound (CIAINNH)n is formed, which can be transformed to aluminum nitride by calcining in
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD
118
an inert gas atmosphere. This route involves the disadvantage that silicon contamination cannot be completely avoided. Calcining polyiminoalanes usually results in the formation of aluminum nitride at comparably low temperatures. If the calcination is carried out in ammonia, carbon contamination is easier to avoid, calcining in argon usually results in the formation of black carbonaceous residues in the range of 10-20 carbon. In general, crystallization is promoted by using ammonia and is prevented if argon is used.
C. Most routes to boron nitride referred to in literature make use of borazole derivatives [4,73-801. A large variety of different ligands, R and R’, have already been mentioned.
R
I
N
R-B’
‘B-R
The easiest way to obtain boron nitride from these precursors involves only heat treatment: for example, borazoles undergo condensation reactions without previous evaporation. The ligand R should either be -NH2 or NHR, and a variety of different ligands R’ are possible. The ceramic yields are found in the range of 26% (R’ = H, R = NHCsHs [4]) and 55% (R’ = H, R = NH2 [4]). Although the starting materials themselves are not polymeric, comparably high ceramic yields are obtained. With R’ = SiR3 and R = NH2, spinnable compounds have been obtained, which might open up possibilities for the formation of boron nitride fibers. In some cases, the formation of white boron nitride with relatively a low oxygen and carbon content could be achieved [75]. Recently, the preparation ofwhiteboron nitride from polyborazylene wasreported [79,80]. Infrared spectra (Fig. 6) of pyrolyzed residues were found to be close to those reported for CVD samples hexagonal boron nitride. For the B-chloroborazoles (R = Cl), however, the use of condensating agents is required. Either [(CH3)3Si]2NR [73,77,78] or(CH3)Si-C = CSi(CH3)3 [73] have already found use. The borazole rings are connected via BNR-B and B - M - B bonds, respectively, and trichlorosilane [73,76] is formed. In some cases, a solid of gellike consistency is obtained. Calcining of these polymers leads to relatively high degree of carbon contamination, even in an ammonia atmosphere. Calcining under inert gas often results in the formation BN/B4C composites with desirable properties.
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
I19
wavenumbers, cm”
6 Infraredspectrum of a themolyzed borazeneoligomerheated in vacuum to 275OC.
In analogy the route of Wiberg for the formation of polyiminoalanes and subsequently of aluminum nitride [61], NaBH4, BCb, and ammonia may be used as starting materials. The intermediate formation of diborane, B2H6, was assumed [81] in this case.
The polymeric compound (BNH2),, is formed as an intermediate and may be thermally decomposed to boron nitride. The synthesis is difficult to carry out because all compounds and intermediates are extremely sensitive to air and moisture. Polymeric adducts of decaboranes, B10H12, are used in many other studies. Diphosphines or diamines (L”) [81-SS] could act as condensating agents that favor the formation of B-L”L-B groups. Most of these polymers are stable toward oxidation and hydrolysis and soluble in polar organic solvents, such as dimethylformamide ( D m or hexamethylphosphorus triamide (HMPT). During pyrolysis in either ammonia or argon, white boron nitride in 70% ceramic yieldand boron carbonitride with ceramic yields ofup to 90% are formed, respectively.
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD
120
V.
POLYMERICROUTES TO TRANSITIONELEMENT CARBIDES AND NITRIDES
Transition element carbides and nitrides are applied as cutting tools because of their extreme hardness and wear resistance. In some cases nitrides and carbides (e.g.,of titanium) form solid solutions over the entire compositional range; other transition metal nitrides and carbides exhibit fairly different structures and are not completely soluble. Carbon contents within the range of few percentage points usually do not influence the mechanical properties of transition metal nitrides, and vice versa. Hence, completely carbon-free nitrides or nitrogen-free carbides are not required, especially for the titanium compounds. Until now, polymeric routes to transition metal nitrides or carbides have not been as numerously reported in the literature as those of the main group elements. They have been developed in most cases to produce thin coatings on various substrates or fibers. Seyferth and h4ignari [86] reported a route to titanium nitride and titanium carbide via tetrakis-dialkylamine titanium compounds. A polymeric or oligomeric product can be obtained by substituting the secondary amine by a primary amine [87,88]. The initially formed tetrakis-alkylamine polycondenses and leads a double-bridged polymer or oligomer. Calcining in argon or ammonia results in the formation of titanium carbide or titanium nitride, respectively.
I
R
I
R
I
R
I
R
Analogously to silicon nitride, titanium nitride precursors can also be prepared by the reaction of titanium tetrachloride with fluid ammonia [89,90]. This leads to the precipitation of highly polymeric products, which can be transferred to metal nitrides or carbonitrides by calcining in ammonia or an inert gas atmosphere. Zirconium and niobiumpolymers were prepared by fairly similar routes, the ammonolysis of the tetrakis-dialkylamines [88] or the chlorides [89,90] in liquid ammonia. After pyrolysis, nitrides or carbonitrides were obtained in high ceramic yields. The formation of titanium nitrides or carbonitrides via the calcination of titanium acetilides, such as Ti4(C=C)(NH)7 or NaTi4(W)(NH)7NH2 at temperatures 8OOOC was reported by Maya [91].
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
121
It should be mentioned that sol-gel routes have also been described in the literature, which finally yield titanium nitride [l l]. Additives, such as furfuryl alcohols, are used in this case, which decompose during the calcination in ammonia and form amorphous carbon. Subsequently carbothermic reactions occur, and finally titanium nitride is formed.
VI.
ELECTROCHEMICAL ROUTES TO CARBIDES AND NITRIDES
A large variety of precursors have been prepared lately with an electrochemical route [92-991. The metal is anodically dissolved in an organic electrolyte, which can be directly converted into a ceramic coating [55-581 or powder without further purification. The method was first reported by Seibold and Russel [92] for the formation of aluminum nitride, who used an electrolyte consisting of propylamine, acetonitrile, and tetrabutylammoniumbromide as a supporting electrolyte to achieve sufficient electrical conductivity. The electrodes were formed by sheets of various metals. The assumed chemical reactions at the electrodes are as follows: Me xNH2R + xexNH2R + Me
-
MeX++ exNHR- + H2
+Me(=),
x2
+ ;H2
The metal is oxidized at the anode, the propylamine is reduced at the cathode, and the corresponding anion and gaseous hydrogen are formed. As an intermediate, monomeric Me(NHR), is assumed. These intermediates condense to oligomeric or polymeric compounds.
The electrolytes were dried and subsequently calcined. The main weight loss occurs at temperatures in the range of 150-350°C (e.g.,Ref.92).A further slight weight loss occurred up to 550"C, and then the weight remained nearly constant. It should be noted that the thermogravimetric analysis TGA profiles were fairly similar and only slightly influenced by the type of metal. The ceramic yields, however, strongly depended on the type of metal used and were in the range of 20-50 wt% [92,96,98,99].
I22
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD
7 XRD patterns aluminum nitride precursors calcined in ammonia at differenttemperatures: (a) driedprecursor; (b) (c) 800OC; (d) and (e)
Allprecursors are amorphous up to calcination temperatures ofaround 600°C. At higher temperatures, in most cases powders with extremely small crystallite sizes of around 2 0 4 0 nm are formed (Fig. 7). A further increase in calcination temperature promotes crystal growth.Withaluminum nitride, a white powder with a low oxygen and carbon content is obtained [97]. Other main group element precursors exhibit fairly different behaviors: Mg and Ca precursors yield metal cyanamide [99]. Calcination of the transition element precursors (Fig. 8) results in the formation of nitrides, carbonitrides, or carbides. For the titanium-containing precursors, TiN/TiC solid solutions can be obtained [96]; the quantity of carbon strongly depends on the calcination atmosphere applied (argon, 31 wt%; ammonia, 5.1 wt%). In contrast, chromium-containing precursors are pyrolyzed in ammonia to CrN; calcining in argon leads to the formation of Cr3C2 [98]. Other products formed are ZrN, TaC, NbC, MoC, and WC. Y-containing precursors lead to the formation of YNTy0.45Co.55 mixtures (Table 1) [99]. Because of the small
CHEMICAL SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
70 *
60
50
40
30
20
28 (CUL)P
8 XRD patterns ceramicproductsobtainedaftercalcining:(a) CaCN2; (b) CrN (c) Cr3C2; (d) YN (open circles); Yo.45Co.55 (closed circles); and (e) TaC.
crystallite sizes, the powders obtained exhibit veryhighsinterability. already shown for aluminum nitride powders, pressureless sintering without the addition of sintering aids at results in densities > 98% of theoretical density (t.d.) The oxygen contents of the pyrolyzed powders were in the range of 1.5-2.0 wt% for aluminum nitride, calcium cyanamide, and the transition metal compounds investigated. The electrochemical synthesis of polymeric precursors is characterized by a broad versatility. Most of the metals can be handled easily and electrolytically dissolved and transferred into polymericprecursors; thus this processing scheme seems to be a general approach and an alternative to already known methods. In addition, all precursor solutions can be mixed with one another, and therefore a wide range of new composites or solid solutions is possible in the near future.
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD Table
NonoxidesDerivedbyElectrochemicallySynthesizedPrecursors
Metal dissolved Ceramic yield AI Ti
zr Cr
Ta Ca Mg Y
(%)
Calcination gas Product NH3 NH3 N2 NH3 NH3 N2
AIN TiN Ti(C, N) ZrN CrN
Ar
C4C2 TaC CaCN2 MgCN2
NH3 NH3 NH3 NH3
cm2
y0.45c0.55
Seyferth, D., Wiseman,G. H., Schwark, J. M., andYu,Y.-F., Am. Chem. 71, Wynne, K. J., and Rice, R. W., Annu. Rev. Mater. Sci., Rice, R.W., Am. Ceram. Bull., 62, Pouskopuleli, G.,Ceram. Int., 15, Walker, B. E., Rice, R.W., Becher, P. F., Bender B. A., and Coblenz, W. Am. Ceram. Bull., 62, Billy, M., Keramische Nitride und Oxinitride, Handbuch der Keramik II K Verlag Schrnid, Germany, Szweda, A., Hendry, A., and Jack, K. H.,Proc. Br. Ceram. 8. Mehrwald, K. M., Ber. Dtsch. Keram. Ges., 46, Harris, L. A., Kennedy, C. R., Wei, G. C., and Jeffers, F. P., J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 67, p. C Wei, G. C., Kennedy C. R., and Harris, L. A., Am. Ceram. Bull., 63, Kuroda, K., Tanaka, Y., Sugahara, Y., and Kat0 C., in (C. J. Brinker, D. E . Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Better Ceramics Through Chemistry Ill, M R S Proc. Vol. 121, Pittsburgh, PA, Belau, Muller, G., Ber. Dtsch. Keram Ges., 65, Haggerty, J. Lightfoot, A., Ritter, J. E., Nair, V., and Gennari, P., Ceram. Eng. Sci Proc., Grieco, M. J., Worthing, F. L., andSchwartz,B., J . Electrochem. 115, Kirnura, I., Hotta, N., Nukui,H.,Saoito,N.,andYasukawa, Lett., 7, Prochazka, and Creskovich, C., Am. Ceram. Bull., 57,
J . Mater.Sci.
CHEMICAL. SYNTHESIS OF NONOXIDES
i25
17. Bauer, R. A., Smulders, R., Brecht, J. G. M., van der Put, P. J., and Schoonman, J., J. Am. Cerum. Soc., 72, 1301 (1989). 18. Vissokov, G. P., and Brakalov, L. B., J . Muter. Sci., 18, 201 1 (1983). 19. Ishizaki, K., Egashira, T., Tanaka, K., and Celis, P. B., J . Muter. sei., 24, 3553 (1989). 20. Baba, K., Shohata, N., and Yonezawa, M., Appl. Phys. Lett., 54, 2309 (1989). 21. Ho, P., Buss, R. J., and Loehman, R. E., J. Muter. Res., 4, 873 (1989). 22. Okabe, Y., Hojo, J., and Kato, Yogyo Kyokuishi, 85, 173 (1977). 23. Schulz, O., Kanziora, D.,and Hausner, H.,(eds.) Ceramic Powder Processing Science, Roc. 1st Int. Conf. Ceramic Powders Processing Science, American Ceramics Society, Westerville, OH, 1988. 24. Somiya, Suzuki, K., and Yoshimura, M., Adv. Cerum., 21, 279 (1987). 25. Volpe, L., and Boudart, M., J. Solid State Chem., 59, 332 (1985). 26. Exell, F., Roggen, R., Gillot, J., and Lux, B., in 2nd Znt. Conf. Fine Particles, (W. E. Kuhn ed.), Electrochem. Pennington, NJ, (1974) p. 165. 27. Hojo, J., Oku, T., and Kato, A., J . Less Common Met., 59, 85 (1978). 28. Kipling, F., J . Chem. 125, 2291-2297 (1924). 29. Yajima, Hayashi J., and Omori, M., Chem. Lett., 931 (1975). 30. Yajima, Okamura, K., Hayashi,J.,and Omori M., J. Am. Cerum. 59 324-327 (1976). 31. Yajima, Hayashi, J., Omori, M.,and Okamura, K., Nature, 261, 683-685 (1976). 32. Ishikawa, T., Shibuya, M., and Yamamura T., J. Muter. Sci., 25, 2809 (1990). 33. Schilling, C. L., Wesson, J. P., and Williams, T. C., Am. Cerum. Bull., 62, 912-915 (1983). 34. Schilling, C. L., Br. Polym. J., 18, 355-358 (1986). 35. Schilling, C. L., Wessel, J. P., and Williams, T. C., J . Polym. Sci. Polym. Symp., 70, 121-128(1983). 36. Peroz, M., Ann. Chim. Phys., 44, 315 (1830). 37. Klemser, O., and Naumann, P., Z. Anorg. Allg. Chem., 298, 134-141 (1959). 38. Mazdiyasni K. and Cooke C. M., J. Am. Cerum. Soc., 56, 628-633 (1973). 39. Segal, D. L., Br. Cerum. Trans.. J., 85, 184-187 (1986). 40. Segal, D.L., Chem. Znd., 544-545 (1985). 41. Stock, and Somieski, K., Ber. Dtsch. Chem. Ges., 54, 740-758 (1921). 42. Larsson, E., and Bjellerup, L., J. Am. Chem. 75, 995-997 (1953). 43. Laineet, R. M., Blum, Y. D., Chow, A., Hamlin, R., Schwartz, K. B., and Rowecliffe, D.J., Polymer Preprints, 28, 393-395 (1987). 44. Barant, V., Orgunosilicon Compounds, Academic Press, New York,1965,pp. 77-8 1. 45 Blum, Y.D., Schwartz,K.B.,and Lain, R.M., J. Muter. Sci., 24, 1707-1718 (1989). Saiko, G., and Kubo, H., in Ceramic Powder Processing Sci46. Matsubayashi, ence, (H. Hausner, G. C. Messing, and A. Hirano, eds.), Deutsche Keramische Gesellschaft, Koln, 1989, pp. 825-831. 47. Seyferth, D., Wiseman, G. H., and Prud’Homme, C., J . Am. Cerum. Soc. Commm., C-l3 (1983). #
RUSSEL AND SEIBOLD 48. Tamio, and Hiroyuki, T., FR 2 583 744-A1 (1986). 49. Legrow, G. E., Lim, T. F., Lipowitz, J., and Reaoch, R. Am. Ceram.Soc. Bull., 66, 363-367 (1987). 50. Seyferth, D., and Wiseman, G. H., J. Am. Ceram Soc., 67, C-l32 (1984). 51. Seyferth,D.,andWiseman,G.H.,in UltrastructureProcessing of Ceramics, Glasses and Composites, (L. L. HenchandD.R.Ulrich, Wiley Interscience, New York, 1984, p. 265. Jackson,T. B., andCutler, R.A., J. Am.Ceram. 72, 52. Virkar, A.V., 2031-2042 (1989). 53. Schwetz, K. A., in Progress in Nitrogen Ceramics, (F. L. Riley, ed.), Martnius Nijhoff, Boston, MA (1983), pp. 245-252. 54. Buhr, H., Muller, G., Wiggers, H., Aldinger, F., Foley, P., and Roosen,A., J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 74, 718 (1991). 99-103 (1991). 55. Jaschek, R., and Russel, C., Coat. Surf. Technol., 56. Teusel, I., and Russel, C., J. Mater. Sci., 25, 3531-3534 (1990). 57. Jaschek, R., and Russel, C., J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 135, 236-241 (1991). 58. Jaschek, R., and Russel, C., Thin Solid Films, 208, 7-10 (1992). Roe, D.C., Staley, R. H., Tebbe, F. N., 59. Baker, R. T., Belt, J. D., Reddy, G. and Vegas A. J., in M R S Symp. Proc., Vol. 121, Better Ceramics Through Chemistry III (C. J. Brinker, D. F. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Pittsburgh, PA, 1988, pp. 471476. 60. Wiberg, E., and Amberger,E., Hydrides of the Elements the Main Group I-N, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1971. 61. Wiberg, E., and May, A., Z. Naturforsch., lob, 229-238 (1955). 62. Einarsrud, M. A., Rhine, W. E., and Cima, M. J. Proc. ECerS (G. de With, R. A. Terpstra,andR.Metselaar,eds.),Elsevier,London,NewYork 1989, pp. 1.38-1.42. 63. Ochi, A., Bowen, H. K., and Rhine, W. E., in MRS Symp. Proc., Vol. 121, Better Ceramics Through ChemistryIll (C. J. Brinker, D. F. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, Pittsburgh, PA, 1988, pp. 663666. Jensen,K.F., Chem. Mater., I , 339-343 6 4 . Gladfielder, W. L., Boyd, D.C.,and (1989). 65. Sugahara, Y.,Onuma, T., Tanegashima, O., Kuroda, K., andKato, C., J. Jpn. Ceram. 101-103 (1992). 66. Interrante, L.V., Carpenter E, L. E., Whitmarsh, C., Lee, W., Garbanskas, M., and Slack, G. A., in M R S Symp. Proc. Vol. 73, Better Ceramics Through Chemistry I1 (C. J. Brinker D. F. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Pittsburgh, PA, 1986, pp. 359-366. 67. Lappert, M. F., Metal and Metalloid Amides, J. Wiley & Sons, New York, 1980, p. 99. 68. Maya, L., Adv. Ceram. Mater., I , 150-153 (1986). 69. Frigo, D. M., Reuvers, P. J., Bradley, D.C., Chudzynska, H., Meinena,H.A., Kraaijkamp, J. G., and Timmer, K., Chem. Mater., 3, 1097-1101 (1991). Dozzi, G., Busetto, C., andMazzei,A., J. Organometal. Chem., 70. Cucinella, 113, 223-243 (1976).
SYNTHESIS CHEMICAL.
127
NONOXIDES
Schleich, D. M., U.S. Patent Riedel, R., Petzow,G.,andKlingebielU.,
J . Mater.Sci.Lett.,
Maya, L., and Angelini, P., J. Am. Ceram. Bender,B. A., Rice,R. W., andSpann,J.
R., Ceram. Eng. Sci.Proc.,
Tanigushi, I., Harada, K., and Maeda, T., Japan Kokai OOO Narula, C. K., Paine, R. T., and Schaeffer, R., in (C. I. Brinker, D. E. Clark, and D.R.Ulrich,eds.), M R S Pr. Vol. BetterCeramicsThroughChemistry I1 Pittsburgh, PA, pp. Paciorek,K. J.L., Nakahara,J. M., andHoferkamp,L.A., Chem. Mater., Rye, R. R., Tallant, D. R., Borek, T. T., Lindquist, D. A., and Paine, R. T., Chem. Mater., Fazen, P. J., Remsen, E. E., and Sneddon, L. G., Polymer Preprints, Paine, R. T., Janik, J.F., Borek, T. T., Lindquist, D. A., Duesler, E. N., Smith, D. M., Kodas, T. T., and Datye, A. K., Polymer Preprints, Seyferth, D., andSmithRees, W., in M R S Proc.Vol. BetterCeramics Through Chemistry Ill (C. J. Brinker, D. E. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.),Pittsburgh, PA, pp. Seyferth, D., and Rees, W. Chem. Mater., Schroeder, H., Reiner, J. R., and Knowles, T. A., Inorg. Chem., Niedenzu, K., and Buschbeck, K.-C., Gmelin Handbook of Inorganic Chemistry, ed., Vol. Boron Compounds: B-H Compounds, Springer, Berlin, pp. ff. Maya, L., in Better Ceramics Through Chemistry III (C. J. Brinker, D. E. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.) M R S hoc. Vol. Pittsburgh, PA, pp. Seyferth, D., and Mignani, G., J. Mater. Sci. Lett. Lappert, M. F., Power, P. P., Sanger, A. R., and Srivastava, R. C.,Metal and Metalloid Amides, Ellis Horwood, Chinchester, Brown, G. M., and Maya, L., J . Am. Ceram. Maya, L., Inorg. Chem., Maya, L., Inorg. Chem., Maya, L.,in M R S Symp. Proc. Vol. Better Ceramics Through Chemistry I1 (C. J. Brinker, D. F. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds. Pittsburgh, PA, p. Seibold, M., andRussel, C., inMRSSymp. Proc. Vol. BetterCeramics Through Chemistry I l l (C. J. Brinker, D. F. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Piasburgh, PA, pp. Seibold, M., Viemeusel, U., and Russel, C., in Ceramic Powder Processing Seience (H.Hausner,G.C.Messing,and Hirano,eds.),DeutscheKeramische Gesellschaft, Koln, pp. Seibold, M., and Russel, C., J . Am. Ceram. Russel,C.,Hofmann,T.,Kulig,M.,andSeibold., Silikattechnik,
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
6 Techniques for Characterization of Advanced Ceramic Powders S. G. Malghan, P. S. Wang, and V. A. Hackley National Institute
Standards and Technology Gaithersburg, Maryland
IMPORTANCE OF POWDERCHARACTERIZATION The practical performance of a ceramic component, the microstructure of the ceramic, and powder behavior during processing are strongly dependent on the physical and chemical characteristics of starting powders [l]. In addition, in the manufacture of advanced ceramic components, detailed information on powder characteristics is required to achieve reproducibility and cost competitiveness. The choice of starting powder characteristics depends on the intended microstructure and application of the final ceramics. For instance, although total oxygen may be one of the most important measurements in silicon nitride powders because oxygen participates in the formation of a grain boundary silicate phase, the total Y2O3 content may be the most desired parameter in zirconia powder processing because it controls phase composition and transformation. The requirements of powder characterization are complicated by the fact that a large number of properties must be defined to understand its characteristics completely. review of Table 1 shows that this task is not simple because the powders are complex materials consisting of numerous features. Therefore, ceramists are faced with the question of what characteristics of powders to measure for a given process. Commonly, an answer to this question lies in the development of parametric relationships between the powder properties and their influence on the performance of the ceramic. The next question is how to measure the powder characteristics. A program has been in progress
MALGHAN ET AL. Table
Properties of AdvancedCeramic Powders That Constitute Their Characterization Physical properties Specific surface area Primary particle size and size distribution Agglomerate size and size distribution Porosity, total quantity and pore size distribution Density Phase composition Crystalline phases, quantity and identification Amorphous material, quantity Chemical composition Major element concentration Minor impurities ppm to =l%) Trace impurities ppm) Inorganic elements Organic elements Composition impurities Surface composition Major elements Minor elements Trace elements Inorganic species Organic species Crystallinity
since 1985 under the auspices of the International Energy Agency to develop procedures for the analysis of ceramic powders An overall goal in this task is to define procedures that provide repeatable and reproducible data. The development of standard reference materials (SRM) stands at the forefront of this task since the SRM are necessary for the improvement of measurement quality In this chapter, we address the available methods for the characterization of ceramic powders, and selected methods have been briefly described. Primarily, for these methods, a description of operating principles, type of data to be obtained, and measurement limitations are presented. In addition, nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy ( X P S ) techniques have been described in more detail because their treatment, as applied to powders, is not available elsewhere. Thermal techniques, such as differential thermal analysis, are not covered because of their specialized use on powders. For interested readers, a number of references have been cited for additional information.
I31
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC
II. PHYSICAL PROPERTIES The major physical properties of ceramic powders constitute size distribution of primary particles and agglomerates, specific surface area, density, porosity, and morphology (e.g., shape, texture, and angularity).
A.SizeDistribution In the measurement of particle or agglomerate size distribution, the major distinction is that agglomerates are made primary particles. Hence, often there is a need to determine the true size of the underlying primary particles. In such cases, the size distribution of particles may be determined by a number of techniques, as shown in Table 2, which lists the commonly used methods With
Table 2 Commonly Used Methods of Particle Size Analysis, Nominal Size Ranges, and Measurement Parameters Nominal particle Measurement Method Coarse particles > 10 pm, sieving Dry Wet Fine particles < 10 pm Field scanning Optical microscopy Electron microscopy Gravity sedimentation Pipette Photoextinction X-ray absorption Radiation scattering, Laser diffraction, scattering scanning Resisitivity Optical Ultrasonic attenuation Column hydrodynamic chromatography Sedimentation fieldflow fractionation Laser Doppler velocimetry Centrifugal sedimentation Photoextinction Mass accumulation X-ray absorption
>l0
Geometric
Image
0.01-10 1-100 0.5-100 0.1-130
Stokes
0.03-900
Geometric
0.05-500
Dynamic/Stokes
1-500 1 0 0 1 m 0.1-1 .o 0.01-1.0 0.01-3.0 0.05-100 0.05-25
0.1-5
Dynamic/Stokes
MALGHAN ET AL.. such a large number of choices, the selection of a system for a given application depends on a number of criteria, including the size range of the application, throughput of the instrument, accuracy, precision, reproducibility, resolution, versatility, cost, and manufacturer support The three methods described in the following text are microscopy, gravity sedimentation, and light diffraction. Their selection is based purely on their technical diversity.
1. Microscopy Three commonly used direct viewing techniques are optical, scanning electron, and transmission electron microscopy. Optical microscopy is used in the size range 1-150 pm for the determination of morphology, agglomeration, and size distribution using automated counting devices. Despite significant improvements in optics, a major disadvantage is its depth of focus, which is about 0.5 pm at Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) is a versatile technique in which a beam of electrons at 5-50 keV scans the specimen surface. The resultingx-rays, backscattered electrons, andsecondary electrons are detected and analyzed by a number of techniques. Magnifications of up to can be achieved at resolutions finer than 20 nm. Depth of focus and magnification are inversely proportional. Automated image analysis systems are available to analyze particle size distribution.However, the major issues remain sample preparationand dispersion of powder, that is, particles tend to agglomerate when deposited on SEM stubs and thereby do not provide complete and true data for primary particles. Intransmission electron microscopy (TEM), 5-0.001 pm particles deposited on thin membranes are examined at times better resolution than that in SEM. TEM is more often used as an analytical tool for surface characterization and texture rather than for routine particle size distribution. 2. Gravity Sedimentation The underlying principle behind the gravity sedimentation method is Stokes’ law, which describes the relationship between the settling velocity of particles in a fluid medium known density and viscosity number of instruments are available in which the settling velocity of particles is measured by x-ray absorption, light absorption, and density changes. One such instrument is the Sedigraph* by the Micromeritics Corporation in which the particle size distribution is determined by x-ray absorption This instrument offers an excel-
*Certain trade names and company products mentioned in the text identified in illustrations to specify adequately the experimental procedure and equipment used. In case does such identification imply recommendation endorsement by the National Institute Standards and Technor does it imply that the products are necessarily the best available the purpose.
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS lent measurement capability in the 0.2-50 pm range of a relatively concentrated suspension containing up to by weight powder in an appropriate dispersion fluid. The data are presented as a continuous plot of percentage weight Of particles smaller than the stated size or other convenient formats. heparation of an appropriate dispersion is a key step in obtaining repeatable data [7]. The dispersion preparation for a given powder requires two Sets of data: the amount and intensity of energy application to break agglomerates into primary particles; and (2) the pH at which the isoelectric point, the point at which the particles carry a net zero charge, occurs in a given aqueous solvent containing a surfactant for stabilization of particles. For each powder, it is necessary to develop an appropriate data for these parameters. 3. Light Scattering Instruments based on light scattering employ a laser beam to radiate particles in a stream, and the resulting scattered light is analyzed using the Fraunhofer and Mie theories to obtain size distribution data When the size of particles is very small with respect to the wavelength of light or when the refractive index of the particles is very close to that of the dispersion medium, such as that of a liquid to form a suspension, the relatively simple equations of Raleigh and Gans can be employed. For colloidal suspensions, however, it is necessary to resort to the Mie theory, which includes the restrictive conditions that the particles be spherical and intrinsically isotropic. With the advent of desktop computers, the application of the Mie theory has become a reality for polydisperse systems. Mie formulated equations to delineate light scattering by particles by considering electrical fields within and outside each particle. The equations for scattering intensity for each scattering angle involved refractive index difference between particle and suspending medium, the wavelength of incident light, and the spherical diameter of the particle. For particle diameter in the range of times the wavelength of incident light, scattering from different portions of the particle is out of phase, which results in interference and reduced intensity. The net effect is an angular distribution of scattered light in the forward direction. This information is utilized in Mie theory computations. number of instruments are available by which 0.03-900 pm particles can be measured in a matter of several minutes from dispersed suspensions. One major advantage of these systems is their ability to handle particulate systems containing different densities and refractive indices. requirement of these instruments is the refractive index data, which may not be readily available for many powders. If the light-scattering particulate systems are not monodisperse, the particle size distribution obtained from these systems represents an average value, related but not identical to the weight-average particle size distribution. These averages are expected to differ depending on particle shape, particle size distribution, and degree of anisotropy.
134
MAL.GHAN ET AL..
B.
Specific SurfaceArea
Particles consist of both internal and external surface area. The external surface area represents that caused by exterior topography, whereas the internal surface area measures that caused by microcracks, capillaries, and closed voids inside .the particles. Since the chosen surface area technique should relate to the ultimate use of the data, not all techniques are useful for fine powders. The commonly used approaches are permeametry and gas adsorption according to the Brunauer, Emmet, and Teller (BET) equation [g]. Because of simplicity of operation and speed of operation, permeametry methods have received much attention. The permeametry apparatus consists of .a chamber for placing the material to be measured and a device to force fluid to flow through the powder bed. The pressure drop and rate of flow across the powder bed are measured and related to an average particle size and surface area. Especially for porous powders, permeametry data include some internal surface area, thus decreasing their value. In the BET method, the volume or weight of adsorbed gas as a function of partial pressure is measured. Most commonly, NZgas is adsorbed by the powder at liquid N2 temperature from a gas stream of NZand He. The NZadsorbed and later desorbed is measured by thermal conductivity in one type of equipment. The BET equation describes the equilibrium between vapor and adsorbate in which multilayer adsorption occurs. The BET equation is typically written in the form PIP0
._
'
+
"
V(1- PIP,)
V,C
(C - 1)P& vmc
where PIP0 is relative pressure (the ratio of the equilibrium pressure to the saturation pressure at a specific temperature), V is the amount of gas adsorbed, and Vm represents V for monolayer coverage. The constant C is related to the energies of adsorption and gas liquefaction. Sample preparation is the key to obtaining reproducible data. Sufficient outgassing, minimal surface contamination, and the absence of microporosity are important aspects of the proper analysis of surface area. BET measurements are carried out in either singlepoint or multipoint mode, in which multipoint data are normally higher and more representative than those of the single point [2].
C.
Density
Theoretical, true, and tap density are three types of densities associated with ceramic powders. Theoretical density is determined by atomic composition and lattice parameters; tap density is determined by a prescribed procedure, which
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS
I35
consists of measuring the volume of a known weight of powder after a certain number of mechanical taps. Therefore, tap density provides a relative measure of fill density or degree of compactibility of the powder. In the determination of true density, the powder volume is determined by the volume of gas displaced by a known weight of powder. Helium pycnometry is the commonly used method for this application. Helium is the most frequently used gas because of its inertness and small size, which enables it to penetrate even the smallest pores. Therefore, contribution tothe volume by pores can beaccounted for the measurement of true density.
D. Porosity Porosity in a powder can come from both closed and open pores. Two primary methods for the determination ofporosityare gas adsorption andmercury porosimetry. It is assumed that gas adsorption is favored in small capillaries because ofthe overlapping surface potentials, which result in capillary condensation.Pores from 1.5 to 100 nm in diameter are determined using the Kelvin equation, which relates capillary radius r to the ratio of the vapor pressure P and the equilibrium vapor pressure of the same liquid over a plane surface Po, as follows:
where is the surface tension of the liquid, V is the molar volume of the liquid, 8 is the contact angle between the liquid and the wall, R is the gas constant, and T is the absolute temperature [lo]. Adsorption in the microporosity range ( r c nm) often exhibits a Langmuir typeof isotherm, normally a characteristic of monolayer adsorption. The second principal method for porosity measurement is mercury porosimetry, in which a nonwetting liquid, such as mercury, is forced into capillaries of radius r. The force Foutcaused by interfacial tension is calculated as F , ~ = 2 m y COS e
(3)
where 8 is the contact angle for mercury. The applied pressure P is related to the force driving the mercury Fin into a capillary and is given by -Fin
= P m2
Equating the two forces results in the Washburn equation [l l]:
MALGHAN ET AL.
136
Mercury porosity measurements are carried out in the pressure range Pa (ambient) to Pa, which corresponds to pore radii from 2 nm to pm.
E.
Morphology
The morphological analysis of particles constitutes the measurement of size, shape, and texture, which describes the surface profile of a particle image. The primary methods of morphology analysis are microscopy techniques, depending on the size of particles. In recent years, a large number of software packages for processing image data fromautomated microscopes have enabled faster accumulation and interpretation of data. However, the major drawbacks of microscopic techniques are representativeness of the sample examined and two-dimensional examination of the particle surface. The data from the shortest dimension may not be adequately represented.
BULKCHEMICAL COMPOSITION large number of techniques are available, depending on the specific need to analyze major chemical components, minor components, nonmetallic impurities, and metallic impurities (see Table 3). Further, the applicability of a technique depends on the concentration of impurities in the powder, a problem of considerable magnitude for ultrapure powders. generalproblemwith the techniques'that require dissolution of the powders is their resistance to chemical attack and lack of complete dissolution. The two major methods of placing the powders in solution are acid dissolution and flux decomposition followed by dissolution [2,3]. The nonavailability of standard reference powders and procedures is a serious drawback to all the analysis methods. It is not possible to cover all the available techniques; therefore, only selected techniques with applicability to bulk and minor impurities are described here.
A.
InductivelyandDirectlyCoupledPlasma
These techniques, used for qualitative and quantitative measurements, utilize excitation atoms in a plasma to obtain their characteristic emissions that are analyzed by photodetection. The powder is dissolved, and the resulting solution injected into the plasma. The fast speed of analysis and applicability to a wide range of elements are strong points, but these methods are subject to errors resulting from powder dissolution. Currently, a number of industrial laboratories are addressing this issue.
B.
Atomic AbsorptionSpectroscopy (AAS)
A A S is a versatile method in which an analyte is atomized in a flame, thus emitting spectral lines. The characteristic spectral lines that correspond to the
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS Table 3 Methods for BulkChemicalandImpurityAnalysis of Metallic and Nonmetallic Impurities in Ceramic Powders Bulk chemical analysis X-ray fluorescence spectroscopy Atomic absorption spectroscopy Inductively coupled plasma emission spectroscopy Direct-current plasma emission spectroscopy Arc emission spectroscopy Gravimetry Combustion Kjeldahl Impurities Neutron activation analysis Mass spectrometry Electrochemical Coulometry Selective-ion potentiometry Potentiometric titration Argentometric Ion chromatography Nuclear magnetic resonance Electron paramagnetic resonance energy required for an electronic transition from the ground state to an excited state are emitted. The absorption of radiation from the light source depends on the population the ground state, which is directly proportional to solution concentration. The absorption is measured by the difference in transmitted signal in the presence and absence of the test element [ However, this technique is also subject to errors resulting from powder dissolution.
C.
X-rayFluorescenceSpectroscopy
The powder in the form fine particulates or dissolved in solution is excited in an x-ray source, and the characteristic fluorescence intensity is analyzed for qualitative and quantitative data. Standards are required for the conversion x-rayintensities to absolute concentrations. The preparation of appropriate standards that include background similar to that in the solution tobe analyzed is critical to obtaining accurate data.
D.
Nuclear Magnetic Resonance and Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR)
In principle, NMR utilizes the atomic nuclear transition, induced by radio frequency irradiation, between two quantized nuclear energy levels in a magnetic
138
MALGHAN ET
AL.
field. This transition caused by resonance in a magnetic field occurs in all atomic nuclei, except in atoms with even numbers of both mass and atomic number. The nuclear spin numbers are zero for atoms withboth mass and atomic numbers that are even, and consequently, nuclear energy splitting does not occur in a magnetic field and these atoms are not active in NMR. All other isotopes in the periodic table are NMR active. ‘H, W , 15N,19F,27Al, W i , 31P, 47Ti, 63Cu, 69Ga, 89Y, and 91Zr are some examples. For an atom with a nuclear spin number I , there are 2 I + quantized nuclear energy levels: -I, -(I - l), . .. (I - l), I. These levels are practically equal in energy outside a magnetic field. If a magnetic field is applied to this atom, however, the nuclear energy split into 2 I + 1 levels separated by (yh/27c)H, where H is the magnetic field strength, h is the Planck constant, and y is the nuclear magnetogyric ratio. The nuclear energy E is expressed by
E=--
rh m,H 2x
where MI = I, (I - l), .. . , -(I - l), -I. If a sample is irradiated by a radiofrequency energy equal to the energy separation, resonance occurs, the nuclei at the ground state are excited to a higher energy state, and an absorption signal is observed. The NMR is therefore an absorption spectroscopy, not an emission spectroscopy (e.g., X P S ) . The magnetogyric ratio is a constant for a specific isotope of interest. However, the magnetic field H is an effective field to the nuclei including the applied external field, the field induced by the electrons around the nuclei, and even the field produced by other parts of the molecule. For Si atoms, for example, 95.3 atom% are 28Si, which have a nuclear spin I = 0 and are not NMR active ( 2 I + = only one energy level; therefore, no resonance can occur). There are 4.7 atom% 29Si in natural abundance, however, and 29Si has a nuT, for example, the 29Si clear spin I = H. In an external magnetic field of nuclear energy is split into two levels separated by approximately 79.5 MHz, with mr = H and -H and with H lower in energy. In addition, the actual magnetic field experienced by the 29Si nuclei in Sic, Si3N4, and Si02 is different and not exactly 9.4 T because the electron density and distribution around the Si nuclei in these compounds are different. This difference makes it possible for to observe the absorption signals at different field strengths and is the “chemical shift.” Chemical shift is a comparative value and is most often referenced to tetramethylsilane [TMS, Si(CH3)4]. This compound can be used as a reference to three frequencies: ‘H, W , and 29Si. The frequency difference between the sample and that of TMS is often divided by the frequency of the spectrometer to give a value in parts per million (ppm), which is spectrometric frequency independent. Other factors, such as spin-spin interaction with neighboring atoms, affect Si nuclear energy level splitting. For nuclei with I 2 1, the nuclear quadrupole
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS effect also alters the energy level splitting. A more in-depth coverage of N M R theory is found elsewhere [13,14]. N M R spectroscopists are also interested in nuclear spin relaxation times. The relaxation time measures the time required for an excited nucleus to return to the ground state. Two types of relaxation times are involved: spin-lattice relaxation time T i , the time constant for thermal equilibrium between the nuclei and crystal lattice, and spin-spin relaxation time T2, the time constant for thermal equilibrium between nuclei themselves. Information on molecular dynamics can be obtained from these relaxation times. Generally, Ti = T2 for lowviscosity liquids and Ti >> T2 for solids. A combination of information in molecular dynamics (from relaxation times), molecular structure (from spinspin interaction), molecular identification (from resonance frequency and chemical shift), and spin density (from signal intensity) make the NMR an extremely versatile tool. The application of NMR spectroscopy to ceramic powders is a relatively new area, but it has potential. N M R application in solids is difficult because of large dipole-dipole interactions that result in line broadening and thus poor resolution. However, by the application of modem instrument technology and discoveiy of pulsed Fourier transform N M R , scientists have developed various line-narrowing techniques to improve resolution [15]. One of the most often utilized techniques is magic angle spinning (MAS). Molecules in solids are not mobile and tumbling as they are in the liquid or gaseous state. This induces large dipolar interactions between two spin centers. If we physically spin the sample, at several kilohertz, the anisotropic part of the nuclear dipole is eliminated. The dipole-dipole interaction is a function of (3 cos2 - l), where is the angle between the static magnetic field and internuclear vector. Setting this term to zero, the “magic” angle is 54”44’ [16]. N M R has been applied most successfully for high-temperature superconductors, YBa2Cu307-6 [17-211. The studies involve mainly 89Y,63Cu, and 65Cu NMR and nuclear quadrupole resonance of this compound below, above, and at the critical temperature. Nuclear relaxation, Knight shift, and crystal structure are often examined at these temperatures. 29Si and *7Al N M R have been applied to silicates, aluminosilicates, and surface-adsorbed molecules on ceramic materials [22]. N M R can also be a powerful technique to determine the surface area [23], porosity, pore size, and molecular diffusion into the crystallattice [24]. The technique is basedon the different relaxation times (or linewidths) of the mobile molecules and adsorbed molecules, the latter losing certain degrees of freedom. The crystal structure of B a T i e has been characterized by 137Ba, 47Ti, and 49Ti NMR at various temperatures up to the Curie point [25]. Structural changes in the alkaline-earth silicate glasses induced by phosphorus were also studied by 31P and 29Si NMR [26]. 29Si MAS NMR is a very useful technique to study the crystal-phase composition and transition in silicon nitride and carbide [27,28]. The a phase of
MALGHAN ET AL..
140
these compounds has more than one Si crystal site; while p phase has only one. This yields different line patterns for different phases. MAS NMR has been used to study high-temperature reactions, sintering, the formation of surface oxide and suboxide, and reaction products with the sintering aid The theory of EPR (also known as electron spin resonance) is very similar to that of the NMR except the frequency falls into gigahertz region because the mass of electrons is smaller. Electrons are negatively charged, so that the splitting of energy is inverted in its order compared with the nuclei Since only molecules with unpaired electrons are EPR active, the application of EPR to ceramics is limited.However,EPR is a unique technique for characterizing powders with dangling bonds (as in carbon atoms), impurities, and defects.
E. Combustion This technique is limited to such elements as carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen that can be liberated in gaseous form during decomposition. The concentration of gas is determined by a property of the gas. Commonly a flux is used to aid the combustion
IV.
PHASE COMPOSITION
A.
X-rayPowderDiffraction(XRPD)
This is the most widely used method for the determination of the phase composition of powders. The x-ray diffractometer contains a source of monochromatic x-rays that irradiate the sample and are diffracted from atomic planes and detected. The angle of diffraction of x-rays by the crystalline planes is characteristic of the crystal structure, and the intensity of scattered radiation is characteristic of the atomic composition. In recent years, automated data processing has enabled higher accuracy andspeed. number of problems are encountered in the quantitative determination of phases in fine powders. Some of these are overlap of phase peaks (e.g., in silicon nitride), orientation of grains, and presence of coarse particles. The last produces distortion of the diffraction data. number of standard reference materials for XRPD have been developed for use in improving the quality of data
V. A.
SURFACECHEMICAL COMPOSITION BY SPECTROSCOPY X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy and X-ray-Induced Auger Electron Spectroscopy (XAES)
X P S (also known as electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis) and XAES provide not only the surface elemental composition but also reveal the oxida-
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS
141
tion states of the elements. X P S , especially, has emerged as one of the most important techniques for studying the chemistry of the ceramic-powdersurface as a result of oxidation at high temperatures. In X P S , when soft x-rays, such as MgKa (1253.6 eV), impinge on a powder surface, photoelectrons with binding energy BE are ejected from the surface with kinetic energy (KE). The relationship among the irradiation energy hv (1253.6 eV in the case of MgKa), KE, and BE is as follows: KE=hv-BE-eS
(7)
where is the work function of the spectrometer. Since is a constant for a specific spectrometer, hv is known and KE can be measured; therefore, BE can be calculated. Often, residual carbon in the form of hydrocarbon (-CH) is found on the powder surface as a contaminant, and the C 1s photoelectron peak at 284.5 eV binding energy is used as a reference to calculate the binding energies of other signals. From the binding energy of the emitted electrons, the surface elemental composition and chemical state can be derived. Detailed information on surface analysis techniques, comparison of XPS and Auger electron spectroscopy (AES), and photoelectron binding energies can be found in the respective references [3840]. For quantitative surface composition, the photoelectron cross sections (or atomic sensitivity factors) are required to convert the signal intensities to atomic ratios. In other words, one photoelectron from C 1s gives a different spectral intensity from that of a Si Is, for example. Scofield cross-sectional values are often used for this purpose [41]. When two spectral signals from different oxidation states of an element (for example, Si 2p from Si3N4 and its surface oxide Si02) can be resolved because of a large difference in binding energy, the surface film thickness can be calculated if the photoelectron mean free paths data are available [4247]. When photoelectrons are emitted from the core level as a result of a photoelectronic process, the surface becomes ionized and unstable. The ion relaxes its energy by drawing an outer electron to fill the inner orbital vacancy left by the photoelectron, and a second electron is emitted by the excess energy. This second emitted electron is an Auger electron (more precisely, x-ray-induced Auger electron, X A E S , or bremsstrahlung-excited Auger electron). A comparison of the photoelectron and Auger processes is shown in Fig. 1. It can be concluded that the kinetic energy of a photoelectron is directly proportional to the energy of irradiation, but the kinetic energy of an Auger electron is independent of the radiation source and possesses kinetic energy equal to the difference between the energy of the initial ion and the doubly charged final ion. The energy of neither electron can exceed the energy of the ionizing photons. Sometimes the difference in kinetic energies of two Auger electrons from two different oxidation states is larger than that of the photoelectrons, and thus the
-
MALGHAN ET AL.
L1 OR 2s
PHOTON
PHOTOELECTRON
OR
p AUGER ELECTRON / 12.3
OR
“-ece---- L, OR b I
I
I OR
1 Comparison of photoelectron and Augerprocesses. Augerspectrum provides better resolution for surface chemical studies, as shown for S i c and Si3N4 powders [42,43,48]. S i c and Si3N4 powders have been studied extensively by X P S or x-ray-induced AES [42,43,48-571. Powders, whiskers, and platelets were treated at elevated temperatures, and surface analysis was carried out by measuring Si 2p X P S or Si KLL AES intensities for Si02 and S i c (or Si3N4). Subsequently, surface oxide film growth rates were measured and surface oxidation activation energies were calculated [42,43,48-511. In some cases, the effects s f the presence of ymia, a sintering aid, and boron, an impurity, were studied [43,48,49]. The effects on surface oxidation chemistry caused by different powder processing routes were also studied [50]. Surface composition, including oxygen and oxynitide concentration, is important information required for nonoxide powder processing. In a recent study, several commercial silicon nitide powders were analyzed for total oxygen at high temperatures, and the “surface” oxygenwasmeasured by AES. The “bulk” oxygen was then calculated based on these data [52]. Commercial S i c
king
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS
143
powders were examined for surface composition and contamination by X P S Ultrafine powders grown bya radiofrequency plasma process were found to have a thin oxide layer; those grown in a vapor-liquid-solid process had a thicker silica layer Surface-sensitive techniques, such as XPS and also contribute to the understanding of moisture effects, surface coating, and interfacial chemistry of ceramic powders
B.
Infrared and RamanSpectroscopy
For a polyatomic molecule containing n atoms, the total degree of freedom is 3n and there are 3n - modes of vibration if the molecule is nonlinear. This shows that molecular vibration in a polyatomic molecule can be very complex. Infrared (R) and Raman are two complementary techniques to study molecular vibration and identify unknown species. There are two fundamental types of molecular vibrations: stretching and bending. Stretching, in which twoatoms increase or decrease their distance but remain in the same bond axis, can be either symmetrical or asymmetric. Bending is a molecular deformation and can be scissoring, rocking, wagging, or twisting. Figure 2 shows these vibrations for a group of atoms. Molecular bending generally requires less energy than stretching and is thus observed at lower frequency. The frequency of stretching depends on the bond strength and mass of the atom attached and can be calculated from
where 2) is stretching frequency in cm-1, c is the velocity of light, Mx and M y are the mass in grams of the two atoms attached to the bond, and k is the force constant in dyneshentimeter of the bond.
Asymmetric
Symmetric
Scissoring
Twisting
Vibrations
a group of atoms.
144
MALGHAN ET AL..
Each of these vibrations has a characteristic frequency and can occur at quantized frequencies only. When IR light of the same frequency is incident on the molecule, the energy is absorbed by the molecule and the amplitude of the particular mode increases. However, this absorption occurs only if this vibrational mode can cause a change in the molecular dipole. Consequently, not all vibrational modes are IR active and the molecular symmetry plays a key role in the reduction of IR spectrum patterns. In addition to these fundamental vibrations, overtone peaks may also be observed with much reduced intensity at two, three times, and so on, the wave numbers, the sum of twoor three times the wave numbers, or the difference between two wave numbers. Detailed IR spectroscopic theory and group theory can be found elsewhere Surface moisture is a problem of concern in ceramic powders, and IR has been used to characterize the surface groups of -OHand -H IR was also applied to characterize chemically bound hydrogen in chemical vapordeposited silicon nitride at various ammonia-silane ratios Surface silicon dioxide on S i c powders was determined by photoacoustic IR and diffuse reflectance IR spectroscopy IR spectroscopy was also used to study the surface oxidation of S i c and Si3N4 Raman spectroscopy is complementary to R.The vibration that is inactive to IR, because ofa high degree of molecular symmetry or lack of dipole change, may be detected by Raman. Raman depends on a change in the polarizability during the vibration instead of the electric dipole moment. When a monochromatic light with frequency impinges on a molecule, the scattered light has the same frequency if the scattering is elastic. is Rayleigh scattering. However, some of the light is scattered with f cause of inelastic interactions. Lines with lower frequency are known as Stokes lines And are formed by the loss energy to the molecules during scattering. Lines with higher frequency are known as anti-stokes lines and are formed by energy gain from the molecules during scattering. The Raman frequency is completely independent of the incident light Rather, it is characteristic of the molecular vibration energy. By measuring the characteristic Raman frequency, one can identify the unknown molecules Application of Raman scattering to ceramic powder characterization is a new research area, and the data are limited.
A suspension of finely dispersed particles is thermodynamically unstable; this system is inclined to lower its free energy through flocculation. The stability and rheology of a powder in a suspension depend on the nature of the solid/ solution interface, particularly on the electrical properties of this region This interface may be described as consisting essentially of two layers (Fig.
CHARACTERIZATION
ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS
145
Shear Plane
0
0 0 Solution
The solid/aqueous solution interface and electrical double layer for a hydrolyzed oxide surface: charge density; electrostatic potential; +, cation; -, anion, surface; c, compact layer; d, diffuse layer.
a compact layer near the surface consisting of potential determining adsorbed species and complexed ions, balanced by a diffuse layer of counterions in lution. Suspension stability is a consequence of mutual repulsion between similarly charged double layers. It is therefore desirable to measure the electrical potential as a function of solution or powder conditions to optimize slurry properties during wet processing. A complete surface chemical characterization should also include information about the type and density of surface sites and the interaction of solution species with the surface. In this section, we cover only in situ techniques for the analysis of powder dispersions, because these systems are most relevant to ceramic powder processing. The focus is on electrokinetic methods for the measurement of particle electrostatic potential. In addition, a brief overview of available surface chemical characterization techniques is given. Additional details on this topic are given by other authors in this book.
MALGHAN ET AL.
I46
A.
ElectrokineticCharacterization
At some distance from the particle surface (usually identified as the beginning of the diffuse layer in Fig. 3), a hydrodynamic shear plane exists that is characterized by the potential. The magnitude of ( is directly related to dispersion stability [71]. For oxides, hydroxides, and related materials, is strongly influenced by solution pH and electrolyte concentration and may be modified by surface-active species, such as oxyanions and polyelectrolytes. The key parameter characterizing a powder surface is the isoelectric point pHg. Under pristine conditions (i.e., no surface contamination), PHiep defines the solution pH at which = 0 and the particles exhibit a net surface charge of zero. This point can be identified from an acid-base titration curve in which is plotted against pH. Shifts in PHiep may result from changes in surface chemistry that occur during aging or chemical treatment of powders [ S ] , for instance, or caused by the chemical adsorption of solution species [72]. The potential may be obtained from measurements of particle mobility using electrokinetic techniques, such as electrophoresis or sedimentation potential [70]. Electrophoresis, the standard technique for submicrometer particles, is based on the movement of charged particles in response to an applied electrical field. Optical scattering methods are used to measure the distribution of particle velocities for a given field strength, and may then be calculated using the Henry equation,
<
<
<
<
<
c
where and E are the viscosity and dielectric constant of the medium, P E is the electrophoretic mobility, and the functionfdepends on the thickness of the double layer ~ - 1relative to the particle radius a. The Henry equation is applicable to many powder slurry systems in which the double layer is thin relative to the particle radius (KU >> l), although more exact solutions exist for the calculation of over a broad range of KU values [70]. Because electrophoresis uses optical detection, this technique is limited to the analysis of dilute systems; however, the recent development of electroacoustic methods has extended analysis to concentrated slumes containing up to 50% vol/vol solids [73]. The electroacoustic effect is the response charged particles to an applied alternating electrical or acoustical field [74], in contrast to the static field employed in electrophoresis. The acoustical response results from relative vibratory motion between particle and medium if the two phases differ in density. If an alternating electrical field is applied, charged particles vibrate in a back-and-forth motion in phase with the applied field, producing a sound wave whose pressure amplitude is proportional to the particle mobility and <.This technique is termed electrokinetic sonic amplitude (ESA). Alternatively, if an ultrasonic wave is applied, the particles vibrate at the sound
<
<
.
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS
I47
frequency, producing a measurable electrical field that is proportional to the particle mobility. This is termed the ulfrasonic vibration potential (WP). ESA is directly proportional to the dynamic mobility, whereas UVP requires knowledge of the high-frequency conductivity the slurry. For this reason, ESA is frequently used for routine analysis of powder slumes under processing conditions An example of the application of ESA to powder characterization is given in Fig. where the effect surface cleaning on a Si3N4 powder is evidenced by a shift in pHiep of the aqueous slurry. This shift is caused by a reduction the surface oxide layer thickness.
B. Overview of Interface Analysis Techniques The most important group of surface properties that characterize an aqueous powder suspension are its acid-base properties. The reaction of surface species with H+ and OH- in solution controls the surface charge and potential as a function of pH. The surface charge and point of zero net charge may be determined from potentiometric and conductometric titrations. In a potentiometric titration, pH is measured as a function of the amount of base or acidadded. Titration curves for the suspension and solution blank are subtracted to obtain a proton uptake curve at several ionic strengths. The common intersection point of this set of curves denotes the point of zero charge, which, once known, maybeused to calculate charge densities at any pH. Solution conductivity may also be used as an indicator in acid-base titrations. Here changes in the slope correspond to reaction end points. Isotopic exchange of radioactively labeled compounds is useful for characterizing the labile nature of complexes formed between surface and solution species and the availability of surface sites Surface complexes and bonding mechanisms may be identified using in situ spectroscopic methods, such as cylindrical internal reflection Fourier transform infrared This technique is sensitive to IR-active vibrations of the interfacial region and is less inhibited by the strong OH absorption interference normally encountered when IR is performed in aqueous environments. The interference problem is avoided by using blank subtraction methods and an internal reflection element that reduces the signal from bulk water by sampling only a microscopic distance into the adjacent suspension. Another technique is extended x-ray absorption fine structure This method allows measurement of the local structural environment around species complexed at the solid/solution interface and yields interatomic distances and the coordination number of the nearest neighbors. Calorimetry measures the enthalpic contributions to interfacial chemical reactions and, in combination with potentiometric titration, can be an effective tool for characterizing powder surface chemistry. The heat of adsorption provides information regarding the affinity and interaction mechanism between solution species and the powder surface.
MALGHAN ET AL.
cleaned surface 0.6
\
&
W
0.3
0.0
-0.3
as-received
-0.6
5
6
7
Q
PH Electrokinetic sonic amplitude analysis Si3N4 slumes before and after powder surface cleaningby Soxhlet extraction. The isoelectric pointsare indicated in parentheses.
VII. This review of physical, bulk chemical, surface chemical, and spectroscopic techniques for the characterization of powders shows that no one or two techniques can provide all the necessary details regarding powder properties. In fact, each method reveals a distinctly different characteristic of the powder. Often, a choice must be made in terms of the selection and measurement of relevant properties of a powder. Whenone is faced with this question of which specific properties to measure, the relationships between powder properties and their effect on the final microstructure and properties of the ceramic should be explored. Currently, the quality and reproducibility of data are significantly affected by the unavailability of standard methods and standard reference materials. Efforts are underway in different organizations around the world to alleviate this problem.
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS
Halloran, J. W., Role of powder agglomerates in ceramics processing, in Formingof Ceramics, Vol. (J. A. Mangels and G.L. Messing, ed.), American Ceramics Society, Columbus, OH, pp. Malghan, G., Dragoo, A.L., Hsu, M., Hausner, H., and Pompe, R., Physical and chemical characterization of ceramic powders in an international interlaboratory comparison program, Materials Science Monogram,Ceramics, TodayTomorrow’s Ceramics, Part D, Malghan, G., and Dragoo, A. L., Characterization of ceramic powders, in Engineered Materials Handbook4eramic and Glasses, ASM International, pp. Weiner, B. B., and Fairhurst, D., How to choose particle size analyzer: Consideringquantitativeandqualititaitiveneeds, Powder Bulk Eng., February, Lloyd, P.J. (ed.), Particle Size-Analysis, Wiley-Interscience, New York, Chapman and Hall, London, Allen, T.,Particle Size Measurement, Malghan, G., et al., Statistical analysis of parameters affecting measurementof particlesize-distribution of siliconnitride by sedigraph, Powder Technol., 73, Frock, H. N., and Weiss, E. L. Particle size control using light-scattering technology, Powder Technol., Brunaur, Emmett, P. H., and Teller, Adsorption of gases in multimolecular layers, J. Am. Chem. Soc., Lowell, and Shield, J. E., Powder Surface Area and Porosity. 2nd ed., Chap man and Hall, London, Washbum, E. W., Phys. Rev., 17, Vickers, T. J., Atomic Fluorescence and Atomic Absorption Spectroscopy Methods in Modern Chemical Analysis, Vol. Academic Press, New York, pp. Abraham, R.J., Fisher, J., and Loftus, P., Introduction to NMR Spectroscopy, John Wiley & Sons, New York, Poole, T. P., and Farach, H.A., Theory of Magnetic Resonance, John Wiley & Sons, New York, Ferrar, T. C., and Becker, E. D., Pulse and Fourier Transform NMR, Academic Press, New York, Fyfe, C. A., Solid State NMR for Chemists, CFC Press, Guelph, Ontario, Canada, Lippmaa, E.,Joon, E., Heinmaa, I., Miidel, V., Miller, A., Stem, R., Furo, I., Mihaly, L., and Banki, P., NMR studies of high temperature superconductors,Physica C , 91, Lutgemeier, H., N M R and NQR investigation of high-Tc superconductors, Physica C , 95, Brinkmann, D., N M R and NQR studies in YBazCu307-6,Physica C, 75,
150
MALGHAN ET AL..
20. Mihaly, L., FWo, I., Pekker, Banki, P., Lippmaa, E., Miidel, V., Joon, E., and Heinmaa, Localizedmagneticmomentsinoxygendeficient YBa~Cu307-6, Physica C, 87, 153-155 (1988). 21. Warren, W.W., Walstedt,R.E.,Bell,R. F., Brennert, G. F., Cava, R.J., Espinosa, G. P., and Remeika, J. P., N M R and NQR studies of high-Tc superconductors, Physicu C, 79, 153-155 (1988). 22. Engelhardt, G., and Michel, D.,High Resolution Solid-state NMR Silicates and Zeolites. John Wiley & Sons, New York, 1987. 23. Glave, C. L., Davis, P.J., and Smith, D.M., Surface area determination viaNMR: Fluid and frequency effects, Powder Technol., 261 (1988). 24. Wang, P. S., and Wittbery, T.N., Surface characterization of 1,3,5-triamino-2,4,6trinitrobenzene byx-rayphotoelectronspectroscopyandFouriertransformnuclear magnetic resonance, J . Mater. Sci., 1533 (1989). 25. Bastow, T. J., AnNMR study of137Ba and 47.49Tiin ferroelectric BaTi03, J . Phys., Condens. Mater., I , (1989). 26. Yang, W., and Kirkpatrick, R. J., 3*P and 29Si magic-angle sampling-spinning NMR investigation of the structural environmental of phosphorous in alkalineearth silicate glasses, J. Am. Cerum. 69(10), C-222, (1986). 27. Carduner, K. R., Carter, R. O., III, Milberg, M. E., and Crosbie, G. M., Determination of phase composition of silicon powders by silicon-29 magic angle spinning nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, Anal. Chem., 59, 2794 (1987). 28. Guth, J. R., and Petuskey, W. P., Silicon-29 magic angle sample spinning nuclear resonance characterization of S i c polytypes, J . Phys. Chem., 5361 (1987). 29. Grutzeck, M., Benesi, A., and Fanning, B., Silicon-29 magic angle spinning nuclear magnetic resonance study of calcium silicate hydrates, J . Am. Ceram. (4), 665 (1989). 30. Sindorf, D.W., and Maciel, G. E., Cross-polarization/magicangle spinning silicon-29 nuclear magnetic resonance studyof silica gel using trimethysilane bondingasaprobe of surfacegeometryandreactivity. J . Phys. Chem., 68,5209 (1982). 31. Taki, T., Ohamura, K., and Sato, M., A study of the oxidation curing mechanism of polycarbosilane fibre by solid state high resolution nuclear magnetic resonance, J. Muter. Sci., 1263 (1989). Richardson, M. F., Shemff, B. J., and Winsborrow, B. G., Magic 32. Hamnan, J. angle spinning NMR studies of silicon carbide: Polytypes, impurities, and highly inefficient spin-lattice relaxation, J . Am. Chem. 6059 (1987). 33. Dupree, R., Lewis, M. H., Leng-Ward, G., and Williams, D. S., Coordination of Si atomsinsilicon-oxynitridesdetermined by magic-angle-spinningNMR, J . Mater. Sci. Lett., 393 (1985). 34. Hatfield, G. R., and Carduner, K. R., Solid state N M R : Applications in high performance ceramics, J. Mater. Sci., 4209 (1989). 35. Wertz, J. E., and Bolton, J. R., Electron Spin Resonance: Elementary Theory and Practical Applications, McGraw-Hill, New York, 1972. 36. Willard, H. H., Memtt, L. L., and Dean, J. A., Instrumental Methods ofAnulysis. 5th D. Van Nostrand, New York, 1974, p. 796.
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS
151
Cline, J. P., XRD standard reference materials-their characterization and uses, in Accuracy in Powder Diffraction 11, NIST Special Publication, Czandema, A. W. (ed.), Methods of Surface Analysis, Elsevier, New York, Carlson, T. A., Photoelectron and Auger Electron Spectroscopy, Plenum Press, New York, Muilenberg, G. E. (ed.), Handbook of X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy, PerkinElmer Corporation, Eden Prairie, Minnesota, Scofield, J. H., Hartree-Slater subshell photoionization cross sections at and eV, J . Elec. Spec. Relat. Phenom., Wang, P. Hsu, M., and Wittberg, T. N. Oxidation kinetics of silicon carbidewhiskers studied by x-rayphotoelectronspectroscopy, J . Mater. Sci., 26, Wang, P. Hsu, M., Malghan, G., and Wittberg, T. N., Surface oxidation kinetics of Si3N4-4%Y203powdersstudied by bremsstrahlung-excitedAuger spectroscopy, J. Mater. Sci., 26, Powell, C. J., Energy and material dependence of the inelastic mean free path of low-energy electrons in solids, J. Vac. Sci. Technol., Powell, C. J., and Seah, M. P., Precision, accuracy, and uncertainty in quantitativesurfaceanalyses by Auger-electronspectroscopyandx-rayphotoelectron spectroscopy, J. Vac. Sci. Technol., Tanuma, S., Powell, C. J., and Penn, D. R., Calculation of electron inelastic mean free paths. II. Data for elements over the eV range, Interfac. Anal., 17, Tanuma, Powell, C. J., and Penn, D. R., Calculation of electron inelastic mean free paths. m. Data for inorganic compounds over the eV range, Surf. Interfac. Anal.,17, G., Hsu, M., and Wittberg, T. N., Surface oxidation 48. Wang, P. S., Malghan, of silicon carbide platelets as studied by x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy and bremsstrahlung-excited Auger electron spectroscopy, Surf. Inte~ac.Anal., 18, Wang, P. Malghan, G., Hsu, M., and Wittberg, T. N., Oxidation of surface-treated S i c platelets studied by X P S and bremsstrahlung-excited AES, Interfac. Anal., 20, Wang, P. Malghan, G.,Hsu, M., andWittberg,T. N., Effects of asilicon nitride powder processing on surface oxidation kinetics, submitted to J. Mater. Res., Pugh, R. J., Surface chemical analysis of oxidized ultrafhe a-Sic powdersby electron spectroscopy, J . Coll. Interfac. Sci., 138, Jenett, H., Bubert, H., and Grallath, E., Comparative surface and bulk analysis of oxygen in Si3N4 powders, Fresenius Z. Anal. Chem., 333, Taylor, T. N., The surface composition of silicon carbide powders and whiskers: An XPS study, J . Mater. Res., 4(1), Rahaman, M.N., Boiteux, Y., and De Jonghe, L. C., Surface characterization of silicon nitride and silicon carbide powders, Am. Ceram. Soc. Bull., 15(8),
152
MMGHAN ET AL..
55. Malghan, G., Pei, P., and Wang, P. Interface chemistry of silicon carbide platelets during alumina coating, Ceram. Eng. Sci. Proc., 12(9-lo), 21 15-2122 (1991). 56. Raider, R., Flitsch, R., Aboaf, J. A., and Pliskin, W.A., Surface oxidation of silicon nitride films, J . Electrochem. Soc., Solid-state Sci. Technol., 123(4), 560 (1976). 57. Adair, J. H., Mutsuddy, B. C., and Drauglis, E. J., Stabilization of silicon carbide whiskersuspensions. I. Influence of surfaceoxidation inaqueoussuspensions, Adv. Ceram. Mater., 3(3), 231 (1988). Malghan, G., Hsu, M., Bartenfelder, D. C., and Hegemann, B., 58. Wang, P. Surface chemistry of a-alumina powder treated by aqueous and nonaqueous solvents, Ceram. Trans., 22, 217 (1991). 59. Konstadinidis, K.,Thakkar, B., Chakraborty, A., Potts, L. W., Tannenbaum, R., and Tirrell, M., Segment level chemistry and chain conformation in the reactive adsorption of poly(methy1 methacrylate) on aluminum oxide surfaces,Langmuir, 8, 1307 (1992). 60. King, G. W., Spectroscopy and Molecular Structure, Holt, Rinehart, and Winston, New York, 1964. Molecular Spectroscopy, McGraw-Hill,New 61. Barrow, G . M.,Introductionto York, 1962. and Straw, H., Spectroscopy, Macmillan, New York, 1962. 62. Walker, 63. Highfield, J. G., andBowen, P., Diffuse-reflectance Fourier transform infrared spectroscopic studies of the stability of aluminum nitride powder in an aqueous environment, Anal. Chem., 61, 2399 (1989). 6 4 . Reisgraf, D.A., and May, M. L., Infrared spectra of aluminum hydroxide chlorides, Appl. Spectrosc., 32, 362 (1976). 65. Stein, H. J., and Wegener, H. A. R., Chemically bound hydrogen in CVD Si3N4: Dependenceon NH3/Sifi ratio andonannealing, J. Electrochem. Soc., Solid State Sci. Technol., 124, 908 (1977). 66. Tsuge, A., Uwamino, Y., and Ishizuka, T., Determination of silicon dioxide insiliconcarbide by photoacousticinfraredFourier-transformspectroscopy, Appl. Spectrosc., 42, 168 (1988). in sil67. Tsuge, A., Uwamino, Y., and Ishizuka, T., Determination of silicon dioxide icon carbide by diffuse reflectance infrared Fourier transform spectroscopy, Appl. Spectrosc., 40, 310 (1986). 68. Kizling, M. B., Gallas, J. P., Binet, C., and Lavalley, J. C., Surface oxidation of silicon carbide: Quantitative measurement andRh effect, Mater. Chem. Phys., 30, 273 (1992). 69. Chamova, L. V., Smimova, T. P., Ayupov, B. M., and Belyi, V. I., The influence of the chemical composition of silicon nitride films on their thermal oxidation parameters, Thin Solid Films, 303 (1981). 70. Hunter, R. J., Zeta Potential in-,ColloidScience, Academic Press, London, 1931. 71. Hackley, V. A., and Anderson, M. A., Effects of short-range forces on the longrange structure of hydrous iron oxide aggregates, Langmuir, 5, 191-198 (1989). 72. Hansmann, D.D., and Anderson, M. A., Using electrophoresis in modeling sul-
CHARACTERIZATION OF ADVANCED CERAMIC POWDERS
153
fate, selenite, and phosphate adsorption onto goethite, Environ. Sci. Technol., 19, Oja, T., Peterson, G., and Cannon, D., U.S. Patent Marlow, B. J., Fairhurst, D., and Pendse, H. P., Colloid vibration potential and the electrokinetic characterization of conccentrated colloids, Lungmuir, Babchin, A. J., Chow, R. and Sawatzky, R. P., Electrokinetic measurements by electroacousticalmethods, Adv. Coll. Interfac. Sci., O’Brien, R. W., Midmore, B. R., Lamb, A., and Hunter, R. J., Electroacoustic studies of moderately concentrated colloidal suspensions, Disc. Faraday SOC., Hackley, V. Premachandran, R. and Malghan, G., to be published in Cerami. Trans., Huang, C. P., The Surface acidity of hydrous oxides, in adsorption of inorganics at Solid-Liquid Interfaces, Anderson and A. J. Rubin, (ed.), Ann Arbor Science Publishers, Ann Arbor, Michigan, pp. Labib M. W., and Robertson, A.A., The conductometric titration of lattices, J. Coll. Interfac. Sci., 77, Atkinson, R. J., Posner, A. M., and Quirk, J. P., The kinetics of isotopic exchange of phosphate at the a-FeOOH-aqueous solution interface, J. Inorg. Nucl. Chem., Tejedor-Tejedor, M.I.,Yost, E. C., andAnderson,M.A., Characterization of benzoic complexes at the goethite/aqueous solution interface using cylindrical internalreflectionFouriertransforminfraredspectroscopy.Part I. Methodology, Lungmuir, Hayes, K. F., Roe, A. L., Brown, G. E., Hodgson, K. O., Leckie, J. O., and Parks, G. A., In-situ x-ray absorption study of surface complexes: Selenium oxyanions on a-FeOOH, Science, Machesky, M. L., and Anderson, M. A., Calorimetric acid-base titrationsof aqueous goethite and rutile suspensions, Lungmiur, 2,
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
POWDER PROCESSING
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
7 Colloid Interface Science for Ceramic Powder Processing Hyun M. Jang Pohang University Science and Technology Pohang, Republic Korea
INTRODUCTION Interfacial phenomena at metal oxide/water interfaces are fundamental to various phenomena in ceramic suspensions, such as dispersion, coagulation, coating, and viscous flow. The behavior of suspensions depends in large part on the electrical forces acting between particles, which in turn are affected directly by surface electrochemical reactions. Therefore, this chapter first reviews fundamental concepts and knowledge pertaining to electrochemical processes at metal oxide powder (ceramic powder)/aqueous solution interfaces. Colloidal stability and powder dispersion and packing are then discussed in terms of surface electrochemical properties and the particle-particle interaction in a ceramic suspension. Finally, several recent examples of colloid interfacial methods applied to the fabrication of advanced ceramic composites are introduced.
II.
INTERFACIALELECTROCHEMICALCHARACTERISTICS
A.
Origins of Surface Charge at the Ceramic Powder/ Water Interface
Most substances in contact with an aqueous medium acquire a surface electrical charge caused by a redistribution of charge in the interfacial region. This process is described as the formation of an electrified interface, namely, an electrical double layer. 157
JANG
158
Several types of redistribution of charges are possible [1,2]: 1. The ionization of ionogenic groups; proteins acquire their charge mainly by ionization of -COOH and -NH2 groups to give -COO- and -NH3+. 2. Unequal dissolution of oppositely charged ions of which the solid phase may be composed (e.g., silver halide particles suspended in water). 3. Unequal adsorption of ions of opposite charge by the solid phase. Adsorption and orientation of dipolar molecules. With regard to ceramic powder (inorganic metal oxides), most experimental studies have revealed the special role of hydrogen and hydroxide ions in determining both the surface charge and potential of all inorganic oxides. It was observed that small changes in concentration of acid or base are able drastically to change the sign and magnitude of the surface charge or potential [3]. On the other hand, the addition of other simple inorganic electrolytes has a smaller effect and usually does not change the pH of the suspension at which the charge and the potential of the oxide are zero [3]. Therefore, the electrical double layer at the ceramic powder/aqueous solution interface is considered established by the unequal adsorption of H+ and OH-. The adsorption mechanism of H+ and OH- has long been attributed to the amphoteric reaction of the surface hydroxide groups -M-OH This is schematically represented as
-M-OH+H+ -M-OH
2
K F ! !
-M-OH:
-M-O- + H +
where -M-OH2+ and 44-0-represent positive and negative surface sites. An alternative to the H+ and OH- adsorption mechanism, suggested by Parks and de Bruyn [S], involves the adsorption of metal-hydroxo complexes derived from the hydrolysis products of materials dissolved from the solid oxide. In case the charge is also caused by amphoteric dissociation of hydroxide groups, but the hydroxide groups are considered a part of the adsorbed hydroxo complexes rather than the real surface. The distinction between these two mechanisms is a fine one, the end result being the same or very similar, depending on how the hydroxo complexes are adsorbed. The main difference is that, in the adsorbed hydroxo complex mechanism, the surface must first dissolve sufficiently to provide enough hydrolysis products and establish the surface charge upon their adsorption. The experimental fact that charged oxide/water interfaces are readily identified through such techniques streaming potential, in which the concentration of hydrolysis products is very unlikely to be significant, indicates that these species are not indispensable to establish the electrified interface. Therefore, the surface
159
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
dissociation reactions given in Eq. (1) must represent the most important charging mechanisms, but some contribution to the surface charge from the adsorption of soluble hydroxo species cannot completely ruled out. The surface charge density on oxides is then given by the difference in adsorption density of hydrogen and hydroxide ions r w and rOH- respectively, and it is defined as
where F is the Faraday constant, is commonly expressed in pC/cmz, andrH+ and ToH- are in mol/cm*. Since the adsorption of hydrogen and hydroxide ions determines both the surface electrical charge and the surface coulombic potential yo, they are called the potential-determining ions (PDI) for metal oxides When these surface parameters (i.e., the surface charge density and the surface coulombic potential) are zero, the solid is said to be at its point of zero charge (PZC). Since the PZC is conveniently represented by - log (activity of the potential-determining ions), it designates the equilibrium suspension pH when the surface charge density at the ceramic particles/aqueous solution interface becomes zero. Thus, this value gives the solution conditions under which the surface is uncharged and the suspension is destabilized. Therefore, a suspension is stable only if the pH is kept sufficiently far from the PZC. Approximate values of the PZC various ceramic materials are listed in Table 1.
Table
Point Zero Charge (PZC) Various Aqueous Ceramic Suspensions
pH
Material Silica, Tin oxide (cassiterite) Titania (rutile, anatase) Zirconia Chromium oxide Goethite (FeOOH) Boehmite (AIOOH) Hematite (synthetic) Alumina (aand y) Calcite (CaC03) Magnesia Mullite (3A1203 . 2Si02) Cordierite
PZC 2-3
12 2-3
JANG
B.
BasicElectricalDouble-LayerTheory
In the preceding section the origin of the surface charge at the ceramic powder/water interfacewasdiscussed. maintainelectroneutrality,the surface charge is then balanced by an equal and opposite charge in the mobile aqueous phase (counterions). This compensating solution charge is created by the adsorption (or condensation) of electrolyte ions at the solution side of the interface. The distribution of the interfacial charges and the consequent variation in the electrostatic potential is the concern of the theory of the electrical double layer (EDL). The well-known Gouy-Chapman-Stem-Grahame(GCSG) model, which has been successfully applied to mercury/solution interfaces by Grahame [6]and to AgI/solution interfaces by other investigators [2], is briefly outlined here. The characteristics of the EDL and the problems associated with a directapplication of theGCSGmodel to themetal oxide (ceramic powder)/aqueous solution interface are then discussed in the next two sections. In the GCSG model, inaddition to the surface charge itself, the solution side of the electrical double layer (or simply the diffuse layer) is regarded as consisting of two regions: an outer diffuse region, in which the ions undergo thermal motion and are distributed according to the equilibrium Boltzmann distribution, and an inner region, where any adsorbed ions are relatively immobile. The Gouy-Chapman theory of the diffuse layer at a charged interfacial region is based on the well-known Poisson-Boltzmann equation:
where v is the mean coulombic potential at any point in the diffuse layer, ni is the number of ions of type i per unit volume in the bulk solution, zi is their valency, including sign, e is the electron charge, &b is the dielectricconstant of themedium, isthepermittivity of vacuum x 10-I2F/m), k is the Boltzmann constant, and T is the absolute temperature. For a single symmetrical z/z electrolyte and a flat interface, Eq. (3) is readily solved with the boundconditions = at x = 0 and = @/& = 0 at = (bulk solution), to give
-
where
COLLOID INTERFACE SCIENCE and
(E;;)
I61
112
K=
= 3.29 x
m-’ at 298 K
where C is the bulk electrolyte concentration in mol/dm3. The quantity IC’ is the center of gravity of the diffuse layer charge and is generally referred to as the “thickness” of the diffuse layer or the Debye-Huckel length. The diffuse layer charge o d is the charge contained in a cylinder of unit cross-sectional area extending from x = 0 to x = and is given by
For curved interfaces, cannot be solved analytically. For spherical interfaces, the Debye-Huckel approximation can be applied, provided that zew 25 mV. Alternatively, solutions may be obtained by numerical methods with the aid of a computer, as have been fully compiled for spherical double layers by Loeb et al. schematic representation of the inner region of the double layer model is shown in Fig. 1. Figure l b describes the distribution counterions and the potential profile w ( ~from ) a positively charged surface. The potential decay is caused by the presence counterions in the solution side (mobile phase) the double layer. The inner Helmholtz plane (IHP) or the inner Stem plane (ISP) is the plane through the centers of ions that are chemically adsorbed (if any) on the solid surface. The outer Helmholtz plane (OW)or the outer Stem plane (OSP) is the plane of closest approach of hydrated ions (which do not adsorb chemically) in the diffuse layer. Therefore, the plane that corresponds to x = 0 in Eq. coincides with the OHP in the GCSG model. The doublelayer charge and potential are defined in such a way that 00 and WO, and wp, and o d and w d are the charge densities and mean potentials of the surface plane, the Stem layer (IHP), and the diffuse layer, respectively (Fig. 1). the analogy of the Langmuir adsorption isotherm, one can derive the following equation (the Stem equation) for caused by the adsorption of ions at the IHP (or ISP):
where Ns is the number of available adsorption sites per unit area, No is Avogadro’s number, M is the molecular weight of the solvent, z* is the valence of cations or anions, including sign, and nf is the bulk concentration of the ionic species in ions cm-3. The terms I$+and Q- are the specific adsorption potentials
I62
JANG
(ISP) (OSP)
Potential
0
P P+Y
Distance "I>
shear plane 0
Potential
IHP
zeta potential reversal 0
0
P P+Y Distance
+
Theelectricaldoublelayer:(a)theinnerregion theelectricaldouble layer, showing the location the M P , O W ,potentials y, and charge densities o;(b) distribution counterions and the potential profile y ( x ) from the positively charged solid surface; (c) distribution and potential drop across the double layerin the presence specifically adsorbed ions.
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
I63
that take into account any noncoulombic contribution to the adsorption energy, changes in the state of solvation of the adsorbed ions, and covalent, van der Waals, or hydrogenbondingbetween the adsorbate and the surface.When these noncoulombic interactions significantly contribute to the total free energy of adsorption + $), adsorption is said to be specific [1,6], and the extent of adsorption then depends on the nature as well the charge of ions. An important consequence is that a specifically adsorbed ion can adsorb against electrostatic repulsion (i.e., and the surface charge may be exceeded by the specifically adsorbed charge >loot, as shown in Fig. IC), therefore reversing the diffuse layer charge. The charge densities at the surface plane, the IHP (or ISP) and the OHP (or OSP), are related by the necessity for overall electrical neutrality:
The potential drop between each plane is assumed linear, and the integral capacity per unit area Ki of the zone between the surface and the IHP is then given by
where &I and P are the dielectric constant and the distance shown in Fig. 1. The integral capacity KO per unit area between the IHP and the OHP is given bY
where and y are the dielectricconstant and the distance between theIHF' and the OHP, respectively. Therefore, (5) through (9) relate the six variables op, 00,od,yp, yo, and y d of the GCSG model of the electrical double layer. Hence, if one of the variables is known, then the others can be calculated, provided that values for the parameters N,, $*, Ki,and KO are also known. In the simple GCSG model already described, the charge densities are assumed uniformly smeared over each plane rather than in the form of discrete ions. Levine and co-workers [8] modified the GCSG model by introducing the discreteness of charge effect to account for various phenomena, mostly relating to adsorption at the mercury/water and silver iodide/water interfaces. Their theory shows that the electrostatic work of adsorption at the IHP is not but
I64
JANG
where is the micropotential in the hole created by the rearrangement of the other adsorbed ions and $‘p is the self-atmosphere potential. The calculation of $‘p is rather complicated and depends on the physical properties of the inner region. An interesting consequence of the discreteness of charge theory is that it predicts that a maximum may be observed in the OHP potential This is a possible explanation for the maxima sometimes observed in electrokinetic potentials as the surface potential is increased. The work of Wiese et al. on silica is a representative example of the applicability of this theory. Among the six interfacial variables discussed inthis section, the surface charge density the surface potential yo, and the potential at the OHP yd (usually called the diffuse layer potential), are most important in characterizing interfacial properties. The three remaining variables (i.e., yp, and od) can be estimated using Eqs. (5), and (8) if 00, yo, and yd are known exactly. can be determined experimentally by the potentiometric titration method, and detailed explanation of the potentiometric titration is given, for example, by Yates [lo]. The estimate of yo for the ceramic powder/aqueous lution interface is discussed in the next section. y d is perhaps the most important interfacial electrochemical parameter since it is closely correlated with the kinetic stability of a given colloidal suspension and it can be conveniently determined (approximately) experimentally. One method of estimating involves applying an electrical field across a dispersion of particles and measuring the resulting particle velocity. This technique, known as electrophoresis, allows measurement of the so-called potential or slipping plane potential. The slipping plane (or shear plane) arises as solid particles move through the fluid, causing the counterions in the diffuse layer to slip away and leaving some of the interfacial charges uncompensated (electrokinetic effect). Although the location of the shear plane is not known exactly, it is likely to be located at a small distance farther from the surface than the O W , that Iyd. Various careful studies showed that the identity of with yd is reasonable for low potentials (for yd less than -1OOmV at 1C2 M electrolyte concentration). At higher potentials, particularly at high electrolyte concentration, the shear plane probably shifts farther from the surface, and 161 is expected to be less than yd. In systems in which polymer adsorption is known to occur, the slipping plane is located rather far from the surface and the electrokinetic effects are reduced. The solution condition at which the 6 potential (or yd) reverses sign has been termed the isoelectric point (IEP) or, simply, the point of 6 potential reversal (PZR). Although both the PZC and the PZR usually give rise to a zero 6 potential, the PZR is a result of surface charge compensation by a strong adsorption at the IHP (00 + op = od = 0 in Fig. l), but at the PZC there is no surface charge (00= 0 in Fig. 1). More recently, the electrophoretic laser light-scattering method was used to
<
<
<
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
I65
c
estimate diffusion coefficients and potentials of small colloid particles by measuring the Doppler shift of the frequency of the scattered light caused by the velocity of the scattering centers [ 1 l]. In addition, the electrokinetic sonic amplitude method is actively applied to the measurement of electrophoretic mobility (thus, potential), especially for a concentrated suspension. In method, an alternating electrical field is applied to the suspension. This createsrelativemovementbetween the colloidparticlesandthe rounding medium, generating a sound wave at the same frequency as the electrical field. The acoustic energy generated is proportional to the electrophoretic mobility. correlation between these measurements and the potential values was established through this relationship [12].
c
c
Surface Potential of a Charged Interface
C.
Because they are electrical insulators, the net potential difference across a ceother ramic powder/water interface yo cannot be directly measured. On the hand, the other two important interface variables (GO and yd) can be measured or estimated, as discussed in the previous section. Therefore, one should be able to calculate or reasonably estimate yo from other experimentally observable quantities for a complete characterization of interfacial properties. In section we first introduce the so-called Nemst approximation for the surface potential yo. The limitation of the Nemst equation is then discussed, and the modified Nemst equation for yo of a ceramic powder/aqueous solution interface is subsequently introduced. The general derivation of an equation for the potential difference across an interfacehasbeenthoroughlytreated by Parsons [l] andalso by Overbeek [13]. The starting point is the condition for thermodynamic equilibrium between the two bulk phases a and p, given by
where jila is the total work required to move charged species from a point in a vacuum and infinitely distant from the phase a to a point in the bulk phase a.This quantity ji is called the electrochemical potential and is given by
F:
+ RT In
+Z,.F$~
where jiP is the standard chemical potential, is the chemical activity of species in phase a, is the charge of that species, F is the Faraday constant, and I$P is the Galvani or inner potential of the phase a. Btrub6 and de Bruyn [l41 pointed out that electrochemical equilibrium between both bulkphases and the surface phase must be considered when the surface potential y o is introduced. Hence, the equilibrium condition to be satisfied is
I66
JANG
where the superscript S refers to the surface phase. Using Eqs. (12) and (13), the inner potential difference between the surface phase and the bulk phase p (mobile liquid phase) can be written as
where
On defining the surface potential yo as the difference in the inner potential between the surface phase and the bulk phase p, Eq. (14) becomes
are the activities of species i in the bulk phase p and the surwhere aPBand face phase S, respectively, when WO = 0. discussed in Sect. it has been experimentally observed that H+ and OH- are the potential-determining ions for metal oxides, even when these ions are not present in the solid phase. By analogy with Eq. (15), the general form of the Nemst equation describing the surface potential of metal oxides can be written as
where the superscript for the bulk aqueous phase has been omitted and is the activity of H+ in the bulk aqueous phase. Only if the surface activity of hydrogen ions is constant and independent of y o does Eq. (16) become the often assumed Nernst equation for metal oxides:
where pH0 = - log the pH at which yo = 0 (i.e., PZC). number of authors [1+16], however, have questioned the validity of this equation for metal oxides. It is now generally recognized that the Nemst approximation for metal oxides is doomed to failure. The problem is in the assumption that the activity of the potential-determining ions on the surface is independent of the surface potential (zeroth order approximation). For example, as the bulk pH decreases
COLLOID INTERFACE SCIENCE
167
and deviates from the PZC, the surface charge density, and thus the surface potential, increases [Eq. (l)]. The probability of finding positively charged sites adjacent to a given positively charged site (-M-OH2+) then increases. This increases repulsive interaction energy on the positively charged sites. The increased repulsive interaction energy enhances the chemical potential and, thus, the activity of positive sites significantly. Therefore, the surface activity hydrogen ions or positive sites is no longer constant, and one cannot derive the Nemst equation. An alternative derivation of Eq. (16), based on the amphoteric reactions of the surface hydroxide groups, given as Eq. (l), has been proposed by Levine and Smith [16].Using the random mixing approximation for the distribution of thethreetypes of surface sites [i.e.,neutral,positive,and negative sites, as shown in Eq. (l)], these authors were able to derive an expression for the dependence ofon the oxide surface. The derivation has also been outlined by Smith [2],and the modified Nernst equation can be written as RT F
\vo = 2.303 -(pH,
RT 2F
r-MO-
- pH) + -In r-MOH;
The first term of the equation clearly represents the Nernst term. Therefore, Eq. (18) can be regarded as a modified version of the Nernst equation relating to the solution pH and taking into account the variation in the surface activity of H' with the surface charge. calculate y o from the solution pH, it is necesto know the surface density of the positively and negatively charged sites, which in turn depends on the surface charge density 00 and the two surface reaction constants (Kaand Kb) that appeared in (1). Since Eq. (18) is based on the random distribution of the surface sites (first-order approximation), it still does not correctly evaluate the variation of the surface activity as the surface charge density varies. For a better approximation of \vo, the term that takes account of the variation in the surface activity in terms of the probabilities of nearest neighbor pairs, should be included. Within the framework of the random mixing approximation, Eq. (18)is also valid for a more complicated system in which the specific adsorption of multivalent electrolyte ions (i.e., adsorption at the IHP, shown in Fig. 1) does occur [17].In this case, however, r-~oin Eq. (18), for example, should be read as the density (purely) negatively charged sites not occupied by the specifically adsorbed cations.
D.
Interfacial Electrochemical Characteristics of a Ceramic Powder Dispersion
As mentioned previously, potentiometric titration is the most widely used experimental technique to study the electrical double layer on insoluble ceramic
JANG
I68
powder (metal oxides). From the titration data, the net adsorption density of the potential-determiningions ( h + - ToH-) and, hence, the surface charge density can be determined. Further information can be obtained from electrokinetic potential potential) and colloidal stability:these properties are closely related to the charge distribution in the electrical double layer. The potentiometric titrations were first applied by Bolt [181 to the study of double layers on oxides with silica sols and later by Parks and de Bruyn with &Fe203 (hematite) suspensions. Their investigations confirmed the potential-determining role of H+and OH- and indicated that the oxide double layers are significantly different from the well-characterized classic double layers at the AgI/ and HgJsolution interfaces. illustrate the characteristic surface charge data for metal oxides, a selection of results from several laboratories and for several oxides in 0.1 M 1:1 electrolyte is depicted in Fig. 2. The results are shown in terms of CO versus ApH curves, where ApH = pH - pHpzc. A curve of 00 versus pAg for the AgI/O.l M KF interface is included for comparison. The principal feature of
(c
--
& , / ,,.-
-3
-2
-I,
/?/// /.*
."
/
2
l
A ~ H or
PZC 5.85
"
.......... ol- Fe24/KCI PZC IO
---
1"-
PZC 4-Fe00H/KCIt PZC 7.6
Cab"Sil/KCI,
PZC 3
2 Experimental surface charge density data for various metal oxides as a function of ApH(ApAg for AgI) for
M 1:l electrolyte.
AgI
I69
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
the plots in Fig. 2 (and all other surface charge results) is that the magnitude of 00 for oxides other than Si02 is considerably greater than that for the corresponding AgI/solution interface. The various ceramic powder dispersions all show essentially the same type of 00 versus ApH behavior [lo]. The much higher charges on the metal oxides and the steep rise with increase in ApH require some explanation, especially because electrokinetic measurements on metal oxide systems suggest that the diffuse double-layer potentials are quite low comparable to and even less than those of AgI systems. M KC1 suspension, Abendroth [l91 found For example, fora silicaand that at pH 9 the surface charge density was -10 pC/cm2, which is considerably higher than the diffuse layer charge of 1.9 pC/cm2 calculated with E@ ( 5 ) from the corresponding 6 potential of mV. Hence, at pH 9, is approximately 20%. This example is typical of most metal oxide data [10,20]. This difference in charge (i.e., = must be balanced by adsorption of electrolyte ions within the region inside the hydrodynamic slipping plane. account for the apparent strong adsorption of electrolyte ions at the ceramic powder/water interface, Yates et al. [10,21] proposed the formation of "ionpairs" at charged surface sites (the site-bindingmodel for the metal oxide/aqueous solution interface). This model and its modifications have been successfully applied to many oxide/aqueous solution interfaces in the presence of simple monovalent inorganic ions [21-231. For a ceramic powder surface in a simple electrolyte solution (e.g., W03 and NaCl), the formation of ion pairs can be represented as
- "OH
- "OH
+Y +
C
+ H+ + X-
"0-
*..Y++ H+
- M-OH,'
*.*X-
(19)
where YX denotes simple electrolyte present in the bulk solution phase. The formation of ion pairs or "surface complexes" readjusts the acid-base equilibria and could thereby affect the surface charge. According to the sitebinding model, the surface charge 00 determined from the proton balance represents the net number of protons released or consumed by all surface reactions, not merely theformation of the ionized surface sites -MO-and -MOH2+. Therefore, the surface charge density as determined by the potentiometric titration should be read
Increasing electrolyte concentration causes additional binding of counterions until equilibrium is reestablished, subject to theeffects of the electrostatic field. In the site-binding model, therefore, the formation of surface complexes is the principal mechanism by which protons are released or consumed by a ceramic powder surface in an aqueous electrolyte solution. The concentration of
I
JANG
ionized surface sites K-MoH~+ and T-Mo- in Eq. (1) or (2)] is generally small in comparison with the surface complexes (r"MoH2+ x-and T-hfo p). This is partially a result of the perturbation of surface equilibria by the electrostatic field. the surface charge and potential become more negative, the release of a proton by the simple dissociative reaction given as Eq. (1) is opposed by an increasing electrostatic repulsion. However, the formation of such surface complexes as - M O +'l is not retarded in an equivalent manner because of the attractive electrostatic term for thecounterion. similar argument can be made for a positively charged surface: Thus, one of the significant points of the sitebinding model is the inclusion of surface complexation in the development of surface charge. In this manner, the surface complexation (site-binding) model can provide a mechanism for the development of surface charge in addition to the role of protons and hydroxide ions in oxidelaqueous solution systems. Figure is a schematic representation of the surface complexation model for an oxide/aqueous solution interface using the NaCl electrolyte asan example of a counterion [22]. Despite successful applications to many ceramic powdedwater interfaces, the site-binding model has several ambiguities in its description of the nature
3 The surface complexation model for a metal oxide/aqueous solution interface using NaCl electrolyte as an example of counterions.
171
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
of counterions at interfaces. That more than 80% of the counterion charges reside inside the shear plane does not necessarily indicate a strong site binding of counterions with oppositely charged surface groups at the ceramic powder/ aqueous solution interface. There is no unambiguous evidence or picture of the actual distribution or location of the counterions inside the shear plane because of the lack of knowledge of the mean distance of separation between the surface plane and the shear plane = p + in Fig. 1) for the oxide/water interface. In addition, little is known about the nature of counterion interaction with the oxide surface (i.e., real chemical binding versus atmospheric condensation caused by electrostatic attraction). In view of these uncertainties in the description of the oxide/aqueous solution interface, Jang and Fuerstenau [24] sought an in situ spectroscopic method to obtain molecular-level information on the nature of the ceramic powder/ aqueous solution interface. The nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spin-lattice relaxation rate of quadrupole nuclei was used to probe the nature of counterion interaction with the oxide surface [24]. The model system studied was a silica/NaCl electrolyte suspension system since NaCl is a typical electrolyte present in aqueous solutions and both Na+ and C1- have nuclear quadrupole moments (quadrupole nuclei). Measuring the spin-lattice relaxation rates ofNa nuclei at two different NMR resonance frequencies and applying the theoretical equation for the chemical exchange of quadrupole nuclei between two different sites (interface and bulk regions) [25], they could estimate the quadrupole coupling constant and the correlation time of the interfacial Na ions In this way, the mode of counterion-silica interaction (i.e., 430- Na+) could be delineated since the electrical field gradient between two oppositely charged surface atoms (0- and Na') is proportional to the quadrupole coupling constant of the interfacial Na ions. This study clearly showed that the main driving force for the adsorption of Na ions stems from purely electrostatic interaction (atmospheric condensation), without a significant short-range chemical interaction. Therefore, the ion-pair formation represented by (19) is not a correct picture of the SiOdaqueous solution interface. Nevertheless, as mentionedpreviously, more than 80% of the counterion charges reside inside the slipping plane. One possible explanation of this discrepancy is that the location of the shear plane is rather far from the surface of charged particle. In this way, most counterion charges can reside within the slipping plane. In this case, however, they do not necessarily undergo a strong site-binding interaction with the surface groups. Theoretical analysis of the interfacial structure of a TiOdaqueous solution interface based on data for surface charge densities and electrokinetic potentials showed that the location of the shear plane is 10-15 away from the surface which agrees with the conclusion drawn from the analysis of NMR data.
x
-e-
m.
I72
JANG
COLLOIDALSTABILITY AND DISPERSION OR CONSOLIDATION A.
Colloidal Stability
The importance of a high green density with a uniform microstructure to improve the various properties of sintered technical ceramics has been documented in numerous studies. Thus, in recent years, extensive efforts have been made to increase the homogeneity of green compact microstructures [26]. Among these, a colloidal consolidation route using a kinetically stable slip with a narrow particle size distribution has received increasing attention [27-291. It has been well known that the stability of a given lyophobic colloid sol (likea ceramic powder dispersion), according to the DLVO(DeryaguinLandau-Verwey-Overbeek) theory [13], is determined by the balance between the repulsive and attractive forces the particles experience as they approach each other. If the stability is caused by the particle charge (electrostatic stabilization), the repulsion force depends on the degree of electrical double-layer overlap. The attractive force is caused by the London-van der Waals interaction. The total potential energy of interaction VT can readily be adjusted by altering the magnitude of the repulsion, either by increasing the ionic strength of the solution or by changing the surface potential or surface charge on the particles. Using the DLVO theory, the total interaction energy of two spherical particles of radius can be written as [11,13,30]
and Aa 12So
r=2a+So
(23)
where So is the surface-to-surface distance of separation between two approaching particles and k l is the Debye-Huckel length [defined in (4)]. v0 in Eq. (22) is the surface potential and can be replaced, with a good approximation, by the Stem potential v p or the potential, in practice, under the condition of the thermal Brownian collision of two particles [30]. Equation (22) is (23) is the efvalid for a constant, low surface potential and large ka. A in fective Hamaker constant of a given colloidal dispersion and depends on the physical properties of the particles and the dispersion medium. Using the geometrical mean approximation [31], this can be expressed as A = (Asinwhere and are the Hamaker constant for solvent-solvent interaction and that for particle-particle interaction, respectively. The Hamaker constants can
c
173
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
be calculated theoretically using optical dispersion data These values can also be determined experimentally, and these experimental methods include (1) coagulation, equilibrium film thickness, surface tension, and attractive London dispersion force. Figure is a schematic representation the total potential energy interaction versus particle separation. The dotted curve represents the contribution derived from the repulsive electrical double-layer interaction VR, and the dashed line denotes the contribution the attractive London-van der Waals interaction VA. The primary maximum and the shallow secondary minimum in the potential energy curve are denoted Vmax and Vmin, respectively. The overall potential energy barrier to coagulation in the primary minimum (permanent coagulation) is given by the expression Vm, - Vmin. One should also realize that the primary minimum is bounded by the contribution the steep Born repulsion caused by the overlapping interaction the electronic cloud in the atoms and the structural force caused by the bounded layers of liquid at the
l 0
I
8 0
l 0
! 0
1 Secondary MinimumcV,,,i)
/'
/
van der Waals Primary Minimum
potential energy
interaction versus particle separation.
I74
'
JANG
particle surface. Also note that the coagulated state, in which two particles are in the deep primary minimum, is thermodynamically more stable than the dispersed state (So = -). Thus, colloidal stability achieved by the increase in the V,, does not correspond to thermodynamic stability. In most cases, ceramic powder dispersions exhibit this type of potential energy curve. Therefore, a well-dispersed ceramic suspension (or a dispersion of finely divided solid particles, in general) corresponds to a kinetically stable state (lyophobic colloid) without possessing a true thermodynamic stability. Contrary to this general notion that dispersions of finely divided solid particles cannot be thermodynamically stabilized, Stol and de Bruyn [34] discussed the conditions necessary for obtaining a thermodynamically stable dispersion (TSD) of solid particles in an aqueous solution medium. They stressed the role of the adsortion of potential-determining ions in lowering the interfacial free energy to promote spontaneous dispersion and subsequently reasoned that for simple inorganic solids a decrease in by about 200 mN/m relative to its value at the PZC may be sufficient to yield a TSD. However, the existence of thermodynamically stabilized dispersions of inorganic solids has not yet been demonstrated experimentally. Figure 5 shows the calculated potential energy interaction VT of A1203 particles = 0.25 pm, = 4.5 lO-*OJ, and M ionic strength) as a function of the surface-to-surface distance of separation for various conditions of potential in an aqueous suspension. Note that the height of the potential energy barrier increases quite sharply as the potential becomes larger than a certain critical value (-30 mV in Fig. 5). Therefore, the potential is a very good index of the magnitude of the repulsive interaction between colloid particles. Because of this, measurements of potential are most commonly used to assess the stability of a given colloidal sol. A concept of critical colloidal stability can be deduced from the DLVO equations introduced in this section. Using (21), (22), and (23), the total interaction energy between two approaching spheres can be rewritten as
c
c
c
In(1 + e-Go ) - where
and
m=
24m,,ebc2
c
I75
COLLOID INTERFACE SCIENCE
r
AhOa
KNOa
Y,
k -
IO
5 Calculated potential energy of interaction VT of A1203 particles as a function thesurface-to-surfacedistance of separationfor conditions of the potential.
c
Deryaguin [l l] showed that Eq. exhibits a minimum value and a maximum (at smaller So) provided m is less than about 0.5. It is quite likely that rapid coagulation occurs near the point at which the total interaction energy rapidly decreases. Deryaguin further showed that a rapid decrease in stability can be expected when m < which occurs when
For a given system, the quantities A and &b are fixed, that varying the electrolyte (in type and concentration) should produce instability at a particular value of &K (Eilers and Korff rule). To the extent that 6 measures the potential characterizing the diffuse part the electrical double layer, it ishardly surprising that it should provide a good description the dispersion-coagulation process. A much more strict test of the dispersion-coagulation process requires an understanding of the region slow coagulation. The overall kinetic stability
176
JANG
and the process of slow coagulation of a given colloidal dispersion can be obtained by determining the stability ratio W. When the potential is high enough to produce a significant potential energy barrier opposing coagulation, the rate of coagulation caused by the thermal Brownian encounter is slowed by a factor W. The stability ratio (ortheretardation factor) is formally defined as
<
where kr and ks are the second-order rate constant of the rapid coagulation (Smoluchowski limit) and the rate constant of the slow coagulation caused by the existence of the potential energy barrier between two approaching particles, respectively. V d r ) is the total potential energy of interaction between two approaching particles at distance r[= + in or The stability ratio can be qualitatively viewedas the ratio of the total numberof particle collisions for a fixed time interval to the number of collisions forming permanent flocculates (or coagulates). generate a stable sol requires a W value larger than lo3 for moderately concentrated sols. The behavior of marginally stable sols (W = has been studied by Wiese and Healy The 6 potential and the corresponding bility ratio of A1203 suspension in stability region are shown in Fig. Note that, at a given concentration of sol particles and electrolyte, the stability ratio rapidly increases at a certain particular suspension pH and, thus, potential, supporting the concept of the critical stability (Eilers and Korff rule) mentioned previously. Further discussion of the relation between the critical colloidalstability and thepacking density of green body derived fromthe corresponding suspension is provided in the next section. These results also suggest that there is a close parallelism between the stability ratio and the potential, especially near the critical stability region. Indeed, a semiquantitative correlation between the stability ratio and the potential can bemade using the DLVO theory. Reerink and Overbeek [36] provided the following theoretical justification based on the normal distribution approximation for the shape of potential energy curve:
<
<
logW = kl logC+k, where kl = Z
and
2
<
I A
-
q1-I. q l.', lo"
KNO3
IO-~M
-
B
0
ii 5
-
2-
I
(W
I
f5 pH
6 (a)[potentialas a function of pH for A1203 electrolyte(notspecificallyadsorbingion)solution.(b)Stability ,41203 sol as a function pH.
in an indifferent ratio for thesame
JANG
I78
where C is the concentration of the bulk ions in moles per liter, is the radius of particle in meters, and z is the valence of the counterions (electrolyte in the bulk phase). \~roin this equation can again be replaced by the potential. If the 6 potential is less than 51.5 mV at 25"C, e\1ro/2kT (= eCj2kT), which appeared in Eq. (27), can be expanded using the Maclaurin expansion (1:l electrolyte). Then Eq. (27), under this condition, can be rewritten as log W =
-2.15 X 109ae2c2 log c + k2 16(kT)2
e
(for 6 < 50 mV) should give a straight line, withthe slope being a constant positive value (log C 0), if the ionic strength of the medium remains constant. Figure 7 shows the log W versus IQ' diagram for the a-cordierite (2Mg0.2A1203-5Si02; Baikowski International Co., mean radius ~ 0 . 4pm) suspension in the.presence of 0.001 M KNO3. W C in Fig. 7 denotes the critical stability point at which there occurs a rapid increase in the kinetic stability of the dispersion. shown in Fig. 7, there is a close linear correlation between log W and IQ' for < 45 mV. In calculating the repulsive interaction energy between colloidal particles (22)] it is usually assumed that a complete equilibrium exists between the particle surface and the dispersion medium at any separation between the particles. This is not necessarily correct, however, because the adjustment of equilibrium takes a finite time and this time may be longer than the time involved in a collision or longer even than the coagulation time. The time needed for adjusting the structure of the diffuse double layer (the relaxation time of the double layer) is equal to the average time needed for the displacement of ions across the double layer. By comparing the different time scales involved in the collision of colloid particles (i.e., double-layerinteraction,surface-charge adjustment, Brownian collision, and coagulation), Overbeek [30] concluded that the double-layer r e laxation is fast even compared withthe shorter time of Brownian encounter, but the surface-charge adjustment is too slow to follow the single encounter. In general, it may even be too slow to adjust the surface charge within the coagulation time. Consequently, in calculating the interaction energy of two particles, the condition of constant charge is probably a better approximation than thatof constant potential, and intermediate cases may be appropriate in practice. If the constant charge approximation is more appropriate than the constant potential approximation during the collision of particles, VR in (22) should be replaced by the expression derived by Wiese and Healy [37],
Thus, a plot of log W with respect to
vR(00)= v R ( \ I ~ ) - ~ T E O E , ~ \ I ~ ;
In (1 - e(-21GTo))
(29)
where VR (00) denotes the potential energy of repulsion caused by the overlap of the diffuse double layers under the condition of constant surface charge.
I79
COLLOID INTERFACE SCIENCE
2
log
1
2000
1000
3000
l* 7 Correlation the square
the
log
6 potential.
cordierite (2Mg0.2A1203.5Si02)
with
Equation (29) also predicts that VR > VR (\v) for a given suspension condition. Using Equation (22) for the expression V R ( ~ Equation ), (29) can be rearranged as
vR(o0) = -2m0~,a\vtIn - e(-a~)) This equation is again valid for a low surface potential and large m.
B.
Powder Dispersion and Consolidation
Figure 8 shows a correlation of the stability ratio of an A1203 suspension (Sumitomo AKP Hp, 0.01 M ionic strength) with the packing density of A1203 green body prepared by gravimetric sedimentation. The packing densities of A1203 as a function of and the surface charge density GO are also plotted
JANG
I80
in Fig. 8. The result clearly shows that the stability ratio or the 6 potential should be larger than a certain critical value for a green body with high packing density. shown in Fig. 8, the critical stability ratio W Cand the critical 6 potential LCof A1203 suspension are 15.8 and 36 mV, respectively. The equilibrium pH corresponding the critical behavior in the packing density is 7.3 in the presence of 0.01 M KNO3; that is, WC,LC, and Icb(crit)l simultaneously occur at pH 7.3. These kinds of critical behaviors were also observed for centrifugally casted ZrO2 green bodies [38] and seem to be essentially independent of casting methods. The incipient point for a rapid increase in the potential energy barrier (at the 6 potential of -35 mV, or between 30 and mV, shown in Fig. is consistent with the critical 6 potential for a rapid increase in the packing density (36 mV, Fig. 8).
0
1.O
logw
8 Correlation packing density W , lclz, and metric sedimentation with
an A1203 green body prepared
gravi-
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
I81
The critical behavior in the packing density when it is plotted as a function of the square of 6 potential was first demonstrated by Aksay and co-workers [29,39]. They showed that there occurs a significant decrease in the packing density as the interparticle binding energy at the cutoff point E, which is approximately inversely proportional to the square of the 6 potential, is increased. They interpreted the main cause of this rapid decrease in the packing density as the retention of third-generation void space in the colloidal solids formed by gravitational settling [29]. Assuming the sediment to be composed of clusters of a fixed number of particles and the sedimentation density to be inversely proportional to the square of the maximum radius of a cluster (aggregate of particles), they later showed [40] that the packing density exhibits a critical behavior when it is plotted as a function of the binding energy or the square of the 6 potential. The incipient point of stability (or instability) in the 6 potential can be estimated using Eq. (25), and this is 40 mV for A1203 under the condition of 0.01 M ionic strength (IC' = 3.04 nm). A remarkable similarity between the 6 potential for the calculated incipient colloidal stability (40 mV) and the critical 6 potential for a rapid increase in the packing density (36 mV; Fig. 8) indicates that a rapid increase in the packing density occurs only when the colloidal suspension nearly reaches the point of its incipient stability. Scanning electron micrographs of iwo ,41203 specimens sintered at 140OOC for 4 h are shown in Fig. 9. The specimen fabricated using a kinetically stable slip (6 = 56 mV and log W = 1.6 at pH 3) shows a homogeneous microstructure with an essentially pore-free state (Fig. 9a). On the other hand, the sample prepared under the condition of low kinetic stability (6 = mV and log = 0 at pH 9) exhibits a nonuniform microstructure, with the large secondgeneration pores [41] induced by a bridging between agglomerated units in the early stage of sintering (Fig. 9b). The colloidal approach also can be successfully used for a low-temperature sintering of technical ceramics. For example, Yeh and Sacks [42] could prepare an agglomerate-free, fine-sized a-AhO3 suspension. Homogeneous green bodies with -69% relative density and -10 nm median pore radius were prepared by slip casting the well-dispersed suspensions at pH 4 (6 = 75 mV). Samples could be sintered at 1150°C to a relative density > 99.5% and an average grain size of 0.25 pm. It was also found that the shrinkage during drying and sintering is considerably reduced compared with the well-known boehmite solgel process. The 6 potential (or interfacial electrochemical parameters, in general) has also proved to be a valuable guide to the understanding of behavior of a complicated multicomponent metal oxide dispersion. Cordierite is a multicomponent metal oxide system (2Mg0-2A1203-5Si02) and has a wide range of potential applications stemming from its important properties oflowthermal
I82
Microstructures a-Al203 specimens prepared at (a) pH The compacts were sintered at 140OOC for h.
JANG
3 and (b) pH 9.
expansion and dielectric constant coupled with high chemical and thermal bility. However, preparing dense cordien'te ceramics has long been a problem because the narrow sintering range near its incongruent melting point Thus, systematic investigation of the interfacial characteristics and colloidal stability cordierite dispersion was recently made to fabricate cordierite ceramics having a dense and uniform microstructure by a uniform colloid process The electrophoretic mobility, which is proportional to the l, potential of suspension for a fixed electrolyte concentration and particle size, aqueous cordierite suspension is shown inFig. 10. As designated inFig. 10, the cordierite (Baikowski Int. Co., average particle radius pm, specific surface area -3 m*/g)/aqueous solution interface is characterized by three distinct points of the l, potential reversal. The result is quite striking because this type l, potential reversal in a natural suspension metal oxide has not been reported until now. As shown in Fig. 10, the PZR 1 of a cordierite suspension is consistent with the IEP ofa fumed silica (Aerosil 200; Degussa Co., Belgium) suspension. This indicates that the interfacial properties of an aqueous cordierite suspension in an acid region are governed by the surface silanol sites (-SiOH) and therefore suggests that the PZR 1 corresponds the inherent IEP an aqueous cordierite suspension. The anomalous increase in the l, potential above pH 3.5 leads to a second l, potential reversal (PZR2) at a higher pH value. This was attributed to the readsorption of dissolved aluminum hydroxy species via the surface-induced hydrolysis [U],for example,
COLLOID INTERFACE SCIENCE
- MOH+ Al(H20),3+
183
-MO-.*.AlOH(H20)~ + 2H+
- MOH +Al(H20)T
440----Al(OH)2(H20),+ + 3Ht
c
As the pH of a suspension increases further, the potential decreases again, revealing another point potential reversal at PZR 3. A careful analysis of the data indicated that the surface-induced adsorption of the molecular Al(OH)3 and the subsequent formation the hydroxylated aluminum surface sites are responsible for the PZR 3 [U].Figure 1l a is a scanning transmission electron micrograph of the cordierite core coated with the aluminum hydroxide layer approximately 15 nm thickness. The uniform surface-induced coating ultrafine scale aluminum hydroxide was achieved by an excess addition of aluminum salt [e.g., Al(N03)3] to the suspension at a pH below the PZR 2 and
c
7
5
9
11
PH Electrophoretic mobilities of cordierite and fumed silica as a function of suspension pH without addition external electrolyte.
184
JANG
(a) Scanning transmission electron micrograph of the cordierite core uniformly coated with the aluminum hydroxide layer; (b) EDAX spectrum of the core region shown in a; (c) EDAX spectrum of the coated layer shown in a. slowly adjusting pH level above the PZR 3 to induce the surface-induced precipitation. The energy-dispersive analyticalx-ray (EDAX) spectrum clearly indicates that the coated layer (Fig. l l c ) is exclusively composed aluminum hydroxide.
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
I85
When particles are suspended in a nonaqueous medium, the electrical double layer is difficult to develop (because the instability of ions in a nonaqueous medium), and therefore inmost cases the electrostatic stabilization represented by Eq. (22) is not expected. In case, stabilization of a colloidal dispersion can still be achieved, under suitable thermodynamic conditions, by the adsorbed polymer chains. Indeed, polymers have been widely used since antiquity to stabilize colloidal particles against coagulation. When two surfaces, from which flexible long chains are protruding into the solution, come close together (Fig. 12), there occurs a sharp repulsive interaction (steric repulsion) above the so-called point Two effects seem to contribute to the steric repulsion. In the narrow gap between the surfaces the long polymer chains lose some their conformations (volume restriction effect). This results in a partial loss chain entropy, in an increase in the free energy, and thus in an entropic repulsion. Furthermore, the concentration of polymer segments in the gap increases, and this osmotic effect results in another contribution to the repulsion. Figure 12 illustrates this schematically. When two adsorbed polymer layers interpenetrate each other as schematically shown in Fig. 13, the repulsive energy interaction under the condition of constant segment density can be written as
where o is the weight of stabilizing moieties (polymer chains) per unit surface area, v2 is the partial specific volume (volume per unit weight) of the moieties, v1 is the volume of solvent molecule, No is the Avogadro number, and 6 is the thickness of the adsorbed polymer layer (Fig. 13). X is the
Thevolumerestrictioneffect(a)andtheosmoticeffect tion by adsorbed or chemically bound long chains.
(b) in stabiliza-
JANG
P
overlap (interpenetration) region
13 Stericstabilizationcaused by theoverlap dispersed solid particles.
adsorbedpolymerlayers
upon close approach
Nory-Huggins interaction parameter and is less than for the steric repulsion or above the 0-point. Therefore, in steric stabilization in a nonaqueous suspension, Eq. (22) for VR should be replaced by Eq. (31). Since the steric repulsion increases sharply (hard-sphere type of repulsion) when two adsorbed polymer layers interpenetrate .each other under the condition of x IX, this provides a very efficient means colloidal stabilization in nonaqueous solvent systems. If the adsorbedpolymer is a polyelectrolyte, which carries i charges per monomer unit, and the particles are suspended in an aqueous solvent containing CSmol of 1:l valence salt per unit volume (liter), the repulsive energy of interaction expressed in Eq. (31) should be modified as [46]
where is defined in Eq. (31) and Vu is the molar volume a monomer unit. for electrosteric stabilization in an aqueous suspension, should be smaller than % + i2/(4VuCS). The term T/(4VuCS)represents the charge-charge repulsion arising from the intermixing of the charged polymeric chains when two particles approach each other.
x
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE
I87
W. FABRICATIONOFCERAMIC COMPOSITES Various methods of colloid interface science are now extensively applied to advanced ceramic processing, including powder synthesis, powder dispersion and consolidation, and microstructural control of green and sintered bodies (especially for ceramic composites). In the author's judgment, the three most important applications of colloid interface science to modem ceramic powder processing are (1) the synthesis, dispersion, and packing of monodisperse (or uniformly sized) powder via the solution-precipitation reaction of relevant metal alkoxides, initiated by Barringer et al. [26,27]; (2) the controlled transformation and sintering of sol-gel derived bodies by the submicrometer-sized colloidal seeds, pioneered by Messing and coworkers [47,48]; (3) the nanometer-scale multiphasic sol-gel processing of multicomponent ceramics, proposed by Roy and Roy [49,50]. Since there are many references for these, I do not review and discuss these in this chapter. Instead, discussion is provided of several recent examples the applications of colloid interface science to the fabrication of advanced ceramic composites. In the fabrication of an A1203/SiC whisker composite, Sacks and coworkers demonstrated that colloidal processing can be effectively used to prepare homogeneous green and sintered bodies by pressureless sintering [51]. By using the combination ofpH adjustment to and polyelectrolyte addition, A1203 particles and S i c whiskers could be codispersed at a high overall solid concentration (-50 ~01%)while maintaining the relatively low viscosities (-100 at the shear rate of desired for casting operations. Green bodies with a high relative density (6670%) were obtained with S i c whisker contents in the range of 5-30 ~01%.Although densification was inhibited by the S i c whiskers, significantly higher sintered densities were obtained by colloidal processing than by conventional processing. Samples with 15 vol% whiskers could be pressurelessly sintered to -97% relative density with zero open porosity and -1.6 pm matrix average grain size [52]. Therefore, these results suggest that the colloidal processing route can be used successfully in the fabrication of S i c whisker-reinforced matrix composites by pressureless sintering. As discussed previously, the DLVO theory predicts that the van der Waals attractive potential combines with the long-range repulsive electrostatic potential to produce the net interparticle potential, which can be either repulsive or cohesively attractive, depending on the magnitude of the repulsive potential. If there exists a very short range ( 4nm) repulsive potential instead of the longrange repulsive potential caused by the diffuse electrical double layer, the approaching particles are weakly attracted to one another but highly repulsive when pushed together A schematic diagram of the interparticle potential corresponding to this situation is shown in Fig. 14. Under certain conditions, the basal surface of mica is known to develop a short-range repulsive potential called the hydration (or solvation, in general)
JANG
I88
Coagulated
o"0 0 ,V
non-touching
network
Waals
Potential
14 Theformationof a weakly attractive non-touching network in the presence of a short-range hydration (solvation) potential.
potential. Using the surface force apparatus, Pashley showed that when mica is immersed in an aqueous solution containing a high concentration of potassium salt, the K+ion in its structural surface site can be strongly hydrated by water molecules. When no long-range repulsive potential is present, surface force measurements showed that the net surface potential has a functional form similar to that shown in Fig. that is, weakly attractive at separation distances > -2 nm and highly repulsive at smaller separations. More recently, Lange and coworkers showed that a short-range repulsive potential can be also developed on the surfaces of A1203 particles. When sufficient salt was added to the slurry, it was noted that the dispersed suspension (as a result of long-range electrostatic repulsion at a low pH) was altered to what superficially appeared to be a coagulated network. Unlike a flocculated network produced by changing the pH to the PZC,the.particles in this attractive network (coagulated network) were easily arranged, as deduced from the rheological data. This suggests that the particles slip into the potential energy well of shallow depth to produce an attractive but nontouching particle network called a coagulated network, as schematically shown in Fig. They further demonstrated that the mixed A1203/ZrO2 green bodies formed from welldispersed suspensions exhibited significant phase segregation, whereas those formed with coagulated slumes under the presence of the short-range hydration potential exhibited uniform microstructures throughout. Since the control of rheological properties (e.g., shear thinning behavior with a suitable viscosity value) and the minimization of phase segregation (differential settling) are very important in the fabrication of ceramic composites from slumes, the processing scheme based on the weakly coagulated slurry seems to be a promising potential approach. Similarly, in the fabrication of a ceramic composite, Bleier and coworkers found that the uniformity of the relative phase distribution can be greatly improved when the potentials of the unlike particles are of the same sign but differ greatly inmagnitude. For example, in the fabrication of an
c
COLLOID INTERFACE SClENCE
189
~203-Zxfkcomposite using a colloidal processing route, the unlike particles (i.e., A1203 and ZrO2) experience a weak, mutual association in the pH range However, when they are more similar electrostatically (e.g., in magnitude of potential) at a lower pH, they do not mutually associate and the spatial uniformity of the ZrO2 phase in the resulting green body and sintered composite suffers They concluded that the observed phenomena are associated with a weak attractive interaction in the secondary minimum in the potential energy curve (Fig. and suggested that the secondary minimum for the interaction between the dissimilar oxide particles is a useful, quantitative guide for predicting conditions under which a homogeneous distribution of constitutive phases (also without extensive agglomeration) can be obtained. Since they also emphasized a weak attractive interaction between the nontouching particles in a shallow potential energy well, their approach very much resembles the previously discussed suspension processing that utilizes the concept of the short-range repulsive hydration potential. eliminate fundamentally problems associated with phase segregation and agglomeration in the fabrication of ceramic composite, Jang and Moon proposed another colloidal processing scheme in which a thermodynamic theory of interfacial electrochemical phenomena is applied. In this approach, a kinetically stable colloidal suspension for the matrix phase (after sintering) is first prepared. Then, precursor precipitates (e.g., zirconium hydroxide ina Al203-ZrO2 composite) for the dispersed phase are individually coated on the matrix-phase colloid particles. The selective, interface-induced nanometer (or submicrometer) scale coating of the precursor on the matrix-phase particle was termed surface-induced coating. In the fabrication of zirconia-toughened alumina (ZTA), for example, one should carefully examine the following three points to set up optimal conditions for the surface-induced coating: (1) the pH range for the formation of kinetically stable A1203 dispersion, (2) the pH range for the enhanced interfacial concentration of ionic species (e.g., zirconium cation and hydroxide anion) needed for a selective formation of the precursor phase for ZrO2 only at the interface; (3) the pH range in which the other two conditions overlap each other. The enhanced interfacial concentration of the ionic species for the surfaceinduced coating on the matrix phase particle was derived based on the interface electrochemical equilibrium and can be expressed as
c
where i can be either zirconium cation or hydroxide anion (for the fabrication of ZTA), is the concentration of the ionic species at a distance r from the charged A1203 surface, Ci(m) is the corresponding bulk concentration, and y ( r ) is the mean coulombic potential at r. @so~vrefers to the change in the sol-
190
JANG
vation energy of ionic species upon adsorption, and denotes any possible short-range chemical interaction free energy (or any free energy change other than the electrostatic and the solvation free energy). A semiquantitive calculation based on the preceding equation clearly indicated that the charged A1203 interface, under suitable conditions can induce a significant interfacial enrichment of both hydroxide and zirconiumions and thus provides a thermodynamic basis for selective surface-induced nucleation at the charged colloid interface. Based on the preceding proposition, homogeneous Al203-ZrO2 composite powder was fabricated by the surface-induced coating of the ultrafine precursor on the kinetically stable colloid particles of A1203 [58]. The composite prepared by this processing scheme was characterized by a uniform spatial distribution of the dispersed ZrO2 phase and by the absence of large ZrO2 grains formed fromhard ZrO2 agglomerates. The composite also showedahighly uniform grain size distribution ofboth the dispersed ZrO2andthe matrix A1203 phases. The uniform grain size distribution of the matrix phase indicates that the homogeneous coating of the ultrafine precursor particles effectively pins the A1203 grain boundaries. More recently, this processing scheme was also applied to the fabrication of Al203-ZrO2-SiCwhisker composites with uniform microstructures and large values of Klc (-12.5IMPa-m'R). The concept on which the surface-induced coating route is based is illustrated in Fig. 15 using the A1203-ZrO2-SiC whisker system as an example. Sacks and coworkers [60,61] proposed another novel approach for enhancing densification and controlling microstructure development of multicomponent ceramics and ceramic-ceramic composites based on the processing of composite particles via a sol-coating route. In this method, they prepared cores crystalline materials (A1203, Si3N4, Sic, and ZrO2) with outer coatings of amorphous silica. Silica coatings were made using the hydrolysis-condensation route of silicon alkoxides (e.g., tetraethylorthosilicate).Before deposition of the coating, the core powders were fractionated using colloidal size separation. Powder compacts prepared with composite particles showed enhanced densification caused by viscous flow of the amorphous coating and the increased threshold concentration for percolation (connected network) of the crystalline phase. An example is illustrated in Fig. 16, in which the core is alumina and the coating is silica. As shown schematically in Fig. 16, if the size of the composite particles is selected properly, this composite structure should viscously sinter at a relatively low temperature to form an alumina/siliceous glass composite. At a higher temperature, the core and coating would react to form mullite. This process was referred to as transient viscous sintering. The amorphous sol-coating approach was also successfullyused to fabricate mullite-matrix composites [60,61] by mixing the silica-coated alumina particles with other silica-coated particles (e.g., zirconia particles for mullite/zirconia composite and S i c particles for mullite/SiC composite).
I91
COLLOID INTERFACE SCIENCE Kinetically Stable and S i c 0 Colloidal Suspensions
Unifonn. Mixed Colloidal Suspension of Al&'SiCoN)
with Submicron Particles attached to Sic whisker via Heterointeraction
Nanometer Scale Surface-induced Coating of the Precursor for the Dispersed Phase
15 Homogeneousfabrication of an A1203-Zr02-SiCwhiskercomposite by surface-induced coating. The preparation of a kinetically stable mixed suspensionand the subsequent compression the electrical double layer, while maintaining the surface potentials near constant values, proved to be a useful strategy for the fabrica-
I92
JANG
-
+
+
___)
3Al~O,*2SQ(M~llit0)
16 Transient viscous sintering of mullite using amorphous silica-coated alumina particles.
tion of ceramic composites. For example, based on the electrokinetic properties of aqueous silica, boehmite, and zro;? dispersions, cordierite-Za composites were fabricated by a mixed colloidal processing route In this method, stable boehmite, silica, and Zro.2 suspensions were f i s t prepared separately and then mixed while continuously stirring at pH at which the 6 potential of the mixed suspension exhibits its maximum. The mixed suspension was quite stable mV). The addition of Mg(N@)2 solution to the mixed suspension then increased the ionic strength and caused it to gel quickly by the compression of the electrical double layer (decrease in the Debye-Hiickel length without significantly decreasing vo).This essentially eliminated the problems associated with the phase segregation (or differential settling) and produced a composite powder with a uniform spatial distribution of constitutive phases. The fabricated composite was characterized by a dense and homogeneous microstructure andbyauniform spatial distribution ofsubmicrometer-sized tetragonal Zro;! particles throughout the matrix This processing scheme was also successfully applied to the fabrication of S i c whisker-reinforced lithium aluminosilicate matrix composites
-
REFERENCES 1. Parsons, R.,Modern Aspects of Electrochemistry, Vol. 1 (J. 0”. Bockris and B. E. Conway, eds.), Butterworths,London, 1954, p. 103. 2. Smith, A. L., Electrical phenomena associated with the solid-liquid interface, Dispersion of Powders inLiquids (G.D. ParFtt, ed.),AppliedScience,London, 1985, p. 99. 3.Modi, H. andFuerstenau, D. W., Streamingpotentialstudies on corundum (a-Al203) in aqueous solutions of inorganic electrolytes,J. Phys. Chem., 61, (1957). 4. Parks, G. A., Theisoelectricpoints of solid oxides, solid hydroxides, andaqueous hydroxo complex system, Chem. Rev., 65, 117 (1965).
193
SCIENCE COLLOID INTERFACE Parks, G. A., and de Bruyn, P.
L., The zero point of charge of oxides, J. Phys.
Chem., 66,
Grahame, D. C., The electrical double layer and the theory of electrocapillarity, Chem. Rev., 41,
Loeb,A. L., Wiersema,P.H.,andOverbeek,J.T. G. The Electrical Double Layer Around a Spherical Colloid Particle, M.I.T. Press, Cambridge, MA, Levine, Mingins, J., and Bell, G. M., The discrete-ion effect in ionic doublelayer theory, J . Electroanal. Chem., 13, Wiese, G. R., James, R. 0.. and Healy, T. W., Discreteness of charge and solvation effects in cation adsorptionat the oxide/water interface,Disc. Faraday Soc., 52,
Yates, D. E., The structure of the oxide/aqueous electrolyte interface, Ph. D. Thesis, University of Melbourne, Australia, Hunter, R. J., Zeta Potential in Colloid ScienceLPrinciples and Applications, Academic Press, New York, Chaps. and Babchin,A. J., Chow, R. and Sawatzky, R. P., Electrokinetic measurements by electroacoustical methods, Adv. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 30, Overbeek, J. Th.G., The interaction between colloid particles, in Colloid Science (H. R. Kruyt, ed.), Elsevier, Amsterdam, p. BCruM, Y. G., and de Bruyn, P. L., Adsorption at the rutile-solution interface. I. thermodynamic and experimental study, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 27, Hunter, R. J., and Wright, H. J. L., Dependence of electrokinetic potential on concentration of electrolyte, J . Colloid Interjac. Sci., 37, Levine, and Smith, L., Theory of the differential capacity of the oxide/aqueelectrolyte interface, Disc. Faraday Soc., 52, Jang, H. M.,andFuerstenau,D.W.,Thespecificadsorptionofalkaline-earth cations at the rutile/water interface, Colloids Surfaces, 21, Bolt, G. H., Determination of the charge density of silica sols, J . Phys. Chem., 61,
Abendroth, R. P., Behavior of a pyrogenic silica in simple electrolytes, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 34,
20. Jang, H. M., The natureof counter-ion adsorption at the oxide/water interface, Ph. D. Thesis, University of California, Berkeley, Yates, D. E., Levine, and Healy, T. W., Site-binding model of the electrical double layer at the oxide-water interface, J . Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I , 70, Davis, J. A., James, R. O., and Leckie, J. O., Surface ionization and complexation at the oxide/water interface, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 63, Houchin, M. R., and Warren, L. J., Surface titrations and electrokinetic measurements on stannic oxide suspensions, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 100, Jang, H. M., and Fuerstenau, D. W., The nature of simple monovalent cation-silica interaction as reflected in the spin-lattice relaxation time of =Na, Langmuir, 3,
Bull, T. E., Nuclear magnetic relaxation of spin-312 nuclei involved in chemical exchange, J. Magn. Reson.,
I94
JANG Barringer,E. A., andBowen, H. K., Formation,packing,andsinteringof monodisperse Ti02 powders, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., Bamnger, E. A., Jubb, N., Fegley, B., Pober, R. L., and Bowen, H. K., Processing monosized powders, in Ultrastructure Processing of Ceramics, Glasses, and Composites (L. L. Hench and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Wiley,New York, p. ner, R. K.,Inorganic colloids for forming ultrastructures, in Science of Ceramic Chemical Processing (L. L. Hench and D.R. Ulrich, eds.), Wiley, New York, p. Aksay, I. A., and Kikuchi, R., Structuresof colloidal solids, inScience of Ceramic Chemical Processing (L. L. Hench and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Wiley, New York, p. Overbeek, J. T. G., Recent developmentsin the understanding of colloid stability, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 58, Hiemenz, P. C., Principles of Colloid andSurface Chemistry, 2nd ed., Marcel Dekker, New York, Chap. Gregory, J. The calculation of Hamaker constants, Adv. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 2, Visser, J., On Hamaker constants: A comparison between Hamaker constants and Lifshitz-van der Waals constants, Adv. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 3, Stol, R. J., and de Bruyn, P. L., Thermodynamic stabilization of colloids, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 75(1), Wiese, G. R., and Healy, T. W.,'Coagulation and electrokinetic behavior of Ti02 and A1203 colloidal dispersions, J . Colloid Interfac. Sci., 51, Reerink, H., and Overbeek, J. T. G., The rate of coagulation as a measure of the stability of silver iodide sols, Disc. Faraday Soc., 18, Wiese, G.R.,andHealy, T. W., Effect of particle size oncolloidalstability, J. Chem. Soc. Trans. Faraday Soc., Jang, H. M., and Lee, K. G., Effects of kinetic stability of colloidal dispersion on thegreenmicrostructureanddensificationbehavior of zirconia, in Ceramic Transactions Vol. 12, Ceram. Powder Science 111 (G. L. Messing, Hirano, and H. Hausner, eds.), Am. Ceram. Westerville, OH, p. Aksay,I.A.,andSchilling,C.H.,Colloidalfiltrationroutetouniform microstructures, in Ultrastructure Processing of Ceramics, Glasses,and Composites (L. L. Hench and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Wiley, New York, p. Shih, W. Y., Aksay, I. A., and Kikuchi, R., Reversible-growth model: Clusterclusteraggregationwith finite bindingenergies, Phys. Rev. A, Zhao, J., and Harmer, M. P., Effect of pore distribution on microstructure development II. First- and second-generation pores, J. Am. Ceram. Soc.,
I
Yeh, T.-S.,and Sacks, M.D., Low-temperaturesintering of aluminumoxide, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., H., Ota, K., and Saito, H., Preparation cordierite ceramics from metal alkoxides (Part II). Sintering, Yogyo-kyokai-shi, Jang, H.M.,and Lee, H., Interfacial characteristics and colloidal stability of cordierite dispersion, Langmuir,
COLLOID INTERFACE SCIENCE
1
Napper, D. H., Polymeric Stabilization of Colloidal Dispersions, Academic Press, New York, Chapts. and Takahashi, A., and Nagasawa, M., Excluded volume of polyelectrolyte, J . Am. Chem. Kumagai, M., and Messing, G. L., Controlled transformation and sintering of a boehmite sol-gel by a-alumina seeding, J . Am. Ceram. Soc., Messing, G. L., Kumagai, M., Shelleman, R.A.,andMcArdle,J.L.,Seeded transformations for microstructuralcontrol in ceramics, Science of Ceramic Chemical Processing (L. L. Hench and D.R. Ulrich, eds.), Wiley, New York, p. Roy, R. A., and Roy, R., New metal-ceramic hybrid xerogels, in Abstracts Ann. Meeting Mater. Res. Boston, MA, p. Roy, R., Ceramics by the solution-sol-gel route, Science, Sacks, M. D., Lee H.-W., and Rojas, 0. E., Suspension processing of A1203/SiC whisker composites, J. Am. Ceram. Lee,H.-W.,and Sacks, M.D., Pressureless sintering of Sic-whisker-reinforced A1203 composites. I. Effect of matrix powder surface area, J . Am. Ceram. Lange, F. F. New interparticle potential paradigm for advanced powder processing, in Ceramics Transactions, Vol. 22, Ceramics Powder Science N (S.-I. Hirano, G. L. Messing, and H. Hausner, eds.), Am. Ceram. Westerville, OH, p. Pashley, R.M., DLVO and hydration forces between mica surfaces in LP, Na', K+,and CS+ electrolyte solutions: Correlation double-layer and hydrationforces with surface cation exchange properties, J . Colloid Znterfac. Sci., Velamakanni, B. V., Chang, J. C., Lange, F. F., and Pearson, D. New method for efficient particle packing via modulation of repulsive lubricating hydration forces, Lungmuir, Baik, Bleier, A., and Becher, P. F., Preparation of A1203-zfl2 composites by adjustment of surface chemical behavior, Mater. Res. Symp. Proc., Vol. Better Ceramics Through Chemistry (C.J. Brinker, D. E. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Mater. Res. Soc., Pittsburgh, PA, p. Bleier, A., and Westmoreland, C. G., Effects of pH and particle size on the processing of and the development of microstructurein alumina-zirconia composites, J . Am. Ceram. Soc., Jang, H.M., andMoon, J. H.,Homogeneousfabricationanddensification of zirconia-toughenedalumina(ZTA)composite by thesurface-inducedcoating, J . Mater. Res., Jang, H. M., Moon, J. H., and Jang, C. W., Homogeneous fabrication of Al2O3ZrOz-Sic whisker composite by the surface-induced coating, J . Am. Ceram. Soc., Sacks, M. D., Bozkurt, N., and Scheiffele, G. W., Fabrication mullite and mullite-matrix compositesby transient viscous sintering of composite powders, J . Am. Ceram. Soc., Sacks, M. D., Scheiffele, G. W., Bozkurt, N., and Raghunathan, R., Fabrication of ceramics and composites by viscous sintering of composite particles, Ceram-
JANG ics Transactions, Vol. 22, Ceramics Powder ScienceN (S.-I. Hirano, G. L. Messing, and H. Hausner, eds.), Am. Ceram. Westerville, OH, p. Lim, B. C., andJang, H.M.,Homogeneousfabricationanddensificationof cordierite-zirconiacomposites by amixedcolloidalprocessingroute, J . Am.
Ceram. Soc., Jang, H. M., Kim, K. and Jung, C. J., Development of Sic-whisker-reinforced lithium aluminosilicate matrix composites by a mixed colloidal processing route, J . Am. Ceram. Soc.,
Ceramic Particles,in Nonaqueous Media Lee Clemson University Clemson, Carolina
INTRODUCTION Properties of final ceramic products made from fine powders are often dependent on the state of dispersion of the paiticles in the liquid media. The particles interact with each other and with what is in the medium. Some of the liquid molecules can adsorb onto the solid surface. Some solid surfaces can be ionized to exhibit surface charges. Ceramic particles in organic liquid media behave differently from those in aqueous media. Many known ceramic-processing techniques involve fine particles dispersed in nonaqueous media. Some of the better known examples are tape casting of barium titanate and aluminum nitride powders and tape or slip casting, extrusion, and injection molding of ceramic high Tc superconductor powders. The theories of colloidal stability used for aqueous slurry systems may also apply to nonaqueous systems. According to the Derjaguin equation [l], the repulsive energy can be written as V, = 2 m y d In(l+ e-KH)
(1)
where: VR= electrostatic repulsive energy between two like particles E = dielectric constant of medium a = particle radius 197
LEE = electrical potential at the diffuse layer
H = interparticle distance K
= Debye-Huckel parameter
The attractive energy, on the other hand, is given by
vA -"12H
where: VA = attractive energy between two identical particles = Hamaker constant
The repulsive energy between two particles of size in a medium is a function of the dielectric constant of the liquid medium. This means a smaller VR for media of organic solvents with smaller than that of water. The dielectric constants of some common liquids are listed in Table 1. The Debye-Hiickel parameter K in (1) also depends on by
where:
e = electron change NA = Avogadro's number C = electrolyte concentration 2 = charge of the ionic species
.
The double-layer thickness 1 / is ~ therefore larger for larger E. However, the ionic strength, C in nonaqueous media is much smaller than that in aqueous media, hence larger VK. The attractive interaction depends largely on the Hamaker constant A, as shown in Eq. (2). The larger the value of A, the greater is the attractive energy between the particles. The net interaction energy is then the sum of VR and VA. Equations (1) and show that a better dispersion of fine particles must come from systems having large and small Fowkes and Lee and Rives [2,3] showed that ion formation in a nonaqueous medium is appreciably higher than predicted by Eq. (1). Steric stabilization of colloidal particles is achieved by adsorption of long-chain molecules on solid surfaces For an effective steric stability by the adsorbed molecules, there are several basic requirements: (1) long chain of the adsorbate molecule, (2) strong adsorption of the adsorbate on the solid particle surface, and (3) good solubility of the chain in themedium Regarding the chain length of a steric stabilizer, there is the question how
CERAMIC PARTlCLES IN NONAQUEOUS MEDIA Table
199
RelevantPhysicalProperties of Solvents
Dielectric Solvent Chloroform Ethanol Methylene chloride Water Tetrahydrofuran Acetone Ethyl acetate Toluene
Viscositya (ea-s) 0.58 l .2 0.45 1 .o 0.55 0.32 0.46 0.59
Ammd
Acidlbasec HPCPb constant 4.8 25 9.1 78.3 7.4 21.5 6.4 2.4
aAt 20°C. bHydrogen bonding cohesion parameter. cBased on Drago’s C and E values [K!], (strong) dcalculated Hamaker constants [5]. Source: Refs. 15 and 16.
(J
6.3 20 9.6 40.4 7.4 6.7 11
8.9 1.6
10-20)
A2 A3
7.6 6.4 7.4
B1 B2 B3 B4
6.6 6.7 8.4
4 (weak).
long the chain must be for effective steric stability. It has been shown by a number experimentalists that the chain length need not be so long predicted by the theory Relatively small molecules, such as fatty acids and some surfactants, are widely used as dispersants. Calvert et al. showed that the maximum packing density of silica suspension in hexane was achieved by a silane surfactant with chain length of carbon number 12. chain length longer than 12 did not improve the packing density. Surfactants that produce electrostatic charges on ceramic particles exhibit large changes in the viscosity and the suspension stability. When steric stabilization is combined with electrostatic stability, the results can be remarkable The more additives used in ceramic slurries for processing, the more complex interactions among the components in the system are expected. Better understanding these interactions is necessary to control particle dispersion and processing in nonaqueous media. The interactions are often indirectly assessed by the rheology of the suspension systems, the 6 potentials, and the green body characteristics. This chapter presents some of the results and an explanation of the rheological and related behavior of alumina, silica, and portland cement particles in various organic solvent media.
II.
RHEOLOGY AND ELECTROSTATICCHARGE
The surface alumina in aqueous environment is well characterized [7-lo]. It has amphoteric sites, that is, acidic sites of aluminum and basic sites of hy-
LEE droxyl. However, the isoelectric point and the point of zero charge of pH = 9 indicate that the surface is weakly basic in water. Although basic molecules can adsorb on an alumina surface via the acidic aluminum sites, more effective adsorption of dispersant molecules is expected for the hydroxyl groups via hydrogen bonding. Figure 1 shows the viscosity of vol% alumina suspensions having the mean particle size of 1.5 pm (Alcoa A-152) in three different organic liquids in the presence of wt% linolenic acid (LNA) per alumina. At low shear rates, they all exhibit shear thinning. Ethyl acetate (EtAc) exhibits the highest viscosity, followed by toluene (Tol). LNA, which is an acid, can adsorb on alumina via acid-base interaction or hydrogen bonding. The structural formula of LNA and those of other organic dispersants are given in Fig. 2. The interaction between the solvent and LNA cannot be responsible for the viscosity curves because the most basic solvent, tetrahydrofuran (THF) [1l], would interact with LNA the most. The acid-base interaction is based on Drago's work on Lewis acid-base interaction energies [12]. Fowkes [2,13,14] expanded the concept to ceramic processing. The relative acidity and basicity of solvents used are listed in Table The ceramic powders used are listed in Table 2. The rheogram in Fig. 1 suggests two possibilities: one is the largest amount of LNA adsorption onto an alumina surface in THF and the least in EtAc for steric stability. The other possibility is that the alumina surface is the most highly charged in THF and the least in EtAc for electrostatic stability. Our electrophoretic deposition experiments yielded alumina particles deposition on the positive electrode, which signifies that the alumina surface in THF was
E
>
IO
'
LNA per
0 3.4 6.8 10.2 13.6 20.4 23B (I/S)
Rheogram of alumina.
vol% alumina in threedifferentsolvents
with 5
201
CERAMIC PARTICLES IN NONAQUEOUS MEDIA
Linolenic Acid (LNA), C-18
H
OH €I$ = CH
-C
- 0 - C%CH - q - N - (CHJ,Si(OEt),
N-(3-Acryloxy-2-hydroxy-propyl)-3-aminopropyl~ethoxysilane(AHAS), 15 memberChain
\
“C-
l
x=14.3
2 Chemicalstructure of dispersantmolecules. negatively charged. In EtAc a smaller amount alumina was deposited on the positive electrode. This means that EtAc is weakly basic relative to the surface alumina, and THF is-more strongly basic. Alumina in toluene yielded an even smaller deposit of alumina on the positive electrode than in EtAc. This agrees with the basicity scale Drago shown in Table 1.
Table 2
Characteristics of CeramicPowders Mean particle Surface area alumina) (mVg
Source Powder Alumina A-l52 AKP-15 Silica Portland cement, type I
Alcoa Sumitomo Stiiber Holnam Santee
0.65 0.5 10
1.2 3.8 7.9 0.16
LEE Although toluene and EtAc are both listed as weak bases, this is the relative basicity to the solid surface. Hence, one can conclude that alumina is a weaker acid in toluene and EtAc, but a stronger acid in THF. The electrophoretic deposition of alumina in the presence of 5 wt% LNA per alumina yielded a deposit on the negative electrode in toluene and on the positive electrode in THF and EtAc. Although LNA is an acid (Fig. 2) relative to the alumina surface, the basic media THF and EtAc overrode the acidity of 5 wt% LNA, causing the negative charge on the alumina surface. In toluene, on the other hand, LNA reversed the charge on the alumina surface. This could be possible because the surface charge of alumina in toluene was nearly zero, shown by the very small amount of deposit of alumina particles on the positive electrode in the absence of LNA. Figure 3 sdows viscosities of 60 vol% AKP-l5 alumina suspensions as a function of shear rate in THF and chloroform (Chl), all with 5 wt% LNA. Both solvents in the presence of LNA exhibited that the suspensions are pseudoplastic with Chl as a better solvent than THF for alumina. A strong positive charge of the alumina surface in chlorofomLNA and a strong negative charge in THFLNA were indicated by the electrophoretic deposition. The surface charges and 6 potentials of alumina are determined primarily by the solvent media. As given in Table 1, choloroform has been classified as a strong acid and THF as a strong base, which is supported by the electrophoretic deposition results.
'p
a
E
0
200
Shear Rate (I/sec) 3 Rheogram per AKP-15 alumina.
60 vol% alumina in THF and
with 5
LNA
203
CERAMIC NONAQUEOUS PARTICLES INMEDIA
Figure is a rheogram of 60 vol% A-152 alumina in THF and toluene at low shear rates in the presence of 2.5 wt% per alumina of aminopolyisobutylene (APIB);(Fig. 2). AnAPIB molecule consists of an amine terminating group and cyclic dicarbonyl joined to a long alkyl chain. The amine functional groups are expected to behave as a base. The rheogram shows that toluene is a better solvent than THF for dispersing alumina at very high solids loading. In toluene, the alumina surface was shown to be negatively charged. In THF, it was charged weakly positively, indicated by a small deposit of alumina on the negative electrode. This disagrees with explanation that THF is a strong base in the presence of LNA; the surface charge of alumina is primarily affected by the liquid media, as seen in Fig. In the presence of APIB, however, the charge is reversed. This indicates significantly strong interactions between APIB and the alumina surface. Figure 5 is a rheogram of 60 vol% AKP-15 alumina in chloroform and in THF at higher shear rates in the presence of 5 wt% APIB. Aslightly lower viscosity of the slurry with THF than with chloroform is shown. A-152 alumina in methylene chloride was deposited in large amount on the negative electrode under an applied electrical field. This agrees with the acid nature of methylene chloride regardless of the nature of APIB. A smaller deposit of alumina in THF on the negative electrode indicates that the positive potential on the alumina surface in THF is smaller than the oxitive potentialin methylene chloride. Since chloroform is a stronger acid than methylene chloride [ll], the low viscosity of the alumina slurry in THF must be caused by a mechanism other than electrostatic, that is, steric stabilization. The sedimentation heights of alumina sediments, shown in Fig. indicate that a strong base "IF and a strong acid chloroform are equally effective in stabilizing alumina particles with LNA and with an aminosilane, AHAS (see
I 13.6
(Vs)
per
4 Rheogram of 60 vol% aluminain THF and toluenewith 2.5 wt% APIB alumina.
204
S E
LEE
IO
>
F
I
,O
(m)
5 Rheogram of 60 vol% alumina in THF per
chloroform with
APIB
alumina. -I
I
.3 .-x
20
Fig This is shown by the more compact sediments. Alumina with an photeric surface was stabilized by dispersants and strongly acid or strongly basic solvents by acombined steric and electrostatic mechanism. Hexane, which is a nonpolar solvent with no hydrogen bonding capability, is shown to be a poor solvent for AHAS, which is a highly polar dispersant. Hexane would introduce a low potential as well; hence the stability had to rely solely on the steric stabilization contribution. When the adsorbate AHAS is not highly soluble in the medium, the dispersant is ineffective as a steric stabilizer. Despite the high dielectric constant of EtOH, it is shown to be an ineffective medium with LNA. EtOH as a weakly acid solvent introduced nearly a zero potential
CERAMIC PARTICLES
205
IN NONAQUEOUS MEDIA
on alumina, although the adsorption isotherm showed a large amount of LNA, =20 mg/g Al203, on the alumina surface. Thus, for the most effective stabi-
lization, a strong electrostatic contribution in addition to the steric contribution becomes essential.
Silica The surface of silica is characteristically acidic because of the silanol groups. Figure 7 is a rheogram of 30 vol% silica suspensions in various media. EtOH exhibited the lowest viscosity and EtAc the highest for silica prepared by base hydrolyzing silicon tetraethoxide followed by calcination at 600°C. The potentials measured by electrokinetic sonic amplitude showed very a low negative value of -15 mV for silica in EtOH, as shown in Fig. 8. According to Drago (Table l), EtOH is a Lewis acid and is not expected to ionize the acid silica surface appreciably. The lowest viscosity must then be from a steric contribution by the adsorbed EtOH via hydrogen bonding and/or esterification (silicon ethoxide formation). A weakly basic solvent, EtAc did not adsorb and did not cause the silica surface to be highly charged. Acetone, as a more strongly basic solvent than EtAc, exhibited a lower viscosity than EtOH for silica. As shown in Fig. 8, the negative potential of silica in acetone is relatively high. In the presence of the organic dispersants LNA or AHAS, the viscosity of the 30 vol% silica suspension in acetone (Fig. 9) decreased substantially. This shows that AHAS is the more effective dispersant than LNA for silica in acetone, despite the small potential, less than around -10 mV in Fig. 8. Based on the chemical structure of AHAS given in Fig. 2, AHAS was believed to be a basic dispersant via the amino group, ester group, and ethoxy groups, representing a multifunctional adsorbate. The -OH group may act as an
<
<
<
I
IO 0.34
3.4
(Vs)
7 Rheogram present.
30 vol% silica in
differentsolventswith no dispersant
206
LEE
Zeta P 0 Viscosity EtOH Acetone Ace+LNA Ace+AHAS
6 potentialand viscosity of 35 vol%silicasuspensionsinvariousmedia. The viscosity values are at the shear rate of 'lo00
-
B
"P-
>
c
0
+
Polymer Linolenic AHAS
IO
U,
> I
. ,:
&L
3.4
(Vs)
Rheogram of 30 vol% silica in acetone with 5 wt% silica compared with a rheogram of no dispersant.
and
per
acid site, however, making the molecule amphoteric. Although strong hydrogen bonding andlor chemisorption of AHAS via Si-0-Et is possible, the molecule must have reversed the charge of the silica surface in acetone. One possible explanation for this is the base-catalyzed enolization of acetone, making the enol form of acetone more acidic. LNA, on the other hand, expected to behave as an acid adsorbate, did not appreciably affect the t; potential. Thus, the lowest viscosity of the silica suspension in the presence of LNA must be from the combined effects of a steric effect by LNA and an electrostatic effect by acetone. For AHAS, this is a more steric contribution than electrostatic. In EtOH, LNA is shown to be a superior dispersant to AHAS (Fig. lo), and in THF (Fig. 1l), AHAS is superior to LNA (Fig. 1l), similarly to the finding in acetone (Fig. LNA in chloroform, shown in Fig. 12, exhibit a poor rhe-
CERAMIC PARTICLES IN NONAQUEOUS MEDIA
-
W/O Linolenic
>.
Figure 10 Rheogram of
vol% silica in ethanol with
wt% LNAand AHAS.
?
2
d !z >.
" .C c -
Linolenic
IO : ,:
(Vs)
Figure 11 Rheogram of
vol% silica in THF with
wt%LNAandAHAS.
'-c
'"
"-c
-c
>.
8
IO
--b
> I
Figure 12 Rheogram of AHAS, and APIB.
vol% silica in Chloroform and THF with
wt% LNA,
LEE ological behavior. The adsorbent silica is acidic and the solvent and dispersant are basic. This combination is shown to be ineffective for dispersing silica. AHAS, on the other hand, is shown to be effective in both choloroform and THF. This may be because of the amphoteric nature of AHAS, discussed previously. Aminopolyisobutylene is also shown to be effective in both chloroform and THF, although not as low in viscosity as AHAS. APIB was previously mentioned as a basic dispersant for the amino groups and carbonyls. It may be that the basic APIB adsorbs on silica very well and is very soluble in both chloroform and THF. To consider the three-way interactions between dispersant-solvent,solvent-solid surface, and dispersant-solid surface, one must consider the relative acidity or basicity of all the participants. Is chloroform a stronger acid than silica? Is THF a stronger base than APIB? Such questions are relevant and need to be answered. It may be speculated that silica is a stronger acidthan chloroform; hence the basicAPIB preferentially interacts with silica over chloroform. If APIB is a stronger base than THF for silica, then it preferentially interacts with silica over THF. However, the exact relative acidity or basicity of the three interacting participants, that is, APIB, solvent, and silica, is unknown. Hence, it is difficult to assess the degree of the interaction quantitatively.
C.
Portland Cement
It is well known that portland cement is strongly basic because of the large proportion of calcium hydroxide. Figure 13 shows the viscosity of cement slurries in various liquids as a function of Brookfield shear rates. At vol% cement in organic solvents, it showed lower viscosities than that in water. A strongly basic liquid medium, THF, exhibited the lowest viscosity with Newtonian be-
Acetone
t
g Y
300
30 RPM
13 Rheogram of
vol% portland cementin various media.
209
CERAMIC NONAQUEOUS PARTICLES INMEDIA
havior. This is also difficult to assess based simply on the Drago and Fowke's acid-base interaction theory, because the cement surface is basic and the THF medium is also basic. Using the relative acid-base scale in Table THF is acid compared with cement and introduces a larger with a smaller ionic strength and higher electrostatic contribution than for the cement surface in water to stabilization of the suspension [Eqs. and In the presence of LNA, EtOH, which most resembles water chemically, shows the 'higher viscosity in Fig. The cement in all other liquid media exhibitedlowviscosities. In particular, the strong acid chloroform and strong base THF show Newtonian low viscosities. The reasoning given for silica in Fig. must apply here as well, that is, the relative acidity-basicity in the suspension among the three participants. When water is added to the cement slumes in an organic medium, chloroform in the presence of LNA (Fig. the viscosity changed little up to water volume above this destroys the stability. Figure 16 vol%of H20. shows the relative diametral tensile strength for specimens from cement dispersed in various liquid media. The diametral tensile strengths were determined by applying compressive loadings diametrically on cylindrical specimens 3 3 cm in diameter and height formed from vol% cement and vol% organic solvent in water. The relative strengths were calculated by dividing the measured values by the strength of the specimen formed from water. The strength of the cement body formed from chloroform-water showed more than a threefold higher strength and a slightly higher strength than EtOH and water. This shows the effectiveness of nonaqueous liquid in forming superior cement components through improved dispersion.
_""
_"
" " " " " " " " " "
%
3
30
60
RPM
14 Rheogram LNA per cement.
24 vol% portlandcementin
mediawith 5 wt%
LEE
210
12
IO of
15 Viscosity of vol%portlandcementwi Ith as a function of water content.
, I
from various
,
,
,
,
wt% LNA in Chloroform
,
2
Relative diametral tensile strengths of 27 day cured portland cement cast media.
In Deryagin, Landau, and Verwey (DLVO) theory the magnitude of attractive energy is represented by the Hamaker constant as shown in Eq. Two like particles in a liquid medium exhibit attraction arising from van der Waals forces. The net Hamaker constant representing the attraction between the two particles in the medium is given by the geometric mean of the two materials in Eq.
CERAMIC PARTICLES
IN NONAQUEOUS MEDIA
21
where the subscripts p p = particle-particle and m m = medium-medium. For a small App/m, that is, better dispersion, one wants the value of App to be close to that of A-. The A- values calculated from the surface tension of the liquid [2,5] are listed in Table 1. If the dispersoid particles are covered by another material, the value of App approaches that of the adsorbate material. In this case, for small App/m, one can select a dispersant having a value ofA close to thatof the liquid medium. Unfortunately, accurate determination of the Hamaker constant for a given material system is not yet well established. Since the Hamaker constant is a function of the polarizability of a molecule, LNA, having three double bonds,would have a relatively high value [5,17]. Plots of the viscosity of alumina suspension as a function of the Hamaker constant of the liquid medium, made by Rives [IS], show that the viscosity minimum at a Hamaker constant = 9 for LNA in acidic solvents and = 8 for LNA in basic solvents. The values of Am in Table 1 show that such solvents as toluene, methylene chloride, chloroform, and THF would be better media for smaller APplm and water the worst. This practice should apply to mixed solvent systems to tailor the Hamaker constant, solubility, electrostatic charge, and so on. This was presented in our recent work elsewhere [19].
IV.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
Ceramic particles can be well dispersed in nonaqueous solvent via electrostatic repulsive forces. In the presence of organic dispersants, the electrostatic repulsive forces can be augmented by steric hindrance from the adsorbed dispersant molecules. The combined hindrances to attraction and coagulation can be very effective in dispersing fine particles and increasing solids loading. For alumina powders, THF is found to be a good medium with an acid dispersant LNA. Chloroform, which is an acidic solvent, is found to be an even better solvent for alumina dispersion with LNA. For a basic dispersant, APIB, toluene is found to be good choice of solvent as well as TI-IF.Chloroform is also found to be a good choice. For silica powders, ethanol is a good medium, but in the presence of an aminosilane, AHAS, the more basic solvents acetone and THF are better dispersionmedia.A strong acid Chloroform was also found to be good with AHAS. For a basic dispersant, APTS, both THF and Chloroform are good dispersion media. THF and Chloroform were found to be excellent in obtaining a low viscosity of cement slurries. Cement specimens formed from 16.7% chloroform in water produced a 3.4-fold stronger cement cast. It may be possible to reduce
212
LEE
the amount of water currently in use in the field to improve the strength of cement concretes. For better dispersion, the relative acid-base interactions of the three participants-liquid medium-adsorbate, adsorbate-solid surface,andsolidsurfaceliquid medium-should be considered simultaneously rather than one pair at a time. reduce the attractive forces between the particles, tailoring the effective Hamaker constant of the particle surface can be made by choice dispersant and solvent. Mixed dispersants and/or mixed solvents may be considered for the purpose. Depending on the choice of dispersant, the role of dispersants may be combined with therole of binders to decrease the content of the organic additives.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The author acknowledges the contributions of data from his graduate and undergraduate students at Clemson University, C. Calhoun, J. Rives, and U. Paik. The financial support from the National Science Foundation and the State of South Carolina is also gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES 1. Shaw, D. J., Introduction to Colloid and Surface Chemistry, 3rd ed., Butterworths, London,1985,p.186. 2. Fowkes, F. M.,Dispersionofceramicpowdersinorganicmedia,in Ceramic Powder Science Advances in Ceramics, Vol. 21 (G.L. Messing, K. S. Mazdiyasni, J. W. McCauley, and R. A. Haber, eds.), Am. Ceram. Soc., Westerville, OH, 1997, p. 41 1. 3. Lee, B. I., and Rives, J. P., Dispersion of alumina in nonaqueous media,Colloids Surfaces, 56, 25 (1991). 4. Napper, D. H.,Polymeric Stabilization of Colloidal Dispersions, Academic Press, NewYork,1993. 5. Johnson,R. E., andMomson,W. H., Jr., Ceramicpowderdispersioninnonaqueous systems, in Ceramic Powder Science, AdvancesinCeramics,Vol.21 (G. L. Messing, K. S. Mazdiyasni, J. W. McCauley, and R. A. Haber, eds.), Am. Ceram. Soc., Westerville, OH, 1987, p. 323. 6. Calvert, P. D., Lalanandham, R. R., Parish, M. V., Fox, J., Lee, H., Pober, R. L., Tormey, E. S., and Bowen, H. K., Dispersion of ceramic particles in organic liquids, in Proc. Mae. Res. Symp., Vol. 73, (C. J. Brinker, D. E. Clark, and D. R. Ulrich, eds.), Materials Research Society, Pittsburgh, PA, 1986, pp. 579-584. 7. Griffiths, D. A., and Fuerstenau, D. W., Effect of pH and temperature on the heat of immersion of alumina, J. Colloid Interfac. Sci., 80, 271 (1981). 8. Robinson, M., Pask, J. A., and Fuerstenau, D. W., Surface charge of alumina and magnesia in aqueous media, J. Am. Cerarn. Soc., 47, 516 (1964).
CERAMIC PARTICLES IN NONAQUEOUS MEDIA
213
Lee, B. I., and Hench, L.L., Electrophoretic behavior and surface reactionssolof gel derived alumina, Colloids Sufaces, 17, Kiselev, A. V., and Lygin, V. I., Infiared Spectra of Sugace Compounds, Wiley and Sons, New York, p. Okuyama, M., Garvey,G., Ring, T. A., and Haggerty, J. Dispersion of silicon carbide powders in nonaqueous solvents, J. Am. Ceram. Soc., 72, Drago, R. S., Vogel, G. C., and Needham, T. E., A four parameter equation for predicting enthalpies of adduct formation,J. Am. Chem. Soc., 93, Fowkes,F.M.,Acid-basecontributionstopolymer-fillerinteractions, Rubber Chem. Technol., 57,
Fowkes, F. M., and Mostafa, M. A., Acid-base interactions in polymer adsorption, Ind. Eng. Chem. Product Res. Dev., 17,
Barton, A. F. M., CRC Handbook of Solubility Parameters and Other Cohesion Parameters, CRC Press, New York, Weast, R. C. (ed.), CRC Handbook of Chemistry and Physics, 52nd ed., Chemical Rubber Co., Cleveland, OH, Osmond, D. W. J., andWaite,F.A.,Thetheoreticalbasisforthestericstabilization of polymer dispersions prepared in organic media, in Dispersion Polymerization in Organic Media (K.E. J. Barrett, ed.), Wiley and Sons, New York, pp. Rives, J. P.,Dispersion of alumina powder in nonaqueous media via steric and electrostaticrepulsiveforces, MS. Thesis,ClemsonUniversity,Clemson,SC, Lee, B. I., and Paik, U., Dispersion of alumina and silica powders in nonaqueous media: Mixed solvent effects, Ceram. h r . ,
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Synthesis and Dispersion of Barium Titanate and Related Ceramic Powders Ki Hyun Yoon and Kyung Hwa Jo* Yonsei University Seoul, Korea
INTRODUCTION To improve the electrical and mechanical properties of advanced electronic ceramics, it is known that the methods of powder preparation and control of the starting materials, that is, grain size and size distribution, have a direct effect on the material properties. There are various kinds of chemical methods for ceramic powder preparation via a liquid phase, which make it easy to control the properties of the powder product and to prepare fine particles. The sol-gel method has some merits, such as highpurity, homogeneity, stoichiometric composition, and infinite flexibility [1,2] using a variety of organic raw materials However, it is necessary to reduce the agglomeration and to control the interaction between particles in suspension. The high reactivity results in shortening the sintering cycle and developing stability against inhomogeneous grain growth. Therefore, research on suspension behavior is necessary, but this can proceed only at a finite pace. The extent to which individual particles exist as aggregates obviously has a major influence on the behavior of the suspension during processing and on the properties and performance of the final product. Therefore, the primary emphases are on the preparation and dispersion of fine powders. The extension of most of the general concepts to high-density *Current affiliation: Daeww Corporation, Ltd., Seoul, Korea
215
YOON AND JO and homogeneous grain growth need to be assured The sintered samples, which are homogeneously packed with fine spherical particles, have high density, a reduced sintering cycle, and enhanced stability against abnormal grain growth. It is believed that by preparation of fine powders and manipulation of the dispersion characteristics, a uniformly packed, high green density compact with stable dispersion will result. From controlling the dispersion characteristics, enhancement of sintered density and stability from abnormal grain growth may be expected.
II. THE SOL-GEL METHOD Whena multicomponent alkoxide is used, the multicomponent or complex alkoxide can be prepared by reacting a combination of single alkoxides or by adding soluble inorganic salts to single or complex alkoxides. The species from an inorganic salt can be incorporated into both multicomponent alkoxides and the alkoxide sol structure itself. If the atom or ion from the salt is to be incorporated into the sol, it must be properly dispersed and then reacted to form the multicomponent oxide. Utilizing an inorganic salt in this manner requires obtaining a stable solution of the alkoxide and the salt. Metal salts less expansive than alkoxide, the use of metal salts compensates for a disadvantage of the sol-gel method. Barium titanate is a well-known dielectric material of technological importance for high-technology ceramics and is normally synthesized byconventional solid-state reaction. For the sol-gel-derived powder, the high surface area of the dried gel results in very high reactivity, which permits low-temperature processing, Therefore, the weight loss that is a problem inthe BaTiOg-PbTiO3 system may be reduced during calcination since vaporization of the PbO is expected to be less. By starting with well-mixed solutions or sols, chemical homogeneity on the molecular scale can be obtained. High purity can be maintained because the successive steps common to many conventional ceramic processes can be avoided The nature the solvent can likewise play a critical role in the synthesis. The solvents are not inert with respect to the reaction sequence. It is important to choose solvents for the complete solubility of alkoxides or salts. Solvents play a direct role through the process of alcohol exchange. The solvent and raw materials were dissolvedcompletely with vigorous stirring before the hydrolysis reaction at a certain temperature. The solution was refluxed for many hours. Generallythis temperature is near the boiling point of the solvent. The solvent must be dried before use to prevent partial hydrolysis. Because the alkoxide and salts are extremely moisture and carbon dioxide sensitive they may be handled under an N2 atmosphere. The early work of
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02
7
Mazdiyasni [S] utilized barium isopropoxide derived from high-purity Ba metal; much earlier, Flaschen [g] used Ba(OH)2 as a starting material. Ritter et al. [lo] studied the alkoxide-based synthesis of phases in aBaO-Ti02 system. Inorganic water-soluble salts, such as Bach and Ba(N03)2, are considered but not investigated because of the potential problems of crystallization of these reagents during drying .of the gels and contamination of the final electroceramic by the residual anionic species [1 l]. For PbTi02, there are two possible structures of product formed by the reaction of a lead salt and a titanium alkoxide [12]. The hydrolysis is performed for metal alkoxide precusors. It is performed by introducing the alkoxide into excess water under vigorous stirring. The purity of water seems to be very important as well, so hydrolysis is performed generally with deionized water. During hydrolysis, the input method of water is steam or slow dripping. The total amount of water for hydrolysis has an effect on particle size The rate of hydrolysis depends on the nature of both the metal ions and the alkoxide groups. The hydrolysis rate generally decreases with increasing length of the n-alkyl chain and with increasing branching of expected that the the alkyl group, presumably for steric reasons [14]. It is hydrolysis rate should increase as the metal ion is more electropositive. In the sol-gel method, the amount of acid usedfor peptization influences the shape and size of the particle [3]. Acid and base additions are generally specified in terms of pH. In this case, however, it is observed that the type of acid plays a much more important role than the pH of the system. The anions of the acid must be noncomplexing or very weakly complexing with metal ions at these low catalytic concentrations. The amount of acid in relation to the metal must not be large enough to prevent the formation of a continuous metal bonding through oxygen. For example, acrylic acid used for peptization in the (Ba, Pb)TiOs system has an ionization constant [4] of 10-5 at 25°C (generally others have ionization constants below Thus, the acrylic acid satisfied the general requirement for an acid for peptization: it must not be too large to prevent the formation of a continuous bonding of metalions of the alkoxide throughhydroxides. After hydrolysis and peptization, gel is formed. The last step, drying, plays a very important role in maintaining a fine powder and has direct effects on the calcination step. The relation between the drying method and the surface area of powders is important. There are many drying methods, such as vacuum, and freeze drying. This point is illustrated with the examples of (Ba0.2Pbo.s)Ti03. In powder preparation, the surface reactivity, that is, the specific surface area, plays a very important role. Specific surface areas are often determined by the BET (Brunauer, Eminett, and Teller) method. Typical BET plots of the sol-gel, CM0 (calcined mixed oxide method), and MSS (molten salt synthesis method) [l51 derived powders are shown in Fig. 1.
YOON AND JO M.
\
p"
m
0
.210 .l40
I
.?Q
BET plotfor(Bao.2Pbo.8)TiO3: (triangles) sol-gelderived (freeze dried); (squares) sol-gel derived (vacuum dried); (filled circles) CM0 derived (air dried); (open circles) MSS derived (air dried).
Table 1 shows that the specific surface area is dependent on the synthesis method for the powders. In general, sol-gel-derived (Bao.2Pbo.8)Ti03 powders have specific surface areas greater than those CMO-derived powders. Generally, the smaller the particle size, the greater is the specific surface area. Thus, it can be expected that the particle size of sol-gel-derived powders is smaller than that of CMO- and MSS-derived powders. When sol-gel-derived powders are dried,the surface areas air-dried,vacuum-dried,and freezedried powders are 36.4,51.9, and m2/g respectively. Freeze-dried powders have the highest value. These results are similar to the value for vacuum-dried powders prepared only from alkoxides by Mazdiyasni et al. [l61 Freeze-dried powders, after heat treating at 600"C, exhibited a surface area value of 19.9 m2/g, which is higher than those obtained by, Mazdiyasni [161 and Rehspringer and Bernier [17], 15 and 16.8 m2/g, respectively, both preparedusing only alkoxide. Metallurgical micrographs for sol-gel-derived (Bao.2Pbo.8)Ti03 prepared by air drying (Fig. 2) reveal that the air-dried powder has the strongest
219
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02 Table
BET Values(SurfaceArea) for (Bao.flb0.8jTiO3
Sol-gel CM0
powder Calcined Dried gel
”
Synthesis method
Air
dry
Air dry
Air dry
Vacuum Freeze
Ref.
Ref.
Ref.
Ref.
dry ~
Surface area, (m2M
agglomerate and the freeze-dried powder has the weakest agglomerate. The results agree with the BET values shown in Table 1. The freeze-drying method may be divided into freezing, sublimation, and desorption steps. The sublimation step is affected by the equilibrium condition of composition versus temperature and pressure. The advantages of this method are that it is easy to control particle size, composition, and input of minor components in the systems homogeneously, low-temperature processing is possible, and evaporation of volatile elements is prevented . The disadvantages are the need for a cold trap at very low temperatures and a vacuum system, this method is difficult to apply to mass production. The resulting monosized and submicrometer particles are easier to process into uniform green microstructures, which results in easier control of the microstructure during densification. This means uniformityof the particle size
2 Metallurgicalmicroscopephotographs for sol-gel-derived (Bao.flbf~.8) TiO3: (a) air drying, (b) freeze drying, (c) vacuum drying.
YOON AND JO
and distribution of the voids, which can be measured by a particle size or pore size analyzer. Figure 3 shows the BaTiO3-PbTiO3, particle size distributions as a function of synthesis method. In Fig. 3, the sol-gelderived powders have the narrowest particle size distribution and smallest mean diameter. The particle size and distribution can also be observed with scanning and transmission electron microscopy (SEM and TEM). X-ray diffraction of (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03 in Fig. shows that the powder is initially amorphous. Samples were calcined at various temperatures, and a progressive reduction in peak width with increasing calcination temperature can beseen. The x-ray diffraction patterns of solgelderived andCMO-derived(Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03 are shown inFig. For CMO-derived powders, the characteristic peaks of unreacted BaC03 are found at 600"C,andthey decrease with increasing the treatment temperature to 900°C. At 9OO"C, the powder is completely a single phase. The degree of crystallinity appears relatively good even at 600°C in the solgel method, indicating that this method has a synthesis temperature lower than that of the CM0 method. Tine infrared absorption spectra have been obtained for powder samples dispersed in pressed KBr disks to identify the molecular structure of their components, specifically organic materials. Figure
Particle
diameter
3 Particle size distributions of ( B ~ I - J . ~ P ~ o .prepared ~ ) T ~ Oby ~ differentmethods. (a) Sol-gel, CMO,(c) MSS.
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02
(b)
4 X-ray diffraction patterns of sol-gel-derived (Ba0.2Pb0.8)Ti03:(a) 60O0C, (c) 400"C, (d) 200°C.(e) 100"C, (0 dried gel.
6 shows the infrared (IR) absorption spectra (Bao.2Pbo.8)Ti03 heated to various temperatures. The absorption bands around cm-1 (peak 1) are caused by the stretching vibration -0-H bonds. With increasing heat treatment, a single C bond diminishes at lo00 cm-1 in size and a double C bond at 1650 cm-l.Peaks2and shift to lowerwavenumbers,and the intensity of the bands decreases with increasing temperature, suggesting gradual evaporation of the residual organic compounds. The absorption band (peak corresponds to the inorganic metal characteristic peak in the sol-gel-derived BaTi03-PbTi03 solid solution. The broad absorption band at cm-1 [l81 corresponds to the characteristic peaks BaTiOs. Lead titanate possesses two characteristic absorption bands at 580 cm and cm-1 [19]. Peak is broad and appears to include a PbTiOs peak in the region; there is a large component Pb in the composition of (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03. The breadth of peak narrows with increasing heat treatment temperature.The sharper peak indicates strengthening of the bonds[20,21]. In the same frequencyrange, the sharp peaksuggestsan increase in crystallization. Figure 7 shows infrared absorption spectra compared withCMO-derived,MSS-derived,and sol-gel-derived (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03. For
YOON AND JO
222
30
5 X-ray diffraction patterns (Ba0.2Pl~o.g)Ti03:(a) 600°C, 1 h (sol-gel derived), @) 900°C. 2 h (CM0 derived),(c)600°C, l h (CM0derived); * (circles) BaC03.
CMO-derived powders heated to 900°C, for MSS-derived powders heated to 8OO0C, and for sol-gel-derived powderheated to the characteristic peaks of the solid solutions indicate complete transition to the final oxide. The IR results show a tendency similar to that of the x-ray diffraction patterns mentioned before. The formation a fully crystalline product appears to be essentially complete at a relatively lowtemperature. Higher temperatures promote grain growth, resulting in an increase in average crystallite size but with no further crystallization. One can also observe a degree grain growth by SEM and
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02
Wavenumber (*102cm"
7 Infraredtransmissionspectra of (Ba1).2Pb&8)Ti03afterheating(a) 90OoC, 2 h (CM0derived), (b) 800"C, h (MSS derived),(c) 600"C, 1 h (sol-gel derived). (From Ref. 7.)
YOON AND JO
(a )
8 SEM photographs of (Bm.flbo.8)Ti03 prepared variousmethodsand sintered at 1200°C (bar = (a) CM0 derived, (b) sol-gel derived (nondispersed), (c) sol-gel derived (dispersed with ;2% PMMA).
"EM. Homogeneous and fine particles lead to a good sintered body. In a good sintered body, grain grows homogeneously. Figure 8 shows SEM photographs of BaTi03-PbTi03 solid solution from various synthesis methods. In the solgel-derived specimens, the grain size is smaller compared with CMO-derived specimens. However, in the well-dispersed system, which is explained in the next section, the grain grows homogeneously, resulting in high density.
DISPERSIONCHARACTERISTICS OF FINEPOWDERS
A.
Dispersion Characteristics at Various pH Values
The electrophoretic mobility is proportional to the 6 potential and is thus a qualitative measure of colloid stability. Therefore, to find how to prevent aggregation and accelerate dispersion, the variation in suspension behavior with pH, which determines the surface charge, and the effect of dispersion on the sintered specimens are the subjects of this study. l, potential measurements can provide important guidance on the preparation of colloidal dispersions. plot of 6 potential against pH for the sol-gel-derived (Bao.2, Pbo.8)Ti03 gel is given in Fig. [22]. The point of zero charge (PZC) is found to occur at (Ba2+, Pb2+, and T i 4 ion concentrations of 10-7, 5.01 10-7, and l0-8M, respectively, or &, = - log [Ba2+] = 6.7, ppb = - log [Pb2+] = 6.3, and h i = -log [Ti&] = 6.0 [23]. point of zero charge (6 = 0) with positive and negative charge branches is shown in Fig. 9. The 6 potential simply decreases to zero with an increase in pH to 7 and becomes increasingly negative with further increases in pH. Thermogravimetric analysis of (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03 powders is shown in Fig. 10.The drastic weight loss is attributed to dehydration and the
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02
c potential as a function
225
pH for sol-gel-derived (Bao.zPbo.s)Ti03.
loss of volatile organic solvent residue from the solution at high temperature for pH and At the isoelectric point, pH 7, the weight loss is small. Mazdiyasni studied the preparation of fine particles and their applications to perovskite materials. In this report, a well-dispersed colloidal system with good reactivityaccelerated the removalof organic residue from the solution and maintained the deagglomerative conditions. Extensive reviews of the charge potential behavior of colloidal systems have been given by Hunter The most important dissociable groups are of the strong acid (sulfate or sulfonate), weak acid (sulfite or carboxyl), weak base (amine), and strong base (quaternary ammonium) types, and they may occur alone at the surface or in various combinations. These combinations form zwitterionic surfaces, and then the driving force removed from the system is replaced by repulsive and interactive forces. The specific surface areas of sol-gel-derived (Bm.2Pb0.8)Ti03powders are m2/g for pH and m2/g for pH and That pH 7 is found to be highly agglomerated, and those at pH and pH indicate good dis-
YOON AND JO
Thermogravimetry function aas of pH for sol-gel-derived (Ba0.2Pbo.g)Ti03:(solidline) pH 1; (dash-dotline) pH (dash-doubledot) pH (dashed) pH 7;(circles) pH (squares) pH (triangles) pH (From Ref. 22.)
persion. Metallurgical microscope photographs the sol-gel-derived (Bao.2Pbo.8)Ti03at various pH are shown in Fig. 11. The results correlate with the weight loss and BET values. For all operations that involve suspensions powders in liquids, the processing behavior is dominated by the rheological properties of the suspension. Suspension rheology is determined largely by the agglomeration of particles within the liquid. Most suspensions of ceramic interest are shear thinning, and their properties depend upon plastic viscosity. Plastic viscosity depends on the state viscosity as a function agglomeration. Figure 12 shows a plot shear rate and pH for sol-gel-derived (Bm.2Pb0.8)Ti03 powders. In the samples at pH 3-9, the shear-thinning phenomenon is apparent, demonstrating that
. ..
...
*'
'
.
,
... ... ....'
.. .
. *-
-
.' I
Metallurgical microscope photographs of sol-gelderived (Bao.2Pb0.8)Ti03:(a)pH 1, (b) pH 3, (c) pH 5, (dl pH 7, (e) pH 9, (0 pH 11, (g) pH 13. (From Ref. 22.)
'p =
30 Shear Rate (sec" )
Suspension viscosity plotted against shear rate for sol-gel-derived (Bao.$b0.8)Ti03:(opencircles)pH 1; (filledcircles) pH 3; (open triangles)pH 5; (filled triangles) pH 7 ; (open squares) pH 9; (filled squares) pH 11; (exes) pH 13. (From Ref. 22.)
227
228
YOON AND JO
there is a weak agglomeration in the suspension. At higher pH or greater negative potential value, the viscosity decreases with increasing shear rate. One of the most obvious effects is the creation of large voids caused by poor packing around aggregates and huge voids caused by the bridging of aggregates. Such voids, much larger than the surrounding grains, cannot be removed during sintering: there is no driving force for elimination of such oversized pores. A more subtle effect occurs when the packing density is not uniform, having denser regions and more porous regions. This leads to locally inhomogeneous sintering and microstructures with completely dense patches and more porous areas. In the dense regions, there is no porosity to impede grain boundary migration, and grain growth is rapid. Sintering kinetics is affected by the state of agglomeration as well. X-ray diffraction patterns of the calcined powders and the sintered specimens of the sol-gel-derived (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03 are shown in Fig. 13. In the pH 1 pattern, not only the characteristic peaks of the solid solution but also second-phase peaks are found from the HCl used to adjust the dispersion characteristics. For the pH 13 specimen, however, only the characteristic peaks of the solid solution appear. At low pH, the degree of crystallinity is reduced and the powder is not synthesized completely. Figure shows infrared absorption spectra of sol-gel4erived (Bao.2Pbo.8)Ti03 calcined powder for various dispersives in pH. The intensity of the hydrogen bond and the characteristic bond of the organic compound in the dried gel decrease as the pH is increased. Peaks 2 and 3 become sharper with an increase in pH and shift to higher frequencies as the crystalline phase becomes more stable. Figure 15 shows the apparent and relative density for
c
13 X-ray diffractionpatterns of sol-gelderived (Bao.2Pbo.s)TiO3dispersed in (a)
1, (b) pH 7, (c) pH 13.
3OOO (cm”)
14 Infraredtransmission of sol-gelderived and
[email protected])Ti03: (a) pH 1, (b) pH 7 , (c) pH
15 Apparentand relativedensityplottedagainstpHforsol-gel-derived (Bao.2Pbo.8)Ti03 sintered at 1200°C for 0.5 h.
229
YOON AND JO
230
I SEM photographs of(Ba0.2Pbo.g)Ti03sinteredat pH 1, (b) pH 7, pH 13. (Bar = 1 pm.)
1200°C for 0.5 h: (a)
(Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03 sintered at 1200°C for h as a function of pH. At pH 7, where the dispersion is poor, the density is the lower than at all other pH levels. The effect on the sintering mechanism of agglomerate size and particle size inyttria-stabilized zirconia hasbeenstudied by Rhodes [26]. According to Rhodes’ report, an agglomerate with a very open arrangement of crystallites may develop large pores pore clusters and leave large lenticular voids that are difficult to close. These results decrease the density. Reeve [27] predicted a similar phenomenon in BeO. At pH 11 and 13, with good dispersion characteristics, the sintered density is high. SEM photographs of the sol-gel-derived (Ba0.2Pb0.8)Ti03as a function of pH are shown in Fig. 16. At pH 13, the grain size is homogeneous; aggregation appears and the sinterability decreases at pH 7.
B. Dispersion Characteristics as a Function of Polymethyl Methacrylate (PMMA) Solvents should have a solubility parameter close to that of the organic polymer chain to maximize extension of the attached chain into the liquid. The extent of polymer adsorption from a solution is determined by the balance of three interactions: polymer-solvent, polymer-adsorbent, and solvent-adsorbent. In good solvents (i.e., solvents in which polymer-solvent contacts are energetically favored over polymer-polymer and solvent-solvent contacts, called 0 solvents), the polymer chains on one particle repel the polymer on another. In contrast, a poor solvent is such that segment-segment contacts are energetically favored, leading to association of the polymer molecules. Since osmotic pressure is a colligative property, intermolecular association leads to fewer osmot-
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02
231
ically active species in solution, and this leads to a negative deviation from ideality. The polymer is tied to the surface at a number of points, but for some of its length it is able to extend into the solution. Segments attached to the surface form trains, which are separated by loops: theends of the polymer are ally able to extend into the solutions as tails. Complete dissolution of the polymer allows the outer segments to extend into the solution and the inner segments to become attached to the particle surface. Polymers can be good dispersants only in suitable solvents. In BaTiOsand related material systems, PMMA is a popular dispersant PMMA is dissolved completely when nhexane and benzene are used as the dispersing medium for this system sedimentation density, show an The results, illustrated in Fig. 17 in terms optimum dispersion in the 70% benzene and 30% hexane mixture. Above 40% n-hexane, the point is reached and the sedimentation density decreases drastically. The point is as follows: with gas molecules, polymer chains can show either positive or negative deviations from ideal behavior. It follows that a temperature can be found at which the solvency leads to ideal osmotic pressure behavior, at least up to a polymer concentration of a few percent. Under solvency conditions, polymer molecules ofamillion molecular weight behave as if they are ideal small molecules. At this temperature, the effects of attractive and repulsive interactions balance one another. This implies
F :
8
e
(% (%)
17 Sedimentation (Bao.zPbo.8)TiO3powderdispersedinsolutions various PMMA contents in benzene-hexane mixtures: (a)0%.(b) OS%, (c) .O%, (d) 1 S%, (e) 2.0%, 3.0%.
YOON AND JO that the polymer chains can telescope one another without change in the Gibbs free energy. Thus, the point represents the transitional point with respect to segmentsolvent interactions. At this point, the polymer segments change from exhibiting a net mutual repulsion to a net mutual attraction. A fuller description of this change would involve consideration of segment-segment, segment-solvent, and solvent-solvent interactions. The adsorption of polymer molecules at aninterface, which determines the segment density distribution function, is critically dependent upon many factors, which include the chemical constitution of the polymer, (2) the chemical nature and geometrical shape of the interface, the chemical composition of the solvent, the mode of attachment of the polymer chains to the surface, and the surface density of the polymer molecules at the interface. It is the subtle interaction of these diverse factors that determines the conformation of a polymer at an interface and thus the steric interactionina particular system. The effect ofPMMA concentration on (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03 sedimentation density in 70% benzene and 30% hexane is shown in Fig. The results show the best dispersion at about 2% PMMA concentration, with a slight decrease in packing at higher concentrations, which can also affect weight loss during firing. Dehydration and removal of the organic residue increased with increasing the concentration of polymer to a critical concentration, above which these decreased. The weight loss is not proportional to the concentration polymer as a dispersant. Poly(viny1 alcohol) in aqueous solution takes up much space, which results in brisk dehydration. This can be confirmed by Fig. 19. Optical micrographs for sol-gel-derived (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03powders dispersed in 70% benzene and 30% hexane mixture as a function of PMMA concentration are shown here. Optimum dispersion ap-
(%
Effect of PMMA content on (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03 sedimentationin 70% benzene and 30% hexane mixture.
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02
233
Metallurgicalmicrographsfor sol-gelderived (Bac~Pbr~)Ti03 powder dispersed in 70% benzene and 30% hexane as a function of PMMA content: (a) 0%, (b) OS%, (c) (d) 1.5%, (e) 2.0%, 3.0%.
pears at about PMMA concentration. This result supports the preceding theory. There are numerous ways of determining the concentration of the polymer in the adsorptionmedium. These include (1) gravimetric analysis by direct weighing of the polymer after vaporization of the solvent, (2) spectrophotometric analysis using the visible, infrared, and ultraviolet regions of the spectra, the refractometric method, viscometric methods, densometric methods, (6) titrimetric analysis, (7) use of radioisotopes, and (8) measurements of the change in other physical constants, such as turbidity, and dipole moment. Viscosity measurement is used to determine the quality of dispersion in suspensions. well-dispersed system usually shows a Newtonian viscosity with no pseudoplasticity. The viscosity of such a system is lower than that of poorly dispersed systems. A plot of viscosity against dispersant concentration typically shows a rapid decrease in viscosity and then a leveling at a concentration required for monolayer coverage of dispersant on particle surfaces. At higher dispersant concentrations the viscosity either rises again or remains low. The degree of agglomeration in dilute particle suspensions can also be found
YOON AND JO
234
by particle size measurements using a photon correlator; agglomeration leads to an increase in the average apparent particle size. Figure 20 represents plots of suspension viscosity against shear rate for solgel-derived (Ba0.2Pb0.8)Ti03 as a function of PMMA concentration. The viscosity decreased with increasing shear rate in the 0% PMMA solution. In this chapter the suspension with no polymer addition shows extensive low shear rate aggregation, as indicated by the high shear-thinning behavior. The viscosity becomes independent of shear rate, that is, Newtonian behavior observed with an increase in the polymer. For the interaction between polymers and a mica sheet, explained in detail by Klein the viscosity of the suspension with polymer washigher than that of the suspension without polymer. The reason for this is the high molecular weight of the polymer itself. Molecular packing and sedimentation density play a crucial role in determining the characteristic of the green and sintered specimens. The high packing density satisfies the conditions for a pore-free and dense, sintered body. Figure 21 shows the apparent and relative densities of sol-gel-derived (Bao.2Pbo.8)Ti03 sintered at 1200°C for 0.5 h after dispersion in PMMA solution. The sintered density increases with increasing the PMMA concentration to 2% PMMA, above which it decreases. The highest sedimentation density at 23% concentration is char-
Shear
20 Suspensionviscosityplottedagainst shear rate for sol-gelderived (Bao.zPbo.8)Ti03 as a functionof PMMA content: (a) 0%,(b) OS%, (c) (d) 1.5%, (e) 2.0%, 3.0%. (From Ref. 28.)
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02
235
3 (% )
Apparentandrelativedensityplottedagainst gel-derived (Bao.2Pbo.8)Ti03 sintered at for 0.5 h.
PMMA content for sol-
acteristic of a well-dispersed suspension. Addition of a polymer enhances the strength, flexibility, and workability of ceramics in its green state, before sintering. It might be preferable for the polymer to function not only as a dispersant but also as a binder. The effect of a dispersant on green and sintered specimens has been studied by Calvert et al. The agglomeration causes inhomogeneous grain growth and void formation. The residual pores and agglomerates in the sintered body act as microflawsthatadversely affect mechanical and dielectrical properties. InFig. 22 the dielectric constant of (Ba0.2Pbo.8)Ti03sintered at 1200°C for 0.5 h is given as a function of PMMA concentration. The packing density increases with increasing PMMA concentration A good packing density results in high sintered density and high dielectric constant. However, at higher PMMA concentrations (>2%), poor dispersion behavior causes decreasing density and results in a decrease in the dielectric constant.
YOON AND JO
r
Temperature
22 Dielectric constantplottedagainsttemperatureforsol-gelaerived (Bao.2Pbo.g)Ti03sinteredat for h withaPMMAcontentof OS%, (c) (d) (e)
(a) 0%, (b)
REFERENCES Sakka,
Sol-gel synthesis of glasses: Present and future, Am. Cerum. Bull.
Segal, D. L.,Sol-gel processing: Routes to oxide ceramics using colloidal dispersionsofhydrogenoxidesandalkoxideintermediates, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, Dislich, H., and Him, P., History and principles of the sol-gel process, and some new multicomponent oxide coatings, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, Jo, K. H., Yoon, K. H., Preparation of sol-gel derived (Bao.zPbo.g)Ti03 powders, Muter. Res. Bull.,
Ueyama, T., Wada, H., and Kanako, N., Pulverization and dispersion technique foragglomeratedparticlesofaluminapowderinaslurry, J. Am Cerum Commun., 71,
Afsten, N. J., Sol-gel derived transparent IR-reflecting IT0 semiconductor coatings and future applications, J. Non-Cryst. Solids,
SYNTHESIS AND DISPERSION OF BaO-Ti02 7. Jo, K. H., and Yoon, K. H., Characteristics of the (Bal-xPh)Ti03 powders prepared by various synthesis methods, J. Kor. Cerum. 27, 127 (1990). 8. Mazdiyasni, K. S., Fine praticle perovskite processing,Am. Cerum. Bull., 591 (1984). 9. Flaschen, S. S., Preparation BaTiOs by chemical methods, J. Am. Cerum. 77, 6194 (1955). 10. Ritter, J. J.. Roth, R. S., and Blendell, J. E., Alkoxide precursor synthesis and characterizationofphaseinthebarium-titaniumoxidesystem, J. Am.Cerum. 155 (1986). 11. Phule,D.P.,andRisbud, S. H.,Sol-gelsynthesisofbariumtitanatepowders Adv.Cerum. Mat., 183 usingbariumacetateandtitanium(1V)isopropoxide, (1988). 12. Grukovich, S. R.,andBlum, J. B., UltrastructureProcessing of Ceramics, Glasses and Composites, John Wiley and Sons, New York, 1984, p. 152. K., Formation,packing,andsinteringof 13. Baninger,E.A.,andBowen,H. monodisperse Ti02 powders, J. Am. Cerum. Soc., C-l99 (1982). Metal Alkoxide. Academic 14. Bradley,D. C., Mehrotra,R.C.,andGaur,D.P., Press, NewYork, 1970, p. O., Influence of synthesis methods of the 15. Yoon, K. H., Oh, K. Y., and Yoon, FTCR effect in semiconducting BaTi03, Mat. Res. Bull., 21, 1429 (1986). 16. Mazdiyasni, K. S., Dolloff, R. T., and Smith, J. S., III, Preparation high purity submicron barium titanate powders, J. Am. Cerum. Soc., 52, 523 (1969). Symp. Proc., Pittsburgh, PA., 17. Rehspringer,J. L., and Bemier, J. C., Mat. Res. 1986, p. 67. 18. Last, J. T., Infrared-absorption studies on barium titanate and related materials, Phys. Rev., 105, 1740 (1957). 19. Congshen, Z., Lisong, H., Fuxi, G., and Zhonghong, J., Low temperature synthe-
sis ZrO2-TiO2-SiO2 glasses from Zr(N03)45H20, Si(OC2H5)4 and Ti(OC4H9)4 106 (1984). by the sol-gel method, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 20. Gottardi,V.,Gulielini, M., Bertoluzza,A.,Fagnano,C.,andMorelli,M.A., Ramanandinfraredspectraonsilicagelevolvingtowardglass, J. Non-Cryst. Solids, 48, 117 (1965). Mat. Sci. Eng., 44, l(1980). 21. Bowen, H. K., Iron diffusion in iron-aluminate spinel, 22. Jo, J. H.,Kim,E. and Yoon, K. H., Dispersion characteristics of sol-gel derived (Bao.flb0.8)Ti03 at various pH, J. Mat. Sci., 25, 880 (1990). 23. Lauf, R. J., and Bond, W. D., Fabrication high field zinc oxide varistor by solgel processing. Am. Cerum. Bull., 278 (1984). Effects of dispersion of barium titanate powder on measure24. Mazdiyasni, K. Bull., ments in an electrical-sensing-zone particle size counter, Am. Cerum. 57, 448 (1978). 25. Hunter, R. J., Zetapotential in Colloid Science, Academic Press, New York, 1981, p. 134. on sintering yittria-stabi26. Rhodes, W. H.,Agglomerateandparticlesizeeffects lized zirconia, J. Am. Cerum. 19 (1981). Bull., 42,452 27. Reeve, R. D., Non-uniform shrinkage in sintering,Am. Cerum. (1963).
YOON AND JO 28. Jo, K. H., and Yoon, K. H., Dispersion characteristics of sol-gel derived (Bao.2pbo.8)Ti03 as a function of PMMA, J. Mat. Sci., 809 (1991). 29. Napper,D. H.,Polymeric Stabilimtion of Colloid Dispersions, Academic Press, NewYork,1983, p. 197. Klein, J., Forces between mica surfaces bearing layer of absorbed polystyrene in cyclohexane, Nature, 288, 248 (1980). 31. Calvert, P., Lanardham, R., Parish, M., and Tormey, E.,Dispersants in Ceramics, JohnWileyand Sons, New York, 1984, p. 249.
10 Rheology and Mixing of Ceramic Mixtures Used in Plastic Molding Beebhas Michigan Technological University Houghton, Michigan
The plastic forming of ceramic shapes is based on the application of external forces to a mixture of ceramic powder and binder. The plastic mixture deforms and flows under applied stresses. The external forces cause the plastic mix to be adjusted to any die or mold, which dictates the eventual shape. Therefore, the flow behavior of such mixes during plastic forming has a major effect on the quality of the ceramic parts. Again, the flow stability of the mix during forming depends on the homogeneity of the ceramic powder and binder mixture. The primary focus of this chapter is to describe the factors that influence flow behavior and mix homogeneity of a plastic mixture containing a high volume fraction of ceramic powder as a filler and a relatively small volume fraction of organic polymeric binder. The emphasis is placed on mixes in which flowability is achieved only above the ambient temperature.
II. The flow of a plastic mass through a die or into a mold is dictated by its rheological behavior. Rheology describes the deformation and flow of a material under the influence of applied stresses. The rheological response of a fluid is generally expressed as viscosity. The viscosity of a fluid is a measure of the
239
240
MATSUDDY
internal resistance offered to the relative motion of different parts of the fluid. Viscosity is defined as Newtonian when the shearing force per unit area z between two parallel planes of fluid in relativemotion is proportional to the velocity gradient between the planes; in other words,
dx where:
q = coefficient of viscosity z = shear stress = forcelarea = Nlm2 = Pa = shear rate = m/s/m = q = dynamic viscosity = zly, (Pa=s) For many fluids, especially if highly concentrated and/or if the particles are asymmetric, deviations from Newtonian flow are observed.The main causes of non-Newtonian flow are the formation of a structure throughout the fluid and the orientation of asymmetric particles caused by the velocity gradient. Non-Newtonian fluids may be classified (shown in Fig. 1) as follows: Pseudoplastic, in which the shear depends on the shear rate alone. Power law, in which the shear is not a linear but an exponential function of shear rate. The rheological expression for a power-law fluid is T = Ky"
(2)
where n is the power-law index and K is known as the coefficient of vis(1) if n = 1, or unity, the cosity. Here, we have three different situations: fluid is characterized as Newtonian; (2) if n < 1, less than unity, the fluid is considered pseudoplastic; and (3) the fluid is characterized as dilatant if n > 1. This lastcharacteristic is sometimes encountered with filled systems when the filler concentration is very high, that the corresponding scarcity of a continuous phase makes it difficult for the dispersed particles to slide over one another. The lack of adequate lubrication by the continuous phase produces frictional voids and sets up structures among the particles under constraint. These structures become increasingly resistant to deformation as the applied shear rate is increased: the viscosity increases with increasing shear rate. Fluids in which no deformation occurs until a certain threshold shear stress is applied, in which upon the shear stress z becomes a linear function of shear rate The characteristics of the function are the slope (viscosity) and the shear stress intercept (yield value) The rheological expression for this type of material, known as a Bingham solid, is
241
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING ORatenl with
Pdnt
t
with
Point
Shear Rate
Figure
-
Classification of non-Newtonianfluids.(After J.
Reed, Introduction
the Principles of Ceramic Processing, Wiley-Interscience, New York.)
Only when the applied stress is greater than the yield stress do viscous flow and shear deformation become manifest. Fluids that show a decrease in shear stress (hence in apparent viscosity) with time are termed thixotropic and are often observed with ceramic slurries. Rheologists have long believed that all fluids are viscoelastic in behavior. a result, the deformation of any fluid from the imposition of a stress is the sum of an elastic deformation, which is recoverable, and viscous flow, which is not recoverable. For fluids low viscosity at moderate rates of shear, the elastic recovery is extremely rapid and the relaxation time is extremely short. a result, the elastic portion of the deformation is too small to measure, and the fluid is considered simply viscous. When viscoelastic fluids are stressed, some of the energy involved is stored elastically, various parts of the system being deformed into new nonequilibrium positions relative to one another. The remainder is dissipated as heat, various parts of the system flowing into new equilibrium positions relative to one another. The elastic nature ofa fluid is characterized by dynamic mechanical or stress relaxation techniques. Dynamic mechanical (oscillatory) testing is a procedure inwhicha sample is sinusoidally strained and the resultant stress is measured. The she& stress varies with the same frequency as the shear rate
MATSUDDY
242
y but not in phase with it, the phase angle between and y being equal to n/2 for anon-Newtonianfluid. Because the normal stress differences are even functions of the shear rate, they vary at twice the applied frequency; they also suffer different phase shifts. Measuring the amplitudes of the stresses and their phase shifts with respect to y is a standard way of studying viscoelastic effects in non-Newtonian fluids. These measurements do not change with time unless the fluid exhibits thixotropy. In measuring viscoelastic effects with an oscillating plate method, the percentage of strain must be selected carefully, because the strain is proportional to the total angle at which the plate is turning. The larger the angle through which the plate oscillates, the greater is the strain. If the angle is too large, the fluid being measured may undergo internal cracking or segregation.
A.
Viscosity of HighlyFilledFluids
Figure 2 shows the flow curves for concentrated aqueous suspensions of 30 vol% 3Y-zirconia and 70 vol% alumina [l]. Figure 2 illustrates near-Newtonian flow characteristic of suspensions with filler concentrations as high as ~01%.Newtonian flow is generally encountered with highly filled suspensions when the polymeric binder concentration in the suspension is fairly low ( 4 ~01%)and the suspension is highly dispersed (discussed later). Figure 3 shows a gradual decrease in viscosity at different ceramic powder concentrations with
p
120
0 15
0
30
45
75
Bo
105
120
135
150
Shear Rate,
2 nia
curves for concentratedaqueoussuspensions of 30 vol%3Y-zircovol% alumina.
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING
* x
4 l00
V/O 55v/O
V/O EEA
SIC + 4 5 V/O
V/O
..
Sic +
V/O
Sic + Sic +
V/O
EEA
V/O EEA
I
l000
Shear Rate (per
Decrease in viscosity at different concentrations of silicon carbide in EEA with increasing shear rate at increasing shear rate at temperature. The flow behavior is typically pseudoplastic. The power-law index n these fluids should be less than The suspension consists ofa silicon carbide powder (Starck and ethylene ethyl acrylate (EEA) polymer ~01%).Figure shows (shear stress)ll2 plotted against (shear rate)ln for vol% silicon carbide in polyethylene at The extrapolated intercept at zero shear rate gives the Bingham yield value .z, The general phenomenon dilatancy was observed by Reynolds in Reynolds observed that a mixture beach sand and water confined in a balloon would dilate if deformed; that is, the total volume the mixture would increase under pressure, causing the liquid level in the balloon to be lowered. In addition to the dilation, such a mixture would exhibit increasing resistance to stirring as the rate stirring was increased, until rupture the pseudosolid material that resulted occurred. A more general meaning the term “dilatant fluid” can be given by extending it to all materials showing increasingly apparent viscosity with an increasing rate shear. Sometimes this is referred to as inverted plasticity to differentiate between volumetric dilation versus no volumetric dilation. Typical dilatant flow curves for two concentrations alumina and paraffin wax are shown in Fig. Reynolds’ approach to dilatancy has some limitations. For example, Reynolds’ approach specifies hexagonal close pack-
" MATSUDDY
N
2m
0
Shear R a t e 1/2 ,
112
4 (Shear stress)ln against(shear rate)ln for 55 vol% siliconcarbidein 45 vol% polyethylene at 150°C.
ing. Such close packing is represented byavoid volume of approximately 28%. Therefore, it is expected that the volume concentration of dispersed, spherical particles must approach 72% for dilatancy to occur. In reality, dilatancy has been observed in fluids with solid concentrations well below 72% (Fig. 5). Besides, the approach does not account for other factors, such as the wetting characteristics of the suspension fluid for the dispersed solid, the pension fluid viscosity, and the effect of particle size of the dispersed solid.
B.
Viscoelastic Behavior of Highly Filled Fluids
Figure 6 shows plots of the storage modulus versus oscillation frequency for samples with S i c concentrations of 50, 57, and ~01%. the solids
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING
I
I
1 1 1 1 .
i
I
I
I
I
I l l l j
Shear Rate,
5 Dilatant fin wax, 37 and 35
curves at 150°C.
concentrations of
alumina and paraf-
loading increases, at lower frequencies the storage modulus increases as a function of shear rate. The S i c filler increases the rigidity of the polymer. The increases in rigidity implies less mobility the macromolecular chains under the influence of the applied shear stress. In a highly concentrated suspension (say above 60 vol%), there is particle-particle interaction analogous to the chain entanglements in polymer solutions, showing a tendency for a rapid decrease in storage modulus that is indicative of nonuniform dispersion and agglomeration. This suggests that the storage modulus decreases because the agglomerates do not absorb much energy during interparticle movement.
C.
Influence of Temperature on Fluid Flow
Temperature has a significant effect on the flow behavior of liquids and slurries, including polymer melts, solutions, and filled suspensions. Viscosity de-
246
MATSUDDY I
109
-
IO8
-
I
I Ill1
I
I
I
I
I
I
V
V
V
V
m
m
m
V
m m Ig,
m
107
-
0
0
V
0
0
b
V
V/O
t
0-
m-
v-
lo5
104L1
-
I
I I 1 1 l l1 l
I
I
Sic +
V/O
5 0 V/O SIC
+
I
I
EEA
50"I/O EEA 57 V/O SIC + 4 3 V/O EEA 6 3 V/O sic + 37 V / O EEA
I I l l10 1
I
I Ill
Frequency,
6 Storage modulus versus oscillating frequency for 40, 50, 57, and 63 vel% silicon carbide with at creases with increasing temperature for both Newtonian and non-Newtonian fluids, primarily because of a decrease in intermolecular forces. The increased flexibility of a polymer backbone chain also contributes to reduce viscosity. The relation between viscosity and the temperature of a filled suspension can be expressed by the modified Eyring equation, which allows for variations in the free volume of the fluid structure:
In this equation h is Planck's constant, No is Avogadro's number, Vm is the molar volume the fluid phase, E is the activation energy needed to overcome the potential barrier between equilibrium positions, is a constant in the range 0.5-1.0, V0 is the van der Waals volume of the molecule, and V is the average volume per molecule in the fluid. Because the exponential form the viscosity equation, mixtures of ceramic powder in thermoplastic binder are only significantly sensitive to temperature change above 70°C In an injection molding operation, it is usual to plot In q versus T for a constant shear rate, not a In q versus 1/T plot at a
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING
247
353 363 373 Temperature(K) cludes
7 Effect of temperature on viscosity at a constant rate of shear of vol% A1203 and vol% ethylene-vinyl acetate. (After Ref. 3).
in-
constant force. An example of one such plot for vol% A1203 loading in vol% ethylene-vinyl acetate copolymer is shown in Fig. 7. The linearity of sucha plot indicates the process sensitivity to temperature change, and the slope provides a measure of the activation energy for viscous flow. For a filled suspension, the effect of temperature on particle-particle interaction must be considered, in addition to the effect of temperature on inter- and intramolecular interaction in polymers. This temperature effect depends on the level of loading. If the temperature is sufficiently high to allow migration of binder from particle-particle interfaces, then the suspension may exhibit dilatancy in place of pseudoplasticity. The effect of temperature is similar to that of shear rate on polymer rheology, but its effect on particle-particle interaction is unpredictable. Both high temperature and high shear rate weaken polymerparticle interaction. However, it is important to remember that the extent of the effect (viscosity and interaction reduction) for a particular change in shear rate or temperature is not predictable. Both factors, exerting their effects at different rates, contribute to the complexity of the system.
D. Effect of FillerConcentration Concentration effects and interparticle forces are of rheological significance with injection molding mixes. Increasing the filler concentration (volume fraction) of a suspension increases the suspension relative viscosity = where is the suspension viscosity and q o is the continuous-phase viscosity.
MATSUDDY In the dilute region (CD O.l), is a linear function of CD and for spheres is found to obey the Einstein relation
(5)
q R= l + 2.5$ As CD increases, particle-particle interactions become significant and Eq. (5) takes the form of a general power-series equation in volume fraction [5]:
-=1+2.5t$+kt$'+ rl TO
+
The second-order coefficient k need not be a constant. In general, k is a complex function of the variables that determine particle interactions. DeBruijn [6] assumed that (6) was a quadratic and that the relative viscosity T R would become infinite when the volume fraction reached the value for cubic closepacked spheres. The value of k then becomes 4.7, but it increases slowly as the particles are more disordered. According to Vand's [7] assumption, however, if pairs of particles separate along rectilinear paths after collision, then k has a value of 7.4. A setback with this approach is that at higher concentrations a large number of terms in Eq. (6) are required to calculate T R , with the greatest influence moving to the terms with high powers of CD. Allowing for interaction between particles and for interactions between particles and continuous phase, Mooney [8] proposed the expression
and introduced k as l/CDmax.In the limit CD + 0, Eq. (7) reduces to 1 + B@. Thus, B can be interpreted as an Einstein coefficient and should be between and 5, depending on the degree of agglomeration and the extent of electrochemical forces between the particles. As CD + l/k, r ) + ~ therefore, k-* refers the maximum possible value of CD, that is, the value for which the suspension loses mobility, k is known as a crowding factor. Equation (7) provides a reasonable fit; as the data for an A1203-EVA (ethylene-vinyl acetate) copolymer (with M n = 3500 and melt flow index = 200, the melt flow index defined in terms of the amount of polymer that flows through a die in a given period of time: the higher the flow rate and thus the lower the viscosity, the higher the melt flow index) show the 4 2 0 3 had an irregular shape and agglomerated with a mean particle size 0.62 Relative viscosities at four powder loadings are given in Table 1. Taking logs of Eq. (7),
B$ lnqR = l-kt$
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING Table 1
RelativeViscosity Determinedat a Shear of A1203-EVA Molding Mixes
Rate of
vol.% A1203
Relative viscosity
1.83 41.0 48.0 3.91 57.0 63.0
6.25 12.55 49.90
In 7
) ~
2.53 5.30
After Ref. 3.
A plot of this equation, shown in Fig. 8, can be used to find the slope at x, y, and
@m:
B 1 - 0.41/$, B 11.43 = 1 - 0.48/$, =
at at Y
Hence B = 2.46, which is a close fit to the Einstein constant 2S@m = 61.396, which is less than perfect close packing of the powder, an effect contributing to shape irregularity and agglomeration.
5 4 ~ -
1 -
0.1
0.3
0.5 0.6
Volume Fraction
8 Plot of <<m.
m.(8) using data from Table 1 can provide the slope at
y, and
MATSUDDY
MIXING The objective in the mixing process is to disperse uniformly a relatively small amount of binder in a much larger quantity of fine powder and to achieve a homogeneous mix-one free of agglomerates that contains the optimum ceramic and binder content while maintaining sufficient fluidity for molding. It is a critical process step in producing high-quality, reliable injection-molded ceramic parts. Nevertheless, it has always been regarded as a simple operation, partly because relatively crude methods of mixing can be made effective if the operation is continued over an extended period of time. Mixing involves the transport of the material in the mixer to produce the desired spatial arrangement of the individual component.
Mixing Mechanism According to Lacey lowing steps
the transport mechanisms can be grouped into the fol-
1. Diffusion mixing: If two materials are placed in a container, after a suffi-
cient length of time has elapsed the molecules of both materials commingle as a consequence of both the concentration gradient and random molecular motion. The result is the formation ofa uniform mixture ona submicrometer scale by molecular diffusion. The type of diffusion process usually encountered in practical mixing situations results from velocity gradients within the fluid. This diffusion process by itself, however, is too slow for the preparation of ceramic molding mixes. Laminar mixing: The term “laminar” is applied to any operation that increases the randomness ofthe spatial distribution of the binder constituents or particles in a system, without reducing their size. In laminar mixing, the binder constituents pass from a less to a more random arrangement. Dispersive mixing: An important application of dispersive mixing is the incorporation of the ceramic powder into the molten organic binder. During dispersion, the agglomerates of the constituent elements of the secondary component of the mixture are ruptured. Whenever there is relative motion between a fluid and a particle, drag forces act on the particle’s surface. If the fluid velocity is greater than the particle velocity, these drag forces tend to accelerate the particle. If the particle velocity is greater than the fluid velocity, they tend to retard its movement. If the particles are spherical and if the Reynolds number (Reynolds number represents the ratio of inertial forces to the viscous force-dominated regime; that is, a low Reynoldsnumber, to one that is inertial force dominated, that is, ahigh Reynolds number) for the flow of a particle is low, then according to Stokes’ law, the drag force exerted on this particle is equal to 6xReqV, where V is the
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING
251
relative velocity between the fluid and the particle, Re is the Reynolds number, is the viscosity of the suspension, and 6n is a geometric factor for a very large diameter tube. High shear stresses promote dispersion in dispersive mixing. In any given system, there is some stress, defined as the critical stress, below which dispersion cannot occur.However,when the shear stress is just slightly larger than the critical stress, only agglomerates with a favorable initial orientation become dispersed. If the flow in the mixer is completely unidirectional, only agglomerates with a favorable initial orientation are ruptured. The others are aligned with the flow, and no further dispersion takes place evenwith continued mixing. However, if the mixer causes the flow pattern to change direction continually, further dispersion can occur as mixing continues. Ultimately, the shear stresses created position all the remaining agglomerates in an orientation favorable for rupture to occur.As mixing proceeds, all three mechanisms function to some extent.
Effect In mixing operations it is essential to know the time required to achieve a homogeneous mix, often referred to as degree of mixedness. Information on the rate of mixing would allow us to understand the basic mechanisms of mixing and the stability of the binder components and to select an appropriate mixing device. In the initial stages of mixing, the binder components change progressively from solid or liquid to semifluid and finally to a fluid state. Mixing mechanisms at this stage are likely to be involved with interdiffusion, mutual solubility of binder components, and binder (molten) interaction with ceramic particle surfaces. Agglomerates are formed as a result of the change in interfacial tensions between the powder particles andmelted binder components and as the entire mix slowly turns into a viscous mass. Subsequent mixing of the viscous mass is essentially dispersive or shear. Since mixing tends toward an equilibrium state, it is easy to see that its rate of attainment is likely to be of the form
where c is the rate constant and t the time, so that X approaches its limiting value asymptotically, as in Fig. 9. From Eq. a plot of -log, - x ) against time should give a straight line of slope c, and the effectiveness of dispersive mixing is indicated by the value of this constant. Although the experiment suggests a relationship of this form, nonetheless it cannot necessarily be taken as complete verification of any particular mechanism that invokes an exponential
MATSUDDY
252
t Rate of completemixing of anattainment asymptotic relation with time.
of equilibriumstateshows
function of time, because temperature and speed (rpm) [lo], as shown in Figs. 10 and 11, can also significantly influence the mechanism of mixing. It is evident from Fig. 10 that the shear mixing becomes progressively less effective as the temperature is increased and as the mix becomes less viscous. On the other hand, the low torque generated at 10 rpm shows (Fig. 11) that the shear forces are insufficient to provide uniform dispersion of the binder in the mix. Further, oxidation of binder components in air with mixing time have been recorded [11,121 from gel-permeation chromatography and infrared spectroscopy (Fig. 12). Figure 12a compares the spectra obtained with polyethylene before and after kneading. Changes in infrared spectra associated with kneaded polyethylene at 160°C for 1 h can be attributed to oxidative degradation. The degradation of polyethylene binder during kneading is further substantiated from the observed shift in the chromatographic peaks (Fig. 12b). Using process tolerance capability (defined as three times the standard deviation divided by the final product dimension L) as an indicator of mixing efficiency, Billiet [l31 showed the time dependence of the mixing operation (Fig. 13). Insufficient mixing time negatively affects the process tolerance capability. There is an optimum mixing time for which capability is greatest; that is, the tolerance that can be held confidently reaches the lowest value. Extending mixing time beyond this time period produces a negative effect on tolerance capability. It has been suggested that the time region I represents net randomizing area inwhich increased mixing time has the effect ofhomogeneizing the mixture and the region 11 is a symmetrical region in which period doubling occurs and the mixture shows areas of inhomogeneity.
C.
Role of ProcessingAids and Dispersion
Shear force alone cannot break down agglomerates. a first step, it is essential to remove the moisture from the powder before preparing a mix. Further-
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING
.i - 1
200
600
500
4001 300
I
200
-
l00
-
0 200
I
-
0 0
5
Plots of torque versus mixing time for 50 vol% A1203 and 50 vol% polyethylene mixed at different temperatures. (After Ref. 9.)
MATSUDDY
300
U
Q
500
-
4OQ-
300-
U
p
200-
-
0 - L -
I
11 Plots of torque versus mixing time for ethylene as a function of speed. (After Ref. 10.)
I
I
vol% A1203 and
l
I
vol% poly-
I
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING
255
> t-
-l
m m
a (L
---- A2-PE.60
0-
I I
I
lo3
loc
IO*
lo6
WEIGHT (b)
12 (a) Infraredspectra ofpolyethyleneillustratingtheeffectofmixing, (After Ref. 11.) (b) Molecularweightdistribution of polyethylene andalumina-polyethylene mixes. (After Ref. 11.)
MATSUDDY
Region I
Mixing Time 13 Regionof optimum mixing time. (After Ref.
more, it is often necessary to premill the powder with a processing aid that modifies the surface characteristics of the powder and breaks down the agglomerates. brief account is presented here to amplify the role of processing aid(s) in achieving an agglomerate-free homogeneous mix. In general, dispersion forces give rise to an attraction between particles in a fluid whose polarizability differs from.that of the particles. The interaction potential is inversely dependent on particle separation, and the magnitude of the interaction is described by the Hamaker [l41 constant. The well-known DLVO theory describes the stabilization of aqueous suspensions of particles on the basis of coulombic repulsions between charged particle surfaces. It is not clear to what extent charged double layers are effective in nonaqueous suspensions. is the subject another chapter in this book. An alternative approach to overcoming these forces in organic fluids is to attach or graft polymer chains to the particle surfaces such that steric hindrance, the so-called entropic repulsion, prevents the particles from approaching one another more closely than the extended length of these chains in the surrounding media. The dispersion process can be illustrated in three distinct stages. First, wetting, in which the powdedair interface is replaced by the powderlfluid interface; second, mechanical disruption, as discussed earlier, in which some of the agglomerates are broken down into smaller particles; and third, stabilization of the resulting dispersion against flocculation.
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING
257
Wetting is the displacement from a surface of one fluid by another. It therefore involves three phases, at least two of which must be fluids. Three types of wetting can be distinguished (1) spreading, (2) adhesional, and (3) immersional. For wetting, the function adhesion tension, y cos CP, is involved, where y is the surface tension of the liquid and CP is the contact angle of the liquid with the solid surface. The author used a simple method of measurement of adhesion tension of a number of processing aids in contact with powders. This was based on measurement the rate of unrestricted penetration the propowder in a small glass tube. The cessing aid into a column of A16-SG adhesion tension y cos CP is then estimated from '" -1=
t
r ycosq k2 271
where l is the distance of penetration in time t to the surface tension contact angle CP, and viscosity 71 of the advancing liquid, r is the radius of the capillaries between particles, and k is a tortuosity constant. In this equation, r/k2 is a constant depending upon the packing of the column and was eliminated by the use of a standard packing. Table 2 presents the calculated adhesion tension y cos CP for processing aids. It has been noted that the higher the measured adhesion tension, the more rapid is the rate of dispersion during the mixing operation. The technique is not suitable for use with polymers that are solid at room temperature, however, because a linear relation between the square of the distance of penetration and time is not attained. For high-melting polymers and waxes, the contact angles of polymers to ceramic substrates have been measured as a function of temperature and time using a goniometer.Figures 14 and 15 illustrate the effect of temperature on contact angle for different polymers [10,17]. Table presents some data for thermoplastic resins and waxes with alumina and silicon nitride substrates. The atactic polypropylene has given by far the best wettability of polymers and waxes. The paraffin and most of the microcrystalline waxes give low contact angles for both alumina and silicon niTable 2
CalculatedAdhesionTension for a Selected Processing Aidand A16-SG Alumina cos 0
Processing Adhesion aid tension Corn oil Camphorated cottonseed oil Peanut oil Olive oil Pine oil Olein Menhaden oil
22.0 17.3 12.4 8.5 7.6 20.7 24.8
TEMPERATURE
1
14 Contact angle of resin to alumina substrate (A) AF'P, mol(D) ecularweight; (B) M P , 6000 molecularweight;(C)low-densitypolyethylene; EVA vinylacetate);(E), (F) medium-densitypolyethylene; (G) polystyrene. (After Ref. 17.) tride, whereas the contact angles for polyethylene and polystyrene withalumina and silicon nitride are relatively high. Besides temperature, it can be assumedthatthesubstrate surface characteristics,suchas adsorbed species, porosity, cleanliness, and morphology, have a profound effect on the wetting of polymers and waxes. similar influence might be expected with fine powders. There is clearly scope for further work on the surface nature and wettability of fine powders, so that progress in the development of improved dispersability in injection molding mixes can be placed on a more rational basis. The mechanical dispersion as applied to mixing has already been discussed. The final stage of the dispersion process is that of stabilization of the dispersed particles against flocculation. It is not intended to give a detailed account of the theoretical basis of dispersion stabilization, because this is extensively covered inthe literature, at leastat lower particle concentrations in
259
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY AND MIXING 60
Polyethylene/Alp03 50
40
30
20
10
0 0 20
10
40
70
60
TIME (mln)
15 Contact angle as a function of time for polyethylene on alumina substrate at different temperatures. (After Ref. IO.)
low-viscosity liquids (e.g., water or solvents). Very little information is available on dispersion stability suspensions with particle concentrations above 50 ~01%.An unstabilized dispersion flocculates by collision the primary particles and thereby reduces the number of particles P in the system: dP = 81tDRp’ -dt
where R is the collision radius the particles, D is the diffusion coefficient, and t is the time. D can be expressed
for particles radius in a fluid of viscosity 1 1 ,where k is the Boltzmann constant and T is the absolute temperature. It has been shown [l81 that the time required to reduce the number particles to half the initial value is given by the equation 412
=-
4KTP0
MATSUDDY Table
Wetting Angles
Thermoplastic Resins and Waxes with Ceramic
Substrates Contact angle 0, (“1 Thermoplastics and waxes
Si3N4
Temperature (“C)
Polyethylene NA-250 Polystyrene D-210 Atactic polypropylene Waxes Paraffin Shell 120 Microcrystalline 18654 Microcrystalline Shell 400 Microcrystalline C1035 Microcrystalline Mobil
200 200 160
-33 -40 -8
160 160 160 160 160
-15 -14 -30 -20 -20
-36
-
<5 <5 <5 <5
At higher particle concentrations vol%), tln decreases rapidly. Thus, the fluids become unstable at higher particle concentrations, and some force of energy barrier is needed avoid flocculation by collision of primary particles.
of Mixedness
D.Degree
Besides deagglomeration, it is also essential to assess the extent of homogeneity, that is, the degree of mixedness. Because of the random nature of the mixing process, statistical analysis is most frequently used. This concerns primarily measurement of the standard deviation or the variance of the spot samples taken from a mixture. The criteria are then expressed in different forms of the standard deviation of the variance. far, the statistical analysis of mixedness in injection molding mixes has not been fully developed. However, Billiet [l31 made a significant observation while he was trying to determine the maximum mixing error Em, that is, the error in injection molding mixes that would result in the loss of the targeted process tolerance capability T, and showed the need for extreme care in weighing and handling at the mix preparation stage. He used the following expression to relate maximum mixing E@ and process tolerance capability T: 3T
IEd= G where is the volumetric powder loading. Measurement of mixedness is often subject to appreciable experimental and sampling error. Therefore, experimental verification of the validity of the theoretical criteria for the degree of mixedness of a mix is not always satisfactory.
PLASTIC MOLDING RHEOLOGY
261
AND MlXING
Simulation of a mixing process by using a computer provides a better alternative. Monte Carlo simulation techniques are often utilized. Monte Carlo techniques are numerical methods that involve sampling from statistical distributions, either theoretical or empirical, to approximate the real physical phenomena without reference to the actual physical systems. For the general discussion of Monte Carlo methods, readers are referred to Hammersley and Handscomb [l91 and Tocher [20].
E. Other Factors The rate of mixing and the degree of mixedness are functions of many variables relating to characteristics of the powder, mixing equipment, and operating conditions. Some aspects of powder characteristics were discussed earlier in the light of rheology. The author has also published [21] some information on mixing equipment. Readers are well advised to refer to these publications. Again, there is no systematic analysis of the operating conditions for preparing injection molding mixes. On a broader basis, careful attention must be given during the mixing operation to a number of factors, such as weighing of each constituent added, the ratio of volume of the mix to that of the mixer,