RE-ENGINEERING THE CHEMICflL PROCESSING PMNT Process Intensification edited by
flndrzej ftankiewicz DSM Research Geleen...
332 downloads
1886 Views
9MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
RE-ENGINEERING THE CHEMICflL PROCESSING PMNT Process Intensification edited by
flndrzej ftankiewicz DSM Research Geleen, and Delft University of Technology Delft, The Netherlands
Jacob fl.Moulijn Delft University of Technology Delft, The Netherlands
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Although great care has been taken to provide accurate and current information, neither the author(s) nor the publisher, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage, or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. The material contained herein is not intended to provide specific advice or recommendations for any specific situation. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. ISBN: 0-8247-4302-4 This book is printed on acid-free paper. Headquarters Marcel Dekker, Inc., 270 Madison Avenue, New York, NY 10016, U.S.A. tel: 212-696-9000; fax: 212-685-4540 Distribution and Customer Service Marcel Dekker, Inc., Cimarron Road, Monticello, New York 12701, U.S.A. tel: 800-228-1160; fax: 845-796-1772 Eastern Hemisphere Distribution Marcel Dekker AG, Hutgasse 4, Postfach 812, CH-4001 Basel, Switzerland tel: 41-61-260-6300; fax: 41-61-260-6333 World Wide Web http://www.dekker.com The publisher offers discounts on this book when ordered in bulk quantities. For more information, write to Special Sales/Professional Marketing at the headquarters address above. Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. Current printing (last digit): 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
CHEMICAL INDUSTRIES A Series of Reference Books and Textbooks Founding Editor HEINZ HEINEMANN
1. Fluid Catalytic Cracking with Zeolite Catalysts, Paul B. Veriuto and E. Thomas Habib, Jr. 2. Ethylene: Keystone to the Petrochemical Industry, Ludwig Kniel, Olaf Winter, and Karl Stork 3. The Chemistry and Technology of Petroleum, James G. Speight 4. The Desulfurization of Heavy Oils and Residua, James G. Speight 5. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by William R. Moser 6. Acetylene-Based Chemicals from Coal and Other Natural Resources, Robert J. Tedeschi 7. Chemically Resistant Masonry, Walter Lee Sheppard, Jr. 8. Compressors and Expanders: Selection and Application for the Process Industry, Heinz P. Bloch, Joseph A. Cameron, Frank M. Danowski, Jr., Ralph James, Jr., Judson S. Swearingen, and Marilyn E. Weightman 9. Metering Pumps: Selection and Application, James P. Poyntori 10. Hydrocarbons from Methanol, Clarence D. Chang 11. Form Flotation: Theory and Applications, Ann N. Clarke arid David J. Wilson 12. The Chemistry and Technology of Coal, James G. Speight 13. Pneumatic and Hydraulic Conveying of Solids, 0.A. Williams 14. Catalyst Manufacture: Laboratory and Commercial Preparations, Alvin B. Stiles 15. Characterization of Heterogeneous Catalysts, edited by Francis Delannay 16. BASIC Programs for Chemical Engineering Design, James H. Weber 17. Catalyst Poisoning, L. Louis Hegedus and Robert W. McCabe 18. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by John R. Kosak 19. Adsorption Technology: A Step-by-step Approach to Process Evaluation and Application, edited by Frank L. Slejko 20. Deactivation and Poisoning of Catalysts, edited by Jacques Oudar and Henry Wise 21. Catalysis and Surface Science: Developments in Chemicals ,torn Methanol, Hydrotreating of Hydrocaribons, Catalyst Preparation, Monlomers and Polymers, Photocafalysis and Photovoltaics, edited by Heinz t-ieinemann and Gabor A. Somorjai 22. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by Robert L. Augustine
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
23. Modern Control Techniques for the Processing Industries, T. H. Tsai, J. W. Lane, and C. S. Lin 24. Temperature-Programmed Reduction for Solid Materials Characterization, Alan Jones and Brian McNichol 25. Catalytic Cracking: Catalysts, Chemistry, and Kinetics, Bohdan W. Wojciechowski and Avelino Corma 26. Chemical Reaction and Reactor Engineering, edited by J. J. Carberry and A. Varma 27. Filtration: Principles and Practices, Second Edition, edited by Michael J. Matteson and Clyde Orr 28. Corrosion Mechanisms, edited by Florian Mansfeld 29. Catalysis and Surface Properties of Liquid Metals and Alloys, Yoshisada Ogino 30. Catalyst Deactivation, edited by Eugene E. Petersen and Alexis T. Bell 3 1. Hydrogen Effects in Catalysis: Fundamentals and Practical Applications, edited by Zoltan Paal and P. G. Menon 32. Flow Management for Engineers and Scientists, Nicholas P. Cheremisinoff and Paul N. Cheremisinoff 33. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by Paul N. Rylander, Harold Greenfield, and Robert L. Augustine 34. Powder and Bulk Solids Handling Processes: Instrumentation and Control, Koichi linoya, Hiroaki Masuda, and Kinnosuke Watanabe 35. Reverse Osmosis Technology: Applications for High-Purity-Water Production, edited by Bipin S. Parekh 36. Shape Selective Catalysis in lndustrial Applications, N. Y. Chen, William E. Garwood, and Frank G. Dwyer 37. Alpha Olefins Applications Handbook, edited by George R. Lappin and Joseph L. Sauer 38. Process Modeling and Control in Chemical Industries, edited by Kaddour Najim 39. Clathrate Hydrates of Natural Gases, E. Dendy Sloan, Jr. 40. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by Dale W. Blackburn 41. Fuel Science and Technology Handbook, edited by James G. Speight 42. Octane-Enhancing Zeolitic FCC Catalysts, Julius Schetzer 43. Oxygen in Catalysis, Adam Bielanski and Jerzy Haber 44. The Chemistry and Technology of Petroleum: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, James G. Speight 45. Industrial Drying Equipment: Selection and Application, C. M. van't Land 46. Novel Production Methods for Ethylene, Light Hydrocarbons, and Aromatics, edited by Lyle F. Albright, Billy L. Crynes, and Siegfried Nowak 47. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by William E. Pascoe 48. Synthetic Lubricants and High-Performance Functional Fluids, edited by Ronald L. Shubkin 49. Acetic Acid and Its Derivatives, edited by Victor H. Agreda and Joseph R. ZoelI er 50. Properties and Applications of Perovskite-Type Oxides, edited by L. G. Tejuca and J. L. G. Fierro
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
51. Computer-Aided Design of Catalysts, edited by E. Robert Becker and Carmo J. Pereira 52. Models for Thermodynamic and Phase Equilibria Calculations, edited by Stanley I. Sandler 53. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by John R. Kosak and Thomas A. Johnson 54. Composition and Analysis of Heavy Petroleum fractions, Klaus H. Altgelt and Mieczyslaw M. Boduszynski 55. NMR Techniques in Catalysis, edited by Alexis T. Bell and Alexander Pines 56. Upgrading Petroleum Residues and Heavy Oils, Murray R. Gray 57. Methanol Production and Use, edited by Wu-Hsun Cheng and Harold H. Kung 58. Catalytic Hydroprocessing of Petroleum and Distillates, edited by Michael C. Oballah and Stuart S. Shih 59. The Chemistry and Technology of Coal: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, James G. Speight 60. Lubricant Base Oil and Wax Processing, Avilino Sequeira, Jr. 61. Catalytic Naphtha Reforming: Science and Technology, edited by George J. Antos, Abdullah M. Aitani, and Jose M. Parera 62. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by Mike G. Scaros and Michael L. Prunier 63. Catalyst Manufacture, Alvin B. Stiles and Theodore A. Koch 64. Handbook of Grignard Reagents, edited by Gary S. Silverman and Philip E. Rakita 65. Shape Selective Catalysis in lndustrial Applications: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, N. Y. Chen, William E. Garwood, and Francis G. Dwyer 66. Hydrocracking Science and Technology, Julius Scherrer and A. J. Gruia 67. Hydrotreating Technology for Pollution Control: Catalysts, Catalysis, and Processes, edited by Mario L. Occelli and Russell Chianelli 68. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by Russell E. Malz, Jr. 69. Synthesis of Porous Materials: Zeolites, Clays, and Nanostructures, edited by Mario L. Occelli and Henri Kessler 70. Methane and Its Derivatives, Sunggyu Lee 71. Structured Catalysts and Reactors, edited by Andrzei Cybulski and Jacob Moulijn 72. lndustrial Gases in Petrochemical Processing, Harold Gunardson 73. Clathrate Hydrates of Natural Gases: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, E. Dendy Sloan, Jr. 74, fluid Cracking Catalysts, edited by Mario L. Occelli and Paul O’Connor 75 Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by Frank E. Herkes 76, The Chemistry and Technology of Petroleum, Third Edition, Revised and Expanded, James G. Speight 77. Synthetic Lubricants and High-P erformance functional Fluids, Second Edition: Revised and Expanded, Leslie R. Rudnick and Ronald L. Shubkin I
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
78. The Desulfurization of Heavy Oils and Residua, Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, James G. Speight 79. Reaction Kinetics and Reactor Design: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, John B. Butt 80. Regulatory Chemicals Handbook, Jennifer M. Spero, Bella Devito, and Louis Theodore 8 1. Applied Parameter Esfimation for Chemical Engineers, Peter Englezos and Nicolas Kalogerakis 82. Catalysis of Organic Reacfions, edited by Michael E. Ford 83. The Chemical Process Industries Infrastructure: Function and Economics, James R. Couper, 0. Thomas Beasley, and W. Roy Penney 84. Transport Phenomena Fundamentals, Joel L. Plawsky 85. Petroleum Refining Processes, James G. Speight and Baki Ozum 86. Health, Safety, and Accident Management in the Chemical Process Industries, Ann Marie Flynn and Louis Theodore 87. Plantwide Dynamic Simulators in Chemical Processing and Clonfrol, William L. Luyben 88. Chemicial Reactor Design, Peter Harriott 89. Catalysis of Organic Reactions, edited by Dennis Morrell 90. Lubricant Additives: Chemistry and Applications, edited by Leslie R. Rudnick 91. Handbook of Fluidization and Fluid-Particle Systems, edited by Wenching Yang 92. Conservation Equations and Modeling of Chemical and Biochemical Processes, Said S. E. H. Elnashaie and Parag Garhyan 93. Batch Fermentation: Modeling, Monitoring, and Control, Ali Cinar, Satish J. Parulekar, Cenk Undey, and Gulnur Birol 94. lndustrial Solvents Handbook: Second Edition, Nicholas P. Cheremisinoff 95. Petroleum and Gas Field Processing, H. K. Abdel-Aal, Mohamed Aggour, and M. A. Fahim 96. Chemical Process Engineering: Design and Economics, Harry Sit la 97. Process Engineering Economics, James R. Couper 98. Re-Engineering the Chemical Processing Plant: Process lntensification, Andrzej Stankiewicz and Jacob A. Moulijn 99. Thermodynamic Cycles: Computer-Aided Design and Optimization, Chih Wu ADDITIONAL VOLUMES IN PREPARATION
Handbook of Methyl Tertiary Butyl Ether, edited by S. Halim Harriid and Mohammad Ashraf Ali Catalytic Naphtha Reforming, Second Edition, Revised and Expanded, edited by George J. Antos and Abdullah M. Aitani
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Preface
The book you are about to read will introduce you to modern ways of reengineering the chemical processing plant by means of Process Intensification (PI). The story behind this book had begun with the paper Process Intensification: Transforming Chemical Engineering, which we published in the millennium issue of Chemical Engineering Progress (January 2000). After a pretty enthusiastic response to our paper by the chemical engineering community, Marcel Dekker proposed to us writing a book on that subject. After some discussions we came to the conclusion that it was not a good idea to write the entire book ourselves because, as you will see next, Process Intensification is a very broad discipline and includes many diverse expertise fields. So, instead of writing all chapters on our own, we have invited a number of prominent experts in various areas of Process Intensification, both from industry and from academia, to contribute to what now has become the world’s first book on that subject. The principal aim of this highly practice-oriented book is to illustrate the current developments and the frontline research in the area of Process Intensification. The book is primarily intended for engineers, technologists and researchers in chemical, biochemical and engineering companies, who are involved in process design and development and are interested in learning more about equipment and techniques that may bring quantum-leap improvements to their technologies. Also for others working in the forefront of process design and
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
development it is intended to be inspiring, in particular for the chemical engineering community in the universities and the National Laboratories. We hope that it will contribute to a better image of the chemical industry and even play a role in attracting more high-quality, motivated students to the discipline. The book may also be beneficial to R&D managerial personnel who wish to have a broader understanding of the principles and methodology of Process Intensification and gain the up-to-date knowledge of the emerging novel equipment and processing methods that could help to achieve technological breakthroughs in the processes at their companies. The book has a certain logical structure that can be inferred from scanning the individual chapter headings. Chapter 1 introduces the reader into the genesis, philosophy and principles of Process Intensification and discusses its dimension and structure. It provides general information on process-intensifying equipment and methods and gives some examples of their application on the commercial scale. The three subsequent chapters describe selected types of the PI-equipment. Most of that equipment have already been successfully implemented on the commercial scale or is ready for implementation. Chapters 2 and 3 are devoted to the rotating equipment, rotating packed beds and spinning disk reactors, in which the use of high gravity fields leads to spectacular miniaturization of the processing units. Chapter 4 in turn describes the technology, design and application of compact and multifunctional heat exchangers. The next three chapters show how bringing certain structures in various scales of chemical processing environment can boost process efficiency, by dramatically improving mixing, heat and mass transfer. Various types and scales of such structuring are presented: microreactors in Chapter 5, large-scale structured catalysts and reactors in Chapter 6 and inline mixing equipment in Chapter 7. Following that “hardware” part of the book, its next four chapters focus on some important methods that can be used for intensification of chemical processes. Chapter 8 presents the application aspects of functional integration of reaction and separation into reactive separation systems, or integration of different separative techniques into hybrid separations. In Chapter 9 the modeling issues of the reactive separation systems are discussed. Chapter 10 discusses some aspects of the integration of reaction and heat transfer in multifunctional reactors, while Chapter 11 focuses on the application of process synthesis principles to the optimal design of integrated chemical processing plants. The final three chapters of the book address more general issues of Process Intensification. Chapter 12, based on the experiences within DSM, shows how the PI-principles can be applied in the industrial environment for redesigning and development of process-intensive chemical plants, while Chapters 13 and 14 focus respectively on safety and sustainability aspects of PI. The chemical industry skyline in the 21st Century is changing. New highly efficient devices have already begun replacing the tens-of-meters high reactors and separation columns. In the still denser populated world inhabited by the still more
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
educated and environment-conscious society, there will be no room (literally and figuratively) for the huge, inefficient chemical factories of today, generating tens of tons of waste per each ton of the useful product. As a part of the society-driven changes miniaturization and, in general, intensification of chemical and biochemical plants, will become inevitable. We are well aware that the present book does not cover all developments in the field of Process Intensification. It has not had such ambitions. With this collection of contributions by the leading experts in the field, we have tried to focus on the main developments and main issues only, hoping that they will give the reader sufficient flavor of PI and will encourage him/her to further studies on how to re-engineer a chemical processing plant basing on the “smaller-cheaper-saferslicker” principles of Process Intensification. Both contributors and editors will be very glad to hear from the reader if we indeed have succeeded. Also suggestions for a possible next edition are welcome! Andrzej Stankiewicz Jacob A. Moulijn
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Contents
Preface Contributors 1. Process Intensification: History, Philosophy, Principles Andrzej Stankiewicz and A. A. H. Drinkenburg 2. Chemical Processing in High-Gravity Fields David L. Trent 3. The Spinning Disc Reactor C. Ramshaw 4. Compact Multifunctional Heat Exchangers: A Pathway to Process Intensification B. Thonon and P. Tochon 5. Process Intensification Through Microreaction Technology Wolfgang Ehrfeld 6. Structured Catalysts and Reactors: A Contribution to Process Intensification Jacob A. Moulijn, Freek Kapteijn, and Andrzej Stankiewicz
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
7. Inline and High-Intensity Mixers Andrew Green 8. Reactive and Hybrid Separations: Incentives, Applications, Barriers Andrzej Stankiewicz 9. Reactive Separations in Fluid Systems E. Y. Kenig, A. Górak, and H.-J. Bart 10. Multifunctional Reactors: Integration of Reaction and Heat Transfer David W. Agar 11. Process Synthesis/Integration Patrick Linke, Antonis Kokossis, and Henk van den Berg 12. Process Intensification in Industrial Practice: Methodology and Application Remko A. Bakker 13. Process Intensification for Safety Dennis C. Hendershot 14. Process Intensification Contributions to Sustainable Development G. Jan Harmsen, Gijsbert Korevaar, and Saul M. Lemkowitz
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Contributors
David W. Agar Lehrstuhl für Technische Chemie B, University of Dortmund, Dortmund, Germany Remko A. Bakker DSM Fine Chemicals Austria, Linz, Austria H.-J. Bart Institute of Thermal Process Engineering, University of Kaiserslautern, Kaiserslautern, Germany A. A. H. Drinkenberg DSM Research, Geleen, The Netherlands Wolfgang Erhfeld Ehrfeld Mikrotechnik AG, Wendelsheim, Germany A. Górak Lehrstuhl für Thermische Verfahrenstechnik, University of Dortmund, Germany Andrew Green BHR Group Limited, Cranfield, England G. Jan Harmsen Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands Dennis C. Hendershot Rohm and Haas Company, Bristol, Pennsylvania, U.S.A.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Freek Kapteijn Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands E. Y. Kenig Lehrstuhl für Thermische Verfahrenstechnik, University of Dortmund, Dortmund, Germany Antonis Kokossis University of Surrey, Surrey, England Gijsbert Korevaar Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands Saul M. Lemkowitz Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands Patrick Linke University of Surrey, Surrey, England Jacob A. Moulijn Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands C. Ramshaw Department of Chemical and Process Engineering, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne, England Andrzej Stankiewicz DSM Research, Geleen, and Delft University of Technology, Delft, The Netherlands B. Thonon P. Tochon
Greth, CEA–Grenoble, Grenoble, France Greth, CEA–Grenoble, Grenoble, France
David L. Trent
The Dow Chemical Company, Freeport, Texas, U.S.A.
Henk van den Berg Faculty of Chemical Technology, University of Twente, Enschede, The Netherlands, and Ghent University, Ghent, Belgium
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
1 Process Intensification: History, Philosophy, Principles Andrzej Stankiewicz and A. A. H. Drinkenburg DSM Research, Geleen, The Netherlands
1.
INTRODUCTION
Process intensification (PI) is currently one of the most significant trends in chemical engineering and process technology. It is attracting more and more of the attention of the research world. Four international conferences, several smaller symposia/workshops every year, and a number of dedicated issues of professional journals are clear proof of it. A number of commercial-scale applications of the PI principles have already taken place. But how did it all begin? 2.
A BIT OF HISTORY
According to Miriam-Webster’s Collegiate Dictionary, the word intensive has probably its origins somewhere in 15th century. And it was not many years later, right at the peak of the Renaissance, when Georgius Agricola published his famous book De Re Metallica (1), the book that is commonly regarded as the first comprehensive textbook on the engineering of mining and metallurgy. De Re Metallica is richly illustrated with woodcuts showing equipment and processing methods used in the times of Agricola. In many of those woodcuts clear elements of process intensification–oriented thinking can be found. One example is shown in Figure 1,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 1 Sixteenth century technology of gold retrieval from gold ore. (From Ref. 1.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
which illustrates the process of retrieving gold from gold ore. The technology is pretty simple. The ore is crushed by the stamp, “C,” ground in the mill, “F,” and mixed with mercury in vessels “O.” Gold is extracted from the ore by mercury and is later separated from it by pressing the mixture through a leather or cloth filter bag (not shown in the drawing). Taking a closer look at the woodcut, one notices that the stamp, the mill and the stirrers for mixing the ore with mercury are all driven by the same water wheel, “A,” via the common axle, “B,” and a number of various gears. Speaking the language of the 21st century, one could say, “A marvelous example of a green, energy-based, highly integrated processing plant!” (One dare not, however, call it a sustainable technology. Not only are the gold reserves unsustainable, but the operations involving mercury are not environmentally friendly, as we all know today.) Yet there is another aspect to Agricola’s woodcut. As one may have noticed, some of the equipment shown (“O”–“S”) exhibits a striking resemblance to the equipment used in the chemical process industry almost 450 years later (see Figure 2). Were the contemporaries of Agricola so ingenious, or are we merely satisfied with the inventions of past centuries? At the dawn of the third millennium, in-series stirred tanks still remain the most common chemical processing system. An attempt to break this domination of the stirred-tank technology by the invention and introduction of the static mixer (2,3), is one of the finest and earliest modern examples of process intensification. Here, the technological leap was achieved not by the improvement of the stirring itself but, quite the opposite, by abandoning the mechanical stirring as a method of mixing fluids! This reveals one of the most important features of PI—the changes it brings are drastic in nature, revolutionary rather than evolutionary. In the scientific literature, the term process intensification started to appear in the mid-1960s and early ’70s, mostly in East European publications concerning
FIGURE 2 Four and half centuries have passed, yet almost no fundamental differences can be seen between the technology of 1556 and that of 2002.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
metallurgical processing (4 –7) (an interesting coincidence, considering that Agricola’s book was also on metallurgy, not on chemical processing). Of course, all of those papers understood process intensification as simply equivalent to process improvement. Also, in the first chemical industry–oriented articles (all of East European origin, by the way), the term process intensification had that same meaning (8–10). The birth of process intensification as a chemical engineering discipline came several years later in the United Kingdom and was marked by the paper published in 1983 by Colin Ramshaw from the ICI New Science Group, who described their studies on the application of centrifugal fields (so-called “HiGee”) in distillation processes (11). A few months later the Annual Research Meeting, entitled Process Intensification, was held at UMIST, Manchester (12). Interestingly, the first paper presented at that meeting concerned processing of gold ore using intensive methods—a strange coincidence, indeed. Both in the paper by Ramshaw and in the report from the UMIST conference, first definitions (or rather descriptions) of process intensification can be found. Ramshaw (11) describes PI as “devising an exceedingly compact plant which reduces both the ‘main plant item’ and the installation’s costs,” while according to Heggs (12) PI is concerned with order-of-magnitude reductions in process plant and equipment. In one of his subsequent papers, Ramshaw writes about typical equipment volume reduction by two or three orders of magnitude (13). Until the early 1990s, process intensification was mainly a British discipline and was focused primarily on four areas: the use of centrifugal forces, compact heat transfer, intensive mixing, and combined technologies (14). It was also the Brits who organized the first international conference on PI (15). By that time, however, process intensification had already become an international business, for many research centers in different countries had entered the field. In Holland, for instance, Delft University of Technology, together with DSM, carried out research on structured reactors (16). Another group in Delft investigated centrifugal adsorption technology (17). In France, Greth CEN institute in Grenoble carried out extensive studies on compact heat exchange equipment (18). In Germany, research on microtechnology flourished in the Institut für Mikrotechnik Mainz (19), while in China a special center at Beijing University was established to carry out R&D activities in the area of high-gravity processing (20). In the United States a number of research institutes started PI-related studies too, e.g., Pacific Northwest National Laboratory in the field of microchannel heat exchangers (21) and MIT in the field of microreactors (22). Also early on, a number of chemical companies got involved in process intensification. This involvement resulted in the first successful commercial-scale applications, such as the methyl acetate process of Eastman Chemical (23), the hydrogen peroxide distillation system of Sulzer (24), and the hypochlorous acid process of Dow Chemical (25).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The end of the 20th century and the beginning of the 21st have seen a fast growth in PI-related activities in both industry and academia. In the UK the Process Intensification Network was launched, gathering a large number of industrial and academic participants; a similar network has been established in the Netherlands. Four international conferences and several smaller symposia on PI have been organized so far. Process Intensification, traditionally tied up with the commodity chemicals sector, has begun entering new areas, such as bioprocessing and fermentation (26–28) and, quite recently, fine chemistry (29). The definition of process intensification has changed accordingly. It is no longer exclusively regarded as drastically smaller equipment/plants (although equipment compactness remains its most obvious feature). Process intensification, as it is widely understood nowadays, comprises novel equipment, processing techniques, and process development methods that, compared to conventional ones, offer substantial improvements in (bio)chemical manufacturing and processing (30). The question may arise why it took so long for PI to come into the picture. One possible answer is the enormous expansion of the process industry in the third quarter of the 20th century, expansion in market size but certainly also in plant scale. There were very few incentives at that time for the very risky introduction of new technologies. In the fourth quarter of the century, much effort was spent on modeling, optimization, and control, resulting, among other things, in the well-known onionskin methodologies of process development (e.g., Ref. 31). Although very worthwhile at the time, these sequential, onionskin methodologies (first the reactor, then separation/purification, then heat integration, then process control, safety, etc.) hindered the thinking in terms of integrated equipment. More incentives were found in environmental engineering, also a topic of the second half of the 20th century, that developed from the end-of-pipe solutions to problems to the integrated process solutions backsourcing the problems. 3. THE PHILOSOPHY AND OPPORTUNITIES OF PROCESS INTENSIFICATION The philosophy of process intensification has been traditionally characterized by four words: smaller, cheaper, safer, slicker. And indeed, equipment size, land use costs, and process safety are among the most important PI incentives. But process intensification can (and should) also be placed in a broader context—the context of sustainable technological development. Several years ago DSM published a picture symbolizing its own vision of process intensification (32), in which skyscraping distillation towers of the naphtha-cracking unit are replaced by a compact, clean, and tidy indoor plant (see Figure 3). The importance of PI for sustainable development and its role in the company’s responsible business has been further stressed in a recent publication by the company’s CEO, Peter Elverding (33). Here,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 3 DSM’s vision of process intensification.
process intensification was the highest-rated activity of DSM within the known “Triple-P” (profit–planet–people) triangle, as shown in Table 1. From this general philosophy of process intensification follow concrete opportunities that PI offers to chemical enterprises, as shown in Figure 4. These opportunities exist primarily in four areas: costs, safety, time to market, and company image. TABLE 1 Process Intensification in the Profit–Planet–People Triangle of DSM Triple P
Process intensification Green routes Recycling Energy efficiency
Profit
Planet
People
•• • • •
••• ••• ••• •••
•• •• •• •
Source: Ref. 32.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 4 Main benefits from process intensification.
3.1.
Costs
Process intensification leads to substantially cheaper processes, particularly in terms of: Land costs, resulting from much higher production capacity and/or number of products per unit of manufacturing area Other investment costs, resulting from cheaper, compact equipment, reduced piping, reduced civic works, integrated processing units, etc. Costs of raw materials, due to higher yields/selectivities Costs of utilities, in particular costs of energy, due to higher energy efficiency Costs of waste processing (less waste generated in process-intensive plants) Figure 5 shows the estimated savings in some DSM technologies, after applying the PI principles (grass-roots situation). 3.2.
Safety
Process intensification drastically increases the safety of chemical processes. It is obvious that smaller is safer. In Table 2 some of the more severe chemical disasters of the past century are listed. The table shows clearly how disastrous consequences may arise from the large inventories when something goes wrong. And of course, one may not claim that process intensification would have prevented all those tragedies. Yet a study done at AIChE showed that methyl isocyanate (MIC),
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 5 Estimated savings in some DSM technologies, achieved by applying PI principles to process and plant design (grass-roots situation).
the poisonous intermediate that was released at Bhopal, could be generated and immediately converted to final products in continuous reactors that contained a total inventory of less than 10 kg of MIC (34)! But process intensification offers not only smaller equipment but also much better possibilities for keeping processes under control, for instance, via extremely efficient heat removal from exothermic reactions (one speaks about heat transfer coefficients exceeding 20,000 W/m2K) or via fully controlled gas–liquid flow in structured catalysts that prevents liquid maldistribution and hot-spot formation. Furthermore, intensification of the processing plant often leads to elimination of one or more of its components, which also has a direct advantageous effect on process safety (“What you do not have cannot leak”). 3.3.
Time to Market
Process intensification also offers substantial improvements to those sectors of the chemical industry in which time to market plays a crucial role, e.g., the fine chemical and pharmaceutical sectors. Ramshaw (35) discussed how process intensification could shorten the time to market in case of a low-tonnage pharmaceutical process. The idea consists in developing a continuous lab-scale process and using it directly as the commercial-scale process. One must not forget that liquid flow of only 1 milliliter per second means, in continuous operation, circa 30 tons per year, which is quite a reasonable capacity for many pharmaceuticals.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
TABLE 2 Some 20th Century Disasters in the Chemical Industry Place
Date
Chemicals
Estimated amount
Casualties
4,500 tons exploded
ca. 600 dead, 1500 injured 28 dead, 89 injured
Oppau/ Ludwigshafen Flixborough
September 21, 1921 June 1, 1974
Ammonium sulfate, ammonium nitrate Cyclohexane
Beek
Propylene (mainly)
Seveso
November 7, 1975 July 10, 1976
2,4,5 Trichlorophenol, dioxin
400-ton inventory, 40-ton escaped 10,000-m3 inventory, 5.5 tons escaped 7-ton inventory, 3 tons escaped
San Juan, Mexico City
November 19, 1984
LPG
10,000-m3 inventory
Bhopal
December 3, 1984 October 23, 1989
Methyl isocyanate
41 tons released
Ethylene, isobutane, hexene, hydrogen
33 tons escaped
Pasadena
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
14 dead, 107 injured No direct casualties, ca. 37,000 people exposed ca. 500 dead, 7000 injured (mainly outside the plant) ca. 3,800 dead, 2720 permanently disabled 23 dead, 130–300 injured
The advantages of such an approach over the conventional one, based on the scale-up philosophy of “stirred tank → bigger stirred tank → even bigger stirred tank, always batch” are twofold: Process development takes place only once, with no scale-up via a pilot plant to the industrial scale. The scale-up of a batch process in stirred tanks is not straightforward, especially in the case of reactions with a large heat effect or a strong viscosity effect, and therefore can be troublesome and time-consuming. All the administrative (FDA) procedures involved in the legal approval of the production technology of the drug take place only once: The labscale technology is the commercial-scale technology. In consequence, the start of commercial production can be greatly speeded up, in some cases even by several years. Time to market will be shortened and the patent lifetime of the drug will be much more effectively utilized (read: utilized longer). 3.4.
Company Image
More and more chemical companies do recognize the fact that their image, their reputation, plays a very important role in successful business. A proper image of the company is necessary to ensure public support for its activities. A study done in the United States showed that only the tobacco industry and the nuclear energy sector had a worse reputation than the chemical industry. The situation in Europe is probably not very much different. On the other hand, process intensification, deeply anchored in the philosophy of sustainable development, in safe and environmentally friendly processing, presents perhaps the simplest, the most obvious key to the improved image of the chemical industry. 4. TECHNOLOGICAL BREAKTHROUGHS AND CREATION OF SHAREHOLDER VALUE In the reality of the global markets of the 21st century, not only do chemical companies compete with each other, they also have to compete with other sectors of the economy by proving to their shareholders that the revenues they receive from the chemical business are as good as or better than from other fast-growing sectors, such as software and servicing. But the chemical process industry struggles to create value for its shareholders. As John Goldhill of Arthur D. Little Inc. wrote, the “chemical industry has lagged other industries in creating value for shareholders for at least the past 10 years” (36). And indeed, when looking at stock index developments in various types of enterprises in the period 1997–2002 (Figure 6), one notices that the value of chemical shares grew substantially slower than in other sectors. The strategy of growth in the chemical process industry at
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 6 History of the Standard & Poor stock index in the chemical sector and other selected sectors of the economy, 1997–2002. (From: www. bloomberg.com.)
the present time is based mainly on mergers, splits, takeovers, and modifying the structure of the product portfolio. It is basically a strategy of growth via trade, not via technological innovation. In most chemical companies nowadays, opportunities are sought in cost reductions via optimization of the primary business work processes (e.g., “operational excellence”) and via opening up bottle necks in the existing production facilities. Unfortunately, neither of these activities can make a company very attractive to shareholders. In the optimization of work processes, a critical limit in cost reductions will soon be reached, and competitors will also follow more or less the same path, so the company’s competitive advantage will only be temporary unless a shakeout takes place. Opening up bottlenecks, squeezing out yet another few percent from existing plants, is also not the way to convince investors that the company is capable of delivering an adequate growth in earnings. One of the most obvious solutions to that problem lies in innovations and technological breakthroughs, because only innovations and technological breakthroughs can ensure a sustainable technological advantage, cost leadership, and growth potential. Innovations and technological breakthroughs are what process intensification is all about.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
5.
PROCESS INTENSIFICATION TOOLBOX
The toolbox for process intensification is schematically shown in Figure 7. It includes process-intensifying equipment (PI hardware) and process-intensifying methods (PI software). Obviously, in many cases overlap between these two domains can be observed as new methods may require novel types of equipment to be developed and, vice versa, novel apparatuses already developed sometimes make use of new, unconventional processing methods. In Figure 7, examples of both PI hardware and PI software are shown. Many of them will be discussed in detail in other chapters of this book. Here, we give only a brief overview of the more important PI items. 5.1.
Process-Intensifying Equipment
As already mentioned, one classic example of technological breakthroughs in process engineering was the invention and commercialization of static (motionless) mixers, examples of which are shown in Figure 8. Nowadays, static mixers not only offer a more size- and energy-efficient method for mixing or contacting fluids. In the SMR static mixer reactor by Sulzer, mixing elements are made of
FIGURE 7 Process intensification toolbox.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 8 Various types of static mixers. (Courtesy: Koch-Glitsch.)
heat transfer tubes (Figure 9). Thanks to that, the SMR units can successfully be applied in processes in which simultaneous mixing and intensive heat removal/ supply are necessary, e.g., in nitration, neutralization, and polymerization reactions. For the cases when efficient mixing has to be coupled with a solid-catalyzed reaction a whole family of open-crossflow-structure catalysts has been developed. The best known of them are the so-called KATAPAK®s, commercialized by Sulzer. One of them, KATAPAK-M® is shown in Figure 10. It has good mixing properties and can simultaneously be used as the support for catalytic material.
FIGURE 9 Static mixer reactor developed by Sulzer. (Courtesy: Sulzer Chemtech.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 10 Sulzer’s KATAPAK-M®. (Courtesy: Sulzer Chemtech.)
KATAPAK®s are applied in catalytic distillation and in some gas-phase exothermic oxidation processes traditionally carried out in fixed beds. In these processes KATAPAK®s exhibit very good radial heat transfer characteristics (37). In nonreactive distillation processes structured packings are also widely used. One of the most recent and most promising types is the Super X-Pack developed by Nagaoka International Corporation, shown in Figure 11. This wire-based packing is claimed to be able to reduce the height of a distillation column by a factor of 5 compared to a conventional tray design, as shown in Figure 12 (38).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Also, the Super X-Pack can save up to 80% energy due to a substantially lower pressure drop. Heterogeneous catalytic processes can often be intensified by the use of monolithic catalysts (39). These are metallic or nonmetallic bodies forming a multitude of straight, narrow channels of defined uniform cross-sectional shapes (Figure 13). In order to ensure sufficient porosity and to enhance the catalytically active surface, the inner walls of the monolith channels are usually covered with a thin layer of washcoat, which acts as the support for the catalytically active species. The most important features of the monoliths are: Very low pressure drop in single- and two-phase flow, one to two orders of magnitude lower than in conventional packed-bed systems
FIGURE 11 Super X-Pack, developed by Nagaoka International Corp. (Courtesy: Nagaoka International Corp.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 12 Height reduction of a distillation column claimed by Super X-Pack. (Courtesy: Nagaoka International Corp.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 13 Monolithic catalysts.
High geometrical areas per reactor volume, typically 1.5– 4 times higher than in the reactors with particulate catalysts Very high catalytic efficiency, practically 100%, due to very short diffusion paths in thin washcoat layer Stankiewicz (40) gives a spectacular example of reactor size reduction by a factor of ca. 100, as a result of replacement of the conventional system with a monolithic reactor operated horizontally in a pipeline. For highly exothermic reactions the so-called HEX reactors present a very promising option. The basic common feature of all HEX reactors is much more favorable heat transfer conditions in comparison with conventional reactors (heat transfer coefficients typically 3500–7500 W/m2K, heat transfer areas up to 2200 m2/m3). A HEX reactor developed by BHR Group Ltd. (Figure 14) was able to decrease the by-product formation in one of ICI Acrylics’ processes by 75% (41) and to decrease the processing time in a Hickson & Welch fine chemical process from 18 hours to 15 minutes, saving 98.6% of batch time (42). Even higher values of heat transfer coefficients than those in the HEX reactors can be achieved in microreactors. Here, values up to 20,000 W/m2K are reported (43). Microreactors (Figure 15) are chemical reactors of extremely small dimensions that usually have a sandwich-like structure, consisting of a number of slices (layers) with micromachined channels (10–100 µm in diameter). The layers perform various functions, from mixing to catalytic reaction, heat exchange, or separation. Integration of these various functions within a single unit is one of the most important advantages of microreactors. The very high heat transfer rates achievable in microreactors allow for isothermal operation of highly exothermic processes (also important in carrying out kinetic studies). The very low reaction-volume-to-surfacearea ratios make microreactors potentially attractive for carrying out reactions involving poisonous or explosive reactants (think about partial oxidation reactions).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 14 HEX reactor developed by the BHR Group. (Courtesy: BHR Group Ltd.)
Also, microchannel heat exchangers have channel sizes around or lower than 1 mm and are fabricated via silicon micromachining, deep X-ray lithography, or nonlithographic micromachining. The reported values of heat transfer coefficients in the microchannel heat exchangers range from ca. 10,000 to ca. 35,000 W/m2K (21,44). High heat transfer coefficients, though not as high as in the previous case, are also achievable in spinning disk reactors (Figure 16). This type of reactor has been developed by Ramshaw’s group at Newcastle University and is primarily applied to fast and very fast liquid–liquid reactions with large heat effect, such as nitrations, sulphonations, and polymerizations. At very short residence times (typically 0.1 s), heat is efficiently removed from the reacting liquid at heat transfer rates reaching 10,000 W/m2K. The spinning disk reactor investigated in one of SmithKline Beecham’s processes offered a 99.9% reduction in reaction time, 99% reduction in inventory, and 93% reduction in impurity level (45). Rotational movement and centrifugal forces are used not only in spinning disk reactors. The earlier-mentioned high-gravity (HiGee) technology, started at ICI’s New Science Group in the late 1970s as a spinoff of a NASA research project in deep space (microgravity environment), has developed into one of the most promising branches of process intensification. It consists of intensifying the mass
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
transfer operations by carrying them in rotating packed beds, in which high centrifugal forces (typically 1000 g) occur. This way, not only mass transfer but also heat and momentum transfer can be intensified. The rotating bed equipment, originally dedicated to separation processes (such as absorption, extraction, distillation), can also be applied to reacting systems (especially those mass transfer limited). It can potentially be applied not only to gas–liquid combinations but also to other phase combinations, including three-phase gas–liquid–solid systems. The HiGee technology has already been successfully applied on a commercial scale, for deaeration of flood water in Chinese oil fields (20), where conventional vacuum towers of ca. 30-m height have been replaced by the rotating machines of ca. 1-m diameter. The earlier-mentioned hypochlorous acid technology of Dow Chemical presents another example of a successful application of rotating packed beds (25). Also, successes have been achieved in the crystallization of nanoparticles. In the group of Chong Zheng, very uniform 15- to 30-nm crystals of CaCO3 are made in a rotating crystallizer at processing times 4–10 times shorter than in the conventional stirred-tank process (46). Another interesting example of process-intensifying equipment, also undergoing commercialization, is the centrifugal adsorber. This is a new continuous device for carrying out ion exchange and adsorption processes. By using a centrifugal field for establishing countercurrent flow between the liquid phase and the adsorbent, very small adsorbent particles (10–50 µm) can be used. This allows for extremely compact separation equipment (see Figure 17) with very short contact times and high capacities (typically 10 –50 m3/h, (17)).
FIGURE 15 An example of a microreactor. (Courtesy: Institut für Mikrotechnik Mainz.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 16 Spinning disk reactor.
Other examples of interesting PI hardware include the supersonic gas– liquid reactor developed at Praxair Inc. (47) and the jet impingement reactor of NORAM Engineering and Constructors (Hauptmann et al. (48)). The former is based on using a supersonic shock wave to disperse gas into very tiny bubbles in a supersonic inline mixing device, while the latter uses a system of specially configured jets and baffles in order to divide and remix liquid streams with high intensity. Also, rotor/stator mixers (49) are dedicated for processes requiring very fast mixing on the micro scale. They contain a high-speed rotor spinning close to a motionless stator. Fluid passes through the region where rotor and stator interact and experiences highly pulsating flow and shear. Inline rotor/stator mixers resemble centrifugal pumps and therefore may simultaneously contribute to pumping the liquids. 5.2.
Process-Intensifying Methods
As seen in Figure 7, three well-defined categories of PI software can be distinguished: Novel processing methods, such as integration of reaction and one or more unit operations in so-called multifunctional reactors and integration of two or more separation techniques in hybrid separations Use of alternative forms and sources of energy for chemical processing Novel methods of process/plant development and operation Multifunctional reactors can be described as reactors that, alongside chemical conversion (and for the sake of it), integrate at least one more function (usually unit operation) that conventionally would have to be performed in a separate
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
piece of equipment. A pretty widely known example of the integration of reaction and heat transfer in a multifunctional unit are reverse-flow reactors (50). Also, a number of interesting reactor concepts for combining endo- and exothermic reactions have been developed (51,52). Reactive separations present probably the most significant class of multifunctional reactors, of which reactive distillation is one of the better-known and commercially applied examples. The multifunctional reactor is in this case a packed distillation column, in which the packing material acts simultaneously as the catalyst carrier. Chemicals are converted on the catalyst and reaction products are continuously separated by fractionation (thus overcoming equilibrium limitations). Besides the continuous removal of the reaction products and higher yields due to the equilibrium shift, the advantages of catalytic distillation units consist mainly in lower energy requirements and lower capital investment (53). Currently, numerous studies are being carried out in the field of reactive distillation modeling, as reviewed recently by Taylor and Krishna (54). Also, research on new internals for catalytic distillation columns attracts a lot of attention. Reactive distillation originates from and finds most applications in the hydrocarbon processing. Recently, interesting papers on the application of reactive distillation in fine chemistry began to emerge (55). The reverse process to the reactive distillation, i.e., reactive condensation, has also been studied (56). Reactive extraction processes involve simultaneous reaction and liquid–liquid phase separation and can be effectively utilized to obtain significant improvements in yields of desired products and selectivities to desired products in multireaction systems, thereby reducing recycle flows and waste formation. The combination of
FIGURE 17 Progress in size reduction of adsorption equipment, up to the most recent centrifugal adsorption technology. (From Ref. 118.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
reaction with liquid–liquid extraction can also be used for separation of waste byproducts that are hard to separate using conventional techniques (57,58). Reactive extraction can also be used for selective separation of amino acids (59). Reactive crystallization, or precipitation, has been investigated by numerous research groups. Processes of industrial relevance include liquid-phase oxidation of para-xylene to terephthalic acid, the acidic hydrolysis of sodium salicylate to salicylic acid, and the absorption of ammonia in aqueous sulfuric acid to form ammonium sulfate (60). A very special type of reactive crystallization is diastereomeric crystallization, widely applied in the pharmaceutical industry for the resolution of enantiomers (61). Another fine example of reactive precipitation is the earlier-described production of nano-size particles of CaCO3 in high-gravity fields (46). Reactive absorption is probably the most widely applied type of a reactive separation process. It is used for production purposes in a number of classical bulk-chemical technologies, such as nitric or sulfuric acid. It is also often employed in gas purification processes, e.g., to remove carbon dioxide or hydrogen sulfide. Other interesting areas of application include olefin/paraffin separations, where reactive absorption with reversible chemical complexation appears to be a promising alternative to the cryogenic distillation (62). Numerous investigations are being carried out in reactive adsorption processes, for instance, in chromatographic reactors, which integrate continuous countercurrent chromatographic separation with chemical reaction (63,64), and in periodic separating reactors, which are a combination of a pressure swing adsorber with a periodic flow-forced packed-bed reactor (65). This allows achieving higher conversions and better yield by separating educts and products of an equilibrium reaction from each other. In the simulated moving bed reactor (SMBR), the movement of the bed with regard to the reactant inlets/outlets is usually realized in a rotating system. One of the more interesting developments here is the rotating cylindrical annulus chromatographic reactor, shown in Figure 18 (66). In this design the inlets of the mobile phase are uniformly distributed along the annular bed entrance, while the feed stream is stationary and confined to one sector. As a result of the rotation of the reactor, the selectively adsorbed species take different helical paths through the bed and can be continuously collected at fixed locations. Another interesting example of reactive adsorption is the so-called gas– solid–solid trickle flow reactor, in which adsorbent trickles through the fixed bed of catalyst, removing selectively in situ one or more of the products from the reaction zone. In the case of methanol synthesis this led to conversions significantly exceeding the equilibrium conversions under the given conditions (67). A huge research effort is devoted nowadays to membrane reactors. The membrane can play various functions in the reactor systems (68); it can, for instance, be used for selective in situ separation of the reaction products, as a result of which an advantageous equilibrium shift can be achieved. It can also be
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 18 Rotating cylindrical annulus chromatographic reactor.
applied for a controlled distributed feed of some of the reacting species, either to increase the overall yield/selectivity of the process or to facilitate the mass transfer (e.g., direct bubble-free oxygen supply/dissolution in the liquid phase via hollow-fiber membranes (69)). The membrane can also be used for the in situ separation of catalyst particles and even homogeneous catalysts from the reaction products (70). Finally, the membrane can incorporate catalytic material, thus becoming itself a highly selective reaction-separation system. Membranes are more and more frequently employed in the life sciences sector, in manufacturing of pharmaceuticals, in combination with a bioreactor in which enzymatic reaction takes place (71). Multifunctional reactors may also combine reaction and phase transition. A well-known example of such a combination is reactive extrusion. Reactive extruders have been used increasingly in polymer industries. They enable reactive processing of highly viscous materials without a need for using large amounts of solvents, as is the case in stirred-tank reactors. Most of the reactions carried out in extruders are single- or two-phase reactions. Recently, however, new types of extruders have been investigated with catalyst immobilized on the surface of the screws, which enables carrying out three-phase catalytic reactions (72).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Fuel cells present another widely investigated type of multifunctional reactors, in which chemical reaction is integrated with the generation of electric power (73). Simultaneous gas–solid reaction and comminution in a multifunctional reactor has also been investigated (74). Among hybrid separations, the integration of membranes with another separation technique presents the most important category. In membrane absorption and stripping the membrane is used as a permeable barrier between the gas and liquid phases. By using hollow-fiber membrane modules, large mass transfer areas can be created, which results in compact equipment. Besides, absorption membranes offer operation independent of gas- and liquid-flow rates, with no entrainment, flooding, channeling, or foaming (75,76). In membrane distillation, two liquids (usually two aqueous solutions) held at different temperatures are mechanically separated by a hydrophobic membrane. Vapors are transported via the membrane from the hot solution to the cold one. The most important (potential) applications of membrane distillation are in water desalination and water decontamination (77–79). Other possible fields of application include recovery of alcohols (e.g., ethanol, 2,3-butanediol) from fermentation broths (80), concentration of oil–water emulsions (81), and removal of water from azeotropic mixtures (82). Membrane (pervaporation) units can also be coupled with conventional distillation columns, for instance, in esterifications or in production of olefins, to split the azeotrope (83,84). Membrane chromatography systems include microporous or macroporous membranes that contain functional ligands attached to their inner pore structure, which act as adsorbents. In this sense, membrane chromatography is a hybrid combination of liquid chromatography and membrane filtration. Its most important potential applications include separations of biomolecules, such as proteins, polypeptides, and nucleic acids (85,86). Among hybrid separations not involving membranes, adsorptive distillation (87) offers interesting advantages over conventional methods. In this technique a selective adsorbent is added to a distillation mixture. This increases separation ability and may present an attractive option in the separation of azeotropes or close-boiling components. Adsorptive distillation can be used, for instance, for the removal of trace impurities in the manufacturing of fine chemicals (it may allow for switching some fine chemical processes from batchwise to continuous operation). Several unconventional processing techniques using alternative forms and sources of energy have been investigated thus far and are of importance for process intensification. The use of the centrifugal fields instead of gravitational ones was discussed earlier in this chapter. On the other hand, the formation of microbubbles (cavities) in the liquid reaction medium as a result of ultrasound waves has opened new possibilities for chemical syntheses. These cavities can be thought of as high-energy microreactors. By their collapse, “microimplosions”
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
take place with very high local energy release (temperature rises up to 5000 K, and negative pressures up to 10,000 bar are reported (88)). This may have various effects on the reacting species, from homolytic bond breakage with free radicals formation, to the fragmentation of the polymer chains by the shock wave in the liquid surrounding the collapsing bubble. In case of solid-catalyzed (slurry) systems, the collapsing cavities can additionally affect the catalyst surface—this can, for example, be used for in situ catalyst cleaning/rejuvenation (89). Sonochemistry has also been investigated in combination with other techniques, e.g., electrolysis, in the case of the oxidation of phenol in wastewater (90). The use of solar energy in chemical processing has also been investigated. Studies describe, for example, the cycloaddition reaction of a carbonyl compound to an olefin carried out in a solar furnace reactor (91) or oxidation of 4-chlorophenol in a solar-powered fiber-optic cable reactor (92). The concept of using solar light for the synthesis of -caprolactam was evaluated, and it was shown that the return on investment was better than for the conventional technology (93). Solar reactors can also be used advantageously in water treatment plants (94). The use of microwave dielectric heating offers significant advantages for chemical synthesis (95–97). Microwave heating was shown to enable some organic syntheses to proceed up to 1240 times faster than by conventional techniques (98). The employment of electric fields to augment process rates and to control droplet size is known for a range of processes, including paint spraying, crop spraying, and coating processes. In these processes the electrically charged droplets exhibit much better adhesion properties. Electric fields can also enhance processes involving liquid/liquid mixtures, in particular liquid–liquid extraction, where rate enhancements of 200–300% were reported (99). Bioseparations (e.g., DNA separation) present another area in which electric fields can be advantageously applied (100). Interesting results have been reported concerning the so-called gliding arc technology, i.e., the use of plasma generated by the formation of gliding electric discharges (101–103). In this technology, gliding electrical discharges are produced between electrodes placed in the fast gas flow. They offer a low-energy alternative for conventional high-energy-consuming high-temperature processes. The applications tested so far in the laboratory and on industrial scale include: methane transformation to acetylene and hydrogen, destruction of N2O, reforming of heavy petroleum residues, CO2 dissociation, activation of organic fibers, air purification from volatile compounds, natural gas conversion to syngas, and SO2 reduction to elementary sulfur. A number of other methods, not falling within any of the earlier-mentioned categories, may prove useful for process intensification. Some of them, such as supercritical fluids, are already known and have been applied in other industries (104,105). Because of their unique properties, especially the high diffusion coefficient, supercritical fluids are attractive media for mass transfer operations,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 19 Process intensification via process synthesis: methyl acetate plant of Eastman Chemical.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
e.g., extraction (106), and for chemical reactions (107,108). On the other hand, cryogenic techniques (distillation or distillation combined with adsorption (109)), nowadays almost exclusively used for production of industrial gases, may in the future prove attractive for some specific separations in manufacturing of bulk or fine chemicals. Among novel methods of process/plant operation, the use of unsteady-state (periodic) operation of chemical reactors has been studied for more than three decades (110). In many processes studied on the lab scale, the intentional pulsing of flows or concentrations led to a clear improvement of product yields/ selectivities (111). Purposeful pulsing of the feed in trickle-bed reactors has been shown to bring significant improvement in mass transfer rates, in catalyst wetting, and in the radial uniformity of liquid flow (112). The commercial-scale applications of the periodic operation are scarce and are practically limited to the reverseflow reactors discussed earlier. One of the main reasons is that a stationary process has the advantage of providing constant production and product purity, without the need for additional investments to synchronize nonstationary with stationary parts of the process. Further developments in the field of advanced process control may definitely change this picture, especially where the time constant of the pulsing mode is small—synchronizing will not be problematic. Finally, in order to get a more or less complete picture of the process intensification toolbox, the PI-oriented methods for process/plant development must be mentioned. Among them, process synthesis (PS) definitely plays the most important role (113–115). Process synthesis is in some sense a sister discipline of process intensification that aims at the development of a cost-optimal process concept based on the required functionalities. It includes diverse levels of activities, starting from basic conceptual plant design (often based on the “out-of-thebox” approach), through the selection of optimal pieces of equipment and optimal interconnections between them (plant integration), up to cost estimates. Process synthesis permits early assessment and evaluation of the manufacturability of products resulting from potential new chemistries. A textbook example of a commercial application of process synthesis is the methyl acetate plant of Eastman Chemical (23), in which a task-oriented integration of reaction and separation in a multifunctional reactor reduced the number of pieces of equipment from 28 to 3 (see Figure 19). In recent years, process synthesis has gone beyond its traditional field of applications and has entered new sectors, such as bioprocessing and pharmaceuticals manufacturing (116,117). REFERENCES 1. 2.
Agricola G. De Re Metallica Libri XII. Basel: J. Froben & N. Episopius, 1556. Taber RE, Hawkinson DR. Fluid Mixing Device. US Pat. 2,894,732, Shell Development Company, 1959.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14. 15.
16.
17.
18.
19. 20.
21. 22. 23. 24.
25.
Sulzer Chemtech. Mixing and Reaction Technology. Technical Information Brochure. Winterthur, Switzerland: 1997. Chvatal V. Hutnicke Listy 1965; 19:466–474. Chervotkin VV, Bokovikov BA, Gogolev YF, Privalov SI. Sb Nauch Tr, Vses Nauch-Issled Inst Met Teplotek 1969; 16:108–118. Grekov EA. Sb Tr Tsent Nauch-Issled Inst Chern Met 1970; 75:77–84. Kolpakov SV, Frantsenyuk IV, Teder LI, Beremblyum GB. Stal’ 1971; 31:401–402. Leszczynski Z. Przem Chem 1973; 52:161–163. Romankov PG. Khim Ind 1977; 49:82–89. Kleemann G, Hartmann K. Wiss Z Tech Hochsch “Carl Schorlemmer” LeunaMerseburg 1978; 20:417–425. Ramshaw C. Chem Engr (London) 1983; 389:13–14. Heggs P. Chem Engr (London) 1983; 394:13. Ramshaw C. Chem Engr (London) 1985; 416:30–33. Proc Eng (London) 1988; 69 (Issue: Energy Efficiency Suppl.): S13–S16. Ramshaw C, ed. 1st International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry, Antwerp, Belgium, Dec 6–8, 1995. BHR Group Conference Series, Publication No. 18. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1995. Stankiewicz A, Smits HA, Glasz WC, Moulijn JA. In: C Ramshaw, ed. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 18. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1995:167–171. Bisschops MAT, van der Wielen LAM, Luyben KChAM. In: Semel J, ed. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 28. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1997:299–307. Thonon B. In: Ramshaw C, ed. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 18. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1995:37–47. Ehrfeld W, Hessel V, Löwe H. Microreactors. Weinheim:Wiley-VCH, 2000. Zheng C, Guo K, Song Y, Zhou X, Ai D. In: Semel J, ed. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 28. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1997:273–287. Tonkovich ALY, Call ChJ, Jimenez DM, Wegeng RS, Drost MK. AIChE Symp Ser 1996; 92(310):119–125. Quiram DJ, Jensen KF, Schmidt MA, Mills PL, Ryley JF, Wetzel MD. AIChE Symp Ser 2000; 96(323):147–162. Siirola JJ. AIChE Symp Ser 1995; 91(304):222–233. Meili A. In: Semel J, ed. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 28. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1997;309–318. Trent D, Tirtowidjojo D. In: Gough M, ed. Proceedings of the 4th International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. Cranfield, U.K.: BHR Group Ltd., 2001:11–19.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
26. 27. 28. 29. 30.
31. 32. 33. 34. 35. 36. 37. 38. 39. 40. 41.
42. 43.
44.
45. 46.
47.
48.
49.
Chisti Y, Moo-Young M. Trans IChemE 1996; 74(Part A):575–583. Hamilton GE, Morton PhH, Young TW, Lyddiatt A. Biotechnol Bioeng 1999; 64: 310–321. Stewart GG. Eur Brew Conv 2000; 28:94–114. Laird T. Org Proc Res Dev 2001; 5:612. Stankiewicz A. Between the chip and the blast furnace. Process intensification in industry and in academia. UEF Conference “Refocusing Chemical Engineering,” Barga, Italy, May 27–June 1, 2001. Douglas JM. Conceptual Design of Chemical Processes. New York: McGraw-Hill, 1988. The future is now! DSM Magazine 1999; 148:4–10. Elverding P. DEFACTO 2001; 15(5):28–32. Hendershot DC. Chem Eng Prog 2000; 96:35–40. Ramshaw C. The desktop fine chemical process. TG Lustrum Congress 2000, “Honey, I Shrunk the Plant,” Delft, Nov 8–9, 2000. Goldhill J, Arthur D. Little Chemical Executive 2001; 1:1–2. Stringaro J-P, Collins P, Bailer O. In: Cybulski A, Moulijn JA, eds. Structured Catalysts and Reactors. New York: Marcel Dekker, 1998:393–416. Manteufel RPC. Surer 3X-Pack and Super 4X-Pack. A new generation of structured packings. ACHEMA, Frankfurt, May 25, 2000. Kapteijn F, Heiszwolf JJ, Nijhuis TA, Moulijn JA. CATTECH 1999; 3(1):24–41. Stankiewicz A. Chem Eng Sci 2001; 56:359–364. Phillips CH. In: Green A, ed. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 38. London: Professional Engineering Publishing Ltd., 1999:71–87. Calder R. BHR News. 2000; Summer:4. Jäckel K-P. In: Microtechnology: Application Opportunities in the Chemical Industry. DECHEMA Monographs Vol. 132. Frankfurt am Main: DECHEMA, 1995:29–50. Thonon B, Mercier P. In: Semel J, ed. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 28. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1997:49–62. Oxley P, Brechtelsbauer C, Ricard F, Lewis N, Ramshaw C. Ind Eng Chem Res 2000; 39:2175–2182. Chen J, Wang Y, Jia Z, Zheng C. In: Semel J, ed. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 28. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1997:157–161. Cheng ATY. In: Semel J, ed. Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 28. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1997:205–219. Hauptmann EG, Rae JM, Guenkel AA. In: Ramshaw C, ed. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 18. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1995:181–184. Bourne JR, Studer M. Chem Eng Proc 1992; 31:285–296.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
50. 51. 52. 53. 54. 55. 56. 57. 58. 59. 60. 61. 62. 63. 64. 65. 66. 67. 68. 69. 70. 71. 72. 73. 74. 75. 76.
77. 78. 79. 80. 81. 82. 83. 84.
Matros YS, Bunimovich GA. Catal Rev-Sci Eng 1996; 38:1–68. Frauhammer J, Eigenberger G, von Hippel L, Arntz D. Chem Eng Sci 1999; 54: 3661–3670. Kolios G, Frauhammer J, Eigenberger G. Chem Eng Sci 2000; 55:5945–5967. Stadig WP. Chem Processing 1987; 50:27–32. Taylor R, Krishna R. Chem Eng Sci 2000; 55:5183–5529. Clarkson JS, Walker AJ, Wood MA. Org Proc Res Dev 2001; 5:630–635. Ben Amor H, Halloin VL. Chem Eng Sci 1999; 54:1419–1423. Minotti M, Doherty M, Malone MF. Ind Eng Chem Res 1998; 37:4746–4755. Samant KD, Ng KM. Chem Eng Technol 1999; 22:877–880. Cascaval D, Oniscu C, Galction A-I. Biochem Eng J 2001; 7:171–176. Kelkar VV, Ng KM. AIChE J 1999; 45:69–81. Bayley CR, Vaidya NA. In: Collins AN, Sheldrake GN, Crosby J, eds. Chirality in Industry. New York: Wiley, 1992:69–77. Safarik DJ, Eldridge RB. Ind Eng Chem Res 1998; 37:2571–2581. Dünnebier G, Fricke J, Klatt K-U. Ind Eng Chem Res 2000; 39:2290–2304. Lode F, Houmard M, Migliorini C, Mazzotti M, Morbidelli M. Chem Eng Sci 2001; 56:269–291. Vaporciyan GG, Kadlec RH. AIChE J 1989; 35:831–844. Herbsthofer R, Bart H-J, Wolfgang J, Prior A. Chem Ing Tech 2001; 73:56–59. Westerterp KR, Bodewes TN, Vrijland MS, Kuczynski M. Hydrocarbon Processing 1988; 67:69–73. Sirkar KK, Shanbhag PV, Kovvali AS. Ind Eng Chem Res 1999; 38:3715–3737. Shanbhang PV, Guha AK, Sirkar KK. J Hazardous Materials 1995; 41:95–104. Huizenga P. The continuously filtering slurry reactor. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Twente, Enschede, Netherlands, 1998. Wöltinger J, Drauz K, Bommarius AS. Appl Cat A: General 2001; 221:171–185. Ebrahimi-Moshkabad M, Winterbottom JM. Catalysis Today 1999; 48:347–355. Carrette L, Friedrich KA, Stimming U. Chem Phys Chem 2000; 1:162–193. Uhde G, Sundmacher K, Hoffmann U. Proceedings of the 5th World Congress of Chemical Engineering, San Diego, 1996: Vol. I, 167–172. Poddar TK, Majumdar S, Sirkar KK. J Membrane Sci 1996; 120:221–237. Jansen AE, Klaassen R, Feron PHM. In: Ramshaw C, ed. Proceedings of the 1st International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. BHR Group Conference Series, No. 18. London: Mechanical Engineering Publications Limited, 1995:145–153. Banat FA, Simandl J. Sep Sci Technol 1998; 33:201–226. Couffin N, Cabssud C, Lahoussine-Turcaud V. Desalination 1998; 117:233–245. Banat FA, Simandl J. Chem Eng Sci 1996; 51:1257–1265. Qureshi N, Meagher MM, Hutkins RW. Sep Sci Technol 1994; 29:1733–1746. Gryta M, Karakulski K. Desalination 1999; 121:23–29. Udriot H, Araque A, von Stockar U. Chem Eng J 1994; 54:87–93. Parkinson G, Ondrey G. Chem Eng 2001; 108(11):31–37. Al-Rabiah AA, Timmerhaus KD, Noble RD. Proceedings of the 5th World Congress on Chemical Engineering, San Diego, California, 1996: Vol. IV, 335–340.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
85. 86. 87. 88. 89. 90. 91. 92. 93. 94. 95. 96. 97. 98. 99. 100. 101.
102. 103. 104. 105. 106. 107. 108. 109. 110. 111. 112. 113.
Roper DK, Lightfoot EN. J Chromatogr A 1995; 702:3–26. Zeng X, Ruckenstein E. Biotechnol Prog 1999; 15:1003–1019. Yu KT, Zhou M, Xu CJ. Proceedings of the 5th World Congress of Chemical Engineering, San Diego, 1996: Vol. I, 347–352. Mason TJ. Practical Sonochemistry. User’s Guide to Applications in Chemistry and Chemical Engineering. New York: Ellis Horwood, 1991. Mikkola J-P, Salmi T. Chem Eng Sci 1999; 54:1583–1588. Trabelsi F, Aït-Lyazidi H, Ratsimba B, Wilhelm AM, Delmas H, Fabre P-L, Berlan J. Chem Eng Sci 1996; 51:1857–1865. Pohlmann B, Scharf H-D, Jarolimek U, Mauermann P. Sol Energy 1997; 61:159–168. Peill NJ, Hoffmann MR. J Sol Energy Eng 1997; 119:229–236. Sattler C, Müller F-J, Riffelman K-J, Ortner J, Funken K-H. J Phys IV France 1999; 9:Pr3 723–727. Alfano OM, Bahnemann D, Cassano AE, Dillert R, Goslich R. Catalysis Today 2000; 58:199–230. Mingos DPM, Baghurst DR. Chem Soc Rev 1991; 20:1–47. Galema SA. Chem Soc Rev 1997; 26:233–238. Gabriel C, Gabriel S, Grant EH, Halstead BSJ, Mingos DMP. Chem Soc Rev 1998; 27:213–223. Gedye RN, Smith FE, Westaway KC. Can J Chem 1988; 66:17–26. Weatherley LR. Heat Recovery Systems CHP 1991; 13:515–537. Park YG. Biochem Eng J 2001; 7:213–221. Czernichowski A, Czech T. Proceedings HAKONE III, 3rd International Symposium on High-Temperature Low-Pressure Plasma Chemistry, Strasbourg, France, 1991: 147–152. Czernichowski A, Leuseur H. Proceedings Symposium “Plasma Applications to Waste Water Treatment,” Idaho Falls, ID, 1991:1–13. Czernichowski A, Polaczek J, Czech T. Proceedings ISPC-11, 11th International Symposium on Plasma Chemistry, Loughborough, 1993:674–679. McClain J. Chem Eng 2000; 107(2):72–79. Marr R, Gamse T. Chem Eng Proc 2000; 39:19–28. McHugh MA, Krukonis VJ. Supercritical Fluid Extraction. Boston: ButterworthHeinemann, 1994. Savage PE, Gopalan S, Mizan TI, Martino CJ, Brock EE. AIChE J 1995; 41: 1723–1178. Hyde JR, Licence P, Carter D, Poliakoff M. Appl Catal A: General 2001; 222:119–131. Jain R, Tseng JT. Production of high-purity gases by cryogenic adsorption. AIChE 1997 Annual Meeting, Paper 33b. Los Angeles, 1997. Zwijnenburg A, Stankiewicz A, Moulijn JA. Chem Eng Prog 1998; 94(11):39–47. Silveston PL. Composition Modulation in Catalytic Reactors. Amsterdam: Gordon & Breach, 1998. Boelhouwer JG, Piepers HW, Drinkenburg AAH. Chem Eng Sci 2001; 56(8): 2605–2614. Han C, Stephanopulos G, Liu YA. AIChE Symp Ser 2000; 96(323):148–159.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
114. 115. 116. 117. 118.
Terril DL. AIChE Symp Ser 2000; 96(323):329–332. Johns WR. Chem Eng Prog 2001; 97(4):59–65. Steffens MA, Fraga ES, Bogle IDL. Comput Chem Eng 1999; 23:1455–1467. Johnson DB, Bogle IDL. Chem Papers 2000; 54:398–405. Bisschops MAT. Centrifugal adsorption technology. Ph.D. dissertation, Delft University of Technology, Delft, Netherlands, 1999.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2 Chemical Processing in High-Gravity Fields David L. Trent The Dow Chemical Company, Freeport, Texas, U.S.A.
1.
INTRODUCTION
The use of high-gravity, or centrifugal, fields for chemical processing has generated much interest in recent years. Fluid acceleration creates an environment in which mass transfer rates are two to three orders of magnitude higher than rates achieved in more conventional equipment, such as packed towers and stirred tanks. Heat transfer is also enhanced. Short contact time and fast transfer rates allow a reduction in equipment size and in-process inventory. Many chemical processes could benefit from these unique properties by reducing the cost of construction, reducing working capital, improving safety, producing less waste, etc. In addition, the use of high-gravity fields may provide solutions to processing problems more effectively and more economically than conventional equipment. Before exploring the wide range of applications, a brief review of the history of development, a discussion of the process fundamentals, and an introduction to mechanical design issues will help to set the boundaries for use of high-gravity fields in chemical processing. 2.
HISTORICAL DEVELOPMENT
The use of centrifugal fields in chemical processing dates to the beginning of the industry with such physical transport operations as pumping, compression, and solid/liquid separations. Extending this use into mass and heat transport operations
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
such as liquid/liquid extraction, gas/liquid interactions, reactions, crystallization, and heat transfer, however, is a much more recent development. Although the commercial application of high-gravity fields has been limited in these recent areas of interest, the potential to improve existing chemical processes and develop new processes remains high. The extension of the use of centrifugal fields into the commonplace of chemical processing had its start in 1945 with the commercial application of a centrifugal liquid extractor to the recovery of penicillin (1). The liquid extractor, based on earlier patents by Podbielniak (2), employed perforated concentric plates for contacting the two countercurrent liquid streams. Pilo and Dahlbeck (3) introduced an apparatus employing a variety of rotor internals and liquid distributors for “countercurrent contact of two fluids having different specific gravities” in their 1960 U.S. patent. Although the authors suggest use of the apparatus for gas scrubbing, distillation, heat exchange, and reactions, commercial application was not exploited. In 1966 Podbielniak (4) described a centrifugal device with concentric perforated plates for gas/liquid contact. Todd (5) extended the concepts of Pilo and Podbielniak to a multistage device in 1969. In 1981 Ramshaw and Mallinson (6) provided for filling the rotor with a high-surface-area material such as glass beads or wire gauze in order to effect improved mass transfer. They also described a rotor for distillation, complete with vapor/liquid contacting, condenser, and boiler. Following this patent, considerable academic interest developed in an attempt to exploit the high mass and heat transfer rates, high-throughput capability, and short contact times afforded by countercurrent fluid contact using centrifugal fields. Sustained commercial application, however, did not occur until 1997, when Zheng et al. (7) described the successful stripping of oxygen from water used in secondary oil field recovery. In 1999 Trent et al. (8,9) introduced the first commercial application involving simultaneous absorption, reaction, and stripping. Both of these involve gas/liquid contact using a woven wire screen for the rotor internals. 3.
PROCESS FUNDAMENTALS
In order to fully appreciate the application opportunities available from use of high-gravity fields, an understanding of what happens within the rotor would be helpful. Since many of the models used to describe chemical processes in more conventional equipment do not apply to high gravity, much of the information available is empirical. However, where possible the traditional models are being modified to match the observed behavior. The process fundamentals of interest here are mass transfer, heat transfer, fluid distribution and holdup, flooding, pressure drop, power requirements, and rotor internals. Although this last item could be considered with the mechanical design discussion, it is included here because the rotor internals can have a significant impact on the other process variables.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 1 Schematic of gas continuous operation of a rotating packed-bed gas/ liquid contactor.
Before addressing these process fundamentals, however, a description of the basic process equipment would be helpful. Figure 1 shows a schematic of a simplified rotating packed-bed (RPB) contactor. This RPB illustrates countercurrent gas/liquid operation. Liquid enters at the eye of the rotor, being distributed on the rotor packing at the inside diameter. The centrifugal force of the spinning rotor accelerates the liquid radially outward. Gas enters the stationary housing and passes through the rotor from outside to inside. The gas exits at the eye of the rotor, while liquid drains from the housing. Seals on the drive shaft and on the rotor ensure that the gas moves through the rotor. Figure 1 shows a gas continuous configuration. A liquid continuous arrangement is also possible (10). For liquid/liquid extraction the preceding description applies if we consider the liquid to be the heavy phase and the gas to be the light phase (11). In both of these scenarios the light phase enters through the drive shaft and channels radially in the rotor end plate to the outer periphery of the rotor for distribution into the heavy phase (see Figure 2). 3.1.
Hydrodynamics
Understanding the flow of liquid and gas through a rotating packed bed is important to understand the performance results achieved. Liquid flow involves two
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 2 Schematic of liquid continuous operation of a rotating packed bed for gas/liquid and liquid/liquid contacting.
components, liquid introduction to the packing and flow through the packing. Flow through the packing occurs in the radial direction with very little tangential or axial spreading (see Figure 3). A slight curvature in the radial flow results from the direction of rotation. The degree of curvature and spreading is primarily a function of rotor speed and liquid viscosity and less a function of packing type and liquid flow rate (12,13). Gas flow does not impact liquid flow through the rotor (14). The flow pattern described results in incomplete wetting of the packing at the outer diameter of the rotor (13). Thus, not all of the packing surface area is utilized for mass transfer operations. For maximum use of the packing surface area, the ratio of the outside diameter to the inside diameter should be minimized. Scale-up from small-diameter to large-diameter rotors typically provides more efficient use of the packing. In spite of this incomplete wetting of the packing, very high mass transfer rates are achieved. Enhanced mass transfer performance results from the initial contact of the liquid feed with the rotor. Studies at the Higravitec Center of Beijing University of Chemical Technology (HCBUCT), using a video camera attached to the rotor, revealed a breakup of the liquid feed into smaller droplets that filled the void spaces
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
of the packing. This effectively increases the interfacial surface area of the liquid beyond that of the surface area of the packing. At a packing depth of about 7–10 mm, most of the liquid has been accelerated to the rotor speed and wets the packing. Liquid flow continues mostly along the packing surface, but some additional droplets fly across the void spaces in the packing. The most intense mixing and mass transfer occur in the inlet zone of the packing. The degree of mass transfer enhancement at the inlet is a function of the type of packing (porosity, shape of packing structure, etc.), rotor speed, method of liquid distribution, and liquid properties (15). Liquid distribution on the rotor affects the initial contact zone performance. Some of the variables to consider include angle of impingement, velocity of the liquid spray, and acceleration of the liquid via rotation. Optimum performance requires full axial wetting of the packing, whereas full tangential wetting is not necessary. The use of nozzles rotating in the same direction and at the same speed as the rotor gave poor results for a hypochlorous acid process due to little surface area or liquid-side mass transfer enhancement (8). Although nozzles rotating in the opposing direction of the rotor would be expected to provide the best mass transfer performance, the increased cost of manufacture of the equipment may not be justified. Gas distribution in the rotor has not been studied as thoroughly as that of the liquid. Gas entering the rotor at the outside diameter accelerates radially inward due to the reducing diameter. Gas tangential velocity relative to that of the rotor varies depending on the rotor packing. With parallel flat plates the low frictional drag (high slippage) makes the gas spiral inward with a path length much longer than the radial thickness of the packing (Figure 4a). The gas path length approaches the radial thickness of the packing as the packing surface area increases and the
FIGURE 3 General flow pattern of liquid in a gas continuous rotor.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 4 Relative path of gas (a) in a rotor of low resistance (e.g. parallel flat plates), and (b) in a rotor of high resistance (low porosity, high surface area).
porosity decreases, due to the increased drag of the rotor on the gas (Figure 4b). This behavior significantly impacts gas-side mass transfer performance (16). The thickness of the liquid film on the rotor packing helps determine mass transfer rates. Film thickness can be shown to be inversely proportional to rotor speed to the 0.8 power (17). Visual measurements using a video camera attached to the rotor show a water film thickness of 20–80 microns on foam metal packing and 10 microns on wire gauze packing (15). Theoretical models estimate similar film thickness values (13,18,19). Film flow is expected to be laminar. In addition to rotor speed, liquid flow rate and fluid properties affect the film thickness (14).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The foregoing discussion focuses on gas continuous operations, in which the bulk of the rotor volume is filled with gas. Liquid continuous operation can be accomplished by collecting the liquid at the outside diameter of the rotor and channeling it back for discharge at a diameter slightly larger than the feed radial position, as illustrated in Figure 2 (20). Gas introduced into the liquid pool at the outer diameter moves countercurrent to the liquid inside the packing of the rotor. Because of the hydraulic pressure of the liquid from the centrifugal force, the gas bubbles start out small and steadily expand. Contact of the bubbles with the rotor packing results in breakup of the bubbles, to maintain a high interfacial surface area. References 21 and 22 illustrate this approach for water deaeration and a centrifugal field bioreactor, respectively. Liquid–liquid contact in an RPB involves introduction of the heavy liquid at the inside diameter of the rotor and the light phase at the outside diameter. The two liquid phases move countercurrent to one another within the rotor packing. Centrifugal force causes the heavy liquid to move radially outward. This displaces the light liquid, which moves radially inward. The design of the rotor packing influences the contact between the two liquid phases (23,24). 3.2.
Flooding
Rotating packed-bed devices handle high volumes of fluids in a small equipment volume, compared to packed towers, due to the acceleration of gravity. The Sherwood flooding correlation for packed towers (25) is expressed as a plot of UG2 a p G 0.2 L gε 3 L
versus
L G G L
0.5
Early RPB researchers discovered that this flooding correlation for packed towers applied equally well to RPBs when the gravity term (g) was replaced by centrifugal acceleration (r2). As acceleration increases, the gas flooding velocity (UG) increases in order to maintain the same value of the first term. Since the ratio of liquid (L) to gas (G) flow remains constant, liquid flow increases commensurately with gas flow. Most researchers observed higher gas velocities before the onset of flooding than predicted by the Sherwood correlation (17,26,27). Measurement of flooding by traditional means of observing a sharp pressure increase as gas rates increase is not effective with the RPB (28). Flooding can be determined experimentally by adjusting rotor speed and holding gas and liquid rates constant. Flooding will occur at the point of maximum pressure drop over a range of rotor speeds (28) or by observing the increased pressure drop change (inflection point) as a function of decreased rotor speed (27,29). In liquid–liquid contact, two types of flooding can occur. The design of the centrifugal contactor defines the throughput capability before flooding occurs. The second type of flooding relates to the principal interface moving into either
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
the light-phase or heavy-phase takeoff. The movement of the principal interface is controlled by the back pressure of the light-phase takeoff, which is a function of the rotor speed and phase density difference (24). 3.3.
Residence Time
Liquid residence time in the packed rotor varies as a function of packing depth, packing type, rotor speed, and liquid properties (26). Two basic approaches have been applied to the measurement of liquid in the rotor. The first measure is the average residence time of the liquid within the rotor, and the second is the liquid holdup on the packing. Due to the flow patterns described previously, not all of the rotor packing is wetted and not all of the liquid resides on the packing surface. As a result, average residence time and liquid holdup are distinct measures of liquid flow, contrary to the experience with packed towers. Tracer methods, both visual and electrical conductivity sensors, have been applied to measure the residence time of the liquid in the rotor (15,26). Measured liquid residence time ranges from about 0.2 seconds to about 1.8 seconds. Time decreases as the rotor speed increases, as liquid flow rate increases, and as the radial position increases. Gas flow rate and liquid viscosity (narrow test range) have little impact on residence time (15,19,26). Since liquid does not completely wet the packing and since film thickness varies with radial position, classical film-flow theory does not explain liquid flow behavior, nor does it predict liquid holdup (30). Electrical resistance measurements have been used for liquid holdup, assuming liquid flows as rivulets in the radial direction with little or no axial and transverse movement. These data can then be empirically fit to film-flow, pore-flow, or droplet-flow models (14,19). The real flow behavior is likely a complex combination of these different flow models, that is, a function of the packing used, the operating parameters, and fluid properties. Incorporating calculations for wetted surface area with the film-flow model allows prediction of liquid holdup within 20% of experimental values (18). Liquid holdup in liquid–liquid extractors must be defined for both the heavy and light phases. The light-phase outlet pressure is used to control the relative liquid holdup of the two phases. Higher light-phase outlet pressure increases the light-phase holdup. This pressure has been correlated with the phase density difference, rotor speed, and rotor dimensions (24). In addition, packing characteristics of volumetric surface area and porosity influence liquid holdup and throughout capability (23). 3.4.
Mass Transfer
Developing correlations to describe mass transfer in rotating packed beds has proven to be a challenge. Penetration theory (31), film-flow theory (32), and modified surface-renewal theory (12) are some examples of leveraging previous work
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
to the rotating packed bed. At issue is the need to include a multiplicity of variables as well as to understand the hydrodynamics of gas/liquid contact within the rotor. Each modeling approach compared experimental data to the models, with reasonable fit. However, these expressions have not yet been validated on multiple-RPB designs and operating conditions. A key to developing a generalized model for mass transfer performance is the proper understanding and treatment of the fluid flows within the rotor, as discussed previously in Section 3.1. The combination of high surface area, high velocities, thin films, and intense mixing in the packing provides an environment for intensive mass transfer, resulting in values for height of transfer unit (HTU) of 1.5–4 cm (26). Mass transfer has been described using HTU, number of transfer units (NTU), mass transfer coefficient (kL, kG), and volumetric mass transfer coefficient (kLa, kGa, k S a). To accommodate the variation in packing surface wetting with radial distance, an area transfer unit (ATU) has been proposed (33). Another proposed method of evaluation uses a volume transfer unit (VTU) to account for the entire volume of the packed rotor (34). Although the ATU and VTU methods may have merit in evaluating RPB performance, these methods make comparison with other transfer devices based on HTU more difficult. The possible physical design parameters affecting mass transfer include packing and packing supports. Atomization of the liquid as it impacts the spinning rotor packing creates high-surface-area liquid drops, in addition to the film wetting of the high-surface-area packing. This atomization results in significant mass transfer apart from the packing surface. As a result, low-surface-area packings produce equivalent, if not better, volumetric mass transfer coefficients than do high-surface-area packings (35,36). This implies that low-surface-area packing with high porosity can effectively replace high-surface-area packing, contrary to the experience with packed towers. The result is lower-cost packing, reduced pressure drop, and higher throughput. Packing supports at the inside diameter of the rotor generally provide a positive effect on mass transfer (36). Due to the atomization of liquid exiting the rotor, additional mass transfer occurs in the space between the rotor and the housing (37). Operational parameters of importance to mass transfer include rotor speed, liquid rates, and gas/liquid ratios. Mass transfer increases proportionately to rotor speed, decreases with increasing liquid flow, and increases with gas/liquid ratio (17,26,36). Although most references present rotor speed as revolutions per minute (rpm), expression as either tangential velocity (r) or multiples of gravity (r2) provides a better basis for comparison among the different rotor designs and for scale-up. Gas-side mass transfer in rotating packed beds does not show the same level of enhanced performance as liquid-side mass transfer. Average volumetric gas mass transfer values for a wire screen packing increased with gas flow rate but decreased with increased rotor speed. Compared to a packed tower, the RPB
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
mass transfer coefficient (1–8 s1) was similar when operated at similar superficial gas velocities (1 m/s). However, when gas velocities were increased (4–12 m/s) in studies with parallel flat plates as the rotor, the mass transfer coefficient also increased, to a high of 45 s1 (16). In a commercial-scale RPB, average volumetric gas-side mass transfer coefficients of 40–50 s1 were achieved using a wire screen packing and gas velocities of 4–5 m/s (9). The factors affecting gasside mass transfer are less understood than those of liquid-side mass transfer. Liquid–liquid mass transfer in centrifugal extraction contactors shows similar trends on performance as the gas–liquid contactors. Mass transfer improves at higher rotor speeds, higher solvent ratio, and higher phase density difference. Since the light-phase outlet pressure controls the liquid holdup of both phases, decreasing the light-phase outlet pressure decreases the light-phase holdup and increases the number of transfer units (24). Packing characteristics of pore size, porosity, and volumetric surface area also play a role in performance (23). Single centrifugal extractors have achieved up to 10 theoretical stages of extraction (38), but they could achieve up to 20 stages with suitable rotor design (11). Liquid–solid mass transfer has also been studied, on a limited basis. Application to systems with catalytic surfaces or electrodes would benefit from such studies. The theoretical equations have been proposed based on film-flow theory (32) and surface-renewal theory (39). Using an electrochemical cell with rotating screen disks, liquid–solid mass transfer was shown to increase with rotor speed and increased spacing between disks but to decrease with the addition of more disks (39). Water flow over naphthalene pellets provided 4–6 times higher volumetric mass transfer coefficients compared to gravity flow and similar superficial liquid velocities (17). 3.5.
Pressure Drop
Gas pressure drop through the RPB rotor is an important consideration when comparing the performance of the RPB with other mass transfer devices, such as a packed tower. Numerous studies on pressure drop in RPB rotors employing a variety of packings have yielded some surprising differences from conventional packed towers. For example, lower pressure drop for wetted packing compared to dry packing has been reported (26,40,41). Not all researchers observed this phenomena, because pressure drop was found to be a function of packing type, rotor design, gas rates, liquid rates, and rotor speed (41). Pressure drop has been reported for a number of rotor internals, including corrugated structured packing (28), foam metal (26,40,42), rectangular and elliptical cylinder plastic grains randomly packed (41), wire screen (43), and glass beads (17). In spite of the variation in porosity from 0.38 to 0.95 and in volumetric surface area from 500 to 4000 m2/m3, all of these studies showed similarities of increased pressure drop as rotor speed increased and gas rates increased.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
In addition to the differences in packing type and characteristics, these studies also had a variety of rotor and housing designs for the gas and liquid inlet and outlet. All of them measured a gas pressure drop from the inlet gas piping or housing to the outlet gas pipe. In an effort to develop models of the pressure drop, most have attributed the pressure drop to centrifugal and frictional forces in the rotor, using a film-flow model (43). Pressure drop is proportional to the square of rotor speed (26,42). Compared to conventional packed towers, the pressure drop is lower per NTU (26) and about 15 times higher at flooding conditions (28). To account for the differences in machine configuration and to better explain the pressure-drop observations (e.g., lower pressure drop with onset of liquid flow), a model based on conservation of mass and momentum, in particular gas angular momentum, was developed (40). This model divided the pressure drop into four increments that included the gas inlet to the machine housing, the rotor, the eye of the rotor, and the gas exit nozzle from the machine. Although the models for pressure drop have a basis in theory, all are fit empirically to data generated from specific equipment. Application of these models may not be relevant to machines of different configurations and packing types (9). In liquid–liquid contactors, pressure drop is defined by the light phase. The heavy phase enters at near atmospheric pressure and is accelerated by the rotor to its discharge pressure. The pressure drop of the light phase is a function of phase density difference, rotor speed, rotor diameter, and location of the principal phase interface (24). 3.6.
Heat Transfer
Most of the experimental work on heat transfer in centrifugal fields has been done on spinning discs, which is the subject Chapter 3 in this book. A brief review of the enhanced heat transfer rates is relevant here. Studies on a smooth, flat spinning disc show heat transfer coefficients as high as about 20 kW/m2K. The coefficient is highest at the inlet to the disc, due to disturbances as the liquid is accelerated to the angular velocity of the disc. The heat transfer coefficient increases with increased rotor speed but decreases with increased radial position. Higher-viscosity fluids decrease the heat transfer rate. Heat transfer is generally higher than predicted from film or penetration theory (44). Modifying the surface of the disc allows enhancement of the heat transfer by introducing liquid film instabilities (waves). Best results come from the combination of thin films and large instabilities as revealed from the study of four surface geometries: smooth, sprayed metal, and two types of concentric grooves. In general, increased rotor speed gives higher heat transfer. However, with the grooved disc, high speeds cause liquid separation from the disc, resulting in lower heat transfer (45).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Heat transfer involving non-Newtonian fluids has not been studied in rotating devices. Models have been developed for gravity-driven heat transfer for power-law fluids (46). These models may be useful as a starting point to evaluate performance in higher-gravity fields. Another method of introducing heat to fluids in rotating devices involves the generation of eddy currents by rotation through a stationary magnetic field. This approach was successfully used in a polymer devolatilization process (47). 3.7.
Power
Estimating power consumption in rotating systems depends on several factors, including acceleration of the liquid, windage effect of gas drag on the rotor, friction in the bearings and seals, and gas pressure drop (33,48). As would be expected from power consumption in such devices as centrifugal pumps, the largest power component involves acceleration of the liquid to the angular velocity of the rotor at the outer diameter. Gas pressure drop actually decreases power consumption in the rotor. Frictional losses are defined by the design of the rotor, bearings, and seals. 3.8.
Rotor Internals
The rotor packing has an impact on all of the previously mentioned process fundamentals. Hydrodynamics, especially at the liquid inlet to the packing, is a function of packing porosity and volumetric surface area (12,13). These same packing properties influence pressure drop, residence time, and flooding velocity (26). Liquid-side mass transfer performance is best with wire gauze as compared to glass beads or parallel flat plates (8). Gas-side mass transfer is better with parallel flat plates than in wire gauze (16). Flat plates provide the best medium for heat transfer (34). 4.
MECHANICAL DESIGN
Since the development of high-gravity fields requires rotating equipment, the mechanical design is very important when considering operating performance, cost of design and fabrication, ease of maintenance, and overall reliability. Although most public reports on RPB studies describe the particular RPB design used in the reported studies, very little information has been published on the mechanical design principles. Original equipment manufacturers of rotating equipment provide an effective resource for proper design and fabrication of RPBs. The following discussion outlines some of the basic issues to be considered in the machine design. Overriding all of the following discussion is the need to design a stable rotor with minimal vibration under the desired operating conditions.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
4.1.
Cantilevered Versus Centerhung Rotor
Once the rotor dimensions of inside diameter, outside diameter, and axial height have been determined from the operating performance requirements, the rotor orientation on the shaft must be determined. Two options are available, cantilevered, also called overhung, and centerhung. These relate to the position of the rotor relative to the shaft and the support bearings. The cantilever design places the rotor at the end of the shaft, while the centerhung design positions the rotor in the middle of the shaft, with bearings on either side of the rotor. Often the determining factor for selection is the ratio of axial height (AH) to outside rotor diameter (OD). The conservative approach limits cantilever selection to AH/OD 0.5, though designs with ratios up to about 0.85 are possible. Numerous examples of rotating equipment, such as pumps, compressors, and centrifuges, can be found for each design configuration. Figure 5 illustrates the vertical-shaft cantilever design; Figure 6 illustrates the horizontal-shaft cantilever design; and Figure 7 illustrates the horizontal-shaft centerhung design. In addition to the rotor dimensions, other considerations for selection of rotor shaft position include impact on operating performance, cost of manufacture, maintenance, and number and type of seals. The operating performance is not expected to deviate significantly based on rotor position. The possible considerations include rotor imbalance due to flooding of the housing and liquid distribution on the rotor. In general the centerhung design is considered more stable, but it has a slightly higher cost of manufacture due to the split case housing, is more difficult to maintain, and requires two shaft seals instead of one. Standard equations for fatigue and rigidity are used to determine shaft diameter for both orientations. 4.2.
Horizontal Versus Vertical Shaft Orientation
The centerhung design is restricted to a horizontal shaft orientation. A verticalshaft cantilever design is expected to have slightly lower maintenance costs than the horizontal-cantilever design. Both cantilever options should have similar design and fabrication costs. Flooding of the housing due to insufficient liquid drainage would be less of a problem with the vertical-shaft arrangement with respect to rotor imbalance. Liquid distribution on the rotor can be influenced by gravity more on the vertical shaft, but the effect should be minimal. Reference 7 illustrates both the centerhung and cantilever horizontal-shaft arrangements and discusses an application for use of the vertical-shaft cantilever design. 4.3.
Seals
Two types of seals are needed to prevent fluid leakage from the housing and to ensure that gas passes through the rotor countercurrent to the liquid. Seals on the shaft as it passes through the housing can be of a design appropriate for the fluids
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 5 Pilot-scale RPB illustrating the vertical-shaft cantilever design with direct motor drive. (Photo courtesy of The Dow Chemical Company.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 6 Pilot-scale RPB illustrating the horizontal-shaft cantilever design with direct motor drive. (Photo courtesy of Higravitec Center of Beijing University of Chemical Technology.)
being handled. Mechanical seals, lip seals, and packing glands are some suitable examples. As mentioned previously, a centerhung rotor requires two shaft seals, whereas the cantilever rotor requires only one. To seal the rotor to prevent gas bypassing, labyrinth seals and liquid ring seals are options. Figure 1 shows the position of seals for a vertical-shaft cantilever design.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 7 Commercial water deaeration RPB using the horizontal-shaft centerhung design and direct motor drive. (Photo courtesy of Higravitec Center of Beijing University of Chemical Technology.)
4.4.
Power Train
Options for connecting the motor drive to the shaft depend on the shaft orientation. A vertical-shaft cantilever design would prefer a belt drive to reduce the cost of manufacture of the support structure and to facilitate maintenance. A horizontal shaft has the additional option of direct coupling. Variable speed can be accomplished through a gearbox or preferably through variable frequency control on the motor. In addition to the power requirements discussed previously, the startup power to overcome the torque of the rotor must be considered. This startup power is related to the time required to reach the desired rotor speed. 4.5.
Liquid Distribution
As discussed previously, proper liquid distribution on the rotor is critical to performance, but it is also important to prevent rotor imbalance. Rotor imbalance
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
from liquid maldistribution is especially a problem with high-viscosity fluids. Liquid distributor pipes extending the axial length of the rotor, depending on the pipe diameter and number, can be a source of additional gas pressure drop. Gas flow around the distributor pipes can also be a source of vibration. In the case of a vertical-shaft arrangement, the liquid head in the vertical distributor pipe must be considered to ensure equal liquid distribution on the axial length of the rotor. The rotor can be used to assist liquid distribution either by attaching the distributor pipes to the rotor or by introducing the liquid onto the rotor and allowing the centrifugal force to move the liquid to the packing. In the former option the liquid must enter the RPB through the shaft, requiring machining of a channel in the shaft and an additional seal. In the case of liquid–liquid extraction, the shaft must have at least one channel for introduction of one of the liquid phases (see Figure 2). 4.6.
Rotor Packing
The selection of the type of rotor packing depends largely on the performance requirements. However, there are some mechanical design considerations. Examples of packing include woven wire screen, pellets randomly packed, foam metal, and structured packing. The materials of construction must have physical properties sufficient to withstand the hydraulic forces created by the accelerating liquid. The packing must be dimensionally stable during operation to avoid rotor imbalance issues. Some packing materials may require supports to keep them in place. Proper design of the supports will consider porosity to prevent flooding, strength, impact on fluid distribution, and pressure drop. 4.7.
Multiple Rotors
Several designs involving multiple rotors have been proposed. To accommodate the need of additional transfer units in countercurrent gas/liquid contact, a vertical shaft with at least two rotors and appropriate internals to conduct the gas from the bottom to the top and liquid from top to bottom can be built (5). Another variation allows for heat transfer in addition to the mass transfer. By providing rotors for condensation and for boiling and multiple packed rotors for gas/liquid contacting, a self-contained distillation column on a single shaft is envisioned (6). Obviously, these multiple-rotor devices are more complex from a mechanical design and construction perspective. However, they offer some interesting possibilities for reducing plant size by combining multiple unit operations and additional stages of separation in one piece of equipment. 5.
APPLICATIONS
The operating and design principles given previously provide a basis for understanding the performance enhancement available to a wide variety of applications.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
These include standard mass transfer operations, such as absorption and stripping, but also include reaction systems. The following section highlights some of the applications for which data are available and suggests other opportunities for exploitation of the intensified mass and heat transfer capabilities. 5.1.
Absorption
Absorption of a component of a gas stream into a liquid is a common practice in the chemical industry to affect cleanup of vent gases, conduct chemical reactions, purify products, or to recover products from process streams. The enhanced mass transfer capability of RPBs provides the opportunity to perform absorption processes in smaller equipment, to lower inventories, to shorten startup and shutdown times, and to lower pressure drop (48). Figure 8 provides a visual comparison of the size of a conventional absorber tower next to three RPBs that handle the equivalent gas and liquid flows (9). An example of industrial relevance is the removal of sulfur dioxide (SO2) from vent gases by absorption into water or a lime slurry (48). In the water absorption process, both gas-film and liquid-film resistance to mass transfer occurs. As a result the overall mass transfer rate is proportional to gas-flow rate and acceleration but inversely proportional to liquid-flow rate. Due to the fast reaction of SO2 with lime, this system is only gas-film diffusion limited. The overall mass transfer rate is largely unaffected by gas- or liquid-flow rate and is proportional to acceleration, but to a lesser extent than the water absorption process. In both cases the overall mass transfer rate is reportedly much higher than the corresponding conventional packed towers. In another study of gas-side mass transfer–limited absorption involving SO2 absorption into a sodium hydroxide solution using a wire screen packing, the overall mass transfer coefficient was found to be lower than reported data for packed towers (16). Replacing the wire screen packing with two parallel rotating plates significantly enhanced the mass transfer performance. Absorption of hypochlorous acid into water, a liquid-side mass transfer– limited process, showed HTU values as low as 4 cm, with a strong dependence on liquid-flow rate. Heat of absorption removal was identified as a potential issue with absorption in rotating beds (9). 5.2.
Stripping
Removal of volatile components from the liquid phase to a gas phase has been the object of much study in RPB devices. One of the early successful applications was oxygen removal from water for use in secondary oil field recovery and boiler water feed (7). The oil field application demonstrated oxygen removal from 6–14 ppm to less than 50 ppb in both 50-T/h and 300-T/h RPBs using natural gas for stripping. The packing had 92% porosity and 500-m2/m3 volumetric surface area
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 8 Commercial use of RPB technology in HOCl process. (Photo courtesy of The Dow Chemical Company.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
and was constructed of wire mesh. Comparison with conventional vacuum desorption in a packed tower combined with chemical reduction agents showed lower cost and equipment size for the RPB approach. The proposed application on oil platforms promises further advantages of weight reduction over conventional process equipment. The boiler feed water deaerator reduced oxygen content to less than 7 ppb by the use of exhaust steam (low pressure). This system operated at lower temperature (110C), used lower-pressure steam (0.05-MPa gauge), and achieved the oxygen specification without the use of chemical reducing agents as compared to conventional thermal desorption in a packed tower (7). The preceding approaches to water deaeration used a gas continuous process in the RPB. A liquid continuous RPB has been designed and tested for this application as well (21). The liquid continuous process allows design of the RPB for reduced power requirements, but it does require higher-pressure gas to overcome the hydraulic head of the liquid. The schematic in Figure 2 shows the liquid takeoff near the eye (inside diameter) of the rotor, thus recovering the power needed to accelerate the liquid. In the case of oil platform water deaeration using produced methane gas, boosting the pressure of the available gas would not be necessary. As with the gas continuous process, mass transfer is enhanced by increasing rotor speed and increasing gas-flow rate. Sampling at various radial positions in the polyurethane foam packing revealed the possibility of liquid back-mixing within the rotor that reduced the mass transfer efficiency, i.e., fewer transfer units than expected (21). Further work on the hydrodynamics of the gas and liquid interaction may be warranted in order to realize the full potential of this energy-saving approach for stripping (49). A novel example of stripping in rotating packed beds is the stripping of residual monomer and solvent from polymers (47). In polystyrene production, conventional vacuum desorption achieves residuals reduction to about 500 ppm. Steam-stripping technology is available to reduce residuals to about 200 ppm. Compared to steam stripping, the RPB technology is expected to reduce capital cost, energy costs, and equipment size and to eliminate the potential for side reactions of steam with the polymer. A pilot-scale devolatilizer, called an Accelerator, and a larger demonstration unit showed the viability of this approach. Data collected at 5–10 mm Hg pressure followed the equilibrium curve for residual styrene and solvent. This indicates that the mass transfer capability is more than adequate to achieve equilibrium conditions in the short residence time in the rotor. As a further effort to minimize process costs, the devolatilization rotating packed bed was combined with a centrifugal pelletizer. Heating of the rotor and polymer was accomplished by eddy currents generated by placing magnets on either side of the rotor. Since the high viscosity of the polymer melt requires higher g-force to achieve thin-film flow over the packing compared to earlier gas/liquid applications, the packing must have sufficient compressive strength to withstand
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
the generated forces. A reticulated foam metal packing of high porosity (90%) and high surface area (500 m2/m3) was used (47). Air stripping of volatile organic compounds from groundwater shows the possibility of using RPB technology for either continuous operation or intermittent remedial operation. Since a wide variety of processes (membranes, air stripping, biological activity, chemical oxidation, and carbon adsorption) are available to remove volatile organics from water, the selection of RPBs will depend on the performance requirements and the relative cost compared to the alternatives. Tests on air stripping of jet fuel components from groundwater show the viability of RPB use (33). Both a wire gauze packing and a reticulated foam metal packing proved effective in removing compounds such as benzene, o-xylene, toluene, 1,2,4-trimethylbenzene, and naphthalene. A demonstrated number of transfer units as high as 12 gave corresponding height-of-transfer-unit values of 2–3 cm. Another stripping application actually involves absorption and reaction as well. Chlorine gas absorbs into sodium hydroxide aqueous solution, reacts to produce hypochlorous acid (HOCl), and is then stripped using excess chlorine gas. The primary measure of performance of this operation is the recovery of stripped HOCl. This study showed the importance of liquid distribution (type of spray nozzle), gas/liquid ratio, and type of packing (wire gauze preferred over glass beads or flat plates). Above a minimal g-force, little performance improvement was seen. Low-surface-area wire gauze packing (660 m2/m3) was just as effective as high-surface-area (2800 m2/m3) packing (8). Scale-up to commercial operation of this process showed a doubling of the HTU for this gas-side mass transfer– limited stripping. The actual pressure drop in the commercial scale RPB was half the expected value. This same correlation, empirically based on centrifugal and frictional factors of film flow, effectively modeled the pilot RPB (9). 5.3.
Distillation
Distillation combines absorption and stripping in one device. Rotating packed beds perform distillation by use of external condensers and reboilers, as in conventional towers (29), or by use of internal heat exchangers as part of the rotor (6). Up to 20 theoretical plates were demonstrated in a rotor of 800-mm diameter (50). Distillation was demonstrated on a 3-tons/h pilot plant separating an ethanol/ propanol mixture at total reflux. The pilot plant consisted of two RPBs, one for stripping and one for rectification, along with external reboiler and condenser, respectively (51). Retrofit of existing distillation towers with an RPB has been proposed as a means to adding separation stages (52). Another pilot distillation study employed only one RPB along with external condenser and reboiler. The cyclohexane/n-heptane mixture was separated at rates up to 9 tons/h at total reflux. The system provided up to 6 transfer units (NTU) of separation in a 21-cm packing depth. The primary variable affecting
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
separation was rotor speed. Two operating pressures and a range of gas loading (reboiler duty) provided additional data for analysis (29,42). 5.4.
Heat Transfer
Heat input or removal in rotating systems is best accomplished using plates to separate the heat transfer fluids from the process fluids (45). Since spinning disc technology is discussed in Chapter 3 of this book, this section will cover only the application of heat transfer in conjunction with rotating packed beds and some of the issues related to further development needs. In the 1950s Hickman developed a centrifugal vapor compression evaporator for seawater desalination (53). This device consisted of multiple spinning discs. Seawater sprayed on one side of the disc evaporated, while the centrifugal force removed the residue from the plate surface. The vapor was compressed and returned to the opposite side of the plate, where condensation provided the heat for evaporation and the desired freshwater for recovery. Overall heat transfer coefficients of 18 kW/m2-K are about three times higher than those achieved in steam turbine condensers. A high-intensity heat pump, called Rotex, has been developed taking advantage of the enhanced heat and mass transfer performance of rotating discs (44). This single device carries out the processes of evaporation, condensation, absorption, and heat transfer to a working fluid. The higher heat transfer coefficients experienced by Hickman led to the concept of placing a peripheral reboiler and core condenser on either side of a rotating packed bed (50). This concept would be useful for distillation applications that need reflux and boilup. The internal exchangers as part of the rotor would decrease the required heat transfer surface area but would involve additional design and fabrication complexity. Although heat exchangers on either end of a packed rotor are an option for replacing external heat exchangers for distillation, the problem of heat transfer within a porous packed bed remains. Heat input can be achieved by use of eddy currents (47), microwaves, or sonic energy. Thus operations such as evaporation, stripping, and endothermic reactions can be envisioned. Heat removal, however, is more problematic. Exothermic reactions must be conducted adiabatically within the rotor, unless a suitable means of extracting the heat of reaction can be developed. One approach could be alternating packing and heat transfer plates. This raises the complexity of design and fabrication but could provide the needed cooling to approach isothermal operation. A simpler method of evaporative cooling is possible if the evaporation is compatible with the chemical process. 5.5.
Adsorption
Centrifugal adsorption technology (CAT) allows the use of very small adsorbent particles (microns) to increase the mass transfer efficiency. Application to ion
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
exchange, volatile organic removal from water, recovery of pharmaceutical proteins, and production of fine chemicals are examples of potential commercial interest. Process advantages include low inventory, low contact time, steady-state operation, and relatively small equipment (54). The CAT mode of operation involves introduction of the adsorbent near the axis of the rotor, allowing the centrifugal force to move the particles radially outward. Liquid introduced at the outer periphery of the rotor moves countercurrent to the adsorbent and is removed at the axis of the rotor. Adsorbent slurry collects at the periphery and is conducted to the rotor axis for discharge. Experiments using activated carbon to adsorb n-butanol from water revealed that the degree of back-mixing is the dominant factor in performance. Back-mixing is a function of rotor speed, density difference between the phases, and the particle diameter (54). The hydrodynamics of two-phase flow in CAT were compared to two-phase flow under gravity using a large-diameter (1.3-mm) particle in water with a small density difference and a small-diameter (81.8-micron) particle in water with a large density difference. The throughput capacity of the CAT was higher than predicted from the homogeneous-flow model, though the model works well for the gravity-flow column. Pressure drop estimates were used to predict void fractions in the range of 0.7–0.8. Higher rotor speeds resulted in higher void fraction (55). 5.6.
Liquid–Liquid Extraction
The use of centrifugal fields for liquid–liquid extraction was perhaps the first commercially successful application of rotating packed beds. Podbielniak modified a patented vapor–liquid contactor (2), using a perforated spiral passageway as the rotor packing, to solve problems with penicillin recovery in 1945 (1). Penicillin broth forms stable emulsions that require centrifugal force to break. Solvent extraction was effective only at low pH, which caused penicillin degradation. Multiple stages were needed to affect the necessary concentration. In addition, the fermentation liquor varied significantly from batch to batch and plant to plant. Conventional countercurrent solvent extraction, mixer-settlers, and mixercentrifuge combinations could not effectively solve these problems without product loss. The centrifugal solvent extractor achieved 98% product recovery by taking advantage of its low liquid holdup, short residence time, high centrifugal force, and multistage countercurrent contacting. Continuous glycerin washing of soap produced by saponification has been demonstrated in a countercurrent centrifugal extractor (38). The device achieves phase separation with as little as 0.02 specific gravity difference and accomplishes up to 10 theoretical stages of extraction. Some of the advantages over prior operations reportedly include flexibility in feed, low holdup, less waste due to more efficient separation, simple operation, rapid startup, and small space requirements. Rotors filled with ceramic foam instead of perforated cylinders have been tested for liquid extraction of trace contaminants from water (23). The test solution
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
used a C12 alkene to extract 1,2-dichloroethane from water. Flow patterns are similar to the previous applications, with the heavy phase introduced at the inner diameter of the rotor and the light phase at the outer diameter. Countercurrent flow is achieved as the heavy phase moves outward, displacing the light phase inward. The results indicate an optimum pore size for the ceramic foam, decreasing height of transfer unit with increasing rotor speed, and increasing holdup with increasing dispersed phase flow. The ability of the centrifugal extractor to solve difficult liquid–liquid separation problems, as illustrated in the previous examples, has allowed its use in a wide range of extraction applications. The long history of use has given it a general acceptance in chemical manufacturing—an acceptance not shared by the broader application of gas–liquid interactions. 5.7.
Crystallization
In the reactive precipitation process of reacting CO2 with Ca(OH)2 slurry to produce nanoparticles of CaCO3, the controlling steps of the process are absorption of CO2 and dissolution of solid Ca(OH)2. The degree of supersaturation depends on the reaction rate and controls the nucleation rate and, therefore, the particle size. The intense mass transfer and micromixing capability of the rotating packed bed provides the environment to produce CaCO3 particles of size 15–30 nm with a narrow size distribution. Reaction time reduces 4- to 10-fold, compared to stirred-tank reactors. Rotor speed, gas–liquid ratio, and initial calcium hydroxide concentration influence reaction rate. An increase in rotor speed reduces the average particle size. Addition of growth inhibitors also helps to control particle size and size distribution (56). High-gravity reactive precipitation (HGRP) has been extended to the production of aluminum hydroxide and strontium carbonate (57). Aluminum hydroxide fibrils precipitate from the reaction of sodium meta-aluminate (NaAlO2), water, and carbon dioxide and are formed in diameters of 1–10 nm and lengths of 50–300 nm. Rotor speed, gas- and liquid-flow rates, and initial reactant concentrations control particle size. Strontium carbonate particles of 40-nm mean diameter and narrow size distribution have been produced from the liquid–liquid reaction of strontium nitrate and sodium carbonate. Crystallization that occurs during evaporation can potentially be intensified by use of vapor recompression and spinning discs. In this scenario, the evaporated vapor is compressed and then condensed on the bottom of the discs to heat the crystallizing fluid (58). This approach may permit operation at higher temperatures, lower surface area, and less time. Recrystallization of an active pharmaceutical ingredient on a spinning disc, employing a solvent/antisolvent approach to induce rapid precipitation, results in the desired small particles (1–15 microns) and narrow particle size distribution (59).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
5.8.
Reactions
A significant number of chemical reactions of commercial interest have reaction rates limited by heat or mass transfer rather than the intrinsic chemical kinetics. Many of these processes could be intensified by application of the RPB or spinning disc technology. Indeed, application of centrifugal fields to reacting systems may represent its greatest potential. Improved yield performance may also be possible (50). Spinning disc technology provides the advantage of heat transfer capability. Thus, temperature control of exothermic reactions such as styrene polymerization and intense mixing allow reduction in reaction time compared to conventional batch reactors, especially in the latter stages of reaction, where viscosity is higher (60,61). Polycondensation reactions that are equilibrium controlled, such as polyesters, could benefit from the thin films generated in the RPB or spinning disc. In these reactions, removal of the coproduct of polymerization, e.g., ethylene glycol, is necessary in order to advance the polymerization, a task that becomes increasingly difficult as the reaction proceeds. The thin films and short residence time of high-gravity devices aid the evaporation and may permit operation at higher temperatures than conventional reactors (50). As mentioned previously, RPB and spinning disc technology may provide benefits for reactions that are mass or heat transfer limited, i.e., for fast kinetic reactions. Unfortunately, the true chemical kinetics are often unknown. A smallscale RPB or spinning disc may prove to be a useful screening tool to determine the intrinsic chemical kinetics. In one such study, six different reactions of interest in the manufacture of pharmaceuticals were screened using a spinning disc reactor (59). Three of the six reactions were found to be limited by liquid–liquid mixing. These include a phase-transfer-catalyzed Darzen’s reaction, a crystallization, and a highly exothermic condensation reaction. In the Darzen’s reaction the reactant inventory was reduced 99% and the impurity level decreased 93% as compared to the conventional reactor. Crystallization achieved mean crystal size of 3 microns, with a narrow size distribution. The highly exothermic reaction had excellent temperature control. A lab-scale RPB has also been used to investigate reactions that are mass transfer constrained in conventional reactors. Testing a reaction that involves release of a volatile organic as part of molecular weight buildup revealed overall process reaction rates equivalent to conventional reactors in time frames more than two orders of magnitude lower. Here the high surface area and surface renewal capability of the RPB helped to overcome the transfer limitations across the liquid boundary. Similar results were seen on other reaction processes that were constrained by a liquid–surface interaction (62). Reactions can be combined with other unit operations, as in the example of reactive stripping in the production of hypochlorous acid (HOCl). An RPB was
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
used to absorb chlorine gas into an aqueous sodium hydroxide solution (caustic) where reaction to HOCl occurs. Since HOCl is unstable in the presence of the coproduct sodium chloride, stripping of the HOCl into the gas phase is necessary to recover a stable product. The reaction of chlorine with caustic is essentially instantaneous: therefore the process reaction rate is liquid-side mass transfer controlled. Stripping of HOCl, on the other hand, is believed to be gas-side mass transfer controlled. The intense mass transfer capability of the RPB allowed 10% higher yields while using less than half the stripping gas as compared to conventional spray tower operation. This study showed low-surface-area, high-porosity wire screen packing to perform better than glass beads or parallel flat plates. Packing support design and liquid distributor type influenced performance. Operating parameters of importance included rotor speed and the gas–liquid ratio (8). Scale-up issues and performance of the commercial HOCl operation (9) are discussed in Section 6. Fermentation reactions are often limited by oxygen transfer rates. The enhanced mass transfer achieved in centrifugal fields applied to bioreactions should be expected to increase productivity. A centrifugal field bioreactor (CFBR) demonstrated higher productivity in the overproduction of lipase with Staphylococcus carnosus as compared to conventional fermenters (22). Both batch and semibatch fermentation in the CFBR showed no influence on the biological activity of growth or exoprotein synthesis. Lipase productivity rates were proportional to oxygen transfer rates, which were 10 times higher than in shaken cultures. The CFBR process involved feed of air and liquid to the outer diameter of the rotor, with takeoff at the center. Air was dispersed in the liquid by either a sieve drum or a multilayer-sintered screen. The inward radial movement of the gas helped to suspend the bacteria in the culture against the centrifugal force. An external circulation loop for the liquid allowed heat exchange and product analysis. Since many fermentation reactions are characterized by foaming, the CFBR was equipped with a foam breaker—a stator with needles positioned at the inside diameter of the rotor. 5.9.
Other Applications
Centrifugal fields in an electrochemical cell facilitate the removal of gas bubbles from the electrodes, thus reducing the voltage requirement. A rotating chlorine cell showed a drop in voltage from 3.17 V to about 2.8 V at 3-kA/m2 current density when accelerated to 200 g (50). Demonstration of a rotating air cathode provided greater voltage drop at higher current density as compared to a stationary cell (50). Dedusting or demisting in rotating devices provides opportunity to remove small particles at very high throughput. A “mop-fan” built with flexible fibers in a conventional fan housing effectively removes 50% of two-micron particles of slaked lime dust in conjunction with water spray on the rotor. Inline rotary
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
demisters employing reticulated metal foam are used for oil separation from air on turbines (50). 6.
SCALE-UP AND COMMERCIAL USE
Although considerable studies on the use of centrifugal fields in chemical processing have been reported for lab- and pilot-scale operations, little information is public on scale-up criteria for either performance parameters or equipment design. Three examples of commercial use of centrifugal fields are available for review. These include liquid–liquid extraction, water deaeration, and reactive stripping for hypochlorous acid production. Commercial application of centrifugal fields encounters considerable resistance from both the technical and business communities due to both real and perceived risks. The real risks involve reliable mechanical design of rotating equipment, which includes seals, bearings, and rotor stability. Perceived risks on process performance may derive from a lack of understanding of the process fundamentals and how performance may change with the scale of operation. Overcoming the tendency to “use what we know and understand” represents a challenge that goes beyond the effort at technology development. Convincing the technical community to accept the risk of rotating equipment for chemical processing may be easier on applications with clear performance advantages over conventional process equipment. A good example is the liquid–liquid solvent extraction of penicillin (1), in which the low residence time and ability to handle emulsions and solids allowed 98% product recovery. The 10% higher yields and 50% reduction in stripping gas for the HOCl reactive stripping process provides another example of performance advantage (8). In addition to the lower operating costs associated with enhanced performance, the business community is interested in lower capital investment and assurance that the process will reliably perform as designed in terms of product capacity, on-stream time, and product quality. The smaller size of the centrifugal equipment may satisfy the capital investment question. This was the primary driver for implementation of water deaeration in China (7). Lower capital is also a driver for the polymer devolatilization application (47). The question of reliable performance is best addressed through convincing the technical community and leveraging the considerable industry experience with design and manufacture of rotating equipment, such as pumps, compressors, and centrifuges. 6.1.
Scale-Up Criteria
A number of parameters can be considered for scale-up of rotating packed beds, including rotor packing, liquid distribution, flooding, pressure drop, rotor speed, HTU, NTU, temperature, and pressure. Since the same packing material (same
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
porosity and volumetric surface area) is used on scale-up as in the pilot equipment, HTU is expected to scale directly. Results from water deaeration (7) and HOCl production (9) indicate this may be true for liquid-side mass transfer– controlled operations but not for gas-side mass transfer–controlled operations. Flooding of the rotor in gas continuous operations would be expected at the same gas velocities as in the pilot RPB. Flooding normally occurs at the inside diameter of the rotor due to the lower cross-sectional area and higher velocities. However, a check of the porosity of the outer packing support may be necessary to ensure that no flooding occurs. If scale-up of rotor speed is based on constant rotor tangential velocity instead of constant g-force, then the gas velocity at flooding will be lower with larger-diameter rotors. Throughput capability and backpressure control of the light-phase takeoff (24) control flooding in liquid–liquid or gas-dispersed systems. Using a pressure drop model based only on centrifugal acceleration and frictional drag, the HOCl scale-up overpredicted the pressure drop of the commercial RPB by a factor of 2 (9). A more rigorous approach to pressure drop calculation that takes into account the conservation of angular momentum and the inlet and outlet zones of the rotor and housing (40) should provide more predictable scale-up performance. Rotor speed has an impact on mass transfer performance, flooding, and pressure drop. Rotor speed on scale-up can be determined based on maintaining constant tangential velocity (r) or constant acceleration (r2). Rotor speed will be higher for constant-acceleration scale-up. Impact on both process performance and equipment design must be understood in making this determination. Scale-up based on constant acceleration is conservative for mass transfer and flooding performance, while constant tangential velocity is conservative for pressure drop. Liquid distribution may be an important parameter, as demonstrated in the HOCl process, where different liquid distributors provided significantly different results (8). The initial contact of the liquid with the rotor influences the mass transfer performance of the RPB in gas continuous operations (15). Although the use of a packing support at the inside diameter of the rotor would be expected to impact this initial liquid contact with the rotor, experiments did not show any reduced mass transfer performance (36). As mentioned earlier, the same rotor internals used in pilot tests should be used upon scale-up. The rotor dimensions of inner diameter and axial height are determined by maintaining a constant superficial gas velocity at the rotor eye. The radial packing depth, and thus the outer diameter, is based on the number of transfer units required. Adjustments in packing depth and packing type may be necessary to achieve the desired liquid holdup or residence time, e.g., for chemical reaction (26). As with any chemical operation, the physical properties of the fluids, such as density, viscosity, and heat capacity, must be known. If chemical reaction is
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
involved, then the intrinsic kinetics must be understood. Of particular relevance is the influence of mass transfer rates on overall reaction rates. 6.2.
Scale-Up Design
Once the rotor dimensions have been determined along with the operating conditions, attention shifts to the mechanical design of the RPB. The major concern with rotating equipment is maintaining stable operation, i.e., limiting vibration. Excessive vibration results in premature seal and bearing failure, poor process performance, metal fatigue, and increased maintenance costs and downtime. Proper mechanical design principles determine the option of cantilevered or centerhung rotor, the shaft diameter, the type and position of bearings, and seal design. The drive train, whether belt driven or direct coupled, is determined by the power requirements and the shaft orientation. The housing must be sufficient to contain the temperature and pressure of the operation and to provide adequate inlet and outlet nozzles for the process fluids. 6.3.
Commercial Examples
Two commercial examples of rotating packed-bed operation are water deaeration for the Chinese oil fields (7) and HOCl reactive stripping in the United States (9). These two cases illustrate nicely the range of process conditions and design features available for successful scale-up. Water deaeration (Figure 7) uses a direct-coupled drive on a horizontal-shaft centerhung rotor to process a low gasto-liquid operation (3 : 1 vol/vol). The HOCl process (Figure 9) employs a beltdriven, vertical-shaft cantilever rotor to contact a high gas-to-liquid ratio. The water deaeration process employed a staged scale-up program. From the lab operations, a 50 tons/hour (T/h) pilot RPB was built and tested in the oil field. Using natural gas for stripping at a gas/liquid ratio of over 2, the desired oxygen content in the exit liquid of less than 50 ppb was demonstrated. This successful demonstration led to the installation of a full-scale commercial RPB to process 300 T/h. This unit has rotor dimensions of 600-mm ID, 1000-mm OD, and 700-mm AH. The wire screen packing has high porosity (92%) and low surface area (500 m2/m3). The rotor spins at a modest 750 rpm. Performance matched that of the lab and pilot units, achieving a typical 30-ppb oxygen content. Two 250-T/h units have been designed for installation on an oil platform to process seawater, providing advantages in size and weight as compared to conventional technology (7). Figure 9 shows the commercial-scale RPB for the reactive stripping process for HOCl production. Figure 8 provides a visual impression of the process intensification that occurs using RPBs. The three RPBs shown in the lower left of the picture process the same volume of gas and liquid as the tall absorber tower to the right. The scale-up factor from the pilot unit of over 400 : 1 yielded a rotor of slightly less than 2 m in diameter. Performance of product yield from raw materials
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 9 Commercial RPB for HOCl production using the vertical-shaft cantilever design with belt drive. (Photo courtesy of The Dow Chemical Company.)
met or exceeded that of the pilot unit. Pressure drop half of that expected implies the need for better predictive correlations. Due to the higher gas-handling capability and the conservative scale-up design, much higher capacities are anticipated as compared to the design. The liquid-side mass transfer performance as measured by chlorate formation showed performance equivalent to or better than that of the pilot RPB. However, the gas-side mass transfer, as represented by HOCl stripping, showed a doubling of the HTU to about 8 cm. The mechanical reliability after two years of operation indicates no issues due to RPB operation. The RPB is very easy to start up and shut down (9). These two successful commercial applications of rotating packed beds prove that scale-up from pilot-scale equipment can achieve the desired process performance in commercial-scale operations. In addition, the mechanical reliability of the rotating equipment is in line with the experience with other rotating
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
devices. Thus, the risk concerns of performance and reliability can be managed acceptably. Both the technical and business communities can have confidence that future applications will meet expectations of process performance and onstream time. 7.
FUTURE
Extension of the use of centrifugal fields into chemical processing, beyond the physical movement of fluids, has shown limited niche application in the past, in spite of considerable research activity. Specialty application of centrifugal fields to liquid–liquid extraction has enjoyed success for more than 50 years. Advantages stem from operation at low density differences, breaking of emulsions, short contact times, and higher efficiencies as compared to other liquid–liquid extractors. The commercial use of rotating equipment for the broader field of gas– liquid operations has only a five-year history. Numerous examples of possibilities in the areas of absorption, adsorption, stripping, distillation, reactions, crystallization, and other operations have been referenced. The chief objections to the use of centrifugal fields have been associated with the risks of scale-up and the operation of rotating equipment. The two commercial applications of water deaeration and HOCl reactive stripping demonstrate the ability to reliably scale up processes involving a wide range of gas–liquid loadings. Process performance in both cases met or exceeded design criteria, with good operating reliability. Further application will likely require significant cost or performance advantages over more conventional process technology. Considerable commercial experience will be needed before centrifugal fields will enjoy common acceptance among both technical and business interests in the chemical industry. To gain that status, projects must be selected carefully to ensure that advantages are realized over alternative technologies. The most likely opportunities for exploitation will come from mass transfer– limited reactions and the combination of unit operations in one device. Examples of reactions mentioned earlier include polymerization, condensation reactions, crystallization, and heterogeneous catalysis. Combined unit operations are illustrated by reactive distillation, polymer devolatilization with pelletization, and the use of heat exchangers (reboilers and condensers) with distillation. In addition to research on process applications, research to define the fundamental performance characterizations is needed. A number of empirical correlations have been developed for pressure drop, residence time, power, flooding, etc. More generalized theoretical expressions for these parameters that accurately predict performance on a wide range of rotor designs and sizes would be very beneficial to confidently scale-up the technology.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
REFERENCES 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. 7.
8.
9.
10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
15.
16. 17.
18. 19.
20. 21.
Podbielniak WJ, Kaiser HR, Ziegenhorn GJ. Centrifugal solvent extraction. Chem Eng Prog Symp Ser 1970; 66(100):43–50. Podbielniak WJ. U.S. Patent 2,044,996, 1935; U.S. Patent 2,172,222, 1939; U.S. Patent 2,281,796, 1942. Pilo CW, Dahlbeck SW. U.S. Patent 2,941,872, June 21, 1960. Podbielniak WJ. U.S. Patent 3,233,880, Feb. 8, 1966. Todd DB. U.S. Patent 3,486,743, Dec. 30, 1969. Ramshaw C, Mallinson RH. U.S. Patent 4,283,255, Aug. 11, 1981. Zheng C, Guo K, Song Y, Zhou X, Ai D. Industrial practice of Higravitec in water deaeration. In: Semel J, ed. 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. London: BHR Group, 1997:273–287. Trent D, Tirtowidjojo D, Quarderer G. Reactive stripping in a rotating packed bed for the production of hypochlorous acid. In: Green A, ed. 3rd International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. London: BHR Group, 1999:217–231. Trent D, Tirtowidjojo D. Commercial operation of a rotating packed bed (RPB) and other applications of RPB technology. In: Gough M, ed. 4th International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. London: BHR Group, 2001:11–19. Peel J, Howarth CR, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: Higee seawater deaeration. Trans IChemE 1998; 76(Part A):585–592. Barson N, Beyer GH. Characteristics of a Podbielniak centrifugal extractor. Chem Eng Prog 1953; 49(5):243–252. Ding X, Hu X, Ding Y, Wu Y, Li D. A model for the mass transfer coefficient in rotating packed bed. Chem Eng Comm 2000; 178:249–256. Burns JR, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: visual study of liquid maldistribution in rotating packed beds. Chem Engr Sci 51 1996; (8):1347–1352. Basic A, Dudukovic MP. Hydrodynamics and mass transfer in rotating packed beds. In: Heat and Mass Transfer in Porous Media Conference Proceedings, 1992: 651–662. Guo K, Guo F, Feng Y, Chen J, Zheng C, Gardner NC. Synchronous visual and RTD study on liquid flow in rotating packed-bed contactor. Chem Engr Sci 2000; 55: 1699–1706. Sandilya P, Rao DP, Sharma A, Biswas G. Gas-phase mass transfer in a centrifugal contactor. Ind Eng Chem Res 2001; 40:384–392. Munjal S, Dudukovic MP, Ramachandran P. Mass transfer in rotating packed beds— II. Experimental results and comparison with theory and gravity flow. Chem Engr Sci 1989; 44(10):2257–2268. Lin CC, Chen YS, Liu HS. Prediction of liquid holdup in countercurrent-flow rotating packed bed. Trans IChemE 2000; 78(Part A):397–403. Burns JR, Jamil JN, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: operating characteristics of rotating packed beds—determination of liquid hold-up for a high-voidage structured packing. Chem Engr Sci 2000; 55:2401–2415. Ramshaw C. U.S. Patent 4,715,869. Dec. 29, 1987. Peel J, Howarth CR, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: Higee seawater deaeration. Trans IChemE 1998; 76(Part A):585–593.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
22.
23.
24. 25. 26. 27.
28. 29. 30. 31. 32.
33.
34. 35.
36.
37.
38.
39.
Voit H, Gotz F, Mersmann AB. Overproduction of lipase with Staphylococcus carnosus (pLipPS1) under modified gravity in a centrifugal field bioreactor. Chem Eng Technol 1989; 12:364–373. Lee JGM, Howarth CR, Ramshaw CR. Trace effluent removal from large flowrate aqueous phase using a packed rotary extractor. In: Proceedings of Value Adding Solvent Extraction (Pap ISEC ‘96), Melbourne, 1996:1185–1190. Jacobsen FM, Beyer GH. Operating characteristics of a centrifugal extractor. AIChE J 1956; 2(3):283–289. Sherwood TK, Shipley GH, Holloway FAL. Flooding velocities in packed columns. Ind Eng Chem 1938; 30:768. Keyvani M, Gardner NC. Operating characteristics of rotating beds. Chem Engr Prog 1989; 85(9):48–52. Singh SP, Wilson JH, Counce RM, Villiers-Fisher JF, Jennings HL, Lucero AJ, Reed GD, Ashworth RA, Elliott MG. Removal of volatile organic compounds from groundwater using a rotary air stripper. Ind Eng Chem Res 1992; 31:574–580. Lockett MJ. Flooding of rotating structured packing and its application to conventional packed columns. Trans IChemE 1995; 73(Part A):379–384. Kelleher T, Fair JR. Distillation studies in a high-gravity contactor. Ind Eng Chem Res 1996; 35(12):4646–4655. Basic A, Dudukovic MP. Liquid holdup in rotating packed beds: examination of the film flow assumption. AIChE J 1995; 41(2):301–316. Tung H-H, Mah RSH. Modeling liquid mass transfer in Higee separation process. Chem Eng Commun 1985; 39:147–153. Munjal S, Dudukovic MP, Ramachandran P. Mass transfer in rotating packed beds— I. Development of gas–liquid and liquid–solid mass-transfer correlations. Chem Eng Sci 1989; 44(10):2245–2256. Singh SP. Air Stripping of Volatile Organic Compounds from Groundwater: An Evaluation of a Centrifugal Vapor–Liquid Contactor. Ph.D. dissertation, The University of Tennessee, Knoxville, 1989. Rumford F, Rae IJ. Performance characteristics of a centrifugal gas absorber. Trans Instn Chem Engrs 1956; 34:195–203. Zhu J, Feng Y, Zheng C, Gardner N. Modeling of mass transfer in rotating packed beds. Proceedings of First International Workshop on High-Gravity Engineering and Technology, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing, 1996. Guo F, Zhao Y, Cui J, Guo K, Chen J, Zheng C. Effect of inner packing support on liquid controlled mass transfer process in rotating packed beds. In: Gough M, ed. 4th International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. London: BHR Group, 2001:107–113. Hassan-Beck HM, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: mass transfer for countercurrent rotating bed. Proceedings of First International Workshop on High Gravity Engineering and Technology, Beijing University of Chemical Technology, Beijing, Elsevier, 1996. Podbielniak WJ, Ziegenhorn GJ, Kaiser HR. Continuous soap washing and finishing, using multistage, countercurrent, centrifugal contactors. J Am Oil Chem Soc 1957; 34:103–106. Sedahmed GH, Al-Abd MZ, El-Taweel YA, Darwish MA. Liquid–solid mass transfer behavior of rotating screen discs. Chem Eng J 2000; 76:247–252.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
40. 41. 42. 43. 44. 45. 46. 47.
48. 49.
50. 51. 52. 53. 54.
55. 56.
57.
58.
59.
Zheng C, Guo K, Feng Y, Yang C, Gardner NC. Pressure drop of centripetal gas flow through rotating beds. Ind Eng Chem Res 2000; 39:829–834. Liu H-S, Lin C-C, Wu S-C, Hsu H-W. Characteristics of a rotating packed bed. Ind Eng Chem Res 1996; 35:3590–3596. Kelleher T, Fair JR. Distillation studies in a high-gravity contactor. Separations Research Program, University of Texas, Austin, 1993. Kumar MP, Rao DP. Studies on a high-gravity gas–liquid contactor. Ind Eng Chem Res 1990; 29:920–924. Aoune A, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: heat and mass transfer characteristics of liquid films on rotating discs. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 1999; 42:2543–2556. Jachuck RJJ, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: heat transfer characteristics of tailored rotating surfaces. Heat Recovery Systems CHP 1994; 14(5):475–491. Shang D-Y, Anderson HI. Heat transfer in gravity-driven film flow of power-law fluids. Int J Heat Mass Transfer 1999; 42:2085–2099. Cummings CJ, Quarderer G, Tirtowidjojo D. Polymer devolatilization and pelletization in a rotating packed bed. In: Green A, ed. 3rd International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. London: BHR Group, 1999:147–158. Gardner N, Keyvani M, Coskundeniz A. Flue gas desulfurization by rotating beds. U.S. Department of Energy, DOE#DE-FG22-87PC 79924, 1993. Al-Shaban K, Balasundaram V, Howarth CR, Ramshaw C, Peel JRA. The hydrodynamic and mass transfer characteristics of a large centrifugal water deoxygenator. In: Proceedings of Energy Efficiency Process Technology, Process Intensification Conference, Athens, 1993:475–484. Ramshaw C. The opportunities for exploiting centrifugal fields. Heat Recovery Systems CHP 1993; 13(6):493–513. Ramshaw C. Higee distillation—an example of process intensification. Chem Eng 1983; 389:13–14. Fowler R. Higee—a status report. Chem Eng 1989; 456:35–37. Hickman K. U.S. Bureau of Saline Water R&D Progress Report No. 12, Nov. 1956. Bisschops MA, van der Wielen L, Luyben K. Centrifugal adsorption technology for the removal of volatile organic compounds from water. In: Semel J, ed. 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. London: BHR Group, 1997:299–307. Bisschops MAT, Luyben K, van der Wielen L. Hydrodynamics of countercurrent two-phase flow in a centrifugal field. AIChE J 2001; 47(6):1263–1276. Chen J, Wang Y, Jia Z, Zheng C. Synthesis of nanoparticles of CaCO3 in a novel reactor. In: Semel J, ed. 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. London: BHR Group, 1997:157–164. Chen J-F, Wang Y-H, Guo F, Wang X-M, Zheng C. Synthesis of nanoparticles with novel technology: high-gravity reactive precipitation. Ind Eng Chem Res 2000; 39: 948–954. Ramshaw C. Process intensification—incentives and opportunities. In: Doraiswamy LK, Mashelkar RA, eds. Frontiers in Chemical Reaction Engineering. Vol 1. New York: Wiley, 1984:685–697. Oxley P, Brechtelsbauer C, Ricard F, Lewis N, Ramshaw C. Evaluation of spinning disk reactor technology for the manufacture of pharmaceuticals. Ind Eng Chem Res 2000; 39:2175–2182.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
60.
Boodhoo KVK, Jachuck RJ, Ramshaw C. Spinning disc reactor for the intensification of styrene polymerization. In: Semel J, ed. 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice. London: BHR Group, 1997:125–133. 61. Boodhoo KVK, Jachuck RJ, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: spinning disc polymerizer for the manufacture of polystyrene. In: Ramshaw C, ed. 1st International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry. London: BHR Group, 1995:175–180. 62. Winnington TL, Drögemüller P. Speeding up slow processes. 4th International Conference on Process Intensification, Brugge, Belgium, 2001.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
3 The Spinning Disc Reactor C. Ramshaw University of Newcastle upon Tyne, Newcastle upon Tyne, England
1.
INTRODUCTION
When considering the options for intensifying reactions that involve multiple fluids, it is helpful to identify the shortcomings of the conventional equipment that is currently in use. In this context, perhaps the most frequently used item is the stirred vessel fitted with a cooling jacket, shown in Figure 1. A turbine impeller generates a circulation comprising two toroidal vortices, and the turbine torque is normally prevented from driving a free vortex by the use of wall baffles, as shown. If a gas–liquid reaction is involved, then the gas is usually injected directly below the impeller via a suitable sparging arrangement. The popularity of the stirred vessel is due to its perceived simplicity and adaptability, coupled with the fact that it is superficially straightforward to scale-up from the laboratory beaker that was used when the process was being developed. Unfortunately, it suffers from several serious problems, as indicated later. In the normal case of a geometrically similar scale-up, it can be readily shown that the surface area per unit volume varies inversely with the vessel diameter. Thus larger vessels are more difficult to cool, since the heat generated by a reaction in a potential runaway situation is proportional to the vessel volume, whereas the surface area available to dissipate a given heat output is decreased. Vigorous reactions may require the reactor to be “detuned” by operating with more dilute feedstock in order to reduce the full-scale reaction intensity. This
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 1 Stirred vessel showing circulation pattern.
could influence the reaction temperature trajectory and compromise the yield and selectivity. A further unfortunate characteristic of the stirred vessel is that its mixing capability is also a strong function of its size. Scale-up usually proceeds on the basis of a constant impeller tip speed, and since the mean circulation speed in the vortices is broadly proportional to the tip speed chosen, the circulation time is proportional to the vessel diameter. Thus the turnover time of the vessel contents increases at the larger scale and the macro mixing performance deteriorates. These fundamental shortcomings of the stirred vessel have generated a considerable degree of uncertainty when fine chemical or pharmaceutical processes are being developed for full-scale operation. This has led the relevant regulating authorities, e.g., the U.S. Food and Drug Administration, to insist on a process validation at laboratory, pilot, and full scale. Since each validation entails significant administration and delay, the procedure can hold up the implementation of commercial production by several years. Because a new metabolically active molecule will be patented as soon as possible and certainly before clinical trials and process development, this delay significantly erodes the time available under patent cover to recoup a company’s R&D expenditure and make a profit from a potential “blockbuster” drug. 1.1.
The “Desktop” Continuous Process
The predominant culture that prevails for the production of fine chemicals/drugs, with an output of up to (say) 500 tons per year, is to operate batchwise. As already noted, this stems from the fact that the process is almost always developed from a batch-operated beaker or flask. However, it is worth observing that an output of 500 tons/year of active substance corresponds to a continuous process flow rate of around only 70 mL/second. This allows various items of intensified equipment
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
to be assembled and operated continuously literally on a “desktop” to meet the production demand. The decision to switch from batch to continuous processing immediately confers an intensification benefit because the peak batch process loads (e.g., heat output, liquid removal, etc.) are distributed in time, so equipment size can be reduced. Thus with a new process, the laboratory scale becomes the full scale when allowed to run continuously and the scale-up delays described earlier are largely avoided. This strategy is generating considerable industrial interest as the commercial pressure to bring new molecules to market rapidly continues to increase. A further factor that favors continuous “desktop” manufacture is its potential impact on the overall business process of making and marketing fine chemicals. Thus it goes without saying that with very short process residence times, the operation can be much more responsive so that grade changes can be effected in seconds rather than hours. This facilitates just-in-time manufacture, which can lead to dramatic reductions in the capital costs associated with the multiple grades of stock that may be needed rapidly to satisfy demanding customers. 1.2.
Exploitation of Centrifugal Fields
Approximately two-thirds of the unit operations performed in process engineering involve multiphase contact (e.g., distillation, gas/liquid reaction, boiling). In the absence of an imposed acceleration field, the system fluid dynamics are dominated by surface forces so that the interfacial area developed is relatively small, and, with no buoyancy force, there can be no countercurrent interfacial motion. When these conditions prevail, the intensity of the operation is very low, with little if any process performance (e.g., reaction, separation, heat transfer) being exhibited. This scenario leads naturally to the suggestion that a high-acceleration field would stimulate the generation of smaller bubbles, higher flooding velocities, and more intense shear stresses. This “Higee” strategy has been championed over many years because of its profound and beneficial impact upon many important multiphase operations: Absorption Distillation Boiling Condensation Liquid extraction Particle disengagement Heat pumps Etc. One particular embodiment of this approach is the rotating packed bed, which was originally conceived as the “Higee” equivalent of a packed column (1),
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 2 The “Higee” contactor (continuous gas phase).
shown schematically in Figure 2. The equivalent stage height within the toroidal packing is about 1.5 cm for a gas film—limited system, compared with about 60 cm in a conventional packed column. Equivalent flooding velocities may be estimated from the Sherwood plot and can be very high, even for packing with a specific surface area exceeding 1000 m1. Since the Higee duty was originally envisioned as being purely orientated to mass transfer, no specific heat transfer capability was provided. However, the spinning disc reactor (SDR) may be regarded as an alternative to the “Higee” rotor. It can act as a mass transfer/ contacting device (possibly with multiple discs) or as a particularly intense gas–liquid reactor (when fitted with heating/cooling provision). Its attraction lies in the high heat and mass transfer rates that can be stimulated between the disc and the thin liquid film generated on its surface, and between the film and the adjacent gas. The performance and applications of the SDR are considered in detail later. As might be expected, the enhanced acceleration field is established on a permanent basis within a rotor that receives and discharges the working fluid. The alternative approach, which relies upon a permanent vortex field, i.e., a cyclone,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
will not be considered here, primarily because the fluid residence time within a vortex cannot be easily controlled independent of the desired acceleration. At this juncture it is helpful to consider the basic physics of motion in a rotating system. 1.3.
Free Motion of a Particle Around an Axis
Consider the free (frictionless) motion of a particle P of mass m rotating around a fixed axis O on a smooth surface, as shown in Figure 3. The particle is constrained to move in a circular trajectory by a light string that exerts an inward tension T and generates a corresponding acceleration. This can be estimated as follows: In time t, P moves along an arc that subtends an angle to the axis. The angular velocity of P is given by d兾dt and its speed is v r, where r is the length of the string. During the time t the change of velocity of P is v v sin () and as → 0, v is directed along the radius toward O. The acceleration is dv v sin ( d ) v as → 0 dt dt Hence, acceleration r2 and the string tension needed to maintain this is T m2r
FIGURE 3 The free motion of a particle around an axis.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 4 Spiral trajectory as a particle moves toward the center of rotation.
If the string is broken, then the acceleration ceases and the particle leaves its circular trajectory and continues along a tangent at a velocity v. If the string is slowly shortened then: 1. The particle moves toward O in a spiral trajectory involving many turns. 2. Work must be done in order to overcome the string tension T. For the proposed frictionless system, this work input results in an increase in the particle’s kinetic energy. Conversely, if the string were lengthened, the particle’s velocity would decrease. Figure 4 shows the spiral trajectory of the particle and the corresponding velocity diagram. The radial and tangential velocity components are dr兾dt, v, respectively, giving a resultant VR that is a tangent to the spiral trajectory. Noting that dr兾dt << v, the angle between v and VR is , where tan (dr兾dt)兾v. As the particle moves inward towards O, the component of T along the spiral trajectory is responsible for increasing its speed. Hence, with an inward tension deemed to be negative we have: m
dv v 2 dr 1 T sin m ⋅ ⋅ dt r dt v
(as → 0)
or dv dr v ⋅ dt dt r
(1)
This confirms that v increases for an inward spiral trajectory (i.e., when dr兾dt is negative). From Eq. (1) we have dv dr v r and integration from v1r1 to v2r2 gives
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
ln
v2 r1 ln v1 r2
i.e., v2 r2 v1r1
(2)
This is an important result because it shows that in a frictionless or free situation, angular momentum is conserved. The same conclusion can be reached from energy considerations, noting that the work done by the string tension as r is reduced is equal to the gain in particle kinetic energy, i.e., T dr m
v2 v2 dr d m mv dv r 2
Hence v dr dv r leading again to Eq. (2). The practical consequence of Eq. (2) for rotational fluid flow can be quite dramatic, as demonstrated by the high wind speeds that may be generated near the center of free vortex flows—e.g., tornadoes and typhoons. 1.4.
Flow Over a Rotating Surface
If we now consider the behavior of a liquid film on a rotating disc, the motion is no longer “free,” because the film is influenced by the disc via the shear force generated at the solid/liquid interface. Liquid supplied to the inner region of the disc is first brought up to the disc’s rotational velocity by the tangential shear force and then moves radially outward, to be discharged from the disc periphery. In a stationary frame of reference, the liquid trajectory is therefore a spiral with arms separated by a radial distance given by 2 dr ⋅ dt In a rotating frame of reference (i.e., that of an observer anchored to the disc), the trajectory is nearly radial. Since this reference frame is most relevant when we consider the disc/fluid interaction, it is helpful to evaluate the flow on this basis. We shall assume that frictionless flow occurs through a closed radial channel that is fixed to the rotating disc. Thus as the fluid moves outward, the only
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
interaction with the disc/channel is via a tangential force. In a time dt, the change per unit mass in the fluid angular momentum as it moves a distance dr is dM d (rr ) 2r dr
(3)
Note that since the fluid is forced to rotate at the disc speed, is constant. The change in angular momentum given by Eq. (3) is brought about by the torque generated by a tangential force F exerted on the fluid at the radius r by the radial channel and acting for a time dt. Since dM Fr dt, the tangential acceleration imposed by the channel on the fluid as it moves radially is F 1 dM dr 2 m r dt dt
(4)
This is the Coriolis acceleration, which is imposed on particles moving in a rotating reference frame—e.g., liquids on a rotating surface or winds in the earth’s atmosphere. The resultant acceleration experienced by a particle is a combination of the radial and tangential components, making an angle to the radius, where tan 2
dr 2 2 r dt v
dr dt
In general dr << v dt and the unconstrained flow will be largely radial. This can be readily confirmed during the operation of a spinning disc reactor or a rotating packed bed, because any deposits from the fluid flow lie close to the radius vector. 2.
THE SPINNING DISC REACTOR
As pointed out earlier, a spinning disc, or more generally a rotating surface of revolution, is an alternative to the “Higee” rotating packed bed. It is particularly effective when high heat fluxes or viscous liquids are involved. The object is to generate a highly sheared liquid film when a liquid is supplied to the unit at or near its center. The film is initially accelerated tangentially by the shear stresses established at the disc/liquid surface. This causes the liquid to approach the disc’s angular velocity and then move outward as a thinning/diverging film under the prevailing centrifugal acceleration. The phenomenon was studied in detail by Woods (2), who photographed the behavior of a fully wetting dilute film of ink as
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
it traveled over a spinning glass disc. Care was taken to supply the liquid from a central axisymmetric distributor in a particularly uniform manner. After calibration, the local film thickness was inferred from the density of the photographic image at that point. Even when great care was taken to ensure that the liquid feed was introduced to the disc in an axisymmetric manner with the minimum disturbance, the smooth inner film always broke down into an array of spiral ripples, as shown in Figures 5 and 6. These spiral structures then broke down further until the wave pattern became utterly chaotic, provided that the disc was big enough. It is known that liquid film flow over a surface is intrinsically unstable, and the phenomenon has been studied by several workers (3–7). It appears to be qualitatively equivalent to the breakdown of a smoke plume rising from a lighted cigarette, where a chaotic zone is generated about 20 cm above the source. The behavior can also be observed when a liquid film flows over a stationary surface such as a windowpane or a dam spillway. Woods concluded that two types of wave existed: nearly two-dimensional (2D) and three-dimensional (3D). The amplitude of the two-dimensional spiral waves grew rapidly, and therefore a theory based on the assumption of small amplitude is not valid across the whole disc. A transition from 2D to 3D waves occurred once their amplitude reached about three to four times the local film mean thickness. Higher liquid flow rates stimulated a more rapid breakup of the wavelets. Only about 1% increase in liquid surface area was ascribed to the presence of waves. Thus any improvement in mass/heat transfer performance generated by the waves is due to the additional shear they induce. It will be appreciated that even in the absence of ripples, highly sheared thin liquid films, such as those that can be readily generated on a spinning surface, provide an ideal fluid dynamic environment for the rapid transmission of heat, matter, and momentum. This is due to the short diffusion path length involved for transfer between the adjacent gas phase to the liquid film and thence to the disc surface. These characteristics of a spinning disc (or more generally a rotating surface of revolution) make it ideal for performing any intrinsically rapid physical or chemical transformation in a liquid, even if it is viscous. Typical examples include polymerization, precipitations, and rapid exothermic organic reactions. Some of these are described in more detail later. 2.1.
The Nusselt-Flow Model
While the fluid dynamics of the actual film-flow process across the disc is dauntingly complex, a very approximate interim flow model may be based upon Nusselt’s treatment of the flow of a condensate film. This assumes that the flow is stable (i.e., ripple free), that there is no circumferential slip at the disc/liquid surface, and that there is no shear at the gas/liquid interface. The treatment is based
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 5 Liquid film behavior on a rotating disc, with Q 19 cm3/s and
(a) 100, (b) 200, (c) 300, (d) 400, (e) 500, (f) 600 rpm.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 5 (cont.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 5 (cont.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 6 Local liquid film behavior on a rotating disc, with (a) Q 19 cm3/s,
100 rpm; (b) Q 19 cm3/s, 200 rpm; (c) Q 13 cm3/s, 400 rpm; (d) Q 19 cm3/s, 500 rpm; (e) Q 19 cm3/s, 600 rpm; (f) Q 19 cm3/s,
600 rpm.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 6 (cont.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 6 (cont.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 7 (a) Sketch of a liquid film on a rotating disc. (b) Detail of a liquid film on a rotating disc.
on the schematic representation given in Figure 7. Part b represents the local film at a radius r. The shear stress on the annular plane at a distance y from the disc provides the radial acceleration for the fluid lying between y y and y s. Thus a force balance on the film lying between r r and r r dr, with zero shear stress at the gas–liquid interface, gives
2 r ( s y)
du dy
(5)
The boundary conditions are: 1. u 0 at y 0 since there is no fluid slip at the disc/liquid interface. 2. du兾dy 0 at y s since there is no shear stress at the gas/liquid interface.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Hence
2 r y2 sy 2
u
(6)
The average film velocity is given by Uav
1 s
s
∫0
u dy
w 2 rs 2 3
The maximum film velocity (at y s) is Umax
w 2 rs 2 1.5 Uav 2
(7)
Referring to Figure 7a, the liquid is supplied to the disc at a radius ri and a mass flow rate M. It is deemed to instantaneously acquire and maintain the disc angular velocity as it moves over the disc to be discharged at its periphery. At a radius r the mass flow rate is given by M Uav s2r
(8)
Eliminating Uav from Eqs. (7) and (8) gives 3M s 2 w 2 2
1/ 3
r −2 / 3
(9)
Inserting Eq. (9) into Eq. (8) gives Uav
w 2 r 3M 3 2 r 2 w 2 2
M 2w2 12 2
2/3
1/ 3
r −1/ 3
(10)
Hence the average time required for the liquid to travel from ri to ro is
∫
t
R0
Ri
dr 3 12 2 Uo 4 M 2 2
1/ 3
(ro
4/3
ri4 / 3
)
(11)
If we consider a typical example of water flowing over a disc under the following conditions: M 3 102 kg/s
103 N-s/m 2
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
10 3 kg/m 3
ri 5 102 m
ro 0.25 m
100 s1 (955 rpm)
then from Eq. (11) the average liquid transit time on the disc is 0.25 s, and from Eq. (9) the film thickness at the disc edge (provided that the film does not break up into rivulets) is 28 microns. A more viscous liquid, such as a polymer (say, 10 N-s/m2), would have a thickness at the disc periphery of 600 microns and a transit time of about 5 seconds. As already noted, the foregoing calculations must be regarded as a guide only, since the films are intrinsically unstable, with waves being amplified as the liquid proceeds to the edge of the disc. It will be appreciated that this process proceeds more rapidly with relatively inviscid liquids. 2.1.1.
Mass Transfer
A conservative estimate of the disc’s mass transfer performance may be obtained from the Nusselt model, assuming that there is no film mixing as it proceeds to the edge of the disc. For unsteady diffusion into a finite stagnant slab, the plot shown in Figure 8 from (8) gives the relative concentration distribution within the slab at various times, with a zero initial concentration and a surface concentration C0 imposed at time t 0. The parameter on the curves is the Fourier number, Fo, where Fo
Dte s2
(12)
and D solute diffusivity within the film te exposure time of the film surface s film thickness As can be seen from Figure 8, if Fo 0.02, the concentration changes within the film are confined largely to the surface layer and the local mass transfer coefficient is given by the Higbie penetration theory (9) as D kL te
1/ 2
(13)
For the previous example of a polymer flowing over the disc, a typical Fourier number may be calculated from: D ⬇ 109 m 2 /s te ⬇ 5 s s ⬇ 6 104 m
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 8 Concentration distribution at various times in a slab x for zero initial concentration and surface concentration C0.
Thus Fo 0.014. Equation (7) shows that the film surface velocity is given by 9 M 2 2 Umax 1.5 Uav ⋅ 2 32
1/ 3
r −1/ 3
Hence from Eq. (11), 32 2 te 2 2 9 M
1/ 3
(
3 4/3 r r14 / 3 4
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
)
(14)
Inserting this into Eq. (13) gives D kL
1/ 2
2 M 2 2 2 3
1/ 6
(r
1 4/3
r14 / 3
(15)
)
1/ 2
However, it must be noted that as the film flows over the disc, the film thickness progressively decreases, provided the liquid fully wets the disc. As this occurs, the concentration profiles normal to the disc plane are compressed, thereby causing a proportionate enhancement of the solute diffusion rate beyond that predicted by penetration theory. Thus the local value of kL can be corrected to account approximately for the steepened concentration gradients by multiplying by a factor s1兾s, where s1 is the film thickness at a radius r1 as given by Eq. (9). The corrected local value of kL is then D kL
1/ 2
2 M 2 2 2 3
1/ 6
r r1
2/3
(r
1 4/3
r14 / 3
)
1/ 2
(16)
At the point of film formation, where r r1, Eq. (16) shows that kL . However, the average value of kL over the disc surface is given by k Lav
1 2
r2 r12
(
)∫
r2
2 k L r dr
(17)
r1
This requires numerical integration. As pointed out at the outset, these estimates of the mass transfer performance are likely to be conservative as the disturbance of the film by ripples has been neglected. This will reduce the exposure time significantly, particularly with inviscid liquids. 2.1.2.
Heat Transfer
The Nusselt model was originally developed to correlate the performance of vapor condensers. In this case, the latent heat of condensation is discharged at the gas–liquid interface and subsequently conducted through the draining condensate film, the conduction path length being the local film thickness. When a liquid film is heated or cooled on a spinning disc, the conduction path length is less (about 50% of the thickness) because all of the sensible heat does not have to be conducted through the entire film. Since the thermal diffusivity of most liquids is typically of the order of 107 m2/s, compared with a mass diffusivity of around 109 m2/s, the Fourier numbers involved in the heat transfer version of Figure 8 are approximately 100 times their mass transfer equivalent. This implies that the heat transfer process involves the whole liquid film rather than merely
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
a thin layer near the disc surface. The Higbie model for heat transfer is therefore inappropriate. For the larger Fourier numbers involved in the heat transfer it is reasonable to represent the film temperature profile approximately by a quadratic expression: T A By Cy 2
(18)
A, B, and C are constants determined by these boundary conditions: 1. T Tw at y 0 2. T Ts at y s 3. dT兾dy 0 at y s It can be shown that y y2 T Tw 2(Tw Ts ) (Tw Ts ) 2 s s
(19)
dT 2(Tw Ts ) dy s
(20)
and y − 1 s
Since the film temperature gradient perpendicular to the disc will be much greater than that in the radial direction, the local heat flux (Q) into the film will be controlled by the value of dT兾dy at the disc surface. Hence dT 2k Q k (Tw Ts ) s dy y 0 Thus the effective film coefficient is h
Q 2k s Tw Ts
(21)
For our earlier example with water on a 0.5-m-diameter disc, Eq. (21) implies that the heat transfer film coefficient at the periphery is 43 kW/m2k, with the predicted film thickness of 28 microns. For this estimate to be realistic it is essential that the film wet the disc and not break up into rivulets. This depends upon a force balance at an incipient “dry-out point,” as indicated in Figure 9. At the film stagnation point the film momentum is potentially destroyed by the action of the component of the surface forces parallel to the disc. Thus for an average film velocity Uav we must satisfy the following condition for rivulet maintenance: 2 T (1 cos ) Uav s
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 9 Schematic showing liquid film “dry-out” on a rotating disc.
where T is the surface tension per unit length, is the contact angle, is the liquid density, and s is the local film thickness. Coherent films are less likely as they become thinner and their velocity decreases. An inspection of Eqs. (9) and (10) reveals that U 2av s is proportional to 2/3M5/3. Hence the tendency to form rivulets is less at higher disc speeds and liquid flow rates and increases with large T and small . 2.1.3.
Film-Flow Instability
The existence of the wave structure within the film is of major practical interest, as was highlighted by some elegant experimental work conducted by Brauner and Maron (7). They monitored the instantaneous local film thickness of a liquid flowing down a stationary inclined plane using a capacitance technique.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Simultaneously the local mass transfer coefficient was measured between the disc and the liquid, using the limiting electrolytic current method. Their plots are reproduced in Figure 10. It was clear that the passage of a ripple was associated with a significant enhancement of the mass transfer coefficient, as a consequence of the flow field associated with ripple propagation. An analogous phenomenon may be observed when sand particles are disturbed by wavelets in shallow seaside pools. While the phenomenon has considerable theoretical interest, its immediate practical implication is very important because it suggests that the disc heat and mass transfer performance could be enhanced still further by appropriately engineering the disc surface profile. Some experimental results are discussed next.
FIGURE 10 Simultaneous time traces of local instantaneous film thickness and transfer rate.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2.2.
Heat/Mass Transfer Performance
An early application of the SDR to heat transfer duty was developed by Hickman (10), who was interested in the desalination of brackish water using a vapour compression evaporator. A sketch of his initial arrangement is shown in Figure 11, where brackish water flowing on one side of a rotating disc assembly was evaporated by condensing steam on the other. The very high overall heat transfer coefficients that could be achieved (up to 45 kW/m2K) ensured that the pressure ratio demanded from the vapor compressor was minimal, thereby establishing very efficient operation. In a further development of the idea (11), a series of disc assemblies was mounted on one vertical shaft that was enclosed within a tower, as shown in Figure 12. It is significant that Hickman did not report any problems associated with the deposition of crystal scale, even though his experimental runs lasted for several hundreds of hours. Radial rather than spiral stains were, however, exhibited, which suggested that the influence of the Coriolis acceleration was minimal. Since the temperature difference between the condensate and the evaporating brackish water was only 1–2C, it is presumed that the equivalent supersaturation was insufficient to cause significant crystal nucleation. The ability of the spinning disc to operate with very small driving temperature and concentration differences can improve the thermodynamic efficiency of the overall process system. This is clearly the case with the Hickman vapor compression evaporator, and it is also exemplified in the applications described next. In general, the power needed to rotate the spinning disc assembly is a small fraction of that saved by virtue of the establishment of an intensified fluid dynamic environment. 2.2.1.
The Rotating Electrolytic Cell
A laboratory-scale rotating chlor-alkali membrane cell was constructed and tested some years ago in ICI. The electrodes comprised closely spaced catalyzed discs that were separated by a Nafion membrane. The anolyte and catholyte concentrations corresponded to those in the brine and sodium hydroxide solutions used in the standard (FM21) industrial version of the membrane cell. As can be seen from Figure 13 (taken from Ref. 12), while the industrial cell voltage at a current density of 3 kA/m2 was 3.17 V, that of the rotating unit was a function of the applied acceleration, falling to about 2.75 V at 100 “g.” At a higher current density, the benefits of enhanced acceleration were even more marked. It will be recognized that the enhanced buoyancy forces generated by the high acceleration can eliminate the polarization effects associated with bubbles that adhere to the electrodes/ membranes or remain in the electrolytes. In principle a compact rotor comprising a bipolar cell assembly of closely spaced discs is capable of an exceptionally high chlorine production rate while operating at exceedingly competitive voltage.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 11 Schematic of the single-element Hickman still.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 12 (a) Schematic of the multiple-disc Hickman still. (b) Full-scale Hickman still.
2.2.2.
The “Rotex” Absorption Heat Pump
The main factor that has been responsible for the slow adoption of absorption heat pumps for heating and air conditioning duties has been their high capital cost compared with that of vapor compression equivalents. This is due largely to the cycle complexity, as shown in Figure 14, which displays the four principal cycle elements, all of which involve vapor–liquid systems: 1. 2. 3. 4.
Condenser Evaporator Generator/boiler Absorber
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 12 (cont.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 13 Voltage characteristics of a rotating chlorine cell.
The only single-phase item involved is the solution heat exchanger, which is intensified by the use of laminar flow in a matrix of fine channels. A sketch of the single-effect Rotex (13) design is shown in Figure 15, where it can be seen that a hermetically sealed rotating disc assembly fulfills the four functions listed. The working fluid consists of a water solution of either mixed alkali metal hydroxides or lithium bromide. The evaporator receives low-grade heat from the circulating ambient air and vaporizes the refrigerant at low pressure, the vapor being promptly absorbed at the absorber disc immediately opposite. Working fluid from the absorber sump, now rich in refrigerant, is returned to the generator via a solution pump and a solution heat exchanger. The latter consists of a matrix of closely spaced metal foil, which, as discussed earlier, gives very efficient heat transfer in a small volume. The heat of condensation and absorption is removed from the condenser/ absorber disc assembly by circulating water that enters and leaves via a mechanical seal. The working fluid is pumped around the cycle by a pitot tube assembly, with the tubes dipping into a peripheral liquid trough. Since the Rotex machine operates with a horizontal axis, the pitot tube arm is counterweighted to resist the frictional torque exerted by the trough. Information recently released (14) shows that the double effect air conditioning version of Rotex has achieved a coefficient of performance of 1.0 at a temperature lift of 35C using lithium bromide solution. This unit is about to enter field trials. Its high performance is entirely due to the intensity of the heat and mass transfer environment generated on the liquid film flowing over the discs. It is also worth noting that Alfa Laval has developed a process evaporator for fruit juice and milk concentration using a nested stack of cones. Figure 16
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
shows the arrangement, in which steam is caused to condense outside the cones while the process fluid is concentrated on the film flowing on the inside surface. In this context it may be observed that the disc and the cone are specific examples of the general case of a rotating surface of revolution. The acceleration causing the outward movement of the liquid film is the resolved component of 2r along the surface in question. Koerfer (15) performed an interesting study with a series of perforated and smooth rotating discs 600 mm in diameter at speeds up to 600 rpm. The mass transfer performance was measured using the oxygen/water system, with the results shown in Figure 17. Very good performance was recorded with the perforated discs, and this was attributed partly to the short exposure time of the film as it negotiated each perforation and partly to the extra film area created. Interestingly, the film behavior was much more predictable when it flowed over the disc surface containing the raised lips arising from the punching operation. Film flow on the alternate side tended to “leak” through the disc, particularly at lower liquid flows, presumably due to the Coanda effect as liquid negotiated the rounded edge of the holes. As part of a general development to use spinning discs in an intensified absorption heat pump, Aoune and Ramshaw (16) measured both the local and average heat transfer performance on smooth rotating surfaces. The disc surface
FIGURE 14 Single-effect absorption heat pump cycle.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
temperature was estimated by extrapolating the values given by the digitized output from thermocouples embedded at depths of 1 mm and 9 mm in a brass disc. The local film temperature was measured by a thermistor contained in a stylus that could be traversed over the disc surface. Using water, the heat transfer coefficient on the 50-cm-diameter disc regularly exhibited a minimum value at a radius of about 17 cm. On the other hand, with the use of a water/60% monopropylene glycol mixture, no minimum was observed and the absolute performance was much poorer than that obtained with water. This behavior is attributed to the tangential fluid slip generated as the feed liquid is brought up to the rotor’s angular velocity. This slip appears to be more marked with low-viscosity liquids, which seems intuitively reasonable.
FIGURE 15 (a) Rotex design concept. (b) Rotex prototype.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 15 (cont.)
Mass transfer studies were then performed, based upon the aeration of liquid that had been previously stripped. The local liquid oxygen concentration was established by carefully abstracting a film sample via a quill that could be traversed over the disc. An Orbisphere oxygen analyzer was used. Rather poor agreement was obtained between the experimental results for water (kL 4 → 10 m/s 104) and the Higbie predictions (approx 1 m/s 104) based upon total exposure time of liquid on the disc. Clearly, liquid mixing within the film generates exposure times that are much shorter than the liquid residence time on the disc. Another study, by Jachuck and Ramshaw (17), explored the influence of surface profile upon the heat transfer performance of a spinning disc. Using a smooth disc as a benchmark it was shown that disc surfaces disrupted with metal powder or grooves gave a significantly improved performance—presumably due to the better film mixing. The best performance at modest disc speeds was obtained with “undercut” grooves (Figure 18), which were originally conceived as a technique for improving the circumferential distribution of any radial rivulets. At higher disc speeds, the film radial velocity was such that liquid was projected off the disc, thereby compromising the heat transfer process.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 16 Alfa Laval concentrator.
2.3. 2.3.1.
Reactor Applications Strategic Considerations
At the most basic level, the SDR is an extremely effective gas–liquid contacting device. This makes it ideal for performing many intensified heat or mass transfer operations and, as will be discussed later, it may be deployed as an evaporator or an aerator/desorber. However, its principal application in the process industry is likely to be as a very high-performance reactor. Since the reactor is the heart of
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 17 Mass transfer performance of a rotating disc (O2/H2O system).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 18
Types of disc grooves tested.
any process, the SDR can radically improve the economics and efficiency of many key processes, both in the commodity and in the fine chemical area. In order to exert full control over the progress of a chemical reaction or physical transformation, the fluid dynamic environment must be sufficiently intense so as to ensure that the mixing and heat transfer rates are faster than the intrinsic chemical kinetics. This concept is shown diagrammatically in Figure 19, which illustrates the progress of a reaction represented simply as A B → C, with the reactants A, B traveling in plug flow along a tubular reactor. When the interdiffusion of A, B is slow compared with the reaction rate, then C is produced near the original plane of A兾B separation. This represents a total loss of control on two counts: 1. The A兾B stoichiometric ratio varies wildly across the reactor diameter. Therefore the selectivity for the desired product C is likely to be compromised because a more realistic reaction scheme will usually include many side reactions.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2. Most of the reaction to C occurs in the immediate neighborhood of the plane of A–B separation. Thus only a small fraction of the available reactor volume is utilized and an opportunity for intensification is lost. On the other hand, when mixing is fast, the A兾B ratio is uniform and control over the product spectrum can be maintained. All the reactor space is used to maximum effect. Since the intrinsic kinetics are allowed free rein, the reactor is able to operate at the maximum intensity permitted by the specific chemical system. While it should be self-evident that a rational reactor design demands a knowledge of both the fluid dynamic environment and the detailed process kinetics, the latter are rarely available. In many instances this leads to the severe limitation of many important reactions by an inadequate fluid dynamic intensity. Some of these are known to be fast, e.g., liquid-phase nitrations, while others are (incorrectly) assumed to be slow, e.g., most polymerizations. In these circumstances the pragmatic approach is to use a high-intensity reactor for each system and then to assess the impact upon the space–time productivity. Obviously, an intrinsically slow system is resistant to further acceleration and this will rapidly become evident. One significant qualification of this contention involves the very
FIGURE 19 The influence of mixing and reaction rates on reactor behavior.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
short residence time in the SDR compared with its conventional counterparts. In certain reactions the process temperature is restricted to one that avoids product breakdown in the time available. Since the residence time in the SDR when performing a polymerization reaction is up to 10 seconds rather than the several hours involved in a conventional stirred vessel, we must re-examine the process’s temperature trajectory. A higher operating temperature may well be acceptable because the undesired breakdown components may not have time to be generated. However, the higher temperature will reduce the liquid viscosity and accelerate the reaction. The lower viscosity will reduce the residence time still further. Therefore the SDR can exploit a process operating envelope that is much larger than what is accessible to conventional technology. With regard to the processing of viscous liquids, by far the most important application relates to the manufacture of polymers. The key processes are: 1. 2. 3.
Condensation reactions Radical reactions Devolatilization
The progress of a condensation reaction is controlled by an equilibrium with a volatile product, which, if continuously removed, drives the reaction forward. Unfortunately, as polymerization proceeds, the liquid viscosity increases, rendering the removal of the volatile component much more difficult. The batch stirred vessel, which is conventionally used for polymer manufacture, has a limited ability to remove a volatile component from the increasingly viscous polymer melt. On the other hand, the SDR can maintain effective mass transfer and, as will be shown in Section 2.3.2, can achieve in one pass (taking several seconds) the same increment in polymerization as would conventionally require tens of minutes. The SDR with one or more discs on the same shaft is therefore capable of performing polycondensation extremely rapidly. The short residence time also facilitates rapid changes of product grade with minimum wastage. The rate of a polymerization that proceeds via a series of radical reactions is controlled by the micromixing environment within the polymer melt. Once again the stirred vessel is a poor means to achieve the high desired intensity, whereas the SDR has an impressive capability in this respect. It is well known that UV radiation is a very effective means of radical generation, and this technique has been proposed in the past for stimulating certain radical polymerizations. However, the radiation extinction distance in a polymer melt is only a few millimeters, so a polymerization reactor comprising a stirred vessel having a diameter of several meters is not a rational option. On the other hand, the thin polymer films that can be created and maintained on the SDR allow all of the polymer to receive a continuous, uniformly high radiation dose and thereby maintain a very high reaction intensity, as described later for the manufacture of butyl acrylate.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 20 Schematic of an SDR styrene polymerizer.
The industrial manufacture of polymers is rarely taken to completion, and this requires unreacted monomer to be removed from the product—when its viscosity is highest. This devolatilization procedure is notoriously difficult because it usually involves the vacuum stripping of a stirred vessel’s contents for many hours. Just as the SDR promotes the removal of the volatile component of a condensation reaction, it is also effective in dramatically accelerating the devolatilization process. 2.3.2.
Polymerization
Polystyrene. The manufacture of polystyrene from various grades of prepolymer has been performed (18,19) on a 36-cm brass SDR using the arrangement shown in Figure 20. A series of concentric grooves was machined in the disc surface in order to improve liquid mixing within the film. The reaction operates via free radicals, which were initiated in this case using benzoyl peroxide. In the first instance a series of batch runs was performed in a conventional laboratory-scale stirred vessel in order to produce a calibration curve (Figure 21) of conversion
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 21 Free-radical polymerization of styrene.
versus time. This vessel was then used to produce about 200 mL of prepolymer at a range of conversions that was supplied to the inner spinning disc surface over a period of about 30 seconds. The SDR was heated from below by a stationary radiant ring, and the polymer produced was collected in a cooled annular trough surrounding the disc. The styrene was diluted with about 16% w/w toluene in order to reduce the viscosity. Figure 21 also shows the increment in polymer conversion in one pass over the disc as a function of the initial conversion in the preliminary batch. It can be seen that the equivalent batch time that can be ascribed to one pass on the disc increases (up to 58 minutes) as the initial conversion increases to 63%. This implies that the benefits of the SDR become more marked as the polymer viscosity increases. It is envisaged that the process can be scaled up either by using a larger disc or by mounting several discs on one shaft. The latter approach (i.e., several discs in series) does, however, involve the problem of transferring polymer from the peripheral collection trough to the center of the next disc. An alternative may be to operate discs on one shaft in parallel. For the experiments just described, the feed rate was roughly 5–10 mL/s, which is equivalent to an output of up to 250 tons/year on a continuous basis, though at this early stage this should not be considered the ultimate limitation.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The fundamental reasons for the high performance of the SDR are still a matter for debate. The significance of micromixing and the consequent improved probability of radical interaction has already been mentioned. However, another factor is expected to be the divergent character of the flow on the disc. This may be expected to align the polymer molecules and thereby encourage the juxtaposition of the reactive groups. Polycondensation. The reaction between maleic anhydride and ethylene glycol has been studied as an example of polycondensation (19). Since the reaction proceeds on an equilibrium basis, in order to drive it to completion the water produced must be eliminated from the increasingly viscous polymer melt. The grooved brass 36-cm disc described earlier for the polystyrene experiments was used at a temperature of 200C and a disc speed of 1000 rpm. As before, the experimental procedure involved the establishment of a benchmark batch calibration against which the subsequent disc runs could be compared. A typical acid number plot versus batch time is presented in Figure 22. As the acid number decreases, the conversion to polymer increases. The water of reaction was removed from the polymer film by maintaining a large nitrogen purge to the vapor space. This technique, rather than the application of a vacuum, was the preferred method for reducing the water vapor partial pressure. It can be seen that the increment in polymerization following one pass in the SDR corresponds to many minutes of reaction in the small batch reactor used as a reference. This is particularly encouraging because the mass transfer intensity in the laboratory stirred reactor is likely to be much greater than its industrial-scale
FIGURE 22 Time savings in the SDR for polyestirification.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
equivalent, and it therefore provides a demanding benchmark for the spinning disc performance. 2.3.3.
Fine Chemical Manufacture
The intense heat and mass transfer environment that can be established within the liquid film flowing over the disc allows high selectivities and conversions to be achieved when fast liquid-phase reactions are performed. Very encouraging results were achieved in an industrial study of a phase-transfer-catalyzed (p-t-c) Darzen’s reaction to produce a drug intermediate (20). In comparison with the currently used batch processes, the ptc reaction on the SDR had a 99.9% reduced reaction time, a 99% reduced inventory, and a 93% reduced impurity level. A more recent study has involved a 20-cm-diameter SDR with a catalytically activated surface to perform the rearrangement of -pinene oxide to campholenic aldehyde (21), which is an important intermediate used in the fragrance industry. The comparative performance of the batch reactor and the SDR is shown in Table 1. For equivalent conversion and selectivity, the unoptimized SDR gave a much higher throughput than the equivalent batch reactor and avoided the need to separate a catalyst slurry from the product. Figure 23 shows the variation of selectivity as a function of disc speed and feed flow rate; Figure 24 gives the conversion levels achieved. While conversion falls from 100% at the higher flows and speeds, presumably due to the reduced liquid residence time on the disc, the selectivity increases. Thus it might be expected that a larger disc (or a sequence of small discs) could combine high conversion and high selectivity. The batch reactor performance is summarized in Figure 25, where it can be seen that 100% conversion requires 5 minutes ( 1 second on the disc) and a maximum selectivity of 65% is reached. 2.3.4.
Precipitation/Crystallization
The operation of crystallizers and precipitators is critically dependent upon the supersaturation environment prevailing within the crystal magma because this influences both the nucleation of new particles and the growth of those that TABLE 1 Comparison of the Best SDR Runs with Batch Results for Conversion of -Pinene Oxide to Campholenic Aldehyde Batch process Process time (s) Processed feed Conversion (%) Selectivity (%) Note
300 1.2 kg/h 100 64 Catalyst separated from the product mixture
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
SDR (continuous) 1 209 kg/h 100 62 No loss of catalyst
FIGURE 23 Selectivity towards campholenic aldehyde at 85C at various feed rates.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 24 Conversion of -pinene oxide at 85C and various disc speeds.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 25 Batch reaction: conversion and selectivity towards campholenic aldehyde.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
already exist. In general, the growth rate has a first-order dependence on supersaturation for diffusion-limited systems and 1.5- to second-order where the surface integration resistance is significant (22). On the other hand, the nucleation rate, whether primary or secondary, has a higher-order dependence on supersaturation, typically in the range 2–9 (23), with the lower values being obtained mainly with low-molecular-weight solutes. Hence it will be recognized that high supersaturation can be readily achieved on SDRs. This feature makes them attractive for producing very small or nanosized particles, which are currently of intense industrial interest. Supersaturation can be generated in several ways. Perhaps the simplest technique is merely to cool a solution saturated at a higher temperature. Alternatively, supersaturation can be created by removing the solvent or adding an antisolvent for systems where the solubility is only a weak function of temperature. Finally, supersaturation can be created by reaction—between either two liquids or a liquid and a gas. In all these cases the intense environment created within an initially crystal-free liquid film moving in plug flow over the disc can generate very high supersaturation and consequently small and fairly uniform crystals. This characteristic of the SDR may be attractive in several industries (e.g., pharmaceuticals and coatings), where the product quality is intimately related to the fineness of the crystals and the tightness of the size distribution. The concept has recently been tested (24) in a spinning cone precipitator (Figure 26), which shares most of the characteristics of a spinning disc except that the centrifugal acceleration vector is not aligned to the cone surface. Barium sulfate was generated by mixing equimolar solutions of BaCl2 and Na2SO4 in a central reservoir. A thin liquid/slurry film flowed to the cone rim, from where it was collected and subsequently analyzed in a Malvern Mastersizer. Equivalent batch experiments were performed, for the purpose of comparison, in a 50-mL agitated beaker. At a supersaturation of 500, defined as Molar concentration of Na 2 SO 4 or BaCl 2 Molar solubility of BaSO4 the cone produced crystals at 6000 rpm that had a Sauter mean diameter of 3.2 microns, compared to 6.85 microns from the batch runs. However, at a supersaturation of 5000, the batch yielded a Sauter mean diameter of 0.75 microns, compared with 0.18–0.32 microns from the disc. The particle size distributions reproduced in Figure 27 highlight the cone behavior at 8000 rpm more starkly, with a decided shift to 0.1–1 microns, compared with 1–10 microns in the batch. Thus it can be seen that for many systems, spinning precipitators hold out the prospect of generating the crystal size distributions that have considerable industrial interest. This view is further reinforced by some earlier work by SmithKline Beecham (20), which crystallized an unnamed product (API) on a
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 26 Spinning cone reactor layout.
15-cm spinning disc. Figure 28, reproduced from their work, compares the product size distribution from the SDR with that of the standard industrial material. Crystallization was induced by adding an antisolvent, and it can be seen that a very significant impact could be made on the normal product size distribution, which was smaller and narrower on the disc. The stainless steel disc was subject to crystal scaling after a few runs. However, a thin layer of PTFE suppressed this without significantly impairing the disc’s heat transfer performance. 2.4.
Comparative Spinning Disc Reactor Costs
It should be borne in mind that the SDR is most effectively exploited when it is run on a continuous basis. The industrial units constructed to date have had disc diameters up to 30 cm and have been capable of processing around 30 g/s of feedstock. This corresponds to a continuous annual output of (e.g., polymer) 1000 tons/year. For a typical pharmaceutical product, a 15-cm disc could process about 7 g/s, equivalent to an annual output of 200 tons. With conventional stirred-vessel technology, a roughly equivalent unit to the 30-cm SDR is a 2000-L batch reactor
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 27 BaSO4 size distribution for a supersaturation of 5000.
fabricated in 316 stainless steel, complete with computer control and a service unit delivering a disc temperature in the range 20C–150C. The cost of such a reactor is estimated to be £250,000 with a range of £200–£400K. Comparative SDR costs have been supplied by the most experienced manufacturers (Triton Chemical Systems Ltd), which has been collaborating closely with Newcastle University during the last 5 years of SDR development. 2.4.1.
Spinning Disc Reactor Layout/Specification
The SDR system is available as a “desktop” or a “floor-standing” unit. The latter is easier to use at pressure and is more versatile for use with ancillaries such as feed units. The desktop system is restricted to the core system shown within the circle in Figure 29, which is a schematic representation of the floor standing arrangement. Experience has shown that SDR design and manufacturing details are very important in ensuring that the unit operates satisfactorily over its full performance range. Thus care must be taken with respect to the feed arrangements to ensure that instantaneous stoichiometric ratios are held constant and that feed liquids are mixed exceedingly rapidly on the disc. A sophisticated feed system is provided to ensure that the delivery of two liquid feeds is accurate. If this level of complexity is not required, then there may be a significant cost saving. As shown in Figure 29, feed liquids are supplied by means of two ram injectors accurately driven by precision step motors. Product is drained from the disc casing into a
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
lower receiving vessel, which can be isolated during SDR operation. This allows product removal without interfering with the progress of the reaction. Specifications for all systems include: a. Constructed with 316L stainless steel contact parts for the reactor (other materials are available). b. Constructed with a vessel to take 3-atm pressure or vacuum (other pressures available). Vessel has twin-wall construction to allow heating or cooling of the jacket. c. Supplied complete with: i. Temperature measurements at the disc. ii. Electronics and interfaces for: 1. Up to 8 measurements of temperature. 2. Up to 8 measurements of pressure etc. iii. An advanced computer control and data-logging system. The main variables on a specific spinning disc reactor are: d. The material of construction. e. The range of ambient conditions under which the reaction take place (temperature and pressure). f. The range of disc speeds available. g. The degree of instrumentation required.
FIGURE 28 Recrystallization of an API: comparison of size distributions.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2.4.2.
Prices
These prices are for the spinning disc reactor as just defined in points a to c, including advanced control and data-logging software with computer and flat screen. The following ancillaries are usually necessary for the system, and these may exist, or Triton can recommend units or can supply them integrated into the system. a. Feed systems b. Heat transfer fluid system(s) for the disc/vessel/feeders c. Reaction atmosphere control systems, e.g., pressure/vacuum/gas feed Example prices are given in Table 2. As can be seen from the table, the cost of the SDR system is significantly less than that for a stirred vessel with a similar productive capacity. However, cost considerations are likely to be much less significant than the competitive edge that SDR technology is likely to bring in terms of improved selectivity and product quality.
FIGURE 29 Schematic of the SDR manufactured by Triton.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
TABLE 2 Spinning Disc Reactor Costs M/C type Type K-01
Type P-01
Description
Small benchtop system, speeds from 100 to 2000 rpm, suitable for disc temperature to 100C 15-cm disc £40,000 30-cm disc £60,000 Free-standing system, speeds from 200 to 4000 rpm, suitable for disc temperatures to 100C 15-cm disc £75,000 30-cm disc £90,000 70-cm disc £120,000 Options
For either system, typical options are: a. Heat/cool system, to provide cooling at the walls to 20C and heating/cooling at the disc for 5C to 120C b. Injector system, 2000-mL capacity, with twin walls to allow heating cooling; feed rates from 0.07 to 7 mL/s; fast down, with index and control system c. Stirrers for the injectors d. Cooled deflector ring system e. Receivers, for operation up to 10 bar 1L 2L 4L f. Additional instrumentation Measurement of heat transfer fluid flow rate Measurement of temperature difference across disc Added temperature measurements (per channel) Added pressure measurement (per channel)
3.
Price
Price £17,500 £5,000
£1,000 £1,400 £980 £1,400 £1,960 £1,400 £400 £100 £400
CONCLUSION
It will be apparent from the examples cited that centrifugal fields in general, and rotating surfaces in particular, can exert a profound influence upon process engineering. Our experience at Newcastle University has repeatedly demonstrated that the greatest gains are achieved when the SDR is presented with the most severe process conditions. While our original target was simply to reduce equipment size and installed cost, it rapidly became apparent that reduced size alone would be insufficiently persuasive for the acceptance and adoption of SDR technology. However, it has now been demonstrated that in addition to yielding
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
a better product (i.e., tighter size/molecular weight distributions, improved purity, etc.), the SDR can transform the whole business process. As with any radical step, the main obstacle to its implementation is the normal human resistance to change. In order to overcome this it is vital that chemists who are developing new processes be as fully conversant with SDRs as with their beakers and flasks. There is therefore a latent market for miniature versions of this equipment throughout the world’s industrial and teaching laboratories. Once the cultural block is overcome and company decisionmakers fully appreciate the breadth of impact in prospect, then the process industry will be fully prepared to meet the challenges of the new century. REFERENCES 1. 2. 3.
4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10. 11. 12. 13. 14.
15.
Mallinson R, Ramshaw C. European Patent No. 2568B, 1969. Woods WP. The hydrodynamics of thin liquid films flowing over a rotating disc. Ph.D. dissertation, Newcastle University, Newcastle, U.K., 1995. Thomas S, Faghri A, Hankey W. Experimental analysis and flow visualization of a thin liquid on a stationary and rotating disc. Trans Asme—J Fluids Eng 1991; 113 (March):73–80. Wasden FK, Dukler AE. A numerical study of mass transfer in free-falling wavy films. AIChE 1990; 36(9):1379–1390. Oron A, Davies SH, Bankoff SG. Long-scale evolution of thin liquid films. Rev Modern Physics 1997; 69(3):931–980. Brauner N, Maron DM, Dukler AE. Modeling of wavy flow in inclined thin films in the presence of interfacial shear. Chem Eng Sci 1985; 40(6):923–937. Brauner N, Maron DM. Characteristics of inclined thin films, waviness and the associated mass transfer. Int J Heat Mass Trans 1982; 25(1):99–110. Carslaw HS, Jaeger JC. Conduction of Heat in Solids. 2d ed. Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1959:101. Higbie R. The rate of absorption of pure gas into a still liquid during short periods of exposure. Trans Am Inst Chem Eng 1935; 31:365. Saline Water Conversion Report for 1959. U.S. Dept. of Interior Office of Saline Water, 1959:40. Saline Water Conversion Report for 1957. U.S. Dept. of Interior Office of Saline Water, 1957:7. Ramshaw C. The opportunities for exploiting centrifugal fields. Heat Recovery Systems CHP 1993; 13(6):493–513. Ramshaw C, Winnington TL. An intensified absorption heat pump. Proc Inst Refrig 1988; 85:26–39. Gilchrist K, Lorton R, Green RJ. Process intensification applied to aqueous Li B rotating absorption chiller with dry heat rejection. 7th UK National Conference on Heat Transfer, Nottingham, U.K., Sept. 10–12, 2001. Koerfer M. Hydrodynamics and mass transfer of thin liquid films flowing on rotating perforated discs. Departmental Report, Chemical Engineering Department, Newcastle University, Newcastle, UK, 1986.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
16. 17. 18.
19.
20. 21.
22. 23. 24.
Aoune A, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: heat and mass transfer characteristics of liquid films on rotating discs. Int J Heat Mass Trans 1999; 42:2543–2556. Jachuck RJJ, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: heat transfer characteristics of tailored rotating surfaces. Heat Recovery Systems CHP 1994; 14(5):475–491. Boodhoo KVK, Jachuck RJJ, Ramshaw C. Process intensification: spinning disc polymerizer for the manufacture of polystyrene. In: Ramshaw C, ed. 1st International Conference on Process Intensification in the Chemical Industry, Antwerp, Dec. 1995. Boodhoo KVK, Jachuck RJJ, Ramshaw C. Spinning disc reactor for the intensification of styrene polymerisation. In: Semel J, ed. 2nd International Conference on Process Intensification in Practice, Antwerp, Oct. 1997. Oxley P et al. Evaluation of spinning disc reactor technology for the manufacture of pharmaceuticals. IEC Res 2000; 39(7):2175–2182. Vicevic M, Jachuck RJ, Scott K. Process intensification for green chemistry: rearrangement of -pinene oxide using a catalyzed spinning disc reactor. 4th International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry, Brugge, Belgium, Sept. 10, 2001. Mullins JW, ed. Crystallization. 2d ed. Butterworths, London, 1972:162. Mullins JW, ed. Crystallization. 2d ed. Butterworths, London, 1972:162. Hetherington P, Scalley MJ, Jachuck RJ. Process intensification: continuous production of barium sulphate using a spinning cone precipitator. 4th International Conference on Process Intensification for the Chemical Industry, Brugge, Belgium, Sept. 10, 2001.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
4 Compact Multifunctional Heat Exchangers: A Pathway to Process Intensification B. Thonon and P. Tochon Greth, CEA–Grenoble, Grenoble, France
1.
INTRODUCTION
In the first part of this paper, the different technologies of compact heat exchangers are presented and their range of application is given. The second part presents the state of the art for heat transfer and fluid flow characteristics for single-phase, evaporation, condensation, and heat and mass transfer. The last part presents applications of compact multifunctional heat exchangers. As proposed by Shah and Mueller (1), heat exchangers may be characterized by the compactness factor, in m2/m3, and it is generally admitted that values greater than 700 m2/m3 characterize compact heat exchangers. Often, compact heat exchangers also refer to nontubular heat exchangers, even if shell-and-tube heat exchangers can have high compactness factors. For the heat exchanger considered, the hydraulic diameter ranges from less than 1 mm to 10 mm. There are mainly two types of compact heat exchangers: the plate type (primary surface heat exchanger) and the plate–fin type (secondary surface heat exchanger). These two types of heat exchangers are described and new technologies are presented. In the process industry, there are only four basic operations: reaction, separation, mixing, and heat transfer. The traditional unit operation is to perform each task in one or more pieces of equipment sequentially, for example, heat transfer in heat exchangers and reaction in reactors. Combining two or more tasks in one piece
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
of equipment is implemented only for control or enhancement purposes; one example is cooling in a jacketed stirred-tank reactor. But this is not an intensified process, because it requires a batch operation, which has poor efficiency, and the reaction cannot be controlled effectively. Examples of multifunctional heat exchangers are: Multistream heat exchanger (heat transfer between more than two fluids) Reactor heat exchanger (reaction and heat transfer) Reflux condenser (heat transfer and separation) This chapter presents the state of the art in compact heat exchanger technology and provides heat transfer and mass transfer characteristics of these devices and their use in the process industry. Heat transfer is commonly required in the process industry for heating, cooling, vaporizing, or condensing. In most cases, only two streams (one hot and one cold) are in thermal contact within the heat exchanger. The most commonly used heat exchanger is the shell-and-tube heat exchanger, which has poor heat transfer performance and requires a significant volume and ground area. Compact heat exchangers and enhancement technologies allow reducing the heat exchanger volume, to increase its effectiveness and to reduce capital and operating costs. Compact heat exchanger technologies are sufficiently advanced, but their use and acceptance in the process industry are not yet widespread. Reasons are the lack of awareness of their benefits and the absence of reliable design methods and investigations under actual operating conditions. Compact heat exchangers include plate heat exchangers as well as plate–fin heat exchangers, which are characterized by hydraulic diameters between 1 and 10 mm. But recent developments in manufacturing techniques, such as printed circuit heat exchangers and diffusion-bonded and superplastic-formed heat exchangers, allow reaching hydraulic diameters below 1 mm. These heat exchangers offer compactness greater than 1000 m2/m3 and are suitable for industrial processes. Rapid advances in range of design and operational reliability have made compact heat exchangers attractive for many applications in various industries. Their high performance has already made their use widespread in the automotive, aerospace, air conditioning, refrigeration, and electrical equipment industries for single-phase and phase-change duties. In the automotive industry, plate-type heat exchangers are used as heaters, evaporators, and condensers (2), and since the 1970s, the volume/heat capacity ratio has been divided by a factor of 2 (Figures 1 and 2). This improvement has been achieved because of a radical change in heat exchanger technology and by the adoption of mass production systems integrating innovative technologies. Compact heat exchangers produced individually are generally more expensive than a conventional shell-and-tube unit, and their payback time will be longer. But taking space, weight, and convenience into account compact heat exchangers can be used cost effectively in a wider range of applications than the niches currently being used in the process industry (3).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 1 Progress in evaporator technology. (From Ref. 2.)
2. 2.1.
COMPACT HEAT EXCHANGER TECHNOLOGY Classification of Compact Heat Exchangers
Heat exchangers can be classified in many different ways, such as according to transfer processes, number of fluids, surface compactness, flow arrangements, heat transfer mechanisms, type of fluids (gas–gas, gas–liquid, liquid–liquid, gas– two-phase, liquid–two-phase, etc.), and industry. Heat exchangers can also be classified according to the construction type and process function (Figure 3). Refer
FIGURE 2 Progress in condenser technology. (From Ref. 2.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 3 Classification of heat exchangers.
to Shah and Mueller (1) for further details. In the follo1wing sections, only nontubular heat exchangers will be described. 2.2.
Plate Heat Exchangers
Plate heat exchangers (PHEs) were formerly used for milk pasteurization and gradually became the standard choice for heat treatment in the liquid-food industry. Actually, pasteurization must be considered a biological reaction, because the native composition of the liquid is denatured during the heat transfer process. In practice this denaturation leads to fouling. The facility of dismantling plate heat exchangers is one of the main reasons for their extensive use in the food industry. Furthermore, because the heat transfer coefficients are high, the fluid path length will be shorter and relatively well defined. Due to the lack of large dead areas in the channels, the corresponding residence time distribution is short and homogeneous. Eventually, with the development of larger plates, their use began to grow quickly in the chemical, petrochemical, district heating, and power industries, but essentially for single-phase duties. The concept of phase change in PHEs originated in the 1970s for ocean thermal-energy conversion (OTEC) applications; the working fluids were Freon R22 or ammonia (4). These first studies on evaporation and condensation have been used for the development of PHEs in the refrigeration
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
industry (5–10). Now PHEs have come to be used more often in the process industry (11–12), but their use is still not widespread. In terms of technology, PHEs are made from corrugated plates (Figure 4) that are pressed together. The plate size ranges from 0.02 m2 to over 3 m2 with conventional pressing technology (Figure 5), but can reach up to 15 m2 for explosionformed plates (Figure 6). The hydraulic diameter lies between 2 and 10 mm for most common plates, but free passages and wide gap plates exist for viscous fluid applications. Typically, the number of plates is between 10 and 100, which gives 5–50 channels per fluid. Furthermore, the use of high-quality metal and manufacturing techniques makes lead plate heat exchangers less prone to corrosion failure than shell-and-tube units (13). To ensure tightness, three technologies are available: gaskets, semiwelded or totally welded, and brazing. The gasketed PHE is the most common type, with the gasket material selected as a function of the application (temperature, fluid nature, etc.). Temperatures up to 200C and pressure up to 25 bars can be achieved by such heat exchangers. For applications where gaskets are undesirable (high pressure and temperature or very corrosive fluids), semiwelded or totally welded heat exchangers are available (Figure 7). The last variant is the brazedplate heat exchanger. The plate pattern is similar to conventional gasketed units, but tightness is obtained by brazing the pack of plates. For common applications copper brazing is used, but for ammonia units nickel brazing is possible. This technology leads to inexpensive units, but the plate size is generally limited to less than 0.1 m2. The drawback is that the heat exchanger cannot be opened, and fouling will limit the range of application.
FIGURE 4 Plate heat exchanger. (Courtesy of Alfa-Laval Vicarb.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 5 Corrugated plates. (Courtesy of Alfa-Laval Vicarb.)
2.3.
Spiral Heat Exchangers
The spiral heat exchanger consists of two metal sheets that are welded together and then rolled to obtain spiral passages. The passages can be either smooth or corrugated; in some cases, studs or spacers are introduced between the metal sheets. These devices have two functions: (1) to adjust the spacing and (2) to induce turbulence and increase heat transfer. The general flow configuration can be crossflow (single or multipass) or counterflow, depending on the configuration of the inlet and outlet distribution boxes. The heat transfer surface ranges from 0.05 m2 for refrigeration applications (Figure 8) to 500 m2 for industrial processes (Figure 9). Spiral heat exchangers are often used for phase-change applications, because the geometry of the hot and cold stream channels can be adapted to the process specifications. Recent developments in manufacturing technologies (laser welding) have allowed the manufacture of cost-effective recuperators based on the spiral concept (Figure 10) or the folded-plate recuperator (14–15).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
2.4.
Plate-and-Shell Heat Exchangers
The basic principle of these heat exchangers is to insert a bundle of plates in a shell (Figure 11). On the plate side, the fluid flows inside corrugated or embossed channels (more often in two passes). On the shell side, the flow is similar to shelland-tube heat exchangers, and baffles can be inserted. This technology can be used for revamping an application, because the shell can be kept identical to that for a bundle of tubes. These heat exchangers are often used in the process industry as boilers (boiling on the shell side) because high pressures can be reached very easily on the shell side. Furthermore, a large gap on the shell side allows the use of dirty services, because cleaning is possible via removal of the bundle of plates. 2.5.
Plate–Fin Heat Exchangers
Aluminium plate–fin heat exchangers (PFHEs) were initially developed in the 1940s to provide the aerospace industry compact, light, and highly efficient heat exchangers for gas/gas applications. Because the mechanical characteristics of aluminum are increased at low temperatures, this technology has been used since 1950 for the liquefaction of natural gases. Nowadays, aluminum plate– fin heat exchangers are extensively used in applications such as air separation, hydrocarbon separation, and industrial and natural gas liquefaction (16). The plate–fin heat exchanger offers process integration possibilities (12 simultaneous
FIGURE 6 Explosion-formed plate. (Courtesy of Packinox.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 7 Various welded plate heat exchangers.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 8 Spiral heat exchanger for the refrigeration industry. (Courtesy of Spirec.)
different streams and more in one single heat exchanger) and high efficiency under close temperature approach (1–2C) in a large variety of geometric configurations. The brazed plate–fin exchanger consists of stacked corrugated sheets (fins) separated by flat plates, forming passages that are closed by bars, with openings for the fluid inlet and outlet (Figures 12 and 13).
FIGURE 9 Spiral heat exchanger for the process industry. (Courtesy of Kapp.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 10 Laser welding of a spiral recuperator. (Courtesy of ACTE.)
In its simplest form, a heat exchanger may consist of two passages, with the cooling fluid in one passage and the warming fluid in the other. The flow direction of each of the fluids relative to one another may be countercurrent, cocurrent, or crossflow. The fins and the parting sheets are assembled by fusion of a brazing alloy to the surface of the parting sheets. The brazing operation happens in a vacuum furnace in which the brazing alloy is heated to its point of fusion. All parts in
FIGURE 11 Shell plate heat exchangers. (Courtesy of ACM and Barriquand.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 12 Components of a brazed aluminum plate–fin heat exchanger. (From Ref. 12.)
contact are bonded by capillary action (Figure 14). Once the brazing alloy has solidified, the assembly becomes one single block. All passages for flow distribution and heat transfer of the streams are contained in the internal geometry of the block. Inlet and outlet headers with nozzles for the streams are fitted, by welding, around the openings of the brazed passages. These nozzles are used for connecting the heat exchanger to existing plant pipework. Numerous fin corrugations have been developed, each with its own special characteristics (Figure 15). Straight fins and straight perforated fins act like parallel tubes with a rectangular cross section. Convective heat exchange occurs due to the friction of the fluid in contact with the surface of the fin. The channels of serrated fins are discontinuous, and the walls of the fins are offset. For air flows,
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 13 Plate–fin heat exchangers. (Courtesy of Nordon Cryogénie.)
louver fins are extensively used; for process applications (single- and two-phase), continuous or offset strip fins are used. For higher-temperature applications or when aluminum is not acceptable, stainless steel (temperatures up to 700C) or copper materials can be used. For very high temperatures (gas turbine heat recovery; T 1200C), a ceramic plate–fin heat exchanger has also been developed (17) (Figure 16). For high-pressure applications in the hydrocarbon and chemical processing industries, a titanium compact heat exchanger has been developed by RollsLaval. This heat exchanger consists of diffusion-bonded channels that are created by superplastic forming of titanium plates (18). This heat exchanger can handle high pressure and corrosive fluids and is suitable for marine applications. 2.6.
Flat Tube-and-Fin Heat Exchangers
The concept of flat tube and fins in heat exchangers has been developed in the automobile industry for engine cooling and air conditioning (19–21). In such applications one of the two fluids is air and the other is either water or a refrigerant. The nonequilibrium of the heat capacities of the two fluids leads to the adoption of different enhancement technologies for both fluids. Generally on the air side the surface is finned (plain or louver fins), and on the other side the fluid flows in small-diameter channels (Figures 17 and 18). The technology is based on
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 14 Stainless steel brazed plate–fin heat exchanger. (Courtesy of Nordon.)
assembling aluminum elements, by either mechanical expansion or brazing. For conventional applications, the pressure can be up to 20 bars. Recently, heat exchangers with operating pressures up 140 bar have been manufactured (22) for car air conditioning systems, using carbon dioxide as refrigerant. 2.7.
Microchannel Heat Exchangers
Microchannel heat exchangers are compact heat exchangers where the channel size is around or lower than 1 mm. Such heat exchangers have been developed for severe environments, such as offshore platforms (23). New applications are also arising for high-temperature nuclear reactors (24). To manufacture such small channels, several technologies are available (25): chemical etching, micromachining, electrodischarge machining, etc. The most common one is the printed circuit heat exchanger developed by the Heatric Company. The channels are manufactured by chemically etching into
FIGURE 15 Different fin geometries.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 16 Ceramic recuperator. (Courtesy of Céramiques et Composites.)
a flat plate. The plates are stacked together and diffusion bonded. These heat exchangers can support pressures up to 500–1000 bar and temperatures up to 900C (not simultaneously with high pressure). The typical size of the channels is 1.0 2.0 mm, and the plate size can be up to 1.2 0.6 m (Figure 19). The processing technique is as flexible as for plate–fin heat exchangers, and crossflow
FIGURE 17 Condenser. (Courtesy of Livernois.)
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 18 Extruded aluminum minitube.
and counterflow configurations are employed. The main limitation of the microchannel heat exchanger is the pressure drop, which is roughly inversely proportional to the channel diameter. For high-pressure applications, the pressure drop is not a constraint; but for other fields of application it will be the main barrier to the use of such heat exchangers. More recently, Chart-Marston has developed the Marbon heat exchanger (26). This heat exchanger is made of stainless steel plates stacked and bonded together (Figure 20). Several configurations are possible: (1) shell and tube, and (2) plate–fin. The use of such a heat exchanger as a chemical reactor is under consideration, and the thermal and hydraulic characterization has been undertaken as Europeanfunded project (27). Very compact heat exchangers are also used for cooling electronic devices or microreactors (Figure 21). In these heat exchangers the channel size ranges from 50 m to 1 mm. Single phase and boiling are encountered in such applications (28). Applications in the chemical processing industries are also foreseen (29). These units can be very small in size and the heat duty per unit volume is very high, up to15 kW/cm3. 2.8.
Matrix Heat Exchangers
Perforated, or matrix, heat exchangers are highly compact and consist of a stack of perforated plates made of high-thermal-conductivity material, such as copper or aluminum, alternating with spacers of low thermal conductivity, such as plastic or stainless steel. The pack of alternate low- and high-thermal-conductivity
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 19 Printed circuit heat exchanger. (Courtesy of Heatric.)
plates are bonded together to form leakproof passageways between the streams (Figure 22). The main bonding technique adopted is diffusion bonding; more information can be found in Ref. 30. Such heat exchangers have been developed for cryogenic and lowtemperature applications (31) and for fuels cells (32). They are suitable for a large range of operating conditions, but there is very little information on their thermal and hydraulic behavior. Furthermore, as the heat is transferred by conduction in the plate, the temperature distribution is not homogeneous. 2.9.
Selection of Heat Exchanger Technology
The selection of the technology of compact heat exchangers depends on the operating conditions, such as pressure, flow rates, and temperature, as well as on other parameters, such as fouling, corrosion, compactness, weight, maintenance, and reliability. Table 1 summarizes the major limits for the different types of compact heat exchangers.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 20 Marbond heat exchanger. (Courtesy of Marston.)
3. 3.1.
SINGLE-PHASE FLOW Flow Pattern
For corrugated heat exchangers, the flow is almost three-dimensional, and the velocity field is difficult to measure. Flow visualization (33–34), realized in a high-scale channel, clearly shows a recirculation area downstream of the corrugation edges (Figure 23). These areas are large at low Reynolds number (left of picture). But the transition to turbulent flow (Figure 24), which occurs at Re 200, reduces the size of these areas. Local information (35–38) on the heat
FIGURE 21 Microchannel heat exchangers.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 22 Matrix heat exchanger.
transfer and velocity fields indicates that the heat transfer coefficients are linked to the flow pattern and to the mixing intensity in the channel; variations of 50% were measured. Furthermore, the size of the recirculation areas could be limited by a proper design or by choosing appropriate operating conditions. The work of Amblard (39) and Hugonnot (34) has shown that choosing the appropriate corrugation angle, and with the Reynolds number above a critical value, a quasi–plug flow can be obtained. This indicates that corrugated heat exchangers could be suitable for chemical reactions. The angle of corrugation has some influence on the global flow pattern. If we consider the entire channel as a two-dimensional medium, the flow behavior can be studied. At this scale the flow can be considered homogeneous if there is the same flow rate through the channel width. Thonon et al. (37) have shown that for low aspect ratio and low corrugation angle ( 30), there is flow inhomogeneity, up to 15% of the flow rate distribution. But at high corrugation angle or for higher aspect ratio (Ar 2), the flow is almost homogeneous. In plate–fin heat exchangers, the flow structure depends on the fin geometry. Continuous fins can be assimilated to rectangular channels and the flow is almost identical to pipe flows. For offset strip fins or louvered fins, there is a high degree of mixing (40), and the flow becomes turbulent even at low Reynolds number (Figure 25). 3.2.
Heat Transfer and Pressure Drop
For corrugated heat exchangers, extensive information is available in the literature (37–42); these studies have shown that the major geometric parameter is the
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
corrugation angle. The enhancement of heat transfer, compared to a smooth channel, is up to six times greater. But at the same time, the pressure drop can be increased by a factor of 100. Other geometric parameters are also influential, and manufacturers are continuously improving the plate’s design. For plate–fin heat exchangers in single-phase flow, the heat transfer coefficients are related to the developed heat transfer surface, and the area ratio must be taken into account. As related to the projected surface, the overall heat transfer coefficient is very high. Heat transfer and pressure drop can be estimated from correlations (43–44), but these correlations give only an estimate of the performance, because local modification of the fin geometry will affect heat transfer and pressure drop. For microchannel heat exchangers there is a large discrepancy between various experimental reports (45). Recent studies (46) have shown that down to TABLE 1 Operating Conditions of Compact Heat Exchangers
Technology Aluminum plate–fin heat exchanger Stainless steel plate–fin heat exchanger Ceramic plate–fin heat exchanger Diffusion-bonded heat exchanger Spiral heat exchangers Matrix heat exchangers Flat tube-and-fin heat exchanger Brazed-plate heat exchanger Welded-plate heat exchanger Plate-and-shell heat exchanger Gasketed-plate heat exchanger Graphite-plate heat exchanger Plastic-plate heat exchanger
Maximal pressure (bars)
Maximal temperature (C)
80–120
70–200
10
No
80
650
2
No
4
1300
2
No
500–1000
800–1000
2
No
30 1000 200
400 800 200
2 2 2
Yes No No
30
200
2
No
30–40
300–400
2
Yes/no
30–40
300–400
2
Yes/no
20–25
160–200
2
Yes
7
180
2
Yes
5
200–250
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Number of streams Fouling
2
Yes/no
FIGURE 23 Flow structure in a corrugated channel: laminar flow (Re 150).
0.5 mm, there is no significant deviation, compared to large tube correlations, but the size of the channels has to be accurately measured. More work is still needed to fully understand heat transfer and fluid flow in submicronic channels. 3.3.
Fouling
The design of heat exchangers under foulant conditions results in oversizing, thus substantially raising the cost of plants. Fouling is also responsible for process inefficiencies, due to increased thermal resistance. In water-cooling applications, particulate and precipitation fouling are frequently responsible for the decrease in heat transfer performance. Hence, the thermal and hydraulic performances need to be well understood if the heat exchange capability of practical equipment needs to be accurately predicted.
FIGURE 24 Flow structure in a corrugated channel: turbulent flow (Re 5000).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 25 Flow structure in plate–fin heat exchangers.
Plate heat exchangers are frequently used in industrial processes because they are more compact and have higher thermal performance than conventional shell-and-tube heat exchangers, and it is generally admitted that plate heat exchangers are less prone to fouling than conventional shell-and-tube heat exchangers due to the higher level of the shear stress. Measured fouling resistances (47–50) clearly indicate that fouling resistance values are about 10 times lower in corrugated channels than on a plain surface and that the geometry (Figures 26 and 27) and the fluid velocity (Figure 28) are the major influential parameters. For instance, it has been shown that the fouling resistance is almost inversely proportional to square of the fluid velocity. This implies that the fluid velocity has to be controlled properly while operating plate heat exchangers.
FIGURE 26 View of the deposit (30 corrugation angle at a velocity of 0.5 m/s).
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 27 View of the deposit (60 corrugation angle at a velocity of 0.5 m/s).
While sizing plate heat exchangers, the great sensitivity of fouling to the fluid velocity and channel geometry precludes the use of a single value for the fouling resistance. If the TEMA fouling resistance values are applied to plate heat exchangers, excess heat transfer surface will be required, which can lead to poor efficiency. It is often recommended that the fouling margin not exceed 25% of the
FIGURE 28 Void fraction in a corrugated heat exchanger.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
extra heat transfer surface. Furthermore, the inverse velocity dependence of the fouling resistance needs to be taken into account at the design stage. If the extra surface required for fouling is provided by adding plates, a maximum heat duty is reached; but adding more plates will finally reduce the heat duty. In design procedures, this needs to be taken into account. In the case of severe particulate fouling conditions, 60 corrugation angle plates should be selected rather than lower corrugation angles, and a minimum fluid velocity of 0.3 m/s is suggested. 4. 4.1.
PHASE-CHANGE HEAT TRANSFER Two-Phase Flow Characteristics
During vaporization or condensation, thermal and hydraulic performances depend essentially on the two-phase flow structure. Furthermore, as very often in industrial processes, the heat exchanger operates in thermosyphon or under natural circulation; knowledge of the pressure drop and liquid holdup is of major importance. But there is very little information on two-phase flow characteristics in compact geometries. Carey (51) has studied pressure drop and void fraction in different types of compact heat exchangers and has outlined the differences with plain tube geometries. Kreissig and Muller-Steinhagen (52) and Margat et al. (53) have shown that the principles of the methods developed for plain tubes can be used but need to be adapted. The main results of these studies are that the liquid holdup is significantly affected by the mass flow rate (Figure 28); the liquid holdup is underestimated by conventional correlation; the two-phase flow multiplier can be estimated from a Chisholm-type correlation. Winkelmann et al. (54) have studied air–water flows in a corrugated heat exchanger. Flow visualization and two-phase pressure drop measurements have been performed. The flow visualizations have shown that the flow pattern is complex and that a wavy or a film flow occurs in most cases (Figure 29). The two-phase pressure drop depends on the total flow rate and vapor quality, and Chisholm-type correlation is proposed. More work is required to characterize the flow structure in compact heat exchangers and to develop predictive methods for the frictional pressure drop and the mean void fraction. 4.2.
Vaporization
Vaporization is the most common unit operation to be found in the process industry; the use of compact heat exchangers as evaporators began 40 years ago for the concentration of sugar or salt solutions. Nowadays, compact heat exchangers are used in several industrial processes, and this is particularly true for plate–fin heat exchangers, which are closely integrated in distillation and separation processes of natural and industrial gases. In most cases, evaporation takes place in an upward
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 29 Two-phase flow visualization in plate heat exchangers.
flow and the fluid enters subcooled. The heat exchanger operates either in natural or forced circulation. In the refrigeration industry, the heat exchangers are often located directly after the expansion valve, so a two-phase mixture is fed at the bottom of the heat exchanger. The main problem with such a configuration is to obtain a homogeneous phase distribution among the channels. Some manufacturers insert a distribution device in the inlet port, and it has been shown that a significant improvement in thermal performance can be achieved. For large compact heat exchangers operating under two-phase flow at the inlet, each phase of the mixtures is fed independently in the channel in order to ensure an effective phase distribution. The design of compact heat exchangers for vaporization duties requires knowledge of the heat transfer coefficients, and it is generally admitted that the basic mechanisms occurring during flow boiling are similar to those encountered in plain tubes (55–57), but no general predictive method is available. For plate heat exchangers, most of the data published have been obtained with pure refrigerants, and the operating conditions are rather different than those encountered in the process industry. The general trend of these studies is that the heat transfer coefficients are significantly higher than those obtained in conventional plain tubes, but the pressure drop is also increased. Concerning boiling of mixtures, compact heat exchangers provide high single-phase heat transfer coefficients; hence the vapor phase will be well mixed, and no major degradation of the heat transfer coefficient should be observed. Concerning plate–fin heat exchangers, the design of such units is much more complicated because up to 12 different fluids can flow in the heat exchangers.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
For distillation and separation processes, the fluids encountered are mixtures, and specific pinch methods have been developed (58–59); a temperature approach of less than one degree can be obtained. To optimize the number of layers per fluid and the type of fins, the heat transfer coefficients need to be accurately predicted in the different boiling zones (subcooled, nucleate, convective, dryout, etc.). Therefore, tests were performed with cryogenic fluids, hydrocarbons (60–61), and refrigerants (62) in order to measure the heat transfer coefficients under actual flow and geometric conditions. Tests with cryogenic fluids are required because the behavior of such fluids is significantly different than that of organic fluids. Microchannel heat exchangers are used for boiling applications, but there is a lack of data for process fluids. Studies using water or refrigerant at low pressures have outlined differences in the flow pattern and in the heat transfer coefficients (63–64). This comes from the fact that the bubble diameter is limited by the channel size. For low and intermediate vapor qualities, the heat transfer coefficients are increased as compared to plain tubes of larger diameters. But for higher vapor qualities, partial dryout may occur and will reduce heat transfer. Because microchannel heat exchangers might operate under large temperature differences, estimation of the critical heat flux is important; but most of the correlations were obtained for flat plates and single tubes, so their extension to microchannels is doubtful (65). To select and apply a boiling method to compact heat exchangers, several facts must be taken into account. The method must be based on the fundamental mechanisms occurring, because purely empirical and curve-fit methods cannot be generalized. The basic assumptions for developing such a method is that both nucleate boiling and convective boiling occur and that the dominant mechanism depends on geometric and operating conditions (Figures 30 and 31). The effect of
FIGURE 30 Vaporization in a plate–fin heat exchanger.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 31 Vaporization in plate heat exchanger.
geometry must be taken into account in the convective area, and that of the operating conditions in the nucleate regime. It is assumed that nucleate boiling correlations, established for plain tubes, are sufficiently accurate and general to be applied for compact heat exchangers. In the convective regime, the heat transfer coefficient is reported to the single-phase liquid heat transfer coefficient, and an enhancement factor is introduced to take into account the liquid–gas interactions. The main questions are to evaluate the single-phase heat transfer coefficient of the given geometry, especially at low Reynolds numbers, and to characterize the enhancement factor. The fundamental problem is to learn whether enhancement factors developed for plain tubes can be applied successfully to compact geometries. Work is being carried out in several R&D organizations, and knowledge on boiling in compact geometries should be improved in the near future. 4.3.
Condensation
Condensation occurs in many industrial processes, but rarely with pure fluids. The fluids encountered are mixtures, and noncondensable gases are often present; this makes the condensation process very complex. In compact geometries the heat transfer coefficient depends on the two-phase flow pattern (51–67). For low condensation rates, the heat transfer is gravity controlled, and the heat transfer coefficient depends on the liquid film thickness. For higher condensation rates, the heat transfer coefficient depends on the vapor shear effect, and for small passages the liquid–vapor interaction leads to high heat transfer coefficients.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
In the case of mixtures or in the presence of a noncondensable gas, the condensing vapor must diffuse through the gas to the phase interface. For this to happen a partial pressure gradient toward the phase interface is necessary. The partial pressure of the vapor falls from a constant value at a rather large distance from the phase interface to a lower value at the interface. Correspondingly, the accompanying saturation temperature also falls toward the interface. Therefore, during condensation, the condensing vapor arrives by diffusion at the condensate surface, and it is the thermal resistance in the vapor that limits the process. Hence in order to improve the heat transfer, one must reduce the thermal resistance on the vapor side. Several factors can enhance the condensation process by reducing the vaporside resistance. During condensation of mixtures or of vapors that contain noncondensables, the heat transfer on the vapor side can be improved by raising the vapor velocity. It has been shown that the heat transfer coefficient can be improved by approximately 30% by increasing the vapor velocity. The use of a finely undulated surface can also achieve significant augmentations in heat transfer during condensation. It has been shown that corrugation can promote turbulent equilibrium between the phases and thus contribute to the increase in heat transfer. Compact heat exchangers are characterized by small hydraulic diameters (1–10 mm), and there is no reliable design method to estimate heat transfer coefficients during condensation in such small passages. In the available literature, condensation of mixtures and of vapor in the presence of noncondensables has been studied, but essentially for conventional geometries (plain tubes), and only few results have been published with fluids representative of actual process conditions (hydrocarbons). A 2002 study (68) has shown that in laminar regime there was a significant mixture effect (decrease in the heat transfer coefficient), but in turbulent regime the mixtures behave as pure fluids (Figure 32). This outlines the high degree of mixing encountered in such heat exchangers, which is not surprising, since the geometric pattern of the plates is similar to modern column packing. 5. 5.1.
HEAT TRANSFER AND MASS TRANSFER Macromixing
Macro- and micromixing are two major issues for compact multifunctional heat exchangers. Macromixing is closely linked to the flow pattern and has often been studied using flow visualization techniques. An effective macromixing will give high transfer rates and homogeneous flow distribution in the channel. The typical scale of macrostructures ranges from half of the channel height to one-tenth of the channel height. Micromixing is associated with much smaller scales and will affect the reaction rate. In this section, we will focus on two technologies able to produce both heat transfer and mixing: the corrugated heat exchanger and the plate–fin heat exchanger.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 32 Mixture effect during condensation.
These heat exchangers have a flexible design and high heat transfer performance and might be suitable for combined heat transfer and mass transfer services. The thermal-hydraulic performances of the two technologies were presented in previous sections. Flow visualization has often been used for analyzing flow structures, but it only gives access to qualitative information or time-average measurements. Using advanced numerical methods allows simulating single-phase flow in complex geometries, such as those encountered in compact heat exchangers. The determination of the mixing ability for water at a Reynolds number equal to 2000 is managed under the aspects of the computational fluid dynamics (CFD) method. An extensive review of turbulence models useful for compact heat exchanger simulation is available in the literature (70). The most appropriate model for each selected geometry will be discussed next. For corrugated heat exchangers, the flow is almost three-dimensional. Analyzing the stream function inside the 60 heat exchanger (Figure 33), we can see that flow is mainly in the direction of the flow inlet, which is a characteristic of subchannel flow. However, a small part of the fluid is deviated by the channels: furrow flow. So for this angle, quasi–plug flow can be obtained, which is in
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 33 Stream function inside the 60-angle plate heat exchanger.
accord with the work of Amblard (39) and Hugonnot (34). The flow can be considered homogeneous since there is the same flow rate through the channel width. This indicates that high teta corrugated plate heat exchangers could be suitable for chemical reactions where macromixing is needed. Analyzing the stream function inside the 30-angle heat exchanger (Figure 34), we can see that the flow feature is equally in the direction of the flow inlet (subchannel flow) and inside the furrow (furrow flow). This result is in good agreement with Gaiser (35). For a two-dimensional wavy channel, a numerical analysis performed at GRETh (69) has shown that the mixing efficiency of corrugated channels is excellent because one corrugation is nearly sufficient to have perfect mixing (Figure 35). For finned passages, all the described phenomena (Figure 36) are in good accord with the regime predicted by the literature (70). Indeed, the flow hits the front edge of the rectangular obstacle and separates immediately. The shear layer reattaches to the wall and splits in two parts: one part flows upstream, creating a recirculating and high-shear area; the other is convected downward by the mean flow. With time, the shear layer becomes unstable near the reattachment point, and it oscillates; it generates a vortex production inside the bubble and a growth of the recirculating area. Due to impinging shear layer instabilities, the
FIGURE 34 Stream function inside the 30-angle plate heat exchanger.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 35 Numerical analysis of the mixing efficiency in a corrugated channel.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 36 Closeup of the flow pattern inside the offset strip fin geometry.
long bubble is broken, and an eddy is liberated and convected toward the trailing edge. At the same time, the bubble length decreases. This vortex shedding occurs on both faces of the obstacle, and a Von Karman street is formed in the wake of the fin. In plate–fin heat exchangers, the flow structure depends on the fin geometry. For offset strip fins, there is a high degree of mixing (25), and the flow becomes turbulent even at low Reynolds numbers (Figure 37). Indeed, after six rows of fins (e.g., about 20 mm), the flow is homogeneous, so the macromixing in the plate–fin heat exchanger is very efficient. 5.2.
Micromixing
Micromixing technologies have only recently been applied to the design of miniaturized devices for chemical applications, so called microreactors. The main components of such microreactors are mixers and heat exchangers.
FIGURE 37 Evolution of a passive scalar inside the offset strip fin geometry.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Two ranges of applications can be distinguished: The laminar regime for highly viscous fluids (such as glue), slow reactions, and long residence time The turbulent regime for classical gas- or liquid-phase reactions, fast reactions, and low residence time The present work will only focus on the turbulent regime, which is characterized by eddies with a wide range of length and time scales. The largest eddies are typically comparable in size to the characteristic length of the mean flow. The smallest scales are responsible for the dissipation of turbulent kinetic energy, which is related to the turbulent fluctuation of the velocity. The higher the fluctuation, the smaller the scales in the flow and the better the micromixing efficiency. So for highly turbulent flows (high velocity or large hydraulic diameter), the micromixing will be very efficient, without any inventive turbulent generators. However, for compact heat exchangers where the hydraulic diameter is not large (a few millimeters) and the velocity not very high (maximum 1 m/s), enhancement techniques are needed in order to lower the turbulent-transition limit. The mixing efficiency is determined by both the value of the pressure drops and the turbulent energy dissipation, (m2/s3):
where is given by
pu L
and L is the total length of the passage, is the voidage of the passage, p is the pressure drop through the passage, and is the density of the fluid. The higher the mixing efficiency, the better is the micromixing. For corrugated heat exchangers, using the numerical simulation for both 60 and 30, we can evaluate directly from the computation and from classical correlation (5–7) (Table 2). The lower the angle, the lower the mixing efficiency. Indeed, while lowering the angle, the flow pattern moves from subchannel flow (helicoidal motion) to furrow flow (duct flow), which reduces the mixing. The mixing efficiency is very low (below 10%), so corrugated heat exchangers, which are able to produce high heat flux, e.g., high macromixing, are not able to produce micromixing. For plate–fin heat exchangers, using the numerical simulation for the OSF geometry, we can evaluate directly from the computation and from classical correlation (8) (Table 2). The OSF geometry is able to produce both macro- and microturbulent scales. For the Reynolds number considered, the fully turbulent
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
TABLE 2 Micromixing Performance for Plate Heat Exchangers (PHE) and Offset Strip Fin (OSF) Heat Exchangers PHE 30 angle Turbulent intensity (%) (m2/s3) (W/kg) (%)
6.2 0.43 13.1 3.2
60 angle
OSF
11.0 2.01 51.0 5.7
10 17.1 24.1 71
regime is not achieved (one must increase the velocity or the plate width by a factor of 2), but this geometry is efficient for heat transfer and mixing. It could be a good concept in the area of temperature-controlled reactions. 5.3.
Two-Phase Flow Heat Transfer and Mass Transfer
Numerous industrial operations involve a heat transfer between a liquid phase and a gaseous phase, with an important mass transfer effect, either as desorptionevaporation or as absorption-condensation. Here are some examples: reconcentration, by evaporation, of solvents, toxic industrial effluents; production, by absorption, of industrial aqueous acid solutions; reversible or irreversible chemical reactions (oxidation, hydrogenation, sulfonation); purification of permanent gases (air, smoke) by scrubbing of soluble vapors; desorbers and absorbers for heat pumps, where these two operations occur simultaneously. In these multifunctional processes, heat transfer and mass transfer are two combined and simultaneous functions, and the objective is to substantially improve these functions in order to save energy, to increase the process efficiency, and to reduce the size and cost of industrial plants. Corrugated pads are often used in the dehumidification process or in chemical heat pumps, but a higher efficiency could be reached by using diabatic units, where the wall could exchange heat with the liquid film. 6. 6.1.
APPLICATIONS Feed/Effluent Heat Exchangers
Feed/effluent heat exchangers are used in many industrial processes to warm up the fluid before the reactor and to cool it down after treatment at high temperature. The conventional design of such heat exchangers is based on shell-and-tube units. But to increase the thermal effectiveness of the heat exchangers, the required heat length becomes very important, and high pressure drop will occur.
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
The alternative to conventional shell-and-tube units is to use plate-type heat exchangers (71). The advantages of PHEs are a high thermal effectiveness for a low pressure drop, compactness, and a low propensity to fouling (72). In the refining industry, large PHEs are used in hydroteater (HDT and HDS); the aim of these treatments is to reduce the naphtha contaminants (sulfur, hydrogen, arsenic, lead, etc.). With the use of such units, two main problems arise: two-phase flow distribution and fouling. At the inlet of the effluent, the flow is a two-phase mixture (gas oil hydrogen) with vapor qualities up to 20%. To ensure a homogeneous flow distribution, the two phases are fed independently at the inlet of each channel (up to 200 channels in parallel). These devices allow reaching high thermal effectiveness and a low-temperature approach. Concerning fouling, because these heat exchangers are totally welded and cannot easily be cleaned, tests have been performed under laboratory conditions and on site to measure the fouling resistance. Full-scale tests, realized at the Belgium Refining Corp in Antwerp (Figure 38), have shown that after two years the thermal performance remained constant. A more precise study was also performed using the Alcor fouling apparatus. A PHE and shell-and-tube unit were connected in parallel; under similar operating conditions, the PHE exhibited no fouling while the shell-and-tube heat exchanger reached fouling resistance values up to 3 104 m2 K/W. Work is still required to optimize the design of such PHEs because the heat transfer mechanisms are complex. On the feed side, a complex mixture is vaporized; on the effluent side, the mixture is condensed with the presence of noncondensable gases. 6.2.
Process Evaporators
Concentration of liquid by evaporation is widely used in industry, and a large variety of techniques have been adopted. Two cases are considered: (1) the effluent is desolved in water (salt solution, for example); (2) the effluent and the water act as a mixture (water–acid solutions, for example). In the first case, the concentration process is very efficient and high concentration can be obtained. In specific cases, crystallization of the effluent can be achieved. Most of the technological developments have been obtained on the projects dealing with desalination of seawater or the sugar industry. For mixtures, the liquid effluent to be concentrated is partially evaporated in a heat exchanger; at the outlet, the vapor phase is richer with more volatile compounds and the liquid phase is richer with less volatile compounds. The evaporator acts as a first stage of distillation. The effectiveness of the evaporation process depends essentially on the mixture-phase equilibrium. In most of the cases, the heating fluid is steam. As a consequence, the channel geometry must me adapted on each side of the heat exchanger to achieve optimal performance. Furthermore, as in most cases, the evaporating fluid
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
FIGURE 38 Process flow sheet. (Courtesy of Packinox.)
has high fouling capacities, so the evaporating side must be cleanable and the dead zone should be avoided. Different types of evaporators are used in concentration processes: (1) flash evaporation through a discharge valve, (2) horizontal tubular or plate reboilers (submerged or falling film), (3) vertical tubular or plate evaporators (climbing or falling film), (4) specific evaporators (direct contact, scraped surface, etc.). Compact heat exchangers are mostly used as vertical evaporators with either falling film (Morgenroth et al. (73)) or climbing film (Brotherton (12), Patel and Thomson (11)). A special high-capacity compact falling-film evaporator has been developed for sugar plants. The use of falling-film evaporators allows one to reach higher heat transfer coefficients than with climbing-film evaporators, especially for low temperature differences. Compared to conventional systems, the overall heat transfer performance can be up to two to five times higher, as a function of the fluid
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
viscosity. Plate heat exchangers are also used as evaporator in sugar plants, with a similar level of enhancement. All the tests realized (lab scale, pilot and industrial units) have shown that plate heat exchangers, even with small hydraulic diameters, are not more sensitive to fouling than plain tubes. Other applications in concentration processes of such compact heat exchangers should be developed, especially in the area of mixture concentration. 6.3.
Integrated Heat Exchangers in Separation Processes
Distillation and separation processes for purifying products requires up to 40% of the overall energy demand in chemical processes (Trambouze (74)), and great efforts have been made by engineers to reduce this energy consumption. The integration of the reboiler and the condenser in distillation columns has already been studied, but the entire potential of integrated heat exchangers has not been achieved (Lyon et al. (75)). As an example, plate heat exchangers have been installed in an isopropanol dehydration plant as reboilers and condensers, and they have been found to be very effective from the viewpoint of heat transfer. Condensers and evaporators used in distillation processes are generally based on the horizontal shell-and-tube design, and this conventional design leads to large units, which have generally low energy efficiency. The integration is not optimal, and the heat exchanger is still a part of the unit. Introducing compact heat exchangers in place of shell-and-tube units will permit greater compactness and lower energy consumption. Because the heat exchanger operates purely in countercurrent, heat is available at a higher temperature than with horizontal shells. For long-term developments, diabatic distillation and separation units must be studied. Reflux condensers are often used in the top of a distillation column, as a first stage to separating the lighter and heavier components. Because the liquid flow and gas flow are countercurrent, a critical gas flow rate exists above which flooding occurs. Although considerable work in the literature has been devoted to free-falling films (mostly in pipes), the issue of flooding in countercurrent gas/ liquid flow has not been settled yet. Furthermore, the literature concerning flooding in narrow passages is extremely poor. Thus, for the case of compact condensers, there is no reliable tool for engineering-type predictions of flooding. From the viewpoint of heat transfer, reflux flows are more complex to study than downward flows. Heat and mass transfer occur simultaneously between the phases, and heat transfer is present between the liquid phase and the walls. Literature provides neither experimental data nor a reliable prediction method for these special system conditions. Studies about condensation inside channels have been carried out only for concurrent downward flow of pure vapors in tubes with large diameters. At present the design parameters for reflux condensation can only be estimated by the classical annular-flow model presented in heat transfer handbooks. However, this model is not applicable under the given conditions, and
Copyright © 2004 by Marcel Dekker, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
it is known from practical applications that the real condensation rate in compact heat exchangers deviates drastically from predictions according to the classical model. Modeling reflux condensation (dephlegmation) in a compact plate–fin heat exchanger has been carried out (Urban et al. (76)), and the critical aspect raised is the distribution of the liquid film o