CARBOHYDRATE BIOENGINEERING
Progress in Biotechnology Volume 1 New Approaches to Research on Cereal Carbohydrates (Hi...
88 downloads
2223 Views
18MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
CARBOHYDRATE BIOENGINEERING
Progress in Biotechnology Volume 1 New Approaches to Research on Cereal Carbohydrates (Hill and Munck, Editors) Volume 2 Biology of Anaerobic Bacteria (Dubourguier et al., Editors) Volume 3 Modifications and Applications of Industrial Polysaccharides (Yalpani, Editor) Volume 4 Interbiotech '87. Enzyme Technologies (Bla~ej and Zemek, Editors) Volume 5 In Vitro Immunization in Hybridoma Technology (Borrebaeck, Editor) Volume 6 Interbiotech '89. Mathematical Modelling in Biotechnology (Bla~ej and Ottova, Editors) Volume 7 Xylans and Xylanases (Visser et al., Editors) Volume 8 Biocatalysis in Non-Conventional Media (Tramper et al., Editors) Volume 9 ECB6: Proceedings of the 6th European Congress on Biotechnology (Alberghine et al., Editors) Volume 10 Carbohydrate Bioengineering (Petersen, Svensson and Pedersen)
Progress in Biotechnology 10
CARBOHYDRATE BIOENGINEERING Proceedings o f an International Conference Elsinore, Denmark, April 23-26, 1995
Edited by S t e f f e n B. P e t e r s e n
SINTEF UNIMED, MR-Center, N-7034 Trondheim, Norway Birte Svensson
Gamble Carlsberg vej 10, DK-2500 Valby, Denmark Sven Pedersen
NovoNordisk A/S, Novo Alle, DK-2880 Bagsvaerd, Denmark
ELSEVIER Amsterdam
- Lausanne
- New
York - Oxford - Shannon
- Tokyo
1995
Published by: Elsevier Science B.V. P.O. Box 211 1000 AE Amsterdam The Netherlands
ISBN 0-444-82223-2 @1995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the prior written permission of the publisher, Elsevier Science B.V., Permissions Department, P.O. Box 521, 1000 AM Amsterdam, The Netherlands. No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, the Publisher recommends that independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made. Special regulations for readers in the U S A - This publication has been registered with the Copyright Clearance Center Inc. (CCC), 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01293, USA. Information can be obtained from the CCC about conditions under which photocopies of parts of this publication may be made in the USA. All other copyright questions, including photocopying outside the USA should be referred to the copyright owner, Elsevier Science B.V., unless otherwise specified. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Printed in the Netherlands
PREFACE The rapid development in glycobiology and glycotechnology has resulted in an enormous increase in our knowledge on the structure, conversion, and application of carbohydrates in industry and medicine. The Carbohydrate Bioengineering Meeting held at the LO-School in Elsinore, Denmark, April 23-26, 1995, gathered 230 scientists, mostly from Europe, with interest in carbohydrate analysis and structure; carbohydrates in medicine and glycopathology; structure, function, application, and protein engineering of carbohydrate active enzymes; oligo- and polysaccharides of industrial interest; and production of carbohydrate containing new materials. The meeting provided a forum where highly distinguished researchers presented their latest results. The strong representation of participants in the EU Biotechnology Programme on Carbohydrate Active Enzymes illustrated a great need for this type of meeting which provides a stimulating atmosphere where established scientists and students in academia and industry can get together. The contributions, both from invited and selected speakers as well as from the poster presentations spanned the broad field in a continuous manner. The Proceedings chapters 1 - 4 address glycoconjugates as modulatory and recognition molecules, structure determination using NMR and mass spectrometry, and microdialysis-chip enzyme-based sensors. Carbohydrate active enzymes turned out to be a predominant topic. Chapters 5 - 8 describe different bacterial enzymes involved either in carbohydrate metabolism, or with potential application in bio-processing of special polysaccharides including at elevated temperatures. Details on the tools utilized in analysis of mechanism of carbohydrases and carbohydrateprotein interactions are discussed in chapters 9 - 12 which include active site mutations coupled with crystal structures and synthetic substrate analogue interactions. Protein engineering of specificity and stability of two industrially important starch-degrading enzymes are described in chapters 13 and 14. The significance and engineering of electrostatics in carbohydrate active enzymes, and the role and engineering of N-linked sugar moieties in protein stability are demonstrated in chapters 15 and 16. A very timely up-date on ceUulolytic enzymes covers in chapters 17 - 21 the new three-dimensional structures and binding domains for biotechnological applications. The description in chapters 22 and 23 of transgenic plants for understanding and manipulation of starch biosynthesis and of the expression of cellulases in transgenic animals both have wide perspective in nutrition and related sciences. Examples on prospects for industrial synthesis of polysaccharides using enzymes not acting on sugar nucleotides, and the potential and details of the complex mechanism of such enzymes, are given in chapters 24 and 25. Furthermore, industrial applications using monocomponent plant cell-wall polysaccharide hydrolases, synthesis of fatty acid-carbohydrate ester surfactants,
vi and the utilization of bacteria in commercial production of sugars derivatives are described in chapters 26- 28. Any scientific meeting is benefitting from economical support. In our case we would like to express our special gratitude for the generous support from the following sponsors: Biosym
Technologies, Boehringer DAKO, Dansk Metal, European Commission/DG XII, European Congress of Biotechnology 5, Nordic Fund for Technology and Industrial Development, Novo Nordisk A/S, Nutek, Pharmacia, Pharmacia Biotech, Radiometer, Silicon Graphics and SNF. Finally, at this point we also wish to express our warm thanks to the participants for their contribution and for making a most exciting and fruitful meeting. A very special thank you to all authors for the effort they have made in the preparation of the manuscripts. We also greatly acknowledge the professional assistance of Ms. Mona K. Eidem in the preparation of this book.
Copenhagen, September 27, 1995
Sven Pedersen, Steffen B. Petersen and Birte Svensson, Editors
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
xi
TABLE OFCONTENTS
Chapter 1: Glycans of glycoconjugates as modulatory and recognition molecules
N. Sharon
1
Chapter 2: NMR studies of the structure and dynamics of carbohydrates in aqueous solution H . van Halbeek and S. Sheng
I5
Chapter 3: Linkage analysis by mass spectrometry of chemically modified oligo-saccharides from glycosphingolipids and glycoproteins B. Nilsson
29
Chapter 4: Development of a novel enzyme based glucose sensor F. Spener, R . Steinkuhl, C . Dumschat, H. Hinkers, K . Cammann and M. Knoll
49
Chapter 5: Carbohydrate binding at the active site of Escherichia coli maltodextrin phosphorylase P. Drueckes, D. Palm and R. Schinrel
59
Chapter 6: The chitinolytic system of Streptomyces olivaceoviridis
H. Schrempf Chapter 7: Properties and production of the P-glycosidase from the thermophilic Archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricusexpressed in mesophilic hosts M. Moracci, L. Capalbo, M. De Rosa, R. La Montagna, A. Morana, R. Nucci, M. Ciaramella and M. Rossi
71
77
xii Chapter 8: Contribution of subsites to catalysis and specificity in the extended binding cleft of Bacillus 1,3-1,4-13-D-glucan 4-glucanohydrolases A. Planas and C. Malet Chapter 9: Probing of glycosidase active sites through labeling, mutagenesis and kinetic studies S.G. Withers
85
97
Chapter 10: Thiooligosaccharides: toys or tools for the studies of glycanases H. Driguez
Chapter 11: Mutational analysis of catalytic mechanism and specificity in amylolytic enzymes B. Svensson, T.P. Frandsen, I. Matsui, N. Juge, H.-P. Fierobe, B. Stoffer and K.W Rodenburg
113
125
Chapter 12: The structure and function relationship of Schizophyllum commune xylanase A Mdr Bray and AJ. Clarke
147
Chapter 13: Protein engineering of cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase from Bacillus circulans strain 251 L. Dijkhuzien, D. Penninga, H.I. Rozeboom, B. Strokopytov and B.W. Dijkstra
165
Chapter 14: Oxidation stable amylases for detergents T.V. Borchert, S.F. Lassen, A. Svendsen and H.B. Frantzen
175.
Chapter 15: Electrostatic studies of carbohydrate active enzymes A. Baptista, T. Brautaseth, F. DrablOs, P. Martel, S. Valla and S.B. Petersen
181
Chapter 16: Effects of glycosylation on protein folding, stability and solubility. Studies of chemically modified or engineered plant and fungal peroxidases K.G. Welinder and J.W. Tams
205
xiii Chapter 17: Modes of action of two Trichoderma reesei cellobiohydrolases T.T. Teeri, A. Koivula, M. Linder, T. Reinikainen, L. Ruohonen, M. Srisodsuk, M. Claeyssens and T.4. Jones
211
Chapter 18: Structural studies on fungal endoglucanases from Humicola insolens G.J. Davies and M. Schiilein
225
Chapter 19: The catalytic domain of endoglucanase A from Clostridium cellulolyticum belonging to family 5: an 0r enzyme V. Ducros, M. Czjzek, A. Belaich, C. Gaudin and R. Haser
239
Chapter 20: Celluosome domains for novel biotechnological application E.A. Bayer, E. Morag, M. Wilchek, R. Lamed. S. Yaron and Y. Shoham
251
Chapter 21: Interactions of cellulases from Cellulomonasfimi with cellulose N. Din, J.B. Coutinho, N.R. Gilkes, E. Jervis, D.G. Kilburn, R.C. Miller Jr., E. Ong, P. Tomme and R.4.J. Warren
261
Chapter 22: Transgenic plants as a tool to understand starch biosynthesis J. K o ~ n n , G. Abel, V. Biittcher, E. Duwenig, M. Emmermann, R. Lorberth, F. Springer, I. Virgin, T. Welsh and l. Willmitzer
271
Chapter 23: Targeted expression of microbial cellulases in transgenic animals S. Ali, J. Hall, K.L. Soole, C.M.G.4. Fontes, G.P. Hazlewood, B.H. Hirst and Hzl. Gilbert
279
Chapter 24: Mechanism and action of glucansucrases J.F. Robyt
295
Chapter 25: Studies of recombinant amylosucrase M. Remaud-Simeon, F. Albaret, B. Canard, I. Varlet, P. Colonna, R.M. Willemot and P. Monsan
313
xiv Chapter 26: Application of cloned monocomponent carbohydrases for modification of plant materials L.V. Kofod, T.E. Mathiasen, H.P. Heldt-Hansen and H. DalbOge
321
Chapter 27: Fatty acid esters of ethyl glucoside, a unique class of surfactants O. Andresen and O. Kirk
343
Chapter 28: A wide range of carbohydrate modifications by a single microorganism: leuconostoc mesenteroides W. Soetaert, D. Schwengers, K. Buchholz and E.I. Vandamme
351
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Glycans of glycoconjugates as modulatory and recognition molecules Nathan Sharon Department of Membrane Research and Biophysics, The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot 7 6100, Israel
Abstract
Glycoproteins and glycolipids are the most common classes of glycoconjugates. Their glycans are structurally diverse, although overlapping to some extent. The functions of these glycans are mostly unknown, but from the information available it is clear that they often modulate the physicochemical properties of the proteins to which they are attached, and sometimes also their biological activities. In addition, there is increasing evidence that many of these glycans, whether protein or lipid bound, serve as recognition determinants in moleculecell and cell-cell interactions. The knowledge accrued is having a marked impact on the biotechnological production of therapeutically useful glycoproteins and provides a strong impetus for the development of novel types of drugs for a wide range of diseases, such as microbial infections, inflammation and cancer.
1. INTRODUCTION Living organisms produce a bewildering array of glycans, many of them in the form of glycoproteins or glycolipids. These generally go under the term glycoconjugates or complex carbohydrates. The question of the function of these glycans is currently attracting increasing interest. Thus, oligosaccharides attached to proteins often modulate the physicochemical and biological properties of the latter. Furthermore, changes in glycan structure accompany many normal and pathological processes, from differentiation and development to cancer. In some cases, specific carbohydrates on cancer cells have been correlated with the tumor grade, metastatic potential and prognosis, raising the possibility that glycans may serve as markers for diagnostic purposes and as targets for drugs. Developments in genetic engineering have made possible the biotechnological production of pharmaceutically useful glycoproteins, both for research purposes and for therapeutic use. Last, but not least, is the prospect of creating carbohydrate-based drugs for the treatment of many diseases, from microbial infections to cancer. Findings made prior to the 1970's have given some indications that carbohydrates may have functions other than as structural materials and energy source [1]. In work carried out in the 1940's and 1950's it has been shown that sialic acid is the receptor for influenza virus, that sugars on the surface of enteric bacteria serve as phage receptors and that such compounds are determinants of ABO blood type specificity. The sixties witnessed the demonstration that
malignant cells have often a different sugar phenotype than their normal counterpart, and that sugars determine the lifetime of glycoproteins in the circulation. These findings were largely ignored by biochemists and biologists alike. During the last quarter of the century the situation has changed, in the beginning rather slowly, then at a steadily accelerating rate, and our knowledge of glycan structures and their functions has increased greatly. These developments have not escaped the attention of the popular press, as reflected in the article entitled "Sugar coated truths" (The Economist, September 24th, 1994): "Researchers have been bewitched by the elegance of nucleic acids and proteins. Now they are opening their eyes to the subtleties of sugars". Here I present a survey of the role of glycans in modulating the properties of the proteins to which they are attached and of their function as recognition determinants. The latter function is shared by membrane bound glycolipids, which is not surprising, in view of the identity of many glycan structures found in both types of glycoconjugate. These subjects have been extensively dealt with in two recent reviews [2,3], in which references to earlier literature can be found.
2. METHODOLOGY Different approaches are being employed in the quest to unravel the role of glycoconjugate glycans. They include modification of the glycans by purified glycosidases or transferases, use of inhibitors of glycosylation or glycoprotein processing and of cell mutants with known defects in glycosylation, and more recently, techniques of molecular genetics. Recombinant glycoproteins can be expressed in heterologous cells or organisms, resulting in different patterns of glycosylation. An extreme example is that of bacteria (e.g., E . coli) which produce completely non-glycosylated proteins. Nucleotide-directed mutagenesis can be applied to modify glycosylation sites on proteins so that they will no longer serve for glycan attachment. With N-glycoproteins, where the carbohydrate is linked to the Asn-X-Ser/Thr sequon, modification of either the first or third amino acid will abolish glycosylation at this site. In glycoproteins with more than one carbohydrate unit, whether N-, O- or both, the sites can be systematically eliminated in various combinations, to form a panel of mutants in which the roles of each carbohydrate chain can be assessed. Although very useful, these and other in vitro methods rarely provide answers to questions concerning the biological roles of carbohydrates in the intact, multicellular organism. Important information in this respect can be derived from investigations of congenital disorders involving genetic defects in protein glycosylation. A well-studied case is that of I-cell disease, a lysosomal storage disease, resulting from the inability to synthesize mannose-6-phosphate (due to a deficiency in N-acetylglucosaminyl phosphotransferase) [4]. Other examples are HEMPAS, a rare form of genetic anemia in humans [5] or the carbohydrate deficient glycoprotein (CDG) syndromes I and II, a set of multisystemic diseases with major nervous system involvement, all of which are due to deficiencies in various steps of N-glycosylation [6,6a]. Last but not least, the use of transgenic animals, still in its infancy, opens up new avenues for the study of glycan function in the intact organism [7]. Carbohydrate structures can now be manipulated by the expression of degradative enzymes that act on a particular carbohydrate in a particular linkage, of transferases that attach monosaccharides to glycoproteins or glycolipids, or of other enzymes, such as those that act on monosaccharide
substituents (e.g. O-acetyl). These structures may also be modified by the complete elimination of a particular glycosyltransferase ("knock-out" experiments). For example, insight into the role of complex or hybrid N-linked glycans in the development of embryos was recently obtained in experiments with transgenic mice, from which the gene for GlcNAc-T I has been removed, using homologous recombination [8,9]. Embryos of such mice exhibited an overall stunting of growth and lethality at around day 10 of gestation. These findings show that complex N-linked chains are not required during early development, but are necessary later, for the completion of morphogenesis.
3. MODULATION OF PHYSICOCHEMICAL PROPERTIES Quite frequently, the carbohydrate groups affect the physical properties of the protein to which they are attached (Table 1). In general, the effects are more pronounced the higher the carbohydrate content of the glycoprotein. The negative charges of sialic acid residues and sulfate groups change the solubility and modify the conformation of glycoproteins, as well as the adhesive properties of cells. These effects are of particular importance for the function of the highly glycosylated mucins which may carry sialic acid-containing oligosaccharides on as many as one third of their amino acids. As a result, they assume rigid, rod-like structures that may reach a length of several hundred nanometers. Mucin regions are often found on cell surface receptors and it is thought that the role of the rigid structures is to extend the functional domains away from the cell surface. Since the surface area of the glycans is quite significant when compared to that of the peptide moiety, they may, in addition, influence other properties of proteins, such as heat stability and susceptibility to proteolysis. These properties are of special interest to industries producing commercially used enzymes, for which stability is a common requirement. Perhaps the most important functions of N-glycosylation are to aid in folding of the nascent polypeptide chain and in stabilization of the conformation of the mature glycoprotein. As a consequence, it may also affect any, or all, of the functions that depend on conformation. In the absence of glycosylation, some (glyco)proteins aggregate and/or are degraded, and as a result, are not secreted from the cells in which they are synthesized. Other glycoproteins are less influenced and are secreted, but have compromised biological activities, while some appear to be totally unaffected. Recent studies suggest that one way in which N-linked oligosaccharide chains affect protein folding is by mediating the interaction of the newly-synthesized peptide with calnexin, a chaperone with apparent selectivity for N-glycoproteins [10]. It is a non-glycosylated membrane protein of 65.4 kDa molecular weight, with a large, negatively charged carboxyterminal cytoplasmic tail and an external domain containing three internal repeats of conserved hexapeptide sequence. Experiments with two viral membrane glycoproteins (influenza virus hemagglutinin and vesicular stomatitis virus G protein), showed that calnexin binds transiently to the newly synthesized glycoproteins that have partially trimmed, monoglucosylated oligosaccharides; the binding coincides with protein folding and oligomer assembly. The proteins remain bound to calnexin for different periods of time, depending on the rates at which they achieve conformational maturation. During this time, the single terminal glucose is rapidly turned over in a deglucosylation-reglucosylation cycle. Once a glycoprotein is folded or
Table 1 Carbohydrates modify the properties of the proteins to which they are linked OFTEN Affect solubility, charge and viscosity; Control folding and subunit assembly; Stabilize protein conformation; Protect against proteolysis Affect the lifetime in circulation Change the immunological properties Modify the transmission of signals by cellular receptors Modify the activity of enzymes and hormones RARELY
assembled into oligomeric form, it is no longer reglucosylated and therefore released by calnexin and is free to leave the endoplasmic reticulum. The carbohydrate may change markedly the quartenary structure of a protein to which it is attached, as demonstrated in the X-ray crystallographic study of the Erythrina corallodendron lectin, a member of the large family of legume lectins [ 11]. The heptasaccharide, linked at Asn17 of each of the two subunits of this lectin, prevents the formation of the characteristic dimer observed in other members of the legume lectin family (e.g. concanavalin A and pea lectin). As a result, these subunits adopt a completely different quaternary structure. Not only is glycosylation at a particular site important in directing protein folding and assembly, but the precise structure of the glycan may also be critical. A clear case is that of human chorionic gonadotropin, a glycoprotein hormone composed of two subunits, for which it was shown that abnormally glycosylated a subunit is unable to associate with the [3-subunit to form the mature hormone.
4. MODULATION OF BIOLOGICAL ACTIVITY The ability of carbohydrates to modulate the activities of biologically functional proteins, occasionally even in an all-or-nothing manner, has been established unequivocally during the last decade in a limited number of cases. For most glycoproteins, however, the role of the carbohydrates is still obscure.
4.1. Enzymes Well documented cases on the effect of carbohydrate on enzymatic activity are rare. One of these is that of tissue plasminogen activator (tPA), a serine protease which converts plasminogen into plasmin and thereby induces clot lysis (fibrinolysis). Naturally occurring type I and type II tPA that possess different numbers of N-linked glycans, differ in the rate of formation of an active complex with fibrin that is able to cleave plasminogen. Plasminogen itself exists in two forms, with either one or more oligosaccharide units attached. The rate of fibrin-dependent plasminogen activation spans a range that is dependent on the glycosylation site occupancy of both tPA and its substrate. At the extremes, this activity for type II tPA with
type II plasminogen (possessing one O-linked glycan) is 2-3 times the value for type I tPA and type I plasminogen with one O-linked and one N-linked glycan [ 12, 13]. Another, more recent, case is that of bovine pancreatic RNase. The enzyme occurs both in unglycosylated (RNase A) and glycosylated (RNase B) form; the latter is a collection isoforms, in which the same polypeptide is associated with nine different oligomannose chains (from Man 5 to Man 9) at the single N-glycosylation site (Ash34). RNase A and RNase B have always been reported as having the same enzymatic activity and were frequently quoted as a proof, provided by nature, that such activity is not affected by the presence of carbohydrates in the molecule. With the aid of a novel sensitive assay using double stranded RNA substrate it was shown [13] that RNase A was more than three times as active as RNase B. The individual glycoforms RNase-Mans, RNase-Man 1 and RNase-Man0, prepared by exoglycosidase treatment of naturally occurring RNase B and separated by capillary electrophoresis, were intermediate in activity (Table 2). These differences were attributed to an overall increase in dynamic stability of the molecule with glycosylation (as demonstrated by measurments of proton exchange rates of the various RNase forms) and to steric effects. Molecular modeling indicated that increasing the size of the RNase oligosaccharide up to five mannose residues could lead to a decrease in activity, whereas the Man5 to Man9 glycoforms would exhibit similar activities, as was indeed found [ 14].
Table 2 Enzymatic activity of RNase A and glycoforms of RNase B 1 Relative RNase Carbohydrate activity A None 1.0 B
2
GlcNAc2Man 0 0.62 GlcNAc2Man 1 0.45 GlcNAc2Man 5 0.28 GlcNAc2Mans_9 0.26
t!
1
Based on ref.[ 13].
2
Modified by enzymatic removal of some mannose residues
4.2. Hormones Chemically or enzymatically deglycosylated glycoprotein hormones bind to their receptors on target cells with the same affinity as the native ones; their ability to activate the hormone responsive adenylate cyclase is, however, drastically decreased [reviewed in 2,3]. Site directed mutagenesis experiments on human chorionic gonadotropin cDNA implied that glycosylation at Ash-52 of the (x-chain alone is sufficient for normal signal transduction. Furthermore, in the absence of this critical oligosaccharide unit, glycosylation at Ash-13 of the [3-chain resulted in intermediate activity of the hormone, whereas glycosylation at Ash-30 of the same chain resulted in an inactive product. Deglycosylated hCG interacts with a different domain of the receptor than the native hormone. This difference may be a factor determining the success or failure of signal transduction from the receptor to the effector system.
The role of carbohydrates in the activity of erythropoietin, a glycoprotein hormone that stimulates erythropoiesis, is the subject of intense studies, not the least because of the great commercial interest in this compound. Erythropoietin has the distinction of being the first recombinant glycoprotein produced industrially for clinical use and is being widely employed for the treatment of anaemia in patients on haemodialysis. Desialylation of the hormone enhanced its in vitro activity by increasing its affinity for the receptor, but decreased its activity in vivo, presumably by decreasing its life-time in circulation. Similar results were reported for the N-deglycosylated hormone, which in vitro exhibited several-fold higher specific activity than the native one, but was inactive in vivo. Examination of several preparations of recombinant erythropoietin that differ in the degree of branching of their N-glycans revealed that in vivo activity of the hormone increased with the ratio of tetraantennary to biantennary saccharides [ 15].
4.3. Other biologically active molecules Carbohydrates on receptors may affect the functional coupling of the latter to effector systems such as adenylate cyclase (via guanine nucleotide binding proteins (G-proteins)) and tyrosine kinase, essential for the transmission of signals from the ligand to the cell. Thus, insulin receptor in which all four potential N-glycosylation sites of the b-subunit have been eliminated by site-directed mutagenesis had similar affinity for its ligand as the wild type receptor but lost its transmembrane signaling ability, as evidenced by lack of stimulation of glucose transport and glycogen synthesis by the hormone [ 16]. Two types of T-cell derived, IgE-binding factor have been described, one of which enhances, and the other suppresses, IgE synthesis in mast cells. The factors share a common polypeptide backbone, but only the former is glycosylated. This is perhaps the only known case of such a remarkable change in the activity of a protein caused by the presence of a carbohydrate [ 17]. In IgG antibodies, elimination of the conserved glycan linked to Asn247 of the heavy chain leads to a loss of some of the effector functions of the molecule, such as binding to Fc receptors on macrophages [ 18].
5. ACTIVITIES OF FREE OLIGOSACCHARIDES Diverse activities are exhibited by free oligosaccharides, either derived from glycoproteins or from other sources (Table 3).This was originally demonstrated with heparin oligosaccharides that, like the parent molecule, act as anticoagulants. Recently it was found that a heparin/heparan sulfate dodecasaccharide activates cell-bound fibroblast growth factor, similarly to full-size heparin (or heparan sulfate proteoglycans, such as syndecan) [ 19,20]. The saccharide binds both to the growth factor and its receptor and the formation of such trimeric complex appears to be a prerequisite for signal transduction. Glycans isolated from plant glycoproteins were shown to delay tomato ripening. Other oligosaccharides that act on plants in different ways have been described, some of which are listed in Table 3.
Table 3 Biologically active oli~osaccharides Structure In animals Heparin-derived Heparan sulfate-derived In plants Oligoglucosides Pectin-derived Oligo-GlcN derivatives Fuc-Xyl-N-glycans Xyloglucan-derived
Activity
Ref.'s
Anticoagulant Growth factor activators
[ 19,20] [19,201
Induce disease resistance Anti-auxins Nodulation factors in rhizobia Delay tomato ripening Inhibit or promote elongation of pea stem segments
[21] [21] [22] [231
[21]
6. CARBOHYDRATES AS RECOGNITION DETERMINANTS There is increasing evidence for the concept, formulated over 20 years ago, that carbohydrates act as recognition determinants in a variety of physiological and pathological processes [24,25] (Tables 4 and 5).
Table 4 Carbohydrates and lectins in cell-cell recognition Process Sugars on Infection Host cells Defense Phagocytes Microorganisms Fertilization Eggs Leukocyte traffic Leukocytes Endothelial cells Metastasis Target organs Malignant cells
Lectins on Microorganisms Microorganisms Phagocytes 1 (Sperm) Endothelial cells Lymphocytes Malignant cells (Target organs)
1
Presumed, no experimental evidence available
This concept evolved with the realization that carbohydrates have an enormous potential for encoding biological information. The messages encoded in the structures of complex carbohydrates are deciphered through interactions with complementary sites on carbohydratebinding proteins, chiefly lectins. Processes in which the participation of carbohydrate-lectin interactions was clearly demonstrated include intracellular trafficking of enzymes, clearance of glycoproteins from the circulatory system and a wide range of cell-cell interactions. Particularly exciting is the recent demonstration that binding of carbohydrates on the surface of
leukocytes, with a class of animal lectins designated selectins, controls leukocyte traffic by mediating adhesion of these cells to restricted portions of the endothelium and their recruitment to inflammatory sites. 6.1. Clearance (traffic) markers The rapid removal of desialylated glycoproteins from rabbit serum via the hepatic asialoglycoprotein receptor (or lectin), a phenomenon discovered in the late 1960's, is the prototype of the saccharide-based recognition system, although its role in nature has not yet been proven beyond doubt [26].
Table 5 Clearance and targeting of glycoproteins Glycoprotein Specificity Asialoglycoproteins Galactose Hormones SQ-GalNAc Lysosomal enzymes Diverse
Receptor
Man-6-phosphate Mannose
Location Liver (hepatocytes) Liver (Kupffer cells, endothelial cells) Ubiquitous Macrophages, liver(endothelial cells)
Several other systems in which the traffic of glycoproteins is controlled by their carbohydrate constituents are known (Table 5). A prominent example is the intracellular routing of lysosomal enzymes to their compartment which is mediated by the recognition between Man-6-P attached to the oligomannose unit(s) of such enzymes, and the Man-6-P receptors [4]. Two such receptors have been described, one cation-independent and of high molecular weight (220 kDa), the other cation-dependent and of low molecular weight (48 kDa). A defect in the synthesis of the Man-6-P marker recognized by the receptors results in I-cell disease (also called mucolipidosis II or MLII), an inherited lysosomal storage disease, characterized by a lack in the lysosomes of those enzymes that normally carry the marker [27]. It is caused by a deficiency of GlcNAc-phosphotransferase, the first enzyme in the pathway of mannose phosphorylation, and is thus a processing disease, the first of its kind to be identified. Therefore, even though the disease is transmitted by a single gene, some 20 enzymes are affected. The enzymes lacking the recognition marker do not reach their destination (the lysosomes), and are, consequently, secreted into the extracellular milieu, which is one of the biochemical abnormalities of the affected cells. The specificity of the GlcNAcphosphotransferase for certain lysosomal enzymes is based on its ability to recognize a specific lysine residue and a particular tertiary domain of the acceptor glycoprotein. Another carbohydrate-specified targeting system is that of the sulfated glycoprotein hormones. Native lutotropin (LH), carrying predominantly mono- and di-sulfated oligosaccharides on its [3-subunit, is cleared from the circulation 4-5 times more rapidly than recombinant LH, produced in CHO cells, that bears only sialylated oligosaccharides. The sulfated oligosaccharides of LH are synthesized by the action of two enzymes, a glycoprotein
hormone-specific GalNAc-transferase and a GalNAc-specific sulfotransferase [28]. The oligosaccharide formed by the two transferases, SO4-GalNAc~4GlcNAc132Manot is recognized by a receptor present on hepatic endothelial and Kupffer cells. Sulfated oligosaccharides are also present on the common precursor to two other hormones, adrenocorticotropin and melanotropin. It has been hypothesized that the attachment of this structure is a general tag that signals rapid clearance, resulting in a short burst of circulating hormones, thus preventing overloading of the corresponding receptors. The presence of well-defined carbohydrate binding proteins on cell surfaces is being exploited for drug targeting to specific organs. Gaucher's disease is caused by a deficiency of the enzyme 13-glucocerebrosidase, resulting in accumulation of glucocerebroside in Kupffer and endothelial (non-parenchymal) cells of the liver. These cells contain on their surface a mannose- (and N-acetylglucosamine) specific lectin. To target the 13-glucocerebrosidase into the above cells, the complex and hybrid sugar chains of the enzyme were trimmed down with the aid of exoglycosidases to expose the mannose residues of the pentasaccharide core. In this way the administered glucocerebrosidase is effectively delivered to the deficient cells where the enzyme is needed to degrade the accumulated glucocerobroside [29]. 6.2. Infection The oligosaccharide repertoire on the host-cell surface is among the key genetic susceptibility factors in viral and microbial infection and in toxin action. A number of viral, mycoplasmal, bacterial and protozoan pathogens use specific carbohydrate structures (of glycoproteins or glycolipids) on host cells as attachment sites in the initial stages of infection [30,31]. Experiments in intact animals have indeed proved that it is possible to prevent bacterial infection by blocking the attachment of the responsible organism with an appropriate sugar (Table 6). Such findings have provided an impetus for the development of carbohydratebased anti-adhesion drugs to combat infections. At present, at least two drugs of this kind have been patented, against bacterial pneumonia and Helicobacter pylori, (a bacterium associated with stomach ulcers). Should a bacterium mutate so that it no longer recognizes the antiadhesive carbohydrates, it will also fail to bind to its cell surface receptors, and therefore lose the ability to cause infection. Moreover, since such drugs do not kill the pathogens, they will not exert selection pressure and their use will not result in the development of resistance. Even if a particular carbohydrate has been established as an inhibitor for a disease-causing microorganism in an animal (or in humans), it must be determined whether the use of this carbohydrate, or its analogues, will not interfere with other processes in the body. One such process is lectinophagocytosis, well documented for the mannose specific E. coli [32]. This mode of phagocytosis may result from binding of the bacteria to phagocytes, e.g. macrophages or neutrophils, which is followed by activation of the phagocytes and uptake and killing of the bacteria. Lectinophagocytosis may occur in vivo and may provide protection against infection by bacteria to nonimmune hosts or in sites that are poor in opsonins. The latter include lungs, renal medulla, the cerebrospinal fluid and the peritoneal cavity, especially during peritoneal dialysis. In another mode of lectinophagocytosis, a wide range of microorganisms (bacteria, fungi and protozoa) that express mannose on their surface, bind to the mannose specific lectin present on the surface of macrophages. This binding, too, may lead to the uptake of the
10 microorganisms by the phagocytic cell and occasionally also their killing. A particularly interesting example of such a microorganism is the pathogenic fungus, Pneumocystis carinii, a
Table 6 Inhibitors of sugar-specific adhesion prevent infection in vivo Organism Animal, site Escherichia coli type 1 Mice, UT Mice, GIT Mice, UT Klebsiella pneumoniae type 1 Rats, UT Shigella flexnerii type 1 Guinea pigs, eye Escherichia coli type P Mice Monkeys Escherichia coli K99 Calves. GIT Pseudomonas aeruginosa UT, urinary tract; GIT, gastrointestinal tract
Human, ear
Inhibitor Meo~Man Mannose Anti-Man antibody Meo~Man Mannose Globotetraose GalI34Gal13OM Glycopeptides of serum glycoproteins Gal+Man+NeuAc
major case of death among AIDS patients. Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV), the causative agent of AIDS, is heavily glycosylated [reviewed in 2]. The major envelope glycoprotein gpl20 of the HIV has a key role in infection by the virus through its interaction with the membrane glycoprotein CD4 of T lymphocytes. Glycosylation of gpl20 appears to be a prerequisite for CD4 binding: the non-glycosylated protein from cells grown in the presence of tunicamycin does not bind to CD4 and treatment of gpl20 with deglycosylating enzymes impairs binding. Of the various inhibitors of glycosylation tested, the most dramatic anti-viral effects observed have been with N-butyldeoxynojirimycin.
6.3. Leukocyte traffic Research carried out mainly during the last 5 years has demonstrated that adhesive interactions mediated by surface carbohydrates and surface lectins play a crucial role in leukocyte trafficking to sites of inflammation and hemostasis and in the migration (homing) of lymphocytes to specific lymphoid organs. In these processes, the carbohydrates serve as "area codes" which are interpreted by E-selectin, P-selectin and L-selectin, members of a family of endogenous lectins [33-35]. The selectins are highly asymmetric membrane-bound proteins. Their extracellular part consists of an amino terminal carbohydrate recognition domain (CDR), an epidermal growth factor-like domain and of several short repeating units related to complement-binding protein They bind specifically to sialyl-Lewisx (siaLe x in brief), NeuAc(ot2-3)Gal(131-4)[Fuc(o~l-3)]GlcNAc, and its positional isomer, sialyl-Lewis a (siaLea), NeuAc(o~2-3)Gal(131-3)[Fuc(o~l-4)]GlcNAc, with both fucose and sialic acid required for binding; sialic acid can be replaced by another negatively charged group such as sulfate. These proteins recognize the carbohydrate ligands only when the latter are present on particular
11 glycoproteins, such as cell surface mucins, pointing to the role of the carrier molecule and carbohydrate presentation in the recognition of the latter by lectins. The selectins provide the best paradigm for the role of sugar-lectin interactions in biological recognition. In broad outline, they all mediate, although with some differences, the adhesion of circulating leukocytes to endothelial cells of blood vessels, leading to the exit of the former cells from the circulation. The extravasation is necessary for the migration of leukocytes into tissues, such as occurs under normal recirculation of lymphocytes between different lymphoid organs or in recruitment of leukocytes to sites of inflammation. L-selectin, also known as "homing receptor", is found on all leukocytes. It is predominantly involved in the recirculation of lymphocytes, directing them specifically to peripheral lymph nodes. In contrast to the homing receptor the two other selectins are expressed mainly on endothelial cells, and only when these cells are activated by inflammatory mediators, mainly cytokines (e.g. interleukin-2 and tumor necrosis factor). The latter are released from tissue leukocytes in response to e.g wounding, infection or ischemia and induce the expression of P-selectin on the endothelial surface within minutes and of E-selectin within 3-4 hours. Recent experiments in animals have provided direct evidence for the role of selectins in the control of leukocyte traffic. For instance, in P-selectin deficient mice, generated by targeted gene disruption, the recruitment of neutrophils to the inflamed peritoneal cavity was significantly delayed [36]. The clinical importance of selectin-carbohydrate interactions in acute inflammatory responses in humans is illustrated by the finding that the neutrophils of two patients had a deficiency in SiaLe x [37]. The specific biochemical lesion responsible for this defect has not yet been established, but is believed to be a reflection of a general fucosyltransferase deficiency in these patients. In agreement with the ligand activity of SiaLe x, the neutrophils of the patients were unable to bind to E-selectin. The above findings imply that this inability prevents the neutrophils from migrating to the sites of infection and suggest that inhibitors of the selectins may be potent anti-inflammatory agents. Prevention of adverse inflammatory reactions by inhibition of leukocyte extravasation has become a major aim of many pharmacological industries. Preliminary experiments in animal models indeed show that oligosaccharides recognized by the selectins exert protective effects against experimentally induced lung injury. These approaches are now being evaluated for treatment of human disease.
7. OPEN QUESTIONS Although the enormous progress made in the last decade in many aspects of glycobiology "has finally opened a crack in the door to one of the last great frontiers of biochemistry" [38], many questions remain unanswered. The structures of the glycans encountered are exceedingly diverse and we are, as yet, unable to discern the principles that guide their formation. Although preliminary insights have been obtained into the central role of the polypeptide backbone in specifying glycosylation [28], the mechanism(s) by which the information encoded in the primary amino acid sequence is translated into a particular glycan structure is still not clear. A related problem concerns the molecular basis for the variations in glycosylation of the same protein between different species or cell types, and in the course of development, differentiation and oncogenesis.
12 The intriguing question of the function(s) of the carbohydrate is for most glycoproteins, whether soluble or membrane bound, still wide open, since only for a small number of glycoproteins, modulation of physicochemical properties or biological activities by their glycans has been demonstrated. One thing is clear: glycosylation can have markedly different effects on different proteins. This means that each glycoprotein must be examined individually and meticulously for the possible functions of the glycans it carries. Progress in this area will therefore be unavoidably slow. Still unresolved is the question of the biological relevance of microheterogeneity - in other words, can unique biological functions be ascribed to different components of the ensemble of glycoforms? The accumulation of evidence on the role of carbohydrates, whether bound to proteins or lipids, as recognition molecules is exceedingly rewarding. It serves as a strong impetus for improving techniques of structural analysis of carbohydrates as well as for the development of new methods of synthesis of oligosaccharides and glycomimetics, a challenge for the carbohydrate bioengineers. Recent developments also focus attention on lectins as co-partners in the recognition process. Of particular importance in this context is the need for a detailed knowledge of their combining sites [39], which should allow the design of highly effective carbohydrate anti-adhesive drugs.
8. A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T Special thanks are due to Dr. Halina Lis for her help in preparing this manuscript.
9. REFERENCES
1
N. Sharon, Complex Carbohydrates: Their Chemistry, Biosynthesis and Functions. Addison-Wesley, Reading, Massachussets, 1975. 2 H. Lis and N. Sharon, Eur. J. Biochem., 218 (1993) 1. 3 A. Varki, Glycobiology, 3 (1993) 97. 4 S. Kornfeld, Annu. rev. Biochem., 61 (1992) 307. 5 M.N. Fukuda, Glycobiology, 1 (1990) 9. 6 J. Jaeken, H. Carchon and H. Stibler, Glycobiology, 3 (1993) 423. 6a J. Jaeken, H. Schachter, H. Carchon, P. De Cock, B. Coddeville and G. Spik, Arch.Dis. Child., 71 (1994) 123. 7 B.D. Shur, Curr. Biol., 4 (1994) 996. 8 E. Ioffe and P. Stanley, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., USA 91 (1994) 728. 9 M. Metzler, A. Gertz, M. Sarkar, H. Schachter, J.W. Schrader and J.D. Marth, EMBO J., 13 (1994) 2056. C. Hammond and A. Helenius, Curr. Biol., 3 (1993) 884. 10 11 B. Shaanan, H. Lis and N. Sharon, Science, 254 (1991) 862. 12 A.J. Wittwer, S.C. Howard, L.S. Carr, N.K. Harakas, J. Feder, R.B. Parekh, P.M. Rudd, R.A. Dwek and T.W. Rademacher, Biochemistry, 28 (1989) 7662. 13 P.M. Rudd, H.C. Joao, E, Coghill, P. Fiten, M.R. Saunders, G. Opdenakker and R.A. Dwek, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 17.
13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39
R.J. Woods, C.J. Edge and R.A. Dwek, Nature Struct. Biol., 1 (1994) 499. M. Takeuchi and A. Kobata, Glycobiology, 1 (1991) 337. I. Leconte, C. Auzan, A. Debant, B. Rossi and E. Clauser, J. Biol. Chem.,267 (1992) 17415. K. Ishizaka, Annu. Rev. Immunol., 6 (1988) 513. R.A. Dwek, Glycoconjugate J., 10 (1993) 357. D. Spillman and U. Lindahl, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol., 4 (1994) 667. A.D. Lander, Chemistry&Biology, 1 (1994) 73. A. Darvill, C. Augur, C. Bergman et al., Glycobiology, 2 (1992) 181. I. Vijn, L. das Neves, A. van Kammen, H. Franssen and T. Bisseling, Science, 260 (1993) 1764. H. Yunovitz and K.C. Gross., Physiologia Plantarum, 90 (1993) 152. N. Sharon and H. Lis, Sci. Am., 268(1) (1993) 82. T. Feizi, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol., 3 (1993) 701. G. Ashwell, in Lectin Blocking: New Strategies for the Prevention and Therapy of Tumor Metastasis and Infectious Diseases (J. Beuth and G. P Pulverer, eds.), Gustav Fischer Verlag, Stuttgart Jena New York, 1994, p. 26. E.F. Neufeld, Annu. Rev. Biochem., 60 (1991) 257. J.U. Baenziger, FASEB J., 8 (1994) 1019. E. Beutler, A. Kay, P. Garver, D. Thurston, A. Dawson and B. Rosenbloom, Blood, 78 (1991) 1183. I. Ofek and N. Sharon, Curt. Top. Microbiol. Immunol., 151 (1990) 91. I. Ofek and R.J. Doyle, Bacterial Adhesion to Cells and Tissues. Chapman and Hall New York London 1994 I. Ofek, J. Goldhar, Y. Keisari and N. Sharon, Annu. Rev. Microbiol., 49 (1995) 239. L.A. Lasky, Science, 258 (1992) 964. M.P. Bevilacqua, Annu. Rev. Immunol., 11 (1993) 767. S.D. Rosen and C.R. Bertozzi, Curr. Opin. Cell Biol., 6 (1994) 663. T.N. Mayadas, R.C. Johnson, H. Rayburn, R.O. Hynes and D.D. Wagner, Cell, 74 (1993) 541. U.H. von Andrian, E.M. Berger, L. Ramezani, J.D. Chambers, H.D. Ochs, J.M. Harlan, J.C. Paulson, A. Etzioni and K.E. Arfors, J. Clin. Invest., 91 (1993) 2893. G.W. Hart, Curr. Opin. Cell Biol., 4 (1992) 1017. N. Sharon, Trends Biochem. Sci., 18 (1993) 221.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
15
NMR studies of the structure and dynamics of carbohydrates in aqueous solution Herman van Halbeek and Shuqun Sheng Complex Carbohydrate Research Center and Departments of Chemistry and Biochemistry, The University of Georgia, 220 Riverbend Road, Athens, Georgia 30602-4712, USA
Abstract
Notable recent developments in NMR methodology for studying carbohydrate structure and dynamics include the increased information gained from the observation of hydroxyl proton signals in supercooled water as well as improved measurements of long-range heteronuclear scalar couplings and 13C relaxation rates. This chapter presents an example of recent progress in each of those categories. (1) A 2-D homonuclear rotating-frame exchange experiment is proposed as a suitable means under supercooled aqueous conditions to detect transient intramolecular hydrogen bonds in the flexible disaccharide sucrose. (2) A modified 2-D 1H-detected heteronuclear multiple-quantum experiment is introduced for speedy and accurate measurement of nJcH (n>2); the application of the so-called HSMBC experiment is illustrated for sialyllactose. (3) The quantitative aspects of the dynamics of the hexasaccharide headgroup of ganglioside GDla embedded in a perdeuterated mixed micelle in aqueous solution are assessed by 1H-detected natural-abundance 13C Tlo measurements; the data are interpreted according to the Lipari-Szabo model-free approach which reveals relatively fast internal motions in the outer region of the hexasaccharide.
1. INTRODUCTION A detailed NMR analysis of the solution conformations and dynamics of a carbohydrate encompasses the following steps: 9 complete assignment of 1H and 13C NMR spectra of the carbohydrate; 9 establishment of spatial (distance and/or torsion angle) constraints between atoms from dipolar and scalar correlation NMR measurements; 9 measurement of 1H and 13C relaxation parameters (that is, T1, T2, Tip, homo- and heteronuclear cross-relaxation rates). Despite the efforts typically involved in conducting the pertinent NMR experiments [ 1,2], the experimentally measurable constraints may fall short in determining the complete conformation and dynamic behavior of an oligosaccharide. Evaluation of the experimental data with computational strategies is then a necessity, typically by using potential energy calculations and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations [3-5]. However, in favorable cases, the NMR study yields a sufficiently large number of constraints to broadly define the conformation of the oligosaccharide in aqueous solution. Often one finds that not all the
16 obtained NMR constraints are compatible with the existence of a single rigid structure, implying that the oligosaccharide is dynamic with respect to torsional vibrations around each glycosidic bond. The past few years have witnessed a vast increase in the number of efforts aimed at the measurement of NMR parameters directly related to the flexibility of carbohydrates, including 1H and 13C T1 and Tip, homo- and heteronuclear cross-relaxation rates, and global and local correlation times (reviewed in [6]). It is gradually becoming clear that very few oligosaccharides adopt a single, fully constrained ("rigid") conformation. The ability of most carbohydrates to present one covalent structure to their environment in many different ways may very well contribute to their versatility in biological functions. NMR spectroscopy not only helps to narrow the conformational space accessible to a flexible oligosaccharide, it also can provide information about the relative populations of and the rate of interconversion between different energetically favored conformers. We will discuss below three examples of this role for NMR in carbohydrate conformational analysis, namely, to aid in restricting the theoretically possible ensemble of conformations for a given oligosaccharide. We present a couple of recently developed NMR methods that provide either additional (hydrogen bond) or more accurately determined (3JcH) parameters to restrain the oligosaccharide structure in question. Also, a quantitative evaluation of 13C relaxation data is presented for a glycolipid system mimicking physiologic cell-surface conditions.
2. HYDROGEN BONDING Hydroxyl proton resonances in aqueous solutions of sugars were first observed over 15 years ago [7], but the value of these protons in the conformational analysis of carbohydrates has been demonstrated only recently [8-11]. Hydroxyl resonances have the potential to provide a wealth of structural information in the form of chemical shifts, 3JH_c_OH couplings, nuclear Overhauser effects (NOEs), and exchange rates. However, this information is accessible only if the intermolecular exchange of OH protons with solvent H20 can be slowed sufficiently. At room temperature, hydroxyl protons in aqueous solutions of carbohydrates engage in chemical exchange with water, the rate of which is very fast on the NMR time scale. Researchers at first applied mixed solvents (water/acetone and water/methanol) to study OH groups at low temperatures (-5 to -10~ (see, e.g., [9]). More recently, 1H NMR studies have been reported of hydroxyl groups in dilute solutions of monoand disaccharides in pure H20 under supercooled (-15 t o - 2 0 ~ conditions [10]. The chemical exchange rates under these conditions are reduced to such an extent that signals can be observed for each hydroxyl site; thus, all hydroxyl proton resonances can be assigned on the basis of (scalar or dipolar) connectivities to non-labile aliphatic protons. The line widths, temperature shift coefficients, and coupling constants of OH protons are valuable hydration and hydrogen-bonding probes in NMR studies [11]. Also, H/D isotope effects of hydroxyl protons/deuterons on 13C resonances can be used to obtain indirect evidence of the involvement of OH groups in intra- or interresidue hydrogen bonds [12]. Furthermore, protruding farther from the glycosyl ring systems than most CH protons, OH protons may serve as long-range sensor conformational probes which can be interrogated by NOESY and ROESY experiments on the carbohydrate in aqueous solution [8,9]. In order to use OH protons as conformational probes for oligosaccharides, special NMR techniques for water
17 suppression must be utilized [13-16]. We report below on the study of intramolecular hydrogen bonds in the disaccharide sucrose in aqueous solution. The three-dimensional structure of sucrose [Fruf-13(2~-~1)~-Glup] (Fig. 1), particularly the conformation of its glycosidic linkage, has been the subject of numerous investigations. Data obtained by NMR analyses and MD simulations on sucrose in solution have led to uncertainties concerning the degree of rigidity of the linkage conformation in solution [ 17-21 ], raising the question whether it is the same as in the crystal structure [22]. Careful 13C T1 measurements for sucrose revealed very fast and small-amplitude torsional and vibrational motions at different sucrose ring positions [23,24] and mobilities of the exocyclic groups different from the ring skeletons [25]; however, on the basis of this type of measurements the glycosidic linkage was judged to be rigid and similar in conformation to that observed in the crystalline state. In 1992, inspired by the work of P6rez c . s . [20], we reinvestigated the solution conformation of sucrose applying new NMR methods to reveal 1H/1H NOE contacts explicitly including OH protons [26]. The results of our quantitative NOE measurements are compiled in Table 1. Interestingly, all NOE connectivities found for sucrose in water solution can be explained in terms of a single conformation, which is virtually identical to the crystal structure. However, based on a quantitative analysis of the magnetic field strength dependence of 1H/1H NOE data, we questioned [26] the rigidity in solution of the sucrose glycosidic bond. The NOEs between protons on different rings proved to be magnetic field strength-dependent, while this did not seem to be the case for NOEs between protons within the glucopyranose ring. We interpreted this observation as evidence of rearrangements occurring around the glycosidic bond between the glucosyl and fructosyl residue that take place much more quickly than the tumbling rate of the molecule in solution. This type of internal motion is transparent to relaxation parameters (including 13C T1) if it occurs on the same time scale as overall molecular tumbling; this seems to be the case for sucrose at ambient temperature. Thus, we demonstrated that sucrose in solution more than likely experiences fast internal motion around its glycosidic bond.
Figure 1. Left: the crystal structure of sucrose (hydrogen bonds are represented by dashed lines) [22]. Right: the 600-MHz 1-D 1H NMR spectrum of sucrose in pure water, recorded at -17~ and pH 6.5.
18 Table 1. Apparent transglycosidic interproton distances for sucrose in aqueous solution Proton pair a Hlg/Hlf Hlg/H3f Hlg/H4f Hlg/H6f H5g / H4f Hlg / OHlf H 1g / OH6f H l g / OH3f H5g / OH3f OH2g / H 1f
Distance b (,&) 2.6 4.6 3.5 4.0 3.0 3.6 3.4 4.0 3.8 3.2
a Data were derived from NOE contacts
observed at 500 MHz and 27~ for CH, and at-10~ for OH protons [26]; 'g' denotes the glucosyl, 'f' the fructosyl ring. b Distances were calculated using the formula rij=((Yref/(Yij)l/6rref in which (Yrefand rre f represent the cross-relaxation rate of and the distance between a reference pair of protons. Intraglucosyl distances H lg/H2g (2.4 ]k), Hlg/H3g (3.7 A) and Hlg/H4g (4.0 ]k) were used as references.
Table 2. Temperature coefficients and scalar coupling constants of the hydroxyl protons of sucrose dissolved in pure water 3JH_c_OH c
Kb
Proton a
OHlf OH3f OH4f OH6f OH2g OH3g OH4g
-8.2 -8.8 -9.2 -11.0 -8.0 -10.3 -9.4
5.7 7.3 5.6 5.3 7.4 4.8 6.4
OH6g
-10.3
5.5
a ,f, denotes the fructosyl, 'g' the glucosyl ring. b Temperature coefficients (~) are in p p m / ~ 103; they were measured over the temperature range-18 to-8~ at 1~ intervals. c Scalar coupling constants (3Jn_c_on) are in Hz; the values were measured a t - 17~ OH H Ha\ ..Hb
3'1
H
-OH '
t.,
H ':2
"
..HOI ~ 0 1C H2
5 C H20H 6
In this study we refine our investigations of sucrose at low temperatures in aqueous solutions in an effort to shed light on the existence of any interresidue hydrogen bonds in the context of its newly revealed flexibility around the glycosidic bond. We were aware that a great deal of effort had been spent by others [27,28] examining intramolecular hydrogen bonding and determining its effect on the overall conformation of sucrose in solution. However, we are the first to use the hydroxyl proton signals of sucrose in supercooled aqueous solution as NMR probes for the detection of intramolecular hydrogen bonds. A capillary tube (1.5 mm i.d.) containing a 20 mM sucrose solution in HzO/D20 (9:1, v/v) was inserted into a 5-mm tube and, once placed in the magnet, the sample was gradually cooled to -17~ All of the sucrose OH signals were indeed observed in 1-1 echo water suppression [ 13] experiments (Fig. 1) and had lines sufficiently narrow to be assigned by a 2-D COSY experiment. Neither the OH temperature shift coefficients (see Table 2), 3JH_C_OH scalar couplings (see Table 2), 13C (COH v s . COD) chemical shifts, nor OH exchange rates allowed us to single out any sucrose hydroxyl group with characteristics significantly different from the others. However, 2-D rotating-frame exchange spectroscopy (ROESY) of sucrose under supercooled conditions revealed a direct exchange between the glucosyl OH2 and fructosyl OH1 protons (see Fig. 2). We conclude that the observation of chemical exchange between OH2g and O H l f ('g' denotes the glucosyl, 'f' the fructosyl moiety in sucrose) provides reasonable
19 evidence for the transient existence of an OHlf:::O2g (or OH2g:::Olf) hydrogen bond in solution under the applied supercooled conditions. This "weak" hydrogen bond is compatible with the flexibility of sucrose around its glycosidic bond. It appears that the intramolecular hydrogen bonding in sucrose is concentration dependent; the existence of hydrogen bonds OHlf:::O2g, OH3f:::O2g, and OH6f:::O5g at higher concentrations has been postulated based i.a. on 13C isotope effects [27]. The existence of the first two hydrogen bonds at high concentration in solution implies flexibility and fast interconversion between two conformers around the glycosidic linkage in solution; in the crystal state only OHlf:::O2g and OH6f:::O5g are observed. It should be noted that the aforementioned 1H/1H ROESY experiment can only detect direct chemical exchange between two OH groups, so it is restricted in its applicability to those hydrogen bonds that involve two participating OH groups (thus, ROESY cannot reveal any hydrogen bonding to ring oxygens). Moreover, the ROESY spectrum contains no information about the identity of the hydrogen-bond donor and acceptor and, therefore, cannot discriminate between the possibilities of an OHlf:::O2g and an OH2g:::O 1f hydrogen bond in sucrose.
I
2g/!f@ f
o
E Q_ EL IY)
-~;
4g
Q_ i
(D --
~
(.o
(~4f 6.6 1
6.~ 6.0 F2 (ppm) I
I
Figure 2. Hydroxyl proton region of a 2-D ROESY spectrum of sucrose in H20/D20 (9:1, v/v) recorded at 600 MHz, pH 6.5, and-17~ The effective spin-lock field strength was set to 1.5 kHz, and the ROESY mixing time was 100 ms.
20
3. HETERONUCLEAR LONG-RANGE COUPLINGS MEASURED BY A TWODIMENSIONAL H.S.M.B.C. EXPERIMENT The classic HMBC experiment [29] has long been recognized as a powerful means to qualitatively detect long-range heteronuclear couplings. For carbohydrates, the HMBC experiment provides the key to primary sequencing, exclusively and entirely based on tracing through-bond J-couplings, the only scalar couplings consistently observable across a glycosidic bond being the transglycosidic 3JcH [30]. However, determining from the HMBC cross-peak patterns the magnitudes of the involved nJcHwith sufficiently high accuracy is not straightforward. Cross-peak multiplets in HMBC spectra are recorded in mixed-phase mode in the 1H dimension due to evolution of 1H chemical shifts and homonuclear couplings during the relatively long delay period required for heteronuclear long-range couplings to evolve [31]. Direct extraction of heteronuclear coupling constants from non-pure absorption patterns is impossible. To find a reference spectrum of the oligosaccharide that has the same phase behavior as the cross peak in the HMBC spectrum is mandatory. A 2-D 1H/1H TOCSY spectrum recorded under otherwise the same conditions as the HMBC spectrum has been used successfully for this purpose [32]. Alternatively, the refocused HMBC experiment designed for the quantitative measurement of long-range coupling constant values based on the HMBC cross-peak intensities [33,34] uses either a 1-D version of the HMBC spectrum (obtained by omitting the 13C pulses from the original sequence) or a full 2-D HMQC spectrum as reference. Both approaches require, therefore, the recording of the reference spectrum in an experiment separate from the HMBC experiment itself. The method we propose here uses the original HMBC pulse sequence, without suppression of one-bond correlations. Indeed, the one-bond correlation peaks are essential because they provide the necessary references for the phase properties of the multiple-bond correlations. Hence, we refer to this experiment as HSMBC for heteronuclear single- and multiple-bond correlation spectroscopy. The pulse sequence of the 2-D HSMBC experiment is shown in Fig. 3. No separate, additional NMR experiment needs to be conducted to obtain an appropriate reference spectrum. Also, the reference peaks here have truly the same phase properties as the multiple-bond correlation peaks, as they are collected during the very same experiment. Values for the long-range couplings can be extracted applying the shift method introduced by Titman et al. [32]. We will illustrate the application of the HSMBC experiment for sialyl(z(2~6)-lactose (SL6):
H
oH
H
Ho
Hn ~9~c~H .
" " C . . " K 17 16 H C
ILI
o
H
21,~
OH
g
[
.~
6H
i4)~ ~
H
O
O/,\
oH ~
\
, "
n o - ~
H
Neu5 Ac- c~(2~ 6)- Galp- 13( 1-+4)- Glcp
OH
21
90x
1H
180x
~zx
tl/2
II
90t)l
Figure 3.
tl/2 9002
Pulse sequence of the 2-D HSMBC experiment. The phase cycling is as follows:
~)1 = X,-X; (~2 = X, X, X, X,--X,--X,--X,--X; t~3 = X,--X, X,--X,--X, X,--X, X.
The HSMBC spectrum of SL6 (Fig. 4) was recorded on a Bruker AMX-600 spectrometer (1H frequency 600 MHz, 13C frequency 150 MHz) using a 20 mM solution of the trisaccharide in D20 at pD 7.3 and 25~ The delay A was set to 45 ms, and the acquisition times t 2 and t 1 were 1.13 s (spectral width 1805 Hz, 4 K complex data points) and 25.6 ms (spectral width 10,000 Hz, 512 real data points), respectively. The relaxation delay was 1 s; 64 scans were accumulated per t~ increment. Quadrature detection in t I was accomplished by timeproportional phase incrementation. The total duration of the HSMBC experiment on SL6 was 15 h. The HSMBC data were processed using BioSym's FELIX software package, version 2.3, on a Silicon Graphics Personal Iris workstation. No multiplication by any window function and no zero-filling in t2 were applied before Fourier transformation. A cosine-squared window function was applied in the tl dimension; the first data point was multiplied by 0.5 to reduce t l noise. No zero-filling was applied in t l. The final resolution in the 13C dimension was 19.5 Hz/pt. Fourier transformation in both dimensions was followed only by phasing in F1. The pair of resulting 1H cross sections was selected that contain the 3JcH and 1JcH correlation multiplets for a particular proton. Each of these spectra was then subjected to Hilbert transformation (to create the imaginary part of the spectral slice) followed by inverse Fourier transformation; subsequent zero-filling to 16 K real points resulted in a digital resolution of 0.1 Hz/pt. After Fourier transformation, the baseline of the signals was carefully adjusted applying the "flat" routine in FELIX and any unwanted signals in the traces were zeroed. The selected 1JcH multiplet was then inverted, shifted by 0.5x3J(trial), and added to its parent multiplet which was shifted in the opposite direction by 0.5x3J(trial). The resulting convoluted multiplet was fitted to the experimental 3JcH multiplet. The calculations are performed by an in-house FORTRAN software routine on a DEC-3100 workstation. The best fit is achieved when COS ~ --
E.T
IElITI reaches its maximum [35], where E is the vector corresponding to the experimental 3JcH multiplet and T is the trial vector reconstructed from the reference multiplet by the procedure outlined above.
22
Neu H3e Neu H3a
Glccz H 1Gal H 1
.!
C) ! |
,0.
.o,
-o
i "~'
o t
Neu C5.b w . , q
,,, ,,
Neu C4.Glccz C5 ~ GIc C4~ Glccz C1~ Glcl3 C1-.Neu C2-,Gal C1/-"
o
E Q_
-o
Q-
,,,
,e.,
N
.,,
.-.
,,,~ll0Do.o
D
o,
(.O ~--,
,.
,....
.,
.-,
,D
..
9
9
..
O
9
LL_
-o
00
i
II
cb
,
!
El
-o
}, I
5.0
I
4.0 F2
I
3.0
(ppm)
Q
o
I
2.0
Figure 4. 2-D HSMBC spectrum of sialyl-(z(2-*6)-lactose in D20, recorded at 600 MHz, pD 7.3, and 25~
The procedure for obtaining the value of a particular long-range coupling constant is graphically illustrated for Glc(z 3JH1c5. Figure 5 shows the doublet taken from the one-bond Glccz 1JH1c1 trace of the HSMBC spectrum, and the subsequent reconstruction of the 3JH1c5 multiplet. The 3JH1c5 coupling constant obtained by this method is 6.5 Hz. This value is accurate to _+0.2 Hz, that is, within two times the digital resolution of the 1-D traces processed as described above. Figure 6 shows the matching patterns of five other nJcH multiplets for SL6, including those for the interglycosidic coupling 3JGa1H1-GlcC4- The values obtained by our method are marked in bold; the italicized values are those obtained by a quantitative HMBC experiment [34]. The selected subset of nJcH values for sialyllactose illustrates that the HSMBC method provides generally more accurate values for the desired couplings in a shorter period of time. The need to record a separate reference spectrum is circumvented, while the accuracy of the "Jfn values is significantly improved over the quantitative HMBC experiment. The HSMBC method also compares favorably with 1-D selective HSQC measurements of the same couplings in SL6 [36].
23 (a)
(b) (c)
31 I~I~, _1
'atrial /~~ [ 'aH1-H2
/v L_
(d) Figure 5. The J-fitting procedure as performed for Glco~ 3JH1c5 from the pertinent traces in the 2-D HSMBC spectrum of sialyl-~(2~6)-lactose. (a) Doublet of Glc~ H1 taken from the 1JH1c1 row; (b) inverted doublet 'a' left-shifted by 3Jnlcs(trial); (c) reconstructed multiplet obtained by co-adding 'a' and 'b'; (d) actual multiplet of Glc~ H1 taken from the 3JHlc5 row.
Gal H1-GIc C4
4.0
(3.9+_0.8)
Neu H3a-C5
+i
Neu H7-C8
Neu H3a-C4 (7.7+ 1.1)
Neu H3a-C2
io'
. ._+ . ~f~
Glccz H1-C5 65
('4.0__+0.+4)
(6.5+_0.9)~
Figure 6. Selected set of 2JcH and 3JcH couplings (__.0.2 Hz) for sialyl-a~(2~6)-lactose, resulting from the fit of experimental (bottom traces) and reconstructed (top traces) 2-D HSMBC cross-peak multiplets. The resulting coupling constant values (in Hz) are marked in bold. For comparison, the values determined by Zhu et al. [34] from a quantitative HMBC experiment on SL6 are included (in italics).
24 4. DYNAMICS OF MEMBRANE-BOUND CARBOHYDRATES
The molecular behavior of an oligosaccharide chain isolated from a glycoprotein or glycolipid hardly mimics the behavior of the chain when bound to a protein or a lipid. For example, the molecular motion of a freely tumbling oligosaccharide will be substantially different from that of the same oligosaccharide anchored to a protein backbone and/or in a lipid bilayer. It is likely that both molecular conformation and internal dynamics are affected upon covalent binding of an oligosaccharide to a protein or lipid. Thus, appropriate caution must be exercised when extrapolating from NMR-derived conformation and dynamics results on isolated oligosaccharides to judgments about similar structures linked to proteins or lipids. NMR efforts are getting under way to examine the conformation and dynamics of oligosaccharides as covalent parts of larger molecular weight glycoconjugates (both intact glycoproteins and glycolipids dispersed in lipid bilayers). Amphipatic in nature, isolated glycolipids aggregate in aqueous solution to form micelles. These systems, in defiance of their long overall rotational correlation times, are amenable to high-resolution NMR study and are the most revealing probes available so far for the study of internal motions in lipid-linked oligosaccharides. The conformation and dynamics have been studied of the carbohydrate headgroups of a number of glycolipids inserted in deuterated dodecylphosphocholine (DPC) micelles in DaO and/or H20 [37-40]. As an example, we present here some of our work on ganglioside GDla Neu5Ac'ot(2-+3)Gal'p~(1-+3)GalpNAc~(1-+4)[Neu5Acot(2-+3)]Galp~(1-+4)Glcp~(1-+ 1)Cer embedded in a perdeuterated DPC micelle in aqueous solution. Without the addition of an organic solvent, 1H NMR studies of GDla in a micellar membrane in H20 at --I~ revealed relatively narrow OH signals, allowing their incorporation in extensive NOE studies. It appeared [40] that the observed interresidue 1H/1H NOE contacts (involving both CH and OH protons) could not be explained by only a single conformation of the GDla hexasaccharide such as the quasi-rigid structures proposed in keeping with 13C T1 data for the GDla free oligosaccharide [41 ] in D20 and glycolipid [42] in DMSO. At least two families of carbohydrate conformers [differing in the relative orientation of the Neu5Ac'ot(2-+3)Gal'13(1-+3)external disaccharide arm; see Fig. 7(a)] must exist in this model membrane system to account for the NOE constraints. The internal dynamics of the oligosaccharide were probed by 1H-detection of the 13C relaxation parameters (T1, Tip, and heteronuclear NOEs) of the GDla hexasaccharide in the micellar system at 13C natural abundance. The results of these measurements are listed in Table 3. The 13C relaxation rates R1 and R2 were converted into the spectral densities J(m) at the pertinent frequencies [40,45-47]. Aided by an independent measurement of the global rotation correlation time 'co of the micellar system (from 31p NMR relaxation measurements on the DPC 31p signal), the spectral density data were interpreted at the molecular level with the Lipari-Szabo model-free approach [43,44]. As illustrated schematically in Figure 7(b), the model-free approach distinguishes the types of molecular motion of an oligosaccharide by their different time scales. The total motion of the molecule is separated into the tumbling of the entire aggregate (with rotation correlation time "Co) modulated by more rapid internal (segmental) motion with characteristic correlation time ('ci) and amplitude expressed by an order parameter ($2). The latter is a measure of internal reorientation (S 2 = 1 in the absence of reorientation; S 2 =0 in the presence of completely isotropic reorientation). The separation of
25
Figure 7. (a) Two conformers of GDla on the DPC micellar membrane, differing in the orientation of the outer disaccharide moiety [40]. (b) Diagram of GDla in a DPC micelle illustrating the independent global and local motion model, the characteristics of which can be described by the Lipari-Szabo equations [43,44]. the motions into distinct regimes is crucial to the success of this method. Thus, the internal dynamics (segmental motions) of carbohydrate molecules in solution can be assessed by NMR spectroscopy if the rearrangements occur much faster (or much slower) than overall molecular tumbling. The internal reorientations in GDla on the micellar surface were found to occur with a rotation correlation time of 0.35 ns. The slow tumbling of the micelle (Mr "" 8 kDa) provided the distinct time scale ('to 2.8 ns), facilitating the discovery of the faster internal motion of a couple of flexible glycosidic linkages in the carbohydrate headgroup [40]. The order parameter S 2 was measured for reorientation of the C-H vectors of each glycosyl residue. As computed from 13C Tip, S 2 was found to be --1.0 for internal residues and--0.5 for the terminal (Neu5Ac') and penultimate (Gal') residues most distal to the lipid (Table 3).
26 Table 3. Average 13C relaxation rates a and dynamics parameters b for the headgroup hexasaccharide in Gnla/DPC micelles in aqueous solution Residue
R 1 [s-1]
GalNAc Neu5Ac Gal, Glc
}
'cNeu5Ac' Gal
}
R 2 [s -1 ]
NOE
% [ns]
'17i [ns]
S2 1
2.2+0.2
12.5+2.0
1.2-+0.2
2.8-+0.1
0
2.3+0.2
7.1_+1.0
1.6_+0.2
2.8_+0.1
0.34_+0.10 0.55+0.08
a The 13C relaxation rates are defined as: R 1 = (T1)-1, and R 2 = (T19)-l. b Obtained by nonlinear least-squares optimization using the equations in Fig. 7(b). The relaxation data for the methylene carbons were not included in the analysis. c Data for Gal' C4 were not included.
Application of the methods discussed to larger complex oligosaccharides as well as to those tethered to proteins (see, for example, [48]) or lipid membranes will continue to provide valuable evidence on the question of internal motions on a time scale of the reciprocal of the NMR frequency range used in the experiment (0.1 to 1 ns). Motions on a slower time scale, which would not be detectable by ordinary 13C T1 experiments, can be studied by rotating-frame relaxation data (T10). With control of the spin-locking field strength, the latter parameter can reveal motions on the Bs time scale.
5. CONCLUSIONS Carbohydrate NMR spectroscopy has reached a level of sophistication at which the number of detectable constraints (including hydrogen bonds and glycosidic bond torsion angles) is sometimes large enough to be incompatible with a single rigid conformer, prompting the consideration of ensemble average models. Internal motion in oligosaccharides can be detected and quantified by NMR spectroscopy if it occurs relatively fast compared to the overall motion of the molecule. Tethering the oligosaccharide to a phospholipid micelle in aqueous solution satisfies this criterion. Knowledge of three-dimensional conformations and the dynamics/flexibility of complex carbohydrates in their natural environment will broaden our insight into their functioning as mediators of numerous biological cell-cell and cell-molecule interactions. It is anticipated that NMR spectroscopy will continue to make invaluable contributions towards this goal.
6. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The authors thank Drs. Leszek Poppe and John Glushka for helpful discussions and Rosemary Nuri for editing the manuscript. This research is supported by National Institutes of Health (NIH) grant P41-RR-05351 and Department of Energy (DOE) Plant Science Center grant DE-FG09-93ER20097.
27 7. A B B R E V I A T I O N S
The abbreviations used are: Cer, ceramide; COSY, homonuclear scalar correlation spectroscopy; DPC, dodecylphosphocholine; f, furanose; HMBC, heteronuclear multiplebond connectivity; HMQC, heteronuclear multiple quantum coherence; HSMBC, heteronuclear single- and multiple-bond connectivity; HSQC, heteronuclear single quantum coherence; MD, molecular dynamics; n-D, n-dimensional (where n=l, 2, or 3); NMR, nuclear magnetic resonance; NOE, nuclear Overhauser effect; NOESY, NOE correlated spectroscopy; p, pyranose; ROESY, rotating-frame Overhauser and exchange spectroscopy; SL6, sialyl-o~(2~6)-lactose; TOCSY, total scalar correlation spectroscopy. The symbols used are defined as follows: J, scalar coupling constant; J(c0), spectral density at frequency co; r, distance; S2, generalized order parameter; c~, cross-relaxation rate; Tt, longitudinal relaxation time; T2, transverse relaxation time; T10, longitudinal relaxation time in the rotating frame; "Co, global rotation correlation time; xi, internal (local) rotation correlation time; ~), torsion angle H1-C1-O1-C'x; ~t, torsion angle C1-O1-C'x-H'x; o3, torsion angle H5-C5-C6-O6.
8. REFERENCES
1 H. van Halbeek, in "Encyclopedia of Nuclear Magnetic Resonance," D.M. Grant and R.K. Harris (eds.), Wiley, Chichester, 1995, in press. 2 J. Dabrowski, in "Two-Dimensional NMR Spectroscopy. Applications for Chemists and Biochemists (Second Edition)," W.R. Croasmun and R.M.K. Carlson (eds.), VCH, New York, 1994, p. 741. 3 S.W. Homans, Prog. NMR Spectrosc., 22 (1990) 55. 4 S.W. Homans, in "Molecular Glycobiology," M. Fukuda and O. Hindsgaul (eds.), Oxford University Press, Oxford, 1994, p. 230. 5 S. PErez, A. Imberty, and J.P. Carver, Adv. Comput. Biol., 1 (1994) 147. 6 H. van Halbeek, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol., 4 (1994) 697. 7 M.C.R. Symons, J.A. Benbow, and J.M. Harvey, Carbohydr. Res., 83 (1980) 9. 8 J. Dabrowski and L. Poppe, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 111 (1989) 1510. 9 L. Poppe and H. van Halbeek, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113 (1991) 363. 10 L. Poppe and H. van Halbeek, Nature Struct. Biol., 1 (1994) 215. 11 B. Adams and L.E. Lerner, Magn. Reson. Chem., 32 (1994) 225. 12 J.C. Christofides and D.B. Davies, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 105 (1983) 5099. 13 V. Sklenfir and A. Bax, J. Magn. Reson., 74 (1987) 469. 14 V. Sklenfir, R. Tschudin, and A. Bax, J. Magn. Reson., 75 (1987) 352. 15 V. Sklenfir and A. Bax, J. Magn. Reson., 75 (1987) 378. 16 M. GuEron, P. Plateau, and M. Decorps, Prog. NMR Spectrosc., 23 (1991) 135. 17 B. Mulloy, T.A. Frenkiel, and D.B. Davies, Carbohydr. Res., 184 (1988) 39. 18 V.H. Tran and J.W. Brady, Biopolymers, 29 (1990) 961. 19 V.H. Tran and J.W. Brady, Biopolymers, 29 (1990) 977. 20 C. Herv6 du Penhoat, A. Imberty, N. Roques, V. Michon, J. Mentech, G. Descotes, and S. PErez, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113 (1991) 3720. 21 J.M. Duker and A.S. Serianni, Carbohydr. Res., 249 (1993) 281. 22 G.M. Brown and H.A. Levy, Acta Crystallogr., Sect. B, 29 (1973) 790. 23 D.C. McCain and J.L. Markley, Carbohydr. Res., 152 (1986) 73. 24 D.C. McCain and J.L. Markley, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 108 (1986) 4259.
28 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
D.C. McCain and J.L. Markley, J. Magn. Reson., 73 (1987) 244. L. Poppe and H. van Halbeek, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114 (1992) 1092. D.B. Davies and J.C. Christofides, Carbohydr. Res., 163 (1987) 269. B. Adams and L. Lerner, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114 (1992) 4827. A. Bax and M.F. Summers, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 108 (1986) 2093. F.J. Cassels and H. van Halbeek, Methods Enzymol., 253 (1995) 69. A. Bax and D. Marion, J. Magn. Reson., 78 (1988) 186. J.J. Titman, D. Neuhaus, and J. Keeler, J. Magn. Reson., 85 (1989) 111. G. Zhu and A. Bax, J. Magn. Reson. Ser. A, 104 (1993) 353. G. Zhu, A. Renwick, and A. Bax, J. Magn. Reson. Ser. A, 110 (1994) 257. P. Huber, C. Zwahlen, S.J.F. Vincent, and G. Bodenhausen, J. Magn. Reson. Ser. A, 103 (1993) 118. L. Poppe, R. Stuike-Prill, B. Meyer, and H. van Halbeek, J. Biomol. NMR, 2 (1992) 109. L. Poppe, C.-W. vonder Lieth, and J. Dabrowski, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 112 (1990) 7762. D. Acquotti, L. Poppe, J. Dabrowski, C.-W. von der Lieth, S. Sonnino, and G. Tettamanti, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 112 (1990) 7772. H.-C. Siebert, G. Reuter, R. Schauer, C.-W. vonder Lieth, and J. Dabrowski, Biochemistry, 31 (1992) 6962. L. Poppe, H. van Halbeek, D. Acquotti, and S. Sonnino, Biophys. J., 66 (1994) 1642. S. Sabesan, J.O. Duus, T. Fukunaga, K. Bock, and S. Ludvigsen, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 113 (1991) 3236. J.N. Scarsdale, J.H. Prestegard, and R.K. Yu, Biochemistry, 29 (1990) 9843. G. Lipari and A. Szabo, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 104 (1982) 4546. G. Lipari and A. Szabo, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 104 (1982) 4559. S. Bagley, H. Kovacs, J. Kowalewski, and G. Widmalm, Magn. Reson. Chem., 30 (1992) 733. P.J. Hajduk, D.A. Horita, and L.E. Lerner, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 115 (1993) 9196. J. Kowalewski and G. Widmalm, J. Phys. Chem., 98 (1994) 28. T.J. Rutherford, J. Partridge, C.T. Weller, and S.W. Homans, Biochemistry, 32 (1993) 12715.
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
29
Linkage analysis by mass spectrometry of chemically modified oligosaccharides from glycosphingolipids and glycoproteins Bo Nilsson National Defence Research Establishment, Department of NBC Defence, S-901 82 Ume~t, Sweden
Abstract Mass spectrometry of oligosaccharides gives structural information on monosaccharide sequence and depending on ionisation technique used, molecular weight. In order to extend the structural information to also include glycosidic linkage positions, specific chemical modif'lcations were introduced. Trifluoroacetolysis was used to specifically degrade high-mannose structures from the reducing terminal. Periodate oxidation followed by reduction, peracetylation or permethylation and analysis of the products by mass spectrometry gave on the basis of the sequence ions linkage positions between monosaccharide residues in oligosaccharides obtained from glycosphingolipids and glycoproteins.
1. INTRODUCTION In order to understand how biological compounds interact i.e. the structure - function relationship, structural analysis is essential. Biological phenomena work through specific interactions of chemical structures. Recent developments of cell systems for manufacturing of biologically important proteins for use in therapy have focused on post translational modifications such as glycosylation. Structural analysis of the carbohydrate chains has therefore become important in order to avoid cell systems that produce glycoproteins with glycosylation, which in humans can cause undesired immunological reactions and unfavourable serum clearance rate. Another type of biologically important glycoconjugates are glycosphingolipids, which are cell surface associated. Since the carbohydrate portion is exposed to the exterior it should be accessible to interactions with other molecules. Neutral and acidic glycosphingolipids have been implicated in several roles, for example receptors for bacteria, virus, bacterial toxins and as tumour associated antigens. Analytical methods for proteins are well developed, but carbohydrate-containing polymers have for long time been difficult to analyse. One of the reasons is that no other biological compounds can form so many isomeric species as carbohydrates. The great number of compounds that can be formed also indicates that the content of biological information is enormous. The biological functions of glycoconjugates are however still not completely
30 understood. Carbohydrates have in the past, in contrast to proteins and nucleic acids, been regarded as less interesting from biological point of view, which have resulted in that less efforts have been investigated in analytical techniques for this type of compounds. When spectroscopic methods as mass spectrometry (MS) and NMR were introduced a dramatic progress in structural analysis of glycoconjugates was noticed. A comprehensive strategy including MS and NMR for glycoprotein analysis has previously been published [1]. This contribution will focus on recent developments in mass spectrometry of glycosphingolipid- and glycoprotein oligosaccharides.
2. MASS SPECTROMETRY Structural analysis of glycoconjugates usually involves various types of mass spectrometric techniques. Traditionally electron ionisation mass spectrometry (EI-MS) of derivatised monosaccharides and oligosaccharides has been used. Compounds have to be volatile in order to be analysed by this ionisation technique. When fast atom bombardment mass spectrometry (FAB-MS) was introduced underivatised as well as derivatised high molecular weight glycoconjugates could be analysed. Later introduced techniques such as electrospray mass spectrometry (ES-MS) and time of flight mass spectrometry (TOF-MS) have further extended the mass range, allowing molecular weight determination of intact glycoproteins. These recently developed techniques have focused mainly on molecular weight determination rather than structural analysis. Carbohydrate-containing polymers differ from other biological substances in features of branching, multiple binding positions and the monosaccharide residues can usually not be discriminated by their masses. Structural analysis of glycoconjugates by mass spectrometry is therefore a special challenge. The structural information, that can be obtained, includes molecular weight and monosaccharide sequence in terms of hexose, deoxyhexose acetamido-deoxyhexose and sialic acid. In order to completely determine a structure several other features have to be assigned e.g. linkage positions between monosaccharide residues. Mass spectra are often recorded after derivatisation, peracetylation or permethylation, which in FAB-MS enhances the sensitivity. The sequence ions of derivatised compounds are formed by ionisation of the ring oxygen followed by a homolytic cleavage process of glycosidic bonds yielding cyclic oxonium ions. Presence of branch points can be determined by the absence of certain sequence ions. Only in exceptional cases binding positions between monosaccharides can be determined e.g. substitution positions of permethylated 2-acetamido-2-deoxyhexosyl (HexNAc) residues. After a primary cleavage of the HexNAc glycosidic bond in EI-MS or FAB-MS the relative intensities of the secondary fragments formed by eliminations determine the substitution pattern (Figure 1). The elimination takes place preferentially from the 3-position of the HexNAc residue [2]. Substitution positions of monosaccharide residues can be determined by gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC-MS) of partially methylated alditolacetates [3], but the sequential order of linkages is in general difficult to determine. NMR-Analysis or enzymatic methods can often provide this information if sufficient material is available. In order to extend the structural information to include linkage analysis in oligosaccharides by mass spectrometry, specific chemical modifications were introduced.
31 228
%
432
%
Hexl --4HexNAc I -
Hexl-3HexNAcl-
464 464
!
196
196 228
I .
m/z 402
m/z 432
% Hexl-3HexNAcl4 I deoxyHexl
196
I,
Hex ! -4HexNAe
638
4?2
I
I-
3 I deoxyHexl 638
196 ,
,
402 [
m~
Figure 1. Relative intensities in FAB-MS of primary and secondary ions derived from 3- and 4mono- and 3,4-disubstituted permethylated HexNAc residues.
3. CHEMICAL MODIFICATIONS Periodate oxidation was used to specifically modify monosaccharide residues in oligosaccharides [4]. Bonds connecting carbons carrying hydroxyl groups in vicinal positions are oxidatively cleaved and aldehydes are formed, which subsequently are reduced with NaBD4 (Figure 2). The product is then analysed after peracetylation or permethylation by GC-MS or FAB-MS depending on the size of the oligosaccharide. I periodate HCOH oxidation
I / C,,, NaBD 4 I acetylation or ] H O reduction HDCOH methylation HDCOAc
HCOH
H,
I
"c
I
//O
HDCOH
t
HDCOAc
I
I
HDCOMe or
HDCOMe I
Figure 2. Reaction steps used for preparation of derivatives for analysis by mass spectrometry.
The products obtained depend on linkage positions between residues and the mass values of ions formed by cleavage of glycosidic bonds for terminal and internal residues after permethylation and peracetylation are shown in Table 1.
32 Table 1 Mass values for terminal and intemal residues after periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and derivatisation Residue
Permethylation
Peracetylation
Non-reducing Hexl6-deoxyHexlHexNAclNeu5Ac2-
179 149 264 289
263 205 334 a
208 204 208 164 245 245
292 288 292 220 287 287
Internal -2Hexl-3Hexl-4Hexl-6Hex 1-3HexNAcl-4HexNAc 1-
Residue
Permethylation Peracetylation
-6HexNAcl-8Neu5Ac2-
249 361
291 a
105 192 148 104
161 304 232 160
-3HexNAc-ol 189 -4HexNAc-ol 233 -6HexNAc-ol 60
231 303 88
Reducing -2Hex -3Hex -4Hex -6Hex
Reduced
a No mass due to lactone formation
Terminal residues are always oxidised and internal hexosyl (Hex) residues are oxidised if 2-, 4- or 6-substituted, whereas 3-substituted are not. For permethylated compounds 2- and 4substituted Hex residues both give a mass increment of 208 mass units (m.u.), but the structures are different. A secondary fragment, formed by elimination of methanol, is seen from the 2-substituted, but not for the 4-substituted Hex residue [5]. In peracetylated samples these two products give in addition an ion formed by cleavage of the bond between carbon 5 and the former ring oxygen, which for the 2-substituted residue is constant of m/z 160, whereas for the 4-substituted the m/z value depends on the mass of the substituent [6]. Both 3- and 4substituted HexNAc residues are resistant to periodate oxidation. As in unoxidised and permethylated compounds these residues are differentiated by the secondary fragments formed by eliminations as will be illustrated by examples below. In order to determine the substitution position of a reducing 2-acetamido-2-deoxyhexose the periodate oxidation has to be carried out on the reduced compound. Substitution positions of branched residues can sometimes be determined (Table 2). A 3,6-disubstituted Hex-ol gives after periodate oxidation and NaBD4-reduction two products, ethylene glycol and glycerol. O-Linked glycans often contain a 3,6-disubstituted HexNAc-ol (GalNAc-ol), which will be cleaved by periodate giving two products, ethylene glycol and N-acetyl tetrosaminitol. In N-linked structures the HexNAc-ol (GlcNAc-ol) is usually 4,6-disubstituted, which is not cleaved by periodate. Another chemical modification, trifluoroacetolysis, is carried out in a mixture of trifluoroacetic acid (TFA) and trifluoroacetic anhydride (TFAA). This mixture has a powerful
33 acetylating property resulting in rapid trifluoroacetylation of hydroxyl groups. Glycosidic bonds are stabilised by inductive effect exerted by the O-trifluoroacetyl groups [7].
Table 2 Products obtained from some common reduced branched residues after periodate oxidation and NaBD4-reduction Branched residue Products
CHDOH 6
Hex-ol
/3
CHDOH
!%
,~
I CH [
CHDOH
~I~OH
CHNHAc ~6
3 HexNAc-ol
CHDOH [
c%
I I CHDOH
~CH
~HaOH
CHNHAc
I I ~CH I CHOH I ~Ct-I 2
CHOH
~6
/
4
HexNAc-ol
Oligosaccharides, N- and O-linked, are released from glycoproteins, as N-trifluoroacetylated derivatives [8, 9]. Under certain conditions glycoprotein oligosaccharides are specifically degraded from the reducing terminal [ 10]. Trifluoroacetolysis is also useful for liberation of the carbohydrate portion from glycosphingolipids [11]. Periodate oxidation in combination with trifluoroacetolysis has been used in structural analysis of high-mannose glycoprotein oligosaccharides, as will be discussed below.
34 4. GLYCOSPHINGOLIPIDS Neutral and acidic glycosphingolipids, isolated various species and cell types, have been subjected to numerous studies of their biological functions. Due to their lipophilic nature these types of compounds are suitable for separation by thin layer chromatography, which has been used for identification by comparison of migration with reference compounds. Neutral glycosphingolipids and gangliosides can be analysed by FAB-MS as underivatised compounds or after permethylation. Besides monosaccharide sequence, composition of the ceramide moiety can be deduced from the spectra [12]. Only in permethylated samples and in the presence of internal HexNAc residues substitution position of these residues can be determined as previously discussed. In order to determine other glycosidic linkages by FAB-MS, periodate oxidation can be used on intact glycosphingolipids [5]. An alternative approach is to release the oligosaccharide from the ceramide portion and then perform the periodate oxidation.
4.1. Release of oligosaccharides The carbohydrate portion of glycosphingolipids can be released by chemical or enzymatic methods. Treatment of neutral glycolipids or gangliosides, containing an unsaturated sphingosine base, with ozone followed by mild base liberates the oligosaccharide [ 13]. Another chemical method, trifluoroacetolysis, also requires an unsaturated sphingosine base and works best on neutral glycosphingolipids. When used on gangliosides partial loss of sialic acid is seen. From N-acetyl hexosamine-containing glycosphingolipids the oligosaccharides are released as N-trifluoroacetyl derivatives, which after permethylation are suitable for analysis by GC-MS [ 14]. An altemative to chemical methods is treatment with enzymes. Enzymatic methods have an advantage in that both the carbohydrate moiety and the ceramide can be recovered separately, which is useful in studies of the ceramide residue. There are number of ceramidases commercially available e. g. from the medicinal leech and from the earth worm Lumbricus terrestris [ 15, 16]. 4.2. Mass spectrometry of glycosphingolipid oligosaccharides Ozonolysis of the GM3 ganglioside released the oligosaccharide: Neu5Acot2-3Gall] 1-4Glc The trisaccharide was subjected to periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and permethylation. Analysis of the product by GC-MS gave a spectrum shown in Figure 3. The primary sequence ion of m/z 289 together with a secondary of m/z 257, formed from the primary by elimination of methanol, are characteristic for a periodate oxidised non-reducing terminal sialic acid. A disaccharide sequence of Neu5Ac2-3Gall- is deduced from the above ions together with rn/z 493. The linkage position between these residues is determined by the mass increment of 204 m.u. representing a periodate resistant hexosyl residue, which therefore must be 3-substituted (Table 1). The alditol-containing ions of m/z 148 and 352 show that the reducing glucose is 4-substituted. These two ions give rise to secondary ions of m/z 116 and m/z 320, respectively, by elimination of methanol. An ion of m/z 89, formed by cleavage within the alditol, shows two O-methylated carbons. El-Mass spectra of carbohydrates never give molecular ion species. In this case an [M-59] § ion of m/z 598 is seen, which is a loss of a
35 methoxycarbonyl radial (. COOMe) from the molecular ion, typical for EI-spectra of sialic acid containing oligosaccharides.
257
188. 9B
289
w r 8B z "~ 7B o z 6B =)
Me
~.
181
LU 4B >
3B
~ 2B w n- IB
~N
31
89
493
MeOOC--I]
Mel
co 5B
~
257+- 289 MeO
i
I
I
L--'0"+" 352
I
ICHOMe
I CIH20Me 148 [M-59]+
493
1481 183
......... t,++
CHDOMe
O
#' "-I-- I ~
159 I
116
ICH2OMe--7
,. . 2++
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
,,,
4++
3++
....
1.4!946,5..I,
[ +B+
598 . . . . . . . . . . .
m/z
+m+
Figure 3. GC-MS spectrum of the GM3 oligosaccharide after periodate oxidation, NaBD4reduction and permethylation.
Treatment of the GTlb ganglioside with ozone liberated the oligosaccharide with the structure of:
Neu5Ac0~2-3Gal[31-3GalNAc[~ 1 ~ 4 Neu5Ac~176
j
3 Gal131-4Glc
A FAB-mass spectrum obtained after the above periodate treatment is shown in Figure 4. A disialyl sequence of Neu5Ac2-8Neu5Ac2- can be deduced from the primary sequence ions of m/z 289 and m/z 650, where the latter ion is an increase of 361 m.u. (Table 1). The linkage between these residues must therefore be 2-8 since the intemal sialic acid residue is not oxidised by periodate. Any other linkage position between these residues would make the internal sialic acid susceptible to periodate and thereby give rise to other ions than the above. Another sialylated sequence of Neu5Ac2-3Gal 1- is determined by the primary sequence ions of m/z 289 and m/z 493 as previously discussed. This monosialylated sequence is linked to the 3position of the GalNAc, determined from the primary sequence ion of m/z 738 and a secondary of m/z 228. Elimination of the Neu5Ac2-3Gal sequence gives rise to m/z 228 specific for a 3substituted 2-acetamido-2-deoxyhexosyl residue [ 17]. The substitution pattern of the branched
36 galactosyl residue cannot be inferred from the spectrum. An [M+23] + ion (molecular ion plus sodium) of m/z 1765 is consistent with a periodate oxidised G-m, oligosaccharide. After trifluoroacetolysis of globoside and reconstitution to the N-acetyl derivative the globo-N-tetraose oligosaccharide was obtained: GalNAc[31-3Galc~ 1-4Gal]31-4Glc
289 228
21i7
[M+23]* 17 ;5
,u ;8. z0
~ 58. m ~ 58.
g,
]8.
1888
m/z
493
288
488
]88
738
588
257 ..,-289 MeOOC'~
G88
493 CH2OMe~
228 "4---738 CH2OMe" ~
1
MeO
I
MeO MeOOC I
Me ~ .
,o%,---od Meo
~
257 4-- 289
788
MeNAc Me ~.
MeOOC
I
,,c-'~,~--~od MeO
___1
888
CH2OMe
/
MeO
2
988
1~8
m/z
?HDOMe
CH2OMe
650
Figure 4. FAB-MS spectrum of the G'rlb oligosaccharide after periodate oxidation, NaBD4reduction and permethylation.
Treatment with periodate as above and analysis by FAB-MS gave a spectrum shown in Figure 5. A periodate oxidised non-reducing terminal GalNAc is determined by the primary
37 sequence ion of m/z 264 and a secondary of m/z 232, formed by elimination of methanol. These ions combined with m/z 468 and m/z 676 show a sequence of GalNAcl-3Gall-4Gall-. The ion of rn/z 676 is an increase of 208 m.u. to m/z 468 and means a 2-substituted or 4-substituted Hex residue. Substitution in the 2-position can however be excluded since no secondary fragment, formed by elimination of methanol, is seen [5]. Substitution of the reducing glucose in the 4-position is calculated from the [M+23] + ion of m/z 863 and the sequence ion of m/z 676.
264
CH,,OMe
IJJ (J z I-
MeODHC
I
676
CH,~OMe'~
~,HoOMe'~
]~l' J, " ~ m ~ M e O D H C OMe
CHDOMe
CHDOMe
MeNAc
i HO CH2OMe
68
""< ..J UJ
2(i4
flail. 96. 88 ~0
468
~t t,
>400 x3 it
232
4g.
31.
1s2 let 14e
I
I
347
468
'[
I
7~9 I
~
I
,[
J~s
e37863 IM+2 m/z
m
Figure 5. FAB-MS spectrum of globo-N-tetraose after periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and permethylation. Reprinted from: Carbohydr. Res. 168 (1987) 15. Copyright 1995 Elsevier.
5. GLYCOPROTEINS Production of recombinant proteins and monoclonal antibodies for use in therapy and diagnosis has renewed the importance of glycoprotein analysis. A complicating factor when working on glycoproteins is the heterogeneity among the oligosaccharides. A given glycosylation site often has several different structures. In order to carry out structural analysis the oligosaccharides have to be released from the polypeptide chain and purified to homogeneity. Separation of released oligosaccharides has traditionally been a problem due to the small differences in structure. New HPLC columns have, however, dramatically improved the separation methods, allowing separation of neutral as well as acidic isomeric structures [ 18, 19]. Structural analysis has been carried out by chemical, enzymatic and spectroscopic methods. Complete structural determination can in most cases be performed by NMR
38 spectroscopy if sufficient material is available. Mass spectrometry usually requires less material but complete structural determination cannot be obtained. 5.1. Release of oligosaccharides There are a number of chemical and enzymatic methods to liberate carbohydrates from glycoproteins. A chemical method frequently used to release N-linked oligosaccharides is hydrazinolysis [20]. After N-acetylation and mild acid treatment the oligosaccharides are recovered as free reducing compounds. O-Linked oligosaccharides are partially degraded from the reducing terminal, using this method. The most commonly used method to release O-linked glycans is reductive 13-elimination [21 ]. By using harsher conditions this procedure can also be used to liberate N-linked structures, which then have to be re-N-acetylated [22, 23]. When using these alkaline degradation methods the carbohydrates are recovered as oligosaccharide alditols. Trifluoroacetolysis is another chemical method for release of N- and O-linked glycans [8, 9]. Sialic acid is partially lost, which makes this procedure more suitable for asialoglycoproteins. The fate of a reducing hexosamine depends on the proportions of TFA/TFAA and under certain conditions this method can be used to specifically modify high-mannose structures, as will be discussed below [24]. All chemical methods suffer more or less from degradations or modifications of the reducing terminal of the released glycans. A viable alternative is therefore enzymatic methods. Several specific endoglycosidases are commercially available. Intact N-linked oligosaccharides can be obtained by treatment with PNGase F from Flavobacterium meningosepticum. For release of O-linked glycans there is an O-glycanase which releases the disaccharide GalI31-3GalNAc from Ser/Thr but not if this disaccharide is substituted. The specificity and sources of endoglycosidases have been reviewed elsewhere [25]. After separation of released glycans structural analysis can be carried out. 5.2. Mass spectrometry of N-linked oligosaccharides Glycoprotein oligosaccharides have been subjected to structural analysis by FAB-MS mostly as permethylated derivatives. In order to extend the structural information beyond sequence and molecular weight, periodate oxidation was used. The procedure used includes the same reaction steps as previously mentioned for glycosphingolipid oligosaccharides. Since almost all glycoprotein oligosaccharides, N- or O-linked, contain a reducing terminal HexNAc the periodate oxidation has to be carried out on the NaBIL-reduced compound in order to be able to determine the substitution position of this residue (Tables 1 and 2). The above procedure was applied to a biantennary oligosaccharide alditol with a structure of: Neu5 Aco~2-6G al [31-4GlcNAc 131-2Manor1 6 /3 Neu5 Ac~2- 6G all31-4GlcNAc]31-2Manor 1"
Man[31-4GlcNAc]31-4GlcNAc-ol
The FAB-mass spectrum obtained is shown in Figure 6. A non-reducing terminal periodate oxidised sialic acid is recognised by the primary and secondary fragments of m/z 289 and m/z 257. These sequence ions combined with m/z 698, from which a secondary ion of m/z 666 is formed, determine a sequence of Neu5Ac2-6Gall-
39 4GlcNAcl-. As previously discussed elimination from a HexNAc takes preferentially place from the 3-position in this case elimination of methanol giving m/z 666 [ 17]. Substitution in the 6-position of the GlcNAc residue can be excluded since this residue would then be oxidised, 289 U..I
Z
2520
9g
80 7g
Z
257
G6
<1: LU Sg i-'-
4it
_J LU 3g,
228 L 233
High mass scan
2gg
378
3oo
478
48g
378 (453)
6e~. . . . . . . . .
seB
o.IIo/, o, ~'CHDOMe ~J I / J' ~ P "" "~_j~'MeOCHD / Iu\ ~ i MeODHC' I "
MeO
CH2OMe~ ] o
J ~
378 MeOOC O
/
I
257 ~-- 289
MOeocHD
l
874 4--906
o
e
233
~ Hoh
o
~MeOL~
MeODHC r
I
(453)
O.
OMe
~ ~
CHrOMe
O
O
e
O
~]
MeO ~
, ..e N ~Ac
478
J--'--CH2OMe j CHOMe
MeODHC ==m=~If~,JrO --CH2
CHrOMe O
7a. . . . . . . . . 0h. . . . . . . . . sa. . . . . . . . i0'D8
CH2OMe"~
MeNAc
I - CH'~
874 906 m/z
666 ~ - 698
MeOOC---] f- CH-~2 ~
CHDOM.
666
Low mass scan
257 4-- 289
>800 x3
I
ii i
~L~
Me.
m/z 698
196
2g.
Ac/
[M+23]*
OO M ~ ~ O T '
~H I CHDOMe
MeNAc
I M e O D H C ==~====If "I"*O
666 ~-- 698
874 ~-- 906
Figure 6. FAB-MS spectrum of a biantennary oligosaccharide alditol after periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and permethylation. Reprinted from: Protein Glycosylation, Cellular, Biotechnological and Analytical Aspects. GBF Monographs 15 (1990) 125. Copyright 1995 VCH.
giving other sequence ions than the above. No sequence ion corresponding to cleavage of the oxidised Gal residue, which would be m/z 453 is seen, instead an ion of m/z 378 is formed by cleavage of the carbon 5 and the former ring oxygen bond of the periodate degraded Gal residue. Both antennae of this biantennary structure contain 2-6 sialylated sequences. These sequences are linked to the 2-position of a mannose residue, deduced from the primary and secondary ions of m/z 906 and m/z 874, respectively. As previously discussed a periodate oxidised 2-substituted hexosyl residue gives a secondary ion by elimination of methanol, in this case m/z 874, which is not seen for a 4-substituted (Figure 5). Using the periodate oxidation
40 allows determination of all glycosidic linkage positions in the linear sequences. Substitution positions of the branched mannose residue can, however, not be determined from the mass spectrum. Since the periodate oxidation was carried out on the reduced compound the 4substitution of the reduced GlcNAc residue is determined from the ion of m/z 233 and combined with m/z 478 the chitobiose structure is established. An [M+23] § ion of m/z 2520 gives supporting evidence for the structure. This method is also useful when screening for sequences in mixtures of structures. The triantennary oligosaccharide fraction from a mouse monoclonal IgA antibody was analysed by FAB-MS after the above periodate treatment [26]. The sequence ions determining linkages in the outer linear sequences are indicated in Figure 7.
289
Gal IIO--4GIcNAcl.-]-O I 392--424 GalIIOB3GaI1--O--4GIcNAcl-~.
88. u.I
r~ Z
<
J
596"- 628
78.
cl z::::) 61t. m ,< 58, LIJ > i
257
257-'-
289
378, (453)
666-- 698
Neu5Ac2-]--OI3G.~O~4GIcNAc_~-O~ 257"-289
493
706"-738 Fucl
196
I
6
BO~lcNAc--ol
I 214
410 ~TR 3 9 2 424 -;~ \ 41 01
288
388
488
628 I
fin
688
698 I I 706
7ffi
m/z
8811
Figure 7. Part of a FAB-MS spectrum of a mixture of triantennary structures after periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and permethylation. Reprinted from: Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 300 (1993) 335. Copyright 1995 Academic Press.
All GlcNAc residues in the antennea of the triantennary structures are 4-substituted deduced from the secondary fragments of m/z 392, m/z 596, m/z 666 and m/z 706, which all are results of eliminations of methanol. Furthermore the ion of m/z 410 shows that the reducing GlcNAc is substituted in the 6-position by a fucose residue. High-mannose structures are less favourable to analyse by FAB-MS as permethylated derivatives due to the absence of branches with N-acetyl hexosamine residues, which as shown above give abundant sequence ions. Peracetylated derivatives are in this case preferable. Two
41 methods for linkage analysis of high-mannose structures by mass spectrometry have previously been published [6, 24]. The first method is based on periodate oxidation and analysis by FABMS and EI-MS of peracetylated and permethylated derivatives. This method allows determination of all glycosidic linkage positions including substitution of branched residues. An example of application of this method is demonstrated on a Man6GlcNAc compound with the following structure: Manor 1 ~ 6 Manor 17
3 Manc~1 ~ 6
Manor 1-2Mano~1j
Man~31-4GlcNAc
3
Periodate oxidation of the NaBH4-reduced compound followed by NaBD4-reduction, permethylation and analysis by FAB-MS gave a spectrum shown in Figure 8. An intense sequence ion of m/z 179 is seen representing the non-reducing terminal mannose residues. A secondary sequence ion of m/z 355 formed by elimination of methanol from m/z 387, which is not seen, determines the Manl-2Manl- sequence [6]. Substitution of the reducing GlcNAc residue in the 4-position is established by the ion of m/z 233. The spectrum also gives information on substitution positions of branched residues. Studies on high-mannose structures have shown that 3,6-disubstituted residues give rise to alditol-containing ions where the positive charge is located on carbon 6 of the disubstituted residue [6]. Two such ions are seen in the spectrum, m/z 809 and m/z 1177. The former ion shows that the Man 1-2Man 1- sequence is linked to the 3-position of the 3,6-disubstituted Man adjacent to the reducing GlcNAc residue. The latter ion, m/z 1177, shows that the other 3,6-disubstituted residue is substituted in the 3-position by a single Man residue. From the [M+I] + ion of m/z 1373 it can be calculated that this branched residue also carries a single Man residue in the 6-position. The intensifies of the branch-specific ions of m/z 809 and m/z 1177 are more prevalent in direct-probe EI-MS. The second method, which is exemplified below, uses degradation with trifluoroacetolysis. Treatment with TFA/TFAA in proportions 1/1 (v/v) at 100~ for 48 h specifically degrades compounds with a reducing terminal N-acetyl hexosamine resulting in products quantitatively depleted of the reducing HexNAc residue [ 10]. For high-mannose structures, as protein-linked or as free reducing compounds, this means that the chitobiose sequence is lost and a mannose residue occupies the reducing terminal position. High-mannose compounds frequently contain a 3,6-disubstituted residue linked to the chitobiose. After TFA/TFAA treatment and reduction (NaBI-h) periodate oxidation is carried out followed by a second reduction (NaBD4). The 3,6disubstituted mannitol will be cleaved by periodate giving two products a glycerol containing two deuteriums and an ethylene glycol with one deuterium (Table 2). The products obtained are analysed after peracetylation by FAB-MS or GC-MS. The procedure described above was applied to the following pentasaccharide: Manotl-3Manotl~ 6 Manor 1j
3 Manl31-4GlcNAc
42 The GC-MS spectra obtained are shown in Figure 9.
IW.
233
179
1177
~._c~ICH2OMe | i
1' '9
MeODHCMeoDHC" "I- O .CH2
809
179 ~MeOOt~ ~'~~~
c.,o,. ] M.O7 / I-2-~
LU 78,
@ z <
M ' ~ 1 7 6 oo. c
68, z no 50.
W ~
='~
" . . . . . . . ___! 179
3O
l
498
1
0
J. CHDOMe
J
3 5 5 - - - (387)
>650 x5
355
o
~
I CH2OMe
[~ .....Ac J~.OM. otc.
CH2OMe t MeO~mm~
Oo. c
MeODHC
o
- o - - -
CH2OMe X
IJJ >~ 4o
~
233
[ M+I]+ 1373 /
_
809
1177
......
1~$2
'LLL ''
m/z
Figure 8. FAB-MS spectrum of Man6GlcNAc-ol after periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and permethylation. Reprinted from: Methods in Molecular Biology: Glycoprotein Analysis in Biomedicine 14 (1993) 35. Copyright 1995 Humana Press. A periodate oxidised, NaBD4-reduced and peracetylated non-reducing terminal hexosyl residue is recognised by the cleavage ions of m/z 160 and m/z 263. The former ion is formed by cleavage of the bond between carbon 5 and the former ring oxygen. Spectrum A shows a glycerol residue from m/z 161 and together with m/z 264, formed by cleavage within the oxidised non-reducing terminal Man residue, it can be concluded that the spectrum represents the mannose linked to the 3-position of the 3,6-disubstituted Man residue in the original pentasaccharide. The other component formed gave spectrum B. An ethylene glycol residue is determined from the ion of m/z 88. The sequence ions of m/z 263 and m/z 551 determine a sequence of Manl-3Manl-. Sequence ions containing the ethylene glycol residue of m/z 376 and combined with m/z 479, formed by cleavage within the oxidised non-reducing terminal, confirm the linkage of the disaccharide sequence. This structure represents the Manl-3Manlbranch, which is linked to the 6-position of the 3,6-disubstituted mannose residue of the
43 original pentasaccharide. Using this method all glycosidic linkage positions including substitution positions of the branched residue can be determined.
uJ () lOe_ < I~1 88 z 23 El 68 < W
160
160 161
A
161 U--
CH '2OAc
I ~
264 / O r / - - - - I CHDOAc
Acoo.:.' ?~_- o1'~ ~coDNC, I " IF 263
CHDOAc
48
> 200 x 5
263 264
--I
"[:I: '
O
..~,L
'~
..........
60
80
d. "~
i1~I.
.... ,,
~08
'I ~
.. I
i~8
. . . . . .
1i8
,'~ II
,~,.~ I. .
168
100
,~,
R16 ,,,,~
L
~8
2~0
2i0
. . . .
i
2go
- 208
3~ m/z
I.U O
Z
186.
6e. I',-I LU
88
/~
Acoo.
A~ ~ - - _ _ _ 1
263
88
48.
O'[~
OOA~
551
> 300 x 10..
ZO
fl:: 8
376
A~
LJJ " >
160
160
B
188
146
.........L . ,,,., L4~_--.:-.L IBO
263 J
I
dd~ i~q:l 2BB
3~e
332 31~ [ ;1 _ ii
9
"3 7 6 .,.,
.,.
l
_
,
4ee
4is . , .
. . .
479 4~3 ( , . . . .
see
_
. . . . .
551 , .
.
.
.
see
m/z
Figure 9. GC-MS spectra of Man4GlcNAc after trifluoroacetolysis, NaBH4-reduction, periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and peracetylation. (A) Branch connected to the 3position of the 3,6-disubstituted mannose residue. (B) Branch connected to the 6-position of the same disubstituted residue. Reprinted from: Anal. Biochem. 200 (1992) 58. Copyright 1995 Academic Press.
5.3. Mass
spectrometry
of O-linked
oligosaccharides
Oligosaccharides linked to Ser/Thr are released by alkaline borohydride as alditols, which is an advantage when structural analysis is carried out by periodate oxidation and mass spectrometry. To illustrate the use of this method on O-linked structures the following linear pentasaccharide alditol was chosen: Gall31-3GlcNAc]31-3Gall31-4GlcNAc[31-6GalNAc-ol Analysis of the intact compound by FAB-MS as permethylated derivative gave spectrum A in Figure 10. Primary sequence ions from the non-reducing terminal of m/z 464, m/z 668 and m/z 914 show a linear tetrasaccharide sequence. An alditol-containing ion of m/z 276 shows a monosubstituted GalNAc-ol and combined with the alditol-containing ions of m/z 521 and m/z 971 the linear sequence is confmned. The substitution positions of the GlcNAc residues can be
44 determined from the intensities of the secondary fragments. As previously discussed secondary fragments derived from a HexNAc residue are formed by preferential elimination from the 3position of this residue [2]. The primary sequence ion of m/z 464 gives a secondary of m/z 228 showing a Gall-3GlcNAc 1- sequence. A secondary ion of m/z 882 formed from m/z 914 by elimination of methanol shows that GlcNAc residue adjacent to GalNAc-ol is 4-substituted. No other linkage positions can be deduced from the spectrum. The monosaccharide composition is confirmed by an [M+I] + ion of m/z 1207. The FAB-mass spectrum of the oxidised compound as permethylated derivative is shown in spectrum B. The sequence ions from the non-reducing terminal of m/z 424 and m/z 228 show a Gall3GlcNAcl-sequence. The secondary fragment of m/z 228 determines the linkage position between the residues in agreement with data obtained from the intact compound (Spectrum A). The sequence ion of m/z 628 means addition of 204 m.u. to m/z 424 and consequently a periodate resistant residue which in this case is a 3-substituted Gal residue. The primary sequence ion of m/z 873 and a secondary of m/z 841 formed from the primary by elimination of methanol show a 4-substituted GlcNAc residue in accordance with the data obtained from the intact compound. From the ion of m/z 873 and an [M+I]+ ion of m/z 951 it can be concluded that the alditol has been shortened to ethylene glycol, which is a product of periodate oxidation of a 6-substituted GalNAc-ol. Supporting evidence for the sequence and linkage positions is furnished by the alditol-containing ions of m/z 305 and m/z 754. In most O-linked structures the GalNAc-Ser/Thr is 3,6-disubstituted. After treatment with alkaline borohydride the GalNAc-ol in the released oligosaccharide alditol is cleaved by periodate giving two products (Table 2). This is examplified by the following trisaccharide alditol: Neu5Ac(x2~ 6 GalNAc-ol Gal~l ~ 3 Analysis of the products by GC-MS after permethylation gave spectra shown in Figure 11. Spectrum A shows a periodate oxidised non-reducing terminal Gal determined by the cleavage ions of m/z 179 and m/z 104. Ions from the alditol part of m/z 189 and m/z 130 show an Nacetyl tetrosaminitol, which is a product of cleavage by periodate of the GalNAc-ol [27]. The spectrum represents the structural element Gall-3GalNAc-ol of the original trisaccharide alditol. The other part of the compound gave spectrum B. As previously discussed the oxidised sialic acid is recognised by the primary and secondary ions of m/z 289 and m/z 257, respectively. An alditol-containing ion of m/z 60 shows an ethylene glycol residue. The base peak of m/z 306 is a loss of a methoxycarbonyl radical from the moleuclar ion. These ions show that the GalNAc-ol is substituted in the 6-position by a sialic acid residue, establishing the structural element Neu5Ac2-6GalNAc-ol of the intact compound.
45
228
2 2 8 --- 4 6 4
668
, ,
uJ U Z r~ Z :::) <(: uJ > .J W -"
8 8 2 ---
914
70 68
971
521
276
58
]0
/196 I
,6, 432L
914
,,2 ~
521
4a
zlm
4,
[M+ll
6a
668
Bio
1207
8821
1
lia
~2r00
m/z
228 2 2 8 -,- 4 2 4 CH2OMe
80 w 0 Z Z
,..:
/,l MeODHC
78
o
~
CH2OMe
0
G0
< u,i > "I<:
so
r
]~
~O/~eO~o
~
~
0
CH~O ~
B
841 -- 873 CH,~O
!
~0
~O~?Me
~
J
~
Pur~n,J^
[,.,+23]
305
/
i.. LM+
" 24 196
951
"l~JlJ lJ/ I l l~,~ . 288
/ ........
O-CH2
~
754
48.
8
628
'
[ ' 368
4OO
754 ............ 500
512
liB_"; . . . . . . 600
663 695 7~?f;
/
[873 ~t;
I"~, ~,A . . . . . . . 788 880
1 I
I /
98
[ :~. . . . . . . 9OO
[89~
m/z
Figure 10. FAB-MS spectra of Gall 1-3GlcNAcl31-3Gall31-4GlcNAc[31-6GalNAc-ol. (A) Intact permethylated. (B) After periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and permethylation. Reprinted from: Methods Enzymol. 193 (1990) 587. Copyright 1995 Academic Press.
46
104 -~2OM e
189
I10 io
)
-~o
1l 5i3
Ii
11;
15;
..!,L ~z.,ll,L..~,!,,,, ...... ,I,, ........ ,........... ,,.............. -,......... ,..,, ............ ,..,I ....... , 188 15e
8
I 130
/
CHDOMe
Jh
~e~.~
29.2
60 I CHDOMe
x5
38p 32e
3~e
Jl,
"
h
[M-45]* 339
,h
m/z
3~8
[M-59] + 306
o --I- C H 2
88 z 28 m 68 ,:( 50. LIJ ,18 > 38 I-.18
--J-:(~H
264
179
c}
rr
I~.N.-~e
>300
MeOOC
LIJ
o
179
LU O zoB, z 88
,,.I
264
MeODHCI~eODHC~
88
;~
189 r CH2OMe
MeO
I
257 * " 289 60
4~ 5"1
9B
oe
58
'
t2e
113
I8fl
I
143 1~6 158
183
2gl 288
24625 7 2)3 289 22`1232 ,L,L . . . . . . L...... L. 258
.,~
388
35B
m/z
Figure 11. GC-MS spectra of Gal131-3[Neu5Aco~2-6]GalNAc-ol after periodate oxidation, NaBD4-reduction and permethylation. (A) Residue linked to the 3-position of the GalNAc-ol. (B) Residue linked to the 6-position of the GalNAc-ol. Reprinted from: Carbohydr. Res., 239 (1993) 35. Copyright 1995 Elsevier.
6. CONCLUSION In order to completely establish an oligosaccharide structure several structural parameters have to be determined e.g. linkage positions, sequence, identification of the monosaccharide building blocks and absolute- and anomeric configurations. One way to address some of these problems by mass spectrometry is to work on chemical modifications of the constituent monosaccharide residues in such a way that differences in mass lead to structural information, as an alternative to investment in costly instruments. Choice of ionisation technique is important, since the structural information depends on formation of fragment ions. El-MS and FAB-MS, in contrast to softer ionisation techniques, produce intense cleavage ions. Specific chemical pretreatments using periodate oxidation and trifluoroacetolysis have added another dimension to structural analysis of glycoconjugates by mass spectrometry, allowing determination of linkage positions in one single analysis. The chemical transformation used has to be specific and the yield of the reactions employed should be quantitative, otherwise wrong conclusions regarding the structure can be drawn from the spectra. Trifluoroacetolysis when used on high-mannose structures satisfies the demands. Periodate oxidation is a quantitative and specific reaction as determined by FAB-MS. However, some large and highly branched high-mannose structures sometimes give incomplete oxidation. This
47 problem could easily be resolved by further oxidation after reduction and complete oxidation was achieved.
7. R E F E R E N C E S 1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27
A-S. Angel, G. Gr6nberg, G. Nilsson, S. Str6mberg and B. Nilsson in Protein Glycosylation: Cellular, Biotechnological and Analytica Aspects. GBF Monographs. H.S. Conradt (ed.), VCH, New York, 15 (1990) 125. G. Gr/3nberg, P. Lipniunas, T. Lundgren, K. Erlansson, F. Lindh and B. Nilsson, Carbohydr. Res., 191 (1989) 261. H. Bj6mdal, C.G. Hellerqvist, B. Lindberg and S. Svensson, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. Engl., 9 (1970) 610. I.J. Goldstein, G.W. Hay, B.A. Lewis and F. Smith, Methods Carbohydr. Chem., 5 (1965) 361. A-S. Angel, F. Lindh and B. Nilsson, Carbohydr. Res., 168 (1987) 15. A-S. Angel, P. Lipniunas, K. Erlansson and B. Nilsson, Carbohydr. Res., 221 (1991) 17. B. Nilsson and S. Svensson, Carbohydr. Res., 69 (1979) 292. B. Nilsson and S. Svensson, Carbohydr. Res., 72 (1979) 183. B. Lindberg, B. Nilsson, T. Norberg and S. Svensson, Acta Chem. Scand., B33 (1979) 230. B. Nilsson and S. Svensson, Carbohydr. Res., 65 (1978) 169. B. Nilsson and D. Zopf, Arch. Biochem. Biophys., 222 (1983) 628. P. Pfthlsson and B. Nilsson, Anal. Biochem., 168 (1988) 115. H. Wiegandt and G. Baschang, Z. Naturforsch., Teil B 20 (1965) 164. B. Nilsson and D. Zopf, Methods Enzymol., 83 (1982) 46. Y.-T. Li, Y. Ishikawa and S.-C. Li, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun., 149 (1987) 167. M. Ito and T. Yamagata, J. Biol. Chem., 261 (1986) 14278. A-S. Angel and B. Nilsson, Methods Enzymol., 193 (1990) 587. M.R. Hardy and R.R. Townsend, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA., 85 (1988) 3289. R.R. Townsend, M.R. Hardy, D.A. Cumming, J.P. Carver and B. Bendiak, Anal. Biochem., 182 (1989) 1. T. Mizuochi, K. Yonemasu, K. Yamashita and A. Kobata, J. Biol. Chem., 253 (1978) 7404. D.M. Carlson, J. Biol. Chem., 243 (1968) 616. Y.C. Lee and J.R. Scocca, J. Biol. Chem., 247 (1972) 5753. H. Krotkiewski, B. Nilsson and S. Svensson, Eur. J. Biochem., 184 (1989) 29. P. Lipniunas, A-S. Angel, K. Erlansson, F. Lind and B. Nilsson, Anal. Biochem., 200 (1992) 58. F. Maley, R.B. Trimble, A.L. Tarentino and T.H. Plummer Jr., Anal. Biochem., 180 (1989) 195. P. Lipniunas, G. Gr6nberg, H. Krotkiewski, A-S. Angel and B. Nilsson, Arch. Biochem. Biophys., 300 (1993) 335. H. Krotkiewski, E. Lisowska, G. Nilsson, G. Gr6nberg and B. Nilsson, Carbohydr. Res., 239 (1993) 35.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
49
Development of a novel enzyme based glucose sensor F. Spener, R. Steinkuhl, C. Dumschat, H. Hinkers, K. Cammann and M. Knoll Institut ftir Chemo- und Biosensorik Mtinster, Mendelstr.7, D-48149 Mtinster, Germany
Abstract
Glucose oxidase from Aspergillus niger is an extremely stable, FAD-dependent enzyme that has found wide application in electrochemical sensing of glucose in blood. Conventional sensor technology immobilises this enzyme in membranes deposited on top of the transducer. Here we report a new containment technology where the glucose oxidase is immobilised in gelatine or polyvinylalcohole and is deposited in the chip in pyramidal containments produced on silicon by anisotropic etching. This configuration of the sensor enhances the adhesion and stability of the membrane and has been applied to monitoring glucose in serum discontinuously as well as continuously in a flow-through system. Moreover we demonstrate the applicability of the containment technology to monitor glucose ex vivo with the help of a microdialysis system.
1. INTRODUCTION 1.1. Glucose oxidase
Glucose oxidase (I]-D-glucose: oxygen 1-oxidoreductase, EC 1.1.3.4) is a FAD-dependent enzyme that catalyzes the oxidation of ~-D-glucose by dioxygen to hydrogen peroxide and 8gluconolactone, which subsequently hydrolyzes spontaneously to gluconic acid. Apart from glucose monitoring in food, drinks and fermentation processes the most important application of this enzyme is in clinical diagnostics. Here it is used as a component of colorimetric diagnostic kits, of dry reagent test strips, and more recently of biosensors for the determination of glucose in blood, serum of plasma. Glucose oxidase (GOD) exhibits useful properties with respect to widespread application in biosensors because of the high specificity for glucose and an extremely high stability [1]. The enzyme has been isolated from various moulds, from red algae, citrus fruits, insects and bacteria. The most widly used enzyme in terms of research and commercialized products, however, is that from Aspergillus niger, a glycoprotein with a high-mannose type carbohydrate content of 10 to 16 % of its molecular mass. The carbohydrate component appears to be in form of a branched polysaccharide that partially surrounds the protein core [2]. Many of the enzyme's physical properties, such as high solubility in water and resistance to proteases for example, may be ascribed to its carbohydrate shell. Partial removal reduces the enzyme's stability.
50
Figure 1. Tertiary structure of FAD-containing glucose oxidase (monomer) from
Aspergillus niger [3]. The holo-enzyme is a homodimer, where each subunit contains the tightly bound (Kd = 1 x 101~ but not covalently attached coenzyme (FAD), and the reaction mechanism is essentially
H=O=,hydroquinones
Glucose " ~
S
GODo,-
= d ) ' -~ - ~
reduced mediators
,_ E ~
Fe(CN)=
~'~ ~
DCPIPH~
Glucose-GODo=
Glucono.~,,,..,,~
lactone
GOD~
DCPIP, low charge density Fe(CN)3, high charge density phenoxazines, ferrocenes,TTF, TCNQ 02, quinones
Figure 2. Natural and artifical substrates in redox reactions catalyzed by glucose oxidase from
Aspergillus niger.
51 dependent on this coenzyme. The recently unraveled tertiary structure of glucose oxidase (Fig. 1) from A. niger [3] shows that this enzyme allows electron acceptors other than dioxygen to reoxidize the reduced FAD in the same way. This is important for the application of the enzyme in the amperometric approach to glucose sensors, because the transfer of electrons between the active site of the reduced enzyme and an electrode takes place slowly or not at all. Transfer of electrons can be facilitated if a small electron acceptor is used as a mediator [ 1]. These compounds have the advantage that they allow amperometric biosensors to operate at relatively low potentials, and this can lead to a decrease in interference from electroactive compounds (Fig. 2).
1.2. Biosensors Given the extraordinary operational stability of glucose oxidase and the world-wide high demand for monitoring glucose in the blood of patients with type I diabetes (insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus) as a parameter for insulin injections that compensate the defect in insulin production by the pancreas, it is no surprise that the foremost application of biosensors to date is in the medical field. Initially biosensors for monitoring blood glucose have been used as analyzers in clinical laboratories. The US-company Yellow-Springs Instruments was the first to offer commercial glucose analyzers, based on the patent of L.C. Clark. Today the decentralized employment of point of care diagnostics in the doctor's office or in intensive care units and the bed-side measurements in hospitals are of greater interest (for example the multiparameter sensor of ISTAT Corp. Princeton, USA). Of utmost importance today, however, is self-testing by patients using miniaturized electrodes with immobilized GOD for blood glucose sensing. In this area 3 sensor systems are in different states of development. A big success already are the commercially available, disposable pen- or card-type sensors. The more provocative approach aims at continuous monitoring of blood glucose to attain normoglycemia and to avoid acute metabolic disturbances. With this in mind work on the development of implantable biosensors is going on for years. Due to the - in this case still limited - stability of the enzyme and still not optimal biocompatibility of all the sensor materials used, this concept has not yet been realized. A solution in the far future may be artificial organs, such as the pancreas, with an inbuild glucose sensor and insulin pump in nanotechnology. The more realistic concept for realization in the near future is a continuously working microdialysis system, were dialysates of the subcutaneuos tissue are channeled to a sensor for continuous glucose monitoring ex vivo [4]. Our approach to the glucose sensor is based on the GOD-catalyzed oxidation of glucose to gluconolactone and concomitant reduction of dioxigen to H202. The latter is electrochemically oxidized at a platinum anode. The anode is polarized at + 600 mV vs. an Ag/AgC1 reference electrode. Often the enzyme is immobilized in a membrane coveting the surface of the anode. The current depends linearly on the glucose concentration in the solution [5]. Until now most enzymatic biosensors have a membrane fixed on top of the transducer. This method often leads to malfunction of the sensor arising from problems like inadequate membrane adhesion and insufficient mechanical stability. Dipcoating procedures are difficult to perform in a reproducible way in order to obtain sensors with identical performances. Sensors with membranes that have separately been casted and mounted to an electrode can hardly be miniaturized and are therefore not suited for potential implantation.
52 In order to solve these problems we developed a new concept for membrane deposition [6, 7], the so called c o n t a i n m e n t s e n s o r s on the basis of micromechanically etched cavities in silicon substrates (<100> crystal orientation, 380 lam thick) with openings towards the analyte solution between 120 and 480 lam width, where the membrane is not located on but in the chip (Fig. 3). At the sides of the cavities platinum electrodes are deposited by means of semiconductor technology such as photolithography and physical vapour deposition. Here we demonstrate the application of this technology to the sensing of glucose in body fluids.
Pt Si SiO 2
Containment with immobilized enzyme
Figure 3. Schematic view of the containment sensor.
2. EXPERIMENTAL
2.1. Chip fabrication A silicon wafer (p-type, 3-inch, (100)-surface, 380 l.tm thick, optically polished on both sides) was oxidized in wet ambient at 1200 ~ for 210 min to get a 1.5 l.tm thick oxide layer. Spin-coating was performed sequentially with HMDS (hexamethyldisilazane) as adhesion promoter and photoresist (AZ 5214E/Hoechst) at 4000 rpm followed by a prebake at 90 ~ for 5 min. The resist layer had a thickness of 1.4 pm. It was exposed to about 80 mJ/cmz of mid UV radiation through a photomask to define the containments on the front side of the wafer. Development with AZ 524MIF/Hoechst was followed by a postbake at 120 ~ for 60 s. A protective coating was then applied to the back side of the wafer to withstand the following oxide etching process which was carried out with BOE (buffered oxide etchant) to get quadratic holes in the front side. Photoresist and protective layers where removed and silicon was etched anisotropically in 20 % KOH solution at 75 ~ for 6 h to create the containment holes. The silicon oxide was then stripped with hydrofluoric acid and a new 150 nm thick oxide layer was created thermally in dry oxygen at 1050 ~ In order to form platinum electrodes the front side of the wafer was first sputter deposited with a 1/am thick aluminum layer which acts as a sacrificial layer for reliable platinum patterning in a lift-off process. Using our newly developed electrospray-coating technique the aluminum layer was subsequently covered with a photoresist layer, again AZ 5214E from
53 Hoechst, which was now used in image 2 reversal mode. The prebake at 90 ~ for 5 min was sequentially followed by a 40 mJ/cm UV exposure through a photomask, a reversal bake at 120 ~ for 5 min, a 320 mJ/cm UV flood exposure, and development with AZ 524MIF. Then aluminum etching was performed with phosphoric acid etchant (PES 83.5-5.5-5.5/Merck) to get a negative mask for the following application of the platinum electrodes and conducting lines. A 200 nm thick platinum layer was then sputter deposited and patterned by removing the aluminum layer in a sodium hydroxide solution. Anodic bonding of a Pyrex | was performed at 500 ~ and 300 V for 60 min. Finally the chips were separated.
glass wafer
2.2. Enzyme immobilisation and membrane deposition The buffer (pH 7.0) was prepared by solving 8.1 g NaC1 (Merck), 0.272 g KH2PO 4 (Sigma), and 0.697 g K2HPO 4 (Sigma) in 1 1 deionized water. GOD (200 U/mg) was obtained from Fluka. 50 mg of acid photo gelatine (Filmfabrik Wolfen, Germany) were allowed to swell in 0.5 ml deionized water for 60 min at room temperature. Then 0.5 ml of the prepared buffer (pH 7.0) solution were added. After mixing the solution was kept at 35 ~ for 60 min, then different amounts of GOD-powder were added to 100 lal of the warm stirred gelatine solution in a small Eppendorf vessel. The vessel with the enzyme was placed in a chamber and the transducer chip was dipped into the enzyme-solution to cover the containment opening with it. Then the chamber was evacuated in order to fill the containment with the gelatine solution. After gelling the sensor surface was cleaned and the sensor was examined under a microscope to ensure a properly filled containment. Then the sensor was stored in buffer solution until the first measurement. Furthermore polyvinylalcohol functionalized with stilbene groups (PVA-SbQ) was used for enzyme immobilization [8]. 1600 U GOD were dissolved in 5 0 0 m g PVA-SbQ 500-88 solution. The solution was filled into the containment and then the PVA-SbQ was hardened by UV-irradiation. 2.3. Measurements The measurements were performed in a two electrode configuration. A chloridized silver wire was used as reference electrode. A voltage of 0.6 V was applied between the containment electrode and the Ag/AgC1 reference electrode (potentiostat Autolab PSTA 1 0 / 4 channel, Eco Chem). The sensors were tested in the buffer solution described above. Before starting calibration the sensors were polarized until the current was lower than 1 hA, which took about one hour. Known amounts of a highly concentrated glucose solution (Merck) were added to the stirred buffer solution to obtain the calibration graphs. When not in use the sensors were stored in buffer solution at 4 ~ The sensor was also probed in a flow system (fixed in a block of acrylic glass with a dead volume of approximatly 10 laD, equipped with a pump from Meredos and a valve from Knauer were used (the flow rate was 50 pl/min). The response time was obtained from the response curves in the flow system. The stability of the sensor was determined by immersing the polarised sensor together with the chloridized silver wire in stirred undiluted human serum (purchased from Sigma) and recording the current. The concentration changes in the undiluted serum were obtained by adding known amounts of high concentrated glucose solution.
54 3. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION The response curves and the corresponding calibration graphs of simultaneously measured containment sensors with different opening sizes (120, 250, 480 pm length of a side) toward the analyte solution are shown in Fig. 4. All sensors with gelatine based membranes responded fast and stable on changes in the glucose concentration. As expected the sensitivity of the sensors increased with increasing opening size. The detection limit was lower than 0.05 mM.
9
30O
'1'
9
i
Glucose / mM
9
i
9
~
350
;
-" -~
25O
300
9
I
"
250
y
-
< c .~ 150 !
.i
100
0
0.416 C 9
I
1.0
,
120 pm opening slzej I
1.5
m
/
200 150
/./f---I
"
/
I
"
l
pm
f
100
1.11 50
< t--
"
B
.
2O0
l
9
I
,
I
2.0 2.5 Time / h
a
I
3.0
,
II
3.5
50 0
9
"~
2
1
2
0
pm
4 6 8 Glucose I mM
10
Figure 4. Dependence of signal on the opening size (edge length) of the containment sensor toward the analyte solution. A, response curves; B, calibration curves. Glucose (0.139 - 9.12 mM) in buffer; 1600 U GOD/ml gelatine-solution.
In Fig. 5 it is demonstrated that the sensor is well suited for a flow system configuration. The sensor responded linearly and reproducibly in a concentration range relevant for continuous subcutaneous monitoring of glucose in a microdialysis system, if the microdialysis needle and flow rate are chosen properly. The response time (t90) in the flow system (Fig. 5) is 65 s for the change in concentration from 0.5 to 1.25 mM, and 104 s for the change from 1.25 to 0.5 mM.
55 60
I
5.0
9
I
9
I
9
9
I
"
I
"
I
so
mM
14
5O
"
"
//"
1.25
B
I
"
I
"
I
"
I
mM
50 2O
40
10
12
'
0
< =
Gluoou
30
2.5
mM
I mM
........
20 1.25
8
10
.........................................
6 |
0.0
9
I
0.5
9
I
1.0
9
I
,
1.5
I
9
2.0
I
,
2.5
I
9
9
3.0
I
9
1700
I
1800
9
I
1900
,
II,
ii
I
9
I
9
I
9
I
8600 8700 8800 8900
Time I s
Time I h
Figure 5. Response curve (A) and response time (B) of the containment sensor in the flow system. Glucose concentrations in buffer; 1600 U GOD/ml gelatine-solution; flow rate 50 pl/min.
160
.
,
'
I
'
,
'
/A'
'
,
140 t20 100
< =
80
=rob
60
+ 1. 2mM + 1.2 m M ~ j ' - ~
+ 1.2 mM
serum
/
40
,..J
new polarization 20
0,
, 20
,
~ 25
,
~ 3o
,
~ 35
,/~,0.4,
2
Time I h
Figure 6. Stability of the containment sensor during measurements of glucose in undiluted human serum. 2400 U GOD/ml gelatine-solution.
56 As demonstrated in Fig. 6, the sensor shows a stable signal in undiluted human serum over more than two days. This demonstrates the applicability of the sensor in undiluted body fluids. Because the linear range of the gelatine based membranes was not sufficient in undiluted probes, the photosensitive PVA-SbQ was chosen for the immobilization of GOD. The calibration plot indeed shows a wider linear range (Fig. 7). 100
I
. . . .
I
'
'
'
'
I
'
'
'
100
'
I
A
'
I
'
I
,
I
'
I
m
I
'
I
m
I
"
I
m
I
B 80
80
60
60
<
<
r-
C
40
40
20
..__/-
/.--.
20
0 I 0
,
,
,
,
I 50
,
,
,
,
I 100
T i m e I min
,
,
,
,
I 150
I 0
,
10
20
30
40
I 50
G l u c o s e I mM
Figure 7. Response curve (A) and calibration curve (B) of the containment sensor with GOD immobilized in PVA-SbQ (1500 U/500 mg solution).
It is possible to store the sensors with GOD immobilized in PVA for more than 3 months in the refrigerator with a minute decline in sensor characteristics only. The influence of interfering substances was not investigated but a behavior similar to planar sensors using the same materials is expected. The results show that enzyme membrane deposition in silicon containments makes glucose sensors with good analytical response behaviour feasible. Linear range, in particular the normal physiological range of 3.9- 6.1 mM (70- 100 mg/dl) for glucose in blood and above in the diseased state, as well as lifetime and response times are reasonable well and acceptable for most practical applications, also for use in flow systems combined with microdialysis sampling. In the introduction we alluded to the lack of stable, implantable and long lasting glucose sensors [9, 10]. On the way toward this goal one immediate solution with application potential is the development of a miniaturized microdialysis system. Such a microdialysis system under development in our laboratory is shown in Fig. 8.
57
B
A gas-pressurized spnng
peffusion-solutio~ I
syringe
.
microcontainment-
f
microdia~/sis-ch~o
,,,
11
i
waste
C silicon t/on
Figure 8. Schematic view of the microdialysis system. A, Principle; B, lay-out of the microdialysis-chip; C, integrated microcontainment sensor.
The analytical response behaviour of these containment sensors is comparable with other sensor configurations which are fabricated in silicon planar technology, but offers the following advantages: - Containment sensors are very robust because the mechanically sensitive membrane is protected inside the chip against damage. Also adhesion problems with the membranes are minimized since they are attached inside the containment. Membrane patterning is not needed. - Encapsulation is no longer a problem since the main components of the sensor (membrane and metal electrodes) are located inside the containment. Encapsulation is further simplified -
58 due to the fact that the conducting leads and the sensitive sensor surfaces are located on opposite sides of the wafer. Thus, encapsulation can be performed on the top side of the whole wafer. - Containment sensors are ideally suited for integration into microsystems as the dead volume added to the system is minute. - The fabrication process is entirely compatible with mass-production technologies since it is a full wafer process. In mass production even the membrane deposition can be performed as full wafer process either under vacuum or with an automated dispense system. Only soldering the plug must be done after the chips have been separated. In conclusion, the containment concept allows the fabrication of glucose sensors with good analytical response behaviour and with a considerably improved technology.
4. REFERENCES
1 2 3
R. Wilson and A. P. F. Turner, Biosens. & Bioelectron., 7 (1992) 165. J.H. Pazur, K. Kleppe and A. Cepure, Arch. Biochem. Biophys., 111 (1965) 351. H.J. Hecht, H. M. Kalisz, J. Hendle, R. D. Schmid and D. Schomburg, J. Mol. Biol., 229 (1993) 153. 4 C. Meyerhoff, F. J. Mennel, F. Bischof, F. Sternberg and E. E. Pfeiffer, Horm. Metab. Res., 26 (1994) 538. 5 F. Scheller and F. Schubert, B iosensoren. Akademie-Verlag, Berlin, 1989. 6 M. Knoll, German Patent DE 4115414A1 (1991). 7 R. Steinkuhl, C. Sundermeier, C. Dumschat, K. Cammann and M. Knoll, German Patent application Nr. P 4337418.2 (1993). 8 R. Renneberg, K. Sonomoto, S. Katoh and A. Tanaka, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 28 (1988) 1. 9 G . S . Wilson, Y. Zhang, G. Reach, D. Moatti-Sirat, V. Poitout, D. R. Th6venot, F. Lemonnier and J.-C. Klein, Clin. Chem., 38 (1992) 1613. 10 S. J. Updike, M. C. Shults, R. K. Rhodes, B. J. Gilligan, J. O. Luebow and D. von Heimburg, ASAIO J., 40 (1994) 157.
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
Carbohydrate
binding
at the active
site of Escherichia
59
coli
maltodextrin phosphorylase P. Drueckes, D. Palm and R. Schinzel Theodor-Boveri-Institut ffir Biowissenschaften der Universit~it Wtirzburg, Physiologische Chemie I, Am Hubland, D-97074 Wtirzburg, Germany
Abstract The oligosaccharide binding site of E. coli maltodextrin phosphorylase was characterised by a site-directed mutagenesis approach. Kinetic studies with oligosaccharides of different length imply that the oligosaccharide binding site consists of five subsites. Subsite five contributes about 14 kJ/mol to binding. Mutations of active site residues E67, E350 and H536 impair oligosaccharide binding significantly. Based on molecular modelling studies residues E350 and H536 appear to be important parts of subsite five, while residue E67 most likely contacts subsite two, which also seemed to be important for binding. Subsites three and four appeared to contribute only little to oligosaccharide binding energy.
1. INTRODUCTION Glycogen phosphorylases (EC 2.4.1.1) are key enzymes of the carbohydrate metabolism. They catalyse the phosphorolytic cleavage of t~-l,4-1inked glucose units to produce t~-Dglucose 1- phosphate: glucose, + P~ +--)glucosen_l + glucose 1-phosphate In muscle glucose 1-phosphate is further metabolised via glycolysis to provide energy, and in liver phosphorylase helps to maintain a constant blood glucose level via the action of glucose 6-phosphatase [4]. Therefore, suppression of glucose output from the liver may be achieved by inhibition of glycogen phosphorylase. Such inhibitors may be of use for therapy of the noninsulin dependent form of diabetes (NIDDM or Type II diabetes). One class of phosphorylase inhibitors consists of glucose analogs which stabilise the inactive T-form of the enzyme. Since there are only weak physiological inhibitors known, a variety of glucose compounds with better inhibitory properties were designed, synthesised and tested by L. Johnson, G. Fleet, N. Oikonomakos and coworkers [13, 23]. An alternate way to look for potent inhibitors other than glucose compounds would be to design analogs derived from the oligosaccharide substrate.
60 However, present knowledge about substrate binding sites of glucosyl residues in phosphorylases is still incomplete. From x-ray crystallography, molecular recognition and site directed mutagenesis studies the binding of glucose 1-phosphate and its derivatives in ground state and transition state is well characterised [20, 21, 3, 12]. Substantially less is known about productive binding of the polysaccharide awaiting degradation. So far no binding of oligosaccharides at the active site of rabbit muscle glycogen phosphorylase has been observed in crystals [18, 12], although there is at least gross structural information on a second carbohydrate binding site responsible for the attachment of carbohydrates to glycogen particles, the "glycogen storage site" [9, 12].
Synthesis
Degradation
Figure 1. Schematic drawing of the substrate binding site of maltodextrin phosphorylase. Subsites 5-2 are the primer subsites.
From kinetic studies with branched and linear oligosaccharides French and coworkers [7, 8] suggested a five glucose unit binding site, four subsites for the primer and one for the glucose moiety (Fig. 1). This subsite concept is comparable to that described for other oligosaccharide degrading enzymes [ 11, 16]. However, glycogen phosphorylases differ from those enzymes: First, in the reaction of phosphorylase a glucosyl residue is transferred to a phosphate group rather than to a water molecule. Consequently the exclusion of water from the active site is of essence for the phosphorylase reaction. Indeed, mutations of active site residues cause an increase of the remarkably low error rate, eg release of glucose rather than glucose 1phosphate [ 15]. Further, the phosphorolytic cleavage of oligosaccharides is freely reversible. At equilibrium (Kcq = Pi/Glc-1-P = 3.6 at pH 6.8) "synthesis" is favoured. In the cell the physiological role of phosphorylase is the energy conserving mobilisation of storage polysaccharides through phosphorolysis due to the relatively high phosphate concentration in the cell. The work presented here is aimed at mapping the oligosaccharide binding site by a combination of a kinetic studies with linear oligosaccharides of increasing length and sitedirected mutagenesis. The E. coli maltodextrin phosphorylase is used as a model system, since this enzyme binds short linear oligosaccharides better than glycogen phosphorylase. In addition, the bacterial enzyme lacks the glycogen storage site, which makes determination of kinetic parameters less complicated
61 2. SUBSTRATE SPECIFICITY OF MALTODEXTRIN PHOSPHORYLASE In the phosphorolysis mode the shortest oligosaccharide degraded by maltodextrin phosphorylase is maltopentaose (G5). Maltotetraose (G4) is degraded much less efficiently exhibiting an approximately 300-fold lowered specificity constant (Table 1). On the other hand no significant additional binding energy is provided by additional glucose units from oligosaccharides with more than five glucose residues (Table 1). A very slow degradation of maltotriose was detectable by thin layer chromatography but this activity was to low to be assayed quantitatively (Htilsmeyer and Palm, unpublished results). In phosphorolysis maltotetraose acts as an inhibitor with an inhibitor constant comparable to the Km values of the oligosaccharide substrate (Table 2). Maltotriose (G3), maltose (G2) and glucose (G) do not inhibit the phosphorylase reaction (Table 2). In the synthesis mode the phosphorylase reaction is efficiently primed in the presence of oligosaccharides with a minimum length of four glucose residues. [7]. Similar to degradation longer oligosaccharides do not have better primer properties. Maltotriose was found to be a markedly less efficient primer molecule. Comparable observations were made for potato phosphorylase [22]. No primer activity of maltose was detectable even at high enzyme concentration and at prolonged incubation times up to 48 h (Htilsmeyer and Palm, unpublished observations). In addition, maltotriose is an inhibitor of the synthesis reaction with a dissociation constant comparable to the Kin-value of the primer molecule maltotetraose (Table 2).
Table 1 Kinetic parameters of maltodextrin phosphorylase action on different oli~osaccharides Substrate Degradation Synthesis
G7 G6 G5 G4 G3
Km kcat (mM) (s -1)
kcat~m (s -1 mM -1)
Km keat (raM) (s -1)
kcat/Km (s "1 mM "1)
0.4 0.5 0.8 3.9 n.d.
45 44 38 0.13 n.d.
3.2 3.0 4.6 4.1 23
15 15 12,5 14,5 0.091
18 22 30 0.5 <0.01
48 44 58 60 2.1
A series of oligosaccharides ranging from G3 to G7 was labelled with dansylhydrazine at the reducing end. Labelled oligosaccharides (from G4 to G7) behave like physiological substrates in both directions. The fluorescence properties of the labelled substrates remained unchanged in presence of phosphorylase (Drueckes, unpublished results). Thus, the fluorophore of the substrates seems not to interact with the protein. This confirms the observation described above that additional glucose residues consecutive to G4 do not interact with the enzyme and that smaller oligosaccharides do not bind to the enzyme. From the kinetic and binding experiments the following model of oligosaccharide binding at the active site of phosphorylases emerges: Oligosaccharides which contain at least four glucose residues in synthesis or five residues in degradation, respectively, are required for effective
62 catalysis. Additional glucose residues do not contribute significantly to binding neither in synthesis nor in degradation. Therefore, the oligosaccharide binding site is composed of five
Table 2 Inhibitory effects of short oligosaccharides, maltose and glucose on the phosphorylase reaction Inhibitor Degradation Synthesis Ki (mM) Ki (mM) G4 0.4 G3 >100 4 G2 >250 >250 G >500 >500
consecutive subsites in the direction of degradation and four glucose binding subsites and one glucose 1-phosphate binding subsite in synthesis. The pronounced loss in catalytic competence between G4 and G3 or G5 and G4, respectively, points to a central role of subsite five in substrate binding both in the ground state and transition state. The contribution of this subsite to binding energy can be quantitated using AAGn = -RT In[ (kcat/Km)n_1//(kcat/Km)n] according to Horumi [11]. A free energy of binding of approximately 14 kJ/mol for subsite five was determined, while for subsite six and seven values of about 0,4 kJ/mol and 1 kJ/mol were determined. Since shorter oligosaccharides are no or only weak inhibitors, subsite five seems not sufficient to bind the oligosaccharide substrate and the other subsites must also contribute to oligosaccharide binding. If it is assumed that binding at two subsites is required for efficient oligosaccharide binding, all oligosaccharides which can occupy those sites should be substrates or at least inhibitors of the phosphorylase reaction. The failure of G3 to be an efficient inhibitor makes a contribution of subsite two to binding evident, since G3 cannot bind at sites two and five at the same time. Only G4 could span both binding sites thus making it an inhibitor molecule in the direction of degradation. If sites three or four would contribute significantly to binding, maltotriose should have inhibitory properties comparable to that of G4. Binding at subsites three and four seems not to provide binding energy or may even lower binding energy ("negative binding"). This is in accordance with observations of Giri and French [8] that subsite three can fit 1,6-glycosidic bonds. However, subsite four is specific for 1,4 linked glucose units. From these data no conclusions on the contribution of subsite one, the catalytic site, can be made.
3. FUNCTIONAL ROLE OF ACTIVE SITE RESIDUES IN OLIGOSACCHARIDE BINDING Since kinetic analysis of the oligosaccharide binding site is difficult due to the lack of suitable substrate analogs and the failure of earlier attempts to measure binding directly, a sitedirected mutagenesis approach was employed to get further information how carbohydrates bind at the active site. In an alanine scanning experiment first suggested by Cunnigham et al.
63 [5] a number of active site residues were changed to alanine (Ddickes et al., in preparation). Only those residues were selected for the mutagenesis experiments which meet at least two of three criteria: - Location at a channel with access to the active site which is most probably identical with the oligosaccharide binding site. This channel, which was proposed by Barford and coworkers [2], consists of an about 1,5 nm long channel from the cofactor binding site to the surface of the enzyme.
- Conservation in all known phosphorylase primary structures including enzymes of bacterial, plant and mammalian origins [ 14]. - Participation in oligosaccharide binding. Only amino acid residues with charged or hydrophilic amino acid side chains were changed, which are commonly involved in carbohydrate binding. In contrast to many other enzymes acting on oligosaccharides [19] no tryptophanes and only few aromatic amino acid side chains seem to be involved in carbohydrate binding by interacting with the plane of the sugar through nonpolar interactions. All mutant enzymes created so far have some properties in common: - They exhibited thermal stabilities comparable to that of the wildtype enzyme except for the E67A mutant enzyme, which is slightly more sensitive to heat. - There are no significant differences in the steady state parameters for maltopentaose and maltoheptaose (Fig. 2A) in the degradation mode or for maltotetraose and maltopentaose in the synthesis mode, respectively (Fig. 2B). This confirms the above mentioned observation that residues beyond the fourth glucose unit do not contribute significantly to binding of oligosaccharides.
- All mutations which influence carbohydrate binding affect binding of inorganic phosphate as well, but to a lower extent. This is in accordance with earlier observations that both substrates in the direction of degradation, inorganic phosphate and the oligosaccharide, do not bind independently [ 10]. 3.1. Effects of m u t a t i o n s on apparent binding According to their effects on apparent binding, the resulting mutant enzymes can be divided into three classes: Few mutant enzymes belonging to the first class showed no or only minor changes in the steady state parameters upon mutation although they are highly conserved in all phosphorylase sequences. In addition, one mutant enzyme, N112A, exhibits significantly increased thermal stability (Drueckes and Schinzel, unpublished results). The functional role of these side chains remains unclear. A second class is built of all mutations which caused only moderate changes of the apparent binding. The loss in apparent ground state binding energy (Fig. 2A) compared to the wildtype enzyme is about 4-6 kJ/mol for all mutants in this class. This corresponds to the loss of one
64 hydrogen bond between uncharged side chains [6, 20]. Indeed, all mutants belonging to this class are mutants of amino acids with hydrophilic but uncharged side chains: N307, Y578 and T346. In the case of the N258A/D259A/N260A mutant enzyme one of the asparagines rather than aspartic acid 259 might be engaged in binding of the oligosaccharide substrate in the ground state. Those three residues are part of a loop which in the inactive T-form of phosphorylase b blocks the putative substrate channel. This loop swings back upon allosteric activation of phosphorylase [2]. The moderate effects of this mutation on the non-allosteric bacterial phosphorylase shows that maltodextrin phosphorylase resembles the R-form of rabbit muscle phosphorylase. The Y578A and T346A mutants are of special interest since for these two mutants the binding energy in the ground state of the oligosaccharide in the synthesis mode is less affected than binding in the degradation mode (Fig. 2). This suggests that the oligosaccharide substrate may occupy partially different binding sites in synthesis and degradation, respectively. Although substitution of E350 by an alanine removes a charge, only moderate changes in apparent ground state binding are observed when compared to the E67A and H536L mutant enzymes. The third class consists of mutant enzymes which showed a more substantial decrease of apparent carbohydrate binding. Here the observed changes in free energy of oligosaccharide binding in the degradation mode are in the range expected for a hydrogen bond with a charged or uncharged residue, respectively (Fig. 2). This is the case for the E67A and H536L mutants, where charged amino acid side chains had been substituted by neutral ones. These data imply that both residues are of major importance in carbohydrate binding. However, in the direction of synthesis the values given (Fig. 2) represent only a lower limit since oligosaccharides are insoluble at high concentrations and thus Km values cannot be determined accurately. Therefore, conclusions about differential effects of these mutations on binding in synthesis and degradation cannot be drawn from the present data. 3.2. Effects of mutations on kcat/Km Changes in kcat/K m c a n be expressed in terms of the free energy of binding: AAG = - RT In[ (kcat~m)mut/(kcat/Km)wt]. In Fig. 3. the effects of mutations o n kcat/K m values are shown. As observed for the Km values, mutations of H536 and E67 causes the largest effects on k~a~Km. Due to the very high Km values kcat]tKm w a s determined directly at [S]<
65 activity. This suggests that a negative charge at this position is indispensable for a fully active enzyme (Drtickes and Schinzel, manuscript in preparation).
Figure 2. Effect of different mutations on Km values for oligosaccharides relative to the Km of the wildtype enzyme. The values for the H536L and E67A mutant give lower limits, since the determination of the apparent Km values was limited by the solubility of the oligosaccharides. (A) Degradation mode; (B) Synthesis mode. G4 = maltotetraose; G5 = maltopentaose; G7 = maltoheptaose.
The D308A mutant enzyme retained wildtype Km while activity is lowered 100-fold. Substituting T346 by alanine affects both binding in the ground state and to a larger extent binding in the transition state. Exchanging Y538 and N307 to alanine affects lqat only
66 moderately, the changes in AAG therefore reflect only the impaired binding in the ground state. Both residues seemed not be involved in transition state binding.
Figure 3. Changes in free energy of activation (calculated from kcat/K m values) of mutant maltodextrin phosphorylase compared with the wildtype enzyme. The values for the H536L and E67A mutant were determined directly at S<
3.3. Structural implications Unlike glucoamylases and or-amylases [17] the glycogen phosphorylases - although highly conserved from bacterial to mammalian enzymes- share no homology with other carbohydrate degrading enzymes. The binding site differs from binding sites in other enzymes acting on oligosaccharides in some respects, for example no tryptophan residues are located near the putative carbohydrate binding site in at the active site of glycogen phosphorylase. Up to now no structure of a phosphorylase - carbohydrate complex has been solved. However, a channel from the active site to the surface of the enzyme had been identified in the phosphorylase b structure [ 1] which is most probably the substrate channel. A maltopentaose molecule had been modelled into the phosphorylase b structure. However, this was only possible under the assumption that the oligosaccharide molecule is distorted mainly between the second and third glucose unit (L. Johnson, personal communication). Since almost all amino acid residues of the catalytic domain of the bacterial and mammalian phosphorylase are conserved [14], the assumption can be made that the 3-D structure of the active sites of both enzymes should be very similar. Therefore, the position of the amino acid residues which correspond to the mutated residues in the bacterial enzyme relative to the maltopentaose molecule was examined.
67 In this model H571 (corresponding to H536 in maltodextrin phosphorylase) and E382 (E350) are relatively close to glucose residue five. Tyr613 (Y578) appears to distant to make direct contacts to the sugar model. Hence the participation of this residue to substrate binding is most likely indirect or mediated by other side chains. In contrast, in the model only one side chain, E382 (E350), seems to be in the vicinity of glucose residues four. Binding at this subsite should contribute only little to binding both in the ground state and the transition state. Comparable to subsite four in the model only one amino acid, aspartic acid at position 339 (D308), is located near the glucose residue at subsite position three. However, the glucose residue at subsite two is in contact to all amino acids found to be involved in substrate binding in the bacterial maltodextrin phosphorylase (except for H571 and E382). From this observation it can be predicted, that subsite two contributes substantially to binding of the substrate and is critical to bind the oligosaccharide molecule in a distorted form. G5
~1376
-r
)-
PLP
Figure 4. Position of amino acid side chains (rabbit muscle numbering) found to be involved in oligosaccharide binding in maltodextrin phosphorylase to a maltopentaose molecule fitted into the structure of phosphorylase b (L. Johnson, personal communication).
68 If the kinetic and site directed mutagenesis studies are combined with the structural model of substrate binding (Fig. 4), a functional model of substrate binding in glycogen phosphorylases emerges: Subsites five and two seem to be of major importance for binding of the oligosaccharide in both the transition state and the ground state, while subsite three and four make no or only small contributions to binding. The different Km values observed for some mutant enzymes in the direction of degradation and synthesis point to a structural rearrangement of parts of the oligosaccharide binding energy site in catalysis.
4. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT We are grateful to L. Johnson, Oxford, for making the coordinates of the oligosaccharidephosphorylase b model available to us. This work was supported by a grant from the EC BIO2-CT94-3025.
5. REFERENCES
1
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15
16 17
D. Barford, J.W. Schwalbe, N.G. Oikonomakos, K. Acharya, A. Hajdu, G. Papageorgiou, J.L. Martin, A. Knott, A. Vasella and L.N. Johnson, Biochemistry, 27 (1988) 6733. D. Barford and L.N. Johnson, Nature, 218 (1989) 233. S. Becker, D. Palm and R. Schinzel, J. Biol. Chem., 269 (1994) 2485. M. Browner and R.J. Fletterick, Trends Biochem. Sci., 17 (1992) 66. B.C. Cunnigham and J.A. Wells, Science, 244, (1989) 1081. A.R. Fersht, J.P. Shi, J. Knill-Jones, D.M. Lowe, A.J. Wilkinson, D.M. Blow, P. Brick, P. Carter, M. Waye and G. Winter, Nature, 314 (1985), 235. D. French and G.M. Wild, J.Amer.Chem.Soc., 75 (1953) 4490. N.Y. Giri and D. French, Arch. Biochem. Biophys., 145 (1970) 505. E.J. Goldsmith, S.R. Sprang, R. Hamlin, N.-H. Xoung and R.J. Fletterick, Science, 245 (1989) 528. D.J. Graves and J.H. Wang, The Enzymes, Vol. III, pp. 460-463, Academic Press, New York (1970). K. Hiromi, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun., 40 (1970) 1. L.N. Johnson, FASEB J., 6 (1992) 2274. J.L. Martin, K. Veluraja, L.N. Ross, L.N. Johnson, G.W.J. Flett, N.G. Ramsden, I. Bruce, M.G. Orchard, N.G. Oikonomakos, G. Papageorgiou, D.D. Leonidas and H.S. Tsitoura, Biochemistry, 31 (1991) 10101. C.B. Newgard, P.K. Hwang and R.J. Fletterick, Crit. Rev. Biochem. Mol. Biol., 24 (1989) 69. D. Palm, S. Becker and R. Schinzel, in Enzymes Dependent on Pyridoxalphosphate and other Carbonyl Compounds as Cofactors T. Fukui, H. Kagamiyama, K. Soda and H. Wada (eds.), pp. 377-385, Pergamon Press, Oxford (1991). M.R. Sierks, C. Ford, P.J. Reilly and B. Svensson, Prot. Eng., 2 (1989) 621. M.R. Sierks, C. Ford, P.J. Reilly and B. Svensson, Prot. Eng., 6 (1993) 75.
69 18 19 20 21 22 23
S.R. Sprang, S.G. Withers, E. Goldsmith, R.J. Fletterick and N.B. Madsen, Science, 254 (1991) 1367. J.C. Spurlino G.-Y. Lu and F. Quiocho, J. Biol. Chem., 266 (1991) 5202. I.P. Street, C.R. Armstrong and S.G. Withers, Biochemistry, 25 (1986) 6021. I.P. Street, K. Rupiz and S.G. Withers, Biochemistry, 28 (1989) 1581. T. Suganuma, J.-I. Kitazone, K. Yoshinaga, S. Fujimoto and T. Nagahama, Carbohydrate Res., 217 (1991) 213. K.A. Watson, E.P. Mitchell, L.N. Johnson, J.C. Son, C.F. Bichard, M.G. Orchard, G.W. Fleet, N.G. Oikonomakos, D.D. Leonidas, M. Kontou and A. Papagoergioui, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 5745.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
71
The chitinolytic system of Streptomyces olivaceoviridis H. Schrempf Department of Biology, University of Osnabriick, Barbarastral3e 11, D-49069 Osnabriick, Germany
Abstract
Streptomyces olivaceoviridis secretes several chitinases. The characterized 59 kDa exochitinase consists of a C-terminal catalytic domain, one central region, and one N-terminal chitin-binding part (12 kDa). The presence of the binding domain was shown to be a prerequisite for an efficient degradation of crystalline ~- and [~-chitins. In addition to the chitinolytic enzymes, S. olivaceoviridis produces a so far unique chitin-binding protein (CHB 1). Biochemical studies and immunofluorescence microscopy revealed that the CHB1 protein binds specifically only to c~-chitin from crab shell or fungi. The role of the novel lectinlike protein is at present being investigated.
1. INTRODUCTION Chitin, a polymer of N-acetyl-D-glucosamine, is highly abundant in nature, since it is present in the exoskeleton of insects, in mollusca, coelenterata, nematodes, protozoa and the cell walls of certain fungi. Naturally occurring chitins vary in the length of their chains which are stabilized by hydrogen bridges to a highly ordered crystalline structure. Chitin is frequently associated with proteins and may be stabilized by additional inorganic compounds. The natural annual production is judged to amount to 108 tons. Thus, apart from cellulose, it constitutes the second most abundant polysaccharide in nature [14]. Chitin can be hydrolyzed by enzymes produced by plants, fungi, and bacteria. Gram-positive streptomycetes are highly abundant in soil and known as important antibiotic producers. Though nearly all Streptomyces species have been shown to be chitinolytic, and chitin has been successfully used to enrich predominantly streptomycetes from soil [11], relatively few studies on chitinolytic enzymes have been performed. Streptomyces olivaceoviridis was identified as the most efficient degrader of crystalline chitin [ 1]. Recently, five chitinases (20.5 kDa, 30 kDa, 47 kDa, 70 kDa and 92 kDa) from S. olivaceoviridis have been purified to homogeneity [ 17]. Many extracellular hydrolases produced by bacteria consist of two or more domains. Most details are known about the catalytic and the binding domains of cellulases (CBDs). Proteins predicted from different bacterial chitinase genes showed in various cases an architecture of several domains, and comparisons of the deduced aminoacids allowed the identification of the
72 individual catalytic domains [23, 2]. With the help of biochemical and genetic data, chitinbinding domains could be identified within chitinases from Bacillus circulans [24]. We succeeded in analysing the catalytic and binding characteristics of an overproduced exochitinase and a novel lectin-like chitin-binding protein from S. olivaceoviridis as well as their corresponding chitin-inducible genes.
2. RESULTS AND DISCUSSION 2.1. The exochitinase and its gene Since S. olivaceoviridis degraded chitin efficiently, its DNA was used for shot-gun cloning experiments. In the presence of chitin, the S. lividans transformants containing the plasmid pCHIO 1 produced like S. olivaceoviridis a chitin-inducible exochitinase of 59 kDa which was proteolytically processed to a 47 kDa protein in the culture medium [2, 3]. Sequence analysis of a reading frame of 1794 base pairs, comparison of the deduced aminoacid sequence, and biochemical studies of the mature protein (59 kDa) and the proteolytically processed form (47 kDa) allowed the identification of one N-terminal chitinbinding domain, one central region with significant similarity to the type III module of fibronectin, and the C-terminal catalytic domain which spans from residues 261 to 597. This catalytic domain belongs to family 18 of glycosyl hydrolases [10] and four amino acids (Ser, Gly, Asp and Glu) were found to be completely invariable in the 12 aligned sequences. It is interesting to note that Asp and/or Glu residues have been discovered in the catalytic region of many glycosyl hydrolases including type-C lysozyme which also hydrolases chitin [22]. The deduced S. olivaceoviridis enzyme has highest overall amino acid identity with the B. circulans chitinase D [2]. The 59 kDa enzyme was shown to adhere very strongly to crystalline chitin and to hydrolyse native crab and fungal m-chitin more efficiently than the 47 kDa truncated form of the enzyme. In contrast, colloidal chitin and chitooligomers were degraded equally well by both forms of the enzymes. Neither standard physiological conditions nor elevated NaC1 and detergent concentrations allowed the removal of the bound Streptomyces exo-ChiO1 (59 kDa) enzyme; only high concentrations of urea and guanidine hydrochloride led to its release. Therefore it has to be assumed that the binding is irreversible under physiological conditions. These data reveal that a strong adhesion of the large form of the enzyme is a requisite for effective hydrolysis of the crystalline structure of chitin. In addition, it can be concluded that the N-terminal domain (12 kDa) of the 59 kDa enzyme is a chitin-binding domain [3]. By immunofluorescence, we could demonstrate that the 59 kDa chitinase mediates a very specific and strong binding to crystalline ~- and [3-chitins from various sources, but does not adhere to colloidal chitin. Since streptomycetes are dominant in soil and expected to encounter fungi in their natural habitat, it was not surprising that the 59 kDa enzyme interacts particularly efficiently with o~-chitin containing spores and phialides from fungi (i. e. Aspergillus proliferans and others). It hydrolyses the chitin within the fungal cell wall very well; thus protoplast-like structures and shortened mycelia are formed. We show for the first time that fungal chitin was hydrolysed considerably more efficiently than crab chitin which is usually used for the analysis of chitinase activities [3].
73
2.2. The lectin-like chitin-binding protein and its gene In the presence of chitin only, several chitinases including the exochitinase described above as well as an extracellular chitin-binding protein (CHB1) were produced by Streptomyces olivaceoviridis. The corresponding gene (chbl) was cloned on a multicopy vector in S. lividans. Like the exochi 1 gene, the chb 1 gene is only transcribed in the presence of chitin in its original host S. olivaceoviridis and the S. lividans transformant harbouring the chb 1 gene on a multicopy vector. Since the S. lividans transformant overproduced the protein only in the presence of chitin, it was rapidly purified to homogeneity [20]. Using immunofluo-rescence microscopy and biochemical analyses, a very specific binding of the overproduced CHB 1 to o~chitin was demonstrated. Native c~-chitin from crab shells consists of N-acetylglucosamine polymer chains arranged in an antiparallel way. Weaker adsorption of CHB 1 was found with colloidal chitin; this derives from native crab shell (x-chitin after treatment with acids, and its structure is probably predominantly amorphous. The CHB1 protein does not bind to carboxymethylchitin and to g-chitin, nor to any other type of cellulose. Since the CHB1 protein strongly interacted with o~-chitin and additional spectroscopical studies suggested a possible involvement of tryptophane residues with the crystalline substrate, we looked for a region within CHB1 harbouring several of these aminoacids. Four tryptophanes were shown to be deduced in the N-terminal part of the CHB 1 protein. By manual alignment of the relative positions of aromatic aminoacids within CHB1 and other glycohydrolases, four tryptophane residues were found in the cellulose-binding domains (CBDs) of several bacterial cellulases [8, 12, 13, 15, 25, 26]. The CHB 1 protein contained within a region of about 100 aminoacids one cysteine, two asparagines, and one glycine. These aminoacids are also present within several cellulose-binding domains (CBDs), each of which consists of approximately 100 aminoacid residues. Thus, they are about 70 aminoacids shorter than the CHB1 protein. It is interesting that two tryptophane residues are present in lectins from plants, such as Vicia faba [21] and Dolichos biflorus [19]. Several conservatively substituted aminoacids show an analogous arrangement of the above-cited CBDs and CHB 1. Lectins from the seeds of several plants (Graminaceae, Solanaceae and some Leguminosae) had been found to bind to N-acetylglucosamine, oligomers of this sugar and chitin [6]. One of the best-characterized chitin-binding lectins of plant origin is the wheat germ agglutinin (WGA). Within lectins, 30 - 43 aminoacids which contain various conserved cysteines and glycines (see also below) have been identified [4]. Analyses of deleted genes and their products from the B. circulans chitinases A1 and D resulted in the identification of chitin-binding domains of 52 to 55 aminoacids [24]. The exochitinase from S. olivaceoviridis [2,3] was shown to be proteolytically processed to a catalytically active part of the enzyme and a chitin-binding part of 131 aminoacids (see above). Up to now, the binding capacities of the domains from the above-mentioned chitinases have been tested with a-chitin, but neither with any other forms of chitin nor with different cellulose types. Despite our alignments, we could not identify similar aminoacid arrangements among the binding domains of the above chitinases and CHB 1. Further studies are necessary in order to test whether the various above-mentioned binding regions possibly mediate the adsorption to regions with a varying degree of crystallinity of the chitin and (or) if they differ in their interaction with regions which are largely or only to a small extent exposed to the surface of chitin. Although the sizes of the binding domains of various cellulases and chitinases of bacterial or eucaryotic origin range from 35 to about 150 residues, their g-structure can in
74 general be predicted (like for CHB 1, data not shown), and they seem to mediate the binding by exposed aromatic residues such as tryptophanes and/or tyrosines. More extensive studies are required to elucidate the structure of proteins interacting solely with a-chitin, in comparison with those binding to various types of cellulose and chitin. Therefore, truncated and mutated forms of the proteins are being investigated at present. Recent data give reason to believe that the cellulose-binding domains from cellulases are involved in the non-hydrolytic disruption of high-molecular weight cellulose. The precise action is not yet known, but it was proposed that the CBD protein binds to and penetrates the cellulose fibre at surface discontinuities and sluffs off cellulose fragments non-covalently associated with fibre but bound to underlying microfibrils [5]. Therefore the interaction of CHB 1 with chitin may assist the hydrolytic attack by enzymes and is being investigated at present. CHB 1 does not possess any antifungal activity. At present we are testing if it mediates the interaction of Streptomyces and chitin-containing fungi. It will also be interesting to analyse if the production of the specific chitin-binding protein is typical for S. olivaceoviridis, which had been isolated in the course of a screening programme [1] as an extremely efficient chitin degrader, or if other Streptomyces species produce binding proteins, too. Up to now, Calcofluor and Congo red [18] have been used to quickly identify polysaccharides within different organisms. However, the dyes are not very specific as they interact with various types of chitin, cellulose, and other polysaccharides. X-ray diffraction spectra have been necessary to distinguish different types of chitin. Since CHB1 binds specifically to a-chitin, it could also be used for the rapid identification of this chitin type. In addition, fluorescein-labelled CHB 1 could serve as a tool to study the synthesis of o~-chitin as well as the dynamics of its crystallization during the development of various organisms. Recent studies have revealed that cellulose-binding domains possess a large potential to purify various proteins. Thus a gene fragment encoding a CBD was fused to several genes encoding proteins of interest [16, 7]. Using similar constructs with the chbl gene, the adsorption of corresponding gene products to chitin could serve as a tool for the rapid enrichment of proteins which are difficult to isolate. Moreover, various proteins could be applied in their chitin-immobilized form.
3. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank M. Lemme for her help with the writing of the manuscript. The studies were supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft Schr 203/3-2.
4. REFERENCES
1 2 3 4
M. Beyer and H. Diekmann, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 23 (1985) 140. H. Blaak, J. Schnellmann, S. Walter, B. Henrissat and H. Schrempf, Eur. J. Biochem., 214 (1993) 659. H. Blaak and H. Schrempf, Eur. J. Biochem., 229 (1995) 132. M.J. Chrispeels and N.V. Raikhel, Plant Cell, 3 (1991) 1.
75 5 6
7 8 9 10 11
12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26
N. Din, N.R. Gilkes, B. Tekant, R.C. Miller Jr, R.A.J. Warren and D.G. Kilbum, Bio/Technology, 9 (1991) 1096. I.J. Goldstein and R.D. Poretz. In I.E. Liener, N. Sharon and I.J. Goldstein (eds.), The Lectins: Properties, Functions, and Applications in Biology and Medicine, Academic Press, pp. 35-250, 1986. J.M. Greenwood, E. Ong, N.R. Gilkes, R.A.J. Warren, R.C. Miller Jr and D.G. Kilbum, Prot. Eng., 5 (1992) 361. J. Hall and H.J. Gilbert, Mol. Gen. Genet., 213 (1988) 112. J. Hall, G.P. Hazlewood, N.S. Huskisson, A.J. Durrant and H.J. Gilbert, Mol. Microbiol., 3 (1989) 1211. B. Henrissat, Biochem. J., 280 (1991) 309. H.J. Kutzner, In M.P. Starr, H. Stolp, H.G. Trtiper, A. Balows and H. Schlegel (eds.), The Prokaryotes: A Handbook on Habitats, Isolation and Identification of Bacteria, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, Germany, pp. 2028-2090, 1981. A. Meinke, C. Braun, N.R. Gilkes, D.G. Kilburn, R.C. Miller Jr. and R.A.J. Warren, J. Bacteriol., 173 (1991) 308. A. Meinke, N.R. Gilkes, D.G. Kilburn, R.C. Miller Jr. and R.A.J. Warren, J. Bacteriol., 175 (1993) 1910. R.A.A. Muzarelli, Chitin, Pergamon Press, 1977. G.P. O'Neil, S.H. Goh, R.A.J. Warren, D.G. Kilburn and R.C. Miller Jr., Gene, 44 (1986) 325. E. Ong, N.R. Gilkes, R.C. Miller Jr., R.A.J. Warren and D.G. Kilburn, Biotechnol. Bioeng., 42 (1993) 401. A. Romaguera, U. Menge, R. Breves and H. Diekmann, J. Bacteriol., 174 (1992) 3450. C. Roncero and A. Dur~in, J. Bacteriol., 163 (1985) 1180. D.J. Schnell, D.C. Alexander, B.G. Williams and M.E. Etzler, Eur. J. Biochem., 167 (1987) 227. J. Schnellmann, A. Zeltins, H. Blaak and H. Schrempf, Mol. Microbiol., 13 (1994) 807. N. Sharon and H. Lis, Science, 246 (1989) 227. M. Sinnott, Chem. Rev., 90 (1990) 1171. T. Watanabe, W. Oyanagi, K. Suzuki, K. Ohnishi and H. Tanaka, J. Bacteriol., 174 (1992) 408. T. Watanabe, K. Kobori, T. Yamada, Y. Ho; M. Uchida and H. Tanaka, In R.A.A. Muzzarelli (ed.), Chitin Enzymology, Eur. Chitin Soc., Ancona, Italy, pp. 329-337, 1993. R.W.K. Wong, B. Gerhard, Z.M. Guo, D.G. Kilbum, R.A.J. Warren and R.C. Miller Jr., Gene, 44 (1986) 315. M.D. Yablonsky, T. Bartley, K.O. Elliston, S.K. Kahrs, Z.P. Shalita and D.E. Eveleigh, In J.-P. Aubert, P. B6guin and J. Millet (eds), Biochemistry and Genetics of Cellulose Degradation. FEMS Symposium 43, London, Academic Press, pp. 249-266, 1988.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), Carbohydrate Bioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
77
Properties and production of the [3-glycosidase from the thermophilic Archaeon Sulfolobus solfataficus expressed in mesophilic hosts M. Moracci a, L. Capalbo b, M. De Rosa b, R. La Montagna ~, A. Morana b, R. Nucci ~, M. Ciaramella ~ and M. Rossi a alnstitute of Protein Biochemistry and Enzymology, CNR, Via Marconi 10, 80125 Naples, Italy blstituto di Biochimica delle Macromolecole, II University of Naples, Via Costantinopoli 16, 80138 Naples, Italy
Abstract
The [~-glycosidase from the thermophilc Archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus (Singly) shows broad substrate specificity, thermophilicity and high resistance to heat and other protein denaturants. It is an interesting model for elucidating the structure-function relashionships in glycosyl-hydrolases as well as the molecular determinants of thermophilicity and thermostability. In this paper we describe different strategies to obtain and optimize heterologous expression of the S[3gly in mesophilic hosts and down-stream processing, which are the pre-requisites for large scale production of the enzyme. We also describe the properties of the expressed enzyme and those of protein chimeras obtained by fusing the S~gly to the glutathione-S-transferase (GST); such fusions are useful tools to investigate on the properties of the enzyme and to easily purify mutants impaired in their activity or stability.
1. I N T R O D U C T I O N Among enzymes involved in carbohydrate metabolism, attention has been recently focused on [3-glycosidases from thermophilic microorganisms, enzymes showing highly thermostable [3glucosidase and [3-galactosidase activities. We have previously reported studies on the thermostable ]3-glycosidase (S[3gly) from the extreme thermoacidophilic Archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus (for a review, see 1). The enzyme is thermophilic - the activity variation with temperature shows increase up to 90 ~ and thermostable - the half life at 75 ~ is 24 hours; it is stable to different protein denaturants and proteases, and moreover it is activated by heat and some protein denaturants. The enzyme has a broad substrate specificity: it hydrolizes [3-D-gluco-, fuco-, and galactosides, and a large number of [3-1inked glycoside dimers and oligomers, linked 131-3, [31-4, and [31-6. It has
78 noticeable exo-cellobiase activity on oligosaccharides with up to 5 glucose residues. Furthermore, it is also able to promote transglycosylation reactions [2,3]. The SI]gly encoding gene, called lacS, has been cloned and expressed in mesophilic hosts [4-6; see below]. We have analyzed the transcriptional organization of the lacS region, we have identified the transcription start site and the presumptive promoter sequences [7]. The enzyme has been crystallized [8] and the resolution of its structure is in progress. The SI3gly belongs to the Glycosyl-hydrolase family 1, including enzymes with 13glycosidase, 13-galactosidase and phosho-13-galactosidase activity, widely distributed among the three living Domains (Bacteria, Eukarya and Archaea). Enzymes of this family share significant sequence similarity with enzymes of cellulase family A, including microbial enzymes with 13-1,4 glucanase activity, which are involved in the degradation of cellulose. Enzymes of both families catalyze hydrolysis of 13-glycosidic bonds, possibly by the same mechanism of general acid catalysis [9]. For its particular features the SI3gly is an useful tool in all circumstances in which wide substrate specificity coupled with resistance to denaturation is required. For instance, its ability to hydrolyze oligosaccharides allows its utilization coupled with mesophilic or thermophilic cellulases in the conversion at high temperature of cellulose to glucose. We are interested in the identification and definition of the functional sites of the SI3gly involved in its different properties (substrate specificity, exo-cellobiase and transglycosylation activities), and to the structural deteminants of thermostability and thermophilicity; such results could also open the possibility of rationally engineering the enzyme to achieve better applicative performance. In this paper we describe different strategies for production, purification and downstream processing of the heterologously expressed SI3gly.
2. HETEROLOGOUS EXPRESSION The development of an innovative enzymology based on enzymes from thermophiles is currently hampered by difficulties in producing thermophilc biomass. The extreme growth conditions of hyperthermophiles and the slow growth rate with consequent low biomass yields, make it difficult both to obtain amounts of enzyme needed for structure-function studies and to devise methodologies for industrial scale up of production. Cloning and overexpression of thermophile genes in mesophilic hosts is now a well-established methodology to overcome these problems. Thermophilic enzymes are inactive at the host optimal temperature and the cells may allow the accumulation of higher quantities of the expression product. Moreover, the intrinsic stability of the heterologous enzymes allows their selective purification from the host proteins. 2.1. Expression in Escherichia coli Expression of protein genes in E. coli is the essential prerequisite for easy production of product for enzymological and structural studies, as well as for manipulation of the genes by random and site-directed mutagenesis. We have over-expressed the SI3gly in E. coli and have purified it to homogeneity by using a heating step which was proved to be crucial: most host proteins were easily removed and two chromatographic steps employed for the purification of
79 the native enzyme were by-passed [6]. Subsequent conventional hydrophobic chromatography, ion-exchange chromatography and gel filtration gave a purified protein with the same specific activity as the native enzyme, but with a better final purification factor and yield. A typical purification gave more than 5 m g ~ culture of homogeneous enzyme. Since the enzyme produced in E. coli shows the same properties of the native one, it can be used as a substrate for mutagenesis studies; by sequence alignment among members of the Glycosyl-hydrolase family 1 several conserved residues can be identified which are potential targets for site-directed substitutions.
2.1. Expression in yeast For its features, the SI3gly has several applicative potentialities in food and pharmaceutical industries; the possibility of expressing high levels of the enzyme in a safe (GRAS) host such as Saccharomyces cerevisiae is particularly attractive. We have previously obtained expression in yeast of the enzyme by using the vector pYE87 based on the classical URA3 selection [5]. However, when this expression system was scaled up to production volumes, it turned out that the amount of enzyme produced was significantly lower than expected, due to plasmid instability. To overcome this problem we have used an autoselection system based on the FBA1 gene, coding for the glycolitic enzyme fructose 1,6 bisphosphate aldolase, that is essential in any growth condition. In this system, the host strain harbors the chromosomal copy of the FBA1 gene stably disrupted [10] and contains a functional copy of the same gene on a plasmid. Since only cells retaining the vector are viable, the plasmid is completely stable after 50 generation in rich media [ 11]. We have constructed an autoselection-expression vector (pYG5) containing a functional copy of the FBA1 gene and the S. solfataricus lacS gene, coding for the SI3gly, under the control of the galactose-inducible UAScAL. Yeast cultures transformed with pYG5 or with pYE87 were subjected to three rounds of growth in non selective medium; with conventional selection plasmids, this experimental scheme favours high rate of plasmid loss (see below). In these conditions the two strains show very similar growth curve and reach the same maximal optical density (Fig.l), showing that the autoselection system does not result in growth disavantage. 12 10 9 pYE87 i pYG5
OF 0
. 20
40
i i 60 80 100 120 140 time
Figure 1. Growth curves of yeast cultures transformed with pYE87 and pYG5 vectors.
80 Plasmid stability was measured in cultures grown in non-selective conditions for 19 generations (Table 1). With plasmid pYE87, based on conventional selection, the fraction of plasmid-containing cells drops to 30%, whereas the autoselection vector pYG5 is present in 100% of the cells, confirming that this autoselection system is very stringent and that there are no plasmidless cells in population. The possibility of scaling-up of this expression system to production volumes will be evaluated.
Table 1 Stability of pYE87 and pYG5 in non-selective medium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . gen_e_r___ati_ons......... 3 19 pYE87 70 % 30 % pYG5 97 % 98 %
3. D O W N S T R E A M PROCESSING
We have developed a down-stream processing methodology for the purification of the enzyme expressed in yeast, taking advantage of the unusual stability of the S]3gly to heat and proteases. This methodology involves two key steps: cell autolysis and extracts thermal precipitation. A pilot fermentation experiment was carried out with a S. cerevisiae recombinant strain expressing the Sl3gly in a 100 liter scale. Cells were collected, subjected to one cycle of freeze-thawing, and then to autolysis. During this process, the enzyme was released into the medium. Interestingly, the time-course of the protein released showed that, whereas total protein concentration decreases with time, presumably due to digestion by endogenous proteases released during the autolysis, the [3-glycosidase activity increased continously with time up to a maximum recovery after 72 hours, testifying once more the exceptional stability of the enzyme. The enzymatic yield,_in terms of units per liter of cell colture, is about 35-fold higher in the recombinant yeast autolysate than that obtained from the S. solfataricus homogenate. The enzyme was further purified by heating the autolysate for 20 min at 80 ~ and discarding the precipitate by centrifugation. The yield of the whole process (units/L cell culture) obtained with this new purification procedure increased up to 56-fold. This methodology for the recovery of a thermophilic enzyme from yeast is suitable for industrial processes, being inexpensive and acceptable for the environment.
4. GST-S]]gly FUSIONS: EXPRESSION AND PURIFICATION We have constructed fusions of the S~3gly to the glutathione-S-transferase (GST) from Schistosoma japonicum and we have obtained their expression in E. coli; such fusions allow at the same time one-step purification of the chimeric enzyme by affinity chromatography on glutathione, and assay of GST activity to follow purification. Therefore they offer an
81 alternative to classical methods for SI3gly purification, and are an essential tool for production of mutant enzyme molecules impaired in activity and/or stability. We made a protein chimera by cloning the lac S gene in the BamHI site of vector pGEX-2T [12], obtaining vector pGexgly. The resulting product contains at the N-terminus the 26 kDa GST polypeptide fused to the 56 kDa SI3gly protein. The sequence at the junction of the two polypeptides was as follows: -Leu-Val-Pro-Arg-Gly-Ser-Met-Tyr-Ser-Phe-Pro-Asnwhere the ftrst six lac S amino acids are in bold. After transformation of JM105 E. coli cells with pGexgly, the expression of the chimeric protein was obtained by induction with IPTG and, after over-night growth, abundant GST expression could be detected in crude homogenate at 37 ~ following the standard GST assay [13]. The extract was loaded on a Gluthatione Sepharose 4B column; no GST activity was released from the column after extensive washing and the fusion was eluted after injection of glutathione buffer. The sample obtained showed both GST and 13-galactosidase activity at 37 and 75 ~ respectively, and an high degree of purity. When the sample was analysed by SDSPolyacrylamide Gel Electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) shown in Fig. 2, a two band pattern was found (lane 2): a 90 kDa band corresponding to the denatured chimera monomer, and a high molecular weight band which corresponds to the incompletely denatured, oligomeric form of the protein, which surprisingly is still active, as demonstrated by 13-galactosidase activity staining (lane 9). A similar pattern (but with bands of reduced size due to the absence of the GST portion) could be found for wild-type S[3gly analysed in the same conditions (lanes 7 and 8). These results demonstrate that the fusion of GST to Sl3gly has little effect on the overall architecture of the latter molecule, poorly affecting its functional folding, oligomerisation and exceptional thermal stability (fusions and wild-type protein samples, before loading on SDSPAGE, were incubated at 100 ~ in 0.1% SDS for 5 min.). Nevertheless, the ]3-glycosidase specific activity of the fusion was as much as 25% less than that of the wild-type enzyme at the same purification step, indicating that the catalytic efficiency and/or specifity were partially affected. In order to separate the GST portion from the fusion and recover the free SI3gly, samples obtained from the affinity chromatography were subjected to cleavage with thrombin protease. In fact, the fusion included a thrombin recognition site (bold residues): -Leu-VaI-Pro-Arg $ Gly-Ser-Met-Tyr-Ser-Phe-Pro-AsnThe arrow shows the bond hydrolysed by thrombin: as a consequence, the S]3gly produced by this digestion would show two additional amino acids at the N-terminus. Unfortunately the proteolytic cleavage resulted inefficient, even at very high thrombin/fusion ratio, probably because the thrombin recognition site is hidden into the chimera structure (Fig. 2, lanes 2 to 6). Indeed the efficiency of cutting was partially enhanced when the protein was pre-incubated at 55 ~ and then subjected to thrombin hydrolysis: in these conditions the GST portion is partially denaturated and presumably exposes the thrombin site. However, this treatment produced incomplete and aspecific protein cleavage (data not shown).
82
Figure 2. 10% SDS-PAGE of GST-SI3gly fusions after treatment with thrombin protease. Left panel: Coomassie staining. Lane 1, Molecular Weight Markers: Phosphorylase b 94,000 Da; Bovine Serum Albumin 67,000 Da; Ovalbumine 43,000 Da; Carbonic anhydrase 30,000 Da; Soybean Trypsin Inhibitor 20,100 Da. Lane 2, GST-SI3gly fusion incubated o.n. at 25 ~ Lanes 3-6, GST-SI3gly fusion incubated at 25 ~ in the presence of thrombin protease (10 units/mg of chimeric protein) for 1, 2, 4 hrs and o.n., respectively. Lane 7, wild-type SI3gly. Right panel: 13-galactosidase activity staining. Lane 8, wild-type SI3gly. Lane 9, GST-SI3gly fusion incubated o.n. at 25 ~ in the presence of thrombin protease (10 units/mg of chimeric protein).
In order to overcome this problem we prepared a new GST-SI3gly fusion, cloning the lacs gene in the BamHI site of vector pGEX-2TK, obtaining pGKgly. The resulting chimera protein, called GST-K-SI3gly, is similar to GST-SI3gly, but includes the recognition sequence for the catalytic subunit of cAMP-dependent protein kinase (PK) that is here underlined:
-Leu-Val-Pro-Arg $ Gly-Ser-Arg-Arg-Ala-Ser-Val-Met-Tyr-Ser-Phe-Pro-AsnWhen this new chimera was expressed and partially purified, it was efficiently and specifically cleaved by thrombin suggesting that the PK recognition sequence worked as 'spacer' between the two polypeptides, exposing the protease site (Fig. 3, lane 1). The 13glycosidase portion obtained in this way contained seven extra amino acids at its N-terminus. Nevertheless, this tail did not affect S~gly activity and thermal stability, conf'mrting that pGKgly vector can be used for the production of S[3gly mutants even severely affected in their properties.
83
Figure 3. 7% SDS-PAGE of GST-K-SI3gly fusions treated with thrombin protease, after Coomassie staining. Lane 1, GST-K-S[3gly fusion incubated o.n. at 25 ~ in the presence of thrombin protease (10 units/mg of chimeric protein). Lane 2, GST-K-S~gly fusion incubated o.n. at 25 ~ Lane 3, Molecular Weight Markers (see Fig. 2 legend). Lane 4, wild-type SI3gly.
5. CONCLUSIONS We have developed different strategies for optimization of the heterologous expression, improvement of the downstream processing, and analysis of the SI3gly, which offer us a versatile set of tools suitable for different applications. Our expression/purification system in yeast can be scaled up to production volumes, maintaining the foreign DNA stably in transformed cells, producing high biomass, high amount of the target product, consistency of yields in large volume fermentors, with low costs. Furthermore, the availability of GST-SI3gly fusions, besides interesting considerations on the structure-activity relationships of the wild-type enzyme, allows the purification of mutants designed to address questions about the enzyme activity, thermostability and thermophilicity.
6. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are grateful to prof. E. Martegani for strains and suggestions. This work was partially supported by: CNR Target Project Biotechnology and Bioinstrumentation, and CNR P. F. Ingeneria Genetica.
5. REFERENCES
1 2
M. Moracci, M.Ciaramella, R. Nucci, L. H. Pearl, I. Sanderson, A. Trincone and M. Rossi, Biocatalysis, 11 (1994) 89. F.M. Pisani, R. Rella, C. Rozzo, C. A. Raia, R. Nucci, A. Gambacorta, M. De Rosa and M. Rossi, Eur. J. Biochem., 187 (1990) 321.
84 3 4. 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13
R. Nucci, M. Moracci, C. Vaccaro, N. Vespa and M. Rossi, Biotechnol. Appl. Biochem., 17 (1993) 239. M.V. Cubellis, C. Rozzo, P. Montecucchi and M. Rossi, Gene, 94 (1990) 89. M. Moracci, A. LaVolpe, J. F. Pulitzer, M. Rossi and M. Ciaramella, J. Bacteriol., 174 (1992) 873. M. Moracci, R. Nucci, F. Febbraio, C. Vaccaro, N. Vespa, F. La Cara and M. Rossi, Enz. Microb.Technol., (1995) in press. A. Prisco, M. Moracci, M. Rossi and M. Ciaramella, J. Bacteriol., 177 (1995) 1614. L.H. Pearl, A. M. Hemmings, R. Nucci and M. Rossi, J. Mol. Biol., 229 (1993) 558. Henrissat, B., Biochem. J., 280 (1991) 309. C. Compagno, B. M. Ranzi and E. Martegani, FEBS Lett., 293 (1991) 97. C. Compagno, A. Tura, B. M. Ranzi and E. Martegani, Biotechnol. Progr., 9 (1993) 594. D.B. Smith and K. S. Johnson, Gene, 67 (1988) 31. B. Mannervik and U. H. Danielson, CRC Crit. Rev. Biochem., 23 (1988) 283.
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), Carbohydrate Bioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
85
Contribution of subsites to catalysis and specificity in the extended binding cleft of Bacillus 1,3-1,4-~3-D-glucan 4-glucanohydrolases Antoni Planas* and Caries Malet Laboratory of Biochemistry, Department of Organic Chemistry, CETS Institut Qufmic de Sarri?t, Universitat Ramon Llull, 08017 Barcelona, Spain
Abstract
Specific low molecular weight oligosaccharides having a chromophoric aglycon were synthesized for kinetic evaluation of the enzyme catalysis. A subsite mapping study showed that the active site cleft is composed of four subsites on the non-reducing end, and allowed to estimate the contribution of subsites - I I m -IV to transition state stabilization. In addition to a proper orientation of the scissile glycosidic bond of the substrate, inhibition kinetics with [3glucan- and cello-oligosaccharides suggest a binding preference of subsite -I for a 3-0substituted over a 4-O-substituted glucopyranose unit. Subsite +I, on the other hand, has a minor contribution to binding but the nature of the aglycon in the substrate largely affects catalysis.
1. INTRODUCTION 1,3-1,4-[3-D-glucan 4-glucanohydrolase (EC 3.2.1.73, abbreviated 1,3-1,4-[3-glucanase) catalyses the regio and stereospecific hydrolysis of [3-glucans containing mixed [3-1,3 and [3-1,4 glycosidic linkages as cereal 13-glucans and lichenan [1,2,3]. The trisaccharide 3-O-[3cellobiosyl-D-glucopyranose (1) and the tetrasaccharide 3-O-]3-cellotriosyl-D-glucopyranose (2) are the final hydrolysis products of barley [3-glucan, thus defining the enzymic specificity of cleavage on [3-1,4-glycosidic linkages in 3-O-substituted glucopyranose units.
I ~,,..OH FI H O ' 7 " .OH-~Z~o~O
(,,,OH
HO"~O~
OH
I (n=l)2 (n=2) The 1,3-1,4-[3-glucanases cloned and sequenced so far belong to two distinct enzyme families, plant and microbial enzymes, with no apparent sequence similarity and unrelated
86 three-dimensional structures. The Bacillus isozymes are the best characterized; they are highly homologous, with molecular masses of 25-30 kDa, active in a wide pH range, basic pI (8-9), and are quite thermostable proteins compared to the plant isozymes. Because of its importance in the food industry (brewing and animal feedstuff), the enzyme is a current target of protein engineering programs both to understand the enzyme function at the molecular level, and to redesign some enzyme properties for practical applications. Recent progress on the structure-function relationships in Bacillus 1,3-1,4-~-glucanases includes identification of the catalytic residues by site-directed mutagenesis [4,5] and chemical modification with active site-directed inhibitors [1], as well as determination of the tertiary structure by X-ray crystallography [6,7]. Bacillus licheniformis 1,3-1,4-~-glucanase is a retaining glycosidase [8] with Glu138 acting as the general acid catalyst and Glu134 as the catalytic nucleophile [5]. The three dimensional structure has been recently refined at 0.18 nm resolution by X-ray crystallography showing almost identical structure to that of the previously reported hybrid H(A16M) enzyme consisting of amino acid residues 1-16 from B. arnyloliquefaciens and the rest derived from B. macerans [6]. The protein adopts a jelly roll ~-sandwich fold with a carbohydrate-binding cleft located on the concave face of a ~-sheet formed of consecutive anfiparallel ~-strands. The catalytic residues Glu134, Asp136 and Glu138 are placed in the same ~-strand, and surrounded by a number of aromatic amino acid residues as it is commonly found in carbohydrate-binding proteins. The polysaccharide substrate may bind into the extended cleft which can be envisaged as formed of individual subsites each one accomodating a glucopyranose unit of the bound carbohydrate. The structure of a covalent enzyme-inhibitor complex between the hybrid H(A16M) 1,3-1,4-~-glucanase and 3,4-epoxybutyl ~-cellobioside [6] provides little information about the binding site cleft, since the cellobiose unit of the inhibitor only partially fills the cleft and it is covalently attached to the protein by an alkyl chain. Kinetic studies, on the other hand, have been limited to natural polysaccharide substrates, namely barley or oat ~-glucan, lichenan, and the reduced SIII pneumococcal polysaccharide (a regular polymer containing alternating 1,3- and 1,4-~-D-glucopyranosyl units [9]). These substrates undergo an extensive endo depolymerization with a large number of glycosidic bonds hydrolyzed per molecule yielding a complex mixture of oligosaccharides in a wide range of molecular weights at initial reaction times. Although they are currently used for analytical purposes (i.e. determination of I]-glucanase contents in cereals), the use of polysaccharide substrates is not appropriate for kinetic measurement in mechanistic studies of the enzyme action. We have recently prepared a family of low molecular weight I]-glucan oligosaccharides bearing a chromophofic aglycon as potential substrates for 1,3-1,4-~-glucanases. Here we describe their use in the enzymology of the Bacillus licheniformis enzyme aimed to evaluate the contribution of subsites in the extended binding site cleft to binding and catalysis.
87
2. RESULTS 2.1. Chromophoric substrates: 4-methylumbelliferyl 13-glucan oligosaccharides A set of low molecular weight 13-glucan oligosaccharides having a 4-methylumbelliferyl aglycon have been synthesized for kinetic evaluation of the enzyme catalysis [ 10]:
OH
r 0 3a
0
.OH'-]
?H
(,,OH
3b-e (n=0,3)
Criteria for designing the specific substrates were: a.-a basic substructure G3G-X according to the requirements of natural polysaccharide substrates (barley [3-glucan and lichenan) to be hydrolyzed by the enzyme, i.e. cleavage of a 13-1,4 glycosidic bond on a 3-O-substituted glucopyranose unit b.-single scissile glycosidic bond, so the enzymic reaction could be described by a simple kinetic model c.-release of a chromophoric aglycon upon enzymic hydrolysis for easy monitoring of the reaction course by continous UV or fluorescence spectrophotometry.
HPLC and NMR monitoring of the enzymic hydrolysis by B a c i l l u s l i c h e n i f o r m i s 1,3-1,4-13glucanase shows that 3a-e undergo a single cleavage with release of 4-methylumbelliferone, and that the reaction proceeds with net retention of the anomeric configuration. 2.2. Number of substites on the non-reducing end and their contribution to transition state stabilization Kinetics were performed at pH 7.3, 53 ~ conditions of maximum activity on the natural substrate barley 13-glucan. Initial velocities (<3% conversion) for 3a-e at different substrate concentrations were determined by monitoring the release of 4-methylumbelliferone at 365 nm (Ae = 5440 M-lcm-1). 3a is a very poor substrate, no saturation kinetics being observed up to 10 mM. The curve v o vs. IS] for 3b-e reaches a maximum and decreases at higher substrate concentration (Figure 1). The data were fitted to equation 1 that corresponds to an acompetitive substrate inhibition model. A clearly biphasic Hill plot, log[v/(V-v)] vs. log[S], (Figure 1, for 3d as an example) is consistent with this inhibition scheme, where a second molecule of substrate binds into the extended binding site cleft with formation of unproductive ternary complexes (ES2), producing a downward curvature of the Hill plot at high substrate concentration with the slope becoming negative (h =- 1). Kinetic parameters are summarized in Table 1.
88 2.0
k +l k2 E + S------~- E.S....___.~ E + p k-1 + S
1.6O~
1.5
1.2-
"~ 1.0
"-" x 0.8"
~E 0.0
E
,
b
h ~ = - I
"//
E.S
0.5-
vo =
-0.5" -1.0" -1.5
0.4-
kcat[Z~[Eo] K. +Is]+
w
-
!
-
|
-
(1)
Kt
i
-' .5-0.5 0.5 1.5 2.5 3.5 0.0-
In IS]
I
0
'
I
5
I
'
10 [S] (mM)
I
15
'
I
20
Figure 1. Steady-state kinetics for 3d. Inset: Hill plot
Table 1 Kinetic parameters of B.licheniformis 1,3-1,4-~-glucanase with substrates 3a-e. Substrate K M (mM) kcat (s "l) K 1 (mM) kcat/KM(M-Is -1) 3a
3b 3c 3d 3e
G-MUa G3G-MU G4G3G-MU G4G4G3G-MU G4G4G4G3G-MU
16.8+2.2 2.69+0.06 0.79+0.02 0.66+0.03
0.139+0.012 4.58+0.06 8.86+0.10 8.78+0.20
57.12+11.5 37.8+1.5 36.4+1.8 29.3+4.9
0.348+0.008 8.27+1.80 1700+60 11200+500 13300+900
a MU: 4-methylumbelliferyl. Conditions: citrate-phosphate buffer pH 7.3, 53~ 0.1 mM CaC12 [E]= 25-100nM, [S]" 3a 1-10 mM, 3b 1-51 mM, 3c 0.1-24 mM, 3d 0.1-22 mM, 3e 0.1-6 mM
The dependence of kcat and K M as a function of the degree-of-polymerization of the substrates approaches a plateau between the tetrasaccharide 3d and the pentasaccharide 3e. It inditates that the binding site cleft is composed of 4 subsites for glucopyranose units on the non-reducing end from the scissile glycosidic bond. This result was further analyzed by computer molecular modelling on the X-ray structure of the Bacillus licheniformis enzyme. Docking of a hexasaccharide into the binding cleft based on the 3D structure of the covalent protein-inhibitor complex between B.amyloliquefaciensB.macerans 1,3-1,4-[3-glucanase and 3,4-epoxybutyl I]-cellobioside [6] is consistent with a cleft containing 4 subsites, where a fifth glucopyranose unit on the non-reducing end is not conformationally restricted by the interaction with the protein in the productive complex, but rather it lays out the cleft and is solvent exposed.
89
Subsite mapping.
Binding to a multi-subsite binding site cleft of a depolymerase may lead to different positional isomers. The observed acompetitive substrate inhibition behaviour for compound 3b-e provides evidence for multiple binding modes, only one leading to a productive complex followed by specific hydrolysis at a single glycosidic bond. The general kinetics model accounts for all possible binary and ternary complexes, k +l,i,n ~_ E + Sn--. k -1,i,n
k2 ,r,n E'S i.n ' ' ' - ' ' - ~ +
E + Pn-1 +X
Sn
E'S i,n'Sj,n
where i and j indicate the binding mode (positional isomer), n is the length of the oligosaccharide, r denotes the productive complex, and E and Sn are the free enzyme and substrate. From steady-state considerations, the experimental kcat, K M and K I parameters relate to the microscopic constants of this model by
i :xr
(
KI -- ~lKr'n q" i,; ~-" 1/Ki'n
i :xr
)
l ~., ~_~1/Ki,nKi,j, n j
k 2,r,n
(kcatl=lk2,r I ~ KM ) ~. Kr )n
i
Kr, n and k2,r, n
being the microscopic Michaelis constant and the hydrolytic coeficient for the productive process, and Ki, n (ir r) and Ki,j,n the microscopic dissociation constants for the unproductive binary and ternary complexes. Only the second order rate constant (kcat/KM) is independent of the eventual formation of unproductive complexes. The subsite mapping model assumes that the free energy of binding at each subsite is an intrinsic constant, unaffected by binding or absence of binding at any other subsites [11], so - -Rr
2;
-
rAs.
h
AGh b being the contribution of a subsite h to the free energy of binding (AGnb) for a substrate of length n in the binding mode i. Because Kr, n and k2,r,n are not experimentally accessible, and assuming that the intrinsic binding energy can be used both for substrate binding and for lowering the activation free energy in catalysis, the contribution of each subsite to ligand
90 binding can not be calculated. Additional substrates to map the reducing end of the binding cleft are first required to complete the analysis and be able to estimate binding energies. However, the effect of occupying a subsite h on the second order rate constant kcat]K M is the contribution of that individual subsite to transition state stabilization, and can be expressed by the difference in transition state activation energy between two substrates differing in one glucopyranose unit according to AG*r,h=n+l = AG r,n+l ~ - AG ~ = - R T In r,n
(keat/KM )n+ 1 (kcat/KM) n
The values of AGh r are calculated from the data in Table 1 and summarized in Table 2.
Table 2 Contribution of subsites to transition state stabilization. Subsite Binding mode -I 3-O-Glcp -II 4-O-Glcp -III 4-O-Glcp -IV 4-O-Glcp -V
AGh* (kcal.mo1-1) -2.1+0.2 -3.5+0.2 -1.2+0.2 -0.11 +0.07
Figure 2. Subsites on the non-reducing end of the bound carbohydrate and their contribution to transition state stabilization.
Binding of 4-O-substituted glucopyranose units to subsites - I I - -IV have a stabilizing effect on the enzyme transition state complex with a larger contribution of subsite -III (Figure 2). A virtual subsite -V would contribute by less than 0.1 kcal.mo1-1, a value assigned to
91 unspecific interactions between the edge of the binding cleft and a fifth Glcp unit facing the bulk solvent in a loose conformation. Kinetics with substrates cannot give any information about subsite -I since it will be always occupied in the productive complex.
2.3. Contribution of substite -I to substrate specificity Being a heterodepolymerase, the contribution of each subsite varies depending on whether it is occupied by a 3-0- or 4-O-substituted glucopyranose unit. In addition to the proper orientation of the scissile glycosidic bond of the substrate, the strict substrate specificity shown by the enzyme suggests a preference for a 3-O-substituted glucopyranose in subsite -I. Inhibition kinetics with [3-glucan- (1, 2) and cello- (4, 5) oligosaccharides were analyzed to address the question of subsite selectivity. !
H
~
,.... OH
, I OH
F
~
~
c"OH
n
1 (n=l)
2 (n-2)
OH
ot4
4 (n=l)
"'OH
5 (n=2)
All of them behave as competitive inhibitors of B. licheniformis 1,3-1,4-]3-glucanase using the 4-methylumbelliferyl tetrasaccharide 3d as substrate. To avoid complex behaviour arising from substrate inhibition, the range of substrate concentration was chosen to be close to K M (0.33 mM < [S] < 1 mM, K M = 0.79 mM), far below K I (3d) = 36 mM (Table 1) under the same experimental conditions. Figure 3 shows the double reciprocal plot for 2 as an example. Inhibition constants are compiled in Table 3. 2
2.5-
1.5 2.0-
1
0.5 0
E 1.5-
[I] (mM)
i O
x o 1.00.50.0 -1.5
J '
I
-0.5
I
0.5
'
I
1.5
1/[S] (mM -1)
Figure 3. Competitive inhibition of 2 using 3d as substrate.
'
I
2.5
'
I
3.5
92 Table 3 Inhibition constants for the competitive inhibitors 1, 2, 4 and 5. Inhibitor K! (mM) 1 G4G3G 12.0+0.1 4 G4G4G 20.4_+0.3 2 G4G4G3G 2.28+0.04 5 G4G4G4G 5.60_+0.11 Conditions: citrate-phosphate buffer pH 7.3, 53~ 0.1 mM CaC12, [E]= 25nM, [S]=0.2-1 mM, [I]: 1 0-10 mM, 2 0-2 mM, 4 0-20 mM, 5 0-10 mM
The tetrasaccharides 2 and 5 are better inhibitors than the trisaccharides 1 and 4 as it may be expected for a glycosidase with an extended binding site. On the other hand, the [3-glucanoligosaccharides 1 and 2 having a [3-1,3 glycosidic bond have lower K! values than the corresponding cello-oligosaccharides 4 and 5. The change in free energy of binding associated with the structural modifications that relate any pair of inhibitors can then be calculated from the relationship A(AGb) = -RTln[(KI)x/(KI)y], where x and y refer to each compound. As shown in the thermodynamic cycle of Figure 4, the total free energy change in going from the worst inhibitor (G4G4G, 4) to the best one (G4G4G3G, 2) is independent of the path taken. However, the effect of each modification on binding depends on the pair of inhibitors considered. Thus, addition of a new glucopyranose unit to the non-reducing end of the ]3glucan-trisaccharide (1--)2, -1.08 kcal.mol ~ has a larger contribution than the same structural modification on the cello-trisaccharide (4--)5, -0.84 kcal.mol-1). Likewise, conversion of a ]3-1,4 to a 13-1,3 linkage has different effect for the trisaccharides (4--)1, -0.35 kcal.mol ~ than for the tetrasaccharides (5--)2,-0.58 kcal.mol-1). If the free energy of binding at each subsite is an intrinsic constant, unaffected by binding to any other subsite (subsite mapping model), this
G4G4G(4) ]
-0.84 "',,
-
~ [ G4G4G4G(5) ]
0 . 3 5 ,-'"
- 0.35 ss /
-
1.43
9
",,
G4G3G(1) ] Figure 4. A(AG b) in kcal.mo1-1 that relate the competitive inhibitors 1, 2, 4 and 5.
differential behaviour is interpreted as an evidence of different binding modes for each enzymeinhibitor complex.
93 Any microscopic interpretation should be handled with care since the measured K I values may be function of all possible equilibria between free enzyme and inhibitor, and a number of binary or even ternary complexes in different binding modes. A preferential binding mode, however, can be expected given the specificity of the enzyme. A binding model consistent with the above data is proposed and summarized in Figure 5.
(4) ~ ~ i ~ i ~ -IV
-III
-II
-I
AG_I (1___>4) ~ r
I
(-0.84)
9
~ 9
AG-I(I~3) - AG-Iv
js S
(-0.35)
oo oo
."
oS
I(
.r
~
(
5
-IV
-III
-II
(-0.58)
9149 9
) -I
I
AG-I(1---)3) - AG-I (1---~)
9
IIK
Figure 5. Proposed binding model describing the preferred binding modes. - O : 4-O-Glcp,-O" 3-O-Glcp. In parenthesis, A(AG b) in kcal.mo1-1
The 13-glucan-oligosaccharides 1 and 2 bind preferentially at subsites -I to -III or -IV, positioning the 13-1,3 glycosidic bond between subsites-I and-II as it may be expected from the substrate specificity shown by the enzyme. The A(AGb) value of-1.08 kcal-mo1-1 that relates 1 and 2 is thus the free energy of binding assignable to subsite -IV. This value is very close to that determined previously for AGe_IV (-1.2 + 0.2 kcal.mo1-1, see w suggesting that the contribution of this subsite to transition state stabilization (AGe_IV) is mainly due to stabilization of the enzyme-substrate complex. The cello-trisaccharide 4 will not bind as the ]3-glucan-trisaccharide 1. If subsite -I prefers a 3-O-substituted Glcp, and binding to subsite -IV is exoergonic, 4 will fill subsites -II to -IV. But, in going to the cello-tetrasaccharide 5, the additional glucopyranose may either lay out of the binding site cleft or fill subsite -I. Since K! for 5 is lower than for 4 (with an associated A(A G b) of-0.84 kcal.mol-1), the cello-tetrasaccharide will not bind to the same subsites -II to -IV because the fourth Glcp will have no contribution to binding, but rather it will fill subsite -I, resulting in a binding mode similar to that proposed for the 13-glucan-tetrasaccharide 2. Therefore, A(AG b) between 5 and 2 accounts for the preference of subsite -I for a 3-0substituted over a 4-O-substituted glucopyranose unit (-0.6 kcal.mol-1). From this model, the contribution of subsite -I to binding a 3-O-substituted glucopyranose unit of 13-glucan
94 oligosaccharides in the normal and preferential binding mode can be evaluated as being 1.4 kcal. mol- 1. The proposed model is tentative and requires further analysis, i.e. evaluation of the inhibitory capacity of the ct and [3 anomers, extend the analysis to larger oligosaccharides to test the consistency of the model, and determination of the 3D structure of some enzymeinhibitor complexes. 2.4. Subsite +I has a minor contribution to binding but a large contribution to catalysis The 4-methylumbelliferyl glycosides 3a-e reported as substrates (see w have an aromatic aglycon that fills subsite +I in the productive complex. To evaluate the effect of the leaving group in the hydrolytic reaction as well as the contribution of subsite +I to the enzyme specificity, compounds 6 and 7 were prepared and assayed with the B. licheniformis enzyme. Together with the 4-methylumbelliferyl trisaccharide 3c, these compounds share a common fragment ~-Glcp-(1-->4)-~-Glcp-(1-->3)-~-Glcp- that occupies subsites -I to -III in the productive complex (Figure 6). The methyl glycoside 6 is not hydrolyzed by the enzyme as determined by HPLC and NMR monitoring. On the other hand, the methyl glycoside 7 is a good substrate. Initial velocities were determined by monitoring the increase of reducing power due to the newly-formed reducing ends upon enzymic hydrolysis. The tetrasaccharide 7 (kcat/KM = 30000 M-ls 1) reacts 18-fold faster than the 4methylumbelliferyl trisaccharide 3c (kcat/KM = 1700 M'ls'l), equivalent to a difference in transition state activation energy (AAG~) of 1.9 kcal-mol 1. This difference in kcat~M is mainly due to kcat since both substrates have approximately the same KM values. If KM reflects the dissociation constant of the enzyme-inhibitor complex, this result suggests that the interaction of the glucopyranose unit of 7 with subsite +I is utilized in stabilizing the enzyme transition state with no additional stabilization of the enzyme-substrate complex.
OH
6
HHO ~
HO~a~,,,~.~ O OH
OH
3c
_OH
00~OxHO~Ox
_OH
_OH ~
:
OH
no hydrolysis
O.~. IVle
_OH o
_
Ho..L.,.,/~c~ HO4W,,,,'K,,-~O--~,~.'~,,--k..~-O~U-.~O
("OH
OH
OH
r OH
OH
(,.OH
~
OH
"IV "111 "11 "1 ' I Figure 6. Binding mode and kinetic parameters for substrates 3c, 6 and 7.
K M = 2.7 mM
kcat = 4.58 s1
KM= 2.6 mM
k at-7 s'
95 In terms of the enzyme mechanism, retaining glycosidases are believed to operate through a double displacement mechanism assisted by general acid-base catalysis [12]. Following the protonation of the glycosidic oxygen by the general acid, the mechanism involves some development of a positively charged oxocarbonium that is stabilized by the catalytic nucleophile either by electrostatic stabilization or by formation of a covalent glycosyl-enzyme intermediate. Since 7 and 3c only differ in the aglycon (leaving group) both leading to the same intermediate, the lower kcat value for 3c indicates that the rate determining step in the hydrolysis of the 4-methylumbellyferyl 13-glucan oligosaccharides is the initial glycosidation step up to the glycosyl-enzyme intermediate, prior to its hydrolytic break down by a water molecule.
3. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The authors thank Udo Heinemann (MCD, Berlin) for the resolution of the x-ray structure of the Bacillus licheniformis enzyme. This work was supported by Grant BIO94-0912-C02-02 from Comisi6n Interministerial de Ciencia y Tecnologfa (CICYT), Spain. C.M. acknowledges a fellowship from Generalitat de Catalunya.
4. REFERENCES
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12
P.B. Hc~j, R. Condron, J.C. Traeger, J.C. McAuliffe and B.A. Stone, J. Biol. Chem., (1992) 267, 25059. F.W. Parrish, A.S. Perlin and E.T. Reese, Can. J. Chem., (1960) 38, 2094. B.A. Stone and A.E. Clarke, in Chemistry and Biology of (1---~3)-]3-Glucans, La Trobe University Press, Australia, 1992. A. Planas, M. Juncosa, J. Lloberas and E. Querol, FEBS Lett., (1992) 308, 141. M. Juncosa, J. Ports, T. Dot, E. Querol and A. Planas, J. Biol. Chem., (1994) 269, 14530. T: Keitel, O. Simons, R. Borriss and U. Heinemann, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A., (1993) 90, 5287. T. Keitel, M. Meldgaard and U. Heinemann, Eur. J. Biochem., (1994) 222, 203. C. Malet, J. Jimdnez-Barbero, M. Bemab6, C. Brosa and A. Planas, (1993) Biochem. J., (1993) 296, 753. M.A. Anderson and B.A. Stone, FEBS Lett., (1975) 52, 202. C. Malet, J.L. Viladot, A. Ochoa, B. G~illego, C. Brosa and A. Planas, Carbohydr. Res., in press (1995). J.D. Allen, Methods Enzymol., (1980) 64, 248. M.L. Sinnott, (1990) Chem. Rev., (1990) 90, 1171.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
97
Probing of glycosidase active sites through labeling, mutagenesis and kinetic studies Stephen G. Withers Protein Engineering Network of Centres of Excellence and Department of Chemistry, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, British Columbia, Canada, V6T 1Z1 Abstract Glycosidases which hydrolyses their substrates with net retention of anomeric configuration (retaining enzymes) do so via a double-displacement mechanism in which a covalent glycosylenzyme is formed and hydrolysed with acid/base catalytic assistance via oxocarbenium ion-like transition states. Strategies for identification of the nucleophilic residue and the acid/base catalytic residue have been devised. By use of mechanism-based inhibitors to trap the glycosylenzyme intermediate and affinity labels to derivatise the acid/base catalyst, in combination with novel mass spectrometric techniques, the identities of these residues have been determined in several glycosidases. In all cases identified to date these have turned out to be the carboxylic amino acids glutamate and aspartate. Armed with this knowledge, a retaining glycosidase has been converted into an inverter through replacement of the nucleophilic glutamate by alanine, along with the addition of alternative anionic nucleophiles such as azide and formate to the reaction medium. This provides the first example in which such a change of mechanism in a glycosidase has been effected.
1. INTRODUCTION The principal criterion by which glycosidases can be classified mechanistically is the stereochemical outcome of the bond cleavage which they carry out. One group of glycosidases hydrolyses the glycosidic linkage with net inversion of anomeric configuration, and these are known as inverting enzymes. Thus an inverting o~-glucosidase, for example, would hydrolyse an ot-glucoside substrate yielding ~3-glucose as the first-formed sugar product. Mutarotation would of course subsequently equilibrate this to the thermodynamic mixture of or- and ]3glucose. The second group of glycosidases hydrolyses the glycosidic linkage with net retention of anomeric configuration, and these are known as retaining enzymes. Different mechanisms are required for such different stereochemical outcomes, and indeed the fundamentals of these mechanisms were proposed over 40 years ago by Koshland [1]. These are shown in the diagram below in which the enzyme active sites are represented by boxes containing two key carboxylic acid residues. Clearly a large number of other residues are essential for specificity and catalysis, particularly those whose function is to bind to and stabilise the substrate as it
98 approaches its transition state conformation. However these have been omitted from this diagram in the interests of clarity.
RETAINING MECHANISM H
I
o
,fo
OH
HOiO
H
INVERTING MECHANISM
oLo H
OH
I
As is suggested by this diagram, there are considerable similarities between these two classes of enzymes in that both contain a pair of carboxylic acid residues suitably disposed on either side of the bond to be cleaved. However, as will become apparent, the roles of these two residues are different. In the case of the inverting enzymes, the mechanism involves a direct displacement in which the water attacks at the anomeric centre with general base catalytic assistance from one of the carboxylates. In a somewhat symmetrical manner, the other carboxylic acid functions as a general acid catalyst, protonating the leaving glycosidic oxygen in a process concerted with bond breaking. This results in hydrolysis with net inversion of anomeric configuration. The mechanism for the retaining enzymes, by contrast, involves a double displacement reaction in which a covalent glycosyl-enzyme intermediate is formed and hydrolysed. In the first step the deprotonated carboxylate functions as a nucleophile, attacking at the anomeric centre and displacing the glycosidic oxygen in a process which occurs with general acid catalytic assistance from the protonated carboxylic acid. This results in the formation of a covalent glycosyl-enzyme intermediate. In the second step water attacks at the anomeric centre of the glycosyl-enzyme species with general base-catalytic assistance from the deprotonated carboxylate, displacing the enzymatic active site nucleophile and releasing product sugar and free enzyme.
99 Both these steps, as well as the single step for the inverting enzyme, proceed via transition states with considerable oxocarbenium ion character. This means that, formally, bond cleavage precedes attack by the nucleophile, reaction proceeding via a dissociative (Snl) pathway. However, there is considerable evidence that there is still some degree of pre-association by the nucleophile, be it water or the active site carboxylate, presumably as one way of helping to stabilise the relatively unstable oxocarbenium ion [2]. The best evidence for the involvement of these oxocarbenium ion-like transition states has come from secondary deuterium kinetic isotope effect studies which provide insight into changes in hybridisation state at the anomeric centre between the ground state for the step in question and its subsequent transition state. Isotope effects between 1.05 and 1.25 have been measured for both steps (glycosylation and deglycosylation) for [~-glycosidases [3,4], and recently large isotope effects have been measured for ~-glycosidases [5]. Additional evidence has come from the potent inhibition afforded by inhibitors such as glyconolactones and amidinosugars which bear considerable structural resemblance to the proposed transition state [6]. Such inhibitors are, of course, recruiting the strong binding interactions which have evolved for stabilisation of the transition state conformation of the cleaving substrate. While the mechanism of retaining glycosidases is most conveniently described as proceeding through a covalent glycosyl-enzyme intermediate via oxocarbenium ion-like transition states, it is also quite possible that the oxocarbenium ion species flanking this covalent intermediate could be sufficiently stable to exist as short-lived species in their own right. This does not, however, significantly change the mechanistic description.
2. CARBOXYLIC ACIDS PLAYING A ROLE IN CATALYSIS 2.1. Identification of the active site carboxylic acids in retaining glycosidases Knowledge of the identities of the two key carboxylic acid-containing amino acids (aspartate or glutamate) in glycosidases is of considerable importance not only academically, but also for any structure/function or mutagenic studies as well as in cases where mutants are being made to provide enzymes of altered properties. A very effective, though typically rather labor-intensive, way of getting this information, as well as insight into the identifies of the other active site amino acids is through X-ray crystallographic determination of the 3-dimensional structure of the protein. Indeed, the structures of a number of glycosidases have now been determined crystallographically, and a compilation of the recently determined structures is provided in a recent review [7]. Frequently, however, this technique is not applicable, or available, and it is necessary to resort to other methods of identification. Further, even when a three-dimensional structure is available it is not always clear which amino acids are important unless the structure of an enzyme/substrate or enzyme/inhibitor complex has been determined. Even then it is also possible that the substrate or analogue may be bound in an unproductive mode, leading to a misassignment. An alternative approach involves the use of affinity labels, or far preferably, mechanismbased inactivators, to specifically derivatise the key amino acids in the active site. This requires the development of reagents which are capable of selectively reacting with and covalently "marking" the residues of interest. This manuscript reviews methods developed in the author's laboratory for the identification of these residues. Identification of active site nucleophiles in
100 glycosidases is carried out using a class of mechanism-based inactivator which traps the glycosyl-enzyme intermediate, in conjunction with electrospray tandem mass spectrometric methods for the localisation and sequencing of the labeled peptide within proteolytic digests. Identification of the acid/base residue can sometimes be achieved using affinity labels, or via detailed kinetic analysis of mutants modified at conserved glutamic and aspartic acids. 2.2. Identification of the active site nucleophile As noted above, the mechanism for retaining glycosidases involves the formation of a glycosyl-enzyme intermediate in which the sugar is covalently attached to the protein via the carboxylic side chain of a glutamic or aspartic acid. One way of identifying the nucleophilic amino acid residue would be to trap this intermediate by somehow decreasing its deglycosylafion rate. This requires differential manipulation of the rates of formation (glycosylation) and hydrolysis (deglycosylation) of the intermediate to slow the deglycosylafion step enormously from its typical values (t 1/2 around 1-10 ms) without ultimately slowing the glycosylafion step to as great an extent, since if this step were also slowed enormously, no intermediate would accumulate. This was achieved through the use of 2-deoxy-2-fluoro glycosides with good leaving groups such as dinitrophenolate or fluoride [8,9]. The presence of the C-2 fluorine substituent slows both the glycosylation and deglycosylation steps in two ways. One way relates to the fact that the hydroxyl substituent at C-2 plays a crucial role in transition state stabilisation in glycosidases by making key interactions (worth more than 8 kcal/mol), probably predominantly hydrogen bonding interactions, with the enzyme active site [10,11]. Replacement of the hydroxyl by fluorine, a substituent of limited hydrogen bonding potential, likely deletes, or at least decreases the value of, these hydrogen bonding interactions, destabilising both transition states significantly. The second way in which the fluorine substituent slows the two steps is through inductive destabilisation of the two electron-deficient transition states. Fluorine is much more electronegative than a hydroxyl, thus the positive charge developed at the transition state will be significantly destabilised by the presence of this substituent, slowing down both steps. The consequence of these two effects combined is a massive (up to 106 - 107 fold) reduction in rates of both steps [12,13]. Incorporation of a good leaving group such as 2,4-dinitrophenolate or fluoride speeds up the glycosylation step relative to the deglycosylation step with the effect that the intermediate is accumulated. Incubation of the enzyme with its corresponding 2-deoxy-2-fluoroglycoside then results in time-dependent inactivation, via the accumulation of a relatively stable 2-deoxy-2-fluoroglycosyl-enzyme intermediate.
H~
r
~1"~\ Ho4
-
o
HO/~O O~N
-o,r I
IH
.OH HO/~O o
,co I
o2N
o"
I
101 Supporting evidence for this mechanism of inactivation has been obtained in several ways. Firstly, stoicheometric reaction of inhibitor and enzyme has been demonstrated by electrospray mass spectrometry and by measurement of the magnitude of the "burst" of dinitrophenolate released [13]. Secondly, 19F-NMR studies of the inactivated enzyme have demonstrated the formation of a covalent ot-D-glycopyranosyl-enzyme intermediate [14]. Thirdly, and very importantly, the intermediate has been demonstrated to be catalytically competent. This was achieved by purifying inactivated enzyme of contaminating inactivator, then monitoring the reactivation of the enzyme consequent on turnover of this intermediate and release of the free enzyme [13,15]. Reactivation can be greatly accelerated by the inclusion of a suitable sugar acceptor into the reactivation mixture, such that turnover occurs via transglycosylation, a reaction typical of glycosidases. Identification of the amino acid residue labelled has been achieved in two distinct ways. The first of these required the synthesis of a radiolabelled version of the inactivator to generate a radiolabelled enzyme. Standard methods of proteolysis, HPLC separation of the resultant peptide mixture, and purification and ultimately sequencing of the radiolabeled peptide were then employed. This strategy was used successfully to identify the active site nucleophiles of four glycosidases, the ~-glucosidase from Agrobacterium faecalis, the exo-xylanase/glucanase from Cellulomonas fimi, the [3-galactosidase from Escherichia coli, and endo glucanase C from Clostridium thermocellum [15-18]. An alternative strategy, which obviates the need for synthesis of radiolabelled versions of the inactivator, involves the use of electrospray tandem mass spectrometry to identify the labeled peptide within a proteolytic digest, by monitoring for a collision-induced fragmentation reaction that is specific to the sugar-peptide linkage. This is illustrated below and in Figure 1 using the identification of the catalytic nucleophile in human [3-glucocerebrosidase by inactivation of the enzyme with 2-deoxy-2-fluoro-[3-glucosyl fluoride as an example [19]. Human 13-glucocerebrosidase is a lysosomal enzyme that cleaves the [3-glucosidic linkage of glucosylceramide. It is a membrane-associated glycoprotein (67 kDa, 497 amino acids) with both high mannose and complex oligosaccharides [20], whose crucial role in glycolipid catabolism has been established by disruption of the GCase gene in mice. Such mice die within hours of birth [21]. Inherited deficiencies of the human enzyme result in the variants of Gaucher disease, the most prevalent lysosomal storage disorder, affecting some 20,000 to 30,000 individuals worldwide. As such, this disease has been a prototype for the development of enzyme replacement therapies using specifically oligosaccharide-modified enzyme for targetting to the major sites of pathologic involvement, the macrophages of the liver, spleen and bone marrow [22-24]. Given the clinical, and commercial, importance of this enzyme, considerable interest in the identifies of active site residues is warranted, especially given the desire to understand the reasons for the inactivity of the enzyme in naturally occurring mutants. Treatment with 2-deoxy-2-fluoro-~-glucosyl fluoride (2FGlcF) resulted in time-dependent inactivation of the enzyme according to pseudo first order kinetics, yielding a value for the second order inactivation rate constant of ki/Ki = 22.7 min-lM 1. Inclusion of castanospermine (8.3 ~M), a known competitive inhibitor of GCase (Ki = 7 t.tM) in an inactivation mixture containing 10.4 mM 2FGlcF reduced kobs, the pseudo-first order inactivation rate constant, from 0.23 n ~ -1 to 0.15 min -1, showing that the inactivation was a consequence of reaction at the active site. Further the intermediate was shown to be catalytically competent by removal of excess inactivator from the labeled enzyme and then monitoring the return of activity. This was
102 a first order process, with a spontaneous reactivation rate constant, kreac of 5.3 x 10-4 min -1, corresponding to a half-life of tl/2 = 1300 minutes. The site of labeling was then identified by proteolysis of the labeled enzyme followed by HPLC separation, using an electrospray ionisation mass spectrometer (ESMS) to identify the labeled peptide by observing a specific, predicted fragmentation reaction, as follows. Peptic hydrolysis of 2FGlc-labeled GCase resulted in a mixture of peptides which was separated by reversed phase-HPLC using the ESMS as detector. When the spectrometer was scanned in the normal LC/MS mode, the total ion chromatogram (TIC) of the 2FGlc-labeled GCase digest displayed a large number of peaks, which arise from every peptide in the mixture (Fig. la). The 2-fluoroglucosylated peptide was then identified in a second run by using the tandem mass spectrometer set up in the neutral loss mode. In this technique the ions are subjected to
!
'| c i"1
IO
lo
~.1oo
J-
1~
14
111
18 INn.
10
~1oo
J:
I"''
12
14
10
18 mlrL
D
o
m~z
1000
11~00
Figure 1. ESMS experiments on glucocerebrosidase proteolytic digests.
limited fragmentation by collisions with an inert gas (Ar) in a collision cell located between the two quadrupole mass filters. Since the ester linkage between the sugar inhibitor and the peptide is quite labile under these conditions, relatively facile homolytic cleavage of this bond occurs with loss of a neutral sugar residue of known mass (165 Da) leaving the peptide moiety with its original charge. The two quadrupole analysers on either side of the collision cell can then be scanned in a linked manner in which the scanning of the two analyzers is offset by the mass of the anticipated "lost" neutral species. Under these conditions only ions differing in m/z by the mass of the lost sugar moiety (165 Da) can pass through both quadrupoles and be detected. As can be seen in Figure l b, when the spectrometer was scanned in this neutral loss tandem MS/MS mode searching for the mass loss m/z 165, corresponding to the loss of the 2FGlc label
103
100 ~
75
-
50
m
FASEA+2r--Gk:
F~
25
FASE
11
3OO
4OO
" m/z
~/ 35OO
6OO
7OO
Figure 2. Tandem MS/MS daughter ion spectrum of the 2FGlc-labeled peptide.
a true reflection of the activity of the enzyme, but results from contamination by wild type enzyme likely due to translational misincorporation, since equivalent levels of misincorporation have been observed previously [26,27]. Indeed, the activity observed is completely inactivatable by 2FGlcF at rates comparable to those of wild type enzyme, a result which is inconsistent with the expected enzymatic activity of a mutant in which the attachment site has been removed. This method has now been applied to a number of different glycosidases, including some whose catalytic nucleophile had been identified previously, namely Agrobacterium faecalis ~5glucosidase, Cellulomonas fimi exo-xylanase/glucanase and Clostridium thermocellum endo glucanase C [28], as well as the Bacillus subtilis xylanase [29]. The importance of these residues to catalysis has been confirmed in each case by kinetic analysis of mutants modified at those positions, and their active site location has been confirmed by X-ray crystallographic analysis of two of the enzymes, the Cellulomonas fimi exo-xylanase/glucanase [30] and the Bacillus subtilis xylanase [31 ]. 2.3. Identification of the a c i d / b a s e r e s i d u e by affinity labeling Techniques for the identification of this residue are not as well developed, or as reliable, as those described for identification of the catalytic nucleophile. One method which has been successful in several cases involves the use of an affinity label based upon a sugar with a reactive anomeric N-bromoacetyl functionality. The hope with this class of labels is that the reactive N-bromoacetyl moiety will react preferentially with the active site carboxylic acid in whose proximity it is bound, as shown in the Scheme below. I
.o~--~\
.
.........
.j
HO,,~
-
0
l
o, .o o
~c.O I
O~c..O t
104 N-Bromoacetyl 13-glycosylamines were first used as affinity labels with Escherichia coli [3galactosidase [32], the labeled amino acid being identified as Met501. More recently we have described their use as affinity labels for both the Agrobacterium faecalis 13-glucosidase and the Cellulomonas fimi exo-xylanase/glucanase [33]. In the former case, mass spectrometric analysis of the enzyme labeled with N-bromoacetyl ~-glucosylamine revealed that, even though simple pseudo-first order kinetics of inactivation had been determined, the inactivated enzyme was labeled with at least three equivalents of inactivator (Figure 3). The picture is further complicated by the presence of two native [~-glucosidase species of masses 51,205 and 51,066, corresponding to species with and without an N-terminal methionine residue. The presence of this N-terminal methionine residue, due to incomplete processing at the higher expression levels employed, has previously been shown to have no effect upon kinetic parameters. However in the case of the Cellulomonas fimi exo-xylanase/glucanase, inactivation by Nbromoacetyl ]3-cellobiosylamine resulted in the addition of only a single equivalent of inactivator per enzyme, as shown by the mass increase of (Am = 382) in Figure 4. The multiple labeling seen for the [3-glucosidase precluded simple identification of the site of labeling which led to inactivation, but the single labeling seen for the C. fimi exo-xylanase/glucanase provided an ideal system for study. Since it seemed unlikely that an appropriate neutral loss fragmentation would be observed in proteolytic digests of the labeled enzyme the identification of the site of labeling was attempted via comparative analysis of HPLC/ESIMS profiles of peptic digests of the labeled and unlabeled enzymes, using the mass information to "realign" the profiles and thereby correct for the irreproducibility of the HPLC chromatograms. A search was thus made for a peptide which was present in the labeled sample, but absent from the unlabeled sample, which was also greater in mass by exactly the mass of the label (Am = 382) than another peak which was present in the unlabeled sample, but (ideally) absent from the labeled. After searching through all the peaks only one peptide was found which met these criteria. Figure 5 shows the composite mass spectrum of all the peptides eluting from the HPLC between 19 and 24 minutes, the region in which the peptide of interest eluted. As can be seen, a peptide of m/z = 1028 is present in the digest of the labeled protein (Figure 5B), but is not found in the equivalent digest of the unlabeled enzyme (Figure 5A). Correspondingly, a peptide of rrgz = 646, smaller by the mass of the label (382), is found in the digest of the unlabeled enzyme, but only at lower intensity in the digest from the labeled. Ideally this peptide would not be found in the sample of the labeled protein digest, but is presumably present because of incomplete labeling or, more likely, because of partial degradation of the labeled peptide. A search of the amino acid sequence of Cex revealed only nine peptides of this mass which could be generated from this protein. The peptide was then further purified by reverse phase (C-18) HPLC, using the mass spectrometer as the detector, and sequenced by the Edman degradation in collaboration with Dr. Ruedi Aebersold, using the modified Edman reagent developed by his group and a mass spectrometric detector [34,35]. The great advantage of this approach, in which a mass spectrometer is used to identify the product modified phenylthiohydantoins, is that the mass of the modified amino acid phenylthiohydantoin is directly obtained. Using this approach the sequence DVVNEA was determined for this peptide, where the 5 th cycle resulted in the release of a phenylthiohydantoin derivative of m/z = 822. This is exactly the mass predicted for the phenylthiohydantoin of Nbromoacetylcellobiosylamine-modified glutamic acid.
105 1
I
422~
~, 1001
Sl,644"
Z
$11~S1,066 II $1,290#
i
2
47
4'i,ao6 ' Mo~ctw' Wdl~t
4,,000
4~,soo
4? 4M
$1;000
51,400
Molecular Welsht
$1,800
4
Figure 3. Reconstructed glucosidase
ESMS
of
000
'
22,758
A
e62
8.0
921
4.0
1014
........
0.0
892
16.1' 12.1'
47J4)0.
8O6
12.1
| n"
--
Figure 4: Reconstructed ESMS of C. fimi labeled with N-bromoacetylglucosylamine, exo-glycanase, a) free, b) labeled.
13-
16.1 646
a,i
47,400
Mdeeular Wellkt
792 80e
646
8.0
~ .,-~~~
752
B
880 |
I
682 7 1 4
22,758
936 9621183 806 922
1028 1014
4.0
0.0
650
700
750
800
850
900
950
1000
1050
m/z
Figure 5. Mass spectra of proteolytic peptides of C. fimi exo-glycanase, A) free, B) labeled.
106 Alignment of the sequence of this peptide with the amino acid sequence of the enzyme indicates that the modified residue corresponds to Glu127. Gratifyingly this residue was recently identified as the most likely candidate for the acid-base residue on the basis of a detailed kinetic analysis of mutants modified at conserved glutamic and aspartic acid residues [36]. In addition, this residue has very recently been located in the active site of the enzyme through X-ray crystallographic determination of the 3-dimensional structure [30]. In addition to the above, the putative acid site acid catalytic residue in the I]-glucosidase from Manicot esculenta has recently been identifed using N-bromoacetyl 13-glucopyranosylamine as affinity label, locating the labeled peptide through use of radiolabels [37].
2.4. Identification of the acid/base residue by kinetic analysis of mutants The alternative approach to identification of the acid catalytic residue involves performance of a detailed kinetic analysis of mutants which have been created in which strictly conserved glutamic and aspartic acids are, individually, replaced by alanine residues. The approach is illustrated with the exo-glucanase/xylanase from Cfimi (Cex). Cex belongs to a family of more than 20 enzymes capable of hydrolysing xylan and cellulose. Hydrolysis occurs with net retention of anomeric configuration [38], thus it is a 'retaining' glycosidase, following a double displacement mechanism [39]. Sequence comparisons permit the identification of a number of conserved amino acid residues in this family, among which are 6 glutamic and aspartic acids, the probable candidates for the acid/base catalyst as noted earlier. As expected, it is found that the catalytic nucleophile Glu233 identified using the fluorosugar approach [16] is indeed one of these conserved residues, thus establishing one of the others as the probable acid/base catalyst. The strategy used thus involves mutation of these conserved Glu and Asp residues to alanine, then detailed investigation of the kinetic properties of the mutants so generated. Such an investigation requires the application of several mechanistic tests, as described below. As noted previously, the residue in question will function as an acid catalyst in the first step (glycosylation) and as a base catalyst in the second (deglycosylation). Therefore deletion of this residue might be expected to slow down both steps. However if a substrate is used which has a very good leaving group not requiring acid catalysis for its departure, then in that case the first step may not be significantly compromised for the mutant, but the second step necessarily will be since this step is common for all substrates of a fixed sugar type. Mutants modified at Glu 127 do indeed show this behaviour as can be seen in the table below. Rates of the first step, glycosylation, were assessed through kcat/Km measurements since in this system kcat~rn represents the first irreversible step, which is indeed glycosylation. Rates of deglycosylation were obtained from kcat values of substrates for which deglycosylation was rate-limiting. As can be seen, for an excellent substrate such as 2',4'-dinitrophenyl cellobioside (pKa of leaving 2,4-dinitrophenol = 4.0) the first step (kcat/Km) is not significantly slowed by mutation, whereas for a substrate requiring some acid catalysis such as 4'-nitrophenyl cellobioside (pKa of 4'-nitrophenol =7.0) there is a significant rate reduction, and for substrates with leaving groups of very high pKa such as 4-bromophenol (pKa = 10) the rate was much lower again. These results are therefore completely consistent with the role of Glu127 as the acid/base catalyst. A second consequence of removal of the acid/base catalyst is that a small cavity, possibly capable of accomodating an anion, will be generated at the ~-face of the substrate adjacent to
107 Table 1 Kinetic parameters for h~,drolysis of various substrates by Cex and E 127 mutants Enzyme Substrate kcat (min "1) Km (mM) kcat/Km (min-lmM-1) Native Cex DNPC 419 0.06 6983 PNPC 677 0.53 1278 PBrPC 255 2.0 128 E127A DNPC 2.4 0.0003 7742 PNPC 2.3 0.025 92 PBrPC 4.0 x 10-2 1.9 2.1 x 10-2
the anomeric centre. Such a site could permit the binding and attack of a nucleophilic anion at the anomeric centre. If a substrate with a good leaving group, such as DNPC, is employed, the second step (deglycosylation) will be rate-limiting, thus reaction of the intermediate with an anion more nucleophilic than water, and one not requiring general base catalysis, will result in an increase in the steady state rate. Such is indeed found to be the case, as is shown in Figure 6. Increasing concentrations of sodium azide as exogenous nucleophile result in progressive increases in kcat values. As can be seen, much greater overall rate increases are seen with DNPC (200-fold) than with PNPC (8-fold), rates reaching a limiting value at higher azide concentrations. This plateauing of rates is clearly due to a change in rate-determining step. As azide concentrations are increased, so the deglycosylation rate increases, and the steady state rate with it, up to the point at which the rate of the deglycosylation step becomes greater than that of the glycosylation step. Beyond this point no further rate increases are observed. The lower maximal rate observed with PNPC than with DNPC is therefore consistent with the smaller glycosylation rate constant for the substrate with the poorer leaving group. This mechanism therefore requires that the reaction product in the presence of azide be ]3cellobiosyl azide. This was clearly shown by chemical synthesis of ]3-cellobiosyl azide and comparison of its chromatographic behaviour and 1H-NMR spectrum with that of the reaction mixture. The two were shown to be identical. Interestingly, as can be seen in Figure 6, values of kcat/Km are esentially invariant with azide concentration. This is also completely consistent with the proposed mechanism since the parameter kcat/Km reflects the first irreversible step in catalysis, formation of the glycosyl-enzyme intermediate, and this step is not affected by nucleophilic competition with the water. These data therefore combine to strongly suggest that Glu127 is indeed the acid/base catalyst in Cex. This is, of course, the same residue that was identified using the Nbromoacetylcellobiosylamine affinity label, and as has been noted earlier, it has been found in the appropriate location in the active site by X-ray crystallographic analysis [30]. This concurrence of findings lends great confidence to this approach to identifying the acid/base residue. 3. MODIFYING THE MECHANISM As noted in the introductory section of this manuscript, both inverting and retaining glycosidases have a pair of carboxylic acids present in their active site, playing crucial roles,
108
,otl , 0
~ 10
0
o
o,o 1.oo
to.,o
1,oo
0 20
30
.
0
40
50
1oo
~
"0
60
Azicle concentration (raM)
B
0 'c
600'
0.060
600
5OO
0.050
soo -."
400
0.040
E 4 0 0 ,."
3oo
0.030
200
0.020
100
0.010
0
r
-9
0
.
-4
600
,
I
1000
,
4
it * 300
g
200
100
"
O.OOC
I
IS00
2000
Azk:le concentration (raM)
Figure 6. Kinetic parameters for hydrolysis of PNPC (panel A) and 2,4-DNPC (panel B) by Cex Glu127Ala in the presence of various concentrations of sodium azide.
albeit these roles are somewhat different in the two cases. In addition, both classes of enzyme catalyse hydrolysis via oxocarbenium ion-like transition states. There are therefore considerable similarities between the two classes of enzyme. However one difference which would be expected would be that the two carboxylic acids should be further apart in the inverting enzymes than in the retainers since, in addition to the bound glycoside, a water molecule has to be fitted in between the two groups. These expectations are indeed conf'm'ned upon inspection of crystal structures of enzymes of both mechanistic classes. Such an analysis [7,27] revealed that the two carboxylic acids are approximately 57k apart (oxygen to oxygen) in retaining enzymes, but approximately 9.5]~ apart in inverting enzymes. This opened up the possibility of converting an enzyme from one mechanistic class to the other by changing the separation of their carboxylic acids. The first attempt to do this on the Agrobacterium faecalis [3-glucosidase, for which no three-dimensional structural information is available, involved simply the mutation of the nucleophilic carboxylate, Glu358, to an aspartic acid, thereby increasing the separation, but only by about 1/~ [40]. This mutant was indeed active, with an activity some 2500-fold reduced over wild type, but product analysis revealed that it still followed the retaining mechanism. Clearly a greater separation was necessary if the mechanisms were to be changed, but in the absence of 3-dimensional structural information it was not clear how this would be
109 achieved. A second alternative involved the complete removal of this residue, replacing it by alanine so that it could not follow a retaining mechanism. This could work well if general base catalytic assistance for the attack of water were not too important. Such a mutant was indeed constructed, but as is shown in the Table below, it was essentially completely catalytically inactive, with an apparent kcat value some 107-fold lower than wild type enzyme. Clearly general base catalysis is very important as has indeed been shown for several other naturally inverting glycosidases (see for example ref. 41). However, addition to this mutant of small nucleophilic anions which do not need general base catalytic assistance resulted in enormous regains of activity of up to 105 fold, most of the way back up to wild type activity.
Table 2 Kinetic parameters for hydrolysis of 2,4-DNP-glucoside by Agrobacterium ~-glucosidase and its Glu358Ala mutant. Enzyme + activators kcat (s -1) Km (mM) Native glucosidase 89 0.031 E358A 7 x 10-6 0.1 E358A + 2M azide 1.1 3.8 E358A + 4M formate 3.0 1.1
Further, analysis of the reaction product in the presence of sodium azide revealed that ctglucosyl azide was indeed being formed, presumably through the inverting mechanism shown below.
I 70 H
o~C~oH
I o/JC~oH
OH H O H o ~ ~
o
OH
L_ N3 ~H3
OH I N3
CH3 I
This provides the first example of a change in mechanism being intentionally engineered into a glycosidase, and thereby serves both as a reassurance that the mechanisms and active site structures of these two classes of glycosidase (inverting and retaining) might not be so
110 different, and that it is indeed possible to modify these enzymes in a defined way so as to alter their catalytic activities.
4. A C K N O W L E D G E M E N T S
The author would like to thank the many co-workers and collaborators who made this work possible. Their names are listed in the references provided. I also thank the Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada and the Protein Engineering Network of Centres of Excellence for financial support.
5. REFERENCES
9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
22
D.E. Koshland, Biol. Rev. 28 (1953) 416. N.S. Banait and W.P Jencks, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 113 (1991) 7958. M.L. Sinnott, Chem. Rev., 90 (1990) 1171. J.B. Kempton and S.G. Withers, Biochemistry 31 (1992) 9961. Y. Tanaka, W. Tao, J.S. Blanchard and E.J. Hehre, J. Biol. Chem., 269 (1994) 32306. G. Legler, Adv. Carb. Chem. Biochem., 48 (1990) 319. J. McCarter and S.G. Withers, Current Opinion in Structural Biology, 4 (1994) 885. S.G. Withers, I.P Street, P. Bird and D.H. Dolphin, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 109 (1987) 7530. S.G. Withers, K. Rupitz and I.P. Street, J. Biol. Chem., 263 (1988) 7929. J. McCarter, M. Adam and S.G. Withers, Biochem. J., 286 (1992) 721. R. Wolfenden and W.M. Kati, Acc. Chem. Res., 24 (1991) 209. I.P. Street, K. Rupitz and S.G. Withers, Biochemistry, 28 (1989) 1581. I.P. Street, J.B. Kempton and S.G. Withers, Biochemistry, 31 (1992) 9970. S.G. Withers and I.P. Street, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 110 (1988) 8551. S.G. Withers, R.A.J. Warren, I.P. Street, K. Rupitz and J.B. Kempton, R.Aebersold, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 112 (1990) 5887. D. Tull, S.G. Withers, N.R. Gilkes, D.G. Kilburn, R.A.J. Warren and R. Aebersold, J. Biol. Chem., 266 (1991) 15621. J.C. Gebler, R. Aebersold and S.G. Withers, J. Biol. Chem., 267 (1992) 11126. Q. Wang, D. Tull, A. Meinke, N.R. Gilkes, R.A.J. Warren, R. Aebersold and S.G. Withers, J. Biol. Chem., 268 (1993) 14096. S. Miao, J.D. McCarter, M. Grace, G. Grabowski, R. Aebersold and S.G. Withers, J. Biol. Chem., 269 (1994) 10975. A. Berg-Fussman, M. Grace, Y. Ioannou and G. Grabowski, J. Biol. Chem., 268 (1993) 14861. V. Tybulewicz, M. Tremblay, M. LaMarca, R. Willemsen, B. Stubblefield, S. Winfield, B. Zablocka, E. Sidransky, B. Martin, S. Huang, K. Mintzer, H. Westphal, R. Mulligan and E. Ginns, Nature, 357 (1992) 407. N.W. Barton, F.S. Furbish, G.J. Murray, M. Garfield and R.O. Brady, Proc. Natl.
111
23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41
Acad. Sci. U.S.A, 87 (1990) 1913. M.L. Figueroa, B.E. Rosenbloom, A.C. Kay, P. Garver, D.W. Thurston, J.A. Koziol, T. Gelbart and E. Beutler, The New England Journal of Medicine, 327 (1992) 1632. S. Fallet, M.E. Grace, A. Sibille, D.S. Mendelson, R.S. Shapiro, G. Hermann and G.A. Grabowski, Pediatric Research, 31 (1992) 496. J. Sorge, C. West, B. Westwood and E. Beutler, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., 82 (1985) 7289. P. Schimmel, Acc. Chem. Res., 22 (1989) 232. Q. Wang, R.W. Graham, D. Trimbur, R.A.J. Warren and S.G. Withers, J. Amer. Chem. Soc., 116 (1994) 11594. D. Tull, S. Miao, S.G. Withers and R. Aebersold, Anal. Biochem., 224 (1995) 509. S. Miao, L. Ziser, R. Aebersold and S.G. Withers, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 7027. A. White, S. Withers, N. Gilkes and D. Rose, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 12546. W.W. Wakarchuk, R.L. Campbell, W.L. Sung, J. Davoodi and M. Yaguchi, Protein Sci., 3 (1994) 467. F. Naider, Z. Bohak and J. Yafiv, Biochemistry, 11 (1972) 3202. T. Black, L. Kiss, D. Tull and S.G. Withers, Carbohydrate Research, 250 (1993) 195. D. Hess, H. Nika, D.T. Chow, E.J. Bures, H. Morrison and R. Aebersold, Anal. Biochem., 224 (1995) 373. E.J. Bures, H. Nika, D.T. Chow, H. Morrison, D. Hess and R. Aebersold, Anal. Biochem., 224 (1995) 364. A.M. MacLeod, T. Lindhorst, S.G. Withers and R.A.J. Warren, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 6571. Z. Keresztessy, L. Kiss and M. Hughes, Arch. Biochem. Biophys., 315 (1994) 323. S.G. Withers, D. Dombroski, L.A. Berven, D.G. Kilbum, R.C.J. Miller, R.A.J. Warren and N.R. Gilkes, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun., 139 (1986) 487. D. Tull and S.G. Withers, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 6363. S.G. Withers, K. Rupitz, D. Trimbur and R.A.J. Warren, Biochemistry, 31 (1992) 9979. H.G. Damude, S.G. Withers, D.G. Kilburn, R.C.J. Miller and R.A.J. Warren, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 2220.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
113
Thiooligosaccharides: toys or tools for the studies of Glycanases H. Driguez Centre de Recherches sur les Macromol6cules V6g6tales (CERMAV-CNRS) B.P. 53, F-38041 Grenoble Cedex 9, France
Abstract The latest syntheses are reported of oligosaccharides having one or several interosidic sulfur linkages. The donor molecules are glycopyranose-l-thiolates, readily prepared from their corresponding fully acetylated derivatives by selective S-deacetylation and activation. SN2 reactions of these donors with acylated acceptors bearing a good leaving group (generally a trifyl group or iodine atom at a secondary or primary position respectively) afforded the expected compounds in good to high yields. These non-natural, hydrolyzed-resistant oligosaccharides are analogues of substrate for glucoamylases, at-amylases, cellulases and 1,31,4-~-D-glucanases.
1. INTRODUCTION Glycosyl hydrolases are carbohydrate acting enzymes that catalyze in vivo the transfer of glycosyl units onto water. These enzymes, in general, can be divided into three groups: glycosidases which act on oligosaccharides and liberate monosaccharides units from the nonreducing end, the exo-glycanases which also cleave glycosidic bonds at the non-reducing end of oligo- and polysaccharides but may liberate mono- or disaccharide, and endo-glycanases which cleave internal glycosidic bonds of polysaccharides. These enzymes have been studied extensively and several reviews have been written on their mechanism of action and inhibition [1]. Nevertheless, the objective of several E.C. projects are the analysis of structural and functional relationships of glycosidases and glycanases with the aims of : i) elucidating the principles that govern substrate specificity at the molecular level, ii) using protein engineering to modulate or change substrate and cleavage specificities. To understand enzyme-sugar interactions and the mechanism of action of these enzymes, naturally-occuring compounds as well as structural analogues which can form reversible enzyme inhibitor complexes are required. These inhibitors may be divided into ground-state and transition-state analogues. The first class of inhibitors should give the most interesting information since these compounds possess the same overall geometry as the natural substrate but have one (or several) interglycosidic oxygen atom(s) or (and) ring oxygen(s) substituted by methylene group(s), nitrogen or sulfur
114
atom(s). These compounds should establish more or less the same polar and non polar interactions with the amino-acids of the active site without being hydrolyzed. Since the first synthesis of a C-disaccharide in which the interglycosidic oxygen atom is replaced by a methylene group [2], extensive research has made available of several carbaanalogues of di- or trisaccharides [3]. However, no papers reported the behaviour of these compounds as competitive inhibitors of the corresponding glycosidases. Aza-sugar inhibitors can be divided into those in which the nitrogen atom between two sugar or pseudosugar units is replaced by the nitrogen functionality [4]. These basic compounds may possess positive charge, and their inhibitory capacities are therefore strongly pH-dependent. However, these compounds especially those which may be considered as transition state analogues are very often potent inhibitors of glycanases [4]. Recently, the enzymatic synthesis of disaccharides containing sulfur in the ring of the reducing or non-reducing units were reported [5] together with the chemical synthesis of analogues of disaccharides with sulfur in the ring of the non reducing sugar and/or a chalcogen atom in the interglycosidic linkage [6]. This paper will discuss the recent syntheses of the largest class of inhibitors: oligosaccharides with interglycosidic sulfur atom(s) and their uses for biochemical and X-ray studies of glycanases.
2. SYNTHESIS OF THIOOLIGOSACCHARIDES 6-Thiogentiobiose and 6-thioallolactose were the first reducing S-linked thiodisaccharides prepared [7]. In 1982, we developed a general strategy for the establishment of any thioglycosydic linkage in good yield [8]. The reaction of glycopyranose 1-thiolate, readily prepared from the corresponding acetylated derivative, with an acylated acceptor bearing a good leaving group (generally a triflyl group) afforded, after subsequent reacetylation, the desired disaccharide in good yield (scheme 1). More recently, an improvement of this method was achieved by a selective in situ S-deacetylation and activation by using cysteamine (cyst.) and dithioerythritol (DTE) [9]. The versatility of these approaches has been shown in a recent review [ 10], which reports all the synthesis and the uses of thiooligosaccharides published up to 1991. This paper will therefore develop the results which have appeared in the literature since that date. 2.1. Synthesis of thiodisaccharides Hasegawa et al. [11] have synthesized several ganglioside analogs containing o~thioglycosides of sialic acid and have observed that these analogs are potent inhibitors of sialidase activities of different subtypes of influenza virus [12]. In this approach, the S-acetyl compound was more or less selectively S-deacetylated with sodium methoxide at low temperature, and the sodium salt thus obtained was then coupled in DMF with glycosyl acceptors, to afford the expected disaccharides upon reacetylation (55-70%). In 1994, von
115
o. f yo, O S-
OH ~
T
+
O
1)HMPA
VR
o.I
2)Ac~O' % 56(> pyr" )"
Mo
)_o:c 4j ~ ~OA c ~ S
aco
l Ac F
700
TfO ~__~Oo
OH
.
+
OAc
F
OR
1 )HMPA 2 )Ac 20,pyr.
O~OR -
~)OMe
Me
(60%)
Acd '-'=f ~)Ac
s
,=-=f OMe OR
Scheme 1
Itzstein and his group [ 13] has described a mild and efficient method for the selective in situ Sdeacetylation and under this condition the desired disaccharide was obtained in more than 80% yield after a few hours. Convenient syntheses of N, N,-diacetyl-thiochitobiose [14a], thiokojibiose, thionigerose and thioisomaltose [14b] were also reported. 2.2. Oiigosaccharides possessing only one thioglucosyl unit 2.2.1. At their non-reducing end
Glucoamylase is an exo-glycanase that hydrolyzes both otl-->6 and otl---~4 glucosidic bonds of starch from non-reducing ends to produce 13-D-glucose. Most fungal glucoamylases possess a separate starch binding domain, and although several enzymes with high activity on raw starch also have strong debranching activity, it remains to be demonstrated whether or not the starch binding domain plays a role in hydrolytic or reversion reactions. It was thus considered 2 w w that 6-thiopanose and its higher oligomers 4-S-ot-glucosyl-4-thiomaltodextrins should be useful tools to understand this duality. 2 As shown in scheme 2, the displacement of the iodine atom of acetylated 6 -iodomaltose by 2 the in situ activated 1-S-o~-D-glucose peracetate afforded the 6-thiopanose in excellent yield (82 %) [15]. The synthesis of higher oligomers is not so straigthforward. However, we thought that coupling reaction of glucose and 6-iodo-13-cyclodextrin catalyzed by cyclodextrin glucosyltransferase (CGTase) should provide the most direct approach to 6W-iodo-malto3 4 dextrins (scheme 3). And indeed, 6 -iodo-maltotriose and 6 -iodo-maltotetraose were obtained
116 2
in good yield. The procedure used for the synthesis of 6-thiopanose applied in the present work afforded the expected tetra- and pentasaccharide in 86 and 80 % yield respectively. The binding experiments of these compounds with both glucoamylase G 1 from A. niger as well as its isolated starch binding domain fragment were done by Dr B. Svensson, Copenhagen (Table 1). The dissociation constant Kd, determined by U.V. difference spectroscopy, decreased from about 1 mM to 0.2 mM when the degree of polymerization increases and these values are approximatively one order of magnitude lower than those reported for ct-l,4-maltodextrins containing the same number of glucosyl residues [ 16].
o\
.t OAc
o\
Aco--v ~
OAc
" - ' A c ~
A C ~ o ~
c SAc
~ ~D~yst.,HMPA A
~
OAc
1
Acoa'
82 %
@~x _oAc
Ac~.~'-
"OAc
OAc
Scheme 2
2.2.2. At a specific inner position
Complex polysacchaddes consisting of glycosyl units interconnected by various glycosidic bonds may be hydrolyzed by enzymes which specifically split only one type of linkage. For example depolymerization of 1,3:l,4-[3-glucans, the major matrix polysaccharides of barley endosperm cell walls, may be hydrolyzed by cellulases, lichenases or to a lesser extent laminarinase (scheme 4). To map the active site of lichenases which specifically cleave 1,4-[3linkages in ~-glucans where the glucosyl residue is substituted at position 3, we decided to synthesize the target molecule shown on scheme 4, as a potential inhibitor for these enzymes.
117 Table 1 Dissociation constants for thiopanose homologs and glucoamylase G1 or its starch binding domain (SBD). Ligand Protein thi0panose homologs a DP
Kd (mM)
SBD
G1
maltodextrins
b
Kd ( m S )
3
0.96 + 0.05
(1.6 + 0.11)
3.8
4
0.30 + 0.03
(0.56 + 0.06)
3.8
5
0.22 + 0.02
(0.32 + 0.01)
1.3
3
0.84 + 0.04
(1.7 + 0.04)
4
0.31 + 0.02
(0.53 + 0.02)
5
0.17 + 0.02
(0.15 + 0.01)
-
aValues in parenthesis, determined by titration calorimetry are for the site of highest affinity. b
Comparison to the dissociation constants found for maltodextrins and the starch binding domain. Reprinted from N.J. Belshaw et al., Eur. J. Biochem., 211 (1993) 717.
I
/ O
OH&
HO HO
+Glucose
I
~
0 H
O
CGTase
I
R
O
_ORo
o c\
cysteamine 2 n= 1 (59%)
5 n=l
R =Ac(86%)
6 n=2
R=Ac(80%)
HMPA~
3 n
\
7 n= 1 R=H 8 n=2 R=H
AcO'~-"'~_ \
AcO...~,,,,r OAC~Ac
Scheme 3
4
OH
1 ) Glucoamylase 2 ) Ac20,pyridine
~'~'"~,~f~\ oR
OH o
2 (22%)
o~c
118
~ - - - 13-Glc 1"~4
~---13-Glc 1"3
cellulases laminarinases lichinases
Me
Scheme 4
119
~
OH Scleroglucan
,-O
OH
1) Ac 2 0 , H + 2)HBr, AcOH 3)Bu 4 NSAc, tol. (2O%) 9OAc AcO-~.,-~ O,
5 steps
(4O%) OTf
o7-2-
OAc
s
I I
o
., OBz
~
OAc Act-td'~~OAc O" d o n o r molecule
~
O
Bz
OBz e. OBz " acceptor molecule
/
1) c y s t , H M P A (35%) or Et 2NH,DMF (45 %)
_OH
2)MeO "Na,MeOH
HO
OH ~.,..~_k"'~......- 0
OBz
OH
. OH
o~ . o ~ z 2 ~ . o ~ ~
o
0
OH
10eq.
0
OP03 =
~
Cellodextrin p h o s p o r y l a s e G l u c o s e o x i d a s e , Catalase (56%) OH
,OH
.oT-7-ZT-o~X-a~o, .o~e"~o" Ii O ~ 9o .
oH
~
_
,o. ,r
_ , o . _o ~,_.~ \ -o7 - - ~ l - o M o -
Scheme 5
The disaccharide acceptor was obtained in six steps from methyl 13-1actoside (scheme 5). Starting from acetylated laminaribiose isolated in 26 % yield by acetolysis of scleroglucan, the donor 1-thioacetyl laminaribiose was easily prepared. However, we were not able to find experimental conditions which afforded the expected tetrasaccharide in good yield. Under various conditions the yield was 35-45 %. This result was in contrast with the ones reported in 2.2.1. The elimination of triflic acid from an acceptor bearing an equatorial aglycon seems to be the side reaction which lowered the coupling yield. Nevertheless, this tetrasaccharide was used as a primer in an enzymatic elongation, using cellodextrin phosphorylase isolated from C. thermocellum [17]. When this enzyme was incubated for 12 h with the tetrasaccharide and glucose-l-P, the corresponding DP 5 was obtained in very good yield (56 %). However, the phosphorolytic synthesis of DP 6 was not so straithforward, since higher oligomers DP 7-8 were also obtained. The recognition of these compounds by lichenases from plant and bacterial origins is in progress.
120
2.3. Oiigosaccharides having sulfur atoms in all their interglycosidic linkages 2.3.1. 4-thiocellooligosaccharides Cellulose, the major polysaccharide in plant cell walls is randomly hydrolyzed by several families of cellulases [ 18]. Because of the complex structure of the natural solid substrate the precise mechanism of recognition and action of these enzymes may be more conveniently approached by the use of inhibitors and/or artificial substrates. The synthesis in the S-series of cello-tris-, tetra- and pentaosides was achieved in excellent yield by stepwise coupling of the same triflate acceptor with S-acetyl 1-thio-4-thiocellodextrins of DP 2, 3 and 4 respectively (scheme 6) [19]. These compounds were used as inhibitors for endoglucanase I (EGI) and cellobiohydrolase II (CBHII) from Humicola insolens which belong to two different classes of cellulases, and which require respectively three and four unmodified 15(1---)4) glucosyl units to efficiently hydrolyze a glycosidic bond. It has been found by Dr. M. Schtilein and his group from Novo Nordisk that these 4thiooligomers are potent inhibitors of these two cellulases (see Table 2) [19]. Furthermore, Prof. T.A. Jones and his group in Uppsala identified the active site residues of CBHII from T. reesei by solving the X-ray structure of the enzyme complexed with the thiocellopentaoside [2O].
Table 2 Inhibition Constants (Ki) for H. insolens EGI and CBHII with methyl 4-thiocellooli~osaccharides. DP 5 ..... _E _n_z__y___m___e .................. Constants .............................................................. D P3 .............................................. _DP___4 EGI
Ki (laM)
330 + 1.6
73 + 1.6
EGI CBHII
Kis(laM)
2,000 + 11
1,000 + 100
-
Ki (laM)
1,~400 + 250
270 + 2.3
15 + 0.9
m
u
35 + 2.7
2.3.2. 4-thiomaltooligosaccharides Rational design to produce enzymes which degrade starch with modified specificity will be possible with a better understanding at the atomic level of the interactions of enzymes with maltooligosaccharides. In order to investigate these interactions using the substrate-analogue approach, efforts have been directed toward a practical synthesis of 4-thiomaltodextrins. We have thought that the acceptor molecule should possess at its anomeric position an ct-thiol unreactive under the coupling conditions, but which can be easily and quantitatively transformed into a donor molecule when necessary. We demonstrated that triphenylmethanethiol has been an useful reagent in the synthesis of 1,2-cis-l-thioglycoses [21] and we showed the feasibility of this strategy by the synthesis of methyl 4,4'-dithiomaltotrioside [22] (scheme 7). This compound was resistant to enzyme hydrolysis, but did not behave as an ordinary competitive inhibitor. The K~ values decreased to a greater or lesser extent, with increase in the time of incubation, and increased at high concentration of inhibitor. This phenomenon may be explained by an abnormal binding of this compound in the active site. This speculation is supported by the results obtained by Drs F. Payan and R. Haser from Marseille who solved the X-ray structure of a crystal of pig pancreatic o~-amylase that was soaked with this compound [23]. They found that three molecules were bound to the enzyme, two in the active site and one on the surface binding site.
A 1 )MeO-,MeOH
AcO
1 )HBr,AcOH 84 %
+
AcO
AcO AcO
( 1 8 steps)
A B C
32%
OAc Scheme 6
2 )3.3 eq BzC1,pyr.
toluene I
60 %
Cl
AcO* Ac OAc
70 %
L
STr
68 % Ac
75%
B
Ac
A
95%
Ac SAC
OMe
Scheme 7
BzO
123 3. CONCLUSION In this review, we would like to point out that thiooligosaccharides constitute a class of non-natural oligosaccharides easily available. The interactions between an oligosaccharide and a protein were initiated by recognition of the solution conformation of the interacting species. From the results obtained from the few X-ray structures of thiosugars, as expected, the C-S bond is longer than the corresponding C-O bond [24]. These differences for thiomaltoside and maltose were shown in figure. It is worthy to note that the non-bonded (C(1')...C(4) in thiomaltoside is only 0.35 ]k longer than in maltoside [25]. 2.455 ~on
.o-
X-"-A._X"
I l
2.805
i Ii
X ~ , o n ..~O
, .o.
1.437
.o
_ . . ."x .x'
I I
I Ii
:
- OH
1.828
Furthermore, recent theoretical studies of the conformation of thiomaltoside [26] as well as NMR data [27] in aqueous solution demonstrated that thiomaltoside is more flexible than its oxygen analogue and that both compounds adopt the same conformation. All these data explain the excellent recognition of thiooligosaccharide by glycosylhydrolases and show that these compounds should be used more extensively for a better understanding of protein-sugar interactions.
4. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This research was supported by CNRS and the BAP, BRIDGE and BIOTECH programmes for E.C. Enzymatic studies were done by Drs. G. Fincher (Adelaide), J. Lehmann (Freiburg), A. Planas (Barcelona), M. Schtilein (Copenhagen) and B. Svensson (Copenhagen).
5. REFERENCES 1 2 3 4
M.L. Sinnott, Chem. Rev., 90 (1990) 1171. D. Rouzaud and P. Sinai, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., (1983) 1353. For references on the synthesis of C-disaccharides see Y.C. Xin, J.M. Mallet, and P. Sinai, J. Chem. Soc., Chem. Commun., (1993) 864 and references cited therein. K. Bock and B.W. Sigueskjold in Atta-Ur Rauman (ed.), Studies in Natural Products Chemistry, vol. 7, 1990 pp. 29 and references cited therein.
124 5a C.H. Wong, T. Krach, C. Guatheron-Le Narhor, Y. Ichikawa, G.C. Look, F. Gaeta, D. Thompson and K.C. Nicolaov, Tetrahedron Lett., 32 (1991) 4 867. 5b H. Yuasa, O. Hindsgaul and M.M. Palcic, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 114 (1992) 5891. 6 S. Mehta, J. S. Andrews, B.O. Johnston, and B. Mario Pinto. J. Am. Chem. Soc., 116 (1994) 1569. 7a D.H. Hutson, J. Chem. Soc., (C) (1967) 442. 7b W. Boos, P. Schaedel and K. Wappenfels, Eur. J. Biochem., (1967) 382. 8a M. Blanc-Muesser, J. Defaye and H. Driguez, J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans., 1 (1982) 15. 8b D. Rho, M. Desrochers, L. Jurasek, H. Driguez and J. Defaye, J. Bacteriol., 149 (1982) 47. 9 M. Blanc-Muesser and H. Driguez, J. Chem. Soc. Perkin Trans., 1 (1988) 3345. 10 J. Defaye and J. Gelas in Atta-Ur-Rahman (ed.), Studies in Natural Products Chemistry, vol. 8, 1991, pp 315 and references cited therein. 11 A. Hasegawa, T. Terada, H. Ogawa, and M. Kiso, J. Carbohydr. Chem., 11 (1992) 319. 12 Y. Suzuki, K. Sato, M. Kiso and A. Hasegawa, Glycoconjugate J., 7 (1990) 349. 13 S. Bennet, M. von Itzstein and M.J. Kiefel, Carbohydr. Res., 259 (1994) 293. 14a L.X. Wang and Y.C. Lee, XVII th Intern. Carbohydr. Symposium, Canada (1994) Abst. B2, 11 p. 285. 14b R.N. Comber, J.D. Friedrich, D.A. Dunshee, S.L. Petty and J.A. Secristin, Carbohydr. Res., 262 (1994) 245. 15 S. Cottaz, H. Driguez and B. Svensson, Carbohydr. Res., 228 (1992) 299. 16 C. Apparu, H. Driguez, G. Williamson and B. Svensson, Carbohydr. Res., in press. 17 E. Samain, C. Lancelon-Pin, F. Fdrigo, V. Moreau, H. Chanzy, A. Heyraud and H. Driguez, Carbohydr. Res., 271 (1995) 217. 18 B. Henrissat, M. Claeyssens, P. Tomme, L. Lemesle and J.P. Mormon, Gene, 81 (1989) 83. 19 C. Schou, G. Rasmussen, M. Schtilein, B. Henrissat and H. Driguez, J. Carbohydr. Chem., 12 (1993) 743. 20 T.A. Jones, personal communication 21 M. Blanc-Muesser, L. Vigne and H. Driguez, Tetrahedron Lett., 31 (1990) 3869. 22 M. Blanc-Muesser, L. Vigne, H. Driguez, J. Lehmann, J. Steck and K. Urbahns, Carbohydr. Res., 224 (1992) 59. 23 F.Payan and R. Haser, personal communication. 24 V. Duffer, H. Driguez, P. Rollin, E. Dude and G. Buisson, Acta Cryst., C48 (1992) 1791 and references cited therein. 25 S. Pdrez and C. Vergelati, Acta Cryst., B40 (1984) 294 and references cited therein. 26 K. Mazeau and I. Tvaroska, Carbohydr. Res., 225 (1992) 27. 27 K. Bock, J. O. Duus and S. Refn, Carbohydr. Res., 253 (1994) 51.
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
125
Mutational analysis of catalytic mechanism and specificity in amylolytic enzymes B. Svensson, T.P. Frandsen, I. Matsui, N. Juge, H.-P. Fierobe, B. Stoffer a and K.W. Rodenburg b Department of Chemistry, Carlsberg Laboratory, Gamle Carlsberg Vej 10, DK-2500 Copenhagen Valby, Denmark. Present address: aUniversity of Copenhagen, Department of Chemistry, Laboratory IV, Universitetsparken 5, DK-2100 Copenhagen 0, Denmark. bAarhus University, Institute of Molecular Biology, C.F. Moilers All6 130, DK-8000/~rhus C, Denmark Abstract
Engineering of proteins and substrates in conjunction with enzyme kinetic, thermodynamic and X-ray crystallographic studies has provided new knowledge on the mechanism of substrate binding and catalysis of starch-hydrolases and related enzymes. Enzyme-substrate interactions at a distance from the site of catalysis will receive special attention to expand the insight into the structural basis of the diversity known to amylolytic enzymes. Examples are reported of mutants of glucoamylase from Aspergiltus niger and mutants and hybrids of barley (x-amylase isozymes with altered specificity. In addition site-directed mutagenesis of barley o~-amylase isozyme hybrids probes side chains critical for association with barley o~-amylase/subtilisin inhibitor.
1. INTRODUCTION In the past three years basic molecular features have been reported of inhibitors, substrate analogs, or products in complex with porcine pancreatic amylase [ 1,2], barley a-amylase 2 [3], soybean [3-amylase [4,5], Aspergillus awamori var. XIO0 glucoamylase (GA) [6-8], Bacillus circulans cyclodextrin glycosyltransferases (CGTases) [9-11], B. stearothermophilus CGTase [12], and Pseudomonas stutzeri maltotetraohydrolase [13] (reviewed in ref. 14). These crystal structures permit interpretation of mutants either rationally designed or selected after random mutagenesis. For native structures, available of Taka-amylase A (A. oryzae) [15], the closely related acid a-amylase from A. niger [16], B. licheniformis amylase [17], sweet potato 13amylase [18], and oligo-l,6-glucosidase from B. cereus [19], modeled complexes may be applied. In addition structure prediction coupled with alignment to related proteins of known three-dimensional structure allows identification at the sequence level of amino acid residues important in activity and stability [14,20]. Valuable information on structure/function relation-
126 ships of a very large number of amylolytic enzymes is thus at hand even when details of the enzyme-substrate interaction at the atomic level are lacking. Mutational analysis of substrate specificity and catalysis (reviewed in ref.s 14,21) has been performed in i) amylolytic enzymes active on o~-1,4 or ~-1,6 linkages of maltodextrins and starch representing seven EC classes within the amylase (~/oQs-barrel structural family; o~amylase, CGTase, cyclodextrinase, neopullulanase, amylase-pullulanase, and recently branching enzyme [22] and pullulanase [23]; ii) the inverting exo-glucanases, ]3-amylase and GA, containing a different (~/OQs- and an (o;/oQ6-barrel, respectively; and iii) the high molecular weight o~-glucosidases probably constituting a separate structural family. The results obtained span from identification of catalytic groups to successful design of mutants with altered properties. In case of B. circulans CGTases [9,24] and A. niger GA [25] the behavior of mutants has been rationalized based on crystal structures of the engineered proteins. The present paper focuses on A. niger GA and barley malt amylase. GA catalyses release of o~-1,4 and ~-l,6-1inked glucose from nonreducing ends of starch and related oligo- and polysaccharides with inversion of the anomeric configuration. Barley c~-amylase, in contrast, is a retaining, strictly o~-1,4 specific endoglucanase. Following the replacement of catalytic residues [26-28] main emphasis currently is on enzyme-substrate contacts at a distance from the site of catalysis. Investigations in GA involve mutagenesis in conjunction with inhibitor binding thermodynamics [29], presteady state kinetics analysis [30-32], and molecular recognition of substrate analogs [33-36] as an extension of the general characterization of enzymic activity and stability. Finally, the target isozyme of barley o~-amylase/subtilisin inhibitor (BASI), one of numerous proteinaceous o~-amylase inhibitors [37], is subjected to site-directed mutagenesis to map the contribution of individual side chains to the proteinprotein binding [38].
2. SITE-DIRECTED MUTAGENESIS OF A. NIGER GLUCOAMYLASE GA is one of the best known starch-hydrolases with respect to structure and function. Ongoing dissection of the interplay between specific parts of the enzyme and substrates/inhibitors, serves to probe the mechanism of action of starch-hydrolases and related enzymes in general and broadens the background knowledge required for rational design of novel enzymes. 2.1. The catalytic site Inverting exoglucanases act by rather simple binding and catalytic mechanisms (for reviews see ref.s 21, 39-40). Glu179 and Glu400 in GA have been identified as the general acid and base catalyst, respectively, using crystallography [6-8], site-directed mutagenesis [26,27], and differential labeling [41]. Insight is lacking, however, in the structural features that define the substrate specificity and the energetics of transition-state stabilization. Crystallography uncovered a remarkable interaction between Tyr48, which is completely conserved in the GAs [42], and 1-deoxynojirimycin bound at the innermost subsite 1 of the funnel-shaped active site [6]. This motivated mutational analysis of the role of Tyr48. Because the obvious replacement by phenylalanine failed, tryptophan was introduced [37]. In wild-type GA OH of Tyr48 hydrogen bonds to OE2 of Glu400, the catalytic base [6] and circumstantial
127 evidence suggests a coupled functionality between these residues, since Tyr48---)Trp and Glu400---)Gln GAs i) undergo similar losses in kcat and increases in Km (Table 1A), ii) have highly reduced binding affinity at the most strongly interacting subsite 2 (Table 1B), and iii) the pH-activity profiles of both mutants increase rather than decline at low pH where protonation of Glu400 is assumed to occur in wild-type GA [27]. As for substrates, the affinity of
Table 1 Mutants at the catalytic site. A. Kinetic parameters ~. B. Subsite 2 affinity a and acarbose binding thermodynamicsb A.
Maltose
kc s-~
Km
Wild-type
10.7
1.21
Tyr48---)Trp
0.12
3.92
Glu179~Gln c
-
-
Glu400---)Gln
0.30
14.8
Enzyme
B.
Maltoheptaose
kc/Km
kc s-1
Km mM
kc/Km
8.48
59.7
0.120
498
0.031
0.762
0.168
4.54
0.047
0.15
0.31
1.05
0.380
2.76
Ka M -~
-AG ~ kJ mol -~
-AH ~ kJ mol -~
TAS ~ kJ mo1-1
mM
Subsite 2 affinity kJ mol -~
0.020
Wild-type
-20.5
9.4•
68.9
32.8
36.1
Tyr48---)Trp
-15.4
2.0•
30.5
10.9
19.6
Glu400---~Gln
- 11.8
.
.
.
.
apH 4.5, 45~ ref. 27; b27~ ref. 29; c50~ ref. 26
Tyr48~Trp GA for the tight-binding pseudotetrasaccharide inhibitor acarbose (Figure 1) was drastically reduced (Table 1B), in fact to an even greater extent than in Trp52---)Phe, Arg54---)Leu, and Arg54---)Lys GAs (see Table 2B), three mutants also located at or near subsite 1 [29]. This behaviour is in accordance with the participation of Tyr48 in a hydrogen bond network involving besides Glu400, the water molecule that exerts nucleophilic attack a at C1 of the substrate glycon ring, and OH of Tyr311, a residue stacking onto the sugar ring at subsite 2 [7,8]. OH of Tyr48 is only 3.43/~ apart from C7A of o-gluco-dihydroacarbose which is equivalent to the endocyclic oxygen in the substrate [8]. Non-bonded electrons of Tyr48 therefore presumably contribute to stabilization of the oxycarbonium ion intermediate [27]. Very recently the structure was solved of A. niger Tyr48~Trp GA in complex with the inhibitor "Iris [25]. In the active site (Figure 2) the hydrogen bond network with Glu400, Tyr311, and Tyr48 has been disrupted and the distance between Glu400 and Tyr311 has increased from 4.70 to 5.21 A indicating that the structure of the active site is indeed perturbed. Compared to other GA crystal structures, Tyr48--rTrp GA lacks a water molecule
128
H
%
N_.~.~ ~~ .0 ~A~__~~
....
o.
~ t _.~<-Lo
/oH
H~ ~I _ . . ~ .
2 ~ ....
_.-o
o. ~o L..~<-2.o HO 0I ~ . . ~ H
j-O d
~ ~ o HO. Figure 1. Molecular structure of the pseudotetrasaccharide inhibitors, acarbose (top) and g luco-dih y droacarbose.
...... Trp
_
Water
Water
_/Glu 400
..........~
48 ~
J j:%:::
. . . . . .
D-
/G,u 400
Trp 48
,'--. " / ~ ,
ss_
J ! " % ~"
~-.. ' / ~ ,
Figure 2. Stereoview of the active site of A. niger GA Tyr48---~Trp with bound 'Iris [25]. Dashed lines indicate hydrogen bond donor-acceptor distances within 3.2/~.
at a position for attack at C1 [25]. The model of Tyr48~Trp GA thus accounts for the decreased activity and loss of affinity at subsite 2, while the relative increase in activity at low pH [27] is not readily explained by the mutant structure [25].
2.2. Enzyme/substrate-OH hydrogen bonds Hydrogen bonds between residues in the active site and polar groups of the sugar substrate contribute importantly to stabilization of the substrate transition-state as may be assessed by site-directed mutagenesis of the amino acids in such pairs of interacting groups (Table 2). Arg54 and Asp55 hydrogen bond to OH4 and OH6 of the sugar ring (see Figure 4) at subsite 1 [6-8] each stabilizing the transition-state complex by A(AG*)=15-21 kJxmol-' [43,44]
129 calculated from the difference in kcaJKm between the parent and mutant GAs. Substitution of these residues hardly affected substrate ground-state binding (Km), whereas mutation of Glu180, Arg305, or Asp309 at subsite 2, greatly decreased the affinity for or-1,4, but not for a1,6-1inked substrates (Table 2A). Arg305 is particularly critical, Arg305---)Lys GA thus has kcJKm reduced by a factor of 10 3 even for isomaltose (Table 2A). The corresponding loss
Table 2 Mutants at residues hydrogen bonding to substrate OH-groups. A. Kinetic parameters". B. Subsite 2 affinity" and acarbose binding thermodynamics b A. Enzyme
Maltose kc S-I
Km
wt
10.7
1.21
R54K
0.007
D55G c
Isomaltose kdKm
Km mM
kc/Km
s "1
Km mM
kdKm
s -1
8.84
0.41
19.8
0.021
59.7
0.120
498
0.53
0.013
-
-
-
0.031
0.032
0.97
0.04
1.50
0.027
0.002
38.5
5x10 -5
0.23
0.190
1.21
E180Q d
1.53
41.4
0.037
0.184
95.0
0.002
30.9
9.39
3.29
R305K
-
>400
0.0024
4x10 -4
21.0
2x10 5
-
-
0.66
D309E
9.11
52.4
0.174
0.089
61.9
0.0014
67.1
9.44
7.11
mM
B.
Subsite 2 affinity kJ mo1-1
wt
k~
Maltoheptaose k~
Ka M -1
-AG ~ kJ mo1-1
-AH ~ kJ mol 1
TAS ~ kJ mol 1
-20.1
9.4x1011
68.9
32.8
36.1
R54K
-18.4 e
8.2x106
39.7
41.2
-1.5
E180Q c
-13.4
2.8X104
25.5
19.8
5.7
R305K
-
9.3x 104
28.5
30.4
- 1.9
D309E
-
2.0x 101~
59.2
31.1
28.1
apH 4.5, 45~ ref. 43; b27~ ref. 29; Cref. 44; aref. 26; efor Arg54---rLeu, ref. 43
in transition-state stabilization energy A(AG*) is calculated to be 10-20 kJxmol l. Arg305 is situated to bridge subsites 1 and 2 (Figure 4) and is crucial in both substrate bond-type specificity and activity. We speculate, therefore, that engineering of the bond-type specificity should concentrate on residues somehow connected with Arg305, and perhaps located in the fifth of the six highly conserved a-+a-segments of the GA (~o06-barrel [6-8,42,45,46] that contains Arg305. The binding thermodynamics for acarbose which is structurally related to the transition-state, indicate that hydrogen bonding especially to the second ring is critical for transition-state stabilization (Table 2B) and that modulation of specificity with less severe consequence on activity may be achieved by mutation of Asp309 (compare data in Table 2A
130 and B) in indirect contact with the ligand via a salt-link with the guanido group of Arg305 [271.
2.3. Molecular recognition of o~-1,4- and ~-l,6-1inked disaccharide substrates The transition-state stabilization energy A(AG*) contributed by OH4', OH6', and OH3 in maltose (Figure 3), known to be critical for GA catalyzed hydrolysis to occur [47], was calculated according to equation (1) [48] from the kinetic parameters determined using a series of monodeoxy-analogs (Table 3; refs. 33,35). Because c~-1,4- and c~-l,6-1inked substrates are hydrolyzed at the same catalytic site, the A(AG*) values for the corresponding monodeoxyanalogs (Table 3) suggest that OH4 in isomaltose and OH3 in maltose are found at a similar (1)
A(AG*) = -R Tin[ (kcJKm)analogue](kcat/Km)parent]
positions in the GA-transition-state complex. This implies, as pointed out before [49], that GA associates with isomaltose in the least populated of its three prevalent solution conformers. The conformationally biased methyl 6R-C-methyl-o~-isomaltoside (not shown) exists primarily in that conformation [49]. In the absence of crystallographic insights identification of interacting pairs of atoms or groups in enzyme-substrate transition-state complexes can in principle be done through combined analysis with mutant enzyme and substrate analogs. In the case of Glu180--+Gln GA
Table 3 Binding energy contributed by substrate OH groups a D(DG*) (kJxmol-1), Analogue
[3-methylmaltosideb.C
o
o~-methylis~176 d
2-deoxy
5.2
1.1
3-deoxy
11.2
8.6
6/4-deoxy
- 1.8
16.5
2'-deoxy
0.19
4.0
3'-deoxy
9.1
2.2
4'-deoxy
18.8
23.2
6'-deoxy
17.4
24.3
apH 4.5 45~ bref. 35; Cref.33; dref. 36
OH 0 OMe HO
o
__\(~~
,,,, OH OMe
Figure 3. Key polar groups are encircled.
the OH2 of maltose supplied no transition-state stabilization energy [33], indicating that a hydrogen bond to wild-type GA (Table 3) was not established in the mutant. However, for monodeoxy-maltose analogs this approach further demonstrated [34], that loss of a protein group hydrogen bonding to a specific substrate ring can weaken the transition-state
131 stabilization at an adjacent glucose residue. Similarly transition-state stabilization of the a-l,6linked substrate was sensitive to loss of hydrogen bonding, A(AG*) for hydrolysis of 3- and 4deoxy-isomaltoside by Glu 180-->Gln GA thus decreased to 3.0 and 10.8 kJxmo1-1, respectively, and Asp309-->Glu GA showed a similar decrease for the 4-deoxy-analog (Table 3). With these two mutants A(AG*) furthermore decreased by 10-14 kJxmol 1 for the 4'- and 6'-deoxyisomaltosides, even though the corresponding substrate OH groups do not bind to Glul80 or Asp309. In contrast, however, the 4'- and 6'-deoxy-analogs of the conformationally blocked methyl 6R-C-methyl-ot-isomaltoside yielded A(AG*) values of 18-20 kJxmol ~ with wild-type and the two GA mutants [36]. We conclude that removal of a hydrogen bond to the glucose ring at subsite 2 hampers the conformational change normally imposed on substrate by GA to secure optimal transition-state stabilization via strong hydrogen bonds to charged groups at subsite 1. 2.4. Distant subsites and the condensation reaction Two binding modes for the inhibitor in D-gluco-dihydroacarbose-GA from A. awamori var. XIO0 revealed flexibility in oligosaccharide accomodation at subsites 3 and 4 (Figure 4). Ser119 OG (not shown) hydrogen bonds with OH3 of the fourth sugar ring in the low (35%) GAC 490
C 491
AC 491
VT'RP 12(
R 48
~'~
...,TRP 52
SP 55
t"'-
"4-.-.,
"~
Figure 4. Stereoview of the interaction of D-gluco-dihydroacarbose with GA from A. awamori var. XIO0 at pH 4.0. The nonreducing end is at the bottom; the low occupancy mode is to the left (from ref. 8.; copyright permission by Elsevier).
occupancy conformation [8]. Mutation on either side of the substrate binding cavity at a distance from the site of catalysis, as in S e r l l 9 ~ T y r , Ser185---)His GAs and the stretch preceding Ser185 (not shown), unexpectedly enhanced condensation as well as a-l,6-bondtype specificity (Table 4A). Clearly remote structural alterations had surprising impact on the
132 functionality of the catalytic site and/or its near vicinity. The quadrouble (loop3B) mutant (Table 4A) of Val181-Ser184 adjacent to Glu179 - the general acid catalyst - and Glul80, thus gave a decreased relative specificity, [(kcaJKm)maltose/(kcaJKm)isomaltose],of 37 compared to a wildtype value of 421. The slight increase in activity for isomaltose was accompanied by significant decrease in activity for maltose. Presumably the critical interaction of Glul80 with the second glucose ring of the substrate has been perturbed in this GA variant. The favorable effect on hydrolysis of the ct-1,6-1inked substrate indicates that the superior activity towards 0~1,4-1inked substrates is more sensitive to structural changes. The triple (loop3A) mutant GA (Table 4A) aimed at mimicking a distinct sequence of the Hormoconis resinae GA [42,45,46] to localize structural elements correlated with the high 0~-l,6-bond activity of that enzyme [51]. But the loop3A mutant GA only slightly favored o~-l,6-bond cleavage and had decreased specificity towards ot-l,4-1inked substrates (Table 4A). While this result confirms that Val181Ser184 in A. niger GA tolerates major structural modification, the Hormoconis resinae GA tripeptide conferred GA a favorable relative specificity without improving the overall activity for ot-l,6-1inked substrates. The Ser185--gHis GA had 4-5 fold reduced specificity (k~JKm) for maltose, maltoheptaose, and isomaltose (Table 4A). Serll9--)Tyr and Ser185~His GAs among a large number of mutants possessed an unusual capacity to produce branched oligosaccharides under conditions emulating industrial
Table 4 Mutants at a distance from the site of catalysis. A. Kinetic parameters a. B. Subsite 2 affinity a and acarbose binding thermodynamicsb A.
Maltose
Isomaltose
kc
Km
s "1
mM
8.84
0.41
19.8
1.05
9.6
0.36
5.65
3.58
1.58
Loop3B d
1.68
1.83
S185H
4.87
2.04
Enzyme
kc
Km
S"1
mM
wt
10.7
1.21
Sll9Y c
10.1
Loop3A d
k~
Km
s -1
mM
0.021
59.7
0.120
498
42.0
0.0086
56.9
0.158
360
0.23
22.9
0.010
31.8
0.171
186
0.92
0.63
24.8
0.0254
38.5
0.316
122
2.39
0.30
55.2
0.0054
29.9
0.323
93
kc/Km
B.
Subsite 2 affinity kJ mol -~
wt
kJKm
Maltoheptaose kJKm
Ka M -1
-AG ~ kJ mo1-1
-AH ~ kJ mol 1
TAS ~ kJ mol 1
-20.1
9.4x1011
68.9
32.8
36.1
S119Y c
-21.3
9.3x1011
68.8
29.9
38.9
Loop3B d
-19.5 1.2x1011
63.7
54.3
9.3
$185H
"pH 4.5, 45~ b27~ ref. 29; Cref. 50 dA:V181T/N182Y/G 183A; B:V181A/N182A/G183K/S 184H
133 saccharification. Although the subsite map [50] and Ka for acarbose [29] were comparable to wild-type data, the enthalpy and entropy of binding varied especially for Ser185-->His GA (Table 4B), indicating that the mutation confers low complementarity in accordance with a histidine being sterically unfavorable at position 185 in A. niger GA. After 96 hours of typical saccharification (Figure 5) hepta- and octasaccharides accumulated with Serll9--->Tyr compared to wild-type GA. The substitution of Ser119 by tyrosine probably suppresses the low occupancy binding mode (Figure 4) due to steric conflicts between the bulky tyrosine side chain and the fourth sugar ring. Consequently, Serll9---~Tyr GA might select the high occupancy conformer and promote condensation with glucose to generate poorly hydrolyzed branched oligodextrins. At present, we cannot discriminate between the possibility of Ser119--->Tyr GA favoring binding of branched oligodextrins resulting in condensation or whether the condensation products once formed are less readily degraded by Serll9--->Tyr
Maltodextrin saccharification 96 hrs
o,
o
o-o-~-o-o-o +
gO 0-0-0-0-0-~
o 9
0-0-0-0-0 + 0 0
iG2
A
6-6-o-o-o
Figure 5. BioGel P2 separation of saccharification products with wild-type and Ser119--->Tyr GAs. The structures are evaluated by NMR spectrometry. than by wild-type GA because their productive binding to the otherwise highly active mutant is suppressed.
2.5. Recognition and binding of maltooligosaccharides at subsites 1 through 3 A thorough analysis of the roles in the binding mechanism of structural elements along the active-site cleft is made possible by presteady state kinetic measurements on selected mutants as done here for i) Glul80 - an important hydrogen bond acceptor of OH2 of maltose at subsite 2, ii) Trp52 and iii) Trpl20, situated at the substrate binding crevace between subsites 1 and 2 and at subsite 3, respectively; both belong to a hydrophobic cluster involved in stabilization of the enzyme-substrate complex [34] and contribute perhaps to activity via hydrogen bonds between indole NH groups and the general acid catalyst, Glu179 (Figure 4). Mutation reduced kcat (at 8~ for maltose hydrolysis to 0.2% (Trp52--->Phe), 3% (Trpl20-->Phe), and 45% (Glul80-~Gln) of that of wild-type GA [30-32]. Glul80-->Gln GA slightly lost capacity in the initial association, K] for maltose being 25 mM [32] compared to
134 3.4 mM for wild-type, while K1 of longer substrates was not affected. Remarkably this mutant rearranged EL to E*L (Figure 6) with k2 of 10% of the wild-type rate and the reverse rate k_2, especially for longer substrates, around 20 times faster than for wild-type GA [32]. Trpl20, stacking with the ring at subsite 3 (Figure 4), had k_2 decreased only for maltose - by around 8 fold - and while k2 for maltose was similar to the wild-type value, decreasing kz values were obtained for that mutant with increasing length of substrate [31]. With longer substrates EL is thus less readily rearranged to E*L when Trp 120 is mutated, whereas wild-type GA behaves the opposite [31]. Mutation of Trp52, situated between subsites 1 and 2, caused slight changes at all steps of the binding mechanism. The efficiency in the last step of formation of productive complex E*L is indicated by 1(2 (i.e. k_2/k2), which for Glul80---)Gln GA remained around 0.5 as compared to values for wild-type decreasing from 0.03 to 0.006, and for the Trp52---)Phe and Trpl20--->Phe GAs from 0.007 to 0.001 for maltose through maltotetraose. The loss in catalytic efficiency is reflected in k3 (Figure 6) for acarbose binding which is 140 s-1 and thus
E + A
~
EA
~
E*A-~
E'A
k.2
E+L
~ EL ~ E*L---, E + P k.l k.2 Figure 6. Pathways for binding of acarbose (A) or substrate (L) to glucoamylase (E) to form inhibited complex (E'A) or product (P). * signifies the step preceding the transition-state.
facilitated for Trpl20---)Phe compared to wild-type GA of k3= 0.6 S -1 [32]. To illustrate the effect at subsite 1 and the catalytic site, glucosyl-l-fluoride was used as substrate. Since the rate of hydrolysis (kcJKm) catalyzed by wild-type and Trpl20---)Phe GA was similar [34], Trpl20 despite the hydrogen bond with Glu179 [6-8], appears not to be essential for the chemical catalysis, but for stabi/ization of transition-state complexes with longer substrates [32]. This was observed also for the Tyrl 16--)Ala, another mutant in the hydrophobic cluster in contact with substrate via Trp 120 [34].
3. GENETIC AND CHEMICAL STUDIES OF BARLEY AMYLASE a-amylases are retaining endo-acting starch-hydrolases of the (13/o08-barrel family [14,39,40,52]. Although the sequence similarity between (x-amylases can be extremely low, a few invariant residues play key roles in catalysis, transition-state stabilization, and maintenance of the active site geometry. A large number of amylolytic and related enzymes representing 18 different EC classes show the same weak similarity [14]. Short sequence motifs recognized at (13/o08-barrel 13-strands furthermore define an evolutionary tree that respects taxonomy and enzyme specificity [20]. Based on this insight, selected motifs near essential residues of the catalytic domain are tentatively correlated with the specificity variation among the family members. A separate useful comparison concerns enzymes from closely related species or
135 isozymes to identify structural features with special impact on physico-chemical and enzymic properties. Germinating barley seeds produce two a-amylase isozyme families, AMY1 and AMY2, showing approx. 80% sequence identity and distinct differences in temperature and pH stability, CaZ§ of activity, sensitivity to the endogeous inhibitor BASI (barley o~amylase/subtilisin inhibitor), turn-over rate and affinity of different substrates, and association with starch granules [53-55]. In AMY1 site-directed mutagenesis [28] at Asp l80, Glu205, Asp291 in the catalytic site and His93 and His290 involved in substrate binding, suggested that the histidines stabilize the transition-state, but since mutants at the three acid residues were inactive, their individual roles in catalysis were assigned entirely on the basis of the crystal structure of acarbose-AMY2:Glu205 as general acid catalyst, Asp 180 as catalytic nucleophile, and Asp291 to guide the nucleophilic water for attack at C1 [3]. Mutation also confirmed that the chemically identified surface site important in adsorption onto granular starch includes Trp279 [28]. Currently three genetic engineering strategies are pursued with the aim of tailormaking new barley (x-amylases. The crystal structure of AMY2 is available [3,56] and cDNAs encoding AMY1 and AMY2 have been expressed in Saccharomyces cerevisiae [54,55]. Occasionally poor yields prevented biochemical characterization of recombinant AMY2 or variant forms of both isozymes [54,55,57,58]. Both the random and the site-directed mutageneses are therefore made in AMY1 or in bipartite AMY1-AMY2 hybrids with Nterminal AMY1 part [58]. Previously random mutagenesis and formation of chimers of different bacterial a-amylases supplied collections of engineered enzymes evaluated by screening especially for improved stability [59-61]. We now implemented related more advanced techniques for the barley (x-amylase. Background information is provided also from mutation at conserved residues in the second and fourth [3~o~ loops of the ([3/o08-barrel of Saccharomycopsis fibuligera amylase leading to enhanced transglycosylation and alteration of the action pattem on oligosaccharide substrates [62-64]. 3.1. Barley o~-amylase isozyme hybrids highlight the role of domain B Functional bipartite AMY1-AMY2 hybrids were obtained by in vivo homologous recombination in yeast of the corresponding cDNAs followed by screening for transformants
112 AMY1 AMY2
116
... VV~I N H R c A d y K D sRGIYC I FE G G T~~ D g R~~LL D W G P H M I CR ... NG H R t A e .h K D g R G I Y C I F E 9 G D a D W G P H M I C R 144
AMYI AMY2
161
D D t k g s D GT a N 1 D T GAD aAAP D I D H L N dRVQ rE L D DD r p Y a D G T g N p D* T9 G A* . .D Fig A A* p ,'0'I D ~ N 1 R V Q k E L B
...
A
Figure 7. Alignment of domain B from barley (x-amylases 1 and 2 [67,68]. Conserved residues are in upper case. The cross-over points for the different AMY1-AMY2 hybrids [66] are indicated by vertical lines. Residues binding to the three Ca 2+ in AMY2 are indicated: * Ca500, 9 Ca501, 9 Ca502 [56].
136 that secrete active enzyme. Reasonable amounts of hybrids, even with a large AMY2 content, were produced provided the first 54 amino acid residues were from AMY 1 [58]. Such AMY1AMY2 hybrids have been extremely useful in site-directed mutagenesis of residues conferring target isozyme specificity for BASI [38,65,66] (see also 3.4). Surprisingly the behavior of hybrid isozymes complied with the origin of domain B [65], that protrudes from the (13/o08barrel at the C-terminus of the third 13-strand [56]. Briefly, if the N-terminal AMY1 part comprised domain B (L161, Table 5), the hybrid resembled AMY1 in enzymic and stability properties. In contrast, if the C-terminal AMY2 portion comprised domain B, the hybrid was inhibited by BASI and had lower substrate affinity (V90; Table 5). However, the Caz+ stimulation of activity - also characteristic of AMY2 - made an exception. Since the ligands to the three Ca2+ found in AMY2 [56] are conserved in AMY1 and, except for the carbonyl group of Gly183, belong to domain B (Figure 7), it remains to be understood how the activity of all hybrids, even L161 with AMY1 domain B, is stimulated by Ca2+ [65,66]. The prospects of creating AMY 1-AMY2 hybrids with useful combinations of isozyme traits encouraged the analysis of hybrids that cross-over within domain B [66] (Table 5). Characterization of such hybrids suggests that the AMY1 segments Val90-Thrll2 and
Table 5 Properties of AMY 1-AMY2 hybrids Substrate p-NPG7
L
Km
Crossover a
s-1
mM
AMY1
660
0.5
L161 b
327
F144 c
Inhibitor
Amylose (DP=17)
kc/Km
k~
Km
kc/Km
Stability
Acarbose
BASI
(pH 3.5)
Ki,app mM
Ki nM
min -1
t~
S-1
%-1
1320
236
0.4
590
2.2
>106
25
0.5
654
535
0.8
669
5.2
>106
15
352
0.7
503
765
1.1
695
8.9
5x103
5
RllC
215
0.5
430
880
1.3
677
11.5
0.62
2
Tl12 c
310
0.5
620
659
0.7
941
4.0
0.73
2
V90b
400
2.4
167
647
1.1
588
11.4
0.33
<1
AMY2
405
2.5
162
684
1.2
570
6.8
0.22
<1
"Residues at the C-terminus of the AMY 1 part are listed to identify the different hybrids; bref. 65; Cref. 66
Ala145-Leu161 define higher affinity for the substrates p-nitrophenyl-maltoheptaoside and amylose, respectively; while AMY2 Leu 116-Leu 160 and Leu 116-Phe 143 are critical for the lower stability at pH 3.5 and the sensitivity to BASI, respectively [65,66]. In the AMY2 model, Leull6-Alal40 of domain B lacks direct contact with the (13/o08-barrel [56]. It is
137 conceivable that this exposed part contains determinants involved in BASI-AMY2 interaction, while segments in contact with the ([3/008-domain influence the substrate affinity. 3.2. Random mutagenesis at the fourth [~-->~ loop of the (~/~)s-barrel of AMY1 Barley or-amylase is described to contain 10 subsites accomodating glucosyl residues in linear substrates - six subsites at the glycon and four at the aglycon side of the catalytic site [69,70] (Figure 8). Considering that certain ~-->ot substrate binding segments are
red. end 1
"]~7 8
9
10
Figure 8. Schematic representation of the kinetically identified subsites in the active site of barley (x-amylase [69,70].
readily identified at the sequence level in the amylase family [14,20], it is tempting to explore the variability permitted in such regions and the impact of structural changes on action pattern and specificity. In the case of barley (x-amylase we focused on Arg183-Tyr185 in the fourth ]3---)orsegment of AMY 1 as target for random mutation. Lys 182 from the corresponding AMY2 sequence (Lys182-Tyr184) binds to the glucose residue at subsite 8 (Figures 8 and 9). Also the equivalent Lys210 in Saccharomycopsisfibuligera amylase is known to bind substrate close to the catalytic site [71]. A pool of AMY1 random mutant genes was transformed into yeast followed by screening on starch plates for colonies secreting active enzyme. The action pattern of a few selected mutants (Table 6) is studied using the substrates p-nitrophenylmaltoheptaoside (pNPG7), pNPG6, and pNPGs. Product analysis indicated that the preferred productive binding mode of AMY 1, where G-pNP occupies subsites 7 and 8, was altered. For both of the highly active mutants (Table 6), albeit a little less conspicuously for the Ser-GlyMet than the Asn-Gly-Tyr mutant, which has also higher activity, primarily p-nitrophenol was released from pNPG7 and pNPG6, suggesting that subsite 8 and maybe 7 were affected by the mutation, p-nitrophenol, however, was not liberated from the poor substrate pNPGs. The AsnGly-Tyr mutant and wild-type AMY1 gave very similar action pattern on this substrate, while the Ser-Gly-Met mutant produced an unusually large amount of pNPG4. In addition, the mutants obtained by random mutagenesis suggested that Gly184 is strictly required for activity. All known o~-amylase sequences, except from cereals, have conserved histidine (Figure 9) at the corresponding position. This histidine interacts with the glucose ring of the aglycon at the bond to be cleaved [1,15]. Mutation in human pancreatic a-amylase revealed that it has a multifunctional role in substrate binding, control of the pH-activity dependence, activation by CI-, and inhibition by a proteinaceous inhibitor [72].
138
g-Amylases (not plants) barley I barley 2
Maltogenic g-amylase Maltotetraohydrolase
*
bb
RXDXXKH RLDFARG
RFDFAKG
RIDAVKH RFDFVRG
Maltohexaohydrolase
RIDAVKH
a-glucosidase
RIDTAGL
Cyclodextrinase
RLDVANE
Pullulanase
RFDLMGX
Isoamylase
RFDLASV
Amylase-pullulanase Neopullulanase
Oligo-l,6-glucosidase
RLDVANE
RLDVANE
RMDVINF
Dextran glucosidase
RMDVIDM
CGT-ase
RXDAXKH
Amylomaltase
RIDHFRG
Branching enzyme
Glycogen debranching enzyme
RXDXVXS
RLDNCHS
~4
Figure 9. Alignment of short sequences containing the catalytic nucleophile (*) and residues (b) binding to glucose rings in the substrate aglycon. 13designates residues in the fourth 13-strand in known three-dimensional structures (modified from ref. 14).
Table 6 Random mutants at the substrate binding Arg183 in the fourth ]3--)o~segment in AMY1 Enzyme
Sequence"
Activity (starch plate)
Wild-type
Arg Gly Tyr
+++
#31
Arg Gly Cys
+
#73
Asn Gly Tyr
+++
#89
Thr Gly Leu
+
# 117
Set Gly Met
++
"Mutated residues are in bold
3.3. Affinity labeling of AMY2 by a series of photoreactive maltooligodextrins Enzyme-substrate interactions illustrated in acarbose-AMY2 [3] cover only subsites 6 through 8 (Figure 8). To get information on the distant subsites, a series of linear maltodextrins; maltotetraose; maltopentaose; and maltohexaose, was synthesized which carried the photoreactive 1-thio-3-diazirine-n-butyl group (diaz) at the reducing end [73]. The 3Hlabeled analogs were covalently bound to AMY2 by photolabeling. In spite of the very
139 concentrated reaction mixtures, reasonable stoichiometry of incorporation and loss of activity were obtained (Table 7). Modified parts of AMY2 are assumed to be in contact with the
Table 7 Labeling of AMY2 with reducing end photoreactive maltooligodextrins Substrate analogue G4-diaz
Gs-diaz
G6-diaz
Reaction mixture": G,-diaz (mM)
30
30
10
AMY2 (mgxm1-1)
0.83
0.45
0.45
Productb: Gn/AMY2 (mol/mol)
0.85
1.12
0.66
Activity (% of native AMY2)
15
15
28
aIrradiation was carried out in 50 mM tris-ethanolamine-HC1 pH 8.0, 10 mM CaC12, for 20 min at 350 nm; banalyzed by 3H incorporation and activity towards pNPG7
photoreactive group at the reducing end of the substrate. The use of tritiated analogs facilitated identification of labeled peptide fragments using conventional protocols for proteolysis, peptide purification, and sequence analysis. Up to 20% of the incorporated label was recovered in a single peptide fragment and combined recoveries of around 60% was obtained within a small number of fragments. By comparing the localization of label in the AMY2 structural model [3,56] and the reported action patterns on maltooligodextrins of DP 5-7 [69,70], specific regions of the protein fold are tentatively assigned a specific subsite location, covered by the aglycon moiety (Table 8). This resulted in identification of the outermost subsite 10 at the segment between the extra helix, that succeeds the sixth 13-strand, and the sixth helix of the ([3/ot)8-fold [56], as labeled by Gs-diaz. Minor reaction occurred at the outer part of the fifth and at the eighth 13~o~ segments. A high affinity at subsite 1 [69,70] (Figure 8) causes preferred productive binding of G6-diaz to label subsite 7. Subsite 9 was basically modified by G4-diaz. Less prominent reaction was expected with subsite 8, which is, however, illustrated in the acarbose-AMY2 model [3]. As a consequence probably of the highly concentrated reaction mixtures and enzymatic cleavage of the maltooligodextrin derivatives, other parts of AMY2 got labeled too (not shown), but to lower degree. It is noteworthy that certain amylolytic enzymes do bind oligodextrins at aromatic groups on the surface in regions separate from the active site [2,3,10,74]. 3.4. Characterization of side chains in AMY2 that stabilize the complex with BASI The activity of AMY2 is specifically inhibited by BASI present in the mature barley seed. BASI belongs to the soybean trypsin inhibitor family containing [3-trefoil fold proteins engaged in protein-protein interaction [75,76]. BASI is a tight, fast reacting inhibitor of Ki = 2.2x10 1~ M [77] which follows a simple two-step binding pathway (Figure 10) where K1 = 0.4 mM, k2 320 sl and k_2 = 7x10 5 s-1 [78]. Chemical modification using group specific reagents suggested that arginines of BASI were important for the association with AMY2. Differential labeling
140 Table 8 Tentative localization of aglycon subsites to ~---)o~segments of the (~/o08-barrel Subsite b 13---)o~segment a
7
5
+++
8
9
++
+++
+ +++
6, at ot6a-+a6b +
7, at o~7a---)a7b
+
8
"As defined in ref. 56.
10
+ bshown
++
in Figure 8.
and subsequent sequence analysis of BASI revealed Arg27, Arg127 and Arg155 to be protected by AMY2 against inactivation by phenylglyoxal [76], suggesting a location at the
BASI + A M Y 2 ~ B A S I - AMY2 ~ B A S I - AMY2*
k., Figure 10. Reaction scheme for BASI and AMY2 [78]. protein-protein interface. Since a ternary complex composed of BASI, subtilisin, and AMY2 apparently can form [79,80], comparison of this labeling pattern and the three-dimensional structure of the homologous inhibitor from wheat, where the protease target site was identified [81], supported the putative identification of AMY2-binding region [76]. BASI-AMY2 was recently crystallized [82] and the preliminary model together with the model of the wheat homologue [81], guided a mutational approach to describe the importance of selected noncovalent bonds between BASI and AMY2 [38]. Advantage was taken of the higher production of AMY1-AMY2 hybrids to test the effect of mutation in the AMY2 part. Hybrids with domain B of AMY2 (V90) and AMY1 (L161) origin, respectively, enabled engineering of decreased affinity for BASI in AMY2 and installation of BASI recognition in AMY1 (Table 9). Mutation in the BASI-insensitive L161 of Thr129~Arg mimics Arg128 in AMY2 and Lysl30---)Pro presumably secures the conformation needed to get significant sensitivity to BASI. In the reverse type of experiment Arg128~Gln in hybrid V90 reduced the affinity for BASI by a factor of 102 (Table 9). A similar effect is obtained by substituting Asp142 forming a salt-bridge to BASI - with the corresponding amide (Table 9). The affinity for BASI decreases with decreasing pH or increasing ionic strength [79,83,84], suggesting that ionic interactions dictate the formation of the complex. Additional support for this point was obtained in recent titration calorimetric studies which demonstrated that the BASI-AMY2 complexation is enthalpy driven with only a small temperature dependence. Thus the hydrophobic effect appears to be of little importance and salt-bridges are most likely critical for the association (C.R. Berland, B.W. Sigurskjold, B. Svensson, unpublished data).
141 Table 9 Ki (nM)of BASI for AMY1, AMY2, AMY1-AMY2 hybrids, and AMY1-AMY2 mutants" Enzyme form b AMY1
L161
>10 6
>10 6
L161T129R/K130P _7•
3
V90-D142N
V90-R128Q
V90
AMY2
18
25
0.33
0.22
"at pH 8.0, ref. 38; bsee Table 5 for hybrid nomenclature
5. CONCLUSION Mutational analysis is a potent tool in structure/function relationship investigations in glucoamylase. Further characterization of mutants with respect to three-dimensional structure, binding thermodynamics, molecular recognition, and presteady state binding kinetics has expanded the understanding of functional roles played by a few selected residues in substrate recognition, specificity, catalysis, and condensation reaction. As a representative of the large family of amylolytic enzymes containing an (x-amylase type (13/o08 catalytic domain, barley oramylase was subjected to isozyme hybridization, localized random mutagenesis in a binding [ ~ o t connecting segment, and site-directed mutagenesis to study the active site, surface site and BASI binding site functionalities. Alterations obtained in substrate affinities and action pattern identify specific areas, especially within domain B, as targets for subsequent engineering experiments. The knowledge gained is useful in guiding similar engineering attempts in related enzymes.
6. FUTURE CHALLENGES Numerous open questions remain in the field of starch-hydrolases and related enzymes. With regard to the a-amylase (13/008 family distinct amino acid residues are located in ]3--+ot segments involved in substrate binding. Is binding loop replacement a valuable approach for rational alteration of specificity in amylolytic enzymes? Different family members contain multiple domains of which the significance has to be elucidated. The domains may represent modules suitable for grafting onto a variety of structural contexts to confer altered properties. Some domain types may be involved in substrate binding or in adsorption of the enzyme onto biological surfaces, e.g. cell walls. CGTases currently represent the most complex structure described. They contain five domains, including a C-terminal one that participates in adsorbtion onto starch. However, domains Nterminally of the catalytic ([3/ot)8-barrel, as found in most debranching enzymes, are of distinct types, for which both a structural model and function are yet to be identified. Another challenge is to explore structural manipulation of the domain B of the ([3/008-barrel in the light of our findings on the crucial role of the isozyme origin of this small module for the properties of the barley a-amylase isozymes. Much is unclear also in the way Ca2§ controls function and stability in many amylolytic enzymes. Finally, do catalytic subsites and more
142 distant subsites co-operate in polysaccharide metabolizing enzymes? Does co-operativity exist among individual domains? The structural basis for the multiple binding modes seen with maltodextrin analogs and glucoamylase and the impact on function is also ill-understood. Some of the above concepts are considerably more developed for cellulolytic enzymes. Synergistic substrate degradation involving several enzymes is thus a shared key question between that area and the amylolytic enzymes. As a reflection perhaps of the presence of starch branch points, the starch degrading enzymes seem to have evolved a larger variation in substrate and product specificity, than found for the cellulolytic enzymes.
7. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We are grateful to C. Dupont, J. Lehmbeck, B.E. Norman, K. Bock, T. Christensen, U. Christensen, C. R. Berland, B.W. Sigurskjold, J. Lehmann, and J. Steck for collaboration in studies not published previously. HPF received a long-term and NJ a short-term EMBOfellowship; BSt holds a post-doctoral fellowship from The Carlsberg Foundation. The financial support from the EU BAP and BRIDGE programmes, The Danish Agencies for Industry and Trade, and The Scandinavia-Sasakawa Foundation is gratefully acknowledged.
8. REFERENCES
10 11 12
13
M. Qian, R. Haser, G. Buisson, E. Du6e and F. Payan, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 6284. S.B. Larson, A. Greenwood, D. Cascio, J. Day and A. McPherson, J. Mol. Biol., 235 (1994) 1560. A. Kadziola, M. Sogaard, B. Svensson and R. Haser (1995) submitted. B. Mikami, E.J. Hehre, M. Sato, Y. Katsube, M. Hirose, Y. Morita and J.C. Sacchettini, Biochemistry, 32 (1993) 6836. B. Mikami, M. Degano, E.J. Hehre and J.C. Sacchettini, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 7779. E.M.S. Harris, A.E. Aleshin, L.M. Firsov and R.B. Honzatko, Biochemistry, 32 (1993) 1618. A.E. Aleshin, L.M. Firsov and R.B. Honzatko, J. Biol. Chem., 269 (1994) 15631. B. Stoffer, A.E. Aleshin, L.M. Firsov, B. Svensson and R.B. Honzatko, FEBS Lett., 358 (1995) 57. C. Klein, J. Hollender, H. Bender and G.E. Schulz, Biochemistry, 31 (1992) 8740. C.L. Lawson, R. Van Montfort, B. Strokopytov, H.J. Rozeboom, K.H. Kalk, G.E. De Vries, D. Penninga, L. Dijkhuizen and B.W. Dijkstra, J. Mol. Biol., 236 (1994) 590. B. Strokopytov, D. Penninga, H.J. Rozeboom, K.H. Kalk, L. Dijkhuizen and B.W. Dijkstra, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 2234. Y. Matsuura and M. Kubota, in Enzyme Chemistry and Molecular Biology of Amylases and Related Enzymes (Ed. The Amylase Research Society of Japan, CRC Press, Tokyo, 1995) p 153. Y. Matsuura, in Enzyme Chemistry and Molecular Biology of Amylases and Related Enzymes (Ed. The Amylase Research Society of Japan, CRC Press, Tokyo, 1995) p
143
14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34
35 36 37 38 39 40 41
137. B. Svensson, Plant Mol. Biol., 25 (1994) 141. Y. Matsuura, M. Kusunoki, S. Harada and M. Kakudo, J. Biochem., 95 (1984) 697. E. Boel, L. Brady, A.M. Brzozowski, Z. Derewenda, G.G. Dodson, V.J. Jensen, S.B. Petersen, H. Swift, L. Thim and H.F. Wrldike, Biochemistry, 29 (1990) 6244. M. Machius, G. Wiegand and R. Huber, J. Mol. Biol., 246 (1995) 545. C.G. Cheong, S.H. Eom, D.H. Shin, H.K. Song, K. Min, J.H. Moon, K.K. Kim, K.Y. Hwang and S.W. Suh, PROTEINS: Structure, Function, and Genetics, 21 (1995) 105. H. Kizaki, Y. Hata, K. Watanabe, K. Katsube and Y. Suzuki, J. Biochem., 113 (1993) 646. H. Jespersen, E.A. MacGregor, B. Henrissat, M.R. Sierks and B. Svensson, J. Prot. Chem., 12 (1993) 791. B. Svensson and M. Scgaard, J. Biotechnol., 29 (1993) 1. H.P. Guan, T. Baba and J. Preiss, Cell. Mol. Biol., 40 (1994) 981. M. Yamashita, T. Kinoshita, M. Ihara, T. Mikawa and Y. Murroka, J. Biochem., 116 (1994) 1233. D. Penninga, B. Strokopytov, H.J. Rozeboom, C.L. Lawson, B.W. Dijkstra, J. Bergsma and L. Dijkhuizen, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 3368. B. Stoffer, T.P. Frandsen, B. Svensson and M. Gajhede, Carbohydrate Bioengineering Meeting, Elsinore April 23-26, 1995, abstr. P16. M.R. Sierks, C. Ford, P.J. Reilly and B. Svensson, Protein Eng., 3 (1990) 193. T.P. Frandsen, C. Dupont, J. Lehmbeck, B. Stoffer, M.R. Sierks, R.B. Honzatko and B. Svensson, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 13808. M. Scgaard, A. Kadziola, R. Haser and B. Svensson, J. Biol. Chem., 268 (1993) 22480. C.R. Berland, B.W. Sigurskjold, B. Stoffer, T.P. Frandsen and B. Svensson, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 10153. K. Olsen, B. Svensson and U. Christensen, Eur. J. Biochem., 209 (1992) 777. K. Olsen, U. Christensen, M.R. Sierks and B. Svensson, Biochemistry, 32 (1993) 9686. K. Olsen, Ph.D. Thesis (1994) University of Copenhagen. M.R. Sierks and B. Svensson, Protein Eng., 5 (1992) 185. B. Svensson, B. Stoffer, T.P. Frandsen, M. S0gaard, M.R. Sierks, K.W. Rodenburg, B.W. Sigurskjold and C. Dupont, Proceedings of 36th Alfred Benzon Symposium (K. Bock and H. Clausen, eds.; Munksgaard, Copenhagen, 1994) p. 202. M.R. Sierks, K. Bock, S. Refn and B. Svensson, Biochemistry, 31 (1992) 8972. T.P. Frandsen, M.M. Palcic, B. Stoffer, R.U. Lemieux, O. Hindsgaul and B. Svensson, in preparation. F. Garcia-Olmedo, G. Salcedo, R. Sanchez-Monge, L. Gomez, J. Royo and P. Carbonero, Oxford Surv. Plant. Mol. Cell. Biol., 4 (1987) 275. K.W. Rodenburg, F. Vallre, N. Juge, X.J. Guo, J.C. Chaix, R. Haser and B. Svensson, Miami Bio/Technology Short Reports, 6 (1995) 9. M.L. Sinnott, Chem. Rev., 90 (1990) 1171. J.D. McCarter and S.G. Withers, Curr. Opin. Struct. Biol., 4 (1994) 885. B. Svensson, A.J. Clarke, I. Svendsen and H. Moiler, Eur. J. Biochem., 188 (1990) 29.
144 42 43 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59 60 61 62 63 64 65 66 67 68 69 70 71
B. Stoffer. Ph.D. Thesis (1994) University of Copenhagen. T.P. Frandsen, T. Christensen, B. Stoffer, J. Lehmbeck, C. Dupont, R.B. Honzatko and B. Svensson, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 10162. M.R. Sierks and B. Svensson, Biochemistry, 32 (1993) 1113. P.M. Coutinho and P.J. Reilly, Protein Eng., 7 (1994) 393. B. Henrissat, P.M. Coutinho and P.J. Reilly, Protein Eng., 7 (1994) 1281. K. Bock and H. Pedersen, Acta Chem. Scand., B41 (1987) 617. A.J. Wilkinson, A.R. Fersht, D.M. Blow and G. Winther, Biochemistry, 22 (1983) 3581. M.M. Palcic, T. Skrydstrup, K. Bock, N. Le and R.U. Lemieux, Carbohydr. Res., 250 (1993) 87. M.R. Sierks and B. Svensson, Protein Eng., 7 (1994) 1479. R. Fagerstr6m, J. Gen. Microbiol., 137 (1991) 1001. C.-I. Brfinden, Curr. Opin. Struc. Biol., 1 (1991) 978. R.L. Jones and J.V. Jacobsen, Int. Rev. Cyt., 126 (1991) 49. M. S0gaard and B. Svensson, Gene, 94 (1990) 173. M. SCgaard, F.L. Olsen and B. Svensson, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci., U.S.A., 88 (1991) 8140. A. Kadziola, J. Abe, B. Svensson and R. Haser, J. Mol. Biol., 239 (1994) 104. M. Sogaard, J.S. Andersen, P. Roepstorff and B. Svensson, Bio/Technology, 11 (1993) 1162. N. Juge, M. Scgaard, J.C. Chaix, M.F. Martin-Eauclaire, B. Svensson, G. MarchisMouren and X.J. Guo, Gene, 130 (1993) 159. Y. Suzuki, N. Ito, T. Yuuku, H. Yamagata and S. Udaka, J. Biol. Chem., 264 (1989) 18933. L. Holm, A.K. Koivula, P.M. Lehtovaara, A. Hemminki and J.K.C. Knowles, Protein Eng., 3 (1990) 181. P. Joyet, N. Declerck and C. Gaillardin, Bio/Technology, 10 (1992) 1579. I. Matsui, K. Ishikawa, S. Miyairi, S. Fukui and K. Honda, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1077 (1991) 416. I. Matsui, K. Ishikawa, S. Miyairi, S. Fukui and K. Honda, Biochemistry, 31 (1992) 5232. I. Matsui, S. Yoneda, K. Ishikawa, S. Miyairi, S. Fukui, H. Umeyama and K. Honda, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 451. K.W. Rodenburg, N. Juge, X.J. Guo, M. Scgaard, J.C. Chaix and B. Svensson, Eur. J. Biochem., 221 (1994) 277. N. Juge, K.W. Rodenburg, X.J. Guo, J.C. Chaix and B. Svensson, FEBS Lett., 363 (1995) 299. J.C. Rogers and C. Milliman, J. Biol. Chem., 258 (1983) 8169. J.C. Rogers, J. Biol. Chem., 260 (1985) 3731. A.W. MacGregor, J.E. Morgan and E.A. MacGregor, Carbohydr. Res., 227 (1992) 301. E.H. Ajandouz, J. Abe, B. Svensson and G. Marchis-Mouren, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1159 (1992) 193. I. Matsui, K. Ishikawa, S. Miyairi, S. Fukui and K. Honda, FEBS Lett., 310 (1992) 216.
145 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84
K. Ishikawa, I. Matsui, K. Honda and H. Nakatani, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun., 183 (1992) 286. M. Blanc-Muesser, H. Driguez, J. Lehmann and J. Steck, Carbohydr. Res., 223 (1992) 129. M. Qian, R. Haser and F. Payan, Protein Sci., 4 (1995) 747. A.G. Murzin, A.M. Lesk and C. Chothia, J. Mol. Biol., 223 (1992) 531. K.W. Rodenburg, I~. V~allyay, I. Svendsen and B. Svensson, Biochem. J., 309 (1995) 969. U. Sidenius, K. Olsen, B. Svensson and U. Christensen, FEBS Lett., 361 (1995) 250. J. Abe, U. Sidenius and B. Svensson, Biochem. J., 293 (1993) 151. J. Mundy, I. Svendsen and J. Hejgaard, Carlsberg Res. Commun., 48 (1983) 81. R.J. Weselake, A.W. MacGregor, R.D. Hill and H.W. Duckworth, Plant Physiol., 72 (1983) 1008. G.P. Pal, C.A. Kavounis, K.D. Jany and D. Tsernoglou, FEBS Lett., 341 (1994) 167. F. Vall6e, A. Kadziola, Y. Bourne, J. Abe, B. Svensson and R. Haser, J. Mol. Biol., 236 (1994) 368. A. T6rr6nen, M. Leisola and S. Haarasilta, Cereal Chem., 69 (1992) 355. A.J. Halayko, R.D. Hill and B. Svensson, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 873 (1986) 92.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 91995 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
The structure and function commune xylanase A
relationship
of
147
Schizophyllum
M.R. Bray and A.J. Clarke Department of Microbiology, University of Guelph, Guelph, Ontario N 1G 2W l, Canada
Abstract The structure and function relationship of the Family G glycosidase, xylanase A from Schizophyllum commune, is reviewed. The action pattern of xylo-oligosaccharide hydrolysis by xylanase A suggests that the binding site spans about seven xylose units (i.e., seven sub-sites), and that the catalytic site is located asymmetrically within them. Ultraviolet difference spectroscopy with xylanase A in the presence of inhibitors and substrates together with chemical modification studies indicate the participation of a tyrosyl residue in the binding of substrates to xylanase A. This binding-site residue has been identified as Tyr97, a conserved aromatic amino acid residue among the Family G glycosidases. Xylanase A catalyzes the hydrolysis of xylan with the retention of anomeric configuration thereby implying a double displacement mechanism of action. Peptide mapping studies with a derivative of xylanase A inactivated by radiolabelled carbodiimide served to identify Glu87, a totally conserved acidic amino acid residue, as the nucleophile in the catalytic mechanism of action of the enzyme.
1. INTRODUCTION The potent wood-degrading basidiomycete (white-rot fungus) Schizophyllum commune produces a full complement of extracellular cellulolytic and heteroxylanolytic enzymes. These include, cellulases (EC 3.2.1.4; 1,4-(1,3;1,4)-[3-D-glucan 4-glucanohydrolase), cellobiohydrolases (EC 3.2.1.91; 1,4)-~-D-glucan cellobiohydrolase) and ~-glucosidases (EC 3.2.1.21 ;]3-Dglucoside glucohydrolase) which act synergistically to efficiently hydrolyse cellulose to glucose. Xylanases (EC 3.2.1.8; 1,4-13-D-xylan xylanohydrolase) catalyze the random hydrolysis of the xylan backbone of heteroxylans which are layered on cellulose fibrils and thereby expose the entire cellulose chains to the cellulolytic complex. The complete degradation of heteroxylans requires, in addition to xylanases, an array of debranching enzymes that may include [3-xylosidases (EC 3.2.1.37), 13-glucuronidases (EC 3.2.1.x), Ot-L-arabinofuranosidases (EC 3.2.1.55) and acetylesterases (EC 3.1.1.6) [1]. Moreover, many fungi and bacteria produce various and multiple forms of these respective enzymes; e.g., the fungus Sporotrichum dimorphosporum produces as many as nine distinct xylanases [2].
148 Xylanases have attracted considerable attention in recent years in view of their diverse industrial potential. Use of microbial enzymes for the industrial hydrolysis of biomass is advantageous because of the high specificity of enzymic reactions, the mildness of the reaction conditions, and the absence of substrate loss due to chemical modification. Two broad areas of application for xylanolytic enzymes have been identified; with and without other enzymes present [1]. Xylanases can be used in conjunction with other hydrolytic enzymes, such as cellulases, in the bioconversion of wastes, such as those from the forest industries [3]. Xylanases used concurrently with cellulases and pectinases may find wider uses in the clarification of must and juices, and for liquefying fruits and vegetables [1], as well as for extracting coffee, plant oils, and starch [4], for improving the nutritional properties of agricultural silage [5], for macerating plant cell walls and in the formation of protoplasts [6], and for providing different textures to bakery products [7]. Further application also exists for the use of xylanolytic enzymes in the absence of cellulolytic enzymes, particularly in the pulp and paper industry. An efficient and economical enzymic process could convert these polluting liquids into higher value compounds such as ethanol, xylulose, xylitol and xylonic acid [8]. Perhaps most significant, and most likely to be applied in the future, amongst the biotechnological processes in the pulp and paper industry is the incorporation of xylanase prebleaching, where the enzymes are used to enhance the delignification of pulps. The pulp and paper industry is under significant market, environmental, and legislative pressure to modify its pulping, bleaching, and effluent treatment technologies in order to reduce the environmental impact of mill effluents [4]. The incorporation of xylanase prebleaching is being considered and tested because it permits the use of lower chlorine charges during the bleaching of kraft pulps, the bleach boosting effect being associated with reduced chloro-organic discharges [4]. To realize the potential of xylanases in industry, it was, and continues to be, necessary to expand our knowledge concerning the behaviour of these enzymes at the structural and mechanistic level. With this information, it may be possible to modify the enzymes more specifically, such as by cross-linking or immobilization, and thereby increase their stability and expand their applicability. Hydrolysis efficiency, specificity, or stability of xylanases may also benefit from application of structure-function information through genetic and protein engineering. An eventual goal of this type of work is to be able to engineer "designer" enzymes with industrially-ideal characteristics, but which retain exquisite specificity for a particular task. The xylanase from Schizophyllum c o m m u n e is an ideal candidate for such studies since it is both produced in relatively larger quantities and released extracelluarly. Both these properties facilitate its routine isolation and purification to homogeneity. In addition, it is characterized by a low molecular weight, no glycosylation and it is highly active. This review will describe the current knowledge concerning the mode of action, structure and proposed catalytic mechanism of S. c o m m u n e xylanase A. In addition, structural information and evidence for a lysozyme-type mechanism of action will be considered, with reference to other related xylanases.
149 2. ENZYME ISOLATION AND PURIFICATION Screening experiments with both stationary and submerged cultures conducted by Jurasek and co-workers in the late 1960s had indicated that S c h i z o p h y l l u m c o m m u n e was a potent producer of both cellulase and xylanase [9,10]. Early attempts were made to produce the enzymes by shake flask cultivation using beechwood sawdust as the major carbon source [ 10]. Also at this time, small amounts of an S. c o m m u n e xylanase were isolated by electrophoresis [11]. A protocol was finally developed by Paice et al. [12,13] for the isolation and purification of xylanase A from S. c o m m u n e strain Delmar grown in submerged culture with spruce sawdust as carbon source. The enzyme was isolated from the culture filtrate by ethanol fractionation. Anion-exchange chromatography and gel filtration on DEAE-Sephadex A-50 and Sephadex G-50, respectively, served to render a homogenous preparation of xylanase A with an overall yield of 25.3% (43-fold purification) [12,13]. A slight modification to this protocol has been described in which prior to the anion-exchange chromatography, an initial gel filtration of the crude xylanase is performed to remove the bulk of the extracellular polysaccharides still present in the ethanol precipitate of the crude enzyme [ 14]. The results of a typical experiment using this latter protocol are presented in Table 1. In most cases, analysis by sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) reveals the presence of only one protein band at 21 kDa. However, xylanase A has been shown to tightly bind carbohydrates [ 12], and residual carbohydrates and/or small amounts of glycoproteins do sometimes remain in the xylanase preparation. In these instances, affinity chromatography on Con A-Sepharose has been employed for their removal [ 14]. The modified protocol is suitable for the purification of large quantities of homogeneous xylanase (15-20 mg/1 of culture). The enzyme is highly stable and can be kept in dilute solutions at 4 ~ for several weeks with no discernable loss of activity [ 14].
Table 1 Purification of xylanase A from culture filtrate of S. c o m m u n e Delmar Total Total Specific Purification Treatment Protein Activity Activity Per step Overall (%) (mg) (IU) (IU/mg) Culture Filtrate 1140 1140 1.0 Ethanol Precipitate 166 876 5.4 5.4 5.4 Sephadex G-50 78.8 665 8.4 1.6 8.6 DEAE-Sepharose 20.4 429 21.1 2.5 21.6 BioGel P-60 7.80 300 38.3 1.8 38.9 -
-
Overall Yield 100 76.9 56.4 37.7 26.4
3. PHYSICO-CHEMICAL PROPERTIES Xylanase A is a SDS-PAGE [14], c o m m u n e [15,16], residues) has been
single chain polypeptide with a molecular weight of 21 kDa, as judged by and has a pI value of 4.5 [12]. Unlike the cellulolytic enzymes of S. xylanase A is not a glycoprotein [12-14]. Its amino acid sequence (197 determined by automated protein sequencing analysis (Figure 1) and the
150 two cysteine residues at positions 111 and 160 form a disulfide linkage [17]. The amino acid sequence is similar to two Trichoderma xylanases (approximately 56% identical amino acids), and also shows at least 40% identifies with the xylanases from Bacillus circulans, B. pumilus and B. subtilis [17]. Alignment of the xylanase sequence with those of the over 60 known 131,4-glucanases and xylanases places this enzyme in Family G of the classification scheme of Gilkes et al. [ 18]. This family is comprised of only xylanases, but of both bacterial and fungal origin. A number of amino acid residues appear to be totally conserved among the Family G xylanases, including two acidic and eight aromatic residues.
1 SGTPSSTGTDGGYY_YSWWTDGAG DATYQN NG_GGSYTLTWSGNNGNLV 48 G G K~WN PGAAS RS ISYSGTYQ PN G NSY LSV..Y..6...t:VTRSS L I..E...Y..YIVESYGSu 98 D_PSSAASHKGSVTC N_GAT_YDILSTWRYNAPSlDGTQTFE~FWSVn:N PKKA 148 P_GGSISGTVDVQC_~FDAffKG L_GMNLG SEH NYQIVAT_EGYOSS_GTATITV Figure 1. Amino acid sequence of xylanase A [17]. Residues in bold type indicate homology amongst at least 10 of the 19 aligned sequences of Family G xylanases [36], while underlined residues identify complete conservation. The two totally conserved Glu residues are shaded. The putative stabilizing anion/nucleophile, Glu87, and the substrate-binding Tyr97 are identified by the asterisks.
The pH optimum exhibited by xylanase A is broad, being centred at pH 5, and the enzyme is most stable within a pH range of 6 to 8 (>90% residual activity after 65 h at 30 ~ [14]. Its optimum temperature for activity (10 min assay) is between 45 ~ and 50 ~ [12,13], and the enzyme is stable at these temperatures for approximately 60 min [17]. Whereas the disulfide linkage present in the enzyme likely contributes to its thermostability, other factors, such as electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions, are probably more important since the other characterized Family G xylanases do not possess disulfides and at least one, the B. subtilis enzyme, is more thermostable [ 17].
4. KINETICS Xylanase A is an endoxylanase [19] with specificity only for xylans; no appreciable cellulase, 13-glucosidase nor 13-xylosidase activity has been detected [13]. The major products of hydrolysis following an 18 h incubation with xylans from either larch (a softwood heteroxylan comprised of a xylose backbone with 4-0-methyl-o~-D-glucuronic acid substituents) or esparto
151 grass (a simple homoxylopyranose polysaccharide) are xylobiose and xylose in a ratio of approximately 3:1. Its Km for soluble xylan is 8.4 mg/ml and homogeneous preparations are characterized by a specific activity of 1.5 x 103 IU/min [13]. The kinetics of xylanase A-catalyzed hydrolysis of a series of xylan homopolymers has been studied to assess the effect of substrate chain length on the process of catalysis through product ratios, Michaelis parameters, and bond cleavage frequencies. To this end, an HPLCbased method was developed to concomitantly quantify both substrate loss and increase of reaction products without the use of radioactivity [19]. In general, xylanase A attacks the longer xylo-oligomers in a mixture, rapidly hydrolysing them to xylobiose and xylotriose. Unlike most other endoxylanases studied in terms of mode of action [20-23], xylanase A exhibits no exo-xylanase character, a trait which is indicated by the lack of xylobiase activity, but cleavage of xylotriose to xylose and xylobiose occurs [ 19]. A similar action pattem to that of xylanase A is exhibited by an endo-l,4-xylanase excreted by Clostridium thermolacticum [24], which hydrolysed 4-O-methylglucuronoxylan to the neutral end products xylobiose and xyltotriose. Xylanase A does not readily catalyze multi-substrate reactions (e.g., transglycosylation), a characteristic that is unusual among other xylanases [21,25-28] and many related carbohydrases but may be related to a relatively short-lived carbonium ion intermediate in the mechanism of catalysis of the enzyme [29]. However, preliminary hydrolysis experiments using high concentrations of xylotriose indicated that under appropriate conditions, product ratios shift as a result of the contribution of multi-substrate mechanisms to substrate degradation. To explain the observed concentration-dependent product-ratio shift of xylotriose hydrolysis (i.e., more xylobiose present than expected for unimolecular hydrolysis), at least three mechanisms have to be considered [30], transglycosylation, condensation, and shifted one-two binding (termolecular shifted complexes). The former two degradative pathways are illustrated schematically in Figure 2. They may occur if the enzyme-intermediate complex is sufficiently long-lived for the leaving group to diffuse away and an acceptor molecule to diffuse in and/or shift to the catalytic site. Clearly, the longevity of the enzyme-intermediate complex, and therefore the propensity of an enzyme to undergo multi-molecular reactions, is largely dependent upon the strength of the positive contribution to binding energy is subsites adjacent to the catalytic site. Figure 2. Possible bi-molecular pathways for degradation of xylotriose by xylanase A. The circles represent xylose residues, while the filled circles denote reducing ends. To result in more xylobiose than expected by the normal uni-molecular hydrolytic pathway (a) under conditions of high xylotriose concentrations, condensation (b) or transglycosylation (c) reactions may precede hydrolysis.
152 Initial rate data obtained from the xylanase A hydrolysis of individual oligomers at 25 ~ and pH 5.8 indicated that Km decreased with increasing chain length of oligomer while kcat increased with chain length up to a degree of polymerization of seven (Figure 3) [19]. Assuming that Km as well as Vmaxand bond cleavage frequencies are directly related to the free energy released in the process of monomer-subsite interaction [31], it appears that xylanase A has at least seven subsites capable of binding xylose residues (Figure 3). Bond-cleavage frequencies indicate a strong preference for intemal linkages and that the catalytic site is located assymetrically within the binding subsites of the enzyme. A thermodynamic binding array calculated by the method of Thoma and Allen [32] using the bond-cleavage frequencies is illustrated in Figure 4 [33]. As typical of enzyme binding sites, the seven subsites vary in their affinity for the substrate xylosyl residues. The sum of affinities of subsites -I and I constitutes a region of positive free energy which may distort the chair form of a bound xylosyl residue into a half-chair, producing the enzyme-induced strain which is proposed to lower the activation energy barrier to form the transition state. The interaction energy for these two subsites is given as a sum since all productive complexes fill both subsites -I and I. The effects of a subsite of low affinity near the active site (i.e., subsite II) would be overcome upon binding of substrates with a degree of polymerization greater than 4 due to the greater affinities associated with subsites -II, -III and III. The strong "endo" character of this binding array is most apparent with these rapidly hydrolysed substrates, and is reflected in the reduced likelihood of a complex being formed the closer one end of the oligomer comes to the repelling effects of subsites -I and I.
5. STEREOCHEMISTRY The use of high-field proton NMR to monitor the chemical shift and coupling constant of the anomeric proton on the hemiacetal carbon of reaction products has greatly facilitated the determination of the stereochemical course of hydrolysis catalyzed by glycanases [34]. Reaction conditions are established such that the initially formed anomer of a hydrolytic reaction accumulates sufficiently to permit analysis by proton NMR before mutarotation of the products occurs. Application of this technique by Gebler et al. [35], using xylotetraose as the substrate, revealed that xylanase A catalyzes hydrolysis with the retention of anomeric configuration. Mechanistically, this implies that this enzyme operates by the double displacement mechanism of Figure 5. The basic features of this mechanism were first proposed for glycosidases by Koshland in 1953 [36] and they have generally remained intact. As modified by Sinnott [29], the mechanism involves the following events: i) an acid catalyst protonates the substrate; ii) a carboxylate group on the enzyme is positioned on the opposite side of the sugar ring to the aglycone; iii) a covalent glycosyl-enzyme intermediate is formed with the carboxylate in which the anomeric configuration of the sugar intermediate is opposite to that of the substrate; iv) the covalent intermediate may be reached from both directions through transition states involving oxocarbonium ions; and various non-covalent interactions provide most of the rate enhancement. That the pH-activity profile for xylanase A is bellshaped and centred at pH 5 [ 12] gives direct evidence for the participation of two catalyticallyessential ionizable groups on the enzyme, one with an acidic pKa and remaining deprotonated
153
at neutral pH (stabilizing anion/nucleophile) while the second has a pK. value closer to neutrality and remains protonated (acid catalyst). 0.50 K
M kcat (mM) (sec 1) 27.9 72.1 '~5:5~~'g"o~O,'~____~ 48.6 51.4 ~--7", o~ . , ~ - - - " ; ~ ,
4.3
0.0 o~
3.6
9.4 65.2 24.4 0.9 ~--.%~,~'-o~O~O'~__I.~. 0.0 36.4 33.3 ~-"gT'o"~~g~o"~~g'~~
26.7
3.6
0.7 17.1 35.9 33.8 11.7 ~-.,%,o,~"gT'o~,,~lgT~-"~~"~_~
0.7
0
0.921
E
~-0.50
1.2 12.8
0
0.8 13.2
-1.00
O.5 16.6
-1.50 -IV
-III
-II
-I
I
II
A
0.00
0.0105
III
-IV
-III
-il
-I
I
II
III
Subsite
Subsite
Figure 4. Relative subsite binding energies for xylanase A obtained from quantitative bond-cleavage frequency analysis and Michaelis parameters. The position of the catalytic site is denoted by the arrowhead.
Figure 3. Bond cleavage frequencies and Michaelis constants of xylanase A catalyzed hydrolysis of xylo-alditols at 25 ~ and pH 5.7. Frequencies are expressed as per-centages of total cleavage events. The arrowhead denotes the probable site of hydrolysis within the binding subsites. The data and figure are adapted from ref. 19.
AH
o
C"
O=C JO
>
o.
RO
o,,//--~o/
"OR
L 6+~ ' Ha, a "O-H
H O N O R
0
AH
O=C " 0 -
A:
0.~-~.H'O-H 9
O=C So"
<
~_~.
RO
ALl ,
,~,,,/'0-H
O=C "('0]
Figure 5. Generally accepted endocyclic pathway of the double-displacement mechanism for the retaining ~-glycosidases.
154 6. DIFFERENCE SPECTROSCOPY Ultraviolet spectroscopic studies of xylanase A in the presence of substrates or inhibitors provided evidence for the participation of one or more Tyr residues in the binding of ligands [37]. Binding of xylooligomer substrates to the enzyme produces a characteristic difference spectrum with a maximum at 283-286 nm indicating that the environment of a Tyr residue(s) located in the binding cleft becomes more hydrophobic. A slight red shift of difference absorbance maxima at approximately 280 and 287 nm relative to a Tyr model compound (with maxima at 275, 283 and 286 nm) and a decrease in the band at 283 nm (Figure 6) suggested either the formation of new hydrogen bonds or the disruption of intrinsic hydrogen bonding network involving the Tyr residue. Since the xylooligomers used in these experiments would have been rapidly hydrolysed to xylobiose and xylotriose, the perturbed Tyr residue could be located in subsites -II, -III or -IV of Figure 4. However, the apparent subsite binding energies would predict that xylose preferentially binds subsite -IV and this weak inhibitor was observed to neither interact directly with the Tyr residue(s) nor induce sufficient conformational changes to perturb it. Thus, the perturbed Tyr residue is postulated to be localized to subsite -III or-II.
j
/
/ l
/
/
/-/ I
I
a
,
\.\ ............... b l, \ "....__
I
~,
I
I
-
0
I
260 270 280 290 300 310
Wavelength (nm) Figure 6. Difference ultraviolet absorbance spectra of (a) 50 laM xylanase A perturbed with 0.75% (wt/vol) xylooligomers and (b) N-acetyltyrosine ethyl ester and (c) N-acetyltryptophan ethyl ester, each perturbed with 40% dioxane. The spectra were recorded with a Beckman DU8 single-beam spectrophotometer at pH 6.0 and 20 ~ The solid bars each represent 0.01 absorbance units. The data are adapted from [37].
155 7. CHEMICAL MODIFICATION An essential step in understanding the catalytic process of an enzyme is to locate and characterize the amino acids comprising the active site, and to study the relationship between these residues and enzyme function. This relationship can be probed effectively by the technique of chemical modification. This approach has the advantage over site-directed mutagenesis in that the starting material for the experiments is fully active, native enzyme. However, interpretation of the results of chemical modification requires care because the physical and chemical properties of the product resultant from modification may affect activity adversely, favourably, or not at all depending on the role of a residue in the catalytic process. In addition, correlation of activity with chemical modification is usually based upon various and often tacit assumptions; for example, that the specificity of the reagent employed is absolute, that the conditions under which the reaction is performed do not disturb protein structure and that the activity changes are not the consequence of either conformational changes or denaturation. In the studies with xylanase A, great care was taken to ensure that these inherent limitations of chemical modification were minimized or eliminated to allow unambiguous interpretation of the data.
7.1. Substrate-binding residues. The participation of aromatic residues Trp and Tyr in the binding of substrate to xylanase A was probed with the group specific reagents N-bromosuccinimide (NBS) and tetranitromethane (C(NO2)4), respectively [14,37]. The results of these studies, which are summarized in Table 2, indicated that both of these amino acid residues are involved. Reaction with NBS led to the complete inactivation of the enzyme. In the course of the chemical modification of xylanase A with NBS, reduced specificity of the reagent resulted in the modification of Tyr, as detected by a sharp increase in absorbance at 280 nm with increasing NBS concentrations. Such reactions invalidated the use of the spectrophotometric method of Spande and Witkop [38] for Trp quantitation which is based on the decrease in absorbance at 280 nm. To circumvent this problem, a fourth-derivative spectrophotometric method for Trp and Tyr quantitation was developed [39]. Employing this new method, NBS-oxidized xylanase A with a residual enzymatic activity of less than 10% was shown to retain 4 of its 8 Trp residues and 16 of its 17 Tyr residues (Table 2). The presence of xylopentaose in the NBS reaction mixtures did not protect from loss of activity, but at concentrations greater than 1%, one less Trp residue was oxidized. These data imply that one Trp residue participates in binding interactions with substrate, while one, two or three others which are not located in the binding site cleft are required to maintain the structural integrity of a catalytically competent enzyme. At present, the identity of the binding-site Trp residue remains unknown, but likely candidates would include one of the two totally conserved Trp residues (Trp80 and Trp 165 of xylanase A) of the Family G enzymes (Figure 1). Investigations on the identity and possible role of a binding-site Tyr in xylanase A were initiated based on the compelling evidence obtained from both the difference spectroscopic study and NBS modification experiments described above. Reaction of xylanase A with a 100fold molar excess of C(NO2)4 led to the nitration of approximately 3 Tyr residues and the concomitant elimination of catalytic activity while N-acetylimidazole (NAI) in great excess had little effect. Through differential labelling with C(NO2)4, employing xylopentaose as protective
156 ligand, and peptide mapping studies, Tyr97 was identified as the catalytically-essential Tyr residue [37]. The differences in both the chemical properties of the two Tyr-specific reagents and their effects on xylanase A are consistent with Tyr97 being located in the relatively hydrophobic environment of a substrate binding cleft. Tetranitromethane is a relatively nonpolar reagent and typically reacts with buried residues whereas NAI is quite polar and has been shown to preferentially modify exposed surface Tyr residues [40]. The nitration of a Tyr would have several consequences, including the effects of the bulky nitro group being placed ortho to the phenolic hydroxyl function. The properties of the substituent nitro group would push electrons into the benzene ring (inductive effect) and thereby lower the pKa of the phenolic hydroxyl from approximately 10.3 to 7.3 [41 ].
Table 2 Chemical modification of xylanase A. Amino Acid Reagent Molar Specificity Excess Asp/Glu WRK 20,800 CMC 20,800 EDC 20,800 EAC 20,800 Cys DTNB 46 His DEP 1,040 Trp NBS 30
Tyr
HNB NAI
C(NO2)4
470 12,000 14 100
No. Modified Residues n.d. n.d. n.d. 3.9 / 12 Glu+Asp 0 3.0 / 3 His 3.97 / 8 Trp 1.10 / 17 Tyr n.d. n.d. 0.7 / 17 Tyr 2.8 / 17 Tyr
% Residual Activity <1 <1 < 1 <1 100 100 <1
Reference
75 65 84 4.8
37 37 14,37 37
14 14 14 14 14 37,39
n.d. - not determined.
Thus, the nitrated Tyr97 would be partially ionized at physiological pH and this may critically disrupt the function of a binding residue in the tight confines of the binding cleft. As with the difference spectroscopic investigations described above, xylobiose and xylotriose would have been the predominant protective ligands remaining in the reaction mixtures during the C(NO2)4 differential labelling studies. Hence, it is very tempting to speculate that Tyr97 is the Tyr residue predicted to be located in subsites -II or -III and perturbed by ligands. This would preclude any possibility that Tyr97 plays a more active role in the mechanism of substrate hydrolysis, such as the proton donor or stabilizing anion as has been suggested for Tyr503 of Escherichia coli lacZ 13-galactosidase [42] or Tyr48 of Aspergillus niger glucoamylase [43], respectively.
157
7.2. Catalytic residues The nature of the pH-activity profile for xylanase A [ 12] implicates the participation of both an acidic amino acid and possibly a histidyl residue in its mechanism of catalysis. The latter possibility arises because the basic limb of the profile reflects the ionization of an imidazolium group, which typically has pK values in the range of 5.6-7.0 in proteins [44]. Alternatively, a second acidic residue may be located in a hydrophobic environment resulting in an increase of its pKa. These possibilities were readily resolved using group specific reagents. All three histidyl residues in xylanase A could be modified by diethylcarbonate (DEP) with no concomitant loss of activity (Table 2) [14]. Since the lack of reactivity with dithionitrobenzoic acid (DTNB) precluded the presence of free sulfhydryls (the two Cys residues present in the protein have since been confirmed to form a disulfide bond [17]), two acidic residues were implicated in catalysis by the enzyme. This was indeed borne out by reaction of the enzyme with carbodiimides. The water-soluble carbodiimide 1-(4-azonia-4,4-dimethylpentyl)-3-ethyl carbodiimide iodide (EAC) in the absence of added nucleophile inactivates xylanase A very rapidly and completely relative to the other carbodiimides, 1-ethyl-3[3-diethylamino)-propyl]-carbodiimide (EDC) and 1-cyclohexyl-3-(2-morpholinoethyl) carbodiimide (CMC) or the isoxazolium salt, N-ethyl-5phenylisoxazolium-3-sulfonate (WRK) [14]. EAC was therefore used for further studies. Analysis of the order of reaction of EAC with the enzyme indicated that an average of at least one molecule of inhibitor binds one molecule of xylanase for inactivation. The inclusion of xylooligomer substrates in the reaction mixtures provided a concentration dependent protection from inactivation indicating that the essential residue is located at the active site. Support for this proposal was provided by differential labelling studies employing xylooligomers as protective ligands and [3H]EAC which demonstrated that only one active-site carboxyl group is modified to inactivate the enzyme. These observations, however, do not preclude the existence of a second catalytically-essential acidic residue at the active site. The catalytically-essential residue susceptible to EAC modification was identified as Glu87 [45]. Reacting exposed carboxyl groups with unlabelled EAC in the presence of substrate, followed by removal of excess reagent and protecting ligand and then complete inactivation of the enzyme with [3H]EAC allowed isolation of peptides with radiolabel only associated with Glu87. Alignment of the amino acid sequences of the Family G enzymes reveals that Glu87 is one of only two totally conserved acidic amino acids, the second being Glu184 (Figure 1). The proposed mechanism of carbodiimide action requires that protonated carboxylic acids catalyze their own modification by both protonating the carbodiimide nitrogen atom and thereby also providing the attacking nucleophile carboxylate anion (Figure 7, reaction pathway a). In view of both this proposal, and that the EAC modification reactions described above were conducted at pH 6.0, it would initially appear that Glu87 participates in the mechanism of xylanase A action as the acid catalyst. However, as suggested by Svensson et al. [46], it is easily conceivable that in the confined space of the active site the carbodiimide is protonated by one specific residue and then is attacked by a carboxylate anion in close proximity to the former (Figure 7, reaction pathway b); a situation which is wholly consistent with the mechanistic scheme proposed for carbohydrases involving a catalytic diad. Evidence for the latter proposal is provided by amino acid sequence homology studies and X-ray crystallography. Indeed, the identity of a putative catalytic residue in xylanase A allows an opportunity to make valuable comparisons between it and related enzymes.
158
y
Stabilizing anion/ Nucleophile
0
R-N=C=N-R '
>
_
R-N=(~-N-R' 0
0
0
R-N a--~--~l -R ' 0"0
Y
Acid catalyst
o,/
R-N=C-N-R '
Figure 7. Alternative mechanisms by which carboxyl side chains in the confines of an active site may be modified by a carbodiiimide. In pathway a, the carbodiimide is protonated by the acid catalyst and then attacked by a proximal carboxylate nucleophile. In pathway b, the acid catalyst serves as both proton donor and subsequently as attacking nucleophile.
8. SEQUENCE ALIGNMENTS AND STRUCTURE PREDICTIONS Unfortunately, a crystal structure has not been determined for S. commune xylanase A. However, X-ray crystal structures have been solved at 1.8, 2.2 and 2.5 A for the closely related Family G enzymes from Bacillus circulans [47], B. pumilus [48] and Trichoderma reesei [49], respectively. Secondary structure predictions and hydrophobic cluster analysis reveal extensive similarities between these enzymes and xylanase A (Figure 8) suggesting that the tertiary structure of all Family G enzymes would share many common features. Indeed, the homologous residues to Glu87 and Glu184 of xylanase A (viz. Glu78 and Glu172 of B. circulans, Glu93 and Glu182 of B. pumitus and Glu86 and Glu177 of T. reesei) are positioned within the active site clefts of their respective enzymes to act as the catalytic residues. Glu93 of the B. pumilus xylanase is salt-bridged to Arg127 [48] while Glu78 of the B. circulans enzyme is within the vicinity of the positive charge contributed by Arg112 [47]. These Arg residues are also totally conserved in the Family G enzymes and correspond to Arg123 of xylanase A (Figure 1). The proximity of this charged residue will have the effect lowering the pKa values of the respective Glu residues and therefore, strongly implicates them as the stabilizing anion/nucleophile. Affinity labelling of the B. subtilis xylanase has subsequently comf'lrmed that these conserved residues serve as the active-site nucleophile [50]. However, there is no direct evidence for the assignment of the acid catalyst. With the B. circulans xylanase, the position of Glu172 relative to the xylotetraose substrate was determined to be similar to that of the putative acid catalyst of hen egg-white lysozyme, Glu35. By analogy to the lysozyme model,
159 Glu172, and presumably Glu184 of xylanase A, fulfds the role of the acid catalyst in the double-displacement mechanism of action. ,o
t
SO
,~
I
r~+
3o
I
o-
,o
~
!
.
~
I
,
I
,o
I
,o
I
II
II
I
,,
I
~1
I
,,o
I
,2o
I
,~
I
,,oO,,;,~
oi j ol o/J,olio
I~
~ , ~
II
I~
I
,o
,,o
I
I
,,.
,6o
!
,,o
,,o
I
,,o
!
[]
! I~*
+
,,
~ t j, L o I o'L II
I~
I
II
~I
I / I l I
I I I~
Figure 8. Hydrophobic-cluster analysis plots comparing the amino acid sequences of the xylanases from S. commune (Sc) [17] and B. circuIans (Bc) [51]. Vertical lines indicate the proposed argreement between the two sequences. The closed arrowheads denote the putative stabilizing anion/nucleophile Glu87 (Sc) and Glu78 (Bc) and the acid catalysts Glu184 (Sc) and Glu172 (Bc) while the open arrowhead identifies the conserved aromatic residue Tyr97 (Sc) and Tyr88 (Bc). The conventional symbols for Pro (.), Gly ( . ) , Ser (~), and Thr (r-l) have been used [52].
The putative roles of the two identified Glu residues in the B. circulans [47] and B. pumilus [53] xylanases have been further probed by site-directed mutagenesis in combination with both kinetic and X-ray crystallographic analyses. For both enzymes, kinetic analyses showed that enzyme activity is greatly affected by site-directed mutations to Glu78/93 and Glu 172/182 but activity is more affected by mutation of Glu78/93 (Glu78Asp and Glu93Ser in B. circulans and B. pumilus, respectively) than in Glu172/182 mutants (Glu172Asp and Glu182Asp in B. circulans and B. pumilus, respectively). This difference in effects is consistent with Glu78/93 having the more critical role of the stabilizing anion/nucleophile. The xynA gene encoding xylanase A has not been cloned from S. commune, but an artificial gene has been synthesized de novo using a novel PCR-based procedure [54]. The nucleotide sequence of this gene encoding xylanase A was designed and tailored for expression in Escherichia coli but sitedirected mutagenesis has yet to be performed. A number of proposals have been made to account for the high pK, value of the specific Glu/Asp residue that participates as the acid catalyst in carbohydrases. With hen egg-white lysozyme, these include i) the low accessibility of solvent to the active site cleft, ii) electrostatic interactions with the charge constellation (mainly Asp52), and iii) its location at the C-terminus of an s-helix macrodipole (negative charge) [55]. Secondary structure predictions using
160 different methods, including hydrophobic cluster analysis, together with comparison to the crystal structure of the B. pumilus xylanase indicate that the putative acid catalyst of xylanase A, Glu184, is not preceded by an 0~-helix but instead, located in a [3-strand [45]. In fact, only one short o~-helix is predicted for xylanase A [45], and only one is observed in the crystal structures of the B. circulans [47], B. pumilus [48] and T. reesei [49] enzymes. While this does not necessarily exclude the role of macrodipoles in the mechanism of action of hen eggwhite lysozyme, it seems that with xylanase A, and likely all other Family G xylanases, other forces must be governing the physical properties of the acid catalyst. That hydrophobic environments favour rearrangement of an intermediate O-acylurea EAC adduct to the stable Nacylurea rather than hydrolysis back to free carboxyl, a situation that occurs upon reactions with EAC [56], would suggest that the modified Glu87, and presumably Glu 184, exists in such an environment. Indeed, Glu 182 of the B. pumilus xylanase is observed to be slightly buried in a more hydrophobic environment [48], but in contrast, both Glu 78 and Glu 172 of the B. circulans enzyme are exposed to solvent [47]. Thus, it remains to be determined what governs the pKa of the acid catalyst for at least the Family G xylanases. The essential binding-site Tyr residue identified in S. commune xylanase A, Tyr97, was predicted to be located in either subsite -III or subsite -II. This residue is homologous to Tyr88 and Tyr96 of the B. circulans and T. reesei xylanases (Figure 1). Based on hydrophobic cluster analysis, all three residues appear in the same secondary structural element (Figure 8) and indeed, Tyr96 of T. reesei XynlI is proposed to pack against the xylose ring in subsite +3 [49]. However, analysis of the X-ray crystal structure of the B. circulans enzyme indicates that two other Tyr residues, Tyr69 and Tyr 80 (homologous to Tyr78 and Tyr89, respectively, in xylanase A), directly participate in substrate binding. In addition, Tyr69 is thought to hydrogen bond to the putative stabilizing anion/nucleophile, Glu78 and play a role in positioning this residue for catalysis [47]. Xylotetraose was used in the X-ray crystallographic studies of B. circulans xylanase-substrate complexes and it was observed to span the catalytic site, thus binding in subsites -II, -I, I and II. Hence, it is conceivable that Tyr88 of the B. circulans xylanase, which is located in the crystal structure on the edge of the active site cleft [47], comprises subsite -III, and as predicted for xylanase A Tyr97, makes binding contacts with substrates of greater degrees of polymerization. A stacking interaction of the highly conserved Trp9 (homologous to Trp 18 of xylanase A) with one of the xylose tings of xylotetraose is also observed in the crystal structure of B. circulans xylanase [47]. It is likely that Trpl8 of xylanase A interacts with substrate in a similar manner and that such interactions provide the observed protection from NBS modification, as described above.
9. CONCLUDING REMARKS The physical, kinetic and chemical modification investigations reviewed above not only identified catalytic and substrate binding residues in the mechanism of action of S. commune xylanase A, but also illustrate both the continued potential and utility of such experimental approaches and techniques. Xylanase A has served as an excellent system for discerning the catalytic mechanism of xylanases, and indeed, retaining carbohydrases in general. Whereas there is little doubt for the formation of enzyme-bound intermediate in the function of retaining
161 carbohydrases, the pathway for its formation involving the protonation of the exocyclic (C1) oxygen illustrated above is strictly conjecture. Kinetic studies on the inhibition of hydroxylated cyclic amines [57] and theoretical molecular dynamic calculations of lysozyme [58] led to a proposal for an endocyclic pathway for the formation of the enzyme-substrate adduct. This latter postulate involves the protonation of the ring (endocyclic) oxygen by the acid catalyst, followed by subsequent nucleophilic attack and displacement. The mechanism requires the rotation of the C1-C2 bond of the carbohydrate substrate rather than invoking substrate distortion for the favourable alignment of electronic orbitals, aturally, the endocyclic mechanism has been received with some scepticism and has initiated much debate (for example, see [59]) Although it remains to be established what the true mechanism involves, most, if not all the data supports an exocyclic mechanism.
10. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS These studies were supported by an operating grant from the Natural Science and Engineering Research Council of Canada to A.J.C. and a Graduate Scholarship to M.R.B. from the Province of Ontario.
11. REFERENCES
8 9 10 11 12
13 14 15 16 17
P. Biely, Trends Biotechnol., 3 (1985) 286. J. Combat, Carbohydr. Res., 118 (1983) 215. K.K.Y. Wong, L.V.L. Tan and J.N. Saddler, Microbiol. Rev., 52 (1988) 305. K.K.Y. Wong and J.N. Saddler, Crit. Rev. Biotech., 12 (1992) 413. M. Linko, K. Poutanen and L. Viikari, in Enzyme Systems for Lignocellulose Degradation, M.P. Coughlan (ed.) pp 331-346, Elsevier Applied Science, London, 1989. C.I. Beck and D. Scott, Adv. Chem. Ser., 136 (1974) 1. J. Maat, M. Roza, J. Verbakel, H. Stam, et al. in Xylans and Xylanases, J. Visser, G. Beldman, M.A. Kusters-van Someren, A.G.J. Voragen (eds.) pp 349-360, Elsevier Science Publishers B.V., Amsterdam, 1992. C.S. Gong, L.F. Chen, M. Flickinger, G.T. Tsoa, Adv.Biochem.Eng., 20 (1981) 93. L. Jur~i~ek, R. Spoko and J. Varadi, Ceska Mykol., 22 (1968) 43. L. Jur~i~ek, J. Varadi and R. Spoko Drev. Vysk., 12 (1967) 73. J. Varadi, V. Necesany and P. Kovacs, Drev. Vysk., 16 (1971) 147. M.G. Paice, L. Jur~igek M.R. Carpenter and L.B. Smillie, Appl. Envrion. Microbiol., 36 (1978) 802. L. Jur~i~ek, M.G. Paice, Methods Enzymol., 160 (1988) 659. M.R. Bray and A.J. Clarke, Biochem. J., 270 (1990) 91. A.J. Clarke, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 912 (1987) 424. A.J. Clarke and M. Yaguchi, Eur. J. Biochem., 149 (1985) 233. T. Oku, C. Roy, D.C. Watson, W. Wakarchuk, R. Campbell, M. Yaguchi, L. Jurasek and M.G. Paice, FEBS Lett., 334 (1993) 296.
162 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 45 46 47 48
N.R. Gilkes, B. Henrissat, D.G. Kilbum, R.C. Miller, R.A.J. Warren, Microbiol. Rev., 55 (1991) 303. M.R. Bray and A.J. Clarke, Eur. J. Biochem., 204 (1992) 191. Y. Mitsuishi, T. Yamanobe and M. Yagisawa, Agric. Biol. Chem., 52 (1988) 921 P. Biely, Z. Kr~.tk3) and M. Vr~ank~i, Eur. J. Biochem., 119 (1981) 559. M. Kubackova, S. Karacsonyi, L. Bilisics and R. Toman, Carbohydr. Res., 76 (1979) 177. I.V. Gorbacheva and Rodionova, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 484 (1977) 94. P. Debiere, B. Priem, G. Strecker and M. Vignon, Eur. J. Biochem., 187 (1990) 573 P. Biely, M. Vr~ank~i and I.V. Gorbacheva, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 743 (1983) 155. M. Vr~ank~i, I.V. Gorbacheva, Z. Kr~itk2~,Z. and P. Biely, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 704 (1982) 114. P. Biely, M. Vr~ank~i and Z. Kr~itk3~,Eur. J. Biochem., 119 (1981) 565. S. Takenishi and Y. Tsujisaka, Agric. Biol. Chem., 39 (1975) 2315. M.L. Sinnott, in Enzyme mechanisms, M.I. Page and A. Williams (eds.) pp 259-297, Royal Society of Chemistry, London, 1987. J.F. Robyt and D. French, J. Biol. Chem., 245 (1970) 3917. J.A. Thoma, G.V.K. Rao, C. Brothers, J. Spradlin and L.H. Li, J. Biol. Chem., 246 (1971) 5621. J.A. Thoma and J.D. Allen, Carbohydr. Res., 48 (1976) 105. M.R. Bray, Ph.D. Thesis (1993) University of Guelph. S.G. Withers, D. Dombroski, L.A. Berven, D.G. Kilburn, R.C. Miller Jr., R.A.J. Warren and N.R. Gilkes, Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun., 139 (1988) 487. J. Gebler, N.R. Wilkes, M. Claeyssens, D.B. Wilson, P. Bequin, W.W. Wakarchuk, D.G. Kilbum, R.C. Miller, R.A.J. Warren and S.G. Withers, J. Biol. Chem., 267 (1992) 12559. D.E. Koshland, Biol. Rev., 28 (1953) 416. M.R. Bray and A.J. Clarke, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 2006. T.F. Spande and B. Witkop, Methods Enzymol., 11 (1967) 498. M.R. Bray, A.D. Carriere and A.J. Clarke, Anal. Biochem., 221 (1994) 278. B. Myers II and A.N. Glazer, J. Biol. Chem., 246 (1971) 412. R.C.Lundblad and C.M. Noyes, Chemical Reagents for Protein Modification, pp 105121, CRC Press, Inc., Boca Raton, 1984. M. Ring and R.E. Huber, Arch. Biochem. Biophys., 283 (1990) 342. M. Stoffer, A.E. Aleshin, T.P. Frandsen, B. Svensson and R.B. Honzatko, Abstract C2.10, 17th International Carbohydrate Symposium, Ottawa, 1994. J.P. Greenstein and M. Winitz, Ann. Rev. Biochem., 38 (1969) 733. M.R. Bray and A.J. Clarke, Eur. J. Biochem., 219 (1994) 821. B. Svensson, A.J. Clarke, I. Svendsen and H. Moiler, Eur.J.Biochem., 188 (1990) 29. W.W. Wakarchuk, R.L. Campbell, W.L. Sung, J. Davoodi and M. Yaguchi, Prot. Sci., 3 (1994) 467. Y. Katsube, Y. Hata, H. Yamaguchi, H. Moriyama, A. Shimnyo and H. Okada, in Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Protein Engineering: Protein Design in Basic Research, Medicine and Industry, M. Ikehara, T. Oshima and K. Titani (eds.) pp 91-96, Japan Scientific Societies Press, Tokyo, 1989.
163 49 50 51 52 53 54 55 56 57 58 59
A. T/3rr6nen and J. Rouvinen, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 847. S. Miao, L. Ziser, R. Aebersold and S.G. Withers, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 7027. R.C.A. Yang, C.R. MacKenzie and R.A. Narang, Nucleic Acids Res., 16 (1988) 7187. C. Gaboriaud, V. Bissery, T. Benchetrit and J.P. Mornon, FEBS Lett., 224 (1987) 149. E.P. Ko, H. Akatsuka, H. Moriyama, A. Shimnyo, Y. Hata, Y. Katube, I. Urabe and H. Okada, Biochem. J., 288 (1992) 117. R.W. Graham, T. Atkinson, D.G. Kilburn, R.C. Miller Jr. and R.A.J. Warren, Nucl. Acid Res., 21 (1993) 4923. V. Spassov, A.D. Karshikov and B.P. Atanasov, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 999 (1989) 1. R. Timokovich, Anal. Biochem., 79 (1977) 135. G.W.J. Fleet, Tetrahedron Lett., 26 (1985) 5073. C.B. Post and M.J. Karplus, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 108 (1986) 1317. M.L. Sinnott, Bioorg. Chem., 21 (1993) 34.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
165
Protein engineering of cyclodextrin glycosyltransferase from Bacillus circulans strain 251 L. Dijkhuizen a, D. Penninga a, H.J. Rozeboom b, B. Strokopytov b and B.W. Dijkstra b
aDepartment of Microbiology and bBIOSON Research Institute, Laboratory of Biophysical Chemistry, Groningen Biomolecular Sciences and Biotechnology Institute (GBB), University of Groningen, The Netherlands
Abstract
The 3D-structure of CGTase from Bacillus circulans strain 251 has been determined at 2.0 resolution, allowing a detailed analysis of structure-function relationships of this protein. The catalytic mechanism of the CGTase cyclization reaction was studied by constructing various mutants using site-directed mutagenesis. 3D-structures of these mutant proteins have been obtained and further analysed.
1. INTRODUCTION Many bacteria and fungi excrete enzymes that degrade starch to facilitate the uptake of carbohydrates into the cell. A number of bacteria belonging to the genera Bacillus, Thermoanaerobacter, Thermoanaerobacterium, Clostridium, Micrococcus, Klebsiella, are able to grow on starch using the extracellular enzyme cyclodextrin glycosyl-transferase (CGTase; EC 2.4.1.19) for the initial attack on this polymeric substrate. CGTases catalyse the formation of cyclodextrins from starch and related o~(1~ 4 ) linked glucose polymers via an intramolecular transglycosylation reaction. CGTase enzymes are functionally related to oramylases, which hydrolyse starch into linear products. In contrast with o~-amylases, CGTase enzymes preferentially add the "non-reducing end" glycosidic C4 hydroxyl group across the scissile ct(1---)4) glycosidic bond, resulting in a glycosidic exchange and the formation of cyclodextrins. CGTase enzymes and o~-amylases share about 30% amino acid sequence identity [2]. Bacteria employing a CGTase for starch degradation are able to subsequently metabolize the cyclodextrins produced as carbon- and energy sources for growth (Figure 1). This appears to involve a cell-associated cyclomaltodextrinase (CDase; EC 3.2.1.54), yielding glucose, maltose and maltotriose from cyclodextrins [1]. The further glucose metabolism proceeds intracellularly via the glycolytic pathway.
166
Figure 1. Bacterial growth on starch (amylose) involving an extracellular CGTase (yielding cyclodextrins, CD), a cell-associated CDase (yielding glucose, maltose and maltotriose), and intracellular glucose metabolism via the glycolytic pathway, yielding pyruvate (Pyr).
Cyclodextrins are cyclic glucose oligomers linked via a(1,4) glycosidic bonds (Figure 2). They possess a hydrophobic internal cavity formed by the glucopyranose CH groups and a hydrophilic exterior surface formed by primary and secondary hydroxyl groups [3]. Cyclodextrins are able to form inclusion complexes with many small hydrophobic molecules in aqueous solutions, resulting in changes in physical properties, e.g. increased solubility and stability, and decreased chemical reactivity and volatility (Figure 2) [14]. Cyclodextrins find an increasing use in industrial and research applications [21 ]. All CGTase enzymes studied thus far from different bacterial sources form a mixture of cyclodextrins consisting of 6, 7 or 8 glucose residues, or-, ~- and y-cyclodextrin, respectively. The relative proportion of the o~-, [3or T-cyclodextrins produced varies with the bacterial source of the enzyme [15]. CGTase enzymes not only produce cyclodextrins from starch but also display coupling, disproportionation and saccharifying activities (Figure 3). The hydrolyzing activity of the Bacillus circulans strain 251 CGTase protein, however, is rather low [12] and generally the enzyme only produces cyclodextrins from starch. All CGTase enzymes studied are also rather sensitive to product inhibition by cyclodextrins. The industrial cyclodextrin production process, involving CGTase, thus could be improved considerably by the construction of mutant CGTase enzymes with improved product specificity and decreased product inhibition
167
off o
15.3 A
I
-~ ~
~ [
I
~ ,
v
-- L
I
hydrophobic inside
I-~hydr~176
Stabilization of light- or oxygen-sens, comp. Stabilization of volatile compounds Alteration of chemical reactivity Improvement of solubility ~--- H20 9 Attraction
Improvement of smell and taste
4 Repulsion
Modification of liquid compounds to powders
Figure 2. Structure and properties of [3-cyclodextrins.
2. METHODS 2.1. Production and Purification of CGTase Proteins
CGTase wild type and mutant proteins were produced using Bacillus subtilis strain DB104A, lacking protease and t~-amylase activity. Cells of this strain carrying the plasmid encoded mutant cgt genes under the control of a cryptic p32 Lactococcus promoter grown in 3 liter fermentors produce high extracellular levels of the CGTase proteins. After concentrating, mutant CGTase proteins were purified to homogeneity by affinity chromatography, using an t~cyclodextrin-Sepharose-6FF column. Bound CGTase was eluted with buffer containing ctcyclodextdn. Using these procedures, a single 3-liter fermentor run allowed purification of up to 300 mg of mutant CGTase protein in a 15-60% yield [2, 12, 17]. 2.2. Cyclization Enzyme Assays The CGTase cyclization activities were measured by incubating appropriately diluted enzyme for 5-10 min at 50 ~ with 5% Paselli SA2 (partially hydrolyzed potato starch) in 10 mM sodium citrate (pH 6.0) as substrate. The [3-cyclodextrin formed was determined with phenolphthalein. One unit of activity is defined as the amount of enzyme able to produce 1 I.tmol of 13-cyclodextrin per rain. o~- and ~,-cyclodextrin formation was subsequently measured by HPLC (see below).
168
Figure 3. Reactions catalyzed by CGTase enzymes.
Cyclodextrin formation was also determined under industrial production process conditions. For this purpose 0.1 U/ml CGTase was incubated with 10% jet-cooked starch in a 10 mM sodium citrate buffer (pH 6.0) at 50 ~ for 45 h. Samples were taken at regular time intervals, boiled for 5 min, and the products formed were analyzed by HPLC using a 25 cm EconosilNH2 10 micron column (Alltech Associates Inc., USA) eluted with acetonitrile/water (60/40%, v/v) at a flow rate of 1 ml per min.
3. RESULTS 3.1. CGTase 3D-structure In previous work the B. circulans strain 251 CGTase encoding gene has been cloned, sequenced, and overexpressed in E. coli and B. subtilis. The CGTase protein has been purified, biochemically characterized and crystallized [8, 9]. The crystal structure of the protein has been determined at 2.0/~ resolution, allowing a more detailed analysis of structure-function relationships of this CGTase [9]. The overall fold of the enzyme is presented in Figure 4. The structure of CGTase in our crystal form is essentially the same as that of B. circulans strain 8 described by the group of Schulz [5, 7]. The protein consists of a single polypeptide chain of 686 amino acid residues, forming five domains (A through E). CGTase shares about 30% amino acid sequence identity with or-amylases. The three-dimensional structures of oramylases and CGTases also show clear structural similarity in the N-terminal A-C domains of approximately 400 residues, which folds into an (~/ct)8-barrel structure [6]. However, compared to or-amylases, CGTases have two additional C-terminal domains (D, E-domains) which fold into ~-pleated sheets.
169
=' 43
+
I 143
Figure 4. Ribbon drawing of CGTase from Bacillus circulans strain 251 [9]. Arrows represent ~-strands; coils represent a-helices. The amino and carboxyl termini are labelled n and c, respectively. The domains of CGTase are labelled [A] through [E]. Selected sidechains are drawn to indicate relative positions of sites mentioned in the text: Asp 229, Glu 257, Asp 328 (active centre), Trp 616 and Trp 662 (maltose binding site 1), Tyr 633 (maltose binding site 2), Trp 413 (maltose binding site 3).
Although crystals of the B. circulans strain 251 CGTase protein are grown and maintained in the presence of a-cyclodextrin or maltose [8], we did not find any a-cyclodextrin or other oligosaccharide bound in the active site of the enzyme [9]. From inspection of electron density maps we have identified three carbohydrate binding sites on the surface of the protein, located in each case parallel to the flat surfaces of aromatic rings. In these electron densities a-maltose could be modelled [9]. This indicated that the a-cyclodextrin had been degraded into short linear maltodextrins during the crystallization process. The first maltose binding site is located in the E-domain. Binding of the maltose mainly occurs through hydrophobic contacts of both glucose-rings with the sidechains of Trp 616 and Trp 662. Three direct hydrogen bonds with the protein are made in which both amide- and carbonyl-group of Asn 667 and the N~-group of Lys 651 participate. At this binding site three water molecules form mediating hydrogen bonds between protein and maltose. The second maltose binding site is also located in the E-domain. This maltose molecule is stacked on Tyr 633 with its reducing glucose unit. Hydrogen bonds are made with the Thr 598 Oy, Ala 599 O, Gly 601 N, Gin 602 N, Ash 603 O81 and N82, Ash 627 O51 and N52, Gin 628 Ne2 and Tyr 633 OH. Only one water molecule is hydrogen bonded to this maltose.
170 The third maltose binding site is located in the C-domain. A maltose molecule is stacked with the apolar face of the reducing sugar on the aromatic sidechain of Trp 413. Further binding to the protein is accomplished by 10 hydrogen bonds. Only three hydroxyl groups of the maltose do not participate in hydrogen bonding. Water molecules are often found to form mediating hydrogen bonds between sugar and protein. Four water molecules appear to be bound to both protein and maltose. CGTases bind strongly to raw starch and their amino acid sequences show the raw-starch binding motif proposed by [ 18]. This raw-starch binding motif is located in the E-domain and it reveals eleven strictly conserved residues [9]" Th r598- Gly601-G ly608-Leu613-Gly614-Trp616- Pro634-Trp636-Lys651-Trp662-Asn667 Of these residues Trp 616, Lys 651, Trp 662, Asn 667 and Thr 598, Trp 636 form the first and second maltose binding site, respectively, referred to above. The other strictly conserved residues (Gly 601, Gly 608, Leu 613, Gly 614, Pro 634) are not found to bind directly to maltodextrin, but are probably required for structural support of the raw-starch binding domain. 3.2. The Active Site The mechanism of starch hydrolysis by o~-amylases and CGTases is not very well understood. It is assumed that the catalytic mechanism bears some resemblance to the mechanism proposed for hen egg-white lysozyme: a Glu sidechain which is protonated forms a hydrogen bond with the oxygen in the glycosidic bond, thereby triggering a rearrangement in which the bond between the C1 atom and the glycosidic oxygen is broken. An intermediate is formed which has a positive charge delocalized over a double bond between the C1 and 05 atoms. This positive charge is stabilized by a negatively charged Asp residue. Next a water molecule attacks the C1 atom, forming a new hydroxyl group on the C1 atom. CGTase and amylases, however, possess one Glu and two Asp residues in the active site, instead of one Glu and one Asp residue. In the a-amylase literature all pairs of these acidic residues have been proposed to be the equivalents of the hen egg-white lysozyme Asp/Glu pair involved in hydrolysis. Site-directed mutagenesis of each of these residues in B. subtilis or-amylase [20] and Taka-amylase [ 10] resulted in inactive enzymes. The CGTase active site is present at the wide end of the (13/ot)8-barrel, with catalytic residues Asp 229, Glu 257 and Asp 328 (CGTase numbering). To elucidate the precise function of each of these three carboxylates in the active site, these three residues were replaced by asparagine (D229N, D328N) and glutamine (E257Q), using site-directed mutagenesis. All mutant proteins were purified and crystallized, allowing a detailed comparison of their biochemical properties and 3D structures with those of the wild type protein. The D229N, D328N and E257Q mutations resulted in virtually complete loss of the cyclodextrin forming, liquefying- and saccharifying activities of CGTase. Wild type CGTase and the virtually inactive mutant CGTase proteins have been used in further soaking experiments with for instance cyclodextrins and the pseudotetrasaccharide acarbose (Figure 5), a strong aamylase and CGTase inhibitor [ 16, 17]. The structure of acarbose is very similar to that of maltotetraose (G4). It consists of one normal maltose and one pseudo-maltose residue which is
171 essential for the inhibitory properties [4]. It consists of an unsaturated cyclitol unit (also called valienamine) and a 4-amino-4,6-dideoxyglucose unit.
H2OH~// .o~
~o
IJ
...."
nu H ~ ~ O
B
HO---z'~ HO~ ! 4 .CH2OoH HO
~
~
A
4 CH2OH
Figure 5. Structural formula of acarbose [17]. Arrows mark the four differences between maltotetraose and acarbose: (i) the C6-hydroxyl group of glucose C is absent; (ii) the Oglycosidic bond between residues C and D has been replaced by an N-glycosidic bond; (iii) the 05 oxygen of residue D has been substituted by a carbon atom (C7); (iv) a double bond has been introduced in residue D between the C5 and C7 atoms.
Acarbose was bound near the catalytic residues and this allowed us to analyse how a linear substrate molecule binds in the active site (Figure 6) which provided further insight into the catalytic mechanism of the enzyme [17]. On the basis of our current knowledge we suggest that Glu 257 is the proton donor in the cleavage reaction and Asp 229 serves as the general base or nucleophile, while Asp 328 is important in substrate binding and may be important for elevating the pKa of Glu 257 [17]. The binding mode of acarbose in CGTase differs from that observed in the complex of pancreatic a-amylase with acarbose where the catalytic Glu was found to be hydrogen bonded to the glycosidic nitrogen [ 13]. 3.3. The Cyclization Reaction CGTases and a-amylases both degrade starch by hydrolysis of a(1,4) glycosidic bonds but produce virtually exclusively cyclic and linear products, respectively. The various CGTases studied can be further distinguished as a-, ~- and 7-CGTases on the basis of their main cyclodextrin product. The B. macerans enzyme is the best studied example of an o~-CGTase [19], whereas for instance the B. circulans strain 251 enzyme is a [3-CGTase [8], producing a mixture of 0~-, 13-, and 7-cyclodextrins in a ratio of 13:64:23 [12]. The 13-CGTases are especially of interest since 13-cyclodextrin is most widely applied [15]. 13-Cyclodextrin is separated from the other cyclodextrins using organic solvents, which is expensive. Therefore,
172 Glu 257 I Arg 375
Asp ,328
)
acarbose
interactions
His 233
t//
Lys 232 \
Asp 229 ~His
140
Figure 6. Schematic representation of the interactions of acarbose bound in the active site of CGTase. one of our main goals is to increase the product specificity of CGTase enzymes by means of protein engineering. At present it is unclear what determines the differences in product specificity between the various CGTases (o~-, [3- and ~,-cyclodextrin ratios) and a-amylases (cyclic versus linear malto-oligo-saccharides). Alignment of amino acid sequences of CGTases and a-amylases, and the analysis of the binding mode of the substrate analogue acarbose in the active site cleft [17], suggested that Tyr 195 might play an important role in the cyclization of oligosaccharides. All (x-amylases studied possess a small residue (Gly, Ser, Val) at this position [11], in strong contrast with the large aromatic amino acids (Tyr or Phe) present in all CGTases studied.
Table 1 Specific Enzyme Activities (units/mg) of Bacillus circulans CGTase Proteins [12] Activity Mutants Cyclization Coupling Disproportionation Y 195 280+4 206_+5 620_+70 Y195F 175_+5 84+10 700_+80 Y195W 74_+4 72_+10 650_+70 Y195L 143+6 18+_4 650_+80 Y 195G 22_+3 25_+4 500_+70
Strain 251 Wild Type and Mutant
Saccharifying 3.0+0.5 2.0_+0.5 3.1_+0.5 4.8-+0.5 4.3_+0.5
We have studied the biochemical properties and crystal structures of CGTase mutant proteins in which the Tyr 195 residue had been replaced by Trp, Phe, Leu and Gly, using sitedirected mutagenesis [2, 12]. With some of these mutants the cyclodextrin product ratio clearly changed, as judged from halo-formation around colonies on starch-containing agar plates,
173 activity assays with phenolphthalein, and HPLC analysis of products formed. Mutant proteins therefore were purified and crystallized, and their X-ray structures were determined at 2.5-2.6 A resolution, allowing a detailed comparison of their biochemical properties and threedimensional structures with those of the wild type CGTase protein. The mutant proteins possessed significantly reduced cyclodextrin forming and coupling activities but were not negatively affected in the disproportionation and saccharifying reactions (Table 1). Also under production process conditions, after a 45 h incubation with a 10% starch solution, the Y195W, Y195L and Y195G mutants showed a lower overall conversion of starch into cyclodextrins. These mutants produced a considerable amount of linear oligosaccharides (Table 2). The presence of aromatic amino acids (Tyr or Phe) at the Tyr 195 position thus appears to be of crucial importance for an efficient cyclization reaction, virtually preventing the formation of linear products [ 12].
Table 2 Starch Conversion and Product Specificity of Bacillus circulans Strain 251 Wild Type and Mutant CGTases a Conversion of Conversion of starch into starch into G 1-G4 cyclodextrins (%) Product ratio (%) oligosaccharides (%) Mutants ot ]3 7 Y195 39.3 13 64 23 0 Y195F 38.8 15 64 20 0 Y195W 33.3 18 63 19 2-4 Y195L 24.4 0 86 14 6-10 Y195G 24.8 19 64 17 16-20 aResults of 45 h incubations of CGTase proteins (0.1 unit of 13-cyclodextrin-forming activity per ml) with 10% jet-cooked starch.
4. DISCUSSION In the Netherlands, AVEBE has developed a process for the production of cyclodextrins with the Bacillus circulans strain 251 CGTase, an enzyme which produces predominantly (65 %) 13-cyclodextrin. Selective precipitation steps with organic solvents may be used for the production of the separate or-, [3- or y-cyclodextrins. To avoid these expensive procedures and to be able to produce cyclodextrins with applications involving human consumption, the development of mutant CGTase enzymes that produce only one particular form of cyclodextrin, and are less sensitive to product inhibition, is required. Rational design of such mutants requires detailed knowledge of the three-dimensional structure of the protein, as well as elucidation of the transglycosylation pathway. The work presented provides a farm basis for the construction of specific or-, [3- or 7-CGTase proteins.
174 5. REFERENCES
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21
H. Bender, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 39 (1993) 714. L. Dijkhuizen, D. Penninga, H.J. Rozeboom, B. Strokopytov and B.W. Dijkstra, Proc. 3rd Int. Symp. Perspectives on Protein Engineering, in press. D. French, Adv. Carbohydrate Chem., 12 (1957) 189. F.R. Heiker, H. B6shagen, B. Junge, L. M~ller and J. Stoltefuss, First Intern. Symp. On Acarbose, W. Creutzfeldt (ed.), pp. 137-141, Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam (1981). B.E. Hofmann, H. Bender and G.E. Schulz, J. Mol. Biol., 209 (1989) 793. H.M. Jespersen, E.A. MacGregor, M.R. Sierks and B. Svensson, Biochem. J., 280 (1991) 51. C. Klein and G.E. Schulz, J. Mol. Biol., 217 (1991) 737. C.L.L. Lawson, J. Bergsma, P.M. Bruinenberg, G.E. de Vries, L. Dijkhuizen and B.W. Dijkstra, J. Mol. Biol., 214 (1990) 807. C.L.L. Lawson, R. van Montfort, B. Strokopytov, H.J. Rozeboom, K.H. Kalk, G.E. de Vries, D. Penninga, L. Dijkhuizen and B.W. Dijkstra, J. Mol. Biol, 236 (1994) 590. T. Nagashima, S. Tada, K. Kitamoto, K. Gomi, C. Kumagai and H. Toda, Biosci. Biotechnol. Biochem., 56 (1992) 207. R. Nakajima, T. Imanaka and S. Aiba, Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol., 23 (1986) 355. D. Penninga, B. Strokopytov, H.J. Rozeboom, C.L. Lawson, B.W. Dijkstra, J. Bergsma and L. Dijkhuizen, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 3368. M. Qian, R. Haser, G. Buisson, E. Du6e and F. Payan, Biochemistry, 33 (1994) 6284. W. Saenger, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl., 19 (1980) 344. G. Schmid, Tibtech, 7 (1989) 244. D.D. Schmidt, W. Frommer, B. Junge, L. M~ller, W. Wingender and E. Truscheit, First Intern. Symp. On Acarbose, W. Creutzfeldt (ed.), pp. 5-15, Excerpta Medica, Amsterdam (1981). B. Strokopytov, D. Penninga, H.J. Rozeboom, K.H. Kalk, L. Dijkhuizen and B.W. Dijkstra, Biochemistry, 34 (1995) 2234. B. Svensson, H. Jespersen, M.R. Sierks and E.A. MacGregor, Biochem. J., 264 (1989) 309. T. Takano, M. Fukuda, M. Monma, S. Kobayashi, K. Kainuma and K. Yamane, J. Bacteriol., 166 (1986) 1118. K. Takase, T. Matsumoto, H. Mizuno and K. Yamane, Biochim. Biophys., 1120 (1992) 281. G. Wenz, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. Engl., 33 (1994) 803.
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
175
Oxidation stable amylases for detergents Torben V. Borchert, S0ren F. Lassen, Allan Svendsen and Henrik B. Frantzen Novo Nordisk A/S, Protein Discovery, 2880 Bagsvaerd, Denmark
Abstract The addition of an amylase to detergents would be a possible means for the removal of problematic starch stains during automated dish wash and/or laundry. Bacillus licheniformis alpha-amylase TermamylTM was chosen as the most suitable alpha-amylase for this purpose although this enzyme had to be stabilized to prevent oxidation. We identified one amino acid, viz. methionin in position 197, which is mainly responsible for the instability of the amylase in an oxidative environment. The search for the optimal substitution for methionine 197 is described.
1. INTRODUCTION Enzymes have been used for a number of years as additives for detergents. Proteases have been the main enzymes added to laundry detergents, but more recently also lipases and cellulases have been used for this purpose. Increasing environmental consciousness on the part of consumers has led to low- and medium-temperature laundering becomming more common; coupled with the wide spread use of automatic dishwashers this has resulted in starch soil removal from clothes and porcelain/silverware becomming a difficult task in the household. Even at wash/dishwash temperatures higher than 50 ~ starch is practically insoluble and difficult to remove, and residual starch stains are commonly found. The solution to this problem could be the addition of a suitable amylase to detergents. Laundry washing and dishwashing are performed under conditions which are rather severe from the point of view of enzyme stability, viz. rather high temperature, high pH, and in the presence of strongly oxidizing compounds. Besides being able to withstand this environment, a suitable amylase should also be compatible with surfactants, calcium chelating agents and proteases present in the detergent. The task was to identify the most suitable amylase, and if necessary alter its properties by protein engineering in order to obtain an amylase that would perform well under the prevailing conditions.
176 2. RESULTS Most of the commercially currently available amylases exhibit an optimum of activity at neutral or slightly acidic pH. Figure 1 shows the pH profile of three alpha-amylases from various Bacillus species: TermamylTM from B. licheniformis, BSG TM from B. stearothermophilus, and BAN TM from B. amyloliquefaciens. Both BAN TM and BSG TM have an activity optimum at pH 5, and little, if any, activity can be detected above pH 10. The activity optimum for TermamylTM spans a fairly broad pH range, and this enzyme displays superior performance at a pH of 10.5, which is relevant for automated dishwashing. TermamylTM is additionally extremely thermostable with an activity optimum around 85 ~ at pH 9.0 (data not shown), despite the fact that it originates from a mesophilic Bacillus species. ~>'120 :~O 100 80 "~ 60 .'o 40
m
~
8SG
9
BAN
Termamyl
20
o~
0
3
'
4
5
6
7pH
8
9
10
v
11
Figure 1. PH profile of BAN TM, BSG TM and TermamylTM. The activity of the three amylases of bacterial origin was measured using the Pharmacia Phadebas TM assay [2] at 37 ~ in a slightly modified Britton-Robinson buffer (50 mM of each of phosphoric acid, boric acid, and acetic acid, supplemented with 0.1 mM calcium chlroide). The buffer was adjusted with NaOH to the relevant pH in the range of 4-10.5. Values for the activity of the three amylases are given relative to the highest value measured for that particular enzyme. >, 120
.m
>-9 100
o
~
:3
80 60
~9
40
~-
20 0
9
0
I
5
,
I
10 minutes
9
i
15
9
I
20
,
I
25
9
30
of incubation
Figure 2. Oxidation stability of TermamylTM. The enzyme was incubated at 40 ~ in a 50 mM Britton-Robinson buffer, pH 9.0, supplemented with 200 mM hydrogen peroxide. Samples were withdrawn at the times indicated, diluted 1000-fold, and the residual activity was measured by the Phadebas TM assay. All values are given as a percentage of the activity at time zero.
177
,41--o
~9 140
o
~
r
120
"~
80
z~
e -
--
100
-c "
60
40
I-" 20
o~
o
"
0
5
10 minutes
15 20 of incubation
25
Termamyl M8L M15LM197L M256L M304L M366L M438L
30
Figure 3. Oxidation stability of TermamylTM and leucine-substituted variants thereof. The experiment were carried out as described in the legend to Figure 2.
Other commercially available amylases, such as FungamylTM of fungal origin, were discarded on the basis of their thermal stability and their pH optima. To examine the oxidation stability of TermamylTM, the enzyme was incubated in the presence of 200 mM hydrogen peroxide for periods of up to 30 minutes. Samples were then withdrawn and diluted to stop the oxidation process, and the residual activity was determined as shown in Figure 2. Rapid oxidative inactivation of the enzyme is observed, and it is clear that this behavior of the protein would limit its application in detergents. The most oxidation-labile amino acid residues in proteins are cysteine and methionine [1], both of which contain sulphur. TermamylTM contains seven methionines but no cysteines.We have substituted the seven methionines, located in positions 8, 15, 197,256, 304, 366 and 438 of the mature protein, with leucine residues. Leucine was chosen as it is a fairly conservative substitution for methionine. The oxidation stability of the resulting seven TermamylTM variant proteins was evaluated by incubation in the presence of 200 mM hydrogen peroxide, and the results are shown in Figure 3. Only one substitution, M197L, had a significant effect on the oxidation stability of the enzyme. During a 30 minute incubation with hydrogen peroxide no loss of activity could be detected; it appears, in fact, that TermamylTM becomes slightly activated by the presence of hydrogen peroxide; an observation we cannot presently explain. In order to identify the optimal amino acid replacement of methionine197, a series of amino acid substitutions in this position was constructed. In addition to leucine, the following amino acids were introduced in position 197: Ala, Cys, Phe, Gly, His, Ile, Ash, Gln, Ser, Thr, and Val. The introduction of a cysteine residue in position 197 creates an enzyme more susceptible to oxidation than the native enzyme, whereas the other substitutions have identical effects on the oxidation stability of the protein: the enzymatic activity of the variant protein is constant or becomes slightly elevated during the 30 minute incubation under oxidizing conditions. The oxidation profile of a selection of the variants is shown in Figure 4. Although a number of amino acid substitutions in position 197 results in an enhancement of the oxidation stability of TermamylTM, significant differences are observed in the specific activity measured under standard non-oxidative conditions at pH 7.3 and 37 ~ (Figure 4). All variants tested display decreased activity compared to the native enzyme. The decrease in specific activity is especially marked when amino acids with bulky side chains are introduced in
178 position 197. Substitution with histidine and phenylalanine residues causes a decrease in specific activities of more than 90% and 80%, respectively, compared to the native enzyme. Amino acids with smaller side chains, such as glycine and alanine, cause less decrease and the resulting variants have almost the same specific activity as the native enzyme. There seems to be a roughly inverse relationship between the volume of the amino acid in position 197 and the specific activity of the variant, as indicated in Figure 6. Interestingly, the methionine (with a volume of 124 /~a) found in the native enzyme, and the wild type TermamylTM specific activity of 7000 NU/mg result in a data point that does not fit into the relationship observed for the complete series of substitutions in position 197.
140
m
-> 9 120
o
100
8O "o 60 ~9 !.----
M197L M197A M197C M197V M197F M197Q Termamyl
---a,
40 20
0
5
10
15
20
25
minutes of incubation
30
Figure 4. Oxidation stability of TermamylTM and a selection of position 197 variants thereof. The experiments were carried out as described in the legend to Figure 2.
.,.,.,.,
>9 O 0
,,.,.,.
0
6
4 2
Q. 0 CO
M
A
F
G
H
L
N
O
A m i n o a c i d at p o s i t i o n
S
197
T
V
Figure 5. Specific activity of TermamylTM (M) and its variants in position 197. The activity of TM the enzymes were measured in a slightly modified Pharmacia Phadebas assay: 50 mM Britton-Robinson buffer, pH 7.3, temperature 37 ~ The reference was TermamylTM (M) with a specific activity of 7000 NU/mg. Amino acids are given by the one-letter denotation.
179 7 6 >
5
0
4
, , m
0 0 CD Q..
r~
3 2 1 0 40
60
80
Volume
100
120
140
A 3
Figure 6. The specific activity of the position 197 variant proteins as a function of the volume of the amino acid in position 197 based on van der Waals radii [3].
3. CONCLUSION We have identified an amino acid which is mainly responsible for the instability of the alphaamylase Termamyl TM towards oxidation. Among the seven methionine residues in this alphaamylase, the methionine in position 197 is the major source of oxidation lability. The optimal substitution for methionine 197 with respect to specific activity is to be found among less bulky amino acids. Furthermore, we have shown that the amino acid residue in position 197 has a tremendous influence on the function of the enzyme.
4. REFERENCES Y. Shecthter et al., Biochemistry, 14 (1975) 4497. Pharmacia Diagnostics AB, 51-0073-00/02. F.M. Richards, J. Mol. Biol., 82 (1974) 1.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
S.B. Petersen, B. Svensson, and S. Pedersen (Eds), CarbohydrateBioengineering 9 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.
181
Electrostatic studies of carbohydrate active enzymes Antonio Baptista l, Trygve Brautaset 2, Finn DrablOsl, Paulo Martel 3, Svein Valla2 and Steffen B. Petersen 1. 1MR-Center, SINTEF UNIMED, N-7034 Trondheim, Norway. WWW: http ://www.mr. sintef.no 2UNIGEN, University of Trondheim, N-7034 Trondheim, Norway 3ITQB, Oeiras, Portugal
Abstract Most charged or titratable residues reside on the protein surface. Each of such residues will exhibit a titration behaviour that is dependent on the local context around the residue. As a consequence both pH, salt and docking of a ligand into the binding cavity of a protein can be expected to alter the protein electrostatics. Electrostatic interactions are the most long range interactions known. It is widely believed that protein electrostatics plays a major role in the recognition between a protein and its ligand(s). In the present chapter we cover the basic theory of protein electrostatics and illustrate in two case stories how electratic based effects may provide important clues in the interpretation of pH activity profiles for the acid and Taka amylases, as well as in the prediction of functional consequences of protein engineering on
Acetobacter xylinum. 1. INTRODUCTION Over the last couple of decades major advances have been made in the understanding of protein structural determination. Initially all contributions came from X-ray diffraction analysis, but lately also multidimensional NMR spectroscopy has proven a valuable tool for the determination of protein 3D structures, although linewidth and dispersion at the moment restricts NMR to relatively small water soluble proteins with a molecular weight not exceeding 30 KD. Today about 1000 protein 3D structures have been determined, and we have learned that many proteins fold into the same 3D fold, despite the fact that they may have little or no detectable sequence homology. Good examples for such proteins are the hemoglobins and the triglyceride lipases, which adapt a packed (x-helix bundle and the characteristico~/]3 - hydrolase fold respectively. This impressive amount of 3D information has provided us with atomic
182 information about the structural basis for protein function. However, in order to understand molecular recognition (docking) and salt and pH dependent phenomena a more elaborate picture need to be developed that also includes the effects the electric force fields that are caused by charged residues at the protein surface. In the present chapter we will present the basic concept of protein electrostatics and we will present two case studies: 1) we will attempt to explain semi-quantitatively why the pH optimum of the acid cx-amylase is shifted towards acidic pH values as compared to the normal neutral cx-amylase. 2) we will illustrate that electrostatics are of major importance in the function of phosphoglucomutase, and through point-mutations prove that such residues are indeed central to enzyme function. The present chapter does not claim that protein electrostatics is the sole important factor that determines protein function, and its variation with physical chemical parameters such as pH, temperature and salt. It is clear that other complex factors must be considered as well, such as quantum mechanical as well as molecular dynamics effects. Work is in progress in various labs including our own addressing these aspects. Here however, we will concentrate on the role of protein electrostatics in protein function.
2. BASIC CONCEPTS OF PROTEIN ELECTROSTATICS 2.1. The role of electrostatics Protein function always depends on the encounter of two or more molecules: substrateenzyme, ligand-receptor, etc. These molecular encounters are the final stage of a diffusional process where attractive interactions have to overcome the random effects of thermal agitation. Given the magnitude and long-ranged nature of electrostatic interactions, it is not surprising that they can play a determinant role in this process, by steering and/or orienting the incoming molecule [ 1]. In the case of enzymes a further functional requirement is the stabilization of the reaction intermediate, without which they could not act as catalysts. Also here electrostatic interactions are of major importance, with the residues of the active site stabilizing the intermediate charge distribution [2]. A much more basic condition for protein function is the existence of a properly folded structure. The hydrophobic effect, usually assumed to be the most determinant factor in the overall folding process, is essentially a consequence of the fact that polar and, specially, charged residues are electrostatically more stable when interacting with water than with the more apolar protein interior. Also, the hydrogen bonding responsible for protein secondary structure is basically the result of electrostatic interactions. Thus, electrostatic interactions occupy a special place among the factors governing protein function and stability, and its proper understanding and modeling is of major importance. The sources of electrostatic interactions in proteins are charged titrable residues (Asp, Glu, His, Lys, Arg, C- and N-terminii, Tyr and free Cys), structural ions (eg, Mg 2+ in PGM), bound ions, solution counterions, etc. In the following section we present some of the models that may be used to compute the electrostatic interactions arising from these charges and to relate them with protein functional features. General reviews of protein electrostatics are Warshel & Russel (1984) [3], Matthew (1985) [4], Rogers (1986) [5], Harvey (1989) [6], Sharp & Honig (1990) [7], Davies & McCammon (1990) [1]. An aspect which is almost impossible to dissociate from protein electrostatics is the effect of pH, because of the charge variability of titrable residues. The sometimes dramatic functional
183 dependence of protein function on pH is a result of the protonation and deprotonation of these residues, which can lead to pronounced changes in the interplay of electrostatic interactions. At first the theoretical task of explaining and predicting such electrostatic changes upon pH may seem straightforward - given the pKa of the titrable residues (available in any biochemistry handbook) it would be a trivial matter to say which residues are charged at a given pH. Unfortunately, the situation is far more complicated because, as explained below, the pK~ may be shifted by several pH units from its typical value. In fact, even the usual concept of pKa becomes inappropriate. Thus, to decide the charge to be assigned to a residue at a given pH one has to resort to fairly more complex methods, as discussed below. 2.2. Electrostatic models There are several approaches to model electrostatic interactions in proteins. The most natural one is to use Coulomb's law to describe the electrostatic force between pairs of charges. This is how electrostatic effects are modeled in molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, probably the most familiar simulation method used with biomolecules, where they are just one type of force among many others, which together determine the dynamical behavior of the protein. Although a complete knowledge of the dynamics can in principle lead to an understanding of most other properties, in practice this kind of simulation may take prohibitive computation times and require an elaborated analysis of the results. Furthermore, some important aspects of electrostatic effects cannot be easily included in a MD simulation. In particular, a fixed charge has to be assigned to each titrable group, which may be a dramatic simplification at pH values where partial protonation exists. In this chapter we will focus on the use of another type of models, where dynamical features are included in an implicit manner. The rationale behind these models is that macroscopic electrostatic concepts such as dielectric constants or continuous charge distributions reflect the microscopic dynamics of charges and dipoles, so that the atomic description of the protein may be replaced, at least partially, with a macroscopic-like picture. Thus, though a molecular system is being deal with, a macroscopic language is adopted and quantitative aspects can be handled using classical continuum electrostatics. Actually, only solvent dynamics are considered, the protein being considered in a single conformation, usually the average one obtained from NMR or X-ray diffraction studies. The simplest macroscopic model assumes that charges in the protein, either from titrable residues or permanent ions, interact through a medium characterized by a single dielectric constant. This approach cannot account for the fact that these two regions have very different dielectric properties. The dielectric constant reflects the orientation of dipoles induced by the local electric field. Two types of dipoles contribute to the global value: permanent and induced. Permanent dipoles arise from an unequal distribution of charge among neighbor bonded atoms, as in the peptide bond or the water molecule. Induced dipoles are due to the deformation of electron clouds be the electric field, an effect called electronic polarization. The orientation of the high permanent dipole of the relatively free water molecules gives rise to a high dielectric constant (-80). In contrast, permanent dipoles in the protein interior are virtually fixed and the orientation of the low dipoles arising from polarization lead to a much smaller value (2-4). The use of a single dielectric constant somewhere between these values is not realistic, since the use of a low value overestimates the interaction of charges at the protein surface, and the use of a high value underestimates the interaction of buried ones. Furthermore, a more subtle but nevertheless very important point is that the electrostatic interaction between a pair of charges
184 does not occur along the straight line connecting them. Instead, electric field lines travel in curved paths over all space, and apparently paradoxical situations may result - eg, two charged residues on opposite sides of a protein may interact with an electrostatic energy characteristic of a dielectric constant even higher than the solvent one. The use of a single dielectric constant cannot possibly account for this kind of effects. A more realistic approach is to explicitly consider that the protein and solvent regions have different local dielectric constants. This means that the interactions can no longer be computed using Coulomb's law. Instead, the Poisson equation of the system of charges and dielectrics has to be solved. In addition to the protein charges, an atmosphere of counterions can be considered around the protein, as in the Debye-Huckel theory of electrolytes; in this case the equation to be solved is the Poisson-Boltzmann one, usually in its linear form. The nature of the solution of either the Poisson or Poisson-Boltzmann equations depends on the particular model being adopted. If the model has some geometrical symmetry an analytical solution may be possible. Otherwise, one has to resort to numerical methods, usually much more demanding in terms of computer time. A simple approximation is to consider the protein to be a sphere with the charges placed at a small distance beneath the surface and surrounded by an ionic atmosphere. For this spherical model it is possible to obtain an analytical solution to the Poisson-Boltzmann equation [8]. Despite the fact that in general proteins will deviate more or less from sphericity, this model was shown to usually give satisfactory results [4], specially when the interactions are corrected according to the solvent-accessibility of the residues [9]. This is probably due to the fact that the shielding effect created by the solvent can be reasonably included even if some surface details are neglected. However, the electrostatic energies obtained with this model include charge-charge interactions but not the so-called selfenergies, which arise from the presence of charges deeply buried into the protein, a situation which, although rare, do occur in some cases. The more detailed approach is to consider explicitly the protein shape and use numerical methods to solve the electrostatic problem. The more common method in use is finite differences, though other methods have also been used (see, e.g. [1], and references therein). Given the atomic detail of these models, it is particularly interesting to compute the electrostatic potential around the protein, which can be conveniently displayed using equipotential surfaces. This representation can be very useful in establishing the relation of functional aspects with pH (see below). The computation of the self-energies is not a problem in these models. Although in the foregoing discussion we have implicitly assumed the protein molecule to be surrounded by water, nothing in the physical assumptions of the models precludes their use with other solvents. An organic solvent will have a much lower dielectric constant, comparable to the one of the protein, leading to a much lower shielding of the interactions, ie, the electrostatic interactions will be much more strong and far reaching than in an aqueous solution. Another variable shielding effect arises from the presence of counterions, ie, shielding also depends on ionic strength. The detailed models using numerical methods can easily be extend to consider different dielectric regions outside the protein, so that, eg, membrane proteins can be simulated in this way [10]. This dielectric regions can correspond to fixed or transient molecular structures. The binding/unbinding of the latter may in principle act as a modulating mechanism of electrostatic interactions, as exemplified below with carbohydrates.
185
2.3. pH-dependent electrostatics As referred to above, there exists a natural and close dependency of electrostatics upon pH. Has we then pointed out, the assignment of charge to the titrable residues may be problematic, since the pK, of a residue may be shifted from its typical value by several pH units. There are two main reasons for these shifts. One is the fact that the protein dielectric environment is different from the one experienced by a model compound (ie, an analogue having the same titrable group as the residue) in solution, to which the tabulated values refer. If a residue is buried into the mainly apolar interior of the protein, its charged form will be more unstable than in the case of a single residue or model compound in direct contact with water, and its pK, will be shifted in the direction of favoring the neutral form. The pKa value resulting from this shift (and assuming an otherwise neutral protein) is usually referred to as the intrinsic pKa [8] and may differ from the model value by several pH units. However, most titrable residues are at the protein surface and its intrinsic pKa's are usual roughly identical to the model pKa's. Yet, another cause for pKa shifts exists for both buried and exposed residues: the interaction with other charges in the protein. The positive form of a titrable residue (Arg, Lys, His, Nterminus) will be more stable/unstable due to the presence of a nearby negative/positive charge, and conversely for a negative form (Asp, Glu, Tyr, free Cys, C-terminus). If these neighbor charges also belong to titrable residues, this pKa shift (and thus the pKa itself) becomes pHdependent. Therefore, one can no longer speak of the pKa of a residue in the usual sense of the value that uniquely characterizes the equilibrium of its two forms at all pH values. Instead, one usually defines an apparent pKa as the pH value at which the residue is half-protonated (ie, at which half of the protein molecules have that residue protonated). (In some extremely anomalous cases even this concept becomes useless, since the half charge may exist at several pH values.) From a theoretical standpoint, the (pH-dependent) pK.~ of a given residue in a given protein may be written as
1 pK = PKmoaeI - ~ A A G w ~ 2.3RT
P
where PKmode I is the pKa of the corresponding model compound in water and AAGw~ t, is the change in free energy for the titration reaction when one moves the residue from water to the protein. This change can be split into the two contributions corresponding to the effects discussed above:
AAGw_~e =
AAGenvironmen t + AGinteractio n
where AAGenvironmen t is the contribution due to moving the residue from water into the neutral protein and AGinteractio n is the contribution due to the interaction with other charged residues. The fin'st term may be obtained by assuming a thermodynamic cycle involving the protonated and unprotonated forms of the residue in both the protein and the solution and computing the free energy terms using the electrostatic models discussed above [11]. For most (exposed) residues, however, this term can be simply assumed to be zero. The t e r m AGinteraction can also be obtained from electrostatic calculations, but one cannot simply assign a fixed charge to the
186 other residues, because at certain pH values some of them may have significant populations of
both protonation forms. Another way of stating the problem is to say that a protein with N titrable residues has 2N possible global charge sets, and that its titration behavior reflects the relative populations of all these sets at each pH value [8] [11]. The computation of all the 2N charge set populations is very demanding and several approximate methods have been suggested [12] [13] [14] [15]. The most simplifying approach is to assume that, although interacting, the residues titrate independently of each other, an approximation which can lead to errors only if strongly interacting residues titrate in the same pH region [12]. When this approximation is used the above interaction term reduces to [ 11] [ 16]. AGinteractio n
=-2g%zj 1 2 i jr
where Wij is the electrostatic interaction between a pair of unitary charges placed at residues i and j and zj is the mean charge of residue j at the considered pH. Therefore, the pK, of a residue i is given by 1
p K i = P K i,imr - ~ ~ Wij z j 2 . 3 R T i*i
where pKi.mu is its intrinsic pKa. The usual procedure is to use the previous equation and the Henderson-Hasselbach equation and compute alternately the pKa's and mean charges until selfconsistency [16]. We will use this approach to compute mean charges at several pH values, with the Wij terms computed with the aforementioned spherical model and corrected for the solvent accessibility, a procedure usually called the modified Tanford-Kirkwood method [9]. Once the residue mean charges are known at a given pH value, one can use those charges in an electrostatic calculation using a numerical method, as described above, and compute the electrostatic potential around the protein molecule. The potential thus obtained corresponds to the mean potential existing at the considered pH value. By repeating this procedure one can obtain a pH-dependent electrostatic profile of the molecule, as done for the PGM study presented below. 2.4. Carbohydrates as electrostatic modulators
The binding of a carbohydrate molecule to a protein may influence the function of the latter in various ways. Usually one tends to focus on induced conformational changes of the protein. However, though conformational changes may lead to pronounced functional differences, purely electrostatic effects also arise and in some cases they may be of more importance than the former (which may not even occur). The most obvious case is when the carbohydrate brings one or more new charges to the protein charge system (eg, glucose-6-phosphate in PGM). Besides being an addition to the existing charge set, the new charge(s) will influence neighbor titrable residues and eventually shift their pKa values, which will result in new mean charges at a given pH value. The pH-dependence of electrostatic interactions may be further modified if the charged carbohydrate is itself titrable. Even when the carbohydrate does not bear a formal charge, it will change the dielectric environment upon binding. A region previously filled with water (assuming no extensive
187 conformational changes) will be occupied by a much lower dielectric medium. This may act on the electrostatics through two different routes. In the first place the binding may cause a total or partial burying of some titrable residues of the protein, causing their intrinsic pH values (see above) to change and thereby shifting their pKa's. Secondly, it will modify the interaction of previous existing charges, by modifying the path of electric field lines. For example, two neighbor charged residues on the surface will in general have their interaction increased if a carbohydrate binds between them, eventually leading to further shifting of their pKa's. The new balance of electrostatic interactions arising from carbohydrate binding may affect the steering and/or orientation of other approaching molecules. For example, a different approach and docking of an incoming substrate may lead to a different reaction rate, if the latter is diffusion-limited. Similar effects may occur with cofactors, effectors, etc. Since further pK,, shifts may occur, the magnitude of the electrostatic changes varies with pH, so that the pH-dependent functional profile of the protein may change as well. In conclusion, carbohydrates may act as versatile electrostatic modulators of protein function even when their binding induce few or none conformational changes on the protein molecule.
3. ELECTROSTATIC PROPERTIES OF oc-AMYLASES The a-amylases are endohydrolases acting on 0c-l,4-glucosidic bonds of starch and related dextrins [17] . They are retaining hydrolases, which means that the stereochemistry at the chiral centers that were linked by the cleaved bond is retained after hydrolysis. Structurally the a-amylases consist of a (13Rz)8-barrel fold succedded by a y-crystalline-type domain of unknown function (Fig. 1). The active site is formed by loops at the C-terminal ends of the barrel l-strands. The amylases may have quite different pH optimum with respect to catalytic activity, e.g. Taka amylase has a pH optimum close to 7.0, whereas the optimum for acid amylase is closer to 4.5. In order to identify possible explanations for the difference in pH optimum for (z-amylases, we have looked at the structures of acid amylase [ 18] and Taka amylase [ 19].
3.1. Experimental The two structures were aligned into identical orientations superimposing the backbone atoms. The charge distributions at various pH values were computed using the Titra program (to be published). The charge of the primary Ca ++ ion was fixed to 2.0, the charge of the secondary Ca ++ ion was fixed to 0.0. A solid molecular surface representation of the molecules was generated using the Grasp program [20], and the electrostatic potential at the surface was computed using the electrostatic model of Grasp (which is based on the DelPhi program [21] ) with charges from the Titra computations. The residues belonging to the active site region were identified using the "scribing" feature of Grasp. 3.2. Results The simulated titration curves for the two amylases (Fig. 2) do show a small shift of the Taka amylase towards a less acidic situation. However, for most of the pH range the difference
188
Figure 1. The structure of Taka amylase. The two Ca ++ ions are shown as yellow spheres. The trace of the structure is color coded according to the intron-exon pattern of the Taka amylase gene (Gines et al., 1989), so that the sequence corresponding to each exon has a distinct color. The orientation of the molecule is the same as for Fig. 3. The figure was generated using the Molscript program [34].
189
Figure 2. Simulated titration curve for acid amylase and Taka amylase, computed using the Titra program.
190
Figure 3. Electrostatic potential at the molecular surface for acid amylase (left) and Taka amylase (fight) at the pH values 2.0 (top), 4.0 (upper middle), 6.0 (lower middle) and 8.0 (bottom). Blue color represents positive potential, red color negative potential. The yellow sphere represents the binding site for the scondary Ca ++ ion, this ion has been assigned a charge of 0.0 in the electrostatic computations, and it has not been included in the surface rendering.
191
Figure 4. Simulated titration curve for the active site environment, based on the simulated titration data from Fig. 2.
192 in the charge properties for these two molecules seems to be rather small, and it is difficult to predict any significant change in pH otimum based on these data. If we look at the electrostatic potential at the molecular surface (Fig. 3) the difference seems to be more obvious. At pH 4.0 there is a significant charge polarity of the bottom of the active site pocket of the acid amylase, wheras for the Taka amylase most of this pocket is strongly positive. As we move past pH 6.0 towards a more neutral environment, we see that we get an increasing polarisation of the active site pocket of the Taka amylase, whereas the acid amylase is moving towards a situation with a strong negative charge in the pocket. If we postulate that the charge polarity is an essential feature of the amylase active site pocket, then this difference between the acid and the Taka amylase seems to explain very much of the difference in pH optimum between the enzymes. In order to identify the residues responsible for this difference the atoms of the active site pocket were identified using the scribing feature of Grasp. The surface of the pocket up to the upper edge between the pocket and the exposed surface was made into a separate surface, and residues close to this surface were identified by two different approaches. In the first approach residues with atoms within 5.0 /~ from the surface were included (Table 1). In the second approach only residues with atoms in direct contact with the surface were included (Table 2). As can be seen,