Bioengineering
Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Bloengi neering
Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics ROBERT J. NIKOLA...
132 downloads
1793 Views
8MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Bioengineering
Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Bloengi neering
Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics ROBERT J. NIKOLAI, Ph.D. Professor, Department of Orthodontics St. Louis University Medical Center St. Louis, Missouri
Foreword by CHARLES J. BURSTONE
LEA & FEBIGER
PHILADELPHIA
1985
LEA & FEBIGER
600 South Washington Square Philadelphia, PA 191064198 U.S.A. (215)922-1330
Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Nikolai, Robert J. Bioengineering analysis of orthodontic mechanics Bibliography: p. Includes index.
1. Orthodontic appliances. 2. Force and energy. 3. Bioengineering. I. Title. [DNLM: 1. Biomedical engineering. 2. Orthodontic appliances. 3. Orthodontics. WU 400 N693b] RK527.N54 1984 617.643 84-5712 ISBN 0-8121-0922-8
Copyright © 1985 by Lea & Febiger. Copyright under the Inter-
national Copyright Union. All Rights Reserved. This book is protected by copyright. No part of it may be reproduced in any manner or by any means without written permission of the Publisher. Prioted in the United States of America
Print Number:
5
4
3
2
1
To My Parents
Foreword
The advancement of orthodontics and the quality of orthodontic treat-
ment are dependent upon a thorough knowledge of basic science. Although there are many orthodontic texts that cover the biologic basic sciences, such as growth and development, neuromuscular physiology, genetics, and anatomy, considerably less attention has been paid to bioengineering. Certainly no basic science could be more relevant to the orthodontic researcher and to the practicing orthodontist than bioengineering. Dr. Nikolai has written the first comprehensive text that can serve as a keystone to the understanding of bioengineering principles in general and their application to clinical orthodontics.
This text develops the fundamental concepts in an orderly way which will allow the orthodontist to understand and use his orthodontic appliances. Since most dentists in their predoctoral training receive little information relative to bioengineering, the development of basic concepts and their application is most important and necessary before moving on to more complicated clinical situations. The sequential presentation of material from the elementary principles to the more complicated force systems of multibanded appliances will allow both student and practitioner to gain a better understanding of how orthodontic appliances work and how to improve clinical therapy based on this understanding. Bioengineering has a broad application to orthodontics and, hence, the scope of the text is very wide. It includes a discussion of the force systems produced from orthodontic appliances, the behavior of the materials that are used, and correlates the relationship between the torce systems and the biologic changes that occur in the dentition and periodontium. The excellent use of clinical problems and examples through-
out the text insures that this is not just another engineering text, but truly a book on orthodontic bioengineering, which can serve both the student and the experienced practitioner. CHARLES J. BURSTONE, D.D.S., M.S. Professor and Head Department of Orthodontics School of Dental Medicine The University of Connecticut vii
Preface
As viewed by the observant bioengineer, the orthodontic appliance is a
unique assembly of small, structural elements. When activated, the appliance exerts a system of forces upon the human dentition. These forces cause, or at least serve to catalyze, biologic remodeling within the dentofacial complex toward achievement of finite, permanent displacements of teeth. From both structural and clinical perspectives, the principal component of the fixed, intraoral appliance is the arch wire. This wire is currently available to the clinician in at least five materials (metal alloys), round and rectangular cross-sections in various sizes, single- and mul-
tistrand formats, and in straight lengths or precontoured into arch forms. Prior to engagement and activation the practitioner may bend or twist the wire, using special tools to place or modify the arch form and detail the wire geometry to the specific patient. The appliance contacts the dentition through crown-affixed brackets and tubes, and the structural assembly may also include various kinds of metallic springs and polymeric elements to exert forces. Moreover, extraoral adjuncts may contribute to the total appliance.
The complexity of the orthodontic appliance as a structure is extended through its dynamic behavior and that of its foundation, the dentition; over time the appliance deactivates slowly in concert with movements within the biologic complex to which it is attached. The overall analysis requires an integrated examination of the appliance and the force system it delivers to the dentition. The characteristics of that delivered force system influence the format of the potential displacements of the teeth. The interested bioengineer now envisions a multifaceted analysis problem. The experienced practitioner, as well as the clinician-in-training, perhaps viewing structural analysis as "foreign territory," should gain some familiarity with the engineering of the orthodontic appliance, and this text has been prepared to assist in that education. Herein the subjects of force and structural analysis are discussed within the framework of practical, orthodontic treatment and at a level appropriate to the
intended audience. The presentation is seemingly theoretical for the most part, although much of the theory has been demonstrated to be ix
x
Preface
well founded through bench and clinical experimentation. The topic
coverage is largely a composite of analytic and graphical mechanics, materials science, and mechanics of deformable bodies (subject titles familiar to the engineering student), but presented with minimal mathematical involvement and with direct application to orthodontics. Substantial attention is given to the interactions between the activated appliance and the biologic systems and processes affected by the transmitted force.
This text is an outgrowth of class notes prepared and carefully revised, over a period in excess of ten years, for a bioengineering course presented to first-year students in an orthodontics graduate program. Not only intended for students, the book should serve the interested, experienced practitioner as well, whether or not previously exposed to formalized graduate or continuing-education coursework in orthodontic biomechanics. Because examples are used throughout, the text as-
sumes at least superficial familiarity with orthodontic therapy that would be gained, for example, through an introductory or survey exposure within the professional dental curriculum. Principles and procedures accumulate from the start in the book, but no preparation in mathematics and science, beyond traditional predental and dental curricula, are required. The text begins with a discussion of needed mathematical "tools." The subsequent three chapters introduce concepts of engineering mechanics in the orthodontic setting. Con-
sidered next is the response to applied force of the dentition and its supporting tissues. Structural analysis procedures are then introduced and applied to simple appliance elements. Chapters are devoted, individually, to bending and torsional analyses of arch wires and to extraoral appliances. Finally, force and structural analyses of entire representative orthodontic mechanics are undertaken.
Orthodontic bioengineering is becoming widely recognized as an important area of formal study for the aspiring clinician. The design and preparation of appliances have been traditionally learned from preceptors, and refined through actual clinical experience. Recent advances in appliances and techniques, however, have resulted from the joint contributions of practitioner expertise and engineering science. Although the latter has demonstrated its potential impact toward overall advance-
ment of orthodontic treatment, the organized application of bioengineering to orthodontics remains relatively obscure, apparently, to the majority of practitioners. Accordingly, the objective in preparing this text was to provide a means whereby a bioengineering approach to the analysis and design of orthodontic appliances and procedures might be outlined to the orthodontic community. Several individuals have intangibly, although importantly, contributed to the completion of this work. Vasil Vasileff, now retired from the School of Dental Medicine at Southern Illinois University, and formerly a faculty member at the St. Louis University Medical Center, presented
the author with his first opportunity to interact with graduate orthodontics students. Kenneth Marshall, former Chairman of the Depart-
xi Preface
ment of Orthodontics, hired and charged the author, trained in engi-
neering rather than in dentistry, to develop the bioengineering course within the graduate curriculum. Lysle Johnston, present Chairman of the Department, through his urging and encouragement, was instrumental in making this text, begun in earnest during a sabbatical leave, a reality. The author would be remiss without acknowledging the influence of
the students in the graduate orthodontics program at St. Louis University, particularly those whose thesis research projects he has supervised; their comments, criticisms, and suggestions were of substantial aid in this effort. Finally, to Charles Burstone, eminent researcher, clinician, and educator, who kindly consented to contribute the foreword to this text, the author expresses his sincere gratitude. ROBERT J. NIKOLAI, Ph.D. St. Louis, Missouri
Contents
1. Mathematical Topics Constants, variables, and functions 1 Frames of reference 3 Displacements of particles and solid bodies Trigonometry
8
10
An introduction to vector algebra 16 Dimensions and units 20 Measurements, computations, and numerical accuracy
21
2. Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
24
Mechanics 24 Force 25
Vector addition and decomposition of concentrated forces 29 The moment of a concentrated force 36 The couple 40 Resultants of force systems exerted on rigid bodies 46 Distributed forces and their resultants 50 Friction
53
Concepts of mechanical equilibrium and their applicability to orthodontic mechanics 56 Synopsis
69
3. Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Internal structure of a solid material 73 Load-deformation behavior of a structural member 78 Mechanical stress 87 Mechanical and structural properties: Standardized testing Chemical and thermal influences 103 Selection of materials 110
71
91
xlii
xiv Contents
4. Energy Analyses in Orthodontics Concepts leading to the process laws Displacement 114
113 114
Mechanical work 115 Energy 117
Heat transfer and thermal energy 121 The conservation-of-energy law 122 Available energy 124 Activation and deactivation processes 125 Strain hardening and heat treatment of metals and alloys A work-energy analysis of the preparation of an arch wire Synopsis 144
5. Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
137 141
146
Mechanical response of the individual tooth to applied
force
148
Transverse crown force systems and tooth displacements Extrusion, intrusion, and long-axis rotation 163 Response of the periodontium to force 169 Displacements related to magnitude and duration of force Controlling the force-time pattern 178 Physiologically proper orthodontic forces 182 Dentofacial Orthopedics 189 Synopsis 191
151
177
6. Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic
Appliance
194
orthodontic appliance: A structure or a machine? 196 Attachment of the orthodontic appliance to the dentition 197 A continuous-arch-wire appliance model 205 The
An overview of the structural analysis of an orthodontic appliance 208 The activation and deactivation characteristics of representative appliance elements 211 The action and response of tip-back bends: An illustration of the four-step procedure in orthodontic structural analysis 224 "Control" of the orthodontic appliance 228 Synopsis 231 7. Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
deformations, strains, and stresses 235 Force systems within the beam 241 Beam
Beam stiffnesses 248
233
xv Contents
Additional topics in elastic bending 252
Application of elastic beam theory to orthodontic arch-wire activation in bending 257 Inelastic behavior in bending 261 Orthodontic wire loops 264 Synopsis
269
8. Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance Structural theory for the straight, circular shaft
272
273
Extension of theory to shafts having rectangular cross-sections 285
Application of shaft theory to the orthodontic arch wire 288 Isolation of the activating torque 288 Responses of the appliance and the dentition to torsional activation 289
Structural influences on active and responsive force systems 295 Anterior-segment torquing mechanics 299 Rectangular-wire torquing 299 Torquing spurs in the appliance 305 Inelastic behavior in third-order mechanics 310 Wire loops, springs, and torsion 314 Synopsis 318 9. Extraoral Appliances
322
The cervical-pull, face-bow appliance Occiusal-plane analysis 326
325
Buccal-view analysis of the cervical appliance
335
A coronal-plane view and comments on the asymmetric problem 343 Canine retraction with headgear 344 Extraoral force delivered to an anterior segment or an entire arch
348
Delivery of extraoral force to the mandibular arch 358 Dual-force headgear 361 The chin-cap assembly 362 Reverse-pull appliances 365 Synopsis 369
10. Force and Structural Analyses of Representative Orthodontic Mechanics Individual tooth malalignments Leveling displacements 374
374
372
xvi Contents
Rotational corrections
379
Bilateral action 385 Interarch mechanics 388 Intra-arch vertical positioning 392 Intra-arch retraction mechanics 402
Prepared, posterior-segment anchorage 412 Class III mechanics 417 Class II mechanics 424 Synopsis 435
Appendix I Glossary of Terms
437
Appendix II List of Symbols
458
Index
463
Mathematical Topics I Orthodontic bioengineering has emerged as an important subfield of
orthodontics, not only for research but for formal study by the practitioner-in-training as well as the experienced clinician. Bioengineering is appropriately termed an "applied science" and, as such, uses numerous mathematical concepts and procedures. This chapter introduces and explores the mathematical topics required in this text. These developments are not unduly rigorous and most will not be totally new to the reader. Familiarization with the necessary mathematics is undertaken initially in this text, rather than to introduce each topic individually as the need arises. As necessary, the reader may refer back to this chapter for a review of any specific concept. Moreover, a foundation is laid for uninterrupted and continuous study of the principles and applications of bioengineering to orthodontics.
Constants, Variables, and Functions Any object having physical attributes or characteristics may be described
qualitatively or quantitatively. For example, a specific orthodontic wire may be characterized as being shiny, made of stainless steel, round, and having a cross-sectional diameter equal to .018 in. The first three de-
scriptive words or phrases refer to qualitative attributes; the last is a quantitative characteristic. Descriptions, whether qualitative or quantitative, are helpful only insofar as their references or bases are familiar and understood. In describing the orthodontic wire, the adjectives were ordered from the least to the most definitive: "shiny" implies a comparison with some herein undefined luster or smoothness of surface; several types of stainless steel, differing from one another metallurgically, are
used in fabricating orthodontic appliances; and "round" is meant to describe the shape of the wire cross-section (but, alternatively, it might
refer to a curvature placed in the wire). Finally, the reference to the "diameter" of the cross-section with the measurement given in inches is
2
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
the most definite because the dimension is well understood and the inch
is an established unit of length. This example suggests that descriptions in quantifiable terms are generally clearer because of familiarity with the bases of those terms. A particular stainless steel may be described in
terms of the constituent materials of the alloy, given in percent by weight or by volume, or implicitly, for example, by the American Iron and Steel Institute grade-and-type designation. (Given the AISI code for the alloy, its composition may be learned by consulting an appropriate metals handbook.) Because many objective descriptions undergo some form of change in the most general discussion, in practical considerations some limits or bounds on the extent of change are often defined or implied. The magnitude of a force, exerted by an appliance on a tooth, may lessen over a period of days as the tooth moves and the appliance partially or totally deactivates. In a structural analysis undertaken to be valid for only a short time, however, the force may be considered as unchanging. The temperature in the oral cavity may vary in a complex fashion and may be affected temporarily by ingesting hot or cold food or beverages. Often, however, it is sufficient to consider oral temperature as unchanging, but elevated some 30°F relative to normal room temperature. (In a study of the characteristics of a metallic arch-wire material, for example, even the fact that intraoral temperature is elevated with respect to the ambient air may be inconsequential.) A constant, then, is defined as a quantity that retains a fixed, unchanging value or level within the bounds of a particular discussion or investigation. A quantity that cannot be regarded as constant while under study, either because its variation is the subject of the study or the contribution of its changing is not negligible in overall considerations, may experience change associated with movement from one location to another, or directly or indirectly as time passes. Location or position may be related to time. The force in a helically-coiled spring may be altered by changing
the position of one end of the spring with respect to the other. The position or orientation of a malposed tooth under the influence of an activated orthodontic appliance may change with time. A variable, is, in general description, a definable characteristic or parameter under study that takes on more than one quantifiable value during the course of a discussion or investigation. Variables may be categorized as independent or dependent. Although this distinction may often depend on viewpoint, a few variables (e.g., time and temperature) are generally independent, and other parameters assume their values in some manner associated with the magnitude(s) of the independent variable(s). In the analysis of the helical spring, the force in the spring may be said to be dependent on the amount of deformation referenced from the passive (zero-appliedforce) configuration; alternatively, the extent of the deformation may be viewed as dependent on the size of the force applied to the spring. In
the example of tooth location versus time, however, the parameter "time" can never be realistically considered as dependent on the orientation or position of a malposed tooth.
3
Mathematical Topics
Whenever two or more variables are involved in a common discussion or investigation, and whenever these variables are interrelated such that one or more unique values of one variable are assumed upon the assignment of specific values to the remaining variables, the first is dependent on, or said to be a function of, the other (independent) variables. A functional relationship is usually expressed explicitly in the depend-
ent variable. For example, if the symbol, y represents a quantity that takes on a particular value upon the assignment of a value to x, the general relationship is written as y = function (x), or simply y = f(x). If the "data" relating y to x originate from an experiment, the function f(x) is subsequently sought toward the facility of determining all values of y within some range or bounds of the independent variable x. The variation in a parametric value might be expressed mathematically in a smooth, continuous manner, and an analytic relationship, an equation, may be written to represent it. This representation can always be set down in a graphical or tabular form, but there are times when a variable takes on individual, discrete, seemingly unrelated values and an equation cannot be derived easily, if at all. The graph or table is then necessary to visualize a pattern in and the range of the variable values. In this text, the typical equation is simple in form and often derivable from the graphical representation of the relationship among the variables.
Frames of Reference When expressing graphically the change in value of a variable, the values and change may be associated with the length of, or distance along, a reference line or axis. Many variables have the possibility of assuming
the value of zero, and this or another convenient reference point or origin is located on the axis. To associate length or distance with the variable values, a scale is needed. In Figure 1-1, an axis is established for
the parameter "time." The origin of the plot coincides with a relative time of zero (hours). The chosen scale assigned one hour to a specific interval, and twelve adjacent intervals "equals" one-half day. In this particular representation, amounts of time elapsed or time change are of interest and negative time readings have no real meaning. Hence, since time is not an algebraic quantity, there is no need to extend the reference
I
t
i
I
i
i
I
I
I
1
1 hr
FIGuRE 1-1. A one-dimensional plot relating time as a variable, in hours, to distance along an axis.
4
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
line in both directions from the origin, which has, therefore, been placed
at the left end of the axis with time increasing to the right. The graphical relationship of one dependent variable to another, or possibly to two other independent variables, is usually established within a two-dimensional, rectangular-coordinates framework. A pair of reference axes are defined as the basis for the graph; the axes are perpendicular to one another with the origin of each the intersection point,
the now-defined origin of the framework as a whole. Ordinarily, one axis is positioned horizontally and the other vertically. When the variables may only assume positive values, the origin is placed at the lowerleft so that variable values associated with the horizontal axis will increase from left to right and values associated with the vertical axis will increase upward. As with the one-dimensional "plot" of Figure 1-1, a variable name (e.g., force) and units of measurement (e.g., ounces) are appended to each axis. A scale is implied by the distance associated with an individual unit division along each axis. When preparing a graph of the relationship between two variables,
symbolized, for example, by x and y (without specifying the units of measurement of either), points would be individually plotted in the x-y plane and each point would be designated by a number pair, or coordinates, (x,y). When plotting a two-dimensional relationship with respect to a set of horizontal and vertical axes, the x-coordinate of a point is often termed the abscissa and the y-coordinate the ordinate. When all points have been plotted, a curve is sketched as a "best fit" through all of the plotted points. An attempt may then be made to obtain an analytic
expression that relates x and y at or near to every point on the drawn curve. Figure 1-2 shows a straight-line relationship that is defined as to position and orientation by just two (x,y) coordinate pairs. A nonlinear relationship is also displayed that may necessitate the plotting of many points prior to sketching the curve to obtain an accurate representation. The scales chosen for the axes need not be identical, regardless of whether or not similar units of measurement are appropriate to the variables symbolized by x and y. The straight line in Figure 1-2 was drawn after the coordinates (1,2) and (2,4) were plotted. If the lower bound for x and y is zero, the plot appropriately begins at the origin of this x-y frame (0,0). The equation of the line is easily determined to be y = 2x. The curve sketched with respect to the same pair of coordinate axes suggests a functional relationship between x and y that is quite different from that of the straight line. Although the numerical relationship of x to y can be readily obtained for any specific point on the curve, the equation relating the two variables at every point on the curve is not easily derived from the plotted points. The two plots of Figure 1-2 may be unrelated to one another or may
be "members" of a family of curves. If the latter is the case, a third variable is involved and, for each value of interest of that third variable, an individual relationship exists between x and y. Plotting a family of curves in the plane is a method of visually describing the relationship among three variables within a two-dimensional reference frame. Gen-
(2,4)
(1,2)
0
1
2
3
4
x
URE 1-2. Relationships between pairs of variables displayed, referenced to an coordinate framework.
thy,
when plotting one curve or a family of curves with respect to a
me framework consisting of horizontal and vertical axes, the dependI variable, expressed graphically as a function of one or two independ-
I variables, is scaled on the vertical axis.
6
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
y
z
FIGURE 1-3. Relationships of an individual dependent variable to pairs of independent variables, sketched within an x-y-z-coordinate framework.
From a two-dimensional plot, in addition to enabling the determinalion of one or more values of the dependent variable for a given value of the independent variable(s), the slope of the curve at one or more specific
points is often useful. This slope represents the rate of change of the dependent variable with respect to a unit increase in the scaled dependent variable and is, geometrically, the inclination of the tangent to the curve at the specified point. The slope at a point may be positive or negative, depending upon whether the dependent variable is increasing or decreasing in value from that point. If the plot of the relationship between two variables is a straight line, the slope is the same at all points. Along the nonlinear curve in Figure 1-2, the slope decreases to x = 1, then increases with increasing values of x. The rectangular-coordinate framework in two dimensions may be extended to three with the addition of a third axis, mutually perpendicu-
lar to both axes in the plane and intersecting the origin of the plane frame. In the coordinate system in space, a functional relationship among three or possibly four variables may be displayed. Figure 1-3 shows a curve and a surface referenced to an x-y-z framework. Both the curve and the surface might represent functions in which z symbolizes the dependent variable and x and y the independent variables. The surface may serve to display a function for all values of x and y within some bounds; the curve, drawn in the surface, may graphically provide the functional relationship for only those values of the independent variables that are of particular interest, A function of three independent variables may be displayed in the spatial framework as a family of curves or
7
Mathematical Topics
The concept of slope can be extended to three dimensions. Along a surface the rate of change of z, for example, the dependent surfaces.
variable, may be considered at a point of the surface independently with respect to unit changes in x and y or with respect to a coordinate in the direction of a curve in the surface. A unique tangent plane is associated
with each point on a surface, and a slope may be computed for any specified direction in that plane. The interpretation of a functional relationship displayed in a threedimensional reference framework is difficult, particularly when sketched in two dimensions. Although the pictorial representation of analytic functions in three dimensions is generally beyond the needs of this text, coordinate systems have other uses, and an important one is the designation of reference directions in a plane or in space. In the study of dental anatomy, a coordinate frame is often placed in an individual tooth; one axis coincides with the long axis of the dental unit. Mutually perpendicular directions associated with this framework are occlusogingival (or occlusoapical), faciolingual (or labiolingual or buccolingual), and mesiodistal. Such a reference frame is shown in Figure 1-4. Note that these axes extend on both sides of the origin of the framework;
rather than adopting an algebraic scheme, a sense is specified (and the direction is implied) in discussions. For example, as indicated in Figure 1-4, "distal" indicates a specific sense in the mesiodistal direction. In a
l(ingual)
dOstal)
Origin
g(ingival) t(acial)
FIGURE 1-4. Mutually perpendicular coordinate directions used in dentistry.
m(esial)
$
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
framework associated with the entire dental arch or dentition, the refer-
ence directions are generally labeled anteroposterior, lateral or transverse, and vertical. A plane of reference is generally associated directly with the coordinate perpendicular to the plane, often with the additional indication of the "side" of the plane being viewed. For example, the occiusal plane is perpendicular to the occlusogingival direction with the view toward the tooth crowns. A buccal plane is perpendicular to a buccolingual direction; an identical lingual plane exists, but the implied view is toward the lingual surface(s). The faciolingual and mesiodistal planes are perpendicular to one another, references associated with an individual dental unit, and the line common to both planes is coincident with the long axis of the tooth. Note that the common terminology for the planes of reference for the dentition, or each arch, as a whole deviates from this pattern; the coronal, the occlusal (or transverse), and the sagittal planes are the mutually perpendicular references, and two of the associated, perpendicular axes have designations unlike their counterpart planes.
Displacements of Particles and Solid Bodies The distance between two points in space (e.g., A and B) is measured in
length units along a straight line connecting the two points. The displacement "path" of a particle moving from point A to point B, however, need not be along that line. The actual distance traveled by the particle in moving from A to B is measured along the path followed, and
may be sizable compared to the straight-line measurement. The displacement of a particle from point A is in magnitude the distance from A to a specific point on the path, and is dependent upon the elapsed time since its coincidence with point A. Displacements of orthodontic interest
are generally small in absolute measurement, but are comparable to characteristic intraoral dimensions. Such displacements may be difficult to obtain accurately because (1) often few, if any, potential references with the dentofacial complex remain stationary over time, (2) position measurements cannot be monitored continuously, and (3) total move-
ments may be an inseparable combination of orthodontic and orthopedic displacements and growth. Although full coverage of this subject is properly relegated to the study of cephalometrics, several portions of the topic fit into the discussions of this chapter. First, any displacement to be quantified, must be measured with respect to a reference frame. The displacement path of a particle must often be estimated by connecting straight-line distances between successive positions of the particle; the larger the number of position measurements, the more accurate the estimation. The displacement of a solid body as a whole is fundamentally described in terms of the displacement of one particle of the body and the angular movement of a line within the body passing through this particle.
9
Mathematical Topics
C, C
1800
01
I
I arc D"D'
C
FIGURE 1-5. Successive positions of a tooth undergoing planar orthodontic displacement, including a change in angular orientation.
Figure 1-5 depicts the displacement of a tooth as well as the displace-
ments of two particles (or points) of the tooth; in this example, the points and movements are planar. The displacement of point D may be expressed in terms of the displacement of point C and the relative movement of D with respect to C. The angular displacement of the tooth is the difference in orientations, 02 — 01, of the line through points C and D. In
fact, all lines of the tooth in the plane of the sketch, or parallel to it, experience the same angular displacement. Because the distance between points C and D in the tooth does not change during the movement, the displacement path of the particle at D with respect to, or as viewed from, point C is a circular arc. The radius of that circular arc is the line segment in the tooth from C to D, the change in angular position of the segment CD represents the angular displacement of the tooth as a whole, and the relative curvilinear displacement of the particle at D with respect to point C is along a circular path, the arc D'D', and equals the product of the length of the segment CD and the angular change, 02 01. In
this computation the angular change must be expressed in radi-
ans, where 22/7 radians is comparable to 180°. The units of the length CD
and the relative displacement DD' are then identical. The completion of the determination of the "absolute" displacement of the particle coinciding with point D must be deferred until later in this
10
Bioerigineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
chapter because this displacement is, mathematically, a vector quantity.
This section has, however, introduced or reviewed concepts associated with particle and angular whole-body displacements and recalled the relationship among the size of the angle, the radius, and the length of the circular arc for a circular segment.
Trgonometry As noted in the preceding section, an angle is the measurement of the
orientation of one line with respect to another in the plane containing the lines. The actual quantification implies a circle centered at the point of intersection of the lines; the curvilinear length of the circular arc between the lines divided by the radius of the circle yields the size of the angle in radians. The example of Figure 1-6 shows an angle of 22/21 radians, or 600. (Although the dimensionless units of degrees are more familiar than radians, many computations to obtain an angle as the result yield the answer in radians.) Angles are often categorized by size: acute angles are smaller than 90°, right angles are exactly 90°, obtuse angles are larger than 90° but less than 1800; and straight angles are exactly 1800. Although circles are described as encompassing 360°, the smaller interior angle between two radii never exceeds 180°. The sum of acute and adjacent obtuse angles within the intersection of two lines is 180°; these angles are termed "supplementary" to one another. A triangle is a plane, three-sided, closed figure made up of three line segments. The intersection of each pair of line segments defines an
QA = OB =
S
AB = s 600 = 22/21 radians s = (22/21)r
0 FIGURE 1-6. Angular measurement.
A
11
Mathematical Topics
angle. Each angle is measured interior to the figure and the three angular measurements always sum to 1800 or 22/7 ("pi") radians. Also, for
every triangle, the ratio of the length of a side to a function of the angle opposite that side is a constant. That function is defined as the "sine" of the angle; it is a dimensionless quantity that has bounds for angles between 0° and 180° of 0 and +1. Triangles are categorized according to the size of the largest interior angle. A right triangle contains, opposite to the longest side termed the "hypotenuse," a right angle. The other two angles, necessarily acute, must sum to 90°; such angles are said to be "complementary" to one another. A right triangle is pictured in Figure 1-7. The following trigonometric functions are defined for an acute angle within a right triangle: sine A =
opposite
=
a
hypotenuse c adjacent b cosine A = =— hypotenuse c opposite a tangent A = adjacent
(1-1)
b
"Opposite" and "adjacent" refer to the positions of sides of the triangle with respect to angle A and the ratios are of side lengths. Similar relationships may be written explicitly for angle B. The defined trigonometric functions are generally abbreviated "sin," "cos," and "tan." Table 1-1 contains trigonometric functional values and conversions between degrees and radians for angles between 0° and 90°. Three additional trigonometric functions—the cosecant (csc), the
C
a
b
FIGURE 1-7. A right triangle with angles and sides labeled symbolically.
12
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics TABLE 1-1. Degrees-radians equivalents and trigonometric functions Degrees 0 1
2 3
4 5 6 7 8
9
10
Radians
Sin
Cos
Tan
0.000
0.000
1.000
0.000
0.018 0.035 0.052 0.070 0.087 0.105 0.122 0.140 0.157 0.175
0.018 0.035 0.052 0.070 0.087 0.105 0.122 0.139 0.156 0.174
0.999 0.999 0.999 0.998 0.996 0.995 0.993 0.990 0.987 0.985
0.018 0.035 0.052 0.070 0.088 0.105 0.123
0.192 0.209 0.227 0.244 0.262 0.279 0.297 0.314 0.332 0.349
0.191
0.367 0.384
0358
22
0.375
0.934 0.927
23
0.401
0.391
0.921
24 25
0.419 0.436 0.454
0.407 0.423 0.438 0.454 0.470 0.485 0.500
0.914 0.906 0.899
0.515 0.530 0.545 0.559 0.574 0.588 0.602 0.617 0.629 0.643
11
12 13 14
15 16 17 18 19
20 21
26 27 28
0.471
30
0.489 0.506 0.524
31
0.541
32 33 34
0.559 0.576 0.593
35 36 37
0.611
38
0.663
29
0628 0646
39
0.681
40
0698
41
0.716 0.733
42 43 44 45
0.751
0768 0.785
0.208 0.225 0.242 0.259 0.276 0.292 0.309 0.326 0.342
0.982 0.978 0.974 0.970 0.966
0.141
Cot 1.571
57.3 28.6 19.9 14.3 11.4 9.51
8.14 7.12
0.158 0.176
6.31
0.194 0.213
5.14 4.70 4.33
0.231
5.67
59
1.15
0.855 0.838 0.820 0.803 0.785
49
Radians
Degrees
0.755 0.743 0.719 0.707
0.869 0.900 0.933 0.966 1.000
Cos
Sin
Cot
0.731
0.625 0.649 0.675 0.700 0.727 0.754 0.781
0.810 0.839
79 78
1.361
1.030 1.012 0.995 0.977 0.959 0.943 0.925 0.908 0.890 0.873
0.656 0.669 0.682 0.695 0.707
0.883 0.875 0.866
1.378
80
1.66 1.60 1.54 1.48 1.43 1.38 1.33 1.28 1.24 1.19
0.601
0.891
81
1.80 1.73
0.857 0 848 0.839 0.829 0.819 0.809 0.800 0.788 0.777 0.766
0.940
1.414 1.396
69 68 67
2.61
0946
1.431
89 88 87 86 85 84 83 82
1.204 1.187 1.169 1.152 1.135 1.127 1.100 1.082 1.065 1.047
0.384 0.404 0.425 0.445 0.466 0.488 0.510 0.532 0.554 0.577
0.951
1.484 1.466 1.448
90
77 76
4.01
0.956
1.501
-
1.344 1.327 1.309 1.292 1.274 1.256 1.239 1.222
0.249 0.268 0.287 0.306 0.325 0.344 0.364
0.961
1.553 1.536 1.518
3.73 3.49 3.27 3.08 2.90 2.75 2.48 2.36 2.25 2.14 2.05 1.96 1.88
1.11
1.07 1.04 1.00 Tan
75 74 73 72 71
70
66 65 64 63 62 61
60 58 57
56 55 54 53 52 51
50 48 47 46
45
13
Mathematical Topics
(sec), and the cotangent (cot or ctn)—are defined as the reciprocals of the sine, cosine, and tangent, respectively. The lengths of the secant
sides of a right triangle are interrelated through the Pythagorean theorem;
for the triangle of Figure 1-7 the relationship is = a2 + b2
(1-2)
or, in words, the length of the hypotenuse equals the square root of the
sum of the squares of the other two sides. Also, from the foregoing definitions and because A and B are mutually complementary: sin A = cos cot A = tan
tan A = cot csc A = sec
cos B = sin A sec A = csc B
B B
B
B
(1-3)
An oblique triangle, incorporating no right angle, is sketched in Figure 1-8. The law of sines for this triangle is
sinD
—
sinE
ci
e
—
sinF
(1-4)
f
Another relationship, valid for the oblique triangle, also relating sides and angles, is the law of cosines: d2 =
e2 =f2+
d2
2ef(cos D) —2fd(cos E)
+
e2
2de(cos F)
f2 =
e2
+ f2
(1-5)
Although the oblique triangle of Figure 1-8 is specifically an obtuse triangle, these two laws may also be used in analyzing an acute triangle.
d
e
FIGURE 1-8. An oblique triangle with angles and sides labeled symbolically.
14
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
y L
0
x
FIGURE 1-9. A line segment referred to an x-y-coordinate framework.
For the right triangle, the sine and cosine laws are replaced by the defini-
tions of the sine and cosine functions and the Pythagorean theorem. Figure 1-9 shows a line drawn in the plane of the page with the origin of an x-y-coordinate framework coinciding with one end of the line segment. Because the reference frame is rectangular, the line makes complementary angles with the x- and y-axes. These angles, labeled and are called the direction angles of the line OL. The "shadow" or projection of the line segment on the x-axis is the apparent length of the line seen from a vantage point far out on the y-axis; that length equals OL cos Similarly, the projection of OL on the y-axis is equal to OL cos The cosines of the direction angles are termed direction cosines. Enclosing the line OL in a rectangle, having adjacent sides coincident with the x- and
y-axes and making the segment OL a diagonal of the rectangle, and noting the two equal right triangles formed (which share a common hypotenuse), the following equations may be written: (x-projection)2 + (p-projection)2 = 0L2 + = 1
(1-6)
The development just completed using Figure 1-9 may be extended to three dimensions. In Figure 1-10 the coordinate framework is again
appended to one end of the line segment (although, in general, the segment may be remote with respect to the frame); the end points of the segment are (0,0,0) and (XN,YN,ZN). The direction angles are defined as in Figure 1-9, except there are three; for instance, in Figure 1-10 the angle 0,
15
Mathematical Topics
\
N
0 z
Q
\\ a y
ox
x
FIGURE 1-10. A line segment in space referred to an x-y-z-coordinate framework.
measured between the x-axis and the line segment and that measurement is made in the plane containing ON and the x-axis. The projections of the segment ON on the coordinate axes are is
y-projection = QN(cos x-projection = ON(cos z-projection = ON(cos
0!,)
respectively, and the three projections are also related to the coordinates of end points of the segment and its direction cosines: x-projection
0 XN y-projection = z-projection = ZN — 0
YN
—
0
(1-8)
An alternative two-step process may be used to obtain the projections. First, for example, project the line on the y-axis and into the x-z plane. The angle 4, measured between the segment ON and the x-z plane, is complementary to and the projection in the plane equals ON cos q5. Second, decompose the x-z plane projection, OQ, into x- and z-axis projections using the complementary angles a and y, measured in the x-z plane. The three projections may then be expressed as follows:
16
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
x-projection = ON(cos 4)cos a
y-projection = ON(cos Os,,) z-projection = ON(cos q5)cos y
(1-9)
The length of the line segment is related to the coordinate-axis projections through the three-dimensional form of the Pythagorean theorem: (x-projection)2 + (y-projection)2 + (z-projection)2
(1-10)
Dividing through by the square of the segment length and noting the resulting forms defining the direction cosines, the expression becomes +
+
=
1
(1-11)
The comparable relationship in the two-dimensional situation, previously examined, is the complementary nature of the two direction angles. (No simple relationship among the three direction angles exists spatially.) Before closing this section, it is important to note that a three-dimensional geometry problem may always be decomposed into two or three
two-dimensional problems. The original problem is, seemingly, expanded from one into two or three, but the gain is in terms of each of the
two or three "projections" being in its own plane setting.
An Introduction to Vector Algebra
physical quantities associated with orthodontic bioengineering possess characteristics in addition to magnitude. A most important entity, the point or concentrated force must be known in magnitude, in direction (and sense), and in point of application to be fully described. A multifaceted description is similarly associated with the displacement of a particle or a point of a solid body. Both the point force and displacement obey the laws of vector mathematics. A vector is a mathematical quantity possessing both magnitude and direction. The equations describing vectors are unique, and vector quantities combine with scalars and with other vectors according to specific mathematical laws and procedures. Vector quantities may be expressed in both graphic and analytic formats. The vector is pictured as a directed line segment. When drawn to scale, the length of the segment is proportional to the magnitude of the vector. The inclination or orientation of the segment, the angle between it and a specified reference line or axis, indicates the direction of the vector. The sense of the vector is denoted by an arrowhead affixed to one end of the segment. Given all other characteristics of a vector, with only two possibilities for sense, it may be specified algebraically. Sense is often linked with direction; two vectors having identical angles with a reference axis, but differing in sense, are said Several
17
Mathematical Topics
be opposite in direction to one another. Without being specific as to the physical quantity represented, a vector is shown in Figure 1-11 with an x-y-coordinate frame included in the sketch that serves as a reference to
for direction and sense. The displayed vector, indicated as having a magnitude of 100 units with the directed line segment subdivided into 5 equal length units, implies a linear scale factor of 100 to 5 or 20 to 1. Figure 1-11 is similar to Figure 1-9 except for the absence of the arrowhead in the latter sketch and the coordinate framework not attached to an end of the line segment in the former. The angles labeled in Figure 1-11 are those which the line of the vector, if extended, would make with the x- and y-axes; therefore, these angles are properly termed the direction angles of the vector. Individual multiplications of the vector length by the direction cosines gives the x- and y-projections of the vector. Converting these (scalar) projections to vector quantities by including the senses and multiplying each by the scale factor for the sketch yields the
x-, and y-components of the given vector. The lengths of the x- and y-projections are indicated as 4 and 3 units; with a 20-to-i scale factor, the x- and y-component magnitudes are 80 and 60, respectively. The rectangular components of a vector are, by definition, mutually perpendicular and individually parallel to a coordinate axis. Hence, the sum of the squares of the component magnitudes (or the lengths of their line-
segment representations) equals the square of the magnitude (or the length) of the original vector. The analytic expression for a vector is typically written in terms of its component magnitudes (projections) and unit vectors (dimensionless and of magnitude one). Vector quantities appear in boldface type in this
y
60 units
Scale: 1:20
80 units
0 FIGURE 1-11. A vector positioned in the x-y plane.
X
18
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
text to distinguish them from scalars. The unit vectors i and j, defined as
associated in direction and sense with the x- and y-directions, are shown in Figure 1-11; note the positive senses corresponding to increasing coordinate values. The equation for the vector displayed may be written as V = 80i + 60j
(1-12)
Shown in Figure 1-12 is a vector in space. The ends of the vector are coincident with points located with respect to the chosen x-y-z-coordinate framework; the "tail" of the vector coincides with point D(3, 1,2) and the vector symbol extends to point E(5,5,6). In this example, the vector represents a 60-g force. A parallelepiped, oriented to the coordinate frame, "surrounds" the vector, which lies on a main diagonal. The length DE of the force vector is found through the three-dimensional form of the Pythagorean theorem: DE = [(5
—
3)2
+ (5
—
1)2 + (6
—
2)21112 =
(1-13)
6
The scale factor for the sketch is, then, 60 g to 6 length units or 10 g to 1 length unit. The lengths of the sides DA (2 units), DB (4 units), and DC (also 4 units) of the parallelepiped correspond to the projections of the given vector, which are parallel to the x-, y-, and z-axes, respectively. The direction angles and of the force vector are the angles EDA, EDB, and EDC, respectively. Similarities in and differences between Figures 1-10 and 1-12 should now be apparent. Defining k as the unit vector y
/
/ /7 y,/
//
/'/I / /
4
1/
/11/
x
1 0(3,12) E(55,6)
Scale:
FIGURE 1-12. A vector referenced to a three-dimensional framework.
1
unit = log
19
Mathematical Topics
parallel to the z-axis and with sense corresponding to increasing z, the
vector equation for the 60-g force may now be written:
F=20i+40j+4Okg
(1-14)
The terms of Equation 1-14 are the x-, y-, and z-components of the force vector. By way of application, Figure 1-12 might be displaying a force exerted by a stretched elastic, pulling from a point (3 cm, 1 cm, 2 cm) in a lateral-anteroposterior-vertical reference frame. (Continuing, the point
(5 cm, 5 cm, 6 cm) is on the line of the force, but the "head" (arrowhead) of the vector located at that point in the figure is merely a result of the particular choice of scale factor for the sketch.) Equation 1-14 charac-
terizes the force as to magnitude, direction, and sense at a particular time, but does not indicate the point of application of the force. To complete the displacement discussion begun in an earlier section of this chapter, a vector addition must be carried out. The displacement of point D, the root apex in Figure 1-5, equals the sum of the displacement vector of point C in the crown and the relative displacement, D with respect to C. In Figure 1-11 the vector components having magnitudes of 80 and 60 units "add" to give the resultant vector V with magnitude of 100 units. (The sum of two vectors depends on both the individ-
ual magnitudes and their directions and senses.) In that example, the (rectangular) components were perpendicular to one another; the components of the apex displacement vector are not 900 apart. Note, however, that the parallelogram law of vector addition, when employed graphi-
cally, is easily undertaken regardless of the relative orientations of the vectors to be summed. The vector addition of the two displacement components is shown in Figure 1-13. The displacement of point C, in reality obtained, perhaps, from successive cephalograms, is drawn to a scale; in this example, the scale magnifies the actual displacement size. The magnitude of the relative displacement is the scalar product of the change in long-axis angulation (in radians) and the length of the axis segment CD. The directions and senses are from C to C' and D" to D', respectively, from Figure 1-5. To accomplish the summation, the two vectors are placed in series, with the tail of one meeting the arrowhead of the other, and they form adjaC (or D)
d(isplacement)D
d010
C, (or D")
FIGURE 1-13. Vector addition. The relationship among the displacement vectors of points in Figure 1-5.
20
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
cent sides of a parallelogram. The third and fourth sides of the parallelo-
gram are added (dashed) to complete the figure and the desired vector, the absolute displacement of point D, is coincident with a diagonal. The length of the resultant vector is measured and multiplied by the scale factor to obtain the magnitude of the displacement of point D. Because the two vectors summed in Figure 1-13 are nearly parallel and have comparable senses, the result in this example is almost as if the component magnitudes were added. Parallel components, however, are the exception and not the rule; the 80-unit and 60-unit components in Figure 1-11 sum to give a resultant magnitude of 100 units, not 140. Additional examples of vector addition are presented in Chapter 2.
Dimensions and Units The quantifiable parameters of orthodontic bioengineering are generally
dimensional and their magnitudes depend upon the units in which the parameters are expressed. Four dimensions are basic or fundamental: length, time, mass, and temperature. All other dimensions of interest may
be derived from these four; the most important is the dimension of force. The result of a dimensional analysis of an equation of classical physics yields force as the product of mass, length, and the inverse of time squared [mass(length)/(time2)}. Dimensions help to describe a quantity, and also to distinguish among apparently similar parameters. For example, pressure is dimensionally mass/length!(time2) or force! (length2) and, therefore, is not identical to, or a type of, force, although the two are related. One quantity already discussed, which is dimensionless (or nondimensional), is angular measurement; another, which will be introduced in Chapter 3, is strain. The numerical value assigned to a dimensional quantity (and some nondimensional quantities as well) is meaningful only when units are appended to that value. Each fundamental or derived dimension generally has several units or sets of units that may be associated with it. The numbers 1, 3, and 36 are different from each other, but when used as expressions of length in yards, feet, and inches, respectively, they are identical.
Because of biologic and materials-science influences on their field, dental practitioners are familiar with two systems of units. Metric units are common to the life sciences; length is measured in meters and mass in grams or fractions!multiples thereof (e.g., millimeters [mm] and kilograms [kg]). In this country the physical sciences have long employed the American engineering system of units; typically, lengths are in feet and forces in pounds-force. In both unit systems the basic unit of time is the second. The derived, composite unit of force in the metric system is
the "newton;" the gram-force is more common now in the United States, but is a distortion of the metric mass unit. In the American engi-
21
Mathematical Topics
neering scheme, force is considered a fundamental dimension and the
"slug" is the derived unit of mass (although pound-mass is also used in a manner comparable to gram-force). Conversions from one metric-units set to another is straightforward; "kilo" indicates 1000 and "centi" means "divide by 100," for example. Such conversions in the American engineering system are more difficult (e.g., 5280 ft/mile and 16 oz/lb);
this is probably a principal reason why the scheme has never been widely accepted outside of the United States. Orthodontists, until now purchasing arch wires having cross-seclions measured in inches, but themselves measuring arch lengths and discrepancies in millimeters, should be pleased about the pressures from abroad toward a worldwide move to the Système International d'Unités (French), or the SI units system. A modified metric scheme, the fundamental SI units of length, time, mass, and temperature are the meter, the second, the kilogram, and the degree Kelvin, respectively. Examples of SI units associated with derived dimensions include the newton (force), the pascal (stress or pressure; one newton per square meter), and the joule (energy; one newton-meter). Currently, the conversion to one international system of units remains incomplete. Hence, the clinician must possess some proficiency in converting from one unit
or set of units to another in the same system and in transposing or converting between the metric and American engineering schemes. Table 1-2 is provided to assist the reader with a partial listing of conversion factors within and between unit systems.
ants, Computations, and Numerical Accuracy Although not professing to be mathematicians, orthodontists are con-
fronted with, and make use of, a substantial amount of quantitative information. Treatment planning is influenced by computations performed after measurements are taken from casts and cephalograms. Today's vendors of wires, elastics, and the whole array of appliance ele-
ments are oriented in the materials and engineering sciences, and clinicians must be able to communicate appropriately with them. To understand the mechanical and structural functions expected of their appliances, and to match sets of appliances properly with the treatment plan, the practitioner must be able to undertake at least a cursory analysis of the force systems created by activation of those appliances. Physiologically-proper forces, to be exerted on the dentition, must be approximated. To follow the development and examples in this text, and more importantly to make clinical use of the knowledge to be gained in the study of the bioengineering topics to follow, the mathematical tools discussed in this chapter become indispensable. When possible, emphases will be placed on the appropriate graphic techniques to carry out an analysis, in
particular to help visualize relationships among variables and in the
22
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics TABLE 1-2. Conversions within and between units systems
Dimension(s)
Length (L)
Area (L2)
Multiply mils
0.001
centimeters meters inches
100 25.4
inches2 centimeters2
0.155
pounds pounds pounds ounces kilograms-force
Force (F)
by
10
645 16
454
4.45 0.278 2.2
to Obtain inches millimeters millimeters millimeters millimeters2 inches2
ounces grams-force newtons newtons pounds
Energy (F-L)
inch-ounces foot-pounds
720 1.36
gram-millimeters newton-meters (joules)
Stress (FIL2)
pounds/inch2 pounds/inch2 pounds/inch2
0.704 0. 07 04
grams/mm2 kilograms/cm2 newtons/meter2 (pascals)
Temperature (T)
degrees F—32
degrees C
6900 5/9 9/5
degrees C degrees F—32
Time (t)
seconds minutes
3600 1440
hours days
Angle
radians
57.3
degrees
1. Degrees F = °Fahrenheit Degrees C = 2. Angular measurement is nondimen-
sional but is quantified in degrees or radians.
3. Joules (J) and pascals (Pa) are derived units in the SI system. 4. Absolute temperature is measured in °Kelvin = °Celsius + 273 or kine = ¶ahrenheit + 460
manipulations of force and displacement parameters. When necessary, analytic procedures will be used and dimensional and units analyses included as a partial check on the correctness of terms and equations. In any analysis requiring mathematical manipulations, after an overview of the entire undertaking and coming to a decision regarding the appropriate procedure to be followed, the input or given data must be gathered or examined. The techniques of obtaining linear and angular measurements, and the accuracy of these data, are expected to be those ordinarily achieved in acceptable cephalometric exercises. Determinations of force magnitudes should generally be to the nearest ½ oz or 15 g. When input data for a problem to be solved originate from a previous statistical analysis, the accuracy of that data is to be determined; if
mean values of parameters are to be used, their standard deviations should be sought.
23
Mathematical Topics
Analyses within this text are to be undertaken and solutions pursued through principles of force and structural mechanics interfaced with
knowledge obtained from clinical experience and experimental research.
Quantifiable results will be sought by using mathematical procedures
introduced in this chapter. After any solution has been obtained it should be carefully checked. Two possible means of checking results are
(1) to proceed to the solution by an alternate method or approach, if available, or to change the order of steps in the solution procedure followed, or at least to substitute the numerical answers obtained into the mathematical relationships initially used to ensure satisfaction; and (2) to make sure that no mistakes exist in dimensions or units in the procedural steps. A dimensional analysis of an algebraic equation, for example, must show identical, net dimensions and units for each term. The solution to a problem involving mathematical operations is only as accurate as the data employed and the accuracy of the computations performed. Deficiencies in either can render a solution inadequate, even if the procedures are all correct. An accurate set of calculations cannot make up for inaccuracies in initial data. Hand-held, electronic calculators and digital computers will yield numerical solutions to six or more
figures, but no more digits should appear in the answer than can be justified. The evaluation of the accuracy of mathematical procedures is a complex matter and will not be investigated here. It is perhaps sufficient to indicate that most input data in orthodontic bioengineering problems are accurate to no more than three significant figures and, therefore, no more than three significant figures should be recorded in the solutions obtained.
Readings Davis, H.F., and Snider, A.D.: Introduction to Vector Analysis. 4th Ed. Boston,
Allyn & Bacon, 1979, Chapter 1.
Drooyan, I., Hadel, W., and Carico, C.C.: Trigonometry. 3rd Ed. New York, Macmillan, 1979, Chapters 1, 4, 5, and Appendix A. Greener, E.H., Harcourt, J.K., and Lautenschlager, E.P.: Materials Science in Dentistry. Baltimore, Williams & Wilkins, 1972, Chapter 1. Spiegel, M.R.: Mathematical Handbook of Formulas and Tables. Schaum's Outline Series. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1968.
Spiegel, M.R.: Theory and Problems of Vector Analysis. New York, Schaum, 1959, Chapter 1.
Thurow, R.C.: Atlas of Orthodontic Principles. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1970, Chapter 5. Wilson, W.A., and Tracey, J.I.: Analytic Geometry. Boston, D.C. Heath, 1949, Chapters 1—3, 13.
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force 22 The activation of an orthodontic appliance creates a system of forces that
are transmitted through the members of that appliance to the dentition, there providing the potential to produce displacements of dental units. Relationships exist between force systems and potential displacements of bodies upon which the forces act. Hence, an understanding of the fundamental principles and procedures of force analysis is indispensable to the practitioner who fabricates, places, and activates the appliance toward the desired end: the controlled movement of teeth. A large portion of the analysis of forces to be discussed has its foundations in the subfield of classical physics known as particle mechanics. Several of the basic concepts may be familiar to the reader from an undergraduate survey course in general physics. Nevertheless, the discussion here commences with no assumptions of previous knowledge of the subject.
Mechanics as an area of study within the physical sciences, is concerned with the state of rest or motion of bodies subjected to forces. Mechanics is subdivided by the physicist according to the sizes of the bodies studied (from the smallest subatomic parts of matter—quantum mechanics— to the planets and galaxies—astronomy) and with respect to the degree of motion (from no movement whatsoever to bodies moving at rates of the order of the speed of light). Although evidence exists that the early Greek scientists understood and used some aspects of mechanics several hundred years nc., the fundamental principles of particle mechanics, as understood today, were formulated by Sir Isaac Newton in the seven-
Mechanics,
teenth century. Newtonian mechanics pertain to bodies of moderate size, if moving then not at the excessive speeds where mass and velocity
may become relatively, mutually indistinguishable, and is separable from relativity theory and celestial mechanics. 24
25
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
Newtonian mechanics is divided into branches known as statics,
which treats bodies at rest and under the action of forces, and dynamics, which deals with moving bodies. Dynamics is further subdivided into kinematics, the study of motion itself, and kinetics, in which relationships between the force systems and the characteristics of body motion are explored. The subareas of study within mechanics also may be categorized according to interest in whole-body motions and displacements of solids, the deformations that solid bodies experience under loading, and the flow of fluids. The principles of Newtonian mechanics, together with their interactions with the biologic systems and processes involved, govern the study of orthodontic forces. The movements of individual teeth are examples of whole-body displacements. Because the activation of the orthodontic appliance requires deformation of one or more elements of the appliance, applicable principles of mechanics of deformable bodies are discussed in subsequent chapters.
This chapter first introduces the principles of Newtonian partide mechanics. The extensions of these principles, enabling the treatment of bodies that are large in comparison to the particle, are then discussed. Some modeling (idealizing from the actual) and approximations will be
found necessary or beneficial and, in each instance, the validity and limitations of the model or approximation must be assured and understood. Although introduced individually, note that in large measure the concepts and principles "fit" together or accumulate to ultimately form a packaged procedure to be employed in analyses wherein total descrip•tions are required of force systems induced in the orthodontic appliance
and in the dentition to which the appliance is attached.
Force is defined as an act upon a body that changes or tends to change the state of rest or the motion of that body. The categories of forces are numerous, and forces are described in many different ways. Two bodies are associated with every force; one body exerts the force and the other receives the force. A first manner of categorizing forces is according to the proximity of the two involved bodies with respect to each other. Contact Force
forces arise due to actual physical contact between the bodies; body forces exist between bodies that are some distance from one another. The most common, sizable body force is the attraction of the Earth for a body on or near the Earth's surface: the weight of the body. Newton's
gravitational law enables the determination of the weight of a body, which is directly proportional to the product of the masses of the Earth and the body and inversely proportional to the square of the distance between the centers of the Earth and the body. Other body forces include those existing in the presence of electric or magnetic fields, but these do not occur routinely in the study of orthodontic force systems and thus will receive little attention. Notably, the weights of teeth and
26 Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
appliance parts are small and may be neglected in comparison to the
contact forces present within the activated appliance. In analysis procedures, forces are associated with the areas or volumes of bodies with which they directly interact, and contact forces are associated with the surface areas over which the contact exists. If the contact area is small in comparison with the total surface area of the body, the force is modeled as exerted on a surface point or particle of the body and is termed a concentrated or point force. On the other hand, if the contact area is relatively large, the pattern of the force intensity over
the area may be an important consideration and, therefore, the force is explicitly termed distributed. For example, the force exerted by an elastic stretched against a hook, soldered to a bracket or to an arch wire, is reasonably concentrated, but the force arising between the periodontal ligament and the root, in response to appliance activation transmitted to the tooth, must be analyzed with regard to its distribution over the sizable surface area of contact. By definition, forces exerted on an individual particle are point forces that may actually or potentially only pull or push the particle. As previously mentioned, two bodies are necessary to the existence of every force. Moreover, whenever one force is created or present, a counterpart exists as well; when one body exerts a force on another, the second body also exerts a force on the first. Between the two bodies there is an action and a reaction, and which force is which depends solely
on point of view. In analysis procedures, however, just one of the two bodies will be examined at a time and that one body will be studied with respect to the forces exerted on it (not those forces exerted by it). Reactive
forces must not be confused with responsive forces; reactions exist as counterparts to both active and responsive forces. In the study of a body subjected to forces, the active forces are those purposely created or those that "load" the body; the responsive forces are also exerted on the body,
but are a direct result of the creation of active forces. The responsive forces are often undesired, but being present they must be included in the analysis. As a final categorization of forces for present purposes, forces are said to be external to a body under study when they are exerted by other bodies not part of the specific analysis. Internal forces arise within a body as a result of loading or activating the body under study. These internal forces "carry" or transmit the action through the body to the responsive locations, for example, to connections with other bodies.
In addition to the gravitational law, Sir Isaac Newton formulated a set of three laws governing the mechanics of a particle. Newton's First Law states that a particle subjected to a balanced system of concentrated forces will remain at rest, if originally at rest, or will move with constant speed in a straight line, if originally in motion. ("Balanced" force system: the net force is zero.) The Second Law indicates that, if the particle is subjected to an unbalanced system of forces, the particle will be accelerated in the direction of the net force exerted; in equation form, the net
27
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
force and the product of the particle mass and its acceleration, with the
three quantities expressed in consistent, related units, are identical in magnitude, direction, and sense. (Acceleration is the time rate of change of velocity and, like the concentrated force, is mathematically a vector quantity.) The Third Law states that paired active and reactive forces are
equal in magnitude, but are directly opposed to one another and are exerted on adjacent particles. A corollary to the Third Law is the existence of internal forces, as previously defined, in canceling pairs; the ramification of this corollary is demonstrated later in this chapter. Newton's First Law might be considered a special case of the Second Law, and in orthodontic force analysis a strong argument may be made to the point that the inertia of an appliance element or a tooth is negligibly small, in particular after the almost instantaneous response, in the form of soft-tissue deformations, immediately following the activation of an appliance. If the inertia, the product of mass and acceleration for a particle, may be neglected in comparison with the individual components of the force system created through activation, the orthodontic system may be said to exist in a kind of quasi-static state; the displacements that take place are small and occur over a relatively long period of
time and, at any instant, a force analysis may be carried out without erring appreciably, as if the system was at rest. Clearly, this approximation has profound consequences; for the purpose of most analyses involving the entire force system, a dynamic body or group of bodies is effectively replaced by a static body or assembly. In Chapter 1 the concentrated force was reported to fulfill the mathematical requisites of a vector quantity. In the complete description of a point force, then, its characteristics as a vector must be stated: magni-
tude, direction, and sense. Moreover, from a physical standpoint the location of the force on or in the body must be given. Figure 2-1 shows a point force exerted on a molar crown. From the sketch, the force is seen to have a magnitude of 200 g; in this two-dimensional idealization, the direction of the force (and that of the dashed line of action of the force) is 700 from the long axis of the tooth. The sense of the force may be said to be up and to the left with respect to the sketch as a whole, and the point of application is point B with the force pushing on that point. (If desired,
an equation in vector form may be written for this or any point force, following the establishment of a reference frame, and all of the necessary characteristics to describe the force, except point of application, would be contained in that equation.) Figure 2-1, then, provides a complete visual description of the 200-g force. The potential or actual effects of a force exerted on a body, whether active or responsive, are displacement and/or deformation. Although both effects are of interest in orthodontic structural analysis, only the association of displacement with force is discussed in this chapter. Disregard-
ing deformation resulting from force application is tantamount to as-
suming that the body, on which the force or force system acts, is perfectly rigid. Although this is a reasonable assumption for some bod-
28
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
200 g
FIGURE 2-1. A concentrated force exerted on a tooth crown.
ies, including individual teeth, it is not a valid assumption for others, for example, elastics. In considering effects of force application, however, bodies that are clearly nonrigid may be reasonably analyzed only within a framework that recognizes differences in passive and active configurations.
The rigid body, then, is a model of Newtonian mechanics used in analysis procedures when only completion of the description of the total force system or the whole-body displacement is sought. (In Chapter 1,
the displacement of point D of the tooth was obtained within the assumption that the tooth was rigid; otherwise, the relative displacement, point D with respect to point C in Figure 1-5, could not have been described as it was.) An important feature of rigid-body mechanics allows the "sliding" of a point force to any location on its line of action found most convenient for analysis purposes. This principle of transmissibility states that the mechanical, whole-body effect of a concentrated force, acting at a specific point, is unchanged by replacing the given force by another force having the same magnitude, direction, and sense as the original force, but acting at some different point on the line of action. Figure 2-2 shows an 80-g force in two different locations on its line of action (dashed); the potential for displacement of the tooth as a whole is the same, whether the force is pulling on the lingual side or pushing on the labial crown surface. Before proceeding further, the general dependence of orthodontic
force upon the independent variable "time" must be mentioned. The
29
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
—— 80 g
FIGURE 2-2. Two concentrated torces having identical displacement potentials. The principle of transmissibility.
concentrated orthodontic force often changes with time and that change
is typically reflected in the magnitude characteristic, although alteration of direction may also occur with time. Magnitudes of force generated by appliance activation decrease during the between-appointment periods and an accompanying change in displacement potential generally oc-
curs. The changes with time may be divided into short-term occurrences, primarily due to soft-tissue deformations immediately upon acti-
vation, and long-term changes associated with tissue remodeling. Magnitude increases and, perhaps, directional alterations take place when the orthodontist reactivates the appliance. Detailed discussions of these phenomena are undertaken later in this text; in the present chapter, force systems are analyzed as if all involved entities are "frozen" at a particular instant in time.
ition and Decomposition of Concentrated Forces Two
fundamental analysis manipulations with point forces are dis-
cussed in this section. First, toward enabling the prediction of the form and direction of a potential rigid-body displacement associated with a system of active forces, the forces are combined in such a way that the mechanical effect of the original system remains unchanged while the resultant is as simple as possible. Second, often in the process of obtaining the resultant of a force system, the replacement of a force by a set of force components with each component having a designated direction is worthwhile. Beginning the first procedure with the fundamental operation, a pair of concentrated forces having intersecting lines of action has, as its resultant, a single force. The two original forces define a plane; the resultant lies in that plane and its line of action intersects the point where the
30
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
lines of action of the original forces come together. The means of reduc-
ing the two concurrent forces to a single force, mechanically equivalent to the combination of the original forces, is known as the parallelogram law of vector addition. To illustrate, Figure 2-3 shows a pair of point forces: one originating from an interarch elastic (EL) and the other from an extraoral appliance (HG); both are exerted on a maxillary molar bracket or buccal tube. The view is from the buccal on the right side. To obtain the resultant graphi-
cally, the directions and senses are sketched exactly as they exist in a two-dimensional picture of the appliance action. The force magnitudes are represented in the lengths of the vectors according to the given scale; because it is twice the magnitude, the length of the headgear force vector is twice that of the elastic force. The given forces intersect at point 0, the center of the bracket in the buccal view, and their vector representations form adjacent sides of a parallelogram. The dashed lines are added to complete the geometric figure. The vector representing the resultant is drawn as the diagonal of the parallelogram; the "tail" of the resultant vector coincides with the point where the "tails" of the given vectors
meet. Its sense is then known, the direction of the resultant may be determined with respect to a chosen reference line with a protractor, and the length of the vector representation is converted to the force magnitude through the scale as indicated. Note that if one of the forces is seemingly pushing on the point and the other is pulling on the point of intersection of their lines of action, one or the other vector must be moved along its line of action until either both "tails" or both "arrowheads" or "tips" of the vectors meet at the point. Then the parallelogram may be completed and the sense of the resultant is determined; either all three "tails" or all three "tips" meet at the common point.
0
EL = 200 g
HG = 400 g 0=
+ 02
Scale: 1 in. = bOg lengths = 2.8 in. H = 280 g = 28°
FIGURE 2-3. Graphical determination of the resultant of frio concurrent forces. The parallelogram law.
31
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
With the aid of a rough sketch, the resultant of two concurrent point forces may be obtained analytically. Seen in the parallelogram construclion of Figure 2-3 is a pair of congruent triangles with a shared side, a
diagonal, coinciding with the resultant vector. Two sides and the included angle of each triangle are known through the characteristics of the given forces. The laws of cosines and sines may then be used to obtain the magnitude of the resultant force and the orientation of its line
of action with that of a given force or some other known reference. Either the vector lengths or the actual magnitudes of the given forces, because length and force size are proportional, may be used in the computations which would proceed as follows: R=
+ HG2 — 2(EL)HG(cos 0) [2002 + 4002 2(200)400(cos 400)]h/2
= 278 g or approximately 10 oz
sin0 EL
=
.
(2-1)
200
R
cb=27.5°
The rough sketch is necessary, accompanying the analytic solution, to determine and illustrate the sense of the resultant force and location of its line of action. If the two forces to be "summed" are perpendicular to one another, the graphical procedure remains essentially unchanged, but the parallelogram becomes a rectangle. The pair of congruent triangles become a set of adjacent right triangles, and the analytic solution is simplified somewhat with the cosine and sine laws replaced by the Pythagorean theorem and the definition of one trigonometric function. An example solulion is given in Figure 2-4. The vector summations of Figures 2-3 and 2-4 may be handled alternatively, using a corollary of the parallelogram law: the triangle law.
R
Q2
= 36 = 6.8 oz
P = 3 oz
I tan 6 =
Q = 6 oz
P
0 = 27°
FIGURE 2-4. The resultant of two concurrent, mutually-perpendicular forces.
=
3
= 0.5
32
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
0
JR
HG
R
P
0 Q
FIGURE 2-5. Resultants obtained for the given forces of Figure 2-3 (top) and Figure 2-4 (bottom) using the triangle law.
Graphical solutions for the examples of Figures 2-3 and 2-4, using the triangle law, are shown in Figure 2-5. Recall that the "tails" or "tips" of the given force vectors must coincide when using the parallelogram law; the solution by the triangle law requires that the "tip" of one given force and the "tail" of the other be coincident. The resultant is drawn from the "tail" of one given force to the "lip" of the other so that the three forces form the sides of a triangle. Note that in summing two concurrent forces by means of the triangle law, one given force may have to be displaced to an artificial location in order that the resultant emerges in the construction along its proper line of action; alternatively, keeping both given forces on their original lines of action in the graphical approach, the resultant obtained is correct in all characteristics except for its actual point of application. Hence, care must be taken in using the triangle law so that the proper line of action of the resultant is ultimately determined and designated correctly.
33
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
The resultant of any number of point forces having lines of action all intersecting at one common point is a single, concentrated force; the line of action of the resultant passes through that same point. To determine the resultant of a system of three or more concurrent forces, the parallel-
ogram law or triangle law may be used repeatedly. Two of the given forces may be combined into one, that one combined with a third given force, and so forth until all of the given forces have been included in the process; the resultant emerges from the final combination involving the
last given force. Because any two of the concurrent forces define a unique plane in which their resultant will lie, the two procedures may be used in a three-dimensional problem. If all of the concurrent forces act in the same plane, the triangle law may be extended to a polygonal law.
Graphically, the given forces are drawn to scale with the "tip" of one touching the "tail" of the next until all have been included, in any order desired. The magnitude, direction, and sense of the resultant are determined by closing the polygon with the vector resultant having its "tip" touching that of the last given force drawn (and its "tail" touching that of the force with which the sketch was begun). The number of sides of the polygon is one more than the number of given forces. In this construction all but two of the given forces must be moved from their actual lines of action. The line of action of the resultant is known, though, to pass through the point common to the lines of action of the given forces. An example of the procedure using the polygonal law is illustrated with three given forces in Figure 2-6. In this example the forces are "added"
in the order indicated by the equation in the figure. The dashed lines suggest the graphical procedure by two successive applications of the parallelogram law. In a force-system analysis, the decomposition of given forces into com-
ponents is often desirable. The procedure is the reverse of that of the parallelogram or triangle law of vector addition. In Figure 2-3 the 200and 400-g forces could be considered components of the 278-g force. In analyses of orthodontic force systems, however, the component directions often coincide with the mutually perpendicular, dental-coordinate directions. In Figure 2-4, with proper orientation, the 3- and 6-oz forces become occlusogingival and mesiodistal components of the 6.8-oz force. The number of mutually perpendicular, nonzero components equals, at
most, the number of coordinate dimensions in a given problem: up to two in the plane problem and three in the spatial problem. Although the determination of vector components perpendicular to one another was outlined in Chapter 1, by way of review consider the example of Figure 2-7 in which the occlusal and mesial components of the 300-g force against the molar are obtained. Graphically, the parallelogram (actually a rectangle because perpendicular components are desired) is constructed around the 300-g force as its diagonal, drawn
to scale. The components are adjacent sides of the rectangle; their "tails" touch that of the given vector. The component magnitudes are obtained from their lengths and the scale factor for the sketch. Analyti-
34
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
V A = 4 oz
7-7
'7
7
B = 6 oz
0 R = 7.5 oz
,, 7, C = 5 oz
7,
7
7 R=A+B+C
FIGURE 2-6. Three concurrent, coplanar forces and their resultant obtained through the polygonal law.
cally, each rectangular-component magnitude is the product of its direction cosine and the magnitude of the given force as indicated in the figure. The three-dimensional problem of decomposition into mutually per-
pendicular components cannot be easily handled graphically. The analytic solution, however, can be a direct extension of that used in the plane problem. A rough sketch, particularly helpful toward determining component senses, should be used. In proceeding, first establish the coordinate directions and, perhaps, sketch the corresponding rectangular parallelepiped around the given force. Second, obtain a set of angles, either (1) the direction angles (angles between the given force and the coordinate axes), or (2) the angles to project the given vector into one of the coordinate planes and onto the axis perpendicular to that plane and, subsequently, to project the component in the plane onto the coordinate axes defining the plane. Again, the procedure illustrated by Figure 2-8 is a review of the spatial relationship between the vector and its mutually
35
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
0
300 0
280 g
F0 = F cos 70° = 300(0.34) = 1000 Fm = F cos 20° = F sin 700 = 300(0.94) = 280 g FIGURE 2-7. Decomposition of a concentrated force into two rectangular components. The parallelogram law in reverse.
perpendicular components previously discussed in Chapter 1 (see Fig.
1-12). Note that only two of the three direction angles need to be meas-
ured or estimated; the third angle can then be determined from the geometric relationship requiring the sum of the squares of the directions cosines to be unity.
a
d
F
I, i/I
a: apical d: distal 0: occlusal I:
F=l2oz
lingual
Fd = 12 cos 30° = 10.4 oz F0 = 12 cos 75° = 3.1 oz
F, = 12 cos 65° = 5.1 oz
(cos 300)2 + (cos 750)2 + (cos 650)2 = 1
FIGURE 2-8. Three mutually perpendicular components of a concentrated force not located in any of the three coordinate planes.
36
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
The Moment of a Concentrated Force action of a concentrated force upon a particle tends to produce, simply, a push or pull displacement; the particle is small and the force seemingly covers the particle as a whole. The magnitude, direction, and sense of the force, together with characteristics of the particle and its supporting structure, are collectively a measurement of the potential of the force to displace the particle. A force, exerted on a small portion of the total surface area of a relatively large body, tends to produce a displacement of the body which is generally rotational. The moment of a force about, or with respect to, a specified point or line is a measure of the potential of that force to rotate the body, upon which the force acts, about the particular point or line. Consider a rigid body that is hanging from a cord attached to just one point of the body. Label that point 0. A force F is exerted on the body so that its line of action does not pass through point 0. Define the line OB so that point B is on the line of action of the concentrated force F and the two lines intersect at right angles to one another. As depicted in Figure 2-9, the line OB and the line of action of force F define a plane. If the distance from point 0 measured along OB is d to the line of action of F, the magnitude of the moment of force F about point 0 is the product of the force magnitude F and the distance d. Given the manner of support of the body in the figure, the application of force F would displace the body from the position shown and cause an angular change in the initially vertical line through point G (the center of gravity, through which the weight resultant acts). The moment of a force about a point is a vector quantity; the direction of the moment vector is perpendicular to the plane defined by the force vector and the point. The sense of the moment vector is determined by a rule associated with the apparent rotational tendency, clockwise or counterclockwise as viewed from above the plane of the force and the point about which the moment is determined: out of the plane if counterclockwise and into the plane if clockwise. The moment vector is located such that its line of action passes through the point about which the moment is computed, and may be specifically positioned wherever convenient along its line of action. The moment vector of magnitude Fd is shown in Figure 2-9. Force and moment vectors may not be directly combined in a force-system analysis and, because the two types of vectors may appear in the same sketch, the short slash is incorporated near the arrowhead in the symbol for the moment vector. To obtain the moment of a force about a point, three quantities must be completely known: (1) the force itself; (2) the point about which the moment is to be found or moment center (point 0 in Fig. 2-9); and (3) the The
length of the moment arm extending from the moment center and traversing the shortest distance to the line of action of the force (line OB in Fig. 2-9). From the determination of the moment of a force about a point, the
37
Introduction to Malysis of Orthodontic Force
Mzz = F(d) = F(d)(cos 0)
FIGURE 2-9. A concentrated torce and moment vectors with respect to lines (axes) through point 0.
38
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
potential of the force to produce rotation about a particular line through
the point may be obtained. The rotational potential with respect to a line, a moment axis, has the greater application in orthodontic mechanics. In Figure 2-9, the moment of F about point 0 is also the moment of the
given force with respect to the line Z-Z. To obtain the moment about another line through point 0, line L-L in Figure 2-9 for example, the magnitude of the moment about line Z-Z is multiplied by the cosine of the angle between L-L and Z-Z. The vector component is the directed projection of the moment about Z-Z on line L-L. Apparent now is the general, three-dimensional nature of the moment representation and computation. The moment axis typically does not lie in the plane of the force and the moment arm. In fact, if the moment axis is in the plane of the force and moment arm, either the axis intersects the line of action of the force and, therefore, the length of the moment arm is zero, or the axis is parallel to the force; in both cases the tendency for rotation about the specified axis is nonexistent, and, correspondingly, the moment with respect to the specific axis is zero. In the general problem, the force for which the rotational potential is sought
likely will not be perpendicular to the moment axis, and one of two approaches may be used: (1) the procedure followed in Figure 2-9 in which the moment vector with respect to point 0 was projected onto line L-L; or (2) the process of Figure 2-10. In the latter approach, the force R is decomposed into components parallel (P) and perpendicular (Q) to the moment axis S-S. Now, the moment of the resultant of several con-
current forces must be equal to the vector sum of the moments of the individual forces with respect to the same axis (a theorem established by the French mathematician Varignon in the late 1600s, before the advent
of vector algebra). Since the moment of P about axis S-S is zero, the magnitude of the moment of R equals that of Q: Qb; the sense is as shown in the figure according to the rule previously established. In problems in which the forces of interest all exist in the same plane, the moment concept may be put into a two-dimensional format. Rotational potentials are obtained with respect to axes that are perpendicular to the plane of the force. In sketches these axes will appear in end views, or as apparent points in the plane. Moment vectors with respect to these moment centers will all have a common direction: perpendicular to the plane of the forces. They may then be treated as algebraic quantities with the distinction between moments having clockwise or counterclockwise rotational potentials made merely by a sign convention. To determine the net rotational tendency with respect to a particular moment axis, owing to the action of several forces, either of two procedures may be followed. The moment vectors may be obtained for each individual force with respect to a particular point on the moment axis, these concurrent vectors may be combined into one by methods of vector addition already discussed, and the resultant moment vector may then be projected onto the moment axis to obtain the magnitude and sense of the rotational potential of the force system. Alternatively, the resultant of the system of forces may be sought and the moment of the resultant then found with respect to the specified moment axis.
39
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
0
0 R
7 I
I
/J
Mss 1
= Q(b)
FIGURE 2-10. A force in space, decomposed into components parallel and perpendicular to a given line, and its moment vector with respect to that line.
The former procedure is employed in Figure 2-11 to obtain the net moment of a pair of concurrent forces with respect to the z-axis of the reference framework. In this instance a two-dimensional solution may be carried out in the plane of the given forces; the z-axis would be perpendicular to the plane of the forces and in the sketch it is, in effect, point 0. The curved-arrow notation indicates the senses of the moments of the 120- and 90-g forces and of the net moment. Two moment computations are displayed with magnitudes and senses obtained with respect to moment axes perpendicular to the plane of the forces through points O and E. The net moment being equal to the moment of the resultant of the two forces enables the determinations of the actual moment arms of the 150-g force with respect to points 0 and E; the moment-arm lengths
are symbolized by o and e, respectively. Viewing the 120- and 90-g forces as x- and y-components of the l50-g force, whether or not to decompose
a force into rectangular components to obtain its moment will depend upon the ease of the actual decomposition process and the establishment of the moment arms of the components versus the determination of the actual moment arm of the given force. The latter can often be a
40
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
y
M0 = 90(3)1 + 120(2) 30 g-mm
= 420 g-mm J M0 30 o = -h-- = = 0.2 mm
d=
\ E(5,0)
ME
=
420
= 2.8 mm
x
0 FIGURE 2-11. Determination of the moment of a force about a point in two dimensions by using rectangular components of that force in the plane.
seemingly difficult geometry program while the moment arms of the
components become clear after the coordinates of the moment center and one point on the line of action of the force are known. The more complex problems of determining the net rotational effect of a system of forces, which may be two-dimensional but nonconcurrent
or three-dimensional in nature, have been outlined as to general approach. They are more easily discussed in detail, however, following the
introduction in the next section, "The Couple."
The Couple A pair of point forces having equal magnitudes and identical directions,
opposite in sense to one another and having noncoincident lines of action, when considered as one mechanical entity is termed a couple. Because the forces have the same magnitude, but are oppositely directed, the net potential of this special force system to translate the body upon which it acts is nil. The lines of action of the two forces are parallel, but are not coincident; as a result, this force system tends to rotate the body acted upon. Also, since the forces are nonconcurrent, they cannot
be combined and, therefore, the couple cannot be simplified further. The couple, occupying a specific plane as defined by the two forces, is illustrated in Figure 2-12. The rotational potential of the couple with respect to point 0, or about a moment axis perpendicular to the plane
through 0, is the sum of the moments of the individual forces with respect to the point. Using the procedure and notation of Figure 2-11,
41
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
y
M0 = 300(1) 300 g
+ 300(3)
= 600 g-mm) = 300(2)
= 600 g-mm)
2mm
= 300(1)) + 300(1))
•
=600g-mm) M0 = 300(3)) + 300(1)
C(2,2)
= 600 g-mm) 8(11) 300 g
D(4,0)
0
x
FIGURE 2-12. A couple and computations of its inherent moment.
noting that with respect to point 0 one moment is clockwise and the
other is counterclockwise, the net moment is found to be 600 g-mm counterclockwise. Using the points B, C, and D as individual moment centers, the same moment is obtained in the three computations—the same as that with respect to point 0. In fact, for all moment centers in or moment axes perpendicular to the plane of the couple, the same result emerges. A couple has, then, an inherent moment, and the magnitude of the couple itself is that of the inherent moment, the product of the size
of one of the forces and the perpendicular distance between the two forces. Because the moments of the individual forces are vector quantities, so also is that of the couple and it follows that the couple itself may be represented mathematically as a vector. The direction of the couple is
associated with the plane of the pair of forces and the sense with its rotational potential, either clockwise or counterclockwise, as viewed looking into the plane of the couple. Figure 2-13 displays a couple and its vector representation (and that of its moment). The direction of the vector C is perpendicular to the plane of the couple (and the "moment arm" b between the forces) and the sense is determined according to the convention noted earlier for moment vectors: out of the plane if viewed as counterclockwise, into the plane if clockwise. Note the slash through the symbol, again to differentiate between force and moment vectors. A couple is completely described when specified are its magnitude,
the plane of the two forces, its sense, and, if the body is nonrigid, the actual points of application of the two forces. The value of the couple as
42
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics C = Pb
FIGURE 2-13. A couple in its plane and its vector representation perpendicular to that plane.
an analysis tool, however, is in the determination of whole-body displacement potential and, when so used, the specific points of application are unimportant. Although its vector representation in Figure 2-13 is shown midway between the two forces, because the moment of the couple is the same with respect to every moment axis perpendicular to the plane of the forces, the vector has no particular line-of-action location and may be drawn through any point of the plane of the couple. This "freedom" associated with the couple vector has far-reaching implications with respect to certain force-analysis procedures. To review, a force acting on a rigid body has the potential, generally, to both translate and rotate the body. Sliding the force along its line of
action will not change this potential. The tendency to rotate the body about a specific axis is associated with the vector characteristics of the force and also with the location of the line of action of that force because the axis and the line define a moment arm. Moving the line of action of the force with respect to the moment axis alters the force direction or the moment arm and, therefore, changes the translational or rotational potential of the force.
The couple, however, has been shown to possess an inherent rotational potential and no tendency to produce translation. Apparently, then, as long as the characteristics of the couple are unchanged, the forces making up the couple may be altered without affecting wholebody response; it follows, though, that an alteration of one force of the pair necessitates a comparable change in the other. Indeed, the use of properties of and operations on forces already discussed, including the
43
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
parallelogram law, demonstrates that the following alterations may be
made without affecting the mechanical effect of the couple on the body as a whole: (1) the forces may be moved ("slid") along their individual lines of action; (2) the forces may be rotated in the plane of the couple, keeping their lines of action mutually parallel and the distance between
them unchanged; (3) the couple may be moved as a whole from the given plane to another parallel plane; and (4) the magnitudes of the forces may be altered, while preserving the equality of force magnitudes
and the moment of the couple, the latter by making a corresponding change in the distance between the lines of action of the forces. Figure 2-14 shows four mechanically-equivalent couples, one being a
curved-arrow representation which is convenient in two-dimensional analyses. These permissible movements of the couple, and the allowable correlated changes in the force magnitudes and the distances between
their lines of action, are embodied in the vector representation of the couple. The couple acting on a rigid body is, mathematically, a "free" vector, having no specific line-of-action location as noted previously. Frce and moment vectors may not be directly combined, and the slash through the moment-vector symbol is a reminder of this fact. Perhaps unfortunately, however, no symbolic distinction is made that would indicate the difference between the vector representing the moment of a single point force and that depicting a couple with its inherent
800 g 200 g .75 mm
-.
mm
200g
600 9-mm
800 g
FIGURE 2-14. Four mechanically-equivalent couples.
300 9
44 Rioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
moment. Note that the moment vector, representing the rotational po-
tential of the concentrated force with respect to a specific moment center or axis, is not a "free" vector. On the other hand, because a couple is a
free vector and through its two-force representation, a couple may be combined with a third force. The form of the resultant from this combination is particularly dependent on the direction of the third force with respect to the couple vector. Figure 2-15 shows the relative position of the force and couple vectors, enabling the placement of the two forces of the couple in a plane containing the third force, which leads to a simple resultant. Figure 2-16 illustrates the combination procedure. With the three forces in the same plane, the couple is represented as two forces having magnitudes equal to that of the single force; the distance between the forces making up the couple is then determined. Next, the couple is translated and rotated in the plane so that one force of the couple shares the line of action of single force and is opposed (in sense) to it. The now directly opposite forces cancel one another and one concentrated force from the original three remains, having the same vector characteristics as the original single force, but with a line of action some distance from it. The procedure of combining a force and a couple may also be carried out in reverse. Given a single force having specific characteristics, including location of line of action, a force and a couple may replace it without altering the whole-body displacement potential. The transla-
800 g-mm
H
FIGURE 2-15. Mutually-perpendicular force and couple vectors referenced to the plane of the force system.
45
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force 200 g
200g
200g
/
mm
/
/
200 g
I B
200 g
200g
/
FIGURE 2-16. Reducing the force and couple of Figure 2-15 to a single force.
tional potential remains unchanged if the force portion of the new sys-
tem has the same vector characteristics as the given force. To leave the rotational potential unaltered, the magnitude, direction, and sense of the couple must correlate with the position of the line of action of the force of the substituted system with respect to that of the given force. In Figure 2-17, in occlusal view the force exerted on the edgewise orthodontic bracket is "moved" by means of the addition of the couple to a parallel position through the long-axis of the tooth. Although seemingly adding to the complexity of a force system, the procedure provides a means to "free" the force vector from its specified location and permit lateral movement of its line of action. A couple is a special two-force system. In orthodontic application, active couples are often created upon bracket engagement of arch wires a
C = Qe
FIGURE 2-17. Moving the line of action of a force 0 through introduction of a couple C. The reverse of the process illustrated in Figure 2-16.
46
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
into which permanent bends or twists have been placed. The dimension
of the couple magnitude is the product of force and length. The couple tends to cause only rotation of the body on which it acts. In addition to its importance as a displacement-producing system, the couple is useful in analysis because it alone enables the transfer of a concentrated force, exerted on a rigid body, from its given location to a parallel, alternative line of action associated with the same rigid body.
Resultants of Force Systems Exerted on Rigid Bodies definition of force, presented earlier in this chapter, was stated in terms of its potential to influence the motion of the body acted upon. In
The
discussions of forces, moments, and couples thus far, references to translational and rotational displacements have been made. The word "resultant" was used previously in discussing the replacement of two forces by one through use of the parallelogram or triangle law. In the analysis of a class of particle- and rigid-body-mechanics problems, including certain applications to orthodontics, relationships are sought between an active system of forces and a displacement pattern to be achieved by, or to result from, force application. Because the force systems often are somewhat complicated in their actual formats, the replacement of the given system by another, which is mechanically equivalent but more easily related to the potential or actual displacement of the body, is usually desirable, if not necessary. Generally, this new or replacement system is simpler, and is termed a resultant of the original force system. It is possible to reduce any force system acting on a body, when relationships between the given system and whole-body displacement potentials are sought, to one force and one couple, and in some instances to just a single force or just one couple. Clearly, these are the most simple resultants.
In the process of determining the displacement format of a body subjected to a set of forces, the resultant of the entire, active force system is sought. (Recall that the active forces "load" the body and are distinguished from responsive forces, which come into being because of contact between the body and whatever supports it. Generally, the respon-
sive force system is present in some form, however abbreviated, even before the loading is applied to the body, simply because of the member weights and the physical contact of the body with its supporting structure. Loading the body, then, usually alters the responsive force system in some manner.) Although a more simple resultant of the active force system may exist, and often does, the resultant sought is usually that referenced to a point in the body known as its center of resistance. The location of the center of resistance depends upon the size and shape of the body, the distribution of the weight of the body, and the manner in which the body is supported. In general, the location of the center of resistance of a body must be found experimentally or approximately by
47
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
appropriate analytic analysis; simple force systems are applied and displacement responses are observed or determined and specific displacement formats are sought. an
Upon the application of loading to a body, which results in an activeplus-responsive force system, and if the entire force system exerted on the body is not completely self-balancing, one of three forms of displacement occurs. Translation is that displacement within which no line in the body experiences a change in angular position (orientation) with respect to a fixed reference line. If the body is rigid, during translation all points in the body follow parallel paths; although these paths may be straight lines, they may also be curvilinear without violating the requisites for translation. In order for a translational displacement to result from the application of force, the resultant of the applied, active force system mj.ist reduce to a single concentrated force, and the line of action of that force must pass through the center of resistance of the body. When the resultant of the active force system is a couple, the resulting displacement is termed pure rotation. All points in or on the body move in circular paths; the centers of those circles are all on one line or axis that pierces the center of resistance of the body. The vector representing the resultant couple is parallel to the axis of rotation. The most common form of displacement is a combination of translation and pure rotation and is known as generalized rotation. The resultant of the active force system is usually expressed as one force and one couple. The displacement may be difficult to describe except to note that the angulation of the body has changed. If the applied force system is two-dimensional and the resultant of the active force system reduces to a single force, its line of action does not pierce the center of resistance of the body, and for small displacements or if the resultant remains constant in all characteristics with respect to the body acted upon, the motion is circular about an axis perpendicular to the plane of the forces but not passing through the center of resistance. Except when the active force system consists entirely of couples, at least a portion of the resultant problem is the simplification of a concurrent force system. Although the parallelogram or triangle law may be used to reduce the concurrent system to a single force, an alternative procedure may be more simple if numerous forces are involved; its advantage in an analytic approach is organization. Useful in both two- and three-dimensional problems, the process follows a sequence of four steps: (1) a coordinate framework is established; (2) each given force is decomposed into its coordinate components; (3) the algebraic sum of each set of components is determined, thereby obtaining the resultant components; and (4) the resultant components may be combined into one single force, using the parallelogram law or the three-dimensional extension of it. A re-examination of a previous example serves to illustrate this procedure (see Fig. 2-3). Figure 2-18 shows the elastic and headgear forces referenced to a chosen framework in a buccal-plane view, the given forces decomposed into components along the reference axes, the resultant components,
48
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
0
0
m
d
192g
365 g
55 9
200 g
400 9
163 g
0
Rd = 400 sin 66° — 200 sin 74°
=365—192=173g = 400 cos 66°+ 200 cos 74°
Rd
d i
=163+55=218g
//1 I
R
I
= '11732 + 2182 = 278 g
FIGURE 2-18. The resultant of several concurrent forces obtained through the use of force components. A two-dimensional example.
and the single-force resultant together with the computations providing
the force characteristics sought. The resultant components as computed suggest that the displacement should have a strong, occlusally directed aspect, but some potential for distal movement also exists. The resultant force does not pass through the center of resistance of the tooth in this two-dimensional analysis. The procedure for determining the resultant of a general force system, consisting of both point forces and couples exerted on a rigid body, is as follows. First, when the entire active force system is under investigation, a reference point is chosen that often will be the center of resistance of the body if its location is known. A coordinate framework is
established, centered at the reference point, with coordinate axes o* ented according to the force-system layout. Second, each concentrated force is transferred from its given line of action to a parallel line passing through the reference point. Displacing the force in this manner requires
the addition of a couple to the force system. Following the approach shown in Figure 2-17, the magnitude of the couple added equals the product of the force magnitude and the perpendicular distance between the new and given lines of action of the force. The sense of the couple is that of the moment of the original force about the reference point. In a
three-dimensional problem, the couple will be represented in vector fashion with its direction perpendicular to the plane of the given and new force vectors. The given force system has now been transformed into a set of concurrent point forces at the chosen reference point and a set of couples (including those given and those created in "moving" forces).
49
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
Third, the forces are combined and the set reduced to a single concentrated force, using the parallelogram or triangle law or following the process outline with Figure 2-18 in which each force is decomposed into coordinate components. The couples, properly represented by free vectors, can all be gathered at any reference point and reduced to one couple. The choice of reduction procedures is the same as that for reducing a system of concurrent force vectors. The given force system now has been replaced by an equivalent system consisting of one point force, or
its two or three rectangular coordinate components, at the reference point and a single couple (or its two or three components). Fourth and finally, to the extent possible or desirable, the force and couple may be
combined; in this part of the process, the direct association with the ref eMnce point is lost (unless, as determined, no couple portion of the resultant exists as associated with the point). In the special circumstance when the force and couple vectors are perpendicular to one another, this pair may be reduced further to a single force. In the plane problem, if
both force and couple, as found with respect to the chosen reference point, are nonzero, these vectors are always mutually perpendicular and, therefore, may be combined to yield the single-force resultant. A two-dimensional resultant problem, using the procedure just outlined, is presented in Figure 2-19. The rectangular plate is viewed from above, initially resting on a frictionless surface. The three forces and the couple are then applied, and the resultant is sought toward description of the displacement produced by the loading. If the plate is homogeneous (its weight uniformly distributed throughout its volume), point 0 at
the geometric center is the center of resistance. By the choice of the 300 g
8mm
2mm
4—
8mm
—
lOOg
200g
L
X
= 300(4)) + 100(0)
= 300— 100 = 200 g
+ 200(4)) + 960)
= —200 g 01 200 g
R=V2002+2002=2800 200 1
°x =
=560g-mm) M0
—h—560 == 2mm
FIGURE 2-19. The resultant of a general two-dimensional force system acting on a solid body.
50
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
orientation of the x-y-coordinate framework, no decomposition of any of
the given forces is necessary in this example. Each force is then moved to point 0; the line of action of one of the given forces passes through 0, so the creation of the concurrent force system there requires the introduction of two additional couples. The resultant force components are determined, then the force portion of the resultant at point 0. The three couples may be combined in algebraic fashion, since they occupy a common plane. Note that the couple portion of the resultant has characteristics identical to those of the sum of the moments of the given forces with respect to point 0; this is always the case, whether the problem is twoor three-dimensional (with vector addition of moments necessary in the spatial situation). The motion resulting from the application of the force system may now be described: point 0 moves in the direction and sense of the 280-g force with accompanying counterclockwise rotation of the plate. The final sketch shows the single-force resultant following combination of the force and couple portions of the resultant (see the procedure shown in Fig. 2-16); the line of action of the single force is fixed and is totally unrelated to the initial choice of point 0 as the reference point for the solution. The typical resultant problems in orthodontic mechanics involve a
single tooth or a dental segment. Because the active force system is ordinarily applied to the labial or lingual crown surface(s), the problem is generally three-dimensional. Although seemingly a somewhat indirect and lengthy process, from the standpoint of ease of viewing, the elimination of the need to express couples in the vector format, and the definitions of orthodontic displacements, it is usually convenient to decom-
pose the actual spatial situation into two or three two-dimensional portions. Employing as the reference the center of resistance as seen in each dental coordinate plane needed, in each plane the force-system components are reduced to force and couple resultant components. If
then desired, as a final step in the solution, the components may be combined and the resultant expressed in the three-dimensional format.
Distributed Forces and Their Resultants Earlier, contact forces were noted as being associated with surface areas
of the bodies acted upon. If such forces directly affect only a small portion of the total surface area of the body, in modeling, that small area is
collapsed around a surface point and a concentrated force is exerted there. On the other hand, when a force system is spread over a relatively sizable portion of the surface area in a continuous manner, the system is termed a distributed force. A resultant, a point force and/or a couple, may
be determined to replace the distributed force system for purposes of examination of whole-body displacement tendencies. When considering associated deformations, however, it is necessary to differentiate among forces according to the sizes of contact areas involved.
51
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
Two familiar examples of distributed force are that exerted by a load of grain or coal against the floor and sides of a railroad car and the force of water pushing against a dam. In the analysis of any distributed force, the pattern of distribution must be established and, to this end, the total contact area is partitioned into small portions. The amount of the total
force associated with each small part of the subdivided area is determined; for each partial area the fraction of the total force divided by that
partial area is the intensity of force there (measured, for example, in pounds per square inch). Generally, the intensity of force varies from one location to another over the total area covered by the distribution. In the railroad-car example, the distributed force arises from the weight of the contents; the depth of the grain at any specific location measured vertically from the car floor is proportional to the local intensity of contact force against the floor. Water pressure increases directly with depth,
and the pressure at a point or level beneath the water surface is the intensity of force there. If the car floor and the dam-water interface are plane surfaces, the forces against each partial area are parallel to one another. In problems involving curved surfaces, the distributions may be decomposed into components yielding two or three systems of parallel, distributed forces. The number of parallel forces in a specific force distribution equals the number of parts into which the contact area is divided. The larger the number of partial areas, the better the approximation by a set of discrete forces of a continuous distribution. If the intensity of force at any location can be expressed mathematically in terms of the coordinates of the location within the contact area, an exact representation of the distribution may be available. Two examples of distributed force occurring with the activation of an orthodontic appliance are the "loading" of the periodontal ligament
by a tooth root and the force system generated within the adhesive when an engaged arch wire transfers contact force through a bonded bracket pad (or when a masticatory force is unintentionally exerted on the bracket). Distributed forces can be external or internal to a body under study; in an analysis of the railroad-car floor, the force of the grain
or coal is a distributed, external load, and every activated arch wire "contains" distributed, internal force. The dimensions of force intensity are force divided by length squared and the intensity of internal force is known as stress. Another vector quantity, stress is discussed in detail in Chapter 3. The systems of distributed force of orthodontic interest may be represented or modeled by one or more sets of parallel forces, with all forces in a set having the same sense. The resultant of a set of such forces is a single force having the direction and sense of the set, with its line of action passing through the center of the distribution (generally not the center of the associated contact area). Although the problem is inherently three-dimensional, many force distributions vary in only one direction parallel to the contact area. In such problems, the two-dimensional sketch of interest wifi contain directions referencing the magnitude of the force intensity from point to point and the associated
52
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
coordinate locating points of the contact area; the area itself will appear
only in edge view. In Figure 2-20, two particular distributions for which the determination of resultants is straightforward are displayed with their resultants. The distributions are assumed uniform in the direction perpendicular to the page and, for simplicity, the areas are assumed to be rectangular with the dimension not seen (perpendicular to the sketch) symbolized by w. The independent coordinate x, extending from zero to L, locates points along the edge of the area and, generally, the intensity (at any point represented by the height of the diagram) may be expressed mathematically as a function of the coordinate x. For any distribution of parallel forces, all having the same sense, the resultant magnitude equals the average intensity multiplied by the area covered by the distribution. For the uniformly distributed loading on the left in the figure, the intensity, which is the same everywhere, is clearly the average intensity. For the linearly increasing, triangular distribution, the average intensity is onehalf of the sum of the minimum (zero) and maximum intensities. Note that the resultant force may be computed as the area, within the boundary of the distribution seen in the figure, multiplied by the width w of the rectangular area covered by the distributed force system. In a dimensional analysis, force/(length2) multiplied by length gives force/length for the "area" of the sketched diagram, and this multiplied by another p
h
L
(L,p0)
(L,h0)
x
— — — — ——1
\ \\ P = h0Lw
4
.1
L
L
L
-
J
3
Lw
\\
\\
FIGURE 2-20. The resultants of uniform and linearly-varying, parallel, distributed forces.
53
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
length (perpendicular to the plane of the sketch) yields force. Also note
the locations of the resultant forces; their lines of action pierce the cen-
ters of the rectangular and triangular "areas" shown in the figure. Again, this development is restricted to distributions over rectangular areas where the intensifies vary only in one direction along one edge of an area. Do not confuse the two areas that have been mentioned: the rectangular contact area over which the force is distributed and the area within the distribution-of-force sketch.
Friction Two materials touching one another share a contact area. The resistance
to movement tangent to this area, of one material relative to the other, is known as friction. Friction may be generated between dry solid surfaces; the resistance to displacement may be lessened if a lubricant is placed between the contacting surfaces. Friction may exist between two solid surfaces, at a solid-fluid interface, or between fluid layers. Friction be-
tween solids is termed rolling or sliding, depending upon the form of relative movement attempted; rolling resistance is highly dependent on the amount of localized deformation where contact occurs. The resistance that precludes actual motion is termed static friction; that which exists during motion is called dynamic friction. Both the static and dynamics forms of sliding friction are of orthodontic interest. Sliding friction is
generated between arch wire and bracket when the wire "guides" the bracket during mesiodistal movement of an individual tooth or when the arch wire is slipped through posterior crown attachments in, for example, the retraction of an anterior dental segment. A classical model of frictional analysis is depicted in Figure 2-21. Before the active force P is applied, to produce intended horizontal movement to the left, the fixed surface on which the block rests responds only to the weight of the block with an upward force, perpendicular to the plane contact area. This force, often symbolized by N (representing "normal") is actually the resultant of a distributed force system
against the bottom, rectangular face of the block and, if the block is homogeneous, initially the distribution is uniform over the contact area. With the application of the force P at a relatively low magnitude, the
responsive distribution of the force against the bottom surface of the block becomes nonuniform and the magnitude, direction, and point of application of the resultant of the distribution are altered. With P sufficiently small, however, the block remains stationary and the changes in characteristics of the responsive force from the horizontal surface take place because the contacting surfaces are not perfectly smooth. (If absolutely no friction existed, the application of P, however small in magni-
tude, would result in motion with no change from the static (P = 0) configuration in the responsive surface force.) With the application of the force
the now-inclined, responsive, resultant force R may be de-
54
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Wi
P
f
p ,-p 777'?
N
FIGURE 2-21. Active and responsive forces exerted on a block supported by a rough horizontal surface.
composed into components perpendicular (normal) and parallel (tan-
gential) to the contact area. Since no potential for vertical motion exists, the normal component is N and the tangential component, in the direction of but opposite in sense to the intended displacement, is the resistive force of friction. Increasing the magnitude of P results in a conesponding increase in the magnitude of the frictional force f, but motion does not occur until the force of friction reaches a maximum value corre-
sponding to a critical magnitude of the applied force P. A slight, additional increase in P beyond this critical size results in motion, and the force of friction generally decreases slightly from the "maximum 1' as the static situation becomes dynamic. A plot of the frictional force versus the applied force P for the model described is displayed in Figure 2-22. Controlled experiments in which frictional forces between plane surfaces were measured have determined that the maximum f and the level
of the frictional force following the initiation of motion are highly dependent on the relative roughness of the contacting surfaces and thtmagnitude of the normal force component N. In the classical model, fmax and the dynamic frictional force are individually assumed proportional to N;
the proportionality constants are the static and dynamic coefficients of friction, quantified empirically for pairs of contacting surfaces. Note that in the static model only the maximum frictional-force magnitude is equal
to the product of the static frictional coefficient and the normal force component N and the model does not consider the manner of distribution of contact force between the surfaces. The classical block-on-plane analysis gives a good fundamental basis
for examining the problem of friction between arch wire and bracket slot. The block and plane are analogous to the wire and slot, but while
55
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
Frictional Component
(Pent, fmax)
Static
Dynamic
Activating Force P FIGURE 2-22. Relationship between the magnitudes of active and frictional forces, P and f, for the block and surface of Figure 2-2 1.
only one contact area exists in the foregoing example (Fig. 2-21), the
orthodontic problem is three-dimensional in that the wire may contact the bracket slot and the accompanying ligation at as many as four locations simultaneously. The direction of the frictional force is bounded by the angulations of wire and bracket slot; the sense opposes the relative motion and depends upon whether force is exerted on the bracket or the wire (action-reaction). If the bracket is to move distally on the wire, the frictional force against the bracket is generally toward the mesial (and its action-reaction counterpart against the wire is directed distally). If the wire is to slide toward the posterior through a stationary bracket, the frictional force from the wire and against the bracket acts toward the distal (since the force of friction against the wire is directed mesially, opposing the intended motion). Oscillation between static and dynamic forms of friction occurs between the wire and slot in an activated retraction appliance as the relative movement takes place in small "steps." As viewed buccally, one or more of four separate forms of contact between bracket and arch wire may be observed during canine retraction. These four forms of contact are shown in Figure 2-23 and a pair of components, normal and frictional forces, would generally exist at each individual contact area. Influencing the normal component of contact force, and therefore the level of friction, are the angulation between arch wire and bracket and the tightness of the ligation. The wire material and that of the ligature, for a given bracket, also influence the frictional resistance. Beyond the classical model, the difference in contact areas that exists with round versus rectangular wire likely affects the magnitude of frictional resistance. For a more complete discussion of friction between bracket and wire, refer to Frank and Nikolai (1980).
56
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Zero angulation, clearance
One-edge contact, clearance
f4
Two-edge contact, zero clearance
Snug wire/slot fit, zero clearance
FIGURE 2-23. Bucca! views of possible contact modes between bracket and orthodontic
arch wire.
Concepts of Mechanical Equilibrium and Their Applicability to Orthodontic Mechanics The definition of "mechanical equilibrium" of a solid body represents an extension of Newton's First Law for a particle. In effect, the practical definition says that the net tendencies for translation and rotation of the body are nil: if the magnitudes of the force and couple portions of the entire force system exerted on the body are both the body is in mechanical equilibrium. If the body was stationary before
this "balanced" force system was applied, the system adds zero net potential for whole-body motion. The balanced force system creates no
inertia, where inertia is proportional to the products of mass and the acceleration components of the body. When the total force system is unbalanced, one or the other or both portions of the resultant of that system are nonzero, an extension of Newton's Second Law governs,
57 Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
and the body undergoes accelerated motion and has been given some
inertia.
An important notion in this discussion is that of the "entire force system": all of the external forces and couples, both active and responsive,
exerted on the body under study. The definition of mechanical equilibrium may be extended to apply to groups of bodies or assemblies. Inter-
nal forces, by definition being within the body or assembly, exist in cancelling pairs and, therefore, collectively contribute nothing to a resultant computation. Internal forces, however, may become external, for
example, when an assembly is disassembled for purposes of analysis and one body or member is studied individually. Pairs of forces associated with the connection(s) of this body to others in the assembly are internal to the assembly, but one of each pair of forces is external to the one member. Under the influence of an activated orthodontic appliance, the dentilion should not be static. Over a finite period of time the teeth are to be moyed and, correspondingly, within the appliance itself, relative movements and changes in as-activated shapes may occur. The concept of the resultant of a system of forces has been discussed toward establishing a procedure by which forms of displacement caused by active forces might be predicted. Also created with the activation of the appliance, however,
are responsive force systems in need of description: the force system transmitted through the tooth and exerted by the root on the periodontal ligament, and that delivered by the appliance to the "anchorage," for example. Force analyses of the entire tooth, segment, and the appliance and its
elements or parts are to be carried out, but exact results need not be obtained. Note, then, that although appliance activation generally results in the creation of some translational and rotational inertia, in the dentition as well as in the appliance, these levels of inertia are not sizable. Both parametric parts of the inertia, the mass and the time rate of change of velocity (the acceleration), are small. Although the entire complex is more dynamic immediately following activation, during the short lime period of soft-tissue deformations, than during the much longer period of tissue remodeling, tooth displacement, and appliance deactivation, the contributions of inertia to the analysis may reasonably be neglected, even in comparison to the smallest of active forces. The pair
of governing vector equations of the orthodontic dynamics problem may, then, be written as Vector sum of all forces
inertia =
(Vector sum of all moments +jot&ti
liriertia)mass center =
0
With the inertia terms deleted, the relationships are those associated with the definition of mechanical equilibrium. The equations are necessary and sufficient conditions for a mechanically static system. Thus, at
58
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
any instant following activation, the dentition and appliance are said to
exist in a quasi-static state and the equations of mechanical equilibrium may be employed to obtain a close approximation to the relative magni-
tudes of the components of the active and responsive force systems. The rationale for the consideration of the mechanical equilibrium problem and its analysis is, therefore, established. The general problem may be stated as follows: Given a body or group of interconnected bodies subjected to a system of external forces and couples, such that the state produced by the system is mechanically static, determine the relationships that must hold among the characteristics of the external force system. Often the problem is one in which several of the characteristics of the force system are quantified and those characteristics that are not given explicitly are to be obtained. Nearly indispensable in proceeding toward the solution of all but the simplest of problems is the use of the free-body diagram, and several of
these diagrams may be needed to solve one problem. In the solution procedure, a body or assembly of bodies is earmarked for study and, as the name suggests, is "freed" from its surroundings (its supporting structure and all of its connections to other bodies); this is depicted in an isolated sketch. All of the external forces and couples exerted, both active and responsive, are shown in the sketch. As has been the convention in previous force diagrams, forces and couples exerted on (not by) the body are displayed. Not only the completed known portions of the force system, but also those forces and couples with unknown characteristics, must be properly depicted. Moreover, to aid in moment computa-
tions, distances and dimensions must be included. Omitting existing parts of the force system, including nonexistent forces or couples, and incorrectly identifying support structures of force-transmission mechanisms (connections) are typical mistakes made in these problems. Once the free-body diagram has been correctly completed, however, the interrelationships among the known and unknown force-system characteristics may be expressed in a rather straightforward manner. For each freebody diagram drawn, a set of scalar equations may be written, obtained from the pair of governing vector relationships written previously. In words, these equations say: All of the forces exerted on the body or group of bodies, pictured and under study, must balance, and the moments of all of the forces and coupies, with respect to any chosen moment center or axis, must also balance.
(This is an alternative way of stating that both the force and couple portions of the resultant of the entire force system must have zero mag-
nitudes.) The number of independent, scalar, algebraic relationships that may be written from each free-body diagram will depend upon the type of force system and whether the problem is one-, two-, or threedimensional.
In the quasi-static orthodontic problem, because body forces are nearly always negligible in comparison with contact forces, understand-
59
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
ing the manner of transfer of force through a connection is fundamen-
tally important. Connections of specific interest include those between the tooth crown and appliance element(s) and between individual parts of the orthodontic appliance. Before examining connections within the appliance, however, the displaying of responsive forces and couples having unknown characteristics and several general types of connections are considered. The complete description of a concentrated support or connection force generally requires the definition of several scalar quantities. The magnItude of a force or couple is the most common unknown in the equilibrium problem. To define the direction of the line of action of a force, one scalar quantity, the size of an angle relative to a reference line, is needed in the two-dimensional problem; two angles are required in the spatial problem. Although nearly always known in practical problems of orthodontic interest, the point of application of a concentrated force is described through the dimensions of the body or in terms of the coordinates of the point in relation to a specified reference framework. In approaching an equilibrium problem in which the vector characteristics of a force are sought, with the point of application of the force known the unknowns may be expressed as the magnitude and one or two angles or as the two or three components of the force referenced to an established set of coordinates. Figure 2-24 illustrates the two methods of displaying an unknown force at a point in two dimensions. On the left, the force is completely described by the magnitude, the one angle, and a convention to define sense of the vector; that convention could be an understanding that the force would appear to be pulling on the point
y
x
F
n
-__,,_,, , Scalar unknowns: F, 6
Scalar unknowns:
FIGURE 2-24. Two methods of illustrating a concentrated force in two dimensions, unknown except for point of application.
60
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
and the angle would be measured counterclockwise from the positive
extent of the x-axis, the angle having a value between 0 and 360°. On the right, the force is completely described in terms of its x- and y-components; two algebraic quantities provide the magnitude and sense of each component. Because the sign convention leading to the determination of sense is more straightforward in the component description of a force, expressing the unknowns as the components themselves is, seemingly, the more convenient procedure in an analytic approach to the equilibrium problem. To clarify, then, although sense often is noted as an individual force characteristic, sense is never a separate unknown in the equilibrium problem. A force at a point is totally described in terms of its components. In
picturing an unknown force in a free-body diagram, an assumption of sense may be made for each component; in solving an algebraic equation
for a component magnitude, the sign accompanying the answer will indicate whether the assumed sense was correct (plus sign) or incorrect (minus sign). Shown in Table 2-1 are several types of connections between bodies, the associated force systems exerted on each body (action and reaction), and the number of scalar quantities involved, exclusive of location of the connection. The first is, effectively, one-dimensional (although it may exist within a two- or three-dimensional problem), the next three are two-dimensional, and the final two are three-dimensional. The first two entries in the table indicate push-contact between two bodies that share a contact area. In the general two-dimensional analysis, the resultant of the distributed force system over the contact area would be displayed as two force components, one perpendicular to and the other tangent to the area at the center of the distribution. When it is reasonable to assume that friction between the bodies is negligible, the force of one body upon the other is perpendicular to the contact surface and, possibly, only one characteristic is an unknown: the force magnitude. The tangential component is the frictional force discussed previously, and it generally adds a second unknown at the contact site (except when proportional to the normal component, and then the sense of the frictional force must be correctly indicated). The third entry in the table, depicting a frictionless hinge connection (with the pin through the two members perpendicular to the plane of the sketch), generally transmits a force having unknown magnitude and direction. The two scalar quantities may be represented as the magnitudes of the components of the force; the components must be mutually
perpendicular, but the pair orientation as a whole may be arbitrarily selected (often most convenient with one component coinciding in direction with the long dimension of one of the interconnected members).
Shown as the fourth entry is the fixed support. Whereas the hinged connection possesses no inherent resistance to the angular movement of one body with respect to the other in the plane of the sketch and in the absence of friction, the fixed support or connection provides that resist-
.
61
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force TABLE 2-1. Connections between members and supports and associated force systems Force system
Description of contact or connection
\\
Action
Bar against fricfiorrless
from
surface
f
Hr
Reactive composaNs of bar against surface
Force components exerted by surface
Bar against rough
:::e
Action and reaction counterpart forces perpendicular to plane of contact. (One componeat magnitude is Unknown.)
Force of bar against surface
Notmal force
\ \ surtace
Remarks
Ft eaction
N2
t
are unknown.)
N2
Components exerted by pin
Bar restrained by frictiortless pin connection
/ p3
Force components from bar against P3I pin
Direction of resultant contact force generalty not longitudinal. (Two component magnitudes are unknown
Force system exerted by support on bar
Couple represents rasistance to rotation inherent in support (Action and reaction interchanged compared to toregoing examples. (Three component magnitudes are unknown.)
—
Action of bar against support
Fixed support of bar in plane setting
J
H4
3
/
I
C4
Frictronless support of shaft in
-
Fixed support of bar
1 C)
C) P)
C) C) P)
Indicated is potential for bar to slide to the right. Friction opposes this tendency. (Two component magnitudes
U
No resistance to longitudinat shaft displacement assumed. (Four component magnifudea are unknown)
Complete resistance to linear and angular dinplacements in all directions. (Six component magnitudes are unknown.)
ance, represented by the couple. In the plane problem only one unknown, its magnitude, is associated with such a couple; the sense of the couple (clockwise or counterclockwise) is obtained through a sign convention in the manner of that of an unknown force component. A number of three-dimensional connections are relatively common within structures and machines, encompassing from one to six potential unknowns, but just two of interest are displayed in Table 2-1. For the bearing-shaft connection, negligible resistance to shaft translation through and rotation within the bearing is assumed. This leaves a force vector and a couple vector, both perpendicular to the shaft axis, generally transmitted through the connection. Expressing each vector in com-
62
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
ponent form, a total of four potential unknowns is present. The force is
associated with the positional resistance of one• body relative to the other, and often equilibrium can exist in the absence of the couple; in such instances the couple is regarded as a secondary effect in primarily giving the connection added stability. The final entry in the table is the totally fixed, rigid connection. This connection, and a weld is a good example, prohibits both translation and rotation of one body with respect to the other in any direction. The force and couple are expressed as sets of three components each, giving a total of six potential unknowns. Before proceeding to a discussion of connections associated with the orthodontic appliance, a straightforward and applicable statics problem is examined. Consider an elastic that is stretched between two connection points in the orthodontic complex. The elastic at either end might be
activated against a hook attached to a bracket, a hook soldered or welded to the arch wire, or a loop bent into the wire, but assume that the elastic is stretched between just two connection locations. A reasonable assumption, based on the flexibility of the elastic, is that a single force is transmitted through the elastic and, therefore, through each connectioti point. Shown in Figure 2-25 are seemingly possible free-body diagrams of the elastic, the first with both forces of apparently unequal magnitudes drawn in arbitrary directions. If, however, the elastic is in mechanical equilibrium, and its weight is comparatively negligible, the moments of the two forces must balance. Choose first a moment center at point A;
with the line of action of P passing through A its moment arm, and therefore its moment, is zero. Hence, the moment of Q with respect to A
//
'4,
0
0
B
A
B
B
A
A
'P P
I
I,
I
t
FIGURE 2-25. Preparation of a free-body diagram for a static elastic stretched between two fixed points.
63
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
also be zero, and thus the line of action of Q must also pass through point A. The direction of Q is then determined as shown in the second diagram of Figure 2-25. Now, making a similar argument using point B as the moment center, the direction of the line of action of I? is determined; the two forces, accordingly, must share a common line of action as shown in the third sketch. Finally, because the entire system of forces must balance in any static situation, the forces P and Q must be equal in magnitude and opposite in sense. Their common line of action is determined by the positions of the two connection points, which both lie on the line. Hence, for any fwo-force member in equilibrium, the two forces must be equal in magnitude, opposite in sense, and share one line of action. Generally, the forces may be either pulling away from or pushmust
.ing toward one another, but an elastic has no resistance to pushing forces and, therefore, when activated it must be "in tension." Now, with the background of Table 2-1 and the force analysis of a stretched elastic, a number of connections associated with orthodontic mechanics are analyzed in Table 2-2. Although all are shown in a twodimensional format, with several a third dimension may be necessary to represent the connection force system completely. In the first entry just one potential unknown is present, the magnitude of P1. provided the orientation (angulation) of the stretched elastic has been or can be measured. Because the bracket in the second example has finite mesiodistal width, the couple, due to angulation of the wire within the bracket, as well as the force may be generated. This is somewhat analogous to the fixed support in two dimensions shown in Table 2-1. Friction, not included in this sketch but potentially present, would add a third scalar quantity. Examining this connection in an occlusal-plane view, assuming the presence of ligation, another force-couple pair must be present, and with friction neglected and round wire engaged, this connection is analogous to that of the bearing-and-shaft connection of Table 2-1. The third entry in Table 2-2 assumes that the rectangular wire will not rotate within the bracket slot; the couple shown is torsional in nature. Also generally present is an accompanying force transverse to the wire, and a total of three potential scalar unknowns in this connection not including friction. The fourth entry presents a somewhat simplified representation with friction included; analogous to the second entry in Table 2-1, this is just one of the possible configurations, in a view from the buccal perspective, already displayed. (See Fig. 2-23.) The fifth entry in Table 2-2 shows the resistance to rotation and translation provided by
a buccal tube. The component H5 may arise from a step bend in the engaged arch wire, a stop, and/or from friction. (If the arch wire was tied back, H5 would have the opposite sense.) Two additional components, a buccolingual force and another antirotation couple, would be seen in an occlusal view, reflecting a total of five potential unknowns associated with this connection. Finally, the connection of a J-hook to an arch wire has little; if any, inherent resistance to rotation. This is the three-dimensional extension of the pin connection with three associated potential unknown force components, two of them existing in the buccal-plane
64
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics TABLE 2-2. Orthodontic appliance interconnections and contact force systems exerted on the appliance members Force system
Connected members
I-look affixed to buccal tube and elastic
Remarks
Reaction
Action
Force trom elastic against hook
Hook force against elastic
Direct tension Lines of action along the stretched elastic. 1
Force system exerted Ofl
Bracket and arch
bracket
V2
wire
Bracket force system against wire
I
Second-order angulation and contact creates couple
V2
Bracket and rectangular arch
Force system from wire
Force system from bracket Third-order angulation and contact creates tingual root torque.
vof
wire C3
H3
Bracket and arch wire
Force components exerted by wire N,
Bracket-generated force components
Friction opposes relative displacement of wire and bracket, No second-order contact assumed.
f4
Stopped arch wire and buccal tube
Generated by stopped arch wire
Reaction of tube against wire
Slop contact with mesial extent of tube produces horizontal force
S
component. H5
v5
J-hook and hook soldered H6 H6
¶
Representative of highpull-headgear force delivery to maxillary anterior segment of arch wire
view. Note that the most general and complex connection, analogous to the final entry in Table 2-1, can be generated between the ligated bracket and a rectangular arch wire: all three force components (the mésiodistal component from a stop or friction) and all three couple components may exist for a total of six potential scalar unknown quantities. The two vector equations governing the equilibrium problem, which indicated that both the force and couple portions of the resultant of the entire force system must be zero, suggest that a maximum of six scalar relationships may be written among the characteristics of the force system properly displayed in the free-body diagram. Although the majority
of the quasi-static problems to be examined are three-dimensional,
65
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
many of these problems may be modeled into two dimensions. Also,
those problems that must be treated in three dimensions may be decom-
posed into several interrelated two-dimensional analyses and approached in parts, each in its own plane. As noted earlier, a relationship exists between the maximum number of independent scalar equations available, relating characteristics of the force system, and the dimensional level and format of that system. Several examples illustrating this relationship and the solution procedures follow. In Figure 2-3, two forces were shown acting on a bracket. Returning to that problem: the equilibrating force exerted on the bracket through its attachment to the band or its bond to the facial crown surface is to be determined. To be pictured in a free-body diagram, then, is the bracket itself and the forces exerted on it. The three existing forces are: the elastic force, the headgear force, and the unknown force. Ignoring the possibility that the two known forces may be slightly out of plane, relative to each other, and neglecting the bracket thickness, the problem then becomes two-dimensional. Moreover, the force system is concurrent with the lines of action of all three forces passing through the bracket center. The free-body diagram is shown in Figure 2-26. All characteristics of the elastic and headgear forces are known. The point of application of
Bg
EL = 200 g
= 400 g
+
Rm =
Rg = B8
97:O=_147O3O0S1fl 66° = 0
400 COS 66° — 200 COS 74° = 0
B8 = 163 = 55 = 218 g F8
+ 2182
278 g
FIGURE 2-26. Free-body diagram of an orthodontic bracket subjected to a twodimensional set of concurrent forces.
66
Bioengineeririg Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
the third force is known, but its magnitude and direction are not. There-
fore, two unknown scalar quantities are unknown and are pictured as mesially- and gingivally-directed components in the facial view. In the problem which is two-dimensional with the forces concurrent, only two independent scalar relationships may be written: the algebraic sum of force components in two mutually perpendicular directions in the plane must be zero to ensure a force balance. The solutions for the components of the bracket force and, subsequently, the resultant of those components are carried out in the figure. The solution yielding algebraically positive results indicates correct initial assumptions of the senses of the components. No moment-balance equation is written. (Clearly, a moment equation using the bracket center as the moment center is identically satisfied since the moment arms of all three forces are zero; hence,
no useful information is obtained from the moment-balance relationship. Another moment center might be chosen, and a moment balance written with respect to it, but the equation obtained would only be useful in replacing one of the two scalar force relationships.) The force just obtained is noted to be identical in all characteristics, except sense, to the
resultant of the elastic and headgear forces found in Figure 2-3; in all equilibrium problems involving a concurrent force system, the resultant of the given forces must be balanced by the force(s) that involve the unknowns. The lever is a second example that has applicability to orthodontic appliance analysis. Figure 2-27 shows a straight member that could represent an arch-wire segment balanced on a "fulcrum" by the forces P1 and P2 at the ends of the member. The fulcrum force and the relationship between the forces P1 and P2 to ensure equilibrium are sought. It is
P1
Pl
C
C
.
L1
L1
P0 x
= P0 — Pi — P2 = 0
P0 =
+
McP2L2)+P1L1)0
-
P2L2 = P1L1
FIGURE 2-27. A lever subjected to a two-dimensional parallel force system.
—
67
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
assumed that the applied forces exist in a common plane and are both
perpendicular to the long dimension of the member. Hence, the problem is two-dimensional and the free-body diagram reflects a parallel force system because neither of the applied forces has a component in the direction of the long dimension of the member. The responsive (fulcrum) force likewise can have no long-dimension component and reflect a balanced system. The magnitude of the fulcrum force is obtained by balancing the forces, algebraically summing the forces in the one direction of all three lines of action. The relationship between P1 and P2 is obtained through a moment balance using any convenient moment center; in this example, point C, which is immediately above the fulcrum, is chosen.
In general, for a two-dimensional parallel force system, two independent scalar equations of equilibrium may be written. One force and one moment equation were used to analyze the lever example. The general vector moment-balance equation previously described indicates that the center of mass of the body or assembly under study is to be used as the moment center. With the inertia effects absent or disregarded, however, it may be demonstrated that a force balance and a moment balance about the mass center demand that moments balance with respect to any selected moment center. It follows that the two scalar equilibrium equations for the problem of Figure 2-27 could have been two moment equations, and those equations would be independent of one another so long as the line through the two moment centers is not parallel to the
direction common to the three forces. Figure 2-28 shows a straight "beam" subjected to a transverse concentrated "load" of 300 g. The problem of determining the responses at the supports is an inversion of that of Figure 2-27; sketching the free-body diagram and using the equa-
300 g
I—
Pt'
6mm
II
P4
FIGURE 2-28. A structural member supported at its ends and subjected to a transverse, concentrated load. The correct free-body diagram shows a parallel force system in one plane.
68
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
lions of Figure 2-27 with P0 = 300 g, the magnitudes of the left and right
support may be shown to equal 100 g and 200 g, respectively. In the final example of this section, a cantilevered straight member is subjected to a loading consisting of forces at its right end, parallel and perpendicular to its long dimension, and a couple, all in a common plane. The left end of the member is engaged in a fixed support, and the components of the support force system are sought. The free-body diagram of the member includes the support resistances to any movement of its left end in the plane of the sketch. This is a general two-dimensional equilibrium problem and a total of three independent scalar equations may be written to relate characteristics of the total force system. An analysis is undertaken in Figure 2-29. A choice of sets of equations is
available: two force and one moment equations, one force and two 80g
I
I I I
lB
A
100 g
I 2100 g-mm
35mm
80 g CA
B
A
lOOg 2100 g-mm
x
— 100 = 0 = = 100 g
bOg M8 —
+ 2100
+ CA
=0
CA = 2100 —2800 = —700 g-mm 700 g-mm
FIGURE 2-29. A cantilevered structural member loaded at its "free" end. A twodimensional system of active and responsive forces and couples.
69
Introduction to Analysis of Orthodontic Force
moment equations (but the line connecting the two moment centers may
not be perpendicular to the direction of the force-component balance), or three moment equations (but the three moment centers may not lie on one straight line). The free-body diagram in Figure 2-29 contains three unknown forcesystem characteristics: the magnitudes of the two force components and that of the couple. The reference frame adjacent to the free-body diagram defines the chosen directions and assumed positive senses for the force-balance relationships written below the sketches. Note that the assumed senses associated with the unknown magnitudes need not coincide with the sign conventions for the equations. In the solution, note that a negative result was obtained for the support couple; this indicates that the assumed sense designated in the free-body diagram was incorrect. Also, recalling that the moment of a couple is inherent, note that its contribution to a moment balance in a two-dimensional analysis is the same, regardless of the moment-center location. The couple portion of the load on the member was included in the moment-balance relationship written, even though the moment center chosen at the right end of the member eliminated contributions from the other applied forces (because their moment arms with respect to point B are zef o) and the couple and moment center appear to be coincident. A partial check of the solution obtained in the figure may be pursued by writing a moment-
balance equation using point A at the left end of the member as the moment center.
Synopsis This chapter introduced the concept of force. Various force manipula-
tions were discussed, including the determinations of the moment of a force and the resultant of a system of forces. The couple, a special force system, was defined and its use as a tool in force analysis, as well as its occurrence as a load and a mechanical response, was considered. Modeling of actual force systems and the bodies acted upon, toward simplification of analyses, were discussed. The resultant of an active force system is sought in order to describe the whole-body displacement that may be produced by the system. A rationale was developed for analyzing the quasi-static problem, applicable to the orthodontic appliance, slowly deactivating between appointments, using the governing equadons of mechanical equilibrium. Force systems produced by activated orthodontic appliances provide the catalyst for the processes that result in the displacements of teeth. Forces are also generated in orthopedic actions toward alterations of growth patterns and to cause movements of dentofacial bones. Hence, a first step in evaluating the potential of a given appliance, with regard to its tendency to produce desired displacements in a controlled manner,
70 Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
or
in the design of a new appliance, is an examination of the forces
created upon activation that are associated with the actual or proposed appliance. This, however, is only the beginning of the total structural analysis. Thus far, deformations have not been considered, nor has the interface between the biologic and mechanical systems. To initiate the action of the orthodontic mechanics, the appliance must be activated; one or more appliance elements must be deformed from their passive configurations, thereby "loading" the appliance and inducing forces throughout it. Because only a part of the total appliance force system can be quantified through direct measurement and the use of equilibrium
equations, relationships between force and deformation must be sought. Such relationships involve the material characteristics of the appliance members as well as their sizes and shapes and will be discussed in the next chapter.
Reference Frank, C.A., and Nikolai, R.J.: A comparative study of frictional resistances be-
tween orthodontic bracket and arch wire. Am. J. Orthod., 78:593-609, 1980.
Suggested Readings F,P., and Johnston, E.R., Jr.: Vector Mechanics for Engineers. 3rd Ed. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1977, Chapters 1 to 4, 6, and 8.
Beer,
Jarabak, J.R., and Fizzell, J.A.: Technique and Treatment with Light-wire Edgewise Appliances. 2nd Ed. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1972, Chapter 1. McLean, W.G., and Nelson, E.W.: Engineering Mechanics: Statics and Dynamics. New York, Schaum Publishing, 1962, Chapters 2, 3, 5, and 8.
Mulligan, T.F.: Common Sense Mechanics. Phoenix, CSM, 1982, Chapters 2 and 3. Smith, R.J., and Burstone, C.J.: Mechanics of tooth movement. Am. J. Orthod., 85:294—307, 1984.
Thurow, R.C.: Atlas of Orthodontic Principles. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1970, Chapter 4.
Thurow, R.C.: Edgewise Orthodontics. 4th Ed. St. Louis, CV. Mosby, 1982, Chapter 2.
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
In planning the treatment of a malocclusion, the orthodontist selects a
series of appliances for sequential use in the correction. Each appliance is a kind of structure. Activated through a deformation from its passive, as-prepared configuration, the appliance attempts to return to that passive state, but is prevented, temporarily, by the resistance of the dentilion to which it is affixed. The appliance responds to the activation by exerting a system of forces against those teeth and portions of the dentofacial complex that hold it in an activated state. Creation of contact forces between the appliance and dentition is accompanied by force sys-
tems within the individual members of the appliance, transmitted through connections from one member to another. The responses of the
appliance members to orthodontic "loading" are fundamentally dependent on the materials of those members. The orthodontist uses a variety of materials: metallic-alloy arch wires, bands, brackets, and headgear components, polymeric "elastics" (bands, modules, 0-rings, chains, threads), adhesives, alginates, acrylics, plasters, among others. It is important, then, that the clinician be acquainted with the basic concepts of materials science as applicable to the specialty. When designing and preparing each arch wire, auxiliary, or retainer, the orthodontist must be able to predict the response of each appliance member to "in-service" conditions. The materials are subjected not only to mechanical actions associated with the induced force
systems, but the environment in which the materials must exist also influences their behavior. The basis for explaining or predicting the response of a structural or machine member under specified conditions of use is found in its properties. A property is, in a general sense, a descriptive quantity that gives a specific characteristic to the member. Properties may be categorized in many ways, but initially they should be divided into those associated directly with the material or materials of the member and those termed 71
72
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
properties, which are descriptive of its size, shape, and appearance. Material properties are further subdivided into characteristics that are independent of external influences, simply termed "material" properties, and those that are associated in some way with the conditions of use or the use environment: mechanical, chemical, thermal, and magnetic, for example. Consider, for instance, the decision of selecting a spring to produce a particular orthodontic displacement. Properties that enter into this design decision include the cross-sectional wire size, the coil diameter, and the overall passive length of the spring (physical characteristics), the stiffness and strength of the wire material (mechanical) and the spring itself (structural), the resistance of the material to corrosion (chemical), and the effects of a somewhat elevated and varying temperature (thermal). The materials of the members of the orthodontic appliance are the focus of this chapter. Behavior of ancillary materials, such as plasters, will not be discussed here. The responses of biologic materials during orthodontic treatment will not be overlooked, but are relegated to a subphysical
sequent chapter. Physical, mechanical, chemical, and thermal are the property categories of primary interest to the orthodontist; optical, electrical,
and magnetic properties, although not to be generally disregarded, are of little importance within the scope of this text and will not be discussed in this chapter. Properties may be interdependent and, as previously mentioned, are often influenced by conditions of use of the material and in-service environment. The characteristics of a stationary body, directly associated with its response to applied or induced forces, which include both material and physical contributions, are known as structural properties. The response to activation of an orthodontic wire loop will depend upon the wire material, the wire cross-section, the loop geometry, and the amounts and directions of the bends made in forming the loop. The behavior of an elastic module used intraorally will differ in some respects from the results of an evaluation of its mechanical characteristics on the bench in the laboratory under ordinary conditions of temperature and humidity or its response as part of an extraoral appliance. Material-property values are generally obtained in controlled experimentation. In-service conditions, as necessary, are created in the laboratory and the required measurements are taken. When widespread use of the results is expected, and to ensure reliability of comparisons, testing procedures must be standardized. Much of the standardization in the United States in testing, particularly in the determination of mechanical properties, has been and is established by the American Society for Testing Materials. Property quantification and certification of testing procedures in the dental fields is carried out under the auspices of the American Dental Association. In the sections to follow, the nature and structure of solid materials are surveyed and the interaction between load and deformation is examined and pertinent structural characteristics are described. The concepts of stress and strain are introduced, mechanical and structural properties
73
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
obtained through standardized testing are defined and discussed as needed for developments in subsequent chapters, and chemical and as
thermal characteristics of interest are considered. The chapter concludes with a set of guidelines to be used when selecting orthodontic-appliance materials.
Internal Structure of a Solid Material Any fluid or solid material is a conglomerate of particles. Forces, generally attractive, exist between pairs of particles, and their magnitudes are determined by particle densities and distances between particle centers. The forces of attraction in a fluid are relatively small and, as a result, the
material readily conforms to its container. The particles in a solid are dense and relatively closely packed; the associated cohesive forces are large enough that, generally, the solid retains shape in the absence of any containment. The smallest subdivided unit of matter, which is representative of a pure material (chemical element), is the atom. Submicroscopic in size, the atom is envisioned as a nucleus surrounded by electrons in a kind of planetary arrangement. The nucleus contains protons and neutrons; these subparticles have approximately identical masses, the proton possesses a small, positive, electrical charge, and the neutron is electrically neutral. The mass of an electron is approximately 1/2000th that of the proton, yet it possesses a negative charge equal in magnitude, but opposite in sense (sign) to that of the proton. The atomic number of an element equals the number of protons in its nucleus. The atomic weight is approxi-
mately that of the nucleus, neglecting the small contribution from the electrons, a figure that numerically is, in essence, the sum of the protons and neutrons and varies with element from slightly more than 1 to in excess of 250. In the element model, the electrons exist in concentric orbits, or "shells," with the nucleus at the center. Heavier atoms may possess more electron shells than light atoms, but independent of the material element each shell—its position designated radially with respect to the nucleus—has a specific electron capacity. Except for the outside shell, which may be incomplete, all shells are totally "filled." The outer shell contains, at most, 8 electrons; elements with like numbers of electrons in their outer shells have similar chemical behaviors and the number of outer-shell electrons is particularly significant in connection with mechanical, electrical, and magnetic properties. Atoms hold together because of the intra-atomic attraction between elecIrons and protons. Overall, an atom is said to be electrically neutral if the numbers of protons and electrons are equal, regardless of the number of
electron shells and the number of electrons in the outer shell. Although possessing a net charge of zero with numbers of protons and electrons equal, the stability of an atom with regard to its potential to combine with other atoms is largely tied to the outer shell and the
74
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodonfic Mechanics
number of "valence" electrons in it. Certain materials are inert or chemi-
cally inactive because the pure chemical elements exhibit filled outer shells together with having no net electrical charge. Many elements do not occur in their pure forms in nature because their atomic instability has resulted in chemical reaction or combination with other elements. In short, the most stable form is that achieved in a configuration with the outer shell of electrons completely filled. With the exception of the noble
gases, to attain this stabilized state an element must either effectively gain or lose from one to four electrons. Filling the outer shell results in the atom assuming a net negative charge, and the atom that loses its valence electrons assumes a positive charge; in either instance the result is a transformation from atom to ion. Ionization yields the potential for the formation of primary, interatomic bonds, of which three forms exist. Ionic bonds are formed when the
valence electrons shed by one group of atoms are transferred to, and complete the outer shells of, other atoms. Table salt is the result of sodium losing its one valence electron to chlorine, electrically neutral with
seven electrons in its outer shell. Covalent bonding is the sharing of electrons. The simplest example is the combination of two hydrogen atoms, another is the sharing among four hydrogen atoms and a carbon atom to form methane, and a third is the formation of diamond solely from carbon atoms. Metallic bonds may be formed by atoms of elements having just a few (generally one or two) valence electrons which are shed easily; formed is a structure of positive ions and "free" electrons or an "electron cloud" and between them the bonding occurs. The type of primary bond is usually indicated by the number of valence electrons in one of the elements; in a few materials, more than one form of bonding can exist. Ionic and covalent bonding results in combinations of atoms known as molecules. Although the molecule is electrically neutral, or nearly so, due to the nonuniform distribution of electrical charges, intermolecular bonds (also termed secondary or van der Waals bonds) may form.
Several types of secondary bonds are defined, but for all forms their strengths are substantially less, often an order of magnitude lower than that of the typical primary bond. Interatomic and intermolecular forms of attraction pull the particles toward one another, but spaces also exist within the particle structures, primarily because mutually repulsive forces between their electron shells become dominant when two atoms become too close to each other. Figure 3-1 depicts the forces of attraction and repulsion, both shown in dashed plots, versus the distance between the centers of a pair
of atoms. The solid curve, the net force versus interatomic spacing, crosses the horizontal axis at the point of equal attractive and repulsive forces—the so-called "equilibrium distance." This equilibrium spacing or distance between atoms varies with the material elements because of atomic size and the number of adjacent atoms in the molecular structure. Also, temperature is an important, controlling parameter. As the temperature is raised (lowered) the mean spacing between atoms increases (decreases), accounting for the thermal expansion (contraction) of materials.
75
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Interatomic Force
\ Force of attraction
N ed
0
Net
/
/
Atomic Spacing
/ Force of repulsion
/
ed: Equilibrium distance
I FIGURE 3-1. Plots of interatomic force versus distance between atoms.
Several material properties are related to the bonding characteristics of atoms and molecules. Density is determined by atomic weight and spacing. Overall strength of a material depends upon bond strengths. Material stiffness is related jointly to magnitudes of bond forces and particle spacings. Thermal and electrical conductivities are low in ionicand covalent-bonded materials and high in materials that are metalli-
cally bonded wherein the free electrons serve as carriers of energy. Prop-
erties are also dependent upon the arrangement of atoms within the material, and atomic arrangements are generally classified as molecular, crystalline, or amorphous in structure. The chemical composition of a limited number of atoms forms a molecule, having a net electrical charge of zero due to primary bonding. From the characteristics of the constituent atoms, the numbers of bonds, the
bond lengths, and possible relative positions of the atoms (molecular geometries) may be determined. Often, for a molecular composition, more than one atomic arrangement is possible; such structural variations are termed isomers. Molecular materials, solids in particular, are held
together through secondary bonding. Such solids have low melting points, indicative of the relative weak intermolecular bonding, but the larger molecules have greater strengths because of the increased num-
76
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
bers of such bonds. Basic to the understanding of molecular structures is
the study of hydrocarbons. In a so-called "unsaturated" hydrocarbon, multiple carbon-to-carbon bonds exist that enable the formation of a large molecule from several smaller molecules in a chemical reaction known as polymerization. One form of this reaction, termed "addition polymerization," beginning with like monomers of ethylene, is illustrated in Figure 3-2. The polymeric molecule, or polymer, obtained is made up of many repeating units, called mers. A number of polymeric materials are familiar to the orthodontist: waxes, alginates (impression materials), acrylics (for retainers), adhesives (for direct or indirect bracket bonding),
and the elastomeric (rubber or rubberlike) bands, modules, "chains," and "threads." Although polymerization can develop lengthy molecular "chains," and the formation of van der Waals bonds, or "cross-linking" (vulcanization of rubber, for example) can create two- and three-dimensional molecular networks having some strength, the majority of engineering materials are made up of thrde-dimensional, repeating patterns of atoms called crystals. The primary bonding is typically metallic, but secondary
bonding can result in similar highly ordered patterns such as in the molecular crystal of table salt. The pictorial conception of a crystal is a spatial structure of straight lines with the atomic nuclei (in table salt, the sodium-ion centers) at their intersections. The three-dimensional, repeating element of the crystalline structure is known as the unit cell. Some 14 different unit-cell geometries are defined and the most common cubic crystal representations are depicted in Figure 3-3. Various material properties may be correlated with crystalline structure, and often the unit cell is indicative of the material class of the solid. Some materials, however, can exist as a solid in more than one crystal structure (polymorphism or allotropism, analogous to isomerism in polymers). A prime example is iron, which may exhibit a body- or face-centered-cubic crystal structure, depending on its temperature or the presence of alloying elements. Materials that do not display the regular, repetitive patterns found in crystalline solids and many polymers, but instead reflect a disordered
A
H
I
I
H
H
H
H
H
H
I
I
I
I
I
I
C
C
C—C————C———-—C
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
H
me
Monomer
Polymer
H: Hydrogen C: Carbon FIGURE 3-2. The ethylene monomer and a portion of the long-chain molecule resulting from addition polymerization.
77
Material B.ehavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Ii
I
Simple cubic
Body-centered cubic
Face-centered cubic
FIGURE 3-3. Representations of simple cubic, body-centered cubic, and face-centered cubic unit cells.
molecular structure, are termed amorphous. Gases and liquids are amor-
phous ("without form") as are a number of oxides including glasses. Although such materials are not generally of specific interest to the orthodontist, some aggregates of crystalline or molecular and amorphous materials may be. Plastics are often reinforced with various "fillers." The divisions between crystals (grain boundaries) contain amorphous matter. Polycrystalline materials are, by definition, aggregates of small crys-
tals. Those polymers having highly disordered molecular structures might be categorized as aggregate materials. The internal, submicroscopic structures of many materials are highly ordered, but imperfections exist. Although often cumulatively occupying a small portion or volume of the material, certain imperfections, particularly in crystalline solids, cannot be ignored owing to their substantial
impact upon properties. Within the crystals themselves atoms may be missing from individual cells, foreign atoms may have replaced some of those of the pure material, atoms may have become displaced to "in-between" (interstitial) locations within the cells, or foreign atoms may have entered the structure and assumed interstitial positions. An extra line or plane of atoms, termed a "dislocation," may be present within the crystal. Imperfections inherently exist at external surfaces where the exposure of surface atoms makes them more vulnerable to reactions with matter within the adjacent environment. Within crystalline materials at internal or grain boundaries, amorphous matter up to ten or more atomic distances in thickness is present which generally possesses at least some relevant property values inferior to those of the individual crystals.
Certain imperfections are created to enhance property values. For example, brass is a solid solution of copper and zinc, termed "substitutional" because zinc atoms are substituted for some copper atoms in the crystal structure to produce the alloy. Steel formation involves elevating the temperature of iron to a level such that the relatively small carbon atoms can fit into the middle of the face-centered-cubic cell structure of the iron. As indicated previously, some material properties are highly sensitive to imperfections. Although the weight fraction of carbon in steel is often less than 5%, the presence of the carbon greatly improves its strength properties over those of pure iron. On the other hand, den-
78
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
sity and material stiffness are termed "structure insensitive" properties
because they are affected only in proportion to the imperfection level or numbers. (For example, the density of stainless steel is equal to the sum of the products of the fractional amounts, by mass, and the densities of the constituent elements.) Atoms, molecules, and crystals within a solid are retained in particular positions because of the existence of an overall, internal, force balance. The potential for relative displacement is often present, however, either in the form of some external effect or simply because the particles are being maintained in a strained configuration. Actually, atoms are continually in motion, vibrating about their equilibrium positions with amplitudes dependent upon temperature; apparently, completely static states occur only at absolute zero. If temperatures become sufficiently elevated and the particles are initially in strained positions, the vibra-
tions can result in displacements to less constrained configurations. Mechanical action can cause particle displacements, often to more constrained configurations, as can an electric or magnetic field if the particle
characteristics are such as to respond to the field. A combination of mechanical and thermal inputs can cause a displacement that cannot be achieved individually at the same level as the combined action. The movements of atoms within a crystal often involve point imperfections; with relatively little mechanical thermal input, an atom can be displaced into a neighboring vacancy or can move a smaller foreign atom interstitially and take its position. Displacements of molecules usually require less input than average atomic movements because secondary bonds are weaker than primary bonds; however, bond density is sometimes an overriding factor. The displacement of entire crystals typically occurs with the grains sliding with respect to one another; secondary bonds with grain-boundary matter are broken and then re-established when the resistance to further movement exceeds what remains of the initial input. A somewhat superficial discussion of the internal structure of a solid material is contained in the preceding paragraphs. Much should be familiar from previous dental-materials coursework, and a more complete treatment of these topics may be found in the materials-science texts in the "Suggested Readings" at the end of the chapter. The objective of this section has been to examine internal material structure to the point of recognizing the existence of relationships with pertinent properties of orthodontic appliance materials. Those relationships will be recalled as the associated properties and material behavior are considered in subsequent sections of this chapter.
Load-Deformation Behavior of a Structural Member generation of forces within the members of an orthodontic appliance, in addition to those associated with interatomic and intermolecuThe
79
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
bonding, and the transferral of induced forces to and through the dentition and into the periodontium, results in the remodeling of the periodontal support system and the displacements of teeth toward corlar
rection of the malocclusion. Although the rigid-body model was used in the discussion of forces in Chapter 2, the rationale was a simplification in force analyses when deformations could reasonably be neglected in comparison to the dimensions of the body or member under study. In fact, for any stationary, supported body, loading and deformation cannot take place exclusive of one another. To the typical engineering struc-
ture, a "load" (an external force system) is applied which results in a pattern of deformation; although perhaps unwanted, that deformation must be included in design or analysis procedures. On the other hand, the clinician produces a deformation, in activating an orthodontic appliance, to induce the desired force system. Although the cause-and-effect roles seemingly are reversed in loading the appliance compared to the typical structure, the parts of the orthodontic appliance may reasonably be termed "structural members" because they carry and deliver force. Accordingly, certain appliance-member characteristics defined in this section will be referred to as structural properties. The practitioner generally produces and observes deformation before, during, and after activation of the orthodontic appliance. Each deformation, defined as any localized or overall change in shape of a mem-
ber, results in an alteration of the force system within the appliance. Most familiar are the deformations necessary to activate the appliance, producing the initial levels of force to be delivered to the dentition. Over a period of time, with movements of teeth, the initial appliance deformations are lessened with corresponding changes in force magnitudes. At a
succeeding appointment, if the appliance has not totally deactivated (lost all force) in the meantime, the practitioner may unload the appliance with configuration changes accompanying disengagement. An appliance member may be said to be structurally passive when it is subjected only to gravitational attraction and any forces responsive only to its small weight. Prior to appliance engagement and activation, the clinician may affect loading and unloading deformations that take an appliance element, typically a length of arch wire, from one passive configu-
ration to another. In the formation of arches or auxiliaries from as-received wire, the orthodontist must apply (often with pliers), and
then release, force systems in order to produce the desired shape changes. Several types of deformation are to be recognized. First, consider two particles within a structural member. A change in the distance between particles reflects a normal deformation. If the distance is increased, the deformation is termed tensile or extensional; if the distance is decreased, the deformation is compressive. A second fundamental deformation is
associated with a pair of lines of particles of the material. If the angle between the two lines changes, a shearing deformation has occurred. Normal deformations are depicted in Figure 3-4; note the changes in relative positions of particles at right angles to the normal deformation,
80
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
11 Passive
configuration
Compressive deformation
Extensional deformation
FIGURE 3-4. Normal deformations, extension and compression, illustrated on an atomic scale.
associated
with bonding forces and distances, the so-called "Poisson
effect." The schematic of a shearing deformation appears in Figure 3-5.
Both normal and shearing deformations can occur simultaneously within a member—indeed, even at the same location. These fundamental forms of deformation may or may not be visually recognizable, depending upon their sizes and the volumes of material affected; an obvious deformation is the extension associated with the activation of an "elastic." Two additional forms of deformation include both of the fundamental forms. Bending is identified externally by a longitudinal shape change in the member, often from a straight to a curved configuration, as depicted in Figure 3-6. In the analysis of bending, the member is conceptualized as an assembly of longitudinal fibers, all having the same shape.
Passive
configuration
Shearing deformation
FIGURE 3-5. An atomic representation of shear deformation.
81
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
I
-
I
Passive bar
Bar deformed in bending FIGURE 3-6. An illustration of bending detormation, together with two measures of this form of deformation.
all fibers are attached to one another in a solid member, bending results in the stretching of some fibers and the compressing of others. In Figure 3-6, if external forces hold the member in the deformed configuration the lower fibers are maintained in compression and the upper fibers in tension. Two external measures of bending deformation are defined; as shown in the figure, a transverse deflection 6 denotes the displacement of a cross-section of the member perpendicular to the longitudinal dimension and an angular coordinate U indicates the rotation of a cross-section. The final type of deformation to be introduced is twisting. Figure 3-7 illustrates that the external measure of a twisting deformation is an angular coordinate 4) which denotes the change in orientation of a transverse reference line in the cross-section. In a twisted member, because the amounts of rotation generally vary from one cross-section to another, and since cross-sections are interconnected, the characteristic internal deformation is a shearing deformation. (Shearing action often also exists within a member subjected to bending activation, but the accompanying deformation is negligible except, possibly, when the longitudinal dimension of the member is small.) Beginning with a structural member in a passive but supported configuration, the application of external force produces an associated deformation. To maintain the deformed configuration induced by the force system, the force system itself must be maintained and the member is said to be constrained. Releasing the load results in a second configuration change, and the member again becomes passive. By definition, the application of force causes an elastic deformation of the member if the passive configurations, before loading and following unloading, are geometrically identical. If, upon unloading, the member does not return Because
to its initial, passive configuration, the loading produces inelastic
behavior.
82
Bioengineeririg Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Passive bar
Fixed end
Twist
deformation
Bar deformed in torsion
FIGURE 3-7. A twist deformation and an angle 4' as a measure of it.
As a first example to study, totally from an external standpoint, the load-deformation behavior of a structural member, the bending of an arch-wire segment is examined. Consider an initially straight piece of wire between two fixed supports. The span, the distance between the supports, is sizable in comparison to the cross-sectional dimensions of the wire. The wire segment has been cut from a longer piece of as-
83
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Applied force P
----Deflection ô
FIGURE 3-8. An arch-wire segment subjected to bending deformation produced by a transverse, midspan force.
received wire. A point force is applied midway between the supports to
generate a bending deformation; specifically, the external deformation of interest is the transverse deflection of the cross-section directly under the applied load. Shown schematically in Figure 3-8 are the undeformed shape (dashed) and a deformed configuration (solid), the latter generated by the applied force. The load-deformation curve, given in Figure 3-9, is the result of the plotting of corresponding values of applied force and deflected position of the midspan cross-section relative to its passive location. The load is slowly increased in small increments and the accu-
mulated deflection grows until the simple structure collapses (is no
Applied Force P 2
/ S: Stiffness p1: Proportional limit
el: Elastic limit
0
Deflection
FIGURE 3-9. A p'ot of applied force versus midspan deflection for the wire segment of Figure 3-8.
84 Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
longer able to sustain the load). The overall shape of the curve is charac-
teristic of crystalline materials, regardless of the member geometry or the type of deformation induced. The initial portion of the plot is linear with the slope then decreasing as the loading (plotted as the ordinate on the graph) becomes relatively substantial. The end point of the linear portion of the plot is appropriately termed the proportional limit. The coordinates of the final point of the curve denote the largest values of deformation and force before failure. The application of a relatively light force to the member of Figure 3-8 results in a small deflection; the two values are the coordinates of a point on the curve of Figure 3-9, most likely below the proportional limit. If the load is held constant and the temperature is not elevated substantially, the deformation of the metallic member will generally remain unchanged, virtually independent of time. Upon release of the load the deformation will disappear and, in general, the original straight-line shape will be regained, provided the elastic limit has not been exceeded. The elastic limit is the extreme point on the force-deformation plot from which unloading will occur with no permanent deformation resulting from the load-unload cycle. Points 1 and 2 in Figure 3-9 are below and above the elastic limit, respectively. An unloading plot from point 1 traces the loading plot between the origin and point 1. The dashed unloading curve from point 2 is notably linear and parallel to the linear portion of the loading plot; the deformation coordinate of the point of intersection of this unloading curve with the abscissa (deformation axis) denotes the permanent deformation of the segment and a new passive configuration of the now bent wire. Internally, the loading to point 1 stretches some interatomic bonds and pushes other atoms toward one another, but no bonds are broken and, as the load is released, the atoms return to their prior equilibrium positions. Loading to point 2, however, severs some bonds and results in movements of crystals relative to one another; new bonds are established that are reflected upon unloading in a new, altered, passive configuration. The elastic limit for a crystalline member is found experimentally to be only slightly beyond the proportional limit and, to simplify computations, the elastic limit is often "placed" at the end of the linear portion of the plot, coincident with the proportional limit. The elastic limit divides the structural character of the wire segment and the load-deformation plot into regions of totally elastic behavior and inelastic response. The slope of the linear part of the curve is the bending stiffness at the "midspan" location of the arch-wire segment. In an orthodontic activation, the loading of a wire is intended to be to a point not beyond the proportional limit so that the totally deactivated configuration is known: generally identical to the preload, passive geometry. Hence, in an elastic activation, the stiffness when quantified enables the determination of (1) the magnitude of the load corresponding to the activating deformation—the load is the product of stiffness and - the amount of activation—and (2) the reduction in the as-activated level of
85
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
loading during deactivation—the product of stiffness and quantified
deactivation increment. The coordinates of the elastic-limit point on the plot are known as the elastic range and the elastic strength. In this example, the elastic range is the largest transverse bending deformation of the midspan cross-section
that the wire segment can experience and subsequently deactivate totally or be unloaded without sustaining a permanent bend. The elastic strength is the maximum magnitude of applied, midspan, bending force without inelastic material behavior occurring somewhere in the segment. A fourth notable elastic structural property is termed resilience. An energy-related quantity, and as such to be discussed in more detail in Chapter 4, resilience is, quantified, the area under the load-deformation diagram up to the elastic limit; for crystalline materials that area is triangular. Dependent collectively upon both elastic-limit coordinates, which themselves are intradependent with stiffness, a member exhibiting low stiffness but a high elastic range may possess a resilience similar to that of a member having greater stiffness but a lesser elastic range. Although the activation of an arch wire in bending is not intended to take the member beyond its elastic limit, the nonlinear portion of the load-deformation diagram is also important because inelastic bending is necessary by the practitioner to place permanent bends. Taking the example wire segment to point 2 on the load-deformation curve results in the appearance of a "gable bend" midway between the supports. How severe a permanent bend the wire can sustain without fracture depends upon the ductility of the wire in bending. Two measurements of ductility are the deformation to fracture, the horizontal coordinate in Figure 3-9 of the final point of the plot, compared to the elastic range, and the toughness, the total area under the load-deformation diagram, compared to the resilience. Both of these quantities just defined, compared to their elastic counterparts, are substantial for the very ductile ligature wire, for example. In contrast, both comparisons are 1:1 for a perfectly brittle member; the fracture point and elastic limit coincide on the load-deformation diagram. A second, pertinent, structural example is that of a stretched elastomeric module. Schematics showing the passive and an activated configuration are presented in Figure 3-10. One end of the module is fixed and the member is elongated by the application of a concentrated force at the other end. The overall deformation (e) is the extended length (L) minus the passive length (L0). As with the arch wire in bending, the larger the
load, the greater the deformation, but the module exhibits a two- or three-part load-deformation diagram, quite different from that of the arch wire. An elastomer is a rubber or rubberlike, often synthetic, polymeric material. The nature of the bonding of atoms and molecules, and the imperfections, make the material inherently more flexible than a crystalline solid of the same size and shape. A typical two-part diagram is presented in Figure 3-11; the solid curve represents loading to failure by rupture (separation). Along the lengthy, linear portion of the plot,
86 Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Stretching force
F
e
L
0
Passive
Activated
FIGURE 3-10. Activation of an elastomeric module in direct tension.
the elongation under load is reflected principally in the uncoiling of long molecular chains. (A typical three-part curve suggests, in the initial nonlinear portion, that secondary bonds must be broken before the major uncoiling of chain molecules can begin; that first part of the curve exhibits decreasing slope with increasing applied force.) As the uncoiling is
completed, material stiffness increases as primary bonds begin to be stretched; with continued increasing of the load the slope of the curve grows and rupture eventually occurs. Accurate determination of the coordinates of the elastic limit of the module is difficult because of the time-dependent nature of the mechanical behavior of the material (to be discussed subsequently). Most elastomers, however, are relatively brittle; their elastic limits are "high" on the load-deformation curves, beyond the linear initial or middle portions of these plots. Inelastic action,
therefore, is never expected in clinical use, as the name "elastomer" suggests.
The dashed curve in Figure 3-11 is representative of rather rapid unloading of the module. Unloaded from a point below its elastic limit, some deformation remains immediately after removal of the activating force, but over time, full recovery of the preload, passive configuration takes place as secondary bonds are re-established (dashed line). Strktly speaking, orthodontic deactivation cannot be shown in Figure 3-11 be-
cause the force in the module depends upon the time elapsed while
87
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Stretching Force F
/ / / 0
/ / Extensional Deformation e
FIGURE 3-11. The force-deformation diagram for the module of Figure 3-10.
under load, in addition to the amount of elongating activation. Hence, stiffness, as the slope of the load-deformation curve, can only be approximated because it, too, is changing with time. As previously mentioned, time-dependent behavior is considered further in a subsequent section of this chapter.
Mechanical Stress concept of internal force was introduced in Chapter 2. The interatomic and intermolecular bonding forces discussed previously in this chapter are fundamentally part of any internal force system. Superimposed on the bonding forces, however, are internal force distributions The
arising from the external loading of the structure through the application of mechanical force or through the imposition of an activating deformation and maintenance of a constrained configuration. The loading of one member creates internal forces in the whole of the structure; these forces
seemingly travel through the loaded member, across the connections and into adjacent members, and ultimately into the supports or foundation of the structure. These internal forces, both from bonding and from external loading, not only exist throughout the lengths of the members, but are also distributed over the entirety of the member cross-sections.
88
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
In general, the intensity of internal force can vary in all directions within
a member. (In structural analyses, although the internal force system arising from external loading is superimposed on the bonding force system and, likely, also a residual internal-force distribution remaining from manufacturing or preactivation fabrication processes, the analyses often ignore all but the first on the basis of magnitude comparisons.) As a first example in this section, consider the activated elastomeric
module of Figure 3-10. Held in this constrained state, although stretched, the module is in mechanical equilibrium with its supports. The internal force system can be exposed in part by making an imaginary cut through the module and arguing that the resulting two parts are each in equilibrium as is the whole of the module. The specific loca-
tion of the "cut" along the module length is arbitrary in this example and is simply made perpendicular to the longitudinal direction. The two portions of the module are shown in Figure 3-12 together with the activating and responsive forces on the entire module. The external forces at the module ends are equal and opposite from a force balance; the exposed internal forces are equal and opposite because they are action-reaction counterparts. Assumed is a one-material, homogeneous module and, with the line of action of the external forces coinciding with the
longitudinal axis of geometric symmetry, the distribution of internal force, arising from the loading, is essentially uniform over the cross-section as illustrated. Also, with the resultant of the internal force system equal and opposite to the external force (from a longitudinal force balance on either module portion), the internal distribution is wholly pulling against the cross-section of the "cut." Finally, because the external loading is only at the ends of the module, and with its weight negligible, the pattern of internal forces on all cross-sections having identical orientations is the same from one end of the module to the other, regardless
of the longitudinal location of the "cut." The average intensity of the internal force in Fig. 3-12) is the resultant, internal-force magnitude (F) divided by the cross-sectional area (As) exposed by the "cut." In the determination of the initiation of inelastic material behavior or failure, intensity of internal force is the critical parameter. In short, but sometimes oversimplified, the larger the cross-section of a structural member,
the greater is the load that it can carry. Stress is defined as the intensity of internal force, per unit area, at a point within a machine or structural member. It is a vector quantity, obtained by dividing a vector (force) by a scalar (area). The dimensions of stress are force divided by length-squared (FIL2). A "cut" exposes an area internal to the member, and that area is divided into a number of subareas with a portion of the internal-force resultant exerted on each subarea. As the number of subareas increases, the size of each subarea becomes smaller and the pattern of internal-force intensity (stress) becomes more detailed. In the module example, the stress everywhere is normal to the area and is the same on every subarea of the exposed cross-section, but this is a special situation; in general, the stress may be oblique to the area and may vary over the whole of a cross-sectional area
89
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
"cut"
F=
Crosssectional area
F A,,
F
FIGURE 3-12. Activation and response at the ends of an elastomeric module, Internal force distribution over a cross-section of the module.
90
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Stress
S5
Ss
S
Sn Sn
Side view
FIGURE 3-13. A general stress vector decomposed into normal- and shear-stress components.
of a member. Shown in Figure 3-13, within the total cross-section, is a typical subarea (As) (enlarged) with the stress s associated with it. Nearly always convenient is the decomposition of the stress vector into components normal (perpendicular) to and tangential to the area; these components are known as the normal and shear stresses, symbolized by a or s,, and r or s5, respectively. When the normal stress is apparently pulling against the area, as in Figure 3-13, it is called tensile stress. A normal stress that pushes against the area is a compressive stress, and is directly analogous to pressure in a fluid. Note the correspondence between the two categories of normal stress and the forms of deformation previously discussed. As an example illustrating the generation of shear stresses, consider an orthodontic bracket pad bonded to a facial crown surface and the bracket subjected to an external force parallel to the facial surface. Figure 3-14, on the left in perhaps a mesial or distal view, shows schematically the enamel crown surface, an exaggerated sketch of the deformed adhesive, and the loaded bracket. On the right, following a "cut" through the adhesive, which is made parallel to the load Q, a free-body diagram has
been drawn of the bracket, pad, and a portion of the adhesive as a whole. Neglecting weight and the faciolingual thickness, the distributed
internal force system exposed by the "cut" is entirely shear. A force balance indicates that the resultant internal force must equal Q. The average shear stress in the adhesive equals the resultant of the distribu-
tion divided by the area in shear k. In the examples of the module in tension and the adhesive in shear, the resultant internal force equals the product of average stress and the corresponding area. The computation in arch-wire bending, however, is somewhat more complex. Figure 3-15 depicts a wire segment with the "right-section cut" (perpendicular to the longitudinal dimension) exposing an internal cross-sectional area (seen only in edge view in the figure) and a typical internal force system including both forms of normal stress as well as shear stress, with none of the three uniformly distributed. In this segment, no inelastic behavior is present and the resultant of the tensile- and compressive-stress distributions is a pair of equal, opposite, and parallel forces—a "bending couple." The resultant of the shear-
91
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Q
Average shear stress where A,.
=
total area exposed by the cut'
FIGURE 3-14. Shear loading of a bonded bracket and shear-stress distribution within the bonding adhesive.
distribution is an internal force tangent to the area exposed by the "cut" and parallel to the direction of external force causing the bending deformation. A complete discussion of bending is undertaken in Chapter 7. stress
Mechanical and Structural Properties: Standardized Testing The
response of a structural member to external loading depends
upon the size and shape, or geometry, of the member, the relationship of the loading pattern or characteristics to that geometry, and the mechanical properties of the material of the member. Problems of analysis
92
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics Compressive stresses
Wire segment Position and direction ot shear stresses
Distribution ot shear stress
FIGURE 3-15. Typical stress patterns internal to a structural member subjected to inplane bending.
or design of structures are often approached by taking experimentally
determined mechanical-property values, substituting them into formulas or equations that express the governing principles of mechanics and
include the contributions of geometric and loading parameters, and thereby obtain or check what might be termed structural potential or capacity. The differences, if any, in bending characteristics of two, .016-
in. -diameter, arch wires, for example, are founded in the mechanical properties of the wire materials. Hence, a familiarity with these material properties is important to the practitioner. Many of the fundamental mechanical properties of a solid material are commonly quantified through the performance of a static tension test. Each test specimen is carefully prepared to minimize experimental varia-
tion or "error" associated with the testing itself. The test volume (the middle portion, longitudinally) of the specimen is uniform in cross-sectional shape and size; the cross-section often exhibits at least one axis of
geometric symmetry. The straight specimen is to be held at its ends, some distance away from the test volume such that the manner of attachment of the loading system to the specimen will not influence the test volume and the data gathered. An example test specimen is shown in the "grips" of the testing apparatus in Figure 3-16. The grips transfer the loading, measured by the testing machine, to the specimen in the resultant form of a longitudinal force having a line of action that passes through the centers of the cross-sections of the test volume. With the weight of the specimen ne-
glected (compared to the load), the specimen is a two-force member, similar to the module of Figure 3-12 and as described in Chapter 2. The grips are attached to the "heads" of the testing machine; one head is movable and the other is stationary. The testing machine has the capability to apply a slowly increasing load (thus the term "static" test) and
Load P
-II
IV
Responsive
forceP
-
FIGURE 3-16. A tensile-test specimen in the grips of a standard test apparatus.
_____ 94 Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
to monitor continuously the magnitude of that load. A longitudinal or
axial dimension within the test volume is known as the "gauge length." Its initial value, before external loading is begun, is shown in Figure 3-16 as 4?,,. An "extensometer" is attached to the specimen at the extremes of
the gauge length, or an alternative procedure is employed, to enable instantaneous measurements of the gauge length which increases during the tension test. (The extensometer weight must also be negligible compared to the specimen load or counterbalanced so as not to create notable testing error or destroy the mechanical symmetry.) In the test itself, the loading is begun from zero and gradually increased until rupture of the specimen occurs. Readings of applied load (which equals the internal axial tensile force) and the corresponding extensional deformation (or extended length) of the gauge length are taken, either manually within equal loading increments or, by means of transducers and a stripchart recorder, recorded continuously by the testing machine and plotted as the test is proceeding. The extension of the gauge length during the tension test will depend upon its initial length; therefore, this extension or elongation is "normalized" with respect to the initial length. Axial deformation per unit length is a form of engineering normal strain: 4?
(3-1) e,,
The test under discussion produces longitudinal tensile strain; if the loading sense is reversed, the gauge length is lessened under pushing force and longitudinal compressive strain is induced. Corresponding to the normal strains are normal stresses against cross-sectional areas exposed by "cutting" the specimen perpendicular to its longitudinal axis. The uniformly distributed internal force system, as in the module example, has an intensity that depends on the size of the exposed area. The engineering tensile stress equals the resultant, internal force divided by the pas-
sive, cross-sectional area. Note that by converting force to stress and deformation to strain, the net effect is the dividing out of the volume of material in the test section and, thereby, eliminating the influences of specimen size from the test results. (As the test specimen elongates under load, the cross-sectional area generally reduces; recall the Poisson effect illustrated in Figure 3-4. Engineering stress and strain are obtaine& by dividing out the undefonned, as-prepared area and length of the test volume. True stress and strain are obtained by dividing the instantaneous, deformed area and length into the corresponding internal force and elon-
gallon, respectively. All stresses and strains discussed in this chapter and throughout the text are engineering stresses and strains.) From the paired readings taken during the tension test, converting force to stress and elongation or stretched length to strain, a tensile stress-strain diagram is prepared (either by hand or plotted by the testing machine). With modifications of coordinates of data only through division by constants, the stress-strain diagram in tension for a specific ma-
95
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
—'C C,) C,)
C
Stainless, nickel-chrome steel
Mild, structural steel E
x: tracture point
0
Tensile Strain
0
Tensile Strain
FIGURE 3-17. Stress-strain diagrams in tension, obtained from static testing, for mild, structural steel (left) and for a stainless steel (right).
terial has the same shape as the tensile, load-versus-deformation plot for
a structural member of the same material. Shown in Figure 3-17 are tensile stress-strain diagrams depicting the behavior of mild, structural steel, which exhibits a yielding phenomenon, and a stainless steel, which does not notably yield. Yielding is the straining of the material at virtually a constant stress well below the level at which rupture occurs. Illustrated in Figure 3-18 are diagrams for a ceramic material and twoand three-part diagrams for typical polymeric materials. The mechanical properties of interest are obtained from the stress-strain diagram for the material and from measurements taken directly from the specimen, and
are analogous to corresponding structural properties, many of which have been defined previously. A crystalline material obeys Hooke's Law, which states that the stress-
strain ratio is constant up to the proportional limit; the constant in this linear stress-strain relationship is the modulus of elasticity E (Young's modulus) in tension, the elastic stiffness of the material and the slope of the initial portion of the diagram. The ultimate strength of the material is the value of the maximum ordinate of the curve; as indicated in Figure 3-17 this may or may not be the stress level at fracture (but if the high point of the cprve is reached in loading, although data may be taken at greater strains, the imminent fracture generally cannot be prevented). The coordinates of the fracture/rupture point are ordinarily termed the fracture strain and fracture stress or strength. The proportional and elastic limits are close together on the curve; the coordinates of the elastic limit are termed the elastic-limit strain and elastic strength of the material. Accordingly, the simple relationship a = Ec, which is the expression of
96
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Tensile Stress
A ceramic material
x: fracture point
Polymeric materials
0
Tensile Strain
FIGURE 3-18. Static stress-strain diagrams in tension for ceramic and polymeric materials.
Hooke's Law in direct tension, holds virtually up to the elastic limit. For
those crystalline materials that yield, the yield strength is the stress level at which this phenomenon is exhibited; because yielding immediately follows the initiation of inelastic action in tension, the values of elastic strength and yield strength are, for practical purposes, equal.
In the discussion of mechanical properties, the word "modulus" implies "per unit volume;" accordingly, the modulus of resilience of the material is quantitatively the area under the stress-strain diagram up to the elastic limit and the modulus of toughness is the total area under the diagram to the point of fracture. A material is relatively ductile or brittle, depending on the extent of the stress-strain diagram beyond the elastic limit. Clearly, the ceramic material of Figure 3-18 reflects no ductility at
all; the plot being linear to fracture indicates the nonexistence of an elastic limit and the inability of the material to take a permanent strain. Typical measures of ductility are, analogous to the content of an earlier discussion of structural characteristics, the fracture strain referenced to the elastic-limit strain and the modulus of toughness relative to the modulus of resilience. A third measure is obtained by taking the two por-
tions of the fracture specimen from the testing machine, mating the fractured surfaces, measuring the as-fractured gauge length, determining the corresponding strain value, and finally multiplying by 100 to obtain the percent elongation at fracture. A fourth measure of ductility,
97
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
similar to the third, is obtained from the pretest cross-sectional area and
the cross-sectional area of the fractured specimen at the fracture location: the percent reduction in area.
Noncrystalline materials, such as the polymers of Figure 3-18, seldom exhibit any useful level of ductility and often do not obey Hooke's Law. As a result, there is little distinction between elastic strength and ultimate strength. Although not exactly correct, the elastic limit may be taken as the point where the slope of the stress-strain curve begins to increase substantially toward rupture. The stiffness per unit volume is not a constant in those ranges where the curve is nonlinear; hence, the simple relation between stiffness modulus and the coordinates of the elastic limit, (cr/e)ej = E for crystalline materials, is not valid for those materials exhibiting a nonlinear first portion of their stress-strain diagrams. To determine the stress level, for a given activation in tension of an elastic for example, it is best to directly measure the force and divide that magnitude by the cross-sectional area. Mechanical properties of materials are obtained from simple experiments, tension tests for example, which generate the fundamental forms
of deformation cited previously. Because their values often depend upon the form of deformation generated in the test, these properties when quantified must be presented as "in tension," "in compression," or "in shear." In addition, the rate of loading during the test will influence mechanical-property values to some extent; for example, distinctions are made between static and impact tests. Furthermore, environmental conditions, particularly temperature in the test locality, may affect values, as may specimen-storage time and conditions prior to testing. Finally, the as-received internal material configuration will partially
determine the values of some mechanical properties, in particular for a metallic material the coordinates of the elastic limit and, therefore, its modulus of resilience. (The influence on properties of permanent deformations and accompanying "residual stresses" is considered in Chapter 4.) Material behavior in static compression is similar to that exhibited in a tension test, but some differences in test specimens and procedures, and in obtained mechanical-property values, do exist. In an axial compression test, with the sense of the loading reversed from that of the tension test, the as-prepared specimen often has a uniform cross-sectional geometry from one end to the other, and is short and thick to ensure symmetric loading throughout the test and to avoid the possible occurrence of lateral deflection or buckling. Load and deformation data are taken, converted to compressive stress and strain, and the diagram is constructed. For a crystalline material, the modulus of elasticity is generally the same in tension and compression, although the extension of the linear portion of the curve to a greater elastic-strength magnitude in compression than in tension is not uncommon. Noncrystalline materials may exhibit a substantially altered stress-strain diagram in compression compared to the tension plot. With molecular materials not extensively cross-linked, the chain molecules that uncoil at low to mod-
98
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
loads in tension clearly would not do so to any great extent in compression. Although some tensile strain is developed laterally from the Poisson effect accompanying the axial loading, with compressive loading, interatomic bond deformations begin almost immediately. Ultierate
mate strength in compression is defined and computed in the same manner as in tension, but the failure mode must be substantially different from the tensile rupture. The load-carrying capacity of a member in direct compression is lost when one of the following occurs: extensive lateral deformation (buckling); longitudinal splitting (also known as internal buckling); or a "slipping fracture," on a plane inclined with respect to the loading axis, due to the exceeding of the ultimate strength of the material in shear. (Although absent on right cross-sections in members undergoing direct tensile or compressive loading, shear stresses exist on all other planes exposed by "cuts" through the members and are largest on planes at 45° with the loading axis.) The nonlinear portion of the stress-strain curve in compression, seemingly related to ductility, is often reduced comparatively in materials that can sustain at least moderate amounts of inelastic action in tension; the opposite may be true with apparently brittle materials because right-section rupture cannot occur under compressive loading. Examples of actual or potential shear deformation, associated with orthodontic appliances, were cited previously; a schematic was shown in Figure 3-5 and the shear strain, generally symbolized by y or is defined as the tangent of the angle developed as two intersecting line segments at a point within the material, passively perpendicular, are inclined to one another with the member under load. In a test to determine mechanical properties in shear, the specimen and loading are typically similar to the bonded bracket assembly of Figure 3-14 except that
the specimen is quite small, is of one material, and in particular the moment distance of the applied force with respect to the specimen support is minimized. Readings of load and angular deformation obtained are converted to shear stress and strain, and the reduced data are plotted to give the stress-strain diagram. Two example diagrams are presented in Figure 3-19. The form of the plot for the crystalline material is, by now, familiar; mechanical properties as derived from the diagram are defined exactly as in the tension or compression test except each name ends with the phrase "in shear." The slope of the linear part of the shear-test curve, however, is generally often termed the modulus of rigidity G. From stiffness magnitudes, many metallic materials seem to be more flexible in shear; for arch-wire alloys, the ratio of elastic moduli in identical units,
shear to axial tension, is about 0.4. (Although measured differently, both normal and shear strains are nondimensional, so these stiffnesses are dimensionally alike.) Hooke's Law for pure shear loading is written T = G-y and is valid up to the proportional limit in shear. For ductile materials in general, the elastic and ultimate strengths in shear are about one-half of the comparable values in tension; for brittle materials, the ratio of ultimate strength in shear to that in tension approaches unity.
99
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Shear Stress
A crystalline material
Shear Strain
0
FIGURE 3-19. Static stress-strain diagrams in shear for crystalline and polymeric materials.
The forms of the stress-strain diagram in shear and in compression are
similar for most molecular and amorphous materials; the initial nonlinear portion of the three-part curves in tension of some noncrystalline materials, as shown in Figure 3-18, is rarely seen under compressive or shear loading.
Previously depending upon mechanical-property data generated elsewhere, in 1977 the Council on Dental Materials and Devices of the American Dental Association announced the ADA Specification Number 32 for orthodontic wires not containing precious metals. The Specification includes a detailed description of the preparation and testing of arch-wire specimens toward the determination of the modulus of elasticity and "yield strength" for the arch-wire material in flexure (bending). A schematic of the cantilevered-beam test is given in Figure 3-20. A bending couple is applied to one end of the specimen where only rota-
tion is permitted; at the other end of the test span the wire is held against a fixed, knife-edge stop. The angular deformation measured is the rotation of the shaft, which is also the rotation of the end cross-section of the specimen engaging the shaft with respect to the passive orientation. A typical plot of the couple versus the rotational deformation, for a specimen of metallic material not exhibiting a well-defined yield point, is
100
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Load couple C
FIGURE 3-20. An illustration of the fiexure-test arrangement dictated by ADA Specification No. 32.
presented in Figure 3-21. To obtain an equivalent yield point, approximating the elastic limit, the dashed line is drawn parallel to the initial, linear portion of the plot, intersecting the deformation axis at the specified offset (approximately 2.9° according to Specification No. 32), and the yield strength of the material is determined from the couple magnitude at the point. (The actual computations to quantify the elastic modu-
lus and yield strength in flexure are outlined in Chapter 7.) A third material property of orthodontic interest may then be computed; the ratio of yield strength to modulus of elasticity is termed the springback of the material and is a close approximation to the elastic-limit strain. Table 3-1 contains approximate values of these three properties in bending for five arch-wire materials. In addition to the static flexure test, an experimental procedure that may be terminated after the data confirms exceeding of the elastic limit, another is required which, in part, provides an indication of the ductility
of the wire material. In this second portion of the Specification, a 90° bend is placed in the wire, then removed, and then replaced at the same cross-section and in the same direction. The radius of the bend is specified. The 90-to-0-to-90° bending cycle is continued at a specific rate until fracture occurs. The number of cycles to failure is then compared with the Specification requirements, which vary somewhat with wire size. Before concluding this section, several additional comments associated with testing and mechanical properties are in order. Indicating that a material is relatively "hard" or "soft" does not pertain, strictly speaking, to any previously discussed property. Hardness is defined as the resistance of a material to localized, permanent, compressive deformation (indentation); it is, therefore, largely a surface phenomenon. Hardness numbers are determined experimentally by subjecting a material specimen to an indenter of a specific geometry exerting a designated load. Indices of hardness familiar to engineers are the Brinell and Rockwell hardness scales. Although hardness is very nearly, directly proportional to ultimate tensile strength for a number of metallic materials, this property must not be confused with material stiffness or resilience. Mechanical properties of some materials are difficult to quantify by testing because their stress-strain characteristics change with time under
101
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Load Couple C
Equivalent
yield point
/ /
/
/ Stiffness
/
/ / 0
Angular Deformation 0
FIGURE 3-21. Couple versus angular deformation; typical plot of flexure-test data obtained according to ADA Specification No. 32.
load. Although not a factor at room or oral temperature with most metals, often it is with molecular materials, particularly certain polymers. Subjecting a typical, orthodontic, elastic module, thread, or "chain" to a moderate tensile load, and holding that load constant while monitoring deformation, a continuing elongation will be observed over a period of hours. The material is said to creep and, from data taken, a strain-versustime curve may be generated similar to the plot of Figure 3-22. If the temperature or time period is sufficiently high or long, the straight-line portion of the curve will give way to a nonlinear increase in strain fol-
lowed by rupture, even though the stress level may be substantially below the ultimate strength of the material as gained from a static, tension test at room temperature. A material that creeps will also "relax." Relaxation is the decrease with time of load carried under conditions of constant strain; a relaxation plot is presented in Chapter 4.
102
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
TABLE 3-1. Mechanical pmperties in bending for selected, orthodontic, arch-wire materials
Modulus of elasticity
Yield strength
Springback*
(x106 lb/in.2)
(x103 lb/in.2)
(x102 in/in.)
A gold alloy
15
150
0.94
Type 302 stainless steel
29
280
0.97
Elgiloy (Cr-Co alloy)
28.5
315
1.1
Material
Nitinol (Ni-Ti alloy)
4.8
195.
4.1
Beta titanium (Ti-Mo alloy)
9.5
170
1.8
upon unloading from the (equivalent) yield point: the yieldstrength-to-elastic-modulus ratio. Yield strength and springback values will vary with cold working or heat treatment. *The recovered, unit
The final topic considered in this section is fatigue, the progressive failure of a material undergoing loading that changes with time. Usually
such loading is cyclic, exhibiting a repeating pattern; the maximum stress generated may be substantially below the ultimate strength of the material obtained from a static test, and still result in an eventual fracture. Examples of cyclic loading pertinent to orthodontics include masti-
Strain
Stage 3
0
Time
FIGURE 3-22. A strain-versus-time plot illustrating the three stages of creep.
103
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Stress
Ultimate strength
Endurance limit
0
Number of Cycles to Fracture
FIGURE 3-23. A typical plot of the results of tests to fracture of a metallic member subjected to cyclic loading in bending.
(relatively high-frequency cycling) and the daily activation, continuous-force, deactivation pattern associated with an extraoral cation
appliance and interrupted loading (low-frequency cycling). A common fatigue failure is the progressive fracture of a bent-wire segment emerging from the acrylic which is part of a retainer; the removal and replacement of the appliance represents one cycle. Figure 3-23 shows the re-
suits of a series of fatigue tests in bending. The curve intersects the stress axis at the ultimate-strength level. The inclined portion of the plot is obtained from fractures occurring at maximum stress levels below the ultimate-strength value; the lower the stress, the greater the number of cycles to failure. Below a particular stress level, termed the endurance limit, fracture does not occur regardless of the number of load cycles. With the retainer in which the wire eventually fractures, the maximum
stress in the activated wire ioop is less than the ultimate strength but greater than the endurance limit of the wire material. Besides indicating
level of ductility, the previously described bending test to fracture within ADA Specification No. 32, owing to the cyclic-loading pattern required, also indirectly provides an approximate, relative measure of arch-wire resistance to fatigue.
Chemical and Thermal Influences With orthodontic application in mind, a discussion of the chemical and thermal behaviors of solids is undertaken. The chemical and thermal material properties themselves are not the principal focus of atten-
104
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
lion, but rather the potential for interactions that may result in deleterious effects upon the mechanical or physical characteristics of orthodontic materials. Some, and often all, of the members of the ortho-
dontic appliance must exist and "work" for substantial periods of time in the oral cavity. Materials used in the mouth must be biologically admissible and the potential for interference with acceptability, because of chemical reactions that may occur over time, either before or during intraoral engagement, must be realized and understood. The oral-cavity environment is inherently corrosive. The oral fluids are strong, potential reactants toward oxidation of metals. Saliva is known to contain salts and acids are often liberated during mastication; ingested food and drink vary widely in their levels of acidity or alkalinity (pH). Food debris may become lodged and remain for relatively long periods of time and provide the catalyst for initiation of corrosion; although generally a dental-care matter, the tendency for this occurrence is increased by the presence of appliances. Both metallic materials (e.g., restorations, wires, bands) and molecular solids (e.g., "elastics," cements, adhesives, acrylics) may be increasingly vulnerable to chemical degradation in the moist oral environment. The effects of chemistry and temperature upon the materials themselves, as well as the products of chemical reactions, must be of concern. The extraoral environment may also influence the structural capabilities of orthodontic appliance materials. The time period between manufacture and actual use can be substantial. Storage may occur with the manufacturer, with the vendor, and with the practitioner. Molecular materials, in particular, often have a finite "shelf-life," which may be reduced by high temperature and humidity. Parts of extraoral appliances come into contact with skin and hair, and the oils as well as perspiration, often together with particles suspended in the air, can and do have a degrading effect. Corrosion is defined as a deterioration because of a chemical reaction that results in apparent disappearance of the material attacked. Corrosion may occur by a chemical solution contacting the material; ionization ensues and the material is dissolved in the fluid. For example, silver will be corroded by a solution containing sulfides with silver sulfide formed in the solvent. A more common form of corrosion is known as electrochemical oxidation. Characteristic of metallic materials, the process begins with a reaction initiated by a fluid that removes electrons, thereby form-
ing positive material ions. In turn, chemical combination of these ions with electrically negative ions in the fluid may take place. Rusting starts with the stripping of three electrons from the iron element, forming the
ferric ion. The degree to which electrons are bound to the atoms in metals varies, and so also does their tendency to form compounds in the
presence of nonmetals having incomplete outer electron shells. Gold and platinum are relatively inactive and, in mining, are often found in the pure form; iron and aluminum, for example, as active metals, are continually oxidized and must be purified (reduced) chemically before metallurgical processing.
105
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Generally, corrosion occurs as a combination of the two forms described. The facility for the ionization of a metal is dependent upon the nature of the fluid-solvent and the inherent activity level of the material; the latter is often termed the electrode potential of the metal and is a direct indicator of its corroding tendency. The determination of the ranking of metals by electrode potential is accomplished through use of the "standard cell" shown in Figure 3-24. Immersed in the solution is the test-metal
electrode on the left and a hydrogen electrode on the right, the two connected externally through a potentiometer. Ionization begins at both
electrodes; however, depending upon the electrode potential of the metal with respect to hydrogen, electrons will flow one way or the other, registering a potential difference on the meter. The experiment is
Potentiometer
H2
V TM ±
1-1k
TM
Electrolyte
Positive ion of test metal or alloy H2: Hydrogen gas Hydrogen ion FIGURE 3-24. A standard electrochemical cell.
106
Bioengineering Analysis of O,thodontic Mechanics
repeated, changing only the test metal. With all potential-difference val-
ues recorded, a ranking such as that given in Table 3-2 is obtained with hydrogen as the reference ion. Consider a cell such as that shown in Figure 3-25 with iron as the electrode on the left and water as the solution. From Table 3-2, iron has a
higher electrode potential than tin and, upon ionizing, electrons removed from the iron flow through the connector to the hydrogen electrode. The hydrogen gas is also ionized and water molecules are decom-
posed into hydrogen and hydroxyl (OH) ions. The electrons coming from the iron unite with hydrogen ions and hydrogen gas is liberated. 3-2. Electrode-potential rankings, with respect to hydrogen, of selected metals and alloys TABLE
The ranking to follow is in the order of most anodic, at the top of the list, to most cathodic at the bottom of the list. Magnesium Aluminum, active Titanium Cesium Vanadium Zinc Aluminum, passivated Chromium Iron
Stainless steel, active Cadmium Cobalt Nickel, active Lead-tin solder Tin
Lead
nconel*, active HYDROGEN Brass
Copper Bronze Monelt Nickel, passivated lnconel*, passivated Stainless steel, passivated Silver Palladium Mercury Platinum Gold lnconel is a nickel-chromium alloy. tMonel is a copper-nickel alloy.
107
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance Electron flow
Fe3t Iron ions OH—: Hydroxyl ion Fe(OH)3: Rust
FIGURE 3-25. A galvanic cell illustrating the electrochemical corrosion of iron.
ferric ions react with the water and oxygen therein to form ferric hydroxide: rust. The rusting of iron will occur in such a galvanic cell, in fact, whenever the iron is connected externally to an electrode having a lower potential (occupying a lower position in Table 3-2) and the elecThe
trodes are immersed in a solution (the electrolyte) wherein hydroxyl ions become available with ionization. In general, the electrode supplying the electrons is called the anode and the receiver of electrons is the cathode. The anode experiences this galvanic corrosion and the location of
the corrosion products will depend upon the relative ease with which the ions, forming those products, are able to diffuse through the electrolyte. In a galvanic cell containing iron and a less active metal, because ferric ions are smaller than hydroxyl ions and because the product requires three OH ions for every ferric ion, rust will usually be found at or near the cathode. The formation of a galvanic cell with the physical contact of an orthodontic-appliance member and an amalgam restoration, in the presence of saliva as the electrolyte, results in momentary ionization and electron flow and the dental "galvanic shock." This is an example of a composition cell established between two dissimilar metals. A tin roof, placed on a
108
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
building having steel siding, becomes cathodic and corrosion begins in
the presence of moisture and direct contact between roof and siding. Important in addition are the more subtle forms of electrochemical cells. A stress cell may form between two different locations on the same material, because of an imbalance in electrode potential. A vivid example of stress corrosion is the etching or corroding of grain boundaries; the
atoms at the boundaries are more loosely bound and, therefore, are potentially anodic with respect to those within the crystals. It follows, then, that a fine-grained metal is potentially more vulnerable to corrosive attack than is a coarse-grained metal. An imbalance in electrode potential at different surface locations of the same material results from localized inelastic action. The region of a permanent bend in an arch wire is anodic in comparison to the passively-straight portions of the wire. A concentration cell may occur involving one material (or two) when the electrolyte is nonhomogeneous. The surface area exposed to an electrolyte is potentially more active where the concentration is lower. In a one-material cell, the region exposed to a diluted electrolyte is anodic with respect to a region in contact with a concentrated electrolyte. The
significance here is the anodic nature of cracks, crevices, and areas under accumulations of debris or other surface contaminations. Moreover, often the deposits of corrosion products aggravate the situation and increase the rate of degradation; localized pitting of a material is a typical manifestation. Electrochemical corrosion requires the presence of two electrodes, physical contact between them for conduction of electrons, and an ionizing, ion-carrying fluid, the electrolyte. Retardation or elimination of corrosion tendencies necessitates minimization of the electrode potential or a break in the "circuit." In two-material systems, corrosion may be prevented by insulating one material from the other or one or both materials from the electrolyte. With one material, isolate it from the electrolyte, keep its surface smooth, clean, and free of sharp edges, and reduce its inherent electrode potential. Steel coated with zinc is "galvanized" to separate the steel from moisture. Because zinc is more active than steel, it is the potential anode should a crack or scratch expose the steel. Orthodontic stainless steel generally resists corrosion well because its surface is protected by passivation with chromium oxide, the nickel in the alloy allows a reduction in carbon content (and a lessening, then of the potential for chromium-carbide formation while retaining strength and ductility properties), and the result is a position in Table 3-2 just above silver.
The foregoing discussion has dealt primarily with "wet" corrosion in which a liquid electrolyte or at least moisture is necessary to the reaction. Dry corrosion is the result of a chemical reaction of the affected material with a gas, often air. With metals the specific gaseous reactant is oxygen and an oxide scale is formed, initially on the metal surface. In general, the rate of increase of the film thickness depends upon the existing thickness, the diffusion coefficients for the reactants, and the temperature. Continuation of the reaction is dependent upon the pene-
109
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
trabiity of the scale film by either the gas or the metal ions. An example of dry oxidation is the passivation of stainless steel; the chromium oxide film is very thin and highly impenetrable. Dry corrosion of molecular materials also occurs; of particular interest is the aging of elastomers. In this oxidation reaction the initial result is an increase in cross-linking (secondary bonding), which causes harden-
ing, stiffening, and embrittlement. Heat, light, stress, and ozone concentration influence aging, which takes place because of the existence of
free-end molecular chains. Antioxidants may be incorporated during polymerization to combine in a monofunctional manner with the chain ends to provide some resistance to aging. The practitioner must be aware of aging and its effects, particularly with regard to the time period and location of storage of polymeric, orthodontic-appliance elements. In a moist environment polymeric materials experience a combination of solution and aging corrosion. "Elastics" that have been stored may contain aging cracks that are catalysts for further and accelerated degradation following activation; intraoral placement of these elements tends to quicken deterioration compared to extraoral application. Another type of degradation occurring in the orthodontic setting involves extraoral appliances, in particular the neck pads, head caps, and
other nonmetallic elements that come into contact with the skin and hair. A form of wet corrosion occurs as skin and hair oils, and perspiration attack these molecular materials over time. Although causing some aging, of equal or perhaps more concern is the chemical reaction initi-
ated by the hydrocarbons that ultimately breaks down the material structure into small molecules, thereby drastically reducing mechanical strength. The progress of this deterioration is relatively slow, and material discolorations indicate the start of the process. Frequent cleansings of washable parts of the extraoral appliance, for example, retards this form of corrosion. The effects of temperature on a material are, to a great extent, manifested through influences upon properties already discussed. The fundamental material response to change in temperature is on the level of atomic activity which, in turn, affects volume. A typical unconstrained solid will expand upon experiencing an increase in temperature; such a material will contract as its temperature is lowered. (Some polymeric materials, however, react differently with temperature changes due to accompanying bonding alterations.) A structural member that is constrained against undergoing volumetric change will be subjected to induced thermal stresses if its temperature is altered; these stresses are superimposed upon those that exist due to mechanical loading. The increased vibrational motions of atoms and molecules, accompanying increased temperatures, generally affect mechanical behavior in that ductility characteristics are enhanced but strength properties are reduced. The rates of, or tendencies toward, creep and relaxation grow as the temperature rises. The greater the atomic motions, the more easily materials may be ionized; hence, increased temperatures generally raise the rates of corrosion and oxidation.
110
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodonfic Mechanics
In general, the effect of an incremental change in temperature is greater upon nonmetals than upon metals. Pertinent to orthodontic application, the influence of the difference between room and oral temperature, or between that of ingested ice cream and coffee, is inconsequential upon arch-wire materials. The effects of such temperature differentials, however, are discernible in many of the elastomeric materials. Although the metallic appliance components do not experience large temperature ranges during actual orthodontic therapy, they may in soldering, welding, or heat-treatment procedures prior to engagement and activation. Note that when the temperature is raised to about 900°F and above, the carbon atoms in stainless steels tend to migrate toward the grain boundaries; they combine with chromium ions to form chromium carbide, and the passivating potential of the alloy is lessened. Hence, care must be taken in soldering or welding this material, and other metals and alloys, to concentrate the heat and hold it for only a very short time.
Selection of Materials In concluding this chapter, comments pertaining to the selection of ma-
terials are appropriate. Although materials and appliance members associated with orthodontic therapy are of specific interest, the same criteria are reviewed and examined in the intelligent selection of materials for any structural or machine application. The relationship of the relevant characteristics or properties of the material to its intended use must be the first and overriding considera-
tion in material selection. The orthodontic appliance is a structural mechanism and, with appliance members available in varieties of physical sizes, attention is focused primarily on mechanical properties. Archwire materials must be ductile if arch fabrication, including the place-
ments of permanent bends and twists, is necessary. Moreover, arch wires must be moderately flexible while possessing substantial elastic strength to provide desired activation and deactivation responses. All parts of the appliance must exhibit strength characteristics to sustain without failure the stresses induced in appliance activation, both at the moment of engagement and over time periods ranging from a few days to, perhaps, several years. Possible chemical reactions, which may affect mechanical behavior or result in unwanted product compounds, must be a factor of serious consideration, particularly in the selection of intra-
oral appliance materials. Ideally, the mechanical characteristics of a structural material should not be influenced by time or by temperature fluctuations that may occur in the service environment; however, with real materials, one or both of these parameters may exert significant impact on mechanical behavior.
111
Material Behavior of the Orthodontic Appliance
Other factors to be evaluated are generally subordinate to those directly associated with in-service use and are given significant weight in the selection decision only when, from principal considerations, two or more materials seem equally suitable or when a compromise is warranted and can be tolerated. The ranking of these additional factors will vary, depending on the specific application and, often, on financial influences. Costs will clearly impact the selection, and they include the initial investment, expenses associated with subsequent fabrication, and costs related to storage of the material. A compromise directly related to initial cost has led to the virtual disappearance of gold alloys as archwire materials. Availability is another factor that may influence initial cost and may, at least temporarily, impact the selection procedure. In any business involving a product, inventories must be kept, and orthodontic practices are no exception. Accordingly, the effects of storage on the material and the needs for handling and working with the material, in transforming it from the condition "as received" to the state of readiness for immediate use, come into consideration. Chemical degradation limits the "shelf life" of a number of materials used by the orthodontist. Moreover, many cements, adhesives, alginates, and acrylics, for example, require storage in controlled environments or careful mixing to produce chemical reactions resulting in optimum material characteristics. Not to be ignored, but often rightfully near or at the end of the list of influencing factors, is appearance. Although advertising may attempt to inflate the importance of external attractiveness, the potential user must place this factor in its proper position in the list of selection criteria. Although often an apparently difficult decision, a sacrifice within the primary selection factor, that of relation of material properties to inservice use, should rarely be made solely to accommodate appearance.
Suggested Readings Burstone, C.J.: Application of bioengineering to clinical orthodontics. In Current
Orthodontic Concepts and Techniques. 2nd Ed. Edited by T. M. Graber and B. F. Swain. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders, 1975, Chapter 3. Burstone, C.J., and Goldberg, A.J.: Beta titanium: A new orthodontic alloy. Am. J. Orthod., 77:121—132, 1980.
Greener, E.H., Harcourt, J.K., and Lautenschlager, E.P.: Materials Science in Dentistry. Baltimore, Williams & Wilkins, 1972, Chapters 3—6, 8, 11, and 13.
Hayden, H.W., Moffatt, W.G., and Wuiff, H.C.: The Structure and Properties of Materials. Vol. III. New York, John Wiley & Sons, 1965, Chapters 1—3, 6, 7, and 10. Jarabak, JR., and Fizzell, J.A.: Technique and Treatment with Light-wire Edgewise Appliances. 2nd Ed. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1972, Chapter 3.
112
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Kusy, R.P., and Greenberg, A.R.: Effects of composition and cross-section on
the elastic properties of orthodontic arch wires. Angle Orthod., 51:325—341, 1981.
Richards, C.W.: Engineering Materials Science. Belmont, CA, Wadsworth Publishing, 1961, Chapters 1—4, 8, 9, 12, and 13. Phillips, R.W.: Skinner's Science of Dental Materials. 7th Ed. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders, 1973, Chapters 2, 3, 11, 15—19, and 32.
Thurow, R.C.: Edgewise Orthodontics. 4th Ed. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1982, Chapters 3, 7, and 8. Van Vlack, L.H.: Elements of Materials Science. 2nd Ed. Reading, Massachusetts, Addison-Wesley Publishing, 1964, Chapters 1—3, 6, 7, and 12.
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics ]
The theoretical developments within classical mechanics have provided two analysis formulations. The four laws offered by Isaac Newton are
the foundation for one approach toward the solution of problems in mechanics, and two mathematicians—Jean Bernoulli, a Swiss, and J. L. Lagrange, a Frenchmen—are generally given credit for the more con-
temporary hypotheses and methods of work and energy. In Chapter 2 the procedures of Newtonian mechanics were introduced as based upon a set of equations of equilibrium or motion, depending upon the state of rest or movement of the mechanical system. The free-body diagram was introduced and employed as a principal tool in the solution of problems. Generally, the objective was the altering,
simplifying, or completing of the description of the set of forces and couples exerted at a particular instant of time upon or within the body or the elements of a structure or machine. In the analysis procedure employing work and energy, the mechanical system undergoes an actual or
contrived process that may be of short or long duration and results in changes in one or more of the characteristics of the system. To prepare for an analysis through use of the principles of work and energy, the body or set of elements or bodies included within the mechanical system under study must be defined. The initial state of the system is described at a particular time; physical, geometric, kinematic, thermal, chemical, and mechanical properties—any characteristics that may experience change during the ensuing process—are noted. The process that is to take place results from an interaction between the system and its surroundings. Therefore, the surroundings, which will influence
the changes in the mechanical system, must also be characterized. Of particular importance are (1) the set of forces and couples to be exerted by the surroundings upon the mechanical system under study and (2) any heat sources or heat "sinks" in the surroundings that may interact with the system. With the system and its surroundings adequately described to define the initial state, an examination of the process is undertaken. A process is the interaction between a defined system and its surroundings that results in a change of state (alteration of character, changes 113
114
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
in property values) of the system. The final state of the mechanical system is described in terms of the properties of the system following com-
pletion of the process. In summary, the analysis is, in general, toward the solution of the following problem: Given the initial state of a mechanical system to be studied and the description of the interaction be-
tween the system and its surroundings during the defined process, characterize the final state of the system. Several processes associated with orthodontic treatment may be analyzed more directly through energy methods than by Newtonian mechanics. Included, and to be discussed in this chapter, are the processes of activation and deactivation of the orthodontic appliance, the placements of permanent bends and twists in an arch wire prior to intraoral engagement, the various forms of heat treatment to which arch wire and some auxiliaries may be subjected, and the actual process of manufacturing arch wire. Because each process to be analyzed generally involves some displacement or motion of the system, and the interaction may include the transfer of heat toward affecting the thermal as well as the mechanical characteristics of the system, it is appropriate that the body or group of bodies or system elements to be studied be termed a "thermodynamic system."
Concepts Leading to the Process Laws In this section appropriate concepts are introduced or reviewed toward
stating and understanding the process laws that govern the work-andenergy approach to mechanics problems.
Displacement As described in Chapter 1, the displacement of a particle is the change in
its position with respect to a reference framework. A straight-line, particle displacement is shown in Figure 4-1. The initial position of the parti-
cle is defined by the vector r1, drawn from point 0 to point P. The particle then moves to point Q. Labeling the coordinate s along the displacement path, the distance covered may be symbolized as where prefix represents "change in" the parameter. Because the the delta displacement is along a straight line in this example, the distance traveled by the particle equals the magnitude of the displacement vector. The displacement vector may be expressed more generally as the difference between the final and initial position vectors, r2 — r1. The displacement of just one point or particle of the body cannot indicate whether or not the orientation or angulation of the body was concurrently changed. If the body is rigid and is moved, but without an angular change, the displacement of the body is a translation and the displacements of all particles of the body have identical vector characteristics. Alternatively, if the orientation of the reference line in the rigid
115
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
y
Q .—
p
r2
0
x
FIGURE 4-1. The displacement of a particle along a straight-line path.
body is changed in the displacement, some form of rotation has occurred. If the body is nonrigid, linear displacements of particles or angular displacements of lines of the body may be the result of widespread or
localized deformations. Displacements accompanying deformations, both visible external changes in shape and alterations internal to the body, are of substantial interest in this chapter. Orthodontic displacements to be studied subsequently include that of one end of an "elastic" with respect to the other in an extensional activation, the displacements that occur in the elongation or compression from the passive state of a helical-coiled spring, the occiusogingival or faciolingual bending deactivation of an arch wire accompanying tooth movement, and the placement of a tip-back or toe-in bend in an arch wire. Mechanical Work
Displacements produced mechanically, whether or not the body experiences deformation, are associated with forces or force systems. Both
active and responsive forces may cause displacements; on the other hand, displacements can result in the creation of forces. Figure 4-2
116
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
y
F
P
0
x
FIGURE 4-2. A concentrated force exerted upon, and during its displacement doing work on, a particle.
shows a force exerted on the particle of Figure 4-1. As the particle under-
goes a displacement with the force acting on it, regardless of the relationship between the force and the displacement, the force is said to be doing mechanical work on the particle if the force has a nonzero component in the direction of the displacement. Although, in general, the magnitude or direction of the force may change during the particle displacement, if the vector characteristics of the force shown in Figure 4-2 are all constant, the work done by the force F on the particle as it moves from point P to point Q is equal to F(cos Although computed from two vectors, mechanical work is a scalar quantity. The component of the force involved is that having the direction of the displacement vector. If the force component and displacement vector have the same sense, the angle 4 is less than 900 and the work is algebraically positive; if the senses are opposite (q5 is between 90° and 180°), the work done is negative. If the force is continually perpendicular to the displacement vector, no work is done on the particle by the force. The force of Figure 4-2 would properly be termed an external force if
exerted on an isolated particle or a particle on the outside surface of a body; if the particle is internal to the body, the contact force would also be internal. Internal forces, occurring in canceling pairs, do zero net work on a rigid body; however, within a nonrigid body the net work of a pair of equal and opposite internal forces may be nonzero because the
117
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
particles on which they act may undergo unlike displacements. In the
absence of friction, the net work done by the force systems connecting one body to another is zero if the parts of the connection are rigid. A couple exerted on a body does work if the body experiences an associated rotation; the work is positive if, in the pertinent plane view, the couple and angular displacement have the same sense. Friction may also do work; if the force of friction is resistive to the displacement, the frictional force and displacement vectors will have opposite senses and the work of friction will be negative.
Work is done by the orthodontist in the placement of permanent bends or twists in arch wires; the forces are transmitted by the hands of the practitioner to and through the pliers and to the wires. In the placement of a tip-back bend, for example, the force system exerted by the pliers on the end of the wire, causing the rotational displacement beyond the elastic limit of the wire resulting in permanent deformation, is
a couple. The clinician does work on an elastic in stretching it, on a spring in compressing it, and on an arch wire in actively engaging it. Appliance elements do work on teeth as their force systems produce desired or unwanted displacements of dental units. In the typical bend or twist placement, activation, or deactivation, the force doing the work changes in magnitude with the displacement, requiring an averaging or a graphical procedure to quantify the work done; examples presented later in the chapter illustrate the methods of computing work in these instances.
The typical process in which mechanical work is done involves a change of state that is reflected partially in the displacements of particles of the mechanical system under study. A cause-and-effect relationship
exists between force and displacement in the process. The external forces that may do work on the system are exerted by elements of the surroundings of the mechanical system, indicating that this form of work is an interaction between system and surroundings. On the other hand, the work of internal forces occurs entirely within the system being
analyzed. In the overall analysis of a process, these two categories of work are often separated because of this difference and its ramifications.
Energy Newton's Second Law for a particle of mass in under the action of a
single, constant force F suggests that this force produces a proportional increase in the speed v of the particle with time t. For a one-dimensional motion, the relationship may be written as (4-1)
where Av and the displacement coordinate s have the same sense, identical to that of the force, as shown in Figure 4-3. The work done by F during the displacement of the particle from point P to point Q may be
118
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics m
P
F
Q
0
v+Av
v
As
At FIGURE
4-3. Changes in kinematic characteristics of a particle as work is done on it.
determined. Multiplying both sides of Equation 4-1 by As, noting that
speed is the time rate of displacement, and with appropriate mathematical operations, the following formula for mechanical work is obtained: Work = F(As)
+ Au)2 = + m[(v
—
v2}
(4-2)
The quantity ½mv2 is recognized as the kinetic energy of the particle; Equation 4-2 indicates that the work done on the particle results in a change in the kinetic energy of the particle. This relationship may be expanded to yield the law of kinetic energy: the work of all of the forces, internal as well as external, acting on a mechanical system, equals the change in kinetic energy of the system. The speeds used in the formula must be referenced to a stationary coordinate framework or one moving in a straight line with constant speed; such reference frames are termed Newtonian. Kinetic energy is energy of motion and the kinetic-energy law is a form of, and in one sense the basis for, the more general process law toward which the discussion of this section is directed. A rationale for partitioning the forms of work done in a process by the external and internal forces was suggested earlier. A parallel division separates the work done that is dependent on the displacement path(s) from that which is dependent only on the initial and final states of the mechanical system. An example of path-independent work is that which is performed by the force of gravity (weight). For processes during which the center of gravity of the system undergoes a change in elevation that is small compared to the radius of the Earth, the magnitude of the work done is the product of the weight and the elevation change. Because the force of gravity acts directly downward, gravitational work is negative when the elevation increases. A second example of path-independent work is that which is done on or by a helical-coiled spring in activating or deactivating it in direct tension or compression. In this example the magnitude of the force changes with the amount of spring deformation. Note that the force activating the spring and the resulting displacement always have the same sense; therefore, the work of activation on the spring is positive and by the spring (and on the attached body) is negative.
119
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics Passive state 0
, —
Initial state 1 ______x
Work12 =
Activated state A
Displaced state 2
x
Work done by gravity (left) and within a spring as it is stretched (right).
Figure 4-4 shows the forces and displacements associated with the work done by an external weight force (left) and that by the internal
forces in a spring (right). Because the amounts of work done are dependent only on the initial and final configurations of the system, and with
the form of the law of kinetic energy, such path-independent work is defined as energy change. Specifically, the work done by the weight force is, in magnitude, set equal to the change in gravitational potential energy, and the work done by the internal spring forces is, in absolute value, set equal to the change in strain energy of the spring. Moreover, in the examples of Figure 4-4, increases in energy levels of the bodies, increased elevation of the center of gravity and increased deformation of the spring, are seen to correspond algebraically to negative amounts of
work done on the bodies. To this point in the discussion, two forms of external energy, kinetic and gravitational potential, and one form of internal energy, strain energy, have been introduced. Energy is defined as the capacity of a body or system to produce an effect; thus far that effect has been, exclusively, mechanical work. Energy is a scalar quantity and generally is referenced
so as to be non-negative. Although kinetic energy has an apparently natural reference (zero speed), gravitational potential energy has no such convenient reference level. Although initially it might seem reasonable to set strain energy equal to zero for the passive state of the spring, this form of internal energy is added to the spring in the manufacturing process when it is given its coiled shape. In actual process analyses, only
changes in energy levels are determined. Zero-energy references are unnecessary, but for each individual process such references may be chosen in a reasonable manner, for each energy form, if so desired.
120
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
A work-energy analysis of standard testing procedures may be undertaken to determine certain mechanical-property values. Such tests were discussed initially in the previous chapter. The general process of interest is the loading of the test specimen. Because the loading is slow, the kinetic-energy change for the process is negligible. Thus, the law of kinetic energy reduces to "The total work of all forces, when individual contributions are algebraically summed, equals zero." With the work of
the weight force, the change in gravitational potential energy, also negligible, the process equation becomes the sum of two work contributions, that done by the external force system in loading the specimen (a positive quantity) and the work of the internal, responsive forces (a negative quantity), which must be zero. Substituting for the work of the internal forces, the final form of the process says that the work done in loading the specimen equals the increase in strain energy of the specimen. Figures 4-5 and 4-6 show the stress-strain and load-deflection diagrams associated with the standard uniaxial tension and ADA bending tests, respectively, which were described in Chapter 3. (In obtaining the diagram of Figure 4-5, the initial volume of the gauge-length portion of
the specimen has been divided out, converting force and deformed length into stress and strain.) With the loading force system increasing in magnitude with deformation, and the resulting need to sum quantities of the form F[AsI (in the tension test cr[A€J) to obtain the external work done, the total work in loading the specimen from its passive state to some deformed configuration is the area under the diagram up to that activated state. The process law says this area also equals the increase in strain energy. Therefore, in Figure 4-5, the process that takes the specimen from point 0 to point el, the elastic limit, requires positive, external
Stress
C
ci
area OABO: modulus of resilience area OCDO: modulus of toughness
0 0
B
Strain
FIGURE 4-5. A stress-strain diagram generated from the data of a standard tensile test.
121
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
p
Load Couple
a!
area OMNO: resilience area OPQO: toughness
Q
0
N
Angular Deformation
FIGURE 4-6. A load-deformation diagram plotted from the data of a bending test of a cantilevered beam.
work per unit volume, and increases the strain energy per unit volume an amount given by the triangular area under the stress-strain plot up to the dashed line. This area is also the magnitude of the mechanical property known as the modulus of resilience in tension ("modulus of" denoting
per-unit-volume). The amount of strain energy per unit volume that may be added to the specimen before fracture occurs is equal to the entire area under the stress-strain diagram, and is known as the modulus of toughness in tension. Analogous areas under the diagram of Figure 4-6 give the resilience and toughness of the arch-wire specimen in bending. Note that both the resilience and toughness magnitudes are dependent upon the "stress history" of the specimen. In their initial states the specimens contain unknown levels of internal energy; these levels are dependent upon the mechanical and/or thermal processes that occurred prior to the tests (including manufacturing operations). Just as a maximum load exists, which the specimen can sustain without fracture, the specimen also possesses a finite capacity for strain energy, and fracture will occur when this maximum level is exceeded. Heat Transfer and Thermal Energy
In general, a process may be initiated or accompanied by the transfer of
heat between the system and the surroundings. When heat is transferred to the system, a heat source must exist in the surroundings. If heat leaves the system, it is absorbed by a heat sink in the surroundings. In the
absence of perfect insulation between system and surroundings, and
122
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
with a temperature differential between them, heat will move from one to the other. Amounts of heat transfer are determinable; heat transfer, like mechanical work, is a scalar quantity, but it has sense, always moving from a region of higher temperature to one of lower temperature.
When heat flows to or from a system of finite size and capacity, the temperature of the system changes; the temperature increases when heat is transferred into the system and decreases when heat flows away from the system. Three forms of heat transfer are distinguishable: (1) conduction, by physical contact between system and surroundings; (2) convection, the transporting of heat between system and surroundings by a third medium, often a fluid; and (3) radiation, the emission and
absorption of rays traveling through space between system and surroundings. If the temperature is uniform within a system at a particular lime, then temperature is a property of the system and is state-related. A change in temperature of a body is reflected in the level of activity of the elemental particles that make up the body, sometimes termed the "particle kinetic energy" of the body. Appropriate, then, is the introduction of the concept of thermal energy, a form of internal energy dependent on the temperature of the body or system. Like other forms of energy, thermal energy is inherently a scalar, non-negative quantity. Its zero level might
be said to coincide with a system temperature of absolute zero, but because only changes in thermal-energy levels occur in process analyses, as with other forms of energy, a fixed reference level is unnecessary. Two types of internal energy now have been mentioned: strain and
thermal energies. Although individually they directly depend upon apparently separate, more fundamental properties, deformation and temperature, strain and thermal energies are not mutually exclusive. For example, the results of the tension tests of two specimens to fracture, initially identical in every characteristic except for a finite difference in the temperatures of the test environments, will generally yield significant differences in resilience and toughness. The lower the test-environ-
ment temperature, the more brittle the response of the specimen. Hence, although the strain and thermal forms of energy may be differentiated from each other, the more important consideration is their contribution to the total internal energy of the system under discussion. Existing experimental evidence suggests that the total internal energy of a body may depend upon other parameters besides deformation and
temperature, but only significant changes in the strain and thermal forms of internal energy occur in processes of orthodontic interest. The Conservation-of-Energy Law
A process occurs when an interaction between the system, defined for
study, and its surroundings takes place. Generally, but not always, a process results in a change of state of the system, usually reflected in an alteration in the total energy level of the system. The law of conservation
123
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
of energy says, in simple terms, that energy can neither be created nor
eliminated within the system. If, in a process, the total energy of the system increases, energy has been transferred from the surroundings into the system. If the total energy of the system decreases, an energy transfer to the surroundings from the system has taken place. If no net energy change of the system occurred during a process (but perhaps levels of individual forms of energy have changed), the net energy trans-
fer to or from the system is zero. Two forms of energy transfer have been defined: mechanical work of
the external forces exerted on the system and heat. Several types of energy, possessed by or contained within the system have been described: the two external forms of note are gravitational potential and kinetic energy and the two significant forms of internal energy are strain and thermal energy. In the general law to be stated, energy transfers are positive when proceeding from the surroundings to the system; energy changes of the system are positive when the final levels exceed the initial
levels. The work of the weight of the system equals the decrease in gravitational potential energy; one or the other, but not both, is included in the formulation. In orthodontic applications, changes in gravitational potential energy as well as electric and magnetic energy contributions rarely occur. With the foregoing definitions, terminology, assumptions, and sign conventions, a form of the law of conservation of energy, sufficiently general for orthodontic applications, may be narrated as follows: The mechanical work of external, contact forces and couples performed on the system plus the heat transfer into the system during a process equals
the increase in internal energy of the system during that process.
This "equation" is also known as the first law of thermodynamics. It is somewhat similar in form, but is actually independent of the law of kinetic energy in that the external work term may be eliminated between the two formulas, yielding an explicit expression for the work of the internal forces. A dimensional analysis of the first-law equation indicates that energy, energy transfer, and work are dimensionally identical. The dimension of work is the product of force and length, so the same is true for heat and energy change (although a variety of units are employed: pound-feet, newton-meters (joules), gram-millimeters, ounceinches, and British thermal units (Btus, for example). The law of conservation of energy is altered somewhat for application to orthodontic processes. First, changes in gravitational potential and kinetic energies may be reasonably neglected. Second, a third form of energy transfer may be defined, to be termed losses, energy escaping from or released by the system in an uncontrolled and usually undesired manner. Because the sense of losses is always from the system to the surroundings, with the sign convention previously assigned to energy transfers, losses are inherently negative quantities. With these alterations, the law of conservation of energy, modified for strict application to orthodontic processes, may be rewritten as follows:
124
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
The mechanical work of the external, contact forces on the system plus the
heat flow into the system minus the losses equals the net increase in the strain and thermal energies of the system.
A schematic of the orthodontic process law is given in Figure 4-7; therein SE, TE, and En represent strain, thermal, and total energy, respectively.
Available Energy A process generally begins with the system in total (mechanical, ther-
mal, and chemical) equilibrium. The final state as well is usually an equilibrium configuration. Any equilibrium state, however, may be constate (1)
En, = SE, + TE, System
WorkW
Losses L
Surroundings
Heat H
state (1)
Enf = SEf + TEf
FIGURE 4-7. A schematic depicting an orthodontically related process and the workenergy law that governs it.
125
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
strained such that, if released from its constraints, without any catalyst
an energy transfer to the surroundings occurs as the system proceeds toward a minimum-energy configuration. Orthodontic examples of these constraints are the maintenance of an elastic in a stretched state and an arch wire at an elevated temperature in a furnace. The available energy of a system is that portion of the internal energy that is released by removing all constraints and permitting the system to come to a completely passive equilibrium state. The total internal energy of a system may be expressed as the sum of its available and unavailable ("locked in") parts. The concept of available energy becomes more meaningful in the study of orthodontic processes within the following sections of this chapter.
Activation and Deactivation Processes When activating an orthodontic appliance, the practitioner applles exter-
nal force and does mechanical work on one or more elements of that appliance. Because negligible heat transfer occurs in such processes, this quantity of work equals the increase in internal energy; since little if any
change in temperature of the system takes place, the internal energy increase is reflected in the strain-energy form. The appliance is taken in the process from a passive state to a constrained, activated state. The visible evidence of the process and the added strain energy are the deformations of activation. The activation process occurs over a short time interval and negligible losses accompany it, but losses may occur over the relatively long time period to follow when the appliance is "working" on the dentition. If no losses, as defined previously, occur subsequent to activation, and the activation does not take the material(s) be-
yond their elastic limits anywhere in the appliance,
all
of the
strain-energy "input" is available to produce displacements of teeth or other movements within the dentofacial complex. As a first example, consider the activation of a linear, helical-coiled spring in compression. (This spring might be wound around an arch wire and positioned against the mesial extent of a canine bracket, for example; when activated the spring provides the distal driving force to do the work of retraction.) The design of the spring is such that, even when the compressive force pushes all of the coils into full contact with one another, the elastic limit of the spring-wire material is not exceeded. The laws of kinetic energy and conservation of energy say that the net contribution from the external and internal forces is zero and the work done by the external forces equals the increase in strain energy of the spring. The spring, compressed from the right end is shown in Figure 4-8; the initial configuration is drawn dashed, and the final, activated state is superimposed. The activated spring is "cut" to expose the internal force system and a free-body diagram of the right-hand portion is included in the figure. Note that the responsive force against the left end
126
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Responsive force
d,
"cut"
force
FIGURE 4-8. The process of compressing an open-coil, helical spring.
of the spring does no work because no displacement occurs there. The relationship between the external force that compresses the spring and the spring deformation is illustrated in Figure 4-9. The spring is termed "linear" when the plot of this relationship is a straight line. The force is seen to increase with the spring deformation and the work done to produce the 8-mm compression of the spring from its passive configuration is the cross-hatched area under the plot:
Work =
=
(160)8 = 640
g-mm
(4-3)
The process law indicates that, with negligible losses during activation, 640 g-mm of strain energy have been gained by the spring. Figure 4-9 shows the loading or activation plot of the linear spring. Because the elastic limit of the spring has not been exceeded, and if the spring was formed from a hard-metal alloy such as stainless steel, no losses of energy will occur over time as an activated configuration of the spring is maintained. As a result, the unloading or deactivation plot will trace the loading curve, indicating that all of the added strain energy of activation is available energy. A second process may now be analyzed in
which the spring is an energy source in the surroundings and under study is the system on which the spring will do work (e.g., a tooth). The
work capacity of the spring in this second process, during which the spring is deactivated to some extent, equals the 640 g-mm of strain energy added to it in the activation process.
127 Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
200
(0
E .2?
160
F1)
0) C-)
0
LI-
-o
0)
a-
a
120
80
40
0
0
2
4
6
8
10
Compressive Deformation (millimeters)
FIGURE 4-9. The force-deformation plot for the linear spring of Figure 4-8.
The analyses of the activation and deactivation processes for an "elastic" are similar to those just discussed for the spring, but notable differences exist in the response of the elastic. Figure 4-10 shows the
activation plot for an elastic band or module, fixed at one end and stretched by an external activating force at the other end. As with the spring, the process laws indicate the equality of magnitudes of work done by the external and internal forces and the increase in internal
P1)
0 0
as
1.0
1
a (inches)
Passive state
FIGURE 4-10. The activation ot an elastic module and the associated torce-elongation diagram.
As noted in Chapter 3, because of the generally amorphous nature of elastic materials, the initial portion of the force-deformation plot is often nonlinear. To simplify the computation of the area under the loading curve, a straight line is sketched that enables equal, partial areas to be cut above and below the actual plot. The obtained triangular area is the mechanical work of the activating, external force,
energy.
(18)1 =
9
oz-in.
(4-4)
and is also the strain energy added to the elastic in the short-term activation process that stretches it, in this example, 1 in. Although springs and activated arch wires may be expected to deactivate partially, if not totally, during between-appointments periods, the activated elastic module often maintains much of its initial stretch for a
substantial length of time. Because of the relatively weak, secondary bonding within certain amorphous materials, when maintained in a stretched configuration many of these materials lose tension over time. The force-versus-time plot for the example polymeric element under constant strain conditions is illustrated in Figure. 4-11. The phenomenon exhibited, defined in Chapter 3, is "relaxation"—loss of force with time and without deactivation. An energy-analysis schematic of this process is provided in Figure 4-12. Like the spring, the activation of the elastic module provides it with available energy to do work on another system; however, although the activating process should not take the material of the module beyond its elastic limit, the amount of available energy may decrease with time due
129
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
24
U,
0 C
=
0 a)
16
0 0
LL
8
0
0
12
6
18
24
30
36
Time (hours)
FIGURE 4-1 1. A relaxation plot characteristic of some polymeric materials.
to relaxation. In the relatively long-term deactivation process, it is gener-
ally impossible to quantitatively separate the energy transferred from the elastic module into external-work and loss portions. To illustrate the effect, however, consider maintaining (constant extensional strain) the activation depicted graphically in Figure 4-10 for several hours. Figure 4-13 shows the force-deformation relationship upon subsequent total unloading of the module. Note that this plot is also nonlinear and the force at the initiation of unloading is somewhat reduced, due to relaxation, from the level immediately following the activation process. Again,
the straight line is sketched in order to aid in the computation of the area: (13)1
= 6.5 oz-in. = strain energy released
(4-5)
The difference between the initially induced strain-energy increment and the strain energy released are the losses of relaxation and the energy no longer available to do work. In other words, the 6.5 oz-in. was the available energy in the elastic at the time of total deactivation. In general, the magnitude of such losses depends on the material of the elastic, the magnitude of the initial force relative to the geometry of the elastic,
and the length of time the activation is maintained. Because the oral environment is potentially more harmful to the polymeric materials of "elastic" elements than the normal air environment, intraoral "elastics"
130
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
20 oz 4
d
-
£0+lin. Initial state
I I 4
I Losses
/ to + 1
I
p
in.
—I
15 oz
Subsequent state
FIGURE 4-12. An energy-analysis schematic of the relaxation process.
should be expected to experience somewhat more dramatic relaxation
and, therefore, greater losses than "elastics" that activate extraoral appliances.
Consider now the process of activating an arch-wire segment in bending. As shown dashed in Figure 4-14, the segment, supported at its ends, is initially (passively) straight. The clinician applies an occlusogingival force between the supports to engage the segment in a bracket. As with the spring and elastic, the force during the process increases from
zero to a maximum value at the point of bracket engagement. Once more the process law says that the mechanical work of the external
alyses in Orthodontics
(e1, F2)
I
to
0.5
e (inches) 13.
The unloading diagram for the elastio module of Figure 4-10.
equals the increase in internal (strain) energy of the segider study. (It is assumed that no displacements occur at the s during short-term activation, so no work is done by the reForces
forces (Qi'
and couples (C1,
there.) The force-deforma-
t for an activation to a state or configuration below the elastic hown in Figure 4-15. Negligible losses occur during and follow'ation. Hence, the work done in this activation of the segment is as in the previous examples:
+ (2)1.5 = 1.5 oz-mm
(4-6)
oz-mm, also the strain energy added, is the energy available to during deactivation. In the orthodontic deactivation process, in system under study remains the wire segment, the possibility at, in addition to the desired tooth movement, one or both of the
s might be displaced. If so, in total deactivation, the desired
132
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Ge
P
C,
Ce
t: left r:
right
FIGURE 4-14. The activation of an arch-wire segment in bending.
energy transfer to the tooth would be less than the 1.5 oz-mm by the
amount of work done by the responsive forces in displacing the supports. (Similarly, in actual situations, the spring or elastic module could deactivate with both ends of the element undergoing movement.) If the tooth is somewhat farther out of alignment than was suggested in the foregoing discussion, the activation process could result in localized inelastic behavior of the segment. Point 1 on the loading curve in Figure 4-16 is the termination of the previous elastic activation; point 2 represents the final state of the present activation process. Once again using straight-line aids, dashed in the figure, the work done in activating the segment is quantified as the sum of three parts making up the total area under the plot:
+ (2)1.5 + 2(1) + + (1)1 = 4.0 oz-mm
(4-7)
The 4.0 oz-mm of work equals the strain energy input to the wire and, although no substantial losses as defined are expected if the wire material is relatively ductile (and the deformation at fracture is substantially in excess of 3 mm), the inelastic activation of the wire limits the energy available to do work. The deactivation process from point 2, depicting maximum movement of the tooth and assuming no work done at the supports of the wire segment, is shown as the solid line in Figure 4-17.
133
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
3 (I) Q)
0 C
0 0. ci)
0
0
U-
2
(1.5,2)
0 0
3
2
1
Deflection 8 (millimeters)
FIGURE 4-15. An elastic activation plot for the wire segment of Figure 4-14.
The cross-hatched area under the deactivation plot is
— (2.8)2.1 = 2.9 oz-mm 2
(4-8)
and is the energy available to do work on the tooth. The unavailable portion of the internal-energy input during activation is 4.0 — 2.9 = 1.1 oz-mm
(4-9)
7eering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
/
(2.5,3) 2
e/
1
2
3
Deflection
(millimeters)
4-16. Loading of the wire segment of Figure 4-14 such that the elastic limit has 'ceeded.
is T
been "locked in" the wire at the activation site. This unavailable
differs conceptually and actually from the losses sustained by the
due to relaxation; although both phenomena result, in effect, in a
of potentially available energy to do work, energy was transother than through external work, from the elastic, but not from re, between the end of the activation process and the conclusion ctivation. (Relaxation of metals generally occurs only when they
135
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
3 a) C)
0 aa)
U
0
U-
2
1.1 oz-mm
/
/
/
/
/
/
/ /
(2.5, 2.8)
/\
0
0
1
3
2
Deflection
(millimeters)
FIGURE 4-17. The deactivation of, and the available and unavailable energies for, the wire segment activated beyond its elastic limit.
have been strained almost to their fracture point or when they are main-
tained under load at substantially elevated temperatures.) Relaxation and inelastic action have been noted in this section as counterproductive toward maximizing the available energy of the activation process. Friction is a third phenomenon that "detours" a portion of the strain energy available to a deactivation process. Recalling the linear
spring analyzed earlier in this section, now consider a canine as the system with the linear spring activated against it at the initiation of a process. A free-body diagram of the tooth during the process is shown
136
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
F' Holding couple C d
m
Spring force P
Frictiona' force
Cpenodontrun
a
FIGuRE 4-18. A buccal-view, free-body diagram of a canine during its retraction into a first-promo/ar extraction site.
in Figure 4-18. Ideally in the process no localized deformations should occur and, therefore, no change in the internal energy level of the tooth. In the absence of friction and tipping, the process law would say that the work done by the spring force (equal, in total deactivation, to the strain energy added in activating the spring) plus the work done by the periodontal force (sense of force to the right, sense of displacement to the left: negative work) equals zero. Considering bodily movement wherein no work is done against the couples, a portion of the energy transferred from the compressed spring during the displacement will be carried into the stationary arch wire by friction. If the displacement is indeed bodily movement, the division of available energy in the spring between the periodontium and the arch wire is in the same ratio as the periodontal and frictional forces, inasmuch as a mesiodistal force balance must exist throughout the process and the displacements of the particles, on which the three forces act, are all identical excepting locations. If tipping occurs, negative work is done
137
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
by the couples which further lessens the desired energy transfer from
the tooth to the periodontium. In this example, typical of processes in the presence of unwanted friction, considering the arch wire as the system under study for the moment, the energy transferred into the wire by the work of the frictional force is initially reflected in an increase in the thermal form of internal energy. If the arch wire is stationary (the frictional force having done work during the displacement of the bracket with respect to the wire), with the momentary, localized increase in wire temperature, all of that energy increment will be transferred immediately into the surroundings with an accompanying return of the wire to the ambient temperature. Hence, in such instances, in a very real sense, energy transfer in the form of the work of friction is a loss.
Strain Hardening and Heat Treatment of Metals and Alloys Mentioned earlier was the existence of a relationship between the level
of internal energy, with the system under study in an unconstrained state, and the mechanical properties of the materials of the system, the metals and alloys in particular. In addition, discussed previously was a sequence of processes in which energy was transferred into a material followed by restoration of the initial equilibrium state with its surround-
ings; the processes as a whole resulted in a net change in the level of internal energy because of inelasticity during loading. Apparent, then, is the ability to design processes which have as their objective to alter the internal-energy level and, thereby, change the mechanical properties of
the system materials. Also indicated in prior discussion was an upper limit to the internal-energy capacity, per unit volume, of a material; failure hypotheses known as the maximum-strain and maximum-internalenergy theories are often employed by practicing engineers in designing load-carrying members and structures. High levels of internal energy, principally in the form of strain energy, are accompanied by residual or "locked in" stresses. Superposition of loading on such stress states may lead to unexpected fractures; hence, a process, which will at least partially release residual stresses, may be carried out to advantage prior to the application of the load. Although the level of internal energy cannot be readily quantified, good indicators of high levels are substantial hardness and lack of ductility. Two categories of processes, carried out on metals or alloys before in-service use, alter the unconstrained-state internal energy in the material. Strain hardening is a process in which energy in the form of mechani-
cal work is transferred into the material, taking the material beyond its elastic limit. When strained elastically, the interatomic bonds are only stretched; upon release of the straining action, the deformation disappears. The loading of a material to a state beyond its elastic limit causes the breaking of interatomic bonds and the establishment of new bonds; permanent, relative displacements between grains occur in crystalline
138
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
materials with the result, upon unloading, of an altered external shape
and, generally, a different stored-energy level compared to that of the originally passive state. The strain-hardening process is undertaken toward an increase in internal energy; however, the process can, particularly in a high-temperature environment, result in a reduction in internal energy. When undertaken at normal room temperature or below, the process is called cold working. Strain hardening may be carried out at an elevated temperature to enhance the interaction between the strain and thermal forms of internal energy; this process is known as hot working. The strain-hardening process, when initiated from a relatively low internal-energy state with a moderate energy transfer, results in increases in the elastic strength and range, the resilience, and, perhaps, the ultimate strength; however, the process reduces the ductility. Because for each material an upper bound
exists to the amount of internal energy per unit volume it can retain without undergoing drastic structural change (including, perhaps, fracture), the degree to which the material can be cold- or hot-worked is limited. In general, when the point of maximum strain-energy capacity is approached, control of the process is lost and, subsequently, a sizable (and, perhaps, explosive) energy loss occurs accompanying fracture. Heat treatment is the general name given to those processes in which the catalyst toward changing the internal-energy level in the metallic material is the transfer of energy into the system entirely in the form of heat. The process is carried out in three steps:
1. The system temperature is elevated by placing it in a high-temperature environment (e.g., a furnace or a hot salt bath) or by electricresistance/induction heating; heat transfer is through convection in using the furnace or bath and by conduction with electrical procedures.
2. Upon reaching the desired temperature, the system is maintained there for a specific period of time. Because no losses are occurring with the system at the temperature of the furnace or bath, while energy is continually flowing into the surroundings with the direct electrical methods, the potential for temperature control is greater with the system enveloped in the high-temperature environment. 3. The system is returned to its initial-state temperature. Although the lime taken to elevate the temperature is not particularly critical, the step-3 time is if an objective of the heat treatment is a specific alteration of the atomic arrangement within the material. Note that sol-
dering and welding procedures also use heat to initiate processes. Although not discussed in detail in this text, a by-product of either process may be a heat treatment. Accordingly, these procedures must be carried out carefully with the realization of the potential effects upon localized internal-energy levels and mechanical properties. The difference between strain-hardening and heat-treatment processes is clear with regard to the forms of energy transfer initiating these
139
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
Losses (uncontrolled energy transfers from the system) are substantial in heat-treatment processes; losses are generally negligible with cold working as long as the energy input does not result in fracture. Ariother distinction between the process categories is in the internalenergy change achieved: typically an increase from strain hardening, but heat treatment may result in either raising or lowering the internalenergy level. Energy schematics showing strain-hardening and heattreatment processes are presented in Figure 4-19. Three types of heat-treatment processes should be familiar to the orthodontist. Following the placement of bends and/or twists in an arch wire, a cold-working procedure, a stress-relief heat treatment may be desirable, particularly if the bends are sharp and when complex loops have been fabricated. The purpose of a stress-relief heat treatment is the release of at least a portion of the residual stresses "locked in" the material, and recovery of some of the ductility lost through strain hardening. processes.
Depending on the material, the dimensions of the member, and the degree of strain hardening, the stress relief may also raise or lower the elastic limit and resilience and/or the ultimate strength. Step 2 in the stress-relief process in a furnace of stainless-steel orthodontic wire is generally carried out at 700 to 900°F for 3 to 5 mm; the time necessary at lower temperatures is excessive, from a practical standpoint, and higher temperatures will likely produce carbide precipitation and loss of corrosion resistance. An annealing heat treatment is carried out at a temperature substan1
Initial state
Work W
Heat
H
Losses L Strain Hardening
> En1
Heat Treatment
Enf
En,
FIGURE 4-19. Energy-analysis schematics of general strain-hardening (left) and heattreatment processes (right).
140
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
tially above that to stress-relieve. The temperature and resulting particle kinetic energy are high enough to dissolve at least a portion of the inter-
nal bonding and permit atomic reorganization. An anneal produces a substantial loss of internal energy and an accompanying reduction of all strength properties and resilience if the material was previously strain hardened. The process also increases ductility, making the material more malleable. The annealing of stainless-steel orthodontic wire requires only a few minutes at temperatures of 1800 to 2000°F. The mate-
rial is fully softened and any carbides are brought into solution. The cooling (third) step in the process is carried out rapidly by quenching in water or oil to prevent reformation of chromium carbides. The time at temperature is generally kept short to minimize the potential for grain growth and, therefore, maximize ductility and corrosion resistance. A hardening heat treatment is usually a long-term process with a step-
2 time of several hours, carried out at a temperature somewhat below that necessary to anneal and with the material often cooled rapidly by quenching. Hardening generally will improve strength properties, particularly with respect to their levels as annealed. Although the particular stainless steels from which orthodontic wire is manufactured will not take a hardening heat treatment, the strength and resilience of gold and chrome-cobalt-alloy wires are raised upon hardening (but at the "expense" of some reduction in ductility). With the effects on properties of strain hardening and heat treatments now outlined, an overview of the processes employed in the manufacture of orthodontic stainless-steel wire may now be undertaken. Initially a relatively large ingot of the material is heated to a temperature near that necessary to anneal, in order to facilitate the working operations to follow. At the elevated temperature the material is "hot rolled" (hot worked), which results in a reduction in cross-section and corresponding lengthening of the member. Now the ingot has been transformed into a straight bar having a round cross-section. To reduce the bar to the final cross-sectional size and shape, the bar is drawn through a series of dies. Each successive drawing is a strain-hardening process that decreases the ductility of the bar. Accordingly, heat treatments must be interspersed between drawings to keep the internal-energy level from becoming excessive. The formation of rectangular wire is accomplished either by drawing the initially round bar through a succession of dies that gradually change the cross-section from circular to rectangular or by performing a rolling operation on the round wire follow-
ing the drawing processes. At some point in the overall wire-formation procedure an annealing heat treatment must take place to ensure that the wire, as received by the practitioner, has the metallurgical format characterized by the carbon atoms in solid solution. The anneal should occur as near to the end of manufacturing operations as permissible, given the strength and resilience requirements of the final product. All of the orthodontic stainless-steel wires currently marketed contain the same principal constituents and virtually identical percentages of iron, chromium, nickel, and
141
Energy Malyses in Orthodontics
carbon. High- and moderate-resilience wires, and "standard" wires pos-
sess different strength, resilience, and ductility characteristics, notable in the hands of the clinician, because production detailing varies somewhat among wire manufacturers and according to desired mechanical properties. The as-received, high-resilience wires exhibit more strain hardening and, therefore, a higher internal-energy level; ligature wire, having a low elastic limit and substantial ductility, is fully annealed as received. With the marketing of the "beta titanium" (titanium-molybdenum alloy) wire, practitioners now have their choice among five arch-wire materials. Each material has specific time and temperature formulations for the different heat-treatment processes, and wires of the same material are often available with several different internal-energy levels. Accordingly, clinicians must be attentive to the vendor's instructional literature when placing permanent bends or twists or when considering or undertaking soldering, welding, or heat-treatment processes.
Work-Energy Analysis of the Preparation of an Arch Wire Orthodontists must be aware of the possibility of a wire fracturing in the
mouth during a between-appointments period. Care must be taken not to induce excessive force or energy into a wire during fabrication and activation. Mastication may load the appliance beyond that of activation and add to the internal energy present in the engaged wire. Because the amount of internal energy in a passive wire, even prior to bend or twist placements, cannot be quantified and may be substantial, the danger of raising the internal-energy level excessively is more subtle than that of overloading the wire with respect to force magnitude. Consider the preparation of an arch from a straight segment of asreceived, stainless-steel wire. The experienced clinician can, by the "feel" of the wire, gauge its relative stiffness in bending, but the level of ductility and the toughness cannot readily be estimated except from specifications often known only by the wire manufacturer. The wire segment is cut to an appropriate initial length and the arch form and offset bends are placed. The amount of additional internal energy localized at any cross-section is related directly to the size of the permanent deformation placed there. The strain energy induced in preparation of the overall arch form is distributed primarily over that which will be the anterior portion of the wire; the stored-energy increment per unit volume is nominal. The localized increases in internal energy will be greater at the sites of the offset bends. If, for example, this arch wire is to provide guidance and, with the buccal segments, anchorage for intraoral canine-retraction mechanics, second-order bends are placed including tip-back bends at the terminal molars; toe-in bends are also placed at the molar sites. Substantial amounts of additional internal, strain energy are induced
142
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
at the locations of the permanent bends, particularly just mesial to the buccal tubes where the lip-back and toe-in bends are superimposed on one another. Moreover, wire engagement likely activates the bends, and the work of the clinician in placing the appliance inputs additional strain energy at the molar sites. At no other cross-sections do both permanent deformations and induced orthodontic loading exist in this example, if fracture would occur, the most likely location is one of the "critical" cross-sections just mesial to a terminal molar. If the wire is ductile and possesses substantial toughness as received, there need be little fear of fracture subsequent to a moderate amount of inelastic bending followed by activation. The more highly resilient wires are generally more brittle, however, and the clinician may wish to increase the "effective toughness" of the wire as a safety measure before placement and activation of the appliance. This may be accomplished without the loss of resilience only through a stress-relief heat treatment, and only if the process is conducted properly so as to result in a net decrease in the internal energy of the passive wire (in particular, localized energy decreases at the critical cross-sections). Figures 4-20 and 4-21 depict the effects of bend placements, of activation, and the internal-energy capacities for a pair of otherwise identical
stainless-steel wires, without and with a stress-relief heat treatment prior to activation. The figures indicate conditions at the critical crosssections for the example under discussion. In Figure 4-20 curves 1 and 2
a)
0 0
U-
0
Deformation
FIGURE 4-20. The force-deformation diagram for an example arch wire, activated in bending tollowing permanent-bend placement.
143
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
a) C)
L2
0
HT
Deforniatton
FIGURE 4-21. The force-deformation diagram for an arch wire, activated in bending subsequent to permanent-bend placement and a stress-relief heat treatment
represent the loading and unloading of the wire during the placement of
the tip-back and toe-in bends; note the permanent set and the new positions of the elastic limit following bend placements. Curve 3, coincident with part of curve 2, illustrates an elastic activation process as the wire is
engaged in the brackets and buccal tubes. The triangular area under curve 3 represents the available strain energy of activation of the wire at the molar, revised through bend placements (strain hardening) from its as-received value. Curve 4 (dashed) is the remaining portion of the plot to fracture and the cross-hatched area represents the internal energy per unit volume that may be added to the as-activated level before fracture will occur. Mastication, which causes superposition of loading increments upon the activated state, would make the dot in the figure move along curve 4 and, perhaps, take the wire material at the critical section beyond the "new" elastic limit. The cyclic loading and unloading pattern of mastication may result in fatigue of the wire (defined in Chapter 3), which will effectively reduce the toughness, even when the elastic limit is not exceeded. As in Figure 4-20, curves 1 and 2 of Figure 4-21 indicate the place-
ment of permanent bends in the wire at the molars. To free at least a portion of the "locked in" (residual) stresses at the critical cross-sections,
144
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
stress-relief heat treatment is undertaken. This process has little effect on the as-bent geometry and no mechanical work is involved, so it may a
be represented simply as the dot marked "HT" on the plot of Figure 4-21. With some ductility remaining in the passive wire following bend placement, the stress relief results in a further raising of the elastic limit
and an accompanying increase in the resilience (beyond the levels achieved through bend placement only). Curve 3, here as in Figure 4-20,
represents the engagement of wire in the buccal tubes and brackets, activating the tip-back and toe-in bends. Because the heat treatment also
raises the ultimate strength of the wire with negligible effect on the deformation to fracture, both the maximum tolerable load and the internal-energy capacity are increased. As in Figure 4-20, curve 4 (dashed) and the cross-hatched area of Figure 4-21 are the remainder of the potential loading curve to fracture and the revised toughness, respectively. With identical bend placements in and activating deformations of the two wires, the gains in both load and additional internal-energy capacilies attributable to the stress-relief heat treatment are apparent from a visual comparison of the two figures.
Synopsis first four chapters contain the concepts of mechanics and materials science needed by the clinician to embark on an intensive, but not exceedingly complex, study of the orthodontic appliance in the manner of a structural bioengineer. To complement the use of Newtonian mechanics in appliance analysis and design, in this chapter the approach of work and energy has been discussed toward examining the mechanical and thermodynamic behavior of the appliance elements over a finite time interval. The concepts of mechanical work, heat transfer, external and internal energies, and system with its surroundings were introduced, followed by the statements of the law of kinetic energy and the principle of conservation of energy. Examples of orthodontic processes discussed were the activation and deactivation of a coiled spring, an elastic module, and an arch-wire segment. Strain hardening and heat treatments have been considered with emphasis on their applications to orthodontics. Prior to the pursuit of direct analyses of orthodontic-appliance members and assemblies, an examination of the kinematics and kinetics of tooth movement is undertaken in the upcoming chapter. Also appropriate is a discussion of the interface of the physiology and the mechanics, and the response of the periodontium and the dentofacial complex at large to the application of force. These and related topics are the subject of Chapter 5 and, with the tools of analytical mechanics, complete the basis from which a bioengineering study of orthodontic therapy and appliances may be approached.
These
145
Energy Analyses in Orthodontics
Suggested Readings Allegheny Ludlum Steel Corporation: Stainless Steel Handbook. Pittsburgh, Al-
legheny Ludlum Steel, 1959. Beer, F.P., and Johnston, E.R.: Vector Mechanics for Engineers-Statics. 3rd Ed. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1977, Chapter 10. Fillmore, G.M., and Tomlinson, J.L.: Heat treatment of cobalt-chromium alloys
of various tempers. Angle Orthod., 49:126—130, 1979.
Fillmore, G.M., and Tomlinson, J.L.: Heat treatment of cobalt-chromium alloy wire. Angle Orthod., 46:187—195, 1976.
Greener, E.H., Harcourt, J.K., and Lautenschlager, E.P.: Materials Science in Dentistry. Baltimore, Williams & Wilkins, 1972, Chapter 7. Hayden, H.W., Moffatt, W.G., and Wulff, J.: The Structure and Properties of Materials. Vol. III. New York, John Wiley & Sons, 1965, Chapter 8.
Howe, G.L., Greener, E.H., and Crimmins, P.S.: Mechanical properties and stress relief of stainless steel orthodontic wire. Angle Orthod., 38:244—249, 1968.
Kohl, R.W.: Metallurgy in orthodontics. Angle Orthod., 24:37—52, 1964.
Marcotte, M.R.: Optimum time and temperature for stress relief heat treatment of stainless steel wire. J. Dent. Res., 52:1171—1175, 1973. McLean, W.G., and Nelson, E.W.: Engineering Mechanics, New York, Schaum Publishing, 1962, Chapter 18. Phillips, R.W.: Skinner's Science of Dental Materials. 7th Ed. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders, 1973, Chapters 16 and 34.
Thurow, R.C.: Edgewise Orthodontics. 4th Ed. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1982, Chapters 1, 7, and 8. Zemansky, M.W., and Van Ness, H.D.: Basic Engineering Thermodynamics. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1966, Chapters 3 and 4.
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
activation of an appliance by the orthodontist creates a complex system of forces that is transmitted generally through the dentition and into the dentofacial complex at large. The system of forces is developed initially within the appliance due to the mechanical work of activation in which one or more appliance members are deformed from the passive configuration. The force system is carried throughout the appliance, The
transmitted from one member to another through their interconnections, and to individual tooth crowns. Force systems delivered to crowns are carried longitudinally through each tooth and are transmitted by the roots to and through the periodontal ligament into alveolar bone and to the maxilla or mandible and beyond. The alveolar process and the bones of the face respond to several categories of force. Physiologic forces exist continuously, but perhaps are most prominent during the eruption of teeth. Functional forces of mastication and deglutition periodically produce force against the dentition, as may the tongue and lips. Orthodontic forces are exerted through me-
chanical connections of activated appliance members to the tooth crowns and induce movements of individual teeth or segments. Forces delivered to the dentofacial complex that result in movements of the maxilla or mandible, or relative displacements of portions of these hard tissues (e.g., palate splitting), are generally termed orthopedic. An individual tooth receives crown force principally from the connection of arch wire to orthodontic bracket. Through incorporation of stops, loops, ligation, and use of round and rectangular wire, forces and couples may be transmitted in faciolingual, mesiodistal, and occlusogingival directions between arch wire crown through the "universal" bracket. Moreover, contact forces may reach the crown through other
than the bracket connections. Eyelets, staples, or buttons may be welded to the orthodontic band or bonded directly to the crown surface where desired and space permits, and appliance members (e.g., elastics, 146
147
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
ligatures) activated against them. Adjacent teeth within the same arch
may push against one another through direct crown contact; they also may "pull" on each other, interconnected through the transseptal-fiber system. Finally, teeth in the opposing arches may exert force upon one another through occlusal surface contact. The individual tooth is highly resistant to localized deformation and is positioned in a flexible supporting structure. The application of crown force displaces the tooth as a whole. The support response to short-term forces, such as those of mastication, is essentially elastic. Tooth displacements arising from forces existing over extended periods of time—orthodontic forces, for example—must b97'
analyzed in two parts: the initial displacement associated with the in* mediate response of the nonrigid alveolar process and the displacement occurring with the biologic remodeling of the tissues. The deformation of the periodontal ligament, accompanying initial tooth displacement, produces a responsive force system against the root. This system is the action-reaction counterpart of that delivered by the root to the ligament, and arises due to the resistance to deformation inherent in the ligament and the bone behind it. Because the stiffness of the ligament itself is relatively low, the deformation of it occurs through-
out the entire contact area between ligament and root; hence, the mechanical response to tooth displacement is a force system that is distributed over virtually the entire root-surface area. Initially, that response may reflect highly varying intensity from one location to another over the root-ligament interface; if the applied force remains for a period of time, remodeling of the alveolar process will alter that intensity pattern toward a more uniform distribution. The ligament is less than 0.5 mm in thickness everywhere, its weight and inertia are negligible, and the alveolar bone-ligament and root-ligament interface areas are virtually equal. Accordingly, the force distributions transmitted from root to ligament and from ligament to bone are nearly identical in all characteristics. Al-
though mature bone is much stiffer than the periodontal ligament, forces against the bone can result in slight deformations, particularly from pressure against the facial or lingual alveolar crestal regions. Upon
reaching the alveolar bone, ligament force against it resulting from crown loading travels into and through the cortical plate and into the bone proper. This force does not disappear; instead, it is distributed farther throughout the bone volume, decreasing in intensity with distance inward from the bone-ligament interface as the effective area of distribution grows. Several reasonable idealizations are proposed at the outset in this bioengineering analysis. The tooth is assumed to be a rigid body; it is displaced, but not deformed, under the action of crown loading and the accompanying response from the periodontium. The weight of the tooth is small compared to the contact forces that may be exerted on it; the weight of each tooth, as well as that of the periodontal ligament, may be neglected. Furthermore, even in the short period of initial displacement following creation of crown force, the inertias of all components of the
148
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
structural and biologic systems are never of significant magnitude to
warrant inclusion in the analysis. In structurally characterizing the penodontium, its response to loading is time-dependent and its biomatenial components must be separated due to differences in mechanical properties. As mentioned previously, the overall stiffness of the periodontal ligament is low compared to that of bone, and although the response mechanisms are different from one another, the stiffnesses of the periodontal ligament in tension and compression generally will be assumed equal in the light of present knowledge. The comparable stiffnesses of alveolar bone are at least one order of magnitude higher than those of
the ligament and the greater hardness and stiffnesses of the cortical plate compared to the spongy bone beneath it may be a factor in portions of the analysis. Mechanical strengths of the teeth and periodontal components need not be of concern; inherent (anatomic) controls against structural failures exist in response to most forms of possible crown loading. In general, replacing strength criteria in ordinary structural (engineering) analyses are pathologic considerations in the study of the periodontium and its influence on the appropriate characteristics of induced forces and the design of appliances.
The total analysis or design problem associated with orthodontic therapy is in two distinct and interesting parts. The "engineering" of appliances will be discussed in subsequent chapters. The biomechanics of the living system to which those appliances are attached is the subject of this chapter.
Mechanical Response of the Individual Tooth to Applied Force Under the action of an applied force system the single tooth experiences
a whole-body displacement due to the nonrigid nature of its supporting structure. To adequately describe such a displacement, a reference frame is established with respect to the initial position and normal orientation of the aligned tooth. This framework includes three mutually perpendicular axes. One axis is coincident with the long axis of the aligned tooth, the second is directed faciolingually and passes through the center of the proper bracket location, and the third is oriented mesiodistally. The cen-
ter of the framework, the point common to all three axes, is located approximately at the center of the crown and is labeled point CC. This reference system, described previously in Chapter 1, is shown within a typical tooth in Figure 5-1. Another useful reference point is the center of resistance of the tooth; the long axis passes through it and the point is designated the cre. Four additional reference points will be introduced subsequently; however, because the tooth is a rigid body, the displacements of these four points and the cre may be readily obtained from the absolute displacement of the long axis, a line perpendicular to the long axis through CC, and point CC itself. (Recall the two-dimensional displacement example in Chapter 1 and the associated Figure 1-5.)
149
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
a
e
a
f
d
m
0
FIGuRE 5-1. A localized reference frame fixed within the tooth and having its origin at the crown-center point CC.
Defined in Chapter 2 were three general forms of rigid-body displacement: pure translation from an active force system mechanically equivalent to a single force with its line of action passing through the center of resistance; pure rotation from an active force system having a single couple as its resultant; and a combination of translation and pure
rotation termed generalized rotation resulting from action equivalent to a force and couple referenced to the center of resistance. Orthodontic displacements as defined have clinical origins, but each may be categorized
under one of the three general forms just mentioned. Although multiple-rooted teeth do not possess the near-axial symmetry of the singlerooted teeth, no special differentiation in overall displacement designations is necessary; point-wise descriptions of root-apex movements, however, may be different for specific, whole-body displacements. The partitioning of the response to crown loading into immediate and longterm components was previously mentioned; nevertheless, a description of displacement ordinarily defines the position and orientation of the tooth, at a specified instant of time after loading, referenced to the preload configuration. The description of an orthodontic (individual-tooth) displacement is often a complex undertaking because the load is principally applied away from the long axis and through the bracket. For this reason, the displacement is decomposed into what is seen individually in the occlusal plane and in two mutually perpendicular vertical planes. Three forms of orthodontic translation are recognized: extrusion, intrusion, and bodily movement. The first two may be viewed from a vertical or transverse perspective, but ordinarily they are not discernible in an occlusal view because particle displacement vectors are parallel to the passive,
150
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
long-axis orientation. In bodily movement, particle displacement vectors
are generally parallel to the occlusal plane or perpendicular to the reference, long-axis angulation. Rotational movements, whether they are "pure" or "generalized," are typically described in terms of the initial and displaced orientations of the faciolingual axis or long axis and the intersection of the axis positions in the sequential configurations: the center of rotation. The two positions of the reference axis define a plane; the center of rotation is in
that plane and is often labeled cr0, and the rotation is about an axis perpendicular to the plane and pierces the cro. These reference lines and the cro are exemplified for a "transverse rotation" in Figure 5-2; note that
the cro may be located within or outside of the confines of the tooth itself. Transverse rotations are those tooth displacements during which the long-axis orientation (angulation) changes. During pure long-axis rotation, the angulation of the long axis is not altered. Transverse rotations
are known to the clinician as "tipping" or "torquing" displacements, depending on whether the center of rotation is apical or occlusal of the center of resistance. Simple tipping is a transverse rotational displacement produced by a single active force directed along the faciolingual or mesi-
odistal axis through point CC. Transverse rotations are called crown movements when the center of rotation is at or near the root apex and root movements when the cro is located within the crown, more specifically between bracket level and the occlusal surface (or incisal edge). During orthodontic therapy, the force system exerted on the crown is transmitted from the activated appliance, primarily through the bracket. The connections of arch wire, "elastics," and auxiliaries to brackets carry a force system to the crown having the general resultant consisting of a concentrated force and a couple. Individually, the force and couple vectors may have any direction; for analysis purposes each vector is decomposed into components in the occlusogingival, faciolingual, and mesio-
crc
cro
/ FIGURE 5-2. Several transverse rotations viewed from a facial perspective and, in each sketch, showing the location of the center of rotation, cro.
151
Response of Dentition and Periodontiurn to Force
distal directions. As previously mentioned, the crown may also be
subjected to additional forces during the period of activation; included
are mesiodistal contact from an adjacent tooth, force transmitted through an eyelet, staple, or button, the force of occlusion, and transseptal-fiber pull. With the exception of the fiber force, which is exerted at approximately the cementoenamel-j unction level, the applied force system is generally located at the occlusogingival position of point CC on the long axis, and any movement of the line of action of a force (to the cre, for example), requires the addition of a couple according to the pro-
cedure outlined in Chapter 2. To describe the responsive force system exerted on a tooth by the periodontal ligament surrounding the root, the composition of the ligament must be examined. Completely enveloping the root from cementoenamel junction to apex (apices), the ligament is a composite of fibers, cells, nerves, and blood vessels embedded in a soft-tissue matrix often termed the "ground substance." From a structural standpoint, two components, in essence, respond to crown loading: the fibers (in bundles) in tension and, in compression, principally the ground substance. The apparent shear resistance of the ligament is generated through redirection of the fibers from their primarily radial configurations with respect to the long axis. Accordingly, the response of the individual ligament is generally a distribution of tensile, compressive, and shear forces over the entire root-surface area while the action on the crown is a system of concentrated forces. The initial intensity of ligament force against a point of the root, produced by appliance activation, varies directly as the displacement of that point from the passive, preactivation state. In analyses of bodily movement and transverse rotations, a twodimensional model is used; for the other orthodontic displacements, two-dimensional modeling is unnecessary, but advantage is taken of the near-axial symmetry of the single-rooted tooth. Certain potential errors are recognized in the modeling of the distributed force transfer at the root-ligament interface. First, a limit exists to the amount of compressive ligament deformation; upon reaching this limit, the stiffness of the ped-
odontium increases substantially. Second, although most fibers are embedded in bone, some terminate in free gingiva; the latter result in a more flexible support structure occlusal to the alveolar crest than apical to it. Third, the remodeling of alveolar bone results in a redistribution of the responsive ligament force; hence, the distributed force changes, not only in resultant magnitude with gradual deactivation, but also in pattern with the long-term, biologic remodeling of the periodontium. The significance of each of these three modeling faults will be noted as they arise within discussions in the sections to follow.
Transverse Crown Force Systems and Tooth Displacements Attention is now restricted to the force-displacement analysis of a single tooth subjected to an active force system that is equivalent to a force and
152
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
couple at point CC; the vector representations of this action have no
occlusogingival components. Therefore, excluded from the discussion of this section are extrusion, intrusion, and long-axis rotation. Moreover, the active resultant at point CC and the problem itself may be decom-
posed, when necessary, into two plane-view (occlusogingival and faciolingual) analyses. Finally, changes in long-axis orientation are generally sufficiently small that the convenient configuration for instantaneous analysis can be the tooth position immediately following activation, and changes in angles between forces and the long axis, and in moment arms, with respect to the passive (preactivation) state, ordinarily, may reasonably be neglected. The orthodontic displacement defined as bodily movement is examined first to enable the introduction of terminology and procedures that will be used throughout this section. The resultant of the crown force system to achieve this translational displacement is mechanically equivalent to a single point force having a line of action passing through the center of resistance; hence, at point CC the equivalent active system is a force and
a related couple. Two typical sets of orthodontic mechanics that may seek to produce bodily movement are canine retraction, with the displacement directed distally, and incisal-segment retraction with the displacement directed lingually. If the active force system is transmitted to the crown at a bracket on the facial surface, the position of the line of action of the "driving force" may or may not be such as to exhibit a tendency only for a transverse displacement. In anterior-retraction mechanics, the line of action of the driving force, with correct positioning of the bracket, passes through the long axis, and therefore, this force has no moment about the long axis (and no potential to cause long-axis rotation). On the other hand, the driving force in canine retraction, when transmitted to the crown by a labial or lingual bracket, does have a moment arm with respect to the long axis of slightly more than one-half the faciolingual crown width: an accompa-
nying tendency for rotation about the long axis is thus exhibited. The two actions are shown in Figure 5-3, and throughout this section the existence of an occlusal-plane couple is assumed, when necessary, to eliminate long-axis rotational potential effectively from any analysis and permit plane-view study. (This couple counters the long-axis moment of the driving force. The effects of the eccentricity of the bracket with re-
spect to the long axis are discussed in Chapter 6.) Shown on the left in Figure 5-4 is the two-dimensional model of transverse crown loading referred to point CC; the plane view contains the long axis and either the faciolingual or the mesiodistal axis of the localized reference frame established previously. To "move" the loading apically the distance d to the center of resistance, a couple must be introduced that compensates for the change in rotational potential associated with the change in the line of action of F. This compensating couple C', with F now located at the cre, and the couple C from the original loading,
are shown in the center sketch of Figure 5-4; because the force F was moved a distance d perpendicular to its direction, the magnitude of C' is
153
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
Ffe
Fmd
FIGURE 5-3. Transverse crown forces applied faciolingually (left) and mesiodistally (right) through the bracket. (When the line of action does not pierce the long axis, the transverse force must be accompanied by an occlusal-plane couple of appropriate magnitude if long-axis rotation is to be prevented.)
the product of F and d. The couple C, having a whole-body, rotational-
displacement potential independent of its location on the tooth, now may simply be placed at the cre and, in order to yield a force-only resultant there, must be identical to C' in all characteristics except sense. Finally, on the right in Figure 5-4 is shown in most simple form the active force system referenced to the cre. Established completely, then, is the
in-plane relationship between the force and couple portions of the resultant action at point CC; for bodily movement the cou pie-force ratio must equal the CC-to-cre distance d, measured along the long axis (more
specifically, perpendicular to the lines of action of the applied force through CC and the cre). In general, the applied force system is first combined into a resultant at point CC to obtain the couple-force ratio, and that resultant is then transferred to the cre to obtain at least a qualitative picture of the tooth displacement to be anticipated from the given loading. The actual location of the center of resistance, generally dependent upon the size and
LI
C'Fd
F
(C = Fd)
FIGURE 5-4. The crown loading in bodily movement: the force and couple at point CC (left); the force moved to the cre with the compensating couple introduced (center); and the force system at the ore reduced to the single-force resultant (right).
154
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
and the manner of support of the body, must be obtained for the tooth by varying, in an experimental format, the couple-force ratio and, for each value, determining the displacement pattern of points on the root surface. Such studies have been carried out using both theoretical modeling (Nikolai, 1974) and laboratory experimentation (Burstone et al., 1982); the cre has been located close to midway between cementoenamel junction and root apex, making d approximately equal to one-half the total tooth length (if the bracket is positioned at midcrown, occlusoshape
gingivally).
Although a substantial simplification, discussion of the distributed responsive force system resulting from transverse crown loading within a two-dimensional model does encompass the essence of that response and, in particular, clearly differentiates among the individual forms of
associated, orthodontic displacements. Neglecting the inertia of the tooth, the resultant of the periodontal-ligament response to deformation by the root, referenced to the cre, must be equal and opposite to the equivalent crown loading at the point. For bodily movement that response is a single force F' as shown on the left in Figure 5-5, identical in all characteristics to the driving force F in Figure 5-4 except sense. Because the tooth experiences no change in angulation in this displacement, F' may be expressed as the sum of a tensile component F exerted on the trailing surface (in the plane view appearing as a curve) and a compressive component against the leading surface as shown in the center sketch of Figure 5-5. If the two halves of the total root surface as divided were identical reflections of one another, and the stiffnesses of the ligament were equal in tension and compression, the two compo-
nents would be equal and, herein, are modeled as such. (The slight angulations of the root surfaces and the deviations of some fiber directions from the normal with respect to the long axis are reasonably neglected in the modeling.) A sketch of the in-plane distributed force of the ligament upon the root is shown on the right in Figure 5-5. Although in bodily movement the displacements of all tooth points are identical, the tensile and compressive distributions are shown nonuniform to properly recognize the
F'
5-5. The plane view of the responsive force of the ligament against the root during bodily movement: the resultant force at the cre (left); the tensile and compressive components (center); and the modeled tensile and compressive distributed forces FIGURE
(right).
155
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
tapering of the root. Accordingly, the intensities are highest at the apex
where the root circumference is smallest and lowest where the root circumference is maximum at the cementoenamel junction. The difference in tensile stiffnesses of intra-alveolar and extra-alveolar fiber bundles is ignored as modeled here, based on the relatively small portion of the total root area in which the latter fibers are embedded. (The twodimensional modeling of the stress distribution, and use of the projected root areas, are tantamount to replacing the approximately round or oval root cross-section of the single-rooted tooth by a square or rectangular cross-section. Shown in Figure 5-6 are the as-modeled and typical, anatomically correct, root "slices" and the distributed force systems exerted on each periphery.) From the discussion of stress in Chapter 3, the maximum ligament tensile and compressive intensities, as suggested in the
model, are dependent on the magnitude of the driving force and the surface area and anatomy of the root. The transverse displacement known as simple tipping derives its name from the simple active force system—a single point force P with line of action perpendicular to the long axis and piercing point CC, which produces an alteration in long-axis angulation. The active force may have faciolingual and/or mesiodistal components; one component is shown on the left in Figure 5-7. The couple-force ratio for this loading is zero; no
applied crown couple exists in a plane containing the long axis. The transferral of the active force to the cre, however, requires the addition of a couple equal in magnitude to the product of P and d (where, again, d is the long-axis distance from the bracket to the cre). The active force
system referenced to the center of resistance is shown in the center sketch of Figure 5-7; the two components indicate that the potential displacement is a translation of the cre in the direction and sense of P and a rotation or tipping of the long axis with sense corresponding to that of C1,. A typical displaced configuration with respect to an initiallyinclined long axis is shown on the right in Figure 5-7. The intersection of the two long-axis positions is the center of rotation for the simple-tipping displacement, slightly apical of the cre. Note that simple tipping
includes displacements of both point CC and the root apex (apices). The resultant of the periodontal-ligament response to simple-tipping tension
tension
//
compression
a likeness of the actual root cross-section
the modeled root cross-section
FIGURE 5-6. 0cc/usa! views of root cross-sections and distributed force systems exerted thereon: the anatomically correct (left) and as-modeled (right) root slices for a single-rooted tooth.
156
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
/
/
P
= Pd
/
I
/
crc
FIGURE 5-7. A plane view of the simple-tipping displacement: the active crown force at point CC (left); the equivalent loading referred to the cre (center); and a typical displacement showing the crc location (right).
action, referred to the cre, is equal and opposite to the action referred
there (Fig. 5-7, center), and is shown on the left in Figure 5-8. Equivalent to this resultant of P' and is the set of four forces shown in the middle
sketch of Figure 5-8; the pair located more apically are individually smaller in magnitude than those positioned closer to the cementoenamel junction. Each of these four forces is the resultant of a quadrant of the total distributed ligament response sketched on the right in Figure 5-8; each quadrant is not exactly triangular due to the tapering of the root.
Both compression and tension exist on either "side" of the root. Proceeding occiusally from the apex, the stress (intensity) levels in the model decrease from relative maximum values at the apex, go to zero and change signs at approximately the cro level, and then increase toward relative maximum values at the cementoenamel junction. The absolute maximum stresses occur at the root apex, due to the minimum root circumference there. Throughout this section in the modeling of the
P,
c,
tension
compression
FIGURE 5-8. The responsive force system against the root during simple tipping: the resultant referred to the cre (left); an equivalent set of two tensile and two compressive forces (center); and the modeled distributed force system in four parts (right).
157
Response of Den tition and Periodontium to Force
distributed response, the tensile and compressive ligament-material
stiffnesses are assumed equal and unchanging over the entire root length as noted previously. Considered next is the response of a single-rooted tooth to the application of a second- or third-order crown couple. This example might be termed "academic" because, in the presence of friction and some existing faciolingual arch-wire resistance, the crown couple will always be accompanied by some amount of transverse force. Nevertheless, pure transverse rotation is worthy of brief discussion. Shown from left to right in Figure 5-9 are the activating couple referred to point CC, the couple moved to the cre, and the displacement format associated with the couple-only loading. The couple-force ratio is mathematically infinite and, with pure rotation occurring, the cre remains stationary and the cro coin-
cides with it. The resultant of the periodontal-ligament response, this couple expressed as four discrete (in this instance, equal) forces, and
the distribution of the response modeled in two dimensions, are depicted from left to right in Figure 5-10. Figure 5-10 is analogous to Figure
5-8; again, the nonlinearity and the maximum intensity at the apex are due to the root taper, but the stress changes sign between tensile and compressive farther from the apex than in simple tipping (associated with the difference in cro locations). Root movement is the term given to the orthodontic tipping-torquing
displacement in which the crown position remains essentially unchanged. To accomplish the displacement, a second- or third-order cou-
ple is applied to the crown in the presence of a transverse "holding" force. A typical root movement is the uprighting displacement, to change tooth angulation with the vertical toward proper orientation of the long axis with respect to the occlusal plane. The principal part and
C0
cro
5-9. A plane view of pure, transverse rotation: the couple loading at point CC (left); the couple moved to the cre (center); and the displacement format showing the coincidence of the cro and the cre (right). FIGURE
158
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
-
tension
compression
FIGURE 5-10. The response to transverse couple loading: the resultant at the cre (left); an equivalent set of four forces (center); and the modeled distributed force system of the ligament against the root (right).
motive action of the applied force system is the couple; the role of the
force is prevention of crown displacement which occurs when the couple alone is exerted on the crown (Fig. 5-9, right). The force H and the couple Ch are shown on the left in Figure 5-11 at the crown center point CC. In the center sketch of Figure 5-11 the displacement format is illustrated with the cro at bracket level; note the direction of cre movement and the sense of the change in long-axis angulation. Correspondingly, shown on the right in Figure 5-11 are the force and couple referred to the cre, which are needed to produce the displacement. The magnitude of this couple is C,, — Hd, where the product Hd arises from the movement of the force H from point CC to the cre. Accordingly, the couple-force ratio necessary to produce this displacement is greater than d that required for bodily movement.
Ch
H
C,, - Hd
FIGURE 5-11. A plane view of root movement: the components of the active force system referred to point CC (left); the displacement and cro location (center); and the equivalent loading at the cre (right).
159
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
In root movement the apex experiences the largest displacement of all points of the tooth; the maximum intensity of the ligament responses is located at the root apex. Shown on the left in Figure 5-12 is the resultant of the distributed force system exerted by the periodontal ligament,
referred to the cre. The force H' is equal and opposite to H and the couple Ch is in magnitude Ch Hd. This force and couple may be combined into a single force located somewhat apical of the cre, and then it may be divided into tensile and compressive components H; and on the trailing and leading root surfaces, respectively, and plane-view modeled as illustrated in the center sketch of Figure 5-12. These forces are the resultants of the tensile and compressive portions of the distributed re-
sponse shown on the right in Figure 5-12. If the center of rotation is occlusal of the cementoenamel junction, nowhere along either the trailing or leading surface of the root does the intensity of the distribution go to zero and change sense. In this way the distributed response is similar to that for bodily movement; however, during root movement the difference in maximum and minimum intensifies is substantially greater than during bodily movement, given the same magnitude of transverse force for the two displacements (Nikolai, 1975). The clinical objective of root movement is to locate the cro within the tooth crown; to achieve the desired result, the mechanics must be capable of developing a holding force of sufficient magnitude to obtain the needed couple-force ratio. The last of the recognized transverse orthodontic displacements, and perhaps the most difficult to achieve clinically, is crown movement. The objective is a transverse displacement of the tooth crown without moving the root apex; this is, as ideally performed, a tipping displacement with the center of rotation at the apex. The displacement is shown on the left in Figure 5-13. From the relationship between the point-wise displacement of the center of resistance and the sense of the long-axis change in angulation, the applied force system referred to the cre must be as shown in the center sketch of Figure 5-13, including both a force and a couple. Furthermore, with the cro at the root apex, the response of
H'
compression
tension
FIGURE 5-12. The periodontal response during root movement; the resultant located at the cre (left); an equivalent system of two forces (center); and the modeled tensile and compressive distributions of force (right).
160
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
C
Cd - Cq
crc
FIGURE 5-13. A plane view of crown movement: the displacement and the crc location (left); the applied force and couple referenced to the cre (center); and the crown force system at point CC (right).
the periodontal ligament against the root as modeled will divide into a
compressive distribution on the half-root surface corresponding to the sense of the active force Q and tension on the remaining surface area. The resulting implication is in combining Q and Cq into a single force; that force must be located between the cre and the cementoenamel junction. It then follows that the active crown force system referenced to point CC consists of a force and a couple as shown on the right in Figure 5-13, the magnitude of the couple is less than the product Qd as indicated, and the couple-force ratio is less than d. Figure 5-14 depicts the resultant components Q' and Cq' of the periodontal-ligament response referred to the cre on the left (components equal and opposite to those of
C'q
cre
tension
compression
FIGURE 5-14. The ligament response during crown movement: the components of the resultant of the response referenced to the cre (left); an equivalent, single-force resultant divided into tensile and compressive parts (center); and the modeled distributed response against the root (right).
161
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
the active force system in the center in Figure 5-13), the resultant liga-
ment response as a single force divided into compressive and tensile portions, and Qj, in the center, and the compressive and tensile distributed responses on the right. Crown movement is the only transverse orthodontic displacement for which the maximum intensities of responsive force occur at the cementoenamel junction. To summarize, all transverse orthodontic tooth movements as defined are produced by a combination of a force approximately perpendicular to the long axis (parallel to the occiusal plane) and a couple in a plane containing the long axis. Looking into that plane, when both components have nonzero magnitudes, the sense of the moment of the force with respect to the cre is opposite to that of the couple. The couple-force ratio, which controls the position of the cro, is given simply as a ratio of magnitudes and equals the occlusogingival distance from point CC to the location of an equivalent, single-force load. (Although the center of resistance is a fixed point in a tooth—its location is independent of the crown loading—the center of rotation is highly dependent on the characteristics of the crown force system.) In the model used in this section, the cro is always located on the long axis or its extension; in reality this may be somewhat (but not substantially) in error in root movement produced by a third-order couple and a sufficiently stiff holding-force potential that will place the axis of rotation coincident, or nearly so, with
the arch wire and, thus, the cro within the bracket slot as viewed mesially or distally. In the analyses of these movements, when necessary the loading may be decomposed into components contained in faciolingual and mesiodistal planes through the long axis; often the transverse action is totally in one or the other of these planes. In the
faciolingual plane, adjacent teeth exerting pushing forces through crown contact can control the cro location; in the absence of a stiff palatal
bar, no such strong control can exist exclusive of ordinary orthodontic mechanics in the mesiodistal plane. Shown in Figure 5-15 is a plot, theoretically derived, of occlusogingival center-of-rotation location versus couple-force ratio for the labiolingual, transverse displacements of an average-size, maxillary central incisor (Nikolai, 1974). The partitioning of the plot into two curves results from the couple-force ratio becoming infinitely large as the bodily-movement displacement is approached. Notable are the substantial effects on cro location as the ratio nears d from above or below. Given in Table 5-1
are results associated with five mesiodistal displacements of a typical canine. The root length and overall long-axis length of the tooth were 17 mm and 22 mm, respectively. The analysis was theoretical assuming linear relationships between intensities and displacements of rootligament interface points, equal ligament stiffnesses in tension and compression, and accounting for root taper. Notable are the substantial differences in extremum (maximum, minimum) interface force intensities among the four tooth displacements generated with the same magnitude of transverse force.
162
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
to 0.9
Distance to cro occliisally from apex, normalized by root length 1.6
1.2
d
0.8
to 0.45 ——
I
to 0.45
—0.8
1.2
—0.4
1.6
2.0
Couple-force ratio (cm)
—0.4
—0.8
—1.2
to 0.9 —1.6
FIGURE 5-15. Lab/olin qua! displacements of a typical, maxillary, central incisor: a plot of cro location along the long axis and its extension versus the ratio of couple to transverse force as the loading components at point CC.
Finally, the remarks of this section need not be restricted to singlerooted teeth. Although the analysis may divide the overall root-surface
area into multiple portions for individual teeth having two or three roots, this is not a significant, complicating factor; neither is the fact of root apices away from the long axis when restricting attention only to transverse displacements. From recent experimentation, the center of resistance of a multiple-rooted (molar) tooth is apparently slightly apical of the midpoint of the overall apices-to-cementoenamel-j unction length (Burstone et al., 1981). Hence, center-of-rotation locations for transverse displacements, in relation to total root length, may be insignificantly influenced by the number of roots.
163
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force TABLE 5-1. Couple-force ratios, center-of-rotation locations, and maximum stress values tar five transverse canine displacements
Displacement format
Simple tipping Bodily movement Crown movement Root movement
Mesiodistal force (g)
Couple-force
Center of
ratio (mm)
rotation (mm/mm)*
Maximum stresses Gingival Root margin apex (g/cm2) 230
60
0
60 60 60
14
0.35 Infinite
11
0
16
1.3
7
85 10 125
Infinite
0.5
125
245
135 20 50
Couple (g-mm)
Pure torquing
1020
The location ot the center of rotafion is given from the root apex and as a fraction of the root length. The model canine has a projected area (mesiodistal perspective) of 0.9 cm2, a root length of 17 mm, and a
length of
22 mm.
fModitied from Nikolai, R.J.: On optimum orthodontic force theory as applied to canine retraction. Am. J. Orthod., 68:290— 302, 1975.)
Extrusion, Intrusion, and Long-Axis Rotation remaining three distinct orthodontic displacements are characterized by several common features. The active force system includes no net force component perpendicular to the long axis of the tooth; therefore, no potential exists to alter the long-axis position or orientation. The resistance to any of these three displacements, as provided by the periodontal ligament, appears to be principally shear in nature. Because the inherent shear resistance of the matrix material of the ligament is low, however, the essence of the response originates with the fiber bundles and, as one or a combination of these displacements begins, fiber orientations are altered toward positions tangential to the root surface. Twodimensional modeling in analyses of these displacements is unnecessary and unwarranted. With single-rooted teeth the anatomy and force system approach a configuration of geometric and mechanical symmetry with respect to the long axis, and the modeling more appropriately takes advantage of this near-symmetry. The analysis is somewhat more involved, however, particularly with long-axis rotation, when the tooth under study is multirooted and the near-symmetry is absent. In pure extrusion the activating system is a concentrated force acting along the long axis and referred to point CC. In the clinical setting, however, the extrusive force is exerted at the crown surface. Moving that force first to point CC and then to the cre, as shown in the leftto-right sequence in Figure 5-16, the extrusive force originating on the facial crown surface is seen to be accompanied by a third-order couple The
164
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Fe
FIGURE 5-16. An applied crown force with the combined potential for extrusion and lingual crown tipping: at the facial surface (left); an equivalent system at point CC (center); and the equivalent system at the cre (right).
and, with it, the potential to also tip the tooth; the crown would move
lingually and the root apex (apices) labially with the cro in the position indicated in Figure 5-9. Accordingly, the occlusally directed crown force must be augmented if the tipping potential is to be countered. (As mentioned earlier, the eccentricity of the typical appliance is discussed generally in Chapter 6.) In response to a purely extrusive potential, the periodontal ligament exerts a distributed force system having a resultant directed apically and positioned along the long axis. The distributed response arises almost exclusively from reorientation and stretching of the ligament fibers although, depending on actual anatomy, there may be some compressive resistance over a small area near the cementoenamel junction. The intraalveolar fibers will provide the majority of the total resistance because of their numbers and higher tensile stiffnesses compared to the supra alveolar fibers; otherwise, the distribution is apparently nearly uniform both circumferentially and longitudinally, and is modeled as such, for the single-rooted tooth. Other than to note the increased root-surface area inherent in the multirooted tooth, no substantial difference in extrusion analysis is necessary for multirooted versus single-rooted teeth. Of particular note, however, is the relatively weak periodontal resistance to extrusive displacements with little, if any, ligament reinforcement from bone compared to other tooth movements; control in this regard must be
provided in the decay characteristic of the activating force, perhaps through the arch wire, and by occlusion. Intrusion and extrusion are similar orthodontic displacements in that both activating loads are, ideally, axial forces, both pure movements are translational, and both resistances to displacement are associated with stretched ligament fibers. Differences between the movements include the sense of the load and of displacement potential and the creation of
165
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
apical pressure as a portion of the force system responsive to an intru-
sive loading. If the intrusive force is applied through the bracket at the facial surface, transferring it to point CC will introduce a third-order couple, opposite in sense to its counterpart in Figure 5-16, indicating that a tendency for labial crown tipping may accompany the intrusion. Shown in Figure 5-17 are the action and response associated with pure intrusive displacement potential. Of particular note is the presence of pressure at the root apex associated with localized ligament compression. With a multirooted tooth this pressure exists not only at each root
apex, but also in the bifurcation region. In the absence of substantial fiber stiffness, the pressures in the compression areas, which are small in comparison to the overall root-surface area, would be high even with a light, intrusive load. In their passive configurations, many of the intraalveolar fiber bundles are obliquely oriented with respect to the rootligament interface. This "hammock effect" protects the root apex or apices from excessive pressures resulting from masticatory, occlusal, and
intrusive orthodontic forces. If the intrusive force is substantial or is present continuously for a long time period, the pressure zones of the root-ligament interface grow and can envelope the entire root-surface area. Hence, because of the tapering of the root toward the apex, under intrusive force both fiber tensions and pressures from the ligament can exist at common points on the root surface; these pressures away from
C = F,e
fiber tension
apical compression
FIGURE 5-17. The force system associated with pure intrusion: the active and responsive resultants (left); and the active force referred to the ore together with the responsive distribution of tension and pressure (right).
166
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
the apex, relatively low compared to compressive intensifies at the apex,
are not shown in Figure 5-17 (and such pressures do not exist at all along the root in response to extrusive loading). A notable difficulty occurs in the attempt to quantify extrusive and
intrusive movements in comparison with similar analyses of other orthodontic displacements. The problem arises when tipping accompanies extrusion or intrusion, which occurs often in clinical practice, thereby altering the perpendicular-to-occlusal-plane distance between occlusal surface (incisal edge) and root apex. Shown in Figure 5-18 are two sets of initial (dashed) and final (solid) positions of a maxillary central incisor as viewed mesially or distally. The two initial positions are identical. The
amounts of extrusive or intrusive displacement must be determined in terms of two reference locations, one fixed within the tooth (e.g., the incisal edge) and a second outside the tooth (perhaps fixed within the maxilla or mandible, although "landmarks" within hard tissues may also move during the period of orthodontic treatment). The orthodontic displacement known as long-axis rotation is characterized by a change in the faciolingual- and mesiodistal-axis angulations as viewed from an occlusal perspective. To produce this displacement the active force system must exhibit a moment about the long axis, and such a moment is associated with a force, having a transverse component, applied tangentially to a facial, lingual, mesial, or distal crown surface. In pure, long-axis rotation no movement of the long axis occurs; hence, the center of rotation is on the long axis as shown in Figure 5-19. To obtain the pure displacement a first-order couple is required as illus-
\
Cant of the palatal plane
Dashed: initial position Sohd: Displaced position FIGURE 5-18. Combined orthodontic displacements of a maxillary central incisor as viewed distally: lingual crown tipping and intrusion (left); and labial root torquing and apparent extrusion (right).
167
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
I, (cN
/ FIGURE 5-19. An occiusal view of an applied first-order couple to generate long-axis rotation (left), and the initial (dashed) and displaced (solid) configurations together with cr0 location (right).
trated, and that couple might be made up of a mesiodistal force applied
through the bracket on the facial surface and a parallel force, but with opposite sense, exerted through crown contact with an adjacent tooth. If no provision is made or no potential exists for creation of the latter force,
the moment with respect to the long axis is present but the expected movement as seen in an occiusal view is a "rolling" displacement with the cro located away from (lingual of, in this example) the long axis. Figure 5-20 shows the sequence with the active force depicted on the left, the equivalent system at the cre (which coincides with point CC in an occiusal view) in the center sketch, and the displaced position (solid) of the crown on the right. The resultant of the periodontal-ligament force system, in response to a first-order crown couple, is a couple identical in all characteristics to the load except for sense. In the pure displacement, points on the surface of the root move circumferentially with respect to their counterparts on the alveolar-bone surface, lengthening and reorienting the fiber bundles toward configurations tangential to the root and perpendicular to the long axis. Fiber strains and stresses vary directly with the displacements of root-surface points, and the amounts of these displacements are directly proportional to the radial distances from the long axis to the points. Accordingly, the intensity of distributed responsive force is minimum at the root apex (of a single-rooted tooth) and increases in magnitude occiusally to a maximum near the alveolar crest. By reason of their attachment in the gingiva, the radial extra-alveolar fibers are more flexi-
168
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
//
F0
• cro
/ I' FIGURE 5-20. A rolling displacement in 0cc/usa! view: the applied force at the facial surface (left); the equivalent force system at point CC (center); and the displaced configuration and cr0 location (right).
ble and, as a result, the fiber tensions are less than those in neighboring,
intra-alveolar fibers. A schematic of the load and the distributed periodontal response is given in Figure 5-21; on the right is a qualitative plot of fiber stress against longitudinal position along the root surface. In the model, the single-rooted tooth is assumed conical in shape; therefore, at a specific occiusogingival level the fiber stresses do not vary in magnitude circumferentially. In reality, the variability in root-surface contour 0 cc
0 0
-J
Fiber
Fiber Stress
Co
FIGURE 5-21. Pure, long-axis rotation: a transverse view of the crown loading and the periodontal response (left); and the variation in fiber stress with longitudinal distance from the gingiva! margin to the root apex for a single-rooted tooth (right).
169
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force tension
compression tension
compression
tension
compression
FIGURE 5-22. Responsive periodontal distribution against the roots of a maxillary first molar undergoing long-axis rotation: apical view (left) and transverse view (right).
results in some localized compression of the ligament, but the percentage of the root surface experiencing pressure is relatively small. Of all the distinct orthodontic displacements, the multirooted tooth undergoing long-axis rotation presents the most substantial difference in response, compared to the single-rooted tooth. Apical of the bifurcation location, an assumption of axial symmetry is totally incorrect. The "long axis" of each root deviates from the long axis of the tooth as a whole with, generally, substantial distances between the long axis and the apices. With the cro on the long axis of the tooth, in this displacement the individual roots experience bodily movement in a curvilinear fashion, with pressures against the leading surfaces and fiber tensions exerted on the trailing surfaces catalyzing the bone remodeling necessary to achieve the movement. Apical and mesial views of the distributed periodontal responses to long-axis rotation of a maxillary first molar are depicted in Figure 5-22. also
Response of the Periodontium to Force applied to the tooth crown, originating in mastication, the activated orthodontic appliance, or from the lips, tongue, or facial tissues, results in the creation of a response within the supporting structure of the tooth. The individual tooth is positioned locally within a socket or Force
alveolus, lined with a soft tissue—the periodontal ligament—which separates the tooth root from the alveolar bone. The basal bone interconnects the units of the dentition; the alveolar processes of the upper arch blend
170
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
into the maxilla and those of the lower arch into the mandible. The
periodontal ligament completely surrounds the tooth root from cementoenamel junction to apex (apices). The ligament is composed of collagenous fibers in bundles, blood vessels, nerves, and cells embedded in an amorphous, viscous matrix (often termed "ground substance"). The ligament is a composite material capable of sustaining and transmitting
tensile loading primarily through the fibers; pressure is transmitted principally by the matrix material. The ligament passively exhibits nearuniform thickness of approximately 0.3 mm and low stiffness, at least an order of magnitude less than that of calcified bone. The primary function
of the ligament is to cushion the bone beneath it from the action of impulsive, masticatory loading of the dental units. The alveolar bone, also, is a heterogeneous material. Although the underlying portions of the bone are somewhat spongy, the layer adjacent to the periodontal ligament is dense and exhibits rather high surface hardness. This layer, the cortical plate (lamina dura), and the cementum anchor the radial fibers that run into and through the ligament. The alveolar bone is relatively stiff as a whole, although some deflection apparently occurs in the thin, crestal regions under the action of relatively high forces applied to the tooth crowns. Forces exerted on the dentofacial complex may be designated as orthodontic if their intent is the movement of teeth through remodeling of the alveolar process; during such remodeling, no significant alteration of basal bone occurs. On the other hand, forces may be exerted with the intention of displacing basal bone without producing relative displacements of teeth within the alveolus; such forces are rightfully termed orthopedic. The internal force system in the periodontium, arising from the application of a crown force, possesses an involved format, made so by the geometric and mechanical as well as the biologic complexities of the responding tissues. The problem, however, can be simplified somewhat through modeling, with a reasonable analysis of the distribution in the alveolus of this internal force pattern including three individual consid-
erations. First, because the periodontal ligament is thin compared to bone dimensions, the distributed force system carried to it by the tooth root is insignificantly altered while transmitted through it. Specifically, the tension-pressure system at the ligament and cortical-plate interface
may be considered identical to that between the root and ligament. Admittedly, a small reduction in intensities exists due to the slightly larger ligament surface area adjacent to the plate compared to the area against the root, but the difference is reasonably ignored. Second, the distribution of normal stress into alveolar bone, in response to loading at the plate surface by the ligament, may be envisioned through the aid of Figure 5-23. Shown on the left is a flat surface (in edge view) of a solid subjected to a compressive force and representations of resulting pressures at various distances from the point of application of the load. In a homogeneous material, such pressures have been shown to decrease in magnitude directly with the radial distance
from the location of the load. (Changing the sense of the load, an ap-
171
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
Compressive force
Pc
PA PB
Pa
p: compressive stress (pressure) FIGURE 5-23. A simplified representation of the alveolar-bone response to pressure loading by the periodontal ligament: the variation of compressive-stress magnitude with distance from the load (left); and the accompanying induced normal and shear stresses (right).
plied tensile force induces corresponding tensile stresses directed radially.) On the right in Figure 5-23 are shown stress-at-a-point sketches for
points A and B. Note the presence of circumferential tensile stresses at right angles to the radially directed pressures at points off the force line. (In general, for either sense of the normal surface load, the two mutually perpendicular normal stresses at each point will exhibit opposite senses. The shear stresses, present at all points like B and C not on the line of action of the concentrated load, indicate a tendency to distort the small
elements of bone material surrounding the points.) The two normal stresses being of the same order of magnitude, the circumferential stresses also decrease in size with increasing distance from the applica-
tion-location of the load. In the problem of analyzing the transfer of force from the root through the ligament and into alveolar bone, the root typically transfers a nonuniformly distributed load rather than a concentrated force. Figure 5-23 depicts, then, a substantial simplification of the response at the bone-ligament interface and within the alveolar bone to transverse crown loading; however, the model does reflect the essential features of that response. Third, a portion of the load applied to one tooth crown can be trans-
mitted directly to adjacent teeth through either crown contact or the transseptal fibers (to be discussed subsequently). Distributions of force by these means depend upon the characteristics of the load, the relative positions of the teeth, and the continuity of the fiber network. The effect of this distribution is twofold: a reduction from expected value of the force transmitted into the periodontal ligament surrounding the loaded tooth and the displacement(s) of adjacent teeth that were not subjected
172
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
to external loading. The phenomenon is most apparent when the crown
loading is mesiodistal in direction, although the effects of the transseptal-fiber system are also present in other orthodontic displacements. The preceding discussion provides a simplistic, qualitative description of the principal effects of the force system within the periodontium at any particular instant in response to crown loading. No general discussion of periodontal response is properly undertaken, however, without considering the influence of time upon the applied and responsive forces. An examination of the response to masticatory action serves well to introduce time as an analysis variable. Chewing forces are primarily intrusive and exist only infrequently during the average day. Moreover, when present, forces of mastication exhibit a periodic pattern, oscillating with jaw movement between zero and some finite value. The responsive forces are induced in the same pattern with the periodontal ligament tending to isolate the impact of mastication from the bone beyond it. The fiber bundles form a hammock-like structure around the root, stretching and relaxing in primarily an elastic manner in response to the occlusal impulses. Although the loading is transmitted into the bone, it is shortterm and "dulled" by the flexibility of the ligament; normally no lasting effects are produced in the ordinary, passive configuration of the dentition and its supporting system. Note that the individual tooth is inherently well protected against the effects of all short-term loading with the possible exception of extrusive force (although occlusion tends to prevent abnormal displacement). The overall response of the periodontium tends toward that of a viscoelastic material, with a rather substantial
time period under uninterrupted force required to produce lasting changes.
The response of the periodontium to the internal force system created by a sustained load, such as that produced by an orthodontic appliance, is fundamentally in two sequential parts. Immediately upon appli-
cation of the crown force system, the tooth undergoes an initial displacement owing to the flexibility of the periodontal ligament. As discussed previously, the form of the displacement depends upon the characteristics of the applied force system. With the exception of extrusion and, possibly, long-axis rotation, the extent of this initial displacement is limited by the complete compression of the ligament between root and alveolar bone. Transversely and intrusively, with allowance for possible small crestal deflections, the narrow periodontal ligament restricts an initial displacement to a maximum of approximately 0.5 mm reflected at the root apex (apices) or the alveolar crest. Any displacement is indicative of the appliance doing mechanical work upon the dentition which reduces the strain energy of activation and the magnitudes of the
components of the force system exerted on the dentition. The initial displacement ordinarily will not deactivate the appliance totally and the result is a "stand-off' between the appliance-teeth and periodontal systems, both in constrained configurations with respect to their previously passive states. If left in these constrained states, in a period of days the
173
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
long-term portion of the periodontal response would become evident
with the biologic remodeling of the periodontium allowing further dental-unit displacement accompanied by additional deactivation of the appliance. If allowed to continue indefinitely, the process might end only upon complete deactivation of the appliance.
The long-term response of the periodontal ligament to continued deformation involves two forms of biologic remodeling: the partial replacement of fibrous matter carrying tensile stress by new, stress-relieved material and the resorption of alveolar bone to relieve and redis-
tribute the pressure. In the portion of the ligament in which fiber stretching is developed and sustained, due to either direct tension or what would otherwise be shear, the tensile strains apparently heighten the activity of fibroblasts, builder cells within the ligament that initiate the formation of new collagenous fibers. The level of activity of these cells is
assumed to be at least partially dependent on the amount of localized pressure developed between the stretched fibers as well as the magnitude of tensile strain. Notable are the categories of fibers within the periodontal ligament. The intra-alveolar or principal fiber bundles radiate from the root and proceed into and through the ligament and into alveolar bone. These fibers are relatively short and differentiation among groups is generally made according to direction as noted in a facial view of the tooth and alveolus. Proceeding apically, included are the crestal, the horizontal, the oblique, the interradicular (attached to multirooted teeth), and the apical fibers. All
but the interradicular fibers are depicted passively in Figure 5-24. The extra-alveolar (supra-alveolar) or gin gival fibers are passively longer and are
embedded in the cementum and in the gingiva occlusal to the alveolar crest. In this group the cementoepithelial fibers radiate from the cementum near the cementoenamel junction, the circumferential bundles are totally
within the gingiva and surround each tooth, and the transseptal fibers weave their way mesiodistally from tooth to tooth, linking the dental units to one another. Given the displacement of a root point, the amount of accompanying fiber strain depends upon the passive length of the fiber. Of the radial groups, the cementoepithelial fibers are the longest and require the greatest length of time to remodel; to hasten readaptation and overall remodeling, and, in particular, toward retention of long-axis rotational displacements, these fibers are sometimes severed with subsequent reattachment occurring naturally in the displaced configuration. With nonextrusive tooth displacements the proximity of the root to
the alveolar-bone surface protects the ligament against failure due to excessive tensile strain. The real concern is sustained compressive deformation of the periodontal ligament. Where pressures exist substantially
in excess of normal blood pressure (25 to 35 g/cm2), occlusion of the vessels occurs and with it an interference in the supply of nutrition to the tissues. Pressures of sufficient magnitude not only interfere with normal blood flow, but drive the blood supply from the area of high
174
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
_— Crestal fibers
Horizontal fibers
Periodontal ligament
Oblique fibers
A
— Apical fibers FIGURE 5-24. The groups of intra-alveolar fiber bundles between root and cortical plate as seen in a transverse view of a single-rooted tooth.
175
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
pressure, reduce or prevent cellular activity, and even force the displace-
ment of the ligament matrix material to regions of lower stress. Sustained high pressure is accompanied by potential for regressive biologic alterations of the ligament (hyalinization, necrosis) and prevents remodeling of the alveolar bone at the cortical plate-ligament interface. Accordingly, not only to lessen the pain associated with tissue deformation, but also to guard against the possibility of ligament pathology associated with sustained high pressures, the magnitudes of the force-system com-
ponents transmitted by appliances to tooth crowns must be limited. The fibrous attachment of the periodontal ligament to the cortical plate enables the transmission of tensile as well as compressive distributed loading into the alveolar bone. A number of cells, in addition to the aforementioned fibroblasts, exist in the periodontal space and contribute to the remodeling process in the absence of excessive pressure. In regions of the bone-ligament interface where continuing fiber tension is present, the fibroblastic activity is accompanied by that of the osteoblasts. These cells play a role in the formation of osteoid, which develops along the outer surface of the cortical plate, adhering to both the surface and the stretched fibers emerging from the plate. In time this new material mineralizes to form bundle bone and eventually calcifies. Each small but distinct movement of the tooth root causes an incremental change in interface stress magnitudes and in osteoblastic action; as a result, the new bone appears in layers (lamellae). The overall effect on osteoblastic and fibroblastic activity, attributable to the initial magnitude of the fiber tension, is not well understood. Notable, however, is the apparent fact that removal of the fiber tension has little effect on the continuation of
bone maturation, once the osteoid has been laid down. Moreover, a reversal of the interface loading to create compression of the ligament against bone does not result in the immediate removal of osteoid; this new tissue exhibits an inherent resistance, significantly more so than mature bone, to such remodeling. Although sustained crown loading results in fiber remodeling and bone apposition in periodontal regions where the radial component (di-
rected out from the long axis) of induced stress is tensile, where the radial stress component is compressive, another form of biologic action occurs. If transverse movement of teeth is to take place, resulting from the application of orthodontic force, alveolar bone must be removed to accommodate the leading root surfaces while new bone is formed in the vacated space(s). The bone-resorption process is stimulated by yet another cell form, and the location(s) of the initiation of the process and the time required to complete it are apparently dependent upon the stress pattern within the periodontium which, in turn, depends upon the form
and magnitude of the applied crown force system. Osteoclasts in the periodontium seemingly are activated, beyond their normal levels, by moderate amounts of stress in certain configurations to break down the protein matrix of bone. When the bone resorption occurs at the bone surface adjacent to the periodontal ligament, the process is termed direct
or frontal resorption. Where the bone-ligament interface stresses are
176
Bioeng!neering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
high, the process begins at some depth within the alveolar bone; this
internal bone remodeling is known as undermining or rear resorption. (Recall that the radial and circumferential normal stresses decrease with distance from a normal surface loading; see Fig. 5-23). Two hypotheses are offered in regard to the mechanical catalyst associated with the remodeling of alveolar bone. On the one hand, there is a strong tendency to relate the remodeling format to the radial stress— bone apposition to tension or the tensile stress component normal to the bone-ligament interface and resorption to the radial compressive stress or pressure. Alternatively, transverse remodeling of long bones is said to be keyed to the sense of the longitudinal stress—apposition by pressure and resorption by tension. Once again recall the discussion of Figure 5-23, particularly the fact that, at a point within the bone, the normal stresses at right angles are opposite in sense to one another. If the analogy is drawn between the longitudinal and transverse directions associated with the long bone and the circumferential and radial directions, respectively, within the alveolar bone, the so-called "piezoelectric effect" theory espoused by the orthopedist does not inherently conflict with the pressure theory of the orthodontist. Much remains to be learned and understood regarding the biologic response of the periodontium to mechanical stress. Moreover, the nahire of the orthodontic appliance and of therapy adds to the complexity of the matter. The effect of biologic remodeling "in isolation" would undoubtedly be a modification of the initially varying stress pattern toward a uniform distribution throughout the ligament and bone, as well as a reduction in the average pressure within the periodontium. Although the crown loading is lessened in overall magnitude as incremental displacements due to remodeling occur, it generally continues to exist and maintains a nonuniform pattern of stress against and within the alveolar bone. This matter is further complicated when several components are included in the crown force system and each is dependent for its magnitude on individual stiffnesses of appliance elements; the couple-force ratio, for example, may change as the overall displacement progresses. Finally, the clinician may interrupt the ongoing process and start another by first unloading, then modifying, and subsequently reactivating the appliance. In concluding this section, a comment on the resistance of cementum to resorption and the activity of cementoblasts is appropriate. These cells potentially sustain and repair the hard outer surface of the root. Both the cortical plate and the cementum are subjected essentially to the same pressures created through the application of crown force; however, a physiologic difference between the seemingly similar tissues is reflected
in a greater resistance to resorption inherent in the cementum. The cementoblast resides in the periodontal space and its routine activity is undoubtedly affected by sustained high pressure. Other factors have a role, but apparently the combination of conditions that sometimes result in root resorption during orthodontic treatment is not now well understood.
177
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
Displacements Related to Magnitude and Duration of Force force system applied to the tooth crown, toward the creation of a displacement, originates in the straining of elements of an appliance in the attachment of it to the dentition. The crown force system may consist of one or several components; they are individually concentrated forces or couples, each having a direction, sense, and an initial magniThe
tude dependent on the manner of appliance-to-crown contact, the amount of activation deformation, and the localized stiffness of the associated appliance element. The components of the applied force system generally lessen in magnitude as time proceeds from the instant of activation, and the significant portions of the force-versus-time pattern for the fixed appliance are (1) the initial magnitude, (2) the rapid decrease in magnitude associated with the deformation of the periodontal ligament, (3) the long-term decay resulting from remodeling of the alveolus (to be examined subsequently in more detail), and (4) any reactivation by the practitioner to begin a new cycle. Notable also is the possible creation of additions to the crown force system resulting from tooth displacement
caused by the principal activation. For example, an arch wire may be initially passive within a bracket, but mesiodistal crown tipping can eliminate the original second-order, wire-to-bracket clearance and gradually result in activation of a counter-tipping couple. In such a situation, although the original crown force system is decaying with time, a portion of the load is inactive initially, then grows from zero to some maximum magnitude dependent in a complex manner upon several parameters, and also, subsequently, decays in the absence of interference with the original activation. The intensity of internal force, or stress, at a particular instant and at a specific point within the periodontium, is directly related to the characteristics of the crown force system at that instant and the specific perio-
dontal location. The change in stress at a point with time follows the same temporal pattern as that of the crown load. The maximum stresses exist in the periodontal ligament and against root and the cortical plate at alveolar-crest or root-apex locations, depending upon crown loading, as discussed previously. Ideally, any tooth movement should be accomplished in a direct and reasonably rapid fashion while minimizing patient discomfort. Largely because of the differences in biologic responses
to stimuli found in virtually any sample of man, however, there currently exists no wide acceptance of one "best" force-time pattern to accomplish even the simplest single-tooth displacements. Nevertheless, the practitioner must be cognizant of several basic guidelines, whichever treatment philosophy is followed:
1. Continuous interruption of the blood supply to the periodontal ligament must be limited in time. 2. The amount of time under load, required to resorb sufficient alveolar
178
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
to permit a measurable tooth displacement, is apparently dependent upon the magnitude of pressure against the periodontal ligament. bone
3. Relatively light forces can generally produce the desired orthodontic displacements. Controlling the Force-Time Pattern The clinician, with the cooperation of the patient, can and must control
the magnitude-versus-time pattern of applied orthodontic force. Two displacements, together with appliance-element stiffnesses, are the key items in that control. The combination of appliance-member displacement(s) (activation) and stiffness(es) determine the initial level of applied crown force. The immediate, soft-tissue deformation and accompanying tooth displacement, and the same stiffness(es) determine the state at which biologic remodeling must begin and to what extent, if at all, the periodontal ligament has been hyalinized. In an over-simplified manner, orthodontic forces are sometimes categorized as "light" or "heavy," according to the initial magnitude of force generated within the appliance. In reality, the important consideration is not whether the initial appliance-element force is 50 g, 150 g, or 450 g, but rather (1) the maximum value and distribution of pressure in the individual periodontal ligament following soft-tissue deformation and (2) the stiffness of the appliance element generating the force. Accordingly, the classification
of appliances as generally "light-wire" or "heavy-wire" devices, with reference to stiffness is somewhat more appropriate. When periodontal-ligament pressures are sufficient to occlude blood vessels throughout a substantial portion of the tissue at the initiation of crown loading, as suggested in the aforementioned guidelines, the existence of a "rest and recovery" portion of the activation-deactivation cycle is imperative. Prior to the end of each cycle and reactivation, the maximum pressures must have dropped (as a result of remodeling and tooth displacement) to levels that permit the restoration of circulation and the
resumption of nutritional activity within the ligament. This requires almost complete deactivation of the appliance or the unloading of it. There need be little concern of losing the displacement achieved since whatever osteoid has been laid down is highly resistant to resorption compared to calcified bone. The intermittent orthodontic force exhibits a cyclic pattern with a period equal to the time between successive appointments. Applied by a heavy-wire appliance, the initial activation distance should be approximately twice, and generally never more than three times the expected, corresponding soft-tissue deformation. (Greater activations may produce some inelastic straining of the appliance as well as, perhaps, excessive force magnitudes.) Although the initial force may be rather high, so also is the appliance stiffness and immediately with the ligament deformation this force decays substantially. Bone remodeling then begins with undermining resorption likely in the higher pressure zones until
179
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
the
applied force drops off further with tooth movement. Again, this
force is termed intermittent because the combination of moderate activalion and high appliance stiffness results initially in ligament necrosis, but ultimately in pressure reduction to low levels long before the next
appointment to ensure the resumption of blood circulation within the soft tissue. A second type of acceptable orthodontic force is that typically applied by an extraoral or removable appliance. The interrupted force has a characteristic magnitude-lime pattern created by the patient who periodically unloads the appliance, thereby totally relieving all force for a
period of time. A typical interrupted, orthodontic force follows a 24hour cyclic pattern with the appliance in place and active for, perhaps, 10 to 14 hours a day. The force may be heavy and decay little; hence the inactive period each day must be sufficient to keep the periodontal liga-
ment healthy over the total period of use of the appliance. Continuous orthodontic forces do not, by their definition, decay to zero during the between-appointments period. Exerted by rather highly flexible appliance elements, activations must be to relatively low force levels so as to occlude no more than a small percentage of the vessels within the periodontal ligament (and not substantially interfere with nutritional activity). Bone remodeling in pressure zones is expected to occur primarily as direct resorption of the cortical-plate surface. Because the continuous-force cycle includes no "rest period," little interference with normal biologic functioning within the soft tissues can be tolerated. Figure 5-25 provides a qualitative comparison between the magnitudetime patterns of acceptable light and continuous, and relatively heavy, but intermittent, orthodontic forces. To produce the total desired displacement by a particular appliance configuration or set of mechanics often requires several months. A new activation-deactivation cycle begins each time the clinician reactivates
the appliance, and this reactivation may occur four or more times in the overall process, for example, in distally driving canines into firstpremolar extraction sites. If the teeth to be moved are receptive to ortho-
dontic force, a reactivation is necessary only when the appliance has exhausted all or most of the mechanical-work capability provided by a prior activation or reactivation. In the absence of some appliance failure, the total displacement is accomplished incrementally, and an examination of one activation-deactivation cycle provides the substance of the
entire tooth-movement process, even though perhaps only one-fourth or less of that total displacement is depicted. Figure 5-26 shows two time-versus-displacement plots for one acti-
vation-deactivation cycle and a between-appointments period of 3 weeks. The displacements are simple-tipping of canine teeth on opposite sides of the same arch. The solid plot represents an initial force magnitude of 60 g; the dashed plot was obtained following activation to 150 g. Each crown displacement takes place in 3 stages. Stage 1 is the almost immediate movement reflecting the deformation of the periodontal ligament by the tooth root; little difference in this first portion of the overall displacement is noted for the 2 teeth as, apparently, 60 g was
180
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
is
0 0
u
soft-tissue deformation
undermining resorption
Heavy, intermittent force
Light, continuous force
deactivation
Time
FIGURE 5-25. A one-cycle comparison of the magnitude-versus-time patterns of intermittent and continuous orthodontic force.
sufficient to completely compress the ligament at the root apex and alve-
olar-crest levels. During stage 2 the remodeling of fibers and bone begins and further displacement is virtually nonexistent. The length of this stage may vary from several days to several weeks or longer, depending on the level of pressure against the cortical plate. From the figure, stage 2 for the tooth initially receiving 60 g of load was completed in about 4 days; for the canine subjected to 150 g this second stage extended to nearly 2 weeks. As bone is resorbed in the pressure zones and the effect of resorption reaches the bone-ligament interface where complete softtissue compression had occurred upon loading, additional tooth movement signals the beginning of stage 3. When direct resorption takes place, stage 3 displacement is more gradual than when substantial undermining resorption is necessary before any further tooth movement can occur. This is reflected in Figure 5-26 in that, after stage 3 began for the tooth receiving 150% more initial force, the displacement progressed at a more rapid rate such that, when the patient appeared on day 22, the practitioner measured nearly the same accumulated canine crown displacement on both sides of the arch (Gianelly and Goldman, 1971). The overall results depicted in Figure 5-26 are indicative of the preference of some clinicians for heavy-force mechanics and others for lightforce appliances and techniques. Conceivably, however, had a third,
similar canine been subjected to an initial force of several hundred grams, stage 2 might not have been completed in 21 days; hence, no rest period for the ligament would have occurred between appointments, a
)flSO of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
I I I I I I
I
/ —U
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
/
Stage 3
—— Stage 2
Stage 1
5
10
15
20
Time (days)
E 5-26. The three-stage pattern of tooth movement. Plots of displacement versus Or a pair of canine teeth, one subjected to an initial distal driving force of 60 g and the other to 150 g (dashed).
182
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
-
reactivation of the appliance might endanger ligament vitality, and the
result of excessive initial force applied 3 weeks earlier is likely an exten-
sion of the total time to complete the full tooth movement. The graphics of Figure 5-26, in illustrating the three-stage nature of orthodontic tooth movement, are indicative of the first, betweenappointments period associated with a long-term displacement; the 1.5 mm is perhaps one-fifth of the total movement desired. A reactivation will produce another displacement-time pattern, similar to the first cycle if (1) nearly total deactivation of the appliance had taken place, (2) the periodontal ligament had been fully revitalized if hyalinization oc-
curred early in the cycle, and (3) the reactivation displacement of the appliance was the same as that at the start of the first cycle. In general, the lighter the force, the less significant may be stage 1 and the shorter is stage 2. Assuming that measurable movement does not take place during the first cycle, subsequent reactivations can be to somewhat larger
initial loads since cellular activity has been ongoing and the tooth or teeth are loosened with slightly wider periodontal space than before the orthodontic force was first applied. Also, the apparently insignificant difference in one-cycle displacements shown in Figure 5-26 may be the long-term result, indicating that an initial magnitude of force might be selected from a range of acceptable values. It is clear, however, that the range is bounded. If the force is too light, the rate of stage 3 displacement will be low and the between-appointments displacement small.
With the load magnitude too large, little more than stage 1 displacements will occur and, with subsequent reactivations and no relief for the tissues from the high pressures, accumulated damage to the periodontal ligament is likely.
Physiologically Proper Orthodontic Forces An orthodontic force or force system may be said to be "physiologically proper" when the force-time pattern produces a reasonable rate of tooth
movement without causing extensive interference with the normal biologic activity within the periodontium and, therefore, no irreversible damage to the tissues. Although very light forces fulfill this prescription, the efficient management of treatment demands that displacements be performed as rapidly as possible. Some discomfort is often associated with activation or reactivation of an appliance due to the relationship between the pressures developed and the pain threshold of the patient; again, efficient management to the end of gaining and maintaining good patient cooperation suggests minimization of this discomfort.The orthodontist, then, should strive to apply force that is controlled both with respect to initial value and, through astute selection of appliance elements, in terms of its decay pattern over time. From the foregoing discussion, the principal indicator of appropriate force is the pressure generated in the periodontium, more specifically, in the periodontal ligament. Because this pressure is actually compressive stress, and stress level is generally related to applied force through the area over which the stress is distributed, a first consideration is the num-
183
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force TABLE 5-2. Root-surface areas in centimeters squared for average normal permanent teeth
Maxillary arch
Mandibular arch
Tooth
Central Incisor Lateral Incisor Canine First Premolar Second Premolar First Molar Second Molar Third Molar
1.40 1.10 2.05 1 .50
1.40 3.35 2.70 1.95
1.05 1.25 1.60 1 .30
1.35
3.50 2.80 1.90
ber of teeth directly affected by the applied force system and the size of
the roots of those teeth. Table 5-2 provides the root surface areas of individual teeth of average size. Note that these areas vary from the smallest to the largest by a factor of 3.3. Given the value of an applied force and the tooth or segment to receive that force, the average stress in the periodontal ligament may be obtained by dividing the force magnitude by the affected root-surface area. Using this approach, then, nearly
twice the force magnitude to displace a mandibular central incisor should be applied to move a maxillary canine. Again, however, the key parameter is specifically compressive stress and three, additional, important factors must be considered in this analysis: (1) the direction of the applied load, (2) the couple-force ratio (or type of displacement desired), and (3) the load-time pattern. Refining the procedure of selecting an initial orthodontic loading magnitude to emphasize pressure and direction of load as criteria suggests replacing the overall root-surface area with projected areas. Table 5-3
gives these projected root-surface areas from three perspectives: occluTABLE 5-3. Projected root-surface areas in centimeters squared for average normal permanent teeth presented from three perspectives
Mandibular arch
Maxillary arch FL
MD
OG
Tooth
FL
MD
00
0.50 0.40 0.70 0.50 0.50
0.70 0.65 0.75 0.75 0.55 1.20 1.00 0.80
0.40 0.30 0.45 0.30 0.30 0.80 0.70 0.50
Central Incisor Lateral Incisor Canine First Premolar Second Premolar First Molar Second Molar Third Molar
0.25 0.25 0.70 0.60 0.60
0.45 0.50 0.75 0.60 0.60 1.10 0.95 0.65
0.20 0.20 0.35 0.30 0.30 0.85 0.75 0.60
1.35 0.95 0.60
FL: Faciolingual perspective MD: Mesiodistal perspective OG: Occiusogirgival perspective
1.05
0.95 0.65
184
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
sogingival, faciolingual, and mesiodistal. The only orthodontic displace-
ments I or which pressure does not cover such an area are extrusion and long-axis rotation, although only a partial (occlusogingival) area may be involved in an intrusive displacement. Recalling the differences in stress distributions produced in the various transverse tooth movements (Figs. 5-5, 5-8, 5-10, 5-12, and 5-14), Table 5-1 presented sets of theoretically determined couple-force ratios, center-of-rotation locations, and maxi-
mum stress values for five such displacements of an average canine. Noting particularly that the distal driving force is identical in four of the displacements, because of the sizable differences in maximum stress
values between simple tipping and bodily movement, for example, a substantially larger crown load may be used in attempting the latter displacement. The influence of root shape should also be brought into the determina-
tion of appropriate crown loading when warranted. Perhaps the best example of root-shape impact is in the comparison between long-axis rotation of the single- and multirooted tooth. The specific factor is the substantially greater amount of bone resorption required to bodily move the bifurcated-root apices that follow circular paths around the long axis.
In other instances, unusual root curvatures or cross-sectional shapes may provide significant input in determining load magnitude. A final, important factor is individual biology. Resistance to or ease of remodeling is affected by alveolar bone density and to an extent by cortical-plate and
periodontal-ligament thicknesses. A reasonable manner of including this parameter is to estimate by clinical observation and patient input, a nearly "optimum" orthodontic force magnitude for a specific tooth displacement early in treatment. Subsequently, by proportions according to projected root-surface area and type of movement primarily, appropriate load values may be established for succeeding displacements to be undertaken in the same dentition and within the same treatment philosophy. With all principal influencing factors now mentioned, a hypothetical procedure may be outlined which leads to the determination of the suggested, initial level of physiologically proper force with which to begin a specific orthodontic displacement in the average patient. The approach to be outlined arises from the impressions of clinicians, based on their experiences, together with theoretical and bench-experimental analyses. The fundamental bases are (1) the knowledge of normal blood pressure
and, therefore, a reasonable approximation of the ligament pressure necessary to interrupt blood flow at a point within that tissue, (2) the assumption that vessel occlusion over a sizable volume within the periodontal ligament for a period of several weeks is necessary to produce irreversible pathology, and (3) the understanding that, whenever direct pressure exists within a portion of the ligament (and at the interfaces), elsewhere in that tissue fiber tension is the direct stress that should not interfere substantially with nutritional activity in those areas. The procedure begins with the following hypothesis: an intermittent,
simple-tipping force should have an initial value such that the cone-
185
Response of Dentition and Periodonfium to Force
sponding average stress within the affected periodontal ligament is approximately 30 g/cm2. In other words, the initial magnitude of the trans-
verse-tipping force should be the product of 60 g/cm2 and the mesiodistal or faciolingual projection of the total root area transferring responsive tension and pressure. (In transverse movements, two projected areas are under normal stress—mesial and distal, for example. Hence, 60 g/cm2 is multiplied by one of these areas or 30 g/cm2 by the sum of the two areas.) If the applied force is to be continuous and no "rest period" will occur over a period of four or more weeks, the initial value should be approximately 0.4 of the corresponding intermittent magnitude (based on the assumption that such a force will decay, beyond stage 1, about 40% during one between-appointments period). For bodily movement, the stress distribution along the root length is substantially more nearly uniform than the response in simple tipping (see Figs. 5-5 and 5-8). Also, the ratio of maximum stresses to applied force is much lower in bodily movement (see Table 5-1). Accordingly, a larger initial force can be tolerated in bodily movement, and the suggested value is based on the average of the alveolar-crest and root-apex stresses taken from Table 5-1. The resulting formulas for the initial val-
ues of the force and couple portions of the intermittent, transverse crown load to produce bodily movement are Transverse force = 3.5(simple-tipping force) Couple = 0.5(transverse force)(total tooth length)
51
(Assumed is the crown force system effectively applied at point CC on the long axis, midway between incisal edge [occlusal surface] and the cementoenamel junction.) Again, examining Table 5-1 and Figure 5-11, the couple-force ratio for root movement is understandably somewhat greater than that for bodily movement. Once more employing as a portion of the basis the average of alveolar-crest and root-apex stresses equal for all transverse movements, the formulas to follow are offered for the torquing of roots through intermittent loading: Transverse (holding) force = 0.8(comparable bodilymovement force) Couple-force ratio = 0.6(total tooth length)
(5-2)
When several teeth are to undergo similar displacements as a single entity, for example, in the retraction of four incisors in either arch, the computations may be made for the segment as a whole using an average
tooth length and the sum of the projected root areas of the individual teeth. Proceeding as above, for transverse crown movement the following formulas are suggested: Transverse force = 1. 7(comparable bodily-movement force) Couple-force ratio = 0.4(total tooth length)
186
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Although not occurring often in actual clinical practice, but appropriate
to include for completeness in the set of formulas for proposed, physiologically proper transverse force systems is this equation for pure torquing:
Couple = (comparable simple-tipping force)(root length)
(5-4)
The couple-force ratio is undefined because no separate crown force acts.
The three nontransverse orthodontic displacements—intrusion, extrusion, and long-axis rotation—might be characterized collectively by the dominance of fiber tensions within the responsive force system. Vir— tually no pressure occurs anywhere between root and periodontium in response to purely extrusive action; in long-axis rotation, the sizes and locations of pressure zones depend entirely on root anatomy. To complete the set of formulas for the force-system components, then, for the
remainder of the eight, previously defined displacements, in the absence of pressure as a principal influence, collective judgments of clinicians, based on their treatment observations, are the principal bases for the following suggestions: Extrusion: Force =
(80
g/cm2)(occlusoapical
projection of root-surface area in cm2) Intrusion: Force =
(60
g/cm2)(occlusoapical
projection of root-surface area in cm2) Long-Axis Rotation: Couple =
(30
g/cm2)(occlusoapical
projection of root-surface area in cm2)(average crown width)
Several addenda to these formulas are pertinent: 1.
If the tooth is against the cortical plate during an attempted intrusive displacement, the applied force computed from the formula should be doubled.
2.
If a multirooted tooth is intruded, the magnitude of force obtained from the formula should be increased 50%.
3.
If long-axis rotation of a multirooted tooth is envisioned, the couple value calculated from the formula is multiplied by 1.5 if the tooth has
two roots or by 2.5 if the tooth has three roots. It is worth repeating that the foregoing formulas are all presented for computations of initial, intermittent crown loadings. If the crown force system is continuous with only a moderate decrease in magnitude during the between-appointments period, beyond that associated with the rapid, soft-tissue deformation, the initial magnitudes should be 50 to 60% less, depending on the amount of long-term decay. On the other
187
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
hand, the interrupted force that is cycled daily may have a magnitude
larger than that of the corresponding intermittent force due to (1) the increased frequency of rest periods and (2) the generally longer accumu-
lated lime of total absence of the interrupted force between appointments. A reasonable procedure is to make the magnitude of interrupted, orthodontic force the product of the corresponding, intermittent force and the ratio of 24 to the number of hours the interrupted force is active during the day. Implicit in the considerations of responsive forces arising from the application of crown loading is the existence at any specific time of the quasi-static state defined in Chapter 2. Hence, the resultant of the distributed force system exerted on the root of a tooth under orthodontic load is identical, for practical purposes of analysis, in all characteristics except sense to the resultant of the force system applied by the appliance to the crown. The appliance as well as the dentition exhibit this quasistatic state. The reaction against the appliance accompanying the action of the appliance is transmitted to the anchorage location(s). Focusing on the appliance momentarily, the force system exerted by the anchorage is equal in magnitude but opposite in sense to that exerted by the crown(s) at the displacement site(s). In general, "anchorage" refers to stability, and in orthodontics the anchorage supports the appliance, receiving the
responsive force system transmitted through the appliance to it. Although in orthodontic therapy the entire force system developed by the appliance is sometimes intended to produce displacements, more often a portion of the appliance is attached to anchorage which, by definition, is to be displaced very little or not at all. The rationale for the use of the extraoral appliance is the location of anchorage external to the oral cavity, against the back of the neck or the cranium. Intraoral anchorage is often necessary or desirable, and the knowledge of the influences of the various force parameters on orthodontic displacement have led to the differential force concept.
The actual meaning of
differential force,
not unrelated to the
hypothesis of a physiologically proper force, is best explained by an example. Consider the distal movement of a mandibular canine into the space created by the extraction of the formerly adjacent first premolar. Using intraoral mechanics exclusively, the distal driving force is created by extending a helical-coiled spring or an elastic module between the
canine and the first molar. The forces against the canine and molar, holding the activating appliance member in a stretched configuration, are equal in magnitude (from a quasi-static analysis of that member) and tend to move both teeth. The force against the molar, however, may be distributed also to the second molar (if "tied" to the first molar) or the second premolar (through crown contact). If the anchorage includes all three posterior teeth mentioned, from the projected areas given in Table 5-3, the anchorage area is approximately 250% larger than that of the canine. Accordingly, although the forces at the anchorage and displace-
ment sites are equal in magnitude, the average periodontal-ligament stress is 3.5 times greater at the canine. The size of the active force (upon
188
Bioengineering Analysis of Orfhodontic Mechanics
the
canine crown) should be just large enough to produce primarily
direct resorption of bone and a reasonable rate of canine movement. The same force magnitude, then, should not be sufficiently great to create adequate pressure to produce appreciable displacement of the anchorage during the between-appointments period. Note that if the active force is relatively large, so also is the responsive force, and both units may move comparable distances over time. Furthermore, extreme force magnitudes can result in displacement of the anchorage while, in effect, producing ankylosis of the canine. Refer-
ring once more to Table 5-1, noting that the distal forces for four movements were equal, changes in the couple-force ratio are seen to alter the maximum-stress values and the overall stress pattern with respect to a uniform distribution as a reference. Apparently, then, a uniform stress distribution is ideal for the anchorage, although it is difficult to obtain in the clinical setting. More realistically, the creation of a crown couple with the appliance to counter in sense the tipping potential of a force against anchorage is a step toward reinforcing that anchorage, beyond that achieved by maximizing the root area within the anchorage. The point is made, then, that the phrase differential force is a misnomer; the differentials are actually in the average stresses and/or the stress-distribution patterns within the ligament at the displacement and anchorage sites.
The parameters that influence the determination of the initial magnitude of a physiologically proper orthodontic force have been indicated in the foregoing discussion, and a set of formulas was given. Through the literature, additional terms have been introduced to describe or categorize forces exerted on the tooth crown. The lightest of these actions have been termed threshold forces, just large enough to result in some remodeling which permits measurable movement over a lengthy, perhaps unrestricted, period of time. Differentiation between "light" and "heavy"
orthodontic forces was undertaken previously. Upper-bound or maximum orthodontic forces produce ligament necrosis for a time, are likely to be initially painful to the patient, but result in tooth movement with no significant, long-term pathology. Forces are termed excessive if they crush the periodontal ligament over a substantial portion of the area under pressure, probably result in little or no tooth movement during a between-appointments period, and if continuous beyond several weeks may cause irreversible tissue damage. During the 1950s and 1960s research was undertaken toward determination of optimum-force magnitudes associated with specific, orthodontic displacements. Values were sought that would produce desired movements most rapidly and cause only minimal interference with normal biologic activity and patient discomfort. A principal motivator in these investigations was the solidification, through in vivo experimentation, of the validity of the differential-force concept. In the late 1960s, however, papers began to appear in the literature exhibiting research results that tended to discount an optimum-force theory. The influence
of the magnitude-time pattern on displacement achieved has been
-
189
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
a) Ca
a)
E
a)
0
Light force,,,1!'
/I'
/ /
Threshold force
\HeavY force
\ \ Excessive
\
force
\
As-Activated Force Magnitude FIGURE 5-27. Qualitative plot of expected, be!ween-appointments displacement versus the initial level of orthodontic force.
shown to be a significant factor in addition to parameters rightfully con-
sidered in the determination of the initial force values. Collectively, from
these efforts, the acceptance of the hypothesis of an existing range of orthodontic force magnitudes has emerged for each specific displacement, which produces no long-term physiologic conflict. The plot of initial force magnitude versus displacement rate of Figure 5-27 provides a qualitative illustration of the present understanding of expected results with a typical patient. Dento facial Orthopedics Although the typical displacements performed during orthodontic treatment are of individual teeth or dental-unit segments, the total therapy in a specific case may, in part, call for dentofacial orthopedics. Examples of orthopedic forces are those induced by an appliance designed to widen the
maxillary arch through palate splitting, to tip the maxilla (altering the angulation as seen in a buccal view), and to exert influence on the pat-
tern of growth of the mandible. The appliance may be intraoral or extraoral, but the applied force must always be distributed over a substantial area and, correspondingly, the magnitude of the total load is large. The load may or may not be transmitted through the dentition, but the biologic remodeling is not intended to be within alveolar bone; in general, relative displacements of adjacent teeth in the same arch are unwanted. In palate splitting, the intention is to induce transverse tension along
190
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
the median suture. The appliance used is totally intraoral, producing bilateral action with force transmitted at least partially through the posterior teeth and often, in part, by direct appliance contact with the hard
palate. That portion of the load imparted through the lingual crown surfaces must originate from an appliance element sufficiently rigid such
that the individual teeth are not displaced relative to their alveoli. Because remodeling is to occur in tensile zones, the magnitude of physiologically proper force is not directly associated with the suture-bone in-
terface area, but with the force-time pattern and the faciolingual projected areas of the tooth roots through which the force is to be transmitted. Because patient discomfort is often used as an indicator of sufficient or excessive activation-reactivation of the appliance, the appliance should be designed so that the pressure generated in those periodontal
ligaments, through which the active force system is transmitted, approaches a uniform distribution. In orthopedic action designed to tip the maxilla, at least a portion of the anchorage may be extraoral; the mandibular arch may also be used in the anchorage. Depending on whether vertical displacements are desired only anteriorly, only posteriorly, or divided between anterior and posterior locations, the vertical component(s) of the load are applied
anteriorly or posteriorly as individual forces, as equal and opposite forces at both locations to form a couple, or as unequal and opposite forces at both locations to generate a force-and-couple resultant. Heavy, continuous arch wires are in place to prevent individual tooth displacements. The desired remodeling is primarily along the zygomatic process; the stress distribution at that interface is nonuniform and the center of rotation for the maxilla as a whole will be located, anteroposteriorly, approximately directly below the point in a buccal view where the stress distribution, or its extension, goes to zero (or changes sense from tension to compression or vice versa). Figure 5-28 illustrates two forms of —
/
—
N
-
Fan
Resultant
HG: Headgear Ill: Class Ill 00: Occlusion II:
Class II
FIGURE 5-28. Tipping the maxilla to open the bite anteriorly (left) and to close an open bite primarily through posterior vertical action (right).
191
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
0 o
Solid: Appliance activated Dashed: Appliance disengaged
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I I
0
24
L 48
72
Time (hours)
FIGURE 5-29. The typical interrupted, force-time pattern of an extraoral appliance.
maxilla tipping. Note that horizontal (posteriorly directed) components
of force nearly always accompany the wanted vertical components, owing to the nature of the appliances. The magnitude of force applied should be gauged by imagining the maxilla as a single tooth with total length equal to the anteroposterior dimension. The tipping load is a force, a couple, or a force and couple, and the couple-force ratio for the desired displacement format may be estimated. Also note that the max-
illa is supported, in essence, only superiorly; as modeled as a large, individual tooth, then, it has only approximately one-half of the equiva-
lent periodontal support of a "tooth" with comparable support (root) surface.
To control mandibular growth downward and forward, orthopedic force may be applied by an extraoral appliance. The force is most often applied by a chin cap rather than through the mandibular dentition. The maximum levels of force used are governed by the acceptable pressures induced against the temporomandibular-joint members. In order that large forces may be employed, the force-time relationship is the typical interrupted pattern of extraoral appliances as depicted in Figure 5-29. This appliance is discussed in more detail in Chapter 9. -
Synopsis This chapter has endeavored to examine the biomechanical response of
the dentofacial complex, with emphasis on the dentition and its sup-
192
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
porting structures, to applied force during orthodontic treatment. The delivered force system, most often exerted through the facial crown surfaces, originating in the activation of an appliance, follows a discernible
path into and through the alveolar process and beyond. The presence of force within the tissues, augmenting the normal physiologic activity, catalyzes biologic processes that result in tissue remodeling, thus per-
mitting measurable displacements of teeth—individually or in segments—or of an entire arch. Eight distinct forms of orthodontic (individual-tooth) displacement have been defined. For each, the characteristics of the crown force system, the distributed responsive pattern of tension and pressure within
the periodontal ligament and against the root, and the displacement format, were discussed. Without becoming deeply involved in the physiology, the remodeling of the periodontal structures has been considered with emphasis on the role of induced internal-force intensity, in particular that of compressive stress (pressure). The movement of teeth by means of orthodontic therapy is known to be controlled by the forcetime pattern of the loading as well as the initial (as-activated) load characteristics; this pattern, in turn, is dependent on the structural properties of certain appliance elements and by the actual displacements that
occur. The seemingly closed loop notwithstanding, advancements through research are leading to the refinements of procedures to determine and apply physiologically proper ranges of orthodontic force. A "cookbook approach" to the quantification of initial levels of crown loading has been offered. The concepts of differential and optimum force were introduced and discussed briefly. Through the former, the term anchorage was defined. Some attention was given to the biomechamcal analysis of dentofacial orthopedic therapy. This chapter has provided descriptions of and guidelines for desirable characteristics of force systems delivered to the dentition in orthodontic treatment. These force systems are developed within and transmitted to the crowns by the orthodontic appliances. Beginning in the subsequent chapter and continuing throughout the remainder of this text, structural analyses of appliance elements are undertaken, individually and in relation to their roles in the appliance as a whole. The ultimate objective is the refinement and improvement of appliance designs toward devices that provide ideal magnitude-time patterns of orthodontic force at those locations where displacements are desired, while concurrently minimizing unwanted, secondary effects elsewhere.
References Burstone, C.J., Pryputniewicz, R.J., Bullock, C., and Hubert, M.: Centers of
rotation of the human maxillary central incisor. J. Dent. Res., 61 IADR Abstract 1095, 1982.
193
Response of Dentition and Periodontium to Force
Burstone, C.J., Pryputniewicz, R.J., and Weeks, R.: Center of resistance of the
human mandibular molar. J. Dent. Res., 60 IADR Abstract 822, 1981. Gianelly, A.A., and Goldman, H.M.: Biologic Basis of Orthodontics. Philadelphia, Lea & Febiger, 1971, Chapter 4. Nikolai, R.J.: On optimum orthodontic force theory as applied to canine retraclion. Am. J. Orthod., 68:290—302, 1975. Nikolai, Periodontal ligament reaction and displacement of a maxillary central incisor subjected to transverse crown loading. J. Biomech., 7:93—99, 1974.
Readings C.H., and Johnston, L.E.: A clinical investigation of the concepts of differential and optimal force in canine retraction. Angle Orthod., 44:113—
Boester,
119, 1974.
Burstone, C.J.: Application of bioengineering to clinical orthodontics. in Current Orthodontic Concepts and Techniques. 2nd Ed. Edited by T.M. Graber and B.F. Swain. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders, 1975, Chapter 3.
Burstone, C.J.: The biomechanics of tooth movement. in Vistas in Orthodontics. Edited by B.S. Kraus and R.A. Riedel. Philadelphia, Lea & Febiger, 1962, Chapter 5.
Burstone, C.J., Baldwin, J.J., and Lawless, D.T.: Application of continuous forces to orthodontics. Angle Orthod., 31:1—14,
1961.
Burstone, C.J., and Pryputniewicz, R.J.: Holographic determination of centers of rotation produced by orthodontic forces. Am. J. Orthod., 77:396—409, 1980. Graber, T.M.: Orthodontics, Principles and Practice, 3rd Ed. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders, 1972, Chapter 10. Jarabak, J.R., and Fizzell, J.A.: Techniques and Treatment with Light-wire Edgewise Appliances, 2nd Ed. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1972, Chapter 7.
Reitan, K.: Some factors determining the evaluation of forces in orthodontics. Am. J. Orthod., 43:32—45, 1957.
Reitan, K.: Bone formation and resorption during reversed tooth movement, in Vistas in Orthodontics. Edited by B.S. Kraus and R.A. Riedel. Philadelphia, Lea & Febiger, 1962, Chapter 3. Ricketts, R.M., et al.: Bioprogressive Therapy, Book 1. Denver, Rocky Mountain Orthodontics, 1979, Section 1, Part 6.
Smith, R.J., and Burstone, C.J.: Mechanics of tooth movement. Am. J. Orthod., 85:294—307, 1984.
Thurow, R.C.: Edgewise Orthodontics. 4th Ed. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1982, Chapters 10—12.
Thurow, R.C.: Atlas of Orthodontic Principles. 2nd Ed. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1977, Chapters 2, 14.
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
Beginning in this chapter and continuing throughout the remainder of
this text, force and structural analyses of orthodontic-appliance elements or members, and assemblies thereof, are undertaken. In the following discussions, the terminology and procedures used in structural analysis are introduced, and the orthodontic appliance is compared to the typical engineering structure. The manner of attachment of the appliance to the dentition is examined in detail, highlighting the associated force system and devoting particular attention to orthodontic brackets. The continuous-arch-wire appliance is then modeled to simplify a geo-
metrically and mechanically complex member for analysis purposes without altering its essential characteristics. A four-step analysis Focedure is introduced. The activation and deactivation behavior of several of the more common orthodontic-appliance elements is discussed. This chapter concludes with a section that examines the "control" of treatment progress and the roles therein of the appliance, the clinician, and the patient. A structure is an interconnected assembly of individual members; the assembly is designed to withstand without failure a specific loading and to transmit the force system induced by that loading into some foundation or supporting substructure. The load may be "dead" weight, some other static action, or it may be dynamic, varying characteristically with time. A "machine" may be distinguished from a structure. The typical structure is designed primarily to sustain a load and its principal components are usually stationary; a machine is designed primarily to transmit a force system from one site within the assembly—the input—to another— the output; moreover, the machine typically has movable parts. Buildings and bridges are familiar structures and a pair of pliers is an example 194
195
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
of a machine. Because both structures and machines include, when "in
service," members within which internal force systems exist, structuralanalysis procedures are as appropriate to machines as they are to structures. Each member of the assembly contributes toward the performance of
the desired function of the machine or structure. The loading of the structure or the input to the machine results in subjecting each element or member to a force system. The force system delivered to a specific member may be transmitted entirely through its connections to other members, or, it may result, in part, directly from external activation. Each member must be analyzed initially to determine the type of force system exerted on it and then the relationship of each component of that force system to the external load or input. After the external force system has been quantified, the internal force distribution throughout the volume of the member must be obtained toward consideration of possible failure of the member. Failure of a structural or machine member occurs when either stresses or deformations exceed their allowable values. Excessive stresses may result in outright fracture of the member or in drastic reduction of its ductility, for example. Excessive deformations may eliminate clearances that must exist or may result in structural instability or collapse of the structure. Stresses generally vary from point to point within the mem-
ber, and deformations ordinarily vary from one cross-section of the member to another; hence, the analysis is undertaken to determine not only the maximum values of stress and deformation, but also where within or along the member they occur. From the discussions within Chapter 3, the material and geometry (size and shape) of a structural or
machine member are known to influence, in addition to the applied force system, the induced stresses and deformations. The typical structural analysis proceeds according to one of two formats: 1.
-
Given the design or actual structure or machine and the failure criteria, to be obtained is the maximum allowable loading or input force system.
2. Given the design, the loading or input, and the possible modes of failure, computations are made to determine whether or not a failure might occur in the actual structure or machine. The analysis procedure follows a well-defined series of steps, regardless of the format. First, a force analysis is undertaken, for the structure or machine as a whole and for each member of the assembly, to obtain in terms of the loading or input the components of the force system exerted on the entire assembly and on each member at the connections. Newton's laws (Chap. 2) and the relationships governing continuity of displacements may be used to carry out this first step. Second, the failure criteria are established (fracture, excessive inelastic behavior, formation or extension of a crack, or deformation beyond established bounds) and
196
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
quantified for each member and for the structure as a whole. Each maxi-
mum permissible stress or deformation is modified in value by a "factor of safety" to account for inadequacies in the theory or model used in the
analysis. Third, "critical" cross-sections and locations of maximum stress therein are pinpointed within each member of the structure or machine. Fourth and finally, the stresses and deformations at the critical
locations are obtained in terms of the force system exerted, and are compared to the failure criteria as quantified to establish the structural integrity, or lack of it, of the assembly. A structural analysis of an existing structure or machine would be undertaken when a change in the loading or input force system is contemplated. Such an analysis would also be carried out as a primary facet in the preparation of a new design. The overriding design objective is always the creation of an assembly that is capable of sustaining, without
failure, the force system to be induced in it. Design constraints with regard to space, materials, and perhaps aesthetics may also require satisfaction. Several alternative designs may meet the principal design criteria, and one may have to be selected through secondary considerations
or judgmental factors. Often, after choosing one design from among those considered, further modification of it occurs that will not result in infringement on the failure criteria; excess material may be removed from regions of low stress, for example. In short, the preceding comments are intended to suggest that design and analysis are closely related.
The Orthodontic Appliance: A Structure or a Machine? The function of the orthodontic appliance is the application of specific
force-system components to selected intraoral sites to produce desired displacements of dental units. The appliance is similar to the typical structure or machine; forces exist at the connections of its elements and within its members when "in service," and it, therefore, may appropriately be subjected to structural analysis. The principal "loading" of the orthodontic appliance, however, is unlike that of a structure or machine; its load source is not an external force system (although the forces of occlusion or mastication may apply secondary, external loading). The "input" to the appliance is the deforming of it from its passive configuration to induce internal forces that are to be transmitted to the displace-
ment sites. The "output" is the force system delivered to the tooth crowns to produce selected movements of portions of the "foundation" to which the appliance is attached. In a strict sense, the action of the appliance is dynamic; most components of the internal force system decrease in magnitude with the passage of time in the activated state. This change is so gradual, however, and the masses of the appliance elements are so small, that analyses of the primary force system in the activated appliance may be undertaken
197
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
using static relationships with negligible error. Restricting attention only
to the generally quasi-static appliance system, failures might be assumed to occur immediately upon activation or not at all during the between-appointments period. Forces of occlusion, however, do provide real dynamic loading, superimposed on the appliance activation. Although this source of "load" is comparatively minor by itself, it can result in loss of structural integrity and failure with, for example, a frac-
ture within the bond between bracket pad and enamel surface. The "loading" of the removable appliance is dynamic when examined in the
context of a time frame of days or weeks, and progressive failure— resulting in the fracture of a wire component of a removable retainer—is not uncommon. Apparently required, then, is at least the direct incorporation in a static-appliance analysis of a factor of safety to account for the dynamic loads that may be intermittently applied to it.
The structural analysis of the ideal orthodontic appliance may be undertaken through a hypothetical design of the appliance. Principal design parameters include specific stiffnesses and elastic ranges of the members of the appliance to be activated. Generally, the activation is such that inelastic material behavior does not occur anywhere in the appliance; hence, maximum stresses may not exceed elastic-strength values. Also important are the appropriate member stiffnesses at anchorage locations, a somewhat subtle consideration to be taken up in later discussions of specific mechanics. The appliance design must con-
sider the possible paths of the force transmitted from the activation site(s) to the anchorage location(s), and the distribution of anchorage force. Pertinent in addition are the shape changes in the appliance and resulting alterations in the force system as deactivation due to tooth displacements takes place; not all of these changes in appliance configurations are mirror images of the activation deformations. And not to be overlooked, the materials of members must be chosen with full regard for the biologic environment in which they will be placed.
-
:achment of the Orthodontic Appliance to the Dentition intraoral orthodontic appliance is supported by the tooth crowns and its overall configuration is maintained through its connections to them. These connections also provide the final measure of continuity The
that permits the transfer of active force from the appliance to the teeth to generate the wanted displacements, regardless of the type of appliance. Although these connections may be made in a variety of ways, considering all phases, types, and philosophies of treatment, the most common is through the orthodontic bracket affixed to the facial or lingual surface of the tooth crown. The bracket as attached is meant to be integral with the crown; hence, it should exhibit high overall stiffness, although strength is more often the principal concern. Failures in bracket-to-crown attach-
ment may occur by fracture, either at or near the solid joint of the
198
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
bracket to its pad or to the band, or in the bond of the pad or band to the
crown enamel. The latter is more common. Attachment of the bracket assembly to the crown may be through cementation of the metal (stainless steel) band that encircles the crown or by bonding of the bracket pad to the facial or lingual surface. The merits or disadvantages of one scheme versus the other may be argued from several standpoints; however, of interest here is the structural comparison. The force system transferred from bracket to crown must travel through the cement or adhesive and the strength of the attachment depends on the size and shape of the attachment area, the characteristics of the force system transferred through it, and the inherent unit strength of the cement or adhesive itself (internally, between it and the band or pad, and its attachment to the enamel). The cement or adhesive may be stressed in many directions because of the various force-system components that may be present—individually and in combinations. In addition, tensile and sheat strengths differ for a specific product and between products. A detailed comparison would, therefore, be lengthy and inappropriate here; however, two general comments are pertinent. First, the bonding area of the band is at least double that of the typical bracket pad; hence, the inherent strengths of the bonding adhesives must be substantially greater than those of band cements. Second, the more nearly uniform the stress distribution within the adhesive, the stronger the bond; accordingly, failures of bonds of pads to enamel surfaces are more likely under loadings that tend to produce "peeling" (from first- or third-order couples or from occlusogingival or mesiodistal forces that have a moment arm with respect to the adhesive) or rotation (from second-order couples) than when the force system is direct tension, shear, or compression. The bracket-band and bracket-pad assemblies are compared pictorially in Figure 6-1 as to stress generation within the bond resulting from the application of a facially directed force. Although the uniform stress distribution is desirable, the average intensity is less within the band cement because of the greater area of attachment. Note also that a failure within the band cement will not result in complete disruption of the force-transmission path for the particular loading shown. Figure 6-2 illustrates several other simple force systems against the bonded bracketpad assembly and the resulting stress distributions within the adhesive.
F,
stress
tensile stress stress
FIGURE 6-1. Applied and responsive force systems exerted on bracket-pad (left) and bracket-band (right) assemblies.
199
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
Fa
tension
F,
compressive stress
compression
shear
FIGURE 6-2. Force systems exerted on the bonded-bracket-pad assembly as loaded by lingually directed compression (left), shear-peeling (center), and a pure couple (right).
Although brackets transmit the bulk of orthodontic force to tooth crowns, other means are also in common use. Buccal tubes are often
attached, in place of brackets, to terminal molar crowns. Buttons, eyelets, and staples are often affixed either to the band or bonded directly to the crown surface. They may be located either mesial to distal with respect
to the bracket on the facial surface, on the lingual crown surface, or, if space permits, on the mesial or distal crown surfaces. Most commonly, a ligature tie or an elastic is activated against the button or eyelet to create a moment about the long axis of the tooth as shown in Figure 6-3. Other orthodontic appliance elements may transfer force to the lingual crown surface. A transpalatal bar may be used to deliver buccolingual force or tipping (torquing) couples bilaterally, for example. Labiolingual treatment therapy divides the transmission of force from the appliance to the dentition between the facial and lingual crown surfaces in order that mesiodistal displacements might be accomplished without the tendency for long-axis rotation. Removable-appliance therapy may make no use of brackets at all. Lateral force generation must then be accomplished by Arch wire
/
I
P
Button
= P(e)
FIGURE 6-3. An elastic extended between a button and the arch wire to generate a moment about the long axis of the tooth (occiusal views).
200
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
(
0
cc
•
I )
C1=Q(e)
FIGURE 6-4. Occlusal views of a distal driving force exerted on the canine bracket (left) and the equivalent force system referred to point CC (right).
pushing, and both facial and lingual surfaces are contacted by elements
of the appliance. Accessibility contributes heavily to the rationale for placing the orthodontic bracket on the facial surface. Often resulting, however, is the eccentric transfer of at least a portion of the appliance force system, as noted in Chapter 5. Because the center of resistance is unreachable directly, the next most favorable reference point is on the long axis of the tooth and occiusoapically at bracket level (point CC in the local reference frame introduced in Chap. 5). Although through the bracket, labiolingual force and any couple may be effectively applied at point CC, mesiodistal and occiusogingival forces may not. These two components of force, commonly existing in the activated appliance, because their lines of action are in excess of one-half of the faciolingual crown width from point CC, embody sizable rotational potentials often undesired. Figure 6-4 (similar to Figure 2-17) presents occlusal views of a distal driving force delivered to the canine bracket and the equivalent force system at point CC. The couple (right) embodies the rotational tendency of the force Q applied to the bracket; if the rotation is unwanted, an
equal but opposite (in sense) first-order couple must be generated within the arch-wire-to-bracket force system or by means of some other appliance-to-crown contact (through an eyelet- or button-to-arch-wire ligation, for example). On the other hand, distolingual rotation of the
canine can be accomplished by using the distal driving force and a mesially directed force applied through point CC, the latter created through crown contact with the adjacent premolar; this force system is presented in Figure 6-5. An occlusogingival force at the bracket tends to 0
d
m
FIGURE 6-5. Occlusal view of a pair of forces acting on the canine crown as a couple capable of producing distolingual rotation.
201
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
extrude and tip the crown lingually or intrude and produce facial crown
Upping, depending on the sense of the force. Countering an unwanted rotational potential is often attempted through placement of an active, third-order twist in an engaged, rectangular wire. Figure 6-6 illustrates the problem in attempting pure extrusion and the ideal elimination of the accompanying Upping potential. (Alternatively, if lingual crown Upping without extrusion is desired, it may be obtained through the sole application of a third-order torque having the appropriate sense or with a lingually directed force applied through point CC. The slight difference in the two displacements, in terms of the locations of the centers of rotation, was discussed in Chapter 5.) The force system carried to the orthodontic bracket from the appliance activation site(s) is transmitted primarily by the arch wire. The bracket is designed principally to accommodate the arch wire and the ligation completes the engaged confinement of that wire. Figure 6-7 (left) presents a view of the ordinary edgewise bracket from a mesial or distal
perspective. The faciolingual and occlusogingival dimensions of the bracket slot admit a range of cross-sectional sizes of round and rectangular wire. The "wings" occlusal and gingival of the slot provide support
F0
F0
C3 = Fje)
Initial position: dashed
FIGURE 6-6. Extrusive displacements: with tipping, achieved with a force located oft of the long axis (left) and with a force and couple having their resultant along the long axis of the incisor (right).
202
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
/Pad d
Base
FIGURE 6-7. The typical edgewise bracket: mesiodistal view (left) and facial view (right).
for the ligature tie or elastic "0-ring" which, when in place, closes the
slot. (Pins, clasps, cams, and "locks" provide resistance to arch-wire disengagement within other types of bracket assemblies.) The faciolingual dimension from the lingual surface of the slot to the lingual extent of the bracket itself is as small as strength and stiffness demands will allow to minimize the distance from arch wire to the long axis (although this "concept" is exchanged in straight-wire-therapy appliances for offsets built into the brackets). Figure 6-7 (right) illustrates a facial view of the typical bracket. Edgewise brackets are classified by occiusogingival slot dimension, by mesiodistal width, and by the absence or presence of a vertical slot ("single" versus "twin"). Irrespective of slot size, the four common bracket designations are: narrow-single, wide-single, narrowtwin, and wide-twin (in order of increasing mesiodistal bracket width). Bracket materials must be strong, stiff, and, true of all intraoral appliance elements, chemically enert in the oral environment. The so-called "universal" bracket design enables the transfer from the arch wire of all six possible components of the force system carried by the wire to it. The occlusogingival and faciolingual components of concentrated force are transferred by direct contact of wire and slot or
ligation as viewed from the mesial or distal. Note that the facially directed force from the wire pushes against the ligation, which may be less
stiff and have less strength than the bracket slot itself. Ordinarily, the arch wire may be able to slide mesiodistally through the bracket slot, depending on the wire-to-slot clearance and the type and tightness of ligation. The transfer of the mesiodistal force component generally does not rely upon friction; instead, it depends more positively on a stop affixed to the arch wire or a ioop placed in the wire. The stop or loop may make mesiodistal contact with a bracket, creating an action-reaction pair of "push" forces, or force may be transferred between the loop and the bracket by a simple auxiliary element capable of carrying tension (a fled length of ligature wire, for example). Typical transfers of the three force components between arch wire and bracket are illustrated in Figure 6-8. The capability of the arch wire to effectively transfer first- and sec-
ond-order couples through the bracket and into the tooth crown is related directly to the mesiodistal bracket width. Each couple consists of a pair of forces generated through wire-to-bracket contact at the mesial
203
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
FIGURE 6-8. Transfers of concentrated force components from arch wire to bracket: occiusogingival (left), faciolingual and lingually directed (center), and mesiodistal (right).
and distal extents of the bracket. As illustrated in Figure 6-9, and re-
called from discussions in Chapter 2, the couple magnitude depends on force size and the shortest distance between the lines of action of the forces. Accordingly, the potential couple size increases with the mesiodistal bracket width. The clearance between arch wire and slot is also a factor, which is discussed further in Chapter 7. In the generation of a first-order couple, one of the forces arises from contact between wire and ligation; hence, if the ligation has low stiffness, the capacity to transfer this couple through the connection of arch wire to bracket is substantially impaired. Accordingly, several alternative means of applying a first-order couple or moment to the crown have been developed and three are examined in Chapter 10. A third-order couple may be transferred by a straight, round wire to the bracket only by friction, but two more positive mechanisms are available to apply the third-order couple to the tooth crown. A rectangular arch wire, having a diagonal cross-sectional dimension greater than the
occiusogingival width of the bracket slot, may transfer this couple through two-edge contact within the slot. (The bracket slot must be stiff enough not to "open" under this loading to the extent that the wire may spin within it.) The distance between the two forces forming the couple, then, is smaller than the diagonal dimension of the wire cross-section. Arch wire
Bracket pad
Wing
Ligation
FIGURE 6-9. Bending couples transferred from arch wire to bracket-ligation system: first-order couple (left), and second-order couple (right).
204
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
An alternative procedure is to loop the round arch wire passing through the bracket such that, as activated, two-point contact is made against (1) the ligation closing the bracket slot and (2) the crown occiusal or gingival
to the slot (depending on the desired sense of the couple). The perpendicular distance between the forces is substantially greater than that of the rectangular-wire procedure, but one of the forces pushes against the ligation and, in the absence of an accompanying lingual driving or holding force, demands at least a moderately stiff and strong closure of the bracket slot. Figure 6-10 depicts the transfer of a third-order couple from arch wire to crown using the two mechanisms just described. More detailed discussions of arch-wire torsion are contained in Chapter 8. Orthodontic force may be transmitted to the bracket other than from the arch wire. Typically, coiled springs or "elastics" are used to produce mesiodistal driving forces within one arch against individual teeth. Because of their small cross-sectional sizes and relatively high flexibilities, "elastics" are most commonly used to transfer interarch force. Various auxiliaries may be engaged and activated against individual brackets; generally, such devices are anchored in some fashion adjacent to the tooth that is to receive the active force. These auxiliaries are discussed later in this chapter and in Chapter 10.
The partial connection of the appliance to the dentition, and the transfer of some orthodontic force, may be other than through the orthodontic bracket. Although similar to the bracket and, like it, transferring force directly to a crown through a bonded base or band, the buccal tube
Q
II I
P
I
Torquing loop
I
Facial surface
I
I I
I
I
I
FIGURE 6-10. Transfers of third-order couples from arch wire to crown: by a rectangular wire to the bracket (left) and by a ligated looped round wire (right).
205
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
special characteristics. Generally affixed to the terminal molars in one or both arches, the buccal tube is open only at its mesial and distal ends and, therefore, transmits buccally directed force from a wire just as well as lingually directed or occlusogingival force. Its mesiodistal dimension is greater than that of the widest brackets; hence, the tube may more effectively transfer first- and second-order couples. Buccal tubes are also made to accommodate the "inner arms" of the face bow, a principal element of a class of extraoral appliances (discussed in Chap. 9). Connections of appliance elements may avoid the bracket or buccal tube entirely and transfer force to the crown directly. Examples already mentioned include the button, eyelet, and staple against which elastics or ligature-wire ties may be activated, and the attachments for lingually affixed appliance elements. Forces may also be delivered first to the arch possesses
wire, and then carried by it to the brackets, buccal tubes, and to the tooth crowns. Because such forces nearly always have mesiodistal com-
ponents, delivery demands rigid attachment of spurs or hooks to, or loops bent into, the arch wire. Typical carriers of such force include the interarch elastic and the J-hook, the latter an extraoral-appliance element.
A
Continuous-Arch-Wire Appliance Model continuous arch wire is a curved structural member, typically extending from terminal molar to terminal molar, and as engaged and activated it generally contacts through brackets and buccal tubes six or more—often at least ten—tooth crowns. At each primary connection site, where arch wire and bracket or tube make physical contact, as The
many as six independent components of a transmitted force system may exist. Although an essentially static analysis may be undertaken, there M no externally applied loading and all components of force are generated through deformations of appliance members occurring in the engagement-activation process. In short, the analysis of a highly indeterminate, geometrically complex structure is required if the force system and the structural characteristics of the wire are to be examined in detail. The task is formidable for the highly skilled structural analyst having sophisticated computer assistance, and is not a problem to be undertaken by the orthodontist. The clinician should be capable, however, of pursuing an approximate analysis that includes the principal features of the activated arch wire or appliance. To this end a model of the continuous arch wire is now proposed and developed. The ideal arch is geometrically symmetric with respect to the midsagittal plane. Often, this symmetry exists in the arch exhibiting a malocclusion, and thereby demands bilateral treatment mechanics. The concur-
rent presence of symmetry in both the dentition and the appliance as activated allows an analysis involving just one-half (the left or right half)
of the orthodontic mechanism. Such an analysis requires a figurative
206
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
s(uperior)
C
F,
Ft
Arch wire— i(riferior)
L FIGURE 6-1 1. Components of the force system in the arch wire transferred across the midsagittal plane in the presence of symmetry: occkisal view (left) and coronal view (right). Either sense of each component can exist.
"cut" through all portions of the appliance that span the midsagittal plane. In many instances only the arch wire must be "cut," and the symmetry demands that, of the six force-system components that could, in general, be transmitted across the plane, only the three shown in the sketches of Figure 6-11 may possibly be nonzero. Any analysis model should take advantage of midsagittal-plane symmetry when the geometry and force system permit it. Various phases of orthodontic therapy often treat groups of teeth as if each group is an individual entity, either in the application of force to produce wanted displacement (in the retraction of an anterior segment, for instance) or in arranging anchorage (in intraoral, canine-retraction mechanics, for example). In portions of orthodontic treatment, the adjacent central and lateral incisors may be considered as a single unit, and so also may the second premolar, the first molar, and possibly the first premolar (if not extracted) and the second molar (if fully erupted and aligned). Such segmentation can substantially simplify analyses, particularly in the presence of midsagittal-plane symmetry. Two distinct curvatures generally exist in the dental arch—that of the anterior portion as observed from an occlusal perspective and the anteroposterior curvature as seen in a buccal view, the latter often termed the "curve of Spee." In the analyses of many orthodontic procedures, the effects of the curvature of the anterior segment may be suppressed without significantly violating the overall structural integrity of the appliance; such suppression serygs to simplify the geometric aspects of the problem. With the exception of analyses of anteroposterior leveling mechanics, the effects of the curve of Spee often may also be neglected. Furthermore, localized first- or second-order bends, although their ef-
207
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
S
p
-1--I
a
/
Actual arch form: dashed
FIGURE 6-12. 0cc/usa! and bucca/ views of the continuous arch-wire model.
if active or stabilizing may be prominent and, therefore, must generally be included, need not be shown explicitly in sketches of the arch wire to be analyzed; the same may be said of third-order twists and of the details of arch-wire loops. Often, then, the overall shape of the contirtuous arch wire may be modeled as shown in Figure 6-12, consisting of three solidly connected, straight-section segments. The central and lateral incisors would always engage the middle (anterior) segment. First premolars (if present) and dental units distal to them would contact the posterior segments of the arch-wire model. The canines would generally fects
be located at the anterior extremities of the posterior segments, but, more appropriately, in nonextraction therapy, they may be part of the anterior or middle segment of the model. Although each arch-wire or appliance analysis is, in reality, threedimensional in general character, the best approach is often through the use of several plane views that are commensurate with the component forces and couples already mentioned. Perhaps the most useful view, particularly with midsagittal-plane symmetry, is that from a buccal perspective. Explicit in this plane are anteroposterior (labiolingual in the anterior segment, mesiodistal in the posterior segments) and occlusogingival components of force, third-order couples in the anterior segment, and second-order couples in the posterior segments. Practically
any analysis of mechanics intending to produce anteroposterior displacements will necessitate a buccal-view evaluation. Anteroposterior movement may also be examined in an occlusal-plane view, but the particular value in this plane analysis is in evaluating mechanics designed to produce mesiodistal displacements in the anterior segment and buccolingual movements in the posterior segments. The force-system components between arch wire and crowns apand faciolingual pearing in the occiusal view include components of force and first-order Anteroposterior or lateral appliance, differences in the action of an asymmetric left side versus right side, may be viewed from the occlusal perspective. An analysis in the coronal plane, from an anterior or posterior view, is
208
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
used less frequently. The coronal-plane perspective is helpful, however,
in studying anterior-segment consolidation, third-order torque in the buccal segments, and the transpalatal bar, for example, or in examining occlusogingival actions, left versus right side, in asymmetric situations. Occlusogingival forces, mesiodistal forces, and second-order couples in the anterior segment, and buccolingual forces and third-order couples in the posterior segment, appear in the transverse-plane view.
An Overview of the Structural Analysis of an Orthodontic Appliance The complexity of an orthodontic-appliance analysis increases with the
number of teeth to which the appliance is attached, when those teeth are directly involved in attempting the desired displacement pattern. The movements of an individual tooth, with the appliance activated to extrude or intrude it, tip or torque it, or correct a rotation, all may make use of practically an entire arch for anchorage and often are not strongly
dependent on the overall geometry of the continuous arch wire and dentition. These analyses are not initiated here, but will be discussed subsequently. The more immediate objective is to introduce and outline the structural-analysis procedure for those mechanics that involve the whole of the appliance attached to a dental arch or make use of appliances in both arches andlor an extraoral appliance. Indeed, the problem requires a careful examination of the actions, responses, and displacement potentials throughout the dentition as a whole and of the structure affixed to it. To begin the analysis, a peripheral examination of the active configu-
ration versus the passive shape of the appliance as a whole must be made. Note specifically the numbers and positions of the individual teeth to which the appliance is engaged. At each bracket or buccal tube where contact exists, the active or passive nature of the connection, with respect to each of the six individual components of the most general force system, is examined. Often, several components are zero at a contact location and in many instances only one component is nonzero, at least until a displacement occurs that may activate one or more additional components. In all but the simplest analyses, some modeling is generally warranted in accordance with the guidelines of the previous section. If the individual activation displacements and force systems associated with adjacent teeth are similar, the dental segment so identified may be treated in the analysis as a single entity. If one or more of the arch-wire curvatures are not relevant to the analysis, they may be neglected in formulating the model. Note that after the modeling to simplify the analysis procedures has been undertaken, the model must be carefully scrutinized regarding its propriety, not only at the instant of activation, but also as to its continued validity throughout the days or weeks during which displacements of teeth and corresponding changes in the activated-appliance configuration are occurring. After the model
209
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
formulated and found acceptable, the next steps are to check for the presence or absence of midsagittal-plane symmetry and to determine the number of necessary plane views together with the specific views to be employed. The entire appliance assembly, in general, is a combination of the intraoral appliances contacting the individual (maxillary and mandibular) dental arches, any interarch attachments, and, if used, the extraoral appliance. Each of the existing subassemblies, considering prior modeling, is separated from the others and the dentition, and is isolated; using the necessary plane views, the force system exerted on each subassembly is sketched. Included are all components arising from appliancecrown contacts, intraoral forces associated with interarch interconneclions, and force systems created through the activation of "headgear." The directions of concentrated forces and dimensions or distances that may be needed as moment arms are also shown in these sketches. Next, is
the transmission of force through the appliance members is qualitatively traced from the location(s) of principal activation(s) to (1) the sites of wanted displacements and (2), if existing, the appliance-crown conneclions and any other contact locations intended to experience little or no
movement during the between-appointments period. If no anchorage exists, the activation sites and the force system against the appliance will be divided (halved) on either side of a plane of symmetry; in the majority of such instances the activation is bilateral with symmetry with respect to the midsagittal plane. The transmission of force is then followed from the activation locations on either side of the plane to the plane of
symmetry itself, where action-reaction matching of the force-system components is carried out. The total number of force and couple components, exerted on the complete appliance assembly, may now be deter-
mined. From discussions in Chapter 2, in each plane view a total of three, scalar, force- and moment-balance relationships are available from Newton's laws and the concept of the quasi-static state of the appliance. The number of force and couple components to be quantified will exceed the number of quasi-static, balance equations by the number of needed "load" versus deformation relationships associated with the activation of the appliance. The complete analysis will likely require a disassembly of the appliances "on paper," separating the auxiliaries from the arch wires, and an examination of each appliance member in a manner similar to that previously described for the principal appliance subassemblies. This detailing will "expose" the force systems that exist at the sites of interconnections between appliance members, and these systems are interrelated in pairs through Newton's law of action and reaction. Each member of the appliance assembly may be placed in one of two categories: (1) those members that are physically deformed from their passive states to achieve the activation of the assembly as a whole; and (2) those members in which force systems arise in response to the activation. For the members in the first category, if the entire force system external to and within the appli-
ance assembly is to be quantified, the amounts of activating displace-
210
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
ment-deformation must be measurable and the load-deformation rela-
tionships must be known. The structural analysis of an orthodontic appliante is accomplished in two principal, sequential parts. First, all of the forces and couples acting on the appliance as a whole and on each appliance member at the interconnections are determined. This procedure, described in a general manner previously, requires the use of force- and moment-balance equations and load-deformation relationships. If the purpose is only to obtain the force systems delivered to anchorage sites, to decide whether or not anchorage reinforcement is advisable, for example, then the analysis may be terminated following the completion of the first portion. The second part of the analysis examines each appliance member internally.
For each, the critical sections and points thereon are located and, as potential sites for initiation of structural failure, are checked for stress levels and amounts of deformation. These stresses and deformations are determined from geometry and material characteristics of the individual
member and the force system exerted on it, and may then be related back to the parameters of the activation itself. This second portion of the analysis may be undertaken for one of several reasons:
1. A failure may have occurred and the need exists to make some modification of the appliance or in the activation of it. 2. Under consideration is the possibility of replacing one or more mem-
bers of the appliance or altering the character of the activation to modify the response, and the structural integrity of the appliance under the new conditions is to be examined. 3. An entirely new design is contemplated, including the shapes and sizes of the appliance members and their materials, with selections to be based in large part on allowable stresses and deformations as related to those that will be generated in the new appliance.
The complete structural analysis of the orthodontic appliance incorporating a continuous arch wire can be a complex undertaking as previously noted. The foregoing, general approach to the process as carefully outlined partially attests to the magnitude of the task. With appropriate modeling, however, and with the knowledge to be gained in the remainder of this chapter and those to follow, the clinician will be able to incorporate the principal features of an appliance in a reasonably straightforward analysis procedure. To this end, the foregoing discussion might be condensed into the organized, four-step process suggested here:
1. Knowing the specific displacement(s) desired, both in form and extent, the individual components of the total force system acting on the dentition, which should produce those displacements, are identi-
fied together with any components present to control the movements.
2. One or more free-body diagrams of the orthodontic appliance as a
whole, and subassemblies and individual elements thereof as
211
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
are sketched. These diagrams include the action-reaction counterparts of the components identified in step 1. The entire force system exhibited in each diagram is investigated through Newton's laws (action-reaction and the force and moment balances). needed,
3. With the aid of the results of step 2 and, once more, using the actionreaction law, the force system(s) transmitted to the responsive locations (anchorage) are evaluated to determine what, if any, unwanted displacements might occur. Stress and deformation computations for individual appliance members may also be undertaken if a possible, structural failure is of concern.
4. As warranted from the results of step 3, appropriate precautions or alterations should be considered and undertaken to minimize any potential, undesired "side effects" of the appliance objective. Such action could involve, for example, reductions in induced force magni-
tudes, making member substitutions in or additions to the existing appliance, or altering parameters intended to control the orthodontic displacements.
The Activation and Deactivation Characteristics of Representative Appliance Elements The completion of the first portion of the structural analysis of an ortho-
dontic appliance initially requires the quantification of the forces and couples induced in those auxiliary elements or at the individual, specific locations along the arch wire where mechanical work is done by the clinician on the appliance to achieve activation. Examples of this work are the compressing of a spring, the stretching of an elastic, and the deflecting of an arch wire to gain bracket engagement. The work of activation is usually concentrated at only a few locations, properly termed activation sites, and at each site knowledge of the amount of localized deformation and the associated element or wire stiffness enable the determination of the induced force system. A subsequent force-system
analysis, assuming that all of the dentition to which the appliance is affixed behaves like a rigid foundation or support-base, is sufficient to approximate the initial magnitudes of the responsive forces throughout the dentition. Although somewhat idealized, such an analysis of the appliance is appropriate because a state of maximum, overall internal loading and deformation exists under the assumption of a rigid dentition and periodontium. The soft-tissue deformations, which in reality permit some immediate tooth movement following activation, serve to partially "relieve" the appliance, releasing a portion of the strain energy induced by the mechanical work of activation and, thereby, reducing the stresses and deformations from their maximum values. As time proceeds following acti-
212
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
vation and stage 1 of tooth movement (defined in Chap. 5), additional
deactivation will likely occur during the between-appointments period with stage 3 displacements. Although some of these movements may serve to generate force systems at locations that were passive when the appliance was initially engaged (the guiding arch wire attempting to keep a canine upright during retraction, for example), this work is accompanied by a transfer of strain energy from one location to another within the appliance. Overall, stage 3 displacements result in a net, continuing decrease in strain-energy level, stresses, and deformations in and of the appliance with respect to the as-initially-activated state. The orthodontist may disengage the appliance before complete deactivation occurs as a result of tooth movement or possible relaxation of some appliance elements. If the unloaded configuration of the appliance is not identical to the original passive configuration, signaled are energy losses, energy transfers other than to the dentition in producing displacements or to the clinician in the unloading process, or increases in unavailable, stored energy in the appliance resulting from exceeding the elastic limit somewhere during activation. Inelastic behavior may be reflected in the metallic appliance members and relaxation in the nonmetallic members. Although the configuration change following a load-unload cycle is more often the rule than the exception, of at least equal and probably of more importance is the fact that the induced increment of strain energy of activation generally cannot be completely controlled with respect to the subsequent work done by the appliance in moving teeth. With the influence of the clinician removed as soon as activation is complete, the appliance will seek to take on a minimum-energy configuration. The added strain energy, transferred to the appliance at the activa-
tion site(s), is immediately distributed throughout the appliance such that the assembly as a whole assumes the deformed configuration characteristic of the lowest energy level possible, consistent with the constraints to which it is subjected. Moreover, with every small tooth dis-
placement that takes place, the appliance adjusts itself to a new, minimum-energy configuration. The ideal appliance, then, is one that most nearly permits the orthodontist complete control over the manner in which the strain-energy input of activation will be distributed and dissipated over time. The first individual orthodontic element to be discussed is not part of an appliance at all, and is used before brackets are affixed and only when and where interproximal space is to be created to accommodate the placement of bands. These "spacers" are small polymeric rings or discs, placed interproximally adjacent to gingival margins, and are "loaded" or activated, in their placements, in direct compression. Figure 6-13 shows a free-body diagram of the activated spacer and the actionreaction, counterpart forces exerted upon the adjacent teeth. Compliance with Newton's laws requires that all four forces shown be equal in magnitude. This magnitude at the time of activation is determined by the amount of deformation of the spacer required to place it and the
213
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
Passive
fl
F4
F4
spacer (representation)
F3
F3
(F3=F4) FIGURE 6-13. The spacer unloaded and activated in direct compression (center) and the adjacent teeth subjected to spacer action (facial views).
load-deformation relationship for the element. Typically, the average
stiffness of a spacer in compression is moderate with the cross-section in the mesiodistal plane (as activated) sizable compared to its dimension in the direction of loading. The width of the ordinary orthodontic band is, however, only a fraction of the periodontal-ligament width at the gingival margin and, as a result, the ligament need not be fully compressed by this loading to create the needed space. Because the forces exerted by
the spacer on the two teeth will be of equal magnitude throughout the active period, the absolute displacements of the individual dental units will be controlled by the resistance of each tooth to movement, either inherent (projected root surface area, crown contacts along the dental arch) or created artificially through an anchoring of one tooth or the other in an attempt to limit the movement to just one unit. Helical-coiled springs may be used as auxiliary elements of both intraoral and extraoral orthodontic appliances. Typically activated by a force applied along the axis of the spring at one end and supported at the other, the member may be loaded in either direct tension or direct compression. Regardless of the sense of the applied force, neglecting its weight compared to contact forces generally makes the spring, like the spacer, a two-force member. Helical springs, to be activated in tension, are usually "wound" (fabricated) to assume a closed-coil, passive configuration while compression springs must exhibit an open-coil (space-between-coils), passive state. Tension springs may be activated (stretched) almost indefinitely and are inherently stable when loaded; however, an elastic limit does exist as the activation actually produces a rather uni-
form bending deformation of the coiled wire. On the other hand, the compression spring can be deformed only until all coils contact one another; this spring is ordinarily designed such that the closed-coil state is achieved with a force producing maximum stresses less than the elasticlimit stress of the spring material. Of some concern must be the stability
of an activated compression spring in the absence of lateral support potential and, to guard against the possibility of lateral buckling (uncon-
214
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
a,
0
0
Deformation
FC
FIGURE 6-14. Helical tension and compression springs (left and center); typical loaddeformation diagram for the linear spring (right).
trolled, large deformation), this spring as an appliance element is usu-
ally wound around the arch wire. The majority of metallic, helical springs are termed "linear" in that they exhibit straight-line load-deformation behavior beneath the elastic limit. The structural properties of a helical spring are primarily dependent on the spring material, the wire cross-section, the coil diameter, and the passive length. Helical springs in tension and compression are shown schematically in Figure 6-14. A typical load-versus-deformation plot for a linear spring is also presented (similar to Fig. 4-9). Given the plot for a specific spring, a measurement of its axial deformation from the passive state provides the magnitude of force at its ends. Figure 6-15 shows a free-body diagram of a compression spring wound around an 0
a,
P
FIGURE 6-15. A helical compression spring making lateral contact with the arch wire about which it is wound, midway between the spring ends.
215
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
arch wire, as activated and making lateral contact with the wire midway
between the ends of the spring. A force balance indicates that the end forces have vertical components that must sum to the force of the arch wire against the spring coils. The lateral forces arise if the spring tends to
buckle laterally or if the section of arch wire, over which the spring is wound, is curved. (An available spring assembly of interest is activated by a pulling force against its "jacket" and an axial wire transferring force from an end coil; the axial wire passes through the spring body. This element exhibits favorable characteristics of both standard tension and compression springs; it is loaded in tension, but activation actually compresses the spring. Accordingly, the assembly incorporates the closedcoil "guard" against exceeding the elastic limit and the axial wire and jacket prevent buckling.) To activate a pulling force in a specific direction within the orthodontic appliance, or to transmit a tensile force from one site to another, an elastic may be used in place of the tension spring. The popularity of the elastic, generally descriptive of the array of bands, 0-rings, modules, chains, and threads of rubber or rubberlike polymeric materials, is associated with its favorable characteristics of high flexibility, small crosssectional dimensions, and low cost. Free-body diagrams of the elastic band (or ring or the looped and tied thread) and the module, loaded in direct tension, are shown in Figure 6-16. A typical load-deformation plot, similar to a portion of Figure 3-11, is also presented. An undesirable feature of the elastic, associated with many polymeric materials, is the tendency toward relaxation. Defined in Chapter 4, the result of reP
Q
a)
0
Elastic module
Elastic band
0 P
Elongation
FIGURE 6-16. An elastic band or looped thread (left) and an elastic module or chain (center) subjected to two-point tension, and an example load-deformation diagram (right).
216
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
laxation is the loss of force magnitude with lime under condilions of constant stretch (strain). Figure 6-17 is a four-part plot for an elaslic showing (1) inilial activalion, (2) maintenance of constant strain for a finite lime period, (3) rather rapid unloading to a stress-free state, and (4) recovery in the absence of
reacivalion. Notable in parlicular is the fourth segment of the plot which indicates that, for some polymers and given sufficient lime, the original passive configuration may be nearly, if not totally, regained if the elaslic limit of the material was not exceeded during activation. (As noted in Chapter 4, these elements are termed elastics, partly because of their sizable elaslic ranges. Strictly speaking, though, the materials are
quite brittle with measurable elongations to failure by rupture not sizably beyond the elastic-limit, extensional deformalions.) Although several comparable characteristics already menlioned suggest preference for the elaslic over the tension spring, a noteworthy advantage of the metallic spring is the virtual absence of lime-dependence in its structural properties. Convenient to transmit tensile force, when moderately high, extensional sliffness is desired, is the looped and lied (twisted, "pig—tailed") length of ligature wire. The ductility of this wire is substantial and the elaslic strength of the "dead soft" material is quite low; this combinalion permits the procedure. Figure 6-18 qualitalively compares the tensile stress-strain behavior of the annealed (as-received), stainlesssteel ligature wire with the same wire material having average resilience.
a)
C
0
U-
I loading
0
relaxation
Elongation
FIGURE 6-17. A four-part hysteresis diagram for an 'elastic" appliance element
217
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
C))
C')
C)
C') C)
0)
C
Strain-hardened wire
Annealed wire
0
Tensile Strain
FIGURE 6-18. Tensile stress-strain diagrams tor annealed and resilient stainless-steel wires having identical cross-sections.
Note that the tying process inelastically deforms the wire, adding to the
strain energy stored locally in the wire; each twist reduces the ductility and the effective deformation to fracture. If the number of twists are excessive and this cold-working process itself does not cause fracture, a small additional load superimposed upon the activated ligation, in overall appliance activation or later from mastication, for example, might cause the ligature to rupture. The longitudinal flexibility of the ligature tie is practically nonexistent, despite its small cross-section; the elastic modulus of its material, generally stainless steel, is high and the relatively low stiffness site is that of the twist-tie. In summary, ligature wire should be expected to carry responsive force; it will not perform as an activating element like the elastic module or the coiled spring. In its intended use (to close the bracket slot) and to generate secondary activation (holding force), this wire serves well as long as the localized embrittlement at the twist-tie is not so extensive that fracture occurs with the superposition of masticatory force upon appliance activation. The rubber-band elastic may be stretched between two points, creating the action-response force pair shown in Figure 6-16, or it may be activated in three- or four-point tension. In the "up-and-down elastic" application (between the maxillary and mandibular arches) the element may be looped around three or perhaps four brackets or spurs (affixed to arch wire). Unless constrained locally at several points, the activated
218
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
elastic will assume a configuration with the longitudinal strain the same
throughout its stretched length. If the load-deformation behavior of an elastic band has been or can be obtained in two-point tension, an analysis of the three- or four-point, equalized-tension problem can be accomplished. First, the magnitude of the tensile force existing throughout the band is obtained from its effective elongation, which is one-half the difference between the passive and activated circumferential lengths, and the load-deformation plot. Second, with the force magnitude the same on either side of the bracket or spur (because the strains are the same), as is shown in Figure 6-19, the direction of the delivered force (to the bracket) bisects the angle formed by the elastic-band segments. The magnitude of the delivered force is obtained from a force-balance on
Q
/ I
— — — - I. — — -
elastic-band segment
P
0 = 2(P cos
0)
P
FIGURE 6-19. A free-body diagram of the portion of an elastic band contacting a bracket; the analysis yields the direction of the force delivered to the bracket.
219
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
the segment free-body diagram shown, with the equation given in the
figure.
Although elastics are always activated in direct tension and helical springs are generally loaded uniaxially, the arch-wire segment spanning several brackets may be subjected to one loading pattern or several patterns concurrently. The most common arch-wire activation is in bending, and when activated in this manner, the wire behaves structurally as
a beam. Detailed discussions of arch-wire bending are contained in Chapter 7, but some general comments are appropriate here. First, a distinction is drawn between occlusogingival and faciolingual bending, simply in terms of the direction of activation and the plane containing the external force system. Second, the anchorage may be totally mesial or distal of the activation site, or it may be divided between locations mesial and distal to the activated section of the wire. For example, a symmetric arch might use the posterior segments for anchorage in mechanics designed to intrude or extrude the incisors; the model of such an arch is shown in buccal view on the left in Figure 6-20 and resembles the cantilevered beam of Figure 2-29. A lingually malposed second premolar might be tipped into alignment by a facially directed force, activated by tying the adjacent arch-wire section into the premolar bracket. In this
example, the anchorage is split between the dental units mesial and distal to the premolar, and an occlusal-view, free-body diagram of the arch-wire segment, showing the concentrated faciolingual forces, appears on the right in Figure 6-20. Third, innumerable load-deformation plots exist for a single arch wire in bending. Although each plot is approximately a straight line for metallic beams, if the deformations are not large and the elastic limit is not exceeded, the slope (stiffness) is dependent not only on the material and the size and shape of the cross-section, but also upon the characteristics of the loading, including its position with respect to the anchorage and, for rectangular cross-sections, the direction of the loading with respect to the cross-sectional geometry. When activating an arch wire to produce a crown force, the displacement must be measurable so that the wire "works" during the betweenappointments period with the force induced having a physiologically proper magnitude. Although such activations may readily be obtained through displacements perpendicular (normal, transverse) to the long I
I
I
I
cp pp
/
buccal view
/
\
occlusal view
FIGURE 6-20. Buccal and occiusal views of arch wires activated in bending by transverse forces: the wire as a cantilevered beam (left) and with divided anchorage (right).
220
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
dimension of the wire, no matter how small the cross-sectional area the
longitudinal (mesiodistal) wire stiffness is much too great. Two procedures are used to effectively reduce the mesiodistal stiffness of the arch wire: (1) More flexible elements are incorporated, nearly always bilaterally, in series with the arch wire, generally stretched between the ends of the wire and posterior anchorage. An example of this arrangement is shown in the buccal view on the left in Figure 6-21. Often this is done in anterior-retraction mechanics incorporating stops, springs, and, perhaps, ligature wire or elastic thread. (2) A loop is bent into the arch wire such as shown in the facial view on the right in Figure 6-21. The more wire incorporated in the loop, the lower the resulting mesiodistal stiffness. Because they are formed through inelastic bending procedures, and most often activated in bending, loops are examined in some detail in Chapter 7. Among other uses, loops are used in space-closing procedures and to "unravel" crowded incisors. Couples, as well as concentrated forces, may be transmitted between arch wire and bracket or buccal tube. Two of the three couples or couple components load the arch wire in bending; the third is associated with activation in torsion. To produce an active, second-order bending couple, in the passive configuration an angular malalignment must exist, as viewed from a facial perspective, between bracket slot or buccal tube and the section of arch wire to be engaged. Accordingly, clinicians place second-order bends in the wire or use preangulated brackets and tubes. The mesiodistal bracket width can greatly influence the magnitude of the second-order couple. Besides defining the distance between two contact forces (generated between wire and diagonally opposed edges of the bracket slot or buccal tube) forming the couple, for a given arch wire increased width (1) reduces any second-order, angular clearance between wire and bracket slot or buccal tube, (2) decreases the adjacent interbracket distances, and (3) tends to increase the as-activated, con-
tact-force magnitudes. In short, the wider the bracket or tube, the greater the potential, second-order bending stiffness. Many characteristics of the first-order couple are similar to those of its second-order counterpart. Located in an occlusal plane, the first-
Coiled
Hooks
Buccal tube Arch wire
FIGURE 6-21. Methods of increasing the longitudinal flexibility of the arch wire: a spring stretched between hooks affixed to the wire and a terminal-molar buccal tube (left) and a loop bent into the arch wire (right).
221
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
order couple arises from a difference in passive angulation between the
arch-wire section to be engaged and the axis of buccal tube or the lingual surface of the bracket slot. Again, the action is bending, and stiffness is substantially affected by an alteration in the mesiodistal bracket or tube
width. Notable with the first-order couple generated specifically between bracket and arch wire, however, is the dependence of stiffness on
ligation, inasmuch as one-half of the force pair exists due to contact between wire and the ligation. Moreover, the ligation may affect the bending stiffness from two aspects: (1) through its own stiffness, and (2) in determining the effective mesiodistal width of the bracket. Because
the ligation can weaken the connection of arch-wire to bracket and lessen efficiency in transferring first-order couples, other means are available to produce long-axis rotations (eyelet-to-arch-wire ties, wedges, and levers, for example); procedures are discussed in Chapter 6-22 shows a typical second-order couple transfer on the left and first-order couple transfers suggesting conventional ligature ties on the right. As with the transfer of a transverse force, anchorage for an active first- or second-order couple may be totally mesial or completely distal to the activation site, or the anchorage may be split (divided) with it partly mesial and partly distal to the activation location. Appropriately noted at this juncture is a comparison of similar parameters appearing in a load-deformation plot in bending for an arch wire, depending on the form of activation. If the wire is activated by a transverse force, the magnitudes of the force and the transverse bending deflection at the point of activation along the wire are plotted. At least the initial portion of the plot is linear and the slope—the stiffness—has dimensions of force divided by length. If the bending activation is by a first- or second-order couple, the deformation is angular; the stiffness in this mode has dimensions of the product of force and length per unit of rotation. Example plots for small-deformation, elastic behavior, together with sample units for stiffness, are given in Figure 6-23. An area under any load-deformation plot represents energy or energy transferred, always having dimensions of force times length [FL]. Couples created in planes containing the longitudinal "axis" of the arch wire induce bending; the couple applied to the wire such that its 10. Figure
plane is perpendicular to the mesiodistal direction creates a twisting
Cd Cm P
C,
FIGURE 6-22. Arch wires activated in bending by couples transferred to them by brackets: an active second-order couple exerted on a wire and transmitted to divided anchorage (left) and bilateral, first-order couples delivered by a wire segment to correct central incisor rotations (right).
222
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
C)
0
IJ_
ci 0
C)
Stiffness
(g-mm/deg) Stiffness (g/mm)
0
Deflection (mm)
0
Rotation (deg)
FIGURE 6-23. Arch-wire load-deformation diagrams in bending; the active force system is a transverse force (left) and a couple (right).
deformation. The twisting or torsional couple can arise from a rectangu-
lar wire and an edgewise bracket, the wire and bracket slot passively angulated, one with respect to the other. The rectangular wire may experience third-order activation following permanent twist placements by the clinician or through the use of "pretorqued" brackets. Torquing spurs bent into round wire are also used to generate third-order action. As with other forms of arch-wire "loading," third-order activation may be sustained by anchorage entirely on one side or the other of the activation site, or the anchorage may be divided between locations mesial and distal to the location of the activation. Free-body diagrams of an archwire segment subjected to a third-order couple with the anchorage split, and of a cantilevered wire loaded by a third-order couple, are shown on
the left and right, respectively, in Figure 6-24. Note that the bracket exerts less influence on the third- than on the first- or second-order stiffness of the arch wire. The mesiodistal bracket width is a factor in
9 Cload
C.,
C action
Cleft
FIGURE 6-24. Free-body diagrams of an arch-wire segment loaded in torsion; the segment on the left reflects divided anchorage, but only one anchorage site exists for the segment on the right.
223
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
torsional wire stiffness only insofar as it affects interbracket distances.
(As noted previously, a third-order couple in a rectangular wire will be transmitted to a tooth crown through a bracket only if the occlusogingival slot width is less than the diagonal dimension of the wire cross-section.) The form of the load-deformation plot for third-order arch-wire behavior is the same as that for first- or second-order-couple loading; for twisting as for bending by couples the loads, deformations, and stiffnesses individually have identical dimensions. In short, the load-deformation plot on the right in Figure 6-23 could qualitatively be representative of the arch wire subjected to active torsion or bending. Chapter 8 is entirely devoted to the third-order behavior of arch wires and associated topics.
For all of the fundamental activations previously discussed, uniaxial tension and compression, the cantilevered or divided-anchorage archwire beam subjected to a concentrated transverse force or couple, and the wire activated by a twisting (third-order) couple, force- and momentbalance analyses made of the member at any specific time following activation results in several quasi-static relationships that are less than the number of unknown characteristics necessary to complete the description of the entire force system. With the exception of the arch wire subjected to a couple loading and having divided anchorage, one additional relationship is needed; for the exception noted, two are needed. For each of these problems, the load-deformation plot provides the equivalent of one equation; with the deformation quantified with respect to the passive state, the plot yields the magnitude of the induced load. In those problems of couple loading and partitioned anchorage, one additional relationship is obtained, dependent on the relative distances between the load and the anchorage sites. Thus, the first portion of the structural analysis is handled, completing the description in all characteristics of the external force system exerted on the arch-wire segment. Detailed discussions of such analyses are taken up in subsequent chapters. The load-deformation behavior for a helical spring in tension or compression and for the arch wire in bending or torsion is virtually independent of time, at least within the elastic limit, because of its material properties. Moreover, provided no inelastic action has occurred, the deactivation or unloading plot will retrace the activation curve. Furthermore, should the elastic limit be exceeded in activation of a metallic appliance element, the deactivation (unloading) plot will be nearly linear with the same slope as that of the linear portion of the activation curve. (This was first discussed in Chapter 3.) Accordingly, for metallic appliance members, the relationship between load and deformation during deactivation is, in essence, known from the plot of these parameters obtained from activation data. Such an extrapolation, however, cannot be made for appliance members of polymeric materials because, generally, their structural behavior is nonlinear and time-dependent. A typical activation-deactivation pattern for a polymer was described previously in this section (see Fig. 6-17).
224
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
The Action and Response of Tip-Back Bends: An Illustration of the Four-Step Procedure in Orthodontic Structural Analysis Until in-depth studies of bending and torsional behavior of individual
members are undertaken, structural evaluations of orthodontic appliances cannot be completed. Nevertheless, in view of the concepts and procedures introduced in this chapter and the rather general discussions herein, with particular consideration of the analysis initiated, a look at an arch-wire example is appropriate. Chosen for examination is a continuous arch wire that fully engages the mandibular dentition from first molar to first molar. As often occurs,
this example appliance is geometrically and mechanically symmetric with respect to the midsagittal plane. All permanent teeth are fully erupted mesial to the first molars and have been aligned occlusogingivally and faciolingually. Because of the symmetry and alignments, together with the nature of the activations, the analysis is undertaken through a right-side buccal view of one-half of the arch wire and the involved dental units. (The additional potential for faciolingual tooth movements is recognized, owing to the development of force systems not within the "plane" containing the long axes, but actions and responses appearing in coronal-plane views are not investigated here.) The intended activations in this example are those produced by bilateral tip-back bends in the wire at the terminal molars; the angular, passive malalignments between wire segments and buccal-tube slots give rise, upon full engagement, to second-order couples exerted by the wire on the molar crowns (through the buccal tubes with the action-reaction counterpart couples against the wire). Three variations in the overall "loading" are to be examined, associated with the bend geometry and the occlusogingival position of the buccal tubes with respect to the "line of bracket slots": (1) the couple alone exerted on the molar; (2) the couple accompanied by an extrusive force; and (3) an intrusive force as well as the couple exerted on the molar crown. Before beginning the force analysis, some modeling is appropriate, as mentioned earlier in this chapter. Proposed is the consideration of the right-side half-arch as "L"-shaped as viewed from an occlusal perspective; the corner of the "L" marks the intersection of anterior and posterior portions of the arch model. The central and lateral incisors engage the anterior section and the canine, premolars, and first molar the posterior section of the wire. Because the intended action is against the first molar, it is separated in the model from the middle segment consisting of the canine and premolars. Shown on the left in Figure 6-25 is the right-side, first molar sub-
jected to the couple created by the tip-back bend. The displacement tendency is that of distal crown tipping with a center of rotation coinciding with the center of resistance in the approximate location indicated. On the right in Figure 6-25 is a free-body diagram of the half arch wire.
225
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
1P Ce
DC6
FIGURE 6-25. Buccal views of a terminal molar subjected to tip-back-bend action in the absence of net occlusogingival force (left), and a free-body diagram of one-half of the arch-wire model showing fhe responsive, contact force system exerted by the dental units (right).
Newton's law of action and reaction yields the couple at the first-molar
site. Because the half-arch is quasi-static, like the dentition, the entire force system acting on it must be balanced in this view. In the absence of substantial second-order bends mesial to the tip-back and, then, assuming second-order clearance between premolar and canine brackets and the wire, together with third-order clearance in the anterior section (or round wire engaged and containing no torquing spurs), the response to the couple loading must be in the form of occlusogingival forces mesial
to the activation site. The pair of equal, parallel vertical forces shown form another couple, opposite in sense to the couple against the lip-back bend; the product of one of the forces and the distance between the pair of forces must equal the magnitude of the tip-back-bend couple in order to yield a balanced force system exerted on the half arch wire. The specific locations of the vertical responsive forces depend on the bending stiffness and the passive geometry of the arch wire relative to the bracket placements and their orientations, but most likely both will act within the middle segment—perhaps against the second premolar and canine. The net effect of the response tends to rotate the line of middle-segment brackets clockwise, as viewed in Figure 6-25. If the arch wire has high bending stiffness, the response to the couple loading may travel to the incisal segment with a tendency there toward intrusion. The sketch on the left in Figure 6-26 shows the combined effect of the lip-back bend and an occlusogingival malalignment of buccal tube and wire, the latter creating a tendency for extrusion. The action-reaction counterparts of the force and couple against the molar are shown against the posterior end of the half arch wire on the right in the figure. Again, assuming ample second-order clearance throughout the middle segment and no third-order activity in the incisal region, the response mesial to the molar is again in the form of occlusogingival force. In fact, the total force system exerted on the half arch wire by the engaged dentition may be balanced, with the given action at the terminal molar, by a single, resultant gingivally directed force as shown. The location of this balancing force is probably at the first-premolar site if the wire exhibits moder-
226
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
P6
C6
0 (= P6)
FIGURE 6-26. Buccal views of a terminal molar subjected to tip-back-bend action in combination with a net extrusive force (left) and a free-body diagram of one-half of the arch-wire model showing the response of the dentition (right).
ate bending
stiffness, but all three teeth in the middle segment are likely subjected to intrusive action. If the wire is very flexible, the second premolar will receive the greatest portion of the distributed, intrusive potential.
The third variation is the most common, found in mechanics designed to establish posterior anchorage; the action against the terminal molars is a combination of distal crown tipping and intrusion. Shown on the left in Figure 6-27 is the right-side molar subjected to the counterclockwise couple and the gingivally directed force, The action-reaction counterparts act against the posterior extent of the half arch wire on the right in the figure. For a third time, assume that the response mesial to the terminal molar is void of couples. Note that, although the addition of one responsive, occlusogingival force could provide, in the free-body diagram of the half arch wire, a vertical force balance, a moment balance would be impossible. Accordingly, two vertical forces of mutually opposing senses are necessary to enable both force and moment balances. Moreover, because the intermediate vertical force must have a magnitude equal to the sum of the other two forces and a sizable counterclockwise moment is necessary for the overall moment balance, the more
C6
-)
FIGURE 6-27. Buccal views of a terminal molar subjected to tip-back-bend action together with a net intrusive force (left) and a free-body diagram of one-half of the arch-wire model showing the response of the dentition (right).
227
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
mesial of the two parts of the vertical, responsive, force system is likely
located in the incisal region as shown. Hence, the intermediate, vertical force is exerted on the middle segment. For each of the three active force systems against the terminal molars, three of the four steps in the previously outlined analysis procedure have been discussed. Figures 6-25 through 6-27 show the desired (or obtained) actions at the activation site, the terminal molar (step 1), and the action-reaction transition to the appliance (the arch wire—with symmetry, the half arch) and the subsequent balancing of the force system on the wire (step 2). The effects of the response elsewhere in the dental arch, gained from a second action-reaction transition, were then noted;
the three variations in response in the order considered are pictured from left to right in Figure 6-28 (step 3). The displacements that occur in
these mechanics are to be restricted to the terminal molar. Undesired side effects, then, are movements within the middle and incisal segments produced by the responsive force systems. The ideal may not be realized, however, inasmuch as the molar demands a sizable active force system commensurate with its root-surface area, and this area is larger
than that of any of the teeth mesial to the molar. Beyond keeping the active force system against the molar as small as reasonably possible, considering the smaller root-surface areas of teeth receiving responsive force, little further discussion of step 4 is reasona-
ble here. The distribution of responsive force is associated with the structural behavior of the appliance, and in this instance knowledge of arch-wire bending (flexure) is required—the topic of Chapter 7. It is notably necessary, in particular when the tip-back couple is accompanied by the intrusive force (see Fig. 6-27), to unitize the middle segment rather than permit an individual tooth to take a majority of the vertical
response. Of concern, in addition, must be the intrusive responsive force against the incisal segment seen in the third variation (Fig. 6-27 and Fig. 6-28, right). The potential for intrusive displacement is not only strong because of the relatively small root-surface area of the half incisal segment, but the line of action misses the center of resistance by some
distance if these teeth have typical angulations and, as a result, the tendency for flaring is also present. One suggestion, assuming the intrusion and flaring are unwanted, is to place up-and-down elastics to transfer a portion of the gingivally directed force to the maxillary arch. Alter-
natively, the patient could wear, for a portion of each day, an FmId
t
F1
I
FIGURE 6-28. The transfers of responsive force systems to the dentition resulting from the terminal-molar activations of Figures 6-25 (left), 6-26 (center), and 6-27 (right).
228
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
appropriate extraoral appliance engaging the incisal segment of the
mandibular arch wire. Clearly, these "remedies" draw on concepts and discussions yet ahead in this text and, as already mentioned, the distribution of the responsive force system is partially dependent on bending characteristics of the arch wire that receive in-depth attention in the
chapter to follow. In short, the example discussed here is typical in format of the whole of Chapter 10; as noted at the beginning of this section, the purpose was to provide a glimpse of a portion of the structural analysis procedure, the foundation for which has been laid in the foregoing sections of the present chapter.
"Control" of the Orthodontic Apptiance of its relation to the structural behavior of the mechanism over time, before closing this chapter several comments pertaining to the "control of the appliance," to use the clinician's terminology, are in Because
order. A difficult concept to define directly, "control" may seem to make reference to displacements of teeth, but a broader interpretation should
be understood. In anticipation of activation or reactivation within the oral cavity, the appliance is prepared with regard to the existing configu-
ration of the dentition and the realignment desired, expecting certain tooth movements to occur in the interval between appointments. Because the displacements of dental units are accompanied by geometric and mechanical alterations of the appliance from the as-activated state, and the orthodontist has no "hands on" influence during the betweenappointments period, control must be built into the appliance design and the activation of that appliance. After the patient has left the office or clinic, three factors govern: (1) the biologic response of the tissues to the induced force system; (2) the minimum-energy principle; and (3) the actions of the patient. The first factor was discussed in Chapter 5. The second factor has been mentioned, but to repeat the principle indicates that, given the locations and formats of connections of the appliance to the dentition and anchorage, the appliance will assume a configuration, within the constraints imposed by those connections and the dentition, which makes the total
strain-energy increment associated with activation quantitatively as small as possible. This strain-energy increment, directly related to the appliance deformation from its original passive state and the accompanying induced forces, is distributed throughout the mechanism. Any crown displacement causes a change in the appliance configuration (due to the connection of mechanism to dentition), a reduction in the strain
energy (due to an energy transfer in the form of work done by the appliance in moving the tooth or teeth), and a redistribution of what remains of the increment to define a new, minimum-energy state. The third factor is well understood as to its potential adverse impact. If any
229
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
portion of the appliance is removable (elastics, an extraoral appliance, or
a retainer, for example), the patient may infringe upon the control estab-
lished by the clinician. Patient cooperation and control go together; a patient who is 100% cooperative leaves the maximum amount of appliance control to the orthodontist. The ideal orthodontic appliance would permit the operator to predict, in extent to within the limits imposed by the incompletely known biologic response factor, the displacements of all points of the appliance where force is transmitted to the dentition and, in effect, to completely but remotely be in control of the deactivation process at all times. Of obvious importance is control of displacements at the anchorage sites. In this regard the extraoral appliance presents a paradox: the rationale for development and use of headgear is the location of the anchorage away from the dentition, and yet, with this appliance, the patient may interfere with operator control to a substantial and, perhaps, critical extent. The process of activating and engaging the orthodontic appliance produces a system of forces within the mechanism that reaches the dentition through the appliance-to-dentition connection sites. Although permitting some initial deactivation with primarily soft-tissue displacements, the resistance of the periodontium that prevents large initial tooth movements generally keeps the appliance under load (activated) for an extended period of lime. Accordingly, during active treatment two sets of forces exist as action-reaction counterparts at the connection sites. One set is primarily and continually related to the deformed configuration of the appliance with respect to its passive state; the other determines in large measure the course of dental-unit displacements over the finite time period. Control of the overall force system, then, must account for this system's influence on both the appliance and the dentition, and all characteristics of each component of the system (force or couple location, magnitude, and direction and sense), together with variations in these characteristics with time, must be considered. With respect to the dentition, force and couple levels should be large enough initially so that, after the soft-tissue movements, sufficient magnitudes remain to produce measurable orthodontic displacements during the between-appointments period. On the other hand, force magni-
tudes cannot be so great as to inflict undue pain and/or result in ankylosis. Concurrently, the force system delivered to intraoral anchorage sites, if any, must be small enough (through distribution as well as by limiting the size of the resultant) not to cause unwanted movements there. Furthermore, the initial force levels chosen will be affected by their expected decay patterns over lime (discussed in Chapter 5). Displacement paths of the dental units will be directly influenced by directional characteristics of the force system; displacements early in the be-
tween-appointments period may alter initial force directions with respect to teeth and, thereby, affect subsequent movements within the same period. Particularly difficult to control are couple-force ratios over time, inasmuch as the individual decay patterns of couple and force are
230
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
related to separate stiffness and deformation parameters. The biologic
system reacts to the local force system as a whole, and not to the individual components. Ideally, force control relative to the appliance should be built into the design of the mechanism. The force system created with the activation
of the appliance must not permit any type of failure at the instant of activation when the stresses and localized appliance displacements are generally greatest. To the point mentioned previously, the allowable "load" on the appliance must account for the expectation of superposition of masticatory forces. Particularly with regard to the possibility of fatigue failure, special precautions must be taken with appliances or appliance elements that are removable and, as a result, are subjected to interrupted force systems. Displacement control pertains primarily to the orthodontic tooth movements, but not to the complete exclusion of the appliance. Allow-
ances must be made, and again largely in the design, such that the mechanism, as it deactivates, will not make unwanted contact with the tissues, thereby giving rise to the potential for trauma or spurious displacements. Displacements, like forces, are vector quantities having direction as well as magnitude. As discussed in Chapter 5, the directions of tooth movements are influenced by the characteristics of the delivered
force systems and, to some extent, by alveolar-bone biology. The bounds on dental displacement magnitudes are directly related to the extent of appliance activation and the between-appointments time period; even in unlimited time, orthodontic tooth movements will not continue beyond total deactivation of the appliance. With metallic appliance elements the orthodontist uses the passive configuration of the appliance and the elastic limits of appliance elements
as guides in activation. Ideally, if the activation does not exceed the elastic limit, the appliance will deactivate to its former, passive state. This does not mean, however, that the movements will be, at their greatest extents, exactly as "read" from the activation, because this "reading" assumes immovable anchorage. Although the majority of metallic, activated appliance elements are expected to produce intermittent force as defined in Chapter 5, displacement control of elements producing continuous force depends upon unloading at the appropriate time by the clinician or the patient, or on intraoral abutments. Because interrupted forces are continuous during their "on" periods, the same is true for this third class of loading. When the continuous force is produced by a polymeric element, the deterioration-aging and relaxation of the material may hinder the maximizing of controlled displacements,
but in an uncontrolled situation (the patient missing one or more appointments, for example), a drop in force magnitude or discontinuance of the force due to failure of the element may be quite helpful. Note that the orthodontist can use the clearances that may exist between arch wire and bracket or buccal tube, particularly with regard to controlling rotations. The wire may be used as an active appliance element, it may be a guide to control the direction of a displacement with a
231
Introduction to Structural Analysis of the Orthodontic Appliance
driving force produced by a separate appliance element, or it may be the "trigger" of an abutment system to limit the extent of a specific displace-
ment component. In canine retraction on a continuous arch wire, some distal crown tipping may be permitted; however, when second-order clearance disappears, a couple countering the tipping moment of the driving force arises with bracket-wire contact. In preparing for Class IT mechanics, posterior-segment crowns may be tipped distally; secondorder bends are placed in the posterior portion of the mandibular arch wire of the Class II appliance, but may become active only when force against the segments begins to upright these teeth and "burn" (eliminate) the anchorage. These two sets of mechanics, and others, are examined in detail in Chapter 10, and means of control of forces and displacements are discussed concurrently.
Synopsis objective of this chapter was to provide the reader with a foundation, based in part on the concepts and procedures of structural analysis, The
for the understanding of the topics of arch-wire bending and torsion, extraoral-appliance force systems, and a variety of orthodontic treatment mechanics, discussed from a bioengineering standpoint in the final four chapters of this text. The uniqueness of the orthodontic appliance, neither a structure nor a machine by their engineering definitions, has been noted. The sequence of procedures in a general structural analysis was outlined, the entire process was seen as divisible into two main portions (related to the external and internal force systems associated with individual appliance members), and a four-step approach to the analysis of the orthodontic appliance was introduced. The complexity of the appliance was noted as to its geometry, material characteristics, and the force systems transmitted between appliance
and dentition. When evaluating the continuous arch wire or an appliance as a whole, the primary actions and responses may be examined in
a less complicated environment through reasonable modeling procedures; preparation of an arch-wire model has been undertaken with the importance of validity evaluation emphasized. Substantial attention was given to the connection sites of appliance to dentition, in particular to the orthodontic bracket and its characteristics with influences on both the properties of the transmitted force system and the structural behavior of the arch wire. The orthodontic appliance was discussed as a quasi-static and indeterminate structure, and in this light the force-deformation characteristics of a number of the more basic auxiliary elements were examined. Mention was also made of the various formats and components of arch-
wire activation, the many stiffnesses that may enter into an analysis, and the associated anchorage configurations; however, it is only an overview with the two chapters to follow devoted to these considera-
232
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
tions. An examination of the effects of activated, tip-back bends served
as a first experience involving an arch wire with the four-step analysis approach. Finally, the clinician's concept of "control" was considered with note of its applicability both to the desired displacements within the dentition and the structural behavior of the orthodontic appliance. This text is not intended to convert orthodontic students or practicing clinicians into structural analysts. The practitioner does, however, contribute significantly to the advancements in design of orthodontic appliances and, as important, is potentially in the best position to knowledgeably critique existing designs from the standpoint of their "in-service" performances. Accordingly, the orthodontist needs at minimum a superficial understanding of the contributions of the structural parameters of the appliance elements to the total behavior of the mechanism to properly employ it in therapy and to evaluate the results achieved with respect to treatment objectives.
Suggested Readings Hsieh, Y.Y.: Elementary Theory of Structures. Englewood Cliffs, N.J., Prentice-
Hall, 1970, Chapters 1, 2. Jarabak, JR., and Fizzell, J.A.: Technique and Treatment with Light-wire Edgewise Appliances. 2nd Ed. St. Louis, C.V. Mosby, 1972, Chapters 3, 8.
Laursen, H.I.: Structural Analysis. 2nd Ed. New York, McGraw-Hill, 1978, Chapters 1, 2.
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
The orthodontic arch wire, more than any other form of structural mem-
ber, resembles a beam. The beam is characterized by its geometry, its loading, and its response to the force systems exerted upon it. The longitudinal dimension of this structural member is large in comparison with its cross-sectional measurements; the interbracket distance, a characteristic length for the arch-wire segment, is ordinarily at least ten times the typical cross-sectional dimension. Beam loading, as well as its responsive force system, generally consists of concentrated and distributed forces directed perpendicular to the longitudinal dimension; couples may be included in the force system. The applied forces and responses may exist in more than one plane; the force system exerted on an archwire beam may be directed occlusogingivally and/or faciolingually. The activation of a beam is reflected in characteristic displacements with respect to a passive configuration. The primary reference for beam deformations is the passive, longitudinal beam axis that pierces the centers of all of the beam cross-sections. Also associated with beam deformations are the right cross-sections which, in the passive state, by definition, are everywhere perpendicular to the beam axis. The two forms of beam deformation of principal importance are the transverse deflection, the displacement of a beam-axis point perpendicular to the passive orientation of the axis at the point, and the cross-sectional rotation, not a twisting but
rather a tipping, angular displacement of the right cross-section. In keeping with the model established in Chapter 6, the typical archwire segment, to be activated in bending, is envisioned as passively flat and straight. Depending on the plane(s) in which the bending occurs, facial or occlusal views of the arch-wire beam are used in analysis. Most often, the bending force systems are exerted by ligated brackets and
buccal tubes, although forces may be transmitted to the arch wire through hooks or loops—by elastics stretched against them, for example. When an auxiliary force acts on a wire in a direction oblique to it, that force is decomposed into longitudinal and transverse components; only the transverse component contributes directly to bending action. Occlusogingival and faciolingual bracket and buccal-tube force systems 233
234
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
(but not mesiodistal forces from, for example, stops, ties to anchorage,
or friction) are associated with the arch-wire bending problem. First- and second-order couples, originating from angulations and two-point contacts between wire and bracket or buccal tube, also enter into the bending analysis. The arch-wire segment, activated in bending through en-
gagement in brackets and buccal tubes, may test the analyst to distinguish between the "load" and the responsive portion of the force system; moreover, the arch-wire beam problem is generally quasi-statically indeterminate, necessitating the use of force-deformation relationships in the solution in addition to force and moment balances. The responsive force system, exerted by the "support(s)" of the arch-wire beam, is the action-reaction counterpart of the force system against the anchorage. Clearances between bracket or tube and wire often play a role in the bending problem. Occlusogingival, dimensional differences
may be important to the determination of a transverse deflection. Changes in shape from the passive beam (arch) configuration are generally consequences of bending activation; depending on the amount of second-order clearance, for example, a faciolingual-plane couple may or may not be developed at a support location as part of the bending force system.
The many facets of the arch-wire bending problem already mentioned suggest a complex analysis procedure. Reasonable simplifications, however, beginning with the straight-segmented, passive, arch-wire model, enable a manageable examination of the significant contributions to the analysis. A first bending example appears to be an inversion of the lever of Figure 2-27. The member of Figure 7-1, however, is subjected to a transverse load located between two anchorage sites. Characterizing the beam by its longitudinal axis, it is shown in the
5)
I-
0 0
2L
U-
Midspan, transverse stiffness
P
Midspan Deflection
FIGURE 7-1. A simple example of a split-anchorage beam: passive (dashed) and activated beam-axis configurations (upper left); a free-body diagram of the beam (lower left); and the force-deflection pattern of activation at midspan (right).
235
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
sketch in the upper left in the figure, passively as a dashed, straight line
and having a solid, curvilinear shape following activation. Such an arch-
wire beam might be maintained in its deformed configuration by the relative occiusogingival positions of three brackets. Assuming that the initial position of the intermediate bracket represents a malalignment to be corrected, the brackets at either end of the wire beam are affixed to teeth that are not to be displaced; the anchorage might be termed "divided" or "split." To make this first example straightforward, distances between adjacent brackets are equal and sufficient second-order clearances are assumed to exist such that no couples arise with activation. The free-body diagram of the activated beam, shown in Figure 7-1 (lower left), is identical to that for a lever having the fulcrum at its midpoint. Force and moment balances indicate that the support forces Qi and QT are equal in magnitude and each is half that of the force P. but none of the three can be quantified by a quasi-static analysis alone. To approach the solution from this point, the configuration of the active state, with respect to the passive beam-axis shape, must be examined. Consider the wire as first engaged in only the support brackets, with activation then achieved by depressing the midsection of the wire to reach the slot of the intermediate bracket. The greater the vertical malalignment, the larger the value of P upon full engagement. From foregoing discussions of material behavior (Chap. 3), the expectation is a linear force-deflection relationship for the metallic wire as shown on the right in Figure 7-1. The slope of the plot is a bending stiffness, the quantity needed to complete the solution; the product of this stiffness and the activating deflection yields the magnitude of P. With the foregoing as an introduction, this chapter develops with a discussion in the following four sections of the geometric and mechanical parameters involved in elastic beam analyses. Next, direct application to activation and deactivation of arch wires in bending is under-
taken. Subsequently considered is the inelastic bending of metallic beams toward an understanding of the influence of the placement of permanent bends in an arch wire which is then to be activated. The chapter closes with a structural analysis of orthodontic wire loops—their characteristics and the influences of loop geometry and wire properties upon activation and deactivation in bending.
am Deformations, Strains, and Stresses reference frame established for determining bending deformations is affixed to the longitudinal axis of the passive, straight beam. The beam axes for arch wires are easily located due to the symmetry of circular and rectangular cross-sections. The general beam problem is three-dimensional with two coordinates of a rectangular framework locating a point The
in the cross-section with respect to its geometric center and the third coordinate locating the cross-section. More specifically in the develop-
236
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
ment to follow, the origin of the frame coincides with the geometric
center of the reference cross-section of the passive beam. The longitudinal coordinate x is measured along the undeformed (straight) beam axis. The y and z axes, completing the framework, are coincident with perpendicular axes of symmetry within the reference, right cross-section of the beam before loading. Although the force systems associated with the activation of arch-wire beam may be located in either the x-z or y-z plane
or in both, when the force system is three-dimensional in character, separate "in-plane" analyses may be undertaken and the results subsequently superimposed. Accordingly, a plane of bending is defined as that
plane containing both the undeformed and the deformed longitudinal axes of a beam, as well as the external load and responsive force system. Arch-wire bending may be reasonably analyzed in parts, individually in the faciolingual and occlusogingival planes as necessary, followed if de-
sired by superposition of the results. In discussions to follow the x-z plane is the plane of bending and an angle 6 is introduced as a cross-sectional, rotational coordinate.
As many as five displacement parameters may be associated with in-plane bending. They are described here in their usual order of importance. First is the linear displacement of a beam-axis point perpendicular to the passive beam axis, quantified by a z-coordinate measurement. Second is the rotation of a cross-section, symbolically indicated by the angle 6. These are the principal displacement parameters and both may be expressed mathematically as functions of the longitudinal coordinate x. Shown in the upper sketch of Figure 7-2 is a cantilevered beam sub-
jected to a concentrated load at its free end; in a separate sketch, the undeformed (dashed) and deformed configurations of the beam axis are
depicted. A reasonable location for the origin of the x-z frame is the center of the fixed-end cross-section, and indicated in the figure are the transverse-deflection and cross-sectional-rotation parameters for an arbitrary value of the longitudinal coordinate and for the "free" end of the beam. The collection of transverse displacements of all beam-axis points yields the deformed beam axis. Because, for all values of x associated with the activated beam, continuity demands that the longitudinal axis and rotated right cross-section be perpendicular to one another, 6 represents the slope of the beam axis, generally varying from one cross-section to another. A third displacement parameter designates the longitudinal shortening of the beam. With axial (longitudinal) force systems excluded in the bending analysis, the curvilinear length of the beam axis is unchanged
by activation, but the x-coordinate distance between the ends of the loaded beam is less than the length. Nearly always in the elastic bending of engaged, activated arch wires, this form of displacement may be neglected in its influence on other beam parameters, as is implied in the symbols z(L) and 6(L) in the example of Figure 7-2. (In leveling procedures within orthodontic treatment, however, because of high mesiodistal wire stiffness and, often, the real presence of longitudinal loading, this shortening can have a sizable influence on displacement potential,
237
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
F
L
0(x)
z(L)
z
FIGURE 7-2. Sketches of a cantllevered beam serving as an example to diagrammatically define the bending displacement z, the transverse deflection, and 0, the rotational displacement of a cross-section.
particularly of incisors.) The fourth and fifth displacement parameters
pertain to deformations of the cross-section itself. In the activation of metallic beams, the induced transverse force systems will rarely alter the passive, in-plane, depth dimension of the cross-section; this potential deformation, which might be significant with soft materials or very short beams, is routinely neglected here. Finally, experimental research has
shown that, under bending action, the right cross-sections of some beams will warp, but no warping occurs when the end view of the plane of loading coincides with an axis of symmetry of the beam cross-section. In summary, in all beam theories the z and 0 deformations are recognized as sizable. Small-deformation theories of bending neglect all forms of deformation except these two. When transverse and angular displacements of cross-sections are substantial, however, the effects of longitudinal shortening must be considered; such analyses are highly involved and, because of their complexity, they are not discussed theoretically in this text.
238
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
In beginning an examination of structural bending, the solid beam is considered to be composed of a large number of longitudinal fibers, each having a very small cross-sectional area in comparison with that of the beam as a whole. One fiber coincides with the longitudinal beam axis. All fibers of the beam as modeled are passively straight and, in the plane of bending, all deformed fibers have identical curvatures. Because these fibers are interconnected, however, reflecting the structural integrity of the beam as a unit, the majority of these fibers experience longitudinal
strain upon activation. Depending on the location of the fiber, this "bending strain" may be tensile, compressive, or zero. Figure 7-3 shows an exaggerated, activated shape of a beam segment in in-plane bending. With the outline of the passive segment superimposed (dashed) and the segment subdivided to simulate the fibrous idealization, the fibers on the side of the beam axis nearer to its center of curvature are seen to have been contracted; the fibers on the other side of the axis are stretched. Note also that the amount of fiber (bending) strain varies with the distance from the beam axis. As shown in Figure 7-3, a local coordinate u is used to measure this distance with the posi-
Neutral surface
FIGURE 7-3. A beam segment in passive (dashed) and activated configurations. Illustrated are the neutral surface, bending strains of the beam fibers," and the coordinate u that locates specific fibers with respect to the neutral surface.
239
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
five sense taken toward the stretched fibers. An in-plane bending activa-
tion results in all fibers having the same u-coordinate value experiencing
equal bending strains and, considering only circular and rectangular cross-sections, the group of fibers undergoing no longitudinal strain coincides with the cross-sectional axis of symmetry perpendicular to the plane of loading. In Figure 7-3 the apparent beam-axis fiber is actually an edge view of the collection of unstrained fibers known as the neutral surface of the beam. Because the cross-sections of arch-wire beams ordinarily do not warp upon activation of the member, the fiber-strain pattern is associated solely with cross-sectional rotational deformation and the strain values are, therefore, proportional to the u-coordinate locations of the fibers. The overall beam shape in plane bending is represented by the curvature of the beam axis, within and coincident with the edge view of the neutral surface. In general, each point on the bending axis is associated with a beam cross-section and has its own center and radius of curva-
ture. If all bending-axis points in a beam segment possess the same center and radius of curvature, that segment is said to be experiencing "pure bending," terminology that will be further explained in a subsequent section of this chapter. Figure 7-4 shows a very short segment of a beam with a typical, relative rotation of one neighboring cross-section
with respect to another. The portion of beam axis within the segment takes on, approximately, the shape of a circular arc with activation, and the center of curvature of that arc is point C. The associated radius of curvature is r and its inverse will be symbolized in this chapter by k. The beam-axis segment is of curvilinear length 3x, where 5 generally indicates "small amount of' or "small change in" the variable that follows it. The angle 4 denotes the relative cross-sectional rotation. Because & is a very short arc length and approaches in magnitude, and because the longitudinal (bending) strain is the deformation per unit length of a fiber having a passive length 8x, the relationship or
(7-1)
is obtained. The coordinate u locates the beam fibers experiencing bending strain e,, and k is the average curvature of the short beam-axis segment. On any specific beam cross-section located by the coordinate x, then, the rate of increase of bending strain from the neutral surface, a constant for the cross-sectional location, is directly dependent on only the beam-axis curvature at that location. On the typical cross-section, in-plane bending deformation of an initially straight beam produces compressive strains in those beam fibers
on one side of the neutral surface and tensile strains in the remaining fibers. The magnitude and sense of any fiber strain at a point in the beam depend on location, defined by the two coordinates x and u for in-plane bending, the geometry and material of the beam, and the force system producing the bending deformation. On any beam cross-section,
240
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
C
=
5x =
GH= Also,
GH
=
4
So,
= k(8x) = e0(ôx) U
U
FIGURE 7-4. The geometry from which may be derived, for an activated beam, the relationship between the intensity of bending strains on a specific cross-section and the beam-axis curvature there.
241
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
(en)max
Neutral axis
(So)rnax
FIGURE 7-5. Fiber-strain and elastic fiber-stress patterns on a typical circular or rectangular cross-section of a beam subjected to in-plane bending.
the fiber strains are proportional to their distances from the neutral sur-
faces and, for beams with circular or rectangular cross-sections, the max-
imum tensile and compressive strains are equal in magnitude. A typical fiber-strain pattern is shown on the left in Figure 7-5 with, for cross-sections of interest here, the neutral surface (seen in edge view) midway between the pictured longitudinal boundaries of the beam. The corresponding bending-stress pattern is obtained from the stress-strain
law for the beam material and the established strains. Because archwire-beam materials are reasonably homogeneous, the stress-strain relationship for any one fiber is that for the material as a whole. Since such materials are metaffic, they behave within their elastic limits according to Hooke's law. The theoretical development and results to follow reflect equal material stiffnesses in tension and compression, a reasonable as-
sumption (verified by experimental research) well beyond the elastic limit for beam material of interest. Shown on the right in Figure 7-5, then, is the elastic, fiber- (bending-) stress distribution associated with the adjacent strain pattern. At any specific point of the cross-section, for totally elastic material behavior, the ratio of stress to strain equals Young's modulus for the beam material. Increasing the beam loading to produce inelastic action will not destroy the antisymmetry seen in the figure, but it will change the relationship between the bending (fiber) stress s,. and u from the linear pattern shown to a nonlinear pattern, corresponding to the general plot of stress versus strain for a typical, ductile, crystalline material (see Fig. 3-17, right).
orce Systems Within the Beam The beam of Figure 7-1 may be described as having a "span" of magnihide 2L, simply supported (because the responses at the beam ends are "simply" concentrated forces, and activated by a transverse, point load
242
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
"midspan." The responsive forces obtained earlier seem to suggest that the load is divided and its halves are transmitted left and right from the midspan site to the beam ends where they are transferred from the member to the supports. This is an oversimplification, but correctly implied is the generation of a force system within the beam, created with application of the load. The internal force system may be "exposed" by figuratively cutting the beam perpendicular to the beam axis at a desired longitudinal location, revealing two adjacent right cross-sections. One at
or the other beam portion is isolated for study; either may be chosen since the force system exerted on one cross-section is the action-reaction counterpart of that exerted on the other exposed cross-section. As an example, the beam of Figure 7-1 has been "cut" half way be-
tween the left support and the load, and a free-body diagram of the shorter, left-hand portion is shown in Figure 7-6. (Even though activation produces deformation, for purposes of force analysis the passiveconfiguration sketch may be used when longitudinal shortening is minimal.) In the activated state, any part of the beam is static (or quasi-static) as is the entire member. Although the force system exerted by one portion of the beam upon the other at the "cut" site is distributed throughout the cross-section, resultant components perpendicular and tangent to the cross-section are initally considered. First, the presence of the support response at the end of the segment and the need for a transverse force balance suggest the existence of a tangential or shear component V. (The symbol V is used because the majority of beams are ori-
ented with the passive longitudinal axis horizontal; the shear force, then, is directed vertically.) Second, because no axial loading is present, a horizontal force balance indicates that the net longitudinal force com-
ponent at the "cut" is zero. (When present in the practical structural problem, axial forces and their effects may be handled separately and superimposed upon those associated with bending.) Third, since the
L
P
2
7-6. A free-body diagram of the left quarter segment of the beam of Figure 7-1, exposing components of the resultant of the internal force system at a specific crosssection and permitting the determination ot their characteristics. FIGURE
243
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
support response and the shear component in the example are not col-
linear, a moment balance cannot exist without the presence of a couple M at the "cut" site. (The symbol M is used because the couple is known as the bending "moment" to the structural analyst.) The magnitudes and correct senses of V and M from quasi-static analysis are given in the figure for the example, simply-supported, split-anchorage beam. In obtaining these components a force analysis of the entire beam is necessary prior to making the "cut" in order that V and M may be expressed in terms of the load and longitudinal dimensions. In the beam problems of interest here, an in-plane bending analysis will involve external loadings consisting of concentrated forces and/or couples located in the x-z plane. The internal components V and M will
be partially dependent on the load and will generally vary with the longitudinal coordinate x from one cross-section to another along the beam length. Using the example analysis as a guide, V may be seen to be unchanged along a beam segment upon which no external force is ap-
plied while M, computed from force and distance, varies in a linear fashion (increasing or decreasing with distance from the force to the "cut" site). Proceeding from one cross-section to another longitudinally, an encounter with an applied, concentrated force makes V "jump" to a new value; M is also affected, but to a less dramatic extent. In the same
analysis procedure, encountering an applied, concentrated couple makes the internal bending moment "jump," but the couple has no effect on V. In detailed beam analyses, plots of V and M versus the longitudinal coordinate x are often sketched. Such diagrams, showing typical varia-
tional patterns of these resultant components of the internal force system, are presented for the example problem below the free-body diagram in Figure 7-7. The determination of the critical cross-section, the location of the largest M value is important in beam analysis; the figure provides that information for the example problem. Although not exhibited in the example, a segment of finite length may exist in a beam in which the bending couple M remains constant. Correspondingly, the shear force V must be zero throughout the segment and the segment is said to be in pure bending. Within the segment the deformed beam axis has the shape of a circular arc and, therefore, every cross-section within the segment has the same center and radius of curvature and, as mentioned previously, the same bending strain pattern. The foregoing comments suggest the existence of relationships between the couple M and the bending stress and deformation patterns for the general beam. Appropriate first, however, is a look at the influence of the shear component V upon bending. Although V is related to M (reflected in Figure 7-7 in that the slope of the M-diagram is everywhere equal to the corresponding shear force), its direct effect on important bending parameters is minimal. Experimental results have shown that transverse deformations attributable to V are generally very small. The component V is the resultant of the transverse shearing-stress pattern, and the average and maximum shearing stresses are typically less than
244
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
P
P
P
2
2
V
P 2
L L
x
2
M
x
FIGURE 7-7. Shear and bending-moment diagrams below a free-body diagram of the beam of Figure 7-1.
10% of their counterparts in bending. Only when the beam is extremely short are the shear effects significant, and such beams are nonexistent in the orthodontic appliance. Hence, the remarks to follow focus solely on one component of the internal-force system in bending.
245
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
Noted previously was the presence of a fiber-stress pattern perpendicular to a right cross-section within the activated beam (Fig. 7-5). For
the two cross-sectional shapes of interest and considering in-plane bending, that pattern is divided in half by the neutral surface. Directly viewing the cross-section, the edge of the neutral surface seen is termed the neutral axis and it coincides with the y-coordinate axis defined earlier. Bending stresses are zero on the neutral axis that divides the distribution into tensile and compressive parts; the resultants of the two parts of the
bending-stress pattern are equal, parallel forces, and their resultant is the bending couple M. In general, then, like M, the magnitudes of these forces and the sr-to-u ratio may vary from one cross-section to another, mathematically dependent on the longitudinal coordinate x. A diagrammatic representation of the relationship among the bending stresses, the pair of force resultants, and M is sketched in Figure 7-8. The bending(fiber-) stress value at a point depends upon the coordinates x and u to specify the location within the beam, upon the loading that enables the determination of M, and finally upon the cross-sectional geometry of the beam. To fill several needs an analytic expression in these parameters is now developed. Figure 7-9 depicts a typical beam cross-section in edge view, and a line of fibers parallel to the y-axis and the associated internal force upon
which attention is focused. The desired, explicit expression for M is obtained by summing the moments of all such "fiber-line" forces about the neutral axis, also seen only in edge view in the figure. Because each fiber has a very small cross-section and is activated in direct tension (or compression), the 0-notation is again used and the fiber-line force equals the product of stress (unchanging in the y-direction) and the fiber-line area: OP =
(7-2)
F, =
F,
M=
FIGURE 7-8. The internal bending couple as the resultant of the fiber-stress distribution.
246
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Neutral axis
= 3M = (SP)u
U
a "tiber"
r
N
Outline ot tensile tiber-stress distribution
FIGURE 7-9. The contribution of the force in one beam fiber to the internal bending couple M.
The moment arm for each fiber-line force 8P is the coordinate value u,
and the sum of the moments is M: M = sum of [u(sn)6A1
(7-3)
Again referring to Figure 7-5 and recalling the beam-material model, if the in-plane bending does not take any fiber beyond its elastic limit, the value of is proportional to the distance between the neutral axis and the fiber-line (which is, again, the coordinate value u). Using this proportion, Equation 7-3 may be rewritten: Sfl
M = —[sum of (u 2SAfl
(7-4)
The quantity in brackets is a geometric parameter of the beam cross-section; it is termed a second momenf of the cross-sectional area and is often symbolized by the letter I. The ratio of Ito c, where c is one-half of the beam depth measured in the plane of bending, is known as the secf ion modulus for the cross-section. Values for the second moment of area and the section modulus are given in Figure 7-10 for circular and rectangular cross-sections; note that, with the loading plane vertical with respect to the sketches, the beam depths 2c are the diameter and the dimension h for the circular and rectangular cross-sections, respectively. Returning to Equation 7-3, the ratio of bending stress to coordinate u may be written as Sn: u
=
(sn)max : c
(75)
247
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending For the circular cross-section:
For the rectangular cross-section: b(h3)
64
and
and
c
c
32 d
6 h
where c = —
h
FIGURE 7-10. Second moments of area I arid section moduli I/c for circular and rectangular cross-sections.
The
desired equation may now be expressed in either of two forms: M=
= (Sn)max1
(76)
This equation relates M, the bending stress in a particular line of fibers (perpendicular to the plane of bending), and a geometric parameter of the cross-section (generally a constant throughout the beam length). The arch-wire-beam activation ordinarily should be fully elastic in order that the totally deactivated and pre-load passive configurations are identical. Accordingly, the maximum magnitude of loading to be exerted on the beam, without anywhere exceeding the elastic limit of the beam material, is of interest. This quantity is known as the elastic strength in bending. From the form of Equation 7-6 and Figure 7-8, the maximum
fiber stresses on a cross-section are located at the points farthest from the neutral axis, and these maximum stresses are proportional to the value of M. Considering the entire beam, the elastic strength depends on the maximum value of M, the internal bending couple at the "critical cross-section," which is dependent on the loading and manner of support of the beam and its longitudinal geometry. Accordingly, the elastic strength may be expressed analytically by setting the maximum bending stress in Equation 7-6 equal to the elastic limit value for the beam material (in tension or compression), and specifying the critical cross-section:
248
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
= (Sn)erL
(74)
The critical bending couple is, therefore, computed from mechanical and geometric property values for the beam. The relationship between and the loading parameters is obtained from a free-body analysis of one of the two beam segments isolated by "cutting" the whole member at its critical section. Finally, then, the elastic strength of a given beam subjected to a particular loading configuration may be determined as maximum or limiting values of parameters associated with the active force systems.
Beam Stiffnesses The theory of elastic bending has its origins in experimental observation
and research proceeding to an empirical development. The initially straight member takes on a curved form when activated or loaded, with the associated deformations largely expressible in terms of the shape of the longitudinal beam axis. Passively plane right cross-sections have
been found to remain plane with activation for problems of interest, even when the deformations are substantial, leading to a simple, linear fiber-strain pattern (see Fig. 7-5). Hooke's law then provides the bending-stress distribution on a cross-section; the resultant is the internal bending couple. This couple is related to the external force system exerted on the beam through force and moment balances. To this point in
the discussion, three governing relationships have been mentioned which contain variables dependent on the longitudinal coordinate x: (1) the curvature of the beam axis and the u-coordinate provide the fiber strains; (2) fiber stresses are everywhere proportional to fiber strains; and (3) the internal bending couple is obtained from the bending-stress distribution and the cross-sectional geometry. An explicit expression, or a set of expressions, for the deformations
of the activated beam, in terms of the beam material, geometry, and loading, is now required. An intermediate result is obtained from eliminating and u from the aforementioned three relationships; or
M=(EI)k
(7-8)
In essence, this equation interrelates deformation (k), force (M), and stiffness (El) parameters; the first two are generally dependent on x, but the third is a constant and is known as the unit bending stiffness. The next step in the derivation eliminates k in favor of its differential expression in terms of z and x and, although the subsequent mathematical operations
are beyond the scope of this discussion, several associated comments are appropriate. First, relatively simple equations are obtained only when the slope of the beam axis is, for all x values, small compared to
249
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
unity (0 less than 45°), and when longitudinal-dimension changes with
activation are negligible; therefore, in invoking these restrictions, the result is a small-deformation theory. Second, the mathematical procedures that must be undertaken yield equations for both the cross-section-rotation parameter 0 and the transverse deflection z. In these derivations use is made of physical constraints to the actual deformations that exist along the beam; such constraints are integral in the supports of the beam and, for the arch-wire beam, exist where the wire engages the brackets or buccal tubes. Third, a number of assumptions involving geometry and material have been made and it is well to recall the list here: cross-sectional symmetry; in-plane bending; elastic activation; Hookean material; and values of the elastic modulus F equal in tension and compression. The split-anchorage, arch-wire beam of Figure 7-1 again serves well as an illustrative example. The span is 2L and the bracket-wire clearances are assumed sufficiently large that transverse forces alone are developed upon activation. With midspan loading, the responsive forces at the anchorage locations have magnitudes that are each one-half that of the active point load. Given is the magnitude of the midspan deflection necessary to activate the member; in perspective, the occlusogingival or faciolingual crown malalignment of a canine or premolar has been measured. If the midspan, transverse stiffness of the wire beam can be determined, and the activation is totally elastic, the product of this stiff-
ness and the activating displacement is the magnitude of the midspan load.
With the external force analysis completed for the entire beam in terms of the applied force F, the next step is the determination of the bending couple on an arbitrary cross-section as a function of P and x. An x-z-coordinate frame is established with its origin taken, for example, at the left-support position with the x-axis coincident with the passive con-
figuration of the beam axis. The undeformed (dashed) and deformed (solid) beam configurations and the reference frame are shown in Figure 7-11. Because of the geometric and mechanical symmetry in the example problem with respect to the midspan cross-section, the M-diagram (Fig. 7-7) and the transverse-deflection pattern exhibit the same symmetry.
z
FIGURE 7-11. An x-z-coordinate frame superimposed upon the passive (dashed) and activated (solid) configurations of the longitudinal beam axis for the Figure 7-1 example.
250
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
With the slope of the beam axis horizontal at midspan and the symme-
try, in effect the solution may be pursued from this point using only one-half of the beam. The equation for the couple M is written from free-body analyses of segments of the beam, or obtained from the M-diagram, and substituted in Equation 7-8. The curvature k is then expressed implicitly in terms of z and x as noted previously, and subsequent mathematical operations yield equations for 0 and z. In the example given,
the equation of interest is PL3
or
P
LEJ
(7-9)
obtained by substituting x = L into the more general expression. A linear relationship between P and z is noted and the ratio of P to z is the midspan, transverse-stiffness equation desired. This stiffness is seen to be directly proportional to the unit bending stiffness El and inversely proportional to a power of the characteristic, longitudinal dimension. With these quantities determined for the wire beam selected and the malalignment (z at x = L) measured, Equation 7-9 provides the value of P and the forces transmitted to anchorage also become known. From the results of this example problem the parametric influences on bending stiffnesses may be discussed in general. A first effect is that of beam material with stiffness proportional to Young's modulus E. A second influence is that of the size and shape of the cross-section. Because the parameter I is a fourth-power function of the cross-sectional dimensions, small changes in cross-section can substantially affect the bending stiffness. For instance, due to the differences in values of I, replacement of a round wire by a square wire having an edge length equal to the round-wire diameter increases the bending stiffness by 70%. Third, a characteristic beam length or span has sizable impact on bending stiffness. In arch-wire bending, this influence is largely that of inter-
bracket distance. In the point-load example, the third power of the length appears in the transverse-stiffness formula; in general, as will be
seen, this L-influence will be determined by the type of loading and which stiffness (transverse or rotational) is being computed. Two other considerations related to the example problem are of interest. First is the influence of the position of the load between the supports upon the transverse stiffness at the beam-axis point under that load. For purposes of comparison, shown in Figure 7-12 is the example beam with the load moved from midspan, left to the one-third-span location. The free-body diagram indicates that the mechanical symmetry is no longer present; the desired stiffness is given in the sketch. A comparison of the expression with Equation 7-9 shows that a lateral shift in the load position a distance equal to 17% of the span (214 results in an increase of
about 27% in the stiffness. Second is the influence of the presence or absence of second-order clearances at anchorage in occlusogingival bending (or first-order clearances in faciolingual bending). Figure 7-13 depicts the original example problem once more, except
251
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
At x = P
P
2L
(El
= 7.6k
L3
I
I
3
3
3
FIGURE 7-12. The split-anchorage example beam with the applied, transverse force moved to the one-third-span location: a free-body diagram of the entire beam and the expression for the transverse stiffness at the load site (above, right).
At x = L: P
x
4c' P
4
FIGURE 7-13. The split-anchorage example beam with no rotational deformation permitted at its ends: a free-body diagram of the entire beam and the expression for the transverse stiffness at the load site (above, right).
_________ 252
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
that the supports permit no beam rotations at those locations (indicative
of zero second-order clearance if the figure shows a facial view). The free-body diagram reflects the presence of couples as part of the support responses; in effect, these couples oppose the rotational tendencies. With the additional constraints on the shape of the deformed beam axis—
its slope forced to be zero at the supports—the stiffness should be expected to rise compared to that expressed in Equation 7-8. Indeed, the transverse, midspan stiffness given on the right in Figure 7-13 for the beam having "fixed ends" is four times that for the same beam material, length, and cross-section, but with ample clearance permitting end rotations.
Additional Topics in Elastic Bending With elastic strength and stiffness defined, a third structural parameter
of interest in bending is elastic range. A counterpart to elastic strength,
range is the maximum measure of a flexural deformation which the beam can experience without an inelastic response occurring somewhere in the member. Hence, elastic strength is directly associated with load and elastic range with the corresponding deformation. In the splitanchorage problem of Figure 7-1, the range of interest is the maximum, elastic, transverse deflection at midspan. The M-diagram indicates the largest bending stresses in the beam to be at midspan, the location of the is equal to PLI2 (Fig. 7-7). The elastic critical cross-section, and range is obtained by first substituting for PLI2 in Equation 7-9 and then eliminating Mcrjt from the resulting expression using Equation 7-7. The largest, elastic midspan deflection may then be expressed as (Sn)eiL2
3Ec
or
(7-10)
In general, elastic range is influenced by the characteristic length dimension, the beam depth in the plane of bending, and elastic-limit strain for the beam material. The power to which the length dimension is raised in the range expression is always one less than that appearing in the corresponding stiffness equation. Instead of the elastic-limit strain, the ratio of elastic-limit stress to modulus of elasticity is often explicit in the range equation; these two mechanical properties are typically more readily available, from reference materials or experimental data, than is the strain value. The existence or amount of second-order clearance at the supports affects the range as well as the stiffness. If the beam is fixed or "built-in" at both ends such that no second-order clearance is present at either site, the value of is lessened to PL/4 and the
253
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
elastic range becomes (Sn)eiL2
6Ec
or
(eu)eiL2
6c
(7-11)
For the same reason that the stiffness was increased, the elastic range is reduced when rotational beam deformation is constrained. In this example, requiring the beam-axis curvature to be zero and exhibit horizontal slope at its ends results in a 50% reduction in range. Elastic range and strength are significant parameters in beam analysis and design because they signify the onset of inelastic material behavior. In the discussion of orthodontic bending, because the actual loading is often induced by a transverse or rotational deformation, range is perhaps the more important of the two. However, because arch-wire activation should normally not produce inelastic bending, the pertinent of the
two parameters (depending upon the loading) should be known or quantified before engagement of the wire. Because of the interrelationship among range, stiffness, and strength, with second- (or first-) order clearance already seen as influencing the first two, it affects strength as well. Just noted was the halving of in the example problem, as it relates to the load on the beam, by eliminating that clearance at both supports. Returning to Figure 7-7 and recalling Equation 7-7, making no changes in the example problem other than eliminating clearances at the supports results in a twofold increase in the critical value of the load P (the elastic strength). Typically, alterations in bending parameters that raise (lower) beam stiffness will also raise (lower) the corresponding elastic strength and concurrently lower (raise) the elastic range. Thus far the discussion of bending behavior has concentrated on the beam having split anchorage and subjected to a transverse, point load applied between the supports. Two additional problems having orthodontic application are the split-anchorage beam under in-plane, couple loading and the cantilevered beam activated by either a transverse, concentrated load or a couple at its "free" end. As with the example problem, of interest are the anchorage responses, the locations of the critical cross-sections and the associated, internal bending couples, the stiffnesses, ranges, and strengths, and appropriate comparisons among results. Shown in the upper sketch in Figure 7-14 is the free-body diagram of a beam of span 2L activated by an external bending couple of magnitude M0. (The loading may either be an applied couple, or the couple induced as a result of a clockwise, midspan, rotational deformation On.) Rotational clearances are ample at the supports and the antisymmetry of the deformed member helps in determining the responsive forces at the ends of the beam. The internal bending couple is zero at each beam end, increases linearly toward the middle cross-section, and at midspan it "jumps" an amount equal to M0; the value of is M012. The stiffness of interest is the ratio of the applied-induced couple to the cross-sec-
254
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
M0
2L
M0
M0
2L
x
L
z
3M0
3M0
4L
L
z
FIGURE 7-14. Free-body diagrams of split-anchorage beams subjected to couple loading at mids pan. No rotational resistance at the anchorage sites exists for the beam in the upper sketch; the anchorage prevents rotation of the ends of the beam in the lower sketch.
tional rotation at midspan and the relationship is M0
6E1
00
L
or
00=
M0L (6E1)
(7-12)
The cross-sectional, rotational range for this beam is (Sn)eiL
(en)eiL
or
3Ec
3c
(7-13)
and the elastic strength may be expressed as M0 =
I 2(Sn)e1
(7-14)
255
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
Shown in the lower sketch in Figure 7-14 is the same beam except that no cross-sectional, rotational clearance exists at either end support, and as a result the anchorage response includes a couple in addition to the transverse force at each end of the beam. Computations of the values of the responsive components require the use of indeterminate-beamanalysis methods and the constraints of zero slope of the beam axis at its ends. The relationship between couple and cross-sectional rotation at midspan for this beam is M0
8E1
M0L
or
=
00
=
(7-15)
8E1
and the rotational range is (en)eiL
or
(7-16)
Pertinent here is a comparison of stiffnesses and ranges for the beams that are identical except for clearances at the anchorage sites; constraining the cross-sectional rotations at the ends of the member results in a 33% increase in stiffness and the same percentage decrease in elastic range. Also of particular note is that the elimination of rotational clearances at the beam ends has no effect on the critical bending couple and, therefore, the elastic strengths are equal for the two beams. Free-body diagrams of cantilevered beams are shown in Figure 7-15. Because of the existence of just one anchorage site (support), prevention
of both rotational and translational displacements must be present there. Although some small amount of cross-sectional, rotational clearance could exist in reality, the equations to follow assume a complete constraint and, therefore, zero slope of the beam axis at its left end. The support response against the beam on the left in the figure includes the expected, transverse force and couple, and the internal bending couple
P
= PL
=M0
L
z
7-15. Free-body diagrams of beams cantilevered from their left ends. The free-end loads are a transverse force exerted on the beam at left and an in-plane couple on the beam at right. FIGURE
_________ 256
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
varies with x in a linear manner from zero at the right end of the member
to the maximum, value of PL at the built-in, left-end support. On the other hand, the same beam on the right is loaded by a concentrated couple at its free end and, with no net potential in the load to translate the member, the response at the support is just an opposing couple. The internal bending couple is unchanged from one cross-section to another along the beam length (pure bending throughout); hence, even if the applied couple M0 loading one beam was equal in magnitude to the product PL for the other beam, the differences in M-diagrams indicate unlike responses of the two, perhaps otherwise identical, members to their loadings. For the beam on the left in Figure 7-15, the stiffness of interest is the
ratio of the load to the transverse deflection of the free end and the relationship is P
3E1
or
PL3
(7-17)
The cross-sectional rotation of the free end of the same beam is (7-18)
Of
therefore, at least this amount of rotational clearance must be present within whatever maintains the activation (e.g., a bracket) if the loading is not to also include a couple. The range of interest in this example is the largest, transverse, free-end deflection that will induce maximum fiber (bending) stresses at the left end not exceeding the elastic limit of the beam material, and that range is or
3Ec
(7-19)
With Mcrit equal to PL at the built-in end of the cantilever, the elastic strength of the beam is P = (sn)ei4
(7-20)
For the cantilevered beam subjected to pure bending on the right in Figure 7-15, the rotational stiffness of its free end is M0
El
or
M0L
(7-21)
and the corresponding transverse deflection is = (7-22)
257
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
(Unless
the transverse position of the right end of the beam is main-
tained by some partial support that would exert a vertical force upward and, by its presence, change the problem entirely, a transverse deflection downward is induced by the given loading.) The range for crosssectional rotations of the free end of this beam is (Sn)eiL
Ec
and, with
or
(en)eiL
(7-23)
C
equal to M0, its elastic strength is given by = (Sn)e11
(7-24)
of Elastic Beam Theory to Orthodontic Arch-Wire in Bending I
The orthodontic appliance is activated by imposing on a passive configu-
ration the deformation of one or more elements of that appliance. The deformations of metallic elements are characteristically bending or twisting; the former predominates. Examples of bending activations are those of arch wires in occlusogingival and faciolingual leveling procedures, utility arches used to intrude or extrude incisal segments, and cantilevered arch-wire segments used to displace individual teeth. Responsive bending deformations also occur in, for example, a face bow in the activation of a cervical-pull headgear and in the buccal-segment portions of an arch wire into which anterior torque has been induced. The majority of orthodontic wire loops are activated in bending. Note that under consideration here is the deformation imposed following whatever forming of the as-received member is undertaken by the practitioner. Although such forming procedures take the material beyond its elastic limit and result in geometric alterations from the as-received configuration, the activating deformation is intended to be elastic in nature. Inelastic bending is discussed in a subsequent section of this chapter. The question arises regarding the validity of applying an engineering bending theory to orthodontic arch wires, inasmuch as these members have very small cross-sectional dimensions compared to the typical structural member. Note that, within the theory, the format of the elastic bending-stress distribution, exhibiting a linear variation from the neutral surface, is as simple as the resultant, internal-force analysis and the continuity of strains will permit. To be sure, the imposition of residual stresses in the manufacturing process and in the placements of bends and twists, prior to appliance engagement, will have some effect on the subsequent structural behavior of the activated wire, but such influences of substance are usually localized and reflected directly in the mechanical properties of the wire material. Arch-wire-bending experimen-
258
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
tation with straight segments has resulted in reasonable agreement between theoretical predictions and actual measurements, provided the deformations are small and assuming Young's modulus in bending is equal to the magnitude of the material stiffness derived from a tensile
test.
The ADA specification for orthodontic wire, discussed briefly in Chapter 3, includes an elastic-bending (flexure) evaluation and the theory wherein the pattern of couple loading versus cross-sectional rotation is examined and structural properties are determined. Although the theory has apparently been accepted by the orthodontic community, care must be taken to avoid exceeding the limits of its applicability. The theory will yield erroneous results when the activating deformations are substantial; its accuracy is suspect, for example, when a transverse deflection of a continuous arch wire exceeds in magnitude that of an adjacent interbracket distance or one-half of the distance between supports in a split-anchorage arrangement. In addition, the theory as discussed here applies, in a strict sense, only to passively straight beams. To this point, the arch-form curvatures of continuous wires across the incisal segment and throughout the posterior segments are not locally severe and are present only in the occlusal plane. The arch-wire model introduced in Chapter 6 suggests that only in the vicinity of the canines is the curvature sufficient to void practical use of the theory. The presence
within the beam span of a permanent bend however, may affect the accuracy of a theoretical analysis in the plane of that bend and, in particular, at the specific location of the bend. In an overall analysis, the inf usion of error originates not so much with the residual stresses, which are usually highly localized, but rather with the change in passive geometry associated with the bend placement. The selection of an arch wire for use in an appliance, for which the Th activation will result in bending deformation of that wire, must be based primarily upon its structural characteristics in bending. The most important parameter is stiffness, which is not only the key to the solution of the indeterminate problem but also provides the elastic activation and
deactivation rates (load per unit of deformation) in bending. Elastic range is significant because prevention of inelasticity during activation is desirable. If the load to be applied is measurable, the strength parameter
provides an upper bound for an elastic activation. Appearing in the bending formulas of this chapter are the modulus of elasticity E and the stress and strain values at the elastic limit. Young's modulus is affected
only slightly, but the elastic-limit coordinates may be substantially changed, by strain-hardening or heat treatment of the arch wire prior to in-service use. The recent additions of nickel-titanium and titanium-molybdenum alloys to the list of available orthodontic-wire materials has broadened the spectrum of values of all three cited mechanical properties. The three structural characteristics are also dependent on wire geometry, more specifically on the cross-sectional dimensions, the shape of the cross-section, and length (span) dimensions. The dependence of stiffness, range, and strength in elastic bending upon arch-wire geomet-
259
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending TABLE 7-1. Dependence of stiffness, range, and strength in bending upon material and geometric properties of round and rectangular wires
Cross-section Material
L3
tr*
Stiffness
rot
E
tr
Range
Strength
ro
Length
L1 L2
(Sn)ei(E1)
tr
L
Round
Rectangular
d4
b(h3)
d1
h
d3
b(h2)
L (Sn)ei
ro
0
*tr; Deformaton is transverse deflection. tro: Deformation is cross-section rotation.
nc and material properties, for both transverse-deflection and cross-sec-
tional-rotational formats, but restricted to solid (single-strand) wires, is given in Table 7-1.
Additional comments regarding cross-sectional geometry are in order here. Note was previously made of the influence of shape and the fact that, because of the additional material present, the bending stiffness of a square wire is potentially greater than that of the round wire,
the two cross-sections having equal depth dimensions. Rectangular wires also exhibit greater strength; however, since only the beam depth is the cross-sectional influence in the range formulas, shape does not impact elastic range. In addition, the differences in the two dimensions of a rectangular (nonsquare) wire produce, for a given orientation of the wire in the brackets, differences in the structural bending properties for occlusogingival versus faciolingual bending. Still another influencing factor is the physical configuration of the wire, be it solid, layered, or stranded. Because in layered or stranded wire the longitudinal elements may slide somewhat with respect to one another upon activation (and deactivation), for a particular overall cross-sectional size and shape, these wires exhibit less strength, greater range, and, most significantly, lower stiffness than their solid counterparts. Braided stainless-steel wire is available in both round and rectangular cross-sections and will take
some permanent bending, exhibiting ductility, without substantially compromising the braiding. Without the use of loops placed in the wire, the practitioner is generally unable to vary the longitudinal dimension(s) of the arch-wire beam to take advantage of the influence of this geometric parameter upon the structural properties under consideration. Except when using a specialized cantilever or when leaving a particular tooth or segment out of the activation, the mesiodistal geometry of the dentition controls the archwire beam spans. From a practical standpoint, then, a quantitative ex-
260
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
TABLE 7-2. Effect of material of a solid arch wire, activated in bending by a transverse force, upon stiffness, range, and strength
Stiffness*
Range*
Strength*
0.52
0.97
0.54
steel
1
1
1
Elgiloy (Cr-Co alloy)
0.98
1.13
1.11
Nitinol (Ni-Ti alloy)
0.17
4.2
0.70
Beta titanium (Ti-Mo alloy)
0.33
1 .86
0.61
Material
A gold alloy
Type 302 stainless
'Given figures are not actual values, but, in each column, are compared to a typical value for the stainless steel.
amination of the effects of material and cross-sectional size and shape
upon stiffness, range, strength in bending is appropriate. Table 7-2 presents the comparative influences of five wire materials, considering wire beams having all other characteristics identical and taking stainless steel as the reference material (setting its three property values each equal to unity). Table 7-3 examines the impact of cross-sectional geometry comparing solid round and rectangular beams having all other characteristics identical. The smaller cross-sectional dimension of each nonsquare, rectangular wire is assumed oriented occiusogingivally. Values of the
parameters are, in each column, normalized with respect to a noted reference wire and, where pertinent, the plane of bending. The fact that the second moment of area (I) varies with the fourth power of the crosssectional dimensions causes the substantial differences in stiffness and
strength between the smallest and largest wires listed, even though their depth dimensions differ by a factor not greater than two. One additional influencing factor, referred to earlier in the stiffness discussion, is the location of the load between specific, split-anchorage positions. An illustrative orthodontic example is associated with the distal displacement of a canine into a first-premolar extraction site, using an arch wire for guidance. The wire beam is supported anteriorly by the incisors and also on each side by a posterior segment. Considering the
half arch (one side), the primary load on the wire is a second-order couple exerted by the canine bracket, created as the tooth tends to tip under the action of the distal driving force. With no anchorage loss, the
261
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending TABLE 7-3. Influence of cross-sectional dimensions of the arch wire upon stiffness, range, and strength in occiusogingiva! and faciolingual bending by a transverse force
Stiffness
Range
Strength
1*
1.5
1*
1.7
1.3
1.5
2.7 4,2
1.2
2.1
1.1
6.1
1.0
2.9 3.9
.016 x .016
2.9
1.3
2.5
.016 x .022 ogt .016 x .022
4.0
1.3
7.6
1.0
3.5 4.8
.017 x .025 og .017 x .025 fI
5.4 11.8
0.9
.019 x .026 og .019 x .026 fI
7.9
1.1
14.8
0.8
Wire size (in.) .014 .016 .018 .020 .022
round round round round round
.0215 x .0275 og .0215 x .0275 Ii
1.3
12.1
1*
19.8
0.8
4.5 6.6 5.8 7.9 7.9 10.0
*Given figures are not actual values, but, in each column, are compared to the value for the wire indicated by the asterisk (*)
tog: Occiusogingival bending. 4f1: Faciolingual bending.
tooth, and with it the couple, move an average distance of 7 mm in the
retraction process, assuming approximately 20 mm (mesiodistally) between lateral-incisor and second-premolar bracket centers. Although a detailed consideration of such a moving-load problem is too complex to include here, the closer the load is to either anchorage site, the higher
are the relevant bending stiffness and strength and the lower is the range. In the canine retraction example, none of the three parameters changes with canine position as much as 30%; therefore, a reasonable, approximate analysis may be undertaken with the canine located mid-
way through its intended displacement: at the midspan location between the anchorage sites.
elastic Behavior in Bending fundamental, characteristic bending deformation is the rotation of one beam cross-section relative to a neighboring cross-section. The beam
The
fibers that are farthest from the neutral surface of the member experience the largest bending strains and, if the relative rotation becomes sufficiently great, the extreme fibers under tensile stress can rupture and a progressive failure of the entire member by fracture may be initiated. If
262
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodonfic Mechanics
the beam material is metallic and ductile, however, as is true of many
orthodontic, arch-wire materials, the stretched fibers can experience substantial strain beyond their elastic limit without rupture, and thereby enable the placement of permanent bends. In plane bending of a straight beam the fiber strains have been noted to increase linearly with distance from the neutral surface (see Fig. 7-5). If the beam material obeys Hooke's law, then the fiber-stress pattern is the same as that for the bending strains with the limit of Hookean be-
havior approximately coinciding with the generation of elastic-limit stresses in the extreme fibers. Whenever the beam loading exceeds the elastic-strength level, however, some extreme fibers are strained beyond their elastic limit and, upon unloading, a portion of the relative rotation remains and the member exhibits permanent deformation (with respect to the previous, passive shape). The beam has been permanently bent. In the fabrication by the practitioner of an arch wire from an as-received, straight piece of wire, permanent bending deformation is widely distrib-
uted over at least the anterior portion of the wire as the arch form is prepared. At any cross-section in the anterior region, the permanent bend may be far from severe. On the other hand, the placement of a loop in that wire requires localized bends that take the wire material substantially beyond its elastic limit and, therefore, demands considerable ductility.
Experimental investigations of the bending behavior of structural members have shown that often beam cross-sections remain plane (do not warp) under load, even when the load produces a moderate amount of inelastic action. In other words, the strain pattern remains linear well beyond the elastic limit of the beam material and through substantial cross-sectional rotations. For metals, however, the slope of the typical stress-strain diagram decreases after the elastic limit is exceeded: hence, taking a metallic beam beyond its elastic limit results in a nonlinear bending-stress pattern such as that shown on the left in Figure 7-16. Because of the linear relationship between fiber strain and the coordinate u, inelastic behavior and stress nonlinearity begin in the extreme fibers and proceed toward the neutral surface as the load is increased beyond the elastic strength. The portion of the cross-section incorporating the fibers not strained to the elastic limit is known as the elastic core, as indicated in the figure. Note that even with inelastic behavior the antisymmetry of the bending-stress pattern remains for the round and rectangular beam cross-sections. The sketches on the left in Figure 7-16 depict the rotational deformation and bending-stress patterns of the loaded (activated) beam. As verified by bench experimentation, deactivation from this state is tanta-
mount to superimposing a reversed, totally elastic loading on the activated configuration. In other words, the resulting bending-stress pattern upon partial unloading is obtained by, in effect, subtracting the stresses of Figure 7-5 from those shown on the left in Figure 7-16. If unloading is continued to its completion, the extreme fibers reach the zero stress state before the load is totally withdrawn and subsequently
263
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
Elastic
core
N (5n)max
FIGURE 7-16. Bending deformation and stress patterns associated with inelastic bending: cross-sectional rotation and bending-stress pattern of the activated state (left) and permanent rotation and remaining residual bending stresses following total deactivation (right).
undergo a reversal of stress. A residual-stress pattern of the form shown
on the right in Figure 7-16 ultimately accompanies the permanent bend
induced. The pattern indicates a reversal in sense of the stresses (as load-induced) in fibers distant to the neutral surface and the incomplete unloading of fibers within the elastic core near the neutral surface. The resultant of this residual-stress distribution may be expressed as four longitudinal forces (two couples) that must exactly cancel one another in
the final reduction to yield a net internal bending couple M of zero magnitude. Typically in orthodontic therapy, the placement of first- and secondorder bends in the arch wire is followed by engagement of that wire. An activation, then, intended to be elastic, is superimposed on prior inelastic action. Because the bend placements produce the residual-bending-
stress patterns just discussed and result in additional strain energy "locked" into the wire, some alterations in structural properties have occurred and the response to activation of the bent wire will be changed somewhat in comparison to that of an otherwise identical, straight wire.
In general, the described inelastic action, upon unloading, results in increased elastic range and strength and reduced ductility. The severity of the permanent deformation, how localized or widely distributed it is, and the longitudinal position and extent of that deformation with respect to the activating load and anchorage, are significant. Of substantial importance also is the directional nature of the effects of bend placements and, therefore, the direction-sense relationships of the bends to the activation. For example, if the permanent bend is second-order, the responses during activation will differ, depending on whether the activating, superimposed bending action is in the same direction and sense, in the same direction but opposite sense, or in another (e.g., the first-
264
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
order) direction. Quantification of these property changes appears to be
virtually impossible, but further consideration of the phenomena is contained in the section that follows.
Orthodontic Wire Loops Although the orthodontic arch wire is often activated in bending to
create faciolingual or occiusogingival tooth movement, routine mesiodistal displacements through arch-wire deformation cannot be accomplished directly because of the extremely high longitudinal stiffness of wire. To reduce this stiffness at a specific location, a wire loop may be incorporated in the arch, effectively providing a spring of manageable flexibility between segments of the arch wire. In general, the orthodontic wire loop may be bent directly into the continuous arch wire, or a loop or spring may be fabricated from a piece of wire and activated between a pair of neighboring teeth. The "legs" of a wire loop extend occiusogingivally from the arch-form plane into the "body" of the loop, the shape of which serves to primarily characterize the loop. The loop having the simplest geometry is shown in Figure 7-17. Generally, this ioop is wholly contained in one plane, its body gingival to the line of bracket slots, and its position usually within the interbracket space between adjacent teeth. The loop shape is attained by the placement of localized bends in a straight piece of wire; hence, the wire material must exhibit substantial ductility to sustain such inelastic strains without fracture. Again, the basic rationale for incorporating loops in appliances is to gain mesiodistal flexibility, although some loops simply serve as stops or as hooks along the arch wire. A typical wire ioop is characterized by the size, shape, and material
F
FIGURE
(right).
F
7-17. A simple wire loop: passive (left) and activated by mesiodistal pulling
_____ 265
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
'Teardrop"
FIGURE 7-18. Orthodontic wire loops: 'teardrop," '7," "L, ' and "box," from left to right.
from which it is fabricated, its overall occiusogingival dimension, its
as-formed geometry, and whether it "opens" or "closes" when activated mesiodistally. Several loop geometries are shown in Figure 7-18, and the association of names such as "teardrop," "T," "L," and "box" is usually made by viewing the individual sketches. The loop in Figure
7-17 and three of the four loops in Figure 7-18 are termed "opening loops;" the area within the loop form tends to enlarge and many (or all) of the bends tend toward reductions in curvature as the loop is activated mesiodistally by pulling action. On the other hand, the same activation of the box loop in Figure 7-18 results in a reduction of the area within the rectangular geometry and two of the four bends tend toward increased curvature; this loop is described as a "closing loop." Several properties influence the mesiodistal stiffness of a wire loop. Figure 7-19 serves to define this stiffness in terms of load and deformation parameters and, as indicated by the diagram, below the elastic limit
a
Activation a
FIGURE 7-19. The mesiodistal-pulling activation of a loop (left) and the associated force-deformation pattern including the graphic definition of the pertinent stiffness (right).
266
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
the loop reflects the Hookean behavior of its material. Because the load-
ing of the ioop produces bending deformation, this stiffness is affected by the wire material (through its modulus of elasticity E) and by the size and shape of the cross-section (through the parameter I). The curvilinear length of wire within the ioop is also highly influential: the more wire present in the ioop, the lower the stiffness. Also impacting stiffness
are the number and severity of bend placements, the procedures in forming the bends and the overall loop geometry, and the relationships between direction and sense of activation and those of the bend placements in fabrication. Strictly speaking, two mesiodistal stiffnesses must be noted, inasmuch as mesiodistal activation may be pulling or pushing, the latter depicted on the left in Figure 7-20; these stiffnesses are generally unequal due to the presence of residual-sfress patterns left by fabrication of the loop. Unfortunately, the influences on stiffness are too complex to permit an analytic determination; desired quantifications must be obtained experimentally. Although the foregoing discussion pertains to mesiodistal loop stiffnesses, noteworthy in addition is the potential, multifaceted nature of loop activation and the possible involvement of as many stiffnesses as there are modes of activation. As can be seen on the right in Figure 7-17, upon mesiodistal pulling activation the permanent bends at the base of the loop tend to remain generally as bent (because the internal bending couples there from mesiodistal activation are small) and a second-order phenomenon appears. If appropriate compensation is not provided in loop formation, second-order couples arise in the presence of inadequate wire-bracket clearances. The magnitudes of these tipping couples depend heavily on the passive angulations of the loop legs with respect to one another, the associated stiffness, the amount of mesiodistal activation, and the second-order clearances. Although not inherent in the typical loop, first-order angulation can be incorporated in the leg fabrication to enable the generation of first-order-couple action upon engagement.
Q
p
P
C, C
FIGURE 7-20. Loop activations other than by mesiodistal pulling: the opening of a simple reverse-closing loop by mesiodistal pushing (left) and an occiusogingival activation of a stepped "L' loop (right).
267
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
Another mode of activation is introduced by fabricating a passive "step," either occiusogingivally as shown on the right in Figure 7-20 or faciolingually. The magnitude of the occiusogingival forces shown as
part of the activation force systems will depend upon the size of the step, the related stiffness, and the amount of occlusogingival activation. The loop containing a faciolingual step, or the loop formed in rectangular wire and passively exhibiting a third-order, relative angulation between leg ends, may undergo torsional as well as bending deformations
upon activation, and will be discussed further in Chapter 9. In summary, all of the individual stiffnesses are generally influenced by the wire and loop properties already mentioned. The previous section of this chapter dealt with inelastic bending and the residual-stress pattern induced with the placement of a permanent bend was noted. The typical orthodontic loop is a composite of straight and bent portions of an initially straight segment of wire. An activation of a ioop may tend to increase or decrease the curvature of a specific permanent bend, and the sense of that activation apparently has an influence on the associated stiffness related to the residual-stress pattern left by fabrication (see Fig. 7-16). In fact, in identical mesiodistal activa-
tions, the closing-loop counterpart of the opening loop of Figure 7-17 has been shown to exhibit a greater mesiodistal pulling stiffness, even though the closing ioop contains slightly more wire (Lane and Nikolai, 1980). Furthermore, the severity of the permanent bend, in terms of the as-bent curvature of the beam axis at the bend, interacting with the beam depth, may also impact stiffnesses, including those akin to firstand second-order effects. Upon activation, much of the deformation seems to occur within the straight sections of the loop while the permanent bends tend to retain their bent shapes. To enhance flexibility, at locations of bends through angles of 90° or greater within the loop, helices may be incorporated. In the typical loop the localized mesiodistal and second-order stiffnesses may be reduced by the presence of helices; apparently most influential is
the increase in curvilinear length of wire necessarily accompanying a helix. Helices placed where the ioop legs blend into the arch form can reduce the potential of a loop to tip teeth adjacent to it. Furthermore, depending on loop geometry, the presence of a helix may affect other stiffnesses as well. For example, the loop of Figure 7-17 depends somewhat for its activation on the opening of the angle between its legs. Comparing it with the loop of Figure 7-21, the incorporation of the helix in the loop body increases the mesiodistal flexibility while the helices at the base of the loop in particular reduce second-order stiffnesses and the tipping potential just previously noted. The mesiodistal elastic ranges of a ioop are influenced, like the associated stiffnesses, by properties of the wire and the loop geometry; analogous to the straight-wire bending discussion, the impact upon a range of the wire depth dimension in the plane of bending is not as great as it is upon stiffness. A particularly important influence on loQp range is the severity of the bend(s) in the body of the ioop. The free-body diagram of Figure 7-22 shows the location and relative size of the critical, internal
268
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
F
F
FIGURE 7-21. An opening loop containing he/ices: passive (left) and activated by mesiodistal pulling (right).
bending couple within a teardrop ioop. The maximum bending strains
induced on activation are found within a permanent bend where residual bending stresses also exist. Of concern is not only an activation possibly taking the wire material within this bend beyond the elastic limit,
Mcrut
P
FIGURE 7-22. A free-body diagram of one-ha/f of the loop of Figure 7-17 showing the location of and an expression for the critical internal bending couple.
269
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending TABLE 7-4. Typical values of stiffness and elastic range for stainless-steel wire loops subjected to mesiodistal-pulling activation*
Loop description
Wire Size (mils)
Wire
in loop
Stiffness (gm/mm)
Range (mm)
(mm)
17 x 25 21 x 25
Teardrop
14
325 525
1.7 1.8
17 x 25 21 x 25
Bulbous
15
275 430
2.0
17 x 25 21 x 25
Reverseclosing
17,5
355 610
2.3 2.5
17 x 25 21 x 25
Reverse-closing with Helix
25
245 455
2.5 2.9
1.9
From Engel, EL. (1977). Notes:
The occiusogingival height of all loops was approximately 6.5 mm. None of the loops was stress-relieved following fabrication. The above stiffness and range magnitudes are averages involving several vendors' wires.
but also that the bend placement has locally embrittled the wire mate-
rial, substantially reducing ductility within the bend. Accordingly, care should be taken both to limit the severity of bends within the body of the loop and to activate the loop to a state somewhat below its predetermined elastic range. Table 7-4 contains approximate magnitudes of stiffness and range associated with mesiodistal-pulling activation for several common loops, but it is important to remember that both properties may be influenced rather significantly by fabrication procedures and, therefore, variations in obtained property values for seemingly identical loops prepared by different practitioners should be expected.
Synopsis The discussions of this chapter have examined the concepts of structural
bending behavior and the application of the theory to orthodontic appliance members—the arch wire in particular. Although the bending problem for the actual, continuous arch wire is almost hopelessly complex, reasonable modeling can result in a manageable problem and analysis. Substantial care was taken in the development of the theory, but with some voids necessary because of mathematical procedures beyond the scope of the text; the thrust was toward understanding the parametric influences on this most common form of appliance activation occurring in orthodontic therapy. The structural response of an arch-wire beam is dependent on sev-
eral geometric and mechanical properties, most of which may be selected and controlled by the practitioner. The ke.y parameter is stiffness and, following its definition with respect to the specific bending prob-
270
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
under analysis, the orthodontist must make a decision as to wire material, cross-sectional size and shape, and a solid versus a twisted, layered, or braided longitudinal format. Material ductility is an additional consideration if permanent bends are to be placed prior to activation and, in this regard, a superficial examination of inelastic bending was undertaken. Consequences of superposition of elastic activation on prior inelastic behavior received attention and led to a discussion of the functions, characteristics, and behavior in bending of orthodontic wire lem
loops.
It is important to note once again that an American Dental Association specification standardizes the evaluation of the orthodontic arch wire in both elastic and inelastic bending. Property values obtained from the results of structural tests are quantified through use of engineering
bending theory. Perhaps this fact gives support to the developments undertaken in Chapter 7 that are not only pertinent but also necessary to the structural considerations of the example orthodontic mechanics discussed in Chapter 10.
References E.L.: A force-activation comparison of retraction loops used with the "018" and "022" bracket assemblies. Master's thesis, Saint Louis University,
Engel,
1977.
Lane, D.F., and Nikolai, R.J.: Effects of stress relief on the mechanical properties of orthodontic wire loops. Angle Orthod., 50:139—145, 1980.
Suggested Readings American Dental Association Specificaton No. 32 for orthodontic wires not con-
taining precious metals. J. Am. Dent. Assoc., 95:1169—1171, 1977.
Andreasen, G.F., and Barrett, RD.: An evaluation of cobalt-substituted nitinol wire in orthodontics. Am. J. Orthod., 63:462—470, 1973.
Andreasen, G.F., and Hilleman, T.B.: An evaluation of 55 cobalt substituted nitinol wire for use in orthodontics. J. Am. Dent. Assoc., 82:1373—1375, 1971.
Andreasen, G.F., and Morrow, R.E.: Laboratory and clinical analysis of nitinol wire. Am. J. Orthod., 73:142—151, 1978. Brantley, W.A.: Comments on stiffness measurements for orthodontic wires. J. Dent. Res., 55:705, 1976. Brantley, W.A., Augat, W.S., Myers, C.L., and Winders, R.V.: Bending deformation studies of orthodontic wires. J. Dent. Res., 57:609—615, 1978.
Brantley, W.A., and Myers, C.L.: Measurement of bending deformation for small diameter orthodontic wires. J. Dent. Res., 58:1696—1700, 1979.
211
Behavior of Orthodontic Wire in Bending
Burstone, C.J.: Variable modulus orthodontics. Am. J. Orthod., 80:1—16, 1981.
Burstone, C.J.: Application of bioengineering to clinical orthodontics. in Current Orthodontic Concepts and Techniques. 2nd Ed. Edited by T.M. Graber and B.F. Swain. Philadelphia, W.B. Saunders, 1975, Chapter 3. Burstone, C.J., and Goldberg, A.J.: Maximum forces and deflections from orthodontic appliances. Am. J. Orthod., 84:95—103, 1983.
Burstone, C.J., and Goldberg, A.J.: Beta titanium: a new orthodontic alloy. Am. J. Orthod., 77:121—132, 1980.
Creekmore, T.D.: The importance of interbracket width in orthodontic tooth movement. J. Clin. Orthod., 10:530—534, 1976.
Goldberg, 1.' and Burstone, C.J.: An evaluation of beta-titanium alloys for use in orthodontic appliances. J. Dent. Res., 58:593—599, 1979.
Goldberg, A.J., Vanderby, R., and Burstone, C.J.: Reduction in the modulus of elasticity in orthodontic wires. J. Dent. Res., 56:1227—1231, 1977.
Jarabak, J.R., and Fizzell, J.A.: Technique and Treatment with Light-wire Edgewise Appliances. 2nd Ed. St. Louis, C. V. Mosby, 1972, Chapters 2, 3. Kusy, R.P.: On the use of nomograms to determine the elastic property ratios of orthodontic arch wires. Am. J. Orthod., 83:374—381, 1983. Kusy, R.P.: Comparison of nickel-titanium and beta titanium wire sizes to conventional orthodontic arch wire materials. Am. J. Orthod., 79:625—629, 1981.
Kusy, R.P., and Greenberg, A.R.: Effects of composition and cross-section on the elastic properties of orthodontic wires. Angle Orthod., 51 :325—342, 1981.
Kusy, R.P., and Greenberg, AR.: Comparison of elastic properties of nickel-titanium and beta titanium arch wires. Am. J. Orthod., 82:199—205, 1982.
Lopez, I., Goldberg, J., and Burstone, C.J.: Bending characteristics of nitinol wire. Am. J. Orthod., 75:569—575, 1979.
Nikolai, R.J.: On optimum orthodontic force theory as applied to canine retraction. Am. J. Orthod., 68:290—302, 1975. Popov, E.P.: Introduction to Mechanics of Solids. Englewood Cliffs, N.J., Prentice-Hall, 1968, Chapters 6, 11.
Smith, JO., and Sidebottom, 0. M.: Elementary Mechanics of Deformable Bodies. London, Macmillan, 1969, Chapters 7, 8.
Thurow, R.C.: Edgewise Orthodontics. 4th Ed. St. Louis, C. V. Mosby, 1982, Chapter 4, 5, 9. Yoshikawa, D.K., Burstone, C.J., Goldberg, A.J., and Morton, J.: Flexure modulus of orthodontic stainless steel wires. J. Dent. Res.: 60:139—145, 1981.
Waters, N.E., Houston, W.J.B., and Stephen, C.D.: The characterization of arch wires for the initial alignment of irregular teeth. Am. J. Orthod., 79:373—389, 1981.
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance 0
0 The
force system transmitted by and through a structural or machine
member, capable of producing pure rotational displacement about a lon-
gitudinal axis, is known as torque. The resultant of a torsional force system is a couple; therefore, the terms "torque" and "couple" are sometimes used interchangeably. In a strict sense, and in the typical engineering setting, however, torque is the more correct term to describe a distributed force system carried by a "shaft" from one location to another within a structure or machine. In orthodontic terminology, torque is often associated with the angulations of long axes of teeth and pertains to the positioning of root apices with respect to crowns. Second-order torque was described in Chapter 5 as a force system used to alter a long-axis orientation in a faciolingual plane that results in mesiodistal displacement of the root tip. Activated uprighting springs exert a second-order torque, and these auxiliaries are
examined later in this chapter. Receiving principal attention herein, however, are the structural considerations of third-order torque which, with respect to the dentition, pertain to faciolingual root movement and control. Although third-order torque may be delivered to an individual dental unit to produce a wanted displacement, perhaps the most common occurrence is in the mechanics of retraction of the maxillary anterior or incisal segment. To reduce overjet, to upright procumbent anteriors, and to angulate incisors with respect to vertical requires that the appliance deliver third-order torque. Third-order torque is often part of
the force system exerted on buccal segments to alter posterior arch width, to cite another example. In typical edgewise orthodontic mechanics, third-order torque is generated when, in order to achieve bracket engagement, a rectangular wire must be twisted about its longitudinal axis during the activation
process. The third-order, passive "mismatch" between wire and bracket, as seen in a mesiodistal view, is created or possibly augmented by a permanent deformation of the wire, by the use of pretorqued brack272
273
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
ets,
or by a combination of the two. To generate third-order action
within a round-wire appliance, torquing spurs or loops are bent into or affixed to the round arch wire and, as seen in a mesial or distal view, they are passively angulated with respect to the long axes of the teeth to be displaced. A round-wire torquing auxiliary, overlaying the main arch wire from canine to canine, is used when appropriate in the incisal-segment retraction mechanics of Begg therapy (Begg and Kesling, 1977). Such torquing spurs may be incorporated in a continuous arch wire as well. The generation of torque at an activation site results in the delivery of
a torsional force system to the dentition. The action-reaction counterpart of the desired torque is that exerted by the dentition on the appliance, and the wire must carry it to the anchorage site(s). The quantification of torque delivered, then, involves an analysis of the wire and, as with the
activated arch-wire beam, presents the analyst with an indeterminate problem. Regardless of the number of anchorage locations, the number of unknown torque resultants (couples) exceeds the number of available, moment-balance relationships of quasi-statics. The analysis must make use of the known or measurable activating twist(s) that are necessarily performed to gain bracket engagement. Torque as the force system
generated and twist as the form of activating deformation are interrelated in the structural response of the loaded member. The complete description of the third-order force system, paralleling the solution of the bending problem, requires the augmentation of the equations of quasi-statics by relationships incorporating torsional stiffness. Torsional action, specifically in the anterior segment, may be generated by an extraoral appliance as well as through intraoral mechanics. Intraoral torsional mechanics are covered in this chapter, but all extraoral-appliance discussions are deferred to Chapter 9. In the sections that follow, torsional theory is developed for the straight, circular shaft and the extensions and modifications of that theory to accommodate the rectangular cross-section. Next, the theory is discussed with respect to its applicability to the orthodontic arch wire. Orthodontic mechanics of anterior-segment retraction are then detailed with emphasis on the role of third-order behavior; both the edgewise and round-wire approaches are examined. Because permanent bends or twists are often placed prior to third-order activation, inelastic behavior of metallic materials in torsion is explored and, subsequently, the superposition of an elastic activation on the residual-stress patterns of clinical fabrication. Finally, loops and springs used in torquing mechanics as well as other auxiliaries having torsional aspects to their activation-deactivation behavior are considered.
Structural Theory for the Straight, Circular Shaft In engineering terminology a "shaft" is a slender member providing
mechanical means by which, through rotational motion about an axis,
274
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
power may be transmitted from one location to another. Power is work
done per unit time and work requires a force system acting through an accompanying displacement (see Chap. 4). The shaft displacement is a rotation about its longitudinal axis and the resultant of the force system producing or reacting to the displacement is a couple. Power is transferred to, carried along, and taken from the shaft; the principal force system existing within the member is known as torque. Transient responses occur during start-up and shut-down of the mechanical system, but while the shaft is turning at constant rotational speed, the input and output torques (couples) balance one another and the shaft experiences an unchanging, overall twist deformation. Early designs of shafts were based on observations within simple experimentation. The typical shaft had a circular cross-section associated with the relative ease of fabrication, the facility of attachment of pulleys and gears to the member, and the character of the shaft motion. A theoretical basis for the design of the circular shaft has been firmly
established through research. Force systems may be interrelated through Newton's laws. Torque is the resultant of an internal distribution of shearing stresses on a shaft cross-section and is transmitted longitudinally within the member, unchanged between locations of forcesystem input or output. The torque-twist relationship is associated with
the stress-strain behavior of the shaft material in shear and with the shaft dimensions, and is independent of the shaft speed under steadystate (constant rotational motion) conditions. Torque may also be transmitted to, from, and through a stationary shaft, and the arch wire may perform the mechanical function of such a shaft. Although the character of shaft loading differs substantially from that of a beam, analogies may be drawn between bending and torsional responses. Influential in their
structural responses are cross-sectional size and shape, longitudinal dimensions, and the mechanical properties of the beam and shaft materials. Accordingly, of interest and principal subjects of the developments to follow are torsional stiffness, range, and strength.
The essential features of the torsional behavior of a shaft may be obtained from a rather simple example. Figure 8-1 illustrates a solid, circular member of radius R and deformable length L. The member is fixed against all movement at its left end and any bending deformations
R
FIGURE 8-1. Side view (left) and end view (right) of a straight, solid, circular shaft.
275
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
and stresses (caused by shaft weight, for example) are assumed negligi-
ble (or such effects can be superimposed on the torsion analysis). The line MN is on the outer surface and, in the passive state, is parallel to the axis of circular symmetry of the member; point 0 is on the axis of geometric symmetry. The end cross-section is a right cross-section; the angle MNO is a right (900) angle. Figure 8-2 depicts the deformation of the shaft, externally visable, following the application of torsional loading to its "free" end. The resultant of the load is a couple T, which represents torque and distinguishes this force system from an applied bending couple. Because the shaft is not rigid and only its fixed end is restrained from movement, a rotational deformation is distributed along the length of the member as characterized externally by (1) the distorted shape of the generator (labeled MN' as activated); (2) the unaltered, straight-line configuration of the shaft axis; and (3) the rotation of the reference, free-end radius to the as-activated position ON'. The radii remaining straight lines and the shaft axis undeformed by the loading are a combined result of the characteristics of the load and the symmetry of the member; as the magnitude of the applied couple is increased, indefinitely until fracture begins,
the pattern of deformation remains that shown in the figure. The amount of "twist" of the free end (with respect to the fixed end) of the shaft, the angle NON' in Figure 8-2, is, however, directly related to the magnitude of the couple loading. The evidence of longitudinal shear resulting from torsional activation is obtained by imagining the unwrapping of the outer surface, "skin," of the deformed shaft. The flattened skin is rectangular, having dimensions L by the shaft circumference, and is pictured in Figure 8-3. Corresponding to the change in inclination of the generator, any small area of the skin that is passively rectangular deforms into the shape of a parallelogram, as shown, upon activation of
M
Torsional couple T
L
FIGURE 8-2. The shaft of Figure 8-1 subjected to a torsional couple applied at its end.
free"
276
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Shaft circumfererice
—
L
FIGURE 8-3. The outer surface of the shaft of Figure 8-2; the shaft "skin" has been unwrapped and flattened into a plane, but not otherwise further deformed.
the shaft; the demise of the right angles of the rectangle is the indication
of shearing strain. In the example under discussion the load is the torque input at the right end of the shaft; the torque is transmitted the length of the member and into the left-end support. A free-body diagram of the entire shaft is shown on the left in Figure 8-4; only the single couple loads the member and a moment balance for the static shaft yields a resultant, responsive couple of the same magnitude T at the fixed end. An analysis of any Responsive torque =T
Internal torque
=T
I
I
I—
Applied torque
T
I
T e
FIGURE 8-4. Free-body diagrams of the shaft of Figure 8-2; the entire shaft of length L (left) and a portion of the shaft of arbitrary length t (right) measured from the free end.
277
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
portion of the shaft, such as that shown on the right in Figure 8-4,
indicates that the resultant of the internal force system on every right section is a torsional couple equal to T. Further indication that the internal torque is the same on all right cross-sections between the shaft ends is the constant slope of the deformed generator MN' in Figure 8-3. (The internal bending couple in a beam changes from one right cross-section to another, when the loading includes transverse forces, due to the moment-arm changes; the shaft, however, is directly analogous to the beam in pure bending.) The deformed generator has an apparent curvilinear shape as viewed in Figure 8-2, but, in the general torsion problem,
it is made up of a series of straight lines in the "plane skin" view with sites of slope changes corresponding to locations of external torsional couples.
In between torque input-output locations, relative rotational displacements of cross-sections exist; the amount of relative twist is directly proportional to the longitudinal distance between cross-sections. In the example shaft, the absolute rotation of the left-end cross-section is zero as constrained; the relative rotations are simply additive along the shaft length (because no intermediate external couples are present) and sum to the rotation of the free-end cross-section. This free-end displacement, indicated by the angle NON' in Figure 8-2, is the twist produced by the input couple T; it is symbolized by the Greek letter 4 (phi) and is analogous to the bending-deformation angle 0. Note that torsional loading of the straight, circular shaft warps no cross-section of the member. The character of unit deformation (strain) on the surface of the shaft is determined by comparing the active and passive configurations of a skin element. Consider a small rectangle, with its sides parallel and per-
pendicular to the shaft axis, as the passive element. Torsional loading displaces the element circumferentially and distorts it with negligible changes in the side lengths. As deformed, the element takes the shape of a parallelogram, indicative of the presence of shearing strain. The passive and activated elements are shown in Figure 8-3 and, in an enlarged view, in Figure 8-5. As noted in Figure 8-5, the angular distortion of the element (the angle between the passive and active configurations of the generator at a specific, cross-sectional location) is the localized, surface shearing strain. Shearing strain was initially defined in Chapter 3; Figures 8-5 and 3-14 are similar, although exhibiting rotational and straight (linear) shear, respectively. For a shaft experiencing only torsional loading, all deformed generators are similar, indicating axial symmetry in the surface shearing-strain pattern. For the example problem under study, the surface shearing strains are everywhere equal and are by the magnitude (in radians) of the angle NMN' in Figures 8-3 and 8-5.
For any shaft cross-section, the axial symmetry results in internal shearing strains varying only with the radial coordinate. The circumferential shearing strains for any specific radial coordinate r are all equal
and the maximum shearing strains exist at the shaft surface (where
278
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
I
I
I
I
shearing strain (es)max
FIGURE 8-5. Small element of the outer surface of a straight, circular shaft shown enlarged (from Figure 8-3) and exaggerated in passive (dashed) and activated (solid) positions and shapes.
r = R). Because torsional loading does not deform the shaft axis, where r = 0 no shearing strains exist. Moreover, for the circular shaft, since
radii from the shaft axis remain straight with activation (ON becomes ON' in Figure 8-2), no radial shearing strains exist and the magnitude of circumferential shearing strain at a point is directly proportional to the coordinate r. Shearing strains at a point generally vary with the passive orientation (edge directions) of the rectangular element there. Shearing strains are always accompanied by shearing stresses. Shearing stresses of equal magnitude exist at a point at right angles to one another in pairs, and the stresses of interest in the arch-wire torsion problem are longitudinal and circumferential; note the element orientation in Figure 8-5. For a crystalline material, paired shearing stress and strain are proportional to one another up to the elastic limit in shear. A stress-strain diagram in shear for a ductile, metallic material is depicted in Figure 8-6; this is a repetition of one plot in Figure 3-19. The material stiffness in shear, also known as the modulus of rigidity, is the slope of the linear portion of the curve and is usually symbolized by G. The stiffness G and the modulus of elasticity in tension or compression are interrelated; for metals and alloys G is typically about O.4E. Also for ductile metallics, the elasticlimit stress in shear is approximately one-half of its counterpart in tension.
279
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
(1)
0)
0,
a)
U)
0) C
0) ci)
U)
Elastic limit in shear
C
Shearing Strain
FIGURE 8-6. Characteristic plot of stress versus strain in shear for a metallic material.
The sketch in Figure 8-7 is of one side of a three-dimensional, internal, material element of the shaft showing shearing stresses acting on areas appearing in edge view from this perspective, which is radial and the same as that of Figure 8-5. (The reference line shown is parallel to the shaft axis.) Because no normal stresses exist on the element, it is said to be subjected to pure shear. (Tensile and compressive stresses do exist in
the shaft, but on elements having orientations differing from that of Figure 8-7.) When the torsional loading of the shaft nowhere causes stresses exceeding the elastic limit, the shearing strains and correspond-
ing shearing stresses are proportional to one another at every point within the shaft. Linear shearing action may be compared to that of a pair of scissors. The shearing strength of a shaft tends to resist the attempt of torsional loading to rotate each cross-section with respect to its neighbor. Another example of rotational shearing-stress development is within the adhesive attaching the bonded bracket-pad to the tooth when a second-order couple is transmitted from arch wire to the bracket and into the crown. Figure 8-8 is a view along the shaft axis into an internal cross-section
through which a torque T is transmitted. Circumferential shearing stresses are shown on the exposed areas of typical, diametrically opposed shaft elements. (A corresponding elemental area appears in edge view in Figure 8-7; the edge labeled a-a is positioned perpendicular to
280
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
parallel to the shaft axis
ss
*
/*
a
FIGURE 8-7. Equal circumferential and longitudinal shearing stresses exerted on an internal element of the activated shaft.
the shaft axis.) Each elemental area may be termed representing a very small portion of the total cross-sectional area A. The resultant shearing force on the small area M has the direction and sense of the shearing stress and is equal to the product (M); this elemental force may be symbolized as 6F5. The elemental forces exerted on the two elemental areas shown are of the same magnitude and direction, but are of opposite sense, due to area location with respect to point 0 (the end view of the shaft axis). These two forces form a couple of magnitude The sum of all such couples over the entire cross-section is the resultant internal torque T.
281
Deli ve,y of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
FIGURE 8-8. An end view into an internal cross-section of the shaft of Figure 8-2 showing circumferential shearing stresses on two elemental areas.
The torque transmitted through the right cross-section of Figure 8-8 may be initially expressed as T
sum of
(8-1)
Refinement of this formula requires knowledge of the manner in which the shearing stress varies through the area A. Figure 8-6 shows a singlevalued relationship between stress and strain and, because this shearing strain varies only with radial location on a specific cross-section, shearing stresses are likewise independent of circumferential position of the elemental area. For totally elastic behavior, stress and strain are proportional to one another and, therefore, the variation with r of the stress as well as the strain exhibits the pattern of Figure 8-9. Mathematically expressed, the pattern indicates = (ss)max:R
or
=
r
(8-2)
282
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
(Ss)max
Resultant torque T
FIGuRE 8-9. Linear relationship between radial position and magnitude of oircumferential shearing stress on the cross-seofion of Figure 8-8 for totally elastic behavior.
Substituting Equation 8-2 into Equation 8-1 yields T=
(5s)max
[sum of (r2&A)]
(8-3)
resulting in the summation now associated solely with the cross-sectional area. The sum is the second moment of area with respect to the shaft axis and, for the solid circular cross-section, is equal to (8-4)
This geometric parameter is known as the polar second moment of area, is often symbolized by the letter I, and is analogous to the second mo-
ment of area I, which appears in the bending analyses of Chapter 7. 21.) In terms of the maximum shearing stress, occurring at the outside surface of the
(Referring to Figure 7-10, for circular cross-sections, J =
shaft, and for totally elastic material behavior, Equation 8-1 can now be written as T=
or
T=
(ss)m;xITR3
(8-5)
283
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
An analogous expression, explicit in the internal bending couple M, was
generated in Chapter 7; the two equations are similar in form. The structural response of a shaft in torsion is characterized by plots of internal torque versus the relative rotations of cross-sections at the ends of shaft segments through which torque is transmitted unchanged. For the simple shaft example of Figure 8-2 the internal torque is constant
throughout the entire length L (and equals the applied torque) and the left-end cross-section cannot move or deform. Accordingly, the appropriate plot, given in Figure 8-10, depicts the applied torque in terms of the free-end twist 4). The slope of the linear portion of the graph is a torsional stiffness and a formula for this parameter may be readily derived. Needed are the stress-strain relationship for the shaft material in shear below its elastic limit from Figure 8-6 = G(e5)
(8-6)
and Equations 8-2 and 8-5 previously developed. Referring to Figures 8-2, 8-3, and 8-5, and noting that the arc = length NN' is small in comparison to L, NN' can be equated not only to R4), but with negligible error also to the product of L and the angle NMN; this yields the relationship R4) = L =
(es)max
(8-7)
ci,
-C) C)
a a
Tei)
Torsional stiffness
Angle of Twist 4'
FIGURE 8-10. Plot of activating couple versus free-end twist angle for the shaft of Figure 8-2.
284
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
The formula sought, the ratio of torque to twist, obtained through elimi-
nation of shearing stress and strain from the equations noted, is
TirR4GJG 2L
L
88 (-)
Torsional stiffness is seen to depend directly upon the shaft radius and
the modulus of rigidity of the material and inversely upon a characteristic length. Again, note the similarity between this formula and its counterpart in the bending developments of the previous chapter. The coordinates of the elastic-limit point of the plot in Figure 8-10 are critical twist angle and the critical torque. In general, the critical crosssection of an activated shaft is that where the internal torque is a maximum and, typically, a critical shaft segment exists. In the example shaft of Figure 8-2 all cross-sections are critical and the critical segment is the entire shaft. If a continuous arch wire is delivering third-order action (torque) to the incisors, the critical "shaft" segments are generally between the canines and the lateral incisors. Under critical conditions, the maximum shearing strains in the shaft are the elastic-limit values for the shaft material. The critical twist as described, then, is the elastic range
for the shaft and, from Equations 8-6 and 8-7, its formula may be derived: —
(es)eiL
—
(55)eiL
1?
—
RG
(89)
The maximum elastic twist of the critical segment is seen to depend on
mechanical properties of the shaft material, the shaft radius, and the length of the critical segment. Once again, the analogy may be drawn between the bending and torsion analyses; similar parameters of the structural member exert like influences on the elastic range. The critical torque is that magnitude of internal torque corresponding to the generation of elastic-limit stresses in shear at the shaft surface of the critical segment. Through a moment balance, this level of internal torque may be related to the system of torsional couples applied to the shaft. The critical torque may be directly expressed, then, by substituting the elastic-limit value for the maximum shearing stress in Equation 8-5: —
(ss)eil
—
R
Tcrit
(5s)eIITR3 —
2
(8-10)
In the example problem, because the entire shaft is the critical segment and the internal torque is everywhere equal to the applied couple at the free end of the shaft, the value obtained from Equation 8-10 is the elastic strength of the shaft in torsion.
285
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
Extension of Theory to Shafts Having Rectangular Cross-Sections Although perhaps not of direct interest to many edgewise practitioners,
the foregoing development of torsional theory for circular shafts was undertaken for three reasons:
1. The axial symmetry, not only in geometry but also in loading and structural response, leads to the least complex formulas for torsional stiffness, range, and strength. 2. This theory provides a basis from which to generate corresponding relationships for the shaft having a rectangular cross-section.
3. Third-order force systems cannot be directly transmitted between round wire and bracket, but can be delivered from round wire to crown by means of torquing spurs and, therefore, circular-shaft theory has application to specific orthodontic appliances. In extending the theory to admit rectangular cross-sections, contributions from the principal influencing parameters—shaft material, length dimension, and cross-sectional size—might be expected to be similar to those exhibited in the circular-shaft formulas. Material properties (elastic-limit strain and stress and modulus of rigidity), when appearing in the equations, each did so to the first power (direct or indirect proportionality); the shaft radius or diameter, however, contributed in a nonlinear manner in two of the three formulas. In this chapter the dimensions of the rectangular cross-section are symbolized by b and c where, by definition, c is less than or at most equal to b. With bending deformation, the response of the rectangular wire depends on the direction of activation; in torsion no such interdependence exists, but one of the two cross-sectional dimensions of the rectangular shaft will be seen to be a more dominant influence than the other. The first analyses of rectangular shafts in torsion were carried out experimentally and by analogy, and were deemed reasonably accurate only when the ratio of b to c was large. In time an exact mathematical solution was obtained, general in terms of b-to-c ratio but highly complex in form. A third approach was that of empirical adaptation, be-
ginning with the form taken from the circular-shaft derivations and using experimentation to complete the formulas. The results of the ex-
perimental studies enabled the clarification of how the individual dimensions b and c should appear in the equations and the quantifications of dimensionless coefficients included in the formulas to generalize them.
The empirically determined formulas for stiffness, range, and strength for the straight shaft having a rectangular cross-section, analogous to Equations 8-8 through 8-10, are as follows:
286
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
T
=
f3bc3G Tcrit
aL(es)ei —
abc2(Ss)ei
aL(ss)ei /3cG
The coefficients alpha (a) and beta (/3) have values that are dependent on the ratio of b to c; the relationships are presented graphically in Figure
8-11 and representative coefficient magnitudes are given in Table 8-LBoth coefficients are seen to increase monotonically, and, as the b-to-c ratio becomes large, they individually approach as an asymptote the value of one-third. A cursory examination of Equations 8-11 suggests that square (b = c) shafts are stronger and exhibit higher torsional stiffness than "ribbon" shafts (b >>c) having the same cross-sectional area. The cross-sectional stiffness parameter, analogous to I for the circular shaft, is seen to be proportional to b(c3). In general, the smaller of the two cross-sectional dimensions, c, seems to be the more influential, but the contribution of the b-to-c ratio also has some impact. The materialand length-parameter influences are assumed, by the chosen forms of the empirical expressions, to be the same as for the circular shaft; the determination that these parameters do not impact the values of a or /3, for a specific ratio of b to c, ensures the validity of that assumption. Also note that the individual influences of the two cross-sectional dimensions depend upon the plane of bending when the member is subjected to transverse (flexural) loading; in torsion, the only load "direction" is longitudinal and, therefore, the cross-sectional dimensions of the shaft affect a specific dependent parameter (e.g., elastic range) in a singular manner. /3
0.33
0.30
a
lic
0.20 13
b
0.10
0
0
1.0
2.0
3.0
6.0
Ratio of b to c FIGURE 8-11. Plots of the coefficients and /3 as functions of the ratio of crosssectional dimensions of the rectangular shaft.
287
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance TABLE 8-1. Coefficient values for specific ratios of cross-sectional dimensions for the rectangular shaft
b/c
a
f3
1.0 1.5
0.208
0.141
0.231
2.0 3.0 6.0
0.246 0.267 0.299
0.196 0.229 0.263 0.299
The complete mathematical solution to the rectangular shaft problem
provides, in addition to expressions for stiffness, range, and strength within the elastic limit of the shaft material, the strain and stress patterns throughout the member. Several points of interest arise from this theoretical development and from experimental observations. Associated with the absence of axial symmetry in the geometry are the appear-
ance of warping of the passively plane cross-section under torsional loading and a complex shearing-strain pattern on the noncircular crosssection. A portion of the strain pattern is exhibited in Figure 8-12; for
linear elastic behavior the shearing-stress pattern is identical to
it.
b
Resultant torque
FIGURE 8-12. Typical cross-section of a rectangular shaft. Characteristic distributions of shearing strains along major and minor axes of geometric symmetry and a diagonal associated with torsional loading are antis ymmetric.
288
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Strains are seen to be zero at the center of the cross-section and at each
of the four corners; the corners remain right angles when the shaft is loaded. The shearing strains change in magnitude nonlinearly from the center (axis) point outward; the patterns are antisymmetric along any line passing through the center point and the cross-section boundary. Shown in the figure are the strain patterns along the axes of symmetry in
the plane of the cross-section and a diagonal through a corner. The maximum values of shearing strain on the cross-section occur at the outer-surface points that are along one axis of symmetry; these are the closest surface points to the shaft axis.
App'ication of Shaft Theory to the Orthodontic Arch Wire analysis of the behavior and effects of an orthodontic arch wire in the presence of third-order activation can be a formidable bioengineering problem. To the foregoing theoretical developments and applicable quasi-static relationships must often be added complications imposed by the existence of several input and output torques and the curvature of the arch-wire "shaft." When the entire, continuous arch wire is involved in third-order mechanics, use of the model developed in Chapter 6 can be both reasonable and prudent. Combining the dental units into segments reduces the number of force-system components to the principal contributions. In general, the pure torque input to a curved shaft, as it is transmitted longitudinally through the member, is modified gradually and a bending component appears. Considering the block-U-shaped wire model, a third-order activation in the anterior section, for example, provokes a bending response in the posterior sections, arising from the 900 change in longitudinal orientation between anterior and posterior portions of the model arch. With the assistance of the arch-wire model, the following problems The
of interest may be examined: (1) the torquing of one tooth with a straight-shaft transmission of load to anchorage; (2) unilateral or bilat-
eral third-order activation of the terminal molar(s) or posterior segment(s) with, possibly, some response located in the anterior segment; and (3) perhaps of greatest interest, the torquing of four incisors or six anterior teeth as a segment, with midsagittal-plane symmetry present and responses in the posterior segments. Isolation of the Activating Torque A third-order couple is almost never exerted on a tooth in the total absence of other force-system components. This torque can be effectively transmitted to the crown by a facial or lingual arch or, in some instances, by a transpalatal bar. Pure third-order loading produces a center of rotation coincident with the center of resistance and, therefore, a crown-displacement potential toward the facial or lingual, depending on the sense
289
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
of the torque. If a faciolingual driving force is not part of the initial
activation, then the combination of appliance-crown contact and bending stiffness of the appliance will result in the appearance of a faciolingual force tending to restrain the crown. Furthermore, an occlusogingival force may also be present, resulting from a "secondary response" to be described in the following subsection. For purposes of analysis, however, it is both possible and practical to examine the effects of thirdorder, active torque upon the arch wire and any existing anchorage, in the absence of other contributions to the force system at the activation site(s), and subsequently superimpose the influences of the remaining components of the total force system. The couple transmitted from the appliance, reflected in two-point crown contact and a resulting pair of forces in the mesiodistal plane of the tooth, is associated with structural characteristics of the appliance and the amount of third-order activation with respect to passive configu-
rations. In conventional edgewise mechanics, permanent localized twists of the rectangular wire, placed prior to activation, create the potential for third-order action. Recently, pretorqued brackets have become widely available. Third-order, anterior torque may also be activated extraorally, as noted in Chapter 9. Interbracket twists or brackets pretorqued at different angles may be used to influence the distribution of torque within a dental segment. As noted earlier, Begg therapy uses a somewhat different torquing format to be contrasted, subsequently,
with that of the twisted, rectangular wire; once again, however, the couple loading is produced through an angular deformation. To the point, regardless of the approach or treatment philosophy, the creation of third-order torque occurs as a result of a particular form or component of activating deformation; hence, it is possible, and also contributory to
the relative ease of overall analysis, to isolate torsional action and its effects from the total appliance load.
Responses of the Appliance and the Dentition to Torsional Activation The
third-order activation of an orthodontic appliance results in
action-reaction counterpart couples exerted on the dentition and appliance at the site(s) of the activation. The load on the appliance is transmitted through it to the support (anchorage) location(s). The anchorage responses are described in format through application of the equations of quasi-statics to the appliance. A single moment balance is initially employed to relate load and response, but individual forces as well as couples may appear with couple loading, due to wire curvature, and necessitate the added use of force balances. In this regard, separate considerations of primary and secondary responses are undertaken here, with primary responses examined first. An active, third-order couple may be generated against an individual tooth within the dental arch. The reaction is a single torsional couple exerted on the appliance, and this torque is transmitted to anchorage, ordinarily through an arch wire. If the activation site is a terminal molar,
____ 290
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
T=T1+T2
Responsive torque
(
Applied
1torque T
Responsive torque
—
T1
€1
€2
FIGURE 8-13. A straight shaft restrained against rotation at both ends and subjected to torsional loading at an intermediate cross-section.
or if a segmented arch wire is engaged, a single anchorage site is possible (although several adjacent teeth may contribute). The basic, quasistatic analysis through a moment balance simply requires that the net activation and anchorage torques be equal in magnitude but of opposite
sense (assuming negligible wire curvature). Figure 8-2 is applicable here;
the fixed end represents the anchorage. Alternatively, the anchorage may be split or divided with the torsional load partitioned and carried by the wire to support sites on either side of the activation location. Such a
straight shaft is depicted in Figure 8-13 and the given equation is the result of the moment balance. If the active torque is located midway between the anchorage sites, the responsive torques are equal if no variation in geometric or material characteristics exists from one end of the shaft to the other. Otherwise, twist-deformation equations must be used to interrelate the responsive torques. The primary response to an incisal or anterior segment activated in torsion is divided between the posterior segments when a continuous arch wire carries the reactive load distally. Often the entire force system as well as the geometry exhibits symmetry with respect to the midsagittal plane. The sketch on the left in Figure 8-14 shows the right half of the activated arch-wire model in buccal view and the essence of the force
F6
C6 F3
F3 = F5 + F6
FIGURE 8-14. Free-body diagrams of the buccal view of an arch-wire model subjected to anterior, torsional loading. Posterior-segment response shown in its resultant form (left) and as distributed among dental units (right).
291
Deliver,' of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
system exerted on it: a third-order couple against the half anterior seg-
ment and an equal, but opposite, second-order couple from the posterior segment. On the right in Figure 8-14, the posterior response is shown in some detail, including occlusogingival forces, which must obey an oc-
clusogingival force balance, and diminishing second-order responses from individual dental units within the posterior segment. The distribution of torque within the anterior segment is considered subsequently. Another example of third-order mechanics exhibiting midsagittalplane symmetry is that of bilateral torquing of the terminal molars or the buccal segments. Figure 8-15 illustrates transverse views of two activated appliances from a posterior perspective. On the left is the archwire model, sketched as if the anterior teeth are not engaged. The bilateral torsional activation results in bending deformation of the anterior portion of the arch, exaggerated in the absence of anchorage response there. On the right is shown a transpalatal bar engaging the molars, contacting the lingual crown surfaces. If the bar is very stiff, under bilateral torque no response of consequence will exist between it and the palatal vault. In both sketches the moment balance is inherent in the activation; the couples on the left and right sides of the arch are equal in magnitude, but opposite in sense to one another. As noted in Chapter 7, when the responsive force system in bending is distributed over several individual dental units, that distribution is nonuniform with the tooth or teeth nearest to the activation site providing the largest portion(s) of the response. The same is true in torsion. For example, if the first molar on the left side is torqued, the second premolar and, if present, the second molar are the principal anchorage units. If the buccal segment on the left side is alone subject to third-order
activation, and a continuous wire engages all three segments, the response is distributed principally in the anterior segment, and the intensity of the distribution decreases with curvilinear distance along the wire from the activation site. The free-body diagram of the model arch wire from a posterior perspective is shown in Figure 8-16. Torque in the buc-
FIGURE 8-15. Bilateral torsional activation of the buccal segments posteriorly viewed; reactions against an arch wire (left) and a transpalatal bar (right).
292
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
F1
F1,
c2(
FIGURE 8-16. Free-body diagram from a posterior perspective of a continuous arch wire subjected to unilateral torquing associated with activation of the left buccal segment.
segment is transformed into bending potential in the anterior region, resulting in occlusogingival force responses there and, in the absence of substantial bracket-wire clearances, second-order couples. If any internal force is carried beyond the anterior segment, the remaining bending potential becomes torsional, with further change in longitudinal direction, and is delivered to the right-side posterior segment. On the left in Figure 8-17 is a free-body diagram of the transpalatal bar with right-side, unilateral activation. With this sense of the applied torque, the response may be partly adjacent to the activation site and exerted by the palate in opposing potential rotation of the bar. On the other hand, because only pressure (no tension but, perhaps, some small amount of frictional shearing force) can be generated between bar and cal
=
FIGURE 8-17. Unilateral, right-side couple loading of a transpalatal bar and the response as viewed from the posterior: clockwise activation (left) and counterclockwise activation (right).
293
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
palate, reversing the sense of the activating couple results in a different
response format, shown on the right in Figure 847. Two forms of secondary response exist as the result of third-order activation of an incisal or anterior segment. From a buccal perspective the arch-wire model resembles a beam, cantilevered from the posterior segments. Figure 8-18 (left) depicts the activated configuration of such a
beam, loaded by a couple at its "free end." The sketch represents the torqued arch wire well except the deformed shape suggests that no constraint is present to prevent occlusogingival displacement of the anterior segment. Such constraint is, in fact, provided by the anterior brackets. Accordingly, consider the arch wire engaged in the posterior segments and, before undergoing third-order activation, the anterior segment is
aligned occlusogingivally with the bracket slots. Accompanying the torque from the twist to gain bracket engagement is an anterior intrusive potential. The complete free-body diagram from a buccal perspective is
shown in the center of Figure 8-18, together with the action-reaction counterpart force system against the maxillary anterior crowns in the application of lingual root torque on the right. Note that changing the sense of the anterior torque reverses all aspects of the response shown in the figure.
Activation of the anterior torque provokes another secondary response which must be viewed from an occlusal perspective. Suggested on the left in Figure 8-19, resulting from the combination of loading and wire curvature, is a tendency for the posterior sections of the arch wire to assume buccally displaced positions. The associated, free-body diagram from an occlusal perspective is shown on the right in the figure; the action-reaction counterparts of the transverse forces induced tend to widen the dental arch in the posterior in the absence of arch-wire constriction before activation. The same arch-widening potential is present for either sense of the third-order action in the anterior portion of the wire. Secondary responses exist in another example previously examined, that of bilateral activation of torsional couples in the posterior segments, if the arch wire also engages the anterior segment. The twist activations produce bending potential in the anterior portion of the wire as noted previously in Figure 8-15, left. Resistance to immediate achievement of that anterior deformation is provided by bracket-wire engagement. In this example, two activation sites must exist and the internal force sys-
segment support
cp
Ta
FIGURE 8-18. Buccal-view diagrams of the arch wire and anterior teeth with third-order, anterior activation. Vertical displacement potential associated with the torquing action (left) and a free-body diagram (center) together with crown loading (right).
294
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Fpe
Tar Ta. Tar
FIGURE 8-19. Occlusal-view diagrams of the arch wire associated with anterior, torsional loading: the posterior, buccal-displacement potential (left) and the free-body diagram assuming no initial, transverse, arch constriction (right).
tems resulting from third-order loading on both sides of the arch are carried mesiafly by the arch wire toward the midline. A free-body diagram of the wire, viewed from the posterior, is illustrated on the left in Figure 8-20. The canines in this example are assumed to be within the posterior segments. Occiusogingival, responsive force systems are exerted by the incisal pairs and, to balance the system, forces must also be induced in the buccal segments. The force system exerted against one
maxillary incisal pair is shown on the right in Figure 8-20. Note that changing the senses of the posterior-segment torques reverses the pattern of the bending potential in the anterior section of the wire and the senses of the secondary responses.
Tpr
FIGURE 8-20. Posterior views of bilateral, buccal-segment torquing with anteriorsegment appliance engagement: free-body diagram of the arch wire (left) and the force system transmitted to an incisor pair (right).
295
Deliveiy of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
Structural influences on Active and Responsive Force Systems Shaft stiffness is dependent on material, cross-sectional shape and size, and longitudinal dimension. Examined first in this subsection are cantilevered wire "shafts" within the context of the previously introduced arch-wire model. Figure 8-21 shows schematically a rectangularwire segment subjected to an activating torque near one end, anchored
at the other end, and having an effective length L. In conventional, edgewise mechanics, the potential for torsional action is achieved by placing permanent, third-order twists adjacent to the anchorage sites and/or through use of "pretorqued" brackets (having slots angulated with respect to the passive wire) at the activation sites. Superficially, perhaps the simplest problem is the torquing of a terminal molar with anchorage provided principally by the remainder of the posterior segment. The initial value of the molar couple is the product of the activating twist (within the elastic range) and the torsional stiffness of the wire segment. In estimating this stiffness, the nonrigidity of the anchorage unit must be considered; in effect, the real characteristic length L of the straight segment is greater than the interbracket distance between the molar and the adjacent tooth. Note in addition that distribution of the responsive couple becomes an important consideration when the active and resultant responsive torques are equal in magnitude, and the tooth adjacent to the molar is smaller in root-surface area. To approach a uniform distribution of the response among the sev-
eral, available, posterior teeth (in the absence of discrete, permanent twists between pairs), the potential for the wire between the individual
Anchorage
L
Applied torque T
FIGURE 8-21. The cantilevered, rectangular-wire shaft modeL
296
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
units of the anchorage to twist must be minimized. Therefore, within
the anchoring segment the torsional stiffness of the engaged segment of wire must be as large as possible. Furthermore, an attempt to isolate or contain the anchorage, such as not to involve the anterior teeth, requires that a portion of wire between the posterior and anterior teeth exhibit high torsional and bending flexibility. (Termination of the activated wire
segment between the anterior and posterior dental segments is one obvious way of isolating the anterior teeth from any effects of molar torquing.) In the presence of midsagittal-plane symmetry, the analysis of incisal- or anterior-segment torquing may be accomplished by considering
either side of the arch. When the wire is "cut" at the midline, it becomes, in effect, a pair of mirror-image cantilevers. Assuming for this discussion that the four incisors are torqued as a unit, each cantilever is supported by a posterior segment with a canine at the mesial extent of the anchorage. The permanent twist in the cantilevered wire segment (in the absence of pretorqued brackets) is placed immediately mesial to the canine bracket. The product of torsional stiffness of the cantilever and the activating twist yields the third-order couple delivered initially to the incisal pair. In essence, the torque is transmitted mesially from anchorage; hence, a portion of the torque is first taken by the lateral incisor and the remainder is delivered to the central incisor. Unless an appropriate twist is placed in the wire between the two incisors, or an equivalent arrangement is attained through use of pretorqued brackets, the lateral incisor will generally receive the larger portion of the resultant couple at activation. (Likewise, in the distribution of the responsive force system, the canine will receive the greatest portion of that resultant at activation.) In fact, because of the flexibility of the periodontal ligament, the first-phase movement of the lateral incisor prevents its acceptance of the entire activation and permits some third-order action to reach the central incisor. As further third-order displacement of the lateral incisor occurs with time, the apportionment of the resultant couple within the pair changes and the central incisor receives an increasing percentage of the total torque. Because the root-surface area of the canine is generally greater than that of the lateral incisor, the distribution of the responsive force system within the posterior segment does not raise the level of concern indicated in the previous example. As a result, the decision as to choices of wire and arch configuration may focus more directly on the requirements at the activation site. Although providing an interesting analysis problem, the effective application of third-order action to a posterior segment is clinically feasible only under special conditions. A first difficulty is that of properly distributing the active torque over a segment including three to five teeth, which demands locally high appliance stiffness or differential twists between the teeth of the segment. Second, transmission of the resultant couple through a continuous arch wire results in the anterior segment becoming the first line of support (anchorage). This couple
297
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
must have a sizable magnitude if wanted displacements are to occur,
and the root-surface area of the anterior segment will be substantially deficient to prevent generally undesired movement there. If bilateral action is wanted, only the dental units to undergo displacement should engage the appliance; no anchorage potential is needed and, ideally, the anterior segment should not be involved. If unilateral action is needed, then progressive torquing (one tooth at a time) should be the approach to keep the resultant-couple magnitude small throughout the mechanics and some, if not all, of the responsive force system should be transmitted other than to the anterior segment (e.g., to the palatal vault if in the maxillary arch or by some means directly to the other posterior segment in the same arch). In the preceding discussion involving cantilevered shafts, the potential problem of insufficient anchorage was noted. The availability of support, both mesial and distal to the activation site, lessens the tendency
for undesired anchorage displacement. (Two response couples, their magnitudes summing to that of the activation-site couple, are ordinarily associated with a larger, total root-surface area than that of the single
anchorage site.) Consider, for example, the torquing of a first molar using a rectangular-wire segment engaging the first and second premo-
lars and the first and second molars. To accomplish the task, in the absence of pretorqued brackets, localized permanent twists are placed immediately mesial to the second molar and distal to the second premolar brackets. These twists are generally made equal in magnitude, such that the wire engaging only the divided anchorage sites would be passive (Fig. 8-22, above). If the twists are unequal, engagement only into
anchorage produces equal but opposite torques against the second molar and the premolar pair (Fig. 8-22, below). Activation at the molar, through elastic twisting to permit bracket engagement there, superimposes a couple load on the molar and response couples at the anchorage sites.
If a uniform, straight, wire segment is the principal appliance element, the partitioning of the molar load for transmission to the two anchorage sites depends on the characteristic, shaft-segment lengths. Because of the division of the mesial response between the premolars, resulting from the flexibility of the periodontal ligament, the effective distance from activation site to mesial support is greater than that to the distal support. Increasing the characteristic length lowers the stiffness; hence, the second molar absorbs more of the activating couple than does the premolar pair. (Since the second premolar, being adjacent to the first molar and having a smaller root surface area compared to it, receives
more than half of the total mesial response torque, the second molar taking the larger portion of the total response may be advantageous.) The division of torque between mesial and distal anchorage sites for this example problem is depicted on the left in Figure 8-23 and corresponds to the pretwisting of Figure 8-22, above. To illustrate the potential influence available to the clinician, as to the partitioning of torque in a di-
298
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Equal
permanent twists
Unequal permanent twists
FIGURE 8-22. Permanent twists placed in a rectangular-wire segment prior to third-order activation in the presence of split anchorage: equal twists (above) and unequal twists (below).
vided-anchorage arrangement, the superposition shown on the right in Figure 8-23 reflects the pretwist geometry of Figure 8-22, below, and the activation itself. The facility is present to effectively modify the split of the responsive torque (as apparently dictated by interbracket distances) through pretwisting to take advantage of the relative sizes of the anchorage units that must absorb that torque. Pretorqued brackets that are appropriately chosen can accomplish the same end.
299
Dellveiy of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
perm
i-I
.+ T7
T45
I FIGURE 8-23. The partitioning of anchorage in the example of the torqued first molar with equal (left) and unequal (right) permanent pretwists.
Anterior-Segment Torquing Mechanics
Rectangular- Wire Torquing The conventional, edgewise practitioner uses a rectangular arch wire in anterior torquing or retraction mechanics. Third-order action potential is achieved through the presence, in the passive state, of an angular differential between the wire cross-section and the bracket slot at each anterior location where torque transfer is desired. The longitudinal dimension of the wire shaft seems to be controlled by the mesiodistal, dental-arch dimensions in the anterior segment. The wire must "fill" the brackets; that is, the diagonal dimension of the wire cross-section must exceed the occlusogingival width of the bracket slot in order to maintain a twist activation. The wire material must be reasonably resilient, exhibiting a substantial elastic range in torsion, to accommodate sizable twist
activations. Generally, one of two orthodontic displacements is attempted in these mechanics: bodily movement or root movement. In the absence of pretorqued brackets, the clinician typically prepares
the arch wire for third-order activation by placing permanent twists immediately mesial to the intra-arch anchorage sites. The often-bilateral twist placements may be quantified as shown schematically in Figure 8-24: the angle between the arch-form plane and the axis of symmetry of the pliers. The amount of torsional activation achieved upon complete
300
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
30° of incisal torque
FIGURE 8-24. A buccal view of a rectangular arch wire held at midarch with pliers, indicating that 30° of torque has been placed.
appliance engagement is, however, actually less than this permanent-
twist angle; the principal portion of the difference is the third-order clearance between wire and bracket slot. This clearance may be computed from the actual cross-sectional dimensions of the arch wire and the occiusogingival bracket-slot width. The clearance is depicted on the left in Figure 8-25 and calculation of the clearance for a .019- by .026-in. wire in a .022-in, slot is presented on the right in the figure. Given in Table 8-2 are the third-order clearances for four combinations of wire and slot sizes; nominal dimensions were employed in the computations. True third-order clearances depend upon the actual wire and slot dimensions and, in effect, upon a stiffness of the bracket slot. In response to
Third-order clearance = Angle VWX — Angle VWY
For a .019- by 0.26-in, wire in a 0.22-in. (slot) bracket: slot size
Third-order clearance
19
Tangent of LVWY
LVWY = 36.2° 22
Sine of LVWX =
V'192 + 262 LVWX = 43.1°
Clearance
43.1 — 36.2
= 6.9°
FIGURE 8-25. Third-order clearance between rectangular wire and edgewise bracket: schematic with geometry (left) and an example quantification (right).
301
Deliveiy of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance TABLE 8-2. Third-order clearances between rectangular arch wires and bracket slots
Wire size (inches)
.016 x .017 x .019 x .021 x
.016 .025 .026 .027
Slot size (inches)
Clearance (degrees)
.018 .018 .022 .022
7.7 2.3
6.9 2.2
the third-order activation, the slot will "open" slightly as the wire attempts to deactivate, torsionally, within it. Although stainless-steel brackets apparently exhibit adequate "slot stiffnesses," vendors have had to reinforce the slots of some plastic brackets and they continue to seek reduced slot flexibility through improved designs and materials. Many clinicians conveniently refer to "torque," quantitatively, in
terms of the size of the permanent-twist placement(s) in degrees. Pretorqued brackets are sized, in part, according to the third-order angulations of their slots with respect to a faciolingual reference. Just as the units of orthodontic force are, properly, grams or ounces, however, ac-
tual torque is determined in gram-millimeters or ounce-inches, for example. To quantify torque correctly as a couple, the combination of shaft stiffness and twist activation are necessary. Earlier in this chapter primary influences were seen to be the cross-sectional dimensions of a solid, rectangular wire (shaft) in determining structural parameters in torsion. Table 8-3 presents relative theoretical values of elastic stiffness,
range, and strength in torsion, per unit shaft length and a common material, for four rectangular wires: typical working- and stabilizingwire sizes associated with the .018- and the .022-in, bracket systems. The torsional stiffness of the largest wire is seen to be nearly five times that of the smallest wire in the table. Also noteworthy is the inverse relationship between size and range. (Nominal dimensions, Equations 8-11, and Figure 8-11 were used in the preparation of Table 8-3.) Additional influ-
ences on all three dependent, structural parameters are the wire material, longitudinal dimension, and the physical character of the wire shaft. Pertinent to physical character, rectangular wire is now marketed 8-3. Comparisons of structural properties in torsion of rectangular arch wires influenced solely by cross-sectional dimensions TABLE
Wire size (inches)
Stiffness
Range
Strength
.016x .016 fl17 x .025
1*
1.5 1.2
1*
zo
1.1 1*
2.5 3.1
.019 x .026 .021 x .027
a6 3.5
4.7
*Given figures not actual values, but, in each column, compared to value for wire adiacent to asterisk (*)
302
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
in several multistranded configurations. Because the strands may move
with respect to one another in activation or deactivation processes, the stiffness in torsion of stranded wire is less than that of the solid wire of the same overall cross-section and material. Moreover, the stiffness is
dependent on the number and size of the individual strands and the
"braiding" pattern within the wire as a whole. Elastic range and strength are similarly affected. Torque is generated in the appliance as the operator produces thirdorder deformation of the rectangular wire to achieve engagement of the anterior brackets; the larger the amount of necessary activating twist, the greater the initial level of torque in the wire. Figure 8-26 illustrates a torque-versus-twist plot for a full-size (for .022-in, bracket slots), stainless-steel, maxillary arch wire. The "torque" is actually the sum of the four couples transmitted to the four maxillary incisors; the twist is that measured at the midsagittal plane, relative to the before-engagement orientation there. The nonlinear portion near the origin of the plot is associated with bracket-wire clearance, bracket-slot flexibility, and manner of ligation; beyond this portion the relationship is, essentially, linear to the elastic limit, reflecting the overall pattern of Figure 8-10. The thirdorder range of this arch is beyond 35° and the slope of the linear portion of the curve, the "working stiffness," was determined to be approximately 217 g-mm/deg. A relatively simple relationship among the relevant parameters for the entire segment is the following: Whole-segment torque = (Working stiffness) )< x (Induced twist — Clearance)
8-12
The nominal bracket-wire clearance for the arch of Figure 8-26 is approximately 3°; the horizontal-axis intercept (dotted extension of the linear portion of the plot) is slightly greater than 3°, reflecting the flexibiities of the bracket-slot and ligation. If the elastic range is sufficiently great to disallow inelastic behavior
during activation, and not minimizing the importance of bracket-wire clearance, the dominant, indispensable parameter to convert the activating twist into torque induced is the third-order stiffness. Shaft theory, examined earlier in this chapter, indicates that, in addition to material, stiffness of a solid, rectangular arch wire depends on cross-sectional size
and longitudinal dimension. In the bilateral delivery of torque to the incisal segment, "longitudinal dimension" refers, in essence, to the amount of wire between the canine and the lateral incisor. Table 8-4 presents third-order stiffnesses obtained through bench experimentation (Wagner, 1981) for 16 maxillary incisal-segment torquing arches. The material was moderately resilient stainless steel, and the occlusalview arch form coincided with the Bonwill-Hawley diagram. Particularly notable are the decreases in stiffness related to the localized, inelastic wire deformation: the permanent-twist placements and the "V" bends. The values in Table 8-4 should be looked upon as indicating trends because of differences in arch lengths among patients; further reductions
Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
217
10
20
30
40
Angle of Twist (degrees)
6. A typical third-order activation plot for a full-size, rectangular-wire, incisalrquing arch.
ss may
be attained through use of additional wire in loops more
than the simple opening loops used in the experimentation. torquing mechanics generally involves one of two attempted orthodontic displacement: bodily or root movement. is the more difficult; separate activations of the torque and ng force are necessary, and the two must be maintained over specific couple-to-force ratio. If the angulations (in a sagittal
304
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics TABLE 8-4. Torsional stiffnesses for representative, stainless-steel, rectangular-wire, incisal-segment torquing arches (in gram-millimeters per degree)*
Bend, twist placements
None (flat arch) V-bends, no twists V-bends and twists Teardrop loops and twists
.018
.018
.022
.022
Working
Stabilizing
Working
Stabilizing
180
190
160 110
170 145 110
270 230 160 125
285 265 235 180
80
'From Wagner, WA. (1981).
view) are not to change during the displacement, the initial torque mag-
nitude will remain constant (assuming no relaxation of the wire). Accordingly, the driving force should also experience no decrease in size with time and segment movement. In reality, this is an impossible set of mandates to the appliance and, therefore, some compromise must be accepted and undertaken in actual therapy. Alternatively, the torque is the principal activation in root movement. The accompanying faciolingual force is primarily responsive; as a secondary activation it arises against the tendency of the torque to move the crowns as well as the roots. The objective is to produce a displacement characterized by a center of rotation located occlusoapically near the bracket level; the ligation and anchorage must be sufficiently strong and stiff to permit rapid
development of a holding force and adequate to prevent sizable dis-
placements of crown points while the torque deactivates with the wanted movements of the roots. The discussions of transverse, orthodontic displacements in Chapter 5 revealed that the couple-to-force ratios for bodily and root movement are quantitatively similar. Using the physiologically proper force theory proposed in Chapter 5, for average-sized, maxillary, incisal segments the total intermittent torque requirement is between 3000 and 3500 g-mm at activation. The accompanying faciolingual force is 200 to 300 g and is split between the two sides of the arch. All four rectangular wires of Table 8-4 can generate in excess of 3500 g-mm of torque within their
elastic ranges. For a chosen rectangular arch-wire size and configuration, together with bracket selection to enable determination of clearance, substitution of the torque requirement and the working stiffness into Equation 8-12 enables estimation of the appropriate amount of twist activation.
The combination of arch curvature and anterior torsional activation produces several secondary effects that were mentioned previously. Of these effects, perhaps the one of most interest and concern pertains to control of the vertical position of the segment while faciolingual bodily or root movement is progressing between appointments. Any changes in the level of third-order activation in the anterior segment is accompanied by a tendency for occlusogingival movement of the anterior section of the wire. Consider, for example, the anterior portion of the wire at
305
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
bracket level with posterior engagement complete, but immediately be-
fore torsional activation and engagement into the anterior brackets. Figure 8-18 shows the result following activation of lingual root-torque in the maxillary anterior segment. In the absence of vertical constraint, the twist activation causes downward movement of the anterior portion of the arch wire; in the clinical situation, the existence of localized (bending) stiffness results in the development of an extrusive force exerted by the wire upon the anterior brackets. If the torque deactivates somewhat, subsequently, the accompanying tendency for extrusion is also reduced. Depending on the specific arch, each 10 to 15° change in elastic twist may be accompanied by as much as a millimeter of vertical movement of
the anterior section of the arch wire if unrestrained. This deflection, together with measured vertical stiffnesses between 100 and 200 g/mm for the arches of Table 8-4 (Wagner, 1981), exemplify the very real potential for extrusive or intrusive movements of the anterior teeth during torquing mechanics. Compensation for the vertical-displacement tendency can be created; the effect can also be used to produce vertical movement in concert with the torquing mechanics. Necessary at the outset is consideration of the desired vertical positions of the anterior teeth with respect to their locations prior to the torquing mechanics. Also note that both activation and deactivation of the twist affect the vertical-displacement potential. As an example, consider the attempt at bodily-movement, anterior retraction while holding the vertical positions of the maxillary anterior teeth. As indicated previously, change in long-axis angulations and reduction in torque magnitude as activated are cause and effect. To approach maintenance of the initial couple-to-force ratio over time and bodily retraction, the driving force must be generated by a low-stiffness appliance element. Ideally, the lingual root torque should not lessen with displacement and, correspondingly, the vertical-displacement potential should also remain unchanged with time. Accordingly, the position of the anterior section of the arch wire, prior to third-order activation, should be somewhat apical of the line of brackets; the amount of this vertical "malalignment" is to be proportional to the magnitude of the forthcoming twist activation. Again, the rule of thumb is 1 mm for every 10 to 15° of actual twist activation. If intrusion is wanted with these torquing mechanics, the passive, vertical "malalignment" of the wire and brackets must be exaggerated. Torquing Spurs in the Appliance As
an alternative to the use of rectangular wire, torquirig spurs
formed in round wire may be used to deliver third-order couples (with or without accompanying driving or holding forces) to the anterior teeth (or, for that matter, to any tooth). The wire must be ductile to accept the permanent bends of spur fabrication without fracture and, concurrently, resilient to sustain third-order activations approaching (and often exceeding) 90° without becoming inelastic. The individual spur may be
________________ 306
Bloengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
FIGURE 8-27. Facial views of torquing spurs: a single, narrow spur engaging an individual crown (left) and a T-loop contacting a pair of teeth (right).
affixed to an arch wire or an integral part of the wire. The spurs may be
attached to or part of a continuous arch wire or incorporated in an auxiliary (as in the Stage III appliance of pure Begg therapy). A single spur may contact an individual crown as shown on the left in Figure 8-27, engaged between the wings of a siamese or in a Begg bracket, or one spur may act on several teeth as suggested by the T-loop on the right in Figure 8-27. The typical lingual root torque generated by a torquing spur is de-
picted in the series of sketches in Figure 8-28. On the left, the spur is shown passively; it is often fabricated to lie near to or in the arch-form plane. In a view from the mesial or distal perspective, the center sketch shows the spur (dashed) following activation, an incisor with a bracket on the facial surface, and the forces exerted by the spur tip and by the arch wire on the bracket. On the right, the lingual holding- or drivingforce component, generally present and exerted by the arch wire, has been added. A vertical (occlusogingival) force component may also exist, as described previously. The labially and lingually directed forces
Passive spur
Arch wire
Lingual force
I
LingUalroot
torque
FIGURE 8-28. Sagittal views of a torquir,g spur and its effects: typical passive angulation (left), tip and in-bracket force pair acting on the crown (center), and with the holding or driving force from the arch wire added (right).
307
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
at the bracket could be combined into a single labiolingual force; how-
ever, the labially directed force in the figure is the counterpart of the spur-tip force, the two forming the couple, and combining the forces at the bracket results in loss of identity of the couple-and-force loading. Of interest is a comparison of the third-order couples generated by rectangular wire and a torquing spur. The differences in the directions of the pairs of forces and the moment arms are shown in Figure 8-29. Those forces exerted by the rectangular wire are directed nearly occlusogingivally while the force pair from the spur acts labiolingually. Because the net translational effect of the force pair is zero (with the individual forces parallel and equal in magnitude), this difference in directions is meaningless with respecf to the action delivered to the dentition. The inherent moment arms for the rectangular-wire and spur couples are the labi-
olingual dimension of the wire cross-section and the occlusogingival height of the spur, respectively; they differ by approximately one order of magnitude (a factor of ten). Hence, if the size of each force generated
by the spur is about one-tenth that of each force of the pair generated within the bracket, the results are approximately equal third-order couples applied by the two appliances. Two other comparisons are noteworthy. First, one force of the pair exerted by the spur, if the wire is engaged in an edgewise bracket, acts against the ligation (which tends to be the weakest, most flexible part of the bracket assembly); alternatively, the Begg bracket incorporates a vertical slot. Second, although a torque having either sense (clockwise or counterclockwise as viewed from a mesial or distal perspective) may easily be generated by a rectangular
wire, the spur tip can only push against the facial surface; hence, to apply a labial-root (lingual-crown) torque with a labial-appliance spur, the tip must contact the crown occlusally to the bracket. Torquing the maxillary incisal segment with spurs is conventional in
Moment arm for torquing spur
Moment arm for rectangular wire
FIGURE 8-29. Sagittal views of maxillary incisors loaded by rectangular-wire torque (left) and spur torque (right) showing differences in force directions and inherent moment arms.
308
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
FIGURE 8-30. The typical passive geometry of a Begg torquing auxiliary.
III of Begg therapy. Figure 8-30 shows a passive Begg torquing auxiliary in an occlusal view. Spurs, approximately 3 mm in height, are bent into the wire; one spur contacts each incisor facial surface with the auxiliary also engaging the canines. The auxiliary is usually formed in .012-, .014-, or .016-in, wire and is typically employed in conjunction with a .020-in, main arch wire. One purpose of the main arch wire is to help to counter the extrusive potential associated with the activation of the auxiliary. Third-order stiffnesses of Begg torquing auxiliaries are substantially less than those of the edgewise wires; correspondingly, the activations of the spurs are greater with the passive spur configurations generally in or near to the arch-form plane. Torsional- and vertical-stiffness data for Stage III appliances are presented in Table 8-5 (Leaver and Stage
TABLE 8-5. Torsional and vertical incisal-segment stiffnesses for six Begg, Stage lii maxillary-arch appliancest
Auxiliary*
Wire size (inches)
Spur angle (degrees)
.012 .014
0 0 0 45 45 45
.016
.012 .014
.016
Overlaying a .020-in. main arch wire. Leaver, SR., and Nikolai, R.J. (1978).
Torsional stiffness
(g-mm/deg)
Vertical stiffness (g-mm)
33 40
41
51
42
70 45 46
61
65
31
39
309
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
Nikolai, 1978); the passive angle of the spurs with the arch-form plane
has, apparently, little influence on either stiffness. Figure 8-31 illustrates a torquing arch incorporating spurs; however, this design is quite different from the Begg auxiliary. First, it is a continuous, maxillary arch wire engaging all teeth through the terminal molars. Second, spurs will contact only the central incisors; the torque is transferred bilaterally along the wire from posterior anchorage directly to the central incisors, with third-order action then apparently carried to the lateral incisors by the transseptal-fiber system within the alveolus. The passive geometry of the arch reflects the attempt to negate unwanted secondary effects; a curve of Spee is placed to counter the potential for extrusion that accompanies third-order activation and the posterior sections are curved toward the lingual to offset the tendency for torsional activation to enlarge the posterior arch width. The appliance may be formed in highly resilient stainless-steel wire with the passive configuration of the spurs in the arch-form plane. The spur height is a clinical variable with its upper bound determined by the distance from bracket line to gingival margin and, for heights of 5 to 6 mm, the typical torsional stiffness of the arch fabricated in .016-in, stainless steel wire is approximately 45 g-mm/deg (Mellion and Nikolai, 1982). Comparing this value to the Begg counterpart in Table 8-5, the difference is principally due to the greater "shaft" length (canine to central incisor) in the arch under discussion. Note that the torquing spur itself is, in effect, a cantilever beam; the greater height reduces the bending stiffness of the spur, but it also enlarges the moment arm of the torsional couple. Be-
FIGURE
wire.
8-31. An occiusal view of the passive configuration of a hybrid, torquing arch
310
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
cause
the overall activation of the anterior section of the arch is primarily
twisting, with only a small contribution from spur bending, for otherwise identical, round-wire torquing arches, the actual torque generated (in g-mm, for instance) is virtually proportional to the height of the spurs. To summarize, regardless of the type of anterior-segment torquing appliance used, the key load parameter is the third-order couple to be transferred from the wire to the tooth crown. This couple is determined principally by a third-order stiffness and the amount of rotational activation. Rectangular-wire stiffnesses are relatively high and the amounts of third-order activation should be correspondingly small; torsional stiffnesses of spur-incorporated round wires are less, thus creating the need for greater angular activations.
Inelastic Behavior in Third-Order Mechanics Prior to twist activation of an arch wire the clinician may alter its config-
uration, through bending and/or torsional deformation, taking the wire beyond its elastic limit to achieve a desired, pre-engagement shape. Such a process changes the external geometry of the wire and induces residual stresses; consequently, mechanical and structural parameters
are affected. Substantial ductility is required of the wire so that the working of it, which strains the material beyond its elastic limit, will not cause immediate—or, while the appliance remains activated, progressive—fracture. Inelastic twisting is examined first in this section. Recall that thirdorder loading of a straight shaft produces a circumferential strain pattern on a cross-section characterized by zero magnitude at its geometric center (through which the longitudinal shaft axis passes) with, generally, the strain increasing with radial distance from the center. On a circular cross-section, the circumferential strain at a point is directly proportional to the radial coordinate of the point. On the rectangular cross-section, these strains vary radially in a nonlinear manner. The maximum strains occur, then, at points on the external boundary of the cross-section. For circular shafts with their axisymmetric circumferential strain patterns, all points on the outer perimeter of the cross-section are subjected to maxi-
mum values. The largest circumferential strains on the rectangular cross-section occur at the two outer-surface points nearest the center (and are on one of the axes of symmetry). The patterns of shearing strains on the two cross-sections of interest are maintained, with increasing load, throughout the elastic range and well into the inelastic region of material behavior. Below the elastic limit, stress and strain are proportional; the patterns of both circumferential stress and strain are
shown in Figure 8-9 for the circular shaft and in Figure 8-12 for the rectangular shaft. The formula for elastic range of a shaft indicates direct dependence of
311
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
critical twist angle upon the characteristic longitudinal dimension (Equa-
tions 8-9 and 8-11). The practitioner typically localizes the permanenttwist placement. This establishes a sizable twist-set within a relatively small portion of shaft length and, as a result, a concentration of residual shearing stress is created. Shown on the left in Figure 8-32 is the loadunload plot for the short section of shaft (wire) in which a permanent twist is placed. On the right in the figure is a curve describing in graphic fashion the circumferential stress-strain relation during the twist placement for the element on the shaft outer surface experiencing the greatest shearing strain during the process; the final point of the plot reflects the residual shearing strain and stress. For a round wire, a direct analogy can be drawn between inelastic bending and twisting when discussing stress patterns. In bending, the variation in normal stress with distance from the neutral axis was considered and, in torsion, the shearing-stress dependence on radial distance from the shaft center is examined. The sketch on the left in Figure 8-33 shows the pattern of increasing circumferential shearing stress with the radial coordinate r for the critical section of the circular shaft that has undergone torsional loading beyond the elastic range for the member as a whole. Within the elastic core of radius re., the relationship between the stress and r is linear; beyond the core, shaft elements have been inelastically strained and the relationship is nonlinear. The center sketch depicts the change-in-stress pattern assodated with the unloading of the shaft section. As noted previously in Chapters 3 and 7, unloading of a structural member always has elastic characteristics, thus the linear relationship between stress-change and the coordinate r for the metallic shaft material. Although the resultants of the load and unload stress distributions shown must be equal in magnitude (because the couple returns to zero upon unloading), the differences in distribution yield, upon superposition of one upon the other,
0) 0) 0)
C)
C)
:3
(I) (5 a)
-c
(I)
Shear Strain e0
Angle of Twist 0
(stress reversal)
FIGURE 8-32. Load-deformation plot for a shaft section in placement of a permanent twist (left) and a stress-strain plot for an element in the section at the shaft outer surface (right).
312
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
Load
Unload
Residual
FIGURE 8-33. The load (left), unload (center), and net residual (right), circumferential, shearing-stress patterns for a metallic shaft strained beyond its elastic limit.
net residual-stress pattern shown on the right in Figure 8-33. The difference between the load and unload third-order deformations is the permanent twist (Fig. 8-32, left). Upon overall unloading, elements near the shaft axis do not completely lose the stress induced with loading. At a specific radial coordinate beyond the elastic core, the loading stress and unloading stress-change exactly cancel one another, and near the outer surface of the shaft the elements experience a stress-reversal upon unloading. For the circular shaft this residual-stress pattern is the same along all radial-coordinate lines, commensurate with the axial symmetry. In the rectangular shaft the patterns are similar to that on the right in Figure 8-33, but they are more nonlinear and relative maximum values vary with radial-coordinate direction. Some changes in pattern occur as the diagonals of the rectangular cross-section are approached; however, the stress magnitudes are not critical in these regions. If the wire material can adequately take a permanent twist without failure, the subsequent concern is the superimposition of an elastic activation. From a practical standpoint, considerations are restricted to rectangular wires. (Round wires that easily fit into brackets will spin within them under torsional activation, with or without placement of permanent twists; torquing spurs incorporated in round wire to enable transfer of third-order actions are bent into the wire.) Two points of practical note are to be made. First, the activating (elastic) twist to gain bracket engagement and create the torque is undertaken in a sense opposite to that of the preceding, permanent-set twist. Thus, the largest shearing stresses of the activation itself, occurring near and at the outer surface of the wire, will be, at the sites of permanent-twist placement, superimposed on the largest residual stresses having the same sense. Accordingly, the maximum net shearing stresses will be at points on the outer surface of the cross-section and will be greater than if no permanent twists had been
the
placed. Distant from the outer surface the activating and residual stresses are of opposite senses and will tend to cancel one another. In short, placements of permanent twists followed by opposite-sense,
third-order activation results in concentrations of sizable shearing stresses at outer-surface locations of the shaft. Localized inelastic action
313
Deliveiy of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
may even occur, which will tend to reduce the concentration of stresses
and distribute them inwardly. A wire material with substantial ductility
is, therefore, absolutely necessary to avoid approach of the fracture point with activation. Second, bench-experimentation has shown that permanent-twist placements tend to lower the third-order stiffness of the arch wire (Table 8-4). The greater the amount of the permanent set, the larger the decrease in the stiffness. For a given magnitude of twist placement, the percentage reduction in stiffness seems to be essentially independent of cross-sectional size. In appliances incorporating torquing spurs, third-order elastic action is superimposed upon a residual-stress pattern remaining from the formation of those spurs. The analysis is complicated from several standpoints, and only a superficial examination is warranted here. Whether formed directly in the arch wire or prepared separately, the spurs are
bent into an initially straight segment of wire. Localized bends are placed to form the spur tip and where the spur joins the arch form. If the spur is formed directly in the arch wire, the three bends are located in a
common plane; if the spur is attached to the wire, the attachment is partially accomplished through inelastic bending that wraps the legs of the spur around the arch wire, and this bending is in a plane that is perpendicular to that of the spur-tip preparation. The activation of the torquing arch of Figure 8-31, for example, is in two parts: the wire segments between the central incisors and the canines experience the bulk of the elastic deformation as they are loaded in torsion while the spurs experience a small amount of bending deformation. Each spur, behaving much like a cantilevered beam, undergoes its maximum bending strains at the junctions with the arch form and experiences virtually zero strain of activation at the tip (apex). Whatever bending activation does occur at the junctions is in a plane at right angles to that of the permanent bends. Torsional couples are transformed into bending couples at these junctions and, although the stress analysis is extremely difficult
there, it is likely that these are critical locations (of maximum total stress). If the spurs are formed separately, then wound around the main
arch wire, the bending activation is directly superimposed upon the residual-stress patterns left by the winding. From the discussion of inelastic bending in Chapter 7, it is preferable to orient the windings such that the activation of the spurs tends to further wind, rather than partially unwind, the bent wire at the junction. The maximum net bending stress will be less with the former procedure. As noted earlier, third-order activation in the anterior portion of the arch wire produces second-order response in the posterior regions due to the curvature of the arch form. In edgewise, anterior-retraction mechanics, the clinician may place loops just mesial to the lead teeth of the
posterior segments. These loops, incorporated in the arch wire, are formed by inelastic bending in the faciolingual plane. Potential wire fail-
ure associated with the superimposition of the activating and residual bending-stress patterns within the loops need not be of great concern if the wire material is ductile, but the influence of these loops on stiff-
314
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
is notable. First, the presence of the loops effectively increases the longitudinal dimension of the shaft portion of the arch wire and, thereby, lowers the third-order stiffness as indicated in Table 8-4. Second, viewing the arch wire from a buccal perspective, the anterior portion is cantilevered from the posterior segments, the loops also effectively increase the beam length and, as a result, the vertical stiffness is reduced in the anterior section to possibly lessen the impact of the generally unwanted, secondary effect discussed previously. The more wire incorporated in these loops, the greater are the third-order and vertical flexibilities in the anterior sections of the arch. Note, however, that the loops oriented gingivally must be passively open to be effective if the
nesses
third-order activation is to produce lingual-root torque. Loops may also have a more direct association with torsion, either in terms of their own internal force systems or their effects upon the teeth; such auxiliaries are discussed in the following section.
Wire Loops, Springs, and Torsion Structural aspects of orthodontic wire loops were first considered in
Chapter 7, and that discussion was restricted to loops that provide mesiodistal flexibility to the continuous arch wire and were activated in flexure within the plane of their bends. Appropriate here in this chapter is the extension of that discussion to consider loops bent directly into the wire or auxiliaries that either experience internal torsional loading when
activated or are intended to transmit torquing couples to individual teeth in order to impart root-movement potential or control. These loops and auxiliaries are exemplified by the "half-box" loop and the uprighting spring. The usual objective in activating a half-box loop is to exert a faciolingual force on an individual tooth. The loop, as prepared from a straight segment of wire through placement of four, right-angle bends, is shown on the left in Figure 8-34. The vertical legs are typically 5 to 6 mm in length and the horizontal section spans one or more interbracket dis-
0 Q
Ce
Passive, buccal view
Occiusal view
FIGURE 8-34. A half-box loop shown passively in a faciolirigual view (left), and as activated and subjected to its typical force system from an occiusal perspective (right).
315
Delivery of Torque by the Orthodontic Appliance
tances,
depending on the specific application. The loop is activated in
the direction perpendicular to the plane of the loop as formed. The sketch on the right in Figure 8-34 shows an occlusal view of the ioop as
ordinarily activated. The active and responsive force systems are included in the figure; capability must be present for generating the firstorder couple(s) to disallow contact between the loop and the gingiva. The faciolingual forces at the activation and anchorage sites are equal and opposite to one another, and the resultant couple is equal in magnihide to that formed by the two forces. (Additional actions may be imparted at the activation site, provided the equilibrating responses can be developed. The loop could also actively transmit a first-order couple, an occlusogingival force, a second-order couple, and, if the ioop is bent in
rectangular wire, a third-order couple to an appropriate malaligned tooth.) In Figure 8-35, the three sections of the half-box loop are separated, making the force systems at the "corners" external. Following activation, the reaction of the tooth crown at the activation site loads one leg in bending; the mesiodistal view of the vertical leg on the left shows the force system of a cantilever (plus torsion if C1 is present). The bending couple in the left leg becomes a twisting couple (Qv) in the midsection of the loop with the right-angle turn in the wire. The horizontal section,
as shown from an occlusal perspective in the center sketch of Figure 8-35, is subjected to a combination of twisting and bending; action-reaclion analysis gives the force system at its left end, and force and moment balances would yield the responsive components at the right end of the section. A mesiodistal view of the right leg of the loop is shown on the
right in Figure 8-35. The 90° turn converts the twisting and bending couples at the right end of the midsection into bending and twisting couples, respectively, at the gingival end of the right leg of the half-box
Qv
0 I
v
QV4I
FIGURE 8-35. Free-body diagrams of the three straight-segment sections of the activated halt-box loop of Figure 8-34.
V
316
Bioengineering Analysis of Orthodontic Mechanics
ioop, and this is the critical section of the ioop (where the internal bend-
ing and twisting moments are concurrently maximum). The right leg of
the loop, then, is also subjected to combined bending and twisting. (With additional components from activation at the occiusal end of the left vertical leg, the analysis becomes more complex. The numerous variations will not be examined here, but in most instances the critical section wifi be located at the bend diagonally opposite to the activation site.)
Of the various structural properties of the loop, interest centers on the faciolingual stiffness since this characteristic, together with the activating displacement, yields the initial crown load. Generally, this stiffness is dependent on wire material, cross-sectional size and shape, and curvilinear length (the amount of wire in the loop). From the foregoing bending and torsional analyses, the mesiodistal wire dimension and the occlusogingival lengths of the vertical legs will be the most influential geometric parameters. All other properties held constant, the greater the
separation between activation and anchorage sites, the greater the length of the horizontal section and the larger the overall flexibility of the loop. Should the action of the loop include an occlusogingival loading component, the midsection length in particular will influence the occlusogingival stiffness.
The uprighting spring is an auxiliary designed to exert a secondorder couple on a tooth crown, adding to an appliance the capability of controlling root-tip position (long-axis angulation) in the faciolingual plane. The spring is formed, usually in round wire, by placing several
permanent bends to obtain the desired shape. One leg of the spring engages the bracket slot (which may be either horizontal or vertical) at the activation site and the other leg is generally hooked over the main arch wire. The passive (dashed) and active (solid) configurations of the spring are shown in Figure 8-36