Aftermaths of War
History of Warfare Editors
Kelly DeVries Loyola College Maryland
John France University of Wales ...
328 downloads
4665 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Aftermaths of War
History of Warfare Editors
Kelly DeVries Loyola College Maryland
John France University of Wales Swansea
Michael S. Neiberg University of Southern Mississippi
Frederick Schneid High Point University North Carolina
VOLUME 63
Aftermaths of War Women’s Movements and Female Activists, 1918-1923
Edited by
Ingrid Sharp Matthew Stibbe
LEIDEN • BOSTON 2011
Cover illustration: ‘Hunger—For three years America has fought starvation in Belgium. Will you eat less wheat, meat, fats and sugar that we may still send food in ship loads?’ by Henry Raleigh, 1880-1945. Reproduction Number: LC-USZC4-10330 (color film copy transparency) // LC-USZC2-562 (color film copy slide), Call Number: POS—US .R35, no. 1 (C size) [P&P] (http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/2002719438) With kind permission of the Library of Congress Prints and Photographs Division, Washington, D.C. Brill has made all reasonable efforts to trace all rights holders to any copyrighted material used in this work. In cases where these efforts have not been successful the publisher welcomes communications from copyrights holders, so that the appropriate acknowledgements can be made in future editions, and to settle other permission matters. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Aftermaths of war : women’s movements and female activists, 1918-1923 / edited by Ingrid Sharp, Matthew Stibbe. â•…â•… p. cm. — (History of warfare, ISSN 1385-7827 ; v. 63) â•… Includes index. â•… ISBN 978-90-04-19172-3 (hardback : alk. paper) ╇ 1. Feminism—Europe—History—20th century. 2. Women political activists— Europe—History—20th century. 3. World War, 1914-1918—Social aspects—Europe. I. Sharp, Ingrid. II. Stibbe, Matthew. III. Title. â•… HQ1587.A34 2011 â•… 305.42094’09042—dc22
2010050340
ISSN 1385-7827 ISBN 978 90 04 19172 3 Copyright 2011 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands. Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Hotei Publishing, IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Koninklijke Brill NV provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change.
contents
v
Contents Acknowledgements . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ix List of Abbreviations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xi List of Illustrations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xv List of Contributors. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . xvii Introduction: Women’s Movements and Female Activists in the Aftermath of War: International Perspectives 1918-1923 Ingrid Sharp and Matthew Stibbe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
part one
commemoration, remembering, remobilisation The aftermaths of defeat: the fallen, the catastrophe, and the public response of women to the end of the First World War in Bulgaria Nikolai Vukov. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .â•… 29 The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919 and Voce nuova (“New Voice”): Corporatism, nationalism and the struggle for political rights Emma Schiavon . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .â•… 49 Raps across the knuckles: The extension of war culture by radical nationalist women journalists in post-1918 Germany Christiane Streubel. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .â•… 69 The Rhineland Horror campaign and the aftermath of war Erika Kuhlman. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .â•… 89
vi
contents part two
the renegotiation of gender roles From “Free Love” to Married Love: Gender politics, Marie Stopes, and middlebrow fiction by women in the early nineteen twenties Ann Rea. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 113 The disappearing surplus: the spinster in the post-war debate in Weimar Germany, 1918-1920 Ingrid Sharp . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 135 After the vote was won. The fate of the women’s suffrage movement in Russia after the October Revolution: individuals, ideas and deeds Olga Shnyrova.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 159 Women activists in Albania following independence and World War I Fatmira Musaj and Beryl Nicholson. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 179 part three
women’s suffrage and political rights A bitter-sweet victory: Feminisms in France (1918-1923) Christine Bard.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 199 Sisters and Comrades. Women’s movements and the “Austrian Revolution”: Gender in insurrection, the Räte movement, parties and parliament Gabriella Hauch. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 221 Who represents Hungarian women? The demise of the liberal bourgeois women’s rights movement and the rise of the rightwing women’s movement in the aftermath of World War I Judith Szapor . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 245
contents
vii
Soldiers, members of parliament, social activists: the Polish women’s movement after World War I Sylwia Kuźma-Markowska. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 265 Political and public aspects of the activity of the Lithuanian women’s movement, 1918-1923 Virginija Jurėnienė. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 287 part four
reconstructing communities/ visions of peace Diverse constructions: Feminist and conservative women’s movements and their contribution to the (re-)construction of gender relations in Hungary after the First World War Judit Acsády . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 309 Elsa Brändström and the reintegration of returning prisoners of war and their families in post-war Germany and Austria Matthew Stibbe. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 333 “We stand on the threshold of a new age”: Alice Masaryková, the Czechoslovak Red Cross, and the building of a new Europe Bruce R.╯Berglund. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 355 “Having Seen Enough”: Eleanor Franklin Egan and the journalism of Great War displacement David Hudson . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 375 Britain in the Balkans: the response of the Scottish Women’s Hospital Units Jill Liddington. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 395 Index . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 419
viii
contents
contents
ix
Acknowledgements The editors would like to thank the LHRI at the University of Leeds and the Humanities Research Centre at Sheffield Hallam University for their generous support of the conference at the University of Leeds in September 2008, upon which this volume is based, and the followup work editorial workshop, which took place at the Academy of Sciences in Budapest in April 2009. They are also grateful to those who attended the Budapest workshop: David Hudson, Olga Shnyrova and Nikolai Vukov, and in particular to Judit Acsády who organised and hosted this event. Finally, they appreciate the kind advice and encouragement of Julian Deahl and Marcella Mulder at Brill. Ingrid Sharp would also like to thank her co-editor, Matthew Stibbe, for his professionalism and her family, Dorron, Søren, Frederike and Ferdinand for their help and support. Matthew Stibbe would also like to thank Sam, Nicholas and Hannah. And Ingrid, of course. Ingrid Sharp Matthew Stibbe May 2010
x
contents
list of abbreviations
xi
List of Abbreviations Allgemeiner Deutscher Frauenverein (General German Women’s Association, founded 1865) AÖFV Allgemeiner Österreichischer Frauenverein (General AusÂ� trian Women’s Association, founded 1893) BCP Balgarska Komunisticheska Partiya (Bulgarian Communist Party, founded 1919) BDF Bund deutscher Frauenvereine (Federation of German Women’s Associations, founded 1894) BeöK Bundesvereinigung der ehemaligen österreichischen KriegsÂ� gefangenen (Federal Association of former Austrian PrisonÂ� ers of War, founded 1924) Confédération Générale du Travail (General Federation of CGT Labour, France, founded 1895) CNDI Consiglio nazionale delle donne italiane (National Council of Italian Women, founded 1903) CSP Christlichsoziale Partei (Christian Social Party, founded in Austria, 1893) DDP Deutsche Demokratische Partei (German Democratic Party, founded 1918) DNVP Deutschnationale Volkspartei (German National People’s Party, founded 1918) Feministák Egyesülete (Hungarian Association of Feminists, FE founded 1904) FFC Fight the Famine Council (founded in the UK, 1919) GDVP Großdeutsche Volkspartei (Greater German People’s Party, founded in Austria, 1920) ICRC International Committee of the Red Cross (founded in Geneva, 1863) International Council of Women (founded in the USA, ICW 1888) ICWPP International Committee of Women for Permanent Peace (founded 1915) IWSA International Women’s Suffrage Alliance (founded 1904) KFO Katholische Frauenorganisation (Catholic Women’s Organisation, founded in Austria, 1906) ADF
xii
list of abbreviations
KPD Kommunistische Partei Deutschlands (German Communist Party, founded 1918) KPÖ Kommunistische Partei Österreichs (Austrian Communist Party, founded 1918) KSCS Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes (official name for Yugoslavia between 1918 and 1929) LCWA Lietuvos katalikių moterų sąjunga (Lithuanian Catholic Women’s Association, founded 1908) LWU Lietuvos moterų sąjunga (Lithuanian Women’s Union, founded 1905) MANSZ Magyar Asszonyok Nemzeti Szövetsége (National AssoÂ� ciation of Hungarian Women, founded 1919) NAACP National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (founded in the USA, 1909) NEP New Economic Policy (Soviet Russia, 1921) NOK Narodowa Organizacja Kobiet (National Organisation of Women, founded Poland, 1918) NSDAP Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (National Socialist German Workers’ Party – the Nazi Party, founded in Munich, 1919) NUSEC National Union of Societies for Equal Citizenship (founded in the UK, 1918/19) NUWSS National Union of Women’s Suffrage Societies (founded in the UK, 1897) OLK Ochotnicza Legia Kobiet (Voluntary Women’s Legion, founded in Poland, 1918/19) PCF Parti communiste français (French Communist Party, foundÂ�ed 1920) POWs Prisoners of War ReK Reichsvereinigung ehemaliger Kriegsgefangener (Reich AssoÂ�Â�ciation of Former Prisoners of War, Germany, founded 1919) RLWE Russian League for Women’s Equality (founded 1907) RMAS Russian Mutual Aid Society (founded 1895) RUWE All-Russian Union for Women’s Equality (founded 1905) SCF Save the Children Fund (founded in the UK, 1919) SDAP Sozialdemokratische Arbeiterpartei (Social Democratic Labour Party, founded in Austria, 1889) SFIO Section Française de l’Internationale Ouvrière (French SociaÂ�list Party, founded 1905)
list of abbreviations
xiii
SPD Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands (German Social Democratic Party, founded 1875) STIs Sexually Transmitted Infections SWH The Scottish Women’s Hospitals (founded in the UK, 1914) UFN Unione Femminile Nazionale (Italian National Women’s Union, founded 1899) USPD Unabhängige Sozialdemokratische Partei Deutschlands (InÂ�dependent German Social Democratic Party, founded 1917) Voluntary Aid Detachment (founded in the UK, 1909) VAD Vereinigung ehemaliger Kriegsgefangener Deutschlands VeK (AssoÂ�ciation of former German Prisoners of War, founded 1925) Women’s Freedom League (founded in the UK, 1907) WFL WILPF Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom (founded 1919) WPP Women’s Progressive Party (Russia) WSPU Women’s Social and Political Union (founded in the UK, 1903) ZLP Związek Legionistek Polskich (Association of Polish Women Legionaries, founded 1926)
xiv
list of abbreviations
contents
xv
List of Illustrations 1. Richard Ziegler, Junge Witwe (Das Zweite Ich), 1920
149
2. The grave of Anna Shabanova in St. Petersburg
173
3. The wife of the Hungarian governor, Miklós Horthy, with a group of women weavers at Buda Castle
313
4. General meeting of the Hungarian Association of Feminists, celebrating the 25th anniversary of their foundation in Budapest
320
5. Front cover of the Hungarian journal, Nők Lapja, 15 March 1916
321
6. Elsa Brändström, 1929
336
7. Alice Masaryková, 1921
356
8. Eleanor Franklin Egan, 29 June 1918
376
9. The eastern portion of Eleanor Franklin Egan’s European tour in 1919
377
10. Dr Katherine Macphail dances the kolo in wartime Serbia
396
11. Map of wartime Serbia, 1915-1918
398
12. Haverfield Orphanage at Bajina Basta, c.1919
410
13. Front cover of Daylight in a Dream, by E. M.╯Butler (1951) 416
xvi
contents
list of contributors
xvii
List of Contributors Judit Acsády is a sociologist, employed by the Sociology Research Institute of the Hungarian Academy of Sciences. She completed her studies at ELTE University, Budapest, in Sociology, English and Hungarian, attending postgraduate courses in Paris and Amsterdam. She was awarded her Ph.D on “Emancipation and Identity” in 2005. Her research includes the history of Hungarian feminism, the history of debates on the woman question in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries, the construction of views on emancipation, and gender relations after the transition. She has published widely in these areas in Hungarian and in English, and has contributed to the work of several international research teams. She was a contributor to The Women’s Movement in Wartime: International Perspectives, 1914-19, eds. Alison S.╯Fell and Ingrid Sharp (Palgrave Macmillan, 2007). She is also the mother of a twelve-year old boy, Áron. Christine Bard is Professor of Contemporary History at the University of Angers. She is a specialist in the political, social and cultural history of women, feminism and anti-feminism, and her many publications in this area include Les Filles de Marianne: Histoire des féminismes 1914-1940 (Fayard, 1995); Les Garçonnes. Modes et fantasmes des Années folles (Flammarion, 1998); and Les Femmes dans la société française au 20e siècle (A.╯Colin, 2001). More recently she has published Ce que soulève la jupe (Autrement, 2010); and Une histoire politique du pantalon (Seuil, 2010). She is president of the association Archives du féminisme, coordinator of the virtual museum Musea, and editor-in-chief of the series Archives du féminisme at the Presses universitaires de Rennes. Bruce Berglund is Associate Professor of History at Calvin College in Grand Rapids, Michigan. A specialist in East Central European history, he has published articles on the Czechoslovak exile community in Britain during World War II, turn-of-the-century religious art in the region, and the architecture of Prague Castle. He is co-editor, with Brian Porter-Szűcs, of the volume Christianity and Modernity in Eastern Europe (Central European University Press, 2010).
xviii
list of contributors
Gabriella Hauch is Professor of Women’s and Gender Studies and Modern and Contemporary History at the Johannes Kepler University in Linz, Austria and from September 2011 she will be Professor of Modern History/Women’s and Gender History at the University of Vienna. She has written widely on Europe and Austria since the eighteenth century and is a specialist in the political, social and cultural history of transformation of societies, gender relations and women’s organisations. Her publications in the area of the First World War period include Vom Frauenstandpunkt aus. Frauen im Parlament 1919-1933 (Döcker 1996); and more recently Frauen bewegen Politik. Österreich 1848-1938 (Studienverlag, 2009). She is co-editor of the ÖsterÂ�reichische Zeitschrift für Geschichtswissenschaften (ÖZG). David Hudson is Associate Professor of English at Hamline UniÂ� versity in St. Paul, Minnesota where he teaches literature and jourÂ� nalism. He has written on soldier narrative and its relation to the canon of First World War literature. His recent work examines the intersections between journalism, propaganda, and literary and personal responses to the war, including an earlier article on the pioneering journalist Eleanor Franklin Egan: “Writing ‘Mesopot’: Eleanor Franklin Egan on the River to Baghdad, 1917” (Philological Papers, 2006). Virginija Jurėnienė is Associate Professor of History in the DeÂ�partÂ� ment of Philosophy and Cultural Studies at the Vilniaus University Kaunas, Lithuania. In 2004 she received her Doctorate in humaniÂ�ties (history) for the Ph.D thesis “The Lithuanian women’s movement at the end of the nineteenth century and the first part of the twentieth century”. Her research interests include the Lithuanian women’s movement, women’s political and social activities, and cultural representations of women in the twentieth and twenty-first centuries. Erika Kuhlman is Associate Professor of History and director of Women Studies at Idaho State University. She is author of Petticoats and White Feathers (Greenwood, 1997) and Reconstructing Patriarchy after the Great War: Women, Gender, and Postwar Reconciliation between Nations (Palgrave Macmillan, 2008). Her current book, Of Little Comfort: War Widows, Fallen Soldiers, and the Remaking of the Nation after the Great War, is under contract at New York University Press.
list of contributors
xix
Sylwia Kuźma-Markowska is Assistant Professor at the American Studies Centre, University of Warsaw. She does research on women’s history, the social history of medicine, birth control and motherhood, and women’s movements in Poland and the United States. Her most recent publications include Zdrowe matki, chciane dzieci. Ruch konÂ� troli urodzeń w stanie Illinois, 1923-1941 (Well Mothers, Wanted Babies. The Birth Control Movement in the State of Illinois, 1923-1941) (NeriÂ�ton, 2010); and “From ‘Drop of Milk’ to ‘Schools for Mothers’ – Infant Care and Visions of Medical Motherhood in the Early 20th Century Polish Part of the Habsburg Empire,” in Medicine Within and Between the Habsburg and Ottoman Empires, ed. D. T.╯Sechel (Vienna, 2010). Jill Liddington is co-author of One Hand Tied Behind Us (Virago 1978, 2000) which quickly became a suffrage classic. Her history of Greenham won the 1990 Fawcett Book Prize. She is Honorary Research Fellow at Leeds University, and her most recent book, Rebel Girls: their fight for the vote (Virago, 2006) was shortlisted for the 2008 Portico Book Prize. In the summer of 2008, she retraced the steps of the American Unit – from Thessaloniki across to Ostravo, then up to Skopje and Vranje. Fatmira Musaj is Research Professor at the Institute of History in the Centre for the Study of Albanology, Tirana. Her field is the history of modern Albania, with the inter-war period as her speciality. Besides numerous articles, she has published the monographs Isa Boletini, 1864-1916 (Albanian Academy of Sciences, 1987) and Gruaja në Shqipëri 1912-1939 (Women in Albania 1912-1939) (Albanian AcaÂ� demy of Sciences, 2002). Her most recent book, Republika Shqiptare, 1925-1928, is in press. Beryl Nicholson is a sociologist and independent scholar. After doing research on North Norway and on population for many years, she has turned her attention to Albanian society in both the present and the period from the state’s foundation in 1912 to the Second World War. Her wide-ranging publications include a contribution to La violenza contro i civili durante la Grande guerra. Deportati, profughi, internati, ed. Bruna Bianchi (Unicopli, 2006), and many journal articles.
xx
list of contributors
Ann Rea is originally from Northern Ireland and works on twentiethcentury English Literature and Irish Literature, having obtained a Ph.D in English Literature from Rutgers University, New Jersey. A Visiting Lecturer at the University of Pittsburgh at Johnstown, PennÂ� sylvania, she is co-organiser of a forthcoming series of MiddleÂ�brow Monographs, is Co-President of the Space Between Society for the Study of Literature and Culture from 1914-1945, and is currently working on various projects that focus on Eilis Dillon’s fiction for adolescents, discussions of Marie Stopes’s ideas about marriage and sexuality in middlebrow fiction, and the spy fiction of John Le Carré, Graham Greene and Eric Ambler. Emma Schiavon has a Ph.D in contemporary history, with a thesis on interventionist feminists in Italy during the First World War. She has focused in particular on the relationship between women, war and citizenship in different contexts and periods and has published articles and essays on this topic in Italia contemporanea, Passato e presente, Genesis, and DWF.╯She collaborates with the Cirsde (Research Centre for Women’s and Gender Studies of the University of Turin). Ingrid Sharp is Senior Lecturer in the School of Modern Languages and Cultures, University of Leeds. She has published widely on gender relations at various stages in German history, and is co-editor with Jane Jordan of Diseases of the Body Politic: Josephine Butler and the Prostitution Campaigns (Routledge, 2003). In 2005 and 2008, she coorganised, with Alison Fell and Matthew Stibbe, two international conferences on the response of women’s organisations and female activists to the First World War and its aftermath. She is co-editor with Alison Fell of The Women’s Movement in Wartime. International Perspectives 1914-19 (Palgrave Macmillan, 2007). Olga Shnyrova is Associate Professor of History at the Ivanovo State University and the director of its research subdivision, Centre for Gender Studies. She teaches courses on Contemporary History, European Studies and Gender Studies and does research on women’s history and women’s movements in Russia and Great Britain. She was contributor to Suffrage, Gender and Citizenship – International PerÂ� spectives on Parliamentary Reforms, eds. Irma Sulkunen, Seija-Leena Nevala-Nurmi and Pirjo Markkola (Cambridge Scholars Publishing, 2009); The Women’s Movement in Wartime: International Perspectives,
list of contributors
xxi
1914-19, eds. Alison S.╯Fell and Ingrid Sharp (Palgrave Macmillan, 2007); and to the Biographical Dictionary of Women’s Movements and Feminisms in Central, Eastern, and Southeastern Europe, 19th and 20th Centuries, eds. Fransiska de Haan and Krassimira Daskalova (Central European University Press, Budapest, 2006). She was also the editor of the Russian translation of Richard Stites’ book The Women’s Liberation Movement in Russia: Feminism, Nihilism and Bolshevism 1860-1930 (ROSSPEN, 2004) and one of the translators into Russian of History of Women in the West (Aletheia, 2007-) Matthew Stibbe is Professor of Modern European History at Sheffield Hallam University. He was a contributor to The Women’s Movement in Wartime: InterÂ�national Perspectives, 1914-19, eds. Alison S.╯Fell and Ingrid Sharp (Palgrave Macmillan, 2007), and has written widely on Germany and Austria during the First World War period. His most recent publications in this field include British Civilian Internees in Germany: The Ruhleben Camp, 1914-18 (Manchester University Press, 2008); GerÂ�many, 1914-1933: Politics, Society and Culture (Pearson, 2010); and an edited book, Captivity, Forced Labour and Forced Migration in Europe During the First World War (Routledge, 2009). He is also co-editor, with Kevin McDermott, of two volumes of essays on post-1945 Eastern Europe: Revolution and Resistance in Eastern Europe: Challenges to Communist Rule (Berg, 2006); and Stalinist Terror in Eastern Europe: Elite Purges and Mass Repression (Manchester University Press, 2010). Christiane Streubel is Reader in Modern History at the WestÂ� fälische-Wilhelms-Universität in Münster, Germany. She specialises in the history of German right-wing women and in media discourses and visualisations of old age in postmodern times. Recent publications include Radikale Nationalistinnen: Agitation und Programmatik rechter Frauen in der Weimarer Republik (Campus Verlag, 2006), and Lenore Kühn (1878-1955): Neue Nationalistin und verspätete BildungsÂ� bürgerin (trafo, 2007). She is also co-editor, with Eva Schoeck-QuinÂ� teros, of ‘Ihrem Volk verantwortlich’. Frauen der politischen Rechten (1890â•‚1933): Organisationen – Agitationen – Ideologien (trafo, 2007), and with H.╯Hartung, D.╯Reinmuth and A.╯Uhlmann, of Graue Theorie: Die Kategorien Alter und Geschlecht im kulturellen Diskurs (Böhlau Verlag, 2007).
xxii
list of contributors
Judith Szapor is Faculty Lecturer at the Department of History of McGill University, Montreal, Canada. She has written on the HunÂ� garian women’s movements, including the Hungarian chapter in Women’s Emancipation Movements in the Nineteenth Century: A EuroÂ�Â�pean Perspective, eds. B.╯Pietrow-Ennker and S.╯Paletschek (StanÂ� ford University Press, 2004). Recently, she published The Hungarian Pocahontas: The Life and Times of Laura Polanyi Stricker, 1882-1959 (East European Monographs, distributed by Columbia University Press, 2005) and, with Maura Hametz and Andrea Pető, edited the volume Tradition Unchained: Jewish Intellectual Women in Central Europe From the Late Nineteenth Century, forthcoming in 2010 at the University of Ottawa Press. Nikolai Vukov is Research Associate at the Institute of Folklore in the Bulgarian Academy of Sciences. He was a contributor to The Burden of Remembering: Recollections and Representations of the Twentieth Century, eds. E.╯Kõresaar, E.╯Lauk and K.╯Kuutma (Finnish Literary Society, 2009); and Neue Staaten – neue Bilder? Visuelle Kultur im Dienst staatlicher Selbstdarstellung in Zentral- und Osteuropa seit 1918, eds. A.╯Bartetzky, M.╯Dmitrieva and S.╯Troebst (Böhlau Verlag, 2005), among other volumes. He has written extensively on monuments, death and commemorations in twentieth-century Eastern Europe. Currently he is a fellow at the Centre for Advanced Study in Sofia, developing a project on reconceptualisations of the “recent past” following major upheavals in modern Bulgaria.
introduction
1
Introduction: Women’s Movements and Female Activists in the Aftermath of War: International Perspectives 1918-1923 Ingrid Sharp and Matthew Stibbe* In November 1918, when an armistice ending the First World War was signed on the western front, Europe had experienced almost four and a half years of continuous fighting (six years if we factor in the two Balkan wars of 1912-13). The victory of the Allies and the defeat of the Central Powers had extremely important and lasting political consequences, notably the collapse of the Russian, Ottoman and Habsburg empires and the redrawing of international frontiers in much of central, eastern and south-eastern Europe. Historic nations which had previously been swallowed up by more powerful neighbours, such as Poland and Lithuania, were revived, while entirely new states, like Czechoslovakia and Yugoslavia, were created on the basis of supposed common ethnicity and linguistic heritage.1 Yet in many ways the war did not end neatly on 11 November 1918. For one thing, the deliberate exclusion of Germany, Austria and Hungary from subsequent peace talks, combined with Allied intervention in the Russian civil war of 1918 to 1920 meant that wartime conditions continued in central and eastern Europe for considerably longer than in the west. For another thing, the western Allies themselves soon fell out over the details of the Versailles peace settlement, culminating in the refusal of the United States Senate in March 1920 to ratify a treaty which the American President Woodrow Wilson had himself helped to negotiate. Italy too was left wholly unsatisfied, not least by what it considered to be the inadequate territorial rewards it was offered, especially in the Adriatic. Outside Europe, Britain and France were able to agree on an imperialist carve up of former Turkish-held territories in the Middle East, but even here problems remained – not least the failure to satisfy the demands of Arab nationalists for independence and of the world *╇ We would like to thank all our contributors for their critical feedback on earlier drafts of this introduction. 1 ╇ Hobsbawm (1994), p.╯33.
2
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
Zionist movement for a “national home” for the Jews in Palestine. The end of the war offered no solutions to these pressing international questions.2 On top of this came the social and human costs of war, which continued to be felt long after the guns had fallen silent. Close to nine million soldiers and six million civilians were killed, and twenty million or so men were maimed or injured, some of them permanently.3 Quite apart from the war dead and war wounded, the November 1918 armistice did little to ensure the safe repatriation of hundreds of thousands of POWs, civilian internees, forced labourers and refugees who had been uprooted from their homes and families during the course of the fighting.4 The demobilisation of millions of troops was itself a mammoth task, causing fears of mass unemployment, a crime wave of unprecedented proportions, or even revolution on the Russian model. And finally, the war had brought hunger, disease and civilian casualties on a grand scale, particularly, but not only in territories which continued to be subject to Allied economic blockade until July 1919. The number of Germans who succumbed to malnutrition during and immediately after the war is estimated at between 478,500 and 763,000, while the Spanish ‘flu pandemic of 1918/19 caused up to 40 million deaths globally, including 200,000 in France, 112,000 in Britain, and 187,000 in Germany.5 In many ways, then, the urgency of immediate need eclipsed any possible social and political gains from the war, such as the extension of suffrage (including female suffrage in some countries); the introduction of more democratic structures; increased state concern for the welfare of populations; and the removal of authoritarian regimes. Or as Richard Bessel puts it, the years after 1918 were “years of upheaval and disorder, of unnatural disruption which had been set in motion by the great calamity of the First World War… Order had been left behind together with ‘peace’ in 1914”.6 The border between war and peace was much more porous in central and eastern Europe than it was in the west.7 In addition to the Russian civil war, other conflicts such as the Polish-Ukrainian war of 1918-19, the Hungarian-Romanian war of 1919, the Polish-Soviet war ╇ MacMillan (2003). ╇Kramer (2007), p.╯251. 4 ╇See the various essays in Stibbe (2009). 5 ╇Kramer (2007), pp.╯153–4; Stibbe (2010), p.╯43; Dallas (2000), pp.╯198–9. 6 ╇Bessel (1993), p.╯283. 7 ╇ Winter (2010), p.╯256. 2 3
introduction
3
of 1920-21 and the Greek-Turkish war of 1919-1922, threatened the stability of the entire region. The new borders were contested in many places, such as between Slovakia and Hungary, Hungary and Romania, Slovenia and Austrian Styria, Polish Silesia and Czech Silesia, Poland and Lithuania.8 Ethnic minorities, “an object of suspicion at home and of desire from their co-nationals abroad”, were barely protected under the new treaties; worst affected were the several million Germans and Hungarians living in post-war Czechoslovakia, Poland and Romania.9 In 1918/19 radical socialist revolution, followed by violent counterrevolution, came to the streets of Berlin, Munich and Budapest, while in Upper Silesia, a territory disputed between Germany and Poland, the League of Nations had to intervene and impose a partition in 1921 after a plebiscite failed to halt clashes between local armed groups.10 Further east, up to two million Russians were rendered homeless by the civil war, not to mention the hundreds of thousands of former German and Austrian POWs trapped by the fighting there.11 On top of this came a wave of violent anti-Semitic pogroms, particularly in parts of Polish Galicia including the former Habsburg city of Lwów (Lemberg). In the much truncated post-war state of Austria, meanwhile, successive governments prepared to expel tens of thousands of patriotic former Imperial Habsburg subjects, mainly refugees and migrants from the war-torn eastern provinces of the old empire, simply on the grounds that they were not ethnically German (or Christian) and therefore no longer had a right to residency. Many of the expellees were women.12 While the political and social history of the immediate post-war period is now fairly well documented, and while there has been increasingly differentiated interest in the role of particular groups of women during the war itself, for example munitions workers, Red Cross nurses and army auxiliaries,13 surprisingly little has been written to date about women’s movements and female activists during this time. This contrasts with the growing volume of literature on masculinities and aggression which continues to dominate discussions of the ╇ For an excellent overview see Gatrell (2010). ╇ MacMillan (2003), pp.╯486 and passim. 10 ╇ Ibid., pp.╯219–21; Gatrell (2010), p.╯564. 11 ╇ Hobsbawm (1994), p.╯51; Nachtigal (2009). 12 ╇ Hoffmann-Holter (1995). 13 ╇See for example Hagemann and Schüler-Springorum (2002); Gatrell (2003); Daniel (1997); Thom (1998); Ouditt (1994). 8 9
4
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
gendered dimension of the war and post-war experience.14 The following set of essays seeks to fill this important gap by investigating responses of women’s movements to the aftermath of the First World War from a comparative, transnational and interdisciplinary perspective. In so doing, it includes accounts of women’s activism in a number of nations usually considered peripheral to the European war story. Many of the nations discussed in this volume are indeed seriously under-researched – there are for example few English-language publications on Albanian female activism. The chapter by Fatmira Musaj and Beryl Nicholson shows clearly how supposedly non-combatant nations were drawn into the conflict, challenging the boundaries between what does and does not constitute war. Likewise, very little has been published on the role of Italian women’s organisations and activists, and what there is focuses on women’s part in protesting against the war during the social and political unrest of 1917 rather than their role on the “inner front”.15 Chapters on women’s organisations in Lithuania, Austria, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Bulgaria and Poland and on individual women working across national boundaries help to uncover the multiplicity of women’s post-war activism, and to place it within a broader historical and comparative context. As well as the geographical scope of the project, its interdisciplinary nature has allowed different methodologies and approaches to be brought to bear on these questions, with insights drawn from literary and cultural studies, sociology and social anthropology, gender and women’s studies, and feminist theory. Chronologically the main focus is on the years 1918 to 1923, with occasional reference to later events and trends. This fairly tight emphasis on the immediate post-war era is justified in view of the crucial importance of this period in shaping future developments: the years under consideration here constitute a distinctive period full of radical potential during which the renegotiation of gender relations took place under unstable and highly volatile 14 ╇See in particular the excellent collection of essays edited by Dudink, Hagemann and Tosh (2004). Also Bourke (1996 and 1999) and Meyer (2009). For recent works on war and gender which do give significant space to women’s movements and female activists see Higonnet et al. (1987); Coetzee and Shevin-Coetzee (1995); Melman (1998); Hagemann and Schüler-Springorum (2002); Braybon (2003); Gehmacher, Harvey and Kemlein (2004); Davy, Hagemann and Kätzel (2005); and Wingfield and Bucur (2006). One very useful volume which addresses itself to women in particular, albeit in the aftermath of the Second rather than First World War, is Duchen and Bandhauer-Schöffmann (2000). 15 ╇ An exception is Ortaggi (2003).
introduction
5
conditions of unprecedented social, economic and political strain. “Women’s movements” and “female activists”, on the other hand, are defined more broadly. Thus “women’s movements” could refer here to organisations formally constituted at international, national or regional level, or to much looser forms of association. Some movements were clearly ideological (pacifist, nationalist, socialist, liberal or centred around suffrage campaigns) whereas others had a less clearcut political agenda. Likewise “female activists” could be individuals driven by prior social commitment or religious belief, or by personal wartime and post-war experiences, or by both. Women’s activism during this period took a variety of forms, from continued war service in the Balkans and central and eastern Europe (Liddington, Kuźma-Markowska) to renegotiations of national identity in Lithuania and Hungary (Jurėnienė, Szapor, Acsády) and ongoing campaigns for the vote in Italy and France (Schiavon and Bard). In post-suffrage states, women worked to establish their political priorities: in Austria and Poland there was female-specific cross-party cooperation on particular issues (Hauch, Kuźma-Markowska) while in Germany the women’s overriding aim was to preserve internal peace and protect the nation from the consequences of political polarisation (Sharp). Some women’s campaigns drew on and reinforced gendered discourses which positioned women as victims rather than historical agents (Kuhlman), while others were able to use gendered expectations such as women’s affinity to charity work to achieve aims possibly unattainable to similarly motivated men (Stibbe, Berglund). Eleanor Franklin Egan’s personal witness to post-war suffering in Europe contributed to international reconciliation by personalising and individualising the fate of the defeated nations for an American readership, revealing the suffering humanity behind the myth of the brutal and barbaric “enemy” (Hudson). While a major aim of the volume is to give an account of the role played by organised women and female activists in the aftermath of war, our collection of essays also addresses the question identified by Joan Scott in her essay for the seminal volume Behind the Lines (1987), asking not simply what impact the war had on these individuals and groups and how they themselves influenced events, but what our knowledge and understanding of these women’s aims and strategies tell us about the politics of war and the transition to peace.16 “Cultural 16
╇Scott (1987) p.╯30.
6
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
demobilisation”, defined by John Horne as the dismantling of the mentalities and mindsets that support the war, was as necessary for a return to peacetime society as military demobilisation. In some nations, however, especially those whose war aims had not been realised, we instead find a tendency to “cultural remobilisation”, with the resentments and bitterness of the war kept alive rather than resolved.17 For some women’s groups in the post-war period, pressing for rights, especially the vote, entailed constant reference to and thus a revival of wartime activities and service that disrupted the return to peacetime values and often proved counter-productive (Schiavon). Nationalist women, too, especially in the defeated nations, had a vested interest in cultural remobilisation, fanning the flames of resentment and bitterness at the injustice of the settlement and using gender discourse to “rap the knuckles” of the faint-hearted men and shame them into renewed militancy (Streubel, Szapor, Acsády). Even where fighting had ceased, war mentalities continued into “peacetime”. Old hatreds and resentments did not evaporate and defeated nations’ suffering was viewed harshly and with suspicion by the victors (see Kuhlman, Hudson). Although we must be wary of exaggerating the sense of alienation, which is most likely to be represented in literary accounts of soldiers’ disillusionment, and of overstating the extent of separation between the experiences of soldiers and civilians,18 there is no doubt that most post-war societies suffered deep and disturbing divisions. Hatred and anger, at one time directed against external enemies, was now also all too often turned inward. Returning soldiers sometimes felt that a changed and disrupted postwar society did not live up to their dreams of peace and resented those who had not experienced frontline conditions, while women who had enjoyed independence and meaningful occupation during the war often found the return to the narrow confines of domesticity difficult and baulked at the priority given to men during the demobilisation process.19 ╇On both cultural demobilisation and remobilisation see Horne (2005). ╇See e.g. Liddle (1996); Watson (2004); and Ziemann (2003) and (2007). 19 ╇But see the comments by Elizabeth Domansky (1996) pp.╯458–9, who argues that, at least in the German context, the mass dismissal of women from their jobs to make way for returning veterans should be seen as beneficial to working-class women. For those with male providers, she writes, the reintegration of the better-paid men into the workforce made economic sense, especially when it was accompanied by the reunification of families separated by the war. 17 18
introduction
7
Women’s role in the process of cultural de- or remobilisation was therefore important, although for many it appeared to consist solely in reintegrating the men into civil society so that “the natural order of things would be restored”.20 The soldier was a liminal figure in the immediate post-war period; seen on the one hand as having suffered on behalf of the nation and on the other as having overstepped peacetime boundaries by what he had witnessed and above all by what he might have done. As a potentially disruptive group, returning soldiers had to be reintegrated as quickly and as completely as possible and given a stake in building the peace. This entailed a process of decontamination and resocialisation: all traces of the violence necessary in combat could be neutralised by a women’s altruistic love, while fatherhood and employment would do the rest. This model relied on a view of women as having been untouched by the war and having kept peacetime values intact throughout. It also depended on their willingness to step back into domesticity and maternity, to bear children and look after the men. In most of the post-war societies, we find an emphasis on marriage as a stabilising social force, and a privileging of heterosexual relationships that had the effect of marginalising those who remained single (Sharp, Bard). This was not unproblematic: women who had organised entire hospitals in the Balkans now returned home and were unable to find employment or purpose (Liddington) and for many, as Ann Rea shows, escapist middlebrow fiction provided the only “safe” way of challenging the conventions of middle-class marriage and breaking free from the drudgery of postwar domesticity. Wives and girlfriends of soldiers wounded on the battlefield were also expected to play a key role in the reconstruction of masculinity, largely through the spirit of self-sacrifice and altruism demanded of them in their relations with the disabled, shell-shocked or disfigured men.21 Whatever their personal feelings, women were exhorted to avoid showing pity or spoiling the men, in case this infantilised war veterans or undermined their masculinity.22 Women also played a crucial role in reintegrating former POWs, for instance – as Judit Acsády shows in the Hungarian case – by organising reception parties for returning prisoners and by helping to “re-educate” them in the cause ╇Nicolson (2009), p.╯3. ╇Kienitz (2008), p.╯248. 22 ╇ Ibid., pp.╯245–7 and 259–70. 20 21
8
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
of patriotism. Although the POWs’ situation was complicated by the more “passive” role they had been forced to play in captivity, and also by fears of their contamination by Bolshevik ideas,23 in Germany and Austria, the Swede Elsa Brändström urged women to recognise the manly and heroic in their suffering (Stibbe). For many women’s groups, their wartime service had been an important factor in supporting and legitimising their claims to greater equality in the life of the nation. Women had proved their patriotism and organisational skills: in some cases, as in Poland and Russia, they had even borne arms, and women of many nations had shown physical courage and endurance as nurses and ambulance drivers under frontline conditions. At home, munitions workers of many nations had worked to supply the army, often at the limits of their capacities, and had shared the fears and deprivations of the wartime economy. It was often women who organised and coordinated women’s labour, freeing men to serve at the front by their efforts. Many leading feminists were therefore puzzled, disappointed and ultimately angry that their service was largely discounted in a post-war discourse that concentrated on the needs of men. Or as Eric Hobsbawm puts it, those who had hoped that the war would lead to a better world were left Â�bitterly frustrated: “The past was beyond reach, the future postponed, the present bitter…”.24 In spite of these setbacks and disappointments, this volume takes the view that the contribution of the women’s movement and individual women activists to the shaping of post-war Europe during this period is highly significant and has been overlooked or unduly marginalised in previous historiography. Given the continuation of armed conflict in much of central, eastern and south-eastern Europe, as outlined above, the collection’s strong emphasis on this region raises new questions about the role of the women’s movement and of individual activists in rebuilding nations and communities or alternatively, in facilitating the rise of new forms of ethno-nationalism and racial intolerance. At the same time, cultural demobilisation as a concept enables us to move beyond more mainstream questions about the reception, impact and representation of women’s war work to look at new and equally important issues concerning the post-war era. Can we identify any similarities and differences between the reactions of the women’s 23 24
╇See e.g. Leidinger and Moritz (2003). ╇ Hobsbawm (1994), p.╯52.
introduction
9
movement in “victorious” nations such as France and the United Kingdom and in “defeated” nations such as Germany, Austria and Hungary? Were the women able to draw positively on their wartime record of service or resistance in order to negotiate a new role in postwar society? Did they feel – or were they expected to accept – responsibility for men’s wartime suffering? What role did the women’s movement play in international reconciliation and the rehabilitation of defeated nations? And how did they respond to some of the challenges of the post-war years, such as the redrawing of national boundaries and the mass displacement of populations? The commonalities and differences in the role of women’s groups and individual activists in cultural demobilisation and remobilisation under circumstances of defeat and victory, national trauma or continued conflict identified by the contributors to this volume serve to challenge any remaining assumptions about a uniform, definitively “womanly” response to war. In addition, we can identify four key themes which run through the essays: commemoration of the war; the renegotiation of gender roles in the war’s immediate aftermath; women’s suffrage and political rights; and women’s contribution to rebuilding shattered communities and creating new visions of peace in the years 1918 to 1923. We have also used these themes as a means of dividing the volume up into distinct sections, although in practice several of the essays could easily fit under more than one heading. Commemoration of war The meaning and significance of the First World War varies hugely between the combatant nations, and still more between combatant and non-combatant nations (Musaj/Nicholson). It is also subject to variation over time, with different social classes, ethnic groups and generations interpreting it in different ways. For Britain and France, this war currently holds an unparalleled place in the public imagination and plays a prominent role in popular culture. For some time, the British version of the war has largely been confined to the trenches of the western front, waged by stoical Tommies and heroic public school boys, most of whom die. Annual poppies and two-minute silences mourn the “lost generation”, the flower of British youth fallen in the mud of France and Belgium and the disillusionment, futility and infi-
10
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
nite sorrow of war.25 The English term “war memorial” encompasses commemoration both of the war as a major event in national, communal and private life, and of the war dead themselves, whereas in France the “monuments to the dead” were just that: monuments to male citizen-soldiers who had sacrificed their lives for the fatherland.26 In spite of these differences, in both countries a kind of “civic religion” was created out of the act of commemorating the war, whereby traditional “Judeo-Christian forms were recast in national terms” – as seen, for instance, in the ceremonial burial of an unknown soldier beneath the Arc de Triomphe in Paris and Westminster Abbey in London, both events taking place on 11 November 1920.27 In this way the nation (or in the case of Canadians, Jamaicans, Australians and New ZeaÂ� landers, the “Motherland”) became sacred, the ultimate “good” that men had been fighting and dying for.28 Unknown warriors were also buried in Washington DC, Rome and Brussels (1921), Prague, Belgrade, Warsaw and Athens (1922) and Sofia, Bucharest and Vienna (1923).29 In Germany, however, the bitterness that dealing with symbols of the war aroused was such that there could be no agreement on the construction of a state memorial to honour the unknown war dead until the architect Heinrich Tessenow was finally tasked by the Prussian government with redesigning Berlin’s eighteenth-century Neue Wache (new guardhouse) for these purposes in 1929.30 Even after Tessenow’s project was completed in 1931, as Laurence van Ypersele notes, the new monument “failed to become a focus of national ritual”.31 Volkstrauertag, the day of mourning for fallen soldiers established in 1925, on the second Sunday after Lent, was also marked by separate commemorations organised by rival veterans associations, in spite of regular appeals for conciliation between the warring parties.32 Meanwhile, at local and communal level images of “manly honour”, “youthful nationalism” and “Christian sacrifice” tended to dominate, although Käthe Kollwitz’s famous sculpture of the “grieving parents” (Die Eltern), ╇Gregory (1994); Winter (1995); Hynes (1990). ╇ Forrest (2009), pp.╯216–7. 27 ╇ Audoin-Rouzeau and Becker (2000), pp.╯186–7. 28 ╇ Winter (1995), p.╯27; Smith (2004). 29 ╇ Audoin-Rouzeau and Becker (2000), p.╯196; van Ypersele (2010), p.╯579. 30 ╇Berger (2004), p.╯118; Mosse (1990), pp.╯97–8. 31 ╇ van Ypersele (2010), p.╯581. 32 ╇Ulrich and Ziemann (1997), pp.╯138–9 and passim. 25 26
introduction
11
installed at the German war cemetery at Roggevelde in Flanders in 1932, carries a very different message.33 In Russia, the war now usually remembered is the “Great Patriotic War” of 1941-45 in which twenty million Soviet citizens lost their lives. In the period 1918-23, the achievements of the October Revolution eclipsed the previous conflict and no monuments were created to honour the fallen soldiers of 1914 to 1917. The First World War was depicted as an unjust “imperialist war” which had inevitably ended in the defeat of the old ruling class and the victory of communism: the only dead body that was commemorated in 1920s Moscow was that of Lenin, placed on permanent show in a special mausoleum in Red Square shortly after his death in January 1924.34 Elsewhere in Europe, commemoration of the war in the immediate aftermath of the November 1918 armistice was often small scale, local and organised by surviving (female) relatives.35 As Nikolai Vukov shows in his essay on Bulgaria, commemoration of a lost and unpopular war was often more difficult, especially in times of social instability and economic collapse, but the desire to remember family and friends who suffered and died in the fighting remained a strong human urge. In other countries, especially where national borders had been radically redrawn (Austria, Hungary, Romania) or where the state was new (Czechoslovakia, Yugoslavia) or reborn from the ashes of a defeated empire (Poland, Lithuania), the construction of a collective memory of war through public acts of commemoration was clearly vital to the establishment of new national identities, although the precise form of commemoration was often still contested.36 Commemoration of women’s wartime service was not a priority and even in victorious countries an anti-feminist backlash was palpable, with women often forced to bear a burden of guilt for the war deaths.37 In France, for instance, the search for the “enemy within”, or for defeatist elements which had supposedly held the glorious French army back, often led women to be “cast… among the villains of choice”, a point illustrated by the intense post-war interest in the Mata Hari story, the true life tale of an exotic dancer who ╇Berger (2004), p.╯118; Winter (1995), pp.╯108–14. ╇Nachtigal (2009), pp.╯177–8; Gatrell (2003), p.╯199; Audoin-Rouzeau and Becker (2000), p.╯196. 35 ╇ Winter (1995), esp.╯pp.╯15–53; van Ypersele (2010), p.╯580. 36 ╇ van Ypersele (2010), p.╯581. 37 ╇See Sharp (2007), pp.╯67–87. 33 34
12
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
was executed in Paris in October 1917 as an alleged German spy and double agent.38 As Olga Shnyrova shows, the Soviet state categorised all feminist activity before the Revolution as “bourgeois” and consequently completely suppressed the memory of these women’s contribution to the war effort. Meanwhile, the only woman whose war service was positively commemorated in official and popular representations of the war across the English- and French-speaking world was the British nurse Edith Cavell, executed by the Germans in October 1915 for helping stranded Allied servicemen to escape from occupied Belgium. According to Katie Pickles, the two hundred or so Allied soldiers Cavell helped to hide in occupied Belgium “paled in comparison with the number of men who enlisted to avenge her execution” after 1915.39 In this way, “chivalrous understandings of patriarchal warfare” were reinforced rather than challenged by the transnational commemoration of a female heroine who was herself only acceptable as a “life-giver”, “a symbol of civilization confronting barbarism” or a “martyr for humanity” – and certainly not as a partisan or as an independent, politically-engaged citizen-patriot fighting for her country or for the cause of freedom.40 In any case, whatever role they had played in the war, whatever the outcome, women were not accepted as central to the war story, which as we have seen focused on the sacrifice and heroism of the soldiers.41 What Mosse describes as the “myth of the war experience” was an exclusively male phenomenon, as were related constructs like that of the “lost generation” or the “cult of the fallen solider”.42 Or as another expert, Alan Forrest, puts it, the grieving and deeply traumatised nations of post-war Europe “saw no reason to commemorate the living when so many real heroes lay dead on the battlefield”.43
╇Darrow (2000), pp.╯269 and 284–94. ╇ Pickles (2007), p.╯203. 40 ╇ Ibid., p.╯202; Darrow (2000), p.╯278; Allen (2008), pp.╯9–10. Even Cavell’s oftquoted final words were used to emphasise her non-partisan and apolitical, “feminine” nature: “I know now that patriotism is not enough; I must have no hatred and no bitterness toward anyone”. 41 ╇ Cf. Darrow (2000), esp.╯pp.╯1–15. 42 ╇ Mosse (1990). 43 ╇ Forrest (2009), p.╯217. 38 39
introduction
13
The renegotiation of gender roles War has been aptly described as a “gendering activity”,44 in that, at the level of ideology at least, the roles of men and women are clearly defined and differentiated as soldier and mother respectively, where “men fight and women wait”.45 This division is undermined in a war seen by some historians as a “total war”, where success depended on the effective mobilisation of the civilian population, in which women were called on to enter the public sphere and take over roles previously reserved for men, even, as war progressed, within the military itself, and civilians and their property were drawn into the war zone and increasingly seen as legitimate military targets.46 While recruitment posters and press coverage stressed the compatibility of these new occupations and roles with traditional femininity and praised the women’s wartime contribution as nurses and in the munitions factories, there was a deep unease at the activities of women who appeared to be challenging gender norms, especially those who joined the military organisations. In most countries, including Poland (KuźmaMarkowska), women in uniform were viewed negatively, often being accused of sexual impropriety or of aping the men.47 However, the most extreme example of this is in Russia after the Revolution in 1917, when Maria Bochkareva, a woman already experienced in combat, formed some 2,000 women into a fighting unit called the Women’s Battalion of Death. The unit was sent to the front to shame the warweary men into continuing to fight, but in the hostile reaction to the unit twenty of the women were lynched by their own side.48 Competing ideas about the role and destiny of women arose within all post-war societies, but in most cases a return to maternalism, domesticity and clearly demarcated gender roles was seen as the key ╇ Higonnet (1987), p.╯4 ╇ Acton (2007) p.╯7 46 ╇Bock (2000), pp.╯240–1; Winter (2010), pp.╯254–6. 47 ╇ For similar trends in Britain and France see Grayzel (2003), pp.╯113–6. 48 ╇ Allen (2008), p.╯20. But it should be noted that the soldiers’ hostility in 1917 was not necessarily indicative of general social attitudes and that women as combatants did gain more acceptance subsequently. According to research by Olga Shnyrova, the battalions were extremely popular outside the army and several more were organised in Moscow, Perm, Odessa and Ekaterinograd, with up to 5,000 women fighting on both sides during the civil war. Afterwards, women were incorporated into the Red Army as non-combatants, some achieving high office as commissars in the army’s political departments. 44 45
14
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
to national regeneration and social stability.49 These priorities were reflected in demobilisation policies that privileged returning soldiers and ignored the claims of women. Often women were dismissed from their jobs and simply expected to return home, get married and have children, regardless of whether there was a home or husband available to them. Although some activists fought the dismissals, there were no mass protests in favour of women’s rights in the workplace. Yet even where opportunities for women’s employment and public engagement were not carried over into peacetime, as they mostly were not, the women’s experience of a measure of autonomy and influence outside the domestic sphere fuelled the demands of the more progressive women’s organisations for greater equality. Suffrage and legal reform, including constitutional equality in some nations, encouraged women’s campaigns in others. However, where suffrage had been granted, emancipation was far from complete, with chronic under-representation of women and their exclusion from international politics in most post-suffrage parliaments. Women’s specific concerns were also often diluted by their minority status within male-dominated parties. What of other gains? Some women’s organisations proved adept at adjusting their rhetoric to the times and used war-related arguments to campaign for longstanding goals. For instance, an improvement in the status of illegitimate children and single mothers was evident in some countries, greater access to contraceptive advice and a trend towards smaller families in others, while a concern with maternal and infant health may have contributed to a dramatic drop in infant mortality rates even in the defeated and disadvantaged nations. For a small minority of educated middle-class women, access to higher education and the professions became easier in the post-war context, while many women entered new categories of work beyond the factory or domestic service as clerks and shop assistants. In some of the more progressive nations, for example in Britain and Scandinavia, marriage reforms were introduced that supported a greater equality between man and wife, while the influence of sexology stressed women’s right to happiness and sexual fulfillment in marriage (Rea).50 Most post-war societies experienced anxiety about the fall in the birth rate in the aftermath of war, not surprising in the light of the high 49 ╇Grayzel (2010); Winter (2010); Frevert (1997); Beddoe (1989). For similar patterns in the realm of peacemaking at international level see also Sluga (2005). 50 ╇ Allen (2008), pp.╯81–2.
introduction
15
male casualties experienced by the combatant nations.51 This led to a perception that a women’s highest duty to her nation was reproduction and that the state had a right to intervene. Ann Taylor Allen writes that, in Europe, post-war “governments reconfigured even the most intimate areas of life, such as sexuality, reproduction and childbearing, as public concerns over which the state exercised control”.52 During the war, tighter regulation of women’s sexual behaviour had been seen as an issue important to soldier morale and habits of surveillance had been allowed to develop; especially where women were in receipt of state benefits, they were expected to conform to expectations of appropriate behaviour. Conservative, pronatalist and pro-family discourses were also very much on the political agenda, although, as Jay Winter correctly points out, “these ideological currents were not uncontested” by women themselves. Indeed, the decline in the birth rate is itself a strong indication of women’s increasing demand for “reproductive self-determination”, a demand which also occasionally expressed itself in political protests against restrictive government legislation.53 Although most democratic nations were content to promote a norm of female behaviour and encourage compliance by social disapproval alone, some states felt able to enforce their priorities more directly: in France, as Christine Bard outlines, a law of 1920 prohibited the distribution or promotion of contraceptives and completely outlawed abortion. Similar legislation can be found in other Catholic countries such as Ireland and Belgium while in liberal, protestant Scandinavia, eugenic concerns made it possible to prevent some individuals from marrying and reproducing at all.54 Abortion on demand was available only to women in Bolshevik Russia; elsewhere, it was either wholly illegal or accepted only under very strict medical conditions. Meanwhile, Italian women after 1922 suffered under the double burden of Fascist and Catholic restrictions on their reproductive rights and freedom of sexual expression,55 and in Romania, people of both sexes were exposed to increasing levels of (male) professional scrutiny as lawyers, doctors, biologists and anthropologists sought to ╇ Winter (2010), pp.╯259–60. ╇ Allen (2008), p.╯3. 53 ╇ Winter (2010), p.╯260. See also Usborne (1988) and Usborne (2007), pp.╯1 and ff. 54 ╇ Allen (2008), p.╯23. 55 ╇See De Grazia (1992), esp.╯pp.╯41–76; and Allen (2008), pp.╯51–4. 51 52
16
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
align older discourses of gender with “modern” understandings of eugenics and “laws of heredity”.56 While state interventions in the private sphere and the backlash against women’s wartime gains were frustrating, some commentators have nonetheless noted a positive effect in terms of greater political recognition of women’s “patriotic” self-sacrifice as mothers, workers or consumers, and a wider social acceptance of unmarried mothers and their offspring.57 Whether this added up to genuine emancipation as opposed to the creation of a common war culture based on nationalism combined with distinct and unequal gender roles is a contested point, however. Indeed, a number of recent studies have emphasised the conservative, authoritarian or anti-emancipatory impact of the war on women, including in the work-place as well as in the sphere of family, reproduction and everyday life (and in cultural representations thereof).58 Women’s suffrage and political rights One of the major changes claimed for the impact of war on women was women’s access to citizenship and political influence, most measurable in the granting of female suffrage in a number of nations soon after the end of the war. While many have interpreted this development as a reward for women’s wartime patriotism and service, this is hard to support, especially as there appeared to be no real correlation between how that service was viewed, the positive or negative responses it aroused, and the enfranchisement of women.59 In the victorious nations, French women’s legitimate expectation that their patriotism and good citizenship during the war years would be rewarded with political rights was disappointed. Despite a bill enfranchising women being passed by the lower chamber in May 1919, the Senate first sat on and then, in November 1922, rejected the bill. In fact, French women had to wait until 1944 before being able to vote and stand for election (Bard). In the UK a suffrage restricted by age ╇See Bucur (2002), esp.╯p.╯220. ╇ This in particular is the thesis of Marwick (1974) and (1988). On single or unÂ�marÂ�ried mothers see also Usborne (1988), esp.╯pp.╯394–5 and Roberts (1994), esp.╯pp.╯166–70, and on women as consumers see Davis (2000). 58 ╇See e.g. Domansky (1996); Daniel (1997); Darrow (2000); Grayzel (2003); McMillan (2003); and Ziemann (2003). 59 ╇ This can be seen in the sphere of private communications as much as in public discourses – see e.g. Ziemann (2003) and Liddle (1996). 56 57
introduction
17
was introduced that excluded most of the women who had actually served as nurses and munitions workers until 1928. In Belgium only bereaved mothers and war widows, as long as they did not remarry, were granted the vote in 1920, thus standing in as proxies for their deceased sons and husbands.60 Along with a number of other proposals on female suffrage, a similar model was also briefly considered by the Fascist regime in Italy for use in local elections, albeit with the cynical purpose of ridiculing those feminists and socialists who continued to campaign for votes for all, irrespective of war service or service to the nation.61 On the same war-related grounds some countries deliberately excluded prostitutes from the franchise (for instance in Austria in 1918 – see Hauch) or from pro-suffrage bills placed before national parliaments (as in the case of pre-Fascist Italy in 1919 – see Schiavon). In the meantime, defeated and unstable successor states to the Habsburg Empire and revolutionary governments in Russia and Germany did initially grant female suffrage in 1917 and 1918 and, of course, as the table shows, most of the Scandinavian states (three out of five) had already granted female suffrage before the outbreak of war, with a fourth following in 1915. Only Sweden had to catch up after the war. Table 1.62 The enfranchisement of women in selected European countries Countries enfranchising Countries enfranchising Countries enfranchising women after World War I women after World War II women before 1918 Finland (1906) Russia (1917) Bulgaria (1937/8, 1944, 1948) Iceland (1908, 1911) Austria (1918) France (1944) Norway (1913) Germany (1918) Albania (1945) Denmark (1915) Poland (1918) Italy (1945) Britain (1918, 1928) Portugal (1945) Hungary (1918-9) Yugoslavia (1945) Lithuania (1919) Romania (1946) Netherlands (1919) Switzerland (1971) Czechoslovakia (1919-20) Sweden (1919-21) Belgium (1920, 1948) Spain (1932) ╇Offen (2000), p.╯264; Sluga (2005), p.╯169. ╇ The much delayed law passed in 1925 was in effect nullified by Mussolini’s decision to end local elections for good in 1926. See De Grazia (1992), pp.╯36–8. 62 ╇ Although this table was originally adapted from one presented by Martin Pugh (1997) p.╯166, we have made some amendments and additions in line with information provided by our contributors. 60 61
18
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
Martin Pugh makes a convincing case that the war helped to promote the cause of women’s rights “not so much by changing attitudes towards women or their role, but, more indirectly, by undermining the political system which obstructed women”.63 Thus in Russia, no amount of war work had allowed women to gain political influence until the Tsarist regime was overthrown in March 1917 and the Provisional Government enfranchised men and women aged twenty and over.64 In Germany, where women’s war work had brought them right into the heart of government – some 1,000 women worked for the Ministry of War under the direction of Marie-Elisabeth Lüders – the Kaiser notably failed to mention women’s claims in his “Easter message” to the German people promising post-war liberal reform in 1917.65 The emphasis on suffrage as a measure of women’s political influence is in any case not especially reliable, not least because legislation was not always put into practice either fully or immediately and in central and eastern Europe especially the extent and significance of the right to vote was affected by rapid political power shifts: in Hungary for example the suffrage laws passed by the Karolyi government in November 1918 were never put into effect and the laws of 1919, although implemented in the elections of 1920, were in 1922 subject to restrictions that reduced the number of voters of both sexes. Equally, apart from in authoritarian regimes where women could be rewarded by mid-level office and informal channels of influence for compliance with and promotion of the government’s ideal of femininity (Szapor, Acsády), the trend was for a very low level of female political activism in all democracies and for women to vote along party rather than gender lines. Few women achieved positions above entry level politics and those who did so rarely identified themselves as feminists. One partial exception was Gertrud Bäumer, leader of the mainstream, bourgeois Federation of German Women’s Associations (BDF) and an elected deputy in the Reichstag for the German Democratic Party (DDP), who held a high-level position within the Reich Ministry of the Interior from 1920 to 1933.66 Yet even at the entry level of politics women could have an impact, for example in Lithuania, where, as Virginjia Jurėnienė makes clear, a fledgling women’s movement outlined a progressive programme for ╇ Pugh (1997), pp.╯166–7. ╇See also Gatrell (2003), pp.╯210–1. 65 ╇Evans (1976), pp.╯208 and 223; Hering (1990) p.╯128. 66 ╇Stachura (1993), pp.╯12–3. 63 64
introduction
19
gender equality in the new state that set the terms of the debate for decades to come. It was also possible for women to exercise influence on public life outside the political arena, and even without the franchise women’s organisations and activists did continue to campaign for women’s inclusion in the life of the state. This can be seen, for instance, in the case of Albania, where – as Fatmira Musaj and Beryl Nicholson show – members of the women’s movement fought to increase the rights of women within the family, education and society; and also in the case of Alice Masaryková in Czechoslovakia, who, as Bruce Berglund indicates, used her position as the president’s daughter and “de facto first lady” to demand a greater role for women in public health projects, Red Cross volunteer work and social welfare campaigns. In France, as Christine Bard argues, despite the lack of the vote and the bitterness this caused, organised women in political parties and feminist movements were still partially integrated into the life of the Republic through shared political values and patriotism. More generally, as the aims and priorities of the women’s organisations and activists themselves were not uniform even within a single nation, it is hard to measure whether the war brought them more gains than losses overall and, in any case, many developments were not unambiguously positive or negative. Enfranchisement of women and legislation that removed some of the barriers to equality did little to break down the religious and cultural assumptions about gender that were more often reinforced than challenged in the context of post-war uncertainty. Or as Gisela Bock puts it: “the main reason for the small number of female members of parliament was ... that they were still not accepted as representatives of the “people”, that is of the men as well. For them to gain such an acceptance would have required ... not just a narrowly defined political, but rather a cultural revolution”.67 Rebuilding communities/visions of peace The immediate years after the First World War represented the “apogee of nationalism” in Europe, to use a phrase coined by Eric HobsÂ� bawm.68 Nowhere was this more evident than in the lands which formerly constituted the Habsburg empire and which now – thanks to a mixture of Wilsonian idealism and Anglo-French Realpolitik – found 67 68
╇Bock (2000), pp.╯244–5. ╇ Hobsbawm (1992), pp.╯131–62. Cf. Sluga (2000).
20
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
themselves reconstituted as new nation-states, many of them with sizeable ethnic minorities to contend with. The losers in this process – Germany, Austria and Hungary – also faced challenges from within by political movements and parties which placed extreme radical nationalism (as opposed to national self-determination) on their banners. Women were by no means immune from the appeal of this new form of politics – as the contributions by Christiane Streubel, Judith Szapor and Judit Acsády make clear. The result was a loss of momentum in terms of the achievement of women’s rights at national level after 1918. Yet while many national women’s movements were forced to confront conservatism and reaction at home, they also at the same time were obliged to redefine what they understood by women’s rights and citizenship in light of new challenges emerging from the need to rebuild and reconstruct communities in the aftermath of war. This was the case, for instance, in old nations facing defeat and sometimes a radical redrawing of their borders (Vukov, Hauch, Szapor, Acsády); with new or resurrected nations seeking to define themselves in the post-war era (Berglund, Liddington, Musaj/Nicholson, Jurėnienė, Kuźma-Markowska); and with women activists who worked at the international or transnational level, seeking to communicate war experiences to audiences back at home (Hudson) or to extend their wartime activism into the post-war era (Stibbe, Liddington). One common theme which appears across all the countries examined here is the extent to which women were expected to take responsibility for healing the wounds of war, whether this was through their work in reintegrating returning POWs and civilian internees, in drawing attention to the plight of starving mothers and children in blockaded central Europe, in nursing the sick and disabled, in working together with men in pacifist or anti-war organisations, in devising new social welfare policies or overcoming political divisions, or in mourning the dead in appropriate ways at local and communal level. On the one hand, this could reinforce existing gender divisions of labour, with men as soldiers and warriors, and women as carers and nurturers, as Christine Bard notes. Yet on the other hand, it could provide opportunities for women to break away from traditional restrictions and make a significant and meaningful contribution to cultural demobilisation in the war’s aftermath. Interestingly, a number of radical feminists in our period, including Amy Lillingstone in Britain, Andrée Jouve in France and Helene Stöcker in Germany,
introduction
21
rejected the essentialist view that women were “naturally” more passive and anti-war than men. For them, female suffrage and women’s entry into national and international politics could not in themselves guarantee the maintenance of peace unless they were combined with broader cultural and educational changes affecting both sexes. First and foremost this meant action designed to demobilise and dismantle the hatreds that had built up between nations before and during the 1914/18 period. For some, it also meant a policy of active cooperation with male-dominated peace movements as opposed to maintaining the radical separatist stance advocated by some feminists which understood and fought war as an expression of male violence against women.69 However, while female anti-war campaigners often took on the difficult work of cultural demobilisation in national settings, both in cooperation with and separately from their male counterparts, there was little evidence of any shared, transnational vision of peace in the immediate post-war period. Thus some women’s movements, particularly in France and Belgium, but also further afield in Britain and America, demanded harsh punishment of Germany and Austria, including the women of those nations, as the precondition for any lasting peace. They condemned the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom (WILPF), founded in Zurich in 1919, for being too “pro-German” and some even went so far as supporting the exclusion of pacifist women from having any influence on the Paris Peace Conference on the grounds that they would be too soft or lenient towards the defeated enemy.70 At the opposite extreme, activists like Elsa Brändström and Helena Swanwick blamed the French for being too hard-line, and even said this publicly before international audiences in the early 1920s (Stibbe, Kuhlman). Here they came close to endorsing the position adopted by the mainstream German women’s leader Gertrud Bäumer, who insisted that German war crimes had been equally matched by French ones.71 Only the radical German peace campaigner Lilli Jannasch was brave enough to expose the German and international Rhineland campaigns for what they actually were – not a search for justice for German women, but a racist and
╇ Wilmers (2008), pp.╯132 and 239; Kuhlman (2007), p.╯237. ╇ Wilmers (2008), pp.╯181–96; Kuhlman (2007), pp.╯228–32. 71 ╇ Wilmers (2008), pp.╯200–1. 69 70
22
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
colonialist diversion from the continued problem of militarism throughout the world, and in Germany in particular.72 Overall, then, our studies suggest that nationalism tended to trump female liberation within women’s movements in the immediate postwar years. However, this does not mean that women activists simply identified with the policies of male nationalists and statesmen. Rather, our findings also tally with those of Glenda Sluga, namely that women’s movements and female activists often appropriated languages of (ethnic and racial) “difference”, “patriotic sacrifice” and “self-deterÂ� mination”73 in order to assert their own claims for greater equality and recognition within the framework of the nation-state or at the level of peacemaking and international politics. Indeed, this applied as much, if not more, in eastern and central Europe as in the west. Here too, as our contributors have shown, women were able to operate “on the fringes of the peace process”, and much more centrally, in the rebuilding of local identities and communities, in the aftermath of the war.74 Bibliography Acton, C. (2007) Grief in Wartime. Private Pain, Public Discourse (Basingstoke: 2007). Allen, A.T. (2008) Women in Twentieth-Century Europe (Basingstoke: 2008). Audoin-Rouzeau, S. and Becker, A. (2000) 1914-1918. Understanding the Great War, translated from the French by Catherine Temerson (London: 2000). Beddoe, D. (1989) Back to Home and Duty: Women in Inter-War Britain (London: 1989). Berger, S. (2004) Inventing the Nation: Germany (London: 2004). Bessel, R. (1993) Germany after the First World War (Oxford: 1993). Bock, G. (2000) Frauen in der europäischen Geschichte: Vom Mittelalter bis zur Gegenwart (Munich: 2000). Bourke, J. (1996) Dismembering the Male: Men’s Bodies, Britain and the Great War (London: 1996). ———╯ (1999) An Intimate History of Killing: Face-to-Face Killing in TwentiethCentury Warfare (London: 1999). Braybon, G. ed. (2003) Evidence, History and the Great War: Historians and the Impact of 1914-18 (Oxford: 2003). Bucur, M. (2002) Eugenics and Modernization in Interwar Romania (Pittsburgh: 2002). Coetzee, F. and Shevin-Coetzee, M. eds. (1995) Authority, Identity and the Social History of the Great War (Providence and Oxford: 1995). Dallas, G. (2000) 1918: War and Peace (London: 2000).
╇ Jannasch (1926), p.╯17. ╇Sluga (2005), pp.╯170–1. 74 ╇Sluga (2000), p.╯516. 72 73
introduction
23
Daniel, U. (1997) The War from Within: German Working-Class Women in the First World War, translated from the German by Margaret Ries (Oxford: 1997). Darrow, M. H. (2000) French Women and the First World War: War Stories of the Home Front (Oxford: 2000). Davis, B. J. (2000) Home Fires Burning: Food, Politics and Everyday Life in World War I Berlin (Chapel Hill and London: 2000). Davy, J. A., Hagemann, K. and Kätzel, U. eds. (2005) Frieden – Gewalt – Geschlecht. Friedens- und Konfliktforschung als Geschlechterforschung (Essen: 2005). De Grazia, V. (1992) How Fascism Ruled Women: Italy, 1922-1945 (Berkeley and Los Angeles: 1992). Domansky, E. “Militarization and Reproduction in World War I Germany”, in Society, Culture and State in Germany, 1870-1930, ed. Geoff Eley (Ann Arbor, MI: 1996) 427–63. Duchen, C. and Bandhauer-Schöffmann, I. eds. (2000) When the War was Over: Women, War and Peace in Europe, 1940-1956 (Leicester: 2000). Dudink, S., Hagemann, K. and Tosh, J. eds. (2004) Masculinities in Politics and War: Gendering Modern History (Manchester: 2004). Evans, R. J. (1976) The Feminist Movement in Germany, 1894-1933 (London: 1976). Forrest, A. (2009) The Legacy of the French Revolutionary Wars: The Nation-in-Arms in French Republican Memory (Cambridge: 2009). Gatrell, P. (2003) “The Epic and the Domestic: Women and War in Russia, 19141917”, in Evidence, History and the Great War: Historians and the Impact of 191418, ed. G.╯Braybon (Oxford: 2003) 198–215. ———╯(2010) “War After War: Conflicts, 1919-23”, in A Companion to World War I, ed. John Horne (Oxford: 2010) 558–75. Gehmacher, J., Harvey, E. and Kemlein, S. (2004) Zwischen Kriegen: Nationen, Nationalismen und Geschlechterverhältnisse in Mittel- und Osteuropa 1918-1939 (Osnabruck: 2004). Grayzel, S. R. (2002) Women and the First World War (Harlow: 2002). ———╯(2003) “Liberating Women? Examining Gender, Morality and Sexuality in First World War Britain and France”, in Evidence, History and the Great War: Historians and the Impact of 1914-18, ed. G.╯Braybon (Oxford: 2003) 113–34. ———╯ (2010) “Women and Men”, in A Companion to World War I, ed. John Horne (Oxford: 2010) 263–78. Gregory, A. (1994) The Silence of Memory: Armistice Day, 1919-1946 (Oxford: 1994). Hagemann, K. and Schüler-Springorum, S. eds. (2002) Home/Front: The Military, War and Gender in Twentieth-Century Germany (Oxford and New York: 2000). Hering, S. (1990) Die Kriegsgewinnlerinnen (Pfaffenweiler: 1990). Higonnet, M. R. et al. eds. (1987) Behind the Lines. Gender and the Two World Wars (New Haven and London: 1987). Hobsbawm, E. (1992) Nations and Nationalism since 1780: Programme, Myth, Reality, 2nd ed. (Cambridge: 1992). ———╯ (1994) Age of Extremes: The Short Twentieth Century, 1914-1991 (London: 1994). Hoffmann-Holter, B. (1995) ‘Abreisendmachung’: Jüdische Kriegsflüchtlinge in Wien 1914 bis 1923 (Vienna, 1995). Horne, J. (2005) “Kulturelle Demobilmachung 1919-1939: Ein sinnvoller historischer Begriff?”, in Politische Kulturgeschichte der Zwischenkriegszeit 1919-1939 ed. W.╯Hardtwig (Göttingen: 2005) 129–50. Hynes, S. (1990) A War Imagined: The First World War and English Culture (London: 1990).
24
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
Jannasch, L. (1926) German Militarism at Work: A Collection of Documents, translated from the German by John Pollock (London: 1926). Kienitz, S. (2008) Beschädigte Helden: Kriegsinvalidität und Körperbilder 1914-1923 (Paderborn: 2008). Kramer, A. (2007) Dynamic of Destruction: Culture and Mass Killing in the First World War (Oxford: 2007). Kuhlman E. (2007) “The ‘Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom’ and Reconciliation after the Great War”, in The Women’s Movement in Wartime. International Perspectives, 1914-19, eds. A.╯S.╯Fell and I.╯Sharp (Basingstoke: 2007) 227–43. Leidinger, H. and Moritz, V. (2003) Gefangenschaft, Revolution, Heimkehr: Die Bedeutung der Kriegsgefangenenproblematik für die Geschichte des Kommunismus in Mittel- und Osteuropa 1917-1920 (Vienna: 2003). Liddle, P. (1996) “British Loyalties: The Evidence of an Archive”, in Facing Armageddon: The First World War Experienced, eds. H.╯Cecil and P.╯Liddle (London: 1996) 523–38. MacMillan, M. (2003) Paris 1919. Sixth Months that Changed the World (New York: 2003). Marwick, A. (1974) War and Social Change in the Twentieth Century: A Comparative Study of Britain, France, Germany, Russia and the United States (London: 1974). ———╯ (1988) “Introduction”, in Total War and Social Change, ed. A.╯Marwick (BasingÂ�stoke: 1988) x-xxi. McMillan, J. (2003) “The Great War and Gender Relations: the Case of French Women and the First World War Revisited”, in Evidence, History and the Great War: Historians and the Impact of 1914-18, ed. G.╯Braybon (Oxford: 2003) 135–53. Melman, B. ed. (1998) Borderlines: Genders and Identities in War and Peace, 18701930 (London: 1998). Meyer, J. (2009) Men of War: Masculinity and the First World War in Britain (Basingstoke: 2009). Mosse, G. L. (1990) Fallen Soldiers: Reshaping the Memory of the World Wars (Oxford: 1990). Nachtigal, R. (2009) “The Repatriation and Reception of Returning Prisoners of War, 1918-1922”, in Captivity, Forced Labour and Forced Migration in Europe During the First World War, ed. M.╯Stibbe (London: 2009) 157–84. Nicolson, J. (2009) The Great Silence, 1918-1920: Living in the Shadow of the Great War (London: 2009). Offen, K. (2000) European Feminisms, 1700-1950: A Political History (Stanford, California: 2000). Ortaggi, S. (2003) “Italian Women during the Great War”, in Evidence, History and the Great War: Historians and the Impact of 1914-18, ed. G.╯Braybon (Oxford: 2003) 216–38. Ouditt, S. (1994) Fighting Forces, Writing Women: Identity and Ideology in the First World War (London: 1994). Pickles, K. (2007) Transnational Outrage: The Death and Commemoration of Edith Cavell (Basingstoke: 2007). Pugh, M. (1997) “The Rise of European Feminism”, in A Companion to Modern European History, 1871-1945, ed. M.╯Pugh (Oxford: 1997) 155–73. Roberts, M. L. (1994) Civilization without Sexes: Reconstructing Gender in Postwar France, 1917-1927 (Chicago and London: 1994). Scott, J. W. (1987) “Rewriting History”, in Behind the Lines: Gender and the Two World Wars, ed. M. R.╯Higonnet et al (New Haven and London: 1987) 19–30.
introduction
25
Sharp, I. (2007) “Blaming the Women: Women’s ‘Responsibility’ for the First World War”, in The Women’s Movement in Wartime. International Perspectives, 1914-19, eds. A.╯S.╯Fell and I.╯Sharp (Basingstoke: 2007) 67–87. Sluga, G. (2000) “Female and National Self-Determination: A Gender Re-Reading of the ‘Apogee of Nationalism’”, Nations and Nationalism, 6/4 (2000), 495–521. ———╯(2005) “National Sovereignty and Female Equality. Gender, Peacemaking, and the New World Orders of 1919 and 1945”, in Frieden – Gewalt – Geschlecht. FrieÂ� dens- und Konfliktforschung als Geschlechterforschung, eds. J.╯Davy, K.╯Hagemann and U.╯Kätzel (Essen: 2005) 166–83. Smith, R. (2004) Jamaican Volunteers in the First World War: Race, Masculinity and the Development of National Consciousness (Manchester: 2004). Stachura, P. D. (1993) Political Leaders in Weimar Germany: A Biographical Study (London: 1993). Stibbe, M. ed. (2009) Captivity, Forced Labour and Forced Migration during the First World War (London: 2009). ———╯(2010) Germany, 1914-1933: Politics, Society and Culture (Harlow: 2010). Thom, D. (1998) Nice Girls and Rude Girls. Women Workers in World War I (London: 1998). Ulrich, B. and Ziemann, B. eds. (1997) Krieg im Frieden: Die umkämpfte Erinnerung an den Ersten Weltkrieg (Frankfurt/M: 1997). Usborne, C. (1988) “‘Pregnancy is the Woman’s Active Service’: Pronatalism in Germany during the First World War”, in The Upheaval of War. Family, Work and Welfare in Europe, 1914-1918 eds. Richard Wall and Jay Winter (Cambridge: 1988) 389–416. ———╯(2007) Cultures of Abortion in Weimar Germany (Oxford: 2007). van Ypersele, L. (2010) “Mourning and Memory, 1919-45”, in A Companion to World War I, ed. John Horne (Oxford: 2010) 576–90. Watson, J. (2004) Fighting Different Wars: Experience, Memory, and the First World War in Britain (Cambridge: 2004). Wilmers, A. (2008) Pazifismus in der internationalen Frauenbewegung (1914-1920): Handlungsspielräume, politische Konzeptionen und gesellschaftliche Auseinandersetzungen (Essen: 2008). Wingfield, N. M. and Bucur, M. eds. (2006) Gender and War in Twentieth-Century Eastern Europe (Bloomington and Indianapolis: 2006). Winter, J. (1995) Sites of Memory, Sites of Mourning: The Great War in European Cultural History (Cambridge: 1995). ———╯ (2010) “Demography”, in A Companion to World War I, ed. John Horne (Oxford: 2010) 248–62. Ziemann, B. (2003) “Geschlechterbeziehungen in deutschen Feldpostbriefen des Ersten Weltkrieges”, in Briefkulturen und ihr Geschlecht: Zur Geschichte der privaten Korrespondenz vom 16. Jahrhundert bis heute eds. Christine Hämmerle and Edith Saurer (Vienna, Cologne and Weimar: 2003) 261–82. ———╯ (2007) War Experiences in Rural Germany, 1914-1923, translated from the German by Alex Skinner (Oxford: 2007).
26
ingrid sharp and matthew stibbe
The aftermaths of defeat
part one
commemoration, remembering, remobilisation
27
28
nikolai vukov
The aftermaths of defeat
29
The aftermaths of defeat: the fallen, the catastrophe, and the public response of women to the end of the First World War in Bulgaria Nikolai Vukov The end of the First World War represented a second national catastrophe for Bulgaria, larger in scope than the one following the Balkan wars of 1912-13, and marked the beginning of the most difficult period in the development of the state since its liberation from Ottoman rule in 1878. Defeat in the war coincided with a soldierly uprising in 1918, in which troops marched from the front to the capital to protest against the government and the King. The uprising was crushed by force and thousands of soldiers died or were wounded by mobilised police units. By 29 September 1918, when an armistice was signed with the western Allies, Bulgaria faced demographic and economic collapse. In the context of defeat, international isolation and economic depression, the country had to solve a multitude of internal issues, putting a huge strain on the fragile democratic system. A successful military coup in June 1923 against the popular left-leaning government of peasant leader Alexander Stambolijski was followed by a failed communist uprising in September, leading to a violent clampdown on all forms of oppositional political activity. All of this conditioned the diverse roles played by Bulgarian women in the war’s aftermath – as observers and participants in demonstrations, as agents of post-war reconstruction, and as the grieving widows and mothers of dead soldiers.
One of the distinctive features of the First World War’s aftermath for the defeated nations in Europe was that instead of peace, relief and reconstruction, the war’s end brought continued misery, ongoing food shortages and repeated outbreaks of political violence, which only began to subside in the mid-1920s. After the armistice and especially after the Treaty of Neuilly in November 1919, Bulgaria found itself facing a familiar array of problems: economic breakdown, international isolation, domestic unrest, a communist uprising and government-backed violence against the left. The continued absence of men, due to deaths and injuries on the battlefield, and the Allied retention of POWs, made a return to pre-war norms impossible, and left Bulgarian women in the position of having to undertake many of the
30
nikolai vukov
tasks of post-war reconstruction and cultural demobilisation on their own. Having increased their role in national life during the war, they now became actively involved in caring for front-line returnees, maintaining contacts with international organisations to overcome the country’s isolation, participating in various political campaigns, and, not least, fighting for their rights in a less than conducive atmosphere. Although in part representing a continuation of their pre-war struggles and experience, the activities carried out by organised Bulgarian women and their associations in the post-war years testified to a new kind of female activism – one which bore the signs of greater independence from male control and affirmed new aspects of women’s mission. This essay seeks to examine the role of female activists and organised women’s movements in Bulgarian public life after the war, focusing in particular on the immediate post-war years. It begins by providing some historical background on the development of the women’s movement in Bulgaria before 1915, and then goes on to explore its responses to the war and the national turmoil which followed in the wake of defeat. Focusing on the intensification of the activities of the women’s movement at this time, the paper will then shed light on three important aspects related to women’s participation in public life: the commemoration of the war dead, the care of the wounded returnees from the front, and the involvement of women in protest movements of various kinds. Without making claims to a comprehensive treatment, the article will also touch upon the contribution of organised women to the process of post-war stabilisation and cultural demobilisation – a topic which has remained largely overlooked in Bulgarian historiography of the inter-war period. Female activists and organised women in the pre-war period From the mid-nineteenth century onwards, the role of women in Bulgarian society was closely related to the process of Europeanisation and the introduction of new patterns in clothing, lifestyles and social manners.1 Modernity was largely perceived in terms of overcoming tradition in everyday life, so that women were important subjects in the debates about the modernisation and nationalisation of Bulgarian 1
╇See Paskaleva (1983); and Cholakova (1995).
The aftermaths of defeat
31
culture in general. Women’s education, for example, received much official attention, although the arguments used in support of this often revolved around the advantages to be gained from women becoming better mothers, housewives, and educators of their children.2 In fact, partly due to such priorities, the only occupational field open for an educated Bulgarian woman until the late 1870s was the teaching profession. After the establishment of the Bulgarian state in 1878, the debate about women’s role in national life moved on to consider issues of citizenship.╯Although the first Bulgarian constitution of 1879 gave voting rights to “all citizens”, in practice it was understood that only men were envisioned in this category and women were therefore systematically excluded from political life.3 Access to the middle-class job market and in particular to more prestigious professions like medicine and law was also largely restricted to men – not least due the narrow openings for women’s professional education and training. Education was indeed an especially important issue for the organised women’s movement in Bulgaria before 1912. Mandatory primary education was introduced for all Bulgarian citizens by the constitution, and a great number of girls’ schools were opened in the country, but in general different policies were pursued for men and women. The prevailing attitude was that girls should attend school for a shorter period, and that the curriculum should focus mainly on cooking, sewing and clothes-making in order to prepare them for their future roles as housewives and mothers. Although towards the turn of the century girls and boys in secondary schools had the same number of classes and the school curriculum for both was similar, the overall emphasis on gender-specific educational activities for girls remained. In the meantime, the demand for more teacher training places for women became a key point in the debates surrounding the law of 1904. The issue of university education was even more controversial. Although in theory Bulgarian women gained access to higher education in 1901 (thirteen years after the first university courses were opened), their status was at first restricted to one of “auditors” and their numbers were tiny compared to men. Moreover, women’s right to attend university was of a “temporary” nature only; it was rescinded completely during the “university crisis” in 1907.
2 3
╇See Daskalova (2001). ╇See Daskalova (2001); and Gavrilova (2001).
32
nikolai vukov
The small minority of women who did succeed in getting a good education also faced barriers in terms of securing a career. Although in 1905 the National Assembly approved a law that aimed to limit discrimination in relation to pay and conditions, the entry of Bulgarian women into traditionally male professions, such as law and medicine, was slow and difficult. The number of educated women increased after 1878, but, with the exception of teaching, the number entering professional jobs was minuscule. For instance, women were banned from practising law until the communist period after 1944. Meanwhile, rural women faced even greater obstacles to professional advancement than their urban counterparts, especially as the villages and agricultural regions were much slower to “modernise”. Here the more limited opportunities for self-realisation outside the family milieu were reinforced by a lack of equal rights to inheritance – a situation very similar to that in other European countries at this time. Compared to education, the question of political rights was of secondary importance to the organised Bulgarian women’s movement at the turn of the century, but even so there was some activity on this front too. With the foundation of the Sofia Educational Association in 1897 and then of the Bulgarian Women’s Union (Bulgarski zhenski sayuz) in 1901 – an umbrella organisation representing all of the women’s associations across the country – the campaign for political representation gained fresh momentum. Although female suffrage was not promoted as a central point in the Union’s programme (due to political considerations and the strong emphasis which many of the traditional associations placed on charity and education),4 it increasingly cropped up in discussions and became the cause of a number of splits and divisions between “moderates” and “radicals”. In addition, the socialist women’s association wanted to align the Union with the “class struggle” and made a strong bid to impose this policy at the 1903 Congress.5 When their efforts failed, they left the Union, to form in 1914 the Socialist Women’s Union, which argued that 4 ╇On the early programme and ideas of the Women’s Union see Daskalova (1998) and Daskalova (1999). 5 ╇ This move was part of the ideological struggle within the Social Democratic party in the early years of the twentieth century. Established in 1891, the Bulgarian Socialist Democratic Party joined in 1894 with the Bulgarian Social Democratic Union to form the Bulgarian Workers’ Social Democratic Party (BRSDP), which, after serious internal disputes, split in 1903 into two wings: “narrow” and “broad” socialists. In 1919 the “narrow socialists” embraced Leninism and renamed themselves the Bulgarian Communist Party (Balgarska Komunisticheska Partiya or BCP).
The aftermaths of defeat
33
working-class women would obtain political equality only by joining forces with men in the struggle for proletarian liberation against the exploiting capitalist class. After the departure of the socialists, the Women’s Union put itself forward as an organisation which stood “above party” and “above class”. Despite ongoing internal divisions – most of which were due to clashes of personality – the Union followed a policy of demanding complete civil and political equality for women. In 1906 it became a member of the International Council of Women (ICW) and the International Women’s Suffrage Alliance (IWSA). Around the same time a new body, the Union of Progressive Women (Sayuz na naprednichavite zheni), was founded. Soon renaming itself “Ravnopravie” (Equal Rights), it was particularly active in its demands for a change in the suffrage laws. In its view, educational and charity issues were marginal; the important thing was to build up a broader public campaign for women’s votes through the press, public assemblies, court petitions and so on. Meanwhile, the Women’s Union also embraced the goal of political equality, but it was much more moderate in its aims and followed a policy of gradualism. Although the issue of women’s voting rights enjoyed some support from representatives of the different political parties (Social Democrats, Democrats, and so on), it failed to gain wider backing or social acceptance, and instead remained the specialist concern of women’s organisations. With the approach of the Balkan wars (1912-13) and the First World War (1915-18) it was pushed aside by more pressing questions. The onset of war The second Balkan War of June to July 1913 led the country to its first national catastrophe, expressed in enormous economic, territorial, and military losses, waves of refugees from territories occupied by neighbouring states, huge social disruption and the failure of the national goal of unifying territories with a Bulgarian population into one state. The defeat and the humiliating Treaty of Bucharest (August 1913) placed Bulgaria in an especially difficult position in terms of its foreign relations, and largely determined its problematic decision to enter the First World War on the side of the Central Powers in October 1915. The different women’s organisations were actively involved in the attempts to find a way out of the country’s disastrous external situ-
34
nikolai vukov
ation after 1913. For instance, women activists who were graduates of Russian schools travelled to Russia and used their personal connections to improve the relations between the two states. They also served as nurses and volunteer auxiliaries at military schools and hospitals. The two main periodicals of the women’s movement, “Women’s Voice” and “Ravnopravie” regularly commented on the role of BulgarÂ� ian women in post-war reconstruction, on their participation as nurses during the 1913 war, on the post-war economic difficulties and on the need to punish those responsible for the catastrophe. The issue of equal rights in education and the professions was also raised, but it was largely overshadowed by the tense political and social atmosphere in Bulgaria on the eve of the country’s entry into the First World War. A striking example of the new roles that women’s organisations (and especially those on the left) were undertaking at this time was the staging of a special “day of women” in March 1915, following the example set by the first women’s conference organised by the socialist Second International in Copenhagen in 1910. Celebrated initially as a day of women workers and international solidarity, the event became a means of mobilising women in their struggle for equal rights in all spheres of life. In Bulgaria, the day was marked for the first time in 1911 by a small group of socialists, and its first mass public celebration was in 1915. In this way, Bulgarian women were able to demonstrate their solidarity with pacifist and anti-war protesters in other European countries. Their claims to an equal role in the building of the nationstate also took on new meanings in the context of campaigns for the preservation of peace. This found expression both in widespread support for the policy of Bulgarian neutrality before October 1915, and in the anti-war protests staged by women during the period of belligerency after October 1915. The short period between the Balkan wars and the First World War was likewise marked by a sharp rise in the activities of women Social Democrats,6 who organised mass anti-war demonstrations which
6 ╇ Here and further on in the text the terms “Social Democrat” and “socialist” will be used interchangeably with reference to Bulgarian women’s activism. The first term refers to the party itself (Bulgarian Workers’ Social Democratic Party), while the second term relates to its ideological profile as “socialist” (claimed by both the “narrow” and “broad” wings), as well as to the name of the Socialist Women’s Union, founded in 1914.
The aftermaths of defeat
35
were also an affirmation of women’s social and political rights.7 Beginning in June 1914 in Sofia, when the first women’s Social DemoÂ� cratic conference was held, with more than 200 delegates taking part, the mobilisation of working-class women systematically increased as war drew closer. Taking particular impetus from the international conference of socialist women at Berne in March 1915,8 they organised meetings and protests against the war in an effort to mobilise the working classes for peace and political rights for women. On 7 June 1915, for example, the Social Democratic women’s group in Plovdiv staged a mass public event, where 800 people (half of them women) voted in favour of a resolution for peace and brotherhood between nations and against the political agitation for “a new war by the Bulgarian bourgeoisie”. As was asserted at the meeting, this was “an appeal against chauvinism and patriotism, for bread and freedom, for class struggle and socialism”. The resolution was sent to the Prime Minister and was published in Rabotnicheski vestnik, the organ of the Bulgarian Social Democratic Party (narrow socialists). Women also participated in the 1 May events in 1915 on a large scale. The Social Democratic Party announced a “Demonstration for Peace”, which was attended by 30,000 workers, many of whom were women. Very often the anti-war message, as well as the demand for women’s rights, was combined with overt propaganda for socialist ideas, making the social protests and the struggle for female emancipation inseparable from the Social Democratic Party’s political agenda.9 And, in this respect, the role of women in political agitation, for instance through carrying messages, distributing bulletins and explaining the party policy, was crucial. The various political and anti-war activities carried out by socialist women were intended to demonstrate the clear difference between them and representatives of the other women’s associations. One of ╇See for example the series of lectures on this topic by Rayna Kandeva and other socialist women activists: “About the European War and Women” – Rabotnicheski vestnik 109, 20 August 1915. 8 ╇ The latter was embraced by women activists at the expense of the other international event, the International Congress of Women at The Hague in April-May 1915, which was perceived largely as an expression of bourgeois women’s activism and despite its broad address to women around the world did not enjoy the support of women socialists in Bulgaria. 9 ╇On the merging of the pacifist and women’s rights claims with the political ones, see for example the municipal elections in the capital on 3 May 1915 as reflected in Rabotnicheski vestnik 14, 26 April 1915; and Rabotnicheski vestnik 17, 30 April 1915. 7
36
nikolai vukov
the most striking demonstrations of this was the series of actions that the Socialist Women’s Union held against the “Day of the Roses”. This holiday was set up for charity purposes by “bourgeois women” with the support of the official authorities and was scheduled for 29 June 1915. The idea was that on this day members of the associations which made up the Women’s Union would sell artificial roses with an appeal to citizens to support the battle against tuberculosis. Socialist women declared themselves against the holiday and on the day before it was due to take place, they organised public protest meetings and carried out wide reaching propaganda to prevent the event. The day was denounced as a “swindle” and as an “annual carnival” of the bourgeoisie, whose purpose was to conceal the link between tuberculosis and poverty among the working-class population.10 In the end, the activities carried out by socialist women prevented the holding of the holiday and it was postponed until a later date.11 At the opposite extreme to anti-war agitation, the First World War also saw some rare but nonetheless significant examples of women volunteering for active combat roles. One of them was Donka Ushlinova (1880-1937), a former participant in the armed movement for the liberation of Macedonia and Edirne Thrace, who fought together with her husband in the Balkan wars, and joined the infantry division in Macedonia during the First World War, where she was awarded the rank of an officer for her heroism. This case was not an isolated one, although in general, the participation of women at the war fronts was restricted to nurses and sanitary workers. Supported in their efforts by the activities of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC), which provided supplies of hospital materials, instruments and medical facilities, these “soldiers of mercy” were a regular presence on the battlefield, caring for the wounded, assisting with the evacuation of casualties, and fighting epidemics. Regretfully, the role of the Bulgarian women’s medical service during First World War (and in the Balkan wars too) still remains a blank page in Bulgarian historiography. However, in contrast to previous conflicts, such as the RussoTurkish war of 1877-8 and the first Balkan war of 1912, women’s participation and input into the First World War was associated not so much with their Red Cross activities, but with the hunger demonstra╇Bradinska (1969), p.╯266. ╇See Rabotnicheski vestnik 63, 25 June 1915; and Rabotnicheski vestnik 59, 20 June 1915. 10 11
The aftermaths of defeat
37
tions and riots staged by the mothers, wives, and daughters of soldiers in protest against the unending shortages and deprivation. The first such riots occurred soon after Bulgaria’s entry into the war and were a reflection of the political and economic crisis in the country, finding expression in social turmoil, rising prices and black market speculation. The most violent protests occurred in villages, where the requisitioning of agricultural foodstuffs and the mobilisation of people and livestock led to widespread hunger. In their demands for peace and the end of food requisitioning, women frequently demonstrated with red flags and black handkerchiefs, and were often joined by old men and children. The first big urban riots took place on 9 March 1916, after a refusal of the municipality in Burgas to pay allowances for soldiers’ families. In the following year, mass demonstrations were carried out in Dupnitsa and the surrounding villages. In 1918, when the government announced a lowering of the bread ration, protests and riots spread to major towns across the country and led to the plundering of warehouses holding requisitioned foodstuffs. Although no particular organisation was behind them, in some towns the riots continued for several days and were put down by use of army units, leading to the arrest and murder of many female participants. In 1916 Gana Avdjieva from Burgas was tried and sentenced as an initiator of the riots, becoming the first female political prisoner in Bulgaria. The women’s riots had enormous impact on the soldiers’ morale on the front line, encouraging a breakdown of discipline and, ultimately, a refusal to fight any more. The sheer length of the war, the lack of adequate supplies for the front and the arrival of news about the poor conditions of families back at home, triggered waves of anti-military propaganda among the soldiers, which increased especially after the October Revolution in Russia and the Fourteen Points issued by the American President Woodrow Wilson in January 1918. The mass flight of troops from the front line after the unsuccessful battle of Dobro pole on 15 September 1918, and the retreating soldiers’ march on Sofia, where they protested against the government and the King, thus came as no surprise to the anti-war movement in view of the population’s mounting discontent. By the time the government agreed to an armistice on 29 September, some 101,000 soldiers had lost their lives, around 153,000 were wounded, and 27,000 were missing. A further 50,000 had fallen victim to epidemics, and 112,000 soldiers were about to become prisoners of war under the Salonika agreement. The Bulgarian army was forced to surrender substantial territories along
38
nikolai vukov
all the boundaries of the pre-1915 state and the goal of national unification of all Bulgarians, which had been one of the major motives for participating in the war, now clearly had to be abandoned. The harsh realities were further sharpened with the signing of the Treaty of Neuilly on 27 November 1919, under which the country had to pay enormous reparations, limit its army to 20,000 men only, and accept the forcible resettlement of hundreds of thousands of its co-nationals from territories now incorporated into neighbouring countries. Isolated internationally, the defeated and truncated state of Bulgaria also faced economic depression, social dislocation and political crisis at home. Female activists and organised women in the war’s aftermath The difficult times that Bulgarian society encountered in the aftermath of the war shaped the roles that women took and in particular had an impact on the work of women’s organisations and individual women activists. In contrast to the pre-war period, the battle for educational, professional and voting rights was put on the backburner for several years and instead efforts towards overcoming the difficult social and economic situation took priority.12 Having become the main pillars of the family during the war years, women were expected to play a major role in post-war reconstruction and in rebuilding those parts of BulÂ� garÂ�ian industry, agriculture, and social welfare which had been destroyÂ�ed in the fighting.13 Although with the gradual return of men from the front, most of the women who had been mobilised as waged workers in factories and war-related industries returned to “normal” domestic activities, many now saw themselves not only as wives and mothers, but as equal participants in civil society. The first and most visible aspect of women’s activism in the immediate post-war years concerned their support for the war wounded and care of soldiers’ graves. In the medical profession, of course, women’s 12 ╇ The Bulgarian suffragist organisation “Ravnopravie,” for example, maintained its existence throughout the entire period of the wars, but it rose to prominence again only in early 1920s. 13 ╇ In fact, from the beginning of the twentieth century women were already an important part of the industrial workforce, and their number rose continuously in the first half of the century, from 22% in 1909 to 36% in 1944. See Todorova (2004), p.╯117.
The aftermaths of defeat
39
role as nurses remained strictly subordinate to that of men as Â�doctors. Here they had little autonomy. However, in the field of commeÂ� morative actions and the cultivation of the memory of the dead, they enjoyed more freedom to shape developments in accordance with traditional customs and practice. After the war the soldiers’ graves remained largely outside the new state boundaries (mainly in Serbia, Macedonia, Greece and Romania). This led to a number of peculiarities, especially given the absence of public ceremonies celebrating the war’s end, and the impossibility of private visits to former battlefield sites. As the state was not permitted to take care of the war graves that were outside its territories, or to build official war memorials until the mid-1920s, most of the monuments were erected by local communities. Meanwhile, individual or “private” forms of commemoration were made more difficult by the lack of bodily remains. In fact, this kind of commemoration was typically left to women, who – in line with custom and tradition – used to bury clothes to mark the death of their sons, fathers, brothers and husbands. With the end of the war, public memorials dedicated to the dead of local and regional communities started to appear across the country – as both sites of remembrance for the fallen soldiers of consecutive wars, and as symbols of the sacrifice which local communities had been called upon to make in the name of the Bulgarian nation. Although often supported by local institutions, such as schools, churches and municipalities, most of these monuments were built with private donations collected by the communities themselves, and in this respect, the involvement of women was crucial. Against the background of enormous economic hardship, they would collect donations, make their own tear-ridden contributions, and maintain the sites identified for such public commemoration. Later, with the coming of state-sponsored memorial projects in larger towns such as Sofia, Plovdiv, and Stara Zagora in the mid-1920s, regional branches of women’s organisations participated in collecting donations for monuments to the war dead. Despite their principled position against the absurdity of the war and their tense relationship with male-dominated military institutions, such as the Ministry of War and the various officers’ associations, such branches were successful in making the commemoration of the dead a key component in the reestablishment of civic responsibility and social unity in the wake of the national disaster.
40
nikolai vukov
In the first years after the war’s end, however, commemoration of the dead did not just mean building memorials, but also taking part in rituals of mourning and remembrance at the family and communal levels.14 In the realm of the family, the memory of the war dead was celebrated according to the traditional calendar, with special days marked out for particular commemorative rites. Aside from the burial rites, which (as noted), customarily included the burying of the dead person’s clothes in the absence of a body, there was also an established system of commemorative acts observed for every member of the community. Among them, the all souls’ days (four in number, accordÂ� ing to the traditional Bulgarian calendar) were used as occasions to honour the immortality of the soul and the undying memory that the living had about their loved ones, in accordance with Christian teaching.15 Graves without bodies in the local cemeteries served to reattach the dead to their communities of origin and to involve them in the cycle of commemorative acts that would enable the appeasement of their souls and the sustenance of their memory. The majority of these commemorative acts were carried out by female members of the community, and especially by the eldest women, who would pour water and wine on the grave, prepare a commemorative meal and serve it to the people attending the ceremony. Thus long before the remembrance of the war dead started to take on state-affirming functions, as it did from the mid-1920s, it had already developed a deeper, more intimate presence at local and communal level, albeit with a female rather than military garb. Indeed, given the lack of officially-sanctioned commemorations until the mid-1920s, private and communal grief was the main expression of mourning for the fallen. Despite some glorious and successful battles at the front, the defeat and the humiliating end to the fighting prevented the emergence of unifying national myths about the war. Instead, the war was associated with the bitter failure of national ideals, and with accusations and counter-accusations on all sides. For instance, the left attacked the government, King Ferdinand and the bourgeoisie in general for supporting Bulgaria’s participation in the war on the side of the Central Powers. On the other hand, socialists, democrats and pacifists were frequently accused by their right-wing opponents of undermining morale and acting as enemies and traitors. 14 15
╇ For a broader, pan-European view see Mosse (1990); and Winter (1995). ╇See Vakarelski (1990).
The aftermaths of defeat
41
Apart from illustrating the clear-cut confrontation between the bourgeoisie and the working class, this was also indicative of the great feelings of bitterness which dealing with the war and its aftermath aroused in post-war Bulgarian politics, and of the failure to engage in an open and honest debate about the merits and demerits of the country’s participation in that conflict – a situation paralleled in post-war Italy, as Emma Schiavon notes in her contribution to this volume. However, in contrast to Italy, the silence of the Bulgarian military on such questions in turn meant that women would become the main guardians of the memory of the fallen – at least in the period before 1923. The cultivation of the memory of the dead went hand in hand with the equally important task of caring for the war wounded and disabled – whether in hospitals or in the family milieu. Against the background of an army whose heroism was now called into question, and a national economy close to collapse, so much so that even basic care for the wounded could not be guaranteed by the state, the need for volunteer medical assistance was enormous. The majority of this volunteer work was undertaken by women, who came forward as individuals or via local branches of women’s organisations. Already during the war women had served in medical units for the wounded and appeals for volunteers had been followed by most of the leading women activists. The lack of specialist medical personnel (until the mid-1920s there were only 125 certified nurses in Bulgaria), and the death of large numbers of medical orderlies on the front lines, made women’s assistance in hospitals absolutely crucial in 1918 and 1919. Most of the volunteers came from the so-called “bourgeois” wing of the women’s movement, although some working-class women also heeded the call. After the brutal suppression of the soldiers’ uprising of 1918, women’s associations were among those that provided firm support to the veterans’ claims for state recognition and pensions, for their right to accessible medical care, and for financial compensation for their wartime service. Apart from the bitter disillusionment caused by the defeat of the soldiers’ uprising, the first post-war months were also marked by expressions of mass discontent, calls for revenge against those held responsible for the catastrophe, and attempts to overturn the heavy penalties imposed on the defeated state under the Treaty of Neuilly. With regard to the latter, women activists and organisations were especially energetic in issuing protests to international women’s groups demanding their support in the quest for a milder treatment.
42
nikolai vukov
For instance, the Women’s Union prepared a series of written complaints against the unjust clauses of the peace settlement, which they forwarded to women’s unions and associations abroad. As in the years after the Balkan wars, declarations and appeals to the international community were made against the redrawing of national boundaries, the loss of territories with a majority Bulgarian population, the mass displacement of Bulgarian refugees, and the delayed repatriation of thousands of prisoners of war. After a somewhat difficult period in its existence during the war, the Bulgarian Women’s Union had a vital role in these post-war activities and in the appeals for peace and cultural demobilisation. Following a series of papers and speeches about disarmament, one of the main activists of the Union, Zheni Pateva, initiated the creation of the Bulgarian branch of the International Committee of Women for Permanent Peace (ICWPP) in 1918. Pateva was a delegate at the International Congress of Women in The Hague in April-May 1915, where she made valuable contributions on disarmament and reconstructing the war-torn nations. In 1920 she was an official representative of the government of Alexander Stambolijski in Norway where she delivered a paper to the ICW, and two years later she was a Bulgarian government delegate at the International Women’s Congress. The Union was also represented at the fourth congress of the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom (WILPF) in Washington DC in 1924 and at the fifth congress in Dublin in 1925. On each of these occasions the Bulgarian cause was presented for the attention of women activists from different countries. Although the appeals for a revision of the Treaty of Neuilly had little effect, Bulgaria gained some sympathy as a defeated nation which had been treated too harshly by the peacemakers in 1919, and this helped to overcome the international isolation which the country had faced in the early post-war years. The fulfillment of their social and patriotic duty did not prevent Bulgarian women from maintaining an increasingly critical stance towards the policies of the post-war state, especially in relation to issues of social and political justice. Opposition to state-sponsored acts of violence in the post-war era was expressed in newspaper articles and, less frequently, through participation in acts of rebellion. Socialist and bourgeois women’s organisations again disagreed over tactics and goals. The transformation of the pre-war Social Democratic Party into the Bulgarian Communist Party (BCP) in 1919, and the latter’s adherence to the Comintern’s line on armed struggle and
The aftermaths of defeat
43
proletarian dictatorship meant that socialist women’s organisations would oppose almost any political programme other than the Leninist one. Based on agitation around issues such as low wages, economic deprivation, and exploitation in the workplace, this struggle resulted in recurrent strikes, labour protests, and public demonstrations in favour of the Bolshevik ideal. In fact, one of the most notable developments in the first post-war years was the subordination of the women’s socialist movement to the broader aims and objectives of the Communist party. On 19 December 1919, the Central Committee of the BCP issued a declaration, pointing out that women, who made up more than half of the population, were now participating in almost equal numbers to men in the production process. The declaration appealed to the party organisations to make every effort to attract working-class women and to recruit them to the class struggle.16 Meanwhile sales of the party’s newspaper for women, Rabotnicheski vestnik, increased from 6,000 in 1919 to 10,000 in 1920, and in 1922 there were 700 female members of the BCP out of a total of 38,500.17 A further 5,800 women were also taking part in educational groups designed to prepare them for entry into the party. In the years 1919 to 1923 a large number of women participated in all of the mass activities organised by the party, including the transport strike and the general political strike in December 1919 and January 1920 respectively; the action in support of the starving population of the Volga region; and various political demonstrations and election campaigns. The involvement of communist women in social and political protest peaked in September 1923, when, following instructions from the Comintern in Moscow, the BCP took the decision to organise an armed uprising against the leaders of the June military coup, with the ill-disguised aim of establishing communist rule. Despite the Communists’ intentions, the uprising was far from having a mass character, spreading to a limited number of regions only (mostly in central and north-western Bulgaria) and involving relatively small groups of the population. What turned it into a bigger and more ╇See Ravenstvo 8, 1 December 1919; and Rabotnicheski vestnik 259, 1 May 1923. ╇Trifonov (1988), p.╯9. The number of women in the Bulgarian Communist Party seems very low compared to the number of men, but it is worth bearing in mind that these figures include only the actual members of the party. In fact, many women engaged in party-led activities without becoming party members, thereby showing their sympathy with socialist ideals and their solidarity with their brothers or husbands. 16 17
44
nikolai vukov
important event was the brutal clampdown by the state. Thousands of rebels were murdered and many of those who survived were given long prison sentences. After the suppression of the uprising, the BCP was banned and in 1924 the Law for the Protection of the State was passed by the National Assembly. The uprising occurred with mass participation of women, both as organisers and as foot-soldiers in the rebellion. They took part in gathering and hiding arms, transferring munitions, acting as couriers, and hosting meetings in their houses. In fact, on 15 September 1923, the decision in favour of an uprising had been taken at the house of Tina Kirkova, a female member of the Central Committee of the BCP.╯During the uprising women offered medical help for the wounded, ensured food supplies for the rebels, and were persecuted on an equal basis to their male comrades. Some of the organisers – including a prominent activist in the communist women’s movement, Tsola Dragoycheva – were sentenced to fifteen years in jail. They were also deprived of the right to practice as teachers. Although the uprising received direct support only from the communist women’s organisations, non-communist women were also horrified by the brutal nature of the government’s response. Protests were issued by bourgeois women’s organisations calling for an immediate end to state repression in the aftermath of the uprising. The leader of the Women’s Union, Ekaterina Karavelova, issued numerous appeals to this end. As an act of public defiance, she turned her home into a place for collecting charity for the victims of the clampdown, and urged local branches of women’s associations in the country to organise similar activities in reaction to the terror. Many members of the Union voiced their opposition to the new legislation on the death penalty, which was passed by the National Assembly in 1923. In 1925, at the time of the communist-backed terrorist attack on St. Nedelya church in Sofia, affiliates from the Women’s Union sent letters to the government calling for an end to the arrest and murder of left-wing political suspects, and in support of the more than one thousand people who had disappeared without a trace in the police departments. At the initiative of Zheni Pateva, a “Women’s Peace Society in Bulgaria” was created in Burgas, which spearheaded opposition against political repressions and police persecutions. The intense political crisis of the immediate post-war years left little space for women to continue their pre-war struggles for equal access to education and the professions, but activity on these lines did not
The aftermaths of defeat
45
cease altogether. Suffice it to say that women were barred from most professional and administrative positions, which were still overwhelmingly occupied by men. A state of relative, though paradoxical, “equality” was created by the 1920 Labour Service Law, which required men over twenty and women over sixteen to perform work on state construction projects for a period of twelve and six months respectively. Aiming to circumvent the armaments limitation clauses of the Treaty of Neuilly, the law placed young men and women in the service of the nation on an apparently similar footing, but this did not mean that they were now regarded as “equal citizens”. Meanwhile, in the early 1920s the Bulgarian women’s movement changed its slogan from demanding the “improvement” of women’s voting rights to demanding “equal rights” in the sphere of suffrage, marking an important step in the development of feminist consciousness.18 Even so, it was only in 1937 that voting rights were granted to Bulgarian women, and then only to those who were married, divorced or widowed.19 Full and equal suffrage was to become a fact only after 1944. In the field of education, the post-war years saw more visible success. In 1918 the Bulgarian academic system appointed the first female assistant professor, the chemist Teodora Raykova-Kăncheva, and in 1924 the Association of Bulgarian Women with Higher Education was established.20 Against the background of economic and political crisis after the war, the Ministry of Education passed a law in 1919 turning all secondary schools into mixed ones, with boys and girls studying together. Although debates about the “special” education of girls persisted, both in society in general and among women activists, progress towards overcoming gender disparities was more and more evident in the post-war years. This was also coupled with increasing levels of literacy among women, with 57% able to read and write by the early 1930s, compared to only 14% in the period before World War I.21 However, the question of how to enhance the education and professional aspirations of peasant women remained a major challenge in the 1920s. Both feminist and socialist women were aware of this chal-
╇See Todorova (2004), p.╯122. ╇ As Daskalova (2001), p.╯183, remarks, women were thus granted the vote only after they had entered into a relationship of dependency on a man. Single women were still not recognised as equal citizens. 20 ╇See Nazărska (2003). 21 ╇See Todorova (2004), p.╯116; and Dinkova (1980). 18 19
46
nikolai vukov
lenge, and continued to advance different solutions over the next two decades. Conclusion Overall, the social and economic changes that occurred in the immediate aftermath of the First World War substantially changed the status of women in Bulgaria and together with the development of the feminist movement, also led to their increased participation in public life. Having survived the war on their own terms and with their own experiences, women were no longer content to be passive subjects and victims, but rather involved themselves directly in social and political campaigns. This testified to an important process that was under way throughout the post-war years – the gradual shift from charity, education and social welfare work to political action, involving either violent resistance against social injustice (on the left) or state-supporting activities (on the centre and right). Commemorating the war dead was an equally important part of this process, involving as it did the mobilisation of local communities in the absence of a clear lead from the central authorities. Metaphorically speaking, the rise of new ideologies of masculinity in the war years was followed by a no less important rise in the activities of organised women’s movements, which also found expression in spheres that were previously reserved exclusively for men. In these new trends, the “above class” and “above party” stance of the Women’s Union and its local branches was paralleled by the socialist women and their class-specific vision of social activism. Embracing rival visions of women’s involvement and role in society – one through education and social integration, the other through aggressive revolutionary activism – “bourgeois” feminists and socialists paradoxically followed similar paths when it came to responding to the challenges of the post-war years. Despite the many ruptures and divergences in their agendas, they both sought to shoulder the heavy social burden of military defeat and in so doing, to open up new outlets for women’s public activity in the war’s aftermath. This surprising similarity in terms of experience, which was superficially masked by exaggerated and overblown ideological differences in the immediate post-war years, would be repeated in the very different context of the Second
The aftermaths of defeat
47
World War and the period of establishment of communist rule between 1944 and 1947. Bibliography Bradinska, R. (1969) Văznikvane i oformyane na zhenskoto sotisaldemokratichesko dvizhenie v Bălgaria, 1885-1915 (Sofia: 1969). Cholakova, M. (1995) Bălgarskoto zhensko dvizhenie v Bălgaria prez Văzrazhdaneto (Sofia: 1995). Daskalova, K. (1998) “Bălgarskite zheni v sotsialni dvizheniya, zakoni i diskursi”, in Ot syankata na istoriyata. Zhenite v bălgarskoto obshtestvo i kultura, ed. K.╯Daskalova (Sofia: 1998) 11–41. ———╯ (1999) “Feminizăm i ravenstvo v bălgarskiya XX vek”, in Mayki i dăshteri. Pokoleniya i posoki v bălgarskiya feminizăm, ed. R.╯Muharska (Sofia: 1999) 80–105. ———╯(2001) “Zhenskata identichnost: Normi, Predstavi, obrazi v bălgarskata kultura ot XIX – nachaloto na ХХ vek”, in Balkanski identichnosti v bulgarskata kultura ot modernata epoha (ХIХ-ХХ vek), eds. N.╯Aretov and N.╯Chernokozhev (Sofia: 2001) 157–228. Daskalova, K., and Gavrilova R. eds. (2001) Granitsi na grazhdanstvoto: evropeyskite zheni mezhdu traditsiyata i modernostta (Sofia: 2001). Dinkova, M. (1980) Sotsialen protret na bălgarskata zhena (Sofia: 1980). Karima, A. (1910) Zhenskoto dvizhenie u nas. Negovoto minalo, nastoyashte i bădeshte (Sofia: 1910), reproduced in Ot syankata na istoriyata. Zhenite v bulgarskoto obshtestvo i kultura, ed. K.╯Daksalova (Sofia: 1998) 198–9. Mosse, G. (1990) Fallen Soldiers: Reshaping the Memory of the World Wars (Oxford: 1990). Nazărska, Z. (2003) Universitetskoto obrazovanie i bălgarskite zheni, 1879-1944 (Sofia: 2003). Paskaleva, V. (1983) Bălgarkata prez Văzrazhdaneto (Sofia: 1983). Todorova, M. (2004) Istoricheska traditsiya i promeni v Bulgaria: zhenski i feministki problemi, in Zhenski identichnosti na Balkanite, eds. K.╯Daskalova and K.╯Slavova (Sofia: 2004) 112–25. Trifonov, D. (1988) Zhenite v Septemvrijskoto văstanie. Entsiklopedichen spravochnik (Sofia: 1988). Vakarelski, H. (1990) Bălgarski pogrebalni obichai. Sravnitelno izuchavane (Sofia: 1990). Winter, J. (1995) Sites of Memory, Sites of Mourning: The Great War in European Cultural History (Cambridge: 1995).
48
nikolai vukov
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
49
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919 and Voce nuova (“New Voice”): Corporatism, nationalism and the struggle for political rights Emma Schiavon* Italy came into the war almost a year after the outbreak of hostilities, on 24 May 1915. Before then Italian society was deeply divided between neutralists who wanted to remain out of the war and interventionists who wished to enter it. The war itself failed to heal these rifts, even though Italy emerged in 1918 on the winning side. In the post-war period social conflict raged between the bourgeoisie, who had supported intervention, and the factory workers and peasantry, on whom it had been imposed. One side orchestrated the occupation of land and factories and launched revolutionary uprisings. The other side fomented nationalist unrest in reaction to what they deemed to be a “mutilated victory”. In this they were encouraged by the prime minister, Vittorio Emanuele Orlando, who in April 1919 walked out of the Versailles peace conference in protest at America’s rejection of Italy’s claims to Dalmatia and the Croatian town of Fiume (Rjeka). In September 1919 the town was illegally occupied by the poet Gabriele D’Annunzio, and his troops remained there until Christmas 1920. Despite this difficult situation, after the war the Italian feminist movement led its most organised and determined campaign for the rights of women to date, arguing that women’s special role during the war entitled them to the vote. New trends developed within the movement during this period and some feminists started following ideologies of radical nationalism. In addition, the idea gained ground that a corporatist system would have provided better representation for women than a parliamentary model based on the individual.
This essay focuses on the Italian women’s movement after World War I with particular reference to the experience of the Milanese feminists, who were the leading group in Italy at that time. Above all it seeks to uncover the contradictory links between nationalism, interventionism
*╇ I would like to thank Grazia De Michele who helped me in many ways with this paper and in particular with translation into English.
50
Emma Schiavon
and feminism during the immediate post-war period by looking at the struggle for women’s rights conducted in the pages of the journal Voce Nuova (New Voice). It is not possible, however, to discuss this issue without first looking at the attitudes taken by the Italian feminist movement during the war itself. In 1915 – contrary to what one might have expected – Italian feminists displayed almost unanimous approval of the government’s decision to enter the war on the Allied side. All independent women’s organisations supported this position, with only a few individual exceptions.1 Part of the explanation for this can be found in the fact that Socialist and Catholic women, who opposed intervention, were no longer part of the independent feminist movement but instead operated within the women’s sections of their respective political parties, a trend which had begun around 1912. This in turn freed the feminist movement to pursue its own autonomous agenda beyond the influence of socialism and political Catholicism. Even so, the feminists’ support for intervention is still highly surprising, since most Italians viewed entry into the war as something imposed upon them by the government rather than as the voluntary fulfilment of a patriotic duty. This in turn formed part of the backdrop to the rise of Fascism in the war’s aftermath. Even in comparison with the French feminists’ total support for the war, the Italian movement’s attitude is rather peculiar, since in May 1915 Italian territory was not directly threatened with invasion, in contrast to the position facing France in August 1914. In fact, the Italian feminists’ involvement in the war effort was more a strategy to achieve recognition of female citizenship than a capitulation to the pressures of patriots or warmongers. This can be seen firstly in the fact that nearly all feminist groups began their campaign for intervention as soon as the war began in 1914, long before any government resolution on Italy’s involvement. Secondly, women’s associations themselves hardly managed to control the enthusiasm that spread within their ranks, especially among younger activists, who saw in the war – rightly or wrongly – an extraordinary chance for emancipation. On the other hand, thanks to the war, the women’s movement sought the rise of an embryonic welfare state, which had been 1 ╇ I have already discussed the interventionism of Italian feminist organisations in two articles: Schiavon (2001) and Schiavon (2004). See also my forthcoming book, Schiavon (2010).
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
51
one of their long-term concerns: welfare organisations would offer appropriate roles for and recognition of new female professional figures. Besides, the nature of the First World War itself – as the first mass industrialised conflict – seemed to shatter previous boundaries between combatants and non-combatants, thus undermining one of the main arguments against women’s enfranchisement: indeed, by 1918 economic production on the home front was proving a crucial factor in Italy’s victory, at least in terms of military operations. Finally we should not underestimate the impact on Italian women of those widespread propaganda images from the countries already involved in the war effort (especially Great Britain) which portrayed strong, self-confident and smiling women at work in all kinds of jobs, often dressed in trousers or uniforms. Such representations broke down the narrow gender rules imposed upon women at the time, especially in Italy. Moreover it has to be remembered that these kinds of image arrived at the same time as news about the patriotic realignment of the Pankhursts and the WSPU.╯Finally it must be stressed that, despite their reassuring declarations, Italian feminists never really abandoned their campaign for the vote for the duration of the war, and even went so far as to organise two national suffrage congresses between 1916 and 1917.2 However, this strategy failed completely to win political rights. Instead, the European-wide post-war gender backlash affected Italian society in the most extreme manner, with the rise of Fascism paving the way for the long-term defeat of any feminist demands. The Italian feminist movement in the aftermath of war In spite of these longer-term trends, in the immediate aftermath of war the Italian women’s movement appeared to be quite strengthened. Many of its leaders had held key positions in war work and propaganda and could now call on managerial and political skills which they had never previously dreamt of. More generally, it seemed that the war experience had strengthened many women’s self-esteem and confi2 ╇On this topic the book edited by Fell and Sharp (2007) marks a quantum leap in the interpretation of feminist movements’ patriotic alignment during the First World War. Fell and Sharp indeed correctly underline how the feminists “rarely lost track of their feminists goals, and frequently attempted to use pro-war nationalist discourse for their own ends” (Introduction, p.╯11).
52
Emma Schiavon
dence in their own abilities, especially among workers. In particular, it was only then that a new class of women, which could be defined as lower middle-class, was formed in Italy; they were teachers, new welfare workers, and above all office workers, whose number both in public and private companies had rapidly increased throughout the war. These women were the only ones who could attain a proper, although limited, economic independence.3 Moreover, the political context had never been so favourable to suffrage issues. Good news from abroad flowed in as votes and civil rights were extended to women in an increasing number of countries. Meanwhile at home almost all political parties had suddenly started supporting suffrage, partly spurred by the new Catholic party – the Partito popolare (Popular Party) – which immediately declared itself in favour of women’s suffrage. In December 1918, shortly after the ceasefire, Italian feminist associations started presenting petitions and putting pressure on MPs. Both the Lega patriottica femminile (Women’s Patriotic League), an association that worked in Rome and was characterised by strong nationalist views, and the Milanese section of the Fascio nazionale femminile (National Women’s Union), which was a kind of federation of all Italian national feminist associations born after the defeat at Caporetto, immediately joined forces and took action. The former urged male parliamentary deputies to take initiatives on their behalf, and advised them not to leave all women’s question in the hand of the Socialists because this attitude would have displeased the mass of women workers. The latter summoned a meeting of its representatives on 12 December 1918 where they exhorted parliament to extend the right to vote to women immediately, and to stop the mass dismissal of those women who had taken on new jobs during the war.4 At this stage it was clear that the Milanese associations were leading the Italian movement toward a more forceful campaign. The Milan women’s movement had been the strongest in the country since national unification and was now led by some important figures, particularly notable for their competence, determination and international links. They included Margherita Ancona, secretary of the radical bourgeois Comitato lombardo pro suffragio (Lombard Suffrage Committee), member of the Italian branch of the International ╇ Curli (1998). ╇ “Per il suffragio femminile” (In favour of female suffrage), Attività femminile sociale, 6/12 (December 1918). 3 4
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
53
Women’s Suffrage Alliance (IWSA), and Italian correspondent for the main international suffrage papers; Carla Lavelli Celesia, leader of the Lombard branch of the more moderate Consiglio nazionale delle donne italiane (National Council of Italian Women, CNDI), which was in turn a member of the International Council of Women (ICW); and Paolina Tarugi, a leading lawyer, journalist and suffrage campaigner. In January 1919 Attività femminile sociale (Women’s Social Activity) the national organ of CNDI, published an open letter written by Margherita Ancona to the journal and to its organisation. In it, she encouraged CNDI’s members to abandon gradualism in favour of a campaign for the immediate introduction of female suffrage on the grounds that the vote would allow them to secure all the important social and economic reforms they had advocated: “The vote, the vote, the vote. If we all act together to claim the right to vote, we will get it”.5 The Milanese associations therefore organised the fourth National Suffrage Congress, held in Milan in April 1919 and preceded by a national meeting held in March at the National Theatre in Rome. Many political parties and women’s associations that had been against the vote before the war attended the two meetings, which subsequently gathered the support of several politicians. The Milan Suffrage congress was thus a great success: nearly all the political parties sent representatives, who in turn declared themselves almost unanimously in favour of the vote (except for the Nationalist party).6 It is worth emphasising that the presence of MPs and ministers did not soften the activists’ tone. Remembering the long years that had elapsed in vain before the war, feminist associations required solemn assurances from MPs in exchange for their support in future elections; they even threatened to hamper their careers in the event of last-minute defec5 ╇ M.╯Ancona, “Per una pregiudiziale” (A question to be resolved before all others can be addressed), Attività femminile sociale, 7/1 (January 1919). 6 ╇ The issue of Italian feminist movement after the First World War has been neglected by historiography. On the national meeting in Rome, see “Per il voto alla donna” (On votes for women), Giovine Europa, 7/3 (March 1919); and on the Milan congress see M.╯Ancona “Per il voto alla donna. Quarto congresso suffragista nazionale (Milano 26–28 aprile 1919)” (On votes for women, national suffrage congress), Giovine Europa, 7/6 (June 1919); “Notiziario. Milano. Per il Congresso nazionale pro suffragio femminile” (Newsletter. Milan. For the National Women’s Suffrage Congress), La Fiaccola. Rassegna femminile di italianità, 2/3–4 (March–April 1919); and “Il congresso femminista” (The Feminist Convention), Il Corriere della sera, 28 April 1919.
54
Emma Schiavon
tions. At the end of the congress the Radical MP and future Minister Luigi Gasparotto committed himself to introducing a bill on women’s suffrage, a promise which he later kept. Completely unmoved by these protestations, the president of the Lombard Suffrage Committee, Margherita Ancona, addressed the MPs, exhorting them to “shut the floodgate of eloquence and save your intellectual strength for writing a simple little statute”.7 An ambitious editorial and political project: Voce nuova (“New Voice”) The weekly feminist paper Voce nuova saw the first light of day on 31 May 1919 and in spite of its short life (the final issue was published on 13 February 1920) it followed and commented on all the most significant parliamentary debates about women’s rights in the post-war period, including the abolition of the law requiring “marital authorisation” before a wife could engage in commercial dealings and property transactions on 17 July 1919; the approval of women’s suffrage in the Chamber of Deputies on 6 September 1919 followed by the dissolution of parliament before the same bill could be put before the Senate; and finally the general election held in November 1919. The project of a weekly political feminist newssheet arose from the suffrage congress which had reinforced the alliance between all the main local feminist associations in Milan – including not only the local branch of the CNDI and the Lombard Suffrage Committee but also the Unione Femminile Nazionale (National Women’s Union or UFN). One of the most important women’s groups at that time, the UFN had branches all over Italy but had started out and still had its main base in Milan. The organisation had operated until the war in quite an autonomous way because of its different ideological inspiration – which was socialist in a broad sense – and because of its methods inspired by the idea of direct action to improve woman’s social conditions. In this way, all of the main women’s organisations based in Milan supported the radical suffragist project of Voce nuova. As a matter of fact, every Italian feminist association claimed the right to vote at that time, but the Milanese feminists were the only ones who believed that ╇ M.╯Ancona, “Da un congresso all’altro” (From one congress to another), Voce nuova 1/2, 7 June 1919. 7
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
55
the most effective strategy was to follow a hard-hitting campaign that aimed exclusively at suffrage. The important Roman branch of the CNDI, for instance, maintained its pre-war position, which called for the vote on principle, but felt it would be “naturally” granted to women once they had proved themselves, through social work, to be mature enough to exercise their new rights. This approach was common before the war to both the CNDI and, in large part, to the UFN, while the only associations which led real campaigns for suffrage were the “Suffrage committees” organised in the Federazione italiana pro suffragio (Italian Suffrage Federation), which was in turn affiliated to the IWSA.╯After the war, however, the UFN joined the “Suffrage committees” in the campaign for civil and political rights, while the position of the CNDI varied, depending on location, from the extremely moderate stance of the Romans, to the much more strident position of the Lombardy branch and its president, Carla Lavelli Celesia. Voce nuova was run by a cooperative in which all the major local organisations were represented and was characterised by an entrepreneurial spirit which was rather unusual for the independent feminist press, to the extent that the paper was able to pay for the salaries of two editors, Paolina Tarugi and Sofia Ravasi. The paper could also rely on the support of the Rome-based Associazione per la donna (Association for the Woman), which had committed itself to funding an office in the capital and to promoting the circulation of the periodical in central Italy. The project was ambitious, especially considering that the pre-war feminist movement in Italy was relatively weak.8 Voce nuova was an organ of public opinion in the widest sense of the term, since it covered domestic and foreign politics as well as strikes and labour unrest in the country. The choice of the weekly format was in fact largely dictated by the rapid pace of political events in Italy at this time, including working-class struggles and the birth of new political parties such as the above mentioned Popular Party and the Fascist Party (both established in 1919) soon followed by the Communist Party (founded in 1921).
8
╇ Pieroni Bortolotti (1972); Buttafuoco, (1984); Tesoro (1992); Migliucci (2006).
56
Emma Schiavon One step from victory
The prevailing tone of the suffrage campaign undertaken by Voce nuova was defiant. Moderate or wavering male politicians were treated irreverently and sarcastically in its pages. The main parliamentary debates on women’s rights were reported in banner headlines or on the front page, transformed for the occasion into a sort of manifesto. The new activism and sense of purpose was no doubt legitimised by the role women had played during the war. Voce nuova’s position was in line with the interventionist choice made by all the Italian feminist organisations at the outbreak of war. Politicians, political parties and programmes were viewed through the lens of interventionism and neutralism, and judged accordingly. The two editors, Paolina Tarugi and Sofia Ravasi, also belonged to the younger generation of activists who had received their political training during the war. They had risen to prominence as journalists working in the field of wartime propaganda at the highest levels. Both had also been on the editorial board of the Bulletin périodique de la presse italienne, which was destined for the Bureau de la presse etrangère in Paris9 and had been contributors to several propaganda papers. In September 1917 Paolina Tarugi had become editor, along with another journalist, of the bi-weekly AssisÂ� tenza civile (Social Welfare), the main organ of the national committees for propaganda and civil assistance on the home front. To put it bluntly, this meant that the ideas of the feminists who wrote for Voce nuova in 1919-20 were rooted in an out-of-date interventionism, a position that would soon become anachronistic as a result of the political and social turbulence which characterised Italy and other European countries in the immediate post-war period. The failure to engage in a genuine and thorough cultural demobilisation was typical for all of Italian society at this time,10 especially among interventionists, but it resulted in a fatal political weakness for the feminist movement. As a consequence, even though at this point it had developed a vehement and well-organised struggle for women’s rights, the Italian feminist movement became politically isolated. 9 ╇ The collections of the Bureau are stored at the Bibliothéque de documentation internationale contemporaine in Paris. The presence of Paolina Tarugi and Sofia Ravasi on the editorial board is noted by Carrozza (1990), p.╯6. 10 ╇On the concept of ‘cultural demobilisation’ from a pan-European perspective, see Horne (1999) and (2002). For a general overview of the Italian situation see Corner and Procacci (1997).
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
57
Voce nuova contributed to this process through its constant references to the war and to women’s role in it. In its view, performance of wartime service was not just an obligation in a banal contractual sense, but a life-changing experience for women, which had reinforced their political self-awareness and had demonstrated to the world their full personality. As one of the paper’s editorials put it on 31 May 1919: The intense way in which, in these last years, we have invested our physical and mental energies has saved us from any accusation of cowardice and is carrying us forwards in strength and composure towards the future, and removing us forever from the sad world of meek compromises, which has never brought us anything but discouragement and regret.11
Voce nuova consistently and clearly rejected the concept of women’s rights as a reward from men for war service. It also dismissed all notions of a gradual extension of rights. Instead it claimed nothing less than the full recognition of women as political subjects. In line with this principle, contributors to Voce nuova were particularly angered by the decision in some European countries, such as Belgium, to grant the vote to the mothers and widows of fallen soldiers. Margherita Ancona defined it aptly as “a vote by proxy awarded to the war dead”, in other words, as a substitution for the deceased male citizen rather than a recognition of women’s right to the vote.12 On 28 June 1919, following the introduction of the MartiniGasparotto bill in the Chamber of Deputies, Voce nuova provided detailed coverage of the stance on female suffrage taken by MPs past and present, providing a list of all those who had defected or changed their positions. A few days later, on 6 July, when the Chamber of Deputies approved the bill to grant women the vote, Voce nuova greeted this event with banner headlines. At the same time, however, it strongly condemned the Chamber’s decision – adopted against the background of jokes and double entendres – to exclude prostitutes from the right to vote. The suffragists of Voce nuova seemed fully 11 ╇ Voce nuova 1/1, 31 May 1919, without title, signed “Voce nuova”. The concept was restated in the following issue – see S. R., “Donna nuova per una famiglia nuova” (A new woman for a new family), Voce nuova 1/2, 7 June 1919. 12 ╇ M.╯Ancona, “Fra senatori e lords” (Between senators and lords), Voce nuova 1/9, 26 July 1919. On the proposal to grant the vote to war widows in France, strongly supported by the nationalist right, see Bard (1995) pp.╯83–4. On similar proposals for “family suffrage” as an alternative to equal political rights for women see Fiorino (1994).
58
Emma Schiavon
aware that the reference to prostitutes had an enormous symbolic significance, and that it concerned all women. The incident showed that there was still a long way to go in terms of securing women’s dignity and freedom: We... know that the struggle for woman’s freedom does not end here. On the contrary we have still achieved little or nothing, and the pitiful discussion on the unfortunate “love workers” (... repudiated by the same men’s egoism and brutality which fuels and creates them) is a sign of how much there is still to do in terms of raising women and the human family to the level of dignity and respect to which we aspire.13
The feminists of Voce nuova seemed, however, to miss a crucial point: the older notion that women might “contaminate” the nation through their involvement in politics had actually been reinforced by the war, and the debates on the exclusion of prostitutes, as well as the portrayal of suffrage as a “reward”, were highly revealing in this respect. The war had symbolically strengthened the idea that only men were entitled to citizenship as only they had been willing and able to sacrifice their lives as armed defenders of their country. The public discourse was more than ever dominated by heroic symbolism, while the prosaic reality of industrialised mass war on the home front, to which women had extensively contributed, was systematically downplayed and hidden by the gendered distinction now being made between (male) Â�soldiers and (female) non-soldiers. In the absence of cultural demobiÂ� lisation, and with even feminists apparently celebrating the continuation of the mindsets of war into the post-war period, the political idea of the nation became imbued with the concept of “armed civic virtue” based on the imagined hard and pure life at the front. This in turn strengthened the notion that women were not “naturally” bearers of rights and could only become so after a profound purification, a sacrifice comparable to that of the soldiers.14
13 ╇ “Il disegno di legge per l’elettorato femminile” (The bill in favour of women’s suffrage), Voce nuova 1/5, 28 June 1919. 14 ╇On the post-war gender backlash see Higonnet et al. (1987), p.╯7. On the concept of the Männerbund (male bonding established during war) see in particlar Mosse (1982); and on the concept of “armed civic virtue” see Elshtain (1987).
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
59
Corporatism and nationalism in the pages of Voce nuova By the middle of September 1919 Voce nuova’s suffrage campaign was over. Already in the eleventh issue, attention was focused on the stance to be adopted by suffragists during the parliamentary elections. The debate was centred on the proposal, already presented by Carla Lavelli Celesia at the suffragist conference, to establish a common programme between all the feminist associations. This was to be submitted, dependÂ�ing on personal beliefs, to the competing political parties. Celesia’s idea was strongly rejected by Voce nuova because it was seen to be impossible to reconcile the different Italian political currents. Sofia Ravasi asserted that interventionism and neutralism were divided by a moral abyss, since “on the one hand, tenacity and enduring sacrifice were being called for, while on the other hand the so-called idealistic position of being against the war reduced all human virtue to impotence”.15 The frustrated expectations of victory and the understandable desire to play a leading role in such a crucial political situation led Voce nuova to set the issue of women’s suffrage aside for a while. Instead, between the first ten days of September and the 1 November it concentrated largely on “national” issues. The paper – as well as the majority of the Italian bourgeois press – enthusiastically greeted the occupation of the Istrian town of Fiume (today Rijeka) by the nationalist poet Gabriele D’Annunzio and a group of soldiers who had operated illegally and on their own initiative. Hitherto the city had been disputed between Italy and Yugoslavia with the western Allies caught in between as arbiters. In November 1919, the failure to reintroduce the Martini-GaspaÂ� rotto suffrage bill after the elections represented the umpteenth setback in the decades-long campaign for the enfranchisement of women, and led Voce nuova to attack the parliamentary system as a whole; in addition they began to suggest that a corporatist system might be the best solution. The exasperation, and maybe a slight naivety, induced the suffragists to think that the exclusion of women from representation would be more difficult in a political system based on social and occupational groupings rather than on the individual. The issue had been addressed for the first time in an editorial by Paolina Tarugi on the formation of the Nitti government in June 1919. The Radical ╇S. R.,“Rinsaldiamo all’avvenire il nostro passato interventista” (Let’s strengthen our future through our interventionist past), Voce nuova 1/18, 12 October 1919. 15
60
Emma Schiavon
Francesco Nitti was strongly opposed as Prime Minister by Voce nuova because of his alliance with the Socialists, even though he had also promised to address the issue of women’s suffrage: While we sincerely hope that those measures required for the safeguarding of the rights of minorities and for the reorganisation of the current electoral systems will be taken, this time we will surely not tolerate any omission of our rights... In spite of this, if parliamentary democracy has had its day, as we believe it has, if from the classical concept of the right to vote as a prerogative of the individual we necessarily move towards the concept [of corporatism] which identifies itself with an expression of class and professional interests, and if the low level of national political life is due... to the lack of political and moral consciousness, then we are not here to uphold systems that are redundant, to perpetuate political immoralities that we strongly condemn.16
This radical questioning of the parliamentary system was at odds with Voce Nuova’s campaign for women’s inclusion, and sure enough, the issue was soon set aside, at least by the editorial staff. However, it was taken up again by another notable contributor to the paper, the Romebased philosopher Teresa Labriola, who was not part of the editorial team. Before the war Teresa Labriola had led the Rome Suffrage committee, within which she already represented the more elitist wing, but during the conflict she came to a radically nationalist view that soon distanced her from the Federazione Italiana Pro Suffragio itself. By 1919, her initial interpretation of Hegel’s idealism, in which she portrayed women’s rights as part of the dialectical integration of the nation and the state, had become characterised by clearly racist elements. This was a form of politics hardly found in Italy and only comparable to the position taken by some “Nazi-feminist” groups in Germany.17 It is no accident that some of Labriola’s more significant articles were published by Voce nuova in the middle of September ╇ P. T., “La crisi e noi” (The crisis and us), Voce nuova 1/5, 28 June 1919. ╇On “Nazi-feminism” in Germany see Crips (1990). Racism, along with the dominant idea of the need for the Italian nation to expand at the expense of other peoples, was present in the Italian National Association before the war. However, hostility towards other nations was rarely expressed, since the need to improve, enrich and expand the Italian people was felt to be more important – see Gaeta (1981). Even though racism was not very common in political programmes, Italian society was of course far from being immune to those racist theories which were becoming widespread all over Europe, especially in medicine, psychiatry and sociology. See here the collection of essays by Burgio (2000). For an analysis of the links between racism and misogyny see especially Babini (2000), and the seminal essay by Rossi Doria (2000) in that volume. 16 17
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
61
1919, while at the same time Margherita Ancona’s collaboration with the paper ended. Ancona had in fact always held a coherent position on the liberal wing of suffragism, and rejected all forms of nationalism and racism. Despite these differences, the corporate representation theory as formulated by Labriola seemed to meet the hopes and aspirations of the pro-war/ pro-interventionist wing of the Italian feminist movement: Action. The Parliament. I am enthusiastic about the former, but I have many and justified doubts about the second... Do you want the vote? Yes. Not for the old parliament but for the new one. For the new parliament of fighters, of producers and of mothers. Do you want the vote? Yes. Your exclusion from the vote today with the current atomistic system – or rather pseudo-system – means your likely exclusion from the future trade union vote, in the new parliament.18
The idea of special representation for women as “fighters, producers and mothers” within a corporatist political system struck a chord with those feminists who had placed special emphasis on the social and national importance of motherhood and motherly values. During the war this long cultivated strategy showed its first important results, for instance through the professionalisation of charity and social welfare based on mutual assistance. The director of Voce nuova, Paolina Tarugi, also contributed to this development with her support for the creation of social welfare services in Italy (in the 1930s).19 In this way, the Italian feminists, despite taking up nationalist themes, continued with their tradition of giving public visibility to the values of motherhood and femininity. There are some parallels here with the strategy adopted by mainstream female activists in Germany, as Matthew Stibbe notes in this volume. However, there are far fewer similarities with the extreme right-wing German women analysed by Christine Streubel, whose main goal seemed to be to reconstruct masculinity as a means to national recovery. Even so, Teresa Labriola’s contribution 18 ╇T.╯Labriola, “L’Azione. (Discorrendo di femminismo)” (The Action. (Talking about feminism)), Voce nuova 1/6, 5 July 1919. On the propagandistic success of fascist corporatism, seen by the contemporaries as a “third way” between capitalism and socialism, and on the success it encountered abroad, see Santomassimo (2006). 19 ╇Nisi Bernocchi (1984). In Italy it was above all the UFN that pursued a maternalist strategy to obtain full citizenship – see Buttafuoco (1997). For the European dimension of the “maternalist” tendency see Bock and Thane (1991) and Offen, (2000). For a general view on Italy see D’Amelia (2005).
62
Emma Schiavon
did point more in the direction of such views, especially as her focus on motherhood was more materialistic and bodily, based on women’s specific contribution to the nation through biological reproduction. This was a stance which was perfectly consistent with her overtly racist statements, including an article in Voce nuova in September 1919 asserting that Italian women might think twice before welcoming the extension of the franchise, particularly as the right to vote had now become a “power instrument in the hands of yellows and blacks” and since a “serious threat comes from niggers aiming to dominate Aryan society”.20 Teresa Labriola was a guest contributor to Voce nuova and so she did not entirely reflect its views. Paolina Tarugi, on the other hand, repeatedly defined the interventionism of the paper as democratic and revolutionary, thus firmly distancing herself from the aggressive imperialism of the nationalists, to whom Labriola was very close. Even so, it is significant that pieces like the one quoted above should find their way into the pages of Voce nuova without the slightest censorship, especially when one remembers that Margherita Ancona and many members of the UFN were of Jewish origin. What actually distinguished the paper from the position taken by its well-known contributor Labriola was above all the awareness of the violently misogynist trend running through neo-nationalist political parties and organisations. After the political elections the hostile attitude of the pro-war parties towards women was denounced and directly contrasted with the openness of the “anti-national” parties on the “woman question”: ... In the [original] programme of the Fasci di combattimento [Fascist groups] women’s suffrage was mentioned in a very clear and explicit way, whereas today it is unclear which evolutionary process [the Fascist groups] are referring to, as the issue is no longer mentioned [by them]. The War Veterans’ Association speaks of elections with universal suffrage and [yet] we are led to understand that they consider the universitas to be formed only by men, leading them to believe that universal suffrage is already in force in Italy at this time. â•… The conservatives, as usual, are silent, and the nationalists, in the words of some of their candidates, even in some women’s meetings,
20 ╇T.╯Labriola, “Il voto alla donna e il femminismo puro” (Votes for women and pure feminism), Voce nuova 1/15, 11 September 1919. For a biographical portrait of Labriola see Taricone (1994).
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
63
have recalled that women used to exist only for breeding farmyard animals!21
Paolina Tarugi in particular spoke in defence of women’s work, especially office work, in face of heavy attacks coming from neo-nationalist parties and veterans’ associations. It is worth noting that Tarugi, in her defence of female workers against the attacks of nationalist war veterans, did not base her argument on the number of single women who now needed to support themselves as a result of the war. Instead, this argument only began to be used during the Fascist period after 1922 in an attempt to resist the Mussolini regime’s policy of excluding women from the workforce. In this sense I would agree with Ingrid Sharp’s assertion in her essay in this volume that the “surplus women” debate was a sign of the weakness of the feminist movement. Tarugi, on the other hand, showed deeper insight when she linked the right to work with the rights of political citizenship: Let us remind veterans that, if for men it was a duty to defend their country by taking up arms for a just and higher cause, for women there was an equal duty to work for mobilised soldiers and to excel in activities for their country. Those who did not do this were called traitors, and these women were accused of being the cause of profligacy, indolence and underhand hostility to the war, and of everything which damaged and undermined the strength of the soldiers and the resistance of the country. So there is no good reason to call that greater female activity an “invasion”: it was for women simply a duty and a right at a time when the entire burden of the family fell on them. Other people also then took up the work of the absent soldiers for their own material survival, but we are in an election period and it is therefore a heroic feat to criticise women, who may neither vote nor be elected, and instead to support the shirkers, who are voters, and may even stand for election.22
21 ╇ P. T., “I partiti ed i gruppi politici si pronuncino sull'insoluta questione del suffragio” (Parties and political groups have to pronounce themselves about the suffrage question), Voce nuova 1/21, 11 November 1919. Emphasis in the original. 22 ╇ P. T., “La disoccupazione degli smobilitati ed il lavoro femminile” (The Unemployment of the veterans and women’s work), Voce nuova 1/20, 1 November 1919, emphasis in the original. Other articles on the same topic and with the same approach include “Rubrica del lavoro – Alle impiegate! L’Unione smobilitati e l’eliminazione delle donne dagli Uffici”, unsigned (Work section – For women office workers! The Veterans’ Union and the exclusion of women from the offices], Voce nuova 1/19, 22 October 1919; and “Rubrica del lavoro – La donna negli uffici” (Work section – Women in the officies) by ‘A Woman office bank worker’, Voce nuova 1/22, 15 November 1919.
64
Emma Schiavon
Despite these clashes with the patriotic associations of veterans, and despite their growing political isolation, the feminists around Nuova Voce clung on to their interventionist position as a matter of principle. This meant continuing to reject any collaboration or even any contact with the increasingly powerful women’s Catholic and Socialist organisations, owing to their neutralist stance during the war. How can this unwavering attachment to the national idea, by a group pursuing a feminist project which seemed so radical at the time, be explained, especially considering that they seemed to be aware of the isolation that such a choice entailed? In contrast to what happened at the same time in Hungary (see the chapters by Judith Szapor and Judit Acsády) and in Germany (Matthew Stibbe), where feminism and nationalism followed clearly different paths, most Italian feminists in the immediate period following the war appeared to experiment – albeit for a short time – with an unusual and rather surprising mix of radical feminist and radical nationalist themes. Nowadays radical nationalism seems to be the most “gendered” of all the modern ideologies. The correlation between nationalism and fanatical glorification of the “masculine” has had an extraordiÂ� narily emotional impact and it is probably the most enduring legacy of fascism. This link between nationalism and certain definitions of masculinity has also been characteristic of more recent extremist movements in Europe’s history. Hence it is no accident that the most profound, and maybe definitive, analyses of the relationship between gender and nationalism to appear over the last years have come from scholars working in central and eastern Europe, and in particular in the former Yugoslavia.23 But when Voce nuova was published this link had not yet been so firmly established and instead elements of an opposite tendency were operating. First of all there was the Risorgimento tradition to which all the protagonists of Voce nuova referred, with its moderate openness to women’s citizenship.╯Then there was of course the experience of war during which feminist interventionists were entrusted with tasks of extraordinary importance on the inner front. Moreover misogyny and gender reaction were not peculiar to nationalism. The moralising against women’s work as a cause of disintegration for working-class ╇See especially Iveković (1999) and (2003); and Iveković and Mostov (2002). On patriarchy in Italian Fascism see De Grazia (1992). 23
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
65
families was persistently evoked by some socialists and trades unionists, for instance.24 Finally, it is worth remembering the experience of the government of Fiume led by Gabriele D’Annunzio in 1919-20, which had given active and passive votes to women and had seen the election of three women to its representative assembly. The short-lived occupation of Fiume was a contingent and extemporaneous event that nonetheless had huge resonance and engendered the warmest enthusiasm amongst Italian feminists.25 However, beyond the influence exerted by one or more significant episodes, at that moment the nationalist-corporative perspective seemed to be the only one able to give representation to those lower middle-class women whose mouthpiece Voce nuova aimed to be from the outset. Voce nuova’s target audience was made up of office workers, teachers, and new welfare professionals (for whom there were cheaper subscription fees). A small army of young and dynamic women, who had just got into the world of work, could not find representation in the socialist trade unions, which had chosen to represent factory workers only, or support from the old liberal ruling class, which was still linked to the upper bourgeoisie. By targeting this group of working women, and by reminding them of their achievements during the war, Voce nuova made a clear and far-sighted choice. However this choice was to collide with the diametrically opposed attitude of the new nationalist organisations, which were bent on riding the wave of veterans’ bitterness against women accused of stealing their jobs. Therefore, the regular references to the war, inspired by the search for political legitimacy, ended up working against the Italian suffragists. On the whole, the post-war attempt to reap the rewards of the interventionist choice of 1914 had already failed by the autumn of 1919. In November Voce nuova tried for the last time to relaunch the suffrage campaign: it requested, with the usual determination, that ╇See Casalini (1998) and (2001); and Willson (2003), p.╯14. ╇See, for example, A.╯Sestan, “Le elezioni a Fiume” (The elections at Fiume), Voce nuova 1/21, 11 November 1919; and “Le elette di Fiume” (Women MPs of Fiume), unsigned, Voce nuova 1/21, 11 November 1919. There are few studies of the women’s suffrage in Fiume; on the festive atmosphere of vital energy in the town during the occupation, and on the freedom of morals, which came close to an ante litteram sexual and homosexual revolution, albeit one that involved almost exclusively men, see Salaris (2002). 24 25
66
Emma Schiavon
the MPs should reintroduce the Martini-Gasparotto bill. But due to their political isolation, these pleas from the Voce nuova suffragists had no chance of being heard. Between December 1919 and February 1920 only four more issues of Voce nuova were published, and the two editors were not afraid to analyse, in their usual clear-headed way, the impasse and the loneliness to which their political project had brought them. In the following years, due to the country’s descent into political conflict and trade union struggles and due to the subsequent explosion of Fascist violence, women’s civil rights, already previously labelled by politicians as a “secondary issue”, were easily forgotten. Moreover, the advent of Fascism in October 1922 meant the transformation of the widespread anti-women prejudice into a consistent government policy and cultural discourse. In summary, the end of the suffrage campaign of 1919 marked the ultimate defeat of the Italian feminists’ “interventionist strategy”. Bibliography Babini, V. P. (2000) Un altro genere. La costruzione scientifica della ‘natura femminile’, in Nel nome della razza. Il razzismo nella storia d’Italia, ed. A.╯Burgio (Bologna: 2000) 475–89. Bard, C. (1995) Les filles de Marianne. Histoire des féminismes 1914-1940 (Paris: 1995). Bock, G. and Thane P. eds. (1991) Maternity and Gender Policies: Women and the Rise of the European Welfare State (London: 1991). Burgio, A. ed. (2000) Nel nome della razza. Il razzismo nella storia d’Italia (Bologna: 2000). Buttafuoco, A. (1984) Cronache femminili. Temi e momenti della stampa emancipazionista in Italia dall’Unità al Fascismo (Arezzo: 1984). ———╯ (1997) Questioni di cittadinanza. Donne e diritti sociali nell’Italia liberale (Siena: 1997). Carrozza, G. (1990) Les “Cartons verts” de la BDIC: une photo d’époque (Paris: 1990). Casalini, M. (1998) “‘Sebben che siamo donne….’. Il movimento operaio e la questione delle lavoratrici”, Passato e presente, 45 (1998) 113–34. ———╯(2001) “I socialisti e le donne. Dalla ‘mobilitazione pacifista’ alla smobilitazione postbellica”, Italia contemporanea, 222 (March 2001) 5–41. Corner, P. and Procacci, G., “The Italian experience of ‘total’ mobilisation 1915-1920”, in State, Society and Mobilization in Europe during the First World War, ed. J.╯Horne (Cambridge: 1997) 223–40. Crips, L. (1990) “Une revue national-féministe: Die deutsche Kämpferin, 1933-1937”, in La tentation nazionaliste 1914-1941, ed. R.╯Thalmann (Paris: 1990) 67–182. Curli, B. (1998) Italiane al lavoro, 1914-1920 (Venezia: 1998). Elshtain, J. B. (1987) Women and War (New York: 1987). D’Amelia, M. (2005) La mamma (Bologna: 2005). De Grazia, V. (1992) How Fascism Ruled Women: Italy, 1920-1940 (Berkeley and Los Angeles: 1992).
The women’s suffrage campaign in Italy in 1919
67
Fell, A. S. and Sharp, I. eds. (2007) The Women’s Movement in Wartime: International Perspectives, 1914-1919 (Basingstoke: 2007). Fiorino, V. (1994) “Il voto familiare tra suffragismo e crisi del parlamentarismo nella Francia di fine Ottocento e primo Novecento”, in Laboratorio di Storia. Studi in onore di Claudio Pavone, eds. P.╯Pezzino and G.╯Ranzato (Milan: 1994) 63–80. Gaeta, F. (1981) Il nazionalismo italiano (Rome and Bari: 1981). Higonnet, M. R. et al. eds. (1987) Behind the Lines. Gender and the Two World Wars (New Haven; London: 1987). Horne, J. (1999) “Smobilitazioni culturali dopo la grande guerra 1919-1939”, Italia contemporanea, 215 (1999) 331–9. ———╯ (2002) “Demobilisations culturelle apres la Grande Guerre” in 14–18. Aujourd'hui. Today. Heute, 5 (2002) 45–53. Iveković, R. (1999) Autopsia dei Balcani. Saggio di psico-politica (Milan: 1999); German translation (2001): Autopsie des Balkans. Ein psycho-politische Essay (Graz: 2001). ———╯ (2002) with Mostov, J. eds. From Gender to Nation (Ravenna: 2002). ———╯(2003) Le sexe de la nation (Paris: 2003). Migliucci, D. (2006) Per il voto alle donne. Dieci anni di battaglie suffragiste in Italia (1903-1913) (Milan: 2006). Mosse, G. L. (1982) Nationalism and Sexuality. Respectability and Abnormal Sexuality in Modern Europe (New York: 1982). Nisi Bernocchi, R. (1984) Le scuole di servizio sociale in Italia: aspetti e momenti della loro storia (Padova: 1984). Offen, K. (2000) European Feminisms 1700-1950. A Political History (Stanford: 2000). Pieroni Bortolotti, F. (1972) Socialismo e questione femminile in Italia 1892-1922 (Milan: 1972). Rossi Doria, A. (2000) Antisemitismo e antifemminismo nella cultura positivistica, in Nel nome della razza. Il razzismo nella storia d’Italia, ed. A.╯Burgio (Bologna: 2000) 455–73. Salaris, C. (2002) Alla festa della rivoluzione. Artisti e libertari con D’Annunzio a Fiume (Bologna: 2002). Santomassimo, G. (2006) La terza via fascista. Il mito del corporativismo (Roma: 2006). Schiavon, E. (2001) “L’interventismo femminista”, Passato e presente, 54 (2001) 59–72. ———╯(2004) “Interventismo femminile nella grande guerra. Assistenza e propaganda a Milano e in Italia”, Italia contemporanea 234 (2004) 89–104. ———╯ (2010) (forthcoming) Interventiste nella grande guerra (Milan: 2010). Taricone, F. (1994) Teresa Labriola. Biografia politica di un’intellettuale tra Ottocento e Novecento (Milan: 1994). Tesoro, M. (1992) “La partecipazione italiana all’International Women Suffrage Alliance”, in Salvatore Morelli (1824-1880). Emancipazionismo e democrazia nell’Ottocento europeo, ed. G.╯Conti Odorisio (Naples: 1992) 388–415. Willson, P. (2003) “Italy”, in Women, Gender and Fascism in Europe, 1919-45, ed. K.╯Passmore (Manchester: 2003) 11–32.
68
Emma Schiavon
Raps across the knuckles
69
Raps across the knuckles: The extension of war culture by radical nationalist women journalists in post-1918 Germany Christiane Streubel At the outset of the First World War, the liberal, social democratic and conservative wings of the German women’s movement at first worked together in the National Women’s Service (Nationaler Frauendienst) in order to support the male war effort. A deep conflict arose in 1917, when the socialist women’s movement and the predominantly liberal orientated Federation of German Women’s Associations (Bund Deutscher Frauenvereine or BDF) called for a democratisation of Germany including female suffrage. Conservative and nationalist women’s organisations vigorously rejected this demand in the final two years of the war, arguing together with their male counterparts that enfranchising the “uneducated masses” would ruin the Kaiserreich. As such, female suffrage came only with the revolution, being granted by proclamation of the Council of People’s Commissars on 12 November 1918. In the meantime, the extreme Right held the new Weimar Republic responsible for Germany’s defeat in the war, and did everything in its power to undermine the latter’s legitimacy in the eyes of the German people.
After the proclamation of female suffrage, the nationalist Right in Germany had to change its policy. In its eyes, more than 17 million female first-time voters1 had to be kept from electing democratic and left-wing parties. After decades of propagating the idea of the “apolitical woman”,2 the Right was forced to lure women to the polls in order to remain a strong force under the new political circumstances.3 New female political opinion leaders were needed to explain why women should vote for right-wing parties and join nationalist organisations.4 In this article I will explore the role of radical nationalist women journalists in rebuilding the nation after defeat and in contesting Germany’s 1 ╇ Cf. Die Wahlen zur verfassunggebenden Deutschen Nationalversammlung am 19. Januar 1919, bearbeitet im Statistischen Reichsamt, Berlin 1919, pp.╯24–5. 2 ╇ Planert (1998), esp. pp.╯224–40; Heinsohn (2000); Stibbe (2002). 3 ╇Scheck (2004), esp. pp.╯23–47; Woodfin (2004); Sneeringer (2007). 4 ╇ Wolfram Pyta has recently stressed the relevance of political opinion leaders in the political culture of Weimar Germany – see Pyta (2008), pp.╯88–9.
70
Christiane Streubel
redrawn national boundaries by analysing two important and widely read right-wing newspapers, the Deutsche Zeitung and Der Tag. My article focuses on two central questions: Firstly, how were gender relations renegotiated in the context of some of the unresolved conflicts of the post-war period? I will describe how female suffrage generated a new group of right-wing female opinion leaders who seized the chance to present women as part of the nationalist political milieu and as equal comrades in arms in the political conflicts of the day. Secondly, I ask if we can identify cultural remobilisation in the actions of female radical nationalists, in line with the use of that concept by John Horne.5 As we shall see, the female journalists analysed here joined their male counterparts in sustaining a culture of war. They portrayed the German population as victims of the Versailles order, helped to identify those whom the anti-republican Right considered to be the worst enemies of the German nation, and took part in proclaiming a special kind of heroism which would convert defeat into victory. I will show that these two phenomena – the renegotiation of gender relations and the practice of cultural remobilisation in Germany by radical nationalist forces –were closely interconnected; both were dependent on each other. The German Right and its radical-nationalist female wing The years from 1918 to 1923 were a period of radicalisation for the German Right, framed by events such as the foundation of the German National People’s Party (Deutschnationale Volkspartei or DNVP) with its radical völkisch wing in December 1918; by the Kapp Putsch of March 1920; and by Hitler’s attempted overthrow of the Bavarian government in November 1923. In the first years after the war, new radical nationalist organisations were set up to the right of the DNVP, not only the Nazi party or NSDAP, but others too, including the Steel Helmet, League of Frontline Soldiers (Stahlhelm, Bund der FrontÂ� soldaten), the Anti-Bolshevik League (Antibolschewistische Liga), the conservative-revolutionary June Club (Juni-Klub), the radical antiSemitic German Völkisch Defence and Defiance League (DeutschVölkischer Schutz- und Trutzbund), and the looser groups of Freikorps, paramilitaries hostile to communism and the Weimar Republic. In the 5
╇See Horne (2005), pp.╯131–2.
Raps across the knuckles
71
years from 1919 to 1923, the German Right was shaken by a permanent conflict between this radical wing and more moderate groups. Formed out of different right-wing parties of the Kaiserreich, the membership of the DNVP itself ranged from conservative aristocratic landowners, hoping for the return of the Hohenzollern monarchy, to völkisch anti-Semites, who called for the establishment of a dictatorship under a new charismatic leader. Furthermore, some members wanted to change the democratic system from within by participating in governments and forming alliances with other Reichstag groupings, while others noisily demanded radical opposition and refused all coopeÂ�ration with republican parties and institutions.6 In 1920, a female counterpart of the radical nationalist organisations came into being, the Ring of National Women (Ring Nationaler Frauen), which incorporated 200,000 members.7 The Ring of National Women was on the one hand part of the more general anti-Versailles agitation, and on the other hand an opportunity for right-wing women to join a “genuinely nationalist” women’s movement serving as an alternative to the established, more liberal-orientated BDF.╯With the granting of female suffrage in November 1918, the Ring was able to gain remarkable influence in radical nationalist circles. Not only was it considered to be the most effective opponent of the BDF in the postwar period, but also the Ring’s representatives became the new female opinion leaders in the periodicals of the German Right. In two leading newspapers, the Deutsche Zeitung, organ of the radical right-wing Pan-German League (Alldeutscher Verband), and Der Tag, which appealed to a more intellectual readership,8 a new type of female journalist was recruited between 1919 and 1923. In Imperial Germany before the war, anti-feminists had dominated the radical nationalist milieu with their ideal of the “apolitical woman”. After the war, the male and female anti-feminists were gradually replaced by a new generation of editors and freelancers who advocated women’s political participation.9 Remarkably, some representatives of the Ring of National Women, through their journalism, became political commentators on the ╇ Hiller von Gaertringen (1996); Schildt (1998), pp.╯131–81. ╇ Another very successful new women’s foundation was the Queen Luise Alliance (Bund Königin Luise), founded in 1923. Cf. Schöck-Quinteros (2007). 8 ╇ Liebe (1956), pp.╯45 and 47. 9 ╇ For a detailed analysis of the Ring of National Women see Streubel (2006a), esp.╯pp.╯116–22, 137–53 and 199–256. 6 7
72
Christiane Streubel
nation’s general problems, discussing matters usually reserved for men. Käthe Schirmacher, Martha Voß-Zietz, Pia Sophie Rogge, and Lenore Kühn were encouraged to write leading articles for the front pages of the Deutsche Zeitung and Der Tag, dealing with topics like loyalty to the fatherland, the meaning of “German honour”, the preservation of Prussia, the demand for a return of Upper Silesia and Danzig to the German Reich, the new coalition governments after 1918/19, and the Treaty of Versailles. All of these authors were activists in the Ring of National Women. The female authors mentioned above did not emerge from total obscurity after World War I.10 Käthe Schirmacher, who held a Ph.D in Romance studies, had first risen to national prominence as an activist of the left-liberal female suffrage movement in the 1890s before she went over to the radical right völkisch movement of the German Empire at the turn of the century. She became a very active representative of the German Eastern Marches Association (Deutscher OstÂ�marÂ� kenverein), an organisation which favoured aggressive policies of Germanisation in those parts of Prussia where Poles formed a large part of the population. In 1919, Schirmacher was elected as a DNVP member of the Weimar National Assembly. Born in Danzig, she represented the electoral district of Danzig-West Prussia. Martha Voß-Zietz, who had supported Schirmacher in her campaign for female suffrage in the 1890s and was a co-founder of the German housewives movement in the Kaiserreich, underwent a similar political metamorphosis. In World War I, Voß-Zietz became a leading member of the German Fatherland Party (Deutsche VaterÂ� landspartei), founded in September 1917. The Fatherland Party was a strong pressure group for a “victorious peace” (the so-called Siegfrieden or “Hindenburg peace”). It condemned the Reichstag Peace Resolution which had called for a negotiated end to the war, and instead demanded a fight to the finish and large-scale annexations, especially in the East. It also agitated against a democratisation of the German Empire. After the war, Voß-Zietz joined the newly-founded German Völkisch Defence and Defiance League which declared the “fight against Jewry” to be its primary goal. Pia Sophie Rogge was an author and poet in Imperial Germany. After the revolution, she became a leading member of the DNVP in ╇ For biographical information on the female journalists mentioned in this chapter see Streubel (2006a), pp.╯92–9 and 122–33; and Streubel (2007). 10
Raps across the knuckles
73
Schleswig-Holstein and ran for a seat in the Reichstag in 1920. In 1923, she joined the German Völkisch Freedom Party (Deutsch-Völkische Freiheitspartei), a new anti-Semitic political party founded in DecemÂ� ber 1922 when radical right-wing politicians broke away from the DNVP. Lenore Kühn, who held a Ph.D in philosophy, supported her husband in editing a Pan-German political journal during the war. In 1917, she was co-founder of the German Philosophical Society, which put itself forward as an anti-Jewish alternative to the older and betterknown Kant Society. After the war, she became Käthe Schirmacher’s campaign aide in Danzig. Upon returning to Berlin, Lenore Kühn was chosen as editor of the DNVP’s official newssheet for women. These women were not only invited to publish in male-dominated newspapers, but they were also important figures in the right-wing women’s press.11 Therefore, they can be identified as political opinion leaders who exerted influence on the cultural attitudes and perceptions of their epoch. Election campaigns and strict education for male weaklings The right-wing women discussed above were fundamental opponents of democracy and the Versailles order after 1919. In the eyes of the male leadership of the DNVP their activities as writers and journalists for the right-wing press were of great value. This was first and foremost because Schirmacher, Voß-Zietz, Rogge and Kühn, among others, were expected to mobilise newly-enfranchised female voters for the radical nationalist cause. Throughout the Weimar period, the number of articles by female authors appearing in mainstream national newspapers indeed increased noticeably when Reichstag elections were approaching.12 Secondly, the female journalists were welcomed as unforgiving and uncompromising critics of the BDF.╯Although female radical nationalists did not share the anti-feminism of many of the male leaders of the German Right, and believed that women should play a role in national politics, they nonetheless attacked the traditional German women’s movement as democratic and internationally orientated, thereby branding them as traitors to their country and as “anti-Germans”. The male leaders of the radical Right may have hoped 11 12
╇Streubel (2006a), pp.╯153–74 and 177–81. ╇ Ibid., pp.╯200–6, 209–10, 220, 227 and 239–40.
74
Christiane Streubel
that this criticism would be read as a condemnation of the women’s movement as a whole.13 But how can we explain the fact that the female journalists were also encouraged to write leading articles for right-wing newspapers that were directed beyond a narrow female readership to the public in general? For example, through leading articles on the front page of daily papers like the Deutsche Zeitung and Der Tag, they were able to define who ranked among the “real Germans” and who did not, why the German people should become “national”, and which political actions of men should be judged as honourable or cowardly. In addition, they established themselves as commentators on foreign affairs, and especially the disputed new borders of the Weimar Republic in East and West.14 This was in marked contrast to the idea of the “apolitical” woman, vigorously promoted by the political Right in Imperial Germany and continued by anti-feminists in the Weimar Republic.15 In May 1921, a male author, Franz Wugk, published an article in the German-national paper Der Tag under the title “Thoughts about a German Jeanne-d’Arc”. He claimed: [B]ecause there is no man to be found to evict the French, the English, the Poles [in the original source he used the pejorative term Polacken], the Belgians, the Danish, the Italians from Germany, we do have to hope for a female messiah after all…; a female Teuton [Germanin] of TaciÂ�Â�tus… And above all, she must have faith in the German future; faith that moves mountains and closes abysses. The faith that is almost too difficult to preserve in these days of hell. When will you come, German Jeanne d’Arc?16
This quote provides a clue as to how to interpret the post-war interest in female journalists who commented on questions of national inter╇ Ibid., pp.╯245–56. ╇See e.g. K.╯Schirmacher, “‘Deutsche’” (Germans), Deutsche Zeitung, 17 June 1921 (leading article); K.╯Schirmacher, “Warum müssen wir national sein?” (Why must we be national?), Deutsche Zeitung, 31 January 1920; M.╯Voß-Zietz, “Deutscher Ehrbegriff” (The German concept of honour), Deutsche Zeitung, 5 September 1922 (leading article); M.╯Voß-Zietz, “Was ist Feigheit?” (What is cowardice?), Deutsche Zeitung, 26 May 1920; K.╯Schirmacher, “Der annektierten Ostmark Verzweiflung” (The despair of the annexed Ostmark), Deutsche Zeitung, 7 September 1920 (leading article); K.╯Schirmacher, “Ostmark für Westmark” (Ostmark for Westmark), Der Tag, 17 April 1921 (women’s supplement); B.╯Prilipp, “Frauen des Rheinlandes” (Women of the Rhineland), Der Tag, 5 June 1921 (women’s supplement). 15 ╇ Planert (1998), pp.╯241–5; Hering (2003), pp.╯380–96. 16 ╇ F.╯Wugk, “Deutsche Jeanne-d’Arc-Gedanken” (Thoughts about a German Jeanne-d’Arc), Der Tag, 11 May 1921 (morning edition). Emphasis in the original. 13 14
Raps across the knuckles
75
est, including foreign affairs. Against the background of the deepseated conflict within the DNVP between the moderate and the radical wing mentioned above, the so-called “national opposition”17 invented the idea of a “male crisis” in Germany. The loss of the war and the current weakness of the new German democracy in the concert of world powers seemed to demonstrate the lack of “true men” since the late Kaiserreich. In particular the new democratic leaders, the so-called “November criminals”, were wrongly blamed for causing the German army’s defeat through the revolution and were attacked as “unmanly” cowards who were unable to defend the nation against “impertinent behaviour” by foreign countries. At the same time, the moderate members of the DNVP could be pressurised into aligning themselves with the more radical, uncompromising line in order to avoid being labelled “unmanly” themselves.18 This strategy would be even more effective if selected women could be presented who demonstrated all these alleged “manly” qualities in contrast to the faint-hearted men. In other words, the brutal, intransigent language of the female journalists showed moderate representatives of the German Right in an unfavourable light. It made them appear weak and cowardly, incapable of acting in the interests of the nation. What they needed was a “rap across the knuckles”, hand-delivered by strict female educators. The female journalists were crucial to spur on tough manliness. Using titles like “So far and no further” or “We are calling you!”, writers like Pia Sophie Rogge and Martha VoßZietz pointed true men in the right direction, acting like Tacitus’s female Teutons.19 An analysis of the articles written by right-wing female journalists reveals a number of recurring arguments. One year after the German revolution, Pia Sophie Rogge reviewed the events in an article for the Deutsche Zeitung and identified a lack of manliness as the main cause of the revolution’s outbreak and the loss of the war. She argued:
17 ╇ Cf. as a contemporary comment on the term “national opposition”: W. [= R.╯Wulle], “Die nationale Opposition” (The National Opposition), Deutsche Zeitung (leading article), 3 October 1919. 18 ╇ Claß (1920), p.╯49–53; Boehm (1920), p.╯8. Cf. Rohkrämer (2007), p.╯147. 19 ╇ P. S.╯Rogge, “Bis hierher und nicht weiter” (So far and no further), Deutsche Zeitung, 23 October 1920; C.╯Hoch [= P. S.╯Rogge], “Wir rufen euch!” (We are calling you!), Deutsche Zeitung, 16 July 1919; M.╯Voß-Zietz, “Ein mahnendes Bismarckwort” (Words of warning from Bismarck), Deutsche Zeitung, 26 June 1920 (leading article).
76
Christiane Streubel Personal courage that differentiated the man of Teutonic descent from the other races of Europe, this sense of being master [Herrensinn] that knocks down each impertinent rascal who offends him – it was not there anymore!
Rogge worried that those men who “were laid to rest on alien ground” were “our last heroes”.20 Even the German princes were not safe from female criticism because they did not stand up for the German Emperor after it became known that the Treaty of Versailles included a paragraph about putting Wilhelm II on trial in an international court of justice.21 Rogge, who was married to a naval officer, defended only officers of the former Imperial army against criticism, “shining material, bred to duty and honour”.22 This defence of the German army leaders was crucial because it strengthened the right-wing “stab-inthe-back legend” (Dolchstoßlegende) and shielded the officers from blame for the defeat.23 At the same time Voß-Zietz, Rogge and Schirmacher ignored an anti-feminist version of the stab-in-the-back legend which blamed women for the defeat. Wives and mothers were accused of writing defeatist letters to soldiers on the front line, begging them to lay down their arms.24 In response, the new female political commentators blamed the majority of the male population for being cowardly traitors, i.e. all men except officers, civil servants and “real leaders”. Pia Sophie Rogge wrote in 1919: “Yes, you cowards, who played soldiers in the Kaiser’s or King’s coat… you treacherously stabbed the army to death!”.25 These female journalists contributed to the hard-line anti-democratic policy of the national opposition. Lenore Kühn equated Germany after the revolution with “voluntary self-emasculation”.26 A search for true manliness in the new democratic government would ╇ P. S.╯Rogge, “Das Leben ist der Güter höchstes nicht. Gedanken zur Jahreswende des Revolutionsmonats” (Life is not the most important thing. Thoughts on the first anniversary of the revolutionary month), Deutsche Zeitung, 21 November 1919. 21 ╇ Hoch [= Rogge], “Wir rufen euch!” (as note 19 above). 22 ╇ P. S.╯Rogge, “In Helm und Schild geboren” (Born in a helmet and shield), Deutsche Zeitung, 3 May 1920. 23 ╇Barth (2003), p.╯149; Cramer (2006), p.╯297. 24 ╇ For contemporary judgements on women at war see Sharp (2001); Daniel (2002); Davis (1996); Davis (2000). 25 ╇ C.╯Hoch [= P. S.╯Rogge], “Das Volk der Treue” (The nation of loyalty), Deutsche Zeitung, 13 April 1919 (women’s supplement). 26 ╇ L.╯Ripke-Kühn, “Finis Livoniae”, Deutsche Zeitung, 28 May 1919 (supplement to “Das junge Deutschland”). 20
Raps across the knuckles
77
be futile, claimed the like-minded Pia Sophie Rogge.27 The democratic government acted only for fear of the men on the street, writing a stream of whiny, useless notes to the former enemy powers.28 Martha Voß-Zietz advised each woman to open Tacitus’s “Germania” and to read how the ancient female Teutons had pushed the exhausted men back towards the enemy. Women had a God-given duty to fight cowardice, she explained to the readers of the Deutsche Zeitung.29 In addition, nationalist women like Voß-Zietz urged intransigence, radical action and ruthlessness. They even criticised male politicians on the Right who were considered to be too weak and faint-hearted for the present tasks. By claiming this, the female journalists supported the extreme völkisch wing of the DNVP against the moderate wing, accusing the moderates of being too soft and conciliatory towards the political Left. Their choice of words left no room for compromise. They demanded “sharp cuts”, “cold hearts”, and “readiness to die” for honour and for one’s beliefs.30 The struggle against the redrawn national boundaries The First World War did not end with the Treaty of Versailles. This becomes even more evident when we look at the contribution made by right-wing female journalists to debates over foreign affairs. Käthe Schirmacher and Lenore Kühn in particular were allowed to publish leading articles on these pressing issues. The Treaty of Versailles had defined new boundaries for the German Empire, but some of the borders were not fixed until the early 1920s. The female journalists were particularly involved in shaping public awareness of four contested territories. The dispute over Upper Silesia led to military conflict between Polish irregulars and the German Freikorps. After a referendum, the allied powers decreed the territory’s division in 1921. A second topic was the situation of the German port city of Danzig, before the war the capital of West Prussia, and after the war a part of the newly-founded Polish state. The dispute about Danzig – which ╇Rogge, “Das Leben ist der Güter höchstes nicht” (as note 20 above). ╇Rogge, “Bis hierher und nicht weiter” (as note 19 above). 29 ╇ Voß-Zietz, “Was ist Feigheit?” (as note 14 above). 30 ╇ Voß-Zietz, “Deutscher Ehrbegriff” (as note 14 above); K.╯Schirmacher, “Wir bauen auf!” (We are rebuilding!), Deutsche Zeitung, 30 October 1923 (leading article); K.╯Schirmacher,“Der Freistaat Danzig” (The Free City of Danzig), Deutsche Zeitung, 27 November 1920 (leading article). 27 28
78
Christiane Streubel
revolved around whether it should stay German or become a Polish city – was decided by re-designating it as a free city under League of Nations administration in 1920. The third topic was the fate of the socalled Baltic Germans, people of ethnic German origin living in Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia, who lost their predominant social position bit by bit after the Baltic states had gained their independence in 1918/19. The German landed class was dispossessed, especially in Latvia and Estonia. The last dispute was the international crisis over reparations which began in January 1923. When Germany fell behind in its payments, French and Belgian troops occupied the heavily industrialised Ruhr district. The German government encouraged the population of the Ruhr to engage in passive resistance and financed a general strike in the area. The Ruhr struggle exceeded the Republic’s capacities, exacerbated the hyperinflation crisis, and had to be aborted in September 1923. John Horne and others have identified these disputed border areas as sites of permanent cultural and political mobilisation, which kept alive the war’s language and its function as a role model.31 Women like Käthe Schirmacher and Lenore Kühn were part of this remobilisation as agitators in civil society. Schirmacher became famous in right-wing circles as one of the leaders of the so-called “National Defence” which mobilised the German citizens of Danzig against the city’s handover to Poland. Lenore Kühn was considered as an expert on the situation in Latvia because she was born and grew up in its capital Riga.32 Both were chosen to report about the situation of the German population in these regions which they described as “unbearable”.33 The female journalists’ line of reasoning, again, left no room for doubt about how to judge these conflicts. Every decision in this dispute was seen as a secret conspiracy of Germany’s enemies which included the victorious powers, the Polish population, Bolshevik Russia and – as domestic enemies – every Democrat, Social Democrat, and Communist as well as every Jew in Germany. Finally, any German 31 ╇ Horne (2005), p.╯150; Gusy (2008), pp.╯23–4. For the gendered dimension of the Ruhr crisis see Koller (2002). 32 ╇Streubel (2006a), p.╯122; Streubel (2007), pp.╯11–4 and 33. 33 ╇K.╯Schirmacher, “Fahrt nach Danzig” (Journey to Danzig), Der Tag, 18 June 1921 (morning edition, leading article); K.╯Schirmacher, “Nun ist es aber Zeit” (It’s about time), Deutsche Zeitung, 14 September 1923; Ripke-Kühn, “Finis Livoniae” (as note 26 above); L.╯Ripke-Kühn, “Bolschewismus in Riga” (Bolshevism in Riga), Deutsche Zeitung, 26 July 1919.
Raps across the knuckles
79
who refused to fight against this imagined world of enemies was condemned as not belonging to the German people either.34 The female journalists prolonged the “ideas of 1914” into the post-war era. These ideas were developed during the war by leading German intellectuals who used the “miracle” of national unity in 1914 as their principle argument. An integral part of these “ideas” was the claim that German cultural superiority justified military aggression in Belgium and elsewhere, vividly condensed in the credo “The German spirit shall cure the world” (“Am deutschen Wesen soll die Welt genesen”). Europe had to be saved from a degenerate, materialistic individualism. The twentieth century could become the century of the Germans. The extreme Right added far-reaching expansionist war aims to the “spirit of 1914”.35 As an alternative political order to the constitutional monarchy they propagated the “absolutist state within the organic racial community of the Volk”, as Jeffrey Verhey observes.36 The female journalists shared these views. They saw the Germans as ideal educators of inferior peoples who could only be lifted to a higher cultural level by accepting German supremacy.37 This message was also directed to the German population in the contested border areas, where it found a warm reception.38 Moreover, these female agitators created in their articles an apocalyptic image of the post-war Weimar Republic as a slave state living at the mercy of hate-filled enemies who longed for Germany’s total destruction. During the Ruhr struggle, Käthe Schirmacher published a leading article under the title “The Clump” (Der Klumpen), a splatter film like description of the rotting corpse of a German citizen, cut up 34 ╇K.╯Schirmacher, “Für Preußen” (For Prussia), Deutsche Zeitung, 26 March 1919 (leading article); Schirmacher, “Warum müssen wir national sein?” (as note 14 above); Schirmacher, “‘Deutsche’” (as note 14 above). 35 ╇Rohkrämer (2007), pp.╯124, 127 and 136; Mommsen (2000), pp.╯178–81. For a detailed analysis see also Verhey (2000); and Bruendel (2003). 36 ╇ Verhey (2000), p.╯156. 37 ╇K.╯Schirmacher, “Balten und Deutsche” (Balts and Germans), Deutsche Zeitung, 4 May 1919 (leading article); Ripke-Kühn, “Finis Livoniae” (as note 26 above); K.╯Schirmacher, “Gegen die deutsch-polnischen Verhandlungen” (Against the German-Polish negotiations), Deutsche Zeitung, 7 August 1919; K.╯Schirmacher,“Gedenket der Not an unseren Grenzen!” (Remember the distress on our borders!), Der Tag, 20 April 1921 (leading article); K.╯Schirmacher, “Verbissene Würde” (Dogged dignity), Der Tag, 22 May 1923 (leading article). 38 ╇See the positive comment of a male journalist on Schirmacher’s work, in A.╯Zimmermann, “Die Deutschnationalen in Weimar” (The German nationals in Weimar), Deutsche Zeitung, 19 March 1919 (leading article).
80
Christiane Streubel
by the French enemy like garbage.39 The female authors constructed feelings that the end of the world was near, thereby legitimising the most brutal reactions in what was billed as a final struggle for existence. Martha Voß-Zietz declared: “Struggle means life and resurrection from this völkisch misery”.40 Käthe Schirmacher indirectly proposed the hostage-taking of the Polish part of the German population and their mistreatment to enforce the revision of the eastern border. In the conflict with Poland, she demanded the continuation of war: “Do we have weapons only to let them rust?”. The execution of pacifists in wartime was propagated as a good strategy, as was the use of unrestricted submarine warfare and the invention of poison gas.41 Revenge was the only possible response towards the former war enemies. Käthe Schirmacher let the readers of the Deutsche Zeitung participate in one of the racist nightmares she had dreamt during the Ruhr struggle: There were grimaces gushing, crawling, climbing from under my bed, half-black paunches, coffee-brown apes, pale yellow dwarfs – the RheinRuhr brood of the night: the future German citizen! I strangle them in mad rage as it becomes day and light.42
The present hateful conditions had to be destroyed to make way for an entirely new world order. The female authors showed a longing for total solutions. They rejected all opportunities for piecemeal revision and reconciliation, now and in the long run. The League of Nations was seen as a “hypocritical disguise for our deadly foe”.43 With their statements on foreign policy, the female radical nationalists perpetuated the war and contributed to cultural remobilisation. Andreas Wirsching has recently focused attention on the dangerous impact of a propaganda that appeals to emotionally disturbed societies trying to put the clock back to an imagined “golden past”, or seeking refuge in
39 ╇K.╯Schirmacher, “Der Klumpen” (The Clump), Der Tag, 26 July 1923 (front page). 40 ╇ Voß-Zietz, “Was ist Feigheit?” (as note 14 above). 41 ╇K.╯Schirmacher,“Endlich!” (At last!), Deutsche Zeitung, 26 August 1920 (leading article); K.╯Schirmacher, “Artikel 227–230” (Articles 227–230), Der Tag, 12 July 1919; K.╯Schirmacher, “Allen Gewalten zum Trotz sich erhalten” (Despite all the powers closing in, hold yourself up), Deutsche Zeitung, 11 July 1923 (leading article). 42 ╇K.╯Schirmacher, “Volk in Schmach” (Nation in shame), Deutsche Zeitung, 10 October 1923 (features supplement). 43 ╇K.╯Schirmacher, “Der Freistaat Danzig” (as note 30 above).
Raps across the knuckles
81
the escapist mentality of “all or nothing”.44 This was exactly the kind of propaganda being pursued here. Agitation against international reconciliation In addition to agitation against the new borders, the female journalists made a crucial contribution to hindering each attempt at cultural demobilisation by the German women’s movement and its most important representative, the BDF.╯In 1920, Marianne Weber, the chairwoman of the BDF, recommended the other board members to postpone the resumption of relations with the international women’s movement. The newly-founded Ring of National Women, she argued, would take advantage of this situation by accusing the Federation of betraying German interests. Worse still, this propaganda might even lead to the secession of the BDF’s right-wing members.45 The most radical criticism against the BDF in 1920 came from Pia Sophie Rogge reporting from a conference of the International Women’s Suffrage Alliance (IWSA) in Geneva. It was published as a leading article in the Deutsche Zeitung. The performance of the German representatives was described as “doglike bootlicking”. With dramatising pathos, Rogge asked the fallen German soldiers for forgiveness, whose graves had been abased by these “rootless, homeless, mollusc-like wretches”.46 Another author alleged that BDF members were only interested in the buffets of international women’s conferences and not in Germany, where women were raped and men butchered. Female radical nationalists claimed after the Reichstag elections of June 1920 that the BDF’s leaders were no longer the true representatives of German women because the DNVP had won more votes than the German Democratic Party (Deutsche Demokratische Partei or DDP), the party most clearly associated with the mainstream women’s movement.47 Under the title “National Spirit Abroad” an╇ Wirsching (2008), pp.╯385–6. ╇ Landesarchiv Berlin, B Rep 235 MF, Bl. 2347, letter from Weber to the Narrower Board (Engerer Vorstand), 15 March 1920. 46 ╇ P. S.╯Rogge,“Genf” (Geneva), Deutsche Zeitung, 24 August 1920 (leading article). 47 ╇ M.╯Diers, “Frauenbewegung und Stimmenzahl” (The women’s movement and the number of votes), Deutsche Zeitung, 26 July 1920 (women’s supplement); M.╯Diers, “Eine Auseinandersetzung mit einer ehrlichen Demokratie” (An altercation with a genuine democracy), Deutsche Zeitung, 2 August 1920. 44 45
82
Christiane Streubel
other female author wrote a leading article for the Deutsche Zeitung in 1923 demanding that Germany should send alternative female representatives to these international meetings, women who were not content simply to be servants of the Allies.48 The criticism continued throughout the period of the Weimar Republic. In 1927, the leaders of the BDF, under the pressure of the Ring of National Women, felt obliged to send some of their right-wing members to the editor of the newspaper Der Tag to ask him for a more favourable coverage of their organisation’s activities. Their mission failed.49 Implicit ideas of female leadership Referring again to the question of the renegotiation of gender roles, Rogge, Schirmacher, Kühn and Voß-Zietz tried to present themselves as part of the new and upcoming political elite. In other press organs addressed to a female readership, especially in the richly illustrated women’s magazine The German Woman (Die Deutsche Frau), they invented the myth of outstanding female “personalities” who were not only able to lead nationalist women’s organisations like the Ring of National Women, but the German people as a whole.50 Their most important justification for this idea was that women had suffered and achieved as much as male soldiers in the First World War. They did their duty on the home front, claimed the female radical nationalists.51 Members of the Ring of National Women tried to establish myths about their own charismatic leaders. For instance, Käthe Schirmacher was presented as a “German female fighter”.52 After the death of Schirmacher in 1930, female supporters symbolically selected her as 48 ╇B.╯Prilipp, “Der Friedensgedanke und die Frauen” (The idea of peace and women), Der Tag, 9 August 1921 (morning edition, leading article); I.╯Hamel, “Nationaler Geist ins Ausland!” (National spirit abroad!), Deutsche Zeitung, 5 July 1923 (leadÂ�ing article). 49 ╇ Landesarchiv Berlin, B Rep 235 MF, Bl. 2503, letter from Margarete von Keyserlingk, 11 November 1927; ibid., Bl. 2503, letter from Keyserlingk to Emma Ender, December 1927; ibid., Bl. 2494, letter from Ender to Käthe Herwarth, 6 August 1928. 50 ╇Streubel (2006a), pp.╯295–302. 51 ╇ L.╯Broecker, “Das Staatsbewußtsein der Frau (Teil 1)” (Women’s conception of the state (part 1)), Die Deutsche Frau, 18 (1925), 15 April 1925, p.╯146; P. S.╯Rogge, “Die Freiheitsbewegung der deutschen Frau” (The German women’s freedom movement), Die Deutsche Frau, 19 (1926), 15 February 1926, pp.╯62–3. 52 ╇S.╯Philipps, “Dr. Käthe Schirmacher”, Die Deutsche Frau, 18 (1925), 1 August 1925, p.╯282; E.╯Spohr,“Dr. Käthe Schirmacher”, Die Deutsche Frau, 21 (1928), 1 February 1928, pp.╯61–2.
Raps across the knuckles
83
successor to the Prussian Queen Luise, who had led German resistance against French occupation during the Napoleonic wars.53 In the male-dominated press like the Deutsche Zeitung or Der Tag, the female radical nationalists did not characterise themselves explicitly as “female leaders” but their mode of language designated them as such. Their anti-democratic ideals led them to demand strict guidance of the people by a small elite. The journalists disparaged the idea of the sovereignty of the people by declaring that the protests, demonstrations, strikes and naval mutinies which sparked off the November revolution were actions of a “wretched horde” and “howling pack”.54 In the world view of these female authors, most of the German people were children misled by internal and external enemies of Germany.55 Due to the supposed eternal characteristics of this tribe, only a few Germans were politically gifted or born leaders.56 By explaining to the male and female readers of the Deutsche Zeitung and Der Tag which was the best path to follow, they presented themselves implicitly as part of the new elite. The solutions they offered were stark and bold: recovering from 1918 meant becoming nationalistic to preserve the German people, venturing one’s life to save German honour, believing with unflinching courage in Germany’s power, and convincing each individual German that foreign spirit had to be exorcised.57 Their manner of speaking and writing was extremely self-confident. Pia Sophie Rogge felt free to criticise respected occupational groups like civil servants, jurists, teachers and even state ministers as “weaklings”. She claimed that she was able “to bring truth to the light of the sun” on how to treat the “Jewish question”.58 Martha Voß-Zietz presented 53 ╇ I.╯Hamel, “Zwei Kämpferinnen für Deutschlands Freiheit” (Two women fighters for German freedom), Deutsche Zeitung, 15 March 1931 (women’s supplement). Cf. “Dr. Käthe Schirmacher †”, Deutsche Zeitung, 19 November 1930; I.╯Hamel, “Der Kämpferin für Deutschlands Ehre. Dr. Käthe Schirmacher zum Gedenken” (To a fighter for Germany’s honour. In memory of Dr. Käthe Schirmacher), Deutsche Â�Zeitung, 20 November 1930. 54 ╇ Hoch [= Rogge], “Wir rufen euch!” (as note 19 above); Rogge, “In Helm und Schild geboren” (as note 22 above). 55 ╇ Voß-Zietz, “Was ist Feigheit?” (as note 14 above). 56 ╇Schirmacher, “Warum müssen wir national sein?” (as note 14 above); M.╯VoßZietz, “In der Führung liegt das Heil” (Salvation lies in leadership), Der Tag, 12 February 1922 (women’s supplement). 57 ╇Schirmacher, “‘Deutsche’” (as note 14 above); Voß-Zietz, “Deutscher Ehrbegriff” (as note 14 above); P. S.╯Rogge,“Jahresabschied” (Before the year is out), Â�DeutÂ�sche Zeitung, 1 January 1921. 58 ╇Rogge, “Das Leben ist der Güter höchstes nicht” (as note 20 above); P. S.╯Rogge, “Judenhetze” (Jew-baiting), Deutsche Zeitung, 17 October 1919 (leading article).
84
Christiane Streubel
herself as an expert on the labouring classes and praised them for their “German concept of honour”.59 Lenore Kühn sharply criticised the Germans’ attitude towards their ethnic comrades in the Baltic countries. She made use of her historical knowledge to present the GermanBaltic people as the “most faithful Germans”. These former “Knights of the Order” would look with horror at the “cowardly” new Germany.60 Käthe Schirmacher declared that because the German people did not comprehend the relevance of articles 227 to 230 of the Treaty of Versailles, she would clear things up for the readers of Der Tag.61 In other articles, she emphasised that she had proven on several occasions that she knew a great deal more about the situation in Danzig and Upper Silesia than many right-wing comrades-in-arms.62 The female journalists claimed that they too were exponents of the true will of the German people. In demanding Germany’s return to alleged lost virtues like honour, loyalty, and pride, the female agitators appointed themselves as arbiters of the true meaning of these extremely emotional concepts, a role previously reserved for men. The conviction that women as well as men could help to define these virtues emerged during the First World War, when the totalisation of war created new concepts like “economic warfare” (Wirtschaftskrieg) and “home front” (Heimatfront).63 Female suffrage also increased the self-confidence of female agitators after 1918 and signalled their rising political influence in the new republican state.64 Looking at the arguments developed in the leading articles written by these female journalists it is striking that most of the authors did not present themselves as female authors who argued from a specifically womanly or maternalist perspective. Instead they used the typical languages of (male) leadership which Thomas Mergel has identified in ╇ M.╯Voß-Zietz, “Deutscher Ehrbegriff” (as note 14 above). ╇Ripke-Kühn, “Finis Livoniae” (as note 26 above). 61 ╇Schirmacher, “Artikel 227–230” (as note 41 above) Horne identifies the controversy over articles 227–230 as a crucial driving force behind the remobilisation of German war culture. See Horne (2005), pp.╯136–7. 62 ╇Schirmacher, “Wir bauen auf!” (as note 30 above); K.╯Schirmacher, “Tatsachen über Oberschlesien” (The truth about Upper Silesia), Deutsche Zeitung, 29 October 1920 (leading article); K.╯Schirmacher, “Der 10. Januar für Danzig” (The 10 January for Danzig), Der Tag, 10 January 1922 (morning edition, leading article). 63 ╇Davis (1996); Daniel (2002). 64 ╇ Hoch [= Rogge], “Das Volk der Treue” (as note 25 above); M.╯Voß-Zietz, “Deutscher Ehrbegriff” (as note 14 above). For gender-oriented conceptual historical studies on terms like Ehre and Treue see, for example, Frevert (2007); and Streubel (2008). 59 60
Raps across the knuckles
85
his study on the culture of parliament and parliamentary speeches in the Weimar Republic.65 When they wrote for the general public in newspapers like the Deutsche Zeitung and Der Tag in the years between 1919 and 1923, Schirmacher, Voß-Zietz, Rogge and Kühn used a language that conjured up an overarching struggle for existence without mentioning particular “women’s questions”. Politics appeared as a matter of life and death that needed tough-minded, intransigent fighters, irrespective of gender. Misery, distress and the coming destruction of the German people were put before the readers’ eyes. This was flavoured with elements of the language of objectivity, as the journalists sought to demonstrate their comprehensive mastery of legal, historical and factual questions.66 In the years of crisis these authors did not have to argue from a specifically female or maternal viewpoint but were put forward as recognised experts on “national” questions, able to speak to and for the German people as a whole. Conclusion In the years of crisis in Germany, ideas of a radicalised, völkisch nationalism were used by formerly disenfranchised women to press forward their demands for full membership in the national community. In addition, they made an important contribution to the remobilisation of German society, not only by continuing a culture of war through speeches and articles, but also by hampering the moderate women’s movement in their attempts at cultural demobilisation. The female radical nationalists won some room for manoeuvre in the aftermath of war due to contemporary gender representations and internal conflicts on the German Right. Women who presented themselves as strict educators in nationalist values were considered useful in bringing shame upon men who acted in a less radical or uncompromising fashion. With the ending of the immediate post-war crisis in 1923, however, opportunities for female radical nationalists to write leading articles on national questions also began to wane. Only the fear of poor election results among female voters, and concern to destroy the influence of the BDF and the DDP, had led male newspaper editors to give a ╇ For the different languages of leadership see Mergel (2002), esp.╯pp.╯270–88. ╇ For the use of different political languages by female DNVP Reichstag deputies see Streubel (2006b), pp.╯138–42. 65 66
86
Christiane Streubel
more prominent voice to right-wing women journalists. Once it became clear that Protestant women were loyal supporters of the DNVP, whose votes could almost be taken for granted at election time, and once it became clear that it was not possible to abolish the republic by relentless opposition and a coup d’état, the strict female educators became obsolete.67 In the calmer waters of the Weimar Republic’s years of “relative stabilisation” between 1924 and 1929,68 the idea of heroic masculinity returned in full force and quickly became a rightwing monopoly.69 In this period too, gender representations are crucial to understanding the phenomena of cultural demobilisation and remobilisation, but the political context had clearly changed with the passing of the immediate post-war period, and right-wing women were now required to take a more back-seat role. Bibliography Barth, B. (2003) Dolchstoßlegende und politische Desintegration: Das Trauma der deutschen Niederlage im Ersten Weltkrieg 1914-1933 (Düsseldorf: 2003). Boehm, M. H. (1920) Ruf der Jungen (Leipzig: 1920). Bruendel, S. (2003) Volksgemeinschaft oder Volksstaat: Die “Ideen von 1914” und die Neuordnung Deutschlands im Ersten Weltkrieg (Berlin: 2003). Claß, H. (1920) “Des deutschen Volkes Wiedergeburt”, Deutschvölkisches Jahrbuch (1920) 49–53. Cramer, K. (2006) “A World of Enemies: New Perspectives on German Military Culture and the Origins of the First World War”, Central European History, 39 (2006) 270–98. Daniel, U. (2002) “Zweierlei Heimatfronten: Weibliche Kriegserfahrungen 1914 bis 1918 und 1939 bis 1945 im Kontrast”, in Erster Weltkrieg – Zweiter Weltkrieg: Ein Vergleich. Krieg, Kriegserlebnis, Kriegserfahrung in Deutschland, eds. B.╯Thoß and H.╯Volkmann (Paderborn: 2002) 391–409. Davis, B. (1996) “Food Scarcity and the Empowerment of the Female Consumer in World War I Germany”, in The Sex of Things: Gender and Consumption in Historical Perspective, ed. V. de Grazia (Berkeley: 1996) 287–310. ———╯ (2000) Home Fires Burning: Food, Politics, and Everyday Life in World War I (Chapel Hill and London: 2000). Frevert, U. (2007) “Honor and Gender in the Outbreak of WWI”, in An Improbable War? The Outbreak of World War I and European Political Culture before 1914, eds. H.╯Afflerbach and D.╯Stevenson (New York: 2007) 233–55. Gusy, C. (2008) “Verfassungsumbruch bei Kriegsende”, in Demokratie in der Krise: Europa in der Zwischenkriegszeit, ed. C.╯Gusy (Baden-Baden: 2008) 15–51. Heinsohn, K. (2000) “Im Dienste der deutschen Volksgemeinschaft: Die ‘Frauenfrage’ und konservative Parteien vor und nach dem Ersten Weltkrieg”, in Nation, Politik ╇Streubel (2006a), pp.╯221 and 243. ╇Kolb (2002), p.╯57. 69 ╇Schilling (2002), pp.╯289–90. Cf. Mosse (1990). 67 68
Raps across the knuckles
87
und Geschlecht. Frauenbewegungen und Nationalismus in der Moderne, ed. U.╯Planert (Frankfurt/M and New York: 2000) 215–33. Hering, R. (2003) Konstruierte Nation: Der Alldeutsche Verband 1890 bis 1939 (Hamburg: 2003). Hiller von Gaertringen, F. (1996), “Die DNVP in der Weimarer Republik”, Historische Mitteilungen, 9 (1996) 168–88. Horne, J. (2005) “Kulturelle Demobilmachung 1919-1939: Ein sinnvoller historischer Begriff?”, in Politische Kulturgeschichte der Zwischenkriegszeit 1919-1939, ed. W.╯Hartwig (Göttingen: 2005) 129–50. Kolb, E. (2002) Die Weimarer Republik, 6th ed. (Munich: 2002). Koller, C. (2002) “Enemy Images: Race and Gender Stereotypes in the Discussion on Colonial Troops. A Franco-German Comparison, 1914-1923”, in Home/Front: The Military, War and Gender in Twentieth Century Germany, eds. K.╯Hagemann and S.╯Schüler-Springorum (Oxford: 2002) 139–57. Liebe, W. (1956) Die Deutschnationale Volkspartei (Bonn: 1956). Mergel, T. (2002) Parlamentarische Kultur in der Weimarer Republik: Politische Kommunikation, symbolische Politik und Öffentlichkeit im Reichstag (Düsseldorf: 2002). Mommsen, W. J. (2000) Bürgerliche Kultur und politische Ordnung: Künstler, SchriftÂ� steller und Intellektuelle in der Geschichte 1890-1918 (Frankfurt/M: 2000). Mosse, G. (1990) Fallen Soldiers: Reshaping the Memory of the World Wars (Oxford: 1990). Planert, U. (1998) Antifeminismus im Kaiserreich: Diskurs, soziale Formation und politische Mentalität (Göttingen: 1998). Pyta, W. (2008) “Antiliberale Ideenwelt in Europa bei Kriegsende”, in Demokratie in der Krise: Europa in der Zwischenkriegszeit, ed. C.╯Gusy (Baden-Baden: 2008) 86–104. Rohkrämer, T. (2007) A Single Communal Faith? The German Right From Conservatism to National Socialism (New York and Oxford: 2007). Scheck, R. (2004) Mothers of the Nation: Right-Wing Women in Weimar Germany (Oxford, and New York: 2004). Schildt, A. (1998) Konservatismus in Deutschland: Von den Anfängen im 18. Jahrhundert bis zur Gegenwart (München: 1998). Schilling, R. (2002) “Kriegshelden”: Deutungsmuster heroischer Männlichkeit in Deutschland 1813-1945 (Paderborn: 2002). Schöck-Quinteros, E. (2007) “Der Bund Königin Luise: ‘Unser Kampfplatz ist die Familie…’”, in “Ihrem Volk verantwortlich”: Frauen der politischen Rechten (18901933), eds. E.╯Schöck-Quinteros and C.╯Streubel (Berlin: 2007) 231–68. Sharp, I. E. (2001) “‘Frauen und Fraß’: German Women in Wartime”, in The Great World War 1914-45, eds. P.╯Liddle, J.╯Bourne and I.╯Whitehead (London: 2001) Vol. 2 74–94. Stibbe, M. (2002) “Nationalism, Anti-Feminism and the German Right, 1914-1920. A Reappraisal”, German History, 20/2 (2002) 185–210. Sneeringer, J. (2007) “‘Frauen an die Front!’ The Language of ‘Kampf’ in DNVP’s Women’s Propaganda 1918-1933”, in “Ihrem Volk verantwortlich”: Frauen der politischen Rechten (1890-1933), eds. E.╯Schöck-Quinteros and C.╯Streubel (Berlin: 2007) 177–98. Streubel, C. (2006a) Radikale Nationalistinnen: Agitation und Programmatik rechter Frauen in der Weimarer Republik (Frankfurt/M and New York: 2006). ———╯ (2006b) “‘Meine Herren und Damen!’ Rednerinnen der deutschnationalen Fraktion im Parlament der Weimarer Republik”, in Mitsprache, Rederecht, StimmÂ�
88
Christiane Streubel
gewalt: Genderkritische Strategien und Transformationen der Rhetorik, eds. D.╯Bischoff and M.╯Wagner-Egelhaaf (Heidelberg: 2006) 113–42. ———╯ (2007) Lenore Kühn (1878-1955): Neue Nationalistin und verspätete Bildungsbürgerin (Berlin: 2007). ———╯ (2008) “’Deutsche Frauen, deutsche Treue’. Entwürfe konservativer Frauen im Ersten Weltkrieg”, in Treue: Politische Loyalitäten und militärische Gefolgschaft in der Moderne, eds. N.╯Buschmann and K. B.╯Murr (Göttingen: 2008) 190–213. Verhey, J. (2000) The Spirit of 1914: Militarism, Myth, and Mobilization in Germany (Cambridge: 2000). Wirsching, A. (2008) “Verfassung und Verfassungskultur der Zwischenkriegszeit”, in Demokratie in der Krise: Europa in der Zwischenkriegszeit, ed. C.╯Gusy (BadenBaden: 2008) 371–89. Woodfin, C. (2004) “Reluctant Democrats: The Protestant Women’s Auxiliary and the German National Assembly Elections of 1919”, Journal of the Historical Society, 4 (2004) 71–112.
The Rhineland horror campaign
89
The Rhineland horror campaign and the aftermath of war Erika Kuhlman* On 11 November 1918 the armistice between the defeated Germany and the victorious Allied powers came into effect, although the peace treaty was not signed until June 1919. This treaty, which imposed sole responsibility for the war on Germany under article 231 (the War Guilt Clause) and consequently demanded high reparations, was bitterly resented in Germany as a slur on German honour. It was only signed when all possibility of armed resistance had been ruled out by military commanders, but still allowed the stab-in-the-back legend (Dolchstosslegende) to flourish, placing the blame for the defeat variously on the home front, a supposed Jewish conspiracy, and big business. The treaty included provisions for the establishment of a League of Nations with the aim of preventing future wars by arbitrating in international disputes. The Treaty of Versailles was not ratified by the US Senate in March 1920, and America also failed to join the League of Nations. The Rhineland was to be occupied and administered by France and Britain for 15 years and a disputed number of the occupying French troops were drawn from their African colonies. These troops were also used when in April 1920 the French marched into the “neutral” zone in response to German troops being deployed in the Ruhr area in contravention of the terms of the peace.
Beginning in April 1920, various German citizens’ organisations, encouraged by their government, launched a campaign against France’s stationing of colonial African soldiers in its zone of the German Rhineland. Far from limiting themselves to the nations directly involved in the situation, groups such as the Volksbund Rettet die Ehre (People’s Federation to Save German Honour) and the Rheinisch Frauenliga (Rhineland Women’s League) deliberately spread their propaganda overseas in an effort to create an international furor over France’s alleged transgressions. While on the face of it, the goal of the drive – known as the “Rhineland Horror” or “Black *╇ A version of this chapter first appeared in Erika Kuhlman, Reconstructing Patriarchy after the Great War: Women, Gender and Postwar Reconciliation between Nations (New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 2008) and is reproduced here with permission of Palgrave Macmillan.
90
Erika Kuhlman
Horror” campaign – appeared to be to rid the area of African soldiers, the crusaders clearly wanted bolder outcomes. Still reeling from the cease-fire and more recently a humiliating peace settlement, the propagandists desired nothing less than the international discredit of the French, a halt to France’s efforts to separate the Rhineland from the rest of Germany, an end to the entire occupation, and the restoration of German honour in the eyes of its own inhabitants and of other nations.1 To reach these goals, the propagandists sent tentacles across the Atlantic, the North Sea, and the Baltic Sea to insure international support for their cause. In the case of the Americans, the campaigners hoped that race-baiting in the United States would draw their former enemy closer to the German side while driving a wedge between the Allied nations, a strategy that had succeeded in other issues involving the occupation.2 As crusaders played upon racialist ideologies prevalent in Europe and in the United States (I use the term racialist to convey the idea that perceived differences among humans are inborn and located in the immutable, physical body), they hinted that the presence of African troops in Germany could foment a race war that threatened the entire world’s white population, thus rendering the campaign not only international, but transnational in strategy. Although the campaign failed to gain the allegiance of the United States or to fully discredit the French or to reestablish German honour or end the occupation, it did (though not intentionally) reveal the hypocrisy inherent in Europe’s racialist justifications for overseas colonisation, the continuation of previously developed assumptions of racial hierarchies and white superiority well into the supposedly “modern” twentieth century, and it foreshadowed the role of racism in events to come by providing a podium for demagogues such as Adolf Hitler, among others.3 It also highlighted the extent to which the continuation of imperialism’s attendant ideologies impeded post-war reconciliation between nations, since, if not for imperialism, France would have had no colonial troops to send to the Rhineland and Germany no basis for complaint; furthermore, Germans could not 1 ╇Nelson (1970), Marks (1983) and Reinders (1968) have viewed the campaign in its diplomatic and political context; Lebzelter (1985), Campt, Grosse and LemkeMuniz de Fario (1998) view the campaign as an attempt to compensate for national anxieties produced by the defeat and occupation; Schüler (1996) explores the international women’s movement’s response to the campaign; and Koller (2001) places the campaign in its European perspective. 2 ╇Schüler (1996), p.╯1. 3 ╇Nelson (1975), pp.╯625–6.
The Rhineland horror campaign
91
have persuaded others that the practice of using African troops was abusive if European and American leaders were not at least partially convinced of imperialism’s racialist underpinnings. Just as colonisation played a role in bringing the Great War about, so it can be blamed, in part, for keeping nations from reconciling to peace.4 The Rhineland Horror campaign encumbered post-war reconciliation in a more insidious, though less obvious, way as well. If the belligerent powers expected the official document that signaled the end of war, the Treaty of Versailles, to aid post-war reconciliation, then signatories to the treaty had to agree to the principle of mutual cooperation through the League of Nations that formed one of the bases of the peace (although Germany did not join the League until 1926, two other major powers involved in the campaign, France and Great Britain, were members). Instead of promoting collaboration and finding a pathway to a solution, the campaign relied on manufactured accusations and manipulated documents to create turmoil. Indeed, historian Sally Marks could find no evidence that the German government ever officially requested that the French withdraw their colonial troops until most of them had already left the Rhineland, indicating that Weimar’s real desire lay in provoking antagonism.5 The treaty’s promise of mutual cooperation to end international strife thus remained unfulfilled. In another way, however, the Treaty of Versailles and its provisions foreshadowed the continuation of strife rather than reconciliation between nations, to which the Rhineland Horror campaign’s shenaniÂ� gans also contributed. In the League of Nations covenant that formed part of the settlement, signatories agreed that only the states that elite nations deemed ready to self-govern – primarily those formerly part of the old Habsburg and Ottoman empires – would be guided by the new principle of self-determination.6 States, mainly located in central and west Africa, considered unprepared for independence would require an intrusive administrative mandate and not be allowed to form their own governments or militaries.7 Thus, the Treaty of Versailles left intact the notion that African people were uncivilised and incapable of governing themselves, paving the way for the bloody ╇ Joll (1984), p.╯148. ╇ Marks (1983), p.╯310. 6 ╇Sluga (2000), p.╯496. Ambrosius (2006), pp.╯159–60 discusses the mandates in relation to location as part of Woodrow Wilson’s racism. 7 ╇ Walters (1960), pp.╯56–8. 4 5
92
Erika Kuhlman
African wars for independence. The belief that the African soldiers stationed in the Rhineland were barbarous and unable to control their physical instincts formed the centerpiece of the Rhineland Horror campaign’s strategy. While the crusade failed to garner broad support, it left intact the notion that “over-sexed” African males had a natural propensity toward raping white women, that females’ natural vulnerability left them easy prey for such attacks, and that therefore women needed white men’s protection from harm. Black men’s access to white women implied a level playing field between the races that constituted a threat to all societies built upon the notion of white supremacy. “The ‘Rhineland Horror’ is not only a disgrace for Germany,” warned the Grenzland Korrespondent. “It is much more. It represents the desecration of white culture in general. At the same time, it means the beginning of the end of the predominance of the white man”.8 Even Europeans such as Helena M.╯Swanwick and Americans such as General Henry T.╯Allen who balked at the campaign’s insistence that African men were unable to control their sexual impulses remained convinced that the white race had created and represented “civilisation,” whereas nonwhite people epitomised barbarism. A few women played combative roles in the battle to relieve Europe of Africans’ presence, while another handful – Europeans and African Americans – exposed the racialist notions underpinning the campaign to a wide audience. One German critic, Lilli Jannasch, considered the Rhineland Horror propaganda both racialist and sexist and her ideas will be discussed in detail below. With very few exceptions, however, women – as individuals and as international activists – united their rhetoric quite closely with the male policymakers and diplomats, thereby generating and responding to imperialist and racialist ideologies of the early twentieth century.9 Women such as Ray Beveridge and Margarete Gärtner (sometimes spelled Margarethe Gartner), and women’s transnational organisations such as the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom (WILPF) and sixty-six other European women’s organisations,10 acted in a manner generally consistent with the imperialist ideologies and racial hierarchies that formed the geopolitical view of the world in which they lived. In back╇ Quoted in Campt et al. (1998), p.╯211. ╇ I am indebted to Manako Ogawa for my interpretation of activist women and their relationship to race and international politics. See Ogawa (2007). 10 ╇Schüler (1996), p.╯5. 8 9
The Rhineland horror campaign
93
ing the Rhineland Horror campaign, members undercut their ability to offer the world a truly alternative vision – including greater freedoms for all women throughout the world – of a post-war world order based upon human equality rather than prejudice and discrimination. Article 22 of the League of Nations covenant, too, reproduced the pre-war imperialist attitudes enshrined in the Berlin Act of 1885, based on the paternalistic conviction that colonialisation would have the effect of “instructing the natives and bringing home to them the blessings of civilisation”.11 In the light of these stated aims, the Rhineland Horror campaign’s efforts to oust colonial troops from the presumed seat of civilisation, Europe itself, seemed hypocritical. The perpetrators of the crusade used the racialism inherent in imperialist ideology to foment an international outrage at the presence of armed African soldiers in the Rhineland. Historian Keith L.╯Nelson has noted that race became the most perfidious weapon the French and German diplomats used against each other in post-war relations, and the diplomatic conversations that took place before the occupation began gave campaigners reason to believe that the scheme might succeed.12 German policymakers had protested against the possible use of African troops, whether colonial French or African American, in the Rhineland during armistice negotiations and this position was supported by British and American negotiators at the Paris Conference.13 However, France had little choice but to deploy colonial troops as it lacked other soldiers to send.14 France began its participation in the Rhineland occupation with a total of 200,000 troops, reduced to 85,000 after the treaty.15 The German Foreign Ministry claimed that the numbers of colonials, often described as “coal black” although many were North Africans of mixed European and African descent,16 reached 30–40,000, or approximately half of the French force. However, Allied observers recorded only 14,000 to 25,000 African troops. Historian Anja Schüler has stated that this was the figure claimed by the French, which she deems more accurate.17 In addition, the presence of colonial soldiers resulted in some 600 to 800 “mixed race” children born of relations