The Complete Soldier
History of Warfare Editor
Kelly DeVries Loyola College in Maryland
Michael S. Neiberg Universi...
208 downloads
2334 Views
6MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
The Complete Soldier
History of Warfare Editor
Kelly DeVries Loyola College in Maryland
Michael S. Neiberg University of Southern Mississippi
John France University of Wales Swansea Founding editors
Theresa Vann Paul Chevedden
VOLUME 53
The Complete Soldier Military Books and Military Culture in Early Stuart England, 1603–1645
By
David R. Lawrence
LEIDEN • BOSTON 2009
Cover illustration: Gervase Markham’s A Schoole for young souldiers containing in briefe the whole discipline of warre, printed for militia training in 1615 and 1616. Courtesy of the British Library. This book is printed on acid-free paper. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication-Data Lawrence, David R., 1962– The complete soldier : military books and military culture in early Stuart England, 1603–1645 / by David R. Lawrence. p. cm. — (History of warfare ; 53) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978-90-04-17079-7 (hbk. : alk. paper) 1. Military art and science—Great Britain—History—17th century. 2. Great Britain. Army—Handbooks, manuals, etc. 3. Military education—Great Britain—History—17th century. 4. Books and reading—England—History—17th century. 5. Early printed books—England—17th century. 6. Great Britain—History, Military—1603–1714. I. Title. U43.G7L38 2008 355.00942’09032—dc22 2008035395
ISSN 1385-7827 ISBN 978 90 04 17079 7 Copyright 2009 by Koninklijke Brill NV, Leiden, The Netherlands. Koninklijke Brill NV incorporates the imprints Brill, Hotei Publishing, IDC Publishers, Martinus Nijhoff Publishers and VSP. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, translated, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission from the publisher. Authorization to photocopy items for internal or personal use is granted by Koninklijke Brill NV provided that the appropriate fees are paid directly to The Copyright Clearance Center, 222 Rosewood Drive, Suite 910, Danvers, MA 01923, USA. Fees are subject to change. printed in the netherlands
For Herenia
CONTENTS Abbreviations .............................................................................. Note on Dates ............................................................................. Illustrations .................................................................................. Acknowledgements .....................................................................
ix xi xiii xvii
Introduction ................................................................................
1
Chapter One “Caesar to this Present day of King James”: Military Books and Military Culture, 1572–1603 ................. Matriculating in the Schoole of Warre: English Entry into the Low Countries War .............................................. Warfare Abroad and Reform at Home ................................. Books, Learning, and Military Culture .................................. Procuring Foreign Military Books .......................................... England’s Worthies: Military Circles and Military Books in Late Elizabethan England ................................... Chapter Two “Companions of Martiall Noblenesse”: Military Circles and Books in Early Stuart England ............. The English Military Experience: 1603–1629 ....................... Early Stuart Military Circles: The Veres ............................... The Military Court of Henry, Prince of Wales .................... Caroline Military Circles ........................................................ Chapter Three “Practice put in Press”: The Evolution of the English Drill Manual ................................................... The Evolution of the Early Stuart Drill Manual: The Dutch Influence .......................................................... The Honourable Artillery Company: The Incubator of English Military Practice ............................................... The Impact of the Instructions For Musters and Armes of 1623 ................................................................................ The Drill Manual in the Personal Rule Period ..................... Drill Manuals in the First Years of the English Civil War .............................................................................
19 23 31 36 46 51 73 75 93 105 126 135 137 156 167 177 185
viii
contents
Chapter Four “A few men rightly instructed to manage Armes”: The Analytical Treatise and Infantry Warfare ....... Soldier-Authors and their Patrons: The Veterans ................. Soldier-Authors and their Patrons: The Amateurs ................ English Translations of Foreign Analytical Treatises ............ Preparation and Action: Infantry Tactics .............................. The Five Vowels ..................................................................... Habiliments & Necessaries of War ........................................ Chapter Five “There is Great Need for Reformation”: Military Books and Mounted Warfare ................................... Late Elizabethan Theories on Mounted Warfare ................. Warfare and Horsemanship Treatises .................................... Jacobean Military Books on Cavalry ..................................... John Cruso’s Militarie Instructions for the Cavallrie and Caroline Books on Cavalry ................................................ Cavalry Manuals in the English Civil War ............................ Chapter Six “Necessary Bulwarks”: Siegecraft Treatises in Early Stuart England ......................................................... Soldiers, Military Architects and Mathematicians ................. Siegecraft and the Mathematical Renaissance ...................... An English School of Military Architecture, 1560–1600? .... Siege Literature: Ostend to Breda ......................................... Analytical Treatises and Specialized Literature on Siegecraft, 1630–1642 ........................................................ The Elements of a Siege ........................................................ Necessary Bulwarks: The Theory and Practice of Siegecraft in the Civil War .................................................
195 196 216 230 243 249 254 261 263 270 280 291 303 313 316 322 326 329 336 345 361
Conclusion ..................................................................................
371
Appendix Military Books Printed in English, 1603–1645 ...... Selected Bibliography ................................................................. Index ...........................................................................................
375 393 417
ABBREVIATIONS A.P.C. Add. Mss. Bod. Lib. BL CSPD CSPV NA SP
Acts of the Privy Council Additional Manuscripts Bodleian Library, Oxford University British Library Calendar of State Papers Domestic Calendar of State Papers Venetian National Archives, London State Papers
NOTE ON DATES During the late sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, the English calendar (Old Style) was ten days behind Continental Europe (New Style) and the new year began on 25 March. All dates are given in the Old Style, but where dates in this book fall within the months of January-March 25, I have denoted both years as such, 1641/42.
ILLUSTRATIONS Figure 1. Robert Dudley, earl of Leicester as depicted in Edward Grimeston’s A Generall Historie of the Netherlands. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................................................. Figure 2. Sir Francis Vere from his Commentaries (1657). Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................................................. Figure 3. Sir Horace Vere from brother Francis Vere’s Commentaries (1657). Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................ Figure 4. William Hole’s 1612 engraving of Henry Frederick, Prince of Wales training with pike. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................................................. Figure 5. Sir John Ogle, a member of Prince Henry’s circle who also established his own military salon at his home in the Netherlands. From Vere’s Commentaries. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................................................. Figure 6. Maurice of Nassau, Prince of Orange (1567–1625) from Edward Grimeston’s A Generall Historie of the Netherlands. The inspirational general whose military reforms heavily influenced the development of the art of war in early seventeenth-century England. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ................. Figure 7. The frontispiece of Jacques de Gheyn’s The Exercise of Armes printed in The Hague in 1607. Courtesy of the British Library ......................................................................... Figure 8. Edward Panton’s A Table expressing the words in the science militarie. London: Adam Islip, 1614. Courtesy of the Bodleian Library, Oxford University. ............................... Figure 9. Gervase Markham’s A Schoole for young souldiers containing in briefe the whole discipline of warre, printed for militia training in 1615 and 1616. Courtesy of the British Library .........................................................................
53 95 102
109
118
139 142 149
151
xiv
illustrations
Figure 10. Title page of the Instructions For Musters and Armes of 1623. Courtesy of the British Library .............................. Figure 11. Title page of Edward Davies’s Art of War and England’s Traynings (1620 edition). Courtesy of the British Library ......................................................................... Figure 12. A page from Edward Davies’s The Art of War and England’s Traynings demonstrating the advancing and countermarching of shot in two ranks. Courtesy of the British Library ......................................................................... Figure 13. The title page of Robert Ward’s popular Anima’dversions of Warre (1639). Courtesy of the British Library .................................................................................... Figure 14. The title page of Garret Barry’s A Discourse of Military Discipline (1634) written for English-speaking soldiers serving in the armies of Europe’s Catholic monarchs. Courtesy of the Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................................................. Figure 15. Portrait of William Barriffe from the frontispiece of his Military Discipline: Or, The Yong Artillery Man (1635). Courtesy of the British Library ............................................. Figure 16. The title page of John Cruso’s Militarie Instructions for the Cavallrie (1632). Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................ Figure 17. The fully armoured cuirassier from John Cruso’s Militarie Instructions for the Cavallrie. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ................. Figure 18. The postures for cavalry found in John Cruso’s Militarie Instructions for the Cavallrie. By the English Civil War, the postures were no longer seen as a necessary part of cavalry training. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ..................................... Figure 19. A bastion defence depicted in Robert Ward’s Anima’dversions of Warre (1639). Courtesy of the British Library .................................................................................... Figure 20. Map of Ostend from Edward Grimeston’s True Historie of the Siege of Ostend (1604). Courtesy of the British Library .........................................................................
168 205
207 212
217 222 293 298
299 318 330
illustrations Figure 21. The frontispiece of Samuel Marolois’s Fortification ou Architectvre militaire tant offensive que defensive, first printed in Amsterdam in 1627 and translated into English by Henry Hexham in 1631. Courtesy of the Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................................... Figure 22. The title page of Thomas Smith’s The Art of Gunnery (1643). Smith’s treatise, originally printed in 1600, was reprinted after the outbreak of hostilities between the Royalist and Parliamentary armies. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ... Figure 23. The frontispiece of Robert Norton’s popular treatise on artillery, The Gunner, printed in 1628. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................................................................... Figure 24. An engraving from Robert Norton’s The Gunner offering instruction on opening a breach in a bastion. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ............................................................. Figure 25. Engravings of siegeworks from Stone’s Enchiridion of Fortification (1645). The chevaux de freis is noted as E on Plate 9. The Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto ...............................................
xv
343
355
358
359
368
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS This study grew out of my dissertation at the University of Toronto where I have had the pleasure of working with a fine group of scholars who have provided me with valuable assistance and guidance during my research. I indebted to Bert Hall and Barbara Todd of the University of Toronto and Ian Gentles of York University for all of their help in preparing this monograph, for their editorial comments, and for their friendship. Special thanks as well to Mark Fissel who commented on the work when it was still a dissertation and Jennifer Mori who has provided suggestions and kind words of encouragement. I also owe a great debt of gratitude to Ken Bartlett, whose advice and support has been instrumental in seeing this book to press. I would also like to thank the members of the Early Modern Discussion Group in the Department of History, University of Toronto as well as the members of the Medieval/Early Modern Thesis Chapter Reading Group, Dana Wessell-Lightfoot, Nicole Greenspan, Jamie Smith, Mark Crane, Michael Ullyot, Jennifer Brewer, Jess Paehlke, and Milton Kooistra, all of whom provided comments on chapters, as well as camaraderie and some fine gastronomic faire. I also would like to express my gratitude to Jennifer Francisco, Rae Pemberton, Louise Kermode, Vicky Dingillo, Marion Harris, and the rest of the staff of the History Department at the University of Toronto for all of their assistance with matters related to my teaching in the department over the years. I wish to express my gratitude to Graham Rees, Maria Wakely, and all of the participants of International Seminars on the Jacobean Book, held in 2004 and 2006 at Queen Mary College, University of London who commented on papers I presented at the seminars. The biannual seminars have fostered the growth of a wonderful community of historians and bibliographers and it has been a real pleasure to have been able to join in the discussions at QM. My research was made easier through the help of the librarians and staff of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library and the Interlibrary Loan Department at Robarts Library, University of Toronto. Thanks also to the librarians at the Centre for Reformation and Renaissance Studies (CRRS) at Pratt Library, Victoria College, University of Toronto, the
xviii
acknowledgements
staff of the Rare Books and Manuscripts Room and the Reproductions Department of the British Library, London, UK as well as staff at the Bodleian Library, Oxford University. I also wish to extend special thanks to Dr. Julia Walworth, Librarian at Merton College, Oxford, who was kind enough to allow me to spend an afternoon in the Merton College Library reading the Elsevier Book Catalogues. This study began to take shape in the early 1990s when I was teaching a history course “From Subject to Citizen” at Durham Academy, in Durham, North Carolina. The course covered the history of Tudor and Stuart England and Colonial America and each year my students watched Ken Hughes’s 1970 film Cromwell. For seven years I watched (on more occasions than I wish to remember) as Richard Harris’s character turned the Parliamentary army into a formidable fighting force and then single-handedly won the English Civil War. Our discussions of Civil War England turned my attention to training and military manuals and eventually led to this study. Durham Academy also allowed me to take a sabbatical year abroad in 1991–2 to pursue an MA degree in War Studies at King’s College, University of London. I owe very special thanks to students and staff at DA, especially Tim Dahlgren, David Gould, Jim Speir, Joe Sievold, and other members of the History Department whom I had the pleasure to work with between 1988 and 1998. At King’s, Professor Beatrice Heuser encouraged me to pursue a Ph.D. and I must thank her for her support as well. While living in Durham I also had the chance to spend the summer of 1996 in a directed readings course at Duke University discussing the early modern military revolution with Alex Roland. I wish to thank Professor Roland for his help in setting my research in motion. I owe thanks to a number of historians who have offered comments, suggestions, and answered queries via e-mail. Dr. David McKetterick, Dr. Tracy Borman, Peter Harrington and Alexandra Guerson De Oliveira were kind enough to take time to help with some vital pieces of information and I am very grateful to all of them for their assistance. At Brill, editors Julian Deahl, Marcella Mulder, Renate de Vries, and Kelly DeVries have been an absolute pleasure to work with over the past three years. Thanks also to the reader at Brill who offered valuable comments on the manuscript. I also wish to thank Mary Newberry for all of her hard work with the copy editing and Ruth Pincoe who provided valuable assistance with the indexing.
acknowledgements
xix
During successive trips to London beginning in 1999, Flavia Goyanna and all in the “Big Brother” house in Shepherd’s Bush were kind enough to provide me with a roof over my head, hospitality, and friendship. I cannot thank Flavia enough for all her support. Finally, my warmest appreciation to my family: my parents Barbara and Rodney who instilled in me a love of military history and books; my brothers, Simon and Michael, who provided cheap airline tickets to make trips to England, my sister Ann, who pushed the project on by asking “when is the book going to be finished?” and my uncle and aunt, Peter and Isabel Lawrence, who were always happy to provide a hot meal and a pint when I was in England. And, to my beloved wife Herenia, who has had to step over drill manuals on the study floor and read about clay pot hand grenades and bastion fortifications; all my love for her patience and help in seeing this book to completion.
INTRODUCTION “For when Mars and Art, true Valour and Policie meet together in a Chiefe, or Commander, they make a compleat Souldier.” So wrote Henry Hexham in his dedication to Henry Rich, earl of Holland, in The Principles of the Art Militarie, a manual on infantry warfare that was printed in 1637.1 It is the making of the “complete soldier” in early Stuart England that is the focus of this study and though Hexham weighed the influence of four elements, I will save valour for another day and concentrate only on war, art, and policy in this study. In the pages that follow the connections between military culture and print culture will be explored, particularly the role of military books and manuals in shaping the complete English soldier in the years 1603 to 1645. This book explores the early modern English soldier as author, patron, and reader and seeks to establish a much firmer place for military books in the fields of military history and book history. In the two score years between the death of Elizabeth I in 1603 and the formation of the New Model Army in 1645, Englishmen penned over ninety books on military subjects. These books included lengthy treatises on the arte militarie, infantry drill manuals, books on personal combat, military histories, and pamphlets on the laws of war, many of which were written with the intention of moulding the “complete” or “perfect” soldier. Most often, the complete soldier was a gentleman, a man of means who could read and write, knew arithmetic and geometry, and who gained his experience either by volunteering for service abroad or by practising the military arts at the local muster ground or military yard. Contemporaries argued, however, that experience alone was not enough to make a complete soldier and those bound for the wars should also take time to study and read about the arte militarie, gleaning what they could from the wisdom and experience of others. When English military books could not answer all the questions a soldier might have about the trade, he was encouraged to purchase works by Spanish, Italian, French, and German authors. Only when he fully
1 H. Hexham, The Principles of the Art Militarie; Practised in the Warres of the Vnited Netherlands (London: M.P. for Matthew Symmons, 1637), The Epistle Dedicatory.
2
introduction
comprehended all that he might be faced on the field of Mars, would he become a complete soldier. Until now there have been no comprehensive studies of early Stuart military books. Barbara Donagan’s seminal article, “Halcyon Days and the Literature of War: England’s Military Education Before 1642,” addressed the significance of the books written in Caroline period, but she did not explore in detail issues related to the role of books and manuals on training.2 As far as the periods preceding and following the early seventeenth century, mid-to-late sixteenth-century English military books were examined in Henry J. Webb’s Elizabethan Military Science: The Books and Practice, while eighteenth-century books on infantry and cavalry training were masterfully handled by J.A. Houlding in his Fit for Service: The Training of the British Army 1715–1795.3 Over the last thirty years John Childs and David Chandler have each published studies of warfare in the later Stuart period that describe the military books and drill manuals printed in late seventeenth- and early eighteenth-century England.4 This book was written to augment our understanding of the evolution of English military books and drill manuals, and to assess how English soldiers used these texts for training as well as for enhancing their understanding of military tactics and the transformations shaping continental warfare during this period. At the same time, we should keep in mind that military books were not reserved solely for martialists, but also were read by scholars and statesmen who turned to these works when pondering questions regarding war and the formulation of state and foreign policy. Traditionally, discussions of military books and manuals have been largely restricted to the field of military history, but these texts must be seen within the broader context of intellectual history and book history. Few historians would argue with H.S. Bennett’s assertion that the seventeenth century was “a reading age,” but consensus over the place 2 B. Donagan, “Halcyon Days and the Literature of War: England’s Military Education Before 1642,” Past and Present 147 (May 1995): 65–100. 3 H.J. Webb, Elizabethan Military Science: The Books and Practice (Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 1965) and J.A. Houlding, Fit for Service: The Training of the British Army 1715–1795 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1981). 4 John Childs’ work, which covers the period 1660–1702, includes The Army of Charles II (London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1976) and The Nines Years’ War and the British Army 1688–1697 (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1991). See David Chandler’s Marlborough as Military Commander (New York, Scribner, 1973); The Art of Warfare in the Age of Marlborough (Staplehurst, UK: Spellmount, 1997); Blenheim Preparation: The English Army on the March to the Danube, Collected Essays (Staplehurst, UK: Spellmount, 2004).
introduction
3
of military books in that age has remained elusive.5 Historiographical debates on the value of military books and manuals have centred on some of the same issues that were argued over nearly three hundred fifty years ago, notably, the practicality of written texts as didactic tools for teaching martial skills, the value of classical and foreign military models and their applicability to early modern warfare in England, and the authority of “amateur” military writers and their understanding (or misunderstanding) of the military realities of the day. The influence of Minerva on Mars, the blending of ancient with modern, and the relevance of military books to the military arts in the early seventeenth century has not been without its sceptics, though there seems to be a growing consensus among historians that military books and manuals were much more influential in shaping practice than was long believed. Much of the scepticism about the value of military books to the early modern soldier first arose in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries when scholars argued the limited role these texts had in shaping military practice. Nineteenth-century antiquarians drew on the descriptions of weaponry, drill, and tactics found in English military treatises, but they made no effort to weigh the influence of the theories posited in the military literature, nor did they attempt to address the influence of drill manuals on the training of either the militia or the soldiers serving in the English Civil War.6 J.W. Fortescue’s A History of the British Army could do little more than provide a short footnote on the noted authorities of late Tudor and early Stuart military literature, mentioning Henry Hexham’s Principles Of the Art Military, Thomas Kellie’s Pallas Armata, or, Militarie Instruictions for the Learned, John Bingham’s Tactiks of Aelian, Robert Ward’s Anima’dversions Of Warre, and John Vernon’s
5 H.S. Bennett, English Books and Readers 1603–1640 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1970), 2. 6 In Francis Grose’s Military Antiquities respecting a history of the English Army from the Conquest to the Present Times (London: L. Stockdale, 2 vols., 1812), the author did not question the validity of what the early Stuart authors had to say about martial practice, but simply incorporated lengthy excerpts from the 17th century treatises into his history of the army. Grose’s discussion of the “antient musketeer” drew on Edward Davies Englands Traynings (1619) and his chapter on pikemen relied on a short description from Markham’s Souldier’s Accidence. Grose offered readers no critique of the military manuals or treatises and was content to present a panegyric of Britain’s military past, a past that depicted the English military as holding a “pre-eminent Rank among the European nations, and scarcely at any time . . . inferior to those of its most warlike neighbours.” See vol. 1: 127.
4
introduction
The Young-Horseman or the Honest plain-dealing Cavalier. Fortescue did not attempt to offer any insight into whether these books were actually used to educate English soldiers.7 In his classic study Cromwell’s Army, C.H. Firth claimed that while the sixteenth- and seventeenth-century military treatises had a “considerable historical value,” he warned that they must be approached with “great caution.”8 The need for caution arose from Firth’s belief that most English military authors relied too heavily on continental sources and therefore the practices they described did not mirror actual English military practice in the Civil War. It might be unfair to accuse Firth of overlooking the importance of Dutch methods in bringing the trained bands up to speed before the war, primarily because the focus of his work is on Cromwell’s army and not the Jacobean volunteer or Caroline trained band member. Firth did, however, recognize that standardization and improvements in training took place before the war, though he was unwilling to draw a connection between those innovations and the military books he mentioned. Instead, he suggested that military treatises needed to be “sifted and tested” before drawing any final conclusions about their value.9 Cromwell’s Army provided the starting point for this process of sifting and testing the late Elizabethan and early Stuart military books, but it was not until the 1950s and 1960s that anyone took up Firth’s challenge. Geoffrey Langsam’s Martial Books and Tudor Verse and Henry J. Webb’s Elizabethan Military Science: The Books and Practice were the first to heed Firth’s call, each seeking to connect the military texts of the Shakespearean world to the late Elizabethan military reforms and to English engagement in the war with Spain. Langsam concluded that Elizabethan military books served multiple purposes; they offered advice on training and tactics, but they also, concerned themselves with a justification for war on scriptural, historical and philosophical grounds. They distinguished between just and unjust wars; they defended the profession and the honor of the soldier; they discriminated between the professional and the soldier of the levy; they defined military ethics; they presented the ideal soldier and his officers, and criticized adversely those who shamed their profession; they described the
7 J.W. Fortescue, A History of the British Army, vol. 1 (London: MacMillian, 1899), 170, 194, 215. 8 C.H. Firth, Cromwell’s Army. A History of the English Soldier during the Civil Wars, the Commonwealth and The Protectorate (London: Greenhill Press, (1903) 1992), xiv. 9 Ibid.
introduction
5
organization of the army, its arms, munitions, equipment, and supply; they concerned themselves with methods of levying soldiers, with transport, mustering, training, pay liaison; they taught methods of fortification and a host of military matters.10
Both Langsam and Webb questioned the extent to which England was isolated from the transformation of European warfare, now described as the “military revolution,” which was taking place during the sixteenth century. Webb raised doubts as to whether the long years of peace during Elizabeth’s reign had actually stifled the impetus for martial reform. Citing the marriage of theory and practice in the last quarter of the sixteenth century, he considered military books to have been vital in transforming the English army into “a relatively efficient implement of war.”11 The creation of the trained bands in 1572–73 occurred well before Anglo-Spanish tensions boiled over into full-fledged war, with reform of England’s militia coming at a time of relative calm. This call for reform was very similar to the period following the Treaty of London in 1604, which ended the Anglo-Spanish war, when Low Countries veterans began to write drill manuals to assist in the standardization of infantry drill and weaponry in the 1610s and early 1620s. Some of the earlier criticism of the questionable credentials of English military authors and the value of their books has been muted as scholars have come to the realization that the proliferation of military books across Europe acted as one of the best means of spreading innovation and codifying practice. J.R. Hale made a significant contribution to our understanding of the ties between military culture and print culture with a succession of books and articles published during his long and celebrated academic career. In 1961, Hale published a short work, The Art of War and Renaissance England, that gave brief summaries of a number of late Elizabethan and early Stuart military books that could be found in the Folger Library in Washington, DC. In his introduction, Hale dispelled the notion that the English were uninterested in war. He asserted that simply because English borders were relatively safe from invasion or that her armies did not regularly threaten the borders of other states, that this somehow constrained Englishmen from studying the art of war. Instead, Hale found that the military interests of the
10 11
Langsam, Martial Books and Tudor Verse (New York: King’s Crown Press, 1951), 1. Webb, Elizabethan Military Science, 3.
6
introduction
late Elizabethan and early Stuart Englishmen were, in fact, quite broad and ranged from interest in the invention of a new explosive to attempts to reconcile the pacifism of the New Testament with the blood and thunder of the Old . . . [which] meant that war, its techniques and its issues, penetrated the imaginative life of the people more deeply than at any previous time, as the proliferation of books ensured that this penetration was not restricted to the places in which wars were actually being fought.12
Hale continued to explore the topic of military books in articles published in the 1970s, including “The Military Education of the Officer Class in Early Modern Europe,” “Printing and the Military Culture of Renaissance Venice,” and “On A Tudor Parade Ground: The Captain’s Handbook of Henry Barrett, 1562.”13 In each of these articles he made the case for the prominence of written texts in military education, particularly as the pace of military change quickened in the late sixteenth century. According to Hale, “the potential officer needed to know a more complex and a more disciplined craft of war than had his late medieval predecessor.”14 Books and drill manuals, he argued, helped make sense of these complexities. Hale’s research on English and Italian military books sparked further interest in the influence of military literature on the education of officers in other European states. This research has broadened our understanding of early modern military culture across the continent and uncovered much stronger ties between the theory of war and its practice on the muster ground and on the battlefield. Over the last three decades, scholars have endeavoured to explore the connection between military books and the men who read and wrote them, discovering that highly trained and highly motivated early modern soldiers were not adverse to the use of instructional texts and manuals as aids for training or tactical inquiry. Fernando González de Leon’s “ ‘Doctors of
12 J.R. Hale, The Art of War and Renaissance England (Washington, DC: Folger Library Press, 1961), 3. 13 J.R. Hale, “The Military Education of the Officer Class in Early Modern Europe,” in Cultural Aspects of the Italian Renaissance: Essays in Honour of Paul Oskar Kristeller, ed. C.H. Clough, (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1976), 440–61; “Printing and the Military Culture of Renaissance Venice,” Medievalia et Humanistica, n.s., 8 (1977): 21–62; “On A Tudor Parade Ground: The Captain’s Handbook of Henry Barrett, 1562,” The Society for Renaissance Studies, Occasional Papers, no. 5 (1978). All three articles appear in Hale’s Renaissance War Studies (London: Hambledon Press, 1983). 14 Hale, “The Military Education of the Officer Class,” 226.
introduction
7
the Military Discipline’: Technical Expertise and the Paradigm of the Spanish Soldier in the Early Modern Period” challenged the notion that sixteenth- and seventeenth-century Spanish officers were “inflexible and unrealistic Don Quixotes,” finding that the Spanish were thinking and writing about military tactics in a thoroughly modern way.15 González de Leon investigated the “complete” or “perfect soldier” genre of military literature published when Spain’s armies were at the height of their power in the late sixteenth century. He discovered that most of the Spanish military books and manuals were written by officers who were either serving, or who had served in the field, and were not directed at armchair generals or courtiers, but at other officers in Spanish service. According to González de Leon, the contribution of Spanish theorists was significant, one that had “no contemporary parallel,” certainly not in the Dutch army, whose officers wrote very little. In Venice, the hub of military publishing in the sixteenth century, there were sixty-seven works of military science issued between 1492 and 1570, most although not all by Italians. Sixty-four other works of similar topic appeared in the rest of Europe during these years. In contrast, we find close to sixty military treatises published in the Low Countries and the Spanish world between 1567 and 1621, most of them written by army officers. These numbers alone suggest strongly that the traditional image of the Spanish soldier stands in need of some revision.16
On a more expansive scale, Sydney Anglo has assessed a vast catalogue of books on hand-to-hand combat in his magisterial work, The Martial Arts of Renaissance Europe.17 Anglo concluded his study with a section on military literature that linked the tradition of the martial arts literature with the early seventeenth-century literature on war. This link was most evident in the military academies that became popular at the end of the sixteenth and beginning of the seventeenth century. Academies were founded for the education of gentlemen soldiers who were increasingly confronted by the complexities of the early modern military profession, a profession requiring the mastery of new organizational, technological, and leadership skills. Though most of these academies were short lived, Anglo identifies them as places where the 15 F. González de Leon, “Doctors of the Military Discipline: Technical Expertise and the Paradigm of the Spanish Soldier in the Early Modern Period,” Sixteenth Century Journal 27 (1996): 61–85. 16 Ibid., 64. 17 S. Anglo, The Martial Arts of Renaissance Europe (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2000).
8
introduction
“old skills of personal combat” intersected with the “up-to-date theoretical military sciences and mathematics.”18 Manuals appear to have fit neatly into this educational environment, offering students some means of comprehending the rudiments of drill and the specialized military arts of siegecraft, gunnery, and logistics. Anglo singled out the manuals of Johann Jacobi von Wallhausen, who in 1617 became the director of the military academy at Siegen, established by John of Nassau-Dillemburg, as the exemplars of early modern military literature. Wallhausen’s books, wrote Anglo, offer modern readers a perfect focus of the most fundamental military ideas of the early seventeenth century: the relationship between ancients and moderns, theory and practice, academic education and battle experience, training exercises and real warfare, and the role of personal combat skills within the larger context of battle.19
Wallhausen’s works were very popular with soldiers of many European nationalities and there is ample evidence to suggest that editions were being consulted by English military writers very soon after their publication on the continent.20 The manuals of Johann Jacobi von Wallhausen were a small part of a larger trend toward the dissemination of military ideas in Europe. Military ideas transcended national boundaries, helped by the polyglot nature of early modern armies. For this reason, we cannot see English military books in isolation, nor
Ibid., 283. Ibid., 287. Johann Jocabi von Wallhausen authored eleven military books between 1615 and 1621, including Alphabetum pro tyrone pedestri. Oder der Soldaten zu Feuss ihr A.B.C (Frankfurt-am-Main: Paul Jacobi, 1615); Kriegskunst zu Fuss (Oppenheim: H. Galler, 1615); Kriegskunst zu Pferdt (Frankfurt-am-Main: Paul Jacobi, 1616); Ritterkunst (Frankfurt-amMain: Paul Jacobi, 1616); Manuale militare, oder Kriegssmanual (Frankfurt: Paul Jacobi, 1616); Romanishe Kriegskunst (Frankfurt-am-Main, Paul Jacobi, 1616); Künstliche Picquen-Handlung. Darinnen schrifftlich und mit Figuren dieses Adeliches Exercitium angewiesen und gelehrt wirdt ets (Hanaw: [s.n.], 1617); Archilen Kriegskunst: darinnen gelehret und fürgetragen werden die initia und fundamenta dieser edlen Kriegskunst (Hanaw: [s.n.], 1617); Corpus Militare, darinnen das heütige Kriegswesen (Hanaw: [s.n.], 1617); Defensio Patriae, oder, Landtrettung: darinnen gezeigt wirdt I. Wie alle vnd jede in der werthen Christenheit Potentaten, Regenten, Stätte vnnd Communen ihre vnd der ihrigen Vnderthanen Rettung vnd Schutzung anstellen sollen: II. Der Modus bene belligerandi, viel hundert Jahr bissher gefählet. . . . (Frankfurt-am-Main: Daniel and Dauid Aubrien and Clement Schleichen, 1621); Camera militaris Oder Kriegskunst Schatzkammer (Frankfurt-amMain: Daniel and David Aubrien and Clement Schleichen, 1621). 20 See J. Cruso, Militarie instructions for the cavallrie: or Rules and directions for the service of horse collected out of divers forrain authors ancient and modern, and rectified and supplied, according to the present practise of the Low-Countrey warres (Cambridge: Thomas Buck and Roger Daniel, 1632). 18 19
introduction
9
can we see Englishmen being isolated from the expanding library of European military books. The first efforts to link early Stuart military books, European military culture, and the wars of the Three Kingdoms can be found in Donagan’s “Halcyon Days and the Literature of War.” Donagan found that despite the years of peace that marked the 1630s, Englishmen were “neither ‘utterly unprepared’ for war . . . nor unshakably civilian.”21 Her article contends (and this author agrees) that the early Stuart soldier-authors writing about the state of military affairs were serious professionals, whose observations were anchored in reality and not in the traditions of the medieval chivalric romance.22 While she did not deny that some authors were hacks, more interested in profit than advancing military theory, Donagan observed that most of these writers were former professional soldiers, fresh from European service and happy to engage in polemical discussions about the nature of modern warfare. Military books, by her estimation, were an integral part of English military culture and very influential in helping prepare men for war in the summer of 1642. Charles Carlton also touched on the influence of military books in Going to the Wars, his study of soldiering in the wars of the Three Kingdoms. Carlton found that alongside the books of merit, works like John Cruso’s Militarie Instructions for the cavallrie (1632) and William Barriffe’s Military Discipline: Or, The Yong Artillery Man (1635) there were a number of English works that he deemed “next to useless.”23 Included in this list were Gervase Markham’s The Souldier’s Exercise (1639), a compendium of two of Markham’s early works, The Souldier’s Grammar (1625) and The Souldier’s Accidence (1628), and Edward Cooke’s The Character of Warre (1626) and his Prospective Glasse of Warre (1628).24 Carlton also noted that gentlemen found the longer analytical treatises (books that covered all aspects of war, from infantry tactics to siegecraft) to be of greater value in the field, owing to the fact that these books covered a wider range of possibilities that soldiers might confront in war. While this may well have been the case for officers, we should not overlook
Donagan, “Halcyon Days and the Literature of War,” 67. Ibid., 99. 23 C. Carlton, Going to the Wars: The Experience of the British Civil Wars, 1638–1651 (London: Routledge, 1992), 71. 24 Ibid., 71–2. 21 22
10
introduction
the significance of the drill manual in training English soldiers in the lower ranks, a subject that, until now, has been overlooked.25 As studies of the wars of the Three Kingdoms continue to multiply, attention is now being paid to areas of the conflict that have been neglected by historians, particularly matters related to military leadership and siege warfare. Though narratives and battle studies remain popular with amateur historians, re-enactors, and members of the academic community, many of these new studies have seen fit to build on the work of Donagan and others, including discussions of the influence of military books on the education and training of soldiers recruited to fight in the English Civil War. Roger Manning has recently argued in favour of a robust aristocratic military ethos in early modern England, one that includes rather than excludes members of the aristocracy. Manning’s English “swordsmen” not only educated themselves in the martial arts by serving abroad, but they also spent time reading a wide variety of titles related to warfare and the military arts. Citing the explosion of military books in the period, Manning points out that, military treatises, manuals on the exercise of arms, translations of classical writers and historians on military topics, newsbooks and newspapers, sermons preached to military societies, depictions of war in graphic arts, not to mention chivalric romances—all testify to the spreading militarization of both aristocratic and popular cultures.26
This interest translated into more effective soldiers and more effective leaders on the battlefield, a point that Stanley Carpenter has examined in his Military Leadership in the British Civil Wars, 1642–1651. Carpenter explores the factors affecting military leadership during the war, a subject he describes as the “missing link” in the historiography of early Stuart England.27 Carpenter, like Manning, argues that members of the aristocracy and gentry read military books in the 1620s and 1630s, making England home to “a vibrant literary tradition about military matters on the eve of the wars.”28 Book study, Carpenter asserts, exposed experienced and amateur officers to the “latest thinking on drill, tactics,
25 See Chapter 3 for a detailed study of the evolution of the printed drill manual in England. 26 R. Manning, Swordsmen: The Martial Ethos in the Three Kingdoms (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2003), 35. 27 S. Carpenter, Military Leadership in the British Civil Wars, 1642–1651 (London: Frank Cass, 2005), 2. 28 Ibid., 55.
introduction
11
and training.”29 In All The King’s Armies, Stuart Reid goes even further, contending that printing and the availability of analytical treatises and drill manuals “revolutionised warfare,” often giving inexperienced officers a valuable (and possibly life-saving) resource on which to draw as battle neared.30 More recently, in his Rethinking Military History, Jeremy Black made the case that books on war not only influenced the evolution of the military profession, but had a significant impact on public opinion. Printing and literacy, Black claims, contributed to the development of a military public, in the sense of a public informed about military affairs and a military interested in public comment on their activities . . . Printing, nevertheless, was important in strengthening the consciousness of a specific military tradition, not the least as printed manuals on gunnery, tactics, drill, siegecraft, and fortification spread techniques far more rapidly than word of mouth or manuscript. Manuals also permitted a degree of standardization that both helped to increase military effectiveness and was important for cohesion and utilization of military resources. More generally, printing and literacy fostered discussion of military organization and methods, and encouraged a sense of system.31
As I noted, historians of print culture have also provided us with some useful tools for understanding how military books were disseminated and received by soldiers and the public. These scholars are exploring military books as objects and as products of early modern print culture, and are also examining soldiers and statesmen as readers of these works. Anna Simoni has written a number of bibliographical studies of late sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century military literature that address patronage and production of military books, the printing of newsbooks and maps related to war, and the printing of foreign military books in the Low Countries.32 In “A Present for a Prince” she described the editions of Jacques De Gheyn’s Exercise of Armes (1607/08) that were dedicated to Prince Henry and the appeal of the new drill manual in the
Ibid. S. Reid, All the King’s Armies: A Military History of the English Civil War 1642–1651 (Stapelhurst, UK: Spellmount, 1998), 3. 31 J. Black, Rethinking Military History (London: Routledge, 2004), 151–2. For a discussion of the influence of printed newsbooks and manuscript works on warfare on public attitudes towards English participation in continental warfare in the period 1477–1559, see S. Gunn, D. Grummitt, and H. Cools, War, State and Society in England and the Netherlands, 1477–1559 (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2007), 257–72. 32 A. Simoni, The Ostend Story: Early Tales of the Great Siege and the Mediating Role of Henrick van Haestens (’t Goy-Houten: Hes & de Graaf, 2003). 29 30
12
introduction
Low Countries and in England.33 In her “Soldier’s Tales: Observations on Italian Military Books Published at Antwerp in the Early 17th Century,” Simoni weighed the international dimensions of Low Countries printing, citing the Italian, English, Spanish, and Dutch military books that were being produced in the Netherlands for the express purpose of meeting the demands of soldiers fighting there.34 Like González de Leon’s Spanish soldiers, Simoni found that Italian soldiers serving in the Spanish army were both authors and readers and that printers in Antwerp were keenly aware of the fact that foreign military books were marketable to soldiers of all nations who were fighting in the Dutch Revolt. Similarly, Jean Tsushima’s important study, “Members of the Stationers’ Company Who Served in the Artillery Company before the Civil War; Ralph Mabbe and his Network,” describes a similar awareness of the marketability of military books by London printers, a number of whom were also members of the Honourable Artillery Company. These printers published military books and manuals for members of the Artillery Company and the other London artillery gardens, as well as printing books intended for an audience of volunteer soldiers who were making their way to the United Provinces.35 Tsushima reveals that the London printers she investigated were training with the Artillery Company and were also responsible for shepherding the works of their fellow soldiers into press. Others scholars of print culture have been looking more closely at the ownership of books by soldiers and how military books may have been read by statesmen or by secretaries who served the great men responsible for the formulation of state policy. Vernon Snow’s “Inventory of the Lord General’s Library, 1646,” revealed that Robert Devereux, the third earl of Essex had a large library, numbering 157 books.36 Essex’s library included works on classical warfare, such as Caesar’s Commentaries, books on chivalry, histories of the Low Countries wars, and works on personal 33 A. Simoni, “A Present for a Prince,” in Ten Studies in Anglo-Dutch Relations, ed. J. van Dorsten, (London: Oxford University Press, 1974), 51–71. 34 A. Simoni, “Soldiers’ Tales: Observations on Italian Military Books Published at Antwerp in the Early 17th Century,” in The Italian Book 1465–1800, ed. D. Rhodes and D. Reidy, (London: British Library, 1993), 255–90. 35 J. Tsushima, “Members of the Stationers’ Company Who Served in Artillery Company before the Civil War; Ralphe Mabbe and his Network,” in The Stationers’ Company and the Book Trade 1550 –1990, ed. R. Myers and M. Harris, (Winchester: St. Paul’s Bibliographies, 1997), 65–92. 36 V. Snow, “An Inventory of the Lord General’s Library, 1646,” The Library, 3rd series, 21, (1966): 115–23.
introduction
13
defence, though the earl does not appear to have owned any works specifically dedicated to modern warfare. Walter Oakeshott, “Sir Walter Ralegh’s Library” and G.R. Batho’s “The Library of the ‘Wizard’ Earl: Henry Percy Ninth Earl of Northumberland (1564–1632)” found that military books were present in the libraries of both men and that Ralegh most likely borrowed military books from Northumberland while the two were imprisoned in the Tower by James I.37 Recent studies by Lisa Jardine, written with Anthony Grafton and with William Sherman, have shown that late Elizabethan secretaries, such as Gabriel Harvey and Henry Wotten, often turned to classical and modern military books as part of their “goal-directed” studies which were meant to better inform their noble patrons when they made policy decisions. Jardine and Grafton’s article, “How Gabriel Harvey Read His Livy” is one of the best studies to date on how the secretary acted as an intermediary between the book and the patron, and how men like Harvey drew on the lessons found in military books to influence and assist those they advised.38 Jardine and Grafton demonstrate that Harvey, the secretary to the earl of Leicester, read from a range of English and European books on the arte militarie and shared his knowledge of military strategy not only with Leicester, but with other members of Leicester’s circle who came to the earl’s household to debate military and foreign policy. Jardine and Sherman’s article “Pragmatic readers: knowledge transactions and scholarly services in late Elizabethan England” further adds to our understanding of the court circles and the military discussions that took place among public figures. Jardine and Sherman note that towards the end of Elizabeth’s reign, “efficient knowledge gathering was an integral part of the activities of those jostling for power, and scholarly readers and their ‘knowledge transactions’ had become a recognized part of these bids for power.”39 When it came to offering advice on military affairs, those eager to engage in these knowledge
37 W. Oakeshott, “Sir Walter Ralegh’s Library,” The Library, 5th series, 23 (1968): 285–327. G. Batho, “The Library of the ‘Wizard’ Earl: Henry Percy Ninth Earl of Northumberland (1564–1632),” The Library, 5th series, 15 (1960): 246–61. 38 L. Jardine and A. Grafton, “How Gabriel Harvey Read His Livy,” Past and Present 129 (Nov. 1990): 30–78. 39 L. Jardine and W. Sherman, “Pragmatic Readers: Knowledge Transactions and Scholarly Services in Late Elizabethan England,” in Religion, Culture and Society in Early Modern England: A Festschrift for Patrick Collinson, ed. P. Roberts and A. Fletcher, (Cambridge University Press, 1994), 106.
14
introduction
transactions naturally turned to works by well-respected English and foreign military authors. With The Complete Soldier, I build on the work carried out by military historians and historians of print culture and book history in the examination of the influence of military books and manuals on shaping military practice in the early Stuart period. I am concerned with how books on the military arts informed English readers about the changes shaping continental warfare, about their use in the knowledge transactions taking place in military circles in England and on the continent and the contributions made, and connections forged, by the veterans who authored these works, the London military societies where they often trained, and the members of the London book trade who printed their books. If we are to fully understand how the theory and practice of war was formulated by Englishmen in the years leading up to the Civil War, we cannot weigh military books in isolation, but we must see them as products of the relations between these various groups. The first two chapters of this book provide an overview of military culture in late Tudor and early Stuart England. Chapter One examines the military circles of gentlemen soldiers formed in the late Tudor period and the education of soldiers who were fighting in the Low Countries and in Ireland before the accession of James I. The English decision to enter the Low Countries wars in 1585 had far-reaching implications for English military culture and I have examined it for that reason. Many of the country’s leading nobles, such as the earls of Leicester, Essex, and Oxford made their way to the Netherlands to fight for the Protestant cause, and in no time, the Low Countries became the place where most English soldiers received their baptism of fire. English entry into the war in the Low Countries also led to the production of a number of late Elizabethan military treatises which were meant to assist soldiers headed for the Netherlands. By the 1580s and 1590s, instructional literature was being seen as a useful aid in military training, a development similar to the use of didactic manuals in other fields and professions in England. As Chapter One will show, Englishmen had no problems finding and purchasing the latest foreign military literature which they read along with works printed in England. Chapter Two explores the important English military circles formed from 1603–1625. Veterans of the Elizabethan wars remained in the Low Countries after James I came to the throne in 1603 and many of the gentlemen soldiers who had relied upon the military patronage of the earls of Leicester and Essex now sought out new military patrons.
introduction
15
This new generation of military patrons included the Veres, Francis and Horace, and James I’s eldest son, Henry Frederick, Prince of Wales. The Vere circle could be found in the Low Countries, while Henry’s court at St. James’s Palace became, for a short time, England’s answer to the continental military court. Though Henry’s court never rivalled the courts of Henri IV or France or the Stadtholder of Orange, Maurice of Nassau, it did become home to many soldiers who hoped that England might adopt a more bellicose foreign policy. With the death of Henry in 1612, his court dispersed, but many of those who had attended the prince, notably Sir Horace Vere, Sir Edward Cecil, and Sir Edward Conway, remained influential in shaping military policy and went on to advocate the introduction of the Jacobean government’s drill manual, the Instructions for Musters and Armes, And the use thereof, in 1623. This chapter assesses how books were part of the education of these soldiers and how the young prince, in particular, began to amass an extensive library of works on military subjects and become a patron of military authors and soldiers alike. Chapter Three describes the evolution of the early Stuart drill manual. A product of the Dutch reforms in infantry drill that marked the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries, the first printed drill manuals in the English language were introduced by private authors, eager to see Netherlandish drill assimilated into English practice. The first detailed description of Dutch drill can be found in Clement Edmondes, The Maner of Our Moderne Training (1600), an appendix to his Observations vpon the five bookes of Caesars Commentaries which appeared in print three years before the The Exercise of Armes, the English translation of Jacques de Gheyn’s Wapenhandlinghe van roers musquetten ende spiessen, printed in The Hague in 1607. A number of copies of de Gheyn’s postures for musket, caliver, and pike soon appeared on broadsheets and in manuals that were products of the exercises taking place at the muster grounds of London’s military companies. Low Countries veterans often returned to London, the heart of early Stuart military culture, and trained alongside gentlemen soldiers at the artillery gardens and military yards at Bishopsgate, Cripplegate, and Westminster. It was in these military societies that friendships and business relations were forged between London’s soldiers and London’s printers; relationships that facilitated the publication of a range of military books. The appearance of private manuals in the early 1620s spurred on the Jacobean Privy Council, backed by members of the Council of War, to print and distribute the Instructions for Musters and Armes in 1623. This manual
16
introduction
became the foundation for later English manuals of arms that formed the basis for infantry practice throughout the Civil War. Chapter Four examines the analytical treatises dedicated to infantry warfare. Works on infantry warfare accounted for the bulk of the books and manuals that could be found in the complete soldier’s library. The English considered themselves foot soldiers, and military writers, wary of market forces, produced most of their titles for an audience of infantrymen. Analytical treatises were books that set out the general rules and precepts on all facets of the art of war, and while some works were dedicated solely to infantry, and to a lesser extent cavalry tactics, other more comprehensive books, such as Robert Ward’s Anima’dversions Of Warre (1639), addressed infantry, cavalry, gunnery, and siege warfare. These longer, detailed works were popular before and during the Civil War, especially among gentlemen officers who believed, as Carlton notes, that the answers to many of the questions that might be faced in the field could be found in the pages of these treatises. Chapter Five details the futile efforts to reform the English cavalry in the early seventeenth century and the limited impact that printed instructions appear to have had on the training of the militia. The matter of mounted warfare in early Stuart England is a complex one. At home, interest in improving the state of the horse companies in the trained bands was lackluster if not downright abysmal between 1603 and 1642, with gentlemen quite content to neglect their duties in this regard. While the elite enjoyed riding horses for pleasure—both James I and Charles I were avid horsemen—there was little impetus in the provinces to improve the horse companies of the trained bands or to develop martial prowess on horseback. This disinterest translated into a dearth of military books on the subject of cavalry, though it should be said that some authors did broach the topic in their analytical treatises. Not surprisingly, there were only two books on mounted warfare, Cruso’s Militarie instructions for the cavallrie (1632) and John Vernon’s The Young-Horseman or the Honest plain-dealing Cavalier (1644) that were printed during the period covered by this study. This is the only area where printed matter appears to have had little or no influence on the evolution of English military practice before 1645. Yet when one looks at the state of English cavalry abroad, in the Low Countries and in Ireland, we see its regular, and even its successful employment in battles and skirmishes. While it has been called the trump card in Ireland in the Nine Years’ War, another study of the English army in the early modern period claimed that both England and Scotland “supplied insignificant
introduction
17
numbers of cavalrymen” to the Dutch army in the Netherlands.40 The English cavalry that did fight at the battles of Turnhout and Nieuwpoort did so with distinction and cavalry detachments continued to serve in the Dutch army throughout the early Stuart period. But we do not see the same emphasis on improving training using the Dutch methods of cavalry in quite the same way that we see that influence impact on infantry training. Finally, Chapter Six discusses the English books on siegecraft printed in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth century. Unlike their European neighbours, the English did not see the need to construct elaborate fortifications to protect their towns, owing primarily to the natural defences the country was afforded as an island nation. But over the course of the period examined in this study, English volunteers increasingly faced bastioned fortifications on the continent and when they returned home, some wrote of their experiences and informed their countrymen of the methods used to attack and defend these great siege works. Sieges in the Low Countries caught the attention of English audiences, and amateur and professional soldiers alike began to realize that knowledge of siegecraft and gunnery were essential for those who followed the wars.
40 For the discussion of cavalry in Ireland, see D. Trim, “Fin de siecle: The English Soldier’s Experience at the End of the Sixteenth Century,” Military and Naval History Journal 10 ( July 1999), 8. On the effectiveness of English cavalry in the Low Countries see R. Manning, An Apprenticeship in Arms: The Origins of the British Army 1585 –1702 (Oxford University Press, 2006), 55.
CHAPTER ONE
“CAESAR TO THIS PRESENT DAY OF KING JAMES”: MILITARY BOOKS AND MILITARY CULTURE, 1572–1603 I pray GOD rayse vp many such mindes, to make our Country of all Nations the most happy: and also that thys worke may stirre vppe the harts of all Noble men, Gentlemen, and all other her Maiesties subjects that minde to professe Armes, that by the exercise of the same they may be better instructed with greater skill, and so with theyr manly and valiant mindes, to the defence of our most gracious sovereigne. Thomas Garrard’s Dedication to Robert Devereux, the 2nd earl of Essex in William Garrard’s The Arte of Warre (1591)
The proliferation of military manuals in late sixteenth- and early seventeenth-century England was part of an ongoing effort taking place across the European continent to quantify the known military world. Analytical treatises and drill manuals dedicated to the arte militarie provided readers with a body of knowledge and a set of rules on a broad range of military activities. But who used these books and what role did military literature play in the education of the “complete” English soldier in this period? I begin to answer this question by exploring the relationships that were established and fostered among gentlemen soldiers in England and on the continent and by examining the books that soldiers possessed and the titles they recommended to friends and comrades. As we will see, men of noble birth dispensed their patronage to scholars and writers and allowed their homes to become centres of learning and repositories for large libraries that included the latest works on military affairs. While we know that books are not always read by their owners, we can get a picture of which titles were influential by examining library catalogues, estate inventories, personal letters, and contemporary accounts and then recording those books repeatedly singled out by English readers. As I demonstrate in this chapter, books on the military arts were easy to acquire and letters often record friends offering advice and suggestions on new titles and recommendations of passages or chapters that illuminated specific tactics, practices, or theories on the art of war. Secretaries cited examples from ancient and modern military
20
chapter one
books in support of the foreign and domestic policies carried out of by their influential patrons. Circles of soldiers and scholars discussed the changes shaping warfare and arranged for young sons or relatives to meet with leading continental generals or captains when they were on their European tours. As one might expect, different readers could draw entirely different lessons from these books. Soldiers headed for the continent read in order to understand more about the tactics and weapons of their allies and their enemies, captains and lieutenants in the trained bands took what they could from these books to assist them in training the young men in the county militias, while courtiers, diplomats, and scholars searched the pages of military books for advice on just war, foreign policy, and, if I might use a truly modern term, the improvement of homeland security. The transformation of European warfare during the sixteenth century required that soldiers learn the new lexicon of warfare and those assigned the task of commanding armies were expected to adapt to the various changes to technology and tactics.1 These “moderne” principles and practices of warfare, described by many contemporaries as “newfangled,” fostered the development of a new aristocratic military ethos, an ethos that was an intermediary step between the agonistic warfare of the medieval period and the more formalized, professionalism of the
1 The transformation of European warfare, more popularly known as the early modern military revolution, continues to be debated among historians and this study was greatly influenced by the seminal works on the subject, including Michael Roberts’s “The Military Revolution, 1560–1660,” in The Military Revolution Debate, ed. C. Rogers (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1995); Gustavus Adolphus: A History of Sweden 1626–1632, vols. 1–2 (London: Longmans, 1957); and “Gustav Adolphus and the Art of War,” in Essays in Swedish History, ed. M. Roberts (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1967). Geoffrey Parker’s The Army of Flanders and the Spanish Road, 1567–1659 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1972) and his influential The Military Revolution: Military Innovation and the Rise of the West, 1500–1800 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1988) set the tone for the debate and sparked a cottage industry devoted the subject of the military revolution. A detailed discussion of these debates falls outside the focus of this study, though the conclusions drawn in the pages that follow suggest that the English were eager to keep pace with the changes in military technology and tactics, though I believe those changes to have been more evolutionary than revolutionary. For a discussion of England’s role in the transformation of European warfare during this period, see G. Phillips, The Anglo-Scots Wars 1513–1550 (Woodbridge, UK: Boydell Press, 1999); D. Eltis, The Military Revolution in the Sixteenth Century (London: Tauris Academic Studies, 1995); and M.C. Fissel, English Warfare 1511–1642 (London: Routledge, 2001).
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
21
state-commission armies of the eighteenth century.2 This new ethos took shape over the course of the sixteenth century and represented a change in the nature, but not necessarily the meaning, of military leadership. As war grew in complexity, members of the military profession where expected to be familiar with all aspects of the art of war, be it infantry and cavalry tactics, siegecraft, the placing of artillery or encamping, and victualling. Those in command were increasingly being called upon to lead and equally important, to manage armies. Thomas Arnold has suggested that warfare in the early modern period had become an intellectual problem and it was expected that task-oriented officers would be able to draw up orders, read maps, oversee the recruitment and maintenance of armies, and work alongside engineers and gunners during siege operations. According to Arnold, “the moment infantry tactics became a problem for educated military men, as happened in Italy for the early sixteenth century; they naturally went about the problem in the manner of intellectuals; they talked, they corresponded, they wrote and they published.”3 By the late sixteenth century, Englishmen were enthusiastically embracing the intellectualization of warfare and advocating the study of the military discipline and the establishment of academies devoted to the training of young noblemen for war. In 1570 Sir Humphrey Gilbert, in an early attempt to facilitate the transformation of warfare in England, proposed a curriculum for educating wards and the sons of nobles and gentry at his Queen Elizabeth’s Academy. Gilbert’s programme was meant to prepare young students for civil and military service. Well educated and praised for his intellect, Gilbert attended Eton and at Oxford in the 1550s before going to war on the continent. The half-brother of Walter Ralegh, Gilbert was a hardened veteran by 1570 when he drew up the curriculum. He had first served the Huguenot cause in France in 1562 before making his way to Ireland where he earned a reputation for his brutality against the Irish rebels and the native population. Following his service in the Irish wars, Gilbert took command of the second volunteer force that arrived in Netherlands in 1572. Gilbert’s days at Oxford taught him that it was the job of
2 A description of the characteristics of the aggregate contract and state-commission armies can be found in John A. Lynn’s, “The Evolution of Army Style in the Modern West 800–2000,” International History Review 18, no. 3 (Aug. 1996): 505–45. 3 T. Arnold, The Renaissance at War (London: Cassell & Co., 2001), 64.
22
chapter one
university to train scholars, not soldiers or statesmen. “Schole clerkes,” he wrote, were “not always the wisest men” with their days at Oxford and Cambridge often spent in “idleness and licentiousness.”4 Military service on the continent and in Ireland had shown Gilbert that practical skills were also essential to a gentlemen’s education and for this reason, students at the academy were expected to study “matters of accion meet for present practize, both of peace and war.”5 Those who did not wish to pursue an education in letters would be expected to study martial activities. In the end, Gilbert’s proposal for the academy failed, but its curriculum, innovative by the standards of the day, reflected an understanding of the growing complexity of warfare and recognized the importance of teaching warfare’s theoretical and practical aspects. Military history and modern military theory were to be taught, as were subjects related to siegecraft and military architecture. Students were expected to understand the “manner of forces they had and have, and what were and are distinct disciplines and kindes of arminge, training and maintaining, of their soldiers in every particular kind of service.”6 One of the goals of the academy was to produce perfect or complete soldiers, versed in theory and skilled in arms of various sorts. Gilbert’s young charges were to be taught to handle the harquebus, to practize in the said Achademie all kindes of Skirmishinges, Imbattelinges, and sondery kindes of marchinges, apointinge amonge them, some one tyme, and some another, to supply the roames of Captaines and other officers, Which they may very well exercise without armes and with light staves, in steade of Pikes and Holbeardes, being yearely allowed for the same.7
Gilbert’s academy may well have failed because it was ahead of its time. Academies to train young nobles and provide officers for the army opened in Italy and Germany in the first decades of the seventeenth century with curricula similar to Gilbert’s.8 All these schools were short lived, closing in most cases because of a lack of funding. 4 H. Gilbert, Queene Elizabethes achademy: a booke of precedence, etc. (Millwood, NY: Kraus Reprint Co., 1973), 3 and 10. 5 Ibid., 10. 6 Ibid., 2–3. 7 Ibid., 5. 8 See J.R. Hale, “The Military Education of the Officer Class,” 228–9. Hale notes the creation of four schools in Italy between 1608 and 1610. These were located in Padua, Verona, Udine, and Treviso.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
23
Consequently, gentlemen intent on volunteering for service abroad and eager to learn more about the arte militarie were best served by turning to military books. Ancient military writers had long been considered the best source of information on military affairs but by the end of the century, tutors were increasingly recommending works by modern military theorists. This chapter examines the development of English military culture in the period 1572 to 1603, looking at the circles of English gentlemen soldiers who served abroad in the “schooles of warre” in the Netherlands, Ireland, France, and Germany and the influence that military books and manuals had on shaping their knowledge of military discipline. A cursory examination of the late sixteenth century in this first chapter is necessary to establish the connections (and continuities) between military practice and military culture in the reigns of Elizabeth I and James I. The military circles formed at the end of Elizabeth’s reign continued to be influential in the first decade of Jacobean rule and the military writers who were part of these circles continued to contribute to discussions about the military arts well into the first quarter of the seventeenth century. Matriculating in the Schoole of Warre: English Entry into the Low Countries War At the end of the 1570s, three English soldiers serving in the Netherlands took a respite from the fighting and put down their swords to take up pen and paper, each urging his fellow countrymen to take heed of the struggle occurring in the Low Countries between the Dutch rebels and their Spanish overlords. Two of the three, Geffrey Gates and William Blandy were at the time serving together as volunteers, while it is unclear whether the third, Thomas Churchyard, was familiar with either Gates or Blandy. Churchyard, then in his fifties, had been a soldier since the late 1530s, fighting with the earl of Surrey in France in 1537 and later in Scotland and Germany in the 1560s, before eventually making his way to the Netherlands.9 Gates, the son of an Essex gentleman joined the ranks of Sir John Norris’s company that left for the Low Countries
9 R. Lyne, ‘Churchyard, Thomas (1523?–1604)’ Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, Sept. 2004; online edn., May 2006.
24
chapter one
in 1578. We know little of Gates’s early life beyond the fact that he, like Blandy, was educated at the Inns of Court. Gates matriculated at Lincoln’s Inn in 1566 while Blandy arrived at the Middle Temple in 1571. By the late 1570s all three men could be counted among the hundreds of English volunteers serving in companies supporting the Dutch rebellion. Their treatises, Churchyard’s A Lamentable, and pitifull Description of the wofull warres in Flanders (1578), Gates’s The defence of militarie profession (1579), and Blandy’s The Castle, or picture of policy . . . (1581) were polemical, written to warn English readers that the war in the Netherlands could have far-reaching implications not only for the Protestant faith and the Dutch people but also for the English Queen and her subjects. The English, they urged, must prepare themselves for war or they too might soon fall under the Spanish yoke. Thomas Churchyard contributed two works to the discourse on the Low Countries war, A Lamentable, and pitifull Description of the wofull warres in Flanders printed in 1578 and A generall rehearsall of warres, which followed a year later.10 Both tracts justified English participation in the conflict, with the Description of the wofull warres in Flanders giving a history of the military campaigns in the Netherlands dating from the wars of Charles V in the 1540s and A general rehearsall of warres offering an account of the events surrounding the outbreak of the Dutch Revolt and its progress up to 1579. Churchyard was an experienced soldier and he showered great praise on the English soldiers for their repeated acts of valour in combat, singling out those gentlemen who, “without the knowledge of our Prince, and hir highnesse honorable Council, stole by secreate meanes, out of England to Flushing, for the whiche at their returne home againe, they were a long while frowned upon, and could not come in Court.”11 At the time Churchyard’s treatises were being printed, Elizabeth I had yet to commit an army to the Netherlands though many of her loyal subjects had already volunteered for service with the Dutch. The intention of Churchyard’s treatises was to herald the success of these men, describing the contributions of Sir Humphrey Gilbert and Captain Thomas Morgan, each of whom led companies to the Low Countries in 1572, as well as “many other Captaines and
10 T. Churchyard, A Lamentable, and pitifull Description of the wofull warres in Flanders (London: Henry Bynneman for Ralph Newberry, 1578) and A generall rehearsall of warres, called Churchyardes choise wherein is fiue hundred seuerall seruices of land and sea as seiges, battailes, skirmiches, and encounters (London: John Kingston for Edward White, 1579). 11 Churchyard, A Lamentable, and pitifull Description, 54.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
25
Gentlemen” who followed them and served with valour and honour. Churchyard had great admiration for these gentlemen volunteers who had risked their lives, and it was believed, their position at court by aiding the Protestant cause abroad. In A generall rehearsall of warres Churchyard linked the contingents serving in the Low Countries in the 1570s with their countrymen who fought with Henry VIII, looking back on the bygone age as a time when “all Chevalrie was cherished, Souldiers made of, and manhoode so much esteemed, that he was thought happie and most valiaunt, that fought credite by the exercise of Armes, and discipline of warre.”12 Geffrey Gates issued his own warning cry to the English people in his The defence of militarie profession, advising his audience that the oppressive treatment of the Dutch citizenry by the army of the duke of Alva, whom Gates described as the “dreadful and renowned chieftaine of the Papists,” was just a glimpse of the fate awaiting England if her soldiers were not trained up in the military discipline. The occupation of the Low Countries by Spanish forces, the execution of the Dutch nobles Egmont and Horne and the introduction of the Inquisition into the Netherlands was further evidence of the “arrogant domination of so implacable people as bee the Spanyards.”13 As Gates saw it, the English Church and English liberties were threatened by this foreign evil, and his pamphlet was meant to “warneth England to waken it selfe out of securitie, and to be watchfull, and wisely to take it selfe.”14 Gates believed that the only way that the English could be assured of security in the future was to improve their military capabilities in the present. Only by advancing the military profession at home could England repress and restrain the “tyrannies and noyfull malice of the wicked.” His months of service had taught him “to love and to honour armes, and in zeale of a good heart to covet the advancement of martial occupation.” So angered was Gates by the tyrannies he witnessed, that his inability to write did not deter him from calling upon a notary “to sette down in writing this draft in the defence and praise of warlike prowess.”15
Churchyard, A generall rehearsall of warres, sig. A.i. G. Gates, The defence of militarie profession, Wherein is eloquently shewed the due commendation of martiall prowesse, and plainly proved how necessary the exercise of armes is for this our age (London: Henry Middleton for John Harrison, 1579), 26. 14 Ibid., 6. 15 Ibid. 12 13
26
chapter one
William Blandy agreed with both Churchyard and Gates that the military profession and martial prowess must be put to better use in defence of the Protestant faith and England’s sovereign prince. In The Castle, or picture of policy . . ., a dialogue with his comrade Gates, Blandy wrote that those who had made the sacrifice in the “cause of our countrye” were to be considered truly honourable men. They that venture theyr lives for these poyntes, are appointed in the right course and race of true honor: for that they obtayne the true and undoubted end of vertue: wherefore all other that purpose unto themselves riches fame and glory depending on the content of the unlettered multitude, and respect not the true soveraygne good, they are rather to be accompted men puff upp with vayne desire, and ambition, then valiant and courageous men.16
In his treatise, Blandy sought to more closely tie the fate of the Prince with that of the soldier. Without the military profession, the state could easily fall into decay and those states on the brink of extinction could only be brought back to life when stability was restored. This could only be done through the establishment of law and order, accomplished under the firm rule of the prince and aided by a well-armed and well-ordered army. For Blandy, the soldier served two purposes, first executing the sovereign’s will “upon the offender at home, and in the Citty” and second, by wreaking “the indignation of the Prince in the field, upon the body of the enemy.”17 Order at home and protection against external threats were thus the only means of securing and preserving the commonwealth; a failure to secure either threat could have dire consequences for the sovereign and her people. Churchyard, Gates, and Blandy recognized that the Englishmen who had already volunteered for service in the army of the States General were helping to turn back the Spanish threat before it reached England’s shores. Their call to arms was meant to attract more gentlemen volunteers to serve in the Netherlands but also bring about improvements to military training in England. From their vantage point all three believed the time for talk had ended and the time for action had arrived. Gates best summed up those feelings, urging that
16 W. Blandy, The Castle, or picture of policy shewing forth most lively, the face, body and partes of a commonwealth . . . (London: John Daye, 1581), 12. 17 Ibid., 15.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
27
when Preaching, professe, plee or persuasion cannot prevaile, in reforming the evils and outrages of the wicked: then must the sword of violence be put in execution, by the hands of them that are able and skilfull to abate and to extinquish the furies of tumults and Rebellions and either to bring to obedience the disordered multitude or else to cut them off from the earth, that peace and civill justice may possesse and rule all the lande, to the restitution and preservation of domestical concord and Societie, without the which mankinde should decay from the face of the earth, & the rest that remained in the worlde, should be in more miserable state then the wild beasts of the desert.18
Many Englishmen heeded the call and over the next forty years thousands of gentlemen volunteered for service in the Low Countries and other foreign fields, in effect forming the core of an English standing army. The constant presence of these soldiers on the continent helped to maintain and shape English military culture at home, infusing it with new tactics and techniques. That army began to take shape on December 9, 1585, the day two fleets set sail from England bound for the Low Countries. A Dutch fleet, recently arrived from the Netherlands, departed from London carrying companies of soldiers raised from the English counties, while an English fleet, under the command of Admiral William Borough, left from Harwich carrying Robert Dudley, the earl of Leicester, his servants, and a contingent of 1585 English troops.19 Among the soldiers accompanying the English fleet were ninety-two gentlemen of quality, men who would serve as regimental colonels and company captains, some of whom would distinguish themselves on the battlefield, while others who would not.20 As Churchyard had reminded his readers six years earlier, the first gentlemen who made their way to the Low Countries had done so for the sake of “knowledge, fame and entertainment” and those travelling with Leicester’s force were no different. Elizabeth’s decision to send the expeditionary force had been a difficult one for the Gates, The defence of militarie profession, 10. G.B. Harrison, The Life and Death of Robert Devereux Earl of Essex (New York: Henry Holt, 1937), 11. 20 For a list of those gentlemen who were part of Leicester’s expedition see R. Strong and J.A. Van Dorsten, eds., Leicester’s Triumph (Leiden: Thomas Browne Institute, 1964), appendix 3, 108–134. Included among the ranks were the Elizabethan figures such as Peregrine Bertie, Christopher Blount, Sir John Conway, father of Edward Conway, Sir Thomas Heneage, William Knollys, Sir Robert Jermyn, William Russell, Robert and Philip Sidney, Sir Henry Unton, Sir Edmund Uvedale, and the writer George Whetstone, who died in a duel with Uvedale outside of Bergen-Op-Zoom in the Netherlands in 1587. 18 19
28
chapter one
Queen. She was wary of openly supporting rebellion against a fellow monarch, Philip II, and she also feared that entering into a lengthy war with Europe’s most powerful state might drain the treasury in much the same way it had depleted her father’s coffers. Yet the encirclement of Antwerp by the duke of Parma’s army in the summer of 1585 had left Elizabeth with no choice but to send troops to the Low Countries in support of the Dutch cause, a decision that was formally ratified with the signing of the Treaty of Nonsuch in August, the same month that Antwerp fell to Parma. The treaty, later described by Thomas Digges, Leicester’s muster-master general, in his Briefe Report of the Militarie Services Done in the Low Countries (1587) as a grant unto the States General of a “large and bountifull aide of men and money,” set the size of the English expeditionary force at 5000 foot and 1000 horse and had also named Leicester as the expedition’s lord general. The signing of the Treaty of Nonsuch was a victory for the militant “political Puritans” in Elizabeth’s Privy Council, men like Leicester, Philip Sidney, Francis Walsingham, the earl of Bedford, Francis Knollys, and Walter Mildmay, who were able to convince Elizabeth that the Spanish military presence in the Low Countries could no longer be ignored and had to be confronted.21 After more than a decade of indecision regarding English military involvement in the Dutch Revolt, the signing of the Treaty of Nonsuch and the decision to dispatch Leicester’s expeditionary force had finally formalized the Anglo-Dutch military relationship. A “small and little troupe” of English volunteers initially arrived in the Low Countries in June of 1572, disembarking in Flushing to assist in the defence of the town. That force, described by Churchyard in A generall rehearsall of warres, was composed of 300 men led by Thomas Morgan, recruited and paid for by Walloon and Fleming exiles living in London.22 A second, larger force of 1100 men commanded by Sir Humphrey Gilbert arrived a month later, and included in its ranks Roger Williams, who would later go on to write two accounts of his long service in the Low Countries. Though Elizabeth publicly denied providing support 21 For a discussion of the debates surrounding the political and religious implications of English engagement in the Netherlands, see H. Dunthorne, “Resisting Monarchy: The Netherlands as Britain’s School of Revolution in the Late Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries,” in Royal Republican Sovereignty in Early Modern Europe, ed. R. Oresko, G.C. Gibbs, and H.M. Scott (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1997), 125–48. 22 J.A. Dop, Eliza’s Knights: Soldiers, Poets, and Puritans in the Netherlands, 1572–1586 (Alblasserdam: Remak, 1981), 142.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
29
for the force, Lord Burghley, Elizabeth’s principal secretary, was kept well informed about its activities through letters sent by Morgan and Gilbert.23 The government, though clearly interested in the impact these mercenaries might have on the situation in Flanders, took care to distance themselves from publicly backing the venture. Rather than engage in supporting the Dutch rebels in their fight with Philip II, the English mercenaries were instructed to stymie French interests in the region. With the intensification of the French wars of religion in the early 1570s, the threat posed to Flanders by the French dissipated, leaving the English with little option but to sell their services to either the Dutch or the Spaniards.24 This initial foray by English soldiers into the Low Countries met with little success, though there are repeated references to the valour of the English soldiers who served in support of rebels. The troops that were sent to Flushing were, for the most part, inexperienced and ill equipped to handle the rigours of war, especially against opponents as seasoned as the Spanish tercios. An anonymous soldier, writing in 1600, described the arrival of many young men and gentlemen from England, France, and Scotland shortly after the revolt began. These men were “no soldiers but onely rich merchants and artificers who both would and could give great entertainment unto such as would fight for them, for seldom valour and riches joyne together in one person except be he Noble.”25 The veteran Roger Williams, also writing some years after the fact, reported that about a third of Morgan’s men had served in Ireland, Scotland, or France, but described the rest as “rawe, look[ing] for no more than bare victuals, lodging, and promise of pay.”26 Williams spoke of the disorder in the ranks and also the fear among many soldiers during the surprise attack launched by the Spanish at Ter Goes in 1572. He blamed the failure of the English to take Sluys and Ter Goes as a product of the ignorance of the English commanders, who knew neither their “own estate, much lesse the enemies.”27 Yet the lack of success of these first contingents and the return of many of these troops to England at summer’s end did not seem 23 D. Caldecott-Baird, ed., The Expedition in Holland, 1572–1574 (London: Seeley Service, 1976), 6. 24 Ibid. 25 BL, Add. MS, 41615, ff. 8–9. 26 R. Williams, The Actions of the Lowe Countries (London: Humphrey Lownes for Mathew Lownes, 1618), 63. 27 Ibid., 76.
30
chapter one
to dampen the enthusiasm of the volunteers who followed in their footsteps, many of whom were motivated as much by religious ideology and the defence of Protestantism as they were by their thirst for adventure or the promises of wealth and glory. As David Trim has asserted in his article on the conduct of English soldiers in the Netherlands, among “many foreign Protestant soldiers in Dutch service, [the English] willingness to serve, their dedication to the cause, and their combat effectiveness all arose from religious conviction and apocalyptic, millenarian beliefs.”28 It was this ideological conviction, so evident in Gates’s The defence of militarie profession, that led the thousands of English volunteers to commit themselves to the cause of the Dutch rebellion in the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries. Religion acted as the glue that bound together many of the volunteers and it was also a significant factor in forging the circles of gentlemen soldiers who are the focus of this chapter. The bloody struggle between Catholic and Protestant on the continent in the 1570s, marked by the horrors of the St. Bartholomew’s Day massacre in August 1572 and Alva’s sack of Antwerp in 1574, heightened fears among England’s Protestants and strengthened their resolve to defend the reformed church through the exercise of arms. Between 1572 and the decision by Elizabeth to send troops to the Netherlands, English volunteers enlisted in the States army to defend the Protestant faith. John Lingham, clerk to Captain William Martin, wrote in 1584 that the English captains he had the pleasure to serve with in the Netherlands fought “for their conscience sake, & the glory of the Gospell.”29 Even before the arrival of Leicester’s expedition in 1585, Lingham could list thirty-seven captains who died in battles and skirmishes with the Spanish who had “spent their dearest blood” for the defence of England and the cause of Protestantism.30 While religion inspired many to volunteer for service abroad, the defence of the Elizabethan state also required that the ranks be filled by those who were not so enthusiastic about donning the corslet and taking up the pike. Contemporary observers could praise the worthy, 28 D. Trim, “Ideology, Greed and Social Discontent in Early Modern Europe: Mercenaries and Mutinies in the Rebellious Netherlands, 1568–1609,” in Rebellion, Repression, Reinvention: Mutiny in Comparative Perspective, ed. J. Hathaway, (London: Praeger, 2001), 47–61. 29 J. Lingham, A True Relation of all English Captains and Lieutenants as have been slain in the Low Countries, together with those now living: as also of such as are fled to the Enemie (London: Roger Ward, 1584). 30 Ibid., sig. A.2v.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
31
as Lingham did, but they could just as easily voice their unease over the quality of soldiers being sent abroad. It was common practice for county officials to clear the prisons and gaols of men when the call for new recruits went out, and while there were many who scorned the practice, it had long been the preferred method of ridding the counties of the unwanted, thereby saving those who contributed to the local economy from being sent off to war. Gates, for one, vigorously condemned the pressing of criminals and vagabonds, despising the fact that the English had, on more than one occasion, called out “the refuse of the people to be soldiers for the service of their Prince and countreie.”31 By drawing on the “worse sort of men,” the reputation of the military profession suffered and the English state, as Gates saw it, faced ruination if such scoundrels continued to be used to defend the country. A year before the Spanish Armada set sail the veteran Barnabe Rich, a vocal proponent of improving military training and a good friend of Churchyard’s, lamented that, when service happeneth we disburthen the prisons of Theeves, we robbe the Tavernes and Alehouses of Tolpottes, and Ruffines, wee scoure both Towne and Cuntrie of Rogges and vagabons. And is not a Captaine that is furnisht with such a company like to do great service, and to keepe them in good discipline. In other Countries where they use the service of malefactours, they admit them not for souldiours, but they send them to theyr Gallies and to other paces of like slavery.32
The Elizabethan government found, just as the Jacobean and Caroline governments would, that the task of finding quality recruits for military service, training them and keeping them in the ranks was fraught with an array of problems. Warfare Abroad and Reform at Home The presence of a large Spanish force in the Netherlands prompted concerns in England over the state of the militia—the force expected to repel any threat from abroad. As Lindsay Boynton and others have shown, Elizabeth’s government established the foundation for an effective
Gates, The defense of militarie profession, 18. B. Rich, A Path-Way to Military Practise (London: John Charlewood for Robert Walley, 1587), sig. C3v. 31
32
32
chapter one
militia system when the trained bands were introduced in 1572–3.33 The threat of foreign invasion was hardly a new concern for the English and prior to the creation of the bands various schemes and recommendations had been put forward to improve the arming and training of the county militias. The push for a change in the early 1570s had come as the result of the Dutch Revolt; the creation of the trained bands, a force that was to be better armed and better trained then its predecessor, was expected to defend the nation against the Spanish tercios, if and when they arrived on the English coast. Traditionally, the militia was composed of men ages sixteen to sixty and it mustered once a year, its ranks brought together and paraded before the sheriff and local commissioners of musters over a two-day period, after which the men were sent back to their homes. The muster did have a training element, which usually took place on the second day of the gathering and involved marching, forming companies into squares, and manoeuvring them about the muster ground. These drills were occasionally followed by mock battles that might involve both foot and horse troops, if the latter were raised in adequate numbers. Yet general musters tended to be administrative in nature, with the counting of men and their weapons and the recording of those not in attendance. The real training of the militia was to take place at home where men engaged in “special” or “private musters.” It was at these gatherings that members of the militia were expected to learn how to use their weapons, how to march in files, and in the case of mounted troops, how to charge the enemy. Between 1569 and 1572 the Privy Council issued orders to rectify some of the shortcomings of the traditional militia system. Instructions from the Council in 1569 expressed the government’s interest in seeing the militia armed with the best weaponry, an almost impossible undertaking considering the difficulty that most counties had in convincing their wealthy inhabitants to contribute to the defence of the shire, not to mention the ongoing problems in maintaining the same weapons over the course of years, if not decades, of use. In June 1569 Council instructions called on the commissioners of musters to increase the number and quality of harquebuses and to procure as For discussions of the creation, see L. Boynton, The Elizabethan Militia 1558–1638, London: Routledge & Kegan Paul, 1967, C.G. Cruickshank, Elizabeth’s Army, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1966 and M. Fissel, English Warfare 1511–1642, London: Routledge, 2001. 33
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
33
many calivers as possible. The caliver was an improvement over the harquebus; it was shorter and easier to handle, but was less powerful than the musket that would eventually become the preferred weapon of the English armies in the early seventeenth century. As far as training was concerned, the counties were left, for now, to their own devices. According to the instructions, commissioners were to “devise how more men may be taught to use” their newly acquired [gunpowder] weapons, with “a number of places . . . chosen for exercises, which they may rent at limited times, as near as possible to market towns, &c., where the conflux of people may be most convenient, and where the harquebuses with their furniture may be most safely kept and preserved in a storehouse.”34 The exercise grounds were to have an enclosed area, at least 120 yards long and wide enough “for persons to assemble in,” which was set aside for target practice with gun and bow. The training grounds were to act as the place where members of the hundred or wapentake might regularly meet to practise their martial skills, and the grounds also were designated as the central location where, in the event of invasion, members of the militia might congregate, collect their arms, and head for pre-established mustering points. The government wished to see training at these grounds carried out at least twice a month, possibly on Sundays or on holidays, with the local justices or captains present to oversee the exercises and to offer prizes to the best shot with harquebus and with bow and arrow.35 The introduction of the trained bands in 1572–3 built on these earlier instructions, stipulating that the members of the bands, while continuing to be drawn from those sixteen to sixty, should be raised from the county’s “better sorts,” particularly yeomen farmers, artisans of good standing, or their sons. These men were to be commanded by gentlemen of the shires and trained by muster masters or veterans who had gained experience in foreign wars. The bands, unlike the militia, were expected to gather together and train at least ten times a year,
CSPD Elizabeth I Addenda, 1566–1579, 79. Directions issued in 1585 called upon band corporals to have a 20 ft. wide and 16 ft. high butt constructed, “remote from the hygh way or other common frequented place, and in the midst thereof to sett a rundell of boorde of a yard and a half braode, with certayne black rundelles and whyte amidst, against which the souldyer is to levell his peece for his better ayme and ready discharginge. According to the instructions, soldiers were to stand at least 150 yards from the butt. J. Goring and J. Wake, eds., Northamptonshire Lieutenancy Papers and Other Documents 1580–1614 (Gateshead, UK: Northamptonshire Record Society, 1975), 18. 34 35
34
chapter one
with the local elite continuing to provide weaponry for those serving in the ranks. Training and outfitting the bands remained the responsibility of the individual shires with the Privy Council continuing to issue instructions to the lords lieutenant and their deputies on the calling of musters, the procurement of weapons, and the methods of training. Once the bands were established the Elizabethan government issued directives on training piecemeal, with instructions issued in the 1580s and 1590s that offered muster commissioners and lieutenants some advice on how to train new members of the bands in the use of shot and in very rudimentary motions. In a letter to lords lieutenant dated May 1584, the Council directed the leaders and captains of the bands to set up a halberd in the plain, whereby everie shot maie passe in that order which the French men call a la file and, as we term it, in ranke as wild geese, and so passing by the halberd to present his peece and make offer as thoughe would shoote. And those which doe not behave them selves with their peeces as they ought maie receave particular instruction and teaching. This exercise would be vsed twoe or three meetings at least for ignorant people, in which time maie bee discerned those that cannot frame themselves in anie likelihood to prove shott, in whose roomes the captaines maie require others to bee placed who are apt therevnto.36
Once all those capable of marching in ranks and carrying their harquebuses were identified to the captains, they were taught to safely hold and load their weapons in unison. The instructions encouraged captains to educate their men in giving false fires, the process whereby the pan was primed but the muzzle was not loaded with powder or shot. False fires were used to give soldiers a small taste of what they would experience in battle, with the “flash of the fyre” expected to “embolden the parties, and make evrie thing familiar and readie vnto them.”37 After recruits felt comfortable priming and firing their weapons with false fires, they were given the chance to add powder to the barrel, and brought forward in ranks to skirmish and then retreat to reload. Only after these steps were mastered were the bands allowed to add a bullet to the mix and compete with one another by shooting at the mark. Using false fires and restricting the amount of target practice saved powder and reduced the costs of training. The Privy
36 37
Ibid., 36–7. Ibid.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
35
Council calculated that two pounds of powder was sufficient for one man over four days of exercising, and with forty shot in each company of one hundred men, eighty pounds of powder would be expected to be consumed at two musters. In another letter from the Privy Council dated March 1597/8 and drawn up by the clerk of the Council, William Waad, the bands were finally given more specific instructions on how to carry out training. The directions provided spelled out which men should receive which weapons, the strongest were to be give pikes, the squarest, muskets, the nimblest, calivers. There was, however, a further suggestion that all men should be familiar with the most common weapons in the early modern arsenal, the pike, harquebus, musket, and caliver. Waad’s letter did not provide any other information on how weapons training was to be carried out, though the letter did point out that companies should be divided into smaller groups to assist in the carriage and use of arms, marching and carrying out the motions of war, and gaining an understanding of “all the formes of armes and wordes of direction.”38 Included in the letter was a list of the words of command for opening, closing and advancing files, making this one of the first attempts by the English government to standardize commands for the militia and for continental-bound contingents.39 Beyond these brief hand-written instructions to the lords and deputy lieutenants, the Privy Council issued no printed instructions to assist with training at musters in the last decade of Elizabeth’s reign. A set of printed instructions, the Ordonances and instructions for musters were issued to English troops serving in the Low Countries in 1590 but they were concerned with the administrative aspects of the musters, particularly the duties and responsibilities of the governors, officers, and soldiers serving in the cautionary towns and not with matters related to the drilling of companies.40 The Ordonances addressed the “many grosse
CSPD SP/12/266, f. 139. Harald Kleinschmidt explores the matter of words of command and the crosscurrents between England and the Low Countries in Tyrocinium militare: militärische Körperhaltungen und -bewegungen im Wandel zwischen dem 14. und dem 18. Jahrhundert (Stuttgart: Autorenverlag H. Kleinschmidt, 1983), 111–15. Stuttgart: Autorenverlag H. Kleinschmidt, c. 1989, Stuttgart: Autorenverlag H. Kleinschmidt, c. 1989. 40 Ordonances and instructions for musters, to be obserued by the gouernors, chiefe officers, captaines and souldiers, in her Maiesties pay in the Lowe Countries and to be put in execution by the officers and commissaries of the musters resident in the garrisons, and attendant on the companies employed in the field: established by her Maiestie, and the Lordes of her Highnesse priuie Counsaile for reformation of 38 39
36
chapter one
and manifest frauds and deceipts” practised by English officers at the mustering in the Netherlands. The Council wished to reform the system by making sure that the officers present at musters root out “abuses and disorders” by ensuring that vagrants and camp followers were not used to fill the ranks and that all soldiers mustered were in possession of their own weapons and not those borrowed from other companies. Despite its efforts to improve the militia, the Elizabethan Privy Council failed in the end to introduce a standardized and codified system for training the bands, leaving it up to individual company captains and muster masters to decide how their men should be drilled. As Boynton noted, the trained bands in 1572–3 had come with the “acceptance of the imperative need for a professional attitude, based on continental standards, in military affairs,” but the Council had failed to establish a set of training instructions that could have assisted in instilling a sense of professionalism among the ranks. Instead, the task of producing a set of instructions fell to veterans and private citizens who were concerned about the poor state of the English soldiery. Books, Learning, and Military Culture The method many would-be reformers used to suggest improvements in training was the military book, which became increasing popular in England during the 1570s and 1580s. The first influential military book of the Elizabethan period, Peter Whitehorne’s Certain waies for the orderyng of Souldiers in battelray was printed in 1560.41 The work, which accompanied Whitehorne’s translation of Machiavelli’s Arte of warre, came from the press of London printer John Kingston for Nicholas England. Like so many of the military authors, Whitehorne was a veteran, a former soldier in the army of Charles V, the King of Spain and the Holy Roman Emperor and he served throughout the Mediterranean during Charles’s campaigns against the Turks in the 1550s. Certain waies for the orderyng of Souldiers in battelray opened with a discussion such disorders as are growen by lacke of discipline among her martiall men (London: Christopher Barker, 1590). 41 P. Whitehorne’s Certain waies for the orderyng of Souldiers in battelray is found in The arte of warre, written first in Italia[n] by Nicholas Machiauell, and set forthe in Englishe by Peter Whitehorne, studient at Graies Inne: with an addicio[n] of other like marcialle feates and experimentes, and in a table in the ende of the booke maie appere, (London: John Kingston for Nicholas England, 1562).
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
37
of how to organize men into battle squares and also included chapters on fortification, siegecraft, and artillery, the first in English to address the transformation of siege warfare that had been taking place on the Italian peninsula.42 The book, written with the express purpose of training the ranks to operate as a cohesive unit in the field, was also one of the first English military books to include text and diagrams depicting various infantry formations used on the continent. New editions of Certain waies for the orderyng of Souldiers in battelray appeared in 1573 and 1588, each being printed with Machiavelli’s treatise on war. Also accompanying the second and third editions of the English translation of Arte of warre was Henry Grantham’s translation of Girolamo Cataneo’s Most briefe tables to knowe redily howe manye ranckes of footemen armed with Corslettess vnarmed, go to the making of a iust battyle, from an hundred vnto twentye thousande.43 Cataneo’s tables were useful in the organizing of large numbers of men into squares or battles and when printed with Whitehorne’s works, the three books created an extensive compendium on the martial arts. Whitehorne’s translation of the Arte of warre proved a popular work and it could be found in the libraries of many gentlemen soldiers well into the seventeenth century. In the dedication to Queen Elizabeth found in the 1562 edition, Whitehorne described his translation of the Arte of warre as a gift to the English people. He explained that he had found much in reading Machiavelli that was profitable to a soldier and had decided that it must be translated to “communicate the same to many,” our Englishmen finding out the ordering and disposing of [the] exploides of warre therein contained, the aide and direction of these plaine and briefe precepts, mighte no lesse in knowledge of warres become incomparable, then it provides also an exercise of the same altogether invincible . . . together with such other things [Certain waies], as by me hath beene gathered, & thought good to adde thereunto.44
The reprinting of Machaivelli’s Arte of warre and the addition of Grantham’s translation of Cataneo’s Briefe tables in 1573–4 does not seem to have been an arbitrary decision on the part of the printer,
42 See Chapter 6 for a more detailed discussion of Whitehorne’s chapters on siegecraft. 43 G. Cataneo, Most briefe tables to knowe redily howe manye ranckes of footemen armed with Corslettes, as vnarmed, go to the making of a iust battyle, from an hundred vnto twentye thousande, trans. Henry Grantham (London: W. Williamson, 1574). 44 Whitehorne, The arte of warre, The Epistle Dedicatorie.
38
chapter one
coming only a year after the establishment of the trained bands. The year before, John Sadler had published a translation of The Four Bookes of Flavius Vegetius Renatus, the fifth century work on the military arts that was consistently quoted by late Tudor and early Stuart military writers, especially those sections that Vegetius devoted to physical fitness and training. Sadler opined that his book was not meant to replace experience, but to augment it, a claim that was to be reiterated by most authors of military books over the next seventy years. “It seemeth a farre better and shorter waye to attaine to the name of a worthye and perfect Captaine,” Sadler asserted, to joyne experience unto knowledge, then to get knowledge by experience. For mans life being short and subject to many casualtyes, oftentimes is cutte before it can come to any such perfection as is required in an excellent man of warre: whereas small experience with vigilente reading and perfecte learninge of the feates of warre, may frame and make many politticke Captaynes in a shorter space. I do not meane that knowledge withoute experience, can do anye great thinge at all; but beinge joyned together, doubtless they may be able to bringe to pass as great and marvelous thinges in valiant men in these our dayes.45
The production of English military books at the end of the 1570s and again in the late 1580s was the result of the growing European tensions and the English decision to become fully engaged in the Dutch revolt and in a war against Spain. A number of these works were modelled on classical military treatises, particularly Vegetius’s manual, while others drew their inspiration from continental treatises that were available through booksellers in the Netherlands, Germany, and Italy. Late Tudor works, such as Thomas Proctor’s Of the knowledge and conducte of warres (1578), Thomas Digges’s An arithmetical vvarlike treatise named Stratioticos . . . (1579), and Thomas Styward’s The Pathwaie to Martiall Discipline (1581) were all popular with English readers and when the war with Spain intensified in 1588 a second wave of English military books, notably Giles Clayton’s Approved order of martiall discipline (1591), William Garrard’s The Arte of Warre (1591), Matthew Sutcliffe’s The practice, proceedings, and lawes of armes . . . (1593), and Robert Barret’s The Theorike and Practike of Moderne Warres (1598), were printed to meet
J. Sadler, The foure bookes of Flauius Vegetius Renatus briefelye contayninge a plaine forme, and perfect knowledge of martiall policye, feates of chiualrie, and vvhatsoeuer pertayneth to warre. Translated out of [sic] lattine, into Englishe, by Iohn Sadler. Anno. 1572. Seene and allovved, accordinge to the order appointed (London: Thomas Marshe, 1572), To the Reader. 45
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
39
the needs of English soldiers.46 By the end of Elizabeth’s reign, seventeen works devoted specifically to the military arts had been printed in England. If translations of continental works are also included, works such as Francois de La Noue’s The Politike and Militarie Discovrses (1587) and Raimond de Fourquevaux’s Instructions for the Warres. Amply, learnedly and politiquely, discoursing the method of Militarie Discipline (1589), as well as those books by English commentators on military affairs, such as those by Blandy, Gates, and Rich, the number of works on the arte militarie rises to thirty-three. A detailed study of these late sixteenth-century works, however, falls outside of the scope of this study and, though I examine some of these titles in later chapters, readers should consult Langsam, Webb, Hale, and Eltis for a more complete picture of Tudor military literature.47 The increased production of military books and manuals in the late sixteenth century was also part of the broader “educational revolution” that was taking place in England. The revolution, which had far-reaching implications for the professions of law, seafaring, and business, also benefited the profession of soldiering.48 Since the 1550s there were increasing numbers of gentlemen in attendance at Oxford, Cambridge, and the Inns of Court. The literacy rate among the nobility continued to rise in the late sixteenth century and there was a concomitant increase in the ownership of books among the elite.49 The late Tudor and early 46 T. Styward’s The Pathwaie to Martiall Discipline (London: T.E. for Myles Jenyngs), went to three editions, the first in 1581, the second in 1582 and a third in 1585. A second edition of Thomas Digges’s An arithmetical vvarlike treatise named Stratioticos (London: Henry Bynneman, 1579), appeared in 1590. 47 G.G. Langsam, Martial Books and Tudor Verse (New York: King’s Crown Press, 1951); H.J. Webb, Elizabethan Military Science: The Books and Practice (Madison, WI: University of Wisconsin Press, 1965); J.R. Hale The Art of War and Renaissance England (Washington, DC: Folger Library Press, 1961); and D. Eltis, The Military Revolution in the Sixteenth Century (London: Tauris Academic Studies, 1995). 48 See F. Caspari, Humanism and the Social Order in Tudor England (Chicago: Teachers College Press, 1968); J. Simon, Education and Society in Tudor England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1967); K. Charlton, Education in Renaissance England (London: Routledge and K. Paul, 1965); and D. Cressy, Literacy and Social Order, Reading and Writing in Tudor and Stuart England (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1980). 49 J.H. Hexter found that lord and deputy lieutenants in the early Stuart period were very likely to have attended university and J.H. Gleason uncovered a similar trend among justices of the peace. In an investigation of the lieutenancy commission of Northamptonshire, Hexter found that between 1607 and 1619 the commission was composed of nineteen men. Of those nineteen, information on the educational backgrounds of fifteen is extant. Out of those fifteen, “eleven matriculated at Oxford or Cambridge, and of the eleven, seven were admitted to the Inns of Courts. Four others, who do not appear on the university registers, also went to the great English
40
chapter one
Stuart periods were marked by what Kenneth Charlton has called “a passionate regard for education” among the English elite that not only saw improvements to education and increased attendance at universities but also greater access to books from foreign and domestic printers (including English translations of foreign works). Travel to European centres of learning also enhanced the education of young Englishmen and gave them the opportunity to study continental warfare first hand. Education gained by study at home or travel abroad was no longer solely for the purpose of scholarship and contemplation, it was also expected that it would be used in the service of the state, making it a virtuous and worthwhile endeavour for all gentlemen.50 This pool of educated gentlemen produced what Wallace MacCaffrey has described as “a corps of talent that no monarch could ignore.”51 This flowering of education also precipitated attempts to standardize knowledge across a range of secular fields, including soldiering.52 At the centre of this transformation was the vernacular manual literature, which has been described as “the supreme exemplification of the modern notion that knowledge should be shared, and that such sharing, far from jeopardizing the interests of the few, would benefit the community at large.”53 By the late sixteenth century, English gentlemen could consult a range of didactic and instructional manuals to answer questions on a variety of subjects that included but were not limited to the law, local administration, navigation, personal defence, horsemanship, and animal husbandry. Manuals such as Anthony Fitzherbert’s The boke of iustyces of peas (1506), L’office et authoryte de Justyces de Peas (1538), and In this booke is contayned the offices of sheryffes, bailliffes of liberties, escheatours co[n]stables and coroners (1538); William Lambarde’s popular and well-respected
schools of law, and one of the four traveled on the Continent under the supervision of a tutor.” Similarly, in a study of early seventeenth-century gentry families in Yorkshire who became justices of the peace, J.H. Levy found that over three-quarters had attended university; see J.H. Hexter, “The Education of the Aristocracy in the Renaissance,” in Reappraisals in History (London: Longmans, 1961), 45–7; J.H. Gleason, The Justices of the Peace in England, 1558 to 1640: A Later Eirenarcha (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1969), 83–4; F.J. Levy, “How Information Spread Among the Gentry, 1550–1640,” Journal of British Studies 21 (Spring 1982), 12. 50 Charlton, Education in Renaissance England, 298. 51 W. MacCaffrey, Elizabeth I: War and Politics, 1588–1603 (Princeton: Princeton University Press, 1992), 456. 52 Ibid. 53 Ibid.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
41
Eirenarcha (1582); and Michael Dalton’s Countrey Justice (1635) offered justices of the peace useful advice on various points of law and local governance.54 There were similar efforts to quantify navigation and seafaring that was to produce a large library of maritime instructional literature between 1528 and 1640.55 Before the mid-sixteenth century, sea captains, navigators, and pilots did not require books on navigation owing to the fact that most ships skirted the coastlines with sailors relying on terrestrial navigation to guide them to their destination. As shipbuilding improved and seafarers took longer journeys across the world’s oceans, books on celestial navigation were soon accompanying sea captains on their voyages. Instructional manuals that relied heavily on mathematical formulae and astronomy were now being purchased along with compasses, astrolabes, and cross staffs to aid in sea-borne navigation. Included among the authors of the first navigational manuals in English was William Bourne, who also authored The Arte of Shooting in great Ordnaunce (1578) a popular work on gunnery. Bourne published three works on navigation in the second half of the sixteenth century, An Almanacke and Prognostication (1567), A Regiment for the Sea (1574), and Inventions and Devices (1590).56 Manuals on personal defence also found wide readership with late Elizabethan and early Stuart readers. Fencing and swordsmanship were integral parts of aristocratic culture and the publication of fencing manuals helped to popularize the techniques of foreign and indigenous fencing masters. Jay Anglin has suggested that during the sixteenth century the defensive arts required greater regulation as they grew in popularity, with leading instructors establishing strict guidelines for governing the use of weapons in mock combat. 57 As the art of fencing evolved and developed in England in the sixteenth century, Anglin points out that English fencing masters followed the traditions of personal combat that had their roots in the Middle Ages. For a time, instructors stifled the development of manuals since they were instruments for perpetuating traditional methods, rather than for introducing innovation. When that innovation did arrive in the Elizabethan period,
Ibid., 191. T. Adams, “The Beginnings of Maritime Publishing in England, 1528–1640,” The Library 14 (1992): 207–8. 56 Ibid., 214. 57 J.P. Anglin, “The Schools of Defense in Elizabethan England,” Renaissance Quarterly 37 (Winter, 1984): 393–410. 54
55
42
chapter one
it came via Spanish and Italian treatises imported into England. The first of these works to be translated into English was the Italian master Giacomo di Grassi’s Ragione di adoprar sicuramente l’Arme si da offesa come da difensa (1570), which was published in London in 1594 as Giacomo di Grassi his true Arte of Defence.58 A year later, London fencing master Vincentio Saviolo’s Vincentio Saviolo his Practise In two Bookes was printed by Thomas Scarlett for John Wolf. The first two decades of the seventeenth century saw the publication of a number of English fencing manuals championing the indigenous schools of defence. George Buck, in his treatise on education in the capital, The Third University of England (1615), described “diverse Schooles in London kept by Maisters of defence” in the early Stuart period that were home to manie professors therof and very skilfull men in teaching the most offensive and defensive vse of verie many weapons, as for long sword, the backe sword, the Rapier and dagger, the single Rapier and dagger, the case of Rapiers, the sword and buckler or Targate, the Pike, the Holdbord, the long staffe, and other.59
Buck noted the influence of foreign treatises, as well as English works, on the development of the fencing schools in London directing his readers to Achille Marozzo’s Opera nova dell’ Arte dell armi (1568) and Englishman George Silver’s Paradoxes of Defence (1599).60 Other English manuals on fencing soon followed Silver’s, including John Seldon’s The Duello Or Single Combat (1610), George Hale’s The Private Schoole of Defence (1614), and Joseph Swetnam’s The Schoole of the Noble and Worthy Science of Defence (1617).61 Like military writers, fencing masters such as Silver and Swetnam argued the merits of various weapons and the methodologies of the different schools of instruction, measuring English technique against that of the Italians and Spanish.62
58 G. Grassi, Giacomo di Grassi his True arte of defence. . . . First written in Italian by the foresaid author, and Englished by I.G. gentleman. (London: G. Shaw? for I. I[aggard], 1594). 59 G. Buc[k], The Third University of England (London: Thomas Dawson, 1615), 985. 60 G. Silver, Paradoxes of defence wherein is proued the true grounds of fight to be in the short auncient weapons . . . (London: Richard Field for Edward Blount, 1599). 61 J. Seldon, The Duello Or Single Combat (London: G.E. for John Helme, 1610), G. Hale, The Private Schoole of Defence (London: John Helme 1614), and J. Swetnam, The Schoole of the Noble and Worthy Science of Defence (London: Nicholas Okes, 1617). 62 See S. Anglo, The Martial Arts of Renaissance Europe (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2000).
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
43
The attempt to codify and standardize practice across a range of fields was not without its problems. Any attempt to establish hard and fast rules for such fluid types of activities as fencing and the military arts could just as easily stifle innovation as it could foster efficiency and order, something recognized by some soldiers who were contemptuous of any connection between the realities of war and the lessons that could be learned from the pages of a book. There was no denying the fact, however, that the military treatise offered a window into a profession that was literally and figuratively becoming regimented. As the organization and battlefield tactics of continental armies underwent a process of modernization over the course of the sixteenth century, the military tasks that accompanied this transformation became increasingly standardized and regularized.63 As drill and military organization were codified on the continent, English officers and administrators would also come to rely on this uniform set of martial practices to guide their own training and that of their men. This meeting and concurrence of learning and arms was reflected in the ever-increasing list of military books printed in English beginning in the 1570s. Printers and booksellers realized that there was a sizable market for this type of literature, particularly among those who were deemed as “souldiers and professours of the art military.” William Eamon, in his study of sixteenth-century scientific “book of secrets” describes the period as one that saw “a growing demand for inexpensive vernacular literature on practical subjects” with printers across the continent paying “close attention to the popular market and adjust[ing] their operations accordingly, commissioning authors to write books for the common man and devising new marketing procedures to sell them.”64 Just as new forms of labour relations prompted the introduction of how-to books on everything from metallurgy and bookkeeping to printing and gardening, the transformation of warfare required its own instructional guides. The London bookseller Andrew Maunsell’s catalogue, which appeared in 1595, reflected this trend with readers being offered the choice of a wide range of books on mathematics, arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, astrology, music, the art of war, and navigation. Maunsell’s Arnold, Renaissance at War, 64. W. Eamon, “Arcana Disclosed: The Advent of Printing, the Books of Secrets Tradition, and the Development of Experimental Science in the Sixteenth Century,” History of Science 22 (1984), 114. 63
64
44
chapter one
catalogue listed books of self defence, such as di Grassi’s True Arte of Defense and Saviolo’s Practise In two Bookes alongside the respected English works on the military arts. The most recently printed manuals, such as Styward’s Pathwaie to Martiall Discipline (1581), Garrard’s Arte of Warre (1591), Clayton’s Approved order of martiall discipline (1591), Roger Williams’s Briefe discourse of Warre (1590), Barnabe Rich’s A Path-Way to Military Practise (1587) and John Smythe’s Certain discourses concerning the formes and effects of diuers sorts of weapons (1591) and Instructions, obseruations, and orders mylitarie (1594) and were all available to Maunsell’s customers, as were the classics of military thought.65 The ancients had been the first to offer a set of rules and precepts governing the art of war; adages and examples from the works of Greek and Roman military thinkers were to influence continental and English military writers well into the seventeenth century. Latin editions of ancient military writers were available to English readers from continental booksellers, such as the Aldine Press, in the early sixteenth century and English translations of classical military texts were available by mid-century. By the end of the century, Maunsell could offer his readers, both in London and in the provinces, all of the leading classical texts on warfare printed in English, including Frontinus’s Stratagemes (1539) translated into English by Richard Morysine, and Whitehorne’s edition of Machiavelli’s Arte of warre and his translation of Onosander’s General Captain, which was printed in 1563 by William Seres.66 Sadler’s edition of Vegetius, which was printed in 1572, remained an influential and oft-cited reference for Elizabethan and early Stuart military commentators, was also listed in Maunsell’s catalogue.67 Editions of the works of Julius Caesar were popular, with new editions and commentaries printed throughout this period. In fact, few of the late Tudor or early Stuart libraries examined for this study were without a Latin or English edition of one of the works of Caesar.68 An 65 A. Maunsell, The Second parte of the Catalogue of English printed Bookes (London: James Roberts for Andrew Maunsell, 1595), 25–7. 66 P. Whitehorne, Onosandro Platonico, of the Generall Captaine, (London: William Seres, 1563). 67 According to Gabriel Harvey in matters of the state and war, “we must put much trust in Aristotle’s and Xenophon’s politics, in Vegetius’ book Of Military Affairs and Frontinus’ Stratagems.” See L. Jardine and A. Grafton, “How Gabriel Harvey Read His Livy,” Past and Present 129 (Nov. 1990), 41. See a more detailed discussion of Harvey’s interest in military books later in this chapter. 68 On the impact of classical military literature on English military thought, see Webb, Elizabethan Military Science, 3–16.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
45
English edition of Caesar’s Gallic Wars, translated by Arthur Golding, was first printed in 1565, but the second edition did not arrive until twenty-five years later. Clement Edmondes’ Oberservations vpon the five bookes of Caesars Commentaries, which will be addressed in more detail in Chapter Three, went through multiple editions in the first decade of the seventeenth century. Translations of other Greek and Roman writers, notably Xenophon, Tacticus, Polybius, Aelian, Polyaenus, and Leo the Issurian provided military, historical, political, and technical examples that English military writers and gentlemen soldiers could consult for advice on martial affairs. Though the classical works on the art of war remained popular, the introduction of greater numbers of gunpowder weapons on European battlefields in the sixteenth century prompted military writers and readers to move beyond the ancient to ponder the truly “moderne” nature of warfare. This modern phase had its roots in Renaissance Italy which witnessed a rapid rise in the number of works on both the art and the science of war in the first half of the sixteenth century. What started in Italy soon spread across Europe with popular Italian works being translated into French, Spanish, German, and English. J.R. Hale’s study of printing and Venetian military culture between 1492 and 1570 reveals that printers recognized that interest in military books was not limited to soldiers, but also included “patricians, foreign ambassadors, educated non-patrician Venetians, poliographi, . . . and engineers.”69 The influence of Italian military books, particularly those written on siegecraft and military architecture, extended beyond the domain of the soldier to other fields of study, most notably mathematics. English gentlemen, like their Europeans counterparts, found they too needed to have a familiarity with these contemporary military examples if they were bound for the wars. Consequently, by the end of the sixteenth century the vocabulary of war was very much a part of the privileged language of the elite and existed alongside a common literary culture in de disciplina militare that linked soldiers across the Europe.70
69 70
Hale, “Printing and the Military Culture of Renaissance Venice,” 436. Levy, “How Information Spread Among the Gentry, 1550–1640,” 12.
46
chapter one Procuring Foreign Military Books
Foreign military books could be procured by English readers with relative ease through a variety of means—through friends and acquaintances travelling on the continent, through agents, or from English and continental booksellers. As young men made their peregrinations around the continent, they purchased books to take home or they placed orders with agents or booksellers who sent the books on to England. Sir Charles Danvers sent two hundred books from Italy in the 1590s, Sir Thomas Bodley sent his agent, the bookseller John Bill, to Spain and Italy to buy the books that would eventually become part of the famous Bodleian Library, while Henry Percy, ninth earl of Northumberland and Henry Wriothesley, earl of Southampton, both used Bill’s services to acquire Italian and Spanish titles for their libraries.71 By the late sixteenth century it was possible for gentlemen soldiers who wished to procure books on the art of war, to peruse a continental catalogue that listed new and old titles along with forthcoming works, place their order with a London bookseller, and be fairly certain that their books would, barring any mishaps during shipping, arrive within the year. In the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries, the focal point of the European book trade was the Frankfurt Book Fair. The Frankfurt fair had its origins in the twelfth century and the book fair pre-dated the invention of printing in the 1450s, with manuscripts sold there a century before printed books came into being. The fair took place twice yearly, an Autumn Fair in late August or early September and a Lenten Fair, (though the dates tended to vary) in March or early April.72 The Frankfurt Fair had grown significantly in size by the end of the sixteenth century and was attracting buyers and sellers from all across Europe. It was not a market solely for those interested in books, and attracted merchants of all sorts, including those selling arms and armour.73 So a soldier shopping for armour, a horse, or a weapon might also have purchased a book to accompany him to the wars. But one need not attend the Frankfurt Fair to purchase books that were sold there. By the 71 G. Ungerer, “The Earl of Southampton’s Donation to the Bodleian Library in 1605 and Its Spanish Books,” Bodleian Library Record 16 (1997): 17–41. 72 J.L. Flood, “ ‘Omnium totius orbis emporiorium compendium’: the Frankfurt fair in the early modern period,” in Fairs, Markets and the Itinerant Book Trade, eds. R. Myers, M. Harris, and G. Mandelbrote, (London: Oak Knoll Press, 2007), 5–6. 73 Flood cites Henri Estienne II’s description of the fair as “a veritable workshop of war.” See Flood, “ ‘Omnium totius orbis emporiorium compendium’”, 8.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
47
mid-sixteenth century customers wanting to see at least a part of the fair’s inventory could consult the bookseller Georg Willer’s catalogues, which first appeared in the 1564 and continued to be printed annually until 1592.74 When Willer’s catalogues were introduced they included titles that he sold at the fair, but keen to attract more buyers he expanded the list to include most of the popular titles in the Frankfurt inventory. By the 1590s, other printers such as Johann George Portenbach, Tobias Lutz, Martin Lechler, and Georg Rab were offering catalogues similar to Willer’s, as were booksellers and printers who sold their books at the Leipzig and Augsburg Fairs, which took place just after the Frankfurt fair. English printers and booksellers attended both the Frankfurt and Leipzig fairs but as buyers rather than sellers, primarily owing to the expense of carrying their books to Germany. In 1598, by order of the Frankfurt Council, a Catalogus universalis was printed listing all of the works available at the Frankfurt Fair. The printing of the Catalogus universalis made it possible to review hundreds of titles that were loosely divided into categories based on language and or subject matter. The catalogue did not list all of the books available for sale at the fair, but those that might have the widest readership. In 1617, the first English edition of the Catalogus universalis was printed by John Bill. Bill, who had been in the business of purchasing books for his noble customers since the 1590s, continued to put out his Frankfurt catalogue until 1628. His editions of the Catalogus universalis offered English customers with a list of Latin, French, and Spanish titles, but he did not include works in German. This meant that some of the most important military books of the period, particularly those written by Johann Jacobi von Wallhausen, had to be purchased in French translation or obtained from Dutch booksellers who sold the works in their original German. Perusal of Bill’s Catalogus universalis offers some clues as to which military books were readily available to English readers. Books on military subjects could be found under the heading Libri Perigrini Idiomati, which is the heading used by Willer.75 The section included biographies, comparative grammars and dictionaries, letters, and miscellaneous titles, as the heading implies. In the late Jacobean and early Caroline period those buying continental military books J.W. Thompson, ed., The Frankfort Book Fair = The Francofordiense Emporium of Henri Estienne (New York, Burt Franklin, 1968), 29. 75 Catalogus universalis pro nundinis Francofurtensibus autumnalibus. . . . (London: John Bill, 1617–1628). 74
48
chapter one
could chose from the latest works by leading military writers such as Wallhausen, albeit in French translation, or some of the late sixteenth century books that were still popular with European readers. For instance, Bill’s 1617 catalogue listed three Italian titles, Carlo Theti’s Discorsi di Fortificationi, Flaminio Della Croce’s Teatro militarie, and Enea Cervellino’s Militar disciplina, along with L’art militarie pour l’infanterie and Art de Chevalerie, both of which were written by Wallhausen.76 Bill also offered classical military treatises like Peter Scriverio’s editions of Vegetius’s De re militari and Frontinus’s Strategemes that were printed in Leiden in 1607. Between 1617 and 1620, along with Wallhausen’s Art de Chevalerie, Bill’s catalogues listed two of the other well-respected works on cavalry, Lodovico Melzo’s Regole Militari sopra il governo e servitio particolare della cavalleria and Giorgio Basta’s Il governo della cavalleria leggiera. Bill lists only one English military book in his catalogue, William Neade’s Doublearmed Man (1625), but this did not necessarily mean that it was being sold at Frankfurt. John Flood points out that Bill also included titles from his London stock in the catalogue and this may explain why this particular book was included.77 Shipping costs to Frankfurt or Leipzig for English military books, and English books in general, meant they were not aggressively marketed on the continent. Consequently the trade in military books went in just one direction, from the continent to England.78 By the 1620s a number of English printers were following Bill’s lead and offering English readers catalogues of their foreign stock. Henry Featherstone, George Thomason, and Richard Whitaker all printed Frankfurt fair catalogues or catalogues advertising their own stock of continental books. There was a decline in the number of sellers and buyers attending the Frankfurt and Leipzig fairs, especially in the early 1630s following Gustavus Adolphus’s campaigns in Germany. Despite the impact of the war in Germany, foreign military books continued to be available to English customers via Dutch booksellers. The Elzevier Book Catalogues,
76 C. Theti’s Discorsi di Fortificationi, (Roma: Giulio Accolto, 1569); F. Della Croce, Teatro militarie, (Milano: B.Lantoni, 1613) and E. Cervellino, Militar disciplina (Venetia, s.n., 1617). J.J. von Wallhausen, L’art militarie pour l’infanterie (Oppenheim: Par Hierome Galler: Aux despens de Jean-Theodore de Bry, 1615) and Art de Chevalerie (Francfort: Par Paul Iaques, aux fraiz de Lucas Iennis, 1616). 77 For a comparison of English and continental books sold at Frankfurt, see Flood, “ ‘Omnium totius orbis emporiorium compendium,’” 25–7. 78 The Elzevier Catalogue for 1638 does list one military book, Digges’s Stratioticos, under its English books titles, but this was possibly a second-hand book.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
49
printed in Leiden and The Hague by the bookselling dynasty established by Louis Elzevier (c. 1546–1617) reveal no shortage of military titles in the family’s book inventories in the catalogues printed between 1627 and 1636.79 The Elzeviers were second-hand booksellers and the books in their catalogues came from their own stock, from works purchased from other booksellers, and from auctions of private libraries. Evidence from the titles found in their catalogues indicates that the various members of the family had newer military books, as well as older works from the turn of the century. The catalogues listed many of the same Italian and French titles that were found in Bill’s Catalogus universalis, together with the German titles that Bill did not make available in England. By the 1630s, the Elzevier catalogues included a number of books on military architecture and gunnery that had flooded the market during the Thirty Years’ War. These included Henrik Hondius’s Description & breve declaration des Regles Generales de la Fortification, de l’Artillerie (1625), Samuel Marolois’s Fortification ov Architectvre militarie tant offensive que deffensive (1627), Paolo Sarpi’s La simmetria dell’ ottima fortificazione regolare (1630), and Adam Freitag’s Architectura militaris nova et aucta, oder Newe vermehrte Fortification (1635). The Elzevier catalogues also listed a number of titles on siegecraft from the first two decades of the century, notably Jean Errard Bar-le-duc’s La Fortification demonstree et redicteen art (1604), Diego Ufano’s Tratado de Artilléria (1613), and Simon Stevin’s Castrametatio, Dat is Legermeting (1617). After Bill’s death in 1630 other English booksellers continued to publish catalogues of foreign books, some connected with Frankfurt, but others that only advertised Italian stock. In Henry Featherstone’s 1628 catalogue of Italian books, one could find fourteen military titles; the oldest was Lelio Brancaccio’s Della nuova disciplina & vera arte militare (1585), while the newest was the 1625 edition of Melzo’s Regole Militari sopra il governo e servitio particolare della cavalleria.80 In 1635, London 79 See D. Davies, The World of the Elsevirs 1580–1712 (The Hague, Martinus Nijhoff, 1954) and P. Morrish, “A Collection of Seventeenth Century Book Sale Catalogues,” Quaerendo 1, no. 1 (1971), 35–6. The Merton College Library, Oxford University has two bound volumes of the Elzevier Catalogues from Leiden, The Hague, and Amsterdam that were printed between 1627 and 1636. 80 H. Featherstone, Catalogus librorum in diuersis locis Italiae emptorum, Anno 1628 Qui Londini in officina Fetherstoniana, prostant venales (London: John Legatt, 1628). The first two editions of Melzo’s Regole Militari sopra il governo e servitio particolare della cavalleria were printed in 1611 and 1619. A German edition, Kriegs Regeln dess Ritters L. Meltzo . . . Wie eine Reuterey zu regieren, etc. Reigles Militaires . . . sur le gouvernement et service particulier et propre de la Cavallerie appeared in 1625.
50
chapter one
bookseller Robert Martin followed Featherstone with his own Italian catalogue and in the list of contents he established a separate heading for military books, De Architecture Machinis & ad Bell.[um] Spectan.[es].81 It is not surprising that Martin categorized the books under such a heading, particularly during the Thirty Years’ War, when the impact and influence of trace italienne fortifications on the military arts was being fully realized. While the bulk of the titles offered by Martin were on the subject of military architecture, he also sold titles devoted to infantry and cavalry warfare. Two years later, on the eve of the First Bishops’ War, George Thomason’s catalogue of Italian books was using the same category headings as Martin and offering a similar stock.82 By 1645, three years into the English Civil War, another London bookseller, Richard Whitaker was listing his Italian stock of books on military subjects alongside works on mathematics.83 That stock was far less extensive than either Martin’s or Thomason’s and only included Joseph Furtenbach’s Architectura Martialis (1630), Herman Hugo’s De militia equestri antiqua et noua ad regem Philippum IV (1630), and editions of Machiavelli’s Arte of warre. The introduction of booksellers’ catalogues made purchasing copies of the latest foreign military books fairly simple for English soldiers or scholars eager to study the arte militarie. New titles from Italian, French, Dutch, and German presses, or old titles printed in the last quarter of the sixteenth century were easily acquired directly from London printers through agents buying from European fairs or through continental booksellers like the Elzeviers. As we will see, gentlemen soldiers bought, read, and drew upon the lessons found within these books, while English military writers used these works as references in their own books. It
81 R. Martin, Catalogus librorum quos (in ornamentum reipublicae literariae) non sine magnis sumptibus & labore, ex Italia selegit Robertus Martine, Bibliopola Londinensis: apud quem in coemiterio Divi Pauli prostant venales (London: Augustine Matthewes, 1633); see also Martin’s Catalogus librorum, ex praecipius Italiae Emporiis selectorum. Per Robertum Martinum. Apud quem venales habentur (London: Thomas Harper, 1639) and Catalogus librorum, plurimis linguis scriptorum de omni ferè facultate tractantium; ac è diversis Europae regionibus congestorum: prostant venales apud Robertum Martinum (London: Thomas Harper, 1640). 82 G. Thomason, Catalogus librorum in diversis Italiae locis emptorum, anno 1636 Quorum facultatum indicem sequens pagina monstrabit. Qui Londini in Caemeterio Sancti Pauli ad insigne Rosae prostant venales (London: John Legatt), 1637. 83 R. Whitaker, Catalogus librorum quos de nundinis Francofurtensibus autumnalibus anni 1645. ac alibi comparavit Richardus Whitakerus bibliopola Londinensis: apud quem jam prostant venales (London: Richard Whitaker, 1645).
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
51
was through these knowledge transactions that military thought was rapidly transferred from one European country to another. England’s Worthies: Military Circles and Military Books in Late Elizabethan England Entry into the Dutch Revolt had many repercussions for military culture in England with one significant development being the formation of military circles in the 1580s. These circles were most often centred on a patron, either of noble birth like the earls of Leicester and Essex in the late sixteenth century or Prince Henry in the early seventeenth century, or a leading military patron like Francis Vere. Military patronage took the place of a system of military hierarchy in early modern England, as it did on the continent. But, as important as the elite or military patron at the centre of the circle was to military command, I want to emphasize the inclusion in these circles of both soldiers and scholars and also the English military authors who are discussed in this book. The military circle was more than just a haven for soldiers, it also served as a forum for discussion of military and political affairs and it is in these circles that we find evidence of the use of military books in knowledge transactions taking place between members of these groups.84 Robert Dudley, the earl of Leicester, and the man given command of English forces in the Netherlands, was at the centre of Elizabethan England’s most important military circle. As a boy Dudley took little interest in books, spending his time hunting, riding, and training for war. In time, thanks to his tutors, Roger Ascham, the author of Toxophilus, and John Dee, the scientist and conjurer, Dudley developed a love of mathematics and geometry that soon turned into a fascination with military architecture and siegecraft.85 Though his education never turned Dudley into a great lover of books or book learning, he did amass a large personal library over the course of his life, which included many works of Renaissance learning as well as works related to military subjects.
84 85
See Jardine and Sherman, “Pragmatic Readers,” 102–24. D. Wilson, Sweet Robin (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1981), 16.
52
chapter one
Leicester’s tutorials with Dee also gave him access to the polymath’s extensive library, the Bibliotheca Mortlacensis, which was the largest in England numbering three to four thousand volumes,86 and home to a fine collection of books on the art of war, the majority of which were of Italian origin (a language Dudley could read). Dee’s military books were primarily dedicated to fortification and gunnery and included Theti’s Discorsi di Fortificationi (1572), Girolamo Ruscelli’s Precetti della militia moderna (1572), Girolamo Cataneo’s Ragionamisto del fabricare le fortezzo (1571), and Jacob Lanterius’s De forticacione (1563). Dee had also purchased a number of the popular analytical treatises on the art of war and single combat that were printed in France and Italy, including Philip, Duke de Cleves’s Instruction de guerre (1558), Marozzo’s Opera nova dell’ Arte dell armi (1568), and Cataneo’s Dell arte militare (1571).87 Leicester most likely furthered his interest in fortifications and siegecraft reading books from Dee’s library, a setting that William Sherman has described as England’s first think tank, as well as engaging in discussions with another of Dee’s students, the mathematician and military writer Thomas Digges.88 Dee, Digges, and Leicester all shared an interest in siege warfare and fortification design, a subject that Digges would later go on to explore in his Arithmentical Warlike Treaties named Stratioticos (1579). Digges completed the work first begun by his father Leonard, who died in 1559. It was Thomas Digges who dedicated the book to Leicester and in that dedication he paid tribute to his patron and to the “sundrie favours” that Leicester had given him.89 Leicester continued to bestow favours on Digges when in 1585 he was chosen to act as muster-master general during Leicester’s expedition to the Netherlands. When the expedition departed England for the Low Countries, the serious soldiers in the army were soon at odds with those who had little or no military experience, men who wished only to stay for a short time and profit as much as they could from their martial adventurers. The professional soldier Sir John Norris made a point of singling out and ridiculing Digges as an amateur, calling him a “paper soldier.” It has been speculated, however,
86 W. Sherman, John Dee: The Politics of Reading and Writing in the English Renaissance (Amherst, MA: University of Massachusetts Press, 1995), 31. 87 See J. Roberts and A.G. Watson, John Dee’s Library Catalogue (London: The Bibliographical Society, 1990). 88 Sherman, John Dee: The Politics of Reading and Writing, xiii. 89 Blandy, The Castle, or picture of policy, 14.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
53
Figure 1. Robert Dudley, earl of Leicester as depicted in Edward Grimeston’s A Generall Historie of the Netherlands. Courtesy of the Thomas Fisher Rare Book Library, University of Toronto.
54
chapter one
that this may not have been a fair assessment of Digges’s work, as he took his job seriously and appears to have been committed to running the campaign as parsimoniously as possible. In fact, it was his attempt to clean up the corrupt pay system in the Netherlands and not his inexperience that most likely raised Norris’s ire. Another military writer, Matthew Sutcliffe, author of The practice, proceedings, and lawes of armes (1593), served alongside Digges and became part of Leicester’s circle after being given the post of judge-advocate general.90 Like Digges, Sutcliffe was more scholar than soldier. He was educated at Cambridge in the early 1570s, where he received his BA and MA degrees before deciding to study law. His early interest in law, and for that matter in military affairs, gave way to a pastoral calling, with Sutcliffe spending the rest of his life in the service of the English church, being named Dean of Exeter Cathedral in 1588. In his dedication in The practice, proceedings, and lawes of armes to Robert Devereux, 2nd earl of Essex, Sutcliffe, a Hispanophobe and devout Protestant, deduced that since wars occur so frequently, was it not in the best interest of soldiers to “reason and talke of warre.” He tried to put to rest the notion that books on war were of little value to soldiers, calling it “notorious follie . . . to condemn Arte and reason” and echoing the refrain that one could “learne much by reading of Military discourses, more than ever his owne experience could teach him.”91 History had shown that the most famous captains, Scipio, Caesar, and others, had spent “much time in reading of ancient deedes of Armes” and Sutcliffe recommended that Englishmen should follow their noble example. This meant that those eager to travel to the wars should begin their studies with the ancient canon, Frontinus, Vegetius, Livy, Caesar, and Xenophon as it provided men with a set of clearly defined rules to follow in times of war, rules that tempered reckless or foolhardy actions on the battlefield. After reading the ancients, Sutcliffe thought it wise to take up La Noue’s Politike and Militarie Discovrses but warned against reading Machiavelli and Valturius, as neither had experienced the realities of war (as Sutcliffe
Manning, An Apprenticeship in Arms: The Origins of the British Army 1585–1702 (Oxford University Press, 2006), 6. 91 Sutcliffe, The practice, proceedings, and lawes of armes. . . . (London: Deputies of Christopher Barker, 1593), The Epistle Dedicatorie. 90
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
55
had).92 Other writers, who went unnamed, should also be approached with caution, as they filled their works with divers formes of battles, some like stares, some like sheares, some like sawes, and some like winde-mill sailes, which never have vse but in mosters; and leave the most necessary pointes of warre, in preparing for the warres, choice of souldiors, marching, encamping, fighting, retiring, besieging, or defending of townes, ambuscades, stratagems, and such like necessary factions of armes.93
There were a number of men in Leicester’s circle, like Dee and Digges, who would not be considered martialists or swordsmen by contemporaries, but who took an interest in military affairs and consequently turned to military books to learn more about the art of war and its effects on domestic and foreign policy. J.R. Hale’s assertion that Italian military books were not only the preserve of the soldier but were read by members of the political and scientific elite was also true for the English. Gabriel Harvey, who held a secretarial post in the Leicester household, believed that the reading of military, historical, and political works enhanced the “trade of our lives,” that is the arts of political discourse and warfare.94 Lisa Jardine and Anthony Grafton have described how Harvey actively read books in order to engage in debates over matters of state with his patron. His library housed English and continental military books, as well as the ubiquitous classical works on warfare.95 Harvey’s writings and the marginalia found in his books and letters reveal how he used adages from military books to add weight to his arguments in support of Leicester and the Protestant war party. V.F. Stern’s study of Harvey’s marginalia found that the military books in his library were heavily annotated and indicated that Harvey closely watched the fighting unfold in the Netherlands. He tried to draw lessons from the ancient authorities and apply them to the contemporary military situation. In his English edition of Frontinus’s Strategemes, purchased in 1578, Harvey compared Philip II of Spain to Philip of Macedon, 92 Sutcliffe states that he spent many years observing the wars, and faced “dangerous experience both in France, Italy, Flanders and Portugal.” Ibid., Sig. B4v. 93 Ibid., The Epistle Dedicatorie. 94 Jardine and Grafton, “How Gabriel Harvey Read His Livy,” 39. 95 Harvey’s library included copies of Frontinus’s Strategemes in English and in Italian (Stratagemi Militari . . . Venice: Bolognino Zalterio, 1574), Peter Whitehorne’s Certain waies for the orderyng of Souldiers, as well as his translation of Machiavelli’s Arte of warre. For a catalogue of the books and manuscripts in Harvey’s library, see V.F. Stern, Gabriel Harvey: His Life, Marginalia and Library (Oxford: Clarendon Press, 1979), 198–248.
56
chapter one
suggesting that the Spanish king had used bribery to win control of towns in the Low Countries, much like his ancient namesake had done. To meet the enemy at their own game, Harvey argued that the English commanders, Gilbert, Frobisher, and Drake, should use the same tactics to their advantage.96 In 1588, Harvey returned to his copy of Frontinus, this time making reference to the fireships used by the English fleet to disperse the Spanish off Calais, citing Cassius’ decision to “set fire to certain large but not too valuable ships” as further evidence of the effectiveness of the tactic and the value of the lessons of history. In his copy of Machiavelli’s Arte of warre Harvey listed the works that he would like to take to war if such an occasion arose (it did not). The passage, described by Stern and by Jardine and Grafton, provides a window into one reader’s sampling of the available military literature, revealing Harvey’s recognition of the authorities in the field. According to Harvey, his “principal Autors for war, after much reading, & long consideration” were Caesar, & Vegetius: Machiauel, & Gandino: Ranzouius, & Tetti: with owr Sutcliff, Sir Roger Williams, & Digges Stratioticos: all sharp, & sound masters of War. For ye Art, Vegetius, Machiauel. & Sutcliff: for Strategems, Gandino, & Ranzouius: for Fortification, Pyrotechnie, & engines, Tetti, & Digges: for ye old Roman worthie Discipline & Action, Caesar for ye new Spanish, & English excellent Discipline & Action, Sir Ro: Williams. Autors enowgh; with ye most cunning, & valorus practices in Esse. [another time] Owr English military Discipline, vnder General Norris, in ye Dialogue, intitulid, The Castle of Policy: Vnder ye Earle of Leicester, In his owne Lawes, & Ordinances. The Spanish Discipline under ye Duke d’Alua, & ye Prince of Parma, ye best Discipline now in Esse, newly discoouerid by Sir Roger Williams.97 Ibid., 142. Quoted in Jardine and Grafton, “How Gabriel Harvey Read His Livy,” 74. Harvey refers to the military standards of the day, Caesar, Vegetius, and Machiavelli while Gandino, Ranzovius, and Tetti are Angelo Gambiglioni, the 15th century Italian jurist whose works explored just war, Heinrich Rantzau the German astrologer’s Henr. Ranzovii Produc. Cimbr. Commentarius Bellicus, Libris sex distinctus, præcepta, consilia, et strategemata, pugnæ terrestris ac navalis, ex variis Eruditorum collecta scriptis, complectens (1595), and the Italian Carlo Theti’s Discorsi delle fortificationi (1575). The English authors include Sutcliffe’s The practice, proceedings, and lawes of armes (1593), Williams, A Briefe Discourse of Warre (1590), and Leonard and Thomas Digges’s Stratioticos (1579), while the Castle, or picture of policy is Blandy’s work noted above. Leicester’s Lawes and Ordinances are a set of the earl’s laws of war written prior to the Netherlands expedition of 1585. 96
97
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
57
From his position in Leicester’s household, Harvey had the opportunity to advise his patron on military and political affairs and bring these titles to the attention of others in the circle. As Stern, Jardine, Grafton, and others have asserted, reading in early modern Europe was often performed publicly rather than privately and this appears to have been the case for soldiers as well as for scholars. Even the terminology used by early modern soldiers mirrored that of the academy. Soldiers entered their respective schools of war, whether in the Low Countries, France, or Ireland, where they gained experience, often leaving as “professours,” and then returned home to write books and manuals to enlighten new students headed for those same theatres. The close-knit circles of soldiers—these bands of brothers bound by ties of kinship and friendship, shaped by the unique experience of war—advised their companions about titles they believed best suited the education of the soldier. The long hours spent in camp and in winter quarters offered these men the opportunity, as we will see in the next chapter with Sir John Ogle’s circle, to meet and discuss the theory and practice of war, share their experiences, and study and debate the latest military literature. Reading aloud would have been a common occurrence amongst groups of soldiers, where a variety of tongues may have been spoken and where some men were literate and some were not. Whether in the warm confines of an estate, on the muster ground or in the field, small group learning was as common for soldiers as it was for the scholar with it being an important part of the training of soldiers. On the muster ground groups of five or ten soldiers often came together to be instructed in the practices of marching or firing their weapons and it is undoubtedly how the first drill manuals were used (discussed in greater detail in Chapter Three). The gentlemen soldiers of the late sixteenth century appear to have shared the contents of military books among individuals and small groups, though it is less likely that the books available in late Elizabethan England were taken to the muster ground and used in the actual training of soldiers. The analytical treatises that were printed in the period were ill-suited to the purposes of training. Books like Garrard’s Arte of Warre, Sutcliffe’s The practice, proceedings, and lawes of armes, and Barret’s The Theorike and Practicke of Moderne Warres did use illustrations and diagrams to depict methods and tactics, but as David Eltis has pointed out, late Elizabethan military books had their limitations, and “much of what was spelt out in seventeenth-century
58
chapter one
texts was left to the imagination of the reader in the previous century.”98 While one might, for example, find reference to the words of command used in infantry drills among the works of Garrard or Sutcliffe, it was only through closest of readings that these references might be revealed. The military books available to members of the Elizabethan circles had their value, and were most likely mined for the general rules found in their pages. Specific practices, particularly those that dealt with training could be found, if one first cleared away the chaff of ancient adages, historical references, and Biblical quotes. An examination of some of the gentlemen soldiers connected to the Leicester’s circle can give us a sense of how the study of military theory was used to enhance its practice. Leicester’s half-brother, Sir Philip Sidney, was a great lover of books who began his studies of the art of war while on his grand tour of Europe in the early 1570s. During his travels, Sidney visited France, Germany, and Italy and his letters to his brother Robert and to his tutor and mentor Hubert Lanquet reveal the importance he placed on book learning as an aspect of military training. When he arrived in Germany, not long into his tour, Sidney stayed with the émigré French printer Andreas Wechel and took time to visit the Frankfurt Book Fair where he purchased the wares of some of Europe’s leading printers. Throughout his trip Sidney was in contact with booksellers and agents, arranging for the purchase of old and new editions dedicated to a variety of subjects, including those related to military affairs. Lanquet maintained contact with Sidney, counselling him to devote his energies to those things that were most essential to a man of noble birth. This included the study of geometry, which Lanquet felt would “one day, be an ornament and a resource to you.” In a letter to Sidney dated January 22, 1573/74, Lanquet reasoned that geometry “may indeed, be of great use to a man of rank, in the fortification or investment of towns, in castremetation and all branches of architecture,” but mastering such a subject would require many hours of study. The work would only be justified if the knowledge was to be put to good use, and not “simply for display.”99 Lanquet took a great deal of interest in military affairs and his advice on books and learning appears to have had a positive influence on
Eltis, Military Revolution in the Sixteenth Century, 62. S.A. Pears, The Correspondence of Sir Philip Sidney and Hubert Lanquet (London: William Pickering, 1845), 25. 98 99
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
59
young Sidney. In letters to his brother Robert and to his friends, Philip passed on that advice, offering suggestions as to which books might profit the education of a soldier. Sidney wrote in the Defence of Poesie that “souldiers were the noblest estate of mankind, and horseman the noblest of soldiers,” and urged young Robert to “joyne the th[o]rough contemplation of it with the exercise, and so shall you profite more in a moneth than others in a year.”100 He went on to recommend that his brother read the well-respected continental treatises on horsemanship written by Frederick Crisone, Claudio Corte, and Pasqual Caracciolo.101 On matters pertaining to siegecraft, Sidney would repeat the words of his tutor some years later, this time to an acquaintance Edward Denny, a cousin of Walter Ralegh, who served in Ireland in the 1580s and 1590s. Sidney advised Denny to spend at least an hour of his studies on books of the art of soldiering as well as histories of war, “as the firste showes what should be done, the other what hath bene done.” He went on to recommend Machiavelli and many other authors wherof I will not take vpon me to judge, but this I thinke if you will study them, it shall be necessary for you to exercise your hande in setting downe what you reed, as in descriptions of battalions, camps, and marches [and] drawing of a plotte & practice of Arthmetike, which would be used in the art of siegecraft.102
These examples suggest that the gentlemen soldier read so as to understand how to organize men on the march, how to prepare armies to encamp or to encircle an enemy in a town. All of these activities, described by contemporaries as the preparations and actions of war, were, to a certain degree, manageable and quantifiable.103 These types of activities could be learned through book study whereas confronting the mayhem of battle and the horrors of war–be it the push of the pike or cold steel of the cavalry charge–were the product of experience alone. To better understand how the preparations and actions were carried out in the field, and to gain much needed experience, many 100 J.M. Osborn, Young Philip Sidney 1572–1577, (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1972), 82. 101 Frederick Grisone, A new booke containing the arte of ryding, and breaking greate Horses (London: William Seres, 1560); Claudio Corte, The Art of Riding, conteining diuerse necessarie instructions, demonstrations, helps and corrections apperteining to horssemenaship, not heretofore expressed by anie Author (London: H. Denham, 1584); Pasqual Caracciolo, La gloria del cauallo (Vinegia: Gabriel Giolito de’Ferrari, 1567). 102 Osborn, Young Philip Sidney, 539–40. 103 See Chapter 4, 294.
60
chapter one
men did as Sidney did, they travelled to the continent and spent time learning the military arts from an experienced veteran. In Sidney’s case, it was time spent with the Imperial commander, Lazurus von Schwendi. Lanquet believed it was important for a man of Sidney’s station to meet and possibly serve alongside the leading soldiers of the day. For this reason, he arranged a meeting between Sidney and von Schwendi in Vienna, forwarding a letter of Sidney’s to the Austrian soldier in the winter of 1573. Von Schwendi, who was considered one of the finest soldiers and military theorists of the day, went on to author a treatise on the art of war, Kriegs Discurs, von Bestellung desz gantzen Kriegswesens, that was printed in Frankfurt in 1593.104 Serving alongside Europe’s most renowned commanders and seeking out their patronage was as common for English soldiers as it was for gentlemen from other European countries. When Robert Sidney made his grand tour of the continent in 1579, he was introduced to Francois de La Noue, the Huguenot general, who like von Schwendi would also author a popular book on military affairs.105 Robert was never to acquire the military accolades that were bestowed upon his beloved brother, though he did go on to serve in the Netherlands as the governor of Flushing where he worked in close association with Maurice of Nassau and earned a reputation as a man who was knowledgeable in military affairs. In 1620/21, nearing the end of his life, Robert, then the earl of Leicester, was called upon by James I to serve on the Council of War that was confronted with the crisis over the situation in Bohemia and the Palatinate. Military circles, such as those connected to Leicester and Sidney, were to become commonplace among the English gentlemen serving in the Low Countries and in Ireland. These circles initially emanated out from the patronage dispensed by the earl of Leicester, and as Roger Manning has recently noted, the patron-client system was used in place of a hierarchical command structure, though sometimes to the detriment of operations.106 Simon Adams correctly asserts that these patron-client relationships played a significant role in shaping English military culture in the Elizabethan and early Stuart periods, owing to the fact that they replaced the military leadership and patronage role once carried out by
L. Von Schwendi, Kriegs Discurs, von Bestellung desz gantzen Kriegswesens, Frankfurt: Andre Wechels seligen Erben (Claudi de Marne vnd Johan Aubri, 1593). 105 M.V. Hay, The Life of Robert Sidney (Washington, DC: Folger Books, 1984), 60. 106 R. Manning, An Apprenticeship in Arms, 35. 104
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
61
the sovereign.107 An English monarch had not led an army into battle since the reign of the Henry VIII and no monarch would do so again until Charles I rode north with his army to fight the Scots at Kelso in June 1639. As Manning, Adams, and others have shown, there were clearly limits to the effectiveness of the clientage system, though it was to remain in place until the outbreak of the English Civil War. There is no doubt that Leicester, in particular, failed to make the best use of the subordinates in his circle and for that matter, his own military education. Even with his apparent interest in siegecraft, he overlooked the necessity of bringing pioneers and trenching equipment with him to the Netherlands and was forced, when confronted with Spanish siege works, to write to England in February 1585/6 to request that men and materials be sent forthwith to assist in the construction of saps and defences.108 With the death of Sidney in 1586 and Leicester in 1588, England lost its leading Protestant warriors and military patrons, leaving it to others to take up the mantle and continue the fight against Spain. The generation of patron-clients that followed Leicester was typified by the men who became part of the circle of Robert Devereux, the second earl of Essex. Included among this illustrious group were Charles Blount, Lord Mountjoy, Henry Wriothesley, the earl of Southampton, Sir Roger Williams, and the Danver bothers, Charles and Henry. Essex’s patronage extended well beyond these names however, and his circle came to include Sir Francis Vere, Sir Robert Sidney, Sir Thomas Bodley, Sir Richard Bingham, Sir William Russell, and Sir Francis Aleyn. All of these clients benefited from the earl’s largesse while serving their patron in one capacity or another in the Low Countries and Ireland, 107 See S. Adams, “The English Military Clientale 1542–1618,” in Patronages Et Clientélismes, 1550–1750 (France, Angleterre, Espagne, Italie), eds. C. Giry-Deloison and R. Mettam. Lille, (Centre D’Historie De La Region Du Nord, 1995), 217–27. 108 For assistance, Leicester turned to Sir Walter Ralegh, then Lord Warden of the Stanneries, who was asked to send 1000 pioneers and miners from Devon and Cornwall. Despite initial support from Elizabeth and the granting of a commission to levy the men, the Queen soon changed her mind. According to Ralegh, the matter had been “stayed [and] I know not for what cause.” When the pioneers did not arrive, blame for the delay was placed on Ralegh’s shoulders, though it had been Elizabeth’s decision not to send them, possibly out of anger over Leicester’s decision to accept the governor-generalship of the States. Of course, much of the blame for such a grievous oversight should fall firmly at the feet of Leicester who should have known that siegecraft was integral part of the war in the Low Countries. See N.L. Williams, Sir Walter Raleigh (London: Penguin Books, 1962), 87; and R. Trevelyan, Sir Walter Raleigh, London: Allen Lane, 2002, 105.
62
chapter one
and many of them can rightfully be described as true soldier-scholars. Like Essex, these gentlemen made good use of military books and they appear, unlike Leicester, to have put their military education to good use. Essex was a particularly good role model in this respect; he was educated, a lover of books and first and foremost a soldier. While Leicester had been a creature of the court, Essex was, as Paul Hammer has pointed out, a man “impatient with life at Court and driven by the feeling that he must make his mark soon if the great events of the world were not to leave him behind.”109 Essex’s military career had an auspicious beginning when, at the age of twenty, he was named colonel-general of the horse for Leicester’s expedition to the Netherlands in 1585. Prior to this appointment Essex had had no military experience beyond exercising his horse in the ring and participating in the Accession Day tilts. While other young gentlemen took the grand tour, either observing or participating in the wars, Essex remained in England and continued his studies. Essex described himself later in life as having a “bookishnesse from my very childhoode,” which carried on into his later life.110 He has been proclaimed as one of the most learned nobles in sixteenth-century England and his circle was home to soldiers and to a number of illustrious scholars who advised him on political and military policy. As a young man Essex received a comprehensive education, studying Latin and French, and later learning Spanish. Following the death of his father, Walter Devereux, in 1575, Essex was made a ward of Lord Burghley and it was in Burghley’s home that he would meet some of the young men, such as Blount, who would later become his clients. His tutors instilled in him a love of learning, and unlike most of his contemporaries from the same social class, he remained in school matriculating at Cambridge in 1577 and then going on to take an MA there in 1581. Of that education, Gervase Markham would write, fifty years later, that Essex was “trained up both of Armes and Letters” and he spent his days at Cambridge dutifully studying and keeping “his acts or disputations more duly, freely, and out of his owne knowledge and
P. Hammer, The Polarisation of Elizabethan Politics, The Political Career of Robert Devereux, 2nd Earl of Essex, 1585–1597 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1999), 92. 110 Ibid., 299. 109
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
63
readings” than many of his fellow students.111 Unfortunately, Essex’s letters reveal little about his scholarly interests and even less about his reading habits. The seizure and sale of Essex’s library after his arrest in 1599 has made it difficult to determine which books may have been a part of his education. While we have some idea about the texts that interested him, we know less about specific areas of study, particularly those that related to the martial arts that may have been a part of his education in these formative years.112 After leaving Cambridge, Essex went to court to seek the favour of the Queen before taking up soldiering and joining Leicester’s expedition in 1585. It was during the fighting in the Low Countries, that Essex’s circle began to take shape, with Sir Roger Williams and Sir Edward Wingfield113 being two of its earliest members. In time, Essex was to become the “great patron of the warrs” and as his circle grew it began to incorporate a very learned group of men, both young and old, who valued military books and the lessons that that these texts could impart. Roger Williams was to epitomize this aspect of the circle. He acted as one of Essex’s military advisors between 1585 and 1595 and was to go on to make a significant contribution to English military literature. Amos Miller calls Williams’s A Briefe Discourse of Warre, one of the most important books on warfare in the sixteenth century and a book that Essex relied upon to shape his military policies.114 A fiery Welshman, Roger Williams was considered by most to be rough around the edges, bloody-minded, often lacking in self-control and, at times, slightly mad—qualities that led him to clash with men of higher birth and character traits that contradicted his own writings on the subject of the “complete soldier.” But there were many who considered Williams to be a soldier of the highest integrity, both brave and skilful, as well as an educated man. Born in 1539/40 in Penrhos,
G. Markham, Honour in his perfection or, A treatise in commendations of the vertues and renowned vertuous vndertakings of the illustrious and heroycall princes Henry Earle of Oxenford. Henry Earle of Southampton, Robert Earle of Essex, and the euer praise-worthy and much honoured Lord, Robert Bartue, Lord Willoughby, of Eresby (London: B. Alsop for Benjamin Fisher, 1624), 27. 112 Paul Hammer notes that there is a record of purchases of school books that covered the trivium of grammar, rhetoric, and logic as well as theological texts, such as Theodor Beza’s Questiones. Hammer also lists The accedens of armory (1562), a book on heraldry. The Polarisation of Elizabethan Politics, 29. 113 Wingfield died in 1596. 114 A. Miller, “Sir Roger Williams—A Welsh Professional Soldier” The Transactions of the Honourable Society of Cymmrodorion, (1972 for 1971), 91. 111
64
chapter one
Monmouthshire, there is evidence that he attended Brasenose College, Oxford, in the early 1550s, but there is no indication that he completed his studies.115 Though his education was cut short, undoubtedly owing to his decision to go to war, Williams nonetheless possessed a keen understanding of military affairs and history, knowledge that he put to good use when writing his books. He saw his first action in France during the first years of the Religious Wars, but after that there is no evidence of his whereabouts until 1572 when he is mentioned accompanying Humphrey Gilbert to the Low Countries. By the time that he met Essex in 1585, Williams had been in the Netherlands for thirteen years and had fought in both the Dutch and Spanish armies. Despite his service in Alva’s army, Williams remained a committed Protestant and returned to the Dutch army in 1578, fighting with the States’ Army and with Leicester’s forces until 1588. The Armada year saw him back in England, assisting in the preparation of the militia.116 When the threat of Spanish invasion died away, Williams went back to the continent, serving first in the army of Henri IV, which was supported by Lord Willoughby’s expedition to Dieppe in 1590, and then with Norris in Brittany in 1591.117 His long and distinguished military career brought him to the attention of other English authors and he is praised in contemporary treatises, histories and letters. Blandy bestowed the highest of accolades on Williams, describing him as a captain of “rare and excellent condition and quality.”118 He also gained praise from men of higher standing such as Leicester, who said that in a fight Williams was “worth his weight in gold.”119 As an experienced veteran, Williams did not suffer fools gladly and his writings reveal contempt for those who were ignorant of the military arts. John Evans shed light on the relationship between the Williams and Essex, noting that when Essex joined the fleet bound for Lisbon in 1589, he sought out Williams’s advice and friendship because he knew that of all the men who had volunteered for the expedition, Williams would be the best man to get him close to the action.120 In 1591, when the English allied themselves with the French against the J.X. Evans, ed., The Works of Sir Roger Williams (Oxford: Clarendon, 1972), xiii. D.J. Trim, “Williams, Sir Roger (1539/40–1595),” in Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004. 117 Ibid. 118 Blandy, The Castle, or picture of policy, 23. 119 Miller, “Sir Roger Williams,” 89. 120 Evans, The Works of Sir Roger Williams, xxxiii. 115 116
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
65
Spanish forces occupying Brittany, Essex and Williams renewed their relationship once again outside the walls of Rouen. In Essex’s dispatches to Burghley, Williams is often mentioned. A year before his arrival in Brittany, Williams had dedicated his A Briefe discourse of Warre (1590), a treatise that spoke directly to the men of substance with whom he served, to his patron Essex. Drawing on his experience in the Spanish army and his study of La Noue’s The Politike and Militarie Discovrses (1587), Williams argued that English officers must be able to maintain order in their ranks just as their Spanish counterparts had learned from their experience in the Low Countries. He heaped scorn on the “Coronells of three dayes,” officers recently arrived from England with no training and no discipline, who can “marre all the armies of the World.”121 But Williams also singled out many gentlemen and officers who had behaved valiantly in the field. He naturally cited Essex, as well as Essex’s brother Walter, and Sir John Norris for their exemplary service during the expedition to Lisbon. Later in his discourse, Williams spoke of others who “shewed themselves most valiantlie,” including one Colonel Huntley, Sir Edmond Udall122 and Sir John Scott,123 all of whom had distinguished themselves at the bloody siege of the town of Bouennene in 1587.124 During the fighting in France, Williams was to meet face to face with Giorgio Basta, the Albanian soldier-author who later made his own contribution to military literature, writing two well-respected and widely read books, Il maestro di campo generale . . . (1606) and Il governo della cavalleria leggiera (1612).125 Their meeting, however, was not to discuss the finer points of the martial arts, but was instead a fight on the field of battle that could very well have robbed Europe of at least one of the period’s noted theorists on the art of war. The two men fought one another in 1592, when the army of duke of Parma, of which Basta was a member, attempted to relieve the siege of Rouen, where Williams was among the English force encircling the town. As Parma’s army neared Rouen, the English
Williams, A Briefe discourse of Warre, 7. Sir Edmund Udall (or Uvedale) was a member of Sir Philip Sidney’s retinue and part of Leicester’s expedition. He served with distinction at the Battle of Zutphen and later contributed two of his military books to the Bodleian. 123 Sir John Scott served in the Netherlands and France in 1580s and was an officer in Essex’s expedition to Cadiz in 1596. For more on Scott’s influence on military writing, see Chapter 3. 124 Williams, A Briefe discourse of Warre, 50–51. 125 See Chapter 5. 121 122
66
chapter one
were able to drive back a force of 2000 Spaniards and Walloons, and in the middle of the two hour melee Williams and Basta battled on horseback. The Albanian got the worst of it, suffering a sword cut to his neck and he was driven from the field, left to fight (and to write) another day!126 Williams died in 1595, but his influence on Essex and a generation of soldiers was far reaching. Paul Hammer, in his study of Essex’s political career, noted that the two men were quite close and that Essex did not simply accept Williams’s A Briefe discourse of Warre as a token of his loyalty, but was said to have “patently followed the advice and arguments” found in its pages.127 Essex not only relied upon soldiers like Williams for advice on military matters, he also drew on the knowledge of scholars in his secretariat. The mathematician and historian Henry Savile acted in the same capacity for Essex as Dee, Digges, and Harvey had done for Leicester, advising his patron on matters related to political and military policy.128 Savile wrote a translation of Tacitus’s The ende of Nero and beginning of Galba Fower bookes of the Histories of Cornelius Tacitus (1591), which went to five editions. He concluded the work with an analysis of the Roman army, A View of Certaine Militar matters, for the better vnderstanding of the ancient Roman histories, which was most likely written to assist the earl in his attempts to reform the English army in the 1590s.129 Other letters to Essex, particularly those from Lord Willoughby, suggest that there were ongoing discussions by soldiers in these circles about improving the state of the army, both at home and abroad.130 As noted, this was also the period that saw the printing of three English books on the military arts, Clayton’s Approved order of Martiall discipline (1590), Garrard’s The Arte of Warre (1591), and Sutcliffe’s The practice, proceedings and lawes of armes (1593), all of which were dedicated to Essex. Written five years after the defeat of the Armada, when defence was still very much on the minds of Englishmen, Sutcliffe recognized that the time was right for the introduction of military reforms. In his dedication to Essex,
A description of the fight can be found in Miller, “Sir Roger Williams,” 110. Hammer, The Polarisation of Elizabethan Politics, 238. 128 See Hammer and D. Womersley, “Sir Henry Savile’s Translation of Tacitus and the Political Interpretation of Elizabethan Texts,” Review of English Studies, n.s., 42 (1991), 313–42. 129 H. Savile, The ende of Nero and beginning of Galba Fower bookes of the Histories of Cornelius Tacitus. The life of Agricola (London: For Richard Wright, 1591). 130 See Chapter 2, 96 n. 48. 126 127
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
67
Sutcliffe urged discussion and debate since in the “beginning of all good successe,” is good counsel and direction: the accomplishment is expedition, in counsel nothing avayleth more then to follow good examples of expert and wise men. If then we would eyther reforme the disorders of our proceedings in warres, or settle the discipline of armes among our souldiers which is slenderly knowen, or practiced by them; what course is better then to viewe, consider, and followe the doings of most warriours both of former, and late times?131
Essex’s circle was replete with “men expert and wise,” who were ready to assist their patron in his military campaigns and, if needed, with the reforms of the militia. Among them none was more the soldier-scholar than Charles Blount, Lord Mountjoy. Mountjoy, who later succeeded Essex as commander of the English forces in Ireland, was a devout Protestant and long-time friend of Essex and the Sidneys. He served in the Netherlands and in France before establishing his reputation in Ireland in the last years of Elizabeth’s reign, a reputation that was to rival that of Francis Vere, the other great English military patron of the day. Robert Naunton, another member of Essex’s circle and author of Fragmenta regalia or, observations on the late Queen Elizabeth (1641), a biographical survey of the age’s leading lights, described Mountjoy as a modest, bashful young gentleman who was “a good peece of a Scholler.”132 Like Philip Sidney, Mountjoy was described as a bookman who also possessed an “inclination to Armes.” Mountjoy read French and Italian, and in his youth undertook the study of a broad range of subjects from natural philosophy to mathematics. He was a skilled horseman, champion of the tiltyard, and greatly enjoyed the company of men of letters, as well as martialists. Naunton drew his reader’s attention to Mountjoy’s addiction to books and their influence on his military career claiming that he “had grown by reading to the theory of a souldier.” So was he strongly invicted by his genius, to acquaintance of the practique of the Warre, which were the causes of his excursions, for he had a Company in the Low-Countries, from whence he came over with a noble acceptance of the Queen, but somewhat restlesse, in honourable thoughts he exposed himself again, and again, and would presse the Queen with
Sutcliffe, The practice, proceedings, and lawes of armes, Dedication to the Earl of Essex. 132 R. Naunton, Fragmenta regalia, or, Observations on the late Queen Elizabeth, her times and favorits written by Sir Robert Naunton (London: s.n., 1641), 38. 131
68
chapter one the pretences of visiting his Company so often, that at length he had a flat denial, and yet stole over with Sir John Norris, into action of Britain, (which was then a hot and active Warre) whom he would always call his father, honoring him above all men.133
While the Queen wished he might remain at court, Mountjoy like Essex before him, wished for nothing more than to join the wars, and rushed off in 1585 to serve with John Norris in the Netherlands and later travelled to Brittany in 1593 to fight once again with Norris. While Norris showed great distain for “paper soldiers” such as Thomas Digges, he did not condemn Mountjoy for his love of military books. Elizabeth recalled Mountjoy from Brittany in 1593, and in seeking to rein in his enthusiasm for war, she forbade him from returning to the continent, suggesting instead that he “follow [his] books, read and discourse of warre.”134 By the time Mountjoy took command of the English forces in Ireland in 1600 he had developed a keen eye for tactics, an ability that may well have been the result of his years studying the art of war.135 Mountjoy’s relationship with Essex was uneasy at first, owing to tensions between them at court. But as was sometimes the case with young men, a rather harmless duel in which neither suffered grave injury was enough to start a fast friendship. Mountjoy did not attend Essex during the voyage to Cadiz in 1596, but he did travel with his patron to the Azores a year later. Upon his return, both Essex and Mountjoy left for Ireland where they were joined by other clients of the earl, notably Henry Wriothesley, the earl of Southampton, and Sir Charles Danvers and his brother Henry, the first two of whom, like Mountjoy, appear to have been quite proud to bear the title of bookmen. Southampton, the son of a recusant who died in the Tower in 1581, had been raised and educated as a ward in Lord Burghley’s household before entering St. John’s College, Cambridge, in 1586. Southampton was only twelve when he went to Cambridge, a year after his friends Essex and the Danvers headed to the Low Countries to serve with Leicester. Burghley had refused to allow his own son Robert to contemplate entering military service, claiming that there was no such thing as an “honest or a good Christian soldier,” though it proved harder for Burghley to discourage his wards who wished to acquire their fame and fortune
133 134 135
Ibid., 38. Ibid., 18. C. Falls, Mountjoy: Elizabethan General (London: Odhams Press, 1955), 33.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
69
on the battlefield. After Southampton left Cambridge with an MA in 1589, he hoped that he might experience the thrill of battle, but was instead forced to wait until 1597 and the expedition to the Azores for his first taste of combat. One wonders whether Southampton made the journey to the islands reading the latest Spanish military books as we know he possessed a copy of Christoval de Mosquera’s Commentario de Disciplina Militar (1596), which he donated to the Bodleian in 1605, along with two other works on the martial arts, which were printed in Venice, Domenico Mora’s Il Soldato (1570) and Ruscelli’s popular Precetti della militia moderna (1568). When Southampton returned from the Azores, he took the opportunity to take his grand tour, stopping in Paris where he once again met up with the Danvers brothers. Now initiated into the world of soldiering, Southampton could finally share stories of his heroics in the Azores with his good friends. His friendship with the Danvers had been strengthened by the events surrounding the brothers’ murder of Henry Long of Wiltshire in 1594. Southampton aided the two men in their escape to the continent and his visit in 1598 marked the first time he had seen his old acquaintances since their flight to France. The brothers returned to England in 1598, having been pardoned by Elizabeth, but during their four years abroad they continued their military service, fighting in the army of Henri IV.136 Southampton and Charles Danvers both shared a love of books, and before he left England, Danvers had purchased over 200 titles from Italian booksellers that included a large number of Italian histories and a lengthy list of the accepted Italian and Spanish authorities on war. Among them were Ruscelli’s Precetti della militia moderna, Diego Salazar’s Tratado de Re Militari (1582), Giovacchino da Coniano’s Tratado dell ordinanze (1564), Girolamo Maggi’s Della fortificatione delle citta (1564), Battista Della Valle’s Vallo: libro cotinente appertenentie ad Capitanii (1524), Francesco Maria II, Duke of Urbino’s Discoursi militari . . . (1583), and Bernardino Rocca’s Impresse, stratagemi, et errori militari (1566).137 The campaign in Ireland proved to be the last opportunity that many of the members of Essex’s had to win fame and glory on the battlefield.
136 P. Hammer, “Danvers, Sir Charles (c. 1568–1601),” Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004. 137 G. Akrigg, Shakespeare and the earl of Southampton (London: Hamish Hamilton, 1968), 41. See also Cecil Papers 170, 2–5 found at the British Library, Cecil Papers at Hatfield House, Microfilm M485/1–127.
70
chapter one
Those closest to the earl, Mountjoy, the Danvers, and Southampton, figured prominently in the earl’s army and accompanying them were hundreds of gentlemen volunteers who wished to assist in the suppression of the rebellion launched by Hugh O’Neill, earl of Tyrone. On his arrival in Ireland Essex was at the height of his power and popularity and, as England’s leading military patron, he also was the darling of late Elizabethan military writers. Williams, Garrard, and Sutcliffe had all dedicated their books to the earl and the name of Essex was being praised in prose and poem. Gervase Markham, whose career as a military writer would continue into the Jacobean age, attached himself to the Essex circle in the early 1590s. He was able to do so through his friendship with Southampton, who Gervase and his brother Francis first met while the two were attending Cambridge in the early 1580s.138 During the 1590s, Gervase sought out the patronage of the members of the Essex circle, ingratiating himself by writing poems in honour of Essex, Southampton, and Mountjoy. Francis Markham, author of the Five Decades of Epistles of Warre (1622), would eventually dedicate one of the epistles found in the book to Henry Danvers, whom he served alongside in Ireland. In that epistle, Francis Markham recalled those glorious days, having seen Danvers “in the warres fighting and bleeding, your noble courage commanded my tongue to praise you, but when (wounded my selfe) I felt your bounty and your favour, you then compelled my heart to love.”139 Though the Irish war proved to be Essex’s undoing, Mountjoy faired much better by effectively commanding the English forces on the island and helping to bring the rebellion to an end in 1603. The setbacks of 1598–9, particularly the English defeat at the Battle of Yellow Ford in August 1598, were soon overcome with Mountjoy putting his military education to good use by engaging Tyrone with a variety of tactics that included the effective use of sconces and fortifications to control the countryside, the use of seapower to land troops at key points behind
138 F.N.L. Poynter, A Bibliography of Gervase Markham 1568?–1637 (Oxford: Oxford Bibliographical Society, 1962), 10. Poynter notes that in Honour in His Perfection, Markham writes that he had “lived many years where [he] daily saw his earle,” knowing him “before the warres, in the warres, and since the warres.” 139 F. Markham, Five Decades of Epistles of Warre (London: Augustine Matthewes, 1622), 141.
“caesar
to this present day of king james”
71
the enemy, and sending mounted units to harass the Irish.140 The final victory over a combined Spanish-Irish force at Kinsale in 1601–2 did much to solidify Mountjoy’s reputation as a complete soldier. In 1624, the year that James I decided to renew war with Spain, Gervase Markham looked back on the Elizabethan martial glories as inspiration for his treatise, Honour in his perfection, a hagiography describing the military exploits of four great English families: the earls of Southampton, Essex, Oxford, and the Willoughbys.141 At the time of writing, members of each of these families commanded regiments that were set to travel to the continent to regain the Palatinate. It was not by coincidence, however, that the late Elizabethan members of each family had all been connected to Essex’s circle and it was their biographies that dominated the treatise. On the title page, Markham added a line to include more of Essex’s followers, praising “the eternall memory of all that follow them now” especially “those three Noble Instances, the Lord Wriothsley, the Lord Delaware and the Lord Mountjoy.” Markham’s Honour in his Perfection linked the Elizabethan and Jacobean military worlds, connecting the military patrons of one age to those of the next. He depicted an unbroken line of English soldiers, comprising the second and third earls of Essex, Southampton, Francis and Horace Vere, and Mountjoy and their heroic ancestors, whose history stretched from “Caesar to this present day of King James.”142
140 A discussion of Mountjoy’s tactics in Ireland can be found in J. McGurk, “Terrain and Conquest 1600–1603,” in Conquest and Resistance: War in Seventeenth Century Ireland, ed. P. Lenihan, (Leiden: Brill, 2001) 87–114. 141 G. Markham, Honour in his perfection or, A treatise in commendations of the vertues and renowned vertuous vndertakings of the illustrious and heroycall princes Henry Earle of Oxenford. Henry Earle of Southampton, Robert Earle of Essex, and the euer praise-worthy and much honoured Lord, Robert Bartue, Lord Willoughby, of Eresby (London: B. Alsop for Beniamin Fisher, 1624). 142 Ibid., 10.
CHAPTER TWO
“COMPANIONS OF MARTIALL NOBLENESSE”: MILITARY CIRCLES AND BOOKS IN EARLY STUART ENGLAND Where Mars doth fight with sword in hand, where Pallas pleads with quill From a poem by Lodowick Flood in The Castle, or Picture of Pollicy (1581) The Norrises, and noble Veeres and Sidnies famous yeares: The Willoughby and worthy Gray, that served still for royall pay: Made England famous every where, To such as did their fortunes heare: Then let us not at home remaine, But Bravely to those warres againe.
Gallants, to Bohemia (1620)
The execution of Essex and Southampton’s complicity in the rebellion of 1601, as well as the death of Mountjoy in 1606 marked the disintegration of the late Elizabethan military circles and the rise of a new generation of English military patrons.1 These early Jacobean military circles formed around the long serving Low Countries veterans, Francis and Horace Veres and Henry Frederick, James I’s eldest son who became the Prince of Wales in 1610. The Treaty of London, signed by the English and Spanish in 1604 brought an end to the Anglo-Spanish war, but did not bring an end to English involvement in the fighting in the Low Countries nor did it see the demise of the patronage system that began under Leicester. Francis Vere, the general of English forces in the Netherlands, continued to dispense patronage just as Leicester, Essex, and Mountjoy had done. However, with the end of the siege of 1 Southampton was imprisoned for conspiring with Essex but he returned to favour under James I. He remained a soldier until his death in 1624 and maintained his ties with the Sidney and Essex families. Southampton was a member of Robert Sidney’s circle in the Low Countries and also accompanied Robert Devereaux, the 3rd earl of Essex to the Netherlands in 1615 where the son of his former patron obtained his first experience in the wars.
74
chapter two
Ostend in 1604, Vere resigned his command, and control over English troops soon shifted back to Maurice of Nassau, though the English colonels Horace Vere, Sir Edward Cecil, Sir Edward Conway, Sir John Sutton, and Sir John Ogle retained control over their regiments and consequently the patronage that accompanied their rank and position within the States army. Back in England, the young Prince of Wales was emerging as a military patron in his own right. By 1611, Henry was seeking to bring Vere, Cecil, Conway, and Ogle into his circle in an effort to create a military court to rival his contemporaries Maurice of Nassau and Henri IV of France. Even as a young man, the prince was a practitioner and a theoretician of the arte militarie and, like Leicester and Essex, his circle would become home to soldiers and scholars alike. Thomas Birch, the prince’s eighteenth-century biographer, described how Henry “entertain[ed ] several learned men in his court,” and a list of pensioners who frequented St. James’s Palace includes poets, pastors, and university professors, as well as swordsmen. Unlike his father, Henry was a great lover of the military arts. He was feted by the continent’s greatest soldiers and military writers, both in England and those on the other side of the channel, as a complete soldier in the making. Muscular, agile, a horseman of great skill, Henry had read much on the subject of war by his sixteenth birthday in 1610. Just prior to his death in 1612, the prince was beginning construction on a library at St. James’s Palace to house his large collection of books, many of which were dedicated to military subjects. His untimely death came as a blow to his countrymen, especially to those soldiers who believed that Henry would attain the military glories that had eluded Elizabethan England’s finest soldiers. Henry’s death led to the dispersal of his circle and forced gentlemen soldiers to seek the favour of the new heir to the throne, James’s second son, Charles. But as soldiers and military writers clamoured for Charles’s patronage, they found the new heir lacked the martial qualities and self-assuredness of his elder brother. Though some believed that he might adopt the martialism that Henry was praised for, Charles never developed a fondness for the military arts and he never pondered establishing a military court. During his reign, military patronage remained, for the most part, in the hands of the prominent Low Countries veterans, Vere, Conway, and Cecil. Only with the emergence of George Villiers, duke of Buckingham, did military patronage, particularly in the years 1624–8, find a home at Charles’s court.
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
75
This chapter opens with a survey of the English military experience during the first quarter of the seventeenth century, tracing the involvement of English troops in the wars in Ireland, the Low Countries and, the Palatinate. This period saw thousands of experienced soldiers as well as equal numbers of conscripted and pressed men sent abroad to fight in these conflicts. Books and manuals were printed to assist both groups of soldiers, with the “old experimented” veterans being advised by military authors to use drill manuals and analytical treatises as aids to improve the training of the ill-disciplined recruit. This was no easy task, since training and preparation of recruits was often neglected due, in part, to the wide range of logistical problems that stymied the Jacobean and Caroline military expeditions. The remainder of the chapter is devoted to the English military circles formed at home and abroad around Prince Henry and Francis and Horace Vere, the military books used by members of these circles, and the influence these military patrons and their circles had on the shaping of policy and the reformation of the military practice in England. The English Military Experience: 1603–1629 When James I came to the throne in 1603, English foreign policy ceased to be bellicose and took a more peaceful tack. Relations with James’s native Scotland had been relatively amicable up to Elizabeth’s death and naturally improved with James’s accession. The Anglo-Scottish treaty of 1586 balanced the English agreement to remain aloof from Scottish affairs with James’s decision to maintain a benign anti-Catholic foreign policy. When James arrived in England in the spring of 1603, it was possible for the English to let their guard down further, with one of the first tangible benefits of the joining of the English and Scottish crowns being the reduction in the size of the garrisons defending both sides of the border. In Ireland, relations between the English and Irish, though tenuous at the end of the century, underwent a marked improvement following the conclusion of the Nine Years’ War (1594–1603) at the end of Elizabeth’s reign. The number of English troops in Ireland was reduced to 8000 foot and 1000 horse when James took the throne, down from 12,000 foot and 1200 horse during the last years of the war. However, much more drastic reductions soon took place, and by 1606 the English army in Ireland numbered less than 1000 foot and 300 horse, with many of those left to control the country being ill-equipped
76
chapter two
and underfed.2 Expenditure on the Irish army continued to drop in the later Jacobean and early Caroline periods, and there is no indication that there were efforts to improve the training of soldiers in Ireland as there were in England during the 1620s with Charles I’s efforts to create the “Exact Militia.” This was undoubtedly due to government’s concerns over the cost of improving weaponry and paying for muster masters to train the soldiers serving in Ireland, but may also have had something to do with their low estimation of the Irish as a fighting force. The contemporary refrain about the Irish soldiers was that they where savages and rebels, more a rag-tag force who fought in the bogs and woods than an organized army like those encountered on the continent. That said, the Irish soldier had proven effective against the English in the Nine Years’ War, both in open combat and in skirmishes and ambushes.3 The beginning of the Thirty Years’ War in 1618 raised new fears at Whitehall about the military threat posed by Spain and France; this meant that little attention was paid to building an effective army to control Ireland owing primarily to the fiscal crisis facing the English government. Paying for a war against the Spanish and then the French taxed the Caroline government and, as Victor Treadwell has observed, the formation of a new military establishment had to wait until the wars “petered out” in 1628.4 Bitter disputes also arose over military patronage in Ireland, as courtiers rushed to sweep up the crumbs of Buckingham’s largesse, creating personal rivalries that further exacerbated the poor state of the army. It was not until the arrival of Thomas Wentworth, viscount Strafford, who assumed the Lord Deputyship of Ireland in 1633, that the first concrete steps were taken to improve the English army in Ireland; an army described at the time of his arrival as “an abomination to the inhabitants.”5 Strafford was confronted by an army only in name; it was spread across the country, mutinous, underpaid, and its soldiers were often forced to sell their weapons to feed themselves. Training was hardly a consideration for either the Fissel, English Warfare, 236. J. McGurk, The Elizabethan Conquest of Ireland: The 1590s Crisis (Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1997), 229. 4 V. Treadwell, Buckingham and Ireland, 1616–1628 (Dublin: Four Courts Press, 1998), 272–3. Treadwell notes that the English government assigned £32,000 to the upkeep of the English forces in Ireland in 1624, an amount that was just half the expenditure for Mansfeld’s expedition to the Palatinate that same year. 5 Quoted in H. O’Grady, Strafford and Ireland, vol. 1 (Dublin: Hodges, Figgis, 1923), 6. 2 3
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
77
officers or their men. Strafford’s reforms, part of his programme of the “Thorough” carried out to strengthen the crown’s authority in Ireland, required enforcement of the laws and, the new Lord Deputy believed, the army, once improved, would be best suited to protect the citizenry. While there is no evidence to indicate that the English soldiers in Ireland were supplied with printed drill manuals or that English military books were printed in Ireland,6 Rolf Loeber and Geoffrey Parker have found evidence of the presence of continental military books among the Spanish soldiers stationed in Ireland in the 1580s. They note the presentation of a book on fortifications to Sir George Carew during his time as lord president of Munster from 1600–1604,7 as well as two books on military architecture thought to have been in the possession of the Irish gunner Samuel Molyneux, who served in the Parliamentary army.8 Irish soldiers, particularly those in Spanish service in the Netherlands, would have had some familiarity with military literature printed on the continent by the 1620s and they may have brought these books back to Ireland when they returned home to recruit new volunteers.9 Indeed, it was the Low Countries that continued to have the greatest influence on the art of war in England in the first decades of James’s reign. Even though the king saw himself as a peacemaker, seeking to strike a balance between Catholics and Protestants in Europe, he refused 6 See E.R.M. Dix, Catalogue of Early Dublin-Printed Books 1601 to 1700 (New York: Lenox Hill, 1912). Carew was Sir Walter Ralegh’s cousin. 7 George Carew, earl of Totnes (1555–1629) served in both the navy and the army in the 1570s and 1580s. Carew fought with some of greatest English military figures of the day, serving with Humphrey Gilbert in the Caribbean, with Henry Sidney and Essex in Ireland, and also accompanying Essex to Cadiz in 1596 and to the Azores in 1597. At the end of his military career, Carew continued to help shape military policy, first as Lord President of Miunster (1600–1604) then as master of ordnance (1608–1624) and finally as a member of the Privy Council (1616–1629) and the Council of War (1624–1629). See U. Lotz-Heumann, “Carew, George, earl of Totnes (1555–1629),” Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, Oxford University Press, 2004. For a discussion of Carew’s time as master of ordnance see R.W. Stewart, The English Ordnance Office 1585–1625: A Case Study in Bureaucracy (Woodbridge, UK: Boydell Press, 1994). Carew played an important part in the siege of Glin Castle outside Limerick in 1600 and was described by contemporaries as “a man that knows well how to manage great artillery.” See McGurk, The Elizabethan Conquest of Ireland, 228. 8 Molyneux’s library housed Nicholas Goldman’s La nouvelle fortification (1645) and Mattias Dögen’s Architectura militaris moderna (1647); see R. Loeber and G. Parker, “The Military Revolution in Seventeenth-Century Ireland,” in Ireland From Independence to Occupation 1641–1660, ed. J.H. Ohlmeyer (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1995), 70–1. 9 See Chapter 4 for a discussion of Irishman Garret Barry’s A Discourse Of Military Discipline (1634).
78
chapter two
to withdraw English support for the Dutch rebels. Nevertheless, one of James’s first foreign policy initiatives was to extricate England from the long war with Spain, which raised the possibility that English troops might be withdrawn from the Netherlands as part of any accord with Madrid. In the summer of 1603, James rescinded the letters of marque given to English privateers and not long after he agreed to begin talks with Spain to end the hostilities that were now a quarter century old. The negotiations, carried out by representatives of the English and Spanish crowns, took place at the same time that English and Dutch soldiers, under the command of Francis Vere, were defending the coastal town of Ostend against a Spanish siege that began three years earlier. While there were fears in the Dutch camp that the English peace with Spain might lead to an end of support for the army of States General, those fears were put to rest when James refused to call for the return of English troops serving in the Low Countries. Consequently, English volunteers continued to make their way to the Low Countries and English regiments, commanded by English colonels, remained in Dutch service until the signing of the Twelve Years’ Truce between Spain and the States General in 1609. English troops also remained in the garrisons protecting the cautionary towns of Brill, Flushing, Bergen-op-Zoom, and the fortifications at Rammekens.10 The motto beati pacifici may have summed up James’s foreign policy, but as far as the Low Countries were concerned England was still at war with Spain and the Netherlands remained the centre of English military culture. Though some veterans returned home after the Twelve Years’ Truce, many more stayed on, owing in part to the mounting tensions over the succession crisis in the nearby Rhenish principality of Cleves-Julich that erupted in 1609. The death of William, duke of Cleves, a Catholic who died without issue in March 1609, sparked a dispute over succession that touched all of the major European powers and exacerbated the religious tensions between Catholics and Protestants. Claimants from both sides of the religious divide came forth to assert their rights to the duchy and disputes between the parties led to the signing of the Treaty of Dortmund in May 1609, which was meant to solve the crisis amicably. The treaty established joint rule over Cleves-Julich with the two main claimants being the Elector of
10 M. Lee, James I and Henri IV, An Essay in English Foreign Policy (Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, 1970), 27.
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
79
Brandenburg (who had the support of Maurice and Henri IV) and the duke of Neuberg (who was the imperial candidate). Despite the agreement in Dortmund, the treaty began to unravel and the situation in the Rhineland worsened rather than improved. The duke of Neuberg, wishing to control the duchy outright, sought the aid of the Hapsburgs who promptly raised an army and took the heavily fortified town of Julich. Neither Maurice of Nassau nor Henri IV were willing to accept Hapsburg control over the duchy and took steps to raise an army to retake Julich and return the situation to the status quo established at Dortmund. The army, commanded by Maurice, was composed of 13,000 men and 3000 horse to which was added a regiment of French troops and a contingent of 4000 English and Scots. Edward Cecil commanded one regiment, while the other colonelcies were given to Hatton Cheeke and Robert Henderson.11 Horace Vere and John Ogle provided men from their regiments and joined Maurice just prior to the siege. The initial phase of this military chess match ended with the siege and capture of Julich by Maurice in July 1610. He then strengthened Julich with a garrison of 2500 men to convince the duke of Neuberg to adhere to the agreements set out at Dortmund. Neuberg thought differently and called on the Spanish general Ambrosio Spinola to bring his army into the Rhineland to retake Julich. The situation, though tense, was more a cold war than a hot one and it was not until 1614 that the two sides once again came to blows. Spinola’s army entered the Rhineland in the late summer of 1614 proceeding with caution and capturing the towns Aachen, Nuys, Mulhem, and Wesel but, weary of its strong defences and its large garrison, deciding against undertaking a siege of Julich. Maurice had remained in command of his polyglot army of Dutch, English, Scots, French, and Germans that was now joined by Horace Vere, who had been given overall command of the English regiments with Ogle, Cecil, Henderson, and his fellow countryman, William Brog, the acting colonels.12 Skirmishing between the armies broke out in September around the town of Rees, though both Maurice and Spinola continued to move cautiously, each wishing to see the situation solved through negotiation rather than by force of arms. J. Miller, Swords for Hire: The Scottish Mercenary (Edinburgh: Birlinn, 2007), 108. Brog continued to serve in the States Army through the beginning of the Thirty Years’ War. See S. Murdoch, ed., Scotland and the Thirty Years’ War, 1618–1648 (Leiden: Brill, 2001), 19. 11 12
80
chapter two
As one contemporary news pamphlet described it, “all lay still, and nothing [was] attempted.”13 On September 23 Maurice brought his entire army into the field with Vere and Ogle in the vanguard. They were to direct their attack against a series of sconces that Spinola had constructed around Rees, but in the end Maurice halted the attack and instead sent his troops out to secure the towns surrounding Rees. The crisis subsided as cooler heads prevailed and negotiations were opened between Spinola and Maurice in December 1614, with the English ambassador Sir Henry Wotten and his French counterpart, Eustache de Refuge, seigneur de Précy, also in attendance. The two sides agreed to stand down their armies and return to their garrisons, bringing the Cleves-Julich crisis to an end. Julich remained in Protestant hands while Wesel, taken in 1614 by Spinola, was garrisoned by a Catholic army. There was widespread concern that the events in Cleves-Julich would mark the beginning of larger continental conflict but this was not to be and it was four years before a new, and much more deadly, struggle broke out in Bohemia. European tensions, however, were not limited to the Rhineland, and further to the north, the Danes were engaged in the Kalmar War with the Swedes from 1611–3. Once again James played the role of peacemaker, undertaking diplomatic efforts to bring the conflict to an end. Despite those negotiations, English and Scots volunteers still travelled to Denmark to serve in the army of Christian IV. In 1613, a contingent of some 4000 English was raised by Robert Bertie, Lord Willoughby, but they and their Scots comrades arrived as the fighting in Kalmar was coming to a close and they had no impact on the outcome of the struggle.14 The campaigns in Cleves-Julich and Denmark proved to be dress rehearsals for the greater European war that unfolded in central Europe following the Bohemian crisis of 1618–20. When Frederick V was driven from his throne in Bohemia and from his ancestral lands in Palatinate, the political and military stakes became much higher than they were in Cleves-Julich in 1614. When news arrived in London that Frederick and 13 H. Peacham, A most true relation of the affaires of Cleve and Gulick as also of all what hath passed this last summer, since the most excellent and victorious prince, Maurice of Nassau, tooke the field with his armie, encamping before Rees in Cleueland: and the losse of Wesel, taken in by the Marques Spinola: vnto the breaking vp of our armie in the beginning of December last past. 1614. With the articles of the peace, propounded at Santen By Henrie Peacham (London: W. Stansby for John Helme, 1615), sig. Cv. 14 S. Murdoch, Britain, Denmark-Norway and the House of Stuart 1603–1660 (East Linton, UK: Tuckwell Press), 190.
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
81
his wife Elizabeth had been forced to flee Bohemia, James I, Frederick’s father-in-law, was faced with a foreign policy predicament. No longer could the English king maintain his cordial relations with Hapsburg Spain as its troops, and those of the Catholic League, hounded his relations across Europe. The English public could purchase news pamphlets and corantos describing Frederick’s disastrous defeat at the Battle of White Mountain in 1620 and the plight of Germany’s Protestants at the hands of the imperial and Spanish forces.15 The presses around St. Paul’s worked incessantly to stir support for a military response to the crisis and as the drums of war reverberated across the continent, English public opinion, fuelled by anti-Catholic sentiment, called for James to send troops to the Palatinate to save the beleaguered couple. As Mark Fissel has pointed out, England was not “a passive spectator” in the wars of religion and with the beginning of the Thirty Years’ War and the end of the Twelve Years’ Truce in 1621, veterans and new recruits wishing to renew the fight with Spain and the Emperor again set off from England’s shores for the continent.16 In 1620 a force of 2200 English foot was raised (the expedition employed no cavalry) and paid for by the government of the Palatinate. The Palatine’s ambassador, Christoph Dohna, elected Horace Vere to command the expedition. Vere’s selection came at the expense of Edward Cecil, who had been a long-time rival of Vere’s owing to disagreements the two had during their service in the Low Countries, disagreements that were further
15 Corontos and news pamphlets on the Bohemian crisis were printed regularly in London throughout the period 1618–1623, included among these were the following titles: Anon., An ansvvere to the question: vvhether the Emperour that now is, can bee iudge in the Bohemian controuersie or no? Together with the extract taken out of the acts of the Dyet at Auspurghe, in the yeare 1584: concerning the kingdome of Bohemia (London: W. Jones for W. Stansby, 1620); Anon., Bohemiae regnum electiuum. That is, A plaine and true relation of the proceeding of the states of Bohemi. . . . (London: William Jones, 1620); Anon., Corant or vveekly nevves, from Italy, Germany, Hungaria, Polonia, Bohemia, France, and the Low-Countries (London: Nathaniel Butter, 1621); Anon., A iournall of the voyage of the young Prince Fredericke Henry, Prince of Bohemia Taken in the sixt yeare of his age, from Prague in Bohemia, to Luerden in Friesland, to the court of Count Ernestus Cassimerus van Nassaw Gouernor of Friesland (London: G. Eld for Nathaniel Butter and Nicholas Bourne, 1623); Anon., The last newes from Bohemia with all the adioyning prouinces that be now vp in armes. Wherein is related all the passages that haue happened since the high and mighty prince elector Palatine of the Rhine was elected and crowned King of Bohemia. With other accidents very delightfull to the reader (S.l.: J. Bill, 1620). 16 Fissel, English Warfare 1511–1642, 271. Roger Manning puts the number of English soldiers in the States Army in 1623 at 9550 and the number of Scots at 3870, for a total of 13,420 or 22% of the total of 60,250. A year later, the English contingent numbered 19,100. See R. Manning, Apprenticeship, 53.
82
chapter two
exacerbated during the Cleves-Julich campaign.17 Among those who volunteered to serve alongside Vere were Henry de Vere, 18th earl of Oxford, Robert Devereux, 3rd earl of Essex, Robert Sidney, then Lord Lisle, Thomas Lord Cromwell, and Sir Edward Sackville. Short of money, Vere’s expedition would come to rely upon contributions from the pockets of these wealthy men to pay the troops and purchase supplies. The addition of so few troops to the Protestant cause could not win back the Palatinate, and they proved unable to stop Spinola’s army of 15,000 men, now under the command of Gonzalez de Córdoba, from overrunning the Lower Palatinate. At the same time the army of the Catholic League, commanded by Count von Tilly, quickly subdued the Upper Palatinate. The English, who were garrisoned in the towns of Frankenthal and Mannheim in the Lower Palatinate, could do little to slow the advance of Córdoba. To make matters worse, on his return to the Netherlands, Spinola captured Julich in 1621, reversing Maurice’s success of 1610 and cutting off the supply route between the Low Countries and the Upper Palatinate.18 In the Palatinate, the situation went from bad to worse; Mainz fell to Córdoba in August 1621, Kreuznach and Oppenheim soon after. Free to assist the Spanish army, Tilly’s imperial troops laid siege to Heidelberg, which capitulated in September 1622 and Mannheim followed in early November. The English garrison at Frankenthal held on during the winter months but it was recognized that it was futile to hold on to the fortification in light of the noose tightening around the town. In March 1623 the English, knowing that they could not alter the situation in the Palatinate, handed over Frankenthal to the Spanish. Vere’s troops fought bravely and stoutly defended the fortifications they garrisoned, but they were finally overwhelmed by the might of the combined Spanish and imperial forces. The loss of the Palatinate prompted a good deal of soul-searching in England in the last years of James’s reign, as the king, his ministers, and Parliament debated a suitable military response to the European crisis. The Council of War, which was first established in January 1620/21 included many of the prominent Elizabethan and Jacobean veterans, including Conway, Cecil, Vere, Ogle, and John Bingham, a veteran
17 C. Dalton, Life and Times of General Sir Edward Cecil, vol. 1 (London: Sampson, Low, Marston, Searle & Rivington, 1885), 329. 18 G. Parker, ed., The Thirty Years’ War (New York: Barnes and Noble Books, 1987), 65.
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
83
and former captain of the London Artillery Company. All of them advised against a full-scale war reminiscent of the Henrician period, insisting that the country could not afford the costs of a large military operation involving moving thousands of men to the continent.19 That council prepared a report on the feasibility of retaking the Palatinate, plans that were soon overtaken by the events in Germany and the failure of Vere’s expedition in 1622.20 A new council, that included the Elizabethan veterans and new members, Viscount Grandison and Lords Brooke, Carew, and Chichester, were appointed to address the new political and military situation in Germany. This second council called for a cautious policy, one that would rely upon small contingents being sent to the continent to ally with Protestant armies already fighting in Germany. The first of these expeditions was commanded by the German military entrepreneur Count Ernst von Mansfeld and supported by a grant of £55,000 raised by James in lieu of subsidies that had yet to arrive from Parliament. Mansfeld landed in London in April 1624 and was soon courting James’s government and the City for their support in raising troops and money to complement the force of 7000 Germans he brought with him to England.21 12,000 English were quickly raised by the press but the men, drawn primarily from the southeast, lacked discipline and training and could hardly be called soldiers. To overcome some of the problems of preparing the troops for war, a set of printed instructions, Count Mansfields Directions of Warre, were issued to the men as they departed England, though most of those conscripted were too ignorant or too weak to take any of their training to heart.22 The expedition departed for the Netherlands in late November 1624 and was expected to march from the Dutch ports to join with French cavalry in operations against the Spanish and imperial troops now controlling the Palatinate.23 The harsh winter and poor communication between the English and their Dutch allies meant that there was no food or supplies available to the expedition when it arrived in Zeeland. As a result of these logistical failures, men began to fall ill Cogswell, The Blessed Revolution (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989), 74. E.I. Carlyle, “Committees of Council under the Earlier Stuarts,” English Historical Review 21, no. 84 (Oct. 1906): 680. 21 Manning, Apprenticeship, 106. 22 Ibid., 190. See Chapter 3 for a discussion of the contents of Count Mansfields Directions of Warre. 23 R. Lockyer, Buckingham, the life and political career of George Villiers, First Duke of Buckingham, 1592–1628 (London: Longman, 1984), 207. 19
20
84
chapter two
and desert the ranks, leading to a general breakdown of order and a decision by Mansfeld to forego the march to the Palatinate and instead aid the Dutch in their attempts to relieve the siege of Breda. Dogged by problems almost from its inception, Mansfeld’s expedition failed miserably and was unable to save either Breda or the Palatinate. The decision to rely upon pressed men, rather than recruiting experienced men from the trained bands seems to have doomed the expedition, the lack of logistical support and regular pay simply making matters even worse. Few of 12,000 men ever made it back to England and the Council of War was forced to return to the drawing board to devise a new set of plans to assist Frederick in regaining his lost lands. The death of James in March 1625 and the accession of Charles I did little to change the fortunes of war for the English. Charles inherited his father’s chief minister, George Villiers, 2nd duke of Buckingham, and both men were eager to lead the country in a war against Spain, particularly after the embarrassing collapse of the Spanish match and the return of Charles and Buckingham from Madrid in 1623. That return led to the “blessed revolution,” a sea-change in English foreign policy that saw a renewal of the old animosities between London and Madrid and the declaration of war against Spain in 1624. The decision to go to war with Spain was greeted with cheers by those who felt James’s government would now put its full backing behind any military operations against the Spanish, thereby avoiding the debacles that marked the expeditions commanded by Vere and Mansfeld. George Marcelline summed up the concerns of many in his Vox Militis (1625), a reprinting of Barnabe Rich’s Allarme to England (1578), that warned that the English lived “without regard of Militarie discipline,” and were being forced to stand and behold their friends in apparent danger “almost subverted by there enemies unjust persecution, and yet with hold[ing] their helping hand and assistance.”24 Marcelline, who dedicated his treatise to Mansfeld, wished to resurrect the reputation of the English soldier, which by this time had taken a beating. Yet his hopes, and those of the nation, were dashed once again when another foray to the continent in 1627, this time in support of the Danes, also faltered.
24
G. Marcelline, Vox militis (London: B[ernard] A[lsop] for Thomas Archer, 1625).
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
85
Charles wished to re-establish the Anglo-Danish military relationship that first took shape during the Kalmar War of 1611–13. In 1625 he agreed to assist his uncle Christian IV with money and men after the Danish king had decided to enter the war against the Emperor. Christian had spent much of the previous decade securing Denmark’s control over north Germany and fending off the Swedes and the Dutch. He sought assistance from his allies and donned the mantle of the new saviour of Protestant Europe. Christian’s foray into Germany did not produce the results that either he, the English or the Dutch had hoped for. The Danes were defeated by Tilly’s army at Lutter in 1626, but this failed to sway Charles from providing assistance and he successfully raised a force of 4000 men under the command of Sir Charles Morgan, which was sent to north Germany to aid Christian’s demoralized army. Once again, the pressing of criminals and vagrants into service exposed the serious flaws in the English system of recruitment and left Morgan with an ineffective force unable to influence the military balance in Germany. Even as failure plagued England’s military operations in the early years of Charles’s reign, the twin problems of recruitment and logistics were continually overlooked during the formulation of a strategy to fight the Spanish. The joint naval-military expeditions to Cadiz in 1625 and La Rochelle in 1627–8 would ultimately suffer from the same shortcomings in command, logistics, and manpower as those sent to relieve the Palatinate in 1620–21 or the Danes in 1625. Even before the English fleet left for Cadiz in October 1625, its commander, Sir Edward Cecil, now viscount Wimbledon, was aware that his army, which was composed of 10,000 “raw” men, would find the voyage a long and difficult one. Though it was hoped that the English would once again “singe the king’s beard” as the fleets of 1587 and 1596 had done, Cecil had some reservations about the operation, particularly after the recent failure of Mansfeld’s expedition. Writing to Buckingham in June 1625, Cecil was fearful that the fall of Breda just months before would discourage the Dutch from letting the experienced Englishmen serving in their army leave to join the fleet headed for Cadiz. By this disposition of the States to the keeping all their old souldiers, I wish your Excellencie will be pleased to be as careful in your choice, as you are desirous of great designs. For otherwise the honour and the charge will both be cast away, as your Excellencie may perceive in some of our latter expeditions, seeing that although there are many called Souldiers in the world, yet but a few there be that are so; for so long a man may live in the profession to inable him sufficiently, that many grow unable
86
chapter two to perform what they know before they have attained to the knowledge of what to perform. The knowledge of war being the highest of human things that God suffereth man’s understanding to reach unto.25
Cecil felt pressed for time in his preparations and told Buckingham that he wished he had “known of this imployment but some months sooner.”26 He went on to inform the duke that previous operations had “suffered (for the most part) more than through the negligence, as in victual, munition, boats for Landing, and for the receiving of sick men to keep the rest from infection.”27 But Buckingham could not afford to give Cecil more time. The duke had been able to convince Charles and Parliament that the war with Spain was in England’s best interest and that it could lead to the return of the Palatinate and take pressure off the Dutch. Once Cadiz and its shipping were destroyed the English navy could be used against other Spanish ports and be turned against the Plate Fleet, thereby cutting off the flow of supplies, money, and men moving between the Americas, the Iberian Peninsula, and the Low Countries. This would slowly throttle the Spanish war effort and either bring them to the negotiating table or weaken Spain to the extent that they would be forced to withdraw from the Palatinate. Yet, it was Buckingham’s own inexperience in military affairs combined with his decision to promote officers who were equally inexperienced that doomed the Cadiz expedition. Martyn Bennett has described how the Privy Council attempted to bring veteran captains and troops from the Low Countries and to see that those men and officers who had returned from the Mansfeld expedition were included in the contingent bound for Cadiz.28 Bennett found that 2000 of the 10,000 men who sailed for Cadiz had experience; but it was Buckingham’s new officers who dominated command and who quarrelled about the mission’s objectives once they reached Spain. Despite his years of experience, blame for the failure of the Cadiz expedition was laid squarely at the feet of Cecil and there is no doubt that he was the wrong man for the job. Such an operation required a man of daring, just as Drake and Essex had been, and not a man of Cecil’s caution. Essex’s son, Robert,
Dalton, Life and Times of General Sir Edward Cecil, vol. 2, 101. Ibid. 27 Ibid., 101–2. 28 M. Bennett, “The Officer Corps and Army Command in the British Isles, 1620– 1660,” in The Chivalric Ethos and the Development of Military Professionalism, ed. D. Trim (Leiden: Brill, 2003), 293–4. 25 26
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
87
the 3rd earl, was becoming a swordsman of some repute and may well have been better suited to the task than the older Cecil. As lord admiral, Buckingham dominated the planning of military operations between 1624 and 1628, and he cast a long shadow over the preparation and the outcome of these expeditions. As a young man, Buckingham had not been educated by soldiers, nor had he spent time in their company; he was neither a scholar nor a student of the military arts like Mountjoy or Essex. Buckingham’s tour of the continent, which he undertook in 1608 at the age of sixteen, saw him spend much of his time in France, training in the arts of horsemanship and fencing and not, like so many of his contemporaries, serving in the war in the Low Countries. When he became James’s chief minister, Buckingham did seek out the country’s leading soldiers, finding them useful allies and founts of information for a subject about which he knew little. During the 1620s, Edward Conway became a close confidant of the duke. The two men often met to discuss military affairs and it was reported in 1622 that they drilled together with pikes.29 Likewise, Edward Cecil also described himself as the “creature you [Buckingham] have made,” and the general was more than happy to offer his patron advice and in return received command of the Cadiz expedition. Sir William Heydon, who came from a family of late Elizabethan and early Stuart soldiers also counselled Buckingham on military matters.30 Buckingham led the attack on La Rochelle in 1627, not allowing inexperience to prevent him from seeking military glories of his own. He had been instrumental in convincing Parliament and the nation to back a war with Spain and in 1627 he turned his attention to France. This new war would be fought in defence of the Protestant faith and the battleground would be at La Rochelle where Richelieu’s army was encircling the Huguenot town. As if on cue, the campaign to take the island fortresses of the Isle de Rhé, which protected the entrance to the port, faced the same problems as those that plagued previous English military operations. Buckingham had chosen his creatures to command over more experienced men. Money, victuals, munitions, and
29 T. Cogswell, The Blessed Revolution (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1989), 59. 30 Heydon’s father was Sir Christopher Heydon, who had served with Essex in Ireland. His uncle John Heydon also fought with Essex in the Netherlands and in Ireland. William Heydon was killed on the Isle de Rhé while his brother, Sir John Heydon, would later fight for the Royalists in the Civil War. See Lockyer, Buckingham, 383.
88
chapter two
trenching equipment were all in short supply, and the training of the newly pressed men awaiting at the south coast ports for embarkation to France was also overlooked. Though the English troops were able to carry out an amphibious landing on the Isle de Rhé and displayed a good deal of heroism in fending off attacks by French infantry and cavalry, they were unable to take the citadel of St. Martin. The La Rochelle expedition, as well as those sent to Germany and Spain, can tell us much more about the lack of English political will and deficiencies in the corrupt system of conscription than they can about the real business of soldiering. In each instance, the bulk of these forces were pressed men with little or no training who were in no position to meet the demands of these operations, particularly the amphibious landings. We must keep in mind that all the English armies raised in the 1620s were conscripted and none were drawn from the available pool of trained men who served in the militia. Approximately 50,000 conscripts were raised over the course of the decade, many of whom were described as drunkards, rogues, gaolbirds, rabble, or the all inclusive “insufficient men.”31 These were not the hardened veterans of the war in the Low Countries, nor were they members of the local trained bands or the London military societies who were, by this time, receiving training according to the infantry drill methods introduced by Maurice of Nassau in the 1590s. While there were conscripted men who became good soldiers and served with distinction, there were also those who were sent abroad with only a rudimentary understanding of how their weapons worked. These men would have received the most basic instructions in drill owing to the short time between conscription and deployment on the continent. Wastage due to sickness and desertion further undermined any cohesion between these men and their officers; that is if cohesion was ever possible under such circumstances. As I will show in the next chapter, drill manuals and instructions were introduced in an attempt to improve the training of conscripts, but sickly recruits lacking in discipline and prone to desertion clearly undermined efforts to turn these men into soldiers. Therefore one must look at the development of the trained bands and the military societies for evidence of the impact of printed books on training and the education of the complete English soldier. Both the
31 S.J. Stearns, “Conscription and English Society in the 1620s,” Journal of British Studies 11 (May 1972): 7–8.
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
89
bands and the military societies used drill manuals and printed instructions during the early Stuart period, with many of these books originating from these venues. As I discussed in the last chapter, the decision by the Elizabethan government in 1572–3 to establish the trained bands had brought about some improvements to training, but standardization of practice was hardly possible without the dissemination of specific instructions that spelled out the correct forms of drill and the accompanying words of command to all those in the militia. On account of the “militia vacation” that began in 1604 and continued until 1612, there was little innovation in the training of the bands in the first decade of Jacobean rule. The Jacobean government’s decision to repeal the 1558 militia law, which required local gentry to contribute weapons, armour, and horses to the bands also undermined some of the positive steps taken to improve training in the previous quarter century. Between 1604 and 1612 few counties mustered their bands and those that did faced opposition from recalcitrant gentry who refused to provide weapons or money for the upkeep of the militia. The decision to renew yearly musters came as tensions were growing in Cleves-Julich. The events in the Rhineland forced James to rethink his neglect of the trained bands and to call for the resumption of regular musters in 1613. During the militia vacation, some dedicated lord lieutenants continued to hold musters and urged their bands to train at special musters. The earls of Northampton and Exeter and lord lieutenants of Norfolk and Northamptonshire pushed their deputies to improve the militia even during the vacation.32 The peace with Spain did not necessarily result in a complete cessation of musters, as there also is recorded evidence that musters were held in Hampshire and Caernarvonshire in 1605 and in Essex, Herefordshire, Norfolk, and Wiltshire in 1608.33 The Privy Council had issued orders for a general muster in 1608, citing the need to remain vigilant against invasion even in “this happy time of peace.”34 Despite those orders, there is no indication that training played a part in these musters, which were carried out primarily for administrative purposes, if they were carried out at all. When musters
32 A. Fletcher, Reform in the Provinces: The Government of Stuart England (New Haven: Yale University, 1986), 286. Thomas Cecil was the earl of Exeter and William Compton, was earl of Northampton. 33 Ibid., 286. 34 J. Wake, ed. The Montagu Musters Book A.D. 1602–1623 (Peterborogh, UK: Northamptonshire Record Society, 1935), liii.
90
chapter two
were resumed in 1613–14 there was a greater emphasis placed on training, though here again the results varied from county to county. In Devonshire, the earl of Bath wrote to the council to inform them that the “trained bands are 5,000 men but not half of them know how to use their weapons.”35 The earl of Exeter lambasted his lieutenants in Northamptonshire for failing to make training a part of the 1613 muster in the eastern division of the county. He found it hard to believe that the lieutenants were “so backward touching the training of the bands . . . considering how necessary a thing it is that men who are appointed to wear armour upon their backs should be learned how to use them, and learn to march with them.” Exeter found that other shires, “Kent, Sussex, Middlesex, Hertfordshire and Hampshire were all trained,” and so directed his deputies to “make sure that you are warranted by my letters.”36 The raising of Spinola’s army in response to the Cleves-Julich crisis prompted the return of regular yearly musters. In 1616, the Privy Council went one step further calling for the standardization of weaponry with calivers to be replaced by muskets at the expense of each county. The cost of replacing the older weapons proved beyond the capacity of many counties, representing another burden on the local inhabitants who were forced to pay higher militia rates. Most counties found they could not raise the additional money without further angering rate payers who were digging in their heels and refusing to pay. Consequently, the process of weapons’ standardization was slow and ad hoc at best. The paucity of arms, a problem that dated back to the Elizabethan period, meant that the older calivers had to be retained by the bands with muskets purchased over several decades, the two types of weapons co-existing in county arsenals well into the 1630s. In the 1610s and 1620s, deficiencies extended beyond the training and arming of the foot to include the raising of horse troops as well. In fact, most counties found it close to impossible to raise complete companies of horse for musters. Boynton noted that those counties closest to London had the best muster returns for the horse, but most deputy lieutenants entered the same tired refrain when returning their muster certificates: “the horse are much decayed.”37
35 36 37
CSPD, Vol. LXXII 1611–1618, 123. Ibid., lv. Boynton, The Elizabethan Militia 1558–1638, 227.
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
91
If there was a centre of activity for English military culture outside the Low Countries in the early Stuart period, it was in London where the formation of military societies inside and outside the city provided a venue for military training during the last years of the vacation. The reformation of the Honourable Artillery Company at Bishopsgate in 1610 was to have far-reaching implications for military training and military literature over the next four decades. The company held regular infantry drill sessions, carried out by its 250 members, and it became the model for military practice in Jacobean and Caroline England. The interaction between Low Countries veterans and members of the companies and the sharing of information about practices and tactics, turned the military societies into the early modern equivalent of a military think-tank. These were England’s very own schools of war, where ideas were exchanged and military books and drill manuals were produced. Owing to the popularity of Artillery Company and a wish to emulate the training taking place at Bishopsgate, other military companies and artillery yards were established, first in Westminster and Middlesex, then in other towns across the country in the 1620s and 1630s.38 With thousands of soldiers going to and from the Low Countries, military culture in England was never wholly exorcised from developments taking place on the continent. When soldiers returned from the wars, they often became muster masters, the only “full-time” professionals connected with the training of the militia, or they were paid to act as sergeants, training the bands for three months before moving on to another riding or county. Privy Council instructions issued in 1625 stated that the sergeants were to be “imployed into the severall counties for instructinge of Souldiers . . . both of ye suffitiencye of the Armes and men, and their skill and readiness to vse their armes, and performe wth knowledge ye duties of Souldiers . . . and to be complete, 38 After the establishment of the Artillery Company in 1610, London suburbs of Southwark and Westminster set up the “Martial Yard” and the “Military Company” respectively, while the towns of Coventry (1617), Colchester (1621), Bury St. Edmunds (1622), Norwich (1625), Bristol (1625), Great Yarmouth (1626), Gloucester (1626), Chester (1626), Ipswich (1629), and Nottingham (1629) formed yards of their own. See K. Roberts, “Lessons in Revolution: The Impact of the London Military Companies,” Cromwelliana, (1992), 38 and “Citizen Soldiers: the Military Power of the City of London,” in London and the Civil War, ed. S. Porter (London: MacMillan Press, 1996). Also see Boynton, The Elizabethan Militia, 263–4 and W. Hunt, “Civic Chivalry and the English Civil War,” in The Transmission of Culture in Early Modern Europe, eds. A. Grafton and A. Blair (Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press, 1990), 218.
92
chapter two
accordinge to the moderne fashione.”39 Some counties were happy to accept the sergeants, with Devon, Lancashire, Cheshire, Northampton, and Pembroke reporting these men did good work in training the bands, while Norfolk saw little need in employing them, having ample “old practiced Souldiers of our owne country . . . very able and sufficient” to perform the task, some even “wthout any further charge to the Countrye.”40 These veterans assisted in the introduction into England of the “moderne fashione” of infantry drill, imported from the Low Countries. In the 1620s the Jacobean and Caroline governments took steps to aid the muster masters and sergeants in their training of the militia, introducing printed drill manuals, complete with engraved pike and shot postures, which helped to spread the so-called “continental infection.” In the rest of this chapter, I discuss how the members of the military circles attached to the Veres and Prince Henry were paramount to development of the military arts in England. They were to become advocates of military reform in the late Jacobean and early Caroline periods, recognizing the value of printed books and manuals in their programme of reform. The veterans Conway, Cecil, Vere, and Ogle all served as members of the Council of War created in the 1620s to prepare England for entry into the Thirty Years’ War. In 1623, Conway and Cecil advocated the introduction of the Jacobean government’s printed drill manual, Instructions for Musters and Armes, as one of the ways of improving the trained bands and standardizing drill across the country. Also, at the urging of these men, James, and then Charles, took steps to form the “Exact” or “Perfect” militia. Their efforts, as well as those of other Low Countries veterans to “spell out” military practice in early seventeenth century England, was, as David Eltis has reminded us, an important difference between late Elizabethan and early Stuart military literature.
39 W. Rye, State Papers Relating to Musters, Beacons, Shipmoney, &c. in Norfolk (Norwich: Goose and Son, 1907), 9. 40 See Boyton, Elizabethan Militia, 247 and Rye, State Papers Relating to Musters, 16. The letter from the Privy Council, dated January 14, 1625/26, specified that the experienced soldiers were to be sent from the Low Countries hither, to be distributed into the several counties, there to teach the captains, lieutenants, ensigns, and other officers and leaders of files in each company the true use of arms and order of soldiers. Report on the Manuscripts of the Duke of Buccleuch & Queensberry, vol. III (Historical Manuscripts Commission, London: HMSO, 1926), 445.
“companions
of martiall noblenesse”
93
Early Stuart Military Circles: The Veres Against the backdrop of the Dutch Revolt and onset of war with Spain and France in 1620s, the early Stuart period witnessed the continuation of the military patronage system that had provided the command hierarchy for contingents serving abroad in the late Elizabethan period. Many of the men who had gotten their first taste of battle in the Low Countries remained in the service of the States General after the death of Elizabeth. The most prominent English military circle was established by Francis Vere, who became the first commoner to command an English army [fig. 2]. Vere’s social status, however, did not lessen his ability to obtain or to dispense patronage. A member of a cadet branch of the de Vere family, the earls of Oxford, Francis Vere rose up through the ranks on the basis of his professionalism, though he too was to benefit from the patronage system, as would his brother Horace, who also had a long and distinguished career in the Netherlands. Francis’s military career spanned the last two decades of Elizabeth’s reign, much of that, Naunton tells us, living “almost perpetually in the camp” in the Low Countries before it concluded with the resignation of his command in 1604.41 Francis Vere received his military education, and a healthy dose of Protestant religious instruction, from William Browne, a puritan and a Low Countries veteran.42 According to the Veres’ biographer, C.R. Markham, little is known of Francis’s education and there is no record that he attended university. Tracy Borman points out that the lineage of the de Vere family, with its long history of military service and Francis’s training under Browne, steered him towards a career as a soldier.43 His education would come in the wars. At the age of eighteen Vere travelled to Paris before setting off for Poland in the company of Captain Francis Allen, where he served for a time in the Polish wars in the early 1580s.44 At the age of twenty-five Vere could be counted among those serving with Leicester in the Netherlands where he first became acquainted with the eminent soldiers discussed in the
Naunton, Fragmenta regalia, 41. C.R. Markham, The Fighting Veres. Lives of Sir Francis Vere . . . and of Sir Horace Vere (Boston: Houghton, Mifflin and Co., 1888), 25. 43 T. Borman, “Sir Francis Vere in the Netherlands, 1589–1603” (PhD. diss., University of Hull, 1997), 106. 44 Ibid., 26. 41 42
94
chapter two
last chapter. While in Netherlands, Vere served alongside Roger Williams at the defence of Sluys, with Thomas Morgan and John Norris at Bergen-op-Zoom, and later with Essex and Ralegh at the Azores and Cadiz. Nevertheless, he might not have obtained the rank of sergeant-major general without the backing of Peregrine Bertie, 1