Advances in
THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR VOLUME 26
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR ...
20 downloads
1319 Views
26MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR VOLUME 26
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Advances in
THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR Edited by
PETERJ. B. SLATER School of Biological and Medical Sciences University of St. Andrews Fife, United Kingdom
JAY S. ROSENBLATT Institute of Animal Behavior Rutgers University Newark, New Jersey
CHARLES T. SNOWDON Department of Psychology University of Wisconsin-Madison Madison. Wisconsin
MANFRED MILINSKI Zoologisches Institwt Abteilung Verhaltensokologie Universitat Bern Hinterkappelen, Switzerland
VOLUME 26
ACADEMIC PRESS San Diego London Boston New York Sydney Tokyo Toronto
/
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
@
Copyright 0 1997 by ACADEMIC PRESS All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the Publisher. The appearance of the code at the bottom of the first page of a chapter in this book indicates the Publisher’s consent that copies of the chapter may be made for personal or internal use of specific clients. This consent is given on the condition, however, that the copier pay the stated per copy fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers. Massachusetts 0 1923). for copying beyond that permitted by Sections 107 or 108 of the U.S. Copyright Law. This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying, such as copying for general distribution, for advertising or promotional purposes, for creating new collective works, or for resale. Copy fees for pre-1997 chapters are as shown on the title pages, if no fee code appears on the title page, the copy fee is the same as for current chapters. 0065-3454f97 $25.00
Academic Press a division of Harcourt Brace & Company 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, California 92101-4495, USA http://www.apnet.com
Academic Press Limited 24-28 Oval Road, London NWI 7DX, UK http://www.hbuk.co.uk/ap/ International Standard Book Number: 0- 12-004526-5 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA 97 9 8 9 9 00 01 0 2 Q W 9 8 7 6
5
4
3 2 I
Contents
Contributors . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Preface. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
ix xi
Sexual Selection in Seaweed Flies
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRE s. GILBURN I. 11. 111. IV.
V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. X.
Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . General Biology. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Population Genetics. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Mating Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Sexual Selection. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Variation in Female Mating Behavior. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . The Preferred Trait: Male Size. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Evolution of Female Mate Preferences. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Discussion ...................................... Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1 3 6 7 12 19 25 32 44 48 49
Vocal Learning in Mammals VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER I. 11. 111. IV. V. VI.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Evidence for Vocal Learning ....................... Survey . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Functional Significance and Origin . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
59 61 63 75 85 90 91
Behavioral Ecology and Conservation Biology of Primates and Other Animals KAREN B. STRIER
I. Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Comparative Paradigms. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V
101 103
vi
CONTENTS
I11. Genetics and Ecology ............................. IV. Methodological Bridges to Disciplinary Convergence . . . . V. Summary ....................................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
126 137 143 145
How to Avoid Seven Deadly Sins in the Study of Behavior MANFRED MILINSKI I . Unjustified Conclusions from Observational Data . . . . . . . I1. Data Are Not Independent: “Pseudoreplication” . . . . . . . I11. Treatments Are Confounded by Time and Sequence Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. No Efforts to Avoid Observer Bias . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Potential Artifacts When Animals Are Not Accustomed to Experimental Procedures ........................ VI . Unsuitable Controls . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . “Proving” the Null Hypothesis with Small Samples . . . . . . VIII . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
160 165 168 169 174 175 177 178 179 179
Sexually Dimorphic Dispersal in Mammals: Patterns. Causes. and Consequences LAURA SMALE. SCOTT NUNES. AND KAY E . HOLEKAMP I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Biology and Study Methods for Spotted Hyenas and Belding’s Ground Squirrels . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Sex Differences in Mammalian Dispersal: Patterns and Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Sex Differences in the Proximal Causes of Natal Dispersal . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Consequences of Sex Differences in Dispersal Behavior . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Directions for Future Research . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
181 184 191 208 228 234 237 239
vii
CONTENTS
Infantile Amnesia: Using Animal Models to Understand Forgetting H. MOORE ARNOLD AND NORMAN E. SPEAR 1. Orientation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11. 111. IV. V. VI. VII.
252 254 257 263 267 275 278 279
Ontogeny of Non-Associative Memory. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ontogeny of Short-Term Retention . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Ontogeny of Long-Term Retention: Infantile Amnesia. . . Perspectives on Infantile Amnesia . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Infantile Amnesia as an “Ontogenetic Adaptation” . . . . . Summary and Comment ........................... References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
Regulation of Age Polyethism in Bees and Wasps by Juvenile Hormone SUSAN E. FAHRBACH I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
285
11. Age Polyethism and Juvenile Hormone in the European
Honey Bee, Apis mellifera. .........................
288
111. Effects of Experimental Treatment with Juvenile
IV.
V.
VI. VII. VIII.
Hormone, Mimics, and Analogs on Behavioral Maturation in the Honey B e e . . ..................... Correlational Data Indicating Juvenile Hormone Titers Increase during Behavioral Maturation and Are At Their Highest in Foraging Bees .......................... Colony Manipulations that Induce Altered Juvenile Hormone Titers and Altered Behavior; Seasonal Changes in Juvenile Hormone Titers and Behavior.. . . . . . . . . . . . Brain Changes Correlated with Behavioral Maturation in the Honey Bee: A Proposed Mechanism for Juvenile Hormone Action on Age Polyethism.. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Comparative Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions and Significance. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
293 297 300 301 306 309 310
Acoustic Signals and Speciation: The Roles of Natural and Sexual Selection in the Evolution of Cryptic Species GARETH JONES
I. Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
317
11. A Case Study: Britain’s Most Common Bat is Two
Species . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
320
viii
CONTENTS
111. Acoustic Resouce Partitioning by Echolocation . . . . . . . . . IV . Cryptic Speices of Echolocating Bats . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . Acoustic Signals and Cryptic Species in Nonecholocating Animals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Speciation in Cryptic Species That Use Acoustic Signals . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Cryptic Species. Genetic Divergence. and Hidden Biodiversity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
330 335 337 339 344 346 348
Understanding the Complex Song of the European Starling: An Integrated Ethological Approach MARCEL EENS
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. The Study Species and Its Song ..................... 111. Song Learning . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV . Relating Song Behavior to the Underlying Neutral Substrate . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . Functions of Song . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Functions and Evolution of the Song Repertoire . . . . . . . . VII. Conclusions and Future Directions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
355 357 362 380 391 406 417 422 423
Representation of Quantities by Apes SARAH T. BOYSEN
I. Representation of Quantities by Apes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Symbolic Facilitation of Quantity Judgments . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Index
...........................................
435 447 458 460
463
Contributors
Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
H. MOORE ARNOLD (251), Department of Psychology, Duke University, Durham. North Carolina 27706 SARAH T. BOYSEN (439, Comparative Cognition Project, Department of Psychology, Ohio State University, Columbus, Ohio 43210 THOMAS H. DAY (l),Genetics Department, Queens Medical Centre, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NH7 2UH, United Kingdom MARCEL EENS (355). Department of Biology, University of Antwerp, UIA, B2610 Wilrijk, Belgium SUSAN E. FAHRBACH (285), Department of Entomology, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, Urbana, Illinois 61801 ANDRE S. GILBURN (l), Genetics Department, Queens Medical Centre, University of Nottingham, Nottingham NH7 2UH, United Kingdom KAY E. HOLEKAMP (181), Department of Zoology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan 48824 VINCENT M. JANIK (59), School of Biological and Medical Sciences, University of St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Fife, KY16 9TS, United Kingdom GARETH JONES (317), School of Biological Sciences, University of Bristol, Bristol BS8 I UG, United Kingdom MANFRED MILINSKI (159), Abteilung Verhaltensokologie, Zoologisches Institut, Universitat Bern, CH-3032 HinterKappelen, Switzerland SCOTT NUNES (181), Department of Zoology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan 48824 PETER J. B. SLATER (59), School of Biological and Medical Sciences, University of St. Andrews, St. Andrews, Fife, KY16 9TS, United Kingdom LAURA SMALE (181), Department of Psychology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, Michigan 48824 ix
X
CONTRIBUTORS
NORMAN E. SPEAR (251), Centerfor Developmental Psychobiology, Department of Psychology, Binghamton University, Binghamton, New York 13902 KAREN B. STRIER (101),Department ofAnthropology, University of WisconsonMadison, Madison, Wisconsin 53706
Preface
The aim of the Advances in the Study of Behavior series remains as it has been since the series began: to serve the increasing number of scientists who are engaged in the study of animal behavior by presenting their theoretical ideas and research to their colleagues and to those in neighboring fields. We hope that the series will continue its “contribution to the development of cooperation and communication among scientists in our field,” as its intended role was phrased in the Preface to the first volume in 1965. Since that time the traditional areas of animal behavior research have achieved new vigor by the links they have formed with related fields and by the closer relationship that now exists between those studying animal and human subjects. The range of scientists studying behavior today is wider than ever before: from ecologists and evolutionary biologists to geneticists, endocrinologists, pharmacologists, neurobiologists, and developmental psychobiologists, not forgetting the ethologists and comparative psychologists for whom the subject is the prime domain. It is our intention not to focus narrowly on one or a few of these fields but to publish articles covering a broad spectrum of the best behavioral work. The skills and concepts of scientists in such diverse fields necessarily differ, making the task of developing cooperation and communication among them a difficult one. However, it is a task of great importance, and one to which the editors and publisher of Advances in the Study of Behavior are committed. We will continue to provide the means to this end by publishing critical reviews, inviting extended presentations of significant research programs, encouraging the writing of theoretical syntheses and reformulations of persistent problems, and highlighting especially penetrating research that introduces important new concepts. The wide range of topics dealt with in the present volume illustrates these aims well, with a good mixture of psychological and biological approaches, as well as laboratory and field studies. In this volume several chapters are on mammals, two are on insects, and one is on birds. In addition, we have something of a departure with one chapter dealing with problems of experimental design in the study of behavior. What they all have in common is that each tackles an important topic and provides insights of wide significance to those interested in the study of behavior. Volume 25 had as a special topic “Parental Care.” It is planned that Volume 27 will focus on the subject of “Stress and Behavior.” By contrast, the present volume features wide-ranging topics in line with the norm for the series. It is our intention to continue the series with this mixture of volumes of eclectic interest and ones focusing on particular themes that appear timely to us. xi
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR, VOL. 26
Sexual Selection in Seaweed Flies THOMAS H. DAYAND ANDRBS. GILBURN GENETICS DEPARTMENT UNIVERSITY OF NOTTINGHAM QUEENS MEDICAL CENTRE NO’ITINGHAM, UNITED KINGDOM
I. INTRODUCTION Darwin is credited with the idea that organisms can change in response to both natural selection, mediated by differences in survival, and sexual selection involving differential reproduction (Darwin, 1859,1871). He proposed the existence of sexual selection because in many species the males possess characters, such as the antlers of deer and the peacock’s tail, that seem to be maladaptive in terms of survival. Such structures are supposed to confer an advantage in reproduction either by increasing a male’s ability to compete for mates, or by making males more attractive to females. These ideas were almost totally ignored for about sixty years, possibly because in the prudish atmosphere of Victorian England, sex was not a subject that could be openly discussed. However, even the scientific community was unconvinced by Darwin’s suggestion that it is a sense of esthetics that renders females reluctant to mate. In the century following the publication of The Descent of Man, sexual selection was mainly considered in the context of speciation. For example, Mayr thought that “many phenomena that have been recorded as furthering intra-specific sexual selection, are actually specific recognition marks” (Mayr, 1963). The contributions of Fisher (1930), which are to this day being actively interpreted, Bateman (1948), Maynard-Smith (1958), and O’Donald (1962) are among the few studies carried out during this period. It was Trivers (1972) who offered the first explanation of why females are usually the more choosy sex; he suggested that the greater investment in terms of energy and parental care would lead females to be more reluctant to mate, and to be discriminating in their choice of mates. The current renaissance of interest in sexual selection occurred in the early 1980s and developed in two largely discrete directions of research. 1
Copyright Q 1997 by Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. 0065-3454/Y7525.00
2
THOMAS H. DAY AND
ANDRB s. GILBURN
The first was primarily concerned with understanding the evolution of exaggerated male characters, and of the female preferences that were thought to be involved in generating them. This approach relied heavily on theoretical models to explore possible mechanisms. The models of Lande, Kirkpatrick, Arnold, Barton, Turelli, Pomiankowski, and many others have been reviewed by Anderson (1994). The second area of research involved ethologists and experimental biologists who were trying to understand mating behavior in a particular species, or group of species. While there were many who used both approaches, it is generally true that in the 1980s the theoreticians rarely modeled actual experimental systems, and few experiments were designed to test the assumptions and predictions of models. At that time the prospects of the two groups interacting were far from bright. It seemed the advice of Grafen was being heeded: To theoreticians I would say: resist the temptation to make your models more realistic. Your function now is to provide the material which will determine what field workers will find interesting in five years time and beyond. Particular species are in themselves boring and deserve modelling only to make general points. To field workers I would say: whatever else you do, don’t go out and measure a parameter in somebody else’s model. Your role is not to be a theoretician’s technician. A good field worker is nobody’s poodle (Grafen, 1987, pp. 231-232).
Fortunately, the 1990s have seen increasing dialogue between experimenters and theoreticians, and, in consequence, our understanding of sexual selection has deepened. This review is unashamedly from the experimentalists’ camp (if, indeed, it still exists), and concerns a single species. The Nottingham group has been studying seaweed flies for over 20 years and has taken a broad approach, being interested in their genetics, ecology, mating behavior, and evolution. Because many results have remained in the form of unpublished theses, or have been published in ecological or genetic journals, the seaweed fly story is not familiar to many behavioral scientists. The study of genetics has benefited immensely from there being several species that are amenable to experimental analysis (including Escherichia coli, Drosophila melanogaster, Caenorhabditis elegans, and Mus domesticus). No single species has contributed in such a dominant way to our understanding of behavior, or of ecology. The wide diversity of species studied have suggested that there are fewer fundamental principles in these disciplines, and that arguably every species is potentially informative. Nevertheless, some species provide greater scope for experimental analysis than do others, and in our view Coelopa frigidu is among them. Seaweed flies do, of course, have limitations, but there are four qualities that make them particularly attractive material for the study of mating behavior:
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
3
1. The mating process is straightforward and easily studied under controlled laboratory conditions.
2. In the wild they occupy a well-defined habitat and natural populations are accessible to study. 3. They can be cultured in the laboratory and have a rapid life cycle. Controlled crosses can be performed so allowing genetic analysis. 4. A large proportion of their genome is contained within polymorphic chromosomal inversions. This means there are very large gene complexes each of which has a readily detectable effect on the phenotype, yet is inherited in a monogenic, rather than polygenic, fashion. Here we shall first review the general biology, ecology, and genetics of seaweed flies before focusing on their mating behavior. Although we are still a long way from identifying the genes determining mating behavior, it is clear that individuals do carry alternative alleles at the relevant loci. It is also evident that mating behavior, and in particular female choice, is subject to multiple selective forces-sexual selection is a pluralistic process. Finally, the combination of laboratory and field work has given us the impression that the mate preferences seen in natural populations are fluid in the sense that gene frequencies are responsive to various ecological factors. 11. GENERAL BIOLOGY
Seaweed flies constitute a small group of Acalypterate Dipterans; worldwide there are about 30 species of Coelopidae, all of them found associated solely with piles of decomposing seaweed beached above high-water mark (Egglishaw, 1960;Dobson, 1974a;McAlpine, 1991). Because of their dependence on marine algae (Dobson, 1976) they are found only on rocky coasts that support sufficient stands of large, brown algae to generate fairly deep deposits on the shore. The distributions of natural populations of Coelopa frigida and C. pilipes, which are restricted to coasts around the North Atlantic, are shown in Fig. 1. Coelopa frigida is aptly named; it is found in Iceland, the Faroes, northern Norway, and Spitzbergen. For much of its rangc in Europe it coexists with C. pilipes (Dobson, 1973,1974b);the larvae of the two species compete (Leggett, 1993; Wilcockson, Day, Phillips, and Arthur, 1996), and adults coexist and even mount animals of the “wrong” species (Leggett, 1993). Whether they can properly be described as sibling species is not clear, but copulation between the two has never been observed, and no evidence for interspecific hybridization has been obtained. However, there is no doubt that within the species C. frigida, adults from
4
THOMAS H. DAY A N D ANDRB S. GILBURN
FIG.1. The distribution of seaweed flies in Northern Europe. The left side of each circle indicates the presence or absence of C. frigida, the right side C. pilipes. Redrawn from Phillips er al. (1995).
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
5
north American, Icelandic, British, and Swedish populations can mate and produce viable offspring in the laboratory. Two physical factors, winds and tides, profoundly influence the biology of seaweed flies. The primary effect is on the availability of their food (predominantly species of Laminaria and Fucus), but it is clear that certain aspects of mating behavior also correlate with tidal variation. The principal agent that detaches large brown algae from their rocky substrate are storms. Once the seaweed is detached, onshore winds can deposit it on the shore and occasionally remove it from above the high-water line. The more regular removal and deposition of stranded weed is a consequence of the tidal movement of seawater, particularly the spring tides that occur once each month. The presence or absence of tides results in there being two extreme types of habitat in which seaweed flies live. In the Kattegat (between Denmark and Sweden) and in the Baltic Sea, occasional storms deposit weed, but it remains beached for long periods of time because of the almost complete absence of tidal movement. In consequence, populations of seaweed flies are effectively living in continuous culture, often with several batches of food present in varying stages of decomposition. Populations living in the Channel Islands in the Gulf of St. Malo (off the northwestern coast of France) experience a distinctly different regime of food availability. The very high tidal fluctuation-among the highest in the world-results in seaweed rarely being present for more than one lunar cycle. This means that during the winter when storms commonly occur, seaweed is regularly replaced, but during the calmer summers, beaches may be almost completely clear of weed. The extreme pattern of food availability to which Baltic flies are exposed results in very stable populations, whereas Channel Island populations are subject to greater fluctuations; when food is abundant, population numbers may reach 109-10'0 animals, whereas at other times there can be no food at all, and the populations are considerably smaller (Butlin, Collins, and Day, 1984). The habitats in the Baltic Sea and the Channel Islands are extremes. Around northern Europe and the east coast of the United States and Canada there is a complete range of variation in tidal movement, and different populations of Coelopa experience varying levels of stability of their food source, and in consequence, of their population sizes. We believe that the observed patterns of mating are a consequence of exposure for countless generations to these different conditions. The life cycle of seaweed flies is typical of Dipterans. Adult C. frigid0 mate deep in the seaweed deposit usually near hotspots of active microbial decomposition. Eggs are laid in clutches of 40-100, which hatch and pass through three larval instars. The larvae ingest the decomposing slime and are nourished by the diverse microbial flora, as well as by the contents of
6
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDR!~ s. GILBURN
ruptured algal cells that release high concentrations of the sugar mannitol (Cullen, Young, and Day, 1987).The survival of larvae depends on colonization of the gut by microbial flora, the presence of fairly high concentrations of NaCl (at least 6L), and on the presence of some constituent-possibly a secondary metabolite-of algal cells (Cullen el ul., 1987). These nutritional requirements account for the distribution of C. frigidu around the North Atlantic. Pupation occurs in the drier parts of the deposit, and the eclosing adults become sexually mature after about 18 hours. The complete life cycle takes 1-6 weeks and is extremely temperature dependent; at 26°C under controlled laboratory conditions a complete generation takes roughly 10 days. 111. POPULATION GENETICS
The amount of genetic variation in C. frigidu is typical of Diptera and of invertebrates in general; approximately one third of enzyme-determining loci are polymorphic (Collins, 1978). However, a rather more novel feature of C. frigidu is that roughly one quarter of its genome is contained within polymorphic chromosomal inversions (Philip, 1958,1966).Eight such inversion systems have been described on the five pairs of chromosomes, but one of them, the ap system on chromosome I, is extremely large and includes about 10%of all polytene bands in the genome (Aziz, 1975; Day, Dobson, Hillier, Parkin, and Clarke, 1982). Although this inversion is a complex of three overlapping inversions, natural populations segregate for only two forms-the a and p sequences. The absence of intermediates must be a consequence of the seriously unbalanced nature of crossover products. The significance of the ap inversion system is that thousands of loci cosegregate as a single Mendelian entity. This means the diverse and profound effects that the inversion has on the biology and behavior of this fly are inherited in a straightforward fashion. All natural populations sampled, however isolated, are polymorphic for the inversion; individuals are either aa or pp homokaryotypes, or are ap heterokaryotypes (Butlin, Collins, Skevington, and Day, 1982a; Day, Dawe, Dobson, and Hillier, 1983). The inversion appears to be of considerable antiquity; dating the original chromosomal mutations by measuring nucleotide sequence divergence has not been attempted. The ap inversion is associated with differences in the rate of development from egg to adult, with pps being the fastest, am the slowest, and aps intermediate (Day, Dobson, Hillier, Parkin, and Clarke, 1980). Whether this is a result of differential rates of larval feeding or of utilization of nutrients is unknown, but the consequence is that aa adults are significantly
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
7
larger than pp individuals, again with aps being intermediate. The genotypes differ in another important respect. Under controlled laboratory conditions there are large differences in egg-to-adult survival, with aps surviving best and aas exhibiting the lowest survival (Butlin et al., 1984; Butlin and Day, 1985a). Furthermore, this heterokaryotypic advantage is strongly density dependent, That such heterosis also occurs in natural populations can be inferred from the nearly ubiquitous heterokaryotypic excess over Hardy-Weinberg expectations (Butlin et al., 1982a; Day et al., 1983; Butlin and Day, 1989), and from the positive relationship that exists between heterokaryotypic excess and larval density (Butlin, 1983; Phillips, Leggett, Wilcockson, Day, and Arthur, 1995). Heterosis is a routine feature of chromosomal inversion polymorphisms (Dubinin and Tiniakov, 1946; Dobzhansky, 1947; Birch, 1955; da Cunha, 1955; Lewontin and White, 1960; Budnik, Brncic, and Koref-Santibanez, 1971; Anderson, Dobzhansky, Pavlovsky, Powell, and Yardley, 1975). Its relevance in the context of sexual selection is that there exist very substantial differences in fitness between individuals, and we might expect nonrandom mating behavior to have evolved that results in the production of offspring of the fittest genotypes. However, it should be noted that heterotic systems do not involve directional selection on additive genetic effects, but rather stabilizing selection and overdominance. In nongenetic parlance, the quality of a male’s genes depends on the genes carried by the interested female-it is complementarity of sperm and eggs, rather than absolute quality, that is important. inversion system in C. Much of this review is concerned with the frigida. In practice the karyotypes of individual animals have not been determined from preparations of salivary gland polytene chromosomes. It has proved much faster and more reliable to type animals on the basis of their genotype at the alcohol dehydrogenase locus (Adh).The two common alleles at the Adh locus are in complete linkage disequilibrium with the ap inversion system such that the Adh-B allele is always associated with the a sequence and Adh-D with the p sequence (Day et al., 1982). With the technique of starch gel electrophoresis a third allele, Adh-C, common in some populations, cannot be used to infer karyotypes unambiguously, since it is associated with both a and p inversions. The Adh-A, -E, and -F alleles are extremely rare in natural populations and have been routinely excluded from analyses. IV. MATINGBEHAVIOR
There have been countless descriptions of weird and elaborate courtship behaviors in animals. These have provoked speculation concerning the
8
THOMAS H. DAY AND
ANDRB s. GILBURN
adaptive significance of courtship that may involve mate attraction, species recognition, the induction of receptivity, and assessment of mate quality. However, some species such as the dung fly, Scutophugu stercoruriu (Parker, 1970a), and the house fly, Muscu domesticu (Tobin and Stoffolano, 1973), copulate with no obvious behavioral preliminaries. At least to human senses, courtship behavior in seaweed flies is particularly unelaborate (Thompson, 1951). The first impression is that the flies bump into each other, mount, and then mate. However, further study has shown that the process naturally terminates at various stages, and that there is abundant scope for mate recognition and choice. It has been routine practice in studies of the mating behavior of seaweed flies to allow a minimum of 18 hours recovery period following anesthesia with carbon dioxide. Ether is never used, particularly since etherization of Drosophilu melunogusfer has been shown to have lasting effects on their behavior (Joachim and Curtsinger, 1990). Consider first by what mechanism males and females encounter each other. Rager (1985) and Soffe (1986) conducted maze tests in which animals were given the choice of proceeding along one of two alternative routes through which flowed a countercurrent of air that had passed over either males or females. Neither males nor females showed any attraction to the opposite sex. However, both sexes were strongly attracted to decomposing seaweed. In particular, they moved against an air current that had passed M solution of 3,5 M solution of D-mannitol, or a through a dibromo, 4 hydroxybenzoic acid, both of which are present in brown algae (Rashid and Prakash, 1972). The implication is that, like many phytophagous insects (see Fraenkel, 1969;Berenbaum, 1990),both sexes are attracted to the larval food source. Mating behavior has been studied by observing and video-recording animals in small arenas and then analyzing the behavioral components during slow playback of the tapes (Day, Foster, and Engelhard, 1989). These data must obviously be interpreted with caution because mating normally takes place deep within seaweed deposits where conditions must differ in many respects. The animals move haphazardly until they are within about 2 cm of each other. The male then moves toward the other animal and mounts. If the male has mounted another male, he invariably dismounts immediately. However, the probability of a female being mounted is significantly higher than a male, suggesting that males do exercise some recognition at a distance. Furthermore, a large female is more likely to be mounted than a small one. By whatever sensory modality such recognition is mediated (perhaps vision or olfaction), it seems probable that some form of passive male choice is occurring; larger females would be more readily sensed than small ones. Females have never been seen to mount another animal.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
9
Within a few seconds of a female being mounted she may curl her abdomen downward making it virtually impossible for the male to engage genitalia (Fig. 2). In addition, the female may kick with her metathoracic legs, flick her wings, and with particularly persistent males, roll completely over. This series of movements has been interpreted as the female rejection response (Day et al., 1989), and it almost invariably results in the male being unable to copulate. After varying lengths of time he usually dismounts. Very shortly after mounting, but prior to any female rejection response, the male moves forward on top of the female so that his prothoracic legs are located in the vicinity of the female’s antennae. The legs are moved up and down several times in such a way that it is probable that his sex combs-serrated, spoon-shaped structures on the inner side of the first metatarsi-rub against the female’s antennae. This action provides the opportunity for stimulatory exchange between the two animals, but its precise function has yet to be determined. Either animal could be gaining information about the other upon which the acceptance/rejection decision is based. Alternatively, the female may be informed that she is mounted by a potential mate rather than being in contact with a piece of seaweed;
FIG.2. The female rejection response in C. frigidu. The female is curling her abdomen away from the mounted male. Reproduced, with permission, from Foster (1989).
10
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRB S. GILBURN
these animals inhabit small crevices in compressed deposits of seaweed. Experiments involving masking of the female aristae (the terminal part of the antennae) or of the males’ sex combs indicate that females are normally in the rejection mode, and require positive stimulation to accept a male (Foster, 1989; Day et al., 1989). Whether such stimulation is involved in habitat discrimination, species recognition, or the quality assessment of conspecifics is not known. If the female does not reject, the male may nevertheless dismount. The circumstances of such dismounting have been studied (see later discussion), and it is clear that males exercise active mate choice. In the absence of both female and male rejection, the genitalia engage and they remain in copula for 30 s to about 30 min. In spite of this very variable duration of copulation, the number of eggs fertilized is not associated with copulation duration. J. J. Hewitt (unpublished results) allowed pairs a single copulation and then counted the number of fertile eggs subsequently laid. He found a bimodal distribution. For about 93% of males from a population at St. Mary’s Island, the mean number was 89 (SE = 4.6), but the remaining males fertilized distinctly fewer eggs (mean = 23, SE = 4.8). Both males and females mate repeatedly in quick succession (Pitafi, Simpson, Stephen, and Day, 1990; Pitafi, Hewitt, Gilbert, and Day, 1994; Pitafi, 1991). The mating behavior of individual males when given single females in quick succession was observed over a 90-min period. During these short bouts of mating, males copulated with a mean of 17 different females (range 9-35). Overnight each male was allowed access to 10 females, which in no case were all fertilized. This regime of observed pairings during the daytime and an excess of females available overnight was continued until the male died. Pitafi calculated that during the male’s lifetime, the mean number of females fertilized by single males was 63 (range 11108). The total number of fertilized eggs laid by each female was also counted, and from this the mean lifetime fecundity of males, as measured by the number of eggs fertilized, was estimated to be 2270 (range 13832987). Those males that apparently transferred fewer sperm at fertilization inseminated significantly more females, but exhibited similar lifetime fecundities. These results suggest there may be alternative insemination strategies among males. The majority of wild-caught males appear to transfer sufficient sperm to fertilize an average clutch of eggs, but probably not many more. About 5 1 0 % of males seem to transfer distinctly fewer sperm, but to many more females. One possible advantage of the latter strategy is that larvae from multipaternal clutches experience weaker competition. J. J. Hewitt tested this possibility by measuring the survival of mono- and multipaternal clutches, but failed to find any difference (unpublished results).
11
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
Whether there are genuinely alternative strategies, and if so, the nature of the benefits, are clearly questions that deserve further study. Returning to the mating behavior of Coelopu, the probability of female rejection (at least in an inbred laboratory strain) dramatically changes following a prolonged mount; 80% of mounts immediately prior to a prolonged mount ended in rejection, whereas only 20%of males were rejected if the female had accepted the previous male (Fig. 3). Copulation not only changes mating receptivity but various other aspects of behavior. The female’s rate of feeding increases, as does the rate of egg production. Virgin females oviposit a mean total of 340 ( S E = 34) eggs (obviously unfertilized), whereas females with males continuously available have a mean lifetime fecundity of 560 eggs ( S E = 49). Mated females produce significantly more clutches. These changes cannot be attributed to the transfer of substantial resources from the male (see later discussion), and so must be a consequence either of trace quantities of some substance in the seminal fluid (see Eberhard and Cordero, 1995), or of the act of copulation itself. Other species in which lifetime fecundities have been determined for both sexes have yielded similar estimates. The once commonly held belief that males have substantially greater fecundity than females-certainly
I
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Sequence of copulations FIG. 3. Change in the rejection rate of females with increasing sexual experience. The data are based on video recordings of 68 mating trials involving two males and two females. Only the first 10 copulations (prolonged mounts) are considered. The solid bars refer to the outcome of mounts immediately preceding the lst, 2nd. 3rd. etc. copulation. The shaded bars refer to mounts immediately following copulations. Data from Pitafi (1991).
12
THOMAS H. DAY AND A N D R 6 S. GILBURN
much more than a fourfold difference-is not supported by these data. There is no doubt that in C.frigidu, as in other species (Lefevre and Jonsson, 1962; Jones, 1973; Nadel and Luck, 1985; Simmons, 1990), males can and do become exhausted of effective sperm. Dewsbury (1982) was evidently correct in pointing out that parental investment in gametes is a misleading way of comparing the reproductive potential of males and females. There is a final point concerning female fecundity. Lifetime fecundities in excess of 500 eggs were measured using a strain that had been maintained in laboratory culture for several years. Butlin and Day (1985b) obtained estimates of about 400 eggs per female for two strains that had been collected less than two years previously. In contrast, the lifetime fecundity of females recently collected from natural populations rarely exceed 200 (Shuker, unpublished results). These data suggest that the regime of laboratory culture imposes directional selection for greater female fecundity, and that substantial additive genetic variance may exist in wild populations for this character. If this is true, it would be worthwhile to identify the nature of trade-offs maintaining such variation in a character that is obviously an important component of fitness. V. SEXUAL SELECTION
For many years students of sexual selection have valued Huxley’s distinction between “intrasexual” selection, usually referring to competition between males, and “intersexual” selection, usually mediated by female mate preferences (Huxley, 1938a,b). In his excellent review, Anderson (1994) pointed out that the competition for mates is similar to competition for any other type of resource, and that the distinctions made by ecologists should be applied in the study of sexual selection. Since sexual selection is now widely recognized as involving many diverse yet interacting processes, it is useful to categorize these processes. We shall follow Anderson’s categorization and consider in turn the effects of contests, scrambles, endurance rivalry, sperm competition, and finally, and in some detail, mate choice. A. CONTESTS
Perhaps the archetypal contest is the fighting between males for access to, and control of, a harem of females such as that occurring in red deer, Cervus elephus (Clutton-Brock et ul., 1979), and elephant seals, Miroungu sp. (Deutsch, Haley, and Le Boeuf, 1990). A long-term consequence of such contests is the evolution of heavy weaponry and pronounced sexual dimorphism. However, elements of contest competition exist in species
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
13
with much more modest weaponry. In C.frigidu, interactions between males have not been observed in the absence of females. Nevertheless, video recordings involving one female and several males clearly indicate that contests do take place, but only after a male has mounted a female. A second male may then mount the pair and the outcome is dependent on the relative sizes of the “resident” and “challenging” male (Day et al., 1989). A large male is rarely displaced yet can readily displace a smaller male without necessarily himself remaining mounted on the female. No particular structures are involved in this contest, the outcome of which appears to be determined by general strength and wrestling ability. The role of these contests as a selective force in the field is difficult to assess. On occasions when hundreds or even thousands of adults collect at hotspots in seaweed deposits, it seems probable that mounted males are challenged in this way.
B. ENDURANCE RIVALRY AND SCRAMBLES In some species there is a discrete polymorphism in male morphology and behavior. Male Salmonid fish (Gross, 1982,1984,1985) and the bluegill sunfish, Lepomis mucrochirus (Gross, 1984), either become sexually mature early and remain small, or take longer to develop into larger males. The two types of male stably coexist in populations and neither is consistently advantaged over the other. Similar ESSs, but known to have a genetic basis, have been described in the cricket, Gryllus integer (Cade, 1979), the isopod, Purucerceis sculptu (Shuster and Wade, 1991), and in swordtail fish of the genus Xiphophorus (Ryan and Causey, 1989). Although the idea of alternative mating tactics usually refers to distinctly different morphs, it can readily be applied to continuously variable characters, as has been done in Scutophugu stercoruriu (Parker, 1970a), Centris pallida (Alcock, Jones, and Buchmann, 1977), and in the genus Punorpu (Thornhill, 1981). In each case size is the relevant character. At one extreme of the size distribution, large animals win contests and perhaps are more enduring rivals, to use Andersson’s terminology (Anderson, 1994). At the other extreme, small males win scramble competitions by being more mobile and available to mate earlier. In such a situation there is obviously the potential for the coexistence of types subject to very different selection pressures. This situation may well exist in C. frigidu. act individuals develop slowly and eclose as large adults, whereas @3s develop fast and are small. There are clear mating advantages to being large: not only do large males win contests but they also exhibit significantly greater longevity as adults (Foster, 1989). They are capable of inseminating more females under optimal conditions (Pitafi, 1991), and at times of stress when food is absent or in
14
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRI? S. GILBURN
short supply, they are more likely to survive to father the next generation. The observation that the frequency of the a inversion increases in tidal populations during calm summers is consistent with them being superior endurance rivals (Butlin, 1983; Butlin and Day, 1989). On the other hand, the highest frequencies of small p/3 individuals are seen in Baltic populations in which food is continuously available and in which scramble competition is more likely to be operating. In the laboratory small males appear to have a much higher mount rate than large males (Gilburn, 1992). Further support for the existence of scrambles comes from experiments conducted under relatively natural conditions (Day, Miles, Pilkington, and Butlin, 1987). Larvae were collected (from St. Mary’s Island and Whitburn) in the seaweed in which they were living and allowed to develop through to adulthood in the laboratory. Eclosing adults could mate as and when they wished, and at intervals females were removed and left to lay eggs. The Adh genotypes of the offspring and the mother were determined, and used to infer the genotype of the father. Genotypes of inferred fathers were then compared with the males available to be fathers. A complication was that the genotype frequencies of inferred fathers were modified to take into account multiple paternity and the finite number of offspring typed. The results confirmed that multiple paternity is common and that it increased with age; between the second and eighth day after eclosion started, the proportion of multiply inseminated females increased from 20 to 65%. More surprisingly, a negative relationship was found between male size and reproductive success (rs = -.570, p = -001). Under these conditions small males exhibited greater mating success than large ones. In spite of all the advantages accruing in terms of contest competition and of female choice (see later discussion), small males appeared to be sexually selected. C . SPERM COMPETITION
Sperm competition refers to the contest between gametes from different males. Its power as an evolutionary force is attested by the extraordinarily bizarre behaviors of males that can best be understood in terms of males increasing the chances of their own sperm being successful at fertilization (Parker, 1970b; Smith, 1984; Eberhard, 1985; Birkhead and Moller, 1992). These behaviors include the removal of sperm from previously mated females (see Birkhead and Hunter, 1990), plugging the female’s genital aperture, and spraying the female with “anti-aphrodisiacs” (Gilbert, 1976). The more mundane, and more common, behaviors of mate guarding and repeated inseminations can also be interpreted in terms of sperm competition (Alcock, 1994). Walker (1980) suggested that the mechanics of sperm storage within the female may influence the evolution of mating behavior.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
15
Tubular spermathecae in which sperm are “stacked” and then used in reversed sequence, favor males that mate last; in contrast, spermathecae that allow free mixing of sperm favor large ejaculates and repeated inseminations. In seaweed flies the spermathecae are spherical and sperm enter and exit by the same route (Foster, 1989). The somewhat complex pattern of sperm precedence can be understood in terms of this anatomy. If two males inseminate in quick succession there is sperm mixing and the progeny are of mixed paternity. Furthermore, the paternity is associated with the relative sizes of the males (Butlin, 1983). However, if inseminations are separated by a longer time interval, there is precedence to the sperm from the later mating male (Thompson, 1951; Burnet, 1961; Butlin, 1983). From the females’ viewpoint, every clutch is likely to be of mixed paternity, but subsequent clutches may be sired by a different set of males. Nevertheless, since stored sperm remain viable throughout her life, later clutches can if necessary be fertilized by sperm acquired from the first males to have mated. From the males’ standpoint, there is selection for multiple mating and for ejaculates containing many sperm. There appears to have been a response to the former, but not the latter. There is increasing evidence that postcopulatory sperm competition may result from females exercising choice in their use of sperm from different males. In several insect species, following insemination by both conspecific and heterospecific males, sperm from conspecifics is preferentially used (Hewitt, Mason, and Nichols, 1989; Bella, Butlin, Ferris, and Hewitt, 1992; Howard and Gregory, 1993; Wade, Patterson, Chang, and Johnson, 1994), and there may even be discrimination between different conspecific males (LaMunyon and Eisner, 1993; Ward, 1993; see also Eberhard and Cordero, 1995). There is no evidence that “cryptic” female choice of this kind occurs in seaweed flies. The considerable variance in the duration of copulation may be interpreted as mate guarding. Insemination usually occurs within 60 s (Pitafi, 1991), but some males remain in copula for much longer. Whether long-copulating males gain in terms of sperm competition has not been tested. Although sperm competition usually refers to competition between males, under some circumstances we might expect it to operate within ejaculates. Heterotic systems involving chromosomal inversions provide the ideal opportunity to study intraejaculate competition. Consider, for example, an aa female inseminated by an CXPmale. The zygotes are expected to consist equally of the fittest a$ heterokaryotypes and the least fit aa homokaryotypes. Any mutation that resulted in the eggs being preferentially fertilized by P-carrying sperm would surely be positively selected. J. J. Hewitt (unpublished results) examined the progeny of such crosses
16
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDR6 S. GILBURN
and failed to find any evidence for segregation distortion. This negative result is perhaps surprising, bearing in mind the large fitness differentials involved. However, because very few loci are expressed in sperm cells, the scope for recognition by eggs of genetic differences between sperm may be limited. D. MATECHOICE The traditional view (Darwin, 1871) that females are more choosy and males more aggressive is supported by Andersson’s review (1994) of 232 studies. In 167 of these, evidence was obtained that females exercise mate choice, whereas in only 30 were the males choosing. For many years there has been active debate over the reasons for this difference in behavior. Bateman (1948) argued that the variance in reproductive success was crucial, but parental investment (Trivers, 1972), the operational sex ratio (Emlen and Oring, 1977), and the potential rate of offspring production (Clutton-Brock and Vincent, 1991) have also been suggested as important factors. While this discussion continues, it is becoming clear that, although females very rarely compete with each other for mates, it is not uncommon for males to discriminate between females. In several species of fish, mate choice is seen in both sexes (Downhower and Brown, 1980; Berglund, Rosenqvist, and Svensson, 1986; Foote and Larkin, 1988; C8te and Hunte, 1989), but the phenomenon is certainly not limited to fish (Burley and Moran, 1979; Burley, 1986; Verrell, 1989; Brown, 1990; Houck and Reagan, 1990). In C. frigida both sexes exhibit mate choice. Because male choice presents fewer interpretational problems, it will be considered first. 1.
Male Choice
The probability that a female is mounted depends on her size, as measured by wing length (Day et d., 1989). As already discussed, this could be passive choice by the male in that large females are likely to be more readily perceived than small ones. Once mounted, the male may dismount with no apparent rejection by the female. This is also dependent on female size; dismounting from large females occurs at a significantly lower frequency. It is possible that female size is sensed during the interaction between the sex combs and the female’s antennae. Alternatively, the length of the female’s body could be assessed using some sort of calliper action involving the male’s pro- and metathoracic legs. By whatever mechanism size is measured, it would seem that the male is actively reaching a decision concerning the female’s acceptability. Whether males exhibit weaker discrimination when the variance in female size is small, and whether there
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
17
is any involvement of inversion karyotype of either sex (in addition to its effect on size), has not been determined. Male dismounting is influenced by a second attribute of the female, the distension of the abdomen (Pitafi et al., 1990; Pitafi, 1991). Females that have yet to lay any eggs possess a strongly convex abdomen. As females lay their first, second, and sometimes third and even fourth clutch of eggs, their abdomen becomes progressively more concave until the ventral surface is closely adpressed to the dorsal surface. While controlling for wing length, Pitafi showed that males are more likely to dismount from females with collapsed abdomens than they are from fully gravid ones. Shortly after mounting, the male’s mesothoracic legs grasp the female’s abdomen. These legs are in exactly the right position to assess the extent of ventral distention of the abdomen, perhaps using proprioreceptors located in the leg joints. It is not difficult to guess the evolutionary raison d’etre of the males’ behavior. As in many other insects (see Anderson, 1994), female size is strongly correlated with lifetime fecundity (Butlin and Day, 1985b). However, from the males’ perspective it is the size of the next clutch to be laid that is of more consequence. Clutch size is also correlated with wing length, although the strength of the association declines in successive clutches. In addition, clutch size declines with clutch order. By combining assessments of both body size and abdominal distention, the male could be gaining an accurate estimate of the number of eggs available to be fertilized. It would seem that the force driving the evolution of the males’ mating behavior is a direct advantage to the discriminating male in terms of fertility. Of course, this interpretation assumes that males do not possess an inexhaustible supply of sperm. That males can and do become impotent following repeated inseminations has been demonstrated (Pitafi et al., 1994). 2. Female Choice
When mounted by a male, females respond in one of two ways; they either accept the male and allow copulation to take place, or exhibit a rejection response and attempt to prevent copulation from occurring. One possible reason for the existence of such a rejection response is that females are expressing a mating preference. If this is true, what is the nature of the preference? Are females preferring to mate with males possessing particular characters, and, if so, what is the nature of these characters? The experiments carried out in the 1980s were aimed at identifying the subject of any preference, and yielded confusing and apparently contradictory results. Some of these problems have now been resolved but others are still not understood. At that time there were many examples of female choice in insects being based on the body size of males (McCauley and Wade, 1978; Borgia, 1981; Gwynne, 1982; Johnson, 1982; Burk and Webb,
18
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRE S. GILBURN
1983; Hughes and Hughes, 1985; Simmons, 1986). It has been an empirical observation that sexually selected characters are more exaggerated and more variable in the preferred sex. In a study of the variation in tail length in birds (Alatalo, Hogland, and Lundberg, 1988), sexually selected characters were usually found to have coefficients of phenotypic variation of greater than 6, while those maintained solely through the action of viability selection had coefficients of variation less than 6. In C. frigida mean male size is larger than mean female size in most, though not all, populations (Gilburn and Day, 1994b), and male size is consistently more variable than female size. The coefficient of variation for male size ranged from 8.6 to 19.4 in a study of 30 populations. Body size was from the start a strong candidate to be the preferred character, and indeed the first experiments supported this idea. Behavioral trials were conducted in which a female was given the choice of two males (Butlin, Read, and Day, 1982b: Butlin, 1983). One of the males was distinctly larger than the other; in half the trials the larger male was an aa homokaryotype, and in the others the male was a @. The inversion karyotype of the father (or in some cases, fathers) was determined by typing the offspring. The females significantly preferred the larger male, rather than either of the karyotypes. A similar experiment conducted on a mass mating basis produced the same results; females chose their mate on the basis of size rather than inversion karyotype. Butlin and Day attempted to demonstrate that such a preference also occurred in natural populations (Butlin, 1983; Day and Butlin, 1987). They collected wild adult females from St. Mary’s Island and Whitburn, and allowed them to lay eggs. The Adh genotypes of the progeny were then determined, which, knowing the mother’s genotype, allowed inference of the father’s genotype. The genotype frequencies among inferred fathers were then compared with a sample of wild collected males that were presumably available to be fathers. There was a significant excess of Adh-CD fathers over the number available to be fathers, and a deficiency of BB and BC fathers. Because CD males are relatively small, and BB and BC males relatively large, this seemed to conflict with the results from laboratory experiments. The experiment was repeated on other natural populations and also using mass mating cultures in the laboratory. Foster (1989) found that BD as well as CD males gained higher than expected mating success. He pointed out that this type of experiment in which paternity is inferred from the Adh genotypes of the mother and her offspring is flawed if females multiply mate. Foster calculated the minimum remating rate to be over 20%, and the true rate was probably much higher. (For example, a female that mated with a BB and a D D male would be scored as having mated with a single BD male.) A technique that at first promised to be a
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
19
powerful one to study mating in natural populations could clearly yield misleading results. A very different approach was adopted by Engelhard, Foster, and Day (1989) who used mating arenas to record on videotape the behavior of females in the presence of three males (all animals originating from St. Mary’s Island). They concluded first, that females carrying an Adh-C allele (i.e., BC, CC, or CD) exhibited a higher rate of acceptance than non-Cbearing females, and second, that it was only non-C females that showed any mating preference. The C allele appeared to confer a lack of mate discrimination. However, Gilburn (1992) reanalyzed their results, and also repeated the experiment, and showed that the non-C grouping of animals was heterogeneous. It is the DD females that have the lowest acceptance rate. A further complication in the studies on natural populations and in most of the early laboratory experiments arose from the effects of male-male competition and male mate choice. It was not until so-called “single-mount” experiments were conducted that a clearer picture of female choice was obtained (Gilburn, 1992; Gilburn, Foster, and Day, 1992). Pairs of virgin adults of standardized age were placed together in mating chambers, and the reaction of the female to the very first mount by the male observed and recorded as acceptance or rejection. The Adh genotype and size of the flies were then determined. Multiple regression analysis showed that this initial acceptance-rejection response was based on the male’s size and not at all on his Adh genotype or karyotype. Many subsequent results have confirmed this conclusion. This long saga of early experiments serves as a warning that the various components of mating behavior including female choice, male choice, and male-male competition can interact with each other in complex ways. Multiple mating is a further complication. Indeed, it remains a puzzle why some females exhibit such strong discrimination in their very first copulation, yet thereafter mate almost randomly. This would make sense if they were monogamous, but they are not. In laboratory trials females mate with several males in quick succession, and wild-caught females are often, indeed usually, inseminated by more than one male (Butlin, 1983; Day and Butlin, 1987; Foster, 1989). VI. VARIATION I N FEMALE MATING BEHAVIOR Two distinct aspects of female mating behavior can be distinguished: acceptance rate and preference. The overall acceptance rate of a group of females refers to the proportion of all mount attempts by males that result
20
THOMAS H. DAY AND
ANDRB s. GILBURN
in female acceptance. This completely disregards the sizes of males. The strength of female mating preference has been measured using logistic regression of acceptance rate on male size. The regression coefficient estimates the strength of female mating preference with respect to male size; it indicates how strongly females discriminate between males of differing size. In theory both acceptance rate and preference are characteristic of individual females: under any given circumstances a female exhibits a certain willingness to mate, and there is a distribution of probabilities that she will accept males of varying size. However, in practice they are features of groups of females because single females cannot be tested against a panel of males. The reason for this is that the probability of acceptance appears to change depending on previous mating experience. Both aspects of female behavior have been studied in natural populations widely distributed throughout the range of C. frigida. Measurements of female acceptance rate will be described before considering female preference. A. ACCERANCE RATESIN NATURAL POPULATIONS
Single-mount experiments were performed on adults collected as larvae from natural populations (Gilburn et al., 1992; Gilburn, Foster, and Day, 1993; Gilburn, Crean, and Day, 1996; Gilburn and Day, 1994a). The inversion karyotype of each female was inferred from its Adh genotype, and individuals whose karyotype could not be determined unambiguously were excluded from the analyses. Consistent differences in acceptance rate existed between inversion karyotypes (Table I). In every population the acceptance rates of act females were higher than those of aps (Wilcoxon signed rank test: z = -3.52, p < .001), which in turn were usually higher than those of pps ( z = -2.76, p < .01). These data provide a test of the Foster and Engelhard hypothesis (Foster, 1989; Engelhard el al., 1989) that Adh-C-bearing females have a higher acceptance than non-Cs (Table 11). It was found that, on average, AdhBCfemales have a similar acceptance rate to BDs, and CDs are intermediate between BDs and DDs. However, there is considerable heterogeneity between populations. Because the Adh-C allele (as defined by electrophoretic mobility in starch gels) can be associated with either form of the inversion, these estimates of acceptance rates do not distinguish between C, and C, alleles, and clearly depend on the relative frequencies of the two types in each sample. If it is true that C, is more common than C, (i.e., BCs are usually cups, and CDs often pps), these results are consistent with the acceptance rates being determined by the inversion karyotype, rather than
21
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
TABLE I FEMALE ACCEFTANCE RATESI N SAMPLES FROM NATURAL POPULATIONS" Female inversion karyotype Population Kampinge, Sweden Traslovslage (A), Sweden' Traslovslage (B), Sweden' Lerkil, Sweden Giant's Causeway, N. Ireland Cushendun, N. Ireland Turnley's Port, N. Ireland Portland Bill, England Wicklow, Eire Helgoland, Germany St. Mary's Island, England Shag Harbour. Canada Niarbyl, Isle of Man Petit Port, Channel Islands L'Etacq (A), Channel Islands' L'Etacq (B), Channel Islands'
CYCY
4
PP
Tidal range (m)b
0.63 0.88 0.73 0.56 0.80 0.71 0.61 0.67 0.67 0.79 0.81 0.46 0.39 0.83 0.94 0.72
0.49 0.67 0.59 0.34 0.58 0.50 0.47 0.61 0.53 0.78 0.77 0.45 0.31 0.72 0.82 0.71
0.43 0.58 0.45 0.36 0.65 0.50 0.36 0.61 0.44 0.56 0.61 0.44 0.22 0.70 0.79 0.56
0.1 0.3 0.3 0.3 1.5 1.6 1.6 1.9 2.0 2.7 4.2 4.2 4.8 9.8 9.8 9.8
' Data taken from Gilburn et al., 1992; Gilburn, Foster, and Day, 1993; Gilburn, Crean, and Day, 1996, Gilburn and Day, 1994a; and Crean and Gilburn, unpublished results. "Tidal range was calculated as the difference between mean high water and mean low water at spring tides for the nearest datum point to each sample site. The data were taken from the Admiralty Tide Tables. The populations at Traslovslage and L'Etacq were sampled on two separate occasions.
Adh genotype. They certainly do not lend support to the idea that Adh-Cbearing females exhibit higher acceptance than non-Cs.
B. STRENGTH OF PREFERENCE IN NATURAL POPULATIONS The regression coefficients of acceptance rate on male size estimate the strength of the preference, with positive values indicating a preference for large males and negative values a preference for small males (Table 111). In every population ap and pp females preferred large males, although the preference was not always statistically significant. It is noteworthy that aa females were more variable in their strengths of preference, and in four populations actually preferred small males. Furthermore, their preference is associated with a feature of the habitat from which they were collected, namely tidal range. This association was discussed by Gilburn and Day (1994a) and is confirmed by the larger data set now available. The prefer-
22
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDR6 S. GILBURN
TABLE I1 THEACCEFTANCE RATESOF FEMALES CATEGORIZED BY ADHGENOTYPE" Adh genotype
Population
BE
EC
ED
CD
DD
Helgoland, Germany Petit Port, Channel Islands L'Etacq (A), Channel Islands L'Etacq (B), Channel Islands Portland Bill, England St. Mary's Island, England Niarbyl, Isle of Man Giant's Causeway, N. Ireland Cushendun, N. Ireland Turnley's Port, N. Ireland Wicklow, Eire Shag Harbour, Canada Mean acceptance rate
0.79 0.83 0.94 0.72 0.67 0.81 0.39 0.80 0.71 0.61 0.67 0.46
0.67 0.75 0.75 0.71
0.78 0.72 0.82 0.71 0.61 0.77 0.31
0.56 0.70 0.79 0.56 0.61 0.61 0.22 0.65
0.47 0.53 0.45
0.72 0.67 0.65 0.65 0.62 0.70 0.37 0.56 0.50 0.52 0.46 0.3 1
0.70
0.60
0.60
0.56
0.54
0.55 0.70 0.41 0.50 0.50 0.47 0.70 0.55
0.58 0.50
0.50 0.36 0.44 0.44
" Data from sources in Table 1. Swedish populations have very low frequencies of the AdhC allele and are not included.
ences of aa and c.P females are stronger in nontidal compared to tidal populations for both karyotypes (Mann-Whitney I/ test, z = -2.67, p < .Ol), whereas no significant association exists for /3P females (z = -1.33, p = .18). The interpretation of this association is far from easy because tidal range correlates with several other habitat features of seaweed flies (including the stability of the food supply and geographical location), as well as with other variables likely to be relevant to mating behavior (such as adult density and the mean and variance of male size). We shall return to this problem later.
C. GENETIC DETERMINATION OF FEMALE PREFERENCE The association between mating behavior and inversion karyotype suggests there may be genetic variation in female mating behavior. This genetic variation might reside at loci present within or near the ap inversion system, or at loci completely unlinked to the inversion. Nonrandom mating could result in linkage disequilibrium between the inversion system carrying genes determining the male trait, and those loci determining the preference. In order to understand the evolution of female mating behavior it is crucial to determine whether the loci determining preference and trait are physically linked.
23
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
TABLE 111 OF PREFERENCE EXHIBITED BY FEMALES IN SAMPLES FROM NATURAL STRENGTHS POPULATIONS" Female inversion karyotype Population _____
~
KLmpinge, Sweden Traslovslage (A), Sweden Trtislovslage (B), Sweden Lerkil, Sweden Helgoland, Germany Petit Port, Channel Islands L'Etacq (A), Channel Islands L'Etacq (B). Channel Islands Portland Bill, England St. Mary's Island, England Niarbyl, Isle of Man Giant's Causeway, N. Ireland Cushendun, N. Ireland Turnley's Port, N. Ireland Wicklow, Eire Shag Harbour, Canada Coefficient of variation in strength of preference
ffa
ffP
PP
+1.76 +1.81 +1.16 +3.24 +0.50 +0.38 +0.96 +0.13 +1.13 0.00 +1.71 +0.44 +0.28 +0.62 +1.26
+0.74 +0.46 +0.69 + 1.86 +0.63 +0.19 +0.40 +0.03 +1.58 +0.39 +1.74 +0.78 +0.29 +0.05 +0.41 + 1.64 0.83
~_______
+2.34
+ 13.14 +5.91 +1.31 -0.11 - 1.46 +0.36 -1.09 + 1.06 -0.19 +1.28 +0.51 +0.11 +1.33 +2.21 + 0.24 2.07
+0.78
0.82
Data from sources in Table I. Preferences are expressed as logistic regression coefficients of acceptance rate on male size. (1
Gilburn and Day (1994~)studied the inheritance of female mating behavior. Animals were collected from a Swedish population (Traslovslage) in which both acceptance rate and female preference had been found to differ significantly between the two inversion homokaryotypes. A laboratory line was established in which only two alleles were segregating: a B allele associated with the a inversion, and a C allele almost certainly associated with the p form of the inversion (as Adh-CC males were of the small size characteristic of /3p homokaryotypes). Males from this " B + C" line were paired with virgin females from a broad-based population (also from Traslovslage) and the behavior of the progeny from any BC X BD crosses typed in mating trials. Because the parents were inversion heterokaryotypes, and there is no recombination at all in males (Day et al., 1982) and none in females in the region of the cup inversion, a finding that the four inversion haplotypes are inherited intact would indicate the relevant loci are located near the inversion. Strong associations were observed between the daughters' Adh genotype and both their acceptance rate and their mating prefer-
24
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDR6 S. GILBURN
ence (Table IV). When an (Y haplotype was inherited from one parent, daughters exhibited a stronger preference than when a P haplotype was inherited, although this was only the case when an (Y haplotype was also inherited from the other parent. These results indicate a relatively simple genetic basis to female mating behavior: the relevant genes appear to be located in the region of the CUPinversion system on chromosome I. The experiment was repeated after the B + C line and the broadbased laboratory stock had been maintained in culture for seven generations. The pattern of inheritance of acceptance rate was unchanged; act females showed the highest acceptance, PPs the lowest, and aps were intermediate, although none of the differences was significant (Table IV). However, in contrast to the earlier tests, no category of female exhibited a significant preference for large males. Either the genes for strong preference had been lost, or they were no longer being expressed. This result is strikingly similar to those obtained in the ladybird beetle, Aduliu bipunctutu. An initial female preference, apparently inherited in a simple fashion (Majerus, O'Donald, and Weir, 1982; Majerus, O'Donald, Kearns, and Ireland, 1986), was lost after laboratory culture for several generations (Kearns, Tomlinson, Veltman, and O'Donald, 1992). The reasons for this apparent instability of preferences in both Aduliu and Coelopu remain to be determined.
TABLE IV ACCEFTANCE RATESA N D PREFERENCES OF FEMALES FROM THE FIRST A N D SEVENTH OF LABORATORY CULTURE^ GENERATIONS Acceptance rates
Preference
1st gen"
7th gen"
1st gen"
7th gen"
(Adh-BE)
0.76
0.56
+ 1.09 (0.82)
( ~ / 3(Adh-BC)
0.48
0.46
(Adh-BD)
0.42
0.45
/3p (Adh-CD)
0.28
0.37
+3.46 (1.08)b p < 0.01 +0.82 (0.63) p = 0.19 +0.71 (0.48) p = 0.14 + 1.93 (0.66) p < 0.01
Karyotype (Y(Y
p = 0.23 +1.23 (0.66) p = 0.09 + 1.23 (0.61) p = 0.07 +0.80 (0.64) p = 0.28
Preferences are given as logistic regression coefficients of acceptance rate on male size (data from Gilburn and Day, 1994~). Standard errors of regression coefficients are given in parentheses. The p values indicate whether the coefficients differ significantly from zero.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
25
VII. THEPREFERRED TRAIT: MALESIZE DETERMINATION OF MALESIZE A. GENETIC In a few species the preferred character in the male is known to have a relatively straightforward genetic determination. For example, most of the genetic variation in male size in the swordtail fish, Xiphophorus nigrensis, is determined by allelic variation at a single locus on the Y chromosome (Ryan and Causey, 1989). There are three classes of male size, small, intermediate, and large, which appear to have different mating strategies (Ryan and Wagner, 1987). In the marine isopod, Purucerceis sculpru, there are also three genetically distinct male morphs probably determined by allelic variation at a single autosomal locus (Shuster and Wade, 1991). The largest morph appears to gain through female choice, the intermediate males mimic females, and the smallest males mature most rapidly and attempt sneaky copulations. In spite of these examples, in most species the male trait is likely to be polygenically determined. It seems improbable that characters as complex as adult body size, color patterns, or mating calls could be predominantly encoded by a single locus in most species. The task of mapping loci that determine a metric character is a formidable one, even in species amenable to genetic analysis (Spickett, 1963; Wolstenholme and Thoday, 1963;Caligari and Mather, 1975;Shrimpton and Robertson, 1988a,b). The prospect that it will be achieved, or even attempted, in the near future for any sexually selected trait must be remote. In C. frigidu it has been clear for some time that the male trait is at least partly determined by the chromosome I inversion system. A study of three British populations revealed that male size was associated with inversion karyotype (Butlin et al., 1982b); act homokaryotypes were the largest, pps smallest, and Cvps were intermediate. A much more extensive survey of 30 populations (Gilburn and Day, 1994b) confirmed the relationship between inversion karyotype and size in all 30 populations. The influence of the inversion was quantified by Wilcockson, Crean, and Day (1995), who cultured the progeny of pairs of adults under conditions of excess food, so that the full genetic potential would be realized. About 80% of the variance in the size of fathers was explained by the father’s karyotype, and the equivalent value for sons was about 77%. This suggested that the ap inversion system is the major determinant of male size. Although the inversion is inherited in a simple Mendelian fashion, there may still be many loci located within it that influence size. If this is so, there must be strong linkage disequilibrium between the relevant alleles such that most, if not all, of the alleles for large size are located on the a form of the inversion and the “small alleles” on the p form. The number of loci involved would then be
26
THOMAS H. DAY AND
ANDRB s. GILBURN
of little consequence because the haplotypes, or coadapted gene complexes, would be subject to the same selection and evolve as if they were a single locus. B. SEXUAL DIMORPHISM IN ADULT SIZEIN NATURAL POPULATIONS For many students of sexual selection the principal challenge has been to understand the evolution of exaggerated secondary sexual characters in males. The responses to this challenge have been reviewed by Anderson (1994). In many cases the preferred trait is expressed only in males, but the very nature of some characters, including, for instance, body size, means they are present in both sexes. For such characters expressed in both sexes, but subject to sexual selection only in males, theory predicts first the evolution of differential expression in the two sexes, and second, that over considerable evolutionary time, the genetic correlation between the sexes could become negligible (Lande, 1981;Lande and Arnold, 1985). The latter prediction is exceedingly difficult to test, but there have been many studies exploring the former. A review of these studies by Pomiankowski and Mgller (1995) showed that additive genetic variation is usually higher in sexually selected traits than in traits not subject to sexual selection. Seaweed flies have provided substantial evidence supporting at least one of Lande and Arnold’s predictions. Coefficients of additive genetic variation have been estimated in samples from five natural populations ( Wilcockson et al., 1995; Day, Crean, Gilburn, Shuker, and Wilcockson, 1996). Traditionally, the additive genetic contribution to the phenotypic variance of a character has been measured by its heritability (Falconer, 1989). However, it has been pointed out by Charlesworth (1984) and Houle (1992) that a better measure, certainly for comparing different traits, is the coefficient of additive genetic variance (the square root of the additive genetic variance divided by the mean). This coefficient excludes nonadditive and environmental effects, and standardizes the variance by the mean. In recognition of the greater familiarity of heritabilities, both CVA and h2 values have been calculated. The values deriving from parent-offspring regressions measured under conditions of excess food are given in Table V. Although coefficients vary considerably between populations, there is a consistent difference between the sexes. The expression of the relevant genes is relatively strong in males, but negligible, and statistically nonsignificant, in females. There does appear to have been an uncoupling of their expression in the two sexes. If it is true that this uncoupling is a slow process (Lande, 1981), we can speculate that male size has been subject to sexual selection for a considerable time.
27
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
TABLE V HERITABILITIES AND COEFFICIENTS OF ADDITIVE GENETIC VARIATION FOR BODYSIZE MEASURED UNDER CONDITIONS OF EXCESS FOOD"
h2 ( S E )
CVA
Population
Location
Males
Females
Males
Females
Trasl(ivs1lge Torekov Svarte St. Mary's Isl. Niarbyl
W coast of Sweden W coast of Sweden S coast of Sweden NE coast of England Isle of Man
70.4 (7.6) 30.4 (10.9) 56.0 (15.3) 41.8 (11.8) 36.8 (12.4)
17.9 (8.1) 8.0 (10.9) -1.6 (15.7) 8.2 (14.9) 10.0 (12.1)
9.8 7.7 10.5 7.7 7.3
2.2 1.6 0.8 1.1 1.8
Data from Wilcockson ef al. (1995) and Day et al. (1996). Both h2 and CVA are expressed as percentages.
Sexual dimorphism in adult size is also observed in natural populations, though the nature of the dimorphism depends on karyotype (Gilburn and Day, 1994b). aa males were larger than aa females in all but one population (,y2 = 23.2, p < .001), whereas /3/3 males were smaller than /3/3 females in 24 of the 30 populations (x2 = 10.8, p = .001). One possible explanation for these observations is that the male trait, enlarged body size, has evolved only on the a form of the inversion, and that body size on the /3 form of the inversion is at or near its optimum as determined by natural selection alone. However, the observation that in @/3sfemales are larger than males does not necessarily mean the male trait is at its naturally selected optimum on the /3 form of the inversion. The presence of hyper- or hypoallometry also provides evidence that a character is sexually selected (Fairbairn and Preziosi, 1994). Indeed, it is probably a better indicator than sexual dimorphism when the naturally selected optima differ in the two sexes, yet the sex with the lower optimum is subject to sexual selection of an intensity that restores monomorphism. Hyperallometry for sexual size dimorphism occurs if males are larger than females and the extent of the dimorphism increases as mean size increases, assuming that males are the selected sex. Hypoallometry is observed when females are larger than males, and the extent of the dimorphism decreases as mean size increases. The two phenomena are caused by the same mechanism. Sexual selection favoring large male size in a species at its naturally selected optimum should lead t o an increase in body size in males and a correlated response in females. Female size may then move back toward its optimum as determined by natural selection, thus reducing the genetic correlation in size between the sexes (Lande and Arnold, 1985). If the male trait is produced relatively late in development, which is often the case,
28
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRk S. GILBURN
the expression of the trait depends on resources available toward the end of development. In other words, males are predicted to develop first to a minimum size necessary for survival and then, if conditions permit, develop further. When conditions are harsh, females and males remain at their naturally selected optima or smaller, but in more favorable conditions, the males may approach their optimum as determined by a trade-off between natural and sexual selection. In C. frigida hyperallometry is observed, but only for the aas and aps (Fig. 4). At the smallest male sizes the dimorphism is not significantly different to unity (in other words, males and females are the same size), but the dimorphism increases as size increases. Because pp homokaryotypic males are generally smaller than females, if they were responding to sexual selection, hypoallometry would be predicted. The fact that this is not seen suggests that pp males are genuinely at their optimum as determined by natural selection. A further complication in understanding the dimorphism is the existence of male mate choice. Because males prefer to mate with large females (Pitafi et al., 1990 Pitafi, 1991), the mean size of females is expected to be displaced from their viability optimum. If both sexes are subject to sexual selection for increased size, the extent of dimorphism would depend on the relative intensities of selection in the two sexes. Furthermore, the reversed dimorphism observed among pps at high larval densities may in part be a consequence of male mate preferences. C. GENETIC VARIATION I N MALESIZEI N NATURAL POPULATIONS Any indirect mechanism of sexual selection requires that the preferred character has a strong genetic determination, or more precisely, has a high coefficient of additive genetic variation (CV,). Furthermore, any good genes mechanism could operate only if the preferred character is a reliable indicator of the relevant fitness genes. In C. frigida adult size could potentially be used by females as an indicator of inversion karyotype, which is known to have a major effect on fitness. The results from laboratory crosses (see Table V) suggest that male size has a high CVA.Because virtually all of this genetic variance is attributable to the aj3 inversion (Wilcockson et al., 1995; Day et al., 1996), male size could serve as a reliable indicator of karyotype. However, these experiments were intentionally carried out at low larval densities in order that environmental influences would be minimized. The crucial issue as far as evolution is concerned is whether there are high CVAsin natural populations, or whether the genetic contribution to male size is effectively swamped by nongenetic factors.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
E
1t
1.3
29
A *.
. ./
c
I
.8
6
5
1.4
7
9
8
1 0 1 1 1 2
1B
.8
6
5
I .4
2 e 0 E
3 a
Q
I .3 1.2 1.1 1
lc
8
9
1 0 1 1 1 2
C
I
5
6
.. . . *
.*
.
.9 .8
7
c
7
8
9
. 1 0 1 1 1 2
Mean size of aol males (mm) FIG. 4. Relationship between the strength of sexual dimorphism and mean size of aa males. Dimorphism values were calculated separately for (A) aa homokaryotypes, (B) ap heterokaryotypes,and (C) pp homokaryotypes.A value of LOcorresponds to sexual monomorphism; values less than 1.0 indicate reverse dimorphism, with females larger than males. Redrawn from Gilburn and Day (1994b).
30
THOMAS H. DAY AND
ANDRB s. GILBURN
CVAshave been calculated using samples collected from natural populations (Day et al., 1996). The method essentially assesses the difference in size between Adh-BB and DD homozygous males (Falconer, 1989). Unlike the coefficients deriving from parent-offspring correlation, which refer to the total additive genetic variation, these coefficients refer to the additive genetic variation attributable to the afi inversion system. However, because the a@system accounts for almost all the genetic variation, the two estimates are comparable. CVA values ranged from 0 to almost 14. It is expected that as larval density increases, competition would increase, and the effect of genetic factors would decline (Falconer, 1989). If the mean size of aa males is taken as a measure of larval density experienced by the adults in the wild, a strong association is observed between CVA and density (Fig. 5). At low densities (at which aa males are large) high values of CVA are seen, but as density increases, the CVAs fall to 0. This means that in low-density populations (which commonly experience high tidal variation), size would be a very good indicator of karyotype, but it would be completely unreliable in high-density populations.
8
9
'E:
urn O P - u
e
2
*&
4% g$! U%
3
4
Mean size of au males (mm)
Larval density
-b
FIG. 5. Relationship between additive genetic variance attributable to the ap inversion and the mean size of aa males in samples from natural populations. Data from Day er al. (1996).
31
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
A further insight into indicator reliability is gained by focusing on those populations from which repeat samples were collected at different times (Fig. 6). CVAvalues are strongly associated with larval density (as measured by the size of am males) and are not at all characteristic of individual populations. There is also a significant difference in the relationship between British and Swedish populations. Swedish animals are generally smaller than British ones, and the regression line (not shown) of CVAvalues against size is correspondingly displaced. In spite of males being smaller, Swedish populations exhibit the full range of CVAs. In the nine populations sampled more than once, the reliability of size as an indicator was highly variable. This means that the intensity of indirect sexual selection is far from constant, and on occasion it may be completely inoperative. In particular, at times of stress when heterosis is strongest and the fitnesses of individuals differ most, good genes sexual selection is unlikely to be a significant force of change. The efficacy of indirect sexual
0 Boul
0 .%ah
A
A 0
w
0
+ & a
+ A 0
O
SMI Whit
.
I Kamp 0
D 0 0
A-
I A A 0
A 0
Lerk
W
Sten
A 0
Tras
Yst
+
w 0
6
5
4
3
+Mean size of clcl males (mm) Larval density
-'b
FIG.6 Relationship between additive genetic variance attributable to the ap inversion and the mean size of aa males. Only those populations sampled on more than one occasion are included. The samples were collected from: Boulmer, Seahouses, St. Mary's Island, and Whitburn (all from Britain, and assigned open symbols), Bua, KBmpinge, Lerkil, Steninge, Traslovslage, and Ystad (all from Sweden, and assigned closed symbols). Data from Day et al. (1996).
32
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRk S. GILBURN
selection as an evolutionary force must depend on larval densities averaged over many generations. D. EVOLUTION OF THE MALEPREFERRED TRAIT Why should the male preferred trait evolve only on one form of the inversion? The presence of additive genetic variation in the male trait within the region of the inversion and the lack of recombination between the two inversion sequences enable the male trait to evolve independently on each form. This explains how male size could vary between karyotypes, but not why this has happened. One of two other conditions is required. First, the cost of carrying the male trait might differ between the two inversion homokaryotypes. In a model, small differences resulted in the fixation of a trait on one form of an inversion and its loss on the other (A. S. Gilburn, unpublished results). Alternatively, if the two sets of homokaryotypic females express different mating preferences, the male trait could evolve independently on each form of the inversion by maximizing the chances of being chosen by females of the opposite homokaryotype. By indicating their karyotype, males could father fitter offspring. The former mechanism is the simpler, and perhaps the more likely, explanation for the evolution of the association between inversion karyotype and male size in C. frigida. VIII. EVOLUTION OF FEMALE MATEPREFERENCES In many species the force driving the evolution of female mating preferences is uncontroversial; these are species in which there is male parental investment. Females are expected to evolve mating preferences for those males willing to invest most in their offspring. The types of male parental investment that have been shown to be the target of female mating preferences vary from the size of nuptial gifts presented by hanging-flies and scorpion flies (Thornhill, 1976,1979,1980,1981; Alcock, 1979) and the size of spermatophores in katydids (Gwynne, 1982) to the quality of a male’s territory, as seen in green frogs (Wells, 1977), red-winged blackbirds (Searcy, 1979), and pied flycatchers (Read, 1986; Alatalo, Lundberg, and Glynn, 1986). In many other species the selective advantage to mate choice is much less obvious. These species have no male parental investment, and the females apparently gain nothing other than genetic material from the male. The evolution of female preferences in such species has been the subject of much controversy, with numerous alternative mechanisms being suggested
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
33
(reviewed by Kirkpatrick and Ryan, 1991), and has been termed the “paradox of the lek” (Borgia, 1979),although the problem is certainly not limited to lekking species. The mechanisms by which the mating preference for large male size in C. frigidu may have evolved are considered in the next section. A. POSSIBLE MECHANISMS The expression of a female mating preference in non-resource-based mating systems could provide a direct benefit to the choosing female (direct sexual selection), or it could increase the fitness of the offspring (indirect sexual selection). Many models of direct sexual selection have been developed, including avoidance of hybridization with heterospecific males (Fisher, 1930; Dobzhansky, 1951)’ avoidance of inbreeding (Parker, 1983) or of males with low sperm fertility (Grafen, 1990), lowering of search costs for mates (Kirkpatrick, 1987), increased fecundity, avoidance of disease or parasite transmission (Borgia and Collis, 1990), and pleiotropic effects of other characters involving innate biases in the females’ sensory system (Parker, 1983; Ryan and Rand, 1990; Enquist and Arak, 1993). There is empirical evidence for the operation of some of these mechanisms of direct sexual selection. There are at least two examples of females gaining an increase in fecundity through the expression of a female mating preference in species with non-resource-based mating systems. Females of the cockroach, Nuuphoetu cinereu, prefer to mate with males that produce offspring with fast development (Moore, 1994);females mating with such males gain an advantage, as they shorten the time between clutches. In the Neotropical frog, Ololygon rubru, the ratio of male to female size is associated with the fertilization rate of eggs (Bourne, 1993). Females prefer to mate with males of an optimum size and thereby maximize their fecundity. One possible example of a female mating preference that has evolved in response to the avoidance of disease transmission is in the guppy, Poecilia reticuluta. Females prefer to mate with males with the brightest carotenoid spots, which are known to become paler when the males are infected with a monogenean parasite (Houde and Torio, 1992). However, it is as yet unclear whether females are avoiding infection themselves, or whether the benefit accrues as a result of producing offspring more likely to be resistant to parasites. A similar situation exists in the satin bowerbird, Ptilonorhynchus violuceus, in which females prefer to mate with disease-free males having brighter plumage coloration (Borgia and Collis, 1989). Perhaps the best example of a preference evolving through pleiotropy, as a side effect of another trait, is the preference for males with lowfrequency calls in the Tdngara frog, Physuluemus pusfulosus. In a cross-
34
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRB S. GILBURN
species study Ryan, Fox, Wilcynski, and Rand (1990) showed that females of a closely related species, P. colorudorum, can exhibit the preference, yet males of this species do not express the mating call. They inferred that the preference predates the male trait. Females expressing the preference have a bias in their basilar papilla tuning, which is present in both species, and it therefore appears that the preference may have evolved as a side effect of the evolution of the basilar papillae. Alleles for female mating preference may evolve through indirect sexual selection by becoming genetically correlated with another trait subject to positive selection. Models of indirect sexual selection are of two types, depending on the nature of this other trait. In the Fisherian process (Fisher, 1930;Lande, 1981;Kirkpatrick, 1982;Pomiankowski, lwasa, and Nee, 1991), the other trait is the male preferred character itself. The two characters become genetically correlated as a result of nonrandom mating; females carrying a mating preference preferentially mate with males carrying the preferred trait. In the “good genes” or viability indicator mechanism (Zahavi, 1975; Bell, 1978; Hamilton and Zuk, 1982; Andersson, 1982, 1986; Kirkpatrick, 1986; Pomiankowski, 1987; Iwasa, Pomiankowski, and Nee, 1991), the other trait is a viability trait that is assumed to affect the expression of the male trait. Nonrandom mating with respect to the male preferred trait also results in nonrandom mating with respect to the viability trait. The preference and the viability trait consequently become genetically correlated. There is considerable empirical evidence in favor of the operation of the viability indicator mechanism (reviewed by Johnstone, 1995). These empirical tests have sought correlations between the male preferred trait and male viability. In the three-spined stickleback (Gasterosteus aculeatus) femalesprefer to mate with males with the highest intensity of red coloration (Milinski and Bakker, 1990). The males that appear in best condition, as estimated from a standard fisheries measure, also possess the highest intensity of red coloration. Infection with parasites reduced the red coloration, and it was suggested that the extent of redness was being used by females to indicate the presence of parasite-resistance genes in the males. Similarly, Mgller (1990) found a correlation between the level of mite infestation and tail length in male barn swallows, Hirundo rusrica. Cross-fostering studies demonstrated that the offspring of some pairs show much higher mite resistance than the offspring of other pairs present in the same nest. Males with long-tailed fathers have been shown to have a higher survival rate (Mgller, 1994a). Females prefer to mate with long-tailed males and also prefer males with the most symmetrical tails (Mgller, 1994b). Tail symmetry was found to correlate positively with survival in males. Norris (1993) showed in the great tit (Purus major) that the viability of male offspring
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
35
is positively correlated with the male preferred trait carried by their father. Females prefer to mate with males possessing large black breast stripes. Norris performed a cross-fostering experiment to obtain an estimate of the unbiased heritability of breast strip size, and found a substantial heritable component to the variation in offspring breast stripe size. In addition, male offspring survival was positively correlated with the size of the breast stripe of their fathers. A similar correlation between offspring viability and male trait size has been found in pheasants (Phasianus colchicus) in which females prefer to mate with males carrying long spurs. Using DNA fingerprinting to determine paternity, von Schantz, Grahn, and Goransson (1994) revealed a positive correlation between the survival rate to adulthood of offspring and the spur length of the father. Female cockroaches (Nauphoeta cinerea) prefer to mate with males that produce offspring with shorter development (Moore, 1994). Development time was found to have a heritable component and to be positively genetically correlated with male attractiveness. Offspring of preferred fathers gained an advantage because fast development leads to earlier sexual maturity. Empirical evidence consistent with the Fisherian process is less abundant. Female mating preference and the preferred male trait are by their very nature sex limited, which makes direct identification of the relevant alleles in the same individual extremely difficult. Consequently, studies of the Fisher process seeking positive genetic correlations have used less direct methods (reviewed by Bakker and Pomiankowski, 1995). One has been to measure the preferred trait in fathers, and the preferences of their daughters. For example, Moore (1989) found that socially dominant males of the cockroach, Nauphoeta cinerea, produced female offspring with mating preferences for socially dominant males. Social dominance in N. cinerea is determined by olfactory differences in the males. In a similar study of the three-spined stickleback, Gasterosteus aculeatus, Bakker (1993) crossed females with males possessing varying amounts of red coloration (the preferred trait), and found a positive correlation between the strength of preference for redness in daughters and the extent of redness in their fathers. A positive correlation between daughters’ preference and sons’ redness was also observed. A second approach has been to look for correlated responses to selection. Wilkinson and Reillo (1994) selected for long and short eye span in the stalk-eyed fly, Cyrtodiopsis dalmanni, in which wild females prefer to mate with males having long eye spans. Female mating preference showed a correlated response to selection in the short eye span line, although preference did not increase in the line selected for long eye span. In a similar experiment using the guppy, Poecilia reticulata, selection to increase or reduce the extent of orange coloration resulted in a correlated response in female preference (Houde, 1994). Females from
36
THOMAS H. DAY AND A N D R 6 S. GILBURN
the lines in which orange coloration in males had increased showed stronger preferences for orange males than did females from the line in which orange coloration had reduced. These studies demonstrate that indirect selection involving good genes or the Fisher process could account for the evolution of female mating preferences. However, it is important to note that these mechanisms, as well as those involving direct selection, are not mutually exclusive. This is to be expected because in any species in which female choice maximizes offspring viability (in other words, good genes sexual selection occurs), nonrandom mating is likely to lead to the development of a genetic correlation between the preference and the preferred trait, assuming, of course, that there is additive genetic variation in both characters. The successful operation of a good genes mechanism also requires additive genetic variation in both characters, so the Fisher process is likely to accompany good genes sexual selection. Distinguishing the relative importance of two mechanisms will surely require a knowledge of the genetics of the preferred trait. If it is determined by genes that affect the trait alone, the Fisher process is likely to be operating, whereas if all the additive genetic variation in the trait is attributable to pleiotropic effects of viability genes, then good genes sexual selection is likely to predominate. B. INDIRECT SEXUAL SELECTION IN COELOPA FRIGIDA
Both forms of indirect sexual selection, the Fisher process and the viability indicator mechanism, could be playing a role in the maintenance of the female mating preference for large male size in C. frigida. Both require additive genetic variation to be present in the preference and the preferred trait, and the establishment of a genetic correlation between them. It has been shown that there is substantial additive genetic variation in the male trait due to the inversion system (Wilcockson et al., 1995; Day er al., 1996), and that differences in female mating behavior are associated with the same inversion system (Gilburn et al., 1993, 1996; Gilburn and Day, 1994a). At least some of these differences appear to be heritable (Gilburn and Day, 1994c;A. S. Gilburn, unpublished results). In most models of the Fisher process the loci determining the preference and the trait are assumed to be unlinked (Lande, 1981; Kirkpatrick, 1982; Pomiankowski et al., 1991), and the genetic correlation between the two characters is assumed to develop as a result of nonrandom mating. Because in seaweed flies both characters are associated with the Olp inversion system, physical linkage rather than nonrandom mating could generate genetic correlations. Theoretical support for this idea was provided by Trickett and Butlin (1994) who added an inversion system to the Kirkpatrick model (1982) of the
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
37
Fisher process. The absence of recombination allowed much stronger genetic correlations to develop than when the loci are unlinked. The presence of an inversion system in C.frigida, carrying additive genetic variation in both the preference and the trait, could generate very strong positive genetic correlations that could fuel the Fisher process. Just as the prerequisite conditions for the operation of the Fisher process exist in C. frigidu, so do they for “good genes” sexual selection. The existence of the ap inversion system allows the evolution of a slightly unusual kind of viability indicator mechanism. Given the very large viability differences between individuals of different inversion karyotypes, homokaryotypic females could maximize their offspring viability by mating disassortatively (aa X pp crosses would produce progeny with very high survival). This differs from traditional ideas of good genes sexual selection in that female seaweed flies are expected to mate not with males of the highest fitness (aps), but with males carrying genes that complement their own. Females could potentially increase their chances of mating with a male of suitable karyotype by exercising a mating preference based on size. Such an indicator system would work because the crp inversion is the major genetic determinant of male body size. Trickett and Butlin’s (1994) model of sexual selection incorporating an inversion system was based on a haploid organism. Although the effect of physical linkage between the preference and preferred character could be determined, any effects of heterosis could not be studied. Their model was limited to the Fisher process alone. In order to assess the potential good genes effects of heterosis on the evolution of preferences, a diploid model was constructed (Gilburn and Day, 1996a). This suggested that when indirect sexual selection alone operates the only type of mating preferences likely to evolve are disassortative. Under most conditions simulated, the advantages accruing from good genes sexual selection are greater than those from Fisherian sexual selection. If the strength of heterosis is weak, a strong assortative mating preference can evolve through the Fisher process, but this results in the rapid loss of the inversion polymorphism. Consequently, it seems unlikely that Fisherian selection acting alone can be responsible for the evolution of mating preferences in C. frigida because the inversion is polymorphic in all populations sampled. If indirect sexual selection alone has shaped the evolution of mating behavior, all homokaryotype females are predicted to mate disassortatively with respect to the ap inversion system. The pattern of mating behavior has now been studied in samples from many wild populations (Gilburn et al., 1992, 1993, 1996; Gilburn and Day, 1994a). Fully disassortative mating was found in only 4 of them; in an additional 12 samples all females preferred large males (see Table 111). In
38
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRJ? S. GILBURN
all populations the pp females preferred large males and consequently tended to mate with aa males; they were mating disassortatively. These females presumably gain a good genes advantage through the production of heterokaryotype offspring, and a Fisherian advantage through the production of large male offspring (which, overall, is the preferred type in all populations). In contrast, aa females varied considerably between populations in their preferences. In some they preferred small males, although significantly so in only one, and in others they exhibited extremely strong preferences for large males. In one of these populations, Trasl6vslage (Gilburn et d.,1993), the aa females expressed a significantly stronger preference for large males than the @ females. As the a form of the inversion is associated with large male size, it appears that a positive genetic correlation exists in this population between the female mating preference and the male preferred trait. The preferences at Traslovslage were measured on two occasions separated by six months and both samples revealed a positive genetic correlation between preference and trait; the Fisherian process may well have been operating in this population throughout this period. In summary, Fisherian and good genes sexual selection could account for the preferences exhibited by p/3 females; the two processes would operate in concert. However, Fisherian selection on aa females is predicted to render the inversion monomorphic, which has occurred in none of the many populations studied, and under good genes selection they are expected to prefer small males, which they do (at least significantly so) in only one population. There appear to be serious difficulties understanding how indirect sexual selection operating in isolation could account for the observed patterns of mating of aa females. These difficulties have led us to consider the role of other mechanisms promoting the evolution of female mate preferences. In particular, a model was constructed that explored whether some form of direct selection could account for the assortative mating usually exhibited by aa females (Gilburn and Day, 1996a). The model incorporated a cost to mating with any male, and a cost to rejecting-a cost that increases as male size increases. Not surprising, /3p females gained an advantage through both indirect and direct sexual selection by expressing a preference for large male size. In contrast, direct and indirect selection would act in opposition for aa females. If aa females mate only with the largest males they would be limiting their mating costs (direct sexual selection), but at the expense of producing offspring of low viability (indirect sexual selection). Likewise, if they prefer small males they produce highly fit offspring, but would increase their own costs, as the rejection of large males carries a higher cost than does rejection of small ones.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
39
The relative strengths of indirect and direct sexual selection determine what mate preferences are expressed by aa females. If the relative costs and benefits of direct and indirect selection differ widely between populations, the preferences of aa females could also vary considerably; PP females are predicted to express a more uniform preference because they are advantaged through both direct and indirect selection. This is consistent with the observation that aa females are more variable in their preference. C. DIRECT SEXUAL SELECTION
What possible direct advantages might accrue from preferring large males or, alternatively, from rejecting small ones? There are, of course, diverse ways in which females might benefit, but no formal rationale exists for identifying the mechanism, or mechanisms, operating in any particular species. In C. frigidu several types of potential benefits have been studied. The first potential direct advantage studied was of a resource-based system comparable to that described in mecopterans (Thornhill, 1976), lepidopterans (Boggs and Watt, 1981), neuropterans (Hayashi, 1993)’ and many orthopteran species (Bowen, Codd, and Gwynne, 1984; Gwynne, 1984,1990; Gwynne and Simmons, 1990; Pardo, Lopez-Leon, Hewitt, and Camacho, 1995). Male seaweed flies do not appear to transfer a large spermatophore or any type of nuptial gift during copulation (Pitafi, 1991). The possibility that the semen contains nutritious components was tested by comparing the weight loss of virgin males with that of males allowed repeated matings (Pitafi et al., 1994). No difference was observed. The only potential cost to males was a modest (13%) reduction in the longevity of mating males compared with virgins, an observation consistent with the findings from many other insect species (Ridley, 1988). Furthermore, analyses of the longevities, weight changes, and fecundities of females yielded no evidence for the transfer of nutrients during copulation (Pitafi, 1991). Clearly, our confidence in excluding a resource-based system in Coelopa is limited by the sensitivity of the weighing machine used, which could detect changes of about 1% of the adults’ weight. A second possibility is that females, by choosing, maximize the cost effectiveness of searching for a mate. Video recordings of mate trials gave no indication that females do any searching at all, and even males recognize potential mates only when they are extremely close to them (Day et al., 1989). The avoidance of mating with small males could potentially benefit females if a copulation reduces the chances of subsequent copulations being successful and small males transfer fewer sperm than large ones. However, females have been observed to remate many times in quick succession
40
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRB S . GILBURN
(Pitafi, 1991). Furthermore, the pattern of sperm utilization indicates sperm mixing, unless inseminations are well separated temporally, in which case there is precedence to those sperm in the most recent insemination. This does not suggest that male behavior has evolved in response to competition from earlier or later mating males. Perhaps females avoid mating with small males because they are more often parasitized or infected with pathogens. In natural populations adult seaweed flies commonly carry a mite, Thinoseiusfucicolu, which is detrimental to cultures maintained in the laboratory (Butlin, 1983). However, these mites are phoretic and very quickly detach themselves from flies when decomposing seaweed is available. Because females mate only in the presence of seaweed, it seems improbable (and has never been observed) that mites transfer to the female during mating. Sexual transmission of pathogenic microorganisms certainly cannot be excluded, but would be an effective force of sexual selection only if small males pose a greater risk to females than do large ones. The suggestion that courtship behavior and female choice have evolved as a species-isolating mechanism is an old one (Huxley, 1942; Mayr, 1942). It is possible that females, by avoiding matings with small males, reduce the chances of producing sterile hybrid offspring? C.frigidu and C. pilipes occur sympatrically throughout much of their range (see Fig. l), and males do occasionally mount females of the “wrong” species (Leggett, 1993). Nevertheless, there are several observations that argue against the preference in C. frigidu having evolved through reinforcement. First, when males do mount females of the wrong species they invariably dismount almost immediately; there would appear to be no selection favoring a speciesspecific female mating preference. Second, the distributions of male sizes are very similar in the two species (although the variance in C. pilipes is smaller), yet both types of female exhibit strikingly similar preferences for large males (A. S . Gilburn and T. H. Day, unpublished results). Finally, the expectation that preferences might be strongest where the species occur together is not supported. Swedish and North American populations in which C. pifipes has never been found express preferences just as strong as, if not stronger than, sympatric populations. If C. frigidu populations are categorized according to whether they occur sympatrically with C. pifipes or not, there is no difference in the strength of preference in the two groups. The close coexistence of the two species over much of their range does not seem to have influenced the evolution of female choice. Let us consider one further mechanism by which female choice could directly benefit the female, one that concerns female fecundity. It is possible to propose many ways in which the exercise of a preference results in increased fecundity, even in non-resource-based systems. For example, the
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
41
interclutch interval in ovoviviparous cockroaches is reduced by females preferring certain males (Moore, 1994). In the frog species Physaluemus pustulosus and Ololygon rubra, a preference for optimally sized males results in greater female fertility (Ryan, 1985; Bourne, 1993). In C. frigida Pitafi (1991) showed that mated females of a highly inbred strain produce significantly more eggs than do unmated ones. This admits the possibility that the acceleration in egg production, apparently triggered by mating, is dependent on male size. This question has yet to be answered.
D. PLEIOTROPY Most models of intersexual selection assume that the evolution of female preference is driven by an advantage either directly or indirectly associated with the male character. A distinctly different idea is that preferences could have originated as a side effect of the evolution of some other character unconnected with mate choice. The preference is supposed to have evolved in response to natural selection, perhaps in the context of feeding or predator avoidance, and only later to have become subject to sexual selection as a pleiotropic effect. Two forms of pleiotropy have been proposed: sexual selection for sensory exploitation (Ryan and Rand, 1990; Shaw, 1995) and sexual selection as a side effect of natural selection on female mating behavior (Rowe, Arnqvist, Sih, and Kruppa, 1994).The sensory exploitation hypothesis envisions that biases in the females’ sensory system result in particular male phenotypes being preferentially selected as mates. Frogs of the genus Physalaemus (Ryan et al., 1990; Ryan and Rand, 1990) and swordtail fish of the Xiphophorus species group (Ryan and Wagner, 1987; Ryan and Causey, 1989) provide the most thoroughly studied examples of this type of selection. The crucial feature of pleiotropy is that the female preference predates the evolution of the preferred trait (Basolo, 1990, 1995; Ryan and Rand, 1990). This is not an easy prediction to test without suitable material to construct phylogenetic relationships, and even then the evidence relies on historical inference of evolutionary pathways. In seaweed flies, both C. frigida and C. pilipes express a preference for large males and this preference is mediated through the same mechanism, a physical rejection response during which males attempting to mount are forcibly removed by the female. These observations are consistent with the preference having originated before the species diverged, but with data on only two species available, convergent evolution cannot be excluded. Sexual selection as a side effect of natural selection on female mating behavior is certainly a possible explanation for the evolution of the female preference in C. frigida. Rowe et al. (1994) have suggested that female
42
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRG S. GILBURN
preferences for large males in water striders have evolved as an adaptive reluctance to mate. In this species mating is known to be costly, and nonrandom expression of the rejection response results in an apparent preference for large males. The water strider mating system is similar to that of C. frigida. Female seaweed flies perform a rejection response that results in selection for large males and there also appears to be a cost to mating that manifests itself in terms of reduced longevity (Pitafi, 1991; A. S. Gilburn and T. H. Day, unpublished results). A similar cost has been described in Drosophila melanogaster (Partridge, Green, and Fowler, 1987; Fowler and Partridge, 1989). If the cost of rejecting small males in Coelopa is lower than the cost of mating with them, nonrandom expression of the rejection response would create an apparent mating preference for large males, as is seen in water striders. OF PREFERENCES I N DIFFERENT POPULATIONS E. EVOLUTION
Why does the strength and direction of the preferences of cra females vary between different populations, and why is this apparently associated with tidal range? Variation in the strength of direct or indirect sexual selection between populations could be reflected in the preferences exhibited by crcr females. Nothing is known about variation in the strength of direct sexual selection between different populations; however, the benefit from good genes selection will be limited through the strength of the association between male size and inversion karyotype. Although in the laboratory most of the variation in male size can be attributed to inversion karyotype (Wilcockson et al., 1995; Day et al., 1996), this association becomes weaker in natural populations because of an increase in environmental variation in male size. If the coefficient of additive genetic variation (CV,) in size varies between populations, then the potential benefits of good genes sexual selection should also vary. In populations in which virtually all the variance in male size is environmental, mating disassortatively with respect to size is unlikely to produce fitter offspring. As the proportion of the variance in male size explained by the a@ inversion system increases, so the advantage gained from good genes selection increases. Samples from natural populations were used to calculate both the CVA in male size and the strength of female mating preferences (Gilburn and Day, 1996b). A significant association exists (Fig. 7) between the preference of aa females and the CVA for male size attributable to the inversion (F = 6.6; df = 1, 11; p = .026, using log[preference + 21). In populations in which the CVA is high, aa females are likely to exhibit a preference for small male size. In other words, when the association between male size and inversion karyotype is the strongest, aa females actually avoid mating
43
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
$
1.2
’
1.0
.
0
0
0
-0.2 . 0
-0.4 3
5
7
9
11
13
Coefficient of additive genetic variation of male size FIG.7. Relationship between the mean preference of aa females and the coefficient of additive genetic variance (CV,) in 14 natural populations. Preferences were transformed as log(preference + 2). CV, values refer to the variance attributable to the cxp inversion system. Data from Gilburn and Day (1996b).
with large males. This may be because under these circumstances a preference for large males would probably result in mating with ( ~males, a and so result in low viability offspring. In these populations the good genes cost of mating with the “wrong” type of male may outweigh any advantage gained through direct sexual selection. The good genes cost to any (Y(Y females preferring large males may account for the increased acceptance rates generally exhibited by (YQ females. The greater willingness to mate associated with the (Y form of the inversion may therefore be a response to selection reducing preference for large male size. The association seen between the preference of aa females and CVAin male size could also offer an explanation for the relationship between their preference and tidal range (Gilburn and Day, 1994a). Using an enlarged data set, a very strong association was seen when the preference of ( ~ a females was regressed on tidal range ( F = 20.8; df = 1, 12; p < . 0 1 , using logtpreference + 21 and log[tidal range + 11); CVAin male size attributable to the inversion was also positively correlated with tidal range ( r = .67; p = .011, using log[tidal range + 11). When the preference of aa females was regressed on tidal range after variation associated with CVA in male
44
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRC S. GILBURN
size had first been removed, the association remained significant (F = 8.3; df = 1, 10; p = .016). This suggests that some, though not all, of the variation in aa preferences is due to the CVAin male size, but that additional variation due to tidal range does exist. A further complication is that tidal range and geographical location are themselves highly correlated: all nontidal populations studied were Swedish, and all tidal populations were located outside Sweden. With the data set available it was not possible to separate the confounded effects of these two variables; when either was removed (having first removed the effects of CVA in male size), aa preference was no longer associated with the other variable. However, suggestive evidence was found of an association within the non-Swedish samples (F = 5.5; df = 1, 7; p = .052). It appears that tidal range may have some effect on the preference of aa females independently of variation in the CVA in the male preferred trait, at least in western Europe. How might tidal range influence female mating preferences? Clearly, tides influence the supply of food. Nontidal populations are effectively continuous cultures, while those subject to tidal conditions usually experience regular replacement of seaweed but also periods when there is none at all. The presence or absence of seaweed must also affect oviposition sites; tidal populations sometimes lack suitable sites, which may in turn affect mating behavior. How the availability of seaweed influences the forces of sexual selection remains a problem to be solved. IX. DISCUSSION We are familiar with the idea that natural selection is a very heterogeneous process. Parasites, predators, inability to withstand climatic conditions, and shortage of essential resources are just some of the causes of selective mortality. Likewise, organisms may exhibit differential reproduction for a multitude of reasons. While it has long been recognized that the forces of sexual selection are diverse, the work on seaweed flies illustrates well that they may operate together and interact in complex ways. It is to be hoped that experimental and field studies, like those reviewed here, will stimulate theoreticians to explore the interactions between different forms of sexual selection. It was Fisher (1930) who first explicitly suggested that natural (viability) selection may act as a brake on sexual selection. This has usually been considered in the context of long-term evolutionary change, with viability selection constraining the evolution of exaggerated male traits. However, animals do not live in habitats that are constant, either spatially or temporally. We should therefore not expect every individual to be subject to the
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
45
same, constant forces of sexual selection. The demonstration that seaweed flies in British and Scandinavian populations may be subject to very different types of sexual selection reinforces this expectation. Furthermore, successive generations of flies living in the same place may experience selection of very different intensities. Such variation in selection will make the task of modeling what is going on even more difficult. We are still some way from understanding the interaction between habitat differences in C. frigidu and differences in female preferences. The problem is likely to be a general one. Multiple associations are observed between, on one hand, the strength of female preference, the mean value of the preferred character (male size), and the coefficients of additive genetic variation in male size (i.e., “reliability of the indicator”), and on the other, larval density, food stability, synchrony of generations, and physical factors such as tidal range. The existence of such a maze of associated variables is a problem familiar to ecologists, but it does make the job of working out a chain of causality extremely difficult. Our best guess at the moment (and it is little more than that) is that tidal range is the principal determinant of food availability. This in turn determines the synchrony of generations, the profile of adults available to mate, and the additive genetic variation in the male trait. How mate availability and genetic variation influence the type and intensity of sexual selection is not yet clear. It is perhaps significant that those laboratory experiments in which the available adults were determined by the natural eclosion sequence yielded results apparently contrary to all other controlled experiments; small males exhibited high mating success. Clearly, more work is needed to clarify the influence of population synchrony. What does appear to be true is that the additive genetic variation in the male trait is associated with the pattern of female mating preferences observed in a population. Perhaps the Holy Grail in the field of sexual selection is the identification of the genes responsible for female mate choice. In at least one respect seaweed flies would seem to be good experimental animals. Differences in female preferences exist that are associated with a chromosomal inversion system. Although such large blocks of genes have a substantial effect on the phenotype and segregate in a straightforward Mendelian fashion, the lack of recombination between alternative inversion sequences will surely hamper detailed genetic analyses. However, there is a more immediate problem to solve. Why are preferences unstable during prolonged laboratory culture? This may not be some esoteric genetical problem restricted to C. frigidu, as a strikingly similar phenomenon has been described in the ladybird, Aduliu bipuncruru (Majerus et ul., 1982,1986; Kearns et ul., 1992). One category of explanation involves changes in allele frequencies. Perhaps culture under unnatural conditions results in mate discrimination being
46
THOMAS H. DAY AND A N D R ~s. GILBURN
disfavored. If this is true, then identifying the mechanism of selection occurring in the laboratory is likely to shed light on the nature of selection in wild populations. Another possibility is that the loci determining female mating behavior are closely linked to those determining the preferred trait. In laboratory culture recombinants may not be selected out, or may even be positively favored. Again, identifying the nature of the selection will surely be informative. The implication of both these mechanisms is that the relevant alleles (or haplotypes) are, generation by generation, being actively maintained by selection, and that laboratory culture somehow alters the selection regime. This would mean that allele frequencies in natural populations are fluid and able to respond fairly rapidly to changes in the environment. An alternative explanation for the apparent instability of mating preferences involves changes in the additive genetic variation in the male trait. It is facile to point out that if all males were identical there could be no scope for the expression of any female preference. In general, the effects of female discrimination necessarily depend on the variation in the males available. However, there may be more subtle interactions between preferences and male variation. As the additive genetic variance in male size increases, so does the scope for disassortment in mating, and the consequent advantages to be gained from good genes selection. A further possibility is that preferences depend on the physiological condition of females. Age and sexual experience are known to be important, but developmental history and nutritional status may also be relevant. It is a biological inevitability that larval densities affect the additive genetic variation among males, but they may also influence female preferences. The observed associations between preference, preferred trait, and environmental factors may be a consequence of nongenetic effects on the expression of female preferences. Over the last 20 years or so of work on sexual selection there has been a shift in emphasis. The peacock’s tail was the paradigm-by what mechanism have male traits become so extravagantly exaggerated? More recently the focus of interest has moved to female preferences, and numerous models have been proposed describing how they may have evolved. Usually each model has explored the features of one particular mechanism, and it has been easy to get the impression that our task, as students of sexual selection, is to decide which mechanism is the correct one. The principal lesson learned from the seaweed fly work is that many types of sexual selection operate simultaneously and that female choice has evolved under the influence of several forces. On reflection this conclusion is hardly surprising. Because abundant additive genetic variation in the preferred trait is now recognized as the norm (Pomiankowski and Mdller, 1995), choosy females are expected to produce
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
47
sexy sons, and Fisherian sexual selection (though not necessarily the runaway process) is inevitable. When we tested for a positive genetic correlation between the preference and the preferred trait, it was present in the population at Traslovslage, suggesting that the Fisher process can operate in natural populations. However, the Fisher process probably plays only a relatively minor role in shaping the evolution of preferences in C. frigidu because the effects of the Fisher process on overall offspring fitness are likely to be swamped by the heterotic effects of the inversion (Gilburn and Day, 1996a). If the Fisher process was unchecked by good genes selection, it would result in the eventual loss of the inversion polymorphism, which evidently has not occurred in any of the populations studied. If additive genetic variation in the male character results from the pleiotropic effects of viability genes, then good genes selection could also operate. As many sexually selected traits are exaggerated and therefore costly to produce, variation in viability genes may well influence the ability of males to successfully produce the trait. This particularly applies to species in which the preference is based on size because genes affecting viability are especially likely to have pleiotropic effects on body size. The existence of the heterotic system in C. frigida means that the potential benefits of good genes selection are extremely large in comparison with other species not polymorphic for chromosomal inversions. In spite of the near certainty that indirect sexual selection occurs, models of the C. frigidu system suggest that offspring benefits are not sufficient to account for the evolution of female discrimination seen in natural populations. Some form of direct selection must operate as well. The problem in identifying forces of direct selection is that there are diverse ways in which the female may benefit by the exercise of choice. Females may be avoiding matings with males of the wrong species or males carrying pathogens or parasites. One form of direct selection for which there is growing support is sexual selection for sensory exploitation (reviewed by Shaw, 1995). Ryan and Rand (1990) suggested that some male secondary sexual characters have evolved because of biases in the females’ sensory system. This is essentially an extension of Parker’s (1983) theory of passive choice; females simply move toward the most intense source of the conspecific cue, rather than actively rejecting particular males. Alternatively, sexual selection could be a side effect of natural selection on female mating behavior. In various species of water striders Rowe et ul. (1994) showed that adaptive female reluctance to mate incidentally selects for certain male phenotypes. Thus, preferences may evolve not only through biases in the females’ sensory system, but through biases in the rejection response. The striking similarities in the mating behavior of sea-
48
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRfi S. GILBURN
weed flies and water striders suggest this type of direct selection also occurs in Coelopa. It is now very clear that the mating behavior of seaweed flies is subject to a cocktail of selective forces. The relative strengths of Fisherian, good genes, and direct sexual selection may well vary between populations, generating the differences in female preferences between natural populations and between karyotypes within populations. In addition, sexual selection very much depends on environmental factors, and so is far from constant temporally. We are familiar with this in the context of viability selection; we should no longer think of sexual selection as a single constant force.
X. SUMMARY Seaweed flies (Coelopa frigida) exhibit no dramatic visual or acoustic displays during courtship, yet are subject to many types of sexual selection. Intrasexual selection occurs both in the form of contests between males and in terms of endurance rivalry, and both sexes exercise mate discrimination on the basis of body size. Male mate choice is unproblematical; it has almost certainly evolved in response to selection for increased fertility, as males prefer to mate with large, gravid females. In contrast, studies on female mate choice have revealed a complex interaction between preference and preferred character (male size), both of which are genetically polymorphic, and several environmental variables. The genetic determination of male size is associated with the a@ inversion system on chromosome I; aa homokaryotypes are large, pps small, and aps intermediate. Laboratory crosses suggest the genes affecting female preference are also associated with this inversion, and in at least some natural populations, a correlation exists between the two sets of genes. A further feature of the ap system is that it is heterotic in natural populations--cup heterokaryotypes exhibit higher egg-to-adult viability than do (YQ or pp homokaryotypes. Mating trials indicate that pp females usually prefer to mate with large a-cu males, and by doing so produce offspring of high viability and increased attractiveness; “good genes” selection and the Fisher process are operating in concert. In contrast, the preferences of aa females vary from population to population. In Scandinavian populations subject to no tidal variation and consistently high larval densities, aa females behave in the same way as pps and prefer large males. They gain a Fisherian advantage but at the expense of producing low viability progeny. In the strongly tidal conditions common in Britain, a-cufemales either show
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
49
little preference, or mate disassortatively with small /3/3 males. They are mating in a good genes manner, yet incur a Fisherian disadvantage. Females may also benefit themselves by exercising choice. Several possible types of direct selection have been studied. There does not appear to be any transfer of gifts or nutrients from the male during copulation; mating in seaweed flies is not a resource-based system. Neither does the female rejection response appear to have evolved as a species-isolatingmechanism. However, preferences may have evolved as an adaptive reluctance to mate. Females rejecting rather than accepting small males exhibit increased longevity, and so, by exercising a preference, they avoid or reduce a cost to mating. It would therefore appear that the Fisher process, good genes selection, as well as direct selection all play a role in the maintenance of female preferences. Furthermore, these forces of selection do not operate equally on all females in a population, and they vary in intensity, depending on environmental factors such as tidal conditions, food availability, and larval density. We discuss the mechanisms by which genes and the environment have molded the mating behavior of seaweed flies.
Acknowledgments Most of the work on seaweed flies reviewed here was supported by grants and studentships from the Natural Environment and Science and Engineering Research Councils. Their help is gratefully acknowledged. We are also grateful to The0 Bakker, Caroline Crean, Margaret Leggett, Michael Ritchie. and David Shuker for valuable comments on the manuscript.
References Alatalo, R. V., Hogland, J., and Lundberg, A. (1988). Patterns of variation in tail ornament size in birds. Biol. J. Linn. SOC.34, 363-374. Alatalo, R. V., Lundberg, A., and Glynn, C. (1986). Female pied flycatchers choose territory quality and not male characteristics. Nature (London) 323, 152-153. Alcock, J. (1979). Selective mate choice by females of Harpobittacus australis. Psyche 86, 213-217. Alcock, J. (1994). Postinsemination associations between males and females in insects-The mate-guarding hypothesis. Ann. Rev. Entomol. 39, 1-21. Alcock, J., Jones, C. E., and Buchmann, S. L. (1977). Male mating strategies in the bee Centris pallida Fox (Hymenoptera: Anthophoridae). Am. Nut. 111, 145-155. Anderson, W., Dobzhansky, T., Pavlovsky, O., Powell, J., and Yardley, D. (1975). Genetics of natural populations. XLII. Three decades of genetic change in Drosophifa pseudoobscura. Evolution 29, 24-36. Anderson, M. B. (1982). Sexual selection, natural selection and quality advertisement. Biol. J. Linn. Soc. 17, 375-393.
50
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRB S. GILBURN
Anderson, M. B. (1986). Evolution of condition-dependent sex ornaments and mating preferences: Sexual selection on viability differences. Evolution 40, 804-816. Anderson, M. (1994). “Sexual Selection.” Princeton University Press, Princeton, New Jersey. Aziz, J. B. (1975). Investigations into chromosomes I , 2 and 3 of Coelopa frigida (Fab.). Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom. Bakker, T. C. M. (1993). Positive genetic correlation between female preference and preferred male ornament in sticklebacks. Nature (London) 363,255-257. Bakker, T . C. M., and Pomiankowski, A. (1995). The genetic basis of female mate preferences. J. Evol. Biol. 8, 129-171. Basolo, A. L. (1990). Female preference predates the evolution of the sword in swordtail fish. Science 250,808-809. Basolo, A. L. (1995). Phylogenetic evidence for the role of a pre-existing bias in sexual selection. Proc. R. SOC. Lond. B 259,307-311. Bateman, A. J. (1948). Intra-sexual selection in Drosophila. Heredity 2, 349-368. Bell, G. (1978). The handicap principle in sexual selection. Evolution 32, 872-885. Bella, J. L., Butlin, R. K., Ferris, C., and Hewitt, G. M. (1992). Asymmetrical homogamy and unequal sex ratio from reciprocal mating-order crosses between Chorthippus parallelus subspecies. Heredity 68, 345-352. Berenbaum, M. R. (1990). Coevolution between herbivorous insects and plants: tempo and orchestration. In “Insect Life Cycles. Genetics, Evolution and Co-ordination” (F. Gilbert, ed.), pp. 87-99. Springer-Verlag, London. Berglund, A,, Rosenqvist, G., and Svensson, I. (1986). Mate choice, fecundity and sexual dimorphism in two pipefish species (Syngnathidae). Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 19,301 -307. Birch, L. C. (1955). Selection in Drosophila pseudoobscura in relation to crowding. Evolution 9,389-399. Birkhead, T. R., and Hunter, F. M. (1990). Mechanisms of sperm competition. Trends Ecol. E d 5,48-52. Birkhead, T. R., and MBller, A. P. (1992). ‘Sperm Competition in Birds: Evolutionary Causes and Consequences.” Academic Press, London. Boggs, C. L., and Watt, W. B. (1981). Population structure of pierid butterflies. IV. Genetic and physiological investment in offspring by male Colias. Oecologia 50, 320-324. Borgia, G. (1979). Sexual selection and the evolution of mating systems. In “Sexual Selection and Reproductive Competition in Insects” (M. S. Blum and N. A. Blum, eds.), pp. 19-80. Academic Press, New York. Borgia, G. (1981). Mate selection in the fly Scatophaga stercoraria: Female choice in a malecontrolled system. Anim. Behav. 29, 71-80. Borgia, G.. and Collis, K. (1989). Female choice for parasite-free male satin bowerbirds and the evolution of bright male plumage. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 25, 44-453. Borgia, G., and Collis, K. (1990). Parasites and bright male plumage in the satin bowerbird (Ptilonorhynchus violaceus). Am. Zool. 30,279-285. Bourne, G. R. (1993). Proximate costs and benefits of mate acquisition at leks of the frog, Ololygon rubra. Anim. Behav. 45, 1051-1059. Bowen, B. J., Codd, C. G., and Gwynne, D. T. (1984). The katydid spermatophore (Orthoptera: Tettigoniidae): Male nutritional investment and its fate in the mated female. Austral. J. ZOO^. 32,23-31. Brown, W. D. (1990). Size-assortative mating in the blister beetle (Lytta magisrer) (Coleoptera: Meloidae) is due to male and female preference for large mates. Anirn. Behav. 40,901-909. Budnik, M., Brncic, D., and Koref-Santibanez, S. (1971). The effects of crowding on chromosomal polymorphism of Drosophila pavani. Evolution 25,410-419.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
51
Burk, T., and Webb, J. C. (1983). Effect of male size on calling propensity, song parameters, and mating success in Caribbean fruit flies, Anastrepha suspensa (Loew) (Diptera: Tephritidae). Ann. Entomol. SOC. Am. 76, 678-682. Burley, N. (1986). Sexual selection for aesthetic traits in species with biparental care. Am. Nat. 127,415-445. Burley, N., and Moran, N. (1979). The significance of age and reproductive experience in the mate preferences of feral pigeons, Columba livia. Anim. Behav. 27,686-698. Burnet, B. (1961). On the distribution of recessive embryonic lethals in a natural population of Coelopa frigida. Genet. Res., Camh. 2, 249-271. Butlin, R. K. (1983). The maintenance of an inversion polymorphism in Coelopa frigida. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. Butlin, R. K., Collins, P. M., and Day, T. H. (1984). The effect of larval density on an inversion polymorphism in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Heredity 52, 415-423. Butlin. R. K., Collins, P. M., Skevington, S. J., and Day, T. H. (1982a). Genetic variation at the alcohol dehydrogenase locus in natural populations of the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Heredity 48, 45-55. Butlin, R. K., and Day, T. H. (1985a). Genic and karyotypic selection on an inversion polymorphism in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Heredity 54, 267-214. Butlin, R. K., and Day, T. H. (1985b). Adult size, longevity and fecundity in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Heredity 54, 107-1 10. Butlin, R. K., and Day, T. H. (1989). Environmental correlates of inversion frequencies in natural populations of seaweed flies (Coelopa frigida). Heredity 62,223-232. Butlin, R. K., Read, I. L., and Day, T. H. (1982b). The effects of a chromosomal inversion on adult size and male mating success in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Heredity 49,51-62. Cade. W. (1979). The evolution of alternative male reproductive strategies in field crickets. In “Sexual Selection and Reproductive Competition in Insects” (M. S. Blum and N. A. Blum, eds.), pp. 343-380. Academic Press, New York. Caligari, P. D. S., and Mather, K. (1975). Genotype-environment interaction. 111. Interactions in Drosophila melanogaster. Proc. R. SOC.Lond. E 208, 163-187. Charlesworth, B. (1984).The evolutionary genetics of life histories. In “Evolutionary Ecology” (B. Shorrocks, ed.), pp. 117-133. Blackwell, Oxford. Clutton-Brock, T. H., Albon, S. D., Gibson, R. M., and Guiness, F. E. (1979). The logical stag: Adaptive aspects of fighting in red deer (Cervus elephas L.). Anim. Behav. 27,211-225. Clutton-Brock, T. H., and Vincent, A. C. J. (1991). Sexual selection and the potential reproductive rates of males and females. Nature (London) 351, 58-60. Collins, P. M. (1978). Studies on geneticpolymorphism in Coelopa frigida. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. CBte, 1. M., and Hunte, W. (1989). Male and female mate choice in the redlip blenny: Why bigger is better. Anim. Behav. 38, 78-88. Cullen, S. J., Young, A. M., and Day, T. H. (1987). Dietary requirements of seaweed flies (Coelopa frigida). Estur. Coast. Shelf Sci. 24, 701-710. da Cunha, A. B. (1955). Chromosomal polymorphism in the Diptera. Adv. Genet. 7,93-138. Darwin, C. (1859). “On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection.” Murray, London. Darwin, C. (1871). “The Descent of Man, and Selection in Relation to Sex.” Murray, London. Day, T. H., and Butlin, R. K. (1987). Non-random mating in natural populations of the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Heredity 58, 213-220. Day, T. H., Crean, C. S., Gilburn, A. S., Shuker, D. M., and Wilcockson, R. W. (1996). Sexual selection in seaweed flies: Genetic variation in male size and its reliability as an indicator in natural populations. Proc. R. SOC.Lond. B. 263, 1127-1134.
52
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDRB S. GlLBURN
Day, T. H., Dawe, C., Dobson, T., and Hillier, P. C. (1983). A chromosomal inversion polymorphism in Scandinavian populations of the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Hereditas 99, 135-145. Day, T. H., Dobson, T., Hillier, P. C., Parkin, D. T., and Clarke, B. (1980). Different rates of development associated with the alcohol dehydrogenase locus in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Heredity 44, 321-326. Day, T. H., Dobson, T., Hillier, P. C., Parkin, D. T., and Clarke, B. (1982). Non-random association of enzyme and chromosomal polymorphisms in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Heredity 48, 35-44. Day, T. H., Foster, S., and Engelhard, G. (1989). Mating behavior in seaweed flies (Coelopa frigida). J. Insect Eehav. 3, 105-120. Day, T. H., Miles, S., Pilkington, M. D., and Butlin, R. K. (1987). Differential mating success in populations of seaweed flies (Coelopa frigida). Heredity 58, 203-212. Deutsch, C. J., Haley, M. P., and Le Boeuf, B. J. (1990). Reproductive effort of male northern elephant seals: Estimates from male loss. Can. J. Zool. 68, 2580-2593. Dewsbury, D. A. (1982). Ejaculate cost and male choice. Am. Nut. 119,601-610. Dobson, T. (1973). Coelopa frigida (Fabricius) and Coelopa pilipes (Halliday) (Diptera, Coelopidae): A study of two sympatric species. Unpublished master’s thesis, University of Newcastle upon Tyne, United Kingdom. Dobson, T. (1974a). Studies on the biology of the kelp fly Coelopa in Great Britain. J . Nut. Hist. 8, 155-177. Dobson, T. (1974b). Mechanisms controlling species composition in natural populations of the seaweed fly Coelopa. J. Nut. Hist. 8, 653-673. Dobson, T. (1976). Seaweed flies (Diptera: Coelopidae, etc.). In “Marine Insects” (L. Cheng, ed.), pp. 447-463. North-Holland Publishing Co., Amsterdam. Dobzhansky, T. (1947). Genetics of natural populations XIV. A response of certain gene arrangements in the third chromosome of Drosophila pseudoobscura to natural selection. Genetics 32, 142-160. Dobzhansky, T. (1951). “Genetics and the Origin of Species.” Columbia University Press, New York. Downhower, J. F., and Brown, L. (1980). Mate preferences of female mottled sculpins, Cotrus bairdi. Anim. Eehav. 28,728-734. Dubinin, N. P., and Tiniakov, G. G. (1946). Structural chromosome variability in urban and rural populations of Drosophila funebris. Am. Nut. 80, 393-396. Eberhard, W. G. (1985). “Sexual Selection and Animal Genitalia.” Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. Eberhard, W. G., and Cordero, C. (1995). Sexual selection by cryptic female choice on male seminal products-a new bridge between sexual selection and reproductive physiology. Trends Ecol. Evol. 10,493-496. Egglishaw, H. J. (1960). Studies on the family Coelopidae (Diptera). Trans. R. En!. Soc. Lond. 112, 109-140. E d e n , S. T., and Oring, L. W. (1977). Ecology, sexual selection, and the evolution of mating systems. Science 197,215-223. Engelhard, G., Foster, S. P.. and Day, T. H. (1989). Genetic differences in mating success and female choice in seaweed flies (Coelopa frigida). Heredity 62, 123-131. Enquist, M., and Arak, A. (1993). Selection of exaggerated male traits by female aesthetic senses. Nature (London) 361,446-448. Fairbairn, D. J., and Preziosi, R. F. (1994). Sexual selection and the evolution of allometry for sexual size dimorphism in the water strider. Aquarius remigis. Am. Nut. 144,101-118. Falconer, D. S. (1989). “Introduction to Quantitative Genetics.” Longman Scientific, Harlow, United Kingdom.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
53
Fisher, R. A. (1930). “The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection.” Clarendon Press, Oxford. Foote, C. J., and Larkin, P. A. (1988). The role of male choice in the assortative mating of anadromous and non-anadromous sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka). Behaviour 106,43-62. Foster, S. P. (1989). Selection concerning reproduction in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. Fowler, K., and Partridge, L. (1989). A cost to mating in female fruitflies. Nature (London) 338,760-761. Fraenkel, G. (1969). Evaluation of our thoughts on secondary plant substances. Entomol. EXP.Appl. 12,473-486. Gilbert, L. E. (1976). Postmating female odor in Heliconius butterflies: A male-contributed antiaphrodisiac? Science 193,419-420. Gilburn, A. S. (1992). Sexual selection by female choice in the seaweed fry, Coelopa frigida. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. Gilburn, A. S., Crean, C. S., and Day, T. H. (1996). Sexual selection in natural populations of seaweed flies: variation in the offspring fitness of females carrying different inversion karyotypes. Proc. R. SOC. Lond. B 263,249-256. Gilburn, A. S., and Day, T. H. (1994a). Evolution of female choice in seaweed flies: Fisherian and good genes mechanisms operate in different populations. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. B 255, 159-165. Gilburn, A. S.. and Day, T. H. (1994b). Sexual dimorphism, sexual selection and the ap chromosomal inversion polymorphism in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Proc. R. SOC. Lond. B 257,303-309. Gilburn, A. S., and Day, T. H. (1994~).The inheritance of female mating behaviour in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Genet. Res., Camb. 64, 19-25. Gilburn, A. S., and Day, T. H. (1996a). The evolution of female choice when the preference and the preferred trait are linked to the same inversion system. Heredity 76, 19-27. Gilburn, A. S., and Day, T. H. (submitted). The evolution of female mating preferences and male preferred traits in seaweed flies. Proc. R. SOC. Lond. B. Gilburn, A. S., Foster, S. P., and Day, T. H. (1992). Female mating preference for large size in Coelopa frigida. Heredity 69, 209-216. Gilburn. A. S., Foster, S. P., and Day, T. H. (1993). Genetic correlation between a female mating preference and the male preferred character in the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Evolution 47, 1788-1795. Grafen, A. (1987). Measuring sexual selection: why bother? I n “Sexual Selection: Testing the Alternatives” ( J . W. Bradbury and M. B. Anderson, eds.), pp. 221-233. Wiley, Chichester, United Kingdom. Grafen, A. (1990). Sexual selection unhandicapped by the Fisher process. J. Theoret. Biol. 144,473-516. Gross, M. R. (1982). Sneakers, satellites and parentals: Polymorphic mating strategies in North American sunfishes. Z. Tierpsychol. 60, 1-26. Gross, M. R. (1984). Sunfish, salmon, and the evolution of alternative reproductive strategies and tactics in fishes. I n “Fish Reproduction: Strategies and Tactics” (G. W. Potts and R. J. Wooton, eds.), pp. 55-75. Academic Press, London. Gross, M. R. (1985). Disruptive selection for alternative life histories in salmon. Nature (London) 313,47-48. Gwynne, D. T. (1982). Mate selection by female katydids (Orthoptera: Tettigoniidae, Conocephalus nigropleurum). Anim. Behav. 30,734-738. Gwynne, D. T. (1984). Courtship feeding increases female reproductive success in bushcrickets. Nature (London) 307,361-363.
54
THOMAS H. DAY AND ANDR6 S. GILBURN
Gwynne, D. T. (1990). The katydid spermatophore: evolution of a parental investment. In “The Tettigoniidae: Biology, Systematics and Evolution” (W. J. Bailey and D. C. F. Rentz, eds.), pp. 27-40. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Gwynne, D. T., and Simmons, L. W. (1990). Experimental reversal of courtship roles in an insect. Nature (London) 346, 171-174. Hamilton, W. D., and Zuk, M. (1982). Heritable true fitness and bright birds: A role for parasites. Science 218, 384-387. Hayashi, F. (1993). Male mating costs in two insect species (Protohermes, Megaloptera) that produce large spermatophores. Anim. Behav. 45,343-349. Hewitt, G. M.. Mason, P., and Nichols, R. A. (1989). Sperm precedence and homogamy across a hybrid zone in the alpine grasshopper, Podisma pedestris. Heredity 62, 343-353. Houck, L. D., and Reagan, N. L. (1990). Male courtship pheromones increase female receptivity in a plethodontid salamander. Anim. Behav. 39, 729-734. Houde, A. E. (1994). Effect of artificial selection on male colour patterns on mating preferences of female guppies. Proc. R. SOC.Lond. B 256, 125-130. Houde, A. E., and Torio, A. J. (1992). Effect of parasitic infection on male color pattern and female choice in guppies. Behav. Ecol. 3,346-351. Houle, D. (1992). Comparing evolvability and variability of quantitative traits. Generics 130, 195-204. Howard. D. J., and Gregory, P. G. (1993). Post-insemination signalling systems and reinforcement. Phil. Trans. R. SOC. Lond. B 340,231-236. Hughes, A. L., and Hughes, M. K. (1985). Female choice of mates in a polygynous insect, the whitespotted sawyer Monochamus scutellatus. Behav. Ecol. Sociohiol. 17, 385-387. Huxley, J. S. (1938a). Darwin’s theory of sexual selection and the data subsumed by it, in the light of recent research. Am. Nut. 72,416-433. Huxley, J. S. (1938b). The present standing of the theory of sexual selection. In “Evolution (Essays on Aspects of Evolutionary Biology)” (G. R. De Beer, ed.), pp. 11-41. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Huxley, J. S. (1942). “Evolution, the Modern Synthesis.” Allen and Unwin. London. Iwasa, Y.,Pomiankowski, A,, and Nee, S. (1991). The evolution of costly mate preferences 11. The “handicap” principle. Evolution 45, 1431-1442. Joachim, D., and Curtsinger, J. W. (1990). Genotype and anesthetic determine mate choice in Drosophila melanogasrer. Eehav. Genet. 20, 73-79. Johnson, L. K. (1982). Sexual selection in a brentid weevil. Evolution 36, 251-262. Johnstone, R. A. (1995). Sexual selection, honest advertisement and the handicap principle: Reviewing the evidence. Biol. Rev. 70, 1-65. Jones, J. C. (1973). A study of the fecundity of male Aedes aegypti. J. Insect Physiol. 19,435-439. Kearns, P. W. E., Tomlinson, I. P. M., Veltman, C. J.. and O’Donald, P. (1992). Non-random mating in Adalia hipunctata. 11. Further tests for female mating preference. Heredity 68,385-389. Kirkpatrick, M. (1982). Sexual selection and the evolution of female choice. Evolution 36,l-12. Kirkpatrick, M. (1986). Sexual selection and cycling parasites: a simulation of Hamilton’s hypothesis. J. Theoret. Biol. 119,263-271. Kirkpatrick, M. (1987). The evolutionary forces acting on female mating preferences in polygynous animals. In “Sexual Selection: Testing the Alternatives” (J. W. Bradbury and M. B. Anderson, eds.), pp. 41-53. Wiley, Chichester, United Kingdom. Kirkpatrick, M., and Ryan, M. J. (1991). The evolution of mating preferences and the paradox of the lek. Nature (London) 350,33-38. LaMunyon, C . W., and Eisner, T. (1993). Postcopulatory sexual selection in an arctiid moth (Utetheisa ornatrix). Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 90,4689-4692.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
55
Lande, R. (1981). Models of speciation by sexual selection on polygenic traits. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 78, 3721-3725. Lande, R., and Arnold, S. J. (1985). Evolution of mating preference and sexual dimorphism. J. Theoret. Eiol. 117,651 -664. Lefevre, G. L. Jr., and Jonsson, V. B. (1962). Sperm transfer, storage, displacement, and utilization in Drosophila melanogaster. Genetics 47, 1719-1736. Leggett, M. C. (1993). Competitive interactions between seaweed flies. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. Leggett, M. C., Wilcockson, R. W., Day, T. H., Phillips, D. S., and Arthur, W. (1996). The genetic effects of competition in seaweed flies. Eiol. J. Linn. SOC.57, 1-11. Lewontin, R. C., and White, M. J. D. (1960). Interaction between inversion polymorphism of two chromosome pairs in the grasshopper, Moraba scurra. Evolution 14, 116-129. Majerus, M. E. N., O’Donald, P., Kearns, P. W. E., and Ireland, N. (1986). Genetics and evolution of female choice. Nature (London) 321, 164-167. Majerus, M. E. N., O’Donald, P., and Weir, J. (1982). Female mating preference is genetic. Nature (London) 350, 521-523. Maynard-Smith, J. (1958). Sexual selection. In “A Century of Darwin” (S. A. Barnett, ed.), pp. 231-244. Heinemann, London. Mayr, E. (1942). “Systematics and the Origin of Species.” Columbia University Press, New York. Mayr, E. (1963). “Animal Species and Evolution.” Harvard University Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. McAlpine, D. K. (1991). Review of the Australian kelp flies (Diptera: Coelopidae). Systemat. Entomol. 16, 29-84. McCauley, D. E., and Wade, M. J. (1978). Female choice and the mating structure of a natural population of the soldier beetle Chauliognarhus pennsylvanicus. Evolution 32, 771-775. Milinski, M., and Bakker, T. C. M. (1990). Female sticklebacks use male coloration in mate choice and hence avoid parasitized males. Nature (London) 344,330-333. Mbller, A. P. (1990). Effects of a haematophagous mite on the barn swallow (Hirundo rusrica): A test of the Hamilton and Zuk hypothesis. Evolution 44,771-784. Moller, A. P. (1994a). Male ornament size as a reliable cue to enhanced offspring viability in the barn swallow. Proc. Nafl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 91,6929-6932. Moiler, A. P. (1994b). Sexual selection in the barn swallow (Hirundo rusrica). IV. Patterns of fluctuating asymmetry and selection against asymmetry. Evolution 48,658-670. Moore, A. J. (1989). Sexual selection in Nauphoeta cinerea: Inherited mating preference? Eehav. Genet. 19,717-724. Moore, A. J . (1994). Genetic evidence for the good genes process of sexual selection. Eehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 35, 235-241. Nadel, H., and Luck, R. F. (1985). Span of female emergence and male sperm depletion in the female-biased, quasi-gregarious parasitoid, Pachycrepoideus vindemiae (Hymenoptera: Pteromalidae). Ann. Entomol. SOC. Am. 78,410-414. Norris, K. (1993). Heritable variation in a plumage indicator of viability in male great tits, Parus major. Nature (London) 362,537-539. O’Donald, P. (1962). The theory of sexual selection. Heredity 22,541-552. Pardo, M. C., Lopez-Leon, M. D., Hewitt, G. M., and Camacho, J. P. M. (1995). Female fitness is increased by frequent mating in grasshoppers. Heredity 74, 654-660. Parker, G. A. (1970a). The reproductive behaviour and the nature of sexual selection in Scatophaga stercoraria L. IV. Epigamic recognition and competition between males for the possession of females. Behaviour 37, 113-139.
56
THOMAS H. DAY AND
ANDRB s. GILBURN
Parker, G. A. (1970b). Sperm competition and its evolutionary consequences in the insects. Eiol. Rev. 45,525-567. Parker, G. A. (1983). Mate quality and mating decisions. In “Mate Choice” (P. Bateson, ed.), pp. 141-164. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom. Partridge, L., Green, A., and Fowler, K. (1987). Effects of egg production and of exposure to males on female survival in Drosophila rnelanogaster. J. Insect Physiol. 33,745-749. Philip, U. (1958). Genetics and cytology of the seaweed fly, Coelopa frigida. Proc. 10th Int. Congr. Genet., Montreal 2, 217. Philip, U. (1966). Chromosomal polymorphism in Coelopa frigida. Heredity 21, 167-168. Phillips, D. S., Leggett, M. C., Wilcockson, R. W., Day, T. H., and Arthur, W. (1995). Coexistence of competing species of seaweed flies: the role of temperature. Ecol. Entomol. 20365-74. Pitafi, K. D. (1991). Male mate choice in seaweedflies, Coelopa frigida. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. Pitafi, K. D., Hewitt, J. J., Gilbert, F. S., and Day, T. H. (1994). Male reproductive incompetence, fertility, and the cost of mating in male seaweed flies. Genet. (Life Sci. A d v . ) 13,9-18. Pitafi, K. D., Simpson, R., Stephen, J. J., and Day, T. H. (1990). Adult size and mate choice in seaweed flies. Heredity 65, 191-197. Pomiankowski, A. (1987). The handicap principle does work-Sometimes. Proc. R. SOC.Lond. E 231,123-145. Pomiankowski, A., Iwasa, Y.,and Nee, S. (1991). The evolution of costly preferences I. Fisher and biased mutation. Evolution 45, 1422-1430. Pomiankowski, A., and M~ller,A. P. (1995). A resolution of the lek paradox. Proc. R. Soc. Lond. E 260,21-29. Rager, F. J. (1985). Investigations on chemical attraction in seaweed flies (Coelopa frigida). Unpublished bachelor’s thesis, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. Rashid, M. A., and Prakash, A. (1972). Chemical characteristics of humic compounds isolated from some decomposed marine algae. J. Fish Res. Board Can. 29,55-60. Read, R. F. (1986). Female mate choice in pied flycatchers: An answer and a problem. Trends Ecol. Evol. 1, 85. Ridley, M. (1988). Mating frequency and fecundity in insects. Biol. Rev. 63, 509-549. Rowe, L., Arnqvist, G.,Sih, A., and Kruppa, J. J. (1994). Sexual conflict and the evolutionary ecology of mating patterns: Water striders as a model system. Trends Ecol. Evol. 9, 289-293. Ryan, M. J. (1985). “The Tlingara Frog.” Chicago University Press, Chicago. Ryan, M. J., and Causey, B. A. (1989). “Alternative” mating behavior in the swordtails Xiphophorus nigrensis and Xiphophorus pygmaeus. Eehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 24,341-348. Ryan, M. J., Fox, J. H., Wilcynski, W., and Rand, A. S. (1990). Sexual selection for sensory exploitation in the frog Physalaemus pustulosus. Nature (London) 343, 66-67. Ryan, M. J., and Rand, A. S. (1990). The sensory basis of sexual selection for complex calls in the tlingara frog, Physalaemus pustulosus (sexual selection for sensory exploitation). Evolution 44, 305-314. Ryan, M. J., and Wagner, W. E. (1987). Asymmetries in mating preferences between species: Female swordtails prefer heterospecific males. Science 236,595-597. Searcy, W. A. (1979). Female choice of mates: a general model for birds and its application to red-winged blackbirds (Agelaius phoeniceus). Am. Nat. 114,77-100. Shaw, K. (1995). Phylogenetic tests of the sensory exploitation model of sexual selection. Trends Ecol. Evol. 10, 117-120. Shrimpton, A. E., and Robertson, A. (1988a). The isolation of polygenic factors controlling bristle score in Drosophila melanogaster. I. Allocation of third chromosome sternopleural bristle effects to chromosome sections. Genetics 118, 437-443.
SEXUAL SELECTION IN SEAWEED FLIES
57
Shrimpton, A. E., and Robertson, A. (1988b). The isolation of polygenic factors controlling bristle score in Drosophila melanogaster. 11. Distribution of third chromosome bristle effects within chromosome sections. Genetics 118, 445-459. Shuster, S. M., and Wade, M. J. (1991). Equal mating success among male reproductive mating strategies in a marine isopod. Nature (London) 350, 608-610. Simmons, L. W. (1986). Female choice in the field cricket Gryllus bimaculatus (De Geer). Anim. Behav. 28, 906-912. Simmons, L. W. (1990). Nuptual feeding in tettigoniidae: Male costs and the rates of fecundity increase. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 27, 43-47. Smith, R. L. (Ed.). (1984). “Sperm Competition and the Evolution of Animal Mating Systems.” Academic Press, Orlando, Florida. Soffe, C. R. (1986). Chemical attraction in the seaweed fly Coelopa frigida. Unpublished bachelor’s thesis, University of Nottingham, United Kingdom. Spickett, S. G. (1963). Genetic and developmental studies of a quantitative character. Nature (London) 199,870-873. Thompson, U. (1951). Studieson thegeneticsandecologyof Coelopa frigida (Fab).Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Durham, United Kingdom. Thornhill, R. (1976). Sexual selection and nuptial feeding behaviour in Bitfacus apicalis. Am. Nat. 110, 529-548. Thornhill, R. (1979). Male and female sexual selection and the evolution of mating strategies in insects. I n “Sexual Selection and Reproduction Competition in Insects” (M. S. Blum and N. A. Blum, eds.), pp. 81-121. Academic Press, New York. Thornhill, R. (1980). Mate choice in Hylobittacus apicalis and its relations to some models of female choice. Evolution 34, 519-538. Thornhill, R. (1981). Panorpa (Mecoptera: Panorpidae) Scorpionflies: Systems for understanding resource-defense polygyny and alternative male reproductive efforts. Ann. Rev. Ecol. Sysr. 12, 355-386. Tobin. E. N., and Stoffolano, J. G . (1973). The courtship of Musca species found in North America. I. The house fly Musca domestica. Ann. Entomol. SOC. Am. 66, 1249-1257. Trickett, A. J., and Butlin, R. K. (1994). Recombination suppressors and the evolution of new species. Heredity 73, 339-345. Trivers, R. L. (1972). Parental investment and sexual selection. I n “Sexual Selection and the Descent of Man, 1871-1971” (B. Campbell, ed.), pp. 136-179. Heinemann, London. Verrell, P. A. (1989). Male mate choice for fecund females in a plethodontid salamander. Anim. Behav. 38, 1086-1088. von Schantz, T., Grahn, M., and Goransson, G. (1994). Intersexual selection and reproductive success in the pheasant, Phasianus colchicus. Am. Nat. 144,510-527. Wade, M. J., Patterson, H., Chang, N. W., and Johnson, N. A. (1994). Post-copulatory, prezygotic isolation in flour beetles. Heredity 72, 163-167. Walker, W. F. (1980). Sperm utilization strategies in non-social insects. Am. Nat. 115,780-799. Ward, P. (1993). Females influence sperm storage and use in the yellow dung fly, Scatophaga stercoraria (L.). Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 32, 313-319. Wells, K. (1977). Territoriality and male mating success in the green frog Rana clamitans. Ecology 58,750-762. Wilcockson, R. W., Crean, C . S., and Day, T. H. (1995). Heritability of a sexually selected character expressed in both sexes. Nature (London) 374, 158-159. Wilkinson, G. S., and Reillo, P. R. (1994). Female choice responds to selection on an exaggerated male trait in a stalk-eyed fly. Proc. R. SOC. Lond. B 255, 1-6. Wolstenholme, D. R., and Thoday, J. M. (1963). Effects of disruptive selection. VII. A third chromosome polymorphism. Heredity 18,413-432. Zahavi, A. (1975). Mate selection-a selection for a handicap. J. Theoret. Biol. 53,205-214.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN THE STUDY OF BEHAVIOR. VOL. 26
Vocal Learning in Mammals VINCENT M. JANIK A N D PETERJ. B. SLATER SCHOOL OF BIOLOGICAL A N D MEDICAL SCIENCES
UNIVERSITY OF ST. ANDREWS
ST. ANDREWS, FIFE, UNITED
KINGDOM
1. INTRODUCTION In this chapter we survey the occurrence of vocal learning in mammals and discuss possible reasons it has evolved. But first it is important to be clear about what we mean by “vocal learning.” The term has been used to describe the influence of learning on a variety of different aspects of vocal communication. Learning can affect the generation of sounds, their usage, and their comprehension. While modifications in sound generation as a result of experience can be described as learning sounds, those in comprehension and usage are rather different phenomena, which are perhaps better described as learning about sounds. Vocal learning, as we discuss it here, refers only to learning sounds, that is, to instances where the vocalizations themselves are modified in form as a result of experience with those of other individuals. Learning that affects usage and comprehension of sounds will be referred to as contextual learning as opposed to vocal learning. Contextual learning in relation to vocal communication is relatively common among mammals. The list of animals in which the utterance of a vocal signal has been brought under conditional control, i.e., which have learned to change the context in which they are using sounds, comprises rats (Lal, 1967), guinea pigs (Burnstein and Wolff, 1967), dogs (Salzinger and Waller, 1962), cats (Molliver, 1963), sea lions (Schusterman and Feinstein, 1965), primates (Myers, Horel, and Pennypacker, 1965; Randolph and Brooks, 1967; Wilson, 1975; Aitken and Wilson, 1979), and dolphins (Lilly, 1965). Other forms of contextual learning in vocal communication involve learning to recognize particular sounds, or learning to react to sounds differently as a result of experience. These are important ways in which learning may influence vocal communication, and the behavior associated with it, but they are not examples of vocal learning in the strict sense in which we use the term here. 59
Copyright 0 1997 by Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. w65-3454f97525.00
60
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
Some types of modification through learning are likely to be easier to achieve than others because different sound parameters are controlled by different mechanisms. Overall duration and amplitude of a sound can be altered by simple modifications of exhalation alone. A longer exhalation phase or higher air pressure while producing the sound is all that is required to cause such changes. For learning to occur here, only the activity of respiratory muscles need be modified by experience. Such changes in duration or amplitude do not affect the overall form of a call. O n the other hand, the detailed matching of a sound pattern requires much more complicated alterations. The fundamental frequency of a sound can be altered only if the activity of muscles controlling the vocal apparatus itself can be modified by experience. In tonal signals this is required to achieve change in the frequency contour of a call. Of course, other more complex processes can be involved in sound production. Rapid amplitude modulation, for example, can cause additional frequency bands in a call. Seemingly subtle changes that require a high degree of coordination between respiratory, laryngeal, and articulatory muscles, like those leading to differences in voice-onset time, can also be involved. Where possible we look at modifications in duration and amplitude and those in frequency parameters separately, and point to these different levels of motor control as they occur in the vocal learning of different groups. Vocal learning has been described only in birds and mammals, and even among these the evidence is patchy. It has been found in all songbirds (Oscines) studied to date (Kroodsma and Baylis, 1982), but appears not to occur in the closely related Suboscines (Kroodsma, 1984,1989). Convincing evidence comes from only two of the twenty or so other orders of birds: the hummingbirds (Apodiformes) (Baptista and Schuchmann, 1990; Gaunt, Baptista, Sanchez, and Hernandez, 1994) and the parrots (Psittaciformes) (Todt, 1975; Pepperberg, 1981). The three groups showing vocal learning are only distantly related to each other, suggesting that it has evolved among birds on at least three separate occasions. In mammals, the importance of vocal learning in our own species contrasts remarkably with the scarcity of evidence elsewhere. Part of the reason for this may be the lack of relevant studies. Absence of evidence for vocal learning in a particular species is certainly not evidence for its absence. In our review of the literature on vocal learning in mammals we attempt to determine the extent to which it occurs in species other than our own, and whether it is widespread or patchily distributed as in birds. This survey enables us to compare and contrast birds and mammals, and to consider the possible functional significance of vocal learning. It may perhaps also shed some light on why it occurs in humans. But first we discuss the methods
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
61
that have been used in various studies and the extent to which these can give unequivocal evidence for or against vocal learning.
11. EVIDENCE FOR VOCAL LEARNING There are several pitfalls in trying to show vocal learning in a particular species. A fundamental problem is the question of whether a particular call was in an animal’s repertoire before it was first noted. Apparent changes in the call repertoire of an animal often relate to other changes in its environment. Examples are alterations in social context, because of the introduction of foreign animals or a change in status, changes in the habitat that alter its sound transmission characteristics, or seasonal events that influence the diurnal behavior patterns of the animal. If a new call arises at the time of such an event, it could be because of a change in the frequency of occurrence of calls that were already present in the repertoire rather than vocal learning. But even a truly new call could arise for different reasons. Maturational processes or improvisation could be responsible, rather than copying from other individuals. Maturational processes lead to changes in vocal tract morphology that can influence sound characteristics. Thus, simple observations of changes in the call repertoire during ontogeny are difficult to interpret. Vocal learning may or may not be involved. Improvisation is another process that leads to the production of new calls. Various different mechanisms can be used to achieve improvisation, and vocal learning, again, may or may not be involved. One possibility is the production of completely new sounds through random sound generation. This form of improvisation would be an interesting case of vocal flexibility. According to our definition it does not involve vocal learning, however, since experience is not required. As we see in our survey, completely random sound production has so far never been the only possible explanation for an observed change in call structure. But there are other forms of improvisation that do involve learning. If an animal produces a completely new call that avoids overlap with calls of other individuals, experience might be used to achieve this avoidance. This would be a case of vocal learning according to our definition. A more restricted form of improvisation might involve a recombination of given subunits of a call. If these units can be produced on their own, this form of improvisation represents a special case of contextual learning. It is simply a matter of calls that are already present in an individual’s repertoire being produced in a new context. Finally, an animal could learn different parts of other individuals’
62
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. 0. SLATER
calls and combine them t o form a new call. This sort of improvisation would be a clear case of vocal learning. Vocal learning is obviously difficult to investigate if changes in calls do not result in matching those of other individuals or model sounds. The most clinching evidence for vocal learning comes from experiments in which animals are trained to imitate sounds that have not been in their repertoire before. If animals are able to copy sounds that are very different from sounds in their natural repertoire, like human speech or computergenerated sounds that were designed t o be different, vocal learning has clearly been demonstrated. In animals that are not capable of imitating such sounds, vocal learning within the natural repertoire can nevertheless be shown by rearing experiments, if infants that were raised with different acoustic stimuli are found to match the sounds they heard in detail. 'It is unlikely that selective reinforcement of randomly produced sounds could result in detailed matching of sounds produced by other animals. Such rearing experiments have commonly been carried out on birds, but few have been attempted on mammals. There are probably two main reasons for this. First, many of the mammalian species involved, such as whales and dolphins, are difficult to keep in the highly controlled acoustic environments necessary for such studies. Second, the species involved are highly sociable and subjecting individuals to experimental treatments involving deprivation likely to lead to suffering is not easy to justify. Because of these difficulties, for many mammals the evidence for or against vocal learning is more circumstantial. The main source of such less direct evidence comes from geographic variation in vocal signals, Where neighboring animals, or those in a social group, share sounds that differ from more distant individuals or those in other groups, vocal learning is a probable reason. This is most obvious where groups are not geographically isolated from each other. However, one has to be careful in interpreting such observations. Geographic variation in vocalizations can also arise because of ecological differences. Transmission characteristics of the environment may influence the extent to which a particular sound in an animal's repertoire is used. Differences in social structure in different locations could have the same effect on the usage of different call types that are present in the repertoire of all members of the species. Even different preferences for certain call versions can be the reason for geographic variation. In what he called action-based learning Marler (1991) suggested that an animal may produce only those sounds from its repertoire that are selectively reinforced by social stimulation. If there are different preferences for particular call types in different populations, action-based learning may result in geographic variation of their call repertoires. This would be a case of contextual learning, but not vocal
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
63
learning. Finally, if animals tend to stay in their maternal groups, genetic transmission is a possible reason for differences in call repertoires. Further research is needed in such cases to show vocal learning unequivocally.
111. SURVEY A. BATS In many bat species the isolation calls of pups exhibit vocal “signatures” (significant individual differences that remain constant over time) and these are used by mothers to find their offspring when they return to the colony to suckle them. Variation in the isolation calls of young big brown bats (Epresicus fuscus) is as great within as between colonies, and between twins as between less close relatives (Rasmuson and Barclay, 1992). The production of a completely new call could be achieved either by producing a call at random, which need not involve learning, by active avoidance of matching the calls of neighboring individuals, or by composing a call mixing different parts of heard calls. Although the last two mechanisms would involve learning, there is no conclusive evidence that they are involved here. However, it is interesting that there are closer similarities in echolocation calls within families than between them in this species (Masters, Raver, and Kazial, 1995), suggesting that echolocation and isolation call development are controlled by different mechanisms. In the lesser spear-nosed bat (Phyllostornus discolor) mothers and infants exchange calls when they reunite, and Esser and Schmidt (1989) suggest that the infant’s isolation call becomes progressively more like the mother’s call over the first few weeks of life. Esser (1994) argues that this is due to learning: he found that the calls of isolated pups that were played a taperecorded call over the first 50 days of life tended to become somewhat similar to it, while those of unstirnulated controls remained highly variable. However, one problem with isolation experiments is the general lack of stimulation. Bats might simply need auditory input of some nonspecific sort to develop normal calling behavior. An experiment with two groups hearing different calls would clarify whether learning is involved. The most convincing evidence for vocal learning in bats comes from the development of echolocation calls in greater horseshoe bats (Rhinolophus ferrurnequinurn) (Jones and Ransome, 1993). This call is an almost pure tone of around 83 kHz. Its sound frequency is higher in summer than in winter, but it also rises in the first year or two of life, and later falls off in old age. When young bats first start to hunt for themselves at a few weeks of age the frequency of the calls they adopt is strongly correlated with that
64
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
of their mother. In both males and females young bats with mothers over five years old have significantly lower echolocation calls than those born to younger mothers. This correlation with maternal age strongly suggests that learning is involved. B.
PINNIPEDS
Most authors place the pinnipeds in the order carnivora. They are classified into the true seals (phocids), the sea lions and fur seals (otariids), and the walruses (odobenids). Evidence for vocal learning has so far been found only in phocids. The most conclusive evidence that seals can learn new sounds comes from the imitation of human speech by captive animals. Two male harbor seals (Phoca vitulina) at the New England Aquarium were able to mimic speech sounds (Ralls, Fiorelli, and Gish, 1985). The more impressive of the two, Hoover, spontaneously developed imitations of a variety of phrases typically produced by visitors to the aquarium, such as “hello there” and “come over here,” as well as his own name and an imitation of laughter. In a controlled conditioning experiment, the second seal was trained to imitate its own name. Evidence in the wild is not so easily obtained. Geographical variation has been described in several species, but authors vary in whether they attribute this to learning. Thomas and Stirling (1983) examined Weddell seal (Leptonychotes weddelli) calls at Palmer Peninsula and McMurdo Sound, two sites on the edge of the Antarctic continent some 4000 km apart. Weddell seals have a large repertoire of vocalizations that they use extensively in the mating season (Thomas and Kuechle, 1982). Although some call types were found at both sites, each colony also had several unique ones. Marked spectral and temporal differences were found in some of the shared calls. Furthermore, seals at McMurdo had more call types in their repertoire than those at Palmer Peninsula. The authors suggest that the combination of fidelity to breeding sites and learning may account for these differences. The problem is to differentiate between these ideas: over a long period of time geographical isolation may lead to genetic differences affecting calls just as learning may give rise to call differences over shorter periods. Morrice, Burton, and Green (1994) compared vocal repertoires of two Weddell seal colonies located in adjacent fjords only 20 km apart. Despite the close proximity of these two colonies they had only 5 of 44 described vocalization types in common. Of the five shared call types two showed significant differences in their start or end frequency between colonies. Furthermore, a song type recorded in 1984 in one of the fjords (Green and Burton, 1988) could not be found again in 1989/1990 (Morrice et al.,
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
65
1994). Such strong dialects between adjacent colonies are rare in mammals and make vocal learning a likely explanation for their occurrence. All other studies on geographic variation in seal calls have concentrated on very distant sites. Thomas and Golladay (1995) studied geographic variation in leopard seal (Hydrurga leptonyx) underwater vocalizations at Palmer Peninsula and McMurdo Sound, the same sites as in the Weddell seal study by Thomas and Stirling mentioned earlier. They found that seals at Palmer Peninsula had more call types in their repertoire and that shared calls varied in frequency and time parameters between the two sites. Bearded seals (Erignathus barbatus) at six distant sites north of Canada and Alaska also differed in various temporal and spectral features of their underwater “trill” vocalizations (Cleator, Stirling, and Smith, 1989). Again, the authors suggest that this may be because of strong fidelity to specific breeding areas, but they do not discuss learning. Terhune (1994), in a study of harp seal (Phoca groenlandica) underwater calls in the Gulf of St. Lawrence and on Jan Mayen Island, sites some 3500 km apart, found spectral and temporal differences in shared call types. Each colony also had one unique call type not found at the other study site. Terhune attributes differences between sites to reproductive isolation. Given the possible role of learning, this seems somewhat sweeping. It is interesting, though, that different samples at each of the two sites were collected on occasions 18-20 years apart and only slight differences, probably attributable to sampling error, were found between the recordings at the same place (Terhune, 1994). This suggests that call repertoires at a particular place are conservative in a way that would be less likely if learning were involved. However, harp seals can live up to 35 years (Reeves, Stewart, and Leatherwood, 1992), so that 20 years might not be enough time to pick up changes caused by copying errors in a learning process. Differences in the pattern of northern elephant seal (Miroungu angustirostris) threat vocalizations between several islands off California were interpreted by Le Boeuf and Peterson (1969a) as evidence for learning. There were marked differences in the pulse rate of threat calls between the colonies, one of which, with its distinct dialect, had been in existence only for a few years. However, later studies showed that, even though there were still clear individual differences in pulse rates, colony differences had disappeared (Le Boeuf and Petrinovich, 1974; Shipley, Hines, and Buchwald, 1981). Note that to change pulse rate the animal has to produce the same sound in quicker or slower succession. It does not change the form of the call. Therefore, this would not qualify as an example of vocal learning according to our definition, unless pulse sequences represent minimum units of call production and single pulses cannot be produced on their own. However, the disappearance of geographic differences in calling behavior
66
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
is an interesting phenomenon that is relevant for our interpretation of geographic variation in other cases. By the end of the 19th century, northern elephant seals were reduced to less than 100 animals all living on Isla de Guadalupe 243 km west of Baja California (Bartholomew and Hubbs, 1960). The population was then protected and started to grow again and to recolonize old breeding sites (Le Boeuf and Petrinovich, 1974). There are two ways in which differences between colonies could have arisen in the first phase of recolonization. The first is a founder effect. The small number of males that emigrated to recolonize a particular breeding site could have had pulse rates on average different from those of the original colony. Once an elephant seal has chosen a breeding site in the first year of its reproductive life, it tends to return to that same site each year (Le Boeuf, Ainley, and Lewis, 1974). A difference in pulse rates between colonies would therefore be likely to persist as long as no further migration occurred. The second possibility is that a few males monopolized most of the females and spread their pulse rate, either through being imitated by younger animals or through genetic transmission. If young males return to their natal rookery to breed, a particular pulse rate could thus establish itself and persist. In small colonies only a few males do indeed monopolize all the females and are the only ones that breed (Le Boeuf, 1974), but there is no clear evidence on whether males return to their natal rookeries to breed. Dispersion from the island of birth after 1968 was considerable (Le Boeuf et ul., 1974), but of 400 males tagged as juveniles on Aiio Nuevo Island between 1964 and 1969 none were sighted at any of the other breeding sites in their first breeding season at the age of 5-6 years (Le Boeuf, 1974). If there is continuing immigration from other colonies, pulse rate in a recolonized site would change and eventually the differences in pulse rate between colonies would disappear. The subsequent studies during rapid population expansion showed this to be the case. Such a process would occur as long as there was no isolating mechanism between populations, whether or not learning has a role in pulse rate development. The longevity of elephant seals made it possible to witness these changes occurring. The observed differences cannot therefore be regarded as a result of learning. C. CETACEANS Toothed Whales (Odontocetes) As with seals, the smaller cetaceans can be kept in captivity, and observations there provide some evidence of vocal imitation. There is anecdotal evidence, largely from keepers, that these animals can modify the broadband frequency squeaks that they produce so as to imitate human speech (Tursiops truncufus, Caldwell and Caldwell, 1972; Delphinupterus leucas,
1.
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
67
Eaton, 1979). The most extensive experimental evidence comes from the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncutus), as this is the cetacean most commonly kept in captivity. They produce whistles, clicks, and burst-pulsed sounds that are all modifiable by experience. Most of the evidence of vocal learning concerns their whistles. Caldwell and Caldwell (1972) recorded a case of spontaneous whistle mimicry when their study animal matched a whistle that was being used to test its sound localization abilities. Reiss and McCowan (1993) also found bottlenose dolphins mimicking whistle sounds spontaneously. Two young males were given control over stimuli by means of an underwater keyboard. Pressing a symbol on this released a sound linked to it and also the presentation to the dolphin of an object or activity, such as a ball or being rubbed. The animals learned to mimic the sounds and later produced them frequently without having pressed the key to hear the appropriate stimulus, but often while playing with the object or engaged in the activity with which it had been linked. When it comes to training, there is no doubt that dolphin whistles can be modified by experience. Richards, Wolz, and Herman (1984) trained a dolphin to imitate computer-generated sounds using food or petting by the trainer as rewards. The animal matched a variety of sounds that were quite different from those it produced before the training. In some cases it produced passable copies the first time a sound was introduced. In further training the animal was rewarded for producing particular whistles when specific objects were shown to it, and would do so with a high degree of reliability. Thus, the dolphin effectively learned vocal labels for those objects. In a subsequent series of experiments, Sigurdson (1993) also successfully trained two dolphins to match computer-generated whistles. A few studies have described the changes in whistle repertoires of infant bottlenose dolphins over time (Caldwell and Caldwell, 1979; Sayigh, 1992; McCowan and Reiss, 1995). However, even though the species is clearly capable of vocal learning, the role of vocal learning in whistle development of infants has not been demonstrated so far. Wang and his colleagues (Wang, Wiirsig, and Evans, 1995) found marked geographic variation in spectral and temporal features of bottlenose dolphin whistles in the wild at sites only a few hundred kilometers apart. Each site had its own resident population with some individuals moving between them. Since dolphins produce individually specific whistle contours, the study did not look at different call types separately, but simply compared general parameters like start and end frequency in all recorded whistles at each site. Experimental work by Moore and Pawloski (1990) provided evidence that vocal flexibility applies to click sounds used in echolocation as well. They succeeded in training a bottlenose dolphin to shift the peak frequency
68
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
of its broad-band ultrasonic echolocation clicks. The anecdotal evidence of dolphins mimicking speech sounds also suggests that clicks can be modified, as they use very rapid click trains called burst-pulsed sounds to produce these imitations. Turning to larger odontocetes, there is also evidence in favor of vocal learning. Pods of killer whales (Orcinus orca) off British Columbia have repertoires of 7-17 call types, which appear to be shared by most individuals in the pod (Ford and Fisher, 1983; Ford, 1991). Groups of pods can be placed in “clans,” which share some call types, although shared types still have pod-specific features; there is no sharing of calls between clans. New pods appear to form by splitting of preexisting ones, with slow divergence of calls thereafter, though there is evidence that pod repertoires can persist for 25 years with little change. Since all animals within a pod are closely related (Bigg, Olesiuk, Ellis, Ford, and Balcomb, 1990), such differences could be caused by genetic differences. However, Ford (1991) reports that individuals occasionally seem to mimic the calls of other pods, suggesting that learning is involved. Studies on captive killer whales have not addressed the question of vocal learning directly. However, Bain (1986) gave an anecdotal report that a female killer whale from Iceland started to mimic calls of a female from British Columbia, Canada, after they had been housed together for a few years. Differences in the vocal repertoire of killer whales between such distant sites are larger than those between sympatric pods (Awbrey, Evans, Jehl, Thomas, and Leatherwood, 1982). However, no spectrographic analysis was provided in Bain’s study. Bowles, Young, and Asper (1988) described the vocal development of a captive killer whale calf, but the role of vocal learning in call development could not be addressed. As discussed earlier, changes in the vocal repertoire during ontogeny can be maturational, genetic, or learned. Van Heel, Kamminga, and van der Toorn (1982) reported an experiment in which a killer whale seemed to spontaneously imitate computer-generated tonal signals that were used in training the animal to perform different tasks. However, these signals were designed to resemble the whale’s own vocalizations, so that vocal learning was not necessary to produce them. 2. Baleen Whales (Mysticetes)
Perhaps the best known example of vocal learning among whales in the wild is that of male humpback whales (Megapreru novaeangliae) in which individuals produce long and elaborate songs lasting up to 20 minutes before repetition (Payne and McVay, 1971). Recordings of the songs of this species off Bermuda over a period of 18 years showed that they changed with time but that at any one time the songs of different individuals were
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
69
similar (Payne and Payne, 1985). Detailed study of songs recorded around Hawaii in two singing seasons (mid-November to mid-May) demonstrated progressive change from month to month through the season, with little difference between the end of one season and the start of the next, the period when the whales are away on their feeding grounds and sing little (Payne, Tyack, and Payne, 1983). This suggests that change is an active process rather than one of forgetting sounds with the passage of time. Nor can the changes be attributed to changing group membership, as Guinee, Chu, and Dorsey (1983) obtained two recordings from each of three identified individuals and found both that they changed and that they did so in parallel with each other. These detailed short-term changes, both within and between individuals, can be accounted for only if animals are imitating one another. However, songs of different humpback whale populations differ completely (Winn, Thompson, Cummings, Hain, Hudnall, Hays, and Steiner, 1981). But even though this species is clearly capable of vocal learning, geographic variation could have evolved because of genetic isolation between populations in different oceans. Bowhead whales (Balaena mysticetus) studied during their spring migration have also been found to sing (Cummings and Holliday, 1987). Their song consists of repeated phrases that can be categorized into one to three themes. A song lasts about one minute but is usually repeated several times. As with humpback whales, all animals in the study population off Alaska sang the same song but the song was different in each singing season (Wursig and Clark, 1993). Cummings and Holliday (1987) always heard one animal singing at a time but another one often started as soon as the first stopped. It is not clear yet whether individuals change their song over the season, but, if so, it would be strong evidence for vocal learning. D. PRIMATES As we get closer to humans, one might imagine that the evidence for vocal learning would become more and more impressive. As we shall see, this is far from being the case. 1.
Monkeys
“There is no conclusive evidence of vocal learning in monkeys” (Snowdon, 1990, p. 225). Perhaps the strongest evidence against vocal learning is in squirrel monkeys (Saimiri sciureus), where isolation-reared animals (Winter, Handley, Ploog, and Schott, 1973), and even deafened ones (Talmage-Riggs, Winter, Ploog, and Mayer, 1972), show normal vocal development. In the squirrel monkey there is also a good example of a dialect that is not based on learning. Two distinct phenotypes of squirrel monkeys,
70
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
the Roman Arch and the Gothic Arch population, named after characteristics of their supraorbital color pattern, show differences in the structure of their isolation calls (Winter, 1969). The unique call structure of each population was present in infants from the first day of their lives (Lieblich, Symmes, Newman, and Shapiro, 1980). Given the normal vocal development of both deafened and isolated individuals, these differences are clearly not based on vocal learning. Furthermore, Struhsaker (1970), who investigated geographic variation in the call structure of vervet monkeys (Cercopithecus uethiops) in various parts of Africa, could not find any differences between populations. Marmosets and tamarins have been studied extensively, mainly by Snowdon and his colleagues. In the field, Hodun, Snowdon, and Soini (1981) measured four parameters of the long call of saddle-backed tamarins (Suguinus fuscicollis). They found differences in the long calls of different subspecies, with that of one individual having features both of its own subspecies, S. f nigrifrons, and of an adjacent one, S. f illigeri, suggesting that learning might be involved. To find out whether this animal could have been a hybrid between the two subspecies, the same four call parameters were measured from two known hybrids of these subspecies in captivity. The hybrids developed a long call with one of the sound frequency parameters being closest to that of a third subspecies, which they had been able to hear in the room where they were housed, while the other parameters resembled those of nigrifrons. The wild animal, on the other hand, resembled the illigeri subspecies in this frequency parameter and in its call duration. The data were not given in detail, and concern up to only 12 calls of each of the three different animals, so it is difficult to assess whether differences in long-call structure reflected vocal learning, genetic differences, or different motivational states during recording sessions. Maeda and Masataka (1987) found variation in long calls of red-chested moustached tamarins (Suguinus lubiutus Zubiutus), that had been caught at two sites 27 km apart. In a subsequent study, a third group, which was caught only 15 km from one of these sites, produced a third call variant (Masataka, 1988). Each particular variant of the call was used by animals living within 6 to 15 km of each of the original catching sites, while animals from further away used different variants. Masataka (1988) reported that there were no geographical barriers between sites where different call variants were found, but there are no data on whether interbreeding between these sites occurs. It is also possible that tamarins adjust their calls according to the habitat by using different forms that are already present in their repertoire or that the variations found belong to particular matrilines. In either case learning need not be involved.
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
71
In a more recent study, Elowson and Snowdon (1994) showed that members of pygmy marmoset (Cebuella pygmaea) colonies modified the structure of their individually distinctive trill contact calls after being placed in a cage adjacent to another colony. The modifications did not result in converging or diverging call structure. This, again, could be evidence for learning, but introducing new animals, even if contact is only acoustic, might shift social relationships within and between colonies. Thus, the modification of calling behavior over time might not be due to learning but could be related to a change in the role or dominance structure of each colony. In this example it is not clear whether call variants that were found after the introduction of the other colony were in the call repertoire before. They simply could have occurred less often because of the different social status of the individual before the introduction. Whether or not macaque food calls are learned has been the cause of some controversy. Field observations by Green (1975), in which he found differences between troops in Japanese macaques (Macaca fuscafa), suggested that food calls might be learned. However, in all three locations studied by Green, extensive food provisioning might have conditioned monkeys to produce only a particular version of their food call from a range present in their repertoire before provisioning started. Subsequently, Masataka and Fujita (1989) carried out cross-fostering experiments between Japanese and rhesus monkeys (Macaca mulafta),and found that the young developed calls more typical of their foster species. However, their result was based on only three animals that might have been atypical (Snowdon, 1990). Owren, Dieter, Seyfarth, and Cheney (1992) failed to replicate Masataka and Fujita’s result. They argue that the calls of adult females of the two species vary a great deal and that there was no significant difference between species in any of the measures used. Even though infants of both species differed significantly in several parameters, calls developed by the cross-fostered infants fell within the distribution range for normally raised members of their own species in most cases. Despite this, it seemed that cross-fostered Japanese macaques did become more similar to rhesus monkeys in several frequency measures after 2 years of age. Given the variability of calls within species and the overlap between them, this is not an easy system in which to test for vocal learning. In training experiments it has been shown that rhesus monkeys can be conditioned to increase overall call duration and amplitude (Sutton, Larson, Taylor, and Lindeman, 1973). Therefore, primates seem to have control over these basic call parameters. However, as pointed out earlier, such shifts do not require any changes in the setting of the sound production organ, but only a longer or stronger expiration phase. In another report about these experiments, Larson, Sutton, Taylor, and Lindeman (1973)
72
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
described changes in the spectral components of the trained calls in the 58 kHz range. It is important to note that these changes were not a requirement of the conditioning procedure but occurred independently of the selective rewards used in the experimental setup. Therefore, they do not represent evidence for vocal learning in the frequency domain. Larson et al. argue that they reflect a decrease in stress over the period of the experiment. Hauser (1992) found differences in the “coo” social contact vocalization of rhesus monkeys between different matrilines on Cay0 Santiago. Again, it is not clear whether these are caused by learning, genetic predisposition, or differences in parental behavior that might affect the extent to which a particular call version in an animal’s repertoire is used. Hauser mentioned that some animals changed their coo calls after migrating into another group, but did not provide further details. As in other studies, such changes could also be the result of a change in usage of calls that were present in the animal’s repertoire before. 2.
Gibbons
Among the primates, gibbons are undoubtedly the most elaborate singers. Both male and female sing, and they often do so in the form of coordinated duets in which the female, with her “great call,” may take the leading role. Gibbons are monogamous and territorial, and the song duets are assumed to function in territory maintenance and pair bonding. In playback experiments, Mitani (1985) showed that females do not approach singing males, but males and females react strongly toward new duets in or close to their territory. Despite their complexity and intricacy, gibbon songs are highly stereotyped with little geographic variation (Marshall and Marshall, 1976). The major role of experience in the development of gibbon vocalizations lies not in copying but in coordination between members of a pair. A newly introduced pair of siamangs (Hylobates syndactylus) completed their great call sequences on only 24% of occasions, the songs terminating because one or the other animal produced a call that was inappropriately placed or timed. However, in recordings made after they had been together for 18 weeks, some 79% of sequences were completed (Maples, Haraway, and Hutto, 1989). There is also evidence, some anecdotal (Marshall and Marshall, 1976) some better documented (Geissmann, 1983; Srikosamat, 1982), that females deprived of a male or with one that does not sing can produce the male contribution to the duet as well as their own. When it comes to development in gibbons, there is no evidence that individuals copy from each other, but there is strong evidence for a genetic influence. This comes from hybrids in nature and in captivity. White-handed gibbons (Hylobates lar) and pileated gibbons ( H . pileafus) hybridize in a contact zone in central Thailand. Brockelman and Schilling (1984) found
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
73
that daughters of mixed parentage develop great calls unlike those of their mothers, but intermediate between the two species. This occurs despite the fact that the calls develop during mutual singing sessions between mothers and daughters. A similar conclusion has been reached from studies of hybrids between the two species in captivity (Geissmann, 1984,1987). Tenaza (1985) also found that the song of two young, a male and a female, from a cross between H. lar and H. muelleri included characteristics typical of their own sex in both species despite having heard those elements from only one of these, that of their own sex parent. Although these hybrid studies appear to argue strongly against a role of learning in gibbon song development, Marler and Mitani (1988) press for caution. If, as has been suggested in birds, young animals are born with a species-specific template that constrains what they will learn, the template in a hybrid might not be well matched to the sounds it experiences, so that it fails to learn parental calls. Mitani (1987) also presented evidence that agile gibbons (Hylobates agilis) show geographic variation in their calls. The populations involved were on separate islands very distant from one another. Therefore, genetic differences could be responsible. Further studies focusing on possible dialects in the wild are needed to evaluate whether some learning could be involved in gibbon call development.
3. Great Apes Of the great apes, the vocalizations of chimpanzees have been the most extensively studied (e.g., Marler and Tenaza, 1977). It was natural that those interested in whether apes could master language first turned to humans’ closest relatives. Although subsequent efforts with various media, ranging from sign language to computer keyboards, met with considerable success, early attempts to “teach chimps to speak” were almost fruitless. Vicki, the common chimpanzee (Pan troglodytes) trained by Hayes (1951), eventually seemed to produce four English words after 7 years of language training. However, no data on the similarity of these sounds with actual words were presented. The bonobo (P. paniscus) called Kanzi, studied by Hopkins and Savage-Rumbaugh (1991), developed a variety of speciestypical vocalizations but, despite extensive interactions with humans, only four calls not shared with control animals. However, the different rearing of Kanzi could have delayed the development of certain bonobo calls, so that these four sounds could have been left over from his call repertoire as an infant. Therefore, they do not represent evidence for vocal learning in bonobos either. When it comes to imitation of conspecific sounds, there is little evidence. Mitani, Hasegawa, Gros-Louis, Marler, and Byrne (1992) describe differences in the pant hoot of chimps between two sites in Tanzania, Mahale
74
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
and Gombe. In a subsequent analysis, Mitani and Brandt (1994) demonstrated that population differences in these calls were largely encoded in only one parameter, namely frequency range. The differences seem, however, quite subtle, which may explain why there are no other reports of geographical variation in chimp sounds. Mitani et al. (1992) argue that these differences could result, not from copying, but from contextual learning stemming from the selective reinforcement within each population if an animal produces sounds that match the population norm. This would be what Marler (1991) called action-based learning, in which an individual produces only those sounds from its repertoire that have been selectively reinforced by social stimulation. In this case the difference in call structure between recording sites would have been caused by different preferences for certain call versions by each population. Alternatively, food provisioning by humans at both sites may have had a conditioning effect that resulted in the observed differences, if individual humans were more responsive to certain call variants. Again, this may have led the animals to use another call variant that was present in their repertoire before without vocal learning being involved. Mitani and Brandt (1994) presented interesting evidence that male chimpanzees match the acoustic characteristics of each other’s pant hoots when calling together. This was statistically significant for the one individual for which a sufficient sample size was available. Depending on its chorusing partner this animal changed the spectral structure of its calls to match those of the other caller. Further research is needed to investigate the flexibility of pant hoot matching and assess whether these changes are learned or a side effect of subtle differences in calling contexts. E. OTHER MAMMALIAN ORDERS A few studies of other mammalian orders have shown similar phenomena to those discussed for primates, although they have not so often been interpreted as evidence for vocal learning. Romand and Ehret (1984) studied the development of sound production in the domestic cat (Felis catus). To investigate the influence of auditory feedback, motivation, and ontogenetic changes in the vocal tract, they compared calls of normally raised, deafened, and isolated kittens. The three groups differed in certain call parameters but individual variability was great. The authors interpret these differences as resulting from the lack of auditory feedback in deafened kittens and from different motivational states in isolated ones. Call parameters of isolated individuals indicated a delayed development of the vocal apparatus and a higher stress level than in normally raised kittens. Romand and Ehret come to the conclusion that call development in cats “follows
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
75
a ‘self-centered strategy’ rather than an ‘open and environmentally dependent’ one” (Romand and Ehret, 1984, p. 648). Molliver (1963) successfully trained cats to increase the duration of their calls in an operant conditioning procedure. As discussed earlier, this does not require any changes in the setting of the sound production organ, but only a longer expiration phase. It is a demonstration of a limited form of vocal learning that has also been found in primates. Slobodchikoff and Coast (1980) found geographic variation in various time parameters of alarm calls given by groups of Gunnison’s prairie dogs (Cynomys gunnisoni) living 13 km apart. An alarm call in this species is a series of several barks. Groups differed in total call length, number of barks per call, duration of each bark, and the time intervals between barks in a series. Again, these parameters describe the timing and duration of a call but not its frequency structure. Pikas (Ochotona princeps) in the United States also show geographic variation in duration and in the fundamental frequency of their short calls (Somers, 1973; Conner, 1982). The two populations studied by Somers are geographically separated by the Colorado River. However, there is an overlap zone at the source of the river where he found individuals with calls intermediate between the two variants. Conner (1982) only found differences between widely separated populations. He argued that variations do not represent vocal dialects but are the result of independent evolutionary histories. As with other cases of geographic variation, further studies are needed to clarify the origin of these differences. Finally, a recent study on banner-tailed kangaroo rats (Dipodomys spectabilis) has shown that they adjust their footdrumming signatures to differ from new neighbors after they change their territory (Randall, 1995). This is an interesting case of plasticity in sound production, although it concerns signals that are not produced by the vocal apparatus and concerns only the timing of signals, so it is not strictly relevant to our purpose.
IV. FUNCTIONAL SIGNIFICANCE AND ORIGIN
In this section we will consider possible reasons why vocal learning evolved in mammals. In discussing this it is important to bear in mind two separate problems. First is the question of why vocal learning arose in the first place, the answer to which may be far back in time and within a different functional context to that in which it occurs today. Second is the more accessible question of why vocal learning persists in certain species. Similar hypotheses may be relevant to both contexts, so that a discussion
76
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. 9. SLATER
of all possible reasons for vocal learning may shed light on both its origin and its current advantages for a particular species. We will consider each of the main hypotheses that have been put forward to account for vocal learning. Earlier discussions have been largely in relation to birds, as vocal learning in this group has been extensively studied. Before discussing the possible relevance of each hypothesis to mammals, we will make brief mention of how these hypotheses measure up to the bird evidence.
A. INTERSEXUALSELECTION In many animals male songs attract females. If a longer or more elaborate song is more effective in this respect, then sexual selection could result in the evolution of very complex displays. Different mechanisms could account for an increased response in the female. Complex auditory input might lead to greater stimulation of the reproductive system of a female or it might simply prevent habituation by females. From a functional perspective, song complexity might be a cue used by females to assess male fitness, if it is costly for males to achieve complexity. Whatever its causal and functional basis, however, if complexity is advantageous, vocal learning may be favored as a means of achieving it. The copying of song elements from conspecifics allows an animal to incorporate new elements into its song, while still retaining the species-specific pattern. The development of completely new sounds without such copying would risk the loss of species recognition. Furthermore, the generation of vocal complexity through an increase in genetic information would undoubtedly be a slow and costly process. Thus, vocal learning could well have been favored as a means of acquiring an elaborate song. Many songbirds have complex song repertoires built up by learning, and sexual selection has frequently been proposed as a reason for this complexity. In line with this suggestion there is evidence that female birds of various species solicit more to repertoires of songs than to single song types (e.g., red-winged blackbird, Agelaius phoeniceus, Searcy, 1988; starling, Sturnus vulgaris, Eens, Pinxten, and Verheyen, 1991), and that the reproductive system of female canaries (Serinus canaria) may be more stimulated by complex than by simple songs (Kroodsma, 1976). In the field, male sedge warblers (Acrocephafusschoenobaenus) with large syllable repertoires have been found to attract females earlier than those with smaller ones (Catchpole, 1980). Thus, several lines of evidence point to the importance of sexual selection in the generation of complex song repertoires in birds.
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
77
Turning to mammals, we know little about the functions of many male vocal displays. In phocids they are often highly varied, and several observations suggest that some of them may be sexual displays. During the mating season male harbor seals produce repetitive vocal displays underwater for up to several hours (Hanggi and Schusterman 1994; Van Parijs, Thompson, Tollit, and MacKay, in press). Male Weddell seals defend small underwater territories against other males; they sing on these territories and stop doing so if a female enters the territory to mate (Bartsh, Johnston, and Siniff, 1992). A large part of the species’ repertoire is produced only by males (Thomas and Kuechle, 1982). Bearded seals and leopard seals, the vocalizations of which vary geographically, also produce underwater songs in the breeding season (Ray, Watkins, and Burns, 1969; Stirling and Siniff, 1979). Further studies of these and other “singing” seals, like the crabeater seal (Lobodon carcinophagus) (Stirling and Siniff, 1979), the Ross seal (Ommatophoca rossi) (Watkins and Ray, 1985), and the walrus (Odobenus rosmarus) (Stirling, Calvert, and Spencer, 1987), should clarify the role of vocal learning in the acquisition of song. Behavioral observations of humpback whales, and the fact that it seems to be only males that sing (Tyack and Whitehead, 1983) and then mainly during the breeding season, suggest that song is a reproductive advertisement display and/or a territorial one. However, even though humpback whale and bowhead whale songs are very complex and change over the singing season, all males in a population sing the same song a t any particular time. We can only speculate on the origin of this phenomenon but, if songs are used to attract females, sexual selection holds a possible explanation. If a maximal response in the female was elicited by presenting the same acoustic pattern repetitively, the singing behavior of humpback whales could represent a communal vocal display that increases the responsiveness of females. The synchronized changes in song over time combined with song complexity could then be a result of conflicting pressures on individual males to make their own song more attractive by introducing new variations, but to maintain a communal display at the same time. Although whales are not easy to study, there is a clear need for more information about how their songs relate to other aspects of their behavior if we are to understand their functional significance. Other baleen whales that produce their sounds in repetitive songlike sequences are fin whales (Buluenopteru physulus) (Watkins, Tyack, Moore, and Bird, 1987) and blue whales (Balaenopteru musculus) (Cummings and Thompson, 1971). However, mysticetes also produce a variety of other social sounds. Repetitive sequences of the same sound could also be used to coordinate group movements. Since low-frequency sounds of whales can travel long distances (e.g., Cummings and Thompson, 1971), it is hard to
78
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
determine whether widely spaced animals belong to one social group or are solitary individuals that happen to be within hearing range. The calls of some bats, like the hammer-headed bat (Hypsignachus monstrosus) (Bradbury, 1977) and the African false vampire bat (Cardioderma COT) (McWilliam, 1987), are used to attract females or act in territorial defense. Studies of whether and to what extent these species learn their calls would be interesting given the small amount of information on vocal learning in bats. B. INTRASEXUAL SELECTION A N D RESOURCE DEFENSE
Vocal learning could also have evolved in relation to territory maintenance and defense. In birds, small song repertoires are often used in matched countersinging between neighboring males on their territories, and the precise matching of songs that learning allows may confer a reproductive advantage. Payne, Payne, and Doehlert (1988) showed that male indigo buntings (Passerina cyanea) that share songs with neighbors do better in various measures of reproduction, including fledging more young. Song learning might enable birds to mimic established and successful individuals (Payne, 1981). This could discourage intruders and result in improved intruder detection if shared songs cannot be reproduced by foreign birds (see also Section IV,D on group recognition). Furthermore, the development of varied song repertoires, which seems to depend on learning, as they have been recorded only in species where vocal learning occurs, can also have a deterrent effect as far as intruders looking for territories are concerned. This has been shown most clearly in the speaker replacement experiments carried out by Krebs, Ashcroft, and Webber (1978) on great tits (Parus major). Krebs (1976) argued that this might be because repertoires give the impression that there are several birds present rather than just one. If repertoire size is a measure of fitness, it could also be used to assess a male’s fighting ability in territorial conflicts. In animals that defend territories it is often unclear whether females choose a particular male because of his vocal display or because of territory quality. In contrast to many terrestrial animals, underwater territories of marine mammals do not hold useful resources for the raising of offspring. The mating system of most singing marine mammals resembles more that of a lek. Therefore, if singing territories are positioned on the migration routes of females, the choice of a territory might have a considerable influence on breeding success. In that case vocal learning might have evolved through intrasexual selection. In marine mammals, there is some evidence that song might be used in male spacing on the breeding grounds. Weddell seals defend small underwater territories next to female haul-out
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
79
sites while they are singing (Watkins and Schevill, 1968; Bartsh et al., 1992). Distances between singing humpback whales are about 2.4 times bigger than between nonsinging whales, suggesting a spacing function of song (Frankel, Clark, Herman, and Gabriele, 1995). No evidence for vocal learning has been found in mammals that defend females or resource-based territories against other males. Examples are elephant seals and gibbons. Elephant seals defend breeding territories around their harems on land and produce threat vocalizations to defend these territories against other males (Le Boeuf and Peterson, 1969b). In gibbons song is thought to function in territory maintenance and pair bonding but not in mate attraction (Mitani, 1985, 1988). In social groups vocal learning could be used in a variety of ways to gain access to resources. In highly social animals the ability to match sound features of other individuals might help to establish and maintain social relationships, or even raise the possibility of deception through the mimicry of sounds made by dominant animals. In bottlenose dolphins the formation of alliances between males has been observed (Connor, Smolker, and Richards, 1992). Imitation of their signature whistles could be used to maintain social bonds or deceive other individuals alike. In primates increasing sociality and the formation of complex social relationships could provide reasons for vocal learning to arise. Chimpanzees are known to form alliances against other group members (Harcourt, 1988) and the behavior of monkeys in social interactions sometimes involves what appears to be deception (reviewed in Cheney and Seyfarth, 1990). However, they do not seem to be capable of vocal learning. There are two possible explanations for this difference between primates and cetaceans. It could mean that vocal learning did not evolve because of advantages in social interactions. Alternatively, it may be because primates use other modes of communication (e.g., facial/gestural displays) to achieve similar results. Poor underwater visibility and the limited ability to use gestures and facial expressions in cetaceans could have favored the use of vocal communication more than in primates. C . INDIVIDUAL RECOGNITION
Nottebohm (1972), in a classic paper on the origins of vocal learning, argued against individual recognition being an important factor in the evolution of vocal learning in birds. Learning, as he points out, often leads to precise similarities between animals, and these would hinder rather than aid individual recognition. Furthermore, slight individual differences in the morphology of the sound production apparatus within a population, if consistent over time, usually introduce enough variability in unlearned sounds to allow individual recognition (Beer, 1969). Individual recognition
80
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
on the basis of simple unlearned calls has been demonstrated to occur in many bird species, such as auks (Tschanz, 1968) and gulls (Beer, 1969), in which vocal learning is unknown. However, set against these arguments, there are ways in which vocal learning may enhance differences between individuals and, especially in high-background-noise environments, this may be important as an aid to discrimination. Even though birds learn their songs from conspecifics, the frequently learn different songs from different individuals so that their repertoires differ. New elements may also appear in their songs as a result of copying errors, or a bird may combine elements from different songs to form a new song (Slater and Ince, 1979). Thus, learning can lead both to new repertoires and to new songs within a bird’s repertoire, so that it is not correct to assume that learning necessarily leads to greater call similarity between individuals. Indeed, one route to individually specific calls may be by combining features learned from several other animals. All groups of mammals that show evidence for vocal learning do live in high-background-noise environments. Bat roosts, in which thousands of animals vocalize in the same frequency range, are one example, sea mammals provide another (Spiesberger and Fristrup, 1990). Additionally, in diving animals air-filled cavities that are involved in sound production get distorted with changing pressure. This could change voice characteristics considerably and mask individually specific cues that could otherwise be used for individual recognition (Tyack, 1991). If individual recognition requires more variability in calls than arises from differences in vocal tract morphology, or if such cues become unreliable during diving, improvisation rather than vocal learning might provide the answer. But there are theoretical reasons for thinking that this way of producing a completely new behavior pattern is a very difficult task. Every pattern that is generated reflects in some way the mechanism by which it is produced. For this reason, computer programs can create only pseudo-random numbers (Morgan, 1984). Even though some birds seem to produce completely new songs in their ontogeny (Marler, Mundinger, Waser, and Lutjen, 1972), improvisation has rarely been reported, suggesting that composing a new sound out of parts of others is an easier way to produce a unique individually specific call. It also ensures that the new call is not accidentally similar to that of other group members. Vocal learning may thus lead to individual distinctiveness by allowing the individual to produce a distinctive new call type that has not been present in the repertoire of its social group before. Examples of mammals that seem to make their signals different from those of other group members are dolphins (Caldwell and Caldwell, 1965,1968), big brown bats (Rasmuson and Barclay, 1992) and banner-tailed kangaroo rats (Randall, 1995). However, if individual recognition is why vocal learn-
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
81
ing evolved, it must be supposed that there are benefits to the individual in allowing itself to be identified. Investigations of vocal learning in bats have concentrated on call similarities between mothers and pups. All species mentioned in Section II1,A are colonial. Mothers leave the roost every night to feed and have to find their offspring on return. Here, the gain in being identified is clear because the offspring will die if not fed frequently. Interestingly, infant greater horseshoe bats of 5 to 7 weeks of age that are still suckled do not have specific isolation calls (Matsumura, 1979), but show learned modifications in their echolocation calls. Perhaps their ability to match the main frequency of the mother’s echolocation call is sufficient for mother-pup recognition so that specific isolation calls are not needed. The need for effective individual recognition does seem to be the most likely reason why vocal learning has evolved in these bats. However, more studies, especially on species that do not breed in big roosts, are needed to assess whether this is the only possible explanation. Information on functions of odontocete sounds is still scarce, but the evidence we have points toward their use in individual recognition and group cohesion. These animals use most of their calls in social interactions, and have never been observed to show singing behavior like that of mysticetes. Even though evidence for vocal learning has been found in every cetacean that has been examined, mysticetes and odontocetes have very different social systems. While mysticetes seem to live alone most of the time, odontocetes live in relatively stable social groups (Tyack, 1986a). Bottlenose dolphins have a large repertoire of whistles, but most of those produced by an isolated individual are of a particular form more or less peculiar to itself and thus termed its “signature whistle” (Caldwell and Caldwell, 1965,1968; Caldwell, Caldwell, and Tyack, 1990).These signature whistles can remain stable for at least 12 years (Sayigh, Tyack, Wells, and Scott, 1990). This stability of signature whistles and their frequent production by isolated individuals supports the idea that they have a role in individual recognition. Tyack (1986b) found that 77% of all whistles of two interacting dolphins fell into two categories. One whistle was largely produced by one animal and the second mainly by the other. Tyack suggested that these were the signature whistles of the two animals, and that the fact that both individuals could produce both whistles may represent mimicry. Bottlenose dolphins have been shown to hunt cooperatively (Hoese, 1971) and support each other if injured (Lilly, 1963). In these situations it is certainly of advantage to a vocalizing animal to be individually identified by its allies. In a playback experiment Sayigh (1992) showed that mother bottlenose dolphins were also more likely to turn toward the signature
82
VINCENT M. JANlK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
whistles of their independent offspring (and vice versa) than toward those of other dolphins. Smolker, Mann, and Smuts (1993) presented evidence for use of signature whistles in mother-calf reunions. Individually specific signals are very common in odontocetes (e.g., Delphinus delphis, Caldwell and Caldwell, 1968; Lagenorhynchus obliquidens, Caldwell and Caldwell, 1971; Physeter macrocephalus, Watkins and Schevill, 1977; Stenella plagiodon, Caldwell, Caldwell, and Miller, 1973) and add to the evidence that vocal learning might have evolved in this group because of benefits it brought to individual recognition and group cohesion.
D. FAMILIAL OR GROUP RECOGNITION In familial or group recognition we encounter the same problem as in individual recognition. There must be some benefit to each individual to be recognized by its group or family members for vocal learning to evolve. Possible reasons are avoidance of inbreeding, cooperation between group members, or the identification and exclusion of strangers. All these arguments have been put foward for birds. Inbreeding avoidance is unlikely to be important, as male birds do not often sing the same songs as their fathers, as would be necessary if females were to use song as a cue. In Darwin’s finches (Geospiza spp.), which include some of the small number of species where fathers and sons are known to sing the same songs, females have been found to mate randomly in relation to song type (Millington and Price, 1985). Group recognition is perhaps more likely as birds usually respond more aggressively to alien songs than to those of neighbors, and, in colonies and in groups of territories, sharing of vocalizations through learning is common. This led Feekes (1977, 1982) to put forward the idea that shared songs might act as a “password” in the colonies of caciques (Cacicus cela) that she studied. It is striking that most odontocetes show individually specific calls, while killer whales have group-specific ones. The social organization of killer whales, with their stable family groups, is very different from that of bottlenose dolphins. Most dolphins live in fission-fusion societies with few stable associations between individuals (reviewed in Norris and Dohl, 1980). Killer whales tend to stay in their parental group throughout their lives (Bigg et al., 1990). They hunt cooperatively on a variety of different prey, ranging from herring to other marine mammals (Smith, Siniff, Reichle, and Stone, 1981; Simila and Urgate, 1993), and food sharing within pods has been observed (Hoelzel, 1991). Here, family-specific calls could help to avoid inbreeding or be used to maintain social bonds between group members and to exclude foreign individuals.
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
83
As with individual recognition, vocal learning could have been a good solution for marine mammals to the problems imposed on group recognition calls by the environment. High background noise could easily mask the subtle effect of differences in vocal tract morphology between different matrilines, making them useless for group recognition. Learning would allow animals to produce completely new sounds that are different enough to be recognized even in noisy conditions. The production of new, very distinctive sounds could also compensate for changing voice characteristics caused by the effects of water pressure on the air-filled vocal tract at different diving depths. In the more fluid social system of bottlenose dolphins, individual recognition to maintain social relationships is likely to be more important. These animals associate in temporary groups of variable size and composition. However, certain long-term associations have been discovered between related females (Wells, Scott, and Irvine, 1987). Small subgroups of two to three males also form relatively stable alliances (Connor et al., 1992; Smolker, Richards, Connor, and Pepper, 1992). Vocal learning could be of advantage in alliance formation and maintenance in this species. Males have been shown to cooperate with other males in aggressive interactions and in herding of females (Connor et al., 1992). Male alliances could use signature whistle mimicry or learned alliance specific calls to maintain their bonding and exclude strangers. Off Sarasota, Florida, approximately half the male bottlenose dolphins develop signature whistles that are very similar to those of their mother, while most females produce signature whistles highly distinct from those of their mothers (Sayigh et al., 1990; Sayigh, Tyack, Wells, Scott, and Irvine, 1995). It seems unlikely that only males develop family-specific calls as a kinship label that facilitates inbreeding avoidance because, while females tend to associate in matrilines later in life, males do not associate closely with their female relatives, though remaining in the same general area. Females may need to develop a signature whistle as different as possible from their mother’s to avoid misidentification. The higher degree of similarity of signature whistles between mothers and sons could stem from the lack of this requirement or it could benefit males if matriline affects dominance in dolphin societies. There is some evidence that it is the sons of only certain females that produce signature whistles like those of their mothers (Sayigh et al., 1995), but further investigation is needed.
E. POPULATION IDENTITY The development of dialects between neighboring populations of potentially interbreeding individuals could lead to assortative mating; this in turn
84
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
might benefit individuals if there are local genetic adaptations that can thereby persist. Nottebohm (e.g., 1972) suggested that dialects that are common in birds might have this effect. Although the idea has received some subsequent support, particularly in the white-crowned sparrow (Zonotrichia leucophrys, Baker and Cunningham, 1985), the weight of evidence is against it. For example, white-crown dialect boundaries do not seem to limit dispersal, song learning in males may occur after dispersal, and females often mate with males singing a different dialect from their natal one (see Catchpole and Slater, 1995, pp. 205-209 for a more detailed discussion). Even though this idea is now generally discounted in birds, it could still be true for marine mammals and bats that possess a similar potential for quick dispersal. If these animals return to their home area to mate, dialects might help to maintain local adaptations. Even in the relatively homogeneous marine environment, differences in local adaptations could exist between coastal and pelagic populations or between areas with different prey species. In many of the examples of geographic variation in mammal calls the actual extent of each population is unknown. Even though some of the locations where seals have been found to differ in their vocalizations are several thousand kilometers apart, these species are mobile as well as widely distributed and could easily cover such distances in their migrations. Humpback whale populations in different oceans on the other hand may well be truly isolated and their dialects are therefore unlikely to be adaptive in maintaining population identity. Variations in call structure of different primate populations have been interpreted as possible evidence for vocal learning by several authors. If call variations between neighboring populations are actually learned, a function in population recognition might be a reason. However, there is no clear evidence for learned differences yet. F. INTENSE SPECIATION Nottebohm (1972) discussed intense speciation as one possible factor in the development of vocal learning in birds. He argued that, with large numbers of species in small geographic areas, vocal learning might have evolved among passerine birds because of the need for rapid change in signals. Subsequently, it was suggested that vocal learning might itself have enhanced speciation in passerines, if learned signals acted to restrict gene flow. However, Baptista and Trail (1992) argue that there is little evidence that differences in bird vocal signals act as a barrier to interbreeding. In mammals, vocal learning does not appear to correlate with rapid speciation, making either of these ideas unlikely to apply. Marine mammals could have gone through a phase of intense speciation when they returned
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
85
from land to sea. However, this seems unlikely to have put any pressure on the development of vocal learning for species recognition, as the available space for dispersal was so great and the habitat was relatively homogeneous.
G. HABITAT MATCHING Different habitats can have very different sound transmission characteristics (Marten and Marler, 1977; Marten, Quine, and Marler, 1977; Wiley and Richards, 1978; Waser and Brown, 1986). If a species lives in various different habitats, or if the transmission characteristics of its habitat change frequently, vocal learning could help to optimize its vocal signals. This idea was originally put forward by Hansen (1979) for birds, many species of which disperse widely and live in a variety of habitats. Data in support of it have been obtained on two species: the great tit (Parus major, Hunter and Krebs, 1979) and the chingolo sparrow (Zonorrichiu cupensis, King, 1972; Nottebohm, 1975). Particularly detailed studies by Handford (1981, 1988; Handford and Lougheed, 1991) suggest that trill rates in this last species in agricultural areas match the habitat that was present before cultivation began, thus pointing to a very slow rate of change. Studies on primates have shown that some species do have calls that are matched to the transmission qualities of their habitat (Brown, Gomez, and Waser, 1995). However, there is no clear evidence for vocal learning in primates. In marine mammals it is unlikely that vocal learning has evolved because of advantages in habitat matching because, compared to most terrestrial environments, the sea has very stable sound transmission characteristics (Spiesberger and Fristrup, 1990). In bats all evidence for vocal learning involves mother-pup interactions. However, it could be possible that vocal learning enables them to match their echolocation calls to particular habitats. Further studies are needed to investigate this possibility.
V. CONCLUSIONS A. FLEXIBILITY I N VOCAL LEARNING We have identified several different levels of complexity in vocal learning. The most simple, in which animals can be trained to alter the overall duration and amplitude of a sound, seems to be a relatively common feature of mammalian communication systems (e.g., bottlenose dolphin, Lilly, 1965; domestic cat, Molliver, 1963; rhesus monkey, Sutton et al., 1973). It is likely that this form of sound alteration is closely linked to contextual learning
86
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J.
B. SLATER
of sounds. If an animal has learned to withhold or produce a sound in different contexts, it has a certain degree of learned control over the onset and offset of calling. An alteration of temporal parameters, like intercall intervals in sound sequences, in relation to auditory experience would thus become possible. This control over the muscles of the respiratory system and their coordination with the vocal apparatus might also be sufficient for learning how to alter total amplitude and duration of single calls. A more elaborate form of this sort of learning might involve significant changes in voice-onset time in a call or complex amplitude modulations that superimpose additional frequency bands on a call. To our knowledge there are as yet no studies of the role of learning in modifying these parameters. The second stage, in which an animal is able to learn how to alter certain frequency parameters to match another individual’s calls, has been demonstrated only in greater horseshoe bats, marine mammals and humans. Here, the activity of muscles of the vocal apparatus itself needs to be modifiable by experience. This needs a different level of neural control and is a significant next step in the evolution of vocal learning. While there are other reasons why an animal might gain control over the respiratory system to make it modifiable by experience (e.g., contextual learning in relation to vocal communication, diving), the vocal apparatus is used only in call production. However, not many studies have looked at this relatively limited form of vocal learning yet. It may be more common than it seems at this point. The ability to copy completely new sounds seems to be rare among mammals. Our review has shown that it is known to occur only in marine mammals and humans. However, we do not know whether the distinction between the ability to imitate new sounds and that to change only certain parameters in a limited way is a real one. More studies focusing on the extent to which calls are modifiable through vocal learning are needed. Bats, for example, might be capable of more drastic changes than the ones we know of so far. B. FACTORS AFFECTING THE EVOLUTION OF VOCAL LEARNING: THEROLEOF MOBILITY Many bird species in three different orders (Passeriformes, Apodiformes, Psittaciformes) show vocal learning, suggesting that it evolved separately in each of these groups. In mammals it is known to occur in humans, cetaceans, phocid seals, and bats, taxa that do not share a unique common ancestor. Here, too, it seems vocal learning has evolved independently in each group. Given this lack of a direct phylogenetic connection, it is interesting to ask whether there is a common factor that could have caused a convergent evolution of vocal learning in these groups.
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
87
We have identified several possible reasons why vocal learning could have evolved in different mammalian groups. If we examine features that these groups have in common with each other and with birds, an obvious similarity is their high mobility. With the exception of humans, they all spend at least part of their lives swimming or flying in three-dimensional environments. The high mobility of animals living in air or water is a fundamental common factor that has influenced various different aspects of their lives. It is more difficult for males to monopolize females. Members of a social group are more likely to lose contact in three-dimensional space. Vocal signals are likely to be used more because animals can disperse more quickly and visual contact is difficult to maintain. The increased use of vocal communication instead of visual signals increases background noise in the acoustic frequency bands used for communication and adds pressure toward signal diversity. Thus, living in these environments could make the development of vocal learning in a species more likely. There are, of course, other mammals, like arboreal or nocturnal ones, that face similar problems to a lesser extent. However, the impact of such problems is certainly highest in flying and swimming animals, as they disperse much more quickly and are not limited to moving only along solid structures in their environment, as are tree-living species, for example.
C. IMPLICATIONS FOR THE EVOLUTION OF HUMAN LANGUAGE In primates, researchers have been looking for evidence of vocal learning for a long time. Even though they clearly have considerable control over their vocal utterances, including the duration and amplitude of their calls, vocal learning has not been unequivocally established in primates other than humans. The fact that dolphins, seals, and many birds spontaneously start to imitate sounds from their acoustic environment in captivity suggests that imitation plays an important role in their lives. Such imitation of new sounds has never been observed in nonhuman primates. It seems strange that our closest relatives show no evidence for vocal imitation, yet humans are so adept at it. The suggested environment of early humans does not seem to have been strikingly different from those of other primates. Thus, all the possible advantages of vocal learning mentioned in Section IV would have been present for other primates, too. Why then did the ability to imitate sounds evolve in humans and not in nonhuman primates? Jakobson (1941) claimed that all the sounds of the world’s languages occur in infant vocalizations, suggesting that the learning of new sounds is not involved in language acquisition. However, today most researchers accept that humans are capable of vocal learning. More recent discussions on natural predisposition for language learning have concen-
88
VINCENT M. JANlK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
trated on the acquisition of language as a communication system (Bickerton, 1990; Pinker and Bloom, 1990), not on whether vocal learning is involved in the acquisition of the sound repertoire. A convincing explanation for the difference between nonhuman and human primates relates to the evolution of language. It might seem difficult to imagine how imitating sounds could have been of any advantage to the first individual that did so. This is certainly true if we assume that the evolution of language relied on vocal learning. However, several authors have argued that language developed in gestures before it affected vocal behavior (Hewes, 1973; Parker and Gibson, 1979). Once a gestural communication system with learned signals had become established, vocal learning would have been greatly favored because it makes it possible to use language even where visual contact is absent. If this sequence of events is correct, the lack of evidence for vocal learning in nonhuman primates would not be so surprising. However, more research, especially on the possibility of a more limited form of vocal learning in nonhuman primates, is needed.
D. FUTURE RESEARCH We have suggested that sexual selection, defense of resources, and individual recognition are the most likely reasons why vocal learning evolved in mammals, assuming that its functional significance has not changed since then. However, further studies are needed to find out how flexible the vocal system of each group is and what they are using this flexibility for. The body of evidence for vocal learning in mammals is still very small compared with that in birds. In many very vocal mammals, such as elephants, vocal learning has not been studied at all. We have already mentioned various other species that would be very interesting to study in this context. The most powerful experimental approaches to the study of vocal learning are certainly conditioning experiments and studying the effects of keeping experimental animals in controlled acoustic environments. If an animal can be trained to imitate a new sound that has not been in its repertoire before or if infants that have been exposed to different stimuli match what they have been hearing in detail, we have found unequivocal evidence for vocal learning. As our survey has shown, many authors interpret less convincing results as evidence for vocal learning. Geographic variation, differences in vocalizations between different matrilines or between normally raised and isolated individuals, changes in the vocal repertoire during ontogeny, and changes in vocal behavior after being housed with new individuals have all been interpreted as indicating vocal learning. All these examples could involve vocal learning, but they do not represent unequivo-
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
89
cal evidence for it. However, they give valuable information on species that could be interesting subjects in which to investigate its existence. Recent investigations of primate communication systems have revealed a greater flexibility than previously thought. Elowson and Snowdon (1994), for example, found significant alterations in call parameters of pygmy marmosets in relation to changes in their social environment. Because individuals did not match conspecifics in this study, trying to show that vocal learning was responsible would be difficult, but it deserves further investigation. In chimpanzees, in which individuals seem to match the pant hoots of their chorusing partners (Mitani and Brandt, 1994), this might be easier. Crossfostering experiments within this species might be able t o give clearer results on whether a limited form of vocal learning exists in nonhuman primates. Concurrent investigations of gestural communication in wild great apes could give information on what role learned gestures play in their natural communication system. Such studies could indicate how likely it is that gestural or vocal communication was the basis for language evolution. Even in those groups where evidence for vocal learning has been presented, information on its significance and flexibility is often lacking. The evidence in bats, for example, is still sparse, though it seems clear that their learning is not as versatile as that in marine mammals. Training bats with different stimuli would help to find out to what extent learning can influence the development of their communication and echolocation calls. More experiments on vocal learning in those marine mammals that show singing behavior are also needed. We still do not know how widespread vocal learning is in these groups and how they learn their songs. In seals, phocids seem to be capable of vocal learning, but there is no evidence for it in otariids. This could simply reflect a lack of studies, but there are also marked differences in the mating strategies of otariids and phocids that could explain the apparent discrepancy. Apart from the elephant seal, all the phocids that show geographic variation in their vocalizations breed at least partly on ice and copulate in the water (Stirling, 1975). This makes it difficult for a male to monopolize several females: they are either scattered on available haul-out sites or else in the water where there is poor visibility combined with increased mobility in all directions. Otariids, on the other hand, breed on land and males often defend harems against other males. The fact that singing behavior has so far been found only in phocids suggests that vocal learning may have evolved in relation to their mating strategy. However, the only clear evidence for vocal learning in seals comes from a harbor seal that imitated human speech spontaneously. There are as yet no further studies of vocal learning in seals, and there is a clear need for them. Comparative studies of how background noise influences call development and usage might also shed light on the origin of vocal learning. While
90
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. 0. SLATER
odontocetes seem to use vocal learning to improve individual recognition, mysticetes apparently use it only in their singing behavior. We d o not know whether vocal learning evolved once or twice in the lineage of cetaceans. Studies on how sexual selection on one hand and individual recognition on the other influence vocal behavior are needed to clarify how vocal learning evolved and persisted in these animals. Further studies on the vocal communication systems of toothed whales would be especially valuable. Even though individual recognition seems to be a likely reason for vocal learning to have evolved in dolphins, vocal learning could be used extensively in their complex social systems, including the possibility to use it in vocal deception. A study of how dolphins use imitation in the wild might open up a new perspective on why their vocal learning evolved. Given that its function might have changed in a particular species, and that dolphins show remarkable cognitive capacities (review in Herman, Pack, and Morrel-Samuels, 1993), including the ability to process syntactical information in signal sequences (Herman, Richards, and Wolz, 1984), it is likely that, once evolved, vocal learning had profound effects on various aspects of their natural communication.
VI. SUMMARY Vocal learning, as we discuss it in this review, refers to instances where vocalizations are modified in form as a result of experience with those of other individuals. While many birds are capable of vocal learning, unequivocal evidence for it is rare in mammals. The most versatile mammalian vocal learners are cetaceans, harbor seals, and humans, all of which are able to imitate new sounds. Greater horseshoe bats learn the main frequency of their echolocation calls from their mothers and are the only other mammals shown so far to be capable of learning t o change frequency parameters in their calls. Nonhuman primates have been conditioned to alter the duration and amplitude of their calls but not their frequency parameters. We suggest that sexual selection, defense of resources, and individual recognition are the most likely reasons why vocal learning has evolved in mammals. However, we know little about the functional significance of vocal learning for these animals and more studies are badly needed.
Acknowledgments We would like to thank Karen McComb, Laela S. Sayigh, Robert M. Seyfarth, and Charles T. Snowdon for helpful comments on the manuscript. V. M. Janik is a fellow of the Studienstif-
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
91
tung des Deutschen Volkes and was supported by a DAAD-Doktorandenstipendium aus Mitteln des zweiten Hochschulsonderprogramms.
References Aitken, P. G., and Wilson, W. A. (1979). Discriminative vocal conditioning in Rhesus monkeys: Evidence for volitional control? Brain and Language 8,227-240. Awbrey, F., Evans, W., Jehl, J., Thomas, J., and Leatherwood, S. (1982). Comparison of Ross Sea and Pacific Northwest killer whale vocalizations. Rep. Int. Whal. Commn. 32,667-670. Bain, D. E. (1986). Acoustic behavior of Orcinus: Sequences, periodicity, behavioral correlates and an automated technique for call classification. In “Behavioral Biology of Killer Whales” (B. C. Krikevold and J. S. Lockard, eds.), pp. 335-371. Alan R. Liss, New York. Baker, M. C., and Cunningham, M. A. (1985). The biology of bird-song dialects. Behav. Brain Sci. 8, 85-133. Baptista. L. F.. and Schuchmann, K. (1990). Song learning in the Anna hummingbird (Calypfe anna). Ethology 84, 15-26. Baptista, L. F., and Trail, P. W. (1992).The role of song in the evolution of passerine diversity. Syst. Biol. 41, 242-247. Bartholomew. G . A., and Hubbs, C. L. (1960). Population growth and seasonal movements of the northern elephant seal, Mirounga angusrirosfris. Mammalia 24, 313-324. Bartsh. S. S.. Johnston, S. D., and Siniff, D. B. (1992). Territorial behaviour and breeding frequency of male Weddell seals (Lepfonychotes weddelli) in relation to age, size, and concentration of serum testosterone and cortisol. Can. J . Zool. 70,680-692. Beer, C. G. (1969). Laughing gull chicks: Recognition of their parents’ voices. Science 166, 1030-1032. Bickerton, D. (1990). “Language and Species.” University of Chicago Press, Chicago. Bigg, M. A,, Olesiuk, P. F., Ellis. G. M., Ford, J. K. B., and Balcomb, K. C. (1990). Social organization and genealogy of resident killer whales (Orcinus orca) in the coastal waters of British Columbia and Washington State. Rep. fnr. Whal. Commn. (Special Issue) 12, 383-405. Bowles, A. E., Young, W. G., and Asper, E. D. (1988). Ontogeny of stereotyped calling of a killer whale calf, Orcinus orca, during her first year. Rir Fisk. 11, 251-275. Bradbury, J. W. (1977). Lek mating behavior in the hammer-headed bat. Z . Tierpsychol. 45,225-255. Brockelman. W. Y., and Schilling. D. (1984). Inheritance of stereotyped gibbon calls. Nature (London) 312,634-636. Brown, C. H.. Gomez, R.. and Waser, P. M. (1995). Old world monkey vocalizations: Adaptation to the local habitat? Anim. Behav. 50,945-961. Burnstein. D. D.. and Wolff, P. C. (1967). Vocal conditioning in the guinea pig. Psychon. Sci. 8, 39-40. Caldwell. M. C.. and Caldwell, D. K. (1965). Individualized whistle contours in bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops rruncatus). Nature (London) 207, 434-435. Caldwell, M. C., and Caldwell, D. K. (1968). Vocalization of naive captive dolphins in small groups. Science 159, 1121-1123. Caldwell, M. C., and Caldwell, D. K. (1971). Statistical evidence for individual signature whistles in Pacific whitesided dolphins, Lagenorhynchus obliquidens. Cefology 3, 1-9. Caldwell, M. C., and Caldwell, D. K. (1972). Vocal mimicry in the whistle mode by an Atlantic bottlenosed dolphin. Cerology 9, 1-8.
92
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
Caldwell, M. C., and Caldwell, D. K. (1979). The whistle of the Atlantic bottlenosed dolphin (Tursiops truncatus)-ontogeny. In “Behavior of Marine Animals: Current Perspectives in Research. Vol. 3. Cetaceans” (H. E. Winn and B. L. Olla, eds.), pp. 369-401. Plenum Press, New York. Caldwell, M. C., Caldwell, D. K., and Miller, J. F. (1973). Statistical evidence for individual signature whistles in the spotted dolphin, Stenella plagiodon. Cetology 16, 1-21. Caldwell, M. C., Caldwell, D. K., and Tyack, P. L. (1990). Review of the signature-whistlehypothesis for the Atlantic bottlenose dolphin. In “The Bottlenose Dolphin” (S. Leatherwood and R. R. Reeves, eds.), pp. 199-234. Academic Press, New York. Catchpole, C. K. (1980). Sexual selection and the evolution of complex songs among warblers of the genus Acrocephalus. Behaviour 74,149-166. Catchpole, C. K., and Slater, P. .I. B. (1995). “Bird Song: Biological Themes and Variations.’’ Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Cheney, D. L., and Seyfarth, R. M. (1990). “How Monkeys See the World: Inside the Mind of Another Species.” University of Chicago Press, Chicago. Cleator, H. J., Stirling, I., and Smith, T. G. (1989). Underwater vocalizations of the bearded seal (Erignarhus barbatus). Can. J. Zool. 67, 1900-1910. Conner, D. A. (1982). Geographic variation in short calls of pikas (Ochotonu princeps). J. Mamm. 63,48-52. Connor, R. C., Smolker, R., and Richards, A. F. (1992). Two levels of alliance formation among male bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops sp.). Proc. Nail. Acud. Sci. U.S.A.89,987-990. Cummings, W. C., and Holliday, D. V. (1987). Sounds and source levels from bowhead whales off Pt. Barrow, Alaska. J. Acoust. SOC.Am. 82, 814-821. Cummings, W. C., and Thompson, P. 0. (1971). Underwater sounds from the blue whale, Balaenoprera musculus. J. Acousr. SOC.Am. 50, 1193-1 198. Eaton, R. L. (1979). A beluga whale imitates human speech. Carnivore 2,22-23. Eens, M., Pinxten, R., and Verheyen. R. F. (1991). Male song as a cue for mate choice in the European starling. Behaviour 116,210-238. Elowson, A. M., and Snowdon, C. T. (1994). Pygmy marmosets, Cebuella pygmueu, modify vocal structure in response to changed social environment. Anim. Behav. 47,1267-1277. Esser, K. H. (1994). Audio-vocal learning in a non-human mammal: The lesser spear-nosed bat Phyllostomus discolor. NeuroReport 5, 1718-1720. Esser, K. H., and Schmidt, U. (1989). Mother-infant communication in the lesser spear-nosed bat Phyllostomus discolor (Chiroptera, Phy1ostomidae)-Evidence for acoustic learning. Ethology 82, 156-168. Feekes, F. (1977). Colony specific song in Cacicus cela (Icteridae, Aves): The pass-word hypothesis. Ardea 65, 197-202. Feekes, F. (1982). Song mimesis within colonies of Cacicus c. cela (Icteridae, Aves). A colonial password? Z. Tierpsychol. 58, 119-152. Ford, J. K. B. (1991). Vocal traditions among resident killer whales (Orcinus orca) in coastal waters of British Columbia. Can. J. Zool. 69, 1454-1483. Ford, J. K. B., and Fisher, H. D. (1983). Group-specific dialects of killer whales (Orcinus orca) in British Columbia. In “Communication and Behavior of Whales” (R. Payne, ed.), pp. 129-161. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado. Frankel, A. S., Clark, C. W., Herman, L. M., and Gabriele, C. M. (1995). Spatial distribution, habitat utilization, and social interactions of humpback whales, Megaptera novaeungliue, off Hawai’i, determined using acoustic and visual techniques. Can. J. Zool. 73,1134-1 146. Gaunt, S. L. L., Baptista, L. F., Sanchez, J. E., and Hernandez, D. (1994). Song learning as evidenced from song sharing in two hummingbird species (Colibri coruscans and C. thalussinus). Auk 111, 87-103. Geissmann, T. (1983). Female capped gibbon (Hylobates pileatus Gray 1891) sings male song. J. Hum. Evol. 12,667-671.
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
93
Geissmann, T. (1984). Inheritance of song parameters in the gibbon song, analysed in 2 hybrid gibbons (Hylobates pileatus X H. lar). Folia Primatol. 42, 216-235. Geissmann, T. (1987). Songs of hybrid gibbons (Hylobates pileatus X H. lar). Int. J. Primatol. 8, 540. Green, K., and Burton, H. R. (1988). Do Weddell seals sing? Polar Biol. 8, 165-166. Green, S. (1975). Dialects in Japanese monkeys: Vocal learning and cultural transmission of locale-specific vocal behavior? Z. Tierpsychol. 38, 304-314. Guinee, L. N., Chu, K., and Dorsey, E. M. (1983). Changes over time in the song of known individual humpback whales (Megaptera novaeangliae).In: “Communication and Behavior of Whales” (R. Payne, ed.), pp. 59-80. Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado. Handford, P. (1981). Vegetational correlates of variation in the song of Zonotrichia capensis. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 8,203-206. Handford, P. (1988). Trill rate dialects in the rufous-collared sparrow, Zonotrichia capensis, in northwestern Argentina. Can. J. Zool. 66,2658-2670. Handford, P., and Lougheed, S. C. (1991). Variation in duration and frequency characters in the song of the rufous-collared sparrow, Zonotrichia capensis, with respect to habitat, trill dialects and body size. Condor 93, 644-658. Hanggi, E. B., and Schusterman, R. J. (1994). Underwater acoustic displays and individual variation in male harbour seals. Phoca vitulina. Anim. Behav. 48, 1275-1283. Hansen, P. (1979). Vocal learning: Its role in adapting sound structures to long-distance propagation and a hypothesis on its evolution. Anim. Behav. 27, 1270-1271. Harcourt, A. H. (1988). Alliances in contests and social intelligence. In “Machiavellian Intelligence: Social Expertise and the Evolution of Intellect in Monkeys, Apes, and Humans” (R. W. Byrne and A. Whiten, eds.), pp. 132-152. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Hauser, M. D. (1992). Articulatory and social factors influence the acoustic structure of rhesus monkey vocalizations: A learned mode of production? J. Acoust. SOC.Am. 91,2175-2179. Hayes, K. J. (1951). “The Ape in Our House.” Harper, New York. Herman. L. M., Pack, A. A., and Morrel-Samuels, P. (1,993).Representational and conceptual skills of dolphins. in “Language and Communication: Comparative Perspectives” (H. L. Roitblat, L. M. Herman, and P. E. Nachtigall, eds.), pp. 403-442. Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Hillsdale, New Jersey. Herman, L. M., Richards, D. G., and Wolz, J. P. (1984). Comprehension of sentences by bottlenosed dolphins. Cognition 16, 129-219. Hewes, G. (1973). Primate communication and the gestural origin of language. Cur. Anthropol. 14, 5-24. Hodun, A., Snowdon, C. T., and Soini, P. (1981). Subspecific variation in the long calls of tamarin. Saguinus jiucicollis. Z. Tierpsychol. 57, 97-110. Hoelzel, A. R. (1991). Killer whale predation on marine mammals at Punta Norte, Argentina; food sharing, provisioning and foraging strategy. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 29, 197-204. Hoese, H. D. (1971). Dolphin feeding out of water in a salt marsh. J. Mamm. 52, 222-223. Hopkins, W. D.. and Savage-Rumbaugh, E. S. (1991). Vocal communication as a function of differential rearing experiences in Pan paniscus: A preliminary report. Int. J. Primatol. 12,559-583. Hunter, M. L., and Krebs, J. R. (1979). Geographical variation in the song of the great tit (Parus major) in relation to ecological factors. J. Anim. Ecol. 48,759-785. Jakobson, R. (1941). “Kindersprache, Aphasie, und allgemeine Lautgesetze.” Almqvist and Wiksell, Uppsala. Jones, G., and Ransome, R. D. (1993). Echolocation calls of bats are influenced by maternal effects and change over a lifetime. Proc. R. SOC.Lond. B 252, 125-128.
94
VINCENT M. JANIK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
King, J. R. (1972). Variation in the song of the rufous collared sparrow, Zonotrichia capensis, in northwestern Argentina. Z . Tierpsychol. 30, 344-373. Krebs, J. R. (1976). Habituation and song repertoires in the great tit. Eehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 1,215-227. Krebs, J. R.,Ashcroft, R., and Webber, M. (1978). Song repertoires and territory defence in the great tit. Nature (London) 271, 539-542. Kroodsma, D. E. (1976). Reproductive development in a female songbird: Differential stimulation by quality of male song. Science 192, 574-575. Kroodsma, D. E. (1984). Songs of the alder flycatcher (Empidonax alnorum) and willow flycatcher (Empidonax traillii) are innate. Auk 101, 13-24. Kroodsma, D. E. (1989). Male eastern phoebes (Sayornis phoebe; Tyrannidae, Passeriformes) fail to imitate song. J. Comp. Psychol. 103,227-232. Kroodsma, D. E., and Baylis, J. R. (1982). A world survey of evidence for vocal learning in birds. I n “Acoustic Communication in Birds” (D. E. Kroodsma and E. H. Miller, eds.), pp. 311-337. Academic Press, New York. Lal, H. (1967). Operant control of vocal responding in rats. Psychon. Sci. 8,35-36. Larson, C. R., Sutton, D., Taylor, E. M., and Lindeman, R. (1973). Sound spectral properties of conditioned vocalization in monkeys. Phonetica 27, 100-110. Le Boeuf, B. J. (1974). Male-male competition and reproductive success in elephant seals. Am. Zool. 14,163-176. Le Boeuf, B. J., Ainley, D. G.. and Lewis, T. J. (1974). Elephant seals on the Farallones: population structure of an incipient breeding colony. J . Mamm. 55, 370-385. Le Boeuf, B. J., and Peterson, R. S. (1969a). Dialects in elephant seals. Science 166,1654-1656. Le Boeuf, B. J., and Peterson, R. S. (1969b). Social status and mating activity in elephant seals. Science 163, 91-93. Le Boeuf, B. J., and Petrinovich, L. F. (1974). Dialects of northern elephant seals, Mirounga angustirostris: origin and reliability. Anim. Eehav. 22, 565-663. Lieblich, A. K., Symmes, D., Newman, J. D., and Shapiro, M. (1980). Development of the isolation peep in laboratory-bred squirrel monkeys. Anim. Eehav. 28, 1-9. Lilly, J. C. (1963). Distress call of the bottlenosed dolphin: Stimuli and evoked behavioral responses. Science 139, 116-118. Lilly, J. C. (1965). Vocal mimicry in Tursiops: Ability to match numbers and durations of human vocal bursts. Science 147, 300-301. Maeda, T., and Masataka, N. (1987). Locale-specific vocal behavior of the tamarin (Sanguinus labiains). Ethology 75, 25-30. Maples, E. G., Haraway, M. M., and Hutto, C. W. (1989). Development of coordinated singing in a newly formed siamang pair (Hylobares syndactylus). Zoo Eiol. 8, 367-378. Marler, P. (1991). Song-learning behavior: The interface with neuroethology. Trends Neurosci. 14,199-205. Marler, P., and Mitani, J. (1988). Vocal communication in primates and birds: Parallels and contrasts. In “Primate Vocal Communication” (D. Todt, P. Goedeking. and D. Symmes, eds.), pp. 3-14. Springer-Verlag, Berlin. Marler, P., Mundinger, P., Waser, M. S., and Lutjen, A. (1972). Effects of acoustical stimulation and deprivation on song development in red-winged blackbirds (Agelaius phoeniceus). Anim. Eehav. 20,586-606. Marler, P., and Tenaza, R. (1977). Signalling behavior of apes, with special reference to vocalization. In “How Animals Communicate” (T. Sebeok, ed.), pp. 965-1033. Indiana University Press, Bloomington. Marshall, J. T., Jr., and Marshall, E. R. (1976). Gibbons and their territorial songs. Science 193,235-237.
VOCAL LEARNING IN MAMMALS
95
Marten, K., and Marler, P. (1977). Sound transmission and its significance for animal vocalization. I: Temperate habitats. Eehav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 2, 271-290. Marten, K., Quine, D., and Marler, P. (1977). Sound transmission and its significance for animal vocalization. 11: Tropical forest habitats. Behav. Ecol. Sociobiol. 2, 291-302. Masataka, N. (1988). The response of red-chested moustached tamarins to long calls from their natal and alien populations. Anim. Eehav. 36,55-61. Masataka, N., and Fujita, K. (1989). Vocal learning of Japanese and rhesus monkeys. Eehaviour 109, 191-199. Masters, W. M.. Raver, K. A. S., and Kazial. K. A. (1995). Sonar signals of big brown bats, Eptesicus fuscus, contain information about individual identity, age and family affiliation. Anim. Behav. 50, 1243-1260. Matsumura, S. (1979). Mother-infant communication in a horseshoe bat (Rhinolophus ferrumequinum nippon): Development of vocalizations. J. Mamm. 60,76-84. McCowan, B.. and Reiss, D. (1995). Whistle contour development in captive-born infant bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus): role of learning. J. Comp. Psychol. 109,242-260. McWilliam, A. (1987). Territorial and pair behavior of the African false vampire bat, Cardioderma cor (Chiroptera: Megadermatidae), in coastal Kenya. J . Zool. 213,243-252. Millington, S . J., and Price, T. D. (1985). Song inheritance and mating patterns in Darwin’s finches. Auk 102, 342-346. Mitani, J. C. (1985). Responses of gibbons (Hylobates muelleri) to self, neighbor, and stranger song duets. Int. J. Primatol. 6, 193-200. Mitani, J. C. (1987). Species discrimination of male song in gibbons. Am. J. Primatol. 13, 413-423. Mitani, J. C. (1988). Male gibbon (Hylobates agilis) singing behavior-Natural-history, song variations and function. Ethology 79, 177-194. Mitani, J. C., and Brandt, K. L. (1994). Social factors influence the acoustic variability in the long-distance calls of male chimpanzees. Ethology 96,233-252. Mitani, J. C., Hasegawa, T., Gros-Louis, J., Marler, P., and Byrne, R. (1992). Dialects in wild chimpanzees? Am. J. Primatol. 27,233-243. Molliver, M. E. (1963). Operant control of vocal behavior in the cat. J. Exp. Anal. Eehav. 6, 197-202. Moore, P. W. B., and Pawloski, D. A. (1990). Investigations on the control of echolocation pulses in the dolphin (Tursiops truncatus).In “Sensory Abilities of Cetaceans” (J. Thomas and R. A. Kastelein, eds.), pp. 305-316. Plenum Press, New York. Morgan, B. J. T. (1984). “Elements of Simulation.” Chapman and Hall, New York. Morrice. M. G., Burton, H. R., and Green, K. (1994). Microgeographic variation and songs in the underwater vocalization repertoire of the Weddell seal (Leptonychotes weddelli) from the Vestfold Hills, Antarctica. Polar Eiol. 14,441-446. Myers, S . A., Horel, J. A., and Pennypacker, H. S. (1965). Operant control of vocal behavior in the monkey Cebus albifrons. Psychon. Sci. 3, 389-390. Norris, K. S., and Dohl, T. P. (1980). The structure and function of cetacean schools. In “Cetacean Behavior: Mechanisms and Functions” (L. M. Herman, ed.), pp. 21 1-261. John Wiley and Sons, New York. Nottebohm, F. (1972). The origins of vocal learning. Am. Nat. 106, 116-140. Nottebohm, F. (1975). Continental patterns of song variability in Zonotrichia capensis: Some possible ecological correlates. Am. Nut. 109, 605-624. Owren, M. J., Dieter, J. A., Seyfarth, R. M., and Cheney, D. L. (1992). “Food” calls produced by adult female rhesus (Macaca mulatta) and Japanese (M. fuscata) macaques, their normally-raised offspring, and offspring cross-fostered between species. Behaviour UO, 218-231.
96
VINCENT M. JANlK AND PETER J. B. SLATER
Parker, S., and Gibson, K. R. (1979). A developmental model for the evolution of language and intelligence in early hominids. Behav. Brain Sci. 2, 367-408. Payne, K., and Payne, R. (1985). Large scale changes over 19 years in songs of humpback whales in Bermuda. Z. Tierpsychol. 68,89-114. Payne, K., Tyack, P., and Payne, R. (1983). Progressive changes in the songs of humpback whales (Megapferanovaeangliae):A detailed analysis of two