Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH VOLUME 16
Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH Editor-in-Chief J. A. CALLOW
Editorial Boa...
24 downloads
1778 Views
15MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH VOLUME 16
Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH Editor-in-Chief J. A. CALLOW
Editorial Board H. W. WOOLHOUSE W. D. P. STEWART
W. G . CHALONER E. A. C. MAcROBBIE
Advances in
BOTANICAL RESEARCH Edited bji
J. A. CALLOW
VOLUME 16
I989
ACADEMIC PRESS Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
London San Diego Boston Sydney
New York Berkeley Tokyo Toronto
This book is printed on acid-free paper @ ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED 24/28 Oval Road, London NWI 7DX
United States Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS INC. San Dicgo, CA 92 10 I
Copyright fi?, I989 by ACADEMIC PRESS LIMITED All rights reserved No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data Advances in botanical research.--Vol. 16 1. Botany-Periodicals 581’.05 QKI ISBN 0-12-005916-9
Typeset by Eta Services (Typesetters) Ltd, Beccles, Suffolk Printed by Galliards (Printers) Ltd, Grcat Yarrnouth, Norfolk
CONTRIBUTORS TO VOLUME 16
P. R . BELL, Deparlment of' Botcmj~ant1 Microbiology, University College, London U'CIE 6B7: U K J. L. HARWOOD, Deprirtrnent of' Biochemistry, University College, Cardif CFI IXL, UK P. M . HOLLIGAN, Murirw Biologid Association qf the U K , Cituriel Hill, Pljwiouth PLI 2PB, U K A . L. JONES, Depcirtment of' Biochemistry, ~Jnirvrsity College, Curdif CFI I X L . U K R . A . SPICEK. Dt>purtment of' Earth Sciences, IJniversity of Oxford, Parks Roud, O.yfiwdOX1 3PR. U K
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
PREFACE
This volume of A h w i c r s in Botunicul RoscurcIi contains articles on lipid metabolism in algae (Harwood and Jones), the alternation of generations (Bell). the formation and interpretation of plant fossil assemblages (Spicer) and primary productivity in the shelf seas of N W Europe (Holligan). Lipid metabolism in algae is extremely diverse which is not unexpected given the diverse evolutionary origins of the group. The review by Harwood and Jones considers the broad range of lipid structures and underlying metabolic processes found in the algae, biit concentrates on results of the relatively few detailed studies that have been made in genera of microalgae such as C 1 1 / u t ~ ~ ~ ~ t i o tDuti(ilidlu, ~ i o t i ~ . ~ . Atiuc:l:vris. and some of the ‘higher’ marine algae such as the fucoids. The relative paucity of detailed studics on algae suggests that further study will be rewarding in uncovering novel pathways that could be important in biotcchnological exploitation. The phenomenon of ‘alternation of generations’, or the change in phase coincident with meiosis, used to form the backbone of elementary botanical training. Unfortunately. its association with often uninspired teaching based on ‘types’ has probably led botanists largely to neglect advanced study of this basic and radical shift in plant development, and the scientific opportunities afforded by lower plants in which this change of phase can be most clearly observed. This situation may change as molecular biologists seek good ‘systems’ in which to study changes in gene-expression and associated triggers or signals. Certainly the morphological events associated with the haplophase/diplophase transition are amenable to analysis by the exciting new molecular technologies and, especially for those without training in classical botany, the article by Bell is a good, thought-provoking introduction to the whole subject of alternation of generations, its basic characteristics in a whole range of plant groups, the associated ultrastructural changes, and an outline of the very small amount of experimental work that has been done so far. ‘Taphonomy’ is the study of the processes of fossilization and is therefore of fundamental importance to the accurate interpretation of the fossil record, and the reconstruction of ancient communities and environments. It is a subject that is relatively new and requires highly integrated multidisciplinary approaches for most effective study. In his substantial review, Spicer considers the various types of fossilization process, and there is a particularly vii
...
Vlll
PREFACE
fascinating account of how recent volcanic eruptions, and especially the events of Mount Saint Helens in 1980, have provided excellent opportunities to observe the consequences of explosive vulcanism in shaping one aspect of the fossil record. The stability of the global environment is currently a ‘hot topic’ in science and accurate predictions of the dynamics of populations, relevant, for example, to the proper exploitation of biological resources and the control of environmental degradation, requires reliable estimates of the various processes leading to the exchange of materials in different components of the global ecosystem. In the final chapter of this volume, Holligan reviews understanding of the ecology and productivity of the important phytoplankton component of marine systems, specifically in the shelf seas of NW Europe. While much is known of the temporal and spatial aspects of phytoplankton growth and the physiological and environmental factors controlling it, less appears to be known about aspects of productivity and the flux of materials through phytoplankton. Holligan considers how improved methodologies and greater cognisance of the physical mixing process in tidally-stirred shelf seas will improve our understanding of productivity. Finally I would like to thank all the authors of articles in this volume for their patience with the editor and their efforts to make his task easier. J. A . CALLOW
CONTENTS
CONTRIBUTORS T O VOLUME 16. . . . . . . . . . .
V
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii
PREFACE.
Lipid Metabolism in Algae JOHN L. HARWOOD and A. LESLEY JONES I. 11. 111.
Introduction .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1
Lipid Structures .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
2
Lipid Composition of Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Fatty Acids . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Lipid Classes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5 5 9
. . . . . . . .
12
V . Metabolism of Lipids in Cyanobacteria (Blue-Green Algae)
. . .
13
Studies with Halotolerant and Halophilic Dunulirllu Species
. . .
19
Metabolism in Marine Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Labelling Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Positional Distribution ofAlgal Fatty Acids . . . . . . . C. EKccts of the Environment on Algal Lipid Metabolism. . . .
28 28 33
VIII. Lipid Metabolism in Other Algal Types . . . . . . . . . .
42
IV. General Remarks on Plant Lipid Metabolism
VI.
VII.
IX.
Conclusions
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
35
47
The Alternation of Generations PETER R. BELL I.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11. The Universality of Life Cycles .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
ix
55 56
CONTENTS
X
I11 . Essential Features of Points of Change . . . . . . . . . . A . Gametogenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Sporogenesis . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
57 57 65
IV . The Significant Features of Aberrant Cycles . . . . . . . . . A . Aberrant Cycles in Natural Conditions . . . . . . . . . B . Induced Aberrations in Sexual Cycles . . . . . . . . .
70 70 72
V . The Causal Approach to Alternation . . . A . General Assumptions . . . . . . B . From Gametophyte to Sporophyte in the C . From Sporophyte to Gametophyte . . VI . General Conclusion .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . Lower Plants . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
78 78 78 82 87
The Formation and Interpretation of Plant Fossil Assemblages ROBERT A . SPICER 1.
Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . The Quality of the Plant Fossil Record . . . . . . . . . B. Vegetational Heterogeneity . . . . . . . . . . . . .
96 98 100
I1 . Plant Remains as Sedimentary Particles . . . . . . . . . . A . Allochthonous and Autochthonous Assemblages . . . . . B . Settling Velocity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
101 101
111. Aerial Dispersal andTransport ofplant Organs . . . . . . . A . Leaf Abscission . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
104 104 106
B.
Organ Dispersal by Wind
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
103
. . . . . . . . . .
112
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
114 115 119 122
VI . Fluvial Transport . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Channel Deposits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
125 126
VII . Lacustrine Environments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Fluvio-lacustrine Deltas . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
130 133
IV .
Litter Degradation o n the Forest Floor
V . Aquatic Processing of Plant Debris . A . Initial Processes-Floating . . B . Transport in the Water Column C . Lcaf Degradation . . . . .
VIII . Fluvio-marine Deltas and Estuaries . A . Pro-delta Slope . . . . . . B . Distributary Mouth Bars . . C . Tidal Flats . . . . . . . D . Interdistributary Embayments .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
140 141 142 143 144
xi
CONTENTS
E . Beaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . F . Lower Delta Plain Marshes . . . . . . . G . Upper Delta Plain Marshes . . . . . . . H . Deltaic Lacustrine and Fluvial Environments. I . Detrital I'cats . . . . . . . . . . .
IX .
Peat and Coal Assemblages
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
147
. . . . . . . . . . . .
X . Vulcanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . The Importancc of Explosive Vulcanism to the Plant Fossil Record: Case Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Debris Flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Preservation in Air-kill Tephra . . . . . . . . . 1) . Lateral Lakes in Volcanic Tcrrnins . . . . . . . . E . Post-eruption Vcgetation Recovery . . . . . . . . XI .
Prcservation and Diagcncsis . Conipt-cssion'lmpressions B . Duripartic Prcscrvation . C . Tissue Mineralization . D . Casts and Moulds . . . A.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
151
. . . . . .
152 160 166
.
.
168
.
.
172 175 175 176 I76 178
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
.
.
. .
. .
.
.
179 1x0 180 1x1
.
.
183
.
.
184
XI1 . Applications of Plant Taphonomy to the Fossil Record . . . A . Specimen Morphology and Taxonomy . . . . . . . B . C om m it ni t y Reco 11s t r uc t i on . . . . . . . . . . C . Rcconstructing Community Suites a n d Regional Vegetation D . The llse of Plant Fossils in Sedimentology . . . . . . XI I I . Conclusions
i44 145 146 147 147
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Primary Productivity in the Shelf Seas of North-West Europe P . M . HOLLIGAN I.
.
194
I1 . Ecological and Physiological Perspectives . . . . . . . . . . A . Ph y t o pla n k to 11 Distributions . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Control of Phytoplankton Production . . . . . . . . .
196 196 202
Ill.
Introduction .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Methods for Estimating Primary Productivity A . Nutrient Budgets . . . . . . . . B . Oxygen and Carbon Fluxes . . . . . C . Biomass Distributions . . . . . . D . Primary Productivity Models . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
IV . Environmental Conditions for Phytoplankton Growth in the NW European Shelf Scas . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Mixing, Processes, Seasonal Stratification . . . . . . . . B. Light Availability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
212 212 213 215 217 217 217 220
Lipid Metabolism in Algae
JOHN L. HARWOOD and A . LESLEY JONES
Dtpwtmeiit of' Biochemistry, University College CurdiflL CardiffCF1 I X L , U K
I. 11.
Introduction .
. . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
Lipid Composition o f Algae. . . . . A. FattyAcids. . . . . . . . . B. Lipid Classes . . . . . . . .
IV.
General Remarks on Plant Lipid Metabolism .
v1.
VII.
VIII. IX.
i
2
Lipid Structures
Ill.
V.
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
5 5 9
. .
12
. .
13
Studies with Halotolerant and Halophilic Dunuliellu Species . . . .
19
Metabolism in Marine Algae . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Labelling Characteristics . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Positional Distribution of Algal Fatty Acids . . . . . . . C. Effects of the Environment on Algal Lipid Metabolism . . .
. . . .
28 28 33 35
. . . . . .
42
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
47
Metabolism of Lipids in Cyanobacteria (Blue-Green Algae) . .
Lipid Metabolism in Other Algal Types . . . . . Conclusions .
.
. I.
INTRODUCTION
Algae are an extremely diverse group of organisms. Not surprisingly, thereAdvances in Botanical Research Vol. 16 ISBN 0-12-005916-9
Copyright $2 1989 Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction on any form reserved.
2
J O H N L. H A R W O O D A N D A . LESLEY J O N E S
fore. their lipid composition and metabolism are exceptionally varied. In this chapter we have concentrated attention on groups of organisms which have been studied in reasonable detail. This selection has, in consequence, neglected some interesting, but isolated, studies. Nevertheless, we believe that it allows readers unfaniiliar with lipids to assimilate more useful information. I n any case. plenty of reviews dealing with specialized aspects are referenced. In order to lay a basis for further discussion of metabolism, we have begun with sections on lipid structure and occurrence in algae. The metabolic sections then deal with organisms of increasing complexity. from the primitive cyanobacteria to marine macroalgae. Finally. we end with a section devoted mainly to green algae, which can be regarded as the nearest in metabolic characteristics to higher plants.
11.
LIPID STRUCTURES
The complex lipids of plants are mainly amphiphilic molecules with a hydrophobic head group and a hydrophilic “tail”, enabling them to form the lipid bilayers of membranes. Algae contain many of the lipids found in higher plants, and also some unusual lipids. The basic structure is a glycerol backbone derived from glycerol 3-phosphate (from the photosynthetic Calvin cycle, or glycolysis) to which is esterified the hydrophobic head group. Phospholipids have phosphate esterified to the sn-3 position with further moieties esterified through this. Glycolipids have sugar moieties as a head group. The structures of the major phospholipids and glycolipids found in algae are given in Fig. 1. Most of the eukaryotic algae contain a range of phospholipids and glycolipids, many of which are found in higher plants. However, the prokaryotic cyanobacteria have only the lipids of the chloroplast thylakoids of higher plants: namely monogalactosyldiacylglycerol (MGDG), digalactosyldiacylglycerol (DGDG), sulphoquinovosyldiacylglycerol (SQDG) and phosphatidylglycerol (PG) (Fig. 2) (Gounaris e f al., 1986). Tri- and tetragalactosyldiacylglycerols have been found in some higher plants, and Chlorrllu contains trigalactosylglycerol (Benson e f al., 1958). Sugars other than galactose may be found. Some red algae have mannose and rhamnose in their glycolipids (Pettitt, T. R., Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L., unpublished). Monoglucosyldiaglycerol (MGlcDG) was found in Nostoe calcicnla (Feige et al., 1980) and Anuhaena variahilis (Sato and Murata, 1982a). In A . variuhilis, MGlcDG appeared to be a metabolic intermediate, being rapidly converted to MGDG by epimerization of C-4 of glucose (Section V). Pham-Quang and Laur (1976a,b,c) found a range of novel glycolipids, phospholipids and sulpholipids in three brown algae, Pelvetia canuliculufn, Fucus vesiculosus and F. serratus. The two Fucus spp. also contain one major
3
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
unknown lipid (Smith and Harwood, 1984a; Jones and Harwood, 1987). In C. c r i s p s and P. lunosa, 3SS-labellingrevealed a number of sulphur-containing lipids, most of which were minor components (Pettitt, T. R.. Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L., unpublished). However. one of these lipids was identified as phosphatidylsulphocholine (PSC), the sulphonium analogue of phosphatidylcholine (PC) (Fig. 3). which has also been identified in diatoms and a Euglena species (Anderson ct ul., 1978a,b; Bisseret L ’ t d.,1984).
ALlprd
X
PA
-H
PC
-Ct$CH2N(CH3)3
PE
+ -C H2C $N H3
PS
+ 4H2CHNHj
+
I
cooOH
OH
PI
PG
DPG
-CH
C$OC-R
I
I
I
0Fig. I . Structures of common phosphoglycerides. PC, phosphatidylcholine; PI, phosphatidylinositol; PE, phosphatidylethanolamine; PG, phosphatidylglycerol; PA, phosphatidic acid. Based on Harwood and Russell (1984).
4
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
Chlorosulpholipids have also been found in some algae and are a major component of Ochromonas danica (Elovson and Vagelos, 1969). An unusual lipid found in a number of green algae and some lower plants, but not detected in angiosperms, is the homoserine ether lipid 1(3),2-diacylglyceryl-(3)-O-4'-(N,N,N-trimethyl)-homoserine (DGTS) (Fig. 4), first identified in 0. danica (Brown and Elovson, 1974). This lipid has since been
X -
Lipid
MGDG
DGDG
?H
I
SQ DG
CH20H
C H2-S Fig. 2 . Structures of common glycosylglycerides.
4-
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
5
0Fig. 3 . Structure of the sulphonium analoguc ofphosphatidylcholinc
Fig. 4. Diacylglycerol trimethylhomoserine ether lipid. identified in Chlumydomonus reinhurdtii, Dunuliellu sulina, Codium spp., Ulvu pertusu and Enteromorphu intestinalis (Sato and Furuya, 1984a,b), and is a major lipid of Chlumydomonus reinhurcitii and D. sulinu (Eichenberger, 1982; Norman and Thompson, l985b). Algae also contain neutral lipids, mostly as triacylglycerols which are, presumably, storage products (Pohl and Zurheide, 1979a,b) with small amounts of mono- and diacylglycerols. They also contain various hydrocarbons as minor constituents and a range of sterols and sterol esters (see Pohl and Zurheide, 1979a). Thus the range of lipid structures in algae varies from the simple constituents of the cyanobacteria to the complex variety in the eukaryotic brown (and other) algae. The structures found vary between the algal divisions and some lipids appear to be characteristic of different algal divisions-for instance, DGTS is found in many Chlorophyceae but has never been detected in any Phaeophyceae. The distribution of lipids within different algae is considered in more detail in the following section.
111.
LIPID COMPOSITION OF ALGAE A. FATTY ACIDS
A large number of algae have now been analysed for their fatty acyl composition. The convenience and sensitivity of gas-liquid chromatographic
6
J O H N L. H A R W O O D A N D A . LESLEY JONES
(GLC) methods have made this possible, whereas, in contrast. there has been much less work on the content of individual lipid classes in either marine or fresh-water algae. Fresh-water algae typically contain similar fatty acids to terrestrial plants. However, the proportions of such acids differ considerably from, for example, higher plant leaves. In general, even-chain acids in the range C,,C,, account for the bulk of the components. In contrast to plant leaves, fresh-water algae usually have a relatively high proportion of C , , fatty acids and reduced levels of C, unsaturatcd fatty acids, especially r-linolenate (Harwood rt d.. 1989). Of course, the total fatty acid composition of organisms gives little information about the specific acyl contents of individual complex lipids, which are usually very different. For example, it has been noted by several authors that triacylglycerols that can accumulate in certain species of algae are usually very low in polyunsaturated fatty acids (e.g. Tornabene ('I u/.. 1983). in contrast to total algal extracts (see Hitchcock and Nichols, 1971). Furthermore, in an analysis of the individual lipids of two strains of Chlam?.doomotiu.F rc.inhardtii. Eichenberger et ul. (1986) noted that. whereas the glycosylglycerides. PG and phosphatidylinositol (PI) contain mainly or exclusively the n-3 isomer of linolenic acid, phosphatidylethanolamine (PE) and DGTS contained the 11-6isomer (1'-linolenate). I n addition, it should be remembered that environmental factors such as light, temperature, nitrogen levels. salt stress or pollution can have a marked effect on fatty acid (and lipid) composition. Representative fatty acid compositions of some fresh-water and salttolerant algae are given in Table I. It will be seen that whereas the C, fatty acids are absent (or only found in trace amounts) in fresh-water algae, these acids may be significant components of organisms living in high-salt environments such as the Dead Sea. In fact, for marine algae the very long chain polyunsaturated fatty acids arachidonic acid and eicosapentaenoic acid (n-3) are usually major components (Pohl and Zurheide. 1979a; Harwood r t al., 1989). Marine algae in general contain a bewildering array of major fatty acids. Some representative examples of compositions for phytoplankton and macroalgae are shown in Table TI. Palmitate is, invariably, the major saturated fatty acid of phytoplankton with myristate often being found in appreciable quantities. In contrast to higher plants, C,, fatty acids are less important, with palmitoleic acid being the major monoenoic acid component. In some cases, e.g. Monochrysis lathrri (Table 11), total C,, acids represent a very minor proportion of the total acyl constituents. One common theme for all marine algae, with the exception of the Chlorophyceae, is that C, polyenoic acids are major constituents. Arachidonic and eicosapentaenoic ( n - 3 ) acids are the main C,, acids and sometimes represent a very high proportion of the total acyl groups of particular lipids. For example, in F. serratus arachidonate accounted for 67% of PC (Smith and
7
L I P I D M E T A B O L I S M IN A L G A E
F a t t y acid composition (“A, total)
16:O 16: I 16:2 l h : 3 16:4 18: I 18:2 I X : 3 1X:4 3 0 : s 3 2 : h F r e s h w a t c r spp.
Scene~1rsniu.sohliquus 35 Clik>r~llti vulguris 26 Chumy1onionu.s 20 reitiliurdt ii S a l t - t o l e r a n t spp. Anki.st,otli~.sriiusspp. I.socI1r:v.vis spp. Nuiinoclrliwi.r spp.
13
3 8 4
tr.
tr.
15
7
2
-
9 2
1
4
23
7
1
14 15 -
25
I
3
12 6 9 2 0
~
~~
7
9
4 4
6 34 6
30 20
2
30
3
2 6 1
29 17
2
~
I - -
1
2 27
-
13 ~~
Data from Hitchcock and Nichols (19711, Hen-Amotz and Tornabene (198.5) and Eichenberger el t i / . (1986). Fatty acids are abbreviated with the figure before the colciii indicatinp tlic number of carbon atoms. and the figure alter the colon indicating the number of double bonds contained.
Harwood, 1984a). while in Chondrus crispus eicosapentaenoate represented more than 25% of the total acids of the glycosylglycerides (Pettitt c ~ tul., 1989). The unicellular marine alga Chnrtonclla untiyuu (Raphidophyccac) was also found to contain rather higher amounts of eicosapentaenoate in all lipid classes (Sato er a/., 1987). A very unusual fatty acid which is found in photosynthetic tissues From higher plants is truns-A3-hexadecenoate. This acid is locatcd exclusively at the sn-2 position of PG (Harwood, 1980a). Interestingly. in view of the postulates concerning its possible role in granal stacking (see Bolton et d., 1978). the same acid is also found in PG in algae with quite different chloroplast morphology. Thus, it has been reported in brown algae (Smith and Harwood, 1983), red algae (Pettitt and Harwood, 1986), Raphidophyceae (Sato et a/., 1987) and diatoms (Kawaguchi er al., 1987). Together with all the negative evidence from higher plants (Bolton er d.,1978), it is clear that whatever the role truns-A3-hexadecenoate plays in nature, it is not in granal stacking. More likely explanations concern its possible involvement with chlorophyll-protein complexes (Remy er al. 1982), as suggested by modelbuilding experiments (Foley and Harwood, 1982; see Foley er ul., 1988). Cyanobacteria, as an evolutionarily less advanced “algal” group, also contain much more simple lipid and fatty acid compositions than other algae. Murata and Nishida (1987) have divided cyanobacteria into four groups based on the original classifications of Kenyon et al. (1972). Examples of each of these four groups are shown in Table I l l . Strains in the first group contain only saturated and mono-unsaturated fatty acids, while those in the other three groups contain linoleate plus polyunsaturated acids characteristic
Fatty acid composition ( "/o total) 14:O 16:O 16:1
Phytoplankton Monochrysis lutheri (Chrysophyccac) Olisthodiscus spp. (Xanthophyceae) Lauderiu borealis (Bacillariophyceae) Amphiciinium carterue (Dinophyceae) Dunaliellu sulinu (Chlorophyceae) Hemiselmis hrutiescens (Cryptophyceac) Macroalgae Fucus vesiculosus (Phaeophyceae) Chondrus crispus (Rhodophyceae) U l w luctuca (Chlorophyccae) Fatty acid abbreviations as for Table I
10 X
16:2
13 14
22 10
5 2
16:3 16:4 7 2 12 tr.
18:l
I I
3 4
4
7
12
21
3
3 tr.
24
1
41
--
-
1
13
IS 3
1 tr.
3
tr.
tr.
2
tr.
26
-
21 34
1
18
-
2 6 2
tr. tr. tr.
~
-
1
1 ~
-
18
18:2
2 5 11
9 9
I t 6 1 1 8 tr.
18:3
18:4
2 8
r .
1 tr. 2 1 1 9
20:4 20:s 1
~~
5 -
1
8
2 1 9 1 3 -
-
9
30
tr.
10 1
7
4
IS
1
4
18
2
17
24
I
14 14
8 22 2
22:6 7 2
25 -
-
tr.
9
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
Group
1
2 3 4
Fatty acid composition ('YO total)
Organism
Anrrcj~.stisnidu1rti.s Atiuhicctm vrrriuhilis Sjnechoiystis 67 14 To1jpotliri.u tenuis
46 32 28 22
46 22 4 3
3 I1 5 16
0 17 17 15
0 16
0 6
0 0 3i 13
0 0 0 II
Data taken from Murata and Nishida (19x7). where rel'crences will he found. €.'ally acid ahhrovations as for Table I .
of each group. Thus, groups 2, 3 and 4 contain a-linolenate, ;j-linolenate and octadecatetraenoate (n-3), respectively (Table I1 1). Filamentous blue-green algae are distributed throughout the four groups, while the prokaryotic green alga Prochloron has a fatty acyl composition placing i t in the first group (Kenrick er d., 1984). B.
LIPID CLASSES
Just as the cyanobacteria contain a relatively simple fatty acid composition, so is their lipid content confined to four major classes only-monogalactosyldiacylglycerol (MGDG), digalactosyldiacylglycerol (DCDG), sulphoquinovosyldiacylglycerol (SQDG) and phosphatidylglycerol (PG). A minor lipid, monoglucosyldiacylglycerol (MClcDG), accounts for a trace amount in some species such as Anucysris vuriahilis but not in others (e.g. Anucystik niduluns). This minor lipid is involved in the biosynthesis of MGDG (see later). The lipid compositions of two cyanobacteria and Prochloron spp. are given in Table IV. When individual membrane fractions were isolated from Anacystis niduluns, the thylakoid, plasma and outer membrane all contained a rather similar amount of the four lipids except that DGDG was somewhat enriched in the outer membrane. However, the lipid content as a percentage of the dry weight was very different, being 57%, 19% and 3% for the plasma, thylakoid and outer membranes, respectively (Murata and Nishida, 1987). In nitrogen-fixing cyanobacteria unusual glycolipids have been reported. These are found i n the heterocysts of the filamentous heterocystous strains as well as in unicellular strains. In A . cylindricu, the glycolipids account for 4.4% of the total lipids. The chemical structures of the four main nonsaponifiable glycolipids were determined about 15 years ago (Bryce e t al., 1972; Lambein and Wolk, 1973) and other minor variants have been reported (see Murata and Nishida, 1987). Eukaryotic algae contain a formidable range of acyl lipids. As a general-
I0
J O H N L. H A R W O O D A N D A. LESLEY JONES
Lipid (YOtotal)
Organism
..IIItrhrrefltr L'oric/hi/i.s
nitluluti.s Proc~/l/ororlspp. A n i i ~ ' j . .tis \
MGDG
MGlcDG
DGDG
SQDG
PG
54 57
I 1i.m.
17 11 II
II II 26
21 5
_5 T_
3
17
not measured. Data takcn from Muratu a n d Nishida ( 19x7). where the original references can be found.
ii.ni. =
ization, the three glycosylglycerides (MGDG, D G D G and SQDG) are major constituents. So far as phosphoglycerides are concerned. all the main classes can usually be detected. Insufficient data are available for generalizations to be made but it appears, thus far, that there are considerable differences between algal divisions in their relative contents of individual phospholipids. Some examples of lipid compositions are given in Table V. DGTS is an unusual lipid which is found in the Chlorophyta, although it was first reported in the chromophyte 0. (lunicu (Nichols and Appleby, 1969; Brown and Elovson, 1974). I t represents a major component in green algae such as Ch1rini~~tlot~iotiu.v rrinhurcltii (Eichenberger and Boschetti, 1978; Table V). and a survey of its occurrence in non-vascular green plants has been made (Sato and Furuya, 1985). Apart from 0. dunicu, Chuttonrllu untiyuu (Sato r t ul., 1987: Table V) is the only chromophyte known to contain DGTS. The lipid has not been reported in brown algae (e.g. Smith and Harwood, 1984a) or diatoms (e.g. Kawaguchi P / ul., 1987). Many fresh-water algae contain chlorosulpholipids (Mercer and Davies, 1979). Again, it was work with 0. dunicu which first revealed large amounts of these lipids (Haines and Block, 1962). The substances were soon identified as sulphur esters that were present in amounts greater than for most glycolipids or phospholipids in the cell. Many of the sulphur esters also contain chlorine, and are therefore known as chlorosulpholipids. In 0. dunicu they represent about 15% of the total lipids. They have been detected in all freshwater species but not in any of the marine species examined (Mercer and Davies, 1979).These unusual lipids have been reviewed (Haines, 1973a,b). Certain diatoms have been found to contain other novel sulphur-containing lipids (Kates, 1987). Characteristically, all species examined contain three sulpholipids in addition to SQDG. They have been identified in Nitzchiu ulhu as sterol sulphate, deoxyceramide sulphonic acid and the PC analogue PSC (Anderson rt ul., 1978a,b; Kates rt ul., 1978). In the non-photosynthetic diatom N. albu, PSC completely replaced PC, but in other diatoms both lipids occurrcd together (Kates, 1987). Overall, the sulpholipids are major constituents of diatoms, representing 30Y0 of the total polar lipids in N. pelliculnsu
TABLE V Tlw acjl lipid conipositiotis Lipid ( O h ) PC PE PI PG DPG Other phospholipids MGDG
DGDG SQDG Other glycolipids DGTS Lipid X Neutral lipids Free fatty acids
Chatronella antiqud
Dutiuliella parvu
Aceiahulnriu meditarraticw ‘
9 n.d. 2 6
0.1 I .2 0.6 3
__
29 18 29 ~
6
of .sonic
ulgue
Chlat?i~.clot?ioti~i.s reiniiurdiiid
31 20 20
3
10
4.2’ 6.2 2.9
.-
37
A_-
5.4 ~
41 16 7
16.9 14.8 15.5
15.0 11.3 22.0
16
n.d.
n.d. 24. I 4.9
-
~
20
Fucus wsicuIosusJ
30.1 1 .5 trace 1.1 1.9
5
~
21 11 7 1 15
CIlOt1dr us crispus ‘’
-
~
3.4 2.2
I5 13
“Sato et ul. (1987); bKates (1987); ‘Eichenberger and Gerber (1987); dEichenberger et ul. (1986); ‘Pettitt n.d. = not detected.
el
ul. (1988b); ’Unpublished data
12
JOHN L. HARWOOD AND A. LESLEY JONES
and over 74% in N . alba. PSC has also been detected in marine red algae such as Chondrus crispus and Polysiphonia lanosa (Pettitt et al., 1988b). A review of the lipids of marine algae has been made by Pohl and Zurheide (1979a). There have been sporadic reports of a wide range of unusual structures. However, in many cases these have not been confirmed and may, in at least some cases, be the products of lipid degradation or modification during analysis. Such processes are well known in plant tissues, and special precautions must be taken to prevent their occurrence (see Harwood, 1980a).
IV. GENERAL REMARKS ON PLANT LIPID METABOLISM A detailed discussion of plant lipid synthesis is beyond the scope of this chapter, and, moreover, specific algal aspects will be dealt with later. However, a few very general remarks together with comprehensive references will be made here. Fatty acid metabolism has been reviewed very recently (Harwood, 1988). De novo synthesis involves the concerted action of acetyl-CoA carboxylase and a type I1 (dissociable) fatty acid synthetase. The end-product of such synthesis is palmitoyl-ACP, which can be specifically chain-lengthened to stearoyl-ACP using a special condensing enzyme. Thus C,, and C,, saturated fatty acids are the products of de novo synthesis. The first unsaturated bond is usually introduced at the A9-position by a desaturase which probably uses acyl-ACP substrates in most instances. Palmitoleic and oleic acids result from this action. Further desaturations are thought to involve complex lipid substrates such as PC and MGDG (Harwood, 1988). These may take place within choroplasts (prokaryotic pathways) or include extra-chloroplastic (eukaryotic pathway) enzymes. Fatty acids can also be elongated, and such reactions are clearly of great importance to many algae where C,, fatty acids are major constituents. Nothing is known about the substrates for such reactions in algae, although acyl-CoAs are used in a number of higher plant tissues (Harwood, 1988). Obviously, where both chain elongation and desaturation are involved in the formation of a given fatty acid, there will be more than one possible route. Thus, arachidonate has been shown in some algae to be formed by a desaturation-elongation-desaturation route from linoleate (Nichols and Appleby, 1969): 18 : 2 (n-6)+18 : 3 (n-6)+20 : 3 (n-6)+20 : 4 (n-6) In contrast, in a euglenoid (Hulanicka et al., 1964) it appears to be formed thus: 18 : 2 (n-6)+20 : 2 (n-6)+20 : 3 (n-6)+20 :4 (n-6)
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
13
So far as complex lipids are concerned, the formation of MGDG and DGDG (Joyard and Douce, 1987), SQDG (Harwood, 1980b; Mudd and Kleppinger-Sparace, 1987) and phospholipids (Moore, 1982; Harwood 1989) has been reviewed. The metabolism of unusual lipids such as the sulpholipids of diatoms (see Kates, 1987). chlorosulpholipids (Mercer et d.,1374) and DGTS (see Schlapfer and Eichenberger, 1983) has also been discussed. In addition, the arsenic lipid (arsenoribosylphosphatidylglycerol) which appears to mediate arsenic excretion in marine organisms has been discussed (Benson, 1987). Other general aspects of plant lipid metabolism will be found in the excellent volumes edited by Stumpf (Stumpf and Conn, 1980, 1987).
V.
METABOLISM OF LIPIDS IN CYANOBACTERIA (BLUE- GREEN ALGAE)
The cyanobacteria, like the eukaryotic algae, have an oxygen-evolving photosynthetic mechanism, yet their prokaryotic morphology makes study of their metabolism much simpler. Their lipid composition and metabolism have been recently covered in an excellent review (Murata and Nishida, 1987), so only a few aspects will be dealt with here. The plasma and thylakoid membranes of cyanobacteria contain glycerolipids-almost exclusively MGDG, DGDG, SQDG and PG. The outer membrane contains lipopolysaccharides and hydrocarbons in addition to glycerolipids. In addition, some nitrogen-fixing species of filamentous cyanobacteria may contain vegetative cells which change into heterocysts (Haselkorn, 1978). These heterocysts contain a refractile multilayered heterocyst envelope which contains unique glycolipids (glycosidic glycolipids and glycosyl ester glycolipids) (Lambein and Wolk, 1973). The glycerolipid composition of several species of cyanobacteria is shown in Table IV. It is noteworthy that the only glycerolipids present in appreciable amounts are those which are regarded traditionally as typical chloroplast thylakoid lipids (Harwood, 1980a; Gounaris rt d.,1986). In addition, it will be seen that for Anucysfis nzduluns, where more detailed analyses have been undertaken, the lipid compositions of different membranes in the cyanobacterium are broadly similar. However, the lipid contents (YO dry weight) are quite different, being 19%, 57% and 3% for the thykaloid, plasma and outer membranes, respectively (Murata and Nishida, 1987). In addition to the four main lipid classes present in cyanobacterial membranes, MGlcDG seems to be a ubiquitous, though minor, component (Feige, 1978). When the fatty acids of cyanobacterial lipids were first studied, it was realized that although these were broadly similar to those of higher plant chloroplasts, there were some notable differences. These include the increased
14
JOHN L. HARWOOD AND A. LESLEY JONES
,
importance of C (especially palmitoleic) acids, the relative reduced prevalence of polyunsaturated fatty acids (including the absence of linoleate and alinolenate from some organisms), the presence of y-linolenate in some cyanobacteria and an absence of trans-A3-hexadecenoate from PG (Hitchcock and Nichols, 1971; Murata and Nishida, 1987). Some efforts have been made to classify cyanobacteria into four subgroups, according to their fatty acyl composition (Kenyon, 1972; Kenyon et al., 1972) (see Section 111). Examples of fatty acid compositions for different organisms are given in Table 111. The individual glycerolipids differ from one another in their acyl compositions. In general, MGDG and DGDG contain the highest ratios of unsaturated to saturated acids. In those cyanobacteria which contain polyunsaturated fatty acids, the latter are also enriched in the glycosylglycerides. The two acidic glycerolipids, SQDG and PG, tend to contain very large amounts of palmitate with only small quantities of palmitoleate. Naturally, the fatty acyl compositions of cyanobacteria and their glycerolipids are very dependent on growth temperature (see later). All glycerolipids of cyanobacteria display the typical "prokaryotic" positional concentration of C,, acids at the sn-1 position and C , , acids at the sn-2 position (Zepke et al., 1978). Studies using ['"C] acetate first established the rapid labelling of all major glycerolipid classes (Nichols, 1968). When H14C0, was used for pulselabelling of 30 species of cyanobacteria, the first lipid highly labelled was MGlcDG. Later, radioactivity appeared in MGDG, and it was proposed that these lipids had a precursor-product relationship (Feige et al., 1980). Moreover, analysis of the glucose and galactose moieties of these two lipids in Anacystis nidulans showed a similar relationship (Fig. 5) and indicated that the sugar moiety was not lost during this interconversion. As a result of these experiments, Sat0 and Murata (l982a) proposed that the mechanism of formation of MGDG involved epimerization at the C-4 atom of the precursor glucose unit. In addition, experiments with cerulenin (see below) suggested that DGDG was formed by galactosylation of MGDG rather than via a glycolipid : glycolipid transferase (see Joyard and Douce, 1987). Cerulenin, a known inhibitor of fatty acid biosynthesis, was tested with Anacystis nidulans. Its inclusion reduced severely the incorporation of radioactivity from H1"C03 into all lipid classes except D GDG (Sato and Murata, 1982a). This was in keeping with the idea that newly synthesized acyl chains are needed for the overall formation of glycerolipids, but because DGDG can be synthesized by galactosylation of MGDG, its labelling is less affected. Indeed, analysis of the sugar residues of D G D G confirmed that a high proportion of the total radioactivity of this lipid was present in the galactose moieties (Sato and Murata, 1982a). A membrane-bound UDP-glucose : diacylglycerol glucosyl transferase was detected in A . variubilis (Sato and Murata, 1982a). This enzyme seems to be present in both thylakoid and plasma membranes (Omata and Murata, 1986) and it is interesting that, in higher plants, the equivalent galactosyl
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
I
15
r
Time ( h ) after labelling
(a)
(b)
Fig. 5. Changes in the radioactivity of monoglucosyl- and monogalactosyldiacylglycerol during pulse-labelling from HI4CO, in A . niduluns and subsequent chase. Gal, galactose; Glc, glucose. Taken from Sato and Murata (1982a)with permission. transferase is found in the chloroplast envelope and, in some cases, also in prothylakoids (see Murata and Nishida, 1987). Fatty acid synthesis was followed in A . vuriubilis by labelling from H14C03 (Sato and Murata, 1982b). Radioactivity was incorporated initially into palmitate, stearate and oleate. In fact, it was suggested that saturated fatty acids were initially incorporated into complex lipids such as MGlcDG and that subsequent desaturations occurred while the acyl groups remained attached to complex lipids. This was in agreement with proposals for higher plants (see Harwood, 1988). Examination of molecular species labelling of individual lipid classes led to proposals that in MGlcDG, stearate could be desaturated to oleate and linoleate but hardly at all to linolenate. In contrast, MGDG was an efficient substrate for successive desaturation of stearate through to linolenate as well as for that of palmitate to hexadecadienoate. DGDG did not appear to be used for desaturation, whereas successive desaturation of stearate, but not of palmitate, appeared to occur on PG and SQDG (Fig. 6). Direct demonstration of lipid-linked desaturation of palmitate in MGDG was made by the use of isotopic labelling. Incubation of cells with H13C03 caused the formation of MGDG enriched in its acyl groups. After 2.5 h, 19% of the palmitate but virtually none of the palmitoleate at the sn-2 positions were enriched in 13C. During a subsequent incubation for 7.5 h in the presence of unlabelled CO, and the fatty acid synthesis inhibitor cerulenin,
16
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
38°C
22°C
18:O 16:O [Gal
1
1
18:l 16:l [Gal
--+
E
18:2
GalDG
--+
18:l 16:O [Gal
- -1
18:3 16:O
18:Z
18:3 16:l
18:2
16:O
[Gal
L
[g;: -[
1611 Gal
Gal
1
Gal
18:3 16:2 Gal
I
1
1
I
I
J
Fig. 6. Pathways for the desaturation of fatty acids esterified to the acyl lipids of A . niduluns. Taken from Sato and Murata (1982b) with permission.
[I3C]palmitate was desaturated to [13C]palmitoleate.Mass spectrometric analysis of the 2-acylglycerol moiety showed that [L3C]palmitoyl[ I 3C]glycerol was converted to [ 3C]palmitoleoyl-['3C]glycerol, and ['ZC]palmitoyl-['zC]glycerol to ['ZC]palmitoleoyl-['ZC]glycerol. If a pathway involving deacylation, desaturation and reacylation had been involved, then this would have been expected to yield products containing partial enrichment (Fig. 7) and this was not found. The results were fully in support of an MGDG-linked desaturation of palmitate (Sato et al., 1986). The idea that desaturation of fatty acids in cyanobacteria required lipidlinked substrates was in agreement with data for A . variahilis reported by Lem and Stumpf (1984a). They showed that cell-free extracts were able to synthesize palmitate and stearate but not oleate from [14C]malonyl-CoA.In addition, although [14C]palmitoyl-ACPcould be elongated to ['4C]stearoylACP, n o desaturation was detected. When ['4C]stearoyl-ACP was used as
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
17
Lipid- linked desaturation
Gly ( U 1-16; 0 ( U) Gly (E)-16:0 ( E l
Gly(U )-16 : 1(U 1 Deacylat ion desaturation and reacylatton
Gly( E 1-16 : 1 ( U )
Fig. 7. Principle of isotopic species analysis to discriminate between the two possible mechanisms of dcsaturation of palmitate. Combinations of the glycerol backbone and the C16 acids at the sn-2 positions of MGDG are presented as Gly-16:O and Gly-16:I. U, unenriched; E. enriched with I T . Redrawn from Sato rt ul. (1986) with permission.
substrate in a A9-desaturase assay, activity was detected in green algae such as C. pyrenoidom, Scenedesmus ohliquus and Chlamydomonas moewensii, but not in A . variahilis or Nostoc spp. Data from other laboratories agree with the above conclusions (Stapleton and Jaworski, 1984b; Al Araji and Walton, 1980). The fatty acid synthetase of A . variahilis is of the type I1 non-associated type (see Harwood, 1988). The malonyl-CoA : ACP transacylase has been purified and found to have rather similar properties to that from spinach chloroplasts (Stapleton and Jaworski, 1984a). The elongation of palmitate to stearate uses palmitoyl-ACP and NADPH and not palmitoyl-CoA or NADH (Lem and Stumpf, 1984a; Stapleton and Jaworski, 1984a). Radioactivity from ['4C]acyl-ACPs was rapidly transferred into complex lipids, especially MGDG, by crude cell extracts of A . variahilis. The first intermediate detected was diacylglycerol (Lem and Stumpf, 1984b), but one presumes that the incorporation into this compound was due to glycerol 3-phosphate acylation and phosphatidate phosphatase. Acyl-CoAs could not act as substrates. Although [14C]oleoyl-ACPwas effective for acylation, the probable lack of formation of this compound in vivo (see above) would prevent the esterification of this moiety which would have to be formed by lipid-linked desaturation (Sato and Murata, 1982b). Compositional studies on cyanobacteria have demonstrated that shifts in growth temperature lead to several types of changes in lipids. In Anacystis
18
JOHN 1.. HARWOOD A N D A . LESLEY JONES
TABLE VI Chunge~in the moleculur .species composition qf’glycerolipids 0f’Anabaena variabilis c u u s t d by growth ietnperuture Lipid
Growth temp. ( C)
Molecular species (YOtotal) C-l C-2
GlcDG MGDG
DGDG PG
SQDG
38 22
18.0 1 8 . 1 1 8 . 2 1 8 : 3 1 8 . 1 1 8 : 2 1 8 . 3 1 8 . 3 1 6 . 0 1 6 . 0 1 6 . 0 16:O 16.1 16.1 1 6 . 1 1 6 . 2
24 22
60 40
10 24
38
1
25
22
2
2
23 12
38 22
1 1
16 4
24 20
0 19
1
56 10
41 26
48 10
26 16
sx
38
...77
0
38 22
10
2
0 6
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
1
11
34
0
35 3
0 32
0 12
16 I
38
0 0 3 1 4
0 61
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0
0 0
0 0
0 0
0 0
9
Fatty acid abbreviations as in Table I . Taken from Murata (1987). with perinission
niciuluns, lowering growth temperature led to an increase in unsaturation and a shortening of chain length (Holton et a/., 1964). Similar changes were found with S~~nec.hococcu.s cedrorum (Sherman, 1979), and in S. lividus lowtemperature growth led to a decrease in palmitate and oleate and an increase of palmitoleate in MGDG and DGDG while stearate decreased and palmitoleate and oleate increased in PG and SQDG (Fork et ul., 1979). In Anucjxtis nidulrms, lowering growth temperature led to a decrease in chain length of mono-unsaturated acids at the sn-I position of all lipids but increased desaturation of palmitate at the sn-2 position of MGDG and D GDG (Sato et d., 1979). In contrast to the above, the unicellular cyanobacterium A . variahilis contains polyunsaturated fatty acids. Lowered growth temperatures led to an increase in a-linolenate at the sn-l position of all lipids, while the composition of C, acids at the sn-2 position remained nearly constant apart from a slight increase in hexadecadienoate in MGDG and DGD G (Sato et al., 1979; Sat0 and Murata, I980b). These experiments are summarized in Table VT, where the molecular species patterns for different lipid classes are shown. In temperature-shift experiments it has been found that A . variahilis rapidly alters its fatty acid composition as well as the positional distribution of such acids on individual glycerolipids. For example, for 10 h after a change in growth temperature from 38 ’C to 28 ‘C, the total amounts of lipids
LIP113 METABOLISM IN ALGAE
19
stayed constant but a desaturation of palmitate at the . ~ n - 2position of M G D G took place (Sato and Murata, 1980a). Molccular oxygen was required for the desaturation, which was prevented by chloraniphenicol or rifanipicin, suggesting that the specific A9-desaturase activity was induced by the downward shift in temperature (Sato and Murata, 1981). Slower decreases in the amounts of oleate and linoleate and commensurate increases in 3-linolenate which occur in M G D G and SQDG and PG were also prevented by protein synthesis o r R N A synthesis inhibitors (Sato and Murata. 1981). Conversely, sudden increases in growth temperature transiently increase de novo fatty acid synthesis but suppress desaturation of existing lipids in A . vuriuhilis (Sato and Murata, 1980a). The rapid changes in unsaturation levels of C , , acids only occurred in M G D G , in keeping with its role in palmitate desaturation (above). Slower changes in the unsaturation of C , fatty acids occurred in all major lipid classes (Murata, 1987). The changes which were found in the lipids of cyanobacterial membranes have been related to an adaptive response to prcvcnt damage caused by low temperatures. The results have been fully discussed (Murata. 1987: MuraLa and Nishida, 1987). I t appears that the plasma membrane (rather than the thylakoids) is particularly susceptible to low-temperature stress in both A nucysl is n iduluns and A nuhuenu vur iuhilis. Apart from temperature, a number of other environmental factors have been shown to alter lipid composition in cyanobacteria. These eKects are summarized in Table V11. Mention was made of the unusual heterocyst glycolipids a t the beginning of this section. These compounds have the structures shown in Fig. 8. The biosynthesis of these glycolipids was first studied by [I4C]acetate incorporation (Abreu-Grobois c t d . ,1977). I t was suggested that hydroxylation of the aliphatic chain at the C-3 and C-25 positions took place after the fatty alcohol was linked to the glycosides. Krespki and Walton ( 1 983) compared the formation of heterocyst glycolipids and glycerolipids during heterocyst formation. They concluded that biosynthesis of the hydrocarbon moieties of heterocyst glycolipids was regulated independently of fatty acid synthesis. In addition, they suggested that a n enzyme system for the hydroxylation of aliphatic hydrocarbon chains of the glycolipids was activated transiently during heterocyst formation. This process and heterocyst glycolipid synthesis are both increased by 7-azatryptophan (Krepski and Walton, 1983). Mohy-UdDhin el ul. (1982) suggested that the latter increased one or more steps of primary alkanol synthesis, making the (2-25 hydroxylation rate-limiting for the formation of the glycoside containing 1,3,-hexacosanetriol.
VI. STUDIES WITH HALOTOLERANT AND HALOPHILIC D U N A L I E L L A SPECIES Dunuliclla spp. possess some special features which make them attractive ex-
20
Environmental change
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
Organism
Effect
Reference
Nitrate increase ilnciej~s1i.rnidu1un.s .Spirul/nu pltrtc~I1.si.s Microc,j,stisuerugiiioscr 0.5cillur oriu ru hrscens
16:01 I 6 : I f 18:2t 18:31 N o change N o change
Piorreck ei nl. (1984) Piorreck P I a/. (1984) Piorreck ei ul. ( 1 984) Piorreck P I uI. ( 1984)
Increasing culture age
Agnienrlluni yuurlruplicuruni Anuh~rrnrrwriuhilis
16: 1. 18: It 1 8 : 2 , Olsonandingram 18:3J ( 1975) 18: l t 1 6 : O . 1 8 : 2 1 Gusevrru/.(1980)
Anaerobic growth
Apli~tio~lirc~c~ hulophj~ticu18 : 21 O.sc,iNtrtoriu linineticu No change
Oren ei a / . ( 1985)
Light presence
Various
No change
Kenyon el ul. ( 1972)
Light intensity
Anuc.j.sti.7 riidulnns
16:0, 1 8 : I f 1 6 : I J DohlerandDatz with increased light (1980)
Light quality
Anrrc~j~sti.~ nit1ulnn.s
GI ycerolipid changes
Temperature drop
Various
Chain length1 Unsaturationt See text Molecular species changes
Datz and Dohler (1981)
Fatty acid abbreviations as in Table I
perimental models. They grow rapidly under axenic conditions to yield populations of very homogeneous cells. Since they are without cell walls, they are easily disrupted and can therefore be separated into relatively pure subcellular fractions. Their lipid composition is rather similar to that of higher plants and is typical of green algae. Moreover, their ability to tolerate a wide range of temperatures and salinities (Brown and Borowitzka, 1979) allows the effects of these environmental stresses on metabolism to be studied. The lipids of two halotolerant species of Dunuliellu, ( D . purva and D.terriolectu) (Evons et ul., 1982a) and six halophilic species (D.viridis from the Dead Sea and various unidentified species from the Sinai) (Evans and Kates, 1984) have been examined. All these species were found to contain high proportions (40 mol %) of glycosylglycerides and low proportions (20 mol YO) of phosphoglycerides. The main glycolipids were MGDG, D G D G and SQDG. The main phospholipids were PG and PC. Analyses for the two halotolerant and two halophilic species are shown in Table VIII.
21
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
Glycosyl ester glycobpids
Glycosd~cglycolipi@
a-0-Glucopyranos yl 25-hydroxyhexacosa~te
3,2 5-Dihydroxyhexacosanyl-0-D-glycopyranoside
no
no
0- a n d
on
no ou
( 9 0 -1. )
0-D-Glucop yranosyl 25.27-dihydroxyoctacosaMte
Fig. 8.
OH
( 1 0 'I. )
YY
noon
on
3,25.27-Trihydroxyoctacosanyl-a-Dglycopyranoside
Structures of heterocyst glycolipids of cyanobacteria
TABLE VIII Lipid composit ion of h u b tolerant and haloph ilic Dun a I iella species Lipid
D. parva
Phosphatidylcholine Phosphatid ylethanolamine Phosphatidylinositol Phosphatid ylglycerol Phosphatidic acid Total phospholipid
9 n.d. 2 6 n.d 17
Monogalactosyldiacy lglycerol Digalactosyldiacylgl ycerol Sulphoquinovosyldiacylglycerol Other glycolipids Total glycolipids
21 II 7 I -
Diacylglycerol-0-(N,N,N-trimethyl)homoserine Non-esterified fatty acid Neutral lipids
D. tertiolecta
4 2 3
8 2 -
C,
D, ,
1 1 tr.
2 1 tr.
4 3 tr. n.d -
19
6
6
22 21
22 19
24
3
9
7 25
15 14 14 tr. tr. 55 53
40
10 tr. 53
15
8
13 15
7
14
15
21
Data expressed as mol YOand taken from Kates (1987) with permission n.d. = not detected.
22
J O H N L. H A R W O O D A N D A . LESLEY JONES
In general, halophilic species had lower levels of phospholipids and proportionally higher amounts of glycosylglycerides than halotolerant species. Moreover, PI, which was found in appreciable amounts in halotolerant species, was only found in trace amounts in the halophilic species. PE was not detected in D. parva. Significant amounts of neutral lipids, principally triacylglycerols and nonesterified fatty acids, were found in all species. These represented 15-25 mol YO and 7-14 niol ‘4, respectively, of the total lipid contents. Interestingly, diacylglycerol-O-4’-( N.N,N-trimethyl)-homoserine was identified as a major component (3 ~ 1 mol 4 Y O )in all species examined (Evans et al.. 1982b). As mentioned in Section 111, this zwitterionic non-phospholipid has been found in many algal species (Eichenberger, 1982; Sato and Furuya, 1985). including D. hrirckau~il(Fried Ct a/., 1982). I t is common also in lower plants (Sato and Furuya, 1984a,b) but has not been detected in any angiosperms or gymnosperms examined. The fatty acids of individual lipid fractions from all Dunalirlla species showed characteristics typical of other plant types, including angiosperms. Thus, palmitate was the major saturated fatty acid and this was enriched in SQDG of the glycolipids. The two galactosylglycerides were enriched in polyunsaturated fatty acids. MGDG was enriched in a-linoleic and hexadecatetraenoic acids. while DGDG contained high amounts of linoleic and x-linolenic acids. DGTS also contained a similar fatty acid content to DGDG. As in higher plants, PG contained high amounts of trans-A3hexadecenoate as well as appreciable amounts of palmitate, linoleate and alinolenate. D . .salina has been extensively studied at the subcellular level by Thompson’s group. Firstly, studies were made of phospholipid metabolism during growth at 30 C or 12 C or after temperature shifts. Generation times were found to correspond approximately to a Q,, of 2. with times of 20 h at 30 C and 80 h at 12 ‘C. Both cultures reached the same cell density but had rather different lipid and protein contents. In general, cells cultured at 12 C had a higher protein and acyl lipid content but a lower chlorophyll content than those grown at 30 C. Interestingly, the chlorophyll ujh ratio was 2.77 at 30 C but 4.09 at 12 C (Lynch and Thompson, 1982). The relative changes in acyl lipid and chlorophyll contents could be correlated with a proportional decrease in thylakoid membranes but an overall increase in cell volume at 12 C. When cells were shifted from 30°C to 12”C, no division occurred for about 96 h, after which division resumed, with a generation time of 80 h. The major particulate subcellular fractions were the chloroplast and microsomal. Whereas the chloroplast fraction was enriched at least four-fold in glycolipids compared to phospholipids, the microsomal fraction contained about twice as much phospholipid as glycolipid. Moreover, the relative proportion of cell phospholipid contained in chloroplasts was significantly reduced when cells were shifted to, or grown at, 12°C. This reflected the relat-
LIPID METABOLISM IN A L G A E
23
ive increase in microsomal menibrancs compared to thylakoids for cclls grown at lower temperatures (Lynch and Thompson, 1982). When the proportions of individual phospholipids of chloroplast or microsoma1 membranes were analysed, they were found to change little with growth temperature. For cells grown at either 30 C or 12 C, the major phospholipids of chloroplasts were PG and PC with smaller amounts of PE and PI. Microsomal menibranes contained PE and PC as the main phospholipids. In contrast, the relative proportions of glycolipids responded to temperature change. In particular, the relative content o f D G D G increased and that of M G D G decreased at 12 C. The ratio of M G D G to DGDG therefore changed from 3.4 in chloroplasts from 30 C cells to 2.1 for 12 C cells. Because poikilotherms need to maintain membrane fluidity at different growth temperatures, it was not surprising that phospholipid unsaturation was increased at 12 C for both chloroplast and microsomal membranes. In temperature-shift studies. the majority of these changes occurred after more than 60 h for chloroplast fatty acids. In the microsomal fraction, significant decreases in palmitate and increases in octadecatrienoate contents were seen within 12 h of temperature shift. Similarly, changes in the fatty acyl content of DGTS were also greater in the microsonial membranes. In contrast, the fatty acid patterns of the chloroplastic glycolipids changed little in response to growth temperature (Lynch and Thompson, 1982). The rather slow response of fatty acid unsaturation to shifts in growth temperature--especially for the chloroplast membranes-raised the obvious question as to how poikilotherms are able to withstand sudden changes in environmental conditions. Following observations with cyanobacteria (Section V), where an “emergency response” seemed to be the retailoring of individual molecular species (Sato and Murata, 198Oa,b), the phospholipids of D..sulinu membranes were examined in more detail. The individual phospholipids were isolated following thin-layer chromatography (TLC). a n d converted to diacylglycerols by digestion with phospholipase C; the diacylglycerols were separated by G L C of trimethylsilyl derivatives. Such procedures showed that there were significant changes in the molecular species of PE and PG. F o r PE there was a decrease in C,, species and co,ncomitant increases in C,, and C,, species. Changes associated with PG included the detection of a new molecular species, dioleoyl, not found at 30 C. Although there were some, limited, changes in fatty acid unsaturation detected during the first 12 h of low-temperature acclimation, it was concluded that the initial alterations in response to low temperatures involved discrete changes in certain molecular species. Such changes in molecular species composition would then augment the effects of acyl chain unsaturation in modifying membrane fluidity (Lynch and Thompson, 1984a). As mentioned above, changes in the fatty acyl composition of chloroplast phospholipids were much slower than for microsomal components. Thus only minor alterations in phospholipid acyl chain compositions were evident
24
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
after 36 h of shifting cells from 30 to 12 C. Between 36 h and 60 h, increases in the percentage of palmitate and a-linolenate were observed in PG. These alterations were accompanied by decreases in trans-A3-hexadecenoate and linoleate (Lynch and Thompson, 1984b). In contrast, the fatty acyl composi:ion of the other main chloroplast phospholipid, PC, did not alter very much over the 60-h period. Changes in the molecular species distribution for PC and PG were also seen after 60-h acclimation. The molecular species changes for PG correlated well with the overall fatty acyl changes. Thus, the 18 : 2/16 : I species was particularly reduced, in keeping with the decrease in both linoleate and rrans-A3hexadecenoate. Significant increases in molecular species containing palmitate and r-linolenate were seen-again in keeping with the fatty acid analysis (Lynch and Thompson. I984b). The change in molecular species of PG which occurred between 36 h and 60 h, following a shift in growth temperature, coincided with a large change in the threshold temperature of thermal desaturation of the photosynthetic apparatus. This was measured by chlorophyll fluorescence and, since lipid compositional changes other than those associated with PG were negligible during this period, suggested that a correlation existed between the molecular species of composition of PG and the thermal stability of the photosynthetic membrane. Taken together with the data on microsomal membrane compositional changes, the experiments suggested strongly that the initial steps in cellular acclimation to low temperatures involved molecular species retailoring. These changes then augmented the effects of increased acyl chain unsaturation as a means of restoring appropriate membrane properties (Lynch and Thompson, 1984~). Further studies on the subtle changes in acyl lipid molecular species used HPLC as the separation technique. Because of the poor absorbance of lipids in the UV. initial quantitation used the laborious procedure of effluent splitting and measurement by GLC of fatty acid methyl esters (Lynch and Thompson, 1983). However, the development of a flame ionization detector allowed more rapid quantitation and the procedure was applied to the analysis of D.sdina PG and galactosylglycerides (Smith et a/., 1985; Cho and Thompson, 1987). In Section IV, mention was made of the so-called prokaryotic and eukaryotic pathways for fatty acid and acyl lipid synthesis in eukaryotic organisms. The relationship between these two pathways in D.salznu was investigated in detail through radiolabelling with [I4C]palmitate, [I4C]oleate and [14C]laurateas precursors. Since only [I4C]laurate could be elongated in D. salina, palmitate gave rise to C,, acids only and oleate to C, , acids (Norman eta/., 1985). After a 2-min incubation with 4 pCi of [I-14C]palmitate, about 3% of the isotope was taken up per 5 x lo8 cells. This allowed experiments to be conducted with a 2-min labelling period followed by a chase period. During the total incubation a gradual movement of radioactivity was
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
25
seen from the microsomal membranes to the chloroplasts. This movement was associated with a decrease in phospholipid labelling and an increase in that of glycolipids. When the individual acyl groups were analysed, it was found that phospholipids only contained [I4C]palmitate. In contrast, glycolipids contained unsaturated C,, acids. After a 16-h chase, over 30% of the glycolipid radioactivity was accounted for by [14C]hexadecatetraenoate. Similarly, when [14C]oleatewas used in labelling studies, the radioactivity was incorporated initially into phospholipids of the microsomal membranes. After only a 20-min chase more than 50% of this microsomal phospholipid labelling was in the form of [*4C]linoleate,showing the presence of an active extra-chloroplastic A1 2-desaturase. By 16 h, chloroplast phospholipids contained 58% and 12% of their radioactivity in linoleate and sr-linolenate, respectively. In contrast, chloroplast glycolipids contained over 70% of their radioactivity as a-linolenate. These results confirmed that in D.salina, as in higher plants (Harwood, 1988), desaturation of oleate occurs mainly outside the chloroplasts, followed by transfer of the resultant linoleate back into plastids for its desaturation to a-linolenate in association with glycosylglycerides. When [I4C]lauratewas used as precursor, the acid entered the chloroplast quite rapidly, where it was used by the de n o w synthesizing enzymes and gave rise to radiolabelled C,, and C , , fatty acids. Moreover, in contrast to [ 14C]palmitate labelling, [‘4C]laurate incorporation resulted in the accumulation of appreciable [’4C]trans-A3-hexadecenoate. These studies were extended to a consideration of the molecular species of PG which were radiolabelled during temperature stress. When[14C]palmitate was used as precursor for a 2-min pulse, the specific radioactivity of PG was higher initially than that of any other microsomal phospholipid. The major molecular species of microsomal PG (80%) was 16 : 0/18 : 2, with about 45% of the 16 : O/ 16 : 0 species. Smaller amounts of 16 : O/ 14 : 2 species were also present (Lynch and Thompson, 1984a). In spite of the heavy concentration of 16 : 0 at the sn-l position, analysis of the radiolabelled PG by phospholipase A, digestion revealed that 30% of the [I4C]palmitate wgs present initially at the sn-2 position. In fact, immediately after labelling, the specific radioactivity of the palmitate at the sn-2 position was 10 times that at the sn- 1 position. Molecular species analysis by HPLC confirmed that [I4C]palmitate was preferentially incorporated into the 16 : 0/16 : 0 species. During the cold-chase period a changing pattern of incorporation of [L4C]palmitateinto either microsomal or chloroplast PG was seen. Thus, whereas microsomal PG always contained more radioactivity at the sn-l position, chloroplast PG initially contained radioactivity almost exclusively at the sn-2 position. With time, both positions of chloroplast PG became equally labelled. These results indicate the “prokaryotic” nature of chloroplast PG synthesis initially, and it is only later that molecular species of presumed microsomal origin appear in the plastid (Norman and Thompson,
26
J O H N L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
I985a). I n fact, further analysis of the chloroplastic molecular species showed that 18: 2/16: 0 was labelled initially, followed only later by 16: Ojl8 : 2 species. When [I"C]laurate was used as precursor, the acid was rapidly taken up by chloroplasts, where it was used by fatty acid synthetase to produce [14C]palmitate and [14C]stearate, and the latter was desaturated to [14C]oleate.These products were rapidly exported to the endoplasmic reticulum, where PG was labelled more rapidly than other microsomal phospholipids. I n marked contrast, chloroplast PG contained no radiolabelled C , fatty acids. Immediately after the 2-min labelling period, this phospholipid contained large amounts of ['4C]laurate, but within 10 min of chase, [I"C]palmitate was the major radiolabelled moiety. In keeping with the proposal that 1 -acyl,2-palmitoyl-PG is the substrate for the A3-desaturase (Harwood and James, 1975), the decline in radioactive palmitate during the 20-60-min chase period was matched by an equivalent rise in the labelling of truns-A3-hexadecenoate. As mentioned above. the proportions of dilrerent cellular membranes in Dutitrlir//rr changes with low-temperature growth. There were also significant changes in the metabolism of chilled cells. Thus, for example. there was no delay in the labelling of the sn-l position of chloroplast PG from [lSC]palmitatein chilled cells. This was due to the increased contribution of "eukaryotic" (microsomal) metabolism at lower temperatures. Moreover, this was in keeping with the previous observations that the molecular species composition of microsomal PG responded more quickly to temperature stress than that of chloroplasts (Lynch and Thompson, 1984a.b). If niicrosomal phospholipids are retailored initially in response to temperature stress. then there should be appropriate enzymes present to remove and re-esterify the different acyl groups (Lynch and Thompson, 1984~).The first enzyme needed would be a phospholipase A and, indeed, such an enzyme has been reported in D..su/inu (Norman and Thompson, 1986). Microsomes, but not chloroplasts. contained a fatty acyl hydrolase with high activity towards endogenous or exogenous PG and PE. The enzyme had little activity towards other phospholipids or MGDG. Because no monoacyl products could be detected, it was not possible to analyse independently the activities of any specific enzymes, such as phospholipase A , or A,, or lysophospholipase which might be present. Lipolysis was most active in the presence of 10 mM C a 2 + , and was enhanced by calmodulin and inhibited by calmodulin antagonists, such as W-7 or 48/80. Most interestingly, the acyl hydrolase activity of 30 C-grown cells was low when measured in vitro at 12 C. However, when cells were chilled to 12'C, activity as measured at 12 C in vitro rapidly increased, thereby providing the mechanism for retailoring phospholipids during low-temperature acclimation. The low acyl hydrolase activity in chloroplasts from similarly treated cells emphasized the key role of micro-
27
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
18:1/16:0 MGDG
18:2/16:0 DGDG 18 1/16 1 MGDG
18 1/16 1 DGDG
18 3/16 0 DGDG
D' s
18 3/16 4 MGDG
>18
3/16 4DGDG
l i g . 9. Pathways for galactosylglyccridc synthesis in Diititrlidltr plasts. Redrawn from Cho and Thompson (1987) with permission.
.srr/inti
chloro-
soma1 metabolism in temperature adaptation (Norman and Thompson, 1986). Although the labelling of galactosylglycerides in D.siilinu has not been studied in as much detail as that of the phospholipids. a recent report describes labelling of molecular species from I4C-labelled fatty acids (Cho and Thompson, 1987), and a fatty acyl hydrolase preferentially attacking MGDG has been reported (Cho and Thompson, 1986). The results of the labelling studies are summarized in Fig. 9. They showed that, as expected (Harwood, 1988), the initial molecular species of MGDG labelled by &novo synthesis was the 18 : 1/16 : 0. This molecular species could then be further desaturated at both positions to eventually produce the highly unsaturated 18: 3/16:4 species. However, after the initial desaturation to 1 8 : 1/16: I , this species (like others) of MGDG was a substrate for galactosylation. The DGDG so produced was itself a substrate for continued desaturation. The 18 : 1/16 : 0 species of MGDG could be galactosylated but the DGDG so produced could only be desaturated at the sn-l position to yield a-linolenate. No further metabolism of palmitate at the sn-2 position took place (Cho and Thompson, 1987). These observations are particularly interesting because not only do they provide further evidence for the involvement of complex (galactosylglycerides) lipids as substrates for desaturations, but they also confirm that ( I ) lipid-linked acyl chains can be subject to a whole series of desaturations and ( 2 ) that several lipid types (in this case DGDG as well as MGDG) may serve as substrates for an individual desaturation. These topics are reviewed more fully in Harwood ( 1 988).
28
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
VII.
METABOLISM I N MARINE ALGAE A.
LABELLING CHARACTERISTICS
There have been relatively few studies on the lipid metabolism of marine macroalgae. There is now, however, a considerable body of work on their lipid and fatty acid compositions. Earlier work in this area has been summarized by Pohl and Zurheide (1979a). Most of the lipids which are found in marine algae occur in higher plants, although there are exceptions, and marked contrasts are seen in the lipid patterns of different algal divisions (Table IX). Marine algae have a characteristic pattern of polyunsaturated fatty acids which is quite distinct from that of higher plants (see Section Ill), and again reflects differences among the algal divisions (Pohl and Zurheide, 1979a). These observed differences in marine algal lipids and fatty acid content are presumably a reflection of differing metabolism, but there is very little detailed information available. The marine algae typically contain high proportions of polyunsaturated fatty acids (e.g. Jamieson and Reid, 1972; Pohl and Zurheide, 1979a). The brown and red algae contain arachidonic (20 : 4. w-6,9,12,15) and eicosapentaenoic (20 : 5 , w-3,6,9,12,15) acids as major fatty acids, with the brown algae tending to have more of the former and the red algae more of the latter. The green algae have only small amounts of C,, fatty acids, but do contain C,, and C , , fatty acids, which are more unsaturated than those of higher plants. Entrromorphu intrstinalis, a marine green macroalga, has among its major fatty acids a-linolenic acid ( 18 : 3, w-6,9,12), which is typical of higher plant photosynthetic tissue, and also octadecatetraenoic (18 : 4, w-3,6,9,12) and hexadecatetraenoic ( 1 6 : 4, w-3,6,9,12) acids (Jones and Harwood, 1987). Octadecatetraenoate is found in some higher plants, e.g. borage (Stymne rt ul., 1987). In this species, octadecatetraenoate is formed from cz-linolenate while esterified to MGDG (Griffiths et al., 1988). Labelling studies on the fatty acids of algae using [I4C]acetate show that the major fatty acids labelled are generally palmitate and oleate. Incorporation of radioactivity into palmitoleate, stearate and the more polyunsaturated C ,, fatty acids with long-chain C,,, C,, and occasionally C,, saturated fatty acids (Table X), is usually seen also. This indicates that the initial pathway of fatty acid synthesis is similar to that of higher plants, but that additional desaturase and elongase enzymes must be present for the production of the complete marine algal fatty acid pattern. The long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids are themselves synthesized slowly, as indicated by time-course studies for up to 24 h with [I4C]acetate, when n o radiolabel accumulates in arachidonate or eicosapentaenoate (Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L., unpublished). A preliminary report for Porphyra yezoensis suggests a route for chain elongation and desaturation in this alga, but further studies are needed to confirm this (Kayama et al., 1986).
TABLE IX The lipid composition of marine algae representing different algal divisions Lipid
Phaeophyta
Rhodophyta
Chlorophyta
F. serratus
F. vesiculosus
Ascophyllum nodosum
Chondrus crispus
Polysiphonia lanosa
E. intestinalis
MGDG DGDG SQDG X
18.1 23.1 32.9 7.5
15.0 11.3 22.0 24.1
19.7 16.6 19.4 17.2
17.6 12.8 14.7 n.d.
17.6 24.6 11.9 n.d.
45.9 14.8 14.8 n.d.
PC PE PG PI DPG DGTS
4.3 5.7 2.5 2.1 4.2
4.2 6.2 2.2 2.9 5.4
3. I 9.8 1.5 2.5 3.1
31.6" 1.8 8.2
18.3" 1.5 5.0
-
-
-
4.9
5.0
7.6
15.0
1.8
2.1
1.8
2.7
NL
Rest
1.6
Data as means n = 3-7; X, unidentified glycolipid; n.d., none detected. Results expressed as YOtotal lipid "PC+ PSC
-
1.5 -
2.6
1.5
-
13.7
3.3
30
J O H N L. H A R W O O D A N D A. LESLEY J O N E S
TABLE X Rudioluhelling
(?f:firttj'acids f r o m
[ ' 4C]uce1ate in various marine algae
Fatty acid (YOtotal fatty acids) 1 4 : 0 16:0 16.1 18:O 1 8 : l 1 8 : 2 2 0 : 0 22:O Others Phaeophyta F. si~rrutiis 5 F. i~e.cicu1osu.c 3.4 A.vc~op/ivlluninorlosion 2.6
42.0 16.0 19.9
Rhodophyta C'honclrus c ~ i ~ p t i . s Polj~siphoniuItrrro.srr
I .5 6.5
5.7 40.9
Chlorophyta E. intc.stinu1i.s
1.7
9.8
13 I 17 1.8 12.1 41.1 tr 11.6 43.3
2 3.8 4.8
6 5.3 4.0
12.0 10.9
3.8 62.6 7.2 21.5
4.3
3.5 4.8
2.8
2.2 42.1
9.2
~
2.9
10 8.9 9.2
4 7.7 4.1
4.6
2.8
~
~
8.7
16.5"
" ~ 1 83: + IX.4: tr
= <0.5"%. Labclling X h in the light at 15 C. F. .serru/u.s at 20 C . Fatty acid abbreviations as for Table I . Data for F. .scrrLrfu.sfrom Smith a n d Harwood (1984a). Othcr d a t a from Jones. A . L. a n d Harwood. J . L. (unpublishcd).
The major lipids of most of the marine macroalgae that have been studied are the glycolipids (Table IX). In the fucoids, Fucus vesiculosus, F. serriitus and Ascophylluni nodosuni, they account for 70- 80% of the total acyl lipids (Smith and Harwood, 1984a; Jones and Harwood, 1987). Similarly high proportions are found in the red and green algae (Pettitt et d.,1988b; Jones and Harwood, 1987) as well as in cyanobacteria and some fresh-water green algae (Section 111). The leaf tissues of higher plants have comparable proportions of glycolipids (Harwood, 1980a), but higher plants generally have more MGDG (25-45%) and less SQDG (10%). All the marine algae so far examined have significantly more SQDG (Table IX). E. intestinalis has the glycolipid distribution most similar to that of higher plant leaf tissue, with 46% MGDG. It has been postulated that the high levels of glycolipids in algae indicate their location in membrane systems other than the chloroplast thylakoids (Smith et ul., 1982). This idea is partially supported by work on Polj,siphonia lunosa, which indicated that the chloroplast lipid content was similar to that of the whole tissue (Pettitt, T. P. and Harwood, J. L., unpublished results). In most of the algae studied, the glycolipids appear to be similar to those of higher plants. However, some unusual glycolipids have been detected. PhamQuang and Laur (1976a,b,c) reported unusual glycolipid structures in several fucoids, and other sugars (such as mannose and rhamnose) have been detected which may partly replace the galactose of MGDG and SQDG in the red algae Chondrus crispus and Polysiphonia lanosa (Pettitt and Harwood, 1986). Pham-Quang and Laur (1976b) found unusual sulpholipids in some
31
LIPID METABOLISM IN A L G A E
Ascoplij~llunitiodosuni
Lipid
"o/
I4C Lipids
F. wsicdosus
F. sewatus
"h I4C Lipids
YOI4C Lipids YO3 2 P Lipids
5.8 1.4 13.2 16.3
8. I 2.1 12.5 28.4
9.2" 4.P 9.0 19.2
1 .9 6.3 4.4 I .4 6.9
2.3 6.8 3.9 2.6 3.7
2.4 4.0
Neutral lipids
17.4
23. I
11.3
Rest
25.3
6.5
4.0
MGDG DGDG SQDG
X PC PE PG DPG PI
2.3
5.4 50.0 7.0 12.2 15.4
10.0
"MGDG includes DPG. *DGDG includes PG. Data as means. I I = 2 or 3 . Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L. (unpublished) and Smith P I cil. (1982)
fucoids, and Chondrus crispus and Polysiphoniu lunosu contained lipids other than SQDG which were detected by 35S-labelling. In both these red algae one of these sulpholipids was probably PSC (Pettitt et ul., 1988b), the sulphurcontaining analogue of PC first noted in the diatom N . ulhu (Anderson et ul., 1978a,b). The glycolipids of the brown algae F. serrutus, F. vesiculosus and Ascophyllum nodosum tend to be poorly labelled from [I4C]acetate in relation to their abundance (Table XI). However, SQDG is well labelled, particularly in Ascophyflum notlosum. This may be a reflection of the higher proportion of C , , and C ,, saturated and mono-unsaturated fatty acids in SQDG, because such acids are more rapidly labelled than the polyunsaturated C,, fatty acids which constitute a major proportion of the MCDG and DGDG acyl chains. MGDG has a higher proportion of label at all incubation times than DGDG, and this may partly reflect a possible role as substrate for the desaturation of linoleate to linolenate, by analogy with higher plants (Roughan e f ul., 1979; Wharfe and Harwood, 1978). However, any discussion of desaturationelongation reactions in these marine algae is complicated by the presence of a much greater variety of polyunsaturated fatty acids than occurs in higher plants. Another notable feature of lipid labelling in these algae is the high propor-
32
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
T A B L E XI1 Unsaturrctron indices of red and brown algal glycoliprdJ Lipid
F. vesiculosus Ascophyllum nodosum
Chondrus crispus
Polysiphoniu
Porphyrtr
lanasa
.13rzoensis
MGDG
3.5
3.4
4.6(1) 2.1 (2)
4.0(1) 2.4 (2)
4.8 ( I ) 2.3 (2)
DGDG
3.1
2.8
2.1
2.4
3.6
SQDG
1.5
0.8
3.4 ( I ) 1.9 (2)
I .4
2.5
Unsaturation index
( % ratty acid x no. double bonds)
= ~-
~~~
~
~~~~
I00
Where twc: bands were detected by TLC. the raster running band is designated ~ ~ ( ~ : o ~ data m i . sfrom Araki (I!ul. (1986).
( I ) . Porphyrci
tion of label found in lipid X (Table XI). This unknown lipid is clearly an important constituent of the fucoids, but its role in metabolism is difficult to assess, as it remains unidentified (Smith and Harwood, 1984a; Jones and Harwood, 1987). It is an acyl lipid with no net charge which stains positively with Dragendorf reagent, indicating the possible presence of a quarternary amino group. It does not contain phosphorus or sulphur. In Chondrus crispus the glycolipids are all poorly labelled from [I4C]acetate, but in Polysiphoniu lanosa the proportion of label in these lipids is much higher (Pettitt, T. R. and Harwood, J. L., unpublished). In E . intestinalis, SQDG is poorly labelled but MGDG and DGDG are fairly well labelled. As noted previously, the fatty acid and lipid pattern of E. intestinulis is different from that of the brown and red algae and, therefore, differences in lipid labelling are not unexpected (Jones and Harwood, 1987). In all these algae, as in higher plants, MGDG is the most unsaturated lipid (Smith and Harwood, 1984a; Jones and Harwood, 1987; Pettitt and Harwood, 1986). The relative unsaturation of the glycolipids of brown and red algae is shown in Table XII. Double bands occur on TLC for DGDG of F. vesiculosus and Ascophyllum nodosum (Jones and Harwood, 1987), for MGDG and SQDG of Chondrus crispus (Pettitt et al., 1988a; Jones and Harwood, 1987), and for MGDG of Porphyra yezoensis (Araki et d., 1986) and Polysiphoniu lanosa. The faster running band (band 1) has a higher unsaturation index in all cases (Table XII). Separation of double bands is caused by binding materials in commercial silica gel plates. The more saturated band is generally more highly labelled (Pettitt et al., 1988a). A similar range of phospholipids is found in marine algae to that of higher plants. All the eukaryotic marine algae so far examined have PG with trans-
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
33
A3-hexadecenoate, typical of higher plant chloroplasts (see Gounaris et al., 1986). As granal stacking is limited in the brown algae and does not occur in the red algae, this is further evidence that this is not the role of trans-A3hexadecenoate (e.g. Roughan, 1984). Caron et al. (1985) reported PG containing trans-A3-hexadecenoate to be preferentially associated with the lightharvesting complexes of F. serratus, but point out that its role may not be the same in algae as in higher plants. PE is the major phospholipid of the brown algae and PC of the red algae. PE and PC in the brown algae and PC in the red algae are highly unsaturated and tend to be only poorly labelled from [14C]acetate (Table XI). Arachidonate and eicosapentaenoate tend to be major components of these lipids (Section 111). The only detailed study of phospholipid metabolism in marine algae is that of Smith et al. (1982). [32P]Orthophosphate labelling in F. serratus showed phosphatidate to be labelled at short time intervals, with labelling decreasing as the incubation time increased, a result which would be expected if phosphatidate is an intermediate in phospholipid biosynthesis (Moore, 1982; Harwood, 1989). A concomitant rise in 32P-labellingin PI and PE was seen, although PC was poorly labelled at all time intervals. As PC was well labelled from [14C]acetate in this alga, such a result may reflect the role of PC as a substrate for desaturation of oleate to linoleate, as in higher plants (see Harwood, 1988). In E. intestinalis no PC was detected and only a small amount of PE. However, this alga contains DGTS, which was first reported in 0. danicu (Brown and Elovson, 1974). It has been found in various single-celled green algae (Eichenberger, 1982; Evans et al., 1982b), bryophytes and pteridophytes (Sato and Furuya, 1984b). As discussed in Section 111, various marine Chlorophyceae contain this lipid, including Ulva lucruca (Sato and Furuya, 1984b) and E. intestinalis (Jones and Harwood, 1987). In E intestinalis this lipid is a significant component (Table IX). It too is a Dragendorf-positive lipid with no net charge, but it does not have the same characteristics on TLC as the unknown lipid X of brown algae (Smith and Harwood, 1984a; Jones and Harwood, 1987). Eichenberger (1982) analysed several algal ‘species for the presence of DGTS and detected none in F. vesiculosus either. It has previously been noted that DGTS is often present in algae with little or no PC (Sato and Furuya, 1984a,b). In Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, which contains no PC, DGTS may be the substrate for the desaturation of oleate to linoleate, a role attributed to PC in higher plants (Schlapfer and Eichenberger, 1983; Section VIII). In D . salina, PC and DGTS are both present, and have similar fatty acid distributions. Metabolic studies using 14C-labelled fatty acid traces also indicate a close metabolic relationship between these lipids (Norman and Thompson, 1985b; Section VI). In E. intestinalis we have carried out labelling studies with [14C]acetate and found DGTS to be only poorly labelled compared with labelling of the glycolipids MGDG and DGDG and the phospholipid PG.
34
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
TABLE XI11 Percentage MGDG derived from prokaryotic (chloroplastic) or eukaryotic (cytoplasmic) pathways of lipid synthesis Prokaryotic or 16.[16
16-[18+20
Eukaryotic
Reference or
18+2~-r18+20 18+20-r16
Entcromorpha spp.
95
5
Ulva spp.
90
10
Rullkotter et al. (1975)
C. vulgaris
60
40
Roughan and Slack ( I 984)
Phaeodacrylum tricornutum
90
10
Arao et al. (1987)
Porphyra yezoensis
20
80
Araki et al. ( 1 987)
F. vesiculosus
10
90
Jones and Harwood (unpublished)
Heinz (1 977)
B. POSITIONAL DISTRIBUTION OF ALGAL FATTY ACIDS
In higher plants there are two pathways producing the diacylglycerol moieties for incorporation into glycolipids (e.g. Roughan and Slack, 1984; FrentZen, 1986; Joyard and Douce, 1987). The chloroplastic pathway produces lipids with a typically prokaryotic arrangement of fatty acids, i.e. with C , , fatty acids at the sn-2 position as in the cyanobacteria (Zepke et al., 1978). The PG of the photosynthetic membranes is of the prokaryotic type in all plants (Murata et al., 1982). The cytoplasmic pathway produces lipids with C,, fatty acids at the sn-2 position. Marine green algae generally show a prokaryotic fatty acid distribution in.their MGDG (Table XIII) (Rullkotter et al., 1975; Heinz, 1977). Phaeodactylis tricornutum (a marine diatom) also shows this typically prokaryotic MGDG (Arao et al., 1987). In F. vesiculosus, however, 10% of the C,, fatty acids are esterified to the sn-2 position of MGDG (Jones and Harwood, unpublished), and this is similar to published data for Chattonella antiqua (Sato et al., 1987), a raphidophyte and a member of the Chromophyta (organisms with chlorophylls a and c). More unusual is the situation in Porphyra yezoensis. In this alga only 20% of the MGDG appears to be derived from the prokaryotic pathway, yet the DGDG appears to be almost entirely chloroplastic in origin (Araki et al., 1987). On the basis of our current understanding of the synthesis of DGDG from MGDG in higher plants, it is difficult to see how this occurs (e.g. Joyard and Douce, 1987).
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
35
Sato et al. (1987) also noted positional specificity in the distribution of other fatty acids between the sn-1 and sn-2 positions in Chattonella antiqua. Eicosapentaenoate is enriched at the sn-1 position in MGDG, DGDG and SQDG, but at the sn-2 position in DGTS and PE. In Phueoductylis tricornutum, this acid was located at the sn-1 position in all the polar lipids except PC (Arao et al., 1987; Kawaguchi et al., 1987). In F. vesiculosus eicosapentaenoate is located (almost exlusively) at the sn-1 position in MGDG and DGDG, and mostly at the sn-1 position in SQDG (Fig. 10; Jones and Harwood, unpublished results), and preliminary results indicate that in PC and PE eicosapentaenoate occurs at both sn-1 and sn-2 positions. In F. vesiculosus MGDG and DGDG and Chattonella antiqua MGDG, octadecatetraenoate occurs at the sn-2 position, as it does in Borago (Stymne et al., 1987). These results from a range of algal species indicate some positional specificity in the transacylation (and, possibly, elongation) reactions for fatty acyl chains, and this specificity differs in both nature and extent in different algae. Generally, however, it appears that in the galactolipids of chromophytes, eicosapentaenoate is esterified to the sn-1 position (Fig. 10). Although C , , acids are not common membrane components of most terrestrial plants, they have been detected at the sn-2 position in some species (Auling et al., 1971).
C. EFFECTS OF THE ENVIRONMENT ON ALGAL LIPID METABOLISM
1. Light Light has a marked effect on the lipid composition of photosynthetic tissues in higher plants, synthesis of the typical chloroplast lipids MGDG, DGDG, SQDG and PG being stimulated in the light, as is the desaturation of their acyl chains (see Harwood, 1983). In Chondrus crispus the total amount of [' 4C]acetate incorporated in the light was higher than in the dark, and a marked increase was noted in PG labelling (Table XIV); this also occurs in Polysiphonia lanosa (Pettitt and Harwood, unpublished results). However, in F. serratus labelling of PG from [14C]acetatedid not increase significantly in the light (Table XIV), although a small but significant increase in PG labelling from [32P]orthophosphate did occur (Smith et ul., 1982). In Chondrus crispus, Polysiphonia lanosa (Pettitt, T. R. and Harwood, J. L., unpublished) and Bryopis maxima (a green marine alga) (Ohnishi and Yamada, 1977), light increased the proportion of oleate and linoleate labelled from [14C]acetate, with decreases in the amount of saturated fatty acids (Table XV). Algal metabolism in this respect appears similar to that of higher plants. The importance of the polyunsaturated C,, fatty acids is difficult to assess as they are labelled only slowly from [14C]acetate. This makes it difficult to study the effect of altered environmental parameters on these important fatty acids in vitro, although some conclusions can be drawn from a
36
JOHN L. HARWOOD AND A. LESLEY JONES
F. vesiculosus MGOG
8%~(~,
18: 18:4 2 65% 18:3
7%
OGDG
16%
1
18:4 5S0/
1 8 : 3 14%
18:2 12%
(3)
(2)
? i vezoensis MGDG
DGDG
-20:5 86% 16:O 9%
18:1 8% 18:2 5%
16:O 76% 18:l 9% 18:2 9%
(2I
-Gal.Gal
Fig. 10. Positional distribution of fatty acids in the galactosylglycerides of two marine algae. See text for details.
study of endogenous fatty acid content when algae are harvested under different environmental conditions. No results have so far been reported of the effect of light on the synthesis and occurrence of C,, fatty acids in marine algae. 2. Temperature Temperature is known to affect the lipid composition of many organisms, and these effects are thought to be a response of the organism to maintain fluidity in, and hence function of, membranes. The alterations that occur in
37
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
TABLE XIV Effect of light on radiolabelling from [32P]orthophosphateor [I4C]acetatein the acyl lipids of F. serratus and Chondrus crispus respectively
F.serratus'
Lipid
Dark
Chondrus crispusb Light
MGDG DGDG SQDG 54.3 f 5.9 10.3 f 1.0 4.9 f 1.9 9.8 f 0.6 1.4 f 0.4 19.3 f 2.9
PE PG PC DPG PA PI
52.1 f 8.6 11.6 f 0.8' 19.3 f 2.9 10.8 f 2.4 1.5 f 0.3 18.9 f 3.3
Dark
Light
10.3 f 0.2 1.9 f 0.4 9.3 f 0.6
14.3 f 2.6' 6.9 f 0.6 13.0 f 5.0
5.4 f 2.0 27.0 f 1.1
18.5 f 1.7' 17.6 f 2.9'
"Data from Smith er at. (1982). bData from Pettitt and Harwood (1987). 'P<0.05 Labelling in F.serratus was with [32P]orthophosphate and in Chondrus crispus with (I4C]acetate. Results are % of total acyl lipid labelled.
TABLE XV Effect of light on the distribution of radioactivity from [I4C]acetateamongst acyl chains in F. serratus and Chondrus crispus Distribution of label (YO14C-labelledfatty acids) 14:O
16:O
F. serratus' Dark 3.4 f 0.5 47.7 f 7.8 Light 3.2 f 0.4 31.5 f 5.4' Chondrus crispusb 6 f l Dark 1f 1 Light
31fl 19 f 2
16:l
-
2 f l 3f2
18:O
18: 1
18:2
Others
12.9 f 2.4 29.6 f 6.3 0.9 f 0.7 5.5 f 1.4 9.9 f 0.5 42.6 f 6.0' 9.4 f 1.6' 3.5 f 1.4 7&3 tr'
40f6 64f6'
3ftr IOfT
I l f l 3 f 5
'Data from Smith and Hanvood (1984b). bData from Pettitt and Hanvood (1987).
'P<0.05
Incubation for F. serratus was carried out for 7 h at 20°C. and for Chondrus crispus for 24 h at 15°C. Fatty acid abbreviations as for Table I.
38
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
plant membranes in response to decreased temperatures lower the phase transition temperature of the membrane lipids, and these effects have been best studied in the single-celled marine green alga D . salina (Section VI). Major strategies which maintain membrane fluidity despite lowered temperature are a reduction in fatty acid chain length, an increase in unsaturation and changes in positional distribution of acids. These changes have been seen in higher plants (Harwood, 1983) and Tables XVI and XVII show that they also occur in some marine algae. Some, but by no means all, higher plants also alter the levels of their complex acyl lipids (Clarkson er al., 1980), though this may also reflect a change in the subcellular morphology of responsive cells (see Harwood, 1989). The relatively constant endogenous fatty acid pattern of Ascophyllum nodosum in winter and summer has been noted before (Jamieson and Reid, 1972). However, many other algae do show increased unsaturation of their fatty acids in winter-the saturation indices of F. vesiculosus, Polysiphonia lanosa and Chondrus crispus are higher in February than in June (Table XVI). Pohl and Zurheide (1979b) reported increased unsaturation in F. vesiculosus and Phycodrys sinuosa from the Baltic Sea in the winter. Changes in unsaturation indices in F. vesiculosus follow very closely changes in sea-water temperature (Pohl and Zurheide, 1979b). In Polysiphonia lanosa the level of eicosapentaenoate-the most unsaturated fatty acid in this alga-drops significantly in the summer (Table XVI). In both Ascophyllum nodosum and Polysiphonia lanosa, labelling from [I4C]acetate shows increased unsaturation of fatty acids at 5°C compared with 15°C. In particular, labelling of the long-chain saturated fatty acids 20 : 0 and 22 : 0 is lower at 5"C, indicating less elongation of saturated fatty acids at lower temperatures. In Chondrus crispus there is increased labelling of C I 4 + C l 6fatty acids at 15°C and decreased labelling of C,, fatty acids, although a higher proportion of unsaturated fatty acids are labelled at 15°C (Table XVII). Another seasonal alteration in lipid metabolism is the distribution of label from [14C]acetate amongst the neutral lipids from algae collected in summer compared with those collected in winter. F. vesiculosus from the Baltic Sea was reported to have reduced triacylglycerol levels in winter (Pohl and Zurheide, 19796) and labelling patterns in F. serratus also change in a similar way. F. serratus collected in summer accumulates [14C]acetate into triacylglycerol, whereas in the winter, label was incorporated into unesterified fatty acids. This may, therefore, be related to an accumulation of triacylglycerol as a storage product in the summer with subsequent breakdown in the winter. In Chondrus crispus, increased labelling of SQDG and DGDG was seen at higher temperatures, and it has been suggested that a similar mechanism to that seen in wheat is in operation (Pettitt, T. R., Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L., unpublished). In wheat, modification of SQDG fatty acids occurs during temperature acclimation (Vigh et al., 1985). However, there is no
TABLE XVI Eflect of season on the fatty acid composition of red and brown algae Alga
Ascophyllum nodosum F. vesiculosus
Chondrus crispus Polysiphonia Ianosa
Fatty acid (% total fatty acid) 16:O
16:l
18:O
18.1
Feb. June
14
2 2
tr.
28 27
9 11
6
15
Feb. June
16 21
1
tr.
11
10
10
2
1
25
10
7
Feb. June
24 34
5 6
I
12 9
2
2
1
1 1
Feb. June
29 32
8 8
12 1
3
-
~
Data as means n = 2.3; tr. = <0.5%. Fatty acid abbreviations as for Table I. Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L. (unpublished)
1
tr.
1
18:2 18:3
5
18:4 20:4 20:5 Others
5
4
5 4
16 18
9 8
12 9
1.95 1.98
9 4
15 15
16 8
11 6
2.38 1.84
4
21 18
29 22
5 tr.
2.53 2.18
6 6
38 26
4 5
2.40 1.95
-
2
Saturation index
-
1
40
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
TABLE XVII Effect of temperature on labelling of fatty acids from [14C]acetate
Alga
Distribution of label (YO14C-labelledfatty acids)
Temperature (-C)
14:O 16:O 16:l 18:O 18:l 18:2 18:3 20:O 22:O Others
Ascophyllum nodosum
5 15
2 14 4 2 4
-
1 1 59 1 1 0 3 7
10
F. vesiculosus
5 15
3 13 4 1 8
tr 9 75 4 1 2 4 0
tr 7
Chondrus crispus Polysiphonia lanosa
5 15 5 15
1 2 8 37
10
3 8
23 36
-
8 t r tr 1
tr
tr
4
4
-
-
5
5
tr 4
-
3
-
2 tr
6 5
12 11
5 3 - - - - - 34 - - -
15 11
3 10
36 29
7
-
tr
-
2 4
4 9
1
2
Labelling for 24 h in the light: tr = <0.5%. Results from Jones, A. L. and Harwood. J. L. (unpublished).
indication in any alga so far studied of the alteration in ratio of PE to PC seen in frost-resistant rye (Clarkson et al., 1980). There are several possible molecular mechanisms for altering membrane fluidity in plants (see Harwood, 1989), most of which may apply to marine algae. The details of these mechanisms are generally unclear, although there are suggestions, for example, that desaturation rates may be linked to oxygen concentrations which are higher at low temperatures (Rebeille et al., 1980). The response of marine algal acyl lipids to changes in temperature is particularly complex in view of the relatively large range of their polyunsaturated fatty acids.
3. Heavy Metals The heavy metal concentrations to which marine algae are exposed vary with the consumption of the underlying rock and with the amount of pollution. The effects of industrial pollution may raise levels of heavy metals in sea water many-fold, especially for transient periods. The marine algae cannot prevent the uptake of metals, and accumulate them, often to 1 0 0 ~ 1 0 , 0 0 0 fold the concentration in sea water (Bryan and Hummerstone, 1973; Bryan, 1980). The metals are probably sequestered in cell walls or physodes of brown algae (Lignell et a f . ,1982; Smith et al., 1986), thus reducing potential toxicity. However, heavy metal exposure has been found to affect lipid metabolism, and a selection of green, red and brown algae have been studied. In E. intestinalis and Chondrus crispus, although Cu2' and Cd2+ are taken up by the algae, no effect on lipid metabolism was seen using either an acute or chronic incubation with the metals. The fatty acid labelling from
41
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE T A B L E XVIII
EHect of Cu2+ on the ratio of counts found in the aqueous and organic phases of'a Garbus extraction
cu*
Alga
F. serratus
F. vesiculosus
+
( p g 1- 1 )
Ratio d.p.m. organic/aqueous
+ 0.6
0 30 300
4.4 f 1.7 4.0 f 0.2"
0 1000
3.5 f 1 . 1 7.1 f 1.2"
2.6
"Significantlydifferent ( P i 0 . l ) Results are means f S.D. (n = 3). The extraction method is described in Smith and Harwood (1984) and results are taken from that reference and Jones, A. L. and Hanvood, J. L. (unpublished).
[14C]acetatewas unaffected, as was the labelling of complex lipids (Jones and Harwood, unpublished). The best-studied marine alga with regard to the effects of heavy metals on lipid metabolism is F. serratus. Cd2+,Pb2 and ZnZ caused a decrease in the incorporation of [14C]acetateinto complex lipids, but few changes in the distribution of label amongst lipid classes (Smith and Harwood, 1984b). In this study the most notable change was that seen in the ratio of radioactivity between the organic and aqueous phases of a high-saltxhloroform-mefhanol-water (Garbus) extraction. Pb2+,Cd2+,Zn2+ and Cu2 all increased the ratio of counts in the organic phase of the extraction, but this was most marked for Cu2+(Smith et al., 1984, 1985). In vitro results for F. vesiculosus and F. serratus (Table XVIII)show this quite markedly. Further work has shown that lipid metabolism in F. serratus is more susceptible to Cuz than that of Ascophyllum nodosum or F. vesiculosus (Jones and Harwood, 1989, unpublished). However, the pattern of fatty acid labelling from [14C]acetate after incubation with Cu2+ in these brown algae is altered in a rather similar fashion (Smith et al., 1984; Jones and Harwood, 1988). Generally, labelled oleate levels are raised and palmitate levels lowered (Table XIX).Similar differences in endogenous fatty acids were seen in algae collected from sites heavily polluted with Cuz+ (Smith et al., 1985). If the pathways of fatty acid synthesis are similar to those of higher plants then it is possible that the activity of the acyl-ACP and/or acyl-CoA transacylases is being affected by Cu2+and other metals. These enzymes transfer acyl chains from thioesters into complex lipids. Palmitoyl-ACP is the initial product of the fatty acid synthetase enzyme system, and the condensing enzyme which adds the C, unit to give 18 : 0 is specific for this reaction (Shimakata and Stumpf, 1982). The desaturation of both palmitoyl- and stearoyl-ACP is carried out by a A9-desaturase. Thus, inhibition of palmitoyl-ACP acyl transfer would allow a higher flux of radioactivity through to oleate, while at +
+
+
+
42
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
TABLE XIX Effect ofCu2 on the incorporation of [I4C]acetateinto fatty acids +
Alga
YORadiolabelled fatty acid
Treatment
14:O 16:O 16:l 18:O 18:l 18:2Others F. serratus
Control 300pgCu2+ I - ' ( 1 hour)
7.5 74.2 1.5 4.3" 58.6" 3.1"
A scophyllum nodosum
Control 30pgCu2+ I - ' (8 days)
2.5 tr.'
21.1 17.1
F. vesiculosus
Control 120pgCu2+I - '
4.0 3.4
28.7 26.7
-
-
1.6 7.2 7.8 0.2 2.7" 15.6" 10.9" 4.8 12.8 62.0 1.6 6.0b 71.6" 3.7
-
0.9
15.6 28.0 1.6 22.0 12.7 34.1b 2.3 20.8
" P <0.0I 'P < 0.05 Fatty acid abbreviations as for Table 1. Data for F. serratus is from Smith el a/. (1984) and for the other algae from Jones, A. L. and Harwood. J . L. (unpublished).
the same time reducing palmitate labelling. At present, there is no experimental evidence to support such a hypothesis, but we are currently evaluating this possible mechanism.
VIII. LIPID METABOLISM IN OTHER ALGAL TYPES Although D . salina and the cyanobacteria are probably the best studied algae, work with some other algae, notably species of Chlorella, merits description here. Important work on the features of fatty acid desaturation was carried on C . vulgaris. The alga failed to desaturate added palmitate or stearate except when denied any carbon source. This was demonstrated by feeding [I4C]acetate under anaerobic conditions. Labelled palmitate and stearate accumulated but there was no desaturation under anaerobic conditions. However, on changing to aerobic conditions, [14C]stearate was converted rapidly to [ 4C]oleate, demonstrating the aerobic nature of the A9-desaturase (Harris et al., 1967). The substrate specificity of the desaturase system forming oleate was investigated with a series of radiolabelled acids from myristate (14 : 0) to nonadecanoate (19 :0) (Howling et al., 1968). Each was desaturated to the corresponding A9-monoenoate, but, in addition, myristate, pentadecanoate and palmitate yielded the A7-monoenoates. These results were interpreted as possibly indicating the presence of a A7-desaturase in addition to the main A9-desaturase, and, in addition, to show that the enzymes held
43
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
Substrate
Product
I
I
D-C-H
I I I H-C-D
DC _____)
D-C-H
I H-C-D
,I
H-C-D D-C-H
D-C-H H-C-D
I I I I
I I
,
-
II I I
DC
H
i
HC
I I HC I1 DC I I il HC I
(A)
(6)
(C)
DC
(D)
Fig. 11. Principle of experiment to demonstrate the reaction mechanism for stearate desaturation in Chlorella vulgaris. No isotope effect: twice as many monodeuterated products [(C) + (D)] as dideuteyated (A). Isotope effect at one position: equal numbers of mono- and dideuterated products. Isotope effect at both positions: product (A) formed preferentially. See Morris (1970) for details.
the substrate bound through the carboxyl group, probably as a thiol ester. The desaturation is highly stereospecific. Morris et al. (1967) incubated C . vulgaris with [erythro-9,10-*H,]stearate, [threo-9,1O-ZH,]stearate, [ ~ - 9 3H]stearate and [~-9-~H]stearate. Analysis of the oleate produced demonstrated that the desaturation involved the loss of the A9 hydrogen atom and of a pair of hydrogen atoms of cis relative configuration. Moreover, because there was an isotope effect at both positions, a stepwise reaction mechanism seemed unlikely and it was concluded that desaturation involves the simultaneous concerted removal of hydrogens (Morris, 1970; Fig. 11). Harris et al. (1965) showed that photosynthetically grown cells of C. vulgaris rapidly formed linoleate and a-linolenate by an aerobic process. Exogenous [1-l4C]stearate was converted to [l-14C]oleate and then [ l 14C]linoleate,showing the sequential nature of the desaturation pathway at the C,, level. Cell-free homogenates from such cells retained the ability to desaturate [l-14C]oleatein the presence of oxygen and NADH or NADPH (Harris and James, 1965). This activity was lost when the homogenate was separated into particulate and supernatant fractions. However, the particu-
44
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
late fraction regained activity if the substrate was added as [I-14C]oleoylCoA. Labelling experiments with C. vulgaris showed that PC became very highly labelled with regard to linoleate (Harris et al., 1967). This led to the suggestion that PC could be involved in oleate desaturation. In addition, further experiments suggested that other complex lipids could be involved in the different fatty acyl desaturations (Nichols et al., 1967). These were the first suggestions of a mechanism for desaturation involving non-thioester substrates, now accepted for, at least, the major pathways of polyenoate formation (Harwood, 1988). Direct involvement of PC in oleate desaturation was shown for Chlorella particulate fractions by Gurr et al. (1969). The chain length specificity of desaturases in C. vulgaris has been studied by Howling et al. (1968). They found that each of the A9-monoenates formed by the first desaturation could be desaturated further to form A9,12-dienoates (with the exception of A-tetradecenoate). Oleate was, however, the most active substrate. Further experiments were carried out with 8-heptadecenoate, 9-octadecenoate and 1 0-nonadecenoate, which yielded, respectively, A8,11-18: 2, A9,12-18: 2 and A10,13-18: 2 (where 18 : 2 stands for octadecadienoate). If the monoenoates were incorporated into a complex lipid before desaturation, then the concept of a desaturase having a specificity relating to the methyl end of the acyl chain is logical. Thus, it was concluded that C. vulgaris might possess two desaturases which were responsible for dienoic fatty acid synthesis. The first was a A12 desaturase which accepted A9-monoenoates, while a second 6-desaturase used 9-monoenates. Oleate would be a substrate for both enzymes. The stereochemistry of oleate and linoleate desaturation was demonstrated to be identical to that for stearate desaturation (Morris et al., 1967), i.e. cis elimination of hydrogen from the 12,13 or 15,16 positions involving the vic-D atoms took place. The presence of a very unusual fatty acid, trans-A3-hexadecenoate, exclusively located at the sn-2 position of leaf PG (Harwood, 1980a), was mentioned in Section 111. Similarly, C. vulgaris cells grown photosynthetically in the light accumulate the acid in this position exclusively. When organic nutrient is available, the acid is almost completely absent from cells, whether grown in the light or dark (Nichols, 1965). The biosynthesis of trans-A3hexadecenoate was investigated, and palmitate established as the direct precursor (Nichols et al., 1965). Desaturation was reduced in the absence of exogenous oxygen, indicating either a substrate requirement for the reaction or the need for oxygen in the supply of enzymes or cofactors involved. When [14C]trans-A3-hexadecenoate was added to C. vulgaris cells it was acylated to all lipids, showing that the specific location of the acid in PG in vivo was not due to a specific acyl transferase. The experiments showed that the most likely substrate for the desaturase was another complex lipid (I-acyl,2palmitoyl-phosphatidylglycerol),and this accounted for the specific location of the trans-A3-hexadecenoate product (Bartels et al., 1967). In addition, a
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
45
reductase system was found in Chlorella which could convert the transhexadecenoate to palmitate; such a system has been suggested to be involved in the function of trans-A3-hexadecenoate in thylakoid membranes (Harwood and James, 1975; Gounaris et al., 1986). Several workers have carried out general metabolic studies with green algae. Frequently, 14C0, and [I4C]acetate have been used. These have the advantage that radioactivity can be incorporated into all fatty acids (acyl groups) and, hence, into all classes of acyl lipids. However, the former, in particular, has the disadvantage that other parts of the lipid molecule are also well labelled (e.g. glycerol, sugars), leading to problems in interpretation. For this reason, [I4C]acetate is often a preferable precursor (Hitchock and Nichols, 1971). Optimal conditions for the incorporation of label from [I4C]acetate with C. pyrenoidosa have been worked out (Yung and Mudd, 1966). Using the same alga and 14C0,, Ferrari and Benson (1961) had earlier established the high metabolic activity of PG and MGDG during steadystate photsynthesis. Similar studies using [I4C]acetate and C. vulgaris showed that the rate of labelling of acyl groups of individual lipids was in the order:
PG > MGDG >PC > SQDG > PI > DGDG > PI This showed again, as with C. pyrenoidosa, that PG and MGDG were very rapidly labelled (Nichols et al., 1967). The rapid labelling of PG was also seen with [3ZP]glycerophosphatelabelling (Sastry and Kates, 1965). In a comparative study on lipid metabolism in C. vulgaris and two cyanobacteria, Nichols (1968) noted that the fatty acids of DGDG and SQDG were labelled much better in the blue-green algae. However, in all three organisms, MGDG was the best labelled of the glycosylglycerides. An important additional result from the general studies of lipid labelling with C. vulgaris was the demonstration that major changes in the fatty acid composition of individual lipids could take place after their de novo synthesis (Nichols et al., 1967; Nichols, 1968; Nichols and Moorhouse, 1969; Gurr et al., 1969; Safford and Nichols, 1970). This in turn led to the idea of a dynamic movement of acyl moieties between lipids and, more especially, to the concept that complex lipids can act as substrates for desaturation. These ideas have now been extended to all types of plants and were discussed briefly in Section IV. Fuller reviews of these aspects have been made recently (Stumpf and Conn, 1987; Harwood, 1988,1989). Chlamydomonas reinhardtii has been used as a useful experimental organism by a number of laboratories. Janero and Barrnett (1981a,b) reported on the detailed lipid composition of strain 137'. However, their results differed somewhat from the recently analysed arg-2 mt + strain (Eichenberger et al., 1986). The latter workers also noted the very similar lipid composition of a chlorophyll b-deficient mutant. Several workers have studied biogenesis of photosynthetic membranes. Beck and Levine (1977) used cultures which had
46
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
been synchronized by a 12-h light/l2-h dark regime. They then followed incorporation of radioactivity into lipids using 35SO:-, 32PO:- and H14CO; as precursors. They concluded that while lipid synthesis occurred predominantly during the light part of the cycle, different (chloroplast) lipids were synthesized at different times. For example, PG was synthesized between 3 h and 4 h in the light, but SQDG was labelled between 7 h and 9 h. Galactolipid synthesis appeared to reach maximal rates at two times-immediately after the lights were switched on and after 7 h. All the lipids (and chlorophyll) were made and inserted into chloroplast membranes before any major increases in photosynthetic capacity were seen. The sequential nature of lipid insertion during membrane biogenesis was notable. These results were extended somewhat by Janero and Barrnett (1982), who looked at cell-cycle variations in the synthesis of PE and PC in nonphotosynthetic membranes. Peak incorporation of radioactivity from [14C]acetate was found around 7 h in the light. Thus, synthesis of thylakoid and non-thylakoid lipids in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii is confined essentially to the light period and occurs in mid-to-late GI. De novo synthesis of acyl lipids relies on the successive acylation of glycerol 3-phosphate to form the key intermediate phosphatidate. The two acylations concerned have been studied in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii (Jelsema et al., 1982). Both enzymes were very much increased upon light induction, the lysophosphatidate acyltransferase particularly so. The peak activities of the enzymes preceded thylakoid membrane biogenesis during the cell cycle. The enzymes were localized by cytochemical techniques, and activity was concluded to be associated with the chloroplast envelope (and in the pyrenoid tubules of the chloroplast and the Golgi apparatus and associated vesicles (Michaels et al., 1983)). The results are in keeping with a role for acyltransferases in chloroplast biogenesis as discussed for plants in general (Joyard and Douce, 1987; Hanvood, 1989). Mention has already been made of the involvement of various complex lipids in fatty acid desaturation. As described in Section IV, PC is thought to be the major substrate for oleate‘desaturation in plants (Harwood, 1988), including C . vulgaris (Gurr et al., 1969). However, in Chlamydomonas reinhardtii, PC is either absent (Eichenberger et al., 1986) or is present in very small amounts in non-thylakoid membranes (Janero and Barrnett, 198 1b). When labelling studies were made with [1-14C]oleate, DGTS was very rapidly labelled (Schlapfer and Eichenberger, 1983). Within 3 h about 80% of the labelled oleate incorporated into DGTS was desaturated to linoleate and linolenate. At the same time, label present in the 16 : 0/18 : 1 molecular species moved into 16 : 0/18 : 2 and 16 : 0/18 : 3 species. These data implied that DGTS acted as a substrate for the desaturation of oleate and linoleate. As further evidence for this role, radiolabelled di- 18 : 1-DGTS was used. The labelled lipid was di-([l-14C]oleoyl)-glyceryl-(N,”-tri-[3H]methyl)homoserine. Appreciable quantities of the intact lipid were taken up by the
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
47
alga and, in part, its oleoyl moieties were desaturated as shown by the successive appearance of 18 : 1/ 18 : 2 and 18 : 1 / 18 : 3 molecular species. Interestingly, in relation to the possible role of DGTS in fatty acid desaturation, this lipid does not appear to be confined to one subcellular compartment. In Chlamydomonas, 15% (Mendiola-Morgenthaler er al., 1985) or 40% (Janero and Barrnett, 1982) of total DGTS is present in the thylakoids. In Dunaliella, 90% was located in the thylakoids (Norman and Thompson, 1985b). A careful subcellular fraction of Acetabularia mediterranea showed that the bulk of DGTS was found in microsomal fractions with a similar distribution to NADH
IX. CONCLUSIONS It should be clear from the foregoing sections that our knowledge of lipids, and especially their metabolism in algae, is poor. Only a few organisms have been studied in any detail, and in most algae which have been examined unknown lipids still remain t o be identified. Considering the tremendous variety of different algae, it will not be surprising to uncover many novel pathways for lipid synthesis in the future. Conceivably some of these metabolic differences may have important applications in other areas. Undoubtedly, the biotechnological exploitation of algae will become more prevalent in the next decade. However, it seems likely to us that, as in the past, the most
48
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
significant discoveries will be made by scientists, inspired by a sense of curiosity, looking “where the light shines brightest”.
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT Work on algae in the authors’ laboratory has been supported financially by the SERC and the NERC, for which we are very grateful.
REFERENCES Abreu-Grobois, F. A,, Billyard, T. C. and Walton, T. J. (1977). Phytochemistry 16, 351-354. A1 Araji, Z. T. and Walton, T. J. (1980) In “Biogenesis and Functions of Plant Lipids” (P. Mazliak, P. Benveniste, C. Costes and R. Douce, eds), pp. 259-262. Elsevier. Amsterdam. Anderson, R., Kates, M. and Volcani, B. E. (1978a). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 528, 77-88. Anderson, R., Kates, M. and Volcani, B. E. (1978b). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 528, 89-106. Araki, S . , Sakurai, T. and Omata, T. (1986). Jap. J. Phycol. 34,94100. Araki, S., Takemaro, S., Kawaguchi, A. and Murata, N. (1984). Plant Cell Physiol. 28,761-766. Arao, T., Kawaguchi, A. and Yamada, M. (1987). Phytochemistry 26,2573-2576. Auling, G., Heinz, E. and Tulloch, A. P. (1971). Hoppe-Seylers Z. Physiol. Chem. 352, 905-912. Bartels, C. T., James, A. T. and Nichols, B. W. (1967). Eur. J. Biochem. 3, 7-10. Beck, J. C. and Levine, R. P. (1977). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 489,360-369. Ben-Amotz, A. and Tornabene, T. G. (1985). J. Phycol. 21,72-81. Benson, A. A. (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stumpf, J. 9. Mudd, and W. D. Nes, eds), pp. 599-602. Plenum Press, New York. Benson, A. A., Wiser, R., Ferrari, R. A. and Miller, J. A. (1958). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 80,4740. Bisseret, P., Ito, S., Tremblay, P. A., Volcani, B. E.,Dessort, D. and Kates, M. (1984). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 7%, 320-327. Bolton, P., Wharfe, J. and Harwood, J. L. (1978). Biochem. J . 174,67-72. Brown, A. D. and Borowitzka, L. J. (1979). In “Biochemistry and Physiology of Protozoa” (M. Levandowsky and S. H. Hutner, eds), Vol. 1, pp. 139-190. Academic Press, New York. Brown, A. E.and Elovson, J. (1974). Biochemistry 13,3476-3482. Bryan, G. W. (1980). Helgolander Meersunters 3 3 , 6 2 5 . Bryan, G. W. and Hummerstone, L. G. (1973). J. Mar. Biol. Ass. ( U K ) 53, 705720. Bryce, T. A., Welti, D., Walsby, A. E. and Nichols, B. W. (1972). Phytochemistry 11, 295-302. Caron, L., Dubacq, J. P., Berkaloff, C. and Jupin, H. (1 985). PIant Cell Physiol. 26, 13 1-139. Cho, S . H. and Thompson, G. A. (1986). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 878,353-359.
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
49
Cho, S. H. and Thompson, G. A. (1987). J. Biol. Chem. 262,7586-7593. Choudhury, M. K. and Eichenberger, W. (1985) Chem. Phys. Lipids 36,351-359. Clarkson, D. T., Hall, K. C. and Roberts, J. K. M. (1 980). Planta 149,464-47 1. Coombs, J. L., Darley, W. M., Holm-Hansen, 0. and Volcani, B. E. (1967). Plant Physiol. 42, 1601-1606. Datz, G. and Dohler, G. (1981). Z. Nuturforsch. C36,856862. Dohler, G. and Datz, G. (1980). Z. Pjanzenphysiof. 100,427435. Eichenberger, W. (1982). Plant Sci. Lett. 24,91-95. Eichenberger, W. and Boschetti, A. (1978). FEBS Lett. 88,201-204. Eichenberger, W. and Gerber, A. (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stumpf, J. B. Mudd and W. D. Nes, eds), pp. 637640. Plenum Press, New York. Eichenberger, W., Boschetti, A. and Michel, H. P. (1986). Physiol. PIunta 66, 589594. Elovson, J. and Vagelos, P. R. (1969) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 62,957-963. Evans, R. W. and Kates, M. (1984). Arch. Microbiol. 140, 50-56. Evans, R. W., Kates, M., Ginzburg, M. and Ginzburg, B.-Z. (1982a). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 712, 186195. Evans, R. W., Kates, M. and Wood, G. W. (1982b). Chem. Phys. Lipids 31, 331338. Feige, G. B. (1978). Eerl Dtsch Bot. Ges. 91, 595-602. Feige, G. B., Heinz, E., Wrage, K., Cochems, N. and Ponzelar, E. (1980). In “Biogenesis and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. Mazliak, P. Benveniste, C. Costes and R. Douce, eds), pp. 135-140. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Ferrari, R. A. and Benson, A. A. (1961). Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 93, 185-192. Foley, A. A. and Harwood, J. L. (1982) In “Biochemistry and Metabolism of Plant . Lipids” (J. F. G. M. Wintermans and P. J. C. Kuiper, eds), pp: 331-334. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Foley, A. A., Evans, J., Rowlands, C. and Harwood, J. L. (1988). Inorganic Eiochemistry 32, 125-1 33. Fork, D. C., Murata, N. and Sato, N. (1979). Plant Physiol. 63,526530. Frentzen, M. (1986). J . Plant Physiol. 124, 193-209. Fried, A., Tietz, A., Ben-Amotz, A. and Eichenberger, W. (1982). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 713,419426. Gounaris, K., Barber, J. and Harwood, J. L. (1986). Biochem. J. 237,313-326. Griffiths, G., Stobart, A. K. and Stymne, S . (1988). Biochem. J. 252,641-647. Gurr, M. I., Robinson, H. P. and James, A. T. (1969). Eur. J. Biochem. 29, 362368. Gusev, M. V., Nikitina, K. A., Grot, A. V. and Vshivtsev, V. S. (1980). Fiziol. Rust. 27,1083-1087. Haines, T. H. (1973a). Annu. Rev. Microbiol. 27,403-41 1. Haines, T. H. (1973b). In “Lipids and Biomembranes of Eukaryotic Microorganisms” (J. A. Erwin, ed.), pp. 197-232. Academic Press, New York. Haines, T. H. and Block, R. J. (1962). J. Protozool. 9,33-38. Harris, R. V. and James, A. T. (1965). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 106,456-464. Harris, R. V., Harris, P. and James, A. T. (1965). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 106, 465473. Harris, R.V., James, A. T. and Harris, P. (1967). In “Biochemistry of Chloroplasts” (T. W. Goodwin, ed.), Vol. 2, pp. 241-253. Academic Press, London and New York. Harwood, J. L. (1980a). In “The Biochemistry of Plants” (P. K. Stumpf and E. E. Conn, eds), Vol. 4, pp. 1-55. Academic Press. New York.
50
JOHN L. HARWOOD A N D A. LESLEY JONES
Harwood, J. L. (1980b). In “The Biochemistry of Plants” (P. K. Stumpf and E. E. Conn, eds), Vol. 4, pp. 301-320. Academic Press, New York. Harwood, J. L. (1983). Biochem. Soc. Trans. 11,343-346. Harwood, J. L. (1988). Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. 39,101-138. Harwood, J. L. (1989). C R C Critical Rev. in Plant Sci. 8, 1 4 3 . Harwood, J. L. and James, A. T. (1975). Eur. J. Biochem. 50,325-334. Harwood, J. L. and Russell, N. J. (1984). “Lipids in Plants and Microbes”. George, Allen and Unwin, London. Harwood, J. L., Pettitt, T. P. and Jones, A. L. (1989). In “Biochemistry of Algae and Cyanobacteria” (J. R. Gallon and L. J. Rogers, eds), pp. 49-67. Oxford University Press, Oxford. Haselkorn, R. (1978) Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. 29,319-344. Heinz, E. (1977). In “Lipids and Polymers in Higher Plants” (M. Tevini and H. K. Lichtenthaler, eds), pp. 102-1 20. Springer-Verlag, Berlin and New York. Hitchcock, C. and Nichols, B. W. (1971). “Plant Lipid Biochemistry.” Academic Press. London. Holton, R. W., Blecker, H. H. and Onore, M. (1964). Phytochemistry 3,595-602. Howling, D., Morris, L. J. and James, A. T. (1968). Biochim. Biophjs. Acta 152,224226. Hulanicka. D., Erwin, J. and Bloch, K. (1964). J . Biol. Chem. 239, 2778-2787. Jamieson. G. R. and Reid, E. H. (1972). Phytochemisty 11, 1423-1432. Janero, D. R . and Barrnett, R. (1981a). J. Lipid Res. 22, 119-1 125. Janero, D. R. and Barrnett, R. (1981b). J. LipidRes. 22, 11261 130. Janero, D . R . and Barrnett, R. (1982). J. Lipid Res. 23,307-316. Jelsema, C . L., Michaels, A. S., Janero, D. R. and Barrnett, R. J. (1982). J. Cell Sci. 58,469488. Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L. (1987). Biochem. SOC.Trans 15,482-483. Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L. (1988). Biochem. SOC.Trans 16,275-276. Joyard, J. and Douce, R. (1987). In “The Biochemistry of Plants” (P. K. Stumpf and E. E. Conn, eds), Vol. 9, pp. 215-272. Academic Press, New York. Kates, M . (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stumpf, J. B. Mudd and W. D. Nes, eds) pp. 613-622. Plenum Press, New York. Kates, M., Tremblay, P., Anderson, R. and Volcani, B. E. (1978). Lipids 13,34-41. Kawaguchi, A,, Arao, T. and Yamada, Y. (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stumpf, J. B. Mudd and W. D. Nes, eds), pp. 653-656. Plenum Press, New York. Kayama, M., Iijima, N., Sado, T., Mankura, T., Araki, S. and Sakurai, T. (1986). Bull. Japan. SOC.Sci. Fish. 52, 575. Kenrick, J. B., Deane, E. M. and Bishop, D. G. (1984). Phycologia 23, 73-76. Kenyon, C. N. (1972). J. Bacteriol. 109, 827-834. Kenyon, C. N., Rippka, R. and Stanier, R. Y. (1972). Arch. Microbiol. 83, 216236. Krespki, W. J. and Walton, T. J. (1983). J . Cen. Microbiol. 129, 105-1 10. Lambein, F. and Wolk, C. P. (1973). Biochemistry 12,791-798. Lem, N. W. and Stumpf, P. K. (1984a). Plant Physiol. 74, 134-138. Lem, N. W. and Stumpf, P. K. (1984b). Plant Physiol. 75, 70C704. Lignell, A., Roomans, G. M. and Pederson, M. (1982). Z. P’anzenphysiol. 105, 103109. Lynch, D. V. and Thompson, G. A. (1982). Plant Physiol. 69,1369-1375. Lynch, D. V. and Thompson, G. A. (1983). Plant Physiol. 72,903-905. Lynch, D. V. and Thompson, G. A. (1984a). Plant Physiol. 74,193-197.
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
51
Lynch, D. V. and Thompson, G. A. (1984b). Plant Physiol. 74,198-203. Lynch, D. V. and Thompson, G. A. ( I 984c). Trends Biochem. Sci. 9 , 4 4 2 4 5 . Mendiola-Morgenthaler, L. and Eichenberger, W. (1984). In “Structure, Function and Metabolism of Plant Lipids” (P.-A. Siegenthaler and W. Eichenberger, eds), pp. 405408. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Mendiola-Morgenthaler, L., Eichenberger, W. and Boschetti, A. (1985). Plant Sci. Lett. 41,97-104. Mercer, E. I. and Davies, C. L. (1979). Phytochernistry 18,457462. Mercer, E. I., Thomas, G. and Harrison, J. D. (1974). Phytochernistry 13, 12971302. Michaels, A. S., Jelsema, C. L. and Barrnett, R. (1983). J. Ultrastruct. Res. 82, 35-51. Mohy-Ud-Dhin, M. T., Krepski, W. J. and Walton, T. J. (1982). In “Biochemistry and Metabolism of Plant Lipids” (J. F. G. M. Wintermans and P. J. C. Kuiper, eds), pp. 209-2 12. Moore, T. M. (1982). Annu. Rev. Plant Physiol. 33,235-259. Morris, L. J. (1970). Biochem. J . 118,681-693. Morris, L. J., Harris, R. V., Kelly, W. and James, A. T. (1967). Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 28,904908. Mudd, J. B. and Kleppinger-Sparace, K. F. (1987). In “The Biochemistry of Plants” (P. K. Stumpf and E. E. Conn, eds), Vol. 9, pp. 275-289. Academic Press, New York. Murata, N. (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stumpf, J. B. Mudd and W. D. Nes, eds), pp. 603-612. Plenum Press, New York. Murata, N. and Nishida, I. (1987). In “Biochemistry of Plants” (P. K. Stumpf and E. E. Conn, eds), Vol. 9, pp. 315-347. Academic Press, New York. Murata, N., Sato, N., Takahoshi, N. and Hamazaki, Y. (1982). Plant Cell Physiol. 23, 1071-1 079. Nichols, B. W. (1965). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 106,274279. Nichols, B. W. (1968). Lipids 3,354-360. Nichols, B. W. and Appleby, R. S. (1969). Phytochemistry 8, 1907-1815. Nichols, B. W. and Moorhouse, R. (1969). Lipids 4,311-316. Nichols, B. W., Harris, P. and James, A. T. (1965). Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 21,473479. Nichols, B. W., James, A. T. and Breuer, J. (1967). Biochem. J . 104,48&496. Norman, H. A. and Thompson, G. A. (1985a). Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 242, 168175. Norman, H. A. and Thompson, G. A. (1985b). Plant Sci.42,83-87. Norman, H. A. and Thompson, G. A. (1986). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 875,262-269. Norman, H. A., Smith, L. A., Lynch, D. V. and Thompson, G. A. (1985). Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 242, 157-167. Ohnishi, J. and Yamada, M. (1977). Plant Cell Physiol. (special issue), 355-364. Olson, G. J. and Ingram, L. 0. (1975). J . Bacteriol. 124, 373-379. Omata, T. and Murata, N. (1986). Plant Cell Physiol. 27,485490. Oren, A,, Fattom, A., Padan, E. and Tietz, A. (1985). Arch. Microbiol. 141, 138142. Pettitt, T. R. and Harwood, J. L. (1986). Biochem. Soc. Trans 14,148-149. Pettitt, T. R. and Harwood, J. L. (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stumpf, J. B. Mudd and W. D. Nes, eds), pp. 657660. Plenum Press, New York. Pettitt, T. R., Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L. (1989a). Phytochemistry 28, 399405. Pettitt, T. R., Jones, A. L. and Harwood, J. L. (1989b). Phytochemistry (in press).
52
JOHN L. HARWOOD AND A. LESLEY JONES
Pham Quang, L. and Laur, M.-H. (1976)a). Biochimie 58, 1367-1380. Pham Quang, L. and Law, M.-H. (1976b). Biochimie58,1381-1396. Pham Quang, L. and Laur, M.-H. (1976~).Phycologiu 15,367-375. Piorreck, M., Baasch, K.-H. and Pohl, P. (1984). Phytochemistry 23,207-216. Pohl, P. and Zurheide, F. (1979a). In “Marine Algae in Pharmaceutical Science” (H.A. Hoppe, T. Levring and Y. Tanaka, eds), pp. 473-523. Walter de Gruyter, Berlin. Pohl, P. and Zurheide, F. (1979b). In “Advances in the Biochemistry and Physiology of Plant Lipids” (L.-A. Appelqvist and C. Liljenberg, eds), pp. 427432. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Rebeille, F., Bligny, R. and Douce, R. (1980). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 620, 1-9. Remy, R., Tremolieres, A. Duval, J. C., Ambard-Bretteville, F. and Dubacq, J. B. (1982). FEBS Lett. 137,271-275. Roessler, P. G. (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stump, J. B. Mudd and W. D. Nes, eds), pp. 649-651. Plenum Press, New York. Roughan, G . and Slack, C. R. (1984). Trends Biochem. Sci. 9,383-386. Roughan, P. G., Mudd, J. B., McManns, T. T and Slack, C. R. (1979). Biochem. J. 184,571-574. Rullkotter, J., Heinz, E. and Tulloch, A. P. (1975). Z. pfunzenphysiol. 76, 163-175. Safford, R. and Nichols. B. W. (1970). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 210,57-64. Sastry, P. S. and Kates, M. (1965). Can. J . Biochem. 43, 144-1453. Sato, N. and Furuya, M. (1984a). Phytochemistry 23, 1625-1627. Sato, N. and Furuya, M. (1984b). In “Structure, Function and Metabolism of Plant Lipids” (P. A. Siegenthaler and W. Eichenberger, eds), pp. 171-174. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Sato, N. and Furuya, M. (1985). Plant Sci. 38,81-85. Sato, N. and Murata, N. (1980a). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 619,353-366. Sato, N. and Murata, N. (1980b). In “Biogenesis and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. Mazliak, P. Benveniste, C. Costes and R. Douce, eds), pp. 207-210. Elsevier, Amsterdam. Sato, N. and Murata, N. (1981). Plant Cell Physiol. 22, 1043-1050. Sato, N. and Murata, N. (1982a). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 710,271-278. Sato, N. and Murata, N. (1982b). Biochim. Biophys. Actu 710,279-289. Sato, N. and Murata, N. (1982~).Plant Cell Physiol. 23, 11 15-1 120. Sato, N. and Murata, M.,‘Miura, Y. and Ueta, N. (1979). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 572, 19-28. Sato, N., Murata, M., Miura, Y. and Ueta, N. (1979). Biochim. Biophys. Actu 572, 19-28. Sato, N., Seyama, Y. and Murata, N. (1986). PIunt CeN Physiol. 27,819-835. Sato, N., Nemoto, Y. and Furuya, M. (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Funcion of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stumpf, J. B. Mudd and W. D. Nes, eds), pp. 661-664. Plenum Press, New York. Schlapfer, P. and Eichenberger, W. (1983). Plant Sci. Lett. 32,243-252. Sherman, L. A. (1979). J. Phycol. 14,427433. Shimakata, T. and Stumpf, P. K. (1982). Proc. Nut. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 5808-5812. Smith, K. L. and Harwood, J. L. (1983). Biochem. Soc. Trans 11,394-395. Smith, K. L. and Harwood, J. L. (1984a). Phytochemistry 23,2469-2473. Smith, K. L. and Harwood, J. L. (1984b). J . Exp. Bot. 35,1359-1368. Smith, K. L., Douce, R.and Harwood, J. L. (1982). Phytochemistry 21,569-573. Smith, K. L., Bryan, G. W. and Harwood, J. L. (1984). Biochim. Biophys. Actu 796, 119-122. Smith, K. L., Bryan, G. W. and Harwood, J. L. (1985aj J . Exp. Bot. 36,663-669.
LIPID METABOLISM IN ALGAE
53
Smith, K. L., Hann, A. C. and Harwood, J. L. (1986). Physiol. Plant 66,692-698. Smith, L. A., Norman, H. A., Cho, S. H. and Thompson, G. A. (1985b). J. Chromatogr. 346,291-299. Stapleton, S. R. and Jaworski, J. G. (1984a). Biochim. Biophys. Acta 794,24&248. Stapleton, S. R. and Jaworski, J. G . (1984b). Biochim. Biophys. Acta794,249-255. Stumpf, P. K. and Conn, E. E. (eds) (1980). “The Biochemistry of Plants”, Vol. 4. Academic Press, New York. Stumpf, P. K. and Conn. E. E. (1987). “The Biochemistry of Plants”, Vol. 9. Academic Press, New York. Stymne, S.,Griffiths, G. and Stobart, K. (1987). In “The Metabolism, Structure and Function of Plant Lipids” (P. K. Stumpf, J. B. Mudd and W. D. Nes, eds), pp. 405-412. Plenum Press, New York. Tornabene, T. G, Holzer, G., Lien, S. and Burris, N. (1983). Enzyme Microb. Technol. 5,435-440. Vigh, L., Horvath, I., van Hassell, P. R. and Kuiper, P. J. C. (1985). Plant Physiol. 79, 756759. Walker, K. A. and Harwood, J. L. (1986). Biochem. J. 237,4146. Wharfe, J. and Harwood, J. L. (1978). Biochem. J. 174, 163-169. Yung, K. H. and Mudd, J. B. (1966). Plant Physiol. 41,506509. Zepke, H. D., Heinz, E., Radunz, A., Linscheid, M. and Pesch, R. (1978). Arch. Microbiol. 119. 157-162.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Alternation of Generations
PETER R. BELL
Department of Botany and Microbiology, University College, London WCI E 6BT, UK
I. 11. 111.
IV.
Introduction. .
. .
. . . . . . .
55
. . . . . . . . . . . . .
56
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
57 57 65
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
70 70 72
. . . . . . . . .
The Universality of Life Cycles.
Essential Features of Points of Change A. Gametogenesis . . . . . . B. Sporogenesis . . . . . . .
The Significant Features of Aberrant Cycles A. Aberrant Cycles in Natural Conditions B. Induced Aberrations in Sexual Cycles .
V.
The Causal Approach to Alternation . . . . . . . . A. General Assumptions . . . . . . . . . . . B. From Gametophyte to Sporophyte in the Lower Plants C. From Sporophyte to Gametophyte . . . . . . .
VI.
General Conclusion
. . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . .
. . . . . , . . . . . .
78 78 78 82
.
87
.
I. INTRODUCTION The “alternation of generations”, the English rendering of “Generationswechsel”, has fascinated botanists since the 19th century. The observations which gave rise to the term were made by the botanist von Chamisso in 18 15 (von Chamisso, 1975) on collections of the tunicate Sulpu gathered while he was becalmed in the Atlantic at the beginning of a Russian exploratory Advancesin Botanical Research Vol. 16 ISBN 0-12-005916-9
Copyright 01989 Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction on any form reserved.
56
PETER R. BELL
voyage around the world. Chamisso noted that the life cycle of Sulpa consisted of alternating generations of oozoids and gastrozooids. Both, however, are now known to be diploid; only the gametes (produced by the gastrozooids) are haploid. “Generationswechsel” was probably brought into botanical terminology by Hofmeister (1851), particularly in relation to the archegoniate plants. Although the archegoniate cycle is, like that of Salpa, biphasic, the two phases normally differ in chromosome number. Nevertheless, Hofmeister’s parallel was justified since the nuclear aspects of the land plant cycle were not recognized until the end of the 19th Century (Overton, 1893; Strasburger, 1894). Much has been written about the alternation of generations of land plants, but attention has been directed principally to its likely evolution (e.g. Graham, 1985), and the selective forces which have moulded its form. Conversely the problem of the physiological events within the plant which drive it through the cycle has attracted little attention. This neglect is partly accounted for by the difficulty of subjecting the cycle to experimental treatments able to give unambiguous results, and partly by the lack of techniques to investigate the intimate events in the cells in which the change in the form of growth is taking place. Nevertheless, sufficient is now known about the gametogenous and sporogenous regions of plants, and of aberrant cycles, to justify constructive speculations about the causal aspects of the cycle.
11. THE UNIVERSALITY OF LIFE CYCLES Examples of life cycles are found at all levels of the Plant Kingdom. As knowledge of life cycles increases, particularly of the microalgae, it may emerge that some form of cycle is the normal accompaniment of photoautotrophic life. Amongst the prokaryotes a well-defined cycle is shown by Nosroc (Lazaroff and Vishniac, 1961). A heterocystous generation alternates with a sporogenous, the transition from the former to the latter being lightdependent. A number of cyanophytes produce minute reproductive cells (baeocytes) by a rapid succession of cell cleavages, and their subsequent development is very suggestive of some form of cycle (Fay, 1983). It is not known whether prokaryotic cycles are regularly accompanied by any change in the number of copies of the genome in the nucleoid. No form of sexual reproduction has been detected in the Cyanophyta. Life cycles are well established in the eukaryotic algae, even in those that are unicellular. Amongst the unicellular green algae, the cycle of Chlamydomonas has been particularly well studied. A medium poor in nitrogen induces gametic behaviour. Different mating types are characterized by complementary agglutins coating their flagella (Adair, 1985; Crabbendam et al., 1986; Samson et al., 1987). Copulation, which begins by association of the tips of the flagella, leads to the formation of a resting zygote. Meiosis takes place on
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
57
germination, and the haploid phase is restored in the production of four meiospores. Amongst the multicellular Chlorophyta, Ulva displays a life cycle in which haplophase and diplophase are morphologically identical. The production of zoospores is preceded by meiosis. The fusion of the gametes is similar to that observed in Chlamydomonas, but the zygote germinates without meiosis, and a diploid plant is formed. Some species of Cladophora show a similar cycle. A clear morphological distinction between motile male gametes and sessile female gametes is also found in the Chlorophyta, the genera Coleochaete and Chara providing striking examples of perfect oogamy. In each the egg cell is either initially or subsequently ensheathed in somatic cells. Significantly, it is also these algae which show ultrastructural and metabolic features (in relation to the photo-oxidation) which are more like those of land plants than of other green algae (summarized in Graham (1985)). The gametophytic phase in oogamous cycles may be dioecious (as in Coleochaete scutata), but there are no reports of morphological differences between the zoospores giving rise to the two sexes. The Phaeophyta and Rhodophyta also show many examples of life cycles. That of Dictyora parallels the cycle of Ulva, except that Dictyota is oogamous. The cycles of some Rhodophyta (e.g. Polysiphonia) are particularly complex and involve three distinct phases. Nevertheless, these complex cycles are not in principle different from those seen in the Chlorophyta. The sexual cycles of all land plants are oogamous. The gametophytic phase of the lower archegoniate plants may be dioecious with no well-defined differences in the size of the spores giving rise to the two sexes. In the moss Macromitrium, and in the heterosporous pteridophytes and all seed plants, the sex of the gametophytes is firmly correlated with differences in spore size, or the manner in which the spores are generated. Life cycles in the eukaryotic photoautotrophs are marked by two conspicuous events, gametogenesis and sporogenesis, each associated with a point of change in the cycle. Close investigation of these phenomena may therefore reveal the factors which control the cycle. Further, if there is evolutionary continuity in the life cycles of the land plants and their algal ancestors, the essential causal features of gametogenesis and sporogenesis should be recognizable at all levels of advancement. Although the information from algal sources is limited, a comparative review will facilitate the subsequent discussion.
111. ESSENTIAL FEATURES OF POINTS OF CHANGE A. GAMETOGENESIS
1. Algae Zsogamous forms. In flagellated unicellular algae, differences between the sexual and the asexual state are probably more extensive than is at first evi-
58
PETER R.BELL
dent. In Chlamydomonas, for example, production of the agglutinins which bring about the adhesion of the flagella preparatory to syngamy involves the activation of genes otherwise quiescent (Forest, 1987). The electron microscope has revealed not only features peculiar to the gametes, but also differences between gametes of complementary mating strains (Martin and Goodenough, 1975). In general, the chromatin of gametes is more condensed than that of somatic nuclei, but it is not known whether this is a feature affecting the nuclei of the two mating strains equally. The gametes of Ulva (Briten, 1971) probably show features similar to those of Chlamydomonas. Oogamous forms. The comparatively gross difference between the gametes which characterizes oogamous cycles involves reduction in the somatic features of the male gamete. In Oedogonium, for example, the spermatozoid, about 20 pm in length, is almost non-photosynthetic (Pickett-Heaps, 1975). The nucleus is reduced in volume, the chromatin is uniformly condensed, and no nucleus can be recognized (Hoffman, 1973). The nucleus of the motile male gamete of Fucus (Phaeophyceae) has similar features (Brawley et al., 1976a). In the Rhodophyta the spermatium of Corallina lacks intact plastids, and the chromatin is in a contracted form suggestive of an arrested mitosis (Peel and Duckett, 1975). The ultimate in specialization amongst algal male gametes is reached by the spermatozoid of the Charales (Chlorophyta). It is an elongated cell, about 60pm in length, containing a linear nucleus. The mitochondria lie at the anterior end in association with the flagella, and the. rudimentary plastids are confined to the tail. The chromatin is again dense, and no nucleolus can be detected (Pickett-Heaps, 1968; Turner, 1968). A striking feature of oogenesis in the green algae is the extent to which this involves unequal divisions. In Oedogonium, for example, the nucleus of the oogonium mother cell divides, but the bulk of the cytoplasm remains with one cell (which becomes the oogonium). The residual cytoplasm and sister nucleus are cut off as a small suffultory cell (Pickett-Heaps, 1975). In Bulbochaete hiloensis, primary and secondary suffultory cells are cut off in sequence (Pickett-Heaps, 1975), and the cytoplasm, which would with equal divisions have been distributed between three cells, remains principally with the oogonium. A comparable situation is found in the Charales (PickettHeaps, 1975). A strikingly unequal division cuts off a small basal cell as the egg is formed. In all the species the development of the egg protoplast involves considerable plasmatic growth, resulting in a several-fold increase in volume. The cytoplasm is characteristically rich in ribosomes, lipid droplets and starch. Mitochondria and small vesicles, many of the latter in Oedogonium of the “coated” kind (Hoffman, 1973), are also conspicuous, but microtubules are not prominent. The nucleus expands and its volume becomes much greater than that of the sperm nucleus (Hoffman, 1971). The chromatin is finely dispersed and the nucleolus enlarged, lacunate, and often accompanied by small
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
59
spherical bodies 0.60.8 pm in diameter (Hoffman, 1971). Scattered throughout the nucleoplasm in both Bufbochaete (Retallack and Butler, 1973) and Oedogonium (Hoffman, 1973) are numerous small aggregates of electronopaque material. The egg cell of Fucus shows similar features (Brawley et al., 1976a). Similar aggregates, with an affinity for the basic stain Toluidine Blue, appear outside the nucleus following fertilization (Brawley et al., 1976b). In Pofysiphonia (Rhodophyta) the egg (carpogonial) nucleus is again enlarged, reaching a volume about five times that of nuclei of neighbouring carpogonial branch cells (Broadwater and Scott, 1982). In some instances the nucleus of the egg cell has been seen connected by a narrow channel with a large vesicle bounded by two membranes lying towards the trichogyne. The contents of the vesicle, although in continuity with the nucleoplasm, lack structure and are almost uniformly electron-transparent. In algae generally the wall of the virgin oogonium does not appear to be notably thickened, and egg cells seem devoid of any conspicuous lipidic layers coating the plasmalemma. Nevertheless, there are indications of some form of isolation of the site of oogenesis from contiguous somatic cells. In Chara, for example, the chloroplasts of the egg cell become cup-shaped and the thylakoids disrupted by the accumulating starch. Those in the cells sheathing the oogonium remain unaffected by these striking changes within the developing gamete (Pickett-Heaps, 1975). 2. Bryophytes and Homosporous Pteridophytes Spermatogenesis. Spermatogenesis in the bryophytes and pteridophytes has much in common, and provides the only instance in land plants in which centrioles appear in the cytoplasm. They are differentiated in association with a centrosome (liverworts) or blepharoplast (mosses, pteridophytes, and zooidogamous gymnosperms), and subsequently function as the basal bodies of flagella. With few exceptions the nucleus of the differentiated gamete is elongated, and its chromatin condensed and without recognizable nucleoli. The skeleton of the gamete is provided, as in the male gametes of the Charales, by a ribbon of microtubules appressed to the nucleus. This ribbon originates in a multilayered structure (MLS) at the anterior end of the gamete. Mitochondria also tend to lie in the anterior part of the gamete (at least one associated with the MLS), and the plastids (which frequently accumulate starch and lose ordered thylakoids) towards the posterior. Plastids and other cytoplasmic components are often shed in a terminal vesicle from the motile gamete. The papers of La1 and Bell (1975), Duckett et al. (1983) and Sheffield and Bell (1987) contain reviews of the differentiation of the male gametes of the mosses, liverworts and pteridophytes respectively. Oogenesis. The female gametes of the bryophytes are less well investigated than those of the male. The egg cell of both liverworts and mosses lies at the base of the canal of the archegonium. Its formation is preceded by two
60
PETER R.BELL
unequal divisions, the first yielding the central cell and the neck canal cell initial, and the subsequent division of the central cell yielding the egg cell and ventral canal cell. The cytoplasm, which is increasing throughout these divisions, remains predominantly with the lower cell and becomes the cytoplasm of the egg. Further plasmatic growth results in the egg protoplast becoming conspicuously large, and the cytoplasm well furnished with ribosomes and organelles. Small aggregates of granular electron-opaque material, about 150nm in diameter and with a texture similar to that of the nucleolus, are scattered in the cytoplasm of the egg cells of Sphaerocarpus (Diers, 1965) and Physcomitrium (La1 and Bell, 1977). Numerous vesicles are also a feature of the egg cytoplasm. At maturity the egg cell becomes separated from the wall of the archegonial chamber by a zone of hydrated mucilage. In Physcomitrium there is convincing evidence that this mucilage is expressed from small vesicles which open at the plasmalemma (La1 and Bell, 1977), and this may be the situation in bryophytes generally. There is no indication of a special lipidic or other membrane around the egg cells of bryophytes so far examined (Sphaerocarpus (Diers, 1965); Marchantia (Bell, 1975; Zinsmeister and Carothers, 1974); Fossombronia (Bajon-Barbier, 1977); Philonotis (Bell, unpublished); Mnium (Barbier, 1972); Physcomitrium (La1 and Bell, 1977)). During maturation of the egg cell the nucleus expands and the chromatin becomes dispersed. The prominent nucleolus is often associated with “nuclear bodies”, small aggregates of nucleolus-like material. These have been referred to as “micronucleoli” (Bajon-Barbier, 1977), but this is illegitimate since they have never been demonstrated to contain RNA, although their affinity for uranium stains does indicate acidity. The nucleus itself becomes lobed in the mature egg, often very strikingly (as in Mnium (Barbier, 1972)). In addition, in Sphaerocarpus, Marchantia (Fig. 1 ) and Fossombronia the envelope of the nucleus is extended in the form of sheets which penetrate deeply into the cytoplasm. Although the connection with the main body of the nucleus is often very narrow, in Sphaerocarpus it could not be conclusively demonstrated that the sheets became detached (Diers, 1965). This is probably also true of the nuclear extensions of Marchantia (Zinsmeister and Carothers, 1974) and Fossombronia (Bajon-Barbier, 1977). In the ferns, the most studied of the homosporous pteridophytes, oogenesis can also be regarded as beginning with the formation of the primary cell of the axial row of the archegonium. Two unequal divisions cut off smaller cells towards the neck of the archegonium, the cell remaining at the base becoming the egg cell. A substantial amount of cytoplasm is generated during this sequence, most of which is retained by the egg cell. The initial stages of oogenesis are accompanied by an accelerating synthesis of RNA and protein (Fig. 2). Subsequently, in mid-sequence protein synthesis falls to a low level, but RNA synthesis continues into the newly formed egg cell. Since these results were based upon quantitative autoradiography following pulse labelling with
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
61
Fig. I Marchanris polymorpho. Section of part of a maturing egg cell showing the nuclear protrusions(*). N, nucleus. x 45 OOO. Inset Thick section of the archegonium from which the h e sectionwas taken. The egg cell (arrow) lies in fluid at the base of the archegonium. x 680. I
tritiated widine, it is possible that the apparent cessation of incorporation in the maturing egg may be a consequence of the nucleoside failing to reach the gamete, now becoming an isolated cell. The cytoplasm of the central cell precedmg the egg is characterized by clusters of small vesicles, many suggestive of degenerating mitochondria and plastids (Bell P. R., 1969). The view that the vesicles represent a phase of limited autophagy is strengthened by the vesicles being associated with acid
62
PETER R. BELL 2
I
3
4
6
RNA
Fig. 2. Pteridium aquilinum. A comparison of the amounts of ribonucleic acid and protein synthesis during oogenesis. I , 2. growth of the primary cell; 3, formation of the central cell; 4,5, 6, formation and maturation of the egg. Based on pulse-labelling and quantitative autoradiography. From Cave and Bell (1 974a).
phosphatase (Tourte, 1970), a marker of lysosomal activity. Subsequently these vesicles discharge at the plasmalemma, resulting in the mature egg being enveloped in an extra lipidic layer (Cave and Bell, 1974b). During maturation of the egg cell the nucleus becomes conspicuously larger and irregular in outline. The chromatin is well dispersed, but the nucleolus is very prominent and often shows structural differentiation. Nuclear bodies are frequent in the nucleoplasm. Although they resemble micronucleoli, and have a strong affinity for the uranyl ion (Bell, 1983a), there is no evidence that these bodies contain RNA or DNA. Similar bodies in the cytoplasm also appear to lack nucleic acids (Bell and Pennell, 1987). It seems beyond doubt that they consist principally, if not entirely, of acidic protein. In the egg cells of certain ferns, but not all (Bell, 1986), maturation of the egg cell is accompanied by a remarkable interpenetration of nucleus and cytoplasm. In Pteridium the nuclear protrusions take the form of vesicular blebs (bounded by both membranes of the nuclear envelope) or hooded sheets (Bell and Duckett, 1976; Fig. 1). In Dryopteris (Bell, 1974) and Histiopteris (Bell, 1980) the sheet-like protrusions are folded and interconnected, giving formations of remarkable complexity. There are clear indications, particularly in Pteridium, that the nuclear bodies enter the vesicular protrusions, and from there the material finds its way into the cytoplasm. There is, how-
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
63
ever, no conclusive evidence that these protrusions open and release the bodies into the cytoplasm. The material seems to leave the nucleus by some form of secretion (Bell and Pennell, 1987). The cytoplasm of the mature egg cell is well furnished with mitochondria and plastids, the latter being irregular in shape and often, following conventional fixation, having very indistinct boundaries (Bell, I983b). The matrices are commonly dense and the internal lamellae rudimentary. High-resolution autoradiography reveals that both mitochondria and plastids contain notable amounts of DNA. Pulse-labelling indicates that incorporation of tritiated thymidine is directly into the DNA within the organelles (Sigee and Bell, 1971; Sigee, 1972). Microtubules do not seem to be a feature of the egg cells of more recent ferns, but they are not uncommon in the egg cell of Todea, representative of an ancient family (Bell, 1986). 3. Heterosporous Pteridophytes and Seed Plants Spermatogenesis. There is little difference in principle between spermatogenesis in heterosporous and homosporous ferns. Marsilea has been studied in greatest detail (Myles and Bell, 1975; Myles and Hepler, 1982). The mature spermatozoid, although larger, is constructed in the manner of that of Pteridium. The same holds for the large spermatozoids of the zooidogamous gymnosperm Zamia (Norstog, 1968, 1974), and probably also of Ginkgo, although this awaits detailed examination. In the conifers (including Taxus) the male gametes are much less elaborate than in the zooidogamous archegoniates. They consist generally of a pair of nuclei in the persistent cytoplasm of the mother (spermatogenous) cell (e.g. Taxus (Pennell and Bell, 1988) and Agathis (Kaur and Bhatnagar, 1984)). There is no detectable provisions for propelling the sperm nuclei into the archegonium, although actin may be involved. In the flowering plants, the sperms while in the pollen tube and during discharge are distinct cells. Each is enclosed in its own plasmalemma, and the pair are surrounded by the plasmalemma of the vegetative cell. In a number of dicotyledons one of the sperm cells is connected with the convoluted vegetative nucleus. The complex formed by the two sperm cells and vegetative nucleus is referred to as the “male germ unit” (e.g. Brassica (McConchie et al., 1985) and Petunia (Wagner and Mogensen, 1988)). Although in the grasses the two sperm cells appear to be clearly separate, they become associated with the vegetative cell on germination, and the association persists during the growth of the tube (Mogensen and Wagner, 1987). The two sperm cells are not always identical in content. In Plumbago, for example, one sperm cell retains most of the mitochondria, and the other the plastids. The cell rich in plastids fuses preferentially with the egg cell (Russell, 1985). Oogenesis. Oogenesis in the heterosporous archegoniates follows a course similar to that seen in the homosporous, but with some significant differences. The archegonia are simpler with less development of the neck. The
64
PETER R. BELL
vesicular phase early in oogenesis appears to be absent and correspondingly no additional lipidic layer has been observed around the egg cell. The interpenetration of nucleus and cytoplasm, so striking a feature in some homosporous ferns, has never been seen in heterosporous forms (Tourte et al., 1971; Robert, 1972). The cytoplasm is rich in organelles, the plastids being commonly dedifferentiated and often curiously shaped (as in Selaginella (Robert, 1972)). In the cycads the egg cells are particularly large, the protoplast in Zamia, for example, reaching a diameter of 3 mm, and its nucleus at least 0.5 mm (Konar and Moitra, 1980). During maturation the Feulgenpositive material in the nucleus contracts to a small globule, but chromatin elsewhere may be too finely dispersed to give a detectable stain. The nuclear surface becomes undulate, and refractive granules, with no detectable Feulgen staining, are seen to stream from its surface into the cytoplasm (Bryan and Evans, 1956). No cytochemical or ultrastructural details of this phenomenon are yet available. In the conifers (including Taxus) oogenesis follows the same course as in the zooidogamous gymnosperms (Konar and Moitra, 1980). In some instances (e.g. Taxus (Pennell and Bell, 1987a)) it is not clear whether the nucleus of the central cell divides, in which case the central itself could function as the gamete. Alternatively, division may take place, but the upper ventral canal nucleus may be resorbed so quickly that it has escaped detection (Konar and Moitra, 1980). The mature egg cells are characterized by a wellordered cytoplasm. An outer zone contains whorls of endoplasmic reticulum and complex inclusions believed to be derived from plastids (Pennell and Bell, 1987a; Camefort, 1966), and long regarded as “protein bodies”. The large nucleus is surrounded by an inner zone of lipid globules and an intermediate zone of mitochondria. Amongst the mitochondria are small uraniophilic bodies (in some conifers clearly Feulgen-positive (Konar and Moitra, 1980)) about 600 nm in diameter. These may represent mitochondria which have lost their internal structure but have retained their DNA (Pennell and Bell, 1987a). Recognizable plastids are conspicuously absent. No recent information is available concerning the egg cells of Ephedra, Gnetum and Welwitschia. The egg cells of the flowering plants tend to be less complex than those of the archegoniates. They are usually larger than the accompanying cells at the micropylar end of the embryo sac, and the nucleus is swollen and barely Feulgen-positive. Although Woodcock and Bell (1968a) were able to show by means of UV microspectrography that DNA was present in the cytoplasm of the egg cell of Myosurus (whereas none was detectable in the cytoplasm of adjacent nucellar cells), the cytoplasm is comparatively poor in mitochondria and plastids (Woodcock and Bell, 1968b). This seems to be a feature of the egg cells of flowering plants generally (Kapil and Bhatnagar, 1981; You and Jensen, 1985). Nucleocytoplasmic interaction of a physical kind has not been observed, and notable cytoplasmic inclusions appear to be lacking.
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
65
B. SPOROGENESIS
1 . Algae Detailed studies of the spore mother cells of eukaryotic algae are remarkably few. Hopkins and McBride (1 976) were able to show by Feulgen microspectrophotometry that the amount of DNA in the zygotic nucleus of Coleochaete scutatu reached eight times the unreplicated haploid level, indicating two rounds of DNA replication before meiosis. Meiosis itself and the differentiation of the meiospores of C. pufvinata has been followed in the electron microscope, but unfortunately with few details of the cytoplasm and no cytochemical data (Graham and Taylor, 1986). The most complete descriptions available are of tetrasporogenesis in the Rhodophyta. In Dasya, for example, the frequency of ribosomes in the tetrasporangium diminishes conspicuously during prophase I, and aggregates of electron-opaque granules, which stain intensely with basic dyes, appear in the cytoplasm during diplotene (Broadwater et al., 1986). It is unfortunate that few details are available of meiosis in the oospore of the Charales. Although a tetrad of nuclei is formed, three nuclei are resorbed (a feature also of the germinating zygote of Spirogyra). Study of this remarkable feature has probably been hampered by the extreme difficulty of fixing the mature egg cell and zygote of the Charales. 2. Bryophytes and Homosporous Pteridophytes Although comprehensive studies of sporogenesis in bryophytes are few, current knowledge points to the sporocytes of both liverworts (Horner et al., 1966; Kelley and Doyle, 1975) and mosses (Brown and Lemmon, 1980) being surrounded by conspicuous polysaccharide walls with a fibrillar texture. The cytoplasm of the sporocyte and subsequent spore mother cell is rich in ribosomes (Horner et al., 1966; Eyme and Suire, 1971; Brown and Lemmon, 1980), and in Riccardia has a corresponding strong affinity for basic stains (Homer et al., 1966). No diminution in ribosome frequencies or basophilic staining becomes apparent until the formation of the spores (EymC and Suire, 1971; Horner et al., 1966). The behaviour of the mitochondria during sporogenesis is unremarkable, but the reduction in the number of plastids, especially in mosses, has attracted considerable attention (Paolillo, 1969; Jensen and Hulbary, 1978). This reduction, leading in some instances to only one being present in the sporocyte, is probably a consequence of division of the plastids failing to keep pace with mitosis in the development of the sporogenous tissue, although reduction by fusion has also been suggested (Jensen and Hulbary, 1978). Where a single plastid is present in the sporocyte, it divides into four at meiosis, one passing into each newly formed spore. The situation in the liverworts is less regular (Ramsay, 1983). Sporogenesis in the homosporous pteridophytes has been studied most
66
PETER R. BELL
extensively in the ferns. Noteworthy features (reviewed in Sheffield and Bell (1987)) are the occlusion at an early stage of all plasmodesmata between the tapetum and the sporogenous cells, and the thickened walls which form around the spore mother cells. During prophase of meiosis there is loss of basophilia from the cytoplasm and a sharp reduction in the frequency of ribosomes. In mid-prophase, balloon-like invaginations of the inner membrane of the nuclear envelope penetrate the nucleoplasm. The “nuclear invaginations” detected at pachytene and subsequently in Psilotum (Gabarajeva, 1984) are probably of like origin. Small aggregates of material with a texture similar to that of the nucleolus are present in the cytoplasm. These aggregates disperse in the cytoplasm of the young spores coincident with an increasing frequency of ribosomes. Also striking at this time is a brief phase in which narrow tubular extensions of the nucleus penetrate the cytoplasm, often running very close to organelles but without evident connection. In Anemia (Schraudolf, 1984) this phase of nucleocytoplasmic interaction takes the form of nuclear invaginations, involving both membranes of the envelope, carrying finger-like columns of cytoplasm into the nucleus. These invaginations often terminate in a swelling, associated internally .and externally with electron-opaque material. In sporogenesis generally in the homosporous vascular archegoniates the plastids have lost much of their internal structure by the end of prophase, but it is progressively regained during the development of the spores. In Lycopodium there are indications of a degeneration of a proportion of the mitochondria and plastids in the mother cell (Pettitt, 1978), but this does not appear to be general in the pteridophytes. In some species of pteridophytes which are usually regarded as homosporous, the spores nevertheless fall into two size classes. A notable example is the fern Platyzoma. Preliminary examinations show that, although there is some variation withing sporangia, the large and small spores are produced separately and in different numbers (Tryon, 1964). Sporogenesis has not yet been investigated in detail, but it appears that omission of one or two of the mitoses in the sporogenous lineage results in fewer spore mother cells and larger spores. There are no indications of regular degeneration of spore mother cells or meiotic products. 3. Heterosporous Pteridophytes and Seed Plants Microsporogenesis. The principal contribution by modern techniques to knowledge of microsporogenesis in heterosporous pteridophytes concerns Azolla. There are close similarities to homosporous sporogenesis, including the formation of a thickened wall around microspore mother cells and the coincident breaking of all plasmodesmatal connections with the tapetal cells (Herd et al., 1985). Subsequently, as the nucleus of the mother cell enters prophase, the density of the cytoplasm diminishes. Isolation of the mother cell is also a feature of the conifers. In addition, studies of developing microsporangia reveal a second layer, the peritapetal
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
67
membrane (Dickinson, 1970a), which surrounds the whole spore sac, including the tapetum. Since this membrane resists acetolysis and probably consists of sporopollenin, it may reinforce the isolation of the developing spores from all but simple nutrients from the parent plant. In other respects, microsporogenesis in conifers (reviewed by Moitra and Bhatnagar (1982)) has many resemblances, including the formation of nuclear vacuoles in prophase (Sheffield et al., 1979), to sporogenesis in homosporous pteridophytes. It should be noted, however, that prophase of meiosis is often prolonged (Anderson et a/. 1969; Owens and Molder, 1971). In Taxus, where prophase lasts about 4 weeks, there is no dramatic fall in cytoplasmic RNA in the mother cells during this time (Pennell and Bell, 1987b). This is possibly also the situation in other conifers with extended meioses. Dickinson (1981), for example, comments on the relatively small decline in cytoplasmic RNA during prophase in Pinus. A remarkable feature of the newly formed pollen grains of Pinus (Dickinson and Bell, 1970) and Podocarpus (Aldrich and Vasil, 1970) is the invagination of the nuclear envelope in a manner similar to that seen in Anemia. In Pinus the electron-opaque material within the invagination has been shown to be rich in RNA (Dickinson and Potter, 1975), and the material in the nucleus surrounding the invagination to be chromatin (Li and Dickinson, 1987). The extensive investigations of microsporogenesis in flowering plants reveal a situation similar in essentials to that in conifers. Isolation of the microspore mother cells by thickened (and often callosed) walls appears to be general. Later in sporogenesis an acetolysis-resistant peritapetal membrane, corresponding to that in conifer microsporangia, has been detected around the tapetum and sporogenous tissue in Cosmos and some other Compositae (Heslop Harrison, 1969). A similar membrane occurs in Brassica, but not in Petunia or Lilium (Dickinson, personal communication). A striking fall in cytoplasmic RNA during prophase has been observed in a number of species, but it is not known whether this is also a feature of those species in which meiosis is prolonged (e.g. Trillium erectum, in which meiosis occurs naturally at 6 6 ° C and lasts several weeks (Sparrow et al., 1955)). In Lilium the fall is now known to involve both ribosomal and messenger RNA (Porter et al., 1984). Nucleolar activity is also conspicuous before metaphase I, and bodies regarded as micronucleoli are frequent in the nucleoplasm (Dickinson and Heslop Harrison, 1976). Also at this time a tendency for the inner membrane of the nuclear envelope to invaginate into the nucleoplasm has been seen in Lycopersicon (Sheffield et al., 1979) and Datura (Sangwan, 1986). Prominent in the cytoplasm of Lilium throughout meiosis are regions of cytoplasm bounded by two or three membranes, and also, following anaphase I, bodies strikingly like nucleoli (“nucleoloids”) (Dickinson and Heslop Harrison, 1976). Both disperse in the young spores, the dispersal being associated with a return of ribosome frequencies to pre-meiotic levels.
68
PETER R.BELL
Neither the source nor the composition of the nucleoloids is yet clear, and it would not be safe to assume on present evidence that they contain RNA (Dickinson. 1987). At the tetrad stage there are also indications in Lilium of activity at the nuclear surface. Both blebbing of the outer membrane of the envelope, the blebs containing electron-opaque material, and vesicular extensions of the nucleus itself, bounded by both membranes of the envelope, have been observed (Dickinson, 1971). Also at this time in Lilium, and probably elsewhere, the plastids, which have become wholly dedifferentiated by the end of meiosis, acquire starch and rudimentary internal lamellae (Dickinson and Heslop Harrison. 1970). Megasporogenesis. In the heterosporous ferns, megasporogenesis has been most fully investigated in Marsilea. As the sporogenous cells prepare for meiosis they acquire thick walls, and on entering meiosis show loss of ribosomes (Bell, 1981). Meiosis results in a tetrahedral tetrad of megaspores indistinguishable ultrastructurally from each other (Bell, 198 1). Nevertheless, before the spores separate, one spore begins to degenerate, followed by two more as the tetrad opens (Bell, 1985). Of the surviving megaspores liberated into the invasive tapetum, one soon establishes dominance, and it alone comes to maturity. In the maturing megaspore the surface of the nucleus is particularly active. Tubular extensions, each connected to the main body of the nucleus by a narrow channel, penetrate far into the cytoplasm. Although they often run close to mitochondria and plastids, sometimes making contact with their envelopes, continuity of contents has never been observed. The cytoplasm of the maturing spore, lying around a central vacuole, is well furnished with ribosomes and organelles. Occasionally, large vesicle-like extensions of the whole nucleus containing only electron-translucent material have been observed within the central vacuole (Bell, 1985). In Seluginella, megasporogenesis is altogether less regular. The mother cells in the megasporangia are fewer than in the microsporangia. Some, with a cytoplasm less rich in RNA, degenerate (Horner and Beltz, 1970). In addition to degeneration of megaspore. mother cells, those remaining may produce megaspores of different sizes, only the larger coming to maturity (Pettitt, 1977). The differences in behaviour can be related to gradients in the cytoplasm of the mother cell. In Isoetes there are similar differences in the number of mother cells in the mega- and microsporangia, but all the megaspores come to maturity. In I. engelmanni each megaspore inherits a large proplastid which, by a remarkable process of budding, restores the plastid population in the maturing megaspore (Pettitt, 1976). In gymnosperms in general the megaspore mother cell appears to be isolated from the nucellus by a thickened wall lacking plasmodesmata. Information about meiosis and the accompanying events in the cytoplasm is limited. In the megaspore mother cell of Ginkgo, Stewart and Gifford (1967) detected a marked polarization in the distribution of the organelles, most of the mito-
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
69
chondria and plastids being confined to the chalazal hemisphere. A similar situation is found in Taxus (Pennell and Bell, 1987a). Also in Taxus most of the ribosomes seem to be conserved during meiosis, but significant cytochemical information corresponding to that relating to prophase in the microsporangia (Pennell and Bell, 1987b) is lacking. In extinct gymnosperms, megaspores were probably formed in tetrahedral tetrads (Pettitt, 1969), but in living species meiosis results in a linear tetrad, or a T-shaped tetrad in which the upper diad has divided transversely to the axis of the ovule. Tetrahedral arrangements are, however, sometimes encountered in conifers in which there are several megaspore mother cells in the nucellus (e.g. Sequoia (Looby and Doyle, 1942)). Normally the spore in the chalazal position is alone capable of further development. In Taxus (and probably, but not certainly, elsewhere) this is also the spore which retains most of the cytoplasm derived from the mother cell. Whether this is a sufficient condition for its survival is not known. In flowering plants the megaspore mother cell, surrounded by a thickened and often callosed wall, is in general characterized by a cytoplasm with dedifferentiated mitochondria and plastids and few ribosomes (Kapil and Bhatnagar, 1981). Megasporogenesis has been studied in greatest detail in Lilium (Dickinson and Potter, 1978). The changes in the cytoplasm parallel those seen on the male side, including pre-metaphase nucleolar activity, and the subsequent appearances of nucleoloids in the cytoplasm. Regions of cytoplasm enclosed in whorls of membrane are also conspicuous. Although in Lilium these are regarded as protecting a proportion of the cytoplasm from the partial autophagy evident elsewhere, Schulz and Jensen (1981) find that the membranes surrounding similar bodies in the megaspore mother cell of Capsella are rich in acid phosphatase, a marker of lysosomal activity. During prophase, vesicular extensions of the nucleus are found in Capsella (Schulz and Jensen, 1981), but in Myosurus these are a feature of the developing megaspore (Woodcock and Bell, L968b). The extensions recall those seen in the developing megaspores of Marsilea, and, as there, occasionally contain internal membranes. Coincident with the nuclear activity in Myosurus, the cytoplasmic DNA (as determined by UV microspectrography) begins to increase, reaching a maximum in the two-celled embryo-sac (Woodcock and Bell, 1968a). In species with monosporic embryo-sacs the mitochondria and plastids are often concentrated in the chalazal region of the megaspore mother cell, resulting in an unequal division between the spores. This has been held to account for the promotion of the chalazal spore, but in Myosurus (Woodcock and Bell, 1968a) and some other species (Kapil and Bhatnagar, 1981) there is no evident inequality in the distribution of the organelles. In Capsella (Schulz and Jensen, 1981) and some Orchidaceae (Rodkiewicz and Bednara, 1976) the chalazal region of the wall of the mother cell and of the subsequent surviving megaspore becomes labyrinthine, leading to the suggestion that
70
PETER R. BELL
this spore alone receives nutrients adequate for development. This view is strengthened by the presence in Oenothera, in which the micropylar megaspore survives, of plasmodesmata in the corresponding micropylar portion of the wall of the mother cell (Jalouzot, 1978). Although the usual terms “microspore” and “megaspore” have been used in this chapter it should be noted that megaspores in seed plants are often smaller than the microspores (Doyle, 1953). “Androspore” and “gynospore” would be a more accurate terminology.
IV. THE SIGNIFICANT FEATURES OF ABERRANT CYCLES A. ABERRANT CYCLES IN NATURAL CONDITIONS
1. Algae
In the algae the reproductive cells appear to be particularly labile. In Chlumydomonas, for example, the gametes can revert to somatic behaviour. A similar situation is found in Ulva and the brown alga Ectocarpus. In Oedogonium the oogonia may develop parthenogenetically, and a cycle continue without meiosis. In Chara crinita, although the nuclear relationships are not clear, the egg cell forms an oospore which develops without fertilization, and most populations appear to maintain themselves by a parthenogenetic cycle. The life cycles of many algae change readily in response to fluctuating environmental conditions. In some instances perfect cycles are so infrequent that the relationship between gametophyte and sporophyte has not been recognized, and the two forms have been placed in separate genera. The situation is further complicated by one form sometimes being able to give rise directly to the other (as occurs, for example, in the Halicystis (gametophyte)/Derbesia (sporophyte) complex in the Chlorophyta (Rietema, 1975)). A general review of algal cycles and their deviations can be found in Ettl et al. (1967). 2. Bryophytes and Homosporous Pteridophytes Although many bryophytes propagate themselves readily by means of gemmae or fragmentation, aberrant cycles with a clear relationship to the sexual cycles are unknown in natural conditions. Amongst the homosporous pteridophytes, natural aberrant cycles are also unknown in the lycopods and Equisetum, but are common in the ferns. A familiar example is provided by Pteris cretica. Common to this kind of cycle (first clarified in Dryopteris by Dopp (1939)) is the failure of telophase in the final mitotic division of the sporogenous cell lineage, and the subsequent production of an embryo without gametic fusion. In the sporangia the failure of telophase in the sporogenous lineage results in the nucleus of the spore mother cell containing a doubled number of chromosomes. During the
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
71
formation of this restitution nucleus a transverse wall grows in from the margins of the cell, resembling in the manner of its formation (except for the absence of transverse microtubules) the phycoplast of a dividing algal cell (Fowke and Pickett-Heaps, 1969). The wall may even begin to constrict the nucleus, but at this point it is rapidly resorbed and the nucleus prepares for the prophase of meiosis (Sheffield et al., 1983). Many ferns with this kind of cycle (the so-called “apogamous” ferns) are (in comparison with their sexual relatives) triploid or pentaploid, and the events in the sporangia are variable. The sporangia producing viable spores normally contain 8 spore mother cells, but 4- and 16-celled sporangia also occur. Sporogenesis in these is irregular and the spores largely inviable. The development of the few which germinate has been little studied. In Dryopteris afinis subsp. afinis, a diploid form, 8-celled sporangia predominate (Sheffield et al., 1983). The spores produced in the 8-celled sporangia of the apogamous ferns are larger than those of their sexual relatives (in which the sporangia contain 16 spore mother cells). In Dryopteris, for example, the respective diameters are of the order of 80 pm and 40 pm, indicating an eight-fold difference in volume. The gametophytes of the apogamous ferns mature faster than those of sexual relatives (Whittier, 1970). After passing through a male phase, an embryo is produced directly, without clear demarcation between the tissue of the gametophyte and the cells initiating the embryo (Laird, 1986). In a second form of apogamous cycle, found hitherto only in tropical ferns, there is no synapsis of chromosomes in the prophase of meiosis. The nuclei reform without division. The second division of meiosis is normal and spores are formed in diads with an unreduced chromosome number (Braithwaite, 1964). Many ferns with this kind of cycle have high chromosome numbers (Walker, 1985). The spore output is generally low, and the spores are variable in size. Embryos are produced directly from the gametophytes, but sometimes only after prolonged growth. A number of cycles involving apogamy are also known from cultivated varieties of ferns. Notable examples’are provided by the varieties clarissima Jones and clarissima Bolton of Athyrium Jilix-femina (Farmer and Digby, 1907). In both, gametophytic outgrowths arise aposporously from the soral regions of fertile fronds, the sporangia themselves being abortive. In clarissima Jones the gametophyte bears antheridia and archegonia, but the archegonia are not functional and the embryo arises apogamously from somatic tissue of the gametophyte. Var. clarissima Bolton is quite similar, but the embryo is said to arise by the parthenogenetic development of an egg cell. Unfortunately these varieties are now very rare in cultivation, and it has not been possible to reinvestigate them by modern techniques.
3. Heterosporous Pteridophytes and Seed Plants Parthenogenetic development of egg cells is known in species of Marsilea, Salvinia, Selaginella and Isoetes (Dopp, 1967; Bhardwaja and Abdullah,
72
PETER R. BELL
1972; Mahlberg and Baldwin, 1975). Since in some instances whole populations are affected, and microsporangia are either absent or very rare (Bhardwaja, personal communication), they are presumably able to maintain themselves by means of parthogenetic cycles. The nuclear aspects of these cycles are not fully known. In Isoetes, polyploidy is probably involved (Marsden, 1976). Apart from various forms of polyembryony (which can be regarded as a form of vegetative reproduction), gymnosperms provide no known examples of aberrant cycles. Angiosperms, on the other hand, provide many. Parthenogenetic cycles are well represented, for example, in the grasses, Compositae and Rosaceae. In all these instances the female gametophyte either develops aposporously from a somatic cell of the nucellus, and is thus diploid from its initiation, or its origin lies in a modified meiosis which results in a pair of nuclei with unreduced chromosome numbers (Nygren, 1967). In Alchemilla some archaesporial cells may reach anaphase of meiosis I, but development does not proceed further. The functional embryo-sacs are either diplosporous or aposporous (Izmailow, 1986). In some flowering plants with apomictic cycles, continued development of the parthogenetic embryo depends upon pollination. Although pollination may do nothing more than provide a general stimulus necessary for the development of the seed and fruit, its function is sometimes more precise. In Panicum maximum, for example, one of the sperm cells fuses with the central cell to form an endosperm nucleus (Warmke, 1954). Endosperm and parthenogenetic embryo then develop together as in a normal seed. B. INDUCED ABERRATIONS IN SEXUAL CYCLES
1. Algae Many of the variations seen in life cycles in nature have been reproduced in culture, and the conditions inducing the aberrations identified (Ettl et al., 1967). Reports of wholly new forms produced experimentally are few. Mainx (1931) was able to obtain a race of Oedogonium plagiostomum (Chlorophyta) with giant cells by germinating fertilized oogonia without preliminary chilling. In several instances the zygote grew out as a single cell and gave rise to a massive filament. Although the supporting cytology is lacking, it seems likely that in the experimental conditions meiosis failed and the growths obtained were diploid. The filaments produced zoospores (with diameters of 40 pm as opposed to 20 pm) and oogonia, but antheridia were very rare. Unfertilized oogonia ultimately degenerated and showed no tendency to parthenogenetic development, despite parthenogenesis being not uncommon in the Oedogoniales in nature. In the Rhodophyta, Waaland (1978) was able to fuse protoplasts from somatic regions of male and female plants of Grifithsiu. These parasexual heterokaryons (the nuclei did not fuse) gave rise to growths having the char-
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
73
acteristic form of tetrasporangial branches, although no viable tetraspores were produced. When the fusion was restricted to protoplasts from the male, or from the female plants, the filaments produced solely the correspdnding sexual reproductive structures, and tetrasporangial features were absent. In the Phaeophyta it has been claimed that treatment of egg cells of Fucus with low concentrations of fatty acids leads to parthenogenesis (Overton, 1913), but these results lack confirmation (Evans et al., 1982). 2. Bryophytes and Homosporous Pteridophytes Bryophytes were the first group of archegoniates in which it was demonstrated experimentally that not only the spores, but also cells in other regions of the sporophyte, would give rise to gametophytic growths (Pringsheim, 1876; Stahl, 1876). Subsequently it was observed that gametophytes generated in this way often bore sporogonia apogamously. In some instances the appearance of sporogonia was encouraged by dryness of the medium, and fluctuations in hydration could lead to bizarre growths in which leaves and sporogonia alternated along the axis of a shoot (see Bauer (1967) for a review of the earlier work). Investigations of the regenerative capacity of young normal sporogonia showed that although the seta would give rise only to protonema, the apical region would regenerate either sporogonia directly, or callus which produced sporogonia on further culture. This difference in response was partiqularly marked in the hybrid sporogonium Funaria x Physcomitrium (Fig. 3). A later discovery was that secondary protonema developed from shoots of naturally-occurring species (and therefore wholly gametophytic in origin) would also develop sporogonia apogamously in culture, particularly if sugar were present in the medium (Lazarenko et al., 1961; Lal, 1961). In Physcomitriumpiriforme, which also behaves in this way, the sporogonia were found to arise from groups of isodiametric intercalary cells initiated by unequal divisions of the normally long protonemal cells (Menon and Lal, 1972). The intercalary cells have a dense cytoplasm containing abundant ribosomes. Some develop labyrinthine walls, but there is no organized interface between the developing sporogonium and the protonemal filament (Menon and Bell, 1981). It is not clear whether the protonema of species with basic chromosome numbers is also capable of behaving apogamously. In all instances hitherto the species which have responded in this way have chromosome numbers which suggest a polyploid origin. In Funaria hygrometrica, which exists naturally as two races (n and 2n), Bauer (1959) found that the protonema of the diploid race produced sporogonia apogamously, but that of the haploid grown in the same conditions did not. The existence of a “sporogonial factor” affecting the readiness with which a gametophyte displays apogamy has been suspected (see Lal, 1984). This may be hormonal. The kinetin-like hormone “bryokinin”, for example, promotes apogamy in Splachnum
Fig. 3. The kinds of regeneration obtainable from the different zones of developing moss sporogonia. A, apical cell and immediately adjacent cells; B,, meristematic region eventually giving rise to the capsule; B,, meristem contributing to the seta, at a later stage forming the apophysis; C, extension zone; D, fully differentiated part of seta; E, foot of a normally developed sporogonium; E,, foot of an apogamously formed sporogonium. The broken lines indicate indefinite continuation of the growth form depicted in the appropriate cultural conditions. From Bauer (1963).
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
75
(Bauer, 1966). The distribution of the factor within a culture may not be uniform. Ripetsky (1980, 1983), working with Portia intermedia, found that protonema regenerated from protoplasts extracted from cells adjacent to the sporogenous cells wholly lacked an apogamous tendency. Protonema regenerated from protoplasts from all other somatic regions of the sporogonium showed frequent apogamy, and the tendency was retained indefinitely in culture. Although the sporogonia of liverworts will also give rise to gametophytes aposporously (Lang, 1901; Burgeff, 1937; Lal, 1984), there are no reports of apogamy. It may be significant that low chromosome numbers, suggestive of the predominance of basic haploidy, are a feature of these bryophytes (Berrie, 1960). Although interest in apospory in ferns was initially concerned principally with those species with apogamous cycles, the ability of young leaves generally to produce gametophytic outgrowths in experimental conditions also became apparent (Goebel, 1907; Lang, 1924). In the experiments of Sheffield and Bell (1981), carried out in defined conditions, small explants of the first leaf of Pteridium sporelings placed on agar medium regularly began to grow out as gametophytes within 3 days (Fig. 4). In these experiments, and in those of Hirsch ( 1975) on Microgramma, sucrose discouraged the aposporous response. Numerous experiments on the induction of apospory in sexual species (Goebel, 1907; Lawton, 1932; Morel, 1963; Sheffield and Bell, 1981; von Aderkas, 1986; Kwa et al., 1988) have shown that the response declines with successive leaves. Although possibly partly a consequence of a thickening cuticle as the form of the leaf becomes more mature, this explanation cannot wholly suffice. Even the delicate prothallus-like outgrowths produced in the soral regions of some forms of Pteridium (possibly a consequence of mites (Whittier, 1966)) cannot be induced to develop into gametophytes in culture (Steil, 1949). Ultrastructural examination of the cells in Pteridium explants changing from sporophyte to gametophyte reveals a rapid resumption of meristematic features. The cytoplasm becomes denser, the ribosomes more numerous, and the mitochondria and plastids, which undergo no dedifferentiation, multiply (Sheffield, 1985). Apogamy can be induced in some pteridophytes by the simple expedient of withholding surface water from cultured gametophytes. Only in a few instances will these outgrowths become well established and produce fertile fronds (Manton and Walker, 1954; Palta and Mehra, 1983). Meiosis is then imperfect and the spores are largely inviable. An extreme form of apogamy is the production of sporangia directly on the gametophyte (Lang, 1929; Lawton, 1932), but again the spores are probably inviable. Numerous experiments on the induction of apogamy in Pteridium (in which the outgrowths achieve only limited development) have been carried out by Whittier and coworkers. The presence of sucrose in the medium (Whittier and Steeves, 1960) and ethylene in the ambient atmosphere (Elmore and Whittier, 1975) pro-
76
PETER R. BELL
Fig. 4. Pieridium aquilinum. Low-temperature scanning electron micrograph of the upper surface o f an aposporous explant. 5 days after detachment of the juvenile leaf from the parent plant. Two of the outgrowths (arrows) have already developed two-sided apical cells. x 95. Micrograph supplied by Dr E. Sheffield.
mote the response. There seems to be a tendency for diploid races of fern gametophytes to yield apogamous outgrowths more readily than haploid (Heilbronn, 1932; Whittier, 1966~). Apogamy has also been recorded in ageing cultures of Lycopodium deprived of surface water (Freeberg, 1957). In Equisetum, apogamous outgrowths of clearly sporophytic form have been obtained by treating gametophytes with kinetin (Ooya, 1974).
3. Heterosporous Pteridophytes and Seed Plants Fragments of young leaves of Marsilea, treated in exactly the same way as those of Pteridium, failed to show any form of development (Sheffield and
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
77
Bell, 1981).There are no records of aposporous regeneration in Sefagineffaor Isoetes. It seems that the acquisition of heterospory carried with it loss of the ability to generate gametophytic tissue aposporously. Parthenogenetic apogamy can be induced in Marsifea and other members of the Marsileaceae by culturing megaspores in the absence of microspores (Shaw, 1897; Mahlberg and Baldwin, 1975; personal observations on Marsifeu vestira). Whether this is effective with heterosporous pteridophytes other than the Marsileaceae is not known. Apospory is not reported in gymnosperms, but the apogamous development of plantlets from tissue of the female gametophyte is recorded in cycads (La Rue, 1954; Norstog and Rhamstine, 1967) and in Ephedra (Konar and Singh, 1979). It is conceivable that aberrations of the cycle could be successfully induced in other archegoniate seed plants, but experiments with Ginkgo, using pollen and explants of female gametophyte, have hitherto yielded only callus (Tulecke, 1967). This has been the experience with a number of other gymnosperms (Winton and Stettler, 1974). Induced apospory in the flowering plants concerns principally the nucellus, the site of megasporogenesis, and those species in which there is already a tendency towards ambivalence. In the grass Dichanthium aristatum, for example, both normal and aposporous embryo-sacs are a feature of the regular cycle. The proportions of the two forms of sac can, however, be varied by altering the photoperiod. With the minimum period of photoinduction necessary for flowering the proportion of the aposporous sacs falls significantly (Knox and Heslop Harrison, 1963). Induced aposporous development of a gametophyte from cells in the male lineage appears not to have been observed. The parthenogenetic development of egg cells of flowering plants can be induced in a number of ways. Irradiation of embryo-sacs will in some instances destroy the nucleus of the egg cell, but the cell nevertheless remains viable, Pollination then results in a haploid embryo (Ehrensberger, 1948). The use of irradiated pollen can also lead to haploid embryos (Laccadena, 1974). Haploid embryos have also been obtained by treating pollen with the dye Toluidine Blue (which binds to DNA). The growth of the tube is not prevented, but the sperm nuclei are inactivated (Illias, 1974). Certain aberrant genes, such as the hap gene in barley (Hagberg and Hagberg, 1980) and the “indeterminate gametophyte” (ig) gene in maize (Kermicle, 1969), can also promote parthenogenesis. Finally, in some instances it is possible to raise haploid embryos by direct culture of the egg cell (Zhou and Yang, 1981). A surprising discovery has been the readiness with which pollen grains in suitable cultural conditions will give rise to haploid embryos. The range of plants in which this has been accomplished is impressive (e.g. Kasha and Sequin-Swartz, 1983). There appears to be little impediment to the development of sporophytic morphology in the presence of the haploid nucleus.
78
PETER R. BELL
V. THE CAUSAL APPROACH TO ALTERNATION A. GENERAL ASSUMPTIONS
In interpreting the observational and experimental data described above it will be assumed that gametophytic and sporophytic morphology and behaviour are each determined by the integrated activation of a number of specific, but probably not contiguous, genes. It is further proposed that the form of growth will depend upon the balance of the activation, rather than one set of genes being completely repressed. Many genes, particularly those concerned with basic metabolism, are likely to be active in each phase. In Ulva, for example, no major differences could be detected between the soluble proteins from gametophytic and sporophytic plants (Hushovd et al., 1982). The differences so far detected in algae affect cell wall chemistry. In the red alga Gigartina, although carrageenan levels are of the same order in sporophyte and gametophyte, the sporophytic carrageenan is poorer in 3,6-anhydrogalactose, and richer in sulphate groups (Pickmere et al., 1973). In a number of siphonaceous algae a regular alternation in the chemistry of the cell wall is correlated with the different growth habits of the two reproductive phases (Tanner, 1981). In the flowering plant Tradescantia, Willing and Mascarenhas (1984) have concluded from an analysis of mRNAs from pollen and shoots that a large proportion of the genes are active in each phase. Similar discoveries have been made in respect of Zea mays (Willing et al., 1988; SariGorla et al., 1986) and Lycopersicon (Tanksley et al., 1981). It appears, therefore, that the number of genes concerned with the reproductive phase may be relatively few. After establishing the sites at which change of phase occurs, the causal approach to the problem of alternation becomes one of identifying the features likely to affect the balance of gene activity at those sites. B. FROM GAMETOFWYTE TO SPOROPHYTE IN THE LOWER PLANTS
1. The Uniqueness of the Female Gamete In looking for intimations of alternation in sexual cycles of algae and homosporous land plants, it seems reasonable to concentrate on the female gamete. There is no evidence that spermatogenesis in zooidogamous plants leads to a gametic cytoplasm rich in developmentally important molecules. The principal gene product appears to be tubulin (Schedlbauer et al., 1973; Pennell et al., 1988) destined for the motile apparatus. The main contribution of the male gamete to the zygote, apart from tubulin in the form of microtubules and axonemes, is a nucleus in which the chromatin is condensed or compacted, not a state associated with transcription.* It is doubtful whether the few organelles of male origin play a significant morphogenetic role. In Chlamydomonas the chloroplasts of the two mating strains fuse, but the * Note, however, the evidence recently presented for the presence of mRNA in the condensed nucleus of the spermatozoid of the fern Phyllitis scolopendrium (Rejon er al., 1988).
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
79
DNA of one appears to be depolymerized (Sager, 1972; Nakamura et al., 1986). Little information is available from other algae. Although the fate of the “limosphere” (a plastid-mitochondrion complex appressed to the nucleus during differentiation of the spermatozoid in mosses (La1 and Bell, 1975)) is obscure, it seems unlikely that plastids are inherited from the male side in either bryophytes or pteridophytes. In the pteridophytes the few incoming male mitochondria are probably degraded in the zygote (Myles, 1978; Sheffield and Bell, 1987). The situation elsewhere is unknown. The development of the copious cytoplasm characteristic of the female gamete is initiated in both algae and archegoniates by one or more unequal divisions. Although the control of unequal divisions is obscure, once the inequality is established, the separate development of the larger cell, which retains most of the cytoplasm, is assured. Further plasmatic growth, accompanied by enlargement of the nucleus and decondensation of its chromatin, leads ultimately to the distinctive ultrastructural features of the mature gamete. So similar are these features in algae and archegoniates that it can be tentatively assumed that the cytochemical features, currently known principally from the ferns, are also similar. It seems likely, for example, that transcription and translation accompanying oogenesis (Fig. 2) will be found to be general, and also possibly transcription unaccompanied by translation continuing into the mature gamete (Fig. 2). The discovery in ferns that if thiouracil is introduced into this RNA. the egg cell, following fertilization with a normal spermatozoid, will give rise to an embryo tending to revert to gametophytic growth (Jayasekera and Bell, 1972), is a clear indication that at least part of the transcription is concerned with the change of phase. The concept of the mature egg cell being already programmed for sporophytic growth seems well founded. Of less evident morphogenetic significance are the aggregates of granular material present in the nucleus and cytoplasm of mature egg cells of algae, bryophytes and ferns, probably in all instances consisting, as in the ferns, of acidic protein. Since this material appears at a time when the chromatin is highly dispersed, it may represent a temporary sequestration of a protein or proteins concerned with chromosomal structure. Also of doubtful significance in relation to change of phase are the high levels of DNA in the mitochondria and plastids of fern eggs, again possibly a feature of egg cells of other lower plants. Besides permitting rapid replication of these organelles during embryogenesis, some of this DNA may be mobilized and utilized in the synthesis of nuclear DNA. Evidence for this is that in the presence of tritiated thymidine the first divisions in the embryo remain unlabelled (Bell, 1961). More relevant to alternation may be the indications in high-resolution autoradiographs of cytoplasmic DNA not satisfactorily related to mitochondria or plastids (Sigee and Bell, 1971). This may correspond to the cytoplasmic I-somes, small packets of informational DNA, believed by E. Bell
80
PETER R. BELL
(1969) to be present in differentiating animal cells and to play a role in controlling protein synthesis. The relatively high level of basic proteins in the cytoplasm of egg cells (as detected by the Sakagouchi reaction) raises the possibility of this DNA being in the form of a chromatin-like complex (Bell, 1963). These considerations lead to the view that in the lower plants the balance of gene activity shifts in favour of sporophytic growth during oogenesis. The causes of this shift are probably to be sought in the progressively richer plasmatic environment in which the nucleus in the female lineage finds itself. Throughout oogenesis the cell with the larger complement of cytoplasm appears to act as a powerful sink, attracting to itself an increasing share of metabolites. Its sister cells remain depauperate or even diminish. In the archegonium the demands of the egg cell appear to be such that the organization of the other cells in the canal cannot be maintained. They suffer lysis in consequence. At the time of maturation, the boundary of the canal is conspicuously thickened and the chamber sealed. It seems likely, therefore, that the products of lysis, amongst which will be nucleotides and polypeptides, are retained in the canal. The egg cell in its final phase of maturation will thus be brought into intimate contact with a concentration of complex molecules, some or all of which may be taken into the cytoplasm. Among prokaryotes the genome is known to respond readily to changes in levels of essential nutrients, and gene activation is adjusted accordingly (see Gottesman (1984) for review). There is no evident reason why eukaryotes should lack comparable regulatory networks. The finalization of the shift in the balance of gene activation towards the sporophytic phase can reasonably be regarded as the response of the genome of the egg cell to the enriched environment of the archegonium. The final size of the female gamete appears to bear little relationship to change of phase. The significance of the very large egg cells of the cycads, for example, is probably to be sought in the general biology of the group. The concept of the uniqueness of the female gamete is supported by the results of fusing gametophytic protoplasts. In mosses this results in a parasexual hybrid of gametophytic form and function (Grimsley et al., 1977). A closer approach to normal fertilization was achieved in Grifithsia with the fusion of protoplasts from male and female plants. The resulting growth did not, however, take on a sporophytic function. 2. The Signijicance of Apogamy Parthenogenesis. In view of the foregoing arguments it might be expected that the parthenogenetic development of female gametes would not be uncommon. This appears to be so in the Chlorophyta (Ettl et al., 1967), although it is not always clear that the development is truly sporophytic. Certainly in Ulva, which has an isomorphous cycle, the sporophytic nature of the thalli arising from unfertilized gametes is confirmed by the attempted meiosis
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
81
in the zoosporangia (Tanner, 1981). The situation in the brown alga Ectocarpus siliculosus is similar (Miiller, 1967). Nevertheless, more detailed information is required on the cytology and cytochemistry of oogenesis in the algae before the hypothesis can be effectively assessed. Surprisingly, in the homosporous archegoniates, parthenogenesis, although reported, has not been conclusively established. In the instance of Ampelopteris prolijer, in which parthenogenesis was claimed following treatment of cultures with IAA (Mehra and Sulklyan, 1976), it was not clearly demonstrated that the sporophyte originated from an egg cell. The old account of Athyriumfilix-femina var. clarissima Bolton clearly needs checking if the variety can be rediscovered. Despite many attempts, von Wettstein (1924) was unable to stimulate partially extracted unfertilized egg cells of either the haploid or diploid races of the moss Funaria hygrometrica into growth of any kind, although adjacent cells regenerated protonema. La1 ( 1 984) reports parthenogenesis in cultures of Physcomitrium. Although these results are impressive, the growth of the moss in vitro was markedly slower than in nature, and fertilization did not occur when the cultures were flooded. It is conceivable that oogenesis in the cultures was imperfect, and the cell which gave rise to the sporogonium not comparable with a normal egg. The reluctance of the unfertilized egg cell in both bryophytes and pteridophytes to develop further may be a consequence of the dispersed state of its chromatin. The compact chromatin of the male nucleus possibly provides a template facilitating the reassembly of the chromosomes and the entry of the zygotic nucleus into mitosis. Natural apogamous cycles. The apogamous cycles of many ferns can be reconciled with the notion of cytoplasmic enrichment, possibly coupled in some instances with the additional influence of a hybrid nucleus. The omission of cell division accompanying the formation of the restitution nucleus, events which seem to depend on a failure of tubulin synthesis at this time, results in the mother cell entering meiosis with a substantially greater,amount of cytoplasm than the corresponding cell in a sexual relative. The richer endowment of cytoplasm is subsequently reflected in the larger spores. The conditions for a shift towards effective sporophytic activation are therefore set, but not completely. A brief gametophytic phase is still necessary. The cytoplasm of gametophytes is envisaged as becoming more elaborate in successive cell generations. Normally this leads to archegonial initials, but in the apogamous ferns to the sporophytic outgrowth. Many, but possibly not all (Gastony, 1985), apogamous ferns are believed to be of hybrid origin (Manton, 1950). Heterozygosity in the genome may stimulate gene activity, leading, in the presence of the favoured cytoplasm, to a relatively rapid transition to the sporophytic phase. There is a parellel with the apogamy induced in allotetraploid species of Dryopteris (Manton and Walker, 1954) by preventing sexual congress. Here, however, the hybrid nucleus is interacting with
82
PETER R. BELL
cytoplasm derived from a normal spore and the transition takes correspondingly longer.
Induced apogamy and chromosome number. Although clearly defined instances of apogamy (apart from parthenogenesis) are wanting in the algae, the many examples in mosses under cultural conditions suggest that the balance in gene activity in these plants can be readily shifted. Increased richness of the medium is usually an effective factor. In the instance of sporogonia produced directly from protonema, unequal divisions yielding small cells with dense cytoplasm are a conspicuous intermediary feature. In ferns, except for the allotetraploids mentioned above, the transition to sporophytic growth is less readily achieved, but it is promoted in a similar manner. It has long been evident that chromosome number itself does not determine form, but in the lower plants it is not without its effects. In algae, for example, parthenogenesis in Cladophora (Foyn, 1934) appears to follow a doubling of the chromosome number at some stage preceding oogenesis. In the bryophytes and ferns, diploid races tend to apogamy (but not parthenogenesis) more freely than haploid. Particularly responsive species may be allotetraploids (Lazarenko et al., 1961; Manton and Walker, 1954). Pteridium, reluctantly apogamous, appears from electrophoretic studies to be genetically diploid (Wolf et al., 1987), and the gametophyte correspondingly haploid. The absence of any clear boundary separating the gametophyte and sporophyte in both natural and induced apogamy indicates the lack of antagonism between the contiguous tissues. This contrasts sharply with the situation in sexual reproduction. The continuity of the cells is an indication of the nearsporophytic condition of the gametophytic cells at the site of the transition. C. FROM SPOROPHYTE TO GAMETOPHYTE
1. Sporogenesis and Microsporogenesis: the Irrelevance of Meiosis The congruence of meiosis and change of phase in the natural cycle immediately suggests a causal relationship. The extensive changes often observed in the cytoplasm at this time have been interpreted as indicating a “clean up” of the cytoplasm (Dickinson and Heslop Harrison, 1977), providing a tabula rasa upon which the transcription and translation relating to the gametophytic phase can proceed uncontaminated by information persisting from the parent sporophyte. Two arguments can be advanced against this interpretation. First, although the events in Lilium (upon which the views of Dickinson and Heslop Harrison are largely based) are indeed spectacular, they are not universal. Change of phase may occur without any significant loss of ribosomes. Second, the notion that the effective expression of the gametophytic genes calls for a new set of ribosomes is difficult to sustain. Although ribosomes
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
83
vary in composition, there is no evidence that a particular composition is associated with a particular kind of growth. The ribosome appears to be purely a functional unit. A more plausible interpretation of the events in Lilium is that they are related to the needs of the meiotic nucleus. The thickened boundary of the mother cell probably prevents the ingress of all but simple nutrients (Heslop Harrison and Mackenzie, 1967), but meiosis, following on the previous mitosis and of short duration, calls for a rapid synthesis of DNA and (for the synaptonemal complexes) of RNA. The essentials are provided by the depolymerization of nucleic acids in the cytoplasm. A parellel is provided by the depolymerization of chloroplast and cytoplasmic ribosomes during spermatogenesis induced by nitrogen starvation in Chlamydomonas. The nucleotides so mobilized are utilized in the replication of the chromosomal DNA preceding the mitosis yielding the gametes (Siersma and Chiang, 1971). In the meiotic system it is possible that ribonucleotides also play a role in promoting the pairing of the homologous chromosomes. Mehra and Kumari (1986), for example, present remarkable pictures of pseudo-meioses in root tips of Ptrrotheca,falconeri in the presence of a range of ribonucleotides. Since there are only three pairs of chromosomes in the species, and the karyotype is readily recognizable, there is no doubt that in many instances tetrads of four haploid nuclei were produced in the meristematic region in response to the treatment. In species in which no significant ribosome depolymerization occurs during meiotic prophase, the needs of the nucleus are presumably met by anabolism of the simple nutrients able to enter the mother cell. This is likely to be relatively protracted and lead to a lengthy prophase.
2. The Significance of Apospory in the Lower Plants That meiosis is not essential for change of phase is unequivocally demonstrated by aposporous regeneration in lower plants. Indeed, in Oedogonium apospory is clearly an alternative to meiosis in the same cell, leading in either instance to gametophytic growth. Although aposporous regenerates may show gigas characters, they are unambiguously gametophytic in form and reproductive behaviour. The gametes are normal and functional, but the development of the embryo, particularly in ferns, may be retarded and irregular. Until other evidence becomes available, it can be tentatively assumed that, as in the fern Pteridium, there are no cytological phenomena in aposporously regenerating cells resembling those seen in meiotic prophase in the same plant. The essential conditions for apospory in the bryophytes and ferns (the algae and fern allies have not yet been adequately studied) can be tentatively identified as the isolation of a portion of the sporophyte, by excision o r otherwise, from the correlating influences of the whole plant and its subjection to nutritional stress (Sheffield and Bell, 1987). Experiments with the fern
84
PETER R. BELL
Todea show that even zygotes develop in a prothalloid manner when isolated and subjected to these conditions (DeMaggio, 1963). The reluctance of successively more mature tissues to yield gametophytic regenerates must indicate some kind of stability acquired as the sporophyte becomes established and possibly implanted in the proteins of its cells. This would make it increasingly difficult to shift the balance of gene activity towards the gametophytic by experimental means.
3. A UniJiedTheory of Sporogenesis The inadequacy of hypotheses associated with meiosis to account for the alternation in the form of growth characteristic of sporogenesis promotes the search for other features of sporangia likely to be significant. In land plants, sporangia tend to be isolated organs, terminating the tips of slender axes or filamentous stalks. In the sporangium the spore mother cells are surrounded by thickened walls of restricted permeability (to judge from the micrographs, also a feature of sporogenesis in the alga Dasya). The boundary of the tapetum is often thickened and in some instances reinforced by an acetolysisresistant membrane. These features can all be reasonably regarded as effecting the isolation of the sporogenous cells from the correlating influences of the parent plant, and also a restriction of their nutrition to simple molecules. They provide a striking parallel to those that bring about aposporous development in experimental conditions. Both sporogenesis and aposporous systems can be envisaged as generating a form of cytoplasmic impoverishment. This is the precise converse, for example, of the situation in the archegonium, and the balance in gene activation is correspondingly reversed towards the gametophytic. The metabolic stress imposed in the sporangium may need to be particularly severe, since the cells concerned are derived from mature tissue. The evidence from lower land plants generally supports the interpretation of sporogenesis advanced here. Microsporogenesis is so similar in all its essentials that it seems highly likely that the same arguments apply. Unfortunately knowledge of sporogenesis in the algae is too limited to allow a reasoned assessment. The shift in gene activation having been achieved, and the immature spores released from the tetrad, transcription can proceed (Franks and Mascarenhas, 1980; Raghaven, 1985). The physical activity at the surface of the nucleus noted earlier is probably related to the establishment of the gametophytic phase. The significance of the “nucleoloids” often present in the cytoplasm is obscure. If RNA is found to be absent, they may be similar to the aggregates of acidic protein occurring in the cytoplasm of fern eggs. 4 . Megasporogenesis The special features of megasporogenesis. Except for Isoetes (and possibly Stylites) and those flowering plants in which all four megaspores enter into
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
85
the formation of the embryo-sac (as in Lilium), megasporogenesis involves the degeneration and lysis of other cells in the sporogenous lineage. Other than in Selaginella, the degeneration is normally restricted to meiotic products. The causes of degeneration are obscure. In Marsilea it has been argued that the degeneration of three spores in each tetrad has a Mendelian basis (Bell. 1979), and there is evidence that this may also hold for flowering plants (Bell, 1979; Correns, 1900). Other explanations call upon gradients within the tetrad and pressure fields within the ovule (see Pennell and Bell (1987a) for discussion). Whatever the causes of degeneration, the surviving megaspore comes to enjoy an environment enriched by the products of lysis. From a causal point of view this is likely to be the most significant feature of megasporogenesis. The causul aspects of megasporogenesis. The lytic products which bathe the maturing megaspore are unlikely to be without effect. In Myosurus, for example, representative of species with monosporic embryo-sacs, the situation of the surviving megaspore strikingly resembles that of the egg cell in a fern (Fig. 5). Taxus presents a similar picture (Pennell and Bell, 1987a). There is no a priori reason why confinement in an enriched environment should not affect the maturing spore and egg cell in exactly the same way. If this interpretation is correct, the predominance of the gametophytic genes, established in the young spore by the conditions of sporogenesis already discussed, will be rapidly reversed as the megaspore matures. Evidence for this view is that in flowering plants, callose, characteristic of the interface of gametophyte and sporophyte, begins to disappear from the wall of the tetrad as the viable megaspore is formed (Rodkiewicz, 1970). The apparent exceptions to this reasoning noted in the preceding section are worthy of further attention. Spore production in Zsoetes resembles that in Platyzoma, differences in spore size being related to differences in the number of spore mother cells. It is therefore conceivable that extended culture of megagametophytes of Zsoetes (in this instance heterotrophic) might, in the absence of fertilization, lead to the production of antheridia. This would indicate that the tendency towards oogenesis and the initiation of sporophytic development were not firmly established. In Lilium, according to Rodkiewicz (1970), the wall of the megaspore mother cell lacks callose at any stage. During meiosis the cytoplasm accumulates paracrystalline arrays of protein (Dickinson and Potter, 1978), possibly utilized in the organization of the tetrasporic embryo-sac. The cytology suggests that after an initial isolation the boundary becomes sufficiently permeable to permit the inflow of nutrients. Active syntheses would then provide an environment within the developing sac tipping the balance of gene activation once again in the direction of the sporophytic. Despite the cytological and cytochemical parallels between the maturation of the egg cells of homosporous archegoniates and the surviving megaspores
86
PETER R. BELL
\
Fig. 5. Diagrlim to show the physiological similarity between the situations of (left) the maturing egg cell of a fern (e.g. P/rridiuni) and (right) the maturing megaspore of a flowering plant (e.g. M w \ uru.s),
of heterosporous plants, the nucleus of the mature megaspore (unlike that of the egg cell of a homosporous plant) remains capable of division. The comparative readiness with which parthenogenesis can be induced in heterosporous ferns and flowering plants, and sporophytic outgrowths obtained from megagametophytes of gymnosperms, indicates that the lineage derived from the megaspore retains its incipient sporophytic state. The haploid conifer Thuja gigantea var. gracilis (Pohlheim, 1968) also presumably arose parthenogenetically, or directly from the megagametophyte. Further evidence in support of the view that the megagametophyte is already becoming sporophytic is the simplicity of the archegonium in the heterosporous archegoniates. Less nucleus+ytoplasm interaction would be required to complete the activation of the sporophytic genes in the gamete. The sporophytic condition imposed during megasporogenesis appears to be particularly stable. Fragments of sporophytes, single cells and protoplasts, if they regenerate at all, yield sporophytic tissue, either directly or by way of callus. There are no reports of regeneration yielding pollen tubes or embryosacs. Apospory in flowering plants bears little resemblance to that in homosporous archegoniates. Aposporous embryo-sacs contain egg cells which invariably develop parthenogenetically, in sharp contrast to the equivalent situation in mosses and ferns. If Cortaderia jubata (Philipson, 1978, and personal communication) is representative, the boundaries of aposporous em-
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
87
bryo-sacs bear no callose. It seems likely that, although resembling normal embryo-sacs, they are effectively sporophytic, lacking any interaction leading to a callosed interface with the nucellar tissue in which they arise, and from which the embryo freely draws its nutrition.
VI. GENERAL CONCLUSION As interpreted in the foregoing, the two reproductive phases in the life cycle of the photoautotrophs depend upon an alternating enrichment (oogenesis) and subsequent deprivation (sporogenesis) of the cytoplasm. This in turn alters the balance of the expression of the relevant genes, and the form of growth and reproduction is determined accordingly. The essentials of the cycle are seen most clearly in the Pteridophyta, and the sites of change of gametophyte to sporophyte and sporophyte to gametophyte are readilyh identifiable and separated by independent somatic development. In experimental conditions the balance in gene activity can be more readily tipped towards the gametophytic than the sporophytic. Nevertheless, the combined effects of gene dosage and hybridity increase the readiness with which the balance can be tipped from the gametophytic to the sporophytic, as evidenced by the polyhaploid gametophytes of allopolyploid species of Dryopteris and Pteris. Gene expression can be made altogether more labile by mutations, as evidenced by horticultural varieties of ferns such as those of Athyrium and Phyllitis (Andersson-Kotto, 1938). Apogamous cycles in ferns can be satisfactorily related to the general hypothesis. Indications from the algae (the relevant information is still fragmentary) are that the principles identified in the homosporous land plants will also apply here. The bryophytes also conform, but the balance in gene activity in mosses can be more readily tipped in either direction by experimental means than in any other homosporous land plants. Heterospory and megasporogenesis do, however, introduce a new situation. The gametophytic phase on the female side is contracted both morphologically and physiologically. Enrichment takes place in the maturation of the megaspore, and the balance of gene activity begins to tip in the direction of the sporophytic state before oogenesis. In addition, gametophytic gene activity in flowering plants appears to be particularly vulnerable, as evidenced by the comparative ease with which embryogenesis can be induced in pollen grains and unpollinated ovules. Tapetal activity, prominent in vascular plants (in the seed plants particularly on the male side), is probably not significant in relation to change of phase. Spores of ferns and fern allies (Pettitt, 1979a), and microspores of conifers (e.g. Taxus (Pennell and Bell, 1986)) and flowering plants (e.g. Lilium (Dickinson, 1970b)) are enveloped in a coat of their own making before becoming exposed to the tapetum. The coat may act as a molecular sieve and
88
PETER R. BELL
exclude informational molecules. Moreover, the tapetum is itself an isolated tissue (particularly where there is a peritapetal membrane), and its products may also be gametophytic. This would account, for example, for the ability of tryphine, the pollen coating of tapetal origin, to evoke the incompatibility response at the stigma surface in a plant such as Raphanus (Dickinson and Lewis, 1973). The “reaction body” formed in the wall of the stigmatic papilla at the point of contact is similar in form and composition to the thickened boundary which develops between gametophyte and sporophyte in archegoniate plants, and which in gymnosperms has been related to precipitation reactions between extracts of these tissues (Pettitt, 1979b). The principal significance of the tapetum probably lies in the production of sporopollenin, augmenting that produced by the spores themselves, and in the release by lysis of simple nutrients supporting their development. The current ability to locate particular molecules in cells at high resolution by means of immunogold cytochemistry will make it possible to detect the instant at which proteins characteristic of the incoming phase appear, or become augmented, at the sites of change. Alternation is not explained by discoveries of this kind, since its roots lie in the general development which leads to reproductive maturity. Nevertheless, the information does help to identify those aspects of development which are specifically concerned with change of phase, and hypotheses based upon these observations can to some extent be checked by experiment. The problem of alternation will probably be solved by concentration on species in which the phases are clearly defined, and other aspects of development are as uncomplicated as possible. The lower land plants and some algae meet these criteria, and await investigation by the powerful techniques now available.
ACKOWLEDGEMENT The author acknowledges with much appreciation profitable discussions of various aspects of this paper with colleagues in many places.
REFERENCES Adair, W. S. (1985). J. Cell Sci. Suppl. 2,233-260. Aldrich, H. C. and Vasil, I. K. (1970). J . Ulstrastruct. Res. 32, 307-315. Anderson, E., Ekberg, I. and Eriksson, G. (1969). Stud. Forest. Suecica Nr. 70, 1-19. Anderson-Kotto, I. (1938). In “Manual of Pteridology” (Fr. Verdoorn, ed.), pp. 284-302. Nijhoff, The Hague. Bajon-Barbier,C. (1977). Biol. CeN 29,67-76. Barbier, C . (1972). C . R. Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci. (Paris) SPr. D 274,3222-3225. Bauer, L. (1959). Nuturwissenschaften46, 154. Bauer, L. (1969). J . Linn. SOC.(Bot.)58, 343-351. Bauer, L. (1966). Z . Pflunzenphysiol. 54,241-253.
T H E ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
89
Bauer, L. (1967). In “Handbuch der Pflanzenphysiologie” (W. Ruhland, ed.), Vol. 18, pp. 235-256. Springer, Berlin. Bell, E. ( I 969). Nature (Lond.)224,326328. Bell, P. R. (1961). Nature (Lond.) 191,91-92. Bell, P. R. (1963). J . Linn. Soc. (Bot.)58, 353-359. Bell, P. R. (1969). Z. Zellforsch. 96,4942. Bell, P. R. (1974). J . CellSci. 14,69-83. Bell, P. R. (1975). In “Form, Structure and Function in Plants” (H. Y. Mohan Ram, J. J. Shah and C. K. Shah, eds). pp. 30-34. Meerut, India. Bell, P. R. (1979). In “The Experimental Biology of Ferns” (A. F. Dyer, ed.), pp. 6786. Academic Press, London. Bell. P. R. (1980). Ann. Bot. 45,475431. Bell, P. R. (1981).J. CellSci.51, 109-119. Bell, P. R. (1983a). J . CellSci. 60,109-1 16. Bell, P. R. (198313). Eur. J. Cell Biol. 30,279-282. Bell. P. R. (1985). Proc. R. Soc. Lond. 223B. 485-494. Bell, P. R. (1986). Ann. Bot. 57, 613-621. Bell, P. R. and Duckett, J. G. (1976). Bot. J. Linn. Soc. 73,47-78. Bell, P. R. and Pennell, R. I. (1987). J . Cell Sci. 87, 283-290. Berrie, G. K. (1960). Trans Bt. Bryul. Soc. 3,688-705. Bhardwaja, T. N . and Abdullah, S. (1972). Nova Hedwigia 21, 521-528. Braithwaite, A. F. (1964). New Phytol. 63,293-305. Briten, T . (1971). J . Cell Sci.9,621-635. Brawley, S. H., Wetherbee, R. and Quatrano, R. S. (1976a). J . Cell Sci. 20,233-254. Brawley, S. H., Wetherbee, R. and Quatrano, R. S. (1976b). J. Cell Sci. 20,255-271. Broadwater, S. T. and Scott, J. (1982). J. Phycol. 1 8 , 4 2 7 4 1 . Broadwater, S., Scott, J. and Pobiner (1986). J . Phycol. 22,49&500. Brown, R.C. and Lemmon, B. E. (1980). Bryologist 83, 137-152. Bryan, G. S. and Evans, R. I. ( 1 956). Am. J. Bot. 43,64&646. Burgeff, H. (1937). Zeit. indukt. Abstamm.-und Vereb.-L. 73,394403. Camefort, H.. (1966). C. R. Hebd. Siances Acad. Sci (Paris) Sir. D 263, 1443-1446. Camefort, H. (1969). Rev. Cytol. Biol. Vig. 32,253-271. Cave. C. F. and Bell, P. R. (1974a). Cyrobiologie 9, 331-343. Cave. C. F. and Bell, P. R.(l974b). Ann. Bor. 38, 17-21. Correns, C. (1900). Berl. Dtsch. Bor. Ges. 18,422435. Crabbendam, K. J., Klis, F. M., Musgrave, A. and Van der Ende, H. (1986). J. Ultrastr. Res. 96, 151-159. DeMaggio, A. E. (1963). J. Linn. Soc. (Bot.)53, 361-376. Dickinson, H. G. (1970a). New Phytol. 69, 1065-1068. Dickinson, H. G. (1970b). Cytobiofogie 1 , 4 3 7 4 9 . Dickinson, H. G. (1971). Grana 11, 117-127. Dickinson, H. G. (1981). Acta SOC.Bat. Pol. 50, 3-12. Dickinson, H. G. (1987). Ann. Bot. 60 (Suppl. 4), 61-73. Dickinson, H. G. and Bell, P. R. (1970). J. Ultrastr. Res. 33, 356359. Dickinson, H. G. and Heslop Harrison, J. (1970). Cytobios 6, 103-118. Dickinson, H. G. and Heslop Harrison, J. (1977). Philos. Trans. R . SOC.Lond. B 277, 327-342. Dickinson, H. G. and Lewis, D. (1973). Proc. R. SOC.Lond. B 183,21-38. Dickinson, H . G. and Potter, U. (1975). Planta 122,99-104. Dickinson, H. G. and Potter, U. (1978). J. CeIlSci. 29, 147-169. Diers, L. (1965). Z. Naturfursch. 20B, 795-801. Dopp, W. (1939). PIanta 29,481-533.
90
PETER R. BELL
Dopp, W. (1967). In ‘Handbuch der Pflanzenphysiologie” (W. Ruhland, ed.), Vol. 18, pp. 531-550. Springer, Berlin. Doyle, J. (1 953). Ann. Bot. 17,465-476. Duckett, J. G., Carothers, Z. B. and Miller, C. C. J. (1983). In “New Manual of Bryology” (R. M. Schuster, ed.), Vol. I , pp. 232-275. Hatton Bot. Lab., Miyazaki. Ehrensberger, R. (1948). Biol. Zbl. 67,537-546. Elmore, H. W. and Whittier, D. P. (1975). Can. J. Bot. 53,375-381. Ettl, H., Muller, D. G., Neumann, K., von Stosch, H. A. and Weber, W. (1967). In “Handbuch der Pflanzenphysiologie” (W. Ruhland, ed.), Vol. 18, pp. 597-777. Springer, Berlin. Evans, L. V., Callow, J. A. and Callow, M. E. (1982). Prog. Phycol. Res. 1, 67-1 10. Eyme, J. and Suire, C. (1971). Le Botaniste54, 109-151. Farmer, J. B. and Digby, L. (1907). Ann. Bot. 21, 161-199. Fay, P. (1983). “The Blue-Greens”. Studies in Biology No. 160. Arnold, London. Forest, C. L. (1987). J. CellSci. 88,613-621. Fowke, L. C. and Pickett-Heaps, J. D. (1969). J. Phycol. 5,273-281. Foyn, B. R. (1934). Arch. Protistenk. 83, 1-56. Franks, R. and Mascarenhas, J. P. (1980). Ann. Bot. 45,595-599. Freeberg, J. A. (1957). Phytomorphology 7 , 2 17-229. Gabarajeva, N. I. (1984). Bot. Zh. 69, 1612-1622. Gastony, G. I. (1985). Am. J . Bot. 72,917-918. Goebel, K. (1907). Sitzber. Kgl. Buyer. Akad. Wiss. Math.-Phys. K I . 37, 119-136. Gottesman, S. (1984). Annu. Rev. Genet. 18,415-441. Graham, L. E. (1985). Am. Scientist73, 178-186. Graham, L. E. and Taylor, C., I11 (1986). Am. J. Bot. 73,597-601. Grimsley, N. H., Ashton, N. W. and Cove, D. J. (1977). MGG 15497-100. Hagberg, A. and Hagberg, G. (1980). Hereditas 93,341-343. Heilbronn, A. (1932). Ber. Dtsch. Bot. Ges. 50,289-300. Herd, Y . R., Cutter, E. G. and Watanabe, I. (1985). Proc. R . SOC.Edin. 86B, 53-54. Heslop Harrison, J. (1969). Can. J. Bot. 47, 541-542. Heslop Harrison, J. and Mackenzie, A. (1967). J. Cell Sci. 2, 387400. Hirsch, A. M. (1975). PI. Physiol. 56, 390-393. Hoffman, L. R. (1971). In “Contributions in Phycology” (B. C. Parker and R. Malcolm Brown, Jr., eds), pp. 93-106. Allen Press, Lawrence, Kansas. Hoffman, L. R. (1973). J. Phycol. 9,62-84. Hofmeister, W. (1 85 1). “Vergleichende Untersuchungen der Keimung, Entfaltung und Fruchtbildung hoherer Kryptogamen.” Hofmeister, Leipzig. Hopkins, A. W. and McBride, G. E. (1976). J . Phycol. 12,29-35. Horner, H. T., Jr. and Beltz, C. K. (1970). Protoplasma 71, 335-341. Horner, H. T., Jr., Lersten, N. R. and Bowen, C. C. (1966). Am. J. Bot. 53, 10481064. Hushovd, 0.T., Gulliksen, 0. M. and Nordby, 0.(1982). Planta 156,89-91. Illias, Z. M. (1974). In “Haploids in Higher Plants” (K. J. Kasha, ed.), p. 136. University of Guelph, Guelph, Canada. Izmailow, R. (1986). Acta Biol. Cracov. Ser. Bot. 2 8 , 3 9 4 3 . Jalouzot, M.-F. (1978). Bull. SOC.Bot. France 125, 167-170. Jayasekera, R. D. E. and Bell, P. R. (1972). Plantn 102,206-214. Jensen, K. G. and Hulbary, R. L. (1978). Am. J . Bot. 65,823-833. Kapil, R. N. and Bhatnagar, A. K. (1981). Int. Rev. Cytol. 70,291-341. Kasha, K. J. and Sequin-Swartz, G. (1983). In “Cytogenetics of Crop Plants” (M. S. Swaminathan, P. K. Gupta and U. Sinha, eds), pp. 1 9 4 8 . Macmillan, Delhi. Kaur, D. and Bhatnagar, S. P. (1984). Phytomorphology 3 4 , 5 6 6 0 .
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
91
Kelley, B. C. and Doyle, W. T. (1975). Am. J. Bot. 62, 547-559. Kermicle, J. L. (1969). Science 166, 1422-1424. Knox, R. B. and Heslop Harrison, J. (1963). Bot. Not. (Lund) 116, 127-141. Konar, R. N. and Moitra, A. (1980). Gamete Res. 3,67-97. Konar, R. N. and Singh, M. N. (1979). Z. Pjanzenphysiol. 95,87-90. Kwa, S . H., Wee, Y. C. and Loh, C. S. (1988). Plant Cell Rep. 7, 142-143. Laccadena, J.-R. (1974). In “Haploids in Higher Plants” (K. J. Kasha, ed.), pp. 1332. University of Guelph, Guelph, Canada. Laird, S. (1 986). “Apogamy in the fern Pteris creticu.” M.Sc. Dissertation, University of Manchester. Lal, M. (1961). In “Plant Tissue and Organ Culture-A Symposium” (P. Mahshwari and N. S. Ranga Swamy, eds), pp. 363-381. International Society of Plant Morphologists, Delhi. Lal, M. (1984). In “The Experimental Biology of Bryophytes” (A. F. Dyer and J. G. Duckett, eds), pp. 97-1 15. Academic Press, London. Lal, M. and Bell, P. R. (1975). Bio/. J. Linn. Sor. 7 (Suppl. I), 85-95. La], M . and Bell, P. R. ( 1977). Ann. Bot. 41, 127-1 3 I . Lang, W. H. (1901). Ann. Bot. 20,503-510. Lang, W. H. (1924). Mem. Proc. Lit. Phil. Soc. Munchester 68,53-67. Lang, W. H. (1929). Ann. Bot. 43,355-374. La Rue, C. D. (1954). Brook. Symp. Biol. 6, 187-208. Lawton, E. (1932). Am. J. Bot. 19,303-333. Lazarenko, A. S., Pashuk, C. T. and Lesnyak, E. N. (1961). Dop. Akad. Nauk. Ukr. SRS 10, 1381-1384. Lazaroff, N. and Vishniac, W. (1961). J. Gen. Microbiol. 25,365-374. Li. F. L. and Dickinson, H. G. (1987). Ann. Bor. 60,321-330. Looby. W. J. and Doyle, J. (1942). Sci. Proc. R . Dub. Soc. 23,35-54. Mahlberg, P. C. and Baldwin, M. (1975). Bot. Gaz. 136,269-273. Mainx, F. (1931). Z. Bot. 24,481-527. Manton, I. (1950). “Problems of Cytology and Evolution in the Pteridophyta.” University Press, Cambridge. Manton, I. and Walker, S. (1954). Ann. Bot. 18,377-383. Marsden, C. R. (1976). J. Adelaide Bot. Curd. 1, 37-54. Martin, N. C. and Goodenough, U. W. (1975). J . Cell Biol. 67,587-605. McConchie, C. A., Jobson, S. and Knox, R. B. (1985). Protoplusma 127,5743. Mehra, P. N. and Kumari, L. (1986). Cytologiu 51,457-466. Mehra, P. N. and Sulklyan, D. S. (1976). Phytomorphology 26,404-410. Menon, M. K. C. and Bell, P. R. (1981). Plantu 151,427-433. Menon, M. K. C. and Lal, M. (1972). Nnturwissenschuften 59,514. Mogensen, H. L. and Wagner, V. T. (1987). Protoplasma 138, 161-172. Moitra, A. and Bhatnagar, S. P. (1982). Gamete Res. 5,71-112. Morel, G . (1963). J. Linn. Soc. (Bot.)58, 381-383. Miiller, D. G. (1967). Pluntu 75,39-54. Myles, D. G. (1 978). J. Cell Sci. 30,265-28 I . Myles, D. G. and Bell, P. R. (1975). J . Cell Sci. 17, 633-645. Myles, D. G. and Hepler, P. K. (1977). J . Cell Sci. 23, 57-83. Myles, D. G. and Hepler, P. K. (1982). Dev. Biol. 90,238-252. Nakamura, S . , Itoh, S. and Kuroiwa, T. (1986). Plant Cell Physiol. 27,755-784. Norstog, K. (1968). Phytomorphology 18,35&356. Norstog, K. (1974). Am. J . Bot. 61,449456. Norstog, K. and Rhamstine, E. (1967). Phytomorphology 17, 374-381. Nygren, A. (1967). In ‘Handbuch der Pflanzenphysiologie” (W. Ruhland, ed.), Vol. 18, pp. 551-596. Springer, Berlin.
92
PETER R.BELL
Ooya, N. (1974). Bot. Mug. (Tokyo) 87,253-259. Overton, E. (1893). VierteQuhrschr. Naturhist. Ges. Zurich 38,169-186. Overton, J. B. (1913). Science37,841-844. Owens, J. N. and Molder, M. (1971). Can. J. Bot. 49,2061-2064. Palta, H. K. and Mehra, P. N. (1983). Caryologiu 36,325-332. Paolillo, D. J., Jr. (1969). Cytologia34, 133-144. Peel, M. C. and Duckett, J. G. (1975). Biol. J. Linn. SOC.7(Suppl. l), 1-13. Pennell, R. I. and Bell, P. R. (1986). Ann. Bot. 57, 545-555. Pennell, R. I. and Bell, P. R. (l987a). Ann. Bot. 59,693-704. Pennell, R. I. and Bell, P. R. (1987b). Am. J . Bot. 74,444450. Pennell, R. I. and Bell, P. R. (1988). J. CellSci. 89, 551-559. Pennell, R. I., Vondy, K. P., Bell, P. R. and Hyams, J. S. (1988). Eur. J. Cell Biol. 46, 51-60. Pettitt, J. M. (1969). Bor. J. Linn. SOC.62,233-239. Pettitt, J. M. (1976). J. CellSci. 20,671685. Pettitt, J. M. (1977). Ann. Bot. 41, 117-125. Pettitt, J. M. (1978). Grana 17,99-105. Pettitt, J. M. (1979a). In “The Experimental Biology of Ferns” (A. F. Dyer, ed.), pp. 213-252. Academic Press, London. Pettitt, J. M. (1979b). Ann. Bor. 44,369-371. Philipson, M. (1978). N. Z. J. Bot. 16,45-59. Pickett-Heaps, J. D. (1968). Aust. J. Biol. Sci. 21, 255-274. Pickett-Heaps, J. D. (1975). “Green Algae.” Sinauer Associates, Sunderland, Mass. Pickmere, S. E., Parson, M. J. and Bailey, R. W. (1973). Phytochemistry 12, 24412444. Pohlheim, F. (1968). Biol. Rundschuu 6 , 8 6 8 6 . Porter, E. K., Parry, D., Bird, J. and Dickinson, H. G. (1984). In “Controlling Events in Meiosis” (C. Evans and H. G. Dickinson, eds), S. E. B. Symposium 38, pp. 363-379. Company of Biologists, Cambridge. Pringsheim, N. (1876). Mber. Konig. Preuss. Akad. Wiss. Berlin, 425429. Raghavan, V. (1985). Proc. R. SOC.Edin. 86B, 5-1 1. Ramsay, H. P. (1983). In “New Manual of Bryology” (R. M. Schuster, ed.), Vol. 1, pp. 149-221. Hattori Bot. Lab., Miyazaki. Rejon, E., Bajon, C., Blaize, A. and Robert, D. (1988). Mol. Rep. Dev. 1,49-56. Retallack, B. and Butler, R. D. (1973). Arch. Microbiol. 90,343-364. Rietema, H. (1975). “Comparative investigations on the life-histories and reproduction of some species in the siphoneous green algal genera Bryopsis and Derbesia.” Rijksuniversiteit Groningen, Netherlands. Ripetsky, R. T. (1980). Ukr. Bot. Zh. 36,30-32 Ripetsky, R. T. (1983). Ukr. Bot. Zh. 40,43-50. Robert, D. (1972). Rev. Cytol. Biol. Vgg. 35, 165-242. Rodkiewicz, B. (1970). Pfunta 93,3947. Rodkiewicz, B. and Bednara, J. (1976). Phytomorphology 26,27&28 1. Russell, S. D. (1985). Proc. nutl. Acad. Sci. USA 82,6129-6134. Sager, R. (1972). “Cytoplasmic Genes and Organelles.” Academic Press, New York. Samson, M. R., Klis, F. M., Homan, W. L., van Egmond, P., Musgrave, A. and van den Ende, H. (1987). Planta 170,314-321. Sangwan, R. S. (1986). Eur. J. Cell. Biol.40,210-218. Sari-Gorla, M., Frova, C., Binelli, G. and Ottaviano, E. (1986). Theor. Appl. Genet. 72,4247. Schedlbauer, M. D., Cave, C. F. and Bell, P. R. (1973). J . CellSci. 12,765-779. Schraudolf, H. (1984). Beitr. Biol. Pflanzen 59,237-260. Schulz, P. and Jensen, W. A. (1981). Protoplasma 107,2745.
THE ALTERNATION OF GENERATIONS
93
Shaw, W. R. (1897).Bot. Gaz. 24, 114-1 17. Sheffield, E. (1985). Proc. R. SOC.Edin. 86B, 45-50. Sheffield, E. and Bell, P. R. (1981). Ann. Bot. 47, 187-195. Sheffield, E. and Bell, P. R. (1987). Bot. Rev. 53,442490. Sheffield, E., Cawood, A. H., Bell, P. R. and Dickinson, H. G. (1979). Planta 146, 597-601. Sheffield, E., Laird, S. and Bell, P. R. (1983).J. Cell Sci. 63, 125-134. Siersma, P. W. and Chiang, K. G. (1 97 I). J . Mol. Biol. 58,47-185. Sigee, D. C. (1972).Exp. Cell Res. 75, 323-334. Sigee, D. C. and Bell, P. R. (1971).J. Cell Sci. 8,467487. Sparrow, A. H., Pond, V. and Kojan, S. (1955).Am. J . Bot. 42,384-394. Stahl, E. ( 1 876). Bor. Z. 34,688-695. Steil, W. N . (1949).Am. Fern J. 39, 19-22. Stewart, K. D. and Gifford, E. M., Jr. (1967).Am. J . Bot. 54,375-383. Strasburger, E . (1894).Ann. Bot. 8,281-316. Tanksley, S. D., Zamir, D. and Rick, C. M. (1981). Science213,453455. Tanner, C. E. (1981). In “The Biology o f Seaweeds” (C. S. Lobban and M. J. Wynne, eds), pp. 21 8-247. Blackwell, Oxford. Tourte, Y. (1970). Rev. Cytol. Biol. V i g . 33, 3 1 1-324. Tourte, Y . , Kuligowski-Andres, J. and Sossountzov, L. (1971).Ann. Univ. A R E R S B , 5-11. Tryon, A. F. (1964).Am. J . Bot. 51,939-942. Tulecke, W. (1967). Phytomorphology 17,381-386. Turner, F. R. (1968).J. Cell Biol. 37, 370-393. Turner, F . R. (1970).J. Cell Biol. 46,220-234. Von Aderkas, P. (1986).Ann. Bot. 57,505-10. Von Chamisso, A. (1975). In “Samtliche Werke” (J. Perfahl, ed.), Vol. 2, Winkler, M iinchen. Von Wettstein, F. (1924).Zeit. Indukt. Abstamm.-und Vererb.-L. 33, 1-236. Waaland, S. D. (1978). Planta 138,65-68. Wagner, V . T. and Mogensen, H. L. (1988). Protoplasma 143, 101-1 10. Walker, T. G. (1985). Proc. R. SOC.Edin. 86B,59-66. Warmke, H. E. (1954).Am. J . Bot. 41,s-1 I . Whittier, D. P. (1966a).Am. FernJ. 56,6144. Whittier, D. P. (1966b). Phytomorphology 20, 30-35. Whittier, D. P. ( 1 9 6 6 ~ )Can. . J. Bot.44, 1717-1721. Whittier, D. P. (1970).Phytomorphology 20, 30-35. Whittier, D. P. and Steeves, T. A. (1960). Can. J. Bot. 38,925-930. Willing, R. P. and Mascarenhas, J. P. (1984). PI. Physiol. 75,865-869. Willing, R. P., Bashe, D. and Mascarenhas, J. P. (1988). Theor. Appl. Genet. 75,751753. Winton, L. L. and Stettler, R. F. (1974).In “Haploids in Higher Plants” (K. J. Kasha, ed.), pp. 259-273. University of Guelph, Guelph, Canada. Wolf, P. G., Haufler, C. H. and Sheffield, E. (1 987). Science 236,947-949. Woodcock, C. L. F. and Bell, P. R. (1968a).Histochemie 12,289-301. Woodcock, C. L. F. and Bell, P. R. (1968b). J. Ulstrastr. Res. 22,546-563. You, R. and Jensen, W. A. (1985). Can. J. Bot. 63, 163-178. Zhou, C. and Yang, H.-Y. (1981). Plant Sci.Lett. 20,231-237. Zinsmeister, D. D. and Carothers, Z. B. (1974). Am. J. Bot. 61,499-512.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
The Formation and Interpretation of Plant Fossil Assemblages
ROBERT A . SPICER
Department of Earth Sciences. Oxford University. Parks Road. Oxford OX1 3PR. UK
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 A . The Quality of the Plant Fossil Record . . . . . . . . . . 98 B. Vegetational Heterogeneity . . . . . . . . . . . . . 100 I1 . Plant Remains as Sedimentary Particles . . . . . . . . . . . 101 A . Allochthonous and Autochthonous Assemblages . . . . . 101 B. Settling Velocity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 103 111. AerialDispersalandTransport ofplant Organs . . . . . . . 104 A . Leaf Abscission . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 104 B. Organ Dispersal by Wind . . . . . . . . . . . . . 106 IV. Litter Degradation on the Forest Floor . . . . V. Aquatic Processing of Plant Debris . . . . . A Initial Processes-Floating . . . . . . B. Transport in the Water Column . . . . . C . Leaf Degradation . . . . . . . . . VI . Fluvial Transport . . . . . . . . . . . A . Channel Deposits . . . . . . . . . VII . Lacustrine Environments . . . . . . . . . A . Fluvio-lacustrine Deltas . . . . . . . VIII . Fluvio-marine Deltas and Estuaries . . . . . A . Pro-delta Slope . . . . . . . . . . B. Distributary Mouth Bars . . . . . . . C . TidalFlats . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Interdistributary Embayments . . . . . E. Beaches . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Lower Delta Plain Marshes . . . . . . G. Upper Delta Plain Marshes . . . . . . H . DeltaicLacustrineand Fluvial Environments I . DetritalPeats . . . . . . . . . . . Advances in Botanical Research Vol . 16 ISBN 0-12-005916-9
. . . . . .
112
. . . . . .
114
. . . . . . . . . . . .
119 122
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
125 126 130 133 140 141 142 143
. . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
115
144 144 145 146 147 147
Copyright 01989 Academic Press Limited All rights of reproduction on any form reserved.
96 IX. X.
XI.
ROBERT A. SPICER
Peat and Coal Assemblages . . . . . . . . . . Vulcanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. The Importance of Explosive Vulcanism to the Plant Case Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. DebrisFlow . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Preservation in Air-fall Tephra . . . . . . . D. Lateral Lakes in Volcanic Terrains . . . . . . E. Post-eruption Vegetation Recovery. . . . . . Preservation and Diagenesis. . . . . . . . . . A. Compression/Impressions . . . . . . . . . B. Duripartic Preservation . . . . . . . . . C. Tissue Mineralization . . . . . . . . . . D. Casts and Moulds . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . Fossil Record:
. . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . .
. . . . XII. Applications of Plant Taphonomy to the Fossil Record. . . . . A. Specimen Morphology and Taxonomy. . . . . . . . .
XIII.
147 151
B. Community Reconstruction . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Reconstructing Community Suites and Regional Vegetation . D. TheUseofPlant FossilsinSedimentology . . . . . . . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
152 160 166 168 172 175 I75 176 176 178 179
180 180 181 183 184
I. INTRODUCTION The study of the history of life on earth involves far more than describing the morphological details of fossils and documenting phylogenies. Every fossil represents evidence that an organism lived, not in isolation, but in the context of a physical setting populated by other organisms. In order to understand the history of life it is essential that the organisms represented by fossils are studied in their proper context; as part of a network of interacting physical and biological agencies that shape the lives of individuals and influence the contribution of those individuals to the processes and patterns of evolution. The environment in which an individual exists is determined not just by contemporaneous conditions, but also by physical and biological circumstances that have preceded it. The palaeontologist must therefore adopt a distinctly four-dimensional view of the world, spanning geological and biological disciplines. Terrestrial life forms of 100 million years before present (mybp) might seem exotic enough, with dinosaurs and coniferous mangroves, but at least we would find some familiarity in small mammals and flowering plants. But further back, in the Carboniferous coal forests of 300 mybp, or the middle Devonian heathlands of 380 mybp, landscapes, and possibly the atmosphere, were more alien. In these environments, plant and animal species, the communities of which they were a part, and the climates in which they existed, were quite unlike those of today. However, these organisms, and the ecosystems which shaped them and in which they lived out their lives, ultimately gave rise to our modern world. In
FORMATION AND INTERPRETATIONOF PLANT FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGES
97
a very real sense, if we wish to understand fully the structure and process of our present environment, and predict accurately the likely consequences of our actions on natural systems, then we have to understand the past. The fossil record provides invaluable data regarding the biotic effects of global climate changes (and in so doing charts those changes), the causes and consequences of wholesale extinctions, and outlines the course of organic evolution. However, the traditional approach of the palaeontologist, in which specimens tended to be investigated in isolation for their morphological or anatomical characteristics, can only provide a partial insight into ancient ecosystems. In recent years a major change in emphasis in palaeontology has been away from the study of individual isolated specimens. Instead a more integrated biological and geological framework is being developed. We are not only seeing the establishment of a more organismal approach, in which the remains are viewed in terms of once-living organisms, but by the analysis of populations of fragmented and less well preserved material in a sedimentological context, we are also gaining the ability to reconstruct, with the minimum of conjecture, whole ancient communities, ecosystems and climates. This approach, which promises to revolutionize our understanding of ancient environments, depends for its success on our ability to interpret correctly how such assemblages were formed and how they represent the source communities. The study of the processes of fossilization is known as tuphonomy. The term was introduced by the Russian palaeontologist Efremov (1940), who considered it as being “the study of the transition (in all its details) of organic remains from the biosphere into the lithosphere”. As such, taphonomy is a subject that encompasses aspects of anatomy, morphology, whole-organism biology, ecology, sedimentology, fluid dynamics, and both biochemistry and geochemistry. Taphonomists seek to identify and, ideally, to quantify, the various sampling biases inherent in transport, deposition and lithification processes that distort the image of ancient life that is discernible from the fossil record. Taphonomy is of fundamental importance in the accurate interpretation of individual fossil specimens or accumulations of remains. These accumulations, or assemblages, are usually not suites of the remains of whole organisms but represent fragmented parts, variously degraded, of a range of different individuals and species that lived at varying distances from their ultimate site of deposition and burial. The taphonomist seeks to understand the processes that gave rise to fossil assemblages and thereby reconstruct ancient communities and environments as accurately as possible. Most biologists accept that evolution has taken place and that within lineages morphologies change with time. Implicit in this acceptance is an appreciation that a changing morphology must often be associated with changing behaviour and tolerance of individual organisms to external conditions. It follows that the structure and composition of communities also’are subject to
98
ROBERT A. SPICER
change. A limit exists, therefore, to the extent to which the present can be used to interpret the past. Biological organisms are not, in large part, timestable, and the principle of uniformitarianism (“the present is the key to the past”) can be applied to biological organisms only with extreme caution. To make palaeobiological interpretations as reliable as possible, and to avoid circularity of argument, taphonomic work, in the first instance, should emphasize the most time-stable assemblage formation processes. Mostly these processes are physical and chemical. Implicit in the broad scope of taphonomy is the requirement for an integrated multidisciplinary approach. The complexity of fossilization processes may be an important reason why taphonomy has only recently emerged as an identifiable and legitimate area of endeavour. Traditional compartmentalization of subject areas and specialization has tended to restrict serious taphonomic investigation, but since the early 1970s taphonomy has contributed greatly to our understanding of ancient life. Ideally plant and animal taphonomy should be reviewed together, because plant-animal interactions are an integral element in shaping ecosystems, the composition of fossil assemblages, and the pattern of evolution. An important aim of palaeobiology is to understand the interdependence of extinct animals and plants, and this can only be done with a strong taphonomic input. Although there are numerous similarities in the way that animals and plants enter the fossil record, there are also sufficient differences to justify their separate treatment. In this overview I will concentrate on advances in plant taphonomy, although similar advances are occurring in animal taphonomy. A. THE QUALITY OF THE PLANT FOSSIL RECORD
An important difference between plants and animals is the way they fragment prior to burial. Unlike the majority of animals, plants are composed of, and produce throughout their lifetime, an indeterminate number of organs that are shed into the environment. These organs have greatly differing potentials for transport, deposition and preservation. For example, huge numbers of extremely durable and easily dispersed spores or pollen may be produced, but floral structures are usually delicate, ephemeral structures, produced in much smaller quantities. Only one trunk is produced by a tree, but leaves are produced in large numbers. Woody trunks may be transported great distances and undergo several cycles of deposition and remobilization prior to final burial, whereas leaves are less easily reworked. The range of reworking potentials exhibited by plant organs introduces another variable known as time-averaging. This phenomenon has long been recognized in animal hard-part fossils such as bones or shells. The durability of these elements means that they may be deposited, exhumed possibly thousands or millions of years later, and redeposited, perhaps alongside the
FORMATION AND INTERPRETATION OF PLANT FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGES
99
remains of recently dead organisms. Thus most assemblages are likely to be time-averaged samples. The delicate nature of many plant organs minimizes the likelihood of time averaging, or at least reduces the averaging effect to a temporal resolution of less than the average life of an individual. However, some plant parts, notably logs and the walls of pollen grains and spores, can be highly resistant to decay and reworking. Assemblages of these organs therefore may contain a significant time-averaged component which degrades community resolution. A detailed understanding of taphonomy and sedimentology is required to minimize the danger of misinterpretations. Whole plants are rarely found in the fossil record and, consequently, palaeobotanical systematics has to handle isolated organs (see Spicer and Thomas (1986) for a number of papers dealing with this topic). Many years may elapse between the first discovery of a particular plant part and the eventual reconstruction of the whole plant. In practice very few whole plants are, or can ever be, reconstructed, and yet it is whole plants that comprise communities. In spite of this problem, plant communities leave ample evidence of their existence and composition in the form of assemblages of isolated organs. In a very real sense, a plant fossil assemblage gives a biased measure of the capacity of the source vegetation to produce litter. Litter production in turn is related to biomass and productivity and as suchis governed by factors such as soil conditions, climate and exposure, community composition, and seasonality (Bray and Goreham, 1964; Bonnevie-Svendsenand Gjems, 1957; Krassilov, 1969; Spicer, 1981). The total amount of litter produced by a stand of vegetation varies from year to year as the community approaches equilibrium with the environment (the climax state), or is disturbed by disease, fire, flooding, grazing etc., or interannual climate fluctuations. A given fossil deposit may be the result of a sudden event such as a flash flood or a volcanic eruption, and therefore it may sample plant debris produced predominantly within a single year. Less catastrophic depositional events reflect the gradual accumulation of material over periods of time sometimes lasting as long as several millions of years. It is therefore extremely difficult to relate directly the quantity of organic material in an assemblage to any similar measure of the source vegetation. Very crude estimates of regional productivity may be made (for example, large coal reserves point to high net accumulation rates of plant debris, and thereby a high ratio of organic productivity in relation to organic degradation or inorganic sediment input), but these estimates are not appropriate for single assemblage analysis. The reasons for this will, I hope, become clear in the course of this chapter. Before proceeding, however, the term “assemblage” will be clarified. A plant fossil assemblage is an accumulation of plant parts, derived from one or several individuals, that is entombed within a volume of sediment that is laid down under essentially the same conditions. This definition allows for
100
ROBERT A. SPICER
the differentiation of assemblages on sedimentological or biological grounds. The best resolution available in the fossil record for community reconstruction is determined by the smallest sedimentological unit that can be recognized that contains a statistically valid sample of the source community. Previously I have proposed that, for quantitative sampling, the concept of the sedimentation unit of Otto (1938) should be employed (Spicer, 1981), and this concept is included in the assemblage definition. In writing this overview of what is a rapidly expanding, yet infant, field of endeavour, I have attempted to present our current state of knowledge and the principles upon which it is based, rather than give an exhaustive review. I have chosen to concentrate on the taphonomy of megafossils (leaves, fruits/ seeds, logs etc.) rather than microfossils (spores/pollen), or molecular fossils (e.g. see Runnegar and Schopf, 1988). I have adopted this approach because a comprehensive introduction to one aspect of plant taphonomy is more likely to be coherent and useful than a superficial treatment of a wider range of topics. B. VEGETATIONAL HETEROGENEITY
Plant species are not uniformly distributed in space or time. In ecological work it is convenient to categorize the heterogeneity within vegetation in terms of communities, and often these blocks of coexisting interacting individuals are labelled in terms of characteristic component taxa. For any given set of more or less constant conditions, sera1 development leads to the establishment of a stable community that is in equilibrium with its environment. The temporary stages involved in the development of this “climax” community usually follow a recognizable sequence or track in which a succession of taxa come and go until the climax state is reached. Ecotonal gradients between adjacent communities in both time and space can also be recognized. This view of plant interaction is one that is useful to the palaeoecologist because resolution of source vegetation at the level of spatial relationships between individuals is difficult to achieve (but techniques and understanding are improving), whereas resolution at the level of community blocks is possible in many instances. Just as communities are not stable on an ecological time-scale, in geological time their composition and character changes with changing environmental (particularly climatic) and evolutionary conditions. Just as the individual lineage evolves, so too does community composition and identity. It is therefore highly misleading and dangerous to extrapolate too far back in time from modern ecosystems. We must think in terms of evolutionary ecotones as well as spatial ecotones, and rely on the fossil record to provide insights into communities and their interactions for which there may be no modern analogues. Fossil assemblages form when plant debris is buried by sediment suffi-
FORMATION A N D INTERPRETATION OF PLANT FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGES
101
ciently rapidly to limit or prevent biodegradation. Because the movement of sediment is involved, the sites of potential fossil formation are dynamic ones where old land surfaces, and the vegetation they support, are being destroyed, and new subaerial land surfaces are being formed and colonized. The communities that act as sources for potential fossil assemblages are in a state of flux to a greater or lesser degree. Debris from disturbed vegetation is more likely to enter the fossil record than climax communities, and yet there is often an implicit assumption in plant palaeoecology, and in particular its application to palaeoclimatology, that the ancient vegetation being studied was in equilibrium with its environment and that the assemblage is an unbiased sample of that source. Nothing could be further from the truth; but that does not mean to say that the fossil record cannot be used for palaeoecological or palaeoclimatological reconstructions. Plant fossil assemblages are highly complex data banks that demand skilled interpretation. The complexity is, at first sight, daunting, but, provided the patterns of assemblage formation are understood, the fossil record is capable of yielding considerably more information about ancient ecosystems than is presently generally appreciated. As an example of the mosaic of communities and seral stages that can be sampled by a river system, consider Figs 1 and 2. Meandering of the hypothetical river erodes into mature “climax” forest of the floodplain. Whole trees, forest litter, and understorey and ground vegetation may fall into the river by bank erosion, while litter may be blown onto the water directly by wind. On the opposite bank, the inside of the bend, sediment is being deposited and being colonized by plants. Litter from communities reoresenting several seral stages may be blown into the river. Similar erosional and depositional processes with attendant differences in vegetation occur on upstream and downstream ends of islands. Further downsteam levee banks, being several metres higher than the surrounding floodplain, are better drained and support a more diverse community than the backswamps and interfluves. However, levee litter is rarely preserved on site because the soils are well oxygenated. The situation is not as negative as it appears. If taphonomic processes are understood, and the fossil assemblage is sampled in such a way as to reveal taphonomically important data, fossil assemblages allow the reconstruction of ancient communities in spatial and temporal relationship to each other. Indeed, it is only through the fossil record that the evolution of communities can be studied.
11. PLANT REMAINS AS SEDIMENTARY PARTICLES A. ALLOCHTHONOUS A N D AUTOCHTHONOUS ASSEMBLAGES
A plant bequeaths evidence of its existence to the fossil record either by
I02
ROBERT A. SPICER
Fig. I. Block diagram illustrating fluvial depositional environments. a, channel lag deposits with logs (see Fig. 14); a'. abandoned channel lag deposits; b, point-bar seres; b', upper point-bar deposits entombing litter derived from upstream riparian sources and local point-bar communities; c. levee communities and deposits; d, undercutting of river banks introducing whole trees and forest floor litter representing mature interfluve communities; e, abandoned channel infill deposits (see Fig. 2).
Fig. 2. Diagram of a vertical section through an active channel normal to flow at meander bend. a, undercutting by high flow velocities at the outside of the bend introducing whole trees and litter from interfluve communities; b, channel lag deposit composed of coarsest channel sediment and logs primarily derived from undercut banks upstream; c, channel lag deposits buried by laterally accreting point-bar deposits-erosion at a and deposition at c causes the channel to migrate laterally, in this case from left to right; d, deposition of plant and inorganic sediment with hydrodynamic settling properties intermediate between those of material found at e and b; e, deposition in upper point-bar sequence of comparatively fine-grained inorganic sediment and plant litter derived from upstream sources and local communities; f, litter from various point-bar sera1communities.
FORMATION AND INTERPRETATIONOF PLANT FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGES
103
naturally abscising various organs that are subsequently transported to a site of sediment accumulation or by becoming buried in situ. Assemblages that are the result of the accumulation of transported material are termed allochthonous assemblages, whereas those that represent accumulation in situ are termed autochthonous. With the exception of peat and coal accumulation or catastrophic inundation, both of which give rise to autochthonous assemblages and will be dealt with later, most plant fossil assemblages are the result of the accumulation of detached organs that have undergone some degree of transport from the site of growth to the site of burial. The interaction of plant parts with sedimentary processes, to produce either autochthonous or allochthonous assemblages, has been termed hiostratinomy (Gastaldo, 1987a). Although the transport potential of different plant organs varies enormously, two basic factors are important: the fluid dynamic properties of the organ, and the position of its point of release into transport media (usually air or water). The way a detached plant organ (or organ fragment) interacts with a fluid medium is potentially governed by the density of the plant particle in relation to that of the fluid medium, together with its shape, size and surface characteristics. B. SETTLING VELOCITY
Let us, for the moment, consider a leaf about to be abscised from the crown of a tree. The “flight” characteristics of that leaf will determine how far the leaf will travel in any given wind speed before it reaches the ground. The further the leaf can travel, the greater the chance it has of encountering a depositional environment. Genetic and environmental factors determine the shape, size, and surface characteristics of the leaf, but density will in part be dependent on the moisture content of the leaf. Sedimentologists have long been able to describe, in approximate terms, the fall of inorganic (usually quartz) grains by treating them as spheres. Many equations in fluid dynamics require that the particle under consideration be ascribed an effective geometrical dimension. For a sphere this dimension is the diameter and, of course, remains the same irrespective of the orientation of the particle to the fluid flow. For a two-dimensional object such as a leaf, such a simple dimension is difficult to ascribe, because as the leaf falls, its orientation is likely to change. Lateral oscillations, or other manifestations of instability during fall, are produced by the formation of a turbulent wake behind the falling object. The generation of this wake can be predicted by calculating a dimensionless number, the Reynolds number, which is proportional to the ratio between inertial and viscous forces. The Reynolds number is given by
104
ROBERT A. SPICER
where U is the fall velocity, L is the effective dimension, p is the density of the particle, and ,u is the dynamic viscosity of the fluid. At low Reynolds numbers, fluid flow past the particle is laminar and the particle descends in a stable orientation. Such conditions exist when the particle is extremely light or the fluid very viscous. At higher Reynolds numbers, however, a turbulent wake is generated which imparts instability to the falling object. To overcome the problem of assigning a single length dimension when the orientation of the particle is constantly changing during fall, various measures that combine dimensions such as length and width have been used (e.g. Allen, 1984; Clift et al., 1978). None are entirely satisfactory and the difficulties in predicting fall behaviour on theoretical grounds have forced a more empirical approach (e.g. Ferguson, 1985; Spicer, 1981).
111. AERIAL DISPERSAL AND TRANSPORT OF PLANT ORGANS The first stage in the formation of fossil assemblages composed of detritus from plants growing in subaerial environments is the shedding of plant parts, either by natural abscission or trauma, into air. Bias introduced into plant assemblages by the timing and frequency of shedding and selective wind transport can be, and usually is, profound. Aerial transport determines what sample of organs a river or lake, for example, receives, and therefore the image of the surrounding vegetation “seen” by the body of water. Many plant organs such as spores, pollen grains, fruits and seeds have become specially adapted to enhance their transportability by wind for reproductive purposes. Intuitively one might expect these organs to be well dispersed by wind and thus have an increased probability of encountering a depositional environment. Other plant parts behave very differently. For example, in the normal course of events floral structures develop into fruits and seeds, and any parts that are shed (e.g. petals) tend to be delicate “throw away” structures with little preservation potential. The leaves of herbaceous taxa are not even shed naturally, and instead wither, rot or fragment, still attached to the parent plant, and thus are most unlikely to enter a deposit except, perhaps, when overwhelmed by event sedimentation (e.g. floods, volcanic ash falls). Between these extremes lie the majority of plant organs. Because of their abundance and utility in biostratigraphy and palaeoclimatic studies, leaves of woody angiosperms have received most attention regarding their relative propensity for wind transport (Spicer, 1975; Roth and Dilcher, 1978; Ferguson, 1985). A.
LEAF ABSCISSION
Marked seasonality is associated with synchronous leaf fall (deciduousness).
FORMATION A N D INTERPRETATION OF PLANT FOSSIL ASSEMBLAGES
105
In modern temperate environments, leaf fall is most noticeable in the autumn, where leaf loss limits frost damage or water stress when the soil is frozen. This phenomenon is most marked in woody angiosperms because broad, thin leaves render them susceptible to freezing and desiccation. Most needle-leaved and microphyllous conifers, with small leaf surface area to volume ratios, and thick epicuticular waxes that limit water loss, are able to withstand these conditions. Some broad-leaved angiosperm taxa (e.g. Rhododendron, Ilex, Hedera) also thrive in understorey situations but these, like the conifers, have thick cuticles and surface waxes. In the case of evergreen taxa, and to some extent deciduous taxa, leaf fall is not restricted to the autumn but occurs year round. Evergreen leaf abscission does not occur at a constant rate, however, and may peak in response to the spring growth spurt or in response to temporary drought. Temperate evergeen leaves tend to remain functional on the parent plant longer than tropical evergreen counterparts (often as little as seven months (Longman and Jernik, 1974) and therefore comparable to temperate deciduous species) and consequently are likely to be under-represented in the fossil record (Ferguson, 1985). In tropical regimes, leaf abscission is also related to seasonality, and in particular the onset of dry conditions. Deciduousness here is often facultative in response to severity of drought, but in some cases the rhythm has become endogenous (Ebel et al., 1985). Ferguson (1985) cites Janzen (1975) as saying that in deciduous tropical forests many woody riparian plants do not experience synchronous leaf