Advances in
ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OPTICAL PHYSICS VOLUME 42
Editors BENJAMIN BEDERSON New York University New York, New York HERBERT WALTHER Max-Planck-lnstitut fur Quantenoptik Garching bei Munchen Germany
Editorial Board P. R. BERMAN University of Michigan Ann Arbor, Michigan M. GAVRILA E 0.M. Instituut voor Atoom-en Molecuulfysica Amsterdam, The Netherlands M. INOKUTI Argonne National Laboratory Argonne, Illinois
W. D. PHILLIPS National Institute for Standards and Technology Gaithersburg, Maryland
Founding Editor SIRDAVIDR. BATES
Supplements 1. Atoms in Intense Laser Fields, Mihai Gavnla, Ed. 2. Cavity Quantum Electrodynamics, Paul R. Berman, Ed. 3. Cross Section Data, Mitio Inokuti, Ed.
ADVANCES IN
ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OPTICAL PHYSICS Edited by
Benjamin Bederson DEPARTMENT OF PHYSICS NEW YORK UNIVERSITY NEW YORK, NEW YORK
Herbert Walther UNIVERSITY OF MUNICH AND MAX-PLANK-INSTITUT QUANTENOPTIK MUNICH, GERMANY
Volume 42
@
ACADEMIC PRESS A Horcourt Science and Technology Company
San Diego
San Francisco New York London Sydney Tokyo
Boston
This book is printed on acid-free paper.
0
Copyright 0 2000 by Academic Press All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher. The appearance of code at the bottom of the first page of a chapter in this book indicates the Publisher’s consent that copies of the chapter may be made for personal or internal use of specific clients. This consent is given on the condition, however, that the copier pay the stated per-copy fee through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc. (222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, Massachusetts 01923), for copying beyond that permitted by Sections 107 or 108 of the U.S. Copyright Law. This consent does not extend to other kinds of copying, such as copying for general distribution, for advertising or promotional purposes, for creating new collective works, or for resale. Copy fees for chapters are as shown on the title pages; if no fee code appears on the chapter title page, the copy fee is the same for current chapters, 1049-25OX/OO $30.00 ACADEMIC PRESS A Harcourt Science and Technology Company 525 B Street, Suite 1900, San Diego, CA 92101-4495, USA http://www.apnet.com Academic Press 24-28 Oval Road, London NWI 7DX, UK http://www.hbuk.co.uk/ap/ International Standard Serial Number: 1049-25OX International Standard Book Number: 0- 12-003842-0
Printed in the United States of America 99 00 010203 QW 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1
Contents CONTRIBUTORS
...................................
ix
Fundamental Tests of Quantum Mechanics Edward S . Fry and Thomas Walther I . Historical Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Bell Inequalities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
111. Loopholes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
IV. Experiments Based on Photons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Experiments Based on Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Contrasts between Photon- and Atom-Based Experiments . . . . . . VII. Greenberger-Home-Zeilinger. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX . Outlook and Perspectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . X . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
1
4 6 8 9 21 23 24 24 25 25
Wave-Particle Duality in an Atom Interferometer Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe 1. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . II. Experimental Setup . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Bragg Reflection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. The Atom Interferometer . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Delayed Choice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Storing Which-Way Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Interferometer with Which-Way Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Quantum Erasure . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX . Incomplete Which-Way Information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . X . Wigner Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI . Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI1. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI11. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
29 33 36 42 48 49 54 57 60 65 69 69 69
Atom Holography Fuji0 Shimizu I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Atomic Beam Source . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . III. Design of Thin-Film Hologram . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Quality Evaluation . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Other Possible Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Conclusions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
73 74 77 89 90 92
vi
Contents
VII . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
92 92
Optical Dipole Traps for Neutral Atoms Rudolf Grimm. Matthias Weidemuller, and Yurii B . Ovchinnikov I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Optical Dipole Potential . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I11. Experimental Issues . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Red-Detuned Dipole Traps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Blue-Detuned Dipole Traps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Concluding Remarks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
95 97 108 123 145 162 165 165
Formation of Cold (T 5 1 K) Molecules J . T Bahns. P. L. Gould. and W C. Stwalley
...................................... ......................... 111. Optical Cooling Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Formation of Cold Molecules Via Laser-Induced Photo-association . . V. Conclusions and Future Directions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Introduction
11. Nonoptical Cooling Techniques
172 191 195 206 219 219 220
High-Intensity Laser-Atom Physics C. J . Joachain. M . Dorr, and N . J . Kylstra I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Multiphoton Processes in Atoms and Ions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Theoretical Methods . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Conclusions and Future Developments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
226 227 237 278 279 279
Coherent Control of Atomic. Molecular. and Electronic Processes Moshe Shapiro and Paul Brumer I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11. Preparation and Dynamics of a Continuum State
.............
I11. Bichromatic Control of a Superposition State . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. The Coherent Control Principle . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Weak-Field Coherent Control: Unimolecular Processes . . . . . . . . . VI . Strong-Field Incoherent Interference Control . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Coherent Control of Bimolecular Processes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
287 289 296 304 304 325 332 342
Contents
IX. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . X. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
vii 343 343
Resonant Nonlinear Optics in Phase Coherent Media M. D. Lukin, l? Hemmer, and M . 0. Scully I. Introduction.
......................................
11. Review of Atomic Coherence Studies. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Resonant Enhancement of Nonlinear Optical Processes:
IV. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. X. XI. XII.
Theconcept . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Analysis of Nonlinear Optical Enhancement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Resonant Enhancement of Four-wave Mixing Processes . . . . . . . . Physical Origin of Nonlinear Enhancement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Optical Phase Conjugation in Double-A Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . For Optical Aberration Correction in Double-A Medium. . . . . . . . Nonlinear Spectroscopy of Dense Coherent Media . . . . . . . . . . . Outlook . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
347 350 353 357 363 367 37 1 375 376 3 82 384 384
The Characterization of Liquid and Solid Surfaces with Metastable Helium Atoms H. Morgner I. Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Reactions of Metastable Helium Atoms with Matter:
General Survey.
....................................
III. Quantitative Evaluation of MIES Data . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
IV. Discussion of Selected Systems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . v. summary. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
387 393 438 449 482 483 483
Quantum Communication with Entangled Photons Harald Weinfirter I. Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
11. Entanglement: Basic Features . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Quantum Communication with Entangled States . . . . . . . . . . . . .
IV. The Building Blocks . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. The Quantum Communication Experiments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
490 492 494 503 519 528 530 530
........................................
535
CONTENTS OF VOLUMESINTHISSERIES . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
545
SUBJECT INDEX
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Contributors Numbers in parentheses indicate pages on which the author’s contributions begin.
J. T. BAHNS(172), Department of Physics, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269 PAULBRUMER (287), Chemical Physics Theory Group, Department of Chemistry, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada M5S 1Al
M. DORR(226), Department de Physique, Universitk du Louvain, B-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium STEPHAN DURR(29), Fakultat fur Physik, Universitat Konstanz, 78457 Konstanz, Germany EDWARD FRY (l), Department of Physics, Texas A & M University, College Station, TX 77843-4242 P. L. GOULD(172), Department of Physics, University of Connecticut, Storrs, CT 06269
RUDOLFGRIMM(95), MPI dur Kernphysik P.O. Box 103980, 69029 Heidelberg, Germany P. HEMMER (347), Max-Planck-Institut fur Quantenoptik, 85748 Garching, Germany C. J. JOACHAIN (226), Physique Theorique, Universitk Libre de Bruxelles, Campus Plaine CP 227, Boulevard du Triomphe, B-1050 Bruxelles, Belgium N. J. KYLSTRA(226), Optics Section, Blackett Laboratory, Imperial College, London SW7 2BZ, United Kingdom
M. D. LUKIN(347), Institute for Theoretical Atomic and Molecular Physics, Harvard-Smithsonian Center for Astrophysics, 60 Garden St., Cambridge, MA 02138 H. MORGNER (387), Institut fur Experimentalphysik, Universitat WittenHerdecke, Stockumer Strafe 10, D-58448 Witten, F.R. Germany ix
X
Contributors
YURII B. OVCHINNIKOV (99, National Institute of Standards and Technology, PHY B167, Gaithersburg, M D 20899 GERHARD REMPE(29), Fakultat fur Physik, Universitat Konstanz, 78457 Konstanz, Germany M. 0. SCULLY(347), Sensors Directorate, Air Force Research Laboratory, Hanscom AFB, MA 01731 MOSHESHAPIRO (287), Chemical Physics Department, The Weizmann Insitute of Science, Rehovot, Israel 76100 FUJIOSHIMIZU (73), Institute for Laser Science, University of ElectroCommunications, Chofu-shi 182-8585, Japan (172), Department of Physics, University of Connecticut, W. C. STWALLEY Storrs. CT 06269 (l), Department of Physics, Texas A & M University, THOMAS WALTHER College Station, TX 77843-4242
MATTHIASWEIDEMULLER (93, Max-Planck-Institut fur Kernphysik, 69029 Heidelberg, Germany HARALD WEINFURTER (490), Sektion Physik der Universitaet Muenchen, 80799 Muenchen, Germany Max-Planck-Institut fur Quantenoptik, 85748 Garching, Germany
Advances in
ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OPTICAL PHYSICS VOLUME 42
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OPTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 42
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS EDWARD S. FRY and THOMAS WALTHER Physics Department, Texas A&M University, College Station, Texas
I. Historical Overview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Bell Inequalities. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Loopholes. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Experiments Based on Photons . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Experiments Based on Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Entanglement in the Micromaser. .................... B. no-Particle Entanglement Based on the Photo-Dissociation of a Molecule . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ...... I . Generation of the Entangled State . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Conditional Detection Probability g . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. Spin Analysis and Detection of the Hg Atoms . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Quantum-Mechanical Prediction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5. Enforcement of the Locality Condition. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VT. Contrasts Between Photon- and Atom-Based Experiments. . . . . VII. Greenberger-Home-Zeilinger . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. Applications . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IX. Outlook and Perspectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . X. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . XI. References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. 111. IV. V.
1 4 6 8 9 10
12 13 15 15 21 21 21 23 24 24 25 25
Abstract: We review recent advances in fundamental tests of quantum mechanics, particularly those involving entangled Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen (EPR) pairs. We will only briefly mention the latest down-conversion experiments and will instead concentrate on the atom-based tests. Specifically, we will discuss the first atomic entanglement in the micromaser; we will then provide an extensive review of an experiment based on photodissociation of the dimer lWHg2.The isotope 199Hghas nuclear spin I = 1/2, and those molecules in a state with total nuclear spin I = 0 are selected. It is an exact experimental realization of Bohm's well-known version of the EPR gedankenexperiment. This experiment will test the Bell inequalities in a regime very different from those using photons.
I. Historical Overview Within only 30 years at the radically changed the way mechanics had in predicting supported the new theory.
beginning of this century, quantum mechanics we view physics. The success that quantum experimental results was startling and strongly However, many were concerned about the 1
Copyright 1 0 2000 by Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any furm reserved. ISBN 0-12-003842-O/ISSN Io.19-2.50XIO $30.00
2
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
implications of quantum mechanics, specifically regarding action at a distance, and its general interpretation. These concerns were voiced by Albert Einstein, Boris Podolsky, and Nathan Rosen (who are generally referred to in this context as EPR) in their famous paper of 1935 (Einstein et al., 1935), in which they argued that quantum mechanics was not a “complete” theory. Presumably, additional parameters, for which the term hidden variables ( H v ) was later coined, would be required in order to make the theory complete. Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen illustrated their concern with a gedankenexperiment using a two-particle system entangled in position and momentum. Bohm’s version of this EPR gedankenexperiment provides a conceptuallynice presentation of the argument; it is based on the entanglement of two spin-I /2 particles (Bohm, 1951), whose wave function can be written
Quantum mechanics predicts that the total spin of this two-particle system is zero, and for measurements of both components in one specific direction, it predicts that the results will be opposite with unit probability. Thus, for a given two-particle system, if particle 1 is measured and found to have spin up (t) in some direction, then particle 2 must necessarily be in a definite state with spin down (I) in that same direction. Furthermore, this knowledge of the spin of particle 2 is obtained without in any way disturbing it; only particle 1 is disturbed by the measurement. Consequently, EPR would argue that the spin of particle 2 must have a “real”, fixed component of spin pointing down in that particular direction. Of course, since the spin of particle 1 could have been measured in any direction, particle 2 should therefore have a corresponding “real” component of spin for every direction. However, quantum mechanics does not permit knowledge of the absolute orientation of an individual spin (all spin components); it teaches us that this is impossible. Quantum mechanics only provides probabilities for the outcomes of measurements of the components of spins in various directions. This situation was untenable in the view of Einstein and many others, and it led to their belief that quantum mechanics was an “incomplete” theory. Specifically, quantum mechanics does not permit knowledge of more than one spin component of a particle, but the EPR gedankenexperiment leads us to conclude that all components are “real” and that it should therefore be possible to determine them. Moreover, to circumvent the EPR argument, we would have to invoke a seemingly instantaneous communication of relative spin orientation between the two particles. Such arguments violated Einstein’s strong belief in causality, and he rejected this action-at-a-distance behavior of quantum mechanics. For an introductory article on action-at-a-distance, see
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
3
Hardy, 1998. For a good tutorial of a different view of the EPR question, see Cantrell and Scully (1978) as well as more recent discussions (Mohrhoff, 1999). The discussions remained purely philosophical in nature until 1964, when John Bell showed (based on Bohm’s classic version of the spin-1/2 particle EPR gedankenexperirnent) that any hidden-variable theory satisfying a physically reasonable condition of locality (LHV theory, e.g., a classical theory) will yield statistical predictions that must satisfy restrictions for certain correlated phenomena (Bell, 1964) such as occur with entangled states [cf. Eq. (l)]. These restrictions are now called Bell inequalities, and they show that the strength of classical statistical correlations is limited. In contrast, quantum mechanics predicts much stronger statistical correlations than such classical theories, and Bell explicitly demonstrated that the quantum-mechanical prediction for the statistical result of correlation measurements on an ensemble of two-particle entangled states can violate the inequalities. In summary, he showed that the classical counterparts of quantum mechanics, the local hidden-variable theories (LHV), always restrict the statistical correlations so that the Bell inequalities are satisfied; whereas the quantum-mechanical predictions for the statistical correlations can violate the Bell inequalities. Thus, for the first time it was possible, at least in principle, to distinguish experimentally between the LHV and quantummechanical pictures. A crucial point is that no particular LHV theory is specified. The test of a Bell inequality is general and leads to discrimination between any LHV and quantum mechanics. The caveat is that the strongest form of the Bell inequalities - the Bell-Clauser-Home (BCH) inequality (Clauser and Horne, 1974) - must be tested. The BCH inequality contains no additional assumptions and therefore provides the strongest possible test. It is remarkable that this equation has actually not yet been tested (cf. Section 111.). The principal problem of experimental tests of these Bell inequalities lies in the fact that experimental imperfections generally preclude a definitive test; that is, they shift the result such that the Bell inequalities are no longer violated. In practice, additional auxiliary assumptions had to be introduced in order to make physically realizable experiments possible with existing technology (Clauser et al., 1969). Specifically, the strong BCH inequality is a ratio of the rate of coincidence events between detectors to the rate of single detection events at each detector. The auxiliary assumptions make it possible to write the inequality as a ratio of coincidence events to coincidence events. Several such experiments, involving correlations between two photons in an atomic cascade or from parametric down-conversion, have been completed (for a review of those experiments, see Pipkin, 1978; Clauser and Shimony, 1978; Duncan and Kleinpoppen, 1988; Chiao et al., 1994; Shih, 1999). They
4
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
generally gave results in agreement with quantum mechanics and violated a weaker form of Bell inequalities derived using the auxiliary assumption required for the case of low detection efficiency. In this article we will briefly discuss the strong Bell inequality and what is involved in testing it. We will then summarize the existing loopholes and briefly describe the optical tests performed since the last review of the field by Y. R. Shih (Shih, 1999). We will then discuss experimental tests based on atoms, with particular emphasis on the photo-dissociation of mercury dimers. This is followed by a discussion about principal differences between optical and atomic tests and then by a brief mention of the advances in the field due to the Greenberger-Home-Zeilingerstates. We conclude with a short discussion of some applications in quantum communication and a summary.
11. Bell Inequalities The test of the strong BCH inequality requires the measurement of coincidence rates Rtt ( e l , O * ) for the simultaneous detection of one particle of the entangled pair at detector 1 with spin up (“t”)in the direction 81 and of the other atom at detector 2 with spin up (‘‘T”) in the direction €I2; the singles rates Rir (ei),which are defined as the rate of detection of particles with spin up in the direction €Ii at detector i, where i = 1 or 2, must also be measured. The parameter for which the pair is entangled (i.e., polarization, timeposition, or spin) or the type of particle (i.e., photon or atom) that is entangled is not significant to the argument at this point. However, for simplicity we restrict our discussion to atomic systems with an entanglement of the spin according to Eq. (1). The BCH inequality is formulated in terms of the ratio of coincidence rates to singles rates for four different combinations of angles for the spin measurement (Clauser and Horne, 1974; Clauser and Shimony, 1978). In the present context, the strong BCH inequality can be expressed as
where 81,e; are two values of angles for the first spin analyzer and 02, 0; are two values of angles for the second spin analyzer. The quantum-mechanical predictions, including experimental imperfections for the above-mentioned coincidence and singles rates, can be written (Fry et al., 1995; Walther and
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
5
Fry, 1997b) as follows:
where q is the detector efficiency for the atoms and is assumed to be the same for both detectors. E + and E - are defined as E + = EM E m and E- = EM - E m , respectively, where EM is the transmission of the analyzers for one spin component, and E , is the leakage through the analyzer for the other spin component. E , and cM are positive definite and are assumed to be identical for both analyzers. Specifically, E + and E - are measures of the capability to discriminatebetween the two spin components in a measurement for optimum discrimination, j if - E + = E - = 1. The two detectors are assumed to be symmetric; they have identical geometries, and f is the detector acceptance solid angle; g is the conditional probability that if one of the atoms of the entangled pair enters the aperture of one detector, then the other atom of that pair enters the aperture of the other detector; N is the total number of entangled pairs per unit time. In an actual experiment the goal will be to choose the angles 81,02, 0{, and 0; such that when the quantum mechanical predictions Eqs. (3) and (4)are used in Eq. (2), the resulting SQ, provides a maximum violation of the BCH inequality. We find that for 01,02, el,,and 0; equal to 135", O", 225", and 90", respectively, the prediction is
+
S ~ ~ ( 1 3 5 ~ , 0 ~ , 2 2 5=-qg&+(l+h(:)'). ~1, 9 0 ~ ) 2
(5)
In order to obtain the largest possible violation of the BCH inequality by the quantum-mechanical prediction, the right-hand side of Eq. ( 5 ) must exceed 1, the parameters q, g, and EM should be as large as possible, and E, should be as small as possible. Finally, it should be noted that any test of the Bell inequalities is statistical in nature because the measured values are ratios of coincidence count rates to singles count rates. Moreover, the measured values must be determined with a sufficiently small error that the error in the measured value of S is much less than the magnitude of the violation (the amount by which the predicted SQM exceeds 1). Specifically, it is not the magnitude of the violation, but rather its comparison to the error limits of an experimentallydetermined value of S, that is a measure of the significance of the violation. As an aside, note that some
6
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
experimental parameters must be measured in order to evaluate SQM,and therefore SQMwill generally have errors associated with it.
111. Loopholes As discussed earlier, the strongest form of the Bell inequalities has not yet been tested; no experiment to date has been entirely free of loopholes (Pearle, 1970; Clauser and Home, 1974; Clauser and Shimony, 1978; Zeilinger, 1986; Santos, 1996). Specifically, one or more of the following loopholes were present: (1) the spatial correlation loophole, (2) the detection efficiency loophole, and (3) the enforcement of locality (the communication loophole). The first loophole - the spatial correlation loophole - relates to the ideal case in which the two-particle entangled state is generated by a two-body decay that involves only the two particles that are entangled. In this case, momentum conservation ensures a strong spatial correlation that is necessary because the experimenter must make sure that both particles of an entangled pair end up in the detectors. In the experiments based on the two-photon cascade in an atom, the atom acts as a third body that can take some of the momentum and thus significantly reduce the spatial correlation between the two photons. Santos and coworkers published a proposal to close this loophole by repeating the atom cascade experiments and closing the spatial correlation loophole by measuring the atomic recoil (Huelga et al., 1994). But this loophole has been effectively closed by the experiments performed several years ago in which correlated photons were produced by parametric down-conversion. The second loophole - the detection efficiency loophole - originates from experimental imperfections. Low detection efficiencies reduce the observable correlation, because the lower the detection efficiency, the lower the probability that both partners of an entangled pair will be detected. In particular, the BCH inequality, Eq. (2), involves ratios of coincidence rates to singles rates. If the detection efficiency is loo%, the ratio of coincidence rates to singles rates has a maximum of unity, but as the detection efficiency decreases below loo%, the maximum value of this ratio decreases rapidly. In fact, for low detection efficiencies, the ratio is so low that the quantum mechanical predictions for SQ, can never violate the inequality. Hence an additional assumption known as the fair sampling assumption was introduced. Physically, the assumption is that the subensemble of those pairs of particles for which both partners are detected behaves in exactly the same way as the remaining subensemble of those pairs for which at least one partner is missed in the detection process as a result of insufficient detection efficiencies. This leads to weaker forms of the Bell inequalities that involve ratios of coincidence rates to coincidence rates; that is. the coincidence rates are normalized to
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
7
some maximum coincidence rate. All tests of the Bell inequalities to date have tested these weaker forms. Unfortunately, it is possible to construct LHV theories that show the strong correlations of quantum mechanics in the limit of low detection efficiencies (Pearle, 1970; Clauser and Horne, 1974). Hence a rigorous test of the Bell inequalities requires high detection efficiencies. From Eq. (5) it can be shown a minimum efficiency q = 0.82 is necessary for a rigorous test, assuming that all other experimental parameters are optimized (i.e., g = E + = E- = 1). However, it has also been shown that for asymmetric entangled states (states for which the two components have weights other than 1/&) an efficiency of 0.67 would be sufficient (Eberhard, 1993). From this discussion, it is clear that atoms could provide an ideal basis for these experiments, because photo-ionization schemes provide high detection efficiencies for nearly all elements of the periodic table (Hurst et al., 1979). As pointed out by Santos (1996), and as is evident in the quantum-mechanical predictions [Eq. ( 5 ) ] , high detection efficiency alone is not enough to test the BCH inequality. High detection efficiencies must be accompanied by a high probability of actually detecting both particles of an entangled pair in their respective detectors - that is, a high conditional probability g of finding particle 2 in detector 2 provided that particle 1 entered detector 1. The third loophole - enforcement of the locality condition (also known as the communication loophole) - requires that the correlation measurement on the two particles be completely independent at each analyzer. Specifically, it is necessary to guarantee that there is no communication between the two analyzers the two spin analyses: they must be outside each other's space-time light cone. This means that the time it takes for selection of a spin analysis direction and the analysis must be short compared to the time required for a light signal to propagate from one analyzer/detector to the other. This requires a relatively large separation of the analyzer/detectors. The first attempt to enforce the locality condition was pursued by Aspect and coworkers (Aspect et al., 1982a). Their experimental scheme did not allow a strict enforcementof the locality condition, because they used periodic switching of the polarizer orientation rather than random orientations; also the choice of the switching period was unfortunate (Zeilinger, 1986). Very recently, however, Zeilinger et al. succeeded in closing this loophole (Weihs et al., 1998). They utilized a down-conversion source and coupled the entangled photon pairs into two fibers that led to two detector arrangements that were separated by 400 m. At each detector, fast electro-optic modulators rotated the plane of polarization between two randomly selected values, 0" and 45".This is equivalent to randomly rotating the subsequent analyzing polarizer. The principle of the setup is very similar to Aspect's experiment, with the important difference that the switching was random. The type of process used to determine the random number is of significance if the locality
8
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
loophole is to be closed. A pseudo-random, computer-generated number is certainly not enough. Consequently,Zeilinger et af. used a light-emitting diode and a beamsplitter as their random generator. Zeilinger's success represents a very important step in the clarification of the EPR argument. However, because the experiment was performed with a detection efficiency of approximately 5%, the detection loophole is not yet closed. The ultimate test must be one that enforces locality and simultaneously closes all other loopholes associated with previous tests. The flight time of the particles to their respective detectors does not influence the arguments in the discussion of the locality condition. It is solely the communication between the two analyzer/detectors that is important. However, the time of flight for the particles is important to a discussion of the lifetime of the entangled state. It is conceivable that the strong correlations predicted by quantum mechanics exist only for a limited time. This is the reason why the experiment by Gisin and coworkers (Tittel et al., 1998) represents a major step forward. They performed a Bell inequality test of the Franson type (Franson, 1989) with time-position entanglement, where the two detectors were separated by more than 10 km.They measured correlations consistent with quantum mechanics after taking into account the losses in the fiber due to imperfect transmission. The large separation requires a minimum lifetime of around 30 ps for the entangled state; this is very long compared to the 40 ns in Zeilinger's experiment. Herein lies one of the benefits of using atoms. Atom speeds are generally much less than the velocity of light, and even with relatively small separations of the detectors, a very long lifetime (milliseconds) of the entanglement can be tested via the Bell inequalities.
IV. Experiments Based on Photons As discussed earlier, most experiments performed so far have been based on photons in polarization or time-position entanglement. The first experiments to give agreement with quantum mechanics were those of Freedman and Clauser (1972), Clauser (1976), and Fry and Thompson (1976). These were followed by the well-known experiments by Aspect et af.(1 982a, 1982b). The first experiments employing two-photon parametric down-conversion were those of Alley and Shih (1987), followed by those of Ou and Mandel(l988). Some of the more recent tests (cf. Fig. 1) have been performed by Kwiat, Zeilinger, and Shih (Kwiat et al., 1995)and by Kwiat et al. (1998). In the most recent experiment, a more refined version of the generation of entanglement via parametric down-conversion was utilized. By combining two thin nonlinear type-I crystals whose nonlinear axes are at 90" each other and using
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
9
FIG. I . Most recent experiments testing the foundations of quantum mechanics were performed with type41 nonlinear down-conversion processes. The uv photons are down-converted into two IR photons of the same wavelength (degenerate case). The figure shows the cones on which the down-converted photons can exit the nonlinear crystal. The top half is polarized horizontally, the lower half vertically. At the intersection of the cones, both polarizations can exist, and hence the photons are entangled.
45" polarized pump light, Kwiat et al. produced the entangled state
1 19)= - ( I H H )
Jz
+expiiSIW))
where the phase iS can be adjusted by tilting the crystals. They achieved the highest production rates of entangled states to date, even surpassing their previous type-II-based source by a factor of 10.
V. Experiments Based on Atoms Experiments based on atoms differ considerably from the photon-based experiments (see also Section VI). For example, entanglement can be produced only by direct manipulation of the atomic degrees of freedom. Several proposals to generate EPR pairs of atoms for experimental tests exist in the literature (Oliver and Stroud, 1987; Freyberger et al., 1996; Lo and Shimony, 1981; Fry et af., 1995). The proposals by Oliver and Stroud and by Freyberger et al. are based on entanglement of atoms in the micromaser. The latter is an extension of the former in which experimentally more realistic conditions, such as nonperfect detection efficiencies and velocity distributions of atoms, are considered. The proposal by Fry et al. (1995) is based on the photo-dissociation of Hg dimers, and the proposal by Lo and Shimony (1981) is based on photo-dissociation of Na dimers.
10
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
FIG. 2. Generic micromasersetup for the generation and detection of entanglement between atoms.
A. ENTANGLEMENT IN THE MICROMASER In a recent article, Englert ef al. (1998) reviewed the entanglement of atoms in a micromaser. We will therefore emphasize only a few key ideas relevant to entanglement in the micromaser and to the experiment of Haroche’s group (Hagley er al., 1997). Entanglement in the micromaser is produced through the interaction of two completely independent Rydberg atoms with a common radiation field in a micromaser cavity. Rydberg atoms are used because their lifetimes are very long and the atom can be treated as a two-level system (two Rydberg levels) interacting with a single mode of the radiation field. In analogy with a spin- 1/2 particle, we designate the higher-energy Rydberg level as It) and the lowerenergy level as 11).A generic experimental arrangement is shown in Fig. 2. Atoms in It) first pass through a classical microwave (Ramsey field 1) field, which prepares them in the superposition state
where 4 I is the phase of the classical field and 81 is the Rabi angle. The state IS,) corresponds to a pure It) or 11) state in another quantization direction. The atoms then pass through a high-Q micromaser cavity, which is resonant with the microwave transition between the two Rydberg levels. Finally, the atoms pass through a second Ramsey field and into a detection system that provides a measurement result or J. for each atom. Consider the entanglement of two atoms initially in the state It) passing successively through the apparatus of Fig. 2. Assume that Ramsey field 1 is off so that atom 1 enters the micromaser cavity in the state It). Suppose that the cavity is in the vacuum state and the interaction strength and time are
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
11
chosen such that the cavity acts as a x/2 pulse; that is, we will find the atom with probability 1/2 in the excited It) or the ground state 11).Correspondingly, the cavity is in the vacuum state (if the atom remains in the excited state) or has one photon stored in it (if the atom underwent a transition to the ground state). We can therefore write the combined atom/cavity state as
Now, suppose Ramsey field 1 is turned on and adjusted so that the second atom is driven to the ground state 11)before entering the cavity. We also choose the interaction with the cavity ( x pulse) such that, if a photon is present in the cavity, the atom undergoes a transition to the excited state It).Now, after atom 2 leaves the cavity, we find the following two-atom/cavity wavefunction,
We see that the cavity part is separable and we are left with an entangled state of the two atoms that is just like that of the two spin-1/2 particles. Practical limitations such as the finite lifetime of the photons in the cavity will result in much smaller correlations than indicated by Eq. (9). Other practical limitations arise from the arrival statistics of the atoms at the micromaser cavity and from imprecise control of the interaction between the atoms and photons that results from variations in the time of flight of atoms through the micromaser. The first experimental demonstration of entanglement between atoms in a micromaser was made by the group of Haroche (Hagley et al., 1997), using atoms in circular Rydberg states. They began with a thermal beam of rubidium atoms and used a laser to optically pump all atoms out of the F = 3 hyperfine level and into other ground state hyperfine levels. By means of a second laser at a 55" angle to the atom beam, they were able to use the Doppler effect to optically pump ground state atoms in a narrow velocity distribution back into the F = 3 level. In the next step, atoms within a thin velocity-segment in the already velocity-selected F = 3 atoms were excited to the required circular Rydberg state using a diode laser to drive the first step of the excitation, followed by radio frequency transitions to the circular Rydberg states (Nussenzveig et al., 1993). The resulting velocity resolution of the atoms in the Rydberg states was f0.4 m/s; also, because the lasers were pulsed, the position of an atom was known to within f l mm, and the interaction time with the fields could be controlled. The entangled state of two atoms was produced as discussed in the previous paragraph, the first atom being excited to Rydberg state IT) and the second to Rydberg state 11) before entering the micromaser cavity.
12
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
The entanglement was verified by measuring P t l , P ~ TPtt, , P l l , where the first (second) subscript corresponds to the result of a measurement on the first (second) particle, e.g., Prl is the probability of finding atom 2 in the ground state 11)when atom 1 can be found in the excited state 1 T). For a pure EPR pair, the probabilities Ptl and P i t should both be 1/2, whereas the Ptt and Pl1 should both be zero. The observed values of Ptl and Plt were both less than 1/2 as a result of three main factors. First, the entanglement is reduced because of the finite lifetime of the photons in the cavity. Second, it was found that the x pulse required to prepare atom 2 in the micromaser cavity was not perfect (it transferred only 80% of the atoms). Third, the detectors showed a relatively high false rate; that is, the 11)detector clicks with a 10% probability even though the atom is in the upper 11) state, and similarly (13%) for the It) detector. The relatively low detection efficiency does not reduce the correlations because the mean number of atoms was low, and the measurements were postselective for coincidences (only those events are registered where both detectors are triggered in the expected time interval between the atoms). In a subsequent elegant experiment, they applied a 7r/2 analyzing pulse (e.g., Ramsey field 2 of Fig. 2) and observed the probabilities PLt and Ptt as a function of the frequency of Ramsey field 2. Their results are consistent with the interpretation that measurement of the first atom of the pair determines “at-a-distance” the state of the spatially separated second atom. This state of the second atom then precesses in Ramsey field 2, and if the frequency of Ramsey field 2 is varied, then the final angle of the second atom varies so that PLTis modulated sinusoidally as Hagley et al. observed. Problems for tests of the Bell inequalities based on the entanglement in the micromaser are the spatial separation of the atoms when they become entangled, and the fact that the entanglement is not generated in one step but requires several steps. Moreover, the detection of the atoms occurs sequentially and would be a problem for the enforcement of Einstein locality. These problems do not arise for experiments in which the two-particle entanglement is produced via the photo-dissociation of a molecule.
B. TWO-PARTICLE ENTANGLEMENT BASEDON DISSOCIATION OF A MOLECULE
THE
PHOTO-
The wavefunction for a diatomic homonuclear molecule consisting of two atoms, each with nuclear spin 1/2, and with total electron and nuclear spin angular momentum zero, can be expressed in terms of separated atom basis states (Fry et al., 1995) as
FUNDAMENTALTESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
13
FIG.3. The Hgz-dissociation-based EPR experiment at Texas A&M University.
where subscripts 1 and 2 label the two atoms, and It) and 11)indicate spin up and spin down, respectively. This state is identical to that of the two spin- 1/2 particles in Bohm’s classic version of the EPR gedunkenexperiment (Bohm, 1951; Clauser and Shimony, 1978). Thus a spatially “separated” entangled state suitable for testing Bell inequalities can be prepared by molecular dissociation. An experimental implementation based on the dissociation of the mercury dimer 199Hg2will now be outlined (see Fig. 3).
1. Generation of the Entangled State Choice of the isotope 199Hgis based on its nuclear spin I = 1/2. A molecule consisting of two 199Hgatoms (a 199Hg2dimer) will be produced in a supersonic beam and will be photo-dissociated via stimulated Raman excitation. Specifically, a laser at M 266 nm drives a transition in the v 58-0 band of the ’EC,. system. A second laser at 355 nm completes the stimulated Raman transition to a continuum level of the ground state and leaves the dissociated atoms with a center-of-mass (CM) kinetic energy of 1.17 eV. Because detection of the two spatially separated Hg atoms will be achieved with pulsed lasers, precise knowledge of their arrival time at the detector is crucial. Not only does the stimulated emission process determine this time very accurately, but the narrow laser linewidth also ensures a narrow distribution of energies in the dimer continuum state and thus leaves the two Hg atoms with a very narrow distribution of kinetic energy. Indeed, the latter contribution to the uncertainty in the velocity toward the detectors is negligible compared to the uncertainties due to the laboratory velocity distribution of the dimers.
14
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
The excitation laser radiation at 266 nm is produced by a frequencytripled Alexandrite laser running at 798 nm. This laser has an intracavity phase modulator that reduces the linewidth by a factor of 4.It has a pulselength of 120 ns and a typical linewidth of 11 MHz (Nicolaescu et al., 1998). We chose Alexandrite for its long pulselength and hence narrow Fourier-transformlimited linewidth. The stimulated transition down to the continuum state is driven by an excimer pumped dye laser operating at 355 nm. The technique to generate the entangled state given by Eq. (lo), involves selecting two 199Hgatoms with a total nuclear spin Z = 0 and is based on the specific symmetry rules of the total wavefunction for a homonuclear diatomic molecule. Because 199Hgis a fermion with nuclear spin 1/2, the 199Hg2dimers must have an antisymmetric total wavefunction with respect to an exchange of the two nuclei in order to conform to the Pauli principle. Based on the symmetry properties of the nuclear, rotational, vibrational, and electronic wavefunctions of 199Hg2dimers in their ground state, it can be shown that the antisymmetric nuclear spin singlet states are associated with symmetric evenN rotational levels, and the symmetric nuclear spin triplet states are associated with antisymmetric odd-N rotational levels (Fry et al., 1995; Herzberg, 1950; Walther and Fry, 1997b), where N is the rotational quantum number. Now, the selection rule for the rotational quantum number in a homonuclear molecular electronic transition is that N can only change by f 1 in a ( ~ u ) ~ C-, 'C; + transition. Because the stimulated Raman process involves two transitions the excitation beam and Raman beam in (Fig. 4), the overall change must be 0, f 2 . Consequently, if the initial state of the dimer has even N, the final continuum state must also have even N. In summary, nuclear singlet states (Z = 0) can be selectively excited using transitions starting with even N. Because of the angular momentum selection rules for the excitation (266 nm)
FIG. 4. Schematic of the preparation of the entanglement between the two Hg atoms. The entanglement is produced by a two-photon Raman process. One laser beam excites the dimer in an excited state, and the second beam pumps the atoms on to a dissociative part of the molecular ground state energy surface. The atoms separate, and the spin analysis can be performed.
FUNDAMENTALTESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
15
and stimulated emission (355 nm) transitions, the final dissociating level of the 'C; ground state must also have even N and hence zero total nuclear spin. The entangled singlet state is thus produced by initially exciting transitions with the 266-nm laser, which start from even-N rotational states. This selection works even in the case when the ( ~ U ) ~excited C ; state is mixed with a 'II state (Walther and Fry, 1997b). The purity of the entangled singlet state will be very high. Since both electronic states involved in the dissociation process are states with angular momentum A = 0, and the total nuclear spin state is I = 0. Any interaction between the electron spins with the nuclear spins of the atoms should be negligible.
2. Conditional Detection Probability g The probability that one atom of a dissociating dimer enters a detector, given that the other atom entered the other detector, is called the conditional probability g; we saw it in Eqs. (3) and (5). It is a function of the size of the dissociation volume (source volume), the angular distribution of the dissociating dimer fragments, the size and position of the detector apertures, and the spread in the velocities of the dissociating fragments. The source volume is the common intersection of the excitation and dissociation (Raman) laser beams with the supersonicdimer beam (cf. Fig. 4). The optimum detectorposition is determined by the vector addition of the initial dimer velocity with the corresponding CM velocity of the dissociating atoms. In principle, g can reach values close to unity. For a fixed detector size and position, the bmaller the spread in the initial velocities of the Hg2 dimers, the larger the conditional probability g. The spread in dimer velocities can be reduced considerably by using the Doppler effect to select spectroscopically only those molecules whose speed lies within a very narrow velocity window. This can be achieved by aligning the 266-nm excitation laser beam (which has a very narrow frequency spread, Av = 33 MHz) so that it nearly copropagates or counterpropagates with the molecular beam. Monte Car10 simulations show that for this laser linewidth, together with the other parameters used in our experimental setup, a value of g > 0.94 can be achieved (cf. Fig. 5 and Fry et al., 1995). Other pairs of atoms originating from the dissociation of different isotopomers will have different velocities toward the detectors and will be suppressed in the detection step; this is the case regardless of whether the other isotopomers have the same or different total mass. 3. Spin Analysis and Detection of the Hg Atoms
The requirements of the spin analysis and detection scheme are high detection efficiency and high discrimination between spin states. The high discrimination and detection efficiency will be achieved using a two-step
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
16
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 0.8 radlus of dissociation region / mm
' 0.92
1
FIG.5. Monte Car10 simulation of the conditional probability g. We repeated the simulation in Fry et al. (1995) with the relevant data of our laser system. Because of restrictions of time of flight, some of the atoms are not detected for large radii of the source volume.
excitation-ionizationprocess. Detection of the Hg+ ion and its photo-electron yields the required high detection efficiency. Immediately following the entrance aperture to each detector, two independent laser beams (253.7 nm and 197.3 nm) illuminate the Hg atoms (cf. Fig. 6 ) .As shown in Fig. 7, the first laser drives a transition from the (6s2)6'So ( F = 1/2) ground state (level 1) to the (6s6p) 63Py ( F = 1/2) state (level 2). ~ The second laser drives a transition from level 2 to the (6p2)6 3 P autoionizing state (level 3). Spin Analysis. The analyzing beams for the two dectors at 253.7 nm lie in parallel planes and are at angles 81, (32 to the +z-axis (cf. Fig. 6 ) . The angles 81, (32 of these 253.7-nm laser beams define the directions in which each atom's nuclear spin component is observed. For a ground state lg9Hg ( F = 1/2) atom, the quantum numbers for the two components of angular momentum in a given direction are mF = &1/2; because J = 0, these are just the components of nuclear spin in that direction. If the 253.7-nm laser beam mF must decrease by 1 in the transition. has left-circular polarization (0-), Thus only ground state atoms for which the projection of the angular momentum (nuclear spin) in the direction of propagation of the left-circular polarized laser beam is mF = + 1/2 can be excited to the 63Py ( F = 1/2) state and subsequently ionized; see Fig. 7. Conversely right-circular polarization could be used to excite the mF = -1/2 state, which could then be ionized.
FLTNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
17
FIG.6. The detection planes are parallel to the dimer beam and the Raman laser used for preparation of the entangled state. The laser at 253.7 nm is the analysis laser, which performs the spin analysis. The quantization axis is the propagation direction of this laser. Ionization is achieved via the 197.3-nm beam.
/
,
, ’ ,/’
;
//,’
,
,,
/ ’
/
’
,’ I
,/ ,
,,
,/
,/
,’/, / /
Ionization limit 197.3 nm
22 GHz
1-
__
-
-
F=3/2 6s6p
Level 2 F=1/2
FIG.7. Photo-ionization scheme used for spin analysis of the Hg atoms. If the Hg atom is in “spin up” (mF = 1/2) with respect to the quantization axis given by the propagation direction of left-circular (0-) polarized 253.7-nm beam, it will be ionized in a two-photon step. Transitions of the “spin down” (mF = - 1/2) are suppressed because of the large detuning from the F = 3/2 state.
Because the transition from the mF = -1/2 to the 63PT (F = 3/2) mF = -3/2 is only detuned by 22GHz, a small fraction of Hg atoms in the spin mF = -1/2 state might still be ionized. This represents the dominant leakage in our analyzer scheme. Imperfect polarization of the 253.7-nm laser beam also leads to a leakage, but this should be negligible.
18
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
Hg Atom Zonizafion. The degree of ionization was calculated by numerically solving the corresponding master equations, assuming Fourier-transformlimited Gaussian pulses with a pulselength of 8 ns (Fry et al., 1995). A maximum value EM = 99.5% can be achieved for the ionization efficiency. The high efficiency of the analyzer/detector is due to the large oscillator strengths of the two transitions and to the favorable ratio of non-radiative to radiative decay rate out of level 3. The 0.5% loss in the ionization process arises mainly from radiative decay out of the intermediate level to the other mF sublevel of the ground state. Because of the circular polarization of the excitation, this other mF sublevel cannot be excited back to the intermediate level. Transitions through the mF = f 3 / 2 hyperfine states are highly suppressed (E,,, < 0.075%), so a very high degree of discrimination between the two spin states is achieved. Crucial to these high efficiencies is the exact timing of the two laser beams. Assuming 8-ns laser pulses, the two laser pulses must be delivered to the detectors within a relative time window of M 4 ns. Otherwise, the achievable ionization rates drop dramatically. In order to minimize the time uncertainty between the two laser pulses, we developed a single flashlamp pumped Ti:Sapphire laser system that produces the two wavelengths simultaneously (Walther et al., 1998).The laser is actually operated as a nanosecond regenerative amplifier that is injection-seeded with two external cavity cw diode lasers at 761.1 nm and 789.9 nm. (The latter operate in a single longitudinal mode and are frequency-stabilized to an external reference.) Because the laser is a regenerative amplifier, it is unnecessary to stabilize the cavity length to match the seed lasers (which would be very difficult for two wavelengths simultaneously). Pulses at both wavelengths are output simultaneously when the cavity is dumped, and we have shown that the relative pulse amplitudes can be adjusted by adjusting the relative intensities of the seed lasers. The relative timing between pulses can be easily adjusted over a few nanoseconds by adjusting the optical path lengths to the detectors. The required 253.7 nm laser source is produced by frequency tripling (double, the sum) the 761.1 nm output. The 197.3 nm laser source is provided by frequency doubling and then two steps of frequency summing.
Hg Atom Defection. After the spin analysis and photo-ionization, the Hg+ and/or the associated photo-electron must be detected with high efficiency and low background. The latter is particularly important because the signal must be reduced to a level at which there is negligible probability of more than one Hg atom in the detection region at a time (otherwise, coincidences between atoms from different dissociating molecules will be observed). The detectors must also have large acceptance angles in order to achieve high values of the conditional probability g (see Section 2) (Fry e f al., 1995).
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
19
Atom detection is via both the resulting ion and the photo-electron. This dual detection has important consequences, because the measurements of singles rates between electron and ion at each detector, and of coincidence rates between detectors, provide independent determinations of the absolute efficiency for electron and ion detection at each detector, as well as of the conditional probability g (Fry et al., 1995; Fry, 1973). These parameters can be internally evaluated from the same data used to test the strong Bell inequality - an important advantage of this scheme. Moreover, other factors like E + and E - can be measured via simple intensity- and polarization-related sets of measurements without relying on quantum-mechanical arguments (Walther and Fry, 1997a). Hg ions will be detected by using four electrostatic lenses first to extract them from the photo-ionization region and then to focus and collimate them to a small-diameterbeam. They are then accelerated (kinetic energy M 25 keV) into an aluminum-coated surface at an angle of incidence of 74" to produce a burst of secondary electrons. The high kinetic energy increases the yield of secondary electrons. For our design, an average of 13 secondary electrons should be produced per ion. Finally, the secondary electrons will be detected with a large input-cone channeltron. The photo-electrons will be extracted from the photo-ionizationregion and guided with the help of electric fields onto a Cu:Be electrode, where secondary electrons will be produced. These will then also be detected using a large input-cone channeltron. The Cu:Be surface should produce, on average, five to eight secondary electrons. The electrodes and input lenses were designed such that photo-electrons originating from the laser beams hitting parts of the detector and other surfaces are suppressed. The present design leads to very high detection efficiencies. The overall probability for detecting an electron or ion is given by
where p ( 0 ) is the probability of detecting no secondary electron; ph(n) is the probability of producing n secondary electrons per ion or electron, when h is the average number of secondary electrons produced; and P c h is the probability for detecting an electron in a channeltron ( p c h M 0.9). pn(n) is given by a Poisson distribution p h ( n ) = $e-' (Benetti et al., 1991). For the high number of secondary electrons produced in our scheme, the sum in Eq. (1 1) is negligible, and the detection probability is reduced from unity only by the probability pn(0) that no secondary electron is generated. As depicted in Fig. 8, overall detection efficiencies close to unity for both
20
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
FIG. 8. Overall efficiency of the Hg detection as a function of secondary electrons produced per electron and Hg ion. We assume an OR decision; that is, the Hg is detected when either the electron or the ion is detected. Our experimental setup should produce more than 5 secondary electrons per electron and 12 secondary electrons per ion.
the electron and the ion should be possible. This has been confirmed by preliminary measurements on the performance of our detector (Fry et al., 1998). An important consequence of the double detection scheme with an OR decision, however, is that background or noise counts must be negligible. Therefore, it is especially important to minimize the Hg partial pressure, but the partial pressure of all other residual gases should also be minimized (an ultrahigh vacuum of < torr). The detector and all surfaces on the line of sight to it must be cooled to liquid nitrogen temperatures to freeze out background Hg atoms (Fry et af., 1995). Finally, it is essential to suppress photo-electrons produced by scattered photons. Nickel plating all metal surfaces eliminates the production of photo-electrons by the 253.7-nm laser beam. Spurious scattering of the 197-nm laser beam must simply be avoided. Of course, for detection efficiencies close to unity, it will be possible to employ an AND detection scheme, which makes background signals, especially from photo-electrons produced by stray light photons, much less important.
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
21
4. Quantum-Mechanical Prediction
The quantum-mechanical prediction SQMof Eq. ( 5 ) can now be estimated by using the quantities g = 0.94, q = 0.99, E + = 0.996, and E- = 0.994, which were derived in the preceding sections. 5 ' ~ ~ ( 1 3 5 ~ , 0 ~ , 2 2 5=~1.112 , 9 0 ~>) 1.
(12)
Thus the BCH inequality is clearly violated by the quantum-mechanical predictions. It should be emphasized that the experiment not only is able to test LHV theories against quantum mechanics but also provides completely independent mechanisms to simultaneously determine the experimental parameters required for the quantum-mechanical prediction (see the preceding section and Fry and Walther, 1996). 5. Enforcement of the Locality Condition
The remaining loophole, the enforcement of Einstein locality (also known as the communication loophole), can be closed by employing electrooptic modulators (EOM). Specifically, the EOM, together with a polarizing beamsplitter, can change the propagation direction of the excitation laser beam and hence the component of spin angular momentum being observed. Rough estimates show that a separation between our detectors of approximately 5 m will be necessary to close the locality loophole in our setup. These estimates include allowances for selecting a random number, switching the EOM, and firing the analysis detection lasers. The distance could be reduced by using picosecond laser systems for the dissociation/ionization process.
VI. Contrasts Between Photon- and Atom-Based Experiments Whenever one is testing a fundamental concept, it is vital to do the study over as wide a range of the parameters as possible. (As an extreme example, one frequently refers to separate laws of conservation of energy and conservation of mass, but we know neither is conserved by itself. In fact, we really have conservation of mass-energy, the conversion between the two being E = mc2; this becomes apparent in studies at high energies.) The experiment with 199Hgdimers described here dramatically extends the parameter range over which Bell inequalities can be tested. With respect to
22
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walther
previous Bell inequality experiments that have been done with photons, the experiment with 199Hgdimers has four different, but related, important aspects. (1) Massive particles versus massless photons. Nonrelativistic massive particles obey the nonrelativistic Schrodinger equation. Photons are very different; see Chapter 1 of Scully and Zubairy (1997) for an excellent discussion. They point out, “The interference and diffraction of matter waves is the essence of quantum mechanics. However the corresponding behavior in light is described by the classical Maxwell equations.” In his classic text, Kramers (1958) says, “one can not speak of particles in a radiation field in the same sense as in the (nonrelativistic) quantum mechanics of systems of point particles.” Clearly, a Bell inequality test with massive particles is in a regime very different from those with photons. ( 2 ) Lifetime of the entangled state. In photon experiments the entangled state generally exists for only a few nanoseconds before being annihilated at the detectors. Even in the recent experiment of Gisin et al. (Tittel et al., 1998), it existed for only 30 microseconds. Because the 199Hgatoms travel relatively slowly compared to the speed of light, the two atom entangled state must continue to exist at large spatial separations for approximately a millisecond in our initial experiment (and for tens of milliseconds in later experiments). This is an increase of several orders of magnitude in the time scale for an entangled state lifetime. ( 3 ) Fermion versus boson. The photon is a boson; a 199Hgatom is a fermion. Thus the new Bell inequality experiment will be done with particles that obey completely different quantum statistics. (4)Inside versus on rhe light cone. Any massive particle must have a velocity less than the velocity of light and must therefore trace out a world line inside the light cone. By contrast, photons travel with the speed of light and must therefore always be on the light cone. Einstein locality plays a crucial role in the Bell inequalities, so experimental tests done well inside the light cone are especially important compared to all the photon tests done on the light cone. In particular, because photons travel with the velocity of light in any reference frame they cannot be strictly localized, and the concept of causality becomes somewhat muddled. There is nothing in quantum mechanics to suggest that any of these four aspects might lead to a classical-like interpretation and to statistical results that satisfy a Bell inequality; for example, there is no suggestion of a time scale or distance scale for the validity of quantum mechanics. On the other hand, there is nothing in non-relativistic classical mechanics to suggest that conservation of energy is not a stand-alone, fundamental law. Thus it behooves us to test the Bell inequalities in very different regimes from those
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
23
of previous studies. The entangled state produced by dissociation of 199Hg2 dimers provides exactly this opportunity.
VII. Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger A quite different approach to testing the issues brought forward by Einstein, Podolsky, and Rosen was proposed several years ago by Greenberger, Horne, and Zeilinger (GHZ) (Greenberger et al., 1989, 1990). The concept is based on the entanglement of more than two particles. They showed that classical theories cannot mimic the strong correlations predicted by quantum mechanics for many-particle entangled systems. Hence it is unnecessary to test an inequality in these systems; rather, a single measurement of the strong correlation is, in principle, sufficient to disprove LHV theories. A GHZ experiment would be definitive and nonstatistical in the sense that no statistical quantities such as rates must be compared; simple observation of the strong correlations is sufficient. The existence of the strong correlations must, of course, still be indisputably established outside any systematic experimental errors. The main problem with the GHZ approach has been the difficulty of producing an entanglement of three or more particles. One possibility is the above-mentioned micromaser technique. Earlier this year, another approach by a group at Los Alamos (Laflamme et al., 1998) succeeded in producing a GHZ state using NMR. They produced an entanglement between the proton and carbon spins in trichloroethylene. However, the requirement for a test is that the entangled particles be spatially separated; the microscopic separation in a molecule is not sufficient. There exists a proposal by Zeilinger's group (Zeilinger et al., 1997) to generate a three-particle entangled state from two entangled photon pairs produced by nonlinear down-conversion. Using an arrangement of polarizing beamsplitters and h/2 plates as well as a beamsplitter, they combine the photon pairs of each source so that there will be some events in which they measure a coincidence among all four outputs. For such events a GHZ state has been generated. Recently, they succeeded in implementing this scheme (Bouwmeester et al., 1999). But instead of two distinct sources, Zeilinger and coworkers used a single 200-fs uv pulse that occasionally produces two entangled pairs of photons by down-conversion in a BBO crystal. On average, they created and detected two entangled pairs every 150 seconds. This is, however, sufficient to demonstrate the generation of a separated multiparticle entanglement. Unfortunately, they have not yet measured a strong correlation, because proving the existence of the GHZ state results in its annihilation.
24
Edward S. Fry and Thomas Walrher
VIII. Applications The properties of entanglement and the physics involved have attracted interest in recent years far beyond the foundations of quantum mechanics. Quantum information, particularly quantum teleportation, quantum cryptography, and quantum computation, rely heavily on the concept of entanglement. In quantum communication schemes, two people, generally referred to as Alice (transmitter) and Bob (receiver), exchange information by the use of quantum entanglement. Recent review articles on quantum information are available; see the review article by Steane (1998) or the collection of articles in Physics World (Rodgers, 1998). Last year, the groups of Zeilinger and DeMartini independently achieved the quantum teleportation of photons (Bouwmeesteret al., 1997;Boschi et af., 1998). Though not comparable to the (unrealistic) teleportation of macroscopic objects in the manner of “Star Trek,” the present experiments demonstrate some startling possibilities. In both experiments, however, the capability of teleportation was subject to restrictions. In the Zeilinger experiment, the successful teleportation was shown by a coincidence measurement of two photo detectors at the emitter (Alice) and receiver ends (Bob). This approach both limited the efficiency of teleportation to 25% and led to an immediate annihilation of the teleported photon, such that no further measurements could be performed on it. In the case of DeMartini’s experiment,the state of the input photon was not arbitrary. A major advance in teleportation was recently made by Kimble and coworkers. They succeeded in teleporting coherent photon states of the radiation field by means of squeezed state entanglement - that is, teleporting states with continuous variables (Furusawa et af., 1998). They achieved a teleportation efficiency of 100% and were able to measure the fidelity of the teleportation by comparing the parameters of the teleported state with the original. Buttler and coworkers have for the first time brought quantum cryptography to the outside world (Buttler et al., 1998). They delivered a quantum cryptography key over the distance of 1 km in a free-space outdoor environment rather than in a fiber/laboratory setup. This is a first tentative step toward using quantum cryptography in satellite communications and the like.
IX. Outlook and Perspectives We hope to have shown, with this review article, that quantum mechanics still poses open questions and suggests the possibility of future applications. Quantum mechanics, even 50 years after its formulation, is still full of surprises.
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
25
To summarize our molecular dissociation EPR experiment, we have shown that the Hg isotope 199Hgis ideally suited for a loophole-free test of the Bell inequalities. It is possible to generate an entangled singlet state of spin-1/2 nuclei by dissociating a 199Hg2dimer using a stimulated Raman transition. Especially important features are the extremely long lifetimes (milliseconds) for the entangled states that can be achieved with atoms as compared to those achieved with photons (nanoseconds to microseconds); the production of an entanglement of fermions rather than bosons; the entanglement of massive rather than massless particles; and the fact that the test is done inside the light cone rather than outside. In addition, because nuclear spins are being observed, the system is relatively robust with respect to external influences, and photo-ionization provides the high detection efficiencies necessary to close the detection loophole. In conclusion, Bohm’s original gedankenexperiment is now becoming an experimental reality.
X. Acknowledgments This research was supported by the Robert A. Welch Foundation grant No. A-1218 and by the National Science Foundation grant PHY-9732459. The authors thank John Clauser and Marlan Scully for many helpful discussions on the theory and for encouragement, as well as Robert Kenefick, Remus Nicolaescu, and Cechan Tian for their experimental contributions and active participation.
XI. References Alley, C. O., and Shih, Y. H. (1987). “A new type of EPR experiment.” In M. Namiki (Ed.). Proc. Inr. Symp. Foundations of Quantum Mechanics, p. 47. Aspect, A,, Dalibard, I., and Roger, G. (1982). Phys. Rev. Lett. 49, 1804. Aspect, A,, Grangier, Ph., and Roger, G. (1982). Phys. Rev. Let?. 49,91. Bell, J. S. (1964). Physics I , 195. Reprinted in J. S. Bell. (1987). Speakable and unspeakable in quantiim mechanics. Cambridge University Press (New York). Benetti, P., Fossati, G., Rosella, M., Tornaselli, A., and Sigon, F. (1991). “Design and test of a Daly-type detector for RIMS.” In S. Hurst (ed.) Conf on Res. Ionization Spectroscopy, p. 373. Institute of Physics. Bohrn, D. (1951). Quantum physics. Prentice-Hall (New York). Boschi, D., Branca, S., DeMartini, F., Hardy, L., and Popescu, S . (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 1121-1 125. Bouwmeester, D., Pan, J.- W., Mattle, K., Eible, M., Weinfurter, H., and Zeilinger, A. (1997). Nature 390, 575. Bouwrneester, D., Pan, J.- W., Daniel], M., Weinfurter, H., and Zeilinger, A. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82. 1345-1349.
26
Edward S.Fry and Thomas Walther
Buttler, W. T., Hughes, R. J., Kwiat, P. G., Lamoreaux, S. K.,Luher, G. G., Morgan, G. L., Nordjolt, J. E., Peterson, C. G., andsimmons, C. M. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81,3283-3286. Cantrell, C. D., Scully, M. 0. (1978). Phys. Reports 3,499-508. Chiao, R. Y., Kwiat, P. G., and Steinberg, A. M. (1994). In B. Bederson and H. Walther (Eds.). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Physics, vol. 34, p. 35. Academic Press (New York). Clauser, J. F., and Home, M. A. (1974). Phys. Rev. D 10, 526. Clauser, J. F., and Shimony, A. (1978). Rep. Pmg. Phys. 41, 1881. Clauser, J. F., Home, M. A., Shimony, A., and Holt, R. A. (1969). Phys. Rev. Lett. 23,880. Clauser, J. F. (1976). Phys. Rev. Lett. 36, 1223. Duncan, A. J., and Kleinpoppen, H. (1988). In F. Selleri (Ed.). Quantum mechanics versus local realism - The Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen experiment, chapter 7, pp. 175-218. Plenum Press (New York). Eberhard, P. H. (1993). Phys. Rev. A 47,747-750. Einstein, A., Podolsky, B., and Rosen, N. (1935). Phys. Rev. 47,777. Englert, B.- G., Loffler, M., Benson, 0.. Varcoe, B., Weidinger, M., and Walther, H. (1998). Fort. Phys. 46, 897-926. Franson, J. D. (1989). Phys. Rev. Lett. 62, 2205-2208. Freedman, S. J., and Clauser, J. F. (1972). Phys. Rev. Lett. 28,938. Freyberger, M., Aravind, P. K., Home, M. A., and Shimony, A. (1996). Phys. Rev. A 53, 1232. Fry, E. S. (1973). Phys. Rev. A 8, 1219. Fry, E. S., and Thompson, R. C. (1976). Phys. Rev. Lett. 37, 465. Fry, E. S., and Walther, Th. (1996). In R. S. Cohen and J. Stachel (Eds.). Experimental metaphysics - Quantum mechanical studies for Abner Shimony, vol. I. Kluwer Academic (Dordrecht ). Fry, E. S., Walther, Th., and Li, S. (1995). Phys. Rev. A 52,4381. Fry, E. S., Walther, Th., and Kenefick, R. (1998). Physica Scripta "6.47-51. Furusawa, A., Ssrensen, J. L., Braunstein, S. L., Fuchs, C. A., Kimble, H. J., and Polziak, E. S. (1998). Science 282, 706-709. Greenberger, D. M., Home, M. A,, and Zeilinger, A. (1989). In M. Kafatos (Ed.).Bell's theorem, quantum theory, and conceptions of the universe, pp. 73-76. Kluwer Academic (Dordrecht ). Greenberger, D. M., Home, M. A., Shimony, A., and Zeilinger, A. (1990). Am. J. Phys. 58.1 13 1. Hagley, E., Maitre, X., Nogues, G., Wunderlich, C., Brune, M., Raimond, J. M., and Haroche, S. (1997). Phys. Rev. 79, 1-5. Hardy, L. (1998). Contemporary Phys. 39, 419429. Herzberg, G. (1950). Molecular spectra and molecular structure. D. Van Nostrand (Princeton, NJ). Huelga, S. F., Ferrero, M., and Santos, E. (1994). Eumphys. Lett. 27, 181. Hurst, G. S., Payne, M. G., Kramer, S. D., and Young, J. P. (1 979). Rev. of Mod. Phys. 5 1,767. Kramers, H. A. (1958). Quantum mechanics. North-Holland (Amsterdam). Kwiat, P. G., Mattle, K., Weinfurter, H., Zeilinger, A., Sergienko, A. V., and Shih, Y.(1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 4337. Kwiat, P. G., Waks, E., White, A. G., Appelbaum, I., and Eberhard, Ph. H. (1998). quant-ph/ 9810003. Laflamme, R., Knill, E., Zurek, W. H., Catasti, P., and Mariappan, S. V. S. (1998). Phil. Trans. R. SOC. Land. A 356, 1941-1947. Lo, T. K., and Shimony, A. (1981). Phys. Rev. A 23,3003-3012. Mohrhoff, U. (1999). Am. J. of Phys. 67, 330-335. Nicolaescu, R., Walther, Th., and Fry, E. S. (1998). Number CTuM69 in CLEO '98, p. 179. OSA.
FUNDAMENTAL TESTS OF QUANTUM MECHANICS
27
Nussenzveig, P., Bemardot, F., Brune, M., Hare, J., Raimond, J. M., Haroche, S., and Gawlik, W. (1993). Phys. Rev. A 48, 3991-3994. Oliver, B. J., and Stroud, C. R. (1987). J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 4, 14261428. Ou, Z. Y., and Mandel, L. (1988). Phys. Rev. Lett. 61,50. Pearle, P. M. (1970). Phys. Rev. D 2, 1418. Pipkin, F. M. (1978). In D. Bates and B. Bederson (Eds.). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Physics, vol. 14, p. 281. Academic Press (New York). Rodgers, P. (1998). Physics World (special issue), vol. 11, pp. 33-57. Santos, E. (1996). Phys. Lett. A 212, 10-14. Scully, M. O., and Zubairy, M. S. (1997). Quantum optics. Cambridge Univ. Press (New York). Shih, Y. H. (1999). In B. Bederson and H. Walther (Eds.). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Physics, vol. 41, p. 1. Academic Press (New York). Steane, A. (1998). Rep. Prog. Phys. 61, 117-173. Tittel, W., Brendel, J., Zbinden, H., and Gisin, N. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 3563-3566. Walther, Th., and Fry, E. S. (1997a). In M. Ferrero, E. Santos, and S. Huelga (Eds.). New developments on fundamental problems in quantum physics, vol. 81 of Fundamental theories ofphysics. Kluwer Academic (Dordrecht). Walther, Th., and Fry, E. S. (1997b). Zeitschcf: Nutu8orschung 52a, 20-24. (Proceedings of the workshop in honor of E.C.G. Sudarshan.) Walther, Th., Liao, Y., Nicolaescu, R., Pan, X. J., and Fry, E. S. (1998). Number CTuC6 in CLEO '98, p. 69. OSA. Weihs, G., Jennewein, Th., Simon, C., Weinfurter, H., and Zeilinger, A. (1998). Phys. Rev. 81(23), 5039-5043. Zeilinger, A. (1986). Phys. Lett. A 118(1), 1. Zeilinger, A., Home, M. A., Weinfurter, H., and Zukowski, M. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 3031-3034.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OPnCAL PHYSICS, VOL. 42
WAVE-PARTICLEDUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER STEPHAN DURR and GERHARD REMPE Fakultat fur Physik, Universitat Konstanz, Konstanz, Germany
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
................. .....................................
11. Experimental Setup
A. Atomic Beam B. Microwave Field . . . C. Internal State Prepara
............
....................
111. Bragg Reflection
.................
..............
A. Generalized Storing Scheme. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
X. Wigner Function .......................... XI. Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . MI. Acknowledgments .
29 33 33 34 35 35 36 36 42 42 45 48 48 49 50 52 54 51 60 60 62 64 65 69 69 69
I. Introduction Wave-particle duality means that a quantum object can exhibit either wave or particle properties, depending on the experimental situation. The wave nature gives rise to interference phenomena, whereas knowledge about the path taken by the object testifies to its particle nature. The crucial point is that it is impossible to observe wave and particle properties simultaneously. When wave-particle duality was introduced in the early days of quantum mechanics, many physicists felt uncomfortable about this concept and 29
Copyright ic, ?OW hy Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-003842-011SSN 104')-250X/00 $3O.(K)
30
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe
searched for ways around it. Einstein, for example, suggested (Bohr, 1949) obtaining information about the way of a photon through a double-slit apparatus by measuring the recoil given to a collimation slit mounted in front of the double slit. He claimed that in this arrangement, an interference pattern and the photon’s way could be observed simultaneously. Bohr’s refutation (Bohr, 1949) of this gedunkenexperiment elucidates the principle of complementarity: He pointed out that the observation of the recoil requires a movable slit with a very well-defined initial momentum. But in such an arrangement, Heisenberg’s position-momentum uncertainty relation predicts such a large position uncertainty of the slit that the interference pattern is smeared out. Hence one can either use a fixed slit to obtain interference fringes or use a movable slit to perform a which-way measurement. Historically, this BohrEinstein dialogue was one of the landmarks of the development and understanding of quantum mechanics. Quantum mechanics enters Bohr’s argument only at one point: where Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation is employed. The importance of the uncertainty relation in which-way experiments is also illustrated in Feynman’s light microscope (Feynman et al., 1965). In this gedunkenexperiment, electrons are illuminated immediately after they pass through a double slit with slit separation d . The position of the electron can be determined from the scattered light with an accuracy of the order of the light wavelength, Az M h. Hence the uncertainty relation implies that after the scattering process, the electron’s momentum uncertainty is of the order of Ap, M h/h. The microscopic origin of the momentum disturbance is the photon recoil, as already pointed out by Heisenberg (1927). For h < d, a which-way measurement is performed, but the photon recoil destroys the interference fringes. On the other hand, for h > d, the photon recoil is too small to wash out the fringes, but the electron’s way cannot be determined because of diffraction. Feynman concluded that “if an apparatus is capable of determining which hole the electron goes through, it cannot be so delicate that it does not disturb the pattern in an essential way. No one has ever found (or even thought of) a way around the uncertainty principle” (Feynman et al., 1965). An experimental realization of Feynman’s light microscope is very difficult, because precise knowledge about the way of the particle through the interferometer must be obtained with high efficiency - a challenging task. Nevertheless, several steps in that direction have been made in the field of atom interferometry (Berman, 1997). Atoms are ideal test objects, because their internal structure gives rise to a large cross section for the interaction with near-resonant light. This makes it possible to investigate the influence of the spontaneous emission of a photon onto atomic interference patterns. With this aim, several experiments have been performed recently (Pfau et al., 1994; Clauser and Li, 1994; Chapman et ul., 1995). They clearly demonstrate the
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
31
change of an interference pattern as a result of photon recoil, but which-way information was not acquired. The gedankenexperiments discussed above emphasize the importance of Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation in which-way experiments. However, in 1991, Scully, Englert, and Walther raised the question whether wave-particle duality is always enforced by the uncertainty relation. They discussed a new gedankenexperiment, in which the way of each atom through a double slit is determined using quantized microwave fields as which-way detectors. In this scheme, no net momentum is transferred to the atom during the interaction with the which-way detector, so the loss of interference fringes is not related to the uncertainty relation. Instead, entanglement- or more general-correlations between the which-way detector and the atomic motion destroy the interference. This new explanation for the loss of interference represents a substantial development, because it no longer refers to classical concepts, such as momentum transfer. Instead, an exclusive quantum feature entanglement - is employed. Of course, entanglement or correlations are present in any which-way experiment. But in the foregoing examples, the mechanical effects of the which-way detector on the particle’s motion can explain the loss of interference as well so that the effect of the correlations is hidden. Hence these schemes cannot be regarded as a proof that correlations alone are sufficient to destroy the interference. Experimental indications for the absence of interference due to correlations can be found in different fields of physics. Such correlations are, for example, responsible for the lack of ground state quantum beats in time-resolved fluorescence spectroscopy (Haroche, 1976). Another example is correlated photon pairs created in parametric down-conversion crystals. If a “signal” photon can be generated along two different paths, then interference cannot be observed because of the entanglement with the “idler” photon (Zou et al., 1991; Herzog et al., 1995). In a further experiment (Eichmann et al., 1993), the interference of light scattered from two trapped ions was investigated. Here, which-way information could be stored in the ions’ internal states, leading to a loss of interference. Correlations also play an important role in neutron interferometers: Flipping the neutron spin selectively in one arm of the interferometer destroys the interference pattern (Rauch et al., 1975; Badurek et al., 1986). The correlation between the which-way detector and the particle’s motion need not always be perfect. Instead, the degree of correlation can be varied so that a continuous transition between a wave and a particle picture is possible. In this intermediate regime, one obtains only incomplete which-way information and retains interference fringes with a reduced visibility. Stimulated by the first theoretical work by Wooters and Zurek (1979), investigators (Jaeger et al., 1995; Englert, 1996) recently found a fundamental limit, connecting
32
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rernpe
the fringe visibility with the maximum obtainable amount of which-way information. The reduction of the visibility due to the storage of incomplete which-way information has been observed in several experiments; for example, changing the polarization of the light field in only one arm of a Mach-Zehnder interferometer reduces the fringe visibility (Schwindt et al., submitted). But this effect can be described in terms of purely classical electrodynamics that is, without entanglement. This is different in the down-conversion experiments we have mentioned, which are based on entangled quantum states. In one of these experiments (Zou et al., 1991), the degree of correlation between the “signal” and the “idler” photon could even be tuned, so that interference fringes with a reduced visibility were created. In another experiment (Brune et al., 1996), transitions between atomic Rydberg states were induced with two Ramsey fields (Ramsey, 1950), and interference fringes were observed in the excitation probability. Between the two Ramsey fields, the atoms passed through a high-quality microwave cavity, thereby shifting the phase of the intracavity field depending on the atom’s internal state. A measurement of this phase shift could (at least in principle) reveal in which state the atom was. By tuning the magnitude of the phase shift, one could adjust the degree of correlation, leading to reduced visibility of the Ramsey fringes. Finally, an Aharanov-Bohm experiment with electrons in a semiconductor was performed recently (Buks et al., 1998). The fringe contrast was gradually reduced by performing a weak measurement of the particle’s way through the interferometer. Technically, this was achieved by coupling a quantum dot in one arm of the interferometer to a quantum point contact. In this article, we will describe several experiments with a novel atom interferometer. Bragg reflection from a standing light wave is used as a beamsplitter for atoms. The atomic beams are recombined with a second standing light wave, and a spatial interference pattern is observed in the far field. Which-way information can be stored in internal atomic states by adding a microwave field. This allows us to study the origin of quantummechanical complementarity (Diirr et al., 1998a). In addition, a quantum eraser can be realized. It is also possible to store incomplete which-way information and to perform a quantitative test of wave-particle duality (Diirr et af., 1998b). The article is organized as follows: After describing the experimental setup (Section 11), we discuss Bragg reflection (Section III), present the atom interferometer (Section IV), and discuss delayed-choice aspects (Section V). We then explain the mechanism used to store which-way information (Section VI) and investigate how its presence changes the interference pattern (Section VII). After discussing quantum-eraser measurements (Section VIII),
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
33
we report experiments where incomplete which-way information is stored (Section IX). Next, we illustrate the evolution of the wavefunction in the atom interferometer using the Wigner function (Section X) and finally give a conclusion (Section XI).
11. Experimental Setup A. ATOMICBEAM Figure 1 shows a scheme of the experimental setup, which has been described in more detail by Kunze et al. (1997a). Light forces (Adams and Riis, 1997) are employed to load a magneto-optical trap (MOT) with 85Rb atoms from background vapor. After trapping, the atoms are cooled further in optical molasses to a temperature of about 10 pK.Then the cloud of atoms is released by turning off the laser light. Freely falling through the apparatus,
20cm
photomultiplier
galvo
detection beam
Fici. 1. Scheme of the experimental setup. *'Rb are atoms dropped from a magneto-optical trap. They form a pulsed atomic beam, which is collimated by two mechanical slits. Then the atoms pass the interaction region containing a standing light wave and a microwave resonator. In the far field, the spatial distribution of atoms is monitored via laser-induced fluorescence.
34
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe TABLE I ATOMIC BEAM.
PARAMETERS OF THE
Longitudinal velocity in the interaction region de Broglie wavelength in the interaction region Time of flight from the (effective) source to the interaction region Time of flight from the interaction region to the detection region Width of the upper collimation slit Width of the lower collimation slit Transverse momentum width after collimation
vx = 2.0mI.s = 2.3nm
hde
t,,,,e rdef
= 176ms
= 92111s
O.lOmm 0.45 mm
Anmm
= 0.25
Fez4
Fe=3
5p2P3/2
Fe=2 F e z1
cycling
1
g: : ; : : ;
I repumping
I
FIG.2. Level scheme of the D2 line of 85Rb. The ground state 5s 2S1/2 is split into two hyperfine components with total angular momentum Fg = 2 and Fg = 3. The excited state 5p 2P3/2is split into four hyperfine components with total angular momentum F, = I , . . . ,4. The magnetic sublevels are not shown.
the cloud forms a pulsed atomic beam, which is collimated by two mechanical slits. The first slit, 1 cm below the MOT, is 0.1 mm wide, and the second slit, M 20cm below the MOT, is 0.45 mm wide. Table I lists the parameters of the atomic beam, and Fig. 2 shows a scheme of the relevant atomic levels. B. MICROWAVE FIELD The interaction region, right below the second slit, contains a standing light wave inside a microwave resonator. The field inside the resonator can be excited with an antenna powered by an external microwave source. The interaction time with the microwave field is controlled by switching the input power on and off. The microwave oscillates at a frequency of OM^ M 2x x 3.035 GHz and induces transitions between the Fg = 2 and the Fg = 3 hyperfine components of the atomic ground state (see Fig. 2). Only Am, = 0
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
35
transitions are induced, because the oscillating magnetic field is parallel to an externally applied 100 pT magnetic bias field. In addition, this bias field Zeeman-shifts out of resonance all transitions except Fg = 2, mF = 0 tf Fg = 3, mF = 0. C. INTERNALSTATEPREPARATION After release from the optical molasses, most of the atoms are optically pumped into the Fg = 3, mF = 0 state using linearly polarized light, as described by Kunze et al. (1997a). In the interaction region, these atoms are transferred to the Fg = 2,mF = 0 state with a microwave 7c pulse. Some atoms remain in the Fg = 3, mF # 0 states even after optical pumping. They are subsequently pushed away using a laser beam resonant with the Fg = 3 tf F, = 4 “cycling” transition, a method similar to that described by Gibble and Chu (1993). After scattering M 50 photons, these atoms no longer reach the detection region, whereas atoms “hidden” in the Fg = 2 state continue their way downward. D. STANDING LIGHTWAVE The standing light wave is created by retroreflecting a laser beam from a flat mirror mounted inside the microwave resonator. The interaction time of the atoms with the standing light wave is controlled by switching the light on and off. The atoms fall through the interaction region with a velocity of only v, = 2.0 m/s. This allows us to perform the whole interferometer experiment with only one standing light wave, which is switched on and off twice. In order to illuminate all atoms with light of approximately the same intensity, we choose a large laser beam waist of ox= 10 mm (l/e2 radius of intensity) in the vertical direction and of my = 8.4 mm in the horizontal direction. However, the finite temperature of the atomic cloud after release from the optical molasses leads to an expansion of the cloud. During the flight to the interaction region, the cloud size increases to about 15 mm (full width at half maximum, FWHM) in the vertical direction. It is therefore impossible to illuminate all atoms with a pulsed light field of the same intensity. Therefore, we select a small fraction of the atoms with a vertical size of 2 mm by gating the photomultiplier signal (see below) only 1 ms. The intensity variations of the standing light wave due to the finite laser beam waist, as seen by these atoms, are less than 6% root mean square (rms). Additionally, the transverse profile of the standing wave exhibits intensity wiggles caused by imperfections in the optical elements. We measured the total transverse intensity variations to be 12%nns.
36
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rernpe
E. FLUORESCENCE DETECTION
The atomic position distribution is observed 45 cm below the MOT, in the far field of the interaction region. For that purpose, the atoms are excited with a resonant laser beam, and the fluorescence photons are detected with a photomultiplier. Before entering the vacuum chamber, the laser beam is reflected from a mirror mounted on a galvo drive. Tilting the galvo allows us to scan the laser beam along the (horizontal) z-direction and to monitor the atomic position distribution. The detection laser beam propagates nearly parallel to the (horizontal)y-axis and has an elliptic Gaussian profile. Its horizontal waist of oz= 50 pm determines the position resolution of the detection system. Depending on the frequency of the detection laser, atoms in different internal states can be detected. To detect only atoms in the Fg = 3 state, we tune the frequency of the detection laser into resonance with the Fg = 3 * F, = 4 “cycling” transition. To detect atoms in the Fg = 2 and Fg = 3 state simultaneously, we add a “repumping” laser beam resonant with the Fg = 2 * F, = 3 transition. In principle, only atoms in the Fg = 2 state could be detected by applying a Fg = 2 H F, = 1 laser, but in practice, offresonant optical pumping into the Fg = 3 state leads to a very low detection efficiency in this scheme. To circumvent this problem, an additional microwave n pulse is applied before the atoms leave the interaction region. A subsequent detection of atoms in the Fg = 3 state then corresponds to the direct detection of atoms in the Fg = 2 state. The state-selectivedetection of atoms constitutes an internal state measurement. This measurement, as discussed so far, projects onto the Fg = 2 or the Fg = 3 state. In order to project onto an arbitrary state of the internal degree of freedom, a microwave pulse with suitable pulse area is applied before the atoms leave the interaction region, and finally, only atoms in the Fg = 3 state are detected. To detect, for example, atoms in the superposition state (IFg = 2) IFg = 3))/&, a n/2 pulse is used.
+
111. Bragg Reflection In the field of atom optics (Adams et al., 1994), a variety of methods to split and recombine atomic beams have been proposed and demonstrated. One of these methods is based on Bragg reflection of atoms from a standing light wave (Martin et al., 1988; Kunze et al., 1996; Giltner et al., 1995a; Bernet et al., 1996).This method provides a beamsplitter, which is particularly useful for applications in atom interferometry, because it creates only two output beams without reducing the total atomic flux (in contrast to, for example, a mechanical double slit). This beamsplitter relies on the fact that nonresonant
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
37
FIG.3. Scheme of the beamsplitter for atoms. Atoms enter a standing light wave, which creates a periodic potential. From this periodic potential, a part of the atoms is Bragg-reflected, while the rest of the atoms is transmitted.
light creates a conservative potential for the atoms, which is called light shift or ac-Stark shift. This potential is proportional to the light intensity, which in a standing wave is a periodic function of position. It follows that the light-shift potential is periodic, too. A beam of atoms entering a standing light wave, as shown in Fig. 3, can be Bragg reflected from this periodic potential. This process is similar to Bragg reflection of X-rays from the periodic structure of a solid-state crystal, but with the role of matter and light exchanged. Here the light creates the periodic structure, from which the matter wave is reflected. In order to achieve Bragg reflection, the angle 8 under which the atomic beam enters the standing light wave must fulfill the Bragg condition
Here, the atomic de Broglie wavelength hm = h / p is determined by the atomic momentum, p; the order of reflection, n, is an integer; and the spatial period of the light intensity equals half a light wavelength, 1 = h/2. The Bragg condition can be rewritten as a condition for the transverse atomic momentum p z = p sin 9 (horizontal in Fig. 3), yielding p z = nhk, where k = 2n/h is the wave vector of the light. After Bragg reflection, the atomic beam is split into two components: one transmitted beam with unchanged momentum and one Bragg-reflected beam with the sign of the transverse momentum, p z , reversed. The reflectivity of this beamsplitter - that is, the fraction of reflected atoms - can be tuned by varying the parameters of the atom-light interaction. For applications in an atom interferometer,one usually prefers a reflectivity of 50%. Here we will calculate the probability amplitudes for reflection and transmission, Eqs. (1 1) and (12), in order to determine the parameters required to create a 5050 beamsplitter and in order to explore the phase shifts occurring
38
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe
in the beamsplitter. Readers who are not interested in this calculation may continue with Section IV. The calculation is based on the model introduced in Bernhardt and Shore (1981), Pritchard and Gould (1985), Kazantsev et al. (1990), Wilkins et al. (1991), Schumacher et af. (1992), Marte and Stenholm (1992), and Durr et al. (1996). We consider a two-level atom inside a standing light wave. The detuning of the light frequency from the atomic resonance is assumed to be so large that excitation and spontaneous emission can be neglected. In this regime, the atom experiences only the light-shift potential V ( z ) = 4hxcos2(kz). The potential depth is determined by the light-shift parameter x = R2/(4A), which depends on the peak traveling-wave Rabi frequency R and on the atom-light detuning A = Wlight - oat,. Note that x is proportional to the light intensity. Restricting the model to one dimension, we obtain the Hamiltonian
h 2 a2 H ( z ) = - - - 4ti~cos’(k~) 2m az2
+
where m is the mass of the atom. We assume that the initial atomic state is a plane wave with transverse momentum p z , which we normalize with respect to the photon momentum, tik, by writing
p z = nhk
(3)
Here, we do not restrict n to be an integer. This makes it possible to investigate the influence of deviations from the exact Bragg condition. The corresponding atomic momentum state is denoted by In). Using cos2(kz) = (2 exp exp(2ikz)}/4, we find (-2ikz)
+
+
where orec = hk2/(2m) is the recoil frequency. Equation (4) shows that the light couples momentum states with a momentum difference of 2hk. This can easily be explained, because a standing wave consists of two counterpropagating traveling waves. An atom can absorb a photon out of one of these traveling waves, followed by an induced emission into the other traveling wave. This Raman-like two-photon process transfers two photon momenta to the atom. Alternatively, an induced emission into the same traveling wave can occur so that the atomic momentum remains unchanged. This process is already possible in a single traveling light wave and gives rise to an energy
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
39
shift, namely the light shift hx. In the standing wave, the light shifts of the two traveling waves add up and create the term 2hxln) in Eq. (4). In the following, we focus on first-order Bragg reflection-that is, n M 1 -and include small deviations from the exact Bragg resonance:
n = 1+An
with
/ A n [ < <1
(5)
+
According to Eq. (4), the initially populated momentum state 11 An) is coupled to the states {. . . , I - 3 An), I - 1 An), 11 An), 13 An), . . .}. Whereas the states I - 1 An) and 11 An) are nearly degenerate, the kinetic energies of the states 13 An) and 11 An) differ by M 8h0,,. We << 80, - where this consider the case of weak coupling - that is mismatch between the kinetic energies prevents the transfer of significant population to the state 13 +An). A similar argument applies to the state I - 3 An). This allows us to perform a two-beam approximation; that is, we neglect the coupling to all momentum states except I - 1 An) and I 1 An). In a matrix representation with respect to the states
+ + +
+
+
+
+
+
+
1x1
+
+
the Hamiltonian is
The diagonal elements of this matrix contain the kinetic energies of the . off-diagonal elements represent momentum states and the light shift 2 h ~The the light-induced coupling between the states. The difference between the kinetic energies and their mean value are
We assume that the light intensity is switched on instantaneously at time t = 0, stays constant during the interaction, and is switched off instantaneously at time r = tpuise.The time evolution operator for such a single light pulse is UBS= exp(-iHrpulse/h).A short calculation using Eq. (7) yields
40
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
with the amplitude coefficients for transmission and reflection t l = cos(Rtp,l,/2)
+- i AEkin h a sin(Qtpulse/2)
rl = -i -~ 2Xi n (f2 t ~ , , ~ ~ ~ / 2 )
0
(11) (14
the Pendellosung frequency
and an overall phase shift due to the light-shift terms in the diagonal elements of H in Eq. (7),
This yields the probabilities for reflection and transmission
and, of course,
The first factor in Eq. (15) is a Lorentzian as a function of An and describes the finite acceptance angle for Bragg reflection. This has been investigated experimentally in Durr and Rempe (1999). For atoms entering the standing light wave exactly at the Bragg resonance - that is, An = 0 - the second factor describes a sinusoidal oscillation as a function of tpulse(or x), which is called Pendellosung (Martin et al., 1988; Kunze et al., 1996; Durr et al., 1996; Durr and Rempe (1999); Giltner et al., 1995b; Ewald, 1917). Both effects, the finite acceptance angle and the Pendellosung, are visible in Fig. 4, which displays the atomic momentum distribution after Bragg reflection for different values of the laser power, P, of the standing light wave. The initial momentum distribution, visible for P = 0, is centered around p z M - hk. At P M 50 pW, atoms with a momentum sufficiently close to the Bragg condition are Bragg-reflected to p z M +hk. The fraction of Braggreflected atoms exhibits Pendellosung oscillations as a function of the laser
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
41
FIG.4. Bragg reffection of atoms from a standing light wave. The atomic momentum distribution after the interaction is shown for different values of the laser power, P , in the standing light wave. The initial momentum distribution (at P = 0) is centered around -hk. Atoms with a momentum sufficiently close to the Bragg condition can be first-order Braggreflected to f f i k . The fraction of Bragg-reflected atoms exhibits Pendellosung oscillations as a function of the laser power. The data were recorded with atoms falling through a continuous standing light wave with a vertical waist of ox= 35 pm, corresponding to an interaction time of x 17 ps (from Kunze et al., 1996).
power. In addition, the acceptance angle increases for larger values of the laser power. We conclude that a Bragg beamsplitter allows full control over both the reflection probability and the momentum width of the reflected beam. In particular, the acceptance angle can be adjusted by varying the light-shift parameter, x. This makes it possible to match the momentum width of the Bragg resonance to the momentum width of the incoming atomic beam. The latter amounts to An = k 0.25 (see Table I), so that according to Eq. ( 1 3 , light fields with 1x1 >> 0.5 o, are required. Taking into account that the two-beam M 0.7 approximation is valid for small values of 1x1 only, light pulses with orec are applied in the experiment. The pulse duration, tpulse,is chosen to fulfill = n/4, as is necessary to create a 5050 beamsplitter for the condition (x(tpulse atoms with An = 0. For these parameters, the reflection probability for atoms with An = 50.25 is 45%, sufficiently close to the desired value of 50%. Table I1 summarizes the parameters of the atom-light interaction.
1x1
42
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe TABLE 2 PARAMETERS OF THE ATOM-LIGHT INTERACTION.
Light wavelength Bragg angle Recoil velocity Recoil frequency Light shift parameter [see Eq. (2)] Duration of one Bragg pulse Separation between Bragg pulses (except Fig. 6b,c)
h = 780nm 9 = hde/h = 3 m a d ,v = 6.0mm/s 0 , = 2n: x 3.8kHz 1x1 PZ 0.7 om tpulsc = ~ / ( 4 l ~=l 45 ) w t X p = 105 ps
IV. The Atom Interferometer As shown in Fig. 5 , an atom interferometer can be realized with two Bragg beamsplitters. The first standing light wave splits the incoming atomic beam, A, into two beams, B and C. After free propagation during a time interval tsep, the two beams are shifted by a transverse distance d with respect to each other. Then a second standing light wave splits each atomic beam again into two components. Now two beams, D and E, are traveling to the left, while beams F and G are traveling to the right. In the far field, each pair of overlapping beams produces a spatial interference pattern. The experiment employs only one standing light wave, which is switched on and off twice, so that the vertical axis in Fig. 5 represents time rather than distance. For first-order Bragg reflection, the transverse distance
is determined by the separation time tsep and the recoil velocity v,, = tik/m. This scheme is similar to a double-slit experiment with slit separation d. This analogy suggests a fringe period of Ap = h/d in momentum space. In the following two subsections, we will discuss the validity of this naive expectation. Again, readers may wish to skip these calculations and directly continue with Section 1V.C. A. PLANE WAVETHEORY With the results of the preceding section, the shape of the fringe pattern can be calculated. We begin by writing down the time evolution operator describing the free flight between the two light pulses during the time interval tsep:
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
43
FIG.5. Scheme of the atom interferometer. Bragg reflection from a standing light wave splits the incoming atomic beam, A, into two beams, B and C. A second standing light wave splits the beams again. In the far field, a spatial interference pattern is observed (Reprinted by permission from Durr et al., 1998a, Nature, Macmillan Magazine Ltd.)
where
is the phase difference that the two momentum states accumulate during the free flight because of the difference between their kinetic energies. In order to describe the complete interferometer, the time evolution operators corresponding to the two light pulses and to the free flight must be multiplied, which yields
Here, the amplitude coefficients for transmission and reflection are
44
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe
with tl and rl defined in Eqs. (11) and (12). The reflection amplitude in Eq. (22) is the sum of two terms. The fist term describes an atom that is transmitted through the first beam-splitter and reflected from the second beam-splitter. This term corresponds to beam E in Fig. 5. The second term corresponds to beam D. Defining y = 2argt1
(23)
that is, t l = It1 leiY/2,the relative phase between the two amplitudes in Eq. (22) is a y. The probabilities for reflection and transmission can easily be calculated, yielding
+
and, of course, 2 Ittotall
+
2 lrtotall
=1
(25)
For the parameters of our experiment, the factor 41rl1*1t11*in Eq. (24) varies between 1 and 0.99. This small variation can be neglected, yielding
+
The total reflection probability oscillates as a function of a y. In order to calculate the shape of the fringe pattern, we must evaluate the dependence of a and y on An. Whereas a is linear in An according to Eq. (19), the dependence of y on An is more complicated and must be determined from Eqs. (1 1) and (23). However, ]An1is small in the experiment, so y can be linearized in An. ~ l we ~ obtain ~ Using l ~ l t =~n/4,
For the parameters of our experiment, Eq. (27) differs less than 3% from the exact result. Whereas a is the relative phase shift, the momentum states accumulate because of their different kinetic energies during tsep, y takes into account the finite interaction time with the standing light waves, 2tpulse. Inserting Eqs. (19) and (27) into Eq. (26) yields
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
45
This is the central result of our calculation. The reflection probability oscillates sinusoidally as a function of An. This oscillation is due to interference between beams D and E. Depending on their relative phase, ct y, the interference is constructive or destructive. A similar argument applies to the interference between beams F and G, creating the corresponding antifringes in JttotalJ2according to Eq. (25). In the limit of long separation times (tsep >> tpulse), the period of the interference fringes as determined by Eq. (28) is An,,,, M 2x/(4~,,t,ep).This result is identical to Ap,,, = h / d as expected from the analogy to a double-slit experiment. We conclude by noting that from a mathematical point of view, the Hamiltonian Eq. (7) is analogous to that of a two-level atom driven by a nearresonant light field in the absence of spontaneous emission. In particular, the Pendellosung corresponds to Rabi oscillations, and the spatial fringes of the interferometer correspond to Ramsey fringes.
+
B. WAVEPACKET THEORY In every realistic situation, the initial state of the atom is a wave packet, not a plane wave. The state vector can be described, for example, in a rescaled momentum representation
I$)
(29)
= jdnJl(n)ln)
where $(n) is the wave function, and n = p,/hk is the rescaled transverse momentum, as in Eq. (3). In our experiment, the initial wave function, $in(n), is nonvanishing only in a small region centered around n = 1. From Eq. (20) the final wave function after the interaction with the standing light waves can be calculated, yielding
The corresponding momentum distribution is
Note that the cross term
+ 2)$:n(n)$in(n + 2)
(32)
ttota~(n)rtota~(n
and its complex conjugate vanish, because $in(n) is nonzero only in a small region with half-width An = 0.25, so the product (n)$in(n 2) is zero for all values of n.
$rn
+
46
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
The first term in Eq. (3 1) describes the right half of the interference pattern shown in Fig. 5 , and the second term describes the left half. The factor \ttotd(n)l2produces sinusoidal fringes according to Eqs. (25) and (28). The envelope of these fringes, l+in(n)[2,is determined by the collimation properties of the incoming beam. In the experiment, the spatial far-field distribution 1 + ( . ~ ) 1 ~ is observed. Within a Fraunhofer approximation, this would be determined by
where tdet is the time of flight from the interaction region to the detection region. The Fraunhofer approximation reflects the simple fact that an atom with transverse velocity nvrec travels the transverse distance z = n'llrectdet during tdet. In particular, the center of the reflected beam and that of the transmitted beam have a velocity difference of 2vreC,so the distance between them in the detector plane is 2Vrectdet = 1.1 mm. The Fraunhofer approximationis not strictly valid for the parameters of our experiment, because the time of flight from the source to the interaction region, t source, has to be taken into account, yielding
with
Each term in Eq. (34) describes one-half of the interference pattern, as in Eq. (31). The argument, n, in the transmitted part is similar to that in Eq. (33), but with fdet replaced by t,,,,, tdet. This reflects the fact that the atom already travels a transverse distance during its flight from the source to the interaction region. The reflected part is shifted with respect to the transmitted part by 2'Urectdet. Here tsource does not appear, because the change of the atomic transverse velocity by 2vrec takes place in the interaction region. It is easy to see that for tsource= 0, Eq. (34) reduces to Eqs. (31) and (33). In the experiment, the effective source of atoms is the cloud after optical
+
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
47
54-
2 3-
7
.-
C
a
w
2-
C
;1 0-1
1
0
position / mrn ............
a
E
3-
7
.c 2a
4-
5 8
1-
0.
1
I
I
-1
0
1
d
position / rnrn .............
.............
-1
0
1
position / mm FIG.6. Spatial fringe pattern in the far field of the interferometer. The solid line is a fit to the experimental data (circles). The dashed line shows the independently measured envelope. Parts (a), (b), and (c) were recorded for a splitting d = 1.3 pm, 3.1 pm, and 5.0 pm, respectively.
48
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
pumping. This is because the atomic momentum changes as a result of photon recoils. This has been taken into account in the value of t,,,,, in Table I. Note that in Eq. (34) we chose z = 0 at the source, whereas in the following, we will always choose z = 0 midway between the transmitted and reflected beams.
C. EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS Figure 6 shows spatial interference patterns observed in the far field. The data were obtained with tpulse = 45 ps. We chose tsep = 105 ps with d = 1.3 pm in Fig. 6(a), tsep = 255 ps with d = 3.1 pm in Fig. 6(b), and tSep= 415 ps with d = 5.0 pm in Fig. 6(c). The solid lines in Fig. 6 represent fits to the experimental data. The dashed lines represent the measured beam envelope, which consists of two broad peaks. The right peak is due to beams F and G, with a shape determined by the momentum distribution of the initial beam A. The left peak is a combination of beams D and E. It is a Bragg-reflected picture of the right peak. The fringe patterns under these two broad peaks are complementary;that is, the interference maxima in the left peak correspond to interference minima in the right peak, and vice versa, as expected from Eq. (25). The best-fit values for the fringe period are 620 pm, 320 pm, and 210 pm, respectively, in good agreement with the theoretical expectation from Eqs. (28) and (34), with tsource= 176 ms and fdet = 92 ms. The best-fit values for the visibility are (75 f l)%, (44 f l)%,and (18 f l)%,respectively. To the best of our knowledge, the pattern displayed in Fig. 6(a) has the highest visibility of spatial fringes ever observed in an atom interferometer. The reduction of the fringe visibility evident in Figs. 6(b) and 6(c) is due to the finite width of the detection laser beam and of the upper collimation slit.
V. Delayed Choice The experiments described so far have already revealed a lot about waveparticle duality. Let us first recall the simple setup considered in Section 111: Atoms pass through a single beamsplitter and are detected in the far field. Each detector click reveals whether the atom is in beam B or beam C. Of course, each individual atom gives a click for either beam B or C. We never find half an atom in beam B and the other half in beam C; that is, each atom has a well-defined way, corresponding to a particle picture. Let us now add the second beamsplitter. The creation of interference fringes can be explained only in a wave picture: The de Broglie wave is split into two components that are recombined later. Depending on the relative
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
49
phase shift accumulated in the meantime, the two components interfere constructively or destructively. To create the interference pattern, each atom must move along both ways simultaneously. The atom therefore exhibits a “split personality”: Sent through the interferometer, it exhibits wave properties, whereas detection behind a single beamsplitter reveals its particle character. In this context, von Weizsacker (1931 and 1941) and Wheeler (1978) raised the question of at what time the atom decides between behaving like a particle or like a wave. Does it happen when the atom passes through the first beamsplitter, or does the atom wait until the detection? Quantum mechanics gives a clear answer: The decision is made at the detection. In particular, the system is in a coherent superposition of the two possibilities before the wavefunction collapses in the measurement process. Whether this is correct can be tested in so-called delayed-choice experiments, where the setup allows one to insert or remove the second beamsplitter after the atom has already passed through the first beamsplitter. The first delayedchoice experiments were performed in light interferometers (Hellmuth et al., 1987). Our experiment offers the possibility of delayed choice without further modifications. Because a pulsed standing light wave is used, there is enough time to decide whether a second light pulse shall be applied after the first pulse is over. The simple fact that interference fringes are observed in our experiment therefore demonstrates that during the first light pulse, the atom cannot decide between particle-like and wave-like behavior, because it cannot “know,” at this moment, whether a second light pulse will be applied.
VI. Storing Which-Way Information In the foregoing discussion about delayed choice, the second beamsplitter is removed in order to determine whether the atom is in beam B or beam C. This is a very rude method, because it completely destroys the interferometer. It is, of course, much more interesting to look for the atom’s way inside the interferometer. For that purpose, a second physical system, called the which-way detector, must be added. With a suitable interaction, the state of the which-way detector must be modified depending on the way the atom takes. A later measurement on the which-way detector then reveals the atom’s way. We use two internal states of the atom as a which-way detector: the Fg = 2, mF = 0 state and the Fg = 3, mF = 0 state (see Fig. 2), which in the following discussion are labeled 12) and 13),respectively (see Fig. 7a). In this section, we will explain how which-way information can be stored in the
50
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
a)
c)
b)
le>-
T
Yight
13>OmW
12>-
w
FIG. 7. (a) Simplified level scheme. (b) Light-shift potentials as a function of position. (c) Sandwiching the first standing light wave between two microwave pulses stores which-way information in internal atomic states (see text). Shown here is the simplified case discussed in Eqs. (43) and (44).
population of these two states. We start by investigating how the properties of a single Bragg beamsplitter depend on the internal atomic state. A. BEAMSPLITTER FOR Two INTERNALSTATES
Only two atomic levels were considered in the preceding calculations. However, the level scheme of real atoms used in the experiment is somewhat more complex (see Fig. 2). We explicitly take into account the hyperfine splitting of the ground state, but we replace all the hyperfine states of the excited level by only one (virtual) state le) for the following reason. Consider an atom initially prepared in state 12). In a detuned standing light wave, each allowed transition from state 12) to an excited state creates its own light-shift potential for the atom. The total potential is obtained by simply adding the individual potentials. For light with a fixed frequency, the situation can therefore be modeled by assuming only one (virtual) excited state le). A similar argument applies to an atom in state 13). This justifies the use of the simplified level scheme shown in Fig. 7(a). Because the standing light wave does not induce any coupling between the states 12) and 13), Eq. (10) holds for each of the two internal states separately. But the light-shift parameter x is different for atoms in states 12) and (3).We denote the two values of the light shift by x2 and x3 and the corresponding values of t l , rl, and p by t2, r2, and p2, and t 3 , r3, p3, respectively. As indicated in Fig. 7(b), the light frequency is tuned between the 12) t+ Ie) resonance and le) resonance. For atoms in state 12),the light is red-detuned and the the 13) light shift is negative, whereas for atoms in state 13), the light is blue-detuned and the light shift is positive. In order to obtain the same reflectivity of the
-
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
51
beamsplitter for atoms in both internal states, the light frequency is carefully adjusted to give x 2 = -x3
Using Eqs. (1 1) through (14), this yields
(37)
p2 = - p3 and
t2 = t3
r2 = -r3
(38) (39)
It is useful to introduce the (not normalized) state vectors I+*), and so on, which denote the external degree of freedom for atoms in each beam in Fig. 5. The phases are chosen with respect to atoms in state 13). It follows that atoms in state 13) that passed through the first beamsplitter are described by the state vector
whereas for atoms in state 12), the state vector is
According to Eq. (14), p = 2xtpulser so a 5050 beamsplitter with x3tpulse = n/4 has p3 = -p2 = 7c/2 and e1(p3-pz) = -1. Equations (40) and (41 ) reveal that the reflection probability is independent of the internal atomic state. However, the amplitude of the wave function experiences two phase shifts depending on the internal state: 0
0
an overall phase factor ei(p3-p2) a n phase shift for atoms reflected in state 12)
The physical origin of these two phase factors is easy to understand. The first phase, p3 - p2, arises simply because the atoms travel in the internal-statedependent light-shift potential during tpulse. The accumulated phase shift increases linearly with tpulse. In contrast to this, the second phase shift is always n - independent of all parameters. An analogy for this n phase shift can be found in classical optics, where a light wave reflected from an optically thicker medium experiences a n phase shift, whereas reflection from an optically thinner medium or transmission into an arbitrary medium does not cause any phase shift. This is analogous to the situation in our experiment, because an atom in 12) sees a negative light-shift potential, corresponding to an optically thicker medium, whereas an atom in 13) sees a positive potential,
52
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe
corresponding to an optically thinner medium. Hence an atom experiences a n: phase shift only if it is reflected and in (2). In the following discussion, we show how this n phase shift can be used to store which-way information by applying a microwave field.
B. COMBINATION WITH THE MICROWAVE FIELD The microwave field is resonant with the 12) tf 13) transition and induces Rabi oscillations between these states. Using the basis { 12), 13)) for a matrix representation of the internal degree of freedom, the Rabi oscillations are described by the time evolution operator
=
(cos(cp/2) sin(cp/2)
- sin(cp/2)
cos(cp/2)
)
where we have chosen an interaction picture in which the states 12) and 13) have the same energy; a rotating-wave approximation has been performed, and cp denotes the pulse area. In order to convert the 7c phase shift in Eq. (41) into a population difference between the hyperfine states, two microwave n:/2 pulses are applied. They form a Ramsey scheme as shown in Fig. 7(c). The atom is initially prepared in state 12). Then a microwave n:/2 pulse is applied, converting the internal state to the superposition state ((3) 12))/& Next, the atom interacts with the standing light wave. Because of the superposition principle, the interaction can be described for the 12)-component and the 13)-component of the state vector separately. Using Eqs. (40) and (41), the state of the system after the interaction with the standing light wave becomes
+
where the phase factor ei(b3-P2) has been ignored for the moment. Equation (43) reveals that the n: phase shift effectively creates an entanglement between the internal and the external degrees of freedom of the atom. This entanglement is the key point for the storage of which-way information. Finally, the second microwave pulse acting on both beams (the transmitted and the reflected) converts the internal state of beam C to state 13), whereas beam B is converted to state -12). Thus the state vector after the pulse sequence shown in Fig. 7(c) is
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
-1 000
-500
0
500
53
1000
microwave detuning / Hz
50 40
E
v-
30
-1000
-500
0
500
1000
microwave detuning / Hz
-1000
500 microwave detuning / Hz
-500
0
1000
FIG. 8. Determination of the differential light shift via Ramsey spectroscopy. The number of atoms that are in beam C and simultaneously in state 13) is measured as a function of the detuning of the microwave frequency from the atomic resonance. Applying the pulse sequence shown in Fig. 7(c), parts (a), (b), and (c) were recorded at constant x with tpulse= 0 p,22 p,and 44 p,respectively. The fringe amplitude varies because of the Pendellosung. The phase shift of the Ramsey fringes reveals the differential light shift x3 - x2. From fits (solid lines) to the data, we obtained (x3 - x2)/(20,,) = 0.73 f0.02.
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
54
Equation (44) shows that the internal state is correlated with the way taken by the atom. The which-way information can be read out later by performing a measurement of the internal atomic state. The result of this measurement reveals which way the atom took. If the internal state is found to be 12), the atom moved along beam B; otherwise, it moved along beam C. So far, we have discussed only the effect of the K phase shift. For a 5050 beamsplitter the additional phase factor ei(p3-p2)equals - 1. Taking this into account, we find that Eq. (44) is modified to
so the states 12) and 13) are exchanged, but this is not essential. The storing process discussed here employs a standing light wave sandwiched between two microwave pulses. It is similar to the technique used by Kunze et al. (1994, 1997b). In passing, we note that the differential light shift x3 - x2 can be measured by scanning the microwave frequency o m around the atomic resonance, similar to the technique of Muller et al. (1995). Counting the number of atoms that are in beam C and simultaneously in state 13), we obtain Ramsey fringes as a function of o m ,as shown in Fig. 8. Without the standing light wave, the population of state 13) exhibits a maximum at the atomic resonance. With the standing light wave, the value of the microwave frequency at this maximum is shifted as a result of the phase difference p3 - pz. Because tpulse is known, the frequency shift of the Ramsey fringes reveals the differential light shift x3 - x2.
VII. Interferometer with Which-Way Information After considering a single beamsplitter, we now return to the complete interferometer. Sandwiching the first Bragg beamsplitter between two microwave 7t/2 pulses stores the which-way information in the internal atomic state, as described above. The state vector after the interaction with the first beamsplitter sandwiched between the two microwave pulses is given in Eq. (45). The second beamsplitter transforms this state vector into
Note that the second Bragg beamsplitter causes a K phase shift for but the population of the internal states remains unchanged. Alternatively, the second (instead of the first) standing light wave can be sandwiched between the two microwave 71/2 pulses. Then the internal state
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
55
contains the information whether the atom was reflected or transmitted in the second standing light wave. The corresponding state vector is
instead of Eq. (46). There is no fundamental difference between these two schemes. In both cases, which-way information is stored and can be read out by measuring the internal state. Clearly, once the atom’s way through the interferometer is known, the interference fringes must vanish. The experimental result is shown in Fig. 9(a): There are no fringes! In order to read out the which-way information, only atoms in state 13) were detected. All other parameters are the same as in Fig. 6(a). Note that the total number of atoms detected here is only half as large as in Fig. 6(a), because half of the atoms are in state 12) where they are not detected. We determined experimentally that the same result is obtained if only atoms in state 12) are detected. Quantum mechanics explains this loss of interference fringes in the following way: If the internal state of an atom is found to be 13), the state vector Eq. (46) collapses to
Because the beams D and F do not overlap in the far field, they do not interfere. The situation is analogous for atoms detected in state 12). But what happens if we do not read out the which-way detector? In this case, we do not have any knowledge about the atom’s way. Can we observe fringes now? No! The mere fact that which-way information is stored in the detector and could be read out destroys the interference fringes. Otherwise, one could first observe the fringes and later read out the detector, which would clearly be in conflict with wave-particle duality. The experimental result is shown in Fig. 9(b). The data were recorded with the same parameters as in Fig. 9(a), but atoms in both internal states were detected, so the which-way detector was not read out. Again, there are no fringes. To calculate the spatial distribution, P ( z ) , of atoms in the far field, the internal degree of freedom must be “traced out.” Using Eq.(46) this yields under the left peak of the envelope
because here the spatial wavefunctions +F(~) and $c(z) vanish. The first two terms describe the mean intensity under the envelope. Interference could
56
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
5
2
4
7 3 .-c 0 2
i -
c
;1
0 -1
0
1
position / m m
-1
0
1
position / m m FIG.9. Atomic far-field pattern obtained in the interferometer with which-way information stored in the internal atomic state. In part (a), only atoms in state 13) are detected so that the which-way information is read out, in contrast to part (b), where all atoms are detected. In both cases, the interference fringes are lost as a result of the storage of which-way information.
be created only by the last two terms, but they vanish because (2 13) = 0. Precisely the same entanglement that was required to store the which-way information is now responsible for the loss of interference. In other words, the correlations between the which-way detector and the atomic motion destroy the interference. This explanation for the loss of interference, as proposed by Scully, Englert, and Walther (1991), was criticized by the Auckland group (Storey et al., 1994). They argue that every realistic which-way detection scheme involves such a strong localization of the particle that the uncertainty relation
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
57
implies a momentum transfer sufficiently large to wash out the fringes. This point of view has been discussed controversially during the last five years (Englert et al., 1995; Storey et al., 1995; Wiseman and Harrison, 1995; Wiseman et al., 1997). An important issue in this discussion is “What constitutes a momentum transfer?” In addition to the classical notion of a momentum transfer probability distribution, the Auckland group also considers quantum amplitudes to describe momentum transfer. They find that this “quantum” momentum transfer cannot be less than that required by the uncertainty relation but that the “classical” momentum transfer can vanish. This is the case, for example, in the Scully-Englert-Walther scheme, in contrast to Einstein’s recoiling slit and Feynman’s light microscope, where “classical” momentum transfer occurs in line with the uncertainty principle. However, the results obtained by the Auckland group are valid only for schemes involving a mechanical double slit. It is a peculiarity of double-slit experiments that any which-way measurement yields position information simply because the two beams are spatially separated. The arguments advanced by the Auckland group do not apply to schemes with spatially overlapping beams, such as our experiment, where beams B and C (see Fig. 5) are never separated in position space; the width of these beams is 450 pm and their transverse shift, d, is only a few micrometers. Hence storing which-way information does not imply any storage of transverse position information. Therefore, Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation cannot imply any momentum transfer. Nevertheless, the interference fringes are lost. This clearly demonstrates that the entanglement alone is sufficient to destroy the interference pattern, as has been discussed in more detail by Diirr et al. (1998a).
VIII. Quantum Erasure One might argue that the loss of interference fringes that we have described is not surprising at all, because atoms in state 12) and atoms in state 13) are different objects, so they cannot interfere -just like apples and oranges. However, this analogy is too naive, as the following experiment will show. In order to test this argument, an observable of the internal state with eigenvectors
is measured. Clearly, the result of such a measurement does not reveal any which-way information. Even worse, the which-way information is lost in an irrecoverable way because of the collapse of the wavefunction. Hence the information is not only unknown but also no longer available. In
58
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
other words, this particular measurement erases the which-way information. This process is called quantum erasure, a concept proposed by Scully and Driihl(l982) and first demonstrated in neutron interferometry (Summhammer et a/., 1983). This complete loss of which-way information allows us to regain interference fringes. This can easily be shown by projecting the state vector Eq. (47) onto, for example, ((3) 12))/&, with the result
+
0
-1
i
position / mm
5
E
.____________. ______________
4
7-3 .-c f 2 3
8 1
0 -1
0
1
position / mm FIG. 10. Quantum erasure. The which-way information is stored in the internal state as in Fig. 9. In part (a) only atoms in state (13) 12))/fi were detected, in part (b) only atoms in state (13) - 12))/&. This internal-state measurement erases the which-way information. Both subensembles exhibit interference fringes.
+
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
59
Obviously, the collapse of the wavefunction destroyed the entanglement between the internal and external degrees of freedom. The far-field pattern of this subensemble of atoms is displayed in Fig. 10(a), where interference fringes are clearly visible. Figure 10(b) displays the position distribution of atoms detected in state (13) - 12))/&. The corresponding state vector is
Again, the far-field pattern exhibits interference fringes, but now the fringe contrast is reversed; that is, the positions of interference maxima and minima are exchanged with respect to Fig. 10(a). This is due to the R phase shifts between beams D and E and between beams F and G. We emphasize that both subensembles exhibit interference fringes. With apples and oranges, this would be impossible. Note, however, that interference fringes are regained only in the subensembles. The pattern of the full ensemble can be obtained as the (incoherent) sum of the patterns in Figs. 10(a) and 10(b). This sum is clearly identical to the pattern shown in Fig. 9(b), where no fringes are visible. Another interesting aspect of quantum erasure is that it relies on the coherent superposition of the possible ways. If the system was in a statistical mixture of the two possibilities, a quantum erasure experiment could not produce any interference fringes. From this point of view, the quantum eraser tests whether the interaction with the light and the microwave is a unitary evolution. Because the patterns shown in Fig. 10 have the same fringe visibility as the initial pattern, we conclude that no significant dissipation occurred. The concept of quantum erasure can be generalized to partial erasure of the which-way information. Consider, for example, the measurement of an observable with eigenstates
1 +cos-12), sin-13) 2 2 1
1 rl cos-13) - sin-12) 2 2
(53)
This measurement yields full which-way information for q = 0, whereas it completely erases the information for q = ~ / 2 For . intermediate values of 1, only partial erasure is achieved; that is, the internal-state measurement reveals incomplete which-way information. The two subensembles in such a partialerasure experiment exhibit interference fringes with a reduced visibility. Hence, partial wave and partial particle character of one and the same atom can be observed simultaneously.
60
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe
IX. Incomplete Which-Way Information Partial quantum erasure thus offers the possibility of a continuous transition between the wave character and the particle character of atomic subensembles. In all these schemes, full which-way information is stored, but the read-out process is more or less efficient. Alternatively, it is interesting to study the case where only incomplete which-way information is stored, so that full which-way information can never be obtained - no matter how the internal state is read out. In these intermediate situations, interference fringes with a reduced visibility are observed in the total ensemble, in contrast to partial quantum erasure, where only subensembles show interference.
A. GENERALIZED STORING SCHEME In the experiments described so far, which-way information was stored using two microwave pulses with area n/2. This scheme is now generalized to arbitrary pulse areas cp. It is sufficient to consider the case where the areas of both microwave pulses are identical. In this case, the state vector of an atom after passing through the first beamsplitter sandwiched between the two microwave pulses becomes
instead of Eq. (45).It follows that no which-way information is stored for cp = 0, whereas full which-way information is stored for cp = n/2. Obviously, incomplete which-way information is stored for intermediate values of cp. As a consequence, the atomic far-field distribution, Eq. (49), is modified to
Hence the visibility of the interference pattern is reduced by a factor lcos cp I with respect to the maximum value V,,, obtained for cp = 0. Figure 11 shows the spatial interference pattern obtained for different values of cp. All other parameters are the same as in Fig. 6(a). Obviously, the fringes are not shifted; only their visibility is reduced. For cp > n/2, the fringe contrast is reversed because cos cp is negative. Figure 12 displays the measured fringe visibility V as a function of cp, when all atoms are detected and the second standing light wave is sandwiched between the two microwave pulses. The solid line shows the theoretical
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
61
4
cn3 E
F
.r= 2 cn +
c = 1 0 0
0 -1
0
1
position / mm 4v)
E
3-
7
.-C 2cn * C
=
0
1-
0
O T
I
-1
I
0
I
1
position / mm FIG. 1 1 . Interference patterns recorded with a variable amount of which-way information stored. In part (a), with cp = n/3. the fringe visibility is reduced. In part (b), with cp = n, the visibility is restored and the fringe contrast is reversed.
prediction
with V,,, = 0.72 determined from the data point at cp = 0. The reduction of V,,, from unity is due to the finite sizes of the detection laser beam and the upper collimation slit and due to background counts in the fluorescence detection, as discussed in more detail in Durr et al. (1998b). The fact that an increase of the pulse area to cp = 7c fully restores the interference pattern provides further evidence for the conclusion that the
62
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe
60% 40%
20%
0%
0
n/4
n;/2
3d4
n
microwave pulse area cp FIG. 12. Visibility V as a function of the microwave pulse area cp. The solid line is the theoretical expectation Eq. (56).
reduction of the visibility in our experiment is due purely to entanglement, as already discussed in Section VII. B. DISTINGUISHABILITY OF THE WAYS Application of the generalized storing scheme stores incomplete which-way information. This means that from a later measurement of the internal atomic state, we cannot determine the atom’s way with certainty. Obviously, there is still a lack of information after this internal-state measurement. This lack of information can be quantified in various ways. One possibility is to employ the standard measure used in information theory, which is related to the concept of entropy in thermodynamics (see, for example, Shannon, 1948). But any monotonic function of this measure of information would also be an acceptable candidate. In the context of which-way experiments, the most convenient of these candidates is the “distinguishability of the ways,” which can be defined as follows. Assume that an observable W in the Hilbert space of the internal atomic state is measured, in order to read out the which-way information. Let p ( Wi, B) and p ( Wi, C) denote the joint probabilities that the eigenvalue Wi of the observable W is found and that the atom moved along beam B or C, respectively. If Wi is found, the best guess that one can make about the way is to opt for beam B if p(Wi,B) > p(Wi, C) and for beam C otherwise. This yields the “likelihood for guessing the right way”
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
63
LWdepends on the choice of the observable W , because this determines what fraction of the stored which-way information is read out. Consider, for example, the case where full which-way information is stored: Choosing W carefully, one can reach LW = 1, whereas an unfortunate choice of W (as in a full quantum erasure measurement) could result in LW = 1/2, so that one might just as well toss a coin. To measure quantitatively how much whichway information is stored, the arbitrariness of the read-out process must be eliminated. This motivates the definition of the “distinguishability of the ways” (Jaeger et al., 1995; Englert, 1996)
D = -1
+ 2max{Lw) W
using the maximum of LW that is reached for the best choice of W. The ways cannot be distinguished at all if D = 0, and they can be held apart completely i f D = 1. In order to measure the likelihood, Lw, we perform the experiment with only one standing light wave sandwiched between the two microwave pulses, while the other standing light wave is removed. This allows us to measure the atom’s external and internal states simultaneously, because the far-field position of an atom now reveals whether the atom is in beam B or beam C. These measurements yield the joint probabilitiesp ( Wi,B) and p ( Wi, C), from which Lw can be inferred. In order to obtain the distinguishability,D, a suitable observable Wept. has to be found that maximizes Lw. This observable can be measured as explamed in Section 1I.E: An additional (third) microwave pulse is applied before the atoms leave the interaction region, and finally, only atoms in state 13) are detected. It can be shown that with the state vector Eq. (54), the third microwave pulse must have an area of 7c/2 - cp (or 3x/2 -cp etc.) and that this measurement should yield
Figure 13 displays the measured values of D as a function of the area cp of the first two microwave pulses. Simultaneously, the area of the third microwave pulse was tuned, too, in order to measure Wopt for all values of cp. According to Eq. (59), D should reach unity at cp = 4 2 , but in the experiment, we find Dm, = 0.81 f0.02. As discussed in Diirr et al. (1998b), this reduction is due to background counts in the fluorescence detection and to intensity variations of the standing light wave. Both effects reduce the measured value of D by a constant factor, independent of cp, so that the quantity actually measured in the experiment is
64
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
100% 1
.c 80% .a ca
60%
0% 0
n14
n12
3n14
n
microwave pulse area ‘p FIG. 13. Distinguishability D as a function of the microwave pulse area cp. The solid line is the theoretical expectation Eq. (60).
instead of Eq. (59). The solid line in Fig. 13 displays Eq. (60) with = 0.81. Note that the distinguishability (as well as the visibility) is an ensemble property. There is no measurement that can be performed on a single atom to yield the value of D (or V). Only an ensemble of atoms can build up an interference pattern or reveal the probabilities from which D can be inferred. In addition, a simultaneous measurement of D and V is not possible. This is because the second beamsplitter must be removed in order to measure the degree of correlation between the internal state and beams B and C, from which D is inferred; but this beamsplitter is needed to produce interference fringes in order to measure V.
D,,,
C . DUALITY RELATION The visibility and the distinguishability quantify how much wave character and how much particle character, respectively, can be attributed to the atom. Obviously, D = 1 enforces V = 0, and V = 1 requires D = 0. Hence in the intermediate regime, the following question arises: Is there a limit on the amount of which-way information that can be stored for a given value of the visibility? The answer is “yes”; such a limit exists in form of the duality relation (Jaeger et al., 1995; Englert, 1996) D2
+ V 2 I1
(61)
This relation is a fundamental limit in quantum mechanics, which applies to every two-beam interferometer and to every type of which-way detector.
a
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
65
~
100%
60% 40% 20% -
p
& A -
=*€*€€€$*$
80%
(VNm,)*
+ (D/Dm=)2
microwave pulse area cp FIG.14. Experimental test of the duality relation based on the data from Figs. 12 and 13. (D(cp)/Dmax)2 ( V ( ( P ) / V , , , is ~ )plotted ~ as a function of cp. According to the duality relation, the data points may not exceed unity. The open circles are close to unity by definition (from Diirr, 1998b).
+
Connecting D and V, the duality relation generalizes the concept of waveparticle duality to the regime of incomplete which-way information and makes a quantitative test of wave-particle duality possible. In our experiment, the reduction of the measured values of the visibility V and the distinguishability D is well understood. In order to test the duality relation, it is therefore justified to divide the measured data from Figs. 12 and 13 by Vm, and D, respectively. The result is shown in Fig. 14, where
is plotted as a function of cp. The data at cp = 0 and cp = x / 2 (open circles) are close to unity by definition. All other data (full circles) are below unity, which means that we find good agreement with the duality relation.
X. Wigner Function All information about a quantum system can be extracted, for example, from its state vector, its density matrix, or - equivalently - its Wigner function:
66
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rernpe
Here $ ( p ) denotes the wave function in the (not rescaled) momentum representation. Equation (63) is equivalent to the standard definition (Wigner, 1932). The Wigner function is a quasi-probability function on phase space, and it allows an elegant illustration of a quantum state. The position (or momentum) probability distribution of the state can be obtained by integration of the Wigner function along the momentum (or position) axis, respectively. This section discusses the evolution of the Wigner function of an atom moving through our experimental setup. The calculation is based on the theoretical model discussed in the preceding sections. Although realistic parameters of the atom-light interaction are chosen ( x = Ore,, Xtpulse = n/4, and tsep= 4/0,), the parameters of the incoming atomic beam have been modified to minimize the computational effort. In particular, we made two simplifying assumptions. First, we assume that the atomic source creates a Gaussian atomic beam that is initially in a minimum uncertainty state. For a reasonable value of the momentum width of the emitted beam, An,, = 0.25, this corresponds to an extremely small size of the source, Azms = h/n. Second, we assume a much shorter time of flight from the source to the = 4n/w,,. These assumptions greatly interaction region, namely f simplify calculation of the Wigner function. Nevertheless, the results display most of the relevant features that would be obtained for realistic parameters. A realistic treatment would have to take into account that the atomic beam is not diffraction-limited; rather, it is emitted from a thermal source and then collimated with two relatively broad mechanical slits. In addition, the source is much larger, and the beam inside the interferometer is much broader, than assumed in the calculation. Results of our computation are shown in Fig. 15. Figure 15(a) shows the initial Wigner function at the source. Because of our simplifying assumption, the Wigner function is described by a Gaussian. In order to fulfill the Bragg condition, the distribution is centered around n = 1. In Fig. 15(b), the atomic cloud has reached the interaction region. The free flight during tsource leads to a shearing of the Wigner function. The size of the cloud (in position space) has increased. The tilt of the principal axes of the ellipsoid with respect to the coordinate system is due to correlations between the atomic momentum and the position that build up during the free flight. Figure 15(c) shows the Wigner function immediately after the first beamsplitter (without any microwave pulses). The incoming beam is split into a transmitted beam, which is less populated but is hardly affected otherwise, and a Bragg-reflected beam, which is shifted by two photon momenta. This beam creates the lower peak centered around n = -1. Because the reflected and transmitted beams are in a coherent superposition, the Wigner function oscillates in the region between the two peaks. Note
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
67
FIG. 15. Wigner function. Light (dark) regions represent positive (negative) values of the Wigner function. (a) At the idealized source, (b) after free flight, (c) after the first beamsplitter, (d) before the second beamsplitter, (e) after the interferometer, (f) after the interferometer with which-way information stored.
68
Stephan Durr and Gerhard Rempe
that these oscillations average to zero when the momentum distribution is calculated but that they give rise to sinusoidal interference fringes when the (near-field) position distribution is plotted. These fringes describe the atomic standing wave formed by the two counterpropagating atomic beams, which are produced in the Bragg beamsplitter. The following free flight during tsep simply shears the Wigner function again, as displayed in Fig. 15(d). Figure 15(e) shows the Wigner function after the interaction with the second standing light wave. Each of the four peaks corresponds to one of the beams in Fig. 5: the lower left to D, the lower right to E, the upper left to F, and the upper right to G. Oscillations are visible halfway between each pair of peaks, indicating that the four beams are in a coherent superposition. A later observation of the far-field position distribution corresponds to a measurement of the momentum distribution. The oscillations between the two upper peaks (beams F and G) create the right half of the interference pattern observed in the experiment. The oscillations between the two lower peaks (beams D and E) create the left half of the interference pattern. The oscillations between the upper half and the lower half of the Wigner function describe near-field interference fringes, which are not observed in the experiment. Let us now add microwave pulses to store which-way information, so that an entanglement between the internal and external atomic state is created. Because the Wigner function displays only the external degree of freedom, it cannot visualize the complete quantum state of the system any more. Information about the quantum state can be displayed in the form of a Wigner function only if the entanglement is removed. This can be achieved either by performing an internal-state measurement, associated with a collapse of the wavefunction, or by “tracing out” the internal state, if no internal-state measurement is performed. The result for the latter, more interesting case is shown in Fig. 15(Q for atoms that passed through the interferometer with the first beamsplitter sandwiched between two microwave n/2 pulses: Storing which-way information, but ignoring the internal state, obviously destroys the oscillations between the left and the right peaks of the Wigner function. Hence interference in the far field (between beams D and E, or between beams F and G) is lost now. The remaining oscillations give rise to near-field interference fringes only between beams D and F and between beams E and G, which are not observed in the experiment. Note that the tiny recoil of the microwave photons has not been taken into account in this computation. Again, this section shows that the loss of interference, as described by the disappearance of the relevant oscillations in Fig. 15(f), is due only to the entanglement with the internal degree of freedom.
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
69
XI. Conclusion Atom interferometry enables us to address fundamental aspects of the quantum theory of measurement in real experiments. We have shown that the loss of interference fringes in a which-way experiment need not be due to Heisenberg’s uncertainty relation. We have also demonstrated how interference can be restored by erasing the which-way information. In addition to this, we investigated a new regime, where only incomplete which-way information is available. This allowed us to study the continuous transition between wave and particle pictures and to test wave-particle duality in a quantitative manner. Future experimental investigations in this field might focus on the investigation of decoherence effects in order to study the transition between quantum and classical physics, leading to a more detailed understanding of the processes underlying the collapse of the wavefunction (see, for example, Wheeler and Zurek, 1983; Zurek,1991; Haroche, 1998).
XII. Acknowledgments We thank T. Nonn for help in the experiment and acknowledge fruitful discussions with S. Kunze. This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft.
References Adams, C. S., and Riis, E. (1997). Progr: Quantum Electron. 21, 1. Adams, C. S., Sigel, M., and Mlynek, J. (1994). Phys. Rep. 240, 145. Badurek, G., Rauch, H., and Tuppinger D.(1986). Phys. Rev. A 34, 2600. Berman, P. R., Ed. (1997). Atom interferometry. Academic Press (New York). Bemet, S., Oberthaler, M. K., Abfalterer, R., Schmiedmayer, J., and Zeilinger, A. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 5160. Bernhardt, A. F., and Shore, B. W. (1981).Phys. Rev. A 23, 1290. Bohr, N. (1949).In P. A. Schilpp (Ed.), Albert Einstein: Philosopher-scienrist, Library of Living Philosophers (Evanston, IL). Reprinted in Wheeler and Zurek, 1983. Brune, M., Hagley, E., Dreyer, J., Maali, X., Wunderlich, C., Raimond J. M.,and Haroche, S. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77,4887. Buks, E., Schuster, R., Heiblum, M., Mahalu, D.,and Umansky, V. (1998). Nature 391, 871. Chapman, M. S., Hammond, T.D., Lenef, A., Schmiedmayer, J., Rubenstein, R. A., Smith, E., and Pritchard, D. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75,3783. Clauser, J. F., and Li, S. (1994). Phys. Rev. A 50, 2430. Diirr, S., Kunze, S., and Rempe, G. (1996). Quantum Semiclass. Opt. 8, 531. Dun; S., Nonn, T., and Rempe, G. (1998a). Nature 395, 33. Dun; S., and Rempe, G. (1999). Phys. Rev. A 59, 1495. Diirr, S., Nonn, T., and Rempe, G. (1998b). Phys. Rev. Len. 81,5705.
70
Stephan Diirr and Gerhard Rempe
Eichmann, U., Bergquist, J. C., Bollinger, J. J., Gilliban, J. M., Itano, W. M., Wineland, D. J., and Raizen, M. G. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 70,2359. Englert, B.-G. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 2154. Englert, B.-G., Scully, M. 0.. and Walther, H. (1995). Nature 375, 367. Ewald, P. P. (1917). Ann. Physik 54, 519. Feynman, R. P., Leighton, R. B., and Sands, M. (1965). In The Feynman lectures onphysics, vol. III, chap. 1. Addison-Wesley (Reading, MA). Gibble, K., and Chu, S. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 1771. Giltner, D. M., McGrown, R. W., and Lee, S. A. (1995a). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 2638. Giltner, D. M., McGrown, R. W., and Lee, S. A. (1995b). Phys. Rev. A 52, 3966. Haroche, S. (1976). In Shimoda K. (Ed.), High-resolution laser spectroscopy (Topics in Applied Physics, vol. 13) Springer (New York). Haroche, S. (1998) Phys. Today 5 1 (7). 36. Heisenberg, W. (1927). Z. Phys. 43, 172. Hellmuth, T., Walther, H., Zajonc, A., and Schleich, W. (1987). Phys. Rev. A 35, 2532. Herzog, T. J., Kwiat, P. G., Weinfurter, H., and Zeilinger, A. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 3034. Jaeger, G., Shimony, A., and Vaidman L. (1995). Phys.Rev. A 51, 54. Kazantsev, A. P., Surdutovick, G. I., and Yakovlev, V. P. (1990). Mechanical action of light on atoms. World Scientific (London). Kunze, S., Rempe. G., and Wilkens, M. (1994). Europhys. Lett. 27, 115. Kunze, S., Diirr, S., and Rempe, G. (1996). Europhys. Lett. 34, 343. Kunze, S., Diirr,S., Dieckmann, K., Elbs, M., Ernst, U., Hardell, A,, Wolf, S., and Rempe, G. (1997a). J. Mod. Opt. 44, 1863. Kunze, S., Diekmann, K., and Rempe, G. (1997b). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78,2038. Marte, M., and Stenholm, S. (1992). Appl. Phys. B 54,443. Martin, P. J., Oldaker, B. G., Miklich, A. H., and Pritchard, D. E. (1988). Phys. Rev. Lett. 60,515. Miiller, J. H., Bettermann, D., Rieger, V.,Sengstock, K., Stem, U., and Ertmer, W. (1995). Appl. Phys. B 60, 199. Pfau, T., Spalter, S., Kurtsiefer, C., Ekstrom, C. R., and Mlynek, J. (1994). Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 1223. F’ritchard, D. E., and Gould, P. (1985). J. Opt. Soc. Am. B 2, 1799. Ramsey, N. F. (1950). Phys. Rev. 78,695. Rauch, H., Zeilinger, A., Badurek, G., Wilfing, A., Bauspiess, W., and Bonse, U. (1975). Phys. Lett. A 54, 425. Shannon, C. E. (1948). Bell Syst. Techn. J. 27, 379. Schumacher, E., Wilkens, M., Meystre, P., and Glasgow, S. (1992). Appl. Phys. B 54, 451. Schwindt, P. D. D., Kwiat, P. G., and Englert, B.- G. (submitted). Scully, M. 0.. and Driihl, K. (1982). Phys. Rev. A 25, 2208. Scully, M. O., Englert, B.- G., and Walther, H. (1991). Nature 351, 11 1. Storey, E. P., Tan, S. M., Collett, M. J., and Walls, D. F. (1994). Nature 367, 626. Storey, E. P., Tan, S. M., Collett, M. J., and Walls, D. F. (1995). Nature 375, 368. Summharnmer, J., Badurek, G., Rauch, H., Kischko, U., and Zeilinger, A. (1983). Phys. Rev. A 27, 2523. Weizsacker, C. F. v. (1931). Z Phys. 70, 114. Weizsacker, C. F. v. (1941). Z. Phys. 1 18,489. Wheeler, J. A. (1978). In Marlow, A. R., (Ed.) Mathematical foundations of quantum theory Academic Press (New York). Wheeler J. A., and Zurek, W. H. (1983). Quantum theory and measurement. Princeton University Press (Princeton, NJ). Wigner E. (1932). Phys. Rev. 40, 749.
WAVE-PARTICLE DUALITY IN AN ATOM INTERFEROMETER
71
Wilkens, M., Schumacher, E., and Meystre, P. (1991). Phys. Rev. A 44, 3130. Wiseman, H. M., and Harrison, F. E. (1995). Nature 377, 584. Wiseman, H. M., Harrison, F.E., Collett, M. J., Tan, S. M., Walls, D. F., and Killip, R. B. (1997). Phys. Rev. A 56, 55. Wooters, W. K., and Zurek, W. H. (1979). Phys. Rev. D 19, 473. Reprinted in Wheeler and Zurek, 1983. Zou, X. Y., Wang, L. J., and Mandel, L. (1991). Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 318. Zurek, W. H. (1991). Phys. Today 44 (lo), 36.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OFTICAL PHYSICS,VOL.42
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY FUJI0 SHIMIZU Institute for Laser Science, University of Electro-Communications, Chofu-shi, Japan
.........................
13
11. Atomic Beam Source . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Coherent Flux. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
14 74
I. Introduction. . . . . . .
111.
IV. V.
VI. VII. VIII.
B. Source and Detector. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. An Example: Metastable Neon Beam Source . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Design of Thin-Film Hologram . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Generation of a Simple Pattern . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Fraunhofer Hologram by Subdivision of a Cell. . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Hologram with Imaging Function . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Gray-Scale Hologram. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Quality Evaluation . . . . . . . . ....................... Other Possible Techniques. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Phase Hologram . . . . . . ......................... B. Bragg Hologram by a St ght Wave . . . . . . . . . . C. Optical Reconstruction of Atomic Interference . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Conclusions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . ....................... References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
15
16 I1 81 81 84 86 89 90 90 91 91 92 92 92
I. Introduction Holography is a technique to manipulate the wavefront of a wave. An arbitrary wave pattern is generated by passing a wave of simpler form through a film called a hologram that has an appropriate complex transmission function. The technique was demonstrated with an optical wave by Gabor (1948) with the expectation to improve the imaging quality of an electron microscope. For the optical wave a wide variety of holographic techniques were developed since the 1960s after the invention of the laser. Holography has been used as a tool to store and reconstruct three-dimensional images of an object. Holography is applicable in principle to any matter wave with monochromatic energy that satisfies the Helmholz equation. The process of holography may be divided into two steps. In the first step, the interferometric pattern between the object and reference waves is recorded on the hologram. In the second step, the wave for the reconstruction is sent through the hologram and is diffracted to produce the object wave. The waves in the first step may be optical waves or any matter waves, or the interference pattern of the two waves may be constructed by computer calculation. In the latter case, the 13
Copyright 02000 by Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-003842-011SSN 1049-25OXlOO$30.00
74
Fuji0 Shimizu
technique is called computer holography. The wave in the second step must be the one through which we would like to observe the object. Owing to the short de Broglie wavelength of particles with mass, however, there were few examples of matter-wave holography. In 1979 Tonomura et al. read optically the interference pattern of electron waves that was recorded on the detector of an electron microscope. The technique has been used to observe phase objects in electron microscopes (see, for example, Tonomura, 1995). Another example of matter-wave holography is limited to atoms, in which an arbitrary image of atoms was produced by a computer-generated hologram (Fujita et al., 1996, Morinaga et al., 1996). Although the wave nature of atoms and molecules was experimentally verified nearly 70 years ago (Estermann and Stem, 1930), there was little development until Gould et al. (1986) studied diffraction of a Na atomic beam by a transmission-type grating made of SiN film. Interferometry of atoms has made large progress in the last 10 years because of the development of laser cooling. In the early 1990s, various types of atom interferometers were demonstrated. They include Young's double-slit interferometer (Carnal and Mlynek, 1991) and the Mach Zender interferometer that uses gratings as beamsplitters and deflectors (Keith et al., 1991). They used thermal beams that have de Broglie wavelength in the range of 10-"m, which was too short to observe the interference pattern as a two-dimensional image by a detector with spatial resolution. Such a mode of detection is possible with a sufficiently cooled atomic beam. Shimizu et al. (1992) recorded Young's double-slit interference pattern of laser-cooled neon atoms on a microchannel plate detector. The first interferometric manipulation of atoms that aimed at atomic image formation was the focusing of an atomic beam by Fresnel lens (Carnal et al., 1991). Production of an atomic pattern by a computer-generated hologram, demonstrated by our group, is the generalization of those techniques. We describe in this article the present status of holographic manipulation of atoms and comment on the possible future of this technique.
11. Atomic Beam Source A. COHERENT FLUX The flux of an atomic beam is limited by collisions of atoms in the beam. It increases with the velocity of atoms. However, for the holographic application, the hologram has to be illuminated coherently. Consider that atoms are released through a hole with diameter a from a reservoir containing atoms with average velocity v and density n,. The number of atoms passing through
75
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
the hole per unit time F is approximately x n,va 2 F =16
However, only those atoms that are emitted within the diffraction angle h/a can be used for interferometry. Therefore, the coherent flux Fcoh is
h2
Fcoh = -n,va
2
16a2
h2ns 16m2v
=-
Atoms should not collide with each other in the beam. The atomic density in the beam is largest at the exit and keeps the same density as in the source approximately by the distance of a. To avoid collisions within this distance, the atomic density must be smaller than
n,
1 cJa
<-
where c~ is the collision cross section. Inserting this relation into the above equation we obtain the maximum coherent flux h2
Fcoh
< 16m2ova
This equation tells us that to obtain larger flux, one should use colder atoms and a smaller source. The absolute value of Fcoh in the above expression is many orders of magnitude smaller than the value of an optical beam. At very low temperature, the collisional rate (JV,rather than the collisional cross section 0,is constant. For laser-cooled alkali atoms, (JV lo-'* m3 s-l. Inserting a magneto-optical trap of typical size (a lop3m and m 3x kg), one obtains Fcoh < 3 x lo4s-I, which is 11 orders of magnitude smaller than the photon flux of a 1-mW He-Ne laser. Considering that approximately lo6 atoms are necessary to draw a black-and-white image with the resolving power of lo3 x lo3, this number is by no means sufficient. The atomic beam that is released from a Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC) of atoms can improve the situation (Anderson et al., 1995; Davis et al., 1995; Bradley et al., 1997;Mewes ef al., 1997).However, the present production rate of BEC atoms is not higher than the limiting value of a thermal source [Eq. (l)]. N
N
N
AND DETECTOR B. SOURCE
A wide range of atoms can be shaped into a beam at room temperature or slightly elevated temperature. The de Broglie wavelength of atoms at room
76
Fuji0 Shimizu
temperature is on the order of lo-" m. Because of the technical limitation of interferometric components, it is difficult to obtain a diffraction angle larger than rad. This limits the size of the reconstructed image. Laser-cooled atoms are free from this restriction. However, it is not practical to use an atomic beam slower than 1m/s on earth, becasue such beams are constantly accelerated by gravity. It is, nevertheless, useful to make the atomic beam from a colder source, because the acceleration by gravity compresses the velocity spread. Up to this time, alkali, alkali earth, metastable rare gas, Yb, and Cr atoms have been laser-cooled and trapped. Chromium is stable on a solid surface and has been used to demonstrate nanometer-scale deposition of atoms by a standing wave of light (Timp et al., 1992; McClelland et al., 1993). Patterns of alkali and metastable rare gas atoms can be recorded on solid surfaces by using proper photoresistant materials (Kreis et al., 1996; Nowak et al., 1996; Bard et al., 1997; Younkin et al., 1997). The pattern of the laser-cooled atoms can be detected with high sensitivity by resonance fluorescence of the cooling transition, because a single atom emits many spontaneous photons during the illumination. The resolution of optical detection is limited by the photon recoil during the absorption and spontaneous emission processes. Metastable rare gases are sensitive to charged particle detectors that have charge-amplifying capability, such as a micro-channel plate (MCP) detector, and thus they can be detected with very high sensitivity. The spatial resolution of an MCP is on the order of 10 pm. A method to obtain higher resolution was developed by Kurtsiefer and Mlynek (1997). They let metastable atoms hit a metal surface and imaged the pattern of ejected Penning electrons on an MCP by using magnifying electron optics. C. AN EXAMPLE: METASTABLE NEONBEAMSOURCE
We describe here a neon atomic beam in the metastable ls~('P0)state that was used in the work in the following sections. Figure 1 shows the apparatus. 2 ) are generated by a weak discharge in Metastable atoms in the l s ~ ( ~ Pstate the channel of the nozzle. The nozzle was made of sapphire and cooled by liquid nitrogen by contact. To increase the flux, the metastable atoms are deflected and collimated by resonant laser beams at 640 nm that travel zigzag between two sets of curved mirrors (Shimizu et al., 1990). The atoms are decelerated in the Zeeman slower and trapped in a magneto-optical trap with a four-laser-beam configuration (Shimizu et al., 1991). A laser beam at 598 nm is focused into the cloud of trapped atoms, and the Is5 atoms are transferred to the ls3 state by optical pumping. Because the ls3 atoms are free from the trapping force, they fall vertically in response to gravity.
77
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY Transfer Deflection
source
18, neon beam
FIG.1. The schematics of a Is3 metastable neon beam source.
111. Design of Thin-Film Hologram Although the basic principle of holography is the same for any kind of wave, actual implementation of atom holography is considerably different from that of optical holography. First, atoms do not transmit through solid material coherently. As a result, holograms for atoms that have been demonstrated to date used thin films with real holes, and their transmission function is binary. Holograms with continuous transmission functions may be constructed if one utilizes coherent reflection from a solid surface. It is also possible, in principle, to make a hologram with near resonant light wave that has a continuous function. The second difference is that the flux of an atomic beam is many orders of magnitude smaller than that of an optical wave. The number of atoms determines the maximum complexity of the pattern that can be drawn. Third, atoms are constantly accelerated by gravity and deflected downward. For cold atoms, the resulting de Broglie wavelength can be much shorter than that at the initial state. Let us consider that a monochromatic atomic wave is emitted from a point source at r = (0,0,O)and passes through the hologram placed on the plane z = -II with the transmission function f ( r )(see Fig. 2). When the diffraction angle is small, the complex amplitude of the wave F(R) on the screen at z = -I1 - 12 is expressed to a good approximation by F(R) = A
s
f(r)ei@(r9R)dr
where the accumulated phase
@(r,R ) = -
pdl=
"I
-
h
v2dt
78
Fuji0 Shimizu
Z
.
Source
-r
HoI ogram
Screen FIG.2. Trajectory of an atom from the source to the screen through the hologram.
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
79
is calculated along the classical pass of the atom that passes through r and R. In this expression, p and v are the classical momentum and the velocity of the atom, respectively. The transmission function of the hologramf(r) is obtained by solving F ( R ) from Eq. (2). Assuming that the gravity force is along the z-axis and that the horizontal velocity is much smaller than the vertical velocity at z = 11, one can expand @ in a power series of r and R as follows:
where m is the mass of the atom; v,, vh, and V d are the velocity at the source, hologram, and screen, respectively; and tl and f 2 are the transit times of the atom from the source to the hologram and from the hologram to the screen, respectively. The first line of the equation is the phase between the source and the hologram, and the second line is the phase between the hologram and the screen. Because the first of the two lines are independent of r and R, the pattern on the screen may be obtained by taking the second terms of two lines only:
This expression is a Fourier integral of the transmission function f ( r ) multiplied by quadratic phase factors. Therefore, the transmission function of the hologram is obtained by the inverse Fourier transform of the atomic image F(R) on the screen as follows:
The range of validity of this expression is estimated from the magnitude of the fourth-power terms o f t and R in Eq. (3). Considering that h / ( m v ) is the de Broglie wavelength of the atom and that vf2 is approximately the length between the hologram and the screen, the condition is given by
80
Fuji0 Shimizu
where 1 is the distance between the hologram and the screen, and R is the size of the image or hologram. When this condition is not satisfied, one has to solve Eq. (2) directly to obtain the transmission functionf(r). Although Kirchhoffs diffraction theory guarantees arbitrary three-dimensional wave generation by specifying the boundary condition on a surface, real implementation is limited by the physical restriction of holograms. The hologram is a passive component. Therefore, the amplitude of f ( r ) cannot exceed unity. When the reconstruction beam illuminates the hologram uniformly, the amplitude off(r) must be more or less uniform to make the average transmission of atoms lie in a practical range. When 1 >> R, the gross structure of f ( r )is the Fourier transform of the image F ( R ) .If the image has a uniform phase, or is “specular,” its Fourier transform shows an extremely large peak around the origin r = (0,O).Even if we set If(0,O)l = 1, the rest of the hologram becomes almost opaque. Uniform amplitude distribution on the hologram plane is obtained only when the phase or the amplitude of the object rapidly changes. The situation is the same for any wave, including an optical wave. The object may have a curved surface to obtain a three-dimensional view. This does not mean the generation of an arbitrary wave field. The wave that is scattered from the diffuse surface of the object has random characteristics and cannot be used for practical purposes except on the imaging surface. For the purpose of pattern generation of atoms, the random phase does not affect the outcome. In special cases, three-dimensional waves with definite phases can be constructed.One such case is when the hologram is placed close to the image plane. Another example occurs when the image is very small so that the image is reconstructed from a large area of the hologram. The Fresnel lens of atoms (Camel el al., 1991) may be interpreted as this kind of hologram. To construct the hologram, we divide the imaging area and the hologram surface by 2N square meshes, where N is an integer. We assign a single value to each cell of the mesh. To make the image diffuse, a random phase factor exp{i+rand(m,,m y ) } is first multiplied on each value F(m,,m y ) of the image plane, where m, and my show the position of the cell along the x- and y-axes. Then the transmission function of the hologramf(j,, j y ) is calculated by the digitized from of Eq. (4),
using the fast-Fourier-transform algorithm. In Eq. (5), d and D are the cell length of the hologram and image, respectively. There are many ways to
81
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
express the complex valuef(j,, j y ) of the hologram. We describe below two methods that we used to make atomic images.
A. GENERATION OF A SIMPLE PATTERN Generation of a simple pattern is often possible without randomization of phase. In this case, both phase and amplitude have a predictable function in the entire dimensional space. However, as a tool to generate a two-dimensional pattern of atoms, the hologram without phase randomization generally either is inefficient or produces only a localized simple pattern. Nevertheless, such a hologram is useful as a component for atom optics, such as beamsplitters, and as a tool to produce a simple pattern, particularly in the near Fraunhofer diffraction region. Figure 3 shows the diffraction pattern of atoms generated by a two-dimensional array of rectangular holes. The hole has the dimensions 250 by 500 nm and is separated from the adjacent holes by 250 nm [Fig. 3(a)]. The hologram was a SiN4 film 100 nm thick and 0.5 pm square. It was illuminated by a point atomic source described in Section II.C from 41 cm above the hologram. The diffractionimage was taken by a micro-channel plate detector placed 46 cm below the hologram. The diffraction pattern [Fig. 3(b)] has, as expected, the same shape as an optical diffraction pattern produced by the holes of similar shape. The figure reflects the characteristics of the source and the metastable Ne atomic wave. The efficiency of the optical pumping from the Is5 state to the 1s3 state is approximately 50%, and the remaining atoms decay to the ground state by emitting a 74-nm the VUV photon. The zeroth-order diffraction pattern of the VUV photons is clearly seen overlapping on the atomic pattern. Its size is approximately 1.5 times larger, because photons move in a straight path, whereas atoms take parabolic paths. In principle, for the same reason, the photon image can be removed by tilting the atomic path from the vertical direction. The metastable atoms may be quenched while passing through the hologram. The intensity of the first-order diffraction pattern relative to the zeroth pattern in the figure is slightly larger than that expected from the calculation. This shows that the effective size of the hole is smaller than the real size, a difference that is probably caused by the quenching of metastable atoms that pass near the 100-nm wall of the hole of the hologram. The quenching distance obtained from the intensity ratio is 12 nm. This distance must be taken into account if one tries to control the transmission function by the shape of the hole. B. FRAUNHOFER HOLOGRAM BY SUBDIVISION OF A
CELL
The method that follows is basically the same as that developed by Lohmann and Paris (1967). (See also Brown and Lohmann, 1966, for the computer
82
Fuji0 Shimizu b
b
b
b
b
b
00
no no 0 . b . b b
b
FIG.3. Diffraction pattern from a two-dimensional array of rectangular holes. (a) The pattern of holes. (b) The atomic pattern.
hologram in optics). The complex number is expressed by controlling the shape and position of the hole in a cell. Let us consider an imaginary plane that is tilted by the angle 8, = sin(h/d) from the hologram plane along the xaxis. For the wave that is diffracted perpendicularly to the reference plane, the distance between the hologram and the reference plane changes by h as the distance along the x-axis moves by the cell length d (see Fig.4). Therefore, the phase of the atomic wave relative to the reference plane changes as 2 m / d .
83
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
Z h
d
< I
I
I I
I
Hologram surface
> x
-2 + i
FIG.4. A method to express a complex number on the hologram. Each point (cell) of the hologram is divided into 4 x 4 subcells. The complex transmission coefficient of the cell is determined by the number and position of open subcells (white area in the figure). The example of the figure shows the number that is proportional to -2 i.
+
The partial wave coming out from the slit on the hologram that is open at the distance Ax from the edge of the cell and has a length Ay has the complex amplitude proportional to Ayexp(27ciAxld) on the reference palne. If the angular spread Bi of the atomic image is small, 2Nd8i << h, this technique expresses a complex number to good accuracy. However, a narrow slit results in a wider diffraction of the atomic wave, and atoms are dispersed to images of many diffraction orders. In Fig. 4, a cell is divided into 4 x 4 square subcells. The phase is expressed in units of n/2, and the amplitude is digitized to five linear steps. The example in the figure shows the transmission function proportional to -1 2i. Figure 5 shows the result of the holography that was designed to draw a letter F by this method (Fujita et al., 1996). The hologram was designed to produce the image at infinite distance by the source placed at infinite distance. The hologram had 256 x 256 cells. Each cell was divided into 4 x 4 subcells as shown in Fig. 4. The hologram was a SiN4 film lOOnm thick and with an area of 350 x 350 pm. The size of the unit cell was 1400 x 1400nm, and the
+
84
Fuji0 Shimizu
FIG.5. The atomic pattern reconstructed by the hologram that is coded by the method described in Fig. 4.
size of a hole was 350 x 350 nm. The atomic beam source, the hologram, and the MCP detector were palced vertically. Figure 5 shows the image that was reconstructed on the MCP. Because the hole size is one-fourth of the cell size, atoms are diffracted approximately over the f4th-order diffraction patterns. Patterns on all orders along the y-axis are seen in the figure. Along the x-axis, some patterns disappear because of the way the phase is expressed. The phase between the adjacent subcells jumps by nN,/2 for the N,th diffraction pattern along the x-axis. At the angle of the N, = 4N lth diffraction, the phase is accurately expressed to produce the designed image. Therefore, the real image appears at this angle. At the angle (4N 2 ) h / d , the phase changes by 5c, and the interference between the odd and even subcells cancels the wave. At the angle 4N h / d , all holes have a positive real value producing a nondiffracted pattern. Similarly, the conjugate patterns are produced at the angle (4N 3 ) h / d .
+ +
+
C. HOLOGRAM WITH IMAGINGFUNCTION In the preceding example, the size of the hole is much smaller than the size of the cell, and images of many orders have nearly equal intensities. There is a more direct way of expressing the transmission function of the hologram,
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
85
which can concentrate a large fraction of atoms in a single set of images (Morinaga et al., 1996). To approximate the complex transmission function f ( j x ,j y ) by a binary function, we add the conjugate functionft(jx, j y ) to make& j y ) real:
Then we set a threshold f, to approximatef,(j,, j y ) with the binary function
where a hole is open for the cell with f b ( j x ,j y ) = 1. This procedure is straightforward, and the characteristics of the atomic pattern on the MCP are easily understood from Eqs. (6) and (7). The diffraction is a linear process, and each term of the transmission function, Eq.(6), produces an independent pattern. The conjugate image is created from the conjugate termft(jx, j y ) . The second procedure is similar to adding a constant to the transmission function and produces the nondiffracted image whose shape is close to the projection of the hologram area on the detector. The appearance of three images is a general characteristic of an intensity thin-film hologram. The image is constructed by summing amplitudes of the partial waves that are diffracted from each cell. Therefore, the area on which an image can be drawn is the area covered by the partial waves coming from a single hole. When the hole has a square shape with the side of the cell d, this is a sin function with the first zero at the angle of the first-order diffracted wave fsin(h/d). The higher-order diffraction patterns cancel out, and the majority of atoms fall within this angle. The hologram must be designed to form the image within this angle. When the hole is smaller than d, atoms are diffracted at a larger angle, and the higher-order diffraction patterns do not disappear generally. Because the normal and conjugate images appear on the side of the nondiffracted pattern, they may overlap with the zeroth-order images, unless the image is written within the angle fd/2h. Figure 6(b) shows the holographic reconstruction of the image by this method (Morinagae et al., 1996). The hologram is designed to focus a point atomic source on the MCP with tl = 0.286 s and f2 = 0.123 s. The hologram had 1024 x 1024 cells with the size of 500nm. The thresholdf, was determined so that approximately 8% of the cells were open. Figure 6(a) is the scanning microscope image of a part of the hologram pattern, where black squares are the holes. Figure 6(b) shows the atomic pattern obtained after 2 hours of accumulation and contains approximately 2 x lo5 atoms. The letters
86
Fujio Shimizu
NEC in the lower part of the figure constitute the reconstructed image. The square in the middle is the nondiffracted beam that shows the projection of the pattern of the hologram. The conjugate image covers the entire picture area and is not distinguishable from the background, because it is completely out of focus on the detector.
D. GRAY-SCALE HOLOGRAM The number of atoms required to draw a black-and-white pattern is approximately the number of cells 2 2 N .If one tries to write a photographic pattern with the gray scale of Ns, then the number scales by the same factor N g , and a long exposure time is necessary with currently available coherent atomic sources. The situation can be eased by increasing the area of the hologram. Because the size of the cell is determined by other factors, such as the size of the image and the distance between the hologram and the imaging plane, a larger hologram means a larger array size of the FFT transformation. When high resolution is not necessary, one can avoid massive FFT by dividing the hologram area into smaller sections and by operating FFT independently.
FIG. 6. The hologram with imaging function at a finite distance. (a) Scanning microscope image of a part of the hologram. The black squares are holes. (b) The reconstructed atomic image.
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
87
-1IIlIU(b) FIG.6. (Continued)
The translational shift of the hologram position by r, causes the phase shift of (rnlhq) (r, . R) in the integrand of Eq. (4). If one choose
m
-(r,
. 0)= 2x
fit2
the phase correction becomes a multiple of 2x. Therefore, the integral Eq. (4) is the same for all sections if the same random function & a n d ( ~ x , my)is used. This condition is automatically satisfied when the length of the image is set equal to the distance between the zeroth and the first diffraction spots. Figure 7 shows the image that was generated by the multiply constructed hologram (Kishimoto et al., 1998; Shimizu et al., 1998). The hologram was made by packing 4 x 4 smaller holograms that had 1024 x 1024 cells. In this example, independent random phase factors were multiplied to
88
Fuji0 Shimizu
FIG. 7. A gray-scale hologram. (a) The original photograph. (b) A part of the hologram pattern. (c) Computer reconstructionof the image. (d) The atomic pattern. The actual size of the figure is l O m m by 5 mm.
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
89
each section, and the FFT were repeated 16 times. The cell size of the hologram was 200nm, and tl = 0.289 s and t 2 = 0.156s. Figure 7(a) is the original pattern, and Fig.7(b) was a part of the hologram. Because the image is placed to the side of the image area, the hologram has holes stretched along the vertical direction. To avoid breaking the hologram film by unidirectional stress, long holes were cut into several pieces so that the maximum length did not exceed three unit cells lengths, 3d. Figure 7(d) is the reconstructed atomic image. The conjugate image is on the right-hand side of the zeroth-order pattern and is not shown in the figure. The accumulation time was 2 hours. The ratio of the open cell was approximately 25%. To avoid forming unsupported islands, the hole size was slightly smaller (160 nm) than the cell size. This generated images of higher-order diffraction. The conjugate image of the (- 1,O)th-orderdiffraction is clearly seen on the left of the zeroth-order image.
IV. Quality Evaluation The ultimate spatial resolution of a wave is the wavelength of the atomic wave,
which can be obtained using a focusing lens with a large aperture. A highquality lens for atoms that can image relatively complex patterns is yet to be developed. When the hologram is the sole optical component to produce an atomic image, the situation is different. The hologram described in the previous section is composed of holes of finite size, where the phase variation of the atomic de Broglie wave within the hole cannot be controlled. Suppose we make a binary image using a hologram with the number of cells 2N x 2N.The maximum information that the hologram can carry is the same as the number of cells 22N.Therefore, the resolving power along an axis cannot exceed 2N. The maximum resolution can be obtained only when the partial waves from all cells contribute to each point of the image. To satisfy this condition over the entire image area, the image size must be larger than the size of the hologram. This means that the resolution of the image cannot exceed the size of a hole of the hologram. The size of the atomic source, the velocity spread of the atoms at the hologram plane and the flatness of the hologram surface are other factors that affect the resolution. Geometrical resolution from the source is the diameter of the source a multiplied by the magnifying factor of the hologram. To obtain the resolving power of 2N intrinsic to the hologram, the atomic
90
Fuji0 Shimizu
wave has to illuminate the hologram coherently. This gives an additional condition
where dN = 2Nd is the size of the hologram. The resolving power is also limited by the relative velocity spread Aw/v of atoms at the hologram plane. The phase has to be accurate to within 7c to reconstruct the designed atomic pattern. When the vertical position of the hologram is changed by Az, the pass length of the atom from the source to the screen changes by approximately AzdN/(wt). The hologram surface has to be kept flat so that this value does not exceed h/2. The presence of background atoms is an another factor that affects the quality of the reconstructed image. Mathematically, the transformation from the hologram transmission amplitudef ( x ,y) to the image amplitude F ( X , Y) is unique. The difference between the real transmission and background functions A f ( x ,y) = f ( x , y) -fb(jx, j y ) prodcues spurious images and background. Because f b is a binary function, the amplitude [Aft is of the same magnitude as In examples in the previous section, a random phase factor was multiplied on each cell area. Therefore, the correlation length of Af is the cell length, and Af(x,y) produces random background on the screen, whose total intensity is of the same order as the total intensity of the transmitted wave. Good contrast is not generally expected if the pattern covers a large portion of the image area.
If[.
V. Other Possible Techniques A. PHASEHOLOGRAM The hologram described in the previous sections is a thin intensity hologram, where at best 22%of transmitted atoms contribute to make the image. A phase hologram theoretically has a maximum efficiency of 100%.Although there is no transparent solid for atomic waves, one can use the Zeeman effect or the second-order Stark effect to produce phase shift on an atomic wave. Both effects have been used to focus and trap slow atoms. For the holographic application, the required magnetic or electric field is much weaker, because the phase shift of 2n is sufficient to achieve arbitrary wavefront manipulation. This value is easily realizable with moderate electric potential or current for the micron-size structure of the hologram (Shimizu et al., 1992; Ekstrom et af., 1995).
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
91
BY A STANDING LIGHTWAVE B. BRAGGHOLOGRAM
An alternative method to produce phase shift is optical dipole interaction by an off-resonant light wave. The diffraction of atoms by a standing wave of light has been used as beamsplitters and reflectors of an atom interferometer. Although no complex atomic pattern has been generated, the diffraction by light may be considered a primitive form of atom holography. Bernet et al. (1997) discussed various modes of interferometric operations in terms of holography. Soroko (1997) discussed an arbitrary atomic wave generation by light. When the thickness of the standing wave is much larger than the wavelengths of the laser and atoms, three-dimensional momentum conservation must be satisfied. The process is equivalent to four-wave mixing, in which two waves are optical waves and the remaining waves are atomic de Broglie waves. If a plane wave is used in one of the optical waves, a planar atomic wave that has the same wave vector generates a scattered atomic wave identical to the second optical wave. This is aberration-free transfer of an optical image into an atomic image. The technique is, unfortunately, not really practical, because the gravity acceleration of atoms has a more serious effect on the phase matching. The accumulated phase shift due to the acceleration becomes larger than n after a vertical drop of
This value is only 50 pm for Ne atoms at v = lm/s, and the atomic beam interacts with the optical wave coherently only for approximately 10 optical wavelengths. If the optical waves are thin, the atomic beam is diffracted to the direction that conserves the momentum only in the plane of optical waves. This is the case for a thin-phase hologram. However, it will not be possible to form an arbitrary pattern of the hologram with all optical waves propagating in a thin sheet. It is more practical to pulse the atomic beam. Unlike photons, atoms move slowly, and it is not difficult to define the interaction region within a thin layer, which functions as a thin-phase hologram.
c. OPTICAL RECONSTRUCTION OF ATOMIC INTERFERENCE So far, we have discussed only the manipulation of atomic de Broglie waves by a hologram that was generated by other means. One may consider the reverse process, where the interferencepattern of atomic waves that is created by spatial variation of potential on atoms is read by optical wave, and the pattern of the phase shift caused by the potential is reconstructed as an optical
92
Fuji0 Shimizu
image. This was the case in the electron holography demonstrated by Tonomura et al. (1979). The recording techniques of the atomic pattern were described in the previous section. For alkalies and metastable rare-gas atoms, recording on photoresists followed by etching will produce a hologram that is adequate for optical reconstruction. Detection by resonant fluorescence or by an MCP detector possesses higher sensitivities. However, relatively poor spatial resolution will limit the complexity of the reconstructed image.
VI. Conclusions The present experimental status of atom holography is rather primitive. However, it is a promising technique for atom manipulation, because it handles atoms in mass, the patterning is completely general, and it controls the pattern from a distance. The technique can also be used to investigate the spatial phase and amplitude structure of an atomic de Broglie wave. However, to make atom holography practical, the flux of the coherent atomic beam has to be improved considerably.
VII. Acknowledgments All holograms presented in this article are fabricated by J. Fujita of NEC Fundamental Research Laboratories, who, together with S. Matsui, was the first to suggest atom holography by using a Lohmann-type binary hologram (Lohmann and Paris, 1967; Onoe and Kaneko, 1979).
VIII. References Anderson, M. H., Ensher, J. R., Mathews, M. R., Wieman, C. E., and Cornell, E. A. (1995). Science 269, 198. Bard, A., Berggren, K. K., Wilbur, J. L., Gillaspy, J. D., Rolston, S. L., McClelland, J. J., Phillips, W. D., Fkntiss, M., and Whitesides, G. M. (1997). J. Vuc. Sci. Technol. B, 15, 1805. Bernet, S., Abfalterer, R., Keller, C., Oberthaler, M. K., Schmiedmayer, J., and Zeilinger, A. (1997). J. Imaging Sci. Technol. 41, 324. Bradley, C. C., Sackett, C. A,, Tollett, J. J., and Hulet, R. G. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 985. Brown, B. R., and Lohmann, A. W. (1996). Appl. Opt. 5,967. Carnal, O., and Mlynek, J. (1991). Phys. Rev. Lett. 66, 2689. Carnal, O., Sigel, M., Sleator, T., Takuma, H., and Mlynek, I. (1991). Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 3231. Davis, M. 0.. Mewes, M.-O., Andrews, M. R., van Druten, N. J., Durfee, D. D., Kum, D. M., and Ketterle, W. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 3969. Ekstrom, C. R., Schmiedmayer, J., Chapman, M. S., Hammond, T. D., and Pritchard, D. E. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 51, 3883.
ATOM HOLOGRAPHY
93
Estermann, I., and Stem, 0. (1930). Z. Phys. 61,95. Fujita, J., Morinagae, M., Kishimoto, T., Yasuda. M., Matsui, S., and Shimizu, F. (1996). Nature 380, 691. Gabor, D. (1948). Nature 161, 777. Gabor, D. (1949). Proc. Roy. SOC.(London) A 197,454. Gould, P. L., Ruff, G. A,, and Pritchard, D. E. (1986). Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 827. Keith, D. W., Ekstrom, C. R., Turchette, Q.A., and Pritchard, D. E. (1991). Phys. Rev. Len. 66, 2693. Kishimoto, T., Fujita, J., Mitake, S., and Shimizu, F. (1998). Private communications. Kreis, M., Lison, F., Haubrich, D., Meschede, D., Nowak, S., Pfau, T., and Mlynek, J. (1996). Appl. Phys. B, B63, 649. Kurtsiefer, C., and Mlynek, J. (1997). Appl. Phys. B B64. 85. Lohmann, A. W., and Paris, D. P.(1967). Appl. Opt. 6, 1739. McClelland, J. J., Scholton, R. E., Palm, E. C., and Celotta, R. J. (1993). Science 262, 877. Mewes, M.-0.. Andrews, M. R., Kurn, D. M., Durfee, D. S., Townsend, C. G., and Ketterle, W. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 582. Morinaga, M., Yasuda, M., Kishimoto, T., Shimizu, F., Fujita, J., and Matsui, S. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 802. Nowak, S., Pfau, T., and Mlynek, J. (1996). Appl. Phys. B B63, 203. Onoe, M., and Kaneko, M. (1979). Denshi Tsushin Gukkai Zasshi 62, 118 (in Japanese). Shimizu, F., Shimizu, K., and Takuma, H. (1990). Chem. Phys. 145, 327. Shimizu, F., Shimizu, K., and Takuma, H. (1991). Opt. Lett. 16, 339. Shimizu, F., Shimizu, K., and Takuma, H. (1992). Phys. Rev. A 46, R17. Shimizu, F., Fujita, J., Morinaga, M., Kishimoto, T., and Mitake, S. (1998). Proc. Int. Con$ Atomic Physics. Soroko, A. V. (1997). J. Phys. B 30, 5621. Timp, G., Behringer, R. E., Tennant, D. M., Cunningham, J. E., Prentiss,M., and Berggren, K. K. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 1636. Tonomura, A., Matsuda, T., and Endo, J. (1979). Jpn. J. Appl. Phys. 18, 9. Tonomura, A. (1995). “Electron holography,” Pmc. Int. Workshop on Electron Holograpahy. Younkin, R., Berggren, K. K., Johnson, K. S., Prentiss, M., Ralph, D. C., and Whitesides, G. M. (1997). Appl. Phys. Lett. 71, 1261.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AM) OFTICAL PHYSICS, VOL. 42
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS RUDOLF GRIMM and M A P H I A S WEIDEMULLER Max-Planck-lnstitut f i r Kernphysik, Heidelberg, Germany
YURII B. OVCHINNIKOV National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD
I. Introduction .................................... 11. Optical Dipole Potential . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Oscillator Model . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Multilevel Atoms .............................. 111. Experimental Issues .............................. A. Cooling and Heat .............................. B. Experimental Techniques . ......................... C. Collisions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Red-Detuned Dipole Traps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Focused-Beam Traps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Standing-Wave Traps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
....................... .......................
V. Blue-Detune
eTraps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.......................
B. Hollow-Beam Traps. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Evanescent-Wave Traps . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ........ VI. Concluding Remarks. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII. References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
95 97 98 102 108 109 117 121 123 125 133 138
141 145 146 150 155 162 165 165
I. Introduction Methods for storage and trapping of charged and neutral particles have very often served as the experimental key to great scientific advances, covering physics in the vast energy range from elementary particles to ultracold atomic quantum matter. The ultralow-energy region became experimentally accessible as a result of the dramatic developments in the field of laser cooling and trapping that have taken place over the last two decades (Stenholm, 1986; Minogin and Letokhov, 1988; Arimondo et al., 1992; Metcalf and van der Straten, 1994; Chu, 1998; Cohen-Tannoudji, 1998; Phillips, 1998). 95
Copyright 0 2000 by Academic F’ress AU rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-003842-01ISSN 1049-25OXl00$30.00
96
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
For charged particles, the strong Coulomb interaction can be used for trapping in electric or electromagnetic fields (Bergstrom et al., 1995; Ghosh, 1995). At the very low temperatures reached by laser cooling, single ions show a variety of interesting quantum effects (Wineland et al., 1995), and ensembles form a crystalline ordered state (Walther, 1993). Laser cooling in ion traps has opened up new possibilities for ultrahigh-precision spectroscopy and related fundamental applications (Thompson, 1993). It is a very important feature of ion traps that the confining mechanism does not rely on the internal structure of the ion, which is therefore accessible for all kinds of experiments. For neutral atoms, it has become routine to produce ensembles in the microkelvin region, and many experiments are being performed with such laser-cooled ultracold gases. It is thus possible to trap the atoms by much weaker mechanisms as compared to the Coulomb interaction. Traps for neutral atoms can be realized on the basis of three different interactions, each class having specific properties and offering particular advantages. 0
0
Radiation-pressure traps operating with near-resonant light (Pritchard et al., 1986; Raab et al., 1987) have a typical depth of a few kelvins, and because of very strong dissipation, they make it possible to capture and accumulate atoms even from a thermal gas. In these traps, the atomic ensemble can be cooled down to temperatures in the microkelvin range. The trap performance, however, is limited in several ways by the strong optical excitation: The attainable temperature is limited by the photon recoil, the achievable density is limited by radiation trapping and light-assisted inelastic collisions, and the internal dynamics is strongly perturbed by resonant processes on a time scale on the order of a microsecond. Magnetic traps (Migdall et al., 1986; Bergeman et al., 1987) are based on the state-dependent force on the magnetic dipole moment in an inhomogeneous field. They represent ideal conservative traps with typical depths on the order of l00mK and are excellent tools for evaporative cooling and Bose-Einstein condensation. For further applications, a fundamental restriction is imposed by the fact that the trapping mechanism relies on the internal atomic state. This means that experiments involving the internal dynamics are limited to a few special cases. Furthermore, possible trapping geometries are restricted by the necessity to use arrangements of coils or permanent magnets. Optical dipole traps rely on the electric dipole interaction with fardetuned light, which is much weaker than all mechanisms discussed above. Typical trap depths are below 1 millikelvin. The optical excitation can be kept extremely low, so that such a trap is not limited by the light-induced mechanisms present in radiation-pressure traps. Under
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
97
appropriate conditions, the trapping mechanism is independent of the particular sublevel of the electronic ground state. The internal groundstate dynamics can thus be fully exploited for experiments, which is possible on a time scale of many seconds. Moreover, a great variety of different trapping geometries can be realized as, for example, highly anisotropic or multiwell potentials. The subject of this review is atom traps of the last class described, along with their unique features as storage devices at ultralow energies. Historically, the optical dipole force, acting as a confining mechanism in a dipole trap, was first considered by Askar’yan (1962) in connection with plasmas as well as neutral atoms. The possibility of trapping atoms with this force was considered by Letokhov (1968), who suggested that atoms might be one-dimensionally confined at the nodes or antinodes of a standing wave tuned far below or above the atomic transition frequency. Ashkin (1970) demonstrated the trapping of micron-sized particles in laser light based on the combined action of radiation pressure and the dipole force. Later he suggested three-dimensional traps for neutral atoms (1978). Bjorkholm et ul. (1978) demonstrated the dipole force on neutral atoms by focusing an atomic beam by means of a focused laser beam. In a great breakthrough, Chu et ul. (1986) exploited this force to realize the fist optical trap for neutral atoms. After this demonstration, enormous progress in laser cooling and trapping was made in many different areas, and much colder and denser atomic samples became available for the efficient loading of shallow dipole traps. In the early 1990s, optical dipole forces rapidly began to attract interest not only for atom trapping, but also in the emerging field of atom optics (Adams er al., 1994). In this review, we focus on dipole traps realized with fur-detuned light. In these traps, an ultracold ensemble of atoms is confined in a nearly conservative potential well with very weak influence from spontaneous photon scattering. The basic physics of the dipole interaction is discussed in Section 11. The experimental background of dipole trapping experiments is then explained in Section 111. Specific trapping schemes and experiments are presented in Sections IV and V, where we explore the wide range of applications of dipole traps and consider particular examples.
11. Optical Dipole Potential Here we introduce the basic concepts of atom trapping in optical dipole potentials that result from the interaction withfur-detuned light. In this case of particular interest, the optical excitation is very low, and the radiation force due to photon scattering is negligible compared to the dipole force. In Section II.A,
98
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
we first consider the atom as a simple classical or quantum-mechanical oscillator to derive the main equations for the optical dipole interaction. Then, in Section I1 B, we discuss the case of real multilevel atoms - in particular, the alkali atoms used in the great majority of experiments.
A. OSCILLATOR MODEL The optical dipole force arises from the dispersive interaction of the induced atomic dipole moment with the intensity gradient of the light field (Askar'yan, 1962; Kazantsev, 1973; Cook, 1979; Gordon and Ashkin, 1980). Because of its conservative character, the force can be derived from a potential, the minima of which can be used for atom trapping. The absorptive part of the dipole interaction in far-detuned light leads to residual photon scattering of the trapping light, which sets limits on the performance of dipole traps. In the following discussion, we derive the basic equations for the dipole potential and the scattering rate by considering the atom as a simple oscillator subject to the classical radiation field. 1. Interaction of Induced Dipole with Driving Field
When an atom is placed into laser light, the electric field E induces an atomic dipole moment p that oscillates at the driving frequency w. In the C.C. and p(r, t) = usual complex notation E(r, t ) = e,!?(r)exp(-iwt) ej(r) exp( -iot) c.c., where e is the unit polarization vector, the amplitude 3 of the dipole moment is simply related to the field amplitude E by
+
+
Here ct is the complex polarizability, which depends on the driving frequency 0.
The interaction potential of the induced dipole moment p in the driving field E is given by 1 2
udip = - - (pE) =
1 2EOC
- -Re(ct) I
where the angular brackets denote the time average over the rapid oscillating and the factor reflects the fact that terms, the field intensity is I = 2~0c1,!?1~, the dipole moment is an induced, not a permanent, one. The potential energy of the atom in the field is thus proportional to the intensity I and to the real part of the polarizability, which describes the in-phase component of the dipole
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
99
oscillation as responsible for the dispersive properties of the interaction. The dipole force results from the gradient of the interaction potential
It is thus a conservative force, proportional to the intensity gradient of the driving field. The power absorbed by the oscillator from the driving field (and re-emitted as dipole radiation) is given by Pabs = (pE) = 2wIm($*)
0
= - Im(a)l EOC
(4)
The absorption results from the imaginary part of the polarizability, which describes the out-of-phase component of the dipole oscillation. Considering the light as a stream of photons hw, the absorption can be interpreted in terms of photon scattering in cycles of absorption and subsequent spontaneous reemission processes. The corresponding scattering rate is
We have now expressed the two main quantities of interest for dipole traps, the interaction potential and the scattered radiation power, in terms of the position-dependent field intensity Z(r) and the polarizability a(w). We point out that these expressions are valid for any polarizable neutral particle in an oscillating electric field. This can be an atom in a near-resonant or far offresonant laser field or even a molecule in an optical or microwave field. 2. Atomic Polarizability
In order to calculate its polarizability cr, we first consider the atom in Lorentz’s model of a classical oscillator. In this simple and very useful picture, an electron (mass m,,elementary charge e) is considered to be bound elastically to the core with an oscillation eigenfrequency 00 corresponding to the optical transition frequency. Damping results from the dipole radiation of the oscillating electron according to Larmor’s well-known formula (see, e.g., Jackson, 1962) for the power radiated by an accelerated charge. It is straightforward to calculate the polarizability by integration of the equation of motion 2 rmi w i x = - e E ( t ) / m , for the driven oscillation of
+
+
100
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
the electron, with the result
Here
202 ro= 671e&Ome c3
(7)
is the classical damping rate due to the radiative energy loss. Substituting e 2 / m e=~ K E O C ~ ~ , /and O ~ introducing the on-resonance damping rate I' = roo= (oo/o)21',,we put Eq. (6) into the form
In a semiclassical approach, described in many textbooks, the atomic polarizability can be calculated by considering the atom as a two-level quantum system interacting with the classical radiation field. One finds that when saturation effects can be neglected, the semiclassical calculation yields exactly the same result as the classical calculation with only one modification: In general, the damping rate (correspondingto the spontaneous decay rate of the excited level) can no longer be calculated from Larmor's formula but is determined by the dipole matrix element between the ground and excited states,
For many atoms with a strong dipole-allowed transition starting from the ground state, the classical formula Eq. (7) nevertheless provides a good approximation to the spontaneous decay rate. For the D lines of the alkali atoms Na, K, Rb, and Cs, the classical result agrees with the true decay rate to within a few percent. An important difference between the quantum-mechanical and the classical oscillator is the possible occurrence of saturation. At too high intensities of the driving field, the excited state gets strongly populated and Eq. (8) is no longer valid. For dipole trapping, however, we are essentially interested in the far-detuned case with very low saturation and thus very low scattering rates (rSc<< I?). We can therefore use expression Eq.(8) as an excellent approximation for the quantum-mechanical oscillator.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
101
3. Dipole Potential and Scattering Rate
With the above expression for the polarizability of the atomic oscillator, the following explicit expressions are derived for the dipole potential and the scattering rate in the relevant case of large detunings and negligible saturation:
These general expressions are valid for any driving frequency o and show two resonant contributions: Besides the usually considered resonance at 0 = 0 0 , there is also the so-called counter-rotating term resonant at 0
= -00.
In most experiments, the laser is tuned relatively close to the resonance at such that the detuning A _= o - 00 fulfills IAl << WO. In this case, the counter-rotating term can be neglected in the well-known rotating-wave approximation (see, e.g., Allen and Eberly, 1972), and one can set o/oo M 1 . With a few exceptions discussed in Section IV, this approximation will be made throughout this article. In this case of main practical interest, the general expressions for the dipole potential and the scattering rate simplify to 00
The basic physics of dipole trapping in far-detuned laser fields can be understood on the basis of these two equations. Obviously, a simple relation exists between the scattering rate and the dipole potential, ll
which is a direct consequence of the fundamental relation between the absorptive and dispersive response of the oscillator. Moreover, these equations show two very essential points for dipole trapping:
102
0
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiillel; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
Sign of detuning. Below an atomic resonance (“red” detuning, A < 0), the dipole potential is negative, and the interaction thus attracts atoms into the light field. Potential minima are therefore found at positions with maximum intensity. Above resonance (“blue” detuning, A > 0), the dipole interaction repels atoms out of the field, and potential minima correspond to minima of the intensity. According to this distinction, dipole traps can be divided into two main classes, red-detuned traps (Section IV) and blue-detuned traps (Section V). Scaling with intensig and detuning. The dipole potential scales as ]/A, whereas the scattering rate scales as ] / A 2 .Therefore, optical dipole traps generally use large detunings and high intensities to keep the scattering rate as low as possible at a certain potential depth.
B. MULTILEVEL ATOMS In real atoms used for dipole trapping experiments, the electronic transition has a complex substructure.The main consequence is that the dipole potential in general depends on the particular substate of the atom. This can lead to some quantitative modifications and to interesting new effects. In terms of the oscillator model we have discussed, multilevel atoms can be described by state-dependent atomic polarizabilities. Here we use an alternative picture that provides very intuitive insight into the motion of multilevel atoms in fardetuned laser fields: the concept of state-dependent ground-state potentials (Dalibard and Cohen-Tannoudji, 1985, 1989). Alkali atoms are discussed as of great practical importance, in order to clarify the role of fine structure, hyperfine structure, and magnetic substructure.
1. Ground-State Light Shifts and Optical Potentials The effect of far-detuned laser light on the atomic levels can be treated as a perturbation in second order of the electric field - that is, it is linear in terms of the field intensity. As a general result of second-order timeindependent perturbation theory for nondegenerate states, an interaction (Hamiltonian 3-11) leads to an energy shift of the ith state (unperturbed energy Ei)that is given by
For an atom interacting with laser light, the interaction Hamiltonian is = -bE, where fi = -er represents the electric dipole operator. For the
3-11
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
103
relevant energies &i, one has to apply a “dressed state” view (CohenTannoudji et al., 1992), considering the combined system “atom plus field.” In its ground state, the atom has zero internal energy, and the field energy is nho according to the number n of photons. This yields a total energy &i = nho for the unperturbed state. When the atom is put into an excited state by absorbing a photon, the sum of its internal energy hoo and the field energy (n - 1)ho becomes &, = hoo (n - 1)ho = -hag nho. Thus the denominator in Eq. (15) becomes &i - &j = hAy. For a two-level atom, the interaction Hamiltoman is ‘FI1 = - p E , and Eq. (15) simplifies to
+
+
for the ground and excited states (upper and lower signs, respectively); we have used the relation I = ~ E O C and I B Eq. ~ ~ (9) to substitute the dipole matrix element with the decay rate r. This perturbative result obtained for the energy shifts reveals a very interesting and important fact: The optically induced shift (known as the light shift or ac Stark shift) of the ground state exactly corresponds to the dipole potential for the two-level atom [Eq.(12)]; the excited state shows the opposite shift. In the interesting case of low saturation, the atom spends most of its time in the ground state, and we can interpret the light-shifted ground state as the relevant potential for the motion of atoms. This situation is illustrated in Fig. 1.
ho
104
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
For applying Eq. (15) to a multilevel atom with transition substructure,' one has to know the dipole matrix elements p, = (eilplgi) between specific electronic ground states Igi) and excited states le,). It is well known in atomic physics (see, e.g., Sobelman, 1979) that a specific transition matrix element
can be written as a product of a reduced matrix element 1IpJIand a real transition coefficient c,. The fully reduced matrix element depends on the electronic orbital wavefunctions only and is directly related to the spontaneous decay rate I'according to Eq. (9). The coefficients cd, which take into account the coupling strength between specific sublevels i and j of the electronic ground and excited states, depend on the laser polarization and the electronic and nuclear angular momenta involved. They can be calculated in the formalism of irreducible tensor operators or can be found in corresponding tables. With this reduction of the matrix elements, we can now write the energy shift of an electronic ground state Igi) in the form
where the summation is carried out over all electronically excited states lei). This means that for a calculation of the state-dependent ground-state dipole potential Udip,i= A&i,one has to sum up the contributions of all coupled excited states, taking into account the relevant line strengths c$ and detunings A,.
2. Alkali Atoms Most experiments in laser cooling and trapping are performed with alkali atoms, because their closed optical transitions lie in a convenient spectral range. The main properties of alkali atoms that are relevant for dipole trapping are summarized in Table I. As an example, the full-level scheme of the relevant ns + n p transition is shown in Fig. 2(a) for a nuclear spin I = 3/2, as in the case of 7Li, 23Na,39741K, and 87Rb.Spin-orbit coupling in the excited I Perturbation theory for nondegenerate states can be applied in the absence of any coupling between degenerate ground states. This is the case for pure linear II or circular of polarization, but not for mixed polarizations where Raman couplings between different magnetic substates become important; see, for example, Deutsch and Jessen (1997).
105
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
TABLE I ALKALI ATOMSTHAT ARE RELEVANT TO OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPPING: TRANSITION WAVELENGTHS h ~AND , Lo,, FINE-STRUCTURE SPLITTING Abs, NUCLEAR SPINI, GROUND-STATE HYPERFTNE SPLITTING Aws, EXCITED-STATE HYPERFINE SPLITTING Ahs, NATURALLINEWIDTH r, RECOILTEMPERATURE TmC(FOR THE D2 LINE), AND THE CORRESPONDING HEIGHTh,, = kaTRk,,/(mg)IN THE FIELD OF GRAVITY. PROPERTIESOF THE
~
670.9, 670.9 ‘Li 7 ~ i 23Na 589.0, 589.6 39K 766.7, 769.9
10 510 1500
WK 4’ K
85Rb 780.0, 794.8 7200 87Rb ‘ 3 3 c s 852.1, 894.3 16600
1 312 312 312 3 312 512 312 712
228 804 1772 462 1286 254 3036 6835 9192
5.9
4.6 18 I12 34 100 17 213 496 604
9.9 6.2
5.9
5.3
7.1 6.1 2.4 0.84 0.81 0.79 0.37 0.36 0.20
1000
740 88 18 17 16 3.7 3.5 1.3
F’=2 F’=l
F=2
(b)
- - - L’=l
1
b0
(4 - - - J’= +’
11
J’= Vz
J = V2
FIG.2. Level scheme of an alkali atom. (a) Full substructure for a nuclear spin I = j. (b) Reduced scheme for very large detunings that exceed the fine-structure splitting ([A1>> Ah). (c) Reduced scheme for large detunings in the range A h 2 IAI >> A m , A h s .
106
R. Grimm, M. Weidemuller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
state (energy-splittinghALS)leads to the well-known D-line doublet 2S1/2-+ 2 P 1 / 22,P 3 / 2 . The coupling to the nuclear spin then produces the hyperfine structure of both ground and excited states with energies h A ~ and s hALs, respectively. The splitting energies, obeying A & >> AWS>> A’Ws,represent the three relevant atomic energy scales. On the basis of Eq. (18), one can derive a general result for the potential of a ground state with total angular momentum F and magnetic quantum number mF, which is valid for both linear and circular polarization as long as all optical detunings stay large compared with the excited-state hyperfine splitting AfiFs:
Here g F is the well-known Land6 factor, the transition frequency 00 refers to the line center of the D doublet, and P characterizes the laser polarization (P = 0, f l for linearly and circularly of polarized light). The detunings A ~ , and F A ~ ,refer F to the energy splitting between the particular ground state 2S1/2,F and the center of the hyperfine-split 2P3/2 and 2P1/2excited states, respectively. The two terms in parentheses in Eq. (19) thus represent the contributions of the 0 2 and the D1 line to the total dipole potential. In order to discuss this result, let us first consider the case of very large ~ ~A;,), detunings greatly exceeding the fine-structuresplitting ( [ A ,1,, I A F , >> in which we can completely neglect the even much smaller hyperfine splitting. Introducing a detuning A with respect to the center of the D-line doublet, we can linearly expand Eq. (19) in terms of the small parameter AgS/A:
Although the first-order term describes a small residual dependence on the polarization P and the magnetic substate mF, the dominating zero-order term is just the result obtained for a two-level atom [Eq. (12)]. The latter fact can be understood in terms of a simple argument: If the fine structure is not resolved, then the detuning represents the leading term in the total Hamiltonian, and the atomic substructure can be ignored in a first perturbative step by reducing the atom to a very simple s --+ p transition; see Fig. 2(b).
* The assumption of unresolved excited-state hyperfine structure greatly simplifies the calculation according to Eq. (18) because of existing sum rules for the line strength coefficients c;; see also Deutsch and Jessen (1997).
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
107
Such a transition behaves like a two-level atom with the full line strength for any laser polarization, and the ground-state light shift is thus equal to that of a two-level atom. This single ground state couples to the electronic and nuclear spin in exactly the same way as it would without the light. In this simple case, all resulting hyperfine and magnetic substates directly acquire the light shift of the initial atomic s state. In the more general case of a resolved fine structure but an unresolved 1 1 , ,I A F ,>> ~ ~A w s ) , one may first consider hyperfine structure (Aks2 ~ A F the atom in spin-orbit coupling, neglecting the coupling to the nuclear spin. The interaction with the laser field can thus be considered in the electronic angular momentum configuration of the two D lines, J = t J ’ = $, In this situation, which is illustrated in Fig. 2(c), one can first calculate the light shifts of the two electronic ground states mJ = ki and, in a later step, consider their coupling to the nuclear spin. Here it is important to distinguish between linearly and circularly polarized light: For linear polarization, both electronic ground states (mJ= f1)are shifted by the same amount because of simple symmetry. After coupling to the nuclear spin, the resulting F, mF states have to remain degenerate like the two original mJ states. Consequently, all magnetic sublevels show the same light shifts according to the line strength factors of 2/3 for the DZ line and 1/3 for the D1 line. For circular polarization (a*),the light lifts the degeneracy of the two magnetic sublevels of the electronic 2S; ground state, and the situation gets more complicated. The relevant line strength factors are then given by $(1 f mJ) for the 0 2 line and +(1 2 m ~ for ) the D1 line. The lifted degeneracy of the two ground states can be interpreted in terms of a “fictitious magnetic field” (Cohen-Tannoudji and Dupont-Roc, 1972; Cho, 1997; Zielonkowski et al., 1998a), which is very useful in explaining how the lifted mJ degeneracy affects the F , m F levels after coupling to the nuclear spin. According to the usual theory of the linear Zeeman effect in weak magnetic fields, coupling to the nuclear spin affects the magnetic substructure such that one has to replace gJmJby gFmF, where gJ and g F denote the ground state Land6 factors. Applying this analogy, and using gJ = 2 for alkali atoms, we can replace mJ by igFmF to calculate the relevant line strength factors f(2 fg F m F ) and f ( 1 7 gFmF) for the 0 2 and ~1 lines, respectively. These factors lead to the mF-dependent shifts for circularly polarized light in Eq. (19). One finds that this result stays valid as long as the excited-state hyperfine splitting remains unresolved. For the photon-scattering rate rscof a multilevel atom, the same line strength factors are relevant as for the dipole potential, because absorption and light shifts are determined by the same transititon matrix elements. For linear polarization, in the most general case A >> A h s considered here, one
i
i.
108
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller, and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
thus explicitely obtains
This result is independent of mF but in general depends on the hyperfine state F via the detunings. For linearly polarized light, optical pumping tends to distribute the population equally among the different mF states and thus leads to complete depolarization. If the detuning is large compared to the groundstate hyperfine splitting, then all substates F,mF are equally populated by redistribution via photon scattering. For circular polarization, Zeeman pumping effects become very important; they depend on the particular detuning regime, and we do not want to discuss them in more detail here. It is interesting to note that the general relation between dipole potential and scattering rate takes the simple form of Eq. (14) either if the contribution of one of the two D lines dominates for rather small detunings or if the detuning is large compared to the fine-structure splitting. Our discussion on multilevel alkali atoms shows that linearly polarized light is usually the right choice for a dipole trap,3 because the magnetic sublevels mF of a certain hyperfine ground state F are shifted by the same amounts. This requires only a detuning large compared to the excited-state hyperfine splitting, a condition that is usually very well fulfilled in dipole trapping experiments. If the detuning also exceeds the ground-state hyperfine splitting, then all substates of the electronic ground state are equally shifted, and the dipole potential becomes completely independent of mF and F. For circularly polarized light, there is a mF-dependent contribution, which leads to a splitting analogous to a magnetic field. This term vanishes only if the optical detuning greatly exceeds the fine-structure splitting.
111. Experimental Issues Here we discuss several issues of practical importance for experiments on dipole trapping. Cooling and heating in the trap are considered in Section III.A, followed by a summary of the typical experimental procedures in Section 1II.B. Finally, in Section III.C, the particular role of collisions is discussed. 3An interesting exception is the work by Corwin er al. (1997) on trapping in circularly polarized light; see also Section IV.A.2.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
109
A. COOLING AND HEATING Atom trapping in dipole potentials requires cooling to load the trap and eventually also to counteract heating in the dipole trap. We briefly review the various available cooling methods and their specific features with respect to dipole trapping. Then we discuss sources of heating, and we derive explicit expressions for the heating rate in the case of thermal equilibrium in a dipole trap. This allows for a direct comparison between dipole traps operating with red and blue detuning.
1. Cooling Methods Efficient cooling techniques are an essential requirement to load atoms into a dipole trap because the attainable trap depths are generally below 1 mK. Once the atoms are trapped, further cooling can be applied to achieve high phasespace densities and to compensate for the effects of possible heating mechanisms (see Section III.A.2) that would otherwise boil the atoms out of the trap. The development of cooling methods for neutral atoms has proceeded at breathtaking speed during the last decade, and numerous excellent reviews have been written illuminating these developments (Foot, 1991; Arimondo et al., 1992; Metcalf and van der Straten, 1994; Sengstock and Ertmer, 1995; Ketterle and van Druten, 1996; Adams and Riis, 1997; Chu, 1998; Cohen-Tannoudji, 1998; Phillips, 1998). In this section, we briefly discuss methods for cooling atoms in dipole traps. Sections IVand V describe the experimental implementation of the cooling schemes in particular trap configurations. Doppler Cooling. Doppler cooling is based on cycles of near-resonant absorption of a photon and subsequent spontaneous emission resulting in a net atomic momentum change per cycle of one photon momentum hk, with k = 2n/h denoting the wavenumber of the absorbed photon. Cooling is counteracted by heating due to the momentum fluctuations by the recoil of the spontaneously emitted photons (Minogin and Letokhov, 1987). Equilibrium between cooling and heating determines the lowest achievable temperature. For Doppler cooling of two-level atoms in standing waves (“optical molasses”), the minimum temperature is given by the Doppler temperature ksTD = hr/2. Typical values of the Doppler temperature are around 100pK, which is just low enough to load atoms into a deep dipole trap. The first demonstration of dipole trapping (Chu et al., 1986) used Doppler cooling to load the trap and keep the atoms from being boiled out of the trap. With the discovery of methods reaching much lower temperatures, Doppler cooling has lost its importance for the direct application to dipole traps.
110
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiillec and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
Polarization-Gradient Cooling. The Doppler temperature is a somewhat artificial limit because it is based on the simplifying assumption of a two-level atom. It was soon discovered that atoms with a more complex level structure can be cooled below TO in standing waves with spatially varying polarizations (Lett et af., 1988). The cooling mechanisms are based on optical pumping between ground-state Zeeman sublevels. The friction force that provides cooling results either from unbalanced radiation pressures through motioninduced atomic orientation or from a redistribution among the photons in the standing wave (Dalibard and Cohen-Tannoudji, 1989). In the latter case, the cooling force can be explained in terms of the so-called Sisyphus effect for a moving atom. The atom loses kinetic energy by climbing up the dipole potential induced by the standing wave of the trapping light. Upon reaching the top of this potential “hill,” the atom is optically pumped back into the bottom of the next potential “valley,” from where it starts to climb again (Dalibard and CohenTannoudji, 1985). Polarization-gradient cooling can be achieved in standing waves at frequencies below an atomic resonance (red-detuned molasses) (Lett et al., 1988; Salomon et al., 1990) as well as above an atomic resonance (blue-detunedmolasses)(Boiron etal., 1995; Hemmerich etal., 1995). In bluedetuned molasses, atoms primarily populate states that are decoupled from the light field, resulting in a reduction of photon scattering but also in a smaller cooling rate as compared to red-detuned molasses (Boiron et al., 1996). With polarization-gradient molasses, one can prepare free-space atomic samples at temperatures on the order of lOT,,, with the recoil temperature N
being defined as the temperature associated with the gain in kinetic energy by emission of one photon. For the alkali atoms, recoil temperatures are given in Table I. The achievable temperatures are much below the typical depth of a dipole trap. Polarization-gradientcooling therefore allows efficient loading of dipole traps (see Section III.B.1) either by cooling inside a magneto-optical trap (Steane and Foot, 1991) or by cooling in a short molasses phase before transfer into the dipole trap. Besides enhancing the loading efficiency, polarization-gradient cooling was directly applied to atoms trapped in a dipole potential by subjecting them to near-resonant standing waves with polarization gradients (Boiron et al., 1998; Winoto et al., 1999). Because the cooling mechanism relies on modification of the ground-state sublevels by the cooling light, a necessary condition for efficient cooling is the independence of the trapping potential from the Zeeman substate, which, in contrast to magnetic traps, can easily be fulfilled in dipole traps as explained in Section II.B.2.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
111
Raman Cooling. The recoil temperature marks the limit for cooling methods based on the repeated absorption and emission of photons, such as Doppler cooling and polarization-gradient cooling. To overcome this limit, different routes were explored to decouple the cold atoms from the resonant laser excitation once they have reached small velocities. All approaches are based on transitions with a narrow line width, which are thus extremely velocityselective, such as dark-state resonances (Aspect et al., 1988) or Raman transition between ground-state sublevels (Kasevich and Chu, 1992). With free atomic samples, the interaction time, and thus the spectral resolution determining the final temperature, was limited by the time the thermally expanding atomic cloud spent in the laser field (Davidson et al., 1994).Taking advantage of the long storage times in dipole traps, Raman cooling was shown to work efficiently for trapped atomic samples (Lee et al., 1994; Lee et al., 1996; Kuhn et al., 1996). The basic principle of Raman cooling is as follows: Raman pulses from two counterpropagating laser beams transfer atoms from one ground state 11) to another ground state 12),transferring 2hk m~mentum.~ Using sequences of Raman pulses with varying frequency width, detuning, and propagation direction, pulses can be tailored that excite all atoms except those with a velocity near v = 0 (Kasevich et al., 1992; Reichel et al., 1995; Kuhn et al., 1996). The cooling cycle is completed by a light pulse resonantly exciting atoms in state 12) in order to pump the atoms optically back to the 11) state through spontaneous emission. Each spontaneous emission randomizes the velocity distribution so that a fraction of atoms acquire a velocity M 0. By the repetition of many sequences of Raman pulses followed by optical pumping pulses, atoms are accumulated in a small-velocity interval around v = 0. The final width of the velocity distribution - that is, the temperature - is determined by the spectral resolution of the Raman pulses. In dipole traps, high resolution can be achieved by the long storage times. In addition, motional coupling of the degrees of freedom through the trap potential made it possible to cool the atomic motion in all three dimensions with Raman pulses applied along only one spatial direction (Lee ef al., 1996; Kuhn et al., 1996). Resolved-Sideband Raman Cooling. Cooling with well-resolved motional sidebands, a technique well known from laser cooling in ion traps (Ghosh, 1995), has also been applied to optical dipole traps (Hamann et al., 1998; Pemn et al., 1998; Vuletic et ul., 1998; Bouchoule et al., 1999). For resolvedsideband cooling, atoms must be tightly confined along (at least) one spatial dimension with oscillation frequencies oosc large enough to be resolved by Raman transitions between two ground-state levels. In contrast to the Raman The two states are, for example, the two hyperfine ground states of an alkali atom.
112
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
cooling discussed in the preceding paragraph, the confining potential of the trap is therefore a necessary prerequisite to the application of sideband cooling. Atomic motion in the tightly confining potential is described by a wavepacket formed by the superposition of vibrational states ~n.,,).In the LambDicke regime, where the rms size of the wavepacket is small compared to the wavelength of the cooling transition, an absorption-spontaneous emission cycle almost exclusively returns to the same vibrational state it started from (An.,, = 0). The Lamb-Dicke regime is reached by trapping atoms in dipole potentials formed in the interference pattern of far-detuned laser beams (see Sections 1V.B and 1V.C). Sideband cooling consists of repeated cycles of Raman pulses tuned to excite transitions with An.,, = -1, followed by an optical pumping pulse involving spontaneous emission back to the initial state with An.,, = 0. In this way, the motional ground state nos, = 0 is selectively populated because it is the only state that does not interact with the Raman pulses. Achievable temperatures are limited only by the separation and the width of the Raman sidebands determining the suppression of off-resonant excitation of the no,, = 0 state. A particularly elegant realization of sideband cooling was accomplished by using the trapping light itself to drive the Raman transition instead of applying additional laser fields (Hamann et al., 1998; Vuletic et al., 1998). For this purpose, a small magnetic field was applied, shifting the energy of two adjacent ground-state Zeeman sublevels relative to each other by exactly one vibrational quantum fro.,,. In this way, the bound states ImF;nosc)and I mF - 1; nosc - 1) became degenerate, and Raman transitions between the two states could be excited with single-frequency light provided by the trapping field (degenerate sideband cooling) (Deutsch and Jessen, 1998). The great advantage of degenerate sideband cooling is that it works with only the two lowest-energy atomic ground states being involved, resulting in the suppression of heating and trap losses caused by inelastic binary collisions (see Section 1II.C). Evaporative Cooling. Evaporative cooling, orginally demonstated with magnetically trapped hydrogen (Hess et al., 1987), has been the key technique for achieving Bose-Einstein condensation in magnetic traps (Ketterle and van Druten, 1996). It relies on the selective removal of high-energetic particles from a trap and subsequent thermalization of the remaining particles through elastic collisions. Evaporative cooling requires high densities to ensure fast thermalization rates, and it requires large initial numbers of particles because so many trapped atoms are removed from the trap by evaporation. For evaporative cooling to be effective, the ratio between inelastic collisions (causing losses and heating) and elastic collisions (providing thermalization and evaporation) has to be large.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
113
In dipole traps, inelastic processes can be greatly suppressed when the particles are prepared in their energetically lowest state. However, the requirement of large particle numbers and high density poses a dilemma for the application of evaporative cooling to dipole traps. In tightly confining dipole traps such as a crossed dipole trap, high peak densities can be reached, but the trapping volume, and thus the number of particles transferred into the trap, is small. On the other hand, large trapping volumes that yield large numbers of trapped particles provide only weak confinement, yielding small elastic-collision rates. This is why only one experiment has been reported on evaporative cooling in dipole traps starting with a small sample of atoms (Adams et al., 1995). By precooling large ensembles in dipole traps with optical methods explained in the preceding paragraphs, much better starting conditions for evaporative cooling are achievable (Engler et al., 1998; Vuletic et al., 1998; Winoto et al., 1999), and this means that evaporative cooling is still an interesting option for future applications. Adiabatic Expansion. When we adiabatically expand a potential without changing its shape, the temperature of the confined atoms is decreased without increasing the phase-space den~ity.~ In dipole potentials, cooling by adiabatic expansion was realized by slowly ramping down the intensity of the trapping light (Chen et al., 1992; Kastberg et al., 1995). In far-detuned traps consisting of micropotentials induced by interference, adiabatic cooling is particularly interesting when the modulation on the scale of the optical wavelength is slowly reduced without modifying the large-scale trapping potential - for example, by changing the polarization of the interfering laser beams. Atoms are initially strongly localized in the micropotentials, resulting in high peak densities. After adiabatic expansion, the temperature of the sample is reduced, as is the peak density. However, the density averaged over one period of the interference structure is not modified.
2. Heating Mechanisms Heating by the trap light is an issue of particular importance for optical dipole trapping. A fundamental source of heating is the spontaneous scattering of trap photons, which, because of its random nature, causes fluctuations of the radiation force.6 In the far-detuned case considered here, the scattering is completely elastic (or quasi-elastic if a Raman process changes the atomic 'Adiabatic changes of the potential shape leading to an increase of the phase-space density are demonstrated in Pinkse et al. (1997) and Stamper-Kurn et al. (1998b). Under conditions typical of a dipole trap, the scattering force that results in traveling-wave configurations stays very weak compared to the dipole force and can thus be neglected.
114
R. Grimm, M. Weidemullel; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
ground state). This means that the energy of the scattered photon is determined by the frequency of the laser, not of the optical transition. Both absorption and spontaneous re-emission processes show fluctuations, and thus both contribute to the total heating (Minogin and Letokhov, 1987). At large detunings, where scattering processes follow Poisson statistics, the heating due to fluctuations in absorption corresponds to an increase of the thermal energy by exactly the recoil energy Er, = k~Trec/2per scattering event. This first contribution occurs in the propagation direction of the light field and is thus anisotropic (so-called directional diffusion). The second contribution is due to the random direction of the photon recoil in spontaneous emission. This heating also increases the thermal energy by one recoil energy Ere, per scattering event, but distributed over all three dimensions. Neglecting the general dependence on the polarization of the spontaneously emitted photons, one can assume an isotropic distribution for this heating mechanism. Taking into account both contributions, the longitudinal motion is heated on an average by 4E,/3 per scattering process, whereas each of the two transverse dimensions is heated by EreC/3.The overall heating thus corresponds to an increase of the total thermal energy by 2Erec in a time I';. For simplicity, we do not consider the generally anisotropic character of heating here; in most cases of interest, the trap mixes the motional degrees on a time scale faster than or comparable to the heating. .We can thus use a simple global three-dimensional heating power &at =E corresponding to the increase of the mean thermal energy E of the atomic motion with time. This heating power is directly related to the average photon-scattering rate by
rSc
It is well known that for intense light fields close to resonance, in particular in standing-waveconfigurations,the induced redistribution of photons between different traveling-wave components can lead to dramatic heating (Gordon and Ashkin, 1980; Dalibard and Cohen-Tannoudji, 1985). In the far off-resonant case, however, this induced heating falls off very rapidly with the detuning and is usually completely negligible as compared to spontaneous heating. In addition to the fundamental heating in dipole traps, Savard et al. (1997) have pointed out that technical heating can occur because of intensity fluctuations and pointing instabilities in the trapping fields. In the first case, fluctuations occurring at twice the characteristic trap frequencies are relevant; they can parametrically drive the oscillatory atomic motion. In the second case, a shaking of the potential at the trap frequencies increases the motional amplitude. These issues have not been studied in detail yet, but they will strongly depend on the particular laser source and its technical noise spectrum. Several experiments have indeed shown indications of heating in dipole
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
115
traps by unidentified mechanisms (Adams et al., 1995; Lee et al., 1996; Zielonkowski et al., 1998b; Vuletic et al., 1998), which may be related to fluctuations of the trapping light. 3. Heating Rate For an ultracold atomic gas in a dipole trap, it is often a good assumption to consider a thermal equilibrium situation, in which the energy distribution is related to a temperature T. The further assumption of a power-law potential then allows one to derive very useful expressions for the mean photonscattering rate and the corresponding heating rate of the ensemble, which also illustrate important differences between traps operating with red- and bluedetuned light. In thermal equilibrium, the mean kinetic energy per atom in a threedimensional trap is ,!?kin = 3 k B T/2. Introducing the parameter K = Epot/Ehn as the ratio of potential to kinetic energy, we can express the mean total energy E as
For many real dipole traps as described in Sections IV and V, it is a good approximation to assume a separable power-law potential with a constant offset Lro of the form U(X,y , z ) = uo
+ a,xn' + a2yn2 + a3zn3
(25)
In such a case, the virial theorem can be used to calculate the ratio between potential and kinetic energy:
For a three-dimensional harmonic trap this gives K = 1, for an ideal threedimensional box potential K = 0. The relation between mean energy and temperature, Eq. (24), allows us to re-express the heating power that results from photon scattering, Eq. (23), as a heating rate
describing the corresponding increase of temperature with time.
116
R. Grimm, M. Weidemuller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
1
--
U
I
FIG.3. Illustration of dipole traps with red and blue detuning. In the first case, a simple Gaussian laser beam is assumed. In the second case, a Laguerre-Gaussian LGol “doughnut” mode is chosen that provides the same potential depth and the same curvature in the trap center (note that the latter case requires e 2 times more laser power or smaller detuning).
r,,
The mean scattering rate can, in turn, be calculated from the temperature of the sample, according to the following arguments: Equation (14) relates the average scattering rate to the mean dipole potential u d i p experienced by the atoms. In a pure dipole trap7 described by Eq. (25), the mean optical potential is related to the mean potential energy EPt, the mean kinetic energy ,!?kin, and the temperature T by udjp
+
= U O E p t = Uo
+ K E b n = UO+-3K2 T
(28)
This relation allows us to express the mean scattering rate as
On the basis of this result, let us now discuss two specific situations that are typical for real experiments as described in Sections IV and V; see illustrations in Fig. 3. In a red-detuned dipole trap (A < 0), the atoms are trapped in an intensity maximum with Uo < 0, and the trap depth U = [Uol is usually large compared to the thermal energy ~ B TIn. a blue-detuned trap (A > 0), a potential minimum corresponds to an intensity minimum, which in an ideal case means zero intensity. In this case U O= 0, and the potential depth U is determined by the height of the respulsive walls surrounding the center of the trap. For red- and blue-detuned traps with U >> kBT, Eqs. (27) and (29) yield the following heating rates:
’
This excludes hybrid potentials, in which other fields (gravity, magnetic, or electric fields) are important for the trapping.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
117
Obviously, a red-detuned trap shows linear heating (which decreases when ks T approaches whereas heating behaves exponentially in a blue-detuned trap. Note that in blue-detuned traps, a fundamental lower limit to heating is set by the zero-point energy of the atomic motion, which we have neglected in our classical consideration. Equations 30a and 30b allow for a very illustrative direct comparison between a blue- and red-detuned trap: The ratio of heating at the same magnitude of detuning [A[is given by
u),
This comparison shows that blue detuning offers substantial advantages in two experimental situations: 0
U
0
K
>> k B T , very deep potentials for tight confinement << 1, box-like potentials with hard repulsive walls
In other words, when a harmonic potential of moderate depth is to be realized for a certain experiment, the advantage of blue detuning is not substantial. The choice of red detuning may be even more appropriate, because the better concentration of the available laser power in such a trap allows one to use larger detunings to create the required potential depth.
B. EXPERIMENTAL TECHNIQUES I . Trap Loading The standard way to load a dipole trap is to start from a magneto-optical trap (MOT). This well-known radiation-pressure trap operating with near-resonant light was first demonstrated by Raab et af., in 1987 and has become the standard source of ultracold atoms in many laboratories all over the world. A MOT can provide temperatures down to a few lOT, when its operation is optimized for sub-Doppler cooling (see Section IH.A.1). This sets a natural scale for the minimum depth of a dipole trap as required for efficient loading. Because of their lower recoil temperatures (Table I), heavier alkali atoms require less trap depth than the lighter ones and thus allow for larger detunings. For the heavy Cs atoms, for example, dipole traps with depths as low as 10 pK can be directly loaded from a MOT (Zielonkowskiet al., 1998b).Trap N
118
R. Grimm, M . Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
loading at much lower depths can be achieved with Bose-Einstein condensates (Stamper-Kum et al., 1998a). For dipole trap loading, a MOT is typically operated in two stages. First, its frequency detuning is set quite close to resonance (detuning of a few natural linewidths) to optimize capture by the resonant scattering force. Then, after the loading phase, the MOT parameters are changed to optimize sub-Doppler cooling (Drewsen et al., 1994; Townsend et al., 1995). Most important, the detuning is switched to much higher values (typically 10- 20 linewidths), and eventually the laser intensity is lowered. For the heavier alkali atoms,8 this procedure provides maximum phase-space densities for trap loading. Another option is to ramp up the magnetic fields of the MOT to compress the sample spatially (Petrich et al., 1994). The dipole trap is filled by simply overlapping it with the atomic cloud in the MOT before the latter is turned off. In this procedure, it is advantageous to switch off the magnetic field of the MOT a few milliseconds before the laser fields are extinguished,because the short optical molasses cooling phase that results establishes the lowest possible temperatures and a quasi-thermal distribution in the trap. For practical reasons, the latter is important because a MOT does not necessarily load the atoms into the very center of the dipole trap. When MOT position and dipole trap center do not coincide exactly, loading results in excess potential energy in the dipole trap. When the MOT light is extinguished, it is very important to shield the dipole trap from any resonant stray light, particularly if very low scattering rates ( 51 s-') are to be reached. The MOT itself can be loaded in a simple vapor cell (Monroe et al., 1990). In such a setup, however, the lifetime of the dipole trap is typically limited to less than 1 s by collisions with atoms in the background gas. If longer lifetimes are required for a certain application, the loading of the MOT under much better vacuum conditions becomes an important issue, as in experiments on Bose-Einstein condensation. Loading can then the accomplished from a very dilute vapor (Anderson et al., 1994), but more powerful concepts can be realized with a Zeeman-slowed atomic beam (Phillips and Metcalf, 1982), with a double-MOT setup (Myatt et al., 1997), or with slow-atom sources based on modified MOTS (Lu et al., 1996, Dieckmann et al., 1998). Regarding trap loading, a dipole trap with red detuning can offer an important advantage over a blue-detuned trap. When MOT and dipole trap are turned on simultaneously, the attractive dipole potential leads to a local density increase in the MOT, which can substantially enhance the loading process. In very deep red-detuned traps, however, the level shifts become too *The lightest alkali atom, Li, behaves in a completely different way. Here optimum loading is accomplished at larger detunings, and optimum cooling is obtained relatively close to resonance (Schiinemann et al., 1998).
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
119
large for the cooling light, and efficient loading requires rapid alternation between cooling and trapping light (Miller et al., 1993).
2. Diagnostics The atomic sample in a dipole trap is characterized by the number of stored atoms, the motional temperature of the ensemble (under the assumption of thermal distributon), and the distribution of population among the different ground-state sublevels. Measurements of these important quantities can be made in the following ways. Number of Atoms. A very simple and efficient method that is often used to determine the number of atoms in a dipole trap is to recapture them into the MOT and to measure the power of the emitted fluorescence light with a calibrated photo-diode or CCD camera. In this way, it is quite easy to detect down to about 100 atoms, but even single atoms may be observed in a more elaborate setup (Haubrich et al., 1996). This recapture method works particularly well if it is ensured that the MOT does not capture any other atoms than those released from the dipole trap. This is hardly possible in a simple vapor cell setup, but it is quite easy if an atomic beam equipped with a mechanical shutter is used for loading the MOT. In contrast to the completely destructive recapture, several other methods may be applied. The trapped atoms can be illuminated with a short resonant laser pulse of moderate intensity to measure the emitted fluorescent light. This can be done also with spatial resolution by using a CCD camera; see Fig. 18(b)for an example. If the total number of atoms is not too low, the detection pulse can be kept weak enough to avoid trap loss by heating. Furthermore, absorption imaging can be used (see Fig. 7), or even more sensitive and less destructive dark-field or phase-contrast imaging methods can be applied to monitor Bose-Einstein condensates sensitively (Andrews et al., 1996; Bradley et al., 1997; Andrews et al., 1997). Temperature. In a given trapping potential U(r), the thermal density distribution n ( r ) directly follows from the Boltzmann factor,
n(r) = noexp
(
2)
--
The temperature can thus be derived from the measured spatial-density distribution in the trap, which itself can be observed by various imaging methods (fluorescence, absorptive, and dispersive imaging). For a three-dimensional
120
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiillel; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
harmonic potential U(r) = im (02 x 2 + o ; y 2 tion is Gaussian in all directions,
+ 01z2),the resulting distribu-
with oi = o ; ' J w . The temperature is thus related to the spatial extensions of the trapped atom cloud by
T = -m( T i m2 i
2
(34)
kB
Obviously, it is very important to know the exact trap frequencies to determine the temperature precisely; a practical example of such a measurement is discussed in connection with Fig. 7(b). This way of measuring the temperature is limited by the resolution of the imaging system and therefore becomes difficult for very tightly confining potentials. A widely used and quite accurate, but completely destructive, way to measure temperatures is the time-of-flight method. The trap is turned off to release the atoms into a free, ballistic flight. This has to be done in a rapid, completely nonadiabatic way; otherwise, an adiabatic cooling effect (see Section 1II.A.1) would influence the measurement. After a sufficiently long ballistic expansion phase, the resulting spatial distribution, which can again be observed by the various imaging methods, directly reflects the velocity distribution at the time of release. Another method, which is not limited by the natural linewidth of the optical transition, is to detect the Doppler broadening of Raman transitions between ground states, using a pair of counterpropagating laser beams (Kasevich and Chu, 1991). Internal Distribution. The relative population of the two hyperfine ground states of an alkali atom (see the level scheme in Fig. 2) can be measured by application of a probe pulse resonant to the closed subtransition F = I + 1/2 + F' = I + 3/2 in the hyperfine structure, which is well resolved for the heavier alkali atoms (see Table I). The fluorescence light is then proportional to the number of atoms in the upper hyperfine state, F = I 1/2. If, in contrast, a repumping field is present in the probe light (as it is always used in a MOT),the fluorescence is proportional to the total number of atoms, because all atoms are immediately pumped into the closed excitation cycle. The normalized fluorescence signal thus gives the relative population of the upper hyperfine ground state (F = I + 1/2); such a measurement is discussed in Section IV.A.2. A very sensitive alternative, which works very well in
+
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
121
shallow dipole traps, is to blow the total upper-state population out of the trap by the radiation pressure of an appropriate resonant light pulse. Subsequent recapture into the MOT then shows how many atoms have remained trapped in the shelved lower hyperfine ground state. The distribution of population over different magnetic substates can be analyzed by Stern-Gerlach methods. When the atomic ensemble is released from the dipole trap and ballistically expands in an inhomogeneous magnetic field, atoms in different magnetic sublevels can be well separated in space. Such an analysis has been used for optically trapped Bose-Einstein condensates (Stamper-Kurn et al., 1998a; Stenger, 1998); an example is shown in Fig. 8(b). Another possibility, which can be easily applied to shallow dipole traps, is to pull atoms out of the trap by the state-dependent magnetic force, a technique that Zielonkowski et al. (1998b) have used for measuring the depolarizing effect of the trap photon scattering; see the discussion in Section IV.B.3.
C. COLLISIONS It is a well-known experimental fact in the field of laser cooling and trapping that collisional processes can lead to substantial trap loss. Detailed measurements of trap loss under various conditions provide insight into ultracoldcollision phenomena, which have been the subject of extensive research (Walker and Feng, 1994; Weiner, 1995). Here we discuss the particular features of dipole traps with respect to ultracold collisions. The decay of the number N of atoms in a trap can be described by the general loss equation
Here the single-particle loss coefficient a takes into account collisions with the background gas in the vacuum apparatus. As a rule of thumb, the l/e lifetime T = 1/aof a dipole trap is 1s at a pressure of 3 x lO-’mbar. This is about three times lower than the corresponding lifetime in a MOT because of the larger cross sections for collisional loss at lower trap depth. The two-body loss coefficient p describes trap loss due to ultracold binary collisions and reveals a wide range of interesting physics. In general, such trap loss becomes important if the colliding atoms are not in their absolute ground state. In an inelastic process, the internal energy can be released into the atomic motion, causing escape from the trap. Because of the shallowness of optical dipole traps, even the collisional release of the relatively small amount of energy in the ground-state hyperfine structure of an alkali atom always N
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
122
E
0.1
0
0.5
1
1.5 time (s)
2
2.5
3
FIG.4. Decay of Cs atoms measured in a crossed-beam dipole trap (see Section 1V.C) realized with the 1064-nm light of a Nd:YAG laser. The initial peak density is 2.5 x 10l2~ m - ~ . When all atoms are in the lower hyperfine ground state (F = 3), the purely exponential decay (l/e-lifetime 1.1 s) is due to collisions with the background gas. When the atoms are in the upper hyperfme level (F = 4). a dramatic loss is observed as a result of hyperfine-changing collisions (loss coefficient p M 5 x lo-" cm3/s). Unpublished data, courtesy of C. Salomon.
leads to trap l0s.5.~Hyperjne-changingcollisions,which occur with large rate coefficients p of typically 5 x 10-"cm3/s (Sesko er al., 1989; Wallace er al., 1992), are thus of particular importance for dipole trapping. Alkali atoms in the upper hyperfine state (F = I + 1/2) can show very rapid, nonexponential collisional decay, in contrast to a sample in the lower ground state (F = I - 1/2). This is impressively demonstrated by the measurement in Fig. 4,which shows the decay of a sample of Cs atoms prepared either in the upper or the lower hyperfine ground state. For the implementation of laser cooling schemes in dipole traps, it is thus very important to keep the atoms predominantly in the lower hyperfine state; several schemes for meeting this requirement are discussed in Sections IV and V. Trap loss can also occur as a result of light-assisted binary collisions involving atoms in the excited state. The radiative escape mechanism (Gallagher and Pritchard, 1989) and excited-state fine-structure-changing collisions strongly affect a MOT, but their influence is negligibly small in a dipole trap because of the extremely low optical excitation. It can become important, however, if near-resonant cooling light is present. Another important mechanism for trap loss is photoassociation (Lett er al., 1995), a process In contrast, a MOT operated under optimum capture conditions is deep enough to hold atoms after hyperfine-changing collisions.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR MEUTRAL ATOMS
123
in which colliding atoms are excited to bound molecular states, which then decay via bound-bound or bound-free transitions. Dipole traps indeed represent a powerful tool for photoassociative spectroscopy (Miller et al., 1993b). Three-body losses, as described by the coefficient y in Q. ( 3 3 , become relevant only at extremely high densities (Burt et al., 1997; Stamper-Kurn et al., 1998a) far exceeding the conditions of a MOT.In a collision of three atoms, a bound dimer can be formed and the third atom takes up the released energy, so all three atoms are lost from the trap. Because a far-detuned dipole trap allows one to suppress binary collision losses completely by putting the atoms into the absolute internal ground state, it represents an interesting tool for measurements on three-body collisions; an example is discussed in Section IV.A.4. In contrast to inelastic collisions releasing energy, elastic collisions lead to a thermalization of the trapped atomic ensemble. This also produces a few atoms with energies substantially exceeding kBT. A loss of these energetic atoms in a shallow trap leads to evaporative cooling (see Section III.A.l) and is thus of great interest for the attainment of Bose-Einstein condensation. In terms of the basic physics of elastic collisions, dipole traps are not different from magnetic traps, but they offer additional experimental possibilities. By application of a homogeneous magnetic field, atomic scattering properties can be tuned without affecting the trapping itself. Using this advantage of dipole trapping, Feshbach resonances have been observed with Bose-condensed Na atoms (Inouye et al., 1998) and thermal Rb atoms (Courteille et al., 1998). Moreover, an intriguing possibility is to study collisions in an arbitrary mixture of atoms in different magnetic substates (Stenger et al., 1998).
IV. Red-Detuned Dipole Waps The dipole force points toward increasing intensity if the light field is tuned below the atomic transition frequency (red detuning). Therefore, already the focus of a laser beam constitutes a stable dipole trap for atoms as first proposed by Ashkin (1978). The trapping forces generated by intense focused lasers are rather feeble, which was the main obstacle for trapping neutral atoms in dipole traps. Attainable trap depths in a tightly focused beam are typically in the millikelvin range, orders of magnitude smaller than the thermal energy of room-temperature atoms. One therefore had to first develop efficient laser cooling methods for the preparation of cold atom sources (see Section 1II.A. 1) to transfer significant numbers of atoms into a dipole trap. In their decisive experiment, S. Chu and coworkers (1986) succeeded in holding about 500 sodium atoms for several seconds in the tight focus of a red-detuned laser beam. Doppler molasses cooling was used to load atoms
124
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
L
7r FIG.5. Beam configurations used for red-detuned far off-resonance traps. Shown below are the corresponding calculated intensity distributions. (a) Horizontal focused-beam trap. (b) Vertical standing-wavetrap. (c) Crossed-beamtrap. The waist wo and the Rayleigh length ZR are indicated.
into the trap, which was operated at high intensities and considerable atomic excitation in order to provide a sufficiently deep trapping potential. Under these circumstances, the radiation pressure force still significantly influences the trapping potential due to a considerable rate of spontaneous emission. With the development of sub-Doppler cooling (see Section III.A.l) and the invention of the magneto-optical trap as a source for dense, cold atomic samples (see Section 1II.B.l), dipole trapping of atoms regained attention with the demonstration of a far-off resonant trap by Miller et al. (1993). In such a trap, spontaneous emission of photons is negligible, and the trapping potential is given by the equations derived in Section 11. Since then, three major types of traps with red-detuned laser beams have been established, all based on combinations of focused Gaussian beams: focused-beam traps consisting of a single beam, standing-wave traps wherein atoms are axially confined in the antinodes of a standing wave, and crossedbeam traps created by two or more beams intersecting at their foci. These different types of traps are schematically depicted in Fig. 5. We shall discuss these trap configurations and review applications of the different types for the investigation of interesting physical questions. Section 1V.A deals with focused-beam traps, Section 1V.B presents standing-wave traps, and Section V1.C discusses crossed-beam traps. Far-detuned optical lattices
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
125
trapping atoms in micropotentials formed by multiple-beam interference represent a trap class of their own. Atoms might get trapped in the antinodes of the interference pattern at red detuning from resonance, but also in the nodes when the light field is blue-detuned. Section 1V.D is devoted to recent developments in far-detuned optical lattices. A. FOCUSED-BEAM TRAPS A focused Gaussian laser beam tuned far below the atomic resonance frequency represents the simplest way to create a dipole trap providing threedimensional confinement [see Fig. 5(a)]. The spatial intensity distribution of a focused Gaussian beam (FB)with power P propagating along the z-axis is described by
where r denotes the radial coordinate. The l/e2 radius w(z)depends on the axial coordinate z via
where the minimum radius wo is called the beam waist and Z R = mv$i denotes the Rayleigh length. From the intensity distribution, one can derive the optical potential U ( r , z )cx Zm(r,z) using Eq. (lo), (12), or (19). The trap depth U is given by U = I U (r = 0, z = 0)1. The Rayleigh length ZR is larger than the beam waist by a factor of xwo/h. Therefore, the potential is much steeper in the radial direction than in the axial direction. To provide stable trapping, one has to ensure that the gravitational force does not exceed the confining dipole force. Focused-beam traps are therefore mostly aligned along the horizontal axis. In this case, the strong radial force U/WOminimizes the perturbing effects of gravity." If the thermal energy k B T of an atomic ensemble is much smaller than the potential depth U , the extension of the atomic sample is radially small compared to the beam waist and is axially small compared to the Rayleigh range. In this case, the optical potential can be well approximated by a simple N
l o A new type of trap for the compensation of gravity was presented by Lemonde et al. (1995). It combines a focused-beam dipole trap providing radial confinement with an inhomogeneous static electric field along the vertical z-axis, inducing tight axial confinement through the dc Stark effect.
126
R. Grimm, M. Weidemuller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
cylindrically symmetric harmonic oscillator,
2 112 The oscillation frequencies of a trapped atom are given by o r= (4fi/rnwo) in the radial direction and by w, = (2.0/mz;)''* in the axial direction. According to Eq. (25), the harmonic potential represents an important special case of a power-law potential for which thermal equilibrium properties are discussed in Section 111.
I . Collisional Studies In their pioneering work on far off-resonance traps (FORT), Miller et al. (1993a), at the University of Texas in Austin, have observed trapping of *'Rb atoms in the focus of a single, linearly polarized Gaussian beam with detunings from the D1 resonance of up to 65 nm. The laser beam was focused to a waist of 10 pm, creating trap depths in the millikelvin-range. Between lo3 and lo4 atoms were accumulated in the trap from lo6 atoms provided by a vapor cell MOT. Small transfer efficiencies are a general property of traps with tightly focused beams resulting from the small spatial overlap between the cloud of atoms in the MOT. Typical temperatures in the trap are below 1 mK, which results in densities close to 10l2atoms/cm3. Peak photon-scattering rates were a few hundred per second, leading to negligible rates of loss by photon heating as compared to losses by background gas collisions. High densities achieved in a tightly-focused beam, in combination with long storage times, offer ideal conditions for the investigation of collisions between trapped atoms. The trap lifetime without cooling illustrated in Fig. 6(a) showed an increase of the lifetime by about an order of magnitude for increasing detunings at rather small detunings. At larger detunings, the lifetime was found to be determined by the Rb background pressure of the vapor-cell to a value of about 200 ms. The shorter lifetimes at smaller detunings were explained in a later publication (Miller et al., 1993b) by losses through photoassociation of excited Rb2 dimers that were induced by the trapping light. This important discovery has inspired a whole series of experiments on ultracold collisions investigated by the Austin group with photoassociation spectroscopy in a dipole trap. Instead of using the trapping light, photoassociation was induced by additional lasers in later experiments. The investigations comprise collisional properties and long-range interaction potentials of ground state atoms, (Cline et al., 1994b; Gardner et al., 1995), shape resonances in cold collisions (Boesten et al., 1997; Tsai et al., 1997), and the observation of Feshbach resonances (Courteille et al., 1998).
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
127
40
790 8M) 810 820 830 840 850 860 870 Dipde Trap Wavelength (nm)
0.1
0.01 f .I 790
810 830 850 trap laser wavelength (nm)
1 870
FIG. 6. Measurement of trap lifetimes and hyperfine relaxation times for Rb atoms in a fardetuned focused-beam trap. (a) Trap decay time as a function of the trapping-beam wavelength. From Miller et al. (1993a). (b) Time constant trel for hyperfine population relaxation versus trapping-beam wavelength, in comparison to the mean time ts between two spontaneous scattering events. From Cline et al. (1994), 0Optical Society of America.
2. Spin Relaxation If the detuning of the trapping light field is larger than fine-structure splitting of the excited state, photon scattering occurs almost exclusively into the elastic Rayleigh component. Inelastic Raman scattering changing the hyperfine ground state is reduced by a factor of about 1/A2 as compared to Rayleigh scattering. The Austin group demonstrated this effect by preparing all trapped 85Rbatoms in the lower hyperfine ground state and studying the temporal evolution of the higher hyperfine state (Cline et al., 1994a). The relaxation-time constant as a function of detuning is plotted in Fig. 6(b) in comparison to the calculated For large detunings, average time between two photon-scatteringevents T~=rsc. the relaxation-time constant ~ , 1 is found to exceed T~ by two orders of magnitude. This shows the great potential of far-detuned optical dipole traps for manipulation of internal atomic degrees of freedom over long time intervals.
128
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller;and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
Using the spin state dependence of the dipole potential in a circularly polarized light beam (see Section II.B.2), Corwin et al. (1997) from the University of Colorado at Boulder have investigated far-off resonance dipole traps that selectively hold only one spin state. The small spin relaxation rates in dipole traps may have useful applications in the search for beta-decay asymmetries and atomic parity violation. 3. Polarization-Gradient Cooling Polarization-gradient cooling in a focused-beam trap has been investigated by a group at the ENS in Paris (Boiron et al., 1998). The trapped atoms were subjected to blue-detuned molasses cooling in a near-resonant standing wave (see Section 1II.A.1). Previously, the same group had performed experiments on polarization-gradient cooling of free atomic samples that were isotropically distributed. A density-dependent heating mechanism was found to be limiting the achievable final temperatures for a given density (Boiron et al., 1996). This heating was attributed to reabsorption of the scattered cooling light within the dense cloud of cold atoms. Of particular interest was the question of whether the anisotropic geometry of a focused beam influences heating processes through multiple photon scattering. Cesium atoms were trapped in the focus (wg = 45 pm) of a 700-mW horizontally propagating Nd:YAG laser beam at 1064 nm. The trap had a depth of 50 pK, and the radial trapping force exceeded gravity by roughly one order of magnitude. From a MOT containing 3 x lo7 atoms, 2 x lo5 atoms were loaded into the trap.' Polarization-gradient cooling was applied for some tens of milliseconds, yielding temperatures between 1 and 3pK, depending on the cooling parameters. To avoid trap losses by inelastic binary collisions involving the upper hyperfine ground state (see Section III.C), the cooling scheme was chosen in such a way that the population of the upper hyperfine ground state was kept at a low level. An absorption image of the trapped cesium atoms at T = 2 pK is depicted in Fig. 7(a), which shows the rod-shaped cloud of atoms. The distribution of atoms had a radial extension (T, = 6 pm and an axial size crZ = 300 pm corresponding to a peak density of 1 x lo'* atoms/cm3. The picture was taken 30ms after the cooling had been turned off. The time interval is large compared to the radial oscillation period (w,/2x = 330Hz) but short compared to the axial oscillation period (oZ/2x = 1.8 Hz). In this transient regime, the axial distribution had not yet reached its thermal equilibrium extension of (T, = 950 pm, which leads to a decrease in density. For the radial extension, the measured value coincided with the expectation for thermal
'
-
I'
The Nd:YAG beam was continuously on during the MOT loading.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
129
FIG.7. Properties of a horizontal focused-beam trap for Cs atoms. (a) Absorption image of the atom distribution. The transverse rms radius in the focal plane is 6 pm. (b) Measurement of the vertical oscillation period (see text). Adapted from Boiron et al. (1998).
equilibrium as determined by the measured temperature and oscillation frequency [see Eq. (34)l. To measure the transverse oscillation frequency, the Nd:YAG beam was interrupted for about 1ms, during which time the cold atoms were accelerated by gravity to a mean velocity of about 1cm/s. After the trapping laser had been turned on again, the atoms vertically oscillated in the trap. The oscillation in vertial velocity was detected by measuring the mean arrival time of the atoms at a probe laser beam 12 cm below the trap [the ordinate in Fig. 7(b)] as a function of the trapping time intervals [the abscissa in Fig. 7(b)]. The measured vertical oscillation frequency o r= 330Hz is consistent with the value o r= 390 Hz derived from the trap depth and the beam waist. The temperatures measured in the dipole trap were about 30 times lower than one would expect on the basis of the heating rates found for an isotropic free-space sample at the corresponding densities (Boiron et al., 1995). No evidence was found for heating of the trapped sample. The reduction of density-dependent heating is a benefit derived from the strongly anisotropic trapping geometry of a focused-beam trap. Because of the much smaller volume-to-surface ratio of an atomic cloud in the focused-beam trap as compared to a spherical distribution, photons emitted during cooling have a higher chance to escape without reabsorption from the trap sample, which causes less heating through reabsorption. 4. Bose-Einstein Condensates
Optical confinement of Bose-Einstein condensates was demonstrated for the first time by a group at M.I.T. (Stamper-Kumet al., 1998a). Bose condensates represent the ultimately cold state of an atomic sample and are therefore captured by extremely shallow optical dipole traps. High transfer efficiencies can be reached in very far-detuned traps, and the photon-scattering rate
130
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller;and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
acquires negligibly small values [see Eq. (14)]. Various specific features of dipole traps can fruitfully be applied to the investigation of many aspects of Bose-Einstein condensation that were not accessible formerly in magnetic traps. Sodium atoms were first evaporatively cooled in a magnetic trap to create Bose condensates containing 5 - 10 x lo6 atoms in the 3S112(F= 1, mF = -1) state (Mewes et al., 1996). Subsequently, the atoms were adiabatically transferred into the dipole trap by slowly ramping up the trapping laser power and then suddenly switching off the magnetic trap. The optical trap was formed by a laser beam at 985 nm (396 nm detuning from resonance) focused to a waist of about 6 pm. A laser power of 4 mW created a trap depth of about 4pK, which was sufficient to transfer 85% of the Bose-condensed atoms into the dipole trap and to provide tight confinement. Peak densities up to 3 x lOI5 atoms/cm3 were reported, representing unprecedented high values for optically trapped atomic samples. Condensates were observed in the dipole trap even without there initially having been a condensate in the magnetic trap. This strange effect could be explained by an adiabatic increase of the local phase-space density through changes in the potential shape (Pinkse et al., 1997). The slow increase of the trapping laser intensity during loading leads to a deformation of the trapping potential created by the combination of magnetic and laser fields. The trapping volume of the magnetic trap was much larger than the volume of the dipole trap. Therefore, phase-space density was increased during deformation, whereas entropy remained constant through collisional equilibration. Using the adiabatic deformation of the trapping potential, a 50-fold increase of the phase-space density was observed in a later experiment (Stamper-Kurn et al., 1998b). The lifetime of atoms in the dipole trap is shown in Fig. 8(a) in comparison to the results obtained in a magnetic trap. In the case of tight confinement and high densities (triangles in Fig. 8), atoms quickly escape through inelastic intratrap collisions. Long lifetimes (circles in Fig. 8) were achieved in the dipole trap and the magnetic trap, respectively, when the trap depth was low enough for collisionally heated atoms to escape the trap. Trap loss was found to be dominated by three-body decay with no identifiable contributions from two-body dipolar relaxation. The lifetime measurements delivered the threebody loss rate constant y = 1.1(3) x cm6/s [see Eq. (35)] for collisions among condensed sodium atoms. Figure 8(b) demonstrates simultaneous confinement of a Bose condensate in different Zeeman substates mF = 0, f l of the F = 1 ground state. To populate the substates, the atoms were exposed to an rf field sweep (Mewes et al., 1997). The distribution over the Zeeman states was analyzed through Stern-Gerlach separation by pulsing on a magnetic field gradient of a few
OPTICAL DLPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
131
FIG. 8. Bose-Einstein condensates of Na atoms in focused-beam traps. (a) Trapping lifetime in optical traps and magnetic traps. The number of condensed atoms versus trapping time is shown. Closed symbols represent the data for optical traps with best transfer efficiency (triangles) and slowest decay (circles). Open circles represent data for a magnetic trap with optimized lifetime. The lines are fits based on single-particle losses and three-body decay. (b) Optical trapping of condensates in all hyperfine spin states of the F = 1 ground state. An absorption image after 340 ms of optical confinement and subsequent release from the trap is shown. Hyperfine states were separated by a pulsed magnetic field gradient during time of flight. The field view of the image is 1.6 by 1.8 mm. Adapted from Stamper-Kurn et al. (1998a).
G/cm after turning off the dipole trap. It was verified that all F = 1 substates were stored stably for several seconds. After the first demonstration of optical trapping, a spectacular series of experiments with Bose-Einstein condensates in a dipole trap was performed by the M.I.T. group. By adiabatically changing the phase-space density in the combined magnetic and optical dipole trap (see above), Stamper-Kurn et al. (1998b) were able to cross the transition to BEC reversibly. Using this technique, the temporal formation of Bose-Einstein condensates could be studied extensively (Miesner et al., 1998). The possibility of freely manipulating the spin of trapped atoms without affecting the trapping potential has led to the observation of Feshbach resonances in ultracold elastic collisions (Inouye et al., 1998) and to the investigation of spin domains and metastable states in spinor condensates (Stenger et al., 1998; Miesner et al., 1999).
5. Quasi-Electrostatic Traps The very interesting case of quasi-electrostaticdipole trapping has not so far been considered in this review. When the frequency of the trapping light is much smaller than the resonance frequency of the first excited state w << w, the light field can be regarded as a quasi-static electric field polarizing the atom. Quasi-electrostatictraps (QUEST) were first proposed (Takekoshi et al., 1995) and realized (Takekoshi and Knize, 1996) by a group at the University
132
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
of Southern California in Los Angeles. In the quasi-electrostatic approximation w << 00, one can write the dipole potential as
where uSutdenotes the static polarizability (w = 0). The light-shift potential of the excited states is also attractive, unlike the far-off-resonant interaction discussed before. Atoms can therefore be trapped in all internal states by the same light field. Because the trap depth in Eq. (39) does not depend on the detuning from a specific resonance line, as in the case of a FORT, different atomic species or even different molecules may be trapped in the same trapping volume. For the ground state of alkali atoms, Eq. (39) is well approximated by applying the quasi-static approximation to Eq. (lo), which gives
Compared to a FORT at a detuning A, the potential depth for ground-state atoms in a QUEST is smaller by the factor 2A/w0. Therefore, high-power lasers in the far-infrared spectral range have to be employed to create sufficiently deep traps. The CO2 laser at 10.6 pm, which is commercially available with cw powers up to some kilowatts, is particulary well suited for the realization of a QUEST (Takekoshi et al., 1995). An important feature of the QUEST is the practical absence of photon scattering. The relation between the photon-scattering rate and the trap potential can be derived from Eqs. (10) and (1 1) in the quasi-electrostaticapproximation
When compared to the corresponding relation for a FORT given by Eq. (14), the dramatic decrease of the photon-scattering rate in a QUEST becomes s-', showing that the QUEST obvious. Typical scattering rates are below represents an ideal realization of a purely conservative trap. Takekoshi and Knize (1996) have realized trapping of cesium atoms in a QUEST by focusing a 20-W C02 laser to a waist of 100pm, resulting in a trap depth of 115 pK. Around lo6 atoms prepared in the F = 3 state were loaded into the trap from a standard MOT. The atom loss rates of ~ 1 s - lwere consistent with pure losses through background-gas collisions. Hyperline relaxation times were found to exceed 10 s.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
133
B. STANDING-WAVE TRAPS A standing wave (SW) trap provides extremely tight confinement in axial dimension, as can be seen from Fig. 5(b). The trap can be realized by simply retroreflecting the beam while conserving the curvature of the wavefronts and the polarization. Assuming small extensions of the atomic cloud, one can write the potential in the form
with the standing wave oriented along the z-axis. The potential depth is four times as large as the corresponding trap depth for a single focused beam discussed in Section 1V.A. As for a single focused beam, radial confinement is provided by a restoring force c/wo.The axial trapping potential is spatially modulated with a period of h / 2 . Atoms are strongly confined in the antinodes of the standing wave (restoring force - f i k ) , resulting in a regular onedimensional lattice of pancake-like atomic subensembles. When aligned vertically, the axial confinement greatly exceeds the gravitational force mg. One can therefore use a rather shallow trap, just deep enough to trap a precooled ensemble,which results in low photon-scattering rates [see Eq. (14)] and large loading efficiencies. The tight confinement along the axial direction leads to large oscillation frequencies w, = k(2i?/n~)’’~at the center of the trap. The oscillation frequency decreases when moving along the z-axis because of the decreasing light intensity. At low temperatures, the energy of the axial zero-point motion $ h a z in the center of the trap can become of the same order of magnitude as the thermal energy iks T even for moderate trap depths.’* In this regime, the axial atomic motion can no longer be described classically but has to be quantized, and the vibrational ground state of the axial motion is substantially populated. The axial spread of the wavepacket is much smaller than the wavelength of an optical transition (Lamb-Dicke regime), giving rise to spectral line-narrowing phenomena. One might even enter a regime where the wavepacket extension comes close to the s-wave scattering length, leading to dramatic changes in the collisional properties of the trapped gas.
-
1. Optical Cooling to High Phase-Space Densities
Well-resolved vibrational levels and Lamb-Dicke narrowing, as realized along the axis of a standing-wave dipole trap, are requirements for the Using the recoil temperature Tree for the cooling transition at the wavelength introduced in Section III.A.I, one can write the zero-point energy as ( h o / k ) ( k B ~ , i r / 2 ) ” * .
134
R. Grimm, M . Weidemiillel; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
application of optical sideband cooling as explained in Section III.A.l. By employing degenerate-sideband Raman cooling, high phase-space densities of an ensemble containing large particle numbers have been achieved by Vuletic et al. (1998) at Stanford. In a vertical far-detuned standing wave, peak phase-space densities of about 1/180 have been obtained with lo7 cesium atoms, corresponding to a mean temperature of 2.8pK and a peak spatial density of 1.4 x lOI3 atoms/cm3. The trap was generated by a Nd:YAG laser with 17-W single-mode power at h = 1064 nm. The large beam waist of 260 pm created a trap depth of from a blue160 pK, which resulted in high loading efficiencies ( ~ 3 0 % detuned molasses released from a MOT) and small photon-scattering rates ( ~ s-'). 2 Atoms oscillated at 0,/2n: = 120 Hz in the radial (horizontal) direction and at 0,/2n: = 130 kHz in the axial (vertical) direction. A dramatic dependence of the trap lifetime on the hyperfine state of the cesium atoms was observed, similar to that shown in Fig. 4 in Section 1II.C. About 1 x lo7 atoms were contained in the trap populating 4700 vertical potential wells. Degenerate Raman sideband cooling was applied between vibrational states of a pair of Zeeman-shifted magnetic sublevels in the lowest hyperfine ground state, as explained in Section 1II.A.1. Suppressed collisional losses through inelastic binary collisions at high densities are greatly suppressed because population in the upper hyperfine state is kept extremely low in this cooling scheme. The Raman coupling was provided by the lattice field itself (Deutsch and Jessen, 1998). Axial and radial temperatures evolved differently during cooling, as indicated in Fig. 9. The axial direction was directly cooled, causing the axial temperature to drop quickly to T, = 2.5 pK. The radial temperature followed by collisional thermalization with a time constant of 150 ms. After sideband cooling was turned off, the temperature increased at a rate of 4 pWs, limiting the achievable final temperatures. This heating rate was much larger than the rate estimated on the basis of photon scattering; this might indicate additional heating sources such as laser noise. The achieved high thermalization rates, in combination with large particle numbers, would provide excellent starting conditions for subsequent evaporative cooling. A different approach to optical cooling of large particle numbers to high phase-space densities was followed by a group at Berkeley (Winoto et al., 1999),who applied polarization-gradientcooling to cesium atoms in a vertical standing-wave trap. The standing wave was linearly polarized, resulting in equal light shifts for all magnetic sublevels of the atomic ground state (see Section II.B.2). Therefore, polarization-gradient cooling, which relies on optical pumping between the ground-state sublevels (see Section 1II.A. 1), could be applied to the trapped sample in a very efficient way. A phase-space density of about with the large number of lo8 atoms was reached.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
0
0
500
135
I000
cooling time [ms] FIG.9. Resolved-sideband cooling of Cs atoms in a vertical standing-wave trap. Evolution of vertical (solid squares) and horizontal (open squares) temperatures. Cooling is applied only along the tightly confining vertical axis; the horizontal degrees of freedom are indirectly cooled through collisional thermalization.From Vuletic et al. (1998).
2. Quantum Interference The regular arrangement of atoms in a standing-wave dipole trap has amazing consequences when a Bose condensate is loaded into such a trap. Macroscopic interference of Bose-condensed 87Rb atoms tunneling from an extremely shallow one-dimensional lattice under the influence of gravity has been observed by Anderson and Kasevich (1998) at Yale University. The dipole potential was created by a vertical standing wave at 850nm (detuning of 65 nm from the D 1line) with a waist of 80 pm, an order of magnitude larger than the transverse radius of the condensate. The condensate of lo4 atoms was coherently distributed among M 30 very shallow potential wells. The wells supported only one bound energy band below the potential edge, which is equivalent to U N ke Tree, where Tree is the recoil temperature [see Eq. (22)] at the wavelength of the trapping field. The gravitational field induces an offset between adjacent wells. For weak potential gradients, the external field can be treated as a perturbation of the band structure associated with the lattice. In this limit, wavepackets remain confined in a single band. The external field drives coherent oscillations at the Bloch frequency, as has been demonstrated with ultracold atoms confined in an accelerated, far-detuned, one-dimensional standing wave by Ben Dahan et al. (1996) at ENS in Paris and by Wilkinson et al. (1996) at University of Texas in Austin. The shallow potential wells allow for tunneling of particles into unbound continuum states. In the Yale experiment,the lifetime of the atoms confined in
136
I<. Grimm, M. Weidemiillel; and Yu. R. Ovrhinnikov
the lattice was purely determined by the tunneling losses. For a lattice of depth U = 1 . I kgTrec, the observed lifetime was ~ 5 0 m sEach . lattice site can be seen as a point emitter of a deBroglie wave. Interference between the different emitter outputs led to the formation of atom pulses falling out of the standing wave, quite similar to the output of a mode-locked pulsed laser. The pulse repetition frequency wreP= mg h / 2 h was determined by the gravitational increment between two adjacent walls. The repetition frequency can be interpreted as the difference in chemical potential divided by ti. This indicates the close relation of the observed effect of coherent atomic deBroglie waves to the ac Josephson effect resulting from quantum interference of two superconducting reservoirs.
3. Spin Manipulation Zielonkowski et al. (1998b) from the MPI fur Kernphysik in Heidelberg have used a vertical standing-wave trap for the manipulation of spin-polarized atoms. Using a large-volume, shallow, red-detuned standing-wave trap kept the depolarizing effects of photon scattering and atomic interactions at a low level while allowing for large numbers of stored atoms. Cesium atoms were trapped in a retroreflected 220-mW beam at a wavelength of h = 859 nm (detuning of 6.1 nm above the D2 line). The waist of the beam in the interaction region was 0.50mm. The maximum potential depth amounted to only 17 pK, which was deep enough to load atoms directly from a MOT at sub-Doppler temperatures. Despite the shallow potential depth, the confining force exceeded the gravitational force by about three orders of magnitude. The transfer efficiency from the MOT into the shallow trap was about 14%,resulting in about lo5 trapped atoms at a lifetime of T = 1.9 s, as shown by the stars in Fig. 10(a). In a first experiment, the spin state m F = 0 was selected by a Stern-Gerlach (SG) force. The force was created by horizontally shifting the zero of the MOT quadrupole field with respect to the position of the dipole trap: see Fig. 10(b). In this way, only atoms with m F = 0 are trapped by the dipole trap; all other magnetic substates are pulled out of the trap by the magnetic dipole force. The depolarizing effect of the trap light was determined by measuring the lifetime TSG of the mF = 0 atoms [see the circles in Fig. 10(a)] and comparing this value with the trap lifetime without Stern-Gerlach selection. ~ ' it possible to The depolarization rate r d e p o , = ~ / T S G - 1 / ~= 0 . 9 ~ made determine the photon-scattering rate from calculated values of the m F-state branching ratios for spontaneous scattering. The resulting scattering rate agrees well with the expectation based on Eq. (21). In a second experiment, spin precession in a fictitious magnetic field (Cohen-Tannoudji and Dupont-Roc, 1972; Zielonkowski et al., 1998a) was
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
137
+4 +3 +2
(a)
(b)
.,-I
+1
h
::D 2
25
1 c,
0
u
2
a
0.0
0.6
1.0
storage t i m e
1.6
(8)
2.0
m,,= 0
-25
-60 -1.0
-1
-0.5
2
0.0
0.5
(mm)
FIG. 10. Spin manipulation of Cs in a vertical standing-wave trap. (a) Storage time with all ground-state sublevels populated (stars) and for the Stern-Gerlach selected mF = 0 state (circles). Shown is the trapped particle number N relative to the number of atoms trapped in the MOT before transfer No. The line represents an exponential fit to the data yielding a time constant of 1.9 s for the unpolarized sample and 0.7 s for the mF = 0 polarized atoms. (b) Trap potentials for the combined magnetic quadrupole and optical trap used for Stern-Gerlach selection of the t n F = 0 state from the F = 4 hyperfine ground state. The zero point of the magnetic quadrupole has been horizontally shifted with respect to the center of the standingwave trap. Atoms with r n F # 0 are expelled from the dipole trap by the magnetic field gradient. Adapted from Zielonkowski et al. (1998b).
demonstrated. The field was induced by an additional off-resonant circularly polarized laser beam, which induced a light-shift scaling linear with mF as discussed in Section II.B.2. The resulting splitting corresponds to a fictitious magnetic field of 50mG. The mF = 0 state was selected by a short SternGerlach pulse resulting in a macroscopic magnetization of the sample. The population of the same state was analyzed after a 150-ms delay. Between preparation and analysis, the atoms interacted with a pulse of the fictitious field laser in combination with a holding magnetic field. The mF = 0 population oscillates with the duration of the laser pulses, which can be directly interpreted as the Larmor precession of the spin in the superposition of fictitious and holding magnetic field. A 27t and a 471rotation of the magnetization were observed.
4. Quasi-Electrostatic Lattices A standing wave created by the light at 10.6pm from a C02 laser creates a QUEST (see Section IV.A.5) with a spacing between the axial potential wells that is large compared to the transition wavelength of the trapped atoms. At the MPI fur Quantenoptik in Garching, such a lattice of mesoscopic potential wells was realized with rubidium atoms (Friebel et al., 1998a, 1998b). A 5-W CO;! laser beam was focused to a waist of 50 pm, creating a trap depth of about 360 pK. Up to 3 x 105atoms could be loaded into the horizontal standing-wave trap which had a lifetime of 1.8 s limited by backgroundgas collisions. Temperatures around 10 pK were achieved by polarizationgradient cooling in the trap.
138
R. Grimm, M . Weidemiillel; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov I
ed
2
-
40-
?
40-
.
- . ....
. .-.
I..,
8
9
I.,
-
3
-..--I
7
7
-7
dipole trap
0
0.
W
20-
8
g
I
- 0
I
w2m
2w I
TO
'
.""'.I
100
'
"'.'.'I
lorn
'
.."."I
'
IOODD
modulation frequency [Hz]
r . 7
'
w I
10
""'.'.I
I z
w
I z
100
I
u1
r
."""I
2w '
r ""'.'I
-
'.'
1000 10000 modulation frequency [Hz]
FIG.11. Excitation spectra of Rb atoms trapped with a CO?laser at 10.6l m , creating quasielectrostatic traps. The spectrum of a standing-wave trap (left-hand graph) is compared to the spectrum from a single-beam trap (right-hand graph). The horizontal axis is the fluorescence of atoms illuminated after 0.6 s of trapping time. The vertical axis gives the modulation frequency of the trap light intensity. Parametric resonances at the oscillation frequencies and at twice their value are observed. The jump at 100 Hz in both graphs is an artifact resulting from a change of the modulation depth and modulation time. Adapted from Friebel et al. (1998a).
The vibrational frequencies of atoms inside the potential wells were measured by modulating the laser intensity in order to drive parametric excitation of the atomic oscillations. When the modulation frequency equals twice the vibrational frequency 20,, (or subharmonics 20,,/n), atoms are heated out of the trap, leading to a reduced lifetime. This effect was demonstrated by varying the modulation frequency and measuring the number of atoms that were left in the trap after a fixed trapping time of 600 ms. The remaining atoms were detected by switching on a resonant light field and recording the fluorescence. The left-hand graph in Fig. 11 shows the excitation spectrum for the standing-wave trap. Parametric resonances at 2 lcHz and at 32 kHz are attributed to excitations of the radial and axial vibrations, respectively. A subharmonic resonance at 16 kHz is also observed. In the right-hand graph of Fig. 11, the excitation spectrum of a single-focused-beam dipole trap is presented. The trap was realized by interrupting the retroreflected laser beam that had formed the standing wave. The radial resonance shifts to 1.6 kHz (subharmonic at 0.8 kHz) because of the four-times-lower trap depth. The reduction of the axial vibrational frequency is more dramatic because it scales as 1 / ( 2 k z ~relative ) to the standing-wave trap (including the factor 4 in trap depth). The axial resonance is now found at 80 Hz (subharmonic at 40 Hz). C. CROSSED-BEAM TRAPS A single focused beam creates a highly anisotropic trap with relatively weak confinement along the propagation axis and tight confinement in the
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
139
perpendicular direction [see Figs. 5(a) and 7(a)]. In a standing-wave trap, the anisotropic atomic distribution of the single-beam trap is split into anisotropic subensembles with extremely tight confinement along the axial direction. Crossing two beams with orthogonal polarization and equal waist under an angle of about 90°, as indicated in Fig. 5(c), represents an obvious way to create nearly isotropic atomic ensembles with tight confinement in all dimensions. In this case, the dipole potential for small extensions of the atomic cloud can be approximated as
It should be noted that the effective potential depth is only U / 2 , because atoms with larger energy can leave the steep trap along one of the beams. 1. Evaporative Cooling
Crossed-beam dipole traps provide a good compromise between decent trapping volumes and tight confinement, and they are therefore suited for the application of evaporative cooling as explained in Section III.A.l. Adams et al. (1995) at Stanford used a crossed-beam configuration oriented in the horizontal plane for evaporative cooling of sodium. A single-mode Nd:YAG laser generated two beams of 4 W each, focused to a waist of 15pm and crossing under 90". The trap depth was close to 1mK. The polarizations of the two beams were chosen orthogonal, which results in a spin-independent trapping potential for the ground states because of the large detuning of the 1064-nm light from the two fine-structure lines of sodium (see Table I). After transfer from a MOT, evaporative cooling was started with -5000 atoms at a temperature of 140 pK and a peak density of 4 x 10l2atoms/cm3, as indicated by the dotted lines in Fig. 12. To force evaporation of highenergetic particles, the Nd:YAG power was exponentially ramped down from 8 W (trap depth 900 pK) to 0.4 W (trap depth 45 pK) within 2 s. After evaporation, 500 atoms were left in the trap. Temperature was reduced by a factor of 35 to 4 pK. Even so, density decreased by about an order of magnitude because the restoring force in the trap is reduced when ramping down the intensity. To keep the density at a high value for efficient evaporation, one would have to compress the cloud further. However, compared to the initial conditions, phase-space density was increased by a factor of 28 in the experiment, indicating the potential of evaporative cooling for the enhancement of phase-space density in dipole traps.
--
N
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller;and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
140
.-3
1.0
C
3
$ $
l a
v
0.5
!? 3
G
0.0 I
I
I
I
I
1
I
1
-60 -40-20 0 20 40 60 Position (microns)
0
-100
I 100
1
Position (microns)
FIG. 12. Evaporative cooling of Na atoms in a crossed-dipole trap. (a) Atom density distribution before (dotted line) and after (solid line) evaporative cooling of Na in a crosseddipole trap. The density decreased by a factor of about 7. (b) Time-of-flight measurement of the temperature before (dotted line) and after (solid line) evaporative cooling. The temperature decreased from 140 pK to 4 pK.From Adams ef al. (1995).
2. Interference Effects Let us now consider the more general case of two beams of equal waist w o propagating in the xy-plane and intersecting at the focal points under an arbitrary angle. The angle between the beams and the x-axis is &$. This configuration includes as special cases the single-focused-beamtrap ($ = 0), discussed in Section IV.A, and the standing-wavetrap (4 = 90"),discussed in Section 1V.B. In the harmonic approximation, the trapping potential can be written as UCB(X,Y,Z) N -U(y) .
(
1 - 2 7 - 2- - 2wx x2 w yy2 2 wo z2)
+
(44)
The potential radii wx,yare given by w: = (cos2$ / w i sin2 $/2zi)-' and w: = (sin2+/wi + cos2 $/2zi)-'. The dependence on y of the trap depth U reflects interference effects between the two waves that lead to a modulation of the trap depth on the scale of an optical wavelength. If both beams are linearly polarized along the y-direction (linlllin), interference results in a pure intensity modulation with period D = h/(2 sin $), yielding h(y) = h,, cos (ny/D). Trapped atoms are therefore bound in the antinodes of the interference pattern, forming a one-dimensional lattice along the y-direction with lattice constant D.In the case of orthogonal polarization of the two beams (linllin), the intensity exhibits no interference effects, but the polarization is spatially modulated between linear and circular with the
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
141
same period D. As discussed in Section II.B.2, the light shift depends on the spin state of the atoms giving rise to a spatial modulation of the potential. For detunings A large compared to the fine-structure splitting A;,, the potential depth is modulated with a relative amplitude {g.rnFA;,/A; see Eq. (20). Malung use of these interference effects, the ENS group investigated Raman cooling (Kuhn et al., 1996) and sideband cooling (Perrin er al., 1998; Bouchoule et al., 1999) in a crossed-beam trap for cesium atoms. The trap consisted of two Nd:YAG laser beams (1= 1064nm) propagating along a vertical xy-plane with a power of about 5 W in each beam. The beams crossed at their common waists (wg M 100pm) under an angle = f53" with the horizontal x-axis. The hyperfine splittings of the ground and excited states were small compared to the detuning of the laser from the D1 and Dz lines of cesium at 894 nm and 852 nm, respectively. For the linllin case, the comparatively large fine-structure splitting of cesium (Aks/A M 5 ) led to spatially modulated potentials with a small yet significant modulation amplitude of M U/l5 for the stretched Zeeman states l r n ~ = l I 1/2. The trap was loaded from lo7 cesium atoms in a MOT. The loading efficiency and the shape of the atomic cloud strongly depended on the laser polarizations of the dipole trap (Kuhn er al., 1996).The potential wells formed by interference of the laser beams were used for resolved-sideband cooling with Raman transitions between the F = 3 and F = 4 hyperfine ground states. Great differences in the performance of sideband cooling were found for the linlllin case and the linllin case because of the different character of the potential wells being weakly or strongly modulated, respectively (Perrin et al., 1998). By optimizing the sideband cooling in the linlllin configuration, single vibrational states (motional Fock states) could be prepared in the onedimensional standing wave. Atoms were first sideband-cooled into the lowest vibrational state Inosc = 0), from which they could be transferred into other pure Inosc)states by Raman transitions at multiples of the resolved vibrational sidebands (Bouchoule et al., 1999).
+
+
N
D. LATTICES When adding more laser beams, one can design a whole variety of interference patterns to create two- and three-dimensional lattices confining the atoms in micropotentials of submicron extension (Deutsch and Jessen, 1998). When this approach is combined with efficient cooling methods, a significant population of the vibrational ground state can be achieved. Many important aspects of these optical lattices have been studied extensively for nearresonant trapping fields that simultaneously provide tight confinement and dissipation (Jessen and Deutsch, 1996; Hemmerich et al., 1996; Grynberg and Triche, 1996).
142
R. Grimm, M . Weidemidler; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
In this chapter, we have so far concentrated on red-detuned traps because of the conceptual differences in the practical realization of dipole traps compared to the blue-detuned traps discussed in the next chapter. In the case of threedimensional far-detuned lattices, this distinction becomes faint because both lattice types are realized through appropriate interference patterns of multiple beams. The atoms are trapped either in the antinodes (red detuning) or in the nodes (blue detuning) of the interference pattern. The main difference between red and blue detuning lies in the photon-scattering rates, as discussed in Section III.A.3. Here, we briefly present novel developments for both types of far-off-resonance lattices reported by several groups (Anderson et al., 1996; Muller-Seydlitz et al., 1997; Hamann et al., 1998; Boiron et al., 1998; DePue et al., 1998). Localized wavepackets oscillating in conservative microtraps are promising systems in which to study fundamental questions related to quantum-state preparation, coherent control, and decoherence of macroscopic superposition states. Furthermore, optical lattices can serve as prototype systems for the study of condensed-matter models based on periodic arrangements of weakly interacting particles. Anderson et al. (1996) have confined lithium atoms in three-dimensional optical lattices formed in the intersection of four laser beams. For lithium, the fine-structure splitting is only 10 GHz, leading to ground-state optical potentials that are independent of the light polarization and the atomic spin state. A face-centered cubic lattice with a nearest-neighbor spacing of 1.13 h was realized by a four-beam configuration. Three-dimensional lattices with periodicity much larger than h could be created by reducing the angles subtended by each possible pair of the four lattice beams.13 Up to lo5 atoms were trapped in the lattice. By reducing the intensity of the trapping light so that only the coldest atoms from a MOT were confined in the lattice, a trapped ensemble with an rms velocity spread corresponding to 1.8 pK was prepared. By adiabatically expanding deep potential wells (see Section 1II.A.l), cooling at the expense of smaller spatial density could be achieved. The temporal evolution of metastable argon atoms stored in the intensity nodes of a blue-detuned optical lattice was investigated by Muller-Seydlitz et al. (1997) at Konstanz University. The lattice of simple-cubic symmetry was formed by three mutually orthogonal standing waves with othogonal linear polarizations resulting in isotropic potential wells with a lattice constant of h/2 = 397 nm. About lo4 atoms are initially captured in the lattice. Figure 13 shows time-of-flight spectra for variable trapping times. After a certain storage time, the light intensity is ramped down, releasing one bound state after the other. For increasing storage times, the population of excited bands in the l 3 In a different approach to creating structures with large periodicities, Boiron et al. (1998) used interference from multiple beams emerging from a holographic phase grating.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
143
250
200 150 100
50
I
-:
storage time T*,
FIG. 13. Time-of-flight spectra of metastable argon atoms trapped in the nodes of a threedimensional far-off-resonance optical lattice. The spectra were taken after various storage times T. Atoms were released from the trap by slowly ramping down the trapping light intensity. Higher-energetic bound states arrive first, deeper-confined states later. After long storage times, only atoms in the lowest bound state are found. From Miiller-Seydlitz et al. ( 1998).
potential wells decreases faster than the population of the vibrational groundstate band, leaving about 50 atoms populating the motional ground state after storage times of about 450ms. Two processes could be identified for this state-selective loss of particles: First, atoms in higher excited bands have a higher probability of leaving the finite extension of the trapping field (wg = 0.55 mm) by tunneling. Second, atoms interacting with the far-offresonance trapping light (detuning 2 nm from resonance for the metastables) are optically pumped into the electronic ground state of argon and are therefore lost from the trap. The probability for an optical pumping process depends on the spatial overlap between the optical lattice field and the atomic wavepacket confined to the potential well. The smaller the spatial extension of the wavepackets, the smaller the excitation rate, and it is smallest for the motional ground state. The reduced photon-scattering probability of deeper-bound states is an important specific property of a blue-detuned optical lattice. The first demonstrationof resolved-sidebandRaman cooling in a dipole trap, explained in Section 1II.A.1 was performed with cesium in a two-dimensional
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
144
llq, 40
20
0
FIG. 14. Resolved-sideband Raman cooling of Cs atoms in a two-dimensional far-offresonance lattice. Shown is the inverse Boltzmann factor I/qs as a function of the applied magnetic field. When the magnetic field tunes the lattice-field-induced Raman coupling to the first-order (at B, x 0.12 G) or the second-order (at B, x 0.24 G) motional sidebands, Raman cooling is most efficient, resulting in the peaks of I/qs. Solid circles are data points; the solid line is a fit to the sum of two Lorentzians. Inset: Corresponding kinetic temperatures measured to determine the Boltzmann factor. The dashed line indicates the kinetic temperature of the vibrational ground state. From Hamann et al. (1998).
lattice by a group at the University of Arizona in Tucson (Hamann et al., 1998). The two-dimensional lattice consisted of three coplanar laser beams with polarizations in the lattice plane. A magnetic field perpendicular to the lattice plane was applied to Zeeman-shift the motional states I r n ~= 4;nose) and ImF = 3;nosc- 1) of the upper hyperfine ground state F = 4 into degeneracy (see Section 1II.A. 1). By adding a small polarization component orthogonal to the lattice plane, Raman coupling between magnetic sublevels with Am, = f l was introduced. In Fig. 13, the inverse Boltzmann factor l / q ~= exp(ho,,,/kBT) is plotted versus the magnetic field. The inverse Boltzmann factor reaches a maximum when the two motional states are shifted into degeneracy by the magnetic field so that sideband cooling by the lattice field becomes effective. The second, smaller peak shows well-resolved cooling on the second-order Raman sideband (An.,, = -2). As shown by the inset in Fig. 14, the thermal energy of the atoms closely approaches the zeropoint energy in the potential wells, indicating a population >95% of the vibrational ground state. Unity occupation of sites in a three-dimensional far-off-resonance optical lattice has been realized by the Berkeley group (DePue et al., 1999). In the
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
145
regime of unity occupation, interactions between highly localized atoms have dramatic effects, and studies of collisional properties of tightly bound wavepackets become possible. The necessary high densities were achieved by applying polarization-gradient cooling to the three-dimensional lattice filled with lo8 cesium atoms and by subsequent adiabatic toggling between the three-dimensional lattice and a one-dimensional standing wave. The threedimensional lattice was formed by three mutual orthogonal standing waves with controlled time-phase differences. After the atoms were cooled in the lattice, the horizontal beams of the lattice were adiabatically turned off, leaving the atoms in a vertical standing-wave trap. Because of their low temperature (700nK), the atoms were essentially at rest at their respective positions. Under the action of the transverse trapping potential, the atoms radially collapsed toward the trap center. All atoms arrived simultaneously at the center after about a quarter of a radial oscillation period. Thereby, the density in the trap center was transiently enhanced by a factor of 10, reaching 6 x 10’2atoms/cm3. At the moment of peak density, the horizontal lattice beams were adiabatically turned on again. A substantial fraction of lattice sites were then multiply occupied and underwent fast inelastic collisions. After multiply occupied sites had decayed, single atoms cooled to near their vibrational ground state occupied 44% of the lattice sites.
V. Blue-Detuned Dipole Traps Laser light acts repulsively on the atoms when its frequency is higher than the transition frequency (“blue” detuning). The basic idea of a blue-detuned dipole trap is thus to surround a spatial region with repulsive laser light. Such a trap offers the great advantage of atom storage in a “dark” place with low influence of the trapping light, which minimizes such unwanted effects as photon scattering, light shifts of the atomic levels, and light-assisted collisional losses. According to the discussion following Eq. (3 I), this advantage becomes substantial in the case of hard repulsive optical walls [K << 1 in Eq. (31)J or large potential depth for tight confinement (fi >> k ~ 7 ‘ ) . Experimentally, it is not quite so simple and straightforward to realize a blue-detuned trap as it is in the red-detuned case, where a single tightly focused laser beam already constitutes an interesting dipole trap. Therefore, the development of appropriate methods to produce the required repulsive “optical walls” has played a central role in experiments with blue-detuned traps. Three main methods have been applied for this purpose: Light sheets, produced by strong elliptical focusing of a laser beam, can be used as nearly flat optical walls (Davidson etal., 1995; Lee etal., 1996).Hollow laser beams can provide spatial confinement in at least two dimensions (Yang et af.,1986).
146
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller, and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
Evanescent waves, formed by total internal reflection on the surface of a dielectric medium, represent nearly ideal mirrors to reflect atoms (Cook and Hill, 1982; Dowling and Gea-Banacloche, 1996). In most blue-detuned traps, gravity is used to close the confining potential from above. Such traps are referred to as gravito-optical traps. As a further experimental possibility, which we have already discussed in Section IV.D, atoms can be trapped in the micropotentials of far blue-detuned optical lattices (Miiller-Seydlitz er al., 1997). In this section, we discuss various blue-detuned traps that have been realized experimentally and their particular features; an overview is given in Table 11. In the following, these traps are classified in terms of the main method applied for producing the optical walls: light-sheet traps (Section V.A), hollow-beam traps (Section V.B), and evanescent-wave traps (Section V.C).
A. LIGHT-SHEET TRAPS In experiments performed at Stanford University, Davidson et al. (1995) and Lee et al. (1996, 1998) have realized light-sheet traps of various configurations and applied them for rf spectroscopy on trapped atoms and for optical cooling to high phase-space densities. The light sheets were derived from the two strongest lines of an all-line argon-ion laser. A laser power of up to 10 W at 5 14nm and up to 6 W at 488 nm was focused with cylindrical lenses to cross sections of typically 15 pm x 1 mm. For the Na atoms used in the experiments (resonance line at 589 nm), this leads to maximum light-sheet potentials in the order of 100 pK. When two light sheets are combined and overlap in space, there are two ways to avoid perturbing interference effects, which could open escape channels in the optical potential. First, if the two light sheets have different frequencies, then the relevant potential is determined by the time average over the rapid-beat note, in which the interference averages out. Second, if the light sheets have the same frequencies but orthogonal polarizations, then interference leads to a spatial modulation of the polarization. In the case of large detunings greatly exceeding the fine-structure splitting, as in the Stanford experiments, the polarization modulation has a negligible effect on the dipole potential [see Eq. (20)]. In the first experiment (Davidson et al., 1995), two horizontally propagating light sheets were combined to form a vertical “V” cross section. This configuration already provides three-dimensional confinement, because the trapping potential is closed along the propagation direction as a result of the divergence of the tightly focused light; see Fig. 15(a). Vertically, the atoms are kept in the trap by gravity. The gravito-optical trap thus has the form of a boat with a length of about 2 mm (for trap parameters, see Table 11).
TABLE 11 PARAMETERS OF VARIOUS EXPERIMENTALLY REALIZED BLUE-DETUNED DIPOLETRAPS. Trap
Confining fieldsa
Atomic species
Light-sheet trap Davidson et a[. (1995)
LS gravity
Na
Inverted pyramid Lee et al. (1996)
LS
Na
gravity
Detuning. depth
# Atoms, transfer
Cooling. temperature
Spccialty
3000
no
-
very long coherence times
1OOTHz 20 pK
4 x 105
Raman 1 .O pK
high phase-space densities
-
IOOTHz
10 pK
Plugged doughnut beam Kuga et al. (1997)
HB
Rb
60 GHz 40 PK
108 30%
molasses 13pK
large number of atoms
Single-beam trap Ozeri et al. (1998)
HE5
Rb
250 GHzC
105
no
single laser beam
Conical atom trap Ovchinnikov et al. (1988)
HE3 gravity
cs
3 GHz -1 mK
106 80%
molassesd -1OpK
high loading efficiency
Gravity-optical cavity Aminoff et al. (1993)
EW gravity
cs
1-10GHz
107
no
ten resolved bounces
Grav.-opt. surface trap Ovchinnikov et al. (1997)
EWkJB gravity
cs
16 30%
reflection 3 PK
atoms very close to surface
1m K e
1GHz' 100pK
LS: light sheets, HB: hollow beam, E W evanescent wave. See Torii er al. (1998). 'Trapping studied in a wide detuning range between 50 GHz and 15THz. Pure reflection cooling demonstrated at a trap detuning of 30 GHz. Number refers to vertical motion only. The horizontal depth was much lower (5 pK). Number refers to evanescent wave. The hollow-beam detuning was much larger (100GHz).
E
a
'
c
P
4
148
R. Grimm, M. Weidemuller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
FIG.15. Light-sheet trap used for rf spectroscopy. (a) Laser intensity produced in a horizontal plane 30 pm above the intersection of the two focused sheets of light. The x- and vdimensions are in microns, and the intensity is normalized to the peak laser intensity. (b) The central Ramsey fringes observed for rf-induced hyperfine transitions for a measurement time of 4 s. From Davidson et al. (1995).
Using this light-sheet trap, Davidson ef al. have stored about 3000Na atoms and have impressively demonstrated the advantages of blue-detuned dipole traps for spectroscopic applications. By using the method of separated oscillatory fields, they have measured Ramsey fringes of the F = 1, m F = 0 -+ F = 2, mF = 0 hyperfine transition of the Na ground state. For the excitation of this transition, an rf traveling wave with a frequency of 1.77 GHz was used. The Ramsey fringes were measured by applying two n/2 rf pulses separated by a time delay of up to 4 s. Initially, all trapped atoms were optically pumped into the lower hyperfine state (F = 1 ). After application of the two rf pulses, the number of atoms transferred into the upper state (F = 2) was measured by applying a short pulse of light resonant with the cycling F = 2 -+ F' = 3 transition and detecting the induced fluorescence. The two central Ramsey fringes observed by varying the rf frequency for a pulse delay of 4 s are shown in Fig. 15(b). By analyzing the dependence of the fringe contrast on the delay between the two rf pulses, a 1 / e coherence decay time of 4.4 s was obtained. In the same experiments, the Stanford group measured the mean residual light shift (ac Stark shift) of the hyperfine transition frequency as caused by the trapping light. From the frequency of the central Ramsey fringe, a corresponding shift of 270 mHz was observed. The absolute light shifts of the two hyperfine sublevels are larger by the ratio of the optical detuning (- 90 THz) to the hyperfine splitting (1.77 GHz) and thus amounted to 14 kHz.This number directly gives the average dipole potential u d i p M h x 14kHz M k B x 0.7 pK experienced by the atom and also allows one to determine an average photon-scatteringrate of 0.01 s-' according to Eq. (14).
-
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
149
106
106 r 0
b
104
2
103
s
102
0
10
30 40 Time (rec) 20
50
FIG. 16. Inverted-pyramid trap used for Raman cooling. (a) Schematic of the trap geometry. (b) Lifetime measurement performed after Raman cooling at a background pressure of - 3 x lo-" mbar. From Lee et al. (1996).
The authors also mention similar experiments performed in a red-detuned dipole trap realized with a Nd:YAG laser. In this case, the longest observed coherence times were -300 times lower, which highlights the advantage of the blue-detuned geometry for in-trap spectroscopy. In a later experiment (Lee et al., 1995), the light-sheet trapping was improved by a new trap geometry in the form of an inverted pyramid. As illustrated in Fig. 16(a), this trap was produced by four sheets of light. Because of the much larger trapping volume provided by the pyramidal geometry, this trap could be loaded with 4.5 x lo5 atoms, which constitutes an improvement over the previous configuration by more than a factor of 100 (see also Table 11). Lee et al. have also tested a similar, tetrahedral box trap, the performance of which was inferior to the inverted pyramid. The particular objective of the experiment by Lee et al. was to obtain high phase-space densities of the trapped atomic ensemble by optical cooling. The authors therefore applied one-dimensional Raman cooling (Kasevich and Chu, 1992) as a subrecoil cooling method; see also Section III.A.l. The geometry of the inverted-pyramid trap is very advantageous for getting dense atomic samples because of a strong spatial compression with decreasing temperature. In an ideal inverted pyramid, the density n would scale as TP3, in contrast to a three-dimensional harmonic oscillator, where n o( T - 3 / 2 . Moreover, this trap configuration provides very fast motional coupling between the different degrees of freedom, which is particularly interesting in a one-dimensional cooling scheme. About 4.5 x lo5 atoms were loaded at a temperature of 7.7 pK and a peak density of 2 x 10" cmP3.Application of a sequence of Raman cooling pulses
150
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller, and Yu. B. Ovchinnikol,
during the following 180ms reduced the temperature of the atoms to 1 pK, and, keeping practically all atoms in the trap, a peak density of 4 x 10" cmP3 was reached. This density increase by a factor of 20 resulting from a temperature reduction by a factor of about 7 indicates that the trap was already in a regime where the confining potential behaves harmonically rather than as in an ideal pyramid. This may be explained by the finite transverse decay length of the light-sheet potential walls. As a result of the Raman cooling, the atomic phase-space density was increased by a factor of 320 and reached a value that was about a factor of 400 from Bose-Einstein condensation. After an initial loss of atoms observed in the first second after the Raman cooling process, an exponential decay of the trapped atom number was measured with a time constant of 7s; see Fig. 16(b). This loss did not significantly depend on the background pressure below lo-'' mbar. which points to the presence of an additional single-particle loss mechanism. This loss was consistent with an observed heating process in the trap that exceeded by 30 times the calculated heating by photon scattering. This heating of unknown origin was identified as the main obstacle to implementing evaporative cooling in the inverted-pyramid trap. The experiments moreover showed evidence that ground-state hyperfine-changing collisions, ejecting atoms out of the trap, were limiting the maximum density achievable with Kaman cooling to 1 0 ' ~cmp3. In a later experiment, Lee and Chu (1998) used the inverted-pyramid trap to prepare a Raman-cooled sample with spin polarization in any of the three magnetic sublevels of the lower hyperfine ground state (F = I). A small bias magnetic field was used to lift the degeneracy of the ground state, and appropriate polarization was chosen for the Raman cooling light. The attained temperature and phase-space density were similar to the unpolarized case. This experiment can be seen as a nice illustration of the general advantage that dipole trapping leaves the full ground-state manifold available for experiments.
B. HOLLOW-BEAM TRAPS Hollow blue-detuned laser beams, which provide radial confinement, are particularly interesting and versatile tools for the construction of dipole traps. Hollow laser beams may be divided into two classes: beams in pure higherorder Laguerre-Gaussian (LG) modes and other hollow beams that cannot be represented as single eigenmodes of an optical resonator. The main difference is that LG beams preserve their transverse profile with propagation (only converging or diverging in width), which is of particular interest for atom guiding (Dholalua, 1998; Schiffer et al., 1998). Other, non-LG hollow beams can change their profile substantially, thus offering additional features of interest for atom trapping.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
151
A Laguerre-Gaussian mode LGpl is characterized by a radial index p and an azimuthal index 1. A hollow beam with a “doughnut” profile is obtained for p = 0 and 1 # 0 with an intensity distribution given by
where P is the power and wo is the waist of the beam. For 1 = 0, this equation gives the transverse profile of a usual Gaussian beam (TEMm mode) as described by Eq. (36). The higher the mode index 1, the larger the ratio between the beam radius and the width of the ring - that is, the harder the repulsive optical wall radially confining the atoms, the weaker the heating by photon scattering.
1. Plugged Doughnut-Beam Trap The dougnut-beam trap shown in Fig. 17(a) was realized by Kuga et al. (1997) at the University of Tokyo; see also Table 11. The LGo3 doughnut beam (WO = 0.6mm) was derived from a laser that was forced to oscillate in a Hermite-Gaussian HGo3 mode by insertion of a thin wire into the cavity. An astigmatic mode converter (Beijersbergen et al., 1993) then transformed the beam into the LGo3 mode. Because a LG beam does not provide axial confinement, the hollow beam was plugged by two additional laser beams (diameter 0.7 mm), which were separated by 2 mm and perpendicularly intersected the hollow beam. The plugging beams were derived from the recycled doughnut beam. An exponential decay of the stored atom number was observed with a time constant of about 150ms [see Fig. 17(b)],which was explained by heating out of the trap by photon scattering. The authors also observed that trapping in a
FIG. 17. (a) Plugged doughnut-beam trap. (b) Measurement of the storage time (filled squares). The filled circles refer to a two-dimensional trap formed by the doughnut beam alone without plugging beams (no axial confinement). Adapted from Kuga et al. (1997).
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller,and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
152
LGol mode showed inferior performance with very short lifetimes of a few milliseconds only, which highlights the benefit of “hard” optical walls for reducing heating by photon scattering. In subsequent experiments (Torii et al., 1998), the storage time of the trap was improved by application of a pulsed optical molasses cooling scheme to a value of 1.5 s, which then was dominated by collisions with the background gas. This noncontinuous molasses cooling scheme allows one to cool the atoms down to nearly the same temperatures as in a continuous cooling scheme, but it suppresses trap losses by light-assisted collisions and the interference of light shifts from the molasses light with the trapping potential. Moreover, potentially severe losses by hyperfine-changing collisions (see Section 1II.C) can be strongly reduced by keeping the atoms in the lower hyperfine ground states in the off-times of the molasses. In such a pulsed cooling scheme, the off-time can last as long as heating by photon scattering (see Section III.A.2)does not significantly degrade the trap performance. The on-time can be as short as the typical cooling time in the molasses.
2. Single-Beam Trap A blue-detuned trap based on a single laser beam has been demonstrated by Ozeri et al. (1999) at the Weizman Institute in Israel; see also Table 11. The trapping beam was produced in an experimentally very simple way by passing a single Gaussian beam through a phase plate of appropriate size, which slufted the center of the beam by a phase angle of IT. In the focus of such a beam, destructive interference leads to a reduced or even vanishing light intensity. By choosing the proper ratio between the diameter of the phase plate and that of the laser beam, Ozeri et al. obtained a darkness ratio (central intensity normalized to maximum intensity) of 1/750. Close to the center of this singlebeam trap, the intensity increases radially with the fourth power of the distance (as in the case of a LGo2 beam), and axially the dependence is quadratic. In order to measure the average light intensity experienced by the atoms in the trap, Ozeri et al. studied the relaxation of hyperfine population caused by photon scattering from the trapping light in a manner similar way to the approach of Cline et al. (1994) in a red-detuned far-off-resonance trap; see also Section IV.A.2.From measurements performed at a detuning of 0.5 nm, it was concluded that the average intensity experienced by a trapped atom was as low as 1/700 of the maximum intensity. In another series of measurements, they observed that at constant temperature, the photon-scattering rate scaled linearly with the inverse detuning. This observed behavior represents a nice confirmation of Eq. (29), which for a power-law potential directly relates the average scattering rate to the temperature with an inverse proportionality to the detuning. N
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
153
In a recent proposal, Zemanek and Foot (1998) considered a blue-detuned dipole trap formed by two counterpropagating laser beams of equal central intensities but different diameters. Along the axis of such a standing-wave configuration, completely destructive interference would lead to minima of the dipole potential with zero intensity. These traps would be radially closed because of the incomplete destructive interference at off-axis positions. This resulting linear array of three-dimensional dipole traps could combine the interesting features of standing-wave trapping schemes (see Section 1V.B) with the advantages of blue detuning. Experimentally, it seems straightforward to realize such a trap by retroreflection and appropriate attenuation of a single slightly converging laser beam.
3. Conical Atom Trap A single-beam gravito-optical trap was recently demonstrated by Ovchinnikov et al. (1998) at the MPI fur Kernphysik in Heidelberg. The conical atom trap (CAT), illustrated in Fig. 18(a), is based on a conical hollow beam and combines experimental simplicity with several features of interest for the trapping of a large number of atoms at high densities: high loading efficiency, tight confinement, low collisional losses, and efficient cooling.
FIG. 18. (a) Illustration of the conical atom trap (CAT). (b) Fluorescence image of atoms in the CAT (lower, elongated blob) combined with an image of atoms in the MOT (upper spot). The dashed lines indicate the conical trapping field. Adapted from Ovchinnikov et al. (1998).
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
154
In the experiment (for parameters, see Table 11) the upward-directed conical trapping beam was generated by using an arrangement of two axicons and one spherical lens. In the focal plane, the beam profile was roughly Gaussian with a diameter of about 100 pm. Within a few millimeters from the focus, the beam evolved into a ring-shaped profile with a dark central region resembling a higher-order Laguerre-Gaussianmode. The opening angle of the conical beam was about 150mad. The trap was operated relatively close to resonance as compared to the other blue-detuned traps we have discussed. With an optical detuning of 3 GHz (12 GHz) with respect to the lower (upper) hyperfine ground state of Cs, a large potential depth was realized, which, together with the funnel-like geometry, facilitated the transfer of as much as 80% of all atoms from the MOT into the CAT. The relatively small detuning requires efficient cooling for removing the heat that results from photon scattering from the trapping light. For this purpose, an optical molasses was applied continuously to cool atoms in the upper hyperfine ground state. This cooling, however, takes place with an inherently reduced duty cycle and is thus similar to the pulsed molasses cooling scheme of Torii er al. (1998), which was discussed before. In the molasses scheme applied in the CAT, the short phases of cooling in the upper hyperfine ground state (typically 50 ps) are self-terminating by optical pumping into the lower hyperfine level. There the atoms stay for a much longer time (typically 2 1 ms) until they are repumped by the light of the intense conical trapping beam. This inherent duty cycle for the molasses provides cooling phases long enough to remove heat efficiently, while the average population of the upper hyperfine state is kept very low. This efficiently suppresses trap loss due to hyperfine-changing collisions (see Section 1II.C). At an atomic number density of 10” cm-3 lifetime measurements of the trapped atoms (l/e lifetime of 7.8 s because of background-gas collisions) showed no significant loss due to ultracold collisions, which indirectly confirmed the predominant population of the lower hyperfine ground state. The CAT was also operated in a pure “reflection cooling” mode without any molasses cooling -conditions similar to those theoretially considered by Morsch and Meacher (1998). Reflection cooling (Ovchinnikov et af., 1995a and b) is based on the inelastic reflection of an atom from a blue-detuned light field, as discussed in more detail in the following section in connection with evanescent waves. In a Sisyphus-like process, the atom is pumped from the strongly repulsive lower to the weakly repulsive upper hyperfine state. A closed cooling cycle requires a weak repumping beam to bring the atom back to the lower state. Such a beam was applied in the CAT experiment from above. The detuning of the conical beam was increased to a few ten GHz to optimize reflection cooling. Because of the lower potential depth, the loading N
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
155
was less efficient ( w 10% transfer from the MOT instead of the 80% reached before), but stable background-gas-limited trapping was achieved. Without the repumping beam, atoms were rapidly heated out of the trap. These observations clearly demonstrated reflection cooling in a blue-detuned trap made of free-propagating light fields. However, optimum reflection cooling requires very steep optical walls so that only evanescent waves are suited to reach temperatures close to the recoil limit by this mechanism, as will be discussed in Section V.C.3. C. EVANESCENT-WAVE TRAPS A hard repulsive optical wall with nearly ideal properties can be realized by a blue-detuned evanescent wave (EW) produced by total internal reflection of a laser beam from a dielectric-vacuum interface. In the vacuum, the EW intensity falls off exponentially within a typical distance of h/2n from the surface and thus provides a very large gradient. The use of an EW as a mirror for neutral atoms was suggested by Cook and Hill (1982), who also proposed to trap atoms in a box realized with EW mirrors. The first experimental demonstration of an atom mirror was made by Balykin et al. (1987) by grazing-incidence reflection of a thermal atomic beam. A few years later, Kasevich et al. (1990)observed reflection of cold atoms at normal incidence. Since then, many experiments have been conducted with EW atom mirrors. An extensive review on EW atom mirrors and related trapping schemes has been given by Dowling and Gea-Banacloche (1996).We thus concentrate on the essential issues and on some interesting new developments. 1. Evanescent-Wave Atom Mirror
The exponential shape of the repulsive optical potential of a far-detuned EW leads to simple expressions for the basic properties of such an atom mirror. The EW intensity as a function of the distance z from the surface is given by I(z) = 10exp(-2z/A)
(46)
where the l / e 2 decay length A = 3L(2ndn2sin28- 1) depends on the angle of incidence 8 and the refractive index n of the dielectric. The maximum EW intensity ZO is related to the incident light intensity ZI by Io/Zl = 4ncos2 e / ( n z - I). The repulsive dipole potential of an atom mirror is independent of the magnetic substate if the detuning is large compared to the excited-state hyperfine splitting and the EW is linearly polarized (see Section 11); the latter is obtained for an incoming linear polarization perpendicular to the plane of
156
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
incidence (TE polarization). In the interesting case of low saturation, the EW dipole potential can then be calculated according to Eq. (19). A very important quantity used to characterize the EW reflection process is its probability of taking place coherently - that is, without spontaneous photon scattering. The probability of an (in)coherent reflection can be calculated by integrating the intensity-dependent scattering rate rsc[Eq. (21)] over the classical trajectory of the atom in the repulsive potential. For large enough laser detuning (still close to one of the D lines), the resulting small probability psp<< 1 for an incoherent reflection process is given by
mA
PSQ
r
= --
ti A"'
(47)
where W I is the velocity component perpendicular to the surface. The light shift of the ground-state sublevel integrated over time in a single reflection process corresponds to a phase shift
mA ti
= -wl
experienced by the atom. The simple relation psp= is a result of the fundamental connection between the absorptive and dispersive effects of the interaction with the light field; see also Eq. (14). As an interesting consequence of the exponential shape of the EW potential, both Eqs. (47) and (48) do not depend on the intensity of the light field, as long as the potential barrier is high enough. For higher (lower) intensities the reflection just takes place at larger (smaller) distances from the surface. Very close to the surface (z ,< 100nm), the van der Waals attraction becomes significant. Its main effect is to reduce the maximum potential barrier provided by the EW mirror (Landragin et al., 1996b). For small kinetic energies, the reflected atoms do not penetrate deeply into the EW and thus do not feel the surface attraction. We have thus neglected the effect of the van der Waals force in Eqs. (47) and (48),and we will continue to do so.
2. Gravito-Optical Cavities A great deal of interest in EW atom mirrors has been stimulated by the intriguing prospect of building resonators and cavities for atomic de Broglie waves (Balykin and Letokhov, 1989;Wallis etal., 1992). The simplest way to realize such a scheme is a single-atom mirror on which the atoms classically bounce as on a trampoline. Such a trapping scheme is referred to as a gravitooptical cavity.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
157
The time tb between two bounces in a gravito-optical cavity is related to the maximum height h and the maximum velocity u1 of the atoms by ?b = 2 m = 2vl/g, where g is the gravitational acceleration. Using Eq. (47) for the probability of photon scattering per bounce, the average photonscattering rate can be expressed as
Analogously, using Eq. (48),the mean light shift 6W,, = UQ/A experienced by the bouncing atom is obtained as
It is a remarkable consequence of the exponential shape of the EW potential that and 601, do not depend on the energy of the atom. For an atom with less energy in a gravito-optical cavity, the higher bounce rate exactly compensates for the decrease in scattering probability and light shift. The average scattering rate can be interpreted as the decoherence rate of the gravito-optical resonator due to photon scattering. It also determines the heating power according to Eq. (23). The mean light shift is of interest for possible spectroscopic applications of gravito-optical cavities. The eigenenergies of the vertical modes in a gravito-optical cavity can be approximately calculated by idealizing the EW potential as a hard wall (Wallis e? al., 1992). In this case, the vertical potential has the shape of a wedge, and the energy of the nth vertical mode is given by
r,,
r,,
(51) where ov= ( 9 7 ~ ~ m g ~ / 8 his) "a ~characteristic frequency. For example, for cesium atoms, &/2n = 2080 Hz, which corresponds to a temperature of A o , / k ~ N 95 nK. Consequently, the population of a single vertical mode with many atoms, a challenging issue for future experiments, requires cooling below this temperature. As an important step for EW trapping, the ENS group in Paris observed the bouncing of atoms in a stable gravito-optical cavity (Aminoff et al., 1993). The atom mirror used in the experiment (diameter 1.5 mm) was produced on a concave spherical substrate (radius of curvature 2cm) to obtain additional transverse confinement of the atomic motion (Wallis et al., 1992); the resulting transverse trap depth was about 5 pK. N
158
(4
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller, and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov Photodiode
Trapping Beams
@ beam
us
Ti: Saphire Laser Beam
104
0
100
200
300
400
500
time (ms)
FIG. 19. Observation of atoms bouncing in a gravito-optical cavity. (a) Experimental setup. (b) Number of atoms detected in the probe beam for different times after their release (points). The solid curve is the result of a correspondingMonte Car10 simulation. Adapted from Aminoff et al. (1993).
In the setup sketched in Fig. 19(a), about lo7 cold atoms were dropped onto the mirror from a MOT located 3 nun above the prism (corresponding bounce period t b = 50 ms). The bouncing atoms were detected by measuring the fluorescence in a resonant probe beam, which was applied to the atoms after a variable time delay. The experimental results displayed in Fig. 19(b) show up to 10 resolved bounces, after which the number of atoms dropped below the detection limit. The measured loss per bounce of -40% was attributed to photon scattering during the EW reflection process “5% according to Eq. (47)], photon scattering from stray light from the mirror ( w lo%), collisions with the background gas (- lo%), and another, unidentified source of loss (- 20%). An explanation for the latter may be the diffusive reflection from an EW mirror, as observed later by Landragin et al. (1996a). The ENS gravitooptical cavity represents the first atom trap realized with evanescent waves. 3. Gravito-Optical Su$ace Trap A new step for gravito-optical EW traps was the introduction of a dissipative mechanism, following suggestions by Ovchinnikov et al. (1995a) and Soding er al. (1995) to cool atoms by inelastic reflections. In a corresponding experiment at the MPI fiir Kernphysik in Heidelberg, Ovchinnikov et al. (1997) realized the gravito-optical surface trap (GOST) schematically shown in Fig. 20(a); see also Table 11. This trap facilitates storage and efficient cooling of a dense atomic gas closely above an EW atom mirror. Aflat atom mirror was used in the GOST, and horizontal confinement was achieved by a hollow, cylindrical laser beam, far blue-detuned from the
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
159
FIG.20. (a) Schematic of the gravito-optical surface trap (GOST). (b) Illustration of the evanescent-wave cooling cycle. The dot indicates an atom that approaches the dielectric surface in the lower hyperfine state; scatters an EW photon; leaves the EW in the upper; less repulsive ground state; and is finally pumped back into the lower state.
atomic resonance. This beam, with a ring-shaped transverse intensity profile providing very steep optical walls, was generated using an axicon (Manek er al., 1998).A Laguerre-Gaussian beam of similar performance would require extremly high order (about LGo, 100). The optical potentials of the GOST thus come very close to ideal hard walls, which leads to a strong reduction of photon scattering from the trapping light even relatively close to resonance. Cooling by inelastic EW reflections (evanescent-wave Sisyphus cooling) is the key to stable trapping in the GOST. The basic mechanism, which was experimentally studied before in grazing-incidence reflection of an atomic beam (Ovchinnikov er al., 1995b; Laryushin et al., 1996) and normalincidence reflection of cold atoms (Desbiolles er al., 1996), is based on the splitting of the 2S1/2ground state of an alkali atom into two hyperfine sublevels. In the case of linear EW polarization, the atom can be modeled as a three-level scheme (Soding er al., 1995; see also Section II.B.2) with two ground states separated by Ams and one excited state, for which the hyperfine splitting can be neglected. An inelastic reflection takes place when the atom enters the EW in the lower ground state and, by scattering an EW photon during the reflection process, is pumped into the less repulsive upper state; see Fig. 20(b). The cooling cycle is then closed by pumping the atom back into the lower hyperfine state with a weak resonant repumping laser [coming from above in Fig. 20(a)]. The mean energy loss A E l from the motion perpendicular to the surface per inelastic reflectionisgivenbyAEl/El = -:A,s/(A +A,), whereEl = mv:/2 is the kinetic energy of the incoming atom and A is the relevant detuning with respect to the lower hyperfine state. With the probability pspfor an incoherent reflection according to Eq. (47), the branching ratio q for spontaneous
160
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
scattering into the upper ground state, and the bounce rate t;' = g/2wl, EW Sisyphus cooling can be characterized by a simple cooling rate:
The vertical motion is damped exponentially because the average photonscattering rate is independent of the kinetic energy; see Eq. (49). The final attainable temperature is recoil-limited to a value of 10Trec,similar to a polarization-gradient optical molasses (see Section 1II.A.1). The GOST was experimentally realized for Cs atoms, the high mass of which is very favorable for gravito-optical trapping. In the gravitational potential, the recoil temperature Tree corresponds to a height hrec = ks Tree/ (mg), which for the heavy Cs atoms is particularly low (hrec= 1.3 pm; see also Table I). As a consequence, Cs atoms cooled close to the recoil limit can be accumulated very close to the dielectric surface. In the experiment, trapped atoms were observed for storage times up to 25 s, corresponding to more than 10.000 (unresolved) bounces. The observed exponential loss with a 1/ e lifetime of 6 s was completely consistent with collisions with the background gas. By time-of-flight diagnostics, a temperature of 3.0 pK was measured, which is quite close to the theoretical cooling limit. In thermal equilibrium, the number density as function of the distance from the surface follows from Eq. (32) (in this case, equivalent to the barometric equation), which for the measured temperature of 3.0 pK corresponds to an exponential decay with a 1/e height as low as 19 pm. The cooling dynamics observed in the experiments is shown in Fig. 21. The initial horizontal temperature is determined by the temperature of the MOT, whereas the much higher initial vertical temperature results from the release of the atoms at a height of -800 pm. With increasing storage time, the vertical temperature follows a nearly exponential decay with a time constant of 400 ms, in good agreement with the cooling rate according to Eq. (52) (with A/2n = 1 GHz, Aws/27c = 9.2 GHz, and q = 0.25). The temperature of the horizontal motion, which is not cooled directly, follows the vertical one with a clearly visible time lag and approaches the same final value of about 3 pK. This apparent motional coupling can be fully explained by a small diffusive component of the reflection from the EW atom mirror, as observed by Landragin et al. (1996a). A very important feature of the GOST and the evanescent-wave cooling mechanism is the predominant population of the absolute internal atomic ground state: The lower hyperline level is populated by more than 99.99% of the atoms. A unique feature of EW cooling is that the trapping and cooling light does not penetrate the atomic sample. Moreover, a possible reabsorption
-
161
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
25 b4 3. v 20 n
Q
s 15
4 (d
k
Q
10
Q
5
z
4
U
0
1
2
time (s)
3
4
FIG.21. Cooling dynamics in the COST. The vertical (open circles) and horizontal (closed circles) temperatures measured for about Id trapped Cs atoms are plotted as a function of the storage time. The solid lines are theoretical fits based on Eq.(52) and the assumption of an EW reflection with a small diffusive, nonspecular component. From Ovchinnikov et al. (1997).
of scattered trap photons is strongly reduced because of the large surface area for photons to escape. Hence trap loss by ultracold collisions (see Section 1II.C) and other density-limiting mechanisms is strongly suppressed as compared to a MOT. One can therefore expect EW Sisyphus cooling to work very well up to number densities of 1013cm-3 or even higher (Siiding ef al., 1995). In the first COST experiments, this interesting regime was out of reach because the trap could be loaded with only lo5 atoms, leading to peak densities of 2 x 10" cmV3.In present experiments with the GOST,performed with a substantially improved loading scheme, the high-density regime of evanescent-wave cooling is being explored. The COST offers several interesting options for future experiments on dense atomic gases (Engler et al., 1998). By detuning the EW and the hollow beam very far from resonance, one can achieve a situation in which the photon-scattering rate is far below 1 s-'. For a sufficiently dense gas, one can then expect very good starting conditions for evaporative cooling, which may be implemented by ramping down the EW potential. This appears to be a promising route to quantum degeneracy of Cs, which, because of anomalously fast dipolar relaxation, seems not to be attainable in a magnetic trap (Siiding et al., 1998; GuCry-Odelin et al., 1998). Other interesting applications of the GOST, arising from its particular geometry, are related to the possible formation of a two-dimensional quantum gas. The vertical motion is much more strongly confined than the horizontal one, so that the corresponding level spacings of the quantized atomic motion differ by nearly six orders of magnitude. In such a highly anisotropic situation,
162
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiillel; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
Bose-Einstein condensation is predicted to occur in two distinct steps (van Druten and Ketterle, 1997). First, the vertical motion condenses into its ground state (Wallis, 1996). Then, in a second step occurring at much lower temperatures, the system condenses to its absolute ground state. The highly anisotropic nature of the trapping potential may be further enhanced by addition of a second, attractive evanescent wave (Ovchinnikov er al., 1991). This can create a wavelength-sized potential well close to the surface, which could be efficiently loaded by elastic collisions. The situation would then resemble that of atomic hydrogen trapped on liquid helium, for which evidence of a Kosterlitz-Thouless phase transition has been reported (Safonov er al., 1998). The prospect of realizing such a system with alkali atomsI4 is of particular interest for studying the effects of quantum degeneracy in a twodimensional system.
VI. Concluding Remarks In this review, we have discussed the basic physics of dipole trapping in fardetuned light, the typical experimental techniques and procedures, and the different trap types presently available, along with their specific features. In the experiments discussed, optical dipole traps have already shown great promise for a variety of different applications. The particular advantages of dipole trapping can be summarized as follows: 0
0
0
The ground-state trapping potential can be designed to be either independent of the particular sublevel or dependent in a well-defined way. In the lirst case, the internal ground-state dynamics under the influence of additional fields behaves in the same way as in the case of a free atom. Photon scattering from the trap light can take place on an extremely long time scale exceeding many seconds. The trap then comes close to the ideal case of a conservative, nondissipative trapping potential, allowing for long coherence times of the internal and external dynamics of the stored atoms. Light fields allow one to realize a great variety of different trap geometries, such as highly anisotropic traps, multiwell potentials, mesoscopic and microscopic traps, and potentials for low-dimensional systems.
l 4 Other experimental approaches to two-dimensional systems based on dipole trapping make use of the particular properties of the optical transition structure in metastable noble gas atoms (Schneble et al., 1998; Gawk ef al., 1998).
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
163
Regarding these features, the main research lines for future experiments in optical dipole trapping may be seen in the following fields: Ultracold Collisions und Quantum Gases. The behavior of ultracold, potentially quantum-degenerate atomic gases is governed by their specific collisional properties, which strongly depend on the particular species, the internal states of the colliding atoms, and possible external fields. In this respect, dipole traps offer unique possibilities, because they make it possible to store atoms in any substate or combination of substates for the study of collisional properties and collective behavior. Experiments along these lines have already been performed (Gardner et al., 1995; Tsai et al., 1997; Stenger et al., 1998; Miesrier et ul., 1998b), but these efforts have opened the door to many other studies involving other atomic species, or even mixtures of different species (Engler el al., 1998). Of particular importance is the trapping of atoms in the absolute internal ground state, which cannot be trapped magnetically. In this state, inelastic binary collisions are completely suppressed for energetic reasons. In this respect, an ultracold cesium gas represents a particularly interesting situation, because Bose-Einstein condensation seems attainable only for the absolute ground state (Soding et al., 1998; Gukry-Odelin et al., 1998). As a consequence, an optical trap may be the only way to realize a quantum-degenerate gas of Cs atoms. Tuning of scattering properties by external fields is another very interesting subject. In this respect, Feshbach resonances at particular values of magnetic fields play a very important role. In optical traps, one is completely free to choose any magnetic field without changing the trap itself. Using this advantage, investigators have observed Feshbach resonances for sodium and rubidium (Inouye ef al., 1998; Courteille et al., 1998), and future experimental work will certainly explore corresponding collisional properties of other atomic species. Highly anisotropic dipole traps offer a unique environment for the realization of low-dimensional quantum gases. In this respect, interesting trapping configurations include standing-wave traps (Section IV.B), optical lattices (Section IV.D), evanescent-wave surface traps (Section V.C), and combinations of such trapping fields (Gauck et al., 1998). New phenomena could be related to a stepwise Bose-Einstein condensation (van Druten and Ketterle, 1997) and to modifications of scattering properties in cases where the atomic motion is restricted to a spatial scale on the order of the s-wave scattering length. Another fascinating approach would be to study collisional properties of ultracold fermions (such as the alkali atoms 6Li and 4oK) with the challenginggoal of producing a quantum-degenerateFermi gas. Direct optical
164
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiillel; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
cooling in a standing-wave dipole trap by degenerate sideband cooling, similar to the method of Vuletic et al. (1998), seems to be a particularly promising route. Spin Physics and Magnetic Resonance. Because dipole traps allow for confinement with negligible effect on the atomic ground-state spin, experiments related to the coherent ground-state dynamics in external fields can be performed in essentially the same way as in the case of free atoms. In such experiments, the trap would provide much longer observation times than are attainable in atomic beams or vapor cells. As a further advantage, trapped atoms stay at the same place, which keeps inhomogeneties of external fields very low. First demonstrationsalong this line are the experiments by Davidson et al. (1995) and Zielonkowski et al. (1998b), as discussed in Sections V.A and IV.B.3, respectively. In principle, a dipole trap constitutes an appropriate environment to perform any kind of magnetic resonance experiment with optically and magnetically manipulated ground-state spins (Suter, 1997).This could be of interest, for example, for storing and processing quantum information in the spin degrees of freedom. A possible, very fundamental application would be the measurement of a permanent electric dipole moment of a heavy paramagnetic-atom-like cesium (Khriplovich and Lamoreaux, 1997). Such an experiment, testing timereversal symmetry, could greatly benefit from extremely long spin lifetimes and coherence times of spin polarization, which seem to be attainable in dipole traps. Trapping of Other Atomic Species and Molecules. Optical dipole traps rely neither on a resonant interaction with laser light nor on spontaneous photon scattering. Therefore, any polarizable particle can be trapped in powerful, sufficiently far-detuned light. For this purpose, the quasi-electrostatic trapping with far-infrared laser sources, such as CO2 lasers (see Sections IV.A.5 and IV.B.4), appears to be very attractive. The trapping mechanism could be applied to many other atomic species or molecules that are not accessible to direct laser cooling. The problem is not the trapping itself, but the cooling to the very low temperatures required for trap loading. There may be several ways to overcome this problem. One possible way to load a dipole trap could be based on buffer-gas loading of atoms or molecules into magnetic traps (Kim et al., 1997; Weinstein et al., 1998) and subsequent evaporative cooling. The effectiveness of cryogenic loading and subsequent evaporative cooling is demonstrated by the recent attainment of Bose-Einstein condensation of atomic hydrogen confined in a magnetic trap (Fried et al., 1998), without any optical cooling involved.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
165
Similar strategies based on buffer-gas loading could open ways for filling optical dipole traps with many more atomic species than presently available or even with molecules. Another possible way could be the production of ultracold molecules by photoassociation of laser-cooled atoms (Fioretti ef al., 1998). The translational energies of these molecules can be low enough for loading into farinfrared dipole traps. An experiment by Takekoshi et af. (1998) indeed reports evidence of dipole trapping of a few CSZmolecules in a C02-laser beam, which may be just the beginning of a new class of experiments in dipole trapping. Optical dipole traps can be seen as storage devices at the low end of the presently explorable energy scale. We are convinced that future experiments exploiting the particular advantages of these traps will reveal interesting new phenomena and hold many surprises.
VII. Acknowledgments We would like to thank Hans Engler, Markus Hammes, Moritz Nill, Ulf Moslener, Martin Zielonkowski, and in particular Inka Manek from the Heidelberg cooling and trapping group for many useful discussions and for assistance in preparing the manuscript. Further useful discussions are acknowledged with Steven Chu, Lev Khaykovich, Takahiro Kuga, Heun Jin Lee, Roee Ozeri, Christophe Salomon, and Vladan Vuletic. We are grateful to Dirk Schwalm for generously supporting the work on laser cooling and trapping at the MPI fur Kernphysik. One of us (Yu.B.0.) acknowledges a fellowship by the Alexander von Humboldt-Stiftung. Our work on dipole trapping is supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft in the frame of the Gerhard-Hess-Programm.
VIII. References Adams, C. S., Sigel, M., and Mlynek, J. (1994). Phys. Rep. 240, 143. Adams, C. S., Lee, H. J., Davidson, N., Kasevich, M., and Chu, S . (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3577. Adams, C. S., and Riis, E. (1997). Prog. Quunr. Electron. 21, 1. Allen, L., and Eberly, J. H. (1975). Optical resonunce and fwo-level atom. Wiley (New York). Aminoff, C. G., Steane, A., Bouyer, P., Desbiolles, P., Dalibard, J., and Cohen-Tannoudji, C. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 3083. Anderson, B. P., Gustavson, T. I., and Kasevich, M. A. (1996). Phys. Rev. A 53, R3727. Anderson, M. H., Ensher, J. R., Matthews, M. R., Wieman, C. E.,and Cornell, E. (1995). Science 269, 198. Anderson, B. P., and Kasevich, M. A. (1998). Science, 282, 1686.
166
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiillel; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
Andrews, M. R., Mewes, M.-O., van Druten, N. J., Durfee, D. S., Kurn, D. M., and Ketterle, W. (1996). Science 273, 84. Andrews, M. R., Kum, D. M., Miesner, H.-J., Durfee, D. S., Townsend, C. G., Inouye, S., and Ketterle, W. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 553. Arimondo, E., Phillips, W. D., and Strumia, F. (Eds.). (1992). Laser manipulation of atoms and ions:Proceedings of the International School of Physics “Enrico Fermi.” Varenna, 9-19 July 1991, North Holland (Amsterdam). Ashkin, A. (1970). Phys. Rev. Lett. 24, 156. Ashkin, A. (1978). Phys. Rev. Len. 40,729. Askar’yan, G. A. (1962). Sov. Phys. JETP 15, 1088. Aspect, A., Arimondo, E., Kaiser, R., Vansteenkiste, N.,and Cohen-Tannoudji, C. (1988). Phys. Rev. Lert. 61, 826. Balykin, V. I., and Letokhov, V. S. (1989). Appl. Phys. B 48, 517. ~~O B.,Vand , Sidorov, A. I. (1987). JETP Lett. 45, Balykin, V. I., Letokhov, V. S., O V C ~ ~ M Yu. 353; Phys. Rev. Left 60, 2137 (1988). Beijersbergen, M. W., Allen, L., van der Veen, H. E. L. 0.. and Woerdman, J. P. (1993). Opt. Commun. 96, 123. Ben Dahan, M., Peik, E., Reichel, J., Castin, Y., and Salomon, C. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 4508. Bergeman, T., Erez, G., and Metcalf, H. J. (1987). Phys. Rev. A 35, 1535. Bergstrom, I., Carlberg, C., and Schuch, R. (Eds.). (1995). Trapped charged panicles and fundamental applications. World Scientific (Singapore). Also published as Physica Scripta T59. Bjorkholm, J. E., Freeman, R. R., Ashkin, A., and Pearson, D. B. (1978). Phys. Rev. Lett. 41, 1361. Boesten, H. M. J. M., Tsai, C. C., Verhaar, B. J., and Heinzen, D. J. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lerr. 77, 5 194. Boiron, D., TrichC, C., Meacher, D. R., Verkerk, P., and Grynberg, G. (1995). Phys. Rev. A 52, R3425. Boiron, D., Michaud, A., Lemonde, P., Castin, Y., Salomon, C., Weyers, S., Szymaniec, K., Cognet, L., and Clairon, A. (1996). Phys. Rev. A 53, R3734. Boiron, D., Michaud, A., Foumier, J. M., Simard, L.. Sprenger, M., Grynberg, G., and Salomon, C. (1998). Phys. Rev. A 57, R4106. Bouchoule, I., Pemn, H., Kuhn, A., Morinaga, M., and Salomon, C. (1999). Phys. Rev. A, 59, R8. Bradley, C. C., Sackett, C. A., Tollet, J. J., and Hulet, R. G. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1687. Bradley, C. C., Sackett, C. A., and Hulet, R. G. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 985. Burt, E. A., Ghrist, R. W., Myatt, C. J., Holland, M. J., Cornell, E. A., and Wieman, C. E. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 337. Chen, J., Story, J. G., Tollett, J. J., and Hulet, R. G. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 1344. Cho, D. (1997). J. KO,:Phys. SOC.30, 373. Chu, S., Bjorkholm, J. E., Ashkin, A., and Cable, A. (1986). Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 314. Chu, S. (1998). Rev. Mod. Phys. 70, 686. Cline, R. A,, Miller, J. D., Matthews, M. R., and Heinzen, D. J. (1994a). Opt. Left. 19, 207. Cline, R. A., Miller, J. D., and Heinzen, D. J. (1994b). Phys. Rev. Lett. 73, 632. Cohen-Tannoudji, C., and Dupont-Roc, J. (1972). Phys. Rev. A 5,968. Cohen-Tannoudji, C., Dupont-Roc, J., and Grynberg, G. ( 1992). Acorn-photon interactions: Basic processes and applications. Wiley (New York). Cohen-Tannoudji, C. (1998). Rev. Mod. Phys. 70,707. Cook, R. J. (1979). Phys. Rev. A 20, 224; ibid. 22, 1078 (1980). Cook, R. J., and Hill, R. K. (1982). Opt. Commun. 43, 258.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL, ATOMS
167
Corwin, K. L., Lu, Z.-T., Claussen, N., Wieman, C., andCho, D. (1997). Bull. Am. Phys. Soc. 42, 1057. Courteille, P., Freeland, R. S., Heinzen, D. J., van Abeelen, F. A., and Verhaar, B. J. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 69. Dalibard, J., and Cohen-Tannoudji, C. (1985). J. Opt. SOC.Am. B 2, 1707. Dalibard, J., and Cohen-Tannoudji, C. (1989). J. Opt. SOC.Am. B 6,2023. Davidson, N., Lee, H. J., Kasevich, M., and Chu, S. (1994). Phys. Rev. Lett. 72, 3158. Davidson, N., Lee, H. J., Adams, C. S., Kasevich, M., and Chu. S. (1995). Phys. Rev. Len. 74, 1311. Davis, K. B., Mewes, M.-0.. Andrews, M. R., van Druten, N. J., Durfee,D. S, Kurn, D. M., and Ketterle, W. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 3969. DePue, M. T., McCormick, C., Winoto, S. L., Oliver, S., and Weiss, D. S. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 2262. Desbiolles, P., Amdt, M., Szriftgiser, P., and Dalibard, J. (1996a). Phys. Rev. A 54, 4292. Deutsch, I. H., and Jessen, P. (1997). Phys. Rev. A 57, 1972. Dholakia, K. (1998). Contemp. Phys. 39, 351. Dieckmann, K., Spreeuw, R. J. C., Weidemiiller, M., and Walraven, J. (1998). Phys. Rev. A 58, 3891. Dowling, J. P.,and Gea-Banacloche, J. (1996). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 37, 1. Drewsen, M., Laurent, P., Nadir, A., Santarelli, G., Clairon, A., Castin, Y.,Grison, D., and Salomon, C. (1994). Appl. Phys. B 59, 283. Engler, H., Manek, I., Moslener, U., Nill, M., Ovchinnikov, Yu.B., Schloder, U., Schiinemann, U., Zielonkowski, M., Weidemiiller, M., and Grimm, R. (1998). Appl. Phys. B 67,709. Fioretti, A., Comparat, D., Crubellier, A., Dulieu, O., Masnou-Seewes, F., and fillet, P.(1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 8 1, 4402. Foot, C. J. (1991). Comtemp. Phys. 32 369. Friebel, S., D’Andrea, C., Walz, J., Weitz, M., and Hansch, T. W. (1998a). Phys. Rev. A 57, R20. Friebel, S., Scheunemann, R., Walz, J., Hansch, T. W., and Weitz, M. (1998b). Appl. Phys. B 67, 699. Fried, D. G., Killian, T. C., Willmann, L., Landhuis, D., Moss, S. C., Kleppner, D., Greytak, T. J. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 3811. Gallagher, A., and Pritchard, D. E. (1989). Phys. Rev. Lett. 63,957. Gardner, J. R., Cline, R. A., Miller, J. D., Heinzen, D. J., Boesten, H. M. J. M., and Verhaar, B. J. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3764. Gauck, H., Hartl, M., Schneble, D., Schnitzler, H., Pfau, T., and Mlynek, J. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5298. Ghosh, P. K. (1995). Zon traps. Clarendon Press (Oxford, England). Gordon, J. P., Ashkin, A. (1980). Phys. Rev. A 21, 1606. Grynberg, G., and Trichb, C. (1996). In A. Aspect, W. Barletta, and R. Bonifacio (Eds.) Coherent and collective interactions of particles and radiation beams: Proceedings of the International School of Physics “Enrico Fermi.” Varenna, 11-21 July 1995. 10s Press (Amsterdam). GuCry-Odelin, D., Soding, J., Desbiolles, P., and Dalibard, J. (1998a). Opt. Express 2, 323. GuCry-Odelin, D., Soding, J., Desbiolles, P., and Dalibard, J. (1998b). Europhys. Lett. 44, 25. Hamann, S. E., Haycock, D. L., Klose, G., Pax, P. H., Deutsch, I. H., and Jessen, P. S. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 80,4149. Haubrich, D., Schadwinkel, H., Strauch, F., Ueberholz, B., Wynands, R., and Meschede, D. (1996). Euruphys. Lett. 34,663. Hemmerich, A,, Weidemiiller, M., Esslinger, T.,Zimmermann, C., and Hhsch, T. W. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 37.
168
R. Grimm, M. Weidemiiller; and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
Hemmerich, A., Weidemiiller, M., and Hansch, T. W. (1996). In A. Aspect, W. Barletta, and R. Bonifacio (Eds.). Coherent and collective interactions of particles and radiation beams: Proceedings of the International School of Physics “Enrico Fermi.” Varenna, 11-21 July 1995. 10s Press (Amsterdam). Henkel, C., Molmer, K., Kaiser, R., Vansteenkiste, N., Westbrook, C. I., and Aspect, A. (1997). Phys. Rev. A 55, 1160. Hess, H. F., Kochanski, G . P., Doyle, J. M., Masuhara, N., Kleppner, D., and Greytak, T. J. (1987). Phys. Rev. Lett. 59,672. Inouye, S . , Andrews, M. R., Stenger, J., Miesner, H.-J., Stamper-Kurn, D. M., and Ketterle, W. (1998). Nature 392, 151. Jackson, J. D. (1962). Classical electrodynamics. Wiley (New York). Jessen, P. S., and Deutsch, I. H. (1996). Adv. A?. Mol. Opt. Phys. 37, 95. Kasevich, M. A., Weiss, D. S., and Chu, S. (1990). Opt. Lett. 15, 607. Kasevich, M., and Chu, S. (1991). Phys. Rev. Lett. 67, 181. Kasevich, M. A., and Chu, S. (1992). Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 1741. Kastberg, A., Phillips, W. D., Rolston, S. L., Spreeuw, R. J. C., and Jessen, P. S. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 1542. Kazantsev, A. P. (1973). Sov. Phys. JETP 36, 861; ibid. 39, 784 (1974). Ketterle, W., and van Druten, N. J. (1996). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 37, 181. Khripolovich, I. B., and Lamoreaux, S. K. (1997). CP violation without strangeness: Electric dipole moments of particles, atoms, and molecules. Springer (Berlin). Kim, J., Friedrich, B., Katz, D. P., Patterson, D., Weinstein, J. D., DeCarvalho, R., and Doyle, J. M. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 3665. Kuga, T., Torii, Y., Shiokawa, N., and Hirano, T. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 4713. Kuhn,A., Penin, H., Hiinsel, W., and Salomon, C. (1996). OSA Trends in Optics and Photonics 7 , 58. Landragin, A., Labeyrie, G., Henkel, C., Kaiser, R., Vansteenkiste, N., Westbrook, C. I., and Aspect, A. (1996a). Opt. Lett. 21, 1591. Landragin, A., Courtois, J.-Y., Labeyrie, G., Vansteenkiste, N., Westbrook, C. I., and Aspect, A. (1996b). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 1464. Laryushin, D. V., Ovchinnikov, Yu. B., Balykin, V. I., and Letokhov, V. S. (1997). Opt. Commun. 135, 138. Lee, H. J., Adams, C., Davidson, N., Young, B., Weitz, M., Kasevich, M., and Chu, S. (1994). In D. J. Wineland. C. E. Wieman, and S. J. Smith (Eds.).Atomic physics 14 AIP (New York). Lee, H. J., Adams, C. S., Kasevich, M., and Chu, S. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 2658. Lee, H. J., and Chu, S. (1998). Phys. Rev. A 57, 2905. Lemonde, P., Morice, O., Peik, E.,Reichel, J., Penin, H., Hiinsel, W., and Salomon, C. (1995). Europhys. Lett. 32, 555. Letokhov, V. S. (1968). JETP Lett. 7, 272. Lett, P. D., Watts, R. N., Westbrook, C. I., Phillips, W. D., Gould, P. L., and Metcalf, H. J. (1988). Phys. Rev. Lett. 61, 169. Lett, P. D., Phillips, W.D., Rolston, S. L., Tanner, C. E., Watts, R. N., and Westbrook, C. (1989). J. Opt. SOC. Am. B 6,2084 (1989). Lett, P. D., Julienne, P. S., and Phillips, W. D. (1995). Annu. Rev. Phys. Chem. 46, 423. Lu, Z. T., Corwin, K. L., Renn, M. J., Anderson, M. H., Cornell, E. A., and Wieman, C. E. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77, 3331. Manek, I., Ovchinnikov, Yu. B., and Grimm, R. (1998). Opt. Commun. 147, 67. Metcalf, H., and van der Straten. P. (1994). Phys. Rep. 244, 203. Mewes, M.-0.. Andrews, M. R., van Druten, N. J., Kum, D. M., Durfee, D. S., and Ketterle, W. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 77,416.
OPTICAL DIPOLE TRAPS FOR NEUTRAL ATOMS
169
Mewes, M.-O., Andrews, M. R., Kurn, D. M., Durfee, D. S., Townsend, and Ketterle. W. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 582. Miesner, H.-J., Stamper-Kum, D. M., Andrews, M. R., Durfee, D. S., Inouye, S., and Ketterle, W. (1998).Science 279, 1005. Miesner, H.-J., Stamper-Kurn, D. M., Stenger, J., Inouye, S., Chikkatur, A. P., and Ketterle, W. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82,2228. Migdall, A. L, Prodan, J. V., Phillips, W. D., Bergemann, T. H., and Metcalf, H. J. (1985).Phys. Rev. Lett. 54, 2596. Miller, J. D., Cline, R. A., and Heinzen, D. J. (1993a). Phys. Rev. A 47, R4567. Miller, J. D., Cline, R. A., and Heinzen, D. J. (1993b). Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 2204. Minogin, V. G., and Letokhov, V. S. (1987). Laser light pressure on atoms. Gordon and Breach (New York). Monroe, C., Swann, W., Robinson, H., and Wieman, C. (1990). Phys. Rev. Lett. 65, 1571. Morsch 0.. and Meacher, D. R. (1998). Opt. Commun. 148.49. Miiller-Seydlitz, T., Hartl,M., Brezger, B., Hansel, H., Keller, C., Schnetz, A., Spreeuw, R. J. C., Pfau, T., and Mlynek, J. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 1038. Myatt, C. J., Burt, E. A., Ghrist, R. W., Cornell, E. A., and Wieman, C. E. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 586. Ovchinnikov. Yu. B., Shul’ga, S. V., and Balykin, V. I. (1991). J. Phys. B: At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 24, 3173. Ovchinnikov, Yu. B., Sijding, J., and G r i m , R. (1995a). JEW Lett. 61, 21. Ovchinnikov, Yu. B., Laryushin, D. V., Balykin, V. I., and Letokhov, V. S. (1995b). J E W Lett. 62, 113. Ovchinnikov, Yu.B., Manek, I., and Grimm, R. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79,2225. Ozeri, R., Khaykovich, L., and Davidson, N. (1999). Phys. Rev. A 59, R1750. Perrin, H., Kuhn, A., Bouchoule, I., and Salomon, C. (1998). Europhys. Lett. 42, 395. Petrich, W., Anderson, M. H., Ensher, J. R., and Cornell, E. A. (1994). J. Opt. SOC.Am. B 11, 1332. Phillips, W., and Metcalf, H. (1982). Phys. Rev. Lett. 48,596. Phillips, W. D. (1998). Rev. Mod. Phys. 70, 721. Pinkse, P. W. H., Mosk, A., Weidemiiller, M., Reynolds, M. W., Hijmans, T. W., and Walraven, J. T. M. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 990. Pritchard, D. E., Raab, E. L., Bagnato, V. S., Wieman, C. E., and Watts, R. N. (1986). Phys. Rev. Lett. 57, 310. Raab, E. L., Prentiss, M., Cable, A., Chu, S., and Pritchard, D. (1987). Phys. Rev. Lett. 59,2631. Reichel, J., Bardou, F., Ben Dahan, M., Peik, E., Rand, S., Salomon, C., and Cohen-Tannoudji, C. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75,4575. Safonov, A. I., Vasilyev, S. A,, Yashnikov, I. S., Lukashevich, 1. I., and Jaakola, S. (1998).Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 4545. Salomon, C., Dalibard, J., Phillips, W. D., and Guelatti, S. (1990). Eumphys. Lett. 12, 683. Savard, T. A., O‘Hara, K. M., and Thomas, J. E. (1997). Phys. Rev. A 56, R1095. Schiffer, M., Rauner, M., Kuppens, S., Zinner, M., Sengstock, K., and Ertmer, W. (1998).Appl. Phys. B 67,705 (1998). Schneble, D., Gauck, H., Hartl, M., Pfau, T., and Mlynek, J. (1998). In M. Inguscio, S. Stringari, and C. Wieman (Eds.). Bose-Einstein condensation of atomic gases: Proceedings of the International School of Physics “Ennco Fenni.” Varenna, 7-17 July 1998. Schiinemann, U., Engler, H., Zielonkowski, M., Weidemiiller, M., and Grim, R. (1998). Opt. Commun., 158, 263. Sengstock, K., and Ertmer, W. (1995). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 35, 1.
170
R. Grimm, M. Weidemullec and Yu. B. Ovchinnikov
Sesko, D., Walker, T., Monroe, C., Gallagher, A., and Wieman, C. (1989). Phys. Rev. Lett. 63, 961. Sobelman, I. I. (1979).Atomic spectra and radiative transitions. Springer (Berlin). Soding, J., Grimm, R., and Ovchinnikov, Yu.B. (1995). Opt. Cornrnun. 119, 652. Soding, J., GuCry-Odelin, D., Desbiolles, P., Ferrari, G., and Dalibard, J. (1998).Phys. Rev. Left. 80, 1869. Stamper-Kum, D. M., Andrews, M. R., Chikkatur, A. P., Inouye, S., Miesner, H.-J., Stenger, J., and Ketterle, W. (1998a). Phys. Rev. Left. 80, 2027. Stamper-Kum, D. M., Miesner, H.-J., Chikkatur, A. P., Inouye, S. Stenger, J., and Ketterle, W. (1998b).Phys. Rev. Lett. 81. 2194. Steane, A. M., and Foot, C. J. (1991). Europhys. Lett. 14, 231. Stenger, J., Inouye, S., Stamper-Kum, D. M., Miesner, H.-J., Chikkatur, A. P., and Ketterle, W. (1998).Nature 396, 345. Stenholm, S. (1986). Rev. Mod. Phys. 58,699. Suter, D. (1997). The physics of laser-atom inferactions. University Press (Cambridge, England). Takekoshi, T., Yeh, J. R., and Knize, R. J. (1995). Opt. Comm. 114,421. Takekoshi, T., and Knize, R. J. (1996). Opt. Lett. 21, 77. Takekoshi, T., Patterson, B. M., and Knize, R. J. (1998). Phys. Rev. k t t . 81, 5105. Toni, Y., Shiokawa, N., Hirano, T., Kuga, T., Shirnizu, Y., and Sasada, H., Eur: Phys. J. D 1,239 (1998). Townsend, C. G., Edwards, N. H., Cooper, C. J., Zetie, K. P., Foot, C. J., Steane, A. M., Szriftgiser, P., Pemn, H., and Dalibard, J. (1995). Phys. Rev. A 52, 1423. Tsai, C. C., Freeland, R. S., Vogels, J. M., Boesten, H. M. J. M., Verhaar, B. J., and Heinzen, D. J. (1997).Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 1245. van Druten, N. J., and Ketterle, W. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 549. Vuletic, V., Chin, C., Kerman, A. J., and Chu, S. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5768. Walker, T. and Feng, P. (1994).Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 34, 125. Wallace, C. D., Dinneen, T. P., Tan, K.-Y. N., Grove, T. T., and Gould, P. L. (1992). Phys. Rev. Left. 69, 897. Wallis, H., Dalibard, J., and Cohen-Tannoudji, C. (1992). Appl. Phys. B 54,407. Wallis, H. (1996). Quantum Semiclass. Opt. 8, 727 (1996). Walther, H.(1993).Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 31, 137. Weiner, J. (1995). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 35,45. Weinstein, J. D., decarvalho, R., Guillet, T., Friedrich, B., and Doyle, J. M. (1998).Nature 395, 148. Wilkinson, S. R., Bharucha, C. F., Madison, K. W., Niu, Q., and Raizen, M. G. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 76,4512. Winoto, S. L., DePu, M. T., Bramall, N. E., and Weiss, D. S. (1999). Phys. Rev. A 59, R16. Wineland, D. J., Bergquist, J. C., Bollinger, J. J., and Itano, W. M. (1995). In I. Bergstrom, C. Carlberg, and R. Schuch (Eds.) Trapped charged particles and fundamental applications. World Scientific (Singapore). Also published as Physica Scripta T59, 286. Zemanek, P., and Foot, C. J. (1998). Opt. Cornrnun. 146, 119. Zielonkowski, M., Steiger, J., Schiinemann, U.,DeKieviet, M., and G r i m , R. (1998a). Phys. Rev. A 58,3993. Zielonkowski, M., Manek, I., Moslener, U.,Rosenbusch, P., and Grimrn, R. (1998b).Eumphys. Len. 44,700.
ADVANCES IN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR, AND OpllCAL PHYSICS, VOL. 42
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1K) MOLECULES J. T. BAHNS, P. L. GOULD, and W C. STWALLEY Department of Physics, University of Connecticut, Storrs, Connecticut
I. Introduction. ........... .................... A. Traditional Techniques for Formation of Low-Temperature ................. Molecules. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Supersonic Molecular Beams . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Matrix Isolation Spectroscopy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Other Approaches to Molecular Cooling. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Atom Cooling and Trapping. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Applications of Cold Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Spectroscopy. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ................ 2. Manipulation of Molecules. . 3. Cold Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ... . . .. . 4. Nucleation and Metastability. . 5. Bose-Einstein Condensation of es. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6. Degenerate Fermi Gases of Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7. The Molecule Laser. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11. Nonoptical Cooling Techniques . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Helium Cluster Cooling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Helium Buffer-Gas Cooling . C. Trap Compression and Evapor D. Three-Body Processes Including Resonances. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Optical Cooling Techniques. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Incoherent Optical Cooling of Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Coherent Optical Manipulation of Molecules . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Formation of Cold Molecules Via Laser-Induced Photoassociation . . . A. Spontaneous Decay . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.....................
2. Observations ..................... B. Proposed Stimul ......................... V. Conclusions and Fu ................... VI. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII. References ....................................
172 173 174 175 175 176 177 178 180 185 186 187 190 191 191 191 192 192 194 195 196 205 206 206 206 21 1 215 219 219 220
Abstract: The formation of low-temperature molecules with translational energy distributions characterized by T 5 1 K is reviewed. Such molecules can in principle be produced optically or nonoptically or by photoassociation of ultracold ( T 5 1 mK) atoms. Recent results producing cold - and especially ultracold - alkali metal dmers and producing cold paramagnetic molecules are highlighted, along with their potential applications and scientific significance. 171
Copyright 02000 by Academic Press All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-003842-01ISSN 1049-250x100 $30.00
172
J. I: Bahns, I? L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
I. Introduction The purpose of this review is to clarify and summarize the many proposals for formation of gas-phase molecules with subKelvin translational and internal temperatures (or average energies (divided by Boltzmann’s constant k) if not in a thermal distribution) and to discuss the exciting and very recent results achieved in implementing these proposals. Indeed, in many cases discussed below, we are discussing population transfer (e.g., into the lowest ground electronic state rovibrational level of a molecule), and not standard cooling by lowering the temperature of a thermal distribution of molecules. In fact, a thermal distribution of ultracold (T 5 1 mK) molecules in the true thermodynamic sense cannot exist, because the true equilibrium state consists of a solid of the same stoichiometry with an absolutely negligible vapor pressure. However, for low-density, low-temperature atomic and molecular gases, the time required to reach true equilibrium (a solid) can be much longer than the corresponding experimental studies. Only the translational degrees of freedom clearly equilibrate thermally on a short time scale. The possibilities for nonthermal distributions among other (internal) degrees of freedom are great, as discussed especially in Section I.D.3. Cold is a relative term. The person on the street might accept 273 K as the hot-cold boundary, for example, whereas 2.7 K, the current black-body temperature of the universe, might be more acceptable cosmologically. We choose 1 K as our boundary to exclude two very powerful and pervasive techniques for producing molecules in the 1-100 K range: supersonic molecular beam expansions (Section I.A. 1) and matrix isolation spectroscopy (Section I.A.2). We reserve the term ultracold for T 5 1 mK. We then survey, in Section I.B, the broad field of molecular cooling (and heating), most of which will not yield or have not yet yielded cold molecules, emphasizing optical techniques. The powerful techniques of atom cooling and trapping relevant to this review are briefly summarized in Section I.C. The major applications/motivations for production of cold molecules are summarized in Section I.D, which includes the following subsections: (1) Spectroscopy, (2) Manipulation of Molecules, (3) Cold Collisions, (4) Nucleation and Metastability, (5) Bose-Einstein Condensation of Molecules, (6) Degenerate Fermi Gases of Molecules, and (7) The Molecule Laser. Finally, in the remainder of this section, we will describe in greater detail the organization of the rest of this review into sections on Nonoptical Cooling Techniques (Section 11), Optical Cooling Techniques (Section 111),Formation of Molecules Via Photoassociation of Cold Atoms (Section IV), and Conclusions and Future Directions (Section V).
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
173
A. TRADITIONAL TECHNIQUES FOR FORMATION OF LOW-TEMPERATURE MOLECULES
There are two powerful and widely used techniques for formation of lowtemperature molecules in the 1-100 K region: the supersonic molecular beam technique and the matrix isolation technique. The primary motivation for introducing these techniques was to simplify complex spectra by greatly reducing the internal partition function (the number of significantly populated internal states) and, in the supersonic molecular beam, the Doppler width. In a sense, many proposals for the formation of subKelvin molecules have evolved from these approaches. Thus we wish here to discuss, but in no sense comprehensively review, these extensive areas of study. It is also useful to examine the plot of energy/temperatureversus deBroglie wavelength [Fig. 1, a reformulation of Fig. 1 in Weiner ef al. (1999), where many of the proposals and results discussed in this review are indicated]. Not only does the reduced partition function at low T simplify spectra, but it also
I
Effusive Beams
I
&
- Magnetic (l.D.2.)
I
I
I
Seeded Supersonic Beams (I.A.l.) Matrix Isolation (l.A.2.)
-
MOT (1.C.)
Helium Cluster Cooling (1I.A.) Hellum Buffer Gas Cooling
\ (11.8)
- FORT (l.D.2.)
I
t I
photoassociated Molecules
Photon Recoil, Molecule Laser (l.D.7.)
-
Doppler Cooling (I.C., II1.A.)
\ \
Optical Molasses (I.C.)
-
\
BEC (LDS.), Atom Laser (l.D.7.)
Evaporative Cooling).-.I(
I 0.01
1
100
I
lo4
106
de Broglie I. (nm) p= mv=hh
FIG. 1 . Energy divided by Boltzmann’s constant k or temperature versus deBroglie wavelength h (MI)(for 23Na) from IOOOK to 1 nK. Topics discussed herein are listed with the corresponding section number in parentheses. The large deBroglie wavelengths (51nm for T?: 1 K) indicates the highly wavelike quantal nature of collisions in the subKelvin regime.
174
J. T Bahns, P. L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
enhances quantum effects in collisions and many body interactions [such as Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC)]. 1. Supersonic Molecular Beams
Molecular (and atomic) beams have been widely used for most of this century to study fundamental properties of atoms and molecules (see Anderson et al., 1966; Ramsey, 1985; Scoles 1988). In the 1950s, Kantrowitz and Grey (1951) and Kistiakowsky and Slichter (195 1) proposed that the pressure behind the aperture emitting the beam be significantly increased, converting the beam from “effusive” to “supersonic” and producing an increased intensity and quite significantly - decreased internal (rotational and vibrational) and translational temperatures. Actually, the mean longitudinal translational energy of the atoms or molecules increased somewhat, while the spread in longitudinal translational energy decreased substantially (and was comparable to the spread in transverse translational energy). For example, early work (e.g., Sinha et al., 1973 and Wu et al., 1978 and references therein) on supersonic expansions of alkali metal vapor (predominantly atoms with a few percent molecules in the gas behind the nozzle) produced an enhanced concentration of molecules and significantly reduced internal (especially rotational) and translational temperatures. However, the temperatures were still quite high compared to those reviewed here (e.g., a 1370K expansion produced 7Li2 with a 50 K rotational temperature and a 190K vibrational temperature (Wu et al., 1978). A major advance came with the coexpansion of rare gases with other species, pioneered by Becker and Henkes (1956). Spectroscopic applications grew rapidly after the work of Smalley et al. (1974). A few percent or less of a species was coexpanded with rare gases such as He and Ar. The Ar was particularly effective in relaxing vibration, whereas He produced very low rotational temperatures in the < 10K regime. Toennies and Winkelmann (1977) achieved a temperature of 15 mK in a 4He expansion. However, the rare gases (and H2) ultimately cluster as the temperature produced by the expansion is reduced. Even 4He2 (and therefore 4He,) has a nonzero binding energy of 1.31 mK (Uang and Stwalley, 1982; Schollkopf and Toennies, 1994 and 1996; Tang et al., 1995; Luo et al., 1996), and thus clustering will occur. One of the techniques that can lead to subKelvin temperatures is the helium cluster “pickup” technique employed especially by Scoles et al. and by Toennies et al., discussed in Section 1I.A. In a sense, it is a version of matrix isolation spectroscopy as well, where the atom or molecule can either sit on the surface of the cluster or be embedded within the cluster. The temperature here is limited by the evaporative cooling of 4He clusters ( ~ 3 7 0 m K or ) (much more expensive) 3He clusters ( N l00mK).
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
175
In principle, spin-polarizedatomic H (Stwalley and Nosanow, 1976; Silvera and Walraven, I980), which has recently been Bose-Einstein-condensed (Fried et al., 1998),is the ultimate “rare gas,” because there is no bound state 00 (Uang and Stwalley, 1980A). for its many-body system in the limit n Even 3He, for which no 3He2 species exists (Uang and Stwalley, 1982), has cluster bound states probably starting with n = 29 (Barranco et al., 1997) and a superfluid phase (Lee, 1997) as n -+ 00. Thus, in some cases, it might be possible to use spin-polarized H in supersonic molecular beam expansions (assuming no low-temperature exoergic reaction with H can occur). However, to the best of our knowledge, no such experiments are under way. --f
2. Matrix Isolation Spectroscopy The use of a rare gas (or other usually inert species, such as H2 or N2) solid matrix to trap and cool a molecule to low temperature, such as 4 K for liquid 4He cooling, has been used since the 1950s (Lewis and Kasha, 1944; McClure, 1954; Becker and Pimentel, 1956; Robinson et al., 1957; Bass and Broida, 1960)to obtain assignable spectra of high-temperature, highly reactive species. Recently, the technique has been extended beyond solids to include liquid 4He (e.g., Takahasi et al., 1993) (liquid 3He is also possible but unexplored). Toennies and Vileson (1998) have recently reviewed the spectroscopy of doped liquid 4He. Such spectra suffer from “matrix shifts” as well as inhomogeneous (matrix) broadening, but they provide a great deal of useful information about highly reactive species not readily obtained by any other technique. In recent years, Jacox (1988, 1990, 1994, 1998) has compiled and reviewed a great deal of matrix isolation spectroscopic data. As noted above, helium cluster spectroscopy (Section II.A) is an extension of matrix isolation spectroscopy. Likewise, helium buffer gas cooling (to ~ 3 0 0 m Kfor 3He and to 1.4K for 4He) technique of Section 1I.B is an extension from traditional solid-state matrix isolation and liquid He “matrix isolation” to a gaseous “matrix isolation.” Again, gaseous spin-polarized H might be an improvement in nonreactive situations over even 3He, with (uniquely) an extremely high vapor pressure (no stable solid or liquid form) at very low temperatures. Note also that a gaseous “matrix isolation” provides a gaseous molecule with a near zero “matrix shift” from the unperturbed gas phase spectrum. N
B. OTHERAPPROACHES TO MOLECULAR COOLING The first discussion of cooling atoms and molecules with light (“luminorefrigeration”) of which we are aware was presented by Kastler (1950), although the example elaborated was an atom, Na. Since then, a number
176
J. Z Bahns, R L. Could, and U? C. Stwalley
of other concepts (and some experimental results) have emerged, including use of near-resonance radiation (Hansch and Schawlow, 1975; Wineland and Dehmelt, 1975; Letokhov et al., 1976; Berman and Stenholm, 1978; see also Section 1.C); spontaneous anti-Stokes scattering (Djeu, 1978; Djeu and Whitney, 1981); selection of slow particles (Vasilenkoet al., 1995); sequential laser cooling of rotation, translation, and vibration (Bahns er al., 1996); and laser cooling of multilevel solids (Kushida and Guecic, 1968; Mungan et al., 1997, 1997A; Edwards et al., 1998). Only the near-resonance approach has provided (for atoms) subKelvin temperatures of interest here (and also trapping), as discussed in Section I.C. The sequential laser cooling scheme (Bahns et al., 1996) has the potential of achieving subKelvin temperatures, but this has not yet been demonstrated. It is discussed in detail in Section 111. Alternatively, one can use already translationally subKelvin atoms, cooled by the techniques of Section I.C, and photoassociate them (Lett et al., 1995; Weiner et al., 1999; Stwalley and Wang, 1999) to form translationally subKelvin molecules. Such molecules can then be trapped and internally cooled, as discussed in Section IV. Finally, there are the nonoptical methods of cold molecule formation, two of which [helium cluster cooling (Section 1I.A) and helium buffer gas cooling (Section II.B)] were mentioned above. Two other nonoptical approaches, trap compression and evaporative cooling (Section II.C) and three-body processes including resonances (Section II.D), are also covered in Section 11. c . ATOMCOOLING AND TRAPPING One of the most impressive advances in science in the past two decades has been the development of techniques to cool atoms (to < 1 mK) and then trap them in ultrahigh vacuum, using lasers but no cryogenics. These techniques include slowing and even stopping an atomic beam, damping the motion of atoms away from an intersection of laser beams (“optical molasses”), trapping of atoms at temperatures of pK and densities of 10” atoms/cm3 in magneto-optical traps (MOTS)and far-off resonance traps (FORTS),and BoseEinstein condensation (BEC) of atoms at nK temperatures and densities of lOI4 atoms/cm3 in magnetic and optical traps. Recent reviews of this field include Metcalf and van der Straten (1994), Dowling and Gea-Banaloche (1996), Adams and Riis (1997), and Weiner et al. (1999). See also the lectures of the 1997 Physics Nobel Laureates (Chu, 1998; Cohen-Tannoudji, 1998; and Phillips, 1998). Because molecules exist in a far greater variety of internal states than atoms, cooling and trapping techniques are not as straightforward as for atoms. In particular, simple atoms often have a two-level cycling transition, where millions of photons can be absorbed and emitted between two levels
-
N
FORMATION OF COLD ( T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
177
without loss to other atomic levels. Similar cycling transitions are extremely rare (or even nonexistent) for simple molecules. One general approach (Bahns et al., 1996) is to generate a set of frequencies (e.g., 20 for the Cs2B’III,X ‘ E l cooling transition example of Bahns et al., 1996) such that a given molecule can absorb and emit photons at least l@times, with every individual absorption and emission event corresponding to one of these possible frequencies. Although many of the techniques for cooling and trapping atoms are not applicable to molecules, the use of laser light that is very far from resonance minimizes spontaneousemission and therefore the problem of optical pumping. Tightly focused laser light tuned well below a resonance line has been successfully used to trap atoms (Chu et al., 1986; Miller et al., 1993). Such a far-off resonance trap (FORT) operates via the interaction of the oscillating dipole moment induced in the atom with the laser field. For light tuned below an atomic resonance, the atom is attracted to a region of strong field. A focused laser beam, having an absolute maximum of intensity at the focus, thus acts as a trap for cold atoms. The depth of the trap depends on the energy of interaction of the dipole with the field and is proportional to the laser intensity Z and to the inverse of the laser detuning A. Spontaneous decays can occur, even for far-off resonant light, causing heating of the atoms in this otherwise conservative potential. This photon scattering rate is proportional to Z/A2. If the figure of merit is the trap depth divided by the scattering rate, then it is preferable to operate at large A, as long as the trap is deep enough to confine the atoms. For light tuned well below the D1 and D2 lines of an atom, an interference effect in the spontaneous Raman scattering suppresses the spin relaxation (optical pumping) that would otherwise accompany this heating (Cline et al., 1994). The extreme case of large detuning is to use an infrared laser (e.g., a COz laser). In this case, the frequency is so far below the atomic resonance that the field is best considered quasistatic. Such a quasi-electrostatic trap (QUEST) of Takekoshi et al. (1995) has been successfully used to trap Cs atoms (Takekoshi and Knize, 1996) and CS2 molecules (Takekoshi et al., 1998). D. APPLICATIONS OF COLD MOLECULES Although a great deal of useful information on atoms and molecules can be obtained at superKelvin temperatures, it is clear that the most precise spectra will be obtained at the lowest observation temperature. Likewise, “hot” molecules will be relatively hard to trap (typically in subKelvin traps) or otherwise manipulate (deflect, focus, reflect, interfere, etc.). Collisions of thermal molecules typically involve over lOOA in collisional angular momentum, as well as thousands or millions or more internal states in each molecule. Thus it is not surprising that quantum effects in general, or quantum
178
J. ‘1: Bahns, P. L. Gould, and U? C. Sovalley
resonances (involving a single internal state in each molecule and a single state of collisional angular momentum) in particular, tend to be “washed out” - that is, they make a negligible contribution to the observed average cross section. Moreover, in the absence of walls (e.g., in electromagnetic traps) and at relatively low densities where two-body (not three-body) processes dominate, such molecules can be very highly metastable with respect to the thermodynamically stable molecular (or other) solid. Such low temperatures at modest (metastable) density offer the interesting possibility of highly quantum-mechanical behavior in the gas phase (Stwalley and Nosanow, 1976), e.g., BEC. A further extension is to the ideal atomic or molecular beam, i.e., the “atom laser” (Mewes et al., 1997) and the “molecule laser” (Julienne et al., 1998), where all species in a single quantum state move coherently in the same direction with the same velocity. Here we briefly discuss the following applications of subKelvin molecules: spectroscopy, manipulation of molecules, cold collisions, nucleation and metastability, Bose-Einstein condensation of molecules, degenerate Fermi gases of molecules, and the molecule laser.
1. Spectroscopy A major motivation for matrix isolation and seeded supersonic molecular beam techniques was higher resolution molecular spectroscopy.The need to go even colder is not as strong because these two traditional techniques already provide a great deal of information. Nevertheless, subKelvin spectroscopy offers the opportunity to virtually eliminate the Doppler effect. Optical and magnetic traps (see Section I.D.2) eliminate “transit time broadening,” although they do introduce new (but often well-understood) terms in the molecular Hamiltonian. Clearly, resolution of closely spaced levels is an important motivation in many molecular systems and may justify the additional complexities of cooling to below 1 K. One example of high-resolution spectroscopy that has blossomed at subKelvin temperatures is the photoassociation of ultracold atoms, first proposed in 1987 (Thorsheim et al., 1987) and recently reviewed (Lett et al., 1995; Weiner et al., 1999; Stwalley and Wang, 1999). Colliding pairs of ultracold atoms have very low thermal kinetic energies [e.g., 7MHz in our 39K magneto-optical trap at 300pK (Wang et al., 1996)l. Thus free-bound absorption lines are as sharp as ordinary bound-bound lines. Moreover, colliding pairs of atoms reach relatively short distances (say, < 50 A) only if the collision is nearly head-on and the corresponding centrifugal barriers are surmounted (e.g., collisional angular momentum 1 = 0, 1, and 2 for 300 pK 39K). Because the probability of free + bound photoassociation decreases with decreasing internuclear distance R, this spectroscopy is ideally suited for
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
179
observing very closely spaced molecu!ar levels with their vibrational wavefunctions concentrated at large (> 10A) internuclear distances (“long-range molecules” (Le Roy, 1973; Stwalley, 1978). Such levels have been studied since 1970 by conventional molecular spectroscopy (Le Roy and Bernstein, 1970; Stwalley, 1970) but with considerable difficulty because the long-range molecule spends very little time near its inner classical turning point. It can be shown that the vibrational spacings and rotational spacings go to zero in the limit that the vibrational quantum number approaches its value at dissociation V D (Le Roy, 1973; Stwalley, 1978). An example of a vibrationally resolved ultracold photoassociation spectrum of 39K is given in Fig. 2; a rotationally resolved spectrum is given in Fig. 3. “Pure long-range molecules” are weakly bound, long-range molecular states where both the inner and outer classical turning points are at large internucleardistance (Stwalley, 1978; Wang et al., 1996A;Stwalley and Wang, 1999). Such species cannot be populated directly from thermally populated levels of molecular ground states. We have succeeded in populating both the 0;(Wang et al., 1997) and the 1, (Wang et al., 1998) pure long-range states
v-9
0g
10
~=124
125
11
12
126
127
13
128 129
’El I
13039.9
I
I
13040.5
14
15
16
17 18 I9 20 21 22 23
130
135
I
I
13041.1
I 13041.7
I
13042.3
-’
Laser frequency (m
FIG.2. The vibrationally resolved photoassociation spectrum of ultracold (300 1K) 39K atoms recorded by “trap loss” (decrease in atomic fluorescence due to excited molecule formation)just below the 4s 4p3,, asymptote (at 13042.876cm-’) (Wanget al., 1997). Three vibrational progressions are shown: the 0; “pure long-range molecule” state (where levels v = 9-23 are shown at the top), the 0: state (where the vibrational numbering is uncertain, but 17 levels are shown at the bottom), and the 1, state (where levels = 124-139 are shown at the bottom). These states correlate with the repulsive 1 311g(0= 0-component), the attractive b311, (R = O+ component) and the attractive 1 ‘II, states, respectively, at short internuclear distance. Each level shows rotational structure (as in Fig. 3) at higher resolution.
+
J. Z Bahns, I? L. Gould, and W C. Snyalley
180
0
200
400
600
800
1000
Relative Laser frequency (MHz)
FIG.3. The rotationally resolved photoassociation spectrum of ultracold (300 pK) 39K atoms recorded by resonance-enhancedmultiphotonionization of the rotational levels J' = 0-4 of the o' = 0 vibrational level of the 0; "pure long-range molecule" state of 39K2 (Wang ef al., 1997).
of 39K2 using photoassociation. Others have populated these states in Na2, Rb2, and Cs2 (see Stwalley and Wang, 1999, and references therein). For 39K2, these fascinating states are at 28 A and 39 A, with binding energies of 6 cm-' and 0.5 cm-' , respectively. Recently, stimulated Raman photoassociation via one of these states has been demonstrated in ultracold 87Rb(Wynar et al., to be submitted). It is likely that the availability of samples of ultracold atoms and molecules will provide additional examples where new and interesting spectroscopic information can be obtained. For example, ultracold polar molecules may find use in precision spectroscopy searches for the dipole moment of the electron.
2. Manipulation of Molecules The ability to manipulate the translational motion of atoms with microstructures and various types of electromagnetic fields has spawned the very active field of atom optics (Adams et al., 1994). There are strong analogies between atoms and light in the area of geometric optics, where classical atomic trajectories are the equivalent of optical rays. For example, atomic beams can be focused by atomic lenses and reflected by atomic mirrors. Furthermore, in analogy with physical light optics, atomic deBroglie waves diffract and interfere. Because the forces exerted on neutral atoms by
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
181
electromagnetic fields are generally small, significant geometrical optics effects are expected only when the atoms are moving rather slowly - i.e., laser-cooled. Because the deBroglie wavelength of room-temperature atoms is very small (e.g., 0.02 nm for a typical Na atomic beam), physical optics effects are also enhanced with slower atoms. One can thus anticipate that advances in the production of cold molecules will generate interest in extending atom optics techniques to molecules, especially in light of potential applications such as interferometry and lithography. In addition, the manipulation of molecules represents an important step in the large jump from simple atomic systems to more complex mesoscopic and macroscopic systems. Although there are many similarities between atom (or molecule) optics and traditional light optics, there are important distinctions. The fact that atoms have mass, whereas photons do not, implies that deBroglie waves, in contrast to light waves, have dispersion in vacuum. In fact, chromatic aberration due to a distribution of atomic momenta can be particularly severe in many atom optics elements. Obviously, these same considerations apply to molecules. Another important difference between atom optics and traditional light optics is the possibility of using dissipation (e.g., laser cooling) to increase brightness. In light optics, optical elements generally preserve brightness at best. If direct laser cooling of molecules becomes practical, then this ability to increase brightness will apply to molecules as well. At present, however, atom optical elements involving spontaneous emission are not applicable to molecules because of the severe problem of optical pumping. Manipulation of molecular beams with applied electric and magnetic fields has been used fruitfully for many decades to measure important properties of molecules (Ramsey, 1985 and Scoles, 1988). These techniques generally take advantage of the fact that the deflection of a molecule by an inhomogeneous field is state-selective. Resonant transitions between states are driven and detected by a change in the deflection. An important variation (Hill and Gallagher, 1975) was to use the resonant field itself to cause the deflection. In this experiment, polar CsF molecules were sent through a microwave cavity, experiencing a standing-waveelectric field resonant with a rotational transition. Molecules in the appropriate states were deflected by the interaction of the electric dipole moment with the strong electric field gradient of the standing wave. As discussed in the introduction, the lack of demonstrated laser-cooling techniques for molecules and, more generally, the inability to have sustained interactions with light (due to optical pumping), have prevented the extension of many of the tools of atom optics to molecules. However, a notable exception is the use of microfabricated diffraction gratings to diffract and interfere molecules (Chapman et al., 1995). The fact that the atom-optical elements were physical structures (as opposed to near-resonant light fields) allowed
182
J. 7: Bahns, P. L. Gould, and W C.Stwalley
them to work equally well for molecules as for atoms. In this work, a pure (>98%) beam of Na2 molecules was obtained from a seeded supersonic expansion by deflecting the Na atoms out of the beam with resonant radiation pressure. This selected beam was then incident on a series of three equally spaced 200-nm period gratings, which formed a Mach-Zehnder interferometer. This particular geometry yields a white-light interferometer whose interference pattern is independent of the deBroglie wavelength. The first grating split the molecular beam, and the second grating reflected the various orders, causing them to recombine at the location of the third grating. This third grating was scanned to read out the resulting interference pattern. Because the interfering beams were physically separated in the middle of the interferometer, it was possible to induce a phase shift in one of the beams by passing it through a gas cell. This allowed the complex index of refraction of Na2 passing through Ne to be measured. More specifically, the ratio of real to imaginary parts of the index was determined. These are related to the phase shift and attenuation of the interference signal, respectively, and yield useful information on the long-range interaction between Na2 and Ne. This initial experiment on molecular interferometry clearly indicates the power and potential of the technique. Superficially, it is somewhat surprising that the interferometer works as well for molecules as it does for atoms. Because the molecules occupy a large number of rovibrational states with different internal energies, one might think that this would wash out the interference pattern. However, as pointed out by the authors, the interferometer effectively makes each particle interfere with itself, rendering the internal state distribution irrelevant. It is also interesting to note that the diffraction of molecules (e.g., by a single grating) is by itself a useful diagnostic for molecular beams. A prime example is the use of such a diffraction pattern to observe directly and verify the existence of the He;! molecule (Schollkopf and Toennies, 1994, 1996). A related experiment determined the size of this dimer (- 6.2 nm) by its inhibited passage through nanoscale (- 100-nm) openings (Luo et al., 1996). The large electric fields available from pulsed lasers have been used to exert significant forces on room-temperature molecules (Stapelfeldt et af., 1997; Sakai et al., 1998). The lasers employed (Nd:YAG at 1.06pm and C02 at 10.6 pm) were very far from any resonances of the molecules (CS2 and I2), so that the interaction was via the static polarizability. The strong electric field induces an electric dipole moment in the molecule, and the interaction of this dipole with the field results in a potential energy. If the laser intensity varies spatially, this position-dependent potential leads to a “nonresonant dipole force” capable of focusing or trapping molecules (Seideman, 1996; see also Friedrich and Herschbach, 1995a). For a positive polarizability, the molecule is attracted toward a region of high field, e.g., toward the waist of a focused
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
183
Gaussian laser beam. This force is essentially the same as that utilized in trapping atoms and microscopic objects (e.g., dielectric spheres) in focused laser beams. In the pulsed-laser experiments (Stapelfeldt et al., 1997; Sakai et al., 1998),a molecular beam was passed transversely through a focused laser beam. The nonresonant dipole force deflected the molecules toward the axis of the laser beam (i.e., toward the region of highest intensity), imparting to them a velocity that depended on their initial location in the intensity gradient of the focused beam. This velocity was measured by subsequently ionizing the molecules with a tightly focused femtosecond pulse and measuring their time of flight to a detector. Molecules with an imparted velocity toward the detector would arrive earlier than those deflected away from the detector. Notably, the initial transverse velocities of the molecules were negligible compared to those imparted by the deflection process. The relative positions of the deflecting and ionizing lasers were then scanned to map out the transverse velocity as a function of position in the deflecting beam. The expected dispersion-shaped curve was observed, indicating that the laser beam did indeed act as a onedimensional lens to focus the molecules. The focal length of this lens was calculated to be typically several hundred micrometers. In these experiments, the depth of the dipole potential was on the order of 5 meV, several orders of magnitude deeper than typical traps for neutral atoms. It should be possible to increase this by an order of magnitude before significant ionization of the molecules occurs. This type of strong-field manipulation appears to be quite general, because it does not rely on internal resonances. Of course, the potential here is transient, lasting only as long as the laser pulse (typically, tens of nanoseconds). The use of intense cw laser light has also been proposed for trapping molecules (Friedrich and Herschbach, 1995). Pendular states, as opposed to freely rotating states, would be produced by the alignment of the induced dipole moment with the field. The energy of these pendular states depends on the intensity, resulting in a potential well for the molecules. However, the cw intensities required for reasonable trap depths [e.g., for 3Hebuffer-gas loading at 300 mK (see Section II.B)] appear to be technically challenging. Based on their success with atoms (see Section I.C), the extension of far-off resonance traps (FORTS) to molecules appears promising. Because multiple transitions are possible in molecules, it is important that the trapping light be detuned below all of these transitions. Also, the detunings should be very large in order to minimize spontaneous Raman transitions, thereby maintaining the state selectivity. The cw Nd:YAG laser at 1.064pm appears to be a good candidate for trapping K2 molecules because it is below resonance with all transitions from the v = 0 level of the X state. With 5 W of power focused to a 50-pm waist, we estimate a trap depth of - 4 0 0 p K and a photon scattering rate of -3 s-' for K2 (X, v = 0). The dominant contributions are from the
184
-
J. Z Bahns, P. L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
-
A state (w 10) and the B state (v 2). Although this trap is not very deep, it is sufficient to hold molecules produced by photoassociation of ultracold atoms (Fioretti et al., 1998; Takekoshi et al., 1999; Nikolov et al., 1999; Comparat et al., 1999). The utility of the Nd:YAG laser for trapping heavier alkali dimers is questionable because it may not lie below all the relevant transitions. The CO;! laser at 10.6pm, on the other hand, should work for any of the alkali dimers. It also has the advantage of a very small scattering rate. This type of low-frequency laser trap is a quasi-electrostatic trap (QUEST) (Takekoshi et al., 1995); that is, the potential energy of a molecule in the laser field is due to the static polarizability (see Tarnovsky et al., 1993 for alkali dimer values). For 20 W focused to a 50-pm waist, the trap depth for K2 will be 600 pK. In a very exciting recent development (Takekoshi et al., 1998), this type of trap has been successfully used to trap Cs2 molecules. This experiment produced cold (150 pK) Cs2 from cold Cs atoms confined in a MOT. The molecules were produced at the focus of a COz laser that confined them for -0.5 s. The trap depth was estimated to be -350pK. Detection of the molecules was by ionization with a frequency-doubled (532-nm) pulsed Nd:YAG laser, followed by time-of-flight mass spectrometry. This sensitive detection scheme allowed the small number of molecules trapped to be observed (- 3 detected). However, continuous formation of molecules by three-body recombination of trapped atoms could mimic a long molecule trapping time. This possibility was dismissed by pushing the atoms out of the trap (with a resonant 852 nm laser beam) shortly after the initial loading of molecules. Trapping with light tuned above resonance has been achieved with atoms (Davidson et al., 1995; Kuga et al., 1997). In contrast with the red-detuned FORTSdiscussed previously (Section I.C), atoms are attracted to the region of minimum intensity of blue-detuned light, e.g., the axis of a “doughnut” beam. This has the advantage of confining the atoms in near darkness (as opposed to a region of high intensity), thereby reducing the photon-scattering rate. However, at a finite temperature, the molecules will sample a finite range of intensities, so the scattering is not completely eliminated. As a practical matter, if light is tuned above a given molecular transition, there are likely to be other transitions nearby, so the wavelength must be carefully chosen to fall in a gap, significantly detuned from other allowed transitions. Magnetic fields can also be used to trap paramagnetic atoms and molecules. Indeed, all atomic Bose-Einstein condensates (BECs) produced thus far have employed magnetic traps (Anderson et al., 1995; Davis et al., 1995; Bradley etal., 1997), although transfer of a BEC from a magnetic to an optical trap has also been achieved (Stamper-Kurnet al., 1998; Inouye et al., 1998). Details of magnetic trapping of a given paramagnetic molecule are complex (Friedrich er al., 1998), although some results are available for 0 2 and NO (Friedrich
-
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
185
et al., 1998), VO (Weinstein et al., 1998A), and CaH (Friedrich et al., 1999). In another very exciting recent report, magnetic trapping of a molecule, CaH, has been observed (Weinstein et al., 1998), with 10' molecules being trapped at -0.4 K for 0.5 s. Clearly, the era of trapped subKelvin molecules is just beginning, including large numbers of CaH at 0.4K and barely detectable numbers of Cs2 at 0.15 mK, orders of magnitude colder. We expect dramatic improvement in these parameters in the near future. Ultimately, such manipulated subKelvin molecules (with specified stoichiometry, e.g. GaAs) may be useful in fields such as lithography, where, for example, nanometer scale structures of Cr have been prepared by deposition of cold Cr atoms (McClelland et al., 1993).
3. Cold Collisions
The collisions of subKelvin atoms have already provided a great deal of interesting information reviewed in Walker and Feng (1994), Weiner (1995), and Weiner et al. (1999). In particular, such collisions (as in the photoassociative spectroscopy discussed in Section I.D. 1) involve only a few partial waves (e.g., collisional angular momenta 1 = 0, 1, and 2 for 39K at 300 pK). Such atomic collisions are highly quantum-mechanical and are frequently dominated by shape resonances (Schutte et al., 1972 and Boesten et al., 1996) or Feshbach resonances (Stwalley, 1976; Uang and Stwalley, 1980; Uang et al., 1981; Tiesinga et al., 1993; Inouye et al., 1998; Courteille et al., 1998; Roberts et al., 1998). The availability of ultracold molecules offers the opportunity to study a variety of atom-molecule and ultimately molecule-molecule collisions. In Table I, we list specific processes for the example of 39K2 that we feel can be studied using existing (Nikolov et al., 1999) and proposed improved (Band and Julienne, 1995; Vardi et al., 1997) methods of molecule formation (see also Section IV). Each process can potentially be studied theoretically by close-coupling methods. Analogous calculations of several of such processes involving H + H2 or He H2 collisions have recently been carried out by Dalgarno et al. (Balakrishnan et al., 1997, 1997A, 1998; Forrey et al., 1998, 1999) and are planned for K K2 by R. C8tt. As indicated in the comments in Table I, such processes provide important information for the possible achievement of molecular BEC discussed in Section I.D.5. The overall stability of a 39K2 (0, 0) BEC depends on the scattering length a for 39K2(0,O) 39K2 (0,O)collisions (process 7) (a positive scattering length indicating stability), and the efficiency of the evaporative cooling depends on the elastic cross section, which is proportional to a2.If high densities of 39K2(0,O) cannot be achieved, sympathetic cooling with 39K
+
+
+
186
. I . I: Bahns, P: L . Gould, and W C. Stwalley TABLE I
POSSIBLE
TYPES OF PROCESSES
TO BE STUDIED USING ULTRACOLD SOURCES, AND 3 9 ~ AVAILABILITY. 2
Process 1.
2. 3.
8.
9. 10.
ASSUMING 39'41K
Comments
39K+ 39K2 (v" = 0, J" = 0)- 39K+ 39K2(0,0)
sympathetic cooling of 39K2(0,0) by 39K for BEC same 39K+ 39K2 ( 0 , l )+ 39K+ 39K2 ((41) ortho --t para conversion, possibly 39K+ "K2 ( 0 , l ) 39K+ 39K2 (0,O) preventing sympathetic cooling of 3 9 ~ (0.1) 2 vibrational quenching reaction (no other 3 9 K 4 1 K ( 0 , J ) level can be produced) near-resonant reaction (exoergic) evaporativecooling of 3 9 ~ (0, 2 0)/ scattering length and stability of 39K2 (0,O)BEC 39K2 (0, I ) + "K2 (0, I ) + 39K2 (0, I ) + 39K2 ( @ I ) evaporativecooling of 3 9 ~ (0, 2 I)/ scattering length and stability of 39K2 (0,l) BEC relaxation that destroys BEC 39K2 (0, I ) + 3 9 ~ (2o , i ) 3 9 ~ (0, 2 o)+ 3 9 ~ (0,1) 2 same 39K2(o,1)+39~2(o,1)+ 3 9 ~ 2 ( o , o ) + 3 9 (0~0) ~2
-
-
or 41K would probably be used instead, in which case processes 1 and 5, respectively, would be critical to know. A further possibility is that metastable ortho 39K2 (0, 1) can undergo BEC [using the evaporative cooling process for 39K2 (0, l)]. In principle, relaxation such as processes 9 and 10 could occur, but they are likely to have very small cross sections. Other processes (e.g., 4 and 6) are less significant for BEC but are of considerable fundamental interest. It is also worth noting that none of the collisions shown can produce K3. Thus it is not clear how K3 can be formed in ultracold collisions; if K3 does not form, this will prevent nucleation to clusters and ultimately to the solid. It is conceivable that the initial collisions corresponding to processes 4 and 6 could also access Feshbach resonances in the lowest electronically excited state of K3, which would then rapidly radiate (in tens of nanoseconds) to the ground state of K3. 4. Nucleation and Metastability
The collisions of ultracold atoms and molecules have very few product channels compared to thermal collisions of the same species. For alkali metals, the dissociation energy of the ground state trimer to the ground state of the dimer and an atom is only about half that of the precisely known (Stwalley
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
187
and Wang, 1999) dissociation energy of the ground state of the dimer to two atoms. Thus at ultracold temperatures, there appears to be no obvious way to produce trimers (and higher clusters) from atoms and ground state dimers. An interesting question is whether a single "seed crystal" (a cluster with N 2 3 atoms) can rapidly nucleate (and destroy) the metastable gas. Similar considerations have been invoked in the discussion of the metastability of high-density spin-polarized atomic hydrogen (Stwalley et al., 1980). Such a seed crystal might be injected or formed by atom-molecule or moleculemolecule photoassociation or by tuning to a Feshbach resonance using a magnetic field, for example. 5. Bose-Einstein Condensation of Molecules
The proposed realization of Bose-Einstein condensation (BEC) in a dilute gas of atomic hydrogen (Stwalley and Nosanow, 1976) was finally achieved some 22 years later (Fried et al., 1998). Meanwhile, the interest in cold H spread to laser-cooled alkali atoms (Section 1.C). BEC was achieved in 1995 for 87Rb (Anderson et al., 1995) and subsequently for 23Na(Davis et al., 1995) and 7Li (Bradley et al., 1997), the latter despite its instability due to a negative triplet scattering length (Moerdijk et al., 1994; CSti et al., 1994).Table I1 lists some TABLE I1 SELECTED COMPOSITE BOSON SPECIES. THESIGN OF THE CORRESPONDING SCATTERING LENGTHa IS G I V E N IF KNOWN.
AN ASTERISK (*) INDICATES THAT A DILUTE-GAS BEC HAS BEEN ACHIEVED.
Species
a/lal
BEC
References
'H
+
*
Fried et al. (1998). Uang and Stwalley (1980A) Uang and Stwalley (1980A) Uang and Stwalley (1982) Bradley et al. (1997) Davis et al. (1995) Bohn et al. (1999) Bohn et al. (1999) Boesten et al. (1996), Tsai et al. (1997) Anderson et al. (1995) Kokkelmans et al. (1998), Legere and Gibble (1998) Stwalley (to be submitted) Stwalley (to be submitted) Stwalley (to be submitted)
'H E T 4He ' ~ i 23Na 39K 4' K *'Rb
+ ++
"Rb
+
'33cs
-
'H2 2H2 (-D2) 3H2 (-T2)
+ +
a Triplet
-
*
*
-
*
(a3C:) scattering length for H and alkali metals; singlet scattering length for 4He and H2 species.
J. T. Bahns, l? L . Gould, and W C. Stwalley
188
TABLE 111 NUCLEAR SPIN STATES (AND THEIR DEGENERACIES) FOR HOMONUCLEAR HYDROGENAND ALKALI DIATOMIC MOLECULES IN THEIR GROUND ELECTRONIC STATES FOR J = 0 AND FOR J = 1. ~~
C(21m 1.W
1,
Atom
I,
'H *H 'H 'Li 7 ~ i 23Na 39 K 40 K 41 K
112 1 112 1 312 312 312 4 312 512 312 712
85Rb "Rb 133Cs
Molecule
J=O
J=l
J=O
+ 1) J=l 3 3 3 3 10 10 10 36 10 21 10 36
composite Boson species for which the sign of the scattering length is relatively well known to be positive or negative (or small with uncertain sign); Fermion species are discussed in the next subsection. Of particular interest has been the case of 133Cs,where the triplet scattering length has been known to be large in magnitude with an uncertain sign because of a resonance near zero energy (Arndt et al., 1997; Leo et al., 1998). Very recently, it has been established to be negative in sign (Kokkelmans et al., 1998; Legere and Gibble, 1998). There are several complications in going from atomic to molecular BEC. First, ground state homonuclear diatomics are usually singlets, so the only (weak) magnetic moment such a molecule possesses is due to its nuclear spin. For some species, such as H2 (0,O) (para Hz), I = 0, so there is absolutely no magnetic moment for magnetic trapping. An optical trap must therefore be used. More generally, the nuclear spin state and its degeneracy complicate BEC, as summarized in Table 111. For example, for '33Cs2(0, 0), there are 28 nuclear spin states. Ignoring any splitting among these states in the absence of a magnetic field, one requires 28 times the total density at a given temperature to achieve 28 simultaneous and degenerate BECs. More generally, there should be some very small terms to break this huge degeneracy. The question will be whether the splittings are larger or smaller than the BEC transition temperature T,, which is typically 5 1 pK.
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K)MOLECULES
189
FIG.4. The transition temperature Tc (K)of a BEC decreases as the square root of the mean interparticle spacing r. Interparticle interactions of the identical particles in a BEC decrease as the cube of r for dipole-dipole interactions and as the fifth power of r for quadrupole-quadrupole interactions. Thus for BEC on the 1K temperature scale or lower, the molecular dipole-dipole interactions will cause significant deviations from the Bose ideal-gas approximation.
In addition, the intermolecular interactions will often be stronger than the interatomic. Figure 4 shows a plot of the log of the BEC T, versus the log of the average interparticle spacing. It also shows typical interparticle interactions for a magnetic dipole moment of 1 nuclear magneton on each identical particle (NN), for a magnetic dipole moment of 1 Bohr magneton (BB), for an electric dipole moment of 1 atomic unit (DD), and for an electric quadrupole moment of 1 atomic unit (QQ). BEC in dilute vapors such as 4He or "Mg, each with I = 0, would involve no multipole moment interactions between the identical particles. Other Bosonic atoms, such as 26Mg(I = l), would involve very weak interactions, with the NN curve well below the BEC curve in Fig. 4. The Bosonic atoms that have now undergone BEC ('H, 7Li, 23Na,and 87Rb)have far stronger interparticle interactions, but the BB curve is still well below the BEC curve for T, in the nanokelvin or even the microkelvin range. Nevertheless, interesting
190
J. T Bahns, l? L . Gould, and W C. Stwalley
“spinor” effects are expected and observed when a mixture of atomic hyperfine BECs interact (Stenger et al., 1998, and Miesner et al., 1999), as in liquid 3He (Lee, 1997). For molecules without dipole moments, simple BEC seems quite possible as well, for example, H2 (0,O) (para H2), for which a positive scattering length of 11.3 a0 and correspondingly stable BEC can be estimated (Stwalley, to be submitted). Sympatheticcooling of H2 (0,O)with an alkali BEC, for example, should be possible because no inelastic or reactive collisions can occur (except those that change the alkali atom hyperfine state). These inelastic collisions can be totally suppressed by using the lowest hyperfine state [e.g., 23Na(F = 1, M F = 1) in Inouye et al., 19981for the sympathetic cooling. The situation is more problematical for Bosonic molecules like ’Li ‘Hor ‘H 19F with large dipole moments (although a heteronuclear, homopolar molecule such as 39K41Kmight still be straightforward, with an extremely small electric dipole moment). In particular, as shown in Fig. 4,the dipole-dipole interaction (curve DD) between dipole moments of order 1 atomic unit is comparable to the BEC transition temperature T, even at nanokelvin temperatures. Thus, as in the case of liquid 4He, liquid 3He (where “Cooper pairing” occurs), Cooper pairs in superconductivity, exitonic BEC, etc., the BEC of molecules with large (- 1 a.u.) electric dipole moments will not be well described as a near ideal BEC.
6. Degenerate Fermi Gases of Molecules Like BEC for Bosonic species, degenerate Fermi gas effects should occur when the mean interparticle spacing in a Fermi gas is comparable to its thermal deBroglie wavelength. Experiments to probe such effects in atoms are under way at Rice (6Li) and JILA (40K) and Harvard ( 53Cr).HD is probably the simplest molecular species for which such effects could be observed. It is worth noting that all identical fermion-identical fermion cross sections go to zero in the limit T + OK. This is because Fermi-Dirac symmetry requires antisymmetry of identical particles. Thus s-wave ( 1 = 0) scattering is forbidden, whereas p-wave (1 = 1) scattering vanishes in the limit T + 0 K because there is a centrifugal barrier (e.g., 300 pK for two 39Katoms). Thus at nK temperatures, Fermi particles are “transparent” to each other, and sympathetic cooling with a nonidentical ultracold particle (e.g., Bosons in a BEC) must be used. The best theoretically studied degenerate Fermi gas is 6Li, for which it has been proposed (Stoof et al., 1996; Houbiers et al., 1997) that a mixture of two atomic hyperfine states (to avoid the “transparency” problem) might produce a superfluid transition at a transition temperature as high as 11 nK (Houbiers et al., 1997).The authors, however, quite reasonably admit that the uncertainty
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
191
in their estimates is large, and we anxiously await further experimental and theoretical results in this fascinating area.
7. The Molecule Laser Recently, the concept of an “atom laser” has been introduced and demonstrated (Mewes et al., 1997; Ketterle and Miesner, 1997)to describe a coherent state-selected atomic beam produced by an atomic BEC, essentially a “matter wave” laser of atoms, not photons. The analogous “molecule laser” has now also been proposed by Julienne et al. (1998), where a stimulated Raman rather than a radiofrequency outcoupler is used to produce a coherent, state-selected molecular beam in the direction of net two-photon recoil. Such beams represent the ideal limit of atomic and molecular beams and should ultimately produce important scientific and technological advances.
11. Nonoptjcal Cooling Techniques Although the emphasis in this review is on highly selective optical techniques for formation of cold molecules, there are important nonoptical techniques as well. These techniques include the helium cluster cooling technique (Section ILA), the helium buffer-gas cooling technique (Section KB), trap compression and evaporative cooling techniques (KC), and three-body processes including resonances (1I.D). A. HELIUMCLUSTER COOLING The advantages of helium free jet expansions for formation of very cold ( w 0.4 K) liquid droplets (large clusters) has long been recognized (Buchenau et al., 1990 and references therein). The cold temperature is maintained by evaporation of He atoms. Doping such clusters provides a unique liquid matrix for extension of matrix isolation technology to lower (subKelvin) temperatures. The liquid nature of the matrix also provides an energetically subtle option for the dopant to sit on the cluster surface or to bury itself in the depths of the cluster. The spectroscopic studies of dopants on or in large helium clusters goes back to 1992, when infrared spectra of SF6 and (sF6)2 buried inside the clusters were obtained bolometrically (Goyal et al., 1992). Further experiments employing mass spectrometry for detection obtained rotational resolution (Hartmann el al., 1995) and established an internal temperature of 0.37-0.38 K (Hartmann et al., 1996), consistent with evaporativecooling. Other work on IR spectroscopy includes interior H20 and its clusters (Froechtenicht et al.,
192
J. T. Bahns, l? L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
1996). Electronic spectroscopic studies have included excited states of He:! (Jiang et af., 1993; Northby et al., 1995), the surface-bound alkali metal dimers (Stienkemeieret al., 1995, 1995A, 1995B, 1996; Callegari et af.,1998; Higgins et al., 1998) and trimers (Higgins et al., 1996, 1996A) and other species (Hartmann et af., 1996, 1996a, and Reho et al., 1997; Stienkemeier et af.,1997).This field has recently been revised (Toennies and Vilesov, 1997; and Whaley, 1998). It is clear that a great deal of interesting spectroscopy will be done in and on such clusters. Of particular significance, in our opinion, is the spectroscopic preference for high spin multiplicities (less energy is released when these species are formed from atoms and consequently less desorption from the cluster). High spin multiplicity species, such as ' C i N, (Ferrante and Stwalley, 1983, 1986), are virtually unobserved experimentally. B. HELIUM BUFFER-GAS COOLING The use of 3He and 4He to cool atomic and molecular species, proposed by Stwalley (1984) (see also Dolye et al., 1995), has recently been demonstrated by Doyle, Friedrich, and their coworkers. In particular, this group has cooled and magnetically trapped Eu (Kim et af.,1997), Cr (Weinstein et al., 1998B), and CaH (Weinstein et al., 1998). When 3He is used, subKelvin temperatures of 300 mK are achieved, whereas use of 4He yields temperatures of 0.81.4K. The species are produced by laser ablation of appropriate solids into the helium buffer gas. For the molecule CaH, approximately lo8 molecules are - ~ a temperature of 400 f 50 mK for a trapped at a density of 8 x lo7 ~ r n and decay time of 0.5 s (Weinstein et af.,1998). Virtually all these molecules are in the electronic, vibrational and rotational ground state. About half of the molecules deposited into the trapping region were trapped. Thus improvement in production methods should lead to even larger numbers of trapped molecules. It should also be extendable to other paramagnetic molecules. Magnetic trapping is the key first step toward evaporative cooling (or sympathic cooling) to pK or even nK temperatures.
-
c.
TRAP
COMPRESSION AND EVAWRATIVE COOLING
The nonoptical formation of diatomic molecules from atoms requires threebody collisions, the rate of which increases as the atomic density cubed. The special case of resonances is discussed in Section 1I.D. Two straightforward ways of increasing atomic density in atom traps are trap compression [e.g., by increasing the magnetic field gradient in a magneto-optical trap (MOT)] and evaporative cooling (e.g., to BEC in a magnetic trap as in Anderson et af., 1995; see also the review of Ketterle and Van Druten, 1996).
FORMATION OF COLD (7'5 I K) MOLECULES
-4
12
eps 0
193
e3L I
I
2
I
I
I
I
6
4
I
I
8
I
I
10
I
I 12
N
FIG.5 . The calculated formation rates (units of cm6/s) for high rovibrational levels of energy E (v,N)(with respect to dissociation) of the lowest triplet (a 'C:) state of Z3Na2in the zero temperature limit (Moerdijk et al., 1996). It is assumed that the recombining atoms are doubly spin-polarized and interact only via s-wave collisions on the adiabatic quartet potential surfaces. No quasibound states above dissociation are formed because they are much higher in energy (at E l k > 1 mK above the dissociation limit).
Although there are apparently no experiments that directly measure the molecular states formed by subKelvin three-body recombination, there are a number of studies of three-body loss (e.g., Stamper-Kurn et al., 1998), where such loss was measured for BECs of 23Naboth in a magnetic trap and in an optical trap. Reassuringly, both rates were found to be the same and in rough agreement with two calculations (Moerdijk et al., 1996; Fedichev et al., 1996), which were an order of magnitude larger and an order of magnitude smaller, respectively. The former calculation is of particular interest because it predicts the branching of the recombination into different rovibrational levels of the lowest triplet molecular state, exclusively formed from doubly spin-polarized atoms. Figure 5 shows the results of Moerdijks et al. (1996) for 23Na2formation, where 86% of the recombination goes into the single most weakly bound level [E(15,O)lk = 0.002 K]. Three-body recombination in "Rb has been used to probe higher-order coherences in a BEC (Burt et al., 1997). The lower rate observed in a BEC compared to a thermal sample demonstrated the reduced density fluctuations in a BEC. The noncondensed
194
J. T. Bahns, P. L . Gould, and W C. Stwalley
rate agreed well with corresponding theory (Fedichev et al., 1996). Threebody recombination may also contribute to formation of translationally ultracold Cs2 molecules (Takekoshi et al., 1999). In the three-body loss work, it has been assumed that the loss was exclusively due to molecule formation, although in principle, three-body inelastic collisions could also contribute. However, because two-body inelastic collisions are often unimportant, as in Stamper-Kurn et al., (1998), such threebody inelastic collisions should not be important. It might also be noted that for the lowest hypefine state, which can be optically but not magnetically trapped (e.g., IF = 1, MF = 1) in 23Na),no such inelastic three-body processes are energetically possible except as the magnetic field goes to zero.
D. THREE-BODY PROCESSES INCLUDING RESONANCES The character of three-body recombination can be altered if there is a twobody long-lived resonance, either single-channel (shape) or multichannel (Feshbach). Such considerations were invoked in 1976 (Stwalley, 1976) in connection with the stability of spin-polarized hydrogen and are further discussed elsewhere (Stwalley et al., 1980; Uang and Stwalley, 1980; Uang et al., 1981). Essentially, the “resonance” is a long-lived intermediate in a two-body collision; thus the three-body process becomes a sequence of two two-body collisions. At the low energies of ultracold collisions, very long resonance lifetimes (microseconds)can still be within the thermal distribution of collision energy. For a given atom A in a specific hyperfine state, this corresponds to A
+ A +A $ ( v , J )
(1)
where # indicates a shape (quasibound) resonance and ( v , J ) represent the vibrational and rotational quantum numbers of the resonance, followed by A$(v,J)
+A
+
A2(v,J- 1)
+A
(2)
[and similar inelastic processes that yield other (v,J ) levels of lower energy], where the lower levels produced are generally either truly bound levels or orders of magnitude more stable quasibound (predissociative) levels. The resonance theory of three-body recombination was formulated in Roberts et al. (1969) for the case of H atom recombination, where the theory predicts a maximum rate at 65 K attributable to a single broad resonance, v = 14, J = 5 of X ‘CLH,, with an energy of 65.8 K with respect to dissociation and a width of 25 K (predissociation lifetime of 0.31 ps) in Le Roy and Bernstein (1971). This single resonance increases the rate by over an N
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
195
order of magnitude from the nonresonant background rate (Roberts et al., 1969). The Dz X 'Cp' (v = 21, J = 1) resonance implies a similar, more dramatic maximum near the energy of the quasibound level (- 124mK above the D D asymptote) (Stwalley, 1976). Essentially, such resonances are formed with a very long time delay and are then relaxed rotationally with a large cross section to more stable levels. To be somewhat more quantitative, a 70K width corresponds to a predissociation lifetime of 1 ps, a 70 pK width to 1 ps (Le Roy and Bernstein, 1971). Thus shape resonances with microKelvin widths at microKelvin temperatures will dramatically enhance three-body recombination rates. Such considerations apply not only to single-channel shape resonances but also to multichannel Feshbach resonances, for example, magnetic-fielddependent hyperfine-induced X Cp' - a 3 C i mixed-state resonances in H2 (Stwalley, 1976), Li2 (Uang et al., 1981), Rb2 (Tsai et al., 1997), and CSZ (Weickenmeieret al., 1985). Such resonances have recently been observed as a function of magnetic field in trapped 85Rb(Courteille et al., 1998; Roberts et al., 1998) and in a Na BEC (Inouye et af., 1998). Not surprisingly, tuning a magnetic field can bring Feshbach resonances into the thermal collision energy range of trapped atoms and BECs (pK and nK, respectively), allowing step 1 (where # now indicates a Feshbach resonance) to proceed, thereby enhancing the three-body recombination and three-body loss. This enhanced three-body loss has been observed in a Na BEC (Inouye et af., 1998 and Stenger et al., 1999). Shape resonances cannot, of course, be as readily tuned with a magnetic field.
+
'
111. Optical Cooling Techniques Current proposals for direct optical manipulation (here we mean cooling, heating, deflection, trapping, diffraction, etc.) of molecules can be broadly classified as either incoherent (resonant optical pumping with spontaneous decay) or coherent (Raman-like). Current incoherent methods appear to be technically more complex (requiring multiple frequencies) but are clearly capable of manipulating (cooling, heating, and trapping) macroscopic quantities of molecules. Starting with a thermal distribution of molecules, the ultimate goal is to cool and trap a large translationally ultracold (< 1mK) molecular sample in the lowest rovibrational level of the ground electronic state (with TROT= TVIB= OK). Although great progress has been made in recent years in manipulating atoms (Section LC), molecules have proven to be resilient to atomic optical manipulation methodologies. This is true mainly because of the increased spectral complexity and multiple spontaneous decay channels (lack of closed
196
J. I: Bahns, I! L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
energy level schemes for recycling population). By changing vibrational and rotational state, molecules can readily shift themselves out of resonance in any known atomic cooling scenario. The analogous problem occurs in atomic laser cooling when there are multiple decay channels to nonresonant hyperfine levels. In this case, the addition of one (generally nearby) “repumping” laser is sufficient to counter this optical hyperfine pumping. But even for the simplest diatomic molecules, optical rovibrational pumping is far more complex than for atoms, typically requiring 19 or more “repump” lasers (Bahns et al., 1996). By limiting the number of states and frequencies involved, there have been a limited number of experimental demonstrations of optical manipulation of gaseous molecules. The only successful incoherent cooling experiment was reported by Djeu and Whitney (1981), who succeeded in cooling C02 molecules in a cell (AT 1 K) by pumping the P(20) transition of the 100-001 band with a 300 W cw C02 laser. However, it was necessary to use collisional equilibration with a hot buffer gas (Xe at 300°C 0.1 Torr) for population of the lower (100) pump level. Successful radiative (single-photon-momentum) deflection of molecules in a highly collimated beam has also been demonstrated by Herrmann et al. (1979). Coherent transfer between two molecular levels formulated by Gaubatz et al. (1990) and Bergmann et al. (1998) by the STIRAP (stimulated Raman adiabatic passage) process has proven to be exceedingly efficient. Presently, adaptations of STIW-like variants for sequential population transfers through multiple intermediate states [such as ladder schemes and RCAP (Raman chirped adiabatic passage), reviewed in Bergmann et al. (1998)l are formulated but remain to be demonstrated for molecules. N
A. INCOHERENTOPTICALCOOLING OF MOLECULES Sequential incoherent optical cooling of thermally populated molecular samples is assumed to require the simultaneous generation and precise frequency control of many laser lines. If a molecule is Raman active, it can in principle be cooled by the sequential technique. For the discussion,a general nomenclature designates the degree of freedom cooled followed by the type of optical transition employed (e.g., RE is cooling rotation using an electronic transition). Table IV lists the other relevant combinations, of which only those utilizing electronic transitions appear practical (RE, TE, and VE), on the basis of having the shortest radiative lifetimes (typically tens of nanoseconds). Sequential optical cooling of molecules, as formulated by Bahns et al. (1996), is restricted to electronic transitions. Only the proposed order rotation-translation-vibration (RE-TE-VE) appears to be practical. The
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K)MOLECULES
197
TABLE IV MOLECULAR CCOLING TYPES.
OVERVIEW OF OPTICAL
Degree of Freedom
Optical Transition
Cooling 5 p e
Electronic/Vibration/Rotation Vibration/Rotation Rotation
TE* TV
Electronic/Vibration/Rotation Vibration/Rotation
VE*
Rotation
Electronic/Vibration/Rotation Vibration/Rotation Rotation
RE* RV** RR
Electronic
Electronic/Vibration/Rotation
EE
EXTERNAL: Translation
INTERNAL: Vibration
TR
vv**
* Proposed in Bahns et ol. (1996). **Demonstrated in Djeu and Whitney (1981).
most challenging step, TE, can be avoided if one begins with a sample of ultracold atoms and performs PAS (photoassociativespectroscopy,Section IV) (Thorsheim et al., 1987; Band and Julienne, 1995) followed by VE cooling, assuming cold rotational energies. After selection of an appropriate set of rovibrational states of sufficient closure, an ensemble of laser frequencies can be generated in a MSF (multiple single-frequency)laser, described later in this section. For vibration, the degree of closure depends on the number of ground vibrational levels in the set. A set of ground vibrational levels, however, is sufficiently closed when spontaneous decays to all levels outside the set have a negligible effect on the population during the time required for cooling. As a general rule, the product of the number of photons needed to cool a degree of freedom times the probability of leaving the cooling cycle (per scattering event) should not exceed unity. For TE cooling Csz (B-X), the minimum set of ground vibrational levels turns out to be 10 (i.e., 21’’ = 0-9 coupled to 21’ = 0) for an initial speed of 2 2 O d s . Spontaneous decays that involve rotational selection rules (e.g., A J = 0, +/ - 1) do not cause a closure problem. Generally, shorter cooling times imply proportionately smaller sets of vibrational levels for achieving closure. RE cooling, illustrated in Fig. 6, is accomplished with the MSF laser (see below). This is accomplished by stepping sequentially (a “P-step” procedure) from a P branch frequency P(J&) to P(J& - 2), then to P(J& - 4), . . . , and finally to P(JN= 4). The first step transfers all population of para molecules from J& to J& - 2 because while stimulated absorption and emission are occurring between the levels (v‘’ = 0, J ’ = J& - 1) and
J. ‘I: Bahns, P. L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
198 J‘=l -
J’=3
FIG.6. Rotational cooling to J” = 0 and 2 levels on an electronic transition (RE cooling) exemplified for the A’C: - X’C; or B In, - X’C,f transitions of the para form of an alkali dimer with odd nuclear spin (e.g., ‘ 3 3 C ~ 2 39K2). r The P branch frequencies would be stepped in order from P(JMAx)to P(JMA~ - 2) . . . to P(4). leaving all para population in J” = 0 or 2 levels.
(v”,JLm), spontaneous emission (“optical pumping”) occurs to the levels (v”,J” - 2). The second step similarly transfers population from the YAX - 2) levels to the (v”,J L A x - 4) levels. The final step transfers (v”,JMAX population from the (d’, 4)levels to the (v”,2) levels. There is no reason to rotationally cool the para molecules below J ” = 2 because of the TE and VE steps discussed below. Assuming saturation of the various P(J”) transitions, the time T required for transferring the population of the set of (w”,J”) levels to the set of (d’, J” - 2) levels can readily be estimated from the effective radiative lifetime of the (v’,J ’ = J ” - 1) level from the Einstein A coefficients:
The effective radiative lifetime can also be readily estimated from the true total radiative lifetime in the absence of resonant P branch [P(J”)] radiation (ignoring the rotational dependence of A v ’ + v t ~ ) : TRADe
’ 9’
(-)TR4D 2 J N-
1
(4)
For the B ‘II, - X C bands of Cs2 given in Table V, T ~ =D25 ns for the B ‘II,,w’ = O rotational levels. Thus 5 TRADe is approximately 275 ns and 292 ns for J” = 6 and J” = 4,respectively. The analogous “R-step” procedure beginning at R(0) and ending at R(JL,) provides the mechanism for rotational population transfer from J ” = 0 to J ” = JLAX.It is important to realize that although R and P
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
199
TABLE V EXAMPLES OF SEQUENTIAL RE - TE - VE COOLING OF PARA133Cs2USINGA MSF LASER OPERATING ON THE 20B In, (0’= 0,J’ = 1 ) - x ‘El (W” = 0 - 9, J ” = 0 AND 2) TRANSITIONS, FOR WHICH EACHFREQUENCY IS PRECISELY KNOWN. ~
~~
~
~~
~
~
~~
Cooling 5Pe
Pump Transition
Pump Plus Selected Raman Sidebands
Irradiation Time (1s)
Total Irradiation Time (ps)
RE RE TE
Po (6) Po (4) Po (2)
0.215 0.292 1 lo00
0.215 0.567 1 lo00
VE
Po (2)
P,,01(6) (v” = 0-9) Pwv(4)(v” = 0-9) P,fl(2) (v” = 0-9) R,,t(O) (w” = 0-9) P,fl(2) (w” = 0-9) R”o~(0)(w” = 1-9)
1.95
1lo00
branches overlap in a molecular band, rotation can be “cooled” or “heated” independently with narrow-band laser excitations. This is possible because R(J) and P(J) lines do not normally coincide in frequency, making it impossible for a given rotational population to interact simultaneously with P(J) and R(J) excitation. Rotationally hot “super rotor” molecules (which could be vibrationally and translationally cold) might be prepared by the R-step technique (Li et al., to be submitted). Such “super rotor” states, potentially with significantly greater energy than bond dissociation energies (e.g., J 2 106 for 6Li2), should exhibit novel collisional dynamics. Short infrared pulses have also been proposed as a means to spin up molecules to high angular momentum states (Karczmarex et af., 1999). Immediately following the RE step, TE cooling, illustrated for even J” molecules assuming the lowest three (rather than the lowest 10 as in Bahns ef af.,1996) vibrational levels form a “closed cycle,” as shown is Fig. 7. For the homonuclear alkali diatomic molecules, selection of the set of the two lowest even J” lines [R(O) and P(2)] can be used to TE cool para molecules. Conversely, selection of the set of the two lowest odd J ” [R( 1) and P(3)] can be used to TE-cool ortho molecules (for 6Li2 and 40K2, these para and ortho designations are reversed). RE-cooled ortho and para molecules can be TE-cooled simultaneously, using an additional pump laser. TE cooling of molecular translation is analogous to the more familiar atomic chirp cooling (Prodan and Phillips, 1984; Ertmer et al., 1985). Molecular TE cooling rates are also comparable to the atomic case and are limited by the 25 ns radiative lifetime of the upper state. For example, in Table V, TE slowing of a Cs2 beam on the B-X bands from o 220m/s, is estimated by Bahns et af. (1996) to require 1 1 ms (equivalent to 1.1 x lo5 spontaneous photon-scattering events). This time will depend on the details of the saturation of various R and P lines, laser polarization, etc. N
N
200
J. T. Bahns, P. L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley V
v " a , J"=O
Y
FIG.7. Translational chirp cooling of J" = 0 and 2 levels on an electronic transition (TE cooling) exemplified for the A I C - X I C or B I II, - X I C transitions of the para form of an alkali dimer with odd nuclear spin (e.g., 133C~2, 39K2). The diagram assumes that only three (rather than 10 as in Bahns er al., 1996) vibrational levels d'are needed for a "closed cycle." The six laser frequencies shown would be simultaneously chirped over the Doppler profile as in atomic c h r p cooling of translation using the MSF laser described below and in Bahns et af. (1996).
Immediately following the TE cooling step, VE cooling is implemented, as illustrated in Fig. 8 (for para molecules, assuming again only the lowest three (rather than the lowest 10 as in Bahns et al., 1996) vibrational levels are Franck-Condon-coupled to v' = 0). VE cooling to v" = 0, J" = 0 is initiated by removing (blocking) the single R(O), v" = 0, J" = 0 tf v' = 0, J' = 1, MSF laser side band. This causes the entire para population to be transferred (optically pumped) unidirectionally to v" = 0, J" = 0. If all but the blocked transition are saturated, the time required for this step depends on the effective radiative lifetime of the blocked transition, given by Trade = I [A,I=o,J L ~ - + , G O , ~ ~ 0 = 1 390ns. For the Cs2 example in Table V, > 99% transfer in this step can be considered complete in roughly 5 effective radiative lifetimes, or 1.95ps. This completes the (unique) RE-TE-VE sequence. The total time required, roughly 11ms, is due to the lack of speed and efficiency of TE cooling compared to RE and VE cooling (these are compared in Bahns er af., 1996). Both the total frequency change of the pump laser, 3.6 GHz, and the rates for both RE steps and TE chirps are experimentally achievable. Generally, by making the appropriate choices of states in the RE, TE, and VE cooling steps, nearly complete population transfer to a single rovibrational level is possible. The Cs2 (B-X)example constitutes a 40 1 level (280 -+ 1 state) transfer (v" = 0-9 and J" = 0, 2, 4, 6 -+ v" = 0, J f f = 0). N
N
--f
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
20 1
v"=2J"=2 v"=2J"=o v%lJ"=2 V'klJ"=o
v"=OJ"=2 v'k0, J"=O FIG.8. Vibrational cooling to the V" = 0, J" = 0 lowest level on an electronic transition (VE cooling) exemplified for the A 'C: - X ' C l or B In, - X'C; transitions of the para form of an alkali dimer with odd nuclear spin (e.g., 133Cs2.39K2).The d' = 0,R (0) MSF laser transition would be blocked, so spontaneous emission (optical pumping) would transfer all population from the coupled manifold of levels to V" = 0,J" = 0.
The MSF laser for performing the above cooling sequence is illustrated in Fig. 9. Again using Cs2 as the example, one begins in (a) with a single narrowband pump (master) laser (tunable and chirpable). The appropriately closed set of sidebands is generated when (b) the pump laser multiply traverses a sample of molecules contained in the Raman gain medium (here, a separate supersonic beam of C S ~ )Inelastic . resonant-stimulated Raman (RSR) scattering generates the ensemble of weaker narrow-band sidebands, which copropagate with the pump beam. The ensemble is then "filtered" by a selector (subtractive spectrometer) and amplified by a high-gain (> lo6) broad-band (- 25 nm) amplifier (Titanium Sapphire). RE, TE, and VE cooling outputs are illustrated in parts (c), (d), and (e), respectively, in Fig. 9 for the Cs2 example. For the RE cooling sequence, only P(J") lines are transmitted by the selector, giving the 10 frequencies required for the "P-step" (for a 280 --t 60 state population transfer). For TE cooling, the 20 frequencies are transmitted by the selector during the sub-Doppler chirp of the master laser. Critical to TE cooling, the Doppler tuning of each RSR sideband (S,i) is related to the pump detuning (6,) by 6si = ( k s i / k p ) & p
(5)
where ksi and kp are the wave vectors of the ith sideband and pump, respectively. This is vital to TE cooling because sub-Doppler chirping of the master pump laser results in synchronously chirped sidebands, all resonant
J. T. Bahns, P. L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
202
C
output for cooling
M2
I/ I(( , ,
v"=O,P(J)
+V'd
I
v'no-a
\:
Pump
Pump + Stimulated Raman
b
I P chirp: P(J)
P(2) and R(0)
R(O),v"=O blocked C
V
FIG.9. The multiple single-frequency laser scheme for generating the frequencies needed for sequential RE, TE, and VE cooling. A single tunable, narrow-band pump laser (a) pumps the Raman gain medium (here a separate supersonic beam of Csz). The appropriate set of Raman sidebands are generated and then selected and amplified for use in cooling. If no selection is employed, all sidebands (P,,.( J ) , v" = 1-9 and Ruj# (J), v" = 0-9) are produced (b). If population transfer (RE cooling) from J to J - 2 is desired, the pump laser is tuned to the PO( J ) line and the Put<( J ) (v" = 1-9) as well as the PO(J)pump line are selected and amplified (c) (the R,. (J),(21'' = 0-9) lines are blocked). If TE cooling of the Doppler profiles of a previously REcooled sample is desired, the pump laser is tuned to the Po (2) line and all sidebands are selected and amplified (d); then the PO(2) pump laser is chirped over the Doppler profile, causing all sidebands to be simultaneously chirped bringing about TE cooling of all 20 lower rovibrational levels. If population transfer (VE cooling) of a previously RE- and TE-cooled sample to the v" = 0, J" = 0 level is desired, then the PO (2) pump line is again used to generate all sidebands, all of which except for the & (0)line are then selected and amplified (e); only the & (0) line is blocked.
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
203
with the same-velocity group of molecules. As molecules decelerate, Doppler compensation occurs simultaneouslyon all sidebands (ksi)when just the pump laser detuning is chirped (d6,ldt). This can be seen in the expression for the Doppler-compensateddetuning rate of the ith sideband (d&/dt), given by d6si/dt = (ksi/kp)d6p/dt = ksi(dv/dt)
(6)
Note that the deceleration of resonant molecules (dvldt) is independent of sideband (k,J (i.e., ksi appears on both sides of the last equality in equation 6). Therefore, the entire ensemble of decelerating molecules are always resonant with each sideband throughout the TE chirp, insuring that all molecules cool (decelerate) at the same rate, irrespective of sideband. In the final step (VE cooling), the selector simply blocks the 0 4 band R(0) sideband (this is easy to perform because it has the highest frequency). This causes the populations of all optically coupled states to be transferred to the “dark” state, v” = 0, J” = 0 (60 + 1 state transfer). It might be noted that the pump- and MSF-stimulated Raman sidebands will be narrowband sidebands. Thus the RE cooling should be carried out with these laser beams perpendicular to the molecular beam, with the small transverse Doppler width of the beam matched to the laser line widths, so that all molecules are RE-cooled. The TE chirp cooling must be carried out with the laser beams and the RE-cooled molecular beam counter-propagating along the beam axis. The RE-, TE-cooled molecules can then be VE-cooled from any direction. As a Raman gain medium for the MSF laser cooling of alkali dimers, we have developed a novel new pulsed high-temperature supersonicbeam (to be described in a future submission to Rev. Sci. Instrum.). This beam, now operating with potassium, involves injection of 0.3-Hz pulses of high-pressure (> 10 atmospheres) Ar from a standard pulse valve into a cell containing highpressure potassium vapor (currently 20 torr; potentially 150 torr). This pulse opens a poppet valve for 50 ms, producing a high-density slit-shaped pulse of K and Kz,with transverse translational and rotational temperatures of 60 K (based on single-shot, rotationally resolved B-X spectra). Besides serving as a Raman gain medium, the pulsed beam can also be used to produce large densities of state-selected cold molecular ions. Studies of ultracold molecular ions are currently possible by conversion of ultracold molecules via state-selected multiple resonance photo-ionization. Tsai et al. (1995) and Chang et al. (submitted) have demonstrated production of cold Na2f in a sodium heat pipe by all optical triple resonance (AOTR) of Na2, using the scheme illustrated in Fig. 10: N
N
J. I: Bahns, F? L. Gould, and W C. Shvalley
204
-
Na(3s)+Na'+c'
40-
30-
-,
"0 e
K
FIG. 10. Scheme for production of state-selected (v+ = 0, N+ = 0) N a i molecular ions (Tsai et al., 1995, Chang et al. (submitted)). If a translationally cold or ultracold source of Na2 was used, one would have an ideal source of state-selected ultracold Nai ions.
A'CT(1,J") + h V 2
+
31Cgf(0,J')
+ hv3 + nl'AF)(O,J)(E > 39,558.06 f0.06cm-') nl'AP'(0,J) X2C;(vf = 0, N + = 0) + e-
3'C;(O,J')
+
(8) (9) (10)
Excitation of Rydberg states lying slightly above the ionization threshold gives rise to state-selective autoionization, restricted to the lowest level of the dimer ion. Similar experiments have been carried out previously by
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
205
all optical double resonance in K2 (Leutwyler ef al., 1981; Broyer ef al., 1983). Accurate energetics permit precise multiple resonance schemes for state-selective production and spectroscopy of other cold alkali dimer and trimer ions (Stwalley and Bahns, 1993). Cooling gas-phase molecules at higher densities where collision effects become important can result in heating via quenching of excited states, reabsorption of anti-Stokes radiation, diffusion (or convection at sufficiently high densities), thermal conduction, multiphoton ionization, etc. We do not attempt to consider the array of such processes here (see, however, Section I.D.3). Without ways of overcoming losses due to these competing processes, there is currently little hope for direct incoherent optical cooling in the presence of frequent collisions. Coherent techniques that rely on the preservation of phase are also expected to be sensitive to collisions. In summary, direct sequential incoherent optical cooling of diatomic molecules using the MSF laser approach, currently under development, appears promising, particularly for faster and more efficient RE and VE cooling. These can also be used to cool molecules formed by incoherent photoassociation of ultracold atoms (Section PI).TE cooling of molecules presents the greater technical challenge but appears feasible. Ultracold stateselected molecular ions can potentially be synthesized from translationally ultracold molecules. B. COHERENT OPTICAL MANIPULATION OF MOLECULES Proposals for direct cooling of molecules by coherent processes have been recently formulated theoretically. One method, developed by Bartana ef al. (1993), uses a series of shaped pulses to cool molecular internal degrees of freedom. The procedure, analogous to a heat pump, maintains a cooled vibrational population on the molecular ground state surface and, simultaneously, a vibrationally hot population on an excited electronic surface. Experimental implementations and the possibility of extension to the ultracold regime await testing. In another method demonstrated theoretically by Garraway and Suominen (1998), non-Franck-Condon state-selective transfers of molecular wavepackets from the ground state potential through an intermediateto a stationary, displaced (in R) excited state have been proposed. The method, adiabatic passage by light-induced potentials (APLIP), uses a counterintuitive sequence of short high-intensity (TW/cm2) red-detuned laser pulses to couple displaced electronic states via a third intermediatedisplaced state. Preliminary modeling for adiabatic transfers via the sequence X I E i - A'C; - 2lrII,inNa2 allows complete transfers despite negligible Franck-Condon overlaps between states. Practical application (particularly for a A configuration) provides additional
J. Z Bahns, t? L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
206
hope for efficient transfers of molecular wavepackets accompanied by large simultaneous changes in R and E. Unfortunately, the predicted threshold intensities for APLIP suggest significant losses due to nonlinear optical processes, such as multiphoton ionization. In summary, incoherent and coherent techniques have been proposed for cooling and manipulating thermally populated diatomic molecules. Experimental tests of these methodologies have recently begun.
IV. Formation of Cold Molecules Via Laser-Induced Photoassociation A. SPONTANEOUS DECAY 1. Proposals
The formation of translationally ultracold molecules, as discussed above, can be accomplished by starting with trapped ultracold atoms and photoassociating these to produce translationally ultracold molecules. This idea was first introduced by Thorsheim et al. (1987), who presented the theory of laserinduced photoassociation applied to sodium atoms via singlet and triplet manifolds (see also Section I.D.1). The scheme involves excitation of cold sodium atoms with a photoassociation laser (hvpA), which pumps ultracold atoms to a long-range high vibrational level of singlet or triplet excited electronic states Na + Na
+ hVpA
+ Nal.
(11)
Because the kinetic energies of ultracold atoms are exceedingly small (smaller than or comparable to the widths of bound-bound transitions), these free-bound transitions are state-selective. Spontaneous radiative decays of Na; via bound-free emission, (14
Na; - + N a + N a + h v
tend to dominate the decay. However, bound-bound emission also occurs,
'
where the final Na2 is either in the electronic ground state (X EL) or the lowest triplet state (a3CT). These bound-bound emissions tend to favor highly vibrationally excited lower-state vibration levels but are generally not
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
207
20
15
h
r
€ sX
10
FI
w
5
0
-5 4
2
6
8
10
12
14
16
18
20
R(A) FIG.11. Single photon photoassociationof ultracold 39Katoms to the v = 191 level of the A C: state 39K2 yields formation of translationally ultracold 39K2molecules in vibrationally excited levels (e.g., v = 36) of the X ' E l ground electronic state (Nikolov et al., 1999).
state-selective. The bound-free emission usually leads to the production of translationally hot sodium atoms that quickly leave the trap. With minor modifications, the analogous scheme for cold potassium (X ' X i ) molecules is illustrated in Fig. 11 based on Nikolov et al. (1999), which is further discussed in Section IV.A.2. For illustration, magnetooptically trapped (MOT) potassium atoms are photoassociated to w = 191 of the A'C; state K
+ K + hVpA
-+
K; (A'Cf, v = 191)
(14)
Spontaneous radiative decay here also is partitioned between bound and continuum states, K ; ( A ' C ~ , V =1 9 1 ) + ( K + K ) o r ( K z X ' C i ) + h v
(15)
Again, most decays are bound-free, but a small fraction (0.15%) is boundbound, leading to a distribution of high-lying vibrational levels, with the Franck-Condon factors suggesting that the most populous is v N = 36.
J. I: Bahns, F! L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
208
It appears that trying to make cold 21’’ = 0, J” = 0 molecules by onephoton photoassociation will not work very well (here with the aim of ultimately trapping them for times long compared to reciprocal collision frequencies or sufficiently long for equilibration between internal and external degrees of freedom). The result will be mostly hot atoms (leading to significant trap loss), and the few molecules produced will be vibrationally hot, with virtually no chance of reaching w” = 0. Rotational heating is less problematic because photoassociation selects only partial waves leading to low rotational quanta (s, p, and d waves), and rotational selection rules allow a greater level of optical control. A better method for producing w” = 0, J” = 0 molecules is needed because optical trapping potentials are too weak to contain molecules heated by V-T or R-T energy transfer collisions with atoms or other molecules. In response to this dilemma, Band and Julienne (1995) proposed a twocolor photoassociative scheme for sodium that provides not only a large improvement in molecular fractions but also a spontaneous decay gateway to ultracold v” = 0 molecules. Their three-step scheme, here adapted to twophoton potassium atom photoassociation (Wang et al., 1997A). is shown in Fig. 12. The first step involves photoassociation of free atoms to high-lying, 35
30
25
0 0
20
0 + . I
15
5
3 10
0
2
4
6
0
10
12
14
16
R(A) FIG. 12. The Band and Julienne (1995) scheme for translationally ultracold molecule formation by two-color excitation, adapted to known states of 39K2.
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
209
long-range levels of the l'n, state (lg at long range in Hund's case c). K+K+hv1 +Kl(llIIg)
(16)
This state has a significantly longer radiative lifetime than the A C: state, which allows molecules to survive more vibrational periods before decaying spontaneously. Therefore, absorption at the l'n, inner turning point by a second laser (hv2) via K;(llIIg) +hv2 + Kl*(nllAu)(e.g.,5'nu,v= 11)
(17)
will have a higher probability. Optimization requires small detuning adjustments which allow for power shifts. Spontaneous decay of the Rydberg state to the ground state,
, V33) +hv K ; * ( ~ ' ~ , ,= L 11) J + K ~ ( X ' C , ~<
(18)
is entirely bound-bound, with roughly 10% of the emission probability to as shown in the Fig. 13 Franck-Condon factors. Estimates for potassium using typical experimentalparameters (Wang et al., 1996) predict a formation rate of lo6 K2 v = 0 molecules per second. Branching of Rydberg emissions to lower-lying excited 'Ci states is expected to be small (<5%), although the relevant potentials and transition dipole moments are somewhat uncertain. Because little selectivity of terminal vibrational levels is possible in this scheme, vibrationally hot molecules would need to be removed (i.e., by photo-ionization or photodissociation) or cooled to V" = 0, J" = 0 by VE MSF LJ" = 0,
N
c 0
U
c
600
Y2
400
0
e 200 0 0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
16
18 20 22
24
28 28 30 32 34
v" in X state
FIG. 13. Franck-Condon factors for the 5 'IT, (v = 11) in Fig. 12.
+X
' E l (v") transition shown
J. T. Bahns, I? L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
210
L
5
Distance r FIG. 14. Schemes of C6t6 and Dalgamo (1997, 1999) for production of various levels (e.g.. u4 = 10, u;' = 0) of the a 'C: state of translationally ultracold 'Liz.
laser cooling prior to trapping. Note that rotational cooling is not necessary because the photoassociation step could selectively produce J' = 2 of the llIIgstate, the Rydberg excitation step could produce J = 1 of the v = 11 level of the 51111,state, and the spontaneous emission could produce J" = 0 and 2 (para molecules) exclusively. More recently, a somewhat different two-color scheme for producing cold (triplet) molecules (e.g., 7Li2 a3C;) has been formulated by C6t6 and Dalgarno (1997). Their method provides large improvements in terminal vibrational state selectivity. The scheme, illustrated in Fig. 14 for producing 7Li2a3C,f (v" = 0) molecules begins with photoassociation to a high vibrational level of the l3C; state: 7Li +'Li
+ hv,
-+ 'Li;(l3C;,4
= 58)
(19)
Spontaneous decay of LiI(w', = 58) is primarily bound-free, but a significant fraction ( ~ 1 1 % )is bound-bound, of which -98% is to a single level, vll 1 - 10: 7 L i ; ( 1 3 C p , = 58) -+ 7Li2(a3C:,wy = 10)
+ hv
(20)
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
21 1
A second laser frequency is chosen that excites w',' = 10 molecules to a lower vibrational level (wk = 10) of the same 13Cg' state: 7Li2(a3Cr,wy = 10) + hvl
+ 7Li;(13Ci, wi =
10)
This level spontaneously decays back to the ground state with an increased bound-bound emission fraction (-22%): 7Li; ( 13C,f,wi = 10) + 7Li2 (a3C:, w; = 0) + hv2 of which -53% is to vg = 0. Recent refinements of the C8t6 and Dalgarno scheme (1999) now include stimulated as well as spontaneous sequences for producing ground singlet (X Cg') and lowest triplet (a 'C,') 7Li2 and 6Li2 molecules. The scheme works best for making triplet molecules. The most favorable spontaneous pathway so far for singlet molecules uses the A'C; state and produces primarily X'Cg' (w; 30) molecules (16.7%), with a smaller relative percentage of decays (-3 x going to w; = 0 [again, with possible postselection of N; = 0 (or 1) molecules].
-
2. Observations Recently, ultracold (- 100 pK) molecules from photoassociated trapped atoms have been directly observed. The first observations of ultracold molecules (cesium dimers in the lowest triplet state and later in the ground singlet state), were made by Fioretti et al. (1998, 1999) using the scheme depicted in Fig. 15(a). To form translationally ultracold molecules, they used an 852-nm laser (tunable from 0 to 300 GHz to the red of the 6 2P3/2 atomic asymptote) to form excited 0; and 1, molecules at long range. C s + C s + h v l +Cs;[O;(l'C:)
-
and l,(l'rIu)]
(23)
For cesium, these states have a unique double minimum structure resulting from avoided crossings at 15 Bohr and 18Bob, respectively. FranckCondon overlaps of the outer wells at these turning points with the lowest triplet and ground singlet states is large, providing efficient spontaneous decay channels for cold molecules: N
J. I: Bahns, t? L. Could, and W C. Stwalley
212
FIG.15. The Csz long-range potentials. (a) The long-range photoassociation (1I ) to the 0; “pure long-range molecule” state, followed by spontaneous emission to the a ’C; lowest triplet state, producing translationally ultracold triplet molecules. (b) The ionization detection of these translationally ultracold triplet Csz molecules by two-photon one-color resonance-enhanced ionization (Fioretti et al., 1998).
In addition, the triplet photoassociation spectrum exhibited two “giant” resonances at -64 and -193GHz. These were interpreted to be due to spontaneous decays originating from the inner well of the 1’ X i state, coupled via tunneling with the outer well where photoassociation occurs. For detection, molecules were two-photon-ionized using (Fig. 15b) Cs2(a3C:,v” > 8 and X’C:,v’’
N
140)
+ 2hv(716nm) + Cs2(5d311,) -, Cs,f + e-
(25)
followed by ion counting with a microchannel plate. Dimer ion counts, typically < 200 s-’, were discriminated against background Cs+ using time of flight. To discriminate against counts from ionized MOT laser-excited states, MOT lasers were turned off for a period long compared to radiative lifetimes prior to the ionizing laser pulses. Spatial and temporal mapping of molecules falling from the trap region by gravity gave a translational temperature of 300 pK.Note that for these high levels (a3Cr,v” > 8 and X I C , + , v N> 140), there is significant hyperfine mixing of singlet and N
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1K) MOLECULES
213
triplet character (Weickenmeier et al., 1985). In addition, the single-photon resonances in the two-photon-ionization spectrum near 716 nm are not assigned, so there may be singlet ungerade states in this region as well. Moreover, the lack of assignments means the internal levels populated in the a3C; and X'C; states are not yet known. Photoassociation signals characteristically tend to weaken with decreasing R due to repulsion of low-angular-momentum collisions by the centrifugal barrier [h2J(J 1) - f12)/(8112 pR2)] (R 150ao for cesium). In studies of cooperative effects of photoassociation and trapping lasers, Fioretti et al. (1999a) found that excitations at large R (- 1500ao) by the trapping laser to an attractive excited state lead to an enhancement (Sanchez-Villicanaet al., 1996) in small-R (< 30 ao) collisions of higher angular momentum (J 6). Small-R collision enhancements were monitored with a photoassociation laser tuned to the pure long-range 0; (v' = 4) state. In studies of trap loss versus ion (Csl) signals, Comparat et al. (1999) found that traploss signals were sensitive to excited l,, O;, and 0s states, but not to the 1, state. However, ion signals were found to be sensitive only to excited 0; and 1, states. This established a definitive link between ion signals and translationally ultracold molecule formation in the lowest triplet and in the singlet ground state. Similar observations of Cs2 molecules, but with much less spectroscopic detail, have been reported by Takekoshi et al. (1998, 1999). Recent observations of cold singlet ground state K2 molecules by Nikolov et al. (1999) used the original MOT photoassociation scheme of Wang et al. (1997), shown in Fig. 11. Here, spontaneous decays following photoassociation to the v' = 191 long-range level of the A 'C,+(O,+) state populated high vibrational levels (e.g., v" = 36) of the ground X'C; state. To detect cold K2, near-resonant two-color photoionization was used. The first step (resonant excitation) was from the X to the B state at 712nm; the second step was ionization of B-state molecules by a doubled YAG pulse, as shown in Fig. 16. Time-of-flight mass spectroscopy was used to discriminate between Ki and K + background signals detected with a channeltron. Again, gating of MOT and photoionization lasers eliminated dimer ion signals due to photoionization out of excited states directly populated by MOT lasers. The rotationally resolved photoassociation spectrum shown in Fig. 17 established that molecule production (as expected) was through the Of state rather than nearby 0; or 1, states. The estimated molecule production rate was < 2000 s-' , consistent with known photoassociation rates for this MOT (< lo7 s-') and with fractional Franck-Condon factors for bound-bound A-X decays (-0.15%). Measurements of cold molecules leaving the detection region gave an estimated molecular speed of -30cm/s (-300pK). Very recently, high production rates to low and intermediate vibrational levels of
+
-
-
J. 1: Bahns, P. L. Gould, and U! C. Stwalley
214
A
532 nm (ionizes) 20
B 'n,
\
15
el2
2700 nm
10
X'cs'
5 0 -
K ( 4 9 + K(4P)
0
30
20
10
R
40
6,
FIG. 16. Diagram of the resonance-enhancedtwo-photon two-color ionization scheme used to state-selectively detect translationally ultracold 39K2X Cp' (v" = 36) molecules.
'
the ground electronic state of K2 have realized (Nikolov et al., submitted) using the two-color method discussed in Section 1V.A.1. One potential means for conversion of w" = 36 state molecules to w" = 0 is the STIRAP process (Gaubatz et al., 1990; Bergmann et al., 1998), illustrated in Fig. 18. Using a counterintuitive sequence of pulses, w'' = 36 molecules could be coherently converted with 100% efficiency to w" = 0 molecules by adiabatic passage through the intermediate A'C: state (e.g., w' = 18). Deeply bound (w'' = 0, J" = 0) ultracold Kz molecules produced this way, although small in number, would offer a multitude of possibilities for high-resolution spectroscopy and collisional studies (Weiner et al., 1999). Ultracold molecular ions can be formed directly from colliding ultracold atoms via two-color photoassociation as illustrated in Fig. 19 for sodium. The scheme, similar to the neutral molecule scheme proposed by Band and Julienne (1995, Fig. 12), utilizes photoassociation to a long-lived 1, (l'rIg) level with the first photon. The second photon is tuned to excite Rydberg state levels from the inner turning wall of the 1'IIgstate. Rydberg state levels, lying slightly above Na; (w+ = 0, N+ = 0), autoionize to produce translationally, N
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K)MOLECULES
215
Trap loss spectrum
ion spectrum I
12970.71
I
I
I
I
I
I
12971.21
I
I
12971.71
Laser frequency (cm-' )
FIG.17. Comparison of the trap loss photoassociation spectrum of ultracold 39K atoms (top) and the 39K: molecularion signal [from ionization of X ' C l (w" = 36) 39K2 as in Fig. 161 as a function of photoassociation laser frequency (LpA in Fig. 11).
rotationally, and vibrationally ultracold molecular ions. Ultracold ions can be trapped in a hybrid MOT-Paul trap, presently under development by W. Smith and coworkers at the University of Connecticut. B. PROFWSED STIMULATED PROCESSES The major limitation of photoassociative methods employing spontaneous decay is the lack of state selectivity. Single or multiply resonant photoassociation can convert free atom pairs into single rovibrational electronically excited-state molecules. Unfortunately,these excited states invariably decay to a myriad of lower bound and continuum states. Furthermore, single-photon photoassociation followed by spontaneous emission populates mainly highly excited bound states in accordance with Franck-Condon overlap. In response to these shortcomings, several approaches have been proposed, all relying on some form of coherent photonprocesses interacting with an initially trapped atomic gas or Bose-Einstein condensate (BEC). Vardi et al. (1997) have developed a theory for stimulated Raman radiative recombination from initial continuum states that is a variant of the STIRAP process (Bergmann et al., 1998). In the STIRAP process, bound state populations can be transferred from one level of a three-level system, through
216
J. T. Bahns, P. L . Gould, and W C. Stwalley
f
A
’c;
v=l8
STIRAP X’X;
G 0
K(4s) + K(4s)
s 10
20
30
40
R
FIG. 18. The combination of our demonstrated method of forming X’C; (71” = 36) translationally ultracold 39Kz molecules (Nikolov er al., 1999) with the well-documented stimulated Raman adiabatic passage (STIRAP) technique (see Bergmann et al., 1998 and references therein) could produce small numbers of translationally ultracold X’C: (d’ = 0) 3 9 ~ molecules. 2
an intermediate state, to a third bound level with 100% efficiency using a counterintuitive sequence of optical pulses. Spontaneous decays from the intermediate state can be completely eliminated (the intermediate state becomes a “dark” state). Using two strong ( 105-108W/cm2) counterintuitive 100 Hz optical pulses ( ~ 2 0 n s )applied to ultracold sodium vapor, Vardi et al. (1997) predicted conversion fractions of -6 x 10-6/pulse leading to 50% of the sample being converted in a time on the order of minutes. Such a conversion would be completely state-selective. Javanainen and Mackie (1998, 1999) have proposed a phenomenological Hamiltonian for the analysis of photoassociation in a BEC. Their analysis focuses on two examples of coherent photoassociation: nonresonant oscillations of atomic and molecular populations in condensates and conversions of condensate populations from atomic to molecular, driven by an adiabatic frequency-sweptlaser. Computed temporal molecular fractions for both cases predict fractional conversions approaching 100% on short (Rabi-like) time scales.
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES I
I
Naz
I
I
I
-
K L A
30-
v
I
Na(3s) + Na(3d)
-
Na(3s) + Na(4s)
L2
‘E
I
X*,i
-
h
I
nl1z;+
40-
-
I
217
3 1,’s
-
Na(3s) + Na(3p)-
mo201 LLI F X
-
A’,
&
LPA
--
-
10-
Na(3s) + Na(3s)
FIG. 19. A photoassociative ionization scheme for production of state-selected (e.g., N+ = 0) translationally ultracold N a i ions from ultracold Na atoms. This is the photoassociative analog of the molecular scheme shown in Fig. 10.
v+
= 0,
Julienne er al. (1998) have performed coupled-channels calculations for a quasi-cw variant of the Raman photoassociative process of Vardi et al. (1997) (see also Mackie and Javanainen, submitted). The model for this process, depicted in Fig. 20, begins with two colliding atoms of energy E on the ground state potential V, (R). Next, atoms are photo-associated with optical coupling matrix element (01) to an excited intermediate state level (q) on potential V1 with laser frequency o I . Level 2rl can decay either by spontaneous decay (yl) or by stimulated emission ( 0 2 , 0 2 ) to a specific arbitrary level of the ground state (212). Once in level w2, molecules are no longer bound by the atomic trap. Cold molecules are coherently “emitted” from the condensate on the artificial molecular channel Vm0,(R),due to atomic center-of-mass motion (minus the
218
J. T. Bahns, P. L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
Ql
4 LOSS
-E
G r o u n d State VdR)
8 2
/
Artificial Molecular C h a d
Vm, (R)
FIG. 20. Diagram of the scheme of Julienne er al. (1998) for production of state-selected diatomic molecules from an atomic BEC.
difference in photon momenta). Calculations of molecule production rates for 1 ps pulses as a function of collisional energy (Elk < 400nK) and detuning predicted large photoassociation rate coefficients of k,, > lo-’’ cm3s-l, capable of exceeding spontaneous losses by 1 to 2 orders of magnitude with large fractional transfers to molecules on a time scale short compared to the oscillation period of the atomic trap, particularly for low (- 1 nK) temperature collisions. If such coherent transfer processes are realized, there are exciting prospects for the future. Notably, coherent photoassociation could form the basis for the “molecule laser” proposed by Julienne et al. (1998) (see also Javanainen and Mackie, 1998, 1999),analogous to the recently demonstrated “atom laser” of Mewes et al. (1997). This would offer an additional armada of possibilities for high-resolution scattering, spectroscopy, and other studies using coherent matter waves. Very recently, Wynar et al. (submitted) have observed a stimulated Raman resonance between colliding pairs of 87Rb atoms and a molecular state of N
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
219
”Rb2 near dissociation (bound by -0.02 cm-I) in a Bose-Einsteincondensed condensate). A sharp resonance (< 1 MHz in width) is observed cloud ( ~ 2 0 % via the = 1, J = 0 level of the 0; pure long-range electronic state below the Rb (52S1/2)+ Rb (5’P3p) asymptote. The DUMP (bound-bound) laser frequency is generated from the PUMP (free-bound) laser using an acoustooptic modulator. Although the translationally ultracold molecules produced have not yet been directly detected, these experiments represent the first demonstration of the stimulated Raman photoassociation of ultracold atoms discussed above.
V. Conclusions and Future Directions The formation of molecules with subKelvin translational temperatures is now possible by a variety of nonoptical and optical techniques, both in cold (1 mK-1 K) and in ultracold (< 1 mK) regimes. It is likely that translationally ultracold molecules will soon be detected at submicroKelvin temperatures, for example, from formation in atom BECs. Greatly improved production rates are also expected. Prospects are also good for producing these translationally cold molecules state-selectively by a variety of schemes such as optical pumping, stimulated Raman photoassociation, and multiphoton ionization. Evaporative cooling of molecules could become an important method for producing ultracold molecules. Application of such techniques to forms of high-resolution spectroscopy in addition to photoassociative spectroscopy are expected. The trapping of such molecules has been achieved, and other cold molecule manipulations (“molecule optics”) will undoubtedly be demonstrated soon. Cold collisions and their applications in turn to low-temperature gas metastability (and its destruction by nucleation), to molecular BEC (and “molecule lasers”), and to degenerate molecular Fermi gases will surely be topics of high interest and excitement as well.
VI. Acknowledgments The authors particularly acknowledge their experimental and theoretical collaborators on formation of ultracold molecules: Yehuda Band, Keith Burnett, Ed Eyler, Paul Julienne, Jing Li, Anguel Nikolov, Marin Pichler, He Wang, Xiaotian Wang, Carl Williams, and Guoxing Zhao. The authors also acknowledge helpful discussions with a great many individuals, including Claude Amiot, Mike Andrews, Vanderlei Bagnato, Klaas Bergmann, Robin CBtC, Alex Dalgarno, John Doyle, Oliver Dulieu, Wolfgang Ernst, Bretislav
220
J. Z Bahns, P. L. Gould, and W C. Stwalley
Friedrich, Bob Gordon, Chris Greene, Dan Heinzen, Randy Hulet, Juha Javanainen, Gwang-Hi Jeung, Paul Lett, Li Li, Marjatta Lyyra, Matt Mackie, Mircea Marinescu, Francoise Masnou-Seeuws, Fred Mies, Jan Northby, Bill Phillips, Goran Pichler, Pierre Pillet, Amanda Ross, Giacinto Scoles, T m a r Seideman, Moshe Shapiro, Win Smith, Peter Toennies, Boudywyn Verhaar, John Weiner, Tsutomu Yabuzaki, Alexandra Yiannopoulou,and Warren Zemke. This work was supported in part by NSF CHE96-12207 and CHE 97-32467.
VII. References Adams, C. S., Sigel, M., and Mlynek, J. (1994). Phys. Rep. 240, 143. Adams, C. S., and Riis, E. (1997). Prog. Quant. Electc 21, 1. Anderson, J. B., Andres. R. P., and Fenn, J. B. (1966). Advan. Chem. Phys. 10, 275. Anderson, M. H., Ensher, J. R., Matthews, M. R., Wieman, C. E., and Cornell, E. A. (1995). Science 269, 198. Amdt, M., Ben Dahan, M., Guery-Odelin, D., Reynolds, M. W., and Dalibard, J. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 625. Bahns, J. T., Stwalley, W. C., and Gould, P. L. (1996). J. Chem. Phys. 104, 9689. Balakrishnan, N., Kharachenko, V., Forrey, R. C., and Dalgarno, A. (1997). Chem. Phys. Lett. 280, 5 . Balakrishnan, N., Forrey, R. C., and Dalgarno, A. (1997A). Chem. Phys. Let?. 280, 1. Balakrishnan, N., Kharachenko, V., Forrey, R. C., and Dalgarno, A. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 3224. Band, Y. B., and Julienne, P. S. (1995). Phys. Rev. A 51, R4317. Barranco, M., Navarro, J., and Poves, A. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78,4729. Bartana, A., Kosloff, R., and Tannor, D. J. (1993). J. Chem. Phys. 99, 196. Bass, A. M., and Broida, H. P. (Eds.). (1960). Formation and rrapping offree radicals. Academic Press (New York). Becker, E. D., and Pimentel, G. C. (1956). J. Chem. Phys. 25,224. Becker, E. W., and Henkes, W. (1956). Z. Physik 146, 320. Berman, P. R., and Stenholm, S. (1978). Opt. Commun. 24, 155. Bergmann, K., Theuer, H., and Shore, B. W. (1998). Rev. Mod. Phys. 70, 1003. Boesten, H. M. J. M., Tsai, C. C., Verhaar, B. J., and Heinzen, D. J. (1 996). P hys. Rev. Lett. 77,5 194. Bohn, J. L., Burke, J. P., Greene, C. H., Wang, H., Gould, P. L., and Stwalley, W. C. (1999). Phys. Rev. A 59,3660. Bradley, C. C., Sackett, C. A., and Hulet, R. G. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 985. Broyer, M., Chevaleyre, J., Delacretaz, G., Martin, S., and Woste, L. (1983). Chem. Phys. Lett. 99,206. Buchenau, H., Knoth, E. L., Northby, J., Toennies, J. P., and Winkler, C. (1990). J. Chem. Phys. 92, 6876. Burt, E. A., Ghrist, R. W., Myatt, C. J., Holland, M. J., Cornell, E. A., and Wieman, C. E. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 337. Callegari, C., Higgins, J., Stienkemeier, F., and Scoles, G. (1998). J. Phys. Chem. 102, 95. Chang, E. S., Li, J., Zhang, J., Tsai, C. C., Bahns, J., and Stwalley, W. C. Submitted to J. Chem. Phys. Chapman, M. S . , Ekstrom, C. R., Hammond, T. D., Rubenstein, R. A., Schmiedmayer, J., Wehinger, S . , and Pritchard, D. E. (1995). Phys. Rev. Left. 74,4783.
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
22 1
Chu, S., Bjorkholm, J., Ashkin, A., and Cable, A. (1986). Phys. Rev. Len. 57, 314. Chu, S. (1998). Rev. Mod. Phys. 70,685. Cline, R. A., Miller, J. D., Matthews, M. R., and Heinzen, D. J. (1994). Opt. Lett. 19, 207. Cohen-Tannoudji, C. N. (1998). Rev. Mod. Phys. 70,707. Comparat, D., Drag, C., Fioretti, A., Dulieu, 0.. and Pillet, P. (1999).J. Mol. Spectrosc. 119,229. CGtt, R., Dalgamo, A., and Jamieson, M. J. (1994). Phys. Rev. A 50, 399. C W , R., and Dalgamo, A. (1997). Chem. Phys. Lett. 279,50. C8t6, R., and Dalgarno, A. (I 999). J. Mol. Spectmsc. 195, 236. Courteille, P., Freeland, R. S., Heinzen, D. J., van Abeelen, F. A., and Verhaar, B. J. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 69. Davidson, N., Lee, H. J., Adam, C. S., Kasevich, M., and Chu, S. (1995).Phys. Rev. Len.74,13 1 1. Davis, K. B., Mewes, M. O., Andrews, M. R., van Druten, N. J., Durfee, D. S., Kum, D. M., and Ketterle, W. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 3969. Djeu, N. (1978). Opt. Commun. 26, 354. Djeu, N., and Whitney, W. T. (1981). Phys. Rev. Len. 46, 236. Dowling, J. P., and Gea-Banaloche, J. (1996). Advan. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 37, 2. Doyle, J. M., Friedrich, B., Kim, J., and Patterson, D. (1995). Phys. Rev. A 52, R2515. Edwards, B. C., Buchwald, M. I., and Epstein, R. I. (1998). Rev. Sci. Insrun. 69, 2050. Ertmer, W., Blatt, R., Hall, J., and Zhu, M. (1985). Phys. Rev. Len. 54, 996. Fedichev, P. O., Reynolds, M. W., and Shlyapnikov, G. V. (1996). Phys. Rev. Len. 77,2921. Ferrante, R. F., and Stwalley, W. C. (1983). J. Chem. Phys. 78,3107. Ferrante, R. F., and Stwalley, W. C. (1986). J. Chem. Phys. 85, 1201. Fioretti, A., Comparat, D., Crubellier, A.. Dulieu, O., Masnou-Seeuws, F., and Pillet, P. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 4402. Fioretti, A., Comparat, D., Drag, C., Amiot, C., Dulieu, 0.. Masnou-Seeuws, F., and Pillet, P. (1999). Euro. Phys. J. D.5, 389. Fioretti, A., Comparat, D., Drag, C., Gallagher, T. F., and Pillet, P. (1999a). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 1839. Forrey, R. C., Balakrishnan, N., Kharchenko, V.,and Dalgarno, A. (1998).Phys. Rev. A 58, R2645. Forrey, R. C., Kharchenko, V., Balakrishnan, N., and Dalgarno, A. (1999). Phys. Rev. A 59,2146. Fried, D. G., Killian, T. C., Willmann, L., Landhuis, D., Moss, S. C.,Kleppner, D., and Greytak, T. J. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 3811. Friedrich, B., and Herschbach, D. (1995). Phys. Rev. Len. 74,4623. Friedrich, B., and Herschbach, D. (1995a).J. Chin. Chem SOC.42, 111. Friedrich, B., decarvalho, R., Kim, J., Patterson, D., Weinstein, J. A., and Doyle, J. M. (1998).J. Chem. SOC.,Faraday Trans. 94, 1783. Friedrich, B., Weinstein, J. D., DeCarvalho, R., and Doyle, J. M. (1999).J. Chem Phys. 110.2376. Froechtenicht, R., Kaloudis, M., Koch, M., and Huisken, F. (1996). J. Chem. Phys. 105,6128. Garraway, B. M., and Suominen, K.-A. (1998). Phys. Rev. Len. 80,932. Gaubatz, U., Rudecki, P., Schiemann, S., and Bergmann, K. (1990). J. Chem. Phys. 92, 5363. Goyal, S., Schutt, D. L., and Scoles, G. (1992). Phys. Rev. Len. 69, 933. Hansch, T. W., and Schawlow, A. L. (1975). Opt. Commun. 13,68. Hartmann, M., Mielke, F., Toennies, J. P., and Vilesov, A. F. (1996a). Phys. Rev. Len.76,4560. Hartmann, M., Miller, R. E., Toennies, J. P., and Vilesov, A. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 75, 1566. Hartmann, M., Miller, R. E., Toennies, J. P., and Vilesov, A. (1996). Science 272, 163 I. Hemnann, A., Leutwyler, S., Woste, L., and Schumacher, E. (1979). Chen Phys. Leu. 62,444. Higgins, J., Callegari, C., Reho, J., Stienkemeier, F., Emst, W.E., Lehmann, K. K., Gutowski, M., and Scoles, G. (1996). Science 273,629. Higgins, J., Emst, W. E., Callegari, C., Reho, J., Lehmann, K. K., Scoles, G., and Gutowski, M. (1999A). Phys. Rev. Lett. 71,4532.
222
. I 7:. Bahns, l? L. Could, and W C. Stwalley
Higgins, J., Callegari, C., Reho. J., Stienkemeier, F., Emst, W. E., Gutowski, M., and Scoles, G. (1998). J. Phys. Chem. A 102,4952. Hill, R. M., and Gallagher, T. F. (1975). Phys. Rev. A 12, 45 1. Houbiers, M., Ferweda, R., Stoof, H. T. C., McAlexander, W. I., Sackett, C. A., and Hulet, R. G. (1997). Phys. Rev. A 56,4864. Inouye, S., Andrews, M. R., Stenger, J., Miesner, H. J., Stamper-Kum, D. M., and Ketterle, W. (1998). Nature 392, 151. Jacox, M. E. (1988). J. Phys. Chem. Ref: Data 17, 269. Jacox, M. E. (1990). J. Phys. Chem. Re$ Data 19, 1387. Jacox, M. E. (1994). J. Phys. Chem. Ref: Data Monograph 3. Jacox, M. E. (1998). J. Phys. Chem. Re$ Data 27, 115. Javanainen, J., and Mackie, M. (1998). Phys. Rev. A 58, R789. Javanainen, J., and Mackie, M. (1999). Phys. Rev. A 59, R3186. Jiang, T., Kim, C., and Northby, J. A. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 700. Julienne, P. S., Bumett, K., Band, Y.B., and Stwalley, W. C. (1998). Phys. Rev. A 58, R797. Kantrowitz, A., and Grey, J. (1951). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 22, 328. Karczmarex, J., Wright, J., Corkum, P., and Ivanov, M. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 3420. Kastler, A. (1950). J. de Phys. et Radium 1 I , 255. (In French). Ketterle, W., and Miesner, H. J. (1997). Phys. Rev. A 56, 3291. Ketterle, W., and Van Druten, N. J. (1996). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 37, 181. Kistiakowsky, G. B., and Slichter, W. P. (1951). Rev. Sci. Instrum. 22, 333. Kim, J., Friedrich, B., Katz, D. P.,Patterson, D., Weinstein, J. D., decarvalho, R., and Doyle, J. D. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 3665. Kokkelmans, S. J. J. M. F., Verhaar, B. J., and Gibble, K. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 951. Kuga, T.,Torii, Y.,Shiokawa, N., Hirano, T., Shimizu, Y.,and Sasada, H. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78,4713. Kushida, T., and Guecic, J. E. (1968). Phys. Rev. IRtt. 21, 1172. Lee, D. M. (1997). Rev. Mod. Phys. 69,645. Legere, R., and Gibble, K. (1998). Phys. Rev. Len. 81, 5780. Leo, P. J., Tiesinga, E., Julienne, P. S., Walter, D. K., Kadlecek, S., and Walker, T. G. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 1389. Le Roy, R. J., and Bemstein, R. B. (1970). J. Chem. Phys. 52, 3869. Le Roy, R. J., and Bemstein, R. B. (1971). J. Chem. Phys. 54,5114. Le Roy, R. J. (1973). In R. F. Barrow et al. (Eds.) Molecular spectroscopy 1 . Chem. SOC. London, p. 113. Letokhov, V. S., Minogin, V. G., and Pavlik, B. D. (1976). Opt. Commun. 19, 72. Lett, P. D., Julienne, P. S., and Phillips, W. D. (1995). Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 46,423. Leutwyler, S., Hofmann, M., Harri, H.-P., and Schumacher, E. (1981). Chem. Phys. Lett. 77, 257. Lewis, G. N., and Kasha, M. (1944). J. Am. Chem. SOC. 66,2100. Li, J., Bahns, J. T., and Stwalley, W. C. To be submitted to J. Chem Phys. Luo, F., Giese, C. F., and Gentry, W. R. (1996). J. Chem. Phys. 104, 1151. Mackie, M., and Javanainen, J. Submitted to Phys. Rev. A. McClelland, J. J., Scholten, R. E., Palm, E. C., and Celotta, R. J. (1993). Science 262, 877. McClure, D. S. (1954). J. Chem. Phys. 22, 1668. Metcalf, H., and van der Straten, P. (1994). Phys. Rep. 244, 203. Mewes, M. O., Andrews, M. R., Kum, D. M., Durfee, D. S., Townsend, C. G., and Ketterle, W. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 582. Miesner, H. J., Stamper-Kum, D. M., Stenger, J., Inouye, S., Chikkatur. A. P.,and Ketterle, W. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 2228.
FORMATION OF COLD (T 5 1 K) MOLECULES
223
Miller, J. D., Cline, R. A., and Heinzen, D. J. (1993). Phys. Rev. A 47, R4567. Moerdijk, A. J., Stwalley, W. C., Hulet, R. G., and Verhaar, B. I. (1994). Phys. Rev. Lett. 72.40. Moerdijk, A. J., Boesten, H. M. J. M., and Verhaar, B. J. (1996). Phys. Rev. A 53, 916. Mungan, C. E., Buchwald, M. I., Edwards, B. C., Epstein, R. I., and Gosnell, T. R. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78, 1030. Mungan, C. E., Buchwald, M. I., Edwards, B. C., Epstein, R. I., and Gosnell, T. R. (1997A). Appl. Phys. Lett. 71, 1458. Nikolov, A. N., Ensher, J. R.. Eyler, E. E.. Wang, H., Stwalley, W. C., and Gould, P. L. Submitted. Nikolov, A. N., Eyler, E. E., Wang, X., Wang, H., Li, J., Stwalley, W. C., and Gould, P. L. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 703. Northby, J. A., Yurgeson, S., and Kim, C. (1995). J. Low Temp. Phys. 101, 427. Phillips, W. D. (1998). Rev. Mod. Phys. 70,721. Prodan J. V., and Phillips, W. D. (1984). Prog. Quant. Electron. 8, 231. Ramsey, N. F. (1985). Molecular beams. Oxford University Press (New York). Reho, J., Callegari, C., Higgins, J., Emst, W. E., Lehmann, K. K., and Scoles, G. (1997). Faraday Discuss. 108, 161. Roberts, R. E., Bemstein, R. B., and Curtiss, C. F. (1969). J. Chem.Phys. 50, 5163. Roberts, J. L., Claussen, N. R., Burke, J. P., Greene, C. E., Cornell, E. A., and Wieman, C. E. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5109. Robinson, G. W., McCarty, Jr., M., and Keetly, M. C. (1957). J. Chem. Phys. 27, 972. Sakai, H., Tarasevitch, A., Danilov, J., Stapelfeldt, H., Yip, R. W., Ellert, C., Constant, E., and Corkum, P. B. (1998). Phys. Rev. A 57, 2794. Sanchez-Villicana, V., Gensemer, S. D., and Gould, P. L. (1996). Phys. Rev. A 54, R3730. Schollkopf, W., and Toennies, J. P. (1994). Science 266, 1345. Schollkopf, W., and Toennies, J. P. (1996). J. Chem. Phys. 104, 1155. Schutte, A., Bassi, D., Tommasini, and Scoles, G. (1972). Phys. Rev. Lett. 29,979. Scoles, G. (Ed.). (1988). Atomic and molecular beam methods. Oxford University Press (New York). Seideman, T. (1996). J. Chem. Phys. 106,2881. Silvera, I. F., and Walraven, J. T. M. (1980). Phys. Rev. Lett. 44, 164. Sinha, M. P., Schultz, A., and Zare, R. N. (1973). J. Chem. Phys. 58, 549. Smalley,R. E., Ramakrishna, B. L., Levy, D. H., and Wharton, L. (1974). J. Chem.Phys. 61,4363. Stamper-Kum, D. M., Andrews, M. R., Chikkatur, A,, Inouye, S., Miesner, H.-J., Stenger, J., and Ketterle, W. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 2072. Stapelfeldt, H., Sakai, H., Constant, E., and Corkum, P. B. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79,2787. Stenger, J., Inouye, S., Stamper-Kurn, D. M., Miesner, H. J., Chikkatur, A. P., and Ketterle, W. (1998). Nature 396, 345. Stenger, J., Inouye, S., Andrews, M. R., Miesner, H. J., Stamper-Kum, D. M., and Ketterle, W. (1999). Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 2422. Stienkemeier, F., Higgins, J., Emst, W. E., and Scoles, G. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 3592. Stienkemeier, F., Emst, W. E., Higgins, J., and Scoles, G. (1995A). J. Chem Phys. 102,615. Stienkemeier, F., Higgins, J., Emst, W. E., and Scoles, G. (1995B). Z Phys. B. 98, 413. Stienkemeier, F., Higgins, J., Callegari, C., Kanorsky, S. I., Emst, W. E., and Scoles, G. (1996). Z. Phys. D. 38, 253. Stienkemeier, F. , Meier, F.,and Lutz, H. 0. (1997). J. Chem. Phys. 107, 10816. Stoof, H. T. C., Houbiers, M., Sackett, C. A., and Hulet, R. G. (1996). Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 10. Stwalley, W. C. (1970). Chem. Phys. Lett. 6, 241. Stwalley, W. C., and Nosanow, L. H. (1976). Phys. Rev. Lert. 36, 910. Stwalley, W. C. (1976). Phys. Rev. Lett. 37, 1628.
224
J. I: Bahns, P. L. Gould, and U? C. Stwalley
Stwalley, W. C., Uang, Y.-H., and Pichler, G . (1978). Phys. Rev. hit.41, 1164. Stwalley, W. C. (1978). Contemp. Phys. 19.65. Stwalley, W. C. (1984). Progl: Quanr. Electl: 8, 203. Stwalley, W. C., Uang, Y. HT, Ferrante, R. F., and Webeler, R. W. H. (1980). J. de Physique 41, C7-27. Stwalley, W. C., and Bahns, J. T. (1993). Laser and Particle Beams 11, 185. Stwalley, W. C., and Wang, H. (1999). J. Mol. Spectrosc. 195, 194. Stwalley, W. C. To be submitted to Phys. Rev. Lert. Takahasi, Y., Sano, K., Kinoshita, T., and Yabuzaki, T. (1993). Phys. Rev. Lett. 71, 1035. Takekoshi, T., Yeh, J. R., and Knize, R. J. (1995). Opr. Commun. 114, 421. Takekoshi, T., and Knize, R. J. (1996). Opt. Left. 21,77. Takekoshi, T., Patterson, B. M., and Knize, R. J. (1999). P hys. Rev. A 5 1, R5. Takekoshi, T., Patterson, B. M., and Knize, R. J. (1998). Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 5105. Tang, K.T., Toennies, J. P., and Yiu, C. L. (1995). Phys. Rev. Lett. 74, 1546. Tamovsky, V., Bunimovicz, M., Vuskovic, L., Stumpf B., and Bederson, B. (1993). J. Chem. Phys. 98,3894. Thorsheim, H. R., Weiner, J., and Julienne, P. S. (1987). Phys. Rev. Lett. 58, 2420. Tiesinga, E., Verhaar, B. J., and Stoof, H. T. C. (1993). Phys. Rev. A 47, 41 14. Toennies, J. P., and Vilesov, A. (1998). Ann. Rev. Phys. Chem. 49, 1. Toennies, J. P., and Winkelmann, K. (1977). J. Chem. Phys. 66, 3965. Tsai,C. C., Bahns, J. T., and Stwalley, W. C. (1995). Chem. Phys. Lea. 236,553. Tsai, C. C., Freeland, R. S., Vogels, J. M., Boesten, H. M. J. M., Verhaar, B. J., and Heinzen, D. J. (1997). Phys. Rev. Lett. 79, 1245. Uang, Y.-H., and Stwalley, W. C. (1980). Phys. Rev. Lett. 45, 627. Uang, Y.-H., and Stwalley, W. C. (1980A). J. de Physique 41, C7-33. Uang, Y.-H., Ferrante, R. F., and Stwalley, W. C. (1981). J. Chem. Phys. 74, 6267. Uang, Y.-H., and Stwalley, W. C. (1982). J. Chem. Phys. 76, 5069. Vardi, A,, Abrashkevich, D., Frishman, E., and Shapiro, M. (1997). J. Chem. Phys. 107,6166. Vasilenko, L. S., Rubtsova, N. N., and Khvorostov, E. B. (1995). J E W Lett. 62, 404. Walker, T., and Feng, P. (1994). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 34, 125. Wang, H., Could, P. L., and Stwalley, W. C. (1996). Phys. Rev. A 53, R1216. Wang, H., Gould, P. L., and Stwalley, W. C. (1996A). 2. Phys. D 36, 317. Wang, H., Gould, P. L., and Stwalley, W. C. (1997). J. Chem. Phys. 106,7899. Wang, H., Wang, X. T., Could, P. L., and Stwalley, W. C. (1997A). Phys. Rev. Lett. 78,4173. Wang, X . T.,Wang, H., Gould, P. L., and Stwalley, W. C. (1998). Phys. Rev. A 57,4600. Weickenmeier, H., Diemer, U., Wahl, M., Raab, M., and Demtroder, W. (1985). J. Chem. Phys. 82, 5354. Weiner, J. (1995). Adv. At. Mol. Opt. Phys. 35,45. Weiner, J., Bagnato, V. S., Zilio, S. C., and Julienne, P. S. (1999). Rev. Mod. Phys. 71, 1. Weinstein,J. D.,deCarvalho, R., Guillet,T., Friedrich, B., andDoyle, J. M. (1998). Narure 395,148. Weinstein, J. D., deCarvalho, R., Amar, K., Boca, A., Odom, B. C., Friedrich, B., and Doyle, J. M.(1998A). J. Chem. Phys. 109,2656. Weinstein, J. D., decarvalho, R., Kim, J., Patterson, D., Friedrich, B., and Doyle, J. M. (1998B). Phys. Rev. A. 57, R3173. Whaley, K. B. (1998). Adv. in Molec. Vibrations and Collision Dynamics 3, 397. Wineland, D., and Dehmelt, H. (1975). Bull. Am. Phys. SOC.20,637. Wu, C. Y. R., Crooks, J. B., Yang, S. C., Way, K. R., and Stwalley, W. C. (1978). Rev. Sci. Insrrum. 49, 380. Wynar, R. H., Freeland, R. S., Han, D. J., and Heinzen, D. J. To be submitted.
ADVANCES JN ATOMIC, MOLECULAR. AND OPTICAL PHYSICS. VOL. 42
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS C. J. JOACHAIN Physique The'orique, Universite' Libre de Bruxelles, CP 227, Boulevard du Triomphe, B-I 050 Bruxelles, Belgium Dipartement de Physique, Universite' de Louvain, 8-1348 Louvain-la-Neuve, Belgium Email: [email protected].
M. DORR Physique Thiorique. Universite' Libre de Bruxelles, CP 227, Boulevard du Triomphe, B-1050 Bruxelles, Belgium Max-Born-Institut, D-I 2489, Berlin, Germany Email: [email protected].
N . KYLSTRA Physique Thiorique, Universite' Libre de Bruxelles, CP 227, Boulevard du Triomphe, B- I050 Bncxelles, Belgium Optics Section, Blackett hboratory, Imperial College, London SW7 2BZ United Kingdom Email: [email protected] I. Introduction. . .
..............................
. . . .
toms and Ions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Multiphoton Ionization and Above-Threshold Ionization. . . . . . . . B. Harmonic Generation. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Laser-Assisted Electron-Atom Collisions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Theoretical Methods. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Basic Equations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Perturbation Theory and Its Breakdown . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Semiperturbative Methods .......................... 1 . Essential States. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . , . . , . , . . . . . . 2. Laser-Assisted Electron-Atom Collisions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Floquet Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1. Basic Equations. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. The Sturmian-Floquet Method. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3. High-Frequency Floquet Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4. Floquet Theory for Laser-Assisted Electron-Atom Collisions . . E. R-Matrix-Floquet Theory . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Low-Frequency Methods . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. Numerical Solution of the Time-Dependent Schrodinger Equation. 1 . Single Active Electron . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2. Several Electrons. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . H. Relativistic Effects. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
225
.
226 227 221 232 236 237 239 24 1 243 243 244 241 241 249 25 1 255 256 265 266 268 212 214
Copyright 0Zoo0 by Academic F'ress All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. ISBN 0-12-W3842-0/1SSN1049-25OX100$30.00
226
C. J. Joachain, M. Dorr; and N. Kylstra
IV.Conclusions and Future Developments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
V. Acknowledgments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
278 279 279
Abstract: The development of lasers capable of delivering short pulses of very intense radiation, over a wide frequency range, has led to the discovery of new, nonperturbative multiphoton processes in laser interactions with atomic systems. In this article, we first give a survey of the main properties of multiphoton processes such as the multiphoton ionization of atoms, the emission by atoms of high-order harmonics of the exciting laser light, and laser-assisted electron-atom collisions. We then review the theory of these processes, giving particular attention to ab-initio nonperturbative methods such as the Sturmian-Floquet approach, the R-matrix-Floquet theory, and the numerical integration of the time-dependent Schr6dinger equation. We also discuss relativistic effects that occur at ultra-high intensities. We conclude by consideringpossible future developments of high-intensity laser-atom physics.
I. Introduction In recent years, intense laser fields have become available over a frequency range extending from the infrared to the ultraviolet, in the form of short pulses yielding intensities of the order of or exceeding the value I, = 3.5 x 10l6W cm-2, corresponding to the atomic unit of electric field strength &, = 5.1 x 109Vcm-’. Such laser fields have been obtained using the “Chirped Pulse Amplification” (CPA) scheme, in which laser pulses are stretched, amplified, and then compressed (Strickland and Mourou, 1985). They are strong enough to compete with the Coulomb forces in controlling the electron dynamics in atomic systems. As a result, atoms and molecules in intense laser fields exhibit new properties that have been discovered via the study of multiphoton processes. These modified properties generate new behavior of bulk matter in intense laser fields, with wide-ranging potential applications such as the study of ultra-fast phenomena, the development of powerful high-frequency ( X W and X-ray) lasers, the investigation of the properties of plasmas and condensed matter under extreme conditions of temperature and pressure, and intense field control of atomic and molecular reactions. Over the last ten years, laser intensities have increased by more than four orders of magnitude (Mourou et al., 1998), up to lo2’ W cmP2, where relativistic effects in laser-atom interactions become important. In this article we shall review the field of high-intensity laser interactions with atoms and ions. Section I1 is devoted to a survey of the new phenomena discovered by studying atomic multiphoton processes in strong laser fields. The theory of these processes is discussed in Section III, where the main nonperturbativemethods currently used are examined. Possible future developments of this rapidly growing area of physics are considered in Section IV.
HIGH-INTENSITYLASER-ATOM PHYSICS
227
We refer the reader to the book edited by Gavrila (1992a) and the articles by Burnett et al. (1993), Joachain (1994), DiMauro and Agostini (1995), and Protopapas et al. (1997a) for previous reviews of the subject.
11. Multiphoton Processes in Atoms and Ions In this section, we shall discuss three important multiphoton processes occurring in atoms and ions: multiphoton ionization,harmonic generation, and laser-assisted electron-atom collisions. A. MULTIPHOTON IONIZATION AND ABOVE-THRESHOLD IONIZATION We begin by considering the multiphoton (single) ionization (MPI) reaction:
where q is the charge of the target atomic system A, expressed in atomic units (a.u.), hm is the photon energy, and n is an integer. This process was first observed by Voronov and Delone (1969, who used a ruby laser to induce seven-photon ionization of xenon, and by Hall et al. (1965), who recorded two-photon ionization from the negative ion I-. In the following years, important results were obtained by several experimental groups, in particular at Saclay where the dependence of the ionization yields on the intensity and the resonance-enhancement of MPI were studied. A crucial step was made in our understanding of MPI when experiments detecting the energy-resolved photo-electrons were performed. In this way Agostini ef al. (1979) discovered that the ejected electron in the reaction (1) could absorb photons in excess of the minimum required for ionization to occur. The study of this excess-photon ionization, known as “above-threshold ionization” (ATI), has been one of the central themes of multiphoton physics in recent years. A typical example of AT1 photo-electron energy spectra, obtained by Petite et al. (1988), is shown in Fig. 1. The spectra are seen to consist of several peaks, separated by the photon energy hm. As the intensity I increases [see Fig. 1(b)], peaks at higher energies appear, whose intensity dependence does not follow the lowest-order perturbation theory (LOPT) prediction according to which the ionization rate for an n-photon process is proportional to I”. Another remarkable feature of the AT1 spectra, also apparent in Fig. 1, is that as the intensity increases, the low-energy peaks are reduced in magnitude. The reason for this peak suppression is that the energies of the atomic states are Stark-shifted in the presence of a laser field. For low laser frequencies
228
C. J. Joachain, M. Dorr, and N. Kylstra
-I
2
L
6
8
I0
12
I4
Electron energy (eV) FIG.1. Electron energy spectra showing AT1 of xenon at a wavelength h = 1064 nm. (a) I = 2 x 10” W cm-’. (b) I = lOI3 W cm-’. From Petite et al. (1988).
(e.g., a Nd-YAG laser with hw = 1.17eV), the AC Stark shifts of the lowest bound states are small in magnitude. On the other hand, the induced Stark shifts of the Rydberg and continuum states are essentially given by the electron ponderomotive energy Up,which is the cycle-averaged kinetic energy of a quivering electron in a laser field and is given (for non-relativistic velocities) by
where me is the absolute value of its charge, and &O is the electric field strength. It is worth stressing that the ponderomotive energy Up is proportional to I / 0 2 and may become quite large. For example, in the case of the Nd-YAG laser, U p = ti0 = 1.17 eV at the intensity I N 1013W cm-2. Because the energies of the Rydberg and continuum states are shifted upwards
229
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS 0.5
x
P
Q)
c -0.5
I, 0.0
13
12 1
1
0.2
1
1
1
1
0.4
1
1
1
1
0.6
1
1
1
1
0.8
1
1
l
1.0
Intensity (arb. u.) FIG.2. Illustration of the mechanism responsible for the suppression of low-energy peaks in AT1 spectra. For low laser frequencies, the intensity-dependent ionization potential of the atom, l,,(l),is such that I,(I) N I, + Up and hence increases linearly with the intensity I (thick curve). Ionization by n photons, which is possible at the intensity I1 for which nfiw 2 I, Up,is prohibited at the higher intensities 12 and 13, where n + 1 photons are needed to ionize the atom. Also illustrated is the mechanism responsible for the resonantly induced structures appearing in AT1 spectra for short laser pulses. At the intensity 12, a Rydberg state (thin line) has shifted into multiphoton resonance with the ground state.
+
relative to the lower bound states by about Up, there is a corresponding increase in the intensity-dependent ionization potential Z p ( Z ) of the atom, so that I , ( ] ) 1: Zp + Up, where Zp = -Ei denotes the ionization potential of the field-free initial state of energy Ei. If this increase is such that nho < Zp Up, then ionization by n photons is energetically forbidden (see Fig. 2). However, atoms interacting with smoothly varying pulses experience a range of intensities, so that the corresponding peak in the photo-electron spectrum will not completely disappear, as seen in Fig. l(b). For short (sub-picosecond) pulses, the AT1 peaks exhibit a substructure (Freeman et al., 1987) because the intensity-dependent Stark shifts bring different states of the atom into multiphoton resonance during the laser pulse (see Fig. 2). This fine structure is not seen in long-pulse experiments because each electron regains its ponderomotive energy deficit from the field as it escapes the laser pulse adiabatically. Highly resolved spectra have been obtained recently by Hansch et al. (1997, 1998). A direct, simultaneous measurement of both the energy and the angular distribution of the photo-electrons has been performed by the group of Helm (Helm and Dyer, 1994; Schyja et al., 1998). In Fig. 3, we show the result
+
230
C. J. Joachain, M. Dorc and N. Kylstra
FIG.3. Density plot of the spatial distribution of the electrons ejected from a Xe atom irradiated by a laser pulse with h = 800nm and I = I .6 x lOI3 W crn-’. The laser polarization axis is along the vertical, and the radial distance from the center is proportional to the photoelectrons’ velocity. The innermost ring corresponds to the first AT1 peak, for which the dominant orbital angular momentum is 1 = 4. Courtesy of Schyja and Helm.
of the deconvoluted camera image of the spatial distribution of the photoelectrons. The rings correspond to the AT1 peaks, and the angular structure in the rings gives directly the dominant orbital angular momentum of the electrons emitted within a particular AT1 peak. For the present case, the dominant orbital angular momentum quantum number of the continuum electron in the lowest AT1 peak is 1 = 4,which indicates that the dominant resonance is an f-state. For increasing laser field strengths approaching the Coulomb field binding the electron ( I > loL4W cm-2), and for low laser frequencies, the sharp AT1 peaks of the photo-electron spectrum gradually blur into a continuous distribution (Augst et al., 1989; Mevel et al., 1993). In this regime, ionization can be interpreted by using a quasi-static model in which the bound electrons experience an effective potential formed by adding to the atomic potential the contribution due to the instantaneous laser electric field (see Fig. 4). This quasi-static approach was used by Keldysh (1965) to study tunneling ionization in the low-frequency limit and was pursued by several authors (Faisal,
231
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
\
\
X \
A, \
FIG.4. Schematic diagram showing (a) tunneling ionization and (b) over-the-barrier ionization. The dashed line corresponds to the contribution to the potential energy due to the instantaneouslaser electric field. The solid line correspondsto the full effective potential energy.
1973; Reiss, 1980; Ammosov et al., 1986). An important quantity in these studies is the Keldysh adiabaticity parameter y, defined as the ratio of the laser and tunneling frequencies, which is given by y=
JX
(3)
where ,Z is the field-free atomic ionization potential. For small y, tunneling dynamics will dominate, the transition from multiphoton to tunneling ionization taking place in the region around y = 1. Above a critical intensity Z, (which is equal to 1.4 x 1014W cm-2 for atomic hydrogen in the ground state), the electron can classically “flow over the top” of the barrier [over-thebarrier (OTB) ionization], so that field ionization occurs and the atom ionizes in about one orbital period (Shakeshaft et al., 1990). The semiclassical, “recollision picture” developed recently (Corkum, 1993; Kulander et al., 1993; Lewenstein et al., 1994) is based on the idea that strong field ionization dynamics at low frequency proceeds via several steps. In the first (bound-free) step, an electron is liberated from its parent atom by tunneling or OTB ionization. In the second (free-free) step, the interaction with the laser field dominates, a fact that was noted earlier by using a simple classical picture of a quivering electron (Kuchiev, 1987; van Linden van den Heuvell and Muller, 1988). As the phase of the field reverses, the electron is accelerated back towards the atomic core. If the electron returns to the core, a third step takes place in which scattering of the electron by the core then leads to single or multiple ionization, while radiative recombination leads to harmonic generation. This semiclassical three-step model has been very useful for explaining, in terms of classical trajectories and return energies, a number of features found
232
C. J. Joachain, M . D6rc and N. Kylstra 106 105
c
m
10‘ 103
v
v)
4
102
c
101
g
100
3
10-1
10-2 10-3
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
Electron Energy (eV) FIG.5. Photo-electron counts as a function of photo-electron energy, for various noble gases, at a laser wavelength of k = 630nm and an intensity I N 2 x lOI4 W cm-* (3 x lOI4 for He). From Paulus et al. (1994b).
in recent experiments. In these experiments, the use of kilohertz-repetitionrate, high-intensity lasers has allowed a precise measurement of photoelectron total yields and energy- and angle-differential spectra over many orders of magnitude in yield. These experimental results have revealed the existence of a “plateau” in the AT1 photo-electron energy spectra (Paulus et al., 1994b; Hansch et al., 1997). An example of such spectra is shown in Fig. 5. For the photo-electrons emitted at certain energies, sharp peaks can appear in the angular distributions (Yang et al., 1993; Paulus et al., 1994a). These angular peaks are sometimes called “rescattering rings,’’ because the distributions are symmetric around the axis of polarization of a linearly polarized laser field. The prominent groups of AT1 peaks that stand out within the plateau have also been studied in atomic hydrogen by Paulus et al. (1996) and in argon by Hertlein et al. (1997) and Muller and Kooiman (1998). Measurements of AT1 electron spectra in an elliptically polarized field have been carried out by Paulus et al. (1 998). The observed ellipticity dependence of emission rates in individual AT1 peaks was interpreted in terms of interference of electron tunneling at different times during an optical cycle. B. HARMONIC GENERATION Atoms interacting with a strong laser field can emit radiation at higher-order multiples, or harmonics, of the angular frequency o of the “pump” laser. For
233
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS 1 O'O
10'
Xe 10 Torr Ar 15 Torr 0 No 40 Torr 0 Ha 70 Torr
t I\
1
L
2
f
2
10'
10' '01
I
25
50
75 100 Hormonic Order
125
FIG.6. Harmonic emission spectra of various noble gases at a wavelength = 1053 nm and an intensity I N 1.5 x lOI5 Wcm-'. From L'Huillier and Balcou (1993).
an initial state of a given parity, the harmonic frequencies appear at odd multiples of the laser frequency,i.e., oq= qo with q = 3,5,. . . .The observation of the third harmonic in noble gases was made by New and Ward (1967). The availability of intense lasers has made it possible to observe high-order harmonics (McPherson et al., 1987; Wildenauer, 1987; Ferray et al., 1988; Macklin et al., 1993; L'Huillier and Balcou, 1993; Miyazaki and Takada, 1995; Nagata et al., 1996; Preston et al., 1996). As an example, we show in Fig. 6 the emission spectra of various noble gases, obtained by L'Huillier and Balcou (1993), who observed the harmonic q = 133 in neon at an intensity I N 1.5 x 1015Wcm-*. In the recent experiments with ultrashort laser pulses at very high intensities (Zhou et al., 1996; Christov et al., 1996; Spielmann et al., 1997; Chang et al., 1997; Schniirer et al., 1998; Rundquist et al., 1998), the atoms experience only a few laser cycles. The highest harmonic frequencies and harmonic orders (q N 297) have been observed under these condition!, reaching into the water window, corresponding to wavelengths around 2.7 A. Other experimental developments have been the spatially resolved measurements of the time dependence (Tisch et al., 1998) and the direct measurement of the temporal coherence (Bellini et al., 1998) of high-order harmonics. The theoretical treatment of harmonic generation by an intense laser pulse focused into a gaseous medium has two main aspects. First, the microscopic, single-atom response to the laser field must be analyzed. The single-atom spectra must then be combined to obtain the macroscopic harmonic fields
234
C. J. Joachain, M. Dorc and N. Kylstra
generated from the coherent emission of all the atoms in the laser focus; this is done by using the single-atom polarization fields as source terms in the Maxwell equations. We shall only discuss here the microscopic aspect of the problem. The power spectrum of the emitted radiation is proportional to the modulus squared of the Fourier transform of the dipole acceleration, a(t), (Burnett et al., 1992; Krause et al., 1992a) the latter being given by
d2 a(t) = -d(t) dt2
(4)
where d ( t ) is the laser-induced atomic dipole moment
d(t) =
(W- eRl*'(t))
(5)
Here 1 9 (t)) denotes the atomic state vector in the presence of the laser field and N
R=Eri i= 1
is the sum of the coordinates ri of the N atomic electrons. When the atom is driven by a monochromatic field, the emitted harmonic radiation can be simply calculated from the induced dipole moment, which can now be expanded as
d(t) =
E [d(qo)e-'qO' + c.c.]
(7)
4
where C.C. denotes the complex conjugate, and d ( - q o ) = [d(qo)]*because d(t) is real. The rate of emission of photons of frequency qo is then proportional to Id(qo)12. At high laser intensities, the harmonic intensity distribution exhibits a rapid decrease over the first few harmonics, followed by a plateau of approximately constant intensity and then a cut-off, corresponding to an abrupt decrease of harmonic intensity. It is important to note that the existence of a plateau is a nonperturbative feature. Perturbation theory is applicable only in the weak-field regime, where the harmonic intensity decreases significantly from one order to the next (Potvliege and Shakeshaft, 1989). It was discovered in the framework of time-dependent Schrodinger equation (TDSE) calculations (Krause et al., 1992b) that the cut-off angular frequency a, of the harmonic spectrum is given approximately by the relation
ho, N I,
+ 3u,
(8)
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
235
In the three-step “recollision model,” the maximum returning kinetic energy of a classical electron recolliding with the atomic core is given by 3.2 Up, so that the highest energy that can be radiated is I, 3.2 U p ,in good agreement with the TDSE calculations and with experiment. An exciting new development is the possibility of using high-order harmonics to generate pulses of extremely short duration, in the range of hundreds of attoseconds (1 as = lo-’’ s). There currently exist several proposed methods of attosecond pulse generation. The first one (Schafer and Kulander, 1997) 0 which involves the use of a very short fundamental laser pulse ( ~ 2 fs) should make it possible to generate single harmonic pulses of subfemtosecond duration. The second one (Corkum et al., 1994) is based on the high sensitivity of harmonic generation to the degree of ellipticity of the fundamental laser pulse. Indeed, invoking the three-step model, it is easy to show that harmonics are essentially produced when the polarization of the laser field is linear, because otherwise the electrons would not return near the parent ion. By creating a laser pulse whose polarization is linear only during a short time (close to a laser period), the harmonic emission can be limited to this interval, so that single sub-femtosecond pulses could be produced. Recent theoretical work (Antoine et al., 1996a, 1996b; Salier2s et al., 1999) also predicts that high-order harmonics generated by an atom in a linearly polarized intense laser pulse form a train of ultrashort pulses, corresponding to different trajectories of electrons that tunnel out of the atom and recombine with the parent ion (see Fig. 7). Under appropriate geometrical conditions, the
+
I
I
0.2
0
0
0.2
0.4 0.6 Time (optical prriod)
0.8
1 .o
FIG.7. Time profile of the filtered harmonic signal, including the 41st to 61st harmonics (solid line), emitted by a macroscopic medium, generated by a laser pulse of intensity 6.6 x lot4W cm-’. The dashed line is the single-atom response. From Antoine et al. (1996a).
236
C. J. Joachain, M. Dorr; and N. Kylstra
macroscopic propagation in an atomic jet allows the selection of one of these trajectories, leading to a train of attosecond pulses, with one pulse per half-cycle. C. LASER-ASSISTED ELECTRON-ATOM COLLISIONS
An electron scattered by an atom (ion) in the presence of a laser field can absorb or emit radiation. Because these radiative collisions involve continuum states of the electron-atom (ion) system, they are often called “free-free transitions” (FFT).In weak fields, only one-photon processes have a large enough probability to be observed. However, as the field strength is increased, multiphoton processes become important. Examples of laser-assisted electron-atom collisions are “elastic” collisions: e- + A ( i ) + n f i o + e- + A ( i )
(9)
inelastic collisions: e-
+ A ( i ) + nhw
-+
e-
+A ( f )
(10)
and single ionization (e, 2e) collisions: e- + A ( i )
+ nfiw + A + ( f ) + 2e-
(11)
where A(i) andA(f) denote an atom A in the initial state i and the final statef, respectively, and A+(f) means the ion A+ in the final statef. Positive values of n correspond to photon absorption (inverse bremsstrahlung), negative values of n to photon emission (stimulated bremsstrahlung), and n = 0 to a collision process without net absorption or emission of photons, but in the presence of the laser field. A review of laser-assisted electron-atom collisions has been given by Ehlotzky er al. (1998). Direct information on laser-assisted electron-atom collisions is obtained by performing three-beam experiments, in which an atomic beam is crossed in coincidence by a laser beam and an electron beam, and the scattered electrons, having undergone m,are recorded. Several experiments of this kind have been done, in which the exchange of photons between the electron-atom system and the laser field has been observed in laser-assisted elastic (Weingartshofer et al., 1977; Weingartshofer er al., 1983; Wallbank and Holmes, 1994) and inelastic (Mason and Newell, 1987; Wallbank er al., 1988; Wallbank eral., 1990;Luan er al., 1991)processes. As an illustration, we show in Fig. 8 the results of Weingartshofer er al. (1983) for laser-assisted “elastic”
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
'1
237
€,= 15.800 eV
e=
ISSO
Energy hw 1 FIG.8. Energy spectrum of electrons scattered by argon atoms in the presence of a C02 laser of photon energy fio = 0.117 eV. The open circles correspond to the experimentaldata; the full line is drawn to guide the eye. The abscissa gives the final electron energy in units of the photon energy with the origin fixed at the initial electron energy Ei = 15.8eV. The scattering angle 8 = 155". The laser intensity I = lo*Wcm-2. From Weingartshofer et al. (1983).
electron-argon scattering. We remark that even at the modest intensity of lo8W cm-*, as many as eleven photon emission and absorption transitions were observed. As seen in Fig. 8, the relative intensities of two successive FFT peaks are of the same order of magnitude, which indicates that perturbation theory cannot be used to analyze these results. Thus, as in the case of the other multiphoton processes discussed above, nonperturbative methods must be developed.
111. Theoretical Methods In this section, following a brief summary of the basic equations of the theory, we shall give a survey of the main methods which have been used to study laser-atom interactions at high intensities. The most appropriate theoretical framework for studying the interaction of an atom with a laser field depends on the characteristics of the laser pulse and of course on the atom or ion being studied. For ow purposes, the relevant laser
238
C. J. Joachain, M. Dorr; and N. Uylstra
parameters are the frequency, maximum intensity, and duration of the laser pulse. With respect to the laser pulse duration, we can, in a nonrigorous way, distinguish between three regimes: the long-pulse, short-pulse, and ultrashortpulse regime. In the long-pulse regime, which is typically characterized by s; we note that the atomic unit of time is 2.4 x s) or nanosecond longer laser pulses, multiphoton processes in the atom can be characterized by rates that depend only on the angular frequency and maximum intensity of the laser. The exact details concerning the turn-on and turn-off of the pulse are not relevant, except for the requirement that the atom evolves adiabatically in the laser field. In this regime, the rates can be calculated using time-dependent perturbation theory when the field is weak, whereas for strong or resonant fields the Floquet approach, which will be discussed below, can be utilized. In the short-pulse regime (pulse durations of the order of picoseconds, or s), the evolution of the atom in the laser field can still be assumed to be adiabatic, apart from isolated resonances between quasi-bound states. In this regime, the shape of the laser pulse is important, so if a comparison is to be made with experiment, the relevant quantities to be calculated are the transition probabilities determined from the instantaneous intensity-dependent rates of the atom in the laser field (Potvliege and Shakeshaft, 1992). When comparing with experiment, the spatial profile of the laser in the interaction region will also have to be considered (Potvliege and Shakeshaft, 1992; Rottke et al., 1994). Once the rates have been calculated for the range of intensities of the pulse, the final probabilities can be determined for a given laser pulse shape. Finally, in the ultra-short-pulse regime (of the order of femtoseconds, or s), the evolution of the atom cannot be considered to be adiabatic, so the only recourse is to obtain information about the multiphoton processes from a direct integration of the time-dependent Schrodinger equation, as discussed in Section 1II.G. Obviously, the boundaries which delimit the three regimes cannot be precisely defined. With respect to the frequency of the laser, we can again distinguish between three regimes. In the low-frequency regime the ionization processes can be viewed in terms of a quasistatic effective potential given by the instantaneous electric field of the laser and the Coulomb potential. In the high-frequency regime the electron orbital frequency is less than the driving laser field frequency and thus an adiabatic approach eliminating the fast laser oscillation proves fruitful. Finally, in the intermediate regime, the photon energy is comparable to relevant atomic transition energies and resonant multiphoton processes will typically play an important role. Regarding the laser intensity, we can subdivide the low-frequency regime into a multiphoton ionization regime at the low-intensity end, an intermediate tunneling ionization regime, and the high-intensity over-the-barrier ionization regime. For intermediate and high frequencies, the laser-atom interaction can
HIGH-INTENSITYLASER-ATOM PHYSICS
239
be described perturbatively when the laser intensity is weak, whereas semiperturbative methods are useful at moderate intensities and close to resonances, when a relatively small number of atomic states are deemed important in describing the laser-atom interaction. Finally, completely nonperturbative methods are required at high intensities. The frequency and intensity regimes described above are to a degree interdependent. Moreover, although such a classification can usually be made for any atom, the intensities and frequencies that characterize the different regimes will depend strongly on the particular atom and on its initial state; e.g., a frequency that is low for the ground state can be high for an excited state. A. BASICEQUATIONS
In order to study the interaction of an atomic system with a laser field, we shall use a semiclassical approach in which the laser field is treated classically, while the atomic system is studied by using quantum mechanics. This approach is entirely justified for the intense fields considered here (Faisal, 1986; Mittleman, 1993; Joachain, 1994). We neglect for the moment relativistic effects and treat the laser field in the dipole approximation as a spatially homogeneous electric field &(t),the corresponding vector potential being A(t), with &(t)= -dA(t)/dt. For example, if the field is linearly polarized, we have
where i is the unit polarization vector, &O is the electric field strength, F ( t ) is the pulse shape function, and 4 is a phase. We note that for a chirped pulse, either o or is time-dependent. Our starting point is the time-dependent Schrodinger equation
+
a
i A - q x ,t ) = H ( t ) \ k ( X ,t ) at
where @(X,t) is the wave function and X denotes the ensemble of the atomic electron coordinates (i.e., their position coordinates ri and spin variables). The Hamiltonian H ( t ) of the system is given by
+
where Hat = T V is the time-independent field-free atomic Hamiltonian. Here T is the sum of the electron kinetic energy operators and V is the sum of
240
C. J. Joachain, M.Dorr; and N. Kylstra
the two-body Coulomb interactions. The laser-atom interaction term is e Hint(t)= - A(?) P m a
e2N +A2(r) 2m
where N is the number of electrons and N
P=):Pi i= I
is the total momentum operator. The term in A’ can be eliminated from the Schrodinger equation ( 13) by performing the gauge transformation
(17)
which gives for Qv(X,t) the Schrodinger equation in the velocity gauge
On the other hand, if we return to the Schrodinger equation (13) and perform the gauge transformation
Q(X,t)
[;
] Qt(X,
= exp - - A(?) R
r)
where R is the sum of the coordinates ri of the electrons [see Eq. (6)], we obtain the Schrodinger equation in the length gauge
As we shall see below, it is sometimes convenient to study the interaction of an atomic system with a laser field in an accelerated frame called the Kramers frame (Kramers, 1956; Henneberger, 1968). Starting from the Schrodinger equation (18) in the velocity gauge, we perform the unitary transformation
(21)
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
24 1
where m
is a vector corresponding to the displacement of a “classical” electron from its oscillation center in the electric field & ( I ) . The Kramers transformation, Eq. (2l), therefore corresponds to a spatial translation, characterized by the vector a(?),to a new frame moving with respect to the laboratory frame in the same way as a “classical” electron in the field &(t).In this accelerated Kramers frame, the new Schrodinger equation for the wave function $A(X,t) is
so that the interaction with the laser field is now incorporated via a(t)into the potential V, which becomes time-dependent. We note that in the case of a linearly polarized monochromatic field E ( t ) = i&o cos (at)
(24)
a(t) = i o cos (at)
(25)
we have
where o=-
f?&O
ma2
is called the “excursion” amplitude of the electron in the field. B.
PERTURBATION
THEORY AND ITS BREAKDOWN
At low intensities (such that the electric field strength &O is much smaller than the atomic fields relevant to the process considered) time-dependent perturbation theory (see Faisal, 1986) can in general be used to study multiphoton processes. The simplest form of this approach is called lowest (nonvanishing) order perturbation theory (LOPT). For example, in the case of an n-photon ionization process from an initial (unperturbed) bound state I$i ) , LOPT
242
C. J. Joachain, M.Don; and N. Kylstra
predicts that the ionization rate r, is given by
r, f
where T!) is the LOFT transition matrix element for the absorption of n photons and the sum is over allowed final states l\Ilf). Thus, if HO = Ha, is the “unperturbed” (field-free) Hamiltonian and G o ( E ) = (E - H o ) - ’ is the corresponding Green’s operator, one has, in the length gauge
where Ei is the energy of the unperturbed initial state. Similar LOFT expressions can be written down for other multiphoton processes such as harmonic generation and laser-assisted electron-atom collisions. The calculation of the LOFT transition matrix element Tjr) is in general a difficult task, particularly for high-order multiphoton processes and (or) for complex atoms. The simplest case is that of nonresonant MPI in oneelectron atoms for which LOFT has been applied successfully for intensities I < 1013W cmP2 and angular frequencies such that fiw >> Up (see Gontier and Trahin, 1980; Crance, 1987). Discrepancies from the perturbative I” power law, which are found at higher intensities, signal the breakdown of perturbation theory, as do other strong-field phenomena such as the “peak suppression” in AT1 spectra, the existence of a plateau in high-order harmonic generation, or successive FFT peaks of comparable height in laser-assisted electron-atom scattering. Let us now return to the transition matrix element, Eq. (28). Using the spectral representation of the Green’s operator G o ( E ) ,namely
with ~~1+~, = Ek I\I~~), we can write
~i,”’in the more explicit form
HIGH-INTENSITYLASER-ATOM PHYSICS
243
which shows that LOFT always fails for resonant multiphoton processes such that Ei + r h o = Ek,, for a particular r E { 1 , 2 , .. . ,n - 1). In this case, modifications of the theory are required, in which the resonantly coupled states are treated in a nonperturbative way, whereas the other states are treated by using perturbation theory. This approach belongs to the category of semiperturbative methods, to which we now turn our attention. C. SEMIPERTURBATIVE METHODS
We shall now describe two semiperturbative approaches, in which some of the interactions are treated in a nonperturbative way, and the remaining ones are treated by using perturbation theory. The first is the method of essential states, which we shall apply to resonant multiphoton ionization (REMPI). The second is a semiperturbative approach to laser-assisted electron-atom collisions.
1. Essential States When resonances are present, and for not too intense laser fields, the multiphoton processes will usually be dominated by the resonant contributions. A convenient way of accounting for this is by formulating an approach based on the Feshbach projection operator formalism (Feshbach, 1958,1962). Two projection operators are defined, P and Q, that project onto the space of, respectively, the field-free states that are resonantly coupled by the field and its complement space. Writing the wave function as * ( t ) = P*(t)
+ Q*(t)
(31)
and inserting this expression into the time-dependent Schrodinger equation, the following two coupled equations are obtained:
Now, by defining the Green's operator in the Q space,
C. J. Joachain, M.Don; and N. Kylstra
244
the second of Eqs. (32) can be formally solved, so that an effective timedependent Schrodinger equation in the P space is found:
(ih
)
- PH(t)P - PH(t)QGQ(t)QH(t)P( P @ ( t ) )= 0
(34)
The Green’s operator GQ can be approximated by accounting for the nonresonant part of the interaction using perturbation theory. Finally, by expanding the wave function P @ ( t ) in the basis of the resonantly coupled, unperturbed states
one obtains a system of coupled first-order differential equations for the resonantly coupled, or “essential,” states of the system d dt
ih - C(t) = H e f f ( t ) C ( t ) where the matrix Heff ( t ) represents the effective Hamiltonian which treats the resonantly coupled states exactly and takes into account the rest of the spectrum in a perturbative way. Various formulationsof essential-statesmethods have been widely employed to study a range of resonant, multiphoton phenomena. Examples include resonantly enhanced multiphoton ionization, Rydberg wavepacket formation and evolution (see Zobay and Alber, 1996; Mecking and Lambropoulos, 1998) and ionization suppression by quantum interference (see Fedorov and Movsesian, 1988; Fedorov et al., 1990). Further applications of the method of essential states are discussed in the review articles of Lambropoulos and Tang (1992) and Burnett et al. (1993).
2. Laser-Assisted Electron-Atom Collisions The theoretical study of electron-atom collisions in a laser field is in general very complex, because in addition to the difficulties associated with the treatment of field-free electron-atom scattering, the presence of the laser field introduces new parameters (such as the laser frequency, intensity, and polarization) which can influence the collisions. It is therefore of interest to start with a simpler problem, such that the target atom is modeled by a center of force, i.e., a potential V(r), and hence does not exhibit any internal
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
245
structure. For a laser field treated as a spatially homogeneous, linearly polarized, monochromatic electric field &(t) = iEo cos (cot), the Schrodinger equation in the velocity gauge is
a
ih- Qv(r,t ) = at
e + V(r) + -A(t) m
1
p Qv(r, t )
(37)
with A(t) = i A o sin(cot) and A 0 = -€o/co. Let us first study the motion of the electron in the presence of the laser field, but without scattering potential ( V = 0). The corresponding Schrodinger equation
is readily solved to give the (nonrelativistic) Gordon-Volkov wave function (Gordon, 1926; Volkov, 1935)
Xk(r,t) = ( 2 ~ ) - exp ~ ’ {i[k. ~ r - k a(t) - E k t / h ] }
(39)
where k is the electron wave vector, Ek = h2k2/2m is its kinetic energy, and a(?)is the displacement vector given by Eq. (25).
It is worth stressing that the Gordon-Volkov wave function, Eq. (39), is the exact solution of Eq. (38) and hence contains the effect of the laser field on the “free” electron “to all orders.” Defining a0 = 010i, this effect is characterized by the dimensionlessquantity k 010 = p i . k,where p = kclo = ke€o/(mo2).Thus a low-order perturbative treatment of the laser interaction with the “free electron” will be valid only if Ik .sol<< 1. In particular, for fast electrons, the parameter p is larger than unity even for laser fields of moderate intensity, so that the exact (nonperturbative) Gordon-Volkov wave functions, Eq. (39), must be used to treat the laser coupling with the “free” electron. Let us now return to the full Schrodinger equation, Eq. (37). Using the Gordon-Volkov wave functions, Eq. (39), and treating the interaction potential V(r) to first order (i.e., in first Born approximation,B1)Bunkin and Fedorov (1966) have shown that the differential cross section for scattering with the exchange of n photons is given (in a.u.) by +
246
C. J. Joachain. M. Dorr; and N. Kylstra
where d o B ’ / d Ris the field-free first Born differential cross section, J, is an ordinary Bessel function of order n,A = k i - kf is the momentum transfer of the collision (k and kf being the initial and final momenta of the electron, respectively), and k f (n)= ( k ? 2no)”*. The Bunkin and Fedorov formula, Eq. (40), in which the electron interaction with the laser field is treated in a nonperturbative way (using the Gordon-Volkov wave functions) whereas the interaction potential V(r) is treated by first-order perturbation theory, provides the simplest example of the use of semiperturbative methods in laser-assisted collisions. Let us now consider collisions of electrons with “real” atoms, having an internal structure, in the presence of a laser. Three types of interactions must then be taken into account. First, the interaction between the unbound electron and the target atom takes place, as in the field-free case. Second, the laser field interacts with the unbound electron. Third, the laser field interacts with the target atom and therefore “dresses” the atomic target states. In order to deal with this problem, which is much more complex than laserassisted potential scattering, Byron and Joachain ( 1984) have proposed a semiperturbativetheory which we now briefly outline. We consider the case for which the incident electrons are fast ( E k i 2 100eV), so that the electron-atom interaction can be treated perturbatively by using the Born series (see Joachain, 1983). Assuming again that the laser field can be described as a monochromatic, linearly polarized, and homogeneous electric field, the interaction between the laser and the projectile electron can be treated exactly, as in the case of potential scattering, by using a Gordon-Volkov wave function. On the other hand, the laser-target atom interaction can be treated by using first-order time-dependent perturbation theory, provided that the electric field strength lo remains small with respect to the atomic unit of electric field strength. (This is a required condition on laser-assisted collisions, because otherwise the target atom would be ionized by the laser.) Furthermore, the laser frequency must not be too close to resonance with an atomic transition between the initial or the final state of the atom and any intermediate atomic state. This semiperturbative theory has been applied to the three kinds of laserassisted scattering processes Eqs. (9)-( 11): “elastic” collisions, inelastic collisions, and (e, 2e) reactions (see the review articles of Francken and Joachain, 1990a; Joachain, 1994; Ehlotzky ef al., 1998). The results show the importance of the dressing of the atomic states by the laser field, even at relatively modest intensities. As an example, we show in Fig. 9 the differential cross section for “elastic” electron-atomic hydrogen scattering with the absorption of one laser photon. The full results, including the target dressing, exhibit important departures from the results in which target dressing has been neglected, particularly at small scattering angles.
+
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
247
Scattering Angle (deg.) FIG.9. Differential cross section for “elastic” electron-hydrogen scattering in a laser field of fio = 2 eVand a peak laser electric field of 0.02 a.u., with the absorption of one net photon by the scattered electron from the laser field. The direction of the momentum transfer A is parallel to the field polarization i. The incident electron energy is 100eV. Solid curve: full results; dashed curve: neglecting target dressing. From Byron et al. (1987).
D. FLOQUET THEORY Having introduced perturbative and semiperturbativemethods, in this Section we consider a fully nonperturbative approach for studying laser-atom interactions, namely the Hoquet theory.
1. Basic Equations Let us now restrict our attention to monochromatic laser fields of angular frequency o and of arbitrary polarization. The HamiltonianH ( t ) of the system
248
C. J. Joachain, M. Don; and N. Kylstra
+
is then periodic, H(t T) = H ( t ) , where T = 27~/0.The Floquet method (Floquet, 1883; Shirley, 1965; Chu 1985) can therefore be used to write the wave function @(X,t) in the form
where the time-independent quantity E is called the quasi-energy, and the function F ( X , t) is periodic in time, with period T, so that it can be expressed as the Fourier series
n=-cc
The functions F n ( X ) are called the harmonic components of @(X,r ) . Using Eqs. (41) and (42), we obtain for *(X,t) the Floquet-Fourier expansion
n=-cc
If we also make a Fourier analysis of the interaction Hamiltonian, +cc n=-cc
and substitute both Eqs. (43) and (44) into the Schrodinger equation (13), we obtain for the harmonic components F n ( X ) a system of time-independent coupled differential equations:
with n = 0, f 1, f2, . . . . These equations, together with appropriate boundary conditions, form an eigenvalue problem for the quasi-energies, which we can write as
(HF- E ) F = O
(46)
where the Floquet Hamiltonian HF is an infinite matrix of operators. In the case of multiphoton ionization, the quasi-energies are complex and can be
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
249
expressed as E = Ei+ A - i -
r 2
(47)
where Ei is the energy of the initial unperturbed (field-free) state and A is the AC Stark shift of the state. The physical meaning of r can be deduced by noting that the integral over a finite volume of the electron density, averaged over one cycle, decreases in time like exp(-rt/h). Hence the characteristic lifetime of an atom described by the Floquet state, Eq. (41), is h / r , which means that r / h is the total ionization rate of that state. We also note that, in the velocity or the length gauges, the interaction Hamiltonian can be written in the form
where H+ and H- are time-independent operators. The coupled equations (45) then take the simpler form
and the Floquet Hamiltonian HF is a tridiagonal matrix of operators. 2. The Sturmian-Floguet Method
The Floquet theory has been used extensively to study multiphoton processes in atomic systems. In particular, detailed calculations have been performed for one-electron atoms. Denoting by r the electron position vector, and following Maquet et al. (1983), the system of coupled equations (49) can be solved by expanding each harmonic component Fn(r)on a discrete basis set:
where the YLM are spherical harmonics and the radial functions S i L are complex Stunnian functions (Rotenberg, 1970). The parameter IC is chosen as complex, allowing the computation of quasi-bound (Siegert) states, in complete analogy to the complex-rotation (or dilatation) transformation method (Chu, 1985). The complex, discrete Sturmian basis is particularly appropriate for obtaining highly accurate solutions to the coupled Floquet equations for one-electron atoms moving in Coulomb or modified Coulomb effective potentials. The Sturmian-Floquet method has been applied extensively to
C. J. Joachain, M. Dorr, and
250
0
1
2
3
N. Kylstra
4
5
6
Electron Energy (eV) FIG. 10. Yield of photo-electrons into the lowest three AT1 channels, versus photo-electron energy, for ionization of H(1s) by a 608-nm pulse whose peak intensity is 6.5 x I O l 3 Wcm-* and whose duration is 0.5 ps. The solid curve is the result of Sturmian-Floquet calculations, and the dashed curve represents the experimental data (Rottke et al., 1994). Some of the subpeaks are labelled by the dominant configuration of the resonant Floquet state.
study multiphoton ionization and harmonic generation in atomic hydrogen (see the review by Potvliege and Shakeshaft, 1992) and other systems modeled by effective single-active-electronpotentials. As an example, we show in Fig. 10 the photo-electron spectrum for the lowest three AT1 peaks (Dorr et al., 1990a; Rottke et al., 1994) for the multiphoton ionization of H(1s) compared with the experimental data of Rottke et al. (1990). The subpeaks are due to Rydberg states moving in and out of resonance when the intensity of the pulse rises and falls (Freeman et al., 1987), as explained in Section 1I.A. Angular distributions for some of the more prominent subpeaks within the different AT1 peaks have also been obtained and compared with the Sturmian-Floquet calculations (Rottke et al., 1994). Another interesting prediction of Floquet calculations is the occurrence of light-induced states (LIS). The emergence of LIS has been seen in onedimensional model-atom calculations (Bhatt et al., 1988;Bardsley et al., 1988) and has been analyzed in terms of shadow poles (Dorr and Potvliege, 1990; Dorr et al., 1991). Shadow poles have been discussed within the context of Sturmian-Floquet calculations (Potvliege and Shakeshaft, 1988, 1992; Fearnside et al., 1995). These poles arise from solutions of the Floquet equations corresponding to unphysical boundary conditions. They can, however, lead to physically observable consequences following the crossing
HIGH-INTENSITYLASER-ATOM PHYSICS
25 1
of a multiphoton threshold, when a shadow pole becomes a physical pole. This can give rise to the appearance of “new discrete states” in certain laser intensity regions. Although LIS arising from such shadow pole resonances have been seen in the calculations mentioned above, as well as in recent ones (Wells e f al., 1998), experimental verification has yet to come forth. 3. High-Frequency Floquet Theory
Floquet theory has been used to study the behavior of atoms interacting with high-intensity monochromatic laser fields whose frequency is much larger than the threshold frequency for one-photon ionization (Gavrila, 1992b, 1997). This approach is formulated in the Kramers frame introduced in Section III.A. For the case of an atom with one active electron, the Schrodinger equation (23) satisfied by the wave function @ A is
a
ih - @A(r, t ) = at
[C+ -
+
1
V ( r a ( t ) ) @A(r,t )
where a(t)is the displacement vector, given by Eq. (25) for the case of linear polarization. Because Eq. (5 1) has periodic coefficients, one can seek solutions having the Floquet-Fourier form, Eq. (43). Making also a Fourier analysis of the potential
one obtains for the harmonic components F n ( r ) of !PA(r,t), as defined in Eq. (42), the system of coupled equations
Gavrila and coworkers have shown that in the high-intensity, highfrequency limit, the atomic structure in the laser field is essentially governed by the potential V O ( Q ,r ) which is the static (time-averaged) “dressed” potential associated with the interaction potential V in the Kramers frame. Detailed calculations of the energies and eigenstates, performed for the hydrogen atom, show that the atom undergoes “dichotomy”; i.e., the electronic cloud in the static, “dressed” potential splits into two disjoint parts. This is illustrated in Fig. 11 for the ground state of atomic hydrogen in a
252
C. J. Joachain, M. Dorc and N. Kylstra
FIG. 1 1 . (a) High-frequency-limit energy eigenfunction of the ground state of atomic hydrogen in the static “dressed“ potential VO(a0,r) in the Kramers frame for a0 = 20a.u., for the case of linear polarization. @(x, 0, z) is the wave function in the xz plane, where the z-axis is chosen along the direction of the polarization vector t . (b) 1QI2 is the corresponding timeaveraged probability density in the laboratory frame obtained by averaging the probability density over one oscillation of the laser field. From Pont ef al. (1988).
linearly polarized laser field. With increasing ao,the wave function undergoes radiative stretching along the polarization axis. As a0 approaches 20 a.u., a saddle appears, as shown in Fig. ll(a), and two pronounced maxima are formed around the endpoints f a0 2 of the “classical” electron excursion. In Fig. ll(b), the time-averaged density is shown in the laboratory frame. Moreover, the ionization potential of the ground state of Vo(a0,r) decreases with increasing ao. An important prediction of the high-frequency Floquet theory (HFFT) is that at sufficiently high intensity, and when the frequency of the laser field is substantially larger than the threshold frequency for one-photon ionization, the ionization rate decreases when the intensity increases. This phenomenon, called adiabatic stabilization, is essentially due to the fact that the quiver motion of the bound electron(s) in the field becomes large, thus inhibiting the ionization process. It was initially investigated by Gersten and Mittleman (1976) and was studied in detail for atomic hydrogen, using not only the approximate high-frequency Floquet theory (Pont et al., 1988; Pont and Gavrila 1990; Gavrila, 1992b; Vos and Gavrila, 1992; Gavrila, 1997) but also the Sturmian-Floquet theory (Dorr et al., 1991; Potvliege and Smith, 1993b) and the R-matrix-Floquet theory (Dorr et al., 1993), which we shall consider in Section 1II.E. It should be noted that in contrast to the high-frequency Floquet calculations, both the Sturmian-Floquet and the R-matrix-Floquet methods provide exact Floquet results for atomic hydrogen. As an example, we show in Fig. 12 the total rate I’ for ionization of H(ls), as obtained from the Sturmian-Floquet method (Dorr et al., 1991)
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
Intensity (I o
253
’ ~w/cm’)
FIG. 12. Total ionization rate versus intensity for H(1s) in a linearly polarized laser field of angular frequency o = 0.65 a.u. The solid line corresponds to the Sturmian-Floquet (DOH et al., 1991) and the R-matrix-Floquet (DOIT et al, 1993) calculations, which are in excellent agreement. The LOPT results are given by the broken line.
and the R-matrix-Floquet theory (Dorr et al., 1993) for an angular frequency o = 0.65 a.u., which is larger than the threshold value (a= 0.5 a.u.) for onephoton ionization. The Floquet results are seen to increase linearly at low intensities, as predicted by lowest-order (in the present case, firstorder) perturbation theory (LOFT). They have a peak near 10l6W cm-’ and then decrease with increasing intensity, thus exhibiting the stabilization behavior. In the Floquet analysis discussed above, a monochromatic laser field of constant intensity is assumed to be present at all times. In reality, an atom cannot be instantaneously released into a super-intense field, but must be subjected to a laser pulse of finite duration. This implies that during the laser pulse turn-on, where the intensity is lower, substantial ionization will occur. In other words, before the atoms experience a super-intense field where they can stabilize, they must pass through a “death valley” where their lifetime is extremely short (Lambropoulos, 1985). Therefore, if adiabatic stabilization is to be observed experimentally, the laser pulse risetime must not be so long that saturation (complete ionization) occurs during the turn-on. However, it must be long enough so that the atom adiabatically remains in the ground state in the Kramers frame. By comparing moquet calculations with timedependent calculations, it has been shown that these criteria can both be fulfilled (Pont and Shakeshaft, 1991; Zakrzewski and Delande, 1995; Piraux and Potvliege, 1998). As the laser pulses become shorter, excited states of the
C. J. Joachain, M . Dorr; and N. Kylstra
254
I
-alCT .-Cfn
n ”
0
5
10
fluence ( J / c ~ ’ > FIG. 13. Photo-ionization yield of the 5 g circular state of neon as a function of the laser pulse fluence (in Jcm-’). The open circles were measured with low peak intensity (up to 1.2 x I O l 3 W cm-2, 1 ps). The solid curve represents a fit using the theoretical perturbative rate (including depletion). The solid circles were measured using shorter pulses, with the same fluence but more intense (up to 1.2 x W c d , 0.1 ps). The yield due to these pulses hardly increases with fluence, which indicates stabilization. From de Boer et al. (1993).
Kramers static potential V O ( C Ir) O ,become populated. As a result, dichotomy becomes less apparent (Kulander et al., 1991; Reed et al., 1991), but stabilization still persists, as will be discussed in Section 1II.G.1. Due to the adiabaticity condition and the high-frequency, high-intensity requirements, the experimental verification of adiabatic stabilization is a very difficult task. Fortunately, the stabilization conditions can be met at lower intensities and frequencies if the atom is prepared in an initial state that is not the ground state but a “circular” Rydberg state with large n, 1, and Irnl quantum numbers, such that its lifetime in the “death valley” regime is sufficiently long (Vos and Gavrila, 1992; Potvliege and Smith, 1993). An experiment of this kind, using two laser pulses, was carried out by de Boer et a1. (1993, 1994) to study the stabilization behavior of the hydrogenlike, “circular” 5g state of neon. A first pulse prepares the initial state. Comparison of the single-photon ionization yield, due to a second laser pulse (see Fig. 13), for both short (0.1-ps) intense and long (1-ps) less intense pulses, shows a suppression of ionization as the intensity increases, in accordance with the theoretical prediction of stabilization. The experimental
HIGH-INTENSITY LASER-ATOM PHYSICS
255
results are in fair agreement with theoretical calculations (Piraux and Potvliege, 1998). In addition to adiabatic stabilization, which occurs at high intensities and high frequencies, several mechanisms of ionization suppression have been suggested that rely on interference between ionization probability amplitudes from a coherent wavepacket of states (Fedorov and Movsesian, 1988; Parker and Stroud, 1989; Fedorov et al., 1990; Piraux et al., 1991; Burnett et al., 1991; Tikhonova and Fedorov, 1997). These mechanisms, referred to as dynamic stabilization, require intensities of the order of 1014W cm-2 but are destroyed at higher intensities. The stabilization in this case arises from an interaction of resonances with comparable (overlapping) widths (see also the discussion on laser-induced degeneracies in Section II1.E). 4. Floquet Theory for Luser-Assisted Electron-Atom Collisions
Floquet methods can also be applied to the study of laser-assisted electronatom scattering. We assume now that, on average, the laser intensity does not vary much on time scales which are of the order of typical scattering times. The scattering process can therefore be described in terms of time-independent transition rates. Starting with the Floquet-Fourier form of the wave function and expanding the Floquet-Fourier components in terms of partial waves, Floquet-closecoupling (FCC) equations can be derived that are satisfied by the corresponding radial functions. These equations and their method of solution are very similar to the close-coupling equations appearing within the context of electron-atom scattering. This will be discussed in more detail in Section 1II.E on the R-matrix-Floquet theory. Dimou and Faisal(l987) have studied laserinduced resonances in laser-assisted electron-proton scattering using the FCC equations. Within the context of the HFFT,Gavrila and Kaminski (1984) have considered scattering in a high-frequency laser. A momentum space formulation of the problem can be obtained by deriving an integral equation for the scattering T-matrix elements, the FloquetLippmann-Schwinger (FLS) equation, in complete analogy with the field-free case. In this approach, the time-dependent Schriidinger equation is first recast into the form of a time-dependent Lippmann-Schwhger equation. Using the Floquet-Fourier form of the wave function and the Gordon-Volkov propagator, an integral equation is found for the Floquet-Fourier coefficients, from which the Floquet-Lippmann-Schwingerequation is obtained for the required on-shell T-matrix elements (Kylstra and Joachain, 1998). By solving numerically the FLS equation for laser-assisted low-energy electron scattering by various potentials, Kylstra and Joachain found that for a low frequency o = 0.0043 a.u. (corresponding to a C02 laser), the differential cross section
C. J. Joachain, M.Dorr; and N. Kylstra
256
do”/dR corresponding to the scattering process ki--+ kf accompanied by the transfer of n photons, is given to good approximation by the Kroll and Watson (1973) formula
where d o ( k f,k;)/d R is the field-free differential cross section corresponding to the transition k f -+ kj,and ky(j = i, f)are shifted momenta such that ky = kj nwao/(A.ao). Finally, we mention that the Floquet theory has also been used to construct “dressed” atomic target states in a nonperturbative way in order to analyze laser-assistedelectron-atom collisions (Francken and Joachain, 1990a, 1990b; Dorr et al., 1994) within the semiperturbative theory discussed in Section III.C.2. This approach is particularly useful to study resonant cases, where the laser frequency is close to a transition frequency in the atom.
+
E. R-MATRIX-FLOQUET THEORY The R-matrix-Floquet (RMF) theory is a nonperturbative approach that has been proposed by Burke, Francken, and Joachain (1990, 1991) to analyze atomic multiphoton processes in intense laser fields. The RMF theory treats multiphoton ionization, harmonic generation and laser-assisted electronatom collisions in a unified way. It is completely ab-initioand is applicable to an arbitrary atom or ion, allowing an accurate description of electron correlation effects. Let us consider an atomic system, composed of a nucleus of atomic number 2 and N electrons, in a laser field that is treated classically as a spatially homogeneous electric field E ( t ) . Although more general cases (such as twocolor fields) have been studied, we shall assume for the moment that the laser field is monochromatic and linearly polarized, so that the electric field & ( t ) is given by Eq. (24). Neglecting relativistic effects, the atomic system in the presence of this laser field is then described by the time-dependent Schrodinger equation [see Eqs. (13)-( 15)]
at
1
. P + -A2 ( t ) 9(X,t ) e2m 2N
(55)
where the vector potential is A ( t ) = i A o sin (or) with A 0 = -&o/o.We shall be interested in the following three processes involving at mos