Advances in Applied Mechanics Volume 1 7
Editorial Board T. BROOKEBENJAMIN Y. C. FUNG PAULGERMAIN L. HOWARTH WILLIAM ...
33 downloads
1014 Views
17MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in Applied Mechanics Volume 1 7
Editorial Board T. BROOKEBENJAMIN Y. C. FUNG PAULGERMAIN L. HOWARTH WILLIAM PRACER
T. Y. Wu HANSZIECLER
Contributors to Volume 17 P. CHADWICK J. L. ERICKSEN
C. S. Hsu
ROBERTR. LONG T. FRANCIS OGILVIE G. D. SMITH
ADVANCES IN
APPLIED MECHANICS Edited by Chia-Shun Yih DEPARTMENT OF APPLIED MECHANICS A N D ENGINEERING SCIENCE THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR, MICHIGAN
VOLUME 17
1977
ACADEMIC PRESS New York
San Francisco London
A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
COPYRIGHT 0 1977, BY ACADEMIC PRESS,INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. NO PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM THE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York. New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published b y ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road. London NWl
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARD NUMBER: 48-8503 ISBN 0-12-002017-3 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA
Contents
vii
LISTOF CONTRIBUTORS
Some Aspects of Turbulence in Geophysical Systems Robert R. Long 1. 11. 111. IV. V. VI.
Introduction Introductory Concepts in Turbulence-Homogeneous Fluids Some Basic Effects of Density Variations and Rotation Thermal Convection Turbulence in Stably Stratified Fluids Third-Order Closure Schemes in Turbulence Research References
2 7 21 33 50 12 84
Singular-Perturbation Problems in Ship Hydrodynamics
IT: Francis Ogilvie I. Introduction 11. Slender-Body Theory in Aerodynamics
111. Slender Ships in Unsteady Motion at Zero Speed IV. Slender Ships in Steady Forward Motion V. Slender Ships in Unsteady Forward Motion References
92 95 105 145
169 185
Special Topics in Elastostatics J . L. Ericksen I. 11. 111. IV.
189 192 200 220 24 1
Introduction Basic Equations Semi-Inverse Methods Experiment and Mechanistic Theory References V
Contents
Vi
On Nonlinear Parametric Excitation Problems C . S. Hsu I. Introduction 11. Asymptotic Analysis for Weakly Nonlinear Systems 111. Analysis by Difference Equations
IV. V. VI. VII.
Second Order Difference Systems Global Regions of Asymptotic Stability Impulsive Parametric Excitation An Example: A Hinged Bar Subjected to a Periodic Impact Load References
245 241 251 266 216 283 286 298
Foundations of the Theory of Surface Waves in Anisotropic Elastic Materials P . Chadwick and G. D.Smith
IV. V. VI. VII. VIII.
304 306 310 314 325 332 341 355 359 313 314
AUTHORINDEX SUBJECT INDEX
317 383
I. Introduction 11. Algebraic Preliminaries
111. Elasticity Tensors
The Fundamental Eigenvalue Problem Plane Elastostatics A Uniformly Moving Line Singularity Elastic Surface Waves. Basic Analysis The Uniqueness and Related Properties of Free Surface Waves IX. The Existence of Free Surface Waves X. Supplementary Topics References
List of Contributors
Numbers in parentheses indicate the pages on which the authors’ contributions begin.
P. CHADWICK, School of Mathematics and Physics, University of East Anglia, Norwich, England (303) The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland (189) J. L. ERICKSEN, C. S. Hsu, Department of Mechanical Engineering, University of California, Berkeley, California (245) ROBERTR. LONG, Department of Earth Sciences, The Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland (1)
T. FRANCIS OGILVIE,Department of Naval Architecture and Marine Engineering, The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, Michigan (91) G. D. SMITH, School of Mathematics and Physics, University of East Anglia, Norwich, England (303)
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Some Aspects of Turbulence in Geophysical Systems ROBERT R . LONG Department of Earth Sciences The Johns Hopkins University Baltimore. Maryland
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . A . The Nature of Turbulent Flows . . B. Dimensional Analysis . . . . . . C. Meaning of Symbol -, . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Introductory Concepts in Turbulence-Homogeneous Fluids . . . . A. Reynolds Stresses . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Turbulent Motion in Pipes and Channels . . . . . . . . . . C. Logarithmic Layer and Drag Coefficient . . . . . . . . . . . D. Eddy Viscosity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Some Basic Effects of Density Variations and Rotation . . . . . . A . Governing Equations for Fluids with Density Variations . . . . B. Available Potential Energy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Richardson Numbers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Thermal Convection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Double Diffusive Convection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Molecular and Turbulent Diffusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . G . Neglect of Rotation in the Surface Layer . . . . . . . . . . H . Some Properties of the Ekman Layer in the Atmosphere . . . . IV. Thermal Convection . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Similarity Theory of Convection and Comparison with Laboratory . . . . . Observations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Molecular Boundary Layers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Nusselt Number-Rayleigh Number Relation . . . . . . . . D . Buoyant Convection from an Isolated Source . . . . . . . . E. New Derivation of the Similarity Theory . . . . . . . . . F. Comparison of Theories of Thermal Convection . . . . . . G . Convection with Shear . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Turbulence in Stably Stratified Fluids . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Experiments without Shear . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Experiments with Shear . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Comparison of Experiments with and without Shear . . . . . D. Energy Arguments . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
2 2
. . . .
7 7
. .
9 16 19
. . . .
.
.
.
.
. . . . . .
4
6
. .
21 22 25 26 28 28 29 30 . 31
. .
33
. . . . . .
35 37 40 44 46
. . . . . .
. .
. . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . .
47 48 50
51 54 59 60
2
Robert R. Long E. Implications of Laboratory Experiments and Observations in the Atmosphere and Oceans . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . F. Eddy Viscosity and Eddy Diffusivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . G. Buoyancy Flux Due to Wake Collapse . . . . . . . . . . . . . VI. Third-Order Closure Schemes in Turbulence Research . . . . . . . . A. Mean Reynolds Stress Model of the Surface Layer of the Atmosphere . B. Ellison’s Derivation of a Critical Flux Richardson Number . . . . . C. Theory of a Mixed Layer of Finite Depth . . . . . . . . . . . . References. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
63 66 70 72 73 80 83 84
I. Introduction This paper discusses turbulence in geophysical systems, particularly atmospheric and oceanographic systems. None of the topics considered is treated exhaustively; rather the emphasis is on the author’s recent research efforts. The reader will need a knowledge of the theory of ideal and viscous fluids, but Section I1 gives a background discussion of turbulence in homogeneous and nonrotating fluids, so that a prior knowledge of turbulence theory is not required. Large-scale, quasihorizontal motions in oceans and atmosphere involve eddies with horizontal dimensions as large as or larger than lo8 cm, and these eddies are sometimes considered to be elements of a turbulent geophysical system. Eddies this large are strongly influenced by the rotation of the earth, however, and we do not consider rotation in this paper except insofar as it affects the properties of the planetary boundary layers in the atmosphere and oceans. This slighting of rotation is a major restriction, but much of the emphasis is on applications of laboratory investigations of turbulent systems in which density variations are of paramount importance but rotation effects are absent. The interpretations of these experimental measurements are often controversial, but they are nevertheless useful in acquiring the rudiments of an understanding of the dynamics of the lower layers of the atmosphere and the upper layers of lakes and oceans.
A. THENATURE OF TURBULENT FLOWS It is not usually difficult to make a decision as to whether a given flow is turbulent or not, but it is difficult to give a precise definition. All turbulent
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
3
flows, however, have three common characteristics (Tennekes and Lumley, 1972), namely, irregularity, dissipation, and rotationality. A random wave field on an ocean surface is irregular but it is nondissipative and irrotational and therefore nonturbulent. An internal wave field in a continuously stratified fluid may be irregular and rotational but it is not dissipative and is therefore also nonturbulent. Of course, if some of the waves break, turbulence exists locally because dissipation and vorticity appear in the turbulent patches. In saying that wave fields are nondissipative we are neglecting the dissipation arising from the viscous terms in the Navier-Stokes equations. Dissipation is always present in nonturbulent flows but is frequently very weak and for moderate time periods may be neglected. This weak dissipation is characterized by a small coefficient of molecular viscosity v (cm' sec-') which appears in the Navier-Stokes equations and which differs from fluid to fluid. The much larger dissipation of turbulent flows is characteristically independent of v despite the fact that turbulent flows are believed to satisfy the Navier-Stokes equations. In turbulence, therefore, the dissipation is related to the nature of the turbulent flow and not to the nature of the fluid. It is occasionally convenient, for example, to use the concept of an eddy viscosity, K , (cm' sec-I). Although K , has the same dimensions as v, it is usually many orders of magnitude larger and, most importantly, varies from one flow to another rather than one fluid to another. Turbulence is often associated with large values of the Reynolds number Re = UL/v where U is a characteristic velocity and L is a characteristic length. For example, in flow of water in a pipe, U may be the mean velocity along the axis and L may be the diameter. When Re is small (less than 2000 or so), the motion is laminar with velocity parallel to the walls, but above a threshold value of Re the motion is normally turbulent. In engineering problems it is customary to regard the size of the Reynolds number as the deciding criterion but other considerations become important in the flows of interest here in which density variations are important. For example, if a plate is heated, fluid above it will begin to move in a pattern of motion called conuection. Since there is no mean velocity, the Reynolds number is zero; nevertheless the resulting motion may be fully turbulent. Again, in the atmosphere and oceans there is usually a mean velocity and, because L is so large (of order of tens, hundreds, or thousands of meters), Re is normally very large, perhaps as high as 10". Nevertheless portions of these bodies of fluid may be in laminar motion (Businger and Arya, 1974) because the gravitational stability that normally exists may be sufficient to prevent the instabilities usually associated with high Reynolds numbers.
4
Robert R. Long
B. DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS Dimensional analysis is of the greatest importance in turbulence research to the extent that some of the most fundamental results in theories of turbulence follow from dimensional arguments. The use of dimensional quantities is also essential in interpreting experimental results because it is an economical way to express various dependences. The basic tool of dimensional analysis is the Pi theorem (Bridgman, 1931; Birkhoff, 1950) which states that if in a group of physical quantities, Ql, Qz ... Q,,, the largest number of quantities with independent dimensions is k, a mathematical relationship of the form f(Q1,Qz
... QJ = 0
(1.1)
may be expressed as a function
... %-k)
= 0,
(1.2) where the R’S are independent, nondimensional groups composed of products of the Q s raised to various powers. In the statement of the theorem a collection of quantities Q1,Qz ... are said to have independent dimensions if it is impossible to construct a nondimensional number composed of members of the collection. Results from dimensional reasoning are often limited by the appearance of so many dimensionless groups that little physical understanding can be obtained from a relationship of the form of Eq. (1.2). For example, consider a pendulum composed of a small spherical bob of radius a. The dependence of the period 7 on the gravitational acceleration g, on the length of the string Z, on the amplitude angle a, and on a may be written cp(”1,
722
7(g/l)1’z =f(a, a / / ) ,
(1.3) and in this form there is no simple dependence of 7 on the length l, for example. In many problems, however, one or more of the nondimensional numbers may be very large or very small (in the pendulum problem all and a may both be small) and it may be permissible to neglect a given number as it tends to zero or infinity. In the pendulum problem the concept of a “pointmass” as an idealization of a small body of material is so well established that we have little difficulty in deciding that in the limit as a l l 4 0 the relationship in (1.3) becomes
(1.4) This approximation permits us to increase our understanding of the problem. We may now conclude that the period is proportional to the square root of the length of the pendulum. z(g/l)”z
= h(a).
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
5
If, as is commonly the case, a is also small, we are tempted to conclude that h(a) in Eq. (1.4) is independent of a as a tends to zero, but without further information we cannot be sure that z remains finite as a -,0. It is conceivable, for example, that h(a) and, therefore, t are proportional to a as a+O. If we solve the problem, using the equations of motion and initial conditions and the approximation a << 1, we find that h(a)3 const, but in fluid mechanics and in turbulence problems especially, it is not usually possible to solve the equations of the problem even though it may often be possible to write down a set of equations, boundary conditions, and initial conditions that we may reasonably expect will uniquely determine the flow problem. In writing down these equations we should incorporate all reasonable approximations, such as 0: << 1 in the pendulum problem, in order to simplify as much as possible. When we do this, we may be able to infer the possibility of neglecting a nondimensional number that is small or large without the necessity of solving the mathematical problem. In the case of the pendulum, for example, if 8(t)is the angle of the pendulum at a given instant of time t, the problem for arbitrary a is determined by the equations
(d28/dt2)+ ( g / l ) sin 8 = 0, 8=a
8=0
att=O,
att=r/4.
(1.6)
Clearly t is a function of a and g/1 since these are the only constant quantities to appear in the complete formulation of the problem. Therefore ~(g//)'/~= h(a) as before. But if we assume a (and therefore 8) is small, sin 8 s 8. Defining t' = t(g/1)'l2, 8' = 8/a, we get the approximate formulation (d28'/dt'2)
8' = 1
at
2' = 0,
+ 8' = 0,
8' = 0
at
t' = t[(g/1)'/2/4].
(1.8)
Now a no longer appears in the statement of the problem and we conclude that z(g/l)1'2 = const. As applied to problems of turbulence, where Re is usually very large, if we could formulate a nondimensionalized set of equations and conditions that determine a given problem and, for Re 3 03, are independent of Re we could conclude that the phenomena in question do not depend on the Reynolds number. In fact we are not sure that this is possible, but in many cases an assumption that Re may be neglected leads to results that are reasonable and agree well with observation (Section 11). Another useful way of approaching the problem of approximation is again illustrated by the pendulum. In the statement of Eqs. (1.5) and (1.6), we may assign arbitrary dimensions to all quantities that enter, demand dimensional homogeneity, and then apply the Pi theorem. Thus, for arbitrary dimensions
Robert R . Long
6
A, B, C . .., we may write
[O] = A,
[t] = D,
[g/d = C ,
[a]= B,
[z]= E,
(1.9)
where the notation [0] = A reads “the dimension of 8 is A.” Requiring dimensional homogeneity in (1.5) and (1.6), we find the O and a must be dimensionless and C = D-’,E = D,i.e., [g/1]= D-2,
[T] = D.
Applying the Pi theorem to the relationship
7
= f ( g / ~a), , we get
7(g/l)”’ = h(a)
as before. On the other hand, if we formulate the problem incorporating the approximation a << 1 (and, therefore, 8 << l), we get sin 8 z 8 and (d’O/dt’) O=a
+ (g/1)O = 0,
att=O,
att=7/4
0=0
The same procedure leads to
[0]= A ,
[a]= A,
[g/q
= 0-’, [t] = D,
[z] = D.
Now there are two dimensions, A and D, and the Pi theorem yields for 7 =f(s/La) ~(g/1)”’ = const as before. Other examples of the latter approach are discussed by Long (1964). We refer to this technique later as generalized dimensional analysis.
-
C. MEANINGOF SYMBOL
-
In most problems there are nondimensional parameters that are large or small, e.g., Re or Re-’. The symbol denotes the order of magnitude of a quantity as the parameter in question goes to zero or infinity. For example, if we say A B and the only small or large parameter is Re, we mean that
-
as Re-co,
A/B-+K
where K is neither zero nor infinity.+Thus K is independent of the particular parameter involved, but if other nondimensional parameters are important, K may be a function of these. Notice that A B implies A / B 1 but this does not imply that K is one, or even close to it, although in cases where we lack any information on the size of K we ordinarily guess that it is about one. An example is the problem of the pendulum. We say 7 (l/g)’” as
-
-
-
This differs from the definition of used by Tennekes and Lumley (1972, p. xii), for example. They require that K lies between f and 5 ! +
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
7
a + 0 because 7/(Z/g)1’2 -+
K
as a -+ 0.
Exact analysis indicates that K = 2n. 11. Introductory Concepts in Turbulence-Homogeneom Fluids
A. REYNOLDSSTRESSES We begin by reviewing the derivation of the equations of motion of a continuum in terms of stress components zij. We erect a rectangular parallelepiped with sides in the coordinate planes and compute all the forces acting on the element at an instant of time t . We first definet stress components: 7ij ij is the stress force per unit area exerted across a face whose normal is ii on the material pierced by - ii by the material pierced by ii . By the law of action and reaction - 7ij ij is the stress force per unit area exerted by material pierced by - ii on the material pierced by ii . For example, the force per unit area across the face in the x 2 x3 plane on the material in the element is - (zl i , + 71 i, + 2 1 3 i3). The normal component of this force, - 71 is called pressure; 71 is tension. We may calculate all forces on the element in the direction i, and so obtain the equations of motion,
,
+
p(du,/dt) = p x , (d7ij/axi), (2.1) where uj are velocity components and X j are components of the body force. We may show that 7ij = zji (Long, 1961) so that there are 3 equations in 9 unknowns, u j , and the 6 unknown stresses. In addition to the equations in (2.1), we use the continuity equation for an incompressible fluid
auilaxi= 0.
(2.2) This is an excellent approximation for water and a very good one for the atmosphere if we confine attention to phenomena of a small scale, say, hundreds of meters (Monin and Yaglom, 1971, Chapter 4). (See also Section I11 of the present paper.) The problem of indeterminacy of Eqs. (2.1) and (2.2) is overcome by the assumption 7‘.J . =
’
- p & .t J
+ &&.. 13 ’
(2.3)
We use the summation convention that a double subscript means addition over this subscript.
8
Robert R. Long
where p is the pressure, dij is the Kronecker delta, p is the dynamic coefficient of viscosity, and cij is the rate-of-strain tensor,
+ (au,/ax,)].
Eij = 4[(aui/axj)
(2.4) This assumption defines a Newtonianjluid and we are assured by experiments that it is very accurate for laminar flows at least. Our equations are now (2.2) and
+
+
p(duj/dt) = - ( a p / d ~ j ) p X j ( a / d ~ i ) ( 2 p ~ i j ) . (2.5) These are called the Navier-Stokes equations. The viscosity p has a value of 0.00018 gm/cm sec for air at atmospheric pressure and 0.01 1 gm/cm sec for gm/cm3 for air and 1 gm/cm3 for water. If we take for density 1.2 x water, the kinematic coefficient of viscosity, v = p/p, is 0.15 cm2/sec for air and 0.01 1 cm2/sec for water. We ignore the small variations of v or p. The external force X j is usually gravity, - g d j 3 , where the X 3 axis is vertical; g may be taken to be a constant equal to 981 cm/sec2 in engineering and geophysical problems. As we have observed in Section I, fluids are generally capable of two distinct types of motion, well illustrated in the familiar flow of water in a pipe (Reynolds, 1895). Dimensional considerations indicate that the nature of the flow is governed by the Reynolds number Re = uo R/v, where u,, is the mean velocity at the center of the pipe and R is the radius of the pipe. Observations confirm the importance of Re. When Re is small, of the order of lo00 or less, the fluid moves steadily parallel to the walls of the pipe in sheets or layers (laminae) with a parabolic velocity distribution as in Fig. 1.
FIG. 1. Flow in a pipe.
This laminar motion changes to highly irregular turbulent motion at a critical value of Re which varies, however, with the entrance conditions and the level of the disturbances in the entering fluid. In turbulence it is convenient to consider a dependent variable such as ui or p, to be represented as a sum of a mean and a fluctuating part, u.1 = a.I + u!I )
P=B+P’, where the overbar denotes an average and where 4 = 0 by definition.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
9
There is one preferred idealized scheme of averaging in turbulence theory and several practical methods. The theoretical average is an ensemble auerage. For example, if we imagine that a turbulence experiment is started up at t = 0 from a state of rest, the ensemble average velocity u at a point (x, y , z) at a later time t, i.e., @(x,y, z, t ) is the velocity at that point averaged over an infinite number of experiments all identical and started from rest, where the measurements at the point (x, y , z) are made exactly t sec after the start. Obviously this is impractical. If the experiment is in a statistically steady state, U = U(x, y , z), and we may average the velocity at the point (x, y , z) over a long period of time. If the experiment is horizontally homogeneous, say, in the x direction, we may average over some portion of the x axis. Either of these is quite satisfactory if performed carefully, although it cannot usually be proved that time and space means converge to ensemble means and an “ergodic hypothesis” (Monin and Yaglom, 1971, p. 216) must be invoked. We need not be concerned with such matters. In the remainder of this section, we consider that the fluid has a constant, uniform density. Substituting into Eq. (2.5), using Eq. (2.2) and averaging, we get
aui - = 0, axi
(2
+ axj
p -++.1 = _ _ ap p x j ) ; : :1
a ( 2 M j - pu:). + axi -
The equations are identical in form to the original equations (2.2) and (2.5) except for the appearance of additional stresses, - pu: uJ called Reynolds stresses. Although the form is similar, notice that we have no information analogous to Eq. (2.3) relating the Reynolds stresses to any other quantities. They are new unknowns and so the problem of turbulence is underdetermined. The situation is the same as that encountered in an effort to deal with Eqs. (2.1) without resort to the stress-rate-of-strain law of Eq. (2.3). The indeterminancy is called the “closure” problem of turbulence. An excellent summary of the various techniques for closing the problem has been given by Reynolds (1976).
B. TURBULENT MOTIONIN PIPES AND CHANNELS Turbulent flows in a pipe or channel or, say, turbulent plane Couette flow between parallel moving planes (Robertson, 1959; Fig. 2), are simple
Robert R . Long
10
/ / / / / / / / / / / / / / - // / / / / 1 UO
x-
UO 4
//-// / / / / / / / / / / / / / / /
FIG.2. Turbulent plane Couette flow.
examples of turbulent motion, and we can gain much insight by considering the theory and observations of these flows. Let us consider plane Couette flow in detail. If we assume a large aspect ratio (width divided by depth of flow), we may neglect variations of any mean quantity in the spanwise direction. We also assume no variation of mean quantities with x or t. The equations become aul
aul
au/
aut
-+((H+u‘)-+v’-+w‘-++’(H at ax ay aZ
=
1 apt ---+
ax
VV2U’ + viiz,, (2.6a)
auf au’ + u’-auf + w’- + (ii + u’)-
aul
at
aZ
ay
ax
1a
= - --
p
p + vV’U‘,
ay
(2.6b)
+ + awl = 0, ax ay aZ
aUI
aUi
-
-
-
where z i z is the derivative of ti. The no-slip boundary conditions are: At z = H/2
At z
=
-H/2
U‘ = U‘ = W‘ = 0
u‘ = U’ = W‘ = 0
ii=uo, =
(2.8)
-uo.
(2-9) In this problem, as in all homogeneous flows, we may absorb gravity in the definition of mod$ed pressure P , P =p
+ pgz + P o ,
(2.10)
where Po is a constant, so that dP/ax, replaces dp/dx, in the equations of motion and gravity g no longer appears. If g is also absent in the boundary and initial conditions, it is apparent that gravity can have no effect on the flow. Using Eqs. (2.7) and averaging Eqs. (2.6a,b,c), we obtain
(a/&)( - ulwl+
vil,)= o
(2.11)
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
11
a(wlu.)/az = o
(2.12)
(a/az)(P/lp+ 77) =0
(2.13)
-m
The Reynolds stress is especially important. The fluid is in general motion along the x axis with velocity increasing upward and, as a particle from above moves downward (w’ < 0), it will tend to conserve its x momentum. When it arrives below (Fig. 3), therefore, it will have an excess of
FIG.3. An eddy.
momentum compared to its environment so that in thenew position, w’ < 0 and N’ > 0,and there is a negative contribution to u’w’.As a particle rises (w‘ > 0), we would anticipate u’ .c 0 and again UIW) tends to be negative. If we define a correlation coefJicient __
c,, = Urw‘/6,6,,
(2.14)
where 6,and cr, are root mean squares of u’ and w’, e.g., 02 = p, our results imply a nonzero correlation between u’ and w’ because of the mean shear. Since there is no mean shear in the spanwise direction, it is clear that w’u‘ = 0. According to Eq. (2.11),the total stress ~
__
-dW‘
(2.15)
f Va, =T
is a constant in the flow. It is sometimes denoted by u: = T where u* is called the friction velocity. Obviously u)wI is zero at the walls where u’ and w‘ are zero so that T = ~ ( i i , )where ~, is the shear at the wall. As we have indicated, the viscosity coefficients are usually very small in the sense that the Reynolds number UL/v is large, where L is some appropriate length scale. For example, in the atmosphere U E lo3 cm/sec, L 1 lo6 cm, v s 0.15 cm2/sec, so Re 2 10”. Even in a pipe, a speed of 30 cm/sec yields Re z 30,000 or so. Thus, a nonzero value of constancy of the sum T = vU2 - UIW), and equality of z and v q at the wall imply a very large value of a2at the walls compared to ti2in the interior. We have already
m,
12
Robert R. Long
illustrated this in Fig. 2. We expect then to find a thin layer near the wall called the viscous boundary layer where viiz is an important part of the stress, and a large region in the interior where vii, is negligible and z r - u'w' in the layer except just at the wall. This is not surprising because one would expect that although the Reynolds number is large in the interior of the flow as a whole, the ,Reynolds number based on local velocities and lengths should be of order one in the viscous layer, i.e.,+ ii6,/v
- 1,
(2.16)
where 6, is the thickness of the layer. Since the Reynolds number is of the order of the ratio of acceleration to viscous force, this implies that viscous and inertia forces are of the same order, i.e., for example, vuu/6,2
-
a:/6,.
-
(2.17)
This also follows from (2.11) and (2.16) if we assume that ii uuin this layer. It is instructive to form the energy equation, but also important to present for discussion some intermediate steps. Let us multiply Eqs. (2.6)by u', u', w' and then average. Using (2.7), we get
The sum of these equations yields the equation for the kinetic energy of the disturbance
a -
(
'd) : z - l
-(T)=- - w' T'+at
aZ a[
-v-(T)
-U'W'U,-E,
__
(2.21)
where E is a positive quantity,
+ (67)' + (vw')2], is the disturbance kinetic energy, (uf2+ u" + w")/2. E =
v[(p.')'
(2.22)
and There are a number of points to be discussed. One is related to the dissipationfunction E. Turbulence is in general to be considered as composed of random motions on a large number of length scales. Those which are +
From now on we take a coordinate system with the lower plate at rest.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
13
found to contain most of the energy have, generally, dimensions that are proportional to the size of the container, e.g., to H in plane Couette flow or to the diameter of the pipe in pipe flow. A quantitative measure of the size of the energy-containing eddies is the integral length scale 1. This may be defined by *
u‘(x, y , z)u’(O, y , Z) dx
l=J, --
(2.23)
0,’
Notice that when turbulence is homogeneous along the x axis, the integrand varies only with the separation so that 1 is independent of x. Equation (2.23) defines a length over which velocities at two points bear some relationship to each other (Fig. 4). The length 1 is proportional to the size of the container,
I
lntegrond
-1-4 I
2
3
4
x , crn
FIG.4. Integral length scale.
although numerically generally considerably smaller. In a pipe of diameter D (Hinze, 1959) the length scale along the axis is about 0.5D while the length scales in the transverse directions are 0.20 - 0.30. Thus the eddies are elongated along the pipe axis. For later purposes we will assume D z 31. There is a decreasing amount of energy in smaller and smaller scales. The __ to originate from the mean-flow energy through the action energy is known of the term - u’w’usin Eq. (2.21).It goes first to the largest scales of motion and this is passed down to smaller and smaller scales by nonlinear interactions, i.e., by virtue of the action of the nonlinear inertia terms. This cascade of energy is opposed by the viscous forces which tend to smooth the velocity field, but these forces, which depend on velocity gradients, are very small for large eddies because v is very small and because gradients associated with large eddies are not large. The viscous forces are negligible unless operating on such small eddies that the viscous forces can be effective. Thus the dissipation term E , involving derivatives, is due to the very small eddies. This brings out one important property. The large eddies in a shearing flow are oriented in preferred ways by the presence of the shear. In the cascade
14
Robert R. Long
process, the smaller eddies lose contact with the mean flow and tend to take on random orientations so that all averages become independent of rotations or reflections of the coordinate system. The small eddies are therefore ’)~ isotropic. Isotropy at small scales is called local isotropy. Thus ~ ( V U = _ _ _ _ _ ~ ( V U= ’ )~~( V W = ’ )~~/ 3in (2.18)-(2.20). We may better appreciate the role of small eddies in the dissipation process by imagining for the moment that there are only two eddies, very different in size so that the velocity may be expressed as u = A sin(x/l)
+ B sin(nx/l),
where n is large. The magnitude of the derivative is au/ax
All
or
Bn/l.
We see that we can have small eddies with very little energy compared to the big eddies, i.e., B << A, but such that the derivative is dominated by the small eddies, i.e., Bn >> A. The smallest scales of motion adjust to the size of the viscosity v. If v decreases, the scale must decrease so as to permit the existence of eddies which can dissipate the energy. Evidently the length, time, and velocity scales q, T, u for these eddies will depend on E and v only. Dimensional analysis yields
,,
= v3/4/E1/4
= v1/2/E1/2,
= v1/4E1/4.
These are called Kolmogorou scales. Notice that the Reynolds number for this scale of motion is precisely one. As we have discussed, the length scale decreases as v decreases. On the basis of the cascade argument, the energy dissipation proceeds at a rate dictated by the action of the large eddies and is in no way related to v . The role of v is simply to dictate the size of the eddies that do the dissipating. Therefore E must be a function of the characteristics of the energy-containing eddies. These have a time scale of l/oUso that the rate of change of kinetic energy should be E o,2/(l/ou) .,”/I. This result is fundamental in turbulence research and asserts that the dissipation time is the time for one rotation of the eddy, so that the system is highly dissipative. The large eddies do not lose much energy to friction. Their dissipation rate is N vo,2/12which is only a fraction,
-
-
of the total dissipation rate. The term -u’w’uz in Eqs. (2.18) and (2.21)an energy source term. In plane Couette flow, we have decided that u‘w’ is negative. Since ii, > 0, ~
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
15
__
- u'w'u, is positive and represents ageneration of disturbance kinetic energy at the expense of the mean shear. We may see this by considering the effect of thoroughly mixing a patch of fluid of dimensions L (Fig. 5). The energy before mixing is
2
L5a2 6
...
After mixing, the whole fluid is moving at the speed of the center of mass and the mean energy is a2L?/8. The difference, a2L5/24,is available for the kinetic energy of the disturbances. b
-1
/
/
FIG.5. Mixing in shear flow.
An important observation is that the energy-production term directly supplies energy to the longitudinal component of the velocity. The other components must get energy in some other way, namely, through the action of the pressure terms in Eqs. (2.18)-(2.20). We see that these all cancel out and tend to increase, when Eqs. (2.18)-(2.20) are added. Since P du'ldy and P' dw'/dz must be positive while P' du'/dx' is negative. The pressure terms tend to produce isotropy of the motion without, however, ever succeeding. The observed situation is roughly cr,,, z 0.55a,, 6,= 0.70au, so that the component retains the largest proportion of the energy (Zeman and Tennekes, 1975). The term d[w'(T' + P'/p)]/dz in Eq. (2.21) is called an energy transport term or energy-flux divergence. If we integrate from one plate to the other in plane Couette flow, w' is zero at both surfaces so this term vanishes. Thus it can only serve to transport energy from one place to the other. The size of the term is of order Co;/l, where C is a correlation coefficient. Here we have used the fact that the scale of the mean motion H is the same as the eddy scale 1. Since C may well be of order one, this term may be of local importance of the same order as the dissipation term.
16
Robert R. Long
The final term a/az(v d T / a z ) is called the viscous transport term. It is of order vo,2/12,which is small compared to o:/1.
C. LOGARITHMIC LAYERAND DRAGCOEFFICIENT We may now estimate the production term in the energy equation. Since it must balance the dissipation term over the whole flow, its order must also be o:/H in the fluid as a whole. We assume, therefore, that u: ii, o:/H in the main portions of the fluid. Since c,, u * , we have
-
-
Integrating, we get
where uo is the constant of integration and is taken to be the mean velocity at the centerline. Obviously, if we had included Re in x, the result would have been valid over the entire flow right down to the wall. Since we omit Re, we must certainly not expect that the resulting expression will be valid near the wall because of the presence there of the viscous layer. It is reasonable, however, to suppose that Eq. (2.24) is an accurate description of the velocity defect in the main body of the fluid. Obviously x 1 so i i - uo u* as Re -+ 00. The velocity-defect law has been tested by experiment and found to be quite accurate (Laufer, 1954). It is an example in fluid mechanics of an outer solution of the Navier-Stokes equations independent of the viscosity. This independence occurs often and is an example of Reynolds number similarity. Equation (2.24) cannot apply all the way to the wall but if Re + co,it is likely to apply arbitrarily close to the wall. Let us consider the solution very near the wall. Here viscosity is important. If we argue from the energy equation that u’w’u, and E are of the same order and that the integral scale is of order z in this layer, then tiz o,/z u,/z. This implies ii u* and therefore the “law of the wall,”
-
-
- -
-
ii/u* = f ( u * z / v ) .
(2.25)
A fundamental result now follows from reasoning of Izakson (1937) and Millikan (1939) who asserted that there will be an overlap region in which both (2.24) and (2.25) hold simultaneously as Re + 00. We may consider
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
17
FIG.6. Regions of validity of inner and outer solutions.
Fig. 6 in which we portray, for a given Re = u, H / v , two regions in which the inner and outer solutions are separately valid. In the general case, of course, we must add the argument Re to the two functions. Obviously the outer and inner solutions depend for their validity on the size of Re. As Re goes to infinity (say, H -+ 00) the influence of H (and therefore Re) at a given z should become negligible in the function f so that the region of validity for the inner solution must eventually increase to include the point z in question as Re -+ 00. Thus an overlap region will exist. Since uo/u* is a constant, it must be a function of Re-' = v/Hu, = q so that in the overlap region
f(t)- m(v) = -x(td, = u*z/v,
q = v/Hu, ,
uo/u* = m(q).
(2.26)
This puts severe restrictions on the forms of these functions. Thus, differentiating with respect to t and q and eliminating x, we get
f't = -m'q,
(2.27)
and since t,~and 5 are independent, each side of Eq. (2.27) is equal to a constant, say, 1 / ~ i.e., ,
f = ( 1 / ~ )In
t + A,
m = ( 1 / ~In ) Re
+ E,
(2.28)
where A, E, and K are universal constants. Let us examine the first function. Since u* and v are constants, we have in the overlap region ii/u, = ( 1 / ~In ) z
+ const.
(2.29)
This is the famous log law for turbulent flow over a surface, derived originally by von Karman (1930) and Prandtl (1932). Obviously it cannot hold down to the surface itself and we have seen that it does not hold far from the surface. It has been verified as accurate just above the viscous layer, i.e., for
18
Robert R. Long
v/u, << z << H, in countless experiments (Tennekesand Lumley, 1972, p. 162) and in the lower layers of the atmosphere (Priestley, 1959, p. 20). When z v/u, ,we are in the viscous layer which joins the log layer to the wall. In this layer the velocity profile is linear. The actual observations show a transition from the linear profile to the log profile between values of zu* /v of 5 and 30, i.e., the log layer begins at zu*/v E 30. From (2.28) we get
-
uo/u* = ( 1 / ~ In )
Re + B.
This is called the logarithmicfriction law. Tennekes (1968) has argued that K is a constant only in the sense Re + CQ. His theory leads to an estimate for large Reynolds number of 0.33 instead of the commonly accepted values of 0.40-0.42 in the pipe flow. He claims support from atmospheric measurements of Businger et al. (1971) but more recent measurements by Pruitt et al. (1973) using a very large dragplate lysimeter to measure the stress strongly suggest the same range 0.40-0.42 in the atmosphere too. In geophysics, for example, airflow over the ground, we are concerned with rough surfaces over which v is irrelevant everywhere because no thin viscous boundary layer exists. The drag originates instead from the form drag due to eddies in the lee of the roughness elements. One then argues that some measure of the roughness, say, a roughness length zo ,appears instead of v or, more precisely, instead of v/u, . The analysis is identical and we get @/U*
uo/u* =
=(l/K)
Wzo),
- ( 1 / ~ In(z,/H) )
+ B,
(2.30) (2.31)
where we define zo so that no constant of integration appears in (2.30). In effect then, zo is the height at which the velocity would vanish if the log layer held down to this level (it does not). Experiment in sand-roughened pipes indicates that zo s ( 1/30)h0 where h, is the average height of the roughness. In the atmosphere, the ratio varies somewhat depending on the nature of the roughnesses but is in the range 1/7-1/30 (Plate, 1971, p. 27). The log law may also be derived by dimensional arguments and in a more general case of shearing flow near a surface, say, flow in a pipe. In this case the stress is not a constant but varies across the flow. One argues, however, that in a layer, v/u, << z << H, the only quantities on which, say, u; can depend is u* and z, where u: is the stress at the surface. Then we must have ziiz/u* = const = l / ~ .
(2.32)
Integration leads to the log law. We may apply this to other quantities, for example, cr,/u* = const
E
= const x (u:/z),
(2.33)
19
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
+ P’Jp) = const. 4
w’( T’
(2.34)
The last reveals that the energy-flux divergence term in the energy equation (2.21) is zero. This is often used to justify neglect of this term in other situations and other regions but this is incautious. Some numbers for the surface layer may be obtained by averaging a number of experiments (Zeman and Tennekes, 1975) CT,
z 2.0u,
CT”
z 1.4u,
ow z
l.lu*.
The u component is largest because the turbulence production is in the x component directly. D. EDDY VISCOSITY
In shearing flows and in many other situations, it is often advantageous to introduce the concept of eddy viscosity K, . We may, for example, define K, by the equation (2.35)
z = K , diiJdz
by analogy with 7 =
(2.36)
v duJdz
for laminar parallel shearing flow. In a turbulent region, z will be almost equal to so that K, u* I, where we assume diildz u* 11. This is in accordance with the analogy since molecular viscosity is of the order of the speed of the molecules times the mean free path and therefore eddy viscosity is of the order of the eddy speed times the size of the eddies. A physical interpretation is sometimes made that K, is of the order of the speed of translation of the eddy times the mixing length, i.e., the distance the eddy moves before it is tom apart or dies out. These, of course, are very closely related because mixing length is obviously of the order of the eddy size. The eddy viscosity in the logarithmic layer is
-m
-
-
(2.37) It may be found by measurement in the rest of the flow in a pipe. There is agreement with (2.37) near the walls but the measured K , / u , R has a maximum of 0.08 about half-way in toward the center of the pipe (Nikuradse, 1932). We see a great difference between eddy viscosity and molecular viscosity in that v is constant but K , varies in space and time. More specifically v is a
Robert R. Long
20
property of the fluid whereas K, is a property of the pow. For engineering purposes K , is often assumed to be constant even when it is obvious that it is not. In some cases this assumption works well, namely, turbulent flow in a jet, wake or mixing layer (layer between two parallel streams of different mean velocity). In a turbulent jet (Fig. 7), for example, the mean motion over most of the core region is well predicted by a constant eddy viscosity model. When rigid surfaces exist, however, turbulent velocities tend to zero and eddy sizes tend to zero near the boundaries so that K, tends to zero at the boundaries and cannot be considered constant.
FIG.7. Turbulent jet.
Notice also the fact that eddy viscosity is almost always many orders of magnitude greater than molecular viscosity. The ratio is K,/v
- ciul/v - Re,
i.e., of the order of the Reynolds number. Even in small laboratory experiments, this will be 100 or larger. there is a possibility that t and dii/dz are of different Since t z --, signs, thereby making K , negative. Observation indicates that this happens only in small regions in shearing flow (Schwartz and Cosart, 1961) although negative viscosity may be more common in more complicated situations. It is interesting that the velocity-defect law (2.24) leads to a Reynolds number Re, 1, where Re, is based on the velocity difference across the interior region, the linear dimension of the region, and the coefficient of turbulent viscosity, i.e.,
-
Re,
- AuHIK, -
u* Hlu,
H
-
1.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
21
111. Some Basic Effects of Density Variations and Rotation
There is great interest among geophysicists and engineers in fluid systems with density variations. These are typical of the atmosphere, seas, lakes, and reservoirs, and even when the variations are exceedingly small, they are almost always exceedingly important. In some cases, for example, in the air above the warmed surface of the earth, there may be a layer in which the average density increases with height, i.e., the fluid is unstably stratified (Fig. 8). Then, there is a strong tendency for light parcels of fluid near the ground to rise and heavier parcels to descend in a type of motion called thermal convection. The heating is sufficiently strong to maintain the average density increase with height close to the ground, but at some distance above the ground the mean density increase becomes very weak or may even be replaced by a density decrease with height (Gille, 1967, p. 380; Townsend, 1976, p. 385). In the layer of density increase with height, the motion may
FIG.8. Unstable density field.
have a regular cellular pattern in the form of Benard cells (Benard, 1901). More usually, especially in geophysical situations, the motion is turbulent or irregular, characterized by plumes or thermals. Layers with mean density increase with height are rather rare in the atmosphere and in oceans and lakes. In addition to the thin surface layer above the heated ground, unstable layers occur in water near the water-air interface when the water is losing heat (e.g., by nocturnal cooling or evaporational cooling or when there is overriding cold air). Such layers may also occur near the ocean bottom in regions of formation of bottom water (Turner, 1973, p. 313). Usually, however the mean density decreases (stably stratified) or is uniform with height. If a turbulent fluid has a mean vertical density gradient, turbulence will tend to reduce this density variation. As a simple example of this process, we can imagine a vessel filled with water with a stable temperature stratification-warm near the top becoming colder with depth. If we now
Robert R . Long
22
induce turbulence by stirring mechanically, the density gradient will ultimately be wiped out. If, on the other hand, the fluid is initially unstably stratified-cold above and warm below--convection will set in automatically and the density gradient will again be eliminated. In the first case the warmth near the top is transported downward; in the second case, the warmth near the bottom is transported upward. Thus there is nearly always a flux ofheat from warm regions to colder regions. A. GOVERNING EQUATIONS FOR FLUIDS WITH DENSITY VARIATIONS
Let us now write down the governing equations for the fluid systems considered in these notes. For a liquid’ such as water in which the density variation is linearly related to temperature, for example, a reasonably accurate set of equations is dv/dt = - ( l / p ) V p- gk
dpldt
+ vV’V,
= khV2p,
(3.3) where v is the velocity vector and kh is the coefficient of heat conduction. We have neglected the rotation of the earth although this will be important for larger scale phenomena (Monin and Yaglom, 1971, p. 406;Section 111,G). In geophysical problems, p varies rather little and it is convenient to define a quantity called buoyancy b: b = ( P - PO)S/PO (3.4) where p o is some representative density, often taken to be p o = 1 gm/cm3 in the case of water. Under the assumption that (p - p o ) / p o << 1, we may neglect the difference between po and p everywhere in the equations except in the gravity-force term and obtain 9
dv/dt = - (l/po)VP - bk v*v=o,
+ vV’V,
(3.5)
(3.6)
dbldt = khV2b, (3.7) where P = p + p o gz + const. The approximation we have made is called the Boussinesq approximation (Boussinesq, 1903). Physically, in making this
’
We do not give a separate discussion for the compressible atmosphere. In the lowest few hundred feet, the same equations are valid if we use for the density p in a liquid the potential density in the gas (Yih, 1965, p. 16).The latter is the density ofa parcel of air when its pressure is changed adiabatically to a reference pressure, usually taken to be lo6 dyne/cm2.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
23
approximation we have taken into account the tendency for a parcel light or heavier than its environment to rise or fall under the influence of gravity [since we do not assume g(p - po)/po is small compared to dwldt], but we have neglected all other effects of density variation, such as, for example, the small excess of momentum pv - p o v of a parcel because its density is p and not po . In natural circumstames this approximation is excellent in water where, for example, temperature variations cause density differences of order of & of 1%. It is also quite good in the lower atmosphere (Monin and Yaglom, 1971, p. 412). There are some delicate points in a careful derivation of the Boussinesq approximation, especially as applied to compressible fluids. These are considered carefully by Spiegel and Veronis (1960). In some special problems certain phenomena of interest may be lost by making the approximation (Long, 1965), but this does not affect the subject of this paper. Our treatment of the governing equations is very brief and the reader is referred to more careful discussions of the equations by Phillips (1966, pp. 8-19), Monin and Yaglom (1971, pp. 421-425), and Turner (1973, pp. 3-13). In the sea, density variations are caused by both temperature and salinity. We assume a linear relationship, p = po( 1 - a T PS) and we use the following form of the Boussinesq equations:
+
dv/dt = - ( l / p o ) V P
+ (gaT - gPS)k + vV’V,
(3.8a)
d T / d t = khV2T,
(3.8b)
dS/dt = k,V2S,
(3.8~)
v.v=o,
(3.8d)
where T is temperature and S is salinity and where the representative density p are positive known constants, k, is the molecular coefficient of salt diffusivity and is much smaller than kh(kh/ksz 1 0 ) . Notice that even when density variations are due to both heat and salt, if we can neglect molecular processes, we may use the simpler set in Eqs. (3.5)-(3.7) in terms of buoyancy b = g(pS - a T ) after setting the diffusion terms vV2v and k h V 2 b in Eqs. (3.5) and (3.7) equal to zero (but see Section 111,E). In parallel flows of homogeneous fluids, we saw that momentum flux T plays a very important role. When the mean density varies vertically in such flows, a parallel concept is that of buoyancy flux, q = kh b, - w”. The conditions of horizontal homogeneity and statistical steady state then insure that both T and q are constants in space and time. Of course, except near boundaries, q will be very nearly equal to - w” and the flux of heat and salt will be due primarily to the turbulent eddies. po is taken to be the density when T = S = 0; the quantities a and
24
Robert R. Long
The energy equation for this simple flow is the same as for a homogeneous fluid except for a term -w" added to Eq. (2.21). We have
a In addition, if we multiply the perturbation buoyancy equation by b and average, we obtain the equation for buoyancy fluctuations,
where N = kh (Vb')Z is the (positive) dissipation function for buoyancy fluctuations, analogous to E in the energy equation. Obviously, N is also __ to the action of very small eddies. attributable w'b has a sign controlled by the correlation between vertical velocity and perturbation buoyancy in rising and falling parcels of fluid. If the mean density increases with height, as in turbulent thermal convection, rising parcels (w' > 0) are associated with lower density (b'< 0) and sinking parcels with higher density so that q = -w" is positive. Then Eq. (3.9) shows that this effect is a source of kinetic energy helping to drive the motion. The correlation coefficient is of order one. [Deardorff and Willis (1967) measured values around 0.5 and 0.6.1 When the mean stratification is stable, q will have the opposite sign as rising parcels tend to be cool and falling parcels warm. One must be careful in the stable case, however, because of the possibility of wave motions contributing to w' and p'. Thus, if the fluid is at rest and stably stratified, it is capable of internal gravity-wave motion in which the basically level density surfaces move up and down in waves. Obviously, if the waves d o not break, there will be no rupture of these surfaces and therefore, neglecting molecular conduction, no flux of heat or buoyancy despite sizable values of w' and b'. The correlation coefficient will be zero. If the waves break, there will be intermittent turbulence superimposed on the wave motion and q will be negative, although the correlation coefficient may be much less than one. Negative 4 means that the kinetic energy tends to decrease. This is because it requires work to lift heavy parcels up and bring light parcels down. There is a tendency in doing this to increase potential energy at the expense of kinetic energy so that some of the other terms in Eq. (3.9)must be energy-producing if turbulence energy is to increase o r be maintained. The term - w'b'b, in Eq. (3.10) is almost always positive, as we have seen, so that this generates buoyancy fluctuations. The first term on the righthand side of Eq. (3.10) is a transport term, analogous to the energy flux divergence in the energy equation. ~
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
25
B. AVAILABLE POTENTIAL ENERGY It is useful to define available potential energy per unit mass (Long, 1970) by considering it to be the kinetic energy per unit mass attained by a parcel of buoyancy b = b' + b(z)as it falls from the height z to the height c at which its buoyancy b is equal to the mean buoyancy b(c) at that level. We have b' = 6([)- 5(z)= - b z 5 approximately, where 5 = z - [ and we have assumed that 5 is small compared with the length scale of the vertical variation of mean buoyancy.? Neglecting disturbance pressure, we may then write dwldr = d2{/dt2= - b
= 6,5
(3.11)
because [ is a Lagrangian quantity, so that d[/dr = 0. Integrating, we get ( w 2 / 2 )- (b,t2/2)= const.
(3.12)
Thus available potential energy may be defined as
V' = - b;t2/2
or
V
= b'2.
(3.13)
We may also identify 4 with potential energy changes. The potential energy of a particle of volume Vo and density p is pgVo z. Let us now define incremental potential energy as pgVo z - p o gVo z so that this potential energy is zero when the particle has the characteristic density p o . If we let V represent the incremental potential energy per unit mass, then, to within the Boussinesq approximation, V = bz. Since b is nearly conservative, putting b = b' + b and assuming no mean vertical velocity, we have ~-
dV/dt
= w'b' =
-4
(3.14)
is the average rate of increase of incremental potential energy per unit mass. We may identify this with available potential energy by differentiating (3.13) and again assuming dbldt = 0. We get dV'/dt = * b d{/dr - $t d6,dt
= iw'b' - *5bzw' = w ' b
(3.15)
so that _ _ _ _ _
dV'/dt = w ' b = - q .
(3.16)
Comparing (3.14) and (3.16), we see that the average rate of increase of incremental potential energy and the average rate of increase of available potential energy are the same. In application, we can conceive of an energy-containing eddy in the form of a whirl with horizontal axis of rotation, with velocity 8,and diameter 1. It 'This may not always. or even usually, be the case but our development here is only suggestive of the definition of Eq. (3.13).
26
Robert R. Long
-
-
will lift parcels from their level of origin a distance 5 1 so that V‘ abI, where b b is the rms buoyancy fluctuation. If the turbulence is not decaying, the kinetic energy must be of this order or larger so that abl/a%I1. In a fully turbulent layer, 1 is of the order of the depth D of the layer.+Thuj we see that if D increases and owis maintained, the layer must become more and more homogeneous. A useful alternative expression for the ratio of available potential energy to kinetic energy is obtained by using b‘ = - 6,5 to eliminate 5 in the expression for V‘. We get R = a;/6,0$.
(3.17)
C. RICHARDSON NUMBERS In most literature on turbulence in stratified fluids (Proudman, 1953, p. 101; Phillips, 1966, p. 201) the role of the energy flux divergence term in Eq. (3.9) is treated rather casually. Typically, the arguments neglect the energy flux divergence and in stable conditions the only energy source term is then - u’w’uz.It is then stated that the sink term q must not exceed the source term if the turbulence is maintained so that ~
14
I /tiiz= Rf < 1,
(3.18)
since E is positive and nonzero. Rf is called thepux Richardson number. In addition, it is possible to define an eddy viscosity K , and eddy conductivity K b by T = K,iiz, q = Kb6, (3.19) so that the condition (3.18) becomes
Ri < K , / K , ,
Ri
=
/6zl/ii:
(3.20)
Ri is called the gradient Richardson number and plays a considerable role in stratified flow theory. We question Eq. (3.18) below but even if the arguments were rigorous, the inequality (3.20) would be of limited usefulness because K , / K b varies strongly with Ri.
’ The large eddies tend to be as large as the dimensions of the region of turbulent motion when there are no density gradients as we saw in Section 11. Here the potential energy may be as large as the kinetic energy but this should not change the order of magnitude of the eddy size. Experiments, for example, those of Moore and Long (1971), have been run in which buoyancy forces are of the same order as the acceleration, i.e., ub u$/l. It was observed that the eddies filled the whole channel in this case.
-
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
27
The argument leading to (3.18) is quite incorrect in laboratory experiments in which a stratified fluid in a closed vessel is agitated by a vibrator (Section V). There is no mean flow, so cz= z = 0 and Ri and Rf are both infinite, yet turbulence and buoyancy fluxes exist even in the presence of very large density gradients (Turner, 1973). Obviously in this experiment the energy flux-divergence term in the energy equation is the only source of kinetic energy. If shear exists, the flux divergence term tends to be of the same order as the shear term in Eq. (3.9), as we saw in Section 11, and this is the apparent reason for the usefulness of arguments that Rf has an upper limit for the existence of turbulence. A commonly cited value is Rf, = 0.15 but the data in the atmosphere, oceans, and experiments scatter in the range 0.05-0.30 (Kullenberg, 1971; Turner, 1973). As indicated by the energy equation, a source of disturbance energy is in the shear of the flow pattern. This is most simply seen in the case of two fluids with a buoyancy jump and velocity jump across a surface of discontinuity. One finds that small waves on the interface will grow exponentially if the wavelength is small enough, i.e., that such a surface is always unstable (Lamb, 1932). With general velocity and density distributions, the problem becomes more difficult but a famous theorem of Miles (1961) is helpful. It states that all uelocity and density distributions are stable f R i > $everywhere in thepow. Accompanying this is a rule of thumb which says that the situation is usually unstable when Ri < somewhere (Hazel, 1972). Hazel analyzed stability and instability when the velocity difference occurs over a thickness greater (r > 1) or less (r < 1) than the layer thickness for the density variation. If r > 1, the Richardson number falls to zero outside of the region of density variation even when Ri is large in the region of density variation. The theorem of Miles indicates that instability may occur and Hazel has shown that it does occur. The condition r > 1 is typical in an experiment of Moore and Long (1971). It may also be common in oceans and other bodies of water. The instability for Ri < 4 is called Kelvin-Helmholtz instability. A number of experiments have been run to investigate it (Scotti and Corcos, 1969; Thorpe, 1973) and they have shown that this instability can lead to turbulence. Its occurrence in clear air in the atmosphere as detected by ultrasensitive radar (Browning and Watkins, 1970) and in the thermocline (Woods and Wiley, 1972) is well established. In the ocean, at least, the instability can be set off by the increase of shear locally due to the passage of long waves along a density interface. The wave roll-up is called billow turbulence and resembles the drawing in Fig. 9. The whole layer then breaks down into a general region of turbulence with the layer of strong density
a
28
Robert R . Long
FIG.9. Billow turbulence.
variation considerably increased in depth. The Richardson number for the new density interface is just above (Thorpe, 1973).
a
D. THERMAL CONVECTION When the density decreases with height, shear is required to initiate instability, as we have just seen. It seems obvious that a density increase with height should be unstable in all circumstances. This is usually, but not always, the case. A classic example is that of a fluid between two parallel, horizontal plates heated from below and/or cooled from above (Benard, 1901). When the heat is first applied, it is conducted through the fluid by molecular conduction and if the temperature difference is not too great, motion will not occur. The retarding effects are from viscosity v which resists any motion, and conductivity k , which serves to transmit the heat without the necessity of motion. The destabilizing effects are buoyancy difference Ab and the depth H. The situation is controlled therefore by the Rayleigh number Ra = AbH3/vk,. When Ra exceeds a critical value (1000-2000 depending on boundary conditions), the convection begins. The motion is not fully turbulent, but in more or less regular convection patterns, until Ra is quite large. In addition, recent experiments (Garon and Goldstein, 1973; Threlfall, 1975) indicate transitions from one turbulent state to another for Ra below lo6 or so. These are imperfectly understood, but are revealed by the presence of discontinuities in the curve of nondimensional heat flux vs Ra at certain values of Ra below lo6.
E. J~OUBLEDIFFUSIVE CONVECTION A curious type of convection can exist in water stratified by both heat and salt even when the density decreases with height. It depends on the very different molecular diffusivities of heat and salt. Two simple thought experiments bring out the main features of the two kinds of motion that are possible. First, following Stommel et al. (1956), a long, narrow heat-conducting pipe is inserted vertically in the ocean extending from the surface to the
29
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
depths. If warm salty water overlies cold fresh water and the fluid starts moving upward in the pipe, it would gain heat through the walls of the pipe. If it heats up to the temperature of the surroundings, it becomes lighter than the surroundings at the same level because it is fresher. The pressure at the bottom is the same as the surroundings so that the pressure will decrease in the pipe more slowly with height. The fluid will stand higher in the pipe, and if the top of the pipe is below this height, a perpetual salt fountain will operate. Second, if warm, salty, heavy water lies underneath cooler, fresher, lighter water, consider a parcel of fluid isolated from its surroundings by a thin heat-conducting shell and then displaced upward. It will lose heat but not salt, and the buoyancy force will drive it back down. It will overshoot and the opposite buoyancy force will operate. In this way, an oscillation is produced. If there is no temperature lag, the parcel is negatively buoyant when it is above its starting point and positively buoyant when it is below, so the motion will be damped if any friction exists. If there is a temperature lag, however, the positive buoyancy will exist for more than 50% of the cycle so that the amplitude can increase. As Stern (1960) pointed out, solid boundaries are not essential to the argument. A slower transfer of salt relative to heat is assured by its smaller molecular diffusivity, and motions of both kinds are possible. In the first case, long, narrow convecting cells called salt fingers” have been predicted and observed. In the second, oscillating motion has been verified. “
F. MOLECULAR AND TURBULENT DIFFUSION We have seen something of the contribution of the frictional term in the Navier-Stokes equations. By way of comparison, it is instructive to see how molecular mixing processes proceed. If we consider a container of water at rest, stratified by a variable distribution of salt, the salt will diffuse according to the equation aslat = ~ , v s . (3.21) Without solving exactly, we can see that for a container of dimensions H , the time for diffusion T, is yielded by ASIT, k, A S / H 2 or T, H’lk, . For salt, k, lo-’ cm2/sec,so that for H = 30 cm, the time for the water to become homogeneous is of order 2-3 years! We can see from this example that molecular processes are very slow. Of course, salt has a particularly low coefficient of diffusion but even for heat the diffusiontime in this experiment is of order of a week. This may be compared to turbulent diffusion. In the problem we are considering, the time scale in a turbulent situation will be a
-
-
-
30
Robert R. Long
-
function of gU and 1 or 7; lit,,. If we stir to produce eddies of speed 10 cm/sec and if the eddies fill the box, is of the order of seconds! It is not surprising, therefore that turbulent diffusion of momentum, heat, and additives dominates in almost all problems. We must sometimes be careful in laboratory experiments in which (T, and I may be quite small and in which strong stability locally may cause intermittent rather than fully developed turbulence (Crapper and Linden, 1974). The importance of molecular diffusion is measured by the Peclet number Pe = U H / k , , where U is a representative velocity, and we may argue that phenomena tend to be independent of both Pe and Re when (as is usual) the two numbers are large. On the other hand, the ratio of these is the Prandtl number Pr = Pe/Re = v / k , and there is strong evidence that in thermal convection, at least, Pr is an important parameter even when v and k, are both very small (Rossby, 1969). G. NEGLECT OF ROTATION IN
THE SURFACE LAYER
The horizontal equations of motion, including the earth’s rotation (Holton, 1972, pp. 1-32) are duldt = (1iPo)(~Piax)+fu,
(3.22)
dvldt = - ( l / P O ) ( a P / d Y ) -fu,
(3.23)
where we neglect molecular friction. In Eqs. (3.22) and (3.23),fis the Coriolis parameter, 2R sin 6, where 6 is latitude and R is the angular speed of rotation of the earth. Since we are not concerned with large-scale motions, we may neglect the variation offwith latitude (Holton, 1972, p. 106). Let us consider statistically steady, turbulent flow of a uniform current of air over the earth’s surface. We neglect all variations horizontally and assume w = 0. Then the horizontal equations become
-fa
=
- ( l / p o ) ( a p / a x )+ (a/az)( -m),
f n = - (l/po)(ap//ay)+ (aid.)( -77).
(3.24) (3.25)
There will be a turbulent boundary layer above the surface and above this we will assume nonturbulent flow so that UIW) and become zero there. Then the uniform current is (3.26) (3.27) If we take the x axis along the direction of the wind at the earth’s surface, as in Fig. 10, we have ug = G cos a, ug = - G sin a.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
31
FIG. 10. Geostrophic wind.The x axis is along the flow at the surface.
Let us integrate Eq. (3.24)from the ground to height H , . We get -u"(O)
-I-m
( H o )=
I
,H o
[fv
- (l/p,)(d~/dx)] dz.
(3.28)
' 0
Since the pressure gradient force does not vary much with height, we may put it equal t o f G in Eq. (3.28).We get
-u"(O)
+ u"(Ho)
(3.29)
since omittingfc only strengthens the inequality. The stress variation, which is zero if rotation is absent, may be neglected if
[- u " ( O )
+ u"(H,)]/U"(O)
I &,
(3.30)
say. Thus, rotation is negligible if (Monin and Yaglom, 1971)
H o 5 uCv'(O)/lOfG= u i / l O f G
(3.31)
where u, is the friction velocity. In the atmosphere u , / G 2 0.05. Putting f= G = lo3, we get H , 5 25 m. This layer in which rotation is negligible is called the surface layer. A similar computation for oceans and lakes may be inappropriate. Csanady (1972) has argued that in the absence of a solid surface in oceans and lakes, Coriolis effects are not negligible for any range of depths.
H. SOME PROPERTIES OF THE EKMAN LAYERIN THE ATMOSPHERE When we consider conditions above the surface layer in the atmosphere, rotation becomes important. Neglecting effects of compressibility and buoy-
32
Robert R. Long
ancy, and assuming a statistical steady state, we obtain Eqs. (3.24k(3.27)
-f(v-
Ug)=a(-m)/az,
f (a - u,)
__
=
a( - u‘w’)/az.
from (3.32) (3.33)
These equations reveal that the stresses vary with height and this variation causes the wind to deviate from the geostrophic wind. Physically it is evident that the velocity vector is along the lines of constant pressure at z = co,and in the frictional layer the vector is directed at an angle to these lines toward lower pressure. The first investigation of the planetary boundary layer was made by Ekman (1905). If the flow is laminar, dimensional analysis indicates that the depth of the Ekman layer is h
- (~/f)”’.
(3.34)
Let us now consider the turbulence in flow over a rough surface of roughness length z o . Near the ground the velocity components may be expressed as ii/u* = ‘p(z/zo)
v/u* = 0,
(3.35)
where y is the friction velocity at the ground and we take a coordinate system with x axis along the wind direction in the surface layer.fdoes not enter (3.35) since, as we have just seen, rotation is unimportant in the lowest layers. Above the surface layer, we may write
(a - .,)/U*
= Xl(Zf/U* 9
zo f l u * ) ,
6- ug)/u*
= X 2 k f /u*
20
From Eq. (3.33), we obtain (ti - .,)/.*
-
3
u*/f
f h*).
h.
(3.36) (3.37) (3.38)
If we use the analogy between molecular and eddy viscosities, Eq. (3.34) indicates Since 1
-
h h, we get
-
- (K,/f)”2 - ( ~ “ l / f ) l ’ ~ . h - o u l f - u*/f
(3.39)
(3.40)
so that (ii - u,)/u, 1 for all zo flu,. Accordingly, we may write the defect laws for small zo as
(3.41) (3.42)
33
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
Let us now match the two regions as in Section I1 (Csanady, 1967). Using
5 = z/zo, q = zo f /u, , we have ugh* = m l ( v ) ?
uglu* = 4 q )
(3.43)
and
d5)- ml(q) = x1(5q), The procedure in Section I1 leads to
-m&)
5q’ = - m i q = 1/K
= x&q).
(3.44) (3.45)
= const
(3.46)
mi = - B = const We get (Kazanski and Monin, 1961; Csanady, 1967) ii/u, = (11K) ln(z/zo)
u&,
= G cos alu, = - (11K) In(z, flu,)
- ug/u.+ = G sin alu,
=B
(3.47)
+A
(3.48) (3.49)
As we have seen, the depth of the Ekman layer is h = Cu,/fl where C is a constant. Csanady (1967) and others (Plate, 1971) have accumulated some evidence from the atmosphere for the validity of these results but the data shows enormous scatter, partly, of course, because buoyancy effects have been neglected. The latter has been included by Zilitinkevich (1967,1975)by considering A and B to be functions of the quantity, Po = 4 / 4.L
(3.50)
where q is buoyancy flux. IV. Thermal Convection
When a fluid is heated from below or cooled from above, or both, there is a tendency for the heated or cooled fluid to rise or fall, respectively, because of the resultant density difference between the convection element and the surroundings. The rising or falling element is called a thermal. Common examples are the thermals experienced and used by glider pilots and birds for soaring above the heated ground on a sunny day. In the oceans, cooling of the upper layers of the water by contact with cool air, by radiation of heat, or by evaporational cooling produces colder elements of fluid which fall in exactly the same way as warmed air rises. Much less is known about convection in the oceans than is known about convection in the atmosphere, so we will emphasize atmospheric and laboratory measurements in this section, but convection in lakes and other bodies of water causes the destruction of
Robert R. Long
34
the summer thermocline in the fall and thus has great importance for the flushing and freshening of the deep portions of these bodies of water. As we discussed briefly in Section 111, a fluid can remain at rest in the region between two horizontal surfaces-the lower heated and the upper cooled-provided the Rayleigh number, Ra = AbH3/vkh, is below a certain critical value which defines marginal stability. For simplicity we assume that the fixed buoyancy at the lower plate is zero and the buoyancy at the upper plate is Ab. For two rigid planes, Ra, = 1708 as found by Jeffreys (1926, 1928), who extended an earlier investigation by Rayleigh (1916).Above Ra,, motion first begins in the form of regular cells. Recent investigations (Krishnamurti, 1968, 1970) concentrate on the nonlinear problem, in which case the Prandtl number becomes important for determining the phenomena. The first experiments were made by Benard (1901),but the first laboratory verification of Ra, was by Schmidt and Milverton (1935). The shapes of the cells that form are very sensitive to the geometry of the boundary and even to slight unsteadiness in the boundary conditions. For example, Koschmieder (1967) and Krishnamurti (1968) have shown that two-dimensional roll cells form first for Ra > Ra, but the hexagonal cells, as observed also by Benard, can be induced by gradual increase or decrease with time (a few degrees an hour) of the imposed temperature difference, the sign of the motion depending on the sign of the temperature change. These observations explain some of the discrepancies in past experiments that were not so carefully controlled. Benards hexagonal cells were probably influenced fundamentally by surface tension effects. We are interested here primarily in the higher Rayleigh numbers since large Ra is typical of oceans and atmosphere. In the latter, for example, we may take Ab s 10, v k h 0.1 and a value of H (height of mixed layer) of lo4 yielding Ra One might guess that phenomena must become independent of H as H co,i.e., Ra -+ co,but observations indicate distinct effects for Ra as high as 10'. For example, the nondimensional heat flux has discrete discontinuities at certain values of Ra (Threlfall, 1975),and Garon and Goldstein (1973) believe that they have observed discontinuities in the slope of heat flux curve at values of Ra above lo6, although this is debatable. Results in Section IV,D suggest other important effects of H for Ra lo5 or higher. There has been a very large number of experiments to investigate turbulent convection at values of Ra up to 10" or so (Malkus, 1954a,b; Thomas and Townsend, 1957; Silveston, 1958: Croft, 1958; Townsend, 1959; Globe and Dropkin, 1959; Somerscales and Dropkin, 1966; Deardorff and Willis, 1967; Somerscales and Gazda, 1969; Chu and Goldstein, 1973; Garon and Goldstein, 1973; Threlfall, 1975).Observations have been made of the mean temperature field and a number of other statistical quantities including rms temperatures, rms vertical and horizontal velocities, dissipation functions N
- -+
-
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
35
and E in Eqs. (3.9)and (3.10), etc. We defer an account of these until we have discussed a theory of convection at high Ra.
AND
A. SIMILARITY THEORY OF CONVECTION COMPARISON WITH LABORATORY OBSERVATIONS
The oldest theory of convection at large Ra is the similarity theory of Prandtl (1932) found independently by Priestley (1954). It is based on an analogy to flow in the turbulent region near a wall in which all mean quantities are assumed to be functions of 7 and z only. Prandtl assumed that in a region 6, << z << H above the thermal boundary layer of thickness 6,, but far from any upper boundary, that all mean quantities, for example, the rms buoyancy ob, are functions of q and z. Then dimensional analysis yields
Kraichman (1962) derived the similarity theory by comparing orders of magnitude in the various equations of the problem. Thus, in the energy __ equation, he assumed that dissipation was E o;/l and that production, w’b’, was of the same order. Since rising parcels are warm and falling parcels cold, he assumed an order-one correlation between w’ and 6‘. He assumed also that o, and ow are of the same order. These assumptions yield
-
If we add the likely requirement that the length scale in the region 6, << z << H is z itself, as in the case of the logarithmic layer in shearing flow,
- -
we derive three of the results in (4.1). The quantity 6,is obtained by the reasonable assumption that ob 6,z. Also enlightening is an equally plausible substitute for the assumption q E, namely, that the buoyancy and inertia terms are of the same order in the vertical equation of motion, i.e., (4.3) Indeed, we find that the similarity theory leads to equal orders of magnitude of all terms in all equations. Although the similarity theory is very old, the evidence is less than convincing that it is correct. One damaging observation in laboratory experiments (Deardorff and Willis, 1967)is that (T, increases with height, roughly as indicated by the similarity theory, but that ouincreases only until the top of the thermal boundary layer or perhaps somewhat higher and then decreases. This has led some investigators, e.g., Bechov and Yaglom (1971), to attempt to modify the similarity theory to allow for two length scales 1,
Robert R. Long
36
and I,. Then from the equation of continuity
-
aulax
- atqay
awlaz
we find 0” 0” ~wlx.l~ and two velocity scales are permitted. This argument is also not convincing because it avoids consideration of the role of pressure forces, which, as we have seen, lead toward equalization of velocity scales. On the whole, laboratory experiments are not favorable to the similarity theory (Townsend, 1976). Comparisons are difficult in part because of problems of accurate measurement and in part because the Rayleigh numbers in experiments are a maximum of 10” or so for reasonably large aspect ratios and this may not be high enough to permit a region 6, << z << H.We will see evidence for this statement in the next section. Many measurements have been made of 5,. The one most quoted is that of Townsend (1959)who fitted a z-’ curve to his data. This is often cited as strong evidence for a z-’ law, but Townsend warned that the data were such that the exponent could lie between - 1.3 and -2.5. This range embraces the similarity theory with an exponent of -$, a theory by Long (1975) discussed below leading to z- 3/2, and a theory by Malkus (1954a) leading to z - ’. In another experiment, Croft (1958) found a z-~’’ behavior for 6, but more recent investigators have asserted that no power law seems to fit the data and this also suggests that Rayleigh numbers are not large enough. There is additional evidence regarding rms velocities given by Malkus (1954b)and DeardorlT and Willis (1967). Over a range of Rayleigh numbers from lo5 to lo9 they find the following N
f ( d 2+ 0’’
+ w”) = const(k,/H)’
Ra,
(4.4) where the double overbar indicates an average over the entire container. A theory of Malkus (1954b)also leads to Eq. (4.4), and this inspired Malkus to make laborious visual velocity measurements with tiny glass fragments as tracers. Deardorff and Willis used a moving hot wire in air. The observations are shown in Fig. 11 and the agreement with the Ra behavior of Eq. (4.4) seems reasonably good. In present terminology, if ou,u w ,cr” are all of the same order, this becomes Q, (HAb)”2, (4.5) where we suppress Prandtl number dependence. This suggests
-
-
uW (ZAb)”’
(4-6) in the region 6, << z << H. The behavior in Eq. (4.5) is different from the similarity theory which yields for the fluid as a whole 6 ,
Iv
q”3H’/3.
(4.7)
37
10
1
I
I
FIG. 11. Experimental observations of average kinetic energy in thermal convection.
If we use the most recent experimental relationship (Garon and Goldstein, 1973; Threlfall, 1975) between q and Ab (see Section IV,C), we have Nu = qH/k,Ab z const Ra””,
(4.8) where the ratio of buoyancy flux to conductive flux is called the Nusselt number. The similarity theory leads to
f(d’4-d2 4-
W”)
Z COnSt(k,/H)’ Rae.",
(4.9) and this is not at all close to the observed behavior as we see in Fig. 11. There are many measurements of ob in the laboratory. If the power law oba Z-” is fitted, n lies between 0.48 (Rossby, 1969) and 0.70 (Somerscales and Gazda, 1969). Townsend (1959) reported n = 0.6. These are not very close to the similarity prediction of n = 0.33. Further comparison may be made with respect to N, the dissipation term for buoyancy fluctuations in Eq. (3.10). The dimensions of N are [ N ] = L2T-’, and similarity theory yields N
-
q5/3z-4/3.
(4.10)
Townsend reported N proportional to z - ~ / ’in his experiments. B. MOLECULAR BOUNDARYLAYERS
Let us now consider the properties of the molecular boundary layers just above a heated plate. In this region, we must consider both conductivity and
Robert R. Long
38
viscosity. If the Prandtl number is small, there will be a thin viscous layer imbedded in a thick conductive layer. If Pr is large, the viscous layer will be thicker. Let us consider the two cases separately: 1. Thick Conductive Layer
Let us first investigate the properties of the imbedded viscous layer. Here inertial and viscous forces balance so that wL6, v. In the perturbation w’6,. In the mean vertical equation buoyancy equation we assume k,):, of motion, we may also assume b or 6, wz/6,. These assumptions, combined with q k , 6/6,, lead to 3/4 - 1/4 p r 7 / 4 6, q - 1/4,,3/4 pr- 114, 6, q3/4v- 114 pr3/4 Obv 4
-
ow,
- (z) -. -
-
-
9
4
1/4 pr1/4
ouu
7
T,
,,1/44 1/4 prl/4
3
-
-
9
q-1/2v1/2 Pr-1/2, (4.11)
where we have assumed o,, ow, and where T, 8,,/ou,, is the time period for the layer. In the thick conductive layer, we may assume that advection and conduction of buoyancy are of the same order, or owcSc/kh 1. In addition we assume that the buoyancy forces and inertial forces are of the same order in the vertical equation - of motion, i.e., (Tb, o;,/S,. Since buoyancy tends to be conserved, obc b, 6, Ab,, where L\b, is the increment of buoyancy over the portion of the layer above the imbedded viscous layer. Finally, assuming q k, db,/S,, we obtain for the buoyancy fluctuations
-
- -
-
-
-- -
obc d b ,
q3/4\,-1/4Pr1l4.
(4.12)
Since this is much larger than 6,,Eq. (4.12) also yields the order of magnitude of 6,. Thus, for the outer boundary layer 3/4 -1/4 pr1/4 6, v3/44- 114 pr- 3/4> 6, q3/4v- 114 pr1/4 Obcv
-
ow,
q1’4v1/4Pr-1/4,
-
ouc
q 1/4v 114 pr-i/4,
-
T,
-
q-
1/2v1/2
p r- 112. (4.13)
Pr’/’ in agreement with the assumption that the viscous Notice that 6,/6, layer is much thinner than the conductive layer. For later purposes we need the equation for the mean buoyancy in the outer boundary layer. We have
6, = q3/4v-1/4Pr1’4f(( Pr3/4,Pr),
( = Z V - ~ ~ ~ (4.14) ~ ’ ~ ~ ,
wheref(5 Pr314, Pr) + g ( l Pr314)as Pr + 0. 2. Thick Viscous Layer
-
We now investigate first the properties of the imbedded conductive layer. Here we assume a balance of advection and conduction, or ~ w c 6 c / k h1,
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
39
- and viscous forces are of the same order and we assume that buoyancy forces or a b c vow,/6f. Using q k , AbC/6,,abc Ab, b,, we get 114 3/4 pr-l/2 -114 314 ~ ~ 1 1 2 , 6, v-i14 314 pr112, 6,-qv Obc 4 4 n w c - 4 114v 114 pr-i/z, fJuc 4114v 1/4 ~ ~ - 1 1 2 , T, v”24- 112. (4.15)
-
-
9
-
- -
-
-
-
- a,,- a, -
In the thicker viscous layer, we may assume equal orders for the viscous, inertia, and buoyancy terms, i.e., aW,,6,,~v 1 and a,,, vaw,/65. We may where is the increment of buoyalso assume awvnb, q and (Tb, ancy across the portion of the layer above the imbedded conductive layer. We obtain for the buoyancy fluctuation,
-
- -
db,
Ab,
q3I4V- ‘I4.
Since this is much less than b,, we have 6, the outer boundary layer
6,
N
$144-
ow,
-
-
abu
114,
v114q 114,
-
q 314 v -114 ,
a”,
-
- LC--
(4.16)
v-1/4q314Pr”’. Thus, for
6,
v1/44 1/4 7
4 314 Pr1/2, Vri2q-‘I2. (4.17)
v-lI4
T,
Pr-’”, in agreement with the assumption that the conNotice that 6,/6, ductive layer is thinner than the viscous layer. Let us now formulate an equation for 6,. In general
6, = q3I4v- 1’4g(5,Pr).
(4.18)
In the main portion of the viscous boundary layer, we may write
s(5,Pr) =fig)+ pr1’2f2(5) + h(5, Pr).
(4.19)
Our analysis so far shows that we may choose h(5, Pr) 0 as Pr co,so that g(5, Pr) = O(Pr’/’). If we differentiate with respect to 5, we get -+
-+
s’(5, Pr) =fll(t) + pr112f;(t) + h’(5, Pr),
(4.20)
where primes denote total or partial differentiation with respect to 5. The derivative g’(5, Pr) must be of order one because
a6,/az
- SL,-
q314v-
(4.21)
l14.
Now (4.22) and since h + 0 as P r -+ co for all 5, we see that h’(5, Pr) Therefore,f,(() = C is a constant. Thus
6, = q3’4v- ‘/“[fl(;“) + C Pr’”
+ h(5, Pr)],
-+
0 as Pr
-+
00.
(4.23)
40
Robert R. Long
where h(5, Pr) + 0 as Pr + co. It is somewhat more convenient to write this as
6, = q3'"v- ' / " [ f ( 5 ,Pr) + C Pr'/']],
(4.24)
where f becomes independent of Pr as Pr + cc.
C. NUSSELTNUMBER-RAYLEIGH NUMBERRELATION Recent experiments (Goldstein and Chu, 1969; Garon and Goldstein, 1973; Threlfall, 1975) have yielded excellent data on the relationship between the Nusselt number Nu and the Rayleigh number Ra in thermal convection within horizontal layers of fluid heated from below. With the Boussinesq approximation, dimensional considerations require that Nu be a function of Ra and Pr. The experimental results have been somewhat disappointing to theorists. A plausible argument (Howard, 1966) suggests that the buoyancy flux q should become independent of the depth as H gets large (large Ra) so that Nu should be proportional to Ra''3 at large Ra. Instead the data seem to indicate a relationship Nu = const Ra",
(4.25)
where n is unmistakably less than 0.333. Recent estimates of n range from 0.278 to 0.293. We will show below that the observations are nevertheless consistent with the assumption Nu + Ra'I3 as Ra -+co. In the development below, we match expressions for 6 in the interior of the fluid with the expressions for 6 in the upper part of the outer molecular layer near the plate where, according to (4.14) and (4.24),
6 = Cq3/"v-' "A A+O, A+Pr'/',
6 + PI-'/",
6+1,
+ q3/"v- '/"hf(&,
Pr),
Pr3/4
as P r - r 0,
~ + l as
Pr+cc.
E+
(4.26) (4.27)
In Eq. (4.26) the function f becomes independent of Pr as Pr + 0 and Pr + 00. In the interior, we introduce a " buoyancy-defect " law for 6analogous to the velocity-defect law for flow in the interior of a pipe or channel (Section 11). We assume (4.28) where U is some unspecified velocity scale and where we allow a possible
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
41
variation of the function x with Pr. The basic assumption in (4.28) is the neglect of the nondimensional number (q'/4v1/4)H/v in the function x analogous to the neglect of the Reynolds number in the velocity-defect law in a pipe or channel. We may also define m(q, Pr) = + A b ~ ' / ~ / q ~ q/ ~=, v ~ / ~ / H ~ ' U/q1/4v1/4 /~, = u(q, Pr). (4.29)
Let us now match Eqs. (4.26) and (4.28). We obtain for the region of overlap
41, PrH6f (&,
Pr) + CA - m(q, Pr)] =
-x(&
Pr).
(4.30)
We now differentiate with respect to and with respect to q and use the resulting two equations to eliminate the derivative of x. We get ah$ '5 = quv(6f+ CA) - q(um),,,
(4.31)
where the prime denotes partial differentiation with respect to (&) and subscripts indicate partial derivatives. If we differentiate (4.31 ) with respect to 5. we get
(f'&()I"
= qu,/u = - s,
(4.32)
where s is a function of Pr which we later take to be a constant. Solutions are
f= *A0
+ BO([E)-~,
u
= Pq-',
(4.33)
where A. , Bo ,and /? are functions of Pr. The factor 4 is introduced for later convenience. Equation (4.31) now yields m =fAo6
+ CA - $yoqs,
(4.34)
where yo is another function of Pr. We may now use the first equation in (4.29) to obtain the Nusselt number ~ ~ 1 prw 1 3 NU = (4.35) [ A o 6 + 2CA - y(Nu Ra)-s/4]4/3' where y is a function of Pr. The physical argument that the velocity scale should not increase with increase in viscosity indicates that s 2 4 so that the buoyancy flux becomes independent of H for large Rayleigh numbers. When Pr is large or small, A . is independent of Pr. If, in addition, Ra is large, we get Nu = K , Ra'/3 Pr'l3, Ra large, Pr small, Nu = K, Ra'/3,
Ra large, Pr large,
(4.36)
where K , and K, are constants. These results agree with the theory of
42
Robert R. Long
Kraichnan (1962), using, among other things, the assumption that the buoyancy increments across the conductive layers are of order Ab. Comparison with Experiment
We may try to determine s, A, 6 + 2CA, and y from experiments. The best data, perhaps, are experimental measurements of heat flux in gaseous helium by Threlfall (1975) and in water by Garon and Goldstein (1973). We make two choices for s, namely, s = f and s = 4, corresponding, respectively, to the theory of Long and to the similarity theory. For helium (Pr = 0.8), we obtain 0.04299 Ra'/3 s = - Nu=---1.433(Ra NU)-'/'^]^/^ ' [I 3
I
'\
s=-
'1
Nu=
2
0.04809 Ra'l3 [l - 2.381(Ra NU)-''*]^'^
(4.37)
where we have used two fairly extreme experiments of Threlfall, Nu = 8.060, Nu = 67.183,
Ra = 9.610 x lo5, Ra = 1.804 x lo9.
(4.38)
Threlfall's experiments included measurements at much lower Rayleigh numbers, but transitions, or discontinuities in the curve Nu =j(Ra), are observed below Ra = lo6, and these are not revealed in the present theory. Garon and Goldstein believe that their data reveal abrupt changes in the slope of the curve at Rayleigh numbers above lo6 but this is less certain. An additional comparison may be made using the data of Garon and Goldstein for water (Pr = 6.8). We get s=-
'1
Nu=
3 s=-
'{
Nu=
2
0.04356 Ra'/3 [l - 1.402(Ra
NU)-'/'*]^/^
0.04786 Rail3 [l - 2.544(Ra Nu)- 1/8]4/3
(4.39)
where we have used the lowest and highest Rayleigh numbers, 16.2,
Nu
=
Nu
= 81.3,
Ra = 1.36 x lo', Ra = 3.29 x lo9.
(4.40)
Notice that the coefficients in (4.37) and (4.39) differ by only 1-2% when s = 4 despite the considerable difference in Prandtl numbers. Figure 12 shows the remarkable agreement between the theoretical curve for s = 4and the observations of Garon and Goldstein. We do not show the
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
43
::' :::I 40 39
3.8
LnNu
3.5
34L
33-
323 1 t
30292ar 16
17
I8
19
20
21
LnRa
FIG. 12. Nusselt number-Rayleigh number relation
comparison with the curve for s = f because the two theoretical curves are almost identical when plotted on these scales. The figure indicates that the curve for s = f is close to a straight line on a log-log plot. The very similar behavior of the data caused both Threlfall and Garon and Goldstein to choose power laws, Nu a Ra0.28 and Nu a Ra0.29, respectively. As illustrated in Fig. 12, the power law gives good agreement but, of course, it has no theoretical basis. In Fig. 12 we have drawn a straight line (power law) in comparison with the theoretical curves for s = f and s = 1 and the data. The theoretical curve for s = f has slight but definite and consistent curvature, and since the data are closer to this curve than to the power law, it seems fair to prefer the present theory corresponding to s = f or s = Threlfall has a plot of his heat flux measurements and there is a good agreement with both the power law and the present theory over the whole range above Ra = lo4 or so, but Threlfall does not supply numerical data and a close comparison is not possible. In Fig. 12 the curve for s = 1 corresponds to the theory of Malkus (1954a).This falls far from the data of Garon and Goldstein, and the Malkus theory seems untenable. We have remarked that the theory of this paper indicates Nu oc Ra'l3 as Ra -+ 00, but there are sensible departures at the Rayleigh numbers of the typical experiment. We may see how large the Rayleigh number must be for Eqs. (4.39) to yield a close approximation to the Ra'/3 law. For s = f, we get Ra > 3 x 10" for an error of less than 1% in the Nusselt number. The corresponding value for s = f is Ra > 1.4 x 10l6.Equations (4.37)give even larger Rayleigh numbers.
t.
Robert R. Long
44
D. BUOYANTCONVECTION FROM
AN
ISOLATEDSOURCE
So far we have concentrated on obtaining an overall picture of thermal convection with no attention to the details of the turbulence. Let us now consider individual thermal elements. They can be conveniently divided into two groups: " plumes and " thermals." The former arises when heat is applied steadily, the latter denotes a buoyant element more or less suddenly released. Let us consider a statistically steady plume and integrate the equation "
ab/at -k v . vb = khV2b
(4.41)
over a circular region of large radius R and thickness Az. We get
\ 5 k , ( g ) r dr do, 2n
wbr dr do = A
'0
R
(4.42)
0
where 6 is the average buoyancy over the area nR2 and A indicates an increment over the distance Az. Since the first term is zero, we have
(4.43) is constant where we have extended the region of integration to infinity because there is no contribution to the integral from any region outside the plume. If we suppose that the plume is caused by applying a buoyancy - Ab to a circular region of the lower surface of radius a, dimensional analysis indicates the following:
6 = F2l3z- 5'3g(r/z,Pr, r/a, F"3a2'3/v), F = Ab3'2a5'2rn(Aba3/vZ, Pr).
(4.44) (4.45)
Let us now consider two separate regions, one near the lower boundary (in the thermal boundary layer) and one far above the boundary. The formulation in (4.44)is valid for all finite a and Ab. As a -+ 0, Ab fixed, the plume disappears. We may obviously obtain a plume of finite properties by letting a + 0, Ab --* co in such a way as to keep F finite. Then we have
6 = F 2 / 3 z -5/3g(r/z,Pr, F 1 / 3 z 2 / 3 / ~ ) .
(4.46)
The last quantity has the form of a Reynolds number and for large z should be negligible. Arguing similarly, we obtain for large F 1 / 3 z 2 / 3 / v ,
6=~
2 ' 3 5/3 ~ -g(r/z,
Pr),
R = zg,(Pr), =~
172(r/z,Pr),
i / 3 113 ~ -
(4.47) (4.48) (4.49)
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
45
where R is the mean radius of the plume. This dependence on z has been found in experiments by Rouse et al. (1952).It is obvious physically that this formulation is valid for finite a and Ab if z/a >> 1. For v3/'/F1'' << z I O(a), we must include an argument involving a. We write, therefore,
6= ~
2 / 3 513 ~ g(r/z, -
F'/3z2/3/v>> 1.
Pr, r/a),
(4.50)
Let us consider conditions near the plate. If we now assume a large plate compared to the thickness of the molecular boundary layer, the mean buoyancy in the boundary layer will be given by the expressions in Eqs. (4.14) and (4.24)with a term - A b added, with q replaced by F/a2 and with a dependence on q = r/a included. We get
6= F 3 / 4 a - 3 / 2 v - 1 / 4 6 [ f (q,5 ~Pr) , + CA] - Ab,
a >> v3/'/F1/',(4.51)
wherefbecomes independent of Pr as Pr gets large or small and where E, 6, and A are given by A + 0,
E(Pr) + Pr3l4, E(Pr)
-+
1,
A -+ Pr"',
6(Pr) + Pr1/4 6(Pr)
-+
1
as Pr + 0,
as Pr + co.
(4.52)
Since Eqs. (4.50)and (4.51)must agree in the outer portions of the molecular boundary layer,
+ 5'/3(z/a)4'3[6f(5~. q, Pr) + 6CA] = g(r/z, Pr, q), where 5 = z F ' / ~ '/'v~Eq. (4.53)becomes -m-2/3
3/4.
(4.53) Defining Aba3/v2= R , z/a = C, y = ECR3 / 8m 1/4,
+ ~ ' / 8 ~ 1 /[6f(Y, 1 2 q,
Pr) + 6CA] = C-5/3g(v/C, Pr, q). (4.54)
Differentiating with respect to R, we get
(4.55)
= 0.
Differentiating Eq. (4.55)with respect to C, we get Yfyy + $fy= 0.
(4.56)
The solution is
f = ~ ( qPr)y-'/3 ,
+ B(q, Pr),
(4.57)
where A and B are arbitrary functions of q and Pr. Substituting Eq. (4.57)
46
Robert R. Long
into (4.55), we get
(4.58) where we see that B(q, Pr) is a function of Pr only. The solution is [B(Pr) + CA]6R'/8m3'4 - D(Pr)m2/3= 1.
(4.59)
If we now solve Eq. (4.54) for g(q/(, Pr, q), we get for Eq. (4.50) 6 = F2/3a- 5 / 3 ~ ( p+~ ~) 2 1 3 1~ / -3 a - 4 / 3 ~(v, Pr). (4.60) The solution should be valid for arbitrarily large z where 6-0. Thus D(Pr) = 0. If we now combine Eq. (4.45) and (4.59), we get
F/a2 = N(Pr)Ab4/3v'/3,
(4.61)
where N(Pr) cc Pr- u3
as Pr
N(Pr) a Pr-2/3
as Pr
-+
-+
0,
co.
(4.62)
The buoyancy gradient is
6, =f ( ~ ) ( F / a ~ ) ~413' ~ z -
(4.63)
for large or small Pr. Notice that the results are valid for arbitrarily large a but a must be larger than the thickness of the molecular boundary layer.
E. NEWDERIVATION OF THE
SIMILARITY
THEORY
The solution in Section IV,D includes the case a co.Then F/a2 a q and A(r/a, Pr) -+ A(Pr). Thus, for an infinite heated plate and an infinitely deep -+
fluid above
6,= const q2/3z-4/3 q = const Ab4/3~1/3 Prq
= const
Pr large or small, 1/3
Ab4l3v1I3Pr-2/3
as P r -+ 0, as P r -+ co.
(4.64)
The other quantities may be obtained by matching the expressions in Eqs. (4.13) and (4.17). Thus in the interior ow = q
l / 3 ~ ' / (P 3 ~ r
At low Pr in the overlap region q1/3z'/3~(pr)= q1/4y1/4p r-
).
1/4f(zq1/4
(4.65) pr3/4/v3/4)
(4.66)
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
47
so that H(Pr) = const. At high Pr and H(Pr) is again a constant. The combined results are
Ow
N
q”3z”3
3
O”*q
z
113 113 9
T
(4.68)
q-1/3z2/3
for large or small Pr. This derivation of the similarity theory for infinite Rayleigh number seems quite convincing. Perhaps the most questionable assumption in the present discussion is the neglect of the Reynolds number F1/3z2’3/vin going from Eq. (4.46) to (4.47), but Eqs. (4.47)-(4.49) have been investigated experimentally by Rouse et al. (1952), using a heat source in a large room, and the dependences on z have been confirmed. F. COMPARISON OF THEORIES OF THERMAL CONVECTION
We have referred to three theories that yield the behavior of mean quantities in a region just above the thermal boundary layer. They are the similarity theory, a theory of the author (Long, 1975), and a theory of Malkus (1954a). With respect to the discussion in Section IV,C, the three theories yield
6, K z-‘- ’, where s = 3, $, 1, respectively. The data in Fig. 12 seem to indicate that the Malkus theory is untenable but do not permit us to distinguish between s = and s = f. On the other hand, the matching procedure of Section IV,C seems very successful in comparison with the data for some value of s less than 1 but greater than or equal to On this basis, the similarity theory s = seems preferable because any other choice of s implies a dependence on the Reynolds number r ] - l = ( q ~ ) ” ~ H /in v the expression for U and therefore for the buoyancy defect 6- Ab. In other words, it seems inconsistent to neglect r] on the right-hand side of Eq. (4.28) but retain a dependence on r] on the left-hand side. The discussion in Section IV,E also provides strong support for the similarity theory. An additional remark is suggestive. We saw in Section I1 that the flow in a pipe or channel is such that the Reynolds number Re, based on the velocity defect, the dimension of the region, and the eddy viscosity coefficient is of order one. In thermal convection, using s = i, the buoyancy defect is of order q2’3H-113from (4.28), (4.29), and (4.33) and using K , K, UH q1I3H4l3,the Rayleigh number Ra, based on the buoyancy defect, the
4
4.
-
4
- -
48
Robert R. Long
dimension of the region, and the eddy coefficients of viscosity and diffusion is Ra,
-
1.
4
This result is not obtained for s = and provides an additional indication that the similarity theory is correct. On the other hand, as indicated in Section IV,C, it may be necessary to reach unattainably high values of Ra before one could expect to obtain the behavior indicated by the similarity theory. G. CONVECTION WITH SHEAR
When convection exists in geophysical systems, shear is nearly always present and, as we see in Eq. (3.9), the shear and convection both provide energy sources. A theory of this turbulent situation is described fully by Monin and Yaglom (1971). It assumes that the momentum flux z and the buoyancy flux q are fundamental parameters and neglects molecular viscosity and diffusion. Any mean quantity may then be expressed in terms of 4 , 7 , and z, for example, (4.69) (4.70) (4.71) and where von Kannan’s constant is included to conform with usage. It is remarkable that (4.69)and (4.70)are valid forms for either stable or unstable conditions. There seems little doubt that the Monin-Obukhov theory is a very good one. It collapses the data very well in the lower atmosphere and has been verified in the stable case by Arya and Plate (1969). In the unstable case, it has been argued by Priestley (1954) that large z corresponds to small L or small z so that when z is large z should disappear from the analysis in the expression for buoyancy. We find for (4.70)
6, = const q 2 / 3 z - 4 / 3 .
(4.72)
Other quantities may be obtained similarly, for example, o,, = const q2’3Z-1/3, gu=
const q1/3z1/3,
ow = const q 1 / 3 z 1 / 3 .
(4.73)
This theory has been examined very carefully by comparing with measure-
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
49
ments on towers in the atmospheric surface layer. Both Dyer (1965) and instead of conformBusinger et al. (1971) find, for example, that 6, K ing with the similarity theory, and the data seem good enough to clearly distinguish between the two behaviors. On the other hand, measurements of ow seem to agree with the similarity theory. The mean velocity distribution certainly depends on T so that it cannot be obtained by the similarity argument. Businger er al. (1971) found ii, a z-’I4
(4.74)
for large z. It is interesting to calculate the behavior of the ratio of turbulent diffusivity to turbulent viscosity. Since T =
K,ii,,
q
=
KbGz,
(4.75)
we find a = K b / K , cc z1I4,i.e., increasing with height. Near the ground, i.e., at small values of z/L+ the energy equation (3.9) reveals that since q is constant the term T U ~takes on increasing importance as the shear increases greatly near the boundary. This implies that the buoyancy becomes a passive quantity, in the sense that the buoyancy term no longer is important in the vertical equation of motion. Then the buoyancy and momentum equations become uncoupled and we see from consideration of generalized dimensional analysis in Section I that buoyancy (or temperature) may be given a dimension independent of the mechanical units of mass, length, and time. Now
6,=f(z,
4, z)
(4.76)
6, = Cq/r’”z.
(4.77)
so that Thus the profile of buoyancy is logarithmic. Of course Zii,/T“2
=
1/K
since there is no effect of buoyancy on the dynamics. These behaviors have been verified by all careful measurements of the first few meters above the ground. In practice, measurements are plotted in terms of (Pm
=
(KZ/U*)iiz 9
(Ph
= (KZu*/q)bz 9
(4.78)
where (P, and (P, are functions of z / L In fact K is chosen to make ( ~ ~ ( =01.) In the measurements of Businger et al. (1971), ( P h ( 0 ) = 0.74 so that the ratio of turbulent diffusivities in neutral conditions, z/L = 0, is
a = K b / K m= ( P m / ( P h = 1.35
(4.79)
approximately. As we have noted, a increases with z/L in the unstable regime.
50
Robert R . Long
The general behavior of (P, and (P, cannot be obtained analytically but we may presume that they can be expanded in a Taylor series about z / L = 0. We get KZ&/U* KZU*b,/q
=
1
+
= 0.74
P,,,Z/L
+PhZ/L.
(4.80)
Upon integration they yield the log-linear laws for the profiles of velocity and buoyancy. These appear to be good approximations for the stable case for all z / L measured but the range of validity in the unstable case is extremely small, certainly less than z / L = 0.3. V. Turbulence in Stably Stratified Fluids
The energy equation (3.9) provides the key to the basic difference between turbulent convection as studied in Section IV and the subject of this section. In the former, the term wlbl= - q provides a source of turbulent energy and in the latter it provides a sink of turbulent energy. It is not surprising that the two kinds of turbulence are very different. Measurements of mean temperatures or salinities in fluid systems normally reveal that the fluid is stably stratified. As we have seen, exceptions are found in the lowest layers of the atmosphere when the air is being heated by the underlying surface and in laboratory experiments with convection, although even in the convection experiments there is often a stable region in the middle of the container away from the heated lower surface and the cooled upper surface (Gille, 1967; Chu and Goldstein, 1973). This phenomenon may be related to the conjecture that the main portion of the liquid core of the earth is stably stratified (W. V. R. Malkus, personal communication, 1975). Recent measurements in the upper layers of the oceans reveal a stable or neutral density distribution even when the surface is losing heat (J. D. Woods, personal communication, 1975)although the failure to find an unstable layer just below the surface may be due to instrumental difficulties. One of the basic features of turbulent, stably stratified fluids is the persistent appearance of layers (sometimes called interfaces), with strong density increase with depth, between layers with little density variation (Stommel and Fedorov, 1967; Woods, 1968; Turner, 1973). Examples in bodies of water are given in these references. The atmosphere also is typified by nearly neutral layers separated by thin layers (inversions) in which potential density decreases rapidly with height. Oceanographers, meteorologists, and engineers have a considerable interest in problems related to the existence, erosion, and motion of interfaces
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
51
between fluids of different densities and the related problems of momentum, heat, and salt fluxes across these surfaces. An example of the practical importance of these studies is artificial destratification of reservoirs to improve water quality in the hypolimnion (stagnant region below the thermocline). One method involves the pumping of fluid from the hypolimnion through a tube and discharging the water into the epilimnion in a jet downward from the free surface. The heavy discharged water moves down to the interface 'and the mixing in the upper layer and the turbulence generated by the jet erodes the interface causing it to weaken, move downward, and eventually disappear (Brush, 1970). Geophysical implications of mixing across density interfaces are numerous. In the oceans, for example, suddenly increased stress forces exerted by the wind at the water-air surface will increase the turbulence and cause the upper mixed layer to increase in depth at a rate dependent on the stress, the instantaneous depth of the layer, the density jump across the interface, and, perhaps, other effects (Kato and Phillips, 1969; Kraus and Turner, 1967). A. EXPERIMENTS WITHOUT SHEAR
A number of laboratory experiments have been designed to help understand the problem. The first was by Rouse and Dodu (1955) and consisted of a vessel with two layers of liquid of different densities. A grid of metal bars was oscillated in the upper layer with a small stroke a, and observations were made of the entrainment velocity u, or the downward velocity of propagation of the interface. We sometimes idealize by considering the density to be discontinuous. Actually, the interface is a thin layer of thickness 1-2 cm. The thickness is independent of the Richardson number (Moore and Long, 1971; Wolanski, 1972; Crapper and Linden, 1974; Wolanski and Brush, 1975), and may be proportional to the depth of the mixed layer (Long, 1973). A detailed understanding of the turbulence in this experiment has not yet been achieved but Linden (1973) has performed allied experiments and has suggested that the large eddies in the upper mixed layer deflect the interface downward, storing potential energy. When this is released by upward motion, a portion of the heavier fluid is ejected into the homogeneous layer and then carried away by the turbulent eddies, leaving the interface sharp again. The experiment of Rouse and Dodu is typical of those without shear and the only source of energy is the energy flux divergence term of Eq. (3.9).We will see that similar experiments have been constructed with shear (Section
Robert R. Long
52
V,B). This yields an energy supply which is of great importance in oceanic and atmospheric motions. Cromwell (1960) constructed a similar experiment to simulate the pycnocline, but the first reliable data were obtained by Turner (1968). Turner ran two different experiments. One was similar to that described above; the other had stirring in both layers. In the first experiment the lower fluid was agitated and fluid was withdrawn from the stirred layer at a rate adjusted to keep the interface at the same distance from the grid. The entrainment velocity is then defined by Au, = Q, where Q is the volume withdrawn per unit time and A is the cross-sectional area of the tank. In the second experiment both layers are turbulent and, with the same stirring action by the two grids, the interface stays at midpoint. Theoretical considerations of the experiments involve the concept of buoyancy b, defined in Eq. (3.4). In all experiments, the density difference is very small so that the Boussinesq approximation is a very good one. As we see in Eqs. (3.5)-(3.7), since there is only one stratifying element (either salt or temperature), this means that b is the only quantity involving density or gravity entering the analysis. In the one-grid experiment with the upper level mixed, if the interface is allowed to move downward at speed u, (no fluid added or subtracted), the buoyancy flux q satisfies the equation,
aq/az = ab/at
(5.1) obtained by averaging Eq. (3.7) and assuming that all mean quantities are homogeneous horizontally. 6 is the mean buoyancy in the upper layer and z = 0 at the top of the layer. In Eq. (5.1), 6changes little with height in the mixed layer and we may integrate to obtain the flux q at the interface, q = Dd(Ab)/dt, where Ab is the buoyancy jump across the interface and q the layer. We may also write
(5.2) = 0 at the top of
q = [d(DAb)/dt]- u,Ab.
(5.3) Let us apply considerations of mass continuity but to an experiment somewhat more general than this, in which there is initially a basic density variation p ( z ) (Fig. 13). The upper portions are agitated and a mixed layer forms of nearly constant density p1 and depth D. In time dt the interface depth increases to D + dD. Conservation of mass yields (P1
+ dPl)(D + dD) = P P ) dD + P1D.
This may be written d(DAb) = D dD(db/dD),
(5.4)
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
53 Z
=O
FIG. 13. Erosion of a stratified fluid.
where b(z) is the original buoyancy distribution in the fluid at rest. In the Rouse and Dodu experiment, the lower fluid has a uniform density, so db/dD = 0 and DAb is constant. Therefore, from Eq. (5.3), q = - u, Ab. This result may be used to define an entrainment velocity when both layers are agitated. In this case, if p o is the average of the densities of the two mixed layers, the buoyancy flux at the interface is q = ( 0 / 2 ) d(Ab)/dt and we may define the entrainment velocity to be
ue
= - - 'z(D/Ab)[d(Ab)/dt].
Quantities on the right-hand side are all easily measured. There have been a number of recent experiments similar to those of Rouse and Dodu and of Turner, for example, by Brush (1970). Equipment identical to that of Turner was constructed by Wolanski (1972; see also Wolanski and Brush, 1975), and the one- and two-grid experiments were run with stratification caused by heat, salt, sugar, suspensions of sediments and minute silica spheres. Additional experiments have been run in Turner's apparatus by Linden (1973), Crapper (1973), and Crapper and Linden (1974) using heat and salt. Baines (1975) has studied a similar experiment with entrainment caused by a jet impinging on an interface. An important finding in the experiments by Turner (1968) may be expressed as
u e / o = C[02/(Ab)]", (5.5) where o is the frequency of the oscillating grid and C is independent of o and Ab. A number of lengths are kept constant in the experiment so that the dimensional quantity C may vary with these. Turner found that for larger values of A b / o z , the exponent n = 1 when stratification is caused by temperature differences and n = 3/2 when caused b y differences in salt content.
54
Robert R . Long
Later investigations (Wolanski, 1972) have confirmed these results and, very recently, Crapper and Linden (1974) have shown rather convincingly that the difference in the values of n is due to the influence of the relatively large molecular conductivity k, in the heating experiments (the coefficient k, is much smaller for salt). It appears that whenever the n = 1 law describes the entrainment, the thin layer of strong density variation has an inner layer or core in which molecular diffusion is important. Indeed, earlier unpublished experiments by Claes Rooth (Turner, 1973) support this interpretation. Rooth found a 312 dependence in heating experiments when larger turbulent velocities are generated. Thus it appears well established that the 312 dependence is appropriate for larger Peclet numbers, Pe = ouIlk, or ouIlk,, where o and 1 are the velocity and length units of the turbulence discussed in Section 11. Crapper and Linden suggest a threshold value of Pe z 200 when =a : and 1 = I’ are characteristic of the turbulence near the interface. The dependence on Reynolds number Re has not been established because of the rather small ranges of Re in the experiments, but both Wolanski (1972), who varied Re by a factor of three, and Crapper and Linden (1974) report very weak dependence, if any. We may, therefore, write for large Pe and Re, and strong stability, u,/m = C , w ~ / ( A ~ ) ~ ” ,
(5.6)
where CI is a function of a , D, and the lengths a , , a , ..., characteristic of the grid. It is convenient to introduce a dimensionless quantity K, by the definition
C , = a 4 D - 3 / Z K , ( a / Dala,, , a/a2 ...)
(5.7)
and, therefore, uJu* = K, Ri*-3/2, Ri* = D A b / u i , (5.8) where u* = ma. It is likely that K , is independent of a / D when this ratio is small.
B. EXPERIMENTS WITH SHEAR Several experiments have been constructed to introduce shearing currents in turbulent density-stratified systems in an effort to simulate atmospheric and oceanic phenomena. The first of these of direct relevance to our discus‘The independence of molecular quantities is common in turbulence as we learned in Section 11. In Turner’s original paper (1968). he expressed the belief that the n = 1 law was the fundamental one and that in some manner the very low dihsitivity of salt caused the n = 3/2 law. He has changed his mind on the basis of the evidence we present here (Turner, 1973).
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
55
sion was that of Kato and Phillips (1969).The apparatus was a large circular annular channel filled with salt water with an initial linear density gradient. A constant stress t = u: was applied by rotating a flat screen at the surface. For larger values of Ri*, they found u,/u* = K ,
Ri*-’,
(5.9)
where Ri* is of the same form as in Eq. (5.8) and Ab is the buoyancy jump from the upper mixed layer to the quiescent region below.+ It is important for later purposes to present an analysis of the relationship between u* and U , where U is the speed of the screen in the experiment of Kato and Phillips. They found that U / u , increased with time (or depth) with u* held fixed. At first glance one might expect this to be an influence of the stable density distribution in the fluid system, but on closer consideration it seems more reasonable to neglect Ab entirely and consider the flow and turbulence in the upper layer as turbulent flow due to the motion of a rough plate at z = 0 with the interface at z = D serving only to reduce the mean velocity to zero at that level. This is supported by a description by Kato and Phillips: “The movement [of a line of hydrogen bubbles] indicated that the mean velocity varied most rapidly near the screen and near the entrainment interface, being almost constant in the central region, where the velocity was typically about half that of the screen.” The mean motion seems very close to that in turbulent plane Couette flow (Robertson, 1959), and a theory for the ratio U / u , may be obtained by use of the technique of Izakson (1937) and Millikan (1939) discussed in Sections I1 and IV. We assume for the mean velocity near the screen (in a coordinate system moving with the screen) tilu* = f ( z / z o ) ,
where zo is the roughness length (Section I1,C) and @(z)is the mean velocity. In the interior we adopt the velocity-defect law (Monin and Yaglom, 1971) (U/2
~-
a) = m l ( i ] .
(5.10)
u*
The defect law should hold near z = zo so that we may match the two expressions for in this region. Writing U / 2 u , = rn,(z,/D), z o / D = q, z/zo = 8, we get m * h ) - f @= ) m1(@). More recent experiments have been run in the Kato and Phillips apparatus using a lower fluid of uniform density (Kantha, 1975). The results d o not yield a simple power law but rather a faster and faster decrease of u, with Ri*. It is possible, however, that molecular viscosity becomes more and more important at the higher values of Ri*.
Robert R . Long
56
The same procedure as in Section I1 yields
u - -2 u*
);(
In
-
+ A,,
K
where K is von Karman's constant and A , is another constant. Kato and Phillips supply data for U ( t )for some of their experiments and, although the paper contains an empirical equation for D(t),it does not agree with the data over the whole time period of the experiment. However, one case permits a comparison and this is shown in Fig. 14 in which the theoretical curve is
U ~
u* 30
I
1
=
(f)
-
+ 5.78.
. . . . ... ..
I
I
1
0
25
In D ( t ) I
.
(5.1 1) '
I...'.
1 .
6
* I
.
O
-
D
-
3
10
-
. O
-
5 -
0
-
1
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
I
I
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
180
200
220
240
The single constant was chosen to give U = 27.25 cm/sec at t = 200 sec. The solid curve in the figure is a plot of Eq. (5.11) in which D ( t ) is given by curve 11, Fig. 5 of Kato and Phillips (1969). The data points are from Fig. 3 of Kato and Phillips. All experiments have the same buoyancy gradient. The agreement is remarkable and leaves little doubt that U / u , is independent of the Richardson number which varied by a factor of 100 over the course of the experiments. Evidently it is not necessary to invoke sidewall friction as in Pollard et al. (1973) to explain the leveling off of the speed of the driving screen at large times.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
57
The work of Pollard, Rhines, and Thompson deserves further discussion. They assume for the Kato and Phillips experiment that the stress exerted by the moving plate is used entirely to accelerate the mixed layer, i.e., d(iiD)/dt = u: or iiD = u i t , where ii is the mean velocity in the upper layer. They also assume, based on several speculative arguments, that the overall Richardson number is equal to one, i.e., DAb/ii2 = 1. Finally from Eq. (5.4) Lib = N2D/2,
where N is the Brunt-Vaisala frequency, N 2 = -db/dz, in the lower, inert layer. A combination of these results leads to D =21/4t1/2~*/N1/2. (5.12) This expression agrees rather well with the data, although it differs from the law chosen by Kato and Phillips. On the other hand, if we assume a relationship of the form u,/u* = const(u:/DAb)”,
Equation (5.12) implies n = 4.Such an entrainment law is not in good agreement with the data over any range. Indeed Niiler (1975)generalized the approach of Pollard, Rhines, and Thompson and obtained a t 1 l 3 law for the initial deepening, again yielding n = 1 as reported by Kato and Phillips. An experiment by Moore and Long (1971) was constructed to permit a steady state. In a large channel shaped like a race track, fluid was injected from nearly horizontal jets at bottom (salt water) and top (fresh water) in opposite directions to obtain a shearing current (Fig. 15). Mean zero vertical velocities were achieved by withdrawing equal volumes of fluid through
-
I
-I
58
Robert R . Long
numerous holes at bottom and top. At larger values of the density difference, two homogeneous layers existed at top and bottom with an interface in the middle. The salt water in the jets comes from a reservoir and the withdrawn fluid at the bottom is pumped back into the reservoir which is kept at a constant level. The jets at the top are of tap water and the slightly salty withdrawn fluid at the top is pumped to waste. Since the fluid returned from the bottom to the reservoir is somewhat less salty than that in the lower jets, salt must be added continually to keep the reservoir at a fixed density. The added salt is transported vertically by the turbulence. The salt flux is known, of course, and this can be used directly to compute the buoyancy flux. The experiment yielded =
K~(Au)~/D
(5.13)
over a range ofDAb/(Au)2of 1-60, where Au is the velocity difference between mean velocities measured near the top and bottom. If we define the entrainment velocity by -u,Ab = q, Eq. (5.13) yields the same result as in Kato and Phillips (Eq. (5.9), if, as seems very likely from the discussion of the Kato and Phillips experiment, Au/u, is independent of the Richardson number, where u: is the constant momentum flux in the tank. Moore and Long also ran unsteady experiments similar to those of Kato and Phillips with a fluid with initial linear buoyancy gradient and subject to the systems of jets and withdrawals at the bottom only. They obtained the result D a t1l3. Since Eq. (5.9) may be written
dDldt
= K,u:
JDAb
and since Eq. (5.4) indicates that Ab cc D in erosion of a linear density gradient, the behavior D a t1I3 is consistent with Eq. (5.9). The velocity observations by Moore and Long apparently relate to those found by Kato and Phillips. Moore and Long report a velocity distribution with strong shears at top and bottom and across the density interface region. This, of course, is exactly the behavior to be expected from plane Couette flow in each layer (see Fig. 17 on p. 68). Finally, in a recent experiment by Wu (1973), the source of energy and shear was a current of air blowing over a vessel containing a two-fluid system. Wu also obtained Eq. (5.9) although his coefficient of proportionality was much smaller. He conjectured that this was because of the very different shear produced in a closed container, but Bo Pedersen (private communication) has suggested that the flow at the interface may have been laminar over much of the length.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems C.
COMPARISON OF EXPERIMENTS WITH AND
WITHOUT
59
SHEAR
The different dependence on Ri* for the two experiments has been the source of perplexity (Turner, 1973; Linden, 1973) because the mixing processes appear to be very similar. Indeed, Linden has stated that the Kato and Phillips data are also consistent with a -312 behavior, although support for the statement seems lacking. We attempt below to construct a unified understanding of the two results. Turner (1973) has made the valuable suggestion that the erosion of the interface should depend on the properties of the turbulence near the interface, in particular on the rms velocity a: and the integral length scale I' near the interface. Thus, he proposed the form ue/o; = F(Ri,),
Ri,
=
I'Ab/02,
(5.14)
where possible dependence on other quantities is suppressed and it is assumed that Pi: and Re are large. In an attempt to determine the dependence on Ril from his density-interface experiments, in which a: and 1' were not measured, Turner used experimental data by Thompson and Turner (1975) in Turner's apparatus with a homogeneous Jluid and one grid. They measured a, and 1 at many levels, where a, is the rms velocity and 1 is the integral length scale at depth z. They found that 0;was proportional to w and that 1 increased linearly with distance from the grid but was independent of w. Although Thompson and Turner's experiment had no density variation, Turner (1973), Thorpe (1973), and Crapper and Linden (1974) have assumed that the results are directly applicable to the mixing experiments. Thus, at z = D they use al/wa = C 2 ( a / D ,a/a,, a/a2 ...)
I'/D = C,(a/a,, a/a2 ...)
(5.15) (5.16)
so that Eq. (5.8) may be written u,/a: = K, Ril3I2,
K4 = K,(a/D, ala,, aja2 ...).
(5.17)
Neglecting viscosity,' the proportionality of a: and w follows from dimensional analysis but only when theJluid is homogeneous because the presence of an interface introduces a new quantity involving time, namely, Ab. We may also obtain a dependence on Ri, for the shearing experiments. With shear and horizontal homogeneity the averaged x-equation of motion yields
ariaz = aqat,
(5.18)
However, wu is analogous to the speed of the plates Au in plane Couette flow. In the latter case it is known that the Reynolds number is involved in the relation between Au and turbulent velocities. Thus oL/wu may vary with the viscosity coefficient. +
Robert R . Long
60
where ti is the mean horizontal velocity at depth z. In the steady state experiments of Moore and Lon11971), &/az = 0 and therefore t is constant with height. Since t = -u’w‘, and since the correlation coefficient is very likely to be of order one in the mixed layers, it follows that u* = is proportional to a;. The interface introduces the length D and it seems reasonable that the eddies fill the whole depth as they would if the interface were a rigid surface. Thus we use I’ D and obtain
-
u,/a; = K , Ri;‘
(5.19)
for the Moore and Long experiment. In the experiment of Kato and Phillips, we may use Eq. (5.18) to obtain the increment of t over the depth D.It is Ar/r
-
UDlTU:,
(5.20)
where is the time period for a change of depth of order D so that ?I. Dlu, . Therefore, ignoring sidewall effects,
-
At/r = (U/u,)(u,/u,) = Ri*-’.
-
(5.2 1)
This reveals that the stress varies very little over the depth, that u* a;, and that Eq. (5.19) again holds. Thus, two different entrainment velocities, Eqs. (5.17) and (5.19), are indicated in the two cases even when the characteristics of the eroding eddies are the same and this is more perplexing than the difference in the exponent of Ri*. The discussion below questions the applicability of Thompson and Turner’s experiment, in particular Eq. (5.15), to an experiment with a density interface and suggests that Eq. (5.17) is incorrect. D. ENERGY ARGUMENTS A different dependence of a;/u, or a;/oa on Ri* in experiments without shear may be obtained by a plausible argument. When there is shear, we have seen that experiment indicates
q
- oi31D - .:ID.
(5.22)
-
Let us now evaluate q in the mixed layer near the interface. We get q aka; where a; is the rms buoyancy fluctuation near the interface, and we make the plausible assumption that the correlation coefficient is of order one. Thus o;’J&
D
-
1
(5.23)
so that kinetic energy and available potential energy, obD (see the discussion in Section 111) are of the same order in the mixed layer. Although the layer has very little density variation, this result may be obtained by considering
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
61
first an experiment with very strong turbulence imposed externally. Then a12/abI' will be very large. As we decrease the turbulence in successive experiments, this ratio will decrease, If turbulence continues to exist, the ratio has a lower limit because aL2/abI' <: 1 would imply that T' < V' and a consequent cessation of the turbulence a5 we discussed in Section 111. It seems unlikely that the ratio will get large again as stability increases so that a12/ab1 should approach a constant. The argument is equally valid with or without shear. Using Eq. (5.23) when shear is absent to eliminate ob in the relationship q u, Ab a; a;, the - 312 law leads to
-
-
u,/u*
-
0L3/Du,Ab
or a:/u*
-
-
Ri*-
u:/(DA~)~'~
(5.24)
(5.25)
'I6
instead of Eq. (5.15). The decrease of rms velocity with increase of Richardson number when density variations are present may be caused by the weak density gradient in the mixed layer. In a layer as a whole, the slight density variation still has dynamic importance as indicated by the proportionality of kinetic energy and available potential energy and by the fact that 4,varying linearly in the layer, has a relatively large value near the interface. Such arguments have been advanced earlier by the author (Long, 1972, 1973). The energy argument may be amplified. Rouse and Dodu (1955) and others (Kato and Phillips, 1969; Turner, 1973; Wu, 1973) have suggested that the Ri*-' law implies that the change of potential energy is proportional to the energy supply by the external source. Thus, as we have seen in Section I11 the average rate of increase of potential energy per unit mass is 4, so that the rate of increase of potential energy for the system is proportional to 4D. In the Kato and Phillips experiment, for example, the rate of working of the external force is r U . If these are proportional, q
- rU/D
u:/D
(5.26)
as in Eq. (5.22). The same conclusion cannot be reached for cases without shear and on this basis it may be argued that the Ri*-3'Z law does not conform to any simple energy argument. We may show, however, that the last conclusion is not correctly drawn. The energy equation, Eq. (3.9), for experiments with or without shear is
ar/at= -d[w'( T' + p'/p,)]/az
-
+ ruz + 4 - E,
(5.27)
where ii, = 0 in the experiment without shear. In the shearing experiments, the velocity difference is proportional to r112, and the two energy-source terms, as well as the dissipation E , are of order aL3/D or oL3/l' near the
62
Robert R . Long
-
-
interface. If q u,Ab is also of this order, we obtain u,/a: Ri;' as in Eq. (5.19). When shear is absent, the single source term is the first term on the right-hand side of Eq. (5.27) and is also of order 0L3/l'.The Ri; law again implies equality of all sink and source terms. The correct interpretation of experimental results thus seems to be that the turbulence has a character that causes potential energy to increase at a rate proportional to the rate at which kinetic energy is supplied to the region of the interface and not necessarily proportional to the rate of generation of kinetic energy at the external source. An additional piece of information may be added in relation to experiments without shear. If we assume that the small buoyancy difference across the mixed layer is of order of the rms buoyancy fluctuation (implying an eddy length scale of the order of the depth of the layer), Eq. (5.23) and Eq. (5.25) lead to
'
-
Ab/Ab
-
Ri*-413.
(5.28)
This quantity was measured by Wolanski (1972) and Wolanski and Brush (1975) for the salt experiments (Fig. 16). There is good agreement with Eq. (5.28), especially at higher values of Ri*. 10'
Ai Ab
,o-'
10
FIG.16. Buoyancy difference across mixed layer as function of Richardson number.
When there is shear, a: in Eq. (5.23) is of order u* and ob is of order so that abD/ug 1 and ab/Ab is proportional to Ri*-'. Notice also that in the mixed layer the velocity shear is ii, u* /D,as we see in Eq. (5.10). Thus the
-
-
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
63
gradient Richardson number Ri = 6z/(Q2is of order one in the mixed layer. Observations in the lower mixed layer in the atmosphere (Businger et al., 1971) indicate that this has a maximum of Ri, z 0.20 and we may speculate that this is the magnitude of Ri in the mixed layer in the experiment. As we have already suggested, Ri 1 means that the slight density gradient in the mixed layer has dynamical significance. We have suggested that
-
u,/o,= K,o:/DAb
(5.29)
is a universal law for entrainment with or without shear, where ouis the rms velocity at or near the interface. Let us apply this to an experiment without shear, as in Turner’s experiment except that the lower quiescent fluid has a linear density gradient. If we also adopt the findings ofBouvard and Dumas (1967) and Thompson and Turner (1975) that ou is proportional to D-3’2, then since Ab = N2D/2, where N 2 is the buoyancy gradient in the lower fluid, we find that D cc t z / l s . This behavior was proposed by Linden (1975) and his experiments with this type of fluid system provided close verification of this time dependence. These experiments, therefore, provide considerable support for the form proposed in Eq. (5.29). E. IMPLICATIONS OF LABORATORY EXPERIMENTS AND OBSERVATIONS IN THE ATMOSPHERE AND OCEANS As we have noted, interfaces or inversions are common in the atmosphere, and properties of the mixed layer near the ground have been measured frequently from meteorological towers. Velocity observations indicate that the mean profile is linear over the upper part of the layer (Businger et al., 1971). This implies that the flux Richardson number Rf = q/zUz becomes a constant if we ignore the small variations of the fluxes in the layer. The constant value of Rf seems to be about 0.20 in the atmosphere (Businger et al., 1971). This compares with the value of0.05 estimated for the oceans by Kullenberg (1971). We may also mention the experiments of Arya and Plate (1969) with air blowing down a wind tunnel over a cooled surface. They found, as in the atmosphere that Rf increases with height from near zero just above the cooled surface. The measurements ended at Rf 2 0.06 and did not extend high enough to establish an asymptotic behavior. Various measurements in the laboratory by Ellison and Turner (1960a,b) indicate values closer to those in the atmosphere, i.e., Rf, 2 0.15. In this connection, we may compute Rf, in Kato and Phillips’ experiment. Since we have decided that the flow closely resembles turbulent plane Couette flow of a homogeneous
64
Robert R . Long
fluid, we may use the data of Robertson (1959) to estimate the shear in the interior region. He measures 17,z 8.2u,/H, where H is the distance between the plates. Taking the average buoyancy flux in the layer as 4 = u,Ab/2 and the relation u, = 2.4u:/DAb found by Kato and Phillips, we get Rf, 2 u,Ab/2u:iiz = 2.4J16.4 z 0.15 (5.30) close to other laboratory results and to estimates in the atmosphere. We may also calculate the constant value of the ratio R = abl/a: in the mixed layer (Eq. 3.17 with abz 6,l). We have (5.31) Rf, = q/zU, = 0.15 Z 0.3a,abD/8.2u:, where we have estimated the correlation coefficient in w" as 0.3 (Arya and Plate, 1969). Using the estimate a,,, = l.lu* (Section II,C) and D = 31 (Section II,B) we obtain R s 1.0. (5.32) Although we compute this in the shearing experiment, the same result is likely to hold in experiments such as Turner's where shear is absent. Thus this critical value of R may be more generally useful than a critical flux Richardson number since Rf -+ co when there is no shear. Typical measurements in the atmosphere show an increase of Ri and Rf with height until both reach asymptotic values near 0.20 and then a sudden transition to laminar flow. This indicates the presence of an inversion commonly found above the mixed layer. In one instance at Tsimlyansk, USSR, the inversion and mixed layer were probed by a thermocouple moved up and down over a depth of 6 meters (Businger and Arya, 1974). The signal reveals an inversion between 2 and 4 meters. Velocities were also measured and Richardson numbers computed. The motion becomes laminar at Ri, r 0.2 1. As found by Businger et al. (1971) both cp, and cp,,, introduced in Eq. (4.78) have the form cp = a + b[ for the whole range of [ = z/L in stable conditions. They give
+ 4.7L (P,, = 0.74 + 4.7[.
cp, = 1
(5.33)
An explanation may be offered for the behavior iiz = const, 6, = const in the upper portion of the mixed layer (Wyngaard, 1973). In the lower portions the relevant length scale is z. As z/L increases the argument contends that this scale should be reduced by the increasing stability until, ultimately, the length should become independent of z. The only length scale is then L. Thus it is argued that iiz and 6, should depend only on T and q and are therefore constants. The explanation is appealing at first glance except that observations indicate a maximum z approximately equal to L so that z/L never
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
65
becomes large. In addition the success of the assumption that stability may be neglected in computing U / u , in Kato and Phillips’ experiment indicates that the eddies are as in plane Couette flow and are not influenced strongly by the stability. As indicated by Eqs. (4.78) and (5.39, the data show that = KiiIKm = ( P m l q h
(5.34)
is roughly constant with increase of [, but the scatter is considerable. There is some controversy about the value of u in neutral conditions, a, = l/cp,,(O). Other investigators suggest values closer to one (Dyer and Hicks, 1970) in the atmosphere although the higher value of 1.35 is closer to laboratory measurements (Page et a/., 1952). Measurements of u have been made by Ellison and Turner (1960a,b) in a turbulent, stably stratified liquid. They found that u decreased with stability from a neutral value (Ri = 0) somewhat over one to values of perhaps 0.25 at Ri = 0.50. This trend seems reasonable because stability should inhibit exchange of the stratifying element more than exchange of momentum. Momentum can be transmitted by internal gravity waves in a nonturbulent or turbulent stratified fluid, whereas turbulence must exist to transmit any appreciable amounts of heat or salt or other element. It appears fairly definite that turbulence does not exist in the atmosphere when the gradient Richardson number Ri exceeds 0.20 or so. We also came to the conclusion that the Richardson number is of order one (possibly 0.20 or so) in the mixed layer in laboratory experiments. In the Ocean we have the belief of Woods (1968) that Ri does not exceed 1 or so when turbulence exists. This seems to be contradicted by old observations in the Kattegat (Jacobsen, 1913; Proudman, 1953) where diffusivities several orders of magnitude greater than molecular were observed at measured Ri of 4-10. However, in recent years we have come to realize that most bodies of water are typified by thin layers of order of tens of centimeters thick in which velocity and density change rapidly (Kullenberg, 1974), so that one must use observations that are very closely separated in the vertical to obtain the correct local values of ir, and 6,.The Kattegat observations were widely separated vertically. The importance of the separation distance is also revealed by the experiments of Moore and Long (1971). It was possible to obtain overall Richardson numbers based on buoyancy and velocity differences from top to bottom of the channel up to values of 100. Nevertheless the gradient Richardson number Ri nowhere exceeded 2-3 ! The maximum Ri were measured in the stable layer in the middle. Since the transfer of salt through this layer was at least as order of magnitude greater than the molecular transfer, turbulence (perhaps intermittent) certainly existed at values of Ri in excess of one but still of order one.
Robert R. Long
66
T
The Monin-Obukhov length may be examined in the mixed layer. Since , : a q a"a b , we get L T 3 I 2 / q a:/.b . (5.35)
- - 02,
-
Since a b 1 we find that the eddy size is proportional to the MoninObukhov length. On the assumption that the eddies fill the whole layer, we also find L D. Quantitatively, using the same approximations as those above, we have
-
L = u:/K~ E 20.
(5.36)
The atmospheric observations suggest a value slightly larger than D. Kitaigorodskii (1960) found 4 D r 1.2 for the mixed layer in the oceans, and recently Sundaram (1973) has computed L/D E 0.25 for a lake.
F. EDDYVISCOSITY AND EDDYDIFFUSIVITY In almost all applications of turbulence theory (except Lumley, 1972), assumptions are made of the form -
W A= - K ( d A / a z ) ,
(5.37)
where A is some scalar quantity, perhaps velocity, buoyancy, kinetic energy, etc. Among other things these gradient transport models require for their validity that the scale of the eddies be small compared with the scale of the mean property (Corrsin, 1974; Lumley and Khajeh-Nouri, 1974). Since this is generally violated in turbulent systems, doubt is cast immediately on this approach. The almost universal assumption of the gradient transport approach is that K is positive, i.e., that the transport is down the gradient. This is certainly the usual case but exceptions exist. For example, in laboratory experiments with turbulent convection with a lower heated surface and upper cooled surface, the heat transport is always upward but in fact at modest values of the Rayleigh number the temperature actually increases with height over a large interior portion of the fluid (Gille, 1967; Chu and Goldstein, 1973; Townsend, 1976). The same countergradient flux occurs in the upper portions of atmospheric layers under unstable conditions. Countergradient flux for A = w 2 has also been observed in the lower atmosphere (Wyngaard, 1973). Despite these objections, such quantities as eddy viscosity K , and eddy diffusivity Kbdefined in T = K,ii,
(5.38)
(5.39) 4= have proved to be useful concepts. In the simplest case of developing, one-
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
67
dimensional stratified shearing flow, these definitions lead to the equations (5.40) (5.41)
but this is not immediately helpful unless we can say something about K , and K , . Our hope is to parameterize K , and K,, i.e., to express them in terms of a, 6, z, and t or in some more complicated way to obtain a mathematically determined problem. A common approach in homogeneous flows is to assume K, and K, are constants. This occasionally gives fairly good results, for example, in problems of jets and wakes (Townsend, 1956),but in most cases the approximation is very crude. As we have seen, near a surface K, is not at all constant but is proportional to distance from the surface. Thus the logarithmic layer is lost completely by assuming K, is constant. Constancy of Kb is a very poor assumption in stably stratified fluids. For example, in the Moore and Long experiment, q is a constant but 6, changes enormously from the mixed layer to the stable layer so that K, = q/6z changes enormously, perhaps by as much as three orders of magnitude from the mixed to the stable layer. In homogeneous flows, the eddy viscosity should be a function only of the 6,1 ue H, where H eddy velocity cuand the integral length scale, i.e., K, is the overall dimension of the system, say, the pipe diameter. Locally, in the u* z, of course. Since we have decided that the turlogarithmic layer, K, bulence in a mixed layer in stratified flow is similar to that in a homogeneous fluid, this should be a valid estimate for the mixed layer. If we use Robertson's data that aZ 8.2ue/H, we obtain for the mixed layer
-
-
-.
=
K , = U: D 1 8 . 2 ~z ~0 . 1 2D. ~~
(5.42)
Atmospheric evidence suggests that K , / K , is a constant near one in the stable regime so that this is also an estimate for K b . On the other hand, laboratory investigations of Ellison and Turner (1960a,b) suggest the possibility that Kb is somewhat less than K , , perhaps Kb Z 0 . 0 6 D. ~~ The eddy coefficient K , in the stable layer may be computed for the Kato and Phillips experiment and the Moore and Long experiment. In the former the buoyancy flux q falls from a maximum just above the stable layer to zero at the bottom of the stable layer. Thus q = fu, Ab = K b Ablh,
(5.43)
where h is the thickness of the layer. From the Moore and Long experiment we estimate h = 016, approximately. Using u, = 2.4ui/DAb, we get
K , = .20ueD Ri*-'.
(5.44)
Robert R . Long
68
- -
In the Moore and Long experiment, q ( A u ) ~ / Dand , K b AuD Ri*-',
(5.45)
so that the behavior is similar since Au/u* is independent of the overall Richardson number. The turbulence in the stable layer is presumably intermittent. A computation of K , in the stable layer is more speculative because velocities were not measured at all accurately in either experiment. As we have pointed out, there is no good evidence that any turbulence can exist at large gradient Richardson numbers in shearing flow so that we may assume in the Moore and Long experiment that the gradient Richardson number is a constant of order one as Ri* varies. Also it appeared that the layer over which the strong shear existed had a thickness of order L1 different from h. Thus Ri 1 L:Ab/h(Au)2. (5.46)
Since h
-
-/D -
D, this leads to L1 K,
-
Ri*-li2. Then
zL, /Au
-
-
u, D Ri*-l1*.
(5.47)
This indicates that K b / K , Ri*-'/' so that the disturbances are less capable of transferring heat than momentum. Again this is reasonable because gravity waves can transmit momentum. The assumed constancy of the gradient Richardson number has support from observations in the Moore and Long experiment (Long, 1973). The velocity distribution resembles that in
FIG. 17. Velocity distribution in the Moore and Long experiment.
Fig. 17, similar to two plane-Couette velocity profiles. The shear in the middle increased, in fact, as Ri* increased so that Ri was roughly constant with a value of 2-3 perhaps. The earliest theory for K , / K , was given by Ellison (1957).' As discussed by Ellison and Turner (1960a,b), the theory may be put in the form Kb/K,,, = a,( 1 - Rf/Rf,)/(1 - Rf)2,
(5.48)
The Ellison theory has been reviewed by Yamada (1975) and is discussed at greater length in Section VI. +
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
69
where a, is associated with the value of a in Eq. (5.34) in neutral conditions, where Rf is the flux Richardson number Rf = q/.rii, = Ri(K,/K,), and Rf, is a complicated function of time scales and rms velocities. All shearing experiments indicate that Rf is bounded as Ri gets large; indeed, if ti, is regarded as the important energy-supply term in the energy equation, i.e., if we neglect the energy flux divergence, Rf must always be less than 1. Therefore, for large Ri (assuming turbulence exists), Eq. (5.48) shows that Rf -,Rf, so that a critical value of Rf exists above which turbulence presumably dies out. The data suggest Rf, = 0.05-0.30. At larger values of Ri, perhaps Ri > 0.1,the quantity 1 - Rf/Rf, is small so that we may write, approximately, 1 - Rf/Rf, = E,
K b / K , Z u , E / ( ~- Rf,)2
= [u,/(l - Rf,)2][1
- Ri Kb/Rf, K,]
(5.49)
or
+ [u,/(l
- Rf,)2] Ri/Rf,}.
(5.50) Since the coefficient of Ri in (5.50) is 15-20, for Ri >> 0.1,we would expect the simpler equation Kb/K, = const/Ri. This was indeed found to be true by Kullenberg (1971). A number of investigators, beginning with Rossby and Montgomery (1935) have chosen for stable conditions the relationship K b / K , = [u,/(l - Rf,)2]/(l
Kb = KbO(1
+
(T
Ri)-',
(5.51)
where (T is a constant and KbO is the value of Kb in neutral conditions. This can be derived from Eq. (5.50) if we ignore the (weaker) variation of K, with Ri. For example, Sundaram and Rehm (1973) have applied Eq. (5.51) to a one-dimensional model of a lake. Their numerical time-dependent integrations yield a thermocline. Equation (5.51) has great limitations, however, in that Ri is small in deep water but Kb is certainly small there since it is protected by the thermocline from disturbances of the mixed layer. This was overcome by arbitrarily choosing a low value in deep levels. Sundaram and Rehm form Ri as Ri = 6 , z 2 / ~ ,0 where T~ is the (given) stress at the surface. The diffusion equation now determines the problem, (5.52)
and no additional dynamics is employed. Although Eq. (5.51) is often used in practical applications it is exceedingly crude when compared to recent results from third-order turbulence closure models (Section VI).
70
Robert R . Long
Kullenberg (1971) has proposed a relationship for K , by assuming a constant flux Richardson number Rf = Rf,. Then (5.53)
If the flow is steady, the kinematic stress in the water t equals the surface kinematic stress 70 = t,pa/pw , where pa and pw are the densities of water and air, respectively, and 7, is the kinematic stress exerted by the air. Kullenberg also assumed a constant drag coefficient in the expression 7, = cd U:. His result is
(5.54) The data on the dispersion of die patterns (assuming the same coefficient of diffusion for heat and dye) fit well. Indeed, the theory assumes mainly that q is proportional to ztl, and this is verified well by experiment. He takes Rf, = 0.05, (close to unpublished estimates by Stigebrandt, but rather low compared to our estimates for Kato and Phillips and other estimates) and A limitation as far as parameterization is concerned is the cd = 1.2 assumption that the stress everywhere in the water is equal to the surface stress. According to Eq. (5.18) this would not permit time integration, for example. Also, of course, the assumption that Rf = Rf, is not permissible for Ri < 0.1. G . BUOYANCY FLUX DUETO WAKECOLLAPSE
Long (1970) has attempted to apply the concept of wake collapse to the exchange of buoyancy (heat or salt) in a density-stratified medium. We suppose that a turbulent region (or patch) of linear dimensions I,, volume Vo, is produced by the breaking of internal gravity waves. We assume the region is initially undisturbed with density given by p ( z ) .Waves break and thoroughly mix the patch. It will then tend to flatten out at a level at which the environmental density equals the density of the patch. If the new level is different from that of the original center of mass of the material, heat will be transported vertically by this process. If z, and z , are the heights of the centroid and center of mass, the average value of density for the mixed patch is
or
p p = p ( z c )+ pzz(Z,)Aj 1; + . . .,
(5.56)
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
71
where A, is of order one. Expanding about z = z , , we get
p p = p(z,)
+ p,(z,)Lc + pzz(zm)$L:+ ... + pzr(Z,)A3 1; + ...,
(5.57)
where L, is the height of the centroid above the center of mass. The patch flattens out at height & above the center of mass given by p p = P ( Z , + 4)= p(zm) + Pz(zm)& + . . or ’ 9
~p
+ [Pzz(Zm)A,& ~ z ( z r n ) l .
~c
(5.58)
The distance L, is easily computed. Taking z = 0 at the centroid
where M is the mass of the patch, or (5.59)
or
L,
=
+
(El pz(0)l,” . ..)/(I?, p(0)l;
+ . ..),
(5.60)
where B , , B , ... are of order one. Thus, since we take I, much less than the vertical scale of the motion,
Lc
- PZ(O)IPz/P(O).
(5.61)
The ratio of Lc to A, pZz$ / p , is of order
i r , 2 ( ~ ) / ~ ( O ) P Z , ( O ) (Aiv1,2/1,2PoAP W P O where A p is density difference across the patch. Thus Iv
Lp
Iv
3
- bZL1;/6,
(5.62) (5.63)
and is proportional to the curvature of the buoyancy profile. Notice that the patch rises when the curvature is negative and falls when the curvature is positive. In either case, heat is transported downward. The flux of buoyancy is 4
-
Kb&
(5.64)
7
where K , is the coefficient of eddy diffusion and is given by the product of the mixing length 4 ,the vertical velocity of the patch wp 16, l l i 2 & , and the ratio y of the volume of the turbulent patches to the whole volume, i.e., the intermittency factor (Hinze, 1959). Thus
-
4
- rezI;/ I 6p2.
(5.65)
This formula plays a considerable role in a theory of turbulence in stratified
72
Robert R. Long
fluids by the author (Long, 1970). For example, we may use the theory to indicate that continuous density gradients tend to be unstable. Thus, in
FIG. 18. Instability of continuous density gradients.
Fig. 18, suppose a profile (solid curve) develops an inflection point. Then the buoyancy flux distribution is as shown so that the mean equation ab/at =
aq/az
leads to the development of a profile of the form of the dashed line. Thus, a discontinuity tends to form and the process continues until a sharp interface develops and some other process, perhaps Kelvin-Helmholtz instability, arises to transfer the heat. VI. Third-Order Closure Schemes in Turbulence Research As discussed in Section 11, the central problem in turbulence is to devise of obtaining a closed set of equations for the mean quantities, for some way-~ example uior u: u> . The problem may be circumvented by direct integration of the Navier-Stokes equations on a high-speed computer-also called numerical simulations of turbulent j o w s . This has been done for threedimensional homogeneous, isotropic turbulence by Orszag and Patterson (1972) and for turbulent shear flow by Orszag and Pao (1974). To save computation, the assumption is often made that the turbulence is twodimensional (Herring et al., 1974). The numerical simulation technique holds promise, at least for computers with the higher efficiencies likely in the future. The maximum Reynolds number that can be simulated is far below those of the atmosphere, for example, although present results tend to indicate that phenomena of large scale differ little with an increase of Reynolds number above the “moderate” range (Orszag and Pao, 1974).
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
73
Another technique is numerical simulation with subgrid scale modeling (Deardorff, 1974). Here the grid scale is made as small as possible, bearing in mind the economics of the computations, and the motions on scales below the grid scale are modeled in a convenient way, recognizing that the choice of the modeling assumptions is not particularly important since the precise nature of the dissipation does not bear strongly on the nature of the largescale motions. Again the technique is expensive, prohibitively so perhaps for complicated geophysical phenomena (Lumley and Khajeh-Nouri, 1974). Finally, a number of authors have used the equations for second moments, modeling the unknown third-order terms (Daly and Harlow, 1970; Daly, 1972; Donaldson, 1972a,b; Donaldson et al., 1972; Jones and Launder, 1972; Ng and Spalding, 1972; Mellor, 1973; Naot et al., 1973; Launder, 1975; Launder et al., 1975; Reynolds, 1976). This is a difficult task and the modeling is often done on an ad hoc basis with little or no justification for the assumptions made. The technique permits a large number of constants to enter the analysis. Some authors argue that these constants are universal and need only be calculated once, but the arguments are not convincing and the “constants ” appear likely, in fact, to be unknown functions of the Richardson number, the Rossby number, etc. Nevertheless, some of the calculations are in reasonable agreement with observation both in nature and in the laboratory, and we will present a discussion of one of these investigations in some detail. A. MEANREYNOLDS STRESSMODELOF THE SURFACE LAYER OF THE ATMOSPHERE We cannot present an adequate discussion of the many second-order closure models. Instead we will consider one approach which represents perhaps the simplest possible one for a case in which density variations are fundamentally important (Mellor, 1973). This investigation relates to the surface layer of the atmosphere, i.e., the lowest layer in which rotation may be neglected and the fluxes of buoyancy and momentum may be considered constant. The mean equations are very simple:
a - -+ vuz), az a 0 = - (- b’w’ + k, bz), az
0 = - (- u’w’
a -(w‘w’)= - ap - - b. dZ aZ -
Robert R. Long
74
The equations for the fluctuating components of velocity and buoyancy are aui
-
ax
ati
ay
aZ
auf aP‘ + (u, + ii-au‘ ax + u’- ay + w’-az + w’tr, = - ax + VV2U‘, aul
-
at
awl + av’ - + - = 0, -
(6.5)
+ (u, + a)-auf + u’-ati + w’-au’ = - + VV%‘, (6.6) ax ay aZ ay awl , aw’ a __ aP‘ + v’+ w’- - -(w’w’) = - b + VVW‘, + (u + a)at ax ay az aZ aZ a01
apt
-
-
at
awl
awl
-
-
(6.7)
aw -+ (u’+~)-+v’-+ at ax ay ati
ati
ab w’-+
w’b;=k,V2b’.
aZ
(6.81
We now take the various moments of Eqs. (6.5)-(6.8) and average, assuming a steady state and that all mean quantities are independent of x and y. We obtain
”I
I-
aut
W’U‘U’- v (u’u’) = 2p’ aZ aZ ax - ~u’w’u,- ~ v ( V U ’ ) ~ , a -
-
’1aZa IaZ
-
-
a-l
r
I
aZ
1
aZa (w’w’)
~
~
= 2p’
a aZ
w’u’v‘ - v - (u’u’)
”1
-
I
aZ
-
(ax
auf +-
a
aZ
I-
aui
~
a aZ
aY)
- 2vVu‘
= - - (u’p’)+ p‘
. VV‘,
(6.11) (6.12)
(E+ E) -
-
~~
(w’v’)
a-
= - - (u‘p’) + p‘ aZ
- 2VVV‘ -
(6.10)
-
- u’b’ - w’w‘u, - 2vVu’ . VW‘,
”]
-
I
aul
= p’
(6.9)
a aZ - 2 aZ (w’p’)
awl ~
- 2V(VW’)Z - 2w”,
a -w’u’w‘ - v
-
aY
aZ
aZa a aZ w’u’w’ - y aZ (u’w’)
-
avl __ = 2p’ - - 2V(VU’)Z,
w‘v‘u‘ - v - (v’v’)
w‘w’w’ - v
~
~
-
(6.13)
(TZ) -
+-
. VW’ - u”,
(6.14)
~
w‘u‘b’ - v b - - kh U’
aZ
=
+ p ’ a- b - (V + kh)Vu’ . V b ,
ax
(6.15)
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
75
(6.16)
I
a -w’w‘b‘- vb’
-
a2
awl
--
aZ
khw‘ __
aab = - - (p’b’)+ p ’ - ( V + kh)Vw’ . Vb‘, az az =
- 2khVb ‘ V b .
(6.17) (6.18)
These are difficult and complicated equations and one may take the viewpoint that little has been accomplished in going from (6.1)-(6.8) to (6.9)(6.18).Indeed it is certain that information is lost in the process. One may, on the other hand, adopt the philosophy that the crudity of the approximations which must now be made in modeling such terms as 2p’ du‘/ax, for example, may be a less serious matter than similarly crude approximations for the nature of the Reynolds stress terms in the mean equations by employing, say, the eddy viscosity concept. This is a matter of faith and it must be realized that the successes scored in this approach may reflect the fact that many adjustable constants enter the analysis below and that these may permit agreement of theory and observation. With these reservations we may, however, present the arguments of Mellor (1973). One of the very important terms appearing in Eqs. (6.9)-(6.14)has the form au; au; p ’ - + - . ax)
(axj
(6.19)
Treatment of this pressure-strain correlation dates back to a suggestion by __ that this term may be related to the sought-for Reynolds Rotta (1951) stresses ui u; and derivatives of the mean velocity by the tensor relation (6.20)
A further assumption is that the coefficients are isotopic fourth-order tensors, i.e., Cijkm = c 1 d i j d k m C28ikdjm + c 3 d j k d i m (6.21) with a similar expression for Cijkm.If we contract (6.20), i.e., let i = j and sum, we get, from continuity,
+
(3c1 -k so that C , = - ( C 2
_ _ _ _ _ _ U ; -k U;U; U;U;) = 0
c, + c , ) ( U ;
+ C3)/3.
+
(6.22)
Robert R . Long
76
We obtain = Cl[bijd2 -
an.
aa.
3Ur.: ]+ C2-axj + C’3 2 J axi’
(6.23)
where c‘ is the magnitude of the turbulent velocity. Notice, however, that Eq. (6.20) is a symmetric tensor so that aii.
0 = (c;- C 3 ) >
axj
so that C ;
= C 3 . We
+ (c;- c;)-afij axi
(6.24)
write the results as
au: aUj p‘ 2+- -(axj a x )
aij 3
u!u’.--c
,j+
KC” (aai -+ aaj) , axj
axi
(6.25)
where K is a constant, and Il is an undetermined length. As we have seen in Section 11 and as is obvious in Eq. (6.25), the contribution of this term to the energy equation is zero so that the pressure serves to redistribute energy from the UIz component (which is contributed to directly by the shear production term) to the other two components. It serves therefore to work toward a return to isotropy. In Eq. (6.9),for example, the first term on the right-hand side of (6.25) is
- (c’/3/,)($u.2
-
+p- $p),
(6.26)
and since will generally exceed the other two components (at least this is true in the neutral case), this is negative and the tendency is for to decrease. In (6. lo), the corresponding contribution is (6.27)
z).
This will tend to be positive and cause to increase (at the expense of These are quite reasonable behaviors. __ one In the second term on the right-hand side of (6.25), there is only contribution, namely, in Eq. (6.13). If we combine it with the term - w’w‘uz, we get _(Kc’2 - w’2)uz.
(6.28)
We cannot really judge whether this has a reasonable form. In the case of a homogeneous fluid, K is apparently quite small compared to one and this contribution is not very important. Then the effect of the quantity in (6.28) is to cause u)wI to decrease, i.e., to cause T to increase. In Eq. (6.12), Eq. (6.25) yields - (cr/31,)(ko’) and this is zero because there is no reason for any correlation between u’ and u’. Thus, there is no contribu-
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
77
tion toward an increase o f u ” which is certainly correct. Indeed, we may reasonably presume that all terms in Eq. (6.12)are zero. The same comments apply to (6.14). The pressure terms in (6.15)-(6.17) may be handled similarly. We assume ~
p’(db’/dxJ = ciju;b‘
(6.29)
and assuming that C i j is isotropic, we get C i j = const d i j . The result may be written p’(db’/dXi)= - (Cf/312)u/bl,
(6.30)
where 1, is another length. The dissipation terms in (6.9)-(6.14) may be approached by recognizing that the contribution to these is negligible except in very small eddies. The hypothesis of Kolmogoroff (1941) was that in the energy cascade from large to small eddies, the natural tendency to isotropy would cause these small eddies to be accurately isotropic. Then ~~~
~ ( V U ’ )= ’ v ( V O ’ )= ~ ~ ( V W ’ )= ’ 43
= d3/3A1,
(6.31 )
where A, is another length. Since we expect no correlations, the dissipation terms in (6.12)-(6.14) are zero. The dissipation terms in (6.15)-(6.17) involve correlations between the velocity gradients and buoyancy gradients in the various directions and, since these eddies are isotropic, these correlations must be zero. In (6.18), however, the dissipation term is not zero. It will depend on the properties of the large eddies. With use of the notation of Ellison (1957), energy dissipation may be taken to be E
cc ct2/2T2,
(6.32)
where 2T2 is a dissipation time taken to be 2T2 cc A, /c‘. In (6.18) we may write k , , m cc b’2/2T1
or
k , ( V b ) 2 = c’b’2/A2 ,
2T,
= A2/c’,
(6.33)
where A 2 is another length. The other terms in the moment equations to be modeled are troublesome. Mellor assumed, for example, (6.34) ~
where A, is a length, and then assumed that ufu; are all constants. Altogether
Robert R. Long
78
Mellor ignores all terms in (6.9)-(6.18) involving a/az. This is hardly defensible, but is certainly the simplest situation and we will assume this also. The modeling is now complete, and we may write our results as follows: (c'/31,)(u" - +ct2)+ 2u)wIuz + + C ' ~ / A=~0,
(6.35)
+ 4cf3/A1= 0, (c'/3l1)(w" - 4~")+ $C"/A~ + 2 w " = 0,
(6.36) (6.37)
UIV' = 0,
(6.38)
(c'/311)(v" - ic") __
(C'/311)u"
+ (w"- K C 1 2 ) U Z + u" = 0,
(6.39)
~
wlu' = 0,
+
(6.40)
- _ _
(C'/312)u'b' w'bu,
+ u'w'b,
= 0,
(6.41)
-
v'b = 0,
(6.42)
-~
+ w'w'bz + (c'/3l2)w'b' = 0, 2(d/A,)b'b' + 2w"b, = 0.
b b
(6.43) (6.44)
We now make the following definitions: __
- w'b' = q, C = C'/U,,
C = z/L,
__
- u'w' = u2 * (Pm =
,
(u'2,
KZa,/U,,
P = (U:/q')b'Z,
_
_
d 2 , w'2) = ,'.(:it (Ph
=
,'v
(KZU*/q)6=,
ub = m/q.
w')
L = -U:/qK (6.45)
Mellor assumed that all the lengths were proportional to z, as is true for example in the neutral case (logarithmic layer). This may well be true in the unstable case as well but there is strong reason from the discussion in Section V to believe that the length scale reaches a maximum in the middle of the mixed layer in the stable case, and then decreases with further height, perhaps to zero again at the upper inversion. We may put aside this difficulty temporarily by defining
I , = KA, ZS
A, = K B zS, ~
(6.46)
l2 = KA,zS A2 = KB'zS, where S is an arbitrary function of z. We obtain
(6.47)
+ 3c3/B, + (c/3A,)[u2 - ~ c ' J= 0, ++c3/B1 + ( C / ~ A , ) [ V~ 421 = 0, 2CS + $c3/B, + (c/3A1)[w2- ic'] = 0, -C/3A1 + S(P,,,(W~ - KC') - [Sub = 0,
-29,s
(6.48) (6.49) (6.50) (6.51)
79
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
If we add Eqs. (6.48)-(6.50), we obtain c3 = B,(rp, - 5)s.
(6.55)
Equation (6.54) may be written -
(6.56)
b2 = B 2 q h S / c .
Eliminating w2 in (6.53) by using (6.50) and then using (6.55) and (6.56), we get
(6.57) Eliminating obtain
ub in (6.51) by using (6.52) and using (6.50) to eliminate w 2 ,we
where y = 3 - 2 A , / B l . Equations (6.57) and (6.58) may be used to compute rp, and (Ph as functions of 5 once choices have been made for the behavior of S and values of the constants. Mellor chooses S = 1, thus assuming length scales proportional to z. He assumes values of the constants appropriate to laboratory measurements in the neutral case:
B , = 15.0,
B 2 = 8.0,
A,
= 0.78,
A,
= 0.79,
K
= 0.056.
(6.59) The agreement of rpm and rph with the atmospheric data of Businger el al. (1971) is quite good (Mellor, 1973, Figs. 1 and 2 ) . 1. Similarity Theory for the Unstable Case
The assumption that the lengths are proportional to z, i.e., S = 1, is probably valid in the unstable case since the convection can probably only act to increase the length scale and it is difficult to imagine it increasing with height faster than z. We have three possibilities as 1 [ + co : (a) qmdecreases or increases slower than i. (b) qm+ const <. (c) rp, increases faster than [. We find that (c) is impossible if we examine the asymptotic behavior of
<
80
Robert R. Long
(6.55), (6.57), and (6.58). In (a) we find the results,
This, of course, is entirely in accordance with the similarity theory for the unstable case. Using (6.59), we obtain
1 p3,
c + 2.47 [
(Ph
0.159 I 11-
(Pm -+
1/3,
0.230 I [ 1-
‘I3.
(6.61)
2. Asymptotic Theory for the Stable Case There is another possible solution of (6.57) and (6.58) for S = 1, I[ 1 + CG, corresponding to the possibility mentioned under (b) in the above section. It is
+ (6Al + W B l Y? c3 1(6Al + B2)/Yt q h / l ( B l / 3 A Z ) [ 1 + ( 6 A l + B 2 ) / y B l ] [ ( y - K)(6Al + BZ)/yB1 - ( 6 4 + 3A2)/B11. (6.62) v,/i
+
1
-+
With Mellor’s values for the constants, we have
4.681,
(P,,
c + 3.8111’3,
q h+
5.071.
(6.63)
This result is obviously appropriate to the stable case if we suppose that S = 1. The solution indicates turbulence for arbitrarily large 1, contrary to our findings in Section V that [ has a maximum value of order one a t the top of the mixed layer. We regard the assumption of S = 1 inappropriate although adopted in the paper by Mellor.
B. ELLISON’S DERIVATION OF A CRITICAL FLUX RICHARDSONNUMBER As we mentioned in Section V, Ellison (1957)gave an interesting derivation of a critical flux Richardson number for the stable case by using three equations which may be identijied as identical to three equations of Mellor. They are Eq. (6.44),
the sum of Eqs. (6.35)-(6.37), i.e., the energy equation -7ii,
-q
+ ( ~ “ / 2 T z =) 0,
T2 = A1/2c’
(6.65)
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
81
and Eq. (6.43)
wlZbz + b'2 - (q/2T3) = 0,
T3 = 312/2c',
(6.66)
where we have introduced certain characteristic times used by Ellison. We now introduce the flux Richardson number Rf = - q/Tiiz .
(6.67)
Then Eq. (6.65) may be written q = C" Rf/2T2(Rf - 1).
(6.68)
Equations (6.64) and (6.66) yield q/2 T3 - wlZbz - 2 TI qb, = 0.
(6.69)
If we now introduce the eddy coefficients of diffusion and viscosity, K, and Krn 9
4 = Kbb,,
?
= K,&,
(6.70)
then R f = - (&,/K,,,)(bZ/D:),
6,
=
- (q2/T2)/(Kb/K,) Rf.
(6.71)
Equation (6.69) becomes (6.72)
If we use (6.68) to eliminate q in (6.72), we obtain 1 -+ 2T3
c12fl
2T2(Kb/K,)(Rf - I)?'
+ 4T:(1
2T1 d4 Rf = 0 (6.73) - Rf)2T2(Kb/&,)
or
We may write this as (6.75)
where (6.76)
Since a, > 0, if Rf increases faster than Rf,, K, tends toward zero. It becomes
Robert R. Long
82
zero at Rf = Rf, and then, obviously turbulence no longer exists. We may then regard Rf, as the upper limit of Rf. In computing Rf, ,Ellison assumed TI = T, and took the value c f 2 / pz 5.5 from neutral data. This gives Rf, z 0.15. We have already discussed that Rf seems to have an upper limit in the laboratory and in nature although there is considerable controversy about the value of Rf,. We may subject Ellison’s result to further scrutiny by using the rest of Mellor’s equations. Since Pmli = 1IRf
(6.77)
manipulation of the solution in (6.55)-(6.58) yields i S = Rf(1 - Rf)”’
(1
Rf),/‘/( -Rf2
1 - _Rf)3’4( _ 1 - -Rf)l’“ , (6.78) Rf3 Rf l
where
(6.79)
and where we have used 3B:’3A1(y - K ) = 1.
(6.80)
This follows from (6.58) if we notice that S = 1 and qm= 1 at = 0 since we have the logarithmic layer for small [ with length scale proportional to z. Notice that Rf, < Rf, so that as R f - + Rf,, the length scale increases to infinity. Mellor (1973) and Yamada (1975) have adopted Rf, as the critical flux Richardson number although one can really only say that this is an upper bound for Rf. Mellor’s data yield Rf, = 0.213. We may relate these results to that of Ellison by finding w2/c2 from Eqs. (6.48)-(6.54). We get w’/c’ = y - [6A, Rf/B1(1 - Rf)]
(6.81)
so that from Eq. (6.76),
Rf,
=
B,y(l - Rf) - 6A1 Rf (B2 + B1 y)(l - Rf) - 6A1 Rf
(6.82)
Ellison evaluated Rf, at Rf = 0, i.e., in neutral conditions, so that he obtained, in effect, Rf4 = Bl Yl(B2 + Bl Y).
(6.83)
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
83
Since Rf, > Rf, , Eq. (6.83) is an overestimate of the critical flux Richardson number. Clearly from the viewpoint of Mellor’s theory, Rf, in (6.82) should be evaluated when Rf = Rf, . We then find Rf, + Rf, so that the two theories are not in contradiction. Arya (1972) was the first to emphasize that c2/wz in Ellison’s theory of Rf, should be considered a function of the stability. C. THEORY OF A MIXEDLAYER OF FINITE DEPTH
As we have seen, the flux Richardson number Rf, is reached when the turbulence length scale becomes infinitely large. This presumably can only occur when z is infinity, so that if Rf, is taken to be the critical flux Richardson number, the theory of Mellor does not predict a mixed layer of finite depth as observed. We may examine this by considering the concept of available potential energy introduced in Section 111. We neglected the disturbance pressure gradient in the vertical equation of motion and obtained
w”
- t26, = const.
Using b‘ z - 6,5, we may eliminate wJ2 -
c2 to obtain
(b”/6,) = const = w; ,
where w o is the vertical velocity when the parcel is at the level at which its density is equal to that of the environment. This suggests the importance of the ratio
R = oz/ai Ib,l.
(6.84)
If R exceeds 1, there will be a tendency for the eddies to die out and turbulence to cease. Using Mellor’s theory, we find
+
R = B2 Rf/[yB, - (YB, 6x41) Rf],
(6.85)
and it is remarkable that R precisely equals 1 when Rf = Rf, . On the other hand, our argument neglects the disturbance pressure gradient. This will have the tendency to cause energy to flow from the component of turbulence kinetic energy to the component. This associates eddy motion with values of R less than one. We conclude that Rf < Rf, and therefore that the layer has a finite thickness. When the mixed layer has a finite depth, it may be reasonable to use a simple expression for S which yields a behavior of the length scale similar to that in turbulent plane Couette flow. The simplest choice is
s=
- (C/CD)?
(6.86)
where C D = D/Land D is the depth of the layer. Elimination of q,, between
Robert R. Long
84
(6.57)and (6.58)yields
where
(
Rf)3'4( 4 I , ) ; : 1- _ 1Rf3
a = Rf(1 - Rf)'I2 1 - Rf2
~
. (6.88)
Clearly the maximum flux Richardson number is attained in the middle of the layer at CD = 4a.The value of C D is uncertain but the data of Businger et al. (1971) and Wyngaard and Cote (1971) reveal very few observations above of approximately 1. If we take CD = 1, then a = 4 and the corresponding maximum Rf is 0.135. We may tentatively take this to be the critical flux Richardson number. Finally, with some manipulation, the correlation coefficient __
cwb= w'b'/a,ob
(6.89)
is given by
(6.90) The value corresponding to Rf = 0.135 is Cwbz 0.40.This is perhaps reasonable although somewhat greater than measured values by Arya and Plate (1969).
Launder (1975) has developed a theory with a set of assumptions quite different from those of Mellor. Nevertheless the results are identical except for different values of the constants A,, A,, B1 ...,and the appearance of several new constants. His value for Rf, is 50% larger than that of Mellor. ACKNOWLEDGMENTS The support of the Office of Naval Research under Contract N00014-75-C-0805 and the National Science Foundation under Grant DES 74-23500-A01 is gratefully acknowledged. REFERENCES ARYA,S. P. S . (1972). The condition for the maintenance of turbulence in stratified flows.Q. J. R. Meteor. SOC.98,264-273. ARYA,S . P. S., and PLATE, E. J. (1969). Modeling of the stably stratified atmospheric boundary layer. J. Atmos. Sci. 26, 656-665. BAINES,W. D. (1975). Entrainment by a plume or jet at a density interface. J. Fluid Mech. 68,
309-320.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems I
85
BECHOV,R., and YAGLOM,A. M. (1971). Comments on the theory of similarity as applied to turbulence in an unstably stratified fluid. Izo. Atmos. Ocean. Phys. 7, 829 (Engl. ed.). B~NARD, H. (1901). Les tourbillons cellularies dans une nappe liquide transportant de la chaleur par convections en regime permanent. Ann. Chim. Phys. [7] 23, 62-144. G. (1950). “ Hydrodynamics.” Princeton Univ. Press, Princeton, New Jersey. BIRKHOFF, BOUSSINESQ,J. (1903). “Theorie analytique de la chaleur,” Vol. 2, p. 9. Gauthier-Villars, Paris. BOUVARD,M., and DUMAS,H.(1967). Application de la methode de fil chaud a la mesure de la turbulence dans I’eau. Houille Blanche 22, 257 and 723. BRIDGMAN, P. W. (1931). “Dimensional Analysis.” Yale Univ. Press, New Haven, Connecticut. BRUSH,L. M., Jr. (1970). “Artificial Mixing of Stratified Fluids Formed by Salt and Heat in a Laboratory Reservoir,” R e . Proj. B-024. New Jersey Water Resources Research Institute. K. A., and WATKINS,C. D. (1970). Observations of clear air turbulence by high BROWNING, power radar. Nature (London) 227,26&263. BUSINGER, J. A,, and ARYA,S. P. S. (1974). Height of the mixed layer in a stably stratified planetary boundary layer. Ado. Geophys. 18A, 73-92 1. BUSINGER, J. A., WYNGAARD, J. C., IZUMI,Y., and BRADLEY, E. F. (1971). Flux profile relationships in the atmospheric surface layer. J. Atmos. Sci. 28, 181-189. R. J. (1973).Turbulent convection in a horizontal layer of water. J. CHU,T. Y., and GOLDSTEIN, Fluid Mech. 60,141-159. CORRSIN, S. (1974). Limitations of gradient transport models in random walks and in turbulence. Ado. Geophys. 18A, 25-60. CRAPPER, P. F. (1973). An experimental study of mixing across density interfaces. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Cambridge. P. F., and LINDEN,P. F. (1974). The structure of turbulent density interfaces. J. Fluid CRAPPER, Mech. 65, 45-63. C R O ~J.; F. (1958). The convective regime and temperature distributions above a horizontal heated surface. Q. J. R . Meteor. SOC.84, 418. CROMWELL, T. (1960). Pycnoclines created by mixing in an aquarium tank. J. Mar. Res. 18, 73-82. CSANADY, G. T. (1967). On the resistance law of a turbulent Ekman layer. J. Atmos. Sci. 24, 467-471. CSANADY, G . T. (1972). Frictional currents in the mixed layer at the sea surface. J. Phys. Oceanogr. 2, 498-508. DALY, B. J. (1972). “A Numerical Study of Turbulence Transitions in Convective Flow,” Lab. Rep. LA-DC-72-81. University of California, Los Alamos. DALY,B. J., and HARLOW,F. H.(1970). Transport equations in turbulence. Phys. Fluids 13, 2634-2649. DEARDORFF, J. W. (1974). The use of sub-grid transport equations in a three-dimensional model of atmospheric turbulence. Trans. ASME, Ser. I Pap. No. 73-FE21. DEARDORFF, J. W., and WILLIS,G. F. (1967). Investigation of turbulent thermal convection between horizontal plates. J . Fluid Mech. 28, 675. DONALDSON, C. DuP. (1972a). Calculation of turbulent shear flows for atmospheric and vortex motions. A I A A J. 10, 4-12. DONALDSON,C. DuP. (1972b). “Construction of a Dynamical Model of the Production of Atmospheric Turbulence and the Dispersal of Atmospheric Pollutants.” Am. Meteorol. Soc.Workshop Micrometeorol., Boston, Massachusetts. DONALDSON, C. DuP., SULLIVAN, R. D., and ROSENBAUM, H. (1972). A theoretical study of the generation of atmospheric clear air turbulence. A I A A J 10, 162. DYER, A. J. (1965). The flux-gradient relations near the ground in unstable conditions. Q. J. R. Meteor. SOC.91. 151-157.
86
Robert R . Long
DYER,A. J., and HICKS, D. B. (1970). Flux-gradient relationships in the constant flux layer. Q.J. R. Meteor. SOC. %, 715-721. EKMAN, V. W. (1905). On the influence of the earths rotation on ocean currents. Ark. Mat., Astron. Fys. 2, No. 11. ELLISON, T. H. (1957). Turbulent transport of heat and momentum from an infinite rough plane. J. Fluid Mech. 2,456466. ELLISON, T. H., and TURNER, J. S. (1960a). Mixing of dense fluid in turbulent pipe flow. J. Fluid Mech. 6, 423-448. ELLISON, T. H., and TURNER, J. S. (1960b). Mixing of dense fluid in turbulent pipe flow. Part 2. Dependence of transfer coefficients on local stability. J. Fluid Mech. 8, 529-544. GARON,A. M., and GOLDSTEIN, R. J. (1973). Velocity and heat transfer measurements in thermal convection. Phys. Fluids 16, 1818-1825. GILLE,J. (1967). Interferometric measurement of temperature gradient reversal in a layer of convecting air. J. Fluid Mech. 30, 371-384. GLOBE,S., and DROPKIN, D. (1959). Natural convection heat transfers in liquids confined by two horizontal plates and heated from below. J. Heat Transfer 81, 24. GOLDSTEIN, R. J., and CHU,T. Y. (1969). Thermal convection in a horizontal layer of air. Prog. Heat Mass Transfer 2, 55. HAZEL,P. (1972). Numerical studies of the stability of inviscid stratified shear flows. J. Fluid Mech. 51, 39-61. HERRING, J. R., ORSZAG, S. A., KRAICHNAN, R. H., and Fox, D. C. (1974). Decay of twodimensional homogeneous turbulence. J. Fluid Mech. 66, 417-444. HINZE,J. 0. (1959). “Turbulence.” McGraw-Hill, New York. HOLTON, J. R. (1972). “An Introduction to Dynamic Meteorology.” Academic Press, New York. HOWARD,L. N. (1966). Convection at high Rayleigh number. Appl. Mech. Proc. Int. Congr., Ilth, 1964, pp. 1109-1115. IZAKSON, A. A. (1937). On the formula for velocity distributions near walls. Tech. Phys. USSR 4, 27-37. JACOBSEN, J. P. (1913). Beitrag zur Hydrographie der danischen Gewasser. Medd. Komm.Harunders. Ser. Hyd. 2. JEFFREYS, H. (1926). The stability of a layer of fluid heated from below. Philos. Mag. [7] 2, 833-844. JEFFREYS, H. (1928). Some cases of instability in fluid motion. Proc. R. Soc., London, Ser. A 118, 195-208. JONES,W. P., and LAUNDER, B. E. (1972). The prediction of laminarization with a two equation model of turbulence. Int. J. Heat Mass Transfer 5, 301-314. KANTHA, L. H. (1975). “Turbulent Entrainment at the Density Interface of a Two-Layer Stably Stratified Fluid System,” Tech. Rep. Department of Earth & Planetary Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland. 0. M. (1969). On the penetration of a turbulent layer into a stratified KATO,H., and PHILLIPS, fluid. J. Fluid Mech. 37, 643-655. KAZANSKI, A. B., and MONIN,A. S. (1961). On the dynamical interaction between the atmosphere and the earth’s surface. Izo. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Ser. Geofz. No. 5, pp. 786-788. KITAIGORODSKII, S. A. (1960). On the computation of the thickness of the wind-mixing layer in the ocean. Bull. Acad. Sci. USSR, Geophys. Ser. 3,248-287. KOLMOGOROFF, A. N. (1941). The local structure of turbulence in incompressible viscous fluid for very large Reynolds number. Dokl. Akad. Nauk SSSR 30, 301-305. KOSCHMIEDER, F. L. (1967). On convection under an air surface. J . Fluid Mech. 30, 9-15. KRAICHNAN, R. H. (1962). Turbulent thermal convection at arbitrary Prandtl numbers. Phys. Fluids 5, 1374-1389.
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
87
KRAUS,E. B., and TURNER, J. S. (1967). A one-dimensional model of the seasonal thermocline. 11. The general theory and its consequences. Tellus 19, 98-106. KRISHNAMURTI, R. (1968). Finite amplitude convection with changing mean temperature. J . Fluid Mech. 33, 44-463. KRISHNAMURTI, R. (1970). On the transition to turbulent convection. J . Fluid Mech. 42, 295-320. KULLENBERG, G . (1971). Vertical diffusion in shallow waters. Tellus 23, 129-135. KULLENBERG, G. (1974). Investigation of small-scale vertical mixing in relation to temperature structure in stably stratified waters. Adc. Geophys. M A , 339-352. LAMB,Sir H. (1932). “ Hydrodynamics,” 6th ed., p. 373. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. LAUFER, J. (1954). The structure of turbulence in fully developed pipe flow. Natl. Aduis. Comm. Aeronaut., Rep. 1174. LAUNDER, B. E. (1975). On the effects of a gravitational field on the turbulent transport ofheat and momentum. J . Fluid Mech. 67, 569-581. LAUNDER, B. E., REECE,G. J., and RODI,W. (1975). Progress in the development of a Reynoldsstress turbulence closure. J. Fluid Mech. 68, 537-566. LINDEN,P. F. (1973). The interaction of a vortex ring with a sharp density interface: A model for turbulent entrainment. J. Fluid Mech. 60, 467-480. LINDEN,P. F. (1975). The deepening of a mixed layer in a stratified fluid. J. Fluid Mech. 71, 385-405. LONG,R. R. (1961). “ Mechanics of Solids and Fluids.” Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. LONG,R. R. (1964). “Engineering Science Mechanics.” Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. LONG,R. R. (1965). On the Boussinesq approximation and its role in the theory of internal waves. Tellus 17, 46-52. LONG,R. R. (1970). A theory of turbulence in stratified fluids. J . Fluid Mech. 42, 349-365. LONG,R. R. (1972). Some aspects of turbulence in stratified fluids. Appl. Mech. Rev. 1297-1301. LONG, R. R. (1973). Some properties of horizontally homogeneous, statistically steady turbulence in a stratified fluid. Boundary-Layer Meteor. 5, 139-157. LONG,R. R. (1975). The influence of shear on mixing across density interfaces. J. Fluid Mech. 70, 305-320. LUMLEY, J. L. (1972). A model for computation of stratified turbulent flows. Proc. Int. Symp. Stratified Flows, 1972, Nocosibirsk, USSR, paper 14, 1-9. LUMLEY, J. L., and KHAJEH-NOURI, B. (1974). Computational modeling of turbulent transport. Adu. Geophys. MA, 169-192. W. V. R. (1954a). Discrete transitions in turbulent convection. Proc. R . SOC.London, MALKUS, Ser. A 225, 185. MALKUS, W. V. R. (1954b). The heat transport and spectrum of thermal turbulence. Proc. R . SOC.London, Ser. A 225, 196. MELLOR,G. L. (1973). Analytical prediction of the properties of stratified planetary surface layers. J. Atmos. Sci. 30, 106-1069. MILES,J. W. (1961). On the stability of heterogeneous shear flows. J. Fluid Mech. 10,496-508. MILLIKAN, C. B. (1939). A critical discussion of turbulent flow in channels and circular tubes. Appl. Mech., Proc. Int. Congr., 5th, 1937 pp. 386392. MONIN,A. S., and YAGLOM,A. M. (1971). “Statistical Fluid Mechanics: Mechanics of Turbulence,” Vol. 1. MIT Press,Cambridge, Massachusetts. MOORE,M. J., and LONG,R. R. (1971). An experimental investigation of turbulent stratified shear flow. J. Fluid Mech. 49, 635-655.
88
Robert R . Long
NAOT,D., SHAVIT,A., and WOLFSHTEIN, M. (1973). Two-point correlation model and the redistribution of Reynolds stress. Phys. Fluids 16, 738. NG, K. H., and SPALDING, D. B. (1972). Turbulence model for boundary layers near walls. Phys. Fluids 15, 2Ck30. NIILER,P. P. (1975). Deepening of the wind-mixed layer. J. Mar. Res. 33,405-422. NIKURADSE, J. (1932). Gesetzmassigkeiten der turbulent Stromung in glatten Rohren. Forschungsarb. Ingenieurwes. No. 356. ORSZAG,S. A,, and PAO,Y. H. (1974). Numerical computation of turbulent shear flows. Adu. Geophys. H A , 225-236. ORSZAG,S. A., and PAITERSON,G. S., Jr. (1972). Numerical simulation of turbulence in statistical models and turbulence. Lecr. Notes Phys. 12, 127-147. PAGE,F., SCHLINGER, W. G., BREAUX, D. K., and SAGE,B. H. (1952). Point values of eddy conductivity ,and viscosity in uniform flow between parallel plates. Ind. Eng. Chem. 44, 424-430. PHILLIPS, 0. M. (1966). “The Dynamics of the Upper Ocean.” Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. PLATE,E. J. (1971). “Aerodynamic Characteristics of Atmospheric Boundary Layers.” U.S. At. Energy Comm., Washington, D.C. R. (1973). The deepening of the wind-mixed POLLARD, R. T., RHINES, P. B., and THOMPSON, layer. Geophys. Fluid Dyn. 4, 381-404. PRANDTL, L. (1932). Meteorologische Andwendungen der Stromungslehre. Beitr. Phys. Atmos. 19, 188-202. PRIESTLEY, C . H. B. (1954). Convection from a large horizontal surface. Aust. J. Phys. 7 , 176. PRIESTLEY, C. H. B. (1959). “Turbulent Transfer in the Lower Atmosphere.” Univ. of Chicago Press, Chicago, Illinois. PROUDMAN, J. (1953). “ Dynamical Oceanography.” Methuen, London. PRUITT, W. O., MORGAN,D. L., and LAURENCE, F. J. (1973). Momentum and mass transfers in the surface boundary layer. Q. J. R. Meteorol. SOC.99, 37Ck386. RAYLEIGH, Lord. (1916). On convection currents in a horizontal layer of fluid where the higher temperature is on the underside. Phil. Mag. [6] 32, 529-546. REYNOLDS, 0. (1895). On the dynamical theory of incompressible viscous fluids and the determination of the criterion. Phil. Trans. R. SOC.London, Ser. A 186, 123. REYNOLDS, W. C. (1976). Computation of turbulent flows. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 8, 183-208. ROBERTSON, J. M. (1959). On turbulent plane-Couette flow. Proc. Annu. Con$ Fluid Mech., 6th pp. 169-182. ROSSBY,C. G., and MONTGOMERY, R. B. (1935).The layer of frictional influence. in wind and ocean currents. Pap. Phys. Oceanogr. 3, 1-101. ROSBY, H. T. (1969). A study of Benard convection with and without rotation. J . Fluid Mech. 36, 309. ROTTA,J. C. (1951). Statistische Theorie Nichthomogener Turbulenz. Z. Phys. 129, 547-572; 131, 51-77. ROUSE, H., and DODU,J. (1955). Turbulent diffusion across a density discontinuity. Houille Blanche 10, 405410. ROUSE,H., YIH, C. S., and HUMPHREYS, H. W. (1952). Gravitational convection from a boundary source. Tellus 4, 201-210. S. W. (1935). On the instability of a fluid when heated from SCHMIDT,R. J., and MILVERTON, below. Proc. R. Soc.London, Ser. A 152, 586-594. W. H., and COSART, W. A. (1961). The two-dimensional wall-jet. J. Fluid Mech. 10, SCHWARZ, 48 1-495. SCOTTI,R. S., and CORCOS,G. M. (1969). Measurements on the growth of small disturbances in
Turbulence in Geophysical Systems
89
a stratified shear layer. Radio Sci. 4, 1309-1313. SILVFSTON,P. L. (1958). Warmedurchgang in Waagrechten Flussigkeitschichten. Forschungsarb. lngenieurwes. 24, 29. SOMERSCALES, E. F. C., and DROPKIN, D. (1966). Experimental investigation of the temperature distribution in a horizontal layer of fluid heated from below. Heat Mass Transfer 9, 1-1 189. SOMERSCALES, E. F. C., and GAZDA, I. W. (1969). Thermal convection in high Prandtl number liquids at high Rayleigh numbers. Heat Mass Transfer 12, 1491. SPIECEL,E. A., and VERONIS,G. (1960). On the Boussinesq approximation for a compressible fluid. Astrophys. J. 131, 44-447. STERN,M. (1960). The salt fountain and thermohaline convection. Tellus 12, 172-175. STOMMEL, H., and FEDEROV, K. N. (1967). Small-scale structure in temperature and salinity near Timor and Mindinao. Tellus 19, 306-325. STOMMEL,H., ARONS,A. B., and BLANCHARD, D. (1956). An oceanographical curiosity: The perpetual salt fountain. Deep-sea Res. 3, 152-153. SUNDARAM, T. R. (1973). A theoretical model for the seasonal thermal cycle of deep temperate lakes. Proc. Conf. Great Lakes Res. 16, 1009-1025. SUNDARAM, T. R., and REHM,R. C. (1973). The seasonal thermal structure of deep temperate lakes. Tellus 25, 157-167. TENNEKES, H. (1968). Outline of a second order theory of turbulent pipe flow. A I A A J. 6, 1735-1155. TENNEKES, H., and LUMLEY,J. L. (1972). “A First Course in Turbulence.” MIT Press, Cambridge, Massachusetts. THOMAS, D. B., and TOWNSEND, A. A. (1957). Turbulent convection over a heated horizontal surface. J. Fluid Mech. 2, 473. THOMPSON,S. M.,and TURNER,J. S. (1975). Mixing across an interface generated by an oscillating grid. J. Fluid Mech. 67, 349-368. THORPE,S. A. (1973). Turbulence in stably stratified fluids: A review of laboratory experiments. Boundary-Layer Meteorol. 5, 95-1 19. THRELFALL, D. C. (1975). Free convection in low temperature gaseous helium. J. Fluid Mech. 67, 17-28. TOWNSEND, A. A. (1956). “The Structure of Turbulent Shear Flow,” 1st ed. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. TOWNSEND, A. A. (1959). Temperature fluctuations over a heated horizontal surface. J. Fluid Mech. 5, 209. TOWNSEND, A. A. (1976). “The Structure of Turbulent Shear Flow,” 2nd ed. Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York. TURNER, J. S. (1968). The influence of molecular diffusivity on turbulent entrainment across a density interface. J. Fluid Mech. 33, 639-656. TURNER, J. S. (1973). “ Buoyancy Effects in Fluids.” Cambridge Univ. Press, London and New York (see Chapter 9). VON KARMAN,T. (1930). Mechanische Ahnlichkeit und Turbulenz. Nachr. Ges. Wiss. Goettingen, Math.-Phys. K l . pp. 58-76. WOLANSKI, E. (1972). Turbulent entrainment across stable density-stratified liquids and suspensions. Ph.D. Dissertation, Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, Maryland. WOLANSKI, E., and BRUSH,L. M., Jr. (1975). Turbulent entrainment across stable density step structures. Tellus 27, 259-268. WOODS,J. D. (1968). Wave-induced shear instability in the summer thermocline. J : Fluid Mech. 32,791-800. WOODS,J. D., and WILEY,R. L. (1972). Billow turbulence and ocean microstructure. Deep-sea Res. 19, 87-121.
90
Robert R. Long
Wu, J. (1973). Wind-induced turbulent entrainment across a stable density interface. J . Fluid Mech. 61, 275-287. WYNGAARD, J. C. (1973). “On Surface Layer Turbulence,” Workshop on Micrometeorology. Science. Press, Ephrata, Pennsylvania. WYNGAARD, J. C., and COTE,0. R. (1971).The budget of turbulent kinetic energy and temperature variance in the atmospheric surface layer. J. Atmos. Sci. 28, 181-189. YAMADA, T. (1975). The critical Richardson number and the ratio of the eddy transport coefficients obtained from a turbulence closure model. J. A m o s . Sci. 32,926933. YIH, C. S. (1965). “ Dynamics of Nonhomogeneous Fluids.” Macmillan, New York. H. (1975). A self-contained model for the pressure terms in the ZEMAN,O., and TENNEKES, turbulent stress equations of the neutral atmospheric boundary layer. J . Atmos. Sci. 32, 1808-18 13. ZILITINKEVICH, S . S.(1967). On the dynamic and thermal interaction between the atmosphere and the ocean. Izv. Akad. Nauk SSSR, Fiz. Atmos. Oceana 3, 1069-1077. ZILITINKEVICH, S. S. (1975). Resistance laws and prediction equations for the depth of the planetary boundary layer. J. Atmos. Sci. 32, 741-752.
Singular-Perturbation Problems in Ship Hydrodynamicst T. FRANCIS OGILVIE Department of Naval Architecture and Marine Engineering The University of Michigan Ann Arbor. Michigan In Memory: Reinier Timman. 191 7-1975
I. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . I1. Slender-Body Theory in Aerodynamics . . 111. Slender Ships in Unsteady A. Problem Formulation B. Radiation Patterns . C. Forced Oscillations . D . DifTraction Problems
Motion at Zero Speed
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Slender Ships in Steady Forward Motion . . . . A. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Ordinary Slender-Ship Theory . . . . . . C. Failure of Ordinary Slender-Ship Theory . . D. The Bow-Flow Problem . . . . . . . . . E . The Low-Speed Problem . . . . . . . . . V. Slender Ships in Unsteady Forward Motion . . A . Introduction and Formulation . . . . . . B. Solution of the Heave/Pitch Forced-Oscillation C. High-speed Slender-Ship Theory . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
. . . . . . .
105 105 107 111 125
. . . . . .
145
95
. . . . . . 145 . . . . . . 147 . . . . . . 151
. . . . Problem .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . . . . . . .
. . .
92
. . . . . .
156 166 169 169 176 182 185
'This article was written while the author was Visiting Professor in the Department of Naval Architecture. Osaka University. Japan. and in the Mathematics Department. ManChester University. England . These visits were supported partially by grants from the Japan Society for the Promotion of Science and the North Atlantic Treaty Organization. respectively. 91
92
T. Francis Ogilvie
I. Introhction Michell(l898) laid the foundation for modern ship hydrodynamics in his extraordinary paper on the wave resistance of a thin ship. Havelock (1923) discovered and extended Michell's work, and for 40years thereafter progress in ship hydrodynamics was almost synonymous with development of thinship theory. Havelock pointed out in his first paper on this subject that one may question the validity of thin-ship theory in practical applications since real ships are hardly thin. Nevertheless, study of the thin ship prospered, and the theory provided some guidance in the reduction of wave resistance, even if it did not give accurate quantitative predictions. The early and continuing success of thin-ship theory was due to two factors: (i) An explicit solution can be found for the case of a ship in steady straight-ahead motion. (ii) The first approximation is essentially a uniform approximation. Khaskind (1946) and Peters and Stoker (1957) also obtained an explicit solution for a heaving and pitching thin ship with forward motion. In all such problems, the ship is replaced by a centerplane distribution of sources, steady or pulsating, as appropriate. The body boundary condition is transferred to the centerplane, thus providing an expression for the normal velocity component on each side of the centerplane, from which an explicit expression for source density can be obtained. If the potential for each source in the distribution satisfies the free-surface condition and a radiation condition, the potential for the superposition of sources satisfies approximately all of the conditions of the problem. Then it is a straightforward matter to find the pressure and to integrate it appropriately over the hull to obtain the force on the ship. Alternatively, the momentum theorem or an energy-flux theorem can be used to obtain similar results from the solution at great distance from the ship. [The latter can even be used to obtain some of the desired quantities in the unsteady-motion problem, as shown by Newman (1959).] If the ship is not symmetrical, either because of its actual shape or because it is yawed, this procedure does not work. A distribution of transverse dipoles must also be placed on the centerplane in the corresponding mathematical problem, and an integral equation must be solved to determine the density of the dipoles. This is a two-dimensional (2-D) singular integral equation with a very complicated kernel, and only the advent of the modern high-speed digital computer made its solution possible. This was first done by Daoud (1973). Similarly, if one tries to satisfy the boundary condition exactly on the true hull surface instead of on the centerplane, a complicated integral equation
Ship Hydrodynamics
93
must be solved, and there is still some controversy about the proper way to do this. Nevertheless, the thin-ship model (perhaps with modifications) still provides the best strictly analytical information available about the wave resistance of a ship, largely because an explicit solution is obtainable. Corresponding results for ship-motion problems have not been so useful, at least partly because a better mathematical model has evglved. (This other model will be discussed in this article, but we may note that it has not been successful in the steady-motion problem.) The thin-ship solution is the first term in a perturbation expansion of the corresponding exact problem. The small parameter may be considered as the ratio beam/length. As this parameter, say, B, approaches zero, the ship reduces to just its centerplane projection, and the hull boundary condition must be satisfied on the two sides of this surface. If, on the other hand, one formulates a slender-ship problem, in which both beam and draft approach zero with the small parameter, say, E, the hull shrinks down to a line, and the limit problem is not a well-posed problem in potential theory. Since the limit problem cannot even be posed properly, let alone solved, one cannot obtain a first approximation to the solution in this way. Thus, in spite of the fact that a ship appears to be more “slender than “thin,” the mathematician was forced until recently to consider it only as thin. The slender-ship problem is a singular-perturbation problem of a kind that aerodynamicists have learned to solve in the last several decades (see, for example, Ward, 1955). Thus it was to be expected that similar approaches should have been made to ship problems in recent years. However, when the aerodynamic techniques were applied in a straightforward way to ship problems, the results were generally disappointing, being sometimes trivial, sometimes nonsensical. Only in the last 10 years have these techniques been satisfactorilyadapted to the special conditions of ship problems so as to lead to reasonable and sometimes useful results. The treatment of these singular-perturbation problems is the subject of this article. The concept of the slender ship-and all that that implies for ship hydrodynamics-should not be considered as competition or a replacement for the thin-ship concept. Rather, it should be considered as a complement to thin-ship theory, offering some new understanding of the physical phenomena of ship hydrodynamics and perhaps eventually leading to some alternative methods of calculating quantities of practical interest. There is a growing body of investigators in ship hydrodynamics working on slender-ship theory. This article is not intended primarily for them, but rather for two other groups: (1) those who are still working largely with the older, more established concepts, who wish to learn quickly the principles, techniques, and possibilities of slender-ship theory, and (2) people who are ”
94
T. Francis Ogilvie
familiar with singular-perturbation techniques in other areas, especially with slender-body theory of aerodynamics, who are interested in finding out what is being done with these techniques in ship hydrodynamics. The section on slender-body theory in aerodynamics is provided as a brief introduction for the first group only. There are some singular-perturbation problems of ship hydrodynamics that are neglected, largely because they did not fit in with the general theme as we have organized it. In this category, we mention especially the work by Rispin (1967) and Wu (1967) in which they show how to solve the 2-D planing problem by matching a locally nonlinear description (without gravity in the first approximation) to a far-field gravity-wave solution. In a similar way, Shen and Ogilvie (1972) developed a theory for a high-aspectratio planing surface in which the local picture is a 2-D nonlinear flow, just like the near-field solution of Rispin and of Wu, while the far-field solution is a lifting-line approximation. There has also been considerable interest in recent years in high-frequency problems and in low-speed, steady-motion problems, in both of which the waves characteristically have a very small wavelength, and so the wave motion is confined to a thin layer near the free surface. These problems are barely mentioned in Sections III,C,3 and III,D,5. From a scientific point of view, they are very interesting as singular-perturbation problems, since they are truly boundary-layer problems. However, some choices had to be made, and the theory for such problems is not discussed in any detail. Also, as implied in the mention of “potential theory,” we assume that the fluid is ideal. Thus, problems of a viscous fluid are not considered at all. Of course, classical boundary-layer theory is one of the best-known of all singular-perturbation problems in fluid mechanics, and an understanding of viscous boundary layers is of critical importance in ship hydrodynamics. The boundary layers on ships are, however, always turbulent, and so the mathematical theory of boundary layers is less useful in ship hydrodynamics than in some other branches of fluid mechanics. To have included such problems in this article would have required the introduction of a tremendous and largely independent subject, probably with marginal benefit, and so there will be no further discussion of nonideal fluids. In general, we have tried to emphasize the physical understanding of problems and, where possible, to indicate the lines of thought that have led to the various formulations and solutions. The research worker first gets an idea that something may possibly be true, then tries to find out whether it really is true, and, if he convinces himself, he then tries to work out a proof (or performs experiments) to convince others. It is unfortunate that only the last of these stages is usually reported, and we have taken the conscious risk of trying to report something from the first two stages as well.
Ship Hydrodynamics
95
In this respect, much of the work discussed here (especially our own work) is based on the method of matched asymptotic expansions. We prefer to think about thesi problems along much the same lines as Van Dyke (1975). Now, Van Dyke’s book is perhaps unsatisfactory to mathematicians, but we believe that he provides an extremely valuable way of thinking about physical problems, a way that often suggests practical solutions. Thus his approach is a useful part of the first stage of scientific investigation as described above. By itself, of course, it proves nothing, and a lot of nonsense has been “derived” with the help of the method of matched asymptotic expansions. In providing references, we have tried to give those that might be of interest for further reading, rather than trying to establish priority of publication or presenting a comprehensive bibliography of the subject. To those who thereby feel neglected, we can only apologize and ask their understanding; we did not want to produce an annotated bibliography, which this article would surely have become had we tried to include all pertinent references. In matters of notation, we consistently follow the usage of Abramowitz and Stegun (1964). 11. Slender-Body Theory in Aerodynamics
The basic concept of the slender body in aerodynamics originated with Munk (1924). He was concerned with the flow around an airship. He noted that such a body has one long axis, parallel to which the fluid velocity component is generally much smaller than the components in the crossplanes. If the reference frame is fixed to the fluid at infinity, one may imagine that the forward motion of the slender body causes the fluid to part-to move sideways-without being greatly disturbed in the longitudinal direction. There is approximately a 2-D flow in each crossplane. Thus the 3-D problem is greatly simplified in being replaced by a set of 2-D problems, and furthermore the powerful methods for solving 2-D flows become available. Of course, such a viewpoint is only valid rather close to the body. Very far away, the flow field caused by any moving nonlifting body appears as if it might have been created by a moving dipole, and such a flow field is in direct contrast to the notion of a 2-D flow pattern. Thus, it must be recognized from the outset that the slender-body description of the flow field is not valid uniformly far away from the body. Furthermore, there generally are stagnation points at the nose and tail of the body, at which points the fluid velocity is approximately equal to the
96
T . Francis Ogilvie
velocity of the body itself, i.e., the longitudinal fluid velocity component dominates the transverse components. At such points, the slender-body concept is completely wrong. Notwithstanding these two difficulties, it has been found that predictions of slender-body theory are fairly good in many important aerodynamic problems, and so the theory has been studied and further developed over a period of several decades. Starting in the 1940s especially, when many aerodynamic vehicles became effectively slender, basic understanding of slender-body theory improved, the accuracy of its predictions increased, and the scope of problems to which it could be applied widened greatly. The final stage in the development of aerodynamic slender-body formalism occurred in the 196Os, when the method of matched asymptotic expansions was applied to such problems. A good textbook treatment has been provided by Ashley and Landahl (1965). This method has not received universal acceptance by workers in the field, but its practical usefulness cannot be denied, and it will be used here. In particular, it provides some simplified viewpoints on slender-body problems and it also provides a formal procedure for relating those viewpoints mathematically. One may also comment that it gives the illusion of proving various conclusions, and so it can be dangerous when used improperly. In slender-body theory, we infer the existence of a small parameter E, which is a measure of the “slenderness” of the body under study. This parameter may be simply the ratio of a typical transverse dimension, say diameter, to the length, or it may be the maximum slope with respect to the longitudinal axis of planes tangent to the body surface. For developing the general theory, its precise definition does not matter. What does matter is that the entire theory is developed in an asymptotic sense as E + 0. That is, any conclusions will be more nearly valid as E becomes smaller and smaller. Whether such conclusions are valid for any finite value of E will always be a matter for further investigation in any particular problem. For convenience in discussing slender-body problems of all kinds, we shall generally consider that ,!J the body length, is O( 1) as E + 0, i.e., L is fixed and its value is not affected by the limit operation. Then, a transverse dimension can be described as being O(E)as E -+ 0. If any ambiguity is likely to arise from such usage, we can revert to the more usual statement, B/L = O(E), where B is the transverse dimension of interest. The basic concept of slender-body theory can be stated mathematically as follows: Iff(x, y, z) is any flow variable, then, in some region near the body,
where the x axis is chosen as the longitudinal axis of the body. This state-
Ship Hydrodynamics
97
ment says simply that derivatives in the transverse directions are very large compared to derivatives in the longitudinal direction. The region in which these statements are assumed to be valid has transverse dimensions that are O(E).These statements are assumptions, and so they cannot be proven. However, they can be made to appear plausible, as is suggested in the following two typical situations: (1) In Fig. 1 there is depicted a section of a slender body which is moving at speed U in the longitudinal direction through fluid at rest. Let v = ( u l , u,, u 3 ) be the fluid velocity caused by the motion of this body. At
FIG. 1. A slender body in steady longitudinal motion.
points A and B, the u2 component has almost the same magnitude but opposite signs. Thus Au, ,defined as u2 IA - u2 IB, has a value comparable to twice u 2 J k The distance D between the two points is O(E),and so A u , / B = O(V,/E).It follows that the derivative of u2 along a path connecting points A and B must be O(U,/E), and thus that derivatives in the transverse planes are large. On the other hand, there is no such reason to expect that d v , / d x should be large. (2) In Fig. 2 there is depicted a cross section of a slender body moving with speed V in the transverse direction. The velocity component u2 at point A must equal V, but at point B v2 is very nearly equal to - V . Again, the is O(E),and so the same argument leads to the conclusion that distance
au,/ay = o ( ~ , / & ) .
Such arguments are not so clear in the case of some flow variables, but nevertheless the relationships indicated in (2.1) can generally be justified,
T. Francis Ogilvie
98
ty
FIG.2. A slender body moving in the transverse direction.
especially if one is willing to overlook the difference in asymptotic behavior between, say, O(E")and O(E"log E).' In order to use the assumption stated in (2.1), let us consider a slender body moving with velocity U = ( U l , U,, U 3 )(possibly a function of time). We assume that the fluid motion can be described in terms of a velocity potential, 4(x, y, z, t), which satisfies the Laplace equation in three dimensions,
The orders of magnitude of the terms in (2.2) have been noted. Although we have not yet determined the dependence of 4 on E, we can assert that the first term in (2.2) is of higher order than the other two terms, and so it can be neglected in the determination of the first approximation for 4. The potential also satisfies a kinematic body boundary condition, &$/an = n U, (2.3) or (2.3') '14.x + n Z 4 y + n 3 $ 2 = n l U l + n Z U , + n 3 u3
-
--
O(#JE)
7
v
O(4lE)
Y
O(E)
Of course, the asymptotic behavior of the two is not the same. Nevertheless, I shall treat them as if they were. This never seems to lead to trouble, and there are two very practical reasons for doing so: (i) A function such as log AE can always be broken into two terms, log A + log E, and, if A = O( 1) as E + 0,these two terms are O( 1) and O(log E ) , respectively. However, the value of A can be changed by making a new definition for E , and so it is clear that the two terms cannot be treated independently, even if they are formally of different orders of magnitude with respect to E . (ii) We derive asymptotic formulas with the intention of applying them for finite values of E, although the formulas are only valid asymptotically as E + 0. If we had to restrict the range of E so that the difference between log E and 1 were large, we would probably never obtain a useful formula.
Ship Hydrodynamics
99
(2.4)
is a unit vector normal to the body surface, directed into the body. For a slender body, it is important to note that n, = O(E)
and
n , , n, = O(1)
as ~ 4 0 .
(2.4)
This fact has been used already in noting the orders of magnitude of the terms in (2.3’).Also, it has been assumed in (2.3’)that U , = O(1) and that U , , U , = O(E),which are useful choices (if arbitrary). These are the largest possible orders of magnitude for the U:s which still allow “small disturbances” to result. Finally, (2.1) has been used in estimating the left-hand side of (2.3’). It is evident that we can drop n , 4x from (2.3’),at least for the first approximation, and we then find that
4 = O(E2),
(2.5)
which is a typical result of slender-body theory. One further approximation, consistent with the above, is usually made. The left-hand side of (2.3) is a directional derivative of 4 taken along the normal vector n. On a slender body, this vector is almost perpendicular to the longitudinal axis. In finding the first approximation for 4, we can replace &$/an by a$/diV, where N is a unit vector, lying in a crossplane, perpendicular to the contour of the body in that crossplane. The relative error incurred in this replacement is O(E’). Thus the first approximation for 4 (strictly, the first term in an asymptotic expansion) satisfies the following conditions:
4yy+ 422 = 0 ; ab/aN = N 2 4 , ,+ N34z= n , U , + n2 U , + n3 U 3 .
(2.6) (2.7)
This is strictly a set of 2-D problems, as was anticipated. The solutions can be found analytically or numerically by standard methods. Apparently the solution at each crossplane is independent of the solution at all other crossplanes, except insofar as they are related by the body geometry, which enters into (2.7). But in fact this is not true, for the simple 2-D solutions in the crossplanes are not unique: At any x, the solution of (2.6) which satisfies (2.7) is arbitrary to the extent that any constant may be added without affecting the validity of the solution. This constant may be different at various crossplanes, and so we must add an arbitrary function of x to any solution determined from (2.6) and (2.7). We must somehow determine this
100
T. Francis Ogilvie
additive function of x, and it turns out to represent a further interaction among the various crossplanes. The additive function of x cannot be determined from the near-field analysis that we have been considering. We must construct a far-field description of the flow in order to determine the interaction among the crossplanes. Before doing this, we should note how the approximate solution z')'''. Since 4 of the above near-field problem behaves for large r = (y' must be harmonic everywhere outside the body contour, and its gradient must vanish at infinity, 4 can be represented as the real part of a complex potential, which can in turn be represented by a Laurent series supplemented by a logarithm term. The potential 4 itself then takes the form
+
4(x, y, z;
t ) = [a(x; t)/2n] log r
+c
+ Ao(x; t )
A,,(x;t ) cos n6 + B,,(x; t ) sin no 9
r"
n= 1
(2.8)
where 0 = arctan y/x. Since 4 = O(E') and (in the near field) r = O(E),we may conclude that ~7= O(E')
and
A,, B,, = O(P+').
(2.8')+
At very large r, the first two terms in (2.8) dominate the others, and so
4(x, y, z;
t)
- [~(x;t)/2nJ
log r
+ Ao(x; t )
as r + co.
(2.8")
Thus, very far away (but still in the near field), the flow caused by the body appears to have been caused by a 2-D source at the origin. We note that the strength of the source can be computed from (2.7),(2.8),and the equation of continuity, with the result that O(X; t ) = - U,[dS(x)/dx], (2.9) where S(x) is the cross-sectional area of the body. From the far-field point of view, as E --+ 0 the body shrinks down to a line, the segment of the x axis between x = 0 and x = L. It is this fact that makes slender-body theory a singular-perturbation problem even in the first approximation, for it is not a well-posed problem in 3-D potential theory to prescribe boundary conditions along a line. If we require that the potential function be harmonic everywhere other than on this line and that it be bounded at infinity as well, then 4 must be singular on the line segment. A convenient way to obtain a general form of the far-field solution is to restate the problem in terms of Fourier transforms with respect to x; the resulting 2-D problems can be solved in a general way and then transformed again to
' We are ignoring differences that are O(log E ) .
See the footnote on p. 98.
101
Ship Hydrodynamics
give solutions of the form
\
W 1 " dkeikX Kn(I k I r)[a:(k; t ) cos no 4(x, y , z, t) = 2n.-, n=O
1
+ b:(k; t ) sin no], (2.10)
where the functions a:@; t) and b,*(k;t) are unknown functions that can themselves be interpreted as Fourier transforms.' Near the x axis, which includes the singular line, r is small, and the terms in (2.10) can be approximated by using the small-r series expressions for the Bessel functions 1 " dkeikxKo(I k I r)ag(k; t ) 271 .-"
\
-1
27t
5"
-m
-
1 28
5-" dkeikxag(k; m
- - log
r
t)
dkeikxag( k ; t ) log ~. Clkl 2 '
(2.1la)*
1 " dkeikxKn(I k I r)c,*(k; t) 'OS no 27t sin
[
-.-m
2"-'(n - I)!cos
t),
N
n > 0.
(2.11b)
In (2.1 la) we see that the first term on the right-hand side behaves like log r in a crossplane, and so it appears to represent a 2-D source of strength 6(x; t) = -2na,(x; t), where ao(x; t ) =
\"
27t.-,
(2.12a)
dkeikxa$(k;t ) .
The full 3-D expression on the left-hand side of (2.1la) can also be rewritten to show that it represents a distribution of sources in three dimensions
The second term on the right-hand side of (2.11a) is simply a function of x; using (2.12a), we can rewrite this function as follows
=--j1
"
d ( & ' ( ( ; t ) log 2 Ix - 4; I sgn(x - < ) = f ( x ; t ) , 47t -"
'
(2.13)
All special functions are denoted as by Abramowitz and Stegun (1964). Here, K. is the modified Bessel function of the second kind. log C = 7 is the Euler constant.
102
T. Francis Ogilvie
where the prime denotes differentiation with respect to 5. The left- and right-hand sides of (2.1 lb) can also be interpreted in terms of 3-D and 2-D distributions of multipoles. It is important to recognize that there is no simple function of just x left on the right-hand side of (2.11b). It is thus seen that the general far-field solution can be expressed in terms of distributions of sources, dipoles, etc., along the x axis. The strengths of these singularities are of course not known. From (2.12b), we might infer that the distribution extends along the entire x axis, but in fact it must be limited essentially to the line segment that represents the remnant of the body in the limit E + 0; we can simply set 6(x; t ) = 0 outside of this segment. A similar step follows also for the multipole distributions. Near the line of sources, the potential corresponding to just the sources takes the following approximate form (1/2n)6(x; t ) log r + f ( x ; t);
(2.14)
this is the right-hand side of (2.1 la) after we use (2.12a) and (2.13). A comparison with (2.8”) indicates that this is precisely the kind of behavior of the far-field potential that we would have liked to find. It follows directly that 6(x; t) = o(x; t),
the value of which is known from (2.9). The expression in (2.8”) represents the near-field potential in its limiting behavior for large r ; the expression in (2.14) comes from one term of the far-field potential, giving the limiting behavior of that term for small r. This is the kind of “matching” that forms the basis for the method of matched asymptotic expansions. It has been a well-known procedure ever since Prandtl first developed classical boundarylayer theory, although much of the formalism has been developed only recently. This matching does not appear to be perfect yet, for we have considered just one term in the series in (2.10). The subsequent terms are more and more singular near the x axis, as (2.11b) shows; it appears that the terms with n = 1 should dominate the n = 0 term if r is small enough, and the n = 2 terms should dominate the n = 1 terms, etc. If this were true, the matching would be destroyed. Physically it does not make sense either; if we start very close to the body, where the flow appears as if it might have been generated by sources, dipoles, quadrupoles, and so on, and then we move farther away, the sourcelike behavior decreases most slowly. Then, if we start very far away and approach the body, the sourcelike behavior should appear first. We conclude that in the far field the lowest-order term in the solution expansion should be sourcelike; other terms are of higher order with respect to E, that is, a: and b: are o(a$)as E .+0 for n > 0. Then the first term in the
Ship Hydrodynamics
103
outer expansion is $(x, y , z, t)
-
-
1 -
2n
“
dkeik“K,( I k I r)a,*(k;t )
(2.10)
t) log r + f ( x ; t)
(2.14‘)
-“
1 --(x; 2n
as r + O .
Now the one-term outer expansion is completely known, since 6, and thus a,, is known. Also, the one-term inner expansion is known, including the additive function of x, for A, in (2.8”) must be the same asf(x; t), given by
(2.13). In the aerodynamic problem, one can proceed to obtain higher-order solutions, although “end effects” are likely to cast doubt on the validity of such extended expansions. In any case, in the free-Surface problems that are the focus of this article, it is difficult enough to obtain a first approximation, and so we are not likely to be concerned with anything beyond. Only a few comments on the interpretation of the above results need yet to be made. The additive function in the near-field 2-D solution, A , orf, has a simple interpretation. At any x it represents an axial flow that is needed to correct the 2-D result represented by the log r term in the approximate solution. To see this, one can start with the right-hand side of (2.12b),which is genuinely three-dimensional in nature. Integrate it once by parts with respect to 9 ; the result is 1 3(x; t) log r 2n -
1
--
4n
5
“
-m
d98’(9; t ) log{ Ix - 5 I
+ [(x - 9)2 + r2I1’*}sgn(x - 9 ) .
As r -P 0, the second term here approaches a well-defined limit, which in.fact is equal tof(x; t ) . If the problem really were two-dimensional, so that 6 were a constant, this extra term would vanish. But the problem is not twodimensional, and f ( x ; r ) represents the value on the axis of the potential which corrects for the nonzero longitudinal rate of change of 6. The 2-D solutions in the various crossplanes are related in two ways: (i) through the body geometry, which enters into the boundary condition on the body at every cross section, and (ii) through the additive “constant at each section,f(x; t ) . The latter depends only on the sourcelike behavior of the flow in the cross-sectional planes, and so it vanishes if there is no sourcelike behavior. There are two cases in which this happens. ”
(1) The body has no thickness. Although this cannot happen in reality, we often assume that a body has no thickness if we are interested primarily in
104
T. Francis Ogilvie
the effect of the body as a lifting surface. In this case, in the near-field solution as given in (2.8), the source term vanishes, and the lowest-order term in the solution expansion is a dipole term. In the far field, we must then start the solution with a line distribution of dipoles, and, as seen from (2.11b), there is no function of x alone when this singular potential is estimated near the line of singularities. So, A, in (2.8) vanishes. Slender-body theory for the lifting body of zero thickness reduces to the simplest kind of a strip theory, with no interaction among the cross-sectional flows. Even if we consider that a lifting body does have thickness, the interactions among sections depends only on the thickness effects. (2) There is noforward motion. In the body boundary condition (2.7), let U , = 0. Again, the source strength is zero. This is indicated by (2.9), but it could also have been deduced from the fact that the 2-D problems represent a translating body, which has no sourcelike behavior. As in the case of the lifting body of zero thickness, all source terms vanish and the interaction term A, (or f) vanishes with them. The slender-body theory for vertical or lateral oscillations of a body at zero speed is thus a primitive strip theory. This reduced capability of slender-body theory to represent interactions among cross sections leads to a special difficulty in the case of slender lifting surfaces: It is generally impossible to satisfy a Kutta condition. A cross section forward of the trailing edge is unaffected (in the first approximation) by what happens at the trailing edge, and so in the theory there can be no adjustment of the pressure and velocity fields ahead of the trailing edge to ensure a smooth flow from the edge. This difficulty has been rectified in recent years by the use of an acceleration potential. See especially Newman and Wu (1973), who treat the problem of unsteady motion of a slender lifting body with thickness by such a method. Also, Rogallo (1969) has shown the nature of the failure of liftingsurface theory near the trailing edge of a slender wing. More generally, errors at the body ends cause the worst problems in aerodynamic slender-body theory. The basic assumptions are violated in such regions, even without difficulties in satisfying a Kutta condition. Similarly in applications to ship hydrodynamics, the theory is most limited in describing the fluid motion near the ends. The nature of the end effects is quite different in the two fields, however, largely because of the presence of the free surface in ship problems, and little benefit would be gained from a discussion here of problems that are specifically aerodynamic. As a final comment about aerodynamic slender-body theory, we should mention how the pressure computation is affected by slenderness. In order to keep the results concise, let us suppose that, if there is a steady forward motion, we introduce instead an opposite uniform stream at infinity. The
Ship Hydrodynamics
105
pressure is computed from the Bernoulli equation,
PIP= - u4.x - 4 r - 3-6x2 + 4; + 4:). P
q E 2 )
-_c
o(E4)
q E 2 )
The orders of magnitude are noted below the terms, the estimates being based on (2.5). We have assumed that 4r = O(4). Thus, in the first-order approximation for the pressure, we have
PIP= - u4.x - 4 r - 34; + 4:)
= O(E’)-
(2.15)
The appearance here of two of the quadratic terms is a characteristic of slender-body theory. Even if the velocity-potential problem itself can be treated as a linear problem, a consistent computation of the pressure generally requires that the two quadratic terms be included. A partial exception will be found later when we develop the solution of some motion problems in terms of two small parameters, in which case we shall neglect quantities that are quadratic in terms of the second parameter. However, the argument will still stand with respect to quantities quadratic in terms of the slenderness parameter E . 111. Slender Ships in Unsteady Motion at Zero Speed
A. PROBLEM FORMULATION Now we consider a slender body whose longitudinal axis is approximately parallel to the undisturbed free surface. Since we have it in mind to apply the results to ship problems, we assume that the body is partially submerged, that is, it intersects the free surface. The body may oscillate vertically or horizontally, it may be fixed and exposed to incident waves, or it may be free to respond to incident waves. We shall not consider the case of longitudinal oscillation of the body (surge, in nautical terms), largely because it is illsuited for the application of slender-body theory; we do not believe that anyone has yet shown whether it is valid to simplify this case through the use of the slenderness property, although such an analysis has been performed formally. It will be assumed throughout this section that the ship has no forward speed. In the notation of Eq. (2.3’) or (2.7), we have U , = 0. Because of the presence of the free surface, the resulting theory is not necessarily a primitive strip theory, as was always the case in the corresponding aerodynamic problem. Since we seldom go beyond linear theory in ship-motion problems, it is
106
T . Francis Ogilvie
convenient at many points to assume that the unsteady motion is sinusoidal. If we are concerned with just the linear problem, other motions can be studied as superpositions of sinusoidal motions, and there is no loss of generality in restricting ourselves to sinusoidal motions. It is still assumed that the body geometry allows for the definition of a slenderness parameter E with implications essentially the same as in the infinite-fluid problem. Again we treat the fluid-motion problem as a problem in potential theory, and so the governing partial differential equation is the Laplace equation in three dimensions. The kinematic condition on the body is the same as before. Thus we start out requiring that (2.2) and (2.3) be satisfied, but with U , = 0 in the latter. Also, the arguments that were presented with respect to Figs. 1 and 2 are still valid, and so we still accept (2.1) as a reasonable hypothesis in the near field, although we shall have to introduce some modifications presently. The new aspect is the presence of the free surface. The boundary conditions to be satisfied there are well known [see, for example, Stoker (1957) or Wehausen and Laitone (196O)l. On the free surface, z = [(x, y, f ) , the pressure is constant, and we can set it equal to zero in the Bernoulli equation
+ +
on z = [(x, y, t). (3.1) p / p = -4, - g i - &(4: 4; 4:) = 0 There is a kinematic condition to be satisfied on the free surface
4 L X+ 4JY- A
+ C, = 0
on z
= i(x,
y, t).
(3.2) In addition, we must satisfy a radiation condition; we postpone specifying this condition until we have a linear problem to work with. We want to simplify the free-surface boundary conditions in a way consistent with the concepts of slender-body theory, as described in Section 11. In the near field, we initially apply (2.1) as before. We must also consider what effect differentiation with respect to time has on orders of magnitude; this is necessary if we are to interpret the time derivatives in (3.1) and (3.2) correctly. There is a range of possible choices, but only three of these lead to ~); = significant results: (i) a4/at = O(4); (ii) a4/at = O ( ~ / E ’ / (iii) O ( ~ / E It ) . will be necessary to provide an acceptable interpretation for presuming that time differentiation is related (in an order-of-magnitude sense) to the slenderness parameter E, and we shall do this presently. It will also be necessary to satisfy (3.1) and (3.2) in the far field. Corresponding to the three possibilities just mentioned for the order-of-magnitude effect of the operator a/&, we shall find that some modifications of the infinite-fluid ideas are needed in the far field. Before examining these cases separately, it is worthwhile to anticipate some simple results and to use them to provide some physical insight into the meaning of the several choices. That is the purpose of the next section.
Ship Hydrodynamics
107
B. RADIATION PAITERNS
In the far field, it turns out that the most reasonable free-surface condition is
& + g4= = 0
on z = 0.
(3.3)
This will be discussed further in Section II1,C. For now, we note only that it is easily obtained from (3.1) and (3.2) by retainingjust the linear terms and eliminating [ between the two equations. Equation (3.3) is the classical free-surface condition for linearized problems involving unsteady motion of a fluid with a free surface. We shall show later that (3.3) should be used in the far field regardless of what assumption is made about the effect of the operator alat. Consider the case of a ship heaving (translating in the vertical direction). If the ship is sufficiently slender, the disturbance far away appears as if it might have been created by a distribution of time-dependent sources on the x axis. This is somewhat analogous to the result for a slender body in an infinite fluid, as expressed in (2.10), but there are two important differences to be noted: (i) In the present case, the simple sources in (2.10) must be replaced by free-surface sources, that is, the corresponding velocity potentials must satisfy (3.3). (ii) In the infinite-fluid problem, vertical oscillation of the body is represented in the far field by a distribution of vertically oriented dipoles on the singular line. In the free-surface problem, the fluid fills only a half-space, and we cannot really distinguish between the effects of timedependent sources at z = 0 and time-dependent vertical dipoles at z = 0. It seems to be somewhat simpler to think in terms of sources, and we do so. Let the source density be given as Re[6(x)ei"'],
0 < x < L.
(3.4)
Then the potential is Re{4(x, y , z)ei"'},
(3-5)
where @(x,y, z) is given by [see Wehausen and Laitone (1960), Eq. (13.17")]:
r ' \
Here, R = [(x - <)z + yz]1/2 and v = wz/g. The integral is to be interpreted as a contour integral indented above the pole at k = v. Far away, where Ro = (xz + yz)"2 is very large, the above potential can be approximated as
108
T . Francis Ogilvie
follows iv
(3.7a)
iv
= -evz x a n H:2) ( vR , ) cos
2
no
n=O
IOLd 5 w J , ( V 5 ) ,
(3.7b)
where an=
{t;
n = 0, n > 0.
The second form is obtained by applying an addition theorem for Bessel functions, as given in Eq. (9.1.79) by Abramowitz and Stegun (1964). The Hankel functions in (3.7b) can be further approximated by their large-r asymptotic representations.
FIG.3. Angular distribution of amplitude of radiated waves from a line of pulsating sources.
We do not know 6(x) in general; it must be determined somehow from the near-field solution. But we obtain useful insight by considering a special case: 8(x) = oo,a constant. This is close to what one might find for a boxlike ship heaving at moderate frequency. For this case, in Fig. 3 the radial distance to the curve at any angle represents the relative magnitude of 4 for the wave radiating at that same angle. This quantity, computed from (3.7b), is proportional to the amplitude of the outgoing wave, and so we can tell from
Ship Hydrodynamics
109
Fig. 3 whether the source distribution causes waves to go out symmetrically in all directions or whether the waves are focused in certain directions. Four cases are shown. For V L= 2 (that is, l / L = IL, where l = 2n/v), the waves propagate outward with essentially the same amplitude in all directions. The source distribution might just as well have been circular, rather than rectilinear. At the other extreme, for V L= 20 ( l / L= rc/lO), the waves go out almost exclusively in the broadside direction ; practically no wave energy escapes in the endwise directions nor even over a wide range of oblique angles. Two in-between cases are also shown. The two extreme cases shown are typical results in radiation problems of acoustics, electromagnetic wave theory, and so on. If the radiator is small in comparison with the wavelength of the radiation, it is not possible to focus the outgoing waves; the distribution of wave energy with direction is essentially uniform. On the other hand, if the radiator is large compared with wavelength, sharp focusing is possible. What is of interest in this example is what is meant by " large " and " small " in the comparison of wavelength and radiator size. Apparently, a l / L ratio of about 3 is very large, and a l / L ratio of about 1/3 is very small. The above results are true only very far away, in an asymptotic sense. It is difficult to make precise statements about the distribution of wave amplitude in a region at finite distance from the oscillating ship. However, the nearby behavior in the short-wave case is suggested qualitatively in Fig. 4. Alongside the body, there are waves propagating in the directions perpendicular to the axis of the body. The shorter the waves, the farther out this
--- .
1-1
r---I \ --I
I--+I-\-
1
I
I--\
I \ ----
FIG.4. Short waves generated by a line of pulsating sources.
110
T. Francis Ogilvie
behavior extends. Analytically, the description corresponding to Fig. 4 can be derived from (3.7a) by using the large4 asymptotic formula for the Hankel function and then applying the method of stationary phase. It turns out that there is no point of stationary phase unless 0 I x I L, but within this range the potential function in (3.7a) is given approximately as follows 4 ( x , y, z ) e ' ~ ' iG(x)evzei(W'-vI~I). (3.8) This result says that there are waves propagating outward in the f y directions, that these waves move as if they were strictly 2-D waves, and that the amplitude at any point ( x , y) of the free surface depends only on G(x), the source density at the same x. Of course, the abrupt change in character of the solution along the lines x = 0, L is fictitious,a result of using the method of stationary phase. If frequency is considered to become higher and higher (wavelength becomes shorter and shorter), the actual wave motion would come closer and closer to this discontinuous pattern. But, for finite frequency and finite wavelength, there must be ever-widening regions spreading out from both ends of the ship in which this idealization is invalid. This is suggested in Fig. 4 by the broken lines emanating from the body ends; in the regions bounded by these lines, the sharp distinction becomes fuzzy between the two regions defined by the stationary-phase procedure. A similar qualification must be made to the result in (3.8) that relates the wave amplitude at any (x, y) exclusively to the value of 6 ( x )for the same x . This relationship becomes more nearly true closer and closer to the singular line. In this discussion of radiation patterns from a heaving ship, the important relationship between wavelength and frequency has been used or inferred several times, that is, 2n/1= v = o 2 / g . (3-9) This is, of course, the dispersion relationship for free-surface gravity waves on deep water. It provides the means to rationalize possible order-ofmagnitude relationships between the operator a/at and the slenderness parameter E. [See the discussion following Eqs. (3.1) and (3.2).] For example, if we consider sinusoidal motion at radian frequency o,there is a wavelength 1 = 27cg/oz associated with the resulting fluid motion, and we may expect the relationship between this 1and the dimensions of the ship to provide a characteristic parameter for describing the motion. This is clear from Fig. 3. In this way, the initially strange idea of relating the effect of time differentiation to the slenderness parameter becomes quite natural: "Time " implies a frequency, which implies a wavelength, which can be compared with body dimensions from which the slenderness parameter is defined. Furthermore, suppose that we assume that o = O ( E - ' ' ~ )so, that a/& =
Ship Hydrodynamics
111
O(E-lI2), which is one of the possibilities mentioned in the discussion of (3.1) and (3.2). A simple plane wave at this frequency might be described in terms
+
of a potential of the form exp(vz io t - ivy). Differentiation of this potential with respect to y or z is equivalent in magnitude to multiplying by v = O ( E - ’ ) .This is an order-of-magnitude effect not encompassed in (2.1), and so we shall have to complement (2.1) with a formalism that adequately accounts for this effect. We shall treat this situation when we come to the case of high-frequency oscillations.
C. FORCED OSCILLATIONS 1. Low-Frequency Oscillations We define low frequency to mean that w = O( 1) as E + 0, or I = O( 1) [see (3.911. We shall also refer to this as the “long-wave’’ problem. In practice, we are likely to think of wavelength in this case as being more or less comparable to ship length, and this is a useful way of thinking. But it is not really correct and it may occasionally be misleading. The statement I = O( 1)” implies that I / B -P 00 as E + 0, where B is ship beam. The ratio I / L may have any value, in principle, just so it remains fixed in the limit process. It could be 1/10 or even 1/100. However, the theory will not be valid unless I / B is very large, and so a small value of I / L may require that B/L be really infinitesimal. Such a theory would not be useful because no one is interested in a ship with such dimensions. So the meaning suggested when we call this a low-frequency or long-wave case is important for practical purposes, although it is not entirely correct. Formally, we most often introduce the assumption o = 0 (1 ) when we differentiate with respect to time, in which case we assume that a/& = O( 1). Also, v and L are O(1). Near Field. There is assumed to be a velocity potential, 4(x, y, z, t) = Re[4(x, y, z)exp(iot)], to which we can apply (2.1). Then the first approximation for $(x, y. z) satisfies the 2-D Laplace equation in the near field, as in (2.6). The kinematic boundary condition on the body is as stated in (2.7) for the infinite-fluid case. It is convenient now to redefine U j “
”
“
U , = 0;
U j = Re(io<jeimt), j
= 2,
3.
(3.10)
on the body.
(3.1 1)
Then the body boundary condition can be rewritten: ac$faN
= io (n ztz
+ n3t3)
We linearize the boundary conditions, and so we apply (3.11) on the body surface at its undisturbed position. (This is not valid in the forward-speed problem, even in the linearized case.) We assume that U j = O ( E ) ;this is
112
T. Francis Ogilvie
adequate for the present case, although we shall need a more precise statement later for the high-frequency case. This assumption concerning U j implies that
4 = O(EZ),
(3.12)
just as in the infinite-fluid problems [see (2.5)]. Now we simplify the free-surface boundary conditions, (3.1) and (3.2). First consider just the linear terms. If we keep both linear terms in (3.1), we must expect that
r = O(4) = O(EZ),
(3.13)
which then implies in (3.2) that
4* = 0,
(3.14)
r,
) . the other hand, we since 4z= O(E)[the effect of (2.1)] and = O ( E ~On might choose to retain both linear terms in (3.2), which would imply that Then, in (3.1), to
r = O(4J = O(E).
(3.15)
r = 0.
(3.16)
4, would be of higher order than r, and so (3.1)would reduce
But this is a trivial result; it means only that we do not yet have the lowestorder term in the expansion for [. Therefore we reject (3.15); it appears that (3.13) is the more reasonable choice. Of course, (3.14) follows directly from (3.13), and this means that the free surface has been replaced by a rigid wall in the problem that defines the first-order approximation of 4. It might seem that we have thereby discarded the free surface completely, but this is not true. It must be recognized that the rigid-wall condition, (3.14), does not mean literally that there is no vertical fluid motion at z = 0; it means only that the vertical component of fluid motion is much smaller than the horizontal component. From the linear terms in (3.1),t we can calculate the corresponding deflection of the free surface [(x, Y,t ) = Re[ - (l/g)4,] = Re[ - (Wg)4(x,
Y,o)ei"'].
(3.17)
From this formula, we can calculate [,,and we observe that it is O(E').The kinematic free-surface condition, (3.2), then requires that +z = + .... The right-hand side is O ( E ~ but ) the left-hand side is O(E).If we want to calculate
r,
+ The term - (1/2)4; in (3.1) is O(E'),the same as @,, and so it should in principle be retained here. However, we generally assume that we may linearize oscillation problems with respect to the amplitude of oscillation, in which case the quadratic term is of higher order in that sense.
Ship Hydrodynamics
113
the left-hand side to an accuracy which is only O(E),we can set the righthand side equal to zero. And this is what (3.14) means. The near-field problem represented by (3.1l), (3.14), and (3.17) was intensively investigated in the mid-1960s by Newman (1964), Joosen (1964), Newman and Tuck (1964), and Maruo (1967a). This was the basis for the early slender-body theory of ship motions, which gave reasonable predictions at zero speed (but only at zero speed). The solution of this near-field problem is no more difficult than in the infinite-fluid case. Since the free surface is replaced by a rigid wall in the 4 problem, we can extend the definition of 4 analytically into the upper halfspace as an even function with respect to z. The extended problem can be interpreted as an infinite-fluid problem, and so it is not necessary here to discuss methods of solution further. The solution of the problem has somewhat different properties according to whether the body oscillates vertically or horizontally. The two cases are depicted in Fig. 5. If the body oscillates vertically, the image of the body
1'
1'
(a)
(b)
FIG. 5. Motion of the body image in the low-frequencyproblem. (a) Vertical oscillation, (b) horizontal oscillation.
moves oppositely, so that the two act together somewhat as a pulsating body. Far away from the body, the potential can be expanded as in (2.8), and the logarithm term is the most important, that is, $(x, .y, z)eiw'
-
{ [ o ( x ) / 2 a ]log r
+ Ao(x)}eiw',
(3.18)
as r = (y' + z2)1/2+ co. [Cf. (2.8").] From conservation ofmass, one can show easily that the source strength is given by D(X) =
-2ioB(x)<, ,
(3.18')
where B(x) is the beam at the waterline. It may be noted that the kinetic
114
T. Francis Ogilvie
energy of the fluid motion per unit length of the body is infinite, a fact that leads to a prediction of infinite added mass per unit length of the body. If the body oscillates horizontally, the image moves in the same direction, so that the total effect is the same as for an oscillating double body in an infinite fluid. In this case then, there is no sourcelike behavior, and the leading term in (2.8) for this problem is the horizontal dipole term, the A , term, that is, $(x, y,
-
~ ) e ’ ~[A,(x) ‘ + A , ( x ) cos O/r]eiut
as r - ,
00.
(3.19)
Whatever method of solution is used, allterms in the expansion (2.8) can be determined except A,(x). There is no information available in the near field alone that can be used to determine this quantity, since the near-field boundary-value problem is a Neumann problem, the solution of which is always nonunique to the extent of an arbitrary additive constant. The additive “constant” is not trivial, since it is really a function of x, and so it contributes to the evaluation of fluid pressure. It does not vanish, as in the infinite-fluid case of an oscillating body; this is a consequence of the presence of the free surface. We must solve the far-field problem in order to determine the additive term. Far Field. The velocity potential must satisfy the 3-D Laplace equation and the free-surface conditions, (3.1) and (3.2). There is no body boundary condition, only a condition that the far-field solution be consistent with the near-field solution. The far-field solution must satisfy a radiation condition, that is, it must represent outgoing waves far away from the body. Since we are here assuming that o = O( 1) as E -,0,differentiation with respect to time and space coordinates does not alter orders of magnitude, that is,
apt, a p x , spy, a p z = O(1)
as
E -,0.
(3.20)
The potential in the far field will presumably be o( I), and so the quadratic terms in (3.1) and (3.2) are all of higher order of magnitude than the linear terms. It is also consistent in the first approximation to satisfy the conditions on z = 0. Then it is a simple step to show that the free-surface conditions can be combined into the form given by (3.3),which, for sinusoidal time dependence, becomes
v4 - 4z= 0
on z = O ,
with v = 0 2 / g .
(3.21)
The reasoning that follows is parallel to the infinite-fluid case: In the limit as E -+ 0, the body shrinks down to a line, and so the far-field solution can be represented in terms of a distribution of singularities on that line. In the presence of the free surface, the simple singularity potentials must be modified so that they satisfy (3.21),and they must represent outgoing waves.
Ship Hydrodynamics
115
Otherwise the distributions are arbitrary. The densities of the sources, dipoles, etc., cannot be determined solely from the far-field problem. Furthermore, in the lowest-order approximation in the far field, there will be only one kind of singularity required and possible-whatever kind matches the leading-order term in the near-field solution as r -+ co. The reasoning still follows that for the infinite-fluid problem. In the case of vertical body oscillation, the near-field solution at large r behaves as in (3.18), and so the matching far-field solution represents a distribution of sources. In the case of horizontal body oscillation, the near-field solution behaves as in (3.19), and so the matching far-field solution represents a line of transverse dipoles. The general problem that was discussed in connection with radiation patterns is precisely the far-field problem for the case of a slender body undergoing vertical sinusoidal oscillations, and so the solution expressed in (3.6) can be used here directly. The estimates given in (3.7a) and (3.7b) are not useful now in setting up the matching to the near field, since they are valid only far away; however, they do show that the solution represents outgoing waves, since ei"'Hi2'(vR,)
- (C/R~12)ei("'-"Ro) as
Ro + 00,
where C is a complex constant. In order to match (3.6)with (3.18), we must approximate the expression in (3.6) for small r. The procedure, in brief, is as follows: Rewrite (3.6) as
l L 4 ( ~Y,, Z) = - - d t h ( 5 ) 2n 0
J"
J"
m
dkpJo(kR)
0
(3.22) r\
The first term can be expressed
(3.23)
as r + 0, that is, it represents the potential for a line distribution of sources of density 26(x) in an infinite fluid; the small-r approximation for this potential was already given in (2.11b(2.13), and we have taken it over directly here except for the change by a factor of 2. The second term in (3.22) can be divided into two parts, a principal-value integral and a contribution from the contour indentation; as r + 0, they can be expressed in terms of standard
116
T. Francis Ogilvie
functions
where Ho is a Struve function. Thus the small-r approximation for $(x, y, z) is (3.25) where
(3.25') After being multiplied by exp(iot), this must match with (3.18), and so we have &(x)= - ioB(x)S,;
AOb) = f ( x ) .
(3.26a) (3.26b)
Just as in the infinite-fluid problem, the near field has provided the information that was lacking in the far field, namely, the value of 8(x), and the far field has provided the information that was lacking in the near field, namely, the additive function A o ( x ) .The latter, in particular, is essential information, for this " constant " in the solution of the 2-D crossplane problems contributes to the pressure field acting on the body. This extra pressure does not depend on y and z, but it may nevertheless cause a net force in the transverse directions, since the pressure is integrated over just the wetted portion of the hull to give net force. In any case, the term A o ( x )in the near-field solution is the only manifestation of interactions among the cross sections at various values of x; it represents a longitudinal wave at a particular x caused by the sources (in the far-field description) at all other values of x. If Ao(x) were equal to zero, the above slender-ship theory would be just a primitive kind of strip theory. In the case of horizontal body oscillations, the resulting theory is just a primitive strip theory, with no interactions among cross sections. The situation is analogous to the infinite-fluid case. The additive function of x cannot be determined in the near field alone; all that can be asserted from the near-field problem is that, for large r, the solution behaves like a constant or like cos O/r [see (3.1911. This fact eliminates the possibility of there being a
Ship Hydrodynamics
117
line of sources in the lowest-order far-field solution; the first term must represent a line distribution of horizontal dipoles of unknown density. The potential for such a distribution can be written down immediately, for example, by differentiating (3.22) with respect to y . This potential can be approximated for small r by a single-term expression that represents a 2-D dipole, that is, it matches the A , term of (3.19), and there is nothing to match with A,. Therefore we must set A, = 0 in the near-field solution for the case of horizontal body oscillations, and there are no interaction effects among the various cross sections. Nonunqormity of the Near-Field Solution. Slender-body theory is by its nature a study in singular-perturbation problems, marked by strong mathematical nonuniformities in the solutions. The far-field solution is nonuniform near the singular line. The near-field solution is nonuniform far away, for it gives no solution (or a trivial solution) outside of the domain 0 < x < L The low-frequency ship-oscillation case presents an even stronger nonuniformity in the near-field solution: It admits of no wavelike motion [except for the add-on longitudinal wave component included in A,(x)]. Physically, one expects a heaving ship to create outgoing waves and these waves ought to be evident in the regions off the sides of the ship. In fact, this is what Fig. 3 showed on the basis of a simple mathematical model. co However, the near-field solution displays no such behavior even as y -+ in the near field. The interpretation of this fact is that the wavelength is so very, very long that the behavior identified as “near-field behavior” occurs entirely in a region which is small compared with a wavelength. Of course, we have already described this as a long-wave theory,” and we implied that ship beam was small compared with the wavelength. But much more is implied: the whole n e a r j e l d is small compared with the wavelength. This seems to be a rather severe constraint on the possible utility of the theory. It also implies that there is no damping (to lowest order) associated with the waves radiated out to the sides. Another aspect of possibly singular behavior may be noted, this being a local singularity. In the case of vertical oscillation of the body, the fluid velocity at the level z = 0 on the side of the body can have only a vertical component. [We are assuming that the body is wall-sided at the waterline.] However, the rigid-wall condition at the free surface says that there can be only a horizontal component of velocity at that same point. Accordingly, the solution must indicate a stagnation point at the juncture of the body surface and the undisturbed free surface. Such a flow condition at that point seems highly unlikely, however. Our general interpretation of the rigid-wall condition seems to be valid enough: The vertical velocity component is very small compared with the horizontal component. However, at the body side the “
118
T. Francis Ogilvie
latter is precisely zero in magnitude, and so this comparison is meaningless there. Our assumptions have led us into setting a poorly posed problem in this respect, but we do not know of any careful analysis of this point. 2. High-Frequency Oscillations; Strip Theory High frequency” will be defined by the order-of-magnitude statement o = O ( E - ’ / ’ ) .The physical interpretation of this should be made in terms of the corresponding wavelength, A = 2ng/oZ, which is now O(E). Since B = O ( E )as well, we presume that the ratio A/B is O( 1) as E -,0. Thus we are assuming that the frequency becomes higher and higher as the body becomes more slender, and it does so in just such a way that A/B can remain fixed. This may seem to be highly artificial, but in fact it leads to an extremely useful theory. As a heuristic explanation, we may say that it is important under certain circumstances to relate wavelength primarily to the ship beam (or possibly draft), rather than to ship length, as was done in the foregoing low-frequency case. The resulting theory corresponds generally to what is usually called strip theory” in naval architecture. The ordinary derivations of this strip theory are quite different from what we shall present here, although it has long been recognized that “ high frequency is generally implied. In the current literature on ship hydrodynamics, we sometimes encounter an objection being made to the use of a high-frequency theory, usually on the basis of the argument that the wavelength is not much smaller than ship length in the most important problems of wave loads and ship motions. To some extent, such an objection misses the practical significance of asymptotic solutions: We develop an asymptotic expansion in terms of a small parameter which is supposed to be approaching zero, and then we apply the theory to cases in which the small parameter has quite a finite value. We can seldom tell from the theory alone whether the finite value of the parameter is really small enough for the approximation to be useful; we never seem to know how small is “small.” In one problem, the small parameter might have to be and in another problem it might be unity. We must have some other basis for judging the validity of the approximation, perhaps experiments, a higher-order calculation, or a