Advances in Applied Mechanics Volume 15
Editorial Board T. BROOKE BENJAMIN
Y. C. FUNG PAULGERMAIN
L. HOWARTH WILLIA...
131 downloads
1375 Views
12MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Advances in Applied Mechanics Volume 15
Editorial Board T. BROOKE BENJAMIN
Y. C. FUNG PAULGERMAIN
L. HOWARTH WILLIAM PRAGER
T. Y . Wu HANSZIEGLER
Contributors to Volume 15 E. 0. TUCK Vrro A. VANONI W. W. WILLMARTH
ADVANCES rN
APPLIED MECHANICS Edited by Chia-Shun Yih DEPARTMENT OF APPLIED MECHANICS A N D ENGINEERING SCIENCE THE UNIVERSITY OF MICHIGAN ANN ARBOR, MICHIGAN
VOLUME 15
1975
A C A D E M I C PRESS
New York San Francisco London
A Subsidiary of Harcourt Brace Jovanovich, Publishers
COPYRIGHT 0 1975, BY ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. N O PART OF THIS PUBLICATION MAY B E REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM OR BY ANY MEANS, ELECTRONIC OR MECHANICAL, INCLUDING PHOTOCOPY, RECORDING, OR ANY INFORMATION STORAGE AND RETRIEVAL SYSTEM, WITHOUT PERMISSION IN WRITING FROM T HE PUBLISHER.
ACADEMIC PRESS, INC.
111 Fifth Avenue, New York, New York 10003
United Kingdom Edition published by ACADEMIC PRESS, INC. (LONDON) LTD. 24/28 Oval Road. London NWl
LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOG CARDNUMBER:48-8503 ISBN 0-12-002015-7 PRINTED IN THE UNITED STATES O F AMERICA
Contents
vii ix
LISTOF CONTRIBUTORS PREFACE
River Dynamics Vito A . Vanoni I. Introduction 11. River Geometry 111. Dimensional Analysis of Alluvial Flows
Bed Forms Suspension of Sediment Initiation of Sediment Motion Mean Velocity V111. Sediment Discharge 1X. Effect of Water Temperature List of Symbols References 1V. V. VI. V11.
2 6 15 20 29 40 46
60 12 78 81
Matching Problems Involving Flow through Small Holes E. 0. Tuck I. Introduction 11. The Effective Size of Holes 111. Double Slits and Split Plates
1V. V. VI. VII. VIII. IX. X.
Laws of Combination for Finite Sparse Distributions of Holes Blockage and Permeability Coefficients Green’s Function for a Rectangular Pipe Vehicles Moving Close to a Plane Surface Water-Wave Transmission through Holes in Walls The Helmholtz Resonator Real-Fluid Effects References V
90 93 99 105 110 119
125 134 141 146 156
vi
Contents
Structure of Turbulence in Boundary Layers W. W. Willmarth I. Introduction 11. Development of Turbulent Boundary Layer Flow 111. Background Knowledge of the Structure of Turbulence Prior to 1955 1V. Recent Developments in Research on the Structure of Turbulence
V. Discussion of Coherent Structures List of Symbols References
INDEX SUBJECT INDEX AUTHOR
159 160 165
171 233 247 247 255
260
List of Contributors
Numbers in parcnthescs indicate thc pagcs on which thc authors' contributions bcgin.
E. 0. TUCK,Department of Applied Mathematics. University of Adelaide. Adelaide, South Australia (89) VITOA. VANONI,California Institute of Technology, Pasadena. California ( I W. W. WILLMARTH, Department of Aerospace Engineering. The University of Michigan, Ann Arbor. Michigan (159)
vii
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Preface
The method of matched asymptotic expansions, which has recently received considerable attention. is one that first was applied in the nineteenth century. For instance, Rayleigh used it effectively in his studies of wave diffraction through openings that are small compared with the wavelength. Professor E. 0. Tuck's article on flow through small holes and gaps is a natural extension of Rayleigh's work. The paper. appearing at a time when the method is so widely appreciated. contains many imaginative applications to the solution of fluid-mechanical problems. There was a period during which many researchers in the field of turbulence became discouraged because of the ditficulty and intractability of the subject. However. many advances are now being made in the effort to understand turbulence. mainly by experimenters using computers to evaluate quickly correlation coefficients of the turbulent field. Gradually a pattern of behavior of the fluid in turbulent boundary layers has been evolving. and one is justified in feeling excitement about the progress. As one who has significantly contributed to this progress. Professor W. W. Willmarth has written a perceptive and informative paper on the present state of research on turbulence. I t should be a useful reference to all interested in turbulent flows. Finally. we take great pride and pleasure in seeing Professor Vito Vanoni's article in print. This article is the summing-up of a life's work: many of the results presented therein were obtained by the author himself. Sediment transportation is a difficult subject. and reliable results concerning it are extremely useful and important to the management of rivers and the protection of our environment. Professor Vanoni has just retired from remunerated service a t the California Institute of Technology. It must be satisfying to have so much solid achievement to look back on. But we know that Professor Vanoni is still very active in research. and we take this opportunity to wish him not only continued health but also continued success in his work. CHIA-SHUN YIH
ix
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
River Dynamics7 VITO A. VANONI California Institute of Technology Pasadena. California
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Features of Rivers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Nomenclature . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Objective and Subjects Covered . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1 . River Geometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Stream Forms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B . Cross-Section Geometry . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Dimensional Analysis of Alluvial Flows . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . General Framework . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Contributions to Dimensional Analysis . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. BedForms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Description . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Prediction of Bed Forms . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Analysis of Bed Form Development . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V . Suspension of Sediment . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Theoretical Relations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Observed Velocity Profiles in Sediment-Laden Flow . . . . . . . . C. Experimental Confirmation of Concentration Distribution Relations . VI . Initiation of Sediment Motion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Entrainment-Mechanism . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Experimental Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VII . Mean Velocity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . General Velocity Relations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Observed Velocity Relations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Depth-Velocity and Depth-Discharge Relations . . . . . . . . . . D . Prediction of Velocity . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E. Selected Velocity Relations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . VIII . Sediment Discharge . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . General Relations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Theoretical Concepts . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Sediment Discharge Measurements in Rivers . . . . . . . . . . .
2 2 3 6 6 6 12 15 15 18 20 20 23 28 29 29 32 36 40 40 41 42 46 46 48 50 53 56 60 60 63 70
t This paper was prepared with the support of National Science Foundation Grant No . GK 3910. 1
2
Vito A , Vanoni IX. Effect of Water Temperature . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Field Observations . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Laboratory Studies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . List of Symbols . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
72 72 74 78 81
I. Introduction
A. FEATURES OF RIVERS River flows differ from those in pipes and channels, normally considered in works on fluid mechanics, in that their boundaries are not fixed but are formed by the flow itself and change continually with time and flow rate. Streams flowing in such self-formed channels are known as alluvial streams. Figure 1, which is a picture of a small river, shows some common features of
FIG. 1. A small meandering river
River Dynamics
3
natural alluvial streams. The channel is very sinuous with very few straight reaches. The presence of the crescent-shaped lakes is ample evidence that the channel has moved. Such a lake is formed when the flow cuts across the neck of a loop and bypasses it, leaving a lake which is often called an oxbow lake. These lakes ultimately will fill with sediment deposited by flood waters which overflow the main channel during high floods. A sinuous river such as the one shown in Fig. 1 is said to meander, and a loop is called a meander. Alluvial streams transport sediment as well as water. Water flow rate or water discharge is seldom steady but fluctuates with periods varying from one day or less to a year or longer. The sediment flow rate or sediment discharge fluctuates with the water discharge, but it is nonuniform even when the water flow is steady. Sediment is eroded from the concave banks and deposited on convex banks in such a way that the meanders tend to increase in amplitude and to move downstream. Beds of alluvial streams often are covered with ripples, dunes, or other forms which move by continuous rhythmic erosion and deposition. These bed forms may change rapidly with change in water flow and appreciably alter the flow resistance of the bed and the capacity of the channel to carry water and sediment. The latter two properties of alluvial streams, i.e., their capacities for carrying water and sediment, are of primary interest to hydraulic engineers; and the need to understand them has provided much of the incentive to study river dynamics.
B. NOMENCLATURE Sediments are classified according to their grain size or grain diameter as clay, silt, sand, gravel, cobbles, and boulders. One of several systems (Lane, 1947; see also ASCE, 1962) used to classify sediment has the following size ranges for these sediments: clay, finer than 0.004 mm; silt, 0.004-0.062 mm; sand, 0.062-2.0 mm; gravel, 2.0-64 mm; cobbles, 64256 mm; boulders, 256-4096 mm. Each class is broken down further into subclasses with maximum size twice the minimum size. For example, sands are broken down into five classes: very fine sand, 0.062-0.125 mm; fine sand, 0.125-0.250 mm; medium sand, 0.250-0.500 mm; coarse sand, 0.500-1.00 mm; and very coarse sand, 1.0-2.0 mm. The sizes and size distribution of sand and finer gravel are often determined by sieving. Sizes of sand are also sometimes determined indirectly by observing their fall velocity in still water and calculating a diameter from the equation for the fall velocity of spheres (ASCE, 1962, 1969b). Silts and clays are usually analyzed by observing their fall velocity. Diameters calculated from fall velocities are called sedimentation diameters or fall diameters. The size distribution of a sediment is of interest in dealing with river behavior. The size distributions of two fine sands
4
Vito A . Vanoni
determined by sieving are shown in Fig. 2 as the logarithm of size against percent by weight finer than the size on a probability scale. The sand with geometric mean size d , = 0.158 mm was artificially prepared, is well sorted, and its size distribution follows a straight line, i.e. the size distribution is essentially log-normal. The other is a river sand that has a much larger geometric standard deviation of sizes cgthan the artifically sorted sand. Its 99.99
I l l I
I
I l l
I
I
I I I
I
.J
99.9
-
003 .04 .06 -08 0 I
0.2
04 0.6 0.8 I
2.
4.
6. 8 10
Grain Size ( m m )
FIG.2. Cumulative grain size distributions for two sands,
size distribution follows the log-normal relations over most of the material but deviates from the relation at the fine and coarse ends of the distribution. The size distributions of many natural river sands tend to be log-normal. If the size distribution is log-normal, the geometric mean size dg can be read directly from the size distribution curve and the geometric standard deviation og can be calculated as in which d,,., and d 1 5 . 9are the sediment sizes for which 84.1% and 15.9% by weight, respectively, of the
Jz
River Dynamics
5
sediment is finer. When the size distribution is not log-normal, og is arbitrarily calculated by the same expression, and d, is calculated as the geomet~median ,,~ size .d,, is read directly from ric mean of d84,1 and ~ iThe the graph at the intersection of the 50% line and the size distribution curve. If the size distribution is log-normal, d, and dSoare the same. The sediment load of a stream, i.e. the sediment that is being transported by the stream, is classified in several ways. In one such classification the sediment in motion is divided into bed load and suspended load. Bed load is defined as the sediment that moves on or near the bed. This sediment is either in contact with the bed or moves in short jumps and makes frequent contact with it. The suspended load is that part of the sediment that moves in suspension. Because of the nature of the turbulent diffusion process, there is continuous interchange between the bed load and the suspended load. In a second classification the total sediment load of a stream is divided into wash load and bed sediment load. The wash load (Einstein et al., 1940) is made up of the fine particles that are found in small quantities in the bed, and the bed sediment load contains particles that are abundant in the bed. The wash load is often taken to be the silt and clay, i.e. sediment finer than 0.062 mm. As may be seen from Fig. 2, approximately 1% of the natural river sand is finer than 0.062 mm and would probably be considered as wash load for this particular stream. In a stream with high velocity and sediment transporting capacity the wash load could contain sediments coarser than 0.062 mm. Because the wash load is fine, it is easily suspended and tends to be distributed uniformly in the flow and hence is moved predominantly in suspension. The capacity of a flow to carry wash load is large, and by definition most of the sediment in the wash load sizes is washed through the river system. For this reason, the amount of wash load transported by a river depends on how much of this kind of sediment reaches it and not upon the capacity of the flow to transport it. On the contrary, the capacity of the stream to carry bed sediment is limited and depends on flow properties such as velocity, depth, etc. The amount of sediment transported as wash load by many rivers is several times that transported as bed sediment load. For example, Jordan (1965) reported that in the decade 1948-1958 the weight of the measured suspended sediment transported by the Mississippi River was 47% clay, 38% silt, and only 15% sand. Correcting for the fact that the apparatus used measured approximately only 60% of the bed sediment load transported would increase the fraction of sand in the total material transported by about 8% and decrease slightly the percentage of clay and silt. The water discharge is usually measured in units of volume per unit time, e.g. cubic feet per second. The sediment discharge is commonly measured in mass of dry sediment per unit of time, e.g. pounds (mass) per second or tons
6
Vito A. Vanoni
per day. Sediment discharge can be subdivided in the same way that load is divided. Thus, use is made of the terms bed load discharge, suspended load discharge, bed sediment discharge, and wash load discharge. Some authors use the term load to denote the sediment discharge as well as the sediment itself. In this chapter load refers to the sediment and sediment discharge refers to the rate of transportation of the sediment. Sediment concentration is usually reported in mass per unit volume or parts per million (ppm) by weight. Two kinds of concentration are now in use. The first, called the point concentration or merely concentration, expresses the amount of sediment passing through an elementary area of the stream cross section per unit volume of the water and sediment passing the elementary area. The second one, known as the sediment discharge concentration, is obtained by dividing the sediment discharge by the water discharge and is expressed in mass of sediment per unit volume of flow or in PPm.
C. OBJECTIVE AND SUBJECTS COVERED The objective of this chapter is to present for rivers and river dynamics information that may be of interest to engineers and scientists not involved directly in this area of study. Because much of the theory is not developed to the point where it is generally accepted, there is often disagreement on the interpretation of observed data. Therefore, much space is devoted to presentation of data so the reader can make his own interpretation or judge the validity of the interpretations presented. In some instances no theoretical interpretations are available, and only descriptive information on stream behavior is presented. Several subjects will be discussed in more detail than others, not necessarily because they are of unusual importance, but because they are of interest to the author. 11. River Geometry
A. STREAM FORMS Stream forms or river channel patterns have been classified by Leopold and Wolman (1957) as braided, meandering, or straight. This classification is based on a macroscopic view of rivers of the kind obtained from an airplane or other high point. A braided river is one that flows in a number of streams which divide and rejoin repeatedly, leaving islands between branches. The braided stream is also thought to be an overloaded one or one in which the
River Dynamics
7
sediment discharge to it exceeds its transporting capacity; however, detailed study of such streams show that they are in equilibrium (Leopold and Wolman, 1957). Most self-formed river channels tend to be sinuous, and straight reaches with lengths equal to more than a few times the stream width are a rarity (Leopold and Wolman, 1957; Lane, 1957). The sinuosity or sinuosity ratio of a stream is expressed as the ratio of the length along the center line of the stream to the length along the valley (Leopold and Wolman, 1957). Figure 3
*
MEAN0ERLENGTH.L
*
is a definition sketch for meanders. The principal dimensions are the length of wavelength L, the width of the meander belt, and the amplitude. The thalweg or deepest part of the channel indicated on the sketch tends to hug the concave bank and crosses the channel at or near the inflection point of the curve. This crossover zone is often referred to as the crossing or crossover. The deepest portion in the thalweg of a meander usually occurs near the concave bank in the vicinity of the axis of the bend, and the shallowest point is usually near the crossing. The amplitude increases by erosion of the concave bank and by deposition of sediment on the convex bank or point. This deposit on the point is called the point bar. Leopold and Wolman (1957) observed that even in reaches that were almost straight, with a sinuosity ratio approaching unity, the thalweg or the line locating the lowest point of the stream, was sinuous, that is, it wandered within the channel. This was
8
Vito A . vanoni
also observed by Brooks (1958) and others in straight flumes. As the thalweg weaves back and forth across the bed, bars are formed in a staggered pattern at the banks of the channels. These have been called alternate bars (ASCE, 1966a). A striking picture of such bars in a straight reach of the Rio Grande appears in Maddock (1969) and ASCE (1966a, Fig. 4). Leopold and Wolman (1957) and others have observed that all streams, regardless of their form, tend to flow in a series of riffles and pools. This characteristic is reflected by rugged saw-toothed shaped longitudinal bottom profiles.
Bankfull
Discharge ( f t 3 / s e c )
FIG.4. Plot of slope against bank-full discharge for braided meandering and straight river channels: the diagonal line in the plot divides data for meandering and braided channels (after Leopold and Wolman, 1957).
Figure 4 by Leopold and Wolman (1957) is a plot of channel slope against bank full discharge for rivers of various forms. The line S = 0.06Q-0.44 divides the data for braided and meandering streams, and shows that for a given discharge a braided stream will have a larger slope than a meandering one. The data on meandering streams are for cases in which the sinuosity is equal to or exceeds 1.5. Streams with sinuosity in this range have welldeveloped loops and are considered to be meandering streams (Leopold and Wolman, 1957). Those with lesser sinuosity than 1.5 are said to be sinuous but not meandering.
River Dynamics
9
The geometry of meanders has been studied by many geomorphologists and engineers. Inglis (1949, cited by Leopold and Wolman, 1957) presented the relation
L = 36Q0.5 (2.11 in which L is the meander length and Q is the dominant discharge. Leopold and Wolman plotted L against bank full discharge for some North American rivers and found that this relation fitted the data extending over eight orders of magnitude only moderately well. Since stream width b was also found to be proportional to Q0.5, the ratio L/b should not vary with Q. Leopold and Wolman (1960) found that for a number of streams varying from a laboratory flow one-foot wide to the Mississippi River one-mile wide, the relation between meander lengths and bank full width was L = 10.9b1.01. (2.2) They reported that the scatter of the data from this line was small and much less than for the relation between L and Q. These authors also found that the mean radius of curvature rm for meanders was related to L by L = 4.1rkg8, (2.3) and hence that the ratio r , / b = 10.9/4.7 = 2.3, approximately. These relations are for bank full stages or discharges and are probably different for other stages. These results indicate that all meanders tend to be similar and account for the fact, pointed out by Leopold and Wolman (1960), that one cannot judge the size of a river from a casual glance at a map without knowing the scale. The above relations were determined from lines fitted to data and are mean values. From a sample of 50 rivers Leopold and Wolman (1960) found that the ratio rm/bhad a mean value of 3.1 and a median value of 2.7 and that two-thirds of the values were between 1.5 and 4.3. Although meanders tend to be similar, the stream width and meander amplitude are different for different streams for the same discharge. Leopold and Wolman (1960) advanced the opinion that the relations between b, L, and rm are only weakly dependent on sediment properties. Width and amplitude appear to depend more strongly on the sediment properties than on other stream characteristics. Schumm (1967) analyzed extensive data from 36 streams with a wide range in type of sediment load. This analysis showed that the type of bed sediment (mean size and size distribution) had an important influence on the meanders and yielded the relation L = 234Q0.48M-0.74 (2-4) in which Q is the discharge of the mean annual flood and M is the percentage of silt and clay (sediment finer than 0.074 mm) in the sediment exposed in
10
vito A. vanoni
the perimeter of the channel. Schumm also obtained a relation for L in terms of the mean annual discharge in which the exponent of the discharge is 0.34 and that of M is the same as in Eq. (2.4). The data in Eq. (2.4) show that the meander length decreases as the percentage M of the silt and clay in the bed increases. Fahnestock and Maddock (1964) observed alternate bars in two adjacent straight reaches of the Rio Grande near El Paso, Texas, which had stabilized rough banks and widths of 100 and 200 ft, respectively. The channels always showed a tendency to form alternate bars, but this was greater in the 200-ft-wide reach and was more pronounced in summer than in winter. Einstein and Shen (1964) observed the formation of alternate bars in straight flumes with smooth and rough nonerodible walls. With smooth walls alternate bars formed only when the ratio of stream width b to depth d had a certain’ value and when the Froude number F had a value approaching unity. The Froude number is defined as F = V/@ in which I/ is mean flow velocity, g is the acceleration due to gravity, and d is flow depth. These bars that formed at the relatively high value of the Froude number were attributed to surface waves. With roughened walls the alternate bars developed for flows that did not produce them with smooth walls. These authors attributed the bar formation to the secondary circulation induced in the vicinity of the erodible bed and rough bank and based their analysis of the problem on this concept. In further experiments with rough banks Shen and Komura (1968) found that no distinct alternate bars formed with uniform flows, but they formed with unsteady flows. In analyzing the formation of alternate bars Sukegawa (1972) assumed that flows in geometrically similar channels are similar when they have the same value of the ratio U , /U*c in which U , is the shear velocity of the flow and U,, is the value of U , for which motion of bed sediment is initiated. He further assumed that the characteristic length for alternate bars was the stream width b. Analysis of laboratory data yielded the following criterion for alternate bar formation:
The ratio U , /U*c gives a measure of the transport rate, i.e., large values of this quotient produce high transport rates. The criterion then indicates that the tendency to form alternate bars and hence to meander increases from stream to stream as transport rate diminishes and the slope increases. Applying the above criterion to data on the Rio Grande reported by Fahnestock and Maddock (1964) gives values of the right-hand side of Eq. (2.5) ranging from 10 to 30 times the observed values of d/b. Apparently this criterion
River Dynamics
11
predicts that all but the narrowest streams (large d/b) tend to meander, and in this sense is in agreement with the field observations. A number of laboratory studies of meandering have appeared in the literature. Friedkin (1945) found that a straight channel was unstable and would meander as long as the flow could move sediment and erode the banks. He also found that the meander lengths and amplitudes increased as discharge or slope increased. In none of his experiments with sorted granular material, some of which lasted for well over 100 hr, was there any tendency for meanders to "cut off'' and form oxbow lakes, as occurs in natural streams. Based on this result and some experiments in which the erodibility of the sediment in which the channel was formed was varied randomly, Friedkin concluded that cutoffs result because of the local differences in the erosion resistance of bank sediments. Ackers and Charlton (1970) made experiments on meandering in beds of sand with median size of 0.15 mm. The wavelengths L of the meanders formed in these studies were proportional to QO.""' in which Q is the flow rate. Data from other studies with coarser sediments gave different values of the exponent indicating that other factors influence the meander length. These workers found that an increase in sediment discharge caused L to decrease slightly. By dimensional analysis and physical reasoning Ackers and Charlton concluded that the ratio L/d,o was a function of at least three other ratios composed of combinations of Q, d,, , g, p, ps - p, p, and C, in which p is water density, p, is sediment density, p the viscosity of the water, and C, the sediment discharge concentration. A plot of L/d,o against Q/d:,Jgd,O(p,/p - 1 ) for several sizes of sediment showed only fair correlation and suggested that other variables were influencing the results. Theoretical treatments of the meander problem have been developed by several workers. Anderson (1967) postulated that a disturbance at the bank of a flow would set up a cross flow that would then induce transverse sloshing as a free oscillation. The wavelength of this oscillation would correspond to that of the meander giving the relation L ~ c Q ' / ~ / ( g d ) ' Eliminat/". ing the depth by means of the relation between Q and depth gave L = 39Q0.39.Callander (1965) presented a linearized stability analysis of straight two-dimensional alluvial channels showing that such channels are unstable and tend to meander. The meander lengths obtained by Callander were in reasonable agreement with the Inglis relation [Eq. (2.1)]. Engelund and Stovgaard (1973) made a stability analysis which took into account the variation of velocity in the vertical direction. These workers found that for a given flow resistance and depth the stream will meander if it is narrower than a certain width, and it will become braided if it is wider than this width. Langbein and Leopold (1966) based their analysis on the hypothesis that the form of a meander is one in which the sum of the squares of the changes in
12
Vito A. Vanoni
direction of each unit length of channel is a minimum. Planforms calculated on this basis were in reasonable agreement with some observed planforms. Field observations show that most rivers meander, a few are braided, and very few are straight even over short reaches. The concept that rivers meander because they are unstable when perturbed in a crosswise direction and which was applied in several stability analyses seems to be valid. However, it is at variance with some concepts and data, namely that of Einstein and Shen (1964) and Shen and Komura (1968) if it is assumed that the formation of alternate bars is an indication of the tendency to meander. Einstein and Shen found that roughening the walls ofa channel induced the alternate bars to form. The finding of Shen and Komura that alternate bars would form in channels with rough walls only when flow was unsteady is difficult to understand and needs further study. Two predominant variables influencing the size of meanders appear to be flow rate and relative amount of fine sediment in the stream bed as found by Schumm (1967). This result agrees with that found in experiments by Ackers and Charlton (1970) that the meander length depends strongly on discharge and sediment size. However, Ackers and Charlton were of the opinion that other quantities, such as the water viscosity and sediment concentration, were also of importance. Einstein and Shen (1964) reported that the Froude number of the flow was a factor in meandering. Large rivers and very sinuous ones have very low Froude numbers (less than 0.5) and it is doubtful that their behavior is Froude number dependent. Equation (2.5) by Sukegawa (1972) suggests that slope as well as the ratio U,,/U, affect the tendency to meander. The quantity U,, typifies the erosion resistance of the bed as does M in Eq. (2.4). U , expresses the sediment transporting capacity of the flow, and S is related to the flow velocity. In principle then, Eq. (2.5) is seen to have some of the same elements as the Schumm equation (2.4). The problem of identifying the pertinent variables in the meander phenomenon is an important one which can be carried out in the laboratory through carefully planned but tedious experiments. The planning can be guided by dimensional analysis, an example of which is that by Ackers and Charlton (1970).
B. CROSS-SECTION GEOMETRY Leopold and Maddock (1953) related surface width b, mean depth d, mean velocity V , and total suspended sediment discharge G,, at a station to the discharge Q for a large number of rivers in the United States. These authors also related b, d, V , and G,, to mean annual discharge Q at various stations along particular river systems. Since mean annual discharge usually increases in the downstream direction, these relations normally show stream
River Dynamics
13
characteristics as one moves downstream and they are called downstream relations. The relations found are: b = aQ"
(2.6a)
d = cQS
(2.6b)
V = kQ"
(2.6~)
Gss
(2.6d)
= pQJ*
The mean depth is defined by d = A/b, where A is the area of the stream cross section. Therefore Q = bdV, from which we get w + f + m = 1 and ack = 1. The average values of the exponents w,f; and m for the foot-second system of units are: Average Values of Exponents Exponent
at a station
W
0.26 0.40 0.34
along river system ~~
.f tn
0.5 0.4 0.1
As remarked above, the exponents at a station are to be applied to the entire range of discharges, and those along river systems apply to the local mean annual discharge measured at a station. Values of the exponent j for total suspended sediment discharge (wash load and bed sediment discharge) measured at a station were found to range between 2.0 and 3.0. Leopold and Maddock (1953) argued that total suspended sediment concentration probably decreases slightly in the downstream direction for flows with a given frequency of occurrence. From this it follows that j for the downstream direction should probably be slightly less than unity. Values of the intercepts a, c, and k varied considerably indicating that the size of the channels is not determined by discharge alone. Figure 5 showing a logarithmic plot of width, depth, and velocity against discharge for the Powder River of Locate, Montana is an example of the relations at a station found by Leopold and Maddock. The exponents w, f ; and m shown in the figure for this particular station are close to the average values listed above. Data for downstream relations for eight river systems from diverse physiographic settings analyzed by Leopold and Maddock show that width, depth, and velocity tend to increase as the mean annual discharge increases. With few exceptions the exponents w were close to 0.5 and exponentsf were close to 0.4. The exponent m varied from 0.05 to 0.16. The values of the exponent w of 0.5 for downstream data agree with the Inglis relation derived from data from canals in equilibrium. This also agrees with the regime relation for width given by Blench (1970).
14
Vito A . Vunoni
I
I I I1111
FIG.5. Relation of width, depth, and velocity to discharge for Powder River at Locate, Montana after Leopold and Maddock (1953).
The ratio bid will increase or decrease with increasing Q depending on whether w - f is positive or negative. Mean values of the exponents at a station indicate that w - f is negative and that bld decreases as Q increases. Leopold and Maddock (1953) found that this was a general trend; that is, as the discharge at a section increases, the width of the streams becomes less relative to its depth. The mean values of the exponents for the downstream relations indicate that w - fis positive and hence that bld increases as mean annual discharge increases. This means that bid for the local mean annual discharge Q increases in the downstream direction since Q increases in the downstream direction. Schumm (1963) found that the width-to-depth ratio for some stable streams in the western United States could be expressed as b = 255M-1.08 (2.71 d ~
River Dynamics
15
in which M is the percent by weight of silt and clay in the sediment in the bed surface. The ratio b/d varied from approximately 2 to over 300. The data deviated appreciably from the mean given by Eq. (2.7) indicating that other variables aside from M were influencing the geometry of the cross section. Equation (2.7) indicates that channels with relatively large amounts of fine and hence erosion resistant sediments on the bed tend to be narrow and deep. Schumm’s finding shows that the shape of the channel of an alluvial stream depends on the properties of the sediment. This helps explain the variation found by Leopold and Maddock (1953) in the coefficients and exponents of Eqs. (2.6) for different streams. 111. Dimensional Analysis of Alluvial Flows
A. GENERAL FRAMEWORK Based on laboratory experience, Kennedy and Brooks (1963) listed the variables involved in alluvial flows, outlined the interrelationships between variables, and tabulated several sets of dependent and independent variables. They also indicated which set of independent variables would give unique values of the dependent variables and which multivalued solutions. The tabulation of variables by Kennedy and Brooks is reproduced as Table 1. There are 15 variables for flumes, and between the variables there are also a number of relations which can be applied in obtaining a solution to flow in flumes. These relations are: (1) Continuity equation Q
=
bdV.
(2) Definition of the friction factorf
(3) Roughness relation giving friction factor in terms of independent variables. This relation is not well formulated. (4) Sediment discharge relation. This relation is not well formulated. ( 5 ) Hydraulic radius-depth relation, which depends on the shape of the cross section. This relation is not well formulated. Since there are 15 variables and five relations, there must be ten independent variables. The symbols used in Eqs. (3.1) and (3.2) are defined in Table 1. Two kinds of flumes are used in laboratory studies of sediment transportation. One is the closed-circuit flume and the other is the once-through or
TABLE 1 INDEPENDENT A N D DEPENDENT VARIABLES FOR STEADY UNIFORM FLOW I N ALLUVIAL STREAMS Independent variables
System
Properties of fluid, sediment, gravity, etc.
Characteristics of flow system (not all combinations listed)
Dependent variables (not all combinations listed)
Functional relations
Unique
Multiple-valued for some ranges
Flumes
X
X X
b
-7
a
Field: Short term
X X
X
Long term (“graded stream”) Very long term
v> P> P , Y
Q, G,
v> P? P , > Y> geology
Climate, man-made works
?
v, kinematic viscosity of the water; p, density of water; p s , density of sediment; d,, geometric mean size of sediment; ogrgeometric standard deviation of sediment sizes; w, fall velocity of sediment in the water; g, acceleration due to gravity; Q, water discharge; d, flow depth; b, flow width; G,, bed sediment discharge; V , mean velocity; r , Alp, hydraulic radius ofstream cross section; S, slope of stream; and f is the Darcy-Weisbach friction factor; A is the area of stream cross section; p is the wetter perimeter of cross section.
3 0
3.
River Dynamics
17
sediment-feed flume. In the closed-circuit flume a given amount of water is put in the flow system, which determines the depth; the width is given, the flume is charged with the desired amount and size-grading of sediment, the pump is set for a given discharge, and the experiment is continued until uniform flow is established. When this occurs, the dependent variables of sediment discharge G, ,hydraulic radius r, and slope S can be measured and the mean velocity I/ and friction factorfare calculated using Eqs. (3.1) and (3.2),respectively. The slope of the flume is usually adjusted to hasten the advent of equilibrium. Dependent and independent variables for this case are listed in the first row of Table 1. In once-through or feed flumes the water and sediment are fed to the flumes at predetermined rates so that sediment and water discharge become independent variables and depth and slope are dependent variables as indicated in the second row of Table 1. The flow characteristics of the flume system can be treated as either dependent or independent as indicated in Table 1, rows 1-6. However when the slope is an independent variable, multiple solutions are indicated and their relations are of limited value. The basis for these predictions is laboratory experience illustrated in Fig. 6 which shows a plot of S against I/ for flows with depths of 0.241 ft over a bed of well-graded fine sand (Brooks, 1958).It is seen that in a certain range of slope the velocity is multivalued, although slope is a unique function of velocity. The field problem differs from the flume problem in that the channel is self-formed. Over the short term the width becomes a dependent variable, and it is postulated that a relation such as that presented by Leopold and I
I
Depth 0241 f t d g = 0 I52 rnrn
~--4' 176
~-
0 0036
H -
00028
Symbol Bed -.
-___
0 0032
1
0-
I I
I
I
I
.
/
I
Form __ ripples
4
sand wove
I3
flat,
I
I
-
1
I
/
/-
cn
"
0.0024
0.0020 0.6
/
n Y
<8
1.0
1.2
1.4
Mean Velocity
1.6
1.8
2.0
2.2
2.4
2.6
( f t / sec)
FIG. 6 . Variation of slope and velocity in constant-depth flume experiments by Brooks (1958) (flume width = 10.5 in.). For plot of sediment discharge-velocity data, see Fig. 32.
28
vito A . vanoni
18
Maddock (1953) exists for width. Data on rivers suitable for justifying a list of pertinent variables are not available and are difficult to obtain because variables such as depth and discharge cannot be controlled. The variables for natural or field streams listed in Table 1 were inferred from the results of flume studies and are subject to confirmation. Several cases in which the relations of Table 1 are confirmed are presented below. From a very long time point of view, on the scale of geologic time, the independent variables are fluid and sediment properties, and geologic factors and climate as indicated in the last row of Table 1. All other variables are dependent. €3. CONTRIBUTIONS TO DIMENSIONAL ANALYSIS
The results of Kennedy and Brooks shown in Table 1 and in their paper represent a significant step in the application of dimensional analysis to flow in alluvial channels. According to the first row of Table 1 sediment discharge G, and slope S in a flume can be written symbolically as G, = f (Q, d, b, P, v, P, , d, , g g , w, 91, S
=f(Q,d, b, P, I), P, , d, , g,,
w, 9).
(3.3a) (3.3b)
The fall velocity w can be calculated in terms of v, p, ps, d, , and g for grains of common shape and it probably can be eliminated without causing excessive error. The width b is apparently not of major importance and therefore is also deleted. When this is done, the water discharge q and sediment discharge g, per unit width of stream are substituted for Q and G, ,respectively. The quantity G, is also eliminated despite evidence that it is a factor of some consequence. Eliminating w, b, and og from Eq. (3.3) gives Y, = f ( 4 , 4 P, v, P s d, 5 Y), 9
S =f(q,
4 P, v, P, , d,
7
9).
(3.4a) (3.4b)
None of the seven independent variables in Eqs. (3.4) or their equivalent could be eliminated without losing essential features of the problem. The dependent variables I/, r, andflisted in the first row of Table 1 can also be solved for. In flume studies the hydraulic radius Y is determined from the relation that defines it, Y = A / p = bd/(b + 2 4 , in which the depth d is measured directly. The velocity V is then calculated from Eq. (3.1) andfis calculated from Eq. (3.2) employing the measured value of S. Characteristics of the flows, such as the kind of bed form and length and height of dunes or ripples, are also determined as functions of the independent variables. In his extensive work on alluvial flows Yalin (1963, 1965, 1972) used the set of variables in Eqs. (3.4) except that he interchanged q and S considering
River Dynamics
19
S as an independent variable and q as a dependent variable. Ackers and Charlton (1970) used the same set of variables as Yalin. Cooper and Peterson (1968) Barr and Herbertson (1968a,b), Herbertson (1969), Blench (1969), Willis and Coleman (1969),Cooper et al. (1972),Willis et al. (1972), and Vanoni (1974) used the set of independent variables shown in Eqs. (3.4) or equivalent sets. TABLE 2
DIMENSIONLESS VARIABLES USEDIN ANALYSES OF LABORATORY DATA Dimensionless variables Authors
Independent
Yalin (1963, 1965, 1972)
Ackers and Charlton (1970)
Cooper and Peterson (1968) Blench (1969), Cooper et ul. (1972) Barr and Herbertson (1968a,b), Herbertson (1969) Willis and Coleman (1969)
F,
Vd
, R:13
Willis et u1. (1972) Vanoni (1974)
F,
d
--
, R,, f2
4"
P
Dependent
20
Vito A. Vanoni
By applying the n-theorem, symbolic equations such as (3.3) and (3.4) are expressed in terms of dimensionless quantities. There are always several choices for these quantities, and the selection depends to some extent on the intuition of the investigator, his objective and preference. Because of this there are some differences in the variables selected by different workers. Some dimensionless variables used by several authors are listed in Table 2. As shown in this table, Yalin elected to consider the slope and hence U, = as an independent variable. His ratios z* and R, were first used by Shields (1936). Ackers and Charlton included the width b in their formulation since they were studying meandering in self-formed channels in which width is a dependent variable. Barr and Herbertson (1968a,b) included width to ensure a general relation, while others eliminated it to simplify an already very complicated relation. Willis and Coleman ( 1969) arrived at their terms by normalizing the Navier-Stokes equations taking into account the effect of the sediment in transit on the density of the flowing medium. These authors did not include the term d/d50in their formulation. The authors who undertook to apply dimensional analysis did so with various objectives in mind. Their results will be discussed in subsequent sections under appropriate headings. The natural river is much more complicated than the laboratory flume. Relations such as those listed in Table 1 which are inferred from results of laboratory studies need to be confirmed by appropriate field data. Such data are scarce or nonexistent because of the difficultiesand expense of obtaining them. Where possible such confirmation will be discussed below under the appropriate headings.
IV. Bed Forms A. DESCRIPTION Figure 7 shows sketches of common bed forms observed in laboratory flumes and natural streams. Bed forms are classified according to ASCE (1966a) as ripples, dunes, transition, flat bed, antidunes, and chutes and pools. This sequence of bed forms can be formed in a laboratory flume with a bed of fine or medium sand by progressively increasing the velocity of a flow of fixed depth. Ripples are roughly triangular in profile, have gentle upstream slopes and steep lee slopes, and by definition have wavelengths of 1 ft or less. The profile moves downstream by sediment moving up the upstream slope and sliding down the lee slope. A photograph of ripples by Hwang (1965) is shown in Fig. 8. Dunes are similar to ripples but by definition have wavelengths in excess of 1 ft. Transition denotes a bed that
21
River Dynamics
. ., .. .. . (0)
( d ) Flat Bed
Ripples
r s u r f a c e wave antidune 7
( b ) Dunes and Ripples
-
( e ) Antidunes and S u r f a c e Waves
.--L
-
. . . . . . . ..
....
( f ) Chutes a n d
Pools
( c ) Dunes
FIG.7. Sketches of bed forms.
FIG.8. Ripples in flume 10.5 in. wide. (Photo by L. S. Hwang, Keck Laboratory, Caltech): depth, 0.241 ft; mean velocity, 1.25 ft/sec; d,, = 0.230 m m .
22
Vito A. Vanoni
has a heterogeneous mixture of low amplitude ripples or dunes and flat areas. The flat bed, as the term indicates, is one devoid of forms; and the antidune is a form that is accompanied by a surface wave in phase with the bed wave, as shown in Fig. 9. Antidunes commonly move upstream by erosion of the lee side and deposition on the upstream side, but they have also been observed to move downstream or not at all. The form known as chutes and pools occurs in very steep streams such as mountain torrents. The commonest bed form in rivers is the dune which offers relatively high resistance to flow and tends to maintain low velocities and high depths. At relatively large flows the resistance to flow is reduced due to modification of the dunes and bed flattening, and the capacity of the channel is increased thus allowing floods to pass without undue rise in the water surface. The advantage of this benign feature of streams to man’s activities such as flow diversion, navigation, and flood control is obvious.
FIG.9. Antidune in flume 10.5 in. wide after Kennedy (1960): depth, 0.248 ft; mean velocity, 3.30 ftlsec, wavelength = 1.97 ft; d,, = 0.233 mm.
The continuity relation for sediment in a two-dimensional stream is
in which gs is the transport rate per unit width in mass per unit time, x is a coordinate along the stream, M , is the mass of the sediment per unit volume of the deposit in the bed, q is the elevation of the bed surface, and t is time. In the case of ripples and dunes that move downstream, the upstream face is being lowered so that a?/& is negative and the sediment discharge g, is increasing all along the upstream face. The opposite is true on the steep lee face where sediment is being deposited. In the case of antidunes that move upstream, the sediment discharge is decreasing on the upstream face and increasing on the eroding downstream face. Thus it is seen that sediment motion in streams with bed forms that move either downstream or upstream is not uniform along the stream but occurs rhythmically. In laboratory studies with fine sands, ripples are observed to form on an initially flat bed when there is even a small rate of sediment movement. A number of studies have observed the development of ripples from a flat bed
River Dynamics
23
with different values of the bed shear stress zo . Because transport rate and zo are correlated, in principle these studies are determining the effect of transport rate on ripple formation. In one such study with 0.215-mm sand, Taylor (1971a)found that ripples formed in 1.3 hr with zo = 0.0266 lb/ft2,in 7 hr with zo reduced by 874, and no ripples formed after 66 hr when zo was reduced 22%. There was small but measurable sediment discharge in all three of these runs. An attempt to induce ripple formation by excavating a small cavity about 2 cm long in the bed in the third run was unsuccessful. Raudkivi (1963) found similar results in experiments with 0.4-mm sand. These experiments indicate that there is a critical or threshold value of shear stress or sediment transport rate for the formation of ripples. Several investigators (e.g. Raudkivi, 1963), have observed that ripple formation occurs in the lee of small naturally formed mounds of sediment a few grain diameters high. Raudkivi observed that ripples tended to grow and spread downstream from such mounds.
B. PREDICTION OF BED FORMS The prediction of bed forms has been developed mainly by analysis of laboratory and field data. A well-known result of one such analysis by Simons and Richardson (1966) is shown in Fig. 10 in which bed forms are shown in terms of median fall diameter of bed sediment and stream power zo V in which zo is the mean bed shear stress exerted by the flow on the bed and V is the mean flow velocity. The product zo V gives the power per unit bed area expended by the fluid in overcoming channel friction. It has been called stream power by Bagnold (1960). The bed forms predicted by Fig. 10 are in good agreement with those observed in some small rivers with depth of 5 ft or less. However, for the Mississippi River (Jordan, 1965)with depth up to 50 ft, Fig. 10 predicts flat beds where evidence indicates that the bed form is dunes. Taylor and Brooks (1962) found that they could infer the bed form from the value of the ratio ff' in which f is the Darcy-Weisbach friction factor [Eq. (3.2)] and f ' is the friction factor predicted by the Moody (1944) pipe friction diagram found in most textbooks on elementary fluid mechanics. In calculating f',4r was used instead of pipe diameter and the median bed sediment size is used for the boundary roughness length. Taylor and Brooks found that for flume data with two sands,Jf' exceeded 2 when the bed form was dunes or ripples but was less than 2 for flat and antidune beds. Nordin (1964) found that this relation was valid for the Rio Grande which had flow depth up to 5 ft and a median sediment size of 0.3 mm. Cooper and Peterson (1968), Blench (1969), and Cooper et al. (1972) found that when flume data were plotted as F2 against C, for limited ranges
24
Vito A . Vunoni
FIG. 10. Relation of bed form to stream power and median size of bed sediment after Simons and Richardson (1966).
River Dynamics
25
of d/ds0 and R,, the data for each bed form separated on the graph from those of other forms. Graphs of this kind do not consider the effect of b, o, , and w in the general relation, Eq. (3.3). The sediment density ps is not ignored since it is essentially constant (2.65 gm/cm3) for natural sediments. Cooper and Peterson concluded that the effect of b was minor even for b/d less than 5. The data analyzed were not adequate to investigate the effect of C,.
Vanoni (1974) indicated bed form on a graph of F against d/d50 for limited ranges of the grain number R, .Such a plot of flume data and some river and canal data is shown on Fig. 11 for R, ranging between 10 and 16. The seven
FIG.11. Bed form chart for R,
=
10 to 16 (ds0 = 0.15 t o 0.32 mm) after Vanoni (1974).
dune points at the extreme right are for the Missouri River at Omaha for depths between 11 and 15 ft. The two antidune points at the extreme right with R, values of 10 and 11 are, respectively, for the Rio Grande with a depth of 2.8 ft and the Rio Puerco with a depth of 4.6 ft. The data for transition and flat beds fall together as do those for antidunes and chutes and pools. No explanation can be offered for this intermingling of data. Vanoni (1974) assumed that the formation of ripples and dunes did not depend on depth but only on factors acting at the bed, that is on zo, v, p, d 5 0 , and g if, as before, we assume that p s is constant and ignore the effects of b and rs, . The ripple and dune forms are then determined by U , and R,. Ripple and dune data from flumes and some rivers and canals are plotted in Fig. 12 in terms of these two parameters. The data for the two bed
26
Vito A. Vanoni
forms are neat1 separated by the dashed line in the graph, the equation for which is U , /& = 3.76R; 0 . 5 9 . This result is not useful in prediction of bed forms since streams with other bed forms can have values of the two parameters shown in Fig. 12. However, the results shown in the figure support the assumption that depth is not a major factor in the formation of
FIG. 12. Plot of R, against U*&
for flows with ripple and dune beds after Vanoni
(1974).
ripples and dunes. This result also demonstrates that ripples and dunes are different mechanically and justifies the classification according to wavelength (ASCE, 1966a) that has developed and which may appear to be arbitrary. Vanoni (1974) also assumed that the sediment size dSoor d, was not a factor in the formation of antidunes, which means that their formation
River Dynamics
27
depends on F and d a / v . A plot of data from approximately 100 observations of antidunes in flumes and rivers showed that for d J g d l v less than 2 x lo5 antidunes formed for Froude numbers F 2 0.84. For higher values of this parameter, the critical value of F fell until at d a / v = 5 x lo6 it reached a value of 0.6. This result indicates that the formation of antidunes depends strongly on Froude number and that deep streams will form antidunes at lower Froude numbers than shallow ones, provided that the velocity or shear stress is large enough to move the bed sediment. Shinohara and Tsubaki (1959) obtained fair correlation between 7 ; and the ratios Hld and H I L for a small river and flumes with dune beds. H and L are respectively dune height and length, d is the flow depth, 7; = zb /(ps - p)gd50, and zb is the bed shear stress due to sand grain resistance. For cases where the bed sediment was coarse, d50 = 0.6-1.46 mm, and the sediment was moved as bed load, both Hld and H I L increased as z; increased. But flume data with 0.21 mm sand in which ripples occurred showed that Hld decreased as 7; increased. Values of Hld for these sands range from 0.06 to 0.24. With the 0.21-mm sand Hld for the ripples rose as high as 0.58. The values of H / L , the dune steepness, for the coarser sand range from 0.02 to 0.1. Yalin (1964, 1972) analyzed flume data on length L and height H of ripples and dunes and concluded that for ripples L was proportional to grain size d 5 o and for dunes L depended on the flow depth d and not on d s O .He found that for R , of 8 or less ripples always occurred, for R , between 8 and 24 either ripples or dunes could occur, and for R , in excess of 24, dunes always occurred. Yalin’s (1972) plots of d / d s o against L / d 5 0 for several limited ranges of R , fitted the linear relation L = 2nd for the highest R , in the range between 40 and 180. For smaller R , , the data deviated appreciably from the linear relation. Yalin’s criterion for predicting whether the bed form will be ripples or dunes is compatible with Vanoni’s hypothesis that these forms are determined by the shear stress and do not depend on depth. On the other hand, the result that the size of dunes depend strongly on flow depth and only weakly on sediment size conflicts with Vanoni’s hypothesis that depth is not important in dune or ripple formation. It would appear that the type of bed form, ripples or dunes, does not depend on depth, but that the size of dunes depends on both depth and sediment size. Gill (1971) developed a theoretical relation for bed wave height that was of the same form as Yalin’s. Southard (1971) showed that for a given sediment in water at a fixed temperature the bed form is determined by depth and velocity. This is compatible with the presentation used in Fig. 11. The results of several workers demonstrate that the kind of bed form developed in sands can be determined in terms of d, I/, d50, p, g, and v.
28
Vito A. Vanoni
Furthermore it appears that this will apply not only to flume flows but also to natural rivers. The work of Shinohara and Tsubaki and of Yalin in expressing dune height and length in terms of the bed shear stress or shear velocity are compatible with Vanoni’s Fig. 12 in which ripple and dune forms also are sorted according to shear velocity. However, Yalin’s finding that dune length depends on flow depth may mean that Vanoni’s hypothesis that ripple and dune formation does not depend on flow depth does not apply to dune dimensions.
C. ANALYSIS OF BEDFORM DEVELOPMENT A well-known theoretical treatment of bed forms was presented by Kennedy (1963, 1969) who introduced the concept of the lag distance. He related sediment discharge to velocity and postulated that a change in velocity would not instantaneously produce a change in sediment discharge according to the velocity-sediment discharge relation but would require a certain time or distance, the lag distance, to make the change. The analysis involved the investigation of the stability of the bed under the action of an inviscid flow perturbed by a sinusoidal disturbance. This gave the dominant wavelength of the bed wave. The result is presented as a graph of Froude number against 2nd/L and a curve indicating the envelope of possible values. This result indicated that antidunes for small 271d/L formed when F 2 0.84. The Kennedy theory also indicated that for larger 2ndlL antidunes would form at values of F < 0.84 as shown in Fig. 11 and reported by Vanoni. Kennedy’s analysis did not contain sediment size and agrees with the finding of Vanoni (1974) that antidune formation does not depend on sediment properties. Kennedy’s theory also gives the wavelength of ripples and dunes without taking into account the sediment size. This agrees with Yalin’s finding that dune length depends on flow depth and not on sediment size but disagrees with Yalin’s result that the length of ripples depends only on sediment size and Vanoni’s result in Fig. 12, which suggests that flow depth is not a factor in determining whether the bed form will be ripples or dunes. In some aspects the Kennedy theory is similar to that of Anderson (1953) which also gives wavelength in terms of the Froude number. Hayashi (1970) extended the work of Kennedy. In their analyses of bed forms, Reynolds (1965) and Gradowcyzk (1968) also used the concept of the lag distance. Reynolds also studied the effect of three-dimensional motions on bed form developrhent. Engelund (1970) formulated the problem of bed stability in terms of the vorticity transport equation which takes into account flow resistance and the distribution of suspended sediment in the flow. The effect of the grain size is accounted for by the fall velocity. The bed form and the
River Dynamics
29
wavelength were predicted in terms of the three parameters F , V / U * , and U , /w.This is a much more complicated but also a more realistic result than those obtained by previous stability analyses and resembles the kind shown in Fig. 11 in that three variables are used. Spectral analysis of bed forms has been applied to laboratory and field data (e.g., Nordin and Algert, 1966) and field data (e.g., Anambhotla et al., 1972). This is a very interesting technique which can be used in connection with some sounding equipment in general use in the field and laboratory to get significant statistical data on bed form geometry. However, at present the technique has outrun the need for such data and is awaiting the development of its applications which are sure to appear. V. Suspension of Sediment A. THEORETICAL RELATIONS
A particle of sediment in a turbulent flow is kept in suspension and diffused into the flow by the action of the turbulence fluctuations. In a uniform two-dimensional steady flow the settling of sediment under gravitationd forces at a given position in the flow is balanced by the upward turbulence diffusion of the grains. The balance of these two actions is expressed in the relation c w + c , dC- = o dY in which C is the sediment concentration at position y above the bed, w is the fall velocity of the sediment grains in the fluid, E, is the diffusion coefficient for sediment, and y is the vertical coordinate. The first term in Eq. (5.1) expresses the rate of settling under gravitational attraction, and the other term expresses the rate of upward diffusion. This equation was derived by Schmidt (1925) in connection with studies of dust in the atmosphere. It was also derived by O’Brien (1933) in studies of transportation of sediment by streams. To solve Eq. (5.1) an expression is needed for E, as a function of y. To get this it is first assumed that /jF,
(5.2) in which I:, is the eddy viscosity or diffusion coefficient for momentum transfer and p is a dimensionless constant. Use is then made of the relation E, =
5
dU , dy
= pEm - -
(5.3)
30
vim A . vanoni
the Prandtl-von Karman velocity defect law
and z=
(5.5)
which follows from the fact that the pressure is statically distributed. In Eqs. (5.3)-(54, z is the shear stress, U is the velocity at the distance y above the bed, U,,, is the velocity at the flow surface, U , = Jzo/p is the shear velocity, zo is shear stress at the bed, p is the density of the fluid, k is the von Karman constant, and d is flow depth. From Eqs. (5.2)-(5.5)the relation for E, is E, =
PkU*(l
-
$)y.
Equation (5.1) can now be integrated to give the Rouse (1937) equation for the distribution of suspended sediment: (5.7) in which
and C,, is the concentration at the level y = a. It should be pointed out that there are no satisfactory theories for calculating Ca. This problem will be discussed in Section VIII. Equation (5.7) gives zero concentration at the surface (y = d ) and infinite concentration at the bed. Both of these results are obviously unrealistic. Figure 13 shows graphs of Eq. (5.7) for several values of z for a = 0.05d. It will be seen that as z is reduced the concentration tends toward becoming uniform. Several workers have developed relations for suspended sediment since the Rouse equation was presented. Einstein and Chien (1954) proposed modifications to the diffusion theory and presented a distribution equation. Hunt (1954)presented a theory for the distribution of suspended sediment in which the diffusion coefficient E, was obtained from the von Karman (1934) velocity profile equation which is more complicated than Eq. (5.7) and yields a distribution equation that has two constants instead of only one as in Eq. (5.7). The theories of Einstein and Chien and of Hunt are discussed
River Dynamics
31
/Surface
FIG. 13. Graph of Rouse (1937) suspended load distribution equation for a/d = 0.05 and several values of z after ASCE (1963).
briefly in ASCE (1963). Ippen (1971) developed an equation in which he used the Krey (1927) equation for the velocity profile, which is
and in which a is defined by (5.10) An interesting feature of Ippen's equation was that the expression for the exponent z contains the quantity v/(U,,) instead of k. Ippen used the Rouse equation instead of his in analyzing data. Equation (5.7) is valid for small concentrations of sediment. Differential equations that attempt to account for the presence of sediment were presented by Halbronn (1949) and Hunt (1954). The Halbronn equation for two-dimensional steady uniform flow is (1 - C,)C,.w
dC + &s-L =o dY
(5.11)
32
Vito A. Vanoni
in which C, is the concentration in fraction by volume. Equation (5.11) follows from Hunt’s more general equation if the diffusion coefficients for momentum and sediment are the same. When C, is small compared to unity, Eq. (5.11) becomes identical to Eq. (5.1).
B. OBSERVED VELOCITY PROFILES IN SEDIMENT-LADEN FLOW Figure 14 shows semilogarithmic graphs of three velocity profiles observed in flumes. The center profile of the figure was measured in a clear water flow 0.554 ft deep, the left profile was measured in a flow transporting a light load of 0.16-mm sand, and the profile on the right was measured in a flow 0.390 ft deep with extremely high concentrations of suspended sediment. The profile for the clear water flow fits the semilogarithmic relation I .o
0.8 0.6
0.4
-
0.2
-
0 .I
0.08
Einstein 8 Chien (1955)-
0.06
-
Run S-16 Mox. C o n c . = 6 2 1 g/I k = 0.18 d,,= 0.274 m m
>
d= 0.390ft
z
% 0.04 a l
3 0
-
-
0.02
0.0I
-
1
I
I
2
X
I
I
3
4
Velocity
I 5
(ft/sec)
FIG.14. Velocity profiles for flows in flumes.
I 6
7
River Dynamics
33
very well and has a k value of 0.4 which is also found in clear flows in pipes. Average values of k for many clear flows are from 3 to 5 % less than 0.4. The profiles for the sediment-laden flows deviate from the semilogarithmic line near the bed with the deviations being greatest for the flow with the highest sediment concentration. The effect of suspended sediment in reducing k was reported by Vanoni (1946) and subsequently by many others. Since the diffusion coefficientsE, and E,,, are proportional to k [Eqs. (5.2) and (5.6)], the presence of sediment in suspension reduces these coefficients. The value of k is determined from plots such as those in Fig. 14. From Eq. (5.4) it will be noted that the slopes of the straight lines on Fig. 14 are given by k/(2.3U,) where the interval on the ordinate is measured in units of logarithmic cycles. Once the value of the bed shear stress zo has been determined U , and k are calculated. In flumes zo is based on measured slope and depth and a correction for the effect of friction on the side walls of the flume. The method of correction known as the side-wall correction method is referred to in Section VI1,D. Vanoni (1946) hypothesized that k and the diffusion coefficients were reduced because some of the turbulence energy was expended in suspending sediment. Einstein and Chien (1952) plotted k from some river and flume observations against the ratio P,/P, in which P , is the power to keep sediment in suspension in a column of unit area and depth equal to the stream depth and Pfis the power expended in overcoming channel friction per unit of bed area. In a subsequent paper Einstein and Chien (1955) presented Fig. 15 which contains many data from rivers and flumes and which shows a trend for k to reduce as P , / P f increases but also shows considerable scatter. Vanoni and Brooks (1957) found that for some flume data the correlation in a k-P,/P, plot could be improved by replacing P , with the power to support the sediment in a thin layer near the bed. This result tended to support the idea advanced by Buckley (1922) and Chien (1956) that the main effect of the suspended sediment in changing k occurs near the bed. Elata and Ippen (1961) studied the effect of slightly negatively buoyant spheres suspended in a water flow in a flume. They also observed a reduction in k and found that the turbulence intensity was increased in the presence of suspended particles. Similar results were obtained by Bohlen (1969) for flume flows of suspensions of spheres in silicone oil which had a small (0.37 cm/sec) fall velocity. This showed that the effect of the particles was not necessarily dependent on their fall velocity and that Vanoni's hypothesis that suspended sediment damped the turbulence was invalid. In studies of flows of suspensions of almost neutrally buoyant spheres in water in small pipes Daily and Chu (1961) and Daily and Hardison (1964) also observed that turbulence intensity in flows with suspended particles was higher than in clear flows. Daily and Hardison also found that in flows with particles the fraction of the
vito A . vanoni
34 0.3 0.2
0.1 0.08
0.06 0.04
0.02
0.01 0.008 0.006 0.004
h.l" Q
0.002
%I?
,"
Kalinske and Hsia E i n s t e i n a n d Chien
0.001 0.0008
Coarse
0.0006
Medium
A
0 0
a"la' 0.0004 0.0002
0.0001 0.00008 0.00006
I
1
1
1
1
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
0.30
0.00004
1 0.35
0.40
k
FIG.15. Effect of suspended sediment o n the von Karman universal constant after Einstein and Chien (1955).
turbulence energy at the higher frequencies increased. In studies of air flows, Peskin (1970) and Peskin and Rin (1967) reported that when glass particles were introduced into air flows the eddy diffusion coefficient diminished. There was a reduction in turbulence intensity and a redistribution of the turbulent energy by decreasing the low frequency portion and increasing the high frequency portion. The observed decrease in diffusivity when particles were added to flows was explained in terms of shifting of energy away from the components with frequencies that are most effective in diffusing particles.
River Dynamics
35
Montes and Ippen (1973) presented a graph of a few data from several sources plotted as k/[l + ( d , J g d , / ~ ) ' ' ~against ] Co the maximum concentration of suspended sediment in percent by volume which occurs near the bed. In the preceding expression, d, is the size of the suspended sand, g is the acceleration due to gravity, and v is the kinematic viscosity of water. The scatter of the few data in the graph by Montes and Ippen is much less than in Fig. 15, but because of the limited data one cannot base firm conclusions on it. Nevertheless, it suggests that the value of k depends on the sediment size and concentration and the fluid viscosity and agrees with the evidence presented earlier. It also suggests that the effect of fine particles is greater than that of coarse ones. In summary, there is agreement that turbulent flows with suspended sediment have smaller values of von Karman constant than clear flows and that the effect of suspended particles is to reduce the diffusivity E, of the fluid. Three investigations (Elata and Ippen, 1961; Daily and Chu, 1961; Daily and Hardison, 1964) with suspensions of essentially neutrally buoyant particles in water flows indicate that the turbulence intensity is higher with particles than without them. The investigation of Bohlen (1969) with particles that are denser than the fluid also show these same trends. The studies reported above of air flows with glass particles differ with those in liquids in that they show a decrease in turbulence intensity in the presence of particles. This may well be due to the extremely large ratio of particle-to-fluid density in the air studies. There is need for studies of the turbulence characteristics of the water flows carrying sand or particles with densities comparable to sands to determine the effect of sediment size and concentration. As shown by Fig. 14 the velocity profiles of flows with suspended sediment have smaller k values than those with clear flows, but they also deviate from the logarithmic relation near the bed. Einstein and Chien (1955) and Montes and Ippen (1973) presented theories which accounted for the effect of suspended sediment in causing the deviation from the logarithmic relation. Einstein and Chien applied the Prandtl mixing length theory, which gives (5.12) and 1 = ky (5.13) in which I is mixing length, k is the von Karman constant, and z and U are, respectively, the shear stress and velocity at distance y from the bed. The value of p in Eq. (5.12) included the mass of the suspended sediment. Near the bed the shear stress z was assumed equal to the value at the bed which also included the effect of suspended sediment over the flow depth. Einstein
vito A . Vanoni
36
and Chien demonstrated that their theory gave good agreement with observed velocities when the constants of integration were obtained from the data but did not carry their work to the point where the values of these constants could be predicted. They found that away from the bed where the concentration was much lower than at the bed the velocity profile followed the usual logarithmic relations with k determined from Fig. 15. In their run S-16 the deviation from the logarithmic relation started when the concentration of sand reached 358 gm/liter as noted in Fig. 14. Montes and Ippen (1973) extended the theory of Einstein and Chien. They postulated that the suspended sediment would have little effect on the velocity profile above the level where the concentration was 5 % of the maximum in the profile. They further approximated the concentration distribution by an exponential relation. Their equation for the velocity profile is
(5.14) in which k and A' are given by (5.15) log A'
=
(
1 U,d 5.5k - 1 - 0.t85) l o g ( 4 z T ) _______
(5.16)
and in which Co and C are, respectively, the maximum and average concentration of suspended sediment over the depth expressed in fraction by volume, s = ps/ p , z = w/kU,, and w is the fall velocity of the sediment. The first term at the right of Eq. (5.14) is predominant near the bed, that is for small y/d, and the second one predominates at larger y/d. Montes and Ippen found that their theory agreed reasonably well with velocity profiles observed in sediment-laden flows in flumes and that it was an improvement over a theory by Ordonez (1970).
C. EXPERIMENTAL CONFIRMATION OF CONCENTRATION DISTRIBUTION RELATIONS Figure 16 shows a logarithmic plot of concentration C against (d - y)/y for data from three flume experiments, two with very fine sand and one with medium sand. When the data on graphs such as those in Fig. 16 plot on
37
River Dynamics -
-
10 -
-
d = 0 390 f t
d5,=0274mm k = 0 18
-
003
01
10 Concentration,
FIG 16
10
C
100
I000
(grn/liter)
Profiles of suspended sediment concentration in laboratory flumes
straight lines, they fit the form of the Rouse relation [Eq. (5.7)]. The value of the exponent z in Eq. (5.7) can be found graphically from such graphs, and p can then be calculated from Eq. (5.8) using observed values of z, w, k, and U , . The two sets of data for the very fine sand follow very well the straight line relation, but the third curve which is for very high concentrations deviates appreciably from the straight line near the bed where the concentration is the highest. This deviation was also found in flume data by Montes and Ippen (1973). The values of calculated from the three z values shown in Fig. 16 are 1.4 for run 19, 1.06 for run 55, and 1.07 for run S-16. The Rouse equation was also found to fit the distribution of different size fractions of sediment suspended in the Missouri River (Vanoni, 1953) in flows approximately 10 ft deep. Figure 17is a graph of measured exponent z against w / k U , from data by Anderson (1942) and Vanoni (1946). The z values were measured from graphs like those in Fig. 16. The Anderson data were obtained from measurements in the Enoree River with flow depths of from 3 to 5 ft. The samples were separated into fractions by sieving, and the exponent z was determined for each fraction. The Vanoni experiments were made with well-sorted quartz sands. Anderson took w to be the fall velocity of a quartz sphere of a diameter equal to the mean sieve size of the sediment and assumed k = 0.4.
38
Vito A . Vanoni
Vanoni measured both w and k . Vanoni’s data for 0.147 mm sediment give p approximately equal to unity, while for the other two finer sediments B ranged from 1.2 to 1.4. The values of p from Anderson’s data were in the range 2-3. Had Anderson used observed k values in his calculations, the p values would be even larger. From Eq. (5.2) it is seen that when p exceeds unity the diffusion coefficient for sediment E , exceeds the eddy viscosity E, . The curved line in Fig. 17 represents a theoretical expression derived by Montes and Ippen (1973).
18
16 14 12 10 N c
08
acl c 0
a
06
W
04 02 0 0
02
04
06
08
10
12
14
16
18
20
22
24
26
28
W -
ku*
FIG. 17. Plot of observed exponents z against w / k U , for flows in flumes.
Plots of observed z against w for sets of suspended sediment concentrations measurements analyzed by size fractions display an interesting relation. Plots of two sets each of such data for the Enoree and Missouri Rivers are shown in Fig. 18. Four of the six sets of Enoree River data not shown on Fig. 18 plotted like Fig. 18a and two plotted like 18b. All but very few plots of over 90 sets of carefully measured Missouri River data were similar to Fig. 18c and 18d. These data show that there is a strong tendency for z to be proportional to w, which means that p is the same for all sizes of sediment present. This is in conflict with some tentative conclusions by Montes and Ippen (1973). Visual observations of flows in flumes which transport suspended sedi-
39
River Dynamics
Meosured exponent,
0.12
-
0.10
-
I
0) 0
> c
'
I
Missouri R. Runs 8 a 9
2
CI
-
Position
R3
10-18-52
Meosured exponenl,
L
FIG.18. Plots of observed exponent z against fall velocity w for several size fractions of suspended sediment at verticals of two rivers. (For Missouri River data see US. Army Corps of Engineers, 1951-53.)
ment show that the sediment is transported in clouds that billow up from the bed toward the surface. These clouds sway laterally and form intermittently. In his early suspended load experiments, Vanoni reported that these clouds tend to form in lines which continued for the entire length of the flume. These lines are reminiscent of streaks of dust or snow that one observes in a wind storm. Figure 19 is a photograph of such dust streaks blowing across a road.
40
vito A . Vanoni
FIG. 19. Dust streaks in a wind storm. Photo by U S . Department of Agriculture, Soil Conservation Service.
VI. Initiation of Sediment Motion A. INTRODUCTION The problem of initiation of motion or entrainment of sediment is of interest to engineers in the design of unlined channels that are to convey water without bed erosion. Since the objective is to eliminate erosion, one is interested in threshold or critical conditions that are on the verge of entraining sediment. These conditions are expressed in terms of mean velocity, bed shear stress, or water discharge although there is a tendency to prefer the use of shear stress since this seems to be the logical one for this purpose (ASCE, 1967). To design stable channels there is a need for the shear resistance of sediment and the distribution of shear stress over the channel beds and banks. In most alluvial streams the portion of the channel surface exclusive of the sloping banks, i.e. the bed, is covered with sands or gravels that are noncohesive. However, most stream banks contain some fine material (silt and clay) which even when present in small amounts can make the banks
River Dynamics
41
cohesive and very effective in resisting erosion. For example, according to experience of irrigation engineers (see ASCE, 1966b)the critical velocity that fine sediments will resist without entrainment are from 0.8 to 3 ft/sec for silt and from 3 to 8 ft/sec for clay, while a 2-mm particle will resist only slightly over 1 ft/sec. The discussion below will be confined to noncohesive sediments. A brief summary of the erosion resistance of cohesive sediments was prepared by a committee of the American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE, 1968). The information available on the entrainment of noncohesive sediment derives exclusively from experiments with most of it coming from laboratory investigations. Information on the nature of the entraining forces is primitive, and there is still discussion on choice of quantities to characterize these forces. The entrainment is related to the turbulent structure of the flow at the bed, the clarification of which is still under investigation.
B. ENTRAINMENT MECHANISM Observations of flows over beds of noncohesive sediment show that when the sediment motion begins it is unsteady and that it occurs intermittently in changing isolated patches. When the mean velocity and shear stress are increased, frequency of movement and its intensity are seen to increase. This suggests that the forces acting to move particles fluctuatejust as velocities in turbulent flows fluctuate. It is clear from this that one cannot measure critical values of, say, velocity or shear stress that are on the verge of moving sediment grains in terms of average values alone without also determining a probability or frequency of motion corresponding to these average values. There is no simple way to determine when motion is impending. Because of this, most critical conditions reported are for small but still finite transport rates ;this is because these conditions are often identified as obtaining when small amounts of sediment are moving. Despite these difficulties, values of critical shear stress by various observers vary surprisingly little. The reason for this is that the transport rate near the beginning of motion is extremely sensitive to shear stress. For example, Paintal(l971) and Taylor and Vanoni (1972a) found that the transport rate of sediment ranging in mean size from 0.2 to 22 mm varied, respectively, as the 17.5th and 16th powers of the shear stress. Sutherland (1967) observed initiation of motion of sand under a turbulent boundary layer of a water flow in the presence of a dyed filament of water at the bed. Violent eruptions occurred along this filament from time to time as bursts of motion of sediment were observed to occur simultaneously with these eruptions. These ejections of dye must be the same as the " lift up " of a
42
Vito A . Vanoni
similar dyed filament reported by Offen and Kline (1974). Grass (1970) visualized the problem of initiation of motion in terms of two probability distributions: (1) the distribution of shear stress at the bed; and (2) the distribution of critical shear stress for the sediment on the stream bed, which depends on the weight or size of the grains and also on their arrangement or packing in the bed. When these distributions overlap even slightly, some sediment will move intermittently and this rate of motion will increase as the amount of overlap increases. By the ingenious use of high speed motion pictures and the hydrogen bubble technique, Grass measured the probability distributions for both shear stress and the critical shear stress. Most of the older determinations identified critical shear stress by visual observation of sediment motion. Shields (1936) was the first to determine it by extrapolating a plot of measured sediment discharge against shear stress to zero transport rate. Paintal(l971) also used this procedure and reported that he was never able to arrive at a satisfactory result by this means. He suggested that a better procedure would be to report shear stress for agreed upon small values of transport rate. Vanoni (1964) assumed critical conditions for very fine sand to obtain when the frequency of motion of sediment in a square centimeter of the bed was between once per second and once in three seconds. Most workers in sedimentation agree that the critical shear stress z,for initiation of motion depends on sediment size ds, fluid properties p and p, and the submerged specific weight of the sediment y, - y. This relation can be written as 7,
=f(&
5
P, iu, Ys -
Y)
(6.1)
or in dimensionless terms as
in which U,, = Jzc/p.The term on the left of Eq. (6.2) will be called the dimensionless critical shear stress and is denoted by T,,. The term on the right of the equation with U , instead of U,, is often called the boundary Reynolds number R , . As written in Eq. (6.2), it is denoted by R*,, the critical value for initiation of sediment motion. C . EXPERIMENTAL RESULTS
The first definitive work on determination of critical shear stress was by Shields (1936) who introduced the dimensionless quantities z, and R , . His classical diagram is shown in Fig. 20 in which the data are given in terms of z, and R, according to Eq. (6.2). The value of ,z, reaches a minimum at
River Dynamics
01
0.2
04
06 08 I0
2
4
6
8 10
R,:
Y.
20
43
40
60 80 100
200
400 6008WiM)O
d.
y
FIG.20. Shields’ diagram for initiation of sediment motion.
R,, = 10 and then increases to 0.06 at R,, = 600 and does not change for higher R,, . For R,, > 600, z, is proportional to d, and is not dependent on viscosity. The curve for R,, < 1 which has a negative slope of unity was extrapolated by Shields and indicates that in this range the stability of the particles does not depend on their size. For a water temperature of 20°C the values of R,, , ,z, , and z, for quartz particles, p, = 2.65 gm/cm3, are listed below: d, (mm)
R*c z*c
z, (Ib/ftz)
I 8
1.53 0.075 0.0032
a
3.32 0.044 0.0037
I
T
8.20 0.035 0.0057
1 23.7 0.035 0.012
2 74 0.043 0.029
4 235 0.054 0.073
8
700 0.060 0.16
Since Shields published his work, many workers have collected data on critical shear stress. Some of these data disagree a few percent with the Shields ,z, and others agree closely. However, there is agreement on general form of the relation, i.e., that T , has ~ a minimum value near R,, = 10 and that for large R,, , zc, is independent of R,, . The shear stress given by Fig. 20 is the mean value of the bed shear stress that will produce little or negligible motion of particles. Since the bed shear stress fluctuates, the value of the instantaneous stress that actually produces motion is larger than the average value. White (1940) made experiments with the objective of measuring the true value of the critical stress. His values of z*, for very fine and coarse sand in laminar flows range from 0.17 to 0.27 and are larger than those given in Fig. 20. In flows with turbulent boundary layers his values of z*, for 0.9 and 5.6 mm sands were approximately 0.1.
2.000
44
Vito A. Vanoni
White’s results indicate that the shear stress that will entrain sediment in steady, i.e., laminar, flow is indeed larger than the mean stress in turbulent flows. Because of the differences in flow structure in laminar and turbulent flows, however, the values obtained by White in laminar flows are not the same as the true instantaneous critical shear stresses on grains moved in turbulent flows. Grass (1970) made simultaneous measurement of shear stress and observations of particle movement of well-sorted sands ranging in size from 0.090 to 0.195 mm. From these data he calculated the mean value and the standard deviation of the stresses obtaining when the particles moved. The surprising aspect of these results is that the mean values of the shear stress obtaining when the particles of different size moved vary little. Values of z, that produced motion ranged from 2.06 dynes/cm2 for the 0.090 mm sand to 2.26 dynes/cm2 for the 0.195 mm sand. Values of R,, based on mean values of z, ranged from 0.84 to 2.8 and are in or near the range where Shields expected z, to be independent of sediment size. Grass explained this result by observing that the coarser sediment particles tended to project higher into the flow where the velocity is higher thus reducing their critical shear stress and increasing the probability of entrainment. He was also able to calculate the standard deviation for both shear stress zo and z, . For the well-sorted sediment, the standard deviation for zo and z, were, respectively, from 0.35 to 0.42 and from 0.25 to 0.35 times the respective mean values. Frequency distribution of zo was skewed toward the large values. Taylor (1971b) and Taylor and Vanoni (1972a) measured the sediment discharge for flows in which the shear stress was near the critical value. The results are shown in Fig. 21 which is a Shields diagram on which isopleths of the dimensionless sediment discharge gs* = g,/p, U , d, are shown. The variation in R, in each pair of runs in each series was effected by changing the water temperature. The depth and mean velocity in each series except series G were kept constant. It is seen that finite sediment discharge was observed even for shear stresses less than the critical value given by the Shields curve. It is also interesting to note that the isopleths of gs* have the same shape as the Shields curve. Taylor (1971b) found by extrapolating gs* that the isopleth for gs* = lo-* came close to the Shields curve. Gessler (1965) analyzed the results of armoring studies to determine the probability of motion of grains of different size in a sediment. In these studies clear water was introduced into a flume with a bed of sediment and the flow rate was maintained at a constant value until the sediment discharge was reduced to 0.5% of its value at the beginning of the experiment. The amount and size distribution of the sediment per unit bed area transported from the flume and remaining in the surface layer of the armored bed were then determined. The probability that particles of a given
River Dynamics I
I
1 , 1 1 1 ,
I
I
I
45 I
1 , 1 1 1 1
,
1
1
1
!
1
1
+ Series D
Series B
Saicr H
I
3
6
10
x)
60
100
Boundary Reynolds Number, R
*
=-
”*
300
600 loo0
dp
u
FIG. 21. Shields’ diagram with isopleths of dimensionless sediment discharge gs* = g,/(p, U , d , ) from low-transport flat-bed experiments by Taylor and Vanoni (1972a).
Numbers near the end of the isopleths indicate values ofg,, . I n each series the data points with the higher values of R , are for warm water. The constant velocity and depth experiment pairs are indicated by the same data symbol.
size would not move under the action of the shear stress of the flow was taken as the ratio of the weight of the particles of this size in the surface layer of the armored bed to the weight in the original sedjment. Gessler took the shear stress that caused the 50% probability of motion to be equivalent to the Shields critical value. He found that for large particles, that is for R , greater than 200, z*, = 0.047 instead of 0.06 given by the Shields curve. His values of z*, for other values of R,, also fell below those of the Shields curve. Sutherland and Irvine (1973) analyzed their data on armoring experiments in terms of a probabilistic model. They found that for sediments with og < 1.4 the initiation of motion could be expressed in terms of R , , og, and a representative size. For sediments with C J ~> 1.4, z, for a particular grain size in a sediment depended on its size as well as on the representative size of the sediment as a whole. The investigation of initiation of motion of sediment particles on the bed of turbulent flows has clearly shown that the entrainment forces are unsteady even in so-called steady flows. For this reason, data on critical shear stress such as those in Fig. 20 give only estimates. Furthermore, because of the way these measurements were made, the values of z, tend to be higher than the true values. In order to be quantitative, z, values should be associated with a transport rate as suggested by Taylor, Paintal, and others or by a probability of movement as was done by Gessler, Grass, and Sutherland and Irvine. The values reported are mostly for flat beds and sorted or wellsorted sediment. The effect of the size distribution needs to be studied
Vito A. Vanoni
46
further. The initiation of motion in dune or ripple beds is not of great practical interest, so there is little incentive to study it further. The few observations available (e.g.,Menard, 1950)show that the critical shear stress for dune beds is less than for flat beds.
VII. Mean Velocity
A. GENERAL VELOCITYRELATIONS The mean velocity V of a stream is defined as V = Q / A in which Q is the discharge in volume per unit time and A is the area of the stream cross section. The common relations for mean velocity are variations of the Chezy relation V = C,Jz (74 in which C, is the Chezy coefficient which depends on fluid properties and the geometry of the bed. The Chezy coefficient is usually expressed in terms TABLE 3 FRICTION FACTORS OF THREE RIVERS
Friction factors Mean depth (ft)
Mean velocity (ft/sec)
0.97 1.6
2.08 2.56 4.27
2.9 2.5 3.6
2.89 4.06 6.57
15.3 19.8 28.9 34.2
2.01 2.68 3.74 4.96
Bed sediment size 4 , (mm)
Manning
DarcyWeisbach
n
f
Bed form
1. Niobrara River, Colby and Hembree (1955) 1.1
0.3 0.3 0.3
0.026 0.022 0.017
0.080 0.054 0.029
-
-
2. R i o Grande, Nordin (1964) 0.3 0.3 0.3
0.030 0.020 0.016
0.074 0.034 0.018
Dunes Transition Antidunes
3. Mississippi River at St. Louis, Jordan (1965) 0.25 0.25 0.25 0.25
0.039 0.035 0.031 0.025
0.071 0.053 0.037 0.024
-
47
River Dynamics
of other friction factors. In terms of the Darcy-Weisbach friction factor f used in pipe flows, C1 = Jsg/f,and Eq. (3.2) results. When the Manning friction factor n, preferred by most river engineers is used, C, = ( 1 . 4 9 / n ) ~ " ~ and
Equation (7.2) is valid only for foot-second units. When units of meters and seconds are used, the constant 1.49 is replaced by unity. Table 3 lists values of friction factors f and n for three rivers with flow depth ranging from 1 to 34 ft. It will be seen that in a particular stream the friction factor tends to diminish as velocity increases. Results for the Rio Grande show that as the velocity increased and the bed form went from dunes to antidunes, the friction factors diminished dramatically. Information on bed forms for the other three rivers is not available. The bed form of the Mississippi River has been observed to change greatly with stage or discharge. Figure 22 shows bed profiles for two stages of the river near Donaldsonville, about 75 miles upstream of New Orleans, reported by Study Reoch , ,57-
-
7
60 o)
100
-
140 1607
o
2
I
Soiling-Llne (Tholweg)
I
(a)
I
60 100
_ _ _ I _
160
140
I59
158
157
156 3
Station in Miles
3
(b)
v)
April 10,1956 Soiling Line Profile
L
0)
157.7
c
s
6 0 - 7
,
157.1
,
-b 0
m c
0) a
60
---100
'
I
--T--r----71
1
' -
-60
(d)
- ..
100 A
FIG.22. Bed profiles of Mississippi River near Donaldsonville 100 miles upstream of New Orleans after Carey and Keller (1957). (a) Plan view; (b) small-scale profile on April 10,1956; (c) profile of bed in study reach on April 10, 1956; (d) profile of bed in study reach on July 10, 1956.
48
Vito A. vanoni
Carey and Keller (1957). For higher stage of 18.3 ft, large bed waves are present, the largest shown being about 30 ft high and 400 ft long. At the 5.8-ft stage the waves are much smaller but have a higher steepness (ratio of height to length). The bed at the lower stage is believed to have the higher friction factor. Studies by Eden (1938)of the 50-mile reach of the Mississippi River between Fulton and Memphis about 600 miles upstream from Donaldsonville showed that the Manning y1 tended to decrease as stage increased, reaching a minimum of about 0.03 at bank full stage.
B. OBSERVED VELOCITY RELATIONS
A common practice in river engineering is to develop a relation between the water surface elevation or stage and discharge and to use this relation for determinations of discharge. Stage is actually the water surface elevation referred to a datum set approximately at the river bottom. The stage or gage reading gives only an approximate depth because the bottom elevation fluctuates as erosion and deposition occur. Flucuations and actual changes in stage-discharge relations for river stations are observed by hydrographers. Some streams show continuous relations, while some others show discontinuous relations. Figure 23 is a plot by Nordin (1964) of hydraulic radius r against mean velocity V for the Rio Grande which shows a discontinuous stage discharge relation. It will be observed that for the low velocity branch of the relation the bed form is dunes and for the high velocity branch the bed form is either flat or antidunes. Colby (1960) was the first to correlate bed form with the two branches of a discontinuous stage discharge curve (see Fig. 26). It is interesting that the explanation of the discontinuity in the curve was suggested to Colby by the results of Brooks (1958) of the kind in Fig. 6 which shows multiple values of velocity for flows of a given depth and slope. The resistance to flow of beds with forms such as ripples and dunes is composed of skin friction and pressure drag or form drag. The form drag occurs because the pressure on the upstream faces is greater than on the downstream faces. Figure 24 shows the pressure distribution over a naturally formed ripple in a flume 1% in. wide (Hwang, 1965; see also Vanoni and Hwang, 1967). The pressure is expressed as (P - P,)/(1/2pV2) in which P is the pressure at a point on the ripple, P , is a reference pressure, p is fluid density, and I/ is the mean velocity in the cross section. The fact that measurements for three velocities formed essentially one curve was taken as evidence that the pressure and hence form drag were independent of Reynolds number. Figure 24 shows that the pressure at the crest and in the lee of
River Dynamics
49
IC
+ c
Y
u)
.-3
-0 0
a
-a 0
I-
F
U
k
I
I .o
0.5 1.0
10 Velocity ( f t / s e c )
FIG. 23. Plot of velocity against hydraulic radius for Rio Grande near Bernalillo, New Mexico after Nordin (1964).
the ripple is relatively smaller than the stagnation pressure which occurs at the upstream face where the dividing stream line between the lee eddy and the main flow attaches to the ripple. This pressure distribution will result in a fluid force acting downstream on the ripple or an equal and opposite resisting force on the flow.
vito A. vunoni
50 12
-
1.0 -
-
8
8
0.2 -
+
e
e
03
/
Mean Bed Elevation I
0
I
01
I
02
I
I
1
I
03
04
05
0.6
I
I
1
07
08
09
Distance ( i t )
FIG.24. Pressure distribution over a typical ripple, after Vanoni and Hwdng (1967).
C . DEPTH-VELOCITY AND DEPTH-DISCHARGE RELATIONS According to Eq. (3.4b), if the depth and fluid and sediment properties are kept constant in an alluvial flow, the slope becomes a function of velocity. Figure 25 is a plot of slope against velocity for data reported by Guy et ul. (1966) for two sets of runs in a flume 2 ft wide with constant depth. The two sets of runs were made with sediments having the same median size but different standard deviations of sizes og. The data delineate a function for each sediment. The difference in the two curves is due to the difference in og for the sediments. The curve for the sorted sediment, og = 1.25, gives multiple values of S in the vicinity of S = 0.003, which is in the flat bed and transition range. The graded sediment shows a much more regular transition. For ripple, dune, and antidune bed forms the slope and hence the friction factors of the flows with the sorted sediment are larger than those with the graded sediment. The reason for this is not known, but it is believed to be due to differences in bed form. In flows with ripples or dunes one would expect the bed with the higher slope to have the higher or steeper bed forms but this was not borne out by the data. At a station on a stream, water density, stream slope, and sediment properties are constant and if we neglect the effect of changes in water temperature, Eq. (3.4b) indicates that velocity is a function of depth alone. The plot of velocity against hydraulic radius for the Rio Grande shown in
River Dynamics
51
MEAN VELOCITY V (ft/sec)
FIG.25. Plot of slope against velocity for two sets of flows with constant depth and bed sediments with different size grading (data from Guy rt ul., 1966).
Fig. 23 could be converted to depth against velocity and can be taken as evidence that Eq. (3.4b) applies to natural rivers. The discharge Q = A V ; and since the area of cross section depends on depth, Q is also a function of depth. This function is the stage discharge relation or the rating curve. Such a relation by Colby (1960) for the Pigeon Roost Creek is shown in Fig. 26 which indicates a discontinuous relation. The median size of the bed sediment in this stream is 0.4 mm. No data are plotted in the transition zone between the two lines of Fig. 26, although at least one set of observations by Colby showed that on a receding flow the transition occurred close to the gage height of 4 ft. The observers were able to wade the stream at low gage height and to determine that the bed form was dunes. At the higher gage heights corresponding to the high discharge segment of the curve, no direct observations of the bed were possible, but the appearance of surface waves indicated that antidunes had formed. The Manning friction factor for the flows over dune beds was approximately 0.03, and for the flows over antidune beds it was approximately 0.015. Some rivers exhibit lower stages for a given discharge on a rising flood than on a falling flood so that the rating curve has a loop in it. Figure 27 presented by Carey and Keller (1957) shows such a loop rating curve for the Mississippi River at Tarbert Landing about 100 miles upstream of New Orleans for the flood of 1950. The bed sediment in this vicinity has a median size of 0.3 mm. This figure shows that for a given discharge the stage in
52
Vito A . Vanoni
20
10
40 60 80 100
200
400 600
1,000
2,000
4,000
10,000
Dischorge (ft3/seC)
FIG.26. Stage-discharge relation for station 34 on Pigeon Roost Creek, Mississippi after Colby (1960).
55 50
t A’ k’l
30 .
/
/
\January
10
I ’
25
FIG.27. Stage-discharge relation for the Mississippi River at Tarbert Landing during the flood of 1950, after Carey and Keller (1957).
River Dynamics
53
January was as much as 8 ft lower than in March. Loops in rating curves are explained in terms of the unsteadiness of the flow and the change in bed form (Henderson, 1966). During a rising flood the slope of the energy gradient is higher than during a falling flood causing the velocity also to be higher on the rising stages. But higher velocity changes the bed form in such a way that the friction factor diminishes, e.g., see Table 3, further reducing the depth and stage. During the falling stage these tendencies are reversed. Other factors that may play a part in the phenomenon of the loop rating curve are the water temperature and the rate at which sediment enters a given reach of stream. Temperature effects are discussed in Section IX. Colby indicated that streams that exhibit discontinuous stage discharge relations are a rarity, and he did not expect many streams in the United States to have this feature. In his view, only streams that have reasonably uniform depths over their widths, have dune covered beds at some flows and bed sediments that can be moved by the flow are expected to show such discontinuity. Most streams are sinuous and therefore have asymmetric cross sections, and their bed forms vary continuously in the longitudinal direction. In such streams bed form will change with stage and other factors; but these changes will not be the same over the length of the stream, so that the change in friction factor and the stage discharge relation is expected to be continuous.
D. PREDICTION OF VELOCITY According to Eq. (3.4b), one can write
in which F = I//& is the Froude number. The function in Eq. (7.3) could be determined from the data in Fig. 25 for the special case of flows with a given constant depth. Introducing the definition of the friction factor f [Eq. (3.2)] into Eq. (7.3) gives
in which d has replaced r in Eq. (3.2). The problem of predicting velocity is now one of predicting f i n terms of the five independent variables on the right of Eq. (7.4). This equation is simplified by omitting ps/ p since in natural streams it varies very little and neglecting ogsince little or no information on its effect is available. This reduces the function in Eq. (7.4) to one with three variables, which is still very complex.
54
vim A. vanoni
Several well-known relations for predicting velocity have yielded solutions to the three-variable equation for f by separating f into two additive parts, a partf’ due to skin friction resistance of the bed and a partf” due to form drag of the bed forms or f =f ’
+f”.
(7.5)
The factorsf’ andf” are considered to apply to two different streams which have the same mean velocity I/. In one procedure or theory the two streams have the same hydraulic radius but different slopes, and in the other they have the same slope but different hydraulic radii. The stream on whichf’ applies has a rigid flat bed covered with sediment of size d, and has either a slope S’ or a hydraulic radius r’. The friction factor f ’ for this stream is assumed to depend on the Reynolds number and relative roughness r/d, or r‘/ds.The one to which f “ applies has either a slope S“ or a hydraulic radius r“ and its roughness is assumed to be independent of Reynolds number. These concepts were first applied to alluvial channels by H. A. Einstein (Meyer-Peter and Muller, 1948). The following relations apply to the theory that divides the slope into two parts: S=S‘+S”
(7.6a) (7.6b) (7.6~)
The theory that divides the hydraulic radius results in the following relations: r
=
r’
+ rtt
(7.7a) (7.7b) (7.7c)
The quantities f ‘ and r‘ are often referred to as the bed friction factor and bed hydraulic radius, respectively, due to sand grain roughness. The termsf” and r” are referred to as due to bed form resistance. From the expressions zo = yrS, zb = yrs’, and z; = yrS” and Eq. (7.6a) it is seen that To = zb
+ zg
(7-8)
River Dynamics
55
in which zo is total bed shear stress, zb is sand grain shear stress, and z: is the form drag or bed form shear stress. The values off’ are assumed to be the same or equivalent to friction factors f for pipes or other rigid channels which are functions of a Reynolds number and a relative roughness. The form drag friction f a c t o r y then will depend only on the geometry of the bed forms and will depend on Reynolds number or water viscosity only to the extent that these quantities affect the bed form. The three hydraulic radii and three friction factors in Eqs. (7.6) and (7.7) are written with the subscript b in some works. All of these quantities apply only to the bed. They are determined by a calculation that eliminates the effect of friction on the walls or banks of the channel. This is done by an empirical method presented by Johnson (1942; see ASCE, 1971a) which is known as the side-wall correction method and which is not presented here. Vanoni and Hwang (1967) determined experimentally the value of the friction factorf; for a ripple bed as a function of geometric parameters of the bed. The relation which fitted their data which are plotted in Fig. 28 is
in which rb is the hydraulic radius of the bed corrected for effects of side-wall friction, H is the mean height of the ripples, and e is a ripple concentration parameter. This parameter was measured as the ratio of the horizontal projections of the lee slopes of the ripples to the total bed area occupied by
0 OP=0.137m m 6 0 - F O O T FLUME
20
30
40
MODIFIED
50 RELATIVE
60
70
80 90 100
ROUGHNESS,
rblen
FIG.28. Form drag friction factor for ripple bed after Vanoni and Hwang (1967).
I50
56
Vim A . Vanoni
the ripples. The data plotted in Fig. 28 and the pressure profile over a ripple shown in Fig. 24 support the assumption that the bed form resistance depends only on geometric parameters. Several ways have been developed for determiningf”. Three of these will be discussed in the next section. E. SELECTED VELOCITY RELATIONS
The three relations presented below were selected because they illustrate the approaches to the solution of this complicated problem. Several other relations are discussed in detail in ASCE (1971a). The method developed by Einstein and Barbarossa (1952) divided the hydraulic radius r into two parts r’ and r”. The friction factorf’ = 8(U‘*/V)* for the sand grain roughness was determined from V
7= 5.75
u*
I)
log 12 2x -
.
(7.10)
in which Ui = @is the friction velocity based on sand grain shear stress and k, is the roughness length taken as d 6 , , the grain size of the bed sediment for which 65 % by weight is smaller. The term x is given as a function of the boundary Reynolds number R* = U; d 6 5 /v and represents the function for transition from hydrodynamically smooth to hydrodynamically rough surfaces and has the value unity for rough boundaries. When x = 1, Eq. (7.10) becomes the same as the Keulegan (1938) equation for rough channels upon which it is based. The friction factorf” is determined from the curve on Fig. 29 which is derived from a plot of river data in the form (7.11) in which Ua = &% and d,, is the grain size for which 35% by weight of the bed sediment is smaller. It will be noted that yr’S = 26, the bed shear stress due to the grain roughness and hence that $’ is the reciprocal of 7; the dimensionless shear stress [Eq. (6.2)] based on zb . These authors argued that the bed load transport rate and hence the bed form depended on +’ and hence that f”would also depend on $’. The sediment size d 3 5 was selected because previous work by Einstein indicated it to be a suitable representative size for determining transport rate. The arguments that lead to the selection of $‘ are similar to those that lead to Fig. 12 in which U, was selected to characterize the forces which generate ripples and dunes and in which depth was neglected. In Fig. 12 the viscosity appears in the grain number R,. In the formulation of Fig. 29 there is a viscosity effect in r‘, but it
River Dynamics
57
Missouri River Near Ornaha,Nebr.
A Elkhorn River Near Waterloo,Neb
+
Big Sioux River Near Akron, Iowa iobroro River Near Butte, Nebr.
0.4 0.50.60.8
!.O
2
3
4
5 6 709!0
20
30
40 50
FIG.29. The Einstein-Barbarossa (1952) form resistance relation.
cannot account for the rather large effects of water temperature on bed form and friction factor observed in sand bed rivers. It will be noted from Fig. 29 that V / U ; decreases as $’ increases; or in other words the friction factor!” increases as zb and hence bed load discharge decrease as is observed in streams. The Einstein-Barbarossa theory does not agree with resistance observed in laboratory channels. This is not surprising since the function in Fig. 29 was derived from river data. Lovera and Kennedy (1969) and Alam and Kennedy (1969) also divided the friction factor and slope into two parts in developing their velocity relation. They determined the friction factor due to skin friction (which they called sf) from data observed in rivers with flat beds, which they presented graphically in the form (7.12)
in which r,, is the bed hydraulic radius obtained by the side-wall correction procedure (Johnson, 1942).A puzzling feature of the graph is that for a given r b / d s 0 , the friction factor& increases as the Reynolds number increases and shows no tendency to transit to asymptotic values as do the friction factors
58
Vito A . Vanoni
for rough pipes. The friction factor for the bed form roughness was presented graphically by Alam and Kennedy (1969) in the form (7.13) The function of Eq. (7.13) was established from data from rivers and flumes. It showed that f : became independent of r b / d S Ofor sufficiently large values of this ratio in which range the Einstein-Barbarossa graph Fig. 29 also applies. In order that Eq. (7.13) predict bed form friction factor the two dimensionless parameters in the function must characterize the bed form. The fact that viscosity does not appear in these terms is in disagreement with the formulation of bed form charts Figs. 1 1 and 12. The success of Fig. 12 in and R , suggests delineating ripples and dune beds in terms of U,/&dyi that f : could also be expressed as a function of these quantities. A practical objection to this is that U , changes much less than I/ and is much more difficult to measure. Engleund (1966, 1967)developed a theory for predicting velocity based on a similarity hypothesis. He hypothesized that similar streams with dune beds will have the same values of ( 1 ) t; and ( 2 ) f ” l f : From these relations it follows that f‘fland z* are also the same in similar flows and therefore that T* is a function of t i . Figure 30 shows the relation between r; and r* developed by Engelund from flume data by Guy et al. (1966).It will be observed that for small t*, t i approaches 0.06, the Shields critical value (Fig. 20) for large R , . Also for flat beds which have negligible form resistance z; = r * , Engelund calculated the mean velocity V in terms of a depth rl’ as (7.14) in which rl‘ is analogous to r’, the bed hydraulic radius due to sand grain roughness. From selected values of d’ and known values of S and d,, ,values of V are calculated from Eq. (7.14) and r; is calculated using tl,, for the sediment size. Then Fig. 30 gives z* from which ro and the depth d are calculated. Figure 31 is a plot of observed depth t l and mean velocity V for the Colorado River at Taylor’s Ferry ( U S . Bureau of Reclamation, 1958) along with curves calculated by the three theories presented. The data plotted in Fig. 3 1 were collected over a three-year period. The ranges in observed slope, water temperature, and median size of bed sediment during this period are listed in Table 4. It will be seen that the observed values plotted on Fig. 31
59
River Dynamics
T . '
FIG.30. Engelund's (1967) relation between
T*
and
7;
used in calculating mean velocity.
I
311.LL--
2I
2
3
4
5
6
I 7
8 9 1 0
Meon Velocity ( f t l s e c )
FIG.31. Plot of depth-velocity data for the Colorado River at Taylor's Ferry compared with three calculated relations.
60
vito A. vunoni
tend to scatter and do not define a single curve. Some of this scatter is certainly due to measurement errors, but most of it must be due to actual variation in the factors determining velocity and depth such as slope, water temperature, and bed sediment size. The agreement between theory and observation is less than satisfactory and is an indication of the current status of the theories. It is believed that a serious omission in all three of the relations is a term to account for the effect of water temperature on bed form. That bed form is temperature dependent has been demonstrated by both the field and laboratory observations presented in Section IX. In the bed form charts in Figs. 11 and 12 the temperature effect is expressed by the grain number R, . This number could also be used in velocity relations. The addition of another variable would improve the relations but would also complicate them greatly. TABLE 4 DATAOBSERVED
Slope
Temperature ( O F ) Median size of bed sediment (mm)
ON COLORADO
RIVERAT TAYLOR'S FERRY
Maximum
Minimum
Average
Used in calculations
0.000333
0.000147
0.000218
0.000217
80
48
64
60
0.400
0.270
0.332
0.320
VIII. Sediment Discharge A. GENERAL RELATIONS Despite the many formulas for sediment discharge that exist and continue to appear in the literature none of them has proven to be adequate for most practical purposes. All of them have to depend strongly on data for determining the relations and only a few depend to any extent on analysis and are, in fact, theoretical. There are several reasons for this. Among these is that few complete stream measurements of sediment discharge are available, and workers in this area are therefore dependent on flume data for guidance. Actually there are complete sets of measurements on only two small rivers (Colby and Hembree, 1955; Hubbell and Matejka, 1959) with depths of 3 ft or less. All other measurements are only estimates based on partial measurements of sediment discharge as will be discussed below.
River Dynamics
61
For flows with constant depth and water temperature and a given sediment, Eq. (3.4a) can be written 9s = f ( V ) . (8.1) A plot of flume data by Brooks from a series of runs with a depth of 0.241 ft is shown in Fig. 32. The velocity-slope data for these experiments are plotted on Fig. 6. The curve in Fig. 32 appears to be continuous in the transition range where the bed form changes from ripples to flat. It is also of interest to note that the flat bed portion of the curve is steeper than the ripple bed portion. For the river case we assume that slope, water temperature, and sediment properties remain fixed so that from Eqs. (3.4) we get
?-
12
10
8 I
C ._
E
\
0
6
a.
P u
A=
: 4 c
c
E
.-
U
m 2
0 0.5
1.0
1.5
2.0
2.5
3.0
Mean Velocity (ft/sec)
FIG.32. Relation between sediment discharge and mean velocity for flow 0.241 ft deep in a bed of fine sand after Brooks (1958). (Flume width = 10.5 in., median bed sediment size = 0.152 mm. For plot of velocity-slope relation, see Fig. 6.)
62
Vito A . Vanoni
A plot of the bed sediment discharge G, against velocity V for the Rio Grande reported by Nordin (1964) is shown in Fig. 33. Although the data scatter considerably, they do show a definite trend and tend to justify Eq. (8.2) and the application of Eqs. (3.3) to rivers. Some of the scatter of data can be attributed to variation in temperature, slope, and bed sediment size and size distribution. The variations in these quantities which were I 05,
I
I
I
transition d antidunes flat
6
I
6 5
I I
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
10
M e a n Velocity ( f t l s e c )
FIG.33. Plot of mean velocity against bed sediment discharge at section F of Rio Grande near Bernalillo, New Mexico (data from Nordin, 1964).
River Dynamics
63
observed in four years of a 10-year period are listed in Table 5. Some of the scatter in Fig. 33 is no doubt also due to the error in sediment discharge which was determined by adding an estimate of the unmeasured portion of the sediment discharge to the measured portion according to the modified Einstein method described in Section VII1,C. TABLE 5 DATAOBSERVED AT SECTION F ON Rro GRAKDE NEARBERNALILLO
Slope Temperature (“F) Median size of bed sediment (mm) Geometric standard deviation of bcd sediment up
Minimum
Maximum
Average
0.00074 58
0.00089 80
0.0008 1 68
0.19 1.49
0.45 3.34
0.29 1.76
B. THEORETICAL CONCEPTS As already indicated theoretical treatments of the sediment transportation problem have not been completely successful. However, some of the concepts developed are interesting and probably will be useful as steppingstones for further developments. A selected few of these will be discussed in this section. The earliest well-known analysis was presented by the French engineer DuBoys (1879) who introduced the idea of the shear stress and presented the transport relation that bears his name. His work had an important influence on development of transport relations for several generations. He visualized that the sediment grains would move in layers of thickness d’ under the action of the shear stress zo . He also assumed that the velocity of the grains diminished linearly with distance below the bed surface as indicated in Fig. 34. If there are n - 1 layers of grains in motion the sediment discharge gs per unit width is gs = n d i ( n - 1) AUW
in which W is the mass of sediment per unit volume of the deposit in the bed and n, d’, and Au are defined in Fig. 34. Assuming that the friction between layers is proportional to the submerged weight of the overlying grains gives the following expression for nd’, the depth at which the frictional resistance
64
-
Vito A . Vanoni /Bed
Surface
FIG.34. Layers of moving bed sediment as conceived by DuBoys (1879).
of the sediment is just equal to the applied shear stress and no motion will occur :
in which cf is the coefficient of friction between the grain layers. When n = 1, the surface layer is about to move and zo has the critical value z,. Substituting this relation into Eq. (8.4) gives the relation zo = nzc which can be used to eliminate n from Eq. (8.3) to give the DuBoys equation 9s =
$dzO(zO
- zc)
(8.5)
in which $ d = 1/2d'Wp, AUz? and is assumed to depend only on sediment properties. Values of t,hd and z, for sands determined from flume experiments by Straub are given in Brown (1950) and also in ASCE (1971b). The values of z,were determined for best fit to the data of the DuBoys equation and are larger than those observed by Shields and others presented in Section VI. The DuBoys equation will give no transport when zo = 7 , . In view of the method used to determine z, it is clear that there will be some transport when the equation indicates that there is none. This equation and others like it in which the sediment discharge is given in terms of bed shear stress are sometimes called bed load relations. In principle they should only predict bed load discharge; however, some engineers apply them to flows with suspended sediment with apparently satisfactory results. A possible reason for this is that the quantity $ d in Eq. (8.5) may have been determined from data in flows which had suspended load as well as bed load. Einstein (1942) developed a bed load formula based on probability concepts. He assumed that grains moved in steps of length L , proportional to d, in which Lo is the constant of proportionality. The grain size d, or L , = ,lo number of grains per second passing through a unit width of a cross section is then taken as the product of the number of grains in the surface layer of a
River Dynamics
65
bed area of unit width and length L , and the probability p s that a grain will be moved in any second. The sediment discharge per unit width is given by
in which c2 d,2 is the bed area occupied by a grain, c, d,3 is the volume of a grain and other symbols are as defined previously. The probability ps has the dimensions of (sec)- and it is made dimensionless by multiplying by the characteristic time d,/w in which w is the fall velocity of the grains. This gave a new probability p = p , d, /w which is the number of steps per second taken by a grain. This probability p was then assumed to be a function of the ratio of the submerged weight of a grain to the shear force on the grain. Introducing these relations into Eq. (8.6) gives the Einstein equation
4 =f(+) in which
and
in which w has been replaced by the Rubey (1933) equation for fall velocity
and F , is a dimensionless factor depending on sediment and fluid properties. The quantity is recognized as the reciprocal of z*,the dimensionless shear stress introduced by Shields. Einstein determined the functionf ( ~from ) flume data for sorted sediment ranging in mediam size from 0.3 to 28.6 mm which also included coal (specific gravity 1.25) and barite (specific gravity 4.2). His plot of ~s against log 4 gave a straight line for $ in excess of 5 with the equation
+
0.4654
= e-0.3919,
(8.8)
This equation gives small 4 and hence small gs for large values of I)which correspond to small shear stress zo. In this respect the Einstein equation gives more realistic results than the DuBoys equation which gives no transport at low shear stress. At high 4 and low I)the theoretical transport rate
Vito A . Vanoni
66
was less than that observed in laboratory flows. To correct for this Einstein modified his theory by increasing the step length L, at high transport rates. His relation did not fit data for graded sediment. Einstein (1950) presented his well-known bed load function in which he accounted separately for bed load and suspended load. He first separated the bed sediment into size fractions and determined the mean size dsi of each fraction and the weight fraction pi that it is of the bed sediment. The sediment discharge gsi for the ith fraction was taken as pi times the transport rate given by a relation for transportation of sorted bed sediments of mean size d s i .The suspended sediment discharge gssiper unit width of the fraction with mean size dsi is
in which Ci is the concentration of suspended sediment of size dsiat distance y above the bed and U is the velocity at distance y above the bed. The concentration Ci was given by the Rouse relation Eq. (5.7)] in which z = w/0.4U; instead of as in Eq. (5.8) and U ; = gr’S. The velocity U was given by U / U i = 8.5 5.75 log xy/ks in which the roughness length k, = db5 and x is the transition function as in Eq. (7.10). In applying Eq. (8.9) use was made of the Einstein-Barbarossa relation Eq. (7.10) and Fig. 29 to get the relations between mean velocity, depth, and U, . The bed load discharge gsbiof bed sediment of mean size dsi was assumed to be
?
+
gsbi
= 1 1.6C,i2dsj
u;
(8.10)
in which Cai is the sediment concentration at level y = 2 4 and is also the concentration C, in Eq. (5.7). The bed load discharge gsbiwas determined as a function of I,// [see Eq. (7.1l)]and three dimensionless quantities which are functions of dsi and U * d , , / v . In deriving the expression for gsbi Einstein made use of the probability concept used in developing Eq. (8.7) and the resulting relation showed that gsbidiminished greatly but did not vanish for large values of,‘)I i.e. small zb . The total sediment discharge gs is then taken as the sum of the bed load and suspended load discharges for all of the size fractions. This gives not only the sediment discharge but also the grain size distribution of the load. Einstein’s value of z was based on a value of 0.4 for the von Karman constant k and on U ; instead of U , as in Eq. (5.8). The shear velocity V; is less than U , and in sediment-laden flows k is less than 0.4 so that Einstein’s value for z is not appropriate. In a later publication, Einstein and Abdel-aal (1972) modified the theory by using a reduced value of k in Eq. (7.10) and in
River Dynamics
67
the expression for z. The values of k recommended were expressed in graphical form as a function of w 3 5&( VdSv)- in which w35is the fall velocity of the sediment size; d,, and the other symbols are as defined previously. Kalinske (1942,1947) analyzed the problem of bed load transport in terms of the local bed shear stress and velocity including temporal fluctuations in these quantities. He first assumed that the velocity U , of a grain moving on the bed was
U,
= m(Uo -
U,>
(8.11)
in which m is a constant, U o is the instantaneous fluid velocity near the bed, and U , is the critical value of U o for starting grain motion. The instantaneous velocity is expressed as U o = O0 Ub in which ifo is mean value of U o and Uois the fluctuating part of U o . Letting P/[(n/4)d,3] be the number of grains per unit bed area, the sediment discharge per unit width gs is given by (8.12)
+
in which U g is the mean velocity of the grains. When Ub is assumed to be normally distributed, the mean grain velocity is given by
-
in which - t, = ( U , - ifo)/(q)1/2 and t = U o / ( ~ ) 1 ’By 2 .assuming that zo U i we have U,/O0 = ( ~ , / z ~ ) by ~ / ~means of which Eq. ( 8 3 ) can be expressed in terms of z,/zo and the relative turbulence intensity (Ut)1’2/Uo. Equation (8.13) shows that U g continues to persist even when ifo < U , or zo < z, , In this regard it resembles the Einstein relation and is compatible with observations in flows. The Kalinske relation was not developed to the point that it could be applied to rivers. Engelund (1966,1967) and Engelund and Hansen (1967) based their transport relation on energy concepts and on their velocity relation presented in Section VI1,E. The rate of increase of potential energy of sediment as it moves up the face of a dune of height H and length L is equated to the rate of work of the shear force in moving sediment over the length L. This gives (8.14)
in which q, is the sediment discharge in volume per unit time and width, c1 is a dimensionless constant, z, is the critical shear stress for initiation of motion and the shear velocity U , is assumed to represent the velocity scale for the sediment. The term zb - z, implies that the shear stress T, is dis-
68
vito A. vanoni
sipated and only the remainder 7; - z, is available to move sediment. Introducing the definition for T* and 2; into Eq. (8.14) and letting z,/(ys - y)d, = 0.06, the Shields value of z*, for large R , , results in the relation
The Engelund curve for dune beds in Fig. 30 can be represented by 0.42: = - 0.06. Also from studies on the expansion loss at a dune crest Engelund (1966) found that j Z / H was constant. Introducing the latter two relations into the above equation gives Engelund's sediment discharge relation
z;
f i e = 0.12y
(8.15)
in which 4e = qs/,/(p, / p - 1)gd:. The constant 0.1 was determined from data by Guy et al. (1966) for flows with dune beds. Bagnold (1966, 1973) considers the bed load to be sediment that is moved by the shear forces but which does not receive upward impulses from turbulence. He visualized that grains received upward impulses by rolling upward over other grains and through elastic collisions with the bed or with other moving particles. Once a particle is launched and hence is saltating it receives forward impulses from the mean flow. The tangential force F per unit bed area resulting from saltating grains colliding with the bed is F = rnUL/T in which m is the mass of the grains colliding with the bed per unit area of bed, Ub is the change in grain velocity due to its collision with the bed, and T is the duration of the collisions. The ratio of the force F to the submerged weight W' of the bed load per unit bed area can be written (8.16) Bagnold considers the ratio F / W as analogous to a coefficient of friction tan CI which he found experimentally to have the value 0.63. Solving Eq. (8.16) for F and multiplying through by ifg the mean velocity of the grains in transit gives (8.17)
in which Fi7, is the rate at which moving grains do work on the bed and W' U g/g( 1 - ps/ p ) = gsb, the transport rate of grains in mass per unit width of bed. In imparting the force F to the bed, grains lose forward momentum which must be supplied continually to saltating grains by the flowing fluid. This momentum is imparted because the mean velocity U gof the grains is less
River Dynamics
69
than the fluid velocity U , around the saltating grains. Based on some experimental evidence and physical reasoning Bagnold concluded that the mean slip velocity of the grains Ub - Dg was approximately equal to w the fall velocity of the sediment grain settling in still fluid. Based on these concepts the rate at which work is done on the grains isf(Ub - w ) in whichfis the mean force acting on the grain. Equating the work done by the grains colliding with the bed to the work done by the mean flow on the grains and introducing tan CI gives
F D g = WDgtan a = f ( u h
- w).
(8.18)
The relationf= az,, is then introduced in which a is the fraction of the shear stress zo due to particle collisions with the bed. Substituting the reIation forf into Eq. (8.18) and rearranging gives
was that existing at y = nd, in which Bagnold assumes that the velocity u,, d, is the sediment size and n is a numerical factor and determined U b from the logarithmic law as
u, = B + 5.75u*
log0.37d
(8.20)
in which D is the mean velocity in the profile and d is flow depth. The factor n was determined from the empirical relation 0.6
n
=
1.4(2)
(8.21)
in which U,, = K/iis the critical shear velocity for initiation of grain motion. The factor a was given by a second empirical equation (8.22) Bagnold's bed load discharge relation is then,
(8.23) Equation (8.23) was found to fit data by Williams (1970) with 1.1-mm sediment and flows of constant depth. It gave different results for flows with the same values of zo 0 but different depths and required a correction for depth to bring calculated and observed values into agreement. It is believed
vim A. vanoni
70
that this is because the mean velocity U has been included in the relation. Bed load transport and other bed phenomena are believed to depend on the bed shear stress or shear velocity and not on mean velocity or flow depth. This idea is born out by the results of Taylor shown in Fig. 21 in which bed load discharge is presented in terms of z* and R , .
c.
SEDIMENT
DISCHARGE MEASUREMENTS IN RIVERS
Routine measurements of sediment discharge of rivers in the U.S. are made by means of samplers called depth-integrating samplers developed by a Federal Interagency Committee (1963; see also ASCE, 1969a).These samplers take a representative sample of water and suspended sediment as they are lowered at a uniform velocity from the stream surface to a point near the bed and then returned to the surface also at a uniform rate. Figure 35 is a diagram showing such a sampler at its lowest position in a vertical at which point the distance from the bed to the sampler inlet tube is denoted by a. As may be seen from Fig. 35, the suspended load in the depth segment a near the bed and the bed load are not sampled. The samplers are designed so the velocity in the inlet tube is the same as the local stream velocity. This is done by placing the outlet port through which air is exhausted from the sample bottle as it is filling, in a low pressure part of the sampler profile. In this manner the friction loss in the sampler flow system is balanced by the difference in pressure between the entrance to the inlet tube and the air exhaust port. Because the velocity in the inlet tube is the same as the local stream velocity U , the sampler performs the integration of the product CU of the local concentration and velocity as indicated in Eq. (8.9). At the same time the sampler integrates U over the depth. The result is that sediment concentration in the sample is the discharge concentration for the sampled portion of the stream. If the transit time of the sampler is recorded, the mean velocity can be calculated from the sample volume, area of inlet tube, and transit time. However, this method of measuring velocity is not very reliable and is not usually used. In order to make a complete measurement of sediment discharge at a station on a river, samples are taken at a number of verticals so that the mean concentration C; of the measured portion of the river flow can be determined. At the same time that sediment samples are taken the mean velocity at each vertical is determined by current meter. Based on these velocity measurements the total discharge Q of the river is calculated. The sediment discharge usually reported is determined as C:, Q. It includes discharge of wash load as well as of bed sediment load.
71
River Dynamics
I
sample bottle
d inlet tube
t
/&/A/ /A\
1
/Ash
//A/
A % & \/
& A \
/&/A\
FIG.35. Sketch of depth-integrating suspended load sampler in a stream.
The reported sediment discharge is less than the true total sediment discharge because the suspended load near the bed and the bed load is not sampled. Because the wash load is nearly uniformly distributed over the depth, the product of its concentration measured by sampling and Q gives a very good estimate of the true wash load discharge. The main error is in the bed sediment discharge. Several ways are available to estimate the unmeasured portion of the bed sediment discharge. One method used in the absence of a better one is to estimate by judgment the unmeasured sediment discharge as a percentage of that measured. Two other more reliable methods are available for calculating the unmeasured sediment discharge. One of these, known as the modified Einstein procedure, was developed by Colby and Hembree (1955; see also ASCE, 1971b).It requires the size distribution of the sampled load and of the bed sediment and data from water discharge measurements. The sampled part of the load is then divided into wash load and bed sediment load, and the correction applied only to the latter. This is done by size fractions first by integrating Eq. (8.9)from 2dSito a to get the unmeasured suspended load. The bed load discharge is then calculated by using a slight modification of the Einstein (1950) bed load function referred to previously in this section. The other method (Colby
Vito A . vanoni
72
1957; ASCE, 1971b) employs several graphs based on river data and experience to get an estimate of the unmeasured sediment discharge with a minimum of computation. Bed sediment discharges corrected by estimating the unmeasured portion of the discharge are given only in reports on detailed investigations. For example, the bed sediment discharges for the Rio Grande plotted in Fig. 33 have been corrected by the modified Einstein procedure. In these data the corrected bed sediment discharge was about twice the measured value.
IX. Effect of Water Temperature
A. FIELD OBSERVATIONS In investigations of the lower Colorado River, Lane et al. (1949) found that for a given water discharge the sediment discharge was about twice as much in winter when the water was cold as it was in summer. Their results are summarized in Fig. 36. The sediment discharge and concentration are
-
:2.00
2000
-
1000
c
d ~
$ .c
1.00 0.50
500
0.20
200
0.10
100
? c
5 0
6
0 c
5 0.05
E ._ D
$ 0.02
_-_ 3
0.0I
0
80
00
8
60
60
c
40
40 2
L c
-
I
0
2
?
?
; 20 ._
20
VI
a
0
LI. Q
I
'
I
1943
'
I
J
J
'
1944
'
I
1945 Year
I
I
I
1946
I
l
1
o
g
0
k-
1947
FIG.36. Plot of suspended sediment discharge and concentration, water temperature, and water discharge against time for Colorado River at Taylor's Ferry after Lane er al. (1949).
River Dynamics
73
high in the winter and low in the summer and tend to diminish with time. The latter behavior was attributed to the observed coarsening of the bed sediment which results from the clear flows released from the reservoirs upstream. These flows selectively pick up more sediment in the finer fractions leaving behind proportionally more coarse particles than fine ones. This coarsening of the bed sediment is sometimes referred to as bed armoring and has occurred downstream from a number of large dams. An extreme case of armoring on the Missouri River below Fort Randall Dam was reported by Livesey (1963) in which the bed coarsened to the extent that sediment movement ceased. Colby and Scott (1965) reported that the Manning friction factor n of the Middle Loup River at Dunning, Nebraska, decreased as temperature decreased. The river at this station has bed sediment with median size of
September
October
Novem be r
FIG. 37. Variation of water temperature, discharge, average velocity, and Manning’s n for Missouri River at Omaha, Nebraska during the fall of 1966, after U.S. Army Corps ofEngineers ( 1969).
74
Vito A. Vanoni
0.35 mm and during the observations the flow rate varied from 300 to 500 ft3/sec. At the maximum temperature of 83°F the mean value of n was 0.033, and at the minimum temperature of 32°F it was 0.020. Detailed studies of the bed profiles revealed that the bed form changed dramatically to cause the large change in friction factor and flow resistance. When the water was warm, the bed was covered with rugged dunes. When the water was cold, dunes were still present on the bed but they were much longer and lower than in the warm water. A remarkable set of observations on temperature effects in a 7-mile reach of the Missouri River near Omaha, Nebraska, were made by the U S . Army Corps of Engineers (1969). Data on water temperature, discharge, average velocity, and Manning n from this investigation for the fall of 1966 are plotted in Fig. 37. This reach of the river has fine bed sediment with median size of 0.2 mm, and for the discharge shown in Fig. 37 it is approximately 10 ft deep and 700 ft wide. The flow is regulated by gates at the Gavins Point Dam about 150 miles upstream of Omaha. This keeps the flow rate high during the navigation season, March 15 to November 15, and then lowers it to about 10,000 ft3/sec during the rest of the year. Figure 37 shows that as the water temperature dropped from 74 to 39°F during the fall of 1966 the Manning friction factor dropped from 0.020 to 0.016 and the average velocity increased approximately 13%. During this period the water surface elevation (gage height) for the discharge of 33,000 ft3/sec dropped about 2 ft. Extensive surveys of the river bed showed that the drop in friction factor was accompanied by the lengthening and lowering of the dunes as reported by Colby and Scott (1965) for the Middle Loup River. It was also found that during this time the number of dunes in the study reach diminished and increasing portions of the bed became flat. B. LABORATORY STUDIES
Definitive studies of the effect of water temperature on sediment-laden flows were made by Taylor (1971b). His results for low transport rate (Taylor and Vanoni, 1972a) given in Fig. 21 show that the qualitative effect of temperature on discharge of bed load varies depending on the value'of the boundary Reynolds number R , . Since the transport rates were very low, all of the load was bed load and therefore the results apply only to bedload. Taylor's experiments were made in pairs with the same velocity, depth, and sediment but different temperatures. Three pairs of such experiments were made in each of the series B, H, and C . The value of R , for the warmer water of any pair of experiments is always larger than for the colder water. It will be seen that in series B the transport rate in the cold water run of each pair of
River Dynamics
‘75
runs is less than in the hot water runs. For the runs in series H and C, the reverse is true; and in series E and D no temperature effect was observed. These data clarify some of the conflicting laboratory results reported in the literature, some of which showed an increase in sediment discharge with increase in temperature whereas others showed the opposite trend. It is clear from Taylor’s results in Fig. 21 that a decrease in temperature can cause a decrease or increase in sediment discharge depending on the value of R , . Taylor’s (1971b; Taylor and Vanoni, 1972b) experiments with high transport rates and flat beds shed further light on temperature effects. These experiments were also made in pairs with the same velocity and depth and sediment but different water temperatures. Taylor measured the total sediment discharge and sampled the suspended load at several points in a vertical. Then he separated each suspended load sample into several size fractions by sieving and determined the concentration of each fraction. Sieve analyses were also made of the total load and the discharge of each size fraction was determined. Typical logarithmic plots of concentration against (d - y ) / y for three of the size fractions from one pair of these experiments (runs F-27 and F-28) are shown in Fig. 38. Straight lines are fitted to the data according to the Rouse relation [Eq. (5.7)]. Other data of interest in these two runs are given in Table 6 and Table 7. From Table 6 it can be seen that in the cool water run F-27 the sediment discharge of all grain sizes was slightly less than in the warm water run F-28. In Figs. 38 it is seen that the suspended sediment concentration for the two fine fractions are smaller in the cool water than in the warm water. Figure 38 shows that for the coarse fraction (d, = 0.322 mm) the reverse is true, the concentration in the cool water is larger than in the warm water. As would be expected from Fig. 38, Table 7 shows that the discharge of sediment in the cool water (run F-27) is smaller than in the warm water for the finer fractions (4 = 0.08 1 and 0.096 mm) but larger than in the warm water for the coarse fraction (d5 = 0.322 mm). Thus it is seen that in a stream opposite temperature effects on transport rate can occur simultaneously on different sediment sizes. From Fig. 38 it can be inferred that the concentration near the bed of the two finer fractions of sediment is less in the cool water than in the warm water, and that the opposite is true for the coarsest fraction. From this and data not shown here it is also inferred that the rate of bed load transport and sediment concentration near the bed are closely related and that the flow with the higher concentration near the bed will also have the higher bed load discharge. This general concept was first expressed by Einstein (1950) in Eq. (8.10). Table 7 lists values of the boundary Reynolds number R , = U , d, /v for the three size fractions of runs F-27 and F-28, the concentration profiles for which are shown in Fig. 38. I t is seen that the values of R , for the two fine
76
Vito A. vanoni 10
--.--
f.'
.--0-T-2YC T- 39°C I
0.I
10
I l l
I
-
dS=0.096mm
--&-I
T-25OC T-39°C
I l l
I
I00
I00 10 Concentration, C(y,d,) (ppm)
10
-
2. \ 2.
I 0 Y
r
0
0
1
0
>
0.I
I Concentration, C(y,d,) (ppm)
10
FIG. 38. Suspended load concentration profiles for three size fractions of sediment in experiment pair F-27 and F-28 by Taylor and Vanoni (1972b).
fractions are less than 10 and that they exceed 15 for the coarse fraction. Referring again to Fig. 21 it is seen that the temperature effects in low transport flows changes sign in the vicinity of R , = 10 and appear to be qualitatively the same as in Taylor's flat-bed runs F-27 and F-28 in which the transport rate is high. These results are taken as evidence that the effect of temperature on bed load discharge in flat-bed flows can be characterized by R , for the individual particles. It appears that for R , < 10 an increase in temperature tends to increase bed load discharge, and for R , > 10 the reverse is true except that there appears to be a value of R , above which there is no temperature effect. The idea that the temperature effect on bed load discharge can be expressed in terms of R , for individual particles is
77
River Dynamics TABLE 6
GENERAL DATAFOR TAYLOR’S RUNSF-27
AND
F-28 Bed sediment
Run
Mean velocity V
Flow depth d
Water temperature
Total sediment discharge
Geometric mean size d,
Geometric standard deviation
(cmisec)
(cm)
(“C)
(gm/cm/sec)
(mm)
gg
F-27
86.6
11.4
24.5
2.10 0.228
1.52
F-28
87.8
11.2
38.9
2.23
TABLE 7 DATAFOR THREESIZEFRACTIONS OF SEDIMENT I N TAYLOR’S RUNSF-27 F-28 Geometric mean size of fraction d, (mm)
Sediment discharge of fraction gm/(cm sec)
F-27 F-28
0.08 1
0.0214 0.0412
3.87 5.24
0.361 0.508
F-27 F-28
0.096
0.0237 0.0271
4.59 6.2 1
0.535 0.622
F-27 F-28
0.322
0.0177 0.0151
Run
Boundary Reynolds number of fraction R ,
15.4 20.8
AND
Exponent
z for fraction
2.70 3.2 1
compatible with the body of information on flow in rough pipes and in boundary layers characterizing the roughness state of the boundary by the boundary Reynolds number and the velocity profile by the shear velocity U , . It is also compatible with Einstein’s bed load function in which the bed load discharge is also expressed in terms of a bed shear stress. The effect of temperature on suspended load discharge is twofold. First, there is the effect on the concentration C, measured near the bed which must be related to the bed load discharge and hence to R , . Then there is the effect on fall velocity which affects the exponent z in Eqs. (5.7) and (5.8), i.e., the gradient of the sediment concentration profile. The above discussions of laboratory studies of temperature effects have dealt only with flows with flat beds. There are some data on the effect of
78
vito A . vanoni
water temperature on the behavior of flows with ripple and dune beds but they are not as extensive as for flat beds. Franco (1968) and Taylor (1971b) made flume experiments with beds of fine sands in which the discharge was kept constant. These experiments were made in pairs with the same velocity and depth but different water temperatures. When the bed was rippled, both sediment discharge and friction factor increased when the temperature decreased. The trend in the sediment discharge is the same as in the three rivers mentioned in Section IX,A but the trend in friction factor is opposite to that in the rivers. In Taylor’s experiment the bed form changed to dunes for some of the flows with higher velocities. The bed form in the warm water runs ( T = 39°C) changed from ripples to dunes at a lower velocity than in the cool water runs ( T = 23°C). In one pair of runs, in which dunes formed in both cool and warm water, the sediment discharge was higher but the friction factor was lower in the cool water run. In this case the trend of sediment discharge with water temperature was the same as in the rivers but opposite to those in runs F-27 and F-28 (Table 6 ) in which the beds were flat. This may be because the boundary Reynolds numbers for the cool and warm water were, respectively, 11 and 15 and hence higher than the critical value of 10 at which the temperature effect appears to reverse. The boundary Reynolds number R , in Taylor’s flume tests ranged from 7.2 to 11 in the cool water runs and from 9.4 to 15 in the warm water runs. The fact that these are close to the critical value in which temperature effect changes sign makes it impossible to interpret the results clearly. Obviously this subject needs further study. The boundary Reynolds numbers based on median sediment size for the Colorado River, Middle Loup River, and Missouri River were all greater than 10. These values of R , are in the range in which Taylor’s flat-bed experiments also showed an increase in sediment discharge with a decrease in temperature. The effect of temperature on bed form and friction factor in rivers like that in laboratory flows is, however, still not explained. LIST OF SYMBOLS distance up from stream bottom coefficient in Eq. (2.6a) fraction of bed shear stress due to grain collisions with bed in Bagnold relation area of stream cross section constant in Eq. (5.14) stream width coefficient in Eq. (2.6b) numerical constants in Eq. (8.6) coefficient of friction
River Dynamics
e
f f’ .f “> f 6 f F
1
L Ll m
M n
Chezy coefficient sediment concentration at a point (mass per unit volume) sediment concentration at distance a from bed sediment concentration of the ith size fraction at distance a from bed sediment discharge concentration = GJQ or gs/q maximum sediment concentration at a vertical in fraction by volume sediment concentration at a point in fraction by volume mean sediment concentration over the depth in fraction by volume concentration of sediment of mean size dSi flow depth flow depth in Eq. (7.14) geometric mean sediment size sediment size mean size of ith fraction of bed sediment the grain size of a sediment for which N percentage by weight of the sediment is finer, e.g. d,, I is the size for which 84.1 by weight is finer concentration parameter for ripples in Eq. (7.9) denotes “function o f ” Darcy-Weisbach friction factor exponent in Eq. (2.6b) Darcy-Weisbach bed friction factor due to sand grain roughness Darcy-Weisbach bed friction factor due to form drag of bed bed shear stress due to grain collisions Froude number = V im factor in Rubey equation for fall velocity of sediment grain tangential bed stress due to grain collisions acceleration due to gravity sediment discharge per unit width of channel discharge of sediment of mean size dSi per unit width bed load discharge of sediment of mean size dSi per unit width = gI/(psu, d,) = dimensionless sediment discharge sediment discharge discharge of suspended sediment height of dune or ripple mean height of dunes or ripples exponent in Eq. (2.6) von Karman universal constant coefficient in Eq. (2.6) mixing length meander length dune or ripple length step length of saltating sediment grain mass of sediment in Bagnold equation exponent in Eq. (2.6~) coefficient in Eq. (8.11) percent of silt and clay in surface of bed Manning friction factor number of layers of moving sediment in DuBoys relation
79
vim A . vanoni P
4 4%
Q r r'
r" b'
rrn
R, R, S R*,
s s' s" t tc
T U
coefficient in Eq. (2.6d) probability, in Einstein relation = p,d,/w wetted perimeter of a channel cross section probability of sediment motion in the Einstein relation factor in Kalinske relation power to overcome friction per unit area of bed power to suspend sediment grains in a prism of unit area and height equal to water depth water discharge in volume per unit width per unit time sediment discharge in volume per unit width per unit time water discharge in volume per unit time = A l p = hydraulic radius of channel channel bed hydraulic radius due to sand grain roughness channel bed hydraulic radius due to form drag of bed bed hydraulic radius of channel mean radius of curvature of meanders grain number = d50&d
a
W
w X
Y
River Dynamics
81
exponent in Rouse equation (5.7) constant in Eq. (8.14) tan CI = coefficient of friction in Bagnold relation = &,/Em
specific weight of water specific weight of sediment eddy viscosity or diffusion coefficient for momentum diffusion coefficient for sediment local elevation of bed coefficient in Eicstein’s step length equation, L , = nods dynamic viscosity of fluid kinematic viscosity of fluid density of fluid density of sediment geometric standard deviation of grain sizes in a sediment shear stress at distance y above bed bed shear stress bed shear stress due to sand grain roughness bed shear stress due to form roughness of bed critical value of bed shear stress for initiation of sediment motion = t o / [ ( y , - .;)d,] dimensionless shear stress = T ~ [ ( Y ,- ;.)d,] dimensionless shear stress based on zb = T ; [ ( Y , - y)d,] dimensionless shear stress based on T ; dimensionless sediment discharge in Einstein equation (8.7) dimensionless sediment discharge in Engelund equation (8.15) = 1/t, , Einstein equation (8.7) parameter in Einstein-Barbarossa equation (7.11) parameter in DuBoys equation (8.5)
REFERENCES ACKERS, P., and CHARLTON, F. G. (1970). Dimensional analysis of alluvial channels with special reference to meander length. J . Hydraul. Res. 8, 287-316. ALAM,A. M. Z., and KENNEDY, J. F. (1969). Friction factors for flow in sand bed channels. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 95, HY6, 1973-1992. ANAHMBOTLA, V. S. S., SAYRE, W. W., and LIVESEY, R. H. (1972). Statistical properties of Missouri River bed forms. J . Waterways, Harbors Coastal Eng. Diu., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 98, WW4, 489-510. ANDERSON, A. G. (1942). Distribution of suspended sediment in a natural stream. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union, 11. 678-683. ANDERSON, A. G . (1953). The characteristics of sediment waves formed by flow in open channels. Proc. Midwest. Cont Fluid Mech., 3rd, t 953 pp. 379-394. ANDERSON, A. G. (1967). On the development of stream meanders. Proc. Congr. Int. Ass. Hydruul. Res., 12th. Vol. 1, Paper A46, pp. 370-388. ASCE. (1962). Sediment transportation mechanics: Introduction and properties of sediment. J . Hydraul. Dio., Amer. SOC. Civil Eng. 88, HY4, 77-107. ASCE. (1963). Sediment transportation mechanics: Suspension of sediment. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. SOC. Civil Eng. 89, HY5, 45-76.
82
vito A . vanoni
ASCE. (1966a). Nomenclature for bed loorms in alluvial channels. Report by task force on bed forms in alluvial channels. J . Hydraul. Die., Amer. Soc. Civil Eng. 92, HY3, 51-64. ASCE. (1966b). Sediment transportation mechanics: Initiation of motion. J. Hydraul. Dia., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 92, HY2, 291-314. ASCE. (1967). Closure of sediment transportation mechanics: Initiation of motion. J . Hydraul. Diu.,Amer. SOC.Cicil Eng. 93, HY5, 297-302. ASCE. (1968). Task Committee report on erosion of cohesive sediment. J . Hydruul. Dic., Amer. SOC.Cieil Eng. 94, HY4, 1017-1049. ASCE. (1969a). Sediment measurement techniques: Fluvial sediment. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. SOC.Civil Eny. 95, HY5, 1477-1514. ASCE. (1969b). Sediment measurement techniques: Laboratory procedures. J . Hydraul. Die., Amer. SOC.Civil Eny. 95, HY5, 1515-1543. ASCE. ( 1971a). Sediment transportation mechanics: Hydraulic relations for alluvial streams. J . Hydruul. Din, Amer. SOC.Ciuil Eng. 97,HYI, 101-141. ASCE. (1971b). Sediment transportation mechanics: Sediment discharge relations. J . Hjdruul. Dic., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 97, HY4, 523-567. BAGNOLD,R. A. (1960). Sediment discharge and stream power, a preliminary announcement. U S . , Geol. Suru., Circ. 421. BAGNOLD, R. A. (1966). An approach to the sediment transport problem from general physics. U S . , Geol. Surv., ProJ Pup. 422-1. BAGNOLD, R. A. (1973). The nature of saltation and bed-load transport in water. Proc. Roy. SOC.,Ser. A 332, 473-504. BARR,D. I. H., and HERBERTSON, J. G. (1968a). Similitude theory applied to correlation of flume sediment transport data. Wuter Resour. Rex 4, 307-315. BARR,D. I. H., and HERBERTSON, J. G. (1968b). A similitude framework for regime theory. Proc. Inst. Civil Eng. 41, 761-781. BLENCH,T. (1969). Coordination in mobile-bed hydraulics. J . Hydraul. Die., Amer. Soc. C i d Eng. 95, HY6, 1871-1898. BLENCH, T. (1970). Regime theory design of canals with sand beds. J . Irrig. Druinugr Dh,., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 96, 1R1, 205-213. BOHLEN,W. F. (1969). “Hotwire Anemometer Study of Turbulence in Open-channel Flows Transporting Neutrally Buoyant Particles,” Rep. 69-1. Exp. Sedimentol. Lab., Dept. Earth Planet. Sci., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge. BROOKS, N. H. (1958). Mechanics of streams with movable beds of fine sand. Trans. Amer. SOC. Civil Eng. 123, 526-594. BROWN,C. B. (1950). Engineering hydraulics. In “Sediment Transportation ” (H. Rouse, ed.), Chapter XII, p. 769. Wiley, New York. A. B. (1922). The influence of silt on the velocity of water flowing in open channels. BUCKLEY, Minutes Proc. Inst. Civil Eng. 226, 183-210. R . A. (1965). Instability of river channels. J . Fluid Mech. 36, 465-480. CALLANDER, CAREY,W. G., and KELLER, M. D. (1957). Systematic changes in the beds of alluvial rivers. J. Hydraul. Dic., h e r . Soc. Civil Eny. 83, HY4, 1331-1-1331-24. CHIEN,N. (1956). Present status of research on sediment transport. Trans. Amer. SOC.Ciuil Eng. 121, 833-884. COLBY, B. R. (1957).Relation of unmeasured sediment discharge to mean velocity. Trans. Amer. Geophps. Union 38, 707-717. COLBY,B. R. (1960). Discontinuous rating curves for Pigeon Roost and Cuffawa Creeks in Northern Mississippi. U S . , Drp. Agr., A g r . Res. Seru. [Rep.] ARS41-36. C. H. (1955). Computations of total sediment discharge, Niobrara COLBY,B. R., and HEMBREE, River near Cody, Nebraska. U S . , Geol. Suru., Water-Supply Pap. 1357.
River Dynamics
83
COLBY,B. R., and SCOTT,C. H. (1965). Effects of water temperature on discharge of bed material. U S . , Geol. S u m , Prof: Pap. 462-G. COOPER,R. H., and PETERSON, A. W. (1968). Analysis ofcomprehensive bedload transport data from flumes. Amer. SOC. Civil Eny., Hjdruul. Spec. Conf, 1968 42 pp. COOPER,R. H., PETERSON, A. W., and BLENCH, T. (1972). Critical review of sediment transport experiments. J . Hydruul. Div., Amer. Soc. Civil Eny. 98, HY5, 827-843. DAILY,J. W., and CHU, T. K. (1961). “Rigid Particle Suspensions in Turbulent Shear Flow: Measurement of Total Head, Velocity and Turbulence with Impact Tubes,” Rep. 67. Hydrodynamics Lab., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge. R. L. (1964). “Rigid Particle Suspensions in Turbulent Shear DAILY,J. W., and HARDISON, Flow: Measurement of Total Head, Velocity and Turbulence with Impact Tubes,” Tech. Rep. 67. Hydrodynamics Lab., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge. D u b u s , P. (1879). Le Rh6ne et les rivieres a lit affouillable. Ann. Ponts Chuussees 5, 141-195. EDEN,E. W., Jr. (1938). A study of bed movement and hydraulic roughness in the Lower Mississippi River. Master’s degree thesis, State University of Iowa, Iowa City. EINSTEIN, H. A. (1942). Formulas for the transportation of bed load. Trans. Amer. SOC. Civil Eny. 107, 561-577. H. A. (1950). The bed load function for sediment transportation in open channels. EINSTEIN, U S . , Dep. Agr., Soil Conserv. Serv., Tech. Bull. 1026. EINSTEIN,H. A., and ABDEL-AAL, F. M. (1972). Einstein bed-load function at high sediment rates, J . Hydraul. Diu., Amer. SOC. Civil Eng. 98, HYl, 137-151. EINSTEIN, H. A., and BARBAROSSA, N. L. (1952). River channel roughness. Truns. Amer. Soc. C i d Eng. 117, 1121-1146. EINSTEIN,H. A., and CHIEN,N. (1952). “Second Approximation to the Solution of the Suspended Load Theory,” Rep. 47-2. Inst. Eng. Res., University of California, Berkeley. EINSTEIN, H. A,, and CHIEN,N. (1954). “Second Approximation to the Solution of the Suspended Load Theory,” MRD Ser. Rep. No. 2. University of California and Missouri River Div., U S . Army Corps Eng., Omaha, Nebraska. EINSTEIN, H. A., and CHIEN,N. (1955). “Effect of Heavy Sediment Concentration Near the Bed on Velocity and Sediment Distribution,” MRD Ser. Rep. No. 8. University of California and Missouri River Div., U.S. Army Corps Eng., Omaha, Nebraska. EINSTEIN, H. A., and SHEN,H. W. (1964). A study of meandering in straight alluvial channels. J . Geophys. Res. 69, 5239-5247. EINSTEIN, H. A., ANDERSON, A. G., and JOHNSON, J. W. (1940). A distinction between bed load and suspended load in natural streams. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 21, 628-633. ELATA,C., and IPPEN,A. T. (1961). “Dynamics of Open Channel Flow with Suspensions of Neutrally Buoyant Particles,” Rep. 45. Hydrodynamics Lab., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge. ENGELUND, F. (1966). Hydraulic resistance of alluvial streams. J . Hydraul. Diu., Amrr. Soc. Civil Eny. 92, HY2, 315-326. F. (1967). Closure to Hydraulic resistance of alluvial streams, J . Hydraul. Diu., ENGELUND, Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 93, HY4, 287-296. F. (1970). Instability of erodible beds, J . Fluid Mech. 42, 225-244. ENGELUND, ENGELUND, F., and HANSEN,E. (1967). “A Monograph on Sediment Transport in Alluvial Streams.” Teknisk forlag, Copenhagen. 0. (1973). On the origin of meandering and braiding in ENGELUND, F., and SKOVGAARD, alluvial streams. J . Fluid Mech. 57, 289-302. FAHNESTOCK, R. K., and MADDOCK, T. (1964). Preliminary report on bed form and flow phenomena in the Rio Grande near El Paso, Texas. U S . , Geol. Suru. Prof: Pap. S l B , B140-Bl42.
84
Vito A . Vanoni
FEDERAL INTERAGENCY COMMITTEE.(1963). “A Summary of the Work of the Federal Interagency Sedimentation Project,” Report s. St. Anthony Falls Hydraul. Lab., Minneapolis, Minnesota. FRANCO, J. J. (1968). Effects of water temperature on bed-load movement. J . Waterways Harbors Diu., Amer. SOC. Civil Eng. 94, WW3, 343-352. FRIEDKIN, J. F. (1945). “A Laboratory Study of the Meandering of Alluvial Rivers.” Waterways Exp. Sta., U.S. Army Corps Eng., Vicksburg, Mississippi. GESSLER,J. (1965). “ Der Geschiebetriebbeginn bei Mischungen untersucht an naturlichen Abpflasterungserscheinungen in Kanalen,” Rep. 69. Lab. Hydraul. Res. Soil Mech., Swiss Fed. Inst. Technol., Zurich. GILL,M. A. (1971). Height of sand dunes in open channel flows. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. SOC. Civil En9. 97, HY 12. 206772074, GRADOWCYZK, M. H. (1968). Wave propagation on the erodible bed of an open channel. J . Fluid Mecli. 33, 93-112. GRASS,A. J. (1970). Initial instability of fine bed sand. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. Soc. Civil Eng. 96, HY3, 619-632. GUY,H. P., SIMONS,D. B., and RICHARDSON, E. V. (1966). Summary of alluvial channel data from flume experiments, 1956-61. U.S., Geol. Suru., Pro$ Pap. 462-1. HALBRONN, G. (1949). Remarque sur la theorie de I’austausch appliquee au transport des mattriaux en suspension. Proc. Meet. Int. Ass. Hydraul. Struct. Res., 3rd, 1949 11-9, pp. 1-6. HAYASHI, T. (1970). Formation of dunes and antidunes in open channels. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. %, HY2, 357-366. F. M. (1966). “Open Channel Flow.” Macmillan, New York. HENDERSON, HERBERTSON, J. G. (1969). Scaling procedures for mobile bed hydraulic models in terms of similitude theory. J . Hydraul. Res. 7 , 315-353. HUBBELL, D. W., and MATEJKA, D. Q. (1959). Investigation of sediment transportation, Middle Loup River at Dunning, Nebraska. U S . , Geol. Suru., Water-Supply Pap. 1476. HUNT,J. N. (1954). The turbulent transport of suspended sediment in open channels. Proc. Roy. SOC.,Ser. A 224, 322-335. HWANG,L. S. (1965). Flow resistance of dunes in alluvial channels. Ph.D. thesis, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena. INGLIS,C. C. (1949). “The Behaviour and Control of Rivers and Canals,” Res. Publ. 13, Vols. 1 and 2. Central Waterpower Irrigation and Navigation Res. Sta., Poona, India. IPPEN, A. T. (1971). A new look at sedimentation in turbulent streams. J . Boston Soc. Civil Eng. 58, 131-163. JOHNSON, J. W. (1942). The importance of considering side-wall friction in bed-load investigations. Civil Eng. (New York) 12, 329-331. JORDAN,R. R. (1965). Fluvial sediment of the Mississippi River at St. Louis, Missouri. U S . , Geol. Surv., Water-Supply Pup. 1802. KALINSKE, A. A. (1942). Criteria for determining sand transportation by surface creep and saltation. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 11, 639-643. A. A. (1947). Movement of sediment as bed load in rivers. Trans. Amer. Geophys. KALINSKE, Union 28, 615-620. KENNEDY, J. F. (1960). Stationary waves and antidunes in alluvial channels. Ph.D. thesis, California Institute of Technology, Pasadena. KENNEDY, J. F. (1963).The mechanics ofdunes and antidunes in erodible bed channels. J . Fluid Mech. 18, 521-544. KENNEDY, J. F. (1969).The formation of sediment ripple, dunes and antidunes. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 1, 147-168. KENNEDY, J. F., and BROOKS, N. H. (1963). Laboratory study of an alluvial stream of constant discharge. Proc. Fed. Inter-Agency Sediment. Con$, Misc. Publ. 970 (U.S. Dep. Agr., pp. 320-330).
River Dynamics
85
KEULEGAN, G. H. (1938). Laws of turbulent flow in open channels. J . Res. Nut. Bur. Stand. 21, Res. Pap. RP1151, 707-741. KREY,H. (1927). Die Quergeschwigkeitskurve bei turbulenter stroemung. Z . Angew. Math. Mech. 7, 2. LANE,E. W. (1947). Report of the Subcommittee on sediment terminology. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Union 28, 936-958. LANE,E. W. (1957). “A Study of the Shape ofchannels Formed by Natural Streams Flowing in Erodible Material,” MRD Ser. Rep. 9. US.Army Corps Eng., Omaha, Nebraska. E. J., and HANSEN, 0. S. (1949). Low temperature increases sediment LANE,E. W., CARLSON, transportation in Colorado River. Civil Eng. ( N e w Y o r k ) 19, 619-620. LANGREIN, W. B., and LEOPOLD, L. B. (1966). River meanders-theory of minimum variance. U S . . Geol. Surv., Prof: Pap. 422-H. LEOPOLD, L. B., and MADDOCK, T., Jr. (1953).The hydraulic geometry of stream channels and some physiographic implications. U S ,Geol. Suru., Prof: Pap. 252. LEOPOLD, L. B., and WOLMAN, M. G . (1957). River channel patterns: Braided, meandering and straight. U S . , Geol. Surv., Prof: Pup. 282-B. LEOPOLD,L. B., and WOLMAN,M. G. (1960). River meanders. Geol. Soc. Amer., Bull. 71, 769-796. LIVESEY, R. H. (1963). Channel armoring below Fort Randall Dam. Proc. Fed. Inter-Agency Sediment. ConJ, M i x . Publ. 970 (US.Dep. Agr., pp. 461-470). LOVERA, F., and KENNEDY, J. F. (1969). Friction factors for flat-bed Rows in sand channels. J . Hydraul. D i n , Amer. SOC.Civil Eny. 95, HY4, 1227-1234. MADDOCK, T., Jr. (1969).The behavior of straight channels with movable beds. U S . , Geol. Sur~:., Pro$ Pap. 622-A. MENARD, H. W. (1950). Sediment movement in relation to current velocity. J . Sediment. Petrology 20, 148-160. MEYER-PETER, E., and MULLER, R. (1948).Formulas for bedload transport. Proc. Meet. Int. Ass. Hydraul. Struct. Res., 2nd, 1948 pp. 39-64. J. S., and IPPEN,A. T. (1973). “Interaction of Two-dimensional Turbulent Flow with MONTES, Suspended Particles,” Rep. 164. R. M. Parsons Lab. Water Resour. Hydrodyn., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge. MOODY,L. F. (1944). Friction factors for pipe flow. Trans. Amer. SOC.Mech. Eng. 66, 671-684. NORDIN,C. F., Jr. (1964). Aspects of flow resistance and sediment transport, Rio Grande near Bernalillo, New Mexico. U.S., Geol. Surv., Water-Supply Pup. 1498-H. NORDIN,C. F., Jr., and ALGERT, J. H. (1966). Spectral analysis of sand waves. J . Hydraul. Diu., Amer. Soc. Ciuil Eng. 92, HY5, 95-114. OBRIEN,M. P. (1933). Review of the theory of turbulent flow and its relation to sediment transportation. Trans. Amer. Guophys. Union, 487-491. OFFEN, G. R., and KLINE,S . J. (1974). Combined dye-streak and hydrogen bubble visual observations of a turbulent boundary layer. J . Fluid Mech. 62,223-239. ORDONEZ,N. A. (1970). Absolute concentration distribution of suspended sediment in turbulent streams. Ph.D. thesis, R. M. Parsons Lab. Water Resour. Hydrodyn., Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge. PAINTAL, A. S . (1971). Concept of critical shear stress in loose boundary open channels. J. HjJdrau/.Res., 9, 91-107. PESKIN, R. L. (1970). “Basic Studies in Gas-solid Suspension,” Final Report (Tech. Rep. 133-MAE-F-NY02930-15)to U.S. Atomic Energy Commission. Dept. Mech. Aerosp. Eng., Rutgers University, New Brunswick, New Jersey. PESKIN,R. L., and RIN, C. H. (1967). The effect of suspended solids on turbulent dispersion. A S M E Fluids Eng. Con$, 1967. Paper 67-FE-17. RAUDKIVI, A. J. (1963). Study of sediment ripple formation. J . Hydraul. Dio., Amer. Soc. Civil Eng. 89, HY6, 15-33.
86
Vito A . Vanoni
REYNOLDS, A. J. (1965). Waves on the erodible bed of an open channel. J . Fluid Mech. 22, 113-133. ROUSE, H. (1937). Modern conceptions of the mechanics of fluid turbulence. Trutu. Amer. Soc. Civil Eng. 102, 463-543. RUBEY, W. W. (1933). Settling velocities of gravel sand and silt. h e r . J . Sci. 25, 325-338. SCHMIDT, W. (1925). Der Massenaustausch in freier luft und verwandte Erscheinungen. Prohl. Kosm. Fiz. 7. SCHUMM, S. A. (1963). A tentative classification ofalluvial river channels. U S . , Geol. Surt.., Geol. Circ. 477. SCHUMM, S. A. (1967). Meander wave lengths of alluvial rivers. Science 157, 1549-1550. SHEN,H. W., and KOMURA, S. (1968). Meandering tendencies in straight alluvial channels. J . Hydraul. Diz;., Amer. SOC. Civil Eng. 94, HY4, 997-1016. SHIELDS, A. (1936). “Anwendung der Aehnlichkeitsmechanik und der Turbulenzforschung auf die Geschiebebewegung.” Report of Prussian Research Institute for Hydraulic Engineering and Naval Architecture, Berlin. SHINOHARA, K., and TSUBAKI, T. (1959). “ O n the Characteristics of Sand Waves Formed upon the Beds of Open Channels and Rivers,” Vol. VII, No. 25, pp. 15-45. Reports of Research Institute for Applied Mechanics, Kyushu University, Japan. SIMONS, D. B., and RICHARDSON, E. V. (1966). Resistance to flow in alluvial channels. U.S., Geol. Surr., Pro& Pup. 422-5. SOUTHARD, J . B. (1971). Representation of bed configuration in depth-velocity-size diagrams. J . Sediment. Petrology 41, 903-9 15. SUKEGAWA, N. (1972). “Criterion for Alternate Bar Formation,” Mem. No. 36. School Sci. Eng., Wesada University, Japan. SUTHERLAND, A. J. (1967). Proposed mechanism for sediment entrainment by turbulent flows. J . Geophys. Res. 72, 6 183-6 194. SUTHERLAND, A. J., and IRVINE,H. M. (1973). A probabilistic approach to the initiation of movement of noncohesive sediments. Proc. Int. Ass. Hydraul. Res., I n t . Synp. Ricer Mech., 1973 VOI. 1, pp. 383-393. TAYLOR, B. D. (1971a). Discussion of initiation ofripples on flat sediment beds, J . Hydruul. Die., Arner. SOC.Ciril Eny. 97, H Y I , 19241930. TAYLOR, B. D. (1971b). “Temperature Effects in Alluvial Streams,” Rep. KH-R-27. W. M. Keck Lab. Hydraul. Water Resour., California Institute of Technology, Pasadena. TAYLOR, B. D., and VANONI, V. A. (1972a). Temperature effects in low-transport, flat-bed flows. J . Hvdraul. Dit.., Amer. SOC. Civil Eng. 98, HY8, 1427-1445. TAYLOR, B. D., and VANONI, V. A. (1972b). Temperature effects in high-transport, flat-bed flows. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 98, HY12, 2191-2206. N. H. (1962). Discussion of resistance to flow in alluvial TAYLOR, R. H., Jr., and BROOKS, channels. Trans. Amer. Soc. Cioil Eng. 127, Part I, 982-992. (1951-53). “Sediment transportation characteristics study,” U S . ARMYCORPSOF ENGINEERS Missouri River, Missouri River Decision, Omaha, Nebraska. U.S. ARMYCORPSOF ENGINEERS. (1969). -Missouri River Channel Regime Studies,” M.R.D. Sediment Ser. 13B. Omaha District, Omaha, Nebraska. U.S. BUREAU OF RECLAMATION. (1958). “Total Sediment Transport Program Lower Colorado River Basin,” Interim report. Sediment. Sect., Denver, Colorado. VANONI, V. A. (1946). Transportation of suspended sediment by water. Trans. Amer. Soc. Cioil E n g . 111, 67-133. VANONI,V. A. (1953). “Some Effects of Suspended Sediment on Flow Characteristics.” Proc. 5th Hydraul. Conf. Bull. No. 34, pp. 137-158. State University of Iowa, Iowa City.
River Dynamics
87
V A ~ O NV. I , A. (1964).“ Measurements of Critical Shear Stress for Entraining Fine Sediments in a Boundary Layer,” Rep. KH-R-7. W. M. Keck Lab. Hydraui. Water Resour., California Institute of Technology, Pasadena. VANONI,V. A. (1974).Factors determining bed forms of alluvial streams. J . Hydraul. Dia., h e r . SOC.Civil Eng. 100, HY3, 363-377. VANONI,V. A., and BROOKS,N. H. (1957). “Laboratory Studies of the Roughness and Suspended Load of Alluvial Streams,” Rep. E6X. Sediment. Lab., California Institute of Technology, Pasadena. VANONI,V. A,, and HWANG,L. S. (1967). Relation between bed forms and friction in streams. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 93, HY3, 121-144. VON KARMAN,T. (1934). Turbulence and skin friction. J . Aeronaut. Sci. 1, 1-20. WHITE,C. M. (1940). Equilibrium of grains on the bed of a stream. Proc. Roy. SOC.,Ser. A 174, 322-338. WILLIAMS, G. P. (1970). Flume width and water depth effects in sediment-transport, U S . , Geol. Surv., Prof: Pap. 562-H. WILLIS,J. C., and COLEMAN, N. L. (1969). Unification of data on sediment transportation in flumes by similitude principles. Water Resour. Res. 5, 1330-1336. WILLIS,J. C., COLEMAN, N. L., and ELLIS,W. M. (1972). Laboratory study of transport of fine sand. J . Hydraul. Dia., Amer. SOC.Civil Eng. 98, HY3, 489-501. YALIN,M. S. (1963). An expression for bed-load transportation. J . Hydraul. Div., Amer. SOC. Civil Eng. 89, HY3, 221-250. YALIN,M. S. (1964). Geometrical properties of sand waves. J . Hydraul. Diu., Amer. Soc. Civil Eng. 90, HY5, Part 1, 105-119. YALIN,M . S . (1965). “Similarity in Sediment Transport by Currents,’’ Hydraul. Res. Pap. No. 6, pp. 1-25. Hydraulics Res. Sta., Walingford, Berkshire, England. YALIN,M. S. (1972). “ Mechanics of Sediment Transport.” Pergamon, Oxford.
This Page Intentionally Left Blank
Matching Problems Involving Flow through Small Holes E . 0. TUCK Di.p n r t i w n t of Applied Mtrthumaticc L iiiwrsiry of Adrlaitle. Adelaide South Australiu
.
I . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I1 . The Effective Size of Holes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Three-Dimensional Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Two-Dimensional Examples . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 111. Double Slits and Split Plates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Exact Solution for the Effective Size of a Double Slit . . . . . . . B. Exact Solution for Flow Normal to Split Plates . . . . . . . . . . C. Approximate Solution for Split Plates . . . . . . . . . . . . . . IV. Laws of Combination for Finite Sparse Distributions of Holes . . . . . A . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Two-Dimensional Arrays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Three-Dimensional Arrays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Two and Three Slits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . E . Uniform Flow Arrays . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . V. Blockage and Permeability Coefficients . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Rectangular Obstacles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Blockage by Walls with Holes . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D. Application to Porous Screens o r Membranes . . . . . . . . . . V1. Green’s Function for a Rectangular Pipe . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A . Line Array of Unit Point Sources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Rectangular Planar Array of Unit Point Sources . . . . . . . . . VII . Vehicles Moving Close to a Plane Surface . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Introduction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Vehicles with Complete G a p Penetration . . . . . . . . . . . . . C. Vertical Force on a Slender Half-Body of Revolution . . . . . . . VIII . Water-Wave Transmission through Holes in Walls . . . . . . . . . . A. Introduction and Exact Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Approximate Solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . C . Finite-Depth Results . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . D . Walls with Continuously Variable Permeability . . . . . . . . . . 89
90 93 93 94 97 99 99 101 103 105 105 106 107 108 109 110 110 111 114 117
119 119
121 125 125 128 132 134 134 135 137 140
90
E. 0.Tuck IX. The Helmholtz Resonator . . . . . . . . . . . . X. Real-Fluid Effects . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . A. Free-Streamline Flows . . . . . . . . . . . . B. Unsteady Flows with Viscosity . . . . . . . References . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . . .
. . . 141 . . . 146 . . . 146 . . . . 149 . . . 156
I. Introduction The method of matched asymptotic expansions (Van Dyke, 1964; Cole, 1968) is a technique that has been used widely and with great success in mechanics ever since it was properly formulated and published by Kaplun and his colleagues (see Kaplun, 1967) at the California Institute of Technology in the 1950s. Van Dyke’s delightful book (1964) was particularly effective in making the technique more accessible to those less interested in the formal mathematical development than in the practical applications. On the other hand, considerable progress has also been made recently (e.g., Fraenkel, 1969) in putting the formal technique on a more rigorous mathematical basis. But one should not be allowed to forget that the intuitive ideas involved, if not their formal expression, are really rather old. In fact, of course, one of Kaplun’s motivations was to give formal asymptotic expression to the concept of the boundary layer, which had been reasonably we11 understood intuitively since Prandtl’s work at the beginning of this century. A somewhat older example, of considerable interest to us in the present chapter, is the work of Rayleigh (e.g., 1870, 1897) on “small” objects or holes in an acoustic field, or “ Rayleigh scattering.” Without explicitly defining inner and outer expansions ’’ or invoking matching principles, Rayleigh was able to separate complicated problems into suitably simplified near-field and far-field problems, the connection being established by what we might now call matching. No doubt it would be possible to see similar insights in work even earlier than that of Rayleigh. As an elementary example of the matching principle, consider an idealized two-dimensional irrotational flow between two plane walls at y = fb, through a small hole 1 y < a 4 b in a barrier placed at x = 0, as in Fig. 1. The quantity flowing could be water, air, heat, or be a representation of a gravitational, elastic, or electromagnetic field, etc. We seek to find an approximate solution as a/b -+ 0 for the flow, e.g., for the streamline pattern or for some gross property such as a blockage coefficient or electromagnetic susceptance. The detail of such analysis will be presented later in this chapter. Here we merely wish to explain the matching process in intuitive terms. “
I
Flow through Small Holes
91
FIG.1. Sketch of channel flow through a small sharp-edged hole at the center ofa blocking wall of zero thickness.
Clearly when u/b = 0 the flow is entirely choked off, a situation of little interest. It is also clear that, to the next order of approximation, so long as we do not go too close to the hole, the residual effect of the hole will have the appearance of a source-sink pair located at the origin, with a sink on the left at (0-, 0) and a source on the right at (0 0). This is the basis for the outer approximation, the analysis of which requires only a determination of a source-type flow in a channel, but which depends not at all on the details of the flow through the hole. On the other hand, if while letting u/b + 0, we stay close to the hole, specifically considering events on a length scale of u rather than b, we must surely see the detailed flow through the hole, andbnly that. In particular, we shall lose any information about the walls y = & b of the channel, which will have disappeared to y = f m. Thus, again we can solve a simplified innerflow problem, involving consideration of the geometry of the hole itself. Finally, we must match the inner and outer flows to complete the solution, there usually being some degree of indeterminacy about both inner and outer approximations. For example, the strength of the apparent source in the outer approximations is as yet unknown. The process of matching may be visualized as follows. Suppose an outer observer in x > 0, of size and general field of vision O(b),attempts to observe the flow situation near the hole. This observer may be considered to be “long-sighted’’ as far as the hole is concerned, and will have difficulty focusing on the hole. All he will be able to see is a blurred sourcelike picture, with fluid streaming radially out of the origin toward him. On the other hand, the inner observer of size O(a)may be considered to be short-sighted, with an inability to see what is going on at a great distance from him. If now he attempts to focus on infinity, hoping to see the channel walls, for example, all he will in fact see (x > 0) is a blurred sourcelike flow, with the fluid streaming away from him radially in all directions. “Matching” merely is the requirement that these two observers be seeing
+,
92
E . 0.Tuck
the same thing, i.e. that the outer approximation of the inner observer’s world agrees with the inner approximation of the outer observer’s world. What follows is a collection of examples of solutions to problems involving small holes, slits, gaps, clearances, passages, gratings, etc. To a considerable extent each section is self-contained, although the common thread of intuitive matching runs through it, and we make extensive use of the concept of the “effective size” of holes, defined in Section 11. Briefly, the ,effective size is a single parameter, of the dimensions of a length, which characterizes the hole in its far field. Once the effective size is known, the actual details of the geometry of the hole are of no further interest for far-field purposes. The idea of such a parameter is not new; for example the quantity used here is proportional to a “ conductivity ” parameter used by Rayleigh (1870). In Section I11 we give a first illustration of matching, using the effective size to compute the amount of leakage through a small central slit in a flat plate normal to a uniform stream. Section I11 also includes the exact solution of that problem and a complementary exact derivation of the effective size of a symmetric double slit, where the spacing of the two slits relative to their size is not necessarily large. On the other hand, the case when there are two or more small slits or holes in a wall, whose sizes are all small compared with the spacing between them, is treated in Section IV. The task is to find the overall effective size of such a combination of holes, when the individual sizes and spacings are given. The problem is itself an exercise in matching, and the result shows a significant difference between two-dimensional slits and three-dimensional holes. The latter are to a first approximation simply additive, whereas this is far from the case in two dimensions. Blockage coefficients are, like effective sizes, single parameters with the dimension of length characterizing in the far field a particular, possibly complicated, geometry. In this case the geometry is that of an obstruction or discontinuity in a pipe, channel, or waveguide. In the last field of application, the blockage coefficient is related to the electromagnetic susceptance of the discontinuity (Marcuvitz, 1951). Various aspects of this parameter (including an analogy with Darcy’s law for flow in porous media) are discussed in Section V, and matching is used to relate the blockage coefficient for a barrier with a small hole to the effective size of the hole. A side issue raised in this work is pursued further in Section VI, where the potential for a point source in a pipe of rectangular cross section is derived, for use in constructing blockage coefficients for such a pipe. Applications to ship hydrodynamics and automobile or train aerodynamic problems are surveyed in Section VII, and applications to water-wave diffraction problems in Section VIII. In Section IX, the classical acoustic
Flow through Small Holes
93
problem of the Helmholtz resonator is considered again from the matchedapproximations point of view. In all these applications, matching of approximate boundary-value problems produces solutions that could be, and in most cases have been, obtained in other ways, e.g. by integral equation or variational techniques. It is hoped, however, that this way of thinking about problems with “ small ” geometrical features is intuitively helpful, by concentrating attention on the boundary-value problem itself, rather than on a mathematical representation of it. Finally, in Section X we look at some real-fluid effects. In the first place we consider unsymmetric flows through holes in which, although the flow is sinklike on one side, separation takes place at the edges of the hole, and a free jet rather than a source appears on the other side. Then we consider effects of viscosity, but only for the very restricted case of small-amplitude unsteady flow, in which the Navier-Stokes equation can be legitimately linearized.
11. The Effective Size of Holes
A. INTRODUCTION In the present section we shall be concerned exclusively with a very idealized boundary-value problem for Laplace’s equation. The domain of interest is the whole of two- or three-dimensional space, with the exception of a wall or barrier which occupies ” the plane x = 0. This wall is impermeable apart from a finite number of openings of a finite size. The wall itself need not be infinitesimally thin, so long as its thickness is only of the order of the size of the openings, or less. The flow that takes place is supposed to be irrotational flow of an inviscid incompressible fluid, so that we have to solve Laplace’s equationexterior to the wall, subject to suitable conditions at infinity. These conditions are fundamental to the whole of the present article. We suppose that as x -P -a, the flow tends asymptotically to that of an apparent sink at the origin, whereas as x +. 00, we similarly postulate an apparent source flow, whose strength must be equal to that of the sink, by continuity. By “ infinity,” we mean a distance large compared with the size of the openings in the wall, and hence also large compared with the wall thickness, if any, so that at infinity the wall is indistinguishable from the plane x = 0. In three dimensions, one normally observes that such a source potential behaves like the reciprocal of distance Y from the origin, thus tending to zero at infinity. However, it is not necessarily true that the potential required in “
+
94
E. 0. Tuck
the present case tends to zero. Instead we must allow it to tend to some constant which may (indeed must) take different values at the two infinities. Additive constants are generally ignored in velocity potentials ; however, in the present case this particular constant turns out to be of fundamental importance.
B. THREE-DIMENSIONAL EXAMPLES Rather than continuing with the above general description, it is probably more illuminating at this stage to write down the solution of a specific problem, namely axisymmetric flow through a sharp-edged circular hole of radius a, in the zero-thickness plane wall x = 0. The solution is quite classical (e.g., Lamb, 1932, pp. 138 and 144), but we repeat it here for completeness. The flow situation is as in Fig. 2, where y is actually a cylindrical polar coordinate. An appropriate solution of Laplace’s equation is any multiple of p, where a, /3 are oblate spheroidal coordinates defined by y = a sin a sec p.
x = a cos DL tan j?,
(2.1) For example, a solution that behaves like a unit source as x + + 00 and a unit sink as x -, - co is
4 = - .P
4na
This gives zero flux across the wall x = 0, y > a, i.e. across a = 742. If r= is distance from the origin, we have r + 00 as B -+ knJ2; more exactly
4-
I
FIG.2. Sketch of two- or three-dimensional flow through a sharp-edged hole in a n infinite plane wall of zero thickness.
Flow through Small Holes
95
so that
4
---f
‘(1 - t) sgn x + 4n s
0(~-3),
where 2 s =-a. 71
Equation (2.4) verifies, as required, that the solution (2.2) behaves like a unit source as x -+ + co and unit sink as x -+ - co.In addition it establishes the appropriate additive constant at these extremities, and shows that, for example
A 4 = +(x=
+ a,) - (P(x= -
(0)
- 1 - --
271s.
The quantity s has the dimensions of length and is fundamental in what follows. We choose to call this particular quantity the effective hole size. A definition of the effective hole size, one which works in more general cases, is that s is the distance from the hole at which the far field potential appears to vanish. If, for example, we define in a general case the far-field potential =
&F
lim
4 3
r/a+ a,
where a is a measure of actual hole dimensions, then &F must be singular at Y = 0. We define s so &F = 0 at Y = s = O(a),even though 4FF is formally not a valid approximation to 4 at this distance. The quantity c
= zs
(2.7)
was observed by Rayleigh (1870) to be the reciprocal of a measure of electrostatic resistance, and was later called by him and others (e.g., Rayleigh, 1894, p. 173) the conductivity of the opening, or more specifically (cf. Lindsay, 1945, p. xxvi) the acoustic conductivity. Another separate interpretation (Rayleigh, 1894, p. 176) in cases where one can usefully imagine a conducting “body” filling in what was the opening (and then the original wall being removed), is that s = c/z is then the electrostatic capacity of the condenser formed between this artificial body and a sphere at infinity.
E. 0. Tuck
96
The numerical computation of s for quite arbitrary and specified opening geometries is a perfectly straightforward numerical task on present-day computers, in contrast to the situation confronting Rayleigh (1894, p. 175), which was “beyond the power of existing mathematics.” Similar computations, in which the geometry of the boundary is input information, are now being made on a routine basis (e.g. Carson, 1967; Taylor, 1973). For single sharp-edged holes of given area in a zero-thickness wall, there is, however, only a weak dependence of s on the actual shape of the edge of the hole. For example, Rayleigh (1894, p. 178) showed that the effective size of an elliptic hole was given by S
2Jabln
- &K(
42 1 - b2/a2)’
(2.9)
where a and b are the minor axes of the ellipse and K is a complete elliptic integral (Abramowitz and Stegun, 1964, p. 590).
FIG. 3. Effective size of an elliptic hole in a zero-thickness plane wall, as a function of eccentricity.
The quantity on the left of (2.9)is the ratio between the effective size of the elliptic hole and that of a circular hole of the same area, as is confirmed by the fact that the right-hand side takes a unit value at b/u = 1. In fact, Fig. 3 shows that there is little departure from unity except for extremely eccentric ellipses, for which as b/a -+ 0 we have S-+
a log(4ulb)’
(2.10)
Jab
which tends to zero (slowly) if a is fixed, but to infinity if either or b is fixed. The last result is somewhat relevant to the case of two-dimensional flow through a slit. However, the nature of two- and three-dimensional sources is
Flow through Small Holes
97
quite different, and we must reexamine the concept of the effective size in the two-dimensional case. Again it is convenient to proceed via an example of an exact solution.
C. TWO-DIMJZNSIONAL EXAMPLES The simplest two-dimensional example is that of an infinitely long slit of width 2a. Figure 1 still describes the flow in the (x,y ) plane, where y is now a Cartesian coordinate. Indeed the transformation of coordinates (2.1) can still be used to solve the problem, but no longer is (2.2) a solution of Laplace’s equation. Instead we use
(2.11) where tan Now as I y I
-+ 00,
r
= sinh y.
-,+aelV’-+ 00,
(2.12)
and
(2.13) where s = +a.
(2.14)
Again, s has the significance of an effective hole size, since the far-field approximation (2.13) appears to vanish at r = s. The above solution can of course be obtained in other ways. In particular, a conformal mapping of Joukowski type gives the solution immediately (Tuck, 1971a). Other somewhat more general two-dimensional configurations can also be solved by conformal mappings of varying degrees of complexity. For example, in Section I11 we obtain the effective size of a hole consisting of two slits, each of width w = b - a, with their center lines separated by a distance h = a b, as in Fig. 4. The result is
+
(2.15)
a remarkably simple formula which reduces to (2.14) when the two holes merge, with a = 0. On the other hand, if h 9 w, i.e. the two holes are far apart, the effective size of the two-hole combination is much larger than its total area would suggest if effective sizes were simply additive. We return to this question in Section IV.
98
E. 0.Tuck
FIG.4. Sketch of two-dimensional flow through a double slit in a zero-thickness plane wall.
Another reasonable generalization is to isolated slits in thick walls. This case was treated by Guiney (1972; see also Davey, 1944; Guiney et al., 1972), and we quote the solution for a slit of width 2a in a wall of thickness 2b as in Fig. 5, namely (2.16)
FIG.5. Sketch of two-dimensional flow through a right-angle-edged slit in a thick plane wall.
99
Flow through Small Holes
%
0
1.4
'
FIG. 6. Effective size of the hole of Fig. 5, as a function wall-thickness/hole-width.
of
0.2
0,h
06
0.8
1.0
1.2
1!6
the ratio
where (2.17)
and K, E, etc. are complete elliptic integrals (Abramowitz and Stegun, 1964, p. 590). A graph of s/a against b/a is given in Fig. 6; note how rapidly the effective size decreases with wall thickness.
111. Double Slits and Split Plates
A. EXACTSOLUTION
FOR THE
EFFECTIVE SIZE OF A DOUBLE SLIT
The two-dimensionalpotential problem illustrated by Fig. 4 can be solved by a number of standard procedures, e.g., by Schwartz-Christoffel mapping. It is sufficient for our purpose, however, simply to observe that a complex velocity w = $ J~ i& = f ' ( z ) of the form
satisfies all requirements. The branch of the square roots is such that, e.g., (.2
- a2)'/2
=
+ q a 2 - x2)1/2, -
on y = O * ,
1x1 < a .
E. 0.Tuck
100
I
Thus w is real for real t = x, with 1 x > b or Ix 1 < a, so that these portions of the x axis represent walls on which 4y = 0, and w is imaginary (i.e., gives & = 0 as required) on the holes y = O? ,a < I x I < b. Further, the above w possesses the required symmetry about the imaginary axis x = 0, and obeys the boundary condition
as y + + 00, which corresponds to a source of strength m. In fact if we write
and integrate, we have for the complex velocity potential
m f ( z ) = -log 2n
z
-
s
m m +J [[271
-
l(1’ - a’)- ‘/’(C2
- b’)-
”’1
d[, (3.3)
where s can now be identified with the effective size of the double slit since the integral portion of (3.3) vanishes at infinity. The quantity s is now determined by the requirement that 4 be an antisymmetric function of y, in particular vanishing over the holes a < I x I < b, and by continuity at x = b i0. Thus we have for y = 0, and x 2 b,
+
[t-’ - ((t2- a2)-”2(t2- b2)-’/’] d t , (3.4) which must vanish at x = b, so that
<
after the substitution = b/t. The integral in (3.5) can be evaluated explicitly, and we have
Flow through Small Holes
101
i.e.,
which is the result quoted as Eq. (2.15).
B. EXACT SOLUTION FOR FLOW NORMAL TO SPLIT PLATES Figure 7 illustrates a problem that is in a sense complementary to that of Fig. 4,namely flow of a stream V in the y direction normal to a plate y = 0, I x 1 < b, which has a slit I x I < a in its center. Again we can easily write
FIG. 7.
Sketch of two-dimensional flow normal to a split plate.
down by inspection the exact general solution to this problem, namely for any real constant c,
w
= -iv(z2
- a 2 ) - 1 / 2 ( ~ 2- b 2 ) - 1 / 2 ( ~ 2- ~ 2 ) .
(3.7) Now the factor i ensures the opposite behavior on the axis y = 0, to the previous case, as required, and flow symmetry about x = 0 is preserved. At infinity we have a2
+ b2 - 2c2 2z2
which represents as required a stream I/ in the y direction. The next term represents a y directed dipole of strength proportional to a2 + b2 - 2c2. The constant c appearing in (3.7) is quite arbitrary, and indeed this degree of arbitrariness is needed because the physical problem is not uniquely specified until we supply the circulation around the separate split plates. The flow region is triply connected ;hence two independent circulation constants
E. 0.Tuck
102
need to be specified in potential flow. However, symmetry rules out any net circulation around the double-plate combination. Thus the circulation around the separate plates must be equal and opposite. Let us denote by K the circulation around the right-hand plate, a < x < b. Now on integrating (3.7) to obtain the velocity potential we have f ( z )=
- il/
-WZ
r
[1 - (1’ - u ~ ) - ~ / ’ (~ ’b2)-’l2(C2- c’)] d(.
(3.9) Evaluating this expression on the right-hand plate a I xI b itself gives
4(x, 0,)
dC(4’ - ~ ’ ) - ‘ / ~ ( b-’ C2)-1’2(<2
=V
- c’),
(3.10)
Jxb
and
$(x, 0,)
= - Vb
+ I/
s,
W
d<[(<2
- a’)-’/’(p
- b’)-1/2(<2 - c’)
-
11.
(3.11) We note that, as expected, the stream function $ is constant on the plate, indicating a stream surface. The actual value of @ in (3.11) is related to the net flux f m through the hole I x I c a, and we have for a < x < b,
fm = $(-x, 0,)
-
$(x, 0,) = -2$(x, O + ) ,
(3.12)
since $ is antisymmetric with respect to x. Thus
On the other hand, the circulation IC follows from the velocity potential 4 given in (3.10). By its construction 4 is an antisymmetric function of y, vanishing for x 2 b. Thus the net change of 4 in an anticlockwise circuit around the right-hand plate is K
= 4(a, 0,)
- 4(4 0 - ) = 24(a, 0,)
b
= 2v
jad((<’
- a’)-’/’(b’
-
<2)-1/’(<2
- 2).
(3.14)
Elimination of the constant c2 between (3.13) and (3.14) gives a relationship of the form
m = AV
+ BK,
(3.15)
where A = A(a, b ) and B = B(a, b ) are definite expressions involving elliptic
103
Flow through Small Holes
integrals. Thus the net flux through the hole is available as a linear combination of the stream speed V and the circulation K , the coefficients being functions only of the geometry of the plate-hole combination. C. APPROXIMATE SOLUTION FOR SPLITPLATES
+
An approximation to the form of the coefficients A , B in (3.15) when a b may be obtained by asymptotic analysis of the elliptic integrals in (3.13), (3.14). However, the final result may also be obtained quite easily by matching techniques, with the added advantage of being valid for more general types of slits. First, however, we can observe that if c = O(b) and a z 6 b, (3.7) reduces to
+
W N -
Vc2 bz '
(3.16)
which represents a source of strength 27cVc2/b. Thus the constant c2 is directly proportional to the apparent source strength of the slit, as seen by an observer far from the center of the slit, but still close to the center of the plate. More generally, we can envisage a situation in which a plate y = O+ , I x I c b is pierced at or near its center x = O(a) 6 O(b)by a slit of a quite general character with an effective size s = O(a)as defined in Section 11. This slit could be simply I x I < a, in which case s = f a ; however it could equally well be multiple, or curved-edged, or represent thickness O(a), etc. Now the outer flow, as seen by an observer of O(b)will appear as a stream I/ past the fixed complete plate x 1 < b together with a source at (0, 0,) and a sink of equal strength at (0,0 - ) . It is the strength of this apparent source-sink pair which we have to determine. The solution to this problem is easily obtained by a Joukowski mapping z = ib([
+ i-'),
(3.17)
which converts the plate into the unit circle in the z plane, with the source at z = i and the sink at z = --i. The exact solution is then
f=
b 2
- 8 - ([ - [ - I )
m [-i + -log--27c [ + i'
(3.18)
On the boundary [ = eie, we have
z
=
b cos 8,
(3.19)
104
E. 0.Tuck
and
(3.20)
2.n Thus
and
#(x, 0,) = -$m sgn x.
(3.22)
Equation (3.22)confirms that there is flux -$m through the slit (one-half of the strength of the source, emitting into a half-plane). For matching, we shall require the behavior of this outer potential near the slit. Let us consider only the upper face, i.e., let [ + i. Then we have 2
3
b([ - i)
+
0
+ io,
.
(3.23)
and
m 2.n
f ---* V b + -log-
[ - i
2i
(3.24) >
i.e. m 2n
4 + V b + -log-
r 2b
(3.25)
where r = I z I . This must match the outer expansion of an inner solution for flow through the slit. The only additional complication relative to Section IT in describing this inner flow is the circulation about the split plates. In fact to account properly for this circulation in the exact formulation of the problem, we must insert an artificial “barrier ” over the slit, where the velocity potential 4 jumps by K. Again, assuming antisymmetry of 4 with respect to y, this means that over the location of the slit we have $(x, 0,) = +&. Now in the present approximate treatment we are confining attention to the upper face, so that if we define @ = I$ - + K , the new potential @ vanishes at y = 0, ,and its solution is as in Section 11. In particular the outer expansion of the inner solution is m 271
@ -+ -1og-
r s’
(3.26)
where s is the effective slit size, and thus q5
1 2
+-K
m r + -log-. 2n s
(3.27)
Flow through Small Holes
105
Equations (3.25) and (3.27) must match; hence m V b - -log 2Tc
1 m 2b = - - K --log 2 2n
S,
i.e., m=
n (~ 2bV) = AV log s/2b
+ BK,
(3.28)
as in (3.15), where
- 2~cb
A=--log(s/2b)’
(3.29)
n log(s/2b) .
(3.30)
and B=
Note that m = 0 when K = 2bV. This is the case in which the slit is effectively absent, the circulation 2bV being precisely that over the right half of an entire plate. Just what in practice is the correct choice for K is virtually impossible to decide, and in any case the present irrotational flow normal to a flat plate is hardly realistic. We shall however return to this question in later sections.
IV. Laws of Combination for Finite Sparse Distributions of Holes A. INTRODUCTION In this section we shall be concerned with a finite number N of holes of general shape, each hole having a supposed-known effective size, distributed over a finite portion of a plane wall in such a way that no two holes are close. That is, we assume that the minimum distance between holes is much greater than the effective size of the holes, so that the fine detail of the local flow through a particular hole is independent of the existence of a neighboring hole, although gross properties such as total flux may be dependent on the other holes. If any small number of holes are close together, we can of course group them and compute exactly an effective size of that combination, as in (2.11). The combination can then be treated as if it were a single hole for the purpose of the sparse-hole distribution. Our aim now is to obtain the effective size of the complete sparse combination of holes.
E. 0.Tuck
106
B. TWO-DIMENSIONAL ARRAYS We consider first the two-dimensional case, although this is much more complicated in its final result than the three-dimensional case. Suppose we have N holes (i.e., slits in two dimensions) spread over the plane x = 0, the jth hole having effective size s j , and being located at y = h j . An outer observer on the right at a great distance from the wall, x -P + CQ, will see a flow which appears to be generated by a row of line sources. Thus the outer solution for x > 0 is q
N
4 = -L 27l
c mj log r j + C,
j=1
where rj
=
[x’ + (y - hj)’]1/2
(4.2)
is the distance from the jth hole, and the quantities m j ,j = 1,2, . . ., N , and C are yet to be determined. In the far field of the outer solution, i.e., at a distance r
=
(x’ + Y ~ ) ’ ’ ~
(4.3)
very much greater than the total width
h = hN
-
h,
(4.4)
of the array of holes, (4.1) reduces to
where N
m = Cmj j= 1
is the total source strength and
m c = - 2-logs. z
(4.7)
Clearly s is the effective size of the whole array, the quantity we wish to determine. Turning now to an inner expansion of the outer solution (4.1) in the neighborhood of the ith hole, we have as x -,0 and y h i , -+
rj+ lhi-hjl,
(4.8)
Flow through Small Holes
107
so that
j t i
But since the ith hole has effective size si,Eq. (4.9) must match the outer expansion of the inner solution, namely (4.10) from (3.3). That is
or (4.11) where A , .= loglhi-hjl, IJ /log s i ,
j#i j = i.
(4.12)
In order to determine the array effective size s in (4.5) it is of no consequence what value we give to the total flux m, so that we can assign m or C as we please. It is convenient to set -2nC = 1, so that N
C A i j m j= 1.
(4.13)
j= 1
Once the individual source strengths mj are determined by solving the algebraic equations (4.13), we find the effective size s from (4.7), thus log s = -2nCIm = l/m, or (4.14)
C. THREE-DIMENSIONAL ARRAYS
A very similar analysis applies to the three-dimensional case, where we suppose N holes spread over the plane x = 0, the jth hole being located at ( y j , zj). Then if rij denotes the distance between the ith and jth holes, we have
E. 0. Tuck
108
to solve the same equation (4.13), but where now (4.15) and the effective size is now given by simply N
s= Emj.
(4.16)
j= 1
But the above formulation is quite inconsistent in the three-dimensional case, for we have already assumed that rij % si ,so that formally the diagonal elements of A , are one order of magnitude larger than the off-diagonals. Hence to consistent order the solution of (4.13) is
m.I = s.1
(4.17)
and the effective size of the array is N
s
csi.
=
(4.18)
i= 1
That is, effective sizes are additive in sparse three-dimensional arrays. The corresponding two-dimensional conclusion is false, as is shown below, in spite of the fact that even in the two-dimensional case the diagonal elements of (4.12) are formally (but only logarithmically) larger than the off-diagonal elements.
D.
TWO AND
THREESLITS
Before solving any particular problem it should be noted that in the two-dimensional case we can always adopt a scaling such that two of the elements of the matrix A i j vanish. Thus if we normalize the array total width h of (4.4) to unity, we have Al, = A,, = 0. In the case of two slits, N = 2, this means that A , is diagonal and we can solve immediately to give
1 m. = __ , log si I
Hence from (4.14)
i
= 1, 2.
(4.19)
Flow through Small Holes
109
Reintroducing the separation h between the slits, we have (4.20) This result simplifies in the case s1 = s2, when we have
s=m,
(4.21)
which happens to be identical with the exact result (2.15),since s1 = $w. We may also note that if the slit s2 disappears, we have ass2+0.
s+sl
(4.22)
The general three-slit case can also be analyzed quite easily. We quote here only the result for the special case where the two outer slits are symmetrically placed and equal in size (sI) while the inner slit is of size s2. Then S
-- = exp(-
h
log(s1/ h ) . IOg(s2 / h ) - log2 2 log(s,/h) + 2 log(s2/h) - 4 log 2
(4.23)
E. UNIFORM FLOWARRAYS It is of interest to consider for what choice of hole size distribution s j , j = 1, 2, ..., N , we can achieve a uniform flow through the array, i.e., the
same source strength at each hole. For three-dimensional arrays, the answer is simple. Since source strength is proportional to hole size, we use a uniform distribution of hole sizes, and their spacing is irrelevant. In two dimensions this is far from the case. If mj = m/N = constant in (4.13), we have N N CA..=-=Nlogs j= 1
m
lJ
(4.24)
or, on exponentiation, using the definition (4.12) of A,,
i.e.
SN
(4.25)
j+i
This formula supplies the required hole sizes in terms of the hole spacings.
110
E. 0.Tuck
In particular, if the mesh is uniformly spaced, i.e., hj = j A for some spacing A, we have (4.26) where sNA 1 - N K,
=
( N - l)!
(4.27)
and (7: i) is a binomial coefficient. That is, the appropriate sizes of slits for uniform flow are in proportion to the corresponding binomial coefficients, i.e., 1-2-1 for three holes, 1-3-3-1 for four, 1-4-6-41 for five, etc. Physically, the central slits need to be larger since the outer slits have less competition for flux.
V. Blockage and Permeability Coefficients A. INTRODUCTION Consider a flow such as that sketched in Fig. 8. The straight boundaries at left- and right-hand infinity are supposed to represent a uniform cylindrical pipe of arbitrary cross section in three dimensions, or a parallel-walled channel in two dimensions. For simplicity, we consider only the case when the cross-section area of the pipe is identical at the two infinities, although the case where this is not so can be treated almost as easily. We suppose that fluid is streaming at speed U through this pipe from x = -00, when it meets an obstruction, change of cross section, etc. The resulting nonuniform flow ultimately smooths itself out, until by the time it reaches x = +a,it must again represent a stream U , if the two crosssection areas are the same, as assumed. We are concerned with the residual effect of the obstruction on this uniform stream, as seen in the far field of the obstruction.
FIG.8. Sketch of flow in a pipe or channel with obstructions.
Flow through Small Holes
111
The appropriate measure of this far-field effect is a blockage coefficient C defined as follows. The velocity potential at both infinities can clearly be represented by
4 = Ux + constant,
(54 where the “constant of integration is only partly arbitrary. Clearly we can assign any one constant in a velocity potential arbitrarily, but once having done so, e.g., at x = -co, the corresponding constant at x = +a is uniquely determined by the geometry of the complete flow pattern, i.e., by the obstruction. It is possible to choose the arbitrary portion of the constant in (5.1) such that the remaining constant is antisymmetric at the two infinities, ie., (5.1) becomes ”
4 + U(x f C)
as x + kco. (54 The constant C in (5.2), having the dimensions of length, is called the blockage coefficient of the obstruction. Its reciprocal 1/C can be called the permeability of the obstruction since it is clear that C = 0 or 1/C = co when there is no obstruction, and C = co or 1/C = 0 when the flow is completely blocked. Similar far-field measures of the effect of departures from uniformity of a pipe have been introduced in other fields, e.g., as the “electromagnetic susceptance ” in waveguide theory (Marcuvitz, 1951). In addition, C has in some cases a very simple electrostatic significance (Lamb, 1898) in terms of the change in capacitance of a parallel-plate condenser due to insertion of an infinite “grid ’’ of disturbances, such that the “walls of the original pipes remain as lines of force. There is a strong analogy between the blockage coefficient C of an obstruction in a pipe and the effective size s of a hole in a wall. Both have the dimensions of a length, and tend to take values comparable with the actual size of the object they measure. Both convey gross information about the object into its far field, thereby “washing out ” the unnecessary detail of its geometry and summarizing the nature of the object (as seen by an observer far from it) in terms of a single number. Both manifest themselves as additive constants in a velocity potential, and therefore do not contribute directly to velocities in steady flow. Both are readily computable for arbitrary object geometry with present-day computers. ”
B. RECTANGULAROBSTACLES
A typical case is a rectangular-sectioned cylinder placed broadside to the stream in the center of a channel, as in Fig. 9. Clearly we could equally consider the central streamline to define a new channel wall, the problem then becoming that for a rectangular protuberance on a wall. The latter case
E. 0. Tuck
112
*+
FIG.9. Sketch of channel flow obstructed by a cylinder of rectangular section normal to the flow.
(using the lower half of Fig. 9) models flow over a ship section, and was studied for that reason by Flagg and Newman (1971). The blockage coefficient can be expressed in terms of elliptic integrals. Figure 10 shows curves of C/h against d/h for various values of b/d, where the channel is of width 2h, and the rectangle has dimensions 2b x 2d.
I I
---
I I
Euct Asymptotic
FIG. 10. Blockage coefficient for the rectangular obstruction of Fig. 9, compared with the leading term C = hh/(h - d ) of the asymptotic expansion for small clearance h - d .
Flow through Small Holes
113
Figure 10 also shows asymptotic results for the case h - d G h of very small clearance between the rectangle and the channel walls. The asymptotic result is E
4~+ -2h E 7c
2
+ %e4 + O ( E ~ ) (5.3) 907c
where E = (h - d)/h. This result was obtained by Taylor (1971, 1973) by matching techniques, although Flagg and Newman (1971) also obtained a similar result by direct approximation of the elliptic integrals in their exact formula. Note that C + 00 as E -+0, when the flow is completely blocked. The dominant term in (5.3) is (5.4) a result which can be obtained easily, as follows. Since all the flux 2hU must pass through the narrow passage between the rectangle and the walls, it must do so at a speed hU/(h - d) for mass conservation. That is, assuming antisymmetry of the velocity potential about x = 0, the potential in the narrow passage is
(“Ix,
4 = h-d
(5.5)
which takes the value [bh/(h - d)]U at the corner x = b. Now when we come to match the emerging narrow-passage flow into the large-passage this large constant will clearly channel flow at velocity U to x = +a, contribute to, and in fact dominate the constant UC in (5.2) at x = +a, leading to (5.4). The above argument is only superficial. Taylor (1971, 1973) gives a more careful and systematic derivation, in which the matching is carried out explicitly via an “edge” region, where the narrow passage opens out into a quarter-plane, as in Fig. 11. In fact, the geometry of this edge region need not be that of a perfect right angle, and Taylor shows that the result (5.3) can be generalized to C h
--
bd 2 - - ~ o ~ ( L , E+ ) a,E2 h(h - d ) z
+
A.,E~
+ o(P)
(5.6)
where A,, A,, and A4 are dimensionless constants associated with a conformal mapping from the actual corner geometry (generalized from Fig. 11 to allow curves, etc.) into an upper half-plane. The conformal mapping when the corner is right-angled as in Fig. 11 is given later [Eq. (7.9)].
E. 0.Tuck
114
,
I
I
I
I
,
I
,
I
C
'
FIG. 11. Sketch of edge flow for a parallel-gap stream emerging into a quarter-plane, around a right-angle corner.
c. BLOCKAGE BY WALLS WITH HOLES Another example is when a pipe is almost completely blocked by a plane wall at x = 0, of thickness much less than the pipe radius, flow taking place only through one or more small holes of size also much less than pipe radius. In this case we may establish a direct connection between the blockage coefficient and the effective size of the holes. For example, suppose we have a two-dimensional flow in a channel of width D as in Fig. 12, which is almost blocked by a wall at x = 0 with a single small hole at x = 0, y = b. The detailed geometry of the hole can, as usual, be arbitrary, so long as we know its effective size s, and s 4 D. The situation discussed in the introduction and sketched in Fig. 1 is of course a special case of the present problem. The outer solution for x $ s is describable in terms of an apparent line source emitting fluid from the location (0, b) of the hole, with velocity potential 7T n $I = U - 9 log 4 sinh-(z - ib) sinh- (z + ib) + UC, (5.7) 7t 20 20
1
[
(e.g., Guiney et al., 1972).As x --+ + co,this potential tends at an exponential rate to a uniform stream, namely
4 + U ( X + C) + O(e-"x/D),
(5.8)
so that the constant C in (5.7) can be identified with the blockage coefficient. On the other hand, as r = z - ib I + 0,
I
n =
m log r/s, 2n
~
(5.9) (5.10)
Flow through Small Holes
115
ty
FIG.12. Sketch of channel flow through a small hole of arbitrary geometry in a blocking wall of small thickness.
where
m
=
2UD
(5.11)
and m
(5.12)
2.n
Equation (5.11) merely expresses conservation of mass, all of the flux m/2 produced by the apparent source eventually arriving at x = 00 as a stream U , with net flux U D in the channel of width D. Equation (5.10) shows that this outer flow matches with the inner flow through the hole, providing Cis chosen so that (5.12) is satisfied, i.e.,
+
(5.13) Equation (5.13) is the required relationship between hole effective size s and channel blockage coefficient C. Note that since s G D, we have (5.14) Although (5.14) is hardly of numerical significance, it is worth noting that the position b of the hole plays a relatively minor role in determining the blockage coefficient. In the special case of a centered (b = ill)sharp-edged hole I y - i D 1 < a of width 2% we have s = +Q, and
c=
D .na --log-. . n D
(5.15)
E. 0. Tuck
116
This result is valid only for u G D, of course. However, it is worth noting that it can also be obtained as the limit u/D 0 of the exact solution for this case (Sedov, 1965, p. 148) namely -+
D na C = - - log sin -,
(5.16)
D
7r.
which is valid for arbitrary a/D. Generalization of the above result to the case of three-dimensional flow in cylindrical pipes is quite straightforward in principle, but difficult in practice because of the apparent need to construct the potential analogous to (5.7) for a point source inside the pipe. If we suppose that the potential for a unit source at (x,y, z ) = (<, r, [) is written as G(x,y, z ; 5, q, c), then clearly (5.7) is replaced by
4 = (2AU) . G(x, Y , 2 ; 0, vl, 5) + uc,
(5.17)
if the hole is located at (0, q, [). In (5.17), A is the cross-section area of the pipe, the appropriate multiple of G being chosen so that the flux produced is precisely AU as required. That is, G must have the property G -+
X
2A
+ constant,
x + +m.
(5.18)
It is appropriate to normalize the Green’s function G by setting the constant in (5.18) equal to zero, in which case C in (5.17) can be identified with the blockage coefficient. On the other hand, if we now consider the behavior of G near the unit source point, we have as r = (x’ ( y - q)’ ( z - [)’)’/’ 0,
+
G -+
-
+
1 47r.r
~
+ constant.
-+
(5.19)
We no longer have the freedom to choose this constant as zero, and must write 1 G-+--+-, 47r.r
1 4ns1
(5.20)
where s1 is a constant of the dimensions of a length which depends on the nature of the cross-section curve of the cylindrical pipe, and is of the order of magnitude of its typical linear dimension, i.e., s1 =
O(A”2).
(5.21)
Note that s1 is a property of the pipe geometry alone, and it is quite independent of the hole geometry.
Flow through Small Holes Thus as r
--f
117
0, the inner expansion of the outer potential gives 1
4 + 2AU( - -
(5.22) (5.23)
where (5.24) Again, (5.23) allows matching with the inner flow through the hole, and identifies s with the three-dimensional effective hole size. Equation (5.24) then determines the blockage coefficient as (5.25) But now we note that, since by assumption the hole size s is much smaller than the typical linear cross-section size A’’’ = O(s,), a simplification of (5.25) analogous to (5.14) applies, namely C=
A (1 + O(sA2ns
~
’’’>>.
(5.26)
This result is, however, of much more numerical significance than (5.14) since the relative error is asymptotically much smaller. Physically, Eq. (5.26) shows that in three dimensions the blockage coefficient of a small hole in a pipe is almost independent of the details of the cross-section shape, and of the placement of the hole in the pipe, depending dominantly only on the cross-sectional area of the pipe and on the effective size of the hole. In spite of this conclusion, there may arise circumstances in which, for example, one may wish to compare the blockage coefficients of pipes of varying cross-section shape but the same area A, or of holes in different positions. In that case it is the quantity s1 that is of primary interest, and in Section VI we give an example of its computation for a rectangular pipe.
D. APPLICATION TO POROUS SCREENS OR MEMBRANES The method of images indicates that, once we have solved for flow in a channel of width D,over a symmetric obstable at its center, we have also solved for flow through an infinitely extended grid or grating of such obstacles, spaced uniformly at separation D. A similar conclusion applies to
118
E. 0. Tuck
any three-dimensional pipe for which the image system can be constructed, e.g. a pipe of rectangular cross section, as considered in Section VI. The interpretation of 1/C as a permeability coefficient is of special interest for such an obstacle, which can be thought of as a porous membrane or screen. The boundary condition (5.2) applies now at distances from the screen which are large compared with its own thickness and the mesh spacing. Indeed, if we are interested in applications of the screen at such distances only, then (5.2) is an equality as an approximation to this far-field velocity potential, i.e.
4 = Ux + UC sgn x
(5.27)
is the far-field potential of the screen. This potential 4 possesses an apparent jump of magnitude
A 4 = 2UC
(5.28)
across the screen. Alternatively, we may write 1 U=-A4, 2c
(5.29)
and interpret this as a statement that the velocity U through the screen is proportional to the potential jump across it, multiplied by the permeability coefficient 1/C. The above takes on a particular significance in unsteady flows of small amplitude, for which the linearized Bernoulli equation p = -p- 84
(5.30)
at
suggests that pressure jumps and potential jumps are related. Thus (5.29) implies on time differentiation that (5.31) showing how the acceleration through the screen is proportional to the pressure jump across it, the constant of proportionality being related to the permeability of the screen. Because of the dependence on acceleration, the constant 1/2pC should perhaps be called an inertial permeability. Equation (5.31) is quite closely analogous to the Darcy law of flow in porous media (Philip, 1970; Morse and Ingard, 1968, p. 252) which would indicate that the velocity is related to the pressure jump, thus “
U = -kAp
”
(5.32)
Flow through Small Holes
119
where the coefficient k is the Darcy constant (or “viscous permeability ”) and measures dissipative (viscous) effects in the flow through the hole. One may speculate that a good empirical approach to inclusion of both inertial and viscous permeabilities would be to add the two effects, i.e. to set Ap
=
-2pCU - k-‘U.
(5.33)
In the special case of time-sinusoidal oscillations, with e - iut time dependence, this simply means that inertial effects are accounted for by modifying the viscous Darcy law (5.32) by use of a “complex” and frequencydependent Darcy constant k
=
k[l
+ 2pCk(-ia)]-l.
(5.34)
The resulting constant of proportionality between pressure jump and normal velocity is equivalent to the “acoustic impedance” (Morse and Ingard, 1968, Chapter 9) of the screen, although (like the “acoustic conductivity” mentioned in Section 11), its definition is quite independent of the particular application to acoustics. An opposite viewpoint to (5.34)is that dissipation is accounted for empirically in equations such as (5.28) by use of a complex, frequency-dependent, blockage coefficient
c‘ = c + [ 2 p k ( - i a ) ] - l .
(5.35)
We thus have at our disposal techniques for estimating theoretically at least the “reactive” or inertial portion of the impedance of a screen, in terms of its geometry. The “resistive ” or viscous portion is usually obtained experimentally; however, techniques such as that of Section X,B could allow simultaneous numerical determination of both reactive and resistive portions, with the advantage that frequency-dependent effects on both portions would be obtained. Finally, it should be noted that, although the above refers only to regular arrays of holes, in the case of random arrays the basic equations should still hold in the mean.
VI. Green’s Function for a Rectangular Pipe A. LINEARRAYOF UNITPOINTSOURCES Our aim in this subsection is to find the potential for a singly infinite array of point sources, each of unit strength, the kth source being located at (ka, 0, 0) on the x axis. By symmetry, the solution will also apply to the case of a single source at the origin between plane walls at x = ?$a.
E. 0. Tuck
120
If we simply sum the corresponding isolated source potentials, the resulting series diverges everywhere. It is necessary to subtract a constant to guarantee convergence, and the required sum is then given by
+ J(x + ka)’ + y 2 + z2 -~ ka/’ (6.1) The last term -2/ka cancels the large-k behavior of the point sources and gives a convergent series. It also ensures that the series in (6.1) actually vanishes at the origin, i.e. that
+
as , / x 2 y’ + z’ -+ 0. Thus, not only is the near-origin behavior that of a unit point source, but there is no “constant” in the difference between the total potential and that of a point source. It is convenient to write the potential (6.1) in nondimensional form as
where
.(X,
R) -
1
+i(
Jm
k=l
1 J(k - X ) 2 + R 2
1 + J(k + X)’ + R’
-
(6.4) No difficulty arises in computing this function by direct summation on the computer. In particular, we have need for the value at X = 0, namely,
This function is shown in Fig. 13. It is physically obvious that, at large distances from the x axis, the above array of unit point sources will appear indistinguishable from a line source of equivalent strength l/a per unit length along the x axis. Thus we expect
,/-
1
4 + 2% log
Jm+ constant,
121
Flow through Small Holes
R
n
I
1.4
I
1.6
I
1.8
FIG. 13. Velocity potential for a line array of discrete point sources, compared with the line-source far-field asymptote.
as.-/, -+ 00. In terms of the nondimensional potential @, this means that we expect that as R + 00 @ ( X , R ) + - 2 log R
+ K1 = @,(R)
(6-7)
for some constant K,. In fact K1 = 2(10g 2 - y )
= 0.231868.. . .
(6.8)
It is probable by analogy with similar channel-flow results [e.g., Eq. (5.8)] that the error 0 - Dmin (6.7) is exponentially small in R. In fact Fig. 13 shows how extremely rapidly + a, the error being only about 1.1 % at R = 1 and 0.04% at R = 2.
B. RECTANGULARPLANAR ARRAYOF POINTSOURCES We can now use the previous results to obtain the potential for a doubly infinite array of point sources over the (x,y ) plane, with spacing a in the x direction and b in the y direction. This is then equivalent, by symmetry, to
E. 0. Tuck
122
the case of a single isolated point source in a rectangular pipe of dimensions a x b. The procedure is to take the line-array solution of the previous section and sum over an infinite number of such arrays distributed with spacing b in the y direction. Once again convergence difficulties arise, however, and we must subtract suitable constants before summing. Thus we write
This series is strongly analogous to (6.1), the function @ playing the same role in (6.9) as the unit-source potential in (6.1). Again the constant -2@(0, jb/a) not only ensures convergence but also ensures that (6.2) is still true near the origin. Given a good subroutine for @ ( X ,R), there is no difficulty involved in computation of the complete potential 6 from (6.9). However, we are really only interested here in the behavior on the z axis, especially for large z. Thus we have
(6.10) (6.11) where 27c
- -Y(Z, P ) = CD(0, Z )
P
+ 2 {qo, Jm) - CD(0,jB)).
(6.12)
j= 1
+ co,namely a It is again clear physically what we should expect as z stream whose magnitude 1/2ab generates exactly one-half of the total flux of the unit source. Thus (b + ( 2 ~ b )'(z -
+ C1)
(6.13)
co,where the constant C , will be a contributor to the blockage as z -+ icoefficient. Note that C1 = Cl(a, b), and has dimensions of length. If we normalize with respect to the geometric mean &6 of the sides of the pipe, we have
c, = JabYdP),
(6.14)
Flow through Small Holes
123
where the normalized coefficient y1 depends only on the aspect ratio /3 = b/a of the pipe. We also expect by symmetry that Cl(a, b)
=
(6.15)
Cl(h a);
hence
Yl(P-7 = Yl(P).
(6.16)
In terms of the dimensionless potential Y , (6.13) and (6.14) imply Y(Z, B) +. Z + pl’zyl(p) as Z + 00. (6.17) This result may also be established analytically, as follows. Thus - 2n
P
m
=
@(O,Z)+ 2 C
j= 1
{ @ ( O , J V )- Q&))
m
where
The series in (6.18) can be summed explicitly,? and we have
f log( 1 +);
j= 1
= log(%)
(6.20)
= nu - log u - log 27c
t For Eqs. (6.8) and (6.20),I am indebted
+ log(1 -
to Dr. Jane Pitman.
(6.21)
124
E. 0. Tuck
Thus with u
=
Z/B, (6.18) gives
or Y
-,Z + constant,
(6.22)
as required by (6.17). The constant in (6.22) must equal /31/2yl. Thus
yl(p) = -7.1c p
2
[
1K log- B - 27t 2 2 1 .
(6.23)
Since K , is readily obtained from (6.19), Eq. (6.23) in fact provides the easiest means of evaluating yl(/3). The series in (6.19) converges extremely Figure 14 shows rapidly, in view of the exponential convergence of @ to the computed variation of y,@) with fi. The property (6.16)is verified by the computations. Note that y1 is negative except for quite severely “squashed ” rectangles with P < 0.14. Finally, we should note that (apart from the coordinates z and x being interchanged) the Green’s function required for the computation of the
I \
0 ’
I
0.6
I
0.0
I
1.0
I 1.2
-D.2-
-0.k-
-0.6-
FIG.14. Contributionto the blockage coefficient for a small hole in a rectarigular-sectioned pipe, as a function of the ratio between the sides of the rectangle.
Flow through Small Holes
125
blockage coefficient C of a small hole in a rectangular tube is obtained by subtracting the constant C1/2ab which appears at infinity via (6.13). Thus
using (6.2). Hence the quantity s1 defined in (5.20) is given by (6.25) The actual correction (5.25) to the bIockage coefficient is proportional to - l/sl, and hence to y1 itself. Hence Fig. 14 indicates that for p > 0.14, the true blockage coefficient is less than that predicted by the first-order result (5.26).
VII. Vehicles Moving Close to a Plane Surface
A. INTRODUCTION There are many fields of application where a body, usually a vehicle of some kind, is moving close to a nearly plane surface, usually the ground. The classical situation is of course that of the automobile or train, whose clearance to the ground is only a small fraction of its lateral dimensions. Various problems in ship hydrodynamics also come into this category, with the plane surface either as the water bottom if the water is shallow, or the side surface of a canal if the ship is moving close to the side. Ground effects on airplanes at takeoff or landing are somewhat similar, although the clearance between the lower surface and the ground is comparable with, rather than small compared to, the lateral dimensions of the vehicle. A rather less obvious application is to architectural aerodynamics (see, e.g., Lighthill and Silverleaf, 1971), especially where there is a passageway or terrace underneath a large solid building. Not surprisingly, the published literature on all of these problems is highly scattered, but it is aIso in most cases rather inadequate, many proprietary studies not being published openly. This is particularly true of the automobile-aerodynamics literature. However, some recent published papers of note are included in symposia edited by Pershing (1968), SciborRylski (1969), and Sachs (1970); further references include Barth (1956), Morelli (1964), Tetens (1966), and others mentioned specifically below. In a field of such significant commercial importance as automobile aerodynamics, it is hardly surprising that little impact has been made by theory,
126
E. 0. Tuck
compared with the more obviously, but not necessarily more rationally, justifiable expedient of wind-tunnel testing. A very interesting practical difficulty has however long haunted the model-car experimenters, namely how should one model the ground in a wind tunnel? Is it satisfactory to use a fixed plane surface beneath a fixed model, or to use a double model with the “ground” as a plane of symmetry, or must one go to the expense and mechanical difficulty of a moving belt beneath a fixed model, in order to simulate the relative motion between car and ground? The answer, as in so many modelling situations, is not at all clear-cut; it all depends on how careful one is, on what one wishes to achieve, and on how much one is prepared to spend. This is hardly the place to discuss such experimental details further; instead see Heald (1934), Walker (1958), Haynes (1960), and the symposia mentioned above. However, it is rather interesting in the context of the present theoretical article to observe that the difference between results (e.g., for drag or lift coefficients)obtained by any of the ground-modeling methods can only be a measure of the importance of the flow (especially of the development of the boundary layer) beneath the car. If there is no significant difference, the rate of growth of the boundary layer beneath the car is not a significant factor relative to that above it. Conversely, if there is a significant difference, then what goes on underneath the car is of fundamental importance, and, for example, further theoretical study of small-gap flows, such as attempted in this article, is indicated. Finally, one should perhaps take the general lack of smoothness of the underside of most cars as an indication of lack of interest by manufacturers in under-vehicle aerodynamics, this being confirmed by the almost complete absence of published studies on this specific question, an exception being that of Carr (1965). This may indicate that under-vehicle aerodynamics is indeed not important in practice. However, small forward-facing airfoils or scoops beneath the front bumper seem to have been used with some success (e.g., Marcell and Romberg, 1970), so that again this question is perhaps still open. In the absence of a specifically lift-inducing character to the vehicle, there will be a tendency for any vehicle to be drawn toward the plane surface, so long as flow actually takes place beneath it. This is a simple Venturi effect, the velocity of the fluid “trapped” at the front of the vehicle and forced to pass beneath it being quite high relative to the vehicle speed, and the resulting low or suction pressure having the dominant effect on the lateral force. The important theoretical question is to determine how much fluid is so trapped, and we discuss this question further below. The opposite case of a force directed away from the wall can occur, either when the body is itself inducing lift, or when the clearance is so small that viscosity prevents the above-mentioned high-velocity flow from taking
Flow through Small Holes
127
place, the pressure beneath the vehicle being instead a “base or separation pressure which is greater than the suction pressure for the completepenetration case. The lifting-vehicle case is of course typified by an airplane in ground effect, and it is clear that any vehicle already subject to a lift force directed away from the ground will sustain an even greater lift as it more closely approaches the ground, its vortex system being augmented (ultimately doubled) by the imaging effect of the ground. References on lifting vehicles in ground effect include Bagley (1960) and Widnall and Barrows (1970). In the two-dimensional case a direct numerical computation of the effect of circulation around bodies in irrotational flow close to the ground was provided by Tuck (1971b). For an automobilelike profile with a realistic ground clearance, the lift force away from the ground could be written in the form ”
F
=
(-O.2l)(+pU2B)
+ (1.26)(pU~)+ (-0.69)(+p~’/B),
(7.1) where B is the base length of the profile and K the circulation around it, taken here as positive when the circulation is from front to back along the top of the vehicle and from back to front under the vehicle. The term in ~ U K shows a 26% augmentation due to ground effect of the standard KuttaJoukowski lift. At zero circulation, we observe a toward-ground force, but as soon as we retard the high under-vehicle velocity by use of a small circulation K > 0.08UB, the sign of F becomes positive. Unfortunately, purely theoretical considerations can provide little information about the value of K , for a body as bluff as a car. An interesting speculation, however, is that it may be desirable to design cars with K = 0, if that is possible. Thus, not only is positive lift undesirable for cars, but in the real three-dimensional case any sectionwise circulation must manifest itself in the form of trailing vortices and hence an induced drag. Ship hydrodynamics also provides examples of both toward-surface and away-from-surface forces. The latter situation is perhaps only rather remotely related to the present discussion since it applies to a zero-gap case, namely low-speed “squat ” of forward-moving ships. At low speeds the free surface behaves hydrodynamically like a rigid plane surface on which the pressure is atmospheric. This is analogous to a “completely blocked” gap with a base pressure equal to the free stream value. Since the velocity over the central portion of the bottom surface of the ship exceeds the free stream value, so that the pressure there is less than atmospheric, the net effect is a downward, or away-from-surfaceforce, inducing a tendency to sinkage ” or squat. A bibliography on the squat problem is given by Tuck and Taylor (1970). Squat itself can be augmented in very shallow water as a result of a “
128
E. 0. Tuck
" toward-surface " Venturi force to the water bottom, although this particular effect is only really significant in lateral movements of the ship. Such lateral movements could be induced by incident waves from abeam (Tuck and Taylor, 1970; Beck and Tuck, 1972), or by docking or other maneuvers (Newman, 1969; Tuck, 1974). In fact (Tuck, 1974) in a sideways maneuver it is at least theoretically possible for the ship to actually become unstable, any small downward movement so reducing the clearance that the resulting increase in squat exceeds the increase in buoyancy, and the ship is forced further downward. A significant theoretical aspect to all of the above-referenced studies on lateral movement of ships in shallow water is the role played by the blockage coefficient C, as defined in Section V. In fact C varies from station to station along the length of the ship, indicating the extent to which various stations block the fluid from passing beneath it. The theoretical analysis (e.g., Newman, 1969) then requires us to determine what proportion of the flow passes under the ship, and what proportion moves lengthwise until it reaches a station of greater clearance (i.e., lower blockage coefficient C). The analysis leads to an integral equation analogous to Prandtl's lifting-line equation, with C playing the role of the chord at a given spanwise coordinate. Toward-surface forces due to forward motion are significant for maneuvering problems of ships near to the side walls of canals (Newman, 1972), or for underwater vehicles close to the bottom or at low speed close to the free surface (Newman, 1965). Similar problems occur when two vehicles of any kind pass each other, e.g. cars and trucks on a freeway, high-speed trains (see papers in Scibor-Rylski, 1969), or ships in restricted waterways (Tuck and Newman, 1974).
B. VEHICLESWITH COMPLETE GAPPENETRATION In this subsection we extend work of Tuck (1971b) on flow over threedimensional bodies of general upper-surface shape, whose lower surface is nearly plane and is situated close (relative to the upper-surface lateral dimensions) to a nearly plane ground surface. This work is presented for its theoretical interest as an example of intuitive matching, although applications to automobile and train aerodynamics are not too distant. A typical flow situation is as sketched in Fig. 15. We must attempt to resolve the " dilemma " faced by a fluid particle originally situated upstream near the ground. As it meets the vehicle, does it pass underneath, or does it go over the top of the vehicle, or around its side? If some fluid does indeed pass underneath the vehicle, then in the limit as
Flow through Small Holes
129
FIG. 15. Sketch of flow over and under a vehicle with a small clearance to the ground.
the gap tends to zero, the flow seen by an observer near the front of the vehicle must appear like that of a sink located at the projected point of intersection of the vehicle with the ground. More generally, an outer observer located anywhere not near the gap must see a velocity potential of the following form
where 4,(x, y, z ) is the classical “double-body’’ potential for flow over the original vehicle plus its mirror image in the ground plane z = 0. That is, &, is the ultimate limiting potential as the gap tends to zero. The integral part of Eq. (7.2) must tend to zero as the gap size tends to zero, and represents a distribution of sources of varying strength m per unit length, over the closed projected intersection curve r between the vehicle and the ground, which has equation x = X(l), y = Y(1),z = 0, or in vector form
r = iX(1) + jY(l)
=
R(1).
(7.3)
Also G ( x , y, z ; X , Y , 2 ) is the Green’s function for the upper surface of the body, being the potential at (x, y, z ) for a unit source at ( X , Y , Z ) in the presence of the double body. We anticipate that rn is negative near the front of the vehicle and positive near its rear. Since G is a unit-source potential, it must have the property that as (x, y , z ) ( X , y , 4, -+
G-+-
1
47111 -
R(1)I
+ GI,
(7.4)
where
) r - R(l)IZ = (x - X)’
+ (y - Y)’ + ( z - Z)’,
(7.5)
E . 0.Tuck
130
and G I is bounded. In order to match with an under-vehicle flow, we shall need the “edge” behavior of 4, i.e. its limit as the point (x, y , z ) moves close to the curve r. This limit is obtainable as in the “slender-body-theory” literature (e.g.,Tuck, 1964). Suppose we consider flow in a plane normal to r at a fixed value 1 = I’ of the arc-length coordinate 1. If r is a plane polar coordinate centered on r in that plane, the slender-body analysis predicts that as r + 0
where?
+
1
m(l)G,(X(I’), Y(l’),0; X(1), Y ( $ 0) dl. (7.7)
It is important to note thatf(1) is of the same order of magnitude as m(l),and is therefore small compared with &. The flow near such an edge will be two dimensional in the plane normal to r since rates of change parallel to r must be small compared to rates of change normal to r. Thus the edge flow near the rear of the vehicle, for example, is two-dimensional flow as in Fig. 11, from the gap into a quarterplane. The actual flux emerging into this quarter plane is thus im(1)at arc 1. If the gap thickness at r is 6(1), this must correspond to a velocity in the gap normal to r of
That is (as was in any case obvious physically), the emerging flux is of the order of the gap size times the emerging normal velocity. The two-dimensional flow in the edge region must in general be solved numerically. However, if the edge is right-angled as in Fig. 11, this can be accomplished by the conformal mapping a
2W)
(t + iz) = 2
J m - 2 log(&a
+ 1) + log 5,
(7.9)
which maps the (5, z ) plane at arc 1 normal to r with origin at r, into the upper half [-plane, with right-angle corner at [ = - 1. The edge limit (7.6) of ?This result was obtained by Mr. M. Peake.
Flow through Small Holes
131
the outer solution now becomes the outer boundary condition for the edge solution at r = co,or = + co,or I [ = co,and the conformal mapping (7.9) then predicts that as 5 + - co or I I + 0,
<
I
(7.10) where V is given by (7.8). The only difference for more general edge geometries would be that the coefficient 4/ne of 6 in (7.10)would be replaced by a numerically determined unit-order dimensionless constant. The velocity V obtained as the outer limit (in the gap as 5 + - co) of the edge flow near r must match an inner flow under the vehicle nor close to r. The equation to be satisfied by the velocity potential under the vehicle depends on the smoothness of the under-vehicle surface and the bottom. In fact the problem is exactly the same as for steady shallow-water flow in rivers, etc., and the standard Friedrichs (1948) stretching procedure can be used to show that 4 satisfies (7.11) where 6(x, y ) is the actual gap size at the location (x, y) inside r. The simplest case is of course that of a uniform gap 6 = constant, in which (7.11) reduces to the Laplace equation in the (x,y ) plane. The boundary conditions for (7.11) are supplied by matching with the inner expansion of the edge flow, i.e. with (7.10), which implies that on r, m
46
4 + 4 0 +f+ --log271 ne
(7.12)
and (7.13) since 5 is a coordinate normal to r in the (x,y ) plane. But for general r, 4, and a4/dn on are of the same order of magnitude with respect to gap size 6, so that V is asymptotically independent of the gap size 6 and (7.12) simplifies to
4 = 40(X(4Y ( 4 0 )
(7.14)
on r. Thus, to leading order, it is quite unnecessary to consider the sourcedistribution part of (7.1) in order to determine the under-vehicle flow. We
132
E. 0.Tuck
need merely solve the generalized two-dimensional interior Dirichlet problem for Eq. (7.11) inside r,subject to given values (7.14) of 4 on r.If we then require the velocity I/ normal to r,or equivalently the source strength m, we obtain it subsequently from (7.13) and (7.8).
C. VERTICAL FORCE ON A SLENDER HALF-BODY OF REVOLUTION We now apply the previous result to the case when the upper surface of the vehicle is half of a body of revolution with equation r = ro(x), 05x I L, the body being slender in the sense that r = O ( E ). L, where E is a small parameter. Note however that the gap size 6 is assumed to be smaller again than the lateral dimension EL. The velocity potential in the absence of the gap is given for Y = O(EL)by the axisymmetric slender-body solution for the double body, namely (Tuck, 1964),
40(x,r ) = ux+
log
+ qx)+
0(&4),
(7.15)
where
a(.) = UrO(x)rb(x)= O ( E ~ ) ,
(7.16)
and
Hence, to obtain the gap flow, we are required to solve a Dirichlet problem in the (x,y ) plane, y I ro(x), with boundary condition as in (7.14), namely,
4
=
#o(x, r o ( x ) )= Ux
+ u(x)log ro(x) + b(x) + O ( E ~ ) (7.18)
on y = ro(x). We shall use here only the constant-gap case 6(x, y ) = constant, when (7.11) reduces to Laplace’s equation. The solution is obtained as a power series in y of the form
4
= @(x)
- +y2CD”(x)+ &y“CD‘”’(x)
+ ---,
(7.19)
where, in order to satisfy (7.18), we must have
CD
- 3r;W
+ 1 r 4 @ ” ”+ ... = Ux + a log ro + b + .... 24 0
(7.20)
Thus
@(x) = Ux
+ a(.)
log ro(x)
+ b(x) + O ( E ~ ) ,
(7.2 1) (7.22)
Flow through Small Holes
133
The x component of velocity is +x
=
aqx) + 0 ( E 4 )
+ (a log ro)’ + b‘ + O ( E ~ ) arb = U + a’ log ro + b’ + + O(E~), = U
~
(7.23)
YO
and the y component is Note that the x component is dominated by the free stream, but that the perturbation from the stream is O(E’), an order of magnitude greater than the y component of velocity. The pressure under the vehicle is thus given by pgap= pm - pU[a’ log ro
+ b‘ + Urb’] + O(e4).
(7.25)
On the other hand, on top of the vehicle the x velocity component is
4x = U + a’ log ro + b‘ + O(c4),
(7.26)
and the radial velocity is a
4r = -r + O ( E ~=) Urb = O(E),
(7.27)
so that the pressure is ptop= pa - pU(a’ log ro
+ b’) - +pU2rf + o ( E ~ ) .
(7.28)
Since the pressure under the vehicle does not depend on y, and that on top does not depend on the polar angle, the net upward force on an element of length dx is
(7.29) giving a total force (7.30)
which is directed downward. The ability of a real viscous fluid to achieve such a downward force is open to question, the result depending essentially on penetration into the gap of the very high velocities at the side of the vehicle. It is conceivable however that such a situation could prevail for high-speed trains, and indeed that the resultant downward force could be undesirably large. It is therefore
134
E. 0. Tuck
of interest to observe that the downward force is minimized in the sense of the calculus of variations by the choice
ro(x)~x2~3
(7.31)
which may represent some kind of optimum shape for a high-speed locomotive nose.
VIII. Water-Wave Transmission through Holes in Walls
A. INTRODUCTION AND EXACTSOLUTIONS This topic represents the original stimulation for the present author’s interest in the whole class of “small-hole’’ problems treated in this chapter, and indeed the computation of the water-wave transmission coefficient does provide an excellent example of the use of intuitive matching and the effective-size concept. The problem in two dimensions is basically to compute what fraction of an incident plane water wave gets through a barrier which is in some way permeable. This fraction is called the transmission coefficient z. Clearly z vanishes for an impermeable wall and takes a unit value in the absence of any barrier. Between, we expect z to depend on the geometry of the obstruction and also on the wavelength of the incident waves. The problem is obviously of some practical importance for breakwater design, and there is a considerable engineering literature on the subject of permeable breakwaters (e.g., LeMthautt, 1958, 1971). Exact treatments of this problem, as a boundary-value problem in the classical theory of infinitesimal water waves (Wehausen and Laitone, 1960), were given for vertical walls of zero thickness with arbitrary hole distributions by Lewin (1963) and Mei (1966). In neither case were computed results obtained for transmission coefficients, with nontrivial distributions of holes. However, it was possible to rederive some simple solutions already obtained, e.g., the surface-piercing barrier treated by Ursell (1947), in which the “hole” extends to an infinite depth, and the complementary case when the barrier extends from infinite depth to a point below the free surface (i.e., the “hole” includes the free surface) treated by Dean (1945). The problem of a single submerged slit was reexamined by Porter (1972), who used essentially the formulation of Lewin (1963),and simultaneously by Guiney (1972; see also Guiney et al., 1972) who adapted Ursell’s (1947) procedure. Figure 16 shows Guiney’s computations of 1 z 1, plotted against the ratio a = h/3, between the depth h of the center of the slit and the wavelength I of the incident waves, for various values of a parameter v = slit
Flow through Small Holes
0
0.05
0.10
135
0.15
0.20
hlh FIG. 16. Comparison between exact water-wave transmission coefficient (Guiney, 1972, solid line) and small-gap theory (Tuck, 1971a, broken line) for zero wall thickness. (From Guiney et al., 1972.)
widthlh. It should be noted that Guiney’s computations (and presumably also Porter’s, which appear to agree with Guiney’s) require a massive amount of numerical integration. Even then, the results, while accurate for arbitrary v (given adequate numerical analysis), are still limited to sharpedged slits in plane walls of zero thickness.
B. APPROXIMATE SOLUTIONS The same problem (i.e., a single submerged slit in a zero-thickness wall) was earlier given an approximate treatment by Tuck (1971a)using the ideas of the present chapter. That is, one supposes that in an outer region far from the slit the residual effect of the slit is that of a source-sink pair situated on an otherwise impermeable wall. The outer solution is then a combination of the appropriate source potential (which satisfies the free surface condition, Wehausen and Laitone, 1960, p. 482) and suitable standing waves which satisfy the boundary condition on the wall. The outgoing wavestproduced by the source, together with the standing waves, combine to produce incident and reflected waves at infinity on one side of the wall, and a transmitted wave at the other infinity. It should be noted that the strength of the source
136
E. 0. Tuck
is oscillatory with the wave frequency, but its amplitude and phase are unknown at this stage. This outer flow is then matched with an inner flow through the slit, which is as treated in Section 11. This matching immediately determines the amplitude and phase of the apparent source-sink pair, and hence ultimately the amplitude and phase of z. The final result for a hole of effective size s is
1~1-’
=1
+
.’I-
-
Ei(4.a)
1 + -e4n4 log?]’ 2 2h
(8.1)
where is an exponential integral (Jahnke and Emde, 1945).This result was given by Tuck (1971a)only for the special case s = +a of a sharp-edged slit of width 2a, and Fig. 16 shows (dashed) computations from (8.1) for this case. Obviously the approximate theory, which should be valid only for small v = 2a/h = 4s/h, shows extraordinary agreement with the exact computations, except in the high frequency (a 4 00) tails of the curves, even at Palues of v as high as 1.0. The reason for this fortunate event is not yet adequately explained, but it may be surmised that what is actually happening is that the frequency is low enough (as indicated by the small numerical values of a ) for a “low-frequency” theory to hold. Such a theory would correspond to the limit a + 0 in (8.1), giving
where log C is Euler’s constant. It can be shown that an approach which assumes from the outset that a is small, i.e. A % h, s, but makes no assumption about the relative sizes of s (i.e. in this particular case +a) and h, also arrives at the result (8.2). This indicates that, at least in the low-frequency range, the approximation (8.1) may indeed be valid for moderate values of v. However, this can only apply to the increasing portion of the curves in Fig. 16, since the low-frequency approximation (8.2)possesses no maximum as a function of a. The above refers only to the special case s = 3. of a sharp-edged slit. Guiney (1972) considered the formula (8.1) in the more general case of a thick-walled slit, where the effective size is given by Eq. (2.12),and plotted in Fig. 5. As one should expect from Figs. 5 and 16, wall thickness substantially reduces the transmission coefficient since it reduces the effective size of a hole of given width. The effect is quite dramatic, as indicated in Fig. 17, from Guiney et a/. (1972). This figure also shows a comparison with experiments. The agreement is remarkably good, indicating that neglected real-fluid effects such as viscosity and separation at the slit edges are not too significant in determining the transmission coefficient.
Flow through Small Holes
fi
L
0.1
137
-
O
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.:
hl A
FIG.17. Comparison of theoretical (solid lines) and experimental (0,A) results for waterwave transmission through thick walls. (From Guiney et al., 1972.) Note: y = wall-thickness/hole-width.
C. FINITE-DEPTH RESULTS Another approach to small-hole problems (not only for water-wave diffraction as in the present section, but in most other applications mentioned in this chapter) is to set up the exact problem in an integral-equation formulation, if this is possible, and then to solve this integral equation approximately for small holes. There are a number of advantages to this approach to deriving the approximations, which is somewhat contrary to the spirit of the present chapter, since the intuitive feeling for the separate inner and outer flows is lost. On the other hand, use of integral equations is an ideal approach to numerical solution for holes of arbitrary size, as discussed later in Sections VII1,D and X,B. The integral-equation approach was used by Packham and Williams (1972) to rederive the result (8.1), and in addition to generalize it to the case of finite depth D of water. The finite-depth extension can of course just as easily be obtained using the matching procedure, it being only necessary to replace the infinite-depth unit-source potential [Wehausen and Laitone, 1960, Eq. (13.3l)] by the corresponding finite-depth potential [Wehausen and Laitone, 1960, Eq. (13.34)], and to modify the standing-wave potentials. The final result using this procedure is
138
E. 0.Tuck
where k = 2a/A is the wave number, and A = A(,!&) m
cD= -2j0
drc[ K~
sinh k D cosh k D sinh’ kD + kD tanh kD
=
+- rco_ _ e_- K_Dcosh’ _ _ _ K (_ D -_ h~) - + 5-21, IC
K
sinh ICD- I
C ~cosh
KD
IC
with rc0 = k tanh kD.
(8.6)
This agrees, after some manipulation, with the result of Packham and Williams (1972). The result (8.3) depends on the four independent length scales s, D, h, and A. There are of course several ways to exhibit the transmission coefficient as a function of the corresponding three dimensionless ratios. For example, Fig. 18 shows z 1’ against tl = h/A, at a fixed value s/h = 0.0375, for several values of h/D. This form of presentation was also used by Packham and Williams (1972). In the limit h/D 3 0 at fixed CI, the infinite-depth result of Fig. 16 (v = 0.15) is recovered. The results show, however, a remarkable low-frequency paradox,” in that the barrier is impermeable to “zero-frequency’’ waves in injinite water
I
“
0 ) 0
,
0.d2
1 I
o.b4
1
0.06
1
1
0.08
I
’
0.10
I
0.12 I
0.14 I
’
I 0.16
1
FIG.18. Water-wave transmission coefficient for a small hole in a wall in water of finite depth, plotted against hole-submergence/wavelength ratio, for a fixed value (0.0375) of the hole-effective-size/submergenceratio, and several values of the submergence/water-depthratio.
Flow through Small Holes
139
depth, but pePfectly transparent to such waves in water of any finite depth, however large. This is of course merely an indication that such very long waves can always “feel” the presence of a bottom, no matter how deep it is. Perfect transmission then occurs because the slowness of the oscillations allows penetration through a hole, no matter how small. The analogy is with tides penetrating a harbor fully, no matter how small its entrance. Another method of plotting the same results is as in Fig. 19 in which we show I z 1’ against D/A at a fixed value of s/D = 0.025, and for several values of h/D. This corresponds to a hole whose width is a fixed fraction (& for sharp-edged slits) of the water depth, but whose depth relative to the water bottom varies from curve to curve. Also shown on this graph (dashed) is a shallow-water result given by Guiney et al. (1972), namely
(TI-’
= 1
+ k’C’,
(8.7)
where C is the blockage coefficient of the slit, obtained for example from (5.16). Since C is symmetric with respect to the center of the channel, (8.7) predicts the same result for h/D = 0.25 and h/D = 0.75. The shallow-water result is clearly satisfactory only for D/A less than about 0.1, which is the usual criterion for the validity of shallow-water theory. The first curve to give poor agreement is that for h/D = 0.75, which is to be expected, since this is the deepest hole, and is the first to be “sheltered” by lack of penetration of the incident wave as it gets shorter.
0.6
1
1
I
-0.75
0-1
Ir”
1 %
0
-
0
,
1
0.02
1
1
0.01
,
1 0.E
1
olos
I I
0.10
I
1
0.12
1
, 0.14
1
t
0.16
!
l
0.10
E. 0 . Tuck
140
D. WALLSWITH CONTINUOUSLY VARIABLE PERMEABILITY A problem approaching practical utility for breakwater design is to compute the transmission coefficient of a vertical wall x = 0, for a given distribution of permeability. The permeability coefficient is discussed in Section V,D; here we consider only the formulation in terms of an effective blockage coefficient C = C ( y ) which may vary with position on the wall. Note, however, that the length scale for any such variations in C must exceed the typical length scales of the pores themselves, otherwise the concept of a relation such as (5.28) between velocity and potential (or pressure) jump breaks down. We also may observe that for a sinusoidal time dependence ,.- iuz, viscous dissipation can be included by use of a complex-valued C(y),as in (5.35). We seek a velocity potential representable on the transmission side x > 0 of the barrier by a suitable distribution, over the location of the barrier, of sources satisfying the free surface condition and representing outgoing waves, and on the incident side x < 0, by an equal distribution of sinks, together with a standing wave. Thus (in the case of infinite depth of water)
where for x > 0 @(x, y, t ) = B?
J'
0
-m
Q(r)G(x, y, r ) 4 . e-iu',
(8-9)
and G(x, y , y) is the potential (Wehausen and Laitone, 1960, p. 482) for a unit source at (0, y~). The source strength Q ( y )is a complex-valued quantity to be determined. Now the boundary condition to be satisfied across x = 0 is (5.28), i.e. in the present case
2@(0, y, t ) - cos ot e k y
=
2C(y)@,,(O,y, t).
(8.10)
The velocity @.,(O, y , t ) is simply proportional to Q(y), specifically @JO,
y, t ) = &?4?Q(y)e-'"',
(8.11)
so that (8.10) implies the integral equation 0
2
J'
-m
Q(r)G(o,Y , V ) & - C(Y)Q(Y)= eky,
(8.12)
which should be quite straightforward to solve numerically. Once the source strength Q ( y ) is determined, the transmission coeffiiient z follows im-
Flow through Small Holes
141
mediately, using the property of the Green’s function G as an outgoing wave at infinity. The above is only an outline of a possible procedure for solving the problem with a general given permeability distribution C(y). In fact, by suitable specialization of C ( y ) we should be able to rederive the previous results of this section. For example, a single slit in an otherwise-impermeable wall corresponds to
c(Y)=[::
-co
Thus, as we should expect, Q (8.12) reduces to -h+a
2
=0
-h+a
(8.13)
except over the location of the slit, and
Q(?)G(O, Y, r ) dy = eky,
IY + h I
< a,
(8.14)
-h-a
which is equivalent to the integral equation used by Packham and Williams (1972). Certain interesting design questions could be answered once an algorithm for solution of (8.12) was developed. For example, if one is concerned only with eliminating transmission, there is no reason to allow any permeability at all, and one can achieve r = 0 by setting C ( y ) = 0 for all y . The price paid is of course a large wave force on the barrier. If one wishes to reduce this force by allowing a measure of permeability, while still minimizing transmission, one has a nice variational problem for choice of C(y).For example, if some total permeability is to be allowed, where should it be placed; mainly near the surface or mainly far from the surface? Similar questions were considered for real breakwaters by LeMehaute (1971).
IX. The Helmholtz Resonator Rayleigh’s (1870) magnificent first acoustical paper is essentially concerned with the computation of the natural frequency of various resonating systems. The Helmholtz resonator consists of a nearly closed box or cavity, whose dimensions are small compared to the wavelength of the sound waves of interest, but large compared with the dimensions of the small opening through which the cavity communicates to the outside world. The physical mechanism of oscillation is quite clear. All oscillators require a balance between inertia and restoring force. In the present case the cavity provides an energy-storage mechanism or restoring force by allowing compression of the contained air, whereas the time-varying flow through the
E. 0. Tuck
142
small gap provides inertia, through its added mass. By dimensional arguments, we can easily establish that the radian frequency of the resonator is given by
where c is the speed of sound, s the linear size of the hole, and V the volume of the cavity. Much of Rayleigh’s (1870) paper is taken up with quantification of (9.1), using an intuitive equivalent of matched asymptotic expansions. Of course, a wealth of subsequent work has appeared on this class of problem, especially using techniques such as variational methods, integral equations, and equivalent electric circuits (for example, see Bouwkamp, 1954; Morse and Feshbach, 1953, p. 1490; Schwinger and Saxon, 1968; Miles, 1970). However, it is doubtful if anything has been or will be written on the subject with the clarity of Rayleigh’s original paper. From the asymptotic point of view the Helmholtz resonator is extremely interesting since it contains the double hierarchy of length scales : gap size 4 cavity size < wavelength. If one defines a geometrical small parameter, say =
gap size -= sv-