Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 ZEOLITES AND ORDERED MESOPOROUS MATERIALS: PROGRESS AND PROSPECTS
This Page is Intentionally Left Blank
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis Advisory Editors: B. Delmon and J.T. Yates Series Editor: G. Centi
Vol.157
ZEOLITES AND ORDERED MESOPOROUS MATERIALS: PROGRESS AND PROSPECTS The 1st FEZA School on Zeolites, Prague, Czech Republic, August 20-21, 2005
Edited by J. Cejka J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic Prague, Czech Republic H. van Bekkum Laboratory of Organic Chemistry and Catalysis Delft University of Technology Delft, The Netherlands
2005
Amsterdam - Boston - Heidelberg - London - New York - Oxford - Paris - San Diego San Francisco - Singapore - Sydney - Tokyo
ELSEVIER B.V. Radarweg 29 P.O. Box 211,1000 AE Amsterdam The Netherlands
ELSEVIER Inc. 525 B Street, Suite 1900 San Diego, CA 92101-4495 USA
ELSEVIER Ltd The Boulevard, Langford Lane Kidlington, Oxford OX5 1GB UK
ELSEVIER Ltd 84 Theobalds Road London WC1X 8RR UK
© 2005 ElsevierB.V. All rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright by Elsevier B.V., and the following terms and conditions apply to its use: Photocopying Single photocopies of single chapters may be made for personal use as allowed by national copyright laws. Permission of the Publisher and payment of a fee is required for all other photocopying, including multiple or systematic copying, copying for advertising or promotional purposes, resale, and all forms of document delivery. Special rates are available for educational institutions that wish to make photocopies for non-profit educational classroom use. Permissions may be sought directly from Elsevier's Rights Department in Oxford, UK: phone (+44) 1865 843830, fax (+44) 1865 853333, e-mail:
[email protected]. Requests may also be completed on-line via the Elsevier homepage (http:// www.elsevier.com/locate/permissions). In the USA, users may clear permissions and make payments through the Copyright Clearance Center, Inc., 222 Rosewood Drive, Danvers, MA 01923, USA; phone: (+1) (978) 7508400, fax: (+1) (978) 7504744, and in the UK through the Copyright Licensing Agency Rapid Clearance Service (CLARCS), 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP, UK; phone: (+44) 20 7631 5555; fax: (+44) 20 7631 5500. Other countries may have a local reprographic rights agency for payments. Derivative Works Tables of contents may be reproduced for internal circulation, but permission of the Publisher is required for external resale or distribution of such material. Permission of the Publisher is required for all other derivative works, including compilations and translations. Electronic Storage or Usage Permission of the Publisher is required to store or use electronically any material contained in this work, including any chapter or part of a chapter. Except as outlined above, no part of this work may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without prior written permission of the Publisher. Address permissions requests to: Elsevier's Rights Department, at the fax and e-mail addresses noted above. Notice No responsibility is assumed by the Publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property as a matter of products liability, negligence or otherwise, or from any use or operation of any methods, products, instructions or ideas contained in the material herein. Because of rapid advances in the medical sciences, in particular, independent verification of diagnoses and drug dosages should be made.
First edition 2005 Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record is available from the Library of Congress. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record is available from the British Library.
ISBN: ISSN:
0 444 52066 X 0167-2991 (Series)
@ The paper used in this publication meets the requirements of ANSI/NISO Z39.48-1992 (Permanence of Paper). Printed in The Netherlands.
V
Preface At the beginning of the 21st century zeolites are the most frequently used industrial catalysts, their applications ranging from oil refining, petrochemistry and the synthesis of special chemicals up to environmental catalysis. The rapid progress of basic research and the development of new processes using zeolites led us to the proposal to organize the 1st FEZA School on Zeolites and to prepare this book. Some two thirds of this book reflects the programme of the 1st FEZA School on Zeolites held in Prague on August 20 and 21, 2005. FEZA stands for Federation of European Zeolite Associations, which was established in 1996 and currently includes 15 national zeolite associations. It is the first time that a FEZA Conference was preceded by a Summer School and, in view of the large number of young researchers (mostly PhD students) attending the School, the idea was well received. Factors of importance were a low financial threshold and an attractive programme. When the prospect of a book was raised, all School lecturers reacted positively and agreed to have their contributions ready five months in advance of the School, enabling the organizers to provide the School participants with the book. When designing the School programme, the focus has been on relatively new and exciting areas of zeolite and molecular sieve chemistry. Thus, four chapters deal with the synthesis of the ever-expanding spectrum of zeolites, zeotypes and ordered mesoporous materials. Delaminated materials, germaniumcontaining zeolites as well as micro/mesoporous composites are shifting the borders here. The synthesis of mesoporous materials is covered by two of the inventors and there is also an account of the frontier topic of high-throughput techniques. Two chapters deal with the analytical side. Quite new is the use of electron tomography, providing inside views of zeolite crystals and mesoporous molecular sieves. The techniques of UV-VIS spectroscopy, photoluminescence and X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy are also not so often applied to zeolites. One chapter reviews the application of quantum-chemical methods to zeolite science to show the necessity of combining experimental and theoretical approaches. In the field of applications, one chapter overviews the progress in zeolitic membranes which slowly, but steadily, are coming into practical use. Three chapters deal with the use of zeolites and mesoporous materials as catalysts in organic conversions. These range from the fascinating ship-in-bottle systems via cascade reactions to bulk applications in oil refining and petrochemistry. A two-day school programme has its time limits. In order to arrive at a publication that can serve as a micro-handbook for students, we invited several world experts to contribute chapters. This has strengthened and enriched the book with fine chapters on trends in the molecular sieves field, zeolite structures, ion-exchange properties of zeolites, advanced applications (with many unique technologies and opportunities) and last but not least a chapter on natural zeolites. Finally, we would like to thank all contributors for timely review of their topics and to acknowledge the support of Elsevier in publishing this book, the financial support of sponsors for enabling the low registration fee and a bursary programme, and particularly the enormous effort of Dr. Nadezda Zilkova (J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague) in editing and formatting the whole book. Prague/Delft - April 2005
Jifi Cejka and Herman van Bekkum
This Page is Intentionally Left Blank
vii
SUPPORT AND SPONSORING (asofApril!5,2005)
The Organizers of the 1st FEZA School on Zeolites wish to thank various Institutions and Companies for their support to the School. Their contributions allowed a reduced registration fee for students and a bursary program.
INSTITUTIONS J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Prague International Visegrad Fund and Ceramic Membrane Centre 'The Pore", Delft University of Technology, Delft
COMPANIES Eurosupport Micromeritics Research Institute of Inorganic Chemistry, Czech Republic Sigma-Aldrich, Czech Republic Total Tricat Zeolites
This Page is Intentionally Left Blank
ix
ORGANIZING COMMITTEE Chairman J. Cejka H. van Bekkum
J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague University of Delft
Secretary N. Zilkova
J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague
Treasurer J. Ondrackova
J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague
Members G. Kosova I. Nekoksova J. Klisakova Z. Pavlackova J. Pawlesa J. Nedvedicka Z. Mlynska
J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Prague Orgit, Ltd. Orgit, Ltd.
This Page is Intentionally Left Blank
xi
List of contributors Thomas Bein Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Munich, Butenandtstr. 5-13 (E), 81377 Munich, Germany Herman van Bekkum Ceramic Membrane Centre "The Pore", Delft University of Technology, Julianalaan 136, 2628 BL Delft, The Netherlands Christian Baerlocher Laboratorium für Kristallographie, CH-8093, ETH Zurich, Switzerland JiríCejka J. Heyrovský Institute of Physical Chemistry, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Dolejškova 3,182 23 Prague 8, Czech Republic Carmine Colella Dipartimento d'Ingegneria dei Materiali e della Produzione, Università Federico II, Piazzale V. Tecchio 80, 80125 Napoli, Italy Avelino Corma Instituto de Tecnología Química, Av. de los Naranjos s/n, 46022 Valencia, Spain Colin S.Cundy Centre forMicroporous Materials, School of Chemistry, University of Manchester, P.O. Box 88, Sackville Street, Manchester M60 1QD, United Kingdom Krijn P. de Jong Department of Inorganic Chemistry and Catalysis, Debye Institute, Utrecht University, Sorbonnelaan 16, 3584 CA Utrecht, The Netherlands Francesco di Renzo Laboratoire de Matériaux Catalytiques et Catalyse en Chimie Organique, UMR 5618 CNRSENSCM-UM1, Institut C. Gerhardt, FR1878, ENSCM, 8 rue Ecole Normale, 34296 Montpellier, France Alan Dyer Institute of Materials Science, University of Salford, Cockcroft Building, Salford M5 4WT, United Kingdom. Francois Fajula Laboratoire de Matériaux Catalytiques et Catalyse en Chimie Organique, UMR 5618 CNRSENSCM-UM1, Institut C. Gerhardt, FR 1878, ENSCM, 8 rue Ecole Normale, 34296 Montpellier, France Pierre A. Jacobs Centre for Surface Chemistry and Catalysis, KU Leuven, Kasteelpark Arenberg 23, B-3001 Leuven (Heverlee), Belgium
xii
Andries H. Jannsen Department of Inorganic Chemistry and Catalysis, Debye Institute, Utrecht University, Sorbonnelaan 16, 3584 CA Utrecht, The Netherlands Anne Julbe Institut Européen des Membranes de Montpellier (UMR 5635 CNRS-ENSCM-UMII) UMII (CC 047), Place Eugène Bataillon, 34095 Montpellier cedex 5, France Kamil Klier Lehigh University, Bethlehem, PA 18015, USA Abraham J. Koster Department of Molecular Cell Biology, Utrecht University, Padualaan 8, 3584 CH Utrecht, The Netherlands Herman W. Kouwenhoven Ceramic Membrane Centre "The Pore", Delft University of Technology, Julianalaan 136, 2628 BL Delft, The Netherlands Lynne B. McCusker Laboratorium für Kristallographie, CH-8093, ETH Zurich, Switzerland Agustin Martinez Instituto de Tecnología Química, Av. de los Naranjos s/n, 46022 Valencia, Spain Svetlana Mintova Department of Chemistry and Biochemistry, University of Munich, Butenandtstr. 5-13 (E), 81377 Munich, Germany PetrNachtigall Institute of Organic Chemistry and Biochemistry, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic and Center for Biomolecules and Complex Molecular Systems, Flemingovo nam. 2, 166 10, Prague 6, Czech Republic WieslawJ.Roth ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Co., 1545 Route 22 East, Annandale, NJ 08801, USA Ferdi Schüth Max-Planck-Institut für Kohlenforschung, Kaiser-Wilhelm-Platz 1,45470 Mülheim, Germany James C. Vartuli ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Co., 1545 Route 22 East, Annandale, NJ 08801, USA Ulrike Ziesse Department of Inorganic Chemistry and Catalysis, Debye Institute, Utrecht University, Sorbonnelaan 16, 3584 CA Utrecht, The Netherlands
xiii
Contents Preface List of Contributors Chapter 1 Introduction to molecular sieves: trends of evolution of the zeolite community F. Fajula and F. di Renzo
v xi 1
Chapter 2 Natural zeolites C. Collela
13
Chapter 3 Zeolite structures L B. McCusker and Ch. Baerlocher
41
Chapter 4 Synthesis of zeolites and zeotypes C.S. Cundy
65
Chapter 5 Synthesis of mesoporous molecular sieves W.J. Roth andJ.C. Vartuli
91
Chapter 6 Recent trends in the synthesis of molecular sieves J. Cejka
111
Chapter 7 Zeolite membranes - A short overview A. Julbe
135
Chapter 8 High-throughput experiments for synthesis and applications of zeolites F. Schüth
161
Chapter 9 Ion-exchange properties of zeolites A. Dyer
181
Chapter 10 Spectroscopic studies of zeolites and mesoporous materials K. Klier
205
Chapter 11 Electron tomography of molecular sieves K.P. de Jong, A.J. Koster, A.H. Janssen and U. Ziese
225
xiv
Chapter 12 Applications of quantum chemical methods in zeolite science P. Nachtigall
243
Chapter 13 Advanced applications of zeolites T. Bein and S. Mintova
263
Chapter 14 An evaluation of the potential of the Ship-in-Bottle approach for catalyst immobilization in microporous supports P.A. Jacobs
289
Chapter 15 Zeolites in organic cascade reactions H. van Bekkum andH.W. Kouwenhoven
311
Chapter 16 Zeolites in refining and petrochemistry A. Corma and A. Martínez
337
Subject index
367
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
1
Introduction to molecular sieves: trends of evolution of the zeolite community Francesco Di Renzo and Francois Fajula Laboratoire de Materiaux Catalytiques et Catalyse en Chimie Organique, UMR 5618 CNRSENSCM-UM1, Institut C. Gerhardt, FR 1878, ENSCM, 8 rue Ecole Normale, 34296 Montpellier, France,
[email protected] 1. THE DEVELOPMENT OF A CLASS OF HIGH-TECHNOLOGY MATERIALS 2. FIELDS OF APPLICATION AND VOLUMES OF PRODUCTION 2.1. Synthetic zeolites 2.2. Natural zeolites 2.3. Mesoporous molecular sieves REFERENCES
1. THE DEVELOPMENT OF A CLASS OF HIGH-TECHNOLOGY MATERIALS At which extent the traditional definition of zeolites is still valid? Are zeolite scientists still dealing with "crystalline aluminosilicates containing pores and cavities of molecular dimensions" [1], or did they create new materials original enough to render this timehonoured definition obsolete? Indeed, the zeolite community has pushed afar the borders of his field of interest, as any healthy body of scientists has to do. Zeolite researchers presently deal with nanopores instead of micropores, self-assembly instead of synthesis, and they prepare periodical structures from any corner of the periodical table, well beyond the limits of the class of ordered silicates. The evolution of the subject (and of the vocabulary used to describe it) has been astounding and somewhat refreshing but the core of the activity of the zeolite scientist is still the same as it was when Barrer described the first documented synthetic zeolite in 1948 [2]: to apply up-to-date characterisation techniques to the design, synthesis and application of periodical self-assembled objects. The history of the synthesis of zeolites has been the object of recent review articles [1, 4,18] and some landmarks are cited in Table 1. The story of the development of zeolites from a mineralogical oddity to a commodity subtly present in the everyday life of each of us truly began with the discovery of zeolite A and synthetic faujasites by Breck and Milton in 1949 [3, 4]. A cheap and reliable synthesis method was available for new materials, original by their structure or their composition. The stage was set for the development of industrial processes based on the outstanding properties of the zeolites: microporosity, cation exchange and reactivity. An appropriate way to peering inside the properties of zeolites is to follow their development from discovery to process. The first relevant property of zeolites is microporosity. Zeolites, like any other tectosilicate, are formed by a continuous network of oxygen-sharing SiO4 or AIO4" tetrahedra. Alkali or alkaline earth cations are trapped inside
2
the network and compensate the negative charge of trivalent aluminium atoms sharing four oxygen atoms with their neighbours. Zeolites are formed by hydrothermal synthesis at temperature levels much lower than feldspar and, for this reason, the cations of the zeolites are hydrated. After the crystallization, the hydration water of the cations can be evaporated by heating. The aluminosilicate framework is rigid enough to avoid collapsing and the micropore volume previously occupied by water is made available to adsorb other molecules. The first commercial application of zeolites was the adsorption of water molecules to dry gas flows [4]. It was early realized that the pore size of zeolites can be tailored, and the selective adsorption of molecules of different size and polarity is nowadays at the basis of many industrial separation processes [19]. The definition of the zeolites as "molecular sieves" correctly describes the screening of molecules of different size by their microporosity [20]. The molecular-size microporosity of the zeolites is also important for catalytic applications. The shape selectivity effect in catalysis corresponds to the selection between possible reaction paths on the basis of the match between shape and size of the reacting molecules and the micropores [21]. Shape selectivity was early recognised [22] and was at the basis of the earliest applications of zeolites in catalysis, specifically as isomerisation catalysts [23]. Table 1 Landmarks in the history of zeolites and related materials 1948 syntheses of mordenite and chabazite 1949 syntheses of zeolites A and X 1954 application of zeolites for gas drying 1959 application of zeolites for paraffin separation 1959 application of clinoptilolite for cation exchange 1961 organic cations as templates 1962 zeolites as FCC catalysts 1967 syntheses of zeolite beta and ZSM-5 1974 zeolites as detergent builder 1978 synthesis of silicalite 1982 aluminophosphate molecular sieves 1983 incorporation of titanium in the TS-1 1992 micelle-templated mesoporous silicates 1994 micelle-templated mesoporous oxides 1999 mesoporous carbons by silica replica 1999 microporous metalloorganic frameworks
R.M. Barrer [2] Union Carbide [3, 4] Union Carbide [4] Union Carbide [4] Ames [5] Barrer and Danny [6] Mobil Oil [7] Mobil Oil [8, 9] Henkel [4] Union Carbide [10] Union Carbide [ 11 ] Eniricerche [12, 13] Mobil [14] G.D. Stucky [15] R. Ryoo [16] Yaghi and O'Keeffe [17]
Natural zeolites have been known, in some ways, since more than two thousand years and have been often used as light building materials since the Roman times [24]. The first industrial applications of synthetic zeolites suggested that natural zeolites could also present a significant added value and prompted the search and discovery of exploitable zeolite deposits [25]. If available natural zeolites have smaller pore opening than synthetic faujasite, they present easily exchangeable charge-compensating cations, and their first application was indeed based on cation exchange: the removal of radionuclides from the wastewater of the nuclear industry [5]. This was the first of many environment-friendly applications of zeolites based on cation exchange, like ammonia removal from wastewater and replacement of phosphates as water softeners in laundry washing. [26] Another environment-friendly application was the use of acidic zeolites as heterogeneous catalysts in replacement of homogeneous acid catalysts, an important source of
3
industrial pollution. The properties of acidic zeolites, in which charge compensation of the framework anion is provided by an acidic proton, are related to the way in which their silicate network relaxes when the proton is involved in the catalytic reaction [27]. Due to the elasticity of their structure, the zeolites present a stronger Bransted acidity than amorphous silica-aluminas and became the standard catalyst in FCC (fluid catalytic cracking), at the core of petrochemistry and refining [28, 29]. It was early realised that the acidity of zeolites is affected by their composition. Zeolites with a low aluminium content, hence a low density of lattice anions, present isolated acidic sites, which strength is not diminished by mutual interaction [30]. In this way, catalytic applications usually demand zeolites with a lower aluminium content than applications in water softening or in the separation of air gases, for which a high density of cations is demanded. The aluminium content of zeolites can be controlled by post-synthesis treatment, like in the dealumination treatments which lead to the ultra-stable Y (USY) used in the FCC catalysts [31]. The aluminium content can also be controlled by modifying the conditions of synthesis, albeit each zeolite structure presents a preferential field of composition. It was early shown that the Si/Al ratio is affected by the pH of the synthesis system, the lowest Si/Al ratio being obtained in the most alkaline systems, in which silica is largely depolymerised and is incorporated as isolated tetrahedra [32]. An important method to form zeolites with a high Si/Al ratio was introduced by the research of Barrer on the use of organic cations as templates for the porosity of zeolites [6]. The idea at the basis of this pioneering work was that tetraalkylammonium cations are larger than alkali or alkaline earth cations and can be surrounded by a larger number of SiCU tetrahedra per AIO4" anion. The application of this principle led to the synthesis of new zeolite structures with low aluminium content, usually defined as high-silica zeolites, like ZSM-5 [9] and zeolite beta [8]. Further developments allowed to form all-silica zeolites, the first one being silicalite-1, a siliceous analog of ZSM-5 [10]. The synthesis of these microporous silica polymorphs, happily unaffected by the toxicological hazards of other crystalline silicas [33], allowed to develop applications of zeolites as hydrophobic adsorbents [34]. The introduction of organic templates brought about a multiplication of the number of different zeolite structures [35-37]. The number of stable configurations of SiCU tetrahedra around template molecules is extremely large [38] and each configuration of tetrahedra corresponds to different shape and size of the micropore system. The nomenclature of zeolites rapidly became a headache for the scientific community, especially due to the attribution of different names to zeolites differing by composition or synthesis method albeit presenting the same configuration of tetrahedra. A welcome clarification came through the activity of the Structure Commission of the International Zeolite Association. Since many years the Atlas of Zeolite Structures of the IZA provides an extensive listing of zeolite framework types, characterised by a three-letter code. This classification does not take into account the composition of the framework, which has to be provided as a side information. The last edition of the Atlas [39], published in 2001, reported 133 framework types and, at the end of 2004, 26 more have been synthesized, characterised and accepted by the Structure Commission of the IZA, which report them on its website [40]. The natural zeolite community has followed a different path towards a systematisation of its nomenclature. An historically-determined nomenclature in which the crystal structure, the nature of the charge-compensating cation and some thermal properties were taken into account in a non-systematic manner [41] has been replaced by a nomenclature in accordance with the rules of the International Mineralogical Association (IMA) [42], in which both the structure and composition of the mineral are considered. This has led to a substantial increase
4
of the number of natural zeolites, as zeolites with the same structure but different main compensating cation have been considered as individual mineral species. A general acceptation of the IMA nomenclature by the natural zeolite community seems to require some induction time [43]. To come back to the effects of the introduction of organic templates in the zeolite synthesis, the formation of silica-rich zeolites was not the only change in composition allowed by the use of organic cations. The incorporation in the silica framework of elements other than aluminium, virtually impossible with small alkali cations, was made easy by the use of large organic cations [44, 45]. This research field was opened by the synthesis of borium containing zeolites (boralites) [46, 47] and titanium silicalites [12] by the ENI scientists and has brought to the development of the processes of catalytic oxidation based on TS-1 catalysts [13]. The incorporation of transition metals in the zeolite framework is still a thriving research field, as it has been shown by the recent development of the old-established fluoride synthesis route [48, 49] towards the incorporation of germanium in silicate zeolites and the discovery of new zeolite types [50]. The research of new compositions led to an important development when the Union Carbide researchers synthesized the aluminophosphate molecular sieves known as AIPO4 [11]. The framework of these zeotypes is formed by alternating AIO4" and PC>4+ tetrahedra and often corresponds to structural types already known for silicic zeolites. However, several original structural types have been synthesized for the first time as AIPO4 and the structures presenting the largest pore size can only be synthesized as gallophosphate or aluminophosphate [51, 52]. Most AIPO4 are prepared in the presence of an organic cation, albeit the first syntheses of these materials have been realized in the absence of organics [53]. The presence of organic cations has proven to be needed to modify the composition of the AIPO4 by substituting a fraction of the PO4+ tetrahedra with SiO4 tetrahedra [54]. The SAPO (silicoaluminophosphate) materials formed in this way present an anionic framework and the corresponding acidic properties, exploited in industrial catalysis. The number of tetrahedra which form the channel or window of a microporous material provides a first indication of the accessibility of the pores. Zeolites are usually defined as small pore, medium pore or large pore zeolites if their pores are delimited by, respectively, 8, 10 or 12 tetrahedra. Typical examples of these classes are zeolite A (structural type LTA, small pores of 4.1 A diameter), ZSM-5 (MFI, medium pores of 5.3 A), and the zeolites X or Y (FAU, large pores of 7.4 A). Zeolites with pores delimited by 14 or more tetrahedra are defined extra large pore zeolites. The structures with pores delimited by the largest number of tetrahedra present 20 tetrahedra around their pores [51, 52]. However, the structures with 20 member rings present interrupted frameworks, with protruding oxygens which significantly decrease the practical pore opening [55]. The most accessible zeotypes are the 18 member ring gallosilicate ECR-34 (structural type ETR, pores of 10.1 A diameter) [56] and VPI-5 (VFI, pores of 12.7 A) [57]. Zinc phosphates or nickel phosphates with pores delimited by 24 member rings have been obtained [58-60]. However, their structure presents both tetrahedra and octahedra and the pore size is somewhat decreased by corner sharing of the framework polyhedra. The development of the oil production towards the processing of heavier crudes has generated a demand for zeolites with still larger pores, able to catalyse the conversion of very large hydrocarbon molecules. Attempting to cope with this demand, the researchers of Mobil led the way towards a new class of molecular sieves [14]. If the available molecular templates, be them hydrated inorganic cations or organic cations, were too small for the desired pore size, the logical answer was to organise silica tetrahedra around larger objects, in
5
fact molecular aggregates. The aggregation properties of surfactants are well known, and the addition of silicates to micellar systems has allowed to form mixed organic-inorganic mesophases corresponding to liquid crystal structures, with silica walls separating surfactant micelles. The removal of the micelles allows to form mesopores with an extremely narrow pore size distribution. A huge body of knowledge about the properties of micellar systems had been made available by the community of colloid science, providing methods to finely tune the size of the micelles and the size of the corresponding mesopores in the final material. The first micelle-templated molecular sieves were formed by using cationic alkylammonium surfactants (cetyltrimethylammonium) and received the collective name of M41s, a definition lumping together several materials: for instance, MCM-41 with parallel mesopores organised in a hexagonal array or MCM-48 with a tridimensional pore system and a cubic symmetry [14]. In a few years, a variety of surfactants were used as templates and mineral phases other than silica or aluminosilicates were used to form the walls between micelles [15,61,62]. The variety of pore geometries and wall compositions made feasible by the collaboration between the colloid scientists and the material scientists is astounding [63]. The contact with the community of surfactants and colloids has not only brought new ideas but also a new language and the discovery of new meanings for old practices. The members of the zeolite community suddenly realized that they had practised self-assembly all their life, when they thought they were just making hydrothermal synthesis, exactly as the would-be gentleman of Moliere was amazed to discover that he has been speaking prose all his life, when he thought he was just talking [64], The blossoming of new materials has been so rapid that the nomenclature of ordered mesoporous materials is in the wild state in which zeolite nomenclature was thirty years ago. A set of rules for writing a standardized crystal chemical formula for both microporous and mesoporous materials has been established by the Physical Chemistry Division of the International Union for Pure and Applied Chemistry, through its Commission on Colloid and Surface Chemistry including Catalysis [65]. The impact of this nomenclature on the activity of the scientists dealing with mesoporous materials has still to be verified. Indeed, crystallography provides a less complete information in the case of the mesoporous materials than in the case of zeolites. At the nanometer scale, the mesoporous materials can present an ordered pore system with a defined space group. However, at the Angstrom scale, the walls between the mesopores are amorphous and diffraction methods are unable to define the position of each atom, as in the case of microporous zeolites. The organisation of the walls has important consequences on the properties of the materials. The inner surface of the pores corresponds to an interrupted framework and mesoporous aluminosilicates present a much smaller acid strength than aluminosilicate zeolites [66]. This situation logically prompted studies on the incorporation of zeolite-like entities inside the walls of ordered mesoporous materials [67-70]. The field of application of ordered mesoporous materials as catalysts has been largely studied [71, 72]. Their main assets are the accessibility to large molecules, the ease with which their surface can be modified by grafting large active groups [73], and the variety of possible compositions of their walls. Materials with silica-based walls are still the easiest to synthesize [62] but the preparation of materials with transition oxide-based walls has been considerably improved by the use of evaporation-induced self assembly, a method in which a surfactant-inorganic mixed mesophase is formed by controlled drying of a liquid film [74-76]. The variety of chemical compositions in which ordered nanocomposites can be prepared has been extended virtually beyond any limit by the nanocasting method, in which a new solid phase is formed inside the porosity of an ordered mesoporous silica [16, 77-80].
6
The possible compositions for the walls of the ordered mesoporous materials go beyond the field of inorganic chemistry, and materials with hybrid organosilica walls have been prepared [81-84]. Some mesoporous benzene-silica hybrids are stable at a temperature higher than 500 °C [84]. Mesoporous materials prepared from polysilazanes and nonionic surfactants can be activated to form silicon carbonitride ceramics, which retain an ordered mesoporosity up to 1500 °C [85]. A parallel expansion of the chemistry of ordered porous materials has been achieved by the contribution of another scientific community, the coordination chemistry scientists, who were at the basis of the development of the MOFs, the metallo-organic frameworks. The preparation of MOFs with permanent porosity has been a long standing challenge. The assembly of rigid molecular building blocks consisting of metal-organic fragments has generated a huge number of 2D and 3D structures, which failed to produce porous materials due to interpenetration of the networks or poor stability leading to collapse upon removal of the guest solvent. Recently, Yaghi and coworkers have reported the successful synthesis of novel rigid and highly porous non-interpenetrating materials based on the coordination of metal ions by carboxylate groups and their assembly into 3D frameworks by organic linkers [17]. This new field of research is rapidly developing, largely due to the accessibility of the metal cations, which provide interesting adsorption sites for the storage of hydrogen and methane [86-92]. The appropriate choice of the organic linkers allows to prepare materials with a surprising thermal stability [93]. 2. FIELDS OF APPLICATION AND VOLUMES OF PRODUCTION 2.1. Synthetic zeolites The world market for synthetic zeolite in 2001 represented some 1.6 million tons (Mt) with 1.3 Mt in the field of detergents, 120 000 tons in catalysis and 85 000 tons in desiccation/adsorption. Zeolites (A-type, LTA) in detergents are basically water softeners, which prevent carbonate precipitation from wash water by extracting hard calcium and magnesium cations via sodium ion-exchange [26]. Zeolite X is also widely used, its large pore volume allowing to include liquid soaps in washing powders and avoid caking. The large expansion of the zeolite detergent market in the past decade has been driven by the growing public sensitivity to environmental issues and the resulting ban on the use of phosphate builders. To date, nearly 90% of the production of zeolite A for detergent uses is consumed in Europe, USA and Japan and growth potential is expected mainly in the Asia-Pacific region [94]. Most of the current large scale commercial processes using zeolite catalysts are in the petroleum refining and the petrochemical industry (Table 2). The unique properties of zeolite catalysts, and their technological and economical impacts on this sector of activity have been reviewed several times [28, 29, 95-97]. Zeolite catalyst consumption is dominated by far by zeolite Y (FAU) for FCC application which accounts alone for nearly 95-97% of the total zeolite catalyst share in terms of tonnage. The remaining share is distributed among a small dozen of different structural types from which over 70 catalysts are derived and used in key processes, including emerging innovative technologies for the synthesis of fine and commodity chemicals [95-99].
7
Table 2 Zeolite structural types used in commercial and emerging catalytic processes Structural type Catalytic process (zeolite or zeotype) FAU (Y) Catalytic cracking, Hydrocracking, Aromatic alkylation, NOx reduction, Acetylation MOR (Mordenite) Light alkanes hydroisomerisation, Hydrocracking, Dewaxing, NOx reduction, Aromatic alkylation and transalkylation, Olefm oligomerisation MFI (ZSM-5, TS-1, Dewaxing, Methanol to gasoline, Methanol to olefins and products, Silicalite) FCC additive, Hydrocracking, Olefin cracking and oligomerisation, Benzene alkylation, Xylene isomerization, Toluene disproportionation, Aromatisation, NOx reduction, Oxidations, Hydration, Amination, Beckmann rearrangement, Cyclodimerisation, BEA (Beta) Benzene alkylation, Aliphatic alkylation, Acetylation, Baeyer-Villiger reaction, FCC additive, Etherification LTL (KL) Alkane aromatisation MWW (MCM-22) Benzene alkylation CHA (SAPO-34) Methanol to olefins AEL (SAPO-11) Long chain alkane hydroisomerisation, Beckmann rearrangement FER (Ferrierite) Olefin skeletal isomerisation ERI (Erionite) Selectoforming RHO (Rho) Amination TON (Theta-1, Long chain alkane hydroisomerisation ZSM-22) Though the global consumption of zeolite catalysts represents less than 10% of the volume consumed as detergents, it constitutes approximately 55% of the global synthetic zeolite market on a value basis [94]. Zeolite adsorbents (mostly A-type and X-type, LTA and FAU, respectively, and to a lesser extent Mordenite, MOR and Y, FAU) are used in a number of processes related to bulk gas separations, dilute impurity removal, drying and chromatography (Table 3). Table 3 Main commercial gas separation and purification processes using synthetic zeolites [100]. Bulk gas separation O2, N2 industrial production (A, X, Mordenite) Medical oxygen production (A, X) H2 production from off-gases (A,X) CO2/CH4 separation (X) Alcohol dehydration (A,X) n-/iso-paraffm separation (A) Xylenes separation (X, Y) Gas analysis r-., .. V . / A V » J J - * \ Chromatography (A,X, Mordenite)
Impurity removal, drying Industrial and natural gas drying (A,X) Insulated glass windows (A) Drying acid gases (Mordenite) Desulfurization of gases (A, Y) CO2 removal (A,X) Solvent recovery (A,X,Mordenite) Silanes removal (A, Mordenite) Removal of rare gases (A) Trapping Hg vapors, SO2, NOx, HC1 (Mordenite) Air Fpollution control (A, X, Mordenite) » , . .„;,' ' Removal of trace NH3 (A)
8
New developments for niche applications of zeolite adsorbents are expected in various domains where they can provide an alternative to carbon filters to meet ultra-low VOCs emission requirements in confined environments (such as houses, vehicle habitacles, painting cabins, workshops ...) [34]. 2.2. Natural zeolites The worldwide production of natural zeolites (mainly clinoptilolite and chabazite) in 1999 was estimated to be between 3 and 4 million tons, on the basis of production reports by some countries and production estimates reported in business journals. China and Cuba definitely dominate the production, with 70% and 15%, respectively, of the total volume Table 4). By far, the largest use of natural zeolites in terms of tonnage is found in the construction industry, for the preparation of dimension stones, pozzolanic cements and concrete and lightweight aggregates. Though exact figures for production and uses are difficult to ascertain, zeolite building materials would account for nearly 90% of the total natural zeolite share. Other applications (ca 350 kt per year) include, in decreasing order by tonnage, pet litter, animal feeding, horticulture, wastewater treatment, odor control, desiccant, fungicide and pesticide carrier, water filtration, gas adsorbent, catalysis, aquaculture, medicinal and pharmaceutical applications, heat storage and solar refrigeration, and many miscellaneous other uses [24]. Table 4 Production estimates of natural zeolites for individual countries in 1999 (Thousands of tons) [101] China 2 500 Greece 4.7 Cuba 500-600 Canada 4 Japan 140-160 4 Italy USA 43 Australia 3.9 Hungary 10-20 Bulgaria 2 Slovakia 12 South Africa 1-2 6 Georgia Other 5 New Zealand 5 TOTAL ca 3 500 The demand for natural zeolites in the past decade has diversely grown, with a high 10% increase for agricultural uses [102], whereas markets for pet litter and water treatment applications leveled in Europe and the US. A main characteristic of the natural zeolite market is the very small volume of imports/exports. Prices of natural zeolites range from 25 to 200 EUR per metric ton, depending on purity and granulometry, making shipping costs prohibitive. The global consumption of natural zeolites is estimated to reach 4.6 Mt in 2005 and 5.5 Mt in 2010 [94]. 2.3. Mesoporous materials The time from discovery to process for synthetic zeolites has been about ten years. This lag has already elapsed since the discovery of the ordered mesoporous materials and times seem ripe for their industrial development. The main obstacle towards viable applications is the presence on the market of much cheaper amorphous alternatives, mainly based on silica gels. Micelle-templated materials has to compete for new applications, to obtain results that can be achieved only thanks to their narrow pore size distribution.
9 Many catalytic applications have been proposed [71, 72]. Mobil announced in 2004 that a mesoporous catalyst was implemented on an industrial plant, but details on the nature of the application are still lacking at the moment in which this notes are written. Hydrotreating or mild hydrocracking processes seem to be the most likely candidates. Other potential applications of ordered mesoporous materials are in chromatographic applications and in the separation of molecules of biological interest, for which their uniform large pores can allow the development of new ways to products of high added value [103105]. The field of sensors and solid-state materials are also promising [106-109]. REFERENCES [I] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [II] [12] [13] [14]
[15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23]
C.S. Cundy and P.A. Cox, Chem. Rev., 103 (2003) 663. R.M. Barrer, J. Chem. Soc, (1948) 127; J. Chem. Soc, (1948) 2158; R.M. Barrer and D.W. Riley, J. Chem. Soc, (1948) 133. R.M. Milton, U.S. Patent 2 882 243 (1959); U.S. Patent 2 882 244 (1959). E.M. Flanigen, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 137 (2001) 11. L.L. Ames, Am. Mineral., 45 (1960) 689. R.M. Barrer and P.J. Denny, J. Chem. Soc, (1961) 971. C.J. Planck and E.J. Rosinski, Chem. Eng. Progr. Symp. Ser., 73 (1967) 26. R.L. Wadlinger, G.T. Kerr and E.J. Rosinski, U.S. Patent 3 308 069 (1967). R.J. Argauer and G.R. Landolt, U.S. Patent 3 702 886 (1972). E.M. Flanigen, J.M. Bennett, R.W. Grose, J.P. Cohen, R.L. Patton, R. Kirchner and J.V. Smith, Nature, 271 (1978) 512. S.T. Wilson, B.M. Lock, C.A. Messina, T.R. Cannan and E.M. Flanigen, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 104(1982) 1146. M. Taramasso, G. Perego and B. Notari, U.S. Patent 4 410 501 (1983). G. Bellussi and M.S. Rigutto, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 137 (2001) 911. J.S. Beck, J.C. Vartuli, W.J. Roth, M.E. Leonowicz, C.T. Kresge, K.D. Schmitt, C.T.W. Chu, D.H. Olson, E.W. Sheppard, S.B. McCullen, J.B. Higgins and J.L. Schlenker, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 114(1992) 10834. Q. Huo, D.I. Margolese, U. Ciesla, P. Feng, T.E. Gier, P. Sieger, R. Leon, P.M. Petroff, F. Schuth and G.D. Stucky, Nature, 368 (1994) 317. R. Ryoo, S.H. Joo and S. Jun, J. Phys. Chem. B, 193 (1999) 7743. H. Li, M. Eddaoui, M. O'Keeffe and O.M Yaghi, Nature, 402 (1999) 276; J. Kim, B. Chen, T. Reineke, H. Li, M. Eddaoui, D.B. Moler, M. O'Keeffe and O.M. Yaghi, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 123(2001)8239. K. Nishi and R.W. Thompson, in F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing and J. Weitkamp, Eds., Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 2, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2002, 736. A. Solden and G. Eigenberger, in F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing and J. Weitkamp, Eds., Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 4, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2002, 2223. J.W. McBain, The Sorption of Gases and Vapours by Solids, Rutledge, London 1932. P.B. Weisz and V.J. Frilette, J. Phys. Chem., 64 (1960) 382. S.M. Csicsery, Zeolites, 4 (1984) 202. R.M. Milton, in M.L. Occelli and H.. Robson (Eds.), Zeolite Synthesis, ACS Symp. Ser. 398, American Chemical Society, Washington, D.C., 1989, p. 1.
10 [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33]
[34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42]
[43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49]
[50]
C. Colella, in F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing and J. Weitkamp, Eds., Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 2, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2002, 1156. F.A. Mumpton, Ed., Mineralogy and geology of natural zeolites, Mineralogical Society of America, Washington, D.C., 1977. R.P. Townsend and E.N. Coker, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 137 (2001) 467. J.A. Rabo and G.J. Gaida, in E.G. Derouane, Ed., Guidelines for Mastering Propeties of Molecular Sieves, NATO ASI Series 221, 1990, 273. J.A. Lercher and A. Jentys, in F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing and J. Weitkamp, Eds., Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 2, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2002, 1097. A. Corma and A. Martinez, in F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing and J. Weitkamp, Eds., Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 5, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2002, 2825. D. Barthomeuf, J. Phys. Chem., 83 (1979) 249. R. Szostak, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 137 (2001) 261. S.P. Zhdanov, in Molecular Sieves, Society of Chemical Industry, London 1968, 62. I. Fenoglio, B. Fubini, R. Tiozzo and F. Di Renzo, Inhalation Toxicol. 12 (2000) 81; I. Fenoglio, A. Croce, F. Di Renzo, R. Tiozzo and B. Fubini, Chem. Res. Toxicol., 13 (2000) 489. F. Fajula and D. Plee, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 85 (1994) 633. B.M. Lok, T.R. Cannan and C.A. Messina, Zeolites, 3 (1983) 282. Y. Kubota, M.M. Helnikamp, S.I. Zones, M.E. Davis, Microporous Mater. 6 (1996) 213. R. Millini, L. Carluccio, F. Frigerio, W. O'Neil Parker Jr. and G. Bellussi, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 24 (1998) 199. M.M.J. Treacy, K.H. Randall and S. Rao, Proc. 12th Int. Zeol. Conf, Baltimore, MD, 1998, 517. C. Baerlocher, W.M. Meier and D.H. Olson, Atlas of Zeolite Framework Types, 5th revised edition, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2001. http://www.iza-structure.org/databases/ R.W. Tschernich, Zeolites of the World, Geoscience Press, Phoenix 1992. D.S. Coombs, A. Alberti, T. Armbruster, G. Artioli, C. Colella, E. Galli, J.D. Grice, F. Liebau, J.A. Mandarino, H. Minato, E.H. Nickel, E. Passaglia, D.R. Peacor, S. Quartieri, R. Rinaldi, M. Ross, R.A. Sheppard, E. Tillmanns and G. Vezzalini, Can. Mineral, 35 (1997) 1571. D.L. Bish and D.W. Ming, Eds., Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Applications, Mineralogical Society of America and the Geochemical Society, Washington, D.C., 2001. R. de Ruiter, J.C. Janssen and H. van Bekkum, Zeolites, 12 (1992) 56. F. Di Renzo, M. Derewinski, G. Chiari, J. Plevert, M.F. Driole, F. Fajula and P. Schulz, Microporous Mater. 6 (1996) 151. M. Taramasso, G. Perego and B. Notari, in L.V. Rees (Ed.), Proceedings of the 5th Int. Conf. Zeol. (Naples 1980), Heyden, London 1980, 40. R. Millini, G. Perego and G. Bellussi, Top. Catal., 9 (1999) 13. E.M. Flanigen and R.L. Patton, U.S. Patent 4,073,865 (1978). J.L. Guth, H. Kessler, J.M. Higel, J.M. Lamblin, J. Patarin, A. Seive, J.M. Chezeau and R. Wey, in M.L. Occelli and H.. Robson (Eds.), Zeolite Synthesis, ACS Symp. Ser. 398, American Chemical Society, Washington, D.C., 1989, 176. A. Corma, M.J. Diaz-Cabanas, J. Martinez-Triguero, F. Rey and J. Rius, Nature, 2002 (418) 514.
11 [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57] [58] [59] [60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78] [79] [80]
M. Estermann, L.B. McCusker, C. Baerlocher, A. Merrouche and H. Kessler, Nature, 352 (1991)320. Q. Hu, R. Xu, S. Li, Z. Ma, J.M. Thomas, R.H. Jones and A.M. Chippindale, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., (1992) 875; J. Yu and R. Xu, Ace. Chem. Res.. 2003 (36) 481. F. d'Yvoire, Bull. Soc. Chim. Fr., (1961) 1762. J. Patarin, J.L. Paillaud and H. Kessler, in Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 2, F. Schiith, K.S.W. Sing and J. Weitkamp, Eds., Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2002, 815. X. Bu and P. Feng, in P. Yang, The Chemistry of Nanostructured Materials, World Scientific 2005, 1. K.G. Strohmaier and D.E.W. Vaughan, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 125 (2003) 16035. M.E. Davis, C. Saldarriaga, C. Montes, J. Garces and C. Crowder, Nature, 331 (1988) 698. G.Y. Yang and S.C. Sevov, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 121 (1999) 8389. N. Guillou, Q. Gao, M. Nogues, R. E. Morris, M. Hervieu, G. Ferey and A.K. Cheetham, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris, (1999) (2) 387. N. Guillou, Q. Gao, P.M. Forster, J.S. Chang, M. Nogues, S.E. Park, G. Ferey and A.K. Cheetham, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 40 (2001) 2831. P.T. Tanev, M. Chibwe, T.J. Pinnavaia, Nature, 368 (1994) 321. F. Schuth, Chem. Mater. 13 (2001) 3184. F. Di Renzo, A. Galarneau, P. Trens and F. Fajula, in F. Schuth, K. Sing and J. Weitkamp, Eds., Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 2, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim 2002, 1311. J.B. Poquelin de Moliere, Le bourgeois gentilhomme, Chambord 1670, act 1, scene 4. L.B. McCusker, F. Liebau and G. Engelhardt, Pure Appl. Chem., 73 (2001) 381. C.Y. Chen, H.X. Li and M.E. Davis, Microporous Mater., 2 (1993) 17. K.R. Kloetstra, H.W. Zandbergen, J.C. Jansen and H. van Bekkum, Microporous Mater., 6 (1996)287. Y. Liu, W. Zhang and T.J. Pinnavaia, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 122 (2000) 8791; Y. Liu, W. Zhang and T.J. Pinnavaia, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 40 (2001) 1255. Z. Zhang, Y. Han, L. Zhu, R. Wang, Y. Yu, S. Qiu, D. Zhao and F.S. Xiao, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 40(2001) 1258. D. Trong On and S. Kaliaguine, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 40 (2001) 3248. D. Trong On, D. Desplantier-Giscard, C. Danumah and S. Kaliaguine, Appl. Catal. A, 253 (2003) 545. A. Taguchi and F. Schuth, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 77 (2005) 1. D. Brunei, N. Bellocq, P. Sutra, A. Cauvel, M. Lasperas, P. Moreau, F. Di Renzo, A. Galarneau and F. Fajula, Coordin. Chem. Rev., 178 (1998) 1085. C.J. Brinker, Y. Lu, A. Sellinger and H. Fan, Adv. Mater., 11 (1999) 579. A. Gibaud, D. Grosso, B. Smarsly, A. Baptiste, J.F. Bardeau, F. Babonneau, D.A. Doshi, Z. Chen, C.J. Brinker and C. Sanchez, J. Phys. Chem. B, 107 (2003) 6114. D. Grosso, G.J. de A.A. Soler-Illia, E.L. Crepaldi, F. Cagnol, C. Sinturel, A. Bourgeois, A. Brunet-Bruneau, H. Amenitsch, P.A. Albouy and C. Sanchez, Chem. Mater. 15 (2003) 4562. M. Kang, S.H. Yi, H.I. Lee, J.E. Yie and J.M. Kim, Chem. Commun, (2002) 1944. A.H. Lu, W. Schmitt, A. Taguchi, B. Spliethoff, B. Tesche and F. Schuth, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 41 (2002) 3489. F. Schuth, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 42 (2003) 3604. B. Tian, X. Liu, H. Yang, S. Xie, C. Yu, B. Tu and D. Zhao, Adv. Mater., 15 (2003) 1370.
12 [81] [82] [83] [84] [85]
S. Inagaki, S. Guan, Y. Fukushima, T. Ohsuna and O. Terasaki, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 121 (1999)9611. B.J. Melda, B.T. Holland, C.F. Blanford and A. Stein, Chem. Mater., 11 (1999) 3302. T. Asefa, MJ. MacLachlan, N. Coombs and G.A. Ozin, Nature, 402 (1999) 867. S. Inagaki, S. Guan, T. Ohsuna and O. Terasaki, Nature, 416 (2002) 304. M. Kamperman, C.B.W. Garcia, P. Du, H. Ow and U. Wiesner, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 126 (2004) 14708.
[86] [87] [88] [89] [90] [91] [92] [93] [94] [95] [96] [97] [98] [99] [100] [101] [102] [103] [104] [105] [106] [107] [108] [109]
M. Eddaoui, H. Li andO.M. Yaghi, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 122 (2000) 1391. M. Kondo, M. Shimamura, S.I. Noro, S. Minakoshi, A. Asami, K. Seki and S. Kitagawa, Chem. Mater., 12 (2000) 1288. M. Eddaoui, J. Kim, N. Rossi, D. Vodak, J. Wachter, M. O'Keeffe and O.M. Yaghi, Science 295 (2002) 469. N.L. Rosi, J. Eckert, M. Eddaoui, D.T. Vodak, J. Kim, M. O'Keeffe and O.M. Yaghi, Science, 300 (2003) 1127. G. Ferey, M. Latroche, C. Serre, F. Millange, T. Loiseau and A. Percheron-Guegan, Chem. Commun, (2003) 2976. D.N. Dybtsev, H. Chun, S.H. Yoon, D. Kim and K. Kim, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 126 (2004) 32. L. Pan, M.B. Sander, X. Huang, J. Li, M. Smith, E. Bittner, B. Bockrath and J.K. Johnson, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 126 (2004) 1308. N. Masciocchi, S. Galli, A. Sironi, E. Barea, J.A.R. Navarro, J.M. Salas and L.C. Tabares, Chem. Mater., 15 (2003) 2153. Global Information Inc. Report "Zeolites: Industry Trends and Worldwide Markets in 2010", Sept. 2001, http://www.the-infoshop.com. C. Marcilly, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 135 (2001) 37. M. Guisnet and J.P. Gilson, in M. Guisnet and J.P Gilson, Eds., Zeolites for Cleaner Technologies, Imperial College Press, London, 2002, 1. M. Stocker, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 2005, in press. K. Tanabe and W. Hoelderich, Appl. Catal. A, 181 (1999) 399. P. Marion, R. Jacquot, S. Ratton, M. Guisnet, in M. Guisnet and J.P Gilson, Eds., Zeolites for Cleaner Technologies, Imperial College Press, London, 2002, 281. S. Sircar and A.L. Myers, in S.M. Auerbach, K.A. Carrado and P.K. Dutta, Eds., Handbook of Zeolite Science and Technology, Marcel Dekker, New York, 2003, 1063. R.L. Virta, in U.S. Geological Survey Minerals Yearbook, 84,1999. T. Ambruster, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 135 (2001) 13. T. Nassivera, A.G. Eklund and C.C. Landry, J. Chromatogr. A, 973 (2002) 97. J. Zhao, F. Gao, Y. Fu, W. Jin, P. Yang and D. Zhao, Chem. Commun., (2002) 752. T. Martin, A. Galarneau, F. Di Renzo, D. Brunei, F. Fajula, S. Heinisch, G. Cretier, and J.L. Rocca, Chem. Mater., 16 (2004) 1725. D.H. Olson, G.D. Stucky and J.C. Vartuli, U.S. Patent 5 364 797 (1994). M.E. Gimon-Kinsel and K.J. Balkus Jr., Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 28 (1999) 113. G. Wirnsberger, P. Yang, B. J. Scott, B.F. Chmelka and G.D. Stucky, Spectrochim. Acta A, 57 (2001)2049. G. Wirnsberger, B. J. Scott and G.D. Stucky, Chem. Commun., (2001) 119.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Natural zeolites Carmine Colella Dipartimento d'Ingegneria dei Materiali e della Produzione, Universita Federico II, Piazzale V. Tecchio 80, 80125 Napoli, Italy
1. INTRODUCTION 2. FROM THE PAST TO PRESENT TIMES 2.1. The early times 2.2. Development of physical-chemical studies 2.3. The discovery of sedimentary zeolite deposits 2.4. The international natural zeolite organisations 3. DEFINITION AND NOMENCLATURE 4. FORMATION 4.1. Zeolite genesis 4.2. Zeolite occurrences 4.2.1. Diagenesis in hydrologically open systems 4.2.2. Diagenesis in hydrologically closed systems 4.2.3. Diagenesis in marine sediments 4.2.4. Burial diagenesis 4.2.5. Genesis from pyroclastic flow 4.3. Zeolites in volcaniclastic deposits 5. PROPERTIES 5.1. Mineralogy 5.2. Chemical and physical-chemical properties 5.2.1. Cation exchange 5.2.2. Reactions with alkalies 5.2.3. External surface reactivity 5.2.4. Physical adsorption 5.3. Other properties 5.3.1. Thermal properties 5.3.2. Physical-mechanical properties 6. APPLICATIONS 6.1. Applications based on ion exchange 6.2. Agricultural uses 6.3. Applications based on adsorption 6.4. Uses as building materials 6.5. Miscellany 7. CONCLUSION AND OUTLOOK BIBLIOGRAPHY REFERENCES
13
14
1. INTRODUCTION As anybody knows, research in the field of zeolite science and technology made its first steps with natural zeolites and was mostly focussed on natural zeolites until the beginning of the 1950s. With the introduction of zeolite synthesis and synthetic materials, interest moved towards these last products, which offered a series of advantages, including (a) wider versatility, due to the large variability of their structures, (b) more open frameworks, suitable for adsorption and catalysis, two of the pillars of the modern chemical technology, and (c) quality, i.e., constancy in constitution and chemistry. From then on, research on natural zeolites, apart from geological and mineralogical studies, was, therefore, mainly devoted to ion exchange, with the purpose to find applications in the removal of toxic and noxious cations from wastewaters of industrial, agricultural or nuclear origin. Successful efforts were also made in agricultural and building applications. The most recent frontier in the application of natural zeolites is in the field of life sciences. One of the drawbacks of natural zeolite research for application purposes is the belief that minerals are in any case a precious resource, compared to the synthetic counterparts, having as major advantage a large availability and, therefore, a lower cost. That is why much research, often with a low degree of innovation, has been and is being performed in unprofitable fields mainly in less favourite or emerging countries, where, for a strange coincidence, a large part of economically valuable zeolite formations are concentrated. Actually, considering natural zeolites as resources of economical value, may be correct, if we look at the raw material, but it may be absolutely untrue if we refer to the cost/benefit ratio, especially in applications for which specific structures and (relative) constancy in composition are needed. Effective usage of natural zeolites should be determined therefore not by the low cost of the material, but rather by the fulfilment of a unique or superior ability, in comparison with the synthetic species.
Fig. 1. Increment of the number of natural zeolites discovered, starting from their appearance on the mineralogy scenery.
15
On these bases, in the following, after some introductory notes on history, constitution, occurrences and formation of natural zeolites, a selection of real or realistic applications will be presented. In other words, instead of listing lots of hypothetical applications of no or doubtful economic value, emphasis will be given to uses in which (a) specific advantages of technical character are evident and/or (b) massive utilizations due to their inexpensiveness are expected. Given the vastness and the variety of the matter dealt with, in order to provide useful reference tools for untreated applications, a comprehensive bibliography of useful books and conference proceedings is included at the end of this chapter. 2. FROM THE PAST TO PRESENT TIMES 2.1. The early times The history begins about 250 years ago in Sweden. A famous mineralogist, Axel F. Cronstedt, was the first man who handled a sample of zeolite mineral, studying its apparent properties and discovering its strange behaviour upon heating [1]. Somebody says that the unknown mineral was stilbite, but there is no certain proof of its identity. On the contrary, the first zeolite, a clear evidence of which is found in the literature is chabazite, described by Bosch D'Antic in 1792 [2]. Several other zeolites were discovered in the following years, but rather slowly if one considers that one hundred years later, around 1850, only about twenty zeolite types were reported in mineralogy books, including analcime, brewsterite, chabazite, edingtonite, epistilbite, faujasite, gismondine, gmelinite, harmotome, heulandite, laumontite, levyne, mesolite, natrolite, phillipsite, scolecite, stilbite, and thomsonite. Starting from the middle of the 19th century until about 1975, there was a moderate increment in the number of zeolites discovered (about one new type every 6-7 years) and a clear acceleration in the last twenty five-thirty years (one mineral, in average, every year) (see Fig. 1). 2.2. Development of physical-chemical studies Hydrothermal zeolites were considered for long time mineralogical curiosities and their beautiful, euhedral, sometimes coloured, crystals had certainly prominent positions in private and public mineral collections. But, in the same time, their "strange" properties attracted the attention of scientists, who started investigations on their physical-chemical studies very early [3]. As regards adsorption properties, Damour, starting from 1840, observed in a series of studies that about all the zeolites known at that time could be reversibly dehydrated with no apparent structural damage [4]. Physical adsorption of gases, besides water vapour, on dehydrated zeolites (especially chabazite) was discovered by Friedel at the end of that century [5] and further investigated by Grandjean [6] and Seeliger [7], who incremented the number of gases and enlarged the experimental conditions. Early observations on adsorption selectivity by dehydrated chabazite (uptake of methanol, ethanol and formic acid; exclusion of acetone, ether and benzene) were made by Weigel and Steinhof in 1924 [8], but this important phenomenon was mainly studied by McBain, who first introduced the concept of "molecular sieving" [9]. Natural zeolites (essentially chabazite and mordenite) were further studied as adsorbents until the middle of the 1950s by Barrer and co-workers [10], before leaving space to the supervening synthetic zeolites. The ion exchange phenomenon was discovered around 1850, studying the behaviour of soils in contact with electrolytic solutions [11,12]. A few years later, Eichhorn [13] observed that zeolites, namely chabazite and natrolite, behaved as ion exchangers and
16 demonstrated the reversibility of the relevant reactions. Specific research was then suspended for long time and concentrated on products, called "permutites", a class of partially crystalline synthetic aluminosilicate exchangers, considered more promising than zeolites as water softeners [14]. Nevertheless some research on ion exchange selectivity of a variety of zeolites for peculiar cations, e.g., ammonium, was performed in the early decades of the 20th century (references in [15]). After a period of obscurity, in coincidence with the introduction of ion exchange resins [16], more prompt in exchanging cations, zeolites found a renewed valorisation, starting from the end of the 1950s, in various sectors of environmental relevance, e.g., treatment of wastewaters and soil rebuilding and remediation (see Sec. 6). 2.3. The discovery of sedimentary zeolite deposits For about two hundred years, zeolites were considered minerals of no practical interest, because of their exiguity in known occurrences in vugs and cavities of basalts (rocks with silica content ranging between 45% and 52%) and other trap-rock formations. However, the discovery of their unique and attractive properties useful for many applications of environmental and industrial relevance, promoted search campaigns to find more significant natural zeolite formations. Evidence for the existence of microcrystalline zeolite occurrences of volcanic origin had sporadically been reported in the literature (see, e.g., [17]), but nobody would have expected that so huge zeolite deposits would have been found in a few decades all over the world (see Sec. 4). Contrary to zeolite samples previously known, said of hydrothermal origin, which were characterized by beautiful, very pure, euhedral crystals of centimetre size (Fig. 2a), the new zeolite minerals, occurring in volcaniclastic rocks and said of sedimentary origin, formed usually at lower temperatures and through slower processes. They were crypto-crystalline (crystal size from 0.1 to a few micrometers, usually <10 um) (Fig. 2b), often co-crystallised with other zeolite species and constantly accompanied by conspicuous quantities of impurities, usually amounting to several tens percent. The early discovered sedimentary zeolite deposits, during the 1950s, were the Green tuff formation of Yokotemachi, Akira Prefecture, Japan, [18], the low-grade metamorphic rocks of Southland, New Zealand [19], and the Neapolitan yellow tuff, around Naples, Italy [20]. Many zeolite occurrences were made known a few years later in the western USA, as a result of a capillary five-year exploration campaign promoted by Union Carbide and other chemical companies [21]. After these, hundreds of zeolite formations were and are being discovered in many countries around the world. 2.4. The international natural zeolite organisations An important role in the diffusion of natural zeolites culture around the world and the promotion of the relevant scientific and technological research has been played by an international organisation, ICNZ (International Committee on Natural Zeolites), founded in 1976 with the purpose to serve as a focal point of worldwide interest in natural zeolites and to be instrumental in the organisation of conferences, field trips, symposia, and special sessions at national and international meetings on the subject of natural zeolites. Creator and propulsor of the Committee for over twenty years was Frederick A. Mumpton (1932-2004), who represented the soul of natural zeolites during his entire academic and scientific life. He organised and/or served as co-editor of the Proceedings of several international conferences and meetings, in particular those of the series: Occurrence, Properties and Utilization of Natural Zeolites (see Bibliography). In 2004 the Committee ceased and changed its name in INZA (Int. Association on Natural Zeolites), saving purposes, functions and activities.
17
Fig. 2. Phillipsite crystals, (a) macrocrystals of hydrothermal origin (sample from Collezione Vesuviana, Arcangelo Scacchi hall, Real Mineralogical Museum, Naples, Italy); (b) microcrystals of sedimentary origin covering a pumice wall in Neapolitan yellow tuff (sample from Rione Sanita, Naples, Italy) (SEM, Oxford-Cambridge S440) Recently, in 1991, a second international organisation has been established: the Natural Zeolites Commission of the International Zeolite Association (IZA-NZC). The purpose of this Commission, like the other IZA Commissions, is that of taking care of a specific sector of the zeolite world, preparing compilations, atlases, handbooks, maintaining data banks, establishing standard procedures. Peculiar objectives of the Natural Zeolites Commission are: (a) preparation of a worldwide catalogue of sedimentary zeolites with information on their occurrence, properties, use, and including also a series of standard analytical procedures for application purposes; (b) preparation of a reference book providing a summary of all our knowledge about natural zeolites, including genesis, mineralogy, crystal chemistry, physical properties and historical notes. 3. DEFINITION AND NOMENCLATURE The concept of natural zeolite and the connected classification underwent numerous changes in the last seventy years. The first definition, taking care not only of the physical-chemical behaviour, but also of the peculiar structure, is due to Hey in the early 1930s [22]. Further proposals on this subject were made by Smith [23] and Liebau [24], but the discovery of new minerals having only partly the structural features, the chemistry and the properties of the "traditional" zeolites, made necessary the redefinition of the term "zeolite" and the proposition of novel nomenclature rules. A Committee was constituted for this in 1993 by the International Mineralogical Association. After a capillary work lasted about five years a Report was produced on the Recommended nomenclature for zeolite minerals [25]. According to this Report "A zeolite mineral is a crystalline substance with a structure characterized by a framework of linked tetrahedra, each consisting of four O atoms surrounding a cation. This framework contains open cavities in the form of channels and cages. These are usually occupied by H2O molecules and extra-framework cations that are commonly exchangeable. The channels are large enough to allow the passage of guest species. In the hydrated phases, dehydration occurs at temperatures mostly below about 400°C and is largely reversible. The framework may be interrupted by (OH, F) groups: these occupy a tetrahedron apex that is not shared with adjacent tetrahedra". It is to be observed
18
that (a) a natural zeolite is no longer necessarily an alumino-silicate, since the tetrahedral (T) position in the framework may be occupied by other cations, than Si or Al, such as Be, P, Zn or others, (b) a natural zeolite is no longer necessarily a hydrated compound able to give rise to ion exchange, because also anhydrous and/or not exchanging minerals can be regarded as zeolites and (c) a natural zeolite is no longer necessarily characterized by a continuous tetrahedral framework, as T cations may sporadically be bound to monovalent species, such as OH or F. The new definition and the connected rules [25] allowed to recognise and to list, as for 1997, 57 zeolite types (Table 1). A few other zeolites have been discovered in the meanwhile, such as nabesite, a berillo-silicate (Na2BeSi40io-4H20) [26]. Table 1 List of natural zeolites* Name
Year of discovery
Amicite Ammonioleucite Analcime Barrerite Bellbergite1 Bikitaite Boggsite Brewsterite5 Chabazite5 Chiavennite2 Clinoptilolite3§ Cowlesite Dachiardite5 Edingtonite Epistilbite Erionite§ Faujasite45 Ferrierite8 Garronite Gaultite Gismondine Gmelinite5 Gobbinsite Gonnardite Goosecreekite Gottardiite Harmotome Heulandite3§ Hsianghualite Kalborsite Laumontite Leucite Levyne5
1979 1986 1797 1975 1993 1957 1989 1822 1792 1983 1923 1975 1906 1825 1826 1898 1842 1918 1962 1994 1817 1825 1982 1896 1980 1996 1801 1822 1958 1980 1805 1791 1825
Idealised formula K4Na4[Al8Si8O32]-10H2O NH4[AlSi206] Na[AlSi2O6]-H2O Na2[Al2Si7Oi8]-6H2O Me2Sr2Ca2M>'4[Al18Sii8O72]-30H2O Li[AlSi2O6]-H2O Ca8Na3[Al19Si77O,92]-70H2O (Sr,Ba)2[Al4Sii2O32]-10H2O (Ca0.5,Na,K)4[Al4Si4O24]- 12H2O CaMn[Be 2 Si 5 Oi 3 (OH) 2]-2H2O (Me/,Me//0.5)6[Al6Si3o072]-~20H20 Ca[Al2Si3O10]-5.3H2O (Ca0.5,Na,K)4.5[Al4.5Si2o-i9048]-~13H20 Ba[Al2Si3O10]-4H2O (Ca,Na 2 )[Al 2 Si 4 O| 2 ]-4H 2 O K2(Na,Cao.5)8[Al,oSi26072]-~30H20 (Na,Ca0.5,Mgo.5,K)x[AlxSii2-x024]-16H20 (K,Na,Mgo.5,Cao.5MAl6Si3o072]-18H2O NaCa 2 .5[Al 6 Siio0 32 ]-14H 2 0 Na 4 [Zn 2 Si 7 O, 8 ]-5H 2 O Ca[Al2Si2O8]-4.5H2O (Na2)Ca,K2)4[Al8Si ,6O48] -22H2O Na5[Al5SinO32]-12H2O (Na,Ca)6.8[(Al,Si)2o04o]-12H20 Ca[Al2Si6Oi6]-5H2O Na3Mg3Ca5[Al19Si117O272]-93H2O (Bao.5,Cao.5,K,Na)5[Al5Si,i032]-12H20 (Me//0.5,Me/)9[Al9Si27O72]-~24H2O Li2Ca3[Be3Si3O12]-F2 K 6 [Al 4 Si 6 0 2 o]B(OH) 4 Cl Ca4[Al8Sii6O48]-18H2O K[AlSi2O6] (Ca0.5,Na,K)6[Al6Si12O36]-~17H2O
3-letter code GIS ANA ANA STI EAB BIK BOG BRE CHA -CHI HEU DAC EDI EPI ERI FAU FER GIS VSV GIS GME GIS NAT GOO NES PHI HEU ANA EDI? LAU ANA LEV
19 Table 1 (continued) Name
Ye;ir of discove;ry
Lovdarite Maricopaite 2 Mazzite Merlinoite Mesolite Montesommaite Mordenite Mutinaite Natrolite Offretite Pahasapaite 5 Partheite 2 Paulingite 5 Perlialite Phillipsite 5 Pollucite 7 Roggianite 2 Scolecite Stellerite Stilbite§ Terranovaite Thomsonite Tschernichite Tschortnerite 8 Wairakite Weinebeneite Willhendersonite 9 Yugawaralite
1973 1988 1974 1977 1813 1990 1864 1997 1803 1890 1987 1979 1960 1984 1825 1846 1969 1813 1909 1801 1997 1820 1991 1997 1955 1992 1984 1952
Idealised formula K4Nai2[Be8Si28O72]-18H2O Pb7Ca2[Ali2Si36(0,OH)IOo]-~32(H20,OH) Mg2.5K2Cai.5[Al10Si26O72]-30H2O K5Ca2[Al9Si23O64]-22H2O Nai6Cai6[Al48Si72O240]-64H2O K9[Al9Si23O64]-10H2O (Na2,Ca,K2)4[Al8Si4o096]-28H20 Na3Ca4[AliiSi85Oi92]-60H2O Na 2 [Al 2 Si 3 O i0 ]-2H 2 O CaKMg[Al5Sii3O36]-16H2O (Me//5.5,Me/)Li8[Be24P24O96]-38H2O Ca2[Al4Si4Oi5(OH)2]-4H2O (K,Cao.5,Na,Bao.5) io[Al i oSi32084] -27-44H2O K9Na(Ca,Sr)[Al 12Si24O72] • 15H2O (K,Na,Ca0.5,Bao.5)x[AlxSi,6.x032]-12H20 (Cs,Na)[AlSi2O6]-nH2O Ca2[Be(OH)2Al2Si4Oi3]-<2.5H2O Ca[Al2Si3Oi0]-3H2O Ca[Al2Si7Oi8]-7H2O (Cao.5,Na,K)9 [Al9Si27O72]-28H2O Na,Ca[Al 3 Sii 7 0 4 o]->7H 2 0 Ca2Na[Al5Si502o]-6H20 Ca[Al2Si6Oi6]-~8H2O Ca4Me3Cu3(OH)8[Ali2Sii2O48]-nH2O Ca[Al2Si4O,2]-2H2O Ca[Be3(PO4)2(OH)2]-4H2O KxCa(i.5-o.5x)[Al3Si3Oi2]-5H20 Ca[Al 2 Si 6 0 16 ]-4H 2 0
3 -letter code LOV -MOR MAZ MER NAT MON MOR MFI NAT OFF RHO -PAR PAU LTL PHI ANA -RON NAT STI STI TER THO BEA ANA WEI CHA YUG
T h e reported zeolite minerals are 61 instead of 57 as referred to in the text. This is due to the fact that, for historical and opportunity reasons, different names have been saved for the isostructural couples clinoptilolite-heulandite and harmotome-phillipsite and for the isostructural triplet analcimepollucite-wairakite. As regards the 3-letter framework-type codes, see [27]. § Zeolite types for which the existence of series has been recognised. A series is constituted by two or more isostructural individual species each characterized by the prevailing presence of one specific extra-framework cation. 1 Me = (K,Ba,Sr); Me' = (Ca,Na).2 A hyphen before the structural code indicates an interrupted framework. 3 Me' = (Na,K); Me" = (Ca,Sr,Ba,Mg). 4 x = 3.2-4.4.5Me" = Ca; Me' = Li3.6KL2Nao.2.6x ~ 4-7. 7 Cs + n = 1. 8 Me = (K2,Ca,Sr,Ba);n £ 2 0 . 9 0 ^ ^ .
4. FORMATION 4.1. Zeolite genesis Zeolite formation in nature follows pathways which are familiar in laboratory synthesis. Zeolite nucleation, crystallisation and crystal growth take place as a result of slow
20
to fast cooling of warm to hot magmas, which are basic, oversaturated in silicate and aluminate species and contain alkaline and/or alkali-earth cations. Magmas may be of volcanic origin or may originate from the interaction of warm to hot fluids with loose volcaniclastic materials, usually fine ashes, deposited in more or less far times as a product of volcanic eruptions. In general, the series of reactions which lead to the formation of zeolite crystals can be schematised as follows: hot fluid + volcanic ash — dissolutlon > oversaturated basic magma — coo/ '" g > zeolite crystals {solution + gel)
The basic character of the magma, deriving from the interaction of the original glassy material with water (hydrolysis) [28], favours the tetrahedral coordination of aluminium, which contributes with silicon to the formation of zeolite framework. The chemistry of the ash and therefore the chemical composition of the resulting solution, together with temperature, are the main parameters playing a structure-directing role. An intermediate stage of glass-to-zeolite conversion is the formation of a gel [28-30], which appears in the early stages of the glass-water interaction, but remains along the whole zeolite crystallisation pathway [29,30]. Its role, however, is not directly connected to nucleation and growth, as there is evidence that zeolite nuclei form from the oversaturated solution at the glass shards / solution interface [31]. Two main parameters differentiate natural zeolitisation from laboratory synthesis: temperature, which ranges from room conditions to several hundred degrees Celsius, and time, which may be very short [32], but also very long, in the case of low kinetics of glass-to-zeolite conversion, especially at low temperatures. 4.2. Zeolite occurrences Despite the apparent simplicity of the process of natural zeolitization, geologists and mineralogists were able to distinguish various zeolite occurrences which correspond to different formation mechanisms in relation to different physical, chemical and geological situations. This matter has been recently reviewed by Hay and Sheppard [33], but an easier and linear approach to this subject may be found in an older paper by Gottardi [34]. As already mentioned, natural zeolites may be classified as hydrothermal or sedimentary, in reference to processes which are not ever very clearly distinguishable from each other. Basically and very schematically, the main differences involve two parameters: distance between the sites of glass dissolution and the sites of crystal deposition, which are usually far in the hydrothermal process and close in sedimentary process (also said diagenesis), and temperature, which is usually higher in the former than in the latter [34]. As regards in particular diagenesis, various distinct situations have been recognised by the geologists [33,34]. The main diagenetic zeolite occurrences are briefly described in the following. 4.2.1. Diagenesis in hydrologically open systems Meteoric and surface waters, percolating through the thick layers of thin volcanic material, become always more basic and saline, as they penetrate in depth. This results in a vertical zonation with formation of clays near the surface and then, going downwards, zeolites, from open types (clinoptilolite, chabazite, phillipsite) to narrow-pore (analcime), and finally alkalifeldspars. Generally, only one or two zeolite species are formed in open systems. A typical example of this type of occurrence is the John Day Formation, Oregon, characterised by fresh glass and clinoptilolite zones, plus sporadic K-feldspar [35].
21
4.2.2. Diagenesis in hydrologically closed systems This system is represented by a closed basin, made of impermeable rocks and filled in the past by a saline alkaline lake. Water in this case could not permeate downwards but only evaporate, so the deposit develops horizontally, instead of vertically as in the previous occurrence. Here pH and salinity in the fluids tend to increase, giving rise to brines, e.g., basic, alkali-rich solutions. Concentric zones of authigenic minerals are so formed, from an outer and upper ring of little altered glass and clay minerals, to zeolites, analcime and a finally alkali-feldspars. A good example for this type of occurrence is Lake Tecopa, California, where the zeolitic ring is constituted by phillipsite, clinoptilolite and erionite, followed by the central feldspar zone [36]. 4.2.3. Diagenesis in marine sediments There are many sub-occurrences belonging to this type of zeolite deposition [34]. One of the most important (essentially from a scientific point of view) is that occurring in ocean floors Here, the contact between sea water and deep sea sediments results in very long times, due to the low temperature, in zeolite formation. Phillipsite usually prevails in surface layers [37], whereas clinoptilolite is preferred in the deeper layers [38]. 4.2.4. Burial diagenesis The burial of surface levels through sedimentation processes and the consequent increase of the geothermal gradient are cause of zeolite formation. Generally, the most open (and hydrated) zeolites, e.g., clinoptilolite and heulandite, prevail in the most recent layers, whereas more compact zeolites (e.g., analcime and laumontite) are found in the ancient and deeper ones. This type of occurrence is typical of several Circum-Pacific countries, such as Japan, New Zealand and the west coast of the United States [39]. 4.2.5. Genesis from pyroclastic flow This zeolitisation process is not ascribable stricto sensu to a real diagenesis, resembling someway hydrothermal genesis. The original products, made of pyroclastic material mixed with abundant fluids, derived from freatomagmatic activities and were emplaced at temperatures of a few hundred degrees Celsius. Zeolites, mostly phillipsite and chabazite with minor analcime, presumably formed at high temperatures, very shortly after the emplacement, through the action of the fluids entrapped inside the mass. This type of occurrence is typical of some European deposits, e.g., those of the Neapolitan area, south Italy [40]. 4.3. Zeolites in volcaniclastic deposits Contrary to strictly hydrothermal types, characterised by large crystals, spread in rocks where their presence is absolutely sporadic (see, e.g., Fig. 2a), diagenetic zeolites are concentrated in enormous formations, generally called tuff deposits, from which they can be readily quarried and, after suitable beneficiation processes, utilised. Only a small part, about one third, of the natural zeolite types reported in Table 1 have been found in sedimentary occurrences, as those described above [33,41]. In some instances such occurrences are rare, as in the case of faujasite, whose only known sedimentary formation is in the Aritayn region, Jordan [42]; in other instances they are very frequent [3]. Clinoptilolite-rich tuffs, for instance, are widely spread in numerous locations all over the world and reserves are being continuously discovered. At present exploited deposits (or in view of possible exploitation) are present in Europe (Bulgaria, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Romania, Slovakia, Slovenia, Turkey, Yugoslavia) [41], in Russia and several states of the
22
former Soviet Union (Georgia, Ukraine, Azerbaijan), in Asia (China, Iran, Japan, Korea), in Africa (South Africa), in Australia and New Zealand and in many countries of America, such as Argentina, Cuba, Mexico and the United States [43]. Apart from clinoptilolite, other frequent, technologically relevant, sedimentary zeolite occurrences are those of mordenite, phillipsite and chabazite. Mordenite is present in several deposits in eastern Europe (Bulgaria, Hungary, Slovakia, Yugoslavia), in Japan, Russia, the United States and New Zealand [43,44]. Monomineralic deposits of phillipsite and chabazite are infrequent [21,43,44]. On the contrary these two zeolites are rather common in joint occurrences, especially in Italy and in a few other locations, in central Europe (Germany) and in Canary Islands (Spain) [40]. Apart from the described types, it is difficult to establish with certainty which sedimentary zeolites, among those discovered [33,41], may have a potential economic interest, because exploitation and utilisations have in some instances a merely local value. Table 2 (first column) lists some zeolite types which, due to relative abundance and/or technical interest, are being exploited or may have chances for future exploitations. 5. PROPERTIES 5.1. Mineralogy Zeolite tuffs are rocks which contain, besides zeolites, various other crystalline or amorphous phases. One parameter that is especially important in determining the nature of both the formed zeolites and the secondary phases is the silicon content of the original rock. More siliceous rocks gave rise, in fact, to siliceous zeolites, such as clinoptilolite, ferrierite and mordenite, whereas intermediate-silica materials led to the formation of the less siliceous analcime, chabazite and phillipsite. The overall mineralogical composition may vary greatly, even in the single deposit, especially in the contents of the various phases, less as regards their nature. Such an inconstancy is ascribable to the chemical and mineralogical heterogeneity of the parent volcanic rocks and also to the different mechanisms of zeolite genesis. Table 2 Principal zeolites in volcaniclastic rocks* Zeolite species Tsi
Analcime Chabazite Clinoptilolite Erionite Faujasite Ferrierite Laumontite Mordenite Phillipsite 1
0.60-0.74 0.58-0.80 0.80-0.85 0.72-0.79 0.68-0.74 0.83-0.85 0.66-0.71 0.80-0.85 0.52-0.77
Chemistry1 Cations CEC (meqg"1) Na Ca, Na, K Na, K, Ca K, Na, Ca Ca, Na, Mg Ca Mg, K, Na Na, Ca K, Na, Ca
3.57-5.26 2.49-4.66 2.04-2.60 2.68-3.42 2.98-3.42 2.09-2.30 3.82-4.31 2.05-2.43 2.92-5.64
Structural features2 Window s>ize (A) Void vol. 1.6 x 4.2 3.8 3.1 x 7.5 3.6 x 5.1 7.4 4.2 x 5.4 4.0 x 5.3 6.5 x 7.0 3.8
0.18 0.48 0.34 0.36 0.53 0.24 0.35 0.26 0.30
Chemical data mostly taken from [33]. Tsi = fraction of tetrahedral positions occupied by Si. Extraframework cations are those more frequently found. Cation exchange capacity (CEC) was calculated from idealised formulae [33,44], having Na as the only extra-framework cation.2 Window size is that of the largest channel [27]; void volume is expressed as cm3 of liquid water per cm3 of crystal [45].
23
The mineral assemblages of the most common zeolite occurrences is as follows. Clinoptilolite- and mordenite-containing tuffs are usually zeolite-rich with contents higher than 50%, up to 80% and over [44]. According to the high silicon content of the parent rock, usual accompanying phases are smectite, quartz, cristobalite and unreacted glass. Sometimes a limited amount of mordenite in clinoptilolite-rich tuffs or clinoptilolite in mordenite-rich tuffs may also be present. Calcite, muscovite and feldspar are other sporadic accompanying phases. Erionite deposits are very rarely monomineralic [46]. It is usually associated to other zeolites, such as clinoptilolite, chabazite and phillipsite and, besides, some clay minerals and feldspars. Its content in the rock is usually low, 20% or less, but the use of these materials is discouraged, because their presence in the environment, due to the thread-like morphology of the erionite crystals, has been associated with the incidence of mesothelioma [47,48]. As regards zeolite formed from less siliceous original magmas, typical examples are those of phillipsite and chabazite, whose parent rocks were usually of trachytic nature. In these cases, the most frequent mineral assemblages include, apart from the two zeolites (often co-present in the same deposit), minor amounts of analcime, biotite, pyroxene and some unreacted glassy material; clay minerals may be sometimes present, too [49]. Zeolite contents are usually high (50-70% or more). Most Italian deposits, spread in the central-southern part of the peninsula, are chabazite-rich with subordinate phillipsite contents, with the important exception of the tuff surrounding the town of Naples (the so-called Neapolitan yellow tuff) in which the situation is opposite. Inconstancy of composition of this type of tuff is a rule, also within the same deposit [50]. 5.2. Chemical and physical-chemical properties Table 2 (second to fourth columns) summarizes some chemical features of the main sedimentary zeolites. It is evident that the mentioned zeolites are medium- to high-silica types. Phillipsite and chabazite belong to the first category, especially if we consider that the values of T$i in the most common joint occurrences [see, e.g., 40] are in the ranges of 0.710.73 and 0.69-0.72, respectively. Instead, clinoptilolite, ferrierite and mordenite are to be considered siliceous zeolites. This chemical character results naturally in different cation exchange capabilities, as it can be seen in the fourth column of Table 2 (CEC values). It is worth to observe that these values are merely indicative, as they refer to pure zeolite species, not to zeolite-rich rocks. On the basis of the theoretical CEC values (Table 2) and zeolite contents in tuff occurrences (see Sub-sec. 5.1), more realistic CEC values for the most common types of zeolitic tuffs may be worked out, as follows: • clinoptilolite-rich tuffs: CEC values ranging between 1.2 and 2.0 meq g"'; • mordenite-rich tuffs: CEC values >1.0 meq g"1 with sporadic much higher values, up to 1.82.0 meq g"1; • phillipsite- and chabazite-rich tuffs: CEC values in the range 1.8-2.5 meq g"1. 5.2.1. Cation exchange The chemistry of natural zeolites may have important effects on their ion exchange properties, mainly in terms of selectivity. It is well known that selectivity is a function of various parameters, depending on (1) framework topology, (2) ion size and shape, (3) charge density on the anionic framework, (4) ion valence and (5) electrolyte concentration in the aqueous phase [51]. Within the same zeolite type, the variation of the framework composition (in practice, Si/Al ratio) and therefore of the framework charge density, affects the cation selectivity [52], as it has experimentally been proven for phillipsite [53]. It is improper, stricto sensu, to compare with each other, in terms of selectivity behaviour, different zeolites having
24
different framework compositions. It is, however, undeniable, according to the EisenmanSherry theory [54], that zeolites with medium to weak anionic field (medium to high silicon content), as most natural zeolites are, prefer, in uni-univalent exchange, cations with low charge density, e.g., NH/, Cs+, whereas in uni-divalent exchange, monovalent cations are preferred, unless divalent cations are characterised by low energy of hydration. Fig. 3, reporting some cation exchange isotherms of clinoptilolite (Fig. 3a) and phillipsite (Fig. 3b), show, although from a purely qualitative point of view, how these two zeolites satisfactorily conform to the predicted behaviour. Curves above the diagonal demonstrate selectivity for NH4+, Cs+, and Pb2+; minor selectivity or unselectivity for Sr2+, Cd2+ and Zn2+ (curves partially or abundantly beneath the diagonal) are mostly explainable by the values of the hydration energy of the three cations (-1443, 1806 and 2044 kJ mol"1, respectively), compared to that of Pb2+ (-1480 kJ mol"'). 5.2.2. Reactions with alkalies Zeolites are generally unstable in alkaline environments, as they tend to transform, similarly to glassy systems, into more stable phases, usually into other framework silicates. This behaviour has suggested in some occasions to utilise zeolitic tuffs as raw material for zeolite synthesis [see, e.g., 60]. The interaction of zeolite-rich materials with Ca(OH)2 is of special interest, because zeolites, like other reactive aluminosilicate systems, e.g., crushed bricks, give rise to calcium silicates and aluminates, which are able to harden upon hydration in both aerial and aqueous environments. This behaviour, already known in ancient times, is typical of a volcanic, mostly glassy material, called pozzolana, which is the genetic precursor of the mentioned Neapolitan yellow tuff, widely spread in the surroundings of Naples, Italy [61]. That is why every material able to behave as pozzolana is called "pozzolanic material" and the property to react with lime is called "pozzolanic activity".
Fig. 3. Profiles of some ion exchange isotherms of Na-exchanged clinoptilolite from Pentalofos (Greece) (a) [55] and Na- exchanged phillipsite from various sites near Naples (Italy) (b) [53,56-59], at 25°C. £(z) and E(S} = equivalent cation fraction in the solid and in the liquid phases, respectively.
25
Fig. 4. Reactivity test of various tuff materials with Ca(OH)2 at 25°C [63]. ERT = sample from Agua Prieta (Sonora, Mexico) (erionite 60%, clinoptilolite 10%); CHT = sample from Marano (Naples, Italy) (phillipsite 31%, chabazite 27%, smectite 4%); CLT = sample from Eskisehir (Anatolia, Turkey) (clinoptilolite 91%); PHT = sample from Tufino (Naples, Italy) (phillipsite 46%, chabazite 5%, analcime 9%, smectite 10%). Residual percentages: inert phases.
Pozzolana has been used since ancient times to obtain, in mixture with Ca(OH)2, hydraulic mortars, sometimes referred to as Roman cement, characterised by a memorable durability, which allows some civil works of about two thousands years ago be still preserved nowadays (e.g., the Pantheon in Rome) [62]. The ability to act as a pozzolanic material is typical of any zeolitic tuff, but the activity is function of different chemical parameters, especially nature, chemistry and content of tuff constituents. Fig. 4 summarizes the results of the reactivity test of four tuff samples with Ca(OH)2, i.e., the ability of these materials to fix lime more or less readily [63]. It is evident that (a) all the tuffs denote a remarkable reactivity for Ca(OH)2; (b) the fastest kinetics is presented by the erionite-rich tuff, which is able to fix in 15 hours the same amount of lime fixed by the other three tuffs in 3 days. The reactivity of the four tuffs is comparable to or ever higher than that of the same pozzolana. Although this statement can not be generalised, it is interesting to note that a typical pozzolana, subjected to the same test, was able to fix the same maximum amount of Ca(OH)2, reported in Fig. 4, in times of the order of 90 days [64]. 5.2.3. External surface reactivity It is well known that zeolites, apart from being microporous solids, exhibit large, negatively charged, external surfaces. Surface charges are balanced by weakly bonded inorganic cations, which results in possible interactions either with large organic cations, unable to enter the internal channels, or with polar molecules. Charge-balancing surface cations in natural zeolites (typically alkaline and alkali-earth cations) can be replaced quantitatively, and essentially irreversibly, by long-chain organic cations, e.g., hexadecyltrimefhylammonium (HDTMA+), ethylhexadecyldimethylammonium, and cetylpyridinium, having also surfactant properties [65]. This involves only the "external"
26
cation exchange capability, leaving unchanged and still available the "internal" cation exchange capability, i.e., most of the original CEC. Surfactant modifications of zeolites, inspired by analogous studies on clay minerals [66], strongly alter the chemistry of the external surface, which becomes enriched in organic carbon, acquires a positive charge and displays anion exchange properties. Accordingly, these materials, even though they save their original ability to exchange cations, are effective to remove inorganic anions from water and, in addition, they exhibit also the capacity to sorb organic molecules. In a series of experiments, a clinoptilolite-rich material from Winston (New Mexico, USA), containing 74% zeolite and 5% smectite, was able to take up by cation exchange an amount of HDTMA as high as 200 meqkg"1. This modified material, while retaining its original ability to exchange Pb2+, displayed a notable affinity for CrC>42~ and also for organic soil pollutants as benzene and perchloroethylene [67]. Humic substances, which are very complex, molecular flexible polyelectrolytes, are common constituents of soil, where they play the fundamental role to store nutrients and to assure their transfer to rhizosphere. These substances, called also humic acids (HA), but normally present in soil in anionic form [68], are stabilised through the formation of organomineral aggregates with colloidal mineral phases, usually clay minerals, C. The aggregation, which can be schematised as [(C-M-HA)x]y, is realised by a cationic bridge, constituted by a polyvalent cation, M [68]. Zeolitic tuffs demonstrated to have an analogous behaviour as clay minerals. Fig. 5 reports some adsorption isotherms of HA on untreated and cation-enriched phillipsite-rich tuff [69]. It is evident that, considering the original untreated tuff as reference, adsorption is more effective, when zeolitic tuff is in Ca2+-enriched form, whereas preexchange with Na+ depresses the formation of the organo-mineral aggregate.
Fig. 5. Profiles of some sorption isotherms of humic acid (HA) on a phillipsite-rich tuff from Marano (Naples, Italy) (see composition in the caption of Fig. 4) at 30°C [69]. q = amount of sorbed HA; C = equilibrium HA concentration in the contact solution; Ca = Ca-enriched tuff; Na = Na-enriched tuff; UNT = untreated tuff.
27
Other large organic molecules may favourably interact with natural zeolite or clay surfaces. Of interest is the ability of these materials, e.g., clinoptilolite- or montmorilloniterich rocks, to adsorb on their hydrophilic, negatively charged surfaces complex substances, such as aflatoxins, which are toxic secondary metabolites of several agricultural products, containing polar functional groups [70,71]. Adsorption, which has been proven either in-vitro or in-vivo, is effective and amounts to some hundred ug per g of adsorber. 5.2.4. Physical adsorption Comprehensive review papers on the sorption properties of natural zeolites can be found in literature [72,73]. Referring in particular to the main sedimentary zeolites, the last two columns in Table 2 show some structural features of interest for sorption applications. Chabazite, clinoptilolite, faujasite and mordenite, which couple reasonably large to large window sizes with wide inner volumes (except mordenite), appear the most suitable materials for adsorption processes. Fig. 6 (a, b), showing some adsorption isotherms of gas and vapours of environmental interest, on chabazite-, clinoptilolite- and faujasite-rich tuffs [74], confirms the expectations. In fact, the best results are presented by the material containing the large-pore faujasite, which displays a normalised adsorption capacity roughly twice that of chabazite-rich tuff capacity and even better, compared to the clinoptilolite-rich tuff. Adsorption rates appear rather high for all the three samples. As regards sulfur dioxide, the performances of the faujasite sample are still the most favourable, whereas those of the other two zeolites are comparable with each other. The results of ammonia adsorption on faujasite are of interest, too. Adsorption capacity is, however, only about half of that displayed for sulfur dioxide and also kinetics appears slower.
Fig. 6. (a) Adsorption isotherms of water vapour on a -90% faujasite-rich tuff (enriched sample) from Aritayn (north-east Jordan) (squares); a chabazite-rich tuff (47% chabazite, 16% phillipsite) from Vulsini (central Italy) (triangles); and a 44% clinoptilolite-rich tuff from Palestra (north-east Greece) (circles), at 25°C [74]. Non-adsorbent phases are not reported, (b) Adsorption isotherms of sulfur dioxide on the same materials (same symbols) at the same temperature. Filled symbols: ammonia adsorption on Aritayn faujasite.
28
5.3. Other properties 5.3.1. Thermal properties The thermal behaviour of zeolites has thoroughly been investigated. When heated, a zeolite powder undergoes a series of physical and chemical changes, which include water loss, decomposition and gas evolution, phase transition, structure breakdown, re-crystallisation, melting, and others [75]. The thermal characterisation of natural zeolites has been carried out by various techniques and the relevant data may be found in several publications [44,76-78]. One of the more interesting thermal properties of natural zeolites, similarly to other hydrated materials, such as perlite, is that they expand on heating, due to rapid water evolution at temperatures at which matter is plastic. This enables, starting from zeolite grains, to obtain lightweight materials, having unit weight up to only one third of the parent tuff stone and, in addition, displaying good sound-proofing and heat insulation. Tuff expansion is obtained by quick heating at temperatures of 1250°C or above, depending on zeolite nature, chemical composition and rock constitution, followed by a rapid quenching to room temperature. Expanded materials have been prepared from clinoptilolite- or mordenite-rich rocks [3], but interesting results have been collected more recently starting from phillipsite- or chabazite-rich tuffs, having a zeolite grade >50% and a SiO2/fluxing (Fe2O3 + Na2O + K2O + MgO + CaO) ratio >3 [79]. The treatment was made at temperatures ranging between 1380 and 1400°C for 2-3 minutes (soaking time) with subsequent quenching. Obtained products were practically not permeable to water, presented a remarkable expansion (>100%) and were characterised by low bulk densities, in the range of 0.9-1.1 g cm"3. Zeolite tuff stones display interesting thermal-insulating properties, due to the combination of the physical-chemical features of their zeolitic constituents with the properties connected to their nature of porous stones. This makes the thermal conductivity of tuff stones particularly low, in the range 0.32-038 W m'1 K"', compared to that of other natural or artificial stone materials, whose values are at least 2 up to 8-10 times bigger [80]. Table 3 Main physical-mechanical properties' of some zeolitized tuffs and other stone materials [80] Tuff deposits Italian3 Rhenish4 Transylvanian5 Former USSR6 Clay brick Limestone Sandstone
Zeolites2 Phi and/or cha Cha + phi or cha Cli Cli or cli + mor -
^(kN m"3) 10-16 13-17 16-23 6-12 15-24 23-26 18-26
P(%) 37-61 31-43 26-31 19-44 8-42 5-15 4-20
cr(MPa) 1-13 5-20 2-4
24-79 10-45 49-147 39-127
y = unit weight; P = percent porosity; a = uniaxial compressive strength. Cha = chabazite; cli = clinoptilolite; mor = mordenite; phi = phillipsite. 3 Samples from various tuff deposits in centralsouthern Italy [80]. 4 This material is locally called trass (Eifel region, Germany). 5 Extending from northern to central Romania. 6 Deposits covering the entire territory of the former USSR from west (Ukraine) to far east (Kamchatka, Russia).
29 As far as heat capacity is concerned, zeolitic tuff has a thermal storage capacity that is greater than that of other non-adsorbent building materials as a result of water adsorption phenomena and the associated heat of adsorption [80]. This explains the ability of zeolitic tuffs to act as heat and humidity regulators. The interior of buildings made with zeolitic tuff stones is, in fact, cool during the day and warm at night, as zeolite removes heat from the environment by desorbing water vapour during the warmest hours of the day and returns this heat during the coolest hours of the night by re-adsorbing water. 5.3.2. Physical-mechanical properties The finely crystalline zeolitic matrix of tuffs cements the other non zeolitic particles and is responsible for the overall mechanical properties of the material. The compactness and the consequent physical-mechanical properties are somewhat variable as they are function of various parameters, such as mineral composition, tuff genesis, and original conditions of the deposit, especially as regards looseness of the parent material, grain size distribution, and others. Table 3 summarizes some data on unit weight, y, porosity, P, and uniaxial compressive strength, a, of a few tuff samples and other stone materials. Compared with other building materials, zeolite tuffs display higher porosities and weaker mechanical properties, which accounts for their inferior durability. It is noteworthy that, unlike other building materials, zeolitized tuffs show no strict relationship between P and a, possibly due to the heterogeneity of the materials. 6. APPLICATIONS There is a long tradition of applied research on natural zeolites in several sectors of industrial, agricultural or environmental significance. Updated reviews on these subject have frequently appeared in Proceedings of Conferences on natural zeolites (see Bibliography). Some additional useful papers, reporting the state of art on natural zeolites utilisations, may also be found in the current literature [see, e.g., 3,81-83]. In analysing such literature, care should be used to avoid to mistake real applications for potential or even hypothetical applications. It is obvious that every zeolite, natural or synthetic, possesses a series of basic properties, i.e., it is potentially a catalyst, an adsorber and a cation exchanger, but this does not mean that it can be really used as a catalyst, an adsorber or a cation exchanger. Application, in fact, implies not only possessing the specific property, but having also a series of other requirements, such as specificity, efficiency, reliability, high cos^enefit ratio. Several uses, which have been or are continuously being proposed for natural zeolites fail in one or more of the previous requirements. Often it is believed that natural zeolites are inexpensive, compared to synthetic zeolites. This is certainly true if the specific application requires little or no tuff processing, but sometimes processing is necessary. Ackley et al. [84], for instance, have demonstrated that the global expenses to process a natural zeolite for a hypothetical use in the purification and separation of gases, would raise its original cost up to 60% over the cost of a commercial zeolite 13X, which is , in addition, definitely more effective. On the basis of the preceding considerations, reported applications will be limited to those, realised or potential, in which natural zeolites display either specificity and/or real inexpensiveness. 6.1. Applications based on ion exchange As mentioned in the Sub-sec. 5.2, natural zeolites display exclusive ion exchange properties for some cationic pollutants of water. This is due to both excellent selectivities (see
30
Fig. 3) [54,85] and reasonable exchange rates, K, ranging between 10" -10" 1 meq" min" [86]. For these reasons, on the basis of laboratory and pilot plant experiments performed by Ames and co-workers [e.g., 87], uses in wastewater purification were proposed since the beginning of the 1960s. Relevant applications have been reviewed in the recent literature [3,82,83,88,89]. Only the main (and most successful) uses will be presented here. Clinoptilolite-rich tuffs have been and are being largely used for removing ammonium from municipal sewages. Large-scale facilities have been constructed, especially in the United States, e.g., in Tahoe Truckee Sewage District, California, and in Rosemont, Minnesota, [90], but smaller plants are reported also in other countries, such as Japan and Hungary [3]. Bed regeneration is performed by NaCl and CaC^ solutions. The exhausted regenerant is recovered and recycled, after ammonia air-stripping by alkalinisation. Stripped ammonia is absorbed by a sulphuric acid solution to give a concentrated ammonium sulphate solution used as fertiliser. An improved procedure to recover either ammonium or phosphate from municipal sewages has been proposed, but the procedure did not go beyond the pilot-plant stage. According to Liberti et al. [91], the above nutrients are separately removed from the sewage by ion exchange with a clinoptilolite-rich tuff and an anionic resin, respectively, and recovered from the mixed, exhausted regenerant solutions as precipitated MgNHUPO^FhO, usable as slow release fertiliser. Processes based on ion exchange are successfully utilized in several countries, e.g., United States, Hungary, Russia and Ukraine, also to remove or reduce ammonia in drinking water [82]. Similarly, natural zeolites of different nature are used in aquaculture to remove from re-circulating hatchery waters ammonium produced by the decomposition of excrement and/or unused food [82]. Further, a Ca-exchanged clinoptiloliterich tuff has been proposed to remove ammonium from NASA's advanced life-support wastewater system [92]. Application of natural zeolites in the treatment of nuclear wastewaters is also widely reported in the technical literature [3,82,88]. For reasons of selectivity (Fig. 3), the most frequently treated radio-nuclides have been 137Cs and 90Sr [87]. Natural zeolites are attractive especially because of their cheapness and much more elevated resistance to nuclear degradation, compared with organic resins. Decontamination by ion exchange allows to transfer radio-nuclides from low-level waste streams of nuclear reactors into zeolitic tuff, which is then stored directly or after incorporation into concrete for long-term burial. Natural zeolites utilised for nuclear waste treatments are chiefly chabazite- and clinoptilolite-rich tuffs. Nuclear sites where applications have been and/or are being realised are spread in the United States, e.g., Richland, Washington, [87], Idaho Falls, Idaho, [87], Oak Ridge, Tennessee [93], West Valley, New York, [94], but a few examples are also reported elsewhere, e.g., Sellafield, U.K. [95]. Natural zeolites have also helped in decontaminating waters and soils after nuclear fallout. Mixtures of natural chabazite and synthetic zeolite A were used in 1979 to remove Cs and Sr, respectively, from the contaminated waters after the Three Mile Island accident [96]. Clinoptilolite was used to inhibit Cs uptake in contaminated Bikini Atoll soils [97]. The same zeolite was used to counteract the fallout from the 1986 Chernobyl disaster [82,98]. The recourse to ion exchange to remove heavy metal cations and other toxic or noxious cations from industrial wastewaters is potentially interesting, given the good to reasonable selectivities that natural zeolites display for most of the above cations [86,99]. Actually, no substantial applications are reported. The failure in passing from basic science to technology is mainly due to unsuitability of many wastewaters to be treated by ion exchange for reasons such as (1) too elevated concentrations of polluting cations, (2) low pHs, and (3) excessive interference of the cationic matrix, all reasons of them resulting in low process
31
performances. A possible overcoming of the above drawbacks, al least in some cases, is to renounce to the continuous treatment in column, adopting a discontinuous process (addition of zeolite to liquid wastes). This further reduces the process effectiveness, but gives the advantage to better modulate the solid-to-liquid ratio to the specific process requirements. Obviously, this practice requires that the (abundant) spent zeolitic sludge is processed to avoid pollutant leaching and dissemination in the environment. Research demonstrated that this is possible through a solidification-stabilisation in a consolidated cement matrix (a safely practice used also to confine radioactive material), taking advantage of the excellent pozzolanic activity displayed by zeolitic tuffs (see Sub-sec. 5.2.2.) [100]. In the range of environmental applications of natural zeolites based on ion exchange, also of interest is the possible use of surfactant-modified zeolites (see Sub-sec. 5.2.3.) for the removal of a series of water contaminants. A recent multipurpose investigation demonstrated good performances of these materials for chromate removal from water in a pilot-plant. In addition, laboratory tests demonstrated excellent selectivities for organics present in oilfield wastewaters and even for bacteria and viruses present in sewage effluents [101]. 6.2. Agricultural uses Soils of volcanic origin, sometimes containing significant amounts of natural zeolites [102], have long since demonstrated to be extremely productive, giving strong indications for a specific role of zeolitic minerals in improving their fertility. Experiments on soil amendment by zeolite are, however, rather recent. They, in fact, began in the 1960s in Japan, but gained a rapid success all over the world in the following years. Natural zeolites proved to be beneficial for the growth of a large variety of plants, including spinach, radish, sugar beet, tomato, maize, rice, potato and cucumber [99]. Although zeolites may contribute to fertilisation with their K content (and sometimes with NH4 content, introduced by ion exchange), their working mechanism in soil is largely undisclosed. It is, however, undeniable that zeolites, with their properties of water retention and cation exchange, enhance the plant conditions, particularly in the neighbourhood of rizosphere. On one hand, they behave, in fact, as a sort of reservoir of available water, on the other they increase the global cation exchange capacity of the soil, ameliorating and modulating the dynamics of the nutrient circulation. In addition, their buffering action involves a substantial pH stability in the case of increase of acidity due to alkali depletion and/or leaching. According to recent investigations [69], a further positive action of natural zeolites might be their ability to stabilise the organic components of soil through the formation of organo-mineral aggregates. This property opens the way to massive uses of natural zeolites also for re-building of depleted and/or desertified soils and recovery of soils polluted by potential toxic elements [103,104]. Natural zeolites have recently been used also for the preparation of soilless substrates [105,106]. This practice allows the cultivation of plants in artificial growing media, composed by NH4- and K-exchanged zeolites, e.g., clinoptilolite, and natural or synthetic apatite, which supply a balanced diet for many production cycles without fertiliser addition. 6.3. Applications based on adsorption Uses of sedimentary zeolites based on adsorption are limited for the reasons reported at the beginning of Sec. 6. They regard essentially the more "open" phases among those listed in Table 2, i.e., chabazite, clinoptilolite and mordenite (faujasite would be ideal for adsorption, but its presence in sedimentary deposits is limited to the only Arytain Jordanian occurrence).
32
Most applications concern water vapour adsorption (see Fig. 6a). There are, in fact, many examples of use of the above mentioned materials as drying media of air [107], sour natural gas and other artificial gas streams [82]. Effective, although more limited as regards quantities, is the use as desiccant, in place of silica gel, in many different applications, such as Freon drying in refrigerating circuits, air drying in the frames of the double window-panes and in packaging of optic instruments. Much research has been carried out in recent years on the possibility to use natural zeolites in water desorption-adsorption cycles, in order to capture thermal energy from waste or discontinuous heat sources and to store it until a possible use for heating and/or drying purposes [see, e.g. 108], but no full-scale devices seem to have been realised. Water adsorption-desorption cycles with chabazite- and clinoptilolite-rich materials proved to be useful also in air-conditioning and refrigeration. This gave rise to the production of refrigerators and other heating/cooling devices by a small company in the United States [109]. Prospects of use for selective adsorption of pollutant gases, such as SO2 (see Fig. 6b), from dehydrated combustion gas effluents are sound, considering the good selectivity of natural zeolites for polar molecules compared to non-polar molecules, such as CO2 [74]. Selectivity and sorption capability for NH3 are also elevated [74,110,111], so that applications are predictable for deodorisation of gaseous mixtures. It is noteworthy that raw tuffaceous materials are already sold for this purpose as house's consumer products in the United States, Japan, Hungary, Cuba and Germany [82]. Massive uses are also reported for the treatment of animal wastes in stables and poultry-houses and as deodorising additions to bentonite-made pet litters [82]. Gas separation processes are limited to the production of high-grade O2 from air in generators operating by the pressure-swing adsorption method. Full-scale plants based on mordenite-rich tuffs are operating in Japan since the end of the 1960s [112]; pilot plants are reported working in other countries, e.g., Bulgaria [107]. Other interesting separation processes, still at level of laboratory scale, are feasible, e.g., the water-ethanol vapour separation by phillipsite-rich volcanic tuff, based on the moderate selectivity of this zeolite for ethanol, compared to water [113]. 6.4. Uses as building materials Tuff stones, as many other stones of different nature, have a traditional local usage as building materials, which dates back to prehistory. In historical times (e.g., in Greek and Roman times), until today, the profitable utilisation of tuffs as dimension stones, in side of clay bricks or other artificial stones, was supported by their reasonable mechanical properties, acceptable durability, but especially excellent ability of temperature and humidity control in houses (see Sub-sees. 5.3.1. and 5.3.2.). This is still the most relevant natural zeolite utilisation, although limited to a restricted number of countries (essentially Bulgaria, Cuba, Germany, Greece, Italy, Hungary, Japan, Mexico, Romania and Turkey). The estimated present tuff consumption as stone material amounts to roughly 3 x 106 tons per year [80]. Zeolitic tuff is also utilised in the cement industry as pozzolanic addition (see Sub-sec. 5.2.2.) to portland cement. This application recalls the use of pozzolana, since the beginning of the 1900s, to obtain blended cements, able to fix the lime formed by the hydration of the calcium silicate components of the portland clinker. The utilisation of zeolitic tuff, as substitute of pozzolana, to obtain pozzolanic cements is based on both economic and technical considerations. On one hand, manufacturing blended cements allows a 40% fuel savings, without reducing the quality of the produced binder (it is to bear in mind that the mixture lime-pozzolana is itself a cement), on the other, it involves some advantages, e.g., the
33
improvement of resistance to lime leaching by flowing waters and to expansion due to sulphate attack [114]. An additional advantage is the slower and decreased heat evolution during hydration, which is beneficial in the setting-up of massive structures [115]. The use of natural zeolite materials in the cement industry is well established in many countries, such as Bulgaria, China, Cuba, Germany, Jordan, Russia, Slovenia, Spain, the United States and Yugoslavia [80]. Research is quite active in Greece [e.g., 116] and in Italy [e.g., 63], but in the latter country a possible application is delayed by the still abundant availability of natural pozzolana and by the consolidated use of other artificial pozzolanic materials, such as fly ash, condensed silica fume and heat-treated clay. The application of natural zeolites in the field of cement manufacture is destined to grow in the next years. In fact, the "next revolution in materials of construction" is to go back to the past. The current concrete construction practice is reportedly unsustainable, because the present production of about 1.7 x 109 tpy portland cement has a not negligible environmental impact from standpoint of energy consumption and global warming. So, the expected trend in the concrete industry in the next years is to recur to ancient practices, such as that to re-use the Roman concretes. This would increase the resort to raw, recycled and waste materials, enabling cost reduction and manufacture of environment-friendly products [117,118]. On the basis of the property to expand on heating (see Sub-sec. 5.3.1.), zeolitic tuffs appear very promising as raw materials for manufacturing lightweight aggregates for concrete. A recent investigation demonstrated that mixtures of such expanded materials, prepared from Neapolitan yellow tuff [79], cement, sand and water, gave rise to concretes, whose unit weight and uniaxial compressive strength after 28 days curing, were quite comparable with those obtained using common aggregates, available on the market [119]. In this same sector, also of interest is the possibility to obtain cellular materials by the use of foaming agents (e.g., treating powdered clinoptilolite-rich rocks at temperatures ranging between 1100 and 1400°C in the presence of silicon carbide [120]. These materials, which can be obtained as granules or pre-shaped blocks, display, besides relevant lightness, very good thermal-insulating properties (thermal conductivities are in the range of 0.06-0.21 W m"1 K"'), much better than that of the parent tuffaceous material (see the relevant data in Sub-section 5.3.1.). 6.5. Miscellany Sedimentary zeolites, e.g., clinoptilolite and mordenite, are widely used as dietary supplements for a variety of animals. This subject has been reviewed recently [121], but abundant previous literature is included in most Proceedings of Natural Zeolite Conferences (see Bibliography). The practice to use natural zeolites for animal nutrition began in Japan some forty years ago in imitation of the successful use of montmorillonite to slow down the passage of feed in the digestive system of the chicken with the result to improve nutrients assimilation. Tests were initially made with swine and poultry, but they were then extended to other animals. The results were in general good to excellent, as faster growth and minor incidence of diseases and death were achieved. The action mechanisms are not completely understood, either because of the complexity of the matter (likely the good results depend on various co-causes involving ion exchange and adsorption properties of the zeolites) or the completely different physiology of the various animals treated. Some actions played by zeolites which are generally believed valid are the following: • better nutrients assimilation and feed efficiency (analogously to the above mentioned action played by montmorillonite);
34
• reduction of ammonium amount in circulation, which is taken up by zeolite and gradually released with the result of a better conversion of feed-stuff nitrogen to animal protein; • stimulation of antibody production with consequent diseases inhibition; • reduction of ammonia levels in blood, • withdrawal of toxic substances (essentially cations) from the vital circle; • withdrawal of aflatoxins ingested with contaminated feed (see Sub-sec. 5.2.3.). Natural zeolites are used also for drug preparation. This practice is widespread in various countries, such as Bulgaria and Cuba. The first application regarded clinoptilolite-rich materials which were tested as antacids on the basis of their alkaline nature. At present blends of natural zeolites associated with other gastric adjuvants, such as sodium carbonate [122] or aspirin [123], are sold as Pharmaceuticals having neutralising properties. The administration of natural zeolites proved to have also anti-diarrheic effects, similarly to the recognised action played by some clay minerals, which are for that reason already used for drug formulations. This and other claimed abilities, possibly due to the capacity of zeolites to adsorb endogenous and exogenous substances responsible for this and other diseases [see, e.g., 124,125], opened the way to the preparation of specific drugs, which are on the market, for instance in Cuba. Another massive application of clinoptilolite-rich tuff, reported in Japan and in Hungary, is that of paper filler in place of kaolin. The zeolitic material, which is needed to be white, is claimed to give a paper bulkier, more opaque, easier to cut and less susceptible to ink blotting than that filled with clay [126]. 7. CONCLUSION AND OUTLOOK Natural zeolites are the ancestors of the present synthetic materials, but it should be a mistake to consider them only for historical reasons. Research on and applications of natural zeolites are still alive and vital fields which deserve attention and offer interesting prospects. What should be borne in mind, however, is that natural zeolites can not be considered as substitutes of the synthetic materials; on the contrary, they should be used for some unique peculiarities, when the inconstancy of composition does not represent an obstacle and when their inexpensiveness accords with the obtained benefit. So, fields of environmental or industrial interest, such as water pollution control, manufacture of cement and lightweight aggregates, agriculture, including soil amendment, decontamination or re-building, animal husbandry and aquaculture, should be regarded as preferential fields both for research and application. Am emerging sector, in which more research is needed, is that of life sciences and medicine. Recent results have, in fact, demonstrated that the application of natural zeolites as dietary supplements for animals, which was originally proposed on an empirical basis, has solid fundaments. Research is, therefore, destined to deepen and widen, with the objective to provide specific therapeutic remedies also for man. BIBLIOGRAPHY Proceedings of Conferences and Workshops • Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Use L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, 546 pp. • Zeo-Agriculture: The Use of Natural Zeolites in Agriculture and Aquaculture W.G. Pond and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), International Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1984,305 pp. • Occurrence, Properties, and Utilization of Natural Zeolites D. Kallo and H.S. Sherry (Eds.), Akademiai Kiado, Budapest, Hungary, 1988, 858 pp.
35 • Zeolites '91: Memoirs of the 3rd International Conference on the Occurrence, Properties and Utilization of Natural Zeolites, G. Rodriguez Fuentes and J.A. Gonzales Morales (Eds.), International Conference Center, Havana, Cuba, 1991, Vols. I-II, 310 + 322 pp. • Natural Zeolites '93: Occurrence, Properties, Use D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), International Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995,622 pp.. • Natural Zeolites Sofia '95 G. Kirov, L. Filizova, and O. Petrov (Eds.), Pensoft Publishers, Sofia, Bulgaria, 1997, 300 pp. • Natural Microporous Materials in the Environmental Technology P. Misaelides, F. Macasek, T. Pinnavaia, C. Colella (Eds.), NATO Sciences Series E 362 (Applied Sciences), Kluwer A.P., Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1999, 516 pp. • Natural Zeolites for the Third Millennium C. Colella and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), De Frede - Editore, Napoli, Italy, 2000, 484 pp. • Zeolite '02: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on the Occurrence, Properties and Utilization of Natural Zeolites Microporous and Mesoporous Materials (Special Issue), P. Misaelides, D. Zamboulis and M. Stocker (Eds.), 61 (2003) 1-294. Clays & Clay Minerals, D.L. Bish (Ass. Ed.), 51 (2003) 589-643. Volumes • Mineralogy and Geology of Natural Zeolites MSA Short Course Notes, Vol. 4, F.A. Mumpton (Ed.), Mineralogical Society of America, Washington, DC, 1977, 233 pp. • Natural Zeolites Clays & Clay Minerals, 29 (5) (1981) 321-416 (Special Issue). • G. Gottardi and E. Galli Natural Zeolites Springer-Verlag, Berlin-Heidel berg, Germany, 1985, 409 pp. • Zeolite Deposits Mineralium Deposita, 31 (6) (1996) 451-599 (Special Issue). • Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Applications Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, Vol. 45, D.L. Bish and D.W. Ming (Eds.), Mineralogical Society of America, Washington, DC, 2001, 654 pp.
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10]
A.F. Cronstedt, Kongl. Vetenskaps Acad. Handl. Stockholm 17 (1756) 120 (in Swedish). L. Bosc D1 Antic, Journal d'Histoire Naturelle 2 (1792) 181 (in French). C. Colella, in: F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing and J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Handbook of Porous Solids, Vol. 2, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, Germany, 2002, p. 1156. A. Damour, C. R. Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci. 44 (1857) 975; also Ann. Chim. Phys., 3rd series, 53 (1858) 438 (in French). G. Friedel, Bull. Soc. Franc. Mineral. 19 (1896) 94 (in French). F. Grandjean, C. R. Hebd. Seances Acad. Sci. 149 (1909) 866 (in French). R. Seeliger and K. Lapkamp, Physik. Z. 22 (1921) 563 (in German). O. Weigel and E. Steinhof, Z. Kristall. 61 (1924) 125 (in German). J. W. McBain, The Sorption of Gases and Vapours by Solids, G. Routledge & Sons, London, U.K., 1932, p. 167. R.M. Barrer, Zeolites and Clay Minerals as Sorbents and Molecular Sieves, Academic Press, London, U.K., 1978.
36 [11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25]
[26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33]
[34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39]
H.S. Thompson, J. Royal Agric. Soc. Engl. 11 (1850) 68. J.T. Way, J. Royal Agric. Soc. Engl. 11 (1850) 313. H. Eichhorn, Poggendorffs Ann. Phys. Chem. (Leipzig), 4th series, 15 (1858) 26 (in German). R. Gans, Jahrb. Konigl. Preuss. Geol. Landesanst. und Bergakad. (Berlin) 26 (1905) 179 (in German). R.M. Barrer, J. Chem. Soc. (1950) 2342. B.A. Adams and E.L. Holmes, J. Soc. Chem. Ind. (London) 54 (1935) IT. R.A. Sheppard, A.J. Gude, 3rd, and G.M. Edson, in: L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Use, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, p. 319. T. Sudo, J. Geol. Soc. Japan 56 (1950) 13. D.S. Coombs, Trans. Royal Soc. New Zealand 82 (1954) 65. R. Sersale, Rend. Accad. Sci. Fis. Mat. (Naples) 25 (1958) 181 (in Italian). F.A. Mumpton, in: D. Olson and A. Bisio (Eds.), Proc. Sixth Int. Zeolite Conf., Butterworths, Guidford, U.K., 1984, p. 68. M.H. Hey, Min. Mag. 22 (1930) 422. J.V. Smith, Mineral. Soc. of America Special Paper 1 (1963) 309. F. Liebau, Zeolites 3 (1983) 191. D.S. Coombs, A. Alberti, T. Armbruster, G. Artioli, C. Colella, E. Galli, J.D. Grice, F. Liebau, J.A. Mandarino, H. Minato, E.H. Nickel, E. Passaglia, D.R. Peacor, S. Quartieri, R. Rinaldi, M. Ross, R.A. Sheppard, E. Tillmanns and G. Vezzalini, Can. Mineral. 35 (1997) 1571. O.V. Petersen, G. Giester, F. Brandstatter and G. Niedermayr, Can. Mineral. 40 (2002) 173. Ch. Baerlocher, W.M. Meier and D.H. Olson, Atlas of Zeolite Framework Types, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2001. M. de' Gennaro, C. Colella, E. Franco and D. Stanzione, Neues Jahrb. Mineral.-Mon.hefte. H. 4(1988)149. R. Aiello and C. Colella, La Chimica e l'lndustria 52 (1970) 347 (in Italian). R. Aiello, C. Colella and R. Sersale, in: E.M. Flanigen and L.B. Sand (Eds.), Molecular Sieve Zeolites-I, ACS Adv. Chem. Ser., Vol. 101, 1971, p. 51. R. Aiello, C. Colella, D. G. Casey and L.B. Sand, in: L.V.C. Rees (Ed.), Proc. 5th Int. Conf. on Zeolites, Heyden & Son, London, U.K., 1980, p. 49. M. de' Gennaro, C. Colella, M. Pansini and A. Langella, in: R. von Ballmoos, J.B. Higgins and M.M.J. Treacy (Eds.), Proc. 9th Int. Zeolite Conf., Butterworth-Heinemann, Stoneham, MA, 1993, Vol. II, p. 207. R.L. Hay and R.A. Sheppard, in: D.L. Bish and D.W. Ming (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Applications, Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, Vol. 45, Mineralogical Society of America, Washington, DC, 2001, p. 217. G. Gottardi, Eur. J. Mineral. 1 (1989) 479. R.L. Hay, Calif. Univ. Publ. Geol. Sci. 42 (1963) 199. R.A. Sheppard and A.J. Gude, 3rd, U.S. Geol. Surv. Prof. Pap. No. 597 (1968). J. Honnorez, in: L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, p. 245. J.R. Boles and W.S. Wise, in: L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, p. 235. M. Utada, in: D.L. Bish and D.W. Ming (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Applications, Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, Vol. 45, Mineralogical Society of America, Washington, DC, 2001, p. 277.
37
[40]
[41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55]
[56] [57] [58] [59]
[60] [61] [62] [63] [64] [65]
M. de' Gennaro, M. Adabbo and A. Langella, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 363. G. Gottardi and J. Obradovic, Fortschr. Miner. 56 (1978) 316. K. Ibrahim and A. Hall, Miner. Deposita 31 (6) (1996) 514. D.B. Hawkins, in: W.G. Pond and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Zeoagriculture. Use of Natural Zeolites in Agriculture and Aquaculture, Westview Press, Boulder, Colorado, 1984, p. 69. G. Gottardi and E. Galli, Natural Zeolites, Springer-Verlag, Berlin-Heidelberg, Germany, 1985. R.M. Barrer, Zeolites and Clay Minerals as Sorbents and Molecular Sieves, Academic Press, London, U.K., 1978, p. 24-27. R.A. Sheppard, U.S. Geol. Survey Open-file Report, No. 96-18 (1996). J.A. Thomas and B. Ballantyne, J. Am. Coll. Toxicol. 11(3) (1992) 259. A. Temel and M.N. Gundogdu, Miner. Deposita 31 (6) (1996) 539. M. de1 Gennaro and A. Langella, Miner. Deposita 31 (6) (1996) 452. M. de' Gennaro, P. Petrosino, M.T. Conte, R. Munno and C. Colella, Eur. J. Mineral. 2 (1990) 779. R.M. Barrer, in: L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, p. 385. R.M. Barrer and J. Klinowski, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans. I 68 (1972) 1956. M. Adabbo, D. Caputo, B. de Gennaro, M. Pansini and C. Colella, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 28(1999)315. C. Colella, Miner. Deposita 31(6) (1996) 554. B. de Gennaro, A. Colella, P. Cappelletti, M. Pansini, M. de' Gennaro and C. Colella, in: J. Cejka, N. Zilkova, P. Nachtigall (Eds.), Molecular sieves: From basic research to industrial applications, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis No. 158, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2005, in press. C. Colella, M. de' Gennaro, A. Langella and M. Pansini, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, ICNZ, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 377. M. Pansini, C. Colella, D. Caputo, M. de' Gennaro and A. Langella, Microporous Mater. 5 (1996)357. C. Colella, M. de' Gennaro, A. Langella and M. Pansini, Sep. Sci. Technol.33 (4) (1998) 467. C. Colella, E. Torracca, A. Colella, B. de Gennaro, D. Caputo and M. de' Gennaro, in: A. Galarneau, F. Di Renzo, F. Fajula and J. Vedrine (Eds.), Zeolites and Mesoporous Materials at the Dawn of the 21st Century, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis No. 135, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2001, (CD ROM), paper 01-O-05. Y. Goto and L.B. Sand, in: D. Kallo and H.S. Sherry, Occurrence, Properties and Utilizations of Natural Zeolites, Akademiai Kiado, Budapest, Hungary, 1988, p. 161. R. Sersale, Rend. Accad. Sci. Fis. Mat, Naples, 25 (1958) 181 (in Italian). R. Sersale, Atti Accademia Pontaniana (Naples), 40 (1991) 257 (in Italian). B. Liguori, D. Caputo, M. Marroccoli and C. Colella, in: V. Mohan Malhotra (Ed.), Proc. 8th CANMET/ACI Int. Conf. on Fly Ash, Silica Fume, Slag and Natural Pozzolans in Concrete, American Concrete Institute, Farmington Hills, MI, 2004, p. 319. R. Sersale and V. Sabatelli, Rend. Accad. Sci. Fis. Mat., Naples, 27 (1960) 263 (in Italian). F. Cadena and E. Cazares, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 309.
38 [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73]
[74]
[75] [76] [77] [78]
[79] [80]
[81 ] [82] [83]
[84] [85] [86]
[87] [88]
S.A. Boyd, M.M. Mortland and C.T. Chiou, Soil Sci. Soc. Amer. J. 52 (1988) 652. R.S. Bowman, E.J. Sullivan and Z. Li, in: C. Colella and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites for the Third Millennium, De Frede - Editore, Napoli, Italy, 2000, p. 287. F.J. Stevenson, Humus Chemistry. Genesis, Composition, Reactions, Wiley, New York, p. 443. S. Capasso, S. Salvestrini, E. Coppola, A. Buondonno and C. Colella, Appl. Clay Sci., 28 (205)159. T.D. Phillips, B.A. Sarr and P.G. Grant, Natural Toxins 3 (1995) 204. A.J. Ramos and E. Hernandez, Anim. Feed Sci. Technol. 62 (1996) 263. D.E.W. Vaughan, in: L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Use, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, p. 353. R. Roque-Malherbe, L. Lemes-Fernandez, L. Lopez-Colado, C. de las Pozas and A. MontesCarballal, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 299. D. Caputo, B. de Gennaro, M. Pansini and C. Colella, in: P. Misaelides, F. Macasek, T. Pinnavaia, C. Colella (Eds.), Natural Microporous Materials in the Environmental Technology, NATO Sciences Series E 362 (Applied Sciences), Kluwer A.P., Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1999, p. 225. C. Colella, in: J. Ma. Rincon and M. Romero (Eds.), Characterization Techniques of Glasses and Ceramics, Springer-Verlag,Berlin Heidelberg, Germany, 1998, p. 112. E. Pecsi-Donath, Acta. Geol. Hung. 6 (1962) 429. L.P. van Reeuwijk, The thermal dehydration of natural zeolites, Meded. Landbouwhogeschool Wageningen, The Netherlands, No. 74-9, 1974 D.L. Bish and J.W. Carey, in: D.L. Bish and D.W. Ming (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Applications, Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, Vol. 45, Mineralogical Society of America, Washington, DC, 2001, p. 403. R. de Gennaro, P. Cappelletti, G. Cerri, M. de' Gennaro, M. Dondi and A. Langella, Appl. Clay Sci. 25(2004)71. C. Colella, M. de' Gennaro and R. Aiello, in: D.L. Bish and D.W. Ming (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Applications, Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, Vol. 45, Mineralogical Society of America, Washington, DC, 2001, p. 551. F.A. Mumpton, in: C. Colella (Ed.), Atti 3° Congresso Nazionale AIMAT, "Omaggio scientifico a Riccardo Sersale", De Frede, Napoli, 1996, p. XXXI. F.A. Mumpton, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 96 (1999) 3463. R. Roque-Malherbe, in: H.S. Nalwa (Ed.), Handbook of Surfaces and Interfaces of Materials, Volume 5: Biomolecules, Biointerfaces, and Applications, Academic Press, London, U.K., p. 495. M.W. Ackley, S.U. Rege and H. Saxena, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 61 (2003) 25. R.T. Pabalan and F.P. Bertetti, in: D.L. Bish and D.W. Ming (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Applications, Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, Vol. 45, Mineralogical Society of America, Washington, DC, 2001, p. 453. C. Colella, in: P. Misaelides, F. Macasek, T. Pinnavaia, C. Colella (Eds.), Natural Microporous Materials in the Environmental Technology, NATO Sciences Series E 362 (Applied Sciences), Kluwer A.P., Dordrecht, The Netherlands, 1999, p. 207. B.W. Mercer and L.L. Ames, in: L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Use, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, p. 451. M. Pansini, Miner. Deposita 31 (6) (1996) 563.
39 [89] [90] [91]
[92]
[93]
[94] [95] [96] [97] [98] [99]
[100]
[101] [102]
[103]
[104]
[105] [106] [107] [108]
A. Hedstrom, J. Environ. Eng. 127(8) (2001) 673. F.A. Mumpton, in: L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Use, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, p. 3. L. Liberti, A. Lopez, V. Amicarelli and G. Boghetich, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 351. C. Galindo, Jr., D.W. Ming, M.J. Carr, A. Morgan and K.D. Pickering, in: C. Colella and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites for the Third Millennium, De Frede - Editore, Napoli, Italy, 2000, p. 363. S.M. Robinson, T.E. Kent and W.D. Arnold, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 579. D.C. Grant, M.C. Skirba and A.K. Saha, Environ. Progr. 6(2) (1987) 104. Anonimous, British Nuclear Technology Paper No. 9, Risley, Warrington, U.K., 1987. E.D. Collins, D.O. Campbell, L.J. King and J.B. Knauer, AIChE Symp. Ser. 213 (1982) 9. W.L. Robinson and G.R. Stone, Bikini Atoll Rehabilitation Committee Summary Report No. 6, BARC, Berkeley, CA, 1988, Appendix A, A1-A48 pp. N.F. Chelishev, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 525. C. Colella, in I. Kiricsi, G. Pal-Borbely, J.B. Nagy and H.G. Karge (Eds.), Porous Materials in Environmentally Friendly Processes, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis No. 125, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 1999, p. 641. D. Caputo, R. Cioffi, B. de Gennaro, M. Pansini and C. Colella, in: Proc. 4th Int. Congress on Energy, Environment and Technological Innovation, Universita di Roma "La Sapienza", Rome, Italy, 1999, Vol. I, p. 73. R.S. Bowman, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 61 (2003) 43. J.L. Boettinger and R.C. Graham, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 23. A. Buondonno, E. Coppola, M. Bucci, G. Battaglia, A. Colella, A. Langella, C. Colella, in: R. Aiello, G. Giordano and F. Testa, (Eds.), Impact of Zeolites and Other Porous Materials on the New Technologies at the Beginning of the New Millennium, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis No. 142B, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2002, p. 1751. E. Coppola, G. Battaglia, M. Bucci, D. Ceglie, A. Colella, A. Langella, A. Buondonno, C. Colella, in: R. Aiello, G. Giordano and F. Testa, (Eds.), Impact of Zeolites and Other Porous Materials on the New Technologies at the Beginning of the New Millennium, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis No. 142B, Elsevier, Amsterdam, The Netherlands, 2002, p. 1759. E.R. Allen and D.W. Ming, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 477. D.W. Ming and E.R. Allen, in: C. Colella and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites for the Third Millennium, De Frede - Editore, Napoli, Italy, 2000, p. 417. I.M. Galabova, in: R. Aiello (Ed.), Proc. 3° Convegno Naz. Scienza e Tecnologia delle Zeoliti, Associazione Italiana Zeoliti, Naples, Italy, 1995, p. 253. R. Aiello, A. Nastro, G. Giordano and C. Colella, in: D. Kallo and H.S. Sherry, Occurrence, Properties and Utilizations of Natural Zeolites, Akademiai Kiado, Budapest, Hungary, 1988, p. 763.
40
[109] [110] [Ill] [112] [113] [114] [115] [116] [117] [118] [119] [120] [121] [122] [123] [124] [125] [126]
D. Tchernev, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 613. D.T. Hayhurst, in: L.B. Sand and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites: Occurrence, Properties, Use, Pergamon Press, Elmsford, NY, 1978, p. 503. D. Kallo, J. Papp and J. Valyon, Zeolites 2 (1982) 13. H. Minato and T. Tamura, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 509. C. Colella, M. Pansini, F. Alfani, M. Cantarella and A. Gallifuoco, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 3(1994)219. G. Malquori, in: Proc. 4th Int. Symp. On Chemistry of Cement, National Bureau of Standards, Monograph No. 43, Vol. II, U.S. Department of Commerce, Washington, D.C., 1962, p. 983. M.I. Sanchez de Rojas, M.P. Luxan, M. Frias and N. Garcia, Cem. Concr. Res. 23 (1993)46. Th. Perraki, G. Kakali and F. Kontoleon, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 61 (2003) 205. P.K. Mehta, Concrete International, ACI, 23(10) (2001) 61. P.K. Mehta, Concrete International, ACI, 24(7) (2002) 23. R. de Gennaro, P. Cappelletti, G. Cerri, M. de' Gennaro, M. Dondi and A. Langella, Appl. Clay Sci. 28 (2005) 309. B.A. Fursenko, L.K. Kazantseva and I.A. Belitsky, in: C. Colella and F.A. Mumpton (Eds.), Natural Zeolites for the Third Millennium, De Frede - Editore, Napoli, Italy, 2000, p. 337. W.G. Pond, in: D.W. Ming and F.A. Mumpton, (Eds.), Natural Zeolites '93. Occurrence, Properties, Use, Int. Committee on Natural Zeolites, Brockport, NY, 1995, p. 449. A. Rivera, G. Rodriguez-Fuentes and L.A. Montero, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 24 (1998)51. A. Lam, L.R. Sierra, G. Rojas, A. Rivera, G. Rodriguez-Fuentes and L.A. Montero, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 23 (1998) 247. G. Rodriguez-Fuentes, M.A. Barrios, A. Iraizoz, I. Perdomo and B. Cedre, Zeolites 19 (1997) 441. B. Conception-Rosabal, J. Balmaceda-Era and G. Rodriguez-Fuentes, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 38 (2000) 161. Y. Kobayashi, Japan Kokai No. 45,041,044 (1970).
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
41
Zeolite structures Lynne B. McCusker and Christian Baerlocher Laboratory of Crystallography, ETH, CH-8093 Zurich, Switzerland
1. INTRODUCTION 2. ZEOLITE FRAMEWORK TYPES 2.1. Characteristics of zeolite framework types 2.2. Selected zeolite framework types 2.2.1. SOD (Type material: Sodalite, |Na8 C12| [Al6 Si6 O241 - SOD) 2.2.2. LTA (Type material: Linde Type A, |Na,2 (H2O)27|8 [Al,2 Si,2 O48]8 - LTA) 2.2.3. FAU (Type material: Faujasite, |(Ca,Mg,Na2)29 (H2O)240| [Al58 Sii34 O384] - FAU) 2.2.4. EMT (Type material: EMC-2, [Na21 (Ci2H24O6)4| [Al21 Si75 Oi92] - EMT) 2.2.5 CHA (Type material: Chabasite, |Ca6 (H2O)40| [Al,2 Si24 O72] - CHA) 2.2.6. GIS (Type material: Gismondine, |Ca4 (H2O)16| [Al8 Si8 O32] - GIS) 2.2.7. MFI (Type material: ZSM-5, |Nax (H2O)16| [Alx Si96-x O,92| - MFI, x < 27) 2.2.8. MEL (Type material: ZSM-11, |Nax (H2O),6| [Alx Si96.x O,92] - MEL, x < 16) 2.2.9. MOR (Type material: Mordenite, [Nag (H2O)24| [Al8 Si40 O96] - MOR) 2.2.10. MWW (Type material: MCM-22, |H2.4 Na3.,| [Al04 B5.i Si66.5 O,44] - MWW) 2.2.11. *BEA (Type material: Zeolite Beta, |Na7| [Al7 Si57 O,28] - *BEA) 2.2.12. AFI (Type material: AlPO4-5, |(C,2H28N)4 (OH)(H2O)X| [Al12 Pi2 O48] - AFI) 2.2.13. VFI (Type material: VPI-5, |(H2O)42| [Al18 P18 O72] - VFI) 2.2.14. -CLO (Type material: Cloverite, |(C7H,4N)24|8 [F24 Ga96 P96 O372 (OH)24]8 - -CLO) 2.2.15. ETR (Type material: ECR-34, |H,.2 K63 Na4.4| [Gan.6 Al 03 Si36., O%] - ETR) 2.2.16. UTL (Type material: IM-12, [Ge,3.8 Si62.2 O152] - UTL) 2.3. Searching the Zeolite Structure Database on the internet 3. ZEOLITE STRUCTURES 3.1. Framework composition 3.2. Extra-framework species 3.3. Stacking faults 4. POWDER DIFFRACTION 4.1. Information in a powder diffraction pattern 4.2 Common applications 5. CONCLUSIONS REFERENCES
42
1.
INTRODUCTION
The fascinating and wonderfully exploitable properties of zeolitic materials, such as their ionexchange properties, their sorption capacity, their shape selectivity, their catalytic activity or their role as hosts in advanced materials, are essentially determined by their structures. For example, sorption characteristics depend upon the size of the pore openings and the void volume; ion-exchange selectivity upon the number and nature of the cation sites and their accessibility; catalytic behavior upon the pore openings, the dimensionality of the channel system, the cation sites, and the space available for reaction intermediates; and host applications on the size and spacing of the cages. Consequently, structural analysis is a fundamental aspect of zeolite science. Information on the framework type alone can elucidate many of the observed properties of a zeolite. The framework type, which just describes the connectivity (topology) of the framework tetrahedral atoms in the highest possible symmetry without reference to chemical composition, defines the size and shape of the pore openings, the dimensionality of the channel system, the volume and arrangement of the cages, and the types of cation sites available. Nonetheless, the chemical composition of the framework, the nature of the species within the channels, and the type of post-synthesis modification also play a very important role in determining the specific properties of a particular zeolitic material. For example, an aluminosilicate framework has a negative charge whereas an aluminophosphate is neutral, a large cation can block or reduce the effective size of a pore opening, a small cation might distort a pore opening, or a sorbed species can influence the catalytic, optical, magnetic or electronic properties of a zeolite. Precise structural details, such as the nature of the distortion of a framework from ideal symmetry or the exact location of non-framework species, are often needed to fully understand the properties of a specific zeolite. Unfortunately, most synthetic zeolitic materials are polycrystalline. That is, single crystals of a size suitable for the application of traditional crystallographic methods of structure analysis (i.e. ~ 50-100 p.m on an edge) are rare. However, zeolites are crystalline with well-defined periodicity even if the crystallites are small, so structural elucidation using powder diffraction data is possible, though not quite so straightforward. Usually a number of analytical techniques are combined to probe the structure of a zeolite. These include sorption experiments (pore size and accessibility), solid state NMR (short range order and connectivity), electron microscopy (symmetry, faulting), and powder diffraction. The following sections of this chapter will cover (1) descriptions of selected zeolite framework types, (2) a discussion of some aspects of real zeolite structures, and (3) a summary of the information that can be extracted from a powder diffraction pattern. 2.
ZEOLITE FRAMEWORK TYPES
Because zeolite scientists recognized very early on that zeolite framework structures are fundamental to the understanding of zeolite chemistry [1], classification of zeolitic materials by framework type, first proposed by Meier and Olson in 1970 [2], has gained wide acceptance in the zeolite community. A framework type, as opposed to a framework structure, simply describes the connectivity of the tetrahedrally coordinated atoms (T-atoms) of the framework in the highest possible symmetry. The framework composition, the observed symmetry, and the actual unit cell dimensions are not considered. In this way, many different materials can be classified under one designation. For example, amicite, garronite, gismondine, gobbinsite, Na-Pl, Na-P2 and SAPO-43 all have the gismondine framework type
43
(GIS). A three letter code (e.g. GIS) is assigned to confirmed framework types by the Structure Commission of the International Zeolite Association according to rules set up by an IUPAC Commission on Zeolite Nomenclature [3,4]. The codes are normally derived from the name of the zeolite or "type material", e.g. FAU from the mineral faujasite, LTA from Linde Type A, and MFI from ZSM-5 (Zeolite Socony Mobil - five). Information pertinent to these framework types is published in the Atlas of Zeolite Framework Types [5] and on the internet at http://www.iza-structure.org/databases/. As new codes are approved, they are announced on the IZA Structure Commission's WWW pages (http://www.iza-structure.org/) and included in the internet version of the Atlas. As of January 2005, 161 zeolite framework types had been confirmed by the Structure Commission. In this chapter, all references to materials whose framework types are known will be accompanied by the appropriate three letter code in boldface type. 2.1. Characteristics of zeolite framework types The feature that is common to zeolite or zeolite-like materials is that they all have a 3dimensional, 4-connected framework structure constructed from corner-sharing TO4 tetrahedra (basic building unit or BBU), where T is any tetrahedrally coordinated cation. This framework structure is relatively open and characterized by the presence of channels and cavities. A description of a zeolite structure almost always begins with a description of the framework type in terms of the size of the pore openings and the dimensionality of the channel system. Pore openings are characterized by the size of the ring that defines the pore, designated an »-ring, where n is the number of T-atoms in the ring. An 8-ring is considered to be a small pore opening, a 10-ring a medium one, and a 12-ring a large one, with free diameters or effective pore widths (calculated using an oxygen radius of 1.35 A) of approximately 4.1, 5.5 and 7.4 A, respectively. Of course, rings can be distorted considerably so these numbers should only be used as a rough guide. A number of structural features (cages, channels, chains, sheets) are common to several different zeolite framework types, so designations such as a-cavity and (3-cage, pentasil unit, crankshaft and double crankshaft chain, and 4.82 sheet or net have crept into common usage. To help the reader, some of these subunits are shown in Figs. 1, 2 and 3. In these drawings, oxygen atoms have been omitted for clarity. Since polyhedral building units are sometimes described in terms of the «-rings defining their faces, these designations are also given in Fig. 1. For example, a truncated octahedron (sodalite cage), whose surface is defined by six 4-rings and eight 6-rings, would be designated a [4668] cage. The three double chains in Fig. 2 also occur as single chains in many zeolites, but these are so common that they are seldom discussed as a characteristic feature of a structure. The Narsarsukite chain is found more often in AlPCVstructures than in silicates, whereas the pentasil chain of edge-sharing [58] cages is characteristic of a family of high silica zeolites (MFI, MEL). The channel walls of zeolites with 1-dimensional pores are often composed entirely of 6-rings. The two possible orientations of the 6-rings in such "6-ring wraps" are shown for the 12-ring channels in AFI and CAN in Fig. 3. A nomenclature similar to that used for cages has also been developed to describe 2dimensional, 3-connected sheets or nets. In this case, the sizes of the three n-rings associated with each node are used for the designation. In the net shown in Fig. 3, for example, each node is associated with one 4-ring and two 8-rings and is therefore called a 4.8 net. To complete the 3-dimensional description, the orientation of the fourth connection can also be
44
Fig. 1. Some subunits and cages/cavities that recur in several framework types.
given as U or D (i.e. pointing Up or Down from the sheet). The example given in Fig. 3 describes the 4.82 sheet found in the GIS framework type, where the connections from half of each 8-ring point up and the other half point down. The 8-rings containing the letters correspond to the central 8-ring (front layer) in the GIS framework type shown in the next section in Fig. 9. Another example of a framework type that can be described in terms of a 4.82 sheet is that of ABW, which has an UUDUDDUD orientation of tetrahedra around the 8nngs. Some frameworks consist only of cages with a maximum ring size of six and have no channels (e.g. the pure-silica clathrasils), but the majority have at least 8-ring channels. These channels can intersect to form 2- and 3-dimensional channel systems, and this can be a critical feature for catalytic or sorption applications. For example, a 1-dimensional channel is much more easily blocked by the formation of coke deposits than is a higher dimensional one where "detours" are possible. The stacking sequence of layers, cages or rings in zeolite frameworks is often described using the "ABC-system". This crystal chemistry terminology, which is usually used to describe the stacking of layers of closest packed spheres (atoms) in metals or oxides, has been adapted to describe stackings in certain types of zeolite structures. For example, seventeen of the 161 zeolite framework types can be described in terms of stackings of hexagonal arrays of 6-rings (Fig. 4), and are known as the ABC-6 family of zeolite frameworks (see SOD and CHA in the following section). The longest stacking sequence reported for the ABC-6 family is that of Giuseppettite (GIU) with sixteen layers (ABABABACBABABABC) [6]. Other stackings described using the ABC terminology involve sheets of sodalite cages (see FAU and EMT in the following section). This concept of stacking sequences is not only an elegant
45
double double double zig-zag sawtooth crankshaft Fig. 2. Some chains that recur in several framework types.
Narsarsukite chain
pentasil chain
way of describing a family of frameworks, but also appears to reflect the way nature builds real materials with such frameworks (see section 3.3). Zeolite frameworks can be classified according to various schemes (e.g. by pore opening, by structural subunit, by channel system, by framework density, by loop configurations, by vertex symbols, and/or by coordination sequences). Most of these features are defined in the introductory pages of the Atlas of Zeolite Framework Types and then given
channel wall in AFI
channel wall in CAN
4.8 2 sheet or net
Fig. 3. Two types of channel walls composed of 6-rings (left), and the GIS 4.82 sheet (right)
46
Fig. 4. ABC-stacking of hexagonal arrays of 6-rings viewed (a) in projection, and (b) from the side. for each framework type. It is perhaps worth noting that the set of coordination sequences and vertex symbols for each of the T-atoms in a given framework type is unique, so this is a good way of determining whether or not the framework of a new zeolite is novel. 2.2. Selected zeolite framework types Although there are 161 confirmed zeolite framework types, only a few of them describe zeolites or zeolite-like materials that are actually used in industrial applications. Sixteen have been selected for a more detailed description here. Some have been chosen because of their industrial relevance, and some because they illustrate specific structural features. They are presented approximately in the order of the historical development of zeolite synthesis from aluminosilicates to high-silica zeolites to aluminophosphates to gallophosphates to gallosilicates to germanosilicates. No ranking is implied. For each framework type, the name and IUPAC crystal chemical formula [4] of the type material is given. In the drawings of the frameworks (Figs. 5-18), the nodes represent T-atoms and the lines oxygen bridges. For clarity, most rings with fewer than eight T-atoms have been made opaque. The selected aluminosilicates are sodalite (SOD), zeolite A (LTA), faujasite (FAU), EMC-2 (EMT), chabasite (CHA), gismondine (GIS). With the exception of EMT, all of these framework types have also been synthesized as aluminophosphates. The high silica zeolites, with a Si/Al ratio of at least 5, are ZSM-5 (MFI), ZSM-11 (MEL), mordenite (MOR), MCM-22 (MWW) and zeolite beta (*BEA). The common feature of these framework types is the presence of 5-rings. To complete the spectrum, two aluminophosphates, AlPO4-5 (AFI) and VPI-5 (VFI), a gallophosphate, cloverite (-CLO), a gallosilicate, ECR-34 (ETR), and a germanosilicate, IM-12 (UTL) will be discussed. 2.2.1.
SOD (Type material: Sodalite, |Na8 C12| |A16 Si6 O24] - SODJ
In the strictest sense of the word, sodalite is not a zeolite, because it has only 6-ring windows and thus has very limited sorption capacity. However its framework density of 17.2 T-atoms per 1000A3 is well within the zeolite range. It is an important material for creating simple periodic arrays of clusters, and is one of the most seriously investigated hosts for advanced materials [7]. The blue pigment ultramarine is a sodium aluminosilicate with a SOD-type framework and sulfide ions replacing the chloride ions inside the cages. Sodalite has much in common with some of the zeolites used in industrial applications. The SOD framework type (Fig. 5a) is best described as a body-centered cubic arrangement of (3 or sodalite cages (see Fig. 1) joined through shared 4- and 6-rings. It is also a member of the ABC-6 family of
47
Fig. 5. (a) the SOD framework type, and (b) the LTA framework type. zeolites [8], and can be viewed as an ABCABC stacking of hexagonal arrays of single 6-rings in the [111] direction (the body diagonal of the cubic unit cell). 2.2.2 LTA (Type material: Linde Type A, |Nai2 (H2O)27|8 [Al]2 Si12 O48]8 - LTA) The LTA framework type (Fig. 5b) is related to SOD, but in this case, the sodalite cages, in a primitive cubic arrangement, are joined via oxygen bridges to form double 4-rings rather than sharing a single 4-ring. This creates an a-cavity (see Fig. 1) instead of a P-cage in the center of the unit cell, and a 3-dimensional, 8-ring channel system. Alternatively, the framework can be described as a primitive cubic arrangement of a-cavities joined through common 8rings (producing a sodalite cage in the center). This is one of the more open zeolite framework types with a framework density of only 12.9 T-atoms per 1000A3. Zeolite A is used as a desiccant both in the laboratory and between the panes of glass in double-glazed windows, and as an ion-exchanger (water softener) in laundry detergents. 2.2.3. FAU (Type material: Faujasite, |(Ca,Mg,Na2)29 (H2O)240| [Al58 Si134 O384] - FAUJ There are also sodalite cages in the FAU framework type (Fig. 6). In this case, they are arranged in the same way as the carbon atoms in diamond, and are joined to one another via double 6-rings. This creates the so-called supercage with four, tetrahedrally-oriented, 12-ring pore openings, and a 3-dimensional channel system along <110>. The framework density, at 12.7 T-atoms per 1000 A3, is even lower than that of LTA. There is a center of inversion in each of the double 6-rings, so the puckered layers of sodalite cages are related to one another by inversion. The framework type can also be described as an ABCABC stacking of such layers. The combination of large void volume (ca 50%), 12-ring pore openings and 3dimensional channel system makes the thermally stable silicate materials with the FAU framework type ideal for many catalytic applications. 2.2.4. EMT (Type material: EMC-2, |Na2i (Ci2H24O6)4| [Al2, Si75 O]92] - EMTj In the same way that lonsdaleite is a hexagonal analog of diamond (or wurtzite one of zinc blende), the EMT framework type (Fig. 7) is the simplest hexagonal analog of FAU. In EMT, the puckered sodalite cage layers are stacked in an ABAB sequence and the layers are related to one another by a mirror plane. This arrangement of sodalite cages creates a medium cavity with three 12-ring pore openings and a larger cavity with five. As in FAU, the
48
Fig. 6. The FAU framework type and its supercage. The three different layers of sodalite cages are indicated with the letters A, B and C. Layer A is highlighted in gray.
resulting channel system is 3-dimensional with 12-ring pores, but the nature of the channel system and of the larger cavities in the EMT framework type is significantly different. As might be expected, this framework type is also well-suited for catalytic applications.
Fig. 7. The EMT framework type showing the medium and larger cavities separately. The two different layers of sodalite cages are indicated with the letters A and B. Layer A is highlighted in gray.
49
Fig. 8. The CHA framework type (AABBCC 6-ring stacking indicated) and its cavity.
2.2.5. CHA (Type material: Chabasite, |Ca6 (H2O)40| [AI12 Si24 O72] - CHAj The CHA framework type (Fig. 8) is another member of the ABC-6 family of zeolite frameworks. While SOD can be described in terms of an ABC stacking of hexagonal arrays of single 6-rings, CHA has an ABC stacking of double 6-ring arrays (or an AABBCC stacking of single 6-ring arrays). This stacking produces an elongated cavity with six 8-ring pores and a 3-dimensional channel system. Unlike the previous examples, the channels in CHA are not straight. The silicoaluminophosphate with this framework type is used in the conversion of methanol to olefins and in the aldol condensation of aldehydes. 2.2.6. GIS (Type material: Gismondine, |Ca4 (H2O)i6| [Al8 Si8 O32] - GISj The GIS framework type (Fig. 9) can be described as a stacking of 2-dimensional arrays of double crankshaft chains (Fig. 2). There are 8-ring channels running parallel to x and y, displaced with respect to one another along z. They intersect to form a 3-dimensional channel system. The double crankshaft chains are very flexible, and so is the GIS framework. Materials with this framework type have symmetries varying from monoclinic (e.g. gismondine) to orthorhombic (e.g. gobbinsite) to tetragonal (e.g. garronite) and the lattice parameters can differ by as much as 6%. The framework type can also be described in terms of 4.8 nets stacked along the x or y direction (see section 2.1). The "maximum aluminum P" zeolite (or MAP for short), which is used as an ion-exchanger in laundry detergents, has this framework tvoe.
Fig. 9. The GIS framework type with a double crankshaft layer highlighted.
50
Fig. 10. The MFI framework type with pentasil chains running parallel to z. One corrugated sheet perpendicular to z has been highlighted in gray. Adjacent sheets are related to one another by inversion centers (in the 6- and 10-rings).
2.2.7. MFI (Type material: ZSM-5, |Na* (H2O)i6| [Alx Si96-x Oi92] - MFI, x < 21) The framework type of the high silica zeolite ZSM-5 (Fig. 10) can be described in terms of [54] units, but it is easier to use pentasil units (Fig. 1). These [58] units are linked to form pentasil chains (Fig. 2), and mirror images of these chains are connected via oxygen bridges to form corrugated sheets with 10-ring holes (e.g. the gray sheet perpendicular to x in Fig. 10). Each sheet is linked by oxygen bridges to the next to form the 3-dimensional structure. Adjacent sheets are related to one another by an inversion center. This produces straight 10ring channels parallel to the corrugations (along y), and sinusoidal 10-ring channels perpendicular to the sheets (along x). The latter channels link the straight channels to one another to form a 3-dimensional 10-ring channel system. Because the pore openings are 10rings rather than 12-rings, the shape selectivity for sorption and catalysis is distinctly different from that of FAU- or EMT-type zeolites, and this fact is exploited in catalysis applications. ZSM-5 has found many applications in refinery and petrochemical processes. 2.2.8. MEL (Type material: ZSM-11, |Nax (H2O),6| [Alx Si96-x O192] - MEL, x < \6) In the MEL framework type (Fig. 11), the corrugated sheets of pentasil chains that are found in MFI are also present (one is highlighted in gray in Fig. 11). However, in MEL, adjacent sheets are related to one another by a mirror plane rather than by a center of inversion. This produces straight 10-ring channels along both x and y. Because these channels are displaced from one another in z, a 3-dimensional channel system is formed. As might be expected, intergrowths of the MEL and MFI framework types can and do occur (see section 3.3). 2.2.9. MOR (Type material: Mordenite, |Na8 (H2O)24| [Al8 Si40 O96] - MOR) In the MOR framework type (Fig. 12), units of four 5-rings [54] (Fig. 1) are joined to one another via common edges to form chains. Mirror images of these chains are connected via oxygen bridges to form corrugated sheets (lying horizontally in Fig. 12). These sheets, displaced by half a translation in c, are then connected to one another to form oval 12- and 8rings along the corrugations. The lining of the 12-ring channels contains 8-rings, but the 8ring openings of adjacent 12-ring channels are displaced with respect to one another, so only
51
Fig. 11. The MEL framework type with pentasil chains running parallel to z. One corrugated sheet perpendicular to x has been highlighted in gray. Adjacent sheets are related to one another by mirror planes (running through the 6- and 10-rings).
very limited access from one channel to the next is possible, Consequently, the channel system is effectively one dimensional. 2.2.10. MWW (Type material: MCM-22, |H2.4 Na3.,| |A1O.4 B5., Si66.5 OM - MWWj The high-silica zeolite MCM-22 has a rather unusual framework structure (Fig. 13). It can be viewed as a stacking of double layers joined by single oxygen bridges. The single layers consist of [435663] cages sharing 4-ring faces, and are joined to a second layer via double 6rings. The two layers of the double layer are mirror images of one another. The framework has two non-intersecting, 2-dimensional, 10-ring, channel systems. One of these lies within the double layer, and the second between the double layers. The latter also has two side
Fig. 12. The MOR framework type (left) and the chain composed of edge-sharing [54] units (right). The chains in the first layer (related by mirror planes) are highlighted in gray.
52
Fig. 13. The MWW framework type showing the double layer, the small [435663] cage and the side pockets at the intersections of the channels running between the double layers. pockets (12-ring access) at each channel intersection that form large cages (see Fig. 13, right). While the [435663] cage with a T-atom inside the cage may appear a little unusual, the geometry is quite reasonable. 2.2.11. *BEA (Type material: Zeolite Beta, |Na7| [Al7 Si57 Oi28] - *BEA;
Zeolite beta is disordered in the c-direction. That is, well-defined layers are stacked in a more or less random fashion. Since no ordered material has yet been produced, the three letter code is preceded by an asterisk to indicate that the framework type (Fig. 14) described in the Atlas is an idealized end member of a series. [54] units are joined to one another via 4-rings to form layers with saddle-shaped 12-rings. Adjacent layers are related to one another by a rotation of 90°. The disorder arises because this rotation can be in either a clockwise or a counterclockwise sense. If the counterclockwise or clockwise rotation were maintained throughout the crystal, the structure would be ordered and chiral. Interestingly enough, whatever the stacking sequence, a 3-dimensional 12-ring channel system results, so for catalytic applications, the stacking sequence is not important (unless, of course, the chirality of the channel system were to be exploited in some way). In 2000, Conradsson et al. synthesized a germanate, FOS-5 [9], with a strict alternation of clockwise and counterclockwise rotations of the *BEA layers (beta polymorph C, |(C3H9N)48 (H2O)36| [Ge256 O5i2] - BEC), and this ordered (non-chiral) framework has been assigned the code BEC. A silicogermanate material, ITQ-17 [10], and a pure silicate overgrowth on ITQ-14 [11] with this framework type have also been reported. It is interesting to note that while the pure germanate contained single crystals, the silicogermanate was polycrystalline, and the pure silicate was only nanometers in size. Germanium is known to stabilize double 4-rings, and these are prevalent in BEC. Consequently, the more germanium in the material, the larger the crystals.
53
Fig. 14. The idealized *BEA framework type with all layers related to one another via a counterclockwise rotation (connections between layers shown as dotted lines). The well-defined layer, and its building unit are shown separately.
2.2.12. AFI (Type material: AlPO4-5, |(Ci2H28N)4 (OH)(H2O)X| [Al12 P12 O48] - AFI) As for all AlPO4-based molecular sieves, the framework of AIPO4-5 (Fig. 15a) contains only even numbered rings, since Al and P alternate throughout the framework. In the AFI framework type, 6-rings are connected to three neighboring 6-rings via oxygen bridges to form 4-rings between the 6-rings and a hexagonal array of 12-rings. The tetrahedra are oriented in a strictly alternating fashion, so that every other one points up to the next layer while the others point down to the previous one. Mirror images of these layers are stacked on top of one another to form a 1-dimensional 12-ring channel system. Unlike the aluminosilicate molecular sieves, which tend to favor double crankshaft chains for connecting 4-rings in adjacent layers (e.g. tetrahedra oriented in an UUDD fashion), the aluminophosphates seem to prefer the Narsarsukite chain (Fig. 2), in which diagonally related corners of the 4-rings form the bonds to the next layer (e.g. UDUD connections). The 12-ring channel in AFI is lined with 6-rings (Fig. 3). 2.2.13. VFI (Type material: VP1-5, |(H2O)42| [Al18 P18 O72] - VFIj The framework of the aluminophosphate VPI-5 (Fig. 15b) is closely related to that of AIPO45. Instead of being linked via 4-rings, the 6-rings in the VFI framework type are linked via two 4-rings sharing a common edge (fused 4-rings). This produces an 18-ring in place of the 12-ring found in AFI. The tetrahedra are oriented in the same manner, and layers are stacked similarly. The 18-ring channel, with an effective width of ca 12 A, is also lined with 6-rings. One feature of the VFI framework type worth noting is the unusual conformation of the fused 4-rings. The geometry is highly strained if the T-atoms are assumed to be tetrahedral. The Al atom on the edge shared by the two 4-rings relieves this unfavorable situation by coordinating to two water molecules in addition to the four framework oxygens, and assumes an octahedral geometry [12]. Upon dehydration, these water molecules are lost, and VPI-5 transforms very easily into the related molecular sieve AIPO4-8 (AET) with 14-rings and fewer fused 4-rings
54
Fig. 15. (a) The AFI framework type, and (b) the VFI framework type. [13,14]. Under carefully controlled conditions, VPI-5 can be dehydrated and retain its framework type (albeit with considerable reduction in symmetry [15]). 2.2.14. -CLO (Type material: Cloverite, |(C7Hi4N)24|8 [F24 Ga 96 P96 O372 (OH) 24 | 8 - -CLOJ Of the gallophosphate molecular sieves synthesized, probably the most exciting material from a structural point of view is cloverite. The -CLO framework type (Fig. 16) consists of a primitive cubic array of a-cavities joined to one another via two [ 4 6 8 ] or rpa units to produce an enormous cavity with a body diagonal of ca 30 A in the center of the cube. However, not all of the T-atoms in the framework are 4-connected. One eighth of the Ga and one eighth of the P form only three bonds to framework oxygens. The fourth bond is to a terminal OH-group. That is, the framework is interrupted. The fact that not all T-atoms are 4-connected is indicated by a dash "-" in front of the three letter code. The terminal OHgroups protrude into the pore openings, and produce an unusual pore shape reminiscent of a
Fig. 16. The -CLO framework type (left) and its large central cavity (right).
55
4-leafed cloverleaf (hence the name cloverite). The ring is composed of 20 T-atoms and 24 oxygens. There are two non-intersecting, 3-dimensional channel systems: one 20-ring (with cloverleaf-shaped pores) and one 8-ring (passing through the a-cavities). The cavity in the center is by far the largest yet observed, and the framework density (11.1 T-atoms / 1000A3) the lowest. A further interesting aspect of the structure is that it can be constructed entirely from double 4-rings. In the structure of the as synthesized material, there is a fluoride ion in each double 4-ring, and this may be suggestive of a synthesis mechanism, since several other gallophosphate materials synthesized in the presence of HF have also been found to contain this unit (e.g. gallophosphate-LTA). 2.2.15. ETR (Type material: ECR-34, |H,.2 K6.3 Na4.4| [Gan.6 Alo.3 Si36.i O96] - ETRj Until quite recently, the largest pore opening in a silicate material seemed to be limited to a 14-ring. By including gallium in a silicate synthesis mixture, Strohmaier and Vaughan were able to break through this apparent ceiling, and produce the gallosilicate ECR-34 with 18-ring channels (Fig. 17) [16]. These 18-ring channels are connected to one another via the 8-rings in [466286] cavities to form a three-dimensional channel system. 2.2.16. UTL (Type material: IM-12, [Ge^.g Si62.2 O,52] - UTL) Over the years, considerable effort has been put into synthesizing silicates with extra-large pores (i.e. larger than 12-rings), and a number have been made. However, the large channels were either one-dimensional or only connected via 8-rings until the germanosilicates IM-12 [17] and ITQ-15 [18] were synthesized in 2004. Both of these have the UTL framework type with 14- and 12-ring channels intersecting to form a two-dimensional channel system (Fig. 18). As was noted earlier, germanium has been observed to stabilize the formation of double 4-rings [19], and indeed in these structures, Ge is located only in the double 4-rings that connect the pure silica layers, which contain primarily 5-rings. The layers themselves consist of chains of [4]58] units, and these chains are linked to one another via one or two additional tetrahedra. 2.3. Searching the Zeolite Structure Database on the internet As mentioned at the beginning of this chapter, essential structural information for all zeolite framework types to which the Structure Commission has assigned a three-letter code is
Fig. 17. A projection of the ETR framework type (left) and its [466286] cavity and 18-ring channel (right).
56
Fig. 18. The UTL framework type. Projection (a) down the z axis, and (b) down the >> axis, (c) The [4158] cage found in the layers, (d) The intersection of the 14-and 12-ring channels.
published on the internet under http://www.iza-structure.org/databases/. If the three-letter letter code of the zeolite of interest is not known, the material name can also be used to find the data. For each framework type, the database contains information such as crystal data (unit cell, space group and coordinates of T-atoms for an idealized SiC>2 composition), framework density, rings present, dimensionality of the channel system, secondary building units (SBU's), coordination sequences and vertex symbols. All of these data are also searchable (under Advanced Search). For example, all framework types with «-rings with n > 14 and a framework density of less than 16-T-atoms/1000A3 can be extracted very easily (Fig. 19). The resulting list shows that there are now several low-framework-density structures with multidimensional channel systems and rings larger than 12. A search without the limitation on the framework density yields 10 framework types. The pore dimensions given in the channel description are calculated from the crystal structure of the type material. The Atlas database also contains drawings of the pore openings (windows), the framework and framework projections, and provides a window in which the framework structures can be manipulated (rotated, zoomed, choice of display styles, range of atoms) and interatomic distances measured. Several other databases are also available on this website, including schemes for building models of the frameworks, a catalog of disordered zeolite FTC
Type Material
FD
FDsi
SBU
Rings present
Dim.
Channel Description
-CLO
Cloverite
11.1
11.1
4-4
20 8 6 4
3
<100> 20 4.0 x 13.2*** | <100> 8 3.8 x 3.8 ***
ETR
ECR-34
14.7
15.4
18 8 6 4
3
1 [001] 8 2.5 x 6.0** o [001] 18 10.1*
OSO
OSB-1
13.4
13.3
14 8 3
3
[001] 14 5.4 x 7.3* o 1 [001] 8 2.8 x 3.3**
14 12 6 5 4
2
[001] 14 7.1 x 9.5* <-> [010] 12 5.5 x 8.5*
18 6 4
1
[001] 18 12.7 x 12.7*
UTL
IM-12
15.2
15.6
VFI
VPI-5
14.2
14.5
3
6
Fig. 19. Results of the framework type search described in the text.
57
structures, and data for simulating powder diffraction patterns for all framework types. This is a powerful resource for zeolite scientists and is frequently accessed. 3.
ZEOLITE STRUCTURES
The framework types discussed in the last section describe only the connectivities of the frameworks. While these characterize the basic framework structure in terms of approximate pore opening, cage arrangement and channel system, and facilitate comparison of related materials, they do not describe real materials. That is, the influence of framework composition, extra-framework cations, organic species, sorbed molecules, or structural defects, is not considered. These aspects are addressed in the following sections. 3.1. Framework composition Many of the interesting properties of zeolites are based on the fact that the framework is anionic and the balancing cations exchangeable. A pure silica (SiCb) framework is neutral, but if some of the tetravalent Si are replaced by trivalent Al to produce an aluminosilicate, the framework becomes negative and counterions such as Na are needed to balance its charge. The neutral aluminophosphate or gallophosphate frameworks can be made anionic in a similar manner by inserting other elements into some of the T-sites. Even a small amount of a transition metal ion in the framework can make the material useful for catalysis applications. Many elements have now been incorporated into zeolite framework structures. What was originally the realm of aluminosilicates has expanded to include a significant portion of the periodic table. In some cases, only a few percent of the element is incorporated, while in others it is a major constituent. The framework composition also affects the stability of a material. For example, a high silica zeolite usually has a higher thermal stability than does the corresponding aluminosilicate, an aluminosilicate tends to be more stable than an aluminophosphate, and a gallophosphate is generally more sensitive to moisture than is an aluminophosphate. As has been indicated in the discussion of framework types, the chemical composition of a framework is sometimes reflected indirectly in certain features of the framework type. For example, double crankshaft chains are prevalent in aluminosilicates, 5-rings in high silica zeolites, Narsarsukite chains in aluminophosphates, 3-rings in zinco- and beryllosilicates, and double 4-rings in germanosilicates. Materials with strictly alternating T-atoms, such as Al and Si in aluminosilicates with a Si/Al ratio of 1, Al and P in aluminophosphates or Ga and P in gallophosphates, also require that only even numbered rings be present. If there are two or more types of T-atoms and these are ordered (i.e. not randomly distributed over all T-sites), the ideal symmetry of the framework type is likely to be reduced. For example, Al and Si alternate in the framework structure of zeolite A (LTA). To illustrate the effect of this ordering on the symmetry, the LTA framework type with all nodes identical and with alternating nodes marked are shown in Figs. 20a and b, respectively. The lattice constant (repeat distance) a and one of the mirror planes for the former is shown in Fig. 20a. In Fig. 20b, the symmetry reduction dictated by the ordering of Si and Al is readily apparent. Two obvious effects of the alternation are that (1) the mirror planes between sodalite cages are gone, and (2) the unit cell has to be doubled along each of the axes. Similar effects are observed in other materials in which the T-atoms are ordered.
58
Fig. 20. The LTA framework type (a) with all nodes identical, and (b) with alternating nodes marked. In (a) the repeat distance a and one of the mirror planes are indicated. In (b) the mirror plane shown in (a) is lost and the repeat distance is doubled in all directions (a'=2a). For simplicity, the necessary doubling of the unit cell in (b) is shown in only one direction.
3.2. Extra-framework species The channels and cages of a zeolite framework are usually filled with extra-framework species such as exchangeable cations, which balance the negative charge of the framework, removable water molecules, and/or organic species. These may come from the synthesis mixture or they may be the result of a post-synthesis treatment. Whatever their origin, it is often of interest to know where they are located. Modern crystallographic techniques generally allow such information to be extracted from diffraction data, but there are some limitations that should be appreciated. The primary problem is the fact that extra-framework species do not generally follow the high symmetry of the framework, so they are what is called "disordered". For example, the Na+ ion in an 8ring of zeolite A is located off-center where it can approach three framework oxygens (Fig. 21), but because there is a 4-fold axis running through the center of the 8-ring, there are four equivalent positions for the Na+ ion. However, there is only room for one Na+ ion per 8-ring. This Na+ ion may hop between the four equivalent positions (dynamic disorder) or it may be stationary but occupy different positions in different 8-rings (static disorder). Conventional X-ray analysis cannot distinguish between these two possibilities, but whichever is the case,
Fig. 21. The 8-ring in zeolite A (LTA) showing a Na+ ion position (gray) with its bonding to 3 framework oxygens, and the 3 unoccupied symmetry equivalent Na+ ion positions (dotted circles).
59 an electron density map generated from the diffraction data will show 1/4 of a Na ion (e.g. 10/4 electrons) at each equivalent position rather than one ion (10 electrons) at a single position. This means that the peaks in the electron density map are weak, and that chemical sense (e.g. known chemical composition, feasible coordination numbers, sensible interatomic distances and angles, no fractional atoms possible, etc.) must be used to interpret them. In the case above, the interpretation is relatively simple, but for more complex molecules, the interpretation of the electron density map becomes more difficult and ambiguous. Nonetheless, very useful information regarding the location of extra-framework species can be gleaned from a diffraction experiment. Examples include the location of the 18-crown-6 molecule required for the synthesis of pure EMC-2 (EMT) [20], the location of sorbed m- and p-xylene in Ba-exchanged zeolite X (FAU) at different loadings [21], and the location of naphthalene sorbed into ZSM-5 (MFI) [22]. 3.3. Stacking faults Closely related zeolite framework structures often form under very similar conditions, and this can lead to the formation of stacking faults or intergrowth structures. For example, both ZSM-5 (MFI) and ZSM-11 (MEL) contain pentasil sheets. The only difference between the two is the linkage between adjacent sheets (they are related by a center of inversion in MFI and by a mirror plane in MEL, see sections 2.2.7 and 2.2.8), and it is not uncommon for an occasional stacking fault to occur [23]. If substantial domains of two framework types are formed and these domains share a common face, the material is referred to as an intergrowth. One of the first zeolite intergrowths to be examined was that of the natural zeolites offretite (OFF) and erionite (ERI), which are members of the ABC-6 family of structures (see section 2.1) with AABAAB and AABAAC 6-ring stacking sequences, respectively [24]. In this case, the stacking is critical, because a single stacking fault in offretite (i.e. a C instead of a B) blocks the 12-ring channel. As might be imagined, the ABC-6 family of zeolites is quite prone to stacking "mistakes". If a stacking fault occurs regularly, a new framework type with a new repeat period is formed. The two structures are then called the end members of an intergrowth series. The Catalog of Disordered Zeolite Structures on the internet describes a number of such families. High resolution electron microscopy is the technique of choice for the investigation of such structural defects. The high-resolution images of a faulted material will show the local stacking sequences and domain sizes quite clearly. As was mentioned in sections 2.2.3 and 2.2.4, both zeolite structures can be built by stacking layers of sodalite cages in an ABCABC (for FAU) or ABAB (for EMT) sequence [25,2]. In this case, the stacking faults do not block the channels, but the local environments are slightly different, so some of the properties of the intergrowth materials can differ from those of the pure end members. Many such systems have been studied using electron microscopy techniques. Examples include studies of faulting in the zeolites beta (*BEA) [27], ferrierite (FER) [28], and NU-86 [29]. For further examples and experimental details, the reader is referred to the review by Terasaki et al. [30]. 4.
POWDER DIFFRACTION
Since zeolite structural information is very often derived from laboratory X-ray powder diffraction data, it is perhaps appropriate to outline a few aspects of the technique. Additional
60
Fig. 22. The relevant features of a powder diffraction pattern and their origin. information can be found in the book Modern Powder Diffraction edited by Bish and Post [31] and in the papers by Langford and Louer [32] and by Baerlocher and MeCusker [33]. 4.1. Information in a powder diffraction pattern A powder diffraction pattern has several features that can be of interest to a zeolite scientist: the peak positions, their relative intensities, their widths, and the background (Fig. 22). Each of these features can be interpreted relatively easily to yield useful information. The peak positions in a powder pattern (usually measured in °26) are determined only by the geometry of the unit cell. Each peak represents at least one reflection (and often several that happen to have similar 29 values). The 28 value is related to the
61
directions. For example, if the short dimension is assumed to be parallel to the c-axis, then the 001 reflections will be broader than the hkO reflections. In principle, this information can be used to establish how the channels of a zeolite of known structure are oriented in a membrane, because it is very thin in one direction. Finally, the background in a powder pattern indicates whether or not an amorphous material is present in the sample. A high background relative to the peaks is usually caused either by a large amount of amorphous material (e.g. unreacted gel) or by X-ray fluorescence. The latter is observed, for example, if an Fe-containing sample is irradiated with CuKa radiation. It can be avoided by changing the wavelength (e.g. to CoKa radiation). 4.2. Common applications Powder diffraction techniques are used on a routine basis by many zeolite scientists. Probably the most common application is the use of a powder diffraction pattern as a "fingerprint" in the identification of synthesis products. Ideally, a laboratory should have a set of "standard" zeolite patterns measured on the in house instrument for direct comparison. For laboratories without such a set of patterns or for those whose set is incomplete, the Synthesis Commission of the IZA has published experimental patterns for some zeolites in the book entitled Verified Syntheses of Zeolitic Materials [35] (also available on the internet at http://www.iza-synthesis.org/), and the Structure Commission has published a book entitled Collection of Simulated XRD Powder Patterns for Zeolites [36], which contains at least one representative powder diffraction pattern for each known framework type. An up-to-date internet version of the latter that includes data for newly approved framework types, is maintained at http://www.iza-structure.org/databases/. Even a cursory examination of the patterns in the Collection shows that different materials with the same framework type can have markedly different diffraction patterns, so direct comparison is not always straightforward. The identification of an unknown phase can sometimes be facilitated if the lattice parameters are determined, and these are compared with those of known zeolites. Of course, lattice parameters can also be used to study the effects of post-synthesis treatment (e.g. ion exchange, calcination, dealumination, sorption, etc.), to estimate Si/Al ratios in well-calibrated systems such as faujasite, to monitor a phase transition as a function of temperature, or to begin the structural characterization of a new material. Indexing a pattern can also serve to establish whether or not a phase is pure. If all lines can be indexed on a single unit cell, there is probably only one crystalline phase present. However, if there are unindexed lines, either the indexing is incorrect or there is a crystalline impurity present. A simple method for the evaluation of whether or not a post-synthesis treatment has induced structural change is to look at the effect on the powder diffraction pattern. Changes in the relative intensities of the peaks indicate that a structural modification has occurred, changes in the positions of the lines indicate that the unit cell has deformed in some way, and broader (or narrower) lines indicate that the crystallinity has deteriorated (or improved). In general, non-framework species have a pronounced effect on the low-angle region of the pattern. For example, a calcined material will tend to have higher relative intensities in this region than the corresponding as-synthesized or loaded sample. The high-angle region is usually less sensitive to the presence or absence of electron density in the channels and cages and more sensitive to distortions of the framework. More detail can be extracted from the powder pattern if a full Rietveld (whole-profile) structure refinement is performed [37,38], but even the simple qualitative evaluation of the pattern described above can be extremely
62
useful. Similarly, the presence of an amorphous phase can be established very easily simply by looking at the diffraction pattern. The determination of the structure of a zeolite with a new framework type remains a challenge to the powder method. Nonetheless, significant advances have been made in this area, and an increasing proportion of the new framework types are solved this way. While the techniques are rather sophisticated and beyond the scope of this chapter, it is perhaps important to know that methods of structure determination from powder diffraction data do exist and that all is not lost if single crystals of a new material cannot be synthesized. It may still be possible to solve the structure from the powder data [39,40,41]. Faulted materials (section 3.3) can also be recognized from their unusual powder diffraction patterns. The patterns are quite complicated, often with broadened lines for certain classes of reflections, and, until quite recently, could not be simulated easily. The calculation requires a knowledge of the structures of the end members, an estimate of the planar fault probability and an accurate description of the faulting involved. Given this information though, the program DIFFaX [42] can be used to simulate a powder pattern, which can then be compared with the observed one. In this way, the degree of faulting can be estimated. Such simulations for a number of zeolite families can be found in the Catalog of Disordered Zeolite Structures. It should be noted that the powder pattern of an intergrowth of two phases will be quite different from that of a physical mixture of those two phases. The latter is simply a summation of the powder patterns of the constituent phases in proportion to the amount present, while the former involves a much more complicated calculation. 5.
CONCLUSIONS
The key to understanding the properties of zeolites and zeolite-like materials lies in their structures. In this chapter, we have tried to convey the beauty and diversity of zeolite framework structures, to introduce some of the jargon used to describe them, and to outline some of the techniques used to characterize them. The main feature of a zeolite structure is its framework type, which describes the arrangement of the cages, the dimensionality of the channel system and the approximate size of the pore openings. A few framework types, selected for their industrial relevance and/or to illustrate some of the more common structural nomenclature, have been presented. However, there are many more, and for more information about a specific framework type, the reader is referred to the relevant references in the Atlas and the Collection. To fully understand the properties of a real zeolitic material though, not only the framework type, but also the composition and true geometry of the framework, the location and nature of the extraframework species, and the number and type of defects must be investigated. Since most zeolites are only available as polycrystalline phases, powder diffraction is an essential structural characterization technique. A powder diffraction pattern can be used to identify a material, to determine unit cell parameters, to estimate the quality of a sample, to monitor phase transitions, to evaluate whether or not a post-synthesis treatment has induced structural changes, to establish whether or not impurities (amorphous or crystalline) are present, or to recognize the presence of a significant level of faulting.
63 REFERENCES [I]
K.F. Fischer and W.M. Meier, Fortschr. Miner. 42 (1965) 50.
[2]
W.M. Meier and D.H. Olson, Adv. Chem. Ser. 101 (1971) 155.
[3]
R.M. Barrer, Pure Appl. Chem. 51 (1979) 1091.
[4]
L.B. McCusker, F. Liebau and G. Engelhardt, Pure Appl. Chem. 73 (2001) 381
[5]
Ch. Baerlocher, W.M. Meier and D.H. Olson, "Atlas of Zeolite Framework Types", 5th edn.,
[6]
E. Bonaccorsi, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 73 (2004) 129.
Elsevier, London, 2001 (formerly "Atlas of Zeolite Structure Types). [7]
R. Jelinek, A. Stein and G.A. Ozin, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 115 (1993) 2390.
[8]
J.V. Smith and J.M. Bennett, Am. Mineral. 66 (1981) 777.
[9]
T. Conradsson, M.S. Dadachov and X.D. Zou, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 41 (2000) 183.
[10] A. Corma, M.T. Navarro, F. Rey, J. Rius and S. Valencia, Angew. Chem., Int. Ed. 40 (2001) 2277. [II] Z. Liu, T. Ohsuna, O. Terasaki, M.A. Camblor, M.-J. Diaz-Cabanas and K. Hiraga, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123(2001)5370. [12] L.B. McCusker, Ch. Baerlocher, E. Jahn and M. Billow, Zeolites 11 (1991) 308. [13] R.M. Dessau, J.L. Schlenker and J.B. Higgins, Zeolites 10 (1990) 522. [14] J.W. Richardson, Jr. and E.T.C. Vogt, Zeolites 12 (1992) 13. [15] J. de Onate Martinez, L.B. McCusker and Ch. Baerlocher, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 34 (2000) 99. [16] K.G. Strohmaier and D.E.W. Vaughan, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125 (2003) 16035. [17] B. Harbuzaru, J.-L. Paillaud, J. Patarin and N. Bats, Science 304 (2004) 990. [18] A. Corma, M.J. Diaz-Cabanas, F. Rey, S. Nicolopoulus and K. Boulahya, Chem. Commun. (2004) 1356. [19] T. Blasco, A. Corma, M.J. Diaz Cabanas, F. Rey, J.A. Vidal Moya and CM. Zicovich Wilson, J. Phys. Chem. B 106 (2002) 2634. [20] Ch. Baerlocher, L.B. McCusker and R. Chiappetta, Microporous Mater. 2 (1994) 269. [21] C. Mellot, D. Espinat, B. Rebours, Ch. Baerlocher and P. Fischer, Catal. Lett. 27 (1994) 159. [22] H. van Koningsveld and J.C. Jansen, Microporous Mater. 6 (1996) 159-167. [23] G. Perego, M. Cesari and G. Allegra, J. Appl. Crystallogr. 20 (1987) 356. [24] J.M. Bennett and J.A. Gard, Nature (London) 214 (1967) 1005. [25] M.W. Anderson, K..S. Pachis, F. Prebin, S.W. Carr, O. Terasaki, T. Ohsuna and V. Alfredsson, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun. (1991) 1660. [26] M.M.J. Treacy, D.E.W. Vaughan, K.G. Strohmaier and J.M. Newsam, Proc. R. Soc. London A 452(1996)813. [27] J.M. Newsam, M.M.J. Treacy, W.T. Koetsier and C.B. de Gruyter, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 420 (1988) 375. [28] R. Gramlich-Meier, W.M. Meier and B.K. Smith, Z. Kristallogr. 169 (1984) 201. [29] M.D. Shannon in "Proc. 9th Int. Zeolite Conf, Montreal, 1992," R. von Ballmoos, J.B. Higgins and M.M.J. Treacy (eds.), Butterworth-Heinemann, Boston, MA, 1993, pp. 389-398.
64 [30] O. Terasaki, T. Ohsuna, V. Alfredsson, J.-O. Bovin, D. Watanabe and K. Tsuno, Ultramicroscopy 39 (1991) 238. [31] D.L. Bish and J.E. Post (eds.), Modern Powder Diffraction, Reviews in Mineralogy 30, 1989. [32] J.I. Langford and D. Louer, Rep. Prog. Phys. 59 (1996) 131. [33] Ch. Baerlocher and L.B. McCusker, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 85 (1994) 391. [34] J. Bergmann, A. Le Bail, R. Shirley and V. Zlokazov, Z. Kristallogr. 219 (2004) 783. [35] H. Robson and K.P. Lillerud, Verified Syntheses of Zeolitic Materials, 2nd edn., Elsevier, London, 2001. [36] M.M.J. Treacy and J.B. Higgins, Collection of Simulated XRD Powder Patterns for Zeolites, 4th edn., Elsevier, London, 2001. [37] R.A. Young (ed.), The Rietveld Method, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 1993. [38]
L.B. McCusker, R.B. Von Dreele, D.E. Cox, D. Louer and P. Scardi, J. Appl. Cystallogr. 32 (1999)36.
[39] W.I.F. David, K. Shankland, Ch. Baerlocher and LB. McCusker (eds.), Structure Determination from Powder Diffraction Data, Oxford University Press, Oxford, UK, 2002. [40] L.B. McCusker in Abstracts 14th Int. Zeolite Conf., E.W.J. van Steen, L.H. Callanan, M. Claeys and C.T. O'Connor (eds.), Transformation Technologies, Cape Town, South Africa, 2004, pp. 42-52. [41] A. Burton, Z. Kristallogr. 219 (2004) 866. [42] M.M.J. Treacy, J.M. Newsam and M.W. Deem, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 433 (1991) 499.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
65
Synthesis of zeolites and zeotypes C. S. Cundy Centre for Microporous Materials, School of Chemistry, University of Manchester, P.O. Box 88, Sackville Street, Manchester M60 1QD, United Kingdom
1. SCOPE OF THIS ACCOUNT 2. HISTORY 3. SOURCES OF INFORMATION 3.1. Background 3.2. Experimental aspects 4. MAKING ZEOLITES AND ZEOTYPES IN THE LABORATORY 4.1. Outline of typical observations 4.2. Following the course of a synthesis 4.3. Microwave heating 5. MODELLING THE PROCESSES OF ZEOLITE SYNTHESIS 5.1. Mathematical models of synthesis reactions 5.2. Molecular Modelling 5.3. Use of a simple reaction model to clarify an experimental concept: how fast is my reaction? 6. STUDIES OF ZEOLITE AND ZEOTYPE CRYSTALLISATION 6.1. The induction period 6.2. Nucleation 6.2.1. Basic concepts 6.2.2. Data and measurement 6.2.3. The nature of nucleation in zeolite systems 6.3. Crystal growth 6.3.1. Experimental observations 6.3.2. Growth models 7. EXPLAINING THE EXPERIMENTAL OBSERVATIONS 7.1. Equilibria and kinetics 7.2. An overall model for the synthesis process 7.3. A stepwise reaction model 7.4. The mechanism in chemical terms 7.5. Alternative views of the synthesis mechanism 7.5.1. Solution-mediated or solid phase? 7.5.2. The nature of growth species 7.5.3. Other porous materials 8. CONCLUSION APPENDIX: SOME EXAMPLES OF ZEOLITE AND ZEOTYPE SYNTHESES 1. Synthesis of MFI materials (silicalite-1, ZSM-5) 2. Microwave synthesis of A1PO4-5 by a fluoride route REFERENCES
66 1. SCOPE OF THIS ACCOUNT This short review of zeolite and zeotype synthesis is written for those who are relatively new to the field. It aims to present an overall introduction to some fundamental aspects of the subject and to indicate where further information can be found. An account of experimental practice is followed by a summary of mathematical modelling procedures. Observations from crystallisation studies then introduce basic principles of the synthesis process. 2. HISTORY Aluminosilicate zeolites and their analogues are almost invariably prepared by the process of hydrothermal synthesis, i.e. by the action of heat upon an aqueous reaction mixture, usually under pressure. Early work was based on attempts to synthesise materials previously observed as natural minerals. However, the resulting claims are difficult to substantiate since there were no reliable methods for fully identifying and characterising the products. The first studies having a sound scientific basis were those of Richard Barrer and Robert Milton, commencing in the late 1940s. Barrer began his work by investigating the conversion of known mineral phases under the action of strong salt solutions at fairly high temperatures (ca. 170-270 °C) and quickly discovered the first synthetic zeolite unknown as a natural mineral (species P and Q [1], later found to have the KFI structure [2]). Robert Milton pioneered the use of more reactive starting materials (freshly precipitated aluminosilicate gels), enabling reactions to be carried out under milder conditions and leading to the discovery of zeolites A and X [3]. Early work on zeolite synthesis utilised only inorganic reaction components but in 1961 the range of reactants was expanded to include quaternary ammonium cations [4,5]. This in turn led to the discovery of silica-rich phases (high-silica zeolites) such as zeolite beta [6] (1967) and ZSM-5 [7] (1972). Many more synthetic zeolites were subsequently discovered [2], as well as new families of zeolite-like or zeolite-related materials [8] known as zeotypes. Examples of the latter include the microporous alumino- and gallo-phosphates (AIPO4S and GaPO4s) [9,10] and the titanosilicates (such as ETS-10) [11]. Zeotype materials display great compositional diversity and frequently have frameworks unknown for zeolites. This increased structural flexibility originates from the intrinsic heteroelement properties and in particular the expanded range of atomic radii, bond lengths and bond angles, leading also to coordination numbers greater than four. Even further removed from the realm of microporous aluminosilicates are the major new class of zeolite-related phases discovered in the early 1990s. Mesoporous materials, synthesised with the aid of surfactant molecules and typified by the M41S and SB A series, have periodic structures with far larger pore sizes (up to ca. 200 A) but are not conventionally crystalline [12-14]. Investigative work aimed at gaining an understanding of the synthesis process has its origins in the 1960s. These studies continue today, aided by discoveries of new materials, advances in synthetic procedures, innovations in theoretical modelling methods and, especially, by the development of new techniques for the investigation of reaction mechanisms and the characterisation of products.
67 3. SOURCES OF INFORMATION 3.1. Background Essential facts and figures on the synthesis of crystalline microporous materials can be found in the textbooks by Breck [15], Barrer [16] and Szostak [8], and also within previous volumes on zeolite science and technology published in collaboration with the International Zeolite Association (IZA) [17,18]. These sources contain (besides much other useful background material) chapters on the synthesis of zeolites, metallophosphates and other porous framework structures. Further background information is available in a number of reviews and surveys and a representative selection of the more recent of these is given in Table 1. 3.2. Experimental aspects Descriptions of the syntheses of zeolites and zeotypes are very widely disseminated in the journal and patent literature. Searches carried out on, for example, zeolite A or ZSM-5 would reveal hundreds of examples. In general, it is often instructive to look both at some of the original synthesis procedures (often as patent examples) and also at some of the most recently published methods. For all materials, the extent of information increases with the length of time since first disclosure. This means that the amount of data on (for example) recently-discovered zeotype phases may be quite limited. A very useful source for experimental methods and reliable synthetic procedures for zeolites and the more common zeotypes can be found in the handbook issued by the Synthesis Commission of the International Zeolite Association (IZA) [51]. Some practical aspects of zeolite synthesis are described in the following section, whilst some illustrative examples of laboratory preparations are given in the Appendix. Scale-up and industrial production are outside the scope of this work. 4. MAKING ZEOLITES AND ZEOTYPES IN THE LABORATORY 4.1. Outline of typical observations A typical hydrothermal zeolite or zeotype synthesis can be described as follows: 1. Sources of the main compositional components (e.g. silica, alumina, heteroatom source) are selected, using criteria such as availability, chemical reactivity and cost. Such reactants are usually in an oxide-like form and amorphous. 2. The chosen reactants are then mixed together with a cation source, usually in a basic (high pH) water-based medium. 3. The aqueous reaction mixture is heated, often (> 100 °C) in a sealed autoclave. 4. For some time after raising to synthesis temperature, the reactants remain amorphous. 5. After the above "induction period", crystalline zeolite or zeotype product can be detected. 6. Gradually, essentially all amorphous material is replaced by an approximately equal mass of product crystals, which are recovered by filtration, washing and drying.
68
Table 1 Selected reviews and surveys relating to zeolite and zeotype synthesis Author(s)
Year
Title (abbreviated)
Ref.
Occelli, Robson (Eds)
1989
Zeolite synthesis (symposium proceedings)
[19]
Gilson
1992
Organic and inorganic agents in molecular sieve synthesis
[20]
Davis, Lobo
1992
Zeolite and molecular sieve synthesis
[21 ]
Occelli, Robson (Eds)
1992
Synthesis of microporous materials (symposium)
[22]
Feijenetal.
1994
Zeolites and their mechanism of synthesis
[23]
Kessler et al.
1994
Fluoride route in the synthesis of microporous materials
[24]
Davis
1995
Strategies for zeolite synthesis by design
[25]
Morris, Weigel
1997
Synthesis of molecular sieves from non-aqueous solvents
[26]
Occelli, Kessler (Eds)
1997
Synthesis of porous materials (symposium proceedings)
[27]
Thompson
1998
Recent advances in the understanding of zeolite synthesis
[28]
Francis, O'Hare
1998
Kinetics & mechanisms of zeotype crystallisation
[29]
Brock etal.
1998
Porous manganese oxide materials
[30]
Oliver et al.
1998
A new model for aluminophosphate formation
[31 ]
Cheetham et al.
1999
Open-framework inorganic materials
[32]
Millinietal.
1999
Synthesis & characterisation of Boron molecular sieves
[33]
Cambloretal.
1999
Synthesis of high-silica molecular sieves in F media
[34]
Matsukata et al.
1999
Conversion of dry gel to microporous crystals in gas phase
[35]
Guth, Kessler
1999
Synthesis of Al,Si-zeolites & related silica-based materials
[36]
Ma et al.
2000
Zeolite-like porous materials
[37]
Fricke et al.
2000
Gallium zeolites: syntheses, properties, catalysis
[38]
Serrano, van Grieken
2001
Heterogeneous events in the crystallisation of zeolites
[39]
Balkus
2001
Synthesis of large pore zeolites and molecular sieves
[40]
Taulelle
2001
Crystallogenesis of microporous metallophosphates
[41]
Eddaoudi et al.
2001
Modular chemistry: SBUs in porous carboxylate design
[42]
Nishi, Thompson
2002
Synthesis of classical zeolites
[43]
Patarinetal.
2002
Synthesis of AlPOs and other crystalline materials
[44]
Anderson, Rocha
2002
Synthesis of titanosilicates and related materials
[45]
Serre, Taulelle, Ferey
2003
Rational design of porous titanophosphates
[46]
Cundy, Cox
2003
Hydrothermal synthesis of zeolites: history, development
[47]
Corma
2004
Towards a rationalisation of zeolitic materials synthesis
[48]
Corma, Davis
2004
Issues in the synthesis of crystalline molecular sieves
[49]
Cundy, Cox
2005
Hydrothermal synthesis of zeolites: reaction mechanism
[50]
69
This is illustrated schematically in Fig. 1 for an aluminosilicate system. The elements (Si, Al) which will make up the microporous framework are imported as precursors containing Si-0 and Al-0 bonds. During the hydrothermal reaction in the presence of a "mineralising" agent, most commonly an alkali metal hydroxide (but occasionally fluoride), the crystalline zeolite product (e.g. zeolite A or ZSM-5) containing Si-O-Al linkages is formed. No radically new bond types are created in this reaction so that the resulting enthalpy change (AH) is small. Whilst the reactants actually employed may include the simple oxides or hydroxides mentioned above (e.g. precipitated silica or alumina trihydrate), it is also very common for the reagents to represent some degree of precombination of components, as for example in sodium silicate solution or solid sodium aluminate. These materials may present advantages in cost or ease of processing and may also offer optimum routes to particular materials. 4.2. Following the course of a synthesis Although it is possible to learn something about the pathway followed in a synthesis reaction from examination of the start (reactants) and the end (products) of the process, the only really satisfactory method is to make observations throughout the course of the experiment. Ideally, this should be by some in-situ, non-invasive method, such as microscopy or spectroscopy. However, there have been only a few such investigations (see e.g. section 6.3.]), largely because of the difficulty of making the necessary measurements on caustic mixtures under conditions of elevated temperature and pressure. More commonly, analyses are carried out on samples isolated at intervals during the course of the synthesis. The best procedure is for material to be periodically extracted from the reaction vessel via a sampling device during a single reaction run. Stirring is usually essential for the provision of homogeneous and representative samples.
Fig. 1. Schematic representation of hydrothermal zeolite synthesis.
70
An alternative procedure is for the original batch of reaction mixture to be divided into a series of aliquots. These are then heated in separate vessels which are removed from the reaction oven at known time intervals. This procedure has the advantage of convenience but suffers from the disadvantage that the reaction conditions may not be exactly the same in every case. Differences may be caused by, for example, trace contaminants in the reaction vessels or small variations in temperature from one vessel to another. (Running each sample in duplicate provides a check on this.) The products from each sample are analysed by some selective technique which recognises a characteristic product property, such as XRD (phase, crystallinity), IR (characteristic band frequencies) or sorption (micropore volume). In each case, a plot of the defining property against time will give an S-shaped growth curve which reflects the rate of product formation. In some cases, other measurements (e.g. crystal size) can also be carried out (see section 6.3.1). A measurement of fundamental importance is the rate of size increase of a crystal with time (the linear growth rate). 4.3. Microwave heating In many synthesis reactions, heating is carried out by direct thermal methods, most usually by placing the reaction vessel in a conventional oven. However, a very useful alternative procedure is microwave dielectric heating [52,53]. In its simplest form, this entails the use of a suitable, microwave-transparent glass or plastic (e.g. Teflon) reaction vessel, which is placed in a laboratory microwave oven. The benefits to zeolite synthesis have been discussed in a review [54]. In conventional (thermal) heating, reactions may be strongly influenced by the rate of heat transfer through the walls of the containing vessel and the resulting thermal gradients across the reaction volume. These limitations are modified when a different form of energy input is applied. The most apparent advantage of microwave heating is the significant shortening of reaction time which is found in virtually every case. The factors underlying the reduced timescale have been analysed [54,55] in terms of the contributions from (i) thermal lag, (ii) the induction period and (iii) crystal growth. The major accelerations derive from (i) and (ii) by virtue of the rapid heating rate to the working temperature and also from nonequilibrium (e.g. differential heating) effects. The rapid heating rate also means that the effects of seeding and of reactant history (e.g. ageing) can also be important [55,56]. In some cases, the special conditions of microwave synthesis can lead to product selectivity, if some component of the system is selectively sensitive to microwave energy input or to heating rate. Such a situation might arise in a heterogeneous reaction mixture containing components of different dielectric properties, or through differences in the rival rates of nucleation and growth of competing phases. Phase selectivity in zeolite Y synthesis has been demonstrated by the suppression of undesired co-products in microwave-mediated preparations, even under conditions (150 °C) where zeolite P would normally dominate in a thermal synthesis [54,57]. 5. MODELLING THE PROCESSES OF ZEOLITE SYNTHESIS Not all our knowledge of microporous materials synthesis has come from laboratory experimentation. Valuable understanding has also been achieved from the development and use of a variety of mathematical modelling procedures. These have increased greatly in
71
importance with the huge growth in computing capability in recent years. Computational methods have been applied both to the thermodynamics and the kinetics of the synthesis process and also to the molecular basis of the synthesis reactions. Important insight can be gained where laboratory and modelling studies are used together in a synergistic way. 5.1. Mathematical models of synthesis reactions Reaction models as used by chemists and engineers are of two basic types: (i) those using a kinetic approach and (ii) those founded on a thermodynamic approach. Those in the first category [58] range from simple empirical correlations to complex computer programs. Of the more complex treatments, the most important are those based on particle numbers, such as the population balance model [59,60] developed extensively by Thompson and coworkers. By the use of groups of equations which describe the evolution with time of the mass and the numbers of particles, hypothetical reactions can readily be explored to assess the effect of changing reaction variables and introducing other components such as seed crystals. For example, predictions of crystal size and size distribution can be developed to reflect changes in nucleation and growth behaviour brought about by gel ageing [61]. A significant thermodynamics-based treatment of zeolite synthesis is the equilibrium model of Lowe [62]. This was initially developed to provide insight into the pH changes which occur in the course of high-silica zeolite syntheses [63]. The model considers the zeolite synthesis process as a series of pseudo-equilibria: amorphous solid <-> solution species «-> crystalline zeolite progress of reaction
>
At the start, amorphous solid is in equilibrium with solution species. This initial equilibrium is then maintained while product crystals grow from the supersaturated solution. Finally, when all the amorphous precursor has been consumed, the crystalline zeolite equilibrates with its mother liquor. This simple analysis enables the solution chemistry, and in particular the effects of solubility and pH, to be understood at a fundamental level [62]. 5.2. Molecular modelling Molecular modelling methods [64-66] have provided insight into (i) the determination of the location and energies of the templating agents occluded within zeolite structures during synthesis and (ii) the detailed investigation of small framework fragments. The key advantage modelling methods offer over experimental techniques is that they permit investigation of the energetics of template-framework interactions, usually through the use of molecular mechanics calculations. This basic methodology has been employed in several different ways to investigate the relationship between template molecules and the zeolite product. For example, Zones et al. have made effective use of modelling methods to aid their search for bulky molecules that are too large, or have the wrong geometries, to synthesise well-known materials which might otherwise crystallise from their reaction mixtures. This has resulted in the discovery of several new structures [67]. The properties of small silica fragments which may be critical to the synthesis process are also difficult to study via experimental methods. Cluster calculations, usually based on
72
quantum mechanical approaches, have proved highly valuable as a tool to probe their detailed structure, geometry and reactions [68,69]. Pereira et al. [70,71] have developed these procedures to examine the interaction between solvated zeolite fragments and template molecules, demonstrating that the organic molecule plays a key role in stabilizing clusters of framework material and preserving their structure under the influence of water. Recently, Wu and Deem [72] have developed a Monte Carlo procedure to model a silicate solution on the atomic scale in the absence of a template molecule. This study has yielded an insight into some of the fundamental processes associated with nucleation such as an estimation of the nucleation barrier and the critical cluster size. 5.3. Use of a simple reaction model to clarify an experimental concept: how fast is my reaction? The statement is frequently made that one zeolite synthesis is "faster" than another but the measurement criteria may be extremely loosely defined. Often, there is no distinction between the induction time and the growth period (section 6), so that it is impossible to tell whether a reaction is "slow" because it takes a long time to nucleate or because the crystals grow slowly in the given circumstances. A comparison of some hypothetical synthesis reactions is shown in Table 2. The data are derived from a computer simulation of zeolite growth based on a very simple kinetic crystal growth model [50,73], i.e. radial growth rate = dr / d^
product mass (m) = 4n7ipr3/ 3
where m is the mass of product crystals (density p, equivalent spherical radius r) per unit volume and n is their number per unit volume. The data are not specific to any particular system but are chosen to be reasonably realistic and could, for example, be related to MFItype syntheses operating at around 100 °C. Following an initial single nucleation event, the monodisperse crystal population is allowed to grow at the stated rate up to a nominal 100% Table 2 A simple model for zeolite growth: demonstration of comparative rate criteria Starting parameters
Run 1
Run 2
Run 3
Crystal radial growth rate (jim h"1) Nucleation rate (# cm'3 h"1)a Induction period (h)
0.01 10" 0
0.02 109 5
0.01 1012 15
Simulation results Time to reach 100% yield, tf (h) Yield at 0.25 tf (%) Yield at 0.50 tf (%) Yield at 0.75 tf (%) Crystallisation rate (% h"1) b Crystal size (um) a applied during first hour of reaction onl;
20 1.6 12.5 42 9.6 4
15 17 0 0 1.8 0 25 0 19.5 100 4 0.4 gradient at 50% conversion
73
conversion of starting materials. (Note that there are no terms to account for a more realistic reaction termination in which growth slows gradually as reactants become exhausted.) The three simulations all reach completion within 15-20 h but have completely different growth profiles. Depending on the criterion chosen (e.g. yield at t/2, total reaction time, crystallisation rate), each one of the three could be claimed as the fastest synthesis! Such ambiguities can be avoided by specifying (a) some form of quantitative growth curve (section 4.2) and (b) a reliable product crystal size distribution (e.g. from a calibrated SEM). From these basic data, an estimate can be made of (i) how long the reaction took to start, (ii) when the first crystals appeared, (iii) the time at which crystallisation stopped and (iv) how to interpret the growth period in the light of the likely nucleation profile. 6. STUDIES OF ZEOLITE AND ZEOTYPE CRYSTALLISATION: A STEP-BY-STEP DESCRIPTION OF THE SYNTHESIS PROCESS The synthesis of crystalline microporous solids is a complex reaction-crystallisation process, usually involving a liquid phase and both amorphous and crystalline solid phases. Described below (section 6) are the main elements of this transformation: the induction period, nucleation processes and crystal growth. Having established this background, the mechanism underlying these changes is then examined in more detail (section 7). 6.1. The induction period The induction period (r) is the time (t) from the start of the reaction to the point at which crystalline product is first observed. It therefore depends on the moment chosen for setting t = 0 (often taken as the time at which the reactants reach the working temperature) and upon the method of analysis used to detect the product (most usually X-ray diffraction). In this time, the zeolitic product is born. Firstly, the reactants interact with one another and begin to equilibrate. During this period, there is an increase in structural ordering within the amorphous phase. There is then a step change leading to the establishment of the zeolite lattice itself, i.e. nucleation. At this point, a statistical selection of the reconstructed areas reach a critical nuclear size and degree of order such that a periodic structure is able to propagate. Crystal growth begins and the newlyformed nanocrystal grows to a detectable size. 6.2. Nucleation 6.2.1. Basic concepts We may imagine a sub-nuclear unit of radius r. As this grows, it gains in cohesive energy, a quantity proportional to its volume (AGV a r"), but also has to expend energy in creating a surface to achieve separation from its surroundings (AGS a r2). As r increases, a point is reached (at the critical nuclear size (rc) [74]) where AGV equals and then exceeds AGS, leading to an overall gain in free energy. This enables a stable unit to be formed: a viable nucleus, capable of growth. For zeolite systems, a critical size of 1-8 unit cells has been estimated by Thompson and Dyer [59]. However, the chemical and physical processes leading up to critical nucleus formation are governed by the structure being formed and by the experimental conditions. If these conditions change, then the necessary critical size will also vary. A notional
74
nucleation rate (J) can be defined as the rate of production of units having radius r > rc. A simple measure of J is often taken by assuming J a 1/r [47,75]. However, since the induction period is a compound term containing components of equilibration time and early growth as well as the time required for nucleation itself, this procedure is subject to error [76,77]. The nomenclature for the most usually recognised types of nucleation can be summarised as follows [74]: primary nucleation may be homogeneous (from solution) or heterogeneous (induced by foreign particles); secondary nucleation (induced by crystals) may be considered as a special case of heterogeneous nucleation in which the nucleating particles are crystals of the same phase. Good general accounts of nucleation in zeolite systems (along with further references) will be found in reviews by Barrer [16] and Thompson [28,60]. 6.2.2. Data and measurement Obtaining direct experimental data on nucleation processes is very difficult due to the extremely small fraction of the total mass involved and the problems of distinguishing this from surrounding reactants of very similar nature and composition. Consequently, much of the information available is more that of early growth behaviour rather than of nucleation itself. Recent cryo-TEM [78] and HRTEM studies [79-81] represent the most direct evidence of nucleation phenomena currently available. However, much useful data can be obtained from "circumstantial evidence", i.e. measurements of the appearance, growth and size distribution of the crystals resulting from the earlier, hidden patterns of nucleation. The procedure of Zhdanov and Samulevich enables the calculation of isothermal nucleation rate profiles from determinations of growth rate and crystal size distribution [16,82]. Originally implemented in analyses of zeolite Na-A [83] and Na-X [82] crystallisation, the method has subsequently been applied to other zeolite systems, including silicalite [84,85]. If it is supposed that all the crystals in a batch have the same (known) growth rate behaviour, the total growth time of each crystal can be calculated. Assuming also that the nucleation point for each crystal can be obtained by linear extrapolation to zero time, the nucleation profile for the whole batch can be determined from their final sizes. Detailed information on nucleation behaviour can also be obtained from work on the ageing of reaction mixtures. The crystallisation behaviour of a synthesis composition is often dependent upon the time-temperature history of the sample in advance of the principal heating step. The first studies to link these time-dependent effects with control of crystal size were those of Freund [86] and of Zhdanov and coworkers [82]. These investigations showed that roomtemperature ageing of aluminosilicate Na-A and Na-X gels resulted in both an acceleration of the crystallisation and a decrease in the crystal size of the product, thus linking the ageing process directly with the number of nuclei formed. More recently, related studies by Cizmek et al. [87], Cundy et al. [88] and Li et al. [89] have provided detailed insights into nucleation processes in the silicalite-1 system. In addition, modelling work has allowed the simulation of gel ageing by population balance methods [61]. Assuming that the ageing step results in the formation of viable nuclei that effectively lie dormant until the temperature is raised, it has been shown that the number of nuclei generated during ageing strongly influences subsequent crystallisation behaviour, whilst their size is relatively unimportant.
75 6.2.3. The nature ofnucleation in zeolite systems It seems reasonable to suppose that the construction of the nucleus of a zeolite crystal may involve a more complex assembly process than is necessary for simpler substances whose unit cells are smaller and contain far fewer atoms, although there should be no difference in basic principles. The nature of the nucleation process in zeolite systems is also complicated by the nature of zeolite synthesis sols. These contain observable solid phases (amorphous gel, crystals) and components (cations, anions) in true solution. However, there is frequently also a colloidal component, invisible to the naked eye, which itself may be amorphous or crystalline. In zeolite synthesis, there is evidence for the participation of both primary and secondary (crystal-catalysed) nucleation, although the former is believed to be the most prevalent [28,60]. Even so, there is often disagreement on whether the predominant mechanism is homogeneous or heterogeneous. However, it can be seen from the foregoing paragraph that in zeolite systems an apparently homogeneous nucleation may actually involve the participation of colloidal amorphous material. Supporting evidence for this came initially from microscopic observations on dilute reaction mixtures [84,90] but the process has recently been directly demonstrated for the "clear solution" syntheses of zeolites A [80], Y [81] and Si-MFI [79]. Using highresolution transmission electron microscopy (HRTEM) in conjunction with in-situ dynamic light scattering (DLS), X-ray diffraction and other techniques, Mintova et al. have imaged the development of crystalline structure within amorphous gel particles of nanometre dimensions. Single zeolite A crystals were observed [80] to nucleate in amorphous gel particles of 40-80 nm in size within 3 days at room temperature. The embedded zeolite A nanocrystals grew at room temperature, consuming the gel particles and forming a colloidal suspension of 40-80 nm crystals. A broadly similar picture was found for the zeolite Y [81] and Si-MFI [79] phases. It has therefore been concluded that (i) the most common process of zeolite nucleation relies on a primary nucleation mechanism and (ii) the most probable primary nucleation mode is heterogeneous and centred upon the amorphous phase of the reaction mixture (which for most "clear solution" syntheses is colloidal in nature). 6.3. Crystal growth 6.3.1. Experimental observations In a typical zeolite synthesis, the first definite evidence for a successful reaction is the appearance of crystals of the product. As noted above (section 6.1), this signal for the end of the induction period is dependent upon the method of detection - most commonly a combination of visual inspection or microscopy with X-ray diffraction. Thereafter, crystal growth can be monitored by the same techniques and the resulting S-shaped growth curve of bulk crystallinity against time is by far the most commonly reported measurement of zeolite crystallisation kinetics (Fig. 2). More closely related to the growth mechanism itself is the crystal linear growth rate and to determine this some form of size measurement is made as a function of time. Suitable data can be obtained from samples taken during the course of small-scale experiments, through the use of particle counters relying on (for example) light scattering, conductivity across an orifice, or diffraction effects. More directly, the sizes of individual crystals can be measured by optical or
76
electron microscopy. These methods were used in the first determinations of linear growth rates (for zeolites A and X) by Zhdanov and coworkers [82,83] and were later applied to ZSM-5 synthesis by Nastro and Sand [91]. In these cases, measurements were carried out on syntheses sampled or terminated at a series of different reaction times. The first in-situ growth rate determinations were made by Lowe et al. [92,93], who used optical microscopy to study the growth behaviour of ZSM-5 and other high-silica zeolites by direct observation of reaction mixtures contained in glass capillaries. This work was extended by Sano, Iwasaki and coworkers using a specially-constructed cell in which a sample of ZSM-5 reaction mixture maintained at temperatures up to 170 °C could be directly observed using an optical reflection microscope [94]. The plots of crystal size against time typically show a constant linear growth rate for most of the reaction with a final tailing-off due to nutrient depletion (Fig. 2). From this and also from the magnitude of the activation energies (ca. 45-90 kJ mol"'), it is very probable that the rate controlling process is the surface integration step of crystal growth itself [16,28,93]. The activation energies are typical of those found for making and breaking T - 0 bonds [95,96] and much higher than would be expected for a process controlled by diffusion from the bulk liquid phase to the crystal surface (see Ref. [16], p. 152). Zeolite crystal linear growth rates show a strong temperature dependence. However, even for a given structure type, the rates are also influenced by other synthesis variables, particularly reaction composition. In a few cases, systematic studies have been reported, although most of these relate to the ZSM-5 system. Some typical zeolite and zeotype crystal growth rates are given in Table 3 (although data on the latter are very scarce). These growth rates are 2-A orders of magnitude smaller than comparable values for simple ionic salts (such as alums or alkali halides) or simple molecular compounds (e.g. sucrose) [74]. This large difference reflects the
Fig. 2. Zeolite or zeotype synthesis: crystal linear growth plot (solid line) and corresponding bulk growth curve (broken line). The crystallinity curve has here been calculated (by cubing the linear growth values).
77 Table 3 Some published values for zeolite and zeotype crystal linear growth rates System investigated
Zeolite or zeotype
Temperature range (°C)
Other parameters investigated
Na-A Na-A
50-100 60-80
Alkalinity, seeding Alkalinity, SiO2 source, Na/K Ageing Si/Al variation SiO2 source Na, TPA, OH, SiO2 pH, TPA / Na (F system) — Composition & conditions Seeding, stirring (growth rate estimated) (growth rate estimated) Si/Al, Al source
Na-X 70-100 NaX,Y 88 Na-analcime 130-160 Na,TPA-ZSM-5 170 Na,TPA-ZSM-5 170 Na,TPA-ZSM-5 150-200 Na,TPA-ZSM-5 90-175 Dodecasil 1H 160-200 AIPO4-5 170-200* CoAPO-5 170-200* SAPO-5 210 * microwave heating
Range of measured linear growth rates 0.5 Al/At (urn h"1)
Ref.
0.011-0.13 0.02-0.06
[83] [97]
0.02-0.11 0.0005 - 0.2 1.2-5.5 0.5-1.1 0.08-1.0 0.4-3.2 0.01-1.17 0.47 - 0.98 6 0 - 120 60-120 30-50
[82] [98] [99] [100-102] [103] [104] [84,93] [105] [54] [54] [106]
nature of the zeolite synthesis reaction, in which a largely covalent, polymeric structure is being assembled piece by piece as T-O-T bonds are formed one after another. This is clearly a more complex and intricate process than the packing of relatively simple units in ionic or molecular crystals where bonding is electrostatic or van der Waals and relatively non-directional. However, the high values for the AlPO4-5-type materials (although enhanced by the high measurement temperatures) would appear to reflect their more polar nature (see section 7.5.3). 6.3.2. Growth models The slow linear growth rates of zeolite crystals at fairly high supersaturations [107] and the rarity of the observation of growth spirals [108] suggests that the predominant growth mode is that of the adsorption layer type [74], controlled by surface nucleation rather than by the screw dislocations necessary for the Burton-Cabrera-Frank spiral growth mechanism [109]. A simple picture of this is given in Fig. 3(a). Following Gibbs-Volmer theory [74], a growth unit is adsorbed on the growing crystal face and migrates to its optimum location (i), a high-energy kink site at which the number of points of attachment are maximised. Following completion of a given layer (ii), no further growth can occur in the absence of a dislocation. The next stage is made possible by the creation of monolayer island nuclei (2-dimensional nucleation) (iii) from which the growth process can continue on a layer-by-layer basis. Direct evidence for the layer growth model is emerging from AFM studies (Fig. 3(b)), the growth terraces sketched in Fig. 3(a) being clearly identifiable. Using a representation of the Gibbs-Volmer type, Agger et al. have modelled the growth of zeolite A in terms of the features seen in AFM images [110]. Growth probabilities are
78
Fig. 3. Layer-by-layer crystal growth: (a) adsorption layer model, showing (i) addition of growth unit with migration to high-energy kink site, (ii) completion of a layer, (iii) further growth through surface nucleation; (b) AFM image of growth terraces on a zeolite A surface (image area 2.5 x 2.5 um2).
assigned to the potential growth sites (edge, kink, etc.) and the relative values for these probabilities are adjusted until the computed unit-by-unit growth pattern matches that observed experimentally. It is found that, to match the observed features, growth at kink sites has to be 500 times faster than growth on the clean surface and 15 times faster than growth at an edge site. It is also apparent that the overall advance of a growth face must be controlled by the surface nucleation rate, the lateral spreading rate being much faster. 7. EXPLAINING THE EXPERIMENTAL OBSERVATIONS: EQUILIBRIA, KINETICS AND MECHANISM 7.1. Equilibria and kinetics As noted earlier (section 4.1), the bond type (e.g. Si-O, Al-O, P-O) of the crystalline product in a synthesis reaction is very similar to that present in the precursor oxides, so that no great enthalpy change (AH) would be anticipated. In fact, the overall free energy change (AG) for such a reaction is also usually quite small, with little difference between the pathways to a number of potential products. The outcome is therefore most frequently dominated not by the prevailing equilibria (thermodynamics) but by the relative rates of various competing reactions (kinetics) [47,49,111-113]. Kinetic control is a pervading influence throughout zeolite synthesis, where the desired product is frequently metastable. Much of the know-how in this industrially important area centres around choice of the exact conditions for product optimisation, so that the
79 required material can be prepared reproducibly and to the same specification (see Ref. [16], p. 175). Quantitative information relating to microporous materials is rare but recent papers by Petrovic et al. and Piccione et al. present data on the thermochemistry of high-silica zeolites [114,115] and the thermodynamics of their synthesis [113]. The observed range of enthalpies of transition is quite narrow at only 6.8-14.4 kJ/mol above that of quartz. Correspondingly, Gibbs free energy changes for the crystallisation of microporous silica phases from amorphous silica are estimated for R4N+-templated zeolites ZSM-5 and beta to be in the range -4.9 to -8.5 kJ/mol SiC>2. No single thermodynamic factor was found to dominate the overall Gibbs free energies and the small energetic differences were taken to suggest that kinetic factors were of major importance in molecular sieve preparation. It is possible to reach an analogous conclusion from calculations based on the Lowe equilibrium model for zeolite synthesis [47,62,92]. Molecular modelling calculations (section 5.2) also point to the similarity in template binding energy between different products of a common organic guest molecule. 7.2. An overall model for the synthesis process We have seen (Fig. 1) how, in the conversion of oxidic starting materials to a microporous crystalline framework, it is necessary both to break chemical bonds and to make new ones, e.g. (Si-O-Si), (A1-0-A1) [reactants] -» (Si-O-Al) [products]. To achieve this, it is necessary to dismantle the original polymeric structures (silica, alumina), confer upon the fragments some reactivity and mobility, and re-combine the resulting elements into a new crystalline framework. The active constituent which achieves this is sometimes known as a "mineraliser" and, since its mode of action is at least partly cyclic, its behaviour resembles that of a catalyst. This is shown diagramatically in the scheme below.
The reactants (designated "A") are attacked by the mineraliser (XT) to give mobile anionic species (AX~) which carry mass to the growing product crystals. These are the monomeric and oligomeric silicate and aluminosilicate anions known to be present in zeolite synthesis solutions [8,16,19], The mineraliser is detached in the crystallisation process, whence it returns to combine again with further reactants. In this scheme, the mineraliser is most commonly hydroxide ion, but it may be (for example) fluoride ion, or even an uncharged complexing agent. Again, the process may not be a simple cycle. In many cases, a portion of the X~ ion is retained within the product together with a charge-balancing cation. In some cases, the mineraliser and associated species may have restricted mobility. However, the general principle is a useful one for the many zeolitetype syntheses which conform to the pattern of nucleophile-mediated condensations. It is not applicable to those metal-organic open framework materials (section 7.5.3) which resemble coordination complexes and whose preparation is essentially an acid-base reaction.
80 7.3. A stepwise reaction model The model given above provides a description of the overall synthesis process. To reach the next level of detail, we may consider the reaction as comprising three stages based on the concepts of the Lowe equilibrium model [62,92] (section 5.7). For any given system, changes in the solid and solution species can be monitored by chemical and physical methods and are reflected in quite simple properties such as reaction pH [63]. Although there will be considerable variation between one system and another, a reasonable generalised mechanism can be proposed (Fig. 4) [50]. 1. The reactants equilibrate with each other and with the reaction solution During the first part of the induction period (section 6.1), the different components of the reaction interact with one another, moving towards a pseudo-equilibrium under the prevailing conditions of temperature and pressure. In many cases, a visible gel phase is present. In other cases, the same type of material is present as colloidal particles, invisible to the naked eye. A fragment or domain of this amorphous component is shown in Fig. 4(a) as a random network of linked tetrahedra [36], This amorphous material equilibrates with the cations and anions of the solution phase in such a way that local areas of increased order are created in which the structure begins to resemble that of the eventual product (Fig. 4(b)).
Fig. 4. Zeolite and zeotype synthesis: order is established ((a)-(d)) within a fragment of the solid phase through interaction with solution species in a cation-mediated self-assembly process (inset (e)).
81
2. Product crystals nucleate and grow from nutrient solution species provided by the reactants, which themselves dissolve further to maintain the equilibrium At some point in the equilibration process (1), areas of sufficient order and regularity are established for them to achieve a new type of growth that is completely regular and periodic. This is the process of crystal nucleation (section 6.2.1) in which the first viable fragment of the crystal lattice itself is established (Fig. 4(c)). This crystal embryo is able to grow in a uniform and systematic way. The same solution species which were involved in the initial equilibration now contribute to the growth, adding mass to the growing crystal. Amorphous areas dissolve to maintain the solution concentration (Fig. 4(d)). 3. When all the reactants have dissolved, the product crystals stop growing and equilibrate with the reaction solution Unless the processes of synthesis are interrupted (e.g. by removing the reaction vessel from the oven), the reaction will continue until a steady state is reached. Normally, this will occur when the reactants are exhausted so that there is no further nutrient available to continue the growth of the crystals. The product crystals are now in equilibrium with the residual species in their mother liquor. 7.4. The mechanism in chemical terms In the foregoing sections (7.2, 7.3), an outline mechanism for the assembly of zeolitelike materials is given. The underlying chemistry which enables these changes to occur comprises two principal elements: (a) a reversible mechanism for the cleaving and re-forming of framework chemical bonds and (b) the cation-assisted construction of ordered regions. The first of these processes has been highlighted by Flanigen and Breck [47,116] and by Chang and Bell [117], namely the breaking and remaking of Si,Al-O-Si,Al (T-O-T) bonds catalysed by hydroxyl ion, the related condensation reaction also playing a part: T - O H + " O - T ^ = ^ T - O - T + OFT T-OH + HO-T ^
T - O - T + H2O
However, the anions do not work in isolation and a crucial role in the progressive ordering process is played by the cations present in the synthesis system. These will act to attract around themselves energetically favourable coordination spheres of oxy-species and in so doing will generate certain preferred geometries. In this way, cation-dependent elements similar to those present in the eventual zeolite product will gradually be assembled. These reactions are responsible for the incremental increase in order leading up to the nucleation step and also subsequently for the related construction of the zeolite or zeotype crystal lattice itself. The notion of cation-assisted ordering derives from the ideas of Breck [118] and forms the basis for the structuring of silicate and aluminosilicate units through electrostatic and (for organo-cations) van der Waals forces as proposed by Flanigen [119,120], Chang and Bell [117] and Burkett and Davis [121-123]. This is illustrated diagrammatically by the central insert (e) in Fig. 4. Here, the hydrated cations are pictured as coordination centres (templates) for the growth-unit additions and ring-closures necessary for the construction of the framework. It is envisaged that this process of structure generation occurs at growth points situated at the solution-solid interface,
82 thus constituting an in-situ self-assembly process for the growing crystal. The nature of the growth units or building blocks is discussed further below (section 7.5). 7.5. Alternative views of the synthesis mechanism The general account presented above (sections 7.2-7.4) is intended to provide a flexible guide to the understanding of synthesis mechanism. Whilst it is certainly misleading to prescribe a single set of unchanging rules for every situation, it nevertheless seems likely that the models given earlier provide a reasonable basis for the interpretation of many experimental observations. However, there are several topics on which reference to the published literature will reveal considerable differences of opinion. 7.5.1. Solution-mediated or solid phase? Throughout the history of the synthesis of zeolite-like materials, there has been much debate about the location of the structure-forming activity [28,36,39,50]. At one extreme, there is the possibility of solution-mediated crystallisation. In this view, the reactants dissolve (to a greater or lesser extent) in the reaction mixture to afford active species, from which the product is formed as it crystallises from the solution. In the opposite view, the solution is seen as more or less inert with the product being formed within the gel phase by a process described as a "solid state transformation". Whereas the solution-mediated route is well known in the science of crystallisation, the alternative is a somewhat shadowy phenomenon for which no chemicallyspecific mechanism has ever been published. There are many transformations which appear to take place in the absence of a welldefined liquid phase but in nearly all cases a liquid-like phase is indeed present, either within the gel or as an adsorbed component. This provides the required mobility for the transport of active species and the construction of the crystal lattice, although active species may not be freely mobile within a bulk solution phase. With this caveat in mind, a mechanism based upon the solution-transport concept still seems the most useful general model. 7.5.2. The nature of growth species Concerning growth species, there are two main areas for controversy: (i) whether the growth units are solution species or particulates, and (ii) whether the formation of a particular structure requires the presence of specific building units. Several authors have postulated mechanisms for zeolite nucleation and growth which involve the aggregation of particles [78,124—127]. Much of this speculation arises from recent work on "clear solution" syntheses in the TPA-silicalite system, using advanced scattering and diffraction techniques. The basic argument is that primary sub-colloidal particles with diameter 3-4 nm aggregate and "density" in a series of steps to give clusters with a size of 6-7 nm and which are amorphous to X-rays. After this, the densified clusters aggregate to particles of around 50 nm in size which display X-ray crystallinity. No detailed explanations have been provided as to how a "growth by aggregation" model operates in chemical terms. For the reaction sol itself, a degree of agglomeration of sub-colloidal or colloidal amorphous particles seems very probable. However, a zeolite or zeotype growth mechanism based upon the aggregation of amorphous with crystalline particles [126], or the agglomeration of non-viable nuclei with other growing nuclei [128], is more problematic. Some form of
83 depolymerisation or in-situ reconstruction step involving mobile growth units is also necessary for the generation of an ordered periodic structure. Direct experimental evidence relating to the significance of aggregation processes comes largely from HRTEM studies. For example, a weakness of an aggregation growth mechanism involving additive entities of ca. 5 nm in size has been highlighted by Davis [129]. This is its inability to account for the existence of ordered crystalline mtergrowths of structurally different phases - a fact which is readily explained by a normal layer-by-layer mechanism of crystal growth (section 6.3.2). There exists a structural similarity between some species which are found in zeolite and zeotype synthesis solutions and the building units which appear in zeolite and zeotype frameworks. Several groups of workers have accordingly adopted the idea that a zeolite containing (for example) double-5-rings is constructed by the extraction and polymerisation of these units from the distribution of such species available in solution, the equilibrium then rapidly shifting to make up the deficit [124,130,131]. Although attractive, this theory, for zeolites at least, cannot be substantiated [132,133]. Predictions made on its basis (for example, on the density of defects in the resulting structures) are incorrect and there is no correspondence between the occurrence of particular solution anions and the nature or formation rate of a particular zeolite. However, such a theory can never be completely rejected since there is always the possibility of an active component present at a low (and possibly undetectable) level. The most generally applicable crystal growth model for zeolite systems is that based on mass gain from simple species (predominantly monomers) in solution [20,28,84,92,93,128,133135]. Following nucleation on or near the surface of an amorphous particle, the crystalline region is extended by the acquisition of growth units from solution. These are replenished by the adjustment of solution equilibria and the dissolution of amorphous (or less ordered) material. The identity of the growth species will depend on the reaction chemistry (e.g. OFT- or F~-based) but the same general principles should apply to every system. This is the type of growth assumed for the general mechanism given in Fig. 4. However, investigation of the nature of the species which carry mass to the growing crystal is a challenging experimental problem, which may in due course be resolved by (for example) a combination of AFM and Raman microscopies. 7.5.3. Other porous materials The majority of investigations on synthesis mechanism have been carried out on the materials which have been known for the longest time, i.e. the zeolites and zeolitic polymorphs. However, some studies are now available on the newer zeotypes such as the metallophosphates (AlPO4s, SAPOs, MeAPOs) [31,41,46,54,106,136-139] and the metal-organic [42,140,141] and other [142] open framework materials. The most significant difference in thinking on the two types of system concerns the importance of specific precursor units. Some workers in the zeotype field have adopted the idea of pre-nucleation building units (PNBUs) [41,143,144], suggesting that the products have been formed by condensation of such units pre-existing in the solution. Complex models of zeotype formation by linkage of 1- to 3-dimensional precursor units have been proposed [31,42,46]. Based largely on NMR evidence of solution species and the commonality of similar structural units in the products, a recent review of metallophosphate formation discusses a synthesis mechanism in which significant elements of the structure exist in solution as identifiable building blocks before being "clipped" together to form the precipitated product [41].
84
Some zeotype systems certainly behave very differently from their zeolite counterparts. One of the most striking demonstrations of this is found in the framework zinc phosphates, which can be crystallised very rapidly under very mild conditions, suggesting a more nearly ionic assembly route. For example, the sodalite analogue Na6(ZnPO4)6.8H2O can be made from a mixture of ZnO, H3PO4, NaOH and water in 24 h at room temperature [145], whilst Na,TMA-ZnPO4-faujasite can be synthesised in 30 min at 4 °C [146]. Even further along the polarity scale are the inorganic-organic hybrid materials [140] such as the complex metal carboxylates. In a recent report [147], a single reaction mixture produced five different cobalt succinates, the structure obtained depending only upon the reaction temperature. As the temperature was increased from 60 to 250 °C, the products became less hydrated and more dense, the structures changing from chains to sheets to frameworks across the series. However, whilst chemical differences between the different classes of microporous materials clearly do exist, it is not yet clear to what extent these affect the mechanism of synthesis. Possibly the products do derive directly from PNBUs but there seems no reason at present to reject the alternative possibility that much of this chemistry goes on at the liquidsolid interfacial growth points rather than (as is implied) independently of the growing crystal. It seems unlikely that any completely new concepts will be necessary to explain the formation patterns of zeotypes. However, just as the range of behaviour observed for zeolites requires a flexible (but coherent) mechanistic scheme, this spectrum will need to be further extended in order to allow for the differences in composition, structure, polarity and solution chemistry found in zeotype synthesis. 8. CONCLUSION Successful syntheses of a wide variety of zeolite and zeotype materials have been developed over the last 50 years. Much is known about the way in which these structures are formed, particularly from recent detailed studies using advanced techniques of microscopy (HRTEM and AFM). However, a number of issues surrounding the mechanism of synthesis remain incompletely resolved. This is partly due to experimental difficulty but is also a reflection of the fact that not all systems are the same. Nevertheless, in the foregoing account an attempt has been made to review our existing knowledge in terms of basic similarities between one reaction regime and another. In this way, it is hoped to establish some overall principles which, with appropriate modification, may be found to be generally applicable, or at least to provide a framework for further analysis. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS The author would like to acknowledge the contribution of his colleagues at the University of Manchester Centre for Microporous Materials in their advice and constructive comments. Particular thanks are due to Jonathan Agger and Itzel Meza who also provided Figure 3, and to Paul Cox (University of Portsmouth) for his sustained help and enthusiasm.
85 APPENDIX: SOME EXAMPLES OF ZEOLITE AND ZEOTYPE SYNTHESES Given below are two examples of flexible zeolite and zeotype syntheses which have been chosen for their merit in demonstrating a variety of techniques and underlying principles. Minimal description is provided (although some references are given to further information), the experiments providing scope for individual exploration and discovery. Important note It is assumed in the following examples of synthesis procedures that those carrying out the experiments will be adequately supervised by experienced scientists and that they will follow established procedures of good practice and safe working [51]. No specific warnings of individual hazards (e.g. caustic substances, pressure in reaction vessels) are here given. 1. Synthesis of MFI materials (silicalite-l, ZSM-5) The target reaction composition is jcNa2O : 60SiO2 : yA\2Oi : 6.0TPABr : 6000H2O : 240EtOH. The primary procedure (x = 3) is as follows. Tetraethyl orthosilicate (225 g) is added to a solution of sodium hydroxide (4.5 g), tetrapropylammonium bromide (TPABr) (28.5 g) and deionised water (1840 g) in a polypropylene container. The vessel is then sealed and the twophase mixture stirred at room temperature until the organic layer has reacted completely to give a clear, homogeneous sol (ca. 48 h). Silicalite. If the above sol is heated at 90-95 °C (preferably with stirring), silicalite is obtained in about 7-14 days as rounded, lozenge-shaped crystals (mostly twinned) of broad particle size distribution (0.5-10 um). Raising the reaction temperature to 130 °C shortens the reaction time (2-3 days) and changes the morphology, the product now being largely untwinned lozenges (3-20 um, aspect ratio 6:3:1). Ageing the reaction mixture before carrying out the
Fig. 5. Silicalite synthesised from hydrolysed tetraethyl silicate sols at («- left) 90 °C, (right -») 130 °C.
86 heating step encourages the generation of "proto-nuclei" [50,88]. For example, over a period of weeks (at room temperature) the crystal size distribution of the final product gradually narrows, eventually (ca. 1 year) reducing to a uniform value of around 2 um. The necessary heating time shortens correspondingly. The nucleation process can also be accelerated by raising the base level (preferably after completion of the initial hydrolysis step). At x = 8, a product of nearmonodisperse 2-4 um crystals may be obtained from unaged reaction mixtures as near-spherical twins (90-95 °C, 4-7 days) or lozenges (130 °C, <2 days), and both reaction time and crystal size can again be further reduced by ageing (Fig. 5). At these high base levels, the reaction mixtures will eventually yield crystalline silicalite at room temperature on storage (>2 years). ZSM-5. The above procedure can readily be adapted for the synthesis of the isostructural ZSM-5 by the inclusion of an aluminium source. The reaction time and product morphology are source-dependent. The most efficient incorporation of aluminium is obtained from soluble sources such as sodium aluminate, perhaps made in-situ [148]. As with other heteroatoms [149], there is a correlation between increasing temperature and increasing ease of aluminium incorporation into the framework of the product, the maximum readily attainable at around 90 °C being Si/Al = ca. 90. Very rapid crystallisation can be achieved by the synergistic use of nanocrystal seeding and microwave heating [55]. 2. Microwave synthesis of AlPO4-5 by a fluoride route [54,150,151] The target reaction composition is 1.0Al2O3 : 1.3P2O5 : 1.6TEA : 1.3HF : 320H2O. Phosphoric acid (85%, mass) (9.2 g) is diluted with water to 50% concentration and triethylamine (TEA) (5.0 g) is then added dropwise. At 0 °C, aluminium triisopropylate (12.6 g) is slowly added to the resulting mixture with intense stirring. After stirring the slurry at room temperature for 2 h, HF (40% (mass) aqueous) (2.0 g) is added and the mixture stirred for a further 2 h. The resulting homogeneous white gel is diluted with the remaining water (170 g), placed in a fluoropolymer autoclave and heated in a temperature-controlled microwave oven at 180 °C. With a CEM MDS-2100 laboratory microwave oven, a highly crystalline product was obtained in 15-30 min as hexagonal rods 6x2 - 45x12 um. In a comparative synthesis using a conventional oven, the minimum reaction time for a well-crystallised product of similar particle size was 12-24 h. In a variant to the microwave procedure, the reaction was stopped on reaching 175 °C (2 min) and the supernatant decanted from the settled solids. Further microwave heating (175 °C, 20 min) of the decanted solution produced a very clean product of uniform size distribution (24x7 um). Similar procedures can be used for CoAPO-5 synthesis [54,150,152] although with this more heterogeneous reaction mixture the microwave/decantation procedure is less effective in narrowing the size distribution. REFERENCES [1] [2] [3] [4] [5]
R.M. Barrer, C. Marcilly, J. Chem. Soc. (A) (1970) 2735. Ch. Baerlocher, W.M. Meier, D.H. Olson, Atlas of Zeolite Structure Types, 5lh Edn., Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2001. R.M. Milton in: M.L. Occelli, H.E. Robson (Eds.), Zeolite Synthesis, ACS Symp. Ser., Vol. 398, 1989, p. 1. R.M. Barrer, P.J. Denny, J. Chem. Soc. (1961) 971. G.T. Kerr, G.T Kokotailo, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 83 (1961) 4675.
87 [6] [7] [8] [9]
[10]
[11] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17]
[18] [19] [20]
[21 ] [22] [23]
[24]
[25]
[26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38]
R.L. Wadlinger, G.T. Kerr, EJ. Rosinski, US Patent 3,308,069 (1967). R.J. Argauer, G.R. Landolt, US Patent 3,702,886 (1972). R. Szostak, Molecular Sieves - Principles of Synthesis and Identification, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1989; 2nd Edn., Blackie, London, 1998. E.M. Flanigen, R.L. Patton, S.T. Wilson, in: P.J. Grobet, W.J. Mortier, E.F. Vansant, G. SchulzEkloff (Eds.), Innovation in Zeolite Materials Science, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 37, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1988, p. 13. J.A. Martens, P.A. Jacobs, in: J.C. Jansen, M. Stocker, H.G. Karge, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Advanced Zeolite Science and Applications, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 85, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994, p. 653. J. Rocha, M.W. Anderson, Eur. J. Inorg. Chem. (2000) 801. A. Corma, Chem. Rev. 97 (1997) 2373. U. Ciesla, F. Schiith, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 27 (1999) 131. F. Di Renzo, A. Galarneau, P. Trens, F. Fajula, in: F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Handbook of Porous Solids, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2002, Vol. 3, p. 1311. D.W. Breck, Zeolite Molecular Sieves, Wiley, New York, 1974. R.M. Barrer, Hydrothermal Chemistry of Zeolites, Academic Press, London, 1982. H. van Bekkum, E.M. Flanigen, P.A. Jacobs (2nd Edn. only), J.C. Jansen (Eds.), Introduction to Zeolite Science and Practice, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis: 1st Edn., Vol. 58, 1991; 2nd Edn., Vol. 137, 2001; Elsevier, Amsterdam. J.C. Jansen, M. Stocker, H.G. Karge, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Advanced Zeolite Science and Applications, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 85, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994. M.L. Occelli, H.E. Robson (Eds.), Zeolite Synthesis, ACS Symp. Ser., Vol. 398, 1989. J.-P. Gilson, in: E.G. Derouane, F. Lemos, C. Naccache, F.R. Ribeiro (Eds.), Zeolite Microporous Solids: Synthesis, Structure and Reactivity, NATO ASI Series, No. C352, Kluwer, Dordrecht, 1992, p. 19. M.E. Davis, R.F. Lobo, Chem. Mater. 4 (1992) 756. M.L. Occelli, H.E. Robson (Eds.), Synthesis of Microporous Materials, Vol. 1, Molecular Sieves, Van Nostrand Reinhold, New York, 1992. E.J.P. Feijen, J.A. Martens, P.A. Jacobs, in: J. Weitkamp, H.G. Karge, H. Pfeifer, W. Holderich (Eds.), Zeolites and Related Microporous Materials, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 84, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994, p. 3. H. Kessler, J. Patarin, C. Schott-Darie, in: J.C. Jansen, M. Stocker, H.G. Karge, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Advanced Zeolite Science and Applications, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 85, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994, p. 75. M.E. Davis in: L. Bonneviot, S. Kaliaguine (Eds.), Zeolites: A Refined Tool for Designing Catalytic Sites, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 97, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1995, p. 35. R.E. Morris, S.J. Weigel, Chem. Soc. Rev. 26 (1997) 309. M.L. Occelli, H. Kessler (Eds.), Synthesis of Porous Materials, Marcel Dekker, New York, 1997. R.W. Thompson, in: Molecular Sieves, Vol. 1, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1998, p. 1. R.J. Francis, D. O'Hare, J. Chem. Soc. Dalton Trans. (1998) 3133. S.L. Brock, N. Duan, Z.R. Tian, O. Giraldo, H. Zhou, S.L. Suib, Chem. Mater. 10 (1998) 2619. S. Oliver, A. Kuperman, G.A. Ozin, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 37 (1998) 46. A.K. Cheetham, G. Ferey, T. Loiseau, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 38 (1999) 3268. R. Millini, G. Perego, G. Bellussi, Top. Catal. 9 (1999) 13. M.A. Camblor, L.A. Villaescusa, M.J. Diaz-Cabanas, Top. Catal. 9 (1999) 59. M. Matsukata, M. Ogura, T. Osaki, P.R.H.R. Rao, M. Nomura, E. Kikuchi, Top. Catal. 9 (1999) 77. J.-L. Guth, H. Kessler, in: J. Weitkamp, L. Puppe (Eds.), Catalysis and Zeolites, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1999, p. 1. Y. Ma, W. Tong, H. Zhou, S.L. Suib, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 37 (2000) 243. R. Fricke, H. Kosslick, G. Lischke, M. Richter, Chem Rev., 100 (2000) 2303.
88 [39] [40] [41 ] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55] [56] [57]
[58] [59] [60] [61 ] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76]
[77] [78] [79]
D.P. Serrano, R. van Grieken, J. Mater. Chem. 11 (2001) 2391. K. J. Balkus, Progr. Inorg. Chem. 50 (2001)217. F. Taulelle, Curr. Opin. Solid State Mater. Sci. 5 (2001) 397. M. Eddaoudi, D.B. Moler, H. Li, B. Chen, T.M. Reineke, M. O'Keeffe, O.M. Yaghi, Ace. Chem. Res. 34(2001)319. K. Nishi, R.W. Thompson, in: F. Schiith, K.S.W. Sing, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Handbook of Porous Solids, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2002, Vol. 2, p. 736. J. Patarin, J.-L. Paillaud, H. Kessler, in: F. SchUth, K.S.W. Sing, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Handbook of Porous Solids, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2002, Vol. 2, p. 815. M.W. Anderson, J. Rocha, in: F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Handbook of Porous Solids, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2002, Vol. 2, p. 877. C. Serre, F. Taulelle, G. Ferey, Chem. Commun. (2003) 2755. C.S. Cundy, P.A. Cox, Chem. Rev. 103 (2003) 663. A. Corma, in: E. van Steen, L.H. Callanan, M. Claeys (Eds.), Proc. 14th Internat. Zeol. Conf., Catal. Soc. S. Africa, Cape Town, 2004, p. 25. A. Corma, M.E. Davis, ChemPhysChem 5 (2004) 304. C.S. Cundy, P.A. Cox, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. (2005), in press. H. Robson (Ed.), Verified Syntheses of Zeolitic Materials, 2nd rev. Edn., Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2001. D.M.P Mingos, D.R. Baghurst, Chem. Soc. Rev. 20 (1991) 1. K.J. Rao, B. Vaidhyanathan, M. Ganguli, P.A. Ramakrishnan, Chem. Mater. 11 (1999) 882. C.S. Cundy, Collection Czech. Chem. Commun. 63 (1998) 1699. C.S. Cundy, RJ. Plaisted, J.P. Zhao, Chem. Commun. (1998) 1465. P.M. Slangen, J.C. Jansen, H. van Bekkum, Microporous Mater. 9 (1997) 259. J.P. Zhao, C.S. Cundy, J. Dwyer, in: H. Chon, S.-K. Ihm, Y.S. Uh (Eds.), Progress in Zeolites and Microporous Materials, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 105, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1997, p. 181. R.W. Thompson, A. Dyer, Zeolites 5 (1985) 202. R.W. Thompson, A. Dyer, Zeolites 5 (1985) 292. R.W. Thompson, in: C.R.A. Catlow, R. Vetrivel (Eds.), Modelling and Reactivity in Zeolites, Academic Press, London, 1992, p. 231. J.D. Cook, R.W. Thompson, Zeolites 8 (1988) 322. B.M. Lowe, Zeolites 3 (1983) 300 (see also Ref. [92]). J.L. Casci, B.M. Lowe, Zeolites 3 (1983) 187. D.W. Lewis, C.R.A. Catlow, J.M. Thomas, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Discuss. 106 (1997) 451. P.A. Cox, J.L. Casci, A.P. Stevens, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Discuss. 106 (1997) 473. C.R.A. Catlow, D.S. Coombes, D.W. Lewis, J.C.G. Pereira, Chem. Mater. 10 (1998) 3249. S.I. Zones, Y. Nakagawa, L.T. Yuen, T.V. Harris, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 118 (1996) 7558. J. Sauer, Chem. Rev. 89 (1989) 199. J.R. Hill, J. Sauer, J. Chem. Phys. 98 (1994) 1238. J.C.G. Pereira, C.R.A. Catlow, G.D. Price, J. Phys. Chem. A 103 (1999) 3252. J.C.G. Pereira, C.R.A. Catlow, G.D. Price, J. Phys. Chem. A 103 (1999) 3268. M.G. Wu, M.W. Deem, J.Chem. Phys. 116 (2002) 2125. H. Kacirek, H. Lechert, J. Phys. Chem. 79 (1975) 1589. J.W. Mullin, Crystallisation, 4th Edn., Butterworth Heinemann, Oxford, 2001. A. Culfaz and L.B. Sand, in: W.M. Meier, J.B. Uytterhoeven (Eds.), Molecular Sieves, ACS Adv. Chem. Ser., Vol. 121, 1973, p. 140. B. Subotic, J. Bronic, T. Antonic, in: M.M.J. Treacy, B.K. Marcus, M.E. Bisher, J.B. Higgins (Eds.), Proc. 12th Internat. Zeolite Conf, Materials Research Society, Warrendale, Pennsylvania, 1999, p. 2057. J. Warzywoda, R.D. Edelman, R.W. Thompson, Zeolites 9 (1989) 187. O. Regev, Y. Cohen, E. Kehat, Y. Talmon, Zeolites 14 (1994) 314. S. Mintova, N.H. Olson, J. Senker, T. Bein, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 41 (2002) 2558.
89 [80] [81] [82] [83] [84] [85] [86] [87] [88] [89] [90] [91] [92]
[93] [94] [95] [96] [97] [98] [99] [100] [101] [102]
[103] [104] [105] [106] [107] [108] [109] [110] [111] [112] [113] [114] [115] [116] [117]
S. Mintova, N.H. Olson, V.Valtchev, T. Bein, Science 283 (1999) 958. S. Mintova, N.H. Olson, T. Bein, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 38 (1999) 3201. S.P. Zhdanov, N.N. Samulevich, in: L.V.C. Rees (Ed.), Proc. 5th Internat. Conf. Zeolites, Heyden, London, 1980, p. 75. S.P. Zhdanov, in: E.M. Flanigen, L.B. Sand (Eds.), Molecular Sieve Zeolites - I, ACS Adv. Chem. Ser., Vol. 101, 1971, p. 20. C.S. Cundy, B.M. Lowe, D.M. Sinclair, J. Cryst. Growth 100 (1990) 189. G. Golemme, A. Nastro, J.B. Nagy, B. Subotic, F. Crea, R. Aiello, Zeolites 11 (1991) 776. E.F. Freund, J. Crystal Growth, 34 (1976) 11. A. Cizmek, B. Subotic, D. Kralj, V. Babic-Ivancic, A. Tonejc, Microporous Mater. 12 (1997) 267. C.S. Cundy, J.O. Forrest, R.J. Plaisted, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 66 (2003) 143. Q. Li, D. Creaser, J. Sterte, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 31 (1999) 141. R. Aiello, R.M. Barrer, I.S. Kerr, in: E.M. Flanigen, L.B. Sand (Eds.), Molecular Sieve Zeolites I, ACS Adv. Chem. Ser., Vol. 101, 1971, p. 44. A. Nastro, L.B. Sand, Zeolites 3 (1983) 57. B.M. Lowe, in: P.J. Grobet, W.J. Mortier, E.F. Vansant, G. Schulz-Ekloff (Eds.), Innovation in Zeolite Materials Science, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 37, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1988, p. 1. C.S. Cundy, B.M. Lowe, D.M. Sinclair, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Discuss. 95 (1993) 235. A. Iwasaki, M. Hirata, I. Kudo, T. Sano, S. Sugawara, M. Ito, M. Watanabe, Zeolites 15 (1995) 308. R.K. Her, The Chemistry of Silica, Wiley, New York, 1979, p. 248. C.J. Creswell, R.K. Harris, P.T. Jageland, J. Chem. Soc. Chem. Commun. (1984) 1261. W. Meise, F.E. Schwochow, in: W.M. Meier, J.B. Uytterhoeven (Eds.), Molecular Sieves, ACS Adv. Chem. Ser., Vol. 121, 1973, p. 169. H. Kacirek, H. Lechert, J. Phys. Chem. 80 (1976) 1291. G.S. Wiersema, R.W. Thompson, J. Mater. Chem. 6 (1996) 1693. F. Crea, A. Nastro, J.B. Nagy, R. Aiello, Zeolites 8 (1988) 262. D.T. Hayhurst, A. Nastro, R. Aiello, F. Crea, G. Giordano, Zeolites 8 (1988) 416. D.T. Hayhurst, R. Aiello, J.B. Nagy, F. Crea, G. Giordano, A. Nastro, J.C. Lee, in: W.H. Flank, T.E. Whyte, Jr. (Eds.), Perspectives in Molecular Sieve Science, ACS Symp. Ser., Vol. 368, 1988, p. 277. A. Tavolaro, R. Mostowicz, F. Crea, A. Nastro, R. Aiello, J.B. Nagy, Zeolites 12 (1992) 756. N.N. Feoktistova, S.P. Zhdanov, W. Lutz, M. Bulow, Zeolites 9 (1989) 136. M.D. Grebner, A. Reich, F. Schuth, K.K. Unger, K.D. Franz, Zeolites 13 (1993) 139. S.A. Schunk, D.G. Demuth, B. Schulz-Dobrick, K.K. Unger, F. Schuth, Microporous Mater. 6 (1996)273. C.S. Cundy, M.S. Henty, R.J. Plaisted, Zeolites 15 (1995) 353. S. Damrul, S. Bazzana, J. Warzywoda, R.R. Biederman, A. Sacco, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 54 (2002) 79. W.K. Burton, N. Cabrera, F.C. Frank, Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London A243 (1951) 299. J.R. Agger, N. Hanif, M.W. Anderson, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 40 (2001) 4065. R.A. van Santen, G. Ooms, C.J.J. den Ouden, B.W. van Beest, M.F.M. Post, in: M.L. Occelli, H.E. Robson (Eds.), Zeolite Synthesis, ACS Symp. Ser., Vol. 398, 1989, p. 617. A. Navrotsky, I. Petrovic, Y. Hu, C.-Y. Chen, M.E. Davis, Microporous Mater. 4 (1995) 95. P.M. Piccione, S. Yang, A. Navrotsky, M.E. Davis, J. Phys. Chem. B 106 (2002) 3629. I. Petrovic, A. Navrotsky, M.E. Davis, S.I. Zones, Chem. Mater. 5 (1993) 1805. P.M. Piccione, C. Laberty, S. Yang, M.A. Camblor, A. Navrotsky, M.E. Davis, J. Phys. Chem. B 104(2000)10001. E.M. Flanigen, D.W. Breck, 137th Meeting of the ACS, Division of Inorganic Chemistry, Cleveland, Ohio, April 1960, Abstracts, p 33-M. CD. Chang, A.T. Bell, Catal. Lett. 8 (1991) 305.
90 [118] [119] [120] [121] [122] [123] [124]
[125] [126] [127] [128] [129]
[130] [131] [132] [133] [134] [135] [136] [137] [138] [139] [140] [141] [142] [143] [144] [145] [146] [147] [148] [149]
[150] [151] [152]
D.W. Breck, J. Chem. Educ. 41 (1964) 678. E.M. Flanigen, J.M. Bennett, R.W. Grose, J.P. Cohen, R.L. Pattern, R.L. Kirchner, J.V. Smith, Nature 271 (1978)512. E.M. Flanigen, in: L.V.C Rees (Ed.), Proc. 5th Internal Conf. Zeolites, Heyden, London, 1980, p. 760. S.L. Burkett, M.E. Davis, J. Phys. Chem. 98 (1994) 4647. S.L. Burkett, M.E. Davis, Chem. Mater. 7 (1995) 920. S.L. Burkett, M.E. Davis, Chem. Mater. 7 (1995) 1453. C.E.A. Kirschhock, V. Buschmann, S. Kremer, R. Ravishankar, C.J.Y. Houssin, B.L. Mojet, R.A. van Santen, P.J. Grobet, P.A. Jacobs, J.A. Martens, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 40 (2001) 2637, and references therein. W.H. Dokter, H.F. van Garderen, T.P.M. Beelen, R.A. van Santen, W. Bras, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 34 (1995) 73. V. Nikolakis, E. Kokkoli, M. Tirrell, M. Tsapatsis, D.G. Vlachos, Chem. Mater. 12 (2000) 845. R.W. Corkery, B.W. Ninham, Zeolites 18 (1997) 379. T.A.M. Twomey, M. Mackay, H.P.C.E. Kuipers, R.W. Thompson, Zeolites 14 (1994) 162. M.E. Davis, in: L. Bonneviot, S. Kaliaguine (Eds.), Zeolites: A Refined Tool for Designing Catalytic Sites, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, Vol. 97, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1995, p. 35. R.A. van Santen, J. Keijsper, G. Ooms, A.G.T.G. Kortbeek, in: Y. Murakami, A. Iijima, J.W. Ward (Eds.), New Developments in Zeolite Science and Technology, Kodansha-Elsevier, TokyoAmsterdam, 1986, p. 169. M.T. Melchior, D.E.W. Vaughan, C.F. Pictroski, J. Phys. Chem. 99 (1995) 6128. J.J. Keijsper, M.F.M. Post, in: M.L. Occelli, H.E. Robson (Eds.), Zeolite Synthesis, ACS Symp. Ser., Vol. 398,1989, p. 28. C.T.G. Knight, Zeolites 10 (1990) 140. H. Lechert, H. Kacirek, Zeolites 11 (1991) 720. B.J. Schoeman, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 22 (1998) 9. H. Weyda, H. Lechert, Zeolites 10 (1990) 251. Z. Liu, W. Xu, G. Yang, R. Xu, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 22 (1998) 33. A. Iwasaki, T. Sano, T. Kodaira, Y. Kiyozumi, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 64 (2003) 145. Y. Huang, R. Richter, C.W. Kirby, J. Phys. Chem. B 107 (2003) 1326. Special Issue on Metal-Organic Open Frameworks, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 73(1-2), (2004). S. Kaskel, in: F. Schiith, K.S.W. Sing, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Handbook of Porous Solids, Wiley-VCH, Weinheim, 2002, Vol. 2, p. 1190. C.L. Bowes, G.A. Ozin, Adv. Mater. 8 (1996) 13. G. Ferey, J. Solid State Chem. 152 (2000) 37. F. Taulelle, M. Pruski, J.P. Amoureux, D. Lang, A. Bailly, C. Huguenard, M. Haouas, C. Gerardin. T. Loiseau, G. Ferey, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121 (1999) 12148. T.M. Nenoff, W.T.A. Harrison, T.E. Gier, G.D. Stucky, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 113 (1991) 378. W.T.A. Harrison, T.E. Gier, K.L. Moran, J.M. Nicol, H. Eckert, G.D. Stucky, Chem. Mater. 3 (1991)27. P.M. Forster, A.R. Burbank, C. Livage, G. Ferey, A.K. Cheetham, Chem. Commun. (2004) 368. C.S. Cundy, M.S. Henry, R.J. Plaisted, Zeolites 15 (1995) 342. G. Bellussi, M.S. Rigutto, in: J.C. Jansen, M. Stocker, H.G. Karge, J. Weitkamp (Eds.), Advanced Zeolite Science and Applications, Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis, vol. 85, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994, p. 177. W.F. Lee, M.Sc. Dissertation, UMIST, Manchester, 1997. I. Girnus, K. Jancke, R. Vetter, J. Richter-Mendau, J. Caro, Zeolites 15(1995) 33. I. Girnus, K. Hoffmann, F. Marlow, J. Caro, G. Doling, Microporous Mater. 2 (1994) 537.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
91
Synthesis of mesoporous molecular sieves Wieslaw J. Roth and James C. Vartuli ExxonMobil Research and Engineering Co., 1545 Route 22 East, Annandale, NJ 08801, USA. e-mail:
[email protected] 1. INTRODUCTION 2. DISCOVERY AND FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF THE M41S FAMILY OF MESOPOROUS MOLECULAR 3. SURFACTANT AND LIQUID CRYSTAL TEMPLATING 4. EXPLOITING SURFACTANT SYSTEM PHENOMENA IN THE SYNTHESIS OF MESOPOROUS MATERIALS 4.1. Variation of surfactant type 4.2. Different structures 4.3. Pore size variation 4.4. Framework composition 5. DIFFERENCES BETWEEN MESOPOROUS MATERIALS AND ZEOLITES 6. SYNTHESIS OF MESOPOROUS MATERIALS 6.1. Synthesis of MCM-41 6.2. Synthesis of cubic MCM-48 6.3. Synthesis of SB A-15 6.4. Synthesis of mesoporous alumina 7. SYNTHESIS OF MICRO- AND MESO-POROUS HYBRID MATERIALS 8. ORGANO-INORGANIC MESOPOROUS COMPOSITES 9. CONCLUDING REMARKS REFERENCES 1. INTRODUCTION The title materials are synthesized in the presence of surfactants and were recognized first in the silica-cationic surfactant systems. The area expanded rapidly becoming an independent, though closely connected to zeolites, interdisciplinary field with potential of practical applications in catalysis and sorption. The discussion outlines the major advances in the synthesis of these materials from discovery to the present, stressing the general trends and interplay between surfactant and oxide chemistries. Representative materials are discussed in detail from the standpoint of convenient synthesis of a high quality useful product. 2. DISCOVERY AND FUNDAMENTAL PROPERTIES OF THE M41S FAMILY OF MESOPOROUS MOLECULAR SIEVES Mesoporous molecular sieves have uniform pores like zeolites but with a diameter greater than about 20 A. They were unknown until beginning of 1990's [1,2]. The area rapidly
92
ZSM-5 ~5 Å Pores
VPI-5 ~12 Å Pores
MCM-41 ~40 Å Pores
Fig. 1. TEM images of MCM-41 and representative microporous materials, ZSM-5 and VPI-5.
expanded into an extensive interdisciplinary field following a series of reports from Mobil R&D Corp, which included a communication at 9th IZC in Montreal, two pioneering publications [3,4], two principal composition of matter patents [5,6] and numerous other patent disclosures [6-9]. This initial work demonstrated that cationic surfactants, such as hexadecyltrimethylammonium cation (CTMA+), can act like equivalents of the organic structure directing agents of zeolites and can generate aluminosilicate and other oxide materials with uniform channels in the mesopore region (>20 A) [7]. As a particularly notable development the periodic structure and enormous pore openings of some of the newly discovered mesoporous molecular sieves was visualized directly by electron microscopy. A
93
representative TEM image, shown in Fig. 1, revealed a remarkable hexagonal honeycomb with pore openings approximately 40 A in diameter. The new material with proven hexagonal arrangement of apparently unidimensional channels was designated MCM-41. The corresponding X-ray powder diffraction pattern (XRD) could be indexed and assigned a hexagonal unit cell (without c direction), see Fig. 2. Two additional discrete structures were identified at higher surfactant/silica ratios. These structures were identified based on unique and indexable XRD patterns: MCM-48, a cubic structure with Ia3d symmetry and 3dimensional pore system, and MCM-50, a lamellar species. Not all of the apparently mesoporous products generated in the presence of surfactants could be assigned a discrete structure. Many materials exhibited only one or two XRD peaks, which could not be unambiguously indexed and used for structure assignment. As a diverse class these new mesoporous molecular sieves were referred to as the M41S family and could be identified by the following fundamental and general properties: •
Thermally stable periodic structure manifesting itself after calcination by at least one low angle line in X-ray diffraction pattern above 18 A d-spacing (Fig. 2)
•
High adsorption capacity with unprecedented uniform mesopores resulting in the presence of capillary condensation in the adsorption/desorption isotherms for small sorbate molecules (Fig. 3).
The detailed accounts of the discovery of the M41S family and subsequent developments have been published recently [7,8]. The discovery, embodied by the unprecedented honeycomb pattern observed in TEM images, was unexpected but resulted from a deliberate and systematic effort to prepare large pore zeolitic or related materials. One of the efforts focused on exploiting the recent discovery that zeolite MCM-22 formed via a layered precursor [10-12]. A conversion of the MCM-22 precursor into a pillared derivative could afford a large pore structure with zeolitic active sites and/or internal microporosity. However, none of the special treatments known at that time enabled sufficient extent of exfoliation (layer separation) in MCM-22-P, which was the essential first step. The introduction of custom made cationic surfactants in the hydroxide form overcame the problems with low efficiency of layer separation encountered initially with MCM-22-P. This new reagent enabled essentially complete swelling of the MCM-22 precursor and afforded the pursued 'pillared zeolite' MCM-36 upon additional treatment [12]. The use of the available surfactant hydroxide was expanded further: as a swelling agent in the presence of active silica sources, such as tetramethylammonium silicate, and directly in the hydrothermal reaction of aluminosilicate gels as the templating reagent. This work produced the first examples of the M41S materials and the accompanying electron microscopy characterization revealed the underlying regular structure. This demonstration, that the combination of surfactants and silica can produce mesoporous materials resembling zeolites in terms of uniform pores and well-defined structure stimulated a systematic exploration of the new area. The behavior of surfactant system was exploited to vary pore size of the generated materials and to produce novel discrete structures. An indepth characterization showed some remarkable and unprecedented physical properties, such as adsorption of gases with capillary condensation in the mesopore region [12]. A comprehensive catalytic testing showed potential for practical applications in hydrocarbon conversion and other processes [7,9].
94
Fig. 2. M41S family of ordered mesoporous materials - X-ray powder diffraction patterns, representative TEM images and proposed structures.
95
Fig. 3. Representative nitrogen adsorption/desorption isotherm for an ordered mesoporous material with approximately 40 A pore.
The initial broad effort established basic foundations and served for further expansion while the principal tenets have remained valid to date. When reported in the open literature, the new large pore materials immediately attracted attention of the scientific community, especially in catalysis and adsorption fields. Subsequent effort by many groups led to unforeseen expansion not only in terms of the overall effort and abundance of materials and phenomena but also new directions pursued. There is probably close to 10,000 publications on the subject [1]. This presentation will focus primarily on fundamental concepts and ideas related to synthesis. For detailed and comprehensive treatments one is referred to the review publications that have been appearing regularly [13-20]. For up-to-date overview of state of the art several recent reviews are especially recommended [17-20]. As the new field expanded and novel concepts were recognized other names were being used to designate the entire class or its subgroups. The examples include ordered or periodic mesoporous materials, mesostructures, mesophases, etc. and they have been used interchangeably. In here we adopted the abbreviated form 'mesoporous materials' as referring to materials with uniform mesopores. In the early 1990's Kuroda et al. reported preparation of porous materials resulting from interaction of layered silica kanemite with alkyltrimethylammonium salt solutions [21]. Later on [22] they proposed the mechanism labeled FSM (Folding Sheet Mechanism; see Fig. 4) to rationalize the nature of the products [23,24].
96
Fig. 4. Proposed mechanism of the formation of a mesoporous material by bending and condensation of surfactant treated kanemite (Folding Sheet Mechanism) ([22]; reproduced by permission of The Royal Society of Chemistry], 3. SURFACTANT AND LIQUID CRYSTAL TEMPLATING
M41S materials were obtained as the result of incorporation of surfactants as structure directing agent in the microporous-type preparations. The identified well defined structures resembled some of the lyotropic liquid crystal phases observed in solutions of the corresponding surfactant compounds [25-28], thus prompting a name for the entire phenomenon as liquid crystal templating (LCT). In the refined version the concept proved all-embracing by proposing two possible pathways, as shown in Fig. 5. One pathway was referred to as liquid crystal initiated. It postulated diffusion of silicate ions into the aqueous region of preformed liquid crystals resulting in assembly of an ordered silica framework. The second pathway was silicate anion initiated and entailed self-assembly upon mutual attraction between silicate and surfactant ions. The latter proved operative in almost all cases. It was further elaborated and in a detailed form is referred to as the cooperative self-assembly [29]. Later on the first pathway representing true LCT was also proved viable [30]. It must be stressed that there is a big difference between the liquid crystal and the templated solid mesoporous phases. The former are equilibrium systems, while the latter are apparently transient. As far as we know the solid mesophases are not produced through equilibration, which makes their formation and existence quite astounding and a bit of a surprise (V. Luzzatti, personal communication). Another new concept formulated in conjunction with the formation of the M41S structures was supramolecular templating, i.e. one involving assemblies of molecules (surfactant aggregates, micelles, liquid crystals) [31]. In contrast, microporous materials are templated by isolated molecules acting as structure directing agents. 4. EXPLOITING SURFACTANT SYSTEM PHENOMENA IN THE SYNTHESIS OF MESOPOROUS MATERIALS The expansion and diversification of the ordered mesoporous materials can be attributed to bringing together two advanced disciplines, i.e. microporous solids and amphiphilic compounds. The latter turned out particularly rich in phenomena that could be exploited for innovation and synthesis of novel and/or designer products. The following developments can be considered as exploiting the principles of surfactant science in the preparation of porous solids.
97
Fig. 5. Schematic representation of the liquid crystal templating mechanism of the ordered mesoporous materials - original with added modifications
Fig. 6. Phase diagram for the cetyltrimethylammonium bromide (C]6H33N(CH3)3-Br; CTAB) in water (based on reference [28])
98
4.1. Variation of surfactant type The initial use of cationic surfactants producing negatively charged frameworks has been extended to amphiphiles with other charges and even ionic pairs. These various possibilities have been represented by the notation system specifying charge for the surfactant (S), inorganic component (I) and auxiliary small counterions, which may be mediating in some systems between the S and I (X - halide, etc, M - alkali metal) [32]. Nonionic surfactants (amines, poly-ethers) also produced mesoporous structures and were usually used with alkoxides as the inorganic component. Novel mesophase structures (see below) were identified when silica (tetraethyl orthosilicate, TEOS) was templated by triblock copolymers in acidic media, apparently through small ion mediation (S°H+)(XT °) [33]. The major supramolecular templating routes are summarized in Table 1, which is based on Ref. [17,18] 4.2. Different structures The first mesoporous structure identified, i.e. the hexagonal unidimensional MCM-41, resembled one of the liquid crystal phases observed in the surfactant-water systems. The corresponding phase diagram indicated existence of other phases at higher surfactant concentrations, namely a cubic and a lamellar one (Fig. 6) [25-28]. This trend was reproduced in the aqueous silica-surfactant system upon changing surfactant/silica ratio with nominally constant surfactant concentration [34]. As the amount of silica added decreased and the ratio surfactant/silica increased, the following sequence of changes occurred: the initially dominant hexagonal MCM-41 gave way to the product with cubic Ia3d symmetry and 3-dimensional channels, MCM-48, through lamellar MCM-50 and finally a soluble molecular silicate was obtained. This experiment can be interpreted as providing the evidence against the liquid crystal initiated pathway, at least in this case. The observation of different structures formed at essentially constant surfactant concentration is inconsistent with templating by a pre-existing liquid crystal phase. The three M41S family silica phases obtained with cationic surfactants in a basic medium represent the primary set of principal mesoporous structures. The observed 'phase' transitions are attributed to changing surface curvature resulting from decreasing packing factor, g, which is related to the surfactant molecule dimensions and defined as [35]: g=V/(ao-l) V - volume of the surfactant chain including contribution from co-solvent or other molecules between the chains ao - effective head group area at the surface / - kinetic length of the surfactant side chain The values of g at which a phase transforms to another are: 1 for a lamellar phase, between 1/2 and 2/3 for the cubic Ia3d phase and 1/2 for the hexagonal phase [35]. Not surprisingly other cationic surfactants and the alternative surfactant systems listed in Table 1 were also able to generate the three basic structures. The cubic MCM-48 type was most difficult to synthesize and consequently quite rare. Other types of surfactants and/or alternative media (acidic or neutral) allowed preparation and recognition of additional structural kinds of mesoporous materials (which could also be correlated with certain g values). More than 20 types of silica mesoporous materials are listed in a recent compilation as unique in terms of structure and/or method of assembly [18]. Several new cubic structures
99 Table 1 Classification of the major supramolecular templating routes according to surfactant charge Surfactant charge Cationic
Surfactant type Alkyl-NR3+
Interaction type +
Alkyl-NR3+
S+XT+
Alkyl-NR3+, R=Et
S+XT+ +
Di-(N-quaternary) Anionic
Neutral
sr
2+
M41S-MCM-41,-48,-50 FSM-16 SBA-3 SBA-1 MCM-48, SBA-6, SBA-8
sr +
Examples/structures
+
Alkyl-OPO3H2" Alkyl-OSO3" R-CO2H
si , S"M r
Amine
N°I°
Poly(ethylene)oxide Alkyl-(EO)n, EO ethylene oxide Amine
gUjU
Alkyl-(EO)n, EO = ethylene oxide Triblock copolymers
(S U H + )(XT + )
SBA-11,-12,-14
(S U H + )(X1 + )
SBA-15,-16 FDU-1 Al(sec-OBu)3 - organized mesoporous alumina
ST+
SV ST
gUjU
Mainly lamellar or disordered; Al, Pb, Fe, Mn, Ni, Co, etc Al (sec-OBu)3 - organized mesoporous alumina HMS and MSU silicas - wormlike structures, similar to M41S and can be modified similarly With TMOS - true LCT Ligand assisted; amine bonding to Nb and Ta alkoxides
with different symmetries were obtained using Si-ethoxide (TEOS, tetraethyl orthosilicate) as the silica source [1,18,33]: SBA-1, Pm3n, with supercage cavities; templated by a cation surfactant with a larger head group SBA-6, Pm3n, like above templated by a divalent template SBA-16, Im3m, cages, templated by a triblock copolymer SBA-2, intergrowth of hexagonal and Fm3n cubic; divalent cationic template SBA-15, a hexagonal (MCM-41-like) silicate obtained with (EO)n(PO)70(EO)n copolymers; attracted attention because of thick silica walls (up to 60-70 A), the opportunity for pore tailoring up to 300 A and microporous connection between mesoporous channels [33]. Only a handful of the identified types of mesoporous materials have been extensively explored and used. A noteworthy occurrence has been that some of the preparations afforded well developed faceted particles, a la ordered crystals. The examples are MCM-48, SBA-1 andSBA-16[36].
100
4.3. Pore size variation The length of surfactant side chain determines dimensions of the hydrophobic domain and consequently unit cell of a liquid crystal. Pores of different diameter can be obtained by changing surfactant size. This initially allowed MCM-41 pore adjustment from about 20 A up to 50-60 A. Further expansion was possible based on another phenomenon, i.e. micelle swelling by solubilized organic compounds. MCM-41 with pores up to 120 A was obtained with mesitylene as an auxiliary organic (expander) in a hexadecyltrimethylammonium templated preparation [4]. Triblock copolymers were found to afford hexagonal structure, SBA-15, with a pore diameter up to 300 A [33]. Pore dimensions can also be tailored by adjusting the synthesis temperature and post-synthesis treatment with amines [18]. 4.4. Framework composition Composition of the inorganic framework can be varied just like the surfactant use has been expanded beyond the original cationic species. The number of explored element combinations has been enormous and often driven by specific catalytic needs and prior experience with amorphous or crystalline compositions [37]. One of the leading approaches was doping of silica formulation with appropriate activating element, such as aluminum (to impart acidity) and titanium or vanadium for redox potential. Based on analogy of AlPO's and SAPO's to zeolites these compositions were also synthesized in the mesoporous form as were other non-silica inorganic oxides and their combinations [38]. Pure metal mesoporous product was obtained via the pre-formed liquid crystal route [39]. Many of the non-silica compositions showed problems with the stability and quality of the structure. Efforts to address these issues have been on going and quite successful in some cases such as all-alumina compositions (see below). Silica-based materials remain dominant as the most versatile and best quality molecular sieves (structure and stability) available by a facile synthesis. These attributes, especially the convenient synthesis made mesoporous silicate attractive for post-synthesis functionalization with other elements as well as organic moieties with active groups/centers. Recently the compositional diversity has been extended further to include both silica and organic moieties within the framework. The new class is referred to as periodic mesoporous organosilicas (PMOs). The synthesis involves surfactantassisted assembly by hydrolysis of organo-silicon compounds. Additional discussion of the PMOs is presented below. Recently carbon based mesoporous materials have been synthesized via a technique using the inorganic mesoporous framework as a template [40]. The approach is designated nanocasting [17]. In fact, these materials were the first to illustrate the existence of the mesoporosity of SBA-15 materials [41]. 5. DIFFERENCES BETWEEN MESOPOROUS MATERIALS AND ZEOLITES The surfactant templated mesoporous materials were treated as an extension of microporous solids and have been adopted by the scientific community as part of the zeolite endeavor. On the other hand there are fundamental differences between the two classes and this has had a significant impact and consequences in the areas of synthesis, characterization, and practical applications, especially catalysis. The ordered atomic structure of typical microporous materials makes them easy to identify and characterize by XRD. The structural information obtained by XRD combined with a few additional characterization data may effectively define the properties and expected behavior
101
of a particular preparation. Furthermore, the ordered structure of zeolites imparts inherent higher stability and catalytic activity in comparison to analogous amorphous compositions. In the case of the ordered mesoporous materials, XRD informs primarily about the presence of ordered pores. In many cases the pattern cannot be indexed (too few and/or broad peaks) to assess symmetry and channel dimensionality. Additional characterization is essential to determine pore size and distribution and to learn other basic properties. Electron microscopy proved quite informative when appropriate images could be obtained. This has been the leading technique for discovery and identification of new products [3,4,36]. It is also very useful when a high quality uniform product is available. In general, the use of electron microscopy as a bulk analytical/characterization tool has been limited and, in view of labor intensive sample preparation, rather impractical. The basic description of a mesoporous sample requires two types of determinations: X-ray diffraction and gas adsorption/desorption isotherm. The latter are usually represented as the amount of gas adsorbed by the sample as the function of relative pressure. This information characterizes pore size distribution. Nitrogen adsorption/desorption isotherm at 77 K is most often used and relatively convenient to carry out. The adsorption of noble gases is used if accurate in-depth pore characterization is attempted, especially quantitative. The calculation of pore size distribution from the isotherms is carried out using appropriate formulas such as Kelvin and Horwath-Kawazoe equations (e.g. as in Ref. [5] and [6]), which involve assumptions and approximations. A more detailed and rigorous treatments have been developed, as for example KJS (Kruk-Jaroniec-Sayari), which is relatively simple and accurate [42]. In practice, the diameter of mesopores can be quickly estimated directly from the position of the capillary condensation or, if not vertical, the p/p0 of the inflection point. The conversion table of p/po values to pore diameters can be found in Ref. [43] and is partially reproduced here in Table 2. The advances in synthesis and characterization of the ordered mesoporous materials also translated into new findings associated with adsorption fundamentals and pore description. Novel features such as hystereses with unusual shapes have been observed and required interpretation. Significant theoretical progress has been made regarding understanding and quantitative treatment of the gas adsorption data in the mesopore region. A comprehensive review of the subjects has been published recently [43]. Table 2 Estimating pore size from nitrogen isotherm - selected value of the nitrogen capillary condensation relative pressure and the corresponding pore diameters [43] P/Po 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4
Pore diameter (A) 24 29.4 34.9 41.3
P/Po 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
Pore diameter (A) 49.6 61.3 79.7 114.i
6. SYNTHESIS OF MESOPOROUS MATERIALS The above discussion concerned some general trends and principles governing the formation of mesoporous materials. On a practical level the formation/synthesis of products with uniform mesopores by self-assembly, especially the silica-based ones, appears quite facile
102
and deceptively simple. Solids with low angle XRD peak indicative of ordered pore structure and narrow pore size distribution have been found to form spontaneously if enough surfactant is available and conditions not particularly harsh. Even a room temperature precipitation can afford products that meet the criteria for mesoporous materials [44] and which might be suitable (e.g. stable enough) for some applications. However, the nature of a mesoporous product, particularly in terms of quality and stability, is strongly influenced by the synthesis conditions. Solids with specific properties (e.g. structure or pore size), high quality XRD, good stability, etc, typically required more constrained synthesis parameters. Non-silica based compositions presented a separate problem altogether because of frequently occurring structural collapse upon surfactant removal. In short, on the one hand the synthesis has appeared quite straightforward but, on the other hand, obtaining a good/desired product by a convenient route required a considerable developmental effort. Among the many varieties of mesoporous materials several stand out as most extensively studied. The initial 3 structures [3,4] remain dominant although MCM-50 has attracted least attention and found little practical value. It has an unstable structure collapsing upon calcination but still exhibits considerable microporosity, which is intriguing and possibly deserving closer attention. However, if a post treatment by adding a reactive silica source, e.g. TEOS, to the as-synthesized MCM-50 is done prior to air calculations, then a uniform mesopore structure (after calcination to remove the surfactant) with retention of the lamellarlike XRD is observed. MCM-41 and MCM-48 type structures and SBA-15 are considered here as representative of the entire class and to reflect the expected range of characteristics and behavior. Another practical aspect of the synthesis of mesoporous materials concerns balancing product quality with simplicity and economics of the procedure [7]. The approaches discussed below were selected primarily because they afford high quality products (structure, stability) from common reagents and by a simple hydrothermal synthesis. 6.1. Synthesis of MCM-41 MCM-41 has unidimensional, presumed to be straight channels. It can be identified by XRD pattern with at least 3 peaks corresponding to hkO reflections of a hexagonal unit cell. It has been possible to vary the dimensions and compositions of the hexagonal framework over a broad range. Many facile synthesis procedures have been identified and developed to produce MCM-41, sometimes to address a particular application need. The synthesis approach described here can afford a high quality representative product under wide range of temperature and time conditions [45,46]. It evolved from the fundamental studies of the interaction of silicate solutions with surfactants and supplied a convenient laboratory synthesis route. In addition, it is based on certain stoichiometric relationships between reagents that justify its characterization as a rational method. Finally, with essentially unchanged approach upon simple lowering of the silica to surfactant ratio a convenient method of MCM-48 preparation is obtained [47]. In this procedure the synthesis mixture is reduced to three basic components: silica (solid), surfactant (halide) and hydroxide as mineralizer (tetramethylammonium hydroxide, TMAOH), all supplied as the convenient reagents. The key parameter is the essentially stoichiometric 1:1 ratio of surfactant and hydroxide, which allows treatment of the product (MCM-41) as formally a surfactant silicate resulting from interaction between silica and surfactant hydroxide. The latter reagent is not a conveniently available or cost effective one to use. Consequently the most desirable surfactant source is its halide salt. The presented
103
method of MCM-41 synthesis demonstrated flexibility and the following important benefits [45]: 1. A high quality product judged by XRD and nitrogen sorption is obtained with the silica/surfactant ratio around 5-6:1. 2. Virtually all surfactant used ends up incorporated in the solid MCM-41 product, reinforcing the rational (stoichiometric) character of the synthesis. 3. Increasing severity of the synthesis conditions (higher temperature, longer time) results in a more robust framework and pore diameter expansion. The latter represents a simple method of tailoring pore size by synthesis time and temperature adjustment. 4. Upon reduction of the silica/surfactant ratio to -3.5/1 a smooth transition to the cubic MCM-48 as the favored phase occurred. This was one of the first demonstrations of 'pure' MCM-48 synthesis by a simple method with common reagents and analogous to the MCM-41 preparation. Synthesis of MCM-41: the synthesis mixture is prepared by mixing 140 g of water, 30 g of silica, 30 g of 25 % tetramethylammonium hydroxide and 80 g of 29 % hexadecyltrimethylammonium chloride solution. The hydrothermal reaction affording MCM-41 can be carried out under variety of conditions, e.g. 16 hrs at 95°C [45]. An alternative robust laboratory method recommended [F. Schuth, personal communication] is a modification of the published procedure [48]: The synthesis mixture comprises: 120 g water, 10 ml 25% ammonia solution, 2.4 g CTAB (hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide), 0.6 g 1-butanol and 10 ml TEOS. Ammonia solution is mixed with water, then CTAB and BuOH are added. The mixture is stirred at 30°C under magnetic stirring until the solution is clear. 10 ml TEOS is added, and stirring is continued for 1 more hour. Then the precipitate is isolated by filtration. The solid is washed with 200 ml water. Drying 90°C for eight hours, calcination 5h, 550°C, heating rate to final temperature ldeg./min. 6.2. Synthesis of cubic MCM-48 In contrast to MCM-41, which seemed ubiquitous, the cubic MCM-48 was obtained initially under special circumstances relying on controlled hydrolysis of the silica source, TEOS [34]. In addition, the initial procedures employed less desirable raw materials, namely TEOS (high cost, handling hazard) and surfactant hydroxide (had to be custom prepared), making the method unsuitable for a routine application and scale-up. The improvements of the MCM-48 synthesis methodology were gradual until around the year 2000 when several reports of facile MCM-48 synthesis using common reagents were published [49-52]. The method was very similar to MCM-41 synthesis but with adjusted silica/surfactant ratio. Alternative effective method of synthesizing MCM-48 included the use of Gemini surfactants (not readily available) [51]. A method allowing tailoring pore size of MCM-48 relied on the inclusion of additional neutral organic component as the co-template [52]. Synthesis of MCM-48: 31 g of silica, 57 g of 25 % tetramethylammonium hydroxide and 165 g water are digested at 100°C. 172 g of 29 % hexadecyltrimethylammonium chloride solution is added and the mixture reacted for 12 hrs. at 150°C yielding MCM-48. The desired product is transient and upon prolonged heating slowly transforms into the lamellar MCM50. The latter is initially difficult to observe since its most prominent XRD peak overlaps with the MCM-48's (220) reflection. The lamellar impurity in MCM-48 can be detected and
104
quantitatively appraised using nitrogen isotherm plot based on the presence of a characteristic horizontal-triangular hysteresis loop above p/po > 0.45 [53]. 6.3. Synthesis of SBA-15: SBA-15 is prepared under acidic conditions using poly(ethylene oxide)-poly(propylene oxide)-poly(ethylene oxide) triblock copolymers, (EO)n(PO)7o(EO)n, as templates, e.g. Pluronic PI23 (n = 20), Pluronic L121 (n = 5) or Pluronic F127 (n = 106). In a typical synthesis [54,55] based on the original procedures [33], 4.0 g of (EO)2o(PO)7o(EO)2o copolymer was dissolved in 150 g of 1.6 M HCL To this solution was added 8.50 g of TEOS, and the resulting mixture was stirred until TEOS was dissolved. The mixture was heated in an oven for 24 h at 308 K and then 24 h more at 373 K under static condition. Silica products were filtered, dried (without washing), and calcined at 823 K. 6.4. Synthesis of mesoporous alumina One of the directions pursued with ordered mesoporous materials has been changing the framework composition. Many different elements could be incorporated in the walls. Among the numerous variations the all-alumina composition has been of special interest. This is related to the wide spread use of alumina as support in catalysis. Successful syntheses with a neutral and anionic template have been achieved [56], see Table 1. The details will be provided in one of the following presentations [56b]. 7. SYNTHESIS OF MICRO- AND MESO-POROUS HYBRID MATERIALS Extensive catalytic testing of mesoporous materials revealed promising performance with practical implications in some process [7,9]. However the observed improvements were mostly incremental compared to state of the art catalysts. This fact in combination with the initial lack of commercially synthesized product hindered practical implementation. In most high value petroleum processes the catalytic activity of mesoporous materials was lower in comparison to zeolite-based catalysts resulting in inadequate conversion levels. The second frequently invoked deficiency of the mesoporous materials was low stability, especially hydrothermal. The apparent lack of stability appears overemphasized and represents a serious problem only for some applications, albeit rather important such as FCC. In general, a particular type of mesoporous material can be made in a quite stable form. Unlike zeolites, the stability of mesoporous materials is very sensitive to synthesis conditions due to amorphous nature of the walls. As shown above, while stability can be improved by adjusting severity of the synthesis (temperature and time) this has little effect upon improving the activity. It has been considered from the very beginning that zeolite-like walls may render mesoporous materials more active and stable. The challenge of mesoporous structures with ordered walls remains outstanding but a number of innovative strategies have been advanced in order to combine zeolitic and mesoporous structures. The following general approaches have been pursued [19]: 1. Simultaneous crystallization of a zeolite and mesoporous solids by using a mixture of structure directing agents for both components [57] 2. Assembly of zeolite seeds, protozeolite clusters, etc, into mesoporous frameworks zeolite synthesis mixture is crystallized for a certain period of time to generate zeolite fragments and then treated with surfactant to assemble the mesoporous structure [58] 3. Simultaneous crystallization of zeolite and mesoporous materials precursor phases [59]
105 4. Recrystallization of mesoporous solid walls into zeolitic domains [60] 5. Coating of mesopore material walls with zeolite fragments/seeds by treatment with a solution containing the latter [61]. Zeolites selected for these attempts were usually ZSM-5, faujasite and zeolite beta. Some promising leads were reported but a real validation through more rigorous systematic testing or commercial implementation remains to be demonstrated. The determination of the real nature of zeolite/mesoporous material composites represents a serious challenge. To date it does not appear to have been adequately resolved. It remains difficult to distinguish physical mixtures (separated phases) versus both structures combined in one phase. Short of a fully refined structural model based on XRD characterization all other characterizations appear not sensitive enough to discriminate between the two possibilities unequivocally. In this situation a functional differentiation, e.g. based on catalytic testing might be the ultimate criterion. This leaves a performance test as a real validation and clear indication of success will be a result exceeding those achieved by each component separately. 8. ORGANO-INORGANIC MESOPOROUS COMPOSITES Because of the unique pore size in the mesopore range of the M41S and related molecular sieves and how these materials are formed, a novel class of materials has been generated. This class of materials has been broadly labeled as organo-inorganic mesoporous composites. The large uniform pore structure allows for functionalization of molecular complexes inside the pores using of the silanol groups present within the pore walls of the material as anchoring sites. Alternatively, because the materials are formed under mild synthesis conditions and via a polymerization mechanism, reactive components such as organosilanes can be used to incorporate, in situ, organo-species within the wall structure, as shown schematically in Fig. 7. In both cases, these functionalized products provide opportunities for designing unusual catalytic/sorptive materials for various applications and present a class of materials significantly different than other uniform porous supports and from the unfunctionalized starting materials. For the post-functionalized materials, the silanols present within the channels provide a suitable anchoring site for chemical attachment. Although the wall composition contains random interatomic bond angles and atomic location, there exists an uncharacteristically large and uniform density of silanol groups (other than the silanols that exist due to incomplete condensation) within the channels due to surfactant packing requirements. NMR studies showed that up to 40% of the silicon atoms located on the surface of the walls could be associated with hydroxyls [62]. An obvious example of an organo-inorganic mesoporous composite would be the assynthesized form of these molecular sieves in which the surfactant template remains attached to the walls of the channels. Although the pores are filled with the surfactant, these assynthesized materials still exhibit significant amount of hydrocarbon sorption capacity. The pore diameter can be changed by changing the surfactant chain length. The hydrocarbon sorption capacity of the resultant calcined versions increased with increasing pore size. However, for the as-synthesized materials, the benzene uptake appeared to be constant, -25 weight %, regardless of the increasing pore size [63]. It appears that the accessible void volume in these as-synthesized materials is constant regardless of the increasing surfactant chain length used in the synthesis or the pore size.
106
Fig. 7. Two primary modes of organic (functional) group distribution in mesoporous frameworks .
The initial example of a functionalized mesoporous molecular sieve was prepared using trimethylsilylchloride as a reagent to react with the silanol groups [4]. The initially present silanol groups were replaced with trimethylsilyl groups which affected on both pore size and sorption characteristics. The pore size, obtained by argon physisorption, did decrease by approximately 10 A consistent with the addition of two trimethylsilyl groups per unit diameter. The pore volume of the functionalized material decreased by -40%, whereas the water sorption capacity was reduced by 67%. It was concluded that this unusual decrease in the water adsorption was a result of both pore size reduction and that the addition of the trimethylsilyl groups affected the hydrophilicity of the walls of the mesoporous material. An approach termed 'functionalization with concomitant surfactant extraction' can be implemented by using an appropriate organic solvent (e.g. alcohol) with dissolved functionalizing reagent. It has a number of advantages such as being a one step procedure, allowing surfactant recovery, having the higher number of available silanols than in a template-free (calcined) version [64,65]. There are many examples of researchers using functionalized mesoporous molecular sieves as separation media. Workers at Batelle Memorial Institute have provided some of the earliest work, adding such groups as mercaptopropylsilane (via reaction with the trimethoxide), ethylenediamine, diethylenetriamine, cyanopropyl, and others [66]. The impetus for their work was the separation of mercury by selective adsorption via complexation of the mercury with the attached sulfur group. These functionalized materials adsorbed significantly higher amounts of mercury per weight of adsorbing material than other available amorphous based adsorbents. The same concept, use of complexation for selective adsorbance, was used for adsorption of copper via an amine functionalized material [67]. Post-functionalized materials have also been used in catalytic reactions. The concept is to "heterogenize" homogeneous catalysts by tethering metal complexes within the mesopore. An example of this is the work of Sir J. M. Thomas and R. Raja [68]. These researchers tethered a metal complex near the surface of the wall. The mesopore allowed free access of the reactant molecules with the catalytic site while the close proximity of the wall (due to the length of the tethered complex) limited and directed the reactants resulting in asymmetric synthesis of products. Yamamoto and coworkers combined both the concept of tethering of a reactive metal site, titanium, with the changing of the hydrophilicity of the wall, addition of a
107
silane, to create more reactive oxidation catalyst. The researchers concluded that the change of hydrophilicity of the pore wall excluded water that would deactivate the oxidation catalyst [69]. The alternative method of producing these organo-inorganic mesoporous composites is by in situ reaction using organosilanes. Organosilica versions of M41S materials were first introduced, almost simultaneously, by groups led by Ozin [70], Stein [71], and Inagaki at Toyota [72]. Also called PMOs, for Periodic Mesoporous Organosilicas, these materials are prepared by hydrolysis of substituted tetra-alkyl orthosilicates. So hydrolysis of bis(triethoxysilyl)-ethane or -benzene, for example, along with TEOS with a surfactant, provides a mesoporous material with an organic link between silica, i.e. the organic groups replace oxygens. A wide number of such materials have been prepared. The methods would seem to be ideal for incorporation of stable functional groups for catalysis. For example, sulfonation of benzene links could give catalytically active sites. Inagaki and coworkers used a benzene molecule as the linker in the silica-based composition. They produced a uniform benzene-silica mesopore material which by HREM imagery suggested a very ordered wall composition [73]. Other researchers used in situ functionalization to enhance the heavy metal adsorption, Cu, Zn and Ni, of functionalized materials using imprinting techniques. These researchers functionalized the walls of the mesoporous materials using a reactive aminosilane metal complex as a reagent. After removing the metals that were used in the synthesis, these functionalized materials demonstrated enhanced metal capacity and rate of uptake compared to equivalent materials prepared except without the metal complex. The authors reasoned the use of the metal complexes as functional groups optimized the density of the functionalized groups within the mesopore channel resulting in more effective uptake of the metals in subsequent sorption testing [74]. The apparent ease of producing these organo-inorganic composites has provided a class of materials that have demonstrated promise in both separations and catalytic applications. The compositions and applications appear to be only limited by the imagination of the researcher. 9. CONCLUDING REMARKS The discussed area expanded considerably with many interesting and exciting developments from the standpoint of fundamental science and potential uses. The synthesis progressed in many directions affording both novel materials and methods for a large scale manufacture. The M41S based catalyst is used in a commercial application [7] and in one commercial process MCM-41 offers advantage over the state of the art catalyst [75]. The inherent flexibility and potential for modifications are the main drivers for continuing interest, innovation and search for improvements. REFERENCES [1 ] [2]
[3]
O. Terasaki (ed.), Mesoporous Crystals and Related Nano-structured Materials, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2004. (a) F. Schuth, in A. Galarneau, F. DiRenzo, F. Fajula and J. Vedrine (eds.), Zeolites and Mesoporous Materials at the Dawn of the 21st Century, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. No. 135, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2001, p. 1. (b) F. Schuth in Ref. [1] pp. 1-13. C.T. Kresge, M.E. Leonowicz, W.J. Roth, J.C. Vartuli and J.S. Beck, Nature (London), 359 (1992)710.
108 [4] [5] [6] [7]
[8] [9] [10] [11]
[12] [13]
[14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29]
J.S. Beck, J.C. Vartuli, W.J. Roth, M.E. Leonowicz, C.T. Kresge, K.D. Schmitt, C.T.W. Chu, D.H. Olson, E.W. Sheppard, et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc, 114 (1992) 10834. C.T. Kresge, M.E. Leonowicz, W.J. Roth and J.C. Vartuli, Synthetic Mesoporous Crystalline Material, US Patent No. 5 098 684 (1992). C.T. Kresge, M.E. Leonowicz, W.J. Roth and J.C. Vartuli, Composition of Synthetic Porous Crystalline Material, Its Synthesis, US Patent No. 5 102 643 (1992). J.C. Vartuli, W.J. Roth and T.F. Degnan, Jr., in J.A. Schwartz, C. Contescu and K. Putyera (eds.), Dekker Encyclopedia of Nanoscience and Nanotechnology, Marcel Dekker, 2004, p. 1791. C.T. Kresge, J.C. Vartuli, W.J. Roth and M.E. Leonowicz, in Ref. [1], p. 53. J.L. Casci, in J.C. Jansen, M. Stacker, H.G. Karge and J. Weitkamp (eds.), Advanced Zeolite Science and Applications, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. No. 85, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1994, p. 329. M.E. Leonowicz, J.A. Lawton, S.L. Lawton and M.K. Rubin, Science, 264 (1994) 1910. S.L. Lawton, A.S. Fung, G.J. Kennedy, L.B. Alemany, CD. Chang, G.H. Hatzikos, D.N. Lissy, M.K. Rubin, H.-K.C. Timken, S. Steuernagel and D.E. Woessner, J. Phys. Chem., 100 (1996) 3788. W.J. Roth, C.T. Kresge, J.C. Vartuli, M.E. Leonowicz, A.S. Fung and S.B. McCullen, in H.K. Beyer, H.G. Karge, I. Kiricsi and J.B. Nagy (eds.), Catalysis by Microporous Materials, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. No. 94, Elsevier, New York, 1995, p. 301. J.C. Vartuli, W.J. Roth, J.S. Beck, S.B. McCullen and C.T. Kresge, in H.G. Karge and J. Weitkamp (eds.), Molecular Sieves, Science and Technology, Vol. 1 (Synthesis), Springer, Berlin, 1998, p. 97. A. Corma, Chem. Rev., 97 (1997) 2373. M.E. Raimondi and J.M. Seddon, Liquid Crystals, 26 (1999) 305. T. Linssen, K. Cassiers, P. Cooland and E.F. Vansant, Adv. Colloid Interface Sci., 103 (2003) 121. A. Taguchi and F. Schuth, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 77 (2005) 1. A. Sayari, in P. Yang (ed.), The Chemistry of Nanostructured Materials, World Scientific, New Jersey, 2003, p. 39. D. Trong-On, in S.G. Pandalai (ed.), Recent Research Developments in Catalysis, Research Signpost, Kerala (India), 2003, p. 171. S. Biz and M.L. Occelli, Catal. Rev.-Sci. Eng., 40 (1998) 329. T. Yanagisawa, T. Shimizu, K. Kuroda and C. Kato, Bull. Chem. Soc. Jpn., 63 (1990) 988. S. Inagaki, Y. Fukushima and K. Kuroda, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., (1993) 680. K. Kuroda, Ref. [1], p. 73. S. Inagaki, Ref. [1], p. 109. P. Ekwall, in G.H. Brown (ed.), Advances in Liquid Crystals, Vol. 1, Academic Press, New York, 1971, p. 1. V. Luzzatti, in D. Chapman (ed.), Biological Membranes, Academic Press, New York, 1968, pp. 71-123. S. Friberg (ed.), Lyotropic Liquid Crystals and the Structure of Biomembranes, Advances in Chemistry Series No. 152, ACS, Washington, 1976. (a) X. Auvray, C. Petipas, R. Anthore, I. Rico and A. Lattes, J. Phys. Chem., 93 (1989) 7458. (b) T. Wolff and G. von Buenau, Ber. Bunsen Ges., 88 (1984) 1098. A. Monnier, F. Schuth, Q. Huo, D. Kumar, D. Margolese, R.S. Maxwell, G.D. Stucky, M. Krishnamurty, P. Petroff, A. Firouzi, M. Janicke and B.F. Chmelka, Science, 261 (1993) 1299.
109 [30] G.S. Attard, J.C. Glyde and C.G. Goltner, Nature, 378 (1995) 366. [31] J.S. Beck, J.C. Vartuli, G.J. Kennedy, C.T. Kresge, W.J. Roth and S.E. Schramm, Chem. Mater. 6(1994) 1816. [32] (a) Q. Huo, D.I. Margolese, U. Ciesla, D.G. Demuth, P. Feng, T.E. Gier, P. Sieger, A. Firouzi, B.F. Chmelka, F. Schuth and G.D. Stucky, Chem. Mater., 6 (1994), 1176. (b) Q. Huo, D.I. Margolese, U. Ciesla, P. Feng, T.E. Gier, P. Sieger, R. Leon, P.M. Petroff, F. Schuth and G.D. Stucky, Nature, 368 (1994) 317. [33] D. Zhao, Q. Huo, J. Feng, B.F. Chmelka and G.D. Stucky, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 120 (1998) 6024. [34] J.C. Vartuli, K.D. Schmitt, C.T. Kresge, W.J. Roth, M.E. Leonowicz, S.B. McCullen, S.D. Hellring, J.S. Beck, J.L. Schlenker, D.H. Olson and E.W. Sheppard, Chem. Mater., 6 (1994) 2317. [35] Q. Huo, D.I. Margolese and G.D. Stucky, Chem. Mater. 8 (1996) 1147. [36] O. Terasaki, T. Ohsuna, Z. Liu, Y. Sakamoto and A. E. Garcia-Bennett, Ref. [1], p. 261. [37] D. Trong On, D. Desplantier-Giscard, C. Danumah and S. Kaliaguine, Appl. Catal. A, 222 (2001)299. [38] X.S. Zhao, G.Q. Lu, A.K. Whittaker, J. Drennan and H. Xu, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 55(2002)51. [39] G.S. Attard, N.R.B. Coleman and J.M. Elliott, in L. Bonneviot, F. Beland, C. Danumah, S. Giasson and S Kaliaguine (eds.), Mesoporous Molecular Sieves, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. No. 117, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1998, p. 89. [40] R. Ryoo, S.H. Joo, M. Kruk and M. Jaroniec, Adv. Mater. 13 (2001) 677. [41] S.H. Joo, R. Ryoo, M. Kruk and M. Jaroniec, J. Phys. Chem. B, 106 (2002) 4640. [42] M. Kruk, M. Jaroniec and A. Sayari, Langmuir, 13 (1997) 6267. [43] M. Kruk and M. Jaroniec, Chem. Mater., 13 (2001) 3169. [44] K.J. Edler and J.W. White, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., (1995) 155. [45] W.J. Roth and J.C. Vartuli, in A. Galarneau, F. DiRenzo, F. Fajula and J. Vedrine (eds.), Zeolites and Mesoporous Materials at the Dawn of The 21st Century, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. No 135, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2001, p. 134. [46] W.J. Roth, Synthesis of M41S, WO Patent 98/06665 (1998). [47] W.J. Roth, Synthesis of The Cubic Mesoporous Molecular Sieve MCM-48, US Patent No. 6 096 288 (2000). [48] M. Grun, I. Laurer and K. Unger, Adv. Mater., 9 (1997) 254. [49] A. Sayari, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122 (2000) 6504. [50] Y. Liu, A. Karkamkar and T.J. Pinnavaia, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun. (2001) 1822. [51] Q. Huo, R. Leon, P.M. Petroff and G.D. Stucky, Science, 268 (1995) 1324. [52] M. Kruk, M. Jaroniec, R. Ryoo and S.H. Joo, Chem. Mater., 12 (2000) 1414. [53] M. Kruk, M. Jaroniec and M.L. Pena and F. Rey, Chem. Mater. 14 (2002) 4434. [54] M. Kruk, M. Jaroniec, S.H. Joo and R. Ryoo, J. Phys. Chem. B, 107 (2003) 2205. [55] R. Ryoo, C.H. Ko, M. Kruk, V. Antochshuk and M. Jaroniec, J. Phys. Chem. B, 104 (2000) 11465. [56] (a) J. Cejka, Appl. Catal. A, 254 (2003) 327. (b) J. Cejka in J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (eds.), 1st FEZA School on Zeolites, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. No. 157, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2005. [57] A. Karlsson, M. Stacker and R. Schmidt, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 27 (1999) 181. [58] (a) Y. Liu, Y. Zhang and T.J. Pinnavaia, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 122 (2000), 8791. (b) Z. Zhang, Y. Han, F.-S. Xiao, S. Qiu, L. Zhu, R. Wang, Y. Yu, Z. Zhang, B. Zou, Y. Wang, H. Sun, D. Zhao and Y. Wei, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 123 (2001) 5021.
110 [59] P. Prokesova, S. Mintova, J. Cejka and T. Bein, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 64 (2003) 165. [60] M.J. Verhoef, P.J. Kooyman, J.C. van der Waal, M.S. Rigutto, J.A. Peters and H. van Bekkum, Chem. Mater., 13(2001)683. [61] D. Trong On and S. Kaliaguine, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 125 (2003), 618. [62] (a) J.S. Beck, D.C. Calabro, S.B. McCullen, B.P. Pelrine, K.D. Schmitt and J.C. Vartuli, Method for Functionalizing Mesoporous Crystalline Material, US Patent No. 5 145 816 (1992); (b) idem, Catalytic Conversion over Modified Synthetic Mesoporous Crystalline Material, US Patent No. 5 200 058 (1993); (c) idem, Sorption/separation over Modified Synthetic Mesoporous Crystalline Material, US Patent No. 5 220 101 (1993). [63] J.C. Vartuli, A. Malek, W.J. Roth, C.T. Kresge and S.B. McCullen, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 44-45(2001)691. [64] V. Antochshuk and M. Jaroniec, Chem. Mater., 12 (2000) 2496. [65] W. J. Roth, Method of M41S Functionalization of Potentially Catalytic Heteroatom Centers into As-synthesized M41S with Concomitant Surfactant Extraction, US Patent 5 925 330 (1999) [66] X. Feng, J. Liu and G.E. Fryxell, Surface Functionalized Mesoporous Materials And Method Of Making Same, US Patent No. 6 326 326 Bl (2001) (b) J. Liu, X. Feng, G.E. Fryxell, L.-Q. Wang, A.Y. Kim and M. Gong, Adv. Mater., 10 (1998) 161. (c) X. Feng, G.E. Fryxell, L.-Q. Wang, A.Y. Kim, J. Lui and K.M. Kemner, Science, 276 (1997) 923. [67] K.Z.M. Hossain and L.Mercier, Adv. Mater., 14(2002) 1053. [68] J.M. Thomas and R. Raja, in O. Terasaki (ed.), Mesoporous Crystals and Related Nanostructured Materials, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. No. 148, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 2004, p. 163. [69] K. Yamamoto, Y. Nohara and T. Tatsumi, Chem. Lett, (2001) 648. [70] C. Yoshina-Ishii, T. Asefa, N. Coombs, M.J. MacLachlan and G.A. Ozin, L., Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., (1999) 2539. [71] B.J. Melde, B.T. Holland, C.F. Blanford and A. Stein, Chem. Mater., 11 (1999) 3302. [72] S. Inagaki, S. Guan, Y. Fukushima, T. Ohsuna and O. Terasaki, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 121 (1999) 9611. [73] S. Inagaki, S. Guan, T. Ohsuna and O. Terasaki, Nature, 416 (2002) 304. [74] M.C. Burleigh, S. Dai, E.W. Hagaman and J.S. Lin, Chem. Mater., 13 (2001) 2537. [75] A. Wingen, N. Anastasievic, A. Hollnagel, D. Werner and F. Schuth, J. Catal., 193 (2000) 248.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
111
Recent trends in the synthesis of molecular sieves Jiff Cejka J. Heyrovsky Institute of Physical Chemistry, Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic, Dolejskova 3, CZ-182 23 Prague 8, Czech Republic 1. INTRODUCTION 2. BEYOND 12-MEMBERED RINGS 2.1. Synthesis of VPI-5 2.2. Synthesis of UTD-1 2.3. Synthesis of SSZ-53 3. GeO2 - INORGANIC STRUCTURE-DIRECTING AGENT 3.1. Synthesis of ITQ-15 3.2. Synthesis of Polymorph C of zeolite Beta (ITQ-17) 4. DELAMINATED AND PILLARED ZEOLITES 4.1. Synthesis of MCM-22 4.2. Synthesis of ITQ-2 5. MESOPOROUS NON-SILICEOUS MOLECULAR SIEVES 5.1. Synthesis of organized mesoporous alumina - "neutral" pathway 5.2. Synthesis of organized mesoporous alumina - "anionic" pathway 6. MESOPOROUS ZEOLITE SINGLE CRYSTALS 6.1. Synthesis of mesoporous ZSM-11 with carbon Black pearls 6.2. Synthesis of mesoporous ZSM-5 with carbon nanotubes 7. MICRO-MESOPOROUS COMPOSITE MATERIALS 7.1. Synthesis of micro/mesoporous composites via re-crystallization 7.2. Synthesis of micro/mesoporous composites using seed crystals (Beta/MCM-48) 8. APPLICATION IN CATALYSIS 9. SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK ACKNOWLEDGEMENT REFERENCES 1. INTRODUCTION Zeolite-based molecular sieves represent one of the most important groups of inorganic materials with an extremely high impact on industrial applications as adsorbents, ionexchangers and catalysts [1,2,3]. In particular, the number of applications of zeolites as highly active, selective and stable catalysts in large-scale technologies steadily increases. It includes oil refinery, petrochemistry, production of fine chemicals and environmental catalysis [4]. While zeolites and later on zeotypes have been well known for more than 20 years, a remarkable boom in the preparation of new types of molecular sieves started at the beginning of 1990s [5,6]. Much synthetic effort has been devoted in recent fifteen years in particular to the enlargement of the size of zeolite channels in order to allow larger molecules to reach the
112
active sites. This approach could have a particular importance in fine chemical and pharmaceutical industry and in petroleum refining. In addition, the increase in the accessibility of acid sites located inside the channel systems of zeolite-based molecular sieves would result in an increase in the number of reactions catalyzed by these catalysts. Fig. 1 shows schematically the required size of pores needed for upgrading different petrochemical raw materials. Recently, several new zeolite structures have been reported consisting of 14membered rings (UTD-1 [7], SSZ-53 and SSZ-59 [8]), bi-directional intersecting 14- and 12membered rings (ITQ-15 [9]) and even 18-membered rings (ECR-34 [10]). Further attempts to synthesize zeolites with at least 20-membered ring channels unfortunately failed. The synthetic effort in many laboratories around the world is focused also on utilization of GeC>2 in mixtures resulting in the synthesis of a number of new structural types of zeolites, e.g. polymorph C of zeolite Beta [11]. However, the main goal is to synthesize molecular sieves with pore sizes of at least several nanometers preserving the advantages of zeolites, in particular their strong acidity and high thermal stability. New synthetic approaches have been also developed to prepare mesoporous molecular sieves with amorphous channel walls and various chemical compositions, pore sizes and surface areas [12,13,14], delaminated zeolites [15,16], mesoporous molecular sieves with crystalline zeolite phases embedded in the channel walls [17,18,19] and mesoporous zeolite single crystals [20,21]. Understandably, these materials allow faster diffusion of reactants and products and transformation of bulkier molecules compared with classical zeolites or zeotypes.
Fig. 1. The relationship between the type of hydrocarbon substrate and the pore size of molecular sieve required for its transformation
This contribution briefly highlights current trends in the synthesis of new types of zeolite-based molecular sieves showing recent development in this very topical area. We have tried to cover the most important examples of the development of these molecular sieves, in which a high potential for future applications of molecular sieves is expected. At the end of
113
each chapter typical synthesis recipes are given. Some interesting catalytic examples of application of these molecular sieves are also included. 2. BEYOND THE 12-MEMBERED RINGS The application of zeolites in catalysis is limited due to molecular size restrictions imposed by currently known zeolites, which significantly limits the possibility of transforming larger organic compounds with larger molecules. To-date only several extra-large pore zeolites and zeotypes (having more than 12 tetrahedrally coordinated T atoms in the ring) have been synthesized. Their catalytic properties are very rarely described due to their complex synthesis procedures and usually rather complicated and costly structure-directing agents. This is the reason why no big potential of these zeolites and zeotypes in practical applications can be foreseen at the moment. A list of zeolites and zeotypes possessing larger than 12membered rings is provided in Table 1 together with the codes (if available) of these structures used by the Structure Commission of the International Zeolite Association, type of T-atoms forming the main channels and pore sizes. All these microporous materials possess structures with one-dimensional channel systems. It is clearly seen that we still have not succeeded to escape from the "1-nm prison" of zeolite and zeotype channel systems. While fully symmetric channels having more than 18 rings should possess pore sizes much larger than 1 nm, the actual shapes are elliptic or highly puckered, which leads to a significant decrease in the effective pore sizes of the microporous molecular sieves. Fig. 2 shows the perspective views of the main channels of gallophosphate cloverite, aluminophosphate VPI-5, and two aluminosilicates CIT-5 and SSZ-59.
Fig. 2. Schematic pictures of main channels of cloverite (A), VPI-5 (B), CIT-5 (C), and SSZ-59 (D)
The first silica-based 14-membered ring zeolite, UTD-1, was synthesized by Balkus et al. [7,22] using bis(pentamethylcyclopentadienyl)cobalt(III) hydroxide as a structure-directing
114
agent. This zeolite is a product of an intergrowth of two or more closely related polymorphs and is characterized by one-dimensional elliptic pores of 0.74 x 0.95 nm dimensions. UTD-1 was synthesized as alumino- and later on as titanosilicate. Based on refinement of X-ray data, the [(Cp*)2Co]+ ion is oriented with its five-fold axis parallel to the channel direction. The second 14-membered ring zeolite, CIT-5 [23], was synthesized using N(16)methylsparteinium. The presence of Li cations seemed to be decisive for its synthesis while without Li other zeolites were formed. The synthesis was carried out at 175 °C for 12 days. Recently two novel zeolites with one-dimensional 14-membered rings were synthesized by researchers of ChevronTexaco (SSZ-53 and SSZ-59 [8,24]). For their syntheses, organic cations derived from (phenylcyclopentylmethyl)ammonium, azocanium or piperidinium were used. Their pore sizes lie between those of CIT-5 and UTD-1 (Table 1). The successful synthesis of silica-based microporous material possessing the largest pore size so far was reported by Strohmaier and Vaughan [10]. Using tetraethylammonium cations and an alkali-metal containing reaction gel they synthesized gallosilicate ECR-34 with hexagonal symmetry and one-dimensional 18-membered ring pores with a diameter of 1.0 nm. The synthesis of ECR-34 was performed from low-silica seeded gallia gel at 100 °C for 17 days. This is the first silicon containing microporous sieve with pore openings larger than 14-membered rings. The successful synthesis shows the potential of preparing thermally stable silicate molecular sieves with extra-large pores. Table 1 List of extra-large pore zeolites and zeotypes Name T-membered ring Code A1PO-8 AET 14 (Al, P) 20 (Ga, P) Cloverite CLO VFI 18 (Al, P) VPI-5 ND-1 24 (Zn, P) NTHU-1 24 (Ga, P) FDU-4 24 (Ge) OSO OSB-1 14 (Be, Si) ETR ECR-34 18 (Ga, Si) DON UTD-1 14 (Al, Si) CFI CIT-5 14 (Al, Si) SFH SSZ-53 14 (Al, Si) SFN SSZ-59 14 (Al, Si)
Pore size (nm) 0.79x0.87
1.32x0.40 1.21 1.05 1.04 0.97 0.73x0.54 1.05 0.74 x 0.95 0.72 x 0.75 0.64 x 0.87 0.62x0.85
References [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [7]
[33] [34] [34]
2.1. Synthesis of VPI-5 15.00 g of pseudoboehmite was dispersed in 64.60 g of water. After that 22.20 g of phosphoric acid was added under vigorous stirring until the mixture became homogeneous and then it was aged for 2 h. Finally, 10.11 g of dipropylamine was added and the viscous gel formed was stirred for another 2 h. The synthesis was performed in Teflon-lined autoclave at 142 °C for 4 h without agitation. The reaction product was diluted with water, filtered off, washed and dried in air at temperatures below 50 °C [35]. 2.2. Synthesis of UTD-1 A silica slurry, prepared from 27.8 g of Cab-O-Sil M5 and 68.4 g of water, was stirred until it became homogeneous. 6.60 g of this slurry was added to 49.15 g of an 8.95 wt. % aqueous solution of bis(pentamethylcyclopentadienyl)cobalt(III) hydroxide and the mixture
115
was stirred for 90 min. A solution of 0.67 g of aqueous 38 wt. % hydrofluoric acid in ca. 70 g of water was slowly added to the reaction mixture. After 20 min of vigorous stirring, the homogeneous gel was concentrated by removing excess of water under reduced pressure. The remaining 24.2 g of the uniform gel was transferred to a Teflon-lined autoclave and heated at 170 °C for 25 days. Finally, the zeolite was recovered by filtration and washed extensively with water [36]. 2.3. Synthesis of SSZ-53 As to borosilicate SSZ-53, a solution of 6.33 g of 0.475M {[l-(4fluorophenyl)cyclopentyl] methyl}-trimethylammonium hydroxide, 1.2 g of aqueous 1 M NaOH and 4.45 g of water was stirred in a 23-mL Teflon-lined autoclave. Then 0.06 g of sodium borate decahydrate was added and stirred until complete dissolution. Finally, 0.9 g of Cab-O-Sil M5 was added to the solution and the mixture was thoroughly stirred. The resulting gel was placed into a Parr reactor and heated at 160 °C for 18 days while rotating at 34 rpm. The zeolite was recovered by filtration and extensively washed with water. [34]. Recently, two new extra-large pore zeolites were synthesized by Corma [9] and Patarin [37] groups. Their channel system consists of two perpendicular channels having 14membered and 12-membered rings, which is the first example of zeolitic microporous molecular sieve exhibiting intersecting extra-large and large pores. In both cases the synthesis was performed in the presence of germanium dioxide as discussed in more detail in the following chapter. 3. GeO2 - INORGANIC STRUCTURE-DIRECTING AGENT Although several very interesting new structural types of zeolites have been recently synthesized using novel types of organic templates, it was found that addition of GeO2 to the synthesis mixture can completely change the synthesis pathways leading to new structural types of zeolites. In the absence of GeC>2 already known zeolites are formed [38,39]. Corma and his coworkers have found that the addition of GeC>2 into the reaction mixture changes the preferential formation of some secondary building units, which results mainly in the formation of double-four-rings (D4R) containing Ge. Therefore, particularly those zeolites having in their structures significant concentrations of D4R are easily formed, without a special preference of the formation of narrow, medium, large or extra-large pore zeolites.
A
B
Fig. 3. Schematic pictures of zeolite structures ITQ-22 (A) and ITQ-17 (B) [39,11]
116
Addition of GeC>2 enabled the first synthesis of pure polymorph C of zeolite Beta (ITQ-17 [11], Fig. 3), which was predicted by Newsam et al. [40] but also of a new family of related materials (like ITQ-16), in which the ratio of polymorphs A, B, and C can be varied [41] (in zeolite Beta polymorphs A and B are in the ratio 60 : 40). The structure-directing role of the GeC>2 in the synthesis of polymorph C has been clearly demonstrated. Fig. 4 depicts a SEM image of the crystals of polymorph C. A number of different templates (from both the structural and sterical points of view) was tested under the same hydrothermal conditions (temperature range 135-175 °C, 15-120 h, Si/Ge 0.5-30) and in all cases pure polymorph C was synthesized despite the fluoride or hydroxide medium employed. However, in the absence of germanium zeolite Beta, with a typical intergrowth of polymorphs A and B, ZSM12 or ITQ-4 were produced [11].
Fig. 4. Scanning electron micrograph of ITQ-17 (Polymorph C of zeolite Beta)
Another interesting new zeolite with a potential application in oil refining, ITQ-21 [42], was synthesized using N(16)-methylsparteinium cation as a bulky and rigid organic structure-directing agent, in combination with fluoride anions and germanium oxide. ITQ-21 is a zeolite with a three-dimensional channel network containing large cavities at the intersections of the channels. Each cavity is accessible through six circular windows of 0.74 nm size. Recently, ITQ-21 was also synthesized in a fluoride-free medium [43].
A
B
Fig. 5. Perspective views of the 14- (A) and 12-membered (B) rings of zeolite ITQ-15 (IM-12 [9,37])
117
For the first time, a zeolite having three interconnected channel systems of different pore entrances (ITQ-22) was synthesized possessing 8-, 10 and 12-membered ring channels [39]. l,5-bis-(methylpyrrolidinium)-pentane was used as a structure-directing agent. It was found that germanium oxide controls and probably also stabilizes the formation of D4R units of this zeolite structure. Two extra-large pore zeolites ITQ-15 [9] and IM-12 [37] both possessing intercrossed 14- and 12-membered rings were independently synthesized using l,3,3-trimethyl-6-azoniumtricyclo-[3.2.1.46'6]dodecane or (6i?,10>S)-6,10-dimethyl-5-azoniaspiro[4.5]decane cations, respectively, as templates. The schematic pictures of their 14- and 12-membered rings are given in Fig. 5 and some of structure-directing agents mentioned in this chapter are in Fig. 6. Detailed structural analysis showed that these two zeolite structures are identical. The presence of GeCh in the synthesis mixture can sometimes lead to the synthesis of a very special zeolite. ITQ-13 [44] synthesized in the presence of doubly charged hexamethonium cations exhibits a three-dimensional channel system with intersecting 10- and 9-membered rings. This is for the first time that a zeolite possesses both 10- and 9-membered rings. Table 2 List of some new zeolite structures synthesized in the presence of GeC>2 Name T-membered ring Pore size (nm) References Code ITQ-13 ITH 10x10 x 9 0.48 x 0.53, 048x0.51, 0.40x0.48 [45] ITQ-15 UTL 14 x 12 0.95 x 0.71, 0.85x0.55 [9] IM-12 14x12 UTL 0.95 x 0.71, 0.85x0.55 [37] ITQ-17 12x12 x l 2 0.63 x 0.75, 0,60 x 0.69 BEC [11] 12 ITQ-21 0.74 (cavity- 1.18) [42] IWW ITQ-22 12 x 10 x 8 0.66, 0.59 x 0.49, 0. 45 >c 0.33 [39] ITQ-24 IWR 12x12 x l O 0.77 x 0.56, 0.72 x 0.62, 0.57 x 0.48 [46]
Fig. 6. Structure-directing agents used for the synthesis of SSZ-53 (A), SSZ-59 (B), polymorph C (C), and ITQ-21 (D)
On the basis of MAS NMR data it can be summarized that in Ge-containing zeolites Ge atoms preferentially occupy crystallographic sites in D4R units. When the synthesis was
118
carried out in fluoride medium, the Ge content increased with decreasing concentration of incorporated fluoride anions, which are preferentially located in D4R units. The effect of substitution of silicon for germanium on the synthesis of these microporous materials was investigated by high-temperature oxide melt solution calorimetry [47,48] and density functional theory [49]. It was found that the enthalpies of formation of Ge-containing zeolites are by ca. 15-20 kJ/mol less energetically favored compared to quartz. The range is higher than that for pure silica zeolites (7-14 kJ/mol), microporous aluminophosphates (5-9 kJ/mol) and pure silica mesoporous materials (14-15 kJ/mol). This clearly indicates that the incorporation of Ge into zeolite frameworks decreases their stability. The destabilization generally increases with increasing Ge content and is more pronounced for structures with lower framework density [48]. On the other hand, the computational results have shown that Ge substitution increases, from the thermodynamic point of view, the probability of synthesizing frameworks containing D4R units with respect to all other types of small cages [49]. As to the related materials, recently three-dimensional GeC^-zeotypes having interconnected network of 14-, 12- and 12-membered rings [50] or a three-dimensional 12membered ring system [51] were synthesized using 4-(aminomethyl)piperidine or 1,4-diazabicyclo[2.2.2]octane, respectively. The second GeO2-zeotype possesses an isotypic framework structure with polymorph C of zeolite Beta. 3.1. Synthesis of ITQ-15 GeO2 (0.60 g) was dissolved in 52.95 g of a 0.6M solution of l,3,3-trimethyl-6azonium-tricyclo[3.2.1.46'6]dodecane hydroxide. Then, 12.60 g of tetraethyl orthosilicate and 0.27 g of aluminum isopropoxide were added and left under stirring until the alcohol and the amount of water necessary to reach the final composition were evaporated. The final gel was homogenized and put into an autoclave for 18 days at 175 °C. After cooling down to room temperature, the solid phase was recovered by filtration and washed. Calcination was carried out in a stream of air at 540 °C for 3 h [9]. 3.2. Synthesis of Polymorph C of zeolite Beta (ITQ-17) 2.93 g GeO2 was mixed with 12.1 g H2O and 2.225g HF (40%) and stirred for 10 min. Then 43.99 g of 0.3 M solution of 1-benzyl-l,4-diazoniabicyclo[2.2.2]octane was added and stirred for another 10 min. Finally, 11.22 g of Ludox AM-30 was added dropwise and homogenized for 20 min. The synthesis was carried out in Teflon-lined autoclaves at 150 °C for 4-6 days. 4. DELAMINATED AND PILLARED ZEOLITES Most of the zeolite syntheses carried out under hydrothermal conditions directly results in the formation of three-dimensional crystalline frameworks. However, several zeolites, like MCM-22 or ferrierite, can be synthesized in the form of layered precursors, which can be transformed by further thermal treatment into the three-dimensional crystal structure. These layered solids arouse an interest due to their ability to intercalate guest molecules between two neighboring zeolite layers. Using a proper treatment, layered zeolite materials can be delaminated while the structure of layers is preserved, which makes accessible all active sites located on the external surface of such catalyst. By adding proper inorganic guest molecules functioning as pillars, the control of the interlayer distance can be achieved. Such materials
119
exhibit strong acidity and thermal stability, which is characteristic for zeolite materials. In addition, the accessibility of acid sites is much higher even for larger organic molecules. At present, MCM-22 and ferrierite represent the only two described examples of zeolites, which can be synthesized in the layered form and further transformed to 3-D crystal structures. Delamination of ferrierite led to the formation of ITQ-6 and ITQ-20 [52], while ITQ-2 can be prepared from the lamellar precursor of MCM-22 [15]. Not only aluminum but also titanium was incorporated into the siliceous ITQ-6 and evaluated in acid and oxidation reactions [52,53]. Particularly, the MCM-22 family represents a very interesting group of interrelated materials, including layered, delaminated, pillared, as well as three-dimensional structures. The schematic picture providing basic structural relationships among known representatives of this family is depicted in Fig. 7. Typical MCM-22 with three-dimensional crystal structure can be synthesized via its lamellar precursor, MCM-22(P), followed by thermal treatment at about 580 °C. However, a direct synthesis method was also described leading to a zeolite designated MCM-49, which is isostructural with MCM-22 but produced in one synthesis step [54]. Although MCM-22 has been already exploited for large-scale benzene alkylation, much more interest has been devoted to its lamellar precursor, which can serve for further applications as a delaminated or pillared material. Fig. 8 shows the X-ray diffraction patterns of MCM-22(P), MCM-22, MCM-56 and MCM-49. The formation of three-dimensional crystalline framework of MCM-22 and MCM-49 can be clearly distinguished from lamellar phases MCM-22(P) and MCM-56. MCM-56 was recognized as an identifiable intermediate in the crystallization of MCM-49 within a few hour time window [55].
Fig. 7. Structural relationships among the individual types of the MCM-22 family (modified from ref. [55])
120
The lamellar precursor can be swollen and subsequently transformed into pillared (MCM-36 [56]) or delaminated (exfoliated, e.g. ITQ-2 [15]) material. The delamination can be performed via addition of a proper surfactant (usually aqueous solution of hexadecyltrimethylammonium salt) under ultrasonic treatment. Strict control of pH and temperature seems to be critical to ensure proper delamination and to avoid the formation of undesired phases [57,58]. X-ray diffraction used to monitor the swelling process clearly showed the diminishing and removal of (001) and (002) diffraction lines due to the partial loss of well-ordered lamellar solid while the FTIR spectra of these materials remained practically unchanged. The resulting delaminated material (ITQ-2) exhibits significantly higher mesopores surface areas compared with MCM-22 (up to 700 m2/g) with preservation of randomly oriented layers, ca. 2.5 nm thick. The introduction of pillars into the interlamellar space of MCM-22(P) results in the formation of pillared material MCM-36 [56]. Roth et al. used tetraethyl orthosilicate or tetramethylammonium silicate solution to form silica pillars in MCM-36. They described that the swelling caused the disappearance of the characteristic diffraction line (002) corresponding to the c-parameter of about 2.7 nm. On the other hand, a new intensive line appeared at low angles, which represents new c-parameter. In general, pillaring of MCM22(P) to MCM-36 caused a shift of (hkl) reflections while those of (hkO) remained unchanged. As a result, the pillaring generated pores with maxima between 3.0 and 3.5 nm, which significantly enhances the catalytic possibilities of this type of zeolite-based materials.
Fig. 8. X-ray powder diffraction patterns of MCM-22(P) - A, MCM-22 - B, MCM-56 - C, and MCM-49 - D
4.1. Synthesis of MCM-22 0.92 g of sodium aluminate and 0.60 g of sodium hydroxide were dissolved in 124.20 g of water to form a clear solution. Then 7.61 g of hexamethyleneimine was added and
121
thoroughly mixed to produce a slightly yellow clear solution. Finally, 9.23 g of silica (Aerosil 200) was added and mixed until white gel was formed. Crystallization was carried out in a Teflon-lined stainless steel autoclave at 150 °C for 7 days with agitation. After cooling down to room temperature, the solid phase was recovered by filtration and washed. Calcination was performed at 580 °C for 6 h [59]. 4.2. Synthesis of ITQ-2 MCM-22(P) was synthesized in the following way: 0.23 g of sodium silicate and 0.81 g of sodium hydroxide were dissolved in 103.45 g of distilled water, after which 6.35 g of hexamethyleneimine and 7.86 g of silica Aerosil 200 were added successively. The mixture was stirred for 30 min at room temperature followed by a 11-day reaction in a stirred Teflonlined autoclave at 135 °C. Swelling of the solid product was carried out by refluxing mixture of 27 g of the slurry with 105 g of a 29 wt. % aqueous hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide solution and 33 g of a 40 wt. % aqueous solution of tetrapropylammonium hydroxide at 80 °C for 16 h. Calcination was performed at 540 °C [15]. 5. MESOPOROUS NON-SILICEOUS MOLECULAR SIEVES The first successful synthesis of siliceous mesoporous molecular sieves opened a new era in the investigation of this type of inorganic materials and also initiated developments in the preparation of new types of non-silica mesoporous molecular sieves. The mesoporous molecular sieves are characterized by well-defined pore sizes of narrow distribution in the range between 2.0 and 30 nm and surface areas larger than 1000 m2/g. These materials have been synthesized using self-assembled molecular aggregates or supramolecular assemblies as structure-directing agents [12,60,61,62,63,64]. In contrast to a huge number of papers dealing with synthesis, characterization and catalytic utilization of silica-based mesoporous molecular sieves, synthesis of organized mesoporous alumina was announced several years later and still not many reports can be found in the open literature [64,65,66,67,68]. This is despite the fact that alumina is a very important material being used as a support of various catalytically active phases with application in large scale industrial processes [69,70]. Preparation of titanium dioxide represents a special field of synthesis of templated porous solids. Various synthesis routes proposed in the literature are not described in this review because titanium dioxide is used in photocatalysis, photoelectrochemistry and sensorics [71,72,73]. Synthesis of organized mesoporous aluminas is based on the same approaches as those successfully used for the synthesis of mesoporous molecular sieves ("anionic", "cationic", and "neutral") using aluminum alkoxide as the source of aluminum and in the absence of any silicon source. In contrast to the synthesis of siliceous MCM-41, the "cationic" route to organized mesoporous aluminas using hexadecyltrimethylammonium cations is the least applied and understood. Cabrera et al. [68] described the possibility to tailor the pore dimensions from 3.3 to 6.0 nm by modifying the ratio of surfactant, water and triethanolamine; however, this synthesis route seems to be less reproducible compared with "anionic" and "neutral" routes. Vaudry et al. [66] described the employment of long-chain carboxylic acids, the "anionic" route, for the synthesis of organized mesoporous aluminas. These syntheses are carried out in alcohols, formamide, chloroform or diethyl ether. While aluminas prepared by Vaudry et al. exhibited surface areas between 500 and 700 m2/g and pore sizes around 2.0 nm, we have reported [74] the effect of the hydrocarbon chain length on the pore size diameter of organized mesoporous aluminas prepared using long-chain carboxylic acids of different chain
122
lengths. It was observed that with increasing length of the chain the pore size diameter increased as well. Poly(ethylene) oxide surfactants serve as structure-directing agents for the synthesis of organized mesoporous aluminas using the "neutral" pathway [17,114,75]. Pinnavaia et al. have shown that alkylamines or poly(ethylene oxide)-poly(propylene oxide) block copolymers can be used for the synthesis of organized mesoporous aluminas [65,75]. Mesoporous aluminas with pore diameters up to 10 nm were prepared depending on the type of the surfactant used and stability of the alumina at high temperatures was achieved by addition of small amounts of La3+ or Ce3+ cations. One of the main advantages of this synthesis route is a relatively weak bonding between surfactant and alumina species not only during the synthesis itself but also in the final product. This allows extraction of surfactant used without the necessity of using a new surfactant for the next synthesis. Such weak interaction between the surfactant micelles and surrounding alumina walls was demonstrated by EPR spectroscopy using 5-doxyl stearic acid as a probe molecule [76]. The final stabilization of the structure of mesoporous alumina proceeds, thus, during thermal posttreatment at temperatures of ca. 120 °C, which allows to change the textural parameters of organized mesoporous alumina by washing with various solvents. To meet the requirements for high-temperature applications of organized mesoporous alumina, the dependence of their textural properties on the temperature of calcination was investigated. It has been shown that organized mesoporous aluminas exhibiting amorphous walls after calcination at 500-600 °C are transformed into a crystalline phase in the temperature range from 800 to 1000 °C, which is accompanied by a decrease in the surface area and void volume. Formation of a-alumina was reported by Liu et al. [77], while we have described the formation of 5-alumina particles [78]. The changes of the textural properties of organized mesoporous aluminas with increasing temperature of the thermal treatment are depicted in Figs 9, 10 and 11. Organized mesoporous aluminas exhibit a typical worm-like structure without the formation of clear hexagonal or cubic structure well known for silicate mesoporous sieves (Fig. 9A). With temperature of calcination increasing above 800 °C, diffraction lines of crystalline alumina phase are found evidencing a phase transformation proceeding at this temperature (Fig. 9B). The increase in the temperature of calcination leads also to significant change of textural properties of organized mesoporous aluminas like a decrease in surface area and void volume (Fig. 10) or increase in the pore size and broadening of pore size distribution (Fig. 11).
Fig. 9. Transmission electron micrographs of organized mesoporous alumina synthesized using the "anionic" pathway and calcined at 420 (A) and 800 °C (B) [78]
123
Mesoporous molecular sieves having chemical compositions different from silicates and alumina including aluminum phosphates, various transition-metal oxides, chalcogenide and nitridic framework, metals, and carbons were recently nicely reviewed by Schiith [79]. 5.1. Synthesis of organized mesoporous alumina - "neutral" pathway A solution containing deionized water (42 mmol) in anhydrous sec-butyl alcohol (10 mL) was added very slowly to a stirred homogeneous solution containing Pluronic 64L a triblock copolymer of composition (PEO)o(PPO)3o(PEO)i3 (2.1 mmol) and aluminum secbutoxide (25 mL). The resulting gel was stirred for 3 h and then diluted with sec-butyl alcohol to react for additional 16 h. The solid product was washed with ethanol and dried at room temperature for 16 h and at 100 °C for 6 h. The calcination was carried out at 500 °C for 4 h. To recover the structure-directing agent (Pluronic 64L) from the as-synthesized solid, extraction with ethanol can be successfully used [65].
Fig. 10. Nitrogen adsorption isotherms of organized mesoporous alumina synthesized using "anionic" pathway and calcined at 420 (A), 600 (B), 800 (C) and 1000 °C (D)
Fig. 11. Pore size distribution of organized mesoporous alumina synthesized using "anionic" pathway and calcined at 420 (A), 600 (B), 800 (C) and 1000 °C (D)
5.2. Synthesis of organized mesoporous alumina - "anionic" pathway 5.1 g of stearic acid was dissolved in 100 ml of 1-propanol. After addition of 3.1 ml of water, the solution was stirred for 30 min. Finally, 13.7 g of aluminum sec-butoxide was added and the reaction mixture was stirred for 20 min. The prepared gel was aged at 100 °C for 50 h under static conditions. After cooling, filtration and washing with ethanol, the solid product was dried overnight at 50 °C. Calcination was carried out in a stream of nitrogen at 410 °C and then in air at 420 °C [74]. 6. MESOPOROUS ZEOLITE SINGLE CRYSTALS Zeolites as crystalline microporous materials are widely used in chemical industry in catalysis, adsorption and separation. Utilization of zeolites should be attributed to the
124
presence of micropores in their structures, inducing various types of shape selectivity [2] based on exact shapes and sizes of their micropores related to the kinetic diameters of organic reactants, intermediates or products. However, the presence of micropores can also limit the catalytic performance of zeolite catalysts, especially when the diffusion is the ratedetermining step of the overall chemical reaction. For that reason different synthetic strategies were investigated to overcome diffusion limitations. One of these approaches is based on the formation of mesopores in zeolite single crystals. Usually mesopores in zeolites were formed by dealumination [80] or desilication [81] and these methods including industrial applications of mesoporous zeolites were recently nicely reviewed by the group of de Jong [21]. A new direct and controlled synthesis of mesoporous zeolite crystals is based on the utilization of small carbon particles (carbon black) having sizes in the range 5-50 nm, which are added to the synthesis mixture for the preparation of the zeolite. Using excess of a zeolite gel it is possible for the zeolite to grow around these carbon particles forming the inert matrix within the whole pore system [20]. This means that after the synthesis the zeolite contains a large number of carbon particles inside the individual crystals. Such particles are removed by combustion leading to the formation of well-defined zeolite single crystals with mesopores the size of which is close to the size of the carbon particles used. A similar approach to the synthesis of mesoporous single crystals includes utilization of multiwall carbon nanotubes as mesopore-forming agents. Schmidt et al. [82] synthesized mesoporous ZSM-5 (silicalite-1) using multiwall carbon nanotubes. As the carbon nanotubes with different diameters can be now synthesized in a controlled way, this method could result in zeolite single crystals having mesopores of variable diameter. In contrast to the use of carbon black beeds, mesopores formed using carbon nanotubes are not spherical and it can be expected that the active sites will be more easily accessible. The external surface of zeolites synthesized with carbon particles differs significantly from that one prepared without them as many carbon particles were localized just at the surface of these crystals. (Fig. 12).
Fig. 12. Scanning electron micrographs of ZSM-5 synthesized without (A) and with Carbon Black Pearls (B)
The first mesoporous zeolite single crystal (ZSM-5) was synthesized by Jacobsen et al. [20] and since that time a particular attention has been devoted to characterization of this material [ 83 , 84 ]. Combination of nitrogen adsorption isotherms, scanning electron
125
microscopy, and three-dimensional transmission electron microscopy used for investigation of ZSM-5 zeolites synthesized from different sources of silicon provided clear evidence that both carbon nanotubes and carbon black were capable of templating the formation of mesopores in ZSM-5 zeolite. The crystallization of ZSM-5 using dissolved silica (Aerosil 200) resulted in much larger ZSM-5 crystals compared with those prepared from tetraethyl orthosilicate. With increasing zeolite crystal size, more carbon particles were surrounded by zeolites while the tortuosity of the mesoporous system was much higher for carbon black pearls compared with carbon nanotubes. The size of zeolite crystals was found to depend also on the heating rate of the crystallization mixture. The higher was the rate the larger were resulting crystals probably due to the shortening of the nucleation time [84]. Nitrogen adsorption isotherms clearly show the increase in the mesoporous volume for ZSM-5 samples synthesized with carbon particles (Figs 13 and 14). Tao et al. [85] synthesized zeolite Y with a significant portion of mesopores by adding the resorcinol-formaldehyde polymer to the zeolite synthesis mixture. Nitrogen adsorption isotherms showed the presence of mesopores with a pore diameter close to 10 nm and a pore volume of 1.37 cnvVg. The presence of mesopores was also confirmed by field-emission scanning electron microscopy.
Fig. 13. Sorption isotherms of nitrogen of ZSM-5 synthesized without (A) and with Carbon Black Pearls (B)
Fig. 14. Pore size distribution of ZSM-5 synthesized with Carbon Black Pearls
126
6.1. Synthesis of mesoporous ZSM-11 with Carbon Black pearls The Carbon Black Pearls labeled BP 2000 was supplied by Cabot Corp. 10 g of carbon black pearls (BP-2000) was dried in an oven at 110 °C overnight. In a 200-mL flask, 17.2 g of 40 % tetrabutylammonium hydroxide, 2.5 g of H2O and 15.1 g of ethanol was stirred to obtain a homogeneous solution. The dried carbon black was impregnated with this solution to incipient wetness. After evaporation of ethanol at room temperature for 12 h, carbon particles were impregnated with 19.3 g of tetraethyl orthosilicate. This mixture was left at ambient conditions to hydrolyze overnight. The hydrothermal synthesis was performed in a Teflonlined autoclave at 180 °C for 72 h. Then the autoclave was cooled, a solid product was filtered and washed with distilled water. Calcination was carried out in a muffle oven at 550 °C for 18 h [86]. 6.2. Synthesis of siliceous mesoporous ZSM-5 with carbon nanotubes Carbon nanotubes were purified by reflux with concentrated hydrochloric acid for 24 h. After that 1.0 g of carbon nanotubes was successfully impregnated with 1.0 g of tetrapropylammonium hydroxide (40 wt. %) and 1.0 g of tetraethyl orthosilicate. Samples were digested for 3 h and then heated to an autoclave at 175 °C for 24 h. After the hydrothermal synthesis, the solid phase was filtered, washed with water and ethanol, and dried at 110 °C. The carbon nanotubes were completely removed by calcination in air at 600 °C for 20 h [82]. 7. MICRO-MESOPOROUS COMPOSITE MATERIALS The acidity and thermal stability of aluminosilicate mesoporous molecular sieves of the MCM-41 and MCM-48 types are relatively low compared to zeolites. These mesoporous materials also suffer from low concentration of Broensted acid sites on the surface of their walls. Low acidity and insufficient thermal stability limit the potential of these catalysts in their application in petroleum refining and fine chemicals manufacture. For these reasons new approaches are sought to increase thermal stability of mesoporous molecular sieves and to induce a strong acidity particularly of the Broensted type. Several approaches were recently described in the literature. Modification of siliceous support with heteropolyacids results in the preparation of highly active acid catalysts [87]; however, lack of stability in polar systems as well as leaching are the main drawbacks of this type of catalysts [88]. In a similar way, attachment of sulfonic groups via organic spacer provided interesting and active acid catalysts but their use is rather restricted due to the presence of thermally unstable organic spacers limiting not only the catalytic application at higher temperatures but also the regeneration [89,90]. Two probably the most promising ways of synthesizing hierarchic micro/mesoporous composite systems are based on partial re-crystallization of originally amorphous mesoporous molecular sieves or on the employment of zeolite seeds as a source of building blocks for their assembly to form the mesoporous material. These hierarchic systems should benefit from the acid strength and concentration of acid sites related to the presence of zeolite nanoparticles and faster diffusion combined with higher accessibility of active sites for bulky molecules. The first approach (recrystallization) was applied to form the ZSM-5/MCM-41 system by impregnation of or ion-exchange in MCM-41 with a solution of tetrapropylammonium hydroxide followed by classical hydrothermal treatment [91]. In this case some portion of originally mesoporous walls should recrystallize into zeolite particles. The other approach stems from the possibility to use zeolite seeds as building units, which are
127
further self-assembled into mesoporous molecular sieves. Therefore, a higher stability and acidity of this composite materials should be obtained using zeolite seeds compared with composite materials prepared by a partial recrystallization [18,19,92,93]. Verhoef et al. provided experimental evidence on the recrystallization of a part of originally amorphous walls of MCM-41 into crystalline particles of ZSM-5 after impregnation of or ion-exchange in MCM-41 with a solution of tetrapropylammonium hydroxide [88]. X-ray diffraction and transmission electron microscopy provided evidence of the formation of particles of ZSM-5 with a diameter of 3 nm. These particles are not mobile to agglomerate to larger particles and it was suggested that they grew from the MCM-41 pore walls. Unfortunately, the formation of ZSM-5 particles was accompanied by a partial collapse of the mesoporous structure. To retain the mesoporous structure either addition of template molecules is proposed or MCM-41 with thicker walls should be used. This approach was confirmed by other experiments showing its applicability in the systems like mesoporous material/Pluronic P123/tetrapropylammonium hydroxide leading to ZSM-5/mesoporous sieve or mesoporous material/Pluronic P123/tetraethylammonium hydroxide forming Beta zeolite particles in mesoporous material [94,95]. Various nanocrystal zeolites were used to assemble in mesoporous material (ZSM-5, Beta, zeolite Y, etc.) [18,19,96, 97 ]. The first steam-stable hexagonal mesoporous aluminosilicates was successfully synthesized from zeolite Y type seeds by Liu et al. [98]. Seeds of zeolite Y were prepared by reacting sodium hydroxide, sodium aluminate, and sodium silicate under vigorous stirring at 100 °C overnight. 27A1 MAS NMR indicated the exclusive presence of tetrahedrally coordinated aluminum, although no diffraction lines of these seeds were observed. The hexagonal mesostructure was achieved by addition of hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide as a structure-directing agent. The same method was employed to prepare a micro/mesoporous composite of ZSM-5 and Beta types [99,100,101,102]. All these materials show characteristic features of microporous as well as mesoporous materials. As the further step in the synthesis of this hierarchic materials, micro/macroporous composites were synthesized although it is not clear at the moment whether such materials can be used in catalysis [103,104]. 7.1. Synthesis of micro/mesoporous composites via recrystallization MCM-41, synthesized using hexadecyltrimethylammonium hydroxide, was ionexchanged with tetrapropylammonium hydroxide-MCM-41 by shaking a suspension of 2.00 g of MCM-41 in 1.22 g of 25.0 wt. % of tetrapropylammonium hydroxide solution in 1 L at room temperature overnight. The solid was recovered by centrifugation, washed in water and subjected to a hydrothermal treatment at 170 °C in a 15-mL Teflon autoclave. The recrystallized MCM-41 was recovered by centrifugation, washed with deionized water and dried under vacuum at 60 °C. The template was removed by calcination in a stream of air at 500 °C for 6 h [91]. 7.2. Synthesis of micro/mesoporous composites using seed crystals (Beta/MCM-48) Zeolite Beta seeds were prepared from 0.816 g of aluminum isopropoxide mixed with 40.0 g of silica sol and 53.02 g of tetraethylammonium hydroxide in a polypropylene bottle. The resulting mixture was stirred at room temperature for 1 h. The clear precursor solution was hydrothermally treated in an oven at 100 °C and the crystallization was stopped when a milky solution containing colloidal particles of zeolite Beta was obtained (at least after 24 h). Simultaneously, solution for the synthesis of MCM-48 was prepared from 0.868 g
128
of hexadecyltrimethylammonium bromide dissolved in a solution containing 50 mL of ethanol, 12 mL of aqueous ammonia and 120 mL of water. Then 1.776 g of tetraethyl orthosilicate was added. Immediately after cooling the colloidal Beta solution to room temperature, 3.50 g of the Beta seed solution was mixed with 6.40 g of the freshly prepared precursor solution of MCM-48. The crystallization was carried out at 100 °C for 40 h [19]. 8. APPLICATION IN CATALYSIS Most of the advanced zeolite-based materials described in the previous chapters have been synthesized very recently. For that reason not much effort has been devoted to investigation of their catalytic properties. However, at least some examples of interesting reactions or promising results are given in this chapter. The extra-large pore zeolite UTD-1 with incorporated titanium was studied in oxidation of alkanes and olefins with hydrogen peroxide or organic peroxides. Particular attention was paid to the oxidation of cyclohexane to adipic acid [105] or oxidation of 2,6-di-tertbutylphenol [106]. Acid form of UTD-1 exhibited the isomerization-to-disproportionation ratio and the distribution of trimethylbenzene isomers in the m-xylene isomerization test reaction similar to those obtained from other large-pore zeolites [7]. m-Xylene isomerization was proposed as a test reaction to distinguish among medium, large and extra-large pore zeolites including UTD-1 and CIT-5 [107]. UTD-1 was found superior to CIT-5 in cracking of triisopropylbenzene; however, both 14-membered ring zeolites exhibited lower catalytic activities in cracking of complex feedstock compared with traditional three-dimensional zeolites Beta or Y [108]. Aluminum-containing ITQ-21 was compared with commercial USY and Beta zeolites in cracking of light vacuum gasoil [42]. The results showed that the catalytic activity of ITQ21 was higher than that of USY and much higher than that of zeolite Beta. On the other hand, ITQ-21 produced more propylene. The gasoline analysis showed that much less olefins were formed compared with USY and Beta while the octane number was the highest with ITQ-21. In acid-catalyzed acylation of 2-methoxynaphthalene to 2-acetyl-6-methoxynaphthalene (2AMN) polymorph C of zeolite Beta was found more selective than zeolite Beta due to a slighly smaller size of its channels. Molecular dynamic calculation confirmed the higher selectivity showing an increase in the ratio of diffusion coefficients for 2-AMN / 1-AMN of about one order of magnitude between polymorph C and zeolite Beta [109]. Delaminated zeolites like ITQ-2, benefiting from greater accessibility of acid sites and shorter diffusion pathways, exhibited a higher catalytic activity in cracking of 1,3diisopropylbenzene or vacuum oil compared with MCM-22 [15]. However, it seems that a high potential of delaminated catalysts can be found in synthesis of special chemicals. Corma and Fornes showed the synthesis of 2-methyl-2-naphthyl-4-methyl-l,3-dioxolane, which has an orange blossom fragrance [110,111]. The most interesting examples employing organized mesoporous alumina as a support for catalytically active species include the utilization of molybdenum oxide for hydrodesulfurization of thiophene [112] and rhenium oxide for metathesis of linear a-olefms [113]. In the former case at least 30 wt. % of M0O3 can spread over the alumina support, which results in almost twice higher conversion compared with the commercial catalysts. In the latter case, rhenium oxide supported on organized mesoporous alumina exhibits high conversions in metathesis of various a-olefms even at room or at only slightly elevated temperature. The high activity in both reactions has been explained by the absence of
129
micropores in organized mesoporous aluminas [114] and the spreading of significantly higher concentrations of active phases compared with commercial aluminas. Mesoporous zeolite single crystals of ZSM-5 were investigated in gas-phase benzene alkylation with ethylene and compared with standard ZSM-5 [115]. Both mesoporous and standard ZSM-5 exhibited the same size and shape of crystals as determined by SEM (2 jim) while the concentration of acid sites based on FTIR and 27A1 NMR measurements was much higher in standard ZSM-5 with no mesopores. Nevertheless, the catalytic activity of mesoporous ZSM-5 was significantly higher compared with standard ZSM-5 due to improved mass transport in mesoporous crystals. Higher selectivities for ethylbenzene observed in mesoporous crystals can be explained by shortening of the diffusion path of products in mesoporous ZSM-5 decreasing, thus, the rate of the second alkylation step [115]. In a similar way, higher activities of mesoporous ZSM-11 in K-hexadecane isomerization and cracking, and of mesoporous Ti-ZSM-11 in epoxidation of 1-octene and styrene were reported compared with standard ZSM-11 and Ti-ZSM-11, respectively [86]. An increase in the activity of mesoporous MCM-41 after the incorporation of seeds of zeolite Beta resulted in a higher conversion of toluene in toluene alkylation with propylene to cymenes compared with Al-MCM-41 [116]. The resulting order of conversions was as follows: nanocrystalline Beta [117] > industrial zeolites Beta > micro/mesoporous composites (Beta/MCM-41) > MCM-41 (Fig. 15). Beta-TUD-1 catalysts with different loading of nanocrystals zeolite Beta were tested in n-hexane cracking [93]. A higher activity of these composite catalysts was observed compared with zeolite Beta and a physical mixture of zeolite Beta and TUD-1. The higher activity of composite material was ascribed to the isolated particles homogeneously dispersed in the mesoporous matrix making easier transport of reactants and preserving acidity of zeolite Beta. A similar composite catalyst (Beta/hexagonal mesostructured silicate) exhibited a high long-term activity and stability in the alkylation of isobutane with 2-butene, which were even higher than over zeolite Beta and much higher compared with MCM-41 or ZSM-5 [100,118].
Fig. 15. T-O-S values of the toluene conversion in alkylation of toluene with propylene over different Beta related catalysts (toluene/propylene molar ratio of 2.0, WHSV = 20h'', reaction temperature 250 °C) over nanosized Beta Bl - 0, industrial Beta iB2 - o, micro/mesoporous composite BM3 - V, and mesoporous Al-MCM-41 - x.
130
9. SUMMARY AND OUTLOOK The continuous effort of numerous academic and industrial laboratories around the world has resulted in recent years in successful synthesis of a number of new porous materials including new structural types of zeolites and zeotypes, siliceous and non-siliceous mesoporous molecular sieves, mesoporous zeolite single crystals, and micro/mesoporous or micro/macroporous composite materials of different chemical compositions. As a consequence of the success of basic research in this area, zeolites have found new industrial applications. In the case of zeolites and zeotypes, several new extra-large pore microporous sieves have been synthesized like UTD-1, CIT-5, SSZ-53, and ECR-34. Their synthesis procedures are rather complex and catalytic data are usually lacking. Some effort has been exerted to enhance the accessibility of catalytically active sites by delamination and pillaring of zeolite precursors related mainly to the MCM-22 type while preserving the structure and properties of zeolitic layers. Some promising catalytic examples appeared in this area showing the potential of delaminated materials in transformation of organic compounds with larger molecules. The role of germanium dioxide as inorganic structure-directing agent has been investigated, which resulted in the successful synthesis of several new types of zeolites with so far not observed structural features (e.g. polymorph C of zeolite Beta, zeolite UTL with intercrossed 14- and 12-membered rings, ITQ-22 possessing 8-, 10-, and 12-membered rings). New types of mesoporous molecular sieves (their first synthesis opened a new subfield of molecular sieve chemistry) have been prepared over the last ten years by new synthetic approaches, different from those known for zeolites. The variety of the synthetic procedures described and the differences in the textural properties due to different synthetic procedures, as well as to the high temperature treatment, give evidence that mesoporous molecular sieves of different chemical compositions are very interesting materials not only in materials science. They could be important also for the application as heterogeneous catalysts, support for immobilization of homogeneous catalysts, adsorbents or materials for synthesis of new types of inclusion compounds. The first successful preparation of micro/mesoporous or micro/macroporous molecular sieves as well as mesoporous zeolite single crystals started an intensive search of optimization procedures for their synthesis, to increase their thermal stability and to tailor their acid, base and redox properties for possible applications in heterogeneous catalysis. There is no doubt that mastering of synthesis of these hierarchic materials is an important challenge in the area of porous materials. It can be expected that many new molecular sieve materials will be synthesized in a near future. These materials as catalysts or adsorbents are promising in different respects. Synthesis of novel molecular sieves is more complex compared with the classical synthesis of zeolites. It usually consists of several steps, e.g. preparing zeolite seeds followed by their assembly into mesoporous molecular sieve. This is of course time-consuming and costly and, thus, their catalytic or adsorption properties have to be superior to those of existing materials. In this respect, we are only in the beginning. In a similar way the acid properties of these molecular sieves have to be tailored as regards the acid strength and the concentration and type of acid sites. This means preparation of zeolite-based molecular sieves with pre-defined concentrations of strong Broensted acid sites and decreasing as much as possible the presence of Lewis acid sites. Lewis sites were shown in many reactions to catalyze undesired reactions causing a decrease in the selectivity or accelerate deactivation of the catalyst. For application of these materials in chemical industry their advantages have to be explored and their
131
syntheses more facile even in large-scale facilities. With increasing pore sizes and decreasing dimensions of crystals, the advantages of traditional zeolite shape-selectivity will probably be smaller; on the other hand, these catalysts might be beneficial due to the possibility of transformation of large organic substrates. Finally, after fifty years of intensive investigation of synthesis, properties and applications of zeolites and related molecular sieves resulting in a number of industrial applications, it is clear that this research area is still very topical and many interesting and useful materials and processes will certainly be developed in future. ACKNOWLEDGEMENT The long-term support of our projects devoted to the synthesis, characterization and applications of zeolite-based molecular sieves by the Grant Agency of the Academy of Sciences of the Czech Republic (A4040411, B4040402) and the Grant Agency of the Czech Republic (104/02/0571, 203/03/0804, 104/05/0192, 203/05/0197) is gratefully acknowledged.
REFERENCES [I] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [II] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22]
A. Corma, Chem. Rev. 97 (1997) 2373. J. Cejka and B. Wichterlova, Catal. Rev. 44 (2002) 375. J. Cejka, Zeolites: Structures and Inclusion Properties, in Encyclopedia of Supramolecular Chemistry, M. Dekker, New York, 2004, 1623. R.A. Sheldon and R.S. Downing, Appl. Catal. A 189 (1999) 163. A. Corma, Chem. Rev. 95 (1995) 559. C.S. Cundy, P.A. Cox, Chem. Rev. 103 (2003) 663. R.F. Lobo, M. Tsapatsis, C.C. Freyhardt, S. Khodabandeh, P. Wagner, C.-Y. Chen, K.J. Balkus Jr., S.I. Zones and M.E. Davis, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 119 (1997) 8474. A. Burton, S. Elomari, C.Y. Chen, T.V. Harris and E.S. Vittoratos, Proc. 14th Int. Zeolite Conf. (E. van Steen et al. - Eds), Cape Town, 2004, 126. A. Corma, M.J. Diaz-Cabanas, F. Rey, S. Nicolopoulus and K. Boulahya, Chem. Commun. (2004) 1356. K.G. Strohmaier and D.E.W. Vaughan, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125 (2003) 16035. A. Corma, M.T. Navarro, F. Rey, J. Rius and S. Valencia, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 40 (2001) 2277. C.T. Kresge, M.E. Leonowicz, W.J. Roth, J.C. Vartuli and J.S. Beck, Nature 359 (1992) 710. F. Schuth and W. Schmidt, Adv. Eng. Mater. 4 (2002) 269. A. Stein, Adv. Mater. 15 (2003) 763. A. Corma, V. Fornes, S.B. Pergher, Th.L.M. Maessen and J.G. Buglass, Nature 396 (1998) 353. A. Corma, V. Fornes, J. Triguero-Martinez, and S.B. Pergher, J. Catal. 186 (1999) 57. Y. Liu, W. Zhang and T.J. Pinnavaia, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 40 (2001) 1255. Y. Liu and T.J. Pinnavaia, J. Mater. Chem. 12 (2002) 3179. P. Prokesova, S. Mintova, J. Cejka and T. Bein, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 64 (2003) 165. C.J.H. Jacobsen, C. Madsen, J. Houzvicka, I. Schmidt, A, Carlsson, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122 (2000)7116. S. van Donk, A.H. Janssen, J.H. Bitter and K.P. de Jong, Catal. Rev. 45 (2003) 297. K.J. Balkus, A.G. Gabrielov, N. Sandier, Mater. Res. Soc. Symp. Proc. 368 (1995) 369.
132 [23] [24] [25] [26] [27] [28] [29] [30] [31] [32] [33] [34] [35] [36] [37] [38] [39] [40] [41] [42] [43] [44] [45] [46] [47] [48] [49] [50] [51] [52] [53] [54] [55]
P. Wagner, M. Yoshikawa, M. Lovallo, K. Tsuji, M. Tsapatsis, M. E. Davis, Chem. Commun. (1997)2179. S. Elomari, S.I. Zones, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 135 (2001) 479. J.W. Richardson Jr., E.T.C. Vogt, Zeolites 12 (1992) 13. M. Estermann, L.B. McCusker, C. Baerlocher, A. Merrouche, H. Kessler, Nature 352 (1991) 320. M.E. Davis, C. Saldiarriaga, C. Montes, J. Garces, C. Crowder, Nature 331 (1998) 98. G. Yang, S.C. Sevov, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121 (1999) 8389. C. Lin, S. Wang, K. Lii, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123 (2001) 4649. Y. Zhou, H. Zhu, Z. Chen, M. Chen, Y. Xu, H. Zhang, D. Zhao, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 40 (2001)2166. K.O. Kongshaug, H. Fjellvag, K.P. Lillerud, T.E. Gier, G.D. Stucky, A.K. Cheetham, in hhtp://www.iza-structure-org/databases/ K.G. Strohmaier, D.E.W. Vaughan, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125 (2003) 16035. M. Yoshikawa, P. Wagner, M. Lovallo, K. Tsuji, T. Takewaki, C.Y. ChenY, L.W. Beck, C. Jones, M. Tsapatsis, S.I. Zones, M.E. Davis, J. Phys. Chem. B 102 (1998) 7139. A. Burton, S. Elomari, C.-Y. Chen, R.C. Medrud, I.Y. Chan, L.M. Bull, C. Kibby, T.V. Harris, S.I. Zones, E.S. Vittoratos, Chem. Eur. J. 9 (2003) 5737. H. He, J. Klinowski, J. Phys. Chem. 98 (1994) 1192. T. Wessles, Ch. Baerlocher, L.B. McCusker, E.J. Creyghton, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 121 (1999) 6242. J.-L. Paillaud, B. Harbuzaru, J. Patarin, N. Bats, Science 304 (2004) 990. A. Corma, T. Navarro, F. Rey and S. Valencia, Chem. Commun. (2001) 1486. A. Corma, F. Rey, S. Valencia, J.L. Jorda and J. Rius, Nat. Mater. 2 (2003) 493. J.M. Newsam, M.M.J. Treacy, W.T. Koetsier, C.B. de Gruyter, Proc. R. Soc. London A 420 (1988)375. A. Corma, M.T. Navarro, F. Rey, S. Valencia, Chem. Commun. (2001) 1720. A. Corma, M.J. Diaz-Cabanas, J. Martinez-Triquero, F. Rey, J. Rius, Nature, 418 (2002) 514. A. Corma, M.J. Diaz-Cabanas, F. Rey, Chem. Commun. (2003) 1050. A. Corma, M. Puche, F. Rey, G. Sankar, S.J. Treat, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 24 (2003) 1156. J.A. Vidal-Moya, T. Blasco, F. Rey, A. Corma, M. Puche, Chem. Mater. 15 (2003) 3961. R. Castaneda, A. Corma, V. Fornes, F. Rey, J. Rius, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125 (2003) 7820. Q. Li, A, Navrotsky, F. Rey, A. Corma, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 64 (2003) 127. Q. Li, A, Navrotsky, F. Rey, A. Corma, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 74 (2004) 87. M.A. Zwijnenburg, S.T. Bromley, J.C. Jansen, T. Maschmeyer, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 73 (2004) 171. M.E. Medina, E. Gutierrez-Puebla, M. Angeles Monge, N. Snejko, Chem. Commun. (2004) 2868. T. Conradsson, M.S. Dadachov, X.D. Zou, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 41 (2000) 183. A. Corma, U. Diaz, M.E. Domine, V. Fornes, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 39 (2000) 1499. A. Corma, U. Diaz, M.E. Domine, V. Fornes, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122 (2000) 2804. A.S. Fung, G.J. Kennedy, L.B. Alemany, CD. Chang, G.H. Hatzikos, D.N. Lissy, M.K. Rubin, H.K.C. Timken, S. Steuernagel, D.E. Woessner. J. Phys. Chem. 100 (1996) 3788. W.J. Roth, Proc. 3rd FEZA Conference on Zeolites (J. Cejka, N. Zilkova, P. Nachtigall, Eds), Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. (2005).
133 [56] [57] [58] [59] [60]
[61] [62] [63] [64] [65] [66] [67] [68] [69] [70] [71] [72] [73] [74] [75] [76] [77] [78] [79] [80] [81] [82] [83] [84] [85] [86] [87] [88]
W.J. Roth, C.T. Kresge, J.C. Vartuli, M.E. Leonowicz, A.S. Fung, S.B. McCullen, Stud. Surf. Sci.Catal. 94(1995)301. W.J. Roth, J.C. Vartuli, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 141 (2002) 273. A. Corma, V. Fornes, J.M. Guil, S. Pergher, Th.L.M. Maesen, J.G. Buglass, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 38 (2000) 301. A. Corma, C. Corell, J. Perez-Pariente, Zeolites 15 (1995) 2. J.S. Beck, J.C. Vartuli, W.J. Roth, M.E. Leonowicz, C.T. Kresge, K.D. Schmitt, C.T.-W. Chu, D.H. Olson, E.W. Sheppard, S.B. McCullen, J.B. Higgins and J.L. Schlenker, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 114(1992) 10834. A. Sayari, Chem. Mater. 8 (1996) 1841. J.Y. Ying, C.P. Mehnert and M.S. Wong, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 38 (1999) 56. F. Schiith, Chem. Mater. 13 (2001) 3184. J. Cejka, Appl. Catal. A 254 (2003) 327. S.A. Bagshaw and T.J. Pinnavaia, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 35 (1996) 1012. F. Vaudry, S. Khodabandeh and M.E. Davis, Chem. Mater. 8 (1996) 1451. M. Yada, H. Kitamura, M. Machida and T. Kijima, Langmuir 13 (1997) 5252. S. Cabrera, J. El Haskouri, J. Alamo, A. Beltran, D. Beltran, S. Mendioroz, M. Dolores Marcos and P. Amoros, Adv. Mater. 11 (1999) 379. C. Misra, Industrial Alumina Chemicals, ACS 184, Washington, 1986. H. Topsoe, B.S. Clausen and F.E. Massoth, Hydrotreating Catalysis, Springer, Berlin, 1996. P. Yang, D. Zhao, D.I. Margolese, B.F.Chmelka, G.Stucky, Nature 396 (1998) 152. E.L. Crepaldi, G.J. de A.A. Soler-Illia, D. Grosso, F. Cagnol. F. Ribot, C. Sanchez, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 125(2003)9770. S.Y.Choi, M. Mamak, N. Coombs, N. Chopra, G.A. Ozin, Adv. Funct. Mater. 14 (2004) 335. J. Cejka, N. Zilkova, J. Rathousky and A. Zukal, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 3 (2001) 5076. W. Zhang and T.J. Pinnavaia, Chem. Commun. (1998) 1185. A. Caragheorgheopol, H. Caldararu, G. Ionita, F. Savonea. N. Zilkova, A. Zukal and J. Cejka, Langmuir, 21 (2005)2591. X. Liu, Y. Wei, D. Jin and W.-H. Shih, Mater. Lett. 42 (2000) 143. J. Cejka, P.J. Kooyman, L. Vesela, J. Rathousky and A. Zukal, Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 4 (2002)4823. F. Schiith, Chem. Mater. 13 (2001) 3184. S. Morin, P. Ayrault, N.S. Gnep and M. Guisnet, Appl. Catal. A 166 (1998) 281. M. Ogura, S.H. Shinomiya, J. Tateno, Y. Nara, E. Kikuchi and M. Matsukata, Che, Lett. (2000) 82. I. Schmidt, A. Boisen, E. Gustavsson, K. Stahl, S. Pehrson, S. Dahl, A. Carlsson, C.J.H. Jacobsen, Chem. Mater. 13 (2001) 4416. A. Boisen, I. Schmidt, A. Carlsson, S. Dahl, M. Brorson, C.J.H. Jacobsen, Chem. Commun. (2003) 958. A.H. Janssen, I. Schmidt, C.J.H. Jacobsen, A.J. Koster, K.P. de Jong, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 65 (2003) 59. Y. Tao, H. Kanoh, K. Kaneko, J. Phys. Chem. B 107 (2003) 10974. M.Y. Kustova, P. Hasselriis and C.H. Christensen, Catal. Lett. 96 (2004) 205. I.V. Kozhevnikov, A. Sinnema, R.J. Janssen, K. Pamin, H. van Bekkum, Catal. Lett. 30 (1995)241. M.J. Verhoef, J.A. Peters, H. van Bekkum, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 27 (1999) 365.
134 [89] [90] [91] [92] [93] [94] [95] [96] [97] [98] [99] [100] [101] [102] [103] [104] [105] [106] [107] [108] [109] [110] [Ill] [112] [113] [114] [115] [116] [117] [118]
W.M. van Rhijn, D.E. de Vos, B.F. Sels, W.D. Bossaert, P.A. Jacobs, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun. (1998)317. W.M. van Rhijn, D.E. de Vos, W.D. Bossaert, J. Bullen, B.Wouters, P. Grobet, P.A. Jacobs, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 117(1998) 183. M.J. Verhoef, P.J. Kooyman, J.C. van der Waal, M.S. Rigutto, J.A. Peters, H. van Bekkum, Chem. Mater. 13(2001)683. Y. Liu, W. Zhang, T.J. Pinnavaia, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 49 (2001) 1255. P. Waller, Z. Shan, L. Marchese, G. Tartaglione, W. Zhou, J.C. Jansen, T. Maschmeyer, Chem. Eur. J. 10(2004)4970. W. Guo, L. Huang, P. Deng. Z. Xue, Q. Li, Microporous Mesoporous Mater. 44-45 (2001) 427. D.T. On, S. Kaliaguine, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 40 (2001) 3248. J. Agundez, I. Diaz, C. Marques-Alvares, E. Sastre, J. Perez-Pariente, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 142 (2002) 1267. J. Agundez, I. Diaz, C. Marques-Alvares, J. Perez-Pariente, E. Sastre, Chem. Commun. (2000) 150. Y. Liu, W. Zhang, T.J. Pinnavaia, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 122 (2000) 7891. Y. Liu, T.J. Pinnavaia, Chem. Mater. 14 (2002) 3. Z.Zhang, Y. Han, L. Zhu, R. Wang, Y. Yu, S. Qiu, D. Zhao, F.-S. Xiao, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 40(2001)1258. P Prokesova, S. Mintova, J. Cejka, T. Bein, Mater. Sci. Eng. C 23 (2003) 1001. J. Perez-Pariente, I. Diaz, J. Agundez, Compt. Rend, in press (2005). K.H. Rhodes, S.A. Davis, F. Caruso, B. Zhang, S. Mann, Chem. Mater. 12 (2000) 2832. Y.-J. Lee, J.S. Lee, Y.S. Park, K.B. Yoon, Adv. Mater. 13 (2001) 1259. K.J. Balkus Jr., A. Khanmamedova, A.G. Gabrielov, S.I. Zones, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 101 (1996)1341. K.J. Balkus Jr., A. Khanmamedova, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 110 (1997) 1007. C.W. Jones, S.I. Zones, M.E. Davis, Appl. Catal. A 181 (1999) 289. J. Martinez-Triguero, M.J. Diaz-Cabanas, M.A. Camblor, V. Fornes, T.L.M. Maesen, A. Corma, J. Catal. 182 (1999) 463. P. Botella, A. Corma, M.T. Navarro, F. Rey, G. Sastre, J. Catal. 217 (2003) 406. A. Corma, V. Fornes, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 135 (2001) 73. M.J. Climent, A. Corma, A. Velty, Appl. Catal. A 263 (2004) 155. L. Kaluza, M. Zdrazil, N. Zilkova and J. Cejka, Catal. Commun. 3 (2002) 151. H. Balcar, R. Hamtil, N. Zilkova and J. Cejka, Catal. Lett. 97 (2004) 25. J. Cejka, N. Zilkova, J. Rathousky, A. Zukal and J. Jagiello, Langmuir, 20 (2004) 7532. C.H. Christensen, K. Johannsen, I. Schmidt and C.H. Christensen, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 125 (2003) 13370. P Prokesova, N. Zilkova, S. Mintova, T. Bein, J. Cejka, Appl. Catal. A, 281 (2005) 85. S. Mintova, Collect. Czech. Chem. Commun. 68 (2003) 2032. Z.T. Zhang, Y. Han, F.S. Xiao, S.L. Qiu, L. Zhu, R.W. Wang, Y. Yu, Z. Zhang, B.S. Zhou, Y.Q. Wang, H.P. Sun, D.Y. Zhao, Y. Wei, J. Am. Chem. Soc. 123 (2001) 5014.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
135
Zeolite membranes - A short overview A. Julbe Institut Europeen des Membranes de Montpellier (UMR 5635 CNRS-ENSCM-UMII) UMII (CC 047), Place Eugene Bataillon, 34095 Montpellier cedex 5, France
1. INTRODUCTION 2. MEMBRANE SYNTHESIS METHODS 2.1. Polymer-zeolite composite membranes 2.2. Supported zeolite membranes 2.2.1. In-situ direct crystallization 2.2.2. Dry or wet gel conversion method 2.2.3. Seeding and secondary growth 2.3. Template removal and formation defects 3. MODIFICATION OF ZEOLITE MEMBRANES 4. CHARACTERIZATION METHODS 4.1. Static characterization methods 4.2. Dynamic characterization methods 5. TRANSPORT MECHANISMS AND MODELING 6. APPLICATIONS OF ZEOLITE MEMBRANES 6.1. Pervaporation 6.2. Gas and vapour separations 6.3. Membrane reactors 6.4. Sensors 7. INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENTS AND LIMITATIONS 8. CONCLUSIONS REFERENCES
1. INTRODUCTION Most of the classical batch separation processes involving zeolite pellets require the sequential regeneration of the adsorbing material. Because a zeolite membrane can potentially sieve out molecules in a continuous way, the development of zeolite membranes has attracted the attention of many research and industrial groups, since the beginning of the 80's. Zeolite membranes are the only membranes able to perform Angstrom-sharp separations and which are stable both thermally and in organic solvents. However, although about 152 zeolitic framework types have been indexed by the IZA, only about 15 structure types were prepared as membranes. A number of examples is reported in Table 1.
136 Table 1 Main zeolite and zeolite-related membrane structures studied in the literature Recent Oxygen Channel Max. Remarks Zeolite type Example of referen number at system "Pore" applications window ces size (A) (*) 1-2 SOD 6 2.8 GS, PV "Zeo-like" structure 3D CO2/CH4 separation 3-4 CHA 8 3.8 GS SAPO-34, SSZ-13 "Zeo-like" structure 3D 4.2 PV, MR, 5-9 LTA 8 Commercial (Mitsui) Na-A (GS?) 2D 4.4 CO2/CH4 separation 10-11 DDR GS 8 Decadodecasil 3R Steam resistant, Studied by NGK 12-18 MFI 10 3D 5.6 GS, PV, VP, MR Silicalite-1 Hydrophobic ZSM-5 Hydrophilic FER 10 2D 5.4 PV, GS 19 ZSM-35 3D MEL 10 5.4 PV 20 ZSM-11 12 FAU 3D 7.4 PV, GS, MR (X : Si/Al= 1-1.5) 21-23 Na-X, Na-Y (Y : Si/Al > 2) 12 ID 24-27 MOR 7.0 PV, GS Acid resistant & hydrophilic BEA (Beta) 12 3D 7.6 PV, GS, MR 28-29 * PV : Pervaporation; VP: Vapor Permeatiorl, GS: Gas separation; MR : Membrane Reactor The MFI membranes have been the most largely investigated, due to their large attractive industrial properties: suitable pore sizes, with high thermal and chemical stability, easy synthesis and possible modification of its chemical composition. These membranes are typically suitable for the separation of commercially important species, such as p-xylene from its isomers. The insertion of Ti in the silicalite-1 structure has also generated a number of studies on TS-1 [30] or ETS-10 membranes [31,32]. Other elements were also inserted in MFI such as Fe [33], B [34], Ge [35], V [30,36]. Pt was inserted in FAU for catalytic applications [21]. A number of other zeolite membrane systems have been reported such as ANA [37], GIS (P) [38], T [39], TON (ZSM-22) [40], KFI, or LTL (L), but also phase mixtures or composite membranes. A number of zeolite-related materials such as MCM [41], A1PO [42], or pillared clays [43] have been investigated as well. The annual number of Elsevier publications on "zeolite membranes" increased from 4 in 1991 to over 50 in 2004. A large number of book chapters and review articles have been published during the last five years, entirely or partially dedicated to zeolite membranes and films [44-55]. An international conference is also specifically dedicated to zeolite films and membranes. Initiated in Gifu (Japan) in 1998, its second edition was held in 2001 in Delft (The Netherlands) and its 3 rd edition (3 rd Int. Zeolite Membrane Meeting) was held in Breckenridge (CO-USA) in 2004. A website is also dedicated to Zeolite and Molecular Sieve Membranes [56]. The objective of this review article is to provide students and young researchers in the field, with a general but relatively short overview of the current state of the art in zeolite membranes. It will cover zeolite membrane preparation, characterization and main applications, while referring to the recent literature. For more detailed reviews, the lecturer will refer to a
137 listing of specialized articles, specialist reviews, and book chapters which have been published over the last five years [44-55]. 2. MEMBRANE SYNTHESIS METHODS There are roughly three types of zeolite membranes: polymer-zeolite composite membranes, self-supported zeolite membranes and supported zeolite membranes. Although the first type has still a number of niche applications, the latter are by far the most largely studied and will be the most largely detailed here. Free standing compact zeolite film with limited thickness (<1 ^m) have been also grown on temporary supports like Teflon® or cellulose [57,58] but this concept can not be easily up-scaled because of the poor permeability and high fragility of the derived self-supported zeolite membranes. 2.1. Polymer-zeolite composite membranes One of the first zeolite based membranes were composite membranes, obtained by dispersion of zeolite crystals in dense polymeric films in order to make "zeolite filled polymeric membranes" [59,60,61]. These membranes have been developed at the end of the 80's for both gas separation and pervaporation. The clogging of zeolite pores by the matrix and the quality of the interface between the zeolite crystals and the polymer matrix (non-selective diffusion pathways) were key points. Although this concept and related studies are relatively old, a number of research teams are still working in this field [62,63], because of the constant improvements in membrane material science. The recent discovery of zeolite colloidal seeds and the evolution of both zeolite surface grafting and ceramic/polymer interfaces knowledge are typical recent advances which are attractive for the development of improved zeolite-filled polymeric membranes. The pervaporation team of the US Environmental Protection Agency is currently developing zeolite filled polymeric membranes with improved ethanol/water selectivities [64]. Their studies include the development of silicalite-l-Poly(DiMethylSiloxane) membranes with optimised amount of zeolite in the membranes and optimised zeolite particle sizes. Polymer-zeolite composite membranes are also studied as interphase contactors in liquid phase oxidation processes [65] or for improving the properties of Nafion® in fuel cells applications [66]. 2.2. Supported zeolite membranes Various types of supports have been used for the synthesis of supported zeolite membranes, whose shape, chemical composition, porous structure (pore size, porosity), micro-, macro-structure and pre-treatment can influence considerably the membrane characteristics. Typical examples of porous support suppliers mentioned in the zeolite membrane literature are reported in Table 2. C1AI2O3 is by far the most largely studied, although other ceramic materials were also reported such as YA1 2 O 3 [67], TiO2 [68], SiC [69], or mullite [70]. Metals (essentially stainless steel (SS)) are also largely considered because of their lower price and easier sealing [3,32,71,72]. Laser perforated stainless steel [73] and etched silicon [74] have been also recently considered for the development of micromembranes A number of groups also considered carbon [75] or glass [76] supports but their poor resistance to either oxygen or basic media is restrictive. Indeed when selecting the support, its thermal and chemical resistances to the synthesis media, to the thermal treatment or to the application conditions, as well as the difference in thermal expansion coefficients between the support and the zeolite layer are important parameters which have to be considered. Depending on whether the substrate surface is hydrophilic or hydrophobic, the amount of surface OH and its stability in high pH conditions,
138 different results are obtained. The surface roughness is also an important parameter which influences the quality of the layer (flat supports can even be polished). In order to promote a good adhesion of the membrane layer, the supports are subjected to various cleaning treatments (e.g. washing with water, acetone, acids, bases, sometimes assisted with ultra-sonic treatment) to remove loose particles, adsorbed salts, or organic compounds. Subsequent to cleaning the supports can be stored in water to prevent adsorption of organics from the atmosphere [51]. Table 2 Typical example of inorganic porous support suppliers mentioned in the zeolite membrane literature Support Supplier Material Support shape Typical pore sizes (nm) Pall-Exekia (USA) Tube 200, 800 aAl 2 O 3 Tube 5 yAl2O3 Inocermic GmbH (Germany) Tube 60, 100, 1900, 3000 aAl 2 O 3 Disk 60, 1800 aAl 2 O 3 Tube 5,60 yAi 2 o 3 Poco Graphite (USA) Tube 700 aAl 2 O 3 Tube 200 Sulzer ChemTech LTD aAl 2 O 3 (Switzerland) Tube 5 yAl2O3 GKN Sinter Metals Filters GmbH Disk 100, 200 aAl 2 O 3 (Germany) Disk 270 ss NGK Insulators Co. (Japan) Tube 100, 200 aAl 2 O 3 Mott Metallurgical Company (USA) SS Tube 200, 500 NOK Corp. (Japan) Tube 120-150, 150-170 aA! 2 O 3 Nikkato Corp. (Japan) Tube 1300 aAl 2 O 3 Golden Technologies (USA) Tube 200 aAl 2 O 3 US filters (USA) Tube 100 aAl 2 O 3 Trumem international (USA) Plate SS 2000-500 Dong-su Co. (Korea) Tube SS 900 Most of the studies have been performed on flat (discs) or tubular supports. It is now a current challenge to increase the surface to volume ratio in modules (from a few m2/m3 to more than 500 m2/m3) by using capillaries [77], hollow fibres [78] or honeycomb supports [69,79,80]. The influence of the support layer characteristics on the flux limitations is also an important concern for industrial applications [81]. There are three main routes to synthesize continuous supported zeolite membranes: the "insitu direct crystallization", the "dry or wet gel conversion method" and the "seeding and secondary growth". 2.2.1. In-situ direct crystallization The first investigations related to the development of supported zeolite membranes concerned the in-situ direct crystallization of zeolites on top of a support, by direct contact of the support with the precursor solution. The method was initially patented in 1987 by H. Suzuki [82]. The membrane is synthesized under autogenous pressure, by both the nucleation and growth of zeolite crystals on the surface of the support grains. A relatively thin zeolite layer crystallizes on the surface and/or in the pores of the porous support. One of the most important problem with this method is the long induction period and the homogeneous nucleation which often alter the membrane quality. The sol compositions which reveal successful for making supported
139
membranes are usually different from the classical ones leading to powders. The influence of the type of precursor, sol composition and support type are discussed in [51] ; examples of successful sol compositions for making MFI, A type and Y membranes are also given. Clear sols are often used in order to limit homogeneous nucleation. In the case of MFI membranes, the molar ratios OH7SiO2, TPA+/SiO2, Na+/SiO2, Al/Si, and H2O/SiO2 strongly influence the membrane characteristics. The support type and pore size can influence the growth of the zeolite material on top of the support or within its pores [36,83]. The separating layer of the final membrane can then be located either outside of the support pores (non infiltrated membrane) or inside the pores (infiltrated composite membranes) as shown in Fig. 1. If the starting sol becomes below supersaturation before the membrane is fully developed, growth must be repeated with a fresh sol. Two or three hydrothermal syntheses are often required to get "good quality" membranes. In many cases, large quantity of non connected zeolite crystals can be observed on the surface of infiltrated composite membranes, after several synthesis steps. The methods for evaluating the membrane quality will be detailed in the "Characterization" section. In the case of MFI membranes, a very simple method can be used at this step: the membrane is washed, dried at about 150-200 °C and tested by single gas permeation (He or N2). As far as the TPA+ ions are blocking the zeolite channels, no gas permeance should be detected if there are no defects. 2.2.2. Dry or wet gel conversion method The second type of method includes the so-called dry gel [84] and wet gel [85] conversions. Since its first description by Xu et al. in 1990 [86] for the synthesis of MFI membrane, the method principle has been extended to ANA, MOR and FER [87,88]. It involves the deposition of an amorphous aluminosilicate gel on the support and its subsequent crystallization under vapours of triethylamine, ethylenediamine and water. When the templating agent is not included in the gel, the crystallization is said to occur by "Vapour Phase Transport" (VPT) [86,89]. The method is called "steam-assisted crystallization" when the dry gel already contains the templating agent [90]. This type of synthesis method allows to avoid homogeneous nucleation, it has also the advantages of improved controllability, minimal waste generation, and reduced chemical consumption, that are desirable for large-scale production of zeolite membranes. However, the large volume shrinkage during the transformation from gel to zeolite often leads to defects in the films. 2.2.3. Seeding and secondary growth The third method, called "seeding and secondary growth" involves the growth of a layer of seed crystals previously nucleated and deposited on the support. This method has been first investigated for growing LTA supported membranes, whose direct synthesis from a sol in contact with a support was highly difficult because of the absence of an SDA (Surface Directing Agent) [91]. The seeding and secondary growth method is now considered as one of the most attractive and flexible approaches for orienting the formation of consolidated thin membranes including A, L, ZSM-5, SOD, FAU and highly oriented silicalite-1 films [92-96]. Bypassing the nucleation and going directly to crystal growth eliminate a serious source of irreproducibility due to adsorbed species or support dissolution, it expands the range of synthesis composition and allows the use dilute sols. The derived membranes are generally highly permeable and selective.
140
Fig. 1. Schematic representations of a thin top layer membrane (Al) and a composite infiltrated
membrane (Bl) on/in asymmetric supports. The corresponding FE-SEM observations of MFI membranes on/in an aAl2O3 support (Pall-Exekia, with 200 nm top-layer pore size) are shown in A2 (seeding/secondary growth) and B2 (in-situ direct crystallisation). The synthesis of seeds (suspension of colloidal crystals) is generally performed at low temperature according to methods reported 10 years ago by various groups for silicalite-1 [97,98]. The seed size is usually in the range 0.05-2 |^m. Depending on the selected temperature, the induction period and synthesis can be very long and can reach a few months. Two steps synthesis allows to control the nueleation and growing steps and consequently the seed size, homogeneity and yield [99,100]. Discrete colloidal monodispersed zeolite seeds are synthesized from clear homogeneous solutions and purified by repeated centrifugation and redispersion. The solid content and the pH of the seed suspensions are adjusted. In most cases the suspensions are filtered and the experiments are carried out in a laminar flow bench to reduce the amount of dust. The size, homogeneity, concentration and dispersion of the seeds are important parameters which directly impact both the penetration of seeds within the support and the quality of the final membrane. Commercial zeolite crystals can also be used and grinded to obtain small seeds [92]. Coating the support with the seeds is a critical task. Different strategies are proposed in the literature. The supports can be seeded by simple contact (deep coating for a few minutes) with a suspension of zeolite crystals at an appropriate pH, and subsequent washing to keep only a surface monolayer [51]. Fig. 2 shows a thick layer of silicalite-1 seeds on CCAI2O3 support after 3 h contact with the seed suspension. The seeding can be performed under vacuum [102] or by electrophoretic deposition in aqueous or non-aqueous medium [103]. The latter method has been applied to the rapid synthesis of A-type zeolite membranes. Two strategies can be used for an electrostatic attachment of the seeds to the support: either a fine-tuned surface charge by pH control and measurement of the support zeta-potential or the adsorption of positively charged polymers [104], and immersion in a suspension whose pH is such that the seed particles are negatively
141
charged. The quality of the seed suspension is important to avoid the deposition of aggregates on the support. The seeded support is then heated at about 150-200 °C to bind the particles on the surface by condensation of hydroxyl groups. A higher temperature (typically 400 °C) is needed when a cationic polymer has been used.
Fig. 2. CCAI2O3 support (200 nm pore size) covered with a thick and close pack layer of silicalite-1 seeds (3 h contact time) and dried for 6 hours at 155 °C [101].
For operating the secondary growth, the seeded support is hydrothermally treated in a diluted synthesis mixture (with or without template) to grow the seed crystals, resulting in a compact zeolite film. A simple steaming of the seed layer can also partially consolidate the zeolite membrane by local dissolution and recrystallization processes in the seed layer. The films are finally dried or calcined if an SDA was used. The MFI system is orthorhombic (or even monoclinic after calcination). Its multidimensional channel network is an excellent model system for fundamental studies related to the influence of preferred crystal orientation on membrane performance. A schematic representation of the channel directions and specific crystal orientations is shown in Fig. 3. Obviously it can be predicted that c orientation is less favourable to high fluxes than b orientation. The habit of MFI crystals is determined by the hydrothermal conditions. Large differences in preferred orientation can be obtained by using different sol concentration, hydrothermal conditions, seeding density, seed sizes and type of SDA [105]. The growth of the crystals in the film is competitive: crystals oriented with the fastest growing direction perpendicular to the substrate surface are able to grow both perpendicular to the substrate and in the lateral direction. These crystals dominate in thick films and the number of crystal faces per unit area decrease with increasing film thickness. A number of growth models have been proposed, including those explaining oblique preferred orientations ; most of them are reviewed in [106]. Without any specific precaution, the MFI membranes are polycrystalline, intergrown and with different preferred crystal orientations. Several strategies have been used to prepare oriented zeolite seed layers such as slow dip-coating [107], seed deposition after cationic polymer adsorption [104], adsorption of positively charged additives on the seeds to compensate the negative surface charge of the crystal faces and change their orientation on the support [108], and finally covalent bonding on functionalised surfaces [109]. The implementation of crystal shape engineering by use of SDA polycations (dimerTetraPropylAmmonium or trimer-TPA instead of regular TPA) as shape/habit modifiers has been clearly demonstrated in [110]. The b-oriented 1 um thick silicalite-1 membranes revealed excellent performance for 0,/5-xylene separation (high p- and low o-xylene fluxes). The morphology and separation performance of both c- and b-oriented MFI membranes are shown in Fig. 4 [110].
142
Fig. 3. Schematic representation of MFI crystal orientation along c or b axis on a porous support.
In order to avoid the infiltration of seeds in the support and to develop ultra-thin membranes (typically 500 nm thick) with a high permeability, a masking techniques has been recently developed in Lulea University [111]. A solution of poly methyl methacrylate (PMMA) in acetone was applied and dried on the support top surface. The interior of the support was subsequently filled with wax and the protective PMMA layer was dissolved in acetone. The masked support was then seeded with a monolayer of silicalite-1 crystals before being submitted to the classical hydrothermal and calcination steps.
Fig. 4. ZSM-5 membrane performance in xylene isomer separation, p-xylene, o-xylene permeance and mixture separation factor (SF) are plotted versus temperature of permeation for typical c-oriented (A) and b-oriented (B) films [110],
In order to accelerate the synthesis of both zeolite seeds and membranes, microwave-assisted hydrothermal synthesis (MW-HT) revealed an attractive method. Colloidal zeolite seeds can be successfully prepared by MW-HT synthesis [100,112,113]. Starting from a seeded support,
143
the MW-assisted secondary growth yields good quality MFI membranes within a few hours, while limiting the dissolution of the DA^C^ support. Typical examples of MFI membranes prepared by this method are shown in Fig. 5. The membranes were obtained very rapidly, i.e. after a synthesis time as short as 30-60 min, at 120-180 °C. Depending on the synthesis conditions, the membrane thickness varies typically from 200 nm to a few microns, with glassy like or columnar morphologies respectively. The performance of these promising membranes which are not yet optimized is still under study [101].
Fig. 5. FESEM observations of the MFI membranes prepared at different temperatures, by MWassisted secondary growth, from a layer of MW derived silicalite-1 seeds [101].
A number of other strategies have been investigated in order to improve the quality (selectivity and fluxes) or the synthesis efficiency of zeolite membranes by pre-treatment of the support. Most of these treatments are listed in [49], and include laser ablation, utilisation of diffusion barriers to limit sol infiltration, oxidation of stainless-steel supports, deposition of iron oxide to favour heterogeneous nucleation on the support and the use of acid attacks to activate the surface. A series of original synthesis strategies has been also reported recently such as flow-through reactors for the homogeneous synthesis of zeolite membranes [77], centrifugal force field [114] or electrophoresis [115] for the preparation of A-type membranes, and pulse laser deposition (PLD) for the secondary growth of oriented MCM-22 membranes [116]. 2.3. Template removal and formation defects When the membrane synthesis requires a template, it has to be removed from the zeolite pores. Chemical leaching or ion exchange with ammonium ions is only possible for big pore sizes (e.g. MOR, Beta, MCM). In most cases, and namely for the MFI structure, the template is removed by thermal treatment in strictly controlled conditions (atmosphere, heating rate, temperature and duration). We have to note that an efficient and gentle low temperature ozone treatment was recently proposed for organic template removal from MFI zeolite membranes [117]. The removal of the template molecules by calcination is often responsible for the formation of cracks which are detrimental to the membrane selectivity. The formation of defects during template removal has been largely studied in MFI-type membranes and also in individual large crystals [118]. A very low heating rate (typically 0.1-0.5 °C/min) up to 400 °C is generally recommended in order to limit the formation of defects in supported polycrystalline MFI membranes. The orientation of the MFI crystals seems also to influence the membrane integrity during the thermal treatment [119]. The formation of cracks is attributed to a compression stress within the film during the cooling step, when the zeolite film is firmly attached to the support [120]. Indeed, most of the silico-aluminate zeolites have a reversed thermal expension coefficient compared to the classical behaviour of ceramic or metallic supports: zeolites contract
144
when heated and expand when cooled. The quality/integrity of the supported zeolite membrane is generally improved by selecting a suitable support and temperature program. An other method to limit the influence of differential expansion coefficients is to grow the zeolite crystals within the pores of the support. This "pore plugging method" [36,83] leads to infiltrated membranes (figure IB) which can withstand heating cooling cycles up to 500 °C without any modification of their properties. It is not difficult with this method to avoid support dissolution and to orient the zeolite crystals. Obviously the growth of zeolite crystals within the support pores limits the membrane permeability, but a precise control of the synthesis conditions, support thickness and pore sizes allows to limit the apparent membrane thickness to a few microns and to get substantial permeability. The contradictory findings which have been reported concerning the influence of infiltration on the membrane selectivity [51 ] are attributed to the difficult comparison of thicknesses, crystallinity and composition of the membranes which are usually modified by a partial support dissolution. An other approach to solve the problem of cracks is to repair them after they have formed. This can be done namely by a selective coking procedure [121]. However in most cases, the increased membrane selectivity is coupled with a substantial decrease of the membrane flux. 3. MODIFICATION OF ZEOLITE MEMBRANES Among the numerous strategies which have been adopted to produce zeolite membranes with either a reduced number of defects or with specific properties, a series of modification techniques have been tested. Most of them are listed in [49]. One can namely mention isomorphous substitutions of e.g. Al, Fe, B, or Ge in the structure, ion exchange, silylation, atomic layer deposition (ALD), chemical vapor deposition (CVD), coking, catalytic cracking, and reactions with adsorption sites in the zeolite structure. Silylation is very attractive for increasing the selectivity of zeolite membrane to H2 [122]. MFI and SAPO-34 membranes have been recently modified by silylation and atomic layer deposition (ALD) to create H2 selective membranes [123]. The multistep synthesis is classically used to repair defects or to increase the zeolite membrane thickness. This technique also allows to superimpose layers with different zeolite structures. We have also to notice that for certain zeolite structures such as FAU or LTA, when the synthesis duration is too long, other phases can appear by transformation of the initial zeolite structure. FAU or MFI membranes can also be modified in order to allow an optical switching of gas transport [124]. The switch (guest) is azobenzene and acts as a nanovalve which is inserted in FAU or MFI membranes (hosts). The flux of single components through the trans-state azobenzene modified membrane is increased by a factor 3 to 6 compared to the cis-state membrane. 4. CHARACTERIZATION METHODS The zeolite membranes quality and the development of methods able to rapidly identify the defects are key-factors for large scale applications. A large number of static and dynamic methods can be used to evaluate the quality of membranes [125]. Static methods allow to study the physico-chemical characteristics of the membrane material. Dynamic methods allow the detection of defects affecting the transport properties and consequently the membrane performance. For zeolite membranes the quality of the adhesion between the zeolite layer and the support, the orientation of zeolite crystals, the layer thickness, and the number and quality of
145 crystal boundaries are key parameters. Defects can occur from an incomplete growth of crystals, a non uniform seeding, a difference between the thermal expansion coefficients of the support and the zeolite, or from the development of stresses during the calcination step. An amorphous or a crystalline phase can also form within the support pores during the synthesis and modifies its transport properties. Depending on the selected application (high or low temperature, for gas, vapour or liquid separations) the influence of defect size, number, location and connectivity are very different. 4.1. Static characterization methods Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM), coupled with energy dispersive X-ray analysis is the most classical method used to study zeolite membranes. It gives access to the homogeneity, morphology, adhesion, infiltration and thickness of the zeolite layer. Crystal sizes can be also evaluated (the length of crystal boundaries influences the permeation properties). HR-TEM and coupled analysis are useful to study the zeolite structure and composition, also within the pores of the support. Atomic Force Microscopy can also be used to study the growth of zeolite films. X-ray diffraction, including grazing incidence XRD, is needed to study the crystalline phases and the orientation of zeolite crystals grown on supports. Gas adsorption (N2, Kr) can be used to estimate the relative quantity of zeolite deposited on the support (BET- or Langmuir equation). When a dense substrate is used, ellipsometry gives the film thickness and void volume fraction. Absorption spectroscopies such as FTIR, are adapted to study the membrane material short range structure. The novel extension of Fluorescent Confocal Optical Microscopy (FCOM) has also to be underlined as a qualitative, non-destructive, three dimensional imaging tool, to view polycrystalline features of MFI membranes. The coupling of this technique with simultaneous reflectance and SEM provides a critical link between the grain structure of MFI membranes and the more qualitative FCOM images. The selective adsorption of large dye molecules (diameter-tuned) within the grain boundaries throughout the membrane thickness, allows to evidence "quantitatively" non-zeolite pores [126]. This very promising technique has yet to be fully explored. 4.2. Dynamic characterization methods Gas permeation measurements with single components or mixtures need to be performed for a real evaluation of zeolite membranes quality, although a large number of contradictory results can be found in literature depending on the conditions used for these measurements. First of all the membrane must be carefully outgassed at high temperature and/or under vacuum before the measurements (in order to eliminate CO2, H2O, organic solvent vapours...). The type of cell and measurement conditions (Wicke-Kallenbach, sweep gas, side of gas feed...) can also influence the results [127] as well as the support characteristics. The single gas permeance of He, H2, N2, O2, Ar, CO2, CH4, C3H8, SF6, butane, hexane, or xylene isomers is classically studied in order to evaluate the quality of zeolite membranes and their molecular sieving or shape selective transport properties. Transient gas phase permeation also allows to measure the effective membrane thickness non-destructively [128]. A series of more sophisticated permeation techniques have been recently proposed in order to better characterise the quality of the membrane and to evaluate qualitatively the contribution of non-zeolite pores to the transport. A number of methods derived from permporometry [125] are under study [111,129]. The method used in [111] consists in measuring the permeance of an inert gas such as He through a MFI membrane, while increasing the partial pressure iplpo) of a condensable gas which can enter into the zeolite pores, such as w-hexane (0/dneHc = 0.43 nm). Zeolite pores are then blocked first by «-hexane adsorption, and when the proportion of n-
146
hexane increases, larger and larger pores are blocked by condensation and become unavailable for He transport (Fig. 6). Around plp0 = 1, essentially macroporous defects participate to He transport. The Kelvin equation can be used to estimate roughly the size of defects, keeping in mind that the Kelvin approximation breaks down for micropores. Typically «-hexane activities of 0.025 and 0.85 correspond to pore sizes of respectively 1.1 nm and 24 nm. Then the He permeance atp/p0 « 0.025 can be used as an estimate of the total permeance via defects larger than micropores [111].
Fig. 6. Principle of permporometry for the dynamic characterisation of zeolite membranes. When the partial pressure of n-hexane (p/po) increases, it blocks first zeolite pores and then larger and larger defects sizes, thus blocking progressively the permeation of He.
Other groups also work on similar principles for the characterisation of zeolite membranes by the so-called Dynamic Desorption Porosimetry or by dynamic desorption of adsorbing species [130]. The single gas permeance ratios N2/SF6 or H2/SF6 are often considered as representative of the zeolite membrane quality. However these values can be quite low even for high quality membranes [131]. Indeed, these ratios are affected by the defect distribution but can also depend on other factors such as the applied feed pressure, the film thickness and the support type. For example the N2/SF6 permeance ratio increases with pressure due to non-linear adsorption of SF6 and also increases with the film thickness due to the mass transfer resistance of the support. In the same way, the ideal or mixture selectivity 2-butane/w-butane is often considered as a good indication of the membrane quality, but varies largely (from 10 up to 200) even for good quality membranes. It is then difficult to use only one of these criteria to compare zeolite membranes.
147
An other interesting characteristic of zeolite membranes is their single gas permeation behaviour at high temperature. Once again, contradictory results were reported in the literature for apparently good quality MFI membranes. Most of the gas permeation studies at high temperature fit with the curve ABCDi reported in Fig. 7, i.e. with the permeance increasing with temperature above about 300 °C [36, 132].
Fig. 7. Schematic evolution of the permeance of single gas through MFI membranes, as a function of temperature. ABC: Activated configurational diffusion, AB: the mobility of adsorbed species increases and occupancy decreases, B: the increase in mobility cannot compensate the decrease in occupancy. C: adsorption is negligible. CD, and CD2 :activated transport through zeolite pores and/or through grain boundaries (?).
This behaviour was described by an activated transport yielding a "Knudsen like" selectivity at high temperature but does not fit with the classical behaviour of fluids at high temperature in zeolite channels. Indeed a continuous decrease of the permeation with temperature should rather be expected for a zeolite membrane made with only one single crystal. A possible hypothesis for explaining an increase of permeance with temperature, while maintaining a good selectivity at low temperature, could be related to the reversible and continuous contraction of zeolite crystals when temperature increases. Such a contraction creates spaces between the crystals, which become available to the gas phase. This behaviour seems to occur for both top-layers [132] and infiltrated membranes [36] and seems to be enhanced by the crystallinity of the zeolite material, i.e. when the synthesis and thermal treatment are performed at higher temperature. The number and quality of crystal boundaries seem to orient either an ABCDi or an ABCD2 behaviour but does not seem to influence directly the separation performance of the membranes at low temperature. As an example, the separation IVw-butane is compared in Fig. 8 for two infiltrated membranes prepared from similar sol compositions but with slightly different synthesis conditions (synthesis temperature and thermal treatment). In both cases, the diffusion of H2 is blocked at low temperature by the strong adsorption M-C4H10. When the temperature increases the quantity of adsorbed n-butane decreases and the selectivity is reverse, in favour of H2. Such a behaviour is classical and was reported earlier by Geus et al. for a CH^w-butane mixture [134]. When there is no more adsorption, the membrane selectivity for the mixture come close to the value for single gases. However the permeances continuously increase for the membrane in Fig. 8a, although they
148 decrease for the one in Fig. 8b. Specific studies have still to be performed in order to clarify the origin(s) and impact(s) of such opposite behaviours at high temperature.
Fig. 8. Separation performance for a mixture H2/«-butane as a function of temperature for two MFI/aAl2O3 infiltrated membranes prepared by the « pore plugging method »: a) membrane prepared at 185 °C for 3 days and fired at 600 °C in air [36], b) membrane prepared at 170 °C for 3 days and fired at 500 °C with 5 % O2 by the group of J.A. Dalmon [133].
5. TRANSPORT MECHANISMS AND MODELING Most of the separation applications of zeolite membranes are based on preferential adsorption, differencial diffusion rates or molecular sieving effects. Key parameters for transport in zeolites by surface transport and micropore diffusion include temperature, pressure, molecular weight, kinetic molecular diameter, pore diameter, molecular collision free path, heat of gas adsorption, and thermal activation energies for both surface and microporous diffusion. Adsorption is a nonactivated, exothermic phenomena which is driven by fugacity. It depends on the adsorption enthalpy (-AHajs) and on the molecular size of the adsorbate. It is a competitive phenomena. Diffusion is an activated process which depends on (-AHa{is), on the molecular size of the adsorbate and on the coverage. Diffusion is generally described by a Maxwell-Stefan approach and can be measured by Pulse-Field Gradient NMR, Quasi-Elastic Neutron Scattering, chromatography uptake, frequency response, or transient permeation measurements. The Maxwell-Stefan model is recognized as the most adapted for explaining the experimental results and the subtle interplay between adsorption and diffusion, as well as the coupling between species diffusion [55]. Prediction of macroscopic transport properties for diffusion of molecular species through microporous crystalline membranes is the key to the development of both classical applications, such as separations and innovative ones such as chemical sensors. However transport in zeolite is a too vast subject which will not be treated here. In addition to specialized articles, readers should also refer to review articles and book chapters such as [50-52,55]. The reference [54] reviews separations by pervaporation through zeolite membranes. Some aspects of these separations are similar to gas-phase separations, except that feed-side coverages are close to saturation during pervaporation, making competitive adsorption and molecule-molecule interaction more important during multicomponent diffusion.
149
6. APPLICATIONS OF ZEOLITE MEMBRANES The unique properties of zeolites coupled with the continuous separation properties of membranes make zeolite membranes and films attractive for a wide variety of industrial applications. When zeolites are grown as films, they offer the potential for continuous separation of industrially important gas, vapour or liquid mixtures, and can be used for applications in membrane reactors, as sensitive chemical sensors, as electrodes (for selective ion transport), for solar energy conversion, as batteries, as optical and data storage materials, or in electronic and thermoelectric applications. The inherent properties of zeolites which are attractive for membrane applications are: regular pore sizes with molecular dimensions (enabling shape or size selective catalysis or separation), a high thermal stability, acid or basic properties, hydrophilic or organophilic properties, possible ion exchange, dealuminationrealumination, isomorphous substitution, and insertion of catalytically active guests (transition metal ions, complexes or chelates, basic alkali metal or metal oxide clusters and even enzymes in ordered mesoporous materials). Zeolite membranes can potentially sieve out molecules in a continuous way. By combining their adsorption and molecular sieving properties, they are useful for the separation of mixtures containing non-adsorbing molecules, or different organic compounds, or mixtures of permanent gases/vapors or water/organics. Hydrophilic Na-A zeolite membranes have been commercialised at the end of the 90's for alcohol dehydration and solvent dewatering. Hydrophobic membranes are attractive to remove organic compounds from water, to separate organic mixtures and to remove water from acidic solutions on the lab scale. The hydrophilic or catalytic properties of zeolites are also exploited in membranes reactors for either conversion or selectivity enhancement. A large number of examples are reported in the literature [44-55] and only few of them will be reported here. 6.1. Pervaporation Pervaporation is a process in which a liquid stream -containing two or more componentscontacts one side of a non-porous or ultramicroporous membrane, while vacuum or sweep gas is applied to the other side. The components in the liquid stream sorb into the membrane, permeate through it and evaporate into the vapour phase. The fundamentals and applications of pervaporation through zeolite membranes are reviewed in [54]. Dehydration of organics is the first, and still the only, commercial application of zeolite membranes [8]. Indeed water is a small molecule {0kinetic(^2O)= 2.9 A, 0fane,,c(C2H5OH)= 4.5 A) which adsorbs very strongly on hydrophilic membranes such as LTA (window size= 4.2 A). This explains why non-zeolite pores have very little effect on the selectivity of hydrophilic membranes. Indeed these membranes behave as poorly selective gas separators (with a Knudsen selectivity only) because of a relatively high concentration of non-zeolite pores (small mesopores). The removal of organics from water with zeolite membranes is generally much less efficient as far as non-zeolite pores are highly detrimental to the currently available hydrophobic membranes (e.g. silicalite-1) which still contain silanol groups and adsorb water. The behaviour of hydrophilic and hydrophobic membranes in a pervaporation experiment for water/ethanol is sketched in Fig. 9. Organic/organic separations are generally more efficient for molecules with different dipoles and sizes.
150 A- HYDROPHILIC ZEOLITE MEMBRANE
B- HYDROPHOBIC ZEOLITE MEMBRANE
Fig. 9. Schematic representation of the contribution of both zeolitic and non-zeolitic pores in: A) hydrophilic (LTA) and, B) hydrophobic (silicalite-1) membranes during pervaporation experiments for a water/ethanol mixture.
The pervaporation-based separation processes are typically attractive for sustainable biofuel production, pollution prevention and wastewater treatment. Membrane technologies can be easily integrated into existing plants in order to separate, fractionate and concentrate contaminants or process components. Membrane technologies require minimal temperature changes and chemical additions, they operates in either continuous or batch modes, they use significantly less energy than traditional separation processes, they do not alter the chemical structure of the processed materials and they can be easily integrated into existing processes due to their modular nature and compact size. The membranes typically used for pervaporation experiments are listed in Table 1. Among the new promising membranes currently considered for more aggressive media and for more selective and long term pervaporation applications, we have to mention MOR, Ttype, ETS-10 and SOD membranes. The development of very thin, strongly hydrophobic membranes with a low number of non-zeolite pores (e.g. by masking or by changing the silanol groups) is the current challenge. 6.2. Gas and vapour separations A number of zeolite membranes have been studied for their attractive gas separation performance. A huge number of results can be found in the literature, in relation with the separation of small molecules like H2, CO2, O2, N2, CO and CH4. Separation can occur by adsorption and/or mobility. In the case of MFI, there can be no strong mobility difference or molecular sieving. As far as the adsorption differences are not important, MFI membranes do not provide high separation selectivity for these small gases [51]. In principe zeolite A with its smaller pore opening would be ideal for separation by molecular sieving but the density of defects is too high in this type of membrane. The modification of MFI membranes by catalytic cracking of silane is an attractive way to increase the membrane selectivity for H2 separation [122,123]. The transport of H2 is also studied in zeolite micromembranes [135]. On the other hand, SAPO-34 [3] and DDR [10-11] membranes revealed particularly attractive for CO2/CH4 separations. Certainly the most promising application of MFI membranes is in hydrocarbon separations. Adsorption increases with the carbon number for linear compounds and steric effect allows to separate n-butane from i-butane. Consequently at low temperature the permeance decreases when the carbon number increases and at high temperature, differences in diffusion factors
151 dominate [132]. A number of attractive separations have been considered such as the extraction of C2-C5 hydrocarbons from natural gas or the extraction of H2 from hydrocarbons in refinery streams from hydrotreating units [51]. The separation of liquid hydrocarbons such as Cs-Cs paraffins (or olefins) and aromatics such as benzene, toluene and xylene is also an attractive application of zeolite membranes. These separations are performed at relatively high temperature and/or low partial pressure (typically 10 % hydrocarbon in He carrier) so that both the feed and permeate sides are in the gaseous state. Highly selective separations were obtained between straight chains and branched alkanes with MFI membranes [16]. The linear hydrocarbons fit well in the zeolite channels, although the branched hydrocarbons have lower adsorption and much lower mobility. The model mixture is «-hexane/2,2-dimethylbutane, but more complex ternary mixtures were also studied [51]. Finally the separation of the three xylene isomers is of high industrial importance because the p-xylene is used to make terephtalic acid and the o-xylene is used for the production of phtalic anhydride. High selectivities (as high as 300) can be obtained for this separation with MFI membranes [51]. Depending on the considered gas, membrane thickness, crystal orientation and experimental conditions, the gas permeance through zeolite membranes typically lies in the range 10"5-10"9 mol.rnV.Pa" 1 . 6.3. Membrane reactors The concept of combining membranes and reactors is being explored in various configurations, which can be classified in three groups, related to the role of the membrane in the process [136]. The membrane can act as : a) an extractor : the removal of product(s) increases the reaction conversion by shifting the reaction equilibrium, b) a distributor : the controlled addition of reactant(s) limits side reactions, c) an active contactor: the controlled diffusion of reactants to the catalyst can lead to an engineered catalytic reaction zone. Typical applications of zeolite membranes in reactors include i) conversion enhancement either by equilibrium displacement (product removal) or by removal of catalyst poisons/ inhibitors and ii) selectivity enhancement either by control of residence time or by control of reactant traffic. A large number of examples are reported and discussed in [49,50,52]. Several of them are reported in Table 3. The use of a zeolite membrane as a distributor for a reactant has been attempted for the partial oxidation of alkanes such as propane to propene [137], or nbutane to maleic anhydride [138]. Limited performances were obtained because the backdiffusion of the alkane is hardly controllable with this type of microporous membrane [139]. Table 3 Examples of applications of zeolite membranes in membrane reactors. Preferential References Type of Reaction Type of zeolite permeating species membrane CONVERSION ENHANCEMEN[T- Product removal Dehydrogenation of /-butane MFI [140] H2 of ethylbenzene MFI, Fe-MFI [141] H2 Syngas production Na-A, Silicalite-1 [6,142] H2 Metathesis of C3H6 Silicalite-1 trans-2-butene [143] Esterification H2O [144,145] Na-A, T, H-ZSM-5 Ammonia synthesis [1471 ZSM-5 NH3
152
Table 3 (continued) Examples of applications of zeolite membranes in membrane reactors References Preferential Type of Reaction Type of zeolite membrane permeating species Fermentation Silicalite-1 ethanol ri49i SELECTIVITY ENHANCEMENT- Control of residence time Pt-Y [21,150] H2 + CO Oxidation of CO [151] z'-butene oligomerization Beta (-butene Conversion of methanol to olefins ZSM-5 methanol [152] [153] Ti-silicalite pollutants Photocatalytic oxidation of trichloroethylene SELECTIVITY ENHANCEMENT- Control of reactant traffic [154,155] Competitive hydrogenation of 1 - Silicalite on catalysi: reactant heptene and 3,3-dimethyl-l-butene pellets (heptene) Isomerization of paraffins Silicalite-1 unconverted [156] reactants Isomerization of xylene is also a very attractive application for MFI zeolite membranes (Fig. 10). The commercialisation of a new zeolite-based membrane is being planned by NGK Insulators for />-xylene production from other xylene isomers. p-xylene molecules which are smaller than those of m- or o-xylene, are sieved from the mixture using the membrane, thus cutting significantly the production costs [157].
Fig. 10. Schematic representation of the p-xylene selective extraction through a MFI membrane from an isomerization reactor.
The concept of zeolite membrane encapsulated catalyst (ZMEC) is an original way to use zeolite membranes in catalytic reactors [158,159]. The concept of coating catalyst particles with a selective zeolite layer can reveal useful for either increasing reactant selectivity (e.g. selective hydrogenation of linear molecules) or product selectivity (e.g. amination of methanol). It also protects the catalyst from poisoning. Polymer-zeolite composite membranes are also studied in rectors, either as interphase contactors in liquid phase oxidation processes [65] or for improving the properties of Nafion in fuel cells applications [66]. Finally reaction and separation microdevices based on zeolite membranes are now also seriously considered [160]. Lab-on-a-chip (scaled-down analog of a chemical processing plant) is becoming a familiar concept to express the miniaturization of chemical and biological analyses, with a drastic reduction of reactant consumption [161]. According to the large number
153 of studies emerging in this field in the recent literature [49], microseparators and microreactors with zeolite membranes will certainly develop very rapidly during the coming years. 6.4. Sensors Zeolite membranes and films have been employed to modify the surface of conventional chemical electrodes, or to conform different types of zeolite-based physical sensors [49]. In quartz crystal microbalances, zeolites are used to sense ethanol, NO, SO2 and water. Cantileverbased sensors can also be fabricated with zeolites as humidity sensors. The modification of the dielectric constant of zeolites by gas adsorption is also used in zeolite-coated interdigitated capacitors for sensing w-butane, NH3, NO and CO. Finally, zeolite films can be used as barriers (for ethanol, alkanes,...) for increasing the selectivity of both semiconductor gas sensors (e.g. to CO, NO2, H2) and optical chemical sensors. 7. INDUSTRIAL DEVELOPMENTS AND LIMITATIONS Industrial applications of zeolite membranes can be considered only for separations where they offer some unique advantage in terms of flux, selectivity, or thermal and chemical stability. The very high fluxes obtained with LTA membranes (typically 100 times higher than those obtained with a polyacrylonitrile membrane at the same H^O/alcohol selectivity) explain the rapid expansion of this type of application at the end of the 90s' [8]. According to a recent conference given by Prof. Kita [162], the classical synthesis method currently used by Mitsui allows to produce about 250 zeolite membranes per day. Both the LTA and T types (Na & K) membranes are now commercial and more than 80 pervaporation and vapor permeation plants are operating in Japan for the dehydration of organic liquids [163]. A typical pervaporation system, similar to the one described in [8], is shown in Fig. 11. One of the most recent applications concerns the production of fuel ethanol from cellulosic biomass by a vapour permeation/ pervaporation combined process. The required heat is only 1 200 kcal per liter of product, i.e. half of that of the classical process. Mitsui has recently installed a bio-ethanol pilot plant based on tubular LTA membranes in Brazil (3 000 liters/day) and a plant with 30 000 liters/day has been erected in India. The operating temperature is 130 °C, the feed is 93 % ethanol, the permeate is water and the membrane selectivity is 10 000. We have also to mention the very recent European alliance of The Smart Chemical Company Ltd (Great-Britain) and Inocermic GmbH (Germany) for the production of multichannel NaA zeolite membrane modules with 5.8 m . The other considered industrial applications concern MFI membranes for molecular sieving (cut-off at 5.5 A). In fact, only MFI and a few other high-Si types are really shapeselective because of their reduced number of defects. NGK Insulators announced the industrial development of both MFI membranes for xylene separation [157] and DDR-type membranes for CO2/CH4 separation [11]. One of the main problems limiting the industrial development of zeolite membranes is their low fluxes. Typically a few m3.m"2.h"'.bar"' are achieved by most of the zeolite-based membranes whose thickness has to be sufficient (currently in the range 0.5-5 urn), in order to limit the influence of non-zeolite pores. An other problem is related to the chemical stability of membranes in both acidic (Al is leached) and basic media (Si is leached). The recent developments of both MOR [31] and ETS-10 [31,32] membranes will contribute to solve this latter problem.
154
A number of technico-economic evaluations clearly show the need for the development on industrial scale of large surface area and high quality MFI membranes [164]. In parallel, research and development of new families of efficient membranes are also required. In spite of their poor hydrothermal stability, silicate and aluminosilicate mesoporous membrane materials like MCM-41 or MCM-48, are attracting much attention in industry because they give access to large calibrated and ordered pore sizes (2-10 nm). These large pores are highly favourable for surface chemistry (grafting of organic, inorganic and metallo-organic molecules, incorporation of heteroelements or transition metals in the framework structure, or by surface modification). This type of zeo-type materials are considered as potentially attractive for a large number of applications [41], including catalysis [165].
Fig. 11. Pervaporation system from Mitsui & Co, a) pilot containing 8 modules with 10 m2 of zeolite membrane in each of them, b) Modular unit containing 10 m2 of zeolite membrane. (From http://www.mitsui.com/Dallas/zeolite. This web site is now closed).
The cost of the support element and the lengthy steps involved in zeolite film synthesis makes zeolite membranes very expensive compared to the well established polymeric membranes. MFI membranes are relatively expensive and their price (about 5.000 €/m2) is typically due by 50% to the support and by 50 % to chemicals. Consequently the development of template-free synthesis on cheaper supports (multi-channels, ceramic foils/plates, capillaries, hollow fibers) is seriously considered, in parallel with the development of continuous, automatic, reliable, and reproducible production methods. For high temperature applications of zeolite membranes the problem of module sealing has also to be considered. Gas-tight sealing of membranes at low temperature is classically performed with polymeric o-rings including Viton®, Kalrez®, although Teflon®, graphite, or
155
water-cooled polymer rings have to be used at high temperature. The full ceramic module currently developed by CEPAration-TNO is a smart attractive concept for high temperature applications, although studies of module reliability under extreme temperature cycling and vibrations will be required. 8. CONCLUSION Zeolite membranes have clearly demonstrated a high efficiency to carry out separations that are not attainable by conventional methods. Even if our understanding of the formation of zeolite structures on porous supports is still poor, the first zeolite membranes (NaA) are already commercialized at large scale for pervaporation applications. A new generation of affordable membranes with improved quality, higher flux and long term stability will be soon available, thank to the increasing interest of industry in this field, for applications in liquid, vapor and gas media. Nevertheless, the control and fine tuning of the properties of the zeolitecontaining membrane configurations remain a challenge. Indeed, despite the use of improved methodology, it is still often difficult to obtain all types of membrane structures with consistent and predictable properties at large scale. Great improvements have been obtained during the last ten years concerning the quality and performance (permeability, selectivity, stability, reproducibility) of zeolite membranes. A number of synthesis process variables have been clearly identified which control the final characteristics of the membranes (crystal size, shape, orientation, membrane thickness and infiltration). This effort, involving a systematic study of process variables, must be maintained to further increase membrane reproducibility and performance. In parallel, the progress of zeolite membrane technology for industrial gas separation applications still needs the development of a generally applicable, « dynamic » and certified quality control method. The possibility to repair non-zeolite pores in already formed membranes could also compensate the current lack of reproducibility of large scale zeolite membranes. The development of low cost, reproducible and simple synthesis methods adapted to large scale synthesis on low cost supports will be a necessary breakthrough for larger industrial development. Finally zeolite membranes with tunable permeation properties will probably be the next important challenge for zeolite membrane researchers in the coming years.
REFERENCES [1] [2] [3]
X. Xu, Y. Bao, C. Song, W. Yang, J. Liu, L. Lin, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 75 (2004) 173. A. Julbe, J. Motuzas, F. Cazevielle, G. Voile, C. Guizard, Sep. Purif. Technol., 32 (2003) 139. S. Li, G. Alvarado, R. D. Noble, J. L. Falconer, Effects of impurities on CO2/CH4 separations through SAPO-34 membranes, J. Membr. Sci. 241 (2005) 121. [4] H. Kalipcilar, T. C. Bowen, R. D. Noble, J. L. Falconer, Chem. Mater., 14 (2002) 3458. [5] A. Urtiaga, E.D. Gorri, C. Casado, I. Ortiz, Sep. Purif. Technol., 32 (2003) 207. [6] B.S. Liu, L.Z. Gao, C.T. Au, Appl. Catal. A, 235 (2002) 193. [7] M.A. Salomon, J. Coronas, M. Menendez, J. Santamaria, Appl. Catal. A, 200 (2000) 201. [8] Y. Morigami, M. Kondo, J. Abe, H. Kita, K. Okamoto, Sep. Purif. Technol., 25 (2001) 251. [9] X. Xu, Y. Bao, C. Song, W. Yang, J. Liu, L. Lin, J. Membr. Sci., 249 (2005) 51. [10] T. Tomita, K. Nakayama, Hitoshi Sakai, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 68 (2004) 71.
156 [11] R.R. Chance, C.Y. Yoon, T.E. Clark, H.W. Deckman, E.R. Thomas, K.R. Geurts, P.J. Rubas, T. Tomita, K. Nakayama, H. Sakai, K. Suzuki, Molecular Transport in DDR zeolite Membranes, in Proc. 3rd Int. Zeolite Membr. Meeting, R. Noble (Ed), Breckenridge, CO USA, July 25-28, 2004. [12] Z. Lai, M. Tsapatsis, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 43 (2004) 3000. [13] G. Li, E. Kikuchi, M. Matsukata, J. Membr. Sci., 218 (2003) 185. [14] F. Jareman, C. Persson, J. Hedlund, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 79 (2005) 1. [15] L. van Dyk, S. Miachon, L. Lorenzen, M. Torres, K. Fiaty, J.-A. Dalmon, Catal. Today, 82 (2003) 167. [16] S. Nair, Z. Lai, V. Nikolakis, G. Xomeritakis, G. Bonilla, M. Tsapatsis, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 18 (2001) 219. [17] M. Pan, Y. S. Lin, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 43 (2001) 319. [18] R. Lai, G. R. Gavalas, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 38 (2000) 239. [19] T. Matsufuji, S. Nakagawa, N. Nishiyama, M. Matsukata, K. Ueyama, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 38 (2000) 43. [20] S. Li, V.A. Tuan, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, Chem. Mater., 13 (2001) 1865. [21] Y. Hasegawa, K.-I. Sotowa, K. Kusakabe, Chem. Eng. Sci., 58 (2003) 2797 [22] I. G. Giannakopoulos, V. Nikolakis, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 44 (2005) 226. [23] H. Kita, K. Fuchida, T. Horita, H. Asamura, K. Okamoto, Sep. Purif. Technol., 25 (2001) 261. [24] K. Weh, M. Noack, I. Sieber, J. Caro, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 54 (2002) 27. [25] G. Li, E. Kikuchi, M. Matsukata, Sep. Purif. Technol., 32 (2003) 199. [26] L. Casado, R. Mallada, C. Tellez, J. Coronas, M. Menendez, J. Santamaria, J. Membr. Sci., 216 (2003) 135. [27] A.Tavolaro, A.Julbe, C.Guizard, A.Basile, L.Cot, E.Drioli, J. Mater. Chem., 10 (2000) 1131. [28] V.A. Tuan, S. Li, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, Chem. Mater., 14 (2002) 489. [29] V.A. Tuan, L.L. Weber, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 42 (2003) 3019. [30] L.T.Y. Au, J.L.H. Chau, C.T. Ariso, K.L. Yeung, J. Membr. Sci., 183 (2001) 269. [31] X. Li, K. Takei, X. Zhang, H. Kita, K.-l. Okamoto, K. Itabashi, in Proc. 8th Int. Conf. on Inorganic Membranes ICIM8, F.T. Akin, Y.S. Lin (Ed), Cincinnati, Ohio, USA, July 18-22, 2004, pp.250-253. [32] Z. Lin, J. Rocha, A. Navajas, C. Tellez, J. Coronas, J. Santamaria, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 67 (2004) 79. [33] X. Zhang, J. Wang, H. Liu, C. Liu, K. Yeung, Sep. Purif. Technol., 32 (2003) 151. [34] H. Kalipcilar, S.K. Gade, R.D. Noble, J.L. Falconer, J. Memb. Sci., 210 (2002) 113. [35] S. Li, V. A. Tuan, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 58 (2003) 137. [36] A. Julbe, D. Farrusseng, C. Guizard, J.C. Jalibert, C.Mirodatos, Catal. Today 56 (2000) 199. [37] A. Potdar, A. Shukla, A. Kumar, J. Membr. Sci., 210 (2002) 209. [38] J.H. Dong, Y.S. Lin, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 37 (1998) 2404. [39] K. Tanaka, R. Yoshikawa, C. Ying, H. Kita, K.-I. Okamoto, Chem. Eng. Sci., 57 (2002) 1577. [40] S.G. Thoma, D.E. Trudell, F. Bonhomme, T.M. Nenoff, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 50 (2001) 33. [41] V.V. Guliants, M.A. Carreon, Y.S. Lin, J. Membr. Sci., 235 (2004) 53 [42] M. Vilaseca, J. Coronas, S. Mintova, T. Bein, J. Santamaria, in Proc. 8th Int. Conf. on Inorganic Membranes, F.T. Akin, Y.S. Lin (Ed), Cincinnati, Ohio, USA, July 18-22,2004, pp. 450-453. [43] A. Shukla, A. Kumar, Sep. Purif. Technol., 41 (2005) 83. [44] M. Tsapatsis, G. Xomeritakis, H. Hillhouse, S. Nair, V. Nikolakis, G. Bonilla, Z. Lai, CATTECH, 3 (2000) 148.
157 [45] J. Caro, M. Noack, P. Kolsch, R. Schafer, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 38 (2000) 3. [46] L. Cot, A. Ayral, J. Durand, C. Guizard, N. Hovnanian, A. Julbe, A. Larbot, Solid State Sci., 2 (2000)313. [47] Y.S. Lin, Sep. Purif. Technol, 25 (2001) 39. [48] A.S.T. Chiang, K.-J. Chao, J. Phys. Chem. Solids, 62 (2001) 1899. [49] J. Coronas, J. Santamaria, Top. Catal., 29 [1-2] (2004) 29. [50] J.G. Sanchez-Marcano, T.T. Tsotsis, Catalytic Membranes and Membrane Reactors, Wiley VCH, Weinhein, 2002. [51] G. R. Gavalas, A review of Zeolite Membrane Preparation and Permeation Properties, in Y. Yampolskii, I. Pinnau, B.D. Freeman (Eds), Materials Science of Membranes for Gas and Vapor Separation, John Wiley & Sons Ltd, Chichester, UK, in press [52] F. Kapteijn, W. Zhu, J.A. Moulijn, T.Q. Gardner, Zeolite Membranes - Modelling, Application. In A. Cybulski & J.A. Moulijn (Eds), Structured Catalysts and Reactors: Second Edition, Revised and Expanded. Marcel Dekker, New York, NY, 2005. [53] J.D.F. Ramsay, S. Kallus, Zeolite membranes, in N.K. Kanellopoulos (Ed.), Membrane Sci. and Technol. Series, Vol. 6, Elsevier, 2000. [54] T. C. Bowen, R. D. Noble, J.L. Falconer, J. Membr. Sci., 245 (2004) 1. [55] R. Krishna, R. Baur, Sep. Purif. Technol., 33 (2003) 213. [56] http://www.tcn.zaq.ne.jp/membrane/english/MemZeoE.htm [57] T. Sano, Y. Kiyozumi, M. Kawamura, F. Mizukami, H. Takaya, T. Mouri, W. Inaoka, Y. Toida, M. Watanabe, K. Toyoda, Zeolites, 11 (1991) 842. [58] W.O. Haag, J.C. Tsikoyiannis, Separation of mixture components over membrane composed of pure molecular sieve, US Patent 5,069,794 (1991). [59] J.M. Duval, Adsorbent Filled Polymeric Membranes; Application to Pervaporation, Gas Separation, PhD thesis, Twente University, The Netherlands, 1993. [60] H.J.C. te Hennepe, W.B.F. Boswerger, D. Bargeman, M.H.V. Mulder, C.A. Smolders, J. Membr. Sci., 89 [1-2] (1994) 185. [61] T. Bein, Chem. Mater., 8 (1996) 1636. [62] T.T. Moore, R. Mahajan, D.Q. Vu, W.J. Koros, AIChE Journal, 50 (2004) 311. [63] L. Y. Jiang, T. S. Chung, C. Cao, Z. Huang, S. Kulprathipanja, J. Memb. Sci., (2005) in press. [64] T.C. Bowen, L. M. Vane, Ethanol recovery by pervaporation through zeolite, zeolite filled polymeric membranes, US Envir. Protection Agency-National risk Management Research LabEPA research bull.. [65] G. Laghendries, G.V. Baron, P.A. Jacobs, Chem. Eng. Sci., 54 (1999) 1467. [66] V. Tricoli, F. Nanneti, Electrochim. Acta, 48 (2003) 2625. [67] E. Piera, A. Giroir-Fendler, J.A. Dalmon, H. Moueddeb, J. Coronas, M. Menendez, J. Santamaria, J. Membr. Sci., 142 (1998) 97. [68] N Nishiyama, K. Ichioka, Y. Egashira, K. Ueyama, L. Gora, W. Zhu, F. Kapteijn, J. Moulijn, in Proc. 8th Int. Conf. on Inorganic Membranes, ICIM8, F.T. Akin, Y.S. Lin (Ed), Cincinnati, Ohio, USA, July 18-22, 2004, pp. 216-219. [69] T.C. Bowen, H. Kalipcilar, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, J. Membr. Sci., 215 (2003) 235. [70] M. Kondo, M. Komori, H. Kita, K. Okamoto, J. Membr. Sci., 133 (1997) 133. [71] M.P. Bernal, G. Xomeritakis, M. Tsapatsis, Catal. Today, 67 (2001) 101. [72] J.L.H. Chau, C. Tellez, K. L. Yeung, K. Ho, J. Membr. Sci., 164 (2000) 257.
158 [73] E. Mateo, R. Lahoz, X. de la Fuente, A. Paniagua, J. Coronas, J. Santamaria, "Preparation of silicalite micromembranes on laser perforated stainless steel sheets" in Proc. 3rd Int. Zeolite Membrane Meeting, R. Noble (Ed), Breckenridge, CO USA, July 25-28, 2004. [74] A.Y.L. Leung, K.L. Yeung, Chem. Eng. Sci., 59 (2004) 4809. [75] X. Zhang, W. Zhu, H. Liu, T. Wang, Short Com. Mater. Let., 58 (2004) 2223. [76] W.-Y. Dong, Y.-C. Long, Microporous Mesoporous Mater.,76 (2004) 9. [77] H. Richter, I. Voigt, G. Fischer, P. PuhlfurB, Sep. Purif. Technol., 32 (2003) 133. [78] X. Xu, W. Yang, J. Liu, L. Lin, N. Stroh, H. Brunner, J. Membr. Sci., 229 (2004) 81. [79] O. Ohrman, J. Hedlund, J. Sterte, Appl. Catal. A, 270 (2004) 193. [80] J. L. Williams, Catal. Today, 69 (2001) 3. [81] F. T. de Bruijn, L. Sun, Z. Oluji, P. J. Jansen, F. Kapteijn, J. Membr. Sci., 223 (2003) 141. [82] H. Suzuki, Composite membrane having a surface layer of an ultra-thin film of cage shaped zeolite, processes for production thereof, US Patent 4 699 892 (1987) assigned to Suzuki. [83] A. Giroir-Fendler, A. Julbe, J.D.F. Ramsay, J.A. Dalmon, "Porous inorganic composite materials, structures, especially membranes, and their manufacture" French patent 94-5562, Int. Pat. Appl. WO 9 529 751 (1994). [84] M. Matsukata, M. Ogura, T. Osaki, P. Raja, H.P. Rao, M. Nomura, E. Kikuchi, Top. Catal., 9 (1999)77. [85] J. Dong, E.A. Payzant, M.Z.C. Hu, D.W. Depaoli, Y.S. Lin, J. Mater. Sci., 38 (2003) 979. [86] W. Xu, J. Dong, J. Li, F. Wu, J. Chem. Soc, Chem. Commun., (1990) 755. [87] E. Kikuchi, K. Yamashita, S. Hiromoto, K. Ueyama, M. Matsukata, Microporous Mater., 11 (1997) 107. [88] M. Matsukata, N. Nishiyama, K. Ueyama, Microporous Mater., 7 (1996) 109. [89] T. Matsufuji, N. Nishiyama, K. Ueyama, M. Matsukata, Catal. Today, 56 (2000) 265. [90] S. Alfar, M. Aruebo, J. Coronas, M. Menendez, J. Santamaria, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 50(2001)195. [91] L.C. Boudreau, J.A. Kuck, M. Tsapatsis, J. Membr. Sci., 152 (1999) 41. [92] G. Li, E. Kikuchi, M. Matsukata, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 62 (2003) 211. [93] S. Nair, Z. Lai, V. Nikolakis, G. Xomeritakis, G. Bonilla, M. Tsapatsis, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 48 (2001) 219. [94] W.C. Wong, L.T.Y. Au, P.P.S. Lau, C.T. Ariso, K.L. Yeung, J. Membr. Sci., 193 (2001) 141. [95] Z. Wang, J. Hedlund, J. Sterte, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 52 (2002) 191. [96] M. Lassinantti, J. Hedlund, J. Sterte, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 38 (2000) 25. [97] A.E. Persson, B.J. Schoeman, J. Sterte, J.E. Otterstedt, Zeolites, 14 (1994) 557. [98] M.C. Lovallo, M. Tsapatsis, A.I.ChEJ., 42 (1996) 3020. [99] Q. Li, D. Creaser, J. Sterte, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 31(1999) 141. [100] J. Motuzas, A. Julbe, R.D. Noble, C. Guizard, Z.J. Beresnevicius, D. Cot, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., (2005) in press [101] A. Julbe, J. Motuzas, M. Arruebo, R.D. Noble, Z.J. Beresnevicius, in J. Cejka, N. Zilkova and P. Nachtigall. (Eds), Proc. 3rd FEZA conf., Prague, Czech Republic, August 23-26'\ 2005, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 158(2005). [102] A. Huang, Y.S. Lin, W. Yang, J. Membr. Sci., 245 (2004) 41. [103] W. Shan, Y. Zhang, W. Yang, C. Ke, Z. Gao, Y. Ye, Y. Tang, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 69 (2004) 35.
159 [104] S. Mintova, V. Valtchev, V. Engstrom, B.J. Schoeman, J. Sterte, Microporous Mater., 11 (1997) 149. [105] W.C. Wong, L.T.Y. Au, P.P.S. Lau, C.T. Ariso, K.L.Yeung, J. Membr. Sci., 193 (2001) 141. [106] A.-J. Bons, P.D. Bons, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 62 (2003) 9. [107] L.C. Boudreau, T. Tsapatis, Chem. Mater., 9 (1997) 1705. [108] L.C. Boudreau, J.A. Kuck, M. Tsapatsis, J. Membr. Sci., 152 (1999) 41. [109] H. Ha, Y.J. Lee, H.J. Lee, K.B. Yoon, Adv. Mater., 12 (2000) 1114. [110] Z. Lai, G. Bonilla, I. Diaz, J.G. Nery, K. Sujaiti, M.A. Amat, E. Kokkoli, O. Terasaki, R.W. Thompson, M. Tsapatsis, D.G. Vlachos, Science, 300 (2003) 456. [111] J. Hedlund, F. Jareman, A.-J. Bons, M. Anthonis, J. Membr. Sci., 222 (2003) 163. [112] C.S. Cundy, J.O. Forrest, R.J. Plaisted, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 66 (2003) 143. [113] C.S. Cundy, J.O. Forrest, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 72 (2004) 67 [114] F. Tiscareno-Lechuga, C. Tellez, M. Menendez, J. Santamaria, J. Membr. Sci., 212 (2003) 135. [115] T. Mohammadi, A. Pak, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 56 (2002) 81. [116] K.J. Balkus, Jr., G. Gbery, Z. Deng, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 52 (2002) 141. [117] S. Heng, P.P.S. Lau, K.L. Yeung, M. Djafer, J.-C. Schrotter, J. Membr. Sci., 243 (2004) 69. [118] E.R. Geus, H. Van Bekkum, Zeolites, 15 (1995) 333. [119] M.J. den Exter, H. van Bekkum, C.J. M. Rijn, F. Kapteijn, J.A. Moulijn, H. Schellevis, C.I.N. Beenakker, Zeolites, 19 (1997) 13. [120] J. Dong, Y.S. Lin, M.Z.-C Hu, R.A. Peascoe, E.A. Payzant, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 34 (2000)241. [121] Y. Yan, M.E. Davis, G.R. Gavalas, J. Membr. Sci., 123 (1997) 95. [122] T. Masuda, N. Fukumoto, M. Kitamura, S.R. Mukai, K. Hashimoto, T. Tanaka, T. Funabiki, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 48 (2001) 239. [123] M. Hong, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., submitted. [124] K. Weh, M. Noack, K. Hoffmann, K.-P. Schroder, J. Caro, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 54 (2002) 15. [125] A. Julbe, J.D.F. Ramsay in "Fundamentals of Inorganic Membrane Science, Technology", Membrane Science, Technol. Series 4, Ed. A.J. Burggraaf & L. Cot, Elsevier (Amsterdam, NL), Chapter 4, 1996, pp. 67-118. [126] M.A. Snyder, Z. Lai, M. Tsapatsis, D.G. Vlachos, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 76 (2004) 29. [127] J.M. van de Graaf, F.Kapteijn, J.A. Moulijn, J. Membr. Sci., 144 (1998) 87. [128] T.Q. Gardner, J.L. Falconer, R.D. Noble, M.M. P. Zieverink, Chem. Eng. Sci., 58 (2003) 2103. [129] T. Tsuru, Y. Takata, H. Kondo, F. Hirano, T. Yoshioka, M. Asaeda, Sep. Purif. Technol., 32 (2003) 23. [130] O. Pachtova, I. Kumakiri, M. Kocirik, S. Miachon, J.-A. Dalmon, J. Membr. Sci., 226 (2003) 101. [131] J. Hedlund, F. Jareman, The synthesis, characterisation of thin MFI membranes in Proc. 3rd Int. Zeolite Membrane Meeting, R. Noble (Ed), Breckenridge, CO USA, July 25-28, 2004. [132] W.J.W. Bakker, F. Kapteijn, J. Poppe, J.A. Moulijn, J. Membr. Sci., 117 (1996) 57. [133] P. Ciavarella, H. Moueddeb, S. Miachon, K. Fiaty, J.-A. Dalmon, Catal. Today, 56 (2000) 253. [134] E. R Geus, H. van Bekkum, W.J.W. Bakker, J.A. Moulijn, Microporous Mater., 1(1993)131. [135] L.H. Chau, A.Y.L. Leung, M.B. Shing, K.L. Yeung, CM. Chan, "Hydrogen and proton transport properties of nanoporous zeolite micromembranes," in Z. Tang and P. Sheng (Eds), Nano Science and Technology: Novel Structure and Phenomena, Taylor and Francis, London, 2003, pp. 228-232.
160 [136] J.A. Dalmon, "Catalytic Membrane Reactors", in: Handbook of Heterogeneous Catalysis, G.Ertl, H.Knozinger and J.Weitkamp (Eds), VCH Pub., 1997, Chapter 9.3. [137] A. Pantazidis, J. A. Dalmon, C. Mirodatos, Catal. Today, 25 (1995) 403. [138] S. Mota, S. Miachon, J.-C. Volta and J.-A. Dalmon, Catal. Today, 67 (2001) 169. [139] D. Farrusseng, A. Julbe, C. Guizard, L. Cot, Sep. Purif. Technol, 25 (2001) 137. [140] U. Illgen, R. Schafer, M. Noack, P. Kolsch, A. Kuhnle, J. Caro, Catal. Commun., 2 (2001) 339. [141] Z. Xiongfu, L. Yongsheng, W. Jinqu, T. Huairong, L. Changhou, Sep. Purif. Technol., 25 (2001) 269. [142] T. Ostrowski, A. Giroir-Fendler, C. Mirodatos, L. Mleczko, Catal. Today, 40 (1998) 191. [143] J.M. van de Graaf, M. Zwiep, F. Kapteijn, J.A. Moulijn, Chem. Eng. Sci., 54 (1999) 1441. [144] J.J. Jafar, P.M. Budd, R. Hughes, J. Membr. Sci., 199 (2002) 117. [145] K. Tanaka, R.Yoshikawa, C. Ying, H. Kita, K-i Okamoto, Catal. Today, 67 (2001) 121 [146] M. P. Bernal, J. Coronas, M. Menendez, J. Santamaria, Chem. Eng. Sci., 57 (2002) 1557. [147] I. Kumakiri I, E. Landrivon, S. Miachon, J.A. Dalmon, In Proc. Int. Workshop on Zeolitic and Microporous Membranes, IWZMM 2001, Purmerend (The Netherlands), July 1-4, 2001. [148] R.L. Espinoza, E. du Toit, J. Santamaria, M. Menendez, J. Coronas, S. Irusta, Stud Surf. Sci. Catal., 130(2000)389. [149] M. Nomura, T. Bin, S.-I. Nakao, Sep. Purif. Technol., 27 (2002) 59. [150] Y. Hasegawa, K. Kusakabe, S. Morooka, J. Membr. Sci., 190 (2001) 1. [151] M. Torres, L. Lopez, J.M. Dominguez, A. Mantilla, G. Ferrat, M. Gutierrez, M. Maubert, Chem. Eng. J., 92 (2003) 1. [152] T. Masuda, T. Asunama, M. Shouji, S.R. Mukai, M. Kawase, K. Hashimoto, Chem. Eng. Sci., 58 (2003) 649. [153] A.J. Maira, W.N. Lau, C.Y. Lee, P.L. Yue, C.K. Chan, K.L. Yeung, Chem. Eng. Sci, 58 (2003) 959. [154] N. van der Puil, E.J. Creyghton, E.C. Rodenmbug, T.S. Sie, H. van Bekkum and J.C. Jansen, J. Chem. Soc. Faraday Trans., 92 (1996) 4609. [155] J.C. Jansen, J.H. Koegler, H. van Bekkun, H.P.A. Calis, CM. van den Bleek, F. Kapteijn, J.A. Moulijn, E.R. Geus, N. van der Puil, Microporous Mesoporous Mater, 21 (1998) 213. [156] E.E. McLeary, R.D. Sanderson, C. Luteijn, E.J.W. Buijsse, L. Gora, Th. Maschheyer, J.C. Jansen, Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal., 135 (2001) 3273. [157] p-Xylene production costs reduced by new zeolite membrane, Focus on Catalysts, 1 (2003) 7. [158] N. Nishiyama, M. Miyamoto, Y. Egashira, K. Ueyama, Chem. Commun, (2001) 1746. [159] N. Nishiyama, K. Ichioka, Y. Egashira, K. Ueyama, L. Gora, W. Zhu, F. Kapteijn, J. Moulijn, in Proc. 8th Int. Conf. on Inorganic Membranes ICIM8, F.T. Akin and Y.S. Lin (Eds), Cincinnati, Ohio, USA, July 18-22, 2004, pp. 216-219. [160] Y.S.S. Wan, J.L.H. Chau, A. Gavriilidis, K.L. Yeung, Chem. Commun, (2002) 878 [161] A.W. Chow, AIChE J, 48 (2002) 1590. [162] S. Kita, "Zeolite membranes for fuel ethanol production" in Proc. 3rd International Zeolite Membrane Meeting, R. Noble (Ed), Breckenridge, CO USA, July 25-28, 2004. [163] S. Ikeda, S. Nakane, M. Matsukata, "Recent advances of zeolite membrane Technologies for dehydration, in Proc. 3rd International Zeolite Membrane Meeting, R. Noble (Ed), Breckenridge, CO USA, July 25-28, 2004. [164] M.L. Maloncy, Th. Maschmeyer, J.C. Jansen, Chem. Eng. J, 106 (2005) 187. [165] A. Taguchi, F. Schttth, Microporous Mesoporous Mater, 77 (2005) 1.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
161
High-throughput experiments for synthesis and applications of zeolites F. Schiith Max-Planck-Institut fur Kohlenforschung, Kaiser-Wilhelm-Platz 1, 45470 Miilheim, Germany 1. INTRODUCTION 2. SYNTHESIS 3. CHARACTERIZATION 3.1. X-ray diffraction 3.2 X-ray fluorescence 3.3 IR analysis 3.4 Gas adsorption 3.5 Miscellaneous techniques 4. CATALYTIC TESTING 4.1. Reactors 4.2. High-throughput studies of the performance of zeolite catalysts 5. LIBRARY DESIGN AND DATA ANALYSIS 6. PERSPECTIVES REFERENCES 1. INTRODUCTION High-throughput experimentation has entered materials science and - with a slight delay catalysis in the middle of the nineties, when the concepts originally developed in the pharmaceutical industry for drug discovery were adapted and applied in these fields [1], although some of the initial ideas date back to the 1970s with the so-called compositional spread approach [2]. High-throughput experimentation is a concerted approach, comprising several different elements which need to be integrated in the high-throughput workflow. These are (i) the automated, often parallel synthesis of solids, (ii) the parallel or fast sequential testing of the relevant properties of the solids, (iii) data management to integrate all the data and to extract knowledge, and (iv) often a robotics environment. In addition, to some extent high-throughput characterization technology is necessary, if a correlation of physicochemical parameters of the synthesized solids with the performance is desired. All scientists active in the field of zeolites know that often wide ranges of parameters and synthesis conditions have to be screened in order to optimize the synthesis of a zeolite or to discover novel materials. The same holds for the evaluation of performance data of zeolites in various applications. Zeolite science and technology is therefore a field where there is a high need to accelerate experimentation and to achieve a higher throughput. Thus, relatively early on in the development of high-throughput experimentation, efforts were made to use the
162 concepts in the zeolite field. The state-of-the-art in this field, possible directions of future work, and the limitation as far as they can be perceived at this stage will be discussed in the following. 2. SYNTHESIS Zeolite synthesis is one of the fields in solid state chemistry, where predictability of the outcome of the synthesis is rather low. It is in most cases not clear, why specific structures do form with certain template molecules and under certain synthesis conditions. Some success has been reached in a more rational zeolite design [3], either by computational design of specific templates or by judicious addition of heteroatoms to induce the formation of certain ring sizes in the structures. However, empirical studies to optimize the formation of certain structures, or systematic exploration of the parameter space often still remains the method of choice in zeolite synthesis. Due to the number of experiments necessary in such studies which take typically times of several hours to several days, there is a strong incentive to work on acceleration of synthesis experiments in zeolite science. On the other hand, there are also major obstacles to overcome in such an endeavour. Zeolite syntheses are often carried out at elevated pressure, reaction media are typically corrosive, precursor solutions and the synthesis gel itself may be highly viscous and difficult to handle, the synthesis is very sensitive to preparation conditions, such as sequence of reagent addition, stirring (difficult for small volumes) may be necessary for some formulations, aging conditions may differ from batch to batch, if automated sequential preparation is chosen, the work-up involving many steps is complex, and the resulting materials are often not phase-pure and difficult to characterize. Nevertheless, in spite of these problems some of the earliest examples for the synthesis of catalytically relevant solids in parallelized and - some points -automated equipment were reported for zeolites [4]. The first report on parallelized zeolite synthesis was published by the Sintef group [5]. They have used a 100 well autoclave which in the simplest case was realized as a Teflon block, but also a metal frame with Teflon linings is possible (Fig. 1). Since only 0.5 ml of synthesis solution was present in each well, the pressures could be handled without any metal reinforcement in this case. For dispensing of the precursor solutions a commercial pipetting robot was chosen. The autoclave block was sufficiently small to be fitted onto the working stage of typical robots. In order to parallelize even more, the blocks could be stacked on top of each other with stainless steel plates and Teflon seals in between different blocks. For product isolation, top and bottom covers are removed from the block and the autoclave content was directly flushed onto filter paper, washed with water and then removed for further Fig. 1. Typical multiautoclave block with Teflon inserts as used by the Sintef team, showing the stacking (reprinted with permission from ref. [51).
analysis. This is probably the biggest disadvantage of system used in this publication, since the isolation and subsequent XRD of the samples is very time consuming and takes away some of the advantages which the system provides. Nevertheless, this
the
163
equipment was used for a systematic investigation of the synthesis field Li2O - CS2O (TMA)2O - Na2O - A12O3 - SiO2 (TMA = tetramethylammonium). Analcime was formed from all cesium containing gels, while five different zeolitic materials, which all had been obtained before in isolated experiments resulted in the Li2O - Na2O part of the synthesis space diagram. The problem of the time consuming analysis was addressed in the work of Maier and coworkers [6]. They crystallized minute amounts of zeolite samples (for the example of TS-1 syntheses) in wells formed by a silicon wafer as bottom plate on which a Teflon block with drilled holes was placed. Each bore formed the wall of a separate reactor chamber. The system was sealed by a top plate made of stainless steel. The amounts of reaction mixture are only several microliters. Reaction solution is removed by placing porous rods into each well, thus removing the supernatant (and possibly also some solid) by capillary forces. The innovative aspect of this publication was the XRD analysis which was performed directly on the wafer without manual intervention. For this purpose a Bruker AXS GADDS X-ray diffraction system was used which allows focussing the X-ray beam by Gobel mirrors onto a small spot with a size as low as 50 urn diameter. Very satisfactory signal to noise ratio could be obtained by this kind of analysis, and identification of the TS-1 phase which had been synthesized with various different templates was possible without any problems. For screening experiments such equipment is certainly very valuable, since it allows synthesis and analysis of materials in an automated fashion in relatively short periods of time. A drawback of the system is the fact that agitation of the reaction mixture is quite difficult, a problem which is not as severe as in conventional autoclaves, since the wells are very small and thus diffusion can provide some homogenization. The use of the silicon wafer as bottom plate could also become a problem for more basic reaction media. In the study on TS-1 formation, no corrosion of the substrate had been observed. However, this should be a solvable obstacle, either by replacing silicon by another material or by coating the silicon wafer. Methods combining the two approaches to some extent were used by Bein and coworkers [7]. They designed a parallel autoclave block with wells drilled into a Teflon block with a size allowing solution volumes of some 100 ul. For product isolation, a filtration module could be integrated into the system after the reaction. In a later embodiment of the multiclave system, a centrifuge setup had been developed which allows separation and washing of the solid. The final product in both cases is collected Fig. 2. X R D patterns for samples on filter paper and is either analyzed manually or isolated from different wells of a sequentially in an automated STOE transmission multiclave. Samples were prepared with XRD setup [8, 9]. identical gel composition expected to Later on, a study was published by Lai et al. [10], in give AIPO4-5, which formed in all which the approach of Klein et al. [6] was essentially cases, demonstrating the reproducibility of the procedure (reprinted with inverted. Also in this study a library of zeolite permission from ref. 11). samples was crystallized onto one substrate, an
164
alumina wafer. However, the setup was integrated in a conventional Parr reactor. The wells of the multiclave were drilled into a Teflon block fitting into the autoclave, each well having a volume of about 40 ul. The top was sealed with the alumina wafer on which an MFI seed layer had been deposited before. The autoclave was then inverted and the crystallization started by heating the autoclave. The product was found to be crystallized onto the alumina wafer. The system was used for the exploration of the synthesis space for MFI type films synthesized in absence of an organic structure directing agent. In the initial phase at the end of the 1990s, parallelized zeolite synthesis was carried out more in form of feasibility studies. The target in the published papers was normally not the discovery of novel zeolites, but to show that the systems did work. Thus, typically known zeolite systems were explored in some more detail as had been done previously in single publications, but no novel discoveries were made. One of the broadest screening studies in the initial phase with the goal of discovering novel materials was performed by Akporiaye et al. [11], primarily directed at the synthesis of aluminophosphates. In this study several novel layered materials were discovered, which are probably formed by the intercalation of the different organic template molecules between aluminophosphate layers. One interesting aspect in this study was the check of the reproducibility of the synthesis of a porous inorganic material in such a multiclave setup. As an example, the authors show a series of diffraction patterns obtained for a set of replicated syntheses in various positions in the autoclave block. AIPO4-5 with rather similar diffraction patterns was formed in all wells, demonstrating the reproducibility of the method (Fig. 2). This may be different for a phase with a more narrow range of synthesis conditions under which it forms, but the experiments nevertheless prove that one can obtain fairly reliable data in such a system. Very interesting novel zinc phosphate structures were discovered in the group of Yu and Xu [12] using a combinatorial approach. The setup resembles the one initially described by Akporiaye [5] in that the well are formed in a Teflon block, with each well having a volume of about 800 ul. Product analysis was done with an automated powder XRD setup after the samples had been transferred to a sample holder. Solids were formed from zinc solution, phosphoric acid and N,N'-dimethylpiperazine as precursors. The most interesting material formed was a zinc phosphate with 16-membered ring channels in one direction, but two other structures with smaller pore openings were also described in this publication. Recently, studies directed at the discovery of phosphonate organic/inorganic hybrid materials were published [9], in which several novel zinc phosphonates were described, in addition to a novel structure which could be realized with various divalent cations and the zwitterion [(HO3PCH2)2(H)N(CH2)4N(H)(CH2PO3H)2]2' in which each phosphonate group and each N-atom is protonated. The MO6 and PO3C polyhedra form eight-membered rings within layers of the structure. The layers are linked by the organic groups which effectively block the eight-membered rings. This explorative study was performed in two steps which is rather typical for a high-throughput program, starting with an exploratory library in order to investigate which cations gave (possibly) microporous solids. The search was focussed in a subsequent step to optimize the synthesis and to create crystals with a size sufficient for structure solution. As successful as these studies were in showing the general possibility of high-throughput synthesis of microporous materials in minute amounts, one should not underestimate the problems associated with such an approach. Especially if the volume of the wells decreases to the range of 10 ul or below, there are additional effects which need to be considered. These problems are probably one reason why most high-throughput discovery studies were rather directed at the formation of metal phosphates or phosphonates instead of at classical zeolites.
165
Precursor solutions for the phosphates are much easier to handle, since the pH is not extreme, all components are liquid, and typically no two phase systems which are difficult to mix are formed, as could happen with alkoxysilane precursors. The additional problems encountered when doing zeolite synthesis on miniature scale have been discussed by Newsam et al. [4], and include: inhomogeneities of precursor mixtures, dispensing of ul of fluids of various different viscosities and vapour pressures. mixing of initial solutions or gels, mixing of multiclave well content under reaction conditions, evaporative fluid losses, oxidative degradation, such as of organic additives, contamination from debris, dirt or chemical attack on multiclave components. Several of these problems can also occur during zeolite synthesis on a larger scale. However, due to the much larger volumes involved, their effect is typically negligible, which is not the case for syntheses carried out on the ul scale. There are thus groups who rely on more conventional autoclaves also for parallelized studies, but the transition to conventional zeolite synthesis are not sharply defined. At hte-company an autoclave system is used which allows larger sample volumes (Fig. 3). 16 inserts are used in one autoclave housing. These inserts can be filled by a dispensing robot and simultaneously placed in a heating unit. Centrifugation in a module, which is adapted to the autoclave set, is used for product isolation. From the centrifuge module the product is transferred to an XRD sample holder where it can automatically be analyzed.
Fig. 3. Autoclave setup for zeolite synthesis. Synthesis module in the disassembled stage and the assembled state (left). Centrifugation module (right). For centrifugation a filter paper between two Teflon elements is placed on top of the 16 Teflon inserts and the system is placed upside down in the centrifuge to remove the liquid (courtesy of hte Aktiengesellschaft, Heidelberg). Even more strongly related with conventional zeolite synthesis are systems consisting of several individual autoclaves. Also in conventional zeolite synthesis, researchers typically
166
place several autoclaves in one oven. Thus, the multiclave system described by Tagliabue et al. [13] in which up to 39 15 ml autoclaves are mounted on one oscillating rack to provide agitation is rather closely related to conventional zeolite synthesis, especially since also filling and work-up has to be done as in conventional zeolite synthesis. Nevertheless, if syntheses are carried out on this scale, results are easier to transfer to technical dimensions. 3. CHARACTERIZATION In the preceding chapter it had already been discussed that it is less the synthesis itself which may be the bottleneck in high-throughput zeolite science but rather the analysis of the solids formed in a high-throughput program. There are several standard characterization techniques which are typically employed to characterize zeolitic materials. These include powder XRD for phase identification, X-ray fluorescence analysis (XRF) or atomic absorption spectrometry to analyze elemental composition, sorption analysis to study the pore system, IR-spectroscopy, typically using adsorbed probe molecules to characterize the acid sites, NMR spectroscopy and many others. For some of these techniques parallelized solutions have been developed and described in the literature, other properties are more difficult to assess in a parallelized or even a fast sequential fashion. However, when considering the development of parallel methods for sample characterization, one has to ask oneself what the purpose of the characterization might be. Often solids are characterized by physico-chemical methods in order to draw conclusions with respect to potential catalytic activity or other desired performance. Only such samples having the proper physico-chemical parameters would then be selected for in-depth catalytic studies. This is done because a catalytic experiment used to involve much more efforts than physicochemical characterization of solids. However, with the availability of high-throughput reactors for catalytic testing this is no longer necessarily the best approach. If catalytic testing takes less time than the analysis, the order may be reversed. After synthesis, firstly all samples prepared could be catalytically evaluated, and only those showing promising or unusual catalytic performance would then be characterized in detail, for instance to establish propertyactivity correlations. If such an approach is chosen, demands for high-throughput characterization are substantially less severe than if every sample is analyzed in detail. However, the exact nature of a specific project will determine, which sequence is the more appropriate one, and so in general there is some need for the development of suitable highthroughput analysis techniques for solid samples and in particular for zeolites. In the following the approaches which have been published so far will be discussed in more detail. 3.1. X-ray diffraction XRD has already been briefly addressed in the preceding section in connection with zeolite synthesis, since this is the standard technique to determine whether a microporous or at least possibly microporous material has formed. Since the existence of channels allowing access of molecules into the structure requires a certain size of the unit cell, a zeolitic material will typically have low angle reflections below around 10° (2©) for Cu-Ka radiation. A very simple way of quickly analyzing a library for the possible presence of zeolitic material is to scan only a narrow angle range between 3° and 10° (2©) and only record the full range for such materials having at least one reflection in this range. This can speed up the analysis by a factor of five to ten, but still requires manual intervention, either for each sample, or when a sample changer is used, at least during isolation of the synthesis product or filling of the sample changer. For larger library sizes, this is thus not a practical solution.
167
Thus, nowadays mostly diffractometers equipped with microdiffraction possibilities and xy-sample stages are used for automated collection of diffraction patterns. The key element in these setups is a Gobel-mirror [14], a parabolical multilayer device which allows the generation of a precisely collimated beam which can be focussed to spot sizes below 100 um. This makes it possible to analyze many different spots on a single substrate with reasonable signal to noise ratio as shown in the initial work by Klein et al. [6]. With a spatially resolving detector, recording of a diffraction pattern is possible within a few minutes. However, also less sophisticated methods are useful, such as covering all but one spot with lead foil which allows the use of an unfocussed beam [10]. However, even if samples can be analyzed in an automatic fashion by XRD, automated phase analysis by computer based methods is still in its infancy. Typically, XRD patterns have to be inspected manually, and especially if phase mixtures are formed, as it often happens in zeolite chemistry, the analysis of the patterns can become the bottleneck. Work is in progress in different laboratories to solve this problem, but no suitable solution has been published yet. 3.2. X-ray fluorescence XRF is one of the standard techniques used for the analysis of the elemental composition of zeolites. However, normally sample preparation is rather complicated, involving the preparation of the zeolite in a ceramic flux or in other matrices in order to have a standard sample geometry and size which is a requirement for precise analysis. This kind of sample preparation is not possible if the analysis is to be performed in high-throughput mode. An alternative method to conventional XRF makes use of focussing the X-ray radiation as in the case of diffraction, however, not the diffracted X-rays are collected, but the element specific fluorescence. Since the matrices and the sample geometries are rather ill-defined in this measurement mode, analysis is more of a semiquantitative character than quantitative. Nevertheless, for screening purposes this is a quite valuable method. So far this technique has not been used for the analysis of zeolites, but rather for libraries of sol-gel derived materials [15], or beads obtained from a split-and-pool protocol [16,17]. It makes use of different micro-XRF analyzers which focus the X-ray beam by a multi capillary system to a spot of around 50 urn diameter, as for instance in the Eagle II uprobe from Roentgenanalytik [15,16], or the ThermoNORAN Omicron system [17]. One can expect that analysis of zeolites will be possible with about the same level of precision as reached for the sol-gel derived libraries. However, this is not sufficient to determine Si/Alratios reliably, especially since it is typically not known whether the sample is fully crystalline when analyzed by XRD in high-throughput mode. Nevertheless, some initial information on elemental composition can be achieved by micro-XRF. 3.3. IR-analysis IR spectroscopy is one of the most useful techniques for the characterization of zeolitic materials. It provides information on the nature of OH-groups in the materials and on the framework vibrations. Even more useful is the IR analysis of adsorbed species. Basic probe molecules, such as pyridine, ammonia, or benzene, allow the analysis of acidic sites. CO adsorbed at low temperature also helps to analyze acidic sites, but can also be used for the analysis of noble metal particles in zeolites. In principle, several samples could be analyzed simultaneously, using an xy-table with which the zeolitic materials could be positioned in the focus of the IR-beam. However, one problem is encountered using such procedures: Typically, background correction is necessary,
168
if adsorbed species are to be analyzed in order to detect small changes in the spectra. Normally, first a spectrum of the activated zeolite is recorded, then the probe molecule is admitted, another spectrum is recorded, and finally the spectrum of the activated zeolite is subtracted. If several samples shall be analyzed simultaneously, this procedure is not as straightforward, since for the background subtraction to work, one has to find exactly the same position for the recording of the background spectrum and the spectrum with the adsorbed probe molecule. We have used this method both in a conventional FTIR setup with a measurement cell which could be evacuated as well as in an FTIR microspectrometer. In both cases we have not been able to record satisfactory spectra in a consistent way. Such a system is extremely sensitive to the conditions of the measurement, and in practice, it is probably too difficult to realize such an approach for routine operation. In addition, superior alternative technology became available over the last years, i.e. focal plane array detector (FPA) systems. These systems were originally developed for imaging in different frequency ranges, mostly for military and astronomical purposes. Such detectors consist of an array of small IR detectors, typically arranged in a rectangular pattern, and a system often used consists of 64x64, i.e. 4096 pixels altogether. This array is part of an imaging setup; thus, radiation of each part of the area to be imaged falls on a defined part of the detector array. Readout of the detector elements can be coupled to the modulation of an FTIR spectrometer, so that simultaneously 4096 spectra are obtained, which allow rather high spatial resolution. This means that experiments which are typically carried out for one sample using IR analysis can now be expanded to encompass a number of samples which have to be imaged on the FPA detector. Such FPA detector setups were first used by the group of Lauterbach for the parallel characterization of solid samples and the product gas stream from catalytic reactors [18,19]. These authors also changed the mode of operation from the previously used step-scan mode to the rapid scan mode which made it possible to even record transient processes [20,21]. The group of Lauterbach was also the first to apply FPA IR spectroscopy to a problem from zeolite science, even if it was only in form of a feasibility study. They investigated the adsorption of CO on Cu-ZSM-5 and on Pt/SiC>2 in order to prove that it would be possible to detect the absorption bands of adsorbed species [19]. Since experiments were carried out at room temperature, bands for CO on the Cu-ZSM-5 would be expected to have very low intensity, and indeed, no spectra for CO on this solid were shown. The band of CO on the noble metal, on the other hand, could clearly be detected without problems, and a signal-tonoise ratio not much different from that obtained for a conventional experiment. We have developed a sorption cell for use in connection with a FPA IR setup for the analysis of eight samples in parallel [22,23]. Fig. 4 shows a photograph of the cell. It is integrated into an imaging mirror system which uses the beam coming out of the external port of an FTIR spectrometer. In order to facilitate sample handling, the samples are placed on a horizontal CaF2 window, IR light passes through the cell from top to bottom. The whole cell can be evacuated and heated, so that sample activation is possible. Several problems are encountered in carrying out such parallelized experiments, (i) The samples have been placed in small apertures in a bigger metal disk which serves as spacer between the two CaF2 windows. Otherwise, the sample will move during evacuation of the cell so that cross contamination between different samples could occur, or sample could even be sucked into the pump, (ii) Temperature homogeneity of the cell can be a problem. Since heating has to be provided from the circumference of the cell, radial gradients may exist, (iii) Most severe is the fact that scattering losses are more severe than in conventional experimentation. All scientists experienced in the analysis of zeolites are aware of often
169
strongly reduced intensity and sloping background due to scattering losses. These losses are an even bigger problem in a parallelized cell, since the necessity to integrate the cell in the imaging system makes the beam path much longer so that even slightly divergent rays caused by scattering are not captured by the mirrors and do not reach the FPA detector. This is most severe for samples with particle sizes in the range of the wavelength of the radiation, and for some samples with unfavourable shapes, such as mordenite with elongated shapes, we did not succeed in recording useful spectra. The problem could be reduced to some extent by pressing the material into small wafers as in conventional IR analysis of zeolitic materials, typically with a thickness of about 10 mg/cm2. Producing wafers with defined thickness also helped in semi-quantitative analysis, and compared to conventional experiments the wafer fragments used can be much smaller which facilitates handling. So even taking into account the problems with parallel IR analysis of zeolites, for many samples the system proved to be useful and analysis times can be strongly reduced by such systems.
Fig. 4. Schematic drawing of the vacuum cell for parallelized IR analysis with adsorbed gases (top) and photograph of the cell (bottom). The light comes from the front, hits the top mirror, passes the cell and is reflected towards the detector by the bottom mirror which is turned away from the viewer. Upper left insert in the photo shows the distance element with the eight apertures in which the samples are placed (from ref. [22]).
One of the most tedious experiments in zeolite analysis is the assessment of acidity using pyridine as probe molecule. Activation, pumping and equilibration times are very time consuming, and thus such experiments typically take up to a day per sample, especially, if
170
thermal desorption experiments are included. With the setup shown above, we have analyzed the acidity of different zeolite samples, such as H-ZSM-5 or H-Y. The spectra were compared to those recorded with a conventional spectrometer and overall were quite similar (Fig. 5). The small deviations are probably caused by small differences in the temperature measurement in the parallel and the conventional cell. If one uses published extinction coefficients, the concentration of acidic sites determined with the parallel and the conventional setup agreed within a few percent.
Fig. 5. IR spectra of pyridine adsorbed on H-ZSM-5 recorded with a conventional setup (top trace) and in the parallelized cell (bottom trace). Samples had been heated to 250°C for 15 minutes before recording the spectra.
The system also proved to be useful for the analysis of CO adsorbed on noble metal particles in different zeolites [23]. Series of samples could be analyzed in relatively short periods of time, and it could be estimated, that the parallel setup could be used for samples with a platinum content as low as 0.1 % at an acceptable signal-to-noise ratio. One can expect that with the rapid scan capabilities implemented by Lauterbach and coworkers even kinetics of fast adsorption and desorption processes could be monitored in a parallel fashion. 3.4. Gas adsorption It would be extremely attractive to also parallelize gas adsorption measurements. There are commercial multiport systems available, but the savings in equipment is rather moderate for these systems. One may think about using FPA IR setups for parallelized gas adsorption, for instance by adsorbing hydrocarbons at their boiling point and analyzing the amount adsorbed via the integral absorption of selected IR bands. We have attempted to use this approach, but extinction coefficient of conventional hydrocarbons are so strongly coverage and pore size dependent, that not even semi-quantitative analysis was possible. Similar problems are expected for other vibrational spectroscopies, since the interatomic potentials are modified by the adsorption process. Thus, a truly parallelized adsorption measurement is still not in sight. 3.5. Miscellaneous techniques: temporal analysis of products (TAP) and temperature programmed desorption (TPD) For two other methods often used for the characterization of zeolitic materials, parallelized implementations have been described in the literature, i.e. TAP studies and TPD experiments. Also these experiments, as is the case for IR measurements with probe molecules, need a long time for sample loading, pumping, pre-treatment and conditioning steps, while the actual experiment is relatively short. These experiments can therefore
171
tremendously be sped up, if the time consuming steps are done in parallel for several samples, while the TAP or TPD experiment itself is analyzed for each sample separately. TPD of basic probe molecules is a method which is often used for the analysis of zeolitic acidity [24]. In a parallelized implementation [25] of this technique, the samples to be studied were placed in a parallel channel reactor-body built analogous to the one described by Hoffmann et al. [26]. By means of a multiport valve, the effluent from each channel could be switched to a mass spectrometer which was used for the analysis of the desorbed gas. In a typical experiment, after conditioning of the samples and adsorbing ammonia, a temperature ramp was started and in a sequential manner the effluent of each catalyst was fed into the mass spectrometer. Flushing and analysis times per channel were 8 s, so that all 10 samples could be analyzed in somewhat more than one minute. This proved to be sufficient to obtain well resolved TPD curves at a heating rate of 10 K/min. The recorded data corresponded well to curves measured with conventional setups. TAP reactor systems are used to obtain transient kinetic data. As in TPD and IRanalyzed adsorption of probe molecules, loading of the system and pre-treatment of the samples is the most time consuming step. In order to solve this problem, van Veen et al. [27] integrated a multisample holder into a TAP setup which is capable of holding 12 samples. The holder is connected to a pulse valve manifold, which allows addressing sequentially each of the samples with a gas pulse. As a case study, 10 different zeolite samples were loaded into the TAP system, and by pulsing 50/50 mixtures of neon and ethane, heats of adsorption of ethane on the different zeolites could be determined. The expected trends in the heats of adsorption (decreasing enthalpy with increasing Si/Al ratio) were found using the TAP system. However, the absolute figures were substantially lower than those measured with a conventional setup, which may be related to the modelling of the signal, in which diffusion and adsorption were lumped together in the study. 4. CATALYTIC TESTING One of the most important steps in high-throughput development of catalysts is the catalytic test itself. For catalytic testing, typically stage I (or "discovery") and stage II ("optimization") systems are discriminated [28]. In a stage I project, typically little is known about the catalytic system, screening is very broad and massively parallelized, the depth of information is rather low, the reaction conditions are often far away from technical conditions, and often the format of the reactor is determined by the format of the analytical assay. This allows a very high sample throughput, but in most cases no exact analysis of the performance of a catalyst. In a stage II project, the reactor and the conditions approach conventional testing and technical processes, more detailed analysis is possible, typically selectivity information is obtained with a rather high level of precision, but on the expense of throughput. The degree of parallelization in stage I screening can reach several hundred samples, while stage II screening typically employs 16 - 64 channel reactors operated in fixed bed arrangement. Catalytic evaluation of zeolitic materials will in most cases require stage II testing, at least with the technology available today. Most zeolite catalyzed reactions are characterized by a complex product spectrum and the danger of deactivation by coking of the catalyst, which is an extremely important factor for practical application. Complex product spectra and changing activity with time are typically difficult to handle in stage I setups. The general discussion in the following will therefore focus on stage II techniques, stage I approaches are well covered in recent review articles [29,30]. Then some examples will be given, which also include stage I systems. However, they are presently mostly of academic interest. To the best
172
of the knowledge of the author, by far the majority of the high-throughput projects in industry - not only those on zeolites - are carried out in stage II mode. 4.1. Reactors Most of the reactors used in stage II systems are variants of the ones described by Hoffmann et al. [26,31,32]. Some types of parallel reactors are shown in Fig. 6. They are characterized by a number of common features: common gas inlet for all channels; catalyst placed in cartridges which can be easily exchanged; outlet via capillaries which provide the major flow restriction in order to minimize the influence of differences in the packing of the catalyst beds; outlet capillaries mostly connected to a multiport valve for switching one channel to analytical systems, the others are vented; flexibility in the analytical system (GC, mass spectrometry, FTIR, etc.); in most cases sequential addressing of the channels; typically all channels integrated into a metal block which is heated.
Fig. 6. Different stage II parallel reactors. Left: 49 channel reactor for normal pressure and temperatures up to 450°C (from ref. 31). Middle: 49 channel reactor for pressures up to 50 bar and temperatures up to 260°C (from ref. 32). Right: Modular slice reactor which can be expanded in multiples of four (courtesy of hte Aktiengesellschaft).
Different implementations of such reactors may differ in detail. For instance, in some cases the flow to the analytical instrument is additionally controlled by a mass flow controller, so that at least during the analysis all catalysts are evaluated at exactly the same space velocity. In other setups, which will be discussed below, a truly parallelized analysis is integrated into the reactor, which allows the elimination of the multiport valve. The general features of such reactors, however, can be summarized as those of a multitubular fixed bed. Critical issues in operating such parallel reactors have been discussed by Moulijn et al. [33], who also had published one of the first prototypes of a parallel reactor, the so-called six-flow reactor [34]. As mentioned above, zeolite catalyzed reactions are complicated by the fact that deactivation easily occurs. This can only be fully solved by truly parallelized analysis, such as provided by the FPA IR systems. Alternatively, if sequential analysis is used, sequential start of the reaction in the different channels is an alternative, so that all catalysts are compared at the same time on stream. However, this requires rather complex valve schemes which are difficult to implement. As a simpler solution, the catalysts performance is analyzed several times in different cycles, so that for each catalyst an activity pattern over time is obtained.
173
One has to keep in mind in these cases, though, that the times-on-stream at which performance is sampled, differ for each catalyst. One other problem, which is not unique for zeolites, but occurs in many zeolite catalyzed reactions, is the fact that gas volumes change during reaction. This makes it more difficult to ensure equal space velocity over all zeolites. If the flow restrictors, for instance capillaries, are placed in front of the catalyst bed, the influence of changing volumes can be minimized. If the restrictors are downstream of the catalyst, additional flow controlling elements have to be incorporated, such as a mass flow controller in the analysis line (to a first approximation not sensitive to changed volume flow). A last problem is the fact that in zeolite catalyzed reactions often high boiling products are formed, either as the desired product, but more often via unwanted side reactions. Such products can be deposited in the multiport valves and lead to clogging of individual ports and build-up of pressure. Most commercial multiport valves capable of handling high pressures cannot be heated to more than 80°C which is not sufficient for many problems. We are operating home built valves which can be used up to 100 bar pressure and a temperature of 200°C. Such systems, however, are complex and require a high level of maintenance. 4.2. High-throughput studies of the performance of zeolite catalysts A number of papers have already been published where high-throughput methods were used for the evaluation of the catalytic performance of zeolitic materials. However, so far these investigations can be considered more as feasibility studies than as targeted at real catalyst discovery. Questions of significance of the recorded data and reproducibility of the results were in the focus of the attention while for real discoveries the programs typically did not have sufficiently broad scope. A particularly thorough study of the influence of the mode of operation of parallel reactors, such as bed dilution, for the example of N2O decomposition over ZSM-5 based catalysts was published by Moulijn et al. [33].
Fig. 7. Main reactions in the aldol condensation of acetone. The different products could reliably be detected in the products stream of an 80 channel reactor filled with different zeolite catalysts by quantitative mass spectrometry (reproduced with kind permission from [35]).
Wang et al. [35] studied various different zeolite catalysts in the aldol condensation of acetone. This reaction is an interesting benchmark, since several different products can be
174
expected for different zeolite catalysts (Fig. 7). As a special feature of the reactor, which was of the general type as discussed above, a low melting alloy was used as heat transfer medium. This ensured a very homogeneous temperature distribution over the 80 channels of the reactor. Equal contact time for catalysts in all channels was ensured by measuring firstly the flow through each channel (deviations between channels around 10 %) and then adjusting the amount of catalyst accordingly. Changes in the gas volume due to reaction were not considered, however, acetone diluted in argon was used, and the system was operated at rather low conversions of around 10 %. Volume changes can therefore be neglected when catalysts are evaluated. Products were analyzed by quantitative mass spectrometry, which needed 8 seconds per channel (3 s measurement time and 5 s flushing times). Duplicates were tested in this system, and the selectivities were rather well reproduced with the exception of compounds formed at low conversion with a low selectivity. Such compounds are present in the gas at concentration well below 1 % and quantitative mass spectrometry becomes difficult in such cases. Trends in selectivities for different zeolites with acidic or basic sites agreed with previous reports. Further conclusions, however, were not drawn from this study. Jacobs et al. showed in a feasibility study that it is possible to obtain meaningful kinetic data using a high-throughput reactor [36]. Decane hydroisomerization was studied over Pt-loaded ultrastabilized Y type zeolites. Complete analysis of the complex product mixture could be achieved in 3.2 minutes using a multicapillary column, and the kinetic data obtained agreed well with those of a kinetic model derived for a conventional reactor. The group of Corma used a high-throughput reactor more as a tool to develop a deeper understanding of a catalytic system, i.e. the dealkylation/transalkalation of alkyl-aromatics over zeolite catalysts by screening a number of zeolites with different pore topology [37]. This is the state which should eventually be reached when high-throughput systems are standard laboratory tools, as they are becoming in a number of groups dealing with heterogeneous catalysis. It is possible to use them as discovery tools, screening many different samples and reaction conditions, but they can also strongly accelerate the understanding of catalytic processes by providing a broader database from which correlations between catalyst properties and performance can be established. The authors used a 16 channel reactor at a pressure of 25 bar and a temperature of 400°C and studied zeolite catalysts with different ring sizes and pore connectivity. A clear correlation between the dealkylation selectivity for ethylbenzene and the zeolite pore volume was observed. Dealkylation selectivity increased with decreasing pore volume. In addition, toluene, which is formed by a bimolecular reaction as a primary product, is also favoured by specific pore systems, with that of zeolite beta and ITQ-23 being the most favourable ones. This study showed, that the combination of high-throughput reactors with properly designed experiments can accelerate the understanding of the catalytic action, in this case of zeolites. The papers discussed so far used the general setup described under section 4.1, i.e. multiport valves for flow selection. However, as stated above, for reactions were deactivation may be a problem, truly parallelized analysis techniques are superior. Some techniques had been described in the earlier publications on high-throughput catalysis research, such as IR thermography [38,39] or Resonance Enhanced Multi Photon Ionization (REMPI) [40]. However, while the first technique does not provide selectivity information and is therefore not suitable for a stage II screening, the second one is rather specific and complex to use, and therefore does not seem to have been used in a real discovery program. Also other parallel methods, such as photoacoustic detection [41] and selective reagent detection [42] have not been used in connection with zeolite catalysts, since also these techniques are rather specific and not generally applicable.
175
Somewhat related to both the REMPI method and the photoacoustic detection is laser induced fluorescence imaging (LIFI) analysis, since it also uses selective optical excitation of molecules in the gas phase leaving a catalyst bed. This technique has been developed as a parallel method to be used for the analysis of catalyst libraries and was also applied for zeolites by Su and Yeung [43]. Here a laser beam tuned to an absorption band of the molecule to be detected is passed through the gas streams leaving the reactor, and in those plumes where the molecule is present fluorescence light is emitted, which can be detected using an imaging system. The authors studied the acylation of benzene by phthalic anhydride over various different zeolites. Only zeolite beta was found to be active in this reaction, and fast deactivation processes on time scales of minutes were observed at high temperatures around 300°C. Picking up such fast deactivation was only possible due to the parallel mode of the analysis. However, the data recorded in this mode are not highly precise, and LIFI is more an analytical method for stage I screening. We have recently used FPA IR imaging to analyze the products from pentane hydroisomerization over different zeolite catalysts. The problem in the use of IR imaging to detect products of a catalytic reaction in a parallel flow-through cuvette, as described by Lauterbach and coworkers [18,19,20,21] and us [44] is the fact that degrees of parallelization going substantially beyond 16 creates a major plumbing problem in connecting the outlets of the parallel reactor channels to the parallel gas cuvette. In order to study pentane hydroisomerization catalysts in a higher integrated system we have developed a reflection setup [45]. Since in a reflection setup the reactor can directly be attached to the cuvette, much higher degrees of parallelization are possible, in our case we realized a 7x7 channel array, i.e. 49 channels. The gases leave the channels of the reactor through a pinhole in a gold coated metal piece which serves as the reflection mirror in the gas cuvette (Fig. 8).
Fig. 8. (a) Schematic drawing of the reflection cell for the FPA IR system. On the left is the reactor. Gas leaves the reactor through gold coated nozzles and directly enters the 49 gas cuvettes. The gold coated nozzles serve also as mirror for reflection of the IR beam. At the outlet of the individual cuvette tubes the gases mix, but the pathlength of the IR beam through the mixed gas is only about l/50th of the pathlength in the cuvette, so that the error is negligible, (b) FPA readout. The 7x7 pattern plots the integrated intensity. Upper spectrum is for one pixel, lower spectrum is the averaged spectrum for a group of pixels belonging to one channel. The ratio of the bands at around 1400 cm"1 gives information on the ratio of n-pentane and i-pentane. Reproduced with permission from ref. [45].
In an evaluation of the setup, pentane hydroisomerization at temperatures up to 300°C over different zeolite based catalysts Pt-MOR was carried out. The catalysts had been pretreated at different temperatures, ranging from 300°C to 800°C. As expected, pre-calcination at intermediate temperature between 500 and 600°C produced the most active catalysts. At lower temperatures autoreduction of platinum and generation of the H-form of the zeolite are
176
not complete, at too high temperatures, the platinum particles sinter and the zeolite framework is destroyed. Conversions could be determined with a relative error of 20%. This is not satisfactory for stage II screening, but for stage I screening it is more than sufficient. In addition, for other reactions much lower errors are expected, since the strongly overlapping bands of iso- and n-pentane made the product analysis very difficult. Finally, a non-catalytic high-throughput study of zeolitic materials shall be mentioned. Atienzar et al. [46] have developed a parallelized photoluminescence setup, which allows spatially and time resolved recording of photoluminescence spectra. This system was used to study various zeolites in which luminescent poly (p-phenylenevinylene) was encapsulated as well as zeolites with 2,4,6-triphenylpyrylium which can be used as photocatalysts. The highthroughput photoluminescence setup was used to quickly optimize the synthesis of the two ship-in-a-bottle systems. 5. LIBRARY DESIGN AND DATA ANALYSIS The more advanced a high-throughput program in catalysis becomes the more important are intelligent design of the libraries and efficient methods for "knowledge extraction" which are typically computer based. These fields are at present still in their infancy, and applications in zeolite science are scarce. Nevertheless, as these problems are highly relevant in highthroughput experimentation, they should at least briefly be addressed. When a library of catalysts for a specific problem shall be created, the question arises, how the members of the library should be selected. Established procedures are those based on factorial design rules or other methods to effectively screen a large parameter space. The only previous information such an approach needs is the range of parameters to be explored, i.e. knowledge about synthesis conditions which are likely to result in the formation of zeolites is necessary in synthetic work, or ideas what kinds of catalysts would perform well in a given transformation have to be supplied. If the boundaries of the search space are given, then well known design-of-experiment (DoE) tools can be used for optimal mapping of the search space. ouCii a idCtondi ucSigii Siuuy ui z-cuiiicS udS, IUI in&ttiiit;c, uccn pciiuiincu uy lagjuituuc ci di.
recently, using the multiclave setup already mentioned above [13]. More chemical information enters the planning of zeolite libraries, if the method suggested by Chen and Deem is used [47]. These authors calculate a figure of merit which serves as the basis for the library design, based on the contributions of structure directing agent and zeolite composition. This study, however, so far only provided a concept, and no experimental implementation has been reported, yet. If several rounds of optimization, either in synthesis or in catalysis, are envisaged, then other, possibly more efficient methods are available. Genetic algorithms, which try to mimic natural evolution, are such a method. The concept shall briefly be described for a catalytic reaction using a catalyst which contains up to eight different elements (Fig. 9). First a set of catalysts is prepared, for instance by a random approach, and evaluated in the target reaction. Catalysts are encoded like a gene, as indicated in Fig. 9. The best performing catalysts are then selected for further optimization. Based on these selected samples, a new library is generated by two operations, mutation, i.e. adding or removing single elements, or cross-over, i.e. exchanging larger parts of the "genes". Then the new library is evaluated, the best samples selected, modified by mutation and cross-over, and so on, until no further significant improvement in performance is reached. Such schemes have been implemented for the development of different catalysts (for instance in [48,49]). As far as the author is aware, no genetic algorithm scheme has been used for the optimization of zeolitic materials, but the
177
work of Serra et al. [49] was directed at least at the optimization of related systems, such as modified acidic zirconia, titania and alumina, used for hydroisomerization of n-pentane.
Fig. 9. Principle of a genetic algorithm in catalyst development. An initial library is created. Elements present in a catalyst are encoded by the light grey color. In a first evaluation, the most active catalysts are selected, indicated by the arrows, as the basis for the next generation. By using "mutation", exchange of one element, or "cross-over", exchange of parts of the code for two catalysts, a new generation is created, which is subjected to the same process.
Genetic algorithms can be useful methods to efficiently approach (at least a local) optimum in a given system, because it feeds-in information from previous experiments in a way which well balances preservation of information and introduction of new elements, if the parameters of the algorithm, such as mutation rate, are properly chosen. Another software based method, which helps to discover connections between parameters describing the catalysts and their performance, are artificial neural networks (ANNs). These techniques seem to have first been introduced by Hattori in heterogeneous catalysis [50], but were not widely used subsequently. However, in recent years, with the advent of high-throughput experimentation, ANNs are receiving increasing attention as a means to predict the performance of catalysts. In an ANN, parameters describing the solids, such as composition, are used as the input layer. The input layer is connected by so-called "hidden layers" with the output layer, which gives the performance of the catalysts. Nodes in the layers are connected by links, which can be considered as transfer functions, influencing data flow from input to output layer. Like in a biological neural network, pathways between input and output layers are amplified, if they are often used, and become weaker, if they are not used. During the training of the network, both input and output layers are known, and by entering for each sample parameters and catalytic performance, the connections in the hidden layers are established. These connections then are able to predict with some degree of certainty also the performance
178
of catalysts, which have not been used in the training step. In zeolite science, such a system has already been used in the 1990s, where the performance of Cu-ZSM-5 catalysts in NO decomposition has been predicted [51]. However, the data set used in this study was rather small, and much bigger data sets and thus more sophisticated ANNs can be generated using the now available techniques of high-throughput experimentation. A more fundamental method to guide the search for novel material relies on so-called descriptors. Descriptors are combinations of properties of solids which are correlated with a target performance. For predicting structural properties of zeolites, descriptors have been developed by Rajagopalan et al. [52]. The descriptor includes properties such as lattice constants, space group, point group, crystal system, presence of certain symmetry elements, ratios of lattice constants and others, and this set of descriptors allowed the prediction of ring sizes of zeolites or M-O bond length. The descriptors described by Rajagopalan et al. were created for a rather specific problem, the prediction of structural features of zeolites. Recently, more comprehensive approaches to the design of libraries and knowledge extraction have been suggested. We proposed a method, by which a so-called descriptor vector is generated for solid catalysts based on the performance of the catalysts in a target reaction [53]. This method has been implemented and has been shown to work for the example of propene oxidation [54,55]. Using the method, the performance of solids in the oxidation of propene to different products could be predicted with a certainty by far exceeding statistical expectation values, although extremely different materials were investigated. A full description of the approach is beyond the scope of this contribution, and thus the reader is referred to the original literature. A somewhat different, but also very comprehensive method was suggested by Caruthers et al. [56,57]. They describe a "knowledge extraction engine" which models the reaction network based on a set of reaction rules. These reaction rules are formulated by a human expert and then implemented in a simplified, but still very complex kinetic model. Using software based methods, this initial set of rules is refined to model the actual behaviour of the reaction system. The part of the knowledge extraction engine describing the kinetics is already well advanced in this system. However, for a full understanding of the system, also the features of the catalyst have to be correlated with the kinetic constants. In order to achieve this kind of modelling, suitable descriptors have to be found to capture the relevant properties of the catalysts, which brings the problem back to the one formulated in the previous paragraph. The case study provided by Caruthers et al. was directed to a problem from zeolite science, i.e. the aromatization of propane over H-ZSM-5. For this particular catalytic problem, the kinetic model was in fact developed to a point, where predictions for different reaction conditions agreed quite well with the experimental data. 6. PERSPECTIVES The different components of an integrated high-throughput approach for zeolite science are in different stages of development. While synthesis, part of the characterization, and catalytic testing are already well developed and in several laboratories used on a routine basis, software based tools for the design of libraries and the extraction of knowledge from the vast amounts of data are still in their infancy. Depending on the type of the problem to be studied, it can be useful to employ conventional methods or to resort to high-throughput experimentation. However, it seems clear that high-throughput experimentation is a powerful methodology in zeolite research, and over the next years, probably most laboratories active in zeolite research will implement such methods to some extent, either in a fully integrated mode, which for cost
179 reasons will mostly be restricted to industrial laboratories, or with selected elements only, which provide the crucial functionality for a given project. While still many of the systems are home built and specifically developed to solve a problem at hand, more and more systems, such as those for synthesis or for catalytic testing, are becoming commercially available, which will significantly speed up the penetration of research laboratories with these technologies. REFERENCES [I] [2] [3] [4] [5] [6] [7] [8] [9] [10] [II] [12] [13] [14] [15] [16] [17] [18] [19] [20] [21] [22] [23] [24] [25] [26] [27]
X.D. Xiang, X. Sun, G. Briceno, Y. Lou, K.-A. Wang, H. Chang, W.G. Wallace-Freedman, S.W. Chen, and P.G. Schultz, Science, 268 (1995) 1738. J. Hanak, J. Mater. Sci., 5 (1970) 964. Recently reviewed in: F. Schiith, Ann. Rev. Mater. Sci., in press Reviewed in: J.M. Newsam, T. Bein, J. Klein, W.F. Maier, and W. Stichert, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 48 (2001) 355. D. Akporiaye, I.M. Dahl, A. Karlsson, and R. Wendelbo, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 37 (1998) 609. J. Klein, C.W. Lehmann, H.-W. Schmidt, and W.F. Maier, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 37 (1998) 3369. K. Choi, D. Gardner, N. Hilbrandt, and T. Bein, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 38 (1999) 2891. N. Stock, N. Hilbrandt, K. Choi, and T. Bein. Stud. Surf. Sci. Catal. 135 (2001) 550 (on CD). N. Stock and T. Bein, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 43 (2004) 749. R. Lai, B.S. Khang, G.R. Gavalas, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 40 (2001) 408. D. Akporiaye, I. Dahl, A. Karlsson, M. Plassen, R. Wendelbo, D.S. Bern, R.W.Broach, G. J. Lewis, M. Miller, and J. Moscoso, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 48 (2001) 367. J. Song, J. Yu, G. Li, Y. Li, Y. Wang, and R. Xu, Chem. Commun., (2002) 1720. M. Tagliabue, L.C. Carluccio, D. Ghisletti, C. Perego, Catal. Today, 81 (2003) 405. M. Schuster and H. Gobel, J.Phys. D: Appl. Phys., 28 (1995) A270. J. Scheidtmann, P.A. Weiss, and W.F. Maier, Appl. Catal. A, 222 (2001) 79. J. Klein, T. Zech, J.M. Newsam, and S.A. Schunk, Appl. Catal. A, 254 (2003) 121. Y. Sun, B.C. Chan, R. Ramnarayanan, W.M. Leventry, T.E. Mallouk, S.R. Bare, and R.R. Willis, J. Combin. Chem., 4 (2002) 569. CM. Snively, S. Katzenberger, and G. Oskarsdottir, J. Lauterbach, Opt. Lett., 24 (1999) 1841. CM. Snively, G. Oskarsdottir, and J. Lauterbach, Catal. Today, 67 (2001) 357. CM. Snively, G. Oskarsdottir, and J. Lauterbach, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 40 (2001) 3028. R.J. Hendershot, P.T. Fanson, CM. Snively, and J.A. Lauterbach, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 42 (2003) 1152. O. Busch, W. Brijoux, S. Thomson, and F. Schiith, J. Catal., 222 (2004) 174. P. Kubanek, H.-W. Schmidt, B. Spliethoff, and F. Schiith, Microporous Mesoporous Mater., 77 (2005) 89. R.J. Gorte, in: F. Schuth, K.S.W. Sing, J. Weitkamp(eds.), Handbook of Porous Solids, WileyVCH, Weinheim, 2002, p. 432. H. Wang, Z. Liu, J. Chen, and H. Liu, Catal. Commun., 5 (2004) 55. C. Hoffmann, A. Wolf, and F. Schuth, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 38 (1999) 2800. A. van Veen, D. Farrusseng, M. Rebeilleau, T. Decamp, A. Holzwarth, Y. Schuurman, and C. Mirodatos, J. Catal., 216 (2003) 135.
180 [28] J.M. Newsam and F. Schuth, Biotechnol. Bioeng., 61 (1999) 203. [29] A. Hagemeyer, B. Jandeleit, Y.M. Liu, D.M. Poojary, H.W. Turner, A.F.Volpe, and W.H. Weinberg, Appl. Catal. A, 221 (2001) 23. [30] S. Senkan, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 40 (2001) 312. [31] C. Hoffmann, H.-W. Schmidt, and F. Schuth, J. Catal., 198 (2001) 348. [32] C. Kiener, M. Kurtz, H. Wilmer, C. Hoffmann, H.-W. Schmidt, J.D. Grundwaldt, M Muhler, and F. Schuth, J. Catal., 216 (2003 110. [33] J.A. Moulijn, J. Perez-Ramirez, R.J. Berger, P. Hamminaga, G. Mul, and F. Kapteijn, Catal. Today, 81 (2003)547. [34] R. Thomas, J.A. Moulijn, V.H.J. de Beer, and J. Medema, J. Mol. Catal. 8 (1980) 161. [35] H. Wang, Z. Liu, and J. Shen, J. Combin. Chem., 5 (2003) 802. [36] W. Huybrechts, J. Mijoin, P.A. Jacobs, J.A. Martens, Appl. Catal. A, 243 (2003) 1. [37] J.M. Serra, E. Guillon, and A. Corma, J. Catal., 227 (2004) 459. [38] F.C. Moates, M. Somani, J. Annamalai, J.T. Richardson, D. Luss, and R.C. Wilson, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 35(1996)4801. [39] A. Holzwarth, H.-W. Schmidt, and W.F. Maier, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 37 (1998) 2644. [40] S.M. Senkan, Nature, 394 (1998) 350. [41] T. Johann, A. Brenner, O. Busch, F. Marlow, S. Schunk, and F. Schuth, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed., 41 (2002) 2966. [42] O. Busch, C. Hoffmann, T. Johann, H.W. Schmidt, W. Strehlau, and F. Schuth, J. Am. Chem. Soc, 124 (2002) 13527. [43] H. Su and E.S. Yeung, Appl. Spectrosc, 56 (2002) 1044. [44] F. Schuth, O. Busch, C. Hoffmann, C. Kiener, T. Johann, J. Klein, S. Schunk, W. Strehlau, and T. Zech, Top. Catal., 21 (2002) 55. [45] P. Kubanek, O. Busch, S. Thomson, H.-W. Schmidt, and F. Schuth, J. Combin. Chem., 6 (2004) 420. [46] P. Atienzar, A. Corma, H. Garcia, J.M. Serra, Chem. Eur. J. 10 (2004) 6043. [47] L. Chen and M.W. Deem, Mol. Phys., 100 (2002) 2175. [48] for instance: D. Wolf, O. V. Buyevskaya, and M. Baerns, Appl. Catal. A 200 (2000) 63. [49] J.M. Serra, A. Chica, and A. Corma, Appl. Catal. A 239 (2003) 35. [50] S. Kito, T. Hattori, and Y. Murakami, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 31 (1992) 979. [51] M. Sasaki, H. Hamada, Y. Kintaichi, and T. Ito, Appl. Catal. A, 132 (1995) 261. [52] A. Rajagopalan, C. Suh, X. Li, and K. Rajan, Appl. Catal. A, 254 (2003) 147. [53] C. Klanner, D. Farrusseng, L. Baumes, C. Mirodatos, and F. Schuth, QSAR - Combinatorial Sciences 22 (2003) 729. [54] C. Klanner, D. Farrusseng, L. Baumes, C. Mirodatos, and F. Schuth, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 43 (2004) 5347. [55] D. Farrusseng, C. Klanner, L. Baumes, M. Lengliz, C. Mirodatos, and F. Schuth, QSAR Combinatorial Sciences, 24 (2005). [56] J.M. Caruthers, J.A. Lauterbach, K.T. Thomson, V. Venketasubramanian, CM. Snively, A. Bhan, S. Katare, and G. Oskarsdottir, J. Catal., 216 (2003) 98. [57] S. Katare, J.M. Caruthers, W.N. Delgass, and V. Venketasubramanian, Ind. Eng. Chem. Res., 43 (2004) 3484.
Studies in Surface Science and Catalysis 157 J. Cejka and H. van Bekkum (Editors) © 2005 Elsevier B.V. All rights reserved.
Ion-exchange properties of zeolites A. Dyer Institute of Materials Science, University of Salford, Cockcroft Building, Salford M5 4WT,United Kingdom.
1. INTRODUCTION 2. ZEOLITE ION EXCHANGE THEORY 2.1. Cation exchange equilibria 2.1.1. Introduction to the theory 2.1.2. The binary ion exchange process 2.1.3. Analysis of isotherms to provide thermodynamic data 2.1.4. Eisenman theory 2.1.5. Zeolites as model cation exchangers 2.1.6. Zeolite cation exchange as a diffusion controlled process 2.1.7. Column models 3. CATION EXCHANGE PROPERTIES OF INDIVIDUAL ZEOLITES 3.1 Introduction 3.1.1. Analcime ANA 3.1.2. ChabaziteCHA 3.1.3. Clinoptilolite HEU 3.1.4. Edingtonite EDI 3.1.5. ErioniteERI 3.1.6. FaujasiteFAU 3.1.7. Ferrierite FER 3.1.8. Gismondine GIS 3.1.9. KFI Zeolite ZK5 (previously described as P and Q) 3.1.10. Laumontite LAU 3.1.11. LTA Zeolite A 3.1.12. Merlinoite MER 3.1.13. MFI ZSM-5 (and other " high silica" zeolites) 3.1.14. Mordenite MOR 3.1.15. Phillipsite PHI 3.1.16. StilbiteSTI 3.1.17. Summary 4. USE OF ZEOLITES AS CATION EXCHANGERS IN COMMERCE AND THE ENVIRONMENT 4.1. Detergency 4.2. Water treatment 4.3. Nuclear waste treatment and accident legacy solutions 4.4. Other comments REFERENCES
181
182
1. INTRODUCTION The phenomenon of ion exchange is thought to be the oldest physical process known to man, dating back to descriptions in the Bible and the writings of Aristotle. It was also the first property of zeolites to be studied scientifically when, in 1858, Eichorn [1] showed that the natural zeolites chabazite and natrolite were capable of reversible cation exchange. Gans, at the turn of the 19* century, synthesised aluminosilicate materials capable of water softening. He called them " Permutits" and for many years they were employed as domestic and industrial water softeners, as well as in the treatment of nuclear waste. This, together with the first identification of "base exchange" in soils (Way [2] and Thompson [3]), led to the misunderstandings perpetuated in elementary texts that zeolites are responsible for the ion-exchange in soils, and that they are widely used as water softeners. In truth the clay minerals contribute mainly to the ability of soils to take up cations, such as ammonium, and Permutits were amorphous materials with low cation exchange capacities and limited chemical stability. Zeolites are, of course, crystalline by definition and the cation exchange properties of traditional aluminosilicate zeolites arise from the isomorphous positioning of aluminium in tetrahedral coordination within their Si/Al frameworks. This imposes a net negative charge on the framework (Si4+-» Al3+) counterbalanced by cations held within the cavities and channels. This is said to create facile cation exchange " lubricated" by the water molecules also present in the voids within the framework. This certainly is so for zeolites with open frameworks but in some of the more narrow-pored frameworks, such as natrolite, cation replacement is slow and difficult. R.M. Barrer commenced detailed studies of zeolites in the mid 1930s, and was responsible for the establishment of the basic equilibrium and kinetic thermodynamic interpretation of zeolite cation exchange properties [5]. Part of the driving force for these early studies came from the discovery that the introduction of different cations into zeolites was of critical importance to the modification of their catalytic, molecular sieve and drying properties. An additional interest came from the realisation that zeolites were ideal models for the development of cation exchange theory because, unlike organic resin exchangers, their framework structures did not appreciably swell on contact with water. The bulk of these investigations were directed to synthetic species, in accord with their commercial significance. Interest on natural zeolites has, in the main, focussed on their availability as economic, and abundant, materials for water treatment and environmental clean-up. Overall, study has shown that zeolites exhibit unique abilities to selectively take up specific cations from mixtures with other cations- even when the competing cations are present at much higher solution concentrations. Zeolites also have high cation exchange capacities (CEC). This chapter will first provide an insight into cation exchange theory as it relates to zeolites, with details of individual properties of the common synthetic and natural species, including details of those having industrial significance 2. ZEOLITE ION EXCHANGE THEORY 2.1. Cation exchange equilibria 2.1.1. Introduction to the theory The following theoretical approach assumes;
183
(a) the system is in a true state of equilibrium (b) the exchange process is fully reversible. If the system is not reversible then there will be two different reactions (one representing the forward exchange, and another the reverse exchange) that need to be examined separately. They will have different standard Gibbs energies. It is worth noting here that the following theory is a rigorous thermodynamic approach and is, by its nature, exact and so can be applied to all cation exchangers [6,7]. 2.1.2. The binary ion exchange process The exchange between a cation A 2A , initially in solution (the ingoing ion), and a cation B ZB , initially in the zeolite (the out-going or counter ion) can be written as: ZB^2-*
+ZABZB
<->
ZB~AZ*
+Z
A
5
Z
*
(1)
ZA,B are the valencies of the ions , and characters with a bar as a superscript refer to a cation inside the zeolite lattice. If the zeolite is contacted with a series of isonormal solutions, constituted from differing proportions of the in-going and counter cations, an ion exchange isotherm can be constructed at a standard condition of temperature and pressure, to yield the distribution of cations between zeolite and solution phases when equilibrium has been reached (checked by prior kinetic tests). It is also imperative that the ratio of the volume of solution (mL) in contact with a known mass of zeolite (g) be at least 20, and larger if experimentally feasible. The correct experimental methodology has been fully described by Dyer et al. [8], and reinforced by Townsend [9], who emphasises the importance of carrying out complete analyses of both solid and liquid phases. This enables an isotherm to be plotted recording the equivalent fraction ( A s ) of the in-going cation in solution against its equivalent fraction in the zeolite (A z ). These quantities can be defined as,
As = ZAmA/(ZAmA + ZBmB) and Az
= ZAMA/( ZAMA + ZBMB)
(2)
mAjniB and MA,MB are the cation concentrations (mol dm"3) in solution and solid phases respectively. Idealised isotherm shapes are shown in Fig.l. They give a pictorial indication of the relative preferences of the cations for the solid and solution phases. When the zeolite phase has equal affinity for both cations the isotherm is a straight line — the dotted line in Fig.l. Isotherm (2) is the shape adopted when A remains in solution i.e, does not readily displace B from the zeolite phase, at the conditions of temperature and concentration of the experiment. Isotherm (3) occurs when A replaces B from the zeolite. The sigmoidal shape of (1) arises when a change in selectivity occurs, in the concentration range being studied, and is indicative of more than one exchange sites being available in the zeolite for the competing cations.
184
The selectivity of a zeolite for ion A can be expressed quantitatively as a separation factor (a) viz:
a=AzmB/BzmA
(3)
where, by definition,
Bz=l-Az
(4)
Fig. 1. Idealised cation exchange isotherms In Fig.l a can be estimated for isotherm (1) from the ratio of area (a) to area (b). Often isotherms representing incomplete exchange are observed. An example of this is sketched in Fig.2. Here the exchange process has reached an equilibrium without the in-going ions being able to replace all the counter ions from the zeolite phase, under the temperature and concentration conditions employed. Under these circumstances it is necessary to " normalise" the isotherm to gain thermodynamic information. This does not compromise the solution activity correction but it clearly does influence the equilibrium constant and zeolite activity coefficients, and the definition of the standard state. In effect the normalisation procedure regards those counter ions not involved in the exchange as part of the exchanger framework [6]. A fuller consideration of the normalisation, and its theoretical justification, can be found in Barrer et al. [10]. As emphasised earlier, to apply thermodynamic analyses to isotherm data it is imperative that the process be demonstrably reversible. In some zeolites the path of the reverse isotherm deviates markedly from that of the forward exchange (Fig.3). This is described as "hysteresis" and can arise from small errors in analysis, but often it is a consequence of changes in occupancy of heteroenergetic cation sites created by drying the zeolite samples prior to their use in generating the reverse curve. Other causes are the
185
incidence of unsuspected ternary exchange, the presence of phase separation and the coexistence of two phases over the composition range studied, or even the precipitation of metal oxide/hydroxides on the zeolite external surface. Further discussion of these points will be considered later.
Fig. 2. Incomplete exchange of Na<-»l/2 Zn in zeolite EUO, forward isotherm • reverse +.
Fig. 3. Isotherms showing hysteresis
Not all isotherms in the literature have been constructed in the formal ways described above. Often they arise from contacting the zeolite with solutions containing only the in-going cation, only one ion is analysed in one phase and various units of concentration are used. These simple approaches can be useful to compare practical selectivities, but when thermodynamic data is required from interpretation of the isotherms, the more rigorous methodology must be followed, with confirmation of full reversibility in order to apply the laws of mass action. When measurements are attempted to construct the reverse leg of the
186
isotherm it is appropriate not to dry zeolites as heating can change the number of cation sites partaking in the ion exchange process. Another simple approach comes from the realisation that each point on the isotherm represents the distribution of ions between the phases. At each point a distribution coefficient (K D ) can be defined for ion A : KD= CJCS
(5)
C z is the concentration of ion A per unit mass of anhydrous zeolite and Cs the concentration of A per unit volume of external solution Distribution coefficients are widely used as convenient checks of practical selectivities under fixed experimental conditions, provided equilibrium has been reached. Examples of this approach are often concerned with comparisons of the ability of zeolites to scavenge toxic metals from solution. 2.1.3. Analysis of isotherms to provide thermodynamic data For a fully reversible isotherm the mass action quotient (Km) can be used to define the process, as with any reversible chemical reaction, namely: Km= Az" mzBA/ BZA mz"
(6)
This leads to the determination of the thermodynamic constant (Ka); Ka=KmT{ fz"lfz')
(7)
where, F=yz//yz/
(8)
yA and yB are the single cation activity coefficients of A Z/> and B ZB , respectively, in solution, and/,, B the activity coefficients of the same cations in the zeolite phase. Ka can be obtained by graphical integration of a plot of In Km T against Az ( or by an analytical integration of the polynomial that provides the computed best fit to the experimental data). The quantity Km T can be described as: Kc=KmT
(9)
Kc is known as the Kielland coefficient and is related to Ka by the simplified Gaines and Thomas [11] equation:
187
\nKa=
(ZB-ZA)+
J lnKcdAz
(10)
0
Values for y A B cannot be determined but Y is accessible from the mean stoichiometric activity coefficients in mixed salt solutions via equation (8) thus:
r-rz,'ir'"-
ttr'£'}*A'-'z''nr'Sl
*•*''*-z'h1'2*
(n)
In equation (11) Zx is the charge on the common anion. an T+BV d Y(±AX can be calculated from y±AX and y±BX (Glueckauf [12]). fA B are available from the Gibbs-Duhem equation. Having obtained Ka, a value of AGe arises from: AGe = -(RT In
tfJZ^Z,
(12)
AGe is the standard free energy per equivalent of charge; R and T have their usual meanings. The standard states of the zeolite exchanger relate to respective homoionic forms of the zeolite i