Literary Criticism and Cultural Theory
Edited by
William E. Cain Professor of English Wellesley College
A Routledge ...
25 downloads
954 Views
3MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Literary Criticism and Cultural Theory
Edited by
William E. Cain Professor of English Wellesley College
A Routledge Series
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 1
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
Literary Criticism and Cultural Theory William E. Cain, General Editor Overheard Voices Address and Subjectivity in Postmodern American Poetry Ann Keniston
Between the Angle and the Curve Mapping Gender, Race, Space, and Identity in Willa Cather and Toni Morrison Danielle Russell
Museum Mediations Reframing Ekphrasis in Contemporary American Poetry Barbara K. Fischer
Rhizosphere Gilles Deleuze and the “Minor” American Writings of William James, W.E.B. Du Bois, Gertrude Stein, Jean Toomer, and William Faulkner Mary F. Zamberlin
The Politics of Melancholy from Spenser to Milton Adam H. Kitzes Urban Revelations Images of Ruin in the American City, 1790–1860 Donald J. McNutt Postmodernism and Its Others The Fiction of Ishmael Reed, Kathy Acker, and Don DeLillo Jeffrey Ebbesen Different Dispatches Journalism in American Modernist Prose David T. Humphries Divergent Visions, Contested Spaces The Early United States through the Lens of Travel Jeffrey Hotz “Like Parchment in the Fire” Literature and Radicalism in the English Civil War Prasanta Chakravarty
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 2
The Spell Cast by Remains The Myth of Wilderness in Modern American Literature Patricia A. Ross Strange Cases The Medical Case History and the British Novel Jason Daniel Tougaw Revisiting Vietnam Memoirs, Memorials, Museums Julia Bleakney Equity in English Renaissance Literature Thomas More and Edmund Spenser Andrew J. Majeske “You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” Culture, Ideology, and Action in the Gastonia Novels of Myra Page, Grace Lumpkin, and Olive Dargan Wes Mantooth
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” Culture, Ideology, and Action in the Gastonia Novels of Myra Page, Grace Lumpkin, and Olive Dargan
Wes Mantooth
Routledge New York & London
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 3
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
Permissions From In a Generous Spirit: A First-Person Biography of Myra Page by Christina Looper Baker. Copyright © 1996 by the Board of Trustees of the University of Illinois. Used with permission of the University of Illinois Press. Introduction to Chief Aderholt by Woody Guthrie © Copyright 1967 by Woody Guthrie Publications, Inc. All rights reserved. Used by permission. From Tobacco Road to Route 66: The Southern Poor White in Fiction by Sylvia Jenkins Cook. Copyright © 1976 by the University of North Carolina Press. Used by permission of the publisher. From the South Carolina Library’s Grace Lumpkin Papers. Used with permission. From Call Home the Heart by Fielding Burke. Copyright © 1983 by The Feminist Press. Used with per‑ mission of The Feminist Press, www.feministpress.org/. Routledge Taylor & Francis Group 270 Madison Avenue New York, NY 10016
Routledge Taylor & Francis Group 2 Park Square Milton Park, Abingdon Oxon OX14 4RN
© 2006 by Taylor & Francis Group, LLC Routledge is an imprint of Taylor & Francis Group, an Informa business Printed in the United States of America on acid‑free paper 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 International Standard Book Number‑10: 0‑415‑97758‑4 (Hardcover) International Standard Book Number‑13: 978‑0‑415‑97758‑6 (Hardcover) No part of this book may be reprinted, reproduced, transmitted, or utilized in any form by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying, microfilming, and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without written permission from the publishers. Trademark Notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation without intent to infringe. Library of Congress Cataloging‑in‑Publication Data Mantooth, Wes, 1970‑ “You factory folks who sing this rhyme will surely understand” : culture, ideology, and action in the Gastonia novels of Myra Page, Grace Lumpkin, and Olive Dargan / by Wes Mantooth. p. cm. ‑‑ (Literary criticism and cultural theory) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0‑415‑97758‑4 (acid‑free paper) 1. merican fiction‑‑20th century‑‑History and criticism. 2. rikes and lockouts in literature. 3. T tile industry in literature. 4. La r movement in literature. 5. Gas nia (N.C.)‑‑In literature. 6. Appa chian Region, Southern‑‑In literature. 7. Page, yra, 1897‑ Gathering storm. 8. Lumpki Grace, 1892?‑1980. To make my bread. 9. Burke, elding, 1869‑1968. Call home the heart. 10. Burke, F lding, 1869‑1968. Stone came rolling. I. Title. I. Series. PS374.S8M36 2006 813’.52093553‑‑dc22
2006004837
Visit the Taylor & Francis Web site at http://www.taylorandfrancis.com and the Routledge Web site at http://www.routledge‑ny.com
RT7584X_Discl.indd 1
6/21/06 12:19:44 PM
Contents
Acknowledgments Introduction “Beats 100 Speeches and 9 Sermons Throwed In”
vii 1
Chapter One “The Will to Win”: Working-Class Culture and Resistance in Myra Page’s Gathering Storm: A Story of the Black Belt
19
Chapter Two “You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”: Cultural Representations in To Make My Bread
49
Chapter Three “Nothing Is Right, but Everything Is Going to Be”: Pre- and Post-Revolutionary Culture in Olive Tilford Dargan’s Call Home the Heart and A Stone Came Rolling
117
Notes
177
Works Cited
225
Index
233
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 5
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 6
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
Acknowledgments
My family has given me incredible support during the years that this project has taken to complete. Deep appreciation goes to my wife, Shuko, and daughter, Hanako, for their patience and encouragement. I am grateful to professor Jim Miller of The George Washington University for sharing with me his enthusiasm for the literature of Grace Lumpkin and Olive Dargan, and to Ann Romines, Chris Sten, Jeff Hotz, Lisbeth Fuisz, and others who commented on many drafts and brought much-needed clarity to my ideas. Finally, Sarah Gunning, Aunt Molly Jackson, Woody Guthrie, Pete Seeger, Joe Glazer, and Hazel Dickens are just some of the singers committed to promoting social justice whose voices have inspired and become part of me. I thank them for having kept the music alive.
vii
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 7
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 8
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
Introduction
“Beats 100 Speeches and 9 Sermons Throwed In”
In early 1929, two organizers for the American Communist Party’s recently established National Textile Worker’s Union (NTWU) journeyed south by motorcycle to investigate the potential for beginning organizing work among textile workers in the Piedmont region (Draper 9).1 Various inquiries eventually led one of these organizers, Fred Beal, to try his luck in Gastonia, North Carolina, which had been described to him as key to organizing the South.2 Beal arrived in Gastonia in mid-March and, at the Loray Mill, the largest in the region, “succeeded in winning over a single, local mill worker. They cautiously decided to set up a secret union local and begin by taking in a few members only” (Draper 10). In a chain of events whose rapidity and magnitude took Beal by surprise, workers at the Loray mill became embroiled in a Communist-led strike that would eventually focus national and even international attention on Gastonia. After Beal had left Gastonia, the initial union inductee was fired for his organizing activities. Several other firings followed. When Beal returned, union members—“far more militant than Beal” (Draper 11)—pushed for a factory walkout. When the mill fired additional workers the following week, the strike ensued. Although very few workers had actually joined the union, “a large majority of Loray’s 2,200 workers [. . . ] walked out,” protesting not only these firings, but also their own growing frustrations about work conditions (Draper 11). They succeeded in bringing production almost to a standstill, but only for a few days. Although various Communist organizations quickly began sending aid and organizational help, most Loray workers found that they couldn’t hold out long against the forces mustered against them. “Court injunctions forbade all strike activity” (Draper 14) and the National Guard was called in to enforce these orders. Many workers returned to their jobs when faced with
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 1
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
evictions from their company-owned homes, and others were replaced by outside recruits. Those who lost their jobs and their homes relocated to a tent colony outside of town (Pope 256). “By April 15 the strike as a strike was defeated. By May 1, the number of strikers had dwindled from about 2,000 to approximately 200” (249). Still, the N.T.W. was determined to show that it was not an ordinary union. Gastonia was its first opportunity to demonstrate that it was a ‘revolutionary’ union that could not be intimidated by violence or discouraged by any obstacles or setbacks. The novelty of a Communist-led strike in the South and the daily street battles attracted nation-wide publicity. [. . . .] By mid-1929, the entire Communist world took up the cause of Gastonia. Protest demonstrations were staged in England, Germany, Denmark and elsewhere. For a few months, Gastonia was lifted out of mill-town obscurity and made into a symbol of all that was wrong with the capitalist system. (Draper 15-6)
As historian Liston Pope put it, “if Communism was brought to Gastonia, Gastonia was brought to the world” (244). Two casualties—each representing opposite sides of the struggle— played a large role in keeping Gastonia in the headlines throughout the latter half of 1929. In June, Gastonia’s Chief of Police, Orville F. Aderholt, was killed when he and several other armed men tried to force their way into the guarded union headquarters.3 In Pope’s assessment, “the Communists’ challenge to Gastonia was almost completely ended by this event. Thenceforth their activities in the region were largely defensive in character and their problem [became one] of resisting expulsion rather than of making positive gains” (252). Aderholt’s death set off the town’s most intense wave of repression against the remaining strikers. Mobs razed the tent colony and the union hall. A number of organizers were arrested in connection with the Aderholt murder and faced capital punishment.4 Then, in September, twenty-nine-year-old Ella May Wiggins—a mother, worker, and union organizer who had written a number of union songs popular among the strikers—was shot while she and other strikers were riding to a union meeting in the back of a flatbed truck. En route, they had met a vigilante group blocking the road to prevent workers from getting to the meeting. As the truck with Wiggins on it was being forced to turn around, members of the vigilante group fired at it. Ella May was hit in the chest and died almost immediately.5 Although several prime suspects were examined at the trial, no one was ever indicted. This outcome—especially
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 2
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
Introduction
when compared with the mass arrests that had followed Aderholt’s death— exacerbated liberals’ sense that Gastonia law was an auxiliary of industrial interests. Following Wiggins’ death, left-wing intervention played an important role in spreading her songs and turning her into the symbolic face of the striking Gastonia worker.6 While striking workers like Ella May had battled mostly with their bodies—facing hunger, evictions from their homes, and violence—other concerned parties had battled more with words. Regional newspapers—most notably the Gastonia Gazette—had vociferously decried the strike, calling for expulsion of the uninvited Communist visitors from the North and a quick return to normalcy. On the opposite end of the political spectrum, hard-line Communist publications such as the Daily Worker had confidently portrayed this strike as the first major Southern battle in a class uprising that would soon overthrow America’s capitalist system (Pope 244-5).7 Not long after Gastonia had ceased to produce new headlines, fiction writers picked up where reporters had left off. In the several years following the strike, novelists continued the process of interpreting what the event had meant. What factors had caused the Gastonia workers to strike when and how they did? What role had Communist ideology played? Workers’ “native” cultural values? The first “Gastonia novel”—Mary Heaton Vorse’s Strike!—came out in 1930. Four more novels inspired by Gastonia were published in 1932: Myra Page’s Gathering Storm; Grace Lumpkin’s To Make My Bread; Olive Tilford Dargan’s Call Home the Heart; and Sherwood Anderson’s Beyond Desire. A final one—William Rollins’ The Shadow Before—appeared in 1934.8 As Joseph Urgo observes, All six novelists saw in Gastonia a structure through which a larger purpose could be served. In each of the novels, Gastonia is given as the focus of the universal class struggle, as a set of real events operating within the context of Marxist ideology. [. . . .] Differences in emphases and selectivity of events in the six novels reflect a variety of ideological sympathies among the novelists drawn to the Gastonia symbol. (67)
When considering the range of “voices” contributing to a “dialogue” about the meaning of Gastonia, it must be recognized that the workers themselves—just as much as reporters, novelists, and historians—had rationales for their behavior before, during, and after the strike. Their authentic voices, however, may be difficult to hear amid other ideologically charged assertions about the strike. Of course, actions alone may be seen as speaking volumes about workers’ level of discontent and resolve to win better conditions. While
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 3
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
occasional direct comments from striking workers appear in articles and letters in leftist publications (such as the Daily Worker and the New Masses), countless unrecorded private thoughts and conversations among workers have been lost in the passage of time. Written records of the songs workers sang—whether newly written for a particular occasion or chosen from a traditional repertoire—provide another way of gleaning insights into how workers saw their conditions of life. The novels that came out after the strike provide other potential ways of imaginatively recovering an intimate human context that is deeper and wider than the parameters of purely historical accounts.9 This book focuses on Myra Page, Grace Lumpkin, and Olive Dargan—the three authors of Gastonia novels who, in my view, penetrate most incisively into the working-class experience beneath historical and political accounts of the strike and its larger context.10 In three main chapters devoted to Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan, respectively, I focus on these authors’ Gastonia novels but incorporate considerable additional information in order to contextualize them. As appropriate, I discuss authors’ familial, cultural, and historical backgrounds as interrelated dynamics that influenced the shape of each novel. I also examine other works by each author in the interest of shedding light on the Gastonia novels and on each writer’s artistic and ideological development.11 My particular focus is on how each novel’s many cultural representations contribute to meaning. Although a single novel cannot possibly convey the whole complexity of a given cultural system, it can suggest this system through carefully chosen allusions that gesture towards the whole. By embedding other cultural texts within fictional contexts, novelists can dramatically influence the way readers perceive these cultural texts’ aesthetic value and social worth. In numerous instances, brief allusions to outside cultural texts in each novel suggest significant and intentional strategies by each author to engage the larger culture in a dialogue with the novel’s system of values. Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan all visited Gastonia either before or during the strike; all had other experiences that would have given them significant insights into portraying working-class life. All active within the political Left before and during the time of writing their Gastonia novels, they wrote with varying degrees of conviction that their own mode of cultural production might influence the country’s political climate. Their interest in exploring the potential of culture produced and consumed by their working-class subjects to shape and reshape ideology seems like a natural extension of their hopes that the novels they wrote might do the same. Indeed, their writings contain numerous searching representations of a wide spectrum of culture:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 4
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
Introduction
folk, popular, mass media, literary. These representations—which reveal an equally wide spectrum of positive, negative, and ambivalent stances towards the relevance of culture to class struggle—offer enlightening windows into the way that cultural texts from different social strata and historical periods can influence each other.12 Any cultural mode capable of expressing class-consciousness and protest against oppression is potentially illuminating to my study. However, certain actual or perceived qualities of America’s folk-based music during this period seem to make it especially prominent in concurrent literary works dramatizing working-class struggle. Granted, creation in any artistic medium may lead both creator and audience towards politically important revelations and may provide a catalyst for affirmative personal or social change. Although I focus on representations of music, I recognize that ideas expressed through such representations may be metonyms for a larger concern with how working-class creative expression relates to economic, political, and mental liberation. Obviously, working-class creativity is not limited to musical expression. Linguistic creativity may also manifest itself in other verbal forms, including figurative speech, sayings, speeches, prayers, and stories. Creativity may also be seen in material culture that allows individual expression to emerge through a communally understood form.13 The question of whether these linguistic or material expressions contribute to liberation must be approached on a case-by-case basis by considering the context in which the expression occurs.14 Still, the particular appeal of using songs (in real situations and in fiction) as vehicles for exploring links between culture and radical action is worth considering. More than a written or visual/material text, a song based on a commonly understood matrix of folk expression may quickly transfer and magnify the energy of individual creation into the energy of group participation. Implicitly, a group singing a song affirms the ideas the song sets forth. While the skill of an individual composer or charismatic performer may be crucial to a “folk” song’s genesis or dissemination, the song’s vernacular accessibility may nevertheless enable relatively widespread replication through participation or imitation. This blurring of individual and group expression is well suited to an ideology emphasizing collective creation and action. Further, by its very aural nature, a song spread through folk channels easily circumvents capital-based publication requirements associated with more middle-class expressive forms. As John Steinbeck commented in his foreword to the left-oriented collection of American protest songs Hard Hitting Songs for Hard-Hit People, “You can burn books, buy newspapers, you can guard against handbills and pamphlets, but you cannot prevent singing” (8). These generic qualities surely explain in part why proletarian writers—
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 5
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
whether inspired by historical precedents or visions of a utopian future—so frequently used representations of working-class music making as a vehicle for exploring folk culture as a potential resource for forming tools of resistance. Such fictional exploration, however, frequently uncovers tensions and contradictions that revolve around a cluster of questions: What, for instance, are the conditions necessary to create and sustain folk culture? In what ways, if at all, can such folk culture address issues socially and politically relevant to new industrialized contexts? What criteria—such as the fair distribution of mental and manual labor—might legitimate the talented practitioner of folk (or non-folk) culture within the socialist or communist society many leftist writers foresaw on the horizon? What stance should the “knowing” intellectual take towards culture that could be perceived as escapist or politically naïve yet is cherished by the folk? Should artistic products emerging from a supposedly exploited group of people be seen as necessarily circumscribed by limits of education, leisure time, and economic resources? If so, does this obligate proletarian writers to contextualize their depiction of folk art so that aesthetic “weaknesses”—crudity, or lack of sophistication—are seen as the result of exploitation? I explore questions such as these in my examination of Page’s, Lumpkin’s, and Dargan’s literature. Assuming that the authors themselves grasped the complete outside texts they alluded to, I investigate these texts as fully as possible in order to understand the potentially complex ways that the ideological positions of these inserted texts’ contexts resonate with the fictional novels that encompass them. I have, for instance, “recovered” the full lyrics to many songs (folk, protest, hymnal, and popular) that the novels allude to only by title or excerpted lines. In other instances, I have looked carefully at longer works that are incorporated in various ways into each novel. Examples include Dargan’s use of Percy Shelley’s Prometheus Unbound and Lumpkin’s use of Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables. I have found—and attempted to demonstrate—that in many cases these cultural allusions have aesthetically complex functions within the novels. Further, granting that ideological motivations shape all versions of history, I also view these novelistic representations of reality as engaging with other thematically related narratives (fictional and purely historical alike). Thus, when these novels allude to historical events or socioeconomic phenomena, I attempt to situate these allusions within a broader informational base. In recent decades, scholars have come increasingly to understand the interconnection between how Appalachia functioned in the national imagination and in the national economy. They have suggested ways that
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 6
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
Introduction America’s dominant culture has used various imaginative constructions of Appalachia to help justify economic exploitation of the region. Romanticized images of brave, adventure-seeking frontiersmen, for instance, have tended to subsume the less glamorous reality that wealthier and more powerful individuals who wanted the more hospitable Piedmont land had forced many settlers of the region westward during the colonial and early national period. Starting in the last two decades of the nineteenth century, Appalachia itself took on a new economic desirability. Following the Civil War and the growth of the railroad industry, new railway spurs leading into the mountains provided a profitable way of removing coal and timber that had been relatively inaccessible before. Viewing these natural resources as a key to recovering from the economic devastation left in the wake of the Civil War, Southern politicians tended to back such development enthusiastically. With the concurrent development of textile mills in the Southern lowland areas, Appalachia also became a potential source of cheap labor.15 Recruiters for textile mills (such as those depicted in Page’s and Lumpkin’s novels) traveled into isolated mountain areas to promote working for the mill (Eller 125). As Lumpkin’s novel highlights, the coming of modernizing forces to the mountains often ensnared previously more self-sufficient people in a capitalist economy and later compelled them to migrate.16 As historian Ronald Eller argues, modernization hit different parts of Appalachia at different times, but “by the eve of the Great Depression, all [areas] were bound together by their common loss of autonomy and by their common relationship to the new order” (xxv). “By 1930,” he claims, most mountaineers, whether they remained on the farm or migrated to the mill villages, timber towns, or coal camps, had become socially integrated within the new industrial system and economically dependent upon it as well. To say the least, this dependence was not on their own terms—that is to say, it was a product not of mountain culture but of the same political and economic forces that were shaping the rest of the nation and the western world. (xxiii)
Not coincidentally, the dominant culture began to show a superficial fascination with Appalachia during the same time that the exploitation of Appalachian natural and labor resources was filling the pockets of outside capitalists—and leaving behind pockets of mountain poverty. Dominantculture depictions of Appalachia as a backwards region could be used to promote the benefits of “modernizing” the mountains. Or, alternately, depictions emphasizing Appalachia as the “land that time forgot” could be used to
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 7
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
obscure the reality that development and dependence on outside economic forces had already blighted much of the region. In From Tobacco Road to Route 66: The Southern Poor White in Fiction, literary scholar Sylvia Jenkins Cook has found that during the post-Civil War period, when the southern mountaineer “came into literary prominence” (11), local-color depictions of Appalachia first focused on “illicit distilling, fights, feuds, and romances,” then later “emphas[ized] [. . . ] the misery, filth, and starvation of such an existence” (12). Nonfiction accounts of poverty in post-Civil War Appalachia tended to imply that “starvation, disease, and ignorance [were] allied to laziness, promiscuity, and stealth” (13).17 Then, towards the turn of the century, as large factories for the manufacture of textiles became a defining part of the South’s post-Civil War landscape, writers of sociology tended to represent this labor system as “an altruistic effort to assist those whites who could not be absorbed as tenants and croppers and also to remove them from direct competition with blacks on the land” (Cook 13-14). In reality, this industrialism “depended for its success on the existence of a huge surplus market of cheap labor, which was forced to live and work in the most dehumanizing conditions” (14). Cook’s study of the sociological literature of Southern mills finds conflicting tendencies in the desire to expose horrific labor conditions and yet portray workers as themselves prone to various types of irrational behavior. The “incongruities [of workers’ behavior],” Cook observes, “make for lively reporting but give pause to the architects of reform. [. . . .] The poor white in the mills, like his forerunners on the land, seemed to provoke literary excess readily but abjured, by his quaint loyalties and prejudices, any comparably drastic political remedy” (15). Later, even as “muckraking and socialist writers were scouring the country for provocative subjects,” the perception of irrational elements in the sociology of poor whites still “precluded their assimilation for a long time into any kind of radical political tradition” (15). The precedent of earlier writing on Appalachia was not the only difficulty for Depression-era radical writers who wanted to emphasize class exploitation as the primary determining factor of poverty. In addition, the ongoing reality of conservative religious convictions and deeply ingrained racial prejudices hindered a desire to portray southern workers who would overcome their poverty if they only understood its root causes. While workers undoubtedly played a role in perpetuating their own oppressed conditions, ruling-class manipulation of social, racial, and religious ideology also contributed to factory workers’ acceptance of the status quo. Within a paternalistic factory system,
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 8
6/22/2006 8:54:24 AM
Introduction workers were constantly reminded by their newspapers and leaders of the unparalleled benevolence of their masters; in the churches their already profound conviction that the agonies of this world were the direct manifestation of the will of God was confirmed heartily by their preachers. The possible growth of any rebellious mentality toward the bosses was further retarded by calculated efforts to create implacable hostility between the poor whites and the only other class that shared a similar predicament and might have shared their interest, the blacks. (Cook 15-6)
At the same time, changing demographics of Southern labor in the early twentieth century prevented social dynamics from becoming static: “[T]here was the impact on the more apathetic lowland whites of the mountain people, driven from their homes by mining and foresting combines and attracted by mill scouts with promises of high wages. These people [. . . ] brought a frequently violent individualism into the ordered industrial routine” (Cook 16). Due to this individualism, Cook argues, “they were not ideal material for labor unions” (16).18 In choosing to use characters from a mountain background to depict a process of radicalization, Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan had to confront current less-than-ideal realities as well as problematic earlier fictional and sociological representations of life in Southern mountains and mills. Guided by Marxist sensibilities, these authors were not as likely as earlier, less political portrayers of Appalachia to romanticize mountain living. Although their novels do not depict exploitation within mountain society that is comparable to that in mill villages, they still examine the dynamics of this society through a Marxist lens, scrutinizing economic factors of life while avoiding idealization of rural living. Dargan, for instance, details the difficulty of mountain farming. Although she (and her protagonist) celebrate the mountains’ natural beauty and the potential satisfaction of running a small mountain farm, she also looks forward to a socialist future in which mechanized, collective agribusiness will relieve rural farmers from such intense labor. Lumpkin is especially attentive to the way that Appalachia functioned within a larger capitalist economy. She shows how dire poverty compels the McClures to sell illegal whiskey and, later, the timber rights to their land. These unfortunate forays into a cash economy become the catalysts that force the family off the land and into the mills. The sensitivity to mountain culture that these authors displayed surely contributed to an ongoing process of reclaiming the reality of Appalachian experience from stereotypes built up over earlier years.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 9
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
10
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
In depicting the strike itself, Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan again had to confront literary and historical precedents regarding white, working-class Southerners. A realistic depiction of Southern society could hardly have avoided acknowledging the prevalence among white workers of racism and religious fundamentalism, both obvious setbacks to revolutionary consciousness. So, as Cook notes, writers who based radical novels upon the Gastonia strike “had to contend not only with the poor white as he had just revealed himself in the strike but with the idea of the poor white as a long-established literary personality. His propensity for the irrational—whether in regard to violence, religion, or the land—would be a major stumbling block” (87). These writers “had an unprecedented opportunity to create a new kind of southern literature in the form of the proletarian novel, but the poor whites were not the best receptacles for their extremely logical materialism” (91). A priori perceptions of backwardness among poor Southern whites, Cook argues, made it “virtually impossible for the Gastonia novels to demonstrate ‘sudden conversion’ [to Communism]” (92). Indeed, strategies to show characters’ gradual movement towards communist values function as a key structuring device in each novel. Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan all work to evoke an optimistic, wider sense of working-class radicalization by focusing on a select group of characters that eventually emerge as part of what might loosely be called a revolutionary vanguard. Initially, these characters’ family and social experiences do little to distinguish them from others in their community. Their self-doubts and ideological limitations are typical of those around them. Eventually, though, they outpace most others in embracing an exemplary Marxist conception of collective action.19 Each novel creates plausible explanations for these characters’ gradual acquiescence to various tenets of radicalism prior to the strike.20 By focusing on these characters, Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan de-emphasize less ideologically flexible members of the working-class community. While Cook emphasizes the “idea of the poor white” as a liability for proletarian writers, I believe that preconceptions about hill folk (and Southerners more generally) actually benefited the Gastonia novelists in certain ways. Likely, Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan recognized that they could better “sell” the virtues of communism during a time of great anxiety about foreign immigration from Eastern Europe by representing radical labor strategies as a phenomenon that had mostly developed organically among indisputably white Americans. They could draw upon popular notions of Appalachians as “true” and “original” Americans to make an assumed “foreign” ideology less threatening to the American population. As Karen Linn notes, many Americans indeed saw Appalachians—“a native-born labor force waiting to
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 10
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
Introduction
11
be industrialized”—as “a leaven to the hordes of immigrants, then forming most of the working class, who brought with them strange customs and dangerous political ideas” (122).21 Gastonia provided an actual case in which a relatively homogenous group of workers with an indisputably white and long-standing American pedigree had engaged in a type of insurrection that—to the chagrin of American Communists—conservatives often rejected outright as un-American. For those who welcomed the strike as the opening act of a greater revolutionary drama, the striking workers’ Anglo-Saxon identity had a particular significance. Conservatives’ stereotypical fears about subversive threats to American political stability tended to be based on prior labor struggles involving immigrant workers in urban, Northeastern factories.22 Gastonia provided an ironic reply to Americans who could only visualize the potential for insurrection in racial others. “Who said there were no proletarians in America?” exclaimed a short New Masses article entitled “Carolina Mill Slaves.” “Look inside a southern mill village” (7). By frequently highlighting Southern workers’ “Anglo-Saxon” identity, radical writers hoped, it seems, that the dominant white American population would better recognize and empathize with the class-based nature of capitalist exploitation after learning that white workers in the American South, former seat of black slavery, were targeted for exploitation precisely because of their ethnicity. The author of “Carolina Mill Slaves,” one Harvey O’Connor, reported that “‘Southern boosters’ had praised southern labor forces as ‘docile, 100% Anglo-Saxon Americans. None of your damned foreigners. These people want to work and they’re willing to turn out a day’s work at a wage a mill owner can afford to pay.’ So chant the southern boosters” (7).23 O’Connor concludes with an ironic emphasis on the actual American precedents for rebellions against perceived oppression: The mill bosses forget that the 100% Anglo-Saxon has produced several loud detonations upon history [such as the American Revolution]. These southern mill workers are an explosive people, hot-headed, handy with a trigger. Especially when they come from the hills. They understand the duty of civil disobedience, and have practiced it. (7)
By depicting the cultural values of Appalachian-born workers fluidly transforming into radical communist values, novelists could further (re)claim revolutionary sentiments as essentially American. Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan all use their novels to demonstrate this pattern of transformation. Characters learn their radical values slowly over the course of each novel, gradually
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 11
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
12
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
modifying behavior that is more stereotypically expected of their class and cultural background. These novels also chart this process of radical transformation in the realm of culture. Representations of characters engaging with culture early in each novel contribute to demonstrating these characters’ lack of radical consciousness. At these earlier points in each novel, the culture itself is conservative, as is characters’ understanding of it. Further into each novel, however, characters have other more “progressive” cultural encounters. In some cases the culture itself is more radically oriented. In other cases, characters demonstrate a relatively sophisticated recognition of how less progressive culture might contribute to their exploitation. Near the end of each novel, cultural texts appear that, according to the novel’s emerging values, are most satisfactorily radical. The realization of this pattern of transformation through the specific mode of American/Appalachian folk song seems significant to each novel’s persuasive strategy. Partly as a response to the aforementioned anxieties over foreign immigration, early twentieth-century interest in Appalachian music had promoted it as quintessentially American folk music (and certainly not as a music that would be associated with threats to the status quo). As part of telling stories of radicalization through Appalachian characters, Gastonia novelists used these characters’ musical culture to offer compelling implicit arguments that communism was closely related to, if not synonymous with, true American values.24 While the Gastonia novels demonstrate workers abjuring racism and religious panaceas during the strike, the actual outcome of the strike did not fully support this optimism. More objective attempts to assess strikers’ motives that were published years after the Gastonia novels suggest that these earlier revolution-minded stories created characters whose eventual informed embrace of communist principles was far from the norm among actual strikers.25 In the novels of Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan, the vanguard characters whose developments are foregrounded all understand and support the strike according to the Communist union’s revolutionary principles. In reality (according to Liston Pope’s careful study), the union’s Communist affiliation probably had little initial influence on most workers’ decision to strike. Frustrated with their conditions, workers who knew little about Communism’s revolutionary aims were willing to embrace any organization promising help. Although Communist organizers held views on religion that were in drastic opposition to most workers’ beliefs, this seems to have had little impact on the initial strike. Organizers exercised judicious restraint in not offending workers’ beliefs: “[T]he Communists presented, during the strike itself, practically no challenge to the religious institutions of the community and voiced little or no public criticism of them. Their silence in this respect
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 12
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
Introduction
13
was doubtless based on a policy of expediency as they sensed the deeply religious background of the workers” (247). Eventually, though, powerful local conservatives succeeded in using the Party’s anti-religious stance as a way of turning many workers against the new union. And, after their views on religion were called into question, organizers did make numerous inflammatory comments that provided fodder for the campaign against them. Thus, many who participated in the initial mass walkout but returned to their jobs within days or weeks came to resent Communist organizers’ atheism and oppose the union on these moral grounds. The approximately 200 workers who fought the strike to its bitter end seem to have been ones whose ties to a church were weak or nonexistent. Pope concludes that Communist organizers’ lack of proper understanding or respect for local workers’ religious heritage was a key factor in the strike’s ultimate failure (262-4). The intertwining of religious beliefs and musical expression in the culture of white Appalachian (and Southern black migrants) created difficult conflicts when Marxist-oriented writers considered folk music traditions in the context of resistance. Although other genres of song—ballads, “play” songs, blues, and instrumental pieces—were also popular, sacred music occupied a particularly important role as a vernacular expressive mode for formulating responses to life’s hardships. Religious songs provided a cultural matrix that normalized stoically accepting hardship and envisioning heavenly rewards as compensation for earthly sorrows. In the case of white Appalachians, this music was nurtured in a relatively pre-industrial cultural context in which poverty and accompanying hardships were less connected to identifiable capitalist oppressors than to inherent qualities of life in a harsh, isolated region. Transplanted to sites of modern industry, such a fatalistic cultural paradigm might be viewed as more problematic, particularly when workers sang such hymns as a form of consolation to offset suffering related to economic exploitation.26 Traditional southern American folk songs (religious or not) did not tend to offer explicit, worldly solutions to whatever social problems they addressed. They often took fatalistic or self-deprecating views of life’s hardships. Partly for this reason, during the early years of the American Communist Party, left-wing intellectuals who were interested in music’s capacity to foster working-class solidarity tended to look elsewhere for musical forms to carry new radical messages.27 R. Sergei Denisoff argues that “it took northern [radical] ideologies to add the social panacea to the perceived dilemmas [conveyed in traditional American folk music]” (15). Denisoff cites the publicity given to Ella May Wiggins’ strike ballads as the introduction of folk material into the CPUSA agenda. Whatever the
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 13
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
14
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
reality of Wiggins’ influence in the strike itself, she was “an appealing figure whose death came to symbolize all that was perceived to be noble in the labor movement and pernicious in the textile industry” (Watkins 193). Further, to intellectuals she represented an ideal of a folk artist whose songs, written in a form accessible to and embraced by striking workers, demonstrated political agency that was organic and yet concordant with leftist ideology. Her distinction as the sole casualty among Gastonia’s striking workers surely increased her symbolic value as bearer of a homegrown cultural weapon dangerous to the capitalist system. Inspired to varying degrees by Wiggins, all four of the female-authored Gastonia novels portray strong female activists who reflect various aspects of what Laura Hapke has termed the “Ella May Wiggins legend” (166). Page’s Marge Crenshaw, Lumpkin’s Bonnie McClure, and Dargan’s Ishma Waycaster (as well as Vorse’s Mamie Lewes) all suggest Wiggins in that they assume activist roles despite the paired burdens of child rearing and absent husbands.28 (Further, Lumpkin’s and Vorse’s Wiggins-influenced protagonists are shown actually writing Wiggins’ songs.) “Wiggins compelled attention,” Hall observes, “in part because she expressed the needs of women who combined bread winning with child rearing under conditions that [in Wiggins’ words] ‘just kept getting worse and worse’” (Family 226). The process of shaping the Gastonia strike into an enduring revolutionary symbol both preceded and included the various novels written about it. The NTWU’s initial decision to begin its Southern campaign in Gastonia was fairly arbitrary. During the same time as the Gastonia strike, a number of strikes with no relationship to the Communist union broke out in other Southern textile cities. Seemingly, the NTWU might have focused its efforts elsewhere with similar results. The Communist Party’s eventual decision to give such singular attention to the Gastonia strike also seems fairly arbitrary. For the CP, addressing the particular grievances of these workers was largely secondary to using the broader symbolic value of the strike to justify and promote its revolutionary agendas: The Communist leadership in the North quickly realized what a windfall Gastonia was. It had been anxiously scanning the horizon for signs of the third period in the United States, and it eagerly seized on Gastonia as just what it had been looking for. If a single Communist organizer could set off such an explosion in far-off North Carolina, where no Communist organizer had ever ventured before, where the workers were supposed to be the most inaccessible and most impenetrable—the ‘purest,’ white, native American stock, the most exploited and oppressed,
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 14
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
Introduction
15
the most easily replaceable, the least exposed to politics or even education—what could not be done in the rest of the country? If Gastonia was the beginning, what might not be the end? (Draper 11)29
As Dee Garrison notes, “strike fiction of the early thirties,” such as that centering on Gastonia, was [. . . ] inspired by the dramatic tensions peculiar to the labor battles in southern textile mills. When the strikes began, one of the nation’s most enduring folk figures, the southern poor white, was already well established in imaginative literature. [. . . .] The meeting of this presumed near-peasant with the northern urban revolutionary offered high literary promise as a provocative subject. (x-xi)
Writers who hoped to convey the validity of applying Marxist analysis to American society probably recognized that they could not have picked a better vehicle. As Mary Heaton Vorse observed after visiting Gastonia during the strike, the mills created Gastonia, the city of spindles. It is handsome, prosperous, thriving. Here is the cotton-mill population culled from hill settlements and from farms supporting the handsome city. The picture one gets is as complete as an egg. Gastonia tells you its story, loud and clear, the very first day. (704)
As I have mentioned above, and as I will discuss frequently in the chapters that follow, the general importance of music in Southern working-class culture combined with a number of new folk-styled songs that local workers wrote about Gastonia provided an additional compelling phenomenon for leftist writers to explore.30 As much as, or more than, what the songs actually said, the idea of such songs surely had a symbolic appeal to those who wanted to see Southern workers embrace unionist-communist values. As Wiley observes, the song texts deal with only a few reasons for striking, repeated over and over: the need to oppose the mill’s cruelty, dishonesty, and indifference toward the workers; the hope of deliverance from the evils of millhand life; the hope for a better life via the NTWU and, later, the ILD; and in a couple of songs, the intolerable hardship of life as a woman millhand. The issues raised in performance were more complex, and their full scope cannot be guessed from the texts. (90)
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 15
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
16
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
Even though they had not stood the test of time required to qualify as genuinely folk, Gastonia songs in a folk idiom that praised (or even mentioned) communist ideas, institutions, and leaders could be seen as giving a certain folk “stamp of approval” to Communist political agendas. In implicit reply to those who opposed the strike with claims that “Russian Reds” were behind the whole disturbance, these songs made the labor uprising seem more inevitable and less incongruous with local values. In particular, the idea that workers were passing these songs among themselves and singing them in groups provided a persuasive symbol for the idea that workers were transmitting communist values more generally. In an article on the Gastonia songs published weeks after Ella May Wiggins’ death, Margaret Larkin thought she recognized the beginnings of such a folk process—one she felt confident would turn strike leaders into enduring folk heroes: It is curious to think how the little handful of organizers from the National Textile Workers Union have passed into legend already. Fred Beal, Vera Buch, George Pershing are names which will be heard for many years in the South. [. . . .] The itinerant workers of the cotton mills are carrying these tunes and the story of the union in Gastonia into every section of the textile South. These songs that begin “Come all ye workers” and end “Let’s stand together, workers, and have a union here” are destined to be the battle songs of the coming industrial struggle. (382-3)
From a current perspective, Larkin’s optimistic prophecy sounds ironic. These songs, like the Communist union of which they spoke, did not last long as living pieces of working-class culture. To the degree that they have survived at all, it has been through the Gastonia novels, as well as through channels of revivalist and academic interest in folklore. Extending Larkin’s left-oriented folkloric interest in the Gastonia songs, a number of later students of the American protest-song tradition—John Greenway, Sergei Denisoff, Richard Reuss, and Archie Green among them—have discussed these songs against a broader canvas of cultural and historical context. Relatively sophisticated artists who have aligned themselves with working-class and leftist causes (Pete Seeger and Woody Guthrie being best known) have kept songs like Wiggins’ “Mill Mother’s Lament” alive through more populist writings, recordings, and performances.31 Writing an introduction to a selection of Gastonia songs in the protest-song anthology Hard Hitting Songs for Hard-Hit People, Guthrie used his distinctive folksy prose stylings to express his passionate admiration for Wiggins:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 16
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
Introduction
17
Ella May Wiggins was shot through the heart on her way to a Union Meetin’ in Gastonia, North Carolina. [. . . .] She never had much schoolin’, but she knowed People. That’s a heap better than a knowin’ books. She had Faith in th’ Union. It was her Religion. It was her Sermon and the poor people was her Church. It was the only Power that promised her a better Life. It was the only Power that would give her kids some groceries to eat and clothes to wear. Faith without Works is Dead. Ella knowed that. So she Worked. She went out and talked the Union. She said, Poor Folks, You got to get together. So’s we can wear good clothes and live in a better house. Who put that bullet in her heart? Why did they shoot her down? Why did they nail Jesus on a cross? That kind of stuff has got to be stopped. And the Union is the only power on earth that’ll put a stop to it [. . . ]. Ella May died for her Union. They sung her songs over the red earth of her fresh dug grave. You’ll sing ’em all over the world. [. . . .] Beats 100 speeches and 9 sermons throwed in. (Guthrie “Chief ”)32
Guthrie’s comments, despite their somewhat overblown and affected colloquialisms, summarize—as effectively as anything I’ve seen—the inspirational quality that Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan recognized in the stories of mountain people who came to their radical values organically, both because of and despite their unlikely backgrounds and hard experiences. While the Gastonia novels do reinforce the more subtle points of their radical agendas through the sort of longwinded speeches and sermons (of a radical nature, of course) that Guthrie ridicules, they also recognize and draw on the more concise power of unmediated folk speech. Page, Lumpkin, and Dargan reflect this aesthetic value in their predominant use of working-class vantage points to narrate experience. The working-class songs they include provide moments within this narration that set forth collective working-class values in a particularly terse format. Long considered relics of an earlier time with little more than historical value for later readers, these novels—like the largely forgotten topical songs within them—have received new scholarly interest and found a new readership in recent years. Read with sensitivity, the Gastonia novels can do more to enrich current readers than simply opening up windows into a bygone era. On the one hand, the social dilemmas and radical political propositions within these novels might superficially seem to have little relevance today. On the other hand, the socioeconomic forces that tend to naturalize the status quo exist in every era. Individuals of any time or place may either
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 17
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
18
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
remain oblivious to these forces, or become more self-aware and then adapt their beliefs and behaviors accordingly. The process of becoming self-aware is rarely simple or painless. By focusing on working-class individuals in a highly repressive socioeconomic environment, the Gastonia novels document particularly difficult and profound processes of self-transformation. In their dramatizations of working-class self-transformation, these novels highlight the more universal value of using familiar cultural texts and beliefs as the basis for gradual changes in culture and perception. Exploring this process in a particular time and place, the Gastonia novels incorporate and synthesize a range of culture—folk and non-folk—that their authors saw as influential within various social strata. These novels themselves then insert themselves into a continuously flowing cultural stream and become potential resources for subsequent cultural synthesis. Indeed, without the presence of these radical novels and others like them in America’s collective cultural past, the contours of its current cultural landscape would surely have a different feel.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 18
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
Chapter One
“The Will to Win”: Working-Class Culture and Resistance in Myra Page’s Gathering Storm: A Story of the Black Belt
The preceding introduction proposed that Myra Page, Grace Lumpkin, and Olive Dargan tended to emphasize the “native” forces that propelled the 1929 uprising of Gastonia workers against their employers. Such an emphasis might compel an American readership—particularly a white, middle-class one—to recognize that they and the apparently revolution-minded strikers shared relatively similar cultural and historical backgrounds. Indeed, Page draws on this rhetorical strategy in her Gastonia novel, Gathering Storm: A Story of the Black Belt (1932). Her core group of protagonists—those who eventually play key roles in the novel’s climactic strike—all grow up in working-class families in the same Southern mill town and develop grievances against the capitalist system that are grounded in local experience. At the same time, Page certainly does not shy away from linking the forces influencing her characters’ rebellion to a geographically broader and more theoretically conceived Communist agenda for a revolutionary takeover of America’s government and economic institutions. Although Page’s novel begins with detailed depictions of the distinct white and black communities in the mill village, it later sends various characters further afield—to work in the shipyards of New York City and the stockyards of Chicago (where they become involved in ill-fated labor movements); to fight in Europe during World War I; to convalesce on an Appalachian farm; and to live in post-Revolution Russia. Eventually, Page uses the Gastonia unionization effort and strike to gather in her wide-ranging flock of characters. She portrays the genesis and outcome of the strike, as well as the meaning characters get from it, as the result of a complex intermingling of ideologies shaped by diverse local and distant experiences. 19
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 19
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
20
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
My own focus on Gathering Storm’s representations of working-class culture begins by examining biographical material that sheds light on Page’s complex relationship to this culture and to the people who created and/or consumed it.1 In telling ways, aspects of family background, artistic inclination, cultural interests, and activist/academic goals all inform Page’s development into the radical writer of Gathering Storm. Page adapted many experiences from her childhood and young-adult life into her fiction, imaginatively transmuting them into experiences of worker-protagonists whose lives, in terms of class background, are distant from her own. The intensely radical orientation of Page’s representations of culture in the novel reflects the trajectory of her own diverse experiences. Born in 1897, Page grew up in an affluent and cultured home in Newport News, Virginia, the daughter of a prominent local doctor and an artistically gifted mother (Baker 10, 14).2 “Surrounded by books,” she freely indulged her passion for reading (qtd. in Baker 10). Music also had importance in Page’s early life. She began formal piano study as a young child and continued through college, encouraged by an aunt, “a highly gifted pianist” (qtd. in Baker 14). Fond memories included playing the organ for her grandmother and singing “rollicking ballads” with her family in the evenings (qtd. in Baker 15). Despite a fairly secure home life, Page became sensitive early to her community’s dramatic class and racial divisions. She learned that vicissitudes of the ubiquitous shipbuilding industry, and the capitalist vision of the shipyard’s absentee owner, shaped her hometown’s social reality—including that of friends from working-class families (Baker 24). Although her parents took a relatively liberal stance towards the region’s Jim-Crow culture, Page observed in retrospect that they “pushed [conservative norms], but they never pushed too far” (qtd. in Baker 12). As a young child, she gained insight into racism through developing a rapport with her family’s black maid, Belle: “I grew fond of her and she of me” (qtd. in Baker 19). Her gradual awareness that social injustices had severely limited Belle’s potential helped her to step outside of her race/class background and imagine “what it was like from a black person’s point of view” (qtd. in Baker 20). Likely, some of Page’s emotional identification with a black worldview came from the times when she and Belle would “[sing] old Negro spirituals and hymns together” (qtd. in Baker 19).3 After completing a master’s degree in sociology at Columbia University, Page took a position as a YWCA industrial secretary at a silk mill near Norfolk. There, she gained intimate and troubling glimpses into factory labor: “When I saw the mill conditions and what the girls and women did day
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 20
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
“The Will to Win” 21 after day, I understood the need for unions” (qtd. in Baker 50). Through this experience, Page came to disagree with the YWCA’s belief that “social relations would right themselves” simply through the influence of “peace and persuasion, law and order, and the power of love” (qtd. in Baker 51). Particularly after her superiors censured her for “preaching socialism and unionism [to the workers],” she decided that “perhaps the solution depended on changing the system itself ” (qtd. in Baker 52). In a further attempt to transcend her privileged class background and understand working-class life, Page again left the South in 1921 and, against the wishes of her family, sought factory work in Philadelphia (Baker 54). Through various menial jobs, she attempted to “study the working people as one of them,” at the same time realizing that, unlike most of the workers around her, she could always fall back on her family’s financial security (qtd in Baker 55). Wanting to grasp the full spectrum of responsibilities entailed in labor activism, she served as an organizer with the Amalgamated Clothing Workers Union while also holding various standard sweatshop jobs. In her acquaintances with the families of co-workers—the overwhelming majority of whom were “foreign-born girls [many of Eastern European descent] who spoke little English” (qtd. in Baker 56)—Page observed a high value placed upon music performance and education as “a part of the way they survived” (qtd. in Baker 59). Although these families used music-oriented gatherings to promote working-class solidarity, they also, Page noted, saw musical education as a way of “qualifying [their children], in a sense, to become members of the middle class” (qtd. in Baker 59). Page’s experiences in the clothing-workers union convinced her of the difficulty of bridging the gap between the workers’ culture and her own: “I wouldn’t be able to function effectively in [this] union setup because of my different background” (qtd. in Baker 64). After deciding against the life of a professional organizer, Page taught at the University of Minnesota and eventually worked towards a doctorate in sociology. For her dissertation, she decided to return to her native South to investigate “traditional attitudes of southern textile workers” (qtd. in Baker 72). Because sociology’s particular academic rigors required heavy use of statistics, she prepared a series of questions for workers and management designed to yield quantifiable insights into attitudes towards social relations. Beneath the dispassionate approach, however, lay a desire to “know what ordinary people were thinking and what kind of potential they had” and, more specifically, “to see the South get organized” (qtd. in Baker 72, 73). The YWCA, with which Page had again become affiliated, helped fund the study, expecting that Page’s research would assist their goal of “helping prepare for unionism among women in
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 21
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
22
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
the South” (qtd. in Baker 72). On the YWCA’s advice, Page selected Greenville, South Carolina, and Gastonia, North Carolina, both major textile cities, for her field research. In the summers of 1925 and 1926, she spent several weeks in “mill hills” outside of Greenville and Gastonia, respectively. Soon after completing her dissertation, “Some Behavior Patterns of Southern Textile Workers,” she adapted it into Southern Cotton Mills and Labor (1929). This commercially published, non-fiction study “included material [. . .] that I couldn’t have gotten away with in the thesis, a cold, removed academic piece.” She tried to write “sympathetically about mill people and what they wanted to be” and “to avoid academic language so that it might appeal to a working-class audience” (qtd. in Baker 98). Despite Page’s working-class sympathies, her impressions of Greenville and Gastonia initially left her feeling ambivalent about the prospects for building strong unions in the southern mills. Workers’ agricultural backgrounds, she felt, had made them “very individualistic. Their habits of action and therefore of thought rarely extend beyond the small family group” (Southern 39). As a result, she found that “textile workers didn’t believe they could work cooperatively in a union (‘Our folks don’t stick together much,’ they said)” (qtd. in Baker 77). Instead of finding workers close to rebellion, she found them generally “resigned or even pleased with their situation” (qtd. in Baker 79). Conservative religious convictions, she felt, contributed to their passivity. Still, Page saw some potential for positive collective action, particularly among “workers [who] had come down from the mountains where communal attitudes were strong” (qtd. in Baker 79). She came to believe that she and similarly motivated individuals could effect change in the southern labor system by “combin[ing] teaching and indirect organizational work with radical propaganda,” turning passive workers into “union fighters [. . .] once they got the idea!” (qtd. in Baker 83). The 1929 Gastonia strike cast a new light on Page’s earlier sense that Southern textile workers lacked enough resolve or indignation to fight labor exploitation en masse. Page found this strike “so dramatic and interesting” that she decided to attempt a novel. “[I]t never occurred to me,” she later observed, “to do anything else” (qtd. in Baker 110). Because she had not witnessed the strike, she “let the [dissertation] research material sift through [her] imagination.” She based various vanguard characters on certain workers she had observed earlier who seemed like potential radicals among a relatively passive majority—those “native southern textile workers [. . .] who were ready for a strike and would join one if they had the chance” (qtd. in Baker 111). The prominent roles played in the strike by Ella May Wiggins—picketing worker, activist, single mother, songwriter—also inspired
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 22
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
“The Will to Win” 23 Page’s attempt to positively reinvent the subjects of her guarded sociological study as militant strikers: “I never knew Ella May personally, but I read everything I could about her and talked with people who knew her. It seemed like I knew her too” (qtd. in Baker 111). When Gathering Storm came out in 1932, it “had little audience outside of workers’ or Left progressive circles” and “received very few reviews,” mostly unfavorable (qtd. in Baker 116). Barbara Foley reports that it was “given short shrift in the Daily Worker and virtually ignored in other leftist organs” (50). Most criticism of Gathering Storm has focused on the work’s admittedly clumsy tendentiousness. Sylvia Jenkins Cook’s assessment of Page’s effort, for instance, is unequivocally cynical: “The book is a display of virtuosity in including all the proper Party doctrines and giving them life in a wishful vision of the South, but it demands the sacrifice of both the reader’s credulity and his right to confront the material with some measure of independence” (123). In Cook’s view, Page exaggerated both “southern horrors” and “the flexibility of southern workers” (122) in the interest of her political vision. She mars her story, Cook feels, with “didactic tone,” “overpropagandizing” (120), and “lack of humanizing details” (121) in character development. Like Cook, Laura Hapke sees Page as driven by “a propagandist’s Communism”—prone to paint scenes of “southern fantasy,” such as those showing white workers easily shedding racist ideology to meet with black workers “on terms of casual equality” and plan an integrated strike (164). Hapke also believes that Page—in her eagerness to build a revolutionary proletariat out of her Southern workers—avoids resolving a fundamental problem of how a female worker can become an “educated woman militant” (166) and still remain within the South’s repressive labor system. At the novel’s conclusion, Page’s main female activist character, Marge, seems destined to become a professional labor organizer. Another of the novel’s models for the activist female worker, the historical Ella May Wiggins, has been killed in the strike. What, Hapke rightly wonders, of the thousands of undereducated female workers left behind? (166).4 Despite such aesthetic and ideological tensions, Gathering Storm deserves further investigation. Among the Gastonia novels, it is unique in trying to bring the experiences of black workers, as well as white, to the fore.5 To intertwine the political destinies of white and black families, her narrative shuttles between the white “Row Hill” and the black “Back Row,” and between this segregated Southern mill village and New York City, where progressive white and black characters work together towards socialist goals. As part of depicting these diverse social realms, Page often represents and makes value judgments on the relative worth of various cultural modes of expression.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 23
6/22/2006 8:54:25 AM
24
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
Particularly, she assesses the role of culture in fomenting or stifling workers’ understanding of exploitation and desire to combat it. Representations of music across a spectrum of styles and within a range of contexts appear most frequently. Characters encounter white hymns and black spirituals, songs associated with wartime patriotism and love of the South, sentimental and jazzy popular songs, older radical songs, and, finally, new protest songs from both white and black traditions. Print mediums such as books, newspapers, and letters are also shown contributing to characters’ worldviews. References to such a range of cultural texts contribute to a discourse on cultural values that runs the novel’s length. Within the ideological framework that the novel constructs, creating or consuming certain cultural products may be politically frivolous or even insidiously repressive, while engaging with other classattentive ones may be politically motivating. In contrast to the “Gastonia novels” of Lumpkin and Dargan, which spend considerable time detailing characters’ way of living in the mountains before coming to the mill, Gathering Storm begins with its central family already long entrenched in mill life. (Lumpkin’s To Make My Bread and Dargan’s Call Home the Heart each devote approximately their first third to incidents that occur in the mountains prior to characters’ migrations.) Page opens her novel around 1915, introducing a white mill family whose stillliving matriarch, “Ole Marge,” had been part of a large out-migration from the North Carolina mountains to the low-lying mill towns some forty years earlier. Long years in the mill village have mostly subsumed mountain heritage into a homogenous culture of white mill workers. As her pre-Gathering Storm sociological study of Southern textile workers reveals, Page had an economic-derived belief that mountain culture was never truly independent of the currents shaping America’s economic development. White mountaineers, she explained, were descended from poor colonial-era settlers who came to the south-Atlantic colonies as debtors or indentured servants, [and] soon found competition with large plantation owners so one-sided that they were forced onto poorer and poorer land and into greater and greater poverty. [. . . .] First they were pushed into the foothills. Many of them retreated into the Appalachian and Blue Ridge mountains [. . .]. Seemingly, this section of the Poor Whites preferred the illusions of semi-independence and social equality which their greater isolation gave. Here in the mountains there were no plantation owners or merchant aristocrats, no Negro slaves. The competition was no less real, but more indirect. These differences in the situation of
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 24
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
“The Will to Win” 25 highland and lowland Poor Whites led, after some generations, to minor differences in the traditions of the two, but these have never been fundamental enough to affect the basic unity between them. (Southern 34-5)
Further, outside of the mountains, in contexts where capitalist interests exploit their labor, all white wage and tenant laborers, regardless of background, are equally “stigmatized” by and “set off from the rest of the southern population” (Southern 35). Thus, Page’s sociological study and her Gathering Storm both use the term “Poor White” (generally capitalized as above) to highlight the idea that poverty creates profound cultural links among a broad and geographically diverse segment of the white population. Nevertheless, Page’s fiction does subtly link Ole Marge’s willingness to openly berate the mills to her having grown up in a mountain culture that values “fighting spirit.” In a long conversation that begins the novel, Ole Marge, prodded by fourteen-year-old granddaughter Young Marge, who has never seen the family’s ancestral hills, tells the story of “how we Marlows come down to the cotton mill” (19). Besides acquainting the reader with key events in the family’s history, this intergenerational conversation shows Young Marge gleaning the seeds of her future activism from an elder’s unschooled and hard-won observations on both mountain heritage and decades of millwork. In trying to understand what she perceives as the factory system’s inherent injustice, Young Marge, who has just begun to work in the mills, is drawn to Ole Marge, sure that “there was nobody [. . .] in Row Hill or all of Greenville who could touch her Granny. Some in the village might call Ole Marge quare ’n with a tongue dipped in bitters. They were just stick-inthe-muds, ’n her Granny too smart for ’em. Too smart ’n with a way all her own” (9).6 A lifetime of doing underpaid mill work and seeing family members die in the mill town’s unhealthy conditions has indeed left Ole Marge’s tongue bitter; she tells Young Marge that “I hates [the mill bosses], ’n God forgive me, ’ll go on hatin’ ’em till I die” (29). In marked contrast to Ole Marge, Sal—the daughter of Ole Marge and the mother of Young Marge— has become apathetic, seeing no alternative to the exploitative millwork that has consumed her health. Sal, a young girl when the family came to the mill, is now “a bent, old woman at forty-two” (45). While Ole Marge’s experience with mill life is portrayed as typical, her radical outlook is not. Her belief that workers’ “only chance” to better their conditions is through class struggle—potentially violent—distinguishes her from disheartened families who quit mill work to return to mountain farms, and from those who have resigned themselves to life as poor factory workers. Since hearing a recruiter’s promotion for the mill, some ten years after the
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 25
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
26
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
Civil War, Ole Marge has held onto a progressive vision of a place “whar our chillen can get some larnin’, ’n a chanct to live decent” (15). Determined to leave the mountains, she secretly killed the family’s potato crop, forcing her family to turn to the mills for survival. Even after realizing that the recruiter had wildly exaggerated his claims about easy work and high wages, Ole Marge maintains faith in industrialism’s potential for raising living standards: Bad as [life in the mill] was, the hills was as bad, or worser. Thar warn’t no goin’ back. I knew that. [. . . .] Thar’d never be schools or nothin’ in the mountains. What we had to do was make the mill do what they’d a-promised, ’n take the chillen outa the mill’n put ’em in school, ’n larn ’em how to read’n write.” (22 emphasis in original)7
Significantly, Ole Marge has acted as well as spoken out to protest labor injustices. She once participated in a notable struggle in Georgia, a walkout strike “in the ’nineties” (25) that won a twelve-hour day and kept children under ten out of the mills.8 Such struggles, as she tells her granddaughter, have gotten workers’ “heads outta the mire, though we are still in it up to our waists” (25). In telling of this strike, she also situates herself as the first female activist in the family’s long line of “fighting people.” Earlier male ancestors fought in the American Revolution, the Civil War, and the Spanish-American War, though, as Ole Marge is careful to add, those wars have never helped “our own people—the common, workin’ folks” (30). Through her stories, Ole Marge pushes her namesake to uphold the family’s legacy of struggle, making Young Marge promise that “no matter what happens” she will not “lose the fightin’ spirit” (30).9 Having established a certain “fightin’ spirit” ideal through Ole Marge, Page then presents a scene in which the family’s practice of singing hymns together seems to compromise this rebelliousness. Every Sunday evening, we are told, the family opens their parlor and, with Young Marge on organ, sings hymns. For Young Marge, this is “the one genuine pleasure of the week” (40). For Page, however, the use of the parlor for this “Sabbath evening ritual” (41) symbolizes how music is alienated from the Crenshaws’ social reality. By singing in the parlor—“a room set apart, dedicated to the high dreams and frustrated hopes [. . .] of a nobler life” (40)—the family tries to temporarily replicate an elusive bourgeois ideal, to the point of putting a superfluous songbook on the organ. Even though “Marge could not read the notes, but played by ear, and the singers knew all the words by heart [. . .] the singing could never begin without the song book” (41).
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 26
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
“The Will to Win” 27 In light of the Marxist convictions she developed as an adult, Page’s upbringing left her ambivalent about Christianity’s value as a motivating force for oppressed people. She herself came from a “strong religious [tradition]” which “for all its faults and rigidities, had a certain energy and poetry that caught hold of [me].” “Religion can be a strength,” she observed, “because it offers so many good things to believe in—the Golden Rule, for example” (qtd. in Baker 113). Nevertheless, her study of Gastonia mill culture convinced her that certain central tenets of Christian belief were a “handicap” in these workers’ lives: “Believing deeply that they were going to go to something better [. . .] made it easier for mill workers to put up with terrible conditions in the present” (qtd. in Baker 113).10 While Page had fond memories of her own family singing hymns, she felt differently when workers she saw as oppressed expressed their desires through religious song: “One night at the boarding house we played hymns and sang. The words to the songs were awful, and the people’s melancholic, rather morbid pleasure in them ruined any pleasure I might have had at the thought of fitting in. I played the piano, but I couldn’t sing those hymns” (qtd. in Baker 80). Such experience colors the depiction of the Crenshaw family singing “all the old favorites” (42). Page makes her point absolutely clear by preceding the hymn session with Marge asking her mother why “mill folks has it so hard?” Sal responds with a stream of religious platitudes that contrasts markedly with Ole Marge’s earlier indignation towards the poverty of mill folks: “Everything’s God’s Will, Marge. It’s hard, but we’ll understand it bettah by ’n by. Parson Brown saws [sic] we gotta bear our cross in patience, ’n re-sign ourselfs to God’s mysterious Plan [. . . .] [R]eligion is a comfort to the poor. It’s all we got” (36-7). The specific hymns that Page identifies as the family’s favorites generally reinforce the idea that the family is drawn to and hindered by religious doctrine that encourages passive acceptance of earthly trials. “There is a Land,” for instance, promises that death will bring a “land of pure delight” where “pleasures banish pain.”11 Similarly, “Shall We Gather at the River” anticipates a place “by the throne of God” where “our pilgrimage can cease” and people can “lay every burden down” and worship “all the happy golden day.”12 “Wash Me and I Shall Be Whiter Than Snow” advises that God will “cleanse” and “create a new heart” in those who “humbly entreat” and “patiently wait.”13 Although the Crenshaws’ music-making tradition provides a vehicle for family unity and creative expression, it falls short in addressing their practical problems. On the one hand, the experience of producing harmonies with the family lifts Marge in an intangible way: “As they sang [. . .] and the harmonies rose and swelled, Marge felt some compelling force take hold of her
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 27
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
28
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
and waft her away to parts unknown [. . . .] What happened to her when they sang, she couldn’t explain, but it sure was sweet” (42).14 On the other hand, “quiet tears slipping down Sal’s cheeks” (42) suggest that, for Marge’s mother, the hymns may painfully highlight unrealized earthly hopes even while promising something better after death.15 Another scene develops Page’s argument that organized religion conspires with labor’s managerial interests in maintaining oppression. Marge— now adrift after her grandmother’s death—attends a revival at the “company church” (103), where, although skeptical and resistant, she eventually succumbs to the pressure to allow herself to be “saved.” In Page’s depiction, the revivalists’ shouts of “Hallelujah, Hallelujah” blend with the “growl, growl” of the mill (105).16 At least one hymn that the Crenshaws had sung in their parlor—“What a Friend We Have in Jesus”—reappears here, suggesting that this family willingly reproduces in their home a culture that also exists as an ideological apparatus in the public sphere. Significantly, Page argued in Southern Cotton Mills and Labor that “colored churches” handicap black workers as much as white churches do their working-class members: “Colored churches exert an exceptionally conservative influence, presenting to their memberships a totally wrong slant on this subject race’s problems and methods of dealing with them” (42). Although she observed that “out of hardship and isolation, Negroes have developed a rich culture of their own” that “reflects the working class nature of their lives,” she did not see this “rich culture” as especially relevant to a struggle against economic exploitation: “only occasionally does a song or story give forth a call to the toiling and oppressed of this race to revolt against their enslavement” (42). Gathering Storm, in contrast, omits organized black churches as a force, for good or ill, contributing to workers’ stance towards oppression, explaining that “the company had not thought it advisable to build a church and hire a pastor for its colored families” (106). When members of the black Back Row community go to their own revival “out in the country,” their singing is not only “far more beautiful” than that of the white revivalists, but also “more their own” (107). In keeping with this aside, Page elsewhere portrays black spirituals as folk culture, autonomous from organized religion, that gives black workers valuable inspiration and guidance. Having opened Gathering Storm describing the white Crenshaws talking about the hardships of mill life and then singing in their parlor, Page then offers a parallel description of how members of the black community who live in “Back Row” (a segregated section of town adjacent to Row Hill) have passed the same Sunday evening with talk and song. The latter scene opens with one of the Back Row patriarchs, Uncle Ben Morgan, “and his two
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 28
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
“The Will to Win” 29 youngest [. . .] sitting on their doorstoops [. . .] while [Ben] strummed his banjo and hummed under his breath” (51). The mood quickly shifts from pastoral content to socio-political discontent as more friends and family gather and talk turns to the various injustices of millwork, sharecropping, and housekeeping for wealthy whites. Through their conversation, these characters reveal that they recognize the mechanisms of oppression but cannot see viable alternatives. As one young sharecropper, Jim, concludes, the economic system traps black sharecroppers in conditions not unlike slavery, “but what kin they do?” (57).17 While the Crenshaw’s Sunday-night music ritual is shaped by the pretensions of going into the parlor and using a songbook, the music on Uncle Ben’s porch is more spontaneous and communally inclusive. It radiates freely into the night and draws people from neighboring cabins. Even Marge, when she happens to step outside, “caught a faint echo of the singing as it floated across the fields from Back Row to Row Hill” (61). A reader might initially surmise that the cultural function of spirituals such as “Swing Low” and “Nobody Knows the Trouble I’ve Seen” parallels that of the hymns sung by the Crenshaws, expressing faith that a world free of suffering awaits after death.18 Page differentiates the two traditions, however. While the Crenshaw family does not analyze how these hymns might shed light on their daily lives, the black singers proudly discuss how their music was once used explicitly to resist oppression: Uncle Ben had told the children more than once how this song [“Steal Away to Jesus”] had been used by the Negroes, when still in slavery, as a signal for a meeting in the woods. Here, late at night, and far away from their master’s plantations, they’d gather as they were forbidden to do, and talk of freedom. (59)
The black singers use the words to another spiritual, “Go Down, Moses”— the “best song we got” and “the truest”—to initiate discussion of their current dilemma: “‘Moses lead [sic] the chillen of Israel,’” Uncle Ben asserts, “‘’n we needs somebody to lead us’” (61). After more talk of how the fifty years since abolition have failed to end black poverty and subservience, the group raises a final hymn—“A Great Day’s Comin’ Bye ’n Bye”—as a rhetorical conclusion (62). Like “Steal Away” and “Go Down, Moses,” this song reveals a smoldering political determination that awaits leadership. Clearly, these juxtaposed representations of the Crenshaws and the Back Row villagers each singing their most cherished songs are intended to favor the latter tradition as a response to social conditions. Page renders this
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 29
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
30
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
Back Row evening to show that black workers have created a context for their spirituals that intertwines aesthetically and religiously fulfilling performance rituals with political aspirations. She does not allow less serious music to dilute the effect of this heady mix of spirituals and debate. When several young boys ask Uncle Ben to liven things up with a few dance tunes, older group members dictate that frivolous entertainment should wait until another night of the week (60).19 In his contributions to the evening’s discussion, the banjo-playing Uncle Ben reveals that he possesses both a valuable musical tradition and (like Young Marge’s grandmother) a determined political vision of a future where his people will know greater socioeconomic equality. Uncle Ben provides Back Row children with a politically motivating answer when they ask why their slave ancestors had not overthrown their oppressors. While another adult advises that, then and now, “there ain’t but one way to git along with white folks’n that is to let ’em have their way,” Uncle Ben counters that “even with all the odds agin ’em, [slaves] did rise up, once in awhile,” even though they were “strung for it” (59).20 One child, George, hears the adults’ grievances and responds that when he grows up “we-uns ain’t gone let the white mens treat colored folks thata way!” (57). While some of his “elders chuckled at his cock-sureness,” Uncle Ben tells them not to laugh: “‘Sonny, mebbe you’s right’” (57). George absorbs Uncle Ben’s progressive vision as an antidote to his own parents’ morbid fatalism, tapping into this elder’s cultural resources by asking Uncle Ben for “a lil’ music” after the serious conversation has run its course (58).21 (Similarly, Young Marge seeks out her Grandmother’s bitter insights as an alternative to her mother’s more defeatist ones.) Years later, Uncle Ben’s stories and songs remain George’s inspiration for “right[ing] the wrongs of his people” (168). While most people his age “were too taken up with jazz ’n craps to pay other things much mind,” George and three like-minded people spend free time “sing[ing] work-songs or spirituals” and discussing problems confronting their race (168). (As will be discussed further, this statement contributes to the novel’s generally negative depiction of jazz.) What line of reasoning might have led Page to privilege black culture’s ability to resist/reform capitalism? More explicitly excluded than white workers from all but the bottom rung of the industrial ladder, black workers were less likely to harbor illusions that they shared a common interest with white industrialists. Their cultural expression might be assumed to reflect this social reality.22 In contrast, dominant culture encouraged whites, regardless of class, to believe that they (a la Ben Franklin or Horatio Alger protagonist) could scale America’s economic ladder. Page’s white workers buy into this ideology and tend to overlook class exploitation. At one point in the novel,
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 30
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
“The Will to Win” 31 a group of white workers agree that all whites should stick together to keep blacks “in their place” (136). In Page’s vision, white culture such as hymns or (as discussed later) popular songs shared across class lines contributes to this false sense of unity. The contrast between Page’s happy recollections of her own family singing hymns and her bleak view of the Crenshaws enjoying the same pastime suggests that the messages conveyed through such culture could have far different implications for middle-class whites who are not trapped in an oppressive labor system and lower-class whites who are. When portraying white bourgeois culture, Page shows class-transcending aesthetic consensus as a potentially seductive danger. When portraying black spirituals, however, she turns race-transcending aesthetic consensus into a potential site for initiating working-class solidarity. After Page develops a cultural context showing that spirituals still give black workers political guidance, she goes on to suggest that spirituals’ power and beauty may also help white workers to transcend their own racial prejudices. Such perspectives towards spirituals are consonant with those articulated in well-known manifestos of the preceding decades by African American intellectuals of the “New Negro” school such as W.E.B. DuBois, James Weldon Johnson, and Alain Locke.23 DuBois’ The Souls of Black Folk, for instance, proposes that the body of black “sorrow songs” stands today not simply as the sole American music, but as the most beautiful expression of human experience born this side the seas. It has been neglected, it has been, and is, half despised, and above all it has been persistently mistaken and misunderstood; but notwithstanding, it still remains as the singular spiritual heritage of the nation and the greatest gift of the Negro people. (373)
To DuBois, the sorrow songs are more than an aesthetically beautiful record of suffering; they are also an expression of “faith in the ultimate justice of things” (73). Johnson similarly argues that spirituals, along with black folk tales, are “the only things artistic that have yet sprung from American soil and been universally acknowledged as distinctive American products” (10). Improving “the status of the Negro in the United States,” he proposes, is foremost “a question of national mental attitude toward the race” (9), and the first step in changing this mental attitude must be a new recognition of the spirituals as great art: “it is the touchstone, it is the magic thing, it is that by which the Negro can bridge all chasms. No persons, however hostile, can listen to Negroes singing this wonderful music without having their hostility melted down” (20). Locke, too, argues that the most “immediate hope” for African
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 31
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
32
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
American “rehabilitation” “rests in the revaluation by white and black alike of the Negro in terms of his artistic endowments and cultural contributions past and prospective” (580). Gathering Storm takes such suppositions a step further: if hostile whites could become sympathetic to blacks through the spirituals’ pathos, they might then prove receptive to a logical demonstration that racism contributes to their own economic plight. Page’s belief in the unifying power of spirituals perhaps had roots in a formative ritual of her early life. As a girl, she made frequent Sunday-night visits to Hampton Institute, a nearby college for black students [. . .] to hear the four hundred or so Hampton students sing Negro spirituals. Whites sat in the balcony, and black students sat in the main auditorium. They might sing the same spiritual, but it sounded different each time as beautiful solo voices, here and there, broke forth. The music rose like a great ocean carrying us into vast spaces, holding us close to the tragedy and beauty and longing of life. For those few moments, I knew spiritual unity with these people, a common meeting ground. When the music ended there was no contact at all, and I felt myself a stranger among strangers. (qtd. in Baker 25-6)
In Gathering Storm, the rigidly segregated structure of working-class society makes the chances for such “spiritual unity” much less likely: Although “[the] colony, known as ‘Back Row’ and ‘niggertown,’ was barely two hundred yards from where the Crenshaws lived [. . .] if the distance had been two thousand miles instead, Marge and the people on her side of the village and those on this could scarcely have known less about one another” (50). Also, Gathering Storm suggests Page’s recognition that a more complex reality of interracial antagonisms might have existed beyond what she had perceived when visiting the black church as a child: At the Wednesday evening service, some rich white folks from Greenville came, with two out-of-town visitors, and sat in the balcony. They told the parson they had come to hear the singing and preaching, but then why did they exchange glances and hide their smiles behind their fans? Martha [Uncle Ben’s daughter] was not the only one who resented these white folks’ curiosity and intrusion. “What they think we is, a circus?” But their resentment the Negroes hid behind a polite servility. (107)
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 32
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
“The Will to Win” 33 Page not only questions whether these spectators sincerely respect the culture they witness, but also links them to economic interests that inherently conflict with those of these struggling black workers. One white spectator is “the mill owner’s son” and the other is “a daughter of the banker [. . .] who owned the land which more than one share cropper tilled” (107). This scene does not raise the hope that encountering spirituals in this context might forge a “spiritual unity” or somehow induce these rich visitors to redistribute some of their assets among the needy. Rather, it serves to add insult to the injuries of economic exploitation. While these privileged whites may freely intrude on a black cultural space, blacks most likely would not have been invited to sing in a white church or home. Significantly, Page represents a spiritual facilitating a brief race-transcendent enlightenment, not in the church (as she had experienced it), but in a factory. When Young Marge hears Ellie Morgan, Uncle Ben’s wife, singing “Let My People Go,” she first thinks about her own family’s desire to somehow get “away from the mills to some better life” (73). Only later does she recognize the bearer of the song as herself a subject worth contemplation: “Does that colored woman singing, feel thataway too? Do her people hate it ’n want to git away?” (73). Although Marge’s encounter with Ellie Morgan and her song is fleeting, it provokes thoughts that initiate the development of Marge’s interracial empathy. Later, when Marge and Martha, who is Ellie’s daughter, happen to meet in the factory and look “one another full in the eye,” “for a moment, the distance which lay between them was bridged” (74).24 Even as Page strives to give older characters like Ole Marge and Uncle Ben certain exemplary qualities, her novel’s bildungsroman structure leaves ample room for the next generation’s independent development. Whether inherited wisdom comes from an older song or an older sage, it must develop somehow before it can help confront previously daunting problems. Characters like Young Marge and George exemplify the idea that workingclass rebels grow by staying rooted in their heritage while still actively pruning away regressive notions and grafting on new ones. Even though Young Marge’s grandmother provides fertile ground for her early growth, Young Marge eventually needs further nurture. Ole Marge betrays her ideological limitations when she tries to explain racism for her granddaughter. Though her husband (now dead) had fought in the Civil War to free slaves, his later aversion to the mills came in part from a belief that “niggers bring bad luck”: “‘up here we keep ’em out our hills, ’n that’s whar I want to stay’” (15).25 When Young Marge asks, “how’d granpa figger niggers bring bad luck,” Ole Marge confesses that she doesn’t know. At any rate, she tells her
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 33
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
34
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
granddaughter, “po’ Whites sure have their share of bad luck wherever they go, niggers or no niggers. But the notion growed up, that somehow or ’tother it was the black man’s fault” (16). Ole Marge herself retains some values, supposedly mountain-based, that are counterproductive to working-class solidarity. She gleefully recounts a distant episode in which mill operators had naively brought members of “the Allen clan to the hill. You know, the Allens what we Marlows’d feuded with goin’ on five generations, we ain’t gone mix with, down here” (23). After the Marlows took up arms against the rival clan, “the mill’d give orders to its agents, not to mix up no mo’ clans” (24). If Ole Marge now sees such feuding as regressive, she does not say so to her granddaughter.26 Page also takes care to show that Uncle Ben, like Ole Marge, has a limited scope—though one justified by his own past experience—in envisioning a future society without racial distinctions. He tells his young children, for instance, that it’s “best not to git mixed up with white folks ’n their chillen. Stay on your own side the fence” (72). Meanwhile, unknown to Uncle Ben, his older son, Fred, has gotten involved with the integrated International Workers of the World (IWW) in New York City. Fred will later travel to Russia to observe Communist society (249). Page proposes other fans for the flames of discontent besides radicalism conceived and handed down orally. Through her older brother Tom, who has left home and found work in New York City, Marge learns for the first time that a print tradition also exists for critiquing the labor system. Following his own initiation into the IWW and then the Socialist Party, Tom sends Marge The Jungle, Upton Sinclair’s famous 1906 novel about the experience of a group of Lithuanian immigrants trying to survive in Chicago’s brutal industrial slums. The novel focuses on Jurgis Rudkus, a man who moves from job to job, suffering new defeats at every turn until, at the novel’s end, his discovery of the Socialist Party seems to promise a better future. The Jungle has a profound effect on Marge: “The next few days Marge walked around like one in a dream. [. . . .] The work-a-day world around her grew indistinct, unreal, for she was far away, living and laboring with the stockyard workers in Chicago, and, finally taking part in their great revolt” (91). After reading the book to herself, “she read the book over again, aloud to Granny and Ruth [her older sister], and the three lived it through together” (91). Ole Marge comments approvingly that “‘that thar Jurgis, he had the fightin’ spirit’” (91). Later, Tom answers Marge’s request for similar books by sending her Edward Bellamy’s Looking Backward and Karl Marx’s “Wage-Labor and Capital” (141).27 Since local dominant interests discourage such intellectual inquiry, Tom’s journey to the North is crucial to Marge’s exposure to
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 34
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
“The Will to Win” 35 radical ideas. When Marge asks at her local library for more books like The Jungle, “the librarian voiced her horror in a fifteen minute monologue” and then steers her towards conventional, innocuous material for an adolescent girl (103).28 In this repressive context, Ole Marge’s orally transmitted alternative interpretations of history and Tom’s inside/outside perspective both gain value. As Tom’s Russian-born romantic interest (and future wife), Bessie, suggests, “we’ll never have a real movement in this country [. . .] till the New Yorks and Row Hills get together” (152). As already discussed, the novel’s first portrait of the Back Row community extols spirituals as an aesthetically and politically rich medium—one that entertains without obscuring sociopolitical needs. Later, however, Page suggests that some in the poor black community view these singing sessions merely as variety in life’s “monotonous tread” (117). She also casts doubt on the novel’s earlier idea that racist whites might undergo dramatic ideological changes simply by appreciating black music. In fact, the novel repeatedly suggests the irrelevance of music in changing the course of an outbreak of interracial violence. Shortly after the local mill owner’s son, Elbert, attends a black revival, he rapes and murders Uncle Ben’s daughter, Martha. He then joins the “cream of Greenville Society” (129) at a white country-club party where, significantly, a jazz band provides entertainment. (Although Page does not mention the band members’ race, the context—and the very fact that their race is not noted—implies their whiteness.) After Martha’s body is found with evidence linking Elbert to the deed, her black boyfriend, Jim, goes to the country club to find Elbert. Just before Jim kills Elbert, an aptly named song played by the jazz band provides an ironic commentary on the situation: “through the open window and into the sultry night drifted the tones of a wailing saxaphone [sic], ‘You Made Me What I Am Today, I Hope You’re Satisfied’” (129). Indeed, Elbert’s exploitative stance towards black life—his view of black culture and Martha’s black body alike as available for his superficial pleasure—has transformed Jim into Elbert’s killer. To avenge Elbert’s death, a white mob descends upon Back Row, where Uncle Ben and his family become the unfortunate recipients of their wrath. In another ironic symbol of music’s inability to head off such a tragedy, Uncle Ben’s young son, Charlie, tries to defend his family by swinging his father’s banjo, club-like, at the attackers. Clearly, the banjo cannot match the mob’s guns: “it jangled faintly as its battered sides were grabbed and tossed aside” (133). In the end, Uncle Ben, his wife, and their two children, Charlie and Myrtle, all die at the hands of the mob. (Jim kills himself as the mob closes in on him.)
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 35
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
36
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
Among local whites, the bloody incident arouses some debate, but little more. At the mill the next day, Marge’s Uncle Mat remembers Uncle Ben as a “good, quiet-kind of nigger, ’n a handy one with the banjo” (136). Marge herself, remembering the time she had heard “Ma Morgan’s singing ‘Go Down Moses,’” finds the courage to criticize fellow workers who, as a matter of principle, take a pro-white stance toward the violent event (136). Still, none of this sympathy actually produces tangible action to soothe racial tensions. While the above chain of events interrogates black music as one factor within the socioeconomic landscape of an interracial Southern mill town, other scenarios in the novel turn similar attention to songs popular primarily among white workers. Through representations of workers engaging with popular music, Page explores from yet another angle how various cultural resources steer workers either towards or away from dealing with their problems constructively. In Page’s hands, this popular music—produced and distributed for mass consumption through sophisticated capitalist channels—provides another explanation for workers’ passive tendencies. Page’s representations of such songs usually suggest ironic disjunction between capitalist culture’s idealized views of life and the novel’s own portraits of workers beset by problems they don’t yet know how to solve. That workers remain attached to these songs in spite of this tangible disjunction represents their false consciousness and inability to align culture with political needs. Page’s use of song titles and lyric fragments alone convey her popular-culture-as-opiate stance. Still, further investigation of these songs’ texts and cultural contexts adds depth to this stance by restoring cultural knowledge that Page likely took for granted among potential readers. Such is the case with the song “Hot Time in the Old Town Tonight,” which appears twice in the novel—once played by Uncle Ben for the black Back Row dance mentioned earlier (63), and once as one of the “two wheezy tunes” that a traveling merry-go-round plays automatically for white patrons (94). “Hot Time,” with its exaggerated dialect and stereotypes of happy-go-lucky blacks enjoying life on the town, debuted in 1896 and became a standard on minstrel-show and musical-revue circuits (McSherry).29 One level of irony in Page’s allusion is unmistakable—life in the bleak mill village, as Page has portrayed it, hardly resembles a “hot time.” Another potential level of irony relates to this song’s association with the Spanish-American War of 1898. As Page and her readers likely knew, Teddy Roosevelt’s Rough Riders adapted “Hot Time” “as their ‘theme song’ during the battle of San Juan Hill, probably one of the first uses of a popular song in this manner” (Reublin).30 Early in Gathering Storm, Ole Marge—who lost a son in this war—corrects Young
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 36
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
“The Will to Win” 37 Marge’s speculation that “it must be fun to live while a war’s on. Teacher told us about it, bands of music, ’n soldiers, ’n flags flyin’”: “That’s what it looks like aforehand. But when they’s on, they’s diff ’rent” (26). Unlike Ole Marge, Sal (her daughter) fondly remembers how the Spanish-American War stimulated a patriotic fervor in the mill village that was “like a circus, somethin’ doin’ all the time” (160). Assuming that Page linked “Hot Time” to this war, her novel’s depiction of this song as an accompaniment for dancing and riding merry-go-rounds contributes to a recurring critique of war and the way popular culture glorifies it. Viewed critically, wartime appropriation of such cheery popular songs obscures the realities of brutal death and imperialist motives with an image of battle as a “hot time in the old town.”31 Gathering Storm offers a similar critique in depicting World War One, when popular patriotic tunes like “Oh Say Can You See?” (“The Star-Spangled Banner”) (161) and “Over There” (203) promoted a unified nationalistic fervor. Only after the war do jaded, traumatized veterans like Marge’s Uncle Mat come to see this conflict as a “rich man’s war ’n a poor man’s fight” (200).32 As mentioned earlier in this chapter, jazz gains various negative connotations in Gathering Storm. It diverts young blacks’ focus from political struggle (168) and feeds white consumers’ desire to enjoy black culture without addressing socioeconomic inequalities (128-30). In this latter case, Page suggests that this music uses its sensual quality to promote vacuous trends. A lyric fragment from another song played at the country-club dance noted earlier conveys this lack of substance: “Everybody’s Doing IT—Doing What? Turkey Trot!” (130). Given Gathering Storm’s overall construction of cultural values, jazz likely struck Page as a music shaped not by working-class needs, but by the consumer market for new fads.33 Often emphasizing rhythm and melody over lyric content, jazz could be more easily co-opted by dominant culture as an apolitical commodity. Further, the phenomenon of racially integrated jazz bands that later made this music politically progressive outside of the South seems highly unlikely in Gathering Storm’s segregated mill villages.34 Particularly since Page wrote Gathering Storm out of a belief (revised in later life) that blacks in a post-revolution America would want and should get “a republic of their own” (qtd. in Baker 117), the idea of musicians and/ or styles integrating across racial lines probably didn’t seem like a logical prediction for the projected new order. While jazz seems to be the music of choice for Page’s upper-class whites to escape reality, popular song in a sentimental vein seems to be the main music (other than hymns) her working-class white characters turn to for solace. In Page’s portrayal, decadent values flaw the former, romantic ones the latter. Facing an imminent death from tuberculosis, Marge’s husband, Bob,
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 37
6/22/2006 8:54:26 AM
38
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
seeks consolation in sentimental songs. Although a doctor has told Marge that “with proper care [Bob] may live for years” (237), he fails rapidly because the family cannot afford good nursing, housing, or nutritious food. Rather than express bitterness (as Ole Marge had done on her deathbed) at how the labor system has compromised his chance at life, Bob wants to “[relive] those days, the bright, early days before youth and hope had gone” (240). His last request to his wife is “‘sing to me.’ She knew what he wanted. The songs they’d sung together as young lovers. ‘Aunt Diana’s [sic] Quilting Party,’ ‘Darlin’ Nellie Gray’” (240). Although Page only alludes to these songs’ titles, their actual lyrics offer ironic contrast with Bob’s situation. “Aunt Dinah’s Quilting Party” evokes a simpler time when communal labor and romance seem to go hand in hand: “On my life new hopes were dawning / And those hopes have lived and grown / And ’twas from Aunt Dinah’s quilting party / I was seeing Nellie home.”35 Also in a sentimental mode, the second song Marge sings to her dying husband adopts the viewpoint of a black Kentuckian lamenting his “Darling Nellie Gray,” taken as a slave “to Georgia / For to wear her life away, / As she toils in the cotton and the cane” (Hanby 53-6). Published in 1856 by the white Benjamin Russell Hanby, then a college student in Ohio, “Darling Nellie Gray” endured in popularity into the twentieth century. Similar to the white hymns that the novel castigates, this song (albeit implicitly antislavery) strives for pathos through showing the singer patiently enduring his loss, “weeping all the day,” growing old until he “hears the angels calling” and knows that he is soon going to a place where “they’ll never take [Nellie] from me anymore” (Hanby 53-6). Finally, as Bob takes his last breaths, Marge sings “his favorite”: “Sing me to sleep, the shadows fall” (240). The song’s next line (which Page does not give) highlights the idea of escaping rather than engaging worldly problems: “Let me forget the world and all.”36 Whom did Page hope to influence through her largely cynical allusions to hymns, jazz, and popular songs? Did she envision a sophisticated Marxist reader, already predisposed to distrust any cultural product that relied so heavily on the capitalist market to circulate? Or, did she foresee as readers Southern workers who might well find one or more of their own best-loved songs lampooned in the novel’s pages? As mentioned earlier, Page claimed to have written the non-fiction Southern Cotton Mills and Labor to “appeal to a working-class audience.” Gathering Storm—in using a range of storytelling conventions to keep the pages turning—seems to go considerably further in its bid for working-class appeal. Touching such an audience—reaching the Marge Crenshaws of the South who vainly searched the local library for realistic stories about people like themselves—was likely one of the foremost
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 38
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
“The Will to Win” 39 desires shaping Page’s literary decisions. In this light, we may see how Page’s novel “defamiliarizes” readers’ perceptions of culture that was likely familiar and beloved. As Victor Shklovsky has suggested, literature may portray a familiar world, but use self-consciously literary techniques to “remove the automatism of perception” (25). In this way, Page’s novel embeds allusions to familiar culture within a value system hypersensitive to culture’s political implications. It strives to replace the warm glow of nostalgia and the false beacon of ritual with a more exacting light. Moving into the climactic final third of the novel, Page includes a chapter whose title, “New Times—New Songs,” clearly anticipates an optimistic cultural change. The chapter opens with the white Tom Crenshaw and the black George Johnson (both having exchanged the IWW for the more militant Communist Party) riding a southbound train from New York to “Riverton” (Gastonia), North Carolina. Tom’s sister Marge, who now works in Riverton’s Corey Mill, has asked for Tom’s assistance in organizing the overworked and underpaid local textile workers. For years, both Tom and George have avoided the repressive South, but George, much more than Tom, harbors intense bitterness towards the region where his beloved mentor, Uncle Ben, was lynched. Page, in keeping with her thesis that white American music tends to obscure harsh realities behind romantic images, shows Tom, with lingering nostalgia for his sunny homeland, naively singing “Dixie” in front of George: Oh, Dixie land, the land of cotton, Old times thar is not forgotten— (259)
He soon realizes his blunder when George, “with a scowl,” tells him to “can it”: “Gol-dern, what a low-down trash I am. Old times—huh” (259), he mutters to himself, thoroughly chastised. When George—whose sensitivity to music’s political implications is better developed than Tom’s—rents a room in “the Hollow” (Riverton’s version of the segregated Back Row where he grew up), he sees that this community also has a spiritual/musical leader like Uncle Ben: “As Uncle John brought forth his banjo and began strumming the strings [. . .] the crowd settled back with a sigh. [. . . .] But for the want of familiar faces, this might be Back Row [. . .]. The same old songs. The same bonds of outcast and down-trodden holdin’, bindin’ ’em all” (267). When the old man starts singing, however, George notices a bitter edge that Uncle Ben’s spirituals had lacked:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 39
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
40
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” Went to Atlanta Never been thar afo’ White folks eat th’ apple Nigger wait for the core (267)
Uncle John’s song moves through additional places and observations on unequal socioeconomic relations, ending with a trip to Heaven, where “Whitefolks sit in the Lawd’s place / Chase nigger down below” (268). Significantly, Uncle John tells the riveted George that various songs like this simply “come into my head” while “rumminatin’ [sic] over things” (268). To George, this change in musical expression—in a vernacular clearly more blunt and less poetic than that of spirituals—reflects a new desire to deal concretely with injustice. As Uncle John’s method of composition suggests, there is a minimal blurring of the line between the way injustice is comprehended and the way it is translated into artistic expression: Slavery ’n freedom They’s most the same No difference hardly ’Cept in the name (269)
An additional new song, which another singer, Jerry, had learned while unjustly sentenced to work on a North Carolina chain gang, starts with traditional-sounding blues laments on being poor and lonely. It progresses beyond this tradition, however, linking these hardships to race prejudice and ending with a communal (though exclusively male-directed) call to action: Stand boys stand No use arunnin’ Look up yonder hill White men acomin’ He got rope in one hand Pistol in ’tother Stand boy stand Brother stand by brother Stand by brother
Page, who acknowledged that when writing Gathering Storm “I may not have known black people then as well as I came to know them later”
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 40
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
“The Will to Win” 41 (qtd. in Baker 115), seems to have constructed this scene using for inspiration an article by Lawrence Gellert, “Negro Songs of Protest,” that appeared in a 1930 issue of New Masses. This article, the first of three which Gellert contributed to New Masses reporting his song-collecting fieldwork among blacks in North Carolina, South Carolina, and Georgia, contains the sources of all four of these songs. While the first three appear in Gathering Storm exactly as printed in New Masses, the final song subtly but significantly alters Gellert’s text. Although the original already had, as Gellert noted, a “militant chord [. . .] rather unusual for that section of the country,”37 Page refines its politics, steering it away from an expressed desire for black-against-white bloodletting and towards the novel’s more refined goal of seeing black and white workers united in class war against the capitalist system. Gellert’s original calls the approaching enemy “white trash”—the term often used to denigrate working-class whites: Stan’ boys stan’ No use arunnin Look up yonder hill White trash acomin’ Is acomin’ He got knife in one han’ Pistol in de odder (Gellert “Negro” 11)
Page changes “white trash” to “white men” and “knife” to “rope,” suggesting that this enemy is not actually as vast as “white trash” might suggest, but rather a smaller, less class-specific sector of the white population—those who might take part in a lynching.38 Further, Page omits a final stanza of the original that anticipates a black retaliation without recognizing the shared oppression of workers black and white: Nigger don’ you run ’way White thrash [sic] acomin’ Is acomin’ Get dat whackin’ stick in yo’ han’ Ruckus boun’ to happen (Gellert “Negro” 11)
Gellert reports that “the tune”—befitting words that suggest fairly indiscriminate, revenge-motivated violence—“is martial[,] guttural and snarlish” (11). Page, in contrast, describes the tune as “a resounding chant” (271),
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 41
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
42
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
thus emphasizing racial solidarity rather than revenge as the song’s guiding principle. While Page’s modified version does not imagine this solidarity transcending racial bounds, it nevertheless does not exclude the possibility of such interracial unity as strongly as Gellert’s text does.39 As in the scene from George’s childhood, the older listeners must suppress the desire of one of the younger set for something less “mournful” and more “lively” (269). Still, George sees these new songs as a hopeful sign that “maybe the war and years since had roused his people from their slumber” (271). He endorses the community’s faith in Uncle John and Jerry as truthful social critics, selecting them as representatives of the new integrated union he hopes to form. Although these new songs excite George, he realizes that they fail to break through the polarizing vision of race-against-race antagonism. To Jerry the chain-gang song simply “means what it says—black man, brother, stand by brother.” Hoping that he can bring a new class focus to this racial militancy, the more politically experienced George tells Jerry, that “thar’s more’n that in it [the song]” (271). Under George’s tutelage, Jerry and Uncle John rapidly drop the rhetoric of their racially angry songs, which would clash with their new understanding of integrated unionism: “I never dreamed to see white ’n colored hands standin’ side by side,” Uncle John later remarks. “But I can see it’s right. It’s the only way” (283). Reinforcing the novel’s earlier representation of a black religious worldview as capable of addressing worldly and otherworldly needs simultaneously, Uncle John now uses the traditional rhetoric of spirituals and sermons to praise unionism. Even when Tom assures Uncle John that he and George were sent by the Union rather than God, Uncle John maintains that he “feels the Lawd’s hand in it somewhars.” For him, the desires expressed in spirituals—for a leader “to deliver us from bondage,” and for a “Great Day comin’ bye ’n bye”—coexist with and are actualized by this Union (282-3). Showing Uncle John as an important mediator between the white, atheistic Tom and the predominately religious black workers, Page suggests that religious faith must be resolved with Union faith rather than rejected outright. Similarly, Page uses an exchange between Jem, a young Communist organizer, and Miz Crane, a newly militant worker with forty years in the mill behind her, to suggest that organizers must also give some leeway to white workers’ religious faith if they are to successfully instill Union faith. In this exchange, Miz Crane wonders why “the Lawd” has let rain fall on evicted strikers, and Jem teases her that “maybe He’s sidin’ with the mill.” Miz Crane then tells him, “Hush, doan your [sic] blaspheme! That’s what I doan like about the Com-mun-ists—no respect for the Almighty.”
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 42
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
“The Will to Win” 43 “Now Ma,” Jem told her, “you know you think us Reds are about it.” “You ain’t so bad,” she admitted grudgingly, “exceptin’ this [irreverence towards religion]. [. . . .] Mercy sakes,” as drops slid down the neck of her blouse, “soon it’s gona pour. I bet the good Lawd’s weepin’ to see what’s happenin’ to His people here on Riverton Hill.” (318-9)
Through Miz Crane, whose spiritual faith does not seem to compromise her activism, Page resolves into a good-natured truce what could be a volatile conflict between atheistic and religious ideologies. If black workers can draw on spirituals to address religious and temporal concerns, what of white workers and their hymn tradition? Since her earlier portrayal of white hymns suggested passivity as a defining trait, Page seemingly cannot resolve this vehicle for religious ideology into one for militant ideology as easily as she has with black spirituals. When Page does show white workers singing their first protest song—“our Union Song” (“Solidarity Forever”), which Tom has taught them to “sing as we march”—she only has Tom tell them “you know the tune already” (285). This melody’s historic background (and the symbolic force it thus generates), however, is decidedly not of a Southern tradition. Rather, it comes from “John Brown’s Body” and “The Battle Hymn of the Republic,” two songs of the Civil War era tied to the cause of abolitionists and the Union Army. The former song was sung in abolitionist circles after Brown was hanged in 1859 for leading a raid on the U.S. arsenal at Harpers Ferry. In early 1862, the Massachusetts abolitionist Julia Ward Howe wrote new words to the tune after visiting a Union Army camp in Virginia. Her song, “The Battle Hymn of the Republic,” uses militant religious imagery (quite unlike that implied in Page’s depiction of white Southern hymns) to tie the Union Army’s cause to God’s will. God’s “righteous sentence” and “fiery gospel” assures this secular Army’s final victory. Instead of focusing solely on heavenly rewards, this song defiantly unites religious conviction and earthly struggle: “let us die to make men free, / While God is marching on.” In the following years, the inspirational militancy associated with this tune was co-opted for various labor causes. Clark D. Halker calls “John Brown’s Body” (or “The Battle Hymn of the Republic”) “the most famous song of the era” and notes that it “appeared as the tune for seven labor song-poems between 1870 and 1890” (87). Later, in 1915, Ralph H. Chaplin—a Kansas-born “radical labor artist, journalist, songwriter, and poet” (Salter 124) associated with the Industrial Workers of the World—again adapted this tune for his “Solidarity Forever.” Sung during numerous labor struggles from then on, it quickly became “virtually the anthem of the American labor movement” (Nelson 62). Chaplin’s song
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 43
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
44
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
draws inspiration from the militant spirit of its predecessors, but names the Union instead of God as the force that will assist a struggle for justice: When the Union’s inspiration through the worker’s blood shall run, There can be no power greater anywhere beneath the sun. Yet what force on earth is weaker than the feeble strength of one? But the Union makes us strong.
While “Battle Hymn” uses vague symbols to evoke the enemy (“the serpent” in one verse), “Solidarity” more explicitly condemns “the greedy parasite / Who would lash us into serfdom and would crush us with his might.” The background of these three songs—as tied to both black liberation and the use of militant (as opposed to passive) religious imagery—does not fit naturally with Page’s depiction of white Southern workers handicapped by racism and religion. As Page uses it, “Solidarity Forever,” then, cannot be said to represent traditional white Southern culture modified slightly to address a new situation. Rather than draw attention to the potential contradictions between old and new ideologies, Page glosses over the deeper implications of the Union song’s background, simply letting white and black workers’ singing symbolize their willingness to embrace the interracial solidarity they had resisted earlier. Significantly, Page notes that Marge’s “voice was husky, for it was the first time in many months that she had sung” (285). While the most militant black workers in the Hollow have already been using songs to arouse indignation, Marge, an equally progressive white worker, has avoided singing, apparently because her culture’s musical resources seemed ill suited to workers’ political needs. The idea that white Southern mill workers might also be able to create valuable new art to comment realistically on their socioeconomic problems seems to have occurred to Page after she wrote Southern Cotton Mills and Labor. In that 1929 work, after discussing in largely negative terms a mill family singing hymns (observations incorporated into the Gathering Storm scene discussed earlier), Page commented that “these Poor Whites had left their folk songs in the mountains, and mill life has not produced any others” (22). While the first three-quarters of Gathering Storm seem to support this assertion, the appearance of songwriter/activist Ella May Wiggins near the novel’s conclusion revises it, showing a white mill worker creating communally embraced portraits of mill life: “Ever since [Marge] had heard Ella May sing, ‘How it hurts the heart of a Mother,’ and her other ballads about the Union, Marge had felt drawn to this woman” (303). The appearance of Ella May’s songs near the novel’s end provides an optimistic sign that formerly
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 44
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
“The Will to Win” 45 barren cultural ground is finally bearing nourishing fruit. As a way of simultaneously reaching workers’ hearts and intellects, these songs are more effective than the verbose rhetoric of northern organizers like Herb Sampson, who (as Tom observes) “never got over goin’ to Harvard” (308). Placed alongside organizers’ more sophisticated speeches, these songs are shown to be a legitimate and necessary part of an apparatus of resistance: “For the mill hands this tiny woman [Ella May] had come to symbolize the will to win” (335).40 Just as Page shows ruling-class interests actively promoting culture that obscures potential tensions, she also shows them trying to suppress this new subversive culture. Earlier, before singing his radical song (“Stand boys stand”), the black Jerry remarks that “the fellow what first learned me it, got shot through his lungs for sassin’ the white boss-man” (270). Now, after Ella May’s well is mysteriously poisoned, she declares, “ain’t [the mill company] promised to get me for makin’ up all them songs?” (338).41 After a bullet fired from a company truck kills her, her fellow workers again concur that she was singled out because of her powerful role in unifying the strikers: “‘They killed our singin’ ’oman,’ the mill hands said, ‘we’ll not forget. They killed her a-purpose’” (360).42 Importantly, this vow to “not forget,” which spreads “from hill to hill,” gives Ella May’s song (like the one Jerry has sung) additional “folk” legitimacy. Communally owned, it cannot be snuffed out simply by destroying its original creator. Even when the inherent qualities of a radical cultural text might not seem “folk,” Page strives to create a folk context by showing that workers accept and claim communal ownership of it. Near the end of the novel, the striking workers are delighted and inspired to discover that the Communist Daily Worker has printed a number of their submissions: “Young Binnie came racing over to Marge, her thin face aglow. ‘Look!’ she waved a newspaper over her head. ‘The Daily’s printed my letter ’n a lot more besides’” (329). At an older, illiterate woman’s request, Marge reads Binnie’s letter aloud: “They double up work on me every day of my life. I have worked every day but a half day and never got more than five dollars a week” (329). As the three women go over another unsigned letter (and easily identify a fellow worker, “Elm,” as its author), “a crowd [. . .] gathered around” (330). Marge reads yet another published letter by a friend—this one seething with colloquially expressed indignation: “Take the mill owner,” Phil’s long letter begins. “He don’t want you to have any thing but man, he wants a new car, all right, every six months, and his big, fine horse, and his twenty-five cent cigars and his servants” (330). Phil’s letter wins approval from the assembled listeners: “‘My, but that’s full of good truth!’ [. . . .] ‘Yah, that’s tellin’ ’em boy’” (333). Concluding with what she claims is “gona be the best of all,” Marge shares a
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 45
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
46
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
biting parody of the Bible’s “Twenty-Third Psalm” written by an anonymous Riverton striker: Corey mill is my sheperd [sic] and I shall not want He maketh me to lie down on park benches, …………………………………………………… Surely poverty and starvation will follow me all the days of my life And I will dwell in a rented house forever. P.S.—That is, if I don’t stand by the Union and fight like hell! (332)
Like Phil’s letter, this submission garners praise: “‘That’s a right smart piece. Who could’ve written it?’ Everybody looked about, questioning. ‘It’s worth settin’ to memory,’ Miz Crane observed, ‘[. . .]. To think this paper’ll print all us mill hands’ll send in’” (332). After workers observe that the local paper would never allow such criticism of economic interests, the scene concludes with several youngsters going through town selling papers: “‘Buy the Daily Worker!’ they piped, ‘Read all about us strikin’!’” (333). That the venerable Daily Worker has published these submissions verbatim conveys to the collected workers that people far away are hearing their experiences, rendered in their own voices, sympathetically. As the above scene demonstrates, this publication also provides an occasion for workers to gather spontaneously and listen to their words publicly performed. The novel form allows Page to go beyond the Daily’s publication of working-class documents by also showing how these texts seemingly win unanimous approval back in their community of origin. Thus, a symbiotic relationship between the Daily Worker and the Riverton workers is suggested. Like Ella May’s ballad, “The New Twenty-Third Psalm” self-consciously adapts a recognizable framework linked to old ideology to carry a radically new message.43 In significant contrast to Ella May’s ballads, though, this text is encountered not as oral culture, but circuitously, through the radical Daily Worker’s modern distribution system. (Workers realize that the partisan local paper would never print such subversive material.)44 Through this modern technology, the piece achieves a quicker and wider dissemination than it likely could through oral transmission alone (and also gives the author safety in anonymity). Such technology, Page suggests, can complement local folkways: after hearing this poem, the illiterate Miz Crane, who had earlier railed against a Communist’s “blaspheme,” now praises such a piece as “worth settin’ to memory” (332). Thus, the Daily Worker is shown to provide one forum where examples of radical culture representing vastly different regional influences can commingle.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 46
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
“The Will to Win” 47 Similarly, the national convention of the Trade Union Unity League (TUUL) in Cleveland, with which Page ends her novel, becomes a site where workers from around the nation (and abroad) see their regional differences subsumed by concerns common to industrial workers around the world.45 Page has already shown the Gastonia strike itself moving from regional to global significance, noting the “angry demonstrations” in support of the Gastonia strike’s organizers on trial “spreading across the oceans to Tokio [sic], Moscow, Berlin and London” (357). Within this widening context, Page’s final musical representation—workers at the TUUL meeting singing “The Internationale”—serves to make the novel’s potentially jarring move from local to global concerns seem inevitable.46 Temporarily left behind is the relatively dejected context of Gastonia’s largely defeated strike.47 Ahead lies a more hopeful vision of a time when, as this song proclaims, “the International Soviet / Shall be the human race” (369).48 Page’s placement of “The Internationale”—significantly, the Soviet Union’s national anthem at the time—as the novel’s crowning piece of protest-oriented culture touches on problems like those, noted earlier, that Laura Hapke sees in Page’s concluding section. Where, in Marge’s trajectory from local to global activism, is the directive for solving the more typical, local problems facing Southern workers who must still confront mill work six days a week? Likewise, where in this implicit “progress” of culture—arriving climactically at “The Internationale”—is the directive for these workers to further adapt their own cultural forms to meet new socioeconomic challenges? Except for its militant, pro-worker theme, this song has little to recommend it as an addition to Southern resistance culture. The songs of Uncle John, Jerry, and Ella May Wiggins (in addition to the “New Twenty-Third Psalm” parody) all flow naturally from these workers’ shared cultural repositories, even while they represent certain transformations or overturnings of earlier values. Page has esteemed Uncle John’s songs and Ella May Wiggins’ ballads because they articulate the problems of mill workers in familiar (and yet ideologically new) terms: We leave our home in the morning We kiss our children good-bye, While we slave for the bosses Our children scream and cry. (335)
Such a verse, especially as contextualized within Gathering Storm, exemplifies Cary Nelson’s argument that “traditional forms [poetry/lyrics using simple rhyme, meter, and diction] continued to do vital cultural work” during the period (1910-1945) now remembered more for the linguistic innovations of literary modernism:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 47
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
48
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” Far from being preeminently genteel, poetry in traditional forms was a frequent vehicle for sharply focused social commentary. Poets were thus often quite successful at making concise, paradigmatic statements about social life. Freed from the need to provide extended analysis or support a thesis with detailed evidence, poetry instead could highlight both the most basic structures of oppression in the culture and the fundamental principles that positive change should observe. (23)
If these are the cultural values Page’s novel has striven to establish, a reader might well ask how the comparatively abstract and elevated rhetoric of “The Internationale” improves upon Wiggins’ song as social commentary appropriate to the Southern textile-mill context: Arise ye prisoners of starvation, Arise ye wretched of the earth! For justice thunders condemnation A better world’s in birth! Marge, looking about to catch the words she didn’t yet know, saw that there were many like herself, straining to learn. Others sung in deep, sure tones. (369)
Would such a song inspire Southern workers to fit their own dilemmas into a similar framework? At the TUUL meeting, another worker, Jem, like Marge inspired and yet overwhelmed by the vast scene of workers united, asks, “you guess[,] Marge, we’ll ever be able to take it all back, to the folks on the hill?” (371). It is a question, tellingly, that neither Marge nor Page, in the novel’s remaining three pages, attempts to answer.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 48
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
Chapter Two
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”: Cultural Representations in To Make My Bread1
Some four-fifths of the way through Grace Lumpkin’s 1932 novel To Make My Bread, John McClure, a young North Carolina textile-mill worker, asks John Stevens, an older worker who is something of an organic radical, for advice on how he and his family can escape the poverty rut that has oppressed them since leaving their Appalachian home more than a decade before. While McClure clings to a hope that factory owners might someday “get the love of God in their hearts and share everything half and half with the poor,” Stevens believes that he should “as well expect a snake to come up and open its mouth gentle and humble for you t’ take out the fangs” (312). When Stevens then suggests that McClure, like most other workers, fears the snake-like power of factory owners, he offends McClure’s masculine pride: “‘I have not any fear,’ John said emphatically. It was something a man could not stand very well, to be told he was a coward. John himself was slow about getting up his anger but when he did, no man could walk over him” (313). Stevens carefully clarifies his meaning: McClure may not be afraid to stand up to any individual, but he would probably bow to a man who commands enough power to dismiss him from his job or jeopardize his family’s well-being. Stevens admits that he too has struggled to resolve this conflict between his individual desire to feel manly and his realization that he lives in a complex society where a traditionally conceived male independence may hurt others: “To get away from that fear, to show I was independent, I’ve traveled all over, and everywhere I’ve found my owner” (313). Significantly, in this same conversation, Stevens invokes the restless wandering of “John 49
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 49
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
50
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
Hardy”—the mythologized protagonist of a well-known American outlaw ballad—to explain the naïve motivation behind his past attempts to “get away from that fear” of an industrial capitalist society that is too powerful and complex to combat alone. Stevens tells John that he has “traveled to the east and traveled to the west, as the ballad of John Hardy says” only to find that the grip of Big Money upon laborers is “the same everywhere” (312). Stevens’ mention of “John Hardy”—a simultaneous invocation and rejection of its code of values—typifies a strategic deployment of cultural allusions that is central to this novel. Tracing the ideological transformations of mountain-bred millworkers who later become union members, To Make My Bread explores how characters engage with culture, and how this engagement influences and reflects their changing orientations towards their socioeconomic circumstances. Although the novel unquestionably climaxes with the strike near the end, Lumpkin is most interested in the arduous steps (and missteps) through which workers like McClure slowly advance towards a radical understanding of the capitalist system under which they labor. Even at this late point in the novel, workers like McClure have not yet begun their strike or recognized the power that may lie in collectively fighting against factory exploitation. The above conversation—one of numerous scenes that suggest the role of cultural “artifacts” in shaping a worldview—represents one of several important steps in McClure’s journey towards communism. Certain cultural artifacts influence characters’ “pre-radical” perceptions of the world; later encounters with new artifacts lead them to revise perceptions of older ones. In this dialectical relationship between culture, insight, and experience, new forms of cultural expression emerge to reflect and influence new ways of thinking and acting. After situating Lumpkin and her writing within a familial and social context, this chapter will focus on these patterns of cultural representation in To Make My Bread. These cultural representations function within the novel’s broader patterns of narrating characters’ ideological transformations. Lumpkin’s working-class characters gradually reject worldviews that valorize individual action at the expense of collective welfare. Further, they gradually reject worldviews that advocate a passive faith that divine powers will eventually compensate for socioeconomic inequalities. Characters come to transform these worldviews into new ones that valorize collective action along specifically Marxist lines. Various inserted cultural texts set into dialogue with each other work at various levels to illuminate and dramatize these processes of ideological change. The novel draws its cultural repertoire from the experiences of these characters and filters it through their aesthetic sensibilities, thus enhancing readers’ identification with a working-class vantage
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 50
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” 51 point. Reflecting the centrality of oral culture in these characters’ lives, the majority of the novel’s allusions are to orally circulated songs—hymns, folk songs, and labor/protest songs of recent composition. Other significant allusions are to written texts, including the Bible, the novel Les Misérables, and writings by Sacco and Vanzetti. Careful attention to this range of allusions within their novelized contexts helps readers to situate the narrative within a socially constructed environment and to participate in the experience of ideological growth that characters undergo. Such consideration of context in a novel must scrutinize not only the rendering of individual “scenes,” but all relevant material that precedes and follows these scenes. For this reason, my focus on cultural representations pays close attention to the specific points at which cultural allusions are placed within the novel and to how these points interrelate and influence the reader’s perception of narrative progress. Thus, the following relatively compressed summary of the novel’s most important plot and structural aspects serves mostly to supplement later, more detailed discussions of specific cultural allusions within specific contexts. Lumpkin’s novel, which encompasses the years 1900 to 1929, follows the white McClure family from their ancestral home in the Appalachian mountains to Leesville, a nearby town where they find work in a textile mill. After years of passively enduring the various effects of low wages and an oppressive workplace, members of the McClures’ youngest generation take part in a strike (historically based on the 1929 Gastonia strike). More than one-third of the novel details the McClures’ lives in the mountains prior to their migration—how they eke out a living through subsistence agriculture, hunting, and, occasionally, selling bootlegged whiskey for cash; how they are influenced by social and economic forces within and beyond their small, isolated mountain settlement; how they incorporate religion, folksongs, dancing, and other value-laden cultural practices into their lives. The novel starts with the birth of John, the youngest child of Emma McClure (whose husband had died from sickness several months before). Emma has three other children: Bonnie, Kirk, and Basil, ages one, eight, and nine, respectively. Emma’s father, John Kirkland (usually referred to as “Granpap”), has recently come to live with them, having lost his own land. Like the other families in the area, the McClures mostly subsist on homegrown corn, beans, and potatoes. What they cannot produce themselves they buy or trade for at a store owned by the Swains, the only literate and financially comfortable family in the area.2 A major source of drama in the novel’s early “mountain section” arises from the different paths that Kirk and Basil take as they approach independent manhood. As Basil becomes increasingly sanctimonious, Kirk gravitates
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 51
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
52
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
toward unruliness. (In a scene that epitomizes this difference, Kirk disrupts a ceremony at which Basil and other young adults are being baptized, stealing the preacher’s horse and galloping into the baptismal stream.) Basil’s new piety evolves into a determination to rise above his family’s poverty. Encouraged by a preacher, he enrolls at a church school outside the mountains and gradually cuts himself off from the rest of the McClure clan. (Later, he will marry into middle-class comfort in the same town where his impoverished family gets by on millwork.) While Basil ceases to care about his family, Kirk continues to help them at home. Showing additional integrity, Kirk takes in Minnie (his sometimes girlfriend) when she becomes pregnant and her father drives her from home. When Minnie—still spending her nights under Kirk’s roof— starts flagrantly seeing another man, Sam McEachern, Kirk tries to numb his frustration with alcohol. Eventually, when Sam takes Minnie from him, Kirk pursues the couple with a gun and is himself shot dead by Sam. Concurrent with showing Basil and Kirk going separate ways, the novel also depicts the development of Emma’s younger children, John and Bonnie. By frequently showing family events through Bonnie’s or John’s perspective, Lumpkin provides insights into how their early experiences and observations will contribute to their later subjectivities. (As their ideological developments eventually lead them to take active roles in forming a radical labor union and leading a strike, they will become the novel’s two most important characters.) Through Small Hardy, a peddler who occasionally passes through the mountains, families like the McClures hear rumors of easy money to be made working in textile mills in towns below. Though a particularly grim and hungry winter tempts them to head for the mill, they hang on for a number of years more. Granpap—who has told his grandsons that “you’re free men [ . . . ] so long as you’ve got your own potato patch and house and a gun” (21)—is especially adamant about holding onto a self-reliant mountain life. Later, however, after losing their land in negotiations with unscrupulous timber speculators, the family—along with other similarly disinherited families—decides to seek a life elsewhere. Thus, the extended McClure family makes the move to Leesville. Though this move is only about “forty miles [ . . . ] as the crow flies” (39), it profoundly changes the family’s relation to the world. The McClures now lease a cramped and run-down company-owned house; eligible family members work long hours at the mill and have little time or energy left over. Thus, realities of mill life soon tarnish earlier dreams of comfort and wealth. Granpap, who has not been able to get a mill job because the management considers him too old, becomes dejected and listless. He returns to the mountains for a time and resumes smuggling whiskey, but eventually
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 52
6/22/2006 8:54:27 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” 53 rejoins his family in the mill village. The family attempts to improve their circumstances by renting a small farm so that Granpap can raise cotton while Emma continues to work at the mill. John and Bonnie manage to attend school for a year, but must enter the mill after Emma develops pellagra, a disease stemming from malnutrition, and becomes too weak to work: “[I]f the young ones did not bring in some ready money, there would be nothing for them or anyone else in the family to eat” (254). After several years “struggl[ing] on the farm, trying to hold on as possible owner,” Granpap is faced with “giving up the farm or becoming a share-cropper.” He chooses the former, having learned from observation that “share-cropping is the same as slavery” (264). Never able to find a place in the mill-village economy that restores the sense of self-worth he had had in the mountains, he slowly loses his will to live. (He even abandons playing his beloved fiddle music after a local preacher discourages it.) Emma eventually dies of her chronic illness. Their formal schooling cut short, John and Bonnie get a different kind of education at the mill. Of particular importance, John develops a relationship with an older worker, John Stevens, who explains how the McClure family’s problems are rooted in economic exploitation and in cultural practices that tend to obscure it. Notably, he also teaches John a song he has written about the various ways that mill workers are mistreated. Even as John is learning from Stevens’ radical mentoring, other forces are pulling him toward identification with the town’s so-called “higher-ups.” Swayed by a charismatic friend, he briefly joins a conservative, racist club in town. Promoted to a higher paying “section boss” job, he hopes to carry out his duties with integrity, but finds that the mill management expects his undivided loyalty in return. When he tells his superintendent about workers’ grievances, he is advised to only concern himself with increasing productivity. He also becomes friends with an attractive female social worker recently hired by the mill; he wants to please her until she proposes that he take a job in which he would secretly notify the management about disgruntled workers. Eventually, John realizes that such opportunities to promote himself financially or socially are incompatible with his instinctive loyalty to fellow workers. Like John, Bonnie goes through a period of believing that she will find the elusive key to succeeding in the mill: “Often her thought turned to God and she prayed that he would bless her undertaking: to make herself so skillful that she would make a good life for herself and hers” (278). As her disappointments accumulate, she too gradually begins to see poverty and her own failure to escape it through a radical lens. She and John both become emboldened after Stevens gives them a “message”—that unions (and, later, revolution) could bring them better lives.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 53
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
54
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
As conditions in the mill village worsen (due in part to machines that put many out of work and require those who remain to speed up), Bonnie, John, and other like-minded workers begin to gather support for a union capable of fighting for better conditions. When a number of these workers, including John and Bonnie, are fired (presumably after a spy reports the fledgling union to the management), others in the factory launch a spontaneous walkout. The Communist organizer Tom Moore (and others working under him) soon appears, having come from the North to give the first-time strikers tactical advice and relief aid. Bonnie, who has overcome her racism after developing a friendship with a black woman, plays an important role in the strike by explaining to blacks in the area why they must not scab, but must join white workers in holding out for better treatment. She also contributes to the strike by writing and teaching others a song explaining the need for a union. Despite the brave efforts of many workers, the strike does not go well. Many workers return to the factory after they are threatened with eviction from their company-owned homes (352). The remaining strikers redouble their efforts and arrange to bring those still working out of the factory at an appointed time (369). Strike organizers are sure that “if they could bring out the rest of the workers [ . . . ], the strike would be won” (371). The strike becomes violent during this phase. First, company thugs kill Bonnie while she is onstage at a union meeting (372). Then, deputies attack the remaining strikers as they carry out their planned march to the mill. Later the same night, when armed and drunken deputies try to force their way into the union hall, a scuffle breaks out and the deputies’ leader is killed.3 In retaliation, numerous strikers are arrested and their encampment ransacked.4 The novel ends shortly after a somber funeral for Bonnie. Although the partisan local newspaper cynically announces that “the first revolutionary movement in the state was buried” along with Bonnie’s casket (383), the most committed strikers have another secret meeting planned. Whatever the outcome, the lessons in tactics and solidarity will prove more important than the strike’s failure to bring the workers any immediate tangible benefits. More “[blood] will be shed,” Stevens tells John, “before we reach that which we are fighting for” (383). As Stevens says in the novel’s final sentence, “this is just the beginning” (384).5 “The Remaking of a Southerner”—Lumpkin and the autobiography/fiction dialectic In what ways might To Make My Bread reflect Lumpkin’s creative reworking and critical (Marxist) interpretation of a body of values and knowledge
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 54
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” 55 gleaned through her family, society, and historical time and place? Lumpkin’s ancestry—which included “a distinguished line of governors, jurists, and members of Congress” (Gilkes 311)—could be traced to early Virginia aristocrats who later settled and found success in Georgia. In Lumpkin’s own post-Civil War lifetime, the family had lost the wealth of earlier generations, but retained a sense of aristocratic nobility. Considering these origins, Lumpkin’s decision to tell a tale of labor radicalization entirely from the perspective of a family from a much humbler class background seems, at one level, like a compelling attempt to work through perceived contradictions in her own identity. Little direct commentary exists from Lumpkin herself about the personal, aesthetic, and political goals behind To Make My Bread. And, further, any attempt to investigate potential links between life experience and literature is complicated by the fact that Lumpkin deliberately left little public extra-literary record of the relatively brief period during which she produced Marxist-oriented writing.6 The Making of a Southerner, a memoir published in 1946 by Grace’s younger sister Katherine Du Pre Lumpkin, offers the most significant light available to the contemporary researcher. As its title suggests, this memoir locates aspects of heritage and upbringing that contributed to the “making” of Katherine’s Southern identity within what Jacquelyn Down Hall describes as “a dispossessed planter family, a family haunted by defeat, obsessed with race, and determined to win back the pride and power lost in the Civil War” (“Open” 110). Of greater importance, it shows how the Lumpkins’ decline from Southern gentry increased Katherine’s ability to perceive the hegemonic underpinnings of her seemingly “natural” subjectivity (as a white, Southern female from a so-called “good family”). Thus, the full “making” of her identity encompassed later processes of unmaking and remaking. Although Southerner rarely mentions Grace or other siblings, it documents family circumstances that Grace shared—class background; inherited notions about race, class, and religion; and events in the family’s history that sometimes problematized these inherited notions. In light of what Southerner reveals, Grace’s literary alignment with the workingclass and with Communism may be seen as a radical break from the subjectivity that her early familial and social experiences had shaped. The criticism of the Southern status quo that pervades To Make My Bread suggests that Grace’s process of questioning and detaching from many of the values she grew up with may have been similar to that described by Katherine.7 Katherine—after attempting to unravel her conflicting views on race, class, and gender—concludes that even as her family was shaping her seemingly secure identity, larger social upheavals that had begun decades before her birth were creating the conditions that would compel her to remake it:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 55
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
56
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
“What had altered me was the South’s own doing. The beginning of the beginning for my change lay far back in history. We had been uprooted. Was there ever so much movement in so brief a span of years?” (236). Katherine’s self-diagnosis works equally well to describe Grace’s approach to the McClures’ transformation in To Make My Bread. As the autobiographical Southerner documents the processes that reshaped Katherine’s gendered, classed, and racialized worldview, the fictional Bread shows how a family of poor white Southerners develops—and then acts on—a radical understanding of their working-class subject positions. Despite the substantial class difference between the vantage points of these two works, both show how related social upheavals within the same crucible of the early-twentieth-century South threaten previously self-evident values. In Katherine’s memoir and Grace’s fiction alike, relative stability within family or society limits the possibilities for individual and collective enlightenment, while familial and socioeconomic turmoil forces such enlightenment into birth. What, then, were some of the critical conditions that contributed to the “uprooting” of Katherine’s Southern identity? During and after the Civil War, Lumpkin’s parents, William and Annette, both experienced the collapse of comfortable lives on plantations worked by slaves. Although Lumpkin’s mother spent her early years on such a plantation, the stability of her childhood ended before she reached age ten. Relatives raised her after her father died in the war and her mother succumbed to typhoid fever (52–4). After growing up on a similar family plantation, Lumpkin’s father joined the Confederate army at age fifteen.8 While William was away, his father, worried about the safety of his family on such an isolated plantation during wartime, closed down the estate and moved everyone to nearby Union Point, Georgia (50). Though William’s father initially planned to return to the plantation after the war, the large amount of money needed to restart farming operations—particularly after losing his slaves—ultimately dissuaded him (74–6). His son (Lumpkin’s father) spent the rest of his life convinced that the Civil War defeat had destroyed the South that he had loved as a child. After giving up an earlier ambition to practice law, William obtained a fairly unglamorous “post with a Georgia railroad” (99).9 Due to this job, the Lumpkins moved frequently to new towns during Katherine’s childhood, first within their native Georgia and later within South Carolina (where, Katherine remembered, they temporarily lost the automatic social distinction accorded to the Lumpkin name in Georgia). Though reduced to a succession of small urban homes that all paled in comparison to their childhood plantations, William and Annette “made every effort to keep up appearances” (106). This determination to uphold antebellum family standards included
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 56
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” 57 an insistence that the Lumpkin children choose friends from families of similar social pedigree (103–4). Even though Katherine was born more than thirty years after the Civil War ended, her father instilled in her (and all his other children) an indignation about the erosion of old-South aristocratic culture and a determination to shore up its battered remnants. Ironically, the magnitude of his obsession helped Katherine to perceive its incompatibility with reality. As Hall eloquently observes, “it took tremendous effort for men like William Lumpkin to reconcile an early twentieth-century present of intense racial and class alienation with a ‘dream replica’ of a paternalistic past. Katherine sensed that effort, those rifts and contradictions—and through them she would eventually slip into critical consciousness” (“Open” 111). Later in Katherine’s childhood, this already cracking facade of elitism further crumbled. The family bought and moved to a two-hundred acre farm in the “Sand Hills,” a region of South Carolina with generally poor, sandy soil. Nearly all their new neighbors “had few acres and very poor little dwellings” and many were malnourished (151).10 The family’s own sense of well-being took a decided turn for the worse when, soon after the move to Sand Hills, William “died of throat cancer” (Hall “Open” 116). Still, they were conspicuously affluent compared to their neighbors: “Ours was the ‘big farm’ of the countryside,” Katherine observed, “our house by far the largest although it was plain and simple” (151). Whereas most of their neighbors did manual labor on small farms that they either owned or rented as sharecroppers, “our fieldwork,” Katherine reports, “of course, was done by Negroes” (153). Surrounded by poor whites for the first time in her life, Katherine recognized and reflected on the roots of her own family’s privilege: “[U]ntil we moved to our farm, I knew little and thought not at all about the ‘poorer classes’” (160). Attending the local school, she (and surely Grace, too) saw their privilege offset against other children’s worn clothes, bland lunches, and lack of education. Her dismay at seeing such poverty mixed with a desire to identify with these other children: “I was a ‘cultured’ child; I used more or less correct English. I could not have made over my speech into the image of theirs if I had tried. I think I would gladly have done it, so hard would they stare at me when I talked, as though I were some kind of foreigner, as indeed they regarded me; and worse, as though I were ‘putting on airs’” (159). Living in the impoverished Sand Hills also pushed Katherine out of her earlier uncritical immersion in religious worship. Although the Lumpkin family had long identified with the relatively sedate Episcopal worship style, the move to this farm necessitated attending a nearby rural Baptist church among their poorer white neighbors. (Whereas the nearest Episcopal church was twelve miles from their home, a little Baptist church was only two miles
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 57
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
58
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
away.) “People would not have understood,” Katherine observed, “if we had failed to [attend this Baptist church]” (162).11 Witnessing a rural Baptist worship style that struck her as variously quaint and oppressive, Katherine began to adopt a more detached sociological perspective toward religion: Our theological tenets [in the Episcopal church] had sifted as softly into my consciousness as snow floats down on a still winter night [. . . . ] The Sand Hills put an end to this. Beliefs suddenly loomed before my mind. I saw and heard what purported to be the same religion I believed in, but it seemed very changed. [. . . . ] They seemed to awaken antagonistic responses in my mind, hearing them as I did against the sound of flat, hopeless voices singing: “Wash me whiter than the snow.” (185)12
New experiences in college and graduate school also destabilized Katherine’s deeply entrenched views about white supremacy and the rationale behind racial segregation. While attending Brenau College in Gainesville, Georgia, her involvement with the YWCA pushed her into previously taboo social contact with black members of the organization. Further, she was “guided toward a leftist literature in sociology and economics by the YWCA’s industrial secretaries,” and began to “think of the South not as an icon but as a social system and to apply to it a critique of racism and capitalism that would grow more radical as time wore on” (Hall “Open” 117). Later, after moving to New York City, she was surprised and troubled by racist white Northerners who “aped our Southern ways, took over our [racist] terminology bodily” (Lumpkin Southerner 202). These encounters gave her a disturbing reflection of her own previously more naturalized racism: “hearing [racial epithets] from their lips had an unpleasant sound, as of something respectable suddenly made indecent” (Southerner 203). Her graduate work in sociology at New York’s Columbia University gave her a more positive and liberating insight into white America—“that it was non-slaveholders who were numerous in the South; that non-slaveholding was the standpoint from which the vast majority of Southern whites had necessarily looked on the world” (Southerner 226). Southern whites who, like the Lumpkins, felt “disinherited” in the postbellum South, were relatively few. This realization suggested to her that the majority of Southern whites—given the right encouragement and critical tools—might be able to relinquish racist feelings about blacks more easily than she, so deeply enmeshed in her family’s narrative of social and economic loss, had been able to. Much like Katherine, Grace sought (or was forced to seek) a life for herself after childhood that diverged from the more traditional expectations that
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 58
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” 59 might have pushed a woman of her class and cultural background towards early marriage and a life of relative leisure: “After high school graduation, [she] taught school and organized a night school for farmers and their wives. [. . . . ] Later she had a government job as home demonstration agent for the county, and learned more about the economic problems of the people on the land” (Gilkes 313). Of particular importance to the story she would tell in To Make My Bread, she “lived out in the mountains of North Carolina most summers, and stayed with people who worked in the cotton mills.”13 Later, she worked for two years as an “industrial secretary of the South Carolina Y.W.C.A.” (Gilkes 313). Then, pursuing her ambition to become a writer, she moved to New York City, working to support herself while taking classes at Columbia University and trying to write.14 Lumpkin’s jobs played an important role in steering her gradually towards radicalism. In 1925, she joined “the office staff at The World Tomorrow, a monthly Quaker publication aimed at promoting peace, conscientious objection to war, and ‘social order based on the principles of Jesus’” (Sowinska x-xi). Lumpkin’s own political views moved left of The World Tomorrow after this publication sent her (along with Esther Shemitz, a coworker and close friend) to “cover the long, momentous, and recurrently violent textile strike in Passaic, New Jersey, the first mass walkout in the United States to be led by the Communist party”: “Having experienced firsthand the revolutionary fervor of the Passaic workers and their leaders, [Lumpkin and Shemitz] returned to New York with a new dedication to the principles and goals of the Communist party, its commitment to the worker, its promise for the artist, and its vision of the future” (Sowinska xii). As Suzanne Sowinska explains, this early exposure to Communist ideology was important to the writing of To Make My Bread: [I]n 1928 she joined the staff of The New Masses; in 1929 she was sent south by the CP to organize among black sharecroppers and to observe and participate in the Communist-led Gastonia textile strikes. This trip provided Lumpkin with much of the material for her first novel. In writing about Gastonia, she saw a way to connect her nascent awareness of a radical political agenda and her prerogative to create art that would serve the proletariat with the landscape of her youth.” (xii-iii)15
She worked sporadically on the book while holding down other jobs to support herself. An advance from the Macauley publishing firm based on an incomplete draft helped her to finish it (Sowinska xiii). The book, which came out in late 1932, received widespread critical praise, “[winning] the Maxim Gorky award as the year’s best labor novel” (Smith 287).
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 59
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
60
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
“[A] book called ‘Lee’s Miserables’” In a sense, To Make My Bread takes Katherine’s insight—that “non-slaveholding was the standpoint from which the vast majority of Southern whites had necessarily looked on the world”—and focuses its implications on a particular facet of Southern working-class experience. In the modern South, this non-slaveholding/slaveholding distinction likely continued to divide the South between the working-class and those who profited from their labor. For Grace Lumpkin, the fact of the numerical difference between the few who had owned slaves and the many who had not might have provided an incentive to imagine the world as viewed through the eyes of this workingclass majority. As Katherine came to believe that critical awareness could counter racism, so Grace came to feel that Marxist rationalism could in time remove the stumbling blocks to unionism and communism—particularly since racism so often obscured class exploitation of whites and blacks. In light of Lumpkin’s desire to promote the movement from ideological transformation to direct action, her decision to write from the perspective of a proletarian family—one without roots in an old slaveholding aristocracy— seems logical. Since the McClures, unlike the Lumpkins, probably found life equally hard before and after the war, their potential for ideological development would not likely be stifled by mourning for a lost, idealized past. While Southerner portrays transformations that occur more in the realm of thought than action, To Make My Bread dramatizes a process in which ideological changes inspire a racially integrated union to carry out a labor strike.16 Like Katherine’s memoir, Grace’s novel traces how tensions in individual experience may cause previously naturalized thought patterns to become visible as socially constructed ideology. In her memoir, the exceptionally articulate Katherine ably depicts one way of thinking emerging from another. In contrast, Lumpkin’s main characters lack Katherine’s verbal resources (and, of course, her sociological training). They are not predisposed to self-consciously recognize the social construction of their beliefs about the world. Thus, their interactions with cultural artifacts offer another way of showing the phenomena of ideological orientation, disorientation, and reorientation. Since certain cultural artifacts reflect widely accepted beliefs, characters’ responses to these artifacts offer a gauge of their alignment with these beliefs. How do characters respond to a particular cultural artifact within a given social context? How does this artifact reflect their own lived experience? How might it cause a reorientation towards experience? Lumpkin’s novel invokes such questions frequently as a way of bringing the ideologies of relatively inarticulate characters into focus.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 60
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
61
Interestingly, the allusion that provides the chronologically earliest insight into cultural products that informed the McClure family’s worldview is not to an old hymn or ballad but, rather, to the French Victor Hugo’s epic social novel Les Misérables (1862). This book—one that Lumpkin’s well-educated parents might have grown up reading—appears through the distorted lens of the McClures’ seemingly complete removal from any print culture.17 During the time that Granpap is in jail, convicted of smuggling whiskey, Emma tells her two youngest children, Bonnie and John, about Granpap’s time in the Confederate Army decades before. In the final year before the South’s surrender, when Granpap and other Confederates had suffered tremendously, Granpap’s unit had included a soldier, only sixteen years old, from a wealthy family and with “a slave to take care of him like a nurse” (86). Emma goes on to recall that “the soldiers used to sit around a campfire at night and the rich man’s son had a book called ‘Lee’s Miserables.’ He’d read to them. The General that owned the army was named Lee. And after hearing the book the soldiers called themselves Lee’s Miserables” (86).18 As Hall has observed, Grace Lumpkin’s proletarian novels “reworked Lumpkin family history to attack every shibboleth that her parents defended” (“Open Secrets” 111). The novel’s reference to the “rich man’s son, one of them that owned slaves before they was freed” (TMMB 86) illustrates such deconstructive tendencies at work. As Lumpkin’s sister Katherine recalled in The Making of a Southerner, their father joined the Confederate Army in 1864, at age fifteen. Like the fictional soldier Granpap remembered from his unit, William Lumpkin was accompanied by “black Pete, his body servant, who had gone away with him and stayed by his side during his soldiering” (Making 51). That William “was a keen wit, a fine teller of tales and singer of songs around the camp fire” (Making 51) also suggests his relationship to the fictional soldier in To Make My Bread. Here, then, Lumpkin uses the eyes of John Kirkland (the future “Granpap”), a poor and illiterate man, to provide an ironic glimpse of a man who could have been her own father, a privileged young soldier who read Les Misérables to the less affluent and educated in his ranks. In constructing the fictional McClures, Lumpkin clearly had in mind a family of considerably more humble class and educational background than her own family had been (and still was). Compared to the Lumpkins, who had lost a significant degree of leisure and economic security based on slaveholding, the McClures are never shown to have benefited economically from slavery (or underpaid black labor). Granpap—in contrast to Lumpkin’s father as portrayed by Katherine—seems to have spent little time in the postbellum years dwelling on the Confederates’ “Lost Cause.” He has taught his daughter that “there
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 61
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
62
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
wasn’t any civil kind of war. Not that he knew about” (86). Because the McClures do not see themselves as having suffered from race-based economic oppression, they are relatively malleable receptacles for a Marxist explanation of white supremacy as a detriment to working-class progress. On one level, this brief allusion to Les Misérables draws attention to the way illiteracy has shaped the McClures’ worldview. Emma does not seem to realize that the book she calls “Lee’s Miserables” was not really about the miseries that soldiers, fighting for a reactionary cause, endured under Robert E. Lee. Quite understandably, however, Granpap’s Civil War experience has made the suffering of “Lee’s Miserables” far more tangible than that of Hugo’s literary characters. That Granpap’s consciousness blurs these two terms, Les Misérables and Lee’s Miserables, works as a symbol for the exploitative forces that ensnared poor whites in the Civil War. Granpap seems to have been compelled to fight to preserve a slaveholding economy that had little relationship to the lives of poor mountain farmers like himself. For the reader, this allusion also operates on a level that is potentially much deeper. Since To Make My Bread and Les Misérables share as their central concern the exposition and eradication of the sociopolitical roots of poverty and oppression, Lumpkin’s allusion may also be seen as a subtle, yet complex act of literary signification. Like To Make My Bread, Les Misérables traces a struggle to escape poverty that is both individual and collective. Both novels interrogate and suggest solutions for poverty in their respective societies. They differ fundamentally, however, in their views of capitalism and its attendant class system. Les Misérables constructs an idealistic situation in which workers flourish in a capitalist factory run by an atypically benevolent, paternalistic man who has risen out of an obscure background. To Make My Bread rejects such views of potential reality as antithetical to Marxism’s view of capitalism as a necessarily divisive, antagonistic socioeconomic system.19 In brief, the early part of Hugo’s multi-volume novel—the section most relevant to Lumpkin’s novel—follows a heroically proportioned protagonist, Jean Valjean, who rises from extremely humble circumstances to remarkable success (though it is short-lived and fraught with anxiety). Released from prison after spending almost twenty years at hard labor for stealing bread, Valjean steals from the home of a bishop. When police arrest Valjean with goods stolen from the bishop’s house, the bishop refuses to accuse Valjean of theft. Instead, he saves Valjean from a return to prison, claiming to have given him the stolen items, then giving him even more. Because of the bishop’s extraordinary mercy, Valjean (using the surname Madeleine to hide his past) refashions his life in the years that follow. He becomes a beloved town mayor and successful factory owner who strives to treat his factory workers
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 62
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
63
humanely. Rather than hoarding his profits, he gives generously to increase the prosperity of all the inhabitants of his town and region. Lumpkin’s novel may be seen as subtly suggesting the shortcomings of Hugo’s text—both as sociopolitical philosophy and as art capable of inspiring altruism in its audience. As Emma continues her anecdote, elaborating on the extent of Granpap’s misery during the war, Lumpkin invites readers to weigh Granpap’s actions ironically against the humane values that, presumably, hearing Les Misérables would have exposed him to: Granpap said he used to get s’ hungry [in the army]. . . . Once he was a-scouting and he came across a little nigger. The little nigger was eating a piece of cornbread. Granpap said snot was running from the little nigger’s nose on the bread. But Granpap hadn’t eaten a thing for two days. He took the bread away from the little nigger and ate it. And it was the best meal, he said, he ever had. (86, ellipses in original)
This story’s incongruous progression from famished soldiers sitting around listening to “Lee’s Miserables” [Les Misérables] to Granpap stealing a poor black boy’s bread suggests the pragmatic impotence of this literature to engender benevolent behavior—particularly within a social context that is already degraded by brutality, desperate poverty, and racism. Hearing Les Misérables, a novel that dramatizes the social virtue of individual kindness and charity, seemingly did nothing to undermine Granpap’s belief in his intrinsic right to take food from a black boy. He came to think of himself as one of “Lee’s Miserables,” but he could not recognize blacks as part of the miserable.20 The fact that Hugo’s protagonist, Valjean, also stole bread, but under moral circumstances notably different from Granpap’s, allows Lumpkin’s scenario to resonate further within the context of Les Misérables. While Lumpkin highlights Granpap’s inability to recognize the suffering of someone arguably more miserable and powerless than himself, Hugo constructs a legitimate moral justification for Valjean’s act. Not personal hunger alone, but concern for the welfare of his widowed sister and her seven children drives Valjean to take a loaf of bread from a bakery: Valjean “did what he could; his sister worked too, but what could she do with seven children? It was a sad group which wretchedness gradually enveloped and choked. One winter was hard, and Jean had no work to do, and the family had no bread. No bread, literally none, and seven children” (1: 82). While Granpap takes the bread without feeling remorse or being punished, Valjean is caught and sentenced to hard labor for five years (which turns into nineteen years as punishment for several
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 63
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
64
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
attempted escapes) for this one act, “done [ . . . ] to feed and clothe seven little children” (1: 85). That Lumpkin uses Emma’s retelling to frame this anecdote adds to its significance. Emma tells the story, presumably as Granpap has told it to her, to dramatize a hunger so intense that a white man would actually relish a piece of snot-covered bread snatched from a “little nigger.” Neither Emma nor Granpap seems to sympathize retrospectively with the boy whose bread was taken some four decades earlier. The fact of this boy’s blackness legitimates the theft within the racist value system handed down from Granpap to his daughter Emma and, now, from Emma to her children John and Bonnie. Lumpkin draws attention to the importance of this oral story as a vehicle for transmitting ideology, showing that it penetrates Bonnie’s consciousness and fascinates (and perhaps even troubles) John’s developing conscience: “Bonnie raised up. She was almost asleep. Perhaps she had been asleep. She had heard the story before. But so had John heard it. Yet he was never tired of hearing it again, or of asking his own questions” (86). Though many years have passed since the event took place, and though Granpap’s grown daughter tells the story, nothing in the family’s isolated mountain experience has made them rethink the implicit values in this story.21 When the McClures move to the textile town that Lumpkin aptly names Leesville, this ideological stasis suddenly changes. In Leesville, the McClures experience a type of oppression worthy of the appellations “Les Misérables” and “Lee’s Miserables” alike. While the former name might convey the general condition of wretchedness and exploitation the McClures will experience, the latter one might tie the oppressive legacy of the lost Confederate cause to the ongoing racism that deters working-class solidarity. As the image of a comrade from a wealthy background reading Les Misérables to fellow soldiers like the illiterate Granpap suggests, the shared misery of war may have blurred class distinctions among white Confederate soldiers, imparting a class-transcendent quality to the colloquial label “Lee’s Miserables.” But as Granpap’s experience at the early-twentieth-century Confederate reunion shows, this perception of solidarity among white soldiers (or among white Southerners more generally) was largely temporary or illusory. During this later time, wealthy politicians and businessmen are shown manipulating veterans’ pride of having fought for the South to further their own financial interests and to agitate the ideology of white supremacy.22 As the young Granpap was susceptible to the class-transcendent rhetoric of Les Misérables, the aged Granpap is still susceptible to such rhetoric at the rally. Notably, Lumpkin shows John, then a boy of ten, at this rally, not yet understanding the manipulative speeches, but storing them in his mind for the time when he might have the knowledge to analyze them critically (185–6). Eventually,
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 64
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
65
new experiences will compel John and Bonnie to revise the implications of various stories that have shaped the family’s worldview. They will become skeptical about the intentions of paternalistic bosses and politicians. They will learn via Marx what Granpap seemingly failed to learn via Hugo—that racism can divide the working class and thus hinder the recognition of classbased oppression. After accepting basic Marxist tenets, this new generation of McClures could not pass on the story of Granpap stealing bread as Emma does, seemingly oblivious to its problematic ideological assumptions.23 Though To Make My Bread does not allude to Les Misérables again, later events continue to evoke and interrogate Hugo’s novel. In particular, John, in his initial belief that he can use his rise within the ranks of the factory system to help less successful fellow workers, might well have taken Valjean’s ascent from poor ex-convict to successful, generous factory owner as a model.24 Lumpkin’s charting of John’s journey towards communism valorizes his deliberate rejection of such atypical escape routes from class circumstances. Lumpkin’s novel also implicitly rejects Hugo’s belief that individual acts of altruism and integrity might significantly reshape a social landscape defined by capitalist corruption and working-class misery. In To Make My Bread, profit-hungry factory owners and disingenuous preachers contradict Hugo’s selfless Bishop Digne and benevolent Valjean. John’s successful and selfish older brother Basil cynically counters Hugo’s Valjean, who retains generosity despite wealth. Granted, Hugo depicts such rare goodness and good fortune against a social background dominated by cruelty and moral backwardness. Like John, Valjean has working-class roots that inspire him to spread his new wealth among the less fortunate. Still, for Lumpkin, Hugo’s portrayal of Valjean’s uncanny success and generosity breaches a social-realist commitment to privileging class antagonism as a defining truth.25 The worldview that the seasoned worker-radical John Stevens imparts to young John McClure succinctly conveys an ideological stance that undermines Hugo’s. McClure recalls hearing “a preacher to the rich say that some day the rich would get the love of God in their hearts and share everything half and half with the poor.” This, Stevens tells him, would be like “expect[ing] a snake to come up and open its mouth gentle and humble for you t’ take out the fangs” (312). McClure comes to share Stevens’ belief that only a revolution to strip the powerful of their wealth will bring social harmony. Through the example of Valjean, Hugo had suggested otherwise. Despite the fact that Hugo shows Valjean heroically turning his factory over to his workers before he flees to avoid rearrest, Les Misérables does not advocate eliminating private ownership and social classes, particularly through revolution. One of Hugo’s narrative asides argues that communism “kills production, and equal division destroys emulation, and consequently labor.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 65
6/22/2006 8:54:28 AM
66
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
It is a distribution made by the butcher who slaughters what he divides. Hence it is impossible to be satisfied with these pretended solutions, for killing riches is not distributing them” (4: 20–1, emphasis added). Rather, Hugo’s ideal government must “encourage the wealthy, and protect the poor, suppress misery, put an end to the unjust exhaustion of the weak by the strong.” It should “democratize property, not by abolishing, but by universalizing it, so that every citizen, without exception, may be a land-owner” (4: 21). For Hugo, an end to social misery requires embracing Christian love and high moral principles. The forgiveness, benevolence, and integrity that the bishop bestows on Valjean, and that Valjean himself later bestows on others, function as a model for the privileged and powerful to emulate. Conversely, Inspector Javert’s mean-spirited refusal to let Valjean reconstruct his identity provides a model to shun. Such aspects of the text suggest that Hugo’s ideal “revolution” would start in the minds and spirits of the wealthy, not among the masses of rank-and-file factory workers who depend on them for a living.26 This most fundamental ideological difference between Hugo and Lumpkin likely explains the nature of Lumpkin’s allusion to this novel—the way it undermines the idea that the popularity of Les Misérables among those who would inherit and rebuild the postbellum New South actually engendered any significant lessening of class exploitation. Lumpkin’s structural placement of Les Misérables relatively early in the novel further points to its intended ironic and problematic status within the novel. (Considering that the allusion occurs in the context of a story relating an incident from the much earlier Civil War, its chronological relation to Lumpkin’s characters actually predates the novel’s principal axis of time.) This structuring gives Lumpkin (and her characters) more time to develop contrasting aesthetic and political premises in the remainder of her novel. In contrast to the way that Granpap’s selfish actions clash with the purported message of Les Misérables, John and Bonnie’s participation in a collective struggle for a union harmonizes with the folk-styled protest songs that both inspire and reflect their actions. This later relatively congruous alignment of song culture and working-class experience may be seen as answering the implied failure of Les Misérables to intervene positively in the development of Lumpkin’s characters’ social consciousness. “Power In the Blood” and “Power in the Factory”: Lumpkin’s radicalization of hymnology While the minister spoke faces strained upwards toward him, as if they were sniffing in the words he said with their nostrils. There were gaunt
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 66
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
67
men and tired looking women, old before their time. There were boys and girls, wan and stunted of the second and third generation of those who had worked in the mills. [. . . .] “What [the minister] said had sense,” Granpap told Frank. “If the rich could get the grace of Jesus Christ in their hearts, hit stands to reason we’d all have enough.” “I didn’t like so much his speaking about us as being pore so much,” Frank said. “If he’d spoke it just once . . .” “No,” Granpap answered before Frank could finish, “hit didn’t seem to fit in exactly. But what he says is mighty true. Only all the rich would have t’ do it together—for there are so many pore.” (TMMB 270)
Lumpkin recognizes important harmonies and dissonances between Christian theology and Marxist ideology. The Christian Bible contains numerous time-honored images and narratives that suggest proper distributions of power—among humans and between humanity and divinity. Guided by Marxism, Lumpkin’s own novel focuses on current relationships between working-class and capitalist powers. Because Lumpkin sees palpable links between aspects of religious culture and oppression, her allusions to religious texts, placed among other allusions to songs and literature, assume an important place in the novel’s schemata of cultural allusions. The novel embeds various religious images and narratives into contexts that highlight and critique their functions as frameworks for conceptualizing reality. In various cases in which characters must interpret their circumstances, these religious frameworks may clash with other cultural frameworks (or with characters’ notions of common sense). Lumpkin’s representations emphasize religion not in its ideal form, but as it has been corrupted by preachers and mill owners wanting to enhance their own positions of authority by exploiting the desire of people under them to do what they see as God’s will. As one key part of establishing patterns of positive transformation, early, relatively naïve, interactions with religious texts precede events or insights that recall these earlier interactions but also connote a new consciousness of and autonomy from prescriptive religious modes of thought. Early in the novel, Lumpkin invokes the Bible’s story of God calling on Abraham to sacrifice his only son. As the novel progresses, a motif of sacrifice develops as characters become entangled within power structures that compel them to sacrifice aspects of self to a new industrial god. Lumpkin introduces this Abraham narrative in the context of a preacher’s displeasure over people in the mountain community dancing to Granpap’s fiddle and Sam Wesley’s banjo. Preacher Warren, the minister for the community, condemns these
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 67
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
68
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
dances as sinful (and also suspects that the donations given to the musicians cut into church offerings). Though the preacher has rebuked him, Granpap rationalizes that “‘David danced before the Lord,’ [ . . . ]. ‘And I ain’t ashamed to play before the Lord. He can look and see there’s no sin in my heart’” (44). While Granpap cites the Biblical David to justify his music, Preacher Warren uses the story of Abraham to explain why Granpap should sacrifice his beloved fiddle music: “And Abraham said, ‘Here am I, Lord,’ when the Lord called him. And the Lord said Abraham must take his only son, even the son he loved, and sacrifice him to the Lord. So Abraham rose up early in the morning and cut wood and took some fire and went to the place he could see afar off, the place the Lord had told him. And up on the mountain he bound his son on the wood of an altar and took up a knife to slay him. But just in time the Lord showed Abraham a ram in a thicket so that Abraham could offer up the ram instead of his son. So the Lord blessed Abraham because he was willing to sacrifice his son that he loved.” (46)
After reciting this familiar Biblical text, Preacher Warren rhetorically asks his congregation, and then Granpap in particular, whether their dedication to God matches Abraham’s: “How many of you,” he asked, “can say with a clean heart, ‘Here am I, Lord’? How many, while you’re working in your corn patch or sitting by your fire, or while you’re dancing your Chains and Under the Garden Gates [square dance figures] can say, ‘Here am I Lord,’ and feel that for the Lord you would sacrifice anything or anybody, your son or your dancing or your playing? “There’s one amongst you,” he went on—and waited a moment, looking around at them all. “There’s one amongst you that calls figures and plays the music. He leads the young ones into sin. He’s old, nearing his grave, and ought to know better. Instead of playing for dancing, he’d do better making his peace with the Lord.” Suddenly preacher Warren pointed straight at Granpap. “What will you say, John Kirkland?” He called out in a high voice. (46)
Deeply offended, Granpap repeats his earlier rationale: “‘I’ll say David danced before the Lord and he played on the cymbal and the lute—and if King David could then John Kirkland can. And that’s between him and his Lord’” (47). He then walks out of the church, initiating “a queer thing
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 68
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
69
[ . . . ] that people talked about long afterward” (47). With the exception of three people, the entire congregation follows him out the door. Voting with their feet, they reject Preacher Warren’s use of the Abraham story as a reason to sacrifice their dancing and instead choose Granpap’s exonerating appeal to King David’s dancing and playing. Here, a Biblical text with liberating implications negates the effect of another with more restrictive implications. As an anecdote contributing to the novel’s examination of exploitation, this story presages various characters’ later struggles to break free of oppressive authority figures. When the McClures become mill workers, mill supervisors as well as preachers presume degrees of authority over what goes on in the family’s home. On the Sunday following Granpap’s dramatic walkout, his young grandchildren Bonnie and John independently test the validity of Preacher Warren’s insinuating sermon: “[R]emembering the story from the Bible, [Bonnie and John] played Abraham and the Lord” (48).27 Their play takes a more serious turn when Bonnie, worried by the preacher’s sermon that Granpap has angered God with his music, decides that they “‘ought really to sacrifice something, not play’” (48). She then convinces John that they should make an offering of their dog, Georgy. Striving to replicate every detail of the story as they remember it, they take him to a mountaintop and prepare to kill him. As they understand the story, God will intervene and stop them from carrying out the ritual. But when no divine sign seems forthcoming, their faith wavers and they call off the sacrifice on their own: “We ain’t a-going to do it. We ain’t a-going to do it,” [John] cried shrilly. He took the knife from the ground and began cutting the cords from Georgy’s feet. [. . . . ] “No, we ain’t,” Bonnie said. “No, we ain’t.” She spoke angrily and it seemed that she was talking not to John but to the Lord. (51)
Although Bonnie and John had intended to blindly emulate the sacrifice narrative, which they have learned as an exemplar of faith, they end up autonomously transforming this narrative along lines that reaffirm the value they place on tangible life. These early examples of breaking free from a strict obedience to the Bible anticipate later scenarios in which characters are caught between following prescriptive orders and taking pragmatic, autonomous action. Much later in the novel, for instance, Bonnie, afraid of incurring her boss’s displeasure, goes to work despite the illness of her youngest daughter, who ends up dying from this neglect. In a later, more positive example of such conflict
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 69
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
70
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
between individuals and authority, numerous workers defy their bosses and walk out of the factory in solidarity with a handful of others who have been fired for involvement with a union. As a leader of the resulting strike, John in particular will have to firmly reject appeals, from preachers and mill managers who present themselves as paternalistic authority figures, to call the strike off. Throughout the novel, additional religious allusions become the basis for other transformations that strip them of their former absolute, axiomatic power in various characters’ lives. One such imaginative transformation is rooted in two thematically related hymns, “There is a Fountain Filled with Blood” and “There is Power in the Blood.”28 These hymns promote reliance upon God’s salvation that the novel’s context seeks to problematize and transform. At a community baptism held at a mountain creek, the aforementioned Preacher Warren starts the ceremony by leading the congregation in the hymn “There is a Fountain Filled with Blood”: “There is a fountain filled with blood, / Drawn from Immanuel’s veins, / And sinners plunged beneath its flood, / Lose all their guilty stains” (61).29 The preacher then builds upon this hymn’s message, telling the youths about to be baptized that they must live pure lives on earth so that “the Lord would bless them and welcome them into his everlasting home” (62). Through a brief glimpse of the preacher’s thoughts preceding the start of this ceremony, Lumpkin draws further attention to the hymn and the preacher’s exhortations as part of a rhetorically instilled worldview with oppressive qualities not yet recognized by participants. This scene, like the earlier one in which Preacher Warren condemned Granpap’s dance music, characterizes preachers, as supposed intermediaries of God, as having a unique (and easily abused) authority to judge the morality of others’ behavior. As noted above, Preacher Warren had unspoken practical reasons for resenting the threat Granpap’s music posed to church attendance and funds. Here, too, Lumpkin shows that the preacher’s words and true thoughts do not necessarily coincide. Readers learn that “to Preacher Warren all the people in the company were pinch-faced and uninteresting” (59). He resents their poverty and has little faith that any of them will live redeeming lives: “If he had met John [McClure] in the road he would have seen just another pinch-faced child with a careless walk, who would grow up to be a careless, slovenly man, living on the lusts of the flesh” (60). By showing that the preacher’s inward condescension conflicts with his outward show of sincerity, the text undercuts the intended sanctity of his service. The characters, presumably, trust the spiritual value of the material that the preacher has selected for their enlightenment. Readers, however, recognize that these characters, lacking access to the preacher’s uninhibited thoughts about them, may be misplacing their trust.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 70
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
71
While this scene uses “There is a Fountain Filled with Blood” to establish how interaction with religious texts contributes to the characters’ “preindustrial” ideologies, a later scene parodies a similar hymn to illustrate how an encounter with the industrial factory system may destabilize certain aspects of ideology. Having just left a native environment in which mountains dwarf scattered cabins, Emma gets her first look at the factory where she will soon begin work. To her, this gigantic manmade structure intrudes audaciously into a space formerly reserved in her mind for nature and God: “Up from the brick structure rose two huge chimneys, towering into the sky, like two towers of Babel. Smoke poured out of them into the wide open heavens” (147 emphasis added). Temporarily at least, the factory awes her as probably only God did before: “[Emma] spoke in a whisper as if she was afraid the factory would hear. ‘You remember that church song,’ she went on speaking low to Ora [her sister] ‘that says, ‘There’s power in the blood.’ Well, that sound [the rumble of machinery] seems t’ say, ‘There’s power in the factory, there’s power in the factory’” (149).30 Emma’s figurative language here (and elsewhere) illustrates the potentially liberating power of words creatively freed from rote usage. For Emma (and the reader), replacing the idea of “power in the blood”—which the hymn characterizes incrementally over several verses—with that of “power in the factory” destabilizes perception. If the “power in the blood” promises to cleanse and save sinners, what then does the “power in the factory” promise? To “cleanse” the poor of their poverty? If so, are those who fail to avail themselves of and profit from the factory’s grace somehow sinful? For the reader, the aesthetically dense, indeterminate relationships between the novel (a still unfolding text), the hymn (an already closed text), and the fleeting parody of this hymn (an incomplete, mostly hypothetical text) prompt such reflections. Emma had simply inherited the figurative concept of “power in the blood” as part of a socially ordained worldview, and perhaps never interrogated it before.31 In contrast, she actually created this new countermetaphor herself. While Emma is familiar with what the hymn promises, she is less sure about the nature of the “power in the factory.” Already, though, her foreboding views of the Babel-like chimneys cast doubt on earlier Biblically informed visions of the mill village as a “land flowing with milk and honey” (136).32 In Emma’s newly activated imagination, the smoke-belching factory seems to challenge the hymn’s assurance that immersion in Christ is sufficient to cleanse all “sin.” As she does at other points in the text, Lumpkin shows here that Bonnie, who will later write labor songs, absorbs certain potentially liberating insights from her mother. The questioning of authority implicit in Emma’s
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 71
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
72
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
creative secularizing of a hymn is not lost on this young daughter. Although Emma, after proposing her altered chorus, “was a little ashamed as she always was of some of her notions before Ora,” “she saw Bonnie look up from under her bonnet as if she understood” (149). Within the context of the novel’s transforming trajectories, Emma’s brief parodic transformation of “There is Power in the Blood” destabilizes an image of God guiding all aspects of life. The reader might surmise that Emma and Bonnie will no longer sing of the “power in the blood” without also hearing the dissonant idea of the “power in the factory.”33 Emma’s parody also has the capacity to activate the reader’s transformative imagination by evoking another well-known parody of “Power in the Blood”—the song “There is Power in the Union,” penned by Industrial Workers of the World luminary Joe Hill in 1913. Although not cited in Lumpkin’s text, this artifact of IWW laborlore was likely part of the cultural repertoire of Lumpkin and many of her contemporary readers. While Emma’s parody replaces the idea of Christ’s cleansing power with that of the factory’s oppressive power, Hill’s song further recognizes the Union’s liberating power: Would you have freedom from wage slavery, Then join in the grand Industrial band; Would you from mis’ry and hunger be free, Then come! Do your share, like a man. There is pow’r, there is pow’r In a band of workingmen. When they stand hand in hand, That’s a pow’r, that’s a pow’r That must rule in every land— One Industrial Union Grand. (qtd. in Kornbluh 140)
Seeing Hill’s parody as an extension of Emma’s is consonant with other structures within Lumpkin’s novel that encourage readers to discover codes of ideological progress within (and in this case external to) the novel’s carefully sequenced cultural allusions. Making this imaginative jump to the external reality of Hill’s radical song, readers may sense more clearly the potentially liberating trajectory of Emma’s observations. Indeed, the labor song that Bonnie eventually writes may be seen as extending and revitalizing the earlier culture of resistance to which “Power in the Union” belongs. As the novel progresses, Emma continues to revise the patterns of her thinking about her relationship to the mill along the critical lines that her
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 72
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
73
earlier parody initiated. Just before her first day of mill work, she comes up with yet another wholly new figurative conception of the mill: “The people entering the door of the mill seemed to Emma as if they were corn being fed into a hopper to be ground up. Emma saw herself going in and coming out different from what she had been” (195). Struggling to reconcile this view with her visions “in the mountains [ . . . ] of round silver dollars dropping into her lap, and of buying good food and fine things in the stores,” she vows that she would not let them make her give up the thoughts she had had of the promised land. She said to herself, that she, Emma McClure, could make money if she tried hard enough. If she worked hard and gave the best she had to the mill, in some fine way she would be recompensed. Perhaps all these people had failed to give their best. Perhaps they were lazy. (195)
After Emma becomes a veteran mill worker, however, her earlier rosy conception of the mill as a “promised land” ceases to brighten her vision of reality. Instead, the image of corn being ground further darkens into a more violent narrative of bones being crushed to sustain the mill—as opposed to those who work there: There was a story the teacher told the young ones at school, and Bonnie, playing teacher, told it over to the children at home. “And the ogre said, ‘I’ll grind your bones to make my bread.’” At first the throb of the mill had been like the throb of a big heart beating for the good of those who worked under the roof, for it gave hope of desires to be fulfilled. A woman, one of the weavers, said to Ora and Emma one lunch hour during the summer, “The weave room has a sound different from the other rooms. It’s like the sound of sinners’ teeth grinding in hell.” Now to Emma the throb of a heart had changed. She was feeling the grind of teeth. The mill crunched up and down—“I’ll grind your bones to make my bread.” (219)
Significantly, Emma revises not only her own earlier conception of the mill’s sound as a beating heart, but also this other weaver’s conception of it being like sinners’ grinding teeth. Her newest creative image drops the other weaver’s problematic linking of workers with sin (perhaps the “sin” of not being able to live up to the speed and perfection of the machines). Instead, it adapts a folktale to imagine the mill itself as a monstrous force that crushes workers’ bones “to make my bread.” (That Lumpkin adapts this phrase for the novel’s
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 73
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
74
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
title suggests that she endorses Emma’s bleak creative conception of capitalist labor—even as she writes towards a more hopeful future that will better enable workers to “make [their] bread.”) Emma does not have access to rational explanations of the mill as a mode of production. She cannot read, and she never meets anyone (as her son meets John Stevens) who can steer her towards a radical conception of labor. Still, through her own exploration of figurative language, she tentatively compares the mill to more familiar and easily grasped concepts. For Emma, an ability to use language creatively to conceptualize her situation serves mostly to strip away her earlier naïve and illusory concepts of mill life. Before her own potential trajectory of radicalization has a chance to run its course, she becomes mentally and physically incapacitated by pellagra. Her youngest children, John and Bonnie, however, are eventually able to use Emma’s disillusionment as the basis for more positively empowering radical thought. Inspired by Emma, they go through their own process of learning to diagnose oppression and, more importantly, fighting to cure it. John will learn an older proto-radical song from Stevens, and his sister will later write her own more radical song. Reflecting this cross-generational progress, this song by Bonnie appearing near the end of the novel will do more than just recognize the factory’s life-consuming power, as Emma’s figurative language has done. Rather, it will challenge this power with the liberating idea of a workers’ union as a potentially greater counter-force.34 As Emma loses her unqualified faith in the “power in the blood” to the new “power in the factory,” John eventually goes through an experience that destabilizes the role of hymns as direct discourse informing his worldview. As a young teenager, John is shaken by the experience of hearing a familiar hymn being sung in a shockingly unfamiliar context. His friend Robert—a boy distinguished by his cold amorality—takes him to where a chain gang is camping for the night. As John and Robert watch from a hidden spot, guards compel the gang (of mostly “full black” men) to sing hymns before being locked into cages for the night. They sing “two hymns that John had never heard before” and then begin “Nearer my God to Thee”: “This one John knew, and all the men seemed to know it well. Their deep mournful voices mixed with the heavy feeling of night just coming, and went up toward the heavens where stars were coming out” (249). The lyrics Lumpkin quotes convey another facet of the theology-oriented worldview that her novel seeks to deconstruct: Nearer my God to Thee Nearer to Thee
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 74
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
75
E’en though it be a cross That raiseth me. Still all my song shall be Nearer my God to Thee. (249)
With such words, the song attempts to reconcile the pain of earthly suffering with consolation—namely, that suffering brings the singer “Nearer my God to Thee.” In this particular context, these words subsume the complex race and class dynamics that underlie the chain gang’s disempowerment. To subdue their prisoners, the guards encourage this emotionally appealing but logically inapt view of imprisonment as a “cross” to be borne stoically. The scene’s development draws further attention to the song’s inadequacy to ameliorate such misery. As the chained men are being returned to their cages, something happens that causes the guards to pull one member out and give him thirty lashes. In John’s horrified perception, “the sound of the leather cutting his back went up into the heavens as the sound of the hymn had gone up. And another sound went up. As the leather came down the man lying across the wheelbarrow groaned” (250). Then, as the whipped man succumbs to his punishment and his own groans “grew fainter, [ . . . ] there came a groan from the cages, and another” (250). Soon, all of the men are groaning in sympathy with their fellow prisoner: “The groans accumulated into one sound. They swelled up until they were louder than the song had been. And they were one groan made of the groans of those who were lying on the shelves in the cages” (250 emphasis added). John recognizes a depth of misery that this hymn cannot possibly explain (and, perhaps, that no words could express). Indeed, the inarticulate mass groan seems to transcend the hymn as commentary on this misery. Still, despite its inadequacy to reconcile, the aesthetic power of this hymn—its simultaneously familiar and defamiliarized quality—moves John to recognize the humanity of the prisoners and feel their suffering: “[John] was lying face down on the ground with his mouth in the dirt. A sickness had come on him. Like Job of old he wanted to curse God and die” (250).35 In marked contrast to John, Robert takes sadistic pleasure in methodically counting the lashes: “‘Twenty-nine, thirty,’ Robert said. ‘Nearer my God to Thee,’ he shouted out and laughed” (251). Though one boy is acutely sensitive and the other utterly crass, both recognize that this enforced singing mocks rather than soothes suffering and oppression of this magnitude. For John, misery comes from recognition of qualities that both link him to and divide him from these men. Though John’s and the chain gang’s respective hymn traditions do not coincide, they intersect at the point of this one hymn. Likewise, John perhaps senses aspects of his own family’s condition
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 75
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
76
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
in this more blatant and magnified spectacle of physical and cultural oppression. Though John has not yet learned to see it, the intertwining chains of low-paid labor and religious ideologies hold down his own family. In this prisoner tableau, exploitation is more easily recognized, since the chains are literal and a gun, rather than just the force of habit, compels these prisoners to sing of a divine rationale for manmade suffering. Lumpkin does not explicitly show how this traumatic experience influences John’s developing class-consciousness. However, as I will discuss in detail further below, the novel’s next chapter shows John encountering a worker who teaches him a song with a radically different perspective towards suffering. Having just undergone an experience that would surely cause him to question the use of hymns as a balm for suffering, John meets John Stevens and learns Stevens’ original song describing the hard lives of textile workers (258–60). Unlike “Nearer My God to Thee,” this song doesn’t rationalize or accept suffering. Rather, it complains heartily and indicts bosses and upperclass townspeople. The chain-gang incident leaves a spiritual void in John that surely informs his receptivity to this new song. Like her brother John, Bonnie goes through life experiences that eventually cause her to recognize a disjunction between her personal beliefs and the ideological implications of various hymns. One way that Lumpkin sets the stage for the “Mill Mother’s Ballad” that Bonnie contributes to the union/strike effort is by showing Bonnie at two earlier stages of her life exuberantly singing hymns without any critical self-consciousness. These scenes suggest that Bonnie’s ability to create the “Mill Mother’s Ballad” grew out of first soaking up and then questioning the hymn culture around her. When her own song appears near the end of the novel, the contrasting values of the hymns she had once loved magnify the import of its fairly modest radicalism. Although these earlier scenes do not provide any explicit clues that Bonnie will later write protest songs, when viewed retrospectively, they subtly anticipate Bonnie’s future creativity. In the first example, Bonnie, only seven years old, sings the hymn “Come Ye Sinners” at her church. After citing three full verses, Lumpkin highlights Bonnie’s relationship to the hymn: “Come, ye sinners poor and needy, Weak and wounded, sick and sore, Jesus ready stands to save you Full of pity, love and power. [. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .] “Come ye weary, heavy laden, Bruised and mangled by the fall.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 76
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
77
If you tarry till you’re better You will never come at all.” Bonnie, who was good at remembering words, did not need the preacher to lay the lines out for her. She could have sung right on, having learned this one the summer before. She had a good voice. John, sitting on the other side of Emma, heard her letting it out. [. . . . ] She liked to listen to the sing-song of the words. John was simply not interested in them. (45)
When Bonnie has become an adult (but still before she learns about communism), her perspective towards hymns remains uncritical. Lumpkin shows Bonnie singing at a “revival service” led by a traveling evangelist, “the well-known Cyclone Carter” (279), and reveals that she “always liked the songs and lifted up her voice earnestly with the others” (279). Some time later, however, Bonnie’s struggle to raise several children while keeping up a job in the mill causes her to”[lose] interest in the church” (317). She recognizes a discrepancy between the ideals promoted by her preacher and her own less idyllic realities: [T]he thing that really disturbed Bonnie was the preacher’s insistence on the sacredness of the family, and his anger at those who did not keep their families together. Nothing would have pleased her more than to stay at home and raise her children in the best way she knew how. And there were many other women like her in the village. Mr. Simpkins [the preacher] seemed to think if they wished they could stay at home and have a life of comparative ease. Because his wife could stay at home, he thought that other men’s wives could do the same. Bonnie could not go to church Sunday after Sunday and hear him scold them for letting the family and the home break up without getting too angry. So she stayed at home with her young ones. (318)
Soon after this, her youngest child becomes sick and dies (319–20). Eventually, the conflict that Bonnie senses between religious ideals and her experience will emerge in an original song, written during the strike, that echoes her conflicting experiences with religion, labor, and motherhood: “We leave our homes in the morning. We kiss our children good-by. While we slave for the bosses Our children scream and cry. [. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .]
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 77
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
78
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” “But listen to me, workers: A union they [the bosses] do fear. Let’s stand together, workers, And have a union here.” (345–6)36
Since, in Bonnie’s reality, “bosses” intrude into the sacred relationship between mother and child, her song’s opening verse revises the preacher’s depiction of the “sacredness of the family.” Her song still emphasizes motherhood, but factors in an economic reality that the preacher’s sermons lack. This song reaches further back into Bonnie’s experience by recalling and revising the hymn, “Come Ye Sinners,” that she had loved as a child. In this hymn, the graphic images of bodily suffering—”weak and wounded, sick and sore”; “bruised and mangled”—are, of course, meant to symbolize spiritual travails. In Bonnie’s later experience as a factory worker, however, bodily injury becomes more literal. (Her husband, for instance, loses his hand in a factory accident [315].) Bonnie’s eventual grasp of the worldly roots of such suffering will make other aspects of the hymn incongruous with her reality. Are the “poor and needy” workers at the Wentworth mill really “sinners”? Have they been “mangled by the fall”? Should they look to Jesus for salvation? Bonnie draws on this hymn’s diction but proposes a new relationship of singer to suffering. As the above verses suggest, Bonnie adopts this hymn’s hortatory stance. (Her song, like the hymn, puts the singers into the roles of both callers and called.) At the same time, she avoids the obscuring symbolism of the hymn’s imagery and provides a new and more pragmatic approach to the problem of suffering. “John Hardy was a brave and a desperate boy”: radicalizing the outlaw hero It is a fact we cannot blink at that the outlaw is the popular hero of Appalachia to-day [ . . . ]. This is not due to any ingrained hostility to law and order as such, but simply to admiration for any men who fight desperately against overwhelming odds. —Horace Kephart. Our Southern Highlanders. (393)37 As individuals, they [bandits] are not so much political or social rebels, let alone revolutionaries, as peasants who refuse to submit, and in doing so stand out from their fellows. [ . . . . ] They are activists and not ideologists or prophets from whom novel visions or plans of social and political organization are to be expected. —Eric Hobsbawm. Bandits (24).
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 78
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
79
I’ve been to the east and I’ve been to the west, I’ve traveled this wide world around. I’ve been to the river and I’ve been baptized, And today I’m on my hanging ground, lord, lord. —Verse from the American outlaw ballad “John Hardy”38 I’ve traveled to the east and traveled to the west, as the ballad of John Hardy says. [. . . . ] It’s the same everywhere. —Grace Lumpkin. To Make My Bread. (312)
In 1930, less than a year after the Gastonia strike had ended, Lumpkin contributed a short piece to The New Masses that included the words to a song later incorporated into To Make My Bread. (She was working as an editor at The New Masses at the time.) Her accompanying notes told of hearing this song, which she identified simply as “Southern Cotton Mill Rhyme,” sung at a recent meeting of the National Textile Workers Union (NTWU) in Charlotte, North Carolina. “To my knowledge,” she reported, “this song has never appeared in print before” (“Cotton” 8). Lumpkin then described the circumstances leading up to the performance: after union members had sung “Solidarity Forever” and then songs by Ella May Wiggins, Daisy McDonald of Gastonia, asked her husband to lead The Southern Cotton Mill Rhyme. Some of us had not heard this song before and Mr. McDonald explained that many years ago he had worked at the loom next to a man in a mill in Buffalo, South Carolina. He said this weaver had spoken out the words of the Rhyme under the noise of the looms, making them up as he worked. And the song has gone from one worker to another and now it is known to hundreds of cotton mill hands who sing it as the workers did that night in the hall in Charlotte. (“Southern” 8)39
Lumpkin must have seen Cotton Mill Rhyme as compelling evidence of a protest tradition that predated Ella May’s recent, more radical calls to “have a union here,” “join the Textile Union,” and “join the I.L.D.”40 Structurally, “Cotton Mill Rhyme” builds rhetorical power through “evidence” accumulated in its thirteen verses (though most in no particular narrative order). Although it gestures towards radicalism by depicting a capitalist industrial structure that prospers through workers’ oppression, it does not add a solution to its depiction of the various indignities and injustices related to being a mill hand: long hours, low pay, children “grow[ing] up unlearned,” being
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 79
6/22/2006 8:54:29 AM
80
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
shunned by the “folks in town” who “spend their money free.”41 Still, one striking detail in the last stanza of the printed lyrics seems to have aroused particular interest among politically attuned New Masses readers: Just let them wear their watches fine And golden chains and rings, But when the great Revolution comes They’ll have to shed those things. (“Southern” 8 emphasis added)
In the next New Masses, Lumpkin responded to questions about this “great Revolution” reference—a detail that seemed to move the song from the realm of a traditional “complaint” song to one reflecting a Marxist belief in capitalism’s inevitable collapse.42 Originally, Lumpkin wrote, “the weaver who made the words” had referred to a “Day of Judgment” rather than a “great Revolution.” She traced the change back to the “[Gastonia] strike of April, 1929,” concluding that “folk songs are made and changed from the knowledge and needs of the people who sing them” (Letter 22). Lumpkin also made a noteworthy comment regarding the song’s tune: The tune as I heard it is original, perhaps the blending of some old ballads. But I know that the Rhyme, with a little adaptation, has been sung to the tune of “John Hardy,” a mountain ballad that is on Columbia Record No. 167-D, sung by Eve Davis who lives in the Great Smoky Mountains near Proctor, North Carolina. (Letter 22)
Evidence from the novel Lumpkin would publish two years later suggests that she recognized several levels of significance to the “Southern Cotton Mill Rhyme.” The slight details she obtained about the song’s author would inspire a significant character in To Make My Bread. Matching the above description from her New Masses piece, this character, John Stevens, had, many years before, “made [this song] up while weaving” (TMMB 258). That Lumpkin distinguished Stevens as the novel’s truest organic radical suggests that she saw this song as a compelling example of social protest that predated any Marxist influence in Southern labor.43 The singing of this song at the Charlotte NTWU meeting alongside the old IWW standard “Solidarity” and Ella May’s painfully fresh songs suggested both continuity and refinement of Southern workers’ creative responses to relatively new industrial pressures. As already discussed above with reference to the transformation of religious imagery, To Make My Bread develops the implications of this idea that traditional cultural modes may
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 80
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
81
dynamically transform to reflect new “knowledge and needs.” The “John Hardy” connection that Lumpkin notes adds a further potential nuance to these observations. In reality, the original idea of pairing the “John Hardy” tune with the new words of the “Cotton Mill Rhyme” might have been motivated primarily by the pragmatics of using a familiar tune to facilitate learning new words. For Lumpkin, however, this phenomenon of fusing a traditional genre (the outlaw ballad) and melody (“John Hardy”) with a new kind of message perhaps suggested a deeper significance. For, as I will discuss in detail below, “John Hardy” as it appears in To Make My Bread becomes infused with symbolic qualities that reflect the transformation of Appalachian people themselves in their move from a rural to an industrial setting. Interestingly, in addressing New Masses readers, most of whom lived north of the Mason-Dixon line, Lumpkin felt the need to identify “John Hardy” as a mountain ballad—and even to recommend a particular recording for those who might want to learn more about the song. Indeed, in a time before such regional American music was widely disseminated outside of the area where it thrived without the stimulus of print or recordings, relatively few urban Northern readers could be expected to have a mountain ballad like “John Hardy” in their intimately familiar cultural repertoires.44 In the rural South, however, familiarity with this ballad was likely. Besides being widespread in oral tradition, it was available on various recordings, including Davis’ and one by Virginia’s Carter Family, the best-selling country-music recording stars of their day.45 Naturally, recognizing how aspects of Lumpkin’s novel’s characterization, structure, and meaning might be read intertextually with “John Hardy” requires an understanding of this ballad in its own right. As an oral genre, ballads (such as “John Hardy”) offer a flexible structure, allowing narratives to expand or contract while still retaining a basic storyline and moral tone (although alteration of certain details may change the overall dramatic emphasis or moral implications considerably). Because of this flexibility, diverse variants of such a song may exist in oral tradition. As a more specific type of narrative within the ballad genre, “John Hardy” fits loosely within a category of American song often referred to as the “outlaw ballad.” Frequently—and such is the case in “John Hardy”—outlaw ballads narrate an individual’s act (or acts) of rash violence and then go on to show this individual’s eventual demise at the hands of the law (or sometimes at the hands of a traitor).46 In “John Hardy” stripped to its bare minimum, Hardy kills another man, tries to get away, and is eventually caught and sentenced to hang. Some versions elaborate on events surrounding the murder, escape,
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 81
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
82
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
and arrest. Significantly, in terms of the meaning Lumpkin finds in this ballad, other versions (including the nine-verse Davis version quoted below) focus more on Hardy’s social connections—the friends, family members, and wife (or lover) who mourn his fate47: John Hardy was a brave and desperated [sic] boy And he carried his gun every day. Well he killed a man near Shawnee Camp And I saw John Hardy gettin’ away, poor boy. They arrested him down at the Big Bend Tunnel And they carried him back to [ . . . ]. Since there is no bail on a murder of a man They locked John Hardy back in jail, poor boy. John Hardy’s friends they was standing around Some afraid John Hardy’s going to hang. Well the judge turned around and he looked in Johnny’s book John Hardy is sentenced to be hung, poor boy. John Hardy’s father he was standing by, Oh, John, what have you done? I killed my partner for fifteen cents And today I am condemned to be hung, poor boy. John Hardy’s mother she was standing by, Oh, John, what have you done? All for the sake of that black-eyed girl, That John Hardy never lied to his gun, poor boy. I’ve been to the east and I’ve been to the west, I’ve traveled this wide world around. I’ve been to the river and I’ve been baptized, And today I’m on my hanging ground, lord, lord. Oh, sister, oh sister, come stand by my side, While my burying is going on. You’ll never tell for death these words you’ve heard When you hear John Hardy’s song, lord, lord.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 82
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
83
When this black cap is put over my face No more shall I see. And when I am in my silent tomb Will you sometimes think of me, lord, lord. John Hardy had one pretty little miss, And she always dressed in lace. Well, she walked right down on the hanging ground, Oh, Johnny, I wish I could take your place, poor boy.48
In his influential 1913 treatise on the culture of the “Southern Highlanders,” Horace Kephart (as noted in one of the epigraphs preceding this section) called the outlaw “the popular hero of Appalachia today.” Assuming the basic accuracy of Kephart’s observation, how should this widespread popularity in Appalachia of “John Hardy” and similar outlaw ballads be understood? Kephart argued that this social phenomenon was “not due to any ingrained hostility to law and order as such, but simply to admiration for any men who fight desperately against overwhelming odds” (393). Further, the aesthetic conventions of outlaw-ballad narratives tended to romanticize and simplify more complex and problematic realities. As Richard Meyer notes, American outlaw ballads in general show a folk tendency to elevate to mythic heroism the actions of men who were in real life “ruthless criminals, capable of savage and at times seemingly indiscriminate slaughter, whose first and often only thoughts were of themselves” (115). Because of the ballad genre’s flexibility, new narratives about new outlaws could be fit into its particular logic. As Arthur Palmer Hudson, a respected North Carolina scholar of folklore and literature, observed in the mid1930s, the “species of folk-song” about “outlaws, feudists, and vagrants” was “the most vital today” because “its pattern is simple and clear. The parts are standardized. It is as easy to make over or repair as the old T-model Ford” (538). Bringing Marxist sensibilities to a study of how and why “bandits” function as symbolic heroes in “peasant” society, Eric Hobsbawm comes closest to conveying the socioeconomic underpinnings of the folk outlaw ideal that Lumpkin recognizes and uses as a basis for radicalization. Hobsbawm finds that bandits and bandit lore tend to arise in societies that “lie between the evolutionary phase of tribal and kinship organization, and modern capitalist and industrial society” (18). He sees social bandits—both as actual entities and as the subjects of folklore—as manifestations of and responses to social oppression, “a special type of peasant protest and rebellion” (40). Visions of revolution, Hobsbawm suggests, do not spur the social bandit:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 83
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
84
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
“As individuals, they are not so much political or social rebels, let alone revolutionaries, as peasants who refuse to submit, and in doing so stand out from their fellows. [. . . . ] They are activists and not ideologists or prophets from whom novel visions or plans of social and political organization are to be expected” (24). Social bandits, unlike true revolutionaries, envision “righting wrongs” as a restoration of an old moral order that they perceive to have decayed (26). And for the oppressed population who exalt them, social bandits typically serve as “surrogates” for revolutionary activity, “as when peasants admire Robin Hoods as their champions, for want of any more positive activity by themselves” (26). The kind of outlaw “about whom men sing ballads: champions, heroes and avengers” engage in “an individual rebellion, which is socially and politically undetermined” and which is “the product and counterpart of the general passivity of the poor” (36). Lumpkin’s use of “John Hardy” as a metaphorical subtext within To Make My Bread is significant in part because of “John Hardy’s” rather equivocal relationship to more overtly romantic outlaw myths. In folk tradition, “John Hardy” does accrue certain characteristics—his initial “getting away” and his assertion that he “never lied to his gun”—that might truly elevate him to the heroic outlaw status that Hobsbawm describes. Mostly, though, his crime perverts this outlaw ideal, since he kills wantonly, not in the process of robbing the rich to give to the poor.49 Moreover, the personal and social consequences of Hardy’s rash violence challenge the myth of the virtually immortal outlaw-hero. The law’s ability to capture Hardy—often characterized as a “desperate little man”—and execute him makes celebrating his audacity illogical. Likewise, after Hardy’s capture, his painful confrontations with those close to him break down an image of the lone outlaw unhindered by family bonds. Thus, although “John Hardy” (like many other examples of the outlaw-ballad genre) has been linked to hyper-masculine frontier codes that celebrate rebellious fighting spirit, it actually reinforces the idea that, for the socialized individual, rash violence is futile and self-destructive.50 The supposedly lone outlaw may briefly generate awe or fear (and perhaps vicarious pleasure for those who retell his exploits) but—as the “John Hardy” narrative seems to demand—he can and will be destroyed. While such a song may effectively dramatize society’s view of the consequences of destructive individual outlaw behavior, it does not offer a satisfactory model for a different kind of behavior that might also be characterized as outlaw—constructive rebellion arising out of classbased, collective discontent against a common oppressor. The trajectory of
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 84
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
85
Lumpkin’s narrative, however, works towards this latter type of rebellion, suggesting how it may evolve from the former.51 Lumpkin’s imaginative work with “John Hardy” is part of a revisionist project designed to show characters who “collectively defy [ . . . ] myths of the poor white” (Sowinska xxviii). Preconceptions about poor whites in general, or about impoverished Appalachian mountaineers more specifically, form part of the ideological backdrop against which Lumpkin’s story is told. Lumpkin treats dominant conceptions of Appalachian culture as points of departure, to be variously acknowledged, refuted, or imaginatively transformed. In creating her own vision of a mountain family carrying organic cultural seeds that could sprout a workers’ revolution, Lumpkin implicitly writes against the grain of popular negative conceptions about Appalachian life. Thus, her novel incorporates two of the most prevalent popular signifiers of “backwards” Appalachian culture—moonshining and feuding—but consciously divests these practices of local-color romanticism.52 Granpap’s involvement with moonshining is not romanticized, but rather is used to indicate the degree to which the McClures are ensnared in the outside cash economy. When Granpap is caught and jailed for smuggling whiskey, the family nearly starves during the following winter. The resulting social and financial instability contributes to their eventual loss of land. And, as discussed in the following section, Lumpkin evokes images of violence—the kind that might, stereotypically, devolve into feuding—both to reveal the true social cost of such violence and to show that quick-tempered indignation may be redirected into more fruitful action. The “ballad” of Kirk McClure Midway into the novel’s “mountain section,” Lumpkin incorporates a fragment of “John Hardy” into an unsettling episode in which Kirk and Basil, Emma’s two teenage sons, have fought violently with each other. In this context, the ballad itself becomes another element in the volatile mix of bravery, bravado, rash violence, and alcohol that fuels the tension between these siblings. Kirk and Basil’s fight centers on jealousy over a girl named Minnie Hawkins, who is notorious within the community for allure and promiscuity. Isolated from larger bodies of people (and, Lumpkin implies, more worthy conflicts), the two brothers “share” and fight over Minnie. After one such fight, Kirk—recovering from a gash Basil has left in his scalp—attempts to show that his injury has not fazed him. He “pretend[s] to have a banjo in his arms” and starts taunting Basil by singing “John Hardy”:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 85
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
86
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” “John Hardy was a brave and a desperate boy And he carried his gun ever’ day, And he killed a man down in Johnson Town, And I saw John Hardy getting away, Pore Boy.” (80)
For Kirk, this opening verse suggests a devil-may-care bravery worth emulating.53 His more levelheaded mother, however, recognizes that the ballad’s complete narrative contains a more sobering truth. She cuts Kirk off as the song descends into the outlaw’s inevitable demise: “They arrested him down at the bi . . .” “That’s enough, Kirk,” Emma said. “Hush!” (80)
Indeed, the full narrative of “John Hardy” is prescient of Kirk’s fate. After Minnie becomes pregnant (either Kirk or Basil might be the father—or possibly neither), Basil loses interest in her and leaves the mountains for a religious school. Although Kirk takes Minnie into his mother’s home, where she bears a child, she begins to secretly see another local man, Sam. When Sam, outlaw fashion, rides on horseback to the McClure home and takes Minnie with him, Kirk follows with his gun and is himself shot dead by Sam. If Kirk’s death itself evokes, or even exploits, a stereotype of a culture given to petty killing (of the same sort that “John Hardy” depicts), the aftermath of his death tends to counter this stereotype. Kirk’s pursuit of Minnie and Sam evokes mythical images of lone outlaws who bravely take problems into their own hands; Kirk’s death, however, subverts this myth of individualism, especially since Lumpkin emphasizes the emotional blow to Kirk’s family.54 Although friends in the community promise Emma that “Sam McEachern will pay for this” (114), the desire for revenge—in contrast to popular-culture stereotypes—never evolves into further violence. Thus, although Lumpkin’s narrative initially plays into a supposed link between violent songs and violent social tendencies, it later revises this stereotype. While Kirk’s downfall is the most immediate and irreversible, the fates of the three other surviving players in this mini drama are also foreshadowed by their roles in this episode. Here, they compromise the well-being of their mountain community through selfish intra-class fighting; later, they compromise the workers’ strike through their indifference (Basil and Minnie) or hostility (Sam) to it. Basil, after leaving home to pursue an education, comes to feel ashamed of his poor family and avoids subsequent contact with them (especially after marrying a woman from a wealthy family).55 Minnie
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 86
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
87
later becomes a mill-town prostitute, serving Basil and tempting his younger brother John. During the strike at the Wentworth mill, Sam leads the deputized thugs hired by the mill owners to terrorize strikers. Suggesting a sort of revised outlaw-ballad justice at work, Sam is shot (possibly by his own men) while leading a raid on union headquarters. Within this work’s socialist bildungsroman framework, all four of these characters provide examples of certain working-class individuals who fall by the wayside while others journey further toward collective consciousness. Kirk’s fatal attempt to resolve his individual struggle alone with a gun and Basil’s deplorable drive to leave his family behind both show ideological patterns that younger siblings Bonnie and John must avoid or overcome.56 In contrast to Kirk and Basil, who fought over a woman who ultimately wanted neither of them, Bonnie and John will end up fighting for workers’ collective interests. Lumpkin suggests that Bonnie and John both learn from the events that separated Kirk and Basil from the family unit. Thus, the scene in which Kirk taunts Basil by singing “John Hardy” includes the detail of young Bonnie “[hanging] onto the side of the bed, looking up at Kirk and listening to the song” (80). In the ensuing years, she must, we are led to imagine, have pondered over the troubling fusion of Kirk’s bravado while singing “John Hardy” and his senseless death. Compared to “John Hardy,” her own later ballad, written for the union, reaches toward a higher social potential. Similarly, John will have to reconcile his admiration for Kirk with the spectacle of his mother’s grief when she finds Kirk’s body (111–2). These early incidents form an important basis for Bonnie and John’s development and for Lumpkin’s demonstration of ideological change spread out over several generations. The “ballad” of Small Hardy Lumpkin’s use of “John Hardy” in association with events leading up to Kirk’s death suggests one way that values implicit in this ballad may lead to destructive results. Another subtle evocation of “John Hardy” that also occurs in the novel’s “mountain section” uses a different tack to suggest that the worldview presented in this ballad might be outdated and incongruous with the industrial society that the McClures will later confront. Even before the above episode in which Kirk sings “John Hardy,” the novel introduces the Hardy name in the guise of a humpbacked peddler, Small Hardy. Small Hardy’s diminutive first name (and perhaps his deformity) hints that he is something quite unlike the mythologized outlaw whose surname he shares. That such a man has managed to reach the remote McClure cabin suggests that penetration of this
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 87
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
88
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
land is no longer exclusive to the region’s old hardy/Hardy stock. As Emma tells Granpap, “Look at that peddler, Small Hardy. The first time he come was some winters ago and now he comes every spring and always talking about the outside” (71). When Granpap—always suspicious of strangers—interrogates him, Small Hardy offers replies that seem to mark him as something less than the hardy people who live here: “Come from far?” Granpap asked. “From the towns,” Hardy said. He wiped his face with a red handkerchief. (36)
When Hardy asks for the best way down from the mountains, a wary Granpap puts the peddler’s character to a further test: “You want steep trails or easy ones?” Granpap asked and he watched Hardy. “Give me the easy ones,” Hardy said. (36).
Granpap “seem[s] to be satisfied” (36), presumably meaning that he has ascertained the weak nature of Small Hardy’s character. Small Hardy may not be an outlaw bandit, but he is on an unscrupulous mission—to drum up interest in millwork among mountain people (who, compared to more experienced industrial workers, might provide docile and cheap labor). He first dazzles Emma with beads and “a fine looking knitted thing, a fascinator, he called it” (38). Then, he broaches the subject that will forever change the McClure family: “Down in Leesville [ . . . ] a Mr. Wentworth, a rich man, has a mill for making cloth like this.” [ . . . . ] “And they say whoever goes down to work there is going to be rich like him—for he started out as poor as the next one. They say out there the rivers flow with milk and honey and money grows on trees.” (39)
At this point in the narrative, Granpap—a staunch individualist—still has the final say in the family. When he challenges the peddler with the observation that mountaineers who turned factory workers (at any wage scale) would lose the tangible security of the houses and land they already own, “Hardy knew the evening was finished” (40).57 Unlike the prototypical “badman” of folklore, Small Hardy himself is not a physical threat. Rather, he is simply a harbinger of powerful and
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 88
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
89
complex economic interests that already seek to exploit the mountains for timber and cheap labor. Hardy admits that he hasn’t “been there [to the mill village] very much. But they [mill financiers] said I was to spread the news” (39). Himself manipulated by economic interests, Hardy in turn helps manipulate such families into selling the timber rights on their land.58 As the novel later reveals, the lumber mill, after giving mountain people temporary employment and prosperity, shut down after taking the best trees. And, “since most people had depended on the wages from the lumber company for paying rent, there was nothing for them to do but leave the mountain and go where they could find ready money” (284)—especially in textile mills and other factories.59 Soon after the McClures have migrated to Leesville—pushed by the timber companies and pulled by Hardy’s claims—another “Hardy” allusion suggests that this new industrial environment has subsumed the rugged individualism that “John Hardy” once loosely symbolized. As the McClures stand in the mill’s management office waiting to find out where they will live and work, a young child with “small hands” that were “bony [ . . . ] like his face” asks a cashier for “a book of scrip fer Mis’ Hardy” (155). The cashier must then ask, “Mis’ what Hardy?” before checking the books. She warns the child that this is the second credit extension at the company store that month. Thus, this scene subtly suggests that John Hardy’s male descendants have become invisible, anonymous figures, absent fathers of hungry children they cannot support. John and Bonnie McClure—deconstructing the outlaw-hero In this same mill environment, where cultural heroes like “John Hardy” seem to have shriveled or disappeared, the two youngest McClure children, John and Bonnie, must come to maturity and define themselves within society. One important aspect of Lumpkin’s narration of the development, and eventual radicalization, of John and Bonnie shows old, individually oriented “outlaw” values transforming into new kinds of socially oriented ones.60 When Bonnie and John participate in the strike at the novel’s end, they culminate not only their own development, but also a multigenerational development—one that has taken the experiences of their older siblings, their mother, and their grandfather into account. For this reason, family experiences throughout the novel should also be seen as contributing to a repository of positive and negative lessons that Bonnie and John draw from as they come to understand the need to approach exploitation collectively. (Especially since the McClures
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 89
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
90
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
are fairly cut off from print culture, family experience plays a crucial role in establishing strategies of response to social situations.) A number of relatively early family experiences evoke the aforementioned model of outlaw behavior (epitomized in the one-on-one act of confronting adversaries with a gun). Besides Kirk’s confrontations with Sam (which led to Kirk being gunned down), several of Granpap’s experiences interspersed throughout the novel work to emphasize the futility of individually taking revenge. An early anecdote recalls how “Tate,” a man with a “fat belly” “whose comfort had always come first” (22), had cheated Granpap out of his own land. Though his code of honor tempted Granpap to kill Tate, he “changed the form of his revenge” (22), hiding in the brush and shooting Tate in the backside with buckshot (thus causing him great temporary discomfort but no permanent injury). Although this morally ambiguous act—one that avoids a cycle of killing but still is not particularly brave—gave Granpap some personal satisfaction, it did nothing to get his land back. Later, also in the mountains, Granpap threatens to use his gun to prevent a man from charging his family rent for living in the cabin they had built themselves.61 When a “Company man” comes to collect this rent, “Granpap met [him] at the door with his shotgun” (134). Then, when Hal Swain tries to tell Granpap that “the company would have a right by law to put the family out of the house,” “Granpap simply pointed to his shotgun” (134). Eventually realizing that this fight is hopeless, however, he admits to his family that going to the mill is the best option—at least temporarily: “maybe we could all make enough to buy back the land up here when the lumber company’s through” (137). (They never do return.) Understandably, Granpap is haunted by these two experiences of being helpless to prevent losing his land. After the family has moved to the more economically structured area around the mill, Granpap talks to a lowland farmer who had gone into debt and lost his land. Hearing of this loss, Granpap asks what the man had done to the person who took his land: “there was an excitement in his voice as if he expected to hear a story of a revenge that suited the crime of taking a man’s land away from him. ‘Nothing,’ the man said. ‘There wasn’t anything to do except pay what I owe’” (172). Later, Granpap will also lose a farm after failing to make a profit raising cotton. By now, he has come to accept that he, like this other man, has little choice but to relinquish the land without a fight (264). While such experiences simply drain the old fighting spirit out of Granpap, they give Bonnie and John a repository of experience that will contribute to their recognition of the need to search for different ways to counteract such oppression.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 90
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
91
John’s early experiences are particularly important to Lumpkin’s examination of how individualistic approaches to fighting adversity must readjust to effectively combat labor exploitation. In devoting more time to John’s early social adjustments to mill-village life than she does to Bonnie’s, Lumpkin suggests that John must negotiate certain threats to class-conscious action to which males are particularly susceptible. Although John and Bonnie both briefly get to attend school for the first time in their lives when the family arrives in Leesville, John—as an eleven-year-old boy—has “things he had to learn outside [the schoolhouse] that Bonnie was spared” (211). A gang of other boys around John’s age, most of whom are the sons of the town’s “higher-ups,” single John out for torment because he is poor, new at school, and far behind them in his education. In her explanation of how John conceives of his problem, Lumpkin shows old ways of dealing with social conflicts juxtaposed with a problematically new social situation. After days of bearing the bullying stoically, at last it came to the place where John wanted to stop school. It was not that he was afraid. He was ashamed in the class room of being so big among the others, and of knowing so little. He thought of going to the hills, running away [ . . . ]. There he would be free and at home. There he could fight on his own ground. He was confused. In the hills families stuck together, but it was man against man. He could not quite make out how to manage with several against him, for the boys who nagged were always together. (211)
John’s boyhood problem has a particular complexity (and symbolic resonance within the novel’s larger emphasis on labor) because the power structure within the tormenting gang both replicates and flows into the larger power structure of the mill. Albert, the gang’s de facto leader, commands respect mostly because of his father’s high position in the mill: “if [other boys] didn’t respect him as son of the Superintendent, then there were ways to make them fear him. [ . . . . ] Just as soon as a boy acknowledged his superiority he was very kind and just” (214). John fantasizes about dealing with his problem as an outlaw-hero might have: “If possible he would have liked to take Granpap’s gun after the whole lot” (214). Indeed, John briefly becomes something of an outlaw after an unavoidable showdown with Albert’s gang. One day after school, this gang waylays John on an out-ofthe-way road (stealing his pants and pouring turpentine on him). Driven by pain and humiliation, John, who is lanky and not very muscular, tackles Albert with surprising effect: “Albert lay still, with blood running from his
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 91
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
92
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
head” (215). Unsure of Albert’s fate, John hides out, outlaw fashion, “on the side of the narrow road to the mountains two nights,” until Granpap finds him—cold, tired, and famished—and brings him home (215). John’s fight has mixed consequences, both for himself and for his whole family. On a positive note, this direct confrontation with the boys stops their bullying. When John finally (and reluctantly) returns to school, “he found little trouble [ . . . ]. Everyone knew by this time that he had got his man and gone up into the hills to hide like an outlaw” (218). Even after the event itself is largely forgotten, “there was a feeling left with those who kept on living in the village that John McClure was a wild boy and one not easily frightened or fought down” (218). On a less positive note, because he had fought “and nearly killed” (217) the son of the man who is superintendent of the school and the mill where Emma works, he jeopardizes his education and, potentially, his mother’s job. As John learns later, restoring peace after his socially complex battle had required an equally complex pulling of social strings. Before John is allowed back in school, his brother Basil (who is engaged to Preacher Warren’s wife’s sister), speaks to Preacher Warren, who presides over the church attended by the mill superintendent and other “higher-ups” in the town. Preacher Warren then “[speaks] to the superintendent of mills over the telephone” (235).62 Thus, whereas John had learned in the mountains that fights are “man against man” (211), he finds that opponents in the mill village—even in seemingly personal school-yard fights— may be backed by powers that complicate or invalidate this individualistic conception of conflict resolution.63 Although John drove off his attackers with sheer physical willpower, he could not overcome the mill village’s power structure using such means since he had to face the reality of needing to reintegrate into society afterwards. Soon after this fight incident, John meets a man who will be instrumental in changing his survival strategies when faced with oppressive conditions. When the McClures’ financial circumstances force John and Bonnie to quit school and begin work in the mill, John encounters John Stevens, an older man who had been in the mills since age eight.64 Stevens becomes something of a surrogate for John’s own father, who had died before he was born. Besides looking out for his physical safety in the mill, he takes an interest in John’s desire to better understand his family’s poverty.65 For John, who has up to this point relied primarily on his family’s repository of experience and culture to guide him, Stevens’ new body of experiential insights and cultural offerings proves invaluable to the process of becoming critically selfaware. Stevens, far from heroically proportioned, is small and limps “from a badly set leg he had broken in a fall when he was eight years old and had just
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 92
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
93
begun to work in the mills” (258). Though “strong and [ . . . ] very active” (258), his skill at his job does not stem from physical prowess, but rather from accepting and taking advantage of the reality that “machines can do the work of many men” (257). A skilled weaver who “liked his machines” (258), he teaches John to distinguish between the actual equipment and the mill management that uses it to exploit workers: “‘It’s what they do to people,’ he said to John [ . . . ] that makes me sick at heart” (258). Considering that John comes to pattern his own values on those of Stevens, the amalgam of traits by which Lumpkin characterizes Stevens points to a reformulation of the criteria that, in John’s world, had traditionally defined heroes. The slightly built, thoughtful Stevens is a clear departure from the brawny he-man workers favored in American folklore (John Henry, Paul Bunyan)—not to mention 1930s-era working-class iconography.66 Unlike individual size or strength, which might set workers against one another, the kind of insight into labor issues that Stevens possesses can be passed from worker to worker.67 Such insight, disseminated among a large body of workers, enables a collective heroism not predicated on individual physical prowess. While Stevens is, justifiably, bitter about the bosses’ disregard for workers’ health and safety, his notion of vengeance is collective rather than personal, and constructive rather than destructive. When John hears Stevens singing an original song about mill workers’ experience, his enthusiastic response shows a recognition that this song is unlike anything that he has been exposed to before: “John wrote the song verse by verse on paper at home”—presumably after memorizing it from Stevens’ singing—“and brought it to show his friend. ‘I’m right glad you liked it that much,’ John Stevens said” (260). This song gives John a new perspective towards adversity that is collective rather than solitary. From its first verse, it demonstrates how the experience of a singular “I” finds support through recognition of and absorption into a collective “we”: I lived in a town away down South By the name of Buffalo And worked in a mill with the rest of the trash As we’re often called you know. (259)
In the second and third verses, the singular “I” reappears, as in the first verse, to reaffirm that the songwriter, a fellow millworker, completely identifies with the people he sings about:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 93
6/22/2006 8:54:30 AM
94
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” You factory folks who sing this rhyme Will surely understand The reason why I love you so Is I’m a factory hand. While standing here between my looms You know I lose no time To keep my shuttles in a whiz And make this little rhyme. (259)
Now that the narrator has established legitimate working-class origins, the remainder of the song uses a collective perspective to describe various situations typical of mill-village experience: We rise up early in the morn And work all day real hard To buy our little meat and bread And sugar, tea and lard. We work from weeks [sic] end to weeks end And never lose a day And when that awful pay day comes We draw our little pay. (259)68
As part of its collective approach to conveying indignation and commiseration, this song also incorporates various slurs and demeaning images that more fortunate members of society have used against mill workers: As we go walking down the street All wrapped in lint and strings They call us fools and factory trash And other low down names. (260)
By reappropriating such words, the song defuses their capacity to shame and puts their power back into workers’ hands. Having documented the factory experiences of John and his family, Lumpkin hardly needs to explain what attracts John to this song. Likely, John Stevens’ comment about this song’s importance to workers in other times and places speaks to John’s new experience as well: “‘I’ve sung it in mill towns in three states and in the North, too, and people have learned it. I feel
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 94
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
95
good sometimes to think I’ve spoken to folks at times when they feel the sorrow of working without much recompense’” (260). Stevens’ song also affirms John’s own sense that an energizing creative pulse emanates from the rattling, throbbing machines around him. While factory work could easily be seen as fatal to mountain culture, John makes an affirmative imaginative connection between the two. Hearing the throb of the machines, John senses that somewhere before he had known a sound like it. One day, listening intently to the looms he remembered. He had stood outside McDonald’s cabin and heard feet pounding inside to the sound of fiddle and banjo. The feet had come down on the floor rhythmically. They got into his blood. The rhythm had beaten up from the shaking floor into his feet, just as it did in the mill. He thought with pleasure that one day he would be one who controlled those machines. (257)
Through these thoughts, Lumpkin suggests that the industrial environment might pump new life into old folk cadences. Immediately following this passage, Stevens’ song functions as an actual cultural entity that confirms, in sense and sound, John’s own intuitive observations: “the song was about factory people, and it was easy to see how John Stevens had made it up while weaving, for his voice, singing it, rose and fell with the rhythm of the looms” (258).69 If aspects of the McClure family’s earlier responses to adversities may be seen as modeled upon an outlaw ideal, then later responses to other crises may be seen as refining this ideal into a new collective outlawry oriented toward class goals. One suggestive illumination of John’s radicalization comes from Richard Meyer’s observations on the outlaw ideal manifested in folklore. The first two of Meyer’s twelve characteristics of the folk “outlawhero” are especially pertinent as parallels to John’s own subjectivity. “First,” Meyers observes, “the American outlaw-hero is a ‘man of the people’; he is closely identified with the common people, and, as such, is generally seen to stand in opposition to certain established, oppressive economic, civil and legal systems peculiar to the American historical experience” (97). “Second, the outlaw-hero’s first ‘crime’—the one that launches his career—is brought about through extreme provocation or persecution by agents of the oppressive system” (99). To a degree, John’s experiences evoke these criteria: John comes from common working people and he experiences provocation that compels his eventual desire to undermine the capitalist system. Just as importantly, though, his experiences deviate from, or are more complex than, such folklore ideals. Even while growing up, John has vacillated between an admiration
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 95
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
96
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
for his successful and “ambitious” brother Basil and a realization that this ambition tends to preclude concern for the rest of his family. Particularly after John’s status changes from schoolboy to mill hand, he must navigate his way through experiences that often contradict each other and thus fail to add up to a clear-cut sense of class identity. Most of John’s experiences do indeed increase his class-consciousness. John sees and experiences various setbacks that frustrate his family’s hopes of bettering their social circumstances through industrial labor. Particularly through his occasional conversations with the older worker John Stevens, he gradually gathers insights that help him to formulate a radical, class-based understanding of these setbacks. Other experiences during the same period in John’s life, however, offer him the tantalizing chance to rise, as an individual, above the dismal status quo of friends and family. John’s greatest struggle with personal ambition begins after he becomes reacquainted with a former school friend, Robert.70 Through Robert “John entered into a different life from that he had been leading. He became acquainted, if not at first hand then at second, with some of the men of the town” (290). Encouraged by Robert, John becomes a member of a reactionary and relatively exclusive local organization (to which, significantly, John’s upwardly mobile brother Basil also belongs): “It stood for the protection of the flag, and the motto was ‘Keep out the foreigner and the nigger. Neither belongs’” (293). Robert espouses a seductively phrased nihilism that diametrically opposes John Steven’s Marxist beliefs: “Religious people say God loves us all and guides us, and others say there is some kind of plan in the universe. I’ve read a lot, John—philosophers and others. And I tell you there is no plan and no guidance. There is no order, no law, no purpose, no progress for the human race. History repeats itself over and over, and here we are, the human race in all its ugliness, just the same as ever. It’s for a man to get out and while there’s a life to be lived, grab just as much as he can and to hell with everybody else.” (292)
John’s new social contacts with “men of the town” lead to better job opportunities: “the authorities of the mill became especially cordial to him, for some of them belonged to the same lodge” (298). Soon, the mill superintendent selects John as a section boss. Although John enters this job knowing that it may test his allegiance to his own social class against that of the ownership class, he hopes to show his kin and friends that “he could be fair, and yet climb higher than others had done” (298). However, when John tries to
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 96
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
97
present workers’ grievances to the management, he is told that “your part is to get work out of those people in there” (299). John’s class allegiances are further tested when he becomes infatuated with an attractive young woman, Ruth Gordon, who has been hired by the mill to start social clubs among the female employees (301). Although she “had left college with the idea of working for the poor” and her clubs promoting good hygiene and diet seem superficially altruistic, they also function to promote decorum and respect for managerial authority. John’s attraction to Ruth causes him to lose interest in the racist club, but his new love interest also threatens to stifle his developing class consciousness. Recognizing John’s popularity among fellow workers, Ruth “was glad that John was interested [in helping her], for if she could get a few or even one to lead she was sure the rest would follow. She had been taught that those who composed the lower elements of society were like sheep and would follow a leader” (301). John sees this darker side of Gordon’s role only after she establishes his trust and friendship and then asks him to become an informer for the mill: “All you need to do is watch the other people and report any who speak in a dissatisfied way” (304).71 The recognition of Gordon’s true function in the mill is one of the turning points that drives John strongly back to his class. On top of this, on the same night that his lust for Ruth turns to disgust, his mother’s deterioration from pellagra worsens and causes her to die soon afterwards. Having cut himself adrift from the tentative ties he had made to people with non-working-class interests, John now feels compelled to seek advice from his old friend John Stevens. Significantly, Stevens has moved to a nearby town by the time John experiences his crisis of class identification. Stevens cannot watch over and critique John’s behavior; John must recognize his own need for advice and go to Stevens for counsel. The advice John receives from Stevens further emphasizes the need for a new kind of outlaw-hero. As Stevens explains, John has the courage to confront another man with fists or gun, but also the common sense to not provoke the power system that could then deprive him of the means to support himself and his family. John still wants to believe that a person can rise fairly in the world through independent struggle, but Stevens argues that “if you want to get up you’ve got to push somebody down unless the start has been made before you, and then, ten to one, it was done in the same way” (314). As mentioned earlier, Stevens confesses that he has tried and rejected the outlaw’s restless search for freedom from social constraints. He has “traveled to the east and traveled to the west, as the ballad of John Hardy says,” only to find that “it’s the same everywhere” (312). Still, Stevens’ conception of the appropriate resistance to oppression retains an important aspect of the outlaw code: Stevens realizes
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 97
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
98
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
that those with the power to oppress will not give it up willingly. Using a poisonous snake as metaphor, Stevens explains his unambiguous mistrust of those who possess power: “From their side they shouldn’t be blamed. They grew up on earth, but just because I know they can harm me or mine, I know I’ve got to kill one when I see it” (311). Through John’s tentative exploration of his ultimate class alignment, Lumpkin adds complexity to what Meyers has proposed as defining characteristics of the outlaw-hero. Although John indeed ultimately “stands in opposition” to all forces that oppress his class, his arrival at this point of unqualified class allegiance is not a foregone conclusion. He passes through a crucial period when—had he been willing to compromise his family and class loyalty—he might have risen above this class. Eventually, John consciously rejects such opportunities as incompatible with working-class solidarity.72 Since John has other alternatives besides the dangerous, secretive life of a labor organizer, his choice of this role reflects sincerity of purpose. Precisely because John’s actions are not predicated on being the victim of an explicit violent act, he represents a new kind of “outlaw”—one more worthy of Lumpkin’s agenda of collective action. Unlike Meyer’s formulation of “extreme provocation or persecution,” the motivations for John incurring such risks derive in part from a new ability to recognize exploitation where he had been blind to it before. (John is initially taken aback, for example, when Stevens tells him that, from his perspective, John’s mother [who died of pellagra] actually should be seen as having been murdered by her bosses.) This portrayal of John’s gradual understanding of a Marxist outlook demonstrates a rhetorical strategy that Barbara Foley has called “conversion” through “the dialectics of process,” as opposed to “conversion through confrontation” (Radical 386). As part of Lumpkin’s attempt to show working-class values moving from individual to collective, John’s gradual development represents a modest heroism accessible to an average worker. While relatively few workers would be driven to hardened crime by the system, all workers could make reasoned decisions about how to collectively resist an oppressive system, even if that meant breaking oppressive social or legal codes. Though John’s somewhat more singular role as a strike leader is particularly emblematic of a new conception of outlaw-heroism, this role is simply a more extreme form of the new identity that all workers turned strikers assume. Regardless of whether workers like John who form a union and go on strike technically break any laws, they risk social ostracism, evictions, blacklisting, beatings, and even death through their actions. (As with outlaws, strikers forfeit basic social benefits—those, in this case, that go along with being pliant employees. But unlike traditional larger-than-life
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 98
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
99
outlaw heroes who operate outside of social structures, new unionist “outlaws” must rebel against the very socioeconomic structure they cannot help but occupy.) Even when public defiance of laws or conventions is communal rather than individual, it still requires individual acts of participation. When the workers collectively defy their overseer’s order to “get to work,” Lumpkin writes that “it was an amazing thing, that they felt the courage to leave their machines” (333). Tom Moore also praises it as “one of the finest things I have ever known” (340). Indeed, the omnipresent “guards who carried sawed-off shotguns, and [ . . . ] pistols ready for use” (368), and who later kill Bonnie, show that the strikers risked physical retribution for daring to fight for change. When John joins the strike, he is tempted to revert to his earlier conceptions of how to confront physical threats. Like many of his fellow mountain-bred strikers, he must be convinced that carrying a gun on the picket line might be self-defeating. This time, it is a Northern Communist organizer, Tom Moore, who advises John: “What’s that in your hand, John?” Tom Moore asked. “Why,” John answered, “you can see. Hit’s my gun.” “I thought,” Tom Moore said straight out, “John Stevens had made you understand better than that.” “Hit’s a fight,” John insisted. “And this is the way I know how to fight.” (346)
After giving John his rationale privately, Tom explains to the other strikers that we can’t fight in that way now. We must use peaceful means to gain what we want. It isn’t that I want to keep you from fighting in the way you are used. But I know from experience we must fight with numbers. [ . . . . ] John McClure came this morning with his shot gun. Now he understands that it is best for him to leave it here. (347)
After the strikers have suffered more provocation and threats, however, John speaks to Moore, “and they had decided that the time had come for them to use guns in their defense. With a gun in his hand he was afraid of nothing” (368). Presenting the possibility of violence not as rash retaliation, but rather as a measured and democratically endorsed last resort, Lumpkin again reworks a stereotype of inherently violent hill folk into a demonstration of rational commitment to the union cause.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 99
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
100
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
“Ye have killed the righteous one: he doth not resist you” The strike that culminates the novel’s narrative of working-class transformation follows a wide-ranging conversation between John Stevens and John McClure in which Stevens draws McClure’s attention to several contrasting historical responses to class conflict: views from the Bible’s book of James; views expressed by Nicola Sacco and Bartolomeo Vanzetti, two working-class Italian immigrant radicals who were convicted on flimsy charges of murder and robbery and executed in Massachusetts in 1927; and views manifested by the 1917 Russian Revolution. The way that Stevens’ instructive conversation with McClure unfolds makes the notion of meaning as process especially significant to this exposition. This conversation emerges out of McClure’s sense of hopelessness and builds towards Stevens telling him of “the message” of new hope—that workers are capable of bettering their conditions by collectively rising and taking wealth from the hands of a powerful few. Fitting the novel’s deployment of schemata of transformation, McClure only learns of this history of ideological (and actual) dissent towards the end of the novel. At this point, he has already tried and rejected a high-paying foreman job that would have forced him to compromise the trust his fellow workers have placed in him. Now, he has reached the nadir of his despair about factory life: “there was nothing for [him and his family] to look forward to but a life of going to the mill, coming home to rest for strength to work in the mill again. Over and over, forever and ever, Amen” (324–5). Remembering, however, that Stevens had vaguely hinted at possessing a “message” that could bring hope to workers’ lives, McClure goes to talk with him. Early in their conversation, Stevens responds to McClure’s question about why the preachers he has known dwell so much on the idea that death is not aristocratic. Opening his Bible, he reads an incendiary indictment against the exploitation of laborers and the hoarding of wealth: Go to now, ye rich, weep and howl for your miseries that are coming upon you. Your riches are corrupted, and your garments are motheaten. [ . . . . ] Behold the hire of the laborers who mowed your fields, which is of you kept back by fraud, crieth out: and the cries of them that reaped have entered into the ears of the Lord of Sabbaoth. [ . . . . ] Ye have condemned, ye have killed the righteous one: he doth not resist you. (325)73
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 100
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
101
Having known only preachers who wanted to appease their wealthier congregation members, McClure had not realized that the Bible contained such perspectives. But even these words, Stevens tells him, are not “the message.” Rejecting the Bible’s assurance that a supernatural being hears “the cries of them that reaped” and offers heavenly compensation for their suffering, he does not advocate patiently waiting for a deity to restore social equality. Stevens’ Biblical commentary flows into his discussion of Sacco and Vanzetti, effectively letting the latter material serve as a reply to flaws he perceives in the Bible’s conciliatory perspective on socioeconomic discord: “‘You speak of preachers who talk of death. I want to tell you now about people who speak of life: and who are killed for speaking so’” (326). McClure learns from Stevens about two men (never actually named in the text) who both worked in a mill, though one of them later became a peddler of fish. They were people like you and me, though they were born in a country across the water, and could not speak our language very well. But they spoke in their own language, and part in our language to the poor. They spoke of life, and because they did the rich put them to death. (326)74
Stevens quotes for John a statement given by the two men—who had by then gathered worldwide attention and sympathy—just prior to their impending execution: This [the execution] is our career and triumph. Never in our full life could we hope to do such work for tolerance, for justice, for man’s understanding of man as now we do by accident. Our words—our lives—our pains—nothing. The taking of our lives, lives of a good shoemaker and a poor fish-peddler—all. That last moment belongs to us—that agony is our triumph. (327)
Next, Stevens reads a letter that Sacco had written to his fourteen-yearold son Dante after he knew that he was to be executed. This letter, and the story behind it, rivets John much as hearing Stevens sing his original labor song had earlier. The letter itself is powerful in its simple, lyrical tenderness: “So, Son, instead of crying, be strong, so as to be able to comfort your mother, and when you want to distract your mother from the discouraging soulness [sic], I will tell you what I used to do. To take her a long walking in the quiet country, gathering wild flowers here and there, resting under
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 101
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
102
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
the shade of trees” (TMMB 327). Sacco then imbeds an enjoinder for social altruism into this intimate family communication: But remember always, Dante, in the play of happiness, don’t use all for yourself only, but down yourself just one step, at your side, and help the weak ones that cry for help, help the persecuted and the victim, because they are your better friends: they are the comrades that fight and fall as your father and Bartol [Vanzetti] fought and fell yesterday for the conquest of the joy of freedom for all the poor workers. (TMMB 327)
As Stevens presents them to John, the repressive social forces dramatized by the execution of Sacco and Vanzetti both reinforce and refine the novel’s earlier suggestions that individuals can no longer escape society. There is no longer an untamed space to which the archetypal frontiersman or lone outlaw can retreat. In the context of this novel’s critique of traditional outlaw mentality, the idea that Sacco and Vanzetti were falsely charged with the outlawlike crimes of robbery and murder also suggests, ironically, that disseminating radical beliefs that threaten a capitalist status quo requires more willingness to assume risk than committing actual armed robbery does. In fact, the threat seemingly posed by Sacco and Vanzetti’s outspokenly radical ideologies (rather than the crimes they were charged with) almost certainly sealed their fates. Stevens explains this to McClure: “They spoke of life [a better life for the poor], and because they did the rich put them to death. The rich called them thieves and murderers. It was their excuse for murdering two innocent men” (326). Early on, the novel establishes that capitalism has already corrupted the socioeconomic autonomy of the most remote pockets of Appalachia, from which people like the McClures have felt compelled to migrate. Later, appropriating a stock ballad phrase, Stevens tells McClure that “I’ve traveled to the east and traveled to the west, as the ballad of John Hardy says. I have talked to many people, and with my eyes I’ve seen many things, curious, and some of them almost unbelievable. It’s the same everywhere” (312). Through the story of Sacco and Vanzetti, he further emphasizes that capitalism’s inescapable grip in America extends to all points of the compass: “‘I told you once,’ John Stevens said, ‘about workers being killed in the West. This [the execution of Sacco and Vanzetti] happened in the North. I could tell you many more stories of people being killed by the rich because they wanted something better’” (327). Lest John assume that such injustice is confined to the South, Stevens shows him that the North can repress individuals who threaten the capitalist system as effectively as the South can. That Sacco and Vanzetti had presumably come to America seeking opportunities that their Italian homeland had not been able
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 102
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
103
to provide further portrays antagonism between workers and capitalists as an international phenomenon. Within the communist value system that the novel establishes, Sacco and Vanzetti’s public stance towards their executions as a “triumph”—a spotlight on the unjust persecution of outspokenly anti-government workers— signifies a high order of valor. Even so, Stevens suggests, these are men whose political philosophies place them closer to nonviolent Biblical martyrs than to revolutionaries. Juxtaposing scripture with his own evaluation of Sacco and Vanzetti, Stevens comments, “‘Ye have condemned, ye have killed the righteous one: he doth not resist you.’ These men didn’t believe in resisting, but in just being good. And they were good” (327).75 To further distinguish between the concepts of individual martyrdom and collective revolution, Stevens tells John of what he considers the real “message”: “We are taught that to struggle is a sin. But it ain’t a sin, John. People must learn that. We must work in a strike, but there is something else. We must go beyond the strike to the message . . . that we must join with all others like us and take what is ours” (328). Significantly, when McClure expresses disbelief that a world where all share work and rewards equally is possible, Stevens cryptically replies that “it has been done, [ . . . ] though it isn’t yet finished” (328). He refers, of course, to Russia as an ongoing and apparently successful experiment in communism—an endorsement that may be seen as inviting comparison to the state of society in America, where workers like Sacco and Vanzetti are unfairly condemned, and others protest but lack the collective power to intervene.76 For John, the idea that God violently opposes the hoarding of wealth comes as a revelation when compared to what he has learned from milltown preachers who favor the well off. The knowledge that the organized state is capable of violently repressing people who criticize and threaten its status quo comes as another revelation surpassing the first in its implications for John’s radical development. These revelations are in turn surpassed by a third and final one (“the message”)—that workers in another country have successfully overthrown a repressive government through collective action. Soon after John learns of “the message,” he and other workers begin to organize a union, setting the gears in motion that will lead to a bloody confrontation with the mill management. During the novel’s climactic strike, Lumpkin’s characters personally model a commitment to revolt and sacrifice themselves within the context of an industrial struggle. McClure’s sister, Bonnie, is fatally shot, leading other strikers to surmise that the mill management had singled her out because of her attempts to bring black mill employees into the union. Her inadvertent sacrifice and its pivotal role in gaining public sympathy for
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 103
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
104
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
the strikers recalls the public effect of Sacco and Vanzetti’s execution.77 This sacrifice comes to infuse new meaning into her song about working-class hardships and hopes for a better life. Similarly, when John McClure encounters Sacco’s letter to his son, his knowledge that the writer’s personal convictions have cost him his life add considerably to the letter’s impact on him. Like Bonnie’s song, the “story” of Sacco and Vanzetti (particularly as reduced to a folk-like archetypal simplicity through Stevens’ retelling and selective quoting) becomes a persuasive text within the novel.78 That Lumpkin would have made the imaginative connection between the Sacco and Vanzetti case and events in Gastonia is not surprising. Following the actual Gastonia strike, when sixteen men and women variously affiliated with the strike faced the death penalty if convicted of first-degree murder in the fatal shooting of the local police chief, the Communist Party frequently compared the blatant disregard for due process in the earlier case with that of the current trial.79 In both cases, judges allowed the prosecution to question the defendants on their dissenting religious and political views. John Salmond reports that “the linking of the events unfolding in Gastonia with the execution of the two Italian anarchists, still a raw nerve among American liberals, was something the ILD [International Labor Defense] shrewdly played upon as the legal proceedings approached” (84). Lumpkin’s novel ends during the strike, on a hopeful note, and thus avoids the bleak outcome of this post-strike Gastonia trial, which ultimately resulted in second-degree murder convictions for seven of the original defendants (who then fled to Russia while out on bail). Nevertheless, Lumpkin’s allusion to Sacco and Vanzetti hints at the difficulties that lay ahead for the strikers. “A union they do fear”: Bonnie McClure’s contribution to the collective outlaw ideal Like her brother John, Bonnie inherits from her family what might be termed a “fighting spirit.” While Granpap and older brother Kirk provide John with influential models of masculine bravery, Emma provides Bonnie with a somewhat analogous feminine model. Emma’s influence may be seen in the unconventional assertiveness that Bonnie eventually develops in the intertwined realms of language and action. At one point during the novel’s mountain section, Emma literally uses a gun to enforce what she believes to be morally right. After her son Kirk brings his girlfriend Minnie to live in the McClure home, Emma is dismayed when a romantic rival to Kirk, Sam McEachern, begins coming to her home while Kirk is away
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 104
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
105
at a job. Galled by Sam’s long, flirtatious visits with Minnie, and trying to avert the violent showdown between Sam and Kirk that such a situation forebodes, Emma decides to take matters into her own hands. Picking up Granpap’s rifle, she orders Sam to leave and does not back down when he in turn points a revolver at her: “She did not flinch from Sam’s gun. If he shot her, he did. Her business was to get Sam away from the cabin” (105). Realizing that no one else will step in and do for her what she sees as necessary to her family’s well-being, Emma temporarily assumes a more traditionally masculine role. In a scene that recalls her mother’s behavior, Bonnie later summons the courage to speak out, and then act, against those with nominal authority over her. After many years as a docile, underpaid mill worker, Bonnie rebels against various stifling social norms. She verbally challenges a supervisor who demands that she give more priority to her mill job than her children. She befriends a black woman who works at the mill and later earns the spiteful title “nigger lover” (354) by promoting a racially integrated union in “Stumptown,” a black enclave outside of Leesburg. During the strike, Bonnie does not capitulate when the mill overseer’s wife, Mrs. Fayon, attempts to dissuade Bonnie and her aunt Ora from participating by appealing to Biblically inscribed gender beliefs: “‘People are talking about you two,’” Mrs. Fayon warns. “‘It’s getting around that you want t’ be like men. And people say the Bible says let women look to their houses and let men tend to the world’” (336). Bonnie must overcome further self-doubts about her entitlement to participate in the strike before she can feel able to perform an original song at a strike meeting: “She was very frightened. Later she became accustomed to the singing. But for the first few times she dreaded getting up before the people as she did now” (345). An ability to work creatively with language also plays a crucial role in the mental development that then enables Bonnie to physically fight repressive social circumstances. Earlier, this chapter highlighted examples of how Bonnie’s mother, Emma, used language creatively to revise a body of metaphorical images centering on her view of the factory labor system. Throughout the novel, Lumpkin suggests that Bonnie shares and learns from her mother’s ability to manipulate words creatively, frequently noting Bonnie’s attentive presence when her mother utters one of her “queer notions.” She shows Bonnie as a little girl not only easily memorizing the words to hymns, but also absorbing their “sing-song” quality (45) so that later she can find new words to fit their rousing cadences. Even as a young girl, Bonnie tinkers with language self-consciously. While falling asleep one night, she dreamily wonders what her first kiss will be like: “Half in
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 105
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
106
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
her sleep she made a silly little rhyme, ‘A smack on the cheek is better than to eat.’ The next moment she was ashamed of this thought and hid it far down in herself. The shame waked her up” (126–7). Perhaps Bonnie’s shame shows that she, like her mother, has internalized a belief that manipulating words is somehow slightly improper. Perhaps, though, this discomfort hints at a latent class consciousness, since Bonnie’s own experiences with poverty and hunger later will impart a new sense of the necessity of such basics as food in the scheme of human relationships. At a much later stage of maturity and responsibility, Bonnie, now a young mother working in the mill, finds that her ability to take apart and reassemble words has the capacity to deflate or undermine the language used to rationalize and enforce authority. In one such case, Bonnie, trying to hold down her mill job after having a baby, asks her boss if she can go home twice a day to nurse: From behind his desk Mr. Burnett looked at her in surprise. ‘Why, Bonnie!’ he said, and smiled at her as if she was a foolish child. ‘I’m willing t’ lose the money while the machines are idle, Mr. Burnett,’ she told him earnestly. ‘No,’ he said, ‘no, Bonnie. I can’t do it.’ When she urged her request he became very irritable. ‘If I let you,’ he said, ‘I’d have to let every other woman who’s got a young baby do the same. And there are plenty of babies in this village, Bonnie.’ ‘And plenty of them dies,’ Bonnie said to him. It was the first time she had said such a thing to anyone in a long time, and the first time she had spoken in that way to one of the higher-ups. She was frightened by her own words, and waited for days afterwards, watching for someone to come up, while she worked at the machines, lay his hand on her shoulder and say, ‘You can’t work here any more.’ (283–4)
As the emphasis on her subsequent fear of being fired shows, Bonnie recognizes that the nature of her rebuttal is likely to be a particular affront to her supervisor. Her pointed echoing of Mr. Burnett’s “plenty of babies” argument presumes a confrontation between equals rather than one between superior and employee. And, as Mr. Burnett no doubt realizes, Bonnie’s argument has a poetic and logical appeal that could easily spread among his employees.80 Some time after this episode, Bonnie again arrives at a small epiphany through language. Troubled after calculating that “‘the cloth I make for fifty cents is sold for six dollars’” (318), she asks her brother and John Stevens if they can shed light on this seeming discrepancy:
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 106
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
107
“Somewhere in between, hit seems that somebody makes five dollars and fifty cents.” “Well, it seems so,” John Stevens answered, looking at her and smiling a little. “But you see the owners, they figure that some money must be added to that cloth to pay for wear and tear on their machines and their buildings and such like.” “They pay themselves for wear and tear on the machines,” Bonnie spoke. “But hit seems I don’t get paid for wear and tear on myself.” She had spoken the words almost in fun, only trying to make a play with the words that John Stevens had spoken. But when she had said them she stopped short, for in those half playful words she felt that she had struck something that had been worrying her, some idea that had tugged at her while she worked, and at home. She saw John and John Stevens give each other a look of understanding. (319)
Partly through Stevens’ prompting, but more through her own proclivity to explore the rhythmic, poetic potential of language, Bonnie arrives unexpectedly at this unsettling insight. In such examples, Bonnie mostly reshapes her own conceptions of reality. When she writes a song that ends up becoming popular among her fellow strikers, however, her linguistic agility influences not only her personal consciousness, but also the collective consciousness of workers like herself. Part of the widespread appeal of Bonnie’s “Mill Mother’s Song” among workers no doubt stems from its use of terse, epigrammatic phrases similar to those Bonnie has created spontaneously in the earlier scenes discussed above. Despite its simple, accessible style, the song creates structural and situational parallels that have a compelling complexity. In the first verse, for instance, We leave our homes in the morning. We kiss our children good-by. While we slave for the bosses Our children scream and cry (345)
the grammatical (subject-verb) symmetry shared by each of the four lines helps to convey the way that home life and factory life are inextricably intertwined. At the same time, the repetitive quality of the first three lines (“we” followed by an action verb) draws attention to the new subject (“our children”) in the final line. The verse may also be conceived as two antithetical halves—the first
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 107
6/22/2006 8:54:31 AM
108
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
idyllic, the second dystopic. Similar rhetorical devices strengthen subsequent verses and lift them beyond the realm of ordinary speech. In addition to documenting shared family and labor experiences, Bonnie’s song appeals to communal values by tapping into and rewriting an earlier song that, Lumpkin suggests, was a staple of the local repertoire. Bonnie, teaching her song to the strikers, reminds them that “you all know the tune, for hit’s ‘Little Mary Fagan,’ [sic] so just listen to the words” (346). This simple reminder encompasses layers of shared experience and values that add potential depth to Bonnie’s song. The dramatic events recounted in “Little Mary Phagan” would have been well known to Bonnie’s audience (and probably to Lumpkin’s contemporary readers as well). On April 26, 1913, Mary Phagan, a girl nearing her fourteenth birthday who worked full-time at the National Pencil Factory in Atlanta, Georgia, had gone to her supervisor to collect a small sum owed to her. (This day, Confederate Memorial Day, was a workers holiday.) Some time later, she was found dead in the factory basement, having been brutally beaten and (it was widely believed) raped. Despite evidence suggesting his innocence, the factory’s supervisor and part owner, the Jewish Leo Frank, was charged with murder. Eventually, after a highly publicized (and sensationalized) investigation and trial, he was convicted and sentenced to death. After Frank’s lawyers took the case to the Supreme Court to no avail, John Slaton, Georgia’s outgoing governor, who had personal doubts about Frank’s guilt, commuted the death sentence to life in prison. Slaton’s decision met with widespread outrage and protests among many Southern whites of the working and elite classes alike. Eventually, a mob—determined to carry out the jury’s original death sentence—broke into the prison where Frank was held, took him, and lynched him. Regardless of whether Frank had in fact raped and murdered Phagan, various social tensions and prejudices within the South tended to predispose a large segment of the population to presume his guilt. At a time when the rise of industrialism in the South was ripping apart an earlier agrarian-based social fabric—a time when “southern nativism had risen sharply in response to an influx of South and East European immigrants” (McNeil 67)—Frank “as a Northerner, an industrialist, and a Jew represented everything alien to the culture” (Dinnerstein 32).81 For the masses of Southern factory workers, Mary Phagan’s murder seemed to confirm, in clearly readable signs, a priori perceptions of labor bosses’ exploitative power, particularly over young female employees. As folklorist Gene Wiggins observes, “at various levels of various consciences Mary Phagan was a symbol of all the mill girls who were being ravished and destroyed (though less literally) by the wealthy” (100).
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 108
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
109
During Frank’s trial, the ballad “Little Mary Phagan” appeared. The handiwork of Georgia mill worker and musician “Fiddlin’” John Carson, this folk-styled ballad drew upon both sentimental and graphically violent imagery to describe and comment upon the events surrounding Phagan’s death: Little Mary Phagan She went to town one day; She went to the pencil factory To get her little pay. She left her home at ‘leven. When she kissed her mother good bye, Not one time did the poor child think She was going there to die. Leo Frank met her With a brutely [sic] heart we know He smiled and said, “Little Mary, Now you go home no more.” [ . . . . ] She fell upon her knees, To Leo Frank she pled. Because she was virtuous He hit her across the head. The tears rolled down her rosy cheeks, The blood flowed down her back. She remembered telling her mother What time she would be back. [ . . . . ] I have a notion in my head When Frank come to die, He took examination In the courthouse in the sky. [ . . . . ] Come all of you good people, Wherever you may be, Supposing little Mary Belonged to you or me?
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 109
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
110
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” Her mother sits a weeping, She weeps and mourns all day. She prays to meet her baby In a better world some day. (qtd. in Wiggins 101–3)82
Apparently, this song’s perspective resonated favorably with working-class Southerners’ views, for it achieved great and lasting popularity. Wiggins reports that there were huge crowds in the vicinity of the Frank trial. John [Carson] had always liked crowds and sought to please them, partly for the sake of what they might drop in his hat. He played what they wished to hear. They wished to hear ‘Little Mary Phagan.’ He probably had no idea that his song was contributing to the feeling that led to the near-assassination of Governor Slaton and the final lynching of Leo Frank. (100)
On the day that Frank’s lynched body was discovered, Carson would also play his song (slightly updated to reflect this outcome) for the crowds that turned out—most in a spirit of triumph and celebration (Oney 571–2).83 As a song that workers immediately embraced and that soon gained folksong status as it spread orally throughout the South, “Little Mary Phagan” might be seen as approximating an aggregate working-class view of the Mary Phagan murder.84 Lumpkin uses the song as such when she shows Bonnie, as she teaches the strikers her new song, commenting that “‘you all know the tune, for hit’s ‘Little Mary Fagan’” (346). Although the novel itself does not provide further insights into the interrelationship of “Little Mary” and “Mill Mother” (or the respective events that they document), a contemporary reader likely would have recognized ways that these two narratives might comment upon each other. In decoding the political implications of the Phagan-Frank case within the context of Lumpkin’s novel, historian Nancy MacLean’s insights are helpful. MacLean characterizes the Phagan-Frank case as “a spectacular instance of a pattern of political mobilization best described as reactionary populism” (920). Instead of Phagan’s death serving as a progressive working-class rallying point for pushing toward lasting positive changes in the factory system, it offered a conservative justification for anti-Semitism and the institution of lynching: [A]lthough the case raised issues concerning the susceptibility of working-class women to economic and sexual exploitation that a radical labor or women’s movement might address, these issues were resolved in a thoroughly reactionary way. [ . . . . ] Anti-Semitism
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 110
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
111
[ . . . ] provided simple answers for the complicated questions of changing patterns of class power and female sexuality. Capitalism was a good social system, unless manipulated and deformed by Jews; young women were pure, asexual beings, unless lured into depravity by treacherous racial others. (942)
Given Lumpkin’s sensitivity throughout To Make My Bread to how education and experience could circumscribe working-class political perspectives, she probably sympathized with how Gastonia strikers would have recalled the Phagan-Frank case—less as a regrettable manifestation of racial intolerance against Frank than as a particularly egregious attack on a vulnerable young female worker by her powerful boss.85 At the same time, she surely viewed this template for resolving class tensions as regressive.86 Thus, her allusion to “Little Mary Phagan” is probably intended to contrast her characters’ strategies for dealing with labor exploitation with those employed during the Phagan-Frank episode and put them in a comparatively favorable light. When Bonnie reminds workers of the melodic source of the new song, she evokes not just the earlier lyrics, but also the whole earlier historical narrative as a gloss upon the new history that the strikers are in the process of creating. Likewise, Lumpkin’s novel brings the Phagan-Frank episode into dialogue with its own assumptions about how to resolve labor/class conflicts. By showing workers trying to build a new union, Lumpkin suggests a positive change in tactics for achieving working-class agency. Lumpkin’s workers do not align themselves with the sort of mob mentality that had allowed Frank’s lynching. Instead, they fight to overcome such reactionary behavior directed against them. Indeed, the use of terror tactics to suppress union activity in Gastonia by the so-called Committee of One-Hundred is akin to the lynching of Frank at the hands of masked men who had dubbed themselves the Knights of Mary Phagan. In the historical reality that Lumpkin’s novel reflects, this citizens’ vigilante group threatened to lynch Northern strike leaders and was responsible for, among other things, destroying the strikers’ headquarters and tent colony and murdering local leader Ella May Wiggins. The tactics of the Committee of One-Hundred, like those of the Knights of Mary Phagan, exemplify MacLean’s “reactionary populism” paradigm.87 In its use of the tune of “Little Mary Phagan,” then, Bonnie’s new union song reminds workers of a legacy of suffering at the hands of employers or others in positions of power. Further, it reminds them that the way this murder case had resolved itself (through lynching) more than a decade before had done nothing tangible to shift the overall balance of power in workers’ favor.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 111
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
112
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
As Lumpkin probably recognized, “Little Mary Phagan” is an especially apt parodic source for setting out a radical stance towards the mortality associated with labor exploitation. (New lyrics set to a conventional religious tune certainly would have carried a different symbolic weight.) In the earlier ballad, the murder might be seen as an extreme form of class exploitation (a powerful boss treating his young female employee as a disposable commodity).88 Although “Little Mary Phagan” depicts a literal and graphic murder—one collected version tells that Leo Frank “picked up a stick from the trash pile / And struck her on the head” (Frank 600)— Bonnie’s song reflects her own recent understanding that disregard for life can assume more subtle forms. Earlier in the novel, after Emma has died of pellagra, Bonnie’s brother John talks to John Stevens and is shocked when Stevens proclaims that “the mill owners killed [Emma]” (311). To Stevens, “the owners of the mill, and all those that get their money from the mills” (311) are liable for the poverty that caused her disease. For Bonnie, John, and other workers accustomed to hearing mill village preachers counsel that “rich and poor, we come to it just the same” (308), Stevens’ verdict offers a radical new way of visualizing the nature of poverty and suffering. According to Stevens’ logic, mill owners’ low wages contributed to the death of one of Bonnie’s children: after her baby dies of pneumonia, Bonnie realizes that she had failed to call a doctor in time to save her sick child because “thinking of the money involved [ . . . ] had held her back” (320). Compared to “Little Mary Phagan,” Bonnie’s song puts a progressive, collective slant on a conflict between workers and bosses. The first stanza of Bonnie’s ballad, which echoes “Little Mary Phagan” most literally, changes the model song’s foreshadowing of a particular murder into a more general foreshadowing of the consequences faced by families whose adults all must work for the mill: She left her home at ‘leven.
We leave our homes in the morning.
When she kissed her mother good-bye,
We kiss our children good-by
Not one time did the poor child think
While we slave for the bosses Our children scream and cry
That she was going to die.
(from “Mill Mother’s Lament”).
(from “Little Mary Phagan”)
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 112
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
113
Similarly, Bonnie’s song transforms the boss’s heartless treatment of a particular young female employee in “Little Mary” into a more general assertion that “for us nor them [workers’ children], dear workers, / The bosses do not care” (346). And while various versions of “Mary Phagan” (including Carson’s original) all appeal to the idea that a higher retribution will be meted out in the afterlife, Bonnie’s ballad proposes a more practical, earthly version of justice: But listen to me, workers: A union they do fear. Let’s stand together, workers, And have a union here. (346)89
“The fountain of inspiration remained dry as a desert”90 Lumpkin’s experiences prior to writing To Make My Bread (those discussed near the beginning of this chapter) offer insight into the resulting novel as a site for her re-envisioning Southern experience through a workingclass lens. As the following brief overview of her literary output following To Make My Bread will demonstrate, Lumpkin’s subsequent writings—in particular, several published in the early 1930s after To Make My Bread— also add retrospective depth to a portrait of a writer whose complex subjectivity eventually pulled her away from radicalism. In Some Take a Lover and Timid Woman—both released in 1933 under the pseudonym Ann Du Pre—Lumpkin explores middle- to upper-class concerns that are far removed from the working-class experiences documented in To Make My Bread. Perhaps inspired by Lumpkin’s own movement away from inherited values, both deal with young women who push the limits of what their families consider morally acceptable. Some Take a Lover is “a story of wealthy New Yorkers, the children and grandchildren of an old tyrant, Mrs. Singleton, who watches with cynical interest their extramarital intrigues, while holding over them the threat of disinheritance in her will. Only one of the group retains her grandmother’s respect, Natalie, who ‘lives in sin’ with a young artist but is loyal and faithful” (Book 274).91 A more compelling novel than Some Take a Lover, Timid Woman opens just before the “coming-out” party that will mark Ellen Guaillard—a “timid” eighteen-year-old from a conservative and respected Southern family—as eligible for courtship and marriage. Ellen remains single, however, and devotes herself to caring for family
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 113
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
114
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
members at home until the family’s financial decline forces her to look for outside work. Thus, at age thirty, she finds employment as a governess for the children of Alex Kingman, whose wife is in a sanitarium. Worried that people are gossiping about Ellen being alone in a house with a married man, her family pressures her to avoid further scandal and return home, where she can still earn money doing seamstress work: “all of them wished her to go back to that house, to spend her life sewing for other people, to live as a nun would live” (252). Ultimately disregarding her family’s concern for her reputation, Ellen decides to continue living with Kingman. Throughout, Timid Woman decries conservative society’s preoccupation with maintaining a “reputation” and sympathizes with Ellen’s aversion to such social restrictiveness. As a gloss upon Lumpkin’s proletarian stint, these two novels show that, amid producing stringently Marxist literature, Lumpkin still found the burdens peculiar to young women from a “respectable” class and social background worth writing about.92 While Ellen’s dilemmas in Timid Woman might seem trivial compared to the more dire survival issues faced by factory workers in To Make My Bread, Du Pre (Lumpkin) still grants that upper-class social conventions truly stifle self-realization for young women from “good” Southern families. As Katherine Du Pre Lumpkin’s portrayal of the Lumpkin family’s concern with social reputation in The Making of a Southerner suggests, Lumpkin daughters like Grace and Katherine grew up in a society closer to that delineated in Timid Woman than in To Make My Bread. And, as lack of money within a once relatively wealthy family provides the catalyst for Ellen’s modest liberation in Timid Woman, a similar decline in the Lumpkins’ resources seems to have provided Grace and Katherine with one incentive to gain financial (and ideological) independence from their more conservative family. To an extent, Lumpkin’s 1935 novel A Sign for Cain unites the explorations of working-class and upper-middle-class existence that were separated in To Make My Bread and the “Du Pre” novels, respectively. While To Make My Bread views the struggle to create a textile union almost entirely from the viewpoint of the working-class McClures, A Sign for Cain shows how the Communist Party’s attempt to start a racially integrated sharecroppers union in an unspecified Southern locale affects characters from diverse social and ideological backgrounds.93 In particular, the Marxist convictions behind this unionization effort are contrasted ironically with the reactionary values of a distinguished but declining Southern family headed by the aging Colonel Gault. To suggest just a few of the complex ways that the unionization effort penetrates into the intertwined lives of characters across the social spectrum,
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 114
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
115
Bill Duncan, a liberal newspaper editor and Communist sympathizer, is a distant cousin of the Gaults. Denis Gault, a young black Communist who has returned from the North to secretly lay the groundwork for this union, is the son of Nancy, a servant in the Gault home. Colonel Gault’s daughter Caroline, a novelist in New York City, is Bill Duncan’s friend, though she scoffs at his radical opinions on art and society. She wants to create meaningful art, but is too ensconced in her comfortable class position to recognize her relationship to the class struggle in her native South. By uttering naïve opinions about the apolitical nature of art, she functions primarily as the novel’s foil for its own more radical aesthetic: “What have I to do with class struggles? The class I belong to is fixed, a class of cultured people all over the world. I am above struggles” (178). Ironically, in the decades following the publication of Cain, Lumpkin herself would adopt an apolitical perspective toward art reminiscent of that satirically voiced in the fictional Caroline Gault’s comment above. Her recollections in a short 1977 essay suggest that she became unable to continue writing from a class perspective so unlike her own. She describes the sudden inspiration for her next novel, The Wedding, as coming at a time when, with two proletarian-inspired novels behind her, she felt “distressed because the fountain of inspiration remained dry as a desert” (321). This novel marked a permanent departure from the proletarian themes that had shaped her earlier literary career.94 A 1951 manuscript for a play entitled “Remember Now” illustrates Lumpkin’s complete rejection of her earlier novels’ insistence that communist society would give individuals greater freedom for self-realization.95 An argument between two allegorically named characters—the now-repentant former radical Virginia and the adamantly communist Karl—is a case in point.96 In her parting words to Karl, Virginia decries what Karl has called the “social gospel”—a belief that society must impose limits on individual freedom in order to ensure social equality. In Virginia’s view, Karl’s communism enforces caring for the poor, and thus destroys what she believes is a more natural human tendency to care selectively and voluntarily for the poor within a small social sphere. Virginia accuses Karl of “[not caring] about the poor and oppressed. You hand your responsibility for them over to the State. [. . . . ] It is what I had been doing. Not caring any more—not being personally responsible—personally, individually responsible” (127). Virginia grounds her anti-communism in a belief that “[God] has planted in each one the love of liberty. That is the greatest gift. Freedom is not a legislated thing” (128). She tells Karl that his “plan for the world” “will die” because it denies a belief in a higher supernatural force controlling
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 115
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
116
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
human destiny: “How can you create when you have cut yourself off from the Creator?” (128). Later in her life, Lumpkin developed social views that were even more fatalistic and opposed to the belief in a human capacity to develop more equitable social structures. In a 1971 letter to Kenneth Toombs, the Director of Libraries at the University of South Carolina, she remarked that there is only one conclusion: The World cannot be saved. There is no Utopia. Human nature is human nature and there are only two eternal verities: God’s nature and Human nature—and these will never change, and they never have changed. The nature of God—The nature of man. There is no help for the world except as a country’s FRAME OF REFERENCE is God, and as an individual finds God and acknowledges Him as his FRAME OF REFERENCE against which he sets any happening either political or personal that might puzzle or challenge him, in order to find wisdom and Truth.
Then, as if suddenly recognizing the degree to which these notions subverted her own more important literary legacy—indeed, the main basis for establishing a repository of her papers at USC—she added, “NOTE: Please excuse me from ‘preaching.’ I got started and couldn’t stop, and won’t do the letter over because I want to get it out on the next mail.”
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 116
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
Chapter Three
“Nothing Is Right, but Everything Is Going to Be”: Pre- and Post-Revolutionary Culture in Olive Tilford Dargan’s Call Home the Heart and A Stone Came Rolling
Near the end of Olive Tilford Dargan’s Call Home the Heart (1932), Amos Freer, a communist union organizer, quotes a “maxim that we workers are so fond of. ‘Life without labor is robbery; labor without art is barbarity’” (366). The implications of Freer’s maxim are explored from numerous angles in Call Home the Heart and its sequel A Stone Came Rolling (1935). This maxim speaks to Dargan’s sense of the current dystopic reality of economic and cultural life under a floundering capital-driven labor system. Further, it anticipates what she envisioned as a more utopian life and culture within a socialist state that would distribute the burdens and benefits of labor equally.1 Throughout these two novels, as Dargan depicts her characters’ production of and engagement with culture within various socioeconomic contexts, she repeatedly finds the current economic system guilty of both robbery (“life without labor”) and barbarity (“labor without art”). Like her character Freer, Dargan envisions a socialist utopia that would give members equal opportunity to develop their artistic potentials. Drawing on each individual’s expressive gifts, humanity would experience an artistic flowering surpassing that of all previous historical epochs. Culminating with close analysis of Call Home the Heart and A Stone Came Rolling, this chapter will explore Dargan’s convictions related to various aspects of culture in what she saw as a pre-revolutionary, dystopic reality, and in what she envisioned as a post-revolutionary utopia. Through additional insights from extant biographical, extra-literary, and supplemental literary resources, it will also explore how these convictions grew out of her family background and life experiences, her earlier work as 117
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 117
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
118
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
a creative artist, and her Marxist-informed interpretation of America’s economic, social, and cultural dynamics. It will explore the many reasons why, in light of her sense of these dynamics, Dargan felt (to cite another Marxist-inflected maxim incorporated into Call Home the Heart) that “nothing is right, but everything is going to be” (296). Whereas Myra Page and Grace Lumpkin were in their early thirties when they wrote Gastonia-inspired novels, Olive Tilford Dargan was already 63 years old. She had been publishing plays, poems, and short stories for almost three decades when she debuted (under the pseudonym Fielding Burke) as a radical novelist with Call Home the Heart. Like Page and Lumpkin, Dargan was middle-class and well educated. Unlike her working-class protagonists, she did not experience leaving a mountain culture and becoming reliant on an exploitative factory system for survival. From what basis, then, did she know the cultural backgrounds of people who left the Appalachian Mountains to seek millwork in towns like Gastonia? What values did she ascribe to Appalachian culture, which existed in relative isolation and stasis even while providing a steady stream of labor for industry that was rapidly evolving due to technological advances? What path of life experiences caused her to ally herself with industrial workers? What factors contributed to her novels’ particular stances towards culture and labor within this rural/ industrial dialectic? How did a longtime desire for social reform develop into a Marxist vision of revolutionary reform? Family background; education and intellectual life; relationships with mountaineers, factory workers, and activists; encounters with folk and high culture, and with primitive and sophisticated modes of production—all these experiences left an imprint on Dargan’s political and artistic convictions and informed the vantage point from which authoring these novels was possible.2 Dargan’s inherited family values and the experiences she garnered moving through life shaped a perspective from which she, as a writer, could inhabit a somewhat ambiguous class position. Though her roots were rural, she eventually moved within urban intellectual circles and traveled abroad. Though she was more economically privileged than many of the subjects of her socially-conscious writing, she also struggled to earn a living. And though she possessed keenly developed aesthetic and literary sensibilities, she was also sensitive to the economic factors that prevented large segments of her society from developing or sharing in these sensibilities. Dargan was born on a Kentucky farm in 1869 to schoolteacher parents who “encouraged self-reliance and political awareness in their four children” (Shannon 434).3 Though her immediate family did not provide an explicit role model for the socially conscious writer Dargan would become, various members likely nurtured
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 118
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
119
aspects of Dargan’s artistic identity. She drew inspiration from grandmothers who were both “colorful frontier storytellers” (Shannon 434) and from her maternal grandfather, Mordecai Day, who “preached that slavery was an abomination before the Lord, displaying courage for social justice” (Lathrop 4). Family circumstances pushed Dargan to assume considerable responsibilities at a relatively young age. Because of her mother’s poor health, Olive began to school herself to take her mother’s place as a teacher, assisting her father in his academy until she was fourteen, and then taking independent charge of a school nearby. Here, despite the difficulties of a rowdy class that had defeated her male predecessor, Dargan managed to instruct her thirty to forty students, who ranged in age from six to twenty, in all subjects and through all grades. She also earned their respect and that of their parents. (Shannon 434–5)
She attended Peabody University in Nashville, Tennessee, on scholarship, graduating in 1888 after two years of study. She then taught in various locations, including at a business school in Houston, Texas. Later, she spent a year at Radcliffe College in Cambridge, Massachusetts, where she studied “English, French, Economics and Philosophy, the two latter her favorite subjects” (Lathrop 6).4 Here, Shannon speculates, “it seems probable that she traced the most enduring and influential of her political friendships to the lectures and parlor meetings she attended [ . . . ] in 1893 and 1894” (435). Following her time at Radcliffe, Dargan briefly resumed teaching, then married Pegram Dargan. Olive had met Pegram, “a minister’s son from South Carolina [ . . . ] who thought himself a poet” (Shannon 435), in Boston several years earlier. When the couple moved to New York City to pursue writing careers, Olive found much greater literary success than her husband, publishing numerous poems in respected periodicals and receiving critical acclaim for her plays (Shannon 435–6).5 During a college camping trip, Dargan had first visited the North Carolina mountains that would later inspire much of her literary output. She vowed that “if I ever own a home of my own, it will be in these mountains” (Brosi). Indeed, much later, in 1906, after selling the stage rights to one of her dramas, she and her husband were able to “make a down payment on 1,000 acres of barely accessible land, a ridge called Round Top, near Almond, North Carolina” (Neufeld 270).6 With a modest literary reputation behind her, she published nothing during the next six years while living there, and she seems to have been frustrated that the duties expected of her as a wife impinged on her literary ambitions (Shannon 436).7 After living
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 119
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
120
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
for several years in England apart from her husband, she returned to her mountain farm in 1916 as a widow—Pegram had drowned at sea the previous year.8 She lived there for the next nine years, intimately involved with the farm and the tenant family who shared and helped run it. During this time, she published a co-authored collection of dramas (1922); a collection of poetry, Lute and Furrow (1922); and a number of short stories based on interactions with her mountain neighbors, which first appeared in magazines and were later collected as Highland Annals (1925). Although, as Shannon notes, “she purchased a house in Asheville [North Carolina] in 1925 in order to spend the winters in relative comfort and safety” (439), she continued to spend considerable time attending to and living on her farm over the next several decades.9 Spanning all the years discussed above, Dargan treasured a friendship, begun during her Radcliffe days, that had influenced her political development. The friend was Rose Pastor Stokes (1879–1933), who became a prominent member of the Socialist Party of America and, later, of the Communist Party.10 In the decades following Dargan’s brief time in New York City, the two friends corresponded extensively. They occasionally managed to spend time together, though Dargan would spend the majority of her time living in isolated Almond, North Carolina, while Rose remained far more politically active “in the world of the Lower East Side” (Rosenbaum 1342). In 1907, Dargan spent a particularly formative period with Rose. Pregnant and separated from her husband, she traveled from her North Carolina cabin to the “Stokes family compound on Caritas Island off the coast of Stamford, Connecticut” (Ackerman 19) and there gave birth to a daughter who died within 24 hours. (She had no other children.) Dargan stayed several more months with the Stokes family, “reading heavily in socialism and beginning to crystallize her own political philosophy” (Ackerman 22). “Half the things that must be done are greater than our art”: Dargan’s pre-1930s poetry The poetry that Dargan wrote during the 1910s and 1920s while living on her mountain farm, in the period before her output of radical prose, has been long out of print and critically ignored. Granted, her poetic form and diction on occasion bows with excessive devotion to fairly elaborate rhyme schemes and what Shannon calls “‘ladylike’ obscurity and high flown language” (436).11 Nevertheless, many of Dargan’s poems are compelling, both intrinsically and because they delve into aesthetic and political issues explored more deeply in her radical fiction.12 As a record of
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 120
6/22/2006 8:54:32 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
121
Dargan’s emerging aesthetic and political values, this poetry sheds light on certain narrative choices in her radical fiction. It offers insight, for instance, into why Dargan gives the fictional protagonist of Call Home the Heart and A Stone Came Rolling certain intellectual and emotional traits she may have seen in herself and yet takes care to show that, unlike herself, this protagonist has virtually no artistic inclinations. Dargan’s poetry, because it critiques the role of poetry (and other art) as a force related to and capable of influencing sociopolitical realities, further suggests one reason why her radical novels generally assign culture a low to modest value in effecting social reform (though, ironically, her novels themselves aspire to such a role). As her poetry and stories make clear, Dargan’s engagement with her adopted mountain community—her participation in local cycles of physical work and leisure, and her friendships with local people—shaped her self-identity. At the same time, she recognized that the writerly side of this identity—the aspect that looked at experience with a literary eye and sought leisure time to craft that experience into poems and stories—implied economic priorities and cultural values different from those commonly shared by her rural neighbors.13 Dargan’s most compelling poems explore the tension between these two aspects of identity. As a late work from the period preceding Dargan’s radical novels, the poetry volume Lute and Furrow (1922) contains several poems—including the title piece—that self-consciously meditate on the potential conflicts between the desire to produce art and the need to do physical work. In its very title, “Lute and Furrow” juxtaposes a symbol of creative art with a symbol of practical survival. The poem’s speaker (clearly reflective of Dargan) feels the call of both, but must attend to the cyclical demands of farming before nurturing artistic desires. The poem moves twice, in four sections, through a winter-to-spring cycle, showing the farmer-artist planning, in a brief wintertime respite from physical work, to “take up my pen and once more / Meet that stranger, my soul” (3). The speaker anticipates now having time to reconnect with the world of literature. She will read leisurely and write “all the poems with beauty half-hid, / Yet touching my haste like a rose” (6). Ironically, this initial desire to release pent-up creative urges soon changes into “the doubt that deadens the dawn.” This doubt finds eventual release not through art, but through returning the next spring to physical labor on the land. Just when the speaker has “almost grasp[ed] the pen,” a fellow farmer, Len, announces that “Winter’s broke”: “Ain’t no time now for foolin,’ we got to start the ploughs” (7). Though the speaker may regret setting aside her creative pursuits, she nevertheless exults that “there is no doubting, no ghosts uncertain stalk / [ . . . ] / Cutting the furrow deep and true where Destiny will walk” (5). Performing physical
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 121
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
122
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
work on familiar land—“when half the things that must be done are greater than our art, / And half the things that must be done are smaller than our heart” (5)—resolves the doubts of doing artistic work in uncharted territory. As Terry Eagleton observes, “literary production and consumption presuppose certain levels of literacy, physical and mental well-being, leisure and material affluence: the material conditions for writing and reading include economic resources, shelter, lighting and privacy” (Criticism 49). If a society’s economic mode of production causes certain members to experience “such phenomena as poverty, physical and mental debility consequent on prolonged and intensive labour, illiteracy or partial literacy, lack of sufficient shelter, privacy and lighting,” then this economic basis effectively “exclude[s] or partially exclude[s] certain social groups and classes from literary production and consumption” (50). Eagleton’s observations speak to a clear irony in the plight of the speaker in “Lute and Furrow.” She feels creatively limited by labor (compromised by factors such as Eagleton has delineated) and yet, in articulating this feeling, actually creates a sophisticated and aesthetically pleasing artifact. She thus possesses the creative means to bridge a fundamental experiential gap between her own posited subject-position and that of readers who may have greater access to education and leisure. While the poem’s internal language problematizes the relationship between manual labor and art, the very material fact of the poem’s existence suggests that labor may fuel as well as smother internal artistic fires.14 In “Sall’s Gap,” another poem from Lute and Furrow, the poet comes to recognize her own race and class privileges. Her aesthetic perceptions of her surroundings potentially obscure the way others differently situated with regards to such privilege may value the same place. Hiking in a secluded gap, she rhapsodizes—in a series of meticulously rhymed seven-line stanzas— about the sublime natural beauty around her.15 Her delight at finding the source of a spring—“the mossy parting / Where a mountain rillet breaks into the light” (43)—is soiled, however, when she follows the stream back down into the valley and there learns that locals simply call the stream and valley “Sall’s branch” and “Sall’s gap.” Initially, she fancies that the stream deserves a more poetic name, believing that “the world from bondage could not be delivered / While men were dead to Beauty; gross, unloving / To all her gifts” (45). Later, however, she learns the story behind the name “Sall’s Gap” from “the wise man of the hill” who “knew the mountains and their lore” (46). Pointedly, he asks her if she would die for the beauty she claims to cherish. He then tells her of Sall, a Cherokee woman who, when the U.S. government forced her tribe to migrate, “begged leave to die where every wild thing knew her, / And every tree and green thing nodded to her” (47). To avoid capture,
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 122
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
123
she “hid and starved one long white winter through” (47) and eventually killed herself rather than submit. Through this story, the poet sees the triviality of her own aesthetic concerns and the presumptuousness of her claim that “men were dead to Beauty” (45). Further, she realizes that her petty desire to change the name of Sall’s Gap would have erased one small reminder of the Cherokee tribe’s dispossession of this land—a political reality which, ironically, enables her very access to and possessiveness of this spring: “I slipped away not speaking. / She starved. And I, had I not somewhat yearned / For supper coming down? Trespasser peeking! / . . . / Sall’s gap? Sall’s brook? So may they ever be! / I set this down for meddlers likest me” (48). Despite (or even because of ) its seemingly conventional poetic values—its lavish evocations of natural beauty and virtuoso adherence to a particular stanza pattern—this poem manages to suggest complex and unsettling implications for the author, for the reader, and for such poetry itself. The poem leaves readers wondering how the poet’s art might change after the mountain man’s story has troubled her aesthetic principles. If the poet sincerely takes to heart the lesson she “sets down” for herself and other poetic “meddlers,” she must become more vigilant about the lure of self-indulgent verse. Readers who have just imbibed the sensual delights of the poem’s opening stanzas now are forced along with the poet to rethink the aestheticizing language through which they first naively accessed this world of natural beauty.16 Other poems in Lute and Furrow further dramatize tension between artistic form and content, between the meticulously crafted verse forms the poet has favored and the gritty realities she now feels compelled to document. In “Pace Tua” (Latin for “by your leave”), Dargan uses an uncharacteristically rambling free verse to muse on several artifacts in her writing room, including a photograph bequeathed by an artist “starving for Paris” (“O God, / Have I got to go to Paris this morning?”), and a bowl from “a young Indian” who “made it and sold it for fifty cents” (“God bless him, I could think of him all day!”) (85). Her last rumination—on a rug made by Granny Whitt, “who sheep-hunted all over these hills / Till she was eighty-two”—strays far afield from the artifact that initiated it. Granny Whitt’s daughter, Zinnia, had “married a half-breed Cherokee” who “was jealous of a white man; / Hid in the laurel, and shot him; / Cut out his eyes and brought them to Zinnia. / She lived two weeks, and left twins an hour old. / They hung him [the Cherokee], under a bridge” (87). Just as the poet seems about to launch into a story about these twins, who are “big enough now / To climb the long hill from Granny Whitt’s / And play in my yard,” she apologetically cuts herself off: “One day—Narrative, narrative! / Shall I slop into your easy path, / And trickle on? / . . . / There’s a garnet in this poem, / If you go after it with a
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 123
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
124
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
dredge” (88). This by-your-leave apology, even if disingenuous, assumes that readers turn to poetry seeking the linguistic equivalents of polished gems (“garnets”), not messy narratives that refuse to resolve themselves or yield a meaning within the confines of a short symmetrical verse form. Like “Lute and Furrow” and “Sall’s Gap,” “Pace Tua” ends up critiquing the very motivations that produced it, although it begins with the poet waking up intending to write, thinking that “I had cleared everything out of my room, / So that my mind, catching on nothing, / Would go sailing in a clear sky” (85). A bare room presumably would have helped the poet to enter a more abstract, philosophical mindset, untroubled by thoughts about specific people in her immediate surroundings. Readers can only wonder what quality of poem might have resulted from a bare room, since she has not fully cleaned out the room (at least the photograph, bowl, and rug remain). Ironically, these items, not a clear sky, end up generating the poem. Challenging the genteel notion that a poem should be gemlike in form and meaning, Dargan creates an ambiguous story and instructs readers to do their own sifting. Readers must find what is beautiful, or at least precious because it evokes an image of life that reflects its actual complexity rather than forcing life’s conflicts into a simplistic artistic resolution. Poetry such as this is a way—just one of many, of course—of creatively engaging with experience. All such art coming from another’s subject-position offers an interpretation of experience with various degrees of verisimilitude to readers’ own experiential knowledge. After engaging with another’s art, readers’ fragmentary understanding of the world may then seem more or less satisfactory, whole, or comprehensible. As suggested in the readings of the poems above, Dargan recognized a potential conflict between an impulse to create aesthetically pleasing art and an impulse to convey social realities—realities that her poetic style might tend to obscure.17 How could she, for instance, create a beautiful poem that truthfully showed how physically demanding agricultural work may stunt artistic/spiritual growth (“Lute and Furrow”)? Or a poem celebrating a hike through beautiful mountains from which whole Indian tribes were forced to leave (“Sall’s Gap”)? Or a neat moral resolution to the story of the “half-breed” Cherokee man’s hanging (“Pace Tua”)? “With conscientious abandon”: Dargan’s short story “Serena Takes a Boarder” Like the poems discussed above, the stories that comprise Dargan’s 1925 Highland Annals are filtered through a first-person narrator (here, named
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 124
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
125
Miss Dolly) whose cultural/aesthetic values mark her as middle-class, highly literate, and thus substantially different from her rural neighbors.18 Compared to the above poetry, however, these stories more easily accommodate rural characters’ experiences and colloquial voices. Because they are less constrained by the formal and aesthetic expectations that governed Dargan’s poetic style, they likewise show less anxiety that literary impulses might distort working-class experiences. Nevertheless, Dargan still frequently highlights the disparity in outlook between herself (a relatively privileged writer) and her neighbors (predominantly subsistence farmers). In these stories, conflicts often arise when Miss Dolly acts on hasty or condescending assumptions about her neighbors’ cultural practices or aesthetic values. Resolution comes through discovering that neighbors’ seemingly irrational or “backwards” attitudes and behaviors are in fact sensible adaptations to their material conditions.19 The story “Serena Takes a Boarder” provides the most dramatic example of the narrator misunderstanding her neighbors’ cultural values, showing the consequences when she tries to reform a mountain woman’s attitude towards work under the assumption that this reform will bring her family greater satisfaction. This story—which Elfenbein calls “a powerful indictment of the American work ethic” (xlvii)—sheds intriguing light on the ambivalence in Dargan’s later radical novels towards primitive subsistence agriculture, a central aspect of life for the Appalachian families in Dargan’s fiction. The story focuses on the relationship between Miss Dolly and the Merlins, a large tenant family on her mountain farm. Although Miss Dolly is on good terms with the family, she secretly feels that the Merlins suffer under mother Serena’s good-natured indifference to housekeeping. She chides Serena—about whom she comments that “work one day and rest six was her version of the great example [the work ethic]” (193)—to stop frittering away her time on impractical pursuits, particularly trying to keep tabs on her freeroaming ducks.20 Initially, after shaming Serena into growing a garden, cooking healthier and more appealing food, and attending to other domestic duties like sewing, washing, and canning food, Miss Dolly delights that Serena’s efforts are yielding a better fed and dressed family. After several months, however, she questions having pressured the easygoing mother into this more conscientious and industrious role, sensing that her intervention has upset the community’s delicate cultural equilibrium: “happiness had fled the mountain” (199). Other local people had always overlooked the dirt and humble food and welcomed an evening with Serena and husband Len—cherished “reservoirs of mountain song and story” (187). Now, visitors have stopped
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 125
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
126
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
coming to the house. Serena no longer drops by to help Miss Dolly with small tasks. Serena’s husband complains to Miss Dolly that “they ain’t any satisfaction in livin’” since his wife began putting all her energy into housekeeping (203). He had married Serena knowing she “wuz like her father,” a man who did minimal work but was well loved: “he’d make a big fire an’ set an’ tell the masterest tales so long as they wuz anybody to drap in an’ listen, an’ when they wuzn’t he’d jest set an’ sing. He couldn’t read a book-word, but he knowed ever’ song from Noher [Noah] down” (205). The Serena who carried on her father’s communal role withers when Miss Dolly tries to cultivate her work ethic.21 After Serena tells Miss Dolly that she’s given up the attempt at domestic reform, Miss Dolly stops promoting industry and accepts the return of Serena’s former carelessness: “[Serena’s] factitious disguise of the past twelve months had dropped utterly away. She assumed my acquiescence and received it. Her utmost effort had been given, and my way had proved a failure. Therefore her own was better, and she returned to it with conscientious abandon” (212). As before, the family looks underfed but content, Serena drops by to help Miss Dolly, and the steady “stream of company” (214) resumes. Miss Dolly’s initial faith that hard work leads to prosperity, and prosperity to happiness, informs her desire to intervene in this family’s lifestyle. From observations and, to a degree, physical experience, she had known that the mountain environment requires intense labor to achieve even a semblance of middle-class material comfort. She had not, however, adequately considered the less tangible losses that a family like Serena’s might incur in pursuit of material well-being. In a surprising reversal of her earlier stance, Miss Dolly resigns herself to the fact that Serena’s sickly youngest child “might die of malnutrition, but tragedy—is it not the commonplace of life? And happiness the rare fortune?” (212–3).22 Revising this story for the 1941 edition (From My Highest Hill), Dargan added a significant paragraph that further justifies Serena’s carefree approach to life by showing that the local economy’s new outlets for industriousness are as creatively stifling as the kind of domestic drudgery Serena shuns. When Serena tells Miss Dolly that she’s quit trying to be a model housekeeper, Miss Dolly at first argues that she should “think of the future you are making for yourself ” (170). Serena vehemently replies, “Future! That’s what I am thinkin’ of ” (170). To explain, she tells Miss Dolly of Aunt Ann and Uncle Jimmie, an elderly couple who “found out they could make fifty cents a day workin’ ever’ minute makin’ chairs fer that shop on the highway to sell.” Now, this couple “won’t take time to look up at
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 126
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
127
you passin.’ [. . . . ] An’ oncet they was the jokin’est old folks anywheres” (170). Serena would rather emulate “Uncle Abe an’ Aunt Mary Walker. He’s eighty-two, an’ don’t wear nothin’ but patches, an she’s up in seventy, but when they come in from the field fer dinner, like as not she’ll grab her guitar an’ he’ll do a shuffle. [. . . . ] Nobody ever goes to their house at the wrong time” (170). Dargan’s text seems to endorse Serena’s viewpoint, as do several photographs in this new edition that match Serena’s descriptions of these contrasting couples.23 Two of these photographs show a neatly dressed Aunt Ann and Uncle Jimmy absorbed in weaving seats and backs for wooden chairs. Captions remind readers that the couple is too busy to “look at you in passin,’” and that “If Aunt Ann looks up she does it sly” (photos after 192). A contrasting photo on the same page shows Aunt Mary and Uncle Abe, she playing guitar, he dancing, and both looking happy despite their ragged clothes, neglected house, and yard crowded with trampled weeds and vines. The caption reads, “Nobody ever goes to their house at the wrong time” (photos after 192). For Dargan (as well as Serena), the former couple seems to epitomize how an obsession with material gain can compromise personal happiness and communal well-being. Aunt Ann and Uncle Jimmy, who had once enriched the community through their fun-loving natures, now hardly take time to “look up at you passin.’” In contrast, Mary and Abe find joy in life despite their poverty and share that joy with anyone who stops by. In another telling aside (included in both the story’s original and revised versions), the narrator links the Merlins’ poverty to this society’s primitive economic base. This poverty is less the product of a mother’s aversion to household “industry” and more the absence of any semblance of modern industrial trends: Serena’s “lifelong acceptance of things as they happened had kept her unaware of the complexities of an occupation made up of a jumble of industries, as farm life must ever be until the ferment of organization begins to heave effectively in the mind of the last individual, the man on the land” (194). Until farming becomes less labor intensive and more productive, Dargan implies, these people do not have an economic goal worth sacrificing their leisure for. In this economic context, the Merlin family’s acceptance of poverty becomes more understandable—perhaps even noble—as does Serena’s determination not to let ceaseless labor erode her generous and “serene” nature. Significantly, the nonmaterial aspirations and the prioritizing of community over self and family that the Merlins intuitively exemplify and embrace (and that Miss Dolly as naïve narrator comes to appreciate) in “Serena Takes a Boarder” anticipate ideologies that Dargan’s later radical novels envision in the scope of labor solidarity and post-revolutionary socialist society. That
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 127
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
128
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
Serena’s family, despite poverty and even malnutrition, freely share songs, stories, and material resources within their community provides a striking indication of preexisting cultural values primed to embrace a more advanced and far-reaching socialist mentality. While this story suggests merely in passing that the “ferment of organization” might increase leisure time and material comfort for families like Serena’s, Dargan’s later radical novels foreground the idea of ferment as a necessary precursor to a higher level of stability. In these novels, the hint in “Serena” that organized labor and technology would benefit mountain culture becomes an extensive exploration of how socialism would benefit all sociocultural groups—working and middle class, rural and industrial.24 And while the poems discussed earlier centralized middle-class artists’ concerns—the artist’s search for a balance between art and physical labor, between aesthetic beauty and social truth—Dargan’s first two radical novels centralize working-class dilemmas, subsuming aesthetic concerns within a broader concern for how cultural expression influences ideological and socioeconomic progress. Where Dargan’s poetry fretted, her novels now insist: The aestheticizing impulse behind art must not compromise social truth. Artists must adopt an appropriately political stance towards subject matter. Art must not merely contemplate problems, but propose solutions. Consistent with these shifts in emphasis, Dargan moves away from the “I” of her poetry and of Highland Annals (both examples of first-person outlooks that seem consistent with Dargan’s own aesthetic and political sensibilities). In its place, she uses a third-person narrative that centers primarily on the consciousness of Ishma, a female character whose roots in working-class Appalachian mountain culture Dargan herself lacked. “I’m only a half and half. You’ll be the whole thing”: Call Home the Heart and A Stone Came Rolling Old personal frustrations (how to effectively realize her activist impulses in a rural environment) as well as new historical developments contributed to the dramatic shifts in artistic direction suggested above. Throughout the decades when (as the stories like “Serena” would have it) she lived the role of “Miss Dolly” to her tenants and neighbors, Dargan was to struggle with a feeling that life on her North Carolina farm, and later in Asheville, had isolated her from the path of activism that friends like Rose Pastor Stokes had taken: [Dargan’s] friendship with Rose had made her a fellow traveler of the Communist party, a sympathy not expressed in action but in understanding and words of encouragement to Rose. She recognized that
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 128
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
129
rural Almond, North Carolina, and even urban Asheville, could be a fatal setting for a lone radical sympathizer flaunting her views. Her humanitarian instincts drove her to help any family member or neighbor who needed help. She felt the need to apologize to Rose for trying to help people one at a time rather than being part of a mass movement to bring a better future for all. (Zipser 277)
When, in April of 1929, the Communist-led National Textile Workers Union instigated a strike in Gastonia, North Carolina, a scene of radical activity moved enticingly close to Dargan’s rural doorstep. Undoubtedly inspired and emboldened by her connection to Stokes, Dargan traveled the one hundred miles that separated Asheville [where she then lived] and Gastonia and fraternized with the strikers. In the last week of April Olive asked Rose to write to the Gastonia headquarters of the textile union and tell them that Olive ‘can be absolutely depended on . . . I have met many of the strikers and it is not necessary for me to go in and out of the union Headquarters, but I’d like to—and they have to be so careful. I’m stamped ‘middle class’ all over you know and they must guard against treachery. But the strikers like me and make me feel blood-kin—bless their weary bones! If you write, dear, sign as R.P.S.—the name they know.’ (Zipser 277–8 ellipses in original)
Going to Gastonia inspired Dargan at a point when she had “decided to write no more. Writing poetry was, she felt, ‘indulging myself,’ and prose was not her medium. But her presence during the tragedy of the Gastonia strike changed her mind” (Polsky 4). Back in Asheville, as Dargan worked on the novel that would become Call Home the Heart, Stokes’ political orientation continued to guide her. Near the end of the process, she anxiously wrote Stokes that “there are two chapters unfinished, that you must censor or approve. I can’t send the book out until you have said yea” (qtd. in Zipser 281). Almost certainly, Dargan refers to the politically unorthodox way that the published novel actually ends—with its protagonist abandoning the strike (after a shockingly racist outburst) and returning to the mountains. Though Stokes presumably approved, Dargan continued to worry about how more dogmatic Communist Party members would receive her novel.25 Thus, she asked her prominent friend Alice Stone Blackwell to send a “few lines” to her publisher, “telling them what you think of the book” (27 July 1932). As she told Blackwell, she expected that Call Home the Heart would
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 129
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
130
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand” come in for a good deal of criticism by the [Communist Party]. [. . . . ] It is hard to please a real party communist. They are narrower than Lenin, their master. I wish they had his great breadth. He realized that communism could never succeed without the great fringe of sympathizers who were not of the party. (27 July 1932)
In reality, nearly all reviewers gave high praise to the novel, ending and all.26 Although Dargan had a complex (and well-founded) sense of affiliation with mountaineers and millworkers, in Call Home the Heart and again in A Stone Came Rolling she adopts the perspective of a mountain-raised woman who, for her own complex reasons, leaves this home, goes to a nearby textilemill village, and allies herself with the textile workers’ cause. Call Home the Heart opens when protagonist Ishma Waycaster is a young woman of eighteen growing up on an isolated homestead high in the North Carolina mountains. The novel first takes Ishma through courtship and marriage to Britt Hensley, then shows a difficult first year as the couple struggle to raise soybeans on a rocky hillside field. Propelled by the failure of this venture and by other frustrations, Ishma deserts her husband and goes to Winbury, a lowland mill village, with a former suitor, Rad Bailey. Rad works as a carpenter and tries to support Ishma so that she doesn’t need to work. Indeed, although she works for a brief period in a Winbury mill to help pay a doctor’s bill, she avoids the fates of many workers around her who have been mentally and physically stunted by long-term millwork. Despite being relatively secure from the mill’s clutches, Ishma becomes engaged with local mill-workers’ struggles. Finding that her increasingly radical politics cannot coexist with Rad’s middle-class aspirations, Ishma extricates herself from this relationship and continues her union work. In a bittersweet, ambiguous conclusion, Ishma ends up fleeing Winbury while the workers are immersed in a strike. She returns to the mountains, where she finds joy in reuniting with Britt, but also feels haunted by having forsaken a path of intellectual development and labor activism. In A Stone Came Rolling, Ishma has returned to the battlefields of industrial labor. In “Dunmow,” another North Carolina town dominated by textiles and other manufacturing, she once again plays a central role in efforts to organize a strong union and orchestrate a wide labor revolt. Although she still longs for a less complicated rural life, this time around she does not defect from battle (except for a brief recuperation in the mountains). The novel ends with an ongoing labor dispute still unresolved, but suggests the workers’ growing resolve to take power away from those who oppress them. In the final paragraph, workers take over a jail to free Ishma, who has been arrested by strikebreakers.27
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 130
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
131
Removed from these narratives as a participant-observer, Dargan no longer seems to feel compelled to distinguish her otherness from her working-class characters. (Her adoption of the male-sounding pseudonym “Fielding Burke” seems calculated to create further distance from her self-image as a female poet sympathetic to but not of the working class.) Instead of evoking the persona of a middle-class writer observing or taking part in working-class experience, as she had in her poetry and stories, Dargan creates a protagonist whose subjectivity both intersects and diverges from her own. Although Ishma shares Dargan’s race and gender (white, female), her working-class mountain background (and her youth) gives her considerably different relationships to both labor and culture within mountain and industrial societies.28 By creating a protagonist who can engage with a broader range of class experiences than she herself plausibly could, Dargan establishes an ideal vantage point for portraying class struggle and tensions she saw as inherent in capitalism across social strata.29 Endowed with exceptional intelligence, fortitude, strength, and attractiveness, Ishma eventually moves on the periphery of intellectual circles familiar to Dargan but rarely known by members of Ishma’s class.30 Without such exceptional qualities, she would not have attracted the interest of Derry Unthank, the leftist doctor who introduces her to Marxist thought, or of Virginia Grant, a wealthy millowner’s wife who lavishes attention on Ishma when she is in the hospital.31 Ishma is similarly exceptional—neither middle-class nor “proletarian”—with regards to her ambiguous relationship to industrial work and industrial workers’ interests. Though she works in a mill for a short time, she never experiences the dire poverty of families who can see no way to survive outside of the mill economy. Fitting Dargan’s belief that technology applied within a socialist society will enable the creation and equal distribution of leisure, Ishma has an enlightened view of factory work that would be less probable for a worker whose health had been sapped by long-term millwork (or whose children also had to work in the mill to help the family). She finds the work among factory machines exciting (albeit tiring): “there was a thrill for her in the roll and swell of the machinery” (CHH 270). These machines “could kill, but they could create. That was their first, great function. When she came in to them she felt that she must greet them good-morning, and start the day comradely with the secret force producing so endlessly and enormously for the markets of men” (273).32 Ishma stops mill work when Derry encourages her to direct her considerable energy towards union organizing. Derry assures her (again making her work experience atypical) that his medical connections will ensure that “[she’ll] not have to pay another dollar” of the hospital bill she is trying to
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 131
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
132
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
pay off (295). He further assures her that there is a higher justice in her ability to escape millwork so easily (while less fortunate workers cannot): “We know that nothing is right, but everything is going to be. That is our creed, Ishma. It will be well with the world some day, because we know that all is wrong with it now” (296). Initially, Ishma’s brief experience as a mill worker and her large capacity for human sympathy motivates her to help individual mill families in difficult circumstances. Later, she comes to embrace more radical direct activism against the sources of exploitation that affect all mill families. Ishma’s fight against labor exploitation has an additional voluntary quality because she, unlike many other mill workers, still has a mountain home to which she can return. Because her mountain ties pull her emotionally, Ishma must struggle intellectually to stick to labor activism. Reflecting at one point on the many industrial troubles that now consume her (“Poor staggering Genie [a chronically fatigued millworker]—young Bert Wiggins, off in the mountains, dying with tuberculosis because Grant-Norburn couldn’t afford air-cleansing devices in their mills—little Jane—lock out— union”) Ishma realizes that “she could get away—back to the mountains, with peace [. . . . ] What was making it impossible but herself?” (CHH 259).33 Since Ishma’s life will be difficult whether she battles capitalism as an activist or the elements as a mountain farmer, her wavering between these two possibilities represents more a struggle between emotion and intellect than between spheres of class interests. In contrast, Ishma’s friend and mentor Derry Unthank, who advocates socialism yet comes from a middle-class background and even owns mill stock, is caught more uncomfortably in the contradictions of his class position. Thus, he tells Ishma that he can never be as effective as she can in fighting on behalf of the working class: “I’m only a half and half. You’ll be the whole thing” (250). “How little it took to make some people happy!”: folk music in a rural context Ishma’s worldly perspective allows Dargan to scrutinize a wide spectrum of cultural practices within both mountains and mill village, and among both workers and the middle class. In her novels’ consideration of the various cultural resources vying for authority in asserting a socially progressive view of reality, Dargan pays particular attention to the ideological functions of folk and religious songs in the lives of her working-class characters. Dargan’s frequent references to such music reflect both its inherent generic qualities and its (perceived) particular functions within the social formations described in her novels. Dargan’s novels return repeatedly to music as perhaps the most
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 132
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
133
prevalent and powerful cultural influence on ideology within the working-class social contexts she portrays. The opening and concluding sections of Call Home the Heart, which take place in the Appalachian mountains, represent numerous old and newly created folk songs, while A Stone Came Rolling, set primarily in a North Carolina textile-mill town farther from the mountains than the mill town in Call Home the Heart, devotes more attention to the hymns that are integral to this community’s religious life.34 The “mountain sections” of these two novels portray the practice of singing old folk songs and creating new ballads to illustrate linked aspects of a still-vital mode of cultural expression among mountain people.35 In contrast, the “mill sections” of these novels do not portray workers creating music purely for pleasure (outside of religious contexts). Not until the end of A Stone Came Rolling does Dargan suggest that workers might profitably transform the cultural modes of secular folksongs and hymns to address new interactions with industrial labor. A chapter in Call Home the Heart simply called “Episode” provides one illustration of how mountain ballad making provides a mode for documenting and reaching consensus on communally significant events. “Episode” seems to propose that “ballad logic” provides a potential alternative to Christian doctrine as a way of reconciling individual and social tensions. When confronted with Ishma’s having abandoned her family for Rad, Ishma’s community seeks resolution to this seeming affront to their moral standards not through a rational examination of her complex impulses (which Dargan has, however, shown the reader), but through preexisting cultural modes that are more emotional than rational. First, they expect that Britt will uphold their community’s standard of manliness, going after Rad and Ishma with a gun and, if necessary, killing the man to bring back his wife (or at least defend his honor) (164–5). Second, they expect their preacher to condemn Ishma according to the standards of their conservative “old-time religion.” In choosing not to pursue Rad and Ishma, Britt denies them their first expectation.36 The preacher, however, comes through with the expected fiery sermon, calling on his “dear fellow Christians, to purge this stain [Ishma’s name] from the sacred leaves of our church-book” (162–3). After preaching, he tells himself that “he had done his job well. He knew it, and [his congregation] knew it” (167). Had Britt, who waits outside the church during the service, done nothing, the preacher’s condemnation probably would have established the community’s final judgment on Ishma. After Britt forces the preacher to engage in a no-holds-barred fight, however, public consensus on Ishma is open for reconsideration. Britt’s ultimate victory gives the community the basis for creating a ballad. Immediately after the fight, Si Welch (“the best ballit-maker
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 133
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
134
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
of which the country could boast”), helped by several others, composes a few verses and a chorus on the spot. Si tells everyone present to “make up lines fer this ballit, an’ git ’em to me by next Sat’day night” (177). Governed by an aesthetic sense that “all ballits ought to end with a lady,” he also tells them that “howsomever long [the final ballad] is, it’s going to end thisaway” and “[gives] them his final triumph”: An’ Ishmer she was cryin’ that night, Cryin’ to Rad Bailee, I wish I’s home with my ol’ true boy, A sittin’ on his knee. (177)
However far this stanza is from Ishma’s true experience or feeling, it taps into a communal understanding of ballad logic that, in contrast to the religious logic dictating preacher Siler’s sermon, allows for a more ambiguous or sympathetic treatment of moral transgressions. Si’s stipulated final stanza encourages other contributors to merge their divergent stances with its sympathy. Now, Si’s wife, Mandy, says that if Ishma comes back, “maybe she’ll be welcome” (177). In showing that this shift in sympathies—from the preacher’s condemnation to the “ballit-maker’s” magnanimity towards Ishma—Dargan gives the ballad qualities that potentially make it both progressive and regressive. Though the shift in sympathy is itself positive, its quick and impulsive nature is less exemplary according to Dargan’s intellectual values. The communal sway to support Britt as the winner of the fight had been more emotional than rational; during the fight, the onlookers’ main desire had simply been “a victory, something that could be celebrated, talked about, thrilled over, and preserved, with personal additions, in their country’s history. It must be a victory, even if they had to give it to the preacher” (173). The ballad that results from the fight (not to mention the fight itself, which is narrated over nearly eight full pages) has a certain humorous mock-epic quality, illustrating the very naïve preoccupation with insular conflicts that Ishma has fled: A fighting man is he [Preacher Siler], my boys, But there’s a better yet;The man who made the preacher fight Is Wimble County Britt! (176).
Dargan’s aside that this ballad would preserve the story of this fight “as long as a fireside remained in the mountains” (174) suggests a conviction that this culture will not advance beyond such crude, emotional perspectives on resolving conflicts.
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 134
6/22/2006 8:54:33 AM
“Nothing is Right, but Everything is Going to Be”
135
Still, Dargan shows that, within this cultural context, creating such ballads is more progressive than passively letting a community outsider shape sentiments through a sermon. Subtly prefiguring larger struggles in which working-class leaders will inspire other workers to challenge industrialists, this scene shows Britt successfully challenging a preacher’s sanctioned moral authority. Watching Britt pummel the preacher, onlookers feel that “God’s law and man’s was broken [ . . . ] They were watching it crack—that mighty law. And the earth held” (172–3). Emotionally uplifted by Britt’s fight, and then by the ballad, the community overrides the condemnation of Ishma handed down to them from their preacher’s pulpit.37 The above “Episode” marks a rare section of Dargan’s narrative where Ishma’s perspective, which generally dominates, is absent. More often, Ishma’s self-conscious reflections on her culture unsettle representations of songs being enjoyed in a social context. Ishma’s ambivalence towards the songs popular in her isolated mountain community fits within her larger ambivalence towards her native culture and thus anticipates her wider ranging search for rational knowledge. Her feelings of distaste and detachment while watching her husband and various friends absorbed in their rendition of “Sourwood Mountain” show the degree to which Ishma feels separated from community values: I’ve got a gal on Sourwood Mountain, That gal’s mine till the jedgment day! I’ve got a gun an’ it ain’t no quitter, Boys, boys, you’d better git away! [. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .] Two men killed on Sourwood Mountain! Come an’ see who’s layin’ in the hay! Tech my gal ef you want to see yer Jesus! Boys, boys, you’d better git away! [. . . . ] How little it took to make some people happy! Why did it take so much for her? She could get no pleasure out of the rough singing and thumping, though Britt was trying to make it interesting by putting in the wildest shakes and quavers wherever he could. She liked music when Nature helped to make it. She liked to sing above the tree-tops to the rising sun. These wriggling, perspiring men, with their whoops and steady pat-pat, made her feel like a chained animal. (136–7)
To see the performance of such a song as reflective of ideology, as Dargan’s representation implicitly does, does not necessarily mean that the solution
96896_Mantooth_06 22.indd 135
6/22/2006 8:54:34 AM
136
“You Factory Folks Who Sing This Rhyme Will Surely Understand”
for social tensions this song embodies (men killing each other to maintain possession of their women) accurately reflects the social practices of those singing. Still, though the singers see this song as merely a vehicle for group entertainment, they endorse its ideology to the extent that they enjoy