Page 1
WRITING URBANISM
Urban design continues to grow and mature as a field of study, research, and professional end...
259 downloads
4548 Views
13MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Page 1
WRITING URBANISM
Urban design continues to grow and mature as a field of study, research, and professional endeavour. This welcome collection of both invited and published essays is panoramically broad and comprehensive in its scope. Combining essays from both practice and academia, this volume includes some of the most significant texts on urban design from the last two decades, a period of transformational growth in the field and exponential growth in the metropolis. Writing Urbanism asks how cities can become more coherent, sustainable, authentic, and equitable, as well as aesthetically compelling and culturally meaningful. The essays probe such issues as community, social equity, design theory, technology, and globalism. How does a rapidly urbanizing and polarizing world embrace these and other issues, and how can urban design translate them into consequential and workable urban form? By assembling a range of voices across different institutions and generations, Writing Urbanism offers the most multifaceted portrait of urban design today. Scholars, students, and design professionals alike will find this collection to be a useful resource for understanding this increasingly important design field and for insights into the forces that shape the city itself. Douglas Kelbaugh F.A.I.A. is Dean and Professor of Architecture and Urban Planning at the University of Michigan Taubman College of Architecture and Urban Planning. He is a leading practitioner, teacher, and thinker in urban design, is the author of several books on urban design, and has taught design at eight schools of architecture in the USA, Europe, Japan, and Australia. Kit Krankel McCullough is a lecturer at the University of Michigan Taubman College of Architecture and Urban Planning. She is Principal of Kit Krankel McCullough Urban Design, and has significant and broad experience as a practitioner of urban design as well as having taught a variety of courses in urban design.
16:21:08:05:08
Page 1
Page 2
THE A.C.S.A. ARCHITECTURAL EDUCATION SERIES
The intent of the Architectural Education Series is to produce readers for use across the curriculum in architecture and design programs matching current lines of scholarly inquiry with curricular needs. Each reader focuses on a thematic topic and is composed of chapters presented originally at A.C.S.A. conferences along with invited chapters. Leading edge design work and scholarship are included to give faculty, students and professionals resources for the studio and classroom. SERIES EDITORIAL BOARD
Michael Benedikt, University of Texas at Austin Luis Carranza, Roger Williams University Thomas Fisher, University of Minnesota Lisa Iwamoto, University of California at Berkeley Fernando Luiz Lara, University of Michigan John Stuart, Florida International University ABOUT A.C.S.A.
The Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture (A.C.S.A.) is a nonprofit organization founded in 1912 to enhance the quality of architectural education. School membership in A.C.S.A. has grown from 10 charter schools to more than 200 schools in several membership categories worldwide. Through these schools, more than 5,000 architecture faculty members are represented in A.C.S.A.’s membership. A.C.S.A., unique in its representative role for professional schools of architecture in the United States and Canada, provides a major forum for ideas on the leading edge of architectural thought. Issues that will affect the architectural profession in the future are being examined today in A.C.S.A. member schools. Additional information is available at www.acsa-arch.org.
16:21:08:05:08
Page 2
Page 3
WRITING URBANISM A design reader
EDITED BY DOUGLAS KELBAUGH AND KIT KRANKEL McCULLOUGH
16:21:08:05:08
Page 3
Page 4
First published 2008 by Routledge 270 Madison Ave, New York, NY 10016 Simultaneously published in the UK by Routledge 2 Park Square, Milton Park, Abingdon, Oxon OX14 4RN Routledge is an imprint of the Taylor & Francis Group, an informa business This edition published in the Taylor & Francis e-Library, 2008. “To purchase your own copy of this or any of Taylor & Francis or Routledge’s collection of thousands of eBooks please go to www.eBookstore.tandf.co.uk.”
© 2008 Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reprinted or reproduced or utilised in any form or by any electronic, mechanical, or other means, now known or hereafter invented, including photocopying and recording, or in any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Writing urbanism : a design reader / edited by Douglas Kelbaugh & Kit Krankel McCullough. p. cm. – (The A.C.S.A. architectural education series) Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 978–0–415–77438–3 (hbk : alk. paper) – ISBN 978–0–415–77439–0 (pbk: alk. paper) – ISBN 978–0–203–92702–1 (ebk) 1. City planning–United States. I. Kelbaugh, Doug. II. McCullough, Kit Krankel. III. Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture. NA9105.W75 2008 307.1′2160973–dc22 2007047375 ISBN 0-203-92702-8 Master e-book ISBN
ISBN10: 0–415–77438–1 (hbk) ISBN10: 0–415–77439–X (pbk) ISBN10: 0–203–92702–8 (ebk) ISBN13: 978–0–415–77438–3 (hbk) ISBN13: 978–0–415–77439–0 (pbk) ISBN13: 978–0–203–92702–1 (ebk)
16:21:08:05:08
Page 4
Page 5
CONTENTS Notes on contributors ix Foreword xv Robert Fishman Preface xxi Douglas Kelbaugh and Kit Krankel McCullough Acknowledgments xxv
I URBAN PROCESS 1
Introduction 3 Kit Krankel McCullough Observations The virtues of cities 6 Alex Krieger Working cities: Density, risk, spontaneity 12 J. Max Bond, Jr. Meaningful urban design: Teleological/catalytic/relevant 14 Aseem Inam Mathematics of the ideal roadtrip 24 Christopher Monson City walking: Laying claim to Manhattan 34 Ben Jacks Preservation, re-use, and sustainability Green Manhattan 45 David Owen Stewardship of the built environment: The emerging synergies from sustainability and historic preservation 57 Robert A. Young DROSS; Re-genesis of diverse matter 61 Lydia Kallipoliti The shared global ideology of the big and the green 69 David Gissen Community Levittown retrofitted: An urbanism beyond the property line 75 Teddy Cruz The mnemonic city: Duality, invisibility, and memory in American urbanism 80 Craig Evan Barton v
16:21:08:05:08
Page 5
Page 6
CONTENTS
Mapping East Los Angeles: Aesthetics and cultural politics in an other L.A. 87 José Gámez Celebrating the city 96 Alan J. Plattus Skid Row, Los Angeles 98 Camilo José Vergara II URBAN FORM 103
Introduction: Further thoughts on the three urbanisms 105 Douglas Kelbaugh Everyday urbanism, landscape urbanism, and infrastructure Everyday urban design: Towards default urbanism and/or urbanism by design? 115 John Kaliski Without end: Mats, holes, and the promise of landscape urbanism 120 Karen M’Closkey Boston’s New Urban Ring: An antidote to urban fragmentation 127 George Thrush Infrastructure for the new social compact 138 William R. Morrish and Catherine R. Brown New urbanism Whatever happened to modernity? 155 Daniel Solomon The town of Seaside: Designed in 1978–1983 by Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co. 168 Andrés Duany and Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk The impact of ideology on American town planning 176 Tony Schuman and Elliott Sclar New Urbanism as a counter-project to post-industrialism 185 Ellen Dunham-Jones Integrating urbanisms: Growing places between New Urbanism and Post-Urbanism 194 Carl Giometti Post urbanism Rem Koolhaas’s writing on cities: Poetic perception and gnomic fantasy 203 William S. Saunders “Bigness” in context: Some regressive tendencies in Rem Koolhaas’ urban theory 220 Jorge Otero-Pailos vi
16:21:08:05:08
Page 6
Page 7
CONTENTS
Habraken and Koolhaas: Two Dutchmen flying over Bijlmermeer 229 June P. Williamson Heterotopias and Urban Design 237 David Grahame Shane III URBAN SOCIETY 245
Introduction 247 Douglas Kelbaugh The public realm Big Brother is charging you 250 Michael Sorkin Communitas and the American public realm 254 Spiro Kostof Contesting the public realm: Struggles over public space in Los Angeles 271 Margaret Crawford Action space 281 Richard Scherr The inscription of “public” and “civic” realms in the contemporary city 291 Michael E. Gamble Globalism and local identity Zone 297 Keller Easterling Dis-assembling the urban: The variable interactions of spatial form and content 303 Saskia Sassen Tropical Lewis Mumford: The first critical regionalist urban planner 313 Liane Lefaivre and Alexander Tzonis The luxury of languor 324 Michael A. McClure and Ursula Emery McClure Technology Technoscience and environmental culture: A provisional critique 333 Kenneth Frampton Technology, place, and the nonmodern thesis 345 Steven A. Moore Immanent domain: Pervasive computing and the public realm 360 Dana Cuff City of dreams: Virtual space/public space 372 Eugenia Victoria Ellis Index 383 vii
16:21:08:05:08
Page 7
Page 8
16:21:08:05:08
Page 8
Page 9
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS Craig Evan Barton is an associate professor of urban design and the Director of the Urban Studies Program at the University of Virginia. He is a founding principal of RBGC Associates. He investigates issues of cultural and historical preservation and their interpretation through architectural and urban design. He is the editor of the anthology Sites of Memory: Perspectives on Architecture and Race. J. Max Bond, Jr. is a partner at Davis Brody Bond in New York. He established the Architects Renewal Committee of Harlem, where he served as director. He is a Fellow of the American Institute of Architects. He received the 2005 President’s Award from the A.I.A. New York Chapter for his commitment to design excellence, activism, and diversity in the profession. Catherine R. Brown (1950–1998) was a Minneapolis landscape architect, civic leader, and director of special projects at the Design Center for the American Urban Landscape at the University of Minnesota. Along with her husband, William Morrish, she is the author of Planning to Stay. Margaret Crawford is a professor of urban design and planning theory at the Harvard Graduate School of Design. Her research focuses on the evolution, uses, and meanings of urban space. Her book Building the Workingman’s Paradise: The Design of American Company Towns examines the rise and fall of professionally designed industrial environments. Her most recent book, Nansha Coastal City: Landscape and Urbanism in the Pearl River Delta, was published in early 2006. Teddy Cruz is principal of Estudio Teddy Cruz and associate professor of architecture at Woodbury University. His practice and pedagogy reflect his commitment to advancing architectural and urban planning projects that address the global, political, and social problems that proliferate on international borders, with special focus on San Diego and Tijuana. Dana Cuff is Professor of Architecture and Urban Design at the University of California, Los Angeles. Her expertise concerns social issues in the built environment, which she engages as a practitioner and as an academic. Her book The Provisional City: Los Angeles Stories of Architecture and Urbanism was supported by the Getty and the National Endowment for the Arts. Andrés Duany is a principal of Duany Plater-Zyberk & Company (D.P.Z.) and a co-founder of the Congress for the New Urbanism. D.P.Z. has become a major leader in the practice and direction of urban planning, having designed over 300 new and existing communities in the United States and overseas. He is a co-author of Suburban Nation and The New Civic Art. Ellen Dunham-Jones is the Director of the Architecture Program at the Georgia Institute of Technology. She serves on the Board of Directors of ix
16:21:08:05:08
Page 9
Page 10
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
the Congress for the New Urbanism, and the advisory boards of the journal Places, the Phoenix Urban Research Lab and the Ax:son Johnson Institute for Sustainable Urban Design in Sweden. Her current research focuses on retrofitting suburbs. Keller Easterling is an architect, urbanist, and writer from New York City. She is an associate professor at Yale University. She is the author of Enduring Innocence: Global Architecture and its Political Masquerades, Organization Space: Landscapes, and Highways and Houses in America. Her forthcoming book, Extrastatecraft, examines global infrastructure networks as a medium of global polity. Eugenia Victoria Ellis is the managing partner of BAU in Elkins Park, PA, and an associate professor at Drexel University in Philadelphia. She has practiced for over 25 years in the states of Illinois, Florida, and Pennsylvania where her focus has been in civic and municipal facilities, energy-conscious environmental design, and health care facilities. Robert Fishman is the Emil Lorch Professor at Taubman College of Architecture and Urban Planning, University of Michigan. He is the author of Urban Utopias in the Twentieth Century: Ebenezer Howard, Frank Lloyd Wright and Le Corbusier and Bourgeois Utopias: The Rise and Fall of Suburbia. He is a past president of the Urban History Association, and Public Policy Fellow at the Wilson Center. Kenneth Frampton is the Ware Professor of Architecture at Columbia University. He has worked as an architect and as an architectural historian/critic in England, Israel, and the United States. His books include Le Corbusier and Labor, Work and Architecture. An expanded and updated edition of Modern Architecture: A Critical History was published in summer 2007. Michael E. Gamble is an associate professor of architecture at the Georgia Institute of Technology in Atlanta and a principal with Gamble and Gamble, Architects. His design research is focused on contemporary urban practices. His firm has received several awards, including the American Institute of Architects Georgia Chapter Honor Award, and has been exhibited in a variety of regional and national venues. José Gámez is an assistant professor of architecture and a member of the Latin American Studies faculty at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte. His research and design practice explores questions of cultural identity in architecture and urbanism. Carl Giometti is a project coordinator with JTS Architects in Lincolnshire, IL. His graduate thesis, “Integrating Urbanisms . . .”, was selected for presentation at the 2006 A.C.S.A. Annual Meeting. He is active in several local and national organizations dedicated to advancing the theory and practice of urban development. David Gissen is a professor at Pennsylvania State University where he teaches architectural and urban theory and design. His research focuses x
16:21:08:05:08
Page 10
Page 11
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
on the architectural production of nature. He is the author of Big and Green and curator of the eponymous exhibition shown at Yale University, Museum of the City of New York, Chicago Architecture Foundation, and The National Building Museum. Aseem Inam is Senior Project Manager at Moule & Polyzoides Architects and Urbanists in California. Prior to that, he conducted research and taught urban design at the University of Michigan. He is the author of the book Planning for the Unplanned and a number of award-winning journal articles. He has worked as an architect, urban designer, and planner in Canada, France, India, and the United States. Ben Jacks is an assistant professor in the Department of Architecture and Interior Design at Miami University, Oxford, Ohio. A licensed architect, he practiced for fifteen years prior to beginning an academic career. He once hiked the Appalachian Trail from Georgia to Maine. He is currently writing a book about walking and the built environment. John Kaliski is a principal of Urban Studios in Los Angeles. A key component of his work is his ability to integrate public concerns into design processes. He has led workshops, charrettes, and meetings nationally and has worked collaboratively with communities and professionals on a broad range of project types. He is the co-author of Everyday Urbanism with John Chase and Margaret Crawford. Lydia Kallipoliti is an architect currently enrolled in the Ph.D. program in the history and theory of architecture at Princeton University. She is the recipient of the 2006 Lawrence Anderson Award from M.I.T. for the creative documentation of architectural history, the Marvin E. Goody award for excellence in the use of materials, and a Fulbright scholarship. For her dissertation, “Mission Galactic Household,” she has been awarded the 2006–2007 Woodrow Wilson Fellowship. Spiro Kostof (1936–1991) was Professor of Architectural History at the University of California, Berkeley. His many books include The Architect: Chapters in the History of the Profession, A History of Architecture: Settings and Rituals, and America by Design, the companion to a five-part television series he presented. He received a posthumous award for excellence in architectural education from the A.C.S.A./A.I.A. in 1992. Alex Krieger, F.A.I.A. is Professor in Practice of Urban Design at Harvard University Graduate School of Design, and former Chair of the Department of Urban Planning and Design. A practitioner as well as a teacher, author and lecturer, he is a founding principal of Chan Krieger Sienewicz in Cambridge, M.A. Liane Lefaivre is the Chair of Architectural History and Theory at the University of Applied Arts in Vienna and a research fellow at the Delft University of Technology Urbanism Department. Her work and numerous books are devoted to architectural culture and criticism in the xi
16:21:08:05:08
Page 11
Page 12
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
framework of cognitive history, architectural history, and creativity in Western culture. Karen M’Closkey is an assistant professor of architecture at the University of Pennsylvania. She is a founding partner of PEG office of landscape + architecture. PEG’s award-winning work spans small-scale retail and residential work to large landscape infrastructure. Michael A. McClure is an assistant professor at the University of LouisianaLafayette and Ursula Emery McClure is an associate professor at Louisiana State University. Their firm, emerymcclure architecture, has developed a wide range of research and design projects and has been recognized by the 2006 Venice Biennale and the A.I.A. Their work and writing have been published in numerous venues including 306090–05, Dwell Magazine, and Southern Living Magazine. Christopher Monson is an associate professor of architecture at the College of Architecture, Art + Design at Mississippi State University. Built around issues of ethics and inter-subjective communication, his research interests include pedagogies of professional design education, contemporary American architecture, theories of formmaking and objecthood, and the philosophical structures of architectural practice. Steven A. Moore is the Bartlett Cocke Professor of Architecture and Planning at the University of Texas at Austin where he teaches design and courses related to the philosophy, history, and application of sustainable technology. He is Director of the graduate program in Sustainable Design and Co-director of the University of Texas Center for Sustainable Development. William R. Morrish is the Elwood R. Quesada Professor of Architecture, Landscape Architecture, and Urban and Environmental Planning, at the School of Architecture, University of Virginia. His work approaches infrastructure as a cultural landscape that knits citizens, public spaces, social institutions, cultural expression, and the natural environment into multi-operational urban landscape networks. Jorge Otero-Pailos is Assistant Professor for Historic Preservation at Columbia University. His research probes the boundaries between contemporary preservation and architecture. A founder and director of the journal Future Anterior, his forthcoming book, Inside Postmodernism: Architectural Phenomenology and How Experience Came to Matter More Than History, traces the struggle to deploy a historical consciousness within modern architecture during the 1970s. David Owen has been a staff writer for The New Yorker since 1991. He is the author of a dozen books, most recently Sheetrock & Shellac, published in 2006, and Copies in Seconds, which was published in 2004. Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk is the Dean of the University of Miami School of Architecture and a principal of Duany Plater-Zyberk & Company (D.P.Z.). She is also a co-founder of the Congress for the New Urbanism. xii
16:21:08:05:08
Page 12
Page 13
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
D.P.Z. has become a major leader in the practice and direction of urban planning, having designed over 300 new and existing communities in the United States and overseas. She is a co-author of Suburban Nation and The New Civic Art. Alan J. Plattus is a professor of architecture and urbanism at Yale University, where he teaches courses on architectural history and theory, urban history, and design, and directs the School’s China Studio. He founded and directs the Yale Urban Design Workshop, a community design center that has undertaken urban design and building projects throughout Connecticut. Saskia Sassen is Robert S. Lynd Professor of Sociology at Columbia University after many years at the University of Chicago and is Centennial Visiting Professor at the London School of Economics. Sassen is the author most recently of Territory, Authority, Rights: From Medieval to Global Assemblages. William S. Saunders is GSD Assistant Dean for External Relations, editor of Harvard Design Magazine and a founding editor of GSD NEWS and Harvard Design Magazine. He is the author of Modern Architecture: Photographs by Ezra Stoller and the editor of eight other books. He has written numerous articles on architectural issues, education, and theory. Richard Scherr is Professor of Architecture at Pratt Institute, where he was previously Chairman of the Graduate Programs in Architecture and Urban Design (1989–1999). He is the author of The Grid (2001), and has written extensively on urban design and theory. Tony Schuman is Graduate Program Director and Associate Professor at the New Jersey Institute of Technology. His is past president of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture (A.C.S.A.). He was a founding member of a series of advocacy and activist organizations including Urban Deadline, The Architects’ Resistance (T.A.R.), Homefront, and Planners Network. Elliott Sclar is Professor of Urban Planning and International Affairs at Columbia University School of International and Public Affairs and the director of the Center for Sustainable Urban Development at Columbia University’s Earth Institute. He was a co-coordinator of the United Nations Millennium Project’s Taskforce on Improving the Lives of Slum Dwellers. He is the author of You Don’t Always Get What You Pay For: The Economics of Privatization (2000). David Grahame Shane teaches at Columbia University, Cooper Union and City College. He co-edited with Brian McGrath the Architectural Design Special Issue “Sensing the 21st Century City; Upclose and Remote.” He has lectured extensively and has published widely. His book Recombinant Urbanism; Conceptual Modeling in Architecture, Urban Design and City Theory appeared in 2005. Daniel Solomon is Professor Emeritus of Architecture and Urban Design at xiii
16:21:08:05:08
Page 13
Page 14
NOTES ON CONTRIBUTORS
the University of California, Berkeley. He is the founder of Solomon E.T.C., a W.R.T. Company. Residential architecture and urban design have been the main focus of his work. He is a co-founder of the Congress for the New Urbanism and an author, most recently of Global City Blues. Michael Sorkin is Director of the Graduate Urban Design Program at City College of New York and the principal of the Michael Sorkin Studio. He lectures widely, is the author of many books and articles, and is currently contributing editor at Architectural Record and Metropolis. For ten years, he was the architecture critic of The Village Voice. His most recent book is Indefensible Space: The Architecture of the National Insecurity State (2007). George Thrush is Director of the School of Architecture at Northeastern University in Boston, M.A. His work seeks to connect transportation, urban design, and civic image in an increasingly privatized economic arena. Alexander Tzonis is Professor Emeritus and former Chair of Architectural Theory and Design Methods at the Delft University of Technology and current Director of Design Knowledge Systems, a multi-disciplinary research center on architectural cognition. A prolific writer, he is author or co-author of a number of books and has contributed over 200 articles on architectural theory, history, and design methods. Camilo José Vergara is a writer, photographer, and sociologist. He has been photographing American urban landscapes since 1977, documenting the changes taking place in the country’s inner cities. His books include Twin Towers Remembered, Subway Memories, and How the Other Half Worships. Vergara has received numerous awards, among them a MacArthur Foundation fellowship in 2002. June P. Williamson is a practicing urban designer and architect in New York City specializing in the practice and theory of mixed-use suburban redevelopment. She has been a visiting professor of architecture at Georgia Tech, the University of Utah, and the Boston Architectural Center. With Ellen Dunham-Jones, she is writing a case-study book about retrofitting suburbs. Robert A. Young is an associate professor of architecture and the Historic Preservation Program Director at the University of Utah. His teaching and research focus combines historic preservation and sustainability in the stewardship of the built environment. He has served on numerous boards related to preservation and revitalization issues.
xiv
16:21:08:05:08
Page 14
Page 15
FOREWORD ROBERT FISHMAN After the near-death experience of the postwar urban crisis, the American city over the last fifteen years has seen a remarkable resurgence. The articles in this remarkable collection embody a new hope, for they were written in precisely the years when the seemingly indissoluble coupling of “urban” and “crisis” was decisively broken and urban design could begin to re-imagine the American city as the site of a new public culture. Yet the tone of these articles is far from triumphalist. Urban design today necessarily bears the burdens of the “urban renewal” years, when a grand vision of a totally rebuilt modern city led to near-total failure. Partly as a result, urban design in practice tends even now to be self-marginalizing in scale and ambition, struggling to challenge imaginatively the limitations of an increasingly privatized urban world. But as the American city renews its material base, seeks to overcome the crippling segregation of the past with a vitally diverse urban culture, and begins to provide models of sustainable energy use for the rest of our society, there is the danger that urban design will remain cautious and constricted. The articles in this book seek in very different ways to challenge our urban design vision to match the historic opportunities. To understand the limitations under which American urban design operated during the urban crisis years, one must go to Detroit and perhaps to a few other lagging metropolitan areas. There one can see the fate that as late as the 1990s was predicted by many experts to be the inevitable one for all American cities: a downtown marginalized and semi-abandoned; once-bustling factory zones turned into depopulated, de-industrialized and racially segregated “inner cities”; suburbs in the “first-ring” just beyond the central city caught in a rolling wave of abandonment about to engulf them; and—at the edge—the feverish, fragmented, low-density growth we know as sprawl.1 This “anti-city,” as the great urbanist Lewis Mumford in the 1960s called our dysfunctional metropolitan regions, reached its peak of disorganization with the “Rodney King riots” in Los Angeles in 1992— perhaps the most destructive urban riots in American history. Meanwhile, urbanists predicted that the rest of the 1990s would bring ever-higher rates of urban crime, concentrated poverty, and flight from the city. Mumford’s despairing 1975 prescription for New York City seemed fifteen years later to apply to all major American cities. “Make the patient as comfortable as possible,” he advised. “The case is hopeless.”2 In fact, the 1990s saw a dramatic recovery of most American cities, a profound reurbanism of American life that made the city again the center of American culture. As Saskia Sassen was perhaps the first to observe, the very forces of globalization that had devastated the factories of our inner cities xv
16:21:08:05:08
Page 15
1 Reynolds Farley et al., Detroit Divided (New York: Russell Sage Foundation, 2000).
2 Lewis Mumford, quoted in B.I. Shenker, “18 experts advise, castigate and console the city,” New York Times, July 30, 1975, p. 35.
Page 16
FOREWORD
3 For further defense and elucidation of “reurbanism,” see my “The Fifth Migration,” Journal of the American Planning Association, vol. 71 #4 (Autumn 2005): 357–367.
4 Julia Szabo, “Regarding Henry,” New York, vol. 28 #3 (June 16, 1995): 42.
were also inexorably re-building the major American downtowns as crucial nodes for global finance and knowledge-production. This “downtown reurbanism” was complemented by another aspect of globalism: “immigrant reurbanism” that repopulated many of the most devastated urban economies and built a new small-scale economy from the ground up. Moreover, after the turmoil of the great black migration to northern cities, a black middle class committed to the cities was finally emerging. Finally, one saw a significant return of the white middle class, no longer confined to the “islands of renewal in seas of decay” as the geographer Brian J.L. Berry had described the gentrifying areas of the 1970s and 1980s. Instead, this “white middle-class reurbanism” complemented the immigrant and black middleclass reurbanism to reinvigorate whole neighborhoods and districts that had seemed lost to the urban crisis.3 Reurbanism meant rising rather than falling urban population, rising tax receipts, jobs to replace those lost by deindustrialization, and a significant shift in the regional balance of power from suburb to city. Perhaps more importantly, reurbanism has been a major cultural force, challenging the suburban car culture with the classic urban virtues of density, walkability, and diversity. Cities are now hip, especially for the growing cohort of the young for whom the city is the natural environment after college, and, increasingly, after marriage and children as well. And if much of this hipness is merely ease of consumption, especially the luxury goods and services lavishly provided in the centers where global capital and large immigrant populations meet, there are also some deeper lessons that perhaps only a dense urban environment can convey: respect for social difference, and the need to limit the “consumption of space” and ultimately the consumption of all other scarce resources. Here surely is a social and cultural movement that could be the basis for a new era in urban design. And yet urban design has, in my view, not yet risen to the challenge of embodying the best of reurbanism. In part this is because the early successes of reurbanism—both in theory and in practice—took place apart from and even in opposition to an urban design still identified with the massive clearances, highrise towers, and top-down power of urban renewal. Jane Jacobs’s seminal Death and Life of Great American Cities (1961) saw large-scale development as essentially a threat to the “closegrained diversity” and sidewalk life that she identified as the essence of the urban experience. The truly seminal urban design “project” for reurbanism therefore was New York City’s Soho district, because it involved the renovation of existing urban fabric. Here a gritty district of semi-abandoned industrial lofts accidentally spared from demolition by the cancellation of Robert Moses’ Lower Manhattan Expressway was re-imagined and re-occupied by artists as an ideal environment for the production of contemporary culture. This radical transvaluation of modernist urban design— “artists are real estate geniuses,” as art critic Henry Geldzahler explained4— xvi
16:21:08:05:08
Page 16
Page 17
FOREWORD
proclaimed that the seemingly obsolete nineteenth-century city was in fact better adapted to modern urban life than anything that modern architecture or urban design had been able to produce. So what was left for urban design beyond some modest “contextual” work? One major urban design project, however, met the challenge of Jane Jacobs and Soho: Battery Park City on the Hudson River at the tip of Manhattan Island, built on 92 acres of landfill from the World Trade Center. Dating back to the early 1960s, the overambitious plans—first for a classic “tower-in-the-park” assortment of office and residential towers, then for an even more elaborate “megastructure”—languished until 1979 when two young urban designers, Alexander Cooper and Stanton Eckstut, were given the challenge of coming up with a wholly new masterplan in just twelve weeks.5 What they produced not only saved that project but established a paradigm for urban design that remains perhaps the most powerful in today’s practice. Indeed, the “Battery Park City model” lies behind many of the articles in this book where it functions as a “default mode” for urban design. Conceived at a low point for the American city, the model’s strengths are still compelling compared to the modernist model it replaced, but so too is the need to get beyond it. For Cooper and Eckstut had learned the Jacobs/Soho lesson: that there was no need for a “new city,” not even on new land. If New York’s traditional fabric worked so well, the key to success was to build more of it. This meant first abandoning the superblock and megastructure ideas and instead extending the Manhattan grid onto the new territory. On the grid, one would put housing that, as they frankly put it, would resemble the “older and more established neighborhoods of New York.”6 A mix of townhouses, low-rise and high-rise apartments, architecture echoing New York’s golden era of the 1920s, would all be built out to the street to achieve that sense of enclosure and sidewalk vitality of the best old neighborhoods. Instead of the flowing modernist space of the superblock, the plan provides small, enclosed parks modeled on the nineteenth-century squares. New York Times architecture critic Paul Goldberger immediately hailed the Cooper/Eckstut plan as one that was “not a visitation from the world of Buck Rogers” but one that “understands the essence of Manhattan.”7 As the plan was gradually built out (it is still not complete) to include both housing and the Cesar Pelli’s World Financial Center opposite the Twin Towers, we have come to understand that Cooper and Eckstut’s neo-traditionalism, a predecessor of so much that we have learned to call “New Urbanism,” was only the beginning of the meaning of this remarkable plan. First, the Battery Park City plan foreshadowed the new balance-of-power between the public and private sectors that has come to define real estate practice. No longer could a public authority strictly define the concept, program, and phasing of a major project, as in the earlier megastructure which had to be built as a complete “total design” or not at all. The xvii
16:21:08:05:08
Page 17
5 David L.A. Gordon, Battery Park City: Politics and Planning on the New York Waterfront (Amsterdam: Gordon and Breach, 1997).
6 Alexander Cooper and Associates, Battery Park City Draft Summary Report and 1979 Master Plan (New York: Battery Park City Authority, 1979). The firm was subsequently renamed Cooper Eckstut and Associates.
7 Paul Goldberger, “A Realist’s Battery Park City,” New York Times, November 9, 1979, p. B4.
Page 18
FOREWORD
8 Tim Love, “Urban Design After Battery Park City: opportunities for variety and vitality in large-scale urban real estate development,” Harvard Design Magazine #25 (Fall 2007): 60–70.
9 Goldberger, p. B4.
“market” was now in control. As Tim Love has observed in a highly perceptive recent article,8 Battery Park City’s reliance on the grid was more than an hommage to the 1811 Commissioner’s Plan. Each block in the masterplan represented a convenient unit for a single developer, thus allowing development to occur sequentially in relatively independent phases and with the variations in program and architecture that mark each developer’s adaptations to a changing market. Moreover, the landscape of Battery Park City aptly expressed the emerging responsibility of the private sector to provide public amenities such as the highly successful Esplanade along the river that municipal government could no longer afford. If Battery Park City reflects the new balance of public and private that took hold during the Reagan years, the project has also come to embody the design/siting principle I would term “finding lost space.” The older urban renewal projects had cleared their own space out of the most thickly inhabited central districts of the city through the ruthless use of eminent domain. The massive human suffering that these projects imposed has now made such displacements politically impossible. Hence the need to find space, and the best places to look are precisely those waterfront sites where disused, obsolete dockyards and wharves can be replaced without significant displacement of people or businesses. Fortunately for urban design, deindustrialization has created in almost every city a large inventory of such “brownfield” sites where lost space can be found: not only waterfront locales but abandoned factory and warehouse sites; railyards that can be replaced or covered; or once-polluted waterways whose long-shunned banks can now be lined with new development. As reurbanism extends its reach from the downtown core into a recovering inner city, such “lost space” potentially available for redevelopment increases exponentially. Paul Goldberger termed the 1979 Battery Park City masterplan “a product of the hard-nosed, practical idealism of the end of the 1970s.”9 Such practicality was no doubt necessary and appropriate during the worst years of the urban crisis. Nevertheless, the Battery Park City model had its faults. Although the use of different developers phased over decades makes design variety theoretically possible, the actual result here and at comparable projects is a corporate blandness in design that cannot match the vitality of the best urban neighborhoods that supposedly inspired the model. As Elliott Sclar and Tony Schuman observe in their contribution to this volume, Battery Park City eschewed the social diversity that it originally promised by abandoning the goal of including affordable housing in each new apartment house. Instead, the profits from luxury development have been used to subsidize affordable housing in other neighborhoods in the city. Ironically, these resurgent neighborhoods have provided the most intense competition for the Battery Park City model. Opposite Battery Park City on the east side of Manhattan lies the Lower East Side, a century ago the most overcrowded slum in the world and, as late as the 1980s, a grim and xviii
16:21:08:05:08
Page 18
Page 19
FOREWORD
dangerous place to avoid. Today the Lower East is one of the liveliest neighborhoods in the world, an ever-fascinating mix of old tenements and new luxury apartments; discount stores that date a century to the “pushcart era” alongside New York’s hippest new bars and restaurants; and a population that blends not only artists and the new-rich young from the nearby financial district, but also Jewish and Italian remnants of the old immigration with newer black, Hispanic, and Asian residents. Can urban design somehow capture this vitality, or perhaps complement it with public spaces and amenities that the market cannot offer? How to incorporate what Max Bond has aptly called the “density, risk, spontaneity” of “working cities” into urban designs that must constantly meet the burden of hard-nosed practicality in a market-driven system? These are the underlying questions that all the contributors to this volume are ultimately facing. Moreover, we are beginning to see some of the answers in a variety of built projects, including, I would argue, the best of the HOPE VI affordable housing that has replaced failed high-rise housing projects with mixed-use communities in cities throughout the United States.10 But the real monument of contemporary urban design is, in my view, Chicago’s Millennium Park (2004 official opening).11 In the Battery Park City tradition, the park is both “found space” and a “public–private partnership.” It occupies the site of some highly unsightly railyards between the Loop and the lakefront in the heart of the city that Chicago designers since Daniel Burnham and the 1909 Plan of Chicago had been trying to capture for civic purposes. And the remarkable public quality of the park could never have existed without the remarkable generosity of Chicago’s private philanthropists, who contributed over 175 million dollars to the project. But Millennium Park finally is an expression of the best of America’s “age of reurbanism.” The park masterplan began as a hardnosed, practical effort to build a massive underground parking garage for the Loop, covered with a modest park. With the political leadership of Mayor Richard M. Daley, the philanthropic leadership of John Bryan, and the design leadership of SOM’s Adrian D. Smith, the plan metamorphosed into an underground intermodal transportation center covered by the most important civic space that America has built since 1945. In contrast to the “festival marketplaces” of the 1970s and 1980s, people are brought together not as consumers but as citizens. Perhaps the most impressive aspect of this civic space is the way in which the best of avant-garde design—Anish Kapoor’s sculpture Cloud Gate; Jaume Plensa’s multimedia Crown Fountain; Gustafson Guthrie Nichol’s ecologically inspired Lurie Garden; and above all Frank Gehry’s serpentine bridge and Jay Pritzker Music Pavilion—forms the basis of a space that is genuinely a people’s park. To visit the park is to join a community as diverse as Chicago itself, sharing a space that brings together the best of American design culture. xix
16:21:08:05:08
Page 19
10 The fairest assessment of HOPE VI can be found in Susan J. Popkin et al., A Decade of HOPE VI: Research Findings and Policy Challenges (Washington, D.C.: The Urban Institute, 2004).
11 Timothy J. Gilfoyle, Millennium Park: creating a Chicago landmark (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 2006) is a history worthy of the park itself.
Page 20
FOREWORD
In a deeply felt contribution to this volume composed in 1987, just four years before his untimely death, Spiro Kostof meditates on what he fears is the irreversible loss of a true “public realm” in America and the “communitas” it once represented. Writing when the urban crisis still held the American city in its grip, Kostof fears that the “urban beauty” in the broadest sense that had been the ultimate goal of urban design “is now a thing of the past, beyond resuscitation,” and that, as a result (quoting Paul and Percival Goodman), “our city crowds are doomed to be lonely crowds, bored crowds, humanly uncultivated crowds.” Although there is much in American life that, two decades later, still bears out Kostof’s negative judgment, one especially regrets that he never lived to see the resurgence of American urbanism, or to join the crowds at Millennium Park. Without triumphalism or false optimism, this book points the way toward that recovery of the public realm through urban design that Kostof rightly asserts “holds our pride as a people.”
xx
16:21:08:05:08
Page 20
Page 21
PREFACE DOUGLAS KELBAUGH AND KIT KRANKEL McCULLOUGH It might be helpful to start with what Writing Urbanism is not meant to be. It is not, for instance, meant to be the canon of definitive writings on urbanism and urban design—or even an exhaustive survey. Neither is it a compendium of urban design case studies, or a collection of writings about particular cities. Nor is it about urban planning, as the text’s underlying bias is design-based rather than policy-based. Nor does the book bear any connection to fictional urbanism, such as the surreal short stories of Italo Calvino or the paintings of Giorgio de Chirico. Last, it is not international in scope or voice, as the authors are, with a few exceptions, American. Put simply, the book is a compilation of what we the editors thought were the best articles on urbanism to be found among contemporary American academicians. Many articles were drawn from the Journal of Architectural Education ( J.A.E.) and the conference proceedings of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture (A.C.S.A.), the sponsor of the book, while others were submitted expressly for this volume at our invitation. Following The Green Braid (2007), this volume is the second in a series A.C.S.A. intends to publish with Routledge. The articles are primarily from the last decade or so, although some date back to the 1980s. To this collection, we added essays by nine guest contributors, who were carefully chosen to either complement, clarify, contest, or broaden the collection. We also invited Robert Fishman, our colleague in Taubman College at the University of Michigan, to write the Foreword. As editors, we wrote the introductions to each of the book’s three sections, which divide the material into Urban Process, Urban Form, and Urban Society. The structure and contents are entirely our doing, and reveal our priorities and betray our predilections, although we have attempted to be open-minded and inclusive in both our selections and invitations. Why did we accept the A.C.S.A.’s and Routledge’s invitation to edit such a book? The first reason was that we feel that urbanism is an underappreciated subject and that urban design is an under-developed sensibility in architectural schools and the profession. The hegemony, even fetishization, of the individual building in both the design studio and professional practice continues to plague architectural culture. The singular building— whether signature or vernacular—remains the digit of design in the built environment. The building is still seen as the morphological, legal, financial, and operational unit of urban development. Buildings too rarely engage in dialogue with their urban, not to mention their climatological, setting or cultural context. Designers have fixated on the pixel rather than the picture. And the individual architect—whether a star or journeyperson—is still xxi
16:21:08:05:08
Page 21
Page 22
PREFACE
romanticized as a solo artist. This heroic notion is becoming anachronistic and romanticized in an era when projects, their design teams, sites, and cities are all becoming larger and more complex. Project planning by real estate developers has increasingly replaced urban planning, as the private sector continues to displace the public, in our often unexamined, headlong rush to privatization of government services and the public realm. American architecture seems to have lost its social conscience and civic compass and, as a result, is faced with some basic challenges. Can contemporary architecture and architects be less self-centered? Can today’s cities be more legible, coherent, holistic, authentic, and equitable, as well as aesthetically compatible and consistent? Can we still share common values, even ideals, in today’s fast changing, diverse cultures, or are proliferating pluralism and commodification inevitable? And, if so, can we translate them into compelling, meaningful, and consequential urban form? These essays address these and related questions. The second reason we agreed to work on this volume is the tsunami of urban development that is sweeping the planet and overtopping our cities and their physical, social, and institutional infrastructures, with the attendant issues of inequality, poverty, disease, and geo-political tension. The rate of global urbanization has been accelerating at an alarming rate. There’s been a tripling of the population living in cities since 1950. Suddenly, the first urban century is upon us, with over half of the world’s population living in urbanized areas now and two-thirds expected to by the year 2030. The rapid pace of urbanization is one of the defining and dramatic phenomena of our time. Massive influxes of people from the countryside are swelling and stressing many existing cities, turning them into teeming agglomerations of ten, fifteen, and even twenty million people, with fifteen of the twenty largest conurbations predicted to be in the “developing world.” Cities now animate a singular civilization that envelops the entire planet. They have become the economic engines of the world’s economy, with the city-state starting to eclipse the nation-state as its fundamental economic unit. Ironically, as cities elsewhere have been densifying in recent decades, many American cities have been decanting residents and jobs to the suburbs and exurbs. And some of their least sustainable aspects, single-use zoning and auto-dependency, are being emulated and exported around the world. The third raison d’être for this anthology is the crisis-cum-emergency of ecological deterioration. It is now an article of faith that our carbon-based economy is on a collision course with global climate change, with a guaranteed temperature rise already in the system that may prove disastrous. Whatever climate predictions or underlying causes one chooses to believe, the world is facing a Herculean set of high-stake issues and increasingly difficult trade-offs. Because cities are inherently more energy-efficient than suburbia and exurbia, urbanism will be an essential part of any strategy xxii
16:21:08:05:08
Page 22
Page 23
PREFACE
for sustainability and regeneration. And because the livability, sociability, and formal coherence of cities play a key role in urbanism, urban design will in turn also play a critical role in sustainability. As the effects of human enterprise and consumption spread to every corner of the planet and invade every environmental niche, we are beginning to be much more mindful of our ecological footprints. While acknowledging that the practice of ecology is often socially constructed, dynamic, and emergent, we also recognize that it is ultimately based on the laws of nature, which are for all practical purposes absolute. We are aware that technology is as much a socio-political as an engineering act, and also that the law of unintended consequences is unrelenting and cannot be repealed. And many of us believe the relativism of the post-structural “critical project” during the last quarter century, as insightful and liberating as it may once have been for many designers and theorists, is giving way to more pragmatic theory and “projective” practices. As we move from a critical-distancing-from-theworld to a critical engagement with it, we must be wary of the embrace of corporate capitalism, with its branding and commodification of just about everything, from architecture to zoos. The burgeoning interest in urban design is a significant and positive part of this sea change, and represents more than a jump to larger-scale design; it also represents a paradigmatic shift to a more inclusive and comprehensive agenda. Today’s students and designers need a better understanding of the emerging megalopolis if they are to design buildings that are more than megaforms inserted into a miasma of urban disorder. In America, this means empirically sensitizing ourselves to the contemporary metropolis and our evolving sense of urbanism. It means understanding the nature of community, with all the collateral issues of diversity, distributive justice, social and environmental equity, and citizen participation, as well as the impacts of technology, especially the remarkable promise and pitfalls of the digital revolution. It also means understanding the geo-political and cultural differences between urbanism in North America and in Europe, Asia, and South America, where more and more American designers will work. (We also need to educate more architects and urban designers from the developing world.) Architects, landscape architects, urban designers, and planners could potentially play a more central and activist role in this century than any in history. Their skills and talents have never been more critical or in more demand. They need to be better prepared for the deluge of environmental, economic, political, and social problems and opportunities that come with rapid global growth and urbanization. And they need to fully understand and utilize the ecological leverage they wield in designing and planning, as well as redesigning and replanning, the built environment. We hope this jostle of writings and images will raise the urban consciousness and conscientiousness of architecture students, faculty, and practitioners, as well as their counterparts in the other design and planning xxiii
16:21:08:05:08
Page 23
Page 24
PREFACE
disciplines and professions. In our opinion, the conversation became too private and insular while critical theory dominated the academy for several decades. After the overly heroic and overly rational ambitions of Modernism failed, the academy over-reacted—understandably, arguably—by becoming too disciplinary, theoretical, and pure. It narrowed the agenda to primarily aesthetic issues, first symbolic and historicist, then speculative and avant-garde, more recently digital. The focus on form and surface has been sophisticated and skillful, if too esoteric and rarefied in its original encounter and intrigue with literary theory and post-structuralist philosophy. Some of the authors in this volume and some readers may disagree with this thumbnail analysis, but few would disagree that architecture became more autonomous, disciplinary, and focused on design per se in the last quarter of the twentieth century. (And some would say this shift was for the better.) As we begin to broaden our cone of vision and respread our interdisciplinary wings, urbanism and urban design deserve more and more attention. The math of urbanization, the imperatives of ecology, and the scales of justice suggest a mandate to reboot and to rethink our mission and methods, as well as our ideals, if idealism is still possible in our era of postmodernity. We believe that the knowledge and insights of our academic and professional colleagues, from different generations and institutions, illuminate and develop ways to think about urbanism and urban design. This is not to say that the authors agree or even converge. The discourse is divided, and the intellectual turf is contested and factionalized. Indeed, the territory is as diverse, fascinating, and complex as the city itself. We hope the range of essays and articles conveys the depth and the breadth of the intellectual terrain and will focus attention on these issues in our schools and the professions. But we cannot risk paralysis from over-analysis. Compelled and inspired by discourse and dialogue, we need to act in the world in new and more effective ways. Taubman College of Architecture and Urban Planning University of Michigan October 2007
xxiv
16:21:08:05:08
Page 24
Page 25
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS First and foremost, we must thank the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture for spearheading this series of readers, and for inviting us to edit this volume. We are particularly indebted to Michael Monti, Executive Director of the A.C.S.A., who provided able direction and guidance, with the assistance of Kevin Mitchell of the A.C.S.A. national office. Our trans-Atlantic thanks go to Caroline Mallinder, who was in charge of publications on the built environment for Taylor & Francis Books, and Georgina Johnson, Assistant Editor. Working with them was a pleasure. We wish to also thank our colleagues at the Taubman College of Architecture and Urban Planning at the University of Michigan for their support. In particular, we received critical and substantial help from Keria Rossin, who attended to the endless details of book writing, and Donald Buaku, who provided digital assistance. Christian Unverzagt and Nick Tobier (who is down the hall in the School of Art & Design) shared images from their collections. And of course there were the many contributors, especially those who wrote new essays for the book. These authors are the sine qua non of such a reader, and, like urban design itself, their individual essays combine to form a compendium that is greater than the sum of its literary parts. We are encouraged by the growth of interest and activity in urbanism and urban design, both in the academy and the profession. Like sustainability and social justice, urbanism is one of those bonds that is almost chemical in its strength. They can unite the world in ways that are both common and profound, and we hope this book adds to the conversation and ultimately to the bond itself. As ever, we are grateful for the unflagging support and forbearance of our respective families, especially our spouses Kathleen Nolan and Malcolm McCullough. Kit McCullough Doug Kelbaugh
xxv
16:21:08:05:08
Page 25
Page 26
16:21:08:05:08
Page 26
Page 1
I URBAN PROCESS
16:21:08:05:08
Page 1
Page 2
16:21:08:05:08
Page 2
Page 3
INTRODUCTION KIT KRANKEL McCULLOUGH When asked to compile essays for an urban design reader we jumped in without first establishing for ourselves what constituted urban design. Consequently everything we read was fair game for inclusion in this volume—as long as it touched on urbanism, design, or both. To define urban design is difficult; indeed, there is no accepted definition. On the occasion of the 50th anniversary of the symposium at Harvard University at which José Luis Sert coined the term, Alex Krieger attempted a definition. Drawing from definitions of the word territory in the dictionary, he came up with “spheres of urbanistic action to promote the vitality, livability and physical character of cities.”1 With this definition in mind, we open this book with Urban Process, in which we consider urban design as “spheres of urbanistic action.” While urban design is often defined as architecture at the largest scale, these essays fit comfortably within “spheres of action” as opposed to physical artifact. There is a preference for small actions over big ones, as well as for collective action, with many participants—in short, an emphasis on the “urban” over the “design.” This preference implies that it is the participants that determine the city more than the physical form. The beauty of the expression “spheres of action” is that it implies a community of actors. In other words, it is ultimately people that define the city, and their actions that constitute its design. Which raises the question, what is the role of design in the city? Perhaps the notion of urban design is undesirable, if not unattainable. Often, the urban areas that are most valued and appreciated are ones that seem to have sprung up organically, or at least incrementally, over time—in other words, not designed. Which begs a second question, can a city truly be designed? Indeed, the urban designer of today is not the master architect ego, à la Howard Rourke in The Fountainhead, making heroic design decisions on the behalf of others. History is littered with examples of architects who have attempted to design in this mode at the scale of the city, with failed, even disastrous results. Rather, the role of the urban designer is to enable citizens to act on their own behalf—to design the structure that allows the possibility of the city, rather than to design the city itself. There can be no single designer of the city because the design of the city is not a finite process; rather it is continual and unending. By necessity, the physical form of the city is shaped by multiple forces, players, and parameters. The urban designer has been likened to an orchestra conductor, someone who directs a process to arrive at a desired collective outcome. Urban design, more than other design disciplines, is inter-disciplinary, crossing the boundaries of architecture, planning, landscape architecture, and 3
16:21:08:05:08
Page 3
1 Harvard Design Magazine, Spring/Summer 2006.
Page 4
KIT KRANKEL McCULLOUGH
engineering. Like planning, urban design is a creature of policy, political decision-making, and power structures. Yet it is distinct from urban planning, because it is predicated on three-dimensional form. The process of urban design is to resolve the political, economic, and social vectors with the goal of arriving at urban form that works. Although urban designers focus on built form, their design mode differs from that of the architecture profession, with its emphasis on the new and the inventive. Urban designers instead take a more empiricist and pragmatic approach, observing human interaction with the built environment in an effort to discern which design moves will hold true for a longer time horizon. Cities are meant to last for a very long time. They do not represent the art of any one era, but evolve over time to reflect both the current and cumulative aspirations of their inhabitants. The essays in this chapter make different observations regarding those aspirations, and arrive at different conclusions as to what makes a city work, but they all describe a working city as one that tries to provide equity, sociability, and urbanity. But it should be recognized that not all spheres of urbanistic action are so ideal, or even so visible or recognizable. Many of the actions that shape the city occur within entirely separate spheres and with entirely different motives, from the traffic engineer whose only objective is to move more cars through an intersection to the financial markets that only wish to maximize the returns and minimize the risk of global capital. Many of the essays in this section describe underlying cultural currents that direct our urbanistic actions without our even realizing it. So rather than orchestra conductor, a more apt metaphor for the urban designer may be Greek chorus. Often the urban design process is one of trying to make people more aware of their actions and how those actions impact and ultimately shape the city—a process of not only enabling, but one of education. Some of the processes described in this section are meant to deliberately counter the global, corporate, financial, and cultural forces that act on our cities: charrettes bring direct public participation into the design process. Finance and zoning mechanisms allow average citizens to act as their own developers to build their own homes and neighborhoods. Artists stage art works, protests, and celebrations that help people to see their city differently, and uncover the hidden forces that shape it. Perhaps there is no sphere in which actions shape our physical environment more, or where it is more crucial to raise awareness and enable people to act, than that of environmental sustainability. Sustainability has emerged as the critical issue facing the design professions, one reason why the first volume in this series of readers focuses on this topic. But beyond sustainability as a specific design strategy, we argue in the Preface that urbanism is in and of itself an important contribution toward sustainability. The essays here remind us that urbanists, as stewards of the built environment, are participating in sustainable design. Re-use is a central tenet of sustainability, 4
16:21:08:05:08
Page 4
Page 5
INTRODUCTION
be it the re-use of existing buildings or urban fabric through preservation or through the regeneration of waste materials and spaces. As we noted in the Preface, cities are innately more energy-efficient on a per capita basis than suburban or exurban sprawl; denser is inherently greener. As David Owen points out in his essay, the mere act of living in a city is one of the most sustainable choices one can make. And so, perhaps we arrive at another definition of urban design, one also posed by Alex Krieger: urban design is a frame of mind, a shared commitment to the totality of the built environment—to urbanism, to the city.
5
16:21:08:05:08
Page 5
Page 6
THE VIRTUES OF CITIES OBSERVATIONS
ALEX KRIEGER (1995)
We Americans have long shown ambivalence towards the city. We have been ambivalent about the value of urbanity to our culture, about the appropriate form that the city should take and, especially, about where one is best placed in relationship to the city. How is “a good place to live” typically represented: a charming porch, a conversation held across a trimly kept yard, a bicycle leaning against a picket fence, lots of green space or a stately home? As enticing an evocation as this is, it does not depict a city very well. Indeed, a number of American cultural predilections inadvertently work against establishing good urban places to live. Among our yearnings, for example, is the desire to be on the move. We want to move up, physically, socially and economically. We want to move away, to start again, to do it better the next time around. We want to spread out, to stand apart, to express our individuality. It is not on the quarter-acre that we already own, but on one of the millions yet untaken that we dream about, believing that on it a good place to live and happiness will be found. Notions of rootedness, stability and permanence of place, which in many cultures are identified with good places to live and with urbanity, have been among Americans a less pressing matter. Such yearnings for progress, mobility, individuality and space continue to determine thousands of choices for dwelling on the periphery of existing cities. Not surprisingly, municipal officials, town planners and mayors frequently remark on the diminishing urbanity within their towns. They decry the popularity of regional malls, lament the lack of activity along main street, worry about falling downtown investment and the migration of residents and businesses outward. They blame sprawl for their problems while envying the good fortune of prosperous suburbs. In pondering how their towns might confront such challenges they often, paradoxically, outline a vision that emulates the perceived advantages of life on the periphery. It is not certain whether such emulation ever brings residents back to town, or merchants or places of work, but contributes to the erasure of distinctions between towns, suburbs, hamlets and other forms of settlement. Without its ramifications fully considered, such homogenization has also been an American goal. Pondering human nature, Ralph Waldo Emerson often reflected on the difficulty of acquiring (much less maintaining) both “rural strength and religion” and “city facility and polish.” Less philosophical by nature, nor inhibited by metaphysical opposites, town boosters before and especially since Emerson sought, and often claimed, to have overcome this difficulty. Their efforts to establish what others have ennobled as the “middle 6
16:21:08:05:08
Page 6
Page 7
THE VIRTUES OF CITIES
landscape,” “borderlands,” “garden cities,” “edge cities,” or “greenfields” ultimately reinforce Emerson’s doubts. The great swaths of development between the ever-receding country and the decongested town seem conducive to acquiring neither rural strength and religion nor city facility and polish. So perhaps Woody Allen’s claim that he is “two with nature” contains a useful insight about town design. The long-standing American yearning for a state of settlement in which the benefits of urbanity and nature are enjoyed simultaneously has been exposed as a form of fool’s gold that devalues both town and country. To compete with their ever-spreading peripheries cities and towns might best maintain their own virtues. Under the leavening forces of rampant disaggregation, however, we need frequent reminders of what these virtues are. Density. An essential ingredient of a town is its density, measured not in square feet but in the juxtaposition of artifice with human activity. “I have three chairs in my house:” Thoreau wrote, “one for solitude, two for friendship, three for society.” He may have preferred solitude but understood the civilizing force of aggregation. Density, as distinct from congestion, promotes engagement. Interaction, made possible by proximity, is crucial and far more difficult to sustain where things are spread out across great distance, e-mail notwithstanding. The photographer, Alfred Steiglitz, urged his students to move in a little closer, to crop their scene a little tighter, after they composed a shot. Similar advise would benefit those who build the American city. Outside of a few pockets of genuine congestion, greater proximity among buildings and activities would benefit sociability. Propinquity. In an age promising ever more instant communication it is easy, but wrongheaded, to assume that physical proximity is no longer important. Each day some 75,000 people visit the Mall of America, located in Bloomington, Minnesota, conveniently outside both Minneapolis and St. Paul. Are they there merely to shop, or does the popularity of the place lie partially in enabling a primitive kind of propinquity to occur? Some do shop, while more seem to be riding the indoor roller coaster, posing with the giant Snoopy, building Lego castles and enjoying the crowd. Our need for contact with others is such that we will commute great distances to places like mall concourses, forgetting that they are but simulations of environments traditionally found in cities such as Minneapolis and St. Paul. The popularity of recreational shopping, tourism, theme parks, sporting events, specialized museums, trade shows, movie theaters (despite five hundred cable channels), even charity walk-a-thons, expresses a subliminal need for social contact—for the sheer pleasure of it. Heterogeneity within an ordered fabric. This is a corollary to locating many things and activities close together. The beauty of Boston’s Back Bay lies in the tension between the similarities and differences among the facades along a block, and the repetition of such blocks along streets which 7
16:21:08:05:08
Page 7
Page 8
ALEX KRIEGER
themselves subtly differ in dimension, landscaping, edge definition and principal use. Buildings, like citizens, warrant their idiosyncrasies so long as each behaves civilly toward neighbors. Spaced at intervals of a half-acre or more, the need for civility lessens. There is a kind of illusion of autonomy about buildings spread over a vast landscape. Juxtaposed realms. Lewis Mumford once defined a town as the place where the greatest numbers of choices are available in the smallest geographical area. Nodding approval, we go so far as to label “Central Business District” on our zoning maps and mix offices with shops. The demise of vital downtowns generally parallels the rise in the use of the term Central Business District. Why would anyone want to live, shop, dine, relax, meet a friend, cruise in a convertible, attend a concert, see a movie, go to school, take a walk with a sweetheart, or simply choose to hang out in a place called the Central Business District? Because our downtowns have become mere business districts their appeal diminishes even for businesses that eventually leave in search of environments that offer their employees a wider array of amenities. Instead of pining for the return of business interests to the downtown we should turn our attention to overcoming the absence of all other interests. Neighbors unlike ourselves. Some of the most charming early suburbs, like Forest Hill Gardens in Queens or Roland Park in Baltimore, contained a rich mixture of dwelling sizes and clusters. Diversity in house types is more likely to accommodate diversity of social, economic and age groups. This is not particularly popular among contemporary suburban developers, many of whom cater their subdivisions to increasingly narrow segments of the population. A growing concern about such environments is that they breed indifference, or worse, intolerance, towards social groups beyond their gates. Such indifference is unlikely to enhance democracy. While towns were always made up of defined neighborhoods, and even enclaves, proximity among them, along with shared streets and public spaces, assured regular interaction. Such interaction, or the mere promise of it, remains one of the advantages of town life. Social landmarks. A statue of President McKinley graces and organizes traffic in an otherwise graceless rotary in North Adams, Massachusetts. The center of Riverside, Illinois, one of the nation’s earliest planned suburbs, is marked by a modest train depot and a beautiful water tower. Landmarks confer coherence and legibility, not status. They highlight things that are dear to a community—like remembering a president or the storage of water. They are not produced by labeling, or through form alone. This is apparently beyond the comprehension of those who name their shopping strip “Center Place,” their office park “Landmark Square,” and mark each with a faux campanile. Texture, detail and narrative. The many buffalo gargoyles on the face of the city hall in Buffalo, New York are not only endearing, but relate a 8
16:21:08:05:08
Page 8
Page 9
THE VIRTUES OF CITIES
place-name to an entire epoch of frontier urbanization. An old storefront in New Bedford, Massachusetts may carry reminders of ships, whaling and trade, not unlike a street in modern Tokyo that exhibits the near-cacophony of a culture obsessed with digital technology. Public environments benefit from such excesses. Robert Browning’s “less is more” was not intended to describe a town’s public realm. The aphorism’s principal modern proponent, Mies van der Rohe, could also be heard to say, “God rests in the details.” A preponderance of detail invested with qualities characteristic of a place was for Kevin Lynch essential to good city form. These details are what Italo Calvino’s Marco Polo describes to Kubla Khan in order to make him see the cities of his travels. Connectivity. Some of today’s most frustrating rush hour snarls occur on the perimeter highways, which pass through the uncrowded suburbs. Arterial highways channel traffic and, therefore, limit choice. A network of streets, narrow, crooked and even redundant, provides actual choice and, more importantly, the promise of choice. On a congested highway relief is no closer than the next set of exit ramps, assuming one knows where they lead. By taking a quick left followed by a right while negotiating an urban street grid, a less busy parallel street is found, a traffic back-up may be avoided, a “short-cut” is imagined, a sense of control or freedom is maintained. This is an advantage that every city cabbie understands, but few highway engineers ever acknowledge. Streetfronts. In a typical contemporary subdivision the elements furthest away from the street right-of-way seem to receive the greatest design attention. Unfortunately, this leaves much of what influences the experience of the public realm under-designed. On the inside of the fence in a Phoenix subdivision there are beautiful homes, immaculate lawns, wonderful terraces, decks and gardens. On the public side there is simply a road for circulation assumed to require none of the pleasures provided by fronting on a street, instead of an artery. Immediacy of experience. Americans are known for their dislike of walking. Yet they actually walk hundreds of yards each day through parking lots, through shopping malls, through corridors of large buildings, through airport terminals. Much of this walking is caused by providing for the convenience of the automobile, and much of it is forgettable. In a car, or on foot, we commute to a destination. The suburban landscape seems to only offer destinations. But it is the seductions along an interesting path that make walking—and cities—enjoyable. Sustainability, persistence, and adaptability. While few parts of any city warrant strict preservation, virtually all have potential for reuse. Unfortunately this is often overlooked in the zeal to build anew, usually somewhere else, under the dubious supposition that rebuilding will enable us to get it right the next time. The town of Southfield, a few miles north of Detroit, now boasts a daily commuter population greater than Detroit’s. 9
16:21:08:05:08
Page 9
Page 10
ALEX KRIEGER
Largely made up of office parks strung along a highway, Southfield’s chief advantage seems to be that it is new and not Detroit. And so with each new Southfield a Detroit withers, but, one suspects, only temporarily. Long after the single-function office towers of Southfield become outmoded (or simply less new and less profitable) enough of the infrastructure, street grid, building stock, cultural institutions, historic monuments, and neighborhood domains of Detroit will have survived to initiate, perhaps even inspire, reuse. The archetypal suburban landscape, with its coarse grain of development, relative absence of history, and single-use zoning has yet to prove as adaptable to changing social habits or needs. Overlapping boundaries. A city is like a stacking of translucent quilts, with layers of social, architectural and geographical strata sometimes carefully, sometimes imperfectly registered. Subtle or precise, such overlapping of precincts is crucial to place-making. An environment without perceivable boundaries is amorphous, indistinguishable from its surroundings and generally place-less. This is sadly characteristic of much of the modern metropolitan landscape. With apologies to Robert Frost, good fences may not insure good neighbors but neither does their absence foster connectivity or communality. Public life. A large downtown shopping mall is a marvel of design and a magnet for activity. But a careful observer will note the limited range of activities that takes place inside. You will be ushered out unto the street for behavior deemed inappropriate by the management. On that street, lowly or grand, you have rejoined the town. In a city the sense of proximity to a public realm remains palpable, with standards of acceptable public behavior discreetly reinforced. An urban environment cherishes this relative openness and, therefore, yields to privatization only with considerable reluctance. The potential for a centered life. Against most planners’ predictions, Los Angeles—the proverbial score of suburbs in search of a town—has recently grown a visible downtown. It is really mostly a collection of corporate office towers, the product of speculative land economics at work. Yet perhaps there is something in human nature that seeks comfort in centering, and such vertical outcroppings of commerce satisfy that impulse, at least scenographically. While there may be fewer economic and technological reasons for concentration, the new Los Angeles downtown or, for that matter, the continuing reinvestment in Boston’s much older center, are expressions of support for centering—concentration as a matter of choice rather than as an historic imperative. There are those who believe that we will continue to disaggregate, leaving cities to live in closer proximity to the splendors of nature, with technology providing a modicum of (digital) social contact. Then how does one explain the invention of the “internet” cafe? Will not the very convenience of being able to perform most daily errands, most work functions and most business transactions from the privacy of our own homes (or anywhere else for that 10
16:21:08:05:08
Page 10
Page 11
THE VIRTUES OF CITIES
matter) compel us to escape the attendant disengagement from society? Retarding isolation will remain the special virtue of the contemporary city. In it, and nowhere else as poignantly, a citizen can still partake of the pleasures of overlap, the pleasures of proximity, the pleasures of propinquity.
This essay is abridged from the original, which first appeared in Places: Forum of Design for the Public Realm, September 1995. 11
16:21:08:05:08
Page 11
Page 12
OBSERVATIONS
WORKING CITIES Density, risk, spontaneity J. MAX BOND, Jr. (2001)
Cities reflect social and cultural norms as well as economic and technical means. They are also expressions of belief and will. The current state of our cities reflects much about our time: mobility, governmental policies, technical shifts, race relations, materialism. Notwithstanding the continuing growth of suburbs and their attendant “edge cities” there is also evidence of a renewed interest in our older cities. Urban redevelopment is being driven by a number of factors, from retooling of the local economy to creative re-use of former industrial districts. While this redevelopment is welcome in any guise, contemporary urbanism in the U.S. betrays tendencies that are antithetical to true urban regeneration because they don’t deal with the whole city. We are witnessing the suburbanization of our cities through the replacement of multi-family dwellings with single family homes and row housing. This makes inefficient use of the existing urban infrastructure and impairs the ability of neighborhoods to generate the local commerce that distinguishes walking cities from car-dependent suburbs. Our cities are undergoing a process of sanitization, an effort to redesign complex urban environments with a narrower palette pitched to bourgeois sensibilities. New York City’s Forty-Second Street, for example, was not only a sleazy precinct but also an entertainment center for working class kids. The redevelopment sponsored by Disney may make tourists more comfortable, because it is so familiar, but at the cost of the city’s messy realism. Urban regeneration is often propelled by the gentrification of working class districts into expensive upper middle class enclaves. This process is frequently attended by cultural cleansing and the withdrawal of support systems for people of low income. There is a palpable fear of risk in current American culture that wants to make everything safe and predictable. As a nation we are ambivalent about the very diversity we value. The success of the ersatz townscapes at Disney World’s Epcot and Universal Studios’ City Walk confirms both our attraction to and fear of close encounters with other cultures. The city offers the possibility of the unexpected, even shocking, encounter. These phenomena reinforce the consumerism that is the bedrock of our national economy and ideology. They manifest an imbalance in spending on private as opposed to public amenities, an emphasis on consumer products instead of buildings and places. The shopping mall and festival marketplace remove the agora to privately owned and controlled settings. 12
16:21:08:05:08
Page 12
Page 13
WORKING CITIES
Government policy favors the private automobile over mass transit despite the cost in congestion, pollution and personal injury. Budget surpluses are targeted for tax cuts rather than improved services and environments. We may participate in a global society but we live in geographically specific places. A list of what makes good cities is fairly obvious, encompassing physical, economic, social and environmental elements. But in U.S. cities these elements are rarely applied with equal resources and commitment to the vast areas inhabited by the majority of people—working people in need of working cities. I speak here of quality housing, schools and libraries; of reliable and efficient municipal services; of properly funded and maintained public transportation of parks and playgrounds. In poorer neighborhoods these essentials of decent living are too often inadequate. Because there is a high correlation between poverty and race in our cities, this burden falls disproportionately on minority groups. Transforming a city to serve all the people requires a shift in values, attitude and will. America is rich enough to be able to make choices and create the city that reflects our goals. What will it take to create a working city? An emphasis on ordinary buildings as well as the exceptional. A focus on the public realm and systems. Increased emphasis on the visual quality of the environment. A merging of the disciplines of architecture and urban design. A shift in government priorities to support desirable land uses and urban systems. Support for the local economy, including the informal sector. Cities must be well designed. Urban populations will only grow significantly if cities provide services, amenities and an attractive physical environment for all people. For poor people cities offer opportunity; for artists and dissidents they offer freedom. For all they present the possibility of social interaction and cultural growth. These qualities have been intrinsic to cities throughout history and explain why people still flock to vibrant urban neighborhoods. The range of possibilities offered by cities is also why our urban future does not reside in a risk-free bourgeois vision but in a denser, more broadly based, model of a pluralistic, dynamic and public urbanism.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 89th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 2001. 13
16:21:08:05:08
Page 13
Page 14
OBSERVATIONS
MEANINGFUL URBAN DESIGN Teleological/catalytic/relevant ASEEM INAM (1999)
MEANINGFUL URBAN DESIGN
The conventional approach to defining the field of urban design is morphological; that is, according to the way it is structured and organized. Urban design is often regarded as an ambiguous combination of architecture, urban planning, landscape architecture, and civil engineering. This definition puts urban designers at odds over power and resource with architects, planners, landscape architects, and civil engineers, and thereby dilutes the leading role urban design can play in the blossoming of cities. Furthermore, much of the recent interest in urban design repeats the familiar deficiencies of the past, such as a focus on the superficial aesthetics and picturesque aspects of cities; an over-emphasis on the architect as urban designer and a singular obsession with design; an understanding of urban design primarily as a finished product; and a pedagogical process that is comfortably rooted in architecture and design (e.g. matters of visual composition). One major problem with current urban design thought and practice is the sense that it is architecture, only at a larger scale and within an urban context. In this school of thought, there is far too much emphasis on the “design”, and not enough of an understanding of the “urban.” Attempting to design a city as one designs a building is clearly misleading and dangerous, because unlike individual buildings that tend to be objects, cities are highly complex, large scale, active entities, and contain a bewildering multiplicity of communities. Few contemporary urban designers demonstrate a fundamental understanding of the complex ways in which cities function. Especially glaring is the naiveté of contemporary urban designers vis-à-vis power structures and decision-making processes, which are dominated by politicians, bureaucrats, corporations, developers, and interest groups. I propose a meaningful approach to urban design, one that is truly consequential in improving the essential qualities of city life. The approach consists of being teleological, that is, driven by purpose rather than defined by disciplines; being catalytic, that is, generating or contributing to longterm development processes; and being relevant, that is, grounded in first causes and pertinent human values. In my view, then, urban design is driven by the purpose of addressing fundamental urban challenges, circumscribed by urban scale and complexity, and rests upon an interdisciplinary set of skills, methodologies, and bodies of knowledge.
14
16:21:08:05:08
Page 14
Page 15
MEANINGFUL URBAN DESIGN
TELEOLOGICAL
Urban design is an ongoing process with built forms such as open spaces, building complexes, and districts produced along the way. Primarily, it is a stimulus to other goals that are more critical to society and to the substantive challenges facing contemporary cities. These goals include community empowerment and social integration, inner city revitalization, cross-cultural learning and collaboration, effective land use, and a wider range of urban form choices for citizens. A teleological urban design would address three critical aspects of the urban experience, which are the relationships between the city and the economy, the city and society, and the city and power. The relationship between the city and the economy considers the economic functioning of the city, including the city as a point in the production landscape as well as a site of investment, the changing international division of labor, and the consequent effects on the specific urban economies. The relationship between the city and society focuses on the city as an arena of social interaction, the distribution of social groups, residential segregation, the construction of gender and ethnic identities, and patterns of class formation. The relationship between the city and power is the representation of urban structure and political power, and considers the city to be a system of communication, a recorder of the distribution of power, and an arena for the social struggles over the meaning and substance of the urban experience. Such an approach would address the question: Why should the field of urban design even exist when there are far more powerful actors shaping cities? Because urban design is the only field that is geared specifically to shape the three-dimensional urban environment at multiple scales, and to constantly assert an effective symbiosis between urban form and society and its political-economic structures. CATALYTIC
Urban design projects and processes would generate or contribute significantly to three types of socio-economic development processes while enhancing the built environment of cities: community development; economic development; and international development. Urban design as a catalyst for community development consists of intelligent community participation in projects, facilitated by: dialogue between community representatives and urban designers; community leadership which is representative of broader community views; institutional partnerships, for example between private and nonprofit sectors; decision-making systems such as simulations and games; and the soft-programming of urban design, like the incorporation of public art into projects, and the integration of designed activities, events, programs, and services integrated into built form. 15
16:21:08:05:08
Page 15
Page 16
ASEEM INAM
1 Urban Design Group, “Involving local communities in urban design.”
2 Jones, Pettus and Pyatok, Good Neighbors: Affordable Family Housing.
For the urban designer, design communication is inherent in the act of design, both as internal communication in the thinking process, and as an external communication with the client, user, or broader community. The people within a given context, such as homeowners in a residential neighborhood or business owners in a commercial downtown, are the agents of change, aided by a communication process that speaks to the formal aspects of their environment. The better this communication process of design is, the higher the level of public awareness and sense of ownership, and the better the internal decisions of change. There are conventional public involvement formats such as public hearings, city council meetings, and planning commission presentations, as well as informal meetings, workshops, and brainstorming sessions. The charrette is one of the more powerful and effective mechanisms for active and intelligent community participation. The Urban Design Group in the UK1 provides a series of clear, concise, and extremely useful community participation forums, including innovative mechanisms such as street stalls and interactive displays. The popularity of the computer program SimCity, a city building simulator, attests to the possibility of designing urban simulation models with broad public appeal. These examples point to creative, engaging, and beneficial forms of not only community participation, but more significantly, community development, because they increase community awareness, generate community strategies, and suggest modes of community intervention in the future of their own environments. An example of soft-programming as a long-term process of community development is illustrated by the Hismen Hin-nu Terrace housing project in Oakland, California.2 With a grant from the City of Oakland, the architect Michael Pyatok studied development scenarios for housing and neighborhood services on several sites in the city and organized a series of workshops using participatory modeling kits to help over 30 neighborhood participants to design plans for the site and to understand the implications of density. The project not only houses families and elderly citizens with low incomes, but also helps mend a deteriorating neighborhood by restoring its main boulevard with housing over shops. Family housing with a day care center around quiet courtyards is built behind a ground-floor market, niches for street vendors, and a job-training center, all of which contribute to community development in the neighborhood. A multi-ethnic mix of tenants is depicted in exterior murals, frieze panels, decorative tiles, and steel entry gates in the form of a burst of sunshine. The art is intended to prove that America’s cultural diversity is a source of energy for creating community, rather than a source of conflict. Urban design as a catalyst for economic development involves designing projects that generate employment on a long-term basis, that attract investment into deprived areas, and that increase business and tax revenues. 16
16:21:08:05:08
Page 16
Page 17
MEANINGFUL URBAN DESIGN
Horton Plaza, a highly successful shopping center in San Diego, generated jobs for local residents when city officials utilized their position as stakeholders in the project to fill half of the nearly 1,000 new jobs, with 70 percent minority workers and 60 percent from high-unemployment, low-income neighborhoods. Urban design as a catalyst for international development takes the guise of sensitivity to indigenous and cosmopolitan contexts, the generation of cross-cultural learning, and urban mediations of economic globalization. Cross-cultural learning arises out of understanding and applying in a sympathetic and appropriate manner, urban design methodologies, processes, and forms from different cultural contexts.3 For example, housing authorities in the United States could learn from Henri Ciriani’s social housing projects in France, which serve as a demonstration of how largescale low-income housing projects built by the government can constitute positive contributions to the urban environment instead of being eyesores. La Courdangle, a large social housing project outside Paris in Saint Denis,4 is a seven-story building with striped cladding and geometric frieze that forms a corner in an otherwise loosely structured urban space. By creating a visually strong plan of geometrical precision, the project inspires a still-life composition device in urban design. Transformed into a picture plane, the various free-standing buildings as well as high-rise buildings that surround the project integrate into a more harmonious urban setting. The courtyard side of the building is a pure, right-angled figure containing a perfectly defined square space. The layering of the facades facilitates the articulation of the decreasing volumes, contains the apartments’ balconies and terraces, and mediates between the architecture of the building and the urbanity of the neighborhood. In this manner, La Courdangle constitutes a low-income housing project that is rich in architectural spaces and detail, while helping define and enhance the urban space around it. The ongoing phenomenon of globalization suggests some strategies for urban designers. Urban designers must be able to understand and react to influences impinging on their communities, regardless of where those influences originate (e.g. World Bank funded housing projects in developing countries) and which actors are responsible (e.g. American architectural firms designing office complexes in London). Furthermore, urban designers must develop associations and networks that extend beyond their spatial reach through collaborative endeavors and thereby provide another mechanism for responding to the multitude of actors who shape their communities. For example, the Indian architect B.V. Doshi utilized an institution, the Vastu-Shilpa Foundation for Studies and Research, to develop an internationally funded (i.e. World Bank), local (i.e. Indore, India) housing project in India, Aranya Nagar.5 The project has been largely a success due to the Vastu-Shilpa Foundation, which carried out considerable research, including surveys to understand the physical and economic factors that 17
16:21:08:05:08
Page 17
3 Inam, “Institutions, routines, and crises: post-earthquake housing recovery in Mexico City and Los Angeles.”
4 Ciriani, Henri Ciriani, pp. 66–73.
5 Serageldin, The Architecture of Empowerment: People, Shelter and Livable Cities.
Page 18
ASEEM INAM
determine the size, type, and density of the housing plots that were specific to the local context. The project translated international expectations into local needs through grassroots research. RELEVANT
6 Kostof, The City Shaped: Urban Patterns and Meanings Through History, p. 13.
7 Ibid., p. 100. 8 Ibid., pp. 10–11.
Urban design that is relevant is pertinent to matters at hand, and is based on fundamental human and natural conditions. I highlight three such relevant approaches to urban design: (1) a history of urban form that analyzes the determinant processes and human meanings of form, (2) a theory of urban form that is normative and based on human values, and (3) a design methodology of urban form that is empirically based and derived from patterns of human behavior. Urban form is related directly to urban process over time; that is, the conjunction of people, forces, and institutions that brings about urban form. A way to examine this historical process is to ask probing research questions: Who actually designs cities? What procedures do they go through? Which are the empowering institutions and laws? Urban process also refers to physical change through time. The tendency all too often is to see urban form as a finite thing and a complicated object, but thousands of witting and unwitting acts every day alter a city’s lines in ways that are perceptible only over a certain stretch of time. City walls are pulled down and filled in; once rational grids are slowly obscured; a slashing diagonal boulevard is run through close-grained residential neighborhoods; railroad tracks usurp cemeteries and waterfronts; and wars, fires, and highways annihilate city cores.6 As an example, let us consider the grid in history. The point is made regularly that grids, especially in the United States, besides offering simplicity in land surveying, recording, and subsequent ownership transfer, also favored a fundamental democracy in property market participation. This did not mean that individual wealth could not appropriate considerable property, but rather that the basic initial geometry of land parcels bespoke a simple egalitarianism that invited easy entry into the urban land market. The reality, however, is much less admirable. Ordinary citizens gained easy access to urban land only at a preliminary phase, when cheap rural land was being urbanized through rapid laying out. To the extent that the grid sped this process and streamlined absentee purchases, it may be considered an equalizing social device. Once the land had been identified with the city, however, this advantage of the initial geometry of land parcels evaporated, and even unbuilt lots slipped out of common reach. What matters most in the long run is not the mystique of the grid geometry, but the luck of first ownership.7 For the conventional urban designer, a grid is simply a grid.8 At best it is a visual theme upon which to play variations: he or she might be concerned with issues like using a true checkerboard design versus syncopated block 18
16:21:08:05:08
Page 18
Page 19
MEANINGFUL URBAN DESIGN
rhythms, with cross-axial or other types of emphasis, with the placement of open spaces within the discipline of the grid, with the width and hierarchy of streets. For the meaningful urban designer, on the other hand, how, and with what intentions, the Romans in Britain, the builders of medieval Wales and Gascony, the Spanish in Mexico, or the Illinois Central Railroad Company in the American Midwest employed the same device of settlement is the principal substance of a review of orthogonal design. In fact, the grid has accommodated a startling variety of social structures, including territorial aristocracy in Greek Sicily, the agrarian republicanism of Thomas Jefferson, the cosmic vision of Joseph Smith in Mormon settlements like Salt Lake City, and capitalist speculation. There have been few serious attempts at a comprehensive and normative theory of urban form. The book Good City Form is an impressive and daring attempt by Kevin Lynch9 at a systematic effort to state general relationships between the form of a place and its value to society. Lynch generalizes performance dimensions, which are certain identifiable characteristics of cities due primarily to their spatial qualities and are measurable scales along which different groups achieve different positions. These performance dimensions are based on the following thinking: The good city is one in which the continuity of [a] complex ecology is maintained while progressive change is permitted. The fundamental good is the continuous development of the individual or the small group and their culture: a process of becoming more complex, more richly connected, more competent, acquiring and realizing new powers—intellectual, emotional, social and physical . . . So that settlement is good which enhances the continuity of a culture and the survival of its people, increases a sense of connection in time and space, and permits or spurs individual growth: development, within continuity, via openness and connection . . . [a settlement that is] accessible, decentralized, diverse, adaptable, and tolerant to experiment. 10 In Lynch’s theory of good city form, there are seven basic dimensions. First is vitality, which is the degree to which an urban form supports the vital functions, biological requirements, and capabilities, and protects the survival of human beings, for example, via adequate throughput of water, air, food, and energy. Second is sense, which is the degree to which an urban form is clearly perceived and mentally differentiated as well as structured in time and space, and the degree to which that mental structure connects with the residents’ values and concepts, for example, via a distinct identity and unconstrained legibility. Third is fit, which is the degree to which urban form matches the pattern and quantity of actions that people usually engage in, for example, via compatibility between function and form. Fourth is access, which is the ability to reach other people, activities, resources, and 19
16:21:08:05:08
Page 19
9 Lynch, Good City Form.
10 Ibid., pp. 116–117.
Page 20
ASEEM INAM
11 Moore and Marans, Advances in Environment, Behaviour, and Design.
places, including the quantity and diversity of the elements that can be reached, for example, via ease of communication and movement. Fifth is control, which is the degree to which the creation, access, use, maintenance, and modification to urban spaces and activities is managed by those who use, work or live in them, for example, via localized power. Sixth is efficiency, which is the cost of creating and maintaining an urban form, for example, via less energy-demanding processes. Seventh is justice, which is the way in which urban form costs and benefits are distributed among people, according to a principles such as intrinsic worth or equity, for example, via equal protection from environmental hazards such as traffic and pollution. A problem-solving approach to urban design would explicitly render its design methodology, and describe how a meaningful urban designer might draw directly from empirical evidence and systematic research. The book A Pattern Language by Christopher Alexander et al. is most useful as a series of thoroughly analyzed and empirically based guidelines to solving common problems of urban form. Each suggested solution is described in a way that provides the key relationships, for example, between human behavior and spatial setting, needed to solve the problem, but in a general enough manner to allow for adaptation to particular lifestyles, aesthetic tastes, and local conditions. Each pattern describes a problem that occurs repeatedly in the built environment. The authors outline an urban design methodology that is based on archetypal problems (e.g. neighborhood size), analyses of built examples, descriptions of historical precedents, and the explicit unpacking of design solutions to render them clear, relevant, and thoughtful. The basis for the design patterns was extensive and thorough empirical research carried on over an eight-year period. There continues to be voluminous research on environment and behavior (e.g. Moore and Marans11) that is highly relevant and useful for urban designers. DESIGNING THE FUTURE OF URBAN DESIGN
12 Inam, “City, catalyst of hope.”
Urban designers are beginning to question what in fact is “urban” in the contemporary environment. A city is and will continue to be a relatively large, dense, and permanent settlement (or network of settlements) of socially heterogeneous individuals, and a point (or points) of maximum concentration for the power and culture of a community. A city is, and will continue to be, a catalyst: its power of attraction providing a concentration and diversity of peoples and purposes; its form celebrating the rich complexity of the human condition; its essence the true nature of human potential.12 In this vein, urban designers should focus more on the “urban” of urban design, and become less infatuated with the “design” of urban design. Urban design must begin with cities: how they work, how they change, and what impacts they have in creating enabling versus destructive impacts. 20
16:21:08:05:08
Page 20
Page 21
MEANINGFUL URBAN DESIGN
For example, urban design has to be seen as both, within the framework of investment and development policies, and as a shaper of those policies. Examples include David Crane’s “capital web of investment decisions”,13 and Richard Lai’s “invisible web of laws”14 that guide people’s behavior. An illustration of these “webs” is the dependence on private investments and initiatives for downtown rebuilding in American cities that has changed urban politics and the nature of the public realm. Private investment is generally seen as performing functions in the public interest. The public sector has become a facilitator; it responds to, reacts to, and regulates private initiatives. There is give-and-take in these public–private transactions as developers demand enhanced development rights, zoning variances, land write-down, financial guarantees, or improvements in order to initiate investment in American downtowns, while planners require in return certain urban amenities, usually public open space, street improvements, public art, housing, or even day care centers.15 The form of the contemporary urban downtown is a product of negotiation, bargaining, and deal-making between city governments and private developers, and not simply the product of an urban designer’s imagination. In this essay, there are three levels of success for an urban design project. These include first, the purely aesthetically informed notion of urban design as a finished product: Does it look good? By the means of compressing its meanings into a concise formal expression, a poetic urban design project draws the mind to a level of perception concealed behind the conventional presentations of urban form. The second is the sense of the project as an object that functions in an affordable, convenient and comfortable manner for its users: Does it work well? By the means of a meticulous understanding of human behavior and human needs, a truly utilitarian urban design project creates an environment that satisfies its users. The third is to have the urban design project generate or substantially contribute to socio-economic development processes: Does it produce significant long-term impacts? In this framework, urban designers and urban design projects become catalysts for long-term human development processes such as community betterment, economic improvement, and cross-cultural understanding. The critical question that guides this meaningful future of urban design is: So what? That is, what consequential purpose has been achieved by particular urban design theories, urban design methodologies, urban design practices, and urban design projects? In order to further develop this line of thought, we can look to the American school of philosophy known as pragmatism. Pragmatism may be best characterized as the attempt to assess the significance for human value of technology in the broadest sense; that is, technology as the totality of means employed to provide objects necessary for human sustenance.16 The primary question that pragmatism raises is the question of meaning. Under what conditions does a statement 21
16:21:08:05:08
Page 21
13 David Crane, Planning and Design in New York: A Study of Problems and Processes of its Physical Environment.
14 Richard Lai, Law in Urban Design and Planning: The Invisible Web.
15 Loukaitou-Sideris and Banerjee, Urban Design Downtown: Poetics and Politics of Form.
16 Kaplan, The New World of Philosophy, p. 14.
Page 22
ASEEM INAM
have meaning, and what meaning attaches to it in the light of those conditions? What these formulations amount to is this: What conceivable bearing does a proposition, such as meaningful urban design, have on the conduct of our lives? Meanings, above all, involve purposes: and a meaningful urban design should involve the most substantive purposes of generating long-term processes of human development and ensuring that outcomes of those processes are highly pertinent to fundamental human values. Such an approach to urban design requires profound cultural understanding, social sensitivity, political savvy, and an in-depth grasp of the nature of cities; but in order to be truly meaningful, it needs to be driven primarily by a moral imperative. We can no longer afford to conceive of critical urban challenges—such as poverty and homelessness—and the socio-economic development processes that address them as being separate from urban design practices and projects. To be effective urban designers, we must help design the processes that shape our cities and foster true human development. REFERENCES
Alexander, C., S. Ishikawa, M. Silverstein, M. Jacobson, I. Fiksdahl-King and S. Angel (1977) A Pattern Language: Towns, Buildings, Construction (New York, Oxford University Press). Adams, P. (1997) SimCity, Cities: The International Journal of Urban Policy and Planning, 14 (6): pp. 383–392. Beauregard, R. (1995) Theorizing the global-local connection, in: P. Knox and P. Taylor (Eds.) World Cities in a World System (Cambridge, Cambridge University Press). Bratt, R. (1986) Public housing: the controversy and the contribution, in: R. Bratt, C. Hartman and A. Meyerson (Eds.) Critical Perspectives in Housing (Philadelphia, Temple University Press). Ciriani, H. (1997) Henri Ciriani (Rockport MA, Rockport Publishers). Crane, D. (1966) Planning and Design in New York: A Study of Problems and Processes of its Physical Environment (New York, Institute of Public Administration). Ellin, N. (1996) Postmodern Urbanism (Cambridge MA, Blackwell Publishers). Frampton, K. (1992) Modern Architecture: A Critical History (3rd edn., London, Thames and Hudson Limited). Harvey. D. (1996) On architects, bees, and possible urban worlds, in: C. Davidson (Ed.) Anywise (New York, Anyone Corporation). Inam, A. (1985) L’Architecture rurale en Inde: indices vers un avenir. Master’s thesis in architecture, Paris, Ecole des Beaux-Arts. Inam, A. (1991) City, catalyst of hope. Manifesto, St. Louis, Washington University. Inam, A. (1992) The urban monument: symbol, memory, presence. Master’s thesis in urban design, St. Louis, Washington University. Inam, A. (1997) Institutions, routines, and crises: post-earthquake housing recovery in Mexico City and Los Angeles. Doctoral dissertation in urban planning, Los Angeles, University of Southern California. 22
16:21:08:05:08
Page 22
Page 23
MEANINGFUL URBAN DESIGN
Jacobs, A. (1993) Great Streets (Cambridge MA, M.I.T. Press). Jones, T., W. Pettus and M. Pyatok (1995) Good Neighbors: Affordable Family Housing (New York, McGraw-Hill). Kaplan, A. (1961) The New World of Philosophy (New York, Vintage Books). Katz, P. (1994) The New Urbanism: Towards an Architecture of Community (New York, McGraw-Hill). Kelbaugh, D. (1997) Common Place: Toward Neighborhood and Regional Design (Seattle, University of Washington Press). Koolhaas, R. (1995) Small, Medium, Large, Extra Large (Rotterdam, 010 Publishers). Kostof, S. (1991) The City Shaped: Urban Patterns and Meanings Through History (Boston, Bulfinch Press). Lai, R.T. (1988) Law in Urban Design and Planning: The Invisible Web (New York, Van Nostrand Reinhold). Loukaitou-Sideris, A. (1996) Cracks in the city: addressing the constraints and potentials of urban design, Journal of Urban Design, 1 (1): pp. 91–103. Loukaitou-Sideris, A. and T. Banerjee (1998) Urban Design Downtown: Poetics and Politics of Form (Berkeley, University of California Press). Lynch, K. (1984) Good City Form (Cambridge MA, M.I.T. Press, first published 1981 as A Theory of Good City Form). Moore, G. and R. Marans (Eds.) (1997) Advances in Environment, Behavior, and Design: Toward the Integration of Theory, Methods, Research, and Utilization (New York, Plenum Press). Moudon, A. (1992) A Catholic approach to organizing what urban designers should know, Journal of Planning Literature, 6 (4): pp. 331–349. Relph, E. (1976) Place and Placelessness (London, Pion). Rowe, P. (1991) Making a Middle Landscape (Cambridge MA, M.I.T. Press). Saunders, W. (1997) Rem Koolhaas’s writing on cities: poetic perception and gnomic fantasy, Journal of Architectural Education, 51 (1): pp. 61–71; and below, pp. 217–231. Scott Brown, D. (1990) Urban Concepts (London, Academy Editions). Serageldin, I. (Ed.) (1997) The Architecture of Empowerment: People, Shelter and Livable Cities (London, Academy Editions). Short, J.R. (1996) The Urban Order: An Introduction to Cities, Culture, and Power (Cambridge MA, Blackwell Publishers). Urban Design Group (1998) Involving local communities in urban design, Urban Design Quarterly, Issue 67 (July): pp. 15–38. Whyte, W. (1988) City: Rediscovering the Center (New York, Doubleday).
This essay is abridged from the original published in the Proceedings of the 87th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 1999. 23
16:21:08:05:08
Page 23
Page 24
MATHEMATICS OF THE IDEAL ROADTRIP OBSERVATIONS
1 Jean Baudrillard, America, Chris Turner trans. (London: Verso, 1988), p. 81.
CHRISTOPHER MONSON (1986)
[We Europeans] shall never enjoy the same freedom—not the formal freedom we take for granted, but the concrete, flexible, functional, active freedom we see at work in American institutions and in the head of each citizen. Our conception of freedom will never be able to rival their spatial, mobile conception, which derives from the fact that at a certain point they freed themselves from [a] historical centrality. Jean Baudrillard, from the roadtrip classic America 1 On U.S. Highway 93, which runs through the Flathead Valley from British Columbia to Missoula and on south eventually to Arizona, lies the city of Kalispell, Montana. Save for its spectacular mountain setting, this small city might be mistaken for any typical American place, being formed by two intersecting highways and orthogonally gridded, with streets numbered north to south and avenues east to west. Through Kalispell, U.S. 93 becomes the city’s Main Street. On its south end, Main Street is forced around a plot in the middle of the roadway, the site of the Flathead County Courthouse. This physical fact would be unremarkable—the building being neither particularly handsome nor its siting unusual—except for the curious experience of driving around it. One can sense clearly, even without benefit of a map, that the Courthouse occupies the singular instance in the entire city grid where the regulation of order, of movement, was denied for another public domain: the symbolic center of regional government. Certainly the reading intended at Kalispell is that of the “noble city,” of a citizenry made virtuous by the centrality of government. And yet traveling around this plot, full with its civil aspirations of both place and polity, remains a distinctly troublesome act, not merely in the discomfort of following short curves in a road that by rights should be straight, but with the nagging fact of that particularly American feeling—by rights it should be straight. Such a thought might be dismissed as anti-authoritarian American populism if it were not for the suspicion that it is exactly such populism the siting of the Courthouse seems to be resisting. After all, broad avenues topped with courthouses are more Haussmann than Everyman. But the concern may be less a question of unwarranted authority than one of deference to an outside tradition. It appears that the Courthouse’s placement—a site deviation of a mere 150 feet from the grid in which it might have easily been built—is construed to be a civil act of profound consequence. The clear suggestion is that the grid itself does not contain this political necessity; that the Courthouse site, as a dis-placement of both the ordered field and of 24
16:21:08:05:08
Page 24
Page 25
MATHEMATICS OF THE IDEAL ROADTRIP
movement through it, is seen to exhibit some ideal civility that its surrounds apparently lack. The denial of movement for the institution of a traditional center strikes at the heart of the American social compact. It is this assault put to the possibility of indigenous form which makes Kalispell and places like it so disconcerting, both to the citizen and the enlightened critic. Baudrillard makes the point that it is exactly such urban civil traditions that have been superseded by the American project: a “historical centrality” overcome by the spatial and mobile conception of American freedom. If Baudrillard offers reason for the anxiety caused by Kalispell’s formal nature, then we have a right to wonder about the recurring attempts to institute a civil order in America through this Trojan Horse of historic form. Should this challenge to an indigenous American civil form go unquestioned? Confronted with the rapid academic and legislative legitimization of postmodern urban strategies, Americans might do better by revisiting those who have offered criticism of these appropriated traditions. Frank Lloyd Wright made a career out of it (most notably with Broadacre City), a practice largely indebted to the eloquent plea of Horatio Greenough nearly a century before: “The want of an illustrious ancestry may be compensated, fully compensated; but the purloining of the coatof-arms of a defunct family is intolerable.”2 Perhaps the issue is not that Americans haven’t thought it incorrect to appropriate the forms of history— certainly, thinkers have long offered arguments to the contrary. But there still appears to be a lack of faith in the possibility of a commensurate democratic order outside of this history and its aristocratic ideals. This is indeed a problem. Against the backdrop of history’s great intellectual and 25
16:21:08:05:08
Page 25
Main Street in Kalispell, Montana, with axial view toward the Flathead County Courthouse. (Photo: Karen Nichols.)
2 Horatio Greenough, “American Architecture” in Form and Function: Remarks on Art, Design, and Architecture (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1958), p. 64.
Page 26
CHRISTOPHER MONSON
3 These thoughts, and the subsequent issues of maintenance and reciprocity, are indebted to the work of Christopher Risher, Jr., and illuminated in his unpublished manuscript “The Problem with Natchez,” p. 2.
artistic achievements, it is not certain whether we might produce comparable successes which exemplify a society of equality.3 To what then can a truly American ideal aspire? The lesson from Kalispell is that the movement expected within the American landscape instills some possibility toward giving form to the collective. The functions of the road which manifest this notion—one could suggest its “mathematics”—give reason to suspect imposed hierarchy, precisely because the road’s nature, its equanimity, diversity, and individuality, is seen counterpoised to such traditions. The search for the proper American collective begins with the fact of movement. THE INDIVIDUAL
4 Baudrillard, p. 75.
5 Reyner Banham, Los Angeles: The Architecture of Four Ecologies (New York: Penguin Books, 1971), p. 23.
Movement was an undertaking begun long before the actual transformation of the American continent. But its earliest manifestation was intellectual, not physical. The political philosophies of the Enlightenment, which had become pregnant with the possibility of an Arcadian world of complete social reorganization, were persistently thwarted by entrenched western governments. Bound from above, Europe was a place that required political and ideological revolution; Arcadia was this, but moreover a moral revolution as well. Such a utopian project, impossible from within the world it was designed to escape, was in search for entirely new ground on which to birth and develop. It is this “fantasy of emigration”4 that from the very beginning defined America. More than the simple physical leap from the Old world to the New, this movement, through the free act of abandoning the historic sociopolitical structure, brought the individual to new light. Movement became the construct by which the newly discerned citizen was gleaned from the sovereign order. But more importantly, emigration materialized the individual in space and the new body politic that this dramatic departure could define. Movement has become the very lore of American life, from the Clipper ship, the DC-3, the ’57 Chevy, to the conquest of space. America’s stories are those told through windshields: Steinbeck, Pirsig, and Kerouac all searched for America on its roads, as did those from the old culture whose perceptions have proved insightful here—Baudrillard’s late twentiethcentury roadtrip mirrored Alexis de Tocqueville’s original tour in the early nineteenth century. Reyner Banham put his finger to it saying, “like earlier generations of English intellectuals who taught themselves Italian in order to read Dante in the original, I learned to drive in order to read Los Angeles in the original.”5 Much of this necessity for firsthand experience is legacy to the formal organization of the land. It is nearly inconceivable that the great American enterprise of movement would ever have been as intense or productive without the very shape of the landscape—the fact of the grid. 26
16:21:08:05:08
Page 26
Page 27
MATHEMATICS OF THE IDEAL ROADTRIP
The institution of the continental grid, the six-square-mile township divisions outlined in the Northwest Ordinance of 1787, was a dramatic invention of the young democracy, even though colored by the dissension and misjudgments one would expect from an undertaking so radically unproven.6 But of larger interest here is the sympathy of the idea to the intrinsic American condition. Thomas Jefferson defended the grid as an assurance that “as few as possible shall be without a little portion of land,”7 and its application was designed as a formal demonstration of that belief. The grid also had the conceptual advantage of providing—in a single legislative idea—the spatial delineation of the entire continent, incorporating lands both urban and rural, undeveloped and never intended for development.8 In that sense, the grid system contained within itself the complete social integration of place, and the landscape was thus marked with equality’s fundamental sign: a social and spatial congruency as in the Buddhist mandala, or the South American Jesuit villages ordered around the cross.9 The grid has always been about fluidity and movement, rather than place or centrality. Even the surveyor’s graceful path of subdividing a township was evidence of this. But nothing could be more illustrative than the fact that towns through the grid were located abstractly every sixth square mile, as a consequence of the system of calibration.10 This was a conscious attempt to objectify the landscape such that the whole existed as agency for the individual. In this schema, one would not be able to find any reference to center, because the basic unit of land was produced through the orthogonal system and its disseminating network of movement.11 It is the grid’s utter denial of center which explains its criticism through comparisons with traditional urban types. As a pure formalist exercise, theorists have always found it both amazingly cogent and maddeningly naïve. It is this apparent “obviousness” that has made the grid a sort of magic talisman for democracy; its emblematic simplicity reduced to an abstraction of orthographics. But it is not this type categorization that best suits the political reality, in fact quite the opposite. If movement is, as suggested, the concretized form which describes and maintains the individual in the collective American psyche, the grid is then the very effort, the essence, the “place” of equality, the only “center” that may be realized. And in this, it is not symbol so much as it is work. This idea of the grid’s work, as both noun and verb, brings forth issues that are more active than simply demonstrative. The economy of the grid, the construction of property rights, personal liberties and jurisprudence are not only manifestations of societal norms, but they also act as methods: procedures which allow for the maintenance of these utopian ideals. Both manifestation and method are inherently necessary for the exemplification of the individual, and together with that individual define the spatial construct of the democratic collective. In this field of democracy, the 27
16:21:08:05:08
Page 27
6 See Hildegard Binder Johnson, Order upon the Land (New York: Oxford University Press, 1976), Chap. 3. 7 Johnson, p. 39.
8 André Corboz, Looking for a City in America: Down These Mean Streets a Man Must Go (Santa Monica: The Getty Center for the History of Art and Humanities, 1992), p. 51. 9 This paraphrases Foucault’s observation of the Jesuits. Michel Foucault, “Of Other Spaces” in Diacritics Spring 1986, p. 27. 10 Benjamin Gianni, Bryan Shiles, and Kevin Kemner, Dice Thrown (New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 1989), p. 18. 11 Corboz, p. 51.
Page 28
CHRISTOPHER MONSON
12 Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy in America, George Lawrence trans. (New York: Harper and Row, 1988), p. 507.
13 Peter Blake, God’s Own Junkyard: The Planned Deterioration of America’s Landscape (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1979), p. 49. 14 Robert Venturi, Complexity and Contradiction in Architecture (New York: The Museum of Modern Art, 1990), p. 104.
citizenry is identified and enabled by these actions it generates: the image of collectivity, its manifestation, and the fact, the method, of its making. This is a particularly important issue in understanding the place of America. Unlike the metaphorical grounding of perspectival space—where the citizenry becomes a pawn in a transcendent order which exceeds them— the mutuality inherent to the operation of the grid is real reciprocity in real time, without the mediating influence of either outside authority or representation. It is, in effect, a physical achievement of equality. This too is the craft of the Constitution: a social pact not by egalitarian imposition, but through the fact that all are equal from the outset. A democracy attendant with equality is thus both manifestation and method, living within a utopian ideal while at the same time enabling its very possibility. Many would attribute this startling product of the American system to the achievement of individual freedom. Certainly Tocqueville employed this analysis. Yet, as Jefferson maintained throughout his life, the great threat to free societies was their inherent tendency toward individual excess at the expense of the common good. Tocqueville spent a good deal of his energy assessing what he called “individualism,” which “at first only dams the spring of public virtues, but in the long run it attacks and destroys all the others too and finally merges in egoism.”12 It is this excess, this “Darwinian” aspect of the idea of freedom, that was described as the single most dangerous problem of democracies. Individualism remains an issue that, despite the brilliant Constitutional development of balances to keep it in check, no doubt still exists in various disturbing forms in contemporary America, as it always has to greater or lesser degrees. And despite the recent wholesale repudiation of Marxism, we cannot ignore the great political struggles that have been borne worldwide to overcome the ideological excesses of both capital and individual freedom. It is this same excess of American formal freedom that Peter Blake denounced in his categorical dismissal of New Orleans’ Canal Street compared to what he considered the lost possibilities of Jefferson’s lawn at the University of Virginia. In the face of Blake’s assertion that Canal Street was banal and completely without civil character,13 Robert Venturi was eventually to defend the natural condition of Main Street by quipping that it was instead “almost all right.”14 In large part, the present argument might be represented by these two American forms: the compelling image of new world order proposed at Charlottesville and the functional pragmatic of street life in New Orleans. But neither alone is the proper paradigm. Instead, it might indeed be the “almost all right”—the middle ground between the pleas of Blake and Venturi—that offers fertile ground: not in the Venturian sense, that Main Street would be all right if only architects had reordered its present peculiarities, but in the possibility that the civil ideal may yet be latent in forms of the commonplace. 28
16:21:08:05:08
Page 28
Page 29
MATHEMATICS OF THE IDEAL ROADTRIP
We begin to see that both of the extreme conditions—historic hierarchy and pure excessive freedom—thrive only by subjugating their systems to their own very particular requirements. It is instead the operation of the “temperate between” which might appear more proper as an indigenous system, realizing that the natural American “place” must be between these two poles; its manifestation, its things, and its people, exist as indivisible with the method which both generates and defends them. This give and take between being liberated and producing liberty is the proper and necessary project of equality. 29
16:21:08:05:08
Page 29
Peter Blake’s comparison of the University of Virginia lawn and Canal Street in New Orleans. [Photos: UVA by George Cserna. Canal Street by Wallace Litwin. From Peter Blake, God’s Own Junkyard: The Planned Deterioration of America’s Landscape (New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, 1979), p. 48.]
Page 30
CHRISTOPHER MONSON
THE OBJECT AND THE GRID 15 This reevaluation of the determinism of rationality is perhaps the most useful work of deconstruction theory. Baudrillard goes as far as to suggest that these concepts are already realized in America: “[E]verything we have dreamed in the radical name of anticulture, the subversion of meaning, the destruction of reason and the end of representation, that whole antiutopia which unleashed so many theoretical and political, aesthetic and social convulsions in Europe . . . has all been achieved here in America . . .” Baudrillard, p. 97.
The question is, as it perhaps has always been, how does society maintain its formal condition of equality? America appears to provide a particularly rich opportunity for its social order to be exhibited through form. We are taught to believe that this has always been the case: that form “tells” us a collective history—primarily through symbol, formal evolution, and all explained by criticism and contemporaneous events. This is the methodological essence of architectural history. But the definition of this process is recognized by the contemporary theories as highly suspect. Its primary fault lies in the fact that such history is produced by interpretation, and subsequently cannot contain its own structural subjectivity.15 History’s defense is to denigrate form’s ambiguity and put its own procedural truth above and beyond the objects to which it lays claim. The result is form being “prostituted” by history making, and in the brothel of typology, style, and representation, form cannot and does not have any truly autonomous reality. In distinction, the American ideal of democracy necessitates form: not to define the society through visuality or a history, but as physical means and ends for its very existence. This is revealed through the American themes of movement and equality. Movement is a construct of three dimensions and time, while equality is a process of coextensive reciprocity. Both of these operations are questions of space, and so, ultimately, of objective form. Mindful of the requirement to both make visible the indigenous social order (manifestation) and act as its system of production (method), it is the necessity of form that maintains the work of this equality. Form as evidenced by the work of America becomes a maintenance of its ideological basis as well as its proof. Such plurality could not be more distant from the historic reading of form. It is in the ensuing search for form sympathetic to the ideal of equality that we must define those objects and processes which deny this democratic work of maintenance. But such conclusions are better seen through a direct inquiry into form, into architecture. These two paradigms of form— historic subjectivity and American objectivity—might be illuminated by an examination of architecture within that demilitarized zone between the old world of history and the new one of modern democracy, New York City. At the center of this question between history and equality is the comparison of two notable Manhattan landmarks, both sited on its “Main Street”—Fifth Avenue—and suggested as culturally important vehicles for American formal invention, the Solomon R. Guggenheim Museum and Rockefeller Center. The contrast between these two forms is defined by two disparate conditions: Rockefeller as the “center in the grid,” and the Guggenheim as the “thing illuminating the grid.” Comparatively, Rockefeller Center exists less in its “thingness” or 30
16:21:08:05:08
Page 30
Page 31
MATHEMATICS OF THE IDEAL ROADTRIP
“objectness” and more in terms of its delineation of a public space, the famed lower plaza fronting the RCA (now GE) Tower. The entire building project has become known by this trademark feature, one defined by most as memorably American. But, beyond its site and the gigantic systems of engineering and economics necessary for its realization, the formal aspects of the complex come clearly from a historic tradition of centered public spaces. Indeed, the building massing and detailing—its setbacks, materials, and art program—defer thoroughly to the nature of the plaza space which is defined by them. Even a private street was cut through the New York grid and aimed at the plaza to further illustrate its centrality (in a move equal to, but the inverse of, the Courthouse at Kalispell). The Guggenheim by such standards is clearly found wanting, which is exactly how it has always been criticized as a piece of urbanism. Indifferent to the street and its context, by the rules of historiographic analysis its spiral stands aloof and unconversant. Yet through its comparisons of difference, the Museum both illuminates the structural form which allows for its “objectness”—the grid of Manhattan—and encourages its determinant reciprocity with the buildings around it. That is to say its aspects of individuality, or its realization of a “thingness” within the grid, is the process by which it maintains the very same individuality in its neighbors. This operation is evident nearby: no one can now deny the uniqueness of the plain apartment blocks behind the Guggenheim, for it was the Museum building which gave them a reality which themselves they had not had until its construction.16 The normative critique would argue, of course, that it was Rockefeller Center which best represented the fullness of form within the grid. Orthographically detailed from the pedestrian, to the street, to the very skyline of Manhattan, its skillful manipulation of scales speaks to every possible analytical reading. Subsumed by this evaluation, subsequent additions to the Rockefeller complex were burdened with the task of repeating its analytical successes, rather than pursuing the more individual possibilities inherent to the grid (the trite plazas at the feet of both the McGraw-Hill and Exxon Towers are heirs to this fault). The Museum building, on the contrary, presumes no such universalist parti. One would never expect to see another “Guggenheim” aped somewhere down the Avenue, because it speaks not to a reusable formal language, but instead to the real operation of individuality within the larger American schema. Of course, the argument leveled against objects like the Guggenheim is the claim of terror that a city of architectural individuality would be to people; without order, semblance of hierarchy, or a vision of the collective. History contends that situations of illuminated individuality are “placeless,” that they exhibit nothing of the reductive possibility of either judgment or analysis; that they, in fact, become interchangeable. André Corboz notes that such critiques are inclined to believe Americans “would as readily 31
16:21:08:05:08
Page 31
16 This operation is now somewhat compromised. By bringing the contrast of the spiral on Fifth Avenue into submission, the Guggenheim’s recent Gwathmey Siegel addition creates a composition by which the building can be occluded into the reasonability of the grid. See Carter Wiseman, “Guggenheim GoAround” in Architectural Record October 1992, pp. 102–3.
Page 32
CHRISTOPHER MONSON
17 Corboz, p. 43.
number their cities . . . as they do their streets.”17 But these arguments fail to differentiate between their deceitful dismissal of all formal individuality, and the appropriate criticism of excess in places like Houston and Denver, or the suburban vapidity of Orange County in California. These instances are far beyond the reciprocal relationship of the properly manifest “thing in the grid,” and must be seen for what they are. The agency of the grid remains, as it always must, but objects within these oft-cited examples exist only as the collusive economies of capital, development, and tax law will allow. There is nothing of the play of object and system, no suggestion that these places maintain any formal equality. Giving nothing back to the grid, they become the bad objects of a misdirected egoism. THE STREET
It is the reciprocal possibility of form and place, object and grid, which appears most applicable in America, a possibility which is neither Houston nor History. Objecthood is the unique component of the process: it is the maintenance of equality among individuals and the form necessary to accomplish that fact which in essence produces democracy. We can observe such effect from objects which exhibit a particularly American urbanism outside that of tradition, in the manner of architectures like the Guggenheim, as well as from the problematic situations which deny those instances, the Kalispells which rely on the centering operation of history. It is the manifest equality promised in the first case, and the question of unwarranted hierarchy in the second, which tell us that it is through the reciprocities of objecthood that the lessons of democracy are told. Moreover, it is the construct of movement that makes such objects both visible and probable. The individuality of objects is heir to the formal possibilities of the grid, and it is the delineation of this orthogonality—its mathematics—which in turn elucidates the ideal of the road in American placemaking. Movement is both parent and progeny in the process of making equality into form. This is the task of many honest American civil conditions, but none more evocative or telling than that of the street. The condition of the street is subject to both the legislative process of order, the irreducible aspect of the grid, and the public desire for the display of its inherent individuality. By fronting objects on the edge of a collective movement system—which both defines the operation of the individual forms and their very possibility—the street brings forth the essence of a reciprocal relationship of public life, individual liberty, equality which allows for its maintenance, and the formal aspects of an architecture which demonstrate the system as both achieved and becoming. We cannot lose sight of the fact that this American civil ideal is difficult to achieve in the face of tradition. If predisposed to history, Main Street is a 32
16:21:08:05:08
Page 32
Page 33
MATHEMATICS OF THE IDEAL ROADTRIP
myth like that of most fairy tales.18 This handicap of interpretation is also why Kalispell looms ever larger. The imperative of history is widely entrenched, and its ability to satisfy the intellectualization of space without absorbing its true indigenous potential is difficult to battle against. But sustaining the work of an architecture which supports the practical ideals of democratic worth and dignity remains the only real way to manifest the idea of America.19 We must deflect the coercion of history and rein in the excesses of freedom, both of which represent grave threats to civil form: history, in its willful ignorance of equality’s defeat of centrality, and the intemperance of freedom which mindlessly creates vulgarity, ego, and spectacle. We recognize too that, in the end, movement is a practice of space, inextricable from the possibility of architecture. It is this fact that again tells us of the essential work of form in expressing the values and tenets of our society.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 74th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 1986. 33
16:21:08:05:08
Page 33
Main Street in Santa Monica, California. Edgemar, by Frank O. Gehry and Associates, is on the left. (Photo by the author.) 18 Rem Koolhaas has said that the effect of EuroDisney on Europeans is much like that of a large sculpture park, because “the myth of Main Street is as unrecognizable as the myths of all the characters in the Disney stories.” Noted in a studio review at Harvard University’s Graduate School of Design, December 1992.
19 Risher, p. 2.
Page 34
CITY WALKING Laying Claim to Manhattan OBSERVATIONS
1 Michel de Certeau (tr. Steven Rendell), The Practice of Everyday Life (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1984), p. 107.
2 David Harvey, The Condition of Postmodernity (Cambridge, MA: Blackwell, 1990). 3 Sam Bass Warner, Streetcar Suburbs: the Process of Growth in Boston, 1870–1900 (Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1962). 4 Kevin Lynch, The Image of the City (Cambridge, MA: M.I.T. Press, 1960).
5 Because of space limitations this particular paper cites nine of approximately three dozen specific New York examples. New York serves as both an arbitrary and a unique frame for walking practices; similar projects have been undertaken elsewhere, in many cases by practitioners who have also practiced in New York. 6 Edward W. Soja, “Thirdspace: Expanding the Scope of the Geographical Imagination” (ed. Alan Read), Architecturally Speaking: Practices of Art, Architecture and the Everyday (New York: Routledge, 2000); Thirdspace: Journeys to Los Angeles and Other Real-andImagined Places (Cambridge, MA, and Oxford, UK: Blackwell, 1996). 7 “Thirdspace: Expanding the Scope of the Geographical Imagination,” p. 14.
BEN JACKS (2006)
The surface of this order is everywhere punched and torn open by ellipses, drifts, and leaks of meaning: it is a sieve-order. Michel de Certeau1 We conceive of the postmodern city as a fragmentary assemblage of fractured parts of the traditional city, districts of modernist reform, and jumbles of late-capitalist consumer experiences. Simultaneity, fragmentation, and ephemerality characterize the experience of the contemporary city.2 Walking around helps us to know the city, to position ourselves within it, to lay claim to it, and to belong. But the city made for walking is largely the city of the past.3 We may now know places in fragments, but to begin to assemble a sense of a city or an urban region or an extensive territory requires more than the relatively straightforward “mental map.”4 For the individual in the postmodern city, the territorial practice of walking is complicated to the point of chaos. How does walking, an old way of laying hold of the city, still help us in this altered spatial, temporal, and conceptual field? This essay documents a range of recent projects in Manhattan by citizens, artists, activists, and revolutionaries who seek to understand and address city concerns through walking.5 Each project represents a subversive means of re-asserting a territorial hold on the character and space of the city in light of the conditions of postmodernity. Through the projects, practitioners attempt to deal with the daily challenge of alien and alienating territory to which one nevertheless wishes to reassert some claim. We find evidence in these intentional walking projects—many of which are mediated through digital technologies—of the coalescence of communities around what geographer Edward Soja has called a “shared spatial consciousness.”6 In “Thirdspace,” Soja cites a recent trend in spatial studies toward rebalancing the traditional oppositional dualism of history and society, of breaking down the dialectic between perceived and conceived space. This ontological shift toward what Soja calls “the trialectics of being” unites “historicality, sociality, and spatiality.”7 Describing the long-term political dimensions of this shift, Soja says: Inspired by the breakdown of totalizing modernist political epistemologies . . . and the possibility of a radical postmodernism . . ., a new socio-spatial movement or “community of resistance” is beginning to develop around 34
16:21:08:05:08
Page 34
Page 35
CITY WALKING
what I am describing as a Thirdspace consciousness and a progressive cultural politics that seeks to break down and erase the specifically spatial power differentials arising from class, race, gender and many other forms of marginalizing. . . . Rather than operating in separate and exclusive channels, this new movement/community is insistently inclusive . . ., searching for new ways of building bridges and effective political coalitions across all modes of radical subjectivity and collective resistance. In this coalition-building, it is a shared spatial consciousness, and a collective determination to take greater control over the production of our lived spaces, that provides the primary foundation—the long missing “glue”—for solidarity and political praxis. 8
8 Ibid., p. 29.
As Soja points out, this new critical spatiality, the ethos surrounding a shared spatial consciousness, is a recent phenomenon in its earliest stages of development. As shared frames of reference for experience, whether of social life or material culture, the projects documented here illustrate specific manifestations of the new consciousness Soja points to. For architecture and the urban landscape, the implications of these practices are that digital means do not trump bodily experience, and that design establishes relevance through daily life and the everyday world. CITY WALKING
Walking affirms, suspects, tries out, transgresses, respects, etc., the trajectories it “speaks.” Michel de Certeau9 In The Practice of Everyday Life, Michel de Certeau opens his chapter on city walking from a vantage point on top of one of the two World Trade Center towers.10 He views our walking from afar, as a surveillant unable to identify individuals—as if we are ants in the labyrinthine spaces of the city. He takes on for a moment the role of the all-seeing scientist content with (or stuck within) the frame of the dominant rational consumer-capitalist order so that we might be able to see beyond the official frame to the everyday. But in the remainder of the text he likens walking to reading and cooking, and he sees in everyday practices myriad ways in which the weak (most of us), trick, trip up, and play with the system. The order that threatens to oppress, he notes, is a “sieve order,” shot through with holes between and within which some maneuvering is possible. In light of de Certeau, we can consider walking from two very different perspectives: from above and afar, from a perspective in which walkers are subjects and objects, controlled by the dominant order, or intimately, from our own perspectives as walkers, in touch with the spaces and gaps in the “sieve order.” These two perspectives correspond to de Certeau’s categories, proper and quotidian, to the scientific and the everyday, and to the official 35
16:21:08:05:08
Page 35
9 de Certeau, Practice of Everyday Life, p. 99.
10 Ibid., p. 91.
Page 36
BEN JACKS
11 Ibid., p. 37. 12 Walking artists and projects directly influenced by situationist ideas, in addition to those described here, include the Italian group Stalker, and the English group Wrights & Sites. Some recent situationist-influenced design projects and speculations are partially documented in Iain Borden and Sandy McCreery, eds. New Babylonians, Architectural Design, June 2001, 71–73. 13 Simon Sadler, The Situationist City, (Cambridge, MA: M.I.T. Press, 1998), p. 3. 14 Most situationist histories explain that delegates from two or three small groups formed the Situationist International—four groups counting The “London Psychogeographical Committee,” a name invented by its only member, artist Ralph Rumney. See Ralph Rumney (tr. Malcolm Imrie), The Consul, Conversations with Gérard Berréby (San Francisco: City Lights Books, 2002), p. 37. Acknowledged also is that the term delegate is perhaps too formal a term, reflecting both the earnestness, and the mock seriousness of participants, who met at Alba “in a state of semidrunkenness.” See Stewart Home, The Assault on Culture: Utopian Currents from Lettrisme to Class War (London: Aporia Press and Unpopular Books, 1988), p. 30.
and the vernacular. The first perspective belongs to what de Certeau calls the strategy of the hegemonic order, and the second to the tactics of the powerless. The walking projects documented here reveal the contours of tactical maneuvering: as complex, localized, territorial, interwoven, and constantly negotiated and renegotiated practices. The practices range from the unconscious everyday to the politically informed and motivated. The more overt practices of resistance—such as surveillance camera mapping—have much in common with those that appear on the surface to take a more cooperative stance toward the dominant order. Alone, each way of walking may seem a bit desperate, deranged, or even silly, but this is perhaps the disguise or the ruse of the everyday, which, as de Certeau argues, makes revolution beside the point: a tactic like walking takes place “within enemy territory.”11 De Certeau defines tactics in terms of the powerlessness of the practitioner: the weak practice tactics in response to the force employed by the dominating power through its strategy. In some of the practices documented here walking is a conscious counter-strategy, a tactic used as a strategy to reclaim public space. As public space has become more limited, controlled, and circumscribed, the tactics of the powerless have had to become more explicitly about using actual public space. Walking is more than a utilitarian way of getting from one place to another: walking is an everyday practice that may be taken up as a tool. Walking, however, crosses overlaid terrains: it may be impossible to separate ideal and practical territorial walking from everyday walking that tends to habituate the walker to surroundings under the control of a dominating and unwanted authority. This lack of clarity about the efficacy of walking has led some proponents of walking as a critical spatial practice to turn to situationist ideas to theorize their activities. At the very least, the situationist’s dérive and psychogeography illuminate the potential of walking to shake the dominion of habit.12 SITUATIONIST AND SITUATIONISM
In The Situationist City, Simon Sadler points out, “one is not even meant to use the word situationism.” He quotes an early dictum from the journal Internationale Situationniste: “The notion of situationism is obviously devised by antisituationists.”13 Generally credited with forming the Situationist International at Alba, Italy, in 1957 are the Lettrist International, the International Movement for an Imaginist Bauhaus (IMIB), and COBRA (a name formed from Copenhagen, Brussels, and Amsterdam).14 What had been a substantially Dadaist and surrealist-inspired aesthetic vision under the Lettrist International and IMIB and an anti-functionalist architectural aesthetic under COBRA became a stronger renunciation of art and a strengthening of the politics of the “situation” through the new organiza36
16:21:08:05:08
Page 36
Page 37
CITY WALKING
tion. Headed by Guy Debord, the group published twelve issues of the journal Internationale Situationniste between 1958 and 1969, and trumpeted its vision for anarchist social democracy.15 Perhaps because he developed intentionally misleading histories, or because he incited dramatic excommunications and resignations of members, or because his The Society of the Spectacle has been widely read, Guy Debord is identified with the set of ideas called situationist.16 Of these situationist ideas, psychogeography and the dérive show up explicitly in the walking projects documented here. The dérive is an intentionally aimless walk, involving both structure and chance, designed to provide a fresh encounter with the city and to uncover its fragmentary nature. Psychogeography broadly refers to the study of the effects of the physical environment on individuals. Guy Debord would have denounced and disowned most new situationist projects for failing to advance revolutionary goals. As Sadler points out: “Situationism was founded on the belief that general revolution would originate in the appropriation and alteration of the material environment and its space. Activities that have not shared this aim have a poor claim to being situationist.”17 Lettrist and situationist ideas, and their predecessors in Dada and surrealism, should be understood as an index of the power of walking, not as unique points of origin for walking practices. If we wish to value walking—its potential for encounter and knowledge—we must look beyond avant-garde provenance. We have an instinct for fresh encounters, for “the end of boredom,” tapped by psychogeography and the theory of the dérive. In a footnote to The Situationist City, Sadler recognizes the connection between Michel de Certeau and the situationists, commenting that de Certeau “vastly expand(s) upon and make(s) explicit what was only inferred in situationism.” Sadler remarks that de Certeau’s “tender, almost poetic tone” has made the constellation of situationist ideas “more palatable to academe.”18 The walking practices documented here, some quiet and gentle, some bearing the overt mark of situationist politics, nevertheless begin to constellate something like a grounded theory of walking. Perhaps the development of community around a fundamentally human attribute like walking is radical, indicative of the new “shared spatial consciousness,” remarked by Edward Soja, and as revolutionary a practice as the current political environment will allow. The walks range from the personal undertaking of Caleb Smith to the more or less mainstream cultural productions of the walking artists, from the organized walks around Manhattan to advocate for a better environment to the radical protest of the Surveillance Camera Players.
37
16:21:08:05:08
Page 37
15 Internationale Situationniste (reprint, Librairie Arthème Fayard, 1997).
16 Guy Debord, The Society of the Spectacle (New York: Zone Books, 1994). As Sadler and others have enumerated, in addition to spectacle, the main lettrist and situationist ideas are psychogéographie (psychogeography), détournement (diversion), dérive (drift), situations (situations), and urbanisme unitaire (unitary urbanism).
17 Sadler, Situationist City, p. 13.
18 Ibid., p. 186 (note 123).
Page 38
BEN JACKS
WALKING PROJECTS CALEB SMITH, “NEW YORK CITY WALK”
19 Caleb Smith, “New York City Walk,” December 2004, (accessed May 19, 2005).
20 Ben McGrath, “The Talk of the Town,” New Yorker, January 3, 2005, pp. 22–23.
The possibility, the idea, of walking every street in the grid of Manhattan occurred to Caleb Smith as the result of coming across a church—the Church of the Transfiguration, “The Little Church Around the Corner,” on 29th Street near 5th Avenue.19 The church is set back from the street, like a jewel in the insistent street grid, and it occurred to Smith then that countless other such jewels lay hidden on the more than 3,000 blocks of Manhattan. He would have to walk every block if he hoped to discover New York’s hidden treasures. Accomplishing the task of walking every block was not Smith’s initial goal, but rather he wished to explore, to sightsee, and to revel in what he called the celebrity and glamor of New York, in contrast to his hometown of Albuquerque, New Mexico. Besides, he had learned to sightsee and wander from his parents in the open spaces of the west— urban exploration was just an extension of that early experience. He began by walking in a new neighborhood every time he went out of his apartment and then reading about the area he had visited when he got home. Later he marked on a map every block he had walked. After realizing the necessity of walking every Manhattan street to discover the city’s secrets, he decided upon a few rules to define the “official” walk: he would walk alone, he would carry his map and a pen to mark off completed blocks, and he would take photographs. The project took him two and a half years to finish. In reporting Smith’s walk in New Yorker magazine, Ben McGrath invokes the trope of the task-obsessed eccentric.20 Beginning with Smith’s decision to finish his walk on the day that Thomas J. Keane had completed his walk of every block in Manhattan fifty years earlier, and ending with his “passing the torch” to another every-block-walker, McGrath slyly suggests that only a complete nut-case would waste his time on such an activity. What McGrath overlooks in his focus on the odd statistics of Smith’s long-distance walk is the care and concern with which Smith looked at the city. Even this point is twisted in the direction of suggesting monomania: he quotes Smith as saying, “Greeenwich Village and the Financial District were almost a total loss, because you’re looking at the map the whole time. I’m clearly going to have to go back and do them again.” Though highly personal, Smith’s walk is motivated quite simply by a love of the city and a willingness to explore, and it is documented without a trace of irony or posturing. Smith’s walk repeats, unselfconsciously and unintentionally, de Certeau’s walking tactic: to walk every street is to insist that the city may be and should be known.
38
16:21:08:05:08
Page 38
Page 39
CITY WALKING
JIM NAURECKAS, “NEW YORK SONGLINES”
“New York Songlines,” an interactive map of Manhattan streets in the form of a simplified grid organizing a collection of hyperlinks, also insists on the knowability of the city.21 The introduction compares Manhattan’s streets to Australian aboriginal songlines, explaining how the song-stories of Aboriginals guided people across the land by way of physical features. Concluding that the aboriginal songline was a way of organizing large amounts of information, the site’s author, Jim Naureckas, argues “the Web is our technological society’s closest equivalent.” Naureckas feels that a certain mindlessness has developed because it is so easy to get around the city using knowledge of the grid, a few signs, a subway map, and taxis. People may go past the same buildings hundreds of times without ever really looking; many lack a sense of place. In answer to this condition, “New York Songlines” offers “virtual walking tours of Manhattan’s streets” that may uncover New York’s own “giants, heroes, and monsters.” The songlines are the result of a kind of reverse engineering; their power comes from the congruity of the hyperlinked Web and the grid organization of the city.
21 Jim Naureckas, “New York Songlines: virtual walking tours of Manhattan’s streets,” (May 23, 2005).
SHOREWALKERS, “THE GREAT SAUNTER”
Shorewalkers, a non-profit environmental/recreational group, takes an onthe-ground approach to knowing Manhattan. Every first Saturday in May since 1985 it has been possible to take a walk around the approximately thirty-two-mile long waterfront edge of the island of Manhattan on “The Great Saunter.”22 The event begins early in the morning at South Street Seaport and proceeds clockwise. Involving in some years as few as seventeen people, and one year more than 500, Shorewalkers’ mission is “to enhance, enjoy and protect the parks, promenades, and paths along the waters throughout the New York metropolitan area.” The group’s activism has
22 Shorewalkers, <www.shorewalkers.org> (May 13, 2005).
Walkers on “The Great Saunter” in 2004, near 150th Street west of Harlem, with the George Washington Bridge in the background. (Photo by Mark Lentz.)
39
16:21:08:05:08
Page 39
Page 40
BEN JACKS
23 Cy A. Adler, Walking Manhattan’s Rim: The Great Saunter (New York: Green Eagle Press, 2003), p. xiii. 24 See Joseph Rykwert, The Idea of a Town (London: Faber and Faber, 1976).
contributed to the establishment and development of the Manhattan Waterfront Greenway, a continuous path around Manhattan linking numerous public parks, providing recreational opportunities and waterfront access. Walking, as de Certeau explored, is a speech act. In the case of “The Great Saunter,” the walk, like much successful protest and advocacy, is explicitly for fun, but it also makes a clear political statement. Cy Adler, a founder of Shorewalkers, in his guidebook, Walking Manhattan’s Rim: The Great Saunter, remarks on the citizen’s ability to speak out in support of the environment, that “no activity symbolizes the essence of conservation more than walking.”23 The act of walking the edge of Manhattan suggests the city foundation ritual.24 In this case the ritual has been repeated annually for the past twenty years, reflecting ongoing concern for the limits and environmental impact of human inhabitation of earth. As citizens and claimants, Shorewalkers walk to advocate an environmental understanding of territory. SURVEILLANCE CAMERA PLAYERS AND THE INSTITUTE FOR APPLIED AUTONOMY
25 Surveillance Camera Players, (May 26, 2005).
Surveillance Camera Players map used on the walking tour of Chelsea. (Drawing by Kelly Shields.)
Advocating against the growing police state, Surveillance Camera Players has protested the use of surveillance cameras in Manhattan since 1996, creating plays for “the bored people who must watch the cameras,” continuously updating maps, authoring position papers, encouraging other security camera protesters, and, beginning in 2000, offering walking tours.25 Each walking tour (nine offered in the summer of 2005) is based on maps of all known cameras in a particular zone. Cameras, reasons S.C.P., do not aid in the prevention of crime, nor are operators interested in the prevention of crime. Rather, vendors promote private security cameras to document events surrounding insurance losses. In wealthy neighborhoods building owners receive discounts on insurance if they install cameras, so cameras proliferate. On the other hand, contends S.C.P., there are few cameras in poor neighborhoods regardless of the level of crime. While arguments in favor of surveillance cameras claim they induce paranoia selectively in criminals, S.C.P. counters that surveillance cameras are intended to induce paranoia in everyone—they cannot do so selectively. In a delightful analysis of press coverage that attempts to position Bill Brown and other members of S.C.P. as paranoid, Brown simply turns the tables on interviewers. He says both, “I am very paranoid,” and “the group isn’t and refuses to become paranoid.” Brown wants us to join him in this refusal to become paranoid. On the contrary, paranoia is a condition of the spectacular society, a condition of the people who supported and continue to support the installation of more than 15,000 surveillance cameras in Manhattan. Now it is almost impossible to walk in Manhattan without encountering a surveillance camera—there are perhaps five to ten cameras for every block. 40
16:21:08:05:08
Page 40
Page 41
CITY WALKING
But if one wanted to take a walk without being watched, the Institute for Applied Autonomy has created iSee, an interactive web-based map of surveillance camera locations.26 The user can enter a starting and stopping point for a trip in Manhattan and, provided the map data is up to date, iSee will generate a camera-avoiding route. The I.A.A. website answers the question, “Who should use iSee?: minorities, women, youth, ‘outsiders,’ activists, and everyone else.” I.A.A. points out surveillance cameras are unregulated and do very little to reduce crime. Police and security guard surveillants watch minorities and young men because of their appearance, women voyeuristically, “outsiders” (including people surveying for surveillance cameras), activists engaged in legal dissent, and others who might be caught kissing a lover in the street or visiting a psychiatrist. In answer to the question, “But what’s the harm?” I.A.A. points out that footage from surveillance cameras is mostly privately owned and may be broadcast without consent. Increasing sophistication—networking and facial recognition software—will compound these problems. Perhaps of greatest concern to I.A.A. is the effect of the surveillance society in social and psychological terms. The iSee map is designed to mirror the use of surveillance cameras, paranoia for paranoia, social caution for social caution. While the issues raised by anti-surveillance groups remain unresolved, anti-terrorist intelligence-gathering efforts have expanded greatly in response to September 11, including the coordination of cameras controlled by New York City police.27 The projects by S.C.P. and I.A.A., responding to the proliferation of surveillance cameras, directly address the worst fears expressed by de Certeau and the situationists.
26 Institute for Applied Autonomy, (May 17, 2005).
27 William Finnegan, “Terrorism Beat: How is the N.Y.P.D. Defending the City?” New Yorker, July 25, 2005, pp. 58–71.
GLOWLAB AND CONFLUX
Explicitly inspired by situationist history and theory, the annual PsyGeo Conflux (held in New York in 2003 and 2004), is both a conference and a public festival concerned primarily with “current artistic and social investigations in psychogeography.”28 Taking place over four days, the conference brings together “visual and sound artists, writers, urban adventurers and the public to explore the physical and psychological landscape of the city.” Most of the events involve some form of walking around and direct experience of the city. Many of the presenters acknowledge situationist origins in psychogeography, the dérive, and détournement. As a clear and significant change from earlier psychogeographical experiments, many of the projects involve digital mapping, transmitted instructions, and other uses of computers and peripherals as tools and media. Odin Cappello’s psychogeographically inspired project “Navigazing” takes an elegant, straightforward, and thoughtful approach to the dérive, sending participants out into the city with viewfinder cards and chalk to view and share the aesthetic experience of framing.29 Cappello’s instructions state the city is filled with “narrative artifacts, points of visual, or aural 41
16:21:08:05:08
Page 41
28 PsyGeo Conflux 2004 press release, (May 20, 2005).
29 PsyGeo Conflux, projects: Navigazing, (September 14, 2005).
Page 42
BEN JACKS
Odin Cappello sends participants into the city to frame and discover “narrative artifacts” in “Navigazing.” (Courtesy Odin Cappello.)
30 PsyGeo Conflux, projects: Street Stripes with Memory, (September 14, 2005). 31 PsyGeo Conflux, projects: Footprint Mapping, (September 14, 2005). 32 PsyGeo Conflux, projects: One Block Radius, (September 14, 2005).
interest that suggest the existence of a story, either real or fictional.” Participants use the viewfinder cards to frame something that they consider to be a narrative artifact, and use chalk to record positions on the pavement. Other participants, and passersby, are drawn into the story. Cappello intends for participants to develop both a physical and psychological awareness of environment. Participants develop such awareness by sighting, measuring, and communicating about narrative objects among a community of peers. Dario D’Aprile uses flour to stencil faux pedestrian crossings, in “Street Stripes with Memory.” A video camera records the effects over time of people and cars using the crossing. D’Aprile’s interest is in the “resistance time of urban furnishings made by flour,” and “to characterize and create traces and ways inside the urban space.”30 In a similar vein, Noriyuki Fujimura’s “Footprint Mapping” uses a backpack with a pedometer, a compass, a webcam, and a computer “to create a digital map of streets and public spaces by gathering ‘footprints’ of participants.”31 Fujimura later collates the walks into a single map. “One Block Radius,” a project of Christina Ray and Dave Mandl (founders of Glowlab and the PsyGeo Conflux), provides a website to serve as a repository of information concerning the city block completely destroyed to build the New Museum of Contemporary Art.32 Conceived as a navigable online map and database, the idea of “One Block Radius” is to collect “the amount of information one would normally find in a guidebook for an entire city.” Included are photographs, video, historical, narrative, and creative writing, and other forms of information gathered from a wide 42
16:21:08:05:08
Page 42
Page 43
CITY WALKING
variety of people having direct experience with the block. The idea is to create a website environment capable of receiving an enormous volume of data at scales not normally considered important, and to make the data available to anyone wishing to navigate the site. The “multi-layered portrait of the block as it has never been seen before (and never will be seen again)” is intended to constitute “an extensive psychogeographic survey.” A revised version of the project allows for the assemblage of similar kinds of information on a citywide scale.33 The psychogeographical projects of the PsyGeo Conflux reflect perhaps the most intentional and self-conscious forms of territorial practice. CONCLUSION
Each of these projects illuminates a particular frame or theme through which we might understand the territorial practice of walking and local negotiations with the dominant order. Walking every street in the grid temporarily unearths an apparently comprehensive collection of memories in physical things. A virtual walking tour similarly contends the city is knowable. Walking the shore consecrates the earth as home. Walking on a 43
16:21:08:05:08
Page 43
Noriyuki Fujimura creates a digital map of a walk in the city using a backpack outfitted with a pedometer, microprocessor, webcam, and laptop in “Footprint Mapping.” (Courtesy Noriyuki Fujimura.)
33 Correspondence with author.
Page 44
BEN JACKS
tour of surveillance cameras protests their proliferation, the police state, and the loss of civil liberties. Walking a psychogeographical drift makes a surprisingly poetic experience out of the raw material of the city. In de Certeau’s terms, each such act of walking is a speech act. Each constitutes a “rhetoric of walking,” making dialogue out of the everyday and the rational. Each reconnects us, no matter how temporarily, to the alienating infrastructure of the contemporary city. It seems the list of intentional and self-conscious tactics has only grown since the historical moment of the situationists, and the dissemination of de Certeau’s thought. Is this in response to the proliferation of academic theory or to conditions? Is this merely the playful illusion and delusion of intellectuals, or is it that we are increasingly aware of all kinds of oppressions, large and small? Quotation, “poaching,” to carry forward one of de Certeau’s playful ideas, is the backbone of walking (as well as of reading and writing). Quotation lets us move forward as a community. When we walk we are quoting the walkers who have come before us, and performing communal turns on each quotation. The myriad ways we walk the city seem to yield ever more turns, more variations, on the spaces of the pedestrian everyday.
This paper was published in a different form in Places 18:1 (Spring 2006) and in the Proceedings of the 94th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 2006. 44
16:21:08:05:08
Page 44
Page 45
GREEN MANHATTAN Why New York is the greenest city in the U.S.
PRESERVATION, RE-USE, AND SUSTAINABILITY
DAVID OWEN (2004)
My wife and I got married right out of college, in 1978. We were young and naïve and unashamedly idealistic, and we decided to make our first home in a utopian environmentalist community in New York State. For seven years, we lived, quite contentedly, in circumstances that would strike most Americans as austere in the extreme: our living space measured just seven hundred square feet, and we didn’t have a dishwasher, a garbage disposal, a lawn, or a car. We did our grocery shopping on foot, and when we needed to travel longer distances we used public transportation. Because space at home was scarce, we seldom acquired new possessions of significant size. Our electric bills worked out to about a dollar a day. The utopian community was Manhattan. (Our apartment was on Sixtyninth Street, between Second and Third.) Most Americans, including most New Yorkers, think of New York City as an ecological nightmare, a wasteland of concrete and garbage and diesel fumes and traffic jams, but in comparison with the rest of America it’s a model of environmental responsibility. By the most significant measures, New York is the greenest community in the United States, and one of the greenest cities in the world. The most devastating damage humans have done to the environment has arisen from the heedless burning of fossil fuels, a category in which New Yorkers are practically prehistoric. The average Manhattanite consumes gasoline at a rate that the country as a whole hasn’t matched since the midnineteen-twenties, when the most widely owned car in the United States was the Ford Model T. Eighty-two percent of Manhattan residents travel to work by public transit, by bicycle, or on foot. That’s ten times the rate for Americans in general, and eight times the rate for residents of Los Angeles County. New York City is more populous than all but eleven states; if it were granted statehood, it would rank fifty-first in per-capita energy use. “Anyplace that has such tall buildings and heavy traffic is obviously an environmental disaster—except that it isn’t,” John Holtzclaw, a transportation consultant for the Sierra Club and the Natural Resources Defense Council, told me. “If New Yorkers lived at the typical American sprawl density of three households per residential acre, they would require many times as much land. They’d be driving cars, and they’d have huge lawns and be using pesticides and fertilizers on them, and then they’d be overwatering their lawns, so that runoff would go into streams.” The key to New York’s relative environmental benignity is its extreme compactness. Manhattan’s 45
16:21:08:05:08
Page 45
Page 46
DAVID OWEN
population density is more than eight hundred times that of the nation as a whole. Placing one and a half million people on a twenty-three-square-mile island sharply reduces their opportunities to be wasteful, and forces the majority to live in some of the most inherently energy-efficient residential structures in the world: apartment buildings. It also frees huge tracts of land for the rest of America to sprawl into. My wife and I had our first child in 1984. We had both grown up in suburbs, and we decided that we didn’t want to raise our tiny daughter in a huge city. Shortly after she learned to walk, we moved to a small town in northwestern Connecticut, about ninety miles north of midtown Manhattan. Our house, which was built in the late seventeen-hundreds, is across a dirt road from a nature preserve and is shaded by tall white-pine trees. After big rains, we can hear a swollen creek rushing by at the bottom of the hill. Deer, wild turkeys, and the occasional black bear feed themselves in our yard. From the end of our driveway, I can walk several miles through woods to an abandoned nineteenth-century railway tunnel, while crossing only one paved road. Yet our move was an ecological catastrophe. Our consumption of electricity went from roughly four thousand kilowatt-hours a year, toward the end of our time in New York, to almost thirty thousand kilowatt-hours in 2003—and our house doesn’t even have central air-conditioning. We bought a car shortly before we moved, and another one soon after we arrived, and a third one ten years later. (If you live in the country and don’t have a second car, you can’t retrieve your first car from the mechanic after it’s been repaired; the third car was the product of a mild midlife crisis, but soon evolved into a necessity.) My wife and I both work at home, but we manage to drive thirty thousand miles a year between us, mostly doing ordinary errands. Nearly everything we do away from our house requires a car trip. Renting a movie and later returning it, for example, consumes almost two gallons of gasoline, since the nearest Blockbuster is ten miles away and each transaction involves two round trips. When we lived in New York, heat escaping from our apartment helped to heat the apartment above ours; nowadays, many of the BTUs produced by our brand-new, extremely efficient oil-burning furnace leak through our two-hundred-year-old roof and into the dazzling star-filled winter sky above. When most Americans think about environmentalism, they picture wild, unspoiled landscapes—the earth before it was transmogrified by human habitation. New York City is one of the most thoroughly altered landscapes imaginable, an almost wholly artificial environment, in which the terrain’s primeval contours have long since been obliterated and most of the parts that resemble nature (the trees on side streets, the rocks in Central Park) are essentially decorations. Ecology-minded discussions of New York City often have a hopeless tone, and focus on ways in which the city might be made to seem somewhat less oppressively man-made: by increasing the area devoted 46
16:21:08:05:08
Page 46
Page 47
GREEN MANHATTAN
to parks and greenery, by incorporating vegetation into buildings themselves, by reducing traffic congestion, by easing the intensity of development, by creating open space around structures. But most such changes would actually undermine the city’s extraordinary energy efficiency, which arises from the characteristics that make it surreally synthetic. Because densely populated urban centers concentrate human activity, we think of them as pollution crisis zones. Calculated by the square foot, New York City generates more greenhouse gases, uses more energy, and produces more solid waste than most other American regions of comparable size. On a map depicting negative environmental impacts in relation to surface area, therefore, Manhattan would look like an intense hot spot, surrounded, at varying distances, by belts of deepening green. If you plotted the same negative impacts by resident or by household, however, the color scheme would be reversed. My little town has about four thousand residents, spread over 38.7 thickly wooded square miles, and there are many places within our town limits from which no sign of settlement is visible in any direction. But if you moved eight million people like us, along with our dwellings and possessions and current rates of energy use, into a space the size of New York City, our profligacy would be impossible to miss, because you’d have to stack our houses and cars and garages and lawn tractors and swimming pools and septic tanks higher than skyscrapers. (Conversely, if you made all eight million New Yorkers live at the density of my town, they would require a space equivalent to the land area of the six New England states plus Delaware and New Jersey.) Spreading people out increases the damage they do to the environment, while making the problems harder to see and to address. Of course, living in densely populated urban centers has many drawbacks. Even wealthy New Yorkers live in spaces that would seem cramped to Americans living almost anywhere else. A well-to-do friend of mine who grew up in a town house in Greenwich Village thought of his upbringing as privileged until, in prep school, he visited a classmate from the suburbs and was staggered by the house, the lawn, the cars, and the swimming pool, and thought, with despair, You mean I could live like this? Manhattan is loud and dirty, and the subway is depressing, and the fumes from the cars and cabs and buses can make people sick. Presumably for environmental reasons, New York City has one of the highest childhood-asthma rates in the country, with an especially alarming concentration in East Harlem. Nevertheless, barring an almost inconceivable reduction in the earth’s population, dense urban centers offer one of the few plausible remedies for some of the world’s most discouraging environmental ills. To borrow a term from the jargon of computer systems, dense cities are scalable, while sprawling suburbs are not. The environmental challenge we face, at the current stage of our assault on the world’s non-renewable resources, is not how to make our teeming cities more like the pristine countryside. The true 47
16:21:08:05:08
Page 47
Page 48
DAVID OWEN
challenge is how to make other settled places more like Manhattan. This notion has yet to be widely embraced, partly because it is counterintuitive, and partly because most Americans, including most environmentalists, tend to view cities the way Thomas Jefferson did, as “pestilential to the morals, the health, and the liberties of man.” New York is the place that’s fun to visit but you wouldn’t want to live there. What could it possibly teach anyone about being green? New York’s example, admittedly, is difficult for others to imitate, because the city’s remarkable population density is the result not of conscientious planning but of a succession of serendipitous historical accidents. The most important of those accidents was geographic: New York arose on a smallish island rather than on the mainland edge of a river or a bay, and the surrounding water served as a physical constraint to outward expansion. Manhattan is like a typical seaport turned inside out—a city with a harbor around it, rather than a harbor with a city along its edge. Insularity gave Manhattan more shoreline per square mile than other ports, a major advantage in the days when one of the world’s main commercial activities was moving cargoes between ships. It also drove early development inward and upward. A second lucky accident was that Manhattan’s street plan was created by merchants who were more interested in economic efficiency than in boulevards, parks, or empty spaces between buildings. The resulting crush of architecture is actually humanizing, because it brings the city’s commercial, cultural, and other offerings closer together, thereby increasing their accessibility—a point made forty-three years ago by the brilliantly iconoclastic urban thinker Jane Jacobs, in her landmark book The Death and Life of Great American Cities. A third accident was the fact that by the early nineteen-hundreds most of Manhattan’s lines had been filled in to the point where not even Robert Moses could easily redraw them to accommodate the great destroyer of American urban life, the automobile. Henry Ford thought of cars as tools for liberating humanity from the wretchedness of cities, which he viewed with as much distaste as Jefferson did. In 1932, John Nolen, a prominent Harvard-educated urban planner and landscape architect, said, “The future city will be spread out, it will be regional, it will be the natural product of the automobile, the good road, electricity, the telephone, and the radio, combined with the growing desire to live a more natural, biological life under pleasanter and more natural conditions.” This is the idea behind suburbs, and it’s still seductive. But it’s also a prescription for sprawl and expressways and tremendous waste. New York City’s obvious urban antithesis, in terms of density and automobile use, is metropolitan Los Angeles, whose metastatic outward growth has been virtually unimpeded by the lay of the land, whose early settlers came to the area partly out of a desire to create space between themselves 48
16:21:08:05:08
Page 48
Page 49
GREEN MANHATTAN
and others, and whose main development began late enough to be shaped by the needs of cars. But a more telling counterexample is Washington, D.C., whose basic layout was conceived at roughly the same time as Manhattan’s, around the turn of the nineteenth century. The District of Columbia’s original plan was created by an eccentric French-born engineer and architect named Pierre-Charles L’Enfant, who befriended General Washington during the Revolutionary War and asked to be allowed to design the capital. Many of modern Washington’s most striking features are his: the broad, radial avenues; the hublike traffic circles; the sweeping public lawns and ceremonial spaces. Washington is commonly viewed as the most intelligently beautiful—the most European—of large American cities. Ecologically, though, it’s a mess. L’Enfant’s expansive avenues were easily adapted to automobiles, and the low, widely separated buildings (whose height is limited by law) stretched the distance between destinations. There are many pleasant places in Washington to go for a walk, but the city is difficult to get around on foot: the wide avenues are hard to cross, the traffic circles are like obstacle courses, and the grandiloquent empty spaces thwart pedestrians, by acting as what Jane Jacobs calls “border vacuums.” (One of Jacobs’s many arresting observations is that parks and other open spaces can reduce urban vitality, by creating dead ends that prevent people from moving freely between neighborhoods and by decreasing activity along their edges.) Many parts of Washington, furthermore, are relentlessly homogeneous. There are plenty of dignified public buildings on Constitution Avenue, for example, but good luck finding a dry cleaner, a Chinese restaurant, or a grocery store. The city’s horizontal, airy design has also pushed development into the surrounding countryside. The fastest-growing county in the United States is Loudoun County, Virginia, at the rapidly receding western edge of the Washington metropolitan area. The Sierra Club, an environmental organization that advocates the preservation of wilderness and wildlife, has a national campaign called Challenge to Sprawl. The aim of the program is to arrest the mindless conversion of undeveloped countryside into subdivisions, strip malls, and S.U.V.-clogged expressways. The Sierra Club’s Web site features a slideshow-like demonstration that illustrates how various sprawling suburban intersections could be transformed into far more appealing and energyefficient developments by implementing a few modifications, among them widening the sidewalks and narrowing the streets, mixing residential and commercial uses, moving buildings closer together and closer to the edges of sidewalks (to make them more accessible to pedestrians and to increase local density), and adding public transportation—all fundamental elements of the widely touted anti-sprawl strategy known as Smart Growth. In a recent telephone conversation with a Sierra Club representative involved in Challenge to Sprawl, I said that the organization’s anti-sprawl suggestions 49
16:21:08:05:08
Page 49
Page 50
DAVID OWEN
and the modified streetscapes in the slide show shared many significant features with Manhattan—whose most salient characteristics include wide sidewalks, narrow streets, mixed uses, densely packed buildings, and an extensive network of subways and buses. The representative hesitated, then said that I was essentially correct, although he would prefer that the program not be described in such terms, since emulating New York City would not be considered an appealing goal by most of the people whom the Sierra Club is trying to persuade. An obvious way to reduce consumption of fossil fuels is to shift more people out of cars and into public transit. In many parts of the country, though, public transit has been stagnant or in decline for years. New York City’s Metropolitan Transportation Authority and Department of Transportation account for nearly a third of all the transit passenger miles travelled in the United States and for nearly four times as many passenger miles as the Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority and the Los Angeles County Metropolitan Transportation Authority combined. New York City looks so little like other parts of America that urban planners and environmentalists tend to treat it as an exception rather than an example, and to act as though Manhattan occupies an idiosyncratic universe of its own. But the underlying principles apply everywhere. “The basic point,” Jeffrey Zupan, an economist with the Regional Planning Association, told me, “is that you need density to support public transit. In all cities, not just in New York, once you get above a certain density two things happen. First, you get less travel by mechanical means, which is another way of saying you get more people walking or biking; and, second, you get a decrease in the trips by auto and an increase in the trips by transit. That threshold tends to be around seven dwellings per acre. Once you cross that line, a bus company can put buses out there, because they know they’re going to have enough passengers to support a reasonable frequency of service.” Phoenix is the sixth-largest city in the United States and one of the fastestgrowing among the top ten, yet its public transit system accounts for just one percent of the passenger miles that New York City’s does. The reason is that Phoenix’s burgeoning population has spread so far across the desert— greater Phoenix, whose population is a little more than twice that of Manhattan, covers more than two hundred times as much land—that no transit system could conceivably serve it. And no amount of browbeating, public-service advertising, or federal spending can change that. Cities, states, and the federal government often negate their own efforts to nurture public transit by simultaneously spending huge sums to make it easier for people to get around in cars. When a city’s automobile traffic becomes congested, the standard response has long been to provide additional capacity by building new roads or widening existing ones. This approach eventually makes the original problem worse, by generating what 50
16:21:08:05:08
Page 50
Page 51
GREEN MANHATTAN
transportation planners call “induced traffic”: every mile of new highway lures passengers from public transit and other more efficient modes of travel, and makes it possible for residential and commercial development to spread even farther from urban centers. And adding public transit in the hope of reducing automobile congestion is as self-defeating as building new highways, because unclogging roads, if successful, just makes driving seem more attractive, and the roads fill up again. A better strategy would be to eliminate existing traffic lanes and parking spaces gradually, thereby forcing more drivers to use less environmentally damaging alternatives—in effect, “induced transit.” One reason New Yorkers are the most dedicated transit users in America is that congestion on the city’s streets makes driving extraordinarily disagreeable. The average speed of crosstown traffic in Manhattan is little more than that of a brisk walker, and in midtown at certain times of the day the cars on the side streets move so slowly that they appear almost to be parked. Congestion like that urges drivers into the subways, and it makes life easier for pedestrians and bicycle riders by slowing cars to a point where they constitute less of a physical threat. Even in New York City, the relationship between traffic and transit is not well understood. A number of the city’s most popular recent transportationrelated projects and policy decisions may in the long run make the city a worse place to live in by luring passengers back into their cars and away from public transportation: the rebuilding and widening of the West Side Highway, the implementation of EZ-Pass on the city’s toll bridges, the decision not to impose tolls on the East River bridges, and the current renovation of the F.D.R. Drive (along with the federally funded hundredand-thirty-nine-million-dollar Outboard Detour Roadway, which is intended to prevent users of the F.D.R. from being inconvenienced while the work is under way). Public transit itself can be bad for the environment if it facilitates rather than discourages sprawl. The Washington Metropolitan Area Transit Authority is considering extensions to some of the most distant branches of its system, and those extensions, if built, will allow people to live even farther from the city’s center, creating new, non-dense suburbs where all other travel will be by automobile, much of it to malls and schools and gas stations that will be built to accommodate them. Transit is best for the environment when it helps to concentrate people in dense urban cores. Building the proposed Second Avenue subway line would be environmentally sound, because it would increase New Yorkers’ ability to live without cars; building a bullet train between Penn Station and the Catskills (for example) would not be sound, because it would enable the vast, fuel-squandering apparatus of suburbia to establish itself in a region that couldn’t support it otherwise. On the afternoon of August 14, 2003, I was working in my office, on the third floor of my house, when the lights blinked, my window air-conditioner 51
16:21:08:05:08
Page 51
Page 52
DAVID OWEN
sputtered, and my computer’s backup battery kicked in briefly. This was the beginning of the great blackout of 2003, which halted electric service in parts of eight Northeastern and Midwestern states and in southeastern Canada. The immediate cause was eventually traced to Ohio, but public attention often focused on New York City, which had the largest concentration of affected power customers. Richard B. Miller, who resigned as the senior energy adviser for the city of New York six weeks before the blackout, reportedly over deep disagreements with the city’s energy policy, told me, “When I was with the city, I attended a conference on global warming where somebody said, ‘We really need to raise energy and electricity prices in New York City, so that people will consume less.’ And my response at that conference was ‘You know, if you’re talking about raising energy prices in New York City only, then you’re talking about something that’s really bad for the environment. If you make energy prices so expensive in the city that a business relocates from Manhattan to New Jersey, what you’re really talking about, in the simplest terms, is a business that’s moving from a subway stop to a parking lot. And which of those do you think is worse for the environment?’ ” People who live in cities use only about half as much electricity as people who don’t, and people who live in New York City generally use less than the urban average. A truly enlightened energy policy would reward city dwellers and encourage others to follow their good example. Yet New York City residents pay more per kilowatt-hour than almost any other American electricity customers; taxes and other government charges, most of which are not enumerated on electricity bills, can constitute close to twenty percent of the cost of power for residential and commercial users in New York. Richard Miller, after leaving his job with New York City, went to work as a lawyer in Consolidated Edison’s regulatory affairs department, spurred by his thinking about the environment. He believes that state and local officials have historically taken unfair advantage of the fact that there is no political cost to attacking a big utility. Con Ed pays more than six hundred million dollars a year in property taxes, making it by far the city’s largest propertytax payer, and those charges inflate electric bills. Meanwhile, the cost of driving is kept artificially low. (Fifth Avenue and the West Side Highway don’t pay property taxes, for example.) “In addition,” Miller said, “the burden of improving the city’s air has fallen far more heavily on power plants, which contribute only a small percentage of New York City’s air pollution, than it has on cars—even though motor vehicles are a much bigger source.” Last year, the National Building Museum, in Washington, D.C., held a show called “Big & Green: Toward Sustainable Architecture in the 21st Century.” A book of the same name was published in conjunction with the show, and on the book’s dust jacket was a photograph of 4 Times Square, also known as the Condé Nast Building, a forty-eight-story glass-and-steel 52
16:21:08:05:08
Page 52
Page 53
GREEN MANHATTAN
tower between Forty-second and Forty-third Streets, a few blocks west of Grand Central Terminal. (The New Yorker’s offices occupy two floors in the building.) When 4 Times Square was built, in 1999, it was considered a major breakthrough in urban development. As Daniel Kaplan, a principal of Fox & Fowle Architects, the firm that designed it, wrote in an article in Environmental Design & Construction in 1997, “When thinking of green architecture, one usually associates smaller scale,” and he cited as an example the headquarters of the Rocky Mountain Institute, a nonprofit environmental research and consulting firm based in Snowmass, Colorado. The R.M.I. building is a four-thousand-square-foot, superinsulated, passive-solar structure with curving sixteen-inch-thick walls, set into a hillside about fifteen miles north of Aspen. It was erected in the early eighties and serves partly as a showcase for green construction technology. (It is also the home of Amory Lovins, who is R.M.I.’s co-founder and chief executive officer.) R.M.I. contributed to the design of 4 Times Square, which has many innovative features, among them collection chutes for recyclable materials, photovoltaic panels incorporated into parts of its skin, and curtain-wall construction with exceptional shading and insulating properties. These are all important innovations. In terms of the building’s true ecological impact, though, they are distinctly secondary. (The power generated by the photovoltaic panels supplies less than one percent of the building’s requirements.) The two greenest features of 4 Times Square are ones that most people never even mention: it is big, and it is situated in Manhattan. Environmentalists have tended to treat big buildings as intrinsically wasteful, because large amounts of energy are expended in their construction, and because the buildings place intensely localized stresses on sewers, power lines, and water systems. But density can create the same kinds of ecological benefits in individual structures that it does in entire communities. Tall buildings have much less exposed exterior surface per square foot of interior space than smaller buildings do, and that means they present relatively less of themselves to the elements, and their small roofs absorb less heat from the sun during cooling season and radiate less heat from inside during heating season. (The beneficial effects are greater still in Manhattan, where one building often directly abuts another.) A study by Michael Phillips and Robert Gnaizda, published in CoEvolution Quarterly in 1980, found that an ordinary apartment in a typical building near downtown San Francisco used just a fifth as much heating fuel as a new tract house in Davis, a little more than seventy miles away. Occupants of tall buildings also do a significant part of their daily coming and going in elevators, which, because they are counterweighted and thus require less motor horsepower, are among the most energy-efficient passenger vehicles in the world. Bruce Fowle, a founder of Fox & Fowle, told me, “The Condé Nast Building contains 1.6 million square feet of floor space, and it sits on one acre of land. If you divided it into forty-eight one-story suburban office 53
16:21:08:05:08
Page 53
Page 54
DAVID OWEN
buildings, each averaging thirty-three thousand square feet, and spread those one-story buildings around the countryside, and then added parking and some green space around each one, you’d end up consuming at least a hundred and fifty acres of land. And then you’d have to provide infrastructure, the highways and everything else.” Like many other buildings in Manhattan, 4 Times Square doesn’t even have a parking lot, because the vast majority of the six thousand people who work inside it don’t need one. In most other parts of the country, big parking lots are not only necessary but are required by law. If my town’s zoning regulations applied in Manhattan, 4 Times Square would have needed sixteen thousand parking spaces, one for every hundred square feet of office floor space. The Rocky Mountain Institute’s showcase headquarters has double-paned kryptonfilled windows, which admit seventy-five percent as much light as ordinary windows while allowing just ten percent as much heat to escape in cold weather. That’s a wonderful feature, and one of many in the building that people ought to copy. In other ways, though, the R.M.I. building sets a very poor environmental example. It was built in a fragile location, on virgin land more than seven thousand feet above sea level. With just four thousand square feet of interior space, it can hold only six of R.M.I.’s eighteen fulltime employees; the rest of them work in a larger building a mile away. Because the two buildings are in a thinly populated area, they force most employees to drive many miles—including trips between the two buildings—and they necessitate extra fuel consumption by delivery trucks, snowplows, and other vehicles. If R.M.I.’s employees worked on a single floor of a big building in Manhattan (or in downtown Denver) and lived in apartments nearby, many of them would be able to give up their cars, and the thousands of visitors who drive to Snowmass each year to learn about environmentally responsible construction could travel by public transit instead. Picking on R.M.I.—which is one of the world’s most farsighted environmental organizations—may seem unfair, but R.M.I., along with many other farsighted environmental organizations, shares responsibility for perpetuating the powerful anti-city bias of American environmentalism. That bias is evident in the technical term that is widely used for sprawl: “urbanization.” Thinking of freeways and strip malls as “urban” phenomena obscures the ecologically monumental difference between Phoenix and Manhattan, and fortifies the perception that population density is an environmental ill. It also prevents most people from recognizing that R.M.I.’s famous headquarters—which sits on an isolated parcel more than a hundred and eighty miles from the nearest significant public transit system—is sprawl. When I told a friend recently that I thought New York City should be considered the greenest community in America, she looked puzzled, then asked, “Is it because they’ve started recycling again?” Her question reflected 54
16:21:08:05:08
Page 54
Page 55
GREEN MANHATTAN
a central failure of the American environmental movement: that too many of us have been made to believe that the most important thing we can do to save the earth and ourselves is to remember each week to set our cans and bottles and newspapers on the curb. Recycling is popular because it enables people to relieve their gathering anxieties about the future without altering the way they live. But most current recycling has, at best, a neutral effect on the environment, and much of it is demonstrably harmful. As William McDonough and Michael Braungart point out in Cradle to Cradle: Remaking the Way We Make Things (2003), most of the materials we place on our curbs are merely “downcycled”—converted to a lower use, providing a pause in their inevitable journey to a landfill or an incinerator—often with a release of toxins and a net loss of fuel, among other undesirable effects. By far the worst damage we Americans do to the planet arises not from the newspapers we throw away but from the eight hundred and fifty million or so gallons of oil we consume every day. We all know this at some level, yet we live like alcoholics in denial. How else can we explain why our cars have grown bigger, heavier, and less fuel-efficient at the same time that scientists have become more certain and more specific about the consequences of our addiction to gasoline? On a shelf in my office is a small pile of recent books about the environment that I plan to reread obsessively if I’m found to have a terminal illness, because they’re so unsettling that they may make me less upset about being snatched from life in my prime. At the top of the pile is Out of Gas: The End of the Age of Oil, by David Goodstein, a professor at the California Institute of Technology, which was published in 2004. “The world will soon start to run out of conventionally produced, cheap oil,” Goodstein begins. In succeeding pages, he lucidly explains that humans have consumed almost a trillion barrels of oil (that’s forty-two trillion gallons), or about half of the earth’s total supply; that a devastating global petroleum crisis will begin not when we have pumped the last barrel out of the ground but when we have reached the halfway point, because at that moment, for the first time in history, the line representing supply will fall through the line representing demand; that we will probably pass that point within the current decade, if we haven’t passed it already; that various well-established laws of economics are about to assert themselves, with disastrous repercussions for almost everything; and that “civilization as we know it will come to an end sometime in this century unless we can find a way to live without fossil fuels.” Standing between us and any conceivable solution to our energy nightmare are our cars and the asphalt latticed country we have built to oblige them. Those cars have defined our culture and our lives. A car is speed and sex and power and emancipation. It makes its driver a self-sufficient nation of one. It is everything a city is not.
55
16:21:08:05:08
Page 55
Page 56
DAVID OWEN
Most of the car’s most tantalizing charms are illusory, though. By helping us to live at greater distances from one another, driving has undermined the very benefits that it was meant to bestow. Ignacio San Martín, an architecture professor and the head of the graduate urban-design program at the University of Arizona, told me, “If you go out to the streets of Phoenix and are able to see anybody walking—which you likely won’t—they are going to tell you that they love living in Phoenix because they have a beautiful house and three cars. In reality, though, once the conversation goes a little bit further, they are going to say that they spend most of their time at home watching TV, because there is absolutely nothing to do.” One of the main attractions of moving to the suburbs is acquiring ground of your own, yet you can travel for miles through suburbia and see no one doing anything in a yard other than working on the yard itself (often with the help of a riding lawnmower, one of the few four-wheeled passenger vehicles that get worse gas mileage than a Hummer). The modern suburban yard is perfectly, perversely self-justifying: its purpose is to be taken care of. In 1801, in his first Inaugural Address, Thomas Jefferson said that the American wilderness would provide growing room for democracysustaining agrarian patriots “to the thousandth and thousandth generation.” Jefferson didn’t foresee the interstate highway system, and his arithmetic was off, in any case, but he nevertheless anticipated (and, in many ways, embodied) the ethos of suburbia, of anti-urbanism, of sprawl. The standard object of the modern American dream, the single-family home surrounded by grass, is a mini-Monticello. It was the car that put it within our reach. But what a terrible price we have paid—and have yet to pay—for our liberation from the city.
This essay was originally published in The New Yorker October 18, 2004. 56
16:21:08:05:08
Page 56
Page 57
STEWARDSHIP OF THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT The emerging synergies from sustainability and historic preservation
PRESERVATION, RE-USE, AND SUSTAINABILITY
ROBERT A. YOUNG (2004)
AN OVERVIEW
Sustainable architecture looks at long-term socioeconomic goals rather than just near-term financial ones. In the United States, the predominant longterm goal has been to extract maximum profit from the land. Natural and built environments have always been vulnerable to wasting due to perceptions that there was always more land somewhere else and that any land use could change when something more profitable could be built upon or extracted from it. In this fashion, land could also be cast aside when easier development choices existed elsewhere. As such, current economics-driven practices continually reshape the built and natural environments. This recurring paradigm is clearly evident in how “undeveloped” lands initially prized for their extractable natural resources were subsequently turned into agricultural lands and then finally were smothered by suburban sprawl, or in how previously developed lands are left to deteriorate. These cycles will affect all open and developed land, eventually leaving them undifferentiated, lacking vitality, and having little to no regional identity. This can readily be seen by the homogeneity of franchise architecture and seemingly identical suburban housing tracts across the country that have proliferated since the advent of the interstate highway system. STEWARDSHIP OF THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
Stewardship of the built environment counters this extraction and consumption-based economic philosophy. Despite the growing emergence of sustainability as a viable design medium, the goals of stewardship of the built environment, based on long-term environmental sustainability, are viewed by many as contrary to the endemic approach of seeking near-term immediate economic gain. Long-term sustainability, while attractive in principle, pales economically against the near-term economic benefits gained from “standard” practices of the past half-century. While defenders of the natural environment have existed as a minority, the current cultural landscape of the United States reflects the premise that the majority has long adopted the depletion-extraction economic perspective as the justifiable paradigm. Today, the fact that vast tracts of the built environment remain underutilized demonstrates how suburban sprawl drains vitality from central cities. Continuing development of the suburban periphery overwhelms 57
16:21:08:05:08
Page 57
Page 58
ROBERT A. YOUNG
previously individual smaller towns adjoining a central city, consumes open or agricultural lands, and subsequently results in increased traffic congestion, air pollution, and infrastructure costs for highways, utilities, and school systems. The concept of stewardship, rather than extraction, is a critical aspect of sustainable design that evaluates how changes in the built and natural environments act as a singular system rather than two separate ones. A primary outcome of stewardship is that it can act to engage the practice of redevelopment and in turn reverse the outward suburban flow back towards the neighborhoods and business districts that already exist within many core cities. Many neighborhoods in older communities already have existing infrastructure, access to public transit, and a far less homogeneous architectural heritage that can act to reduce overall construction expenses, make housing more affordable, and engender a higher and more affordable quality of life than their suburban counterparts. Concurrent to the emergence of sustainability, the recognition of the economic and social value recaptured in existing buildings has resulted in a steadily growing interest in historic preservation nationwide. While the preservation movement has often been derided as being opposite to the “accepted” concepts of growth and profitability, successful historic preservation projects nationwide have shown that preservation can be a strategy that not only retains a cultural identity of a given community but also can be successful in generating renewed community development and maintaining a long-term sustainable aspect of the environment. A NEXUS
1 Lucy, W., and Phillips, D. Confronting Suburban Decline. Washington, D.C.: Island Press, 2000. 10.
The renewed interest in preserving and/or rehabilitating buildings at the turn of the twenty-first century can be directly traced to the American Bicentennial. Tax laws enacted between 1976 and 1986 made rehabilitating historic buildings attractive and spawned significant growth in the rehabilitation industry. The 1986 tax act, however, has virtually eliminated investment opportunities in historic property rehabilitation. This catalytic decade of rehabilitation activities created an awareness of the amenities that a revitalized central city could provide. Many central city neighborhoods are likely to have the advantages of more non-profit institutions, interesting architecture, walkable neighborhoods, and access to mass transit. Recognition of these amenities brought about the new urbanist movement of the late twentieth century. While this movement ascribes to providing housing that adopts the amenities common to existing central city neighborhoods, the tyranny of “easy development decisions” still generates a greater increase in development at the suburban periphery rather than the redevelopment of the original built environment that first held (and often still does hold) these features. As described by Lucy and Phillips:1
58
16:21:08:05:08
Page 58
Page 59
STEWARDSHIP OF THE BUILT ENVIRONMENT
In land development, business calculations may lead to options that are relatively easy to accomplish, such as . . . greenfield residential subdivisions . . . They receive extra weight with options that are difficult to implement such as mixed-use residential and commercial developments on infill sites even if the more difficult options hold potential for higher profits. Accordingly, many central city buildings and land have been left fallow as the suburbs push further outward. Since large-scale residential projects are often perceived as more profitable due to the realizable economy in mass production, these projects tend to be large in scope and require large tracts of open (or cleared) land. While new urbanism projects occur in both the suburban and central city contexts, the vast majority still appear to be in suburban locations. As a result, open suburban land is still being developed or central city buildings are being removed to create a “tabula rasa” for new development and existing building stock that can be reused is often removed. Due to the perceived difficulty in navigating regulatory procedures and the expense of assembling tracts within the central city, particularly in historic districts, the developers initiate suburban developments more frequently and at a large scale rather than at the individual homeowner scale. Sustainability, stewardship, and preservation seemingly having reached a nexus in that they all are beginning to reach for the same economic, ecologic, and social viability values. However, misperceptions, miscommunications, and outright arrogance and ignorance quite often lead to multiple parties standing in opposition to one another while these common long-term values and goals become imperiled. All parties want certain aspects of the same thing but fail to reach a viable means of doing so, especially as the project scope and scale of larger developments tend to lead to an “all or nothing” attitude from all parties involved. A possible alternative having greater implications for sustainability in the long term is the historic preservation/stewardship approach that adapts and reuses the existing built environment rather than continuing to build in the suburban periphery or worse, remove existing buildings to simply replace them with new construction. The concepts of sustainability, stewardship, and preservation have gained increased visibility in the past fifteen years. Surprisingly, all have moved along parallel paths without significant interaction and each in its own way substantiates the goal of long-term viability of the built and natural environments. Sustainability recognizes the need to do things in the present that can protect the future. Stewardship recognizes the trade-offs that need to be assessed to protect both the natural and built environments. Preservation recognizes the importance of understanding the past while promoting older buildings as part of the future of the built environment. From the large-scale collaborative efforts common with the conversion of military 59
16:21:08:05:08
Page 59
Page 60
ROBERT A. YOUNG
bases for contemporary civilian uses to the growing number of private homeowners respectfully rehabilitating inner-city houses, there is a growing list of examples that demonstrate how all three perspectives are compatible with one another. The sustainable aspects demonstrate how existing building stock can fit into promoting redevelopment within the urban core and thereby promote long-term revitalization. Extending the idea, appropriate stewardship can cultivate a renewed social and economic vitality in the community while reducing the net cycle of extraction and consumption all along the rehabilitation/reuse spectrum. And lastly, the integration of the sustainability and preservation financial incentives directly helps to make the process even more acceptable from an economic perspective while fostering the retention of our cultural roots. CONCLUDING COMMENTS
With the further recognition at a broader scale of the synergies that these three concepts interactively generate, a longer term sustainable built environment can be realized. Through the appropriate stewardship of both the natural and built environments, the relationship between reused buildings and the retention of a healthy natural environment will become increasingly evident. Through recognition of the social and economic values offered by historic preservation, the connections of the cultural past to the future societal viability of reused buildings can result in the reduced pressures of expansion at the suburban periphery and renewed use of the urban core. Individually, each is a potentially significant strategy to undertake but collectively they form a synergistically coherent perspective that can hold a tremendous potential for (re)shaping a sustainable cultural landscape and ecosystem.
This essay is abridged from the original published in the Proceedings of the 92nd Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 2004. 60
16:21:08:05:08
Page 60
Page 61
DROSS; RE-GENESIS OF DIVERSE MATTER PRESERVATION, RE-USE, AND SUSTAINABILITY
LYDIA KALLIPOLITI (2005)
The word dross refers to matter that is foreign, worn out and impure; it is a phantom material condition that is unnoticeable to such an extent that it almost does not exist in our perception. Dross is worthless; it is an incidental, displaced material, and a side effect of chemical reactions that serves no purpose. Nevertheless, when it appears, a necessity is created for its removal. In time and through the use and misuse of language, the word has signified waste, impurity or any incongruous accumulation of disparate elements, pieces and material fragments.1 However, the etymological origin of the word refers to a residual substance that emerges in transitional material stages,2 such as the process of melting a metal or the sedimentation of a liquid. Therefore, dross signifies more than an entropic landscape: it depicts material derailment and the production of displaced matter. Along with the compelling will to subvert, invert or transmute matter unceasingly to higher states, the occurrence of dross reminds us that pure operations of making seem to belong to the sphere of impossibility. The purpose of analyzing the ingredients and the properties of dross substance lies beneath the wonder of metamorphic materials. Dross may be a spin-off of alchemical endeavors and a phantom material condition, but at the same time it is a product, or better stated a by-product, of social reality, paraphrasing Donna Haraway.3 The intrinsic properties of dross substance are analyzed to serve as a medium for the comprehension of a cultural phenomenon of incidentally displaced matter that is automatically rendered meaningless and serves no purpose whatsoever. Based on the perception of material impurity, this paper will attempt to encompass the generative potential of obsolete objects and spaces, or in other words waste material that is displaced culturally or functionally from either its previous or its original identity. The cultural fabric for this condition revolves around the material ramifications of unprecedented technological evolutions in communications that have irreversibly shifted our production and consumption modes during the past two decades. The technological evolutions in computer software and hardware that have been producing novel tools, have been in parallel producing immense quantities of “techno-junk,” tons of purposeless and
61
16:21:08:05:08
Page 61
1 See Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary, 2 Middle English “dros” originates from Old English drOs—DREGS. Dregs, grounds and settlings are sediments that have settled at the bottom of a liquid, or small amounts of residue. For the etymology of the word “dross,” see the Cambridge Dictionary Online,
3 I am borrowing here Donna Haraway’s definition of the “cyborg” as a cultural product of emerging socio-political regimes and practices of everyday life. Specifically, Haraway writes: “A cyborg is a cybernetic organism, a hybrid of machine and organism, a creature of social reality as well as a creature of fiction.” See Donna J. Haraway, Simians, Cyborgs and Women. The Reinvention of Nature (New York: Routledge, 1991), 149.
Dross materials.
Page 62
LYDIA KALLIPOLITI
4 The rates of computer obsolescence are so extreme that “in the year of 2005, one computer will become obsolete for every new one put on the market.” See Jim Puckett, Leslie Byster, Sarah Westervelt, Richard Gutierrez, Sheila Davis, Asma Hussain and Madhumitta Dutta (2002), “Exporting Harm. The High-Tech Trashing of Asia,” The Basel Action Network (BAN) & Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition (SVT SVTC) (February 25, 2002), . Accessed February 25, 2004. 5 “Exporting Harm,” The Basel Action Network & Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition. 6 Silicon Valley Toxics Coalition, .
7 Sheila Kennedy writes how secondary and tertiary methods of post-industrial production produce recombinant materials: materials within materials. For example, many sheet claddings are made of chopped up or reconstituted bits of other materials. See Sheila Kennedy and Christoph Grunenberg, KVA: Material Misuse (London: AA Publications, 2001), 63.
indestructible matter, almost impossible to dispose of. Over the past decade, concerns related to waste streams have shifted in their orientation. Waste is no longer an issue that relates solely to quantity. It now also relates to the intricacy of the waste matter and its material composition. With the advent of highly advanced manufacturing methods and processes, many products that reach the end of their useful lives quickly and unexpectedly, are highly complex in form and material composition, containing in parallel high amounts of embodied energy. Electronic waste, known as e-waste, is the largest growing industry of waste on a global scale.4 Alongside the numbers, a personal computer “contains over 1,000 different substances, many of which are toxic, and creates serious pollution upon disposal.”5 Its subsequent recycling becomes an excruciating and elusive task that requires numerous preparatory stages of shredding and segregating into constituent components and materials; this new type of intensive manual labor is reportedly exported to Asia and prison houses.6 Considering the socio-political conditions directly linked to this rising material reality, there seems to be a necessity to use defunct circuitboards as larger readymade complexes or as components embedded in other materials for entirely new uses. Such a practice is supported through the production of materials by recombinant methods and assemblies: materials within materials.7 Spanning scales, from the scale of obsolete “objects” to the scale of obsolete “rooms” and “buildings,” a mundane reality of big defunct objects— displaced building parts—is overwhelming the contemporary city. “Technojunk” is an emerging city-born condition; defunct oil tanks, air-conditioning tubes, advertising billboards, containers and other apparatuses articulate a new urban language that violates the building envelope or attaches itself to it as an outgrowth. If one identifies in the city fabric a stratum of buildings that can be easily mapped due to their longevity, equivalently one could identify a stratum of mechanical appendages that cannot easily be mapped due to their ephemerality. The significantly different lifetime of the two strata is the cause for an erosion of the outer building shell that cannot adapt to the change taking place in it or around it. The un-mappable urban condition of this “floating matter” in the city has not yet been explored by contemporary architecture. The necessity of such a discourse is not only driven by the formulation of an ecological awareness, but also by the need to manipulate this kind of raw material and engage with “techno-excrements” as an emerging city-born condition, derivative of the urban system’s internal erosion. RE-GENESIS OF DIVERSE MATTER; A DESIGN POST-PRAXIS
We think of Picasso’s bicycle seat (Bull’s Head) of 1944: You remember that bull’s head I exhibited recently? Out of handle bars and the bicycle seat I made a bull’s head, which everybody recognized as a 62
16:21:08:05:08
Page 62
Page 63
DROSS; RE-GENESIS OF DIVERSE MATTER
bull’s head. Thus a metamorphosis was completed; and now I would like to see another metamorphosis take place in the opposite direction. Suppose my bull’s head is thrown on the scrap heap. Perhaps some day a fellow will come along and say: “Why there’s something that would come in handy for the handle bars of my bicycle . . .” and so a double metamorphosis would have been achieved. 8 By engaging a strategy of irony as a legitimate method of approaching phenomena, Picasso asserts that there is no social or constructed reality “that we have to accept in toto,”9 but a composite present realm consisting of fragments. A discourse of “collaging” fragments is ironic, because it resists utopia. It recognizes a loss in objects, buildings or urban domains that have misplaced their previous fixed identity and encompasses this loss as a generative potential. In this citation, meaning is not an inscribed, static quality, embedded in objects. Conversely, it is tacit and malleable; it is perpetually redefined, as the object is appropriated and re-used, as it undergoes a metamorphosis. In this sense, the tactic of re-use is not solely an environmental strategy directed to the ethics of the world’s salvation. It becomes a psycho-spatial or mental disposition, “fueling a reality of change, motion, action.”10 Along the same lines of thought, the condition of flow and unremitting transformation is characterized by Gyorgy Kepes as a fundamental reorientation of the twentieth century. He explains that, The dominant matrix of nineteenth-century attitudes was the use of Marx’s term “reification”; relationships were interpreted in terms of things, objects or commodity values. Today a reversal of this attitude has begun to appear; there is a steadily increasing movement in science and in art toward processes and systems that dematerialize the object world and discredit physical possessions. What scientists considered before as substance shaped into forms, and consequently understood as tangible objects, is now recognized as energies and their dynamic organization. 11 Stretching strategies of appropriation, re-use and transformation, dross praxis does not begin from scratch, but from the reality of an existing inoperative component; therefore, meaning is inevitably shifted. It can no longer be located in the process of representing an abstract concept, but in the act of manipulating matter and bonding new functions to objects that have lost their previous, fixed identity. Instead of a genesis of meaning, there is a regeneration of meaning and identity. A dross post-praxis dwells conceptually in what one could consider as the counterpart of parthenogenesis— the phenomenon of virgin birth. It emerges as a germinal creative drive, through the desire for transformation of existing information, concepts and 63
16:21:08:05:08
Page 63
8 Alfred Barr, Picasso: Fifty Years of his Art (New York: Published for the Museum of Modern Art by Arno Press, 1946), 241. 9 Colin Rowe and Fred Koetter, Collage City (Cambridge, Mass: M.I.T. Press, 1978), 149.
10 Rowe and Koetter, Collage City.
11 Gyorgy Kepes, “Art and Ecological Consciousness” in Gyorgy Kepes (Ed.), Arts of the Environment (New York: George Braziller, 1972), 11.
Page 64
LYDIA KALLIPOLITI
12 David J. Furley argues that this philosophical position is credited to Democritus and the theory of atomism in ancient Greek philosophy. See David J. Furley, Two Studies in the Greek Atomists (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1967). According to Democritus, “the nature of the eternal things is small existences (ουσαι) unlimited in number, and in addition to these he assumes space (τπο ) infinite in extent.” See Cyril Bailey, The Greek Atomists and Epicurus (New York: Russell & Russell Inc, 1964), 117.
Re-use paradigms of building parts and components, using “molding” techniques. Work by Lo/Tek and Rachel Whiteread.
physical entities; it engrafts a copiousness of thought, defying pure, virginal creations. If we assume that nothing emerges “out of zero,”12 a post-praxis aims to retain the energy induced in creative systems and exploit the accumulative effect of knowledge and materiality. COLLAGE VERSUS MOLDING
The issue of re-use has emerged as monumentally appealing, as an offspring of rapidly advancing industrialized processes. Marcel Duchamp’s declaration of the urinal as a work of art emancipated a syllogism that disconnected the reminiscence an object was carrying along with it from its materiality. The object could then be viewed as raw material utilized for further spatial deployments. In the same spirit, Kurt Schwitters gathered material from the street and collaged it to make interior artifices in his Hanover apartment and created the compelling work of the “Merzbau.” Schwitters’ declaration was to build out of nothing—merz—meaning out of displaced material that experienced the loss of its identity. However, the importance of the “Merzbau” extends to the material techniques Schwitters deployed; he did not simply put together his collected materials in an additive manner. Instead, he created a second smooth membrane that sealed the realm of “collage.” Eventually, the compositions of the prosthetic art became latent building material, revealed locally through openings called “grottos.” Schwitters’ wrapping of his collected waste material depicts two fundamentally different principles that constitute simultaneously bipolar and inherent drives in creative praxis. These principles are collage and molding; where the first denotes an additive logic of juxtapositions and superimpositions and the latter denotes a procedural, evolving logic of transfusion. Collage, as a process of bringing fragments together and interrogating their newly formed relationships in new assemblages, constitutes a prime artistic revolution of the twentieth century. Collage embeds the notion of
64
16:21:08:05:08
Page 64
Page 65
DROSS; RE-GENESIS OF DIVERSE MATTER
re-use in an elemental sense. It is a practice that “violates ‘property’; a kind of theft.”13 Although molding also involves the appropriation of existing objects and contexts, its case is vitally different. The obsolete matter is interrogated for its textural and formal potential and successively used either as a matrix or as material that can be plastically manipulated. Then the matrix is subjected to a process of many stages: a process that essentially feeds itself as molds and casts change roles in and out without a definitive ending. By putting the two principles of collage and molding in opposition, one can draw the following assumptions: if collage signifies the change of context, then molding signifies a material transfer; if collage’s scope is a syntax change, then molding’s scope is a substance change; if the intrinsic principle of collage is prosthesis of parts, then the intrinsic principle in molding is fusion of parts; if collage is about transformation, molding is about transmutation. COMPOSITE RE-USE
Experimenting with dross strategies, two methodologies are engaged: composite graft and plastic matter. Composite grafting denotes the combination of actual obsolete objects with their molded by-products, where “by-product” refers to new artificial objects that can be formed by using an obsolete component as a reproductive matrix; or a mold where new materials can be cast. This operation functions under the premise that the occurring by-product components will retain partially characteristics of the original object, but will have different properties, creating assembly lines of materials with new local behaviors and properties, according to the material synthesis of the by-products. Composite materials make a useful analogy to the methodology of a composite graft; they are composed of elements that work together to produce material properties that are different to the properties of those elements on their own. The method also touches on some of re-use’s most deeply rooted conventions, such as the conviction that re-use should be structured as a precise analogue of the way that natural systems deal with their waste: in closed loops. By considering the production of new components out of casting on found objects, artificiality becomes part of the equation for effectively managing waste streams. Plastic matter refers to a condition of material indeterminacy, where material is malleable and deformed slightly from its original status, while retaining some of its primary characteristics. In reality, this condition occurs in a wide variety of thermoplastic polymers when heat is applied to them and they reach a mesophase where they are neither liquids nor solids. Heating is a method that is considered distinct from any tools linked to the architectural design process; however, the effects of heating in materials such as thermoplastic polymers that directly affects their chemical composition could be described as a physical analogue of currently available digital tools. 65
16:21:08:05:08
Page 65
13 Gregory L. Ulmer, “The Object of Post-Criticism” in Hal Foster (Ed.), The Anti-Aesthetic: Essays on Postmodern Culture (New York: The New Press, 1998), 102.
Page 66
LYDIA KALLIPOLITI
In order to test my selected methodological operations, I have created a matrix of objects escalating in scale that can serve as a pool for design exploration. The items of this matrix are a circuitboard, a helmet, a plastic container, a bikelid, a watertank, a partition wall and a building part. In the selection of objects, a number of parameters were considered, ranging from the textural and formal complexity of the obsolete objects, disposability difficulties and other factors. Each object of the matrix ran through different digital molding processes, escalating in complexity and varying the relationship between the cast and the mold. Consequently, the objects themselves along with the by-products that emerge from the molding operations will be used in design experiments, each in a different site and location. In this sense, the matrix plays the role of a generating device for new material, new images and new concepts. Each obsolete object delivers innumerable and variable by-products that can either open the imagination through an apocalypse of the material plasticity in each case, or can be directly used in new assemblages. An example of a dross design experiment is sited in the basement infinite corridor of M.I.T.’s main building. This location has become a depositor and a pick-up point for obsolete electronics, such as outmoded computers and machinery, acquiring in time a dross function. The intention was to use
Matrix of selected obsolete objects, spaces and building parts.
66
16:21:08:05:08
Page 66
Page 67
DROSS; RE-GENESIS OF DIVERSE MATTER
some of the discarded items, that is, the circuitboards, to create a pocket device that accommodates within it the obsolete matter and also registers its flux in and out of the corridor. The installation was conceived as a second skin on the wall—a double layer created of circuitboards and elastomer circuitboard by-products—that can be opened and “stuffed” with more obsolete items. The combination of flexible and rigid components successively into assembly lines of double-skin stripes yields a heterogeneous performance to the device, where the stripes open up and deform in multiple ways according to diversified local material properties of the new skin. In the experiment, both collage and molding operations were implemented. Molding was put in effect via the direct selection and use of the matrix’s objects as molds for the production of new elements with different material properties. Collage was put in effect via the repetition of different types of components joined in assembly lines. The combination of actual obsolete components with their occurring by-products—differentiated in texture, elasticity, form and performance—was a decision that initially made little sense, given standard environmental ethics that reason the reduction of haphazard material compositions. However, the process entailed a disclosure; the material produced out of this quasi-evolutionary logic could
Matrix of by-products generated through the use of the obsolete item as a “mold.”
67
16:21:08:05:08
Page 67
Page 68
LYDIA KALLIPOLITI
“Pocket Wall” made of obsolete circuitboards and their molded byproducts, located in the basement infinite corridor of M.I.T., and accommodating and recording the flux of obsolete items. 14 The term “adhoc ecology” is based on Charles Jencks and Nathan Silver’s definition of “adhocism,” as in situ design decisions taken for specific needs and purposes. See Charles Jencks and Nathan Silver, Adhocism: The Case for Improvisation (New York: Doubleday, 1972).
be described as an enhanced mosaic of new and preexisting properties, where the re-use of obsolete matter was no longer semantically linked to its previous use. In this sense, the strategies of composite graft and plastic matter unravel an unorthodox field of ad hoc ecology,14 meaning a methodology of re-use for specific needs, places and purposes. Withholding the burden of precise future predictions for a “natural” or metabolic, closedloop material re-use, composite graft could be useful in dealing with a new genealogy of materially intricate waste objects, so that they can be re-used as they are; launched by the drive of material synthesis, rather than the task of cautiously segregating materials in constituents.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 93rd Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 2005. 68
16:21:08:05:08
Page 68
Page 69
THE SHARED GLOBAL IDEOLOGY OF THE BIG AND THE GREEN
PRESERVATION, RE-USE, AND SUSTAINABILITY
DAVID GISSEN (2003)
Many of the massive proposals for the World Trade Center site exhibited this past year at the Winter Garden of the World Financial Center contained references to their “green-ness,” but of all the projects that made such claims, the proposal by Norman Foster and Partners stood out. The text of Norman Foster and Partners’ entry to the competition claimed that the striking twin-tower proposal “would be the biggest and greenest building ever built.” Through a variety of building technologies and subtle articulations of architectural form, Foster would certainly be able to realize such a structure, but his statement raises several theoretical issues: why would an architect want to achieve both of these contradictory goals; and how can a building be the most massive building ever built and the most environmentally sensitive? It would seem that massive development and environmental sensitivity are contradictory projects and therefore are not compatible. The unprecedented scale of Foster’s proposal demands a rethinking of the increased weaving of what might be called the theories of the “big” and the theories of the “green.” Foster’s project is not alone; recent buildings by his firm and buildings by many other firms employ environmental technologies and siting techniques at huge scales. Collectively, these projects force us to understand why and how “bigness” and “greenness” are conflated, and how we ever imagined these theoretical approaches as opposed. DEFINING BIGNESS AND GREENNESS
The large-scale architecture that defines late-modern, post-industrial, “global” urbanism was first dubbed “colossal architecture” by Mario Gandelsonas in 1990 and then “bigness” by Rem Koolhaas in 1993. Gandelsonas came up with his concept of colossal architecture by examining the work of Cesar Pelli through the writings of Jacques Derrida and Saskia Sassen.1 Koolhaas arrived at his concept of bigness as a way to describe his firm’s large-scale architectural approach that was being exhibited at M.O.M.A. in 1993 (the concept of bigness extended his critique of twentieth-century urbanism, first laid out in Delirious New York).2 Both “colossal” architecture and “bigness” described building types such as skyscrapers, high-rise buildings, mid-rise buildings, large-span buildings, among numerous other large-scale constructions. Both Gandelsonas and Koolhaas claimed that these structures emerged from the economic forces of globalization, forces that demanded universal architectural 69
16:21:08:05:08
Page 69
1 “Conditions for a Colossal Architecture” in Cesar Pelli: Buildings and Projects, Mario Gandelsonas and John Pastier, 1991, Rizzoli: New York. 2 “Bigness” in S,M,L,XL, Rem Koolhaas et al., 1995, Monacelli Press: New York.
Page 70
DAVID GISSEN
3 “Conditions for a Colossal Architecture,” p. 12.
4 “Bigness,” p. 502.
5 Hassan Fathy, “Natural Energy and Vernacular Architecture: Principles and Examples with References to Hot Arid Climates” Theories and Manifestoes of Contemporary Architecture, Charles Jencks and Karl Kropf (eds.), 1975, Academy Editions, p. 145. Kenneth Frampton, “Critical Regionalism: Six Points for an Architecture of Resistance” in The Anti-Aesthetic, Hal Foster, 1983, Port Townsend, WA: Bay Press, p. 17. Roland Rainer, Livable Environments 1972, Zurich: verlag fur Architektur Artemis.
solutions for living, working, and the sites for the production and consumption of goods. Using Cesar Pelli’s World Financial Center and Pacific Design Center as examples, Gandelsonas described colossal architecture as an architecture of endless growth and infinite verticality: “By cutting the towers’ shafts at different heights, Pelli provides a way to indicate the concept of the infinitely tall tower . . . This same concept of cutting something infinitely long is present in the colossal length of the Pacific Design Center, a skyscraper on its side . . . the colossal implies the enormous, the immense, the excessive, the lack of limits: ‘the infinite is present in it. It is too big, too large for our grasp, for our apprehension.’ ”3 Koolhaas describes bigness with similar language, but in this case, bigness is described as architecture that uses technology to realize a limitless interior space, disconnected from its surroundings: “Together, all these breaks—with scale, with architectural composition, with tradition, with transparency, with ethics—imply the final, most radical break: Bigness is no longer part of any urban tissue. It exists; at most it coexists. Its subtext is fuck context.”4 Between the 1960s and the 1990s, “green” or “environmentally conscious” architecture theorists, such as Maxwell Fry, Roland Rainer, Hassan Fathy, Sym Van der Ryn, and Kenneth Frampton, attacked the same buildings and building practices that Gandelsonas, and more particularly Koolhaas, used to outline their vision for a new global architecture. Green building theory can roughly be surmised as an ideology that professes the maintenance of local resources and cultural building traditions through a form of ecological and cultural mimesis. In “Natural Energy and Vernacular Architecture,” Hassan Fathy argues that large buildings with their equally large air-conditioning packages are causing people to “forget” local responses to the environment. Fathy calls for the use of vernacular low-tech approaches to mitigate the financial and environmental impact of large buildings. In his book Livable Environments, Roland Rainer derided the skyscraper’s and the highway’s consumption of land, calling for regionally based, small scale development. Pictures of German farmhouses and Japanese gardens were used as illustrations of a more environmentally sensitive way to build. Kenneth Frampton has repositioned the ideas in his famous “Critical Regionalism” essay in more recent and explicitly environmentalist works including his essay “Architecture and Ecosophy.” Frampton continues to maintain that large-scale speculative developments are at odds with a more local, climatically and topographically based architecture, and that these developments were responsible for the destruction of unique landscapes and cultural features.5 Frampton, Fathy, Van der Ryn, and Rainer cite the product-like nature of skyscrapers, the bulldozing of land, and the use of artificial lighting and ventilation, as symptoms of rampant international development that has gone out of control. In response, these thinkers call for humanly scaled 70
16:21:08:05:08
Page 70
Page 71
THE SHARED GLOBAL IDEOLOGY OF THE BIG AND THE GREEN
buildings that incorporate the “intimate knowledge of specific places” and “locally-inflected tactile features,” including topography, context, climate, and natural light. This combination of local features “jointly have the capacity to transcend the mere appearance of the technical,” while withstanding “the relentless onslaught of global modernization.”6
6 Fathy, p. 145; Frampton, p. 17.
THE SHARED GLOBAL AGENDA OF BIGNESS AND GREENNESS
Although the idea of a “large-scale global environmentalist architecture” would seem contradictory, within the past five years a number of architects have made claims that their projects were both “big” (in the way outlined by Gandelsonas and Koolhaas) and green (by many of the standards presented by Rainer, Fathy, Van der Ryn, and Frampton). Architects such as Norman Foster, Richard Rogers, William McDonough, and Kenneth Yeang claim that several of their recent projects simultaneously owed their form to the forces of international capitalist development and green ideology. Among the many projects, the Gap San Bruno Headquarters (1996) by William McDonough and Menara Mesiniaga (1996) by Kenneth Yeang are significant “big and green” projects, particularly described in this way. William McDonough describes Gap’s San Bruno Headquarters as a key feature of his “green business revolution,” and Kenneth Yeang received the Aga Khan award for the way he fitted IBM’s regional headquarters into its Malaysian eco-system. Numerous magazines, architectural journals, and architectural institutions have praised these projects for “tempering” the forces at work in international business that destroy context. On Kenneth Yeang’s Menara Mesiniaga, the jury of the Aga Khan prize reported: “designing with the climate in mind, it brings an aesthetic dimension to [Menara Mesiniaga] that is not to be found in typical glass-enclosed air-conditioned high rise building. The tower has become a landmark, and increased the value of the
71
16:21:08:05:08
Page 71
Below left: Gap San Bruno Headquarters, William McDonough + Partners. (Image courtesy of William McDonough + Partners.) Below right: Menara Mesiniaga, Hamzah & Yeang. (Image courtesy of Hamzah & Yeang Architects.)
Page 72
DAVID GISSEN
7 Aga Khan Prize, Jury Report, 1996;
8 “Making the Business Case for Going Green,” Michael Fainelli, Christian Science Monitor, October 18, 2001.
9 “From Western Marxism to Western Buddhism,” Slavoj Zizek in Cabinet Magazine, issue 2.
10 “Multiculturalism’s Silent Partner: It’s the New Globalized Consumer Economy, Stupid,” David Reiff, Harpers Magazine, August 1993, p. 62.
land around it. The jury found it to be a successful and promising approach to the design of many-storied structures in a tropical climate.”7 William McDonough often is praised in architecture and business magazines for showing that good business practices can incorporate green perspectives. The Christian Science Monitor wrote: “His statements encapsulate his efforts to bring about a rapprochement between corporate America and the environmental movement. One colleague in the environmental movement calls him ‘our great translator,’ because he can defend the dreams of the environmental movement with arguments that an MBA can understand.”8 The “success” of McDonough and Yeang is largely due to their ability to rectify what are presented as “opposing” forces of greenness and bigness within contemporary business. Yeang and McDonough should be praised for their commitment to reducing building energy consumption, their sympathy to local resource availability, and their constant incorporation of natural light and air in almost all of their projects. Yet the oppositional rhetoric that they have inherited from the early green movement, and that they and others use to describe their method of mediating “big” architecture, needs to be examined. Rather than seeing projects such as Menara Mesiniaga and the Gap San Bruno building as remarkable because they adjust or “translate” between global business practices and local and ecological issues, these projects actually reveal the international, global ideology that big business and environmentalism often share. As Mark Jarzombek so carefully argued, green technological systems became a billion dollar business in the 1990s, and companies often justified big green buildings as lowering the costs of business. These important observations force us to re-think whether “green” architecture is a movement about corporate resistance, which is how it has been traditionally positioned, or whether it shares some fundamental feature with the capitalist flow. Both the Slovenian theorist Slavoj Zizek and the American writer David Reiff offer a new theoretical connection between the global and the local, an explanation which could help re-position the links between the “big” and the “green.” As Zizek noted: “the opposition between globalization and the survival of local traditions is false. Globalization directly resuscitates local traditions, it literally thrives on them.”9 Zizek here is talking about tourism, spice trades, language and cultural classes, and other instances where business thrives off what is “local.” David Reiff makes a similar argument when he claims that globalization is not a form of “westernization,” as is so often claimed. “Western Civilization does not occupy a sacred place in the heart of capitalism. In fact, the dominant ideal of a ‘white, European male’ stands in the way of capturing whole new markets of non-white, non-European, non-male consumers . . . Everything is commodifiable . . . there is money being made on all the Kinte cloths and Kwanza paraphernalia.”10 72
16:21:08:05:08
Page 72
Page 73
THE SHARED GLOBAL IDEOLOGY OF THE BIG AND THE GREEN
In a related argument, Alan Calquhoun has demonstrated that the supposed “resistance” within a locally based, small-scale culture is often false. What are often called vernacular “responses”, ideological systems that certainly would not produce a 2,000,000 square foot office tower, are nonetheless often the very same “products” of cultural elites. One need not look too far back in history to see the way local and vernacular cultures are maintained as ways to maintain cultural cohesion, in the name of centralized or globalized forms of power.11 Using these arguments as a new interpretive framework, the supposed distance between bigness and greenness might be false. Like the American business man who imagines himself to learn “Japanese-ness” in order to conduct a highly competitive business in Japan, big projects now learn the particularities of the local in order to better position the needs of a business enterprise. According to a thinker such as Slavoj Zizek or David Reiff, the presence of Western corporations does not automatically result in the attitude “f k context”; often corporations embrace the local, and the forces of globalization are often needed to resuscitate local features. Menara Mesiniaga and Gap San Bruno have brought attention to the unique architecture and climatology of Malaysia and California. Menara Mesiniaga and Yeang’s other realized Malaysian towers, such as ABN-AMRO, incorporate traditional methods of air ventilation found in traditional Malaysian houses and they incorporate local plant species, all in a skyscraper format. Gap San Bruno’s habitat roof for local birds and plant life has brought increased attention to its local Californian eco-system, and put wildlife firmly within the matrix of corporate experience. Another big and green project, Eastgate, located in Zimbabwe and designed by the Pearce Partnership, is based upon termite mounds found in Zimbabwe, which use a form of natural air-conditioning to keep the mound cool. The architects studied the termite mounds and local houses, which also use local cooling methods, and incorporated them into a massive office and shopping mall building made from locally available resources and covered with native plant species.12 In an effort to affirm the inherent resistance that green architecture theory is supposed to offer, many green theorists might argue that what is being recovered is not the “real” culture, just the one that big business enterprises find useful. The wind-catching techniques that Kenneth Yeang claims are based on Malaysian traditions are not the “real” wind-catching techniques used by “real” Malaysian builders, because they are only being used for resource efficiency and their cultural meaning has been lost. The designers of Eastgate are not interested in maintaining local ecology and are not operating within a business format that resists the impact of capitalist production. The local cultures that Alan Calquhoun refers to are not the type green theorists want to revive, and so on. But what philosophical system could possibly sort through these types of divisions without resorting to a 73
16:21:08:05:08
Page 73
11 Alan Calquhoun, “Critique of Regionalism,” Casabella Magazine, 630–631, pp. 51–55.
12 In a similar development, books such as Sol Power, by Sophia and Stefan Behlig (New York: Prestel, 1996), interpret all local, indigenous, regionalist architecture through the lens of Western energy use. Malaysian long houses are “good” because they do not require airconditioning; igloos and grass houses of the steppes are “good” because they do not require heat. The actual economic or cultural conditions that shaped these buildings are ignored in lieu of a Western search for indigenous smarts. Interpreting local architecture based on the thrifty use of commodities that a building’s inhabitants never even had the opportunity to use to heat or cool their homes is a questionable enterprise.
Page 74
DAVID GISSEN
problematic epistemology? These are difficult questions that big and green projects raise and that must be addressed for those green thinkers that continue to position themselves against the “big.” A big and green project suggests alarming correlations and contradictions located within the contemporary theories of bigness and greenness. It is virtually impossible to argue with any architect who is interested in mitigating the environmental impact of buildings, especially large ones. Recent buildings such as M.V.R.D.V.’s “Pig City,” a multi-story slaughterhouse, begin to operate on an ideological plane that acknowledges the massive scale of nature production under capitalism, that is the intertwining of the big and green. The architects of this building do not emerge as “enobled” subjects who have tamed global forces by making an environmentally sensitive place to destroy thousands of animals. M.V.R.D.V. demonstrate how efforts to be “good” environmentally result in a larger and more massive factory environment. Similar thinking is behind their “stacked garden,” realized as the Dutch Pavilion at Expo 2000. In this exhibition pavilion, regional natural forms actually “de-naturalize” a global building type toward its surroundings, exposing the global ideology of environmentalism, while making a very environmentally responsible building, nonetheless. The fact that environmentalism can so easily be incorporated or extend out of twenty-first-century forms of global business practice may cause some environmentalist or politically active architects to shrink away from the big and green project. The fear is that one might be participating in some larger unstated corporate enterprise, yet the linkages between what were once imagined as opposed theories provide the circumstances for an evolving site of investigation. Hopefully we will be able to look to many more architects who examine the inter-dependence of the forces of globalization and environmentalism on some conceptual level. There is still much need for an architecture that brings attention to the destruction and maintenance of international material conditions as this moves through the parameters of international business. The ideological issues and conflicts of big and green projects should not result in an abandonment of the seeming hypocrisies advanced by them, but in a renewed reflection on the liberatory momentum contained within architecture’s paradoxes. ACKNOWLEDGMENT
The author wishes to thank Rachel Schreiber who provoked the question about Foster’s project, and forced a re-examination of many of the author’s arguments about this subject. Dutch Pavilion, M.V.R.D.V. (Image courtesy of M.V.R.D.V.)
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 91st Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 2003. 74
16:21:08:05:08
Page 74
Page 75
LEVITTOWN RETROFITTED An urbanism beyond the property line
COMMUNITY
TEDDY CRUZ (2007)
1. THE POLITICAL EQUATOR
Along the newly reconstituted global border that this post-9/11 world has produced between first and third worlds (a division, freshly reconceptualized by the Pentagon’s New Map, between “The Non-Integrating Gap” and the “The Functioning Core”), we are witnessing how societies of overproduction and excess are barricading themselves in an unprecedented way against the sectors of scarcity they have produced out of political and economic indifference. On one hand, the increasing migration of people across this global border gives shape to an unprecedented illegal flow from the non-integrating gap as the migrant communities from Latin America, Africa, and Asia move northward in search of the “strong” economies of the functioning core. On the other hand, the redistribution of centers of manufacturing moves in the opposite direction, as the functioning core targets the non-integrating gap as the site to enact its politics of outsourcing and its search for the world’s cheapest labor markets. The dramatic images emerging from this political equator converge and are intensified through the prism of the current politics of fear manifested at the border between the United States and Mexico. As the U.S. Congress passes regulation to build 700 more miles of border wall, the fusion of antiterrorism and anti-immigration sets the stage for the current confrontations over immigration policy and the further hardening of social legislature in the American metropolis. Geographies of conflict such as the San Diego– Tijuana border become anticipatory scenarios of the twenty-first-century global metropolis, where the city will increasingly become the battleground where strategies of control and tactics of transgression, formal and informal economies, legal and illegal occupations meet.
2. STRATEGIES OF SURVEILLANCE: TACTICS OF TRANSGRESSION
But despite the apocalyptic implications of a more fortified border with intensified surveillance infrastructure, the growing tension between the various communities of San Diego and those of Tijuana have elicited a multitude of insurgent responses—new opportunities for constructing alternative modes of encounter, dialogue, and debate, sharing resources and infrastructure, recycling at the most outlandish levels the fragments and situations of these two cities, and constructing practices of encroachment into the increasingly privatized and controlled public realm. 75
16:21:08:05:08
Page 75
Page 76
TEDDY CRUZ
Flow of waste moves north to south: migrant housing.
A series of “off the radar” two-way border crossings—North–South and South–North across the border wall—suggests that no matter how high and long the post-9/11 border wall becomes, it will always be transcended by migrating populations and the relentless flows of goods and services back and forth across the formidable barrier that seeks to preclude them. These illegal flows are physically manifested, in one direction, by the informal land use patterns and economies produced by migrant workers flowing from Tijuana and into San Diego, searching for the strong economy of Southern California. But, while “human flow” mobilizes northbound in search of dollars, “infrastructural waste” moves in the opposite direction to construct an insurgent, cross-border urbanism of emergency. This cross-border urbanism is made, for example, of nomadic disposable houses that literally move on wheels from San Diego into Tijuana, and also of a large amount of left over materials and systems, including garage doors and rubber tires that are recycled into new spatial narratives and informal infrastructure. Most recently, this invisible flow was made visible, when the general public was finally made aware of the thirty or so tunnels that have been dug in the last eight years, a vast “ant farm”-like maze of subterranean routes crisscrossing the border from California to Arizona. An archaeological section map of the territory today would reveal an underground urbanism worming its way into houses, churches, parking lots, warehouses, and streets. Not only were the fantastic images of cross-border two-way tunnels, all equipped with retaining walls, electricity, water extraction, and ventilation systems, exposed here, but also the undeniable presence of an informal economy and density at work at the border. 3. FROM THE GLOBAL BORDER TO THE BORDER NEIGHBORHOOD
This is how the perennial alliance between militarization and urbanization is reenacted at the San Diego–Tijuana border and later reproduced in many US neighborhoods, as the expansion of a social legislation of fear is transforming the 11 million illegal laborers who live there into criminal suspects. What are the implications of these forces of control on one hand and of non-conformity on the other in the reshaping of the American city? Our participation in the 2007 Rotterdam Architecture Biennale reflects on these trans-border urban dynamics, using this territory of conflict as backdrop to critically observe the clash between current top-down discriminating forms 76
16:21:08:05:08
Page 76
Page 77
LEVITTOWN RETROFITTED
of urban economic re-development and planning legislature (as expressed through dramatic forms of unchecked eminent domain policies supporting privatization and NIMBYism), on one hand, and the emerging American neighborhoods nationwide made of immigrants, on the other, whose bottom-up spatial tactics of encroachment thrive on informality and alternative social organizational practices. Our project primarily engages the micro scale of the neighborhood, transforming it into the urban laboratory of the twenty-first century. The forces of control at play across the most trafficked checkpoint in the world have provoked the small border neighborhoods that surround it to construct alternative urbanisms of transgression that infiltrate themselves beyond the property line in the form of non-conforming spatial and entrepreneurial practices. A migrant, small-scale activism alters the rigidity of discriminatory urban planning of the American metropolis, and searches for new modes of social sustainability and affordability. The political and economic processes behind this social activism bring new meaning to the role of the informal in the contemporary city. What is interesting here is not the “image” of the informal but the instrumentality of its operational socioeconomic and political procedures. The counter-economic and social organizational practices produced by non-profit social service organizations (turned micro-developers of alternative housing prototypes and public infrastructure at the scale of the parcel) within these neighborhoods are creating alternative sites of negotiation and collaboration. They effectively search to transform top-down legislature and lending structures, in order to generate a new brand of bottom-up social and economic justice that can bridge the political equator.
4. CASA FAMILIAR: PRACTICES OF ENCROACHMENT
The most experimental work in housing in the U.S. is not in the hands of private development or government. It is instead in the hands of progressive, community-based non-profit organizations such as Casa Familiar 77
16:21:08:05:08
Page 77
Human flow moves south to north: illegal zoning.
Tijuana subdivision: mini tract homes retrofitted to accommodate growth.
Page 78
TEDDY CRUZ
working at the border neighborhood of San Ysidro, California. These types of agencies have been the primary social service organizations engaging and managing the shifting cultural demographics caused by immigration within many mid-city neighborhoods in the U.S. DESIGNING CONDITIONS, DESIGNING COLLABORATION: A.H.O.Z. MICRO-POLICY
Working with the premise that no advances in housing design in the U.S. can occur without advances in its housing policy and subsidy structures, our collaboration with Casa Familiar has been grounded on the shaping of counter political and economic frameworks that can, in turn, yield tactical housing projects inclusive of these neighborhoods’ informal patterns of mixed-use and density. In San Ysidro housing will not be only “units” spread indifferently across the territory. Here, housing is dwelling in relationship to a social and cultural program managed by Casa Familiar. In this context, density is not just an amount of “units per acre,” it is an amount of “social exchanges per acre.” In the last five years, we have designed a micro-policy with Casa Familiar that can act as an informal process of urban and economic development for the neighborhood, and empower the community of San Ysidro to become a developer of alternative dwelling prototypes for its own housing stock. This “Affordable Housing Overlay Zone” (A.H.O.Z.) micro-policy proposes that community-based non-profit organizations such as Casa Familiar can become mediating agencies between the municipality and the neighborhood, facilitating knowledge, policy, and micro-credits. In essence, these agencies will incrementally become informal City Halls, managing and supporting the shifting of socio-cultural demographics within many of these inner city neighborhoods. LIVING ROOMS AT THE BORDER
“Living Rooms at the Border” is the small housing project that emerges from the micro-policy and serves as a catalyst to anticipate San Diego’s needed densities and mixed uses, while becoming a political instrument to enable Casa Familiar to further transform existing rigid zoning regulation for the border city of San Ysidro. The informal negotiation of boundaries and spaces typical of this neighborhood becomes the basis for incremental design solutions that have a catalytic effect on the urban fabric. In a small parcel where existing zoning allows only three units of housing, this project proposes, through negotiated density bonuses and by sharing kitchens, twelve affordable housing units, the adaptive re-use of an existing 1927 church on the site as a community center, offices for non-profit in the church’s new attic, and a community garden that serves as social armature to support this community’s nonconforming micro-economies and improvisational public events. Connected 78
16:21:08:05:08
Page 78
Page 79
LEVITTOWN RETROFITTED
Counter tactics of development, as a community-based non-profit organization (Casa Familiar) becomes a facilitator of political and economic frameworks for affordable mixed housing (in the border neighborhood of San Ysidro).
to the garden and the church, this armature is composed of a series of openair rooms that contain electricity, serving as a site for a variety of neighborhood activities. The ambiguity of these spaces takes a different meaning as they are inscribed with a social program and community organization managed by Casa Familiar. The pairing of ambiguity and specificity is the essence of this project. The tactical interweaving of dwelling units and social service infrastructure transforms the small parcel into a system that can anticipate, organize, and promote social encounter. Furthermore, Casa Familiar injects micro-economic tactics such as time banking through sweat equity to produce alternative modes of affordability (barter housing units, exchange of rent for social service, etc.). In a place where current regulation allows only one use, we propose five different uses that support one another, suggesting a model of social sustainability for the neighborhood, one that conveys density not as bulk but as social choreography and neighborhood collaboration.
This essay is drawn from a paper presented at Global Place: Practice, Politics and the Polis, a conference at the University of Michigan in January 2007. 79
16:21:08:05:08
Page 79
Page 80
COMMUNITY
THE MNEMONIC CITY Duality, invisibility, and memory in American urbanism CRAIG EVAN BARTON (1996)
Ask your wife to take you around the gin mills and the barbershops and the juke joints and the churches, Brother. Yes and the beauty parlors on Saturdays when they’re frying hair. A whole unrecorded history is spoken then, Brother. Ralph Ellison, Invisible Man, 1952 This essay explores the effect of race upon the development of the urban fabric of cities in the American South. While these cultural issues are present throughout America, the American South is a particularly interesting field of inquiry because of the historical relationship between black and white cultures, their proximity to one another throughout the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries and ultimately because so many of the critical events of the Civil Rights Movement took place there. Using the work of Hannah Arendt, Pierre Nora and Maurice Halbwachs, the text examines the issues of duality, invisibility, and memory and proposes to integrate them into a critical reading of the southern city in an effort to better understand the imprint of the phenomenal cultural forces left upon the physical form of cities. In “The New Cultural Politics of Difference,” Cornel West proposed that in attempting to control the means and practices of representation, the late twentieth-century cultural worker faced three critical challenges which he defined as intellectual, existential and political.
Aerial view of Selma, Alabama.
1 “The New Cultural Politics of Difference,” in West, Cornel, Keeping Faith Philosophy and Race in America (New York: Routledge Press, 1993), p. 5.
The intellectual challenge . . . is how to think about representational practices in terms of history, culture and society. How does one understand, analyze and enact such practices today? An adequate answer to this question can be attempted only after one comes to terms with the insights and blindnesses of earlier attempts to grapple with the question in light of the evolving crisis in different histories, cultures and societies. The existential challenge requires that the cultural worker acquire the requisite cultural capital necessary to produce and survive. The political challenge necessitates a view toward the coalescing of black and white peoples based upon a commonalty of moral and political intent. 1 It is in light of West’s existential challenge that I would like to examine issues of race, culture, spatial representation and urbanism. As architects 80
16:21:08:05:08
Page 80
Page 81
THE MNEMONIC CITY
and urbanists we are among the cultural workers to whom West refers; the cultural capital which we need to acquire lies in the invisible history and memory of the city. Intellectually we bear the responsibility through our work to investigate, discern and ultimately to make legible the “invisible histories” to which Ellison refers. The nature of this investigation is speculative and as such is incomplete. But I feel the discussion which these issues prompt is critical to our conception of the city of the future. I find that the questions and issues which I keep returning to are those which seek to understand the role of race in our conception of the historical city (by which I mean the city of collective memories), and in a vision for the city of the future. My interest lies not so much in using the lens of architectural design and history to acquire a synthetic understanding of the chronological development of architectural typology and in so doing to review the development of urban form in America, but rather to go beyond the orthodox methods of architectural history and design to comprehend, within the city, the relationship between space, form, history and memory. In doing so I find that I am more compelled by that to which architecture does not yet speak directly: issues of race, ethnicity and recognition of cultural identity. These have become the resonant concerns of my work. I speak from the margins, as a witness to an architectural culture and history which has yet to adequately represent the diversity of the culture which it shelters. Left unquestioned, architecture, and the architectural history of America, would leave us with the succinct impression that the worldview reflected in its interpretation of built form, is one which contains little or no reference to any of us living and working at the margins: no women, blacks or any group understood to be “other.” Is it simply a question of historical oversight, corrected by tardy acknowledgment of the contributions of many of these groups? I suspect not. Contemporary cultural criticism has attempted to re-focus the debate from object to subject; forcing us to ask whom and what does history seek to interpret and represent. The history of the United States is largely mute about the presence and contribution of marginal cultures, and specifically black culture, to the development of American culture. The discursive language of the city speaks to few of the components of cultural identity to which I feel a proprietary interest. As a discipline, architecture proposes that the city is the synthesis of the memory of its political, social and economic histories. Moreover, this synthetic, collective urban history is understood to be legible and as such is subject to a variety of modes of formal analysis. The theoretical and pragmatic investigation of American urbanism has typically focused on issues such as technology and its impact upon typology and morphology, and on the significance of style in the evolution of urban fabric. Because cities have traditionally been understood as artifacts of the dominant cultures which built them, the impact of their marginalized cultures has not been thoroughly examined, and yet the form and image of 81
16:21:08:05:08
Page 81
Page 82
CRAIG EVAN BARTON
2 Wright, Richard, White Man Listen! (New York: Doubleday, 1957), p. 109.
3 Plessy v. Ferguson was argued before the United States Supreme Court in April 1896 and decided in favor of the plaintiff later that year. In this case the court affirmed a lower court ruling supporting the constitutionality of a statute enacted by the State of Louisiana which provided for separate railway cars for white and black travelers. The ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court provided for a revised reading of the obligations of the Thirteenth Amendment (which made illegal the practice of slavery) and modified the scope of the language of the Fourteenth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution (which provided for equal protection under the law for all citizens). In the case of the Fourteenth Amendment the interpretive revisions of the scope of the amendment’s language allowed the doctrine of “separate but equal” to be articulated.
American urbanism, particularly in the American South, is clearly linked to the presence of a black population and culture. The problem of course is that history is subjective, constructing a narrative, which with its gaps and omissions has tended to render black culture historically “invisible.” Writing in 1957, Richard Wright noted that, “The history of the Negro in America is the history of America written in vivid and bloody terms; it is the history of Western Man writ small.”2 For the black cultural worker, West’s tenets of “production and survival” are inextricably tied to a responsibility to augment the narratives of dominant history through the “excavation” and construction of those objects and devices capable of evoking memory. In this context memory becomes a tool with which to construct a critical reading of the city by making visible that which is invisible. Historically the construction of American black culture has been cast in terms of duality and of opposition. To be black is to be the “other,” separate and subordinate to dominant culture. Black culture has been defined not so much by what it is but by what is not. To be black is to be not white, and as such to be understood as being neither politically empowered nor culturally affluent. The oppositional nature and the terms of the definition of this cultural construction have resulted in a singular and monolithic representation of black culture, when in fact black culture is rich and diverse. The irony of course is that in America, black culture serves as a sort of avant-garde testing ground for popular culture in general. Fashion, music, art and language draw heavily and directly from contemporary black culture. Black culture is nothing if not diverse, yet the myth of a singular black experience prevails, and when accepted as fact serves only to demodulate the complexity of black culture, marginalize it, remove it from the discourse about the construction of culture and ultimately render it invisible. The invisibility of black cultural narrative is largely due to the informal traditions and formal statutory practices of racism, which with its separation of black and white cultures formed a series of racially distinct social, physical and spatial structures. Within the form and structure of American cities, particularly cities in the American South, the physical and spatial legacy of Plessy v. Ferguson3 (in which the social and political doctrine of “separate but equal” was articulated) and its interpretation of the Constitution’s Fourteenth Amendment is an urbanism of separation, duality and invisibility, where the forms and spaces of black culture were separate from and subordinate to those of white culture. By separating one culture from the other and by establishing a hierarchy of space and form, black culture was effectively isolated and rendered invisible in the public realm of the dominant culture. The concept of “separate but equal” identities creates a hierarchy of value which elevates the products of the dominant culture and relegates to a 82
16:21:08:05:08
Page 82
Page 83
THE MNEMONIC CITY
subordinate status the products, forms and spaces controlled or conditioned by marginal culture. Because the urban artifacts of black culture were so devalued within the fabric of the city they have become both phenomenally and literally invisible. As a result, the urban artifacts produced and/or conditioned by black culture have largely been excluded from the theoretical discourse about the conception and re-invention of American urbanism and so the impact of black culture upon it has been minor. Yet a critical reading of American urbanism is incomplete if it fails to include the forms and spaces influenced by black culture. There are many ways in which invisibility can be defined. Literally we understand that which is invisible is that which is unseen. Contemporary culture ascribes a generally positive value to invisibility, nominally equating it with the freedom to move unseen. Within the context of architecture and urbanism invisibility is a cultural construction, achieved by consciously removing from the public gaze that which is neither intended nor desired to be seen. Within an understanding of the phenomenal forces of culture operative in the city, “invisibility” is as much a social and political phenomenon as it is a literal and physical one. Considered in this context Hannah Arendt’s concept of “spaces of appearance” provides a critical tool with which to understand the construction of invisibility. For Arendt “the space of public appearance”4 is that “space” “which comes into being whenever men are together in the manner of speech and action.”5 Further it is the space
Segregated drinking fountain. (Photo by Elliot Erwitt, courtesy Magnum Photos.)
4 Arendt, Hannah, The Human Condition (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1958), p. 199. 5 Ibid.
where I appear to others as others appear to me . . . This space does not always exist, and although all men are capable of deed and word, most of them—like the slave, the foreigner, and the barbarian in antiquity, like the laborer or craftsman prior to the modern age, the jobholder or businessman in our world do not live in it. No man, moreover, can live in it all the time. To be deprived of it means to be deprived of reality which humanly and politically speaking is the same as appearance.6
6 Ibid., pp. 198–199.
Yet to be visible in this space one must be able to “appear through speech and action” in the public realm. The duality of American urban structure particularly in the South made “visibility” for black culture virtually impossible. Perhaps the most important legacy of the American Civil Rights Movement was its challenge to enter and to be visible in the space of public appearance. In the theory of landscape architecture, the result of an agent or (culture) acting upon a medium or (a natural area) is defined as a “cultural landscape.” 7 If by analogy a fragment of the city is the medium and culture the agent that acts upon it, the result can be defined as a “cultural fragment.” It is axiomatic, then, that the memory of culture is inscribed onto these fragments, and that these fragments, conditioned by social, political and cultural forces, form the fabric of the city. Individually and collectively
7 Sauer, “Landscape,” in Lark, Robert P. and Gary L. Peters, eds., Dictionary of Concepts in Human Geography (Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1983), pp. 139–144.
83
16:21:08:05:08
Page 83
Page 84
CRAIG EVAN BARTON
these cultural fragments are what Pierre Nora terms “lieux de memoire” or “sites of memory.” As mnemonic devices these fragments are the sites where
8 Fabre, Genevieve and O’Mealley, Robert, eds., History and Memory in African American Culture (New York: Oxford University Press, 1994), p. 284.
9 Halbwachs, Maurice, The Collective Memory (New York: Harper & Row, 1980), p. 50b.
10 Ibid.
memory crystallizes and secretes itself at a particular historical moment, a turning where consciousness of a break with the past is bound up with a sense that memory has been torn—but torn in such a way as to pose the problem of the embodiment of memory in certain sites where a sense of historical continuity persists.8 Linked through “excavation,” construction, or forms of intervention, the “collective memory” or mnemonic narrative of the city is made visible in these fragments. The narratives evoked by these sites of memory provide a means to further explore the idea of the American city as a cultural artifact; to examine the dominant and marginalized cultures which form the city. Further they offer the opportunity to investigate alternative readings of the fabric of the American city by examining the issues of site, form and memory as they relate to the spatiality of culture and to the construction of “place” within the urban landscape. Within this proposition lies the idea that “place” is codified by the relationship of form and space to a series of social, political and cultural forces which historically have shaped the form of any given city. When they are made “visible” in the urban fabric these forces provide a narrative structure with which to comprehend the memories of a city. Here it is important to understand the concept of memory which Maurice Halbwachs defines as the “group or collective memory.”9 For Halbwachs collective memory allows an individual to “act merely as a member of group helping to evoke and maintain impersonal remembrances of the group,”10 and as such collective memory can function as a historical narrative. Within any given urban fabric, some of these cultural fragments are more legible (opaque) and others are invisible (transparent). The relative transparency and opacity of the cultural fragments reflects the explicit hierarchy of social values and status. The most opaque fragments are historically connected to the dominant culture, and are literally the most solid and visible, while the fragments of marginalized cultures tend to be transparent, invisible and ephemeral. For these marginalized cultures, the power of the fragment as a mnemonic device lies in its ability to supplement the gaps of dominant history. With greater legibility these fragments hold the potential to alter the context in which urban history is read, and through this altered context to develop architecture derived from the reading and analysis of these fragments and thus expressive of that culture. The cities of the American South provide an opportunity to examine the construction of invisibility, the legibility of various “sites of memory” and the articulation of narratives of collective memory. As an example, in a city 84
16:21:08:05:08
Page 84
Page 85
THE MNEMONIC CITY
like Selma, Alabama, one finds an urbanism of duality, where there are in fact two separate “cities,” one black and one white with areas of overlap or superimposition. These cities are constructed or formed by a series of fragments codified by responses to the specific narratives of black and white culture. However, these dual cultural narratives are distinct and in their distinction are not equally legible, so that most of the narratives and fragments of black Selma recede and become “invisible.” The dual structure of the city in fact provided for the construction of separate sites of memory, and spaces of appearance. The sites of memory for Selma’s white culture are the spaces of the public realm. The political, social and culture spaces formed by the morphological structure of the city are coincident with the conveyed meanings of the courthouse (the Dallas County Courthouse), the public square and the main street (Broad Street) and the entry into the city (the Edmund Pettus Bridge). This is the “city” which is legible in maps, images and texts. The equivalent spaces of the black city contain narrative structures which are more disparate, not supported by a morphological structure, and in fact are superimposed upon an urban form that never intended to support them. For example, the major political and social space in the black city is found in the street, Sylvan Street, which connects two of the city’s major black churches (First Baptist and Brown’s AME Chapel). This street does not read as a space of public assembly, yet within the dual nature of southern urbanism, where entrance is denied to the more formal public realm, this is precisely its role. The dual structure of the urban fabric creates spaces where this is a discontinuity between site, form and meaning. This phenomenon forces certain spaces to derive meaning from a use superimposed onto them, while allowing other spaces to derive meaning directly from the form of the city. The segregated school house, the separate “colored” entrance to a movie theater, the unpaved street, the shotgun house, the separate cemetery and the inaccessible public building are but a few of the examples of the types of mnemonic fragments still extant in the fabric of American cities. Within them lie the formal devices of hierarchy of scale, material and implied permanence useful for the conception of architectural intervention. In contemporary society many of these devices with which “invisibility” was built lie obscured and unseen, bearing a muted witness to an era recalled by only a few. Left obscured, these fragments, their memories, and the narratives derived from them are once again marginalized. These elements form a critical part of our cultural history which needs to be preserved. It can be argued that the challenge of the late twentieth century American architect/urbanist is to be able to discern the “sites” of memory and from them “build” the mnemonic city by creating those interventions that increase the opacity of specific cultural fragments. With increased “visibility” these fragments can provide the narratives that alter the 85
16:21:08:05:08
Page 85
Dallas County Courthouse, Selma, Alabama. (Author’s photo.)
Edmund Pettus Bridge, Selma, Alabama. (Author’s photo.)
Page 86
CRAIG EVAN BARTON
Brown’s Chapel and First Baptist Churches, Sylvan St, Selma, Alabama. (Author’s photo.)
perception of the history of the city. This task is significant because within the urban fabric of cities in the American South lie sites seminal to understanding the evolution of the American Civil Rights Movement and the social, political and cultural transformations which emerged from it. As such these cities provide a unique opportunity to examine the strategies and methodologies for discerning, analyzing and interpreting the fragments and narratives of black and white culture. Unfortunately, for a variety of reasons, many of these sites are now so difficult to discern that we may say that they are “invisible.” Their “invisibility” contributes to an incomplete reading of the history and culture of these cities. Legible, these fragments constitute the basis for the mnemonic city, a city of memory.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 84th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 1996. 86
16:21:08:05:08
Page 86
Page 87
MAPPING EAST LOS ANGELES Aesthetics and cultural politics in an other L.A.
COMMUNITY
JOSÉ GÁMEZ (2000)
INTRODUCTION
During the 1980s and early 1990s, scholars in both Europe and Latin America began to look to the Chicano experience in the United States as a means of understanding global processes of differentiation and ethnic identification.1 This interest in Chicano identity is due, in part, to its position within processes of cultural production; cultural practices tied to the politics of Chicano identity have made visible the conditions of internal colonization and of postcolonial resistance through a variety of media including art, literature, and urbanism. As the largest Mexican-American city in the U.S., Los Angeles—particularly East Los Angeles—has become an integral part of the social identity of many Chicanos and Latinos. Here, place and identity intersect creating both a real and an imagined geography that has served as the place of and inspiration for a range of critical practices. These conscious and creative explorations have contributed to the production of distinctly Chicano and Latino cultural landscapes. In this sense, the politics of Chicano identity have helped to translate, re-inscribe, and re-claim the (post)colonial center—the modern metropolis.2 This paper explores three areas of Chicano cultural production rooted in East Los Angeles in order to illustrate their importance to understandings of contemporary Latino L.A.: street muralism, the spatial narratives of Asco and Frank Romero, and the architectural investigations of James Rojas and the team of Margaret Crawford and A.D.O.B.E. L.A.. By revisiting these past manifestations of an other Los Angeles, this paper will illustrate how the politics of identity can inform the contemporary city.
1 See: Hector Calderón and José David Saldívar, eds., Criticism in the Borderlands: Studies in Chicano Literature, Culture, and Ideology (Durham: Duke University Press, 1994) 1.
2 See: Homi K. Bhabha, The Location of Culture (London: Routledge, 1994).
CHICANO SOCIO-SPATIAL IDENTITY
Writer and poet Rubén Martínez has described his life in Los Angeles as a “blend of cultures, languages, and ideologies (Anglo/Latino, Spanish/ English, individualist/collectivist)”—as a life located in both the North and South and neither simultaneously.3 For Martínez, L.A. is shaped by social and spatial divisions that are rooted in global political geographies and realized in local cultural landscapes. Los Angeles and the American Southwest have been understood as Atzlán, the Chicano cultural homeland; Los Angeles was once a Mexican territory and became an American city via military occupation and cultural domination. The same is true of much of what is 87
16:21:08:05:08
Page 87
3 Rubén Martínez, The Other Side: Notes from the New L.A., Mexico City, and Beyond (New York: Vintage Departures, 1993).
Page 88
JOSÉ GÁMEZ
4 See: Edward Murguia, Assimilation, Colonialism, and the Mexican American People (Austin: University of Texas Press, 1975); see also Anne McClintock, “The Angel of Progress: Pitfalls of the Term Postcolonialism,” Colonial Discourse and Post-Colonial Theory: A Reader, edited by Patrick Williams and Laura Chrisman (New York: Columbia University Press, 1994) 291–304. 5 See: Tomás Ybarra-Frausto, “The Chicano Movement: The Movement of Chicano Art,” Exhibiting Cultures: The Poetics and Politics of Museum Display, edited by Ivan Karp and Steven D. Lavine (Washington DC: Smithsonian Institution, 1991) 128–129. 6 See: Shifra M. Goldman and Tomás Ybarra-Frausto, “The Political and Social Contexts of Chicano Art,” Chicano Art: Resistance and Affirmation, 1965– 1985, edited by Richard Griswold del Castillo, Teresa McKenna, and Yvonne Yarbro-Bejarano (Los Angeles: Wight Art Gallery/ University of California Press, 1991) 83–95.
7 Guillermo Gomez-Peña, “A New Artistic Continent,” High Performance 9.3 (1986): 27.
now considered the southwestern region of the U.S. As an occupied territory and, later, as an annexed state, California became a colonized space—a space overtaken by American westward expansion. The local Mexican populations therefore became internally colonized peoples.4 In this sense, Los Angeles became and continues to be a cultural and physical borderland in the sense described by Martínez. In many ways, this need to negotiate cultural worlds provides a tie to the Chicano movement in both art and politics. As an outgrowth of the 1960s era of social struggles, the Chicano movement, or El Movimiento, was ideologically aligned with the civil rights movements in the U.S. as well as international student and Third World liberation movements.5 Although it shared common goals with a wide range of struggles, the Chicano movement aimed to address the marginalized condition of Mexican-American groups in the United States. While few printed documents spell out a specific Chicano art manifesto, the outlines of an aesthetic can be found in a variety of sources including artists’ statements, oral histories, and the influential publication, El plan espiritual de Atzlán (“The Spiritual Plan of Atzlán”), that emerged from the Chicano Youth Conference held in Denver in 1969.6 In these documents, one finds a political vision clearly tied to grass-roots artistic production; artists were called upon to help disseminate information and to help define the cultural identity of the Chicano communities. This link between cultural identity and manifestations of that culture in material form provides a key to understanding Chicano socio-spatial practices as they apply to architecture and the city. Chicano art provides evidence of clearly motivated cultural practices: Chicano art, by definition, seeks to bring to light colonial legacies and forces of marginalization by drawing upon and re-defining the cultural landscape of the city. In this sense, Chicano art actively embraces the politics of identity in order to engage a wide range of urban audiences. To be clear, it is not the production of the urban barrio per se that this paper takes as its focus; rather, it is the conscious expression of Chicano identity as a representational practice that lies at the center of this investigation. However, Chicano art often draws its strength from everyday barrio life in which “art objects are embedded in a network of cultural sites . . . that express the community’s sense of itself, the aesthetic display projecting a sort of visual biculturalism.”7 This bicultural expressiveness illustrates the cultural hybridity necessary to navigate the contemporary postcolonial metropolis. The location of Chicano culture within a borderland between the social worlds of the U.S. and Mexico is its greatest asset—one that has drawn the attention of scholars and cultural theorists worldwide. In the words of Guillermo Gomez-Peña, an internationally respected artist and cultural critic, the “strength and originality of Chicano-Latino con88
16:21:08:05:08
Page 88
Page 89
MAPPING EAST LOS ANGELES
temporary art in the US lies partially in the fact that it is often bicultural, bilingual, and/or biconceptual.”8 This type of cultural flexibility allows Chicano and Latino artists to operate within what both Gomez-Peña and cultural theorist Homi Bhabha have described as a third-space of cultural expression that confronts the postcolonial present.9 The border, in this sense, becomes a site for intervening into the present that “demands an encounter with ‘newness’ that is not a part of the continuum of the past and present. It creates a sense of the new as an insurgent act of cultural translation.”10 MURALISM AND THE (IN)VISIBLE CITY
The urban mural is one example of such insurgent cultural translation. While not solely tied to the Chicano movement, the urban mural developed as a medium of expression that helped to reclaim the public realm of the city and contributed to a larger struggle to overcome racism and poverty. Urban murals, as components of a political visual voice, became one of the most enduring modes of insurgent cultural translation available not only to Chicano communities in Los Angeles but also to marginalized communities in general.11 Influenced by the Mexican muralists of the 1930s, the Chicano movement called for a monumental public art easily accessed in everyday life. This was often translated into the appropriation of available surfaces for the dissemination of information and images. By mixing longstanding symbolic iconography rooted in cultural tradition with images tied to local settings, murals provided cultural commentaries tied to contemporary struggles. As Coco Fusco, an artist and cultural theorist, has pointed out,
Figure 1. Willie Herrón’s The Cracked Wall (photo by Ramón Ramírez). 8 Ibid., 27.
9 See: Homi Bhabha, The Location of Culture (London: Routledge, 1994).
10 Ibid., 7.
Symbolic action expressed via artistic creation . . . has become the primary arena for innovative self-definition among politically disenfranchised peoples. This syncretic fusing of different forms of belief and practice has enabled disempowered groups to maintain their traditions while endorsing various cultural recycling methods that infuse old icons with new meanings.12
11 See: Alan W. Barnett, Community Murals: The People’s Art (London: Associated University Presses/Cornwall, 1984).
Murals, as representations of political identity, have also helped to shape debates within the Chicano community. In the work of artists such as Judith Baca, urban murals serve as symbolic reminders to greater Los Angeles of an other L.A. often subsumed under a mythologized Spanish heritage.13 Her work has attempted to create a unified identity that confronts dominant cultural (mis)representations and re-inscribes an often overlooked Mexican past into the contemporary urban realm. But for others, attempts to define unified notions of identity are themselves limiting. Willie Herrón’s mural, The Cracked Wall, illustrates that the Chicano community is not easily defined (see Figure 1). Herrón’s mural, located in a back alley rather than 89
16:21:08:05:08
Page 89
12 Coco Fusco, English is Broken Here: Notes on Cultural Fusion in the Americas (New York: New Press, 1995) 33–36.
13 A similar project to memorialize African American, Asian American and Latino urban histories in Los Angeles has been Dolores Hayden’s Power of Place Project. See: Dolores Hayden, The Power of Place: Urban Landscapes as Public History (Cambridge, MA: M.I.T. Press, 1995).
Page 90
JOSÉ GÁMEZ
along a public avenue, was intended not as a gesture towards the city at large but rather as a commentary internal to the Chicano community and as a reminder of local problems such as gang activity, drug abuse, and provincialism. In this sense, Herrón did not seek a homogeneous unity; rather, he sought to draw the community together around a set of issues critical to the development of Latino Los Angeles. In so doing, muralists like Baca and Herrón initiated a dialog that has contributed to both the physical and social shape of east L.A.. WALKING IN L.A.: ASCO AND THE POLITICS OF PLACE
14 Asco consisted of Harry Gamboa, Jr., Gluglio “Gronk” Nicandro, Willie Herrón, and Patisse Valdez.
15 Arjun Appadurai, “Disjuncture and Difference in the Global Cultural Economy,” Colonial Discourse and Post-Colonial Theory: A Reader, edited by Patrick Williams and Laura Chrisman (New York: Columbia University Press, 1994) 331.
The internal critique begun by Herrón in The Cracked Wall carried over into his work in the collaborative art group Asco during the early 1970s.14 Active from 1971 to 1985, Asco was the first and most influential Chicano conceptual/performance art group to come out of East Los Angeles. Utilizing improvisation, performance, and guerrilla theater, Asco transformed the city into their canvas; through a series of performances beginning with Stations of the Cross on December 24, 1971, Asco began their cultural assault on institutions shaping the barrio. Staged unannounced along a one-mile stretch of Whittier Boulevard in East L.A., Stations of the Cross appropriated and re-deployed Catholic iconography in order to challenge local institutional power structures while simultaneously locating the politics of identity within the space of the city. The choice of Whittier Boulevard itself was not haphazardly made; Whittier connects the east side to downtown Los Angeles and has often been called the symbolic heart of East L.A.. Additionally, Whittier was the site of the Chicano Moratorium—a Vietnam protest rally that ended in police violence and the death of Rubén Salazar, an active Chicano journalist with the Los Angeles Times. Asco returned to Whittier Boulevard several times over the following years and each new performance continued to explore the connections between the politics of identity, space, and place (see Figure 2). Additionally, each new performance introduced investigations into various media—film, muralism, and photography—thereby providing numerous opportunities to appropriate and re-articulate the image of the city. Through the use of site-specific performances, film, and guerrilla tactics, Asco put the politics of identity of East Los Angeles in general, and Whittier Boulevard specifically, into play within a broad discursive landscape. While created prior to the present state of media technologies, Asco’s place-based interventions are early examples of what cultural theorist Arjun Appadurai has labeled the ideoscapes of contemporary cultural flows— the “concatenations of images . . . and counter-ideologies of movements explicitly oriented to capturing state power or a piece of it.”15 Chicano urban art, in this sense, served to mobilize landscapes of images that 90
16:21:08:05:08
Page 90
Page 91
MAPPING EAST LOS ANGELES
challenged notions of a unified Chicano identity, of established artistic practices, and mainstream perceptions of the East Los Angeles. In doing so, East L.A. became a symbolic and physical center in the production of Chicano identity and served as evidence that public space is tied to socio-spatial action. POST-ASCO TACTICS: COLLECTIVE URBANISM
The influence of Asco’s urban theater spread as other groups, among them Los Four, took on the politics of identity in Los Angeles.16 Grupos, or collaborative artistic groups, are in many ways a legacy of the Chicano movement that persists to this day; grupos were often formed around local arts centers and aimed to promote grassroots artistic practices including social and spatial action. Los Four grew out of this tradition by incorporating street imagery into their work, particularly graffiti, as a means of bringing the politics of everyday life into the realm of artistic production. After the group’s demise in 1983, Los Four co-founder Frank Romero continued to paint scenes of East Los Angeles in order to bring the message of Chicano struggle to outside audiences. This agenda remained a central part of Romero’s work and provided a lens onto the politics of identity in Los Angeles for both Chicano and mainstream art audiences. For Romero, Whittier became a paradigmatic site of cultural resistance; two of his paintings, The Closing of Whittier Boulevard and The Death of Rubén Salazar, represent clashes between the dominant society of Los Angeles and the Chicano community in East L.A. (see Figure 3). As with the previous efforts of Los Four, Romero intended to further the agenda of the Chicano movement by introducing the politics of identity into established artistic circles. However, the importance of place remained; by addressing sitespecific events, Romero maintained a dialog with East L.A., contributed to the on-going development of Chicano identity, and connected the space of 91
16:21:08:05:08
Page 91
Figure 2. Left: Asco performing First Supper (After a Major Riot) in 1974 (image copyright held by Harry Gamboa and reprinted courtesy of the artist). Figure 3. Right: Frank Romero’s The Death of Rubén Salazar (image copyright held by Frank Romero and reprinted courtesy of the artist).
16 Los Four were contemporaries of Asco and the group was active from 1973 to 1983. The members of Los Four were: Carlos Almaraz, Roberto de la Rocha, Gilbert “Magu” Luján, and Frank Romero.
Page 92
JOSÉ GÁMEZ
17 The Closing of Whittier Boulevard was painted in 1984 and The Death of Rubén Salazar was painted between 1985 and 1986.
18 See: George Lipsitz, Time Passages: Collective Memory and American Popular Culture (Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press, 1990).
19 Mike Davis, “Chinatown Revisited?” in Sex, Death, and God in L.A. (Berkeley: University of California Press, 1994) 35. 20 James T. Rojas, “The Enacted Environment: The Creation of ‘Place’ by Mexicans and Mexican Americans in East Los Angeles,” Master’s Thesis, Department of Architecture, M.I.T., 1991, 14.
the gallery to the streets of the barrio. In doing so, the often de-politicized context of artistic display was disrupted through the introduction of the politics of identity. Interestingly, Romero did not participate in either of the events he depicted in The Death of Rubén Salazar or in The Closing of Whittier Boulevard; each event occurred in the early years of the Chicano movement while Romero’s paintings were executed some fifteen years later.17 Here, Romero drew upon the collective memory of East Los Angeles for his inspiration. In this sense, the works of Asco, Los Four, and Romero are not only related but are, in many ways, successive projects within a particular family of resemblance—entities within an on-going set of cultural negotiations.18 EVERYDAY PRACTICES AND THE OBJECT OF STUDY
By delving into social and political issues, Chicano artists began the process of re-writing the history of Los Angeles in order to include pieces of a story previously left out. This was not simply a process of historical revision: this was a spatialized project that took the urban realm as a part of its tactical base. The city became the site, subject, and text for critical intervention. In this sense, the city is not a rigid plan; rather, it is a set of collective inheritances to be continually re-articulated. In this light, the socio-spatial “praxis” and “material force” of Chicano and Latino communities illustrate processes of urban transformation and provide ways to re-think contemporary urbanism.19 For urban planner James T. Rojas, East Los Angeles is an enacted landscape where the “identity of place . . . is created through the culturally related behavior patterns of the residents.”20 Through his work as a graduate student in the Department of Architecture at M.I.T., Rojas illustrated the means by which the city is tailored to meet the cultural preferences of Mexican and Mexican American communities in East Los Angeles. This process of place-making through enactment involves various forms of architectural and urban props—murals, fences, vendor carts—that are incorporated into the existing urban fabric and help to create distinctive cultural landscapes. Although unpublished, Rojas’ master’s thesis has been widely influential within architectural, urban design, and urban planning circles (particularly in academia) where both faculty and students have drawn upon his work as the basis for further research. Rojas provided not only a reading of a Chicano cultural landscape but also a new academic terrain largely overlooked by schools of architecture and urbanism. The importance of Rojas’ work can be gauged by more recent research into Chicano Los Angeles; by 1994, this line of work had entered the mainstream of artistic, architectural, and academic practices. Rodolfo F. Acuña, a 92
16:21:08:05:08
Page 92
Page 93
MAPPING EAST LOS ANGELES
Chicano Studies Scholar whose work has chronicled the history of East Los Angeles, included a section on Chicano urbanism in his book, Anything But Mexican: Chicanos in Contemporary Los Angeles, that is based largely upon the work of Rojas.21 Similarly, the collaborative art and architecture group, A.D.O.B.E. L.A. (Architects and Designers Opening the Border Edge of Los Angeles), has also taken the cultural landscapes of L.A.’s Latino neighborhoods as the objects of both academic and professional pursuits.22 Through continued investigations into the cultural trans-formation of urban spaces and through design practices that actively engage Chicano and Latino communities in Los Angeles, A.D.O.B.E. L.A. has both continued the line of inquiry begun by Rojas as well as the tradition of the grupo—a central component of the Chicano art movement. Further illustrating the growing influences of non-traditional architectural investigations within mainstream circles was the inclusion of A.D.O.B.E. L.A.’s work in two major architectural and urban design exhibitions: Urban Revisions: Current Projects for the Public Realm, held at the Museum of Contemporary Art (M.O.C.A.) in Los Angeles and House Rules, which was held at the Wexner Center for the Arts in Columbus, Ohio, and later published in the architectural journal Assemblage.23 Urban Revisions intended to focus attention on a number of selected urban design and planning projects from around the country addressing a range of social, cultural, economic, ecological, and political concerns. In response to M.O.C.A.’s call, A.D.O.B.E. L.A. submitted a proposal that highlighted an absence from the exhibition: “vernacular design on behalf of cultural survival.”24 Conceding the oversight, M.O.C.A. invited A.D.O.B.E. L.A. to intervene in the main exhibit. In response, A.D.O.B.E. L.A. created pieces that worked themselves into the gaps of the larger exhibit in order to metaphorically illustrate the appropriation of urban landscapes common in many Latino communities in Los Angeles: gallery spaces were tagged with cultural markers; East L.A.’s ubiquitous vendor carts were parked between project displays; and an urban map detailing the overlaps of toxic waste sites, sites of under-employment, and Latino neighborhoods, served to remind M.O.C.A.’s visitors of an other urban reality. House Rules grappled with the problem of re-thinking the American ideal of the single-family detached home through design interventions and theoretical speculation. Here, A.D.O.B.E. L.A. was paired with urban theorist Margaret Crawford, further illustrating the infiltration of Chicano politics into the main-stream. Using a hyper-realistic architectural model depicting a typical Californian suburban bungalow transformed to meet the cultural needs of Mexican Americans in East L.A., the project by A.D.O.B.E. L.A. and Crawford illustrated cultural practices of appropriation while challenging accepted architectural representational standards. Additionally, the Crawford/A.D.O.B.E. L.A. project added critical theoretical depth to the 93
16:21:08:05:08
Page 93
21 See: Rodolfo F. Acuña, Anything But Mexican: Chicanos in Contemporary Los Angeles (London: Verso, 1996) 11–12. 22 A.D.O.B.E. L.A. was established in 1992 as a collaborative and activist group of architects, artists, and designers in Los Angeles whose members have included Ulises Diaz, Ignacio Fernandez, Gustavo Leclerc, Alessandra Moctezuma, Elipio Rocha, Leda Ramos, and Rosa Velasco.
23 See: Assemblage 24 (1994); see also: Elizabeth Smith, ed., Urban Revisions: Current Projects for the Public Realm, exhibition catalog (Cambridge, MA: M.I.T. Press, 1994); Richard M. Carp, ed., Saber es poder/Interventions (Los Angeles: Los Angeles Museum of Contemporary Art, 1994).
24 Carp n. pag.
Page 94
JOSÉ GÁMEZ
25 Margaret Crawford and A.D.O.B.E. L.A., “Mi casa es su casa,” Assemblage 24 (1994): 12.
26 Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak, Outside in the Teaching Machine (New York: Routledge, 1993) 63. 27 See: Renato Rosaldo, Culture and Truth: The Remaking of Social Analysis (Boston: Beacon, 1989).
28 Dolores Hayden, The Power of Place.
29 Appadurai 326.
work of Rojas by illustrating how the “heroic bricolage” described in the work of Michel de Certeau can be found in East L.A..25 CRITICAL PRACTICE AND SPACE
Both the M.O.C.A. and Wexner Center exhibits indicate the extent to which the margins have entered into the center of theoretical debates. Largely overlooked in both theory and design, the politics of identity have made in-roads primarily via cultural critique. The power of making visible the previously invisible exposes not only formerly silenced voices but also the mechanisms by which silence is maintained. However, as with any marginalized position working from within the center itself, the project of speaking the unspoken is simply not enough. The charge must be one of “developing a vigilance for systematic appropriations of the unacknowledged social production of a differential” within the practices of the center.26 This calls for a continual re-reading of past cultural productions in an on-going effort to keep culture in motion—to free cultural productions from reification.27 As a practice, the revisiting of past works such as those of Asco, Romero, Rojas, and Crawford/A.D.O.B.E. L.A. serves to maintain in motion an understanding of the politics of identity that seeks to reclaim histories while preserving the power that critique holds. Therefore, the practice of revisiting past forms of cultural production remains a necessary project, given that the ability to consume and maintain space as transparent and/or ordered is tied to operations of power. As Dolores Hayden has stated, “[o]ne of the consistent ways to limit the economic and political rights of groups has been to constrain social reproduction by limiting access to space.”28 In this sense, the re-enactment of place through both symbolic and physical means is a vital part of the continued struggle towards visibility and to stave off cultural disappearance. In this on-going battle, creative and imaginative practices are now important aspects of cultural expression. As Arjun Appadurai states, the “image, the imagined, the imaginary—these are all terms which direct us to something critical and new in global cultural processes: the imagination as a social practice.”29 This is not to say that the works described above present true images of urban life; rather, they provide momentary glimpses of another reality. In this sense, the works of Chicano artists such as Asco, Los Four, and Romero as well as more recent works by Rojas, A.D.O.B.E. L.A., and Crawford provide ways to examine the public realm that avoid reductions to zero-degree cultural categories implicit in many contemporary urban and architectural practices. These views frame the city as something more than the site of nostalgia or cultural consumption. Here, the city provides an important zone of interaction—a space of cultural hybridity within which to explore the politics of identity. By looking to various forms of cultural production, both formal and informal, one finds that murals, architectural props, spatial practices, and artistic 94
16:21:08:05:08
Page 94
Page 95
MAPPING EAST LOS ANGELES
representations emerge as important tools in the development of an aesthetic and an ability to exhibit culture from within a marginalized community.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 88th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 2000. 95
16:21:08:05:08
Page 95
Page 96
CELEBRATING THE CITY COMMUNITY
ALAN J. PLATTUS (1987)
The urban festival provides a bridge between the ordinary city of everyday experience and the extraordinary city—projected in part by the festival— of idealistic and technological urbanism; of utopian hopes, projects, and illusions. The extraordinary city provides a glimpse of the city as it might be—for good or ill—as certain groups, certain constituencies within the city, would like it to be. We are quite familiar with some of those moments of heightened, intensified, highly concentrated urban vision. They are often key episodes in the most ordinary histories of architecture: for example, Chicago’s World Columbian Exposition of 1893. Such events may be arrière or avant-garde, and are usually both. They may serve as harsh urban reality; that is certainly one of their principal functions. But they have often done so dialectically, in a way that reveals as well as conceals, that—as the Russian literary critic Mikhail Bakhtin has argued—liberates as well as represses or oppresses. Festivals—both the singular, one-time-only special events, and the reiterated festival calendar (now much reduced from its peak in the late middle ages, but certainly still with us) which charts the rhythms of our seasonal religious and social life in cities—provide an index for both the continuity of tradition fundamental to the existence of cities and the disjunctions of change, programmed and spontaneous. They are then, not surprisingly, among the most significant vehicles for understanding the city, but also for more active interpreting, and therefore ultimately shaping the city. To paraphrase Clifford Geertz’s famous description of the Balinese cockfight, they are stories we tell ourselves about ourselves—and about our cities.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 75th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 1987.
96
16:21:08:05:08
Page 96
Page 97
CELEBRATING THE CITY
Parade of Fools, Ann Arbor, Michigan, April 1, 2007. (Photo by Rebekah Modrak.)
97
16:21:08:05:08
Page 97
Page 98
SKID ROW, LOS ANGELES COMMUNITY
Omar Avenue at Boyd Street, 2007.
San Julian at Sixth Street, 2007.
CAMILO JOSÉ VERGARA (2007) Making toys, furniture, artificial flowers, storing and processing fish, and serving the homeless are the main activities of L.A.’s Skid Row. As one learns more about the individual complexity of each of these businesses, their interdependence, and their relationship to the missions and the street people, the more extraordinary this urban economy seems, thriving as it has for decades among the misery, disease, and despair. Skid Row has been the largest public display of human misery in the United States and it has been so since I started documenting the area in 1995. Numbering in the thousands, derelict people have been concentrated in a small area of about fifty square blocks. The missions came to the area first. The Fred Jordan Mission is over forty years old, and the Union Rescue Mission, now in a new building, has been here for ninety years. Many of the hotels built long ago to accommodate travelers became S.R.O.s after the train station was relocated, providing another cheap place to live; some offer a bed for as little as twenty five dollars a night. The missions were followed by soup kitchens, health facilities, and methadone clinics. People know to drive to this part of the city to bring food and clothing for the homeless, and their charity gives further impetus for the down-and-out to congregate here. Now, in addition to corporate and government buildings, old industrial buildings have been transformed into lofts, galleries, restaurants, and hotels. L.A.’s old downtown is becoming the city center officials had proudly declared unnecessary. Since the fall of 2006 the climate in the streets of Skid Row has changed when the L.A.P.D. started to increased searches and arrests of the homeless; now people are kept moving from corner to corner. I witnessed many searches and arrests in Skid Row, but none impressed me more than one in May of 2007 when I heard a loud police siren, then “Wake up!, Wake up!” came blaring from the loud speakers of the patrol car. Surprised, I looked and saw a policeman standing in front of a sleeping person on South Fourth Street. The person under the blanket had overslept. It was 9 a.m. When I asked who was pushing the homeless a woman explained “the city, the police, the maintenance people.” I asked: “Where are they going?” She replied: “They are going to jail. They are going under the bridges, by the L.A. River. They are going to the missions, but some don’t want to go there.” The police finally have gained control of Skid Row. I had the feeling that I was seeing its last days. In a decade Skid Row will perhaps become L.A.’s equivalent of Greenwich Village. I heard a Whole Foods is coming to downtown. 98
16:21:08:05:08
Page 98
Page 99
SKID ROW, LOS ANGELES
Fifth Street at Stanford Avenue, 1996.
Fifth Street between Towne Avenue and Crocker Street, 1994.
99
16:21:08:05:08
Page 99
Page 100
CAMILO JOSÉ VERGARA
Southeast corner of St. Julian and Sixth Street, 2003.
441 Towne Avenue, 2007.
100
16:21:08:05:08
Page 100
Page 101
SKID ROW, LOS ANGELES
Gladys Avenue south of Sixth Street, 1999.
Towne Avenue between Fourth and Fifth Streets, 2006.
101
16:21:08:05:08
Page 101
Page 102
16:21:08:05:08
Page 102
Page 103
II URBAN FORM
16:21:08:05:08
Page 103
Page 104
16:21:08:05:08
Page 104
Page 105
INTRODUCTION Further thoughts on the three urbanisms DOUGLAS KELBAUGH
It is an article of faith that we design the built environment in an everchanging social, cultural, economic, technological, and ecological milieu. Contemporary urban development has responded to these changing factors in ways that might loosely be called “market urbanism.” This term is used here to refer to current conventions and modes of land acquisition, professional planning and design services, government regulation, financing, and construction for the thousands of real estate development projects that spring up in places and at times determined by macro and micro market forces and by the decisions of private developers. This market-driven redevelopment is kin to what Robert Fishman refers to as “reurbanism” in the Foreword, although his two exemplars—Battery Park City in Manhattan and Millennium Park in Chicago—are of a higher and more exalted order. Most of these projects are small or unremarkable, or both. However, their accumulation inevitably changes the face of America in ways that are not planned, organized, or self-conscious. Thus, the recent conversion of downtown office buildings into hotels and condominiums, or factories and warehouses into residential lofts, has transformed many urban centers. Post-World War II suburbia has likewise been transformed by the tsunami of subdivisions, gated communities, arterial strips, and retail malls. There are, however, three contemporary paradigms of urbanism that are self-conscious: New Urbanism, Everyday Urbanism, and, to a lesser extent, what I call Post Urbanism. These three approaches or attitudes (other than New Urbanism, it is hard to call them movements) represent the cutting edge of theoretical and professional activity in Western architecture and urbanism. I would like to contend that all three paradigms are basic and somewhat inevitable conditions and that each has its merits and demerits, but not in equal proportion—at least for most American cities at this point in their evolution. This essay examines their overlaps and oppositions, methodologies and modalities, strengths and weaknesses, in hopes of sketching the outlines of a more integrated position. Although the essays assembled in this section do not all fit smoothly or completely in these three categories, the taxonomy helps structure the conversation about urban design. Indeed, for better or worse, we’ve divided the section into subsections under these three titles. We invited several provocative urban designers/writers to punctuate the papers. The collection 105
16:21:08:05:08
Page 105
Page 106
DOUGLAS KELBAUGH
attempts to characterize the dialogue over the last decade about urbanism in general and urban form in particular. THE FORMAL/CLASSICAL PARADIGM
New Urbanism is by far the best known of these three paradigms. It is the most organized, with the Congress for the New Urbanism (C.N.U.) to promote and defend its tenets. It is also the one with which I am most familiar and aligned, albeit with reservations and criticisms. The Charter of the New Urbanism, ratified in 1996, aspires to truly utopian goals. The aspirations are an explicit mix of both noble ends and practical means: to equitably mix people of different income, ethnicity, race, and age; to build public architecture and public space that makes citizens feel they are part of, and proud of, a common culture and community; to weave a tighter urban fabric that mixes land of different uses and buildings of different architectural types; to sponsor and integrate transit, revenue sharing, planning, and governance at the metropolitan scale; and to be economically sound and ecologically responsible at the scale of the building, neighborhood, and region. Rarely, it must be said, are its ideals fully achieved, especially in a single project or community. As these ambitious, lofty principles indicate, New Urbanism seeks to counter the physical fragmentation, social dislocation and polarization, and functional compartmentalization of the modern city. It envisions a structural relationship between social behavior and physical form, and maintains that good design can have a measurably positive effect on the sense of place and community. Its basic model is a compact, mixed-use, diverse, transit-friendly, walkable city with a hierarchy of buildings and places that promotes face-to-face social interaction. In more specific terms, New Urbanism’s Charter advocates mixed-use centers where low- and mid-rise buildings form a continuous street wall, and where offices and affordable housing can be located above retail shops. It is not dense by European or Asian standards, but it is denser than conventional American sprawl. Its idealized urban hierarchy runs the gamut from background housing and private yards to foreground civic and institutional buildings, with public squares and parks. The built environment is organized along the urban “transect,” which, like the ecological transect, subdivides and codifies a prototypical cross-section of development from natural countryside to urban core. The continuum has six zones of gradually increasing building density and height, with a seventh zone for special districts. To engage with these practices, the C.N.U. has popularized a set of alternative principles and practices throughout North America, Australia, and parts of Europe. Among these are models for Transit Oriented Development (T.O.D.) to reduce auto-dependency and Traditional Neighborhood Development (T.N.D.) to encourage mixed-use. 106
16:21:08:05:08
Page 106
Page 107
INTRODUCTION
In terms of historical antecedents, New Urbanism is reminiscent of the City Beautiful movement, and it embraces open spaces and housing typologies that recall the Garden City tradition. Typically, its architecture is also historically derivative—in a style that is, in a word of its own coinage, Neotraditional. The New Urbanist vision also seeks to influence society beyond physical planning and design. For instance, its adherents have sought to reform contemporary financial and banking practices that encourage developers to build and “flip” projects for quick profits. They seek the patient capital of investors who would stay in a project for the long haul. And they lament the way Wall Street, through real estate investment trusts, has limited the architectural palette to a limited number of standard “product” types. THE INFORMAL/VERNACULAR PARADIGM
By comparison, Everyday Urbanism is not as tidy, doctrinaire, or utopian as New Urbanism. Nor is it even an established movement. Nevertheless, it has a body of literature and a clearly stated goal: to celebrate and build on ordinary life, with little pretense about the possibility of a perfectible or ideal environment. Its proponents argue for “elements that remain elusive: ephemerality, cacophony, multiplicity and simultaneity.” Everyday Urbanism is informal and bottom-up, as opposed to formal and top-down, and unlike New Urbanism, it downplays, and even denies, the relationship between physical form and social behavior. Its advocates frequently celebrate the ability of indigenous and migrant groups to respond in resourceful and imaginative ways to ad hoc conditions and marginal spaces. Its aim is to help people adapt and improvise, often in spite of physical design and planning. In practical terms, proponents of Everyday Urbanism support such activities as the appropriation of space on sidewalks and in parking lots (as well as on vacant lots and in private driveways) for informal commerce 107
16:21:08:05:08
Page 107
Above left: Denver’s former Stapleton Airport is being converted into a 4,700 acre New Urbanist community with 12,000 homes, master-planned by Calthorpe Associates. (Photo courtesy of Calthorpe Associates.) Above right: Mixed-use buildings at Stapleton designed in a background, contemporary architectural style, and built to the sidewalk to define a continuous street wall with residential and office uses above retail shops— a traditional but still compelling configuration that should be the norm in urban developments. (Photo courtesy of Calthorpe Associates.)
Page 108
DOUGLAS KELBAUGH
and festivities. It champions the vernacular architecture and street life and art of vibrant, ethnic neighborhoods such as those of Los Angeles. An international example might be Curitiba, Brazil, with its populist ethic and low-tech, bus transit system. Despite its grassroots quality, however, Everyday Urbanism should not be confused with conventional real-estate development. It is more personalized, politicized, and democratic than the standard “product” built and financed by mainstream developers and banks. Its very ability to fly below the organized financial radar and work in the gaps and on the margins has allowed it to empower disadvantaged and disenfranchised people and communities. THE AVANT-GARDE/INVENTIVE PARADIGM
Parking lots, sidewalks, driveways, and vacant lots are productively taken over by informal markets in Everyday Urbanism. (Photo courtesy of Margaret Crawford.)
It must be said that no one formally labels themselves a Post Urbanist; Post Urbanism is not even a widely used term. Nevertheless, I use it here to refer to the avant-garde paradigm that has grown out of what has been called the post-structuralist or critical architectural project of the last several decades. With its embrace of dynamic global information and capital flows, this urbanism is critical of most traditional norms and conventions, although sometimes in a playful, satiric way. Relativistic, predictably unpredictable, and without formal orthodoxies or principles, it favors bold form—either broken and fractal, or continuous and flowing. At its purest, Post Urbanism argues that shared values or metanarratives are no longer possible in a world increasingly fragmented and composed of heterotopian ghettoes of the “other” (e.g. the homeless, the poor, minorities) and mainstream zones of fantasy commerce, information exchange, and free-range tourism. These liminal and exciting zones of taboo and fantasy and 24/7 zones of unfettered consumerism are viewed as liberating because they allow “for new forms of knowledge, new hybrid possibilities, new unpredictable forms of freedom.” Espousing ever wilder and more provocative design, Post Urbanism also aspires to engage an increasingly sophisticated, celebrity-conscious consumer of the built environment. Urban works born of these ideas include the mega-forms of Rem Koolhaas, Zaha Hadid, and some less strident proposals of Steven Holl. Frank Gehry’s proposals for Atlantic Terminal in Brooklyn and Grand Avenue in Los Angeles, as well as Daniel Libeskind’s Denver Art Museum complex, are other examples. In formal terms, the abstract architectural language and topological explorations of Post Urbanism are often one of surface and skin. There is little direct reference to the physical context, even if it’s contemporary. A variety of avant-gardist shock tactics may also be deployed, no matter how modest the building program or unimportant the site. However, it is sometimes difficult to know if a project is neo-avant-garde or truly avant108
16:21:08:05:08
Page 108
Page 109
INTRODUCTION
garde—that is, whether surprise and spectacle is employed for its own sake, or whether the principal motive is to inspire genuine belief in the possibility of change. Nevertheless, Post Urbanists have described their discordant and exceptional insertions into the city as examples of open, democratic urbanism. And they criticize New Urbanist communities as stultifying and irrelevant in light of modern lifestyles and technology, especially digital media and what I call the Electronic Now. For them, New Urbanism’s desire for orderliness embodies nostalgia for a romanticized past that never existed. Meanwhile, the ad hoc liveliness of Everyday Urbanism, while less scenographic and predictable, would lack aesthetic cohesion and ambition for them. Despite their theoretical and aesthetic sophistication, however, it is questionable whether Post Urbanist works give back as much as they take from the city around them. The projects themselves are typically selfcontained, if not self-centered, with little faith in the work of others to complete a fragmented urban fabric. Meanwhile, sprawling auto-centric cities like Atlanta, Houston, and Las Vegas are sometimes held up as models of a liberating mobility. METHODOLOGIES AND MODALITIES
Underlying these paradigms are three very different methodologies. New Urbanism is clearly the most precedent-based. It aims to extrapolate from enduring architectural principles and typologies, as well as historical examples and traditions as they intersect contemporary environmental, technological, social, and economic practices. It is also the most normative, with its goals and principles carefully inscribed in the C.N.U. Charter, and adapted to local conditions through the relatively standardized tool of the community design charrette. Politically active, the C.N.U. has also built coalitions with other movements such as Smart Growth, and other organizations such as the Urban Land Institute, U.S. Green Building Council, and the A.I.A. These links have given it traction and clout as a national organization, as seen in the postKatrina replanning of the Gulf Coast. New Urbanists believe that a coherent hierarchy of architectural types, street types, and public spaces can best sort out and make legible the complex mixture of land uses and buildings that cities have always possessed and are now requiring. They have thus lambasted the post-World War II zoning that separated and compartmentalized land uses, as if, in Ken Greenberg’s words, it could only juggle one ball at a time. To be sure, mixed-use urbanism, with its walkability and chance encounters, is now the one and only urban approach that everyone, from Leon Krier to Rem Koolhaas, seems to embrace. This is a major, pervasive, and positive sea change. However, as single-use zoning is phased out, a new 109
16:21:08:05:08
Page 109
The BMW plant by Zaha Hadid overtly expresses flows of industrial assembly. Its Post Urbanist architecture is visually dynamic and aggressive, with laminar forms invading the site and surrounding the existing buildings like solidified lava. (Photo courtesy of Zaha Hadid Architects.)
Page 110
DOUGLAS KELBAUGH
way to create urban order is needed. A new appreciation for architectural typology, New Urbanists believe, can provide this foundation. Thus, in place of zoning codes focusing on function and bulk, they advocate form- and typology-based codes promoting normative architectural and urban forms. New Urbanist emphasis on typology partly derives from a desire to dignify the many background buildings needed to make a coherent city. Builders and designers are freed to refine details and building form rather than overhaul or re-invent them. A typology also provides familiar architectural vessels into which new functions can be poured, helping to preserve the memory of the city. And it makes future architectural and urban form more predictable. Indeed, without agreed-upon design typologies, the effective practice of urban design and planning is almost impossible. Everyday Urbanism is far less normative and doctrinaire. Where New Urbanism grew out of concern for precedent and typology, it emerged from the community design movement that has stubbornly survived since the 1970s in a few cities, and recently been revived in others. It views the design professional as a student of the popular and the quotidian rather than the ideal and elite, and a participant more than a leader of public dialogue. Everyday Urbanism’s concern for citizen control makes it the most open-ended and populist of the three urbanisms. And because it is about celebrating the ordinary rather than starting over with a new and presumably more sophisticated model, it is also the most modest, incremental, and compassionate of the paradigms, with the strongest commitment to social and economic justice. However, if the New Urbanist romanticizes the past, the Everyday Urbanist overestimates the power of the commonplace. These are flaws that Post Urbanism seeks to take on directly by accepting, and seeking to express, the powerful techno-flow of a global world, both real and virtual. Rather than seeking accommodation, its projects are bold and experimental rather than normative, and often relish the chance to violate design guidelines, zoning codes, existing typologies. Post Urbanists also don’t tend to engage the public as directly in open dialogue—perhaps because they feel the traditional “polis” is increasingly obsolete, and its civic institutions too calcified to promote new possibilities. Celebrated in the media as solo artists or lone geniuses, they cultivate Howard Roarkish personas, despite the reality that large multidisciplinary teams are needed to realize their designs. Perhaps the quintessential Post Urbanist is Rem Koolhaas, the vanguard Dutch designer and brilliant provocateur. He has proclaimed, perhaps as a trope but irresponsibly in any case, that urbanism is dead; that there is no longer any hope of achieving urban coherence or unity. Like the 110
16:21:08:05:08
Page 110
Page 111
INTRODUCTION
talented and less nihilistic Steven Holl, he has dropped typology in favor of topology. Rigorously consistent within their own architectural vocabulary and physical site, Post Urbanist projects often seem to be designed within an invisible envelope, with almost zero attention to offsite relationships. For this reason, they tend to be perceived as confrontational, even brazen. Like mid-twentieth-century Modernist projects, they want to make a radically new start and are comfortable and even like and depend on being at odds with their surroundings. But unlike Modernism, form is now increasingly un-tethered from a sense of common, shared values and is free to be arbitrary, even bizarre. Yet, in spite of their hubris, many a Post Urbanist building is a spatial and formal tour de force. They can be sophisticated foreground architecture and icons of great formal skill and elegance, however convoluted, enigmatic, or haunting their shapes. However, if New Urbanists are overly optimistic about urban centers and neighborhoods as aesthetically consistent wholes—beautiful in the traditional Viennese or Parisian sense—Post Urbanists may be criticized as too willing to settle for the city of internally unified but disparate fragments. Where New Urbanists want to be normative at too many scales, Post Urbanists want to be free at too many scales—from the baluster to the building to the bioregion. And, if New Urbanism tends to hold too highly the best practices of the past and Everyday Urbanism overrates a prosaic present, the Post Urbanist is overinvested in endlessly exciting topology and an audacious future. It must be said that the differing clientele for the three paradigms may explain some of these proclivities. Everyday Urbanists often work for nonprofit and community groups with limited resources and political power; thus, their commissions and projects are more modest, sometimes built with volunteer labor. New Urbanists often work for land developers, especially on the suburban greenfield projects for which they are best known; however, their lesser-known but numerous urban redevelopment projects, including Hope VI, may be sponsored by government agencies or public/private partnerships. Post Urbanists projects are typically the result of prestigious competitions and commissions by wealthy and powerful institutions, corporations, and patrons who seek high profile, iconic buildings. These different client groups have different missions and audiences, ranging from subaltern minorities to middle-class consumers to urbane cognoscenti and glitterati. In this sense, it is no surprise that the three paradigms lead to different physical outcomes. However, this is not to tautologically imply that they are solely the result of different clientele. The paradigms do seem to represent and resonate as deeper, more intrinsic modes of thought, design, and production.
111
16:21:08:05:08
Page 111
Page 112
DOUGLAS KELBAUGH
OUTCOMES
New Urbanism, with its Latinate clarity and order, achieves the most aesthetic unity and coherent sense of community, in my opinion. It orchestrates different uses at a human scale in familiar architectural types and styles. However, its formal harmony is usually achieved in historical styles that lack authenticity and tectonic integrity. Such skin-deep pastiche is more understandable for speculative housing, which must sell in the marketplace or bankrupt the developer/builder. It is less excusable for nonresidential buildings, especially public structures that are allowed to break the design code, but all too rarely rise to first-rate design. Many New Urbanists claim that the issue of architectural language or style is irrelevant or overblown. But clearly it does matter to design professionals and academics, judging from the ferocity of the debates. And if style is of little consequence to developers (and their public), why isn’t there more contemporary architecture in their projects? Clearly, architectural style is important because it embodies and expresses values, meanings, and attitudes that are deeper than outward and visible form. By contrast, Everyday Urbanism has trouble achieving any aesthetic coherence, day or night, micro or macro. But it is egalitarian and lively. And while Post Urbanist site plans look exciting, with their laser-like vectors, fractal geometries, jumbled fragments, and sweeping circulatory systems, when realized, they are often overscaled and empty of pedestrians. Tourists in rental cars experiencing the city through their windshields may be better served than actual users, for whom there is less human-scale nuance and architectural detail to reveal itself over the years, especially to pedestrians. Ironically, Post Urbanism suggests local citizens are tourists in their own city, just as tourists have become citizens of the world. Everyday Urbanism is, in a sense, already ubiquitous in the informal squatter settlements of global cities, where the working- and under-classes seek a stake in the urban economy. But it doesn’t make much sense in the cities of Europe, where a wealthier citizenry has the luxury of punctuating a mature and dense urban fabric with Modernist commercial and institutional buildings as counterpoint to the traditional architecture. And the heavy masonry fabric of European cities sets off the new, highly glazed, gravitydefying buildings of Post Urbanism better than North American cities, which are more spatially open and sporadic, and where glass curtain-wall buildings already dominate. Because our cities lack the horizontal viscosity of European cities and are often underprogrammed and made empty by parking lots, New Urbanist infill usually adds the greatest value. NAGGING QUESTIONS
What can be said then about the possibility of a more integrated approach to urbanism in America, one that might merge the best of these three 112
16:21:08:05:08
Page 112
Page 113
INTRODUCTION
approaches while avoiding their weaknesses, and be more sustainable than any of the three on its own? Is there any hope for integrating these three paradigms into a richer and more lasting urbanism? Everyday Urbanism is too often an urbanism of default rather than design. It is a bottom-up approach that is “too much bottom, not enough up” in Michael Speaks’ words. Can it raise its design expectations and standards as its clientele becomes more mainstream? New Urbanism is too often formulaic, realized in banal and cloyingly historicist architecture. It often fails to deal with either regional or economic issues, such as jobs/housing balance. Can it move beyond “the post-modern notion of the city as solely a place to live, not to work,” and embrace a more raw and potent mix of uses, including industry? Post Urbanism is too often an urbanism of trophy buildings, of which a city needs and can absorb only so many. Can it produce good but quiet background buildings that are more urbanistically sensitive and architecturally contextual? Certainly, Americans can expect a more physically ordered and architecturally ambitious commons than Everyday Urbanism offers and a more humane one than Post Urbanism promises. Although Europe may delight in Post Urbanist avant-gardism and the developing world may embrace the informality of Everyday Urbanism, wouldn’t the typical American metropolis benefit most from New Urbanism at this point in its history? Arguably, the unevenness of American urbanism would also benefit from “some rules that prove the exceptions,” just as European cities are enriched by Modernist “exceptions that prove the rule.” For most North American cities, New Urbanism represents the responsible middle path, less glamorous than Post Urbanism and more ambitious than Everyday Urbanism. But can it learn from the other two paradigms and their cultures? Despite being the most comprehensive and successful design and planning movement of its generation, New Urbanism must evolve if it is to remain responsible and responsive. Like all movements, it will ultimately ossify and lose its meaning and value as it runs the inevitable and ever faster historical course from archetype to type to stereotype. There are a number of serious questions that New Urbanism needs to address if it is to evolve into a more integrated paradigm. Can its exemplary urban principles be realized in contemporary architecture, especially the public and institutional buildings, and employ the talent and skill of Post Urbanist architects? Can it live up to its egalitarian ideas of social diversity and affordability as seriously as Everyday Urbanists? And can it fully address ecological challenges and develop a bio-urbanism? Last, is New Urbanism flexible enough to align with and harness the emerging forces of the global economy? Or will it rely too heavily on top-down formal templates, form-based codes and regulations, outdated technics, and moral mandates? As the late Jane Jacobs pointed out in Dark 113
16:21:08:05:08
Page 113
Page 114
DOUGLAS KELBAUGH
Age Ahead, sprawl will densify and diversify, and inner cities will rebound and redevelop, only if underlying economic and social forces make it an inevitable, natural, sustainable, and voluntary process. Otherwise, New Urbanism will become another failed utopian vision and movement, a misfortune in a field littered with broken dreams and promises.
114
16:21:08:05:08
Page 114
Page 115
EVERYDAY URBAN DESIGN Towards default urbanism and/or urbanism by design?
EVERYDAY URBANISM, LANDSCAPE URBANISM, AND INFRASTRUCTURE
JOHN KALISKI (2007)
Whatever happened to “Everyday Urbanism?” Is it an organized urban design movement? Does it actively influence urban policy and shape cities? I ask these design-oriented questions because this is an ill-defined area of inquiry left open in the book, Everyday Urbanism, co-edited by John Chase, Margaret Crawford, and me.1 Certainly there is no “Everyday Urban Design School.” Everyday urban design is also not taking over planning departments. I know of few people who have constructed explicitly “everyday” design practices. Still, one can argue that the concept of the everyday remains a notion that all designers reckon with at some point in their professional life. However, this hardly constitutes a design movement; everyday urban design is better described as an attitude that needs better definition. When Douglas Kelbaugh wrote “Three Urbanisms and the Public Realm” in 2001, he claimed there were three competing urbanisms: New Urbanism, Post-Urbanism, and Everyday Urbanism.2 While he stated that other forms of urban design were relevant including “environmentalism, regionalism, historicism, etc,” the first three were the ones that most succinctly encapsulated for him the millennial moment. In contrast, the everyday as expounded in Everyday Urbanism was grounded in a reaction against the determinism of any defined urban design practice.3 We were seeking means to observe and remain open to the diversity of cities. We were interested in the neglected places and experiences of cities that other urbanisms ignored. We thought these could be a starting point to construct a practice of inclusive, non-dogmatic urbanism. Given our interest in exploring the complexity of the whole city, championing of the role non-experts play in ameliorating neglected urban environments, and our sense that professional designers would do well to acknowledge the vitality of the tactics of the everyday to produce urbanism, I am not surprised that Kelbaugh reached the conclusion in his essay that our efforts were potentially “urban design by default rather than by intention.” Despite the critique, we were pleased Kelbaugh put us in the same league as people who have changed urban design. Time has demonstrated that he was one of the few commentators who trucked faith in our ideas. Most critics of Everyday Urbanism dismissed the ideas as irrelevant to professional design practices.4 While Kelbaugh was an articulate advocate for the idea that three urbanisms were wrestling with each other, in truth his match 115
16:21:08:05:08
Page 115
1 John Chase, Margaret Crawford and John Kaliski, editors, Everyday Urbanism (The Monacelli Press, New York, 1999).
2 For this essay I am utilizing the following version of this article: Douglas Kelbaugh, “Three Urbanisms and the Public Realm” (from Proceedings, 3rd International Space Syntax Symposium, Atlanta, 2001). 3 Our first collective act as likeminded individuals was to help organize a symposium for the Los Angeles Forum for Architecture and Urban Design. “Urban Design, Urban Theory and Urban Culture” sought to broaden discussion of urban design practices in the context of “Urban Revisions,” a 1994 exhibit at the Los Angeles Museum of Contemporary Art curated by Elizabeth Smith. 4 Dell Upton, “A World Less Ordinary,” Architecture, February 2000, pages 54–55. In this review Upton states that Everyday Urbanism is, “best read as essays in architectural ethics, meant to sensitize designers to the intellectual and political contradictions inherent in their professional positions rather than to recommend specific design practices.”
Page 116
JOHN KALISKI
5 See Andrés Duany, “Restoring the Real New Orleans,” Metropolis, February 2007.
6 See Michigan at Trumbull: Turning the Corner (A. Alfred Taubman College of Architecture and Urban Planning—University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, 2000), pages 6–11 and pages 32–39. The student team was led by myself, Kelli Kavanaugh, Doug Kelbaugh, Patricia Machemer, James Singleton, and Andrew Zago. Andrew Zago and I concentrated on developing zoning game theories that were performance oriented as opposed to prescriptive and working with the students tried to animate the land use implications of the approach through time. 7 February 22, 2007 e-mail from Andrés Duany to John Kaliski.
was never a contest, just a good narrative that highlighted the preeminence of New Urbanism. New Urbanism, Kelbaugh’s middle-way, was the champion in 2001 and six years later is the near hegemonic approach to urban design in the United States. It is demanded by publics, adopted by developers, and accepted by decision-makers. Its preeminence amongst planners is simple. It provides straightforward place-making principles that are imageable, reassuring, and communicable. New Urbanism’s appeal is also related to its fleetfootedness. New Urbanists quickly adopt concepts from outside their canon, a smart tactic that creates constant renewal within the movement. For example, Andrés Duany, the keenest New Urbanist of them all, recently proclaimed the need to consider “opt-out zones” in hurricane-ravaged New Orleans.5 In these free zones, New Urbanism’s bread and butter— codes—would be forgiven. Presumably landowners and developers, freed from the restrictions of government, will feel incentivized to rebuild. Notwithstanding Duany’s right to utilize anything that works, I recall the moment in 2000 when a team of professionals working with students in a design charrette sponsored by the University of Michigan proposed just such an approach for a shrinking area of Detroit, the Briggs neighborhood near the old Tiger Stadium.6 Our belief then, like Duany’s now, is that in certain cases it is useful to free individuals from the miasma of constraining regulation, a tactic of self-help set loose to revitalize a community. Despite our convictions we were not surprised when the Mayor at that time, Dennis Archer, walked right by our project and enthused about the certainty of the picket fences, traditional infill house forms, and prescriptive pattern language proposed by a team led by Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk. When I reminded Duany of this incident (and the possibility that perhaps he had evolved into a closet everyday urbanist), he explained to me, “(y)ours is but one of the tools, but an important one and increasingly so.”7 So, are everyday practices becoming a treasured hammer in New Urbanism’s toolbox? To a small extent, yes. Despite the interest of New Urbanists in some aspects of the everyday, holding a sustained interest in the everyday makes it difficult to claim a singular position in urban design. Starting and ending points in everyday planning and design remain always contingent upon the variable situation at hand. The consequence of this is that I am compulsively programmed to state in response to questions regarding my underlying principles acknowledgement of New Urbanism followed by the negative sounding phrase, “but I am not a New Urbanist because . . .” Why can’t I find constructive language to respond to the same question, for instance, “I am an everyday urbanist because . . .”? Can one construe everyday urbanism as inspiration for a set of urban design principles without being forced into essentialist proclamations? The following thoughts are an attempt to frame a practice of city design through an acknowledgement of the everyday. 116
16:21:08:05:08
Page 116
Page 117
EVERYDAY URBAN DESIGN
Everyday urban design begins with respecting and honoring the daily rituals and cycles that shape communities. The forms and places of communities are therefore most justly formed through incremental design processes implemented through time. In everyday contexts designers are asked to facilitate the portraits that communities desire to draw for themselves. In this regard a framework of democracy becomes the most cogent means to shape citizens’ as well as designers’ ideas regarding the space of the city. The ideas contained in these discourses are most often memorialized through codes. The incremental legal changes that shape everyday environments, like an organic urbanism, are far superior to either acts of book burning or wholesale clearance. Designers, working with communities, also benefit from the scrutiny of public debate. While some good designs are constrained, on balance, weak ideas are strengthened. With regards to design, awareness of the everyday as a motive force encourages each individual to learn equally from the traditional as well as the new, the present, and the ubiquity of the present in the past and the future. Precedence can thus meld with innovation. Consequently the North American everyday urban designer is simultaneously accepting and critical of automobility, suburbia, single-family houses, shopping malls, sprawl, and all the other accretions of contemporary urbanisms, believing that each addresses a human need and that all remain a subject for betterment as opposed to obliteration. Reform thus is built into or anticipated by each act of urban design. Under these conditions urban design becomes a specific and singular opportunity to nurture daily life—hardly an “urban design by default.” While one might question openness to all urban experiences in a harsh world that demands ready and predictable solutions to pressing needs, I prefer the beginning everyday stance described above. I believe that it leads to the possibility of specific design subtlety and complexity. I remain confident that this leads to urban design where each project is necessarily different, shaped by individual circumstance, not connected by common design tropes, themes, or practices, but stitched together through careful observation and evolution of highly specific situations and conditions. Each everyday urban design realized is unique unto itself. While it is useful to have a framework to describe the potentials of urban design shaped by the everyday, are there specific places and principles that exemplify the approach? With a sense of speculation I recently turned to Archinect, a web-based design community, and asked this virtual world what they felt were the “designed” places that best exemplified the everyday and everyday practice.8 There was a wide range of response: examples proffered included Jon Jerde’s orchestrated shopping centers as well as Louis Kahn’s monumental central court at the Salk Institute. Some bloggers felt the everyday was best exemplified by informal spaces or pathways to and about local scenes. One person mentioned a specific bench in 117
16:21:08:05:08
Page 117
8 See www.archinect.com, “Discussions.” I want to thank all who participated in the post and thread for their generous and open thoughts.
Page 118
JOHN KALISKI
Montserrat, Spain; another, leftover space just off a sidewalk where people gather to talk. Rem Koolhaus’ architectural work was discussed as well as Covent Garden in London, downtown Culver City, California, Douglas Loop in Louisville, Kentucky, Jackson Square in New Orleans, and Pioneer Courthouse Square in Portland, Oregon. Moore Ruble Yudell’s student center at the University of Cincinnati was nominated, as was The Grove, a shopping center in the middle of Los Angeles incorporating architects Koning-Eisenberg’s renovations of the historic 3rd and Fairfax Farmer’s Market. The vitality of developing world favelas and the rawness of Downtown Los Angeles’ skid row were each seen to have qualities that, if not always comfortable, were certainly related to the range of everyday experiences that need to be learned from. While no canon of everyday design was fixed through this discussion, the thread on Archinect also featured a less evolved discussion of everyday urban design principles. In this regard the range of places that were mentioned demonstrated a core principle of inclusiveness. Another principle that came up in the posting was the idea of both acknowledging and anticipating uses of time in urban design and architecture. Others emphasized that designing the informal and formal spaces and land in-between structures is of greater importance than the buildings themselves. Jane Jacobs’ notions of incremental city making were mentioned as well as more intentional urban tactics, such as the scripting of spaces. All of these principles suggest that there is a nascent theory of everyday urban design that transcends narrowly drawn urban ideologies or fetishized place making. The broadness of response solicited on Archinect constitutes a critical recognition that everyday urbanism, within the context of the design act, constitutes a true middle ground, because unlike its new urban or posturban cousins, all possibilities can be vetted with equanimity. Everyday equanimity forces one to eschew the notion that there should be a formal “Everyday Urbanism” or “Everyday Urban Design” movement. Yet everyday urban design could nevertheless be construed as an approach to a broad-based and inclusive critical practice with case studies and approaches that seek to promulgate more humane and liberal approaches to the production of the city. Notwithstanding an aversion to fixed theories or outcomes, there are givens that distinguish design practitioners interested in the everyday from their colleagues who adopt more focused approaches. Amongst these are three key concepts that relate to the open approach just suggested: interest in present contexts as starting points, acceptance of democratic design discourses to reform these starting points, and application of design intelligence to addressing the concerns and needs of everyday design discourses. Communities necessarily start with the present. Even within extraordinary situations without any pre-existing pattern of human inhabitation, environmental factors establish an almost infinite network of present clues 118
16:21:08:05:08
Page 118
Page 119
EVERYDAY URBAN DESIGN
to guide any prospective urbanism. The consequent urban program based upon the here-and-now emphasizes an ideal of betterment, reform, and the retrofit of an existing situation. The urban designer influenced by the everyday imagines the present, as opposed to precedent, as the first source for inspiring a better future.9 Communities are also made up of competing interests that have varying visions for urban life. Democracy is the increasingly accepted tool to debate and shape neighborhood, community, city, and region.10 Democratic urban form making demands urban design nimbleness. The individual urban designer is asked by publics to contribute a broad palette of ideas and approaches. The process is more akin to the decorating of individual domestic environments for highly particular clients, each with a different opinion, than many designers steeped in universal approaches would care to admit. In short people want their Downtowns, and their suburbs, and their transit, and their freeways, and their cars, and their Main Streets and they expect urban designers to use collaborative talents to illustrate, educate, and frame unique approaches to each new situation. Urban design in these circumstances is an opportunity on the part of communities to utilize designers, as opposed to design ideologues or ideologies, and through the medium of design allow for the illustration of alternative points of urban departure. In essence, what the everyday demands is not so much design leaders as designers who deploy design intelligence, the visualization of urban options for the citizenry at-large in order to facilitate decisions that reflect the consensus of an open and democratic community. In the seven years since the publication of Everyday Urbanism, a book that described how practices of everyday life are related to and can influence understandings of urbanism, this is what I as a designer have been attempting to realize. Returning to the original question, whatever happened to “Everyday Urbanism,” urban design within the context of everyday urbanism is never an organized movement but a critical, humbling, and creative attitude towards practice open to any designer interested in the ecumenical practices and productions of the contemporary city.
119
16:21:08:05:08
Page 119
9 This concept establishes a crucial difference with New Urbanism that at its root utilizes precedent as the source for an inspired future. 10 See John Kaliski, “Democracy Takes Command: New Community Planning and the Challenge to Urban Design,” Harvard Design Magazine, Spring/Summer 2005.
Page 120
WITHOUT END Mats, holes, and the promise of landscape urbanism
EVERYDAY URBANISM, LANDSCAPE KAREN M’CLOSKEY (2005) URBANISM, AND INFRASTRUCTURE 1 See Anne Whiston Spirn, “The Authority of Nature: Conflict, Confusion, and Renewal in Design, Planning, and Ecology” in Bart R. Johnson and Kristina Hill, eds., Ecology and Design: Frameworks for Learning (Washington: Island Press, 2002). Spirn describes the dogma associated with appeals to nature as given or original, which promulgate a “nature” apart from cultural construction.
2 See footnote 27 in Charles Waldheim and Marili Santos-Munne, “Decamping Detroit” in Georgia Daskalakis, Charles Waldheim and Jason Young, eds., Stalking Detroit (Barcelona: Actar Press, 2001), p. 110. For an excellent review of this book, see Grahame Shane. “The Emergence of Landscape Urbanism,” Harvard Design Magazine (19, Fall 2003/Winter 2004): www.gsd.harvard.edu/hdm. 3 For a related discussion on erasure and void, see James Corner, “Landscraping” in Daskalakis, Waldheim and Young, pp. 122–125.
The authority of nature has been usurped by the authority of landscape.1 Though no longer appealing to an idealized nature as the measure of morality and counterpoint to the city, landscape has, in a sense, replaced the word nature in that it is used as the measure of freedom, and as an emancipator from architecture. For architects, the widespread adoption of landscape terminology and ecological metaphors is a means to expand the techniques by which architecture is produced, providing alternatives to conventional master planning, which is perceived as the great failure of modernism. One way this shift has become manifest is in the emergence of the “field” of landscape urbanism, which positions landscape “as the most relevant medium for the production and representation of contemporary urbanism.”2 While reflecting many positive changes, including more reciprocal relationships among design disciplines, the current framing of landscape urbanism has not gone far enough beyond the simple replacement of master planning with the equally generic term landscape. In other words, landscape as a representation of urbanism is more developed than landscape as a production of it. In tracing the lineage of landscape urbanism, the recurring notion of the “hole” becomes evident.3 This paper positions Alison Smithson’s essay “The City Center Full of Holes” (1977) as a direct antecedent to contemporary landscape urbanism, suggesting that, though we have adopted her use of landscape infrastructure as a holding strategy for unpredictable futures, we have not yet fully advanced her conception of landscape as a healing salve to decentralizing post-industrial cities. I briefly outline the role of “holes” as they relate to landscape and will argue why they must be delineated more specifically if landscape urbanism is to productively combine both its architectural and landscape architectural predecessors. While covering the same geographic territory as landscape architecture or urban design, landscape urbanism is described as an interdisciplinary model, which positions landscape as the generator, rather than backdrop, of urban development. Rather than relying on the formalistic solid/void of older models where void and, by extension, landscape is a residual of architecture, landscape urbanism suggests the opposite, wherein the public landscape infrastructure organizes and shapes urban development. Charles Waldheim, who coined the phrase landscape urbanism in 1996, positions Tschumi’s Parc de La Villette as its progenitor, suggesting an architectural lineage that 120
16:21:08:05:08
Page 120
Page 121
WITHOUT END
draws landscape out of its position within landscape architecture and regional planning and more closely aligns it with architectural critiques of the 1970s and 80s.4 In the primary texts outlining the theoretical impetus for landscape urbanism, several authors distance themselves from landscape architecture in two ways: first, landscape architecture’s legacy of the picturesque, which foregrounds formal and pictorial representations; and secondly, from the environmental determinism of the 1960s and 70s, which gave ecology a central role, as evidenced strongly in the work of Ian McHarg. In Landscape Urbanism: A Manual for the Machinic Landscape, Alejandro Zaero-Polo states, “the [landscape] discipline never developed a means of producing complexity away from imitation, and never evolved beyond the picturesque.” 5 Though this is a common and reductive sentiment, there is no doubt that both landscape and architectural practices today increasingly emphasize diagrammatic processes and organizations over pictorial representations, using ecology as a paradigm for connectivity and indeterminacy.6 The conflation of cultural and natural processes, and the incorporation of humans into ecological systems, are very promising developments that position landscape urbanism as a viable, less formulaic and more site-specific alternative to New Urbanism or the generic city. Waldheim points out that this strategy is particularly suited to the postindustrial, decentralized or so-called Shrinking City, where inward vacancy and outward expansion are its defining characteristics.7
The greening of the depleted city centre may even be the most obvious characteristic of the future city centre. Alison Smithson 8 The inversion from conventional planning using architectural solids to a green infrastructure of holes was introduced by Alison Smithson in 1977, in her essay “The City Center Full of Holes.” Alison and Peter Smithson’s work has recently been positioned as a progenitor to contemporary architects’ interest in flexibility, indeterminacy and landscape. The Smithsons were instrumental in prompting a shift from fixed functionalism to one in which time was recognized as a primary factor in design, and Team X members criticized many practitioners of their day as being stuck in a static and deterministic “Euclidean Groove.” 9 The concept of mat building, outlined by Alison Smithson in 1974, focused on flexible frameworks for accommodating growth and change and challenged the separation of architecture and urbanism. Her essay “How to Recognize and Read Mat-Building” became the basis for a recent Case Series book on Le Corbusier’s Venice Hospital.10 The last essay in the book, by Stan Allen, eloquently lays out the shift from mat building, which uses architecture as the primary method of ordering, to what he terms mat urbanism, which uses infrastructure and 121
16:21:08:05:08
Page 121
4 Charles Waldheim, “Landscape Urbanism: A Genealogy,” Praxis 4 (2002): 10–17.
5 Alejandro Zaero-Polo, “On Landscape” in Mohsen Mostafavi and Ciro Najle, eds., Landscape Urbanism: A Manual for the Machinic Landscape (London: Architectural Association, 2003), p. 133. See also essays by Christopher Hight and Michael Hensel in the same publication and Waldheim, Praxis. 6 See Julia Czerniak, ed., Case: Downsview Park Toronto (Munich, London, NY: Prestel, 2001). 7 In addition to Praxis, see Waldheim and Marili Santos-Munne, in Daskalakis, Waldheim and Young, pp. 105–121. 8 Alison Smithson, “The City Center Full of Holes,” Architectural Association Quarterly 9/2, 3 (1977): p. 11.
9 Alison Smithson, ed., Team X Primer (Cambridge: M.I.T. Press, 1968), p. 20. The term “Euclidean Groove” was used by Aldo van Eyck.
10 Hashim Sarkis, ed., Case: Le Corbusier’s Venice Hospital (Munich, London, NY: Prestel, 2001).
Page 122
KAREN M’CLOSKEY
11 “If on the one hand, the Smithsons were among the first to recognize the potential of infrastructure to influence the future development of the city, they also unwittingly endorse the conceptual apparatus of modern sprawl”. Stan Allen, “Mat Urbanism: The Thick 2D” in Sarkis, p. 124. 12 Smithson, “The City Center Full of Holes,” p. 11.
13 Ibid., p. 13. Though Smithson did not speak to environmental concerns as the basis for her thesis, she does footnote the necessity of natural resource conservation. Also, on the necessity for framing ecological function within aesthetic convention, see Joan Nassauer, “Cultural Sustainability: Aligning Aesthetics and Ecology” in Joan Nassauer, ed., Placing Nature: Culture and Landscape Ecology (Washington: Island Press, 1997).
landscape as organizing frameworks. Yet in 1977, just three years after the publication of her “Mat-Building” essay, Alison Smithson’s seemingly overlooked essay “The City Center Full of Holes” is the first to explicitly propose a landscape strategy to address the depopulation occurring in postindustrial cities. This was, at the time, a unique proposition for architects. If Smithson’s infinitely extendable mat inadvertently leads to expansive development and sprawl,11 then “The City Center Full of Holes” addresses its corollary: vacancy and abandoned infrastructure. While she laments the deteriorating urban fabric, she doesn’t propose to fix it with architecture. Instead, she recommends that the holes appearing in cities be landscaped as “holding operations” for future development.12 Using abandoned railroad right-of-ways and areas adjacent to freeways, she proposes that these infrastructures be appropriated to provide connective tissue from the city centers to dispersed regions beyond. Positive associations with large scale connective landscapes, well-known to the English via garden cities, would encourage the acceptance of wildness in small vacant city sites without negative allusions to abandonment. Smithson states “If we can see what to do with the disused railway yards, using them as connective places, we might begin to indicate to people how to behave towards small vacant sites, interstical [sic] places.”13 These derelict sites and outdated infrastructures become conduits for the future reorganization of the post-industrial landscape. Therefore, sustainability in this context refers to the construction of provisionary uses and infrastructures which hold together disparate and changing urban circumstances. Though Smithson did not directly combine the “mat building” concept with the “green holes” concept, the part-to-whole relationship of the mat is akin to the site-to-system connectivity of the strategy of holes. The “Holes” essay is an outgrowth of earlier writing by the Smithsons and other Team X members, who differentiated between fixes, such as roadways and associated greenways, and more transient uses:
14 Smithson, Team X Primer, p. 68.
If this distinction between the changing and the fixed were observed there would be less need for elaborate control over things for which no good case can be made for controlling, and legislative energy could be concentrated on the long-term structure. 14
15 “This project is more a discourse on what should not happen at Melun-Senart than on what should.” Rem Koolhaas et al., S,M,L,XL (New York: Monacelli Press, 1995), p. 974.
This framework was seen to sustain an infrastructure able to absorb social, cultural, and environmental changes but it also sustains our (architects’) relevance to large scale practice, after the so-called fall of the master plan. This strategy has been the basis for several of O.M.A.’s large-scale projects. For example, in the planning framework for the new town of Melun-Senart (1987), Koolhaas describes their approach as outlining what should not happen rather than what should.15 122
16:21:08:05:08
Page 122
Page 123
WITHOUT END
A system of bands . . . is inscribed on the site like an enormous Chinese figure. We propose to invest most of the energies needed for the development of Melun-Senart in the protection of these bands, in maintaining their emptiness. 16
16 Ibid., p. 981.
By Team X’s definition, these bands would be fixes. O.M.A.’s ambition is to render more flexible measures absent in the solid/void of master plans, while being able to retain the projective order of the plan. Even so, the landscape is described by Koolhaas as “void” or “empty” and the criteria by which it is generated remain largely hidden; the Chinese figure self-contained. They no doubt had criteria by which the bands were determined, but these were not elucidated. Without being specific about how they are generated, implemented, maintained or connected, the holes, like the voids of the master plans, appear to be another formal device unrelated to the specificities of the site. As mentioned earlier, Waldheim distinguishes landscape urbanism from landscape architecture’s roots in regional planning, yet still acknowledges that one of the most pressing issues facing contemporary designers is “the relationship between natural environments and processes of urbanization globally.”17 To this end, Ian McHarg’s work has been criticized due to his neglect of cities and dogmatic belief that ecology was the only relevant basis for design.18 McHarg, founder of the Landscape Architecture and Regional Planning department at the University of Pennsylvania and author of the highly acclaimed book Design with Nature (1969), was unquestionably narrow in his view of designers as mere objective collectors of data, yet he recognized the underlying geologic and hydrologic aspects of landscape process which could give rise to defining appropriate locations and uses. McHarg’s mappings, comprised of transparent overlays each containing a different value with both social and natural characteristics, provided the basis for the location of design interventions and resulted in gradations of grey which “revealed” areas best suited to certain types of development. The blackest areas represent “no-build” zones and resemble O.M.A.’s Melun-Senart. In the examples shown, Smithson, Koolhaas and McHarg all use the instrumentality of the hole as a way of guiding action. For Smithson, the ways in which the landscape could be framed were essential to a landscape’s function. Knowing that the entire network could only be selectively maintained or occupied, the appearance of the landscape and its performance are inseparable.19 For Koolhaas, the holes provide an infrastructure of protection, but still present landscape generically. And for McHarg, the instrumentality of the hole is based on the materiality of landscape and natural processes, though he neglects the design repercussions at the site or human scale. Despite McHarg’s reductive conception of design, he was concerned with the connectivity of systems and performative aspects of landscape as 123
16:21:08:05:08
Page 123
O.M.A.’s diagram of Melun-Senart, in S,M,L,XL, Rem Koolhaas et al. (New York: Monacelli Press, 1995), pp. 980, 981. Reprinted with permission from O.M.A.
17 Waldheim, Praxis, p. 10.
18 Ibid., p. 12. Also, see Anne Whiston Spirn, p. 36.
19 I am referring to Julia Czerniak’s introduction to the Downsview Park competition where she states that the projects, in general, privileged performance over appearance. See “Appearance, Performance: Landscape at Downsview” in Czerniak, pp. 12–21.
Page 124
KAREN M’CLOSKEY
McHarg’s mapping of physiographic obstructions in order to determine road alignment, in Design With Nature, Ian McHarg (New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1992 edn.), p. 37. Reprinted with permission of John Wiley & Sons.
20 It was Corner’s phrase “landscape as urbanism” to which Waldheim has acknowledged his debt. See footnote 1 in Waldheim, Praxis, p. 17. 21 James Corner, “The Agency of Mapping: Speculation, Critique and Invention” in Denis Cosgrove, ed., Mappings (London: Reaktion Books Ltd., 2002), pp. 213–252.
22 James Corner, “Ecology and Landscape as Agents of Creativity” in George F. Thompson and Frederick R. Steiner, eds., Ecological Design and Planning (New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1997), p. 81.
material. He also emphasized the use of mapping as a generative tool. This had a great influence on his students, such as James Corner, without whom there would be no “landscape urbanism” as it is currently defined.20 Corner has made a significant contribution to the conceptualization of landscape by devising methods of representation to better explain the processes of change inherent to landscapes, with conflating natural and cultural systems, and with describing mapping itself as the most creative and formative act.21 The approaches taken by Smithson, Koolhaas and McHarg—aesthetic, programmatic and material—should not be considered exclusive or competing interests but must be creatively incorporated together. While I am encouraged by the aspirations and collaborative framework of landscape urbanism, our fear of repeating the mistakes of the modernist master planners and apprehension regarding the reductivist nature of environmental determinism risks leaving landscape urbanism without criteria. In describing the influence of ecological thinking on landscape practice, Corner states that “There is no end, no grand scheme . . . just a cumulative directionality toward further becoming.” 22 While it is true ecological processes have no goal, that is not necessarily the primary characteristic towards which we should strive. Complete openness can be as reductive as complete control. I share the ambitions of this work, but am concerned about the generalizations and flattening out of precedent. Right 124
16:21:08:05:08
Page 124
Page 125
WITHOUT END
McHarg’s successional diagrams of dune development, in Design With Nature, Ian McHarg (New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1992 edn.), p. 8. Reprinted with permission of John Wiley & Sons.
Phasing Diagrams of Fresh Kills “Lifescape” by Field Operations, in Praxis 4: Journal of Building + Writing (New Orleans, Cambridge: Praxis, Inc. 2002), p. 25. Image courtesy of PRAXIS, Writing + Building.
now, there is an over reliance on bracketing landscape as urbanism primarily through park design—Central Park to Parc to La Villette to Downsview and Fresh Kills—but parks are only one necessary aspect of urbanism. Instead, we should construct a much broader history of precedents and begin to incorporate, albeit in reconstituted relationships, the criteria of dwelling, 125
16:21:08:05:08
Page 125
Page 126
KAREN M’CLOSKEY
working, transportation and recreation set forth in the C.I.A.M. functionalist city, critiques of which began with the Smithsons and Team X over fifty years ago. Landscape urbanism will in future, with its temporal and political characteristics, set the scene (albeit momentary) for democracy in action. 23 23 Mohsen Mostafavi, “Landscapes of Urbanism” in Mostafavi and Najle, p. 9.
24 Alison Smithson, Team X Primer, p. 64.
Just as the modernists and New Urbanists are criticized for tying architectural form to social betterment, we cannot assume that adopting a landscape model, even if it is not a formal one, is any more likely to democratize, as suggested in the above quotation. As it stands now, landscape is still representative in many descriptions and projects—representative of freedom, democracy or ameliorative to architecture. Architects have already answered the call of Team X, which was to move beyond the “Euclidean groove.” Now we have to take on their other challenge of disciplining dispersal “so that any resultant development does not become absolutely structureless.”24 NOTE
This essay was written in 2004 and I have left its content unaltered though the discourse supporting landscape urbanism has been advanced since then. The essay is framed within the context of how landscape urbanism has been positioned by those involved in developing programs of landscape urbanism within schools of architecture. In particular, I am referring to Charles Waldheim, founder of the Landscape Urbanism concentration at University of Illinois, Chicago and current Director of Landscape Architecture at the University of Toronto, and Mohsen Mostafavi and Ciro Najle’s involvement with the post-graduate certificate in landscape urbanism at the Architectural Association and work as editors of Landscape Urbanism: A Manual for the Machinic Landscape. Since then, Waldheim has published The Landscape Urbanism Reader (New York: Princeton Architectural Press, 2006), which includes essays from fourteen authors whose diversity positively expands the historical and theoretical framework of landscape urbanism. While the term is useful for describing collaborative practice, and individual project examples and essays demonstrate its potential and complexity, the question about its efficacy as a “disciplinary realignment” remains when considering its pedagogical implications.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 93rd Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 2005. 126
16:21:08:05:08
Page 126
Page 127
BOSTON’S NEW URBAN RING An antidote to urban fragmentation GEORGE THRUSH (1996)
The premise of this paper is that clear spatial order and hierarchy are necessary if we are to attain meaningful social, political, and cultural diversity in our cities, and in the space between them and the suburbs. We should not expect, simply because buildings look different from one another, and because the landscape between them seems fractured and uncontrolled, that we are representing the heterogeneity that today is taken in architectural discourse to be synonymous with political pluralism. We are not. Our contemporary urban and suburban landscape is often a homogeneous assemblage of meaningless commercial difference. If we want a heterogeneous landscape capable of representing real differences in culture, politics, and social order, we need, paradoxically, a strong, centered, spatial order that can lend hierarchy to public life. What follows is a proposal to transform the metropolitan area centered on Boston, Massachusetts, into just such a meaningfully heterogeneous landscape by means of an urban design strategy called the New Urban Ring. The New Urban Ring is a proposal to assemble a ring of space (composed largely of under-used parts of the city such as railroad right-of-ways, turnpike air-rights, some neighborhood streets, bridges, tunnels, bikeways, and even parts of the airport) around the central core of Boston to serve the following purposes: 1) to provide a circumferential transportation system to link the existing radial subway and transit lines between the city center and Route 128; amid the neighborhoods, nearby suburbs, and under-developed industrial land; 2) to provide a continuous boulevard for pedestrians, cyclists, and other citizens to move through, rather than between neighborhoods; 3) to act as a catalyst for urban development in the area between the city and the suburbs, and thereby allow the urbanity of the city to grow to metropolitan dimensions, rather than allow it to continue to wither in the face of competition from edge cities, and suburban sprawl; and 4) to provide a place for civic representation; for public buildings, spaces, and monuments to accrue meaning and express difference by virtue of their relationship to one another. The objective of the New Urban Ring is to address large-scale urban design, and regional forces. This scope mimics that of earlier utopian schemes, but with an important difference. The New Urban Ring engages this metropolitan scale while allowing for the kind of deference to local historical urban fabric that so often eluded earlier utopian schemes. Indeed the very act of making a figure-ground drawing of a 25 square mile area 127
16:21:08:05:08
Page 127
EVERYDAY URBANISM, LANDSCAPE URBANISM, AND INFRASTRUCTURE
Page 128
GEORGE THRUSH
Figure 1. Regional Figure/ Ground Drawing: Boston, Brookline, Cambridge, Somerville, Chelsea & Everett 1996, George Thrush. (Drawing by Salvatore Raffone.)
centered on downtown Boston (Figures 1 and 2) speaks to the desire to address both scales. The New Urban Ring is in some important ways a proposal to resist the commercial forces that make our society and its built environment increasingly homogeneous. If we desire that meaningful difference in our society be reflected in the built environment, we must find a way to make difference recognizable. The New Urban Ring is a proposal to establish a shared realm: a datum around Boston that conforms to and reinforces the city’s urban morphology. In relation to this “common ground,”1 differences in ethnicity, race, politics, style, and ideas will be more recognizable, and therefore more meaningful. Many architectural, social, and political critics, including Richard Sennett,2 Mike Davis,3 and Mickey Kaus,4 have discussed the ways in which we avoid the social, cultural, and political pluralism promised by American cities, and create artificially homogeneous communities instead. They make distinctions between public and private life (Sennett), actual and pseudopublic places (Davis), and “social” versus “civic” spending by the government (Kaus). Sennett and Davis speak to the fact that architecture and urban design are often complicit in this descent into individual isolationism, and the concomitant loss of public life. Kaus attempts to re-define public expenditures in terms of public, rather than individual, good. These critiques rely on making distinctions between economic identity on the one hand, and political or civic identity on the other. HOMOGENEITY AND HETEROGENEITY
Figure 2. Regional Figure/ Ground Drawing with New Urban Ring: Boston, Brookline, Cambridge, Somerville, Chelsea & Everett 1996, George Thrush. (Drawing by Salvatore Raffone.)
1 Common Ground: A Turbulent Decade in the Lives of Three American Families, Lukas, Anthony J., New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1985. 2 The Fall of Public Man, Sennett, Richard, New York: W.W. Norton & Co., 1974. 3 City of Quartz, Davis, Mike, London: Verso, an Imprint of New Left Books, 1990. 4 The End of Equality, Kaus, Mickey, New York: Basic Books, 1992.
When we look around us at even the most successful of today’s urban developments we see commercial culture as the only source of our collective identity. From the waterfront developments of The Rouse Corporation to the “Eisner-ization of America” (to call it “Disney-fication” seems unfair to the real Walt Disney, who had nothing to do with creating the current confusion between fantasy and reality) and the increasingly eerie similarity of experience that one finds in such formerly disparate places as Georgetown (Washington, D.C.), Harvard Square (Cambridge, MA), Halsted Street (Chicago, IL), and a host of other increasingly “mall-like” new urban districts, the shops, wares, people, food, habits, and activities of the participants all seem remarkably alike. This phenomenon is the source of a very real fear about the increasing homogeneity in our society. It is often taken to be the most pressing problem in our rapidly changing culture. We buy the same products; watch the same TV shows; eat the same fast foods; experience the same landscape—indeed, the latent heterogeneity of American society seems to be evaporating despite the fact that the country is composed of more different kinds of people than ever. Meaningful differences between people and places seem to be disappearing in the face of rampant commercialism and burgeoning communi128
16:21:08:05:08
Page 128
Page 129
BOSTON’S NEW URBAN RING
cation technologies that further minimize the importance and character of actual, rather than virtual, place; the effects of which we have not even begun to understand. But it is in the nature of capitalism to standardize products, increase market share, and reduce difference in the world. We also know that capitalism also widens gaps in income5. These are not new observations, but if we are serious about trying to forge prescriptive connections between the form and content of our society in our roles as designers of the built environment, they are not observations that we can afford to ignore. But by fretting about the physical and spatial results of our economic system (which the electorate shows no signs whatever of wanting to change), many critics miss the opportunity to resist the cultural and spatial homogenization of our society through non-economic, or civic means. The idea behind the New Urban Ring suggests that it is not the aforementioned commercial homogeneity that is the problem so much as its opposites: excessive heterogeneity, psychological isolation, lack of meaningful contact with others, and impoverished civic life. This lack of civic commonality threatens us much more than the fact that we will soon all buy everything we own from “The GAP”. Because, while it is disturbing that we all may one day wear the same tasteful plum colored shirts and khaki pants, it is more disturbing that we may take this to be the total measure of our social worth. Mickey Kaus, the author of a strategy for the renewal of American Liberalism titled, provocatively, The End of Equality, advocates many political measures that might replace what he calls “money liberalism” (or government efforts to try to balance private economic fortunes) with “civic liberalism” (a more direct strategy of renewing civic life and civic obligations).6 but they are all means by which we might resist the superficial heterogeneity of capitalism with some elements of a more substantive homogeneity associated with a more cohesive society: a more cohesive society that might, it almost goes without saying, actually see benefits to the community as clearly as we now see benefits to ourselves. Because our political discourse is so dominated by discussion of individual rights (to have abortions, to desecrate the flag, to own and shoot guns, to smoke pot, to not pay taxes, to build on wetlands, etc.) we do not discuss what we would like to have as the common property of the community. Is the promise of America truly “the right to be left alone” (what Isaiah Berlin would call negative liberty)?7 Or is there an affirmative good that resides in his conception of its opposite, “positive liberty”? Is the freedom to support something as a society not also a very important freedom? Finally, is there a way to revise our public life so that it is both accepting the kind of difference that Richard Sennett describes,8 while at the same time retaining the strength of our shared political will? If the answer is 129
16:21:08:05:08
Page 129
5 The End of Equality, pp. 7–16.
6 Kaus describes the failure of what he calls money liberalism, or the traditional liberal agenda that “seeks to prevent income differences from corroding social equality by the simple expedient of reducing the incomes differences—or, more accurately, suppressing the income differences continually generated in a capitalist economy.” In its place, he offers civic liberalism, which “pursues social equality directly, through government action, rather than by manipulating the unequal distribution of income generated in the capitalist marketplace.” This distinction between money liberalism and civic liberalism holds tremendous opportunities for programming a re-designed landscape for America’s cities. The End of Equality, p. 18. 7 Four Essays on Liberty, Berlin, Isaiah, Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1969, pp. xxxvii–lxiii (Introduction). 8 “The Passive Body,” Sennett, Richard, GSD News, Winter, 1995, Harvard University Graduate School of Design, p. 28.
Page 130
GEORGE THRUSH
9 “Ring Dreaming and Making,” Krieger, Alex, from Catalogue #2: The New Urban Ring, Thrush, George, Boston: Northeastern University, 1994, pp. 12–16.
yes, and if spatial order can be said to play a role in the construction of such public life, then the urban design program of the New Urban Ring is a call for such an affirmative step. It holds the possibility to serve as what we might call the footprint of an improved social order. Various rings for Boston have been conceived by different people at different times along a number of different routes, but they all share a similar animus. They are all responses to what Alex Krieger calls the lack of “rims” to connect the “hub and spoke” structure of the Boston region.9 This article will describe the history of that spatial order, its political and social ramifications, and the accompanying transportation strategies that have evolved to serve the region. In keeping with the rationale for the New Urban Ring itself, the essay will first address these issues with respect to the city, then the suburbs, and finally the New Urban Ring. The New Urban Ring derives its strength from synthesis. It joins the regional scale of transportation planning to the human scale of urban design; it relates the importance of spatial order to political identity; and it focuses its energy on the crucial space between city and suburb, the most vexing segment of the “middle landscape.” So to understand the importance of this proposal for Boston, we must first look at the forces that have pulled the region apart and how, by weaving it back together, a new metropolis could be born. BOSTON’S GEOGRAPHY: ISOLATION AND IN-FILL
10 Boston: A Topographical History, Whitehill, Walter Muir, Cambridge, MA: Belknap/ Harvard University Press, 1968, p. 1.
Figure 3. City of Boston Evolving Landmass, 1630–1995 from Mapping Boston by Krieger, Alex and Cobb, David, p. 118, M.I.T. Press, 1999 (copyright The Muriel G. and Norman B. Leventhal Family Foundation, cartography by MapWorks, Herb Heidt and Eliza McClennan, Norwell, MA).
The evolution of Boston as a geographical entity is interesting in its own right. What began as a “hilly peninsula, almost completely surrounded by water”10 has been transformed through landfill over the past three and one half centuries into a much larger, flatter, and more contiguous land mass (Figure 3). One can follow the evolution from the original Shawmut peninsula; to the early town with its active waterfront; to the thickened “neck” connecting the peninsula back to Roxbury; to the enlargement of Charlestown and the beginnings of the long process to in-fill the Back Bay; to the enlargement of East Boston, the completion of the Back Bay, and the construction of Fan Pier; and finally, the completion of the in-fill at Fort Point Channel, Charlestown, and East Boston for what is now Logan Airport. But much of the city’s original form came from civic divisions that remain to this day. Charlestown, Cambridge, Brookline and Boston Proper, South Boston, and East Boston, can all trace aspects of their distinctiveness today to the physical separation of their pasts. All of these places existed in Boston’s earliest days, but they were more a series of islands than part of a cohesive city. And it was due to their separation that the system of spokes connecting them to the hub of the original Shawmut peninsula was born. When there were large bodies of water separating these communities, ferries and bridges were the only way to connect them. Over time these 130
16:21:08:05:08
Page 130
Page 131
BOSTON’S NEW URBAN RING
initial radial routes from the center of Boston Proper became the primary roads in the adjoining communities as well. As the city grew, however, the watery voids that separated the landmasses began to shrink. A prolonged series of landfill projects began to construct the Boston that we know today. But the system of radial arteries lived on. Moreover, they became even more important than ever as orientation devices, because even as the city became a more contiguous piece of land, its neighborhoods remained quite distinct. They were created at different moments during this evolution of landmass and shoreline, and independently of one another, so they often shared little in the way of orientation, density, and urban morphology. In a 1986 design studio at Harvard’s GSD, Mario Gandelsonas directed his students in describing some of this complexity through a series of drawings which are very helpful in making this point about the city’s inherent morphological contradictions (Figures 4–6). So, from a physical standpoint, Boston was conceived as a collection of parts: both with respect to the parts of the city that remain separated from the “hub” by water, such as Charlestown, East Boston, and to a lesser extent, South Boston; and with respect to its internal “islands” of Roxbury, Dorchester, Brookline (politically distinct but virtually surrounded by Boston), and Allston/Brighton. Landfill has subsequently made whole that which was separated at the start, though it has never fully succeeded in re-connecting the fabric of the region. PAROCHIALISM IN POLITICS
The physical distinctions that describe Boston’s neighborhoods and nearby suburbs are reinforced by political distinctions that mark their ideals and prejudices. The city has had a long history of conflict between local and regional interests. Perhaps the best known, and most easily recognized, is the ongoing friction between Catholic voters (traditionally Irish, Democrat, and urban) and their Protestant counterparts (traditionally English, Republican, and suburban). This has evolved over time, but what is remarkable is the extent to which one can still describe the area’s politics in these terms. After the great migration of the Irish to Boston in the middle of the nineteenth century, they quickly began to emerge as a political force in the city. In a town that had been politically dominated by Protestants since the time of the Puritans, the political rise of the Irish was seen as a threat. The result was that, since the Protestants continued to control State politics for some time, they sought to limit the power of their urban brethren by limiting the political power of the city. The most powerful tool in this repressive arsenal was (and remains) something called “Home Rule,” a State law under which the City of Boston must gain the approval of the legislature before levying any new taxes.11 By controlling the city’s ability to raise 131
16:21:08:05:08
Page 131
Figures 4–6. Diagram of Boston, 1986 from “The Order of the American City”, Gandelsonas, Mario Assemblage #3, 1987, p. 65 (figures 2a–c).
11 The Rascal King: The Life and Times of James Michael Curley (1874–1958), Beatty, Jack, New York: Addison-Wesley, 1992, Chapter 7, p. 263 and p. 269.
Page 132
GEORGE THRUSH
revenue, the Protestant suburbanites limited the potential power of the Catholic Irish. But this mutual animosity also caused Bostonians and their political leaders to resist other, more beneficial regional alliances that might have served the metropolitan area much better than the latent parochialism and separatism that emerged. American politics is filled with ethnic and religious conflicts like these, but in Boston they were particularly destructive to planning and designing the built environment because this conflict between the city and all of its neighbors restrained inter-municipal cooperation and regional planning. Due to its inherently fractured and separated physical character, the area known as “the Boston Region”—which is actually no larger than an average-sized metropolis—could not be planned like one. So, in a place where cooperation between small political entities was essential, there were profound political obstacles to coordinating the physical planning of the city as a whole. REGIONALISM IN TRANSPORTATION, INFRASTRUCTURE, AND RECREATION
The most important precursors to the regionalism of the New Urban Ring were Arthur Shurtleff and the Boston Society of Architects’ (B.S.A.) Committee on Municipal Improvements. The Committee’s proposal for an Inner and Outer Boulevard was remarkably like today’s proposed New Urban Ring. It consisted of circumferential (or ring-like) boulevards that would cross municipal, class, and racial boundaries. Shurtleff’s analytical drawings of both existing and proposed radial and circumferential routes throughout the region offer the evidence that such boulevards were necessary then, and remain so today. To reinforce the similarity of conditions which support the need for the New Urban Ring (in any of its variants) today, refer to the images of the contemporary city with overlays of the B.S.A.’s 1907 plan, its 1994 plan, and the author’s alignments of the New Urban Ring. While they are all different, each alignment takes advantage of the same latent morphology in the region, and each connects radial routes through circumferential connections. Each of these urban boulevards has the added regionalizing effect of crossing economic, ethnic, class, and racial boundaries. Perhaps the most profound regionalization of Boston’s transportation planning and infrastructure came in the 1970s under the leadership of Fred Salvucci, then Governor Michael S. Dukakis’ Secretary of Transportation. This is important because it is the regional scale of transportation infrastructure that can serve as the armature for the regionalized urbanism of the New Urban Ring. He certainly benefited from the previous administration’s decision (with his encouragement) to abandon the so-called “Inner-Belt” expressway that would have so fractured Boston’s physical landscape as to make it nearly irreparable. But Salvucci inherited a Metropolitan Transit Authority whose range was limited to fourteen municipalities, and as such 132
16:21:08:05:08
Page 132
Page 133
BOSTON’S NEW URBAN RING
had little regional impact. He left with the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority serving seventy-eight cities and towns, and extending far out into suburban Boston. The key to his overall regionalization efforts was the Boston Transportation Planning Review of 1974, which ultimately led to many important improvements in this area. The most critical improvements were the extension of the Red Line subway route; the Orange Line extension/Southwest Corridor Park; the purchase of commuter rail lines to the north and south of the city from the Boston-Maine and Conrail respectively; and finally, most influentially, the depression of the Central Artery and the construction of the Third Harbor Tunnel.12 SUBURBANIZATION: POLITICS REDUX
The regionalization of the Boston area’s transportation infrastructure made the entire region much more accessible. It became possible to commute between the city center and the more distant suburbs. There were even steps taken toward making “inter-modal” stations, such as those at Quincy and Alewife, that offered automobile commuters the chance to exchange their cars for public transit while still well outside of the city. The resuscitated transportation network also took the concerns of inner-city pedestrians to heart for the first time since the advent of the large-scale highway systems after World War II. Special attention was given to the quality of stations and, in the case of the Southwest Corridor Park, an entirely new pedestrian sequence was created alongside the new Orange Line. But there remained an aspect of even these enlightened transportation planning efforts that continued to segregate the region. For even as the area’s radial connections between inner city and suburb were being strengthened, the circumferential connections through the often under-developed “middle-landscape” of nearby suburbs and disenfranchised urban neighborhoods were being ignored. The interests of the suburban commuters to downtown were being served at the expense of the even greater needs of the residents of the space “in-between.” So it became clear that some sort of ring, or belt, or loop was needed; something that approximated the scale and connectivity of the Inner Belt, but that served instead as more of a urban development generator, much as Route 128 had for the suburbs a generation earlier. THE NEW URBAN RING: AN ANTIDOTE TO URBAN FRAGMENTATION
So the mission of the New Urban Ring is a complex one. It is to resist the latent parochialism of the Boston region from both a political and bureaucratic standpoint and to take advantage of the opportunities for regionalism. The intersection of these goals could create the physical landscape for a new kind of politics, one that political writer E. J. Dionne calls 133
16:21:08:05:08
Page 133
12 From an interview with Claire Barrett, former Member of M.B.T.A. Board of Directors, 8/22/95.
Page 134
GEORGE THRUSH
13 Why Americans Hate Politics, Dionne, E. J., New York: Touchstone, 1991, Chapter 13, pp. 329–355.
14 Ibid., p. 333.
15 The End of Equality, pp. 7–16.
the need for a strong political middle:13 a political movement that could harness that great deal about which Americans do not disagree. This will not be easy. As Dionne notes, “conservatives and liberals are suspicious of an ethic of the ‘public good’ for very different reasons. Conservatives who dislike government see the revival of a civic politics as a way of invoking old language to justify modern big government. Liberals, fearful of too much talk about virtue and community, fear that civic talk will mean the creation of a homogeneous community. When liberals hear talk about ‘the common good’, they often think of Jerry Falwell.”14 Mickey Kaus, another astute observer of the contemporary political scene, is more specific in his description of exactly how we might physically achieve this “common good.” His “civic liberalism” is a program for required national service, national health care, the draft, public day care, and civic celebrations; all as a means of encouraging the racial and class mixing that traditional “money liberalism” has failed so miserably to produce.15 But the program and alignment for Boston’s New Urban Ring is designed specifically to make a place for Kaus and Dionne’s vision of a renewed public sphere. Of course it must also serve as the kind of infrastructure that can create jobs, provide transportation, and play other more prosaic roles in contemporary life. In addition, it should serve as an especially safe place in the city, where travel through previously unwelcoming neighborhoods would now be possible. Perhaps most importantly, it would allow for the representation of Boston’s rich (and parochial) character along a regional route. As discussed earlier, the commercial (or artificial) heterogeneity of haphazard development patterns could be replaced by a heavily structured public sequence where key sites would have tremendous opportunities for real civic, rather than commercial, meaning. Physical homogeneity could make cultural and political heterogeneity possible. URBAN DESIGN STRATEGIES
In order for all of these opportunities to find their way into the real experience of the city, however, different ring typologies would have to be developed to accommodate the widely varied spatial conditions found in the Boston area. There would be three basic cross-sectional typologies. One would be a single, complex boulevard, along the lines of Vienna’s Ringstrasse, that would include dedicated lanes for rapid transit, ample pedestrian paths, and controlled vehicular lanes (Figure 7). The second would be a two, or even three, road system of parallel streets that would allow the separation of truck service and automobile traffic from the transit- and pedestrian-based central boulevard. Such a system would create the possibility of two-sided building types like supermarkets which could sit directly on the street front on the central boulevard, while retaining ample parking access from one of the secondary circumferential streets. Finally, in some of the tighter existing conditions, the Ring might continue with only 134
16:21:08:05:08
Page 134
Page 135
BOSTON’S NEW URBAN RING
allées of trees and building setback and height regulations to help transform existing streets into parts of the New Urban Ring. Another way that the Ring could be apprehended is as an episodic series of nodes, rather than as a continuous spatial corridor. In this configuration, the character and definition of the nodes (presumably at key transportation transfer points) would be especially important. In either case, however, the Ring could perform a critical role in the spatial orientation of both visitors and residents alike, helping to form a mental map of one’s surroundings; something which has always been notoriously difficult in Boston—even for long time residents. By making constant reference to a single center (the downtown core, or center of the Ring), both the physical and political structures of the city are reinforced. Building regulations would, of course, depend on the selection of either the continuous or episodic structure for the Ring (and there is no reason why both could not be employed along different portions of the Ring). For the continuous type, building setbacks, height limitations, and colonnade dimensions would be part of the visual guidelines used to inform development along the alignment. This type of urban design strategy would work best with a surface transportation system, such as a trolley or dedicated bus line, because its visibility along the route would be important for maintaining the Ring’s “continuity.” The episodic, node-based Ring would rely more on landmarks, towers, and other identifiable elements visible from a great distance, and as such would be able to work with a subway type transportation system, because the stations would occur at the specified nodes and their route beyond the nodes would be of less importance.
Figure 7. The Ringstrasse, Vienna, Austria.
REGIONAL MASTER PLAN
Many neighborhood-specific proposals could grow from the New Urban Ring. The idea has tremendous power because it need not, and indeed could not and should not, be implemented all at one time. Instead it can serve as the backbone of a regional “master plan” that would encourage development in the Boston region that would be integrated, progressive and morphologically appropriate, without being unnecessarily nostalgic in the process. Using the New Urban Ring as a regional “master plan” would do more for maintaining the oft-cited and presumably much-loved “character” of Boston than any collection of historical stylistic guidelines. Such a plan could have a major impact on many important projects that are being considered right now. The location of a “megaplex,”16 either as a whole or, more preferably, as a series of parts connected by the New Urban Ring, is one example, but there are several others. There are tremendous development opportunities along the Conrail railroad right-of-way in Cambridge and Somerville; vast tracts around Sullivan Square; large 135
16:21:08:05:08
Page 135
16 A combination of a large convention facility and a domed football stadium currently under review by the Massachusetts State Legislature.
Page 136
GEORGE THRUSH
portions of Charlestown’s waterfront that are now underutilized; Central Square in East Boston has the potential to be one of the city’s most beautiful; and all the way from South Boston to Roxbury, there is un-used or underused land looking for a vision of how it might all work together. THE FUTURE
17 “Turning Point”, The Boston Globe Magazine, October 30, 1994, p. 29.
A 1989 state transportation study reviewed circumferential transit. In 1994, Harvard, M.I.T., and The Boston Globe convened The Boston Conference on “the accessible region” at which a national jury admonished the city and state to get together and “build the Urban Ring,”17 and in 1996, the Massachusetts Bay Transportation Authority will commission a study of the idea. But the power of this fundamentally urban design proposal must not be allowed to dissolve into merely a question of ridership estimates based on current conditions. The New Urban Ring is a proposal that could repair and re-make the region by re-connecting its citizens, ideas, beliefs, and activities into a greater whole. But it will not happen merely because designers think it is a formally attractive idea. Citizens must be persuaded that there is more to American life than pure individualism; more than separatism and commerce. If we desire a heterogeneous public life in place of the commercial homogeneity that we currently endure, the space between Boston’s downtown core and its nearby suburbs offers the perfect place to try to build it. We need not build it all at once. But we need to start (Figure 8). NOTE
As of 2007, the transit connections envisioned in the New Urban Ring have been extensively studied as a prelude to some form of implementation, but because the region still lacks a regional planning authority, the larger and even more critical physical and economic development aspects of the proposal have not yet received similar attention. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Beatty, Jack. The Rascal King: The Life and Times of James Michael Curley (1874–1958). New York: Addison-Wesley, 1992. Berlin, Isaiah. Four Essays on Liberty. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1969. Davis, Mike. City of Quartz. London: Verso, an Imprint of New Left Books, 1990. Dionne, E. J. Why Americans Hate Politics. New York: Touchstone, 1991. Kaus, Mickey. The End of Equality. New York: Basic Books, 1992. Kennedy, Lawrence W. Planning the City Upon the Hill. Amherst: The University of Massachusetts Press, 1992. Krieger, Alex. “Ring Dreaming and Making” from Catalogue #2: The New Urban Ring, Thrush, George. Boston: Northeastern University, 1994. 136
16:21:08:05:08
Page 136
Page 137
BOSTON’S NEW URBAN RING
Figure 8. Boston’s New Urban Ring, with two case study areas built-out in Boston University/ Cambridgeport and Melnea Cass Boulevard, Roxbury; 1996, George Thrush. (Drawing by Salvatore Raffone.)
Lukas, Anthony J. Common Ground: A Turbulent Decade in the Lives of Three American Families. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1985. Palmer, Thomas C. “Turning Point”, The Boston Globe Magazine, October 30, 1994. Schneider, William. “The Suburban Century Begins”, The Atlantic Monthly, June 1992. Sennett, Richard. “The Passive Body”, GSD News, Winter, 1995. Harvard University Graduate School of Design. Sennett, Richard. The Fall of Public Man. New York: W.W. Norton & Co., 1974. Whitehill, Walter Muir. Boston: A Topographical History. Cambridge, MA: Belknap/ Harvard University Press, 1968.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 84th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 1996. 137
16:21:08:05:08
Page 137
Page 138
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
EVERYDAY URBANISM, WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN (1995) LANDSCAPE URBANISM, AND INFRASTRUCTURE Infrastructure is a metaphor for a much bigger set of issues or a much deeper reckoning about the future. It’s a metaphor for how we care about and cope with the future. It’s not just concerned about structures. Structures are important. They provide a service that has value. But the highways, bridges, dams and water systems are also a means by which we relate to each other as humans and this fragile and beautiful planet. It’s these built systems that create our hoped-for protection—and connection. I believe a starting point for any kind of strategy on infrastructure is to think about the built environment with as much discipline and passion as the most concerned bring to the question of the natural environment. Nancy Rutledge Connery Executive Director National Council on Public Works Throughout his 1992 election campaign, President Clinton spoke of the need to establish a new compact between the national leadership and its citizens in a common quest to rebuild America’s economy as well as its communities, emphasizing infrastructure development as one of the primary tools for accomplishing both. Before long, infrastructure became the buzz word of the day, tossed about as casually in the media as it was at cocktail parties. When the Clinton Transition Team contacted us regarding our thoughts as urban designers on the role and function of infrastructure in the remaking of community, we found ourselves reexamining some fundamental questions. What is infrastructure? How can an expanded understanding of it maximize the benefits of new infrastructure dollars for human, plant, and animal communities? Unfortunately, we found that infrastructure is often narrowly equated with public works. Each community has a public works department responsible for the planning, design, and maintenance of the “practical” aspects of city services, such as transportation, water supply, sewage, garbage disposal and, in many cities, parks and recreation. To describe infrastructure as public works, and to define public works as those utilitarian functions which merely support the economic productivity of the community, hides the broader possibilities of infrastructure as the repository of cultural imagination, the network for community connections, and a vivid display of local ecological resources. 138
16:21:08:05:08
Page 138
Page 139
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
INFRASTRUCTURE AS A REPOSITORY OF CULTURAL IMAGINATION: MEANING AND BEAUTY
Builders of the post-World War II landscape have separated function from form in infrastructure, regarding the city’s network of transportation, power lines, water supply, sewage, and garbage disposal as mere utilitarian systems rather than cultural artifacts or forms of public art. This split is clearly illustrated by Le Corbusier’s central text on urbanism, The Radiant City, published in 1933. One of the book’s infrastructure diagrams is particularly telling. In it, Le Corbusier illustrates how he and many other designers have selectively edited infrastructure out of the new urban utopia, treating it as a mere utilitarian system to tap for needed services. In his scheme the landscape is green, the sun bright, and the highway skillfully hidden in foliage. Infrastructure blight—electrical lines, sewers, power plants, and factories—is drawn below the picture frame, tied to the houses in this idyllic landscape by neutral thin lines. The messy, ugly workings of infrastructure are stowed out of sight like the power plant of a transatlantic ship, which performs the dirty job of transforming natural material into head, clean water, and power below the water line of the ship. With the unsightly clutter of infrastructure hidden beneath the drawing, the residential landscape takes on the contours of a 19th century park, a tranquil place to re-create oneself far from the modern world’s assaults upon the well-being of the inhabitant. A ROOM WITH A DIFFERENT VIEW: CONSEQUENCES OF THE SPLIT
As in Le Corbusier’s drawing, we have designed and planned our postWorld War II American cities under the illusion that infrastructure was a utility to be placed out of sight and separated from the landscapes that nurture us spiritually as well as economically. The results have been mixed. We assumed that the landscape had an ever-increasing capacity to absorb growth and remain a pristine scenic backdrop. Since the 1950s, many suburbanites have believed that they could escape the ugliness of the urban infrastructure and environmental degradation of the city and start over in the woods and wetlands of the surrounding suburban communities. Landuse planning would protect their “room with a view”—their uninterrupted “view” of the sun, their patch of green, and the purity of their water. Infrastructure would be constructed outside the picture frame. Thus, most suburban comprehensive plans are based on the separation of two worlds: the utilitarian and the natural. Utilitarian structures were conceived as benign, single-function service systems that by-passed homes as they supplied the needs of economic productivity. They could leave untouched the natural, or aesthetic, environment where homes are established, children are raised, and families recreate. This bisection was successful as long as these systems remained inconspicuous and little in number, and there was enough undeveloped land to buffer subdivisions from infrastructure. 139
16:21:08:05:08
Page 139
Page 140
WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN
Consequences of the split view of infrastructure: “From the backyard into the front yard.”
But the newness of the suburban landscape has begun to wear off and the older infrastructure of the inner city is collapsing. In the suburbs, wetlands have been drained and channeled into storm sewers; woodlands have disappeared. Small county roads are being expanded into trunk highways to meet increased demand. New thoroughfares are treated as mere functional conduits whose sole purpose is to move goods, services, and people fast and efficiently. Today, the infrastructure, which was supposed to remain in the alley at the rear of the house, has crept into full view in the front yard, fracturing, destroying, and homogenizing a landscape which was supposed to be a safe, comfortable refuge from the grittiness of the city. WHERE DO WE LOOK FOR ANSWERS?
The city and suburb are beginning to find that degraded and degrading infrastructure is an issue they have in common. Both are learning that infrastructure is a cultural utility, a civilizing amenity, not a necessary evil to be placed “below the picture frame.” Infrastructure is the visible underpinning of civic life, which can instruct citizens about their values and relationships to each other and highlight the connections between the city, suburb, and the hinterland whose natural resources sustain it. Infrastructure can—and should—make those lines of connection clear and vivid. To build infrastructure that participates this deeply in the imaginative life of its community requires a fundamental shift in our attitude toward the landscape. In his book Discovering the Vernacular Landscape, John Brinckerhoff Jackson, the noted scholar of American landscape, says that the most magnificent city complexes “recognize the need to integrate infrastructure, or civil engineering, with landscape, or architecture.” Beautiful 140
16:21:08:05:08
Page 140
Page 141
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
and brilliant schemes are created when “they both reorganize space for human needs, both produce works of art in the truest sense.” To do this we need to recognize the inseparability of landscape and infrastructure. In “The Word Itself,” one of the essays in the book, Jackson writes: A landscape is not a natural feature of the environment but a synthetic space, a man-made system of spaces superimposed on the face of the land, functioning and evolving not according to natural laws but to serve a community—for the collective character of the landscape is one thing that all generations and all points of view have agreed upon. He points to Holland, an engineered landscape largely reclaimed from the North Sea, or Frederick Law Olmsted’s design for the Boston Fens as examples of this synthetic landscape whose “organizations of space have been so well assimilated into the natural environment that they are indistinguishable and unrecognized for what they are.” For Jackson, infrastructure not only provides the backdrop for culture but the very ingredients that make it possible: In the contemporary world it is by recognizing this similarity of purpose that we will eventually formulate a new definition of landscape: a composition of made-made or man-modified spaces to serve as infrastructure or background for our collective existence; and if background seems inappropriately modest we should remember that in our modern use of the word it means that which underscores not only our identity and presence, but also our history. INFRASTRUCTURE AS LANDSCAPE: THREE BACKGROUNDS FOR OUR COLLECTIVE EXISTENCE
In order for infrastructure to become the background for our collective existence, identity, presence, and history, we believe that infrastructure must fulfill broader cultural, social, and ecological functions. The infrastructure in these human-made landscapes should serve multiple goals. Chief among these goals is enriching our sense of place, by bridging our commonwealth and enhancing the workings of ecological systems. INFRASTRUCTURE: ENRICHING OUR SENSE OF PLACE
Traditionally, we have conceived of infrastructure as a neutral gray utility, as objects and spaces devoid of cultural expression or celebration out of a fear of distracting the motorist or drawing attention to the messy plumbing of the city. Sometimes we neglect exploring the cultural possibilities of infrastructure under the misguided policy, “If it looks good, it costs too much.” We must remember that these pieces and systems perform the essential 141
16:21:08:05:08
Page 141
Page 142
WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN
Three infrastructure backgrounds to our collective existence: “Enrich, connect and enhance, place, ecology and commonwealth.”
“cultural workings” of our society. They enrich our sense of who we are and characterize the places we inhabit. We need, then, to give priority to infrastructure projects that improve formal, spatial, and aesthetic connections and create a heightened sense of place for our citizens. Beautiful infrastructure that is inspired by and responsive to the physical and topographic features of the locale is primary to creating community identity and a personal sense of orientation. One of America’s most outstanding examples of the rich layering of cultural and function in infrastructure is Philadelphia’s Fairmount Waterworks, built in 1815. Among the country’s first urban water systems, the steam-driven 142
16:21:08:05:08
Page 142
Page 143
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
plant pumped water from the Schuylkill River into the homes of Philadelphia residents. To house these waterworks, the city chose a group of Greek Revival temples, designed by Frederick Graff, a utilitarian acropolis set into Fairmount Park that symbolized the new democratic urban landscape amid the park’s natural systems. Though newer facilities have been built to meet the city’s increased demands for water, the waterworks stand today as a historic landmark, an infrastructural “ruin” that provides a tangible reminder of the cultural values that have shaped the city. Following the Fairmount Waterworks, our whole web of infrastructure—roads, water mains, pumping stations, garbagetransfer facilities, and water treatment plants—need to be more broadly conceived as not only service system, but as armatures for culture. As such, they have three functions: to provide a repository for collective memory, to establish an orientation and path-finding framework, and to provide a clear curriculum of civic instruction on how to use and value this investment. Where do we go from here?
Garrison Keillor once joked, it’s “remarkable that all the towns in Iowa were named after their water tanks.” Keillor, in his way, underscored the basic legacy among American cities throughout the 19th and 20th centuries of building public temples and parks to house infrastructure. Not only did they define the public realm and symbolize democracy’s collective power, but these landmarks remind us of our daily struggle to shape the forces of nature into the landscapes which provide the foundation for our modern cities, as in New Orleans, for example, where city water pumps battle round the clock to prevent the groundwater from flooding the slim crust of elevated land upon which the city’s character is defined. Just as it provides the lines of continuity between the past and the present and provides the foundation upon which our future rests, infrastructure can also shape a spatial framework for cognitive path-finding to help citizens find their way across a metropolitan landscape. In the past we have used historic monuments, civic buildings, parks, and prominent topographic features as visual landmarks that help us orient ourselves in the city and mark sub-districts within a larger metropolitan area. More recently, however, we have given little thought to the usefulness of infrastructure— the highways, power lines, and waterworks—as signature landmarks that can guide us through the complex web of places in urban landscapes. The city of Phoenix has taken steps to capture this opportunity. As part of a proposed $1 billion infrastructure development, the city asked us in 1987 to assist the Phoenix Arts Commission in constructing a unique urban design plan which used public works to improve the physical quality of the community. The city’s goal, according to the Phoenix Public Arts Plan, is the construction of 143
16:21:08:05:08
Page 143
Page 144
WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN
. . . a series of sites linked to the spatial and public infrastructure systems of Phoenix. This approach allows for not only the provision of sites suitable for artists’ works, but also for the creation of a public orientation system. The public art “system” idea helps a person locate oneself within the expansive urban landscape partly by creating a heightened sense of orientation. This can be created by responding to the context of natural and built landscape, climatic conditions and the historic/cultural tradition of the desert Southwest. Collectively individual works of art and the public art system as a whole can help the citizen to better understand and comprehend both the city and the region. This plan has resulted in several public artworks, including the transformation of a new cross-town expressway into a desert parkway heavily planted with native vegetation; a standard highway overpass into a new neighborhood gateway; and a garbage-truck transfer station into a public landmark and environmental education center. Infrastructure is now part of Phoenix citizens’ “mental map.” These cognitive landmarks help them define themselves and the place in which they live. These infrastructure facilities were also designed to be didactic—instructing citizens about the meaning, value, and function of the systems that support their communities. Incorporating instructional devices establishes a connection between the community and the engineered utility, transforming basic facilities into attractive public places in which citizens experience key lessons of public responsibility. That connection provides a common set of experiences that facilitate a clearer understanding of how we, as individuals, are related and how our actions are connected to maintaining the quality of the place. For example, Phoenix citizens have learned that the city’s infrastructure legacy dates to the irrigation canals of the Hohokam that crisscrossed the valley floor nearly 1600 years ago. Today, these irrigation canals provide the basis for linking neighborhoods and the city with the basic life-giving force of the area’s water. In a city dominated by streets and highways, these canals and water systems have become new focuses of community activity and development, and a framework for a new community map. The city of Phoenix has extended this kind of civic instruction into one of the most banal of urban infrastructures—a garbage-transfer and recycling center—with impressive results. “I would like this facility to become one of the features visitors come to Phoenix to see,” says Ron Jensen, director of the city’s Department of Public Works. Supported by the Phoenix Arts Commission, artists Linnea Glatt and Michael Singer— with the help of consulting engineers Black and Veach—transformed this standard landfill project into an educational landmark. Described as a multi-functional marketplace, the facility not only serves as a site for solid-waste transfer, recyclable materials sorting, and vegetation recovery 144
16:21:08:05:08
Page 144
Page 145
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
Phoenix Public Art Works “cultural infrastructure.”
and mulching, but also hosts educational and demonstration projects for the public. Designed as much more than the standard single-use dump, Phoenix’s new waste facility includes a desert landscape built upon a mound of discarded concrete sidewalk and demolition material; recycling displays that chronicle the history of waste disposal; a solid-waste library; amphitheater for films and lecture; and an elevated walkway that allows visitors to view 145
16:21:08:05:08
Page 145
Page 146
WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN
waste operations. In 1992, the public got its first glimpse of the facility at a black-tie event called “Dance at the Dump,” fulfilling a goal outlined in a project brochure: “Unlike most recycling or transfer facilities that operate in an ‘out of site, out of mind’ context, this facility will encourage visitors to view the entire operation.” Though the costs for this innovative and imaginative investment are comparable to those of building a standard landfill transfer station, the payoffs are much greater in the long term. For one thing, the facility teaches more responsible “refuse” habits. By teaching citizens how to be better consumers of the service, the system is more efficiently used and maintenance costs are reduced. Furthermore, visitors learn about the impacts of their waste behavior on the larger eco-community. Site landscaping and connections between the building and the surrounding mountains remind visitors about how good waste management can help to reduce degradation of the area’s fragile desert. An adjacent storm-water recharge landscape, currently under construction, teaches lessons about desert water harvesting. And by making this facility a civic showpiece rather than a dumping ground, the city multiplies the land-use possibilities of surrounding sites. The waste complex, for example, could serve as an anchor for new private and public development centering on education, recycling, and the environment. INFRASTRUCTURE: BRIDGING OUR COMMONWEALTH
In our earnest efforts to provide the needed infrastructure to service a vital economy, we’ve often forgotten that infrastructure is one of the most visible fruits of a community’s collective labor. As a result, we’ve pursued a wasteful, inequitable course that squanders this collective infrastructure investment, subdivides what we share, and abandons poorer communities. Starting in the 1950s and ending in the 1980s, we focused our natural resources on building an infrastructure system for our cities across our nation. In some areas, these systems exist with underutilized excess capacity; in others, aging infrastructure is in rapid decline. Instead of building upon this foundation, since 1980, we have diverted system maintenance funding to capitalize on new infrastructure at the outer limits of urban centers—at the expense of our networks in our existing city. We’ve stretched our resources to such an extent that gaps have begun to appear in the fabric of not only our inner cities, but our first- and second-ring communities, as well. The future costs of this neglect are staggering. Infrastructure is a public resource that requires continual maintenance. Recent federal reports state that deferred maintenance has contributed to America’s economic decline. By some estimates, more than $3 trillion are needed nationwide to upgrade our existing systems. Not surprisingly, few citizens are aware of the magni146
16:21:08:05:08
Page 146
Page 147
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
tude of the investment we have made—in money, energy, and social upheaval—to construct and maintain existing infrastructure in our cities. We have so successfully placed it out of sight that we have lost contact with its fundamental role in shaping our collective existence. In cities such as Cincinnati, Ohio (population 350,000), however, greater awareness of this investment is changing urban attitudes and policies. As part of a recent public assessment of the city’s infrastructure, city officials and business leaders calculated the replacement cost of that infrastructure as $10.2 billion in 1990 dollars. This major community investment—bridges, park systems, river-front esplanades, storm-water channels, and waterfiltering stations, not to mention more linear miles of retaining walls than any other American city to keep neighborhoods on the hills overlooking the Ohio River from sliding down its banks—provides civic identity and ensures Cincinnati’s competitive edge as a regional marketplace. Aware of its valuable heritage, Cincinnati has begun to rebuild a stronger sense of community by leveraging its infrastructure heritage. One of the most positive results of this public effort was the enlistment of the larger community in the making and maintaining of public works. With the help of neighborhood groups and individual citizens, a city commission of business and community leaders recently inventoried city facilities and procedures. The commission’s final report presented more than 100 recommendations, including an earnings tax proposal that voters passed as one of the first steps towards rebuilding the city’s infrastructure and neighborhoods. This community involvement proved so valuable that citizen committees are now appointed on an ongoing basis to advise a variety of city departments. The lasting benefit of this civic exercise is an engaged public, involved in the long and difficult task of making public infrastructure contribute to community revitalization, from economic prosperity and social vitality to the physical quality of the city’s neighborhoods. The success of these efforts rests on the recognition that infrastructure is created by our collective efforts and represents our collective wealth. As such, it becomes the public domain that we own and share. Therefore, infrastructure should be designed as bridges to link us rather than walls to divide us. But this hasn’t happened. In our eagerness to use infrastructure primarily to maintain the wealth of central marketplaces, we have ignored the possibility of using those same systems to reinforce and access the “common” wealth of an interconnected city. As Cornell West describes, We must focus our attention on the public square—the common good that undergirds our national and global destinies. The vitality of any public square ultimately depends on how much we care about the quality of our lives together. The neglect of our public infrastructure and sewage systems, 147
16:21:08:05:08
Page 147
Page 148
WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN
bridges, tunnels, highways, subways and streets—reflects not only our myopic economic polities, which impede productivity, but also the low priority we place on our common life. Already, many city residents have lost control of their streets to commuter traffic and their trees to disease and pollution. In the outer suburbs, residents find that they have lost their cherished natural resources, the woodlands, fields, and streams that enhance the quality of their lives and underpin the basic economic value of their home investments. In their place, they find woodlands cleared and streams channeled into box culverts for warehouse discount stores, office parks and massive highway rights-of-way, whose traffic spews heavy metals and noise into the air. As we lose these features, we lose our sense of security, orientation and, most importantly, our sense of community. The resulting isolation makes it easy to abandon established neighborhoods for “safer” places ever farther out on the metropolitan fringe, thereby despoiling even more open space. Where do we go from here?
Infrastructure systems must improve both the functional and physical sense of connection between neighborhoods and the larger community. We should give priority to infrastructure projects that address basic inequities between inner city and suburban neighborhoods. Despite the fact that inner-city residents are taxed at higher rates to maintain the basic core of water and power systems that serve the outer edges, they are increasingly segregated from the growing range of jobs, goods, and services available to middle- and upper-middle-class residents in suburban areas. Dispersed employment centers in the suburbs are poorly serviced by transit, restricting job access to low-income families without automobiles. Yet, highways subdivide inner-city neighborhoods to accommodate job commutes for suburban workers crisscrossing the metropolitan area via the central core. The narrow utilitarian focus of past infrastructure has created invisible barriers between economic classes and ethnic groups, reinforcing in some cases and causing in others a de facto form of class segregation. To balance the existing investment disparity between city and suburb, new development growth should be forced to pay the true cost of infrastructure at the expanding metropolitan edges rather than simply the construction price tag. Before we consume more raw land, we should successfully capture the full potential of our existing investment. We should give priority to new infrastructure projects that build on past investments and seek to reunite the segmented parts of the commonwealth—projects that link and integrate development with compact, mixed land-use development. 148
16:21:08:05:08
Page 148
Page 149
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
Transportation planning should begin with the premise that we must reduce travel time to work, through consolidating destinations and providing convenient access to alternate modes of travel. We must recognize that there is no such thing as truly free parking (even if the driver does not pay for the privilege). Instead we must promote projects that underwrite employer-based transportation programs, to incrementally change worker habits and locational decisions. “The key to integrating our thinking about transportation and land use,” says planner Joel Woodhull of Southern California’s Rapid Transit Development, “is to focus on access rather than mobility. Mobility means going faster and farther. Access means getting to more places conveniently. With access, the focus is on places. Mobility focuses on paths, often to the neglect or even the destruction of places.” We should encourage infrastructure projects that evolve out of public participation. Traditionally, the supply side of the economy—businesses and manufacturing—has been seen as the primary client of infrastructure development so that we’ve produced industrial systems rather than a public realm for community. The primary users of infrastructure, however, are average citizens. Federal programs should encourage projects which incorporate their needs and demands while improving service and the quality of place. Public participation, if properly orchestrated from the beginning, does not add cost. On the contrary, in the long term it increases the effectiveness and acceptance of the system as a cultural amenity and minimizes the possibility of protracted citizen protests and environmental lawsuits. Countering our municipal funding crises, public participation produces solutions that leverage each dollar to improve both service and quality of place. And public involvement produces educated users of the system, reducing abuse and decreasing maintenance costs, while it builds the long-term commitment necessary to support both construction and operating costs. Finally, to assist this dialogue we need to develop a new vocabulary for infrastructure that enlarges functional engineering terms to include words that describe the cultural and social life of a community and its qualities of place. Because we have viewed infrastructure as the servant of industry and national defense, the terms for its planning and design are technical and standardized. To create infrastructure that bridges the diverse social patterns and needs of our metropolitan commonwealth, we need a language that transforms “arterial streets” into community avenues and “detention ponds” into neighborhood parks. INFRASTRUCTURE: ENHANCING ECOLOGICAL FUNCTION
Until now, we’ve favored the conventional simple engineering approach, in which infrastructure denies the richness of natural systems, ultimately 149
16:21:08:05:08
Page 149
Page 150
WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN
stripping away complex wealth from the landscape. The engineering approach creates a single-use network that moves goods, services, and people over the land through capital-intensive concrete and steel conduits that neither give nor receive much support from the landscape through which they pass. Unfortunately, we have crisscrossed the American landscape with such simple systems in our attempt to create a standardized national system of support for our nation’s participation in the global market. In the process we have ignored the diverse physical and cultural features of regional geography in our construction of a rational infrastructure system. On the other hand, an alternate complex design approach mimics ecological function and the spirit of the landscape, and builds what J.B. Jackson, in “The Word Itself,” calls “synthetic organizations of space [that] have been so well assimilated into the natural environment that they are indistinguishable and unrecognized for what they are.” This system seeks to use the ecological features, functions, and character of the landscape to benefit both society and natural systems. Designed to be integrated into the landscape, complex systems are also multiuse, providing twice the benefit from a single investment. Using this new definition of infrastructure, even the most mundane and “un-public” of urban functions—the sewage-treatment plant—can become a beautiful ecological civic landmark. In 1990, the village of Alvo, Nebraska, hired Minneapolis artist and engineer Viet Ngo to create a sewage-treatment system. Using a serpentine form inspired by Native American earthworks, Ngo created a sewage-holding pond covered with a carpet of duckweed. As plant-massings drive from the pond’s intake pipe to the outflow in an adjacent lake, they metabolize excess algae while absorbing and bio-concentrating harmful chemicals. “We chose it because it costs less and we believed it would be environmentally kind,” says Barbara Hollinger, village vice chairperson, in a 1991 Artnews article on the project. “The results have just been excellent, cleaner and clearer in appearance, and it’s prevented any algae’s growth. And it totally transforms the area. It no longer looks like your typical sewage lagoon at all—it’s beautifully artistic.” This project and others like it clearly point to a new type of artistic ecological engineering that provides public service while adding beauty and fiscal value to our civic investment. We have created infrastructure to turn “straw into gold,” to control nature and make it the supporting foundation for our lives. As we collect the gold, we should not forget to maintain the fields that grow the straw. Even in a global “information” market, we still need living forests to supply the timber for our houses and replenish the air we breath with oxygen. If natural resources are fundamental to our lives, then the maintenance of natural systems should be the starting point for the creation of future 150
16:21:08:05:08
Page 150
Page 151
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
infrastructure. Without clean water, air, healthy forests, and unspoiled land, the infrastructure will cease to run and thereby sustain our existence. The recognition that our infrastructure facilities and natural systems are interdependent, and that long-term viability of the systems is necessary in order to support social and economic stability, changes the way we define the word landscape. Infrastructure is more than a utility. It is a foundation for our sense of being and place and carries within its veins the lifeblood of many different communities—the neighborhoods and habitats for human, plant, and animal populations. Ultimately, there is no economy without a living nature. Without it, infrastructure ceases to function, the marketplace withers and dies, and individuals lose the common ground of community. Where do we go from here?
Whenever possible we should choose multi-functional systems over singleuse systems, favoring projects that function ecologically and use natural systems as extensions and components of an infrastructure. For one thing, they are more economical in the long term. Multi-functional systems tend to require the acquisition of land, but those additional property costs can be off-set in the long-term municipal maintenance costs of concrete and steel systems. Moreover, lands bordering a green system command higher property values. We should encourage the development of this kind of infrastructure that serves economic growth at the lowest long-term municipal cost. We should favor projects that enrich and connect existing communities of plants and animals. Highway and pipeline corridors move people and oil, but they can also provide pathways for plants and animals on their cyclical migrations. Biologists believe that these pathways will become increasingly important as the climate band shifts, driving the movement of many species northward. Corridors connecting species-rich patches may become vital to preserving our existing bio-diversity. We should, therefore, promote projects that improve the “living” viability of the natural systems, projects that use native plant materials and provide protection against the invasion of foreign plant materials that undermine local plant and animal habitats. Native vegetation planted along the East Coast interstate system, for example, could have stalled the spread of the destructive kudzu vine that has used the highway corridor as an expansion route on its devastating northbound rampage to engulf and damage power lines and bridges, thereby increasing local maintenance costs. We should develop infrastructure projects that protect and replenish natural systems. Water quality is rapidly becoming the number one environmental issue for both the public and private sector. Just how much environmental health and economic recovery are connected is perhaps best illustrated by the struggling economies of Eastern Europe. A 1992 151
16:21:08:05:08
Page 151
Page 152
WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN
Environmental Science and Technology article estimated that 70 percent of Czechoslovakia’s waters are heavily polluted; 30 percent cannot even support fish. Much of the country’s water is unusable for industrial consumption, not to mention damaging to plants and animals. Just as people cannot survive drinking water contaminated with mercury and other persistent contaminants, industry cannot thrive without larger quantities of clean water. Incentives should be given to infrastructure projects that clean their wastes as much as possible on site and recharge local water resources. Excellent models found abroad, and to a limited degree in the United States, make effective use of the natural systems that use hyper-accumulator plants to clean polluted water and soils. We must use every means to encourage infrastructure projects that aggressively recycle products and reclaim places. Newark, New Jersey Mayor Sharpe James instituted an aggressive recycling program that both cleans up the city and unites citizens in a common civic mission. Plastics are collected and recycled into new public benches for neighborhood parks and streets. The public works department in Phoenix shreds thousands of discarded tires, recycling them into a new road-surface material to replace asphalt. This recycled material has the added advantage of increasing traction and reducing solar heat gain on road surfaces. As we recycle our waste into new products, we should also reclaim the used sections of urban areas and the riches of their natural systems buried long ago by early metropolitan expansion. In Minnesota, the RomoseWashington Metro Watershed District is working with the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, the City of St. Paul, the University of Minnesota’s College of Architecture and Landscape Architecture, and residents of the Phalen neighborhood to revitalize this older, inner city neighborhood on the outskirts of downtown St. Paul. The strategy was: 1 To create a neighborhood commercial transit center and park to serve as a new focal point for this mid-density ethnic community. 2 To remove a deteriorating, crime-ridden 1960s shopping center and reclaim the pre-development wetland beneath the site. 3 To daylight piped and buried portions of Phalen Creek that run through the community and rebuild this ecological waterway system. Not only would the waterway provide recreational green space within the Phalen community, it would also enhance habitats for herons and waterfowl that use the area as a flyway. At the same time, this low-cost ecological water-management and treatment system would filter and clean water upstream, improving the quality of the water that ultimately flows into the Mississippi River. In our haste to built metropolitan landscapes, we have buried many streams, wetlands, woodlands, and other natural systems. The Phalen neigh152
16:21:08:05:08
Page 152
Page 153
INFRASTRUCTURE FOR THE NEW SOCIAL COMPACT
borhood project demonstrates that just as we recycle our aluminum cans, we can also reclaim from underneath the architectural solid waste of past development. Furthermore, we can reclaim the natural systems that will help us manage our waste while rejuvenating local economies, the social fabric, and the beauty of our neighborhoods. We believe that the role of infrastructure in President Clinton’s new compact is to create the systemic framework for each community’s mission: to nurture economic productivity, cultural expression, and social equity while preserving and replenishing natural resources. Infrastructures can become the vessel to carry forward the dreams of a new compact into physical reality, supporting a diversity of animals and beings across large, complex metropolitan regions. The collective wealth of our community’s infrastructure binds us together and provides a public landscape within which we, as individuals, find our identity and common ground between each other and supportive natural processes. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Appleyard, Donald, Kevin Lynch, and John Myer. The View From the Road. Cambridge: M.I.T. Press, 1964. Braunfels, Wolfgang. Urban Design in Western Europe: Regime and Architecture, 900–1900. Trans. K.J. Northcott. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1988. City of Phoenix, Department of Public Works. 27th Avenue Solid Waste Management Facility, 1991. Cronon, William. Nature’s Metropolis: Chicago and the Great West. New York: W.W. Norton & Co., 1991. Forman, Richard T. and Michael Godron. Landscape Ecology. New York: John Wiley and Sons, 1986. Illich, Ivan. H20 and the Waters of Forgetfulness. New York: Heyday Books, 1985. Jackson, John Brinckerhoff. “The Word Itself.” In Discovering the Vernacular Landscape. New Haven: Yale University Press, 1984. —— . “The Public Landscape.” In Landscapes, Ervin Zube (ed.). Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1970. —— . The Necessity for Ruins. Amherst: University of Massachusetts Press, 1980. Kastner, Jeffery. “The Duck Weed Factor—Devil’s Lake, N.D.” ARTnews 90:2 (February, 1991). Le Corbusier. The Radiant City. New York: Orion Press, 1963. Lopez, Barry. Arctic Dreams. New York: Chares Scribner’s Sons, 1986. Morrish, William. “The Urban Spring: Formalizing the Water System of Los Angeles.” In Modulus 17, David Gobel and Mary Mead (eds.). Charlottesville: University of Virginia Architectural Review, 1984. Morrish, William and Catherine Brown. “Western Civic Art: Works in Progress.” Places 5:4 (1988): 64–77. Morton, H.V. The Fountains of Rome. New York: MacMillan Publishing Co., 1966. National Council on Public Works Improvement. Fragile Foundations: A Report on America’s Public Works, February, 1988. 153
16:21:08:05:08
Page 153
Page 154
WILLIAM R. MORRISH AND CATHERINE R. BROWN
Reich, Robert B. The Work of Nations. New York: Vintage Books, 1992. Smale, John. Infrastructure Commission Report. City of Cincinnati: Department of Public Works, 1987. Spirn, Ann Whiston. The Granite Garden. New York: Basic Books, 1984. Stodola, Betsy (ed.). Public Art Works: The Arizona Model. City of Phoenix: Phoenix Arts Commission, 1993. West, Cornell. “Learning to Talk Race.” The New York Times Magazine (2 August 1992): 24–26. Woodhull, Joel. “How Alternate Forms of Development Can Reduce Traffic Congestion.” In Sustainable Cities: Concepts and Strategies for Eco-City Development, Bob Walter (ed.). Los Angeles: Eco-Home Media, 1990.
This article was originally planned for Productive Park, a publication produced by the Architectural League. Portions have been published in “Beautiful Infrastructure,” On the Ground, winter/spring 1995, and in Patrick Condon, ed., Sustainable Urban Landscapes: The Surrey Design Charrette (Vancouver, 1996). 154
16:21:08:05:08
Page 154
Page 155
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO MODERNITY? NEW URBANISM
DANIEL SOLOMON (2007)
This essay is a stew that began to cook some time ago with a beautiful exhibition of women’s fashion at New York’s Metropolitan Museum entitled Chanel, curated, designed and sponsored by the current director of the House of Chanel, Karl Lagerfeld. This exhibition dealt powerfully with the question of modernity and the relationship of modernism to a long cultural legacy that predated it. It brought into focus for me the most perplexing questions about the movement called New Urbanism that I have been part of, about the stunning successes New Urbanism has had, and about its equally stunning failures. The set of ideas and practices that carry the banner of New Urbanism have a history much longer than the name. Similar ideas about the relationship of urban land to hinterland, of the city to its transportation infrastructure, the city to its own history and the role of public space in the culture of the city came together long ago. In their earlier incarnations they were resisted and ultimately crushed by the collision of the same rigid orthodoxies— modernist and revivalist—that marginalize New Urbanism today and make it in the eyes of many the domain of maudlin saps—aesthetic and political reactionaries whose ideas about the city are discredited upon arrival because of the imagery in which they are clothed. In the decades since the 1920s, modernity and the isms it has spawned have taken many forms. In America, the term modernism in relation to architecture and town planning has a more specific and prescribed meaning than it does in other places and other disciplines. There was something radical in the canon of modernism as it was initially applied to American architecture and town planning that modernist aesthetics in other pursuits did not share. The person most clearly identified with this radicalism was Walter Gropius, as Director of the Weimar Bauhaus and later in his role as program director of Harvard’s School of Architecture beginning in 1937. In the nearly seventy years that modern architecture has been taught at Harvard, variations on its curriculum became the norm at schools of architecture, and ideas hatched at Harvard became an almost universally shared and rarely questioned set of received opinions among American architects. In that seventy years there have been many people of extraordinary and diverse abilities who have taught in Harvard’s Graduate School of Design, and their individual accomplishments are indisputable. For the purpose of this essay, however, I want to focus not on the many fine achievements of people on the Harvard faculty, but on an influence of the school that has been pernicious. I want to make the case that the way in which modern architecture is introduced at Harvard is one important source 155
16:21:08:05:08
Page 155
Page 156
DANIEL SOLOMON
of the debilitating style wars that now swirl through the world of urbanism causing debilitating havoc. Gropius’ idea of education for modern architects represented a kind of revolution that shared its most basic idea with Mao Tse Tung’s Cultural Revolution or the revolution of the Taliban. The idea is that young people need to be protected from the corrupting influence of knowledge. Gropius did everything he could to insulate young architects from architectural history and from the traditional mimetic and representational skills of the Beaux Arts. Following his lead, American architectural education became a widespread cult of unlearning. Gropius tossed architectural history as it had traditionally been taught out of the professional curriculum, but at Harvard modernism needed some new theoretical grounding. To fill the bill, he launched his colleague, Sigfried Gideon, on the writing of two extraordinarily influential books, Space, Time and Architecture and Mechanization Takes Command. For my generation of architecture students, even 3000 miles from Harvard, Space, Time and Architecture occupied the position next to our bosoms that Mao’s Little Red Book did for the Red Guards. The thesis of Space, Time and Architecture goes something like this: the way people see and perceive things changes with the times. As evidence, Gideon invokes the standard art-historical view of the relationship between Renaissance humanism and the discovery of the laws of perspective. He then claims a similar relationship among a series of modern phenomena including the theory of relativity, cubism, steel frame construction and high speed transportation. The term space/time is his shorthand for a modern revolution in the perception of architecture and cities, equivalent to the discovery of perspective. In the sixty-nine years since the Gropius anschluss at Harvard, things have become more sophisticated without really changing. Architectural theory at the Harvard Graduate School of Design is taught by Professor Michael Hayes and his survey course is required for all first year students. The syllabi I have for this course begin with Space, Time and Architecture, even though it is safe to say that most architectural historians now regard it as an ingenious work of propaganda as pseudo-history. Perhaps to insulate his students from this heretical view, Professor Hayes tells his fledglings how to read Gideon by providing in the syllabus a handy “Premise for Interpreting Gideon.” . . . modern architecture plays a significant role in an ongoing cognitive revolution—that extended process of intellectual transformation whereby a society whose life habits and perceptual apparatuses were formed by other, now anachronistic, modes of production are effectively reprogrammed for life in the new industrialized world.
156
16:21:08:05:08
Page 156
Page 157
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO MODERNITY?
To paraphrase Professor Hayes’ paraphrase of Gideon in other and simpler words, he is saying that if people don’t like the mechanization and abstraction of our brand of modern architecture, don’t worry: it’s their fault. As a modern architect and an initiate into the true workings of historical process, you have an obligation not to listen to them. The infuriating smugness of this self-validating Gropius/Gideon pedagogy was bound over time to create merciless backlash. This is not smugness just as an unattractive personal habit, but smugness as a theory and a world view. Right after Gideon in the syllabus, now into the second week of graduate school, comes an introduction to the Frankfurt School for Social Research with special emphasis on Theodor Adorno and his Philosophy of Modern Music, published in its final form in 1949. If Gideon is the foundation for a system of ideas, Adorno is the keystone. The thrust of Adorno’s essay is to compare and contrast false modernity and true modernity, represented respectively by the music of Igor Stravinsky and that of Arnold Schoenberg. For Adorno, Stravinsky was the prisoner of historical sentiment, his music filled with primitivism, references to folk tunes, marches and classical structure. Schoenberg, on the other hand, was the true adventurer in the modern spirit since his twelve tone system is a pure abstraction, an invention of the mind incapable of reference to anything outside itself. What’s more, Schoenberg’s harsh dissonances are an appropriate art for the harsh, dissonant turmoil of modern life as opposed to Stravinsky’s “neo-classical objectivism,” a construct of what he called “premature harmonies, ignoring the persistence of social contradictions.” May God spare architecture students from suffering anything as indulgent as “premature harmonies.” Most of the Marxist intellectuals of the Frankfurt School, like Karl Marx himself, were Jewish. Though they were assimilated and secular, they retained an element of Judaism in their thinking, and they freely appropriated the Jewish doctrine of the Messiah, giving it a new name—The Revolution. Until the revolution came, society would remain in a fundamental state of disorder. The function of art is to reify or give expression to this state of disorder and thereby raise social consciousness and hasten the revolution. Therefore all worthy art must have an element of negativism or dissonance about it. Art that does not suffers from “premature harmonies.” Sorry everyone, no joy allowed until after the revolution. One of the forms of “premature harmony” that Adorno attacked most viciously was American jazz, which he pronounced “yatz,” and associated with the German word “hatz,” a pejorative for the baying of a bloodhound. He wrote the long vituperative essay On Jazz in 1933, never having heard any jazz in live performance, but continued revising it and making it even nastier after he came to this country in 1940. In jazz, he saw American Negroes as complicit in their own oppression. He dismissed the great jazz of the 1950s as watered-down Delius and Debussy, but he found one thing 157
16:21:08:05:08
Page 157
Page 158
DANIEL SOLOMON
positive (that is in Marxist terms—negative) in the lead instrument of the bebop of the 1950s—the saxophone. He observed that the saxophone is a metal horn played like a woodwind. It therefore has a kind of sexual ambiguity or Zwischengeschlechtlichkeit, and since this androgyny represents a critical challenge to the established sexual order of society, the saxophone is OK. Newly minted graduate students in architecture at Harvard are taken in their second week on this through-the-looking-glass journey into the topsyturvy world of Marxist aesthetic theory, where positive is negative, negative is positive and the redeeming quality of a saxophone is its androgyny. In fairness to Professor Hayes, his course goes on to present other contending points of view, and some, like those of Robert Venturi and Colin Rowe, are more congenial to New Urbanism. But these later readings are a bit like comparative religion as taught at Notre Dame, unlikely to win large numbers of converts to Islam or Buddhism. The institution has a point of view and Professor Hayes’ message to fledgling architects at Harvard, and to those unfortunate enough to be elsewhere, is clear: populist hostility to an abstract modernism is philistine ignorance to be ignored; references to vernacular building, the imperatives of place or classicism are inadmissible and dissonance not harmony is the order of the day. By the third week of school, the seeds of hostility to New Urbanism are well sown at Harvard. If Michael Hayes’ tune has a familiar ring to it, it is because you cannot listen to a Charlie Rose interview of a star architect without hearing echoes of it. These ideas are completely pervasive in architectural culture whether or not those who believe in them have any idea of their source. From the studiously unpretentious language of Frank Gehry to its opposite in the many big words of Peter Eisenman, what unites the purveyors of the blobs to those of the wiggles and the shards is a set of ideas that comes from Sigfried Gideon and Theodor Adorno out of Michael Hayes. The Hegelian view of history says that revolutions breed counterrevolutions of equal and opposite force. If this is true, it explains why after seventy years of the Gropius curriculum in schools of architecture, an institution like the Institute for Classical Architecture should suddenly appear on the scene and flourish with such remarkable vitality. There is no question that the I.C.A., many of its members, and the architecture department at Notre Dame are doing something important and desperately needed after the modern academy’s seventy year assault on architectural knowledge. Recovery of the knowledge that helped make the world civil for centuries is unquestionably a good thing. But the I.C.A. is tinted in a way—notice I say “tinted,” not “tainted” or “stained”—that sets it apart, I think a long way apart, from a strategy for contemporary urbanism. 158
16:21:08:05:08
Page 158
Page 159
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO MODERNITY?
I.C.A. announces events all the time and the subject matter is usually something about a fabulous collection of Dresden porcelain or a tour of a 200 room mansion owned by Doris Duke or someone like her on a thousand acre estate in Santa Barbara or Newport. Last year, I found myself by fluke at the annual Driehaus Awards dinner in Chicago, surrounded by I.C.A. members at the event sponsored by Notre Dame. The room, way up in a high-rise, was, thanks to American building technology of the 1920s, the largest perpendicular Gothic interior I’ve ever seen, next to Westminster Abbey. It was twice the size of any similar room at Cambridge or Oxford. There was a sprinkling of people I knew from the Congress for the New Urbanism (C.N.U.) and elsewhere, but mostly it was a big crowd of surprisingly young strangers. I later learned that the youngest of the young were actually Notre Dame’s architecture students attending on assignment. The young women—whatever their talents, accomplishments and politics—were absolutely radiant with a fragrant, pre-Raphaelite innocence that I thought had been expunged from the world forever by Coco Chanel and her generation twenty years before I was born. Astonishingly for an architectural gathering, there was not an unstructured black jacket in sight. Except for the conspicuously frumpy presence of the C.N.U. Board, the hundreds of mostly young men seemed to frequent the same excellent tailor as Prince Charles. Where in the world, I wondered, do these people shop? The highlight of the evening was the awarding of the Driehaus prize to the English neo-classical architect Quinlan Terry. He accepted the award and said the following: We must build in the manner of our forefathers, in brick and lime masonry. If we do so, the natural orders of architecture will re-emerge: the Doric, the Ionic and the Corinthian. He said this with a straight face to enthusiastic applause while standing on the 12th floor of a high rise surrounded by the architectural treasures of Chicago Loop from William Lebaron Jenny and Louis Sullivan to Frank Gehry’s Pritzker Pavilion across the street, surely one of the great public spaces in America. That this skillful and intelligent architect, Quinlan Terry, neither saw nor acknowledged any contradiction was clearly a matter of choice. It is the same choice to resist assimilation into the larger culture for the sake of traditional values that the Shakers or the Hasidic Jews of Brooklyn make. It is a choice that is perfectly OK for an architect, like a musician joining an early music consort, but not for an urbanist. Urbanism is engaged with the history of the city and the gears of history, like a good bicycle, have many speeds forward, but also like a bicycle, no reverse. Many people outside of New Urbanism think that we are all just like Quinlan Terry, trying to ride our bicycle backwards and like him, unwilling to engage with what is around us. What is around us are the forces of 159
16:21:08:05:08
Page 159
Page 160
DANIEL SOLOMON
CCTV Building, Beijing, China. Rem Koolhaas. Rem Koolhaas, Content (Köln: Taschen, 2004).
technological change, of population pressure, of environmental degradation, of global warming, of hegemonic urban sprawl. The Driehaus Awards dinner was a gathering of a committed sub-culture, which is attractive to some young people, but I think not very many. Where do the other young people go, and why? Most of them do not choose to decontextualize their own lives, in fact they regard being with it and plugged in to the way things are going as a high virtue. We can thank Rem Koolhaas’ newest book Content for defining the very look of with it and for contextualizing the work of town planners and architects in current events more vividly than any New Urbanist has done. At the same time he portrays the dark side of globalization in a more terrifying way than almost anything I have ever seen. The single exception was the extraordinary program on Frontline on the scale of what can only be called slave labor in China under the ironic name of Communism. Rem understands and actually diagrams how China’s sweat shop economy has sucked the economic life out of Europe and the U.S. and he knows the enormous social consequences. Rem puts his dark insights about the world and his own work right on the cover of the book—Big Brother Skyscraper, Sweat Shop Economy. To me what is simply amazing is the gleefulness with which he casts himself in the role of Prince of Darkness, according to his own vision of hell. He records for our amusement some light-hearted banter with Prada fashionistas about the desperate poverty of Lagos, and he sneaks in some Larry Flynt style photographs of female genitalia. Naughty, naughty, I guess is the point. His design for the CCTV Building in Beijing is not only a dazzling symbol of oppression; it is the very instrument of oppression. CCTV’s control of information is vaster and more insidious than its co-conspirator Google, which eradicated the existence of Tank Man from the internet in China. Imagine a situation in which 97 percent of the residential fabric of New York and Chicago including the most vibrant neighborhoods were demolished in ten years and the population was forcibly relocated to sterile new suburbs through a massively corrupt system of expropriation. Imagine that occurring with the television, press and an internet police force forbidding any murmur of protest. Without any exaggeration, that is exactly what is happening in Shanghai and Beijing today and it is what Rem’s building celebrates. To achieve the symbolic and terrifying about-to-topple cantilever of the CCTV Building, Koolhaas enlisted ARUP Engineers. In a little essay he calls “Post-Modern Engineering,” he discusses how ARUP used their computational might to analyze the indeterminate redundancies and concentrations of loads on the exposed truss-work that holds up the monstrous cantilever and to derive the irregular patterns of the trusses. He wonders about what happened to the scientific rationalism that would have been revolted by the exercise and he asks wistfully, “Why don’t they just say NO?” 160
16:21:08:05:08
Page 160
Page 161
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO MODERNITY?
Edificio Mirador, Madrid, Spain, designed by MVRDV with Blanca Lleo de Arquitectura. Terence Riley, On-site: New Architecture in Spain (New York: Museum of Modern Art, 2006).
The cadences of Winston Churchill during the fearful days of 1940 come to mind: “a new dark age made more sinister, and perhaps more protracted, by the likes of perverted science.” So, from its early days as the cultural arm of Bolshevism, avant-gardism, after almost eighty years wandering in the wilderness, has found steady employment as an agent of the dark side of globalization. Do not think for a minute that Rem Koolhaas’ CCTV is an aberrant exception in this regard. The social housing shown by the Museum of Modern Art in its 2006 exhibition entitled On-Site celebrated what curator Terence Riley considers the vitality of new architecture in Spain, including avant-gardist housing where the Spanish put their Algerians, Turks, Africans and Arabs: dwellings and play space for the next generation of train bombers. The social housing in On-Site is exactly the opposite of what we New Urbanists were able to accomplish through HUD’s HOPE VI program, where immigrant populations and our own poor were integrated into classic American neighborhoods. HOPE VI is where the aesthetically conservative strain of New Urbanism found a high social purpose. But New Urbanism finds itself in a loony situation. On one hand there is a powerful modernist establishment comprised of the best universities and museums throughout the world, the professional architectural press and most newspaper and magazine critics. For them town building and architecture are history-less and a-political subjects. Reference to anything prior to the modern period is culturally inadmissible and belief in social purpose is just not hip. There are of course exceptions to this—Yale as a school and architects from Lou Kahn to Rafael Moneo—but the exceptions are just that: exceptions to the juggernaut of modernist right-think. On the other hand, opposing the juggernaut is this now thriving neo-classical 161
16:21:08:05:08
Page 161
Page 162
DANIEL SOLOMON
movement that does little to dispel the impression that it is willfully oblivious to the technical, demographic and political changes that distinguish our time from other times. We New Urbanists have our own agenda about the city which seems barely connected to this cultural debate, but we find ourselves in the cross-fire of an intolerant modernity on one hand and a revival of classical knowledge that has so far failed to separate itself from a longing for the riding-to-the-hounds society that was eradicated in World War I. I would like to focus on a pair of my own cultural heroes who seem to me to point the way around the cultural schism that threatens the great cause of urbanism and urban reconstruction. Let’s consider Coco Chanel. She is most often associated with a quintessential modernist object—the supremely beautiful, elegant and unchanging sixty-year-old design for the bottle of Chanel #5. At first glance this design appears to confirm Adorno’s conception of the modern, in its abstraction and rejection of narrative reference. Before Chanel #5, perfumes all had names like Night in China, Harem Musk or Dark Fantasy. The Chanel #5 bottle rejects all that in favor of an abstraction, a bit of pseudo-science implying the formulation and testing of Chanel’s 1 through 4, which of course never existed, and also love of the beautiful form of the Helvetica #5. But Chanel was not selling perfume bottles: she was selling perfume. Perfume is all about sexuality, and smell—the most animal of the senses—packaged in a bottle. It is the abstraction of the bottle that makes the sensuality of the contents all the more vivid and meaningful. The bottle of Chanel #5 is, like her clothing and like her life, a splendid contradiction and a seamless synthesis of opposites. Chanel was not only the most original, gifted and prolific designer of her generation; she was a business genius on the scale of an Andrew Carnegie. She started in a foundling home, absolutely penniless, and she built an industrial empire, all of her own conception, the first and probably history’s most powerful woman C.E.O. But she never concealed or was in the least embarrassed by the fact
New dresses designed by Coco Chanel. Harold Koda et al., Chanel. (New York: Museum of Modern Art, 2005.)
162
16:21:08:05:08
Page 162
Page 163
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO MODERNITY?
that she began her career as a demimondaine whose rich lovers competed for her sexual favors with gobs of money to back her first ventures. Karl Lagerfeld says splendidly, “Chanel was a mystery and a paradox. Reality is bearable only if it is made up of such things.” In her cosmos it was inconceivable that femininity and feminism could be considered different ideas. She wanted to dress a woman so that she could enter a room on equal terms with the army general, the bishop and the head of state, as confident and reassured by her dress as they. Her version of femininity was simultaneously egalitarian and aristocratic, simultaneously athletic and erotic. She dressed a woman to go the opening of the Paris Opera in such a way that you knew she was capable of climbing a tree. She believed in physical ease as the predicating condition for elegance. She referred to classical antiquity in clothing made of industrial mass-produced fabrics like jersey, and she absolutely mastered the traditional crafts of the milliner and the tailor. The October 1926 Vogue called her classic “little black dress” the “Chanel Ford, the frock that all the world will wear.” Chanel’s two main ideas—her conception of women and her idea of the relationship of abstraction to life—are completely congruent with those of a friend and collaborator of hers, the great choreographer George Balanchine. It is not overstating the case to say that Balanchine united a classical tradition and modernism with more originality, more force and more enduring success than any other artist in any discipline. In this regard, his work, his contribution and his life story are one and the same. If one tries to draw some lessons from the synthesis he brought about, it is worth knowing how Balanchine became Balanchine, because his story is as rich with contradictions as Chanel’s. His career began at the age of ten when he was accepted into the Imperial Ballet School in St. Petersburg, part of the court of Tsar Nicholas II. In the Frenchified court of the Tsars, classical ballet, which evolved from fencing exercises in the court of Louis XIV, was preserved and perfected. Balanchine was raised at court, often appearing in the fabled Maryinsky Theater with its greatest stars. After the tumult of World War I and the Revolution, he found himself, age twenty-one, undernourished and unemployed in Paris. Then fatefully, the 20th century’s greatest genius at recognizing genius, Serge Diaghilev, invited him to audition. Diaghilev audaciously made this superbly trained classical dancer and the most supremely elegant of all 21-year-olds the Ballet Master of his world famous Ballets Russes. His first assignment was to collaborate with Igor Stravinsky and Henri Matisse, no less, on a reworking of the ballet Le Chant de Rossignol. Matisse did the sets, the costumes and the make-up and arranged red and white chrysanthemums in the hair of the principal ballerina, Alicia Markova. Coco Chanel hosted the cast party after the opening and Stravinsky played the piano at the party. 163
16:21:08:05:08
Page 163
Page 164
DANIEL SOLOMON
The other Ballets Russes artists that young Balanchine was thrown in with included Picasso, Prokofiev, Tchelitchew, Jean Cocteau, Kurt Weill, Lotte Lenya—an unbelievable list. He went from the court of the Tsar to Diaghilev’s court of modernism at its absolute pinnacle of excellence. Michael Hayes begins the education of architects with Adorno’s sour diatribe against Stravinsky, and it is revealing that Stravinsky found his natural collaborator, George Balanchine, in the most sensual of the arts— ballet. Just like the bottle of Chanel #5, the most characteristic and famous of the Stravinsky/Balanchine ballets strip away all narrative reference: no story telling and no sets, costumes that refer only to the dancer’s
Dance choreographed by Balanchine. Costas, Balanchine: Celebrating a Life of Dance. (Windsor, Connecticut: Tide Mark Publications, 2003.)
bodies. There is nothing on the stage but the life force of the music and the geometries he makes of the dancers themselves. And Balanchine’s dancers were better schooled in classical dance, more disciplined than any dance company had been before. Balanchine’s grand abstractions demanded more from the corps de ballet than had ever been asked of it before—more athleticism, more musicality, more speed. When his vision exceeded what even his own superbly trained corps could do, he would arrange his soloists in formation and use them like a chess master attacking with his bishops. Balanchine was a modernist who extended the tradition of classicism he inherited. He was also a modernist who was not a slave to modernity. He carried the whole history of ballet in his head and did all kinds of things with it—narrative story ballets, huge spectacle ballets, movies and Broadway musical comedy, which he helped revolutionize. Over their long careers, Stravinsky and Balanchine managed a trick that architects and town planners should be able to do and one that is strictly forbidden in the dictat of Harvard aesthetic theory. They were able to engage popular culture in its own terms, excel within it, and never compromise their own standards. When things got slow in 1941, Balanchine even took a job with Ringling Bros. choreographing elephants. He asked Stravinsky to collaborate with him, and Stravinsky had only one question, “Would the elephants be 164
16:21:08:05:08
Page 164
Page 165
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO MODERNITY?
young?” Balanchine assured him that they would be young and beautiful and the collaboration proceeded. Chanel and Balanchine were such complete masters of their disciplines that they could draw upon its entire history as situations demanded. Neither was ever prevented from doing anything that interested them by an ideology or an aesthetic canon that made some things off limits. A question to ask is, were there ever people in the world of architecture and urbanism who were as cosmopolitan, as eclectic, as simultaneously modern and as embracing of history as Chanel and Balanchine? The fact is that modernity as a driving force in architecture and town planning predates the rigid prescriptions of Harvard modernism by half a century at least. During that long span of time there were classically trained architects in many places, fascinated by implications of new technologies and the problems and possibilities of the new industrial city. Cities and city dwellers suffered in many ways from the 1850s through the 1920s, but one thing they did not suffer from during those years was the systematic unlearning of their historic craft by architects and builders. That came later. There is a list of architects during this proto-modern period who were cosmopolitan eclectics in a way that seems appropriate as role models for contemporary urbanists. Of this list, the one who for me stands out as the most gifted and the most interesting is Otto Wagner, architect to Franz Joseph, the last Hapsburg emperor. He perhaps more than any other represented the contribution that architecture should make to urbanism and as teacher what architectural training should consist of, so that generations of architects can contribute to urbanism as the conditions of the city change. Wagner was a schooled classicist who consciously placed himself in
Development of the Quays of the Danube Canal, New Aspern Bridge, Regulation of the Stubenviertel. Otto Wagner, Sketches, Projects and Executed Buildings (London: Architectural Press, 1987).
165
16:21:08:05:08
Page 165
Page 166
DANIEL SOLOMON
competition with Michelangelo, Palladio and Bernini, without copying them directly. But he considered it his mission as an architect and as a teacher to move from classicism to a modern Nutzstil, a classically based negation of revivalism that was directed at appropriate expression of the programs and building methods of the times. He was fascinated both by the spatial order of the traditional city and the new infrastructure of the industrial city. Otto Wagner, architect to the emperor, died of starvation and influenza in 1918, seven weeks before the armistice. The collapse of the AustroHungarian Empire brought about a completely new political and economic situation in Vienna, and it was Wagner’s pupils, the Wagnerschuler, who had exactly the right skills to adapt and to build magnificently in the new Marxist/Leninist Viennese Social Democracy that emerged in the ruins. Eva Blau’s splendid book The Architecture of Red Vienna tells this amazing story. After the war, the new socialist government, controlling only the historic city center and not its surrounding countryside, had an urgent need to house a dispossessed urban proletariat. And they had to be housed quickly and economically in the midst of the remaining glories of the baroque imperial city—but in a way that celebrated their status as the backbone of the new economy and the new political regime. Who better than the Wagnerschuler to bring about this synthesis of new circumstance and the historic city? To this day, the social housing of Red Vienna is one of the glories of the world and it represents a synthesis, never equaled, of classical architectural principles, urbanism and the modern spirit. The architecture of Red Vienna put in a brief appearance in the United States. The 1920s garden apartment movement in New York reached its apogee in a series of social housing projects in the Bronx, sponsored by garment workers’ unions for their members. The planning, programming and decorative language of these enduringly beautiful buildings are straight out of Red Vienna and even today, they are some of the most livable dwellings in the city. Abruptly, however, the garden apartment movement came to an end as the high modernist form of Euro-modernism seized the American stage in the early 1930s, and we all know the rest of that story. Simultaneously the architecture of Red Vienna itself came to an even more abrupt and symbolic end in 1934 with the routing of the socialist administration and the shelling of the most famous icon of Red Vienna, Karl Marx Hof, by right-wing militias called the Heimwehr. It is significant that that the Wagnerschuler ethos was eradicated by the same cultural forces that New Urbanism is battling today. In Europe it was wiped out by neo-classicism from the left in Russia, from the right in Germany and Austria, and by the adoption of conservative vernacular in the form of Heimatstil by the political right. In America the cultural wipe-out 166
16:21:08:05:08
Page 166
Page 167
WHATEVER HAPPENED TO MODERNITY?
was at the hands of hegemonic modernism, emanating first from the new Museum of Modern Art and slightly later from Harvard. At the same time this cultural wipe-out was occurring with respect to architecture and the city, the very same attitude that the Wagnerschuler embodied was flourishing in other art forms and is still flourishing to this day in some of them. That attitude consists of a fascination with what is new and promising in the moment that one is living through and simultaneous reverence for the historical past of one’s discipline—simultaneous fidelity to the highest standards of excellence and an absence of dogma—a playful, creative eclecticism that allows one to do many things and perform in many situations. Chanel lives; Balanchine lives; cities will be better if we can live as well.
Karl Marx Hof, Vienna, Austria, designed by Karl Ehn. (Photos by Daniel Solomon.)
167
16:21:08:05:08
Page 167
Page 168
THE TOWN OF SEASIDE NEW URBANISM Designed in 1978–1983 by Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co. ANDRÉS DUANY AND ELIZABETH PLATER-ZYBERK (1986)
This essay comprises an excerpt from the presentation of the new town of Seaside at the 74th Annual A.C.S.A. Meeting in 1986, followed by an appraisal by Andrés Duany twenty-five years after its design. DESIGN
The site and the program were perceived to approximate the size and components of a small town, permitting the turning away from the methods of contemporary real estate development toward those of traditional American urbanism. To this end, the retail center is conceived as a downtown commercial district, the conference facility doubles as town hall and a portion of the recreation budget is dispersed to create small civic amenities throughout the town. Civic character is further reinforced by reserving sites for public buildings such as a chapel, a primary schoolhouse, a fire station and a post office, to be shared by adjacent communities. The program is expanded to include a service station and a workshop district. A study of towns throughout the American South indicated that a community of genuine variety and authentic character could not be generated by a single architect. Building is, therefore, given over to a multitude of designers. The public buildings are to be freely designed by architects selected for their known sympathy with the regional vernacular. The private buildings will be commissioned by the individual citizen/buyers subject to the provisions of a Master Plan and Zoning Code. These documents are intended to generate an urban environment similar to that of a small southern town of the period prior to 1940. The Code has been tested several times in university design studios and has proven workable. It is envisioned that the town of Seaside will be substantially built out in ten to fifteen years, depending on economic conditions. In designing and administering the plan and Code, D.P.Z. abdicates direct responsibility for the design of individual buildings and acts as the municipal authority.
168
16:21:08:05:08
Page 168
Page 169
THE TOWN OF SEASIDE
SITE
The site is 80 acres located in Walton County in Northwestern Florida, adjacent to the settlement of Seagrove Beach. It straddles County Road 30-A and fronts 2300 feet of beach to the south. PROGRAM
The given program calls for a new vacation resort of some 300 dwellings of different types, 100–200 units of lodging, retail and offices, a commercial center, a civic/conference facility and a recreational building. EXISTING CONDITIONS
The layout of Seaside responds to pre-existing natural and manmade conditions as follows:
• Two large gorges providing access to the beach determine the location of • • • • •
the central square and the easternmost street. The most wooded areas are preserved along the diagonal avenue and in open areas around the tennis club and city hall. High ground determines the location of the clubhouses and the small squares. A central square opens to the south, increasing the building frontage on the ocean. The existing grid of Seagrove to the east is received and extended to provide multiple access points and social continuity. The new street grid is left open to the north allowing access to the inland lake at some future time.
STREETS
The vehicular network structures the master plan. In addition to providing access to all parts of the town, it has the following characteristics:
• Geometric perfection at the center which disintegrates toward the edges
• •
as a result of circumstance, a formal organization common to most of the towns studied. A concentric layout which increases the number of buildings with an ocean view and allows a majority of the streets to terminate at the shore. The provision of on-street parking throughout, minimizing the need for parking lots and reducing vehicular speed.
WALKWAYS
The public pedestrian areas consist of walks at both sides of every street, squares at important street intersections and larger squares related to public buildings. In addition, an extensive system of footpaths through the blocks 169
16:21:08:05:08
Page 169
The public pedestrian areas consist of walks at both sides of every street, squares at important street intersections and larger squares related to public buildings. In addition, an extensive system of footpaths through the blocks makes walking more convenient than driving.
Page 170
ANDRÉS DUANY AND ELIZABETH PLATER-ZYBERK
makes walking more convenient than driving. These paths provide a secondary level of urbanism related to outbuildings at the rear of residential lots. A boardwalk along the length of the beach secures the public nature of the shoreline. PRIVATE LAND
The proportion and dimension of lots are specifically related to their intended building type. In order to provide a relatively neutral urban fabric and to facilitate marketing, many lots are standardized, but others do not avoid the idiosyncratic characteristics which generate unusual buildings that serve as landmarks. There is a gradual downsizing of residential lots toward the center of town in order to increase density. PUBLIC BUILDINGS
The major public buildings (town hall, tennis club, school and chapel) are located inland to activate those areas farthest from the shore. These buildings are bound to the central square by corresponding public spaces: the town hall is connected by a secondary square, the tennis club by a major avenue and the chapel by a market square. Pavilions at the beach termini of each north–south street belong to the residents of these streets. The southern portion of the central square will contain small public outbuildings responding in an ad hoc manner to changing needs in the early years of the town. The plans of the public buildings as shown in the drawing are hypothetical, since most have not yet been designed. Public buildings are not subject to the Code except for the provision that they be painted white, to insure public identity despite a size which is often less than that of private buildings. PRIVATE BUILDINGS
The private buildings may be houses, apartments, shops, offices, lodging or workshops. Building forms will be generated by the provisions of the Code as interpreted by many designers. Building uses are not strictly controlled as in conventional codes, but loosely determined by a conjunction of specified building form and urban location. PUBLIC SPACES
The proportions of the squares, avenues, streets and alleys at Seaside are derived from exemplary types found in the town studies. There is little possibility of unsatisfactory spatial results because nothing is invented. The variety of types is controlled by a combination of right-of-way widths of the plan and the height assignments of the Code. The variety is intended to be sufficient for residents to be oriented without resource to street signs.
170
16:21:08:05:08
Page 170
Page 171
THE TOWN OF SEASIDE
This drawing approximates how Seaside would be completed if the building envelopes were all filled to the maximum.
ZONING CODE
The Seaside Code applies to all privately owned lots. It is a highly distilled document controlling only those aspects of building form which directly affect the public realm. The Code is graphic rather than written, so that the owner/designer may understand its provisions without professional assistance and not perceive it as a tiresome obstacle to building. There are eight building types. Three are for mixed use, three are principally residential and one is for workshops. The Code employs the conventional tools of zoning but with substantial variation. Principal among these are the following:
• Variances are granted on the basis of architectural merit. • A specified minimum percentage of the lot frontage must be built out in order to maintain the spatial definition of the street.
• Picket fences are mandated for some lots with deep front yards for the same reason.
• Porches in residential districts and arcades in commercial districts must be built to a specified percentage of the frontage. This is essential to the southern town as a type, and a positive influence on the social utilization of the street.
• Outbuildings at the rear of lots are encouraged. These create a secondary
•
level of urbanism tied to the footpaths and tend to generate rental apartments dispersed within single family areas. This is intended to prevent homogeneity of age and income common to modern developments. The location of parking within the lots is specified with precision to prevent parking lots from causing discontinuities in the street frontage. 171
16:21:08:05:08
Page 171
Page 172
ANDRÉS DUANY AND ELIZABETH PLATER-ZYBERK
• Minimum and maximum heights of roofs and porches are specified to
• •
control the spatial proportion of the public spaces and to determine the degree of formal variation in streets. Towers of small footprint (200 sq. ft.) are encouraged everywhere so that even the most landlocked house may reach for a view of the sea. Boundaries between zoning types occur at mid-block rather than more conventionally along streets. This allows streets and squares to be perceived as coherent spatial entities with similar building types on all sides.
The above is excerpted from the original published in the Proceedings of the 74th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 1986.
SEASIDE AT TWENTY-FIVE (2007) Seaside is very similar to and also very different from what we thought it would be. Seaside as built is very similar physically to the plan of twenty-five years ago—perhaps more than any of our plans since. The deviations that did occur, such as the drastic proliferation of the “temporary retail” shacks on the gulf front, are not at all bad. Indeed, they are possibly better than the 172
16:21:08:05:08
Page 172
Page 173
THE TOWN OF SEASIDE
open square that we originally proposed. Also different is the Athenaeum, which was coded to be similar to Jackson Square in New Orleans, but which has emerged as a layout more akin to the lawn at the University of Virginia—it is neither better nor worse, just different. Generally, over time, as the house lots became more expensive, the building envelopes envisioned by the Code became more filled out. The early houses were smaller and articulated into pavilions; the later ones are boxier and in my opinion, conducive to better urbanism. Even the hard-to-implement parts of the plan: the live-work units, the public school, the chapel, have been achieved. Perhaps the most difficult of all, the Krier Tower, is today closer to reality than ever. Much of the outcome of today’s Seaside is due to the personality of the founders as surely as to any of the technical aspects of the plan and Code. Robert and Daryl Dans were true architectural connoisseurs and Seaside now has a series of brilliant architectural pieces that exceed the Code standards. The Rossi, Stern, Chatham, Gorlin, Mockbee, Machado-Silvetti, Hall, Berke, Massengale, Solomon and Merrill buildings (I am listing only the better known names—not just the better buildings) caused Seaside to become a kind of architectural Mecca, quite independent of the urbanism. This was not expected and it is not necessarily for the better. These may be the best buildings, but they have not necessarily led to the best urbanism. Despite the constraints of the Code, these buildings are almost always too idiosyncratic to be the background buildings that the town thrives on. Be that as it may, through their publication, they did make Seaside more visible, which raised the sales prices, which in turn permitted the better workmanship. Too bad for affordability, though. Way gone are the days of the house that I sold for less than fifty thousand dollars! Another unexpected improvement to the plan: Robert, and particularly Daryl, became great incubators of local commercial talent. Seaside has spawned scores of private businesses, some starting as humbly as a barbecue or a flea market table, now the backbone of the town center. It is a credit to the Seaside plan that it had the capacity to absorb them. Regarding capacity to grow which is essential to urbanism: we did envision that Seaside would expand to the north, and when the much bigger Watercolor came along, so influenced by Seaside that it is completely compatible, it was able to attach. So today, this little patch of provincial Florida has more first-rate architecture than anywhere else in Florida—not excluding older and larger cities. This, however, has not been Seaside’s only influence. Seaside’s inception intercepted the then-emerging development pattern of high rise coastal condominiums and row houses with the inland areas abandoned to undervalued second-rate uses and parking lots. The scars of that early disease are still visible nearby. What the Seaside model achieved is to extend the value previously confined to the waterfront in depth. This resulted in a more human and ecological pattern, and also great wealth: a wealth that has been 173
16:21:08:05:08
Page 173
Page 174
ANDRÉS DUANY AND ELIZABETH PLATER-ZYBERK
distributed not just among Robert and his siblings but broadly among realtors, restaurateurs and most hearteningly, the contractors and their craftsmen. Robert and Daryl Davis’s fanaticism gradually raised the standard of craftsmanship, proving bit by bit, over the years, that people will pay for quality design and construction. The crews with which Seaside first started its buildings could hardly hammer a nail or hang sheet-rock straight—the usual. Twenty years later the construction crews, not only at Seaside but throughout the Panhandle, have become masters unsurpassed anywhere in the U.S. This excellence has created wealth for the working people, as they charge well for it. The very latest houses at Seaside are built like ships or cabinets. This workmanship has decanted to the subsequent towns of Rosemary Beach and Alys Beach—where design and craft are, if possible, even better. That Seaside’s influence became widespread was certainly not expected. I remember hearing Leon Krier early on saying that it would be a very important project. And important it became if influence is the measure. The influence has been helped along by a much-criticized part of Seaside: that it is “not a real town”—that it is a resort and that the houses are available for rental. Yet it is precisely as a result of the rental program that hundreds of thousands of people have been able to experience what it means to live in a compact, diverse and walkable community. Living in a place is crucial to understanding urbanism; because unlike architecture, urbanism cannot be properly assessed from photographs, not even from a short visit. It requires getting up in the morning and walking out to find the coffee and bread and paper and then having the independence all day long of family members with plenty to do, then shopping for dinner and staying up, in some cases very late, at the square.
The Type III buildings (live–work townhouses) in the center of Seaside. Photo courtesy of DPZ.
174
16:21:08:05:08
Page 174
Page 175
THE TOWN OF SEASIDE
Many suburban people (developers included) have taken the experience back home and implemented what they lived and learned. This was made easier because as a resort, Seaside attempts an ideal. After all, no one displaces themselves for vacation to live as one does daily. Resorts are compelled to be better, utopian even. We continue to design them because they are the closest that we urbanists have to experimental sites. The idealism of a resort can give clarity to a concept. Seaside with sequential residents has become a propaganda machine. A full-time community of everyday living cannot be quite as effective. The criticism that Seaside is a resort we understand, but on balance I approve of its destiny as a demonstration project. Least expected was the way that Seaside took over our lives. Robert and Daryl have lived in Seaside for two decades and defined the modern role of town founders, inducing the software of society and culture as well as the hardware of buildings and infrastructure that mere developers supply. They also proved that it is better business to do one such project for thirty years than three conventional ones for ten each. This has influenced the development industry to no end. As for the planners, the whirlwind of New Urbanism has taken over our lives as well. Without Seaside we may have become architects of a different sort. We like to remember the many designers that Seaside has touched. The process of sequential building design enabled by the Code has involved scores of young architects whose careers are better for it. For us as teachers this has been particularly satisfying.
175
16:21:08:05:08
Page 175
Page 176
THE IMPACT OF IDEOLOGY ON NEW URBANISM AMERICAN TOWN PLANNING TONY SCHUMAN AND ELLIOTT SCLAR (1992)
DEMOCRACY’S CHALLENGE CITY AND REGION IN DISEQUILIBRIUM
1 Johnson, K. “Take our Poor: Angry Hartford Tells Suburbs.” The New York Times, 1, 85. February 12, 1991. 2 Moran, M. Interview on National Public Radio, Poughkeepsie, N.Y. Station. August 23, 1991.
3 Phillips, K. The Politics of Rich and Poor: Wealth and the American Electorate in the Reagan Aftermath. New York: Random House. 1990. 4 Reich, R. “Secession of the Successful.” New York Times Magazine. January 20, 1991.
5 Peterson, I. “Planned Communities are Multiplying.” The New York Times, Section 10: 1, 11. April 21, 1991.
6 Boles, D. “Reordering the Suburbs,” in Progressive Architecture, May 1989. 78–91. Kelbaugh, D. Editor. The Pedestrian Pocket Book. New York: Princeton Architectural Press. 1989. Langdon, P. “A Good Place to Live,” in The Atlantic Monthly. March, 1988. 38–60.
We may have reached the limits of development guided by market responses to the ideals of a privatized society. Accumulating evidence suggests that the ownership of a single-family detached dwelling accessed by private automobiles and situated in self-governing communities located at a safe distance from the economic and social woes of the center city is no longer economically viable for increasing numbers of people. Recently, the City Manager of Hartford, Connecticut, proposed the dispersal of inner city public housing residents to surrounding suburban communities.1 The New Jersey Supreme Court ordered municipalities to provide a “fair share” of affordable housing in their region (the Mount Laurel decisions). The former Mayor of Bridgeport, Connecticut, in filing for municipal bankruptcy protection, declared, “The system isn’t working.”2 The disequilibrium between central cities and their surrounding regions is reaching crisis proportions. It may be seen as the spatial dimension of an economic reorganization to a service economy accompanied by a decade of conservative administrations whose fiscal policies have widened the gap between rich and poor.3 While the wealthy have been able to insulate themselves from the distressed and tense urban centers—“the secession of the successful”4—the suburbs are not immune from the consequences of unplanned development. The impact of environmental destruction, pollution, congestion, and chaotically dispersed land use has raised the cost of doing business and diminished the quality of daily life. Renewed interest in more tightly planned communities from developers, design professionals, and the public at large attests to a widespread dissatisfaction with suburban sprawl.5 The Traditional Neighborhood Development advocated by architects Elizabeth Plater-Zyberk and Andrés Duany and the Pedestrian Pocket concept developed by Peter Calthorpe have received careful attention from both popular and professional journals.6 While the present regional discontent may provide a window of opportunity for comprehensive planning efforts, any optimism must be guarded. The historical record suggests that only a commonly perceived national emergency can induce Americans to challenge their deep-rooted ideological antipathy to government intervention in urban and regional development. 176
16:21:08:05:08
Page 176
Page 177
THE IMPACT OF IDEOLOGY ON AMERICAN TOWN PLANNING
This paper traces the evolution of the contradictory pulls of ideology and circumstance on American town planning from the 1909 National Conference on City Planning, where the terms of debate were first framed, to two current developments in New York City—Roosevelt Island and Battery Park City. These two projects offer competing paradigms for future urban development and exemplify a century-long ideological struggle over the role of government in guiding metropolitan development. FRAMING THE DEBATE
By the time the first National Conference on City Planning was held in Washington, D.C. in 1909, the paradigmatic debates that would characterize the profession to the present day were already well formed. While the 43 Conference participants were united in their enthusiasm for the developing “science” of city planning, their views as to the goals and mechanisms for this new field were extremely diverse. Despite general agreement that the planning function ought to shift from private civic and commercial organizations to public commissions, there was considerable disagreement about what this public role ought to be. At issue were two sets of questions. The first asked whether the discipline of planning should focus on improving the physical appearance of cities or on improving the conditions of daily life for their inhabitants. Was the goal of planning a more beautiful city or, in the words of English planner T.C. Horsfall, “a more beautiful life?”7 The second set of questions asked whether the problems of urban life were due primarily to the systemic failings of a political economy based on private investment or to the individual moral failings of the population. Those who subscribed to the latter view sought relief through building codes and zoning regulations to control the physical fabric of the city, and municipal reform to curb the political power of clubhouse machines.8 Those concerned with identifying and dealing with the under-lying systemic causes of congestion sought more drastic measures. Benjamin C. Marsh, Executive Secretary of the Committee on Congestion of Population, blamed congestion on land speculation and exploitation and insisted that these evils “must be checked by the only competent power—the government.”9 For him, planning was nothing less than “democracy’s challenge to the American city.” PLANNING IN TIME OF CRISIS INDUSTRIAL HOUSING FOR WAR WORKERS
Although even conservative housing reformers were convinced that some degree of government intervention in urban development was necessary, they believed this should go no further than modest regulation of market activity. Only a national emergency—the impact of inadequate housing 177
16:21:08:05:08
Page 177
7 N.C.C.P. (National Conference on City Planning]. Proceedings of the First National Conference on City Planning. Facsimile edition. Chicago, IL: American Society of Planning Officials. p. 77. 1909.
8 The profession of social work, which developed in parallel and overlapping step with the planning profession, had a similar split. Those who viewed the problems of the poor as moral failings advocated uplift and education. Those who viewed the problem as systemic advocated community organizing. 9 N.C.C.P. (National Conference on City Planning]. Proceedings of the First National Conference on City Planning. Facsimile edition. Chicago, IL: American Society of Planning Officials. p. 105. 1909.
Page 178
TONY SCHUMAN AND ELLIOTT SCLAR
10 Testimony by leaders such as Homer L. Ferguson, president of the Newport News Shipbuilding and Drydock Company, turned the tide. The Newport News Daily Press of March 9, 1918 carried this account of his testimony before the Senate committee investigating shipyard conditions: In his stirring appearance before the committee, Mr. Ferguson described housing conditions in Newport News as insufferable and he called for immediate action by the Government . . . [He] testified to the alarming conditions at the shipyard where, because of inadequate housing, they were unable to employ enough men for a single shift, even though the yard could and should be operating day and night to turn out the ships so urgently needed. Finally, he warned that such conditions prevailed at all the shipbuilding centers of the nation—and for the same reason. 11 United States Housing Corporation. Report of the United States Housing Corporation. Vol. I edited by James Ford. p.22. 1920. 12 Ibid., p.1. 13 Ibid., p.7. 14 Ibid., p.44.
15 May, C. “Yorkship Village: A Development for the New York Shipbuilding Corporation, Camden, N.J.” Architectural Forum, June. 1918.
conditions on industrial production during World War I—allowed the progressives a brief opportunity to expand the acceptable boundaries of government control of development. Even under this duress it took a series of dramatic appeals by representatives of private industry—shipbuilders and munitions manufacturers—to impel the government into direct provision of housing.10 On June 13, 1918, the Secretary of Labor announced the war-time production measure, stating that “The Government will build, own, control and rent the houses until after the war” (emphasis added).11 Reflecting the prevailing sentiment against permanent government involvement, the enabling legislation gave explicit instructions that “such property shall be sold as soon after the conclusion of the war as it can be advantageously done.”12 With this mandate, the U.S. Housing Corporation was created in July 1918 to implement the construction program. The magnitude of the task was impressive: housing was needed for 292,649 workers in 71 different cities or districts.13 In assuming responsibility for this undertaking, the government had no long term vision for the future of these communities beyond recouping as much of its investment as possible after the war. The planners, on the other hand, under the leadership of Town Planning Division director F.L. Olmsted, Jr., saw the program not only as an emergency measure, but as a demonstration of the potential of comprehensive town planning. They envisioned the developments as “model communities in the sense that they are being studied and will inevitably be copied by the architects and builders of the future.”14 In the planning stages this discrepancy between the planners’ expansive goals and the government’s more restricted ones posed no problem. On the contrary, the government’s overriding concern with recouping their investment and salvaging materials after the armistice led to the decision to build permanent housing of good quality rather than quick temporary shelters. Since the appropriations did not come through until August 1918, only a small part of the construction program was implemented. After the armistice on November 11, 1918, only 22 of the initially projected 83 projects were carried through to completion, with 15 more built on a curtailed basis. The quality of these projects, however, did not escape notice. A contemporary review in Architectural Forum grasped the significance of this commitment of government funds to community development: “The opportunity for the individual to live in surroundings of decency and amenity, so often denied to the man without financial backing, becomes now a matter of national policy.”15 Communities such as Fairview (in Camden, New Jersey) and Hilton (in Newport News, Virginia) along with residential districts such as those in Bridgeport CT and New Brunswick NJ remain socially and economically viable neighborhoods, often in the face of grave deterioration in surrounding areas. 178
16:21:08:05:08
Page 178
Page 179
THE IMPACT OF IDEOLOGY ON AMERICAN TOWN PLANNING
THE DEPRESSION ERA GREENBELT TOWNS
Despite continuing opposition to government intervention in the housing market, the Depression afforded progressive town planners a second opportunity to implement their broader vision of balanced regional growth. This time the economic crisis was so severe—a fourth of the work force was unemployed in 1932—that they were able to go far beyond the scope of the World War I housing projects. Funded under the Emergency Relief Appropriation Act, the program was intended first and foremost to provide construction jobs for relief workers. Between 20,000 and 30,000 workers participated in the construction of the three new towns built under the program. Greenbelt, Maryland, alone employed over 13,000.16 As in the war worker housing effort, the planners involved in the greenbelt program were interested in pursuing a broad agenda. Guiding the operation was Resettlement Administration chief Rexford Guy Tugwell, whose intellectual affinity with the Garden City ideals of Ebenezer Howard included a belief in planning as a device to implement broader social and economic restructuring of society. Tugwell’s version of the Garden City did not propose fully independent cities but rather a network of suburbs located near major cities on which they depended for employment. Other features of Howard’s “social invention” survived intact: single ownership of land, controlled land values through government ownership and leasing, the establishment of the city as an independent legal and political entity, and the greenbelt itself. In the greenbelt towns, housing was seen as only one aspect of a broader problem. By building independent self-governing cities for the poor, the R.A. confronted the more basic problem of disenfranchisement. The original greenbelt program called for construction of 19 satellite towns close to major cities. As in the earlier case of industrial housing, conservative pressure imposed limits on the scope of development. Just three of the towns were actually built—Greenbelt, Maryland, Green Hills, Ohio (outside Cincinnati), and Greendale, Wisconsin (outside Milwaukee). The R.A. retained ownership until Congress ordered divestiture following World War II, with sale preference given to snug residents and veterans groups. The greenbelt towns are frequently cited as the high point of comprehensive planning in the United States.17 Ironically, although successful government-led effort failed to launch serious regional planning movement in the United States, the lessons were not lost on the British. The greenbelt program provided the blueprint for the English postwar new town effort.18 PLANNED FAILURE: THE FEDERAL NEW TOWNS
The prosperity of the decade following World War II seemed to make the planning debate a moot issue. For the first time, home ownership appeared within reach of every working family. A suburban boom fueled by cheap oil, industrial jobs, and V.A. and F.H.A. mortgages transformed a nation of renters into a solid home-owning majority. By the mid-1960s, however, a 179
16:21:08:05:08
Page 179
16 Christensen, C. The American Garden City and the New Towns Movement. Ann Arbor, MI: U.M.I. Research Press. 1986.
17 Arnold, J. The New Deal in the Suburbs: A History of the Greenbelt Towns Program, 1935–1954. Columbus, OH: Ohio State University Press. 1971. Christensen, C. The American Garden City and the New Towns Movement. Ann Arbor, MI: U.M.I. Research Press. 1986. Stein, C. Toward New Towns for America. Cambridge, MA: M.I.T. Press. 1951. 18 Hall, P. Cities of Tomorrow: An Intellectual History of Urban Planning and Design in the Twentieth Century. London: Basil Blackwell. pp. 164–165. 1988.
Page 180
TONY SCHUMAN AND ELLIOTT SCLAR
19 H.U.D. (U.S. Dept. of Housing and Urban Development). New Communities: Problems and Potentials. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Dept. of H.U.D., 23. 1976. 20 According to a 1976 study, H.U.D. was acquiring Flower Mound (near Dallas, Texas), Jonathan (Minneapolis, Minnesota), Newfields (Dayton, Ohio), Park Forest South (Chicago, Illinois), and Riverton (Rochester, New York). Development was continuing on Harbison (Columbia, South Carolina), Maumelle (Little Rock, Arkansas), Shenandoah (Atlanta, Georgia), and Soul City (Raleigh/ Durham, North Carolina). An environmental lawsuit enjoined further development at CedarRiverside (Minneapolis, Minnesota). Gananda (Rochester, New York) was being phased out as a conventional subdivision. St. Charles, Maryland (Washington, D.C.) was continuing development but was begun as a conventional subdivision in 1964 (H.U.D. 1976). 21 H.U.D. (U.S. Dept. of Housing and Urban Development). New Communities: Problems and Potentials. Washington, D.C.: U.S. Dept. of H.U.D. p. 34, 1976.
combination of social, political, and environmental problems forced another look at the need for planning. Central cities were becoming enclaves of lower income minorities; suburbs were frustrated by the proliferation of jurisdictions; and there was growing concern for the environmental consequences of suburban sprawl. A legislative response to these concerns emerged in 1970 as Title VII of the Urban Growth and New Community Development Act. Part A of the legislation directed the President to prepare a national growth report to assist in formulating a national growth policy; part B expanded the program of loan guarantees and grant assistance for new communities, making this aid available to public as well as private developers. In 1970, President Richard Nixon, in his State of the Union message to Congress, asserted that “the Federal government must be in a position to assist in the building of new cities and the rebuilding of old ones.”19 On the surface it appeared that the Title VII program represented the culmination of a 60-year campaign for regional planning under government leadership. Here was a program to channel national growth explicitly based on the English new towns model. Yet by 1975 the program was a shambles and a moratorium was placed on Title VII contract approvals. H.U.D. had funded 13 separate projects with loan guarantees up to $50 million. Of the eight projects started under Title VII and at least partially occupied by December 1976, H.U.D. was obliged to acquire five. One was phased out as a conventional subdivision, another blocked by a lawsuit. Only the Woodlands, outside of Houston, Texas, was holding its own.20 H.U.D.’s own internal evaluation revealed that the program staff was thin on management, finance, construction, and marketing.21 As a result, H.U.D. relied on projections by the developers and their consultants with regard to regional growth rates, market share, and land valuations. Moreover, neither H.U.D. nor the Administration had formulated any national growth policy to guide the staff ’s work in selecting developers for Title VII new communities. Ironies abound in this story of a new initiative gone awry. As long as the government built new communities for purposes other than planning (e.g. emergency war worker housing, depression work relief) it employed the finest planning minds in the nation who did careful research before committing federal funds. When at last the government sponsored a planning program as such, it turned over effective control of the process to the developers themselves. In the end, despite the good intentions of the bill’s sponsors to encourage innovative and balanced development, Title VII was a pipeline of federal funds to private real estate companies whose motives were often no different from conventional land speculators. In the process, the reputation of government-assisted planning got a black eye. One arena where the federal regulations did make a notable impact was in the racial and economic integration of the federally funded new communities. Although not all projects embraced the concept with equal 180
16:21:08:05:08
Page 180
Page 181
THE IMPACT OF IDEOLOGY ON AMERICAN TOWN PLANNING
enthusiasm, the results, especially with respect to income mix, were significant.22 CONTEMPORARY PLANNING STRATEGIES: TWO MODELS
The Plan for New York City, published in 1969, described two new communities planned for Manhattan—Roosevelt Island and Battery Park City. The projects shared several important characteristics. Both involved innovative site assembly—the recycling of a derelict island in one case and the creation of landfill in the other. Both projects contained a mix of uses. The residential populations of both projects were described as a roughly even mix of low–middle- and upper-income residents.23 As built, however, the two projects could not be more different. While Roosevelt Island has held to the original intentions as a heterogeneous community, Battery Park City has become an exclusive upper-income enclave. This shift represents more than a dramatic retreat from the democratic premise of the initial proposal. Battery Park City is emblematic of the privatization of planning activity that attended the ideological shifts of the 1980s. The public authority abdicates control over land-use decisions in favor of deal-making and negotiation.24 The process is justified by the economic efficiency of the market-place. In the face of these same pressures, however, Roosevelt Island continues to pursue its original mandate. At stake are two competing views of urban life and social structure.
22 A survey which compared H.U.D. new towns with 13 non-federal communities found only 2,000 subsidized units out of 222,000 in the non-federal communities compared with 27 percent of all housing units in the Title VII projects. Moreover, the satisfaction of residents in subsidized housing in the new communities was found to be substantially higher than for residents in subsidized housing elsewhere (H.U.D. 1976, Appendix D). 23 C.P.C. (New York City Planning Commission). The Plan for New York City. New York: Dept. of City Planning. 1969.
24 Fainstein, S. “Promoting Economic Development: Urban Planning in the United States and Great Britain.” Journal of the American Planning Association. 57. 1: 22–33. 1991.
ROOSEVELT ISLAND
Occupying a narrow 147-acre strip of land in the East River between Manhattan and Queens, Roosevelt Island is a remarkable community in many respects. Many of these reside in the accomplishments of its physical plan. It is accessed by the only commercial mass transit aerial tramway in the country. Vehicular traffic has been substantially curtailed. It is the only large-scale residential project in the country with an underground garbage collection system. The island is barrier-free and provides a substantial number of units for the physically challenged. The landscaping includes 4l acres of parks and a 4½ mile pedestrian promenade at water’s edge. The provision of such recreational facilities and generous open space is not uncommon in upper-income suburbs or luxury condominiums. What is distinctive about Roosevelt Island is its ability to deliver on its original commitment to a “diverse community.” The General Development Plan written in 1969 established a precise unit break-down by income, with specific provision for the elderly and physically challenged: 30 percent lowincome; 25 percent moderate-income; 20 percent middle-income; and 25 percent market rate units.25 In addition to this income mix, Roosevelt Island has maintained an integrated racial composition, with a 23 percent minority population. Significantly, the median income for Black households on the 181
16:21:08:05:08
Page 181
25 A.K.R.F. [Allee, King, Rosen, & Fleming, Inc.]. Roosevelt Island Southtown: Final Environmental Impact Statement. New York: Roosevelt Island Operating Corp. 1990.
Page 182
TONY SCHUMAN AND ELLIOTT SCLAR
26 Ibid., C-10
27 Russo. A. Planner, Roosevelt Island Operating Corp. Personal interview. 26 August. Stein, Clarence S. 1978. Toward New Towns for America. Cambridge, MA: M.I.T. Press. 1991.
island is higher than for White ones, suggesting that the island is a residence of choice for middle-income Blacks.26 In Northtown I, the first phase of development, completed in 1977, all 2,142 units received some form of public subsidy. The low-income units were dispersed throughout a large (1,000 units) apartment complex so that only management knows which tenants require the deeper subsidy. In 1984, however, when development resumed after an interruption caused by New York’s fiscal crisis and the Urban Development Corporation’s near bankruptcy, the flow of federal funds for housing subsidies virtually dried up. The developer for the second construction phase, Northtown II, was designated because they had access to enough Section 8 rent subsidy certificates to make 20 percent of the project affordable to low-income households. While this permitted the new development to maintain its mixed income character, conventional market wisdom concentrated all the subsidized units in a single, detached building, with four other new towers devoted to luxury rental units. For the first time, low-income households were segregated by place of residence, leading to some stereotyping of “the Section 8 kids.” In response to this experience, the Roosevelt Island Operating Corporation is exploring ways to disperse the subsidized units throughout Southtown, the final phase of development.27 In the absence of federal funds, and with only modest assistance available from city and state sources, Southtown will depend on an internal cross-subsidy where low- and moderate-income units are subsidized by fees from developers of luxury apartments. Because the housing market is still mired in a deep recession, no contracts have been signed for Southtown. The present stalemate illustrates an inherent dilemma in linking the supply of “affordable” housing to the demand for luxury units. BATTERY PARK CITY
28 Deutsche, R. “Uneven Development: Public Art in New York City.” In Out of Site: A Social Criticism of Architecture, edited by Diane Ghirardo. Seattle, WA: Bay Press. 1991. 29 C.P.C. (New York City Planning Commission). The Plan for New York City. New York: Dept. of City Planning. Vol. 4.26 1969.
Battery Park City is a mixed residential and commercial development on 92 acres of landfill in the Hudson River stretching north from Battery Park at the southern tip of Manhattan. The current development plan is actually the fifth proposal for the site, and the only one whose residential component is entirely based on market rate housing. Although earlier proposals for the site also emphasized luxury housing,28 by the time the Plan for New York City was published in 1969, the housing mix had become equal thirds of low– middle- and upper-income units.29 Battery Park City got off to a slow start. The landfill was not complete until 1977, and by then the city was mired in a recession. In 1979 Richard Kahan, the newly appointed head of the Battery Park City Authority (B.P.C.A.), hired architects/urban designers Alexander Cooper and Stanton Eckstut to produce a new master plan. To convince the N.Y. State legislature to continue its support, this plan had to reconfigure the development not only in its physical dimension but in its legal framework and financing 182
16:21:08:05:08
Page 182
Page 183
THE IMPACT OF IDEOLOGY ON AMERICAN TOWN PLANNING
strategy as well. The new legal approach was to have the N.Y.S. Urban Development Corporation condemn the site and convey the title to B.P.C.A. By transferring ownership to an independent public benefit agency this maneuver exempted the project from New York’s planning and zoning regulations, and from public scrutiny as well. The economic strategy was to attract private financing by eliminating all subsidized housing, offering tax abatements, and relocating the commercial buildings to the center of the project opposite the World Trade Center. Thus the much praised physical character of the Cooper/Ekstut site plan—the reintegration of the landfill into the Manhattan grid—was as much a rediscovery of New York’s history of incremental private development of small land parcels as it was a romantic invocation of its most livable neighborhoods. The physical aspects of the plan have received a great deal of critical acclaim. The New York Times hailed it as a “triumph of urban design.”30 Writers wax enthusiastic over its public parks and promenades.31 But if the exterior spaces are indeed handsomely designed and inviting, the residential construction is less convincing in both physical and social terms. Despite the street and avenue organization of the Master Plan, Battery Park City lacks the heterogeneity of Manhattan’s culturally diverse neighborhoods like Chelsea or the Upper West Side. It has no side streets to speak of and lacks the row houses to leaven the scale of the large apartment buildings. The apartments themselves are relatively small, both in the number and size of rooms, leaving the exterior styling an empty gesture to New York’s grand old apartment buildings. Demographically, the development reflects the flat profile of the narrow stratum that benefited from the 1980s surge in the financial services sector: the new households are young, wealthy, and childless.32 There are few neighborhood services, and families with children had to organize to get a playground built. The social justification for all this private luxury in a publicly aided project is that Battery Park City spins off profits that the City uses to rehabilitate low-income housing in poor neighborhoods like the South Bronx and Harlem. Excess Battery Park City revenues are used to guarantee Housing New York bonds issued by the N.Y. State legislature. Proceeds from the first $210 million in bonds have already been applied to rehabilitate 1,850 units in the South Bronx and Harlem.33 The public/private partnership which generates funds for subsidies through market development reinforces uneven spatial development in the process. The mostly uncritical praise which Battery Park City has received for the excellence of its “public” spaces masks both the exclusion of the public from the decision-making process and the ways in which different groups are affected by the broader development process involved.
183
16:21:08:05:08
Page 183
30 Goldberger, P. “Public Space Gets a New Cachet in New York.” The New York Times. Section H, 35. May 22. 1988. 31 Gill, B. “The Skyline: Battery Park City.” The New Yorker. 20 August. 1990 Hiss, T. “At Land’s Edge, a Contentment of Light and Shape.” The New York Times. Section C, 1.18. October 19. 1990.
32 According to a 1988 tenant survey, 85 percent of the residents had incomes over $50,000 and 37 percent over $100.000. Less than 12 percent of the population was under 19 years old or over 65, and over 88 percent of the units contained only one or two people. 73 percent of the apartments are studio and one bedroom (B.P.C.A., 1988). Curiously, in two tenant surveys, the B.P.C.A. has not collected data on the racial composition of the residential population. 33 B.P.C.A. Annual Report. New York: B.P.C.A. 1988. Internal memorandum. April 6. 1987.
Page 184
TONY SCHUMAN AND ELLIOTT SCLAR
CONCLUSION
The transfer of funds from Battery Park City to the South Bronx parallels the Regional Contribution Agreements (R.C.A.s) that compromise the New Jersey M.L. Laurel decision. The R.C.A.s permit municipalities to buy their way out of 50 percent of their obligation to provide their “fair share” of low- and moderate-income housing. The result benefits willing receiver cities like Newark, Camden, and New Brunswick, but in the process reinforces the very economic and racial spatial stratification they were meant to redress. Whether manifest in the bankruptcy of Bridgeport, Connecticut, or the explosion of pent-up racial rage in the Crown Heights section of Brooklyn, New York, the spatial segregation of American society is an economic and social time bomb. The failure to develop a strong and systematic approach to town planning and hence orderly regional growth has left us with a pattern of regional development in which speculators erect scattered subdivisions for individuals who seek personal solutions to the crises of urban life by fleeing cities and segregating themselves in small, homogeneous enclaves. Although a consensus is emerging among planners and civic-minded members of the business community that more compact socially and economically mixed communities are a necessity, it is not clear that this consensus can produce a politically effective coalition. The willingness to concentrate on the aesthetic qualities of new developments regardless of their socio-economic composition dilutes the strength of this consensus. Projects such as Seaside, Florida, offer scenographic and tightly concentrated plans that exploit the social appeal of the town center. In the main, however, these new (or borrowed) town planning models do not address issues of equity. Their seductive appeal only fosters the illusion of solving problems by avoiding them. Only a public authority can assure a balanced resolution to the efficiency/ equity dilemma. Government has both the responsibility and the resources to take a long-range view of social and spatial development. Money spent after the fact to clear up the social and economic problems of sprawl and isolation does not add value to the products of America; it only slows the rate at which they deteriorate. Town planning history teaches that societies with a long-term perspective will be both more efficient and more equitable than those that choose to place ideology before experience.
This essay was originally published in the Proceedings of the 80th Annual Meeting of the Association of Collegiate Schools of Architecture, 1992. 184
16:21:08:05:08
Page 184
Page 185
NEW URBANISM AS A COUNTER-PROJECT TO POST-INDUSTRIALISM
NEW URBANISM
ELLEN DUNHAM-JONES (2000)
New Urbanism’s unusual combination of neo-traditional styling and progressive attempts at social reform has made strange bedfellows out of its liberal and conservative critics. Bashed from the left as conservative nostalgia and bashed from the right as liberal social engineering, New Urbanism has an uncanny way of attracting uncommon enemies and advocates.1 Urbanism, “new” or otherwise, is far too complex to advance purely right- or left-wing agendas, and critiques of New Urbanism that attempt to dispose of it neatly on ideological grounds tend to be grossly oversimplified. New Urbanism has been able to attract a surprisingly diverse following precisely because it cannot be easily reduced to a single agenda, as its critics claim. As a forum and a model, it merges popular, pragmatic, critical, idealistic and subversive strategies, allowing for many interpretations. I find myself attracted to New Urbanism not for its traditionalism, but for its radicalism; not for its capitulation to market forces, but for its critical defiance of them; not for its formulaic responses, but for its truly multi-disciplinary approach. I admire New Urbanism’s commitment to a political process of mobilizing and empowering communities to challenge the pattern, regulations and financing of seemingly out-of-control sprawl. Where many of my academic and architect colleagues see Luddite reactionaries resisting progress by indulging in nostalgic simulations of the past, I see committed reformers critical of the status quo debating and sharing multiple strategies and scales of alternative forms of development. In a post-industrial world dominated by the placelessness of digital media and global transactions, I see New Urbanism as a counter-project to postindustrialism. How do we determine if such a position is reactionary or revolutionary? Assuming continued advances in computer and telecommunication technologies, post-industrialism promises peace and harmony through global economic interrelationships and unlimited access to information. These, in turn, will presumably lead to abundant good equitably distributed, laborless leisure and self-determination. This view portrays the decentralized and dematerialized post-industrial world as a very progressive place.2 Architects like Frank Gehry and Bernard Tschumi make extensive use of digitally mediated design processes that expressively endorse the promise of a postindustrial future of unlimited possibilities. Similarly, Rem Koolhaas and 185
16:21:08:05:08
Page 185
1 For liberal critiques of New Urbanism, see the comments by Margaret Crawford, Detlef Mertins, Michael Hays and Michael Sorkin in the CD-ROM proceedings of Exploring (New) Urbanism, Proceedings (Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Graduate School of Design, Department of Urban Planning and Design). From the political right, see for example the on-going defense of sprawl and critiques of New Urbanism in the libertarian journal Reason. Their recent articles are summarized in “Sprawl Brawl,” Reason Online (April 8, 1999).
2 Various writers and futurists have contributed to this rosy picture: Daniel Bell, Marshall McLuhan, Alvin Toffler, George Gilder, Thomas Friedman and William Mitchell, etc.
Page 186
ELLEN DUNHAM-JONES
3 Rem Koolhaas et al., S. M. L. XL. (New York: Monacelli Press, 1995), 971.
4 From 1980 to 1990, cities with strong downtown markets retained about 40 percent of office growth, while weaker downtown markets lost up to 85 percent of office growth to their suburbs. See William C. Wheaton, “Downtowns Versus Edge Cities: Spatial Competition for Jobs in the 1990s,” Working Paper 45 (Cambridge, MA.: M.I.T. Center for Real Estate, 1993).
“Layers” from a photographic series titled “Welcome Home” exploring loneliness in new subdivisions around Atlanta, GA. (Photo by Lee Hughey.)
Peter Eisenman embrace the freedom represented by the speed, mobility and malleability of digital, nomadic, post-industrial culture. Koolhaas argues for a “lite urbanism” that ridicules traditional preoccupations with matter and substance.3 But post-industrialism has a dark side as well. The pace of innovation in digital technologies has been matched by an ever-widening income gap between rich and poor. As the economy has become more integrated globally, it has become increasingly decentralized locally. In U.S. metropolitan areas, 60 to 85 percent of real estate development during the past thirty years has occurred on suburban peripheries.4 The resulting landscape of decentralized, disconnected pockets of office parks, malls, strips, condo clusters, corporate campuses and gated communities clipped onto suburban arterials reflects the values and policies of mobile capital, the service economy, post-Fordist disposable consumerism and banking deregulation. This pattern, expanding at the periphery in ever lower densities, further exacerbates the spatial segregation of rich and poor, consumes open space, requires more and more driving and degrades air, water, land and habitat in the process. New Urbanists see the environmental and social impact of the postindustrial landscape as regressive. They have turned away from this future to promote diverse, compact, mixed-use, mixed-income, transit- and pedestrian-oriented communities. While their critique and concern for social and environmental goals may indeed be viewed as progressive (though hardly new), the prevalence of neo-traditional styling in New Urbanist projects that perpetrates the cultural dominance of traditional elites means they are generally viewed within architectural discourse as conservative. Can New Urbanism open itself more to the progressive aspects of postindustrialism? Can it recognize the positive impact of the global and the digital, and use these to induce more inclusive expressions of design, place and power? I will argue that New Urbanism’s continued development as a progressive force would benefit from a greater recognition of its role in the shift from industrial to post-industrial culture and development. Instead of providing a retreat from the post-industrial present, New Urbanism’s promise lies in creating stronger interchanges between physical neighborhoods and digital networks, in not simply countering post-industrialism but urbanizing it. NEW URBANISM VERSUS SPRAWL
During the 1970s and 1980s, while the American economy was hard at work producing sprawling beltway boomtowns and Edge Cities, architectural discourse focused on divergent theories and their associated styles while professional journals highlighted the individual buildings of star designers. New Urbanism emerged in the early 1990s as one of the few organized forums for an ongoing discussion of alternatives to conventional 186
16:21:08:05:08
Page 186
Page 187
NEW URBANISM AS A COUNTER-PROJECT TO POST-INDUSTRIALISM
suburban development. Various approaches coalesced and diverged, from reconfiguring suburban patterns into new mixed-use towns to infilling underdeveloped locations in existing cities. Some proponents were motivated more by the environmental advantages of walkability and transit-oriented development. Others were more inspired by the social benefits of the renewed emphasis on well-designed public spaces. All recognized a common enemy in the regulations and development practices that perpetuated sprawl. The movement grew as it took on the rewriting of regulations and the partnering with various agencies and disciplinary groups including the Department of Housing and Urban Development, the Environmental Protection Agency, Fannie Mae, the Urban Land Institute, the Institute of Transportation Engineers, the U.S. Green Building Council and the National Resources Defense Council. The involvement of diverse professionals focused increasing attention on the non-physical aspects of city design, such as community-building programs, affordable mortgage policies and financing structures. Initially recognized for its concern with greenfield new towns, New Urbanism has expanded its attention to urban and suburban infill, most notably through work on HOPE VI public housing projects.5 If sprawl is the post-industrial landscape of private investment, the insistent now, speed, disposability and the temporary contract, New Urbanism counters that by emphasizing that which is public, pre-existing and enduring. New Urbanism urges people to slow down, to get to know their neighbors and to become more connected with their environment. New Urbanists have proposed a now-familiar alternative pattern that recasts the isolated office parks, strip malls and subdivisions into mixed-use, walkable, transit-served districts and neighborhoods oriented around public town centers. Wide cul-de-sacs and wider arterials are replaced with gridded networks of narrow streets that calm and distribute the flow of traffic. Sidewalks, street trees and architectural codes governing the basic profile of the building front treat the space of the street as a figural public space or outdoor room. Front porches, or stoops (depending on the regional architectural history of a place), are intended to enable sociability among neighbors; the close mixing of lot sizes and building types is intended to encourage socioeconomic diversity. Densities from eight to forty dwelling units per acre are sought both as means of increasing social interaction, preserving unbuilt land and wildlife habitat, and supporting shops and transit service. This is more than an alternative template. New Urbanist developments seek to build on the existing identity of a place, rather than allowing it to be determined by ever-changing stores and short-term uses. Unique landscapes, whether streams, forests or wetlands, are preserved and made into identifying or recreational features. Regional building types, materials, landscape and planning strategies are called upon to further link the present to that which has endured in a place. Codes and covenants are intended to sustain 187
16:21:08:05:08
Page 187
5 Despite the inclusion of projects executed in a variety of styles, scales, densities and locations in books like Peter Katz’s The New Urbanism (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1994), and The Charter of the New Urbanism, Michael Leccese and Kathleen McCormick eds. (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1999), the neotraditional small town has firmly established itself as the dominant model of New Urbanism in the eye of the public, the architectural press and many C.N.U. members.
Page 188
ELLEN DUNHAM-JONES
this character, emphasizing predictability instead of post-industrial flux and changeability. STUCK IN THE PAST OR MOVING INTO THE FUTURE?
Three views of an exurban highway interchange: at the present, as it will look with current development patterns, and how it could look if reoriented around its village center and rail station. (Source: New York Regional Plan Association, 1996.)
New Urbanism arose out of its founders’ reformist impulse to improve situations through design solutions. They reject the design autonomy sought by post-structuralist theorists and neo-avant-garde designers. Instead of critiquing culture, New Urbanists engage and redesign it. Moreover, they fervently believe that design is not autonomous but synergistic: Each individual design decision matters in terms of how it triggers social, environmental and economic effects within the urban whole. This belief in the power and meaningfulness of design has helped attract many designers to the movement, myself included. It has helped to empower designers and non-designers alike to refuse to accept sprawl’s logic of autonomous development as inevitable. Instead, through the power of design, new development becomes an opportunity for radical re-imagining. From Seaside to the New York Regional Plan Association’s aerial views of conventional versus reconfigured development patterns, the early New Urbanist designs were startling precisely because they so radically broke with conventional expectations. Even more revolutionary is the New Urbanists’ willingness to work on regulatory and procedural issues in order to empower their designs and fundamentally change the rules of the game. Based on their successes with mixed-income neighborhoods, the Department of Housing and Urban Development hired the New Urbanists to write the design guidelines for the HOPE VI public housing revitalization grants—a $5 billion program aimed at deconcentrating poverty. Similar partnerships with the Environmental Protection Agency expanded the Smart Growth Network while partnerships with the Institute of Transportation Engineers, the U.S. Green Building
188
16:21:08:05:08
Page 188
Page 189
NEW URBANISM AS A COUNTER-PROJECT TO POST-INDUSTRIALISM
Council and the Natural Resources Defense Council have resulted in new street standards with greater attention to pedestrian safety and comfort, as well as the development of L.E.E.-N.D., a new system for ranking environmental benefits at the neighborhood scale. Model ordinances for Traditional Neighborhood Developments, form-based codes like the SmartCode, and comprehensive plans are inspiring policy changes across the country, most notably along the Mississippi Gulf Coast where New Urbanists were invited by the Governor to assist in planning the rebuilding after Hurricane Katrina. Often overshadowed by the architectural media’s attention to individual projects, this collective work by the Congress for the New Urbanism to reform the rules of development continues to effectively challenge the status quo. It could not have happened without the New Urbanists’ strong convictions about the need for change, the possibility of change and the viability of their alternative. Sadly, however, in fighting for change and winning over converts, New Urbanist principles have increasingly stiffened into rules. Types have become models.6 The elasticity and ingenuity of design is increasingly being sacrificed to the need for formulas, easy answers and a recognizable marketing image. There is an odd disconnect between what is exciting about the ambitious New Urbanist agenda and the places New Urbanists claim as successes. While the agenda looks forward to a world of vital neighborhoods and diverse communities, the places themselves seem increasingly frozen in a very singular image of the past; there seems to be little recognition of the value of ongoing change. Even where regional characteristics help particularize the architecture, there is a generic quality to designs that draw almost exclusively on white upper middle-class traditions, and the quiet gentility and formal civic behavior associated with them. As New Urbanism has become more successful, its designs have become more reactionary and less revolutionary. What happened to the spirit of invention and discovery that the changing of the regulations was meant to empower? Has New Urbanism become a part of the machine it set out to resist, simply another formula to replace the earlier one? New Urbanism is premised on the idea that designers armed with strong knowledge of good precedents can translate the movement’s simple principles into a masterplan and images from which to generate design codes in a relatively short time—during a seven- to ten-day charrette, for example. The expectation has been that the charrette introduces urban variety through the inclusion of many hands, and that the execution of the design by many builders over a period of time will introduce architectural variety. However, as New Urbanism moves into the mainstream, production builders and financing entities seek to undertake projects in ever larger increments. Developing in larger increments means more repetition of 189
16:21:08:05:08
Page 189
6 In his Dictionnaire of 1832, Quatremère de Quincy distinguished between the type, of which many permutations are possible, and the model, which is repeated precisely. The shift from interpretable design codes to pattern books, discussed later, exemplifies this change.
Page 190
ELLEN DUNHAM-JONES
7 There are notable exceptions. Hedgewood Properties is the developer and production builder for Vickery, a Greenfield T.N.D. in Cumming, GA, with almost no repetition of house designs and unique public spaces distinguished by their preserved trees. The result is a place with both a strong identity and surprising variety.
models, rather than development of typological variations.7 The bigger New Urbanism gets, the more it repeats itself. Seaside is an expensive resort hotel. It cannot be the poster child for New Urbanism. But, in fact, it got so many things so right. It is infused with a respect for tradition and feeling for place, but never allowed those lessons to squelch a love of design and innovation. Even though a non-coded common interest in Victorian architectural language settled into the place, it still speaks in varied voices. Akin to post-Fordist mass customization, each house riffs jazzily on familiar themes. There is a far greater balance between individual expression and a unified communal identity than in many later New Urbanist developments. Conversely, at projects like Celebration, the use of pattern books, intended to raise the quality of the work of production builders while keeping costs down, has resulted in far greater uniformity than at Seaside. Designers’ efforts to tweak, change, customize and improve the world no longer seem welcome. I worry that as New Urbanism becomes more focused on formulaic recreations of the past, it will lose its commitment to design and fall short of providing for the post-industrial future. New Urbanism needs to think more creatively about how to use new technologies to create a future that rises to its challenge of simultaneously addressing the larger scale of the region, where characteristics of the land and ecosystems might dictate broad development patterns, and the smaller scale of the neighborhood, in which varying degrees of variety and individual expression might be encouraged. GRASPING THE POST-INDUSTRIAL FUTURE
8 Some research indicates that the growth in telecommuting is expected to be greatest in people who telecommute three to four days a week and visit traditional offices on another day. These workers cannot really choose to live anywhere; they still must live within commuting distance of their workplace. New Urbanism’s stress on the availability of transit may be an especially strong attraction to this group of part-time commuters. See “Alternative Workplace Strategies,” Wharton Real Estate Review, 1:1 (Spring, 1999). William J. Mitchell predicts that the emerging wired generation will gravitate to precisely this kind of lively twenty-four-hour neighborhood. William J. Mitchell, E-topia (Cambridge, MA.: M.I.T. Press, 1999).
Perhaps New Urbanism has written off the promise of a post-industrial future too quickly. Do the digital and the global have to work against placemaking and result in decentralized, economically segregated, consumerist sprawl? Certainly not, and this is where there remains room for design innovation. Many New Urbanist developments are heavily wired and are already attracting the digerati who can choose to live anywhere. New Urbanism offers people working all day at computer screens easy opportunities to take a break from technological interfaces. People-filled places and natural habitats are a short walk away, accessible without using a car. Many of the increasing number of telecommuters are likely to embrace the social, environmental and transit possibilities of New Urbanism.8 But New Urbanism could go much further in imagining how telecommuting, computer software and digital networks might more radically reconfigure buildings, neighborhoods and regions. As sociable, local neighborhoods become overlaid with highly used global information networks they are likely to foster ever-more flexible, hybrid building types—such as new combinations of retail and 190
16:21:08:05:08
Page 190
Page 191
NEW URBANISM AS A COUNTER-PROJECT TO POST-INDUSTRIALISM
services, entertainment and education facilities, and living and working. Like the now-ubiquitous wifi-coffee shop’s successful combination of hightech and high-touch, we may soon see more organic farms incorporated into business centers. This mixing and integrating of activities is consistent with New Urbanist principles and in many cases can be easily woven into traditional neighborhoods, but it requires new approaches to flexible building design, development financing and land-use regulation. Taking full advantage of the new technology and economy requires a willingness to further adapt neotraditional typologies, even to develop new ones. For example, New Urbanists have done a better job at integrating retail and residences than workplaces and residences. More thought could be given to converting office parks into mixed-use urban neighborhoods, using skinny floorplate buildings with incubator office space in neighborhood centers, and designing live–work units that allow for the running of a small business (with dual entries, accommodation of delivery services and variously sized office suites/workshops). And just as New Urbanists think about the benefits of the corner store, they could consider providing neighborhood-based telecommuting, delivery-coordination and business support centers. While analysis of regional vernacular building materials and typologies can go a long way toward helping New Urbanists design in relation to climate and place, New Urbanists would also do well to consider the newer digital tools that allow designs to be more specifically responsive to their particular places. Innovative uses of geographical information systems, computational fluid dynamics modeling and traffic modeling programs can be used to better understand the specific wind, sun, drainage and transportation patterns of places. Such digital information can be extremely useful in designing plans and green building designs that are more place-specific and environmentally responsible.9 Some New Urbanists are already finding innovative ways to use digital technology to empower local voices in the process of design and construction. Peter Calthorpe recently posted growth scenarios for Salt Lake City on the internet and got 17,000 citizens to vote their preferences. In recent decades, many sectors of the industrial economy have employed computation to better coordinate supply and demand and produce more consumer-responsive high-quality, automated, small-batch, varied product lines. Sophisticated market monitoring and analysis enabled this kind of “mass customization” to be linked to consumer preferences. Though these techniques have been used to develop niche markets where fashion serves to differentiate consumer identity and exacerbate class and economic differences, they might also be put to the service of New Urbanism. In a small step toward “mass customization” in housing construction, Armonics, an Indianapolis-based New Urbanist architecture firm, used 191
16:21:08:05:08
Page 191
Sales Center at New Town at St. Charles, MO, a new urbanist community designed by Duany Plater-Zyberk & Co. (Photo by Steven Patterson.) 9 To help Los Angelenos establish neighborhood centers, Marc Futternan wrote a program called “Ped-GRiD” that layers information about pedestrian activities onto a G.I.S. database. Analyzing diverse data such as how many beds in a hospital, traffic counts and parks, Ped-GRiD can predict which locations will better support pedestrian activity and where community-building development should be directed. He hopes to make the technology available to individuals, who could then upload their own information to the database and conduct their own research as a form of teledemocracy. See Dan Damon, “Driven to Despair,” Guardian-Online (July 15, 1998).
Page 192
ELLEN DUNHAM-JONES
10 Since the original publication of this article, several New Urbanists have collaborated with modular and manufactured housing producers both as a means of reducing costs (such as the Katrina Cottage “starter home” designed by Marianne Cusato and sold as a kit-of-parts from Lowe’s Home Improvement Stores) and as a means of providing customizable variety within typological continuity.
digital software to expand and diversify the number of builders involved in a large housing project. They adapted “Expedition,” a program commonly used for construction management, to enable them to monitor numerous contracts (fifty-seven in all, ranging from $2,000 to $2.8 million) on a 200-unit HUD HOPE VI housing project. Many of the contractors were from the local area and consisted of one- or two-person teams. In addition to contributing a significant amount of variation in finishes and details to the completed homes, this process recirculated dollars in the community and provided opportunities for disadvantaged businesses.10 New Urbanism is not a one-size-fits-all model. It is a forum for sharing strategies about a variety of models that implement the principles of its charter. As such, the Congress of the New Urbanism is already a postindustrial information exchange. The challenge for New Urbanists is to continue seeking ways of looking not just to the past, but to the future, to open design back up to the positive, innovative and inclusive aspects of post-industrialism. New Urbanism’s critique of the destructive and regressive aspects of post-industrialism and sprawl provides the movement with tremendous strength. New Urbanism’s privileging of local places, connecting to existing conditions, face-to-face communication, communal interaction and preservation of unmediated landscapes and natural habitats, resonates especially effectively at a time when these seem threatened by post-industrial forces. However, as a counter-project to post-industrialism’s doctrine of speed, mobility and malleability, New Urbanism should be wary of being overly committed to replicating the slow, the fixed and the enduring. The more perfect the recreation of the past, the more inflexible it becomes for dealing with the future, with diversity and with less perfect neighboring conditions. New Urbanism was initially proposed as a forum for promoting democratic tolerance for difference, not a tyrannical consensus. Instead of the absolute order and lockstep conformance of perfectly unified 1970s-vintage planned urban developments, New Urbanism was premised on a somewhat looser process of incorporating multiple voices into the system, with the intent of producing more variety—albeit within strict constraints at the interface between public and private space. In confronting the realities of working with production builders’, NIMBYs’, public agencies’ and consumers’ and bankers’ expectations of predictability, New Urbanism has lost much of that original flexibility, diversity and choice. New Urbanists would benefit from remembering that there is a virtue in the inclusion of the imperfect and the unfixed; a bit of peeling paint and the occasional purple house remind us that we are not slaves to consensus and conformity. Similarly, a fervent and creative embrace of post-industrial opportunities 192
16:21:08:05:08
Page 192
Page 193
NEW URBANISM AS A COUNTER-PROJECT TO POST-INDUSTRIALISM
and tools may help New Urbanism avoid becoming a slave to consensus and conformity. Enriching the interface between neotraditional neighborhoods and the internet may provide the opportunities for New Urbanism to better connect the past with a progressive and diverse future.
This article was originally published in Places, Spring 2000, Volume 13, Number 2, and the author is grateful to the Design History Foundation for permission for republication. It has been updated with slight modifications. 193
16:21:08:05:08
Page 193
Page 194
INTEGRATING URBANISMS NEW URBANISM Growing places between New Urbanism and Post-Urbanism CARL GIOMETTI (2006)
1 Jane Jacobs, The Death and Life of Great American Cities (New York: Random House, 1969).
2 Robert Fishman, Post Urbanism vs. Re-Urbanism: Peter Eisenman vs. Barbara Littenberg and Steven Peterson, Michigan Debates on Urbanism, Vol. III (Ann Arbor, MI: The Regents of the University of Michigan, 2005).
Thinking has its strategies and tactics too, much as other forms of action have. Merely to think about cities and get somewhere, one of the main things to know is what kind of problem cities pose, for all problems cannot be thought about in the same way. Which avenues of thinking are apt to be useful and to help yield the truth depends not on how we might prefer to think about a subject, but rather on the inherent nature of the subject itself. Jane Jacobs 1 The city is the culmination of the human condition, a manifestation of utopian ideas and practical policy. The ideas guiding the city down different “avenues of thinking” are as diverse as the people who reside in them. The city has the power to absorb and reflect whatever theory is being thrust upon it. In the end, the city will evolve, sometimes for the better, sometimes not; but it will emerge fresh, ready for the next idea. New Urbanism and PostUrbanism describe current ideas of the existence of a city. This paper will outline a possible “next idea”; keeping some of the thoughts of each, while discarding those that no longer apply. The two schools of thought often appear at odds with each other; however, when treated as ingredients they actually make up a more complete idea of urbanism. The recent Michigan Debates on Urbanism created dialog among many seemingly disparate ideas of urbanisms. What always emerged, despite whatever disagreements the participants may have had, was recognition that there is no right answer to designing a city; we can only hope to ask the right questions.2 Negotiating a place between New Urbanism and Post-Urbanism may or may not lead to any new solutions, but it may raise better questions as to how we can form a more integrated urban theory. NEW URBANISM
3 Jane Jacobs, The Death And Life of Great American Cities (New York: Random House, 1969).
The most popular of the recent urban movements is New Urbanism. Its theoretical foundation relies upon creating lively neighborhoods that possess diverse styles of living. Constructed upon Jane Jacobs’s idea of “organized complexity” a city, neighborhood, or town is a complex organism consisting of interconnected parts.3 The New Urbanist theories concerning “community,” as both an idea and a physical object, have been mainstreamed into planning practice. 194
16:21:08:05:08
Page 194
Page 195
INTEGRATING URBANISMS
The practitioners of New Urbanism have expanded beyond theory and many explicit design “manuals” exist on how to execute the ideals of the New Urbanist. These manuals have shaped a multitude of plans throughout the country. Unfortunately, New Urbanist developments are typically enormous, over-planned communities with little variance in architectural or economic style. Even Peter Calthorpe, a well-known proponent of New Urbanism, questions whether New Urbanism has become a style rather than a set of open-ended principles.4 Reasons for this may arise from the difficulty of executing a project of truly spontaneous diversity. Diversity is only achievable by differentiations in several urban qualities, particularly time. Certain roles, such as lower income housing and local retail, are difficult to fulfill in new construction.5 It has proved problematic to create truly mixed-use, mixed-income developments. These sorts of purposes will be brought about by the evolution of an area, not cataclysmic creation. In order to fund new construction for the low- and middle-classes, where profit margins tend to be small, it must be executed on an enormous scale (this business model is often referred to as the Wal-Mart model). As Modernism demonstrated, large urban renewal projects are inappropriate and in conflict with ideas of neighborhood and economic growth. Therefore, New Urbanism copes with projects that are just as architecturally sterile and economically unsustainable as its Modernist predecessors were. These projects attract labels of being “nostalgic” or “old-fashioned” and disappoint those, like Peter Calthorpe and other founders of the Congress for New Urbanism, who see their ideas gone awry. A healthy city is not nostalgic. It may contain elements that represent a previous period but imitation of the past produces stagnation and devolution. From a theoretical perspective, New Urbanists seem “too ready to return to the old city.” Critics point to those such as Leon Krier for an extreme case of the historical approach to urbanism. Although Krier is a fringe element, his positions are worth noting. While they may seem absurd under most circumstances, his schemes must serve as a warning to whole-heartedly accepting historical models of urbanism. This point is the most relevant criticism for New Urbanism. Historical models are useful as lessons for the future, not determinations of it. Moreover, no lesson has been more valuable than understanding the sensitivity needed when making changes to the urban fabric, as each building serves is own particular, and often unrecognizable, purpose; and regardless of whichever period of urbanism one aligns with, a good neighborhood is a terrible thing to destroy. POST-URBANISM
If there is to be a “new urbanism” it will not be based on the twin fantasies of order and omnipotence; it will be the staging of 195
16:21:08:05:08
Page 195
4 Robert Fishman, New Urbanism: Peter Calthorpe vs. Lars Lerup, Michigan Debates on Urbanism, Vol. II (Ann Arbor, MI: The Regents of the University of Michigan, 2005). 5 Jane Jacobs, The Economy of Cities (New York: Random House, 1969).
Page 196
CARL GIOMETTI
6 Rem Koolhaas, “What Ever Happened To Urbanism?” in Theories and Manifestos of Contemporary Architecture, Charles Jenks & Karl Kropf (Chichester, West Sussex: Academy Editions, 1997). 7 Jacques Derrida, “The Decentering Event in Social Thought” in Social Theory: The Multicultural and Classic Readings, Charles Lemert (Boulder, CO: Westview Press, 1999). 8 Douglas Kelbaugh, Repairing the American Metropolis (Seattle, WA: University of Washington Press, 2002).
9 Kevin Lynch, The Image of the City (Cambridge, MA: The M.I.T. Press, 1960).
uncertainty . . . Since it is out of control, the urban is about to become a major vector of the imagination. Rem Koolhaas 6 The center is not the center. Jacques Derrida 7 If New Urbanism is looking to a city’s past for guidance, Post-Urbanism is looking beyond the present for its direction. “Post-Urbanism” is a term coined by Douglas Kelbaugh to represent those who believe that urbanism is an idea of the past or will soon become of the past.8 Unlike the term “New Urbanism” which represents specific, agreed-upon ideals, Post-Urbanism refers to a group of people practicing design around a shared philosophical foundation. He aligns the writings of Rem Koolhaas, among others, to this classification. Adjectives shared among these philosophies are disconnectedness, placelessness, and the notion that there is no context. Cities are no longer centers but a “gray” area lacking edges or boundaries. Those who fit the classification of “Post-Urbanist,” beside Koolhaas, include names such as Frank Gehry, Peter Eisenman, and Daniel Libeskind; although most seek to refrain from any association as such. They earned the moniker of being “post-” or “anti-” urban by designing buildings that act to differentiate, a sculptural reaction against the urban fabric. Armed with the philosophies of thinkers such as Jacques Derrida, their architecture exploits the loaded adjectives used repeatedly in postmodern discussion. A building is not bound by its function or its geography. There is no such thing as context, nor is there anything to be referred. This ideology is the zeitgeist mentality, the current spirit of the age. Buildings respond to technological achievements that allow people to become more connected, while removing the necessity for physical proximity. At first, it may seem difficult to discern how a design philosophy that preaches the destruction of contexts is necessary in an urban philosophy. Post-Urbanism is necessary for the creation of the unique, the departure from communal context. If New Urbanists’ developments resemble the “Wal-Mart model” of architecture, Post-Urbanists are the Gucci of architecture. Post-Urbanists are the trendsetters, the icons, and signature practitioners. Their rejection of context has given its architects incredible proficiency at creating places. Put another way, in their rejection of the ideological “centers” of architecture, they end up creating even stronger ones. Across the world, cities display the place-making effects of having a Post-Urbanist building. Bilbao, Chicago, and Los Angeles all have a Gehry building—an abstract, entirely unique piece of architecture that is used for its iconic value. These buildings are the points of reference that Kevin Lynch championed.9 The “post-urban” object, as it is described here, can be traced throughout time: it possesses permanence. It is a representation of an urban 196
16:21:08:05:08
Page 196
Page 197
INTEGRATING URBANISMS
condition at a particular point in time.10 However, like its counterpart, PostUrbanism is not without its shortcomings as well. Columbus, Indiana has long been visited for its unique array of architecture. It boasts buildings by Eero Saarinen, Harry Weese, I.M. Pei and Richard Meier, among many others. Each building stands out as an extraordinary architectural achievement. However, despite the quantity and quality of the numerous designs, the town remains architecturally stagnant, but in a rather odd way. By constructing individual pieces that each demands its own attention, the city becomes a virtual gallery of architecture, something meant only to be experienced in a certain environment, a Disneyland of architecture. Absent is any architectural contrast in quality, where Saarinen’s church might emerge and stand gracefully among a real urban fabric and truly create a place. Instead, it is engaged in a battle with every other building for dominance over the area. This conflict is akin to placing two Eiffel Towers right next to each other. In this case, it is more like placing fifty together. The over abundance of defining elements diminishes their effectiveness to a null value. To use Robert Venturi’s language “. . . the exception has become the rule.” The context of Columbus is to have no context, the Post-Urbanist dream. The absence of an urban fabric prevents the city from developing community and architecture from gaining an identity.
10 Aldo Rossi, The Architecture of the City (Cambridge, MA: The M.I.T. Press, 1982).
AN URBAN TYPOLOGY
To begin the formulation of a theoretical intermediary between these two, a language is useful to guide the dialog of the city and define roles within the urban whole. Aldo Rossi undertook the task of analytically dissecting a city and defining the role of each of its parts. He argued that the city is a collection of two principal types of architecture: dwellings and primary elements.11 The satellite picture of Paris (right) defines these two elements better than a textual definition. There is a collection of buildings and block layouts, which are all slightly similar to each other, generally describable as “ordinary.” Departures from this understood pattern are present, signified with architecture of a different scale, quality, or aesthetic. While it may seem problematic to rely on a structuralist dialect to describe the chaotic forces apparent in a city, Rossi’s system has some distinct advantages. Rossi articulated this condition: “In order to study the irrational it is necessary to take up a position as a rational observer. Otherwise, observation and eventually participation give way to disorder.”12 One of the strengths of Rossi’s idiom is that while dissecting different parts of a city into its components, the actual application of his typologies is an open-ended system. That is, the idea of dwellings and primary elements is more ephemeral than it is explicit. The syntactical structure, like a city 197
16:21:08:05:08
Page 197
Satellite image of Paris.
11 Ibid.
12 Ibid.
Page 198
CARL GIOMETTI
13 Lars Lerup, After the City (Cambridge, MA: The M.I.T. Press, 2000).
14 Ibid.
15 Jane Jacobs, The Death and Life of Great American Cities (New York: Random House, 1969).
itself, can evolve through time while still maintaining its pertinence and applicability. Dwellings are the present representation of a city, an item that is not unique but responds to the entirety of a superior structure. The dwelling builds what is to be the urban fabric. Lars Lerup employed a French word, meme, to describe the way dwellings are constructed. Meme is reproduction through imitation. He states, “Memes help affect our values. They do not exactly determine our values, but direct and constrain them.”13 It is this process by which the urban fabric is created and sustained. The values of the city are established by the vernacular and the dwellings arise out of the need to “summarize the city’s image.” The dwelling embodies the values of the culture that it houses. For example, the suburban dwelling exploits mobility and privacy, creating “American distance” between people.14 The dwelling is reliant on the whole, constructed image to fill the spaces along the street. It is a created perception of what is normal to a city. New York has its brownstones, Chicago its bungalows, San Francisco its cascading row houses. Rossi titles the second of the two principal city typologies as the primary element. The primary element is the artifact of a city, the “element(s) capable of accelerating the process of urbanization in a city.” It is a complete entity unto itself: it does not require an immediate aesthetic relation to its surroundings. In fact, primary elements are most often considered such because of their disassociation with previously established patterns. The idea of the primary element gaining its distinction by emerging from the dwelling demands a brief mention of the relational architecture. Often architecture is judged solely on its artistic achievement, its ability to dissent from the ordinary. After all, how often will a building achieve notoriety for its ability to “fit in”? This criterion limits the title of “good architecture” to that of primary elements, those buildings that depart from the context. However, the ability of a piece of architecture to satisfy its role within the urban form should be given equal, if not greater merit. Jane Jacobs first described the value of the “plain, old brick building” in terms of its socioeconomic function. It provides cheap rent, encouraging small businesses and the eventual development of an interconnected neighborhood. Old buildings are small business incubators and can be more valuable than any signature piece of architecture.15 The dwelling establishes the field from which the primary element will depart. A place cannot be unique without the ordinary. These plain buildings will never appear on the cover of architecture magazines, but a theory of urbanism that does not value the vernacular of an area is simply incomplete. Re-engaging the two presiding theories now creates a more complete picture of what is urban. New Urbanism describes the life of a dwelling, the common everyday interconnectedness that allows a city to function. The approach to understanding this condition is similar to that of Bernard 198
16:21:08:05:08
Page 198
Page 199
INTEGRATING URBANISMS
Rudofsky’s Architecture without Architects but brought to a contemporary context. Dwelling spaces are not artistic expressions; they respond to other universal ideas. The Dogon village Rudofsky studied is the result of social, economic, environmental, and a slew of other forces. The interpretation is the responsibility of the whole population. Perhaps this is a reason for New Urbanism’s widespread acceptance outside of the planning and architectural professions. It is responding to the commonly held ideals that shape the universal nature of our environment. Post-Urbanism is then sufficient to explain the primary element, the particular, artistic interpretation. It produces artifacts that will either question or celebrate the execution of the universal. This is the architect’s realm. The ability of a city to provide opportunities for the particular to emerge is incredibly important, especially when discussing the growth of a city. THE GROWTH OF A CITY’S ARCHITECTURE
The joint resolution between New Urbanism and Post-Urbanism is more than a theoretical compromise. The interplay between the two can test a city’s architectural life. The appearance of contextcreating and context-departing buildings tracks the rise and fall of an urban area. For an area to grow into a city it must have some original structure: in other words, it must have a collection of people. Upon the incorporation of a town or village, the existing structures become its dwelling. At this point the goal of the city must be to grow worthy of a primary element. While it exists in this “seedling” form, it draws architectural resources from outside areas. It does not possess the maturity to develop its own architecture. When a city begins to diversify its fabric, it earns a primary element. That is, when an aspect of its culture grows unique to that of a greater whole, a piece of architecture will be constructed to serve as an artifact, freezing that uniqueness in time.16 The evolutionary process of creating dwellings to earn new unique elements is perhaps the most explosive innovating force in the architecture of a city. However, this process is not without precedent. For some time, economists have understood this model as “import replacement.”17 For example, an area is developing an industry around the production of coasters. The local craft of making coasters is sought after worldwide. While the town is the center of the coaster-making world, it lacks industries to create drinks to place on the coasters, so must import them. Eventually, a perceptive businessman thinks that perhaps the people in this town would like to have their own glasses to place upon their world famous coasters. Therefore, he builds a shop making various glasses that work in conjunction with the coasters. His business becomes popular and the town no longer needs to import glasses to place on its coasters. It has 199
16:21:08:05:08
Page 199
16 Aldo Rossi, The Architecture of the City (Cambridge, MA: The M.I.T. Press, 1982).
17 Jane Jacobs, The Economy of Cities (New York: Random House, 1969).
Page 200
CARL GIOMETTI
18 Carl Condit, Chicago, 1910– 1929: Building, Planning, and Urban Technology (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1973).
19 Carl Condit, Chicago, 1930–70: Building, Planning, and Urban Technology (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1974).
absorbed an import, diversified its economy, and is now searching for another import. The next import could be cup holders or perhaps paper towels to clean the unfortunate spill. If this process continues and compounds, as it does in growing cities, the town will be developing new industry after new industry, perhaps even over achieving its original businesses. This growth, however, did not occur until it produced something other than its beloved coaster. The ability of a city to import new types of architectural elements into its own model and then replace it with another import is a measurement of a city’s vibrancy. Every populated area will possess its own dwellings, but its ability to depart from this context, or “original industry,” will determine its architectural achievement. Every large city has experienced this type of architectural growth during some period of prosperity. Chicago during the late 1800s and early 1900s was departing from its bungalow context more rapidly that perhaps any other city at that time.18 London, Paris, Rome, and many others all had similar periods. All, at one point, were smaller, less diverse towns that grew because they were able to create unique primary elements and then rapidly build on the strength to construct another one. Because of their role as the symbol of a culture’s pervasiveness, the creation of primary elements is also a good indicator as to the health of a city. Returning to Chicago, in the early part of the 1900s, the Loop was the center of all economic activity in the American Midwest. The city grew at incredible rates, as evidenced by the rapid construction of primary elements. Architectural imports were absorbed and replaced quickly. The Tribune Building competition gathered ideas from throughout the architectural spectrum where they battled each other for primacy on Chicago’s turf. German architect Mies van der Rohe took his ideas of Modernism to the city, and created some of the best artifacts that remain of this period. As in most cities, the growth eventually slowed, and Chicago ceased to replace its architectural imports with new ones.19 Architects began to copy each other and created memes. That is, instead of new artifacts being created, the process stalled. From this point, the city began to attempt to build the vernacular support for new unique elements. Often excluded from these histories is the role of the dwelling, the neighborhood. During this same period, Chicago was increasing in population faster than any city previously had. The influx of people demanded the expansion of the dwelling space. Immigrants of all nations stitched themselves into the urban fabric, popularly known as the American “melting pot” effect. Ethnic neighborhoods each began their own, more localized process of city vernacular. The strength of a context has a direction correlation to the amount of meaningful opportunities to depart from it.
200
16:21:08:05:08
Page 200
Page 201
INTEGRATING URBANISMS
FORMULATING STRATEGIES
Armed with the joint theories of New and Post-Urbanism, it is necessary to look how they may shape the future, not simply explain the past. Recently, few topics have received as much attention as suburbia. Cities have struggled for years to cope with the transition into becoming a region. At the time Rossi authored The Architecture of the City he set forth three scales with which to study a city. The levels were: 1 The scale of the street, including the built areas and empty spaces that surround it; 2 The scale of the district, consisting of a group of blocks with common characteristics; 3 The scale of the entire city, considered as a group of districts.20 In the present day, a fourth scale must be added:
20 Aldo Rossi, The Architecture of the City (Cambridge, MA: The M.I.T. Press, 1982).
4 The scale of the region, an area made up of a city and its subordinate areas. By adding this new level, Rossi’s hierarchical system of describing an area still pertains. Certain suburbs are dwelling areas, the bedroom communities, each imitating the other with slight variation, the meme. Others, due to some unique circumstance, become centers. Whether it is a center of retail or entertainment or whatever functions it specializes in is irrelevant. The center-suburb is the primary element for the suburban region. The individual suburb can be analyzed using the same criteria. In addition to the various social and environmental arguments, suburban development has been criticized for its lack of place. It is an endless, undulating row of strip developments and detached single-family houses. Only recently, and mostly thanks to New Urbanism, have areas such as the suburban central business district (C.B.D.) or transit-oriented development (T.O.D.) come to exist. These developments enclose areas of density and diversity in a suburban setting, a “pedestrian pocket.”21 They begin to develop street life and other urban characteristics. These developments could perhaps represent the maturity of the suburb. The suburb creates an artifact by growing a portion of city life. S