Wordsworth's Classical Undersong Education, Rhetoric and Poetic Truth
Richard W. Clancey
Copyright material from www...
31 downloads
982 Views
10MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong Education, Rhetoric and Poetic Truth
Richard W. Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
This page intentionally left blank
Education, Rhetoric and Poetic Truth Richard W. Clancey Professor of English John Carroll University Cleveland, Ohio
9& 10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
t&
First published in Great Britain 2000 by
MACMILLAN PRESS LTD Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire RG21 6XS and London Companies and representatives throughout the world A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library.
ffi
First published in the United States of America 2000 by
ST. MARTIN'S PRESS, INC., Scholarly and Reference Division, 175 Fifth Avenue, New York, N.Y. 10010 ISBN 0-312-22560-1 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Clancey, Richard W., 1928Wordsworth's classical undersong : education, rhetoric and poetic truth / Richard W. Clancey. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 0-312-22560-1 (cloth) 1. Wordsworth, William, 1770-1850-Knowledge-Literature. 2. Wordsworth, William, 1770-1850 —Knowledge —Classical philology. 3. Classical education—England —History—18th century. 4. Classicism —England —History— 19th century. 5. English poetry-Classical influences. 6. Rhetoric, Ancient. 7. Poetics. I. Title. PR5892.L5C53 1999 821'.7-dc21 99-43170 CIP
© Richard W. Clancey 2000 All rights reserved. No reproduction, copy or transmission of this publication may be made without written permission. No paragraph of this publication may be reproduced, copied or transmitted save with written permission or in accordance with the provisions of the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988, or under the terms of any licence permitting limited copying issued by the Copyright Licensing Agency, 90 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 0LP. Any person who does any unauthorised act in relation to this publication may be liable to criminal prosecution and civil claims for damages. The author has asserted his right to be identified as the author of this work in accordance with the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988. This book is printed on paper suitable for recycling and made from fully managed and sustained forest sources. 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 09 08 07 06 05 04 03 02 01 00 Printed and bound in Great Britain by Antony Rowe Ltd, Chippenham, Wiltshire
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
ISBN 0-333-76034^-
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
To my beloved teacher, Father Joseph McMahon, and to John Carroll
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
This page intentionally left blank
Acknowledgements
viii
L is t of A bbrevia tions
x
Introduction
xi
PART I: Wordsworth's Academic Training 1 Early Years
3
2 Wordsworth at Hawkshead: the Ethos of an English Grammar School
10
3 The Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake and the Hawkshead of William Wordsworth
25
4 Cambridge and 'knowledge ... sincerely sought and prized / For its own sake'
52
PART II: Wordsworth and Horace: Ethos and Poetic Truth 5 Horatian Poetics
67
6 The Mind of the Poet
87
7 The Poet's Truth
110
PART III: Classical Undersong: 'lively images', 'strong feelings', 'purest Poesy' 8 Ethos and the Power of The Prelude 9 The Poet's Calling 10 Classical Undersong, Text, 'angels stopped upon the wing'
127 150 164
Appendix: Aristotle's Ethical Proof: a Sampling of its Use in Recent Criticism
180
Notes
187
Works Cited
199
Index
208 vn 10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Contents
I would like to thank the Wordsworth Trust and especially its Chairman, Jonathan Wordsworth, and its Director, Robert Woof, for their kind help in my research, for allowing me to study Wordsworth materials in the Wordsworth Library, Grasmere, and for permission to quote from my lectures given at various Wordsworth Winter Schools. Here also I acknowledge my debt to Sylvia and the late Richard Wordsworth. It was through their kindness and encouragement that I was able to begin my research on Wordsworth's education. I thank the Governors of Hawkshead School for permission to study the contents of the school library and documents connected with the school's history, and for me to use my photograph of Hawkshead Grammar School on the jacket of this book, and especially I am indebted to John West, curator of the school, for his generous kindness in helping me with my research. Thanks are due to the Cumbria County Archives, Kendal, and especially its archivist Sheila MacPherson, for much assistance and allowing me to study the Hawkshead School materials in their keeping; Eileen Jay and the Armitt Trust, and its onetime Director, John Gavin, for their assistance and for allowing me to study the T. W. Thompson papers in their keeping; the Lancashire County Archives, especially its Archivist, Bruce Jackson, MA, DAA, for permission to study Hawkshead School materials and for permission especially to study the last will of the Revd William Taylor (document reference WRW/F 1786); Cambridge University Library, especially E. S. Leedham-Green, Assistant Keeper, the Archives, for allowing me to study manuscripts and other materials connected with the history of Cambridge University; the Master, Fellows and Scholars of St John's College, Cambridge, in permitting me the use of their archives, particularly for allowing me to quote vm 10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Acknowledgements
from the St John's College Order Book: especially I would like to thank Malcolm Underwood, Archivist, for all his kind assistance in my research; the Master, Fellows and Scholars of Emmanuel College, Cambridge, for allowing me the use of their archives, and especially Dr Frank Stubbings, onetime Keeper of Rare Books, for all his assistance in my research; and the staff of the Grasselli Library, John Carroll University, and especially Ruth Reider, for all their assistance. I am grateful to Pamela Tabor for typing the first version of the manuscript and for her excellent editorial assistance, and to Jane and John Panza for typing the final version and, in turn, for their excellent editorial assistance. Special thanks are due to my chairperson, Jeanne Colleran, for her very helpful reading of my manuscript and for all her generous support in making this book possible. I also thank my colleagues George Bilgere and John McBratney for their very helpful reading of my manuscript and their excellent advice, and Bruce Graver of Providence College for his very careful reading of my manuscript and for his very helpful advice. I offer special thanks to the Administration of John Carroll University for its generosity in awarding me a George Grauel Faculty Fellowship and for all its generous support over a number of years enabling me to complete this book. Especially I would like to thank Dr David La Guardia, Associate Provost of John Carroll University, my former chairperson, without whose patience and continued kind help this book would never have seen the light of day. Especially, I must thank Mary Wedd, onetime Principal Lecturer in English, Goldsmith's College, University of London, and Duncan Wu, Reader in English, University of Glasgow, for their inspiration, kindness and generous help in making this book possible. Finally, I would like to thank Harvard University Press for its permission to quote from its edition of the Loeb Classical Library text and translations of Horace's Satires, Epistles and Ars Poetica; W. J. B. Owen for permission to quote from the three-volume edition of The Prose Works of William Wordsworth, edited by him and J. W. Smyser; and Cornell University Press for its permission to quote from The FourteenBook Prelude, edited by W. J. B. Owen. Full bibliographical details for these editions are given in the list of works cited at the end of this book.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Acknowledgements ix
AP
DNB EY, MY, LY
14-Bk NP
Prose
PW
TWT
WC
Horace. Ars Poetica. Loeb Classical Library: Satires, Epistles and Ars Poetica. Trans. H. Rushton Fairclough. Rev. edn Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press, 1929. Dictionary of National Biography. The Letters of William and Dorothy Wordsworth. The Early Years, The Middle Years, The Later Years. Ed. Ernest de Selincourt. 2nd edn rev. Chester L. Shaver, Mary Moorman and Alan G. Hill. Oxford: Clarendon, 1967-82. Wordsworth, William. The Fourteen-Book 'Prelude'. Ed. W. J. B. Owen. Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1985. Jonathan Wordsworth, M. H. Abrams, and Stephen Gill, eds. The Prelude: 1799, 1805, 1850. By William Wordsworth. New York: Norton, 1979. The Prose Works of William Wordsworth. Ed. W. J. B. Owen and Jane Worthington Smyser. 3 vols. Oxford: Clarendon, 1974. The Poetical Works of William Wordsworth. Ed. Ernest de Selincourt. Rev. Helen Darbishire. 5 vols. Oxford: Clarendon, 1952-63. Thompson, T. W. Wordsworth's Hawkshead. Ed. with Introduction, Notes, and Appendixes by Robert Woof. London: Oxford University Press, 1970. The Wordsworth Circle.
x 10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
List of Abbreviations
This study began in a schoolhouse, in an almost ancient classroom about 27 feet long and 15 feet wide. At one end is a fireplace and the raised desk of the schoolmaster; at the other, on the wall near the corner, a crudely painted list of the schoolmasters going back to the sixteenth century. I sat at one of the narrow desks near the spot where 'W Wordsworth' had been dug into the wood. Other desk tops had been deeply scored by similar carvings. I stared at the white walls, listened as a young Oxford graduate articulately explained the history of the school. Hundreds and hundreds of boys had passed through this schoolhouse. William Wordsworth spent eight years here. I wondered about this school, its teachers, its students, and especially its curriculum of Latin, Greek and mathematics. I wondered especially about how much this school and its teaching had affected a lively, talented lad who was to become one of England's greatest poets, a poet whose special genius was so particularly indebted to his earliest years, a poet whose youth had become the substance of some of the finest poetry in the English language. As I speculated about Hawkshead School and its possible effects on William Wordsworth, I resolved to do this study. Since that decision I have come to find how intriguing research into the early years of a writer can be. Usually, much information is simply not available. But in Wordsworth's case, undoubtedly because his youth is the source of so much of his poetry, that is not the case. There have been especially good biographies of Wordsworth by Emile Legouis, G. W. Meyer and Mary Moorman, covering the general character of his youth in detail. There are also Mark Reed's splendid volumes Wordsworth: the Chronology of the Early Years, 1770-1799 and Wordsworth: the Chronology of the Middle Years, 1800-1815, meticulously accounting XI
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Introduction
for everything in Wordsworth's life during this period. The Cornell Wordsworth editions have also been of enormous help, as has been the biography of Wordsworth by Stephen Gill, a work reflecting so well its author's intimate knowledge of the Wordsworth manuscripts. Alan Liu, Wordsworth: the Sense of History, and Kenneth Johnston, The Hidden Wordsworth, provide us with a wealth of detail, and John Mahoney, William Wordsworth: a Poetic Life, illustrates how much poet and text are one. I should also mention Bruce Graver's work on Wordsworth's translations and the work of Duncan Wu, a complete critical edition of Wordsworth's juvenilia done as a doctoral dissertation at Oxford, and his excellent volumes Wordsworth's Reading 1770-1799 and Wordsworth's Reading 1800-1815. In addition to these, there are two valuable related volumes, Ben Ross Schneider's Wordsworth's Cambridge Education and T. W. Thompson's Wordsworth's Hawkshead, edited by Robert Woof, who has added extensive appendixes on Hawkshead School and library. Morris Marples has given us a general survey of the secondary education of six romantic poets and a fine discussion of Wordsworth at Hawkshead (15-47). My intent has been to complement these works. One may question the value of yet another study in this area, but my concern is with that schoolroom, with what happened within those walls, with the teachers who taught there, with their traditional and seemingly narrow curriculum, and especially with their mode of classical instruction. One cannot help but wonder how Wordsworth related to so much structure, for in the years when he was occupied in that schoolroom, he was also abroad in the mountains immediately outside. One cannot help but think of the boy who is described so vividly under a very different kind of tutelage: Oh! when I have hung Above the Raven's nest, by knots of grass And half-inch fissures in the slippery rock But ill-sustained; and almost (so it seemed) Suspended by the blast that blew amain, With what strange utterance did the loud dry wind Blow through my ears! the sky seemed not a sky Of earth, and with what motion moved the clouds! {Prelude 1.330-39)1
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
xii Introduction
What teacher's voice could ever compete with 'the loud dry wind'; what text could hold the eyes of a youth who, as though suspended, free, had seen the sky and moving clouds as Wordsworth had? How could algebra or Euclid, declensions or conditional sentences, poetic figures or the pomposities of classical oratory ever contain Wordsworth's imagination? He was 'the infant Babe', he the child, 'creator and receiver both, / Working but in alliance with the works / Which it beholds' (2.232, 259-61). Wordsworth himself had claimed that at Cambridge he 'was not for that hour, / Nor for that place' (3.81-2). Wordsworth's disaffection with Cambridge cost him a fellowship, deprived him of a secure future, and changed his life. Did this disaffection begin in that rural schoolroom? And yet it was at Hawkshead that Wordsworth truly became a poet. With deep affection he tells us in Book 10 of The Prelude that he began to write poetry at the urging of his beloved teacher William Taylor: This faithful Guide . . . He loved the Poets, and if now alive Would have loved me, as One not destitute Of promise, nor belying the kind hope That he had formed, when I, at his command, Began to spin with toil my earliest Songs. (541-56) By 1787, when Wordsworth left Hawkshead for Cambridge, he had written not just some good schoolboy verse, but - as Paul Sheats has shown so well - some good poetry. Still, the question naturally arises: did Wordsworth become a poet completely outside of or perhaps even despite Hawkshead? As an American, I was always tempted to read Tom Sawyer into the William Wordsworth of this period. Book 5 of The Prelude seems to invite such an association. There Wordsworth satirizes those educators who attempted to make prodigies of ordinary children through elaborate and unnatural educational means. His purpose is simply to emphasize his own natural education. He was never 'force-fed'. He was never trammeled by ideologies or constraints. He was free; he was educated by and for Nature: This Verse is dedicate to Nature's self And things that teach as Nature teaches: then
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Introduction xiii
xiv Introduction
Oh! where had been the Man, the Poet where, Where had we been, we two, beloved Friend? If in the season of unperilous choice,
(232-40)
The question then arises, did Hawkshead, particularly in its classical-literary tuition, 'teach as Nature teaches'? Answering this question is one of the major goals of this book. It is a crucial question. Practically no poet has built so much of his poetry out of his experiences in youth. How much of a positive element was Wordsworth's Hawkshead education in those experiences? Furthermore, Ben Ross Schneider shows that Wordsworth was disaffected with Cambridge for philosophical and political reasons, and also for specifically literary reasons (40). At Cambridge the major emphasis was placed on mathematics even though classical and literary studies did remain a part of the undergraduate curriculum. But the point is that Wordsworth's basic, formal literary training was achieved at Hawkshead, though at Cambridge Wordsworth continued his formal study of the classics. In addition, particularly under William Taylor and then under Thomas Bowman, his successor, Wordsworth was encouraged and enabled to read much contemporary poetry. Thus Wordsworth's education was not just classical, but broadly literary as well. A study of Wordsworth's juvenilia reveals that at Hawkshead he worked hard at what must be called extracurricular classical translations. Serious Latin translation was begun at Hawkshead. There Wordsworth did his first extended piece of poetry, 'The Vale of Esthwaite'. When Wordsworth moved on to Cambridge, the classical translations and the original composition continued in much the same pattern as at Hawkshead. As will be shown later, Wordsworth's teachers and tutors, because of those close ties between Hawkshead and St John's, enabled Wordsworth's classical and literary studies to form one process, one coherent curriculum that Wordsworth followed in addition to his official Cambridge studies. Also, Wordsworth's own creative poetic endeavor in these Hawkshead-Cambridge years reveals change but also coherence, as Paul Sheats has shown (Making W. Poetry 1-59). Thus the foundation and essential fabric of
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
We had been followed, hourly watched, - and noosed [?]
Wordsworth's early poetic achievement developed organically from his Hawkshead classical education, though also influenced by British poetry, much from the eighteenth century. With these issues in mind, I studied the nature and influence of Wordsworth's Hawkshead training. I came upon a number of primary sources dealing with the history of the school and detailing the academic backgrounds of Wordsworth's schoolmasters. I have been particularly helped through the good offices and kindnesses of Dr Frank Stubbings of Emmanuel College, Cambridge. Through Dr Stubbings I have been able to study the manuscripts containing the lectures of William Bennet, Bishop of Cloyne, who in the 1770s lectured on the classics at Emmanuel and very possibly taught Wordsworth's teacher William Taylor. Also, through the generous help of Mr Malcolm Underwood, Archivist of St John's College, Cambridge, and Dr E. S. Leedham-Green, Cambridge University Archivist, I have been able to study the records which substantially reveal the classical curriculum at Cambridge and at St John's College in the time of James Peake, Wordsworth's first schoolmaster, and in Wordsworth's time as well. In reconstructing Wordsworth's classical education at Hawkshead, I have found that - for its day and age - it was both excellent and practically unique. Generally it had a standard eighteenth-century English grammar-school curriculum, but Wordsworth's Hawkshead training was truly enlightened. Furthermore, there was a renewed zeal in classical study at St John's in Wordsworth's time. Thus the character and potential influence of Wordsworth's total classical education have proved much more significant than one might expect. As will be shown in detail below, Wordsworth's teachers were talented and ahead of their time. His first major schoolmaster, James Peake, came to Hawkshead in 1766, eager and fully equipped through his own education to reform the school. Peake was educated at Manchester Grammar School, at that time recently and creatively improved. He had studied classics and mathematics at St John's College, Cambridge, Wordsworth's future college. Under a new president at St John's, the curriculum and spirit of classical studies had been enhanced while Peake was finishing his degree. William Taylor, who profoundly affected Wordsworth, was a student of Peake's at Hawkshead, a fellow of Emmanuel College, Cambridge, and an honors graduate. He too had excellent classical training and a love of eighteenth-century poetry. His was a directly creative influence on Wordsworth. It must be remembered that
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Introduction xv
Hawkshead, and St John's as well, and James Peake and William Taylor, and lastly Thomas Bowman, were all committed to the classics as the mode of humanistic and literary education. But there was clearly something unique in the way Wordsworth learned the classics and was formed to literature by them. On the surface the content and the authors studied in Wordsworth's classical training were highly traditional. A classical education was heavily rhetorical. Oratory, Demosthenes, Cicero, et al., were at the heart of the curriculum. The other genres studied - epic, drama, history, literary epistles, moral essays - all had a powerful rhetorical cast. The goal of such an education from ancient times through the Middle Ages, Renaissance and eighteenth century was rhetorical as well. Students were trained for the law, the church, public service. The classics indirectly served banking, trade and commerce. Also the very essence of classical education, the trivium, the arts of the word, grammar, rhetoric and logic, had subsumed literature and poetry to grammar and rhetoric. Poetry was prominent in medieval and Renaissance schools but always studied with grammar and as a handmaid to rhetoric. Wordsworth was trained in standard classical authors. He does not appear to have studied drama, but he began Demosthenes in Greek at 16 (TWT 91). But there is something very different in the way he was taught, in the academic goals set for him especially at Hawkshead. The structure of his education, as will be seen shortly, was free of so many artificial shackles which typically encumbered classical education. Furthermore, there must have been a great personalism in his education, a respect for expressivism and subjectivity even when the rhetorical dimensions of his education are fully accounted for. Epic must have been emphasized and the ethical resonance of the poet's voice seems to have been regarded as special. Stephen Gill's assessment of Wordsworth as a 'visionary poet' has relevance here: Too little attention has been paid to the imperious, self-willed Wordsworth, who wanted to be recognized as an intellectual power, (vii) From his Hawkshead years Wordsworth seems clearly to have derived a sense of vocation and a sense of election to that vocation. Again Stephen Gill is most helpful. Further on we shall consider Gill's eloquent tribute to Wordsworth's Hawkshead education; here we
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
xvi Introduction
should note that he offers an explanation of Wordsworth's poetic selfconfidence, of how his vocational conviction shaped The Prelude (2-7). I would urge that the firmness of Wordsworth's personal conviction about his calling and his attachment to The Prelude in all its epic accoutrements were nurtured by a distinctive classical education that privileged epic and ethos. Much of Wordsworth's personalism and romanticism can be traced to the classical sources in his education as well. The prophetic and the ethical are especially decisive here. The popular tradition sees Wordsworth as a revolutionary. Ben Ross Schneider emphasizes his revolt against the snobbery and stultification of Cambridge, academic, political and otherwise. It may thus seem heretical to claim Wordsworth as a classically rhetorical poet no matter what the uniqueness of his classical education. But as Schneider himself shows so well, using Wordsworth's study of Cicero's De Officiis, it was from such classical writers as Cicero that Wordsworth derived some of his most advanced ideas (72-6). For Schneider, to understand Wordsworth as a revolutionary romantic, one must first see his reaction against the narrowness, arrogance and cruelty of late-eighteenth-century Cambridge: 'Wordsworth's revolt in 1788 against Cambridge foreshadows, parallels, and helps to explain his revolt in 1798 against eighteenth-century culture' (17). But Schneider also points out that the classics are not to be identified with the Cambridge view of the human condition or the nature of art or life: The Roman writers first influenced and then supported his [Wordsworth's] conclusion that the good life was the one conducted in harmony with nature herself, not merely in harmony with nature's mechanical laws. ... Tacitus' noble savages, Horace's and Juvenal's longing for the country life, Virgil's description of it in the Georgics and Thomson's imitation of Virgil, all contributed to Wordsworth's conclusion. (246) These comments are somewhat different from remarks Schneider makes earlier when speaking of Wordsworth's study of Horace's Ars Poetica and Literary Epistle: 'In these works he made his first acquaintance with those eighteenth-century critical principles he was later to violate so deliberately and successfully' (12). Schneider would seem to suggest that Horace's classical critical doctrine is identical with eighteenth-century neoclassical critical doctrine. Such an attitude is so common that it deserves comment. I wish this study to emphasize the
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Introduction xvii
significant difference between classical critical doctrine and eighteenth-century neoclassicism. Recent eighteenth-century scholarship has abundantly demonstrated that eighteenth-century literary theory itself is hardly a rigid formalism ostensibly derived in toto from the study of the classics, especially from Horace. James Engell's Forming the Critical Mind (1989) is a penetrating treatment of the substantial variety in eighteenth-century critical thought. As was noted above, recent scholarship on Horace, especially the work of C. O. Brink, shows how much richer this great Latin lyricist is than some scholars of the eighteenth century would seem to allow. Thus in claiming Wordsworth to be a classically rhetorical poet, I do not suggest any kind of crypto-conservatism in Wordsworth; nor do I wish to invite a deconstructive analysis exhibiting an intrinsic contradiction in his essential romanticism. Wordsworth is surely the premier romantic poet as Meyer Abrarns has so famously demonstrated (Mirror 100-3). However, Wordsworth is both classical and romantic - expressive and lyrical and also rhetorical. Very simply, Wordsworth is a highly committed poet with profound epic aspirations. Here his classicism, especially in its rhetorical dimensions, emerges. As Abrarns has shown so well in Natural Supernaturalism, Wordsworth's ultimate design and goal are prophetic (11-80). He is ever the lyric poet, yet running through practically the entire fabric of his poetry is a real, though frequently muted, anxiety for relation beyond the immediate utterance. Wordsworth sought to imitate and outdo his hero Milton. Wordsworth's ultimate encompassing endeavor was a prophetic poem, The Recluse, capable of embracing intentionally and architecturally all of his poetry. Not every Wordsworth poem promises or insinuates such affiliation, but so many do bespeak a relationship to a great tradition of vatic utterance that such implication and hankering are major features of a significant part of Wordsworth's poetry. The Prelude is a promise, a completed declaration and a demonstration of Wordsworth's goal to be poet and prophet. 2 Wordsworth may well have abandoned any attempt to complete The Recluse by the time of the 1836 edition of his poetry, the first done after Coleridge's death in 1834. It may very well be true that he abandoned The Recluse because he found he simply could not do it; it lay beyond his abilities (Home at Grasmere, ed. Beth Darlington, Introduction, 31). But he never repudiated his vatic intention as such. No record so far shows he repented of his Miltonic ambition. The goal Wordsworth proposes to Coleridge remained a cherished ideal:
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
xviii Introduction
Prophets of Nature, we to them will speak A lasting inspiration, sanctified By reason, blest by faith: what we have loved Others will love, and we will teach them how, Instruct them how the mind of Man becomes A thousand times more beautiful than the earth On which he dwells. ... (Prelude 14.446-52) What could be broader in scope? The major part of Wordsworth's poetry, whether narrative or lyric, reflects this zealous spirited endeavor. But there is an added feature connected with this epic-like goal, its personalist, subjective, even lyrical aspect: 'we to them will speak / A lasting inspiration.' '[W]hat we have loved / Others will love, and we will teach them how, ...' Here Wordsworth as voice and as person projects himself as an epic model. To achieve this goal, he needs more than the ordinary resources of an epic narrator. He must prove himself to be a worthy protagonist and hero in what Abrams has identified as 'the distinctive Romantic genre of the Bildungsgeschichte', or the account of a secularized 'conversion and redemption' and 'selfformation', a narrative 'which culminates in a stage of self-coherence, self-awareness, and assured power that is its own reward' (Nat. Supernat. 96). This goal requires exceptional rhetorical skill to validate the authority of the voice and the claim of exemplary worth in the voice's experiences. The Bildungsgeschichte lays a double burden on the voice. The story of religious conversion, for example, derives its worth ultimately from the presumed value of the faith experience and its enclosing theodicy. But as Abrams points out in his discussion of 'Wordsworth's Program for Poetry' (Nat. Supernat. 21-32), Wordsworth differs from Milton, goes beyond theodicy, and strives 'to outdo Milton's Christian story'. Wordsworth seeks nothing less than 'to create out of the world of all of us ... a new world which is the equivalent of paradise' (28). One need not agree with all the details of Abrams' secular reading of Wordsworth's intentions, but it is clear that Wordsworth's validating norms must derive from largely novel and clearly subjectivist elements. Furthermore, when the epic goal is to be verified in the narrator as such, then the narrator's burden of self-validation is particularly onerous.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Introduction xix
The popularity of Wordsworth's poetry, especially The Prelude, strongly demonstrates Wordsworth's success in this endeavor. It is my contention that this success can be explained by our having recourse to Aristotle's Rhetoric and its discussion of what Aristotle calls the ethical proof, the means whereby the authority of the rhetorical voice is established by its demonstration from the very text itself that it is knowledgeable, honest, and generously disposed to its audience. Aristotle was the first rhetorical theoretician to delineate the triadic relation of these components and to insist that the ethical proof be established clearly in the text. 3 I hope to show that the grandeur, beauty and success of Wordsworth's poetry, particularly The Prelude, benefitted handsomely from his enlightened classical education which inspired the development of his powerful rhetorical ethos as described by Aristotle. The clear presence of these key Aristotelian values is a credit to Wordsworth himself and certainly to a large degree to the classical texts he studied and to the way he was taught them. Klaus Dockhorn ('Wordsworth und die rhetorische Tradition in England', recently translated by Heidi Saur-Stull) was a pioneer scholar of Wordsworth and classical rhetoric. Recent scholarship has shown a strong classical-rhetorical presence in Wordsworth (Bialostosky, Graver, Ginsberg, and so forth). J. Douglas Kneale has devoted an entire volume to Wordsworth's rhetoric, Monumental Writing, and two recent articles to Wordsworth's use of the classical figures of apostrophe and chiasmus. In an article on Wordsworth's sophisticated use of voice in Book 10 of The Prelude, Brooke Hopkins shows Wordsworth's skillful deployment of such devices as 'asyndeton', 'synathroesmus', 'polysyndeton', and 'anaphora' (291). Wordsworth's purpose, as he 'impersonates and sometimes even parodies his earlier self, is to render 'a kind of judgment on the naivete, not to say blindness, of his previous confidence in "History"' (289). Hopkins is concerned with Wordsworth's subtle use of voice. But typical of much in this line of criticism, her convincing study could easily be paralleled with a joint consideration of the ethical dimensions of the powers of voice displayed by Wordsworth. I wish to consider Wordsworth's use of the Aristotelian ethical proof. It is not just one dimension of his artistic achievement; it is at its core. Wordsworth's education in a special way endowed this core. Because Wordsworth's program for poetry is so personal, so ethically charged, he had to do The Prelude, and yet paradoxically it did not need to be published in his lifetime. It was always there.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
xx Introduction
Wordsworth became a recognized bard of epic stature despite vicious criticism; he became poet laureate and achieved a fame second only to Shakespeare and Milton; and all the while his great Prelude lay unpublished. It could be argued that never was a poet's fame achieved so fully while his greatest poetic achievement lay embosomed in his consciousness awaiting posthumous publication. But The Prelude was always a sustaining source of strength for Wordsworth. It was his chief poetic proof of ethical stature, the moral ground of his poetic vocation and being. Geoffrey Hartman reminds us that The Prelude always enjoyed a secret life and yet an efficacious presence in and among the works and designs of Wordsworth. I would suggest that, though The Prelude lay unpublished, it always existed high in Wordsworth's consciousness and thus demanded of him an almost constant affectionate tinkering. His lofty intention and the supervening creative power of that intention also reigned high in Wordsworth's creative consciousness. The fervor of this inclusive zeal is the chief fruit of Wordsworth's education and the essence of Wordsworth's classicism. Because Wordsworth is so ingeniously subtle in the way he maintains and modulates this supervening prophetic intention, I have characterized its operative presence as a major component in Wordsworth's classical undersong. The Oxford English Dictionary defines undersong in this way: 1. A subordinate or subdued song or strain, esp. one serving as an accompaniment or burden to another. Freq. transf. of natural sounds 2. fig. An underlying meaning; an undertone. I find the figurative sense of this term to be true for most of Wordsworth's poetry. Geoffrey Hartman and Edwin Stein would seem to use the term similarly. Reflecting on Herbert Lindenberger's discussion of Wordsworth's use of the many voices in English poetry, Stein notes: Wordsworth also evoked those voices in a greater variety of ways than anyone else had done. ... There were many stops on the allusive instrument he used, and it produced borrowed tones of different quality and depth: As the thematic voice changed, so did the undersong. (1)
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Introduction xxi
Hartman comments similarly, but more to our purpose; he identifies the classical burden directly in Wordsworth's undersong. In a study of Wordsworth's 'A LITTLE onward lend thy guiding hand' (PW 4: 92-4), Hartman discusses the extensive Miltonic (Samson Agonistes) and classical (Oedipus at Colonus, Sophocles) foundations of the poem (Unremarkable 91). We find in this essay a model for the study of the operative presence of the classical in Wordsworth. Speaking of Wordsworth's revived interest in the classics in 1801, Hartman notes: Interpreters have commented adequately on the poet's return to Nature or memories of childhood and somewhat on his return to the writers of Reformation England. Equally remarkable is his regression, after 1801, to the Classics. It begins with a renewed interest in the poets of the Reformation, who were also poets of the Renaissance - who managed, that is, to revive the Classics as well as Scripture. (Unremarkable 93) Further on, Hartman states, 'Wordsworth's movement toward the Classics is virtually as daring as his movement toward childhood' (93). Finally, in his conclusion, Hartman says: The life of Wordsworth's lines is often uneasy and as if somewhere else: still to be manifested by the action of time or the utterance of future readers. ... Keeping The Prelude in reserve, almost like God his own Son, Wordsworth reposed on a text-experience whose life remained with God. He delayed becoming the author of a poem so original that it could not be accommodated to known forms of Christianity. In what he does publish, then, the relation of author to poem is often the strangest mixture of knowingness and childlikeness - it is, in short, a divine idiocy. The intertextual glitter of Milton, his blended might of Scripture and Classical lore, is but an undersong to Wordsworth's intratextual strain that repeats something already begotten in himself. (116; emphasis mine) What is striking in Hartman's commentary is the way the classics are one element in the rich texture of Wordsworth's poetry, and yet an element multivalent in its relations both in a particular office to Wordsworth as poet and as a referential embodiment and coalescing force for a number of other elements. Thus in and through the classics, Hartman discusses Milton, the Renaissance, Scripture, childhood,
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
xxii Introduction
and even the intratextual dynamics of Wordsworth's own expression. I do not mean to read into Hartman's commentary a privileging of the classics as the dominant source or influence in Wordsworth. I simply suggest that the classics stand out as the relational constant resonating in a richly orchestrated texture of sources and creative procedures. The accessible accommodation of the classics in these various relationships and the constancy of the classics as an ideal mode of expression, yet also as a comparative mode to be superseded at times, as in the Reformation by Scripture, illustrate the value of the classics. They operate as a common poetica franca, a common currency of poetic expression, and yet also in their grander moments as a norm of regal stature. The operative presence and normative value of the classics are a constant in Wordsworth, especially perceived in his overarching prophetic intention. This presence is what I call classical undersong. Its primary component is an epic-like design grounded in the classical tradition and immediately exemplified by Milton. But this design requires an artistic courage and correspondingly secure sense of authority. Here the Aristotelian ethical proof serves Wordsworth well. It endowed his voice rhetorically and lyrically and helped engender the goal Wordsworth envisioned and never actually ceased to work for. But the full dynamic of Wordsworth's classical undersong is realized not merely in his need for ethos, but in his prophetic goal for us. The one need feeds the other in Wordsworth. His ultimate intention is to rouse us 'to noble raptures', to the achievement with nature of a new 'creation' (Prose 3: 8). Wordsworth's goal is democratic. He urges us to realize our potential for poetic vision, our ethos for poetic creation. His prophetic goal in our behalf and his zeal for the achievement of that goal had their start in the classical training he received at the Free Grammar School at Hawkshead.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Introduction xxiii
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
This page intentionally left blank
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Parti Wordsworth's Academic Training
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
This page intentionally left blank
1
Very early in his Autobiographical Memoranda, Wordsworth recounts the death of his parents. In the second paragraph he speaks of his mother's death in 1778. He then discusses his father who never recovered his usual cheerfulness of mind after this loss, and died when I was in my fourteenth year, a schoolboy, just returned from Hawkshead, whither I had been sent with my elder brother Richard, in my ninth year. (Prose 3: 371) From the age of 14 Wordsworth was an orphan, and this fact probably weighed more heavily upon him - even throughout his life - than either he or anyone has ever guessed. It is impressive that losing his parents rose so quickly to mind when at 77 he began to dictate the recollections of his life. Wordsworth's biographers consistently point out that his parents and almost all the major influences on his early life were affective and affirming.1 But Gill warns us that there were dark moments. The professional demands made on his father were severe and possibly caused the Wordsworth children to spend extended periods with relatives (Life 15). Wordsworth reflects upon one of these dark moments, as he admits to having an obdurate nature as a boy. In his Memoranda he recounts an incident when he wantonly tore into a family portrait at his grandparents' home in Penrith. He speaks of being punished and then comments: But possibly, from some want of judgment in punishments inflicted, I had become perverse and obstinate in defying chastisement, and rather proud of it than otherwise. (Prose 3: 372) 3
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Early Years
4
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
The cause of this was, that I was of a stiff, moody, and violent temper; so much so that I remember going once into the attics of my grandfather's house at Penrith, upon some indignity having been put upon me, with an intention of destroying myself with one of the foils which I knew was kept there. I took the foil in hand, but my heart failed. (Prose 3: 372) Despite his nature, Wordsworth's relationship with his parents was affectionate and strong. The image in The Prelude of his mother as guiding her children, not dominating them, of her lovingly allowing them as full a freedom as children can sustain, stands out as one of the poem's great portraits: Behold the Parent Hen amid her Brood, Though fledged and feathered and well-pleased to part And straggle from her presence, still a Brood, And she herself from the maternal bond Still undischarged; yet doth she little more Than move with them in tenderness and love, A centre to the circle which they make; (5.248-54) The terms 'centre' and 'circle' form the perfect image of the world his parents created, an environment in which especially his mother instructed him by love, example, tolerance and wisdom. Moorman suggests that Wordsworth's mother taught him to read (1: 15). She also formed his conscience. The child Wordsworth complained of not having received an expected penny for going to church. '"Oh," said she, recanting her praises, "if that was your motive, you were very properly disappointed"' (qtd in Auto. Mem., Prose 3: 371-2). His father opened his extensive library to Wordsworth as a boy. His father, according to Moorman, cared for English poetry, and it was he who taught his son William to learn by heart 'large portions of Shakespeare, Milton and Spenser.' His library was at his sons' disposal at all times, and William - the most voracious reader in the family - soon found in
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
He also admits that his disposition caused his mother anxiety. He was the only one of her five children whose future worried her:
Early Years 5
Moorman implicitly outlines the character of Wordsworth's father as teacher and the manner of Wordsworth's learning under his aegis. She notes how preoccupied John Wordsworth was with the Lowther affairs, but as one reads her account, one finds it easy to imagine even this busy father as a learned influence on his sons. If William had to memorize poetry extensively, John Wordsworth must have heard him recite at least some of that poetry. He and his library were a center to which Wordsworth returned. John Wordsworth was free with his books and tolerant in the way his son could use them. At Penrith Wordsworth attended a dame school run by Mrs Ann Birkett, where he studied with Mary Hutchinson, his future wife. They read the Bible and memorized passages (Moorman 1: 15). They also used The Spectator as a text for reading. Wu quotes a Dove Cottage manuscript recording Mary Wordsworth's comments about The Spectator as a reader: '"What would our modern Teachers say, to the Spectator being used by Children under 8 years of age? - But this old Lady tho' no bad Teacher, was indifferent to method" (D.C.Ms 167 36v; her emphasis)', (Wds Reading 1770-1799 131). In the Memoirs Christopher Wordsworth comments that 'tradition reports' that Ann Birkett was concerned with 'exercising the memory, without prematurely taxing the reasoning powers, of her young pupils' (1: 33; emphasis his). He then immediately comments that Wordsworth approved of her insistent training of the memory. Wordsworth also attended for a time a grammar school in Cockermouth conducted not too successfully by a Rev. Mr Gilbanks. Though not an impressive teacher, Gilbanks apparently was neither taxing nor severe (Gill, Life 16-17; Moorman 1: 15). There were classical texts of John Wordsworth available to William before he went away to school, but he undoubtedly did not begin the serious reading of Latin, as we shall shortly see, until he went to Hawkshead in 1789. Wu discusses what is apparently one volume of Cicero, containing orations, De Officiis, De Senectute and De Amicitia. Though not used till the Wordsworth boys were at Hawkshead, it was still part of their father's library and a part of their father's image as a learned man (Wu, Wds Reading 1770-1799 28-9; for a discussion of a Nepos, see 105. See Graver, 'Wu's Reading' 2-3, for further information on the Cicero).
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Fielding's novels, Gil Bias, Don Quixote, and Gulliver a world of endless delight opened up to him. (WW 1: 9; quotations from Memoirs 1: 34)
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Gill adds an eloquent note to the catalogue of Wordsworth's preHawkshead teaching influences. Gill discusses Wordsworth's 'The Sparrow's Nest', with its great tribute to Dorothy, '"She gave me eyes, she gave me ears; / And humble cares, and delicate fears; / A heart ... And love, and thought, and joy"' (Life 17). He cautions us that Wordsworth came to a full realization of the power of Dorothy's influence only after many years, but 'their mutual affection was the one absolute good he remembered from his Cockermouth years' (Life 17). Christopher Wordsworth in the Memoirs also comments similarly on this poem and on the great blessing Dorothy was to his uncle: 'Her loving tenderness and sweetness produced a most beneficial effect on his character', all the more important because of '[t]he contrast between the temper of the brother and sister ...' (1: 34). What stands out in all these pedagogical influences is the way in which in their best features they complement the loving and wise training of Wordsworth's parents, especially the genial nurturing of his mother. We do not usually regard the 'Blest the infant Babe' passage of The Prelude (2.232-89) as an academically geared educational text as such. But if we notice his mother's attendance to him and his easy, trusting response, we see more than maternal bonding. An entire schema of affective cognition and bracing self-confidence shows itself in Wordsworth. From being held in her arms he developed a vantage-point absolutely imperial in its scope. Speaking of himself, he claims: For him, in one dear Presence, there exists A virtue which irradiates and exalts Objects through widest intercourse of sense. (2.239-41) There are several interesting differences between the earlier and later versions of this section of The Prelude. Jonathan Wordsworth in his notes observes that when the deletion from the 1805 and the additions to the 1850 are accounted for, we find that [t]he child's power and creativity are thus reduced ... and his responses have been sentimentalized. The result is a more credible baby, but a weakened statement of Wordsworth's intuition of strength drawn from the child-mother relationship. (NP 81)
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
6
Even when these differences are allowed, we still have a child whose relationship to nature and the world has been fundamentally shaped by its being nurtured by its mother, especially through the emotive force in that nurturing. The following are from the additions made to the later versions, additions found in the Fourteen-Book Prelude: Is there a flower to which he [the child] points with hand Too weak to gather it, already love Drawn from love's purest earthly fount for him Hath beautified that flower; already shades Of pity cast from inward tenderness Do fall around him upon aught that bears Unsightly marks of violence or harm. (2.246-52) The emotive texture of the passage is marked by the dramatic contrast between 'flower', 'hand / Too weak', 'love's purest earthly fount', 'pity ... tenderness', and then 'violence'. Wordsworth is very much in the school of the heart. Thus when the child so schooled by its mother becomes 'creator and receiver both, / Working but in alliance with the works / Which it beholds' (259-61), the child reciprocally nurtured - becomes reciprocally creative and thus is 'like an Agent of the one great Mind' (258). The child learns a power of creativity socially conditioned and emotively sensitized because its own entire process of maturation has been not isolated at all but grounded in a dynamic of loving affirmation and reconfirmation. Wordsworth's whole educational formation is the product of care without threatening concern. The process initiated in his mother's arms, at her knee, among his father's books, in his presence and shadow, all bespeak a reciprocally and affectively conducted tutelage which evoked a creativity because the tutelage was as tolerant as it was firm and tender. When Wordsworth speaks of his going to Hawkshead and describes the essential character of the total educational process there, he does so in much the same language he has employed in speaking of his education at home in Cockermouth: Fair seed-time had my soul, and I grew up Fostered alike by beauty and by fear;
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Early Years 7
8 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
(1.301-6) It is a 'seed-time', not a dominative regimen to which he must submit. He is '[f]ostered alike by beauty and by fear', an interesting contrast between the external made internal, 'beauty', and the emotive-internal, 'fear'. He is 'favoured' and is 'transplanted' to a 'beloved Vale'. Thus he is cherished and caringly handled, but is 'transplanted' - the botanic image correlative to 'seed-time' - and is controlled, but controlled in an emphatically nurturing and nondominating order. So it is that he and his brothers were 'let loose / For sports of wider range'. The pattern is set which will be repeated again and again. Like his parents, the educative forces in his life are loving, exemplary, tolerant and wisely firm, directive but cherishingly so. The parental-familial model is also imagistically reflected in Book 5, which deals explicitly with education and which - as we have seen appropriately contains Wordsworth's eloquent tribute to his mother: 'My honored Mother, she who was the heart / And hinge of all our learnings and our loves ...' (259-60). In the same book, in his fervid indictment of mechanistic education, we find a similarly domesticfamilial nurturing reference. In the strangulation of forced learning, nature is forgotten. The opposing imagery describing a kindly nature is eloquent: Meanwhile old Grandame Earth is grieved to find The play-things which her love designed for him Unthought of: in their woodland beds the flowers Weep, and the river sides are all forlorn. (339-42) One of the most interesting discussions of Book 5 and of the issue of Wordsworth and education is to be found in Richardson's Literature, Education, and Romanticism: Reading as Social Practice 1780-1832 (see 122-6 for his treatment of Book 5). As we shall see, the whole of Wordsworth's education is characterized in similarly familial and affective imagery. His academic education and even his years at Cambridge are seen in this way.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Much favoured in my birth-place, and no less In that beloved Vale to which erelong We were transplanted - there were we let loose For sports of wider range.
Wordsworth also recounts his relationship to the classics, the way they were taught him and his characteristic regard for them and use of them, in this kind of imagery. In all of these commentaries he is impressively consistent. The way he was educated at Hawkshead and paradoxically to an important degree the way he was allowed to learn at Cambridge also reflect the teaching process begun by his parents. Ultimately that process of affection, model tolerance and wisdom will prove a fundamental guide to our understanding of the full ethical dimension of his poetry and critical doctrine and the way his classical undersong enriches his work. There is an honesty, a self-effacing candor in Wordsworth's treatment of himself. Often when he is acerbic in his critical arguments, he frequently steps back, conceding he may be pushing his views too strongly, but even his expressions of self-assurance emerge in contexts where he is open, detailed, admitting of his faults. We readily see that his convictions arise not from solipsistic self-regard, but from patterns of experience, wisely disciplined and challenged by the pedagogical force of those whom he loved and who clearly loved him. From every quarter, not just Nature, a pattern of beauty and fear emerged, urging him always not only to the frankness of confession but also to a simultaneous ideal of objectivity, the truth of the palpably real. In all of this learning process a social force and a social goal constantly exert themselves and draw him on. Even when Wordsworth speaks most cherishingly of the 'mind of Man ... / In beauty exalted ... / Of quality and fabric more divine' (14. 450-6), he does so to Coleridge as part of a program to serve humanity. Thus honesty, truth and audience-concern become ethical goals not simply informing his argument, but goals which are of the substantial fabric of his motives, ideals and loftiest expression.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Early Years 9
Wordsworth at Hawkshead: the Ethos of an English Grammar School
Wordsworth is eminently a poet of place and has brought Hawkshead and its environs close to us in some of the most vivid poetry in our language. The Free Grammar School at Hawkshead was both a major institution in a particular locale and a major example of one of the most important cultural institutions in the West, the English classical grammar school. Because Hawkshead School had been revitalized not long before Wordsworth's coming, both its ancient character and renewed academic discipline stimulated Wordsworth as a student. Later on he would say of his years at Cambridge that he felt 'a strangeness in the mind, / A feeling that I was not for that hour, / Nor for that place' (14-Bk 3.80-2). In contrast, of the summer before taking his degree, he speaks of France and really himself also as though both were 'standing on the top of golden hours' (6.341). But if ever there were a place and an hour aureate in their beauty and forever present to him, that place and that hour were at Hawkshead when he was a boy. Much of the character, curriculum, and even methodology of the ancient English grammar school survives today, but there is also much that has been lost. Just to imagine the academic routine of a school whose absolutely dominating regimen was the teaching of the classical languages is a challenge for us. Even where today the classics are taught with genius and enthusiasm, our overall curricula tend to be broad and frequently conflicting. A half-dozen subjects jostle for a student's attention. Then it was mainly the classical languages; usually they alone took up, I would estimate, routinely at least 70 per cent of the time and energy of most students. 2 Wordsworth himself shows us that he had a very definite opinion on the specialized nature of the English grammar school. In a letter to 10 10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
2
the Rev. H. J. Rose of Cambridge University, in January of 1829, Wordsworth complains of what he regards as serious contemporary problems in education. He is concerned with what he feels is a lack of proper philosophical and religious grounding in such institutions as the nonsectarian infant school, the University of London, and the Mechanics' Institutes. He then describes the kind of school which he regards as having an authentic philosophical and religious basis, the Edwardian and Elizabethan grammar school: If we look back upon the progress of things in this country since the Reformation, we shall find that instruction has never been severed from moral influences and purposes, and the natural action of circumstances, in the way that is now attempted. Our forefathers established, in abundance, free grammar schools; but for a distinctly understood religious purpose. They were designed to provide against a relapse of the nation into Popery, by diffusing a knowledge of the languages in which the Scriptures are written, so that a sufficient number might be aware how small a portion of the popish belief had a foundation in Holy Writ. (LY II: 23) We notice immediately that Wordsworth in speaking of the grammar schools does not speak of the classics, that is, classical literature, history or philosophy, but only of the classical languages as these pertain to the study of the Scriptures. We also notice that Wordsworth claims a pragmatic, indeed an apologetic or rhetorical purpose for grammar schools. Wordsworth's description reflects one of the major motives investing the Anglican grammar school. For us his emphasis on language as the means whereby a religious goal is to be achieved is especially interesting. Wordsworth reminds us that the grammar school was not necessarily committed to the teaching of classical literature or cultures; its goal was a truly linguistic mastery of the classical languages. Such a linguistic goal characterized grammar schools very often even when a religious purpose was not primary. The Renaissance classical school in Europe generally taught Latin and Greek, both for the mastery of those languages and for the sake of relishing the literatures of Greece and Rome. But even the Renaissance classical school had a significantly heavy commitment to linguistic and compositional goals. It is not always easy to determine if indeed the Renaissance school maintained an appropriate balance between the study of the classical languages and classical literature. The fervid
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The 'Ethos' of an English Grammar School 11
enthusiasm in the Renaissance for writing in a truly classical style complicates the issue.3 As Wordsworth notes, the English Tudor grammar school had a significantly religious cast. But the history of the English grammar school goes back to medieval times and to a degree can be traced to ancient Rome. It is worth pausing over that history. It tells us much about Hawkshead Grammar School and it helps us understand Wordsworth's experience with and attitude toward classical learning. The father of the history of education in England, Arthur Francis Leach, in volume 1 of Early Yorkshire Schools, a work devoted to the ancient grammar schools of York, Beverley and Ripon, begins by quoting himself and thus also quoting what has turned out to be one of the great statements concerning English academic history. The statement makes a claim about what at one time was thought to be England's oldest school, St Peter's in York: 'Such an institution is older than the House of Commons, older than the Universities, older than the Lord Mayor, older than the House of Lords, older even than the throne or the nation itself. Such an institution exists in the "School of the Cathedral Church of the Blessed St. Peter of York, commonly called St. Peter's School."' (vii) In our text (1898), Leach goes on to explain that the above claim (1892) for St Peter's in York as England's oldest grammar school must be set aside in favor of Canterbury School, whose founding his researches show to have been 'from 621, and, by fair inference, from the days of Augustine' (viii). It is possible to trace the history of the English grammar school back through the Middle Ages to the classical schools of rhetoric in ancient Rome, whose character was definitively established by Quintilian (C.35-C.100). One of the great historians of English classical education, Foster Watson, considers the connection more nominal than real (Old Schools 7-8). For Watson, however, the crucial moment in educational history came near the time Charlemagne was crowned Holy Roman Emperor (800). It was he at about this time who established his Palace School and invited the great Alcuin of York to be 'schoolmaster in what was the pioneer Court School' (Old Schools 1). What is especially significant for Watson is that the curriculum in this school contained 'subjects' not for religious goals, but 'because of their bearing upon social and individual culture' and because they 'were independent of the ecclesiastical colouring' (1).
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
12 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
A recent scholar does not see the secularization of Carolingian education as so easily achieved. Charles Jones, writing on 'Bede's Place in Medieval Schools', and having studied the use of Bede's manuscripts as school texts in the ninth century, sees very little difference in what the monks enlisted by Charlemagne taught within the monasteries to student monks and what they taught in monastic or cathedral schools open to externs: So the theocrats Pepin and Charles were quite satisfied with the Jarrow curriculum and imposed it by fiat. After all, were not the militia Christi and the militia Caroli marching together towards the New Jerusalem? (271; emphasis his) It is worth noting, even in our brief consideration of the history of the English grammar school, that its connection with both church and state, with practical and even professional training, and at times with pious endeavor has frequently dominated the grammar school in its various forms all through its long history in the West (Watson, Old Schools 1-2). Watson also notes that grammar was crucial in the Carolingian court school and was strenuously insisted upon by Charlemagne as he enlisted abbots and bishops 'requiring them to attend rigorously to the spread of the "study of letters'" (2). Watson points out that in the Middle Ages and down into the Renaissance, the seven liberal arts were taught, the emphasis in the grammar school being on the trivium: grammar, dialectic (logic) and rhetoric. But Watson notes that there was not necessarily that much classical literature taught, nor even grammar. Because the instruction was oral and because the disputation method was so popular even for professional studies, the study of literature and even grammar largely was sacrificed to the study of dialectic (5-8). It should also be recalled that the use of Latin was essential in every profession and even in commerce. The grammar schools were successful from a practical perspective, so much so that many a schoolmaster was more accomplished in Latin than in his native language (9-10). With the Renaissance and with the development of printing, the whole nature of grammar school instruction became much more literary, linguistic and sophisticated (12-23). In England, however, the Reformation brought a severe dislocation and much irreparable damage to grammar schools throughout the country. Following the dissolution of the monasteries (1536 and 1539) and with the
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The 'Ethos' of an English Grammar School 13
Chantries Acts of 1546-48, large numbers of grammar schools connected with these institutions were suppressed. In theory new educational foundations were to be made and some were, and some grammar schools were simply refounded; Eton and Winchester were handled by special provisions. Still, many grammar schools were lost to English education (Old Schools 26-39). During the reign of Mary Tudor a number of the English clergy went into exile on the continent and most were influenced by Calvin and his followers. Upon the accession of Queen Elizabeth I (1558) they returned and some founded grammar schools. Two prominent Marian exiles who eventually became archbishops under Elizabeth are of concern to us. Edmund Grindal, upon his return, became master of Pembroke Hall, Cambridge, and in 1575 he became Archbishop of Canterbury. Grindal founded and endowed a free grammar school in St Bees in what was then Cumberland. The school is not far either from Cockermouth or Hawkshead (Old Schools 51-6). It is worth pausing to consider the statutes laid down for St Bees School by Grindal. They are detailed and reflect the religious dedication of so many Anglican clerics exiled during Queen Mary's reign. His statutes are most explicit about religious instruction and prayer and about the study of Greek. Neither of these elements is as such exceptional in grammar-school statutes, but Grindal has a degree of fervor and explicitness about both which is somewhat rare. But most interesting for us is the declaration in Chapter 6 in his Statutes and Ordinances in which he describes the nature and purpose of the languages and the classical works to be studied in his school: He [the schoolmaster] shall chiefly labour to make his Scholars profit in the Latin and Greek Grammar, and to the end they may the better profit therein he shall exercise them in the best Authors in both Tongues that are meet for their Capacity. Provided always, that the first Books of Construction that they shall read either in Latin or Greek shall be the smaller Catechisms set forth by public Authority for that purpose in the said Tongues which we will they shall learn by heart, that with the knowledge of the Tongues they may also learn their Duty towards God and Man. These Books only shall be read in the said School except it shall be otherwise appointed hereafter by those that have Authority. (St. Bees Statutes 9-10) 4 Next follows a reading list for the school which includes the
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
14 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Catechism, Psalter, Book of Common Prayer, the New Testament, all to be studied in English, then the Latin grammar, then a list of 16 authors, Cicero figuring the most prominently because five of his works (rather standard) are named. There are the major Latin writers like Sallust, Julius Caesar, Terence, Virgil, Horace and Ovid. There are also some non-classical authors, such as Christian writers from late classical times, Prudentius for example, and Renaissance Christian writers like Mantuan and Buchanan (10). Also one finds Grindal's comments on Greek interesting. The Greek grammar of Cleonard is specifically required. Beyond this requirement the master is left to choose any Greek author he may wish. This suggests a minimal and linguistic cast to Greek study (11). A final instruction tells the schoolmaster that he may use these authors and works as he sees fit, but he must include study of the accidence and the grammar and the Catechism for each form. Finally he is to be vigilant that the students are not to possess 'lewd or supersticious Books or Ballads' (11). There are several items here of special interest as we look at the history of the English grammar school. It is important to notice the insistence from the beginning that students shall study grammar and, therefore, that this may be done, the schoolmaster shall 'exercise them in the best Authors in both Tongues that are meet for their Capacity'. We are reminded of Wordsworth's linguistic-apologetic definition of a grammar school given in his letter to H. J. Rose in January of 1829 (above, p. 11). Clearly in both Grindal's view and Wordsworth's understanding what mattered was first the mastering of the classical languages. And that this might be achieved, according to Grindal, authors are to be chosen who are 'meet' for the students' capacity. Obviously a grammar school in this view is not essentially literary but linguistic. It is helpful to recall that biblical study per se may not require a sophisticated reading of the classics, but classical learning is crucial for Patristic commentary. Grindal does not say that the classical languages are to be studied so that Anglicanism can be defended, but he does say that the students are to learn their 'Catechisms... by heart' in Latin and Greek and 'that with the knowledge of the[se] Tongues they may also learn their Duty towards God and Man'. Grindal is almost as direct in naming the religious purpose of a grammar school as Wordsworth. But the Elizabethan-Stuart grammar school simply repeats, though perhaps with more linguistic intensity, the religious character very possibly
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The 'Ethos' of an English Grammar School 15
already established in the clerical-court grammar schools from the time of Charlemagne. As long as Latin was a universal language and with the intense study of Latin and Greek encouraged by the Renaissance and Reformation, the grammar school would continue to be religious and linguistic. Classical style and Biblical Greek simply intensified a long-established pattern. Grindal's statutes are also important because they give classical status to non-classical writers such as Prudentius, Mantuan, and Buchanan. They are recommended for their classical style and decency of content. John Colet, Dean of St Paul's and founder of St Paul's School (1509), recommends Prudentius and Mantuan and others for the same reason (Watson, En. Gram. Schools 373-5). What are of concern immediately to these clergymen are both style and content, but the fact that style is so important even with clergymen tells us how much style alone mattered. Colet is quite explicit when speaking of the authors to be studied at St Paul's: T wolde they were taught all way in good literature, with laten and greke, and good auctors suych as haue the veray Romayne eliquence joined with wisdome, specially Cristyn auctours that wrote theyre wysdome with clene & chast laten other in verse or in prose, for my entent is by thys scole specially to incresse knowlege and worshipping of god & oure lorde Crist Jesus & good Cristen lyff and maners in the children.' (qtd in Watson 373-4) It is not surprising that a cleric, even before the Reformation, would have so explicit a religious purpose in establishing a school. What does surprise us is the way that purpose is tied to classical style: 'veray Romayne eliquence' and 'with clene & chast laten'. What also interests us is that the writers chosen by both Colet and Grindal are important not necessarily only because of definite religious content. Some of the writers are religious per se, but some are not. For example, Prudentius (348-410), an attorney, judge and official in the Roman imperial court, was famous for much religious poetry. George Buchanan, classical tutor to James VI, wrote Latin poetry but his general Latin output is not that extensively religious. Lactantius (c. 240-c. 320), named by Colet, was regarded as the Christian Cicero and his extant work is mainly apologetically religious in character.5 Mantuan, Johannes Baptista Spagnolo (1448-1516), friar and humanist, was famous for his Eclogues, a mainly secular work. Holofernes in Love's Labour's Lost (IV.ii.95) has made Mantuan a part of our immediate literary
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
16 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
consciousness. Mantuan's content was suitable for students, and he was a fine Latin poet (Watson, En. Gram. Schools 302-3, 375-6). What counted, then, was not so much that these writers be explicitly religious - Watson calls Mantuan 'safe' (376); what counted was a decency of content and classical style. Ultimately style made the classical writer, not position in history or Greco-Roman cultural commitment. Again Watson expresses the situation very well as he describes Colet's position on authors: the founder of the great classical school of St. Paul's was anxious to combine the advantages of classical style, if possible, with Christian subject-matter. Cicero was not suggested, for he was a heathen; but the Ciceronian style should be induced through reading Lactantius. Vergil should not be studied directly, for he too was not a Christian, but the Vergilian style should be inculcated through Prudentius, Sedulius, and Proba. (375) Colet and Grindal are major sixteenth-century clerical voices. They are followed in the seventeenth century by Puritan educators whose religious concern was intense. The seventeenth century was the age when, according to Watson, 'the English Grammar Schools were most flourishing,' but 'they subserved a practical national aim' (Old Schools v). Puritan schoolmasters were not necessarily dedicated to 'the teaching of the classics per se'; they wanted the grammar schools to be dedicated to 'the intensive study of the Scriptures' and the formation of a true 'pietas literata' (v; emphasis his): The dominating aim of education at that time and for the next generation was, in the words of Professor Patten, 'the visualisation' of the old theocratic dispensation of the Hebrews. Undoubtedly the 'holy languages' helped the general aim; and the classical aspects of those languages 'were added unto them,' sometimes very effectively; often, it must be added, with much searching of heart, (v) That dedicated clergymen and zealous Puritans would turn classical study to particularly religious and linguistic purposes, as we have noted, is not surprising. What does amaze us is the capacity of pagan classical authors to survive and be revered in this heady religious context. Milton's education, as we shall see, in Colet's own school, is certainly religious but very comprehensive in its use of the great heathen classics.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The 'Ethos' of an English Grammar School 17
The similarity between Colet's educational goals without Cicero and Grindal's goals with him is clear. The classical canon could be manipulated by them and others, but somehow the same great figures generally emerge because they were the masters of classical expression. Qualities of text created the canon, not credentials based on history or philosophy or culture. It seems effete to value so highly the 'mere' capacities of expression that they constitute what is claimed to be the truly 'classical'. But it is the classical style which is the constant element. Comenius and others in the seventeenth century could so decry the reading of pagan writers that they called for new texts whereby classical languages and expression could be mastered (Watson, En. Gram. Schools 535), but as Watson also points out such an exclusivist attitude was not usually characteristic of 'cultured Puritans'; they maintained the general theory that Latin, Greek and Hebrew were the 'holy' languages, which especially enabled the pupil to get a closer acquaintance with the Bible, and with the earlier times of the Christian Church [As they read the pagan classics,] pupils were duly enjoined to remember their own responsibility in living in an age in which religion had illuminated their life and transcended the possibilities of the authors whom they had to read for the sake of their language and style. (536) Puritan writers like the ancient Christians and the ascetics of the Middle Ages could protest the sensuality of the Greco-Roman body of literature, but it survived. Allegory eased it through the monastic curriculum and the qualities of language, their Biblical-linguistic significance, eased the conscience of the Puritans. But relishing the qualities of text one way or another shows up again and again in establishing the classics and in determining the quality of a text done after classical times as being worthy to be called classical. Milton, whom we will discuss on this point ahead, is our most pertinent example. This stylistic hegemony explains much that has been sterile and much that has been brilliant in the long history of classical education. Wordsworth understood the sheer power of supposedly 'mere' language. To a large extent his power as a founding voice of romanticism was nurtured by his mastery of the dynamics of classical expression.6 Watson sees in the collapse of the Puritan ideal a major reason for
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
18 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
the generally acknowledged fact that after 1660 the English classical grammar school fell into a decline (Old Schools v-vi). Other scholars do not read the history of the grammar school in quite the same way. Richard Tompson, in Classics or Charity? The Dilemma of the EighteenthCentury Grammar School, surveys the state of the grammar school at that time. Tompson points out how some authorities like A. F. Leach and J. E. G. de Montmorency see the grammar school in the eighteenth century at its nadir because of low enrolments, poor faculty, bad teaching, low standards, and lack of discipline (4-13). We must recall that England did not have any national system of governmentsupported, primary education until 1870. Thus most grammar schools were of private charitable foundation, operated independently, and as such legally were responsible only to the Court of Chancery and ultimately to the Lord Chancellor.7 Tompson sees the main difficulty of the eighteenth-century grammar school as caused by its theoretically exclusive classical curriculum. The classical education afforded the poor in a free grammar school was frequently of little use unless the student went on to the university. Various attempts were made to handle this problem. Because of inflation and other social factors, many grammar schools were practically ruined, but despite its many problems, by and large the eighteenth-century grammar school, argues Tompson, survived pretty well (78-103). Reforms in the general operation of charities were mounted at the end of the eighteenth century and finally issued in the founding of a Royal commission, the Brougham Commission, whose report came in 1819. Thorough reform in secondary education, grammar school curricula, and so forth, did not really get underway until well into the nineteenth century (Barnard, History En. Ed. 126-34). Reform seems to have been delayed by a legal action initiated at the end of the eighteenth century, but Tompson shows that there were real efforts at reform and much more was accomplished than is realized, and thus the grammar schools were changing by the end of the eighteenth century (104-16; 124-6). Speedy grammar-school reform was challenged by the famous Leeds Grammar School case which began in a suit in Chancery in 1796. The dispute centered on an attempt by the governors of the school to expand the curriculum by using endowment income for the hiring of two additional schoolmasters, one to teach writing and a basic kind of arithmetic used for bookkeeping, and a second master to teach French and other foreign languages (116-17). Because the schoolmaster at
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The 'Ethos' of an English Grammar School 19
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Leeds refused to hire the additional staff, a suit was filed against him. He refused, claiming that the charitable foundation upon which the school was established would not allow income from the trust to be used for any teaching other than Latin and Greek, and, besides, surplus funds should be paid to the schoolmaster and the usher (117). The litigation was resolved in Lord Chief Justice Eldon's judgement in 1805. The essence of his ruling is described by Tompson as follows: Eldon found t h a t . . . the school was 'for teaching grammatically the learned languages.' He rested this definition on usage, and not merely on the terms of the founder's will and subsequent grants. Eldon did not say, however, that there was no room for any other subject besides classics or that it was utterly illegal for other subjects to be taught. (Eldon qtd in Tompson 119) Eldon had actually proposed a compromise which in effect required the litigants to work out a plan of reform whereby subjects could be added to the curriculum to the degree that these new subjects conduced to the main work of the school, the teaching of Latin and Greek (119-21). Unfortunately it appears that, both in further legal actions and in the popular mind, the Lord Chief Justice's ruling in effect prohibited any deviation in endowed schools whose charters stipulated that the teaching of Latin and Greek was the main work of the school. Still, as Tompson is careful to show, change and reform came to the grammar school anyway (124-6). For our purposes, the Leeds Grammar School case has a special interest because of the prominence given to the definition of a grammar school and thereby to the nature of the study of the classical languages. The issue at stake was whether or not anything besides the teaching of Latin and Greek would be allowed, and the ruling was that '"the Charity is a Charity for the purpose of teaching the learned languages'" and again '"for teaching grammatically the learned languages'" (Eldon qtd in Tompson 124, 119). Eldon decided the case on the basis of the statutes and the continued practice of the schoolmasters at the Leeds Grammar School. He was impressed when the governors complained in their petition that over the years "'nothing else hath been taught therein but the Greek and Latin Tongues'" (qtd in Tompson 117). We notice the word 'Tongues' and see why Lord Eldon ruled as he did, 'the school was "for teaching grammatically the learned languages'" (119). What strikes us is the way the linguistic emphasis has clung to and
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
20
really dominated the teaching of the classics. It is the classical languages which were taught primarily, even though - of course - the literatures of Greece and Rome were also studied and even though studying those literatures constituted the theoretical goal of the study of the languages, at least for most literate people. Samuel Johnson in his Dictionary had defined a grammar school as '[a] school in which the learned languages are grammatically taught'. It is as though Eldon had simply used Johnson's definition. He did not. He consulted the school's statutes and school practice over the years. In Eldon's influential judgement we catch what most people thought of the manner and the content of classical instruction: the learned languages studied grammatically. Judging from Tompson's detailed account, no one disputed Eldon's definition; the only discussion focused on the limitations in curriculum the Lord Chief Justice thereby stipulated. Nothing was said about classical literature or the Reformation-Anglican ideal of studying the languages of the Scriptures and their patristic commentaries. The nature and purpose of a classical education never seems to have been a major concern. The problem in Leeds was that it had become a rich commercial city. Interest in 'the learned languages' had declined; the only question was whether or not the charitable foundation would lawfully be allowed to support other kinds of teaching. That studying the classics meant basically studying 'the learned languages' 'grammatically' seems to have been a foregone conclusion. It also seems to be an important comment for us about how the classics were understood generally. Of course a moment's reflection would bring most people to define and defend the classics because of their beauty and power of thought. Lord Eldon was not academically narrow. 8 But the general sense of most late-eighteenth-century academic thinking on the classics would not automatically hail them primarily as literature. With much care and detail in his Classical Education in Britain 1500-1900, Clarke covers the history of the eighteenth-century grammar school in his chapter entitled 'The Unreformed Grammar School' (46-60). He is specifically concerned with the study of the classics and sees much that needed reform but also much that was excellent. He reminds us of the key importance of teachers and their power to inspire and to overcome all kinds of obstacles. Basically the picture that Clarke and Tompson give is positive. Grammar-school reform, despite the narrow interpretation drawn so generally from Lord Eldon's ruling, was very much the concern of the best educators in England. One of the most interesting reforms to get
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The 'Ethos' of an English Grammar School 21
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
started in the eighteenth century was that of prizing classical literature more for its own sake and less for its merely linguistic properties. The late seventeenth century and the eighteenth century, the Neoclassic period par excellence, present one of the great paradoxes of literary history. For all of the feverishly formal imitation of classical literature, the study of the classical languages themselves becomes more and more an academic and learned achievement and less an enthusiastically embraced general cultural accomplishment supported by the rising middle class. More and more, French becomes the language of diplomacy. Latin and Greek are studied with scholarly zeal, but lose in the aesthetic affection of many of the supposedly cultivated classes. The classics become the task of schoolboys and the province of scholars. Clarke discusses two important eighteenthcentury changes, the decline of spoken Latin and the rise of 'verse composition' (Class. Ed. 46-8). We shall see that Wordsworth cherishes a special love for the classics which is related to his theory of romantic poetry: 'spontaneous overflow of powerful feelings'. Clarke, in his chapter 'The Schools in the Nineteenth Century', speaks of reforms in grammar-school education and of a '"new humanism"' (74-5). One wonders if possibly something of the nineteenth-century achievement in classical study was anticipated at Wordsworth's Hawkshead. Clarke tells us that at the beginning of the nineteenth century there were between seven and eight hundred grammar schools unevenly distributed throughout England: Certain schools such as Eton and Winchester had always been boarding-schools; others, owing to valuable endowments, good headmasters or other reasons, had developed into public schools, schools, that is, which drew their pupils from the country as a whole rather than from their immediate vicinity. But so far as curriculum and methods of teaching went there was little difference between one endowed school and another; from this point of view Eton was only the largest and most important of the grammar schools. (74) The story of nineteenth-century classical education is the record of reform and achievement especially in the way the classics were taught. Though Lord Eldon had ruled in 1805 that grammar-school endowments stipulated to support classics teaching were to be assigned principally to that purpose, Clarke argues that the classics would not
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
22
have remained the main subject of grammar-school instruction simply because the endowed curriculum was protected by law; 'there were many who were chafing at the dead hand of the past' (75). Reform came from within from schoolmasters who had been trained in the eighteenth-century system and realized that changes had to be made: The old system was revivified. The changes introduced may at first sight appear to be slight, but they were none the less significant. Englishmen did not talk about a 'new humanism,' but something which could with justice be so described gradually replaced the old humanism which had survived from the time of the Tudors. (75) In describing the achievements of public-school classical teaching, Clarke emphasizes the accomplishments of great master teachers of the classics, for example, Butler and Kennedy of Shrewsbury, Arnold of Rugby, Lee of King Edward's School, Birmingham (78-81). In many ways Thomas Arnold is most pertinent for us. On the one hand, he is famous for regarding '"the study of language"' as the perfect instrument for the education of a young person, and he especially admired the inherent powers of the Greek and Latin languages in this regard (qtd in Clarke 79). Thus one might consider Thomas Arnold as merely enthusiastic for the grammatical study of the learned languages. But Arnold cared for meaning and content above all else. He loved the Greek historians. He introduced Plato and even Aristotle to his sixthform students, even though Aristotle was usually regarded as exclusively a university author (79-80). In his teaching Arnold was enthusiastic and inspiring. The same power he exhibited so tellingly in the pulpit he also demonstrated in the classroom. He was always sympathetic to his material and concerned for his students. He loved the classics, but he loved the English language as well: '"Every lesson in Greek or Latin may and ought to be made a lesson in English."'9 The same kind of enthusiasm marked the teaching of Samuel Butler of Shrewsbury who had the power of convincing his students of the intrinsic worth of classical subjects (80). One of the best assistant masters under Thomas Arnold, Prince Lee, went on to become headmaster of King Edward's School in Birmingham. Lee was famous for the way he insisted on good English translations. This practice was far superior to so much translating done in the eighteenth and even early nineteenth century in which an English equivalent had to be
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The 'Ethos' of an English Grammar School 23
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
produced for each and every Latin or Greek word. Such literalism is hardly translating at all. Lee insisted that the Latin or Greek be taken fully into account and the closest English idiomatic equivalent discovered so that the capacities of both languages and the special qualities of the text would all be realized (81). This zealous emphasis on doing good English translations from Latin and Greek became a major feature in classical academic reform in the nineteenth century. The concern for 'good' English reminds us of Coleridge's schoolmaster Boyer and his concern for honest English diction. Clarke points out that Boyer's preference for Greek authors to Latin identifies him with the nineteenth-century grammar-school reform. Especially in the first half of the nineteenth century, '[t]he belief in the virtues of the original genius and the poetry of nature which grew up in the mid-eighteenth century gave the literature of Greece a greater prestige than that of Rome which was so largely derived from it' (Clarke 76; Biog. Lit. I: 8-9). The mention of Boyer and of 'original genius and the poetry of nature' takes us back to our original concern of tracing Wordsworth's classical education. Our next step is to describe that education. We have noticed that the great reforms and accomplishments of nineteenth-century, public-school classical teaching were really the achievements of talented, inspired, devoted teachers. In many ways Wordsworth and Coleridge seem to have had a classical education whose quality shows in anticipation the best of nineteenth-century classical teaching. Wordsworth's golden hours at Hawkshead were very much the gift of his extraordinary teachers and the gifted way they taught him the classics.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
24
The Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake and the Hawkshead of William Wordsworth
For Wordsworth, the soul of education was certainly not 'the little that can be learned from books and a master'; what mattered was 'all that life and nature teach' (LY II: 19). We have noticed that Wordsworth felt himself an outsider at Cambridge, that he was 'not for that hour, / Nor for that place' (Prelude 3.81-2). Did Wordsworth similarly feel estranged at Hawkshead and simply learn from nature? Perhaps the answer is in the following from The Prelude: the earth And common face of Nature spake to me Rememberable things; sometimes, 'tis true, By chance collisions and quaint accidents (Like those ill-sorted unions, work supposed Of evil-minded fairies), yet not vain Nor profitless, if haply they impressed Collateral objects and appearances, Albeit lifeless then, and doomed to sleep Until maturer seasons called them forth To impregnate and to elevate the mind. (1.586-96) Wordsworth tells us that nature saw to it that nothing in his experience was wasted. His classical education at Hawkshead is largely a story of how the classics were more than 'chance collisions' or 'quaint accidents'. They were confederates of nature and emerged later on as a major, tempering undersong in his poetry and critical doctrine. Wordsworth not only attended a particular kind of institution, the 25
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
3
English classical grammar school; he attended a particularly good institution in that tradition. Hawkshead Grammar School was endowed and founded by Edwin Sandys (c. 1516-88), Archbishop of York, who had the vision and the practical experience of a successful reformer. He was self-exiled during the reign of Mary Tudor. He returned to England with the accession of Elizabeth I. He became successively the bishop of Worcester and London and finally Archbishop of York. Because of his scholarship, he participated in the preparation of the Bishops' Bible in 1568 (DNB). Sandys was a learned, realistic and devout churchman. Like many successful men in the sixteenth century, he wanted to found a grammar school in his birthplace. The school was established through Letters Patent of Elizabeth I. Sandys drew up the statutes himself, completing them in the year he died, 1588. In many respects these regulations are similar to other school statutes of the sixteenth century: the schoolmaster to be paid £20 and the usher £3-6s; the long school day, March to October, 6:00 or 6:30 to 11:00 a.m., and then 1:00 to 5:00 p.m. In winter the day began an hour later and ended an hour earlier. There are to be two vacations, one at Christmas and the other at Easter. Prescribed prayers are to be recited every day; there is to be religious instruction at least once a week, and the schoolmaster and students are to attend the parish church in a body on Sunday on a regular basis (Cowper 470-81). Sandys is especially important because, like Bishop Grindal in his statutes, as we have seen, Sandys requires that his schoolmaster know both Latin and Greek. The schoolmaster is to have '"good understandinge in the Greeke and Latyne tongues'" (qtd in Cowper 473). The usher is to take over in the absence of the schoolmaster and thus should have something of the same qualifications (Cowper 473-4). The curriculum is stated very simply and is for us the single most important item Sandys mentions. 10 The schoolmaster is "To teache gramm'r, and the pryncyples of the Greeke tongue, wth other Scyences necessarie to be taughte in a gramm schole"' (qtd in Cowper 472). Sandys is somewhat exceptional in being so explicit about the teaching of Greek. He is truly exceptional in speaking of teaching other sciences necessary for a grammar school. I have not found any direct supporting evidence, but it seems that this statement encouraged the teaching of mathematics at Hawkshead. The connections between Llawkshead and Cambridge were strong. Archbishop Sandys was at St John's as an undergraduate and was
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
26 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
master of Catherine Hall, and Wordsworth's teachers at Hawkshead were all Cambridge graduates. Their excellent instruction in mathematics had helped Hawkshead students do well at Cambridge (Schneider 4-5); it was a prized and famous part of the Hawkshead curriculum (Gill 27-8). The advantage of Archbishop Sandys' Statutes was that they could allow, possibly even encourage, development in the curriculum. As we saw in connection with the Leeds Grammar School case, the nature of many charity bequests to grammar schools with respect to curricula could be quite rigid, and even so, the bequests had to be followed. H. Swainson Cowper gives an account of some of the most trying difficulties in the history of Hawkshead School during the seventeenth century and then gives an important general comment: Yet, in spite of all these vexations, the school rubbed along and flourished in a sort of way through the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries: for the very reason that these were the good days of Hawkshead, and the class of schooling provided suited the state of local society. (494) Cowper reminds us that the Free Grammar School of Edwin Sandys, Archbishop of York, was a grammar school serving a market town and a very rugged, at times almost inaccessible, section of northwestern England. But the area of and around Hawkshead was fairly prosperous at the end of the eighteenth century, and Hawkshead itself remained a fairly important place. Hawkshead Grammar School thus reflected the general prosperity and even the slow but real upward mobility of the local rural population. Since Latin and Greek and mathematics were the university subjects, Hawkshead boys who were clever would do well at the university and in the clergy and the other learned professions later on. Those lads who did not go on to the university found in the curriculum the standard academic training still accepted even for those destined for commerce or military service or farming. Thus from an economic and a sociological standpoint, Hawkshead was very much a 'general', middle-class secondary school. The classics and mathematics constituted its curriculum, but its academic culture or general ethos was bourgeois with that important strain of the bucolic which usually protects students and faculty from bourgeois pretension. Hawkshead was a very healthy social environment. It should also be noted that Sandys founded and Hawkshead remained a classical grammar school. Contrary to Johnston's comment (70), the
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, fames Peake, Hawkshead 27
school did not provide for 'charity boys' until the eighteenth century (TWT 283-4). Archbishop Sandys gave a brief but broad curriculum statement. The headmasters allowed their charges enough time off so that they could avail themselves of the necessary services of a writing-master and the social benefits of a dancing-master (TWT and Woof 92-4). What we notice in this context is that Wordsworth's Hawkshead schooling, mutatis mutandis, especially if one substitutes Latin and Greek for modern subjects, was not that different from what one might find in a literate small-town secondary school in the US or Britain today. The basic academic environment would be much the same. Hawkshead did enjoy one special advantage, the quality of the teaching staff. There were four excellent schoolmasters at Hawkshead at the end of the eighteenth century: James Peake, 1766-81; Edward Christian, 1781-82; William Taylor, 1782-86; Thomas Bowman, 1786-1829. n Though apparently he was not graduated from Cambridge with honors, Peake must have had some reputation for scholarship. He was chosen headmaster of Hawkshead in the summer of 1766, after having completed only three years at St John's, Cambridge. He had one more term to go before finishing his bachelor's degree. His appointment is dated 24 July 1766. It was made by the bishop of Chester 'on a lapse' (Admissions St. John's, Part III 692; Venn). Peake was awarded his bachelor's degree in 1767, his MA in 1775. He was ordained a deacon in July 1767 and priest 25 September 1768. He remained at Hawkshead until 1781 when he was appointed through the patronage of Henry Augustus Cavendish, the Duke of Devonshire, the vicar at Cartmel and minister of the parish church at Edensor. The parish was connected with the duke's great estate, Chatsworth. Peake remained at Edensor until his death in December 1803 (692). What clearly establishes both Peake's ability as a mathematician as well as a classicist was the success enjoyed by Hawkshead boys when they went up to Cambridge. Peake also apparently enjoyed a fine reputation as a teacher (TWT 50). Wordsworth was a full year ahead of other freshmen at Cambridge in mathematics (Prose 3: 373). Furthermore, when Peake came to Hawkshead, there were between 45 and 50 students. When Taylor succeeded Peake in 1782, there were 90 (Schneider 5). It should also be remembered that Taylor, a first-class mathematician, graduated with honors, second Wrangler, had been a student of Peake at Hawkshead. Hawkshead attracted good students even from other good grammar schools where mathematics was also
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
28 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
taught because Hawkshead students were so successful in mathematics at Cambridge. And in Wordsworth's time, students trained by Taylor and Bowman continued to send a number of very good mathematicians to Cambridge (4-5). A study done by Charlotte Kipling indicates that much of the mathematical work done at Cambridge in the eighteenth century falls below standard and certainly honors work done by undergraduates today. Kipling suggests that the very weak preparation of so many undergraduates in Wordsworth's time necessarily kept the standards lower than they otherwise might have been. However, Kipling demonstrates most amply that Wordsworth's Hawkshead training was more than sufficient to enable him to be graduated with honors. Her sense is that Wordsworth refused to compete for honors because he refused to submit to the whole complicated and, as he thought, odious process of honors competition at Cambridge. But she has no doubt that, given his superior Hawkshead training, Wordsworth easily could have earned an honors degree (96-102). The success of mathematics at Hawkshead leads us to inquire how Peake came to be so interested in mathematics and so accomplished a mathematics teacher. He attended two important academic institutions at points in their history of major scholastic reform, St John's College at Cambridge, which we shall discuss later, and Manchester Grammar School. Today Manchester Grammar School enjoys the reputation for being one of the finest secondary schools in England. In the eighteenth century, when Peake was there as a student, it was in the process of a major reform. Manchester Grammar School was founded by Bishop Oldham of Exeter in 1515 as a Renaissance grammar school which also was to provide religious instruction (Mumford 7-19). The school survived the various political, religious and economic challenges of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, and by the second half of the eighteenth century it enjoyed a certain prosperity (20-204). One of the means enabling the school to survive and even prosper was the establishment of boarding houses and the granting of halfholidays on Tuesday, Thursday and Saturday so that students could study such subjects as mathematics, French and even bookkeeping (Bunn 23-33). Provisions were made so that students could study mathematics in the eighteenth century quite seriously and even see scientific demonstrations (Hans 40). Peake matriculated at Manchester on 25 June 1759 and remained for about four years, entering St John's, Cambridge, in October 1763.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, fames Peake, Hawkshead 29
During his time at Manchester, the Rev. William Purnell was High Master. Purnell, MA Oriel College, Oxford, had been second master for 27 years and then became High Master in 1749. He continued in that position until his death in 1764 (Manchester School Register 33). Purnell was scholarly and benevolent. He had a retiring personality but was a dedicated and excellent teacher. During some of the most trying days Manchester Grammar School experienced in the eighteenth century, the dedication and talent of Purnell served the school very well indeed (Mumford 142-3, 151). What was special about Purnell was his broad literary culture, which enabled him to encourage his students to read modern as well as classical literature and which led him to collect money in order to expand the library holdings in modern literature, acquiring such works as Robinson Crusoe, Don Quixote, the poetry of Pope, Prior, Spenser, and works on ancient and modern history (143, 169, 525-6). 12 Purnell was also interested in plays, classical and modern. There was a Christmas play every year, and so important had this become under Purnell's supervision as high master that in 1759, 1760, 1761, the Christmas play was performed for the town in the first theatre ever to be erected in Manchester, a theatre which had just opened in 1753. The performance of plays caused Purnell to be criticized by a prominent local citizen to whom Purnell, a devout clergyman and also a humble man with a sense of humor, replied in part: 'My notions of the stage are different from yours. I think it may be made use of for good ends and purposes and to promote virtue and religion as well as the pulpit. There are some vices more fit for reproval by the stage than by the pulpit As to virtue and religion, I have as great a regard for them as yourself, but as to reputation, I am entirely indifferent about it.' (qtd in Mumford 191-2) Purnell was Peake's main teacher at Manchester. He is especially important because he cherished the classics for a broad range of reasons, one of which was their value in teaching English composition. Through his efforts, six, possibly seven, copies of Henry Felton's A Dissertation on Reading the Classics and Forming a Just Style were purchased for the school library.13 This was a popular eighteenthcentury work designed to teach students a sophisticated approach to the translation of the classics which in turn would enhance their English expression. Because Purnell purchased so many copies of
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
30 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Felton, I would conclude that Purnell must have been convinced that the classics can be an aid to English composition (Mumford 142-3, 169, 525-6). 14 The point here is that the school Peake attended prior to his going to St John's at Cambridge was the model for the reformed Hawkshead Grammar School Peake brought into being when he came to Hawkshead in 1766. Certainly the most obvious similarity, the enlarged curriculum at Manchester, is matched by the emphasis placed on mathematics at Hawkshead. We have already noted that many Hawkshead students did very well in earning honors degrees at Cambridge. It is a significant indication of how strong mathematics was at Manchester that 1759, the year Peake arrived, has been called the 'Annus Mirabilis' for the grammar school because so many of her students had done so well in the Cambridge Mathematical Tripos: the positions of first, third, and fifth Wrangler were all held by scholars from the Manchester School. It is doubtful whether many English Grammar Schools possessed equally good mathematical teaching at this period. (193) Of even greater concern to us than the mathematics is the teaching of the classics. Purnell's qualifications were excellent, his experience extensive, and his dedication and humanity a legend.15 But there must have been in the teaching itself something of the man who revered the classics but also loved modern literature, the production of plays, and the development of skill in English composition. It is impossible to imagine anyone as literate and humane and contemporary in his literary tastes as William Purnell not glossing his commentaries on the Latin and Greek texts with references to English literature. From the evidence we have of Purnell's academic character, there would certainly seem to be every suggestion that his treatment of the classics was richly holistic, that is, a treatment of the classics which regards them not as sui generis and supreme, but as part of a living, evolving literary tradition. I should like to stress again that it was Purnell who secured six copies at least of Felton's Dissertation on Reading the Classics. Felton is a powerful proponent of the holistic teaching of classical literature and encourages great creativity in studying composition. With some classics teachers, creativity sprang from competing with the classical texts as norms of style. With Felton the same competition was recognized, the classical texts enjoying a major standing as a norm of stylistic excellence, but Felton is much
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 31
more daring in the ways he suggests the classical texts be studied for the sake of creativity in English.16 Much of this spirit of holistic classical teaching and even daring in using the classics as models for creative composition could well have shown itself in the teaching of Purnell. Peake entered St John's College, Cambridge, in October 1763. Very shortly St John's went through a major academic reform under its new master, Dr William S. Powell. In July 1765, St John's College authorities voted to establish semiannual college examinations (C. Words., Scholae 352-3). Wordsworth, as will be shown, did well in several of these examinations. Peake must have seen their implications for future Hawkshead boys going to St John's. Classics, though not part of the university's final examinations, were still important because some of the most prestigious prizes and awards given at Cambridge were given through competitive examinations in classics. Most of the Hawkshead boys who went on to the university went to Cambridge, and a large number of these went to St John's (Schneider 1-9). Peake was appointed to Hawkshead in 1766, and not too long afterward he began teaching one of his best students, William Taylor. The beloved teacher of Wordsworth is buried in the cemetery of Cartmel Priory. Cartmel is south of Hawkshead in the Furness Peninsula, and it was in this area that Taylor was born. He came up to Hawkshead, studied under Peake, and then went off to Emmanuel College, Cambridge, in October 1774; he was awarded his BA in 1778 and his MA in 1781; he was ordained a deacon in 1780; and was master of Hawkshead School from 1782 to 1786 (Woof in TWT 342; Venn). Taylor was talented and very successful at Cambridge. He was graduated second Wrangler, that is, with second highest standing in the mathematical Tripos, which meant in effect second in his graduating class. He also won the second Smith's prize (Venn), one of two prizes awarded for excellence in mathematics (Schneider 26). Taylor had a close friend at Emmanuel who left a warm tribute to him in a work dedicated to the worthies of Cambridge University. Taylor's friend was the minor poet and critic George Dyer, the friend also of Charles Lamb, Coleridge, and Wordsworth (DNB; Moorman 1: 264). There is nothing minor about Dyer's tribute to Taylor. He begins by admitting that in the course of his discussion of the various colleges at Cambridge, his concern has been to recount the lives and achievements only of those who have 'left literary memorials behind them ...' (History of Cambridge 2: 391). Dyer goes on, praising Taylor as 'a man of no common talents and worth'. They were close friends,
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
32 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
though Taylor was an expert mathematician and Dyer's strongest instincts lay elsewhere. They studied, walked together, shared ideas and interests and reading well beyond the routine academic requirements. Dyer tells us that 'we disputed, but never quarrelled: we always parted friends— He was not less a man of taste than judgment; and our disputes were probably advantages to [us] both ...' (History of Cambridge 2: 391). It is this comment by Dyer which makes me question the possibility of much political influence of Dyer on Taylor (Williams 30-1). Dyer's eulogy, written long after Taylor's death, recalls the full range of Taylor's attributes and interests and gifts: his metaphysics, his classical scholarship, his lack of exterior polish and even apparently his accent, so many elements which showed Taylor as decent, caring, and wise, a perfect man to become a schoolmaster. Yet [h]e was not a man of the world: he, so to speak, had been never in it: but a most piercing eye, a very fine physiognomy, a childlike modesty, and natural urbanity, commanded universal respect and esteem [L]et those who knew William Taylor ... bear testimony, that he was endowed with the most excellent qualities, both moral and intellectual. (392) Dyer has a footnote in which he comments on Taylor's second place in the Tripos. He and another student were the two top mathematicians among the examinees. There was a friendly rivalry between them, so friendly it was no real rivalry at all. Taylor accepted second place, glad at his friend's success (393). Through the extensive researches of Thompson, as reported by Schneider, a volume of Chatterton's verse was discovered which once had belonged to Taylor. The following is inscribed in the flyleaf: 'To the Revd. William Taylor, Master of the Free Grammar School at Hawkshead, to mark my appreciation of his luminous and pertinent reflections on the poets of our time, and especially the unhappy boy whose genius is evident in many of the pieces contained in this slender volume.' (qtd in Schneider 77; 273, note 22) And here we begin to see the taste and influence of Taylor. Unfortunately we don't know what Peake's reading habits were, but if Purnell's taste for and encouragement of the poets of his time rubbed
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 33
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
off on Peake, we can readily imagine Peake's encouraging an interest in contemporary poetry in Taylor, and thus we see the marvelous effect of Taylor's attachment to poetry in the generous words of a grateful admirer. Schneider makes a good case for Taylor's affection for the eighteenth-century graveyard, and melancholic poets such as Gray, having chosen a part of the 'Elegy' for his tombstone. His affection for the tragic Chatterton is a logical corollary to his admiration for Gray. Wordsworth's own melancholy posture in much of his early verse, Schneider points out, could very well have been encouraged by Taylor (76-9). But also important in this context is the clear indication of the teaching methods and teaching ability of Taylor. Moorman points out that the donor of the edition of Chatterton's poetry was Edmund Irton of Irton Hall, Cumberland. His mother had married a second time and her husband was the Rev. Reginald Brathwaite, vicar of Hawkshead and owner of Belmont. This was a large home able to accommodate his new wife and her six children. Irton was 20 when Taylor became headmaster at Hawkshead (WW 1: 50). Thompson points out that Irton had left Hawkshead School by 1780 and had gone on to Trinity College, Cambridge (53). One wonders how the young Irton came to know Taylor and how he came to hear Taylor lecture or discourse on poetry. He is undoubtedly commenting from personal experience: '"my appreciation of his luminous and pertinent reflections on the poets of our time ..."' (qtd in Schneider 77, 273, note 22). But however Irton heard Taylor, his comments evoke a vivid teacher in whatever context he worked. Since the 'teaching of contemporary poetry was certainly then not part of a grammar-school curriculum, Taylor must have met with students on an informal basis and possibly had contact in this way with the local gentry. But it surely seems possible that any teacher with this kind of commitment to contemporary poetry and this kind of gift for animated elucidation would strongly demonstrate these gifts in the context of teaching classical poetry. Naturally we cannot be certain. There seem to be no accounts of Taylor's teaching methods. We can only conjecture on the basis of our own experience. I would suggest that what Dyer and Irton describe is a personable, enthusiastic, learned, and articulately holistic teacher of the classics. Moorman goes from her discussion of Irton's gift of the Chatterton to Taylor to the whole question of Wordsworth's reading of contemporary poetry. Given his somewhat strained and dependent financial
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
34
situation as shown so clearly in his uncles' account books (TWT 91), we can be rather certain that he did not have the resources to buy editions of contemporary poets (Moorman, WW 1: 51). In his recent volume on Wordsworth's life, Johnston offers an extended commentary on eighteenth-century poets Wordsworth read (76-92). Also, from the research of Thompson into Hawkshead School library holdings contemporary with Wordsworth, 17 we learn that the library apparently had almost no eighteenth-century verse, yet Wordsworth clearly demonstrates much knowledge of such poetry. As Moorman, Sheats, Stein and Wu remind us, 18 Wordsworth's own early poetry is rich in eighteenth-century allusion and echo. He tells in Book 10 of The Prelude that William Taylor 'loved the poets' (552). As Moorman suggests, Taylor must have shared volumes of poetry with Wordsworth, and thus Taylor proved to be the perfect teacher for an aspiring poet (WW 1: 51). Thomas Bowman, Jr, son of the Thomas Bowman who had become usher in 1784 and then headmaster upon Taylor's death in 1786 (TWT 342), commented extensively on one occasion about Wordsworth's reading. According to Bowman, Wordsworth was an enthusiastic, an omnivorous reader as a young man at school: 'But it was books he wanted, all sorts of books; Tours and Travels, which my father was partial to, and Histories and Biographies, which were also favourites with him; and Poetry - that goes without saying. My father used to get the latest books from Kendal every month, and I remember him telling how he lent Wordsworth Cowper's "Task" when it first came out, and Burns' "Poems" ' (qtd by Woof in Appendix IV in TWT 344) In correspondence with Thomas Bowman, Jr, upon the death of his father, Wordsworth expresses his gratitude that the senior Bowman introduced him to so much eighteenth-century poetry: '"Langhorne's poems and Beattie's 'Minstrel' & Percy's 'Reliques' . . . Crabbe & Charlotte Smith & the two Wartons"' (qtd in TWT 344). Mrs Eileen Jay, whom Woof cites and thanks for having shared the text with him of this recollection of Bowman, Jr, explains in her discussion of this material the meaning of Bowman, Jr's reference to Kendal. There was a library in Kendal, 'the "Kendal Newsroom" or "Coffee Room" ... established in March 1779. Its facilities were available to local gentlemen by subscription, and Wordsworth himself used the "Newsroom" in adult life ...' (Jay 28).
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 35
What Bowman, Jr, seems to be describing is a Wordsworth already familiar with and enthusiastic about modern poetry. Given Wordsworth's testimony in The Prelude and Edmund Irton's tribute and his enthusiasm for reading just described, we may inquire if there is any evidence to indicate how Taylor supplied Wordsworth with books and possibly even discussed or even explained poetry to Wordsworth. Taylor as a true teacher of contemporary poetry is clear enough in the Irton tribute. Unfortunately there seem to be very few documents extant pertaining to Taylor directly.19 One document, however, is helpful with our point at hand: Taylor's will. Taylor died in June 1786 (Woof's Appendix III and IV in TWT 336, 342). His will is dated 25 April 1786. In his will he makes bequests in favor of his mother, his aunt and two nephews, and his brother-in-law. It is the disposition of his library which is our main interest. Taylor assigns his library to his nephews, John Taylor Oldham and Matthew Oldham. He stipulates that the executors of his will, Reginald Brathwaite and John Brathwaite (Reginald was the rector of Hawkshead), are to be compensated for any expenses they incurred in handling his estate and they are each to receive ten guineas and books at their discretion from his library. The remaining books were to go to his nephews. He is quite specific about this item in the will. 20 The books are to be divided between the young men when they become 21. It seems unlikely that Taylor would speak so fully of his library unless the library were of some consequence. It must have contained at least some books of value and, one would assume, it must have been fairly extensive so that the executors could choose books for themselves and still there would be enough left as a bequest for his nephews. It seems reasonable to suppose that Taylor's library could have been a good source of books for Wordsworth. Taylor could very well have loaned and discussed eighteenth-century poetry with Wordsworth and Irton and others. Certainly he could have loaned volumes of poetry the way Bowman was later to do. In the spring of 1779, Wordsworth came to Hawkshead and remained until October 1787. Taylor took over as headmaster some time after May 1782. There is no record in the school archives as to exactly when Taylor came to Hawkshead. Edward Christian's resignation is dated 18 July 1782 (Woof in TWT 342). Dr Frank Stubbings, onetime Hon. Keeper of Rare Books, Emmanuel College Library, has pointed out that 'Taylor was elected a Fellow of Emmanuel in 1781 and continued to sign the "College orders" until May 1782, when he apparently went to Hawkshead.'21
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
36 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Taylor taught at Hawkshead from 1782 until his illness and death in 1786. It is not possible to say precisely when he taught Wordsworth, presumably during most or all of Taylor's years at Hawkshead. During Taylor's time there could have been as many as 90 to 100 boys, and apparently there were four on the teaching staff: the headmaster, two assistant masters and a writing-master (Woof in TWT 342-3; Schneider 4-5). Taylor must have taught the top three forms at least. One wonders what authors, particularly what classical poets, Wordsworth studied under Taylor. In order to answer that question, we shall consider the standard authors usually studied in grammar schools at that time and note the authors Wordsworth clearly knew. Finally, we shall consider the textbooks Wordsworth is known to have used. At the end of the eighteenth century, as we saw above, there was a very serious debate in England over secondary education. The famous liberal Lord Brougham led a campaign in Parliament to investigate all charitable trusts and foundations, especially those designed to provide free education in grammar schools. Such endowments were the chief means whereby the poor could receive secondary education. Parliament, in July 1817, commissioned Nicholas Carlisle, an assistant librarian in the King's Library and Secretary of the Society of Antiquaries, to conduct a survey of all endowed schools. Carlisle went about his commission with dispatch. He sent out questionnaires to all known grammar schools; he even advertised in The Gentleman's Magazine. In 1818 he published the results, a report on 475 schools (Mack 132-7; Carlisle 1: xxx-xliv). Carlisle's survey was the first of its kind ever published and provides an excellent picture of the English grammar school at the end of the eighteenth and beginning of the nineteenth centuries. Carlisle's questionnaire mainly required information about each school's history, its board of governors and basic organization, its scholarships or exhibitions at the universities, the name and salary of its headmaster. Carlisle also asked for a copy of the school's statutes, 'the routine of education prescribed', that is, daily timetable or schedule, and the name of the Latin grammar used (1: xxxiii-xxxiv). Carlisle's two-volume report, A Concise Description of the Endowed Grammar Schools in England and Wales, is arranged alphabetically by name of county and then alphabetically by name of school. Only a dozen schools or so actually report by name the classical authors studied, but there is such strong consistency in the authors named and in so many other elements reported that it seems safe to assume a basic similarity in the classical curriculum. The weekly and daily
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 37
schedules are very similar: school six days a week with some free afternoons. The daily schedule has school starting about seven and running till five with about two to three hours off for meals, and so forth. Half-holidays are common as are about eight weeks of vacation. Many schools describe their classical curriculum the way St Bees describes its curriculum. We have noticed above that in the sixteenth century, Archbishop Grindal was most explicit about curriculum. He named the catechism, the Psalter, the New Testament, and then 16 authors, and with Cicero he cites a number of his works to be read. In Carlisle's Concise Description, the report from St Bees reads: The Eton Latin and Greek Grammars are in use — and the Classical Authors are such as are usually read in great Schools. Writing also and arithmetic, geography, English grammar, and various branches of Mathematics are taught by a Third Master, who has a quarterly charge on those who receive such instructions, the School being only free for the Classics. (1: 167; emphasis his) The comment on the nature of the classical authors studied, 'as are usually read in great Schools', is typical of many schools, indicating the prestige or conservative influence of the great public schools. The fact that so many grammar-school teachers were educated at Oxford or Cambridge also helped secure the sameness of the curriculum. Teachers will ordinarily teach what they have been taught themselves. Teachers will also be concerned to satisfy the needs of the best students. Thus, because usually some students, at least in the better grammar schools, were headed toward the university, the overall classical curriculum would be structured to satisfy university requirements. Even though mathematics became the dominant study for honors at Cambridge, the classics continued to hold an important place in undergraduate education (Clarke, Cl. Ed. 67-73). But even for those clearly not intending to go on to the university, there was, as we noticed above, a certain eclat in studying Latin. Thus for social as well as academic reasons, the grammar-school curriculum tended to be traditional and standardized. Certain authors are so standard they are almost universally studied: Ovid, Horace, Virgil, Juvenal, Caesar, Cicero, Sallust, Livy, Tacitus, Xenophon, Homer, Demosthenes. Others are very common but not necessarily universal - Catullus or Pindar, for example. But as one goes through the whole body of literature on the grammar school, one finds great consistency in the curriculum (50-5).
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
38 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
St Paul's in London, the school of Milton, readily exemplifies the conservative character of the curriculum and teaching methods typical of the great public schools. In the Carlisle report on St Paul's, the Statutes as written by John Colet, the founder of the school, are given. Under the heading '"What Shall Be Taught"', Colet discusses the curriculum. He begins by admitting that he is unsure about particular details, but he is sure that he wants good authors, both Christian and classical, to be taught. Colet is most insistent that the Latin studied and used be of the purest sort: T would they were taught always in good literature bothe Laten and Greeke, and good autors such as have the verrye Romayne eloquence joyned with wisdom, specially Cristen autors, that wrote their wisdome with clean and chaste Laten, other in verse or in prose ' (Carlisle 2: 76; emphasis his; spelling as in Carlisle) Aside from this quotation, the Carlisle report does not quote Colet's comments about particular authors to be studied. As we have already seen, Colet was very much a conservative Christian and admired Cicero's style but not the study of Cicero, because he was a pagan (Watson, English Grammar Schools 374-5). In Milton's time, however, as is abundantly clear from Clark's detailed study of Milton's education at St Paul's, a typical classical curriculum was vigorously in force. Clark discusses a manuscript from the seventeenth century preserved in Trinity College, Cambridge, from among the manuscripts of Thomas Gale, High Master, 1672-97. The manuscript, 'The Constant Method of Teaching in St. Pauls Schoole London', lays out the entire schedule of lessons, authors studied, exercises in translation and composition, and so forth., and the times for each lesson, each day, for all eight forms (classes) for a typical week. Clark then gives this entire schedule verbatim (Milton St. Paul's 109-13). Clark next synthesizes the main features of the classical curriculum as given in the Gale manuscript. Finally Clark presents what he calls 'Conjectured Curriculum of St Paul's School 1618-1625'. This is a curriculum which Clark arranges, having taken into consideration all the circumstances special to Milton's time at St Paul's. Clark shows a curriculum and class schedule which are practically the same as in the Gale manuscript for the end of the seventeenth century (110-21).
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 39
40
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Conjectured Curriculum of St Paul's School 1618-1625
Class I. Class II. Class III.
Class IV.
Class V.
Class VI.
Class VII.
Class VIII.
Latin Grammar. Read Sententiae Pueriles and Lily, Carmen de Moribus. Latin Grammar. Read Cato, Disticha Moralia and Aesop, Fabulae (in Latin). Latin Grammar. Read Erasmus, Colloquies and Terence, Comedies, for colloquial Latin, and Ovid, De Tristibus, to begin poetry. Latin Grammar. Read Ovid, Epistles and Metamorphoses (and perhaps other elegiac poets), and Caesar and perhaps Justin for history. Begin Greek Grammar, and continue with some review of Latin Grammar. Read Sallust for history and begin Virgil, Bucolics. Greek Grammar and the Greek Testament in the morning. Begin Cicero (possibly Epistles and Offices), continue Virgil (and perhaps take up Martial). Greek Grammar. Read minor Greek poets (perhaps chosen from Hesiod, Theognis, Pindar, and Theocritus), Cicero, Orations, and Horace. Hebrew Grammar and Psalter in the morning. Read Homer, Euripides, and Isocrates (and perhaps Demosthenes), Persius and Juvenal. (Perhaps Dionysius for history and Aratus.) (121)
From the above and from various studies of sixteenth- and seventeenth-century grammar schools, Clark shows how typical his conjectured curriculum for St Paul's School in Milton's time is for the authors studied and the routine of classes and the exercises are quite standard (121-6). Our next illustration is from Carlisle's report. It too lists authors and classes. It is 'The Weekly course of Instruction', in force at Shrewsbury School at the beginning of the nineteenth century. This is the grammar school which Dr Samuel Butler (1774-1839) took over as
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The exercises and themes were correlated with the authors and guided by textbooks of grammar and rhetoric.
headmaster in 1798 and turned into one of the finest public schools in England. Both as teacher and scholar, Butler enjoyed great success for a number of years, achieved fame and was made bishop of Lichfield.22 The advantage of seeing the 'Weekly course of Instruction' for Shrewsbury in detail is that it shows us the classical curriculum and regimen of study at a major grammar school in which are reflected most of the significant reforms in grammar-school education in nineteenth-century England. It was this curriculum in the hands of Butler, the master teacher, that trained some of England's best classical scholars. 23 It is quoted as it stands in Carlisle: The Weekly course of Instruction, for the Sixth and Upper part of the Fifth Form, is, on MONDAY. 1. Chapel. History. 2. Dalzel's Analecta Majora: The parts read in this Class are, Thucydides, Plato, the Greek Orators, Aristotle, and Longinus. 3. Cicero's Orations. 4. Virgil. Chapel. TUESDAY 1. Chapel. Repeat Virgil. Shew up Latin Theme. 2. Dalzel's Analecta Majora: The parts read in this Class are, the Greek Plays, Pindar, and the Greek Lyrics, Theocritus, Callimachus, and Apollonius Rhodius. After the Second Lesson, a Lecture is given by The Head Master on Greek metres; or, from Copplestone's Praelectiones Academicae; or, on some subject connected with Antient Literature. Half-Holiday. Dancing, Fencing, French, Drawing, and Writing. WEDNESDAY 1. Chapel. Tacitus. Demosthenes, or Selections from Plautus: and repeat the Dalzel of yesterday. 2. Greek Play. 3. Horace. Odes. 4. Scriptores Romani. Chapel. THURSDAY 1. Chapel. Repeat Horace, Shew up Latin Verses.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 41
42 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong Homer. Lecture in Algebra. Half-Holiday, as Tuesday.
FRIDAY 1. Chapel. Repeat Homer. Shew up Lyrics. 2. Juvenal, or Horace, Sallust, and Epistles. 3. Tacitus, or Demosthenes. 4. Virgil. Chapel. SATURDAY 1. Chapel. Repeat Juvenal or Horace. Lecture in Euclid. 2. An open Lesson: either English translated into Greek Prose, or into Latin Prose, the Master being present. A Lecture on the Greek Grammar. A construing Lesson in Greek Play, or what the Master judges most convenient. The Prepositors of the Week shew up Greek Verses. Half-Holiday, as Tuesday and Thursday. SUNDAY Church in the Morning. Chapel in the Evening. After Evening Chapel, the Fifth and Sixth Forms are examined in Pretyman's Theology, or Seeker's Lectures: The Fourth, in Watts's Scripture History: The remainder of the School, in the Catechism. (2: 389-90) In order to compare St Paul's in the seventeenth century with Shrewsbury at the beginning of the nineteenth, one should compare the top four classes at St Paul's, Class V through Class VIII, with the classes shown in our Shrewsbury illustration, the top three classes or forms, the two parts of the sixth and upper part of the fifth form. These forms were taught by Butler. What we notice immediately is that St Paul's teaches Hebrew, at least its fundamentals, to its top class, and Shrewsbury does not. We next notice that St Paul's begins Greek with the grammar in Class V and reviews Latin grammar in the same year. At Shrewsbury the form corresponding to St Paul's Class V, the upper part of the fifth form, would have completed its regular training in Greek grammar and is occupied with major authors, as are the two parts of the sixth form. In this connection the whole curriculum at Shrewsbury seems much advanced as compared with that of St Paul's. It seems amazing that so good a school as St Paul's would, for example, only have taken up Cicero's orations in its seventh class.24
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
2.
The extensive curriculum in Greek at Shrewsbury is strikingly in advance of that at St Paul's. This is revealed in such things as using Dalzel's Analecta Maiora25 and the inclusion of Demosthenes on both Wednesday and Friday as one major alternative to two major Latin writers, Plautus and Tacitus. Demosthenes is listed only as a possibility at St Paul's. Also among the Greek authors studied at Shrewsbury are Aristotle and Longinus. They do not show up often among grammar-school authors. Aristotle was not that highly regarded as a philosopher in the eighteenth century and only the Poetics and Rhetoric were widely read. 26 Finally, we notice that the 'Prepositors of the Week', that is, the monitors at Shrewsbury, are required to do Greek poetry. Shrewsbury reflects the augmented study of Greek in the nineteenth century, and St Paul's teaching of Hebrew recalls the grammar school's commitment to biblical study. The authors studied, however, are generally the same. In Greek both schools studied Homer, Hesiod, Pindar, Theocritus and playwrights. In Latin the similarity is even greater: Virgil, Horace, Juvenal, Sallust and Cicero. Also at Shrewsbury the Eton anthology Scriptures Romani was used. Through using such a common anthology Shrewsbury would also teach authors found at St Paul's. Both schools did translation and verse composition in Latin and Greek. The verse composition is not shown in Clark's 'Conjectured Curriculum', but it is discussed and illustrated further on in his text (198-208). St Paul's in Milton's time and Shrewsbury under Butler were similar in other respects. Butler was a great classical scholar and one of the great schoolmasters of England (Clarke, Greek Studies 14, 23, 91-2). Milton's headmaster, Alexander Gil, was an excellent classical scholar and teacher (Clark 65-99). Both schools were about the same size, 153 students at St Paul's with three masters to teach them (42). Shrewsbury had 130 with a headmaster and second master (Carlisle 2: 387-8, 394). At both schools it was relatively easy for the headmasters to get to know their students and have a positive influence on them. Clark comments that Alexander Gil, Milton's headmaster, and Alexander Gil, Jr, undermaster in Milton's time, but not a teacher of Milton, both had a profoundly beneficial influence on Milton (65-6, 98). Wordsworth undoubtedly studied such standard schoolboy works as the Distica Catonis or some such text to learn sufficient phraseology in order to do a minimum of Latin conversation at least for the classroom exercises.27 Schneider is one of the first to comment extensively on Wordsworth's classical curriculum at Hawkshead and St John's,
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 43
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Cambridge. Schneider points out that Wordsworth would have studied Virgil, Horace, Caesar and Cicero at Hawkshead; and for the semiannual examinations at St John's, he would have studied Horace, Virgil, Tacitus and Livy, and in Greek Xenophon, Sophocles and Demosthenes (Schneider 68). As we have seen, these are standard authors in good grammar schools. When the Greek authors are taken into account, we see that Wordsworth participated in a sophisticated classical curriculum. But in order to grasp the range of Wordsworth's classical study and also something of its depth, we should note at what stage Wordsworth began the study of Greek and we should consider how seriously he pursued this study. Schneider has claimed, 'For even from a purely academic standpoint, Hawkshead was one of the best schools in England' (4).28 For this to have been true, the curriculum in Greek was crucial. Furthermore, enhancement of Greek studies was a major element in the reform of classical teaching at the public schools in the nineteenth century (Clarke, CL Ed. 76; see also his Greek Studies 22-4). Wu in his detailed Wordsworth's Reading 1770-1799 provides the most complete presentation available of classical authors known either certainly or possibly to have been read by Wordsworth during his years at Hawkshead and Cambridge. Some authors were studied in academic texts and some were possibly read only in translation (for example, Aristophanes). Some authors, like the Greek poets Anacreon and Callistratus were translated by Wordsworth as part of his early work in poetry. 29 From various sources, Wu documents Wordsworth's familiarity with the following Greek authors: Anacreon, Aristophanes, Callistratus, Demosthenes, Homer, Lucian, Moschus, Sophocles, Theocritus and Xenophon. He does the same with the following Latin authors: Caesar, Catullus, Cicero, Horace, Juvenal, Livy, Quintilian, Lucretius, Martial, Nepos, Ovid, Phaedrus, Pliny the Younger, Statius and Virgil. This is an impressive list by late eighteenth- and even nineteenth-century standards as can be seen from our consideration of authors studied at Shrewsbury. Thompson and Woof in his annotations (90-1) and Wu (Wordsworth's Reading 1770-1799 169-70) give detailed accounts of books purchased for Wordsworth when he was at Hawkshead. Both Thompson-Woof and Wu quote Ann Tyson's Account Book and the accounts kept by Wordsworth's guardian uncles, Richard Wordsworth of Whitehaven and Christopher Crackenthorpe Cookson. Of special interest are the Greek texts purchased for Wordsworth. Ann Tyson records '"A Greek Exercises'" (Wds Reading 1770-1799 169); and
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
44
Richard Wordsworth's account shows '"2 Vol Homer & 1 Vol. [sic] Lucian for my Nephews'" (170); and from the same '"a Hedrick's [sic] Lexicon for William"' and '"a Demosthenes for William"' (170). The Ann Tyson Account Book also has an item of special interest, 'Paid for Anabasis'. The Anabasis was for Robert Greenwood, a schoolmate of Wordsworth (169). If Greenwood studied Xenophon, Wordsworth must have also studied Xenophon at school. These Greek texts are significant because they reveal that Hawkshead in the 1780s was teaching Demosthenes, an achievement of Samuel Butler's students in their highest forms. Emphasis on Demosthenes apparently did not reach St Paul's until the 1830s (Clarke, CL Ed. 81). Wordsworth was '"in Greek"' at 15 and doing Demosthenes at 16 (TWT 90-1). The fact that he received his own dictionary, that is, '"a Hedrick's [sic] Lexicon for William"' at the cost of one pound indicates seriousness in his classical studies. A pound was a considerable sum in those days. The 'Hederick's Lexicon Manuale Graecum ... [is] a Greek-Latin/Latin-Greek word-book which went through several editions in the eighteenth century' (Woof note in TWT 91). Though textbooks would surely have been shared and passed down from one Wordsworth brother to another, possibly William would keep both the word-book and the Demosthenes for Cambridge where he hoped to distinguish himself and earn a fellowship. As Schneider points out, Hawkshead boys had done well at Cambridge (4-7). Furthermore, given the quality of Wordsworth's instructors, his comment that Shaw taught him Latin so well, the excellence of Manchester Grammar School and Peake's clear teaching success at Hawkshead, and the very high quality and personal commitment of Taylor and Bowman, both Wranglers, one can see how Wordsworth's Greek curriculum could be so advanced. But the intriguing question is, how did Wordsworth actually study these classical authors? We know from his letter to Landor that as a student at Hawkshead he was not required to compose Latin or Greek verse (LY I: 125). Such a requirement commonly obtained in most public schools and good grammar schools. Wordsworth's experience was clearly something of an exception (Clarke, Greek Studies 18-19; Cl. Ed. 16-20, 58-9). There is another feature in the classical training at Hawkshead which seems a bit singular, not because it was done, but because it was done so generally that it must have been done with official approval and even perhaps encouragement. I refer to the use of translations or 'ponies'. It is possible to document a number of translations of major
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 45
authors which Wordsworth had at hand and apparently used in the preparation of his lessons. For example, we have already noted from the remark of Thomas Bowman, Jr, recalling his father's comment, that Wordsworth used the '"old books'" in the school library and that he used the Sandys translation of Ovid's Metamorphoses (Metamorphosis [sic] in 1632 edition, the one used at Hawkshead).30 In the foreword to the 1970, University of Nebraska Press, text of the 1632 edition, Bush comments extensively on the virtues of the Sandys translation. He begins his discussion by quoting the first nine lines of the Metamorphoses. This is followed by translations from Golding, Sandys and Dryden. Bush then comments in part: In substance Golding here follows Ovid with relative fidelity, but his tone is hardly Ovidian and the movement of his long lines [fourteeners] is monotonous. Sandys aims always at extreme conciseness and does not admit the padding that translations in verse commonly invite [B]oth Golding and Dryden are less literal and more lucid, (ix) Bush concludes his foreword, 'The reading of Sandys, both the translation and the commentary, gives us the feeling and flavor of Ovid in the last age of his full fame' (xiii). Thus Bush praises the Sandys translation as superior to Golding's and different from and in certain respects more interesting than Dryden's. Sandys 'gives us the feeling and flavor of Ovid'. This praise that Bush offers for the value of the Sandys translation recalls the values which Graver has demonstrated Wordsworth shows in his translation of the Aeneid. Wordsworth sought a new kind of translation, not one tightly literal, nor one loose and paraphrastic, but a translation literal enough and yet also one adroitly idiomatic in its English expression so that both Virgilian-Latin qualities and authentic English expression subsist in a single, aesthetically coherent whole, an authentic yet interesting 'translation that preserves its [the Aeneid's] qualities of sound, syntax, cadence and meaning' ('Wds. & Lang, of Epic' 274; emphasis his). Surely such an achievement is similar to the achievement Bush attributes to Sandys, who 'gives us the feeling and flavor of Ovid'. Graver does not suggest that Wordsworth derived his concept or ideals of translation from the George Sandys translation of Ovid. The Sandys translation is one of the most used books in the Hawkshead Grammar School Library. It is virtually impossible to know who used
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
46 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
a book like this, and when, in such a library, but Bowman, Sr, did say that Wordsworth used this volume. Probably other students did as well. But possibly Wordsworth's clear attachment to this translation of Ovid and the fact that so much of his Latin and probably Greek training come through the use of similar translations indicate that Wordsworth's skill as a translator began in the regular use of classical translations like these when he was at Hawkshead. Wordsworth's use of a translation as a formal device in his education began with a very special kind of Latin grammar which was used at Hawkshead. The history of Latin grammars in England, especially since the Renaissance, is a fascinating and complex story. Here we can consider only some of the highlights. What is known as Lily's Grammar was made from an accidence, done in English by Colet and Lily (eight parts of speech, declensions, conjugations, and so forth.). The second part, done by Lily and Erasmus, was a syntax in Latin containing grammatical verses by Lily, sections on figures of speech, prosody, quantity, and so forth. The first part was known as A Shorte Introduction of Grammar, and the second as Brevissima Institutio seu Ratio Grammatices.31 The Lily Grammar became the authorized grammar by royal decree in about 1540, though it was by no means the only grammar used in England. In 1758, the Lily Grammar was taken over and changed by Eton College 'and became known as the Eton Latin Grammar' (Watson, En. Gram. Schools 243-59; for further comments on grammar, see Watson 273-5). The problem with the Lily or Eton Grammar was that the syntax was in Latin and the general pedagogical method employed in teaching the syntax was to have students memorize it in Latin, even though, in many cases, they did not understand the rules they were learning by heart (Clarke, Cl. Ed. 51; Watson, En. Gram. Schools 261). In the seventeenth century the Lily Grammar had been completely translated into English in various editions (Watson, En. Gram. Schools 265-6). Wordsworth used a very special kind of text which translated and annotated elaborately some of the most difficult sections of the Lily-Eton Grammar. The text was done by Thomas Dyche, clerical schoolmaster and author and compiler of many school texts. 32 It is worth quoting its full title and other comments from the title page in order to see what his Latin text offered: The Youth's Guide to the Latin Tongue: or, an EXPLICATION of Propria quae maribus, Quae genus, and As in praesenti. Wherein the Rules are made plain and easy to the Capacity of
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 47
48
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
The sections of the Lily-Eton Grammar which Dyche translates and explains deal with such troublesome items as the gender and declension of proper nouns and rules governing the formation of the perfect tenses of verbs, and so forth. In the Lily-Eton Grammar, these sections of the rules are presented in Latin hexameter verse, the first and third by Lily and the second by Thomas Robertson, another sixteenthcentury schoolmaster (254). Dyche's process of literal translation coupled with explanations is so elaborate, it almost amounts to an illustrative treatise on the art: and value of literal translation. In his Preface Dyche explains that his purpose is to help students understand the rules they are required to memorize. He makes no apologies for dealing with basic information and not offering elaborate glosses. He writes for young students, not scholars, and his purpose is to make 'our Common Grammar, however censured by some ...as instructive as any that can be made use of (ii; emphasis his). Watson shows that all kinds of elaborate translations and commentaries had been done on the Lily Grammar (En. Gram. Schools 265-72). The Lily Grammar was instituted as the 'authorised Latin Grammar' about 1540, and its institution 'is parallel to the authorization of a particular rendering of the Scriptures' (252). It continued as the 'authorised' grammar despite frequent challenges (a bill to strip it of official status was introduced in the House of Lords as late as 1675 but was then dropped). When it was taken over as the Eton Grammar in 1758, it retained '[t]his recognition' until 1868 (259). By the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries royal authorization was not nearly so important as the social prestige of the grammar's being identified as the Eton Grammar (Stray 2-3). With Dyche, then, one gets the Eton rules with all of their cultural and academic authority plus much enlightened training in translation. It may be because Shaw used this grammar (with Peake's approval) that Wordsworth claimed he learned so much Latin so efficiently from him (Prose 3: 372). There is good evidence to suggest that the Eton Grammar was in use at Hawkshead by 1785. Perhaps Thomas Bowman, Sr, was not as enthusiastic about the Dyche as were others at Hawkshead. In the Nicholas Carlisle report on Hawkshead School in 1818, Carlisle states: 'The Eton Grammars are now used here: and the system of Education is nearly the same as at all other public Schools'
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
young Learners, By A new Verbal Translation, the Examples declin'd, and the Sense illustrated with useful Notes and Observations from the best Grammarians (Italics his). 33
(Concise Description 1: 662). Perhaps that comment suggests, especially by the adverb 'now' and the reference to the education at Hawkshead being the same as 'all other public Schools', that the Dyche grammar has been abandoned and that Hawkshead has taken on the typical academic regimen of a standard public school: 'Eton Grammars', both Latin and Greek, and very probably composing verse in Latin.34 To return to Wordsworth and his use of translations, we find that possibly his earliest classics text is Phaedrus, Fabularum Aesopiarum Libri Quinque, 1765. 35 This text is preserved in the Swarthmore College Library. It provides an intricately arranged but literal translation of Phaedrus' version of Aesop's tales; its manner of presentation is similar to that of Dyche. In the front part of the book at the left side of each line of each tale are to be found numbers running from one through six or seven as determined by the number of words in each line of Phaedrus' verse. The numbers indicate the place for each word if grammatical English word order were to be employed. In the back of the text is a special vocabulary where each word stands alphabetically but verbatim, that is, as it stands in the text - not changed to nominatives or principal parts. Tale and line numbers are provided. The particular meaning of each word in each and every one of its contexts is given and each word is parsed as it stands in each context. The students get both full, idiomatic translation and a full explanation of how the word achieves the meaning assigned to it in each instance of its use. In his preface to the Phaedrus, the editor-translator N. Bailey is very defensive about doing any translating whatsoever. He pleads that he has used as simple an English equivalent as he could find for the Latin. He wants to be accurate and clear, not figurative, and as helpful as possible. Some may accuse him of making his text too easy for students. He argues that he has not; he maintains that the young need every assistance. He points out that many Latin students have invested five or even six years in the study of Latin with really little to show for their efforts. Bailey contends that the main reason for their slow progress is the great amount of time spent memorizing Latin grammar rules. He insists that his system is much more effective, that it really works (vii-viii). It is interesting to pause over Bailey's comments. For him the goal of Latin study is the reading of the text, not the elaborate mastering of Latin grammar as such. As we shall see, Wordsworth also cared most about the classics for themselves, and he cared deeply about the art of translation. These important components in his relationship to the classics could thus have begun with his earliest texts.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 49
Wordsworth intended to do professional translation or work close to it. In association with Francis Wrangham, he did the 'Imitation of Juvenal' in the mid-1790s (Graver, 'W's Translations from the Latin' 20; PW 1: 32-6, 372-4). This familiarity with Juvenal probably began at Hawkshead since Juvenal was a standard grammar-school author. Thanks to the efforts of Wu, we possibly have the Juvenal translation Wordsworth used. In the school library is a copy of the Stapylton translation in which Wu has discovered the signatures of Robert Greenwood and Fletcher Raincock, contemporaries of Wordsworth, and a signature which could very well be that of William Wordsworth from that time (Wds Reading 1770-1799 79-80). Wordsworth also used a translation of Horace and this is one of the most sophisticated he employed. It would appear certain that he owned at least the second volume of the Christopher Smart translation of Horace (The Works of Horace Translated into English Prose ... Dublin, 1772; Graver, 'W's Translations from Latin' 63; Wu, Wds Reading 1770-1799 76-7). Though a literal translation, this is nevertheless a supple handling of Horace. Smart enhances his treatment of Horace with some excellent annotations, some by Smart himself and some drawn from other classical critics. For example, one favorite critic whom Smart quotes or summarizes fairly often is Richard Hurd, the great eighteenth-century editor and critic of Horace. As we shall see, Wordsworth made a fine art out of a kind of literal translation, a translation which almost matches the Latin and English texts competitively. Finally, both Wu and Graver show that Wordsworth was very familiar with Dryden's translation of Virgil. Wu also shows that Wordsworth and his brothers had clearly used the Pitt translation of the Aeneid (dated 1736; Wu, Wds Reading 1770-1799 140-1). 36 We have seen that in connection with every major author, Wordsworth used a translation. It would seem that such a practice was sanctioned by his schoolmasters. We have also noted that he did no Latin verse composition. In the next section we will take up the implications of these two elements in his education because they figure so explicitly and implicitly in his work with the classics at Cambridge. But here we can pause to realize how consistent such instructional broadmindedness is with the whole procedure of teaching at Hawkshead and the whole fabric of Wordsworth's life during his Hawkshead years. Peake came from a reformed and enlightened Manchester Grammar School. He earned an excellent reputation for Hawkshead (TWT 90) and created a lively academic environment
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
50 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
which enabled Wordsworth to learn and enjoy not only mathematics and classics but also French and even dancing (92-4). Taylor and Bowman, as we saw, also considerably expanded Wordsworth's education through the leaven of contemporary poetry and broad reading (342-7; Jay 28). Gill pays special tribute to the excellent classical education Wordsworth received, its 'humane' character, its power to enable him to love the classics for themselves (27), and especially its demonstration that there was no '"burden of the past"'; there was instead a 'continuum' between the 'Classics prescribed for study' and the literature of his own time. His teachers, 'young enough themselves, perhaps, still [felt] ... some of the enthusiasm they fostered in their pupils' (29). These elements cannot be stressed enough. Wordsworth was educated holistically, by a father who was both a lawyer and a lover of poetry, by Peake, mathematician and student of Purnell, classicist, mathematician, and lover of contemporary literature, and especially by Taylor and Bowman. The one was honors graduate, metaphysician, mathematician, friend and lively foil to Dyer, and generous in sharing his love for contemporary poetry. Taylor was undoubtedly educated holistically by Peake and very probably by William Bennet, Bishop of Cloyne, who, as Fellow of Emmanuel College when Taylor was an undergraduate, lectured brilliantly on the classics and readily and affectionately related them to British literature. 37 Bowman, also an honors graduate, generous with his books, was educated at Trinity College, Cambridge, and tutored by the excellent scholar William Collier (Regius Professor of Hebrew) who himself was a published poet. 38 Hawkshead provided Wordsworth with the same affection, tolerance, example, and wisdom that he had enjoyed at home at Cockermouth. He was spared the tedium and artificiality of Latin verse composition and was allowed to use translations honestly with the effect that he became a skilled translator himself and a connoisseur of texts. Here at Hawkshead he began to write poetry with an ethical zeal nurtured by the genuineness of the homely but inspired academic world which he so warmly shared.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Mancunian Paradigm, James Peake, Hawkshead 51
Of my earliest days at school I have little to say, but that they were very happy ones, chiefly because I was left at liberty, then and in the vacations, to read whatever books I liked. For example, I read all Fielding's works, Don Quixote, Gil Bias, and any part of Swift that I liked; Gulliver's Travels, and the Tale of the Tub, being both much to my taste. (Auto. Mem., Prose 3: 372) It seems presumptuous to attach much importance to Wordsworth's education when he so disarmingly emphasizes that at its earliest stages at least it was mainly a matter of freedom and reading. It is also interesting to discover that the poet Wordsworth so readily recalls reading so much prose. It seems even more presumptuous to attach importance to Wordsworth's Cambridge education when such an assertion is clearly and even plaintively undercut by his comments in Book 3 of The Prelude: Yet, from the first crude days Of settling time in this untried abode, I was disturbed at times by prudent thoughts, Wishing to hope, without a hope; some fears About my future worldly maintenance; And, more than all, a strangeness in the mind, A feeling that I was not for that hour, Nor for that place. (75-82) 52
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Cambridge and 'knowledge ... sincerely sought and prized / For its own sake'
In a frank passage in Book 3 he accuses himself of being 'a spoiled Child' and unable to accept the 'captivity' which then he equated with 'in-door study' (355, 359, 370). In general his characterization of Cambridge is negative mainly because it failed to build an academic community where disinterested learning mattered before all else (374-401; 449-81). Gill reminds us that Wordsworth did indeed fail to use his opportunities at Cambridge made possible by his Hawkshead education and 'connections who could ease the way to academic and Church preferment' (37). Unfortunately 'within five years' he 'had thrown away every advantage' and despite 'an excellent start he had abandoned serious academic competition, taking only a pass degree' (37). Schneider explains how the system of academic competition or 'emulation' worked at Cambridge (25-39) and cites that and Wordsworth's being socially disadvantaged as causing his alienation, '[m]arked by his gown as a poor boy, eating left-overs from the Fellows' table, ... his culture nullified by his brogue, his gold [was] turned to lead by his station in the new society' (47). Moorman offers the view that Wordsworth's 'dislike [of emulation] was, perhaps, the main obstacle in the way of his obtaining a fellowship'; he was appalled at seeing the 'havoc' which 'the "low and mean" passions' caused when these were roused by competition (1: 96). Gill is sympathetic to the evaluations of Schneider and Moorman, but he also points out that Wordsworth's main reason was 'a resistance to having his life shaped for him by those he did not like and in ways he could not approve' (40). Johnston is much of the same mind as Gill (170-4). I would agree with Moorman and add that too little attention is paid to Wordsworth's eloquent description of what a university should be, a place cherishing 'a conviction of the power that waits / On knowledge, when sincerely sought and prized / For its own sake' (3.391-3). Schneider and Gill, however, both document the serious study Wordsworth gave to classical authors and to poetry. Gill speaks of Wordsworth's 'enjoyment of the Classics as living literature', his extensive reading of English poets, his allusiveness as reflected in An Evening Walk (41-2). Schneider recounts the classical authors Wordsworth studied at Cambridge and discusses major modes of influence they had on Wordsworth's poetry (75-6, 245-7). Wu provides a highly detailed account of Wordsworth's performance in the semiannual examinations he underwent at St John's College (Wds Reading 1770-1799 166-8). These examinations always
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Cambridge 53
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
included a classical text. The College Examination Book gives a list of the texts set for each examination and an evaluative ranking of those who took the examinations. Wordsworth ranked in the '1st Class' once, in the '2nd Class' once; once he is specifically credited with doing well 'in the Classic'; twice he is credited with doing well in the part of the examination he took. In these latter instances, the examinations given in December 1788 and June 1790, from my study of the College Examination Book, I would agree with Wu that Wordsworth very probably discussed and did well in treating the assigned classical texts (Wds Reading 1770-1799 167, 168). Christopher Wordsworth's comments in The Memoirs of William Wordsworth, however, would seem to challenge any claim for Wordsworth's proficiency in the classics. Christopher Wordsworth states, 'Nature appears to have done more for Wordsworth than books ...' He further points out: 'At that time it was not the custom of northcountry schools to exercise their pupils much in classical composition,' and 'Wordsworth was a fair Latin scholar ...' (1: 43; emphasis his). Despite Wordsworth's performance in examinations and his clearly affective relationship to the classics, was he only a 'fair' Latinist? Here it is appropriate to consider the question of Wordsworth's not having done Latin verse composition and the correlative question, did this lack harm the development of an aspiring poet? Perhaps the best answer is Wordsworth's comment to Walter Savage Landor in 1822: In respect to Latin Poetry, I ought to tell you that I am no judge, except upon general principles. I never practised Latin verse, not having been educated at one of the Public Schools. My acquaintance with Virgil, Horace, Lucretius, and Catullus is intimate; but as I never read them with a critical view to composition great faults in language might be committed which would escape my notice; any opinion of mine, therefore, on points of classical nicety would be of no value .... (LYl: 125) Wordsworth seems almost smug; delivered of the burden of verse composition, he is free to enjoy the classics for themselves and became 'intimate' with many major poets. This love of the classics is a major characteristic of his relationship to the literature of Greece and Rome and a fine testimony to the excellent and liberal regime when he was at Hawkshead. His expression 'intimate' has an affective ring and reminds us of his affective ideal for university learning. Verse composition was required by the school's statutes of the '"Cheifeste
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
54
Schollars"' (qtd in Cowper 480), but this prescript does not seem to have been enforced in Wordsworth's time. Very basic Latin composition, the '"making of Latins'", had become a really major feature in English classical schools generally from the sixteenth century (Watson, En. Gram. Schools 401-12). Clarke points out that verse composition in Latin and Greek became more and more widespread as the eighteenth century progressed, despite the protests of some schoolmasters (Cl. Ed. 46-8). Wordsworth did do some Latin prose composition; regular themes were required when he was at St John's College.39 He possibly refers to these exercises in Book 6 of The Prelude: 'Misled, in estimating words', because of 'the trade in classic niceties, / The dangerous craft of culling term and phrase / From languages that want the living voice' (107-11), he admits to having used the classical languages in some kind of compositional work. Owen, in commenting on this passage, notes Wordsworth's letter to Landor. Owen also suggests that Wordsworth may be referring to the general practice in schools of using a work like Gradus ofParnassum, a popular English-Latin phrase book used for Latin composition (14-BK Prelude 114). Owen cites Coleridge's Biographia Literaria where, in a manner of speaking, Coleridge glosses Wordsworth's comment on 'classic niceties' in The Prelude. Coleridge is speaking of Gray's imitating Shakespeare and Milton, and of how such a poetic process really seems to result in a 'style of poetry, which I have characterised above, as translations of prose thoughts into poetic language'. This style of poetry had been kept up by ' the custom of writing Latin verses, and the great importance attached to these exercises, in our public schools' (Biog. Lit. I: 20-1). Coleridge credits Wordsworth with having brought out this very idea in conversation and for having expressed it far more competently than Coleridge feels he has been able to do (21). Given Wordsworth's comments to Landor, we can perhaps assume that Wordsworth traded in 'classic niceties' only in doing themes. In any case, Coleridge shows us how opposed Wordsworth was to artificial diction of any kind in poetry. An artist who created poetry as made from 'a selection of language really used by men' (Prose 1: 123) would hardly approve of verse concocted from phrase books. Given Wordsworth's strong and theoretically grounded opposition to Latin verse composition, it is undoubtedly just as well that he was not forced into such an artificial exercise. Wordsworth's freedom from doing Latin poetry, I would argue, should be coupled with his use of translations. Together these
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Cambridge 55
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
elements encourage a textuality in Wordsworth of the highest order. The use of translations is an interesting and complex feature in the history of classical education in England especially in the seventeenth century. 40 This accommodation appears to have helped Wordsworth become, not only much more than 'a fair Latin scholar', but a gifted Latinist. It would seem that from his ready access to and extensive use of translations, Wordsworth developed his interest in the art of translation and turned this interest into a major venue for distinguished poetic achievement. Graver has given us the most comprehensive treatment to date of Wordsworth's skill in translating Latin poetry. 41 But for easy access to Wordsworth's achievements in classical translating, the Hayden edition of Wordsworth's poetry is helpful here because it gives the poems chronologically and enables us to realize the prominence of translation in his early work. Hayden gives six translations and one partial translation among the first 24 poems, that is, up to An Evening Walk, published in 1793 (1: 37-76, 921-6). In the Landon-Curtis Cornell edition, Early Poems and Fragments, 1785-1797, 59 pages are devoted to Wordsworth's fragmentary translations from the Georgics alone (588-647, DC MSS. 2, 5, 6, 7). Wordsworth apparently had no intention of doing a systematic translation of the Georgics (614), but some translations are quite good (for example, Georgics hi.75-94: The Thoroughbred Horse, 625-7; see also Graver, 'Georgic Beginnings' 154-9). These fragments are one more instance of the high quality and seriousness of Wordsworth's classical study at Cambridge. He may not have been disinterested totally; some passages appeared in his verse eventually (Graver 141-3); and he certainly shows consistent skill and dedication. Of the Latin translations in Hayden, two are from Catullus and two are translations of sections of Virgil's Georgics. These are all fine pieces. The twenty-fourth poem in the Hayden sequence is titled 'Ode to Apollo' (1: 76). This is identified by Hayden (1: 926) and Graver ('Words. Translations' 170) as Wordsworth's translation of Horace's 'Quid dedicatum poscit Apollinem' (Odes 1.31). This is dated by Graver as 1788, done not long after Wordsworth had begun his studies at Cambridge. In his article 'Wordsworth and the Romantic Art of Translation', Graver also discusses a translation done by Wordsworth in 1794, the famous Horatian ode 'O fons Bandusiae' (Odes 3.13). These two translations are important specimens of Wordsworth's work and both are very good. Graver comments that they are 'among the most graceful poetic translations of Horace in our language' (170).
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
56
In the first we have a translation done shortly after Wordsworth had completed his education at Hawkshead and in the second one done about three years after he had completed his bachelor's degree at Cambridge. Thus translations continued to be a part of Wordsworth's classical education. He did not use them to make the classics easy, but found in them the intimate secrets of the stylistic nature of classical literature. In his discussion of these translations, Graver shows that they differ from each other very much. In his translation of the 'Quid dedicatum poscit Apollinem' (Odes 1.31), 1788, Graver praises Wordsworth for his 'subtlety' in his 'understanding of Horace's spirit...' (170). Graver shows that Wordsworth's translation is excellent but somewhat free, 'by treating the Latin freely, he retains an implicit Horatian idea more fully than literal translation would allow' (171). But there are additions to Horace's ideas and other changes which Wordsworth introduces in his translation, though perfectly consistent with eighteenth-century ideals of translation and made so that Wordsworth can use a particular verse form, yet they also hint at a possible weakness in Wordsworth's command of his language. Perhaps in 1788 his skill as a poet was not fully enough developed to fit Horace's ode into this kind of stanza. (171) In discussing Wordsworth's translation, 1794, of Horace's 'O fons Bandusiae' (Odes 3.13), Graver shows how much more literal Wordsworth's translation is, 'following the Latin almost line for line' (172). For example, Wordsworth manages to catch a number of Horace's qualities of sound, even 'the predominant liquid consonants of Horace's poem' (172). What Wordsworth has achieved is a kind of translation very different from that done by Dryden, Pope and others in the eighteenth century: 'The result is an English that is influenced by the sounds and structures of the language of Horace ...' (173). But Wordsworth has done more than modify or even reform the methods of translation typical in the eighteenth century. Actually Wordsworth is using a method of translation which Graver identifies as essentially romantic in character and splendidly described by Goethe in his '"Noten und Abhandlungen" to the West-Ostliche Divan' (169). Goethe speaks of three modes of translation: rendering the text literally, paraphrasing the text, and then, as Graver explains, providing a poetic translation in which the translator seems to have created
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Cambridge 5 7
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
'ein Drittes,' a third something, a language which somehow combines and falls between the native and foreign tongues — the translator infuses his language with a new versatility - rhetorical, rhythmic, metric. Thus in Voss's translation of the Iliad, Homer appears as an 4eingedeutschte Fremde,' a 'be-Germaned foreigner,' not wholly German and not wholly Greek either (169-70) Graver argues that this form of translation, which seeks to preserve as much as possible of the original language in all its texture and idea, is correlative to the basic romantic notion of organicism in style, that is, the necessary identification of meaning with expression, a theory of style which Wordsworth explains so well in his Essays upon Epitaphs. There Wordsworth insists that language in good poetry is not as clothes are 'to the body', but as 'the body is to the soul'. The relationship is one of intimate consubstantiality (Prose 2: 84). Graver elaborates on the Wordsworthian-romantic theory of style: The organic metaphors fundamental to so much of Romantic poetry call into question whether meaning can exist apart from the words which express it. A poem, or indeed any literary work of art, is more than a representation of ideas: it is an imaginative experience, active and ongoing, in which such qualities of language as sound, syntax, and cadence interact with meanings and possibilities of meaning, to move the reader. (173) In his 1794 translation Wordsworth illustrates his command of romantic style by so literally, closely, yet also sensitively translating Horace that Wordsworth 're-creates' in his English translation 'a sense of what it is like to read Horace' in Latin, and he creates this experiential reality 'more fully than did any earlier translator' (173). Thus by 1794, Wordsworth demonstrates his skill in the romantic art of translation, and also amply demonstrates his command of the organic principle of romantic style. Wordsworth never seems to have lost his interest in these principles. My argument is that Hawkshead's genius for tolerance and sufficient academic rigor inspired a special classicism in Wordsworth. The translations are a key example. In his study of Wordsworth's partial translation of the Aeneid into heroic couplets, begun in 1823, and involving only about three books, Graver shows that in this translation also Wordsworth strove to achieve a romantic translation, a true 'ein Drittes'. Even though Wordsworth was disappointed
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
58
Cambridge 59
the translation has been admired by discerning judges, and with good reason: Wordsworth's rendering of Virgil's Latin is remarkably subtle and complex [He strives] not only to make his translation literally accurate, but to make it imitate Virgil's patterns of sound, syntax, cadence, and idea. ('Wds. and Lang, of Epic' 261) As in his consideration of Wordsworth's 1794 translation of 'O fons Bandusiae', Graver points out in his discussion of the Aeneid that Wordsworth's method of translation is related to his concern for the romantic notion of organic style, but Graver also points out that Wordsworth's doctrine and practice in translation are related as well to his theory of diction as expressed in the Preface to Lyrical Ballads: In Lyrical Ballads, Wordsworth reacted against artificial diction by treating subjects from rustic life in diction that was correspondingly simple and plain. Similarly, in his translation Wordsworth ... attempts to choose words and ornaments that are most faithful to the character of the original poem. In the case of Virgil that meant adhering to Virgil's diction more closely than did his predecessors, and being more faithful to Virgil's 'genuine ornaments.' (263) Graver points to Wordsworth's correspondence with Lord Lonsdale in 1823-24 as an excellent source for Wordsworth's discussion of his Aeneid translation. In his letter of 17 February 1824, Wordsworth says that in his translation he hoped to produce a work which should be to a certain degree affecting, which Dryden's is not to me in the least. Dr. Johnson has justly remarked that Dryden had little talent for the Pathetic, and the tenderness of Virgil seems to me to escape him. Virgil's style is an inimitable mixture of the elaborately ornate, and the majestically plain and touching. The former quality is much more difficult to reach than the latter, in which whoever fails must fail through want of ability, and not through the imperfections of our language. (LY I: 253; emphasis his) Wordsworth next expresses his concern that he has translated a passage near the end of Book 1 poorly (Aeneid 1.752). Wordsworth
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
and admitted failure, Graver sees much merit in it. He notes that
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
refers to Dryden's translation of this passage as 'meanly' done, but he frets that he in turn has been 'harsh and bald' (254). Graver has shown how important are Wordsworth's interest and skill in translations. The Aeneid translation is the longest work Wordsworth did after completing The Excursion; it is a work Wordsworth devoted himself to with great effort and interest. He abandoned the project because he judged that he had failed in his attempt to recreate in English verse as full a complement of Virgil's 'genuine ornaments' of style as he had hoped (5 February 1824, LY\: 252; emphasis his). But Wordsworth did succeed admirably in demonstrating great skill as a Latinist. One may not be impressed with Wordsworth's performance in his examinations; he did well, not brilliantly. One cannot but be impressed with his talents as a translator; these Graver illustrates clearly and thereby shows explicitly a genuine classical sensibility in Wordsworth ('Words, and Lang, of Epic' 285). 42 Many other twentieth-century scholars, Cooper, Worthington [Smyser], Bush, and others have also demonstrated Wordsworth's great ability in using classical material. 43 I hope to demonstrate the ethical power in Wordsworth's simultaneous lyric and rhetorical impulse. I would urge that this quality is a key to one of his most characteristic classical powers, his use of the ethical proof as detailed in Aristotle's Rhetoric. There, Aristotle claims that 'Persuasion ... achieved by the speaker's personal character may almost be called the most effective means of persuasion ...' (1356a 25). We shall consider this mode of proof in detail further on. Here we should note that skill in using the ethical proof would not make one necessarily a classical rhetorician because Aristotle seeks to base his Rhetoric on universal principles. However, to deploy the ethical proof in all of its Aristotelian scope, and further, to evoke simultaneously correlative reminiscences of Horace, whose poetic doctrine is so close to Wordsworth in its personalism and simultaneous aspiration for poetry of the highest cognitive order, would surely invest one with the credentials of an Ancient. It is these ethical-Horatian achievements which explain to a large degree the classical undersong I find so prominent in Wordsworth. Many scholars like Bialostosky and Altieri have discussed Wordsworth's considerable rhetorical and (as we noted above) classical rhetorical skills, and others like Thomas have shown Wordsworth's talent as a teacher. 44 This he conceived as a major part of his vocation as he explained to Sir George Beaumont: 'Every great Poet is a Teacher: I wish either to be considered as a Teacher, or as nothing' (MY I: 195).
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
60
My concern is with the ethical endeavor, as described by Aristotle, and especially with the persona in Wordsworth's texts, Wordsworth as both rhetor and lyric poet. It is this person who speaks to us, convinces us, and remains even today a major poetic voice. Wordsworth's translations reveal much of his high ethical sense. In speaking of his work in translating part of the Aeneid, Graver comments: Convinced that the affecting power of Virgil's poetry depends upon his style, Wordsworth is endeavoring to reshape his language, in more or less subtle ways, to partake of the nature of the original. ('Words, and Lang, of Epic' 264) Graver maintains that the principle expressed above describing Wordsworth's goal of translating Virgil as faithfully as possible is the same he states in the Preface to Lyrical Ballads with respect to poetic style: I have at all times endeavoured to look steadily at my subject; consequently, there is I hope in these Poems little falsehood of description, and my ideas are expressed in language fitted to their respective importance. (Prose 1: 133, lines 210-13) 45 Wordsworth seeks to be as loyal as possible to Virgil, to capture in English the very qualities of the Latin language as rendered poetically by Virgil (Graver, 'Words, and Lang, of Epic' 261-4, 273-4, 283-5). This endeavor is more than realism or stylistic naturalism. Wordsworth sets out to translate Virgil and charges himself with failure because he could not achieve the fidelity he sought with true artistic appropriateness (261). But we must remember that a Wordsworth seeks to translate a Virgil. I would contend his zeal was hardly misspent. In the translation process Wordsworth secured his own sense of what a truly iconic text great poetry is. This same reverence, this romantic dedication to organicism of style, is reflected in Wordsworth's love of the classics for themselves. In a letter to his brother Christopher, Wordsworth also included congratulations to his nephew Christopher, Jr, for his extraordinary achievements and the honors he received when he earned his undergraduate degree at Cambridge. One of his honors was 'Senior Classic in the Classical Tripos' (8 February 1830, LY II: 201 and footnote). In a second letter also sent to his brother and to Christopher, Jr,
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Cambridge 61
62
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
I should detest your honours if I thought they would cause you to love classical Literature less for its own sake when the stimulus of reading for distinction is withdrawn. But I have no apprehension of this fatal and too common result, in your case. (LY II: 215) These comments remind us of a passage we have already considered from Book 3 of The Prelude where Wordsworth speaks of loving learning for its own sake: Youth should be awed, possessed, as with a sense Religious, of what holy joy there is In knowledge if it be sincerely sought For its own sake (Prelude ['05] 3.396-9) There is an engaging consistency in Wordsworth's attitudes toward education, texts and the classics. Conscience, authenticity, the thing itself, T have at all times endeavoured to look steadily at my subject' (Prose 1: 133), all reflect one strong, dedicated focus. We shall see how this consistency and the moral energy it embodies led to an exalted ethics of poetry and poetic truth. In the Memoirs, Christopher Wordsworth, Jr, Wordsworth's literary executor, speaking of himself, records the following declaration by Wordsworth: To one of his nephews, an under-graduate, he said, 'Do not trouble yourself with reading modern authors at present; confine your attention to ancient classical writers; make yourself master of them: and when you have done that, you will come down to us; and then you will be able to judge us according to our deserts.' (Memoirs 1: 48; emphasis his) There is a touching humility and bracing self-confidence in Wordsworth. He reveres the classics; they are to be mastered; they are ideals, models, embodiments of artistry and wisdom. And yet they invite comparison and even rivalry. They do not daunt Wordsworth, but they teach him, in the words of Horace, 'sapere aude,' to dare to
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Wordsworth again congratulates his nephew and makes the following comment on the classics:
think for himself. Such were his skills and such the quality of his education that he could invite comparison with the classics and confidently go on in his own way. Such was and is the power of the ethical stature in his verse that he can rouse and even endow us with the zeal to do the same. At Cambridge and in the following years, we see how the affection, wisdom, modeling, and tolerance of Wordsworth's education are melded into his respect for texts. The ineluctable beauty of the classics and the freedom especially of his Hawkshead days taught Wordsworth the true dynamic of language 'really used by men' and even the potential of silent poets.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Cambridge 63
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
This page intentionally left blank
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Part II Wordsworth and Horace: Ethos and Poetic Truth
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
This page intentionally left blank
5
Wordsworth's classical undersong is especially to be found in his poetic rendering of what Aristotle identifies as the ethical mode of argument (Rhetoric 1355 b 24). Here Wordsworth and Horace, a classical poet he admired profoundly (Prose 2: 479), are strikingly similar. Before discussing the presence of the ethical argument in Horace and its Horatian analogue in Wordsworth, we should also recall that Aristotle does treat \\Qoq, ethos, extensively in the Poetics (Chapter 15) and in the Rhetoric (II. 12-17, 1389 a -1391 b ; Wisse 36-43), in terms of what we would call characterization of agents in a literary work or in terms of the means whereby an orator can appeal to different character types, classes of people, age groups, and so forth, in his/her oration. Horace is also concerned with proper characterization in poetic texts, as Brink has shown so well (Prolegomena 110-13, 139-40, 144, 251-2). But our focus is with the ethical appeal as delineated by Aristotle in the Rhetoric, as it exists in two of Horace's literary epistles, especially in the Epistle to Florus, and the degree to which Horace as author and as the persona particularly in that work embodies the principles of Aristotle. Brink shows interest in some related Aristotelian elements such as Horace's concern 'to link appropriateness of emotional styles with real emotion' (The 'Ars Poetica' 188). However, I have not found any critic applying the elements of the ethical proof as such directly to Horace. Let us recall Aristotle's definition of rhetoric: Rhetoric may be defined as the faculty of observing in any given case the available means of persuasion. This is not a function of any other art. (1355b 24)
67 10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics
68
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Of the modes of persuasion furnished by the spoken word there are three kinds. The first kind depends on the personal character of the speaker [the ethical proof]; the second on putting the audience into a certain frame of mind [the pathetic proof]; the third on the proof, or apparent proof, provided by the words of the speech itself [the logical proof]. (Rhetoric 1356a 24-5; see also Brink, Prolegomena 82-3) In explaining the ethical proof, Aristotle comments, 'Persuasion is achieved by the speaker's personal character when the speech is so spoken as to make us think him credible' (1356a 25). Argument based on the character of the speaker is really crucial in those issues 'where exact certainty is impossible' (25). He also points out that the ethical proof 'may almost be called the most effective means of persuasion' (25). In his commentary, Grimaldi gives a translation of this passage which identifies the ethical proof as the most important rhetorical proof: '"the fact is that r)0og, practically speaking, carries the most authoritative jriaxig"' (Rhetoric I 42; emphasis his). In a further discussion, Aristotle names the ethical triad: 'There are three things which inspire confidence in the orator's own character ... good sense, good moral character, and goodwill' (1378a 91). Rhetorical demonstration, that is, the three fundamental modes of persuasion referred to above, is artistic or textual because it functions in the speech itself, not extraneously to it, as do 'witnesses', legal documents, and so forth (1355b 24). Thus the three qualities of the ethical proof also are to be verified in the text itself. To be trusted, the speaker must show in the very texture of the discourse, that is, 'by what the speaker says', that the speaker possesses 'personal goodness' (1356b 25). Aristotle also notes that the orator's evaluation, acts of praise or blame, redound to the credit of the orator himself or herself. Our moral worth is measured by the values we esteem (1366a 56). Even in matters of style, ethos can be enhanced; Aristotle gives the example of the ethical force of maxims (1418a 212). l As noted above, one of Wordsworth's strongest classical qualities is his use of the ethical proof as delineated by Aristotle. Thus far neither in Wu's research nor in my own have I found a direct use of the Rhetoric by Wordsworth. I attribute his ethical prowess to his general training in classical rhetoric and in the classics themselves. Though scholars are not unanimous, Brink argues a clear Horatian-Aristotelian
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Let us also recall his threefold structure in rhetorical demonstration:
connection. 2 The Wordsworth-Horace connection, as we have seen, is strong and affectionate (Thayer 29-32, 53-64). The ethical argument in Horace is vital. 3 He verifies it as voice and pursues it in his argument. Horace eloquently and thereby ethically ennobles the status of the poet and stipulates the requisites for the poet's 'good moral character' (1378a 91). We shall examine Horace's equally eloquent and ethical argument for the special nature and worth of poetic knowledge, the poet's 'good sense', and his concern for audience. On these points he is one with and even in advance of Aristotle, and in these issues he and Wordsworth make some of the most appealing arguments for poetry that we have in our common literature. What especially identifies Wordsworth and Horace as brothers in poetry is the ethical zeal in their affection for poetry. To show Aristotle's influence on Horace, Brink focuses on the high status which the Aristotelian critical school afforded the poet. This must have appealed to Horace: Throughout his career as a critic Horace steadily pleaded for professional poetic standards; but he pleaded no less steadily against the divorce of poetry from the activities of the civis Romanus, the vir bonus, the vir sapiens Here [through Aristotle] he found poetics as part of a larger philosophy ... the proximity of the moral and political worlds which still hinted at the function of poetry in the close-knit political scene of the Greek city state. (Prolegomena 235-6) In Brink's explanation of Horace's recourse to Aristotle, we very well could have the basis of Horace's appeal to Wordsworth. His most obvious gift - like Wordsworth's - is the lyrical, the expressive, but in his critical doctrine he privileges the genres of drama and epic; the lyrical as envisioned by Horace often clearly aspires to the vatic, the rhetorically humanistic and the social (Prolegomena 221, 228). Aside from determining the degree of influence of Aristotle on Horace, there is abundant evidence that Horace fully shared in the dominative rhetorical concern so prominent in the whole tradition of Greco-Roman poetry. 4 This rhetorical bias plus his zeal for the status of the poet and poetry impelled his ethical concerns and fired his eloquence in behalf of his vocation. One of Horace's most striking ethical considerations of the office of poet comes in his Satires, specifically Bk I.iv.5 Here Horace seems to deny that the language of everyday life and ordinary experience and the very ordinary experiences themselves can constitute fit material
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 69
for poetry. In talking about his satires, Horace seems to assert that he should not be called a poet simply because he can 'concludere versum' ('round off a verse'); nor is one a poet if he 'writes as I do, lines more akin to prose', 'qui scribat uti nos / sermoni propiora' (lines 41-2). Horace then defines poetry and claims that comedy properly speaking cannot be regarded as poetry: ingenium cui sit, cui mens divinior atque os magna sonaturum, des nominis huius honorem. idcirco quidam Comoedia necne poema esset quaesivere, quod acer spiritus ac vis nee verbis nee rebus inest, nisi quod pede certo differt sermoni, sermo merus. (Satires I.iv.43-8) If one has gifts inborn, if one has a soul [more] divine and tongue of noble utterance, to such give the honour of that name. Hence some have questioned whether Comedy is or is not poetry; for neither in diction nor in matter has it the fire and force of inspiration, and, save that it differs from prose-talk in its regular beat, it is mere prose. (53) How amazing it would have turned out in the history of literature if the satires of Horace, some of the best satires we have, had not been regarded as poetry. Furthermore, what if comedy too had been excluded from poetry? Horace hardly seems serious, or at least he is to be taken ironically. Further on, he comments rather wryly, 'Hactenus haec: alias iustum sit necne poema', 'Of this enough. Some other time we'll see whether this kind of writing is true poetry or not' (I.iv.63, 53). Brink comments that the assertion of Horace that true poetry must be filled with passion - even in Horace's own terms - has relevance for 'some kinds of poetry' (Prolegomena 163; emphasis his). In this context Horace wishes to deny that poetry is 'playing with words in verse'. Also, Horace does not really wish to demean satire so severely, 'the argument is resolved into uncommitted irony' (Prolegomena 164). Horace does not say that a special or indeed an elegant language is required for poetry, but simply that an authentically impassioned language is required, a language which flows from a spiritually charged soul, a language which has 'the fire and force of inspiration'. Wordsworth says much the same when he locates poetic discourse
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
70 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
democratically in the 'metrical arrangement [of] a selection of the real language of men in a state of vivid sensation' (Prose 1: 119), language which bespeaks 'the essential passions of the heart' and language which is 'more permanent, and a far more philosophical language' (Prose 1: 125).6 In Horace's Epistle to Florus we find this inspired, lofty ideal of poetry argued as being especially found in the sincere passion of the poet and in the authentic language used by the poet. I would call Horace's theory of authentic diction for poetry so crucial that it amounts to philological poetics, but a poetics demanding a seamless fabric of authentic emotion, passion and utterance. To put Horace's theory of poetry and diction into proper context, we should recall that his epistles share the familiar structure and tone of his satires. However, the epistles are affirmative, never obscene, and are filled with advice and discussion. The three so-called Literary Epistles, because of their emphasis on strictly literary topics, alone constitute Book II of the Epistles. The Epistle to Augustus was completed in very probably 12 BC and the Epistle to Florus in 19 BC; the one to Augustus is placed first because of the prestige of the addressee. The Epistola ad Pisones, or Ars Poetica, was probably done around 10 BC (Rudd 1-21). The addressee of the Epistle to Florus is Julius Florus, a lawyer in the retinue of the future emperor Tiberius. He was a poet, a friend of Horace, and had asked Horace to send him some poetry (Rudd 13). Horace's reply in his verse letter is basically 'a series of excuses', begun wittily, as to why he had not written and especially why he had not sent any poetry to Florus.7 Finally in line 106, of a poem of 216 lines, Horace gets to his major reason for not writing poetry, as the tone changes from the elegantly witty to the quietly reflective. From here to line 125, Horace speaks of the labor involved in writing really good poetry. Next, from line 126 to the end of the poem (especially from line 141 on), Horace pleads his second major reason for not writing poetry: at his age he should devote what is left of his life to the study of philosophy, not to the frivolity of writing lyric verse. Rudd gives an excellent summary showing how this poem is structured 'as a series of pleas a characteristically Roman feature' (17, 14-18). I would emphasize the paradox that the affective brilliance of this poem lies in the irony in Horace's poetic arguments for not writing poetry, especially as expressed in the poignant, mature sensibility of the last two arguments. The poem begins as a series of seemingly friv-
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 71
olous excuses offered to a young poet by a tired, older practitioner. Awe for poetry and reverence for the poet's vocation gradually come to the fore. Horace ends his poem with a priestly tribute to poetry and to the vatic ideal of a true poet. The Epistle to Florus is a masterpiece of ethical poetry in two ways: a poet in retirement self-deprecatingly pleads in elegant verse that he is no longer equal to the demands of his art; a humble poet protests the superiority of philosophy to poetry and yet does so in verse a part of which Brink calls 'philosophical poetry' (Epistles Bk. II522). Brink calls Horace's position here a 'fiction' and calls the Epistle to Florus 'a highly wrought poem' (266). I would go much further than Brink. I see much more than 'philosophical poetry'; I see the Epistle to Florus as a text sustaining autotelic poetic epistemology. In the section quoted below, lines 106-25, we have our first argument concerning poetry and the poet, especially beginning in line 109, 'qui legitimum cupiet fecisse poema', 'But ... [the poet] whose aim is to have wrought a poem true to Art's rules' (433). First we should consider this statement in its full context quoted below: Ridentur mala qui componunt carmina; verum gaudent scribentes et se venerantur et ultro, si taceas, laudant quidquid scripsere beati. at qui legitimum cupiet fecisse poema, cum tabulis animum censoris sumet honesti; audebit, quaecumque parum splendoris habebunt et sine pondere erunt et honore indigna ferentur, verba movere loco, quamvis invita recedant et versentur adhuc intra penetralia Vestae; obscurata diu populo bonus eruet atque proferet in lucem speciosa vocabula rerum, quae priscis memorata Catonibus atque Cethegis nunc situs informis premit et deserta vetustas; adsciscet nova, quae genitor produxerit usus. vemens et liquidus puroque simillimus amni fundet opes Latiumque beabit divite lingua; luxuriantia compescet, nimis aspera sano levabit cultu, virtute carentia toilet, ludentis speciem dabit et torquebitur, ut qui nunc Satyrum, nunc agrestem Cyclopa movetur. (Epistles Il.ii. 106-25)
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
72 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Those who write poor verses are a jest; yet they rejoice in the writing and revere themselves; and, should you say nothing, they themselves praise whatever they have produced - happy souls! But the man whose aim is to have wrought a poem true to Art's rules, when he takes his tablets, will take also the spirit of an honest censor. He will have the courage, if words fall short in dignity, lack weight, or be deemed unworthy of rank, to remove them from their place, albeit they are loth to withdraw, and still linger within Vesta's precincts. Terms long lost in darkness the good poet will unearth for the people's use and bring into the light - picturesque terms which, though once spoken by a Cato and a Cethegus of old, now lie low through unseemly neglect and dreary age. New ones he will adopt which Use has fathered and brought forth. Strong and clear, and truly like a crystal river, he will pour forth wealth and bless Latium with richness of speech; he will prune down rankness of growth, smooth with wholesome refinement what is rough, sweep away what lacks force - wear the look of being at play, and yet be on the rack, like a dancer who plays now a Satyr, and now a clownish Cyclops. (433, 435) Scholars have noted the emphatic legal reference in this poem (Rudd 13). The expression legitimum ... poema, 'a poem done according to the precepts of art' (my translation), reflects a metaphor derived from the various applications of lex, and such applications, as one can readily see, are easily carried to the arts (Brink, Epistles Bk II 330). I would suggest that as Horace speaks to Florus, a poet to a poet who also happens to be lawyer, the evocation of lex or law is crucial. Rudd, emphasizing the notion of 'censor' here, reminds us, without stating it, that Horace offers another reason, a legal reason as it were, for not writing poetry. It is an exalted skill to be practised according to standards, 'conditions or procedures that constitute an art' (Brink, Epistles Bk II330). Poetry makes legitimate demands; it cannot be done capriciously; it is not simply a matter of inspiration. Here, then, we have an honest and knowing declaration of the strongest ethical stature. Horace may be playful in refusing to send poetry to his friend, but he reminds us that it is an art which has demanding standards. The poet's responsibilities which Horace lays out in this section, especially from lines 111 through 119, are, as Brink notes, concerned with diction, 'Words, ... ordinary ... archaic ... [and] new' (Epistles Bk II 331; emphasis his). I would underscore the ethical force of his care about language. Horace, though presumably speaking only to Florus,
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 73
really opens his text to the service of his readers, his audience in the broadest sense. In each instance where the task of the poet is described philologically, there is a humanistic aspect which is emphasized as well. Here we find the humanistic seeds of Wordsworth's egalitarian 'language really used by men'. With these concerns in mind, I would like to comment on five other key terms used in the context: splendor (line 111, splendoris); pondus (line 112, pondere); honore (line 112, honore); obscurata (line 115, obscurata); speciosa (line 116, speciosa). In our context the work of the poet is first laid out negatively. The poet is to 'remove' 'words [which] fall short in dignity' (433) ('parum splendoris'), regarded as worn-out in effect by Brink (Epistles Bk II 332); '[words which] lack weight' (433) ('sine pondere'), and words which are 'deemed unworthy of rank' (433) ('honore indigna ferentur'), rendered as '[words enjoying] a "position, recognition" of which they are not worthy' by Brink (Epistles Bk II 333). In addition, the poet is to 'unearth' (435) '[t]erms long lost in darkness' (435) ('obscurata'), and 'bring into the light - picturesque terms' (435) ('speciosa vocabula rerum', line 116).8 In all of these examples the text refers to words, some to be removed and others to be unearthed and brought into usage. But what we have is a positive catalogue of values derived from or related to aesthetic technique and the highest forms of human achievement. The poet is to be a master of words whereby he or she is to make real the splendor (brightness, lustre, clarity, nobility) of the pondus in human nature (weightiness or firmness morally considered in human character) and the honor in human beings (honor, esteem, public office, tribute, beauty). The poet's task is to make verbally real the grandeur in human nature, but to make that grandeur aesthetically splendid in the highest sense of aesthetic and human meaning. The poet's vocabulary also requires the revitalization of the obscurata (that which has been darkened or suppressed or made obsolete). It requires especially the speciosa vocabula rerum, words for things which expose and express and luminously display by shape and figure and idea the full beauty of the person or thing recounted. In all of this process Horace seems to be stipulating as the chief task of the poet the uncovering and the elucidation in words of the highest human values of the highest order. Also, the social-linguistic history of the race is required to stamp or thus confirm the pondus and honor of individual experience. Therefore, the obscurata must be revitalized and a social ancestry, as it were, established. In all of this the speciosa vocabula are crucial as the language of the poet because the poet's primary daedal
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
74 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
office is precisely to use the speciosa to make luminous and therefore socially inspiring the pondus and honor the poet seeks to expose and express. Brink summarizes the goal of the poet in this process as 'intensity and lucidity' (Epistles Bk II 328). In his commentary on this section, Brink has several notices of the social function of the poet; for example: in reference to 'censoris' (line 110), he speaks of 'the censor in the social field' (Epistles Bk II 332), of the possible 'social connotation' of 'pondere' (line 112) (333), the 'patriotic note' connected with 'Latiumque' (line 121) (342), and so forth (328-48). My concern is to point out that one of the most appealing features of this poem is Horace's profound and eloquent ethical zeal in delineating the office of poet. To these I should like to add the following gloss on line 120 which speaks of the poet as a social benefactor and uses the image of a river: vemens et liquidus puroque simillimus amni, 'Strong and clear, and truly like a crystal river, he [the poet] will pour forth wealth and bless Latium with richness of speech' (435). Horace's philological poetics embodies in the linguistic achievements of the poet simultaneously the highest form of poetic art and humanistic value. Here the vatic function of the poet is eloquently tied to language, and it is especially tied to speech, that part of language which the cives share collectively as the most obvious part of their cultural existence. The vates gives language as a voice to the people. Horace, the enthusiastic Augustan poet, has not lost his basic republicanism. This will prove to be a major connection with Wordsworth. The ethical ramifications are also important here. Implicitly the reading audience feels empowered as it is reminded that public speech is enhanced by poetic art. We emphasize the poet's function here encouraged by Brink's comment on line 120, 'By an easy metonymy, the qualities of the poem are seen as those of the poet' (340). I would add that Horace provides a foundation for Wordsworth's theory of poetic language as 'selection' (Prose 1: 125). In the Ars Poetica Horace assigns similar ethical responsibilities to the poet with a similar degree of artistic and social earnestness. There is the famous section on usage and its being the supreme law for language (AP lines 60-72). But this injunction comes after Horace has urged the poet to use sensitivity in stitching words together so that an old word can take on new vigor in a particular context ('notum si callida verbum / reddiderit iunctura novum', AP lines 47-8). The poet is urged to confect new words provided they are needed, and provided certain principles of etymology and taste are duly observed. After all,
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 75
Horace insists, why cannot a modern poet serve his nation the way Caecilius, Plautus, Cato and Ennius have? Horace emphasizes in this passage the same social and artistic authority of the poet (lines 48-59) which we have just observed emphasized in his letter to Florus. The passage on the ultimate authority of usage as the standard for language is dominated by an extended and vivid meditation on mortality (lines 60-72). The passage is plaintive because of such remarks as 'debemur morti nos nostraque,' 'We are doomed to death - we and all things ours' (line 63, p. 455). The passage ends with the famous declaration that language, like everything else, is subject to change and all is as usage determines, 'si volet usus, / quern penes arbitrium est et ius et norma loquendi': all is 'if Usage so will it, in whose hands lies the judgement, the right and the rule of speech' (lines 71-2, p. 457). Brink comments extensively on these lines (The 'Ars Poetica' 146-60), and he initiates his remarks with the following declaration: There follows [lines 60-70] what poetically is perhaps the most remarkable piece of the Ars ... Nature presides over natural change Language is related to the unalterable conditions of life: the recurrence of the seasons and the impermanence of the human lot. Hence the sudden rise of poetic tone, to something like the lyric intensity of the Odes .... Ep. II. 2. 111-19 [to Florus] lack this dimension. (146-7) The philosophical power of this passage suggests that Horace is possibly overlooking philology and even poetry itself. In glossing line 71, the expression 'si volet usus', ('as use will have it'; my translation), Brink comments that here Horace 'wants to ... lay stress on the impersonal or "natural" features of language' (158). Rudd, in glossing 'usus', employs the expression 'norms of educated speech' (162). I would also note that we cannot forget that Horace is dealing with speech, language, 'norma loquendi' ('the rule of speech' [line 72]) and thus, by implication, with poetry. Though Horace seeks to emphasize the impersonal power of language, he also emphasizes that language lives on the human tongue. Furthermore, both here and in his Epistle to Florus, he insists that there are ways in which the poet can influence language as such as the poet seeks to enhance the language of good poetry. The poet's task is to bring the 'speciosa vocabula rerum' (line 116) into currency and in this way he/she will 'bless' ('beabit,' line 121), or as Brink
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
76 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
suggests '"quicken, enrich"' or even '"delight"' (Epistles Bk II 342) the poet's own nation and culture. I would stress the ethical inspiration in this passage because the poet so honestly and honorably dedicates him/herself to the task of recognizing the objective power and dynamic of language and especially its social character and value. Here Horace wins his audience because he honors the communal and natural character of language, and yet he empowers both commonwealth and poet by arguing that there is an artistic way the poet can raise natural language into the 'speciosa vocabula rerum'. So it is that Horace would have the poet enrich the tongue of the commonwealth. One final point: if Horace stresses the office of the poet to bless his or her nation with bounteously rich expression, then necessarily Horace must believe with Wordsworth in the condign potential of 'a selection of language really used by men' (Prose 1: 123) for poetry. If a poet is called to so endue the speech of the nation, then the speech of the nation, its native potential in utterance, must be fit to receive this poetic endowment. The native linguistic core must be apt for poetry. And furthermore, this poetry when ingested and when informing native utterance is more than decoration or an elegant bauble. Thus 'legitimate' poetry enables the people to speak and voice their will with power concerning the most crucial issues in their total polity. This vatic ordinance is clearly at the heart of Wordsworth's critical doctrine. The Epistle to Florus is a master-work which luminously demonstrates the stature of the poet because Horace does not merely claim that status, he demonstrates it by the very elegance of his verse. But the ethical proof redounds to the nation and to poetry itself. They too, people and the art, possess an ethos, and it is these ethical repositories which Horace has also enriched. Our next concern is with poetic sincerity, a popular and contemporary credential for establishing the full honesty of the poet and the full authenticity of the text. 9 Meyer Abrams cites as a major source for the emergence of romantic expressivism a line in the Ars Poetica which begins 'si vis me flere' (Mirror 71-2). The full passage is one of the most famous texts in Horace: Non satis est pulchra esse poemata; dulcia sunto et quocumque volent animum auditoris agunto. ut ridentibus arrident, ita flentibus adsunt humani voltus: si vis me flere, dolendum est
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 77
78 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
primum ipsi tibi: tune tua me infortunia laedent, Telephe vel Peleu; male si mandata loqueris, aut dormitabo aut ridebo.
Not enough is it for poems to have beauty: they must have charm, and lead the hearer's soul where they will. As men's faces smile on those who smile, so they respond to those who weep. If you would have me weep, you must first feel grief yourself: then, O Telephus or Peleus, will your misfortunes hurt me: if the words you utter are ill suited, I shall laugh or fall asleep. (459) Abrams shows that the expression 'si vis me flere, dolendum est / primum ipsi tibi', '[i]f you would have me weep, you must first feel grief yourself,' became a rhetorical commonplace. Over the years it was related to and used as an illustration and pivotal maxim arguing the importance of the 'evocation of feeling' as that principle became crucial in poetry. Abrams provides several examples of how the expression has been used in English literature and how it was related to poets and their task to be ethically convincing. He cites the splendid example of Samuel Johnson's comment on Cowley's elegy for Lord Hervey: "There is much praise [in this poem], but little passion ... When he wishes to make us weep, he forgets to weep himself..."' (72). Thus in this passage we clearly see Horace as a major proponent of authorial sincerity. Also from the context we have quoted, we should notice Horace's insistence on sincerity of characterization. As voice in his own poem, Horace calls out to two typical characters in Roman drama, Telephus and Peleus, that their expression must be in keeping with their character, that they must clearly feel what they speak or he as audience will sleep or laugh. This passage and the next six lines (that is, lines 99-111) would all seem to reflect a notion commented on by Brink with respect to lines 108-11, 'the psychology of style'. Horace is concerned in this passage 'to link appropriateness of emotional styles with real emotion - a doctrine of poetic sincerity, a rarish thing in ancient literary criticism' (The 'Ars Poetica' 188). Before leaving Horace's exemplification of the principle of sincerity, we should stress emphatically once again the extended commentary by Williams on the high quality and the sincerity of Horace's political
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
(99-105)
poetry (Tradition 79-101). Octavian was able to inspire Augustan poets to such an extent that they were convinced 'that they had a real place and function in society' (51). Horace's 'most original contribution to Roman literature' was his direct use of 'the form of lyric poetry to make political statements' (76). Williams also stresses that Horace 'is the poet, above all, of human relationships' (83). When these elements are put together, one can understand how, even in political verse where sham would seem almost a necessity, Horace could create poetry which is both excellent and honest, pragmatic, lyrical and true. Again we can see the appeal of Horace to Wordsworth. Both are lyric poets; Horace cherishes the Roman-Augustan ideal and Wordsworth aspires to do The Recluse. The ethical ideal we have so far considered in Horace involves his arguments for the exalted status of the poet. A second mode of ethical argument in favor of the poet, also found in the Ars Poetica and in the Epistle to Florus, further enhances the poet's status by claiming a special order of poetic truth. 10 According to Horace, there is a truth, a specific endowment of poetry, quite beyond ordinary human reason. Horace does not pronounce on the nature of poetic cognition; he urges the special nature of poetic insight in poetic terms. Ironically, as was said above, some of Horace's best arguments for the validity of poetic truth are to be found in the Epistles to Florus where he seems to prefer philosophy to poetry. A first step to understanding Horatian epistemology, however, is in the Ars Poetica with its mandate for a fully accomplished poetic mimesis. Horace speaks of the necessity of the poet's learning by serious study, 'Socraticae ... chartae' (line 310), which Rudd glosses as 'meaning, in general, "works on moral philosophy"' (202). Further on, Horace urges his tyro poet, once he or she has become an imitative artist, to look carefully at the exemplary instance of human conduct (lines 317-18). Brink cautions that this requires one to '"scrutinize"' (Horace's 'respicere', line 317), but this passage does not speak of mere 'realism', but a kind of general typology (The 'Ars Poetica' 342-3). He also points to relevant passages in Aristotle's Poetics where mimesis is discussed (Brink 343). Here I would suggest we have an explicit Horatian argument via mimesis for poetic epistemology. By far one of the most moving declamations on poetic epistemology is found in the final 90-line section of the Epistle to Florus, a rendering of Horace's second reason for not writing poetry. 11 Our passage begins with a delightful interval, lines 126-40, a humorous self-burlesque by Horace in which he claims he cares only to be deluded in his poetry
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 79
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
and to care nothing for correction, 'Praetulerim scriptor delirus inersque videri' (line 126), T should prefer to be thought a foolish and clumsy scribbler ... rather than be wise and unhappy' (435). He recounts the happily deceived gentleman from Argos who thought he saw live performances and enjoyed them even though on an empty stage. His friends cured him of his delusions, and the man complained bitterly. He was happier deluded. Horace claims he wants the same fantasizing repose. Clearly Horace argues by masterfully delightful humorous contrast. He also argues by ironic example, self-directed (Brink, Epistles Bk II 348-9). His deprecatory comments remind one of Chaucer. The emphasis is on truth. The truth required in artistic evaluation is just as real as any form of social or human accountability. Artistic standards are not frivolous preferences; art has objective standards; aesthetic delusion is a form of madness; art has its necessary truth to tell (Brink, Epistles Bk II 516). The humorous tone of these last 15 lines is carried over even as we enter the most serious section of the whole poem. Here Horace declares his intention to seek wisdom, to abandon the useless toys of lyric verse, and take up the serious work of moral philosophy: Nimirum sapere est abiectis utile nugis, et tempestivum pueris concedere ludum, ac non verba sequi fidibus modulanda Latinis, sed verae numerosque modosque ediscere vitae. quocirca mecum loquor haec tacitusque recordor (141-5) In truth it is profitable to cast aside toys and to learn wisdom; to leave to lads the sport that fits their age, and not to search out words that will fit the music of the Latin lyre, but to master the rhythms and measures of a genuine life. Therefore I talk thus to myself and silently recall these precepts (437) Horace has hardly abandoned his sense of humor. He speaks in the first line of becoming wise and casting aside toys, the nugis, '"childish frivolities," in particular his lyric poetry' (Rudd 140). But more to our purpose, when speaking of moral philosophy, he describes it in elegant musical, philosophical and poetic terms, verae numerosque modosque ediscere vitae (line 144, 'to master the rhythms and measures
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
80
of a genuine life' 437). The musical elements are reminiscent of Pythagorean and Platonic metaphors for the moral life (Brink, Epistles Bk II 359-60; Rudd 140). Brink also sees the poetic reflected here, 'numeros ... modos (vitae): "way of life" understood in musical and poetic terms' (Epistles Bk II 360). It is significant that if Horace were serious about abandoning poetry, he would hardly choose musical metaphors whereby the same terminology is shared by philosophy, music and poetry. The musical terminology is also reminiscent of lyric poetry, among the ancients almost always associated with music. It is lyric poetry which Horace supposedly has abandoned (Lyne 186-7). But I would contend that what he is actually doing is characterizing philosophy through poetry. As his supposed repudiation of poetry comes in poetry, so his honoring of philosophy, and moral philosophy at that, comes in musical-poetic metaphors. Horace subtly unfolds an epistemological hierarchy. He bends philosophy to poetry by defining it through a pattern of poetic terms; poetry becomes dominant. From lines 146 through 179, Horace takes on a serious yet ironic tone. He meditates on the foolishness of avarice and concludes, using much legal terminology, that ownership - even when established most reconditely - is useless. Nothing is of any avail: 'Death reaps great and small - Death who never can be won over with gold ...' (lines 178-9, p. 439). I am much impressed with what I find to be the brilliant irony running all through this section. Brink (Epistles Bk II 360-82) and Rudd (16-17, 140-4) do not comment much on this point, but Brink offers a general statement on the Epistle as a whole: that Horace may claim he has abandoned poetry, but he has done so in 'a highly wrought poem' (266; see also 412). And yet the irony is so luminous in the account of death's victory that Horace gives us, not baleful lament, but elegant poetry which today for us has the ring of romantic elegy. The last 36 lines of the poem start out as a discussion of moderation. Despite the inevitability of death, Horace is neither depressed nor burning with determination to make what remains of his life count in a particularly spectacular way. He speaks with calm good humour. He does not say his meditative powers have overcome the menace of death or the threatening finality of change. Horace simply speaks with a modest, lyric warmth as he moves to acceptance and repose. The final 12 lines of the poem are especially poignant. They take us back to the reality of death, and yet they also maintain in lively good humor the tone of acceptance and repose we have just encountered:
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 81
Non es avarus: abi. quid? cetera iam simul isto cum vitio fugere? caret tibi pectus inani ambitione? caret mortis formidine et ira? somnia, terrores magicos, miracula, sagas, nocturnos lemures portentaque Thessala rides? natalis grate numeras? ignoscis amicis? lenior et melior fis accedente senecta? quid te exempta iuvat spinis de pluribus una? vivere si recte nescis, decede peritis. lusisti satis, edisti satis atque bibisti: tempus abire tibi est, ne potum largius aequo rideat et pulset lasciva decentius aetas. (205-16) You are no miser. Good! What then? Have all the other vices taken to flight with that? Is your heart free from vain ambition? Is it free from alarm and anger at death? Dreams, terrors of magic, marvels, witches, ghosts of night, Thessalian portents - do you laugh at these? Do you count your birthdays thankfully? Do you forgive your friends? Do you grow gentler and better, as old age draws near? What good does it do you to pluck out a single one of many thorns? If you know not how to live aright, make way for those who do. You have played enough, have eaten and drunk enough. 'Tis time to quit the feast, lest, when you have drunk too freely, youth mock and jostle you, playing the wanton with better grace. (441) In this last section Horace challenges himself and Florus too with a series of moral inquiries. The fact that he may not be avaricious is of no moment if he fails in other regards like being superstitious or fearful of death or unforgiving of his friends. Then comes the splendid passage, vivere si recte nescis, decede peritis (line 213, 'If you know not how to live aright, make way for those who do' 441). Next follows the banquet imagery, reminiscent of Lucretius, which possibly suggests, but not necessarily, that Horace wishes to abandon life and accept death (Rudd 149-50). Brink does not read this last passage bleakly. Horace has told Florus all along that the reason he has sent him no poetry is especially that he must drop poetry and take up philosophy. As was noted above,
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
82 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Brink suggests that there is irony here because Horace's declaration of abandonment of poetry comes in a poem (Epistles Bk II266, 402). I would insist that all through the poem we have a masterful illustration of Horace's self-deprecating irony. He protests that he can write no more poetry because excellent verse seems beyond his talents, and this protest itself is rendered in elegant verse at many times quite above and beyond the chatty nature of a mere letter. He also claims that he prefers delusion and yet expresses his claim in conjunction with a brilliantly rendered anecdote. The sophistication of the rendering suggests the most knowledgeable of raconteurs. It is the consistent, suave irony melded into a metrical text of equally suave modulation that makes this such excellent poetry. Horace attacks avarice and does so by using legal jargon as he shows the fatuity of even legally protected possession. Even when Horace speaks of implacable death, he uses such masterful expression that he, Horace the poet, subdues to poetry that which he theoretically claims cannot be subdued. His poetry contradicts his theory by its own immortal power of expression coupled with its engaging metrical cadences: quidve Calabris saltibus adiecti Lucani, si metit Orcus grandia cum parvis, non exorabilis auro? (177-9) - what avail Lucanian forests joined to Calabrian, if Death reaps great and small - Death who never can be won over with gold? (439) The rhetorical questions Horace asks are typical enough; their traditional philosophical import is clear. They answer themselves. Nothing does or can matter if all ends in death. Brink takes Horace's image of lives being hauled off in a manner like the reaping of grain back to Euripides. Death as 'reaper' provides 'a lyric or epic touch'. Further on, Brink says that his 'Orcus, mowing his victims down with a scythe, is a composite Graeco-Roman figure, and a highly effective one at that' (Epistles Bk II 381-2). My point is that these elegant measures and these lucid poetic figures, this dominative topping of poetic tradition, elevates moral preachment to self-motivated poetic mosaic. I mention Brink because he reminds us of how sophisticated and
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 83
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
literary and mythologically traditional - yet vigorous - Horace's figure is. I would argue that Horace has created an absolute order of poetic truth. Good images, tellingly imaginative figures are not in themselves sufficient to create an epistemology. Figurative material is practically as available to rhetoric and to a degree as available to scientific discourse as it is to poetic discourse. What raises the poetic discourse here to epistemological status and authority is the contextual density of the literary self-reference. When the expression and cadences of a text are so overtly, self-consciously and successfully literary, then the meaning enjoined asserts a literary or poetic epistemology. When the tenor of a passage or an entire text projects a truth which is organically and inextricably embodied in a vehicle ontologically literary as such, then we have poetic truth epistemologically realized as such. I am much indebted here obviously to Northrop Frye: In all literary verbal structures the final direction of meaning is inward In literature, questions of fact or truth are subordinated to the primary literary aim of producing a structure of words for its own sake, and the sign-values of symbols are subordinated to their importance as a structure of interconnected motifs. Wherever we have an autonomous verbal structure of this kind, we have literature. (1048) Wimsatt's notion of the 'concrete universal' is also relevant here. He joins that notion to his theory of objective criticism and proves most helpful to our endeavor to uncover the idiosyncratic way in which a literary text means and the way in which it is known: In each poem there is something (an individual intuition - or a concept) which can never be expressed in other terms. It is like the square root of two or like pi, which cannot be expressed by rational numbers, but only as their limit. Criticism of poetry is like 1.414 ... or 3.1416 ... , not all it would be, yet all that can be had and very useful. (83) Kinneavy provides a short but excellent critique of Wimsatt (317). Kinneavy also discusses a whole range of critical theories which treat the nature of the literary object (307-43). He is very careful to locate his relationship to Abrams' famous presentation in The Mirror and the Lamp (310-11, and passim). My use of Frye and Wimsatt may suggest I read in Kinneavy's terms Horace as a formalist (333-43) or a mimeti-
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
84
cist (313-320), respectively. However, as I hope to show ahead, I find Horace quite beyond these schools of critical theory. In his reference to Orcus (line 179), Horace gives us a wonderful picture of death, and yet presents it in so sublimely a literary mode that it can be contemplated profoundly without threat or sense of menace. The final word auro bespeaks its essentially literary cast excellently. Its humor, coupled with the upside-down legalese of the entire context, reminds us that we are indeed dealing with change, mortality and death in a speculative context but with a literary provenance. It is like Aristotle's comment on imitation and so many critics' commentaries on aesthetic distance or meaning; we can consider the reality intimately, enjoyably, as Wordsworth maintains (Prose 1: 139-40), but we are not necessarily threatened thereby. Horace's whole performance in this poem is like his description of the implacable nature of Orcus; he gives us such a masterful performance which is particularly realized by his irony. Thus, even if it could be convincingly argued that the banquet imagery is such that Horace feels compelled to depart from this life (Rudd 149-50), we would protest. Brink observes that 'here the call is to life, philosophical and moral.' Our wily poetic comrade is most assuredly a peritus vitae, an expert at living. He has made moral philosophy into a fine art. Here again Brink is most valuable: H[orace] demonstrates, from within as it were, what makes great poetic art great and how that quality renders the making of such poetry both worthwhile and very difficult — The poem succeeds in that the reader is made to feel and understand that the two aims [of poetry and philosophy] are not really incompatible. Its [that is, the poem's] poetry appears clearly the best vehicle for its [philosophical] conclusions. This is an outstanding example of philosophical poetry as H[orace] saw it — (Epistles Bk II 522) Brink speaks of the fusion of philosophy and poetry, or the compatibility of poetry and philosophy or, as Brink expresses it, 'philosophical poetry'. What I am suggesting is quite different. Epistemology refers to the way we know. In his letter to Florus, Horace says that the poet blesses the nation through an endowment of language. This endowment, I claim, must mean ideas of a special kind embodied in a perfectly realized mode of expression. Brink suggests that the poetry is the vehicle and the philosophy is the tenor. I would urge that the poetry is both vehicle and tenor at once.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
Horatian Poetics 85
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
A parallel emerges with the poet posing as deluded and then demonstrating his sophisticated skill as a raconteur. Here we have irony and actually an ironic way of knowing. One could claim this process as primarily rhetorical, but the subject and subject-matter are a poet and the way aesthetic truth should affect the poet. The voice is a poet illustrating on at least two levels of irony simultaneously how hard the truth about one's self as an artist is to acquire, live with, and use, and how ironically only a sophisticated artist in many ways would realize and be capable of using such truth when acquired. The same kind of irony, as has already been noted, operates in the musical-poetic imagery and the legalese and the elegance of the picture of Orcus. The use of irony as a mode of thought complements the supreme irony of using elegant poetry to disavow poetry for philosophy. I do not think we have philosophical poetry. I think Horace gives us poetry quite on its own and quite superior to philosophy. Nothing that is known in this entire poem - even at the highest philosophically moral level - could be known unless conceived poetically. The truth here as apprehended and specifically conceived, the intelligible species as such, is ontologically poetic. Horace claims that a poet has 'gifts inborn ... a soul divine and tongue of noble utterance'. Poetry must possess 'fire and force of inspiration' (Satires I.iv.43-6, 53). To be so masterfully and lyrically ironic in dealing with the most serious human issues, to do so with such understanding and delicacy, to build a single text with such poised, poetic cadences, all this gives us poetry as truth kindled with the white fire of special genius. Wimsatt comments: '"A poem should not mean but be." It is an epigram worth quoting in every essay on poetry' (81). I would insist, however, that there is meaning in the elegant Epistle to Florus, a meaning typical in quality of all Horace's great poetry, a meaning as absolute in its own order of being as that found in Mozart's great G minor symphony or in Beethoven's late quartets. In Horace we have meaning which excites but is quite beyond even legitimate paraphrase; meaning quite beyond the dialectics of aesthetics. In the Epistle to Florus Horace inscribes the nature of poetry in a structure and mode of expression rich in evocations of Parnassus.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
86
6
Geoffrey Hartman recently assigned a somewhat doubtful future to the study of poetry: The reading, writing, and also viewing of novels will continue. But already the reading of poetry, though not the writing of it, is jeopardized. Poe thought that a long poem was a contradiction: lyric nuggets held together by prosy passages. My recent experience as a teacher tells me that even midsize poems are now a contradiction to students. ('Fate of Reading Once More' 388) One hopes that there is at least a touch of irony somewhat reminiscent of Horace in Hartman's dark prediction about the reading of poetry. But what is interesting and certainly true to the experience of those who teach, there is much poetry being written. And here we fondly recall Harold Bloom's ringing assertion: Wordsworth has begun something new, something that keeps on beginning, despite all the waves of modernism, postmodernism, or what you will. In the longest perspective that we can achieve, the supposedly sober and tame Wordsworth remains the most original and disturbing poet of the nineteenth or the twentieth century. (138) Is the secret of Wordsworth's perduring power a strength of poetic presence that is challengingly new and yet somehow familiar? Is he read today for the same reason that poetry continues to be written, that the poetic act is so fundamental it is almost compulsive and the poetry closest to that basic impulse is still cherished in 87
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The Mind of the Poet
88 Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
[A] characteristic excellence of Mr. W's works is: a correspondent weight and sanity of the Thoughts and Sentiments, - won, not from books; but - from the poet's own meditative observation. They are fresh and have the dew upon them. His muse, at least when in her strength of wing, and when she hovers aloft in her proper element, Makes audible a linked lay of truth, Of truth profound a sweet continuous lay, Not learnt, but native, her own natural notes! S. T. C. (II: 144-5; emphasis his) Coleridge also speaks of Wordsworth's 'perfect truth of nature' (148), his 'austere purity of language' (142), 'sinewy strength and originality of single lines and paragraphs' (148), 'meditative pathos, a union of deep and subtle thought with sensibility' (150), and finally 'imaginative power' where 'he stands nearest of all modern writers to Shakespeare and Milton; and yet in a kind perfectly unborrowed and his own' (151). There is a linguistic but especially a cognitive emphasis which stands out in this catalogue. Wordsworth's originality is stressed, but his stature is confirmed in terms of the capacious giants Shakespeare and Milton. In effect Coleridge gives us an ethical account of Wordsworth's powers, especially his feeling commitment to truth and with truth, 'meditative pathos ... [and] sensibility'. Here I find Coleridge also speaking of sincerity, honesty of commitment. It is this combination of appeals which possibly has led scholars to notice a third appeal in Wordsworth, his call to his readers to share in his very act as poet. Nabholtz urges that such a sharing is characteristic of romantic prose generally and certainly of Wordsworth's famous Preface ('My Reader My Fellow-Labourer' 69-80). He even sees the 'identification of prose reader as poet' (76). Bialostosky speaks of how, according to Wordsworth's doctrine in the Essay Supplementary, such 'passion and power' can be diffused by the poet that 'the external
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
an otherwise increasingly barren age? Certain key elements help explain our ready attachment to Wordsworth. A truly important one of these is named by Coleridge in his famous discussion of Wordsworth's poetry in the Biographia Literaria:
effort of producing critical discourse, making new poems, ... or committing political acts' can result (Wordsworth, Dialogics 16). Meisenhelder argues much the same (233-5). Is Wordsworth's attraction a rousing of the creative energies of his readers? Is the eloquent conclusion to the Prelude a call from Wordsworth to Coleridge to share their work as poets with people at large? Prophets of Nature, we to them will speak A lasting inspiration, sanctified By reason, blest by faith: what we have loved Others will love, and we will teach them how, Instruct them how the mind of Man becomes A thousand times more beautiful than the earth On which he dwells, above this Frame of things (Which 'mid all revolutions in the hopes And fears of Men doth still remain unchanged) In beauty exalted, as it is itself Of quality and fabric more divine. (14.446-56) Much critical discussion has been devoted to this passage. Havens offers a helpful comment on the term 'Nature' (14-Bk Prelude, 14.446); he reminds us that Wordsworth probably never regarded 'himself as primarily a poet or prophet of external nature; "the Mind of Man" was the main region of his song' (2: 637). In invoking the Prospectus, he anticipates Abrams' discussion of Wordsworth's master poetic purpose (Nat. Supernat. 17-32). Also commenting on the conclusion of The Prelude, Thomas emphasizes that Wordsworth intends 'to teach his readers how to love, or how to think, and not what to think', and that in this emphasis on manner we have 'the heart of Wordsworth's ideas about poetic education' (3; emphasis his). Jonathan Wordsworth regards 'the poet's bravura' (emphasis his) in this passage as rather sad, 'to be valued chiefly in its poignancy' (Borders of Vision 338). I find that this passage recalls the enthusiasm of Wordsworth's and Coleridge's shared idealism in Somerset. But Wordsworth let the passage stand, and if it does not speak necessarily for Coleridge, it does announce Wordsworth's sustained determination to make his poetry serve a public purpose. His appeal now, to us in our time, could surely reflect how well his purpose and means have coincided.
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The Mind of the Poet 89
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Wordsworth's success is not the achievement of didacticism, despite his declaration in a letter to Sir George Beaumont, 'Every great Poet is a Teacher: I wish either to be considered as a Teacher, or as nothing' (MY I: 195). Coleridge is undoubtably right: the main appeal of Wordsworth was and continues to be 'perfect truth of nature', moving expression, and the genius of imagination. And there is something else, his position as poet. His call to his readers to share his vocation is a major element in the power of his truth, and this is so because of his clear moral stature as poet. The appealing aspects we have just recounted in Wordsworth by now have a familiar ring, the characteristic Aristotelian ethical values. But one wonders if Aristotle's doctrine is relevant in our time. Before explicating Wordsworth according to Aristotle, we should note that the use of the ethical proof in strictly literary analysis has grown significantly in our time. In my Appendix, I give a sampling of recent studies. 12 Here let me comment on one element in one of the studies discussed fully in the Appendix. In his dissertation, Cherry offers a helpful distinction between empirical author and implied author, and so forth; we shall simply predicate the ethical values we discover in Wordsworth to Wordsworth as empirical author. Certain nuances should be noted as to the relationship between Wordsworth as empirical author and possible personae in his works. Because this is such a large question, and because ethical predication should be assigned to the empirical author (we follow Cherry here), we will leave the issues of implied author and Wordsworthian personae mainly untouched. We will still note, however, some aspects of his polyphonic character. His reverence for authentic poetic language inspires his candor and also his subtlety as he discloses himself with a fascinating variety in his texts. The Preface to Lyrical Ballads is one of our most important critical statements. Its doctrines have been debated for almost two hundred years, but I think that the key to its appeal lies in the feisty exuberance of its voice. The drama of that voice as it champions a new creed in poetry is largely the drama of a contender, one minute defensive, somewhat unwilling, a bit embarrassed at having to undertake an apologetic task, and the next moment insistent, almost stentorian, then confessional, vulnerable, and then lyrical and Delphically engaging. The Preface, as we noted, is one of the great canonized documents in English literature, but we must approach this text with a degree of caution. Heffernan, one of Wordsworth's most sympathetic critics, has reservations:
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
90
The Mind of the Poet 91
Parrish is much more positive. The Preface 'remains a remarkably literate, coherent, and rich analysis of what Wordsworth felt throughout his career to be the central topics of criticism' (10). Parrish emphasizes the 'rhetorical' purposes and character of the Preface (10-11). Nabholtz offers a careful analysis of the Preface as a highly successful rhetorical piece. It may not yield itself easily to logical scrutiny, but in all fairness such analysis misses 'the integrity of the work as rhetoric and as apologia' (80). Nabholtz is especially helpful in noting the ethical force of the Preface; though he does not explicitly cite Aristotle or discuss the elements of the ethical proof, he does speak of Wordsworth's 'ethical appeal' (73) in the 'exordium' or first 'five-paragraph introduction' to the Preface (72). But it is Nabholtz's use of 'apologia' (80) and his overall view of the 'means' of the Preface in achieving its goal, to 'establish the credibility of the writer' (71; emphasis his), which show his awareness of much of Wordsworth's ethical endeavor. 13 My main concern is the ethical stature of Wordsworth as voice in the Preface. I read the Preface as more in the vein of celebratory or epideictic rhetoric. In part Wordsworth is apologetic, but mainly his 'arguments' are thinly supported, impassioned and eloquent assertions. The rhetoric I find in the Preface is that of Henry V's St Crispin's speech or John of Gaunt's 'This England'. The Preface neatly divides itself as each major ethical issue is urged. Wordsworth starts, taking up vigorously the first requisite of ethical argument, the task to establish his honesty as chief voice in the Preface. This endeavor begins with his declaration of purpose for Lyrical Ballads, 'The first Volume of these Poems ... was published, as an experiment ...' (lines 14-15) 14 and runs through the first eight paragraphs (184 lines) of the Preface. Wordsworth's chief concern is to explain what Lyrical Ballads attempts as poetry and what he hopes to accomplish in the Preface by way of defense of his verse. Wordsworth's tone is frank and insistent but also winningly self-effacing. Immediately, even in these first paragraphs, a pattern emerges followed throughout the Preface. Where Wordsworth is concerned to establish his personal veracity, as it were, he uses the first person and
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The Preface simply does not have the homogeneity of a schematic treatise. More than an ephemeral outburst and less than a definitive account of the poetic art, the Preface is in fact the mirror of a mind in motion, at once the mind of a rebel who came to destroy and the mind of a poet who came to fulfill. (56-7)
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
speaks with almost a confessional candor. Where he is occupied in formal argument, he uses the third person. But as we shall see, the sections devoted to self-authentication provide an inspiriting tonality which echoes in and enlivens the more cognitive sections with a modulated but warm personalism. The Preface begins quite defensively in the first person. As Nabholtz points out, 'these "introductory remarks" are rhetorical and apologetic' (71). But it is the personalism that gives these lines their winning tone. The third paragraph offers a disclaimer. It begins with a familiar and homely appeal: 'Friends', out of respect for the poet's achievements in this poetry, urged him to do an elaborate defense. Naturally he must demur, but he does not do so before planting a vigorous claim for the value of Lyrical Ballads as an ultimate poetic standard. The poet hides himself as he voices this claim through the mouths of others. His 'Friends' urged him, from a belief, that, if the views with which they [the poems] were composed were indeed realised, a class of Poetry would be produced, well adapted to interest mankind permanently, and not unimportant in the quality, and in the multiplicity of its moral relations: and on this account they have advised me to prefix a systematic defence of the theory upon which the Poems were written. (28-33) Wordsworth's argumentative ploy is all too familiar; it is impossible not to use it sometime in one's life. Here we catch and possibly approve Wordsworth's candor - that he would risk being so openfaced gives a relaxed familiarity to his text; the very homeliness of his argumentative ploy enhances his sincerity far more than would a sophisticated argument. Here we can expect argument without guile. Wordsworth must refuse an elaborate defense, though, because he realizes how 'coldly' (34) his attempts would be viewed, 'the selfish and foolish hope of reasoning' his audience 'into an approbation of these particular Poems' (36-7; emphasis his). Furthermore, space forbids his doing a logically rigorous defense that would require discussing such items as 'the present state of the public taste' (42) and 'in what manner language and the human mind act and re-act on each other, ...' (44-5). He 'therefore [has] altogether declined to enter regularly upon this defence ...' (47); but it would be 'something like impropriety' not to say something in explanation or 'introduction' (he does not use the word defense here) to 'Poems so materially differ-
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
92
ent from those upon which general approbation is at present bestowed' (48-51). Wordsworth is hardly suave in making his excuses, but he is very definite in limiting the responsibilities of his defense. As Nabholtz and others point out, he does defend himself despite his disclaimer.15 But the style of his refusal is still quite effective. His honesty is shrewdly evidenced by his image of how 'coldly' any defense would be viewed. We sympathize with him and the charge of potential prejudice is cheerfully borne by us, his readers. We are impressed at how his mind can anticipate learned objections and the dimensions of proper learned explanation. We are glad, however, to be delivered from such theoretical disquisition. We are intrigued, finally, because Wordsworth admits the risk of 'impropriety' if he does not say something. His 'Poems [are] so materially different ' This procedure is typical of so much of the first-person, gangling rhetoric of the Preface. As expected in the elaborate but obvious demur, Wordsworth frees himself from potentially threatening burdens, but he also placards a bold claim for his poetry. He reveals his honesty, shows intellectual acuity in acknowledging problems involved in a fully detailed defense of his poems, and thus we come to respect his character and his defense - the novelty of his poetry, so self-effacingly declared, guarantees this - but we are also eager, if warmed at all to the challenge of his endeavor, to hear him out and do so all the while we contend against our potential for prejudice. We have noted already in Stephen Parrish's reading of the Preface, 'Wordsworth's poetic tactics and his critical pronouncements taken together make it clear that poet and reader are joint participants in the experience of literature' (32). As we have also seen, Nabholtz is of much the same mind (76). This is clearly demonstrated in our paragraph, but what is amazing is Wordsworth's skill in luring us into bearing the rhetorical burdens so willingly. But I would contend that we are lured, not as laborers, but as sympathetic confidants. All Wordsworth asks is a friendly hearing. Wordsworth becomes rather defensive16 in the fourth paragraph with a somewhat pompous declaration of literary principle. Here we have the third-person declarative counterpart to Wordsworth's firstperson confessionalism: It is supposed, that by the act of writing in verse an Author makes a formal engagement that he will gratify certain known habits of association This exponent or symbol held forth by metrical
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The Mind of the Poet 93
94
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Wordsworth frankly admits that his readers may very well charge him with violating the conventions of verse even though these conventions evolve in time and create sequentially different legitimate bodies of expectation. Wordsworth realizes that readers will experience 'strangeness and awkwardness' (69) because they will not recognize his verse as poetry (64-71). Thus he begs to be allowed to state what I have proposed to myself to perform;... that I myself may be protected from one of the most dishonourable accusations which can be brought against an Author; namely, that of an indolence ... [not knowing] his duty, or, when his duty is ascertained, ... [not] performing it. (72-80) It may seem strange that a poet seeking 'to destroy' (Heffernan 56) would be so preoccupied with, almost daunted by, the conventions of poetry, historically apprehended. He returns to the first person and admits the strangeness of his work, but he wants to place it somehow in that tradition. We respect his candor and his professional knowledge. We also feel flattered that he cares that his readers see him as struggling to align himself with legitimate aesthetic expectation. His fear of the charge of 'indolence' seems sincere. It is a valuable reference. The charge necessarily lurks in any context where the new is heralded and a competing artistic tradition must be challenged. It is so easy for a contending voice to sound flippant. Wordsworth censoriously comments on 'the gaudiness and inane phraseology of many modern writers' and speaks of those who would condescendingly 'inquire by what species of courtesy these attempts can be permitted to assume that title' of poetry (lines 66-71). However, we are inclined to allow him his peevish tone. He has already pleaded for our tolerance. Especially, though, we hold our judgement because his conscience is clearly aroused, his respect for his audience truly genuine, as he frets over 'one of the most dishonourable accusations' an author can face, 'indolence', failure to perform his professional 'duty'. Such self-effacing concern for audience and tradition in a context where an author projects a new kind of artifact
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
language must in different aeras of literature have excited very different expectations: for example, in the age of Catullus, Terence, and Lucretius, and that of Statius or Claudian, and in our own country, in the age of Shakespeare and Beaumont and Fletcher, and that of Donne and Cowley, or Dryden, or Pope, (lines 52-61)
is rare and highly engaging. As audience, we are comrades in his defensive process - just as Parrish and Nabholtz have observed. But we feel an intimacy as we become privy to his fervor and vulnerability. And here we feel the lyrical as well as ethical power of Wordsworth. He has won our respect. With the dominance of the third-person declarations and the classical references to the Roman writers Catullus, Terence and Claudian, this paragraph has a strong classical heft. It provides an austere, tempering prelude, a kind of learned Doric frame, for the four absolutely crucial and distinctively Wordsworthian paragraphs that follow, paragraphs 5, 6, 7 and 8 (lines 81-184), which perhaps more than any other critical texts define Wordsworth and much of English literary romanticism for the academic and even the popular mind. Paragraph five declares Wordsworth's 'object... [as] proposed in these Poems' (81) and retails, particularly as the text reads in its final version, the special materials so characteristic of his poetry, 'incidents and situations from common life' (82), 'a selection of language really used by men' (83-4), 'the primary laws of our nature: ... [as] we associate ideas in a state of excitement' (88-90). Paragraph six contains Wordsworth's famous definition of poetry rendered as part of an elaborate defense of the 'worthy purpose' to be found in each poem (123; emphasis his). Paragraph seven, shortened in the final version, has his famous justification of feeling, 'feeling therein developed gives importance to the action and situation, and not the action and situation to the feeling' (147-9). Paragraph eight expands on Wordsworth's doctrine of feeling, his 'endeavour to produce or enlarge' the domain and the health of human feeling (158-9). The critical commentary is extensive on Wordsworth's purpose, choice of rural life and 'language really used by men', his definition of poetry and doctrine of feeling.17 Our concern is with the ethical dimensions of these paragraphs and the possibility of their fulfilling Coleridge's claim that among Wordsworth's strongest appeals are 'weight and sanity of the Thoughts and Sentiments' (II: 144) and correlatively a 'perfect truth of nature' (II: 148). We should expect to be foiled in our quest. Coleridge famously criticized many of the theories in these paragraphs, though he concedes that Wordsworth is to be praised for, among many things, his attack on 'falsity in the poetic style of the moderns' (II: 40). Coleridge disagrees with Wordsworth's theory of diction, 'language which actually constitutes the natural conversation of men' (II: 42). He objects to Wordsworth's focus on
10.1057/9780230595750 - Wordsworth's Classical Undersong, Richard Clancey
Copyright material from www.palgraveconnect.com - licensed to Universitetsbiblioteket i Tromso - PalgraveConnect - 2011-03-18
The Mind of the Poet 95
Wordsworth's Classical Undersong
Tow and rustic life' (II: 43). Practically the whole of Chapter 17 of Biographia Literaria II is devoted to criticism of Wordsworth on these points. And yet, despite the negative commentary by Coleridge and others especially on the issues of common life and common language, we are intrigued because we are implicitly touched by the ethically generous view Wordsworth takes of the materials and agents in the poetic act. His democratic and attempted philosophic inclusion perhaps reveals why these Wordsworthian paragraphs have generated so much interest. If Stephen Parrish is right, the Preface gives us 'a remarkably literate, coherent, and rich analysis of what Wordsworth felt throughout his career to be the central topics of criticism' (10). The paragraphs will exhibit that rich analysis in a special way. The first of the especially 'Wordsworthian' paragraphs, paragraph five, beginning with 'The principal object, then, proposed in these Poems ... ,' is dominated by the rather grand, third-person impersonality of some of Wordsworth's best theoretical declamation. Nabholtz indicates that this paragraph shows 'in full play' the 'rhetorical procedures' so far clearly shown in 'the exordium' (74). I do not see a clearly classical procedure here. I see much classical reference and many classical figures, but I find an overall argumentative pattern made up of first-person confessional avowal and third-person insistent pronouncement without much formal argument even of an enthymematic character. In this paragraph, Wordsworth declares his special purpose in doing the poetry of Lyrical Ballads and the special rationale he cherishes for focusing on country life and rural folk. I quote from the beginning of the shorter 1800 version and the longer 1850 version from the Owen and Smyser text: 1800 The principal object then which I proposed to myself in these Poems was to make the incidents of common life interesting by tracing in them, truly though not o