Wool: Science and technology
Other titles in the Woodhead Publishing Limited series on fibres, published in association with The Textile Institute: Series Editor: Professor J E McIntyre Bast and other leaf fibres Cotton: Science and technology High-performance fibres Regenerated cellulose fibres Silk, mohair, cashmere and other luxury fibres Smart fibres, fabrics and clothing Synthetic fibres
Wool: Science and technology Edited by W S Simpson and G H Crawshaw
Cambridge England
Published by Woodhead Publishing Limited in association with The Textile Institute Woodhead Publishing Ltd Abington Hall, Abington Cambridge CB1 6AH, England www.woodhead-publishing.com Published in North America by CRC Press LLC 2000 Corporate Blvd, NW Boca Raton FL 33431, USA First published 2002, Woodhead Publishing Ltd and CRC Press LLC © Woodhead Publishing Ltd 2002 Chapter 9 and Chapter 11 © The Woolmark Company 2002 The authors have asserted their moral rights. This book contains information obtained from authentic and highly regarded sources. Reprinted material is quoted with permission, and sources are indicated. Reasonable efforts have been made to publish reliable data and information, but the authors and the publishers cannot assume responsibility for the validity of all materials. Neither the authors nor the publishers, nor anyone else associated with this publication, shall be liable for any loss, damage or liability directly or indirectly caused or alleged to be caused by this book. Neither this book nor any part may be reproduced or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, microfilming and recording, or by any information storage or retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publishers. The consent of Woodhead Publishing and CRC Press does not extend to copying for general distribution, for promotion, for creating new works, or for resale. Specific permission must be obtained in writing from Woodhead Publishing or CRC Press for such copying. Trademark notice: Product or corporate names may be trademarks or registered trademarks, and are used only for identification and explanation, without intent to infringe. British Library Cataloguing in Publication Data A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data A catalog record for this book is available from the Library of Congress. Woodhead Publishing ISBN 1 85573 574 1 CRC Press ISBN 0-8493-2820-9 CRC Press order number: WP2820 Cover design by The ColourStudio Typeset by SNP Best-set Typesetter Ltd., Hong Kong Printed by TJ International Ltd, Cornwall, England
Contents
Preface List of contributors
xi xiii
1
Wool production and fibre marketing w s simpson
1
1.1 1.2 1.3 1.4 1.5 1.6 1.7 1.8 1.9 1.10 1.11 1.12 1.13 1.14 1.15 1.16
General introduction World wool production Wool harvesting Clip preparation Participants in the wool trade Wool sampling Fibre diameter Fibre length Wool colour Bulk testing Dark fibre contamination Specification of woolscour deliveries Computer blend selection Wool promotion The Fernmark brand Marketing of distinctive wool types References
1 3 5 5 5 11 13 14 15 16 16 17 18 18 19 19 20
2
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment l a halliday
21
2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 2.5
Introduction Nature of contaminants Historical overview of scouring methods Unit operations Scouring chemistry
21 21 22 23 33 v
vi
Contents
2.6 2.7 2.8 2.9 2.10 2.11 2.12 2.13
Development of scouring systems Chemical treatments in woolscours Drying Solvent scouring Woolgrease and its recovery Effluent Process control and quality assurance Energy conservation References
35 39 42 45 46 49 55 56 57
3
Fibre morphology h höcker
60
3.1 3.2 3.3
Introduction General chemical composition Composition and structure of morphological components of wool Outlook References
60 61
4
Physical properties of wool j w s hearle
80
4.1 4.2 4.3 4.4 4.5 4.6
The wool fibre Effects of water Observed mechanical properties Structural mechanics Electrical properties Yarns and fabrics References
80 80 84 106 118 122 126
5
Wool chemistry w s simpson
130
5.1 5.2 5.3 5.4 5.5 5.6 5.7 5.8 5.9 5.10 5.11 5.12
General introduction Chemical composition Degradation by radiation and heat Photobleaching and photoyellowing Absorption of acids Absorption of alkalis Dyeing with acid dyestuffs Acid, alkali and enzymic hydrolysis Oxidation with peracids Chlorine-based oxidation Reduction Sulphitolysis
130 131 131 132 135 137 139 141 143 145 145 146
3.4
67 76 78
Contents
vii
5.13 5.14 5.15
Metal salts Miscellaneous reactions Crosslinking References
147 150 151 156
6
Mechanical processing for yarn production l hunter
160
6.1 6.2 6.3 6.4 6.5 6.6 6.7 6.8 6.9 6.10
Introduction Worsted processing system Preparation for spinning (drawing) Semi-worsted processing system Woollen processing system Spinning Twisting Winding, clearing and lubrication Yarn steaming (setting) Top dyeing References Bibliography
160 161 177 180 181 192 206 207 208 208 209 213
7
Chemical processes for enhanced appearance and performance w s simpson
215
7.1 7.2 7.3 7.4 7.5 7.6 7.7 7.8 7.9 7.10 7.11 7.12 7.13
Introduction Bleaching Prevention of dyebath yellowing Insect-resist treatments Shrinkproofing Antistatic properties Flame-retardant wool Photostabilisers Stainblocking Multi-purpose finishes Polymer grafting Removal of vegetable matter by carbonising Setting References
215 215 216 217 219 224 225 226 228 229 230 232 232 234
8
Practical wool dyeing k parton
237
8.1 8.2
Introduction Dyestuff chemistry
237 238
viii
Contents
8.3 8.4 8.5 8.6 8.7 8.8 8.9 8.10 8.11
Dyeing of different substrate forms Classification of wool dyestuffs Commercial forms of dyestuffs Levelness Dyeing fibre blends Treatments to improve colour fastness Environmental issues Fibre protection Summary References
240 242 247 248 251 252 252 256 256 257
9
Manufacture of wool products k russell, d m cdowell, i ryder and c smith
258
9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 9.7 9.8
Introduction Twisting Winding Warp preparation for weaving Weaving yarns Fabric design Weaving machinery Knitting and knitwear Bibliography
258 258 264 266 269 270 273 275 289
10
Carpets, felts and nonwoven fabrics g h crawshaw and s j russell
290
10.1 10.2
Carpets Felts and nonwoven fabrics References
290 304 312
11
Finishing s a myers
314
11.1 11.2 11.3
Finishing of woven fabrics Finishing of knitted fabrics Finishing of knitwear Reference
314 328 330 332
12
Overview of global dynamics in the wool textile industry p d f kilduff
333
Introduction Overview of trends in world textiles
333 333
12.1 12.2
12.3 12.4 12.5 12.6 12.7
Contents
ix
Factors shaping global integration in textiles Overview of trends in wool textile production and trade Factors behind the declining importance of wool and wool textiles Patterns of industry development and adjustment Outlook for the wool textile industry References
335 337 342 349 355 357
Index
360
Woolmark Consulting Group offer bespoke consultancy and a range of services to help you keep ahead of new technology and innovation.
IMPROVED EFFICIENCY Technical expertise to effectively deliver improved efficiency and quality to the wool textile pipeline DELIVERING THE LATEST TECHNOLOGY Constant wool innovation and technology transfer to the industry is vital for growth EXPERTISE Undisputed leader in wool easy care, non-wovens, new blends, vapour management and thermal comfort
For further information e-mail:
[email protected] or contact: The Woolmark Company, Valley Drive, Ilkley, West Yorkshire Tel: +44 1943 886232 Fax: +44 1943 886293 www.woolmark.com www.woolmark.com/consulting
Preface
Werner von Bergen and his collaborators released Volume 1 of their Wool Handbook in 1963, and two further volumes followed soon after. This series was unique in presenting a broad-spectrum description of every pertinent aspect from sheep-raising to wool consumer products. These texts were subsequently enlarged and reprinted in several editions. Another notable previous publication was Wool. Its Chemistry and Physics by Alexander and Hudson, first published in 1954. More recently, two more narrowly focused texts have appeared, both highly valued in industry and academia. They are Maclaren and Milligan’s Wool Science. The Chemical Reactivity of the Wool Fibre (NSW Science Press 1981) and Lewis’ Wool Dyeing (Soc. Dyers and Colourists, Bradford, 1992). The present text is therefore the first attempt in almost 40 years to present a comprehensive view of the wool industry from fibre marketing through to manufacture of consumer products. In Chapter 1, I briefly describe a major overhaul that has occurred of the methods of trading wool, basically moving the entire system from one of individual intuitive skill to one based on laboratory measurements of sale lots. Wool-scouring also has improved enormously in efficiency with a host of small and a few large innovations. Chapter 2 describes this modern technology, which reflects a strong emphasis on environmental concerns such as treating effluent discharges and energy conservation, coupled with far better quality control and capabilities for new add-on processes. Chapters 3, 4 and 5 describe the principal sectors of current wool science. Understanding of wool fibre morphology, and of physical and chemical properties continues to progress and, in doing so, highlights just how intricate and complex is the wool fibre. Instrumentation, now available for isolating and sequencing wool proteins and for determining their structural arrangement, is beginning to offer a better-informed basis for technologists to devise improved wool products and processes. Chapters 6 onwards deal in turn with each major aspect of wool proxi
xii
Preface
cessing technology. I have to say the contributing authors have been, and in most cases still are, working in the heartlands of these industries. Spinning, weaving and knitting are the three really major physical processes. The Chapter on wool carpets exemplifies how one particular consumer product may be woven, tufted, knotted, or needled to create a great variety of pattern and texture. Chemical processes that improve appearance or performance of wool products have been brought together in Chapter 7 to better highlight the technical options available to meet special specifications. The development of synthetic fibres with specialised performance features, allied with higher expectations of consumers, has been a strong motivation for creative new processes for wool. Flameproof protective clothing and antistatic carpets are just two fairly recent examples where wool products meet the most demanding requirements. Wool dyeing innovation is similar to wool-scouring in some respects in that it has been driven by a greater emphasis on energy conservation, shorter treatment times, and better management of effluents, in addition to the publicly more visible competitive demands for high standards of stylish and stable colouration of wool products. The final chapter is intended to put these modern developments in the wool industry into a global context amongst other fibres and textile technologies. I wish to sincerely thank my co-authors for their efforts to make available an up-to-date text for wool technologists, textile students and so many others interested in this old, yet modern, industry. W S Simpson
Contributors
Editors: Dr W S Simpson 19 Longmuir Street Christchurch 4 New Zealand E-mail:
[email protected]
Dr G H Crawshaw Flat 5 Chapel House Wells Road Ilkley West Yorkshire LS29 9JD UK
Chapter 1:
Wool production and fibre marketing Dr W S Simpson, 19 Longmuir Street, Christchurch 4, New Zealand E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 2:
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment Mr Lindsay A Halliday, 145 Bells Road, West Melton, Christchurch RD1, New Zealand E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 3:
Fibre morphology Professor D H Höcker, German Wool Research Institute, 52062 Aachen, Veltmanplatz 8, Germany E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 4:
Physical properties of wool Professor J W S Hearle, The Old Vicarage, Church Lane, Mellor, Stockport, SK6 5LX, UK E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 5:
Wool chemistry Dr W S Simpson, 19 Longmuir Street, Christchurch 4, New Zealand E-mail:
[email protected] xiii
xiv
Contributors
Chapter 6:
Mechanical processing for yarn production Professor Lawrance Hunter, CSIR Division of Manufacturing and Materials Technology, PO Box 1124, Port Elizabeth, South Africa E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 7:
Chemical processes for enhanced appearance and performance Dr W S Simpson, 19 Longmuir Street, Christchurch 4, New Zealand E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 8:
Practical wool dyeing Mr Keith Parton, Clariant UK Ltd, PO Box 42, Calverley Lane, Horsforth, Leeds, LS18 4RP, UK E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 9:
Manufacture of wool products Mr Kevin Russell, Mr David McDowell, Mr Ian Ryder, and Mr Colin Smith, The Woolmark Company, Valley Drive, Ilkley, West Yorkshire, LS29 8PB, UK E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected] [email protected] [email protected]
Chapter 10:
Carpets, felts and nonwoven fabrics Dr G H Crawshaw, Flat 5, Chapel House, Wells Road, Ilkley, West Yorkshire, LS29 9JD, UK, and Dr Stephen Russell, School of Textiles and Design, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK E-mail:
[email protected] [email protected]
Chapter 11:
Finishing Mr Steven A Myers, The Woolmark Company, Valley Drive, Ilkley, West Yorkshire, LS29 8PB, UK E-mail:
[email protected]
Chapter 12:
Overview of global dynamics in the wool textile industry Dr P D F Kilduff, Department of Textile and Apparel Technology, School of Textiles, NCSU, 240 Research Drive, Raleigh, NC 227695-8301, USA E-mail:
[email protected]
1 Wool production and fibre marketing W S SIMPSON
1.1
General introduction
Sheep husbandry is an important pastoral activity across most of Europe, the Americas and Asia. Its purpose nowadays is primarily meat production, although the wool harvest has for centuries been an important basis of local textile industries. European colonisation of large areas of the southern hemisphere suitable for pastoral production led to much larger numbers of sheep and a more dominant emphasis on wool production. A large proportion of the wool harvest from Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, Argentina and Uruguay is exported to textile manufacturers in the northern hemisphere. For about a century (from 1860–1960) these manufacturers were almost entirely to be found in Western Europe. Since 1960, wool manufacture has declined in some of these countries and more volatile trading patterns have emerged. Russia, Japan, Iran and China are some of the countries that have fluctuated between minor and major importers of southern hemisphere wool. Another trend, which gathered momentum since the end of the 1939–45 war, has been the drive for greater productivity from textile machines and consistent high-quality standards for textile products, so that standardised raw material is demanded. This turned the spotlight on wool marketing practices. Competition from synthetic fibres intensified. Their prices were usually stable, or actually reduced as the scale of production increased. Particularly important were technological advances in converting petroleum gases into reactive monomers suitable as starting materials for synthetic fibre production. Moreover, the consistent and precisely specified properties of synthetic fibres were very much in harmony with the ability to finetune textile machinery for high production rates. In the face of this growing competition it was inevitable that the historic reliance of buyers and sellers of raw wool on intuitive judgement and experience in making trades came under pressure for change. Basically, the onus for developing, testing and implementing more sophisticated wool 1
2
Wool: Science and technology
marketing systems fell mainly on Australia and New Zealand. Australia is by far the dominant producer of fine Merino wool and accounts for almost half the quantity of wool worldwide that comes onto the open market. The Australian Wool Corporation (AWC), over the approximate period of 1950–1990, chaperoned the wool producers towards more efficient fleece preparation, and the wool trade into more efficient wool handling, packaging, transportation and sale methods. The AWC would also fund a considerable portion of the R&D efforts of Australian CSIRO scientists who were to verify new test methods and develop equipment for wool-brokers and test houses. In Australia, numerical specification of wool would focus on those measurements of most importance to the worsted industry. New Zealand had a closely parallel responsibility as the predominant producer of crossbred wool for open sale. These wools, in many respects, posed a greater problem in sampling and testing because of the greater variability within and between sale lots and the diversity of end-uses. Although carpets were mainstay products after the 1939–45 war, considerable segments of the crossbred wool clip were destined for woven and knitted clothing, blankets, furnishing fabrics and many other products. In similar fashion to the AWC role in Australia, the New Zealand Wool Board (NZWB) encouraged the wool trade to participate in trials of new marketing procedures, and contributed a high proportion of funds to enable scientists at the Wool Research Organisation of New Zealand (WRONZ), formally incorporated in 1961, to develop sampling and testing methods and equipment, as well as scientific, manufacturing and product research relevant to coarser wools. The numerical specifications would emphasise those features of most importance for spinning on the woollen system. By about 1990, almost all the testing and marketing procedures had been implemented in both Australia, New Zealand and South Africa. The last had a very similar fine wool profile to that of Australia and co-operated very closely in all aspects of wool testing, adoption of standards and marketing procedures. The regular meetings of the International Wool Textile Organisation (IWTO) meant reviews of outstanding concerns to the wool textile industries could be aired and responsibility for redress taken by the appropriate research laboratories, test houses, or trade committees. Representatives of long-established wool manufacturers could expand their historic emphasis on such things as tariffs and regulation of trading in woollen goods to participate in IWTO sub-committees examining the technical and practical issues involved in routinely using the proposed new wool specifications. These were not all the problems to be addressed. Not only were the major traditional wool manufacturers confronting stiff competition from a burgeoning type of new textile industry featuring relatively cheap synthetic fibre products, but consumer interests increasingly required proof of product performance. On the one hand, the primary fibre needed
Wool production and fibre marketing
3
to be free from agricultural chemical residues, and on the other, retailers of wool products wanted a performance endorsement. Both aspects were fairly solidly secured in the 1980s, particularly through a very successful promotion campaign headed by the Woolmark label on products approved according to International Wool Secretariat (IWS) Standards. New problems have arisen during the 1990s, not so much with sales and test methods, where continued improvements in equipment and computer technology remain in vogue, but rather a renewed competitive pressure on wool prices. This has occasioned calls for relief from wool growers who wish to see wool marketing overhead costs, such as levies collected by AWC and the NZWB, to be much reduced. Another change is some revival of direct sales between consortiums of specialist wool producers and corresponding clubs of manufacturers in Europe or Asia. Irrespective of these continual shifting patterns in wool trading, the wool industry does now possess a sophisticated array of sampling and testing procedures that provide reliable support in terms of technical data. Whether the transaction is made through the auction system, private treaty or increasingly, one would expect, through electronic means such as the Internet, the packages of wool test methods described later in this chapter will remain relevant.
1.2
World wool production
Table 1.1 is reproduced from the 1998/99 Statistical Handbook of New Zealand Wool Group, a division of the NZWB.1 The major trend is a reduction in Australian wool production in the 1990s due to poor prices, which in turn was initiated by a recession in Japan and other important wool consumers. Recovery has been hindered by acquisition of a considerable stockpile in Australia early in the decade. Economic disruption has also halved wool production in the Soviet Union (now CIS), but it is growing significantly in China. New Zealand production is fairly stable, in spite of modest prices and several droughts during the 1990s. The slow downward trend is, in part, a result of buoyant investment in dairying as a more profitable use of grassland. There are several features of world wool production worthy of additional comment. Australian wool production is highly concentrated on the Merino breed and it therefore has a very dominant position in fine wools, accounting for about half of world supplies. Although approximately 75% of New Zealand production is categorised as crossbred type, i.e. about 140 000 clean tonnes, this represents just 30% of world supplies. The UK is a very substantial producer of coarse carpet wools and most of its 46 000 tonne production competes directly with New Zealand offerings to the carpet industries in Europe and elsewhere. Halfbred wools comprise a quite high
Table 1.1 World wool production [Reproduced from the 1998/99 Statistical Handbook of New Zealand Wool Group, Wool House, Wellington] Country
World wool production (thousand tonnes clean) 1992– 1993– 1994– 93r 94r 95r
1995– 1996– 1997– 96r 97r 98r
1998– % 99p change 1997–98 to 1998–99
Australia
573
544
473
452
472
455
443
-3%
New Zealand
193
214
213
199
203
197
185
-6%
China
119
120
128
139
149
146
151
3%
Soviet Union/CIS
207
194
157
124
118
103
90
-13%
United Kingdom
47
45
45
44
43
44
46
5%
Uruguay
64
66
60
56
60
55
45
-18%
Argentina
60
52
48
43
41
37
37
0%
Turkey
38
38
37
37
36
36
36
0%
South Africa
44
43
38
38
36
33
34
3%
India
28
28
28
28
28
28
28
0%
Pakistan
21
21
22
22
23
23
24
4%
Iran
21
21
22
23
23
23
23
0%
Ireland
18
18
18
18
17
18
18
0%
Spain
16
17
17
16
16
16
15
-6%
Morocco
14
14
14
14
14
15
15
0%
USA
23
22
19
18
15
15
14
-7%
Mongolia
12
12
11
11
11
11
11
0%
Romania
13
12
11
11
10
10
10
0%
France
12
11
11
11
11
11
10
-9%
Chile
11
11
11
11
9
9
9
0% -27%
Brazil
17
13
11
11
11
11
8
Peru
7
6
7
7
7
8
8
0%
Germany
7
7
7
8
8
8
7
-13%
Greece
6
6
6
6
6
7
7
0%
Iraq
7
7
7
6
6
6
6
0%
Italy
6
6
6
5
5
5
5
0%
Portugal
5
5
5
5
5
5
5
0%
132
124
127
126
125
127
127
0%
1721
1677
1559
1489
1508
1462
1417
-3%
Merino
813
777
681
643
653
626
609
-3%
Halfbred
405
388
383
365
368
363
350
-4%
Crossbred
503
512
495
480
487
473
458
-3%
Other countries World total of which:
r = revised; p = provisional; Source: IWTO. Data extracted from 1998/99 Statistical Handbook of New Zealand Wool Group.
Wool production and fibre marketing
5
fraction (25%) of the total world wool production. This classification notably includes a large proportion of the predominant Corriedales and Merino cross wools sold out of Argentina and Uruguay. World wool production in total is, however, modest compared to the volumes of cotton and synthetic fibres. Wool available for manufacturing from all sources at the end of the twentieth century accounts probably for no more than 3% of total world fibre supply.
1.3
Wool harvesting
Most wool is harvested by shearing live sheep using powered hand clippers. Blade shears are still preferred for flocks run where harsh weather can occur, because about 10 mm of fleece can be left on the sheep for protection. Slipe wools are produced at meat-works. Woolly sheepskins from slaughtered sheep and lambs are chemically treated to weaken the fibre roots so that the wool can be pulled off the pelt. The main wool classifications are full fleece (a year’s growth), second shear and early shorn (part-year’s growth), and crutchings (shorn from the hindquarters before lambing). Lambswool (shorn at about six months), woolly hogget (shorn at one year) and shorn hogget (shorn as lambs and then at 18 months) are other descriptions used in New Zealand. Each woolproducing country uses a variety of other classifications.
1.4
Clip preparation
During shearing, each fleece is examined with the objective of removing faults relating to colour, length and contamination, and collecting each separately. The main categories are belly wool, short discoloured crutch wool, stains and dags. Vegetable matter and cotted (i.e. felted) parts of the fleece are also separated. Skirted fleeces are sorted into uniform groups or lines. Fine wool lines will discriminate on the variables of fibre diameter, length, strength, colour and vegetable contamination. The main sorting principles for carpet wools are discolouration and fleece tenderness. Slipe wools, produced in meat works, are classed along similar lines, the main difference being a wash that removes most of the woolgrease and suint, as well as any sodium sulphide depilatory adhering to the wool.
1.5
Participants in the wool trade
1.5.1 Woolgrowers Sheep farmers have been constantly urged to improve their performance with respect to putting a better product into the start of the wool market-
6
Wool: Science and technology
ing and manufacturing chain. Apart from the obvious requirement for good sheep husbandry and a breeding and selection strategy, there are several aspects involving responsible farm management. Some pasture weeds produce burrs and seeds that become entangled in the growing fleece. Substantial contamination cannot be taken out by conventional mechanical processing, and carbonising (an acid process which embrittles vegetable matter) is required, adding costs in wool classing and processing. Environmental concerns are another issue where the woolgrower is ultimately responsible for using approved pesticides, drenches and agricultural sprays, so that the shorn wool contains no unwanted residues. Finally, workers in the shearing shed need to be well informed on best practices and skilled in classing and skirting (Section 1.4) before loading the wool harvest into farm bales. Provided these responsibilities of the woolgrowers are reliably fulfilled, the onward task of taking the clip to auction, usually via a wool broker, or a direct sale at the farm gate, is much facilitated.
1.5.2 Wool brokers and wool buyers For wool sold at auction, a reputable wool broker is the traditional intermediary who prepares farm lots. Nowadays, this entails aggregating similar sale lots, particularly small lots, weighing, sampling and cataloguing. There are formal procedures for core sampling and obtaining a pre-sale test certificate from a test house to be available at the auction. A grab sample of full-length wool is also obtained, which is displayed alongside the test certificate at the auction room. This is an enormous transformation that has mainly been effected since 1970, after which time the means for improved testing and their ratification by IWTO (Section 1.1) have come to dominate wool marketing. Previously, a few large and many small wool-broking companies had relied upon the personal expertise of their staff. Their ability to judge the yield (i.e. the weight of clean wool remaining after scouring) and mean diameter, for example, were extraordinary. In the latter case, staff in both wool broking and wool buying companies were adept at assigning a fineness estimate for each sale lot in their notebooks prior to auction. For fine wool products, where wool mean fibre diameter is a critical parameter, these assessment experts were capable of discriminating readily between 18, 20, and 22 micron wools, and more often than not their subjective assessments correlated with laboratory measurements to within a fraction of a micron. They also included other judgements on ‘style’, which meant a synthesis of fibre crimp and other fleece characteristics that they and their clients believed to be a superior judgement of processing and product performance as compared to a limited array of objective measurements.
Wool production and fibre marketing
7
Efficient sampling and testing procedures (Sections 1.6–1.12) have largely eliminated this bias, and basically in the 21st century most wool trading will be underwritten by physical measurements. Exceptions will still exist, typically where a wool-buyer and a wool-grower agree at the farm gate on a transaction price. Direct selling has the attraction of very low transaction costs. It is seen to best advantage when an atmosphere of mutual trust is developed between a manufacturer and a number of wool-grower clients. For example, Cavalier Corporation is a prominent New Zealand carpet manufacturer. The company has a subsidiary which has established a good record in arranging direct acquisition of wool on a regular basis. Many of the woolgrowers became directly involved with individual carpet manufacturers about 1950 when the first commercial flocks of Drysdale sheep were taking shape. The Drysdale breed was named after Dr Dry, a geneticist who discovered a gene which led to remarkably coarse wool from the sheep which carried it, and it is particularly sought after for some styles of carpets. In Australia in 1997, approximately 80% of the wool clip was sold at auction using the services of one of about 30 wool-broking companies operating in that country.2 Private buyers account for the remaining 20% of the wool market, the larger companies being affiliated to the national Private Treaty Wool Merchants Association.
1.5.3 Test houses The Australian Wool Testing Authority (AWTA) was established as a statutory body by an Act of the Commonwealth Government in 1937. With the advent of large-scale sampling and testing of wool sale lots, the activities of AWTA expanded greatly. The form of governance was changed, and since 1982 AWTA Ltd has operated as a public company limited by guarantee, without shareholders. Its guarantors nominate directors with an additional director representing CSIRO. They are as follows: • • • • • • •
Australian Council of Wool Exporters Federal Council of Private Treaty Merchants National Council of Wool Selling Brokers of Australia Wool Council of Australia Wool Scourers and Carbonisers Association of Australia Wool Textile Manufacturers of Australia Australian Wool Corporation
Pre-sale wool test certificates comprise about 66% of all documents issued by AWTA Ltd since 1984. The remainder are certificates for scoured and carbonised wool, and the company is also active in testing of imported
8
Wool: Science and technology
woolpack materials. Very similar organisations operate in New Zealand (NZ Wool Testing Authority) and South Africa. They are, themselves, subject to regular quality control audits. The issue of reliable sampling was at the heart of introducing fundamental changes in wool marketing methods. Sampling technology is described in more detail in Section 1.6. It should, however, be emphasised here there are two basic methods of sampling, which have quite different and explicit purposes. Objective measurements of core samples comprise yield (i.e. percentage of clean wool), diameter, colour and vegetable matter content. Pre-sale certificates are shown adjacent to a grab-sample of the same lot prior to auction. Post-sale test certificates for greasy wool may also be issued, notably when several sale lots are later combined. Most New Zealand wool is scoured prior to export and the pre-sale certificate is redundant. A different sampling and test regime applies to scoured wool shipments, and a notable replacement for the yield test of greasy wool is the ‘residuals’ test, i.e. the result of a solvent extraction of a representative sample in order to quantify wool fats and residues not totally removed by the scouring process.
1.5.4 British wool marketing There are many similarities between marketing arrangements in Australia, New Zealand and South Africa and that in the UK, notably a strong reliance on the auction system and a Board which takes a broad overview of the industry.3 The most recent report of the British Wool Marketing Board indicates there are about 75 000 farmers contributing to an annual wool production in the UK of 46 million kilos. Amongst their activities, the Board organises regular auctions, supports training of shearers and promotes British wools in carpets manufactured in the UK. In the northern hemisphere, institutions such as the Bradford Conditioning House have for many years offered a weighing and testing service; in their case for the large number of wool manufacturers concentrated in the West Riding of Yorkshire. The application of objective specifications of wool lots is clearly gaining increased support as the British Wool Marketing Board indicates3 considerable investment in equipment for the purpose, and a stated interest in future marketing of British wools internationally using the Internet.
1.5.5 Wool exporters including wool scourers There are two methods for obtaining wool from exporting companies. Under the ‘indent buying’ system, the overseas buyer nominates an upper price, wool type and quantity, and the exporter attempts to fill the order on
Wool production and fibre marketing
9
essentially a commission basis. Under the ‘firm offer’ system, the exporter takes the initiative and makes a firm offer to a buyer including price and other details. If the offer, usually open for 24 hours, is accepted, the onus is on the exporter to fill the order on the terms of the offer. In cases of dispute, the IWTO have regulations applying to trading, such as ordering retests when the specification of the delivery is questioned. A good number of powerful European and Asian textile companies bid at auction, and essentially can be regarded as exporters who principally buy on behalf of their own wool manufacturing mills. Wool scouring companies have several different objectives according to their ownership and, to some extent, their location. For some, their predominant business is scouring on commission for an exporter or a local manufacturer. Others may be owned in part or in whole by wool manufacturers, and a sizeable part of their business is essentially ‘in house’. Some of the largest wool scouring companies have a wool trading operation including wool exporting. One of the advantages of a wool scour is the ability to blend wool lots to make up large consignments to specifications of overseas clients. The technology supporting this type of wool export operation is described in Sections 1.12 and 1.13. The major southern hemisphere wool exporting countries have wellestablished test houses (Section 1.5.3), which are regularly subjected to quality-control audits. Objective measurements of core samples comprise yield (i.e. percentage of clean wool), diameter, colour and vegetable matter content. Formal pre-sale and post-sale test certificates are issued for greasy wool. Scoured wool shipments have a somewhat different sampling and test regime before issue of a scoured wool test certificate. This would include a ‘residuals’ test, i.e. the result of a solvent extraction of selected samples in order to evaluate the presence of wool fats and other residues not removed during the scouring process. Wool scouring presents a good opportunity to pool and blend similar lots purchased by a particular exporter. Following scouring, the wool is baled at medium or high density and commonly paralleled in container-sized lots of about 20 tonnes. Therefore, the principal advantage is an intelligent amalgamation of wool into consignments of a specification and regular tonnage appropriate to manufacturers.
1.5.6 Central wool facility Central wool facilities are essentially strategically-placed port storage and packaging depots where greasy or scoured wool is made up into shipments. Greasy wool, for example, has traditionally been ‘double-dumped’, i.e. two bales pressed into one dense package to reduce shipping space. Ports
10
Wool: Science and technology
around Australia with wool-handling facilities are serviced by three companies who specialise in this business. Dumping has some technical problems that will be just touched upon here. The presses are themselves remarkable, working almost continuously for several months with thrusts of 300 or even 500 tonnes. The compression of two 150 kg bales together is demanding on the pack material, which must comply with strict specifications. Tensile strength is only one consideration. One of the problems discovered with polypropylene packs, for instance, is shattering of fibres, which contaminate fine wool and are visible faults in finished fabrics.Another problem with highly compressed wool bales is that, after some months in a compressed conditions, the wool is difficult to ‘open’, i.e. to break up into a manageable form for scouring. Bale-warmers and various opening machines have been devised to solve this problem. Packaging of wool from farm bale to densely compressed shipping containers is itself an interesting topic. Jute was the dominant material until the advent of synthetic fibres. As noted above, these have not been troublefree. Nylon packs seemed likely prospects, because fibre contamination would essentially be invisible owing to the similar dyeing properties of wool and nylon. However, cost considerations are important too. It seems likely polyethylene will continue to develop as a preferred woolpack material.
1.5.7 Wool flow patterns and the auction system The full flow diagram for shorn wool sold at auction is shown in Fig. 1.1. The important auction process lies essentially between wool broker and exporter on the right of the diagram. Data flow describing wool samples involve a test house, shown on the left of the diagram. Auctions remain the dominant feature of wool sales in Australia and South Africa, but as mentioned in the general introduction, in New Zealand in the final few years of the 1990s there has been a very significant movement towards private sales. Woolscouring companies are among those taking a more aggressive approach to acquiring greasy wool direct from the woolgrower, particularly in New Zealand. In 1998/99 in New Zealand, the total sales of new greasy wool was about 185 300 tonnes, of which just 83 700 tonnes were sold at auction. Of the balance, growers sold 75 000 tonnes privately, and most of the remaining 26 600 tonnes was recovered as slipe wools.1 The latter enters the international wool market as a specialty product favoured by particular wool manufacturers, or is sold to one of the prominent wool exporters.
1.5.8 Historic form of the wool auction system Until changes began to be introduced after 1960, the historic form of the wool auction was identical in most respects to the commodity marketing of
Wool production and fibre marketing
11
Wool grower Test house
Wool broker
Wool exporter
Wool scour
Central wool facility Mill
1.1 Flow diagram for shorn wool to be sold at auction. Samples and test data involve a test-house.
a great many agricultural products. There was a roster of sale dates for all the wool producing regions and, on the day, all the product put up for sale was in full view for inspection, i.e. wool bales were cut open before lot-bylot sale to bidders representing the international wool manufacturing community. Other than the weight of each greasy wool lot, buyers had no other factual information, but in practice they were highly skilled in judging the relevant attributes of each lot (Fig. 1.2). The International Wool Textile Organisation (IWTO) had evolved over many years to become something close to a regulatory body. Delegates from all the member countries represent all the commercial interests to be found in the flow chart for the auction system (Fig. 1.1). Adoption of regulations governing wool trading, accreditation and dispute procedures essentially gave IWTO the status of professional governance of the wool industry, with particular emphasis on standards and accreditation of wool supplies coming onto the international market.
1.6
Wool sampling
The largest obstacle to overcoming the cumbersome features of the old traditional auction system was the highly variable quality of sale lots. This could commonly be exacerbated by poor growing conditions or sloppy classing and skirting. Therefore, it was hardly surprising that wool buyers and manufacturers insisted on extensive and repetitive technical trials before they could be convinced on the key issue of sampling. Wool sampling, in essence, replaces the opportunity for buyers to exercise their skills and judgement whereby they view the whole contents of every bale, by presenting to them a small sample attached to some test house measurements (Fig. 1.3). Nevertheless, this crucial victory in
12
Wool: Science and technology
1.2 Photograph of a traditional New Zealand wool-broker’s store taken about 1957. Bales were opened for inspection several days before auction.
obtaining the confidence of all parties has rested upon the development of two methods of sampling greasy wool lots. Grab sampling entails slitting open each bale and drawing out a regulated number of full-length wool staples to make up a composite sample of about 5 kg of greasy wool representative of a typical line of 3 to 20 bales (or even much larger lines in Australia). The entire wool lot is then weighed before undergoing the second method of sampling. Core sampling, as it is called, entails punching a sharp-ended tube through at least 97% of the length of each bale, sufficiently often to provide five samples of 150 g each, the cores being immediately sealed in a plastic bag for test house measurements complying with Core Test Regulations IWTO-19. To set up the greasy wool auction, the grab samples are assembled in long lines of trays in a display hall, each rejoined by a test certificate derived from the core sample. This enables the buyer to see both a representative full-length staple display and have accurate data on fibre diameter, yield, colour, clean weight and vegetable matter content. To give some idea of the speed at which buyers must operate to fill their buying orders, about 300 lots are sold every hour, and up to 3400 lots in a single day, comprising up
Wool production and fibre marketing
13
1.3 Photograph of a complete assembly of representative grab samples of New Zealand wool lots to be auctioned. Each numbered viewing box has a data sheet from a test-house and other information.
to 35 000 bales of wool. In Australia, at peak times these volumes are greatly exceeded.
1.7
Fibre diameter
No measurement could better exemplify the divergence in priorities between fine and coarse wools than measurement of fibre diameter. For fine Merino wools, the predominant average within a lot lies between 18 and 21 microns and there is a useful price premium at the finer end of that range. The mean diameter, of course, relates closely to both the spinning limit and the luxury handle, where every micron finer creates an advantage. Increasingly in recent years, a new niche sector has developed in production of super-fine wool with breeders going to extraordinary pains to produce tiny amounts of wool in the 14 to 17 micron range, which can sell at extreme prices. For crossbred wools destined for carpets, the mean diameters are most commonly in the 30–38 micron range and the New Zealand Romney and Coopworth wools that dominate this class have a good reputation for efficient processing. For some products in the carpet market the fibre blends
14
Wool: Science and technology
are actually improved by addition of very coarse wools, e.g. Drysdale or British moorland sheep fleece wools. (For a better appraisal of matching wool blends to carpet styles see Chapter 10.) However, there is a significant intermediate diameter range (halfbreds, Corriedale and Down breeds) of 25–30 microns where diameter variability becomes a significant issue. A few very coarse fibres can affect the comfort of wearers of knitwear constructed from these wools. The airflow method has been almost exclusively employed by test houses to measure mean fibre diameter until recent times. It is calibrated to record mean diameter of a wool lot reduced to a plug of clean core sample material through which air is forced under pressure. The method depends on a pressure drop principle; the greater the drop, the finer the wool. It is a simple, cheap measurement but has the drawback of inaccuracy when testing lambswools and medullated wools, where the diameter is increased relative to sample weight by empty spaces and hollow cells within the fibres. Much painstaking work over many years was required to produce calibration samples that were fully acceptable to wool manufacturers. Definitive measurement of mean fibre diameter and variability has, for many years, depended on expensive microscope measurements of fibre snippets. This laborious technique has been employed by test houses but was generally regarded as suitable mainly for research workers. Since about 1970 however, there has been a series of brave attempts to master the problem of providing a representative array of fibre snippets and analysing them with a scanning instrument. Computation of the fibre profile of the sample is rapidly becoming a trivial procedure with the advent of powerful computers. Presently, it seems inevitable that there will soon be complete reliance on cost-effective equipment to record wool fibre diameter profiles using laser-scanning devices, such as OFDA (Optical Fibre Diameter Analyser), a development of BSC Electronics in Perth.
1.8
Fibre length
Objective testing of fine Merino wools has come to include a measurement of wool staple length and strength (IWTO-30 test method) applied to greasy wool samples. The Atlas machine developed about 1985 for this purpose has since been somewhat improved but essentially it has remained a fairly daunting and expensive test. Individual wool tufts are fed into a grip-break device. In addition to a calculated fibre tenacity it also records the position of break along the sample. Attention given to this technically difficult measurement reflects the desire of manufacturers to know, in advance, every feature of processing performance. For manufacturers, the results of this test can indicate the percentage of fibre that breaks during processing. Short fibres unsuited to further worsted processing are extracted in the form of noils in the combing process to prepare tops.
Wool production and fibre marketing
15
For New Zealand crossbred wools, where a very high percentage of the clip arrives via the auction or other routes at a woolscour prior to export, the more useful index of fibre length is actually a critical test of fibre entanglement induced by the scouring process, in addition to accounting for breakage at weak or thin places in some or all of the fleeces making up the scourment. Consequently, WRONZ developed a test based on processing representative samples through a dedicated, narrow-width wool carding machine. A minimum of five samples of the output sliver are analysed by the well-known Almeter equipment, which then produces a statement of short fibre percentage, mean fibre length, and a coefficient of variation of hauteur. This ‘length after carding’ test (NZ Standard 8719:1992) is essentially only available using equipment tested and validated in New Zealand. However, with active collaboration from other countries this test is steadily becoming recognised and applied on an international basis. Testing wool scourments in this way results in a substantial consolidation of the data at the ‘sale-by-sample’ stage provided to auction buyers. Whereas the latter lots are commonly in the range 500–2000 kg, scourments are generally exported as one or several container loads of dense-packed bales, each holding about 16–20 tonnes.
1.9
Wool colour
A colour parameter in wool specification has no relevance to dozens of wool breeds around the world where the wool harvest is a great mixture of brown, yellow and white colours. However, it has a strong relationship with the value put on New Zealand wool sale lots since these vary widely in the incidence of yellowness (Section 5.4) in otherwise basically white fibre. Australian fine wools are very substantially protected from yellowing during wool growth because of the dense structure of a Merino fleece so that colour measurement at point-of-sale of fleece wools is of minor commercial interest. A relatively low priority for colour testing of Merino fleece is not to be confused with the importance of exceptionally good whiteness, often achieved by bleaching, for many fine wool products. A New Zealand Standard (NZS 8707:1984) developed by WRONZ has progressed to the status of an IWTO Draft Test Method (IWTO-DTM-56).4 The actual measurements are made by observing the reflectance from a chopped fibre wool sample packed into an observation cell. Strictly speaking, all three CIE tristimulus X, Y, and Z values are needed to construct a total description of wool colour. It should be seriously emphasised there are two aspects of wool fibre colour measurement which are important in the context of the appearance of final textile products. Rather than resort to complex equations, the simple difference between green and blue tristimulus measurements (i.e. Y–Z) is an adequate measure of wool yellowness. The other important discriminator among wool lots is their total light
16
Wool: Science and technology
reflectance or brightness and for this, the tristimulus Y value has satisfied all requirements. To summarise, (Y–Z) yellowness measurements will usually rank between 0 (very good whiteness) to 8–12 (very yellow) and the brightness index Y will range from about 70 at best down to about 40 for very dull wools. These figures are, or are closely related to, the percentage of incident light reflected back to reach the eyes of the observer.
1.10
Bulk testing
Bulk testing has assumed considerable importance right through the chain from sheep breeder to manufacturer. The essence of the test is essentially to quantify the loftiness or space-filling capabilities of particular wool lines. This, in turn, is largely dependent on the degree of crimpiness, which is almost non-existent in some wool types and in general increases as the wool gets finer. However, the correlation with mean diameter is not always satisfactory. For example, carpet wools with a broad spectrum of fibre diameters will yield a bulkier yarn than those with a narrow range, even though the mean diameters are similar. The procedure for the Core Bulk Test involves running a scoured core sample through a small card, loading 2.5 g into a cylinder, applying a loaded piston and measuring the volume occupied by the sample. The Core Bulk Test is one where it is mandatory for the wool sample to be held in an airconditioned environment (65% RH and 20 °C) for at least 24 hours before testing. The regulations pertaining to some of the other tests described earlier also require the wools to be held and tested in the same conditioned environment.
1.11
Dark fibre contamination
Merino wools are particularly affected by even minute contamination with dark fibres. In fine white or pale shades of fabric, every dark fibre is a visible fault that entails close inspection and individual removal with tweezers by a mill operative. Down breeds of sheep with a black face and legs present a problem of contamination too, as the main part of their fleece is white. The problem is largely pursued through training in fleece skirting procedures in the shearing shed and generally avoiding contamination along the processing chain. Counting individual coloured fibres on a microscope slide has been the traditional laborious method, appropriate mainly for research purposes. With the advent of laser scanning equipment for fibre diameter measurement, there are now better prospects for including a statistical measure of dark fibre contamination.
Wool production and fibre marketing
1.12
17
Specification of woolscour deliveries
Most New Zealand woolscours have acquired Near Infrared Reflectance Analysis (NIRA) instruments. These greatly improved in-house quality control, although an external certification is still necessary from a test house before the measurements are formally recognised by clients and manufacturers. The NIRA equipment provides rapid measurements of moisture regain, residual grease content and scoured wool colour. The instrumentation can also produce an unofficial measure of fibre diameter, wool bulk and fibre medullation.5 Predictive equations are required for each of the measurements, derived from very extensive sampling and validation experiments. Considerable precautions are also needed in order to transfer the predictive data base between instruments sited in other laboratories.6 The measurement of fibre length of scoured wool is very important, and the relevant ‘length after carding’ test was described in Section 1.8. The wool may have had faults such as cotting and the scouring process itself introduces some degree of fibre entanglement. By emulating, with carefully controlled equipment, the opening and carding process in industrial processing, the ‘length-after-carding’ test breaks a comparable proportion of fibres and provides important guidance about the future processing performance of the scourment. In summary then, a scoured wool specification has test information on the variables of colour, fibre diameter, fibre length after carding, bulk, medullation content, and vegetable matter content. These six parameters have been shown to be a necessary and sufficient data set for predictive expectations of scourments.7 Most of these tests have already been briefly described. However, in the context of specifying relatively large scourments some additional points should be made. These have particular significance for on-line quality control in the woolscour. Although wool colour is measured as for auction lots of greasy wool (NZS 8707:1984 and IWTO(E)-14-88, which is based on the NZ Standard method), a significant additional development is the use of on-line colour monitoring. A video camera and computer display ‘as-is’ wool colour by viewing the wool-flow, thus facilitating corrective action and avoiding re-scouring if the scouring process deteriorates in quality. The vegetable matter test (IWTO-19-85) has some problems when applied to most New Zealand scourments, because the commonly low levels of contamination make it difficult to carry out representative sampling. The most important technology to come into use in woolscours in recent years is the adoption of Near Infra Red (NIR) equipment for quality control purposes. Modern NIR equipment scans a wide spectral range, extending into the visible region, so that ‘as is’ colour can be measured by this method. Predictive equations for bulk and medullation are constantly
18
Wool: Science and technology
being improved. The core bulk test (NZ 8716:1994) may ultimately be replaced in test houses by an NIR test. Similarly, the long-standing method of measuring medullation by the definitive but expensive projection microscope method will ultimately be replaced. Although NIR instruments can be calibrated to obtain a measure of medullation, the newer forms of laser scanning instruments for fibre diameter measurement (see Section 1.7) are most likely to also quantify medullation.
1.13
Computer blend selection
A computer expert system has been developed to define objective fibre specifications appropriate for carpet yarns according to the processing route and product specification.8,9 The system can be customised to suit the machinery and processing conditions in yarn manufacturing plants. By way of example, if the product has been manufactured in the past, the customary blend, if still available, is sampled and measured to quantify its properties. This information can then be applied to currently available lines of wool to determine a computer-selected blend using least-cost-blending software. However, using a least-cost strategy for purchasing wool may not be the ideal solution because processors may find machine settings, processing efficiency and product properties need to be revised to take full advantage of the technology. One of the interesting outcomes of relying on computer selection of lots comprising a blend has been the observation that visually different unscoured blends do indeed conform after processing to the end result sought. A significant advantage of computer blend technology is the assistance that can be provided to new entrants into wool processing, or to processors wanting to quickly develop a new product using their existing equipment. Following a series of successful validation trials8,9 it became possible for wool exporters in New Zealand to provide an enhanced service to clients using 100% New Zealand wool in their product. It also offered a new marketing opportunity whereby mills unfamiliar with these wools, for example in emerging markets in China, could be supplied with blends suited to their equipment and the desired final product.
1.14
Wool promotion
The International Wool Secretariat (IWS) was formed in 1946, the three signatories being Australia, New Zealand and South Africa. In later years, Uruguay showed an interest and was eventually admitted to membership. Levies from their woolgrowers supported a head office in London, and somewhat later a large technical centre in Ilkley, Yorkshire. Branches in
Wool production and fibre marketing
19
most leading countries provided technical and marketing support for their local wool manufacturers. They also had considerably autonomy in developing promotional campaigns appropriate for their particular market and these were usually strongly identified with the Woolmark, a quality certification mark. The quality assurance aspect involved labelling garments, textiles and carpets that met set standards of performance. This very extensive programme was generally admired and supported by retailers as well as manufacturers. Brand recognition by consumers worldwide was one of the highest for any type of product. Section 12.7 highlights the extremely competitive environment faced by wool products in achieving consumer awareness. An effort by the Australian Wool Corporation to intervene and maintain high wool prices in 1991 led to stockpiling of almost a year’s supply of Merino wool, followed by a long period of very slow recovery. New Zealand had experienced a long-term slow decline in wool prices and this was exacerbated by economic crises in Asia in the 1990s. They subsequently withdrew from the IWS and developed their own marketing strategy.
1.15
The Fernmark brand
New Zealand’s share of world carpet wool usage had declined significantly in recent years and with that decline came a move from generic promotion under the Woolmark logo to a brand marketing programme that more specifically identified New Zealand as the country of origin of the pile fibre. This fundamental change in marketing philosophy saw Wools of New Zealand in 1994 take over the Interior Textiles Division of IWS, which it had previously fully funded, and strike out on its own with the new Fernmark brand entity. The fern leaf image was selected for its general association with New Zealand. Initially, the emphasis for branding has been on carpet wools with the development of segmented brandnames for various classes of product, to be used in conjunction with the Fernmark brand. Other segment brands have been developed, such as Isolana, for use with bedding products. Ultimately, all major product segments that use New Zealand wool are likely to have specific brands used with the Fernmark.
1.16
Marketing of distinctive wool types
Over the past 30 years, the major thrust in wool marketing has clearly been driven by the objective measurements of important wool fibre variables. In the case of coarse and medium diameter wool types, the sheep breed and flock discriminations such as ewes, wethers and lambs have, in principle, become of minor importance compared to the physical specifications of
20
Wool: Science and technology
wool lots. However, in a similar fashion to the emergence of direct selling to reduce transaction costs associated with wool auctions, there has been some revival of marketing based on particular features of fleece from certain breeds. Superfine Merino wools are the best example of what is essentially niche marketing. It combines the commercial interests of woolgrowers who specialise in producing very fine lines of wool (<18 micron) and manufacturers with a capability and reputation for creating luxurious wool products. Another instance is the development of breeding strategies for Perendale wool. Perendale sheep are the outcome of a long term breeding and selection programme at Massey University, New Zealand, led by Professor Peren. The notable marketing attribute of Perendale sheep is the additional bulkiness (see Section 1.10) of yarns made from their wool as compared to the general run of crossbred wools of otherwise comparable quality. The sheep farmers involved with the breed have formed a marketing alliance to promote their wools with the intention of extracting some price premium for their product. Comparable marketing strategies have been extensively used in the UK to promote not just a brand name for knitwear or distinctive clothing such as tartans, but to put forward the particular credentials of British wools.
References 1 Anon., New Zealand Wool Statistical Handbook, 1998/99 edition. Prepared by New Zealand Wool Group, Wool House, Wellington, New Zealand. 2 Anon., Objective Measurement of New Zealand Wool. Prepared by Fibre Technology Section, Wools of New Zealand and extracted from The New Zealand Wool Industry Manual, 2000 update. ISSN 1173-6402. 3 Anon., British Wool Marketing Board. Report and Accounts: 2000. 4 IWTO Draft Test Method IWTO-DTM-56, Internat. Wool Text. Org., Brussels, Belgium. 5 Hammersley M J, ‘NIR Analysis of Wool’, in Near-Infrared Analysis, Eds: D A Burns and E Ciurczak, Marcel Decker Inc., New York, 1991. 6 Hammersley M J, Ranford S L and Townsend P E, ‘Near-Infrared Analysis of Wool; The Calibration Transfer Problem’. Proc. 8th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Christchurch, New Zealand, 1990, II, 218–29. 7 Wood E J, Burling-Claridge G R, Ranford S L, Hammersley M J, Edmunds A R and Thomas B L, ‘Recent Developments in the Objective Measurement of New Zealand Wool’, 9th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Biella, Italy, II, 44–52. 8 Carnaby G A, Maddever D C and Ford A M, ‘The Application of Linear Programming to Wool Blending and Specification’. Proc. 7th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Tokyo, Japan, 1985, II, 186–94. 9 Maddever D C, Cuthbertson I M and Edwards S, ‘An Expert System Tool for Specification of New Zealand Wool to be Used in the Manufacture of Carpet Yarn’, 9th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Biella, Italy, 1995, I, 18–25.
2 Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment L A HALLIDAY
2.1
Introduction
Raw or ‘greasy’ wool is contaminated with impurities, the type depending on the breed of sheep, the area in which the sheep are raised, and husbandry methods. The role of woolscouring is to: • •
•
clean the contaminants from the wool by means of an economic process ensure that the wool is in a physical and chemical condition to suit the intended processing route (e.g. for topmaking to minimise entanglement and retain the staple structure) comply with environmental requirements (this requirement has become much more important over the last 20 years).
The term ‘scouring’ is used here in the generic sense of a process that removes contaminants from raw wool. Thus, it includes all processes which aim to clean wool including those which use solvents other than water and those which use solids as a carrier for removing the contaminants. Scouring clearly is a critically important step in wool processing. It must be carried out using technology that enables the wool to attain its optimum performance in further processing.
2.2
Nature of contaminants
The main contaminants are woolgrease, suint and dirt. Woolgrease, technically a wax, is produced by the sebaceous glands in the skin of sheep, while suint is produced by the sudoriferous (sweat) glands. A more precise way of defining woolgrease and suint in relation to the analysis of greasy wool relates to their solubilities in organic solvents and water respectively. Thus suint can be defined as the water-soluble fraction of the fleece and woolgrease as the solvent-soluble fraction.1 Woolgrease is comprised principally of high molecular weight esters formed from a mixture of sterols (including cholesterol) and aliphatic alco21
22
Wool: Science and technology
Table 2.1 Typical concentrations of non-wool contaminants (Percent by mass on greasy wool) Maximum
Minimum
Average
10.0
16.1
Australian (New South Wales) Merino52 Grease
25.4
Suint
12.0
2.0
6.1
Dirt
43.8
6.3
19.6
New Zealand crossbred 53 Grease
8.5
1.6
5.2
Suint
12.1
2.2
8.0
Dirt + suint moisture
—
—
7.9
hols with straight and branched chain fatty acids. The amount present on the wool depends upon the sheep breed, with Merinos recording the highest amounts (Table 2.1). Crossbred wool usually has substantially less. For most processing routes, the requirement is to reduce the grease on the fibre to below 0.5%. Suint is mainly potassium salts of organic acids: potassium comprises 90% of the cations present and this represents 25–27% on the weight of dry suint. In scouring liquors, at alkaline pH levels, suint has detergent properties. The amount present also depends on the breed type, with crossbreds tending to have more than merino. The range of the levels of the contaminants is notably wide; especially for the dirt. The differences in type and level of contaminants help to explain why different hardware and processes have proven necessary in woolscouring. For example, the large amount of fine dirt on some of the fine wools from Western Australia is very difficult to remove, and low scouring throughputs are often necessary; whereas a high yielding coarse wool from New Zealand represents the other extreme of being very easy to scour. Raw wool may also be contaminated with vegetable matter (VM). Where the wools are heavily contaminated with VM, they may have to be carbonised to remove it (Section 2.7.1). A major proportion of the wools requiring carbonising are from Australia and South Africa.2
2.3
Historical overview of scouring methods
Traditionally, wool was scoured in hot, aqueous solutions of soap and alkali. Synthetic detergents have largely displaced soap, but aqueous scouring has remained the principal method. However, the use of volatile solvents
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
23
to scour wool in batchwise processes was introduced about 1900.1,3 Conventional aqueous scouring removes the woolgrease in emulsion, the suint in solution and the dirt in suspension. Solvent scouring removes the woolgrease in solution, and removes both the dirt and suint in suspension. Various dry-powder-type processes have been employed or advocated in the past, where solids are used as carriers to remove the contaminants from the wool.1 Types of materials used have included gypsum, kieselguhr, aluminium silicate, and bran. A method currently under development in Australia uses microwave energy to heat the greasy wool while it is being contacted with a powder.4 Many developments in woolscouring and effluent treatment have been commercialised over the last 30 years, several of which originated in work carried out in the research laboratories of WRONZ (New Zealand) and CSIRO (Australia). Other research organisations, technical centres, machinery manufacturers and processors themselves have also contributed. More recently, with the reduction in bulk funding available for research and development laboratories, a greater proportion of the work has been commercial and has not been reported in the literature.
2.4
Unit operations
2.4.1 General overview A woolscouring works typically includes facilities for blending and mechanically cleaning greasy wool, and drying and blending the scoured wool, as well as the scouring machine itself. The possibility of carrying out additional chemical processing may also be provided.
2.4.2 Blending systems for greasy wool Two basic types of blending systems may be identified: i)
ii)
In-line blending systems (Fig. 2.1) are used where the wools being blended have similar characteristics. Partially opened wools are layered horizontally into an accumulator (blending bin) and an inclined spiked lattice empties the bin from one end, providing effective mixing. Such systems are often used by scourers of fine wools. Computerised weighbelt blending systems (Fig. 2.2) are used for blending wools that have different characteristics. Such systems include multiple weighbelt lines that deliver the wool onto a conveyor for mixing. Further opening-dusting followed by layered blending may also be included.
24
Wool: Science and technology
Bale breaker
Conveyor
Blending accumulator
Hopper feeder
2.1 Typical in-line blending system.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
Accumulator Accumulator Accumulator hopper hopper hopper feeder feeder feeder weighbelt weighbelt weighbelt
Hopper feeder / accumulator
Weighbelt
Accumulator conveyor
Hopper feeder
2.2 Typical computerised weighbelt blending system.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
Blending systems are usually built-up from standard items of equipment (e.g. hopper feeders and weighbelts), and may be customised to suit the requirements of the user. Dimensions of existing buildings often impose constraints on the layout.
2.4.3 Preheating bales of fine wool Before densely packed fine wool is blended, preheating may be necessary to facilitate opening of the wool. Fine wools are often compressed to high densities to facilitate storage and to lower the cost of transport. Australian greasy wools are usually exported in ‘tripacks’, at roughly three times the density of a farm bale. Where ambient temperatures in the scouring plant are low, the packed wool remains very hard and difficult to process. It may be necessary to heat the wool to relax strains and enable efficient opening and blending; also to reduce wear and tear on the processing equipment. It has been suggested that the temperature of the greasy wool needs to be at least 15–25 °C to allow adequate opening and blending.5 There are three main methods of heating the bales of wool: i) warm rooms ii) steam injection iii) microwave and ‘dielectric’ heating methods.6
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
25
Warm rooms have long been used to prepare farm bales for processing. With tripacks, a longer holding time is necessary and access for forklifts is necessary. The rate of heating can be increased by increasing the temperature, but mills set an upper limit of about 75 °C to avoid damage to the wool.5 Disadvantages are the high labour costs, potentially high heating costs and the space requirements. Injection of steam into tripacks has been practised, but yellowing of the wool at the point of injection has been a problem, especially if high temperature steam is used.5 The Australian Wool Corporation developed the Forced Convection Bale Warmer to overcome the problems of conventional steam injection. This unit used two fluids – low temperature dry steam and warm air – which were applied to the tripack sequentially.5 Although the unit was technically successful it has not sold in numbers. Radio frequency heating techniques have been used in the wool industry for some time, mainly using the dielectric frequency range; typically 13.56 or 27.12 MHz. Although commercial use of bale heaters utilising dielectric heating has been reported in the literature, their use has not become widespread. Presumably, this has mainly been because of their high capital and running costs. More recently, the successful commercialisation of bale heating systems using radio frequency power in the low microwave range (915–922 MHz) has been reported.7
2.4.4 Opening and dusting Wool may be opened and dusted before and after scouring, and there are generally benefits for all types of wool if both of these processes are carried out appropriately. Greasy wool is opened to facilitate the removal of contaminants in the scour, and to assist the blending process. Opener-duster machines are also used to remove dirt and VM prior to scouring, which reduces the solids loadings in the liquors and effluent. After scouring and drying, wool is opened to assist its transport by pneumatic conveying, to help even-out the moisture distribution in the wool mat, and to facilitate further dusting of the wool. There are results to indicate that mild opening of fine wool after drying may be beneficial to the worsted carding process8 but further testing has indicated that such pre-opening has advantages only when the scoured wool is notably entangled.9 Any opening of wet fine wool, even the relatively gentle action of a feed-hopper, has been shown to reduce the top length and should be avoided.8 Coarse wools generally can withstand quite intensive opening, both before and after washing.1 Dag and slipe wools in particular will benefit from such treatment. It is interesting to note that the most recent commercial developments in opening equipment mainly for coarse wools – the
26
Wool: Science and technology
Short Wool Processor and the Scoured Wool Cleaner – have been high intensity machines. The following types of machine are commonly used, listed approximately in order of increasing intensity of opening: Bale-breakers are strongly-built, large machines for breaking open bales prior to opening/dusting in a drum opener. The mechanical action may be derived from drums with teeth (see Fig. 2.1) or from large flails rigidly attached to shafts.The former types are often used by scourers of fine wools, while the latter are favoured by the commission scourers in the UK for handling rolled fleeces. Feed-hoppers are machines with multiple roles of feed-rate regulation, opening and wool containment. They have a spiked lattice which carries the wool out of the hopper for delivery to the next stage of the process (see Fig. 2.3). Drum openers most commonly have two drums (Fig. 2.3), but configurations have ranged from one to four drums (Fig. 2.4). New Zealand scourers have recently favoured three-drum units for their flexibility and additional cleaning capacity. Many of these openers are now supplied with screens that are cleaned automatically as they slide sideways out of the machine under the power of hydraulic rams. There are also various options available for handling the waste from openers, including straightforward gravity discharge into waste containers, pneumatic conveying, and mechanical systems such as augers and belt conveyors. Measurements by WRONZ on the performance of multi-drum openers in industry showed that they removed 5 to 16% of the dirt on the wool, depending on the wool type, provided the screens were cleaned regularly.10 These measurements were carried out on New Zealand wools and a
Variable speed motor drive
Wool flow
Variable speed motor drive
Hoppermatic
Lattice motor speed
Feedrate controller
Lattice motor speed
Ultrasonic sensor
Loadcell
No 1 hopper feeder
Drum opener
No 2 hopper feeder
2.3 Opening and feeding system.
54
Weighbelt
[Courtesy of ANDAR.]
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
27
2.4 Three-drum greasy wool opener. [Courtesy of Kaputone Wool Scour (1994) Ltd.]
lesser performance would be expected on fine wools, which contain more grease. The opening process carried out by rotating drum openers appears to occur in three main ways.10 Intense opening takes place firstly at the feed or ‘nip’ rollers at the entry to the opener, as the teeth on the drum tear or ‘pick’ at the constrained wool mat. Secondly, fixed teeth on the screens will break up the wool flow with a strong effect since they are normally designed to intersect with the rotating teeth on the drums. An important innovation from WRONZ was the development of a self-cleaning-teeth assembly, which provides a self-cleaning capability and a means to adjust the number of rows of fixed teeth in the ‘up’ position while the opener is in operation.11 Thirdly, there is less severe opening as the wool changes direction on transferring from one section of the opener to the next. One of the outcomes of the considerable amount of work carried out at WRONZ on the opening and dusting of greasy wool was the design of a self-cleaning machine, the WRONZ Autoclean, which reached the commercial prototype stage.12 Although its opening and dusting performance was up to expectation, it has not achieved commercial success. Stepped opener-dusters use a smaller diameter rotor than drum openers (Fig. 2.5). Their usage at the greasy end of the scour has much reduced during the last 20 years, mainly because the dusting screens became rapidly
28
Wool: Science and technology
blocked with dirt, and they essentially become an expensive inclined conveyor. They are better suited to the cleaning of scoured wool. The Short Wool Processor is based on the principle of hinged flails (as in a dag crusher) attached to a rotor. It may be used in continuous or batch processing modes. The Short Wool Processor is used off-line mainly to pre-open and dust dag wools and slipe wools. Cott Openers are used for breaking apart cotted fleeces. The main working part is usually a rotor fitted with angled teeth or pins which combs a fringe away from the fleece as it is fed at a controlled rate.1 The feeding system is usually a conveyor belt that delivers the fleece to a pair of restraining spiked rollers, or to a spiked roller working in combination with a ‘piano key’ set-up. Cyclic Openers have a large diameter drum fitted with teeth, with intersecting workers located above it. It is fed via conveyor and feed rollers. In New Zealand, it was used mainly on slipe and dag wools; elsewhere it was also used to open wools prior to carbonising. It may be used in batch or continuous mode.1 In New Zealand, the Short Wool Processor has largely superseded the Cyclic Opener. The less demanding duty on scoured rather than greasy wool suits the Stepped Opener-Duster machine. The degree of opening is determined at the design stage by the selection of the number of drums, their speed, and whether feed rollers are required. Figure 2.5 shows a scoured wool dedusting system that includes a three-drum stepped opener-duster. In this example, the wool is delivered onto a picking conveyor before it is transported by pneumatic conveying to its destination for discharge by a condensor. The air from the condensor is exhausted to atmosphere via filter bags or cyclones. Scoured Wool Cleaners are a WRONZ development commercialised by Mentec.13 Unlike most opener-dusters for wool, which have multiple drums or rotors with the wool being fed from one drum to the next, the Scoured Wool Cleaner is a single-rotor machine, with the wool being fed near one end and discharged at the other end. Thus, the wool has an axial flow
Wool flow
Air & dust out
Wool Dryer
Picking Stepped opener/duster conveyor
Condenser & conveyor
Fan
Dust Collection
2.5 Scoured wool finishing system.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
29
component as well as a rotational component. In this respect, the Scoured Wool Cleaner is similar to the willows or ‘beater-scutchers’ used for dedusting in the carbonising process.14 It achieved rapid penetration into the New Zealand scouring industry, owing to its proven wool cleaning capability. A smaller machine operating on a similar principle is available for recovering fibre from the waste of the main unit. Fearnought machines operate like a card with swift, workers, and strippers. They are mainly used by scourers in the UK for opening and blending.
2.4.5 Washing wool in scouring trains A scouring train comprises a number of wash bowls and squeeze heads, and is usually linked to an in-line dryer and a woolgrease recovery system. Figure 2.6 shows a typical plant layout for a scour for fine (e.g. Merino) wools; while Fig. 2.7 shows a typical plant layout for coarse (e.g. NZ crossbred) wools. Older conventional scouring lines typically include four bowls having rake or harrow mechanisms that dunk and transport the wool. The scoured product from such designs is satisfactory for most purposes so that the basic mechanical motions of aqueous scour bowl design have not changed greatly over the last 100 years. Most of the greasy wool processed throughout the world is still scoured in aqueous systems using rake and harrow machines.15 Details of the bowls have, however, changed significantly. Over the years, various major innovations in scour bowl design have reached commercial prototype stage but only a few have gained ultimate commercial acceptance. Of particular note were the different designs of aqueous jet scours during the 1960s by CSIRO and the University of New
80 610 Bowl 1 Bale breaker
Bowl 2
Bowl 3
Bowl 4
Bowl 5
Bowl 6
8 Drum dryer
3 Drum stepped opener
Feeder Opener Feeder
Weighbelt
2.6 Scour plant for fine wools.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
62 715 Bowl 1 Feeder Opener Feeder Weighbelt
Bowl 2 Bowl 3 Bowl 4
Bowl 5
Bowl 6 Feeder
2.7 Scour plant for coarse wools.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
6 Drum dryer
3 Drum stepped opener
30
Wool: Science and technology
South Wales.1 These designs were aimed at improving the combing results when compared with scouring on conventional machinery and while they achieved that aim, it was also shown that conventional scouring mechanisms could be developed to achieve a similar improvement in processing performance (e.g. in the Petrie-Wira Improved Scour).16 An important scouring development commercialised during the 1960s was the Fleissner suction drum scouring bowl.17 Perforated suction drums are used to transport the wool and also to wash it by means of liquor flow from outside to the inside of the drums. In the original design, the liquor circulation pumps were located inside the drums. In later designs, an axial flow pump was installed in a side space of the bowl. It is interesting that the original design allowed for flexibility in bowl length, ranging from one to three suction drums long.17 During the late 1980s, a 3 m-wide suction drum scour was installed in Uruguay,15 which remains the largest working width of woolscour available from any manufacturer. The suction drum design has been successful mainly for high yielding fine wools; on dirtier wools, product cleanliness becomes an issue. The wool mat acts as a filter for fine dirt, some of which may remain in the wool mat at the exit of the final suction drum bowl. For this reason, a ‘hybrid’ scour has been installed by some mills with a selection of suction drum and rake bowls being fitted into the scour train. Hence, the particular bowls are chosen depending on their prime function: grease and suint removal or dirt removal. Rake and harrow bowls fulfil most of the requirements for the washing of fine and coarse wools. Rake systems using three-throw crank drives have proven most popular, since they can be set up to have a lesser felting effect than a square action single harrow, and their compact dimensions makes the bowl easier to cover. A small number of machines have used swing-rake mechanisms, which simulate the movement of a hand-held fork,1 to move the wool through the bowls, but they are only suitable for blends that demand a particularly strong mechanical action. A hopper-bottomed scour bowl of recent design (ANDAR) is shown in Fig. 2.8. The wool is fed into the bowl and is submerged and wet-out by means of the suction drum, which is mechanically driven at the required speed. Liquor within the scour bowl is circulated from the spraybox to the squeeze press by means of the flow-around pump. A heat exchanger may be installed within the spraybox or installed separately to heat the liquor flow between the flow-around pump and the spraybox. The main rake moves the wool through the bowl where it is picked up by the head rake, which in turn delivers the wool to the drain tray. The squeeze press removes liquor from the wool and then transfers it to the outfeed conveyor for delivery to the next step in the process.
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment Suction drum
Main rake Head rake
Wool in
Squeeze ool W press
31 t ou
Spraybox
Flowback from next bowl
Flowback to previous bowl Heavy solids
2.8 ANDAR bowl flow diagram.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
During early 1978, two ‘mini-bowls’ designed by WRONZ were installed by ANDAR as a replacement for the first scouring bowl at the original installation of the WRONZ Comprehensive Scouring System (see Scouring Systems) in Timaru, New Zealand. The impetus for this development was the general trend towards shorter scouring bowls, the knowledge that many raw wools are easy to wash, and the stimulus given to the industry in New Zealand by the demonstration of the Lo-Flo wash-plate process to the trade at Geelong in 1977.18 Comparative trials showed that the scouring efficiency of two mini-bowls was comparable with that of two bowls of conventional length (the mini-bowl was 2.7 m long, while the conventional bowls were 6.7 m and 5.8 m long).19 The benefits due to mini-bowls were several including: space savings, reduction in energy losses, reduced volume, reduced capital cost, reduced maintenance, and ease of operation.18 Commercialisation was successful, with ANDAR/WRONZ mini-bowls installed in New Zealand and overseas soon afterwards. Subsequent experience showed that mini-bowls were not ideal for washing low yielding fine wools, mainly because dirt removal could be a limiting factor. However, they were still chosen by some processors for scouring and rinsing applications of high yielding fine wools on the basis of their own experience, and they are widely installed for the processing of New Zealand coarse wools, often in combinations with long conventional bowls. The mini-bowl hopper design, with its hopper of full scour working width, became the basis for the ANDAR
32
Wool: Science and technology
multi-hopper designs to follow. Scour lines comprising bowls of one, two, three, and sometimes four hoppers long were installed, mainly in Australia, Asia, and the USA.
2.4.6 Squeeze heads The action of the squeeze rollers (Fig. 2.9) is critical to the efficiency of removal of contaminants from the wool. As the wool mat enters the nip of the squeeze rollers, it is subjected to intense hydrodynamic forces which are particularly efficient at removing woolgrease and suint from the wool fibres, but less efficient at removing dirt. Efficient squeeze rolling also minimises the carryover of contaminants entrained in the wool mat to the next bowl in the scouring line. The efficiency of the squeeze rollers of the last bowl in the scouring line is also very important. By reducing the regain of the wool entering the dryer, the energy usage of the dryer is reduced while its wool throughput capacity is increased. The squeezing efficiency of rollers in a scouring line increases with temperature and with the applied downforce on the top roller. Typical industrial squeeze rollers are designed for a maximum downforce in the range of 5 to 10 tonnes per metre of scour width. Thus, a 2 m-wide
2.9 Squeeze press. [Courtesy of Jandakot Wool Washing Pty Ltd.]
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
33
scour line will normally have a squeeze roller set capable of 20 tonnes total downforce at the exit of the final scouring bowl. Other bowls in the line may be equipped with so-called ‘10 tonne’ presses. Most modern squeeze rollers are pressurised via pneumatic systems. The bottom rollers are commonly of solid steel with a stainless steel coating. The top rollers are also commonly made of steel with a lapping of polyamide rope of square cross section. Where acid conditions are expected (e.g. in the final bowl, where insect resist treatments may be applied, or in the acid bowl of the carbonising process), the lapping should consist of polyester rope owing to its superior acid resistance. Historically, the top rollers were lapped with wool top or nylon tow but such lapping has been largely superseded due to the superior durability of square rope. A few scourers, mainly in Europe, have chosen to use polyurethane coatings for the top squeeze rollers. The regain of wool from squeeze rollers is between 50 and 100% depending on the efficiency of squeezing.1 The main factors affecting the result are the liquor temperature, the downforce on the top roller, the type and condition of the lapping on the top roller, and the evenness of wool flow through the rollers. It is useful to consider what results might be expected for some specific processing conditions. Wool regains in the range 60–70% should be achieved with 10 tonne squeeze rollers with top roller lapping of nylon rope on 2 m-wide scouring lines with bowl temperature of about 60 °C. Figures in the range 50–60% should be achieved for 20 tonne presses with similar operating conditions.
2.5
Scouring chemistry
2.5.1 Detergents and builders Before the 1950s, the main detergent used to scour wool was soap, which was used with an alkaline builder, usually soda ash.20 The propensity of soaps to form insoluble salts with calcium and magnesium ions in hard water areas prompted the development of synthetic detergents and the most common ones used in the scouring industry today are non-ionic types.15 Until recently, nonyl or octylphenol ethoxylates have been most popular. However, they are not readily biodegradable and concerns regarding the environmental effects of such detergents and their breakdown products has resulted in voluntary and legislative restrictions on their use in several countries. As a result, the usage of the more biodegradable fatty alcohol ethoxylates is increasing. Soda ash (sodium carbonate) remains the most common builder used, although sodium chloride or sodium sulphate are sometimes used. The
34
Wool: Science and technology
action of the builder is to stabilise the emulsified woolgrease and dirt, and prevent redeposition back onto the wool.15 Suint has soap-like detergent properties when either natural alkalinity is present in the fleece or alkali is added to the washing liquors.1 Greasy crossbred wools contain more suint than fine wools and, unlike such wools, are naturally alkaline, as well as containing much less woolgrease. This explains why crossbred wools are usually scoured with a hot first bowl without any addition of soda ash. In contrast, soda ash may sometimes be added to the early bowls of fine wool scours. Table 2.2 shows typical bowl operating temperatures for scouring with neutral non-ionic detergent. The optimum temperature depends on the actual detergent used, but is usually within the range 50–65 °C.15 Where alkaline scouring conditions are employed, temperatures less than 55 °C should be used. Desuinting is favoured by many scourers in Europe, in part because the contaminants removed in Bowl 1 are thereby eliminated from the woolgrease recovery system connected to the following bowl(s). This has potential benefits in terms of reduced wear on pumps and centrifuges in the woolgrease recovery system. Siroscour in 3-stage mode uses a modified desuinting bowl (see Section 2.6 for details). The rate of detergent usage depends on the type of wool being scoured, but should be less than 9 litres/tonne greasy weight for merino wools and less than 3 litres/tonne greasy weight for crossbred wools. More of the detergent should be added to the second and third hot scouring bowls to enable the countercurrent flowback system to have greatest effect. However, when scouring merino wools this approach may have to be tempered if the detergent foams excessively in the later scouring bowls. The rate at which wool can be scoured depends greatly on the type of wool. Thus, a relatively clean crossbred wool from NZ usually can be scoured at more than twice the throughput of a low-yielding Merino type Table 2.2 Typical bowl temperatures for aqueous woolscouring (°C) Bowl No.
1
2
3
4
5
Desuinting
<35
60
60
55
50
6 50
(fine wool)
D
S
S
S
R
R
Conventional
60
60
60
50
50
50
(fine wool)
S
S
S
R
R
R
Conventional
65
60
60
cold
cold
60
(NZ crossbred)
S
S
S
R
R
R
Where D = desuint, S = scour (with detergent addition to bowl), R = rinse.
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
35
from Western Australia. The latter wools have a greater surface area to clean owing to the smaller fibre diameter, have more woolgrease, and commonly have much more fine dirt which is difficult to remove. Wool throughputs have increased markedly over the last 30 years owing to improvements in scour and dryer design, process control, and increase in scour working width. Thus, a 3 m-wide scour is capable of washing good quality NZ crossbred wools at a rate of 5.5 tonnes/h. It is of interest to note that, as the working width of woolscour increases, the throughput per metre of width also increases, probably because edge effects are less important for wider scours.
2.5.2 Water quality There are two main sources of problems associated with water quality: hardness and the presence of multivalent metal ions.20 While hardness, in the form of calcium and magnesium ions in the water, does not interfere directly with the action of non-ionic detergents, their presence could cause redeposition of fibre contaminants and dyeing problems. It has been suggested that it is possible to scour greasy wool satisfactorily in water of total hardness up to 70 mg CaCO3 /litre, while unsatisfactory scouring is likely to occur over 100 mg/litre.15 In hard water areas it may be necessary to install a softening plant in order to prevent such problems. Apart from calcium and magnesium, the presence of metal ions such as iron can cause severe dyeing problems by interacting with dyestuffs.20
2.6
Development of scouring systems
For many years, woolscouring of the wide range of wools available was viewed as an art rather than a science. Even wools of the same breed and micron range vary widely in their scouring properties, depending on where the sheep were raised and the methods of husbandry. An early system of note was the Duhamel process, which was introduced in France during the 1920s.1 The system included several elements that were to become cornerstones of woolscouring in the future, e.g. bowls with conical shaped bottoms and the use of decanter and nozzle-disc centrifuges to remove dirt and woolgrease from the liquors, respectively. The process never received universal acceptance, perhaps because poor scouring could have been expected under the liquor conditions used;1 but it is also likely that maintenance problems on many items of equipment would have been severe. Even today, with the major advances in materials and design, the selection of pumps, fibre screens, solids removal systems and centrifuges must be approached warily.
36
Wool: Science and technology
During the 1960s, research and development on scouring machinery concentrated on the design of individual scour bowls. During the 1970s, while such developments continued, they became viewed in the context of a systems approach to woolscouring. This was necessary as energy and pollution discharge costs soared,21 while there was also new environmental awareness. This process probably began with the WRONZ Comprehensive Scouring System (see Fig. 2.10), which was first installed at a new woolscour in Timaru, New Zealand in 1972.1,22 The system was designed after the main deficiencies of typical plant design and operation had been identified.1 The major outcomes were to integrate the contaminant removal systems into the operation of the scour so that all heavy effluent (i.e. that originating from the hot scouring bowls rather than from the rinsing bowls) received treatment before discharge. Such treatment included removal of fibre and heavy solids, and recovery of woolgrease. Batchwise operation, where the scour bowls were ‘dumped’ to drain from time to time, was replaced by a fully continuous process. Liquor management was ‘tight’, with avoidance of bowl overflows and use of bowl-to-bowl ‘flowback’ running countercurrent to the wool flow. The ‘flowdown’ of heavy liquor to drain was at a controlled rate that could be set manually or automatically via measurement of a particular property of the liquor (e.g. density or turbidity). Heat was recovered from the flowdown and used to preheat fresh water being fed to the scour. During 1977, CSIRO released the Lo-Flo process to industry.23 This had a high level of effluent treatment integrated into the scour process. The LoFlo process relied on the phenomenon of ‘concentration destabilisation’. When this liquor condition was reached, all of the suspended solids were
Greasy wool
Scoured wool Fresh water from heat recovery system
Product wool grease
Sludge Effluent to drain
2.10 Simplified flow diagram of WRONZ comprehensive scouring system.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
37
able to be removed by centrifuging, and the liquor was then able to be re-used indefinitely. It was considered that several substances were involved in causing the destabilisation of the liquor. One was suint, another was the detergent added to scour the wool and the builders such as soda ash that were added to the liquors.23 Destabilisation was said to be enhanced by high temperatures, and the liquors were heated almost to boiling point before centrifuging. During equilibrium operation, a mass balance for soluble substances (suint, builder, and detergent) was said to be achieved where the mass of such substances discharged with the sludge from the decanter and with the cream from the disc separator(s) equalled their rate of introduction to the machine.23 There would also be a significant mass of soluble substances carried forward from the Lo-Flo unit to the next washing stage. The Lo-Flo process was trialled by IWS at full-scale in a mill in the UK. To facilitate the transport of wet wool through squeeze rollers at very high liquor concentrations, wash plate systems were used both in the CSIRO laboratory machine and in the IWS full-scale machine. Wash plates include a perforated metal sheet down which the wool is caused to slide by a jet of liquor into the nip of the squeeze rollers.21 In practice, IWS found that it was necessary to maintain a small flowdown from the Lo-Flo unit.21 For dirty wools, the decanter sludge production increased and the suint removal was improved so that the flowdown could be eliminated. Guided by experience in operating their full-scale Lo-Flo installation for two years, the Mini-Flo process was introduced by the IWS, mainly to address the low rates of dirt removal of the wash-plates.21 Their Lo-Flo installation was modified to trial the process, and achieved 65% recovery of woolgrease and 59% recovery of dirt.21 The Mini-Flo prototype used conventional bowls to remove dirt from the wool after the wash plates, while the commercial design used mini-bowls for the purpose. While the results from the commercial prototype were promising, neither Mini-Flo nor LoFlo achieved continued commercial success. An early reference to Siroscour (Fig. 2.11) highlighted the need for cleaner wool and better dirt recovery, both of which had been problems with Lo-Flo.24 Residual contaminants could affect processing performance in several ways, including contributing to dust and fly in the mill, affecting the performance of processing additives, leading to increased wear and tear on machines, and visual effects on both topmaking and subsequent processing (e.g. in spinning and dyeing).25 Studies by CSIRO scientists had also shown that each of the usual wool contaminants, i.e. grease, dirt and suint, had easy-to-remove and hard-to-remove fractions. The model of contaminant removal was as follows:25
38
Wool: Science and technology Greasy wool
Scoured wool Fresh water from heat recovery system Product wool grease
Sludge Effluent to drain
2.11 Simplified flow diagram of Siroscour.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
1) 2)
the contaminant mass is penetrated by water and detergent; the contaminants begin to swell as the water penetrates the mass (the rates of penetration and swelling vary considerably for different contaminants); 3) wool grease globules are formed within the swollen mass; 4) the complexed and uncomplexed easy-to-remove contaminants are removed from the surface of the wool; 5) the hard-to-remove contaminants, which may either be only partially swollen or adhering strongly to the fibre surface, are partially removed. Easy-to-remove contaminants comprised the unoxidised woolgrease, readily soluble suint and loosely held minerals, together with organic and proteinaceous dirt. The remaining hard-to-remove contaminants comprised a small fraction of the total oxidised grease, slowly soluble suint, sub-micron mineral dirt and flakes of protein contaminant.26 To facilitate the scouring of most of the contaminants, and to assist in the removal of the contaminants from the liquors, ‘two-stage’ and ‘three-stage’ scouring was promoted. Three-stage scouring was the preferred mode of operation.25 The first stage (Bowl 1) removed dirt without removing woolgrease by using a modified suint bowl. Small additions of detergent and soda ash were made and the temperature was kept below 35 °C. This improved the recovery of dirt via settling tanks or hydrocyclones in the liquor treatment loop connected to Bowl 1, since there was less chance that non-settleable greasedirt complexes could be formed. In the second stage (Bowls 2–4), the easyto-remove contaminants were removed. Bowls 2 and 3 were scouring bowls containing hot detergent liquor while Bowl 4 acted as both a rinsing bowl to remove the easy-to-remove contaminants entrained in the wool mass and as a soaking bowl to encourage further swelling and hydration of the hard-to-remove contaminants. The third and final stage (Bowls 5 and 6) removed the hard-to-remove contaminants. Siroscour provided a system which will effectively wash the full range of
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
39
fine wools, much in the same way that the WRONZ System provided a similar outcome for New Zealand wools. While the WRONZ System with mini-bowls was indeed capable of efficiently and effectively washing the better types of fine wool, it was not capable of washing all types. A happy marriage of CSIRO and WRONZ technologies took place in the first ANDAR Siroscour, where Bowls 3 and 4 were mini-bowls, as there were space constraints at that particular site. A comprehensive series of trials comparing the performances of different woolscours in industry was reported by the IWS in 1993.27 This was actually the second series of such trials, carried out because there were a number of weaknesses in the first series of trials.25 They were carried out by running four-tonne (greasy) batches each of fleece and skirtings through five different scours: a conventional rake/harrow scour, a suction drum scour (Fleissner), a Siroscour, a short-bowl (mini-bowl) scour, and a solvent scour (de Smet). The results showed strong relationships between specific opening energy and top length (hauteur), and between specific opening energy and noil. Specific opening energy has proven to be a useful measure of the degree of entanglement of wool presented to the card. This measurement technique was developed and used at CSIRO, Geelong. By suitably instrumenting their card, they were able to determine the work done per kilogram of wool carded, i.e. ‘the specific opening energy’.9 Since there are so many variables at play in any particular scour, only a proportion of which can be measured and reported, it is difficult to confirm causal relationships. The method of changing only one or a few variables on a particular scour is therefore preferable, and such tests were carried out on a Siroscour in Asia.25 These tests confirmed the better performance of 3-stage scouring, compared with conventional scouring, both in terms of increased top length and better whiteness (Table 2.3). This is the type of result that scourers have always aimed for and disproves the proposition that better colour can only be achieved at the expense of a more felted product (e.g. via increased mechanical energy input through the scouring process) and hence reduced top length. A subsidiary trial using three-stage scouring was carried out where the degree of mechanical action both in greasy wool opening and in agitation in the bowls was reduced. This had the expected effect of improving the top length but with a small reduction in whiteness (Table 2.3).
2.7
Chemical treatments in woolscours
2.7.1 Carbonising Raw wools are contaminated with amounts of vegetable matter (VM) depending on the environment in which the sheep were raised. The VM
40
Wool: Science and technology
Table 2.3 Comparison between conventional and three-stage scouring for wool scoured at a commercial topmaking plant (Mill A)25 Topmaking
Hauteur (mm) Conventional
Whiteness of tops (Y)
3-stage
Conventional
3-stage
Mill A
65.6
67.3
65.1
65.5
CSIRO
68.7
69.1 (70.6)
66.4
67.0 (66.2)
includes burrs, seeds, twigs, and straw.28 While the woolscouring process is very efficient at removing grease, dirt and suint from the raw wool, it is not effective at removing much vegetable matter. Pre- and post-scour opening and dusting machines can be specified or customised to remove small amounts of VM, but its removal is usually regarded as one of the functions of the card.2 Where the level of VM contamination is high, or where a VM-free product is required, a chemical treatment known as carbonising is necessary. A recent estimate puts the total volume of raw wool carbonised at more than 100 million kg per annum.2 The carbonising process takes advantage of the difference in chemical stability of wool keratin and VM (mainly cellulose and lignin) towards mineral acids. The carbonising process comprises conventional scouring, acidising, drying, crushing, beating, neutralising and final drying of the product. If alkaline scouring conditions are employed by means of additions of sodium carbonate, it is necessary to rinse the wool well before it is acidified.2 Sulphuric acid is the usual choice, applied at a concentration in the treatment bowl in the range 4.5–7.5%,depending on the bowl temperature and on the residence time of the wool in the bowl.2,28 A wetting agent effective under acid conditions is selected to obtain maximum penetration of acid into the VM, while minimising the acid content of the wool. Materials of construction are selected to resist damage by the acidic liquors. The acid concentration in the bowl is best measured by acid-base titration: Knott showed that the densitometric method overestimated the acid concentration by more than 20 g/l for most of a trial week. Moisture removal prior to drying traditionally used squeeze rollers. More recently, it has become accepted practice to install a continuous centrifuge after the acid squeeze roller and before the dryer feed-hopper. Centrifugal moisture removal provides a lower and more even regain distribution in the acidified wool, reducing the loss of fibre strength. Modern high-throughput plants use a separate dryer and baker rather than an integrated unit. Thus, the dryer is designed for rapid drying at low
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
41
temperature but with significant heat inputs, while the baker is designed for higher temperatures but with lower heat inputs. This provides improved flexibility in control, including an opportunity to redistribute the wool mat by means of a feed-hopper prior to the baker. The drying stage is critical in the process,2,28 since acid hydrolysis of the protein chains may occur. Damage can be minimised by drying at low temperatures (60–70 °C) with high air flow rates through the wool mat. After drying, the wool is baked at a temperature in the range 105– 130 °C. Baking times in industry are typically 3–10 minutes depending on factors including openness of the wool mat, wool mat thickness, throughflow air velocity, and the amount of acid on the VM.28 Under the influence of the concentrated sulphuric acid, the VM becomes brittle and charred, which facilitates its removal in the crushing and beating stages. During baking, some acid may react with the wool to form covalently bound sulphate, which can cause problems in subsequent dyeing processes. The amount increases with temperature, baking time and acid concentration on the wool.2 It is necessary to crush the VM directly after baking because its crushability decreases when moisture is reabsorbed.2 Crushing is carried out by passing the wool between sets of pressurised rollers arranged in series, and there is a trade-off between efficient crushing and length reduction in the wool fibre. Beating (dedusting) of the wool entails mechanical action in willows or stepped opener-dusters.2,14,28 Much of the now friable vegetable matter is removed at this stage. After beating, the carbonised wool retains an acid content that can cause damage to the fibre if it is not properly neutralised. Neutralisation is usually carried out in a scouring train comprising 4 to 5 bowls.2 The first bowl contains water, in order to remove free acid and to allow hydration of the wool. The next 2 bowls usually contain sodium carbonate solution to neutralise the wool. Nonionic detergents may also be added to the neutralising bowls.28 The fourth and sometimes the fifth bowls contain rinse water to remove residual sodium carbonate.
2.7.2 Bleaching, insect-proofing and control of photo bleaching Certain chemical processes normally carried out in textile and carpet mills can be applied within the constraints of a continuous scouring regime. Bleaching with sodium metabisulphite or peroxide, insect-resist treatments and a photobleaching control process are those most commonly applied. The chemistry and treatment conditions are described in detail in Chapter 7.
42
Wool: Science and technology
2.8
Drying
2.8.1 General The clean, wet wool from the final squeeze roller set of the woolscouring line carries 50–100% of its bone dry mass as water, depending mainly on the temperature of the water in the bowl, the squeeze pressure and the type and condition of the covering (‘lapping’) on the top roller. The percentage of moisture based on the wool base is termed ‘regain’, and this parameter must be reduced to a typical target value of 16% at the exit of the dryer. Drying is responsible for 30–60% of the heat usage of a typical woolscour1 and ways of reducing the usage of heat have constantly been sought.29 A future approach to energy conservation is ‘airless’ drying, where the material is dried in an atmosphere of superheated steam rather than in hot humid air.30 Energy usage may be much reduced by recompressing and reusing the water vapour,29 or by merely using the recovered heat in wet processing.30 It was found that colour changes on drying should not be a problem but that only thin layers of wool could be handled by the technology. The latter requirement is likely to limit the applications, particularly in the drying of loose fine wool. Applications of superheated steam drying have been hindered by lack of suitable equipment and the corrosive conditions encountered.29
2.8.2 Commercial dryers The dryers used in the scouring and carbonising industry are of the continuous throughput type with throughflow air circulation. The air and material flows within a wool dryer are normally worked in counterflow to maximise the thermal efficiency and drying capacity. Dryers are classified according to the mode of transport of the wool. A suction drum dryer (Fig. 2.12) is fed by means of a belt and the wool is conveyed through it by perforated suction drums. Fixed baffles located inside the drums restrict the air flow to the upper or lower half of each drum alternately. The air circulation may be heated by steam or hot water coils located above and below fans mounted at the ends of the drums. Alternatively, the air circulation heating may be via direct gas firing. Suction drum dryers are compact, are easily controlled and have reasonable capital cost. Conveyor dryers carry wool through the dryer on a perforated slat conveyor through which hot air is circulated downwards (Fig. 2.12). Heating may be via steam or hot water coils or via direct gas firing. Such dryers occupy a larger floor area than drum dryers of the same production capacity since the rate of air circulation through the wool is lower. Upwards air
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
43
Exhaust
Fresh air in
Wool in
Wool out Suction drum dryer
Exhaust Fresh air in Wool out
Wool in
Conveyor dryer
Exhaust
Fresh air in Wool in Wool out
Unidryer
2.12 Types of wool dryer, not drawn to scale.54 [Courtesy of ANDAR.]
flow has the aim of improving the evenness of drying but only very low airflow rates can be used before the wool is lifted off the conveyor. Capital costs of conveyor dryers are higher than for drum dryers and they usually have a slower response in temperature control. Fig. 2.13 shows a conveyor
44
Wool: Science and technology
dryer of recent design, where the wool is conveyed by means of porous sandwich belts. The Unidryer (Fig. 2.12) is a more recent introduction, and was originally intended to be a rapid (‘high intensity’) dryer for carbonising loose wool.31 The wool is carried through the dryer between two woven polyester conveyors while being subjected to reversing airflows in alternate sections of the dryer. The original design used air temperatures up to 150 °C, and relatively heavy bed weights of wool. Lower operating temperatures were used in later designs mainly due to industry concerns about wool yellowing. Because the wool mat is totally contained, throughflow air velocities may be adjusted without the wool drop-off problems that might occur in a suction drum dryer. This means that control of air velocity with possible energy savings is a viable means of regain control. Cleaning requirements should be less frequent because it is less likely that fugitive wool will accumulate in the dryer. It was originally commercialised in the UK on loose wool and then hanks, but achieved little market penetration. Early applications of the Unidryer included the drying of hanks, coils of yarn in the WRONZ Twistset process, and loose stock in dyehouses.1 The Unidryer was succesfully installed in a
2.13 Modern sandwich-conveyor dryer. [Courtesy of Jandakot Wool Washing Pty Ltd.]
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
45
woolscour of 3 m working width in New Zealand during 1996 and further sales followed. Historically, most of the dryers in the wool industry have been heated by means of steam coils. More recently there has been a trend towards heating by means of direct firing with natural gas where it is available. This trend has been driven by improvements in dryer capacity, speed of response in control, and savings in process heat owing to the elimination of transmission and boiler losses that characterise steam systems. Heating by means of radio frequency power has a theoretical advantage in that the energy should be preferentially absorbed by the moisture in the wool, which should result in a more evenly dried product. However, suitably controlled and well maintained hot air dryers produce wool that is sufficiently uniform for baling directly, with lower capital and running costs than radio frequency drying.
2.9
Solvent scouring
There are several major advantages of solvent scouring. Felting and entanglement associated with aqueous scouring are largely eliminated, woolgrease recovery is much increased, suint recovery may be designed into the process, and aqueous effluent problems are avoided. At first sight then, there are several clear cut advantages to be gained from solvent scouring, with only minor disadvantages – the necessity for solvent recovery, possible toxicity and fire hazards to be set against it.32 Several different processes reached commercial prototype status during the 1950s–1970s without achieving significant commercial success. These included a process developed at the Swedish Institute for Textile Research,33 the CSIRO solvent jet process,32 and a process developed in Yorkshire at the West Riding Woollen and Worsted Mills Ltd.34 The Swedish and CSIRO processes both used a relatively high boiling point petroleum fraction, while the Yorkshire process used tetrachloroethylene. The most successful solvent scouring technology has been the de Smet process, with seven plants in commercial operation in 1990.35 It uses a combination of non-polar (hexane) and polar (isopropyl alcohol) solvents to target woolgrease and suint removal from the wool respectively. However, despite the acceptable results obtained for the de Smet plant in comparative testing of woolscour performance,27 there has been little further market success for this technology in the 1990s. A contributing factor is the high capital cost for such plant compared to conventional aqueous plant, during a time of low profitability in the wool industry generally. A new type of solvent scour was commissioned in Japan during 1983.This was the Toa-Asahi process and the solvent used was 1,1,1 trichloroethane. The wool was solvent degreased, dedusted and then given a conventional
46
Wool: Science and technology
soap/soda scour to remove residual suint and dirt. Only one plant was ever installed, and it has ceased operation. Part of the problem with this process was that the chosen solvent both depletes ozone and is a greenhouse gas.36 Historically, high capital costs have militated against the installation of solvent scouring systems. Additionally, because many of the investments in scouring during the 1990s have been for plant upgrades or plant relocations rather than for ‘greenfield’ installations, the opportunities for a step-change in technology have been limited. An exception is the solvent scouring technology from Wooltech Ltd, of Brisbane, Australia,37 who have developed a system using a formulation of 1,1,2 trichloroethylene (TCE). This solvent is non-flammable and does not deplete ozone, since it chemically degrades before reaching the ozone layer. However, TCE is toxic to humans and requires appropriate handling, as described in material safety data sheets (MSDSs) which are available on-line.38 A full-scale topmaking plant including a complete Wooltech solvent scouring system was installed in Trieste, Italy in time for the ITMA Exhibition of 1995 in Milan. Enhancements of fibre properties have been claimed by the treatment using TCE, including increased tenacity, elongation and resilience.37 It has also been claimed that such enhancements combined with the very low residual grease content of the scoured product enables good quality yarns to be spun using the rotor system. When compared with conventional aqueous scouring equipment, which is simple, robust, and has a long working life, solvent scouring equipment is much more sophisticated, and requires a chemical process engineering approach to its operation. However, if the aqueous scouring plant has a comprehensive effluent treatment system added to comply with strict environmental regulations, the levels of engineering sophistication are similar. It will always be difficult to remove the suint and to a lesser extent the dirt, from the raw wool by means of TCE. However, subsequent processing may be arranged to include further cleaning and obtain a satisfactory product (e.g. by backwashing). Capital and operating costs, as well as processing performance, will ultimately determine the success of this technology. At the time of writing, there have been no further installations of the Wooltech system.
2.10
Woolgrease and its recovery
It is useful to clarify terminology relating to woolgrease.1 The material secreted from the sebaceous glands of sheep is ‘wool wax’. The material recovered from woolscouring liquors or by solvent extraction from greasy wool is known as ‘woolgrease’ which, as well as wool wax, may contain pesticide residues, dirt, suint components, and detergent. When the crude wool-
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
47
grease is refined, the product is known as ‘lanolin’. The major components of lanolin are high-molecular-weight esters formed from a mixture of sterols, aliphatic alcohols, and diols combined with straight chain, branched chain, and hydroxy fatty acids. Minor components are free alcohols and acids.1 Acid cracking is a long-established process which includes woolgrease recovery, but because it is applied at ‘end-of-pipe’, it is described in the effluent treatment section. Centrifuging is almost universally used and is most efficiently employed by integrating the operation with the liquor circulation in the scour train as in the WRONZ System or Siroscour. The design of the woolgrease recovery system depends on the quantity and quality of the woolgrease available on the raw wool. For coarse wools (e.g. New Zealand Romney types), two-stage recovery is used. In this type of plant, the liquor is first pumped to a nozzle/disc centrifuge set up as a concentrator to produce a cream for subsequent feeding to a disc separator set up as a purifier. This is usually a self-desludging machine rather than a nozzle machine since there is only a small quantity of dirt in the feed. For Merino wools, a three-stage recovery plant is used, where three centrifuging stages are used in series. Again, the first stage is concentration using nozzle/disc centrifuge(s) and the third stage is purification; but interposed is an additional concentration stage, typically using a self-desludging disc centrifuge. Fig. 2.14 shows a recently installed woolgrease recovery plant for Merino wools. For practical reasons of centrifuge operation and to assist the removal of water-soluble contaminants and dirt, water at almost boiling temperature is added with the cream being fed to the purifier. The product from the purifier centrifuge should be woolgrease at less than 1% moisture. Part only of the grease present in woolscouring liquors can be recovered by centrifuging and this fraction differs in composition from that remaining in the liquor.39 The recovered material is relatively unoxidised while the remainder is relatively oxidised and tends to be darker and of less commercial value. Recycling the clean phase from the separators back to the first hot scouring bowl is usually carried out as part of a system to control the level of total solids in the bowl and this favours the recovery of woolgrease.40 Feeding the liquors to the primary centrifuges at elevated temperatures assists recovery, but there appears to be little benefit in using temperatures above about 75 °C. However, it is claimed that a feed temperature close to boiling point enhances recovery when operating in the Lo-Flo regime.23 Only a minority of commercial centrifuges are suitable for use on woolscour liquor, which brings technical challenges for high-throughput (2.4–3.0 m width) scouring machines. Solvent extraction and aeration have been very rarely used for woolgrease extraction.
48
Wool: Science and technology
2.14 Woolgrease recovery plant. [Courtesy of Jandakot Wool Washing Pty Ltd.]
Woolgrease has an enormous diversity of uses whether as the material recovered in scouring plants, as the refined product (lanolin), or as chemical derivatives of woolgrease1,40 and lanolin. Crude woolgrease has been used for anti-corrosive coatings or additives, leather processing aids, release agents, and tree-wound dressings. It is refined to lanolin by a process of deodorisation, bleaching, and neutralising to provide a lighter coloured product with little odour and low free fatty acid and moisture contents. Lanolin is used widely in the pharmaceutical and cosmetic industries. In pharmaceutical uses, the desired properties of lanolin and its derivatives include their general inertness and ease of emulsification. Cosmetic uses take advantage of the material’s ability to absorb large quantities of water as water-in-oil emulsions or when suitably modified, to stabilise oil-in-water emulsions. Lanolin may be saponified to the constituent acids and alcohols. Cholesterol is one of the most frequently sought after products of saponification, and is one of several that can be further transformed for cosmetic and pharmaceutical use. The wool wax acids are useful in protective surface coatings, corrosion inhibitors, and when converted to metallic soaps, as lubricants.
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
2.11
49
Effluent
2.11.1 Effluent components It is useful to group unit operations and processes together to provide what are known as primary, secondary, and advanced (or tertiary) treatments of effluent.41 In primary treatment, physical operations such as screening, sedimentation, and centrifugation, are used to remove floating and settleable solids found in the effluent. In secondary treatment, biological and chemical processes are used to remove most of the organic matter.The most widely-used measure of organic pollution in effluents is the 5-day biochemical oxygen demand (5-day BOD or BOD[5]). In advanced treatment, additional combinations of unit operations and processes are used to remove other constituents, such as nitrogen- and phosphorus-containing compounds, that are not significantly reduced by secondary treatment. Land treatment processes, now more commonly termed ‘natural systems’, combine physical, chemical, and biological treatment mechanisms and produce-water with quality similar to or better than that of advanced wastewater treatment.41 Woolgrease recovery and dirt recovery are now integrated with the operation of the scour line. However, after such primary treatment the effluent remains highly polluting and difficult to treat. The effluent from a 2 metre-wide woolscour can give a pollution load similar to that of a town with over 30 000 people.42 Effluent discharge from an efficient scouring plant contains these components: i) An oxidised less biodegradable fraction of woolgrease.43 ii) A dissolved organic component (suint) relatively easy to biodegrade. iii) A dirt content which varies tremendously. Fine particles associated with residual woolgrease cannot be completely removed by mechanical means. iv) Minor components such as detergents, insect resist agents, bisulphite, peroxide, and builders (e.g. sodium carbonate). Jamieson and Stewart identified the contributions of the main contaminants to the pollution load and summarised the results in the following formulae:1 BOD[5] = 2400 ¥ Suint + 5100 ¥ Oxidised grease + 11 350 ¥ Top grease + 185 COD = 8267 ¥ Suint + 30 980 ¥ Oxidised grease + 28 326 ¥ Top grease + 6454 ¥ Dirt + 1536
50
Wool: Science and technology
BOD[5] and COD are given in mg/litre and the contaminant concentrations are percentages by mass in the effluent. BOD[5] is the Biochemical Oxygen Demand: it is the quantity of oxygen needed to oxidise one litre of the waste under the conditions likely to be met with in natural receiving waters; the [5] refers to the length of time for which the sample is incubated, namely 5 days. COD is the Chemical Oxygen Demand; it is the amount of oxygen in milligrams required to chemically oxidise one litre of the waste under specified conditions. The formulae illustrate that the oxidised grease is indeed more difficult to degrade by biological means than the top (or unoxidised) grease.
2.11.2 Primary methods of effluent treatment Minimisation of water usage and production of relatively concentrated effluent streams is part of efficient scour management.A concentrated effluent is more conveniently treated than a high-volume waste stream. Primary treatment should, therefore, be integrated with scouring. Modern scouring systems such as the WRONZ or Siroscour systems incorporate primary treatments. Sedimentation (settling of particles by gravity) in settling tanks is still practised industrially, but the use of settling tanks in liquor treatment loops may cause scour liquors to become anaerobic and discoloured due to microbial activity. The use of hydrocyclones has become more widespread as pump and hydrocyclone design have improved. The Lemar Stage 1 Process may be used to increase the rate of woolgrease recovery and to dewater the sludges produced by a typical WRONZ System.1 In this process, the flowdown effluent and sludges are combined and pumped via a hydrocyclone to a decanter centrifuge. The centrate from the decanter is fed to a disc centrifuge where woolgrease (an additional 8–10%) is recovered. Dissolved air flotation has been tested at full scale as a treatment for heavy liquors. It was found that the liquors from a modern scouring system were too concentrated and the results were no better than sedimentation or thickening.44
2.11.3 Secondary treatments Chemical destabilisation by acid cracking is the oldest industrial method for treating woolscour effluents, and is still used by several mills,42 mainly in Europe. It involves adding sulphuric acid to the effluent to provide a pH of 2–3.5, and allowing the resulting sludge to settle. A low grade woolgrease is recovered from the sludge by boiling followed by filter pressing. The method works efficiently for effluents from soap/soda scouring, but is
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
51
unreliable for effluents from scours which use non-ionic synthetic detergents. Acid cracking at the boil has been shown to overcome the difficulties encountered with non-ionic detergents.42 There have been many variations of chemical coagulation and flocculation, regarding both the chemicals used and the process details. Generally, chemical coagulation produces a voluminous sludge that requires dewatering. Simple filtration is not possible since the woolgrease in the sludge causes the filters to clog. Historically, rotary drum vacuum filters using precoats have been employed for dewatering, at considerable running cost. Recent advances in this type of process have included the additional use of polymeric flocculants in a multi-pronged chemical approach, along with decanter centrifuges for sludge dewatering.42,45 Generally, processes using large amounts of chemicals are now considered ecologically undesirable. Alternative approaches treating wastes as a resource are coming to the fore.46,47 Sirolan CF is a chemical flocculation process developed to treat heavy effluent, i.e. the flowdown from hot scouring bowls combined with the sludges from the heavy solids loops. After pH adjustment with acid and flocculation with a polymer, effluent is fed to a decanter centrifuge where suspended solids are removed as a sludge with 50–70% total solids. This process removes over 95% of the solvent extractable and suspended solids, and reduces COD by about 75%. It is used commercially by several scours in the UK and Australia. SWIMS47 is an acronym for Scour Waste Integrated Management System. Its features are: i)
effluent treatment is closely integrated with the operation of the scouring line; ii) each waste stream is treated separately; iii) the wastewater treatment systems are modular; and iv) the scouring wastes are considered as a resource. As well as the heavy liquor flowdown from the hot scouring bowls, in three-stage Siroscour operation there are discharges from the modified desuinting bowl and from the rinsing bowls. Evaporation of the desuinting flowdown produces a potassium fertiliser, while the rinsewater is subjected to microfiltration or other membrane treatment. Suint in the effluent produced by Sirolan CF still has substantial COD. Laboratory and pilot plant trials have substantially removed this by aerobic treatment (Sirolan CFB) except for some bio-refractory material which still exerts a COD. Sludge from Sirolan CF has proved satisfactory as an ingredient for the making of compost when mixed with a variety of materials.47 Alcohol destabilisation occurs if water-soluble alcohols are added to woolscour liquor, to give three phases:1
52
Wool: Science and technology
i) Grease/alcohol phase saturated with water; ii) Dirt/water phase saturated with alcohol; and iii) Water phase containing suint and saturated with alcohol. Alcohols including n-butanol and n-hexanol have been used in laboratory and pilot plant studies, while a full-scale plant using n-pentanol ran for 5 years before the woolscour ceased operation for reasons unrelated to the effluent process.1 Woolscour emulsions may also be destabilised by short-term aerobic or anaerobic treatments, and the woolgrease flocculates into a sludge.43 A twostage laboratory process working on Australian scouring liquors removed 70–90% of the woolgrease (without significantly biodegrading it) at a combined hydraulic retention time of 4–10 days. Such destabilisation is apparently not robust enough for commercial processes to have been developed based on it alone, but anaerobic pretreatments have been used as precursors to full scale coagulation and flocculation processes,1,42 and there are probably opportunities for more leverage to be gained from such low cost destabilisation, perhaps incorporating chemical treatments or electrocoagulation. By way of contrast, aerobic digestion uses free oxygen to convert wastes into carbon dioxide and water, plus biomass. Long residence times are necessary and the feedstock must generally be dilute. Process variables that need to be monitored include temperature, oxygen levels, pH, nutrient levels and degree of mixing. Scours in Germany and Australia have successfully used such treatments. A topmaking plant in Germany reported BOD reductions from 1100 to 80 mg/l and COD reductions from 2500 to 1200 mg/l.46 Commercial anaerobic digestion plants have been reported, but generally the process requires long treatment times and is prone to upsets in the feed.1 A conventional sludge digestion plant has been operating in New Zealand fed with flowdown liquors in admixture with domestic effluent since the early 1980s.1 When operated at a retention time of 20 days, 80–95% reductions in BOD and suspended solids were achieved. Ultrafiltration is a membrane process which is used to separate suspended solids from dissolved solids. On heavy liquors, it produces a suint solution and a concentrated grease-dirt sludge (concentrate). Ultrafiltration plants have been used in the UK scouring industry on heavy liquors for some years, with the concentrate trucked away to appropriate disposal sites and the ultrafiltrate discharged for further treatment at the local sewage works.42 Ultrafiltration and microfiltration have also been used successfully to treat rinsewaters to enable recycling of water in the scouring process. Microfiltration membranes have a larger pore size than ultrafiltration membranes, and hence exhibit higher flux rates.
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
53
Evaporation may be carried out as a stand-alone effluent treatment if suitable outlets for the sludge are available. Various commercial plants are available, and are in use in Europe, Asia and Australia (Fig. 2.15). The efficiency of energy usage may be improved by a number of means, e.g. multiple effect evaporation, use of the steam produced to heat the scour, or by mechanical or thermal vapour recompression.
2.11.4 Tertiary treatments Several systems using biological lagoons are in operation in rural areas of Australia.42 A typical process involves a number of pits and lagoons in series as follows: i) A sludge pit to remove settleable solids. ii) A deep anaerobic pond, sealed by a floating crust of woolgrease. This pond receives the heavy flowdown effluent. Retention time is approximately two to four weeks.
2.15 Effluent treatment plant incorporating an evaporation system. [Courtesy of Jandakot Wool Washing Pty Ltd.]
54
Wool: Science and technology
iii) An aerated lagoon, perhaps using floating aerators. iv) A large holding lagoon, which also receives the dilute rinsewater effluent from the scour. It acts as an evaporation pond or as a holding pond for subsequent irrigation to land. One scour in Australia combines the anaerobic pond and aerated lagoon into a facultative41 lagoon. The dilute effluent is recycled to the scour via a trickling filter, settling and chlorination.42 The main disadvantages with lagooning systems are occasional odour problems and the need for unpleasant cleaning out of the sludge pit and anaerobic ponds.
2.11.5 Total treatments Evaporation and incineration eliminates all aqueous effluent. During the 1970s, over 22 mills in Japan which operated woolscours installed various evaporation and incineration plants.1 Discharge requirements of increasing severity stimulated such expensive measures. Unlike the situation for a stand-alone woolscour plant, the capital and running costs were spread over a large operating base. At the time of writing, all of the scouring operations within Japan have been replaced by lower cost processing options outside Japan. Today’s evaporation plants are typically of the multiple effect falling film type, sometimes operating under vacuum.42,46 Sludges are often burnt in a two-stage process, where the first stage generates a combustible gas by pyrolysis. This approach minimises problems associated with fusion of potassium compounds in the combustion zone and with deposition of particulates downstream of the combustion zone. The performance of a very comprehensive effluent treatment plant at a topmaking mill in Germany has been described.46 Evaporation/incineration is used to treat the heavy effluent while the rinsewaters are treated separately in an aerobic biological system. Condensate from the evaporation plant is reused in the scour rinsing process after stripping ammonia by steam and removing odours and pesticides via a fixed bed bioreactor. Main routes for disposal have been to landfill or for more dilute sludges to be spread on land. Landfill disposal is becoming less favoured as dumping charges increase.47 Suitably conditioned sludges have some value as a fertiliser in agriculture,46 but there may be adverse effects in some cases of sludge disposal on land.48 Composting of sludges is already being carried out commercially by a topmaker in Australia, and it is likely that this method will become more widely used. It has been shown that the sludge from Sirolan CF may be readily composted and that the woolgrease and associated pesticide
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
55
residues arising from on-farm treatments to control lice, flystrike etc are broken down in the process.47 It has also been shown that composting of woolscour sludges and solid wastes must be carried out with care to avoid inadequate results.48 Trials on the pelletising of sludge for use as a fuel or slow release soil improver/conditioner have also been reported.47
2.12
Process control and quality assurance
Over the last 30 years in particular, there has been sustained development in control and instrumentation systems in woolscouring. Often, such developments have been mainly applications of generic innovations from outside the industry (e.g. weighbelt feeding) but significant innovations have also derived from the special needs of the industry (e.g. the Drycom moisture meter). A brief mention of the more significant developments of both types will be given here. Weighbelt feeding of the greasy wool to the scour is now regarded as essential, to provide an even feed-rate of wool with benefits in terms of consistent scouring and drying, increased productivity and provision of management information. Scourcom set the standard for state-of-the-art computerised control systems for woolscours (Fig. 2.16).1,49
2.16 Scourcom computer monitors. [Courtesy of Jandakot Wool Washing Pty Ltd.]
56
Wool: Science and technology
Hoppermatic control of the level of greasy wool in feed-hoppers has allowed for improved control of the opening and feeding stages.1,49 Various on-line monitors have been developed to measure the regain of wool at the exit of the dryer with the most successful unit being the Drycom moisture meter.1,20,49 Control of liquor quality is now practicable by means of density or turbidity sensors.1,20,49 Suitably rugged and reliable sensors are now available commercially for scouring and rinsing applications. The Trimwaste system controls the discharge of sludge from settling tanks.1,20,49 The potential number of applications for this system has reduced as hydrocyclones have become more widely used instead of settling tanks. Continued development has taken place in the measurement of scoured wool properties by means of Near Infra Red Analysis (NIRA). A ‘Generation III’ instrument has recently been successfully installed in a woolscour.50 This instrument has detectors operating in the visible region as well as the near infra red, which has enabled accurate measurement of the ‘as is’ and ‘base’ colour of the scoured wool. In addition, residual grease and moisture levels are monitored simultaneously, with most of the information for these measurements originating from the near infra red detectors. Since the measurement time is now down to 45 seconds, the information is valuable as a guide to the operation of the scour itself. Integrity of the wool sample has been achieved by automated sample coring, transport, loading into the instrument, measurement and sample sealing.
2.13
Energy conservation
Woolscouring is an energy intensive process. In terms of the operating costs for a woolscouring plant, energy is second only to labour. Considerable work was carried out on energy efficiency in woolscouring during the 1970s and early 1980s in response to the rapid fuel price rises of the time.1,51 While there was little scope for reducing the electricity usage in woolscouring, there was considerable potential for savings of process heat by improved design of the heating system, improved control and by installing heat recovery systems. Taking advantage of heat recovery from heavy effluents and from rinsewater is now routine, but heat recovery from dryer exhaust air is less common due to a longer payback time and more demanding practical requirements. Owing to the installation of new, higher productivity scours of 2.4 m and 3.0 m working width during the last 20 years, average energy costs per kilogram of wool scoured have fallen. Improved process control whereby throughputs can be maintained at higher average levels has assisted this result.
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
57
References 1 Stewart R G, Woolscouring and Allied Technology, Wool Research Organisation of New Zealand, Third Ed., 1988. 2 Knott J and Robinson B, Wool Carbonising, Guimares, Eurotex, 1994. 3 Roberts Beaumont, Woollen and Worsted, London, G Bell and Sons Ltd, Third Ed., 1919. 4 Lennox-Kerr P, ‘Clean, green and dry’, Wool Record, 158, (3657), 44, 1999. 5 Christoe J R and Napper G J, ‘The warming of fine wools using the AWC Forced Convection Bale Warmer’, Proc. 8th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Christchurch, Wool Res. Org. of NZ, 1990. 6 Gibson M, The application of radio frequency heating techniques in wool processing, part 2, Wool. Sci. Rev. 46, 1973, 30–43. 7 Nadj L et al, ‘Microwave wool bale warming’, Text. Asia, July 1998, 42. 8 Eley J R et al, Report to Topmakers I, Report No G50, CSIRO, Geelong, 1985. 9 Robinson G A, ‘The Nature of Scoured Wool and its Preparation for Carding’, Proc. Symposium on Woolscouring and Worsted Carding, 38–43, CSIRO Div. Text. Ind., Geelong, 1986. 10 Taylor M E, Improvements to greasy wool openers – II, dusting performance of three multi-drum openers, WRONZ Report No 85, 1981. 11 Taylor M E, Improvements to greasy wool openers – IV, fixed self-cleaning teeth, WRONZ Report No 93, 1982. 12 Taylor M E, The WRONZ Autoclean Opener, WRONZ Report No 149, 1987. 13 Tucker S G, ‘Survival of the fittest’, Wool Annual, (Massey Wool Association of NZ (Inc.)) 1996, 18–23. 14 Lipenkov Y, Wool Spinning Vol 1, Moscow, Mir, English translation, 1983. 15 Robinson B, A basic guide to raw scouring, IWS Technical Information Letter, Ilkley, Report TIL/ET-6, 1991. 16 Atha K E, Commercial development of the CSIRO aqueous jet scourer and the Petrie/Wira improved wool scourer, Appl. Polym. Symp., 1971, 18, 1147–56. 17 Karsch F, Development trends in wool scouring, Mell. Textilber., 1968, 49, 885–9. 18 Chisnall P E and Stewart R G, ‘Studies in Woolscouring Part IV: Commercial Scouring with Mini-Bowls’, Text. Inst. Ind., 17, 68–9, 1979. 19 Jamieson R G, ‘Studies in Woolscouring Part V: The Scouring Efficiency of MiniBowls’, Text. Inst. Ind., 17, 70–1, 1979. 20 Christoe J R, ‘Developments in wool scouring – an Australian view’, Wool Sci. Rev., 1987, 64, 25–43. 21 Morgan W V, Gibson J D and Robinson B,‘How soaring effluent costs have influenced scouring techniques’, Wool Record, 137 (3427) 18–19, 54, 1980. 22 Gibson J M D, Morgan W V and Robinson B, ‘Aspects of wool scouring and effluent treatment’, Text. Inst. Ind., 17, 31–7, 1979. 23 Wood G F, Pearson A J C and Christoe J R, The CSIRO Lo-flo Process, An In-process Effluent Treatment for Aqueous Woolscouring, CSIRO Div. of Text. Ind. Report No G39, 1979. 24 Christoe J R, ‘New Approaches in Wool Scouring’, Aust. Textiles, 7 (2), 37–8, 1987. 25 Bateup B O and Christoe J R, ‘Siroscour: Study of Technical Innovation’, Proc. Top-Tech ’96, 419–31, Geelong, CSIRO Div Wool Tech, 1996.
58
Wool: Science and technology
26 Anon., ‘CSIRO Scouring System Commercialised’, CSIRO Text. News, No 17, 1–2, 1987. 27 Robinson B and Lee C S P, ‘A Comparative Study of Raw Wool Scouring Systems’, IWS Environmental Technical Bulletin ETB-27, Ilkley, 1993. 28 Mozes T E, ‘Raw-wool carbonizing’, Text. Prog. 17, 3, 1988. 29 Keey R B, Introduction to Industrial Drying Operations, Oxford, Pergamon Press, 1978. 30 Schwartze J P, Evaluation of the superheated steam drying process for wool, Aachen, Shaker Verlag, 1999. 31 Nossar M S and Chaikin M, ‘A new development in the drying of textile fibres with air’, Proc. 5th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Vol 5, 635–46, Aachen, DWI, 1975. 32 ‘Solvent scouring of raw wool’, Wool Sci. Rev., 1963, 23, 40–54. 33 Lindberg J and Ekegren S, ‘A new method for solvent scouring of raw wool’, Proc. Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Melbourne, CSIRO, 1955, E, 342–6. 34 Saville N, Shelton W J, Ward R and Sewell J, ‘A system of wool scouring using chlorinated solvents’, Appl. Polym. Symp., 1971, 18, 1157–61. 35 Barker G V and Davin F, ‘A focus on solvent scouring with special reference to the de Smet plant in Western Australia’, Proc. 8th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Christchurch, Wool Res. Org. of NZ, 1990. 36 Robinson B, Recent developments in raw wool scouring and carbonising, IWS Technical Information Letter, Ilkley, Report TIL/ET-7, 1991. 37 Hopkins P, Solvent Cleaning of Wool: Some Recent Developments, Deutsches Wollforschungsinstitut Report No 119, pp 128–135, 1997. 38 http://www.msds.pdc.cornell.edu/ 39 Anderson C A and Wood G F, ‘Fractionation of wool wax in the centrifugal recovery process’, Nature, 193, 742–4, 1962. 40 Stewart R G and Story L F (eds), ‘Woolgrease A review of its recovery and utilisation’, Tech. Papers, Vol 4, WRONZ, 1980. 41 Metcalf & Eddy Inc., Wastewater Engineering: treatment, disposal, and reuse, New York, McGraw-Hill, Third Ed., 1991. 42 Robinson B, Effluent treatments for raw wool scour liquors, IWS Technical Information Letter, Ilkley, Report TIL/ET-8, 1991. 43 Lapsirikul W, Cord-Ruwisch R and Ho G, ‘Anaerobic bioflocculation of wool scouring effluent’, Water Research, 28, 8, 1743–47, 1994. 44 Halliday L A, Pollution control and by-product recovery in the New Zealand woolscouring industry, MSc thesis, Joint Centre for Environmental Sciences, University of Canterbury and Lincoln College, 1976. 45 Aronsson G and Turner G, ‘Reductions in woolgrease and COD levels of woolscouring effluents by combined chemical coagulation and centrifugation’, Proc. 9th Int. Wool Text. Conf., Biella, 1995. 46 Hoffman R, Timmer G and Becker K, ‘The environmentally friendly production of wool tops – waste water treatment at BWK’, Proc. 9th Int. Wool Text. Conf., Biella, 1995. 47 Bateup B O, Christoe J R, Jones F W, Poole A J, Skourtis C and Westmoreland D J, ‘Effluent management’, Proc. Top-Tech ’96, 388–407, Geelong, CSIRO, 1996. 48 Williamson W M, ‘The decomposition of woolscour and fellmongery sludges’, PhD thesis, Plant and Microbial Sciences Department, University of Canterbury, 1998.
Woolscouring, carbonising and effluent treatment
59
49 Stewart R G and Jamieson R G, ‘Raw wool scouring – a New Zealand perspective’, Wool Sci. Rev., 1987, 64, 16–24. 50 Ranford S L, Marsh C, Schuler L P, Ellery M W, Walls R J and Piper C F, ‘Advances in visible/near infra red scoured wool process control technology’, Proc. 10th Int. Wool Text. Conf., Aachen, 2000. 51 Halliday L A, Barker G V, and Stewart R G, ‘Energy Use in the New Zealand Textile Industry’, Report No 29, NZERDC, Auckland, 1977. 52 Lipson M and Black U A F, J. Proc. Roy. Soc. NSW, 1944, 78, 84–93. 53 Ross D A, NZ J. Agric. Res., 1959, 2, 214–28. 54 Halliday L A, ‘Future opportunities in the scouring industry’, Wool Annual, (Massey Wool Association of NZ (Inc.)) 1994, 27–30.
3 Fibre morphology H HÖCKER
3.1
Introduction
Wool is the generally accepted generic description of the hair of various breeds of domesticated sheep (Ovis aries), although it is also commonly used as the generic name of all animal hair, particularly including the socalled fine animal hair, i.e. the hair of the cashmere and angora (mohair) goat as well as the cross-breeds of both (cashgora), of camel, vicuna and alpaca, of the angora rabbit, and of many others including the hair of the yak. The morphology and composition of human hair also closely resembles that of wool. While wool contains a-keratins (protein molecules in a-helix conformation,1 in a complex mixture with proteins of irregular structure), silk and feathers are composed of b-keratins (protein molecules partially in b-pleated sheet conformation2) (see Fig. 3.1). From a macromolecular point of view, wool is a composite fibre, i.e. a fibril-reinforced matrix material with both the fibrils and the matrix consisting of polypeptides (thus of chemically similar nature), interconnected physically and chemically. From a morphological point of view, the wool fibre is a nanocomposite (the reinforcing fibrils have a diameter of about 10 nm) of high complexity with a clear hierarchy indicating an enormous degree of self-organisation. A detailed description of its structure is given in Sections 3.3.4 and 3.3.5. From a protein structural point of view, only the fibrils are regarded as a-keratins, they being embedded into a protein matrix of irregular structural conformation. The fibrils (microfibrils) are typical intermediate filaments, i.e. one type of protein constituting the cytoskeleton, others being actin filaments and microtubuli. They are generally called keratinintermediate filaments (KIF) and the matrix materials in which they are embedded are called keratin associated proteins (KAP).
60
Fibre morphology
61
(b)
(a) 3.1 a-Helical1 (a) and b-sheet2 (b) conformation of polypeptide chains. [Reproduced from Pauling, Corey and Bronson.1,2]
3.2
General chemical composition
Wool is a protein fibre and as such consists of the elements carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen and sulphur (see Table 3.1).3 Except for the large sulphur content, the elemental composition is typical of proteins. The sulphur mainly derives from the amino acid cystine, which has two sulphur atoms forming a disulphide bond, this being the most important crosslinking element of wool. Beside cystine, 20 other amino acid residues are found in wool (see Table 3.2). They are distinguished by their side chain, which imparts a special character, being either hydrophilic or hydrophobic, acidic or basic. Note that, in their ionised state, a deprotonated carboxylic acid group may be regarded as basic, and a protonated amino group as acidic. From Table 3.2 it can be seen the proportions of acidic and basic groups are approximately the same (800–850 mmol/g of each).
62
Wool: Science and technology Table 3.1 Elemental composition of dry wool [From: Zahn, Wortmann and Höcker3] Element
Weight (%)
Carbon
50–52
Hydrogen
6.5–7.5
Oxygen
22–25
Nitrogen
16–17
Sulphur
3–4
Ash
0.5
This high content of oppositely charged side chains facilitates a second kind of crosslinking, i.e. salt-bridges between a glutamate or aspartate residue and a protonated lysine or arginine residue. Salt-bridges will obviously be sensitive to the pH-value of the fibre. A third kind of crosslinking element is the isodipeptide bond between a glutamic or an aspartic acid and a lysine residue. Additionaly, hydrogen bonds have to be included as stabilising elements of wool, notably between amide groups but also between a variety of other hydrogen donating and accepting groups. Hydrogen bonds render wool sensitive to all kinds of hydrogen bond-breaking reagents. Absorption of water, for example, has a major effect on the physical properties of wool fibres (see Chapter 4). After reduction and carboxymethylation (to protect thiol groups), four fractions of proteins can be extracted from wool, namely the low sulphur fraction (LSF), the high (HSF) and ultrahigh sulphur fraction (USF), and the high Gly/Tyr fraction (HGT). The approximate portions, molar masses, and sulphur contents of these proteins are given in Table 3.3. The LSF fraction originates from the KIF.4,5 The amino acid composition of wool, as compared with that of the above mentioned fractions, is given in Table 3.4. Each fraction consists of a number of protein families, each one of them made up by closely related members.6–12 In addition to proteins, wool contains about two percent of internal lipids and external lipids as well. The latter are generally known as woolgrease and are almost completely removed on scouring. There are many fractionated and refined forms of woolgrease, the most widely known of which is lanolin. Internal lipids consist mainly of cholesterol, fatty acids and polar lipids such as ceramides, cerabrosides and cholesterol sulphate (Table 3.5). These lipids originate from all kinds of membranes surrounding living cells and separating the different compartments within the cell such as the
Amino acids with hydroxyl groups in the side chain
Y
Tyrosine
Tryptophan
S T
W
Lysine Histidine
Serine Threonine
K H
Aspartic acid Glutamic acid Asparagine Glutamine Arginine
‘Acidic’ amino acids and their w-amides
‘Basic’ amino acids and tryptophan
D E N Q R
Name and abbreviation
Chemical character of side group
Table 3.2 Amino acid composition of fine Merino wool [From: Lindley4]
CH2
CH3
—CH2—OH CH OH
CH2
CH2 N
—(CH2)4—NH2
N H
H N
NH
OH
350
900 570
40
250 80
200 600 360 450 600
—CH2—COOH —(CH2)2—COOH —CH2—CONH2 —(CH2)2—CONH2 (CH2)3 NHC NH2
Concentration (mmol/g)
Side chain
Fibre morphology 63
G A V P
L I
F
Glycine Alanine Valine Proline
Leucine Isoleucine
Phenylalanine
Amino acids without reactive groups in the side chain
M
Cysteine Thiocysteine Cysteic acid Cystine Lanthionine Methionine
Sulphur-containing amino acids
C
Name and abbreviation
Chemical character of side group
Table 3.2 (cont.)
CH2
CH3
CH2 —CH2—CH(CH3)2 CH CH2 CH3
CH2
260
680 270
760 470 490 520
10 5 10 460 5 50
—CH2—SH —CH2—S—SH —CH2—SO3H —CH2—S—S—CH2— —CH2—S—CH2— —(CH2)2—S—CH3 —H —CH3 —CH(CH3)2 CH2
Concentration (mmol/g)
Side chain
64 Wool: Science and technology
Fibre morphology
65
Table 3.3 Approximate portions, sulphur contents and molecular masses of protein fractions obtained from Merino wool (see text) Protein fraction
Portion (%)
Sulphur content (%)
Molecular mass (kg/mol)
Ref.
Low sulphur
58
1.5–2
45–50 45–60
6 7
High sulphur
18
4–6
14–28 11–23
8 9
Ultrahigh sulphur
8
8
28 37
8 10
High Gly/Tyr
6
0.5–2
9–13 11–12
11 12
Table 3.4 Amino acid composition (mmol/g) of Merino wool and three protein fractions extracted [From: Crewther5] Amino acid
Merino wool
LSF
HSF
USF
Ala
417
518
238
275
Arg
602
585
398
248
Asp
503
655
60
82 1734
Cys*
943
546
1859
Glu
1020
1138
772
905
Gly
688
709
497
702
Ile
234
295
215
330
Leu
583
826
144
151
Lys
193
326
38
1
Met
37
44
0
0
Phe
208
243
50
103
Pro
633
342
969
853
Ser
860
588
1163
1100
Thr
547
354
893
832
Tyr
353
345
164
151
Val
423
477
331
317
LSF = low sulphur fraction, HSF = high sulphur fraction, USF = ultra high sulphur fraction. * Cysteine and half cystine.
66
Wool: Science and technology
Table 3.5 Wool lipids [From: Zahn,Wortmann and Hoffmann14] Class/Name
Formula
Fatty acids Palmitic acid Stearic acid Oleic acid Protein bound fatty acid 18-Methyleicosanoic acid
CH3—(CH2)14—COOH CH3—(CH2)16—COOH CH3—(CH2)7—CH=CH—(CH2)7—COOH CH3—CH2—CH(CH3)—(CH2)16—COOH 24
Sterols Cholesterol Desmosterol (= 24-Dehydrocholesterol)
HO Polar lipids
O
Ceramide HN
(CH2)16
CH3 (CH2)12
HOH2C Cerebroside (Sphingolipid)
CH3
O HN
(CH2)21
CH2OH O O
CH3 (CH2)12
C H2
CH3
OH
Cholesterol sulfate
24
NaO3SO
Fibre morphology
67
nucleus, the endoplasmatic reticulum, the Golgi apparatus, etc. At the termination of the keratinisation process, lipids are trapped in various locations within the compacted mass of wool proteins. It is specially to be noted that there is one fatty acid, 18-methyl eicosanoic acid (18-MEA), that is covalently bound to the surface of the fibre.13 One percent of wool consists of mineral salts, nucleic acid residues and carbohydrates.14 The content of mineral salts is partially nutrition dependent. Nucleic acids can be isolated from wool and used to discriminate between wool of different origins, and particularly between sheepswool, cashmere, and yak fibre.15 Carbohydrates originate from glycoproteins representing former membrane proteins.
3.3
Composition and structure of morphological components of wool
The classical morphology of wool is represented by Fig. 3.2, showing the gross hierarchy of morphological elements.16 The fibre is surrounded by cuticle cells which overlap in one direction and which consist at least of four layers, the epicuticle, the A-layer and the B-layer of the exocuticle, and the endocuticle. The cuticle surrounds a compacted mass of cortical cells of spindle form aligned with the fibre axis and with their fringed ends interdigitating with each other.17 Both cuticle and cortical cells are separated by the so-called cell membrane complex comprising internal lipids and proteins. This cell membrane complex is the component between the cells that guarantees strong intercellular bonding via proteins generally called desmosomes. Transmission electron micrographs of cross-sections of the cortex cells (Fig. 3.3) clearly demonstrate the presence of macrofibrils oriented in the direction of the fibre axis and embedded into the intermacrofibrillar matrix which contains cytoplasmic residues and nuclear remnants. The macrofibrils themselves consist of hundreds of microfibrils (KIF) embedded in a matrix of interfilament material (KAP). The fine structure of the intermediate filaments will be described in more detail later. Clearly, at least two kinds of cortex cells can be distinguished due to different intensity of staining, namely the orthocortex cells, which appear lighter, and the paracortex cells, which appear darker upon staining with silver nitrate in ammonia solution.18
3.3.1 The cuticle The cuticle cell is a nearly rectangular sheet, slightly bent, with a width of about 20 mm, a length of 30 mm, and a thickness of 0.5–0.8 mm (at the scale
68
Wool: Science and technology
2 nm
Dimer
2.8 nm
Protofilament
4.5 nm
Protofibril
10 nm
Microfibril keratin intermediate filament KIF Interfilament material
300 nm Macrofibril
Paracortex cell Orthocortex
Endocuticle Exocuticle Epicuticle
Paracortex
3.2 Hierarchy of a merino fibre with a diameter of 20 mm. The intermediate filament shows three fibrillar subunits. [According to Eichner et al.16]
edge). From cross-sections of about 50 fibres, it was determined that the weight fraction of the cuticle with respect to the whole fibre is between 6 and 16%.18 Transmission electron microscopy of longitudinal sections provides other structural information. There is only a single layer of cuticle cells surrounding the orthocortex while neighbouring the paracortical cells two to three cuticle layers can be detected. The outer cuticle cell generally is thicker than the cuticle cells lying below it. Fibres with extremely small diameter (15 mm and smaller) show single cuticle cells surrounding the fibre stem like a spiral. The cuticle cells have some overlap, with the
Fibre morphology
69
Macro-fibrils
Micro-fibrils Matrixproteins
3.3 Cross-section of cortex cells.
transition from one cuticle cell to the next being either planar or stepwise. While the tip end of the cuticle cell is clearly separated from the cuticle cell below it, the root end of the lower cuticle cell becomes decreasingly thinner and neighbouring cells seem to merge, exhibiting a common endocuticle. Cuticle cells overlaying the paracortex are longer by 40% than those neighbouring the orthocortex. Another distinction is the extent of overlapping. Next to the orthocortex, about 20% of the total length of the cuticle cells are covered by neighbouring cuticle cells while next to the paracortex there is 30% overlap.18 The surface of the cuticle cells contains a covalently bound fatty acid, the chiral 18-methyl eicosanoic acid (18-MEA), very probably bound via a thioester linkage. This has sometimes been called the F-layer, although from transmission electron microscopy it seems more plausible that the fatty acid is integrated into the surface rather than forming a separate layer. The epicuticle, though not yet precisely described, is highly resistant to attack from alkalis, oxidizing agents, and proteolytic enzymes. It is about 2.5 nm thick and amounts to approximately 0.1% of the weight of the fibre. It has been
70
Wool: Science and technology
considered to consist of lipids (including the 18-MEA), proteins, and/or carbohydrates, and, due to its chemical inertness, has been called a resistant membrane containing small proline-rich proteins (SPRPs) typical of proteins of the cornified envelope (CE) of the stratum corneum. The skin19 (cutis) consists of two components: the external epidermis and the connecting tissue containing corium. The epidermis is a cornified layered plate epithelium consisting of several morphologically distinguishable living cell layers such as the stratum basale, the stratum spinosum, the stratum granulosum, and the stratum lucidum covered by a dead cornified cell layer, the stratum corneum, a filament matrix composite.20 The fibrils represent a-keratins or intermediate filaments.21 The plasma membrane of the stratum corneum in conjunction with the protein layer represents the cornified envelope. The A-layer is sulphur-rich (35% S) and characterized by a high degree of crosslinking via disulfide and isodipeptide bonds. There is a marked similarity between the A-layer and the CE, characterized by a similarly high content of the protein loricrin (65–70%) which is rich in Gly, Ser, and Cys. When wool is exposed to chlorine water, oxidation of some of the cuticle proteins lifts up surface bubbles known, since this reaction was first described, as the Allwörden membrane. The formation of the Allwörden membrane occurs as a result of an osmotic effect due to the oxidative cleavage (by means of Cl+) of proteins in the A and B-layer forming degradation products that are too large to diffuse out of the fibre through the resistant membrane with isodipeptide crosslinks. The A-layer-rich Allwörden membrane was found to contain 42% loricrin, 51% ultrahigh-sulphur cuticle proteins and 7% involucrin.3 Thus, the Allwörden membrane is a complex aggregate and may be considered to consist of the epicuticle and part of the A-layer. The B-layer contains 20% S and is correspondingly less cross-linked than the A-layer. The endocuticle, finally, is very low in sulphur and, being more readily permeable, is the usual diffusion pathway for water and other reagents.
3.3.2 The cortex The cortex, comprising 90% of the fibre, consists of different kinds of cortex cells, ortho- (60–90%) and paracortex cells (40–10%), the latter containing a larger amount of sulphur than the former and hence being tougher and more highly cross-linked, as clearly seen upon staining with silver nitrate and transmission electron microscopical inspection. Moreover, in fibres from fine wool breeds, e.g. Merino sheep, the two different cortex cells are arranged in a bilateral manner and the borderline between ortho- and paracortex proceeds in a helical manner along the fibre axis. This results in a
Fibre morphology
71
3.4 Ortho- and paracortex by scanning electron microscopy in conjunction with energy dispersive X-ray fluorescence; light pixels: Sfluorescence (above). Organization of ortho- and paracortex along the wool fibre (below).
stable crimp, the paracortex always being situated in the inner part and the orthocortex in the outer part of the curvature (Fig. 3.4). The cortex is composed of spindle-like cortex cells with a length of 45–95 mm and a width of 2–6 mm. In orthocortex cells, cytoplasmatic residues and nuclear remnants are rarely present. The macrofibrils are clearly separated and show a hexagonal arrangement of microfibrils.
72
Wool: Science and technology
The paracortex cells do not only show the macrofibrils but also clearly distinguishable microfibrils with high density of packing exhibiting both random distribution and hexagonal packing. The borderline between the macrofibrils is less clear than in orthocortex cells. Cytoplasmic residues and nuclear remnants are found in every paracortical cell.22
3.3.3 The macrofibrils Each cortical cell is composed of 5–20 macrofibrils at the widest point with a diameter of 100–300 nm embedded into the intermacrofibrillar matrix material comprising cytoplasmatic and nuclear remnants of the keratinocytes.
3.3.4 The microfibrils The macrofibrils are composed of bundles of 500–800 microfibrils (KIF), each of them being enveloped by KAPs. There are five acidic Type I KIF and five basic Type II KIF, and more than a hundred KAPs, some of which are heavily crosslinked.23 The structure and composition of these components are discussed in more detail in following sections. Two dimensional SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis allows separation of the proteins (Fig. 3.5), obtained upon exhaustive mercaptolysis of wool and carboxymethylation of the resulting thiol groups.24 The types of proteins obtained are listed in Table 3.6. The most impressive example of self-organisation is the structure of the intermediate filaments. The Type I and Type II keratins are expressed just above the bulbus in the wool follicle as the first components of the fibre (Fig. 3.6). In higher areas of the follicle, the isthmus and the infundibulum, glycine-tyrosine rich proteins KAP 6, 7, 8 of the orthocortex and the sulphur-rich proteins KAP 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the paracortex, and eventually the ultra sulphur-rich proteins KAP 5 and 10 of the cuticle cells are expressed.
3.3.5 Primary structure of the wool protein 8c-125 The primary structure of wool keratins has been evaluated from protein sequencing as well as from DNA sequencing. The primary structure of the wool protein KIP 8c-1 is given in Fig. 3.7. It is characterized by an Nterminal and a C-terminal domain. Both are rich in proline and cystine residues. The residues inbetween constitute four a-helical segments, 1A, 1B, 2A and 2B, separated by linkers L1, L12, and L2. The combined segments 1A, L1 and 1B as well as 2A, L2 and 2B have equal length of 20 to 21 nm. The amino acid residues in the helical segments are organised in
Fibre morphology
73
pH 8.9
Type II
UHS
LS
SDS Type I HS
Unknown HGT Type I
Type II
LS = low sulphur; HS = high sulphur; UHS = ultrahigh sulphur; HGT = high glycine tyrosine proteins
3.5 Separation of wool proteins after extraction from Merino wool and subjection to two-dimensional polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis at pH 8.9 in one direction and in the presence of SDS in the other one. [Reproduced from Dowling, Crewther and Parry.24]
heptades; thus the columns are numbered from a to g. The amino acid residues a and d have predominantly hydrophobic side chains. 3.3.5.1 Dimer formation This is the basis of the formation of a heterodimer in the form of a coiled coil. As indicated in Fig. 3.8, the hydrophobic effect is primarily responsible for the formation of the dimer, which additionally is stabilised by saltbridges (Coulombic forces) between the amino acid residues c and g.
74
Wool: Science and technology
Table 3.6 Wool proteins [From: Haylett, Swart, Parris, and Joubert9] Protein family
Number of amino acid residues
Properties
5 acid Type-I KIF
392–416
276 amino acid residues
5 basic Type-II KIF
479–506
80–100 sulphur-rich KAP
94–211
in a-helical central rod domain consisting of 4 segments 16–24 mol% half cysteine
3–15 ultra sulphur-rich KAP
168–197
33–37 mol% half cysteine
10 Type-I-glycinetyrosine-rich KAP
61–84
35–40 mol% Gly + Tyr
5 Type II-glycine-tyrosinerich KAP
ca. 80
60 mol% Gly + Tyr
Outer root sheath
Gene family cell type KAP 5,10 cuticle
Inner root sheath
KAP 4 paracortex KAP 1,2,3 cortex KAP 6,7,8 orthocortex Type I and II keratins cortex
3.6 Expression of KIF (Type I and II) and KAP genes in the wool follicle. Protein genes are activated and transcribed in different cell types in the sequence indicated.
Fibre morphology N-terminal domain 1A
L12
L1
5 Heptades
NAc S F P S S S P P C T P C P V C F G D E
F C N F S S C S C T G N A G N C S G
N L L R C R V S G L A I N S W E F N
2A
1B
L2
2–3 Heptades
14–15 Heptades
C-terminal domain 2B 17 Heptades
20–21 nm
20–21 nm
a b c d e f g
a b c d e f g
M L V N I
QF AS RQ AE L E
L Y L L R
Y I I N I A Y R I L K V L H L
Q E L A D D E Q D D S E I E R
S E C R N D T L G E D S C E S
Y L A L A F E V L L L L L E
K N L E E
F Q K V K R L E R T E K K V
E D E R S
R Q S V L T G S R L A E S N
T R K E R
Q QQ E S P N L PCV T K E Q A K L D I C Q E N T
V T P A A D V E V N L R D G L Q
75
D L N R V L N E T R A Q RR D Y E A L V E T N W V EE Y I R Q T E E L N K Q V V S S S E Q L QS C Q T E I I E L R R T V N A L Q V E L QA Q H N L R D S L E N T L T E T E A R Y S C Q L NQ V Q S L I S N V E S Q L A E I R G D L E R Q N Q E Y QV L L D V R A R L E C E I N T Y R G L L D S E D C K L
P P T A K T I P P P P P R P S R
C C T C T P S C A C C R C C Y
N A N G I C S A A T V S G N V
3.7 Secondary structure and primary structure of an a-keratin monomer, wool protein 8c-1 of the wool intermediate filament. The bold lines characterize the a-helical segments 1A, 1B, 2A, 2B. a-helical segments, the linkers L1, L12, L2, are found. As indicated in the primary structure, the proline and cysteine concentration is particularly high in the terminal domains. The hydrophobic amino acid residues are characterized by vertical lines in the primary structure (amino acid residues a and d within the sequence of heptades) [Reproduced from Parry and Fraser.25]
Two different KIPs, one of acidic and the other of basic nature, form the dimer, a heterodimer. In the helical domains 1B and 2B, six pairs of salt-bridges are formed and between a cationic and an anionic amino acid residue always three non-ionic residues are found. Molecular dynamic simulations showed that the a-helical structure of the segment 1A is inherently stable. In contrast, an a-helical structure superimposed on the linker segment L12 almost instantaneously breaks down upon dynamic simulation.26
76
Wool: Science and technology
N
1A
b
L2
L12
L1 1B
e
2A
2B
C
g a
d
d
a
c
f f c
g
e
b
3.8 a) Schematic representation of a heterodimer of two KIFs as a coiled coil, i.e. a left-turned superhelix. b) Cross-section of a dimer; the amino acid residues a and d are in close contact (hydrophobic effect) while the positions g and e are further apart, interacting via Colombic forces between cationic (g) and anionic (c) residues.
3.3.5.2 The packing of dimers The packing of dimers is end-on and the stabilisation occurs via antiparallel combination with another end-on row of dimers shifted against the first row in such a way that the 2B segments overlap. Thus, a protofilament is formed with four KIF molecules in the cross-section and with a diameter of 2.8 nm. The interaction between the 2B segments is stabilised by lateral formation of disulfide bonds (Fig. 3.9).27 The protofilament then is doubled to form the protofibril with eight KIF chains in the cross-section, and two protofibrils form a half-filament. Eventually, two half-filaments form the intermediate filament with a diameter between 8 and 10 nm.28 Thus, the intermediate filament is an excellent example of a self-organised nanostructured fibre that is the reinforcing element in wool.
3.4
Outlook
The morphology and composition of the morphological constituents of wool are still under investigation. An enormous impact came from genomics, which helped to clarify the proteom of wool, in particular of the keratin intermediate filaments. A second, very strong innovative impulse
Fibre morphology
77
Coiled-coil-dimer
Protofilament (Tetramer)
Protofibril (Octamer)
Half filament (2 protofibrils)
Protofibril: 4.5 nm
10-nm-Filament 8–12 nm
Protofilament: 2-3 nm
3.9 Packing of dimers to form the intermediate filament.
came from the comparison of wool with the cornified envelope of the stratum corneum (see Section 3.3.1), the amino acid composition of which was determined using cultured human epidermal keratinocytes. As indicated in Fig. 3.10, the model proposed by Steinert29 for the outer two thirds of the epidermal cornified envelope comprises a lipid envelope followed by isodipeptide-crosslinked involucrin and crosslinked loricrin above the cytoplasma surface, and is finally integrated by the keratin intermediate filaments that are themselves connected by the protein filaggrin. Wool is definitely the most complex fibre one could imagine. Its morphology and chemical structure, as well as its physical properties, are of utmost importance for a thorough understanding of industrial chemical
78
Wool: Science and technology
Lipid envelope
Involucrin
Loricrin
Cytoplasmatic surface
Keratin filaments
Filaggrin
3.10 Model of Steinert representing the outer two thirds of the human epidermal cornified envelope. The cytoplasmatic surface consists of cross-linked loricrin. Keratin filaments are linked via filaggrin. The isodipeptide cross-linked involucrin is situated below the lipid envelope [Reproduced from Steinert and Marekov.29]
treatments, and dyeing and finishing processes, as well as of its appearance and performance.
References 1 Pauling L, Corey R B and Bronson H R, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, 1951, 37, 205–11.
Fibre morphology
79
2 Pauling L, Corey R B and Bronson H R, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. USA, 1953, 39, 253. 3 Zahn H, Wortmann F-J and Höcker H, Chemie in Unserer Zeit, 1997, 31, 280–90. 4 Lindley H, in Chemistry of Natural Fibres, ed. Asquith R S, Plenum Press, London, 1977, p 147. 5 Crewther W G, Proc. Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Aachen, 1975, I, 1. 6 O’Donnel I J and Woods E F, J. Polymer Sci., 1956, 21, 397. 7 Jeffry P D, J. Text. Inst., 1972, 63, 91. 8 Gillespie J M, in Biology of the Skin and Hair Growth, ed. Lyne A G and Short B F, Angus and Robertson, Sydney, 1965, p 377. 9 Haylett T, Swart L S, Parris D, and Joubert F J, Appl. Polym. Symp., 1971, 18, 37. 10 Lindley H, Gillespie J M, and Haylett T, Symposium on Fibrous Proteins, ed. Crewther, Butterworth, Sydney, 1967, p 535. 11 Zahn H and Biela M, Eur. J. Biochem, 968, 5, 567. 12 Gillespie J M and Reis P J, Biochem J, 1966, 98, 669. 13 Negri A P, Cornell H J, Rivett D E, Textile Res. J., 1993, 63, 109. 14 Zahn H, Wortmann F-J, Wortmann G and Hoffmann R, Ullmann’s Encyclopedia of Indus. Chem., 1996, A 28, 395–421. 15 Kalbe J, Kuropka R, Meyer-Stork L S, Sauter S L, Loss P, Henco K, Riesner D, Höcker H and Berndt H, Biol. Chem. Hoppe-Seyler, 1988, 369, 413. 16 Eichner R, Rew P, Engel A and Aebi U, Ann. NY Acad. Sci., 1985, 455, 381. 17 Rogers G E, Ann. NY Acad. Sci., 1959, 83, 378–399 and J. Ultrastruct. Res., 1959, 2, 309–30. 18 Phan K-H, PhD Thesis D 82, Aachen, 1994, Mainz, Wissenschaftsverlag Aachen, ISBN 3-930085-72-0. 19 Ackermann A B, Histologic Diagnosis of Inflammatory Skin Diseases. Lea and Febiger, Philadelphia, 1978. 20 Brody E, J. Ultrastruct. Res., 1959, 2, 482–511. 21 Matoltsy A G, ‘Structure and Function of the Mammalian Epidermal Horny Layer’, in The Skin of Vertebrates, ed. R J C Spearman and P A Riley, Linnean Society Symposium Theories (London), 9, 1979, 57, and Osbourne M, J. Invest. Derm., 81, 1983, 104. 22 Powell B C and Rogers G E, Formation and Structure of Human Hair, eds Jolles P, Zahn H and Höcker H, Birkhäuser, Basel, 1997, p 59, and Parry D A D, ibid, p 177. 23 Marshall R C, Text. Res. J., 1981, 51, 106–108, and Rogers G E, Kuczek E S, Mackinnon P J, Presland R B and Fietz M J in The Biology of Wool and Hair, Chapman & Hall, London, NY 1988, eds Rogers G E, Reis P J, Ward K A, Marshall R C, p 69–85. 24 Dowling L M, Crewther W G and Parry D A D, Biochem J., 1986, 236, 705–712. 25 Parry D A D and Fraser R D B, Int. J. Biol. Macromol., 1985, 7, 203–13. 26 Knopp B, Jung B and Wortmann F-J, Macromol. Theory Simul., 1996, 5, 947–956. 27 Sparrow L G, Dowling L M, Loke V Y and Strike P M, in The Biology of Wool and Hair, (see Ref. 23), p 145–55. 28 Franke W F, Margin T M and Hermann H, in Verhandlungen der Gesellschaft Deutscher Naturforscher und Ärzte, 115. Versammlung, Freiburg 1988, Wissenschaft Verlagsges Stuttgart 1988, p 153–164. 29 Steinert P M and Marekov L N, J. Biol. Chem., 1995, 270, 17702.
4 Physical properties of wool J W S HEARLE
4.1
The wool fibre
4.1.1 Structural complexity As is clear from Chapter 3, wool and other hair fibres have the most complicated structures of all textile fibres. All of the many levels of structure described in Chapter 3 have an influence on the physical properties of the fibres, and the mechanisms are now mostly understood qualitatively and, in many parts, supported by quantitative analysis. For convenience, the wool structure is summarised in Fig. 4.1, which is similar to Fig. 3.2 but emphasises aspects that are relevant to a discussion of the physical properties of fibres.
4.1.2 Dimensional and other features An idealised wool fibre has a circular cross-section, with diameters for different wools covering a range that can roughly be put as 20 to 40 mm. In reality, the cross-section is slightly and imperfectly elliptical. Fibre lengths range roughly from 5 to 50 cm. The fibres are helically crimped to varying degrees. The differences between different wool types and the methods of measuring dimensions are discussed in Chapter 1. In general, this Chapter will deal with generic features of wool fibres and will not cover differences between different wools. The density of wool is 1.3 g/cm3. The refractive indices of wool are reported1 as 1.553 parallel to the fibre axis, 1.542 perpendicular, and a birefringence of 0.010.
4.2
Effects of water
4.2.1 Moisture absorption The proteins in wool contain —CO.NH— and other groups that attract water. Figure 4.2 shows the change in moisture regain (mass of absorbed 80
Physical properties of wool
81
Epicuticle
Nuclear remnant
Low-S High-S proteins proteins high-tyr proteins
Lefthanded Righthanded coiled-coil α-helix rope
Exocuticle Endocuticle a Cuticle
Matrix Microfibril
Macrofibril
I 7
I 200
Cell membrane complex Para cell Ortho cell Cortex
I 1
I 2
I 2 000
I 20 000 nm
4.1 Wool fibre structure. Note that many wool fibres have a mesocortex, as well as ortho- and para-cortex, and in some coarse wools there is a medulla. [Drawn by Robert C Marshall, CSIRO.]
water/mass of dry fibre) with relative humidity.2 In a standard atmosphere of 65% RH and 20 °C, regain values range from 14 to 18%. Preston and Nimkar3 found that loose wool retained 133% regain when suctioned at -30 cm of mercury from the wet state but only 45% when centrifuged at 1000 g for 5 minutes. This contrasts with other fibres where the two methods give similar values. As can be seen in Fig. 4.2, there is hysteresis in moisture absorption, with the desorption curve being higher than the absorption curve. The shorter intermediate curves show the changeover from absorption to desorption at different humidities. Regain at a given relative humidity varies with temperature; at 70% RH, Darling and Belding4 found values between 17 and 18% from -29 °C to 4 °C, but then it fell to 13% at 71 °C. There have been a number of thermodynamic and mechanistic theories of moisture absorption in wool.5 There is general agreement that the sigmoidal shape of the absorption curve is a combination of water directly held on hydrophilic sites in the protein molecules, which increases rapidly from zero relative humidity and then levels off, and more loosely held water, which increases rapidly at high humidiites. Speakman6 divides the absorption into three types as shown in Fig. 4.3. The first type (a) is
82
Wool: Science and technology
Regain (%)
30
20
10
0
20
40
60
80
100
Relative humidity (%)
4.2 Change of moisture regain of wool with humidity. [After Speakman et al.2]
assumed to be bound to hydrophilic groups in protein side-chains, and has little effect on torsional rigidity or, according to Hearle,7 on dielectric constant and electrical resistance. The second type (b) is attached to groups in the main chain, where it replaces intermolecular hydrogen bonds, and is linearly related to rigidity. The third type (c) is absorbed on top of types (a) and (b). When wool takes up water, the swelling is almost entirely radial, with little change in length. The overall volume increases, initially by a lower amount than the volume of absorbed water, but above about 15% regain the volumes are additive. Table 4.1 shows a set of values for radial and volume swelling, together with the change in fibre density.8 The swelling behaviour is explained on the presumption that most or all of the water is absorbed by the matrix, due to the presence of accessible hydrophilic groups, and that this increases the lateral spacing between fibrils, whose length does not change. The first molecules to be absorbed can pack efficiently with the protein molecules, but the later ones merely increase the volume.
4.2.2 Heat of sorption Table 4.2 gives values for the heat of wetting of wool, namely the amount of heat evolved when the wool is completely wetted out from different regains.8 From this, the differential heat of sorption, namely the heat evolved when one gram of water is absorbed, is calculated. The initial bonding of water to hydrophilic groups generates a large amount of
Physical properties of wool
83
Regain (%)
30
20 Total
10
a 0
b
20
40
c 80
60
100
Relative humidity (%)
4.3 Absorption of water in three types. [After Speakman.6]
Table 4.1 Moisture absorption and swelling of wool [From: WIRA8] Moisture regain (%)
0
2
5
7
10
15
20
25
30
15
27
42
68
85
94
98.5
11.7
14.6
16.3
26.2
32.8
36.8
Approximate 0 RH (%)
2.5
Radial swelling (%)
0
0.66
1.82
2.62
4.00
Volume swelling (%)
0
1.57
4.24
6.10
9.07
Density (g/cm3)
1.304
1.310
1.314
1.315
1.315
6.32
14.3
1.313
8.88
20.0
1.304
1.291
1.277
33 100
1.268
heat, but near saturation the effect is small. It has been found that the differential heat of sorption H follows equation [4.1], which is based on Kirchoff’s equation for dilution of solutions. This is expressed in terms of the relative humidities, h1 and h2, at temperatures, T1 and T2, for a constant regain: 2.3 log(h1/h2) = 9 H(1/T2 - 1/T1)
[4.1]
The values in Table 4.2 are for take-up of liquid water. For absorption of water vapour, the latent heat of condensation (2450 kJ/kg at 20 °C), which is three times the maximum heat of sorption from liquid water, must be added to the values. This evolution of heat has an important influence in clothing. When 1 kilogram of wool is taken from 40 to 70% RH, 160 kJ of
84
Wool: Science and technology
Table 4.2 Heat of absorption of wool from liquid water [From: WIRA8] Regain (%)
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
Approximate RH (%)
0
15
42
68
85
94
98.5
Heat of wetting (kJ/kg) Diff’l heat of sorption (kJ/kg)
101 854
64.5 624
38.1 431
20.5 276
10.0 159
4.19 100
1.13 41.9
33 100 0 33.5
heat are evolved. The main effect of this is to slow down the impact of moving between hot dry atmospheres indoors and cold damp atmospheres outdoors.
4.3
Observed mechanical properties
NOTE: Much of the data in the literature is reported as conventional stress, based on area, in N/mm2 = MPa or, for older work, in dyne/cm2 = 0.1 Pa. Generally, in the textile literature, it is preferable to use specific stress, namely (force/linear density) based on fibre mass. For wool, assuming a density of 1.3 g/cm3, 1000 MPa = 0.77 N/tex, 7.7 cN/dtex or 7 g/den. Stresses are also often normalised in terms of the tension at 15% extension in wet wool, which is the middle of the yield region; this is typically around 35 MPa (27 mN/tex or 0.25 g/den).
4.3.1 Load–extension properties The most extensive study of the mechanical properties of wool was carried out by Max Feughelman and his colleagues at CSIRO Ryde9 from the 1950s onwards. A special feature of their work is that, provided the fibre is not strained by more than 30% or for longer than 1 hour, it can be returned to its virgin state by soaking in water at 52 °C for 1 hour, so that many tests can be made on one fibre. Most of their tests were on fibres from sheep housed and fed in controlled conditions. These factors reduce the problems of variability within and between fibres. Figure 4.4 shows a typical load–extension curve of a wet wool fibre. The features of the curve are: (i) a low-stress decrimping extension near A; (ii) an initial stiff region up to B, usually referred to as the Hookean region – but, though linear, it is visco-elastic, not elastic; (iii) a yield region up to C; (iv) a stiffer region up to break at D. In tests on different fibres, there is little variation in the points B and C at 2% and 30% extension respectively, but the break extension varies more widely, since it is less if there is any weakness or damage in the fibre. Break extensions of 50 to 60% are typical of a good fibre. From the
Physical properties of wool
85
start of the yield region, there is a progressive loss of the X-ray diffraction pattern corresponding to the a-helix and a growth of the pattern for the extended b-chains.10 Variability along the fibre length changes the shape of the curve, because thin portions extend more easily than thick portions. Consequently, part of the fibre may be suffering high extension in the yield region, while other parts are still in the Hookean region and only yield at a higher load. These features were studied in detail by Collins and Chaikin,11 and Fig. 4.5 illustrates the stress–strain curves of fibres that are more or less regular. Their theoretical calculations12 indicate that a perfectly uniform fibre would have a constant yield stress, i.e. zero slope between B and C in Fig. 4.4, and that the changes of slope at B and C would be sharper than are usually found. If the change in cross-section along the fibre is continuous, the effect is to give a higher yield slope, but, if it is discontinuous, there will be steps in the yield region. Figure 4.6 shows how the stress–strain curve changes with humidity and temperature.13 As the wool becomes drier, the main effects are to raise the yield stress, and there is some increase in yield slope. The initial modulus decreases with increasing moisture regain, as shown in Fig. 4.7.14 It has been
D
8 7
Load (gf)
6 C
5
B
4 3 2 1 A
0 0
10
20
30
40
50
Extension (%)
4.4 Load–extension curve of a Corriedale wool fibre in water at 20 °C. AB is the Hookean region, BC the yield region, and CD the post-yield region. Up to B, the rate of extension was 0.375% per hour, and beyond B, 1.875% per day; the whole test took 25 days. [From Feughelman.9]
86
Wool: Science and technology
Stress (kg/mm2)
10 2
2
5
1
1 2
0
50
0 Extension (%)
4.5 Stress–strain curves of wool fibres: (1) with good uniformity; (2) a more irregular fibre. [From Collins and Chaikin.11]
noted15 that although the change to the yield region occurs at higher strains in drier fibres, it is at the same fibre length as at 100% RH, indicating that the additional extension is due to axial shrinkage of the fibre on drying, with some compression of the internal structure. Strength increases in line with the increase in yield stress, but to a lesser extent because of a reduction in break extension. An increase in temperature lowers the stress over the whole curve, with a large change between 40 and 80 °C. The shape of the curve is markedly different at 100 °C (Fig. 4.8). The stress–strain curve is affected by the chemical environment. Figure 4.9(a) shows the effect of alcohols. Because the molecules are larger, they do not cause as much lowering of the stress–strain curve as water. The higher the alcohol, the higher is the stress, with an effect similar to reduction of humidity. Acids inherently tend to lower the stress–strain curve, as shown by formic and acetic acids in Fig. 4.9(b), but this is counterbalanced by the difficulty of the larger acid molecules penetrating the fibre.
4.3.2 Recovery behaviour The shape of the stress–strain curve of wool in extension is not unusual for polymers, though the changes at B and C are particularly sharp. The recovery behaviour is completely different; in most polymers there is no recovery from yielding. In wet wool, as shown in Fig. 4.10, there is complete recovery from extensions up to 30%, but the recovery follows a different curve and only joins the extension curve at about 1/3 of the yield stress. In the post-yield region above 30%, the recovery curve has a similar shape,
Physical properties of wool
0 8.3 27.5 41.0
Stress (N/mm2)
250 200
68.0 84.4 100% RH
150 100
2 Stress (N/mm )
200
87
0°C 20°C 40°C
150
60°C 100 80°C 50
100°C
50 10
0
20 30 40 Extension (%)
50
(a)
0
60
20
40
60
80
Extension (%) (b)
4.6 Change of stress–strain curves with test conditions:13 (a) influence of moisture at room temperature; (b) influence of temperature for wet wool.
Relative Young's modulus
3
2
1
0
20 10 30 Moisture regain (%)
4.7 Change of initial modulus with regain. [From Peters and Woods.14]
but at zero stress there is a small unrecovered extension, which increases with the imposed extension. In his extensive tests at 65% RH, Meredith16 found that the elastic recovery of wool decreased with increasing imposed extension. From 30% extension, the elastic recovery (recovered extension/imposed extension) was 0.6. Table 4.3 gives other recovery data, showing the effect of humidity and imposed extension.17
88
Wool: Science and technology
Stress (108 dyn/cm2)
8
22°C
6
4 100°C 2
0
40 80 Extension (%)
4.8 Stress–strain curves of wet wool at 22 and 100 °C. [From Peters and Woods.14]
3 2 1 10
0
Stress (108 dyn/cm2)
Stress (108 dyn/cm2)
20
5 4 20
3 10
0
20 40 60 Extension (%)
(a)
1
4 5
20 40 Extension (%)
60
(b)
4.9 Effect of chemicals on stress–strain curves. (a) 1 – water, and alcohols, 2 – methyl, 3 – ethyl, 4 – n-propyl, 5 – n-butyl or n-amyl. (b) 3 – water, and acids 1 – n-butyric, 2 – propionic, 4 – acetic, 5 – formic. [From Peters and Woods.14]
4.3.3 Time dependence Wool fibres contain many bonds sensitive to time under load, so that viscoelasticity shows up in reduced stress as rate-of-extension is decreased, in creep under constant load, in stress relaxation at constant extension and in changes in dynamic properties.
89
Stress
Physical properties of wool
0
10
20
30
40
Strain (%)
4.10 Stress–strain curve of wet wool in extension and recovery. The stress is in arbitrary units. [From Morton and Hearle.5]
Table 4.3 Elastic recovery of wool [From: Beste and Hoffman17] Humidity
Elastic recovery from extension of 1%
5%
10%
60% RH
99%
69%
51%
90% RH
94%
82%
56%
In the low-strain Hookean region, Fig. 4.11, from studies by Feughelman and Robinson,18 shows that the higher stress at lower humidities relaxes with time towards the stress in the wet state. From larger strains, Fig. 4.12 shows the stress relaxation of human hair, which will be generally similar to wool, from different extensions in water at 35 °C and from 40% extension at different temperatures.14 The curves divide into four regions, which shows that there are different relaxation mechanisms within the fibre structure. There is rapid decay in less than a second, which, if it were the only mechanism, would lead to an asymptotic approach to a limiting tension. This is followed by a slow decay to 100 seconds, then a faster decay from 100 to 10 000 seconds, before the curve begins to flatten out. The increase in rate at higher temperatures is also shown in Fig. 4.13 for relaxation from the mid-point of the yield region.19
90
Wool: Science and technology 5
RH
Tensile modulus E′, (GPa)
0 4
32
65 3 91 2 100 1 E′• 10–1
10o
101
102
103
104
Relaxation time (min)
4.11 Stress relaxation of a wool fibre from 0.8% extension at different relative humidities.18 The stress, calculated on the basis of the wet cross-sectional area, is normalised to the stress at 0.8% extension in a wet fibre. [From Postle et al.26]
Figure 4.14 shows the creep in a wet wool fibre for short times (2.5 minutes) under different loads in the yield region at 18.5 °C and in the yield region at different temperatures.20 The rate decreases with time and, on a linear time scale, appears to become asymptotic to a constant value. Creep is faster at higher temperatures. Feughelman20 found that the results fitted the empirical equation: 1/e = (a/t) + b
[4.2]
where e is extension at time t, and a and b are constants dependent on load and temperature. When tested over longer times and plotted on a logarithmic scale, Fig. 4.15 shows that another mechanism appears to take over at around 100 minutes and begins to level off in a typical sigmoidal plot at about one week.18 The creep, or stress relaxation, in wool will show up as higher extensions at a given stress in load–extension testing. Figure 4.16 shows the effect on Young’s modulus, which decreases as the rate of extension is decreased.18 As can be seen in Fig. 4.17(a), the dynamic modulus, measured by small oscillations at 116 Hz,21 is highest at a small mean strain level in the Hookean region, is lower through the yield region, and rises again in the post-yield
Physical properties of wool
91
Stress (108 dyn/cm2)
16 12
49%
8
39% 30%
4 20% 0 –2 10 10–1
(a)
10 102 103 104 Time (seconds)
1
Stress (108 dyn/cm2)
12
8
105
25°C 35° 45° 55°
4
65° 75°
85° 95°
0 1
10
(b)
102 Time (seconds)
103
4.12 Stress relaxation of wet human hair: (a) at 35 °C from different extensions; (b) from 40% extension at different temperatures. [From Peters and Woods.14]
3
f / f1
80°C 2
70°C 50°C
1
30°C
30°C 80°C
0
10
102
50°C 70°C
103
Time (min)
4.13 Relaxation of wet wool from 15% extension at different temperatures.19 f/f1 is the ratio of the stress after the given time to the stress after 1 hour. [From Morton and Hearle.5]
92
Wool: Science and technology
Extension (%)
30
Load(g) 6.7 6.5 6.3 6.1 5.9 5.7
20
10
(a) 0
50
100
150
Time (seconds)
°C 25.3 20.5 14.8 9.8
Extension (%)
20
4.4 10
(b) 0
50
100
150
Time (seconds)
4.14 Creep in a wet wool fibre with a diameter of 44.5 mm:20 (a) under various loads at 18.5 °C; (b) under 6 gram load at various temperatures. Note that 6 gram equals 38.5 MPa, which is towards the end of the yield region.
region. Conversely, the plots of loss angle d in Fig. 4.17(b) are roughly mirror images of the modulus plots, being highest in the yield region. Figure 4.18 shows the change in tan d in dry fibres with temperature, as measured by Meredith in bending.22 For wool, there is a rise, presumably to a peak characteristic of many polymers around -100 °C, at low temperature; a peak at about 20 °C; and then a rise at high temperature.
4.3.4 Directional effects The bending behaviour of fibres relates to their tensile properties, with the outside of the bend being in tension and the inside in compression. For
Physical properties of wool
93
90 80 a
Extension (%)
70
b
60 50 40 30 20 10
1
10
102 103 Time (minutes)
104
Young's modulus (⫻107g wt/cm2)
4.15 Creep of keratin fibres in water: (a) human hair at 72 MPa; (b) Cotswold wool at 69 MPa. [From Peters and Woods.14]
2.0
20°C 1.8
40°C 1.6
10
1
0.1
0.01
Rate of extension (% per min)
4.16 Change of Young’s modulus in wet Cotswold wool with rate of extension at 20 °C and 40 °C.18 [From Morton and Hearle.5]
small curvatures with a constant modulus, there is a central neutral plane and the maximum strain is ±(r/R), where r is the fibre radius and R is the radius of curvature. If there is yielding, the neutral plane is displaced in order to minimise the deformation energy. In most polymers, yielding is
94
Wool: Science and technology 2.4 Modulus E' (relative units)
2.2 2.0
0 11
1.8 1.6
33 52.9
1.4
73.8
1.2 85
1.0
92.5 98
.8
100
.6 .4 (a)
10
20
30
40
50
60
Strain ε (%)
Loss angle d (degrees)
6 5 4 3 2
73.8 52.9 11 33 0
1
98 85 92.5
100
0 0 (b)
10
20
30
40
50
60
Strain ε (%)
4.17 Dynamic mechanical properties of Lincoln wool at different humidities at 25 °C and 116 Hz: (a) Dynamic modulus E¢. Unit modulus at 0.6% extension equals 2 GPa. (b) Loss angle d. [From Danilatos and Feughelman.21]
easier in compression than extension, so that the neutral plane moves out and a plot of equivalent stress against strain in bending falls below that in extension, as found for several fibres by Chapman.23 However, for Lincoln wool, the bending curve goes above the tensile curve, as shown in Fig. 4.19(a). Experiments up to higher curvatures on a coarser horse hair fibre show the effect of the eventual yielding in compression, Fig. 4.19(b). The initial identity of both curves shows that the tension and compression moduli are the same in the Hookean region. Figure 4.20 shows the effect
Physical properties of wool
95
0.05 b
Tan δ
0.04 0.03
a d
0.02 0.01
–50
0
50
100
150
Temperature (°C)
4.18 Loss factor for several fibres measured in bending by Meredith22. Curve (d) is for wool. The others are: (a) mercerised cotton, (b) viscose rayon, (c) secondary acetate [From Morton and Hearle.5]
of temperature and humidity on the nominal initial bending modulus: the black circles are repeats at 20 °C after tests at 60 °C; the dotted line is calculated from tensile modulus and swelling data of Bendit and Feughelman,24 and shows good agreement despite being on different wools at different rates. The changes in differential axial length of wool on drying, as discussed in Section 4.4.3, cause wool to bend on drying from the form in which it grows from the follicle, and this leads to the helical crimp of wool fibres. The torsional properties of wool were measured by Mitchell and Feughelman.25 Figure 4.21 shows that there is a linear relation between the reciprocal of torque and the reciprocal of twist angle. The resistance to twisting decreases with increasing humidity. Speakman6 showed that the reduction in torsional rigidity followed a sigmoidal plot against moisture regain, Fig. 4.22, but was linear when plotted against the intermediate absorption, shown as type (b) in Fig. 4.3. The shear modulus, as measured in torsion, is reported26 to be 1.7 GPa at 0% RH, 1.1 GPa at 65% RH, and 0.13 GPa at 100% RH. The effects of temperature, strain and moisture on torsional stress relaxation are shown in Fig. 4.23. Figure 4.24 shows the transverse load–extension curve of wet porcupine quill.27 The initial modulus of 0.37 GPa should be valid as a measure of the properties of the material of the wool fibre, but, as suggested by Hearle,28 the yielding is probably due to breakdown of the composite structure at some level. Kawabata has developed sensitive methods for measuring the properties of fibres in different directions. He reports the following values
96
Wool: Science and technology
Bending Stress (MPa)
100
Tensile
0
10
(a)
20
Strain (%)
200 Bending Stress (MPa)
100
Tensile
0 (b)
10 Strain (%)
20
4.19 Nominal stress–strain curves in bending compared with tensile curves: (a) Lincoln wool; (b) horsehair. [From Chapman.23]
Physical properties of wool
97
5
4 Nominal bending modulus (GPa) 3 20°C 40°C 60°C
2
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
100
R.H. (%)
4.20 Effect of temperature and humidity on nominal bending modulus of Lincoln wool. See text for explanation of black circles and dotted line. [From Chapman.23]
at 25 °C and 55.3% RH: axial modulus EL = 3.33 GPa; transverse modulus ET = 1.09 GPa; shear modulus GLT = 1.47 GPa.29
4.3.5 Fibre strength: fracture and fatigue For ‘good’ wool, the evidence indicates that wet fibres break at an extension of 50 to 60% at a stress of about 100 MPa. Figure 4.25 shows a plot of break load in a standard atmosphere against the local area of cross-section at the break point of wool fibres.30 The slope of the upper bound line indicates an intrinsic strength of 300 MPa. However, the break load of individual fibres, when related to their average diameter or linear density, may be much lower than this due to variability, which causes failure to occur at a thin place. The points falling below the line in Fig. 4.25 can be attributed to
Wool: Science and technology 10 ty mi di
8
Re 0%
5 4
H. R.
lat
6
90 %
ive
Hu
7
. R.H 58% .H. 0% R
10
Torque–1 (dyne-cm)–1
9
3 2 1 0 0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
Twist–1 (radians–1)
4.21 Reciprocal of torque plotted against reciprocal of twist angle for a wool fibre of diameter 44.6 mm when wet.25 [From Feughelman.9]
1.0
Relative modulus of rigidity
98
0.8
Cotton
Total regain
Cotton Wool
a-Phase only Total regain
Wool
b-Phase only
0.6
0.4
0.2
0
10 20 Moisture regain (%)
30
4.22 Relative torsional rigidity plotted against moisture regain. The upper plots are for wool; the comparison for cotton shows a plot against the first absorbed water in a two-phase model. [From Morton and Hearle.5]
Physical properties of wool
99
100 % R.H.
1.4
9.1°C 21.5°C Tt T60 35°C 1.0 42°C 10–1
1 10 Time (minutes)
1.7 rads. 84.5 1.5 16.1 16.1 Tt 9.0 1.3 34.5 T60 69.1 401 1.1 1.0 –1 100 10
(a)
0 % R.H. 100 % R.H.
1 10 Time (minutes)
100
(b)
4.23 Torsional stress relaxation, plotted relative to stress after 60 minutes: (a) effect of temperature at 100% RH; (b) effect of strain at 0% and 100% RH. [From Chapman.15]
Lateral stress (MPa)
15
10
5
0 0
2
4
6
8
10
Lateral strain (%)
4.24 Stress–strain curve for porcupine quill in lateral extension.28 [From Feughelman.9]
some defect in the fibre, which may be a surface crack, an internal flaw, or some general weakness in the fibre. The form of tensile fracture is a granular break perpendicular to the fibre axis, Fig. 4.26(a).31 In some fibres, the break is in short or long steps joined by an axial split, Fig. 4.26(b,c). The two transverse cracks are an indication
Wool: Science and technology 35 30 Load (gf)
100
25 20 15 10 5 0
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
1600
2 CSA (µm )
4.25 Break load of wool fibres plotted against area of cross-section at point of break.30
(a)
(b)
(c)
4.26 Three views of the tensile fracture of wool fibres. [From Hearle et al.31]
Physical properties of wool
101
of prior damage to the fibre, either a pre-existing split or flaws in two places along the fibre. When wool is repeatedly flexed by pulling to-and-fro over a pin, there is a combination of axial splitting and surface wear,32 as shown in Fig. 4.27. Severe repeated buckling, either in a laboratory test or in a carpet, leads to the formation of axial cracks due to internal buckling in axial compression,32 as shown in Fig. 4.28(a). This leads to rupture, Fig. 4.28(b), and is followed by axial splitting.
(a)
(b)
4.27 Failure in wool fibres on flexing over a pin. [From Hearle et al.31]
(a)
(b)
(c)
(d)
4.28 Failure in repeated severe buckling of a wool yarn. (a) transverse crack; (b) ruptured end; (c,d) subsequent axial splitting. [From Hearle et al.31]
102
Wool: Science and technology
4.3.6 Thermal properties, transitions, supercontraction The thermal conductivity of horn, which is a similar material to wool, increases from 194 mWm-1K-1 at 0% moisture regain to 290 mWm-1K-1 at 30% regain.32 For fibre assemblies, the trapped air leads to much lower values of thermal conductivity. Figure 4.29 shows the variation of specific heat of wool with temperature at various regains.33 The peak below 0 °C at higher regains will be due to the latent heat of ‘freezing’ of loosely bound absorbed water. There is also an indication of a step increase at around 40 °C, which would correspond to a second-order glass transition. A differential scanning calorimetry study by Phillips34 showed that the change in specific heat was considerably affected by fibre ageing. Wool with 15% regain stored at 20 °C for 52 days showed a pronounced endotherm near 60 °C on the first heating cycle, which disappeared in a second run after rapid cooling, but reappeared after 15 days reageing. Figure 4.30 shows how the transition temperature falls with increasing water content. The effect of the second-order transition on mechanical properties is shown by the large drop in the stress–strain curve of wet wool between 40 °C and 80 °C, as seen in Fig. 4.6. The position of the transition is clearly 3.5 33.9 % 30.7 %
3.0
Specific heat (Jg–1 K–1)
28.4 % 2.5 24.8 %
2.0
16.9 % 7.6 %
2.5 Dry 1.0
0.5 –100
–50
0
50
100
Temperature (°C)
4.29 Variation of specific heat of wool with temperature and regain.33 [From Morton and Hearle.5]
Physical properties of wool
103
Transition temperature (°C)
160 140 120 100 80 60 40 20 0 0
10 20 Water content (%)
30
4.30 Variation of transition temperature of wool with water content. [From Phillips.34]
shown in Fig. 4.31 by the change in the strain at the end of the yield region in wet wool. There is no change up to 60 °C, but then there is a rapid increase. The plot of initial modulus against temperature shows a reduction associated with the glass transition, but it then drops rapidly above 100 °C to almost zero at 130 °C, Fig. 4.32. The effects above 100 °C are attributed to a first-order transition and are associated with the phenomenon of supercontraction, which may be brought about in various ways. A fibre that has been stretched to above 40% extension, steamed and released, will contract to less than its original length. Irreversible supercontraction occurs when wool is immersed in a boiling solution of phenol or a lithium halide in water, and reversible supercontraction occurs in cuprammonium hydroxide or a lithium halide solution in milder conditions. In a hot solution of lithium halide, the fibre contracts in a first stage to around -15% extension, with a complete loss of crystallinity, as shown by X-ray diffraction, and of birefringence. After a few minutes, second-stage supercontraction goes to a final value between -30% and -50% extension. Washing the fibre after the first stage restores the fibre to its original state, but this does not occur after the second stage. First-stage supercontraction occurs after many hours in a cold lithium bromide solution above a critical concentration; second-stage supercontraction occurs when the concentration is increased and heat is applied. Chapman35 used this procedure to investigate the change in tensile properties. Figure 4.33 shows the stress–strain curves in water and in cold LiBr solution after first- and second-stage supercontraction.
Wool: Science and technology
Strain at point C
104
0
20
40
60 Temp. (°C)
80
100
Hookean modulus ¥ 10–10 (dyn.cm–8)
4.31 Change in strain at end of yield region in wet wool (point C in Fig. 4.4). [From Chapman.15]
2.0 Rate of strain (8%/min.)
1.0
0
20
40
60
80 100 120 Temp. (°C)
4.32 Change in initial modulus of wet wool with temperature. [From Chapman.15]
In wet wool, the X-ray diffraction pattern of a-keratin is lost at about 130 °C, indicating a melting of the intermediate filaments (IFs). In dry fibres, a melting endotherm occurs at around 225 °C.
4.3.7 Ageing and setting The stress relaxation of wool has been referred to in Section 4.3.3. However, it can be viewed in another context as ‘ageing’ of the fibre. This is particularly important in relation to wrinkling and wrinkle recovery in wool fabrics. In effect, the ageing of bent fibres in the fabric, due to stress relaxation, means that they have been ‘set’ in a new form with changed properties. Setting can be accomplished more rapidly by other treatments. Feughelman36 studied the behaviour after setting in boiling water for 1 hour. Figure 4.34 shows the stress–strain curves in water at 20 °C for the original unset fibre and a fibre that had been set at 10% extension. Both because of the increased set length and a reduction in the initial modulus, the start of the
Load F15 冣
1st stage
Water
1.0
Strain (%)
2nd stage –30
–20
–10
105
冢
Normalised stress
Physical properties of wool
0
10
20
30
4.33 Stress–strain curves in water and in LiBr solution after first- and second-stage supercontraction. [From Chapman.35]
yield region at A is shifted to a much higher extension, when based on the original length. The yield slope is unchanged and the end of the yield region at B is shifted only slightly to a higher extension. Feughelman found that the change was only partial after setting for just one minute. The points A and B were in the same positions as in Fig. 4.34, but the fibre was not set: its length under zero stress was unchanged. The initial part of the curve started from 0% extension and followed a sigmoidal path, with high-lowhigh slopes, to the start of the yield region at A. Feughelman also found that releasing the fibre, after 1 hour set, in water at 100 °C for 1 hour, restored the fibre almost to its original length and stress–strain curve. Release at 120 °C led to supercontraction. As described in Section 7.13, setting is assisted by chemical treatments that attack disulphide bonds, and may be locked in if more permanent chemical cross-links are formed.
4.3.8 Fibre friction Wool has the unusual feature of a directional frictional effect (DFE). It is harder to pull against the scales than with them. For wool on wool, there are three options: (1,2) fibres with roots and tips opposed, pulled with or against the scales; (3) fibres with roots and tips at same end, pulled either
106
Wool: Science and technology 5
Stress (108 d/cm2)
4
Setting strain Original
A
B
3 2 1 0
0
10
20 Strain (%)
30
40
4.34 Stress–strain curves, unset and set at 10% extension in boiling water. [From Hearle et al.37, based on measurements by Feughelman.]
way. For wool on another substrate, there are the two options of with or against the scales. Typical experimental results are given in Table 4.4. As with all fibres, the values of the coefficient of friction m depend on the state of the surfaces, particularly the presence of lubricants, and the environmental conditions. It is also found that Amontons’ Law is not strictly followed, so that m is not a constant independent of normal load, but is merely a ratio of friction force to normal load.
4.4
Structural mechanics
4.4.1 The chemical background As is clear from other chapters in this book, wool is composed of a complicated cocktail of proteins and other chemical substances. This means that the thermal and mechanical responses of the fibres are determined by a variety of interatomic and intermolecular bonds and a diversity of structural forms. The mechanics of most of the properties is understood qualitatively, and there are some quantitative theories. Much detail remains to be worked out, but this should be achieved through advances in computer modelling and in analytical techniques, which define structure more precisely. The different parts of wool fibres that influence mechanical properties are shown in Fig. 4.1. The keratin proteins in the intermediate filaments (IFs) can, to a first approximation, be regarded as forming microfibrillar crystals with a-helical chains intra-molecularly linked by hydrogen bonds, though an idealised behaviour will be modified by the presence of various side-groups. Under
Physical properties of wool
107
Table 4.4 Friction of wool [From: Morton and Hearle5] with scales
against scales
same direction
Wool on wool – static – kinetic
0.13 0.11
0.61 0.38
0.21 0.15
Wool on rayon – static – kinetic
0.11 0.09
0.39 0.35
Wool on nylon – static – kinetic
0.26 0.21
0.43 0.35
Wool on wool – crossed fibres
0.20–0.25
0.38–0.49
Pair of twisted wool fibres – dry – wet
0.11 0.15
0.14 0.32
Unswollen wool, swollen** ebonite
0.58
0.79
Swollen* wool, unswollen ebonite
0.62
0.72
Swollen* wool, swollen** ebonite
0.65
0.88
Wool on ebonite – polished surface – rough surface
0.60 0.50
0.62 0.61
Wool on horn: dry
0.3
0.5
Wool on horn: wet, pH 4.0 – untreated – chlorine treated – alcoholic KOH treated – sulphuryl chloride treated
0.3 0.1 0.4 0.6
0.6 0.1 0.6 0.7
* in water ** in benzene.
tension, a crystal lattice transition is observed, extended-chain b-crystals form and the hydrogen bonds become inter-molecular. Terminal domains (tails) of the keratin molecules contain cystine and project into the matrix. The keratin-associated proteins of the matrix are more complicated. The mechanical role of the glycine-tyrosine-rich proteins is not understood, but the cystine-rich proteins constitute a cross-linked network, within the globular molecules, between globules and connecting to the terminal domains of the IF proteins. In the dry state there will be hydrogen bonding between matrix protein segments, but, in wet fibres, absorbed water will give a mobile structure. Other intermolecular bonds will also influence the mechanical response. The cell membrane complex has a different chemistry. The link to mechanics has been little investigated, but the presence of lipids means that it is probably a fairly weak material. The mechanical responses of the various layers of the cuticle also need more study.
108
Wool: Science and technology
4.4.2 The fibril–matrix composite The main features of the stress–strain relations can be explained in terms of an axially oriented, parallel assembly of fibrils (IFs) in an amorphous matrix. Feughelman38 laid the foundations of the theory with the two-phase model shown in Fig. 4.35. Swelling of the matrix by absorbed water, which pushed the fibrils apart, explained the high transverse swelling and low axial swelling of wool. The initial extension in the Hookean region is resisted mainly by the deformation energy of the hydrogen-bonded a-helices in the fibrils, with a small contribution from the matrix. Lower shear and transverse moduli are determined mainly by the softer matrix. Quantitative analysis of the anisotropic mechanical properties would follow composite theory. For elements in parallel, which applies to the axial extension of the two-phase model, the mixture law adds forces or averages moduli. For elements in series, extensions are added or compliances averaged. Across circular units in a matrix, as applies to the shear and transverse response of the two-phase model, the stress distribution is more complicated, but the predictions tend to be closer to the series model. A three-dimensional finite-element analysis of the anisotropic elasticity was carried out by Curiskis39,40, but the detailed predictions have been criticised by Postle et al.26 page 23. The possible role of breakdown of the cell membrane complex or elsewhere, which would give the observed yielding under transverse stress, is discussed in Section 4.4.4. The two-phase model was extended to cover the large-strain extension and recovery behaviour by Chapman.41* The model results from a proper analysis of the mechanics of the composite system of fibrils and matrix, both of which have specific load–extension properties. For the fibrils, a plot of free energy against extension will have the form shown in Fig. 4.36(a), which is based on a diagram by Feughelman.9 The energy minima at A and B correspond to the coiled and extended crystal forms. Differentiation gives the force–extension curve shown in Fig. 4.36(b). OA is the extension of the a-helices and FC of the b-crystals. For infinitely large crystals, the extension would jump from A to C, because of the instability of a decreasing force region. At intermediate extensions, both forms * There was an earlier theory by Feughelman and Haly42, based on an alternation of X-zones, which extended in the yield region, and Y-zones, which extended in the post-yield region. There were subsequent detailed variations of this model, and in 1994 Wortmann and Zahn43 suggested an explanation in terms of the IF structure. In the same year, Feughelman44 suggested another model, which was based on separate globular molecules surrounded by water in the matrix. A review by Hearle28 concludes that the Chapman model and its later developments, as described here, are basically correct, though enhancements are needed to take account of more complicated structural details.
Physical properties of wool
109
would be present along DF at the force for equilibrium between a and b, which is given by the slope of the line AB in Fig. 4.36(a). In small crystals, thermal vibrations will cause the jump to occur at the lower force H in Fig. 4.36(b).The expected force–extension relation for the fibrils is thus OHJFC. Along JF, the fraction of a will be decreasing and of b increasing. For the ideal a-helix, the extension to F is 120%, but, for the actual IFs, it is probably only 80%, as some parts are not able to change to the b-crystalline form. In practice, wool fibres will break at around 50% extension, marked by the point G. On the Chapman model, the matrix in the wet state is assumed to act as a rather highly cross-linked, swollen rubber. The matrix stress–strain curve can be derived from the supercontraction experiments shown in Fig. 4.33. Following the X-ray diffraction evidence, it is assumed that the a-crystals are disrupted in first-stage supercontraction, so that the stress–strain curve
Filament
Matrix
4.35 Feughelman’s38 two-phase microfibril–matrix model. [As drawn in Postle et al.26]
(a)
(b) Activated state ∆F
B ∆F* A Length of unit in state B (unfolded) Length of unit in state A (folded) Extension of Burte-Halsey unit
A Force
Free energy
Stress field ‘F’
Fc Fe
C
H EJ D O
G
F
B Extension
4.36 (a) Free-energy diagram for a Æ b transition. (b) Force diagram. [From Hearle.28]
110
Wool: Science and technology
is then dominated by the matrix. If the matrix ceases to contribute after second-stage supercontraction, the small resistance to extension is the residual effect of the disrupted IFs. Subtraction of the stress–strain curve after the second stage from that after the first stage thus gives a prediction of the matrix stress–strain curve, as shown in Fig. 4.37(a). In Fig. 4.37(b), it is shown that this curve is close to a theoretical rubber elasticity curve, based on the inverse Langevin function form, with two free links between junction points. The deviation at high stress can be attributed to some rupture of cross-links, which leads to the observed loss of some recovery from extensions over 30%. The maximum extension of the rubber-elasticity curve is about 50%, and this defines the limit at which the matrix will rupture and wool fibres will break. Higher extensions can be achieved, as was done by Bendit45, if cystine cross-links are allowed to break by treatment in hot water. This leads to the maximum extension of 80% for completion of the a Æ b transition. In the Chapman model, the composite fine structure is treated as a fibril, with helical chains, in parallel with an amorphous matrix, with the two linked at intervals to give a series of zones, as shown in Fig. 4.38. Originally, this form was chosen for simplicity in modelling, but now the links correspond to the IF keratin tails, which are cross-linked to the KAPs in the matrix. The stress–strain curves of the two components of the wet fibre are shown in Fig. 4.39(a), based on the above arguments. Up to 2% extension, Fig. 4.38(a), both components extend together, but, as described above, almost all the stress comes from the fibrils. When the critical stress is reached, one of the zones, arbitrarily selected either due to variability or thermal vibration, opens from the a helix to the b extended chain. The tension in the fibril drops to the lower equilibrium value and the matrix extends to make up the tension. There would be an infinitesimal drop in tension, but this is picked up by further extension, so that further zones continue to open. The stress through the yield region, Fig. 4.38(b), remains constant and equal to the IF critical stress plus the small contribution of the matrix at 2% extension. At 30% extension, Fig. 4.38(c), all zones have opened. Further extension in the post-yield region, Fig. 4.38(d), causes the matrix stress to increase. In recovery, Fig. 4.38(e), there is no critical factor and the zones all contract together until they disappear and the initial stress–strain curve is rejoined. With the values shown in Table 4.5, the predicted stress–strain curve is shown in Fig. 4.39(b). This is identical with the experimental stress–strain and recovery curves, if the variability that causes the slope in the yield region is absent. At humidities below 100%, intermolecular hydrogen bonds stiffen the matrix. This gives a larger matrix contribution to the stress and thus increases the initial slope and the yield stress. In the initial and post-yield regions, the matrix stress can be calculated by subtracting the assumed fibril
Normalised stress Load 冢 F15 冣
Water
1st stage 1st stage
冢–2nd stage冣
1.0
2nd stage extrapolated
0
10
20 30 Strain (%)
(a)
40
50
Theoretical rubber elasticity
Nominalised stress
Experimental matrix curve
1.0
(b)
0
10
20 30 Extension (%)
40
4.37 (a) Stress–strain curves of wool after first- and second-stage supercontraction, and for (first stage – second stage), which is assumed to be the matrix curve. The curve for wool in water, which in recovery is almost parallel to the matrix curve, is shown for comparison. (b) Comparison with theoretical rubber-elasticity curve. [From Chapman.35]
112
Wool: Science and technology From 0% to 2%: uniform extension at 2%: IFs reach critical stress
From 2 to 30%: zones open in succession in open zone: IF at eq. stress, matrix at 30%
At 30% extension, all zones open
Beyond 30%, IF at eq., matrix stress rises
In recovery, IFs at eq. stress all zones contract until they disappear
4.38 Schematic representation of the sequence of changes in the Chapman model. [From Hearle.28]
stress from the experimental curves shown in Fig. 4.6. For the intermediate extensions, calculation is not possible, but Fig. 4.40 shows matrix stress– strain curves interpolated in this region.37 They are typical of an amorphous polymer with hydrogen bonds that are broken at a yield stress. Setting can be explained37 on the assumption that the rupture and reformation of cross-links relieves the stress and shifts the origin of the matrix
113
Stress
Stress
Physical properties of wool
M c
b eq
a
Strain
(a)
0
Strain (b)
4.39 (a) Stress–strain curves for fibril and matrix; (b) Predicted stress–strain curve of composite. [From Hearle.28]
Table 4.5 Controlling parameters for Chapman model [From: Hearle28] Parameter
Value
Determines
Notes
Microfibrils a modulus
1.75 GPa
Initial fibre modulus (plus small matrix contribution)
Similar to theoretical calculation
Critical stress a Æ b trans’n
0.035 GPa
Fibre yield stress (plus small matrix contribution)
Reasonable at 2% strain
Equil’m stress a Æ b trans’n
0.07 GPa
Junction of extension and recovery curves
Reasonable on basis of Fig. 4.36
b modulus
1.75 GPa
Additional microfibril extension in post-yield region
Actually higher; negligible effect
a Æ b strain
80%
Extension in opened zones
From X-ray diffr’n expt’s; less than ideal a-helix
Matrix # Nonlinear stress/strain
See Fig. 4.37(b)
Post-yield and recovery curves (plus microfibril contribution)
From supercontr’n expt’s & rubber elasticity theory
In’l modulus
0.35 GPa
Addition to microfibril tension
Follows from #
Extension at critical stress
30%
End of yield region
Follows from #
Ideal max’m extension
40%
Limiting extension if no cross-link failure
Follows from #
Actual max’m extension
50%
Fibre break extension and strength
Greater than ideal max’m due to cystine bond break
114
Wool: Science and technology
0 8.3 27.5 41.0
Stress (108 dynes/cm2)
25
20
100% R.H. 68.0
84.4
15
10
5
0
10
20
30 Strain (%)
40
50
60
4.40 Predicted matrix stress–strain curves at different humidities. Dotted lines are interpolated between calculated curves from model. [From Hearle et al.37]
stress–strain curve to the setting strain, as shown in Fig. 4.41(a). Application of a sequence similar to that shown in Fig. 4.34 gives the new stress–strain curve, shown in Fig. 4.41(b). The positions of the points A and B are found to be the same as in the experimental curves of Fig. 4.34, but something different happens in the low-stress region. Visco-elasticity in dry wool in the Hookean region is explained by the progressive breakage of hydrogen bonds in the matrix due to thermal vibrations. This will be intensified at larger strains. If the thermal and chemical conditions are right, other bonds, such as cystine cross-links, will also show time-dependent breakage. The lowering of the critical condition for the a Æ b transition due to thermal vibrations, as shown in Fig. 4.36(a), is another source of time-dependence. Detailed theoretical treatments of these effects follow the classical visco-elastic models, either in their mathematical formulations26 or by adding viscous elements to the computation of the two-phase model.46 By adjusting parameters, it is possible to fit experimental results, but more detailed understanding and modelling is needed in order to derive predictions from first principles.
4.4.3 The ortho-cortex and fibre crimp The two-phase model with fibrils parallel to the axis of the fibre, as shown in Fig. 4.35, and the subsequent treament of the fibre mechanics, applies
Physical properties of wool Stress
115
Original
X
Y
Strain
Stress (Arb.units)
(a)
15 X 10 Original
Y
Setting strain A A'
B
5 X
(b)
0
10
B'
Y 20 30 Strain (%)
40
4.41 (a) Postulated changes in matrix stress–strain curve after setting. (b) Calculated behaviour of set fibres. [From Hearle et al.37] Note: The X lines, which do not give a reasonable prediction, follow a vertical shift of the stress–strain curve; the Y lines with a horizontal shift give a prediction similar to the experimental results.
strictly only to the para-cortex of wool and, with some detailed modification of input parameters, to the meso-cortex. In the ortho-cortex of wool, the IFs (microfibrils) are bundled together in macrofibrils. Electron microscope pictures show circular IF cross-sections at the centres of macrofibrils, becoming increasingly elliptical towards the circumference. This implies that the IFs and the associated matrix follow helical paths in the macrofibrils. Electron microscope tomography47 enables quantitative measurements of twist angles to be made. The structure is like that of a twisted yarn. Similar theory will apply, though account must be taken of the shear stress between IFs and this will lead to a change in tensile properties, which can
116
Wool: Science and technology
be approximated as a reduction of stress at a given extension by the factor cos2 a, where a is the twist angle at the surface of a macrofibril. A more important consequence is the influence of dimensional changes associated with moisture content, as analysed by Munro and Carnaby.48 The simplest assumption is that the wool fibre is straight when wet, since this is the state in which it is formed. The IFs are then widely separated by the swollen matrix. Drying the fibre will cause a lateral contraction that will reduce the twist angle and cause the macrofibril to extend. The increased stress-free length of an isolated macrofibril would depend on a balance of contraction at the circumference and extension at the centre. However, on the other side of the wool fibre, the lateral contraction of the para-cortex will not cause any extension, because the IFs are parallel to the fibre axis. Consequently, the fibre acts like a bimetallic strip and bends to minimise the deformation energy. The longer orthocortex will take the outside of the bend and the shorter paracortex the inside, as is observed experimentally.49,50 This is the source of crimp in wool fibres. There is some uncertainty about the detail of the helical form. If the ortho–para boundary rotates along the fibre, it would automatically generate a helix. However, if the boundary remains in the same transverse direction, the minimum energy state would be a tight coil, but, to form this from the straight fibre, it is necessary for the fibre to twist. If twisting is allowed, the intermediate state at a given fibre length would be a unidirectional helix; if it is not, alternating right- and left-handed helices would form, as in bicomponent synthetic fibres.
4.4.4 Fibre strength and the cell membrane complex On the Chapman model, as described in Section 4.4.2, the matrix would break at a lower extension than the IFs, and would trigger fibre breakage at around 50% extension. However, the wool fibre is a composite at a number of levels, and it is likely that the system of cells bonded together by the cell membrane complex (CMC) plays a part in determining the form of breakage. Once a crack started in the matrix of one cell, it would be expected to propagate across the cell. The CMC will act as a weak bond, which, as in fibre composites, blocks crack propagation. However, there will be stress transfer from the ruptured cell to neighbouring cells, which causes them to break in a nearby region. This gives rise to the granular breaks shown in Fig. 4.26. The above argument applies to the intrinsic strength, which gives the upper bound in Fig. 4.25. There are many possible causes of lower values of strength. As already mentioned, if the fibre is variable, failure at the weakest link will give a lower apparent strength when related to the average
Physical properties of wool
117
fibre thickness. Lower intrinsic strength will result from any damage or defects in the fibres. Weakness in the CMC is another, more fundamental, possibility.51 For short fibre composites, the strength is reduced, compared to a system without slip, by a slippage factor SF, which is given by equation [4.3]: SF = 1 - (1/4)(S/B)(D/L)
[4.3]
where S is the tensile strength of the cell, acting as a short fibre in the composite, B is the bond strength of the CMC between cells, D is the cell diameter and L is the cell length. In ‘good wool’, with B reasonably high and (D/L) small, SF should be close to 1, but, if there are thick, short cells with weak CMC, then there will be appreciable loss of strength. The slippage effect will be greater in the transverse direction when (D/L) is equal to one. This is the most likely cause of the yielding in transverse extension of porcupine quill, as found by Feughelman and Druhalla.27 Breakdown of the CMC will lead to the multiple split ends that are often seen in failure of wool in fatigue situations. The transverse axial cracks are a natural consequence of the buckling of aligned elements within the structure.52
4.4.5 Fibre friction and the scales Qualitatively, the scales on the wool fibre would be expected to give a ratchet-like action, due to scales interlocking with one another or catching on asperities on a surface. This would give rise to the directional frictional effect. Figure 4.42 shows the various possible interactions, and from the geometry it is intuitively obvious that motions against scales, Fig. 4.42(b,d), will give more resistance than with scales, Fig. 4.42(c,e). For fibres in the same direction, Fig. 4.42(a), the friction will have an intermediate value. Lincoln53 has given a more detailed analysis based on the components of normal load and frictional force, as shown in Fig. 4.43(a). If F is the frictional force and N is the normal load, Amontons’ Law, F = mN, has a constant coefficent of friction m. Polymeric fibres are generally found to follow a power law: F = aNn. This formulation implicitly assumes that the normal load and frictional force are respectively perpendicular and parallel to the surfaces, both locally and generally. For the scales on wool, this is not so. In Fig. 4.43(a), W and F are the components related to the overall surface, N and P are the components related to the local plane of contact, which makes an angle q with the overall surface plane. Putting P = aNn, the forces are related by equation [4.4].
118
Wool: Science and technology
Tip
Root (a)
(b)
(d)
(c)
(e)
4.42 Directional friction in wool: (a) between fibres lying in same direction; (b) between fibres against scales; (c) between fibres with scales; (d) on plane surface against scales; (e) on plane surface with scales. [From Morton and Hearle.5]
F cos q - W sin q = a(W cos q + F sin q)n
[4.4]
The frictional force increases rapidly as q goes from negative values, i.e. moving away from the slope, to positive values, as in Fig. 4.43(a). Contact with a wool fibre as shown in Fig. 4.43(b) will have different angles, depending on which part of the scale is in contact. These may be simplified as a saw-tooth with two angles, a and b. Combining positive and negative values of a and b, as appropriate, leads to the frictional forces shown in Fig. 4.43(c), in which the mean force against the scales is higher than the mean force with the scales.
4.5
Electrical properties
4.5.1 Dielectric constant and loss factor At the base level for dry wool, the dielectric constant of wool is about 1.5, and this will result from dipolar groups in the protein and other molecules. In practice, the major influence is that of water. H2O is a permanent dipole, and its orientation in an electric field determines the dielectric constant e. The lag in responding to an alternating field determines the loss factor tan d. The structural features that influence these values are the amount of absorbed water and the firmness with which it is bound; the test conditions that change the values are frequency and temperature. A measurement problem is that the only easy way to measure dielectric properties is on a fibre assembly. Hearle7,54 made tests on yarns wound
Physical properties of wool W
Motion
N
R
119
F
q F
P
With scales
(a) W
W -b
a
b
-a
0 +a
Against scales q +b
a (b)
b
(c)
4.43 (a) Frictional contact at an angle to the overall surface. (b) Different angles of contact on wool scales. (c) Combined effect with and against scales. [From Morton and Hearle.5]
between two cones. The results are shown in Fig. 4.44. The dielectric constant and power factor rise steeply at higher moisture contents and lower frequencies.
4.5.2 Electrical resistance Electrical current in wool is carried either by charged ions present as impurities or by the mobility of protons in hydrogen bonds. According to a theory by Hearle55, only dissociated ions are free to move, and the degree of dissociation depends on the dielectric constant e through its influence on the dissociation energy of two charged particles. Application of the Law of Mass Action leads to equation [4.5]: log R = (A/e) + B
[4.5]
where R is the electrical resistivity and A and B are constants. Changes in e cause orders-of-magnitude changes in resistance, because of the logarithmic dependence. Empirically, it was found that at higher values of moisture content M, log R varied linearly with log M. Figure 4.45 shows the variation of resistance with moisture content and compares the theoretical and experimental results. Up to about 6% moisture content, the resistivity of wool is constant with a value over 1012 ohm cm or, in mass terms, 1012 ohm g/cm2. The drop in resistance starts at a higher moisture content than in cotton and this reflects the way in which the first absorbed water is firmly bound. A comparison against relative humidity is shown in Fig. 4.46. Wool lies between the more conductive cellulose fibres and the less conductive synthetic fibres.
120
Wool: Science and technology
64% R.H.
4
0.4 cosf
em
64% R.H.
47% R.H. 0% R.H.
2
0.2
47% R.H. 0% R.H. 0
0.1
1
a)
100 10 f kc/s
0
0.1
1
10 100 f kc/s
3.0 em a 2.5 b c
d e f g
2.0
0.1 tan d
a
0.05
cb d
h i 1.5 b)
0.1
1.0
f Mc/s
10
0
i 0.1 3¢s
e f g h
10
1.0
f Mc/s
4.44 Dielectric constant and loss factor of wool yarns with a packing factor of 52–53%. (a) By bridge method at lower frequencies7 (the loss is expressed by the power factor cos f, which equals sin d); (b) By a resonance method at higher frequencies.54
Physical properties of wool
121
14
y Log Rs or e–r + c
12
Wool
10 Cotton 8 6 4 1.9
0.1
0.3
0.5
0.7 Log M
1.1
0.9
1.3
1.5
4.45 Log–log plot of resistance against moisture content, showing a comparison of experimental values (full lines) and theoretical predictions from equation [4.5] (dotted lines). [From Morton and Hearle.5]
14
Acetate
12 Log Rs
Terylene
Nylon
Orlon Silk
10 Wool 8 Cotton
Viscose
6 4 10
20
30
40 50 60 70 Relative humidity (%)
80
90
4.46 Plot of resistance on a logarithmic scale against relative humidity for a variety of fibres. [From Morton and Hearle.5]
4.5.3 Static electrification Static electricity is easily generated when two different surfaces are separated. Typically this occurs in rubbing or in walking on wool carpets. A determining factor in the detection of static charging is how fast the charge can leak away. If the material is a perfect insulator, the limiting charge is given by conduction across the gap between the surfaces as they separate but, if the material is a moderate conductor, conduction can occur back through the material to the unseparated region. If the material is a good conductor, all the charge can flow back and none is left on the material. For practical time scales, static charges begin to drop from the maximum
122
Wool: Science and technology
limiting value when the resistivity falls to 1010 ohm cm, and will be very small below 106 ohm cm. The values in Fig. 4.46 show that wool will suffer from appreciable static charging below 60 to 70% RH. Static electrification is described in detail by Morton and Hearle.5
4.6
Yarns and fabrics
4.6.1 Structural mechanics of fibre assemblies In general terms, the mechanics of wool yarns and fabrics follows treatments that are common to all textiles. These are described in books.56,57 An account that is specifically related to wool is given by Postle et al.26 Hearle58 includes nonwovens. The extensive work on fabric hand and the KES-F testing system, which is particularly relevant to the effects of finishing of wool fabrics, has been reviewed by Kawabata and Niwa.59 In addition to the particular tensile and other properties, the special features of wool are fibre crimp, which leads to high bulk and softness, and scales, which lead to felting. Good recovery properties are also beneficial, and especially the regeneration of properties by washing. Setting, whether temporary by drying or permanent by chemical cross-linking, maintains the form of yarns, fabrics and garments.
4.6.2 Wool yarns Most wool yarns are twisted structures. Twist, or the alternative of entanglement by felting, is necessary to hold staple fibres together. The effect of obliquity is to reduce the stress at a given extension, but wrapping round in a curved path generates transverse pressure and hence axial friction, which grips the fibres. An approximate analysis56 gives the effect on the yarn stress–strain curve in terms of the surface twist angle a and a factor k that depends on the resistance to slip: (yarn stress at given extension/fibre stress at same extension) = cos2 a(1 - k cosec a) [4.6] The first term is the direct effect of obliquity. The second term is the reduction in stress due to slip from fibre ends. The factor k is proportional to 1 (a Q/mL2) /2. This shows the more effective gripping of fibres with small radius a, large length L, and high coefficient of friction m, in yarns with a short migration period Q and high twist a. The twist is given in operational terms by: 1
tan a = 0.0112(1/jr)C /2T
[4.7] 3
where j is the packing factor, r is fibre density in g/cm , C is yarn linear density in tex, and T is twist in turns/cm.
Physical properties of wool
123
As (1 - k cosec a) decreases from a limiting value when k cosec a << 1, the central length of fully gripped fibre becomes smaller. Equation [4.6] breaks down below (1 - k cosec a) equal to 1/2. The fibres are no longer fully gripped anywhere and there is cumulative slippage.This is the turnover condition between self-locking yarns and draftable rovings. Figure 4.47(a) gives examples of the stress–strain curves for worsted and woollen rovings twisted on a laboratory twister60, and Fig. 4.47(b) gives a comparison of the experimental values of modulus and strength with values predicted from equation [4.6] with fitted values of k. The more irregular woollen structure does not fit the theory and is much weaker than the worsted structure. Modulus results for the worsted yarn can be fitted to equation [4.6], but the strength values require an additional numerical factor, which reflects a higher effective fibre strength in yarns than in fibre tests. A more detailed theory for wool yarns in which there is negligible slip from fibre ends is given in Postle et al.26 This takes account of the bulkiness of wool yarns, and the reduction in volume during extension as the outer fibres compress the underlying structure. The shortest path hypothesis provides a useful procedure. Because fibres are slender, the energy needed to bend and twist them is small and can be neglected, so that they take up the shortest available path. Once a fibre has been pulled into such a path, any further yarn extension requires fibre extension, which is much more strongly resisted and dominates the deformation energy. Following the early work of Carnaby and Grosberg,61–63 a number of more detailed analyses have been made using more elaborate mathematical and computational techniques. However, the underlying difficulty is to have an adequate description of the complex fibre arrangement in wool yarns, which can have a major influence on when the structure jams so that fibres are forced into extension. The more difficult problem of the formation of yarn structure needs to be solved as a prelude to analysing the mechanics of the structure.
4.6.3 Fabric mechanics Postle et al.26 provide a full account of work on the mechanics of woven and knitted fabrics. In general, deformation under low forces depends on the resistance to bending and twisting of yarns, so that the initial modulus is low. When tensions are high enough to straighten yarns or jam the fabric, the forces increase and follow the resistance to yarn extension. Because fabrics are thin, they have a low bending resistance. However, the double curvature needed for good drape and handle also requires in-plane deformation.64 This is found in woven fabrics by a trellis action, which gives very low resistance to shear, and in knitted fabrics by the loop structure, which gives a low resistance in all directions.
3
20
1 Specific stress (g wt/tex)
Fiber
15°
2 g/tex
10°
15 0
2
4
6 % 8 No.1
No.2
Fiber
10
35°
5 15°
30°
40°
20°
40° 35° a = 50° 30° 25° 20° 15°
a = 50°
10°
(a)
20
0
60
40
0
20
40
60
Extension (%)
Yarn/fibre ratios
1·0
0·5
(b) 0
20
40
60
Helix angle a (°)
4.47 a) Stress–strain curves of fibres and twisted rovings. No. 1 – worsted. No. 2 – woollen. (b) Comparison of theory and experiment. No. 1 – worsted. Yarn modulus: black circles, experimental; short dash line, theoretical plot of cos2 a(1 - 0.133 cosec a). Yarn strength: open circles, experimental; long dash line, theoretical plot of 2.3 cos2 a(1 0.24 cosec a). No. 2 – woollen. Yarn modulus: black triangles, experimental. Yarn strength: open triangles, experimental. The two lines coming down from top left are for two theories of effect of obliquity without slip. [From Hearle and EL-Sheikh.60]
Physical properties of wool
125
An aspect of particular importance to wool fabrics is the relaxed state of the fabric. After manufacture or finishing, the fabric will have certain dimensions, but relaxation will change these. For knitted fabrics, Munden65 defined two relaxed states: dry-relaxed for fabrics allowed to recover from knitting stress for at least 24 hours; wet relaxed after wetting and subsequent conditioning. Wrinkling, creasing and crease recovery in wool fabrics, which involve the bending response of wool fibres, have been modelled by Chapman.66,67 Wool is used in needled nonwoven fabrics, in which the fibre arrangement generates the friction to provide fabric strength. The active geometry consists of curved fibre paths in the plane of the fabric passing round the ‘pegs’ (tufts of fibres) that result from the needling action.68 Needled fabrics are necessarily rather thick and, if they are to be stable self-locking structures, must be compacted, so they lack low in-plane resistance and therefore are limited in drape capability. Felts are a long-established form of wool fabric, made possible because of the directional frictional effect in wool (see Section 4.4.5). When a mass of wool fibres is agitated, particularly in hot wet conditions when the fibres are very flexible, each fibre moves in the low-friction direction. The roots move forward followed by the tips – in other words, if the fibre direction is defined as root-to-tip, the fibre as a whole moves progressively backward. Each step involves an increase of interlacing with neighbouring fibres. Eventually a highly interlaced, self-locking felt is produced.
4.6.4 Carpets Wool is used as a carpet fibre because of its bulk, resilience and durability. Carnaby and Wood69 have reviewed the physics of carpets. Important aspects are comfort and compression, appearance retention, and wear resistance. The compression behaviour is determined by the bending and bending recovery of fibres within the carpet pile. An aspect of this related to appearance is the problem of shading, which can cause great concern to customers. It has been shown that this is due to patches of fibres lying in different directions. In some cases, the cause is clear. For example, the movement in turning a corner provides shear forces in a particular direction, which causes the fibres to bend over from their initial direction to follow the shear. Neighbouring regions which are not walked on, or are subject to a symmetrical pattern of treads, will have fibres that remain lying in the original direction. In cases where there is no obvious cause, it is presumed that there is some asymmetric action at an early stage of the use of the laydown or use of the carpet, which causes the pile to reverse, and that this is intensified by subsequent treading.
126
Wool: Science and technology
Carpet wear has been modelled in terms of fatigue sites that are moreor-less randomly distributed through the carpet pile. This leads to a progressive loss of fibre material. Wear is much more severe in turning-walk trials than in straight walk. The commonest form of fibre breakage is the development of cracks in severely kinked fibres.70
References 1 Preston J M, Modern Textile Microscopy, Emmott, London, 1933. 2 Speakman J B, Cooper C A and Stott E, ‘Wool: moisture relations’, J. Text. Inst., 1936, 27, T183–96. 3 Preston J M and Nimkar M V, ‘Measuring the swelling of fibres in water’, J. Text. Inst., 1949, 40, P674–88. 4 Darling R C and Belding H S, ‘Textile yarns: moisture absorption at low temperatures’, Industr. Eng. Chem., 1946, 328, 524–9. 5 Morton W E and Hearle J W S, Physical Properties of Textile Fibres, 3rd edition, The Textile Institute, Manchester, 1993. 6 Speakman J B, ‘An analysis of the water adsorption isotherm of wool’, Trans. Faraday Soc., 1944, 40, 6–10. 7 Hearle J W S, ‘Capacity, dielectric constant and power factor of fibre assemblies’, Text. Res. J., 1954, 24, 307–21. 8 WIRA, Wool Research Vol 2: Physical Properties of Wool Fibres and Fabrics, Wool Industries Research Association, Leeds, 1955. 9 Feughelman M, Mechanical Properties and Structure of Alpha-keratin Fibres, UNSW Press, Sydney, 1997. 10 Bendit E G, ‘A quantitative X-ray diffraction study of the alpha-beta transformation in wool keratin’, Text. Res. J., 1960, 30, 547–55. 11 Collins J D and Chaikin M, ‘The stress–strain behaviour of dimensionally and structurally non-uniform wool fibres in water’, Text. Res. J., 1965, 35, 777– 87. 12 Collins J D and Chaikin M, ‘Structural and non-structural effects in the observed stress–strain curve for wet wool fibres’, J. Text. Inst., 1968, 59, 379–400. 13 Speakman J B, ‘Intracellular structure of the wool fibre’, J. Text. Inst., 1927, 18, T431–53. 14 Peters L and Woods H J, Protein Fibres in Meredith R (editor), Mechanical properties of textile fibres, North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1956. 15 Chapman B M, ‘A review of the mechanical properties of keratin fibres’, J. Text. Inst., 1969, 60, 181–207. 16 Meredith R, ‘Textile fibres: comparison of tensile elasticity’, J. Text. Inst., 1945, 36, T147–64. 17 Beste L F and Hoffman R M, ‘Resilience of fibres and fabrics: quantitative study’, Text. Res. J., 1950, 20, 441–53. 18 Feughelman M and Robinson M S, ‘Some mechanical properties of wool fibers in the “Hookean” region from zero to 100% relative humidity’, Text. Res. J., 1971, 41, 469–74. 19 Katz S M and Tobolsky A V, ‘Wool fibres: relaxation of stress’, Text. Res. J., 1950, 20, 87–94.
Physical properties of wool
127
20 Feughelman M, ‘The creep of wool fibres in water’, J. Text. Inst., 1954, 45, T630–41. 21 Danilatos G and Feughelman M, ‘Dynamic mechanical properties of a-keratin fibers during extension’, J. Macromol. Sci. – Phys., 1979, B16, 581–602. 22 Meredith R, ‘Dynamic mechanical properties of textile fibres’, Proc. 5th Int. Congress in Rheology 1968, University of Tokyo Press, 1969, Vol 1, 43–60. 23 Chapman B M, ‘The bending stress–strain properties of single fibres and the effect of temperature and relative humidity’, J. Text. Inst., 1973, 64, 312–27. 24 Bendit E G and Feughelman M, ‘Keratin’ in Encyclopaedia of Polymer Science and Technology, Vol 8, 1–44, Wiley, New York, 1968. 25 Mitchell T W and Feughelman M, ‘Torsional properties of single wool fibres. Part I: Torque–twist relationships and torsional relaxation in wet and dry fibres’, Text. Res. J., 1960, 30, 662–7. 26 Postle R, Carnaby G A and de Jong S, The Mechanics of Wool Structures, Ellis Horwood, Chichester, 1988. 27 Feughelman M and Druhalla M, ‘The lateral mechanical properties of alphakeratin’, Proc. 5th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Aachen, 1975, 2, 340–9. 28 Hearle J W S, ‘A critical review of the structural mechanics of wool and hair fibres’, Int. J. Biological Macromol., 2000, 27, 123–38. 29 Kawabata S and Kawashima Y, ‘Measurement of the anisotropy in the elastic modulus of cotton and silk fibres’, Proc. 29th Text. Res. Symp., Mount Fuji, 2000, 51–8. 30 Woods J, Orwin D F G and Nelson W G, Proc. 8th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., 1990, 557–68. 31 Hearle J W S, Lomas B and Cooke W D, ‘Atlas of Fibre Fracture and Damage to Textiles’, 2nd edition, Woodhead Publishing, Cambridge, 1998. 32 Baxter S, ‘Textiles: thermal conductivity’, Proc. Phys. Soc., 1946, 58, 105–18. 33 Haly A R and Snaith J W, ‘Specific heat studies of various wool–water systems’, Biopolymers, 1968, 6, 1355–77. 34 Phillips D G, ‘Detecting a glass transition in wool by differential scanning calorimetry’, Text. Res. J., 1985, 55, 171–4. 35 Chapman B M, ‘Observations on the mechanical behaviour of Lincoln-wool fibres supercontracted in lithium bromide solution’, J.Text. Inst., 1970, 61, 448–57. 36 Feughelman M, ‘The mechanical properties of set wool fibres and the structure of keratin’. J. Text. Inst., 1960, 51, T589–600. 37 Hearle J W S, Chapman B M and Senior G S, ‘The interpretation of the mechanical properties of wool’, Appl. Polymer Symp., No. 18, 1971, 775–94. 38 Feughelman M, ‘Two-phase structure for keratin fibres’, Text. Res. J., 1959, 29, 223–8. 39 Curiskis J I, ‘A study of the micromechanics of fibrous reinforced composite materials using finite-element techniques’, PhD thesis, University of New South Wales, 1978. 40 Curiskis J I and Feughelman M, ‘Finite element analysis of the composite fibre, alpha keratin’, Text. Res. J., 1983, 53, 271–4. 41 Chapman B M, ‘A mechanical model for wool and other keratin fibres’, Text. Res. J., 1969, 39, 1102–9. 42 Feughelman M and Haly A R, ‘The mechanical properties of wool keratin and its molecular configuration’, Kolloid Z., 1960, 168, 107–17.
128
Wool: Science and technology
43 Wortmann F-J and Zahn H, ‘The stress–strain curve of a-keratin fibers and the structure of the intermediate filaments’, Text. Res. J., 1994, 64, 737–43. 44 Feughelman M, ‘A model for the mechanical properties of the a-keratin cortex’, Text. Res. J., 1994, 64, 236–9. 45 Bendit E G, ‘Quantitative X-ray diffraction of the a-b transformation in wool keratin’, Text. Res. J., 1960, 30, 547–55. 46 Hearle J W S and Susutoglu M, ‘Interpretation of the mechanical properties of wool fibres’, Proc. 7th Int Wool Text. Res. Conf., Tokyo, 1985, 1, 214–23. 47 Bryson W G, Mastronarde D N, Caldwell J P, Nelson W G and Woods J L, ‘High voltage microscopical imaging of the macrofibril ultrastructure reveals the threedimensional spatial arrangement of intermediate filaments in Romney wool cortical cells – a causative factor in fibre curvature’, Proc. 10th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Aachen, 2000 (on CD from DWI, Aachen). 48 Munro W A and Carnaby G A, ‘Wool-fibre crimp. Part I: The effects of microfibrillar geometry’, J. Text. Inst., 1999, 90, 123–36. 49 Horio M and Kondo T, ‘Crimping of wool fibres’, Text. Res. J., 1953, 23, 373–87. 50 Mercer E H, ‘The heterogeneity of the keratin fibers’, Text. Res. J., 1953, 23, 388–97. 51 Hearle J W S, ‘Can genetic engineering enhance the miracle of wool? Part 3: Why worry about fibre strength?’ Text. Horizons, 1997,August/September 12–16. 52 Hobbs R E, Overington M S, Hearle J W S and Banfield S J, Buckling of fibres and yarns within ropes and other assemblies, J. Text. Inst., 2000, 91, 335–58. 53 Lincoln B, ‘The frictional properties of the wool fibre’, J. Text. Inst., 1954, 45, T92–107. 54 Hearle J W S, ‘The dielectric properties of fibre assemblies’, Text. Res. J., 1956, 26, 108–11. 55 Hearle J W S, ‘The electrical resistance of textile materials: IV. Theory’, J Textile Inst, 1953, 44, T177–98. 56 Hearle J W S, Grosberg P and Backer S, Structural Mechanics of Fibers, Yarns and Fabrics, Wiley-Interscience, New York, 1969. 57 Hearle J W S, Thwaites J J and Amirbayat J, Mechanics of Flexible Fibre Assemblies, Sijthoff & Noordhoff, Alphen an den Rijn, Netherlands, 1980. 58 Hearle J W S, ‘Mechanics of yarns and nonwoven fabrics’, in Chou T-W and Ko F K (editors) Textile Structural Composites, Elsevier, Amsterdam, 1989. 59 Kawabata S and Niwa M, ‘Fabric performance in clothing and clothing manufacture’, J. Text. Inst., 1989, 80, 19–51. 60 Hearle J W S and El-Sheikh A, ‘The mechanics of wool yarns’, Proc. 3rd Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Paris, 1965, IV, 267–76. 61 Carnaby G A and Grosberg P, ‘The tensile behaviour of staple-fibre yarns at small extensions’, J. Text. Inst., 1976, 67, 299–308. 62 Carnaby G A and Grosberg P, ‘The mechanics of the relaxation of wool carpet yarns. Part I: Theoretical analysis’, J. Text. Inst., 1977, 68, 24–32. 63 Carnaby G A and Grosberg P, ‘The mechanics of the relaxation of wool carpet yarns. Part II: Experimental evaluation of theory’, J. Text. Inst., 1977, 68, 33–6. 64 Amirbayat J and Hearle J W S, ‘The anatomy of buckling of textile fabrics’, J. Text. Inst., 1989, 80, 52–70. 65 Munden D L, ‘The geometry and dimensional properties of plain-knit fabrics’, J. Text. Inst., 1959, 50, T448–71.
Physical properties of wool
129
66 Chapman B M, ‘A model for the crease recovery of fabrics’, Text. Res. J., 1974, 44, 531–8. 67 Chapman B M, ‘The relationship between single fibre bending behaviour and fabric wrinkle recovery’, Proc. 5th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Aachen, 1975, III, 483–92. 68 Hearle J W S, ‘A theory of the mechanics of needled fabrics’, in Lennox-Kerr (editor), Needle-felted Fabrics, The Textile Trade Press, Manchester, 1972, 51–64. 69 Carnaby G A and Wood E J, ‘The physics of carpets’, J. Text. Inst., 1989, 80, 71–90. 70 Hearle JWS, Liu H, Tandon S K and Wood E J, ‘Fibre Fatigue mechanisms in wool carpet near and the modelling of carpet durability’, Proc. 10 th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Aachen, 2000 (on CD from DWJ, Aachen).
5 Wool chemistry W S SIMPSON
5.1
General introduction
This chapter describes the effects of radiation and heat on wool and its response to acids, alkalis, oxidants, reductants, followed by a brief treatment of specific reactions of its amino acid side chains. Chapter 7 is basically concerned with chemical modifications of wool designed to enhance one or more textile attributes such as flame-resistance. Over the full range of wool types, fibre diameters vary between about 10 and 80 mm. Diffusion of reactant chemicals from an immersion solvent, which most commonly is water, may be slow. In addition to fibre diameter variations, diffusion is also moderated by the hydrophobic epicuticle on the external face of wool scale cells, with the path of least resistance usually along the junctions between these cells and the interior cortical cells. Within each cell there are more variations in protein organisation, resulting in micro-heterogeneous regions of both hydrophobic and hydrophilic character. A direct result of these complex variations in wool morphology is that kinetics of diffusion and polarity of the reactants may be at least as important as inherent reactivity. For example, highly reactive chlorine water preferentially attacks the surface of wool fibres within seconds, whereas immersion in an excess of cold dilute acid could take an hour or more to achieve an equilibrium uptake. Provided the constraints to diffusion are taken into account, the chemical reactions of amino acid sidechains of wool proteins are consistent with those of proteins in general. Cystine (CYS) crosslinkages are a special feature of keratin fibres. Reactions of CYS with oxidants and reductants are of major importance, being an integral part of the chemistry involved in isolating wool proteins, in the physical behaviour of wool, and in technical processes such as shrinkproofing and bleaching. CYS is also one of the amino acids principally affected by radiation and heat, as described in Section 5.3. 130
Wool chemistry
5.2
131
Chemical composition
Wool is one of a large group of animal fibres that are almost entirely composed of a family of proteins generally known as a-keratins. Although there are some chemical variations between species, there are also remarkable similarities of structure and composition between comparable types of proteins in animal fibres. The physical form of keratin fibres is as diverse as porcupine quills, various horns and antlers, and extremely soft fine coats of small mammals such as the mouse. The overall amino acid composition of keratins depends, to a large part, on the relative proportions of the two major types of protein, namely the high- and low-sulphur proteins (see Chapter 3). Merino wool, for example, has a notably higher cystine (CYS) content than coarse wools as a result of having a larger proportion of high-sulphur proteins. One of the earliest reliable amino acid analyses was that of Corfield and Robson.1 It remains an adequate description of wool composition and is reproduced in Table 5.1.
5.3
Degradation by radiation and heat
Most of the radiation chemistry of wool is concerned with the effects of exposure to sunlight. Weathering during wool growth varies greatly according to the type of fleece. A dense, fine wool Merino fleece is damaged almost exclusively at staple tips, with heavy secretions of woolgrease and suint contributing to the protection. Coarse open fleeces are more generally exposed to sunlight. Severe weathering implies brittle fibre tips, loss of staple strength and dull or yellow discolouration. Photo-oxidation of CYS is the most damaging reaction, weakening the fibre. Other residues extensively damaged by prolonged exposure to sunlight are TYR, TRP, PHE, THR, MET, ILEU, LEU, PRO and HIS. Additional carbonyl and amide groups are formed following cleavage of the peptide N–Ca bond, as shown in equation [5.1]. R
R¢
hu
CH C
NH CH C
O
O
O
R
R¢
CH C O
NH2 +
C
C
O
O
[5.1]
This reaction is implicated both with fibre strength loss and subsequent susceptibility to hydrothermal yellowing (Section 7.3). Meybeck and Meybeck2 suggested that aromatic amino acids absorb UV light and, after energy transfer to glycine and alanine, there is a photochemical conversion to glyoxylyl and pyruvyl peptides according to the mechanism of equation [5.2].
132
Wool: Science and technology R C
NH CH C
O
O
hu R
C R C O
O2
NH C
C
O
+ H
O R
C
C
OO O
O
NH C
R C O
NH C
C
C
OOH O
N
C
C
+ H
[5.2]
O H2O NH2 + R C
O
C
O O
R C O
NH C
C
OH O
The intermediate structures on the left-hand side arise from further H atom transfers with additional wool protein chains. Minor amounts of other a-ketoacids are detectable in wool following irradiation in the dry state. Few carbonyl groups are detectable when wool is irradiated in water, despite pronounced yellowing. Photochemical damage also increases the susceptibility of wool to discolouration when subsequently exposed to dry heat. Even undamaged wool will develop brownish discolouration when exposed to temperatures over 110 °C for a prolonged period. Just as the dry heat yellowing of silk has been attributed to a dehydration reaction of the SER side chain, similar dehydrations leading to unsaturated carbon bonds have been suggested as the principal source of dry heat discolouration of wool.3
5.4
Photobleaching and photoyellowing
In Section 5.3, photochemical degradation has been implicated in sensitising wool to subsequent discolouration when boiled, as in dyeing, or exposed to dry heat. Depending on the conditions of exposure, sunlight may either yellow wool or bleach it. Irradiation of wool in ambient conditions with 254 nm UV light, causes wool to appear green, due to formation of two chromophores, which fade rapidly in post-irradiation reactions to leave a residual yellow colour.4 Irradiation of wool with different UV wavebands selected from sunlight or artificial sources5 demonstrated that UV below 331 nm increases wool yellowness, whereas visible light above 398 nm induces photobleaching. In the transition range, neither effect is markedly dominant
Wool chemistry
133
Table 5.1 Amino acid composition of wool [From: Corfield and Robson1] Amino acid
Abbreviation
Alanine
ALA
Amide N Arginine
N as % of total N of wool 4.12 6.73
ARG
19.1
Aspartic acid
ASP
4.38
Cystine
CYS
7.3
Glutamic acid
GLU
8.48
Glycine
GLY
6.29
Histidine
HIS
1.91
iso-Leucine
ILEU
2.44
Leucine
LEU
5.85
Lysine
LYS
3.92
Methionine
MET
0.32
Phenylalanine
PHE
2.12*
Proline
PRO
5.05
Serine
SER
8.66*
Threonine
THR
5.12*
Tryptophan
TRY
0.82
Tyrosine
TYR
2.62
Valine
VAL
4.16
Total
99.39
* Corrected by the factors 1.02, 1.10, 1.09 for PHE, SER and THR respectively for loss during hydrolysis.
although physical damage to the wool is strongly promoted by these intermediate wavelengths. Window glass absorbs radiation shorter than 305 nm so that wool carpets and furnishings exposed to transmitted sunlight noticeably whiten and brighten due to photobleaching of the wool substrate. Control measures for shade changes are described in Section 7.8. Photobleaching by visible light has been considered as an alternative to chemical bleaching,6 and this idea has been extended to evaluating bluelight sources for wool bleaching. Wet wool bleaches more rapidly than in the air-dry state, and King showed that thioglycollic acid enhanced still further the rate of photobleaching,7 but the chemical residues are troublesome. More dramatic photobleaching results from blue-light irradiation of wool soaked in a dilute hydrogen peroxide solution. If the solution is also made alkaline, extraordinary levels of whiteness can be attained within a minute or so.8 The results were sufficiently encouraging to develop a prototype bleaching machine for continuous treatment of wool sliver. Indus-
134
Wool: Science and technology
trial take-up of this technology has not occurred, quite probably because manufacturers would prefer raw material improvements to be the responsibility of wool suppliers, particularly as in this instance a substantial investment is required for equipment that, in turn, requires specially trained operators. Major research efforts have been devoted to understanding the chemistry underlying photoyellowing. The summary of much of this work9 highlights the problems of assigning yellowness to specific chromophores. TRP was long regarded as the most reactive aromatic absorber, with some known yellow decomposition products. One of the earliest correlations was found to be between the TRP content of a range of keratins and their rate of yellowing when irradiated at 310 nm in the dry state.10 More direct evidence was derived by radiolabelling TRP in wool, prior to UV irradiation. After solubilising the wool by reduction, alkylation and proteolytic digestion, a radioactive yellow fraction was isolated by ionexchange chromatography.11 Recent attempts to isolate and identify the yellow components of wool, however, exclude the possibility that TRP decomposition products are the main contributors.9 The principal reason is that most of the known products of TRP degradation, including the major one, kynurenine, are colourless, and the minor coloured products such as N-formylkynurenine are very weak chromophores. Semi-quantitative calculations were sufficient to suggest they could not account for more than 20% of wool yellowness. Isolation and characterisation of yellow wool components entails a difficult first step, i.e. solubilising wool in a manner which neither destroys them nor introduces new artifactual coloured compounds. Wool sufficiently damaged to be significantly yellow is inherently unstable, and dissolution with strong acid or alkaline treatments is visibly accompanied by substantial additional yellowing.9 Simpson9 found papain/bisulphite treatments were also questionable because a significant amount of enzyme is introduced as a contaminant. The pale yellow material in the solution of wool extracts is apparently destabilised by the reducing agent and the colour tends to bleach on standing and often disappears entirely within a day or so. Simpson9 considered the most satisfactory method was dilute acid hydrolysis at 60–80 °C for several days. Almost all the yellow colour was released in the first 5–10% of the wool to be solubilised, and, following a series of enzyme hydrolyses and chromatographic separations, the yellow fractions could be substantially purified. The main fraction was hydrophobic and was eluted from a reverse-phase chromatographic column as three components of very similar amino acid composition, optical density profile and very weak fluorescence. They appeared to be different levels of polymerisation of peptides, notable for very high proline content, about 22 mol %, and low in aromatic amino acid content.
Wool chemistry
135
Small proline-rich proteins (sprs) have been found in the cornified cell envelope of keratins and in the epidermis of many mammalian species,12 and are notable for very low amounts of the aromatic acids TRP, TYR and PHE.These proteins are claimed to be particularly associated with wool epicuticle (Section 3.3.1). A major portion of wool yellowness thus appears to be derived from a minor wool protein. The method of extraction and purification results in a kind of hydrophobic complex, resistant to complete enzymatic hydrolysis. In pure aqueous solutions for example, the coloured material condenses into dark brown treacle-like droplets. A yellow-brown solution is restored by addition of methanol but alcoholic solutions are incompatible with further enzymatic hydrolyses. Another aspect of interest in this investigation9 was the chromatographic separation of the high-proline fractions from a high-TYR/GLY fraction that was completely colourless. A clear, yellow component representing perhaps 10% of the total colour was also retrieved, which had fluorescence and optical density properties suggestive of a TRP degradation product incorporated in a mixture of chromatographically similar peptides.
5.5
Absorption of acids
At room temperature, immersion of wool in aqueous solutions of strong acids or alkalis is essentially an ion-exchange titration of the 0.8 mM/g of both carboxyl and amino groups on amino acid sidechains. Ionic interactions between —COO- and —NH4+ groups play an important part in stabilising the protein structure of wool in the vicinity of its isolectronic point at about pH 6.5. Equilibration in an excess of either acidic or alkaline solution is slow, particularly in the pH 3–10 range, where a time of the order of an hour is required even with regular agitation of the solution. Equilibrium rates are slow as a consequence of an electronic barrier formed at fibre surfaces, following an initial absorption, and can be greatly reduced by addition of a neutral salt. Figure 5.1 illustrates the effect of adding KCl on the shape of the titration curve of wool with HCl and KOH.13 There has been considerable interest and effort devoted to providing a theoretical understanding of the acid/base behaviour of wool fibres. Essentially, wool is a fine example of a highly consolidated protein whose behaviour might usefully be compared to soluble proteins of similar acidic and basic amino acid content. The latter have titration characteristics more akin to simple acids and bases. The two principal theoretical models for absorption of acids and bases by wool are those of Gilbert and Rideal,17 and of Donnan. Both have been critically examined in several textbooks.14–16 In the light of current knowledge, the former has been the most successful in terms of prediction of wool titration behaviour, and an abbreviated account of its application follows.
136
Wool: Science and technology
KOH-Millimoles per gram dry wool-HCl
0.8
Ionic strength 0.2 Ionic strength 0.02 No salt
0.6 0.4 0.2 0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1
3
5
9
7
11
13
PH
5.1 Combination of wool with hydrochloric acid and with potassium hydroxide as a function of pH. The influence of a salt on shifting the acidic side of the curve is shown. [From Steinhardt and Harris.13]
Gilbert and Rideal17 made these assumptions: i)
All positively charged groups (mainly amines) have identical properties. ii) All carboxylic groups have similar affinities for protons. iii) Absorbed anions may occupy any positively charged site. Thus, the anions and protons in an aqueous solution can be regarded as being independently absorbed by immersed wool samples. The only other formal requirement of the theory is that electrical neutrality of the fibre must be maintained. The thermodynamic analysis that followed culminated in their well-known equation for titration of wool with hydrochloric acid. log10
(Dm H + Dm Cl ) qH = - pH 1 - qH 4 ◊ 6RT
[5.3]
(qH is the fraction of sites filled by protons, and the final term incorporates changes in the chemical potential of hydrogen and chloride ions respectively). Steinhardt and Harris13 were able to confirm that the equation did fit the experimental data for the titration of wool with hydrochloric acid. More
Wool chemistry
137
significantly still, if sodium chloride is added so that the titration is carried out at essentially constant ionic strength, Gilbert and Rideal derived the secondary equation pH 0.5 = log10 [Cl] -
Dm H + Dm Cl 2◊3RT
[5.4]
The subscript 0.5 refers to an equilibrium pH, when half the proton binding sites are filled. When the chloride concentration is increased, so also is the pH at the point of half saturation. Therefore, less acid is required to achieve a given equilibrium pH when the chloride concentration is increased. It becomes difficult to extrapolate this result in a quantitative fashion for more complex wool–acid–salt combinations, but this basic result is a fundamental factor in devising good conditions for processes such as wool dyeing. Stated in the simplest terms, it affords a scientific basis for the advantages of adding salts in order to raise the ionic strength of dyebaths. This approach is taken further in Section 5.6. Long exposure at room temperature to an excess of strong acid will hydrolyse some of the amide groups in wool, releasing ammonia and creating additional carboxylate groups, thereby increasing the measured acid uptake of wool. At pH values greater than 11, alkaline degradation reactions of cystine and peptide bond hydrolysis become increasingly likely for even brief exposure at room temperature. Acids with more complex anions considerably alter the position of the titration curve as compared to HCl, but not its general shape, the changes reflecting a greater affinity of organic anions for wool compared to the chloride ion. For example, several dyestuff-like anions, such as diphenylbenzenesulphonate, are taken up as strongly at pH 4 as chloride ion at pH 2. An extreme example of supra-stoichiometric absorption results from immersion of wool in pure formic acid, which grossly inflates the fibres to several times their original diameters. After rinsing well with water they return to their initial state. The textbook by Alexander and Hudson14 provides an extensive review of every aspect of absorption of both weak and strong acids. A majority of the original papers to which they refer were written as long ago as 1930–1950 but, for the most part, they have not been materially updated by more recent research.
5.6
Absorption of alkalis
Titration data for absorption of alkalis by wool mirrors, in many respects, absorption of acids but with one substantial difference. Alkalis degrade proteins at low concentrations and temperatures, at a significant rate, so that it is very difficult to attempt reversible alkaline titrations beyond a very restricted range by comparison with acids.
138
Wool: Science and technology
Chemical groups in wool that alter their state of ionisation in increasingly alkaline conditions are listed below. Their approximate concentration in most wool types, in milliequivalents/kg, and their normal titration range vary widely. • HIS, (68), pH 5.5–7.0 • Terminal amino groups, (25), pH 7.5–8.5 • TYR, (260), pH 9.8–10.4 • LYS, (190), pH 9.5–10.5 • ARG, (600), pH 11.5–12.5 Addition of salts in an alkaline titration of wool has a similar effect in displacing the uptake curve as with acids, so that more alkali is taken up at less extreme pH values when neutral salts are added. The reactions of cystine and other disulphides in alkaline conditions have attracted a great deal of research attention. Maclaren and Milligan list over 40 references yet conclude that there is still room for some disagreement about the mechanism.18 In the case of combined cystine in wool, attack at the b-carbon offers a plausible mechanism for the degradation products that have been identified. The principal reaction steps are illustrated in equation [5.5] (R = wool protein chain). NH
C
CH CH2 C
S
S
CH2
O
O
CH (cystine) NH
OH– NH
C
CH CH2 C
S
O
S– + HO CH2 CH
C
C
O
S
CH2
[5.5]
NH
OH– –S
NH CH CH2
O
O
CH (lanthionine) NH
Lanthionine is one of the main products of alkaline degradation, and the selection of reaction steps shown also account for the appearance of some
Wool chemistry
139
free sulphur. Dehydroalanine is also formed as a minor product when some of the intermediate product sidechain HO—CH2 loses water. The latter product is also known to be capable of reacting with lysine in alkaline conditions to form lysinoalanine. These examples are just indicative of the sequential and complex variations of degradative reactions possible when wool is exposed to strongly alkaline solutions.
5.7
Dyeing with acid dyestuffs
5.7.1 General The theoretical background of absorption of low molecular weight mineral and organic acids is the same as that of the absorption of high molecular weight acids. However, as might be expected, the coulombic forces which substantially explain absorption of hydrochloric acid by wool, and the influence of salts added to the aqueous acid, fall short of explaining all the features of absorption of high molecular weight dyes. For these larger molecules, the principles of fixation in wool fibres is decidedly more complex. The morphological structure of wool is itself a mediating factor, as discussed in the next section. The detailed technology and practical aspects of wool dying are described in Chapter 8.
5.7.2 Morphological structure of wool and its influence on dyeing The three steps in dye transfer from an aqueous dyebath are: i) Diffusion of dye to fibre surfaces ii) Dye transfer across the surfaces iii) Diffusion of dye through wool fibre structures Good dyeing equipment, affording thorough liquor circulation, should eliminate the delays and uneven access to dyes implied in the first step. For the second step, the wool epicuticle offers a significant resistance to dye penetration. It is now accepted that dyes gain access to undamaged wool fibres mainly via junctions between wool cuticle scales.19 Lipids are present to varying degree at the surface and in intercellular interstices, and they present an obstacle to entry of dyes into wool fibres. Wool that has previously been scoured in the normal aqueous fashion, when extracted with a good solvent for lipids or alternatively stripped with anhydrous sodium tertbutoxide, responds with faster rates of dye uptake and better uniformity of dyeing.20 Wools with surface damage, or degraded by sunlight, chlorination or carbonising treatments for example, will respond differently when exposed to dyebath conditions.
140
Wool: Science and technology
Dyestuffs, which first penetrate into wool between cuticle cell junctions as mentioned, are now known to next diffuse throughout all the nonkeratinous regions, and also the endocuticle and intermacrofibrillar material regions of the cell membrane complex.21,22 The final stages of dyestuff diffusion inside wool fibres entails a progressive transfer of dye into the sulphur-rich matrix proteins surrounding microfibrils in cortical cells. Even when dye exhaustion is virtually complete, the internal fibre–dye equilibration process is not, and in practical situations an industrial dyeing process may justify an extended dyeing time. A further curious but informative observation from optical and electron microscope studies of dye location in wool fibres is that the initial favoured entry of dye through the cuticle scale junctions is also followed by dye transfer into the adjacent exocuticle and A-layer. The non-keratinous regions, which are so important in the early part of the dye cycle, are found to be almost totally devoid of dye at the completion of the dyeing process.
5.7.3 Dye uptake chemistry The Gilbert and Rideal model was briefly described in the context of acid–base equilibria when wool is immersed in an aqueous solution (Section 5.5). Both this theory and the alternative approach based on the Donnan theory have been tested to find the extent to which they explain dye absorption. Lewis23 concluded that neither theory is particularly successful, especially for dyes with a highly hydrophobic character. However, some of the concepts of the ionic attractions driving absorption of simple acid dyes are a logical extension of titration of wool with common organic acids. A good example of this is the uptake of a fairly simple acid dye. Experimentally it could be demonstrated24 that, from a dyebath containing just Crystal Ponceau and hydrochloric acid, there is an initial rapid absorption of both hydrogen and chloride ions. Over time, the slower diffusing dye anions displace chloride in the fibre, as demonstrated by first a rapid fall in chloride concentration in the bath followed by a more gradual rise again. The influence of a salt on shifting the acidic side of the titration curve of wool is shown in Fig 5.1. Basically, at higher ionic strengths, hydrogen ions are more readily absorbed because the repulsive electrical charge which develops at the surface boundary of the fibres is substantially masked. Exactly the same effects explain why salts, commonly sodium acetate or sulphate, are to be found in most acid dyebaths. Less acid is required for a given uptake of hydrogen ions. This facilitates dye anion absorption at less extremely acid conditions and conveniently also reduces the risk of acid damage to the wool substrate.
Wool chemistry
141
Zollinger25 expanded on these ionic aspects of dyestuff affinity for wool and distinguished between coulombic, van der Waals and hydrophobic binding forces. For three carefully selected acid dyes, there was a clear indication of the hydrophobic bonding interaction of an aliphatic sidechain. These studies were based on comparisons of dyeing behaviour between normal and modified wools, notably by blocking ionic sites. Meybeck and Galafassi26 contributed considerably to an understanding of the nature of acid dyestuff binding on wool. They showed that few salt anions (chloride) are released from wool in the course of dyeing compared to the amount of dye absorbed. For slightly hydrophobic dyes, of the order of 10% of bound chloride ions are released, while for more strongly hydrophobic dyes, release of chloride ions is negligible. This result, along with a variety of contributory studies,23,pp68–72 added further weight to their propositions. On the basis of these results, Meybeck and Galafassi formed three principles in relation to wool dyeing: i) Hydrogen bonds are not formed between the dye and the fibre. ii) Coulombic forces play a part in attracting dye anions into the wool fibres but then they locate to hydrophobic sites where they then become strongly fixed. iii) To have a high affinity for the wool, anionic dyes must have a hydrophobic character.The structure of the dye molecule must be such that the hydrophobic substituents are situated some distance from the polar groups.
5.8
Acid, alkali and enzymic hydrolysis
5.8.1 Acid hydrolysis Complete acid hydrolysis is the most common method of preparing solutions of amino acids from wool and other proteins for quantitative analysis. Evacuated, sealed tubes containing the sample and 6 M HCl are typically treated at 105 °C for 24 hours. TRP is destroyed and correction factors are applied to calculate SER, THR and TYR contents (see Table 5.1). This analytical routine is questionable for detection of amino acids modified by exposure of wool to sunlight. Partial oxidation products of cystine disproportionate to cysteic acid and cystine, and quite certainly unstable carbonyl groups (Section 5.3) notably glyoxylyl and pyruvyl either react with other side chains or simply decompose. Amides of GLU and ASP are hydrolysed and the ammonia released is also measured. The whole procedure is, of course, now a routine one for proteins in general. Amino acids and ammonia react with ninhydrin to form blue derivatives, which are quantified as they emerge from a chromatographic column.
142
Wool: Science and technology
Partial acid hydrolysis has been evaluated as a general method for selectively producing wool peptides suitable for gaining amino acid sequence information.27 Maclaren and Milligan18 summarised all the results, including hydrolysis in more dilute solutions and lower temperatures, and concluded that this approach was not useful for extensive sequencing of wool proteins. In weaker acid hydrolytic conditions, the amides of GLU and ASP are the most readily hydrolysed and a standard method has been developed for the analytical determination of amide nitrogen as ammonia and other amino groups so released. The peptide bond adjacent to ASP is the most labile, with GLY and SER the next most easily released amino acids. Mild acid hydrolysis for the purpose of providing an analytical determination of amide groups in wool has been specifically developed because the drastic conditions employed for complete acid hydrolysis of wool and wool protein fractions (i.e. the preliminary step before amino analysis, typically 6 M HCl at 105 °C) compromises the measurement. The reason is that a significant fraction of other amino acids, notably SER and THR, decompose as well and, in so doing, release additional ammonia. Acid hydrolysis aimed more specifically at wool amide groups, therefore, should be sufficiently mild to avoid these complications. Inglis et al. judged that a treatment with 2 M HCl at 100 °C for 14 hours in sealed evacuated tubes is adequate for the release of ammonia from all amide groups in wool (and silk), with no significant hydrolysis of other potential contaminants.18 Attempts to isolate yellow compounds from wool, as discussed in Section 5.4, seem likely now to employ variations of conditions for mild acid hydrolysis to advance the prospects for complete chemical characterisation. In particular, the emphasis should be on keeping the temperature low, possibly at the expense of longer reaction times of the order of several days, in order to avoid the loss of unstable compounds.
5.8.2 Alkaline hydrolysis and alkali solubility Alkaline hydrolysis of proteins, including wool, destroys much of the CYS and lesser amounts of ARG, HIS and SER, but unlike acid hydrolysis it conserves the TRP content. In the context of wool chemistry, the most useful application of alkaline treatments is the alkali solubility test, the UK version being BS 3568:1988. This relatively mild treatment with 0.1 M NaOH at 65 °C for 1 hour is a standard test for assessing wool damage. It is particularly useful for detecting loss of CYS crosslinkages, acid damage and sunlight degradation, all of which increase solubility beyond about 10%, which is a figure typical for undamaged wool. Oxidative bleaching processes for example (Section 7.2) must be carefully managed to avoid
Wool chemistry
143
excessive oxidation of CYS (see also Sections 5.9 and 5.10) and the alkali solubility test is very commonly used as a quality control check. Conversely the test is very sensitive to the introduction of new stable crosslinkages, which reduce the amount of extractable peptides. A mild alkaline treatment will itself convert some CYS to lanthionine crosslinkages and lower the amount extractable in a subsequent alkali solubility test.
5.8.3 Enzymic hydrolysis The solid, crosslinked structure of wool is resistant to proteolytic enzymes. In the general introduction (Section 5.1) attention was drawn to the difficulties of large molecules permeating the wool structure. Trypsin does diffuse slowly along cell membranes and after several days incubation the fibres readily disintegrate into a dispersion of cortical and scale cells.28 However, if wool is first reduced and alkylated, it is much more accessible to enzymes. Because enzymes afford a relatively mild form of digestion, novel crosslinkages or amino acid derivatives unstable to acid hydrolysis can be released and characterised.29 In this way the reaction of phenylisocyanate with LYS, SER, THR and GLU residues could be detected30 and the unusual peptide bond e-(g-glutamyl) lysine could be isolated and identified.31,32 At least three proteolytic enzymes are necessary for near-complete hydrolysis following the reduction/alkylation step.33 Typically, widespectrum enzymes such as papain, pepsin and pronase, used in combinations or sequential digestions, produce peptide mixtures that are ultimately cleaved to form a solution of individual amino acids. Prolidase is required to break proline bonds and amino peptidase removes Nterminal residues in step-wise fashion. Whilst these more complex procedures have identified some relatively unstable modified amino acids, they are not a universal panacea for resolution of all the questions about wool degradation. Essentially, the proteolytic enzymes are inactive when introduced to the solutions of yellow extracts obtained as described in Section 5.4. It is worth re-emphasizing that enzymes are effective in normal aqueous media but that they are unable to penetrate and degrade hydrophobic aggregates of complex wool peptides.
5.9
Oxidation with peracids
TRY, CYS, and cysteine (CYSH) are the amino acids most susceptible to oxidation. Because of its importance in crosslinking wool proteins and directly influencing the strength and elasticity of wool fibres, the detailed chemistry of CYS oxidation has been very extensively studied.
144
Wool: Science and technology
Complete oxidation of CYS to cysteic acid (CYSA) in wool is best achieved with either peracetic or, better still, performic acid. This method forms the basis for post-oxidation procedures beginning with ammonia extraction followed by successive precipitations and purifications in order to prepare well differentiated fractions of soluble wool proteins. The products of these separations have been described as a-, b- and g-keratoses.34 Although both the oxidising acids are likely to rupture some peptide bonds and possibly slowly attack other side chains, O’Donnell and Woods34 found peracetic acid was the more likely of the two to have non-specific effects, possibly because there is a significant amount of hydrogen peroxide in its aqueous solutions. Prolonged oxidation with performic acid does, however, convert MET to its sulphoxide, TRP is converted to N-formyl kynurenine and other products, and some SER, THR and TYR may be affected by vigorous treatments.18 The principal present use of peracetic acid is as a component in the peracetic/ammonia solubility test. Under carefully controlled conditions, the test detects the presence of crosslinkages remaining in wool after cleavage of disulphide bonds.27 When a sufficient excess of oxidant is present, the end product of oxidation of CYS is combined CYSA, i.e. W—CH2—SO3H, where W represents a wool protein chain. Exposure to lesser amounts of chemical oxidant, or photo-oxidising sunlight for that matter (see Section 5.3), results in formation of intermediate products. Chemical structures of those believed to be present1 are shown in equation [5.6] O W CH2
S
S
CH2 W
W CH2
O
S
CH2 W
O
O W CH2
S
[5.6]
O
SH
W CH2
S
O
S
OH
O
Treatment of partially oxidised wool with strong acids leads to disproportionation reactions of intermediate sulphoxides. A typical stoichiometric relationship is given by equation [5.7]. O 5 W CH2
S
S
CH2
W + 2 H2O
O [5.7]
O 3 W CH2
S
S
CH2 W + 4 W CH2
S O
OH
Wool chemistry
5.10
145
Chlorine-based oxidation
Partial oxidation of wool is commonly observed as a result of industrial processes for bleaching (see Section 7.2) and shrinkproofing wool (see Section 7.5). Hydrogen peroxide is a favoured bleaching agent, applied using conditions that limit damage to CYS within acceptable values. Present-day technology essentially confines the industrial use of chlorine and its oxidative derivatives to acidic processes that principally modify wool surface properties. Therefore, they are primarily pretreatments for shrinkproofing, with a second-stage application of polymers (Section 7.5.7). There is a very extensive literature describing oxidation of wool with gaseous chlorine, chlorine water and numerous chlorine-release compounds. One of the earliest observations was that of von Allwörden.35 Wool fibres immersed in either chlorine- or bromine-water develop sacs on individual scales of the fibre surfaces. Osmotic pressure can develop due to oxidation and dissolution of some protein components of cuticle scale cells, provided the epicuticle is undamaged and prevents their diffusion into the immersion liquid. This reaction is therefore the basis of a simple laboratory test using a microscope to detect surface damage of immersed wool fibres. Chlorine derived from hypochlorite solutions has a markedly different reaction with wool depending on the pH of the treatment. This is because the active agent in a solution of calcium hypochlorite, commonly known as bleaching powder, is the hypochlorous ion, ClO- at pH values above 8.5, mainly undissociated HClO in near neutral conditions, while at pH 2 free chlorine accounts for about 70% of the total active chlorine in a dilute solution.Alkaline conditions result in high CYSA levels in the cuticle, whereas acidic treatments promote extraction of soluble acidic peptides from cuticle cells. The alkaline treatment results in a resist to acid dye uptake, whereas the acid method enhances it compared to untreated wool. These differences have been exploited in patterned fabrics to afford cross-dyed effects.36
5.11
Reduction
Wool keratins are structurally stabilised by the disulphide crosslinkages of cystine. Reductive cleavage of cystine, followed by structural reshaping of a fabric and then reforming the bonds, is the basis of chemical setting of pleats and creases. The same principles apply to the permanent waving of human hair. Complete reduction entails two successive nucleophilic displacement reactions – see equation [5.8] (W = wool protein chain and RS- is the reductant thiol).
146
Wool: Science and technology W CH2 S
S
CH2 W + RS–
W CH2 S
W CH2 S
S
R + RS–
R
S
S
S
R + W CH2 S–
R + W CH2 S–
[5.8]
A high concentration of a thiol, such as thioglycollic acid, would be required to achieve full reduction in acid conditions. By adjusting to pH 9–10, which is the pK value for thiol groups, adding a proportion of an organic solvent such as n-propanol, and using a high concentration of a protein disaggregating medium such as urea, total reduction of cystine is readily attained. Maclaren and Milligan18 emphasise the importance of pure reagents. For example, freshly distilled thioglycollic acid avoids acylation of amino groups by thiolactone impurities, and urea should be free of ammonium cyanate, likely to form carbamoyl derivatives with amino groups. Sodium borohydride is another reductant offering high yields of thiol but there is also some peptide bond hydrolysis.37 Extensive reduction of wool cystine may also be achieved with tetrakis (hydroxymethyl) phosphonium chloride (THPC) (see equation [5.9]). The active agent is the phosphine derivative formed by dissociation of THPC in aqueous solution.38 R
R W CH2
S
S
CH2 W + R
P + H2O
2W
R (R = hydroxymethyl group)
CH2
SH + R
P R
O
[5.9]
By way of contrast with the reversible equilibrium reduction characteristics of thiol solutions, the reaction with THPC is irreversible and requires but a small excess of reagent. Because phosphines react slowly with alkylating agents, it is also possible to carry out alkylation of thiol groups derived from cystine with chloroacetate in the same solution.39 Some undesirable modifications of TYR and cysteine can occur38 with THPC, whereas near-quantitative reduction can be achieved with tri-n-butyl phosphine, without unwanted side reactions.40
5.12
Sulphitolysis
Sulphitolysis of cystine in wool is of major industrial importance in processes such as the setting of yarns and fabrics, mild bleaching methods, and after-treatments following oxidative shrinkproofing and bleaching processes. Sulphite (SO32-), bisulphite (HSO3-) and disulphite (S2O52-) exist in equilibrium in aqueous solution. HSO3- is predominant in acid conditions and SO32- is the main species above pH 7. At pH >9 sulphitolysis of cystine is a reversible bimolecular displacement reaction,41 see equation [5.10]
Wool chemistry O– W
CH2
S
S
CH2 W + 2 O
S
147
O 2 W CH2
S
O–
[5.10]
O–
S O
Below pH 9 the reaction is more complex, that with bisulphite forming thiol and S-sulphonate anions (equation [5.11]). O W
CH2
S
S
CH2 W + HS
O O–
W
CH2
SH + W CH2
O
S
S
O–
[5.11]
O
Oxidative sulphitolysis is also possible (equation [5.12]) O W
CH2
S
S
CH2
W + 2S O–
O O–
2W
CH2
S
S
O–
[5.12]
O–
Sulphitolysis reactions reverse readily with rinsing in water but reversal is slower in acidic conditions. There have been long-standing speculations about wool cystine being divisible into four fractions of different reactivity, but Maclaren and Milligan18 conclude, after reviewing all the evidence, that there is not a sound case for this proposition.
5.13
Metal salts
Chrome dyeing is by far the most widely used process involving metal complexes in wool and is dealt with in Chapter 8. More recently, zirconium and titanium salts have featured in the development of flame-retardant wool products (see Section 7.7).Wool does, however, interact strongly with a wide variety of metal salts useful in more limited applications. As might be anticipated, the principal binding sites are carboxyl and sulphydryl groups for metal cations. Sometimes, more elaborate metal complexes with amino, guanidine and imidazole groups have been proposed in order to account for large uptakes. Maclaren and Milligan18 provide a comprehensive description of metal–wool reactions. The principal studies and applications are summarised here.
5.13.1 Mercury Methyl mercuric iodide is generally used in quantitative analysis of thiol and disulphide groups in wool.42 Mercury salts bind in large amounts, e.g. over 2000 mmol g-1, of the chloride.43,44 However, Hg binding is suppressed by excess chloride, which obviates the use of wool as a sorbent for mercury salts in sea water. Mercuric salts are well known for their ability to form
148
Wool: Science and technology
complexes with nitrogen compounds such as amines. Extended multinuclear complexes are likely in the water-swollen matrix proteins of wool, and these would account for the supra-stoichiometric absorption observed with mercuric chloride solutions. Thiol groups would react readily and completely with mercuric ions.
5.13.2 Silver Silver ion is taken up in greater amount as the pH is increased, and is reversibly bound on carboxyl groups with a small amount irreversibly reacting with all the thiol groups present to form a mercaptide.45 In alkaline conditions, silver ions appear to catalyse degradation of cystine, resulting in H2S and additional thiol groups being formed, which in turn convert to mercaptides. This conclusion was supported by evidence for a stoichiometric release of hydrogen ions into solution as silver was absorbed in acidic conditions, where decomposition of cystine by silver salts is negligible. There is close to complete binding of Ag+ ion on carboxyl groups at pH 6, this falling to about 22% at pH 1.5.45 The additional uptake of silver in alkaline conditions due to extra mercaptide formation has led to some useful applications. There has been some exploitation of silver ion in histochemistry, notably as a heavy-metal stain useful as a marker in electron microscopy. Weight increases of the order of 16% are achieved with treatments of wool in ammoniacal silver nitrate solutions at pH 10.5.46 Electron micrographs of wool sections subsequently show dense crystallites of silver sulphide in sulphur-rich regions of the fine structure of wool, presumably formed by reactions involving hydrogen sulphide released by alkaline hydrolysis of cystine. Similar deposits of lead sulphide were observed following alkaline sodium plumbite treatments of wool.47
5.13.3 Copper About 280 mmol g-1 Cu(II) is taken up by wool from a perchlorate solution,48 forming a green complex with carboxyl groups. Treatment with cuprammonium hydroxide in concentrated ammonia results in a 40% weight increase, contraction of the fibres, and loss of the normal keratin structure.49 A brief treatment is fully reversible by rinsing in dilute acid. These two widely different outcomes, the first essentially reflecting the affinity of cupric ions for carboxyl groups in mildly acidic conditions, and the second the supra-stoichiometric absorption possible in strongly alkaline conditions, favour cupric ion interaction with presumably amino and other nitrogencontaining side chains.
Wool chemistry
149
Copper salts are well known for their ability to form complex amines, the affinity being markedly stronger than is the case for silver. On the other hand, the susceptibility of cystine to degradation in alkaline solutions containing silver ion is much greater than for comparable solutions containing copper complexes. Provided the treatment of wool in ammoniacal copper is not too prolonged, as mentioned earlier, the absorbed salts can be washed out and the fibres return to their normal state without a residual amount of copper sulphide or combined copper mercaptide. Supercontraction is the historic description of the structural collapse, and in this respect the treatment is an excellent demonstration of the dependence of wool proteins on hydrogen bonding and amino–carboxyl salt linkages in order to maintain a stable structural form. Interactions which alter the structural stability of wool are described in detail in Chapter 4.
5.13.4 Aluminium Aluminium ions bind on carboxyl groups, and also on sulphonic acid groups produced by oxidative bleaching processes which modify a proportion of the cystine.The rate and extent of binding is increased by adding n-propanol to the solution, with a pronounced effect on the mechanical properties of the fibres. Basically the treatments reduce the stress required to produce an initial strain, or, in other words, the wool is more easily extended yet loses nothing in ultimate strength or recovery from extension. There are some subtleties of Al/alcohol treatments such that the ultimate effects are sensitive to the percentage of water in the ethanol, propanol or butanol mixture, and the actual quantity of Al absorbed appear to be less important than the absorption locations opened up by the particular solvent mixture.50 Unlike Ag+ and Cu+2, Al+3 has a very low affinity for nitrogenous groups. Just as the ammoniacal copper treatment of wool (Section 5.13.3) offers an example of structural destabilisation due to very extensive destruction of crosslinking hydrogen bonds, so, too, the more easily extendable wools treated in some Al/water/organic solvent mixtures highlights another structural feature. In such solutions, the Al+3 ion is sufficiently small to be transported into hydrophobic parts of the wool structure opened up by the organic solvent. Interference with the hydrogen bond cross linkages in these regions is therefore demonstrably a significant factor in the physical properties of wool. Since Al ions hydrolyse at pH values greater than 4, the optimum pH for wool treatments is in the pH 3–4 range, where the rate of hydrolysis is low and wool has sufficient negative character to strongly absorb Al cations.
150
Wool: Science and technology
5.13.5 Other metals Wool modified by polymer grafting of methacrylic acid to increase its carboxylic acid content has been evaluated for removing iron, and potentially other metal ion pollutants, present in water. Heavy metal complexes, including uranyl acetate, phosphotungstic acid and osmic acid have been used for examination of wool by X-ray diffraction and electron microscopy.18 There does not appear to be much specificity attached to these treatments. Following some initial absorption, which may well have a specific type of binding site, what appears to follow is a time-dependent accretion of more heavy metal ions on the original binding template. These accretions build up most readily in the most accessible regions of the fibre structure and clearly delineate cell boundaries and other features readily observable in electron micrographs.
5.14
Miscellaneous reactions
5.14.1 Iodination Iodine dissolved in alcohol or potassium iodide reacts with wool in two ways. There is formation of a complex with amino groups which is reversible51 and irreversible di-substitution in the TYR side chain. Richards and Speakman52 found the latter reaction converted up to 96% of TYR to 2 : 4 diiodotyrosine, from treatments in alcoholic solutions of iodine.
5.14.2 Ninhydrin Ninhydrin has a well-known reaction with the amino groups of amino acids in solution, forming a strong blue colour used in quantitative analysis of the amino acids in hydrolysed proteins. Wool boiled in ninhydrin takes up sufficient for a weight increase of 15%, and this results in changes in fibre mechanical properties.53 The main physical effect is a large increase in the work needed to extend the fibres in water. At first, this was thought to be due to ninhydrin forming additional crosslinkages, but a more likely reason is the lower absorption of water by the treated wool when immersed. The weight change, however, indicates that reactions additional to those with the free amino groups in intact wool must occur, as they would account only for a theoretical 3% weight increase. This is most likely a parallel situation to the accumulation of heavy metals such as osmium (Section 5.13.5) in wool, owing to successive reactions or condensations of more reagent upon an original group-specific template of reactions with wool fibres.
Wool chemistry
151
5.14.3 Diazonium salts and staining tests Pauly54 first demonstrated the reaction of diazotised sulphanilic acid with TYR and HIS residues of soluble proteins. Depending on pH and other reaction conditions, other residues are also modified.18 The principal interest in this reaction in wool chemistry is its adaptation as a visual test of fibre damage. Undamaged fibres remain colourless under conditions where damaged fibres rapidly develop red-brown colouration. Glynn55 preferred 2-nitroaniline as the base of a diazonium salt for this test. Allied with a microscope, this very simple test reaction is an extremely useful one in wool quality control. Staining tests can be very informative regarding the sites and extent of damage sustained by wool fibres and fabrics. Simpson and Page56 found it was possible to mix a selected high-molecular weight acid dye and a lowmolecular weight basic dye to form a staining solution that showed no tendency to co-precipitate. This proved to be very useful in delineating progressive damage to wool fabrics exposed to sunlight degradation behind window glass. The standard staining solution was as follows: • • •
0.06% CI Acid Red 52 0.025% CI Basic Blue 3 0.12% acetic acid
Application conditions were 15 minutes at 20 °C followed by 1 minute rinsing. The colours of surface and shielded fibres showed every variation from red, pink, mauve to blue according to changes in ionic character and permeability.
5.14.4 Esterification Alexander et al. demonstrated that wool treated with boiling methanol (65 °C), n-propanol (97 °C), and n-butanol (117 °C) for 6 hours with 0.1 M HCl as catalyst, resulted in 60, 50, 35% esterification respectively of the carboxyl sidechains.57 Some amide groups are converted to esters and some susceptible peptide bonds may succumb to N- and O-methylation.58
5.15
Crosslinking
5.15.1 Effects of crosslinking Potential practical applications of crosslinking reactions include the restoration of physical properties such as depletion of natural cystine crosslinking
152
Wool: Science and technology
due to degradation by sunlight. Industrial processes such as oxidative bleaching also damage cystine and suggest that some repair mechanism may be helpful. A treatment which utilises a bifunctional reagent reactive with wool protein sidechains is the obvious approach to take. In many instances, however, there is no discernable effect on fibre properties because only one functional group reacts with a pendant group on a protein chain or alternatively the predominant bifunctional reactions are with the same protein chain. A long chain molecule with reactive end-groups may be more successful at crosslinking than rigid aromatic bifunctional reagents,59 which require more precise positioning of reactive groups on wool proteins to effect a cross-linking reaction. Definitive proof of crosslinking requires isolation and characterisation of the relevant amino acid–reagent linkages. A majority of potential crosslinkages would hydrolyse should the wool be solubilised. Isolation by following a reduction/alkylation route followed by extraction and several steps of enzymic hydrolysis is always a lengthy and difficult procedure with no certainty of eventual success. Changes in fibre solubility (in various reagents), swelling, setting, tensile behaviour, abrasion resistance and supercontraction are alternative indicators, which most commonly can be reasonably reliable measures of crosslinking. Their disadvantage, of course, is that they do not identify the particular fibre protein end-groups involved in crosslinking. Of the several recognised solubility tests, the performic acid/ammonia test is probably the best in most circumstances.60 The first step is oxidation of all the cystine with performic acid, followed by an extraction of soluble proteins with dilute ammonia. New crosslinkages stable to oxidation reduce the amount of extractable material. Concentrated urea solutions are well-known swelling and disaggregating solvents for proteins, in combination with a reductant, such as urea/thioglycollate61 or urea/bisulphite.62 The alkali solubility test63 has the longest history and is a standard method still (0.1 M sodium hydroxide at 65 °C for 1 hour) but can be difficult to interpret. Urea/reductant methods are valuable when crosslinkages are likely to be unstable to oxidising agents or alkalis.
5.15.2 Formaldehyde Formaldehyde reactions with wool have been the subject of numerous studies, in large part because formaldehyde is capable of introducing
Wool chemistry
153
crosslinkages in wool, as well as being cheap and being a small molecule that diffuses rapidly into wool fibres. Although formaldehyde appears to confer no measurable improvements to fibre strength or fabric abrasion resistance when used either as a pre-treatment or included in dyebaths and bleaching processes,18 it can be successfully used to replace a dye carrier when wool/polyester blends are dyed at high temperature.64 There is a considerable history of formaldehyde usage with wool products that do not involve crosslinking, but depend essentially on disinfection. Some examples include dusting greasy wool bales with paraformaldehyde to inhibit growth of microorganisms in storage, disinfection of blankets during laundering, and sterilising Indian wool suspected of containing Anthrax spores.18 Sidechains of ARG, LYS, TYR, TRP, HIS, cysteine, and the amide derivatives of ASP and GLU are known to be capable of reaction with formaldehyde. Some of these reactions can be bi-functional as well as mono-functional, so that new wool protein crosslinkages are likely. In addition to simple —CH2—, i.e. methylene crosslinkages, formaldehyde has a known propensity for self-condensation so that —CH2—(OCH2)n— or oxymethylene crosslinkages are feasible. Verifying the sites and extent of formaldehyde reactions with wool has proved to be difficult since most of the modified amino acid sidechains are unstable under the hydrolytic conditions required to release them for analysis. McPhee65 did, however, conclude that ARG residues are extensively modified under all conditions, whereas the amide derivatives of ASP and GLU react only in acid or in alkaline solutions. Whereas formaldehyde treatments of wool in acid conditions did not improve resistance to attack by insects, McPhee found that treatments at pH 12 modified most of the TRP and roughly half of the ARG and primary amino and amide groups. The treated wool, after neutralisation, showed good resistance to clothes moth larvae and newly hatched carpet beetles. Table 5.2, reproduced by Maclaren and Milligan18 from the primary data of McPhee65 and Reddie and Nicholls,66 illustrates the complexity of the formaldehyde reactions with wool under different conditions. Maclaren and Milligan18 discuss in detail the experimental difficulties in identifying amino acid modifications caused by formaldehyde treatments, essentially because the hydrolytic reagents needed to release individual amino acids may in themselves induce additional modifications. Modified amino acids isolated from acid hydrolysates of formaldehydetreated wool include Ne-methyllysine (A), thiazolidine-4-carboxylic acid (B) and djenkolic acid (C), the latter being the only example of a crosslinkage so far identified (Equation [5.13]).66–68
0.5
7.0
12.2
0.1
6.7
3.0
0.33
2.7
2.7
0.35
0.35
3.5
98
60
60
20
20
35
Temp. (°C)
24
2
2
0.5
48
20
Time (h)
—
870
1270
1200
450
770
Amount of HCHO bound (mmol.g-1)
—
—
—
400
50
300
AMIDEb
300 300 — — —
50c 80d 140d d
210
150
400
c
ARGe
0c
LYS
160
d
25d
55d
0
0
50f
TYR
Groups modified (mmol.g-1)a
40h
25h
40h
50
50
50g
TRP
46
46
46
45
45
45
Ref.
a
The initial amide, lysine, arginine, tyrosine, and tryptophan contents found by McPhee65 were 670, 210, 600, 350, and 54 mmol.g-1, respectively; the initial lysine, tyrosine, and tryptophan contents found by Reddie and Nicholls66 were 240, 420, and 40 mmol.g-1 respectively. b By ammonia determination after partial hydrolysis. c By colorimetry after ninhydrin treatment. d By indirect analysis after treatment with 1-fluoro-2,4-dinitrobenzene. e By reflectance spectrophotometry after applying Sakaguchi reagent. f By colorimetry after applying Pauly reagent and dissolution in alkali. g By reflectance spectrophotometry after applying Ehrlich reagent. h By colourimetry (Spies and Chambers method).
pH
Conc. (M)
Conditions of treatment
Table 5.2 The extent of reaction of formaldehyde with various residues in wool
154 Wool: Science and technology
Wool chemistry
155
O C CH3
NH(CH2)4
OH
S
CH
CH2
NH2
CH C
HN
(A)
(B)
O H2N CH CH2 C
S
CH2
S
CH2
O
OH
[5.13]
OH
NH2
OH
O
CH C
CH2
(C)
5.15.3 Dialdehydes Dialdehydes have attracted research and practical interest because of their obvious potential for crosslinking proteins in general. Glutaraldehyde is clearly the most successful. It has been applied in treatments of woolly sheepskins, where it has a dual role in tanning the leather and protecting the wool from felting during laundering.69 Glutaraldehyde reacts predominantly with LYS residues, although there is an unresolved debate about the nature of the crosslinkages.18,p192 The main disadvantage of the process is that it imparts a golden colour to the wool, although this can be mitigated to some extent by adding bisulphite to the treatment bath.
5.15.4 Other bifunctional reagents One of the early papers describing a crosslinking process for wool employed various alkyl dibromide solutions applied in a one-step treatment which included dithionite. This reducing agent opened up the fibre by cleavage of some cystine, allowing the dibromide to reform this crosslink and add a variety of other bifunctional reactions.70 Acyl and aryl dihalides, dimaleimides and bifunctional acid chlorides, isocyanates and active esters have all been reacted with wool from both aqueous and organic solvents. An example of this type of treatment is that of cyanuric chloride (2,4,6 trichloro-s-triazine), which is a relatively cheap industrial reagent, applied from an aqueous acetone solution at room temperature.71 About 300 m mol/g of wool of the reagent is incorporated and there is reduced solubility in all the regular alkali, urea-bisulphite and acid solubility tests, which is strong circumstantial evidence for crosslinking. Apart from the commercial use of glutaraldehyde as a tanning and fibre stabilisation process (Section 5.15.3) and the regular re-discovery of useful applications for formaldehyde treatments, there has been no
156
Wool: Science and technology
sustained development of crosslinking processes, presumably as any product performance advantages are insufficient to justify their industrial development.
References 1 Corfield M C and Robson A, ‘The amino acid composition of wool’, Proc. Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Australia, 1955, C79–86. 2 Meybeck A and Meybeck J, ‘Photo-oxidation of the peptide group, I. Fibrous Proteins’, Photochem. Photobiol., 1967, 6, 355–63. 3 Hoare J L, ‘Chemical aspects of wool yellowing’, WRONZ Communication 2, 1968. 4 Launer H F, Effect of light upon wool, ‘Part I, Greening and yellowing by germicidal ultraviolet.’ ‘Part II, Post-irradiation loss of colour in the dark after germicidal ultraviolet’, Text. Res. J., 1963, 33, 258–63, 910–18: ‘Part IV, Bleaching and yellowing by sunlight.’ ‘Part V, Yellowing and bleaching by ultraviolet and visible arc light’, Text. Res. J., 1965, 35, 395–400, 813–19. 5 Inglis A S and Lennox F G, ‘Studies in wool yellowing, Part IX, Irradiation with different UV wavebands’, Text. Res. J., 1965, 35, 104–9. 6 Launer H F, ‘Rapid bleaching of wool with extremely intense visible light’, Text. Res. J., 1971, 41, 311–14. 7 King M G, ‘The effects of reducing agents on the photobleaching and photoyellowing of wool’, J. Text. Inst., 1971, 62, 251–60. 8 Simpson W S, ‘Comparison of chemical and photochemical bleaches for wool’, Proc. 8th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Christchurch, NZ, IV, 279–87, 1990. 9 Simpson W S, ‘Physics and chemistry of wool yellowing’, WRONZ Report R217, 1999. 10 Lennox F G and Rowlands R J, ‘Photochemical degradation of proteins’, Photochem. Photobiol., 1969, 9, 359–67. 11 Holt L A and Milligan B, ‘Application of enzymic hydrolysis and tritium labelling to a study of the modification of tryptophyl residues in proteins’, Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 1973, 26, 871–6. 12 Steinert P M, Kartasova T and Marekov L N, ‘Biochemical evidence that small proline-rich proteins and trichohyalin function in epithelia by modulation of the biochemical properties of their cornified cell envelopes’, J. Biol. Chem., 1998, 273, 11758–69. 13 Steinhardt J and Harris M, ‘Combination of wool protein with acid and base – HCl and KOH’, J. Res. Natl. Bur. Standards, 1940, 24, 335–67. 14 Alexander P and Hudson R F, Wool: Its Chemistry and Physics, London, Chapman and Hall, 1954. 15 Vickerstaff T, The Physical Chemistry of Dyeing, London, Oliver and Boyd, 1954. 16 Peters R H, Textile Chemistry – The Physical Chemistry of Dyeing, Vol. 3, Amsterdam, Elsevier, 1975. 17 Gilbert G A and Rideal E K, ‘The combination of fibrous proteins with acids’, Proc. Roy. Soc., 1944, A182, 335–46. 18 Maclaren J A and Milligan B, Wool Science. The Chemical Reactivity of the Wool Fibre. NSW Science Press, 1981.
Wool chemistry
157
19 Hall R O, ‘Fibre structure in relation to dyeing’, J. Soc. Dyers and Col., 1937, 53, 341–4. 20 Joko K, Koga J and Koroki N, ‘The interaction of dyes with wool keratin – the effect of solvent treatment on dyeing behaviour’, Proc. 7th Int. Wool Text. Conf., Vol. 5, 1985, 23–32. 21 Leeder J D, Rippon J A and Rivett D E, ‘Modification of the surface properties of wool by treatment with anhydrous alkali’, ibid, Vol. 4, 312–21. 22 Leeder J D, Rippon J A, Rothery F E and Stapleton I W, ‘Use of the transmission microscope to study dyeing and diffusion processes’, ibid, Vol. 5, 99–108. 23 Lewis D M, Wool dyeing, Soc. Dyers and Col., Bradford, 1992. 24 Elod E, ‘Theory of the dyeing process. Influence of acid dyes on animal fibres’, Trans. Farad. Soc., 1933, 327–47. 25 Zollinger H, ‘The dye and the substrate: The role of hydrophobic bonding in dyeing processes’, J. Soc. Dyers and Col., 1965, 81, 345–50. 26 Meybeck J and Galafassi P, ‘The effects of hydrocarbon substituents in azo dyes on wool dyeing’, 4th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Berkeley, Calif, App. Polymer Symp., No. 18, Part 1, 463–72, 1971. 27 Consden R and Gordon A H, ‘The peptides of cystine in partial hydrolysates of wool’, Biochem. J., 1950, 46, 8–20. 28 Burgess R, ‘The use of trypsin for the determination of the resistance of wool fibres to bacterial disintegration’, J. Text. Inst., 1934, 25, T289–94. 29 Holt L A, Milligan B and Roxburgh C M, ‘ASP, ASN, GLU and GLN contents of wool and two derived protein fractions’, Aust. J. Biol. Sci., 1971, 24, 509– 14. 30 Caldwell J B, Milligan B and Roxburgh C M, ‘The sites of reaction of phenylisocyanate with wool’, J. Text. Inst., 1973, 64, 461–7. 31 Asquith R S, Otterburn M S, Buchanan J H, Cole M, Fletcher J C and Gardner K L, ‘Identification of eN (g-glutamyl) lysine crosslinks in native wool keratins’, Biochim. Biophys. Acta, 1970, 221, 342–8. 32 Milligan B, Holt L A and Caldwell J B,‘The enzymic hydrolysis of wool for amino acid analysis’, 4th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Berkeley, Calif., Appl. Polymer Symp., No. 18, Part 1, 1971, 113–25. 33 Schmitz I, Baumann H and Zahn H, ‘Ein Beitrag zur enzymatschen Totalhydrolyse von Wollkeratin’, Proc. 5th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Aachen, II, 313–25, 1975. 34 O’Donnell I J, and Woods E F, ‘The preparation of wool protein solutions’, Proc. Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Australia, CSIRO, 1955, Vol. B, 48–55. 35 von Allwörden K, ‘Properties of wool – detection of damaged wool by chemical means’, Z. Angewandte Chem., 1916, 29, 27–32. 36 Simpson W S, ‘Effect of chlorination under different conditions on the dyeing of wool’, WRONZ Communication 47, 1976. 37 Gillespie J M, O’Donnell I J, Thompson E O P and Woods E F, ‘Preparation and properties of wool proteins’, J. Text. Inst., 1960, 51, T703–9. 38 Wolfram L K, ‘The reaction of tris(hydroxymethyl) phosphine with keratin’, Proc. 3rd Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Paris, 1965, II, 505–12. 39 Maclaren J A, ‘Quantitative reduction and alkylation of wool’, Text. Res. J., 1971, 41, 713–14. 40 Maclaren J A and Sweetman B J, ‘Preparation of reduced wool and S-alkylated wool keratins using tri-butylphosphine’, Austr. J. Chem., 1966, 19, 2355–60.
158
Wool: Science and technology
41 Cecil R in The Proteins, ed. H Neurath. Academic Press, NY, Vol. 1, 1963, p. 438. 42 Leach S J, Meachers A and Springell P H, ‘Micro- and submicro methods for the estimation of thiol and disulphide groups in insoluble proteins using radioactive mercurials’, Anal. Biochem., 1966, 15, 18–30. 43 Friedman M and Mavri M S, ‘Sorption behaviour of mercuric salts on chemically modified wools and polyamino acids’, J. Appl. Polymer Sci., 1973, 17, 2183–90. 44 Friedman M, Harrison C S, Ward W H and Lundgren H P, ‘Sorption behaviour of mercuric and methylmercuric salts on wool’, J. Appl. Polymer Sci., 1973, 17, 337–90. 45 Simpson W S and Mason P C R, ‘Absorption of silver ions by wool’, Text. Res. J., 1969, 39, 434–41. 46 Kassenbeck P and Hagege R, ‘Development Des Methods D. Analyses Histochemique’, 3rd Int. Congr. Wool Textile Res., Paris, 1965, I, 245–58. 47 Sikorski J and Simpson W S, ‘Studies of the reactivity of keratin with heavy metals’, J. Roy. Microscopical Soc., 1959, 68, 35–40. 48 Guthrie R E and Laurie S H, ‘Binding of copper II to mohair keratin’, Austr. J. Chem., 1968, 21, 2437–43. 49 Whewell C S and Woods H J, ‘A reversible contraction phenomenon in animal hairs’, Nature, 1944, 54, 546–9. 50 Edgar J S and Simpson W S, ‘The effect of aluminium on the load – extension characteristics of some wool yarns’ and ‘The absorption of aluminium by wool from water alcohol mixtures’, Text. Res. J., 1975, 45, 809–11 and 281–4. 51 Blackburn S and Phillips H, ‘The action of iodine on wool’, J. Soc. Dyers and Col., 1945, 61, 100–3. 52 Richards H R and Speakman J B, ‘The iodination of wool’, J. Soc. Dyers and Col., 1955, 71, 537–44. 53 Cockburn R and Speakman J B, ‘Cross-linking reactions in keratin III. The action of ninhydrin on wool’, Proc. Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Australia, 1955, C315–39. 54 Pauly H, ‘The diazo reactions of proteins’, Z. Physiol. Chem., 1915, 94, 284–90. 55 Glynn M V, ‘Diazo compounds in the determination of wool damage’, J. Soc. Dyers Col., 1952, 68, 16–20. 56 Simpson W S and Page C T, ‘The effect of light on wool and the inhibition of light tendering’, WRONZ Report No 60, 1979, pp. 3–5. 57 Alexander P, Carter D, Earland C and Ford O E, ‘Esterification of the carboxyl groups in wool’, Biochem. J., 1951, 48, 629–32. 58 Holt L A and Milligan B, ‘Esterification of wool’, Austr. J. Biol. Sci., 1970, 23, 165–73. 59 Hinton E H Jnr, ‘A survey and critique of the literature on crosslinking agents and mechanisms as related to wool keratin’, Text. Res. J., 1974, 44, 233–92. 60 Caldwell J B, Leach S J and Milligan B, ‘Solubility as a criterion of crosslinking in wool’, Text. Res. J., 1966, 36, 1091–5. 61 Gillespie J M, ‘The isolation and properties of some soluble proteins from wool’, Austr. J. Biol. Sci., 1964, 17, 282–300. 62 Lees K, Peryman R V and Elsworth F F, ‘The solubility of wool in ureabisulphite solutions and its use as a measure of fibre modification – Part II’, J. Text. Inst., 1960, 51, T717–32. 63 Harris M and Smith A L, ‘Oxidation of wool IV. Alkali solubility test for determining the extent of oxidation’, Amer. Dyest. Rep., 1936, 25, 542–5.
Wool chemistry
159
64 Baumann H, Muller H, Mochel L and Spiegelmacher P, ‘Chemische veränderungen und schutz der Wolle beim HT-Färben von Polyester/wolle – Stückware, Melliand Textilber., 1977, 58, 420–2. 65 McPhee J R, ‘The reaction of formaldehyde with wool and its effect on digestion by insects’, Text. Res. J., 1958, 28, 303–14. 66 Reddie R N and Nicholls C H, ‘Some reactions between wool and formaldehyde’, Text. Res. J., 1971, 41, 841–52. 67 Trézl L, Heiszman J and Tyihák E, ‘Changes in the thermal behaviour of wool due to pretreatments. Formation of heat resistant crosslinkage’, 5th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Aachen, 1975, II, 488–98. 68 Middlebrook W R and Phillips H, ‘The action of formaldehyde on the cystine disulphide linkages of wool’, Biochem. J., 1947, 41, 218–23. 69 Happich W F, ‘New process expands uses for woolskins’, 4th Int. Wool Text. Res. Conf., Berkeley, Calif., Appl. Polymer Symp., No. 18, 1971, Part 2, 1483–90. 70 Marzona M, Di Modica G and Marzona M, ‘Crosslinking of wool keratin with bifunctional aldehydes’, Text. Res. J., 1971, 41, 701–5. 71 Harris M and Brown A E, ‘New developments in the chemical modification of wool’, Amer. Dyest. Rep., 1947, 36, 316–19.
6 Mechanical processing for yarn production L HUNTER
6.1
Introduction
The mechanical processing stage in the wool pipeline commences with the clean scoured wool and ends with the yarn ready for the fabric manufacturing stage. The main objectives of this stage are to disentangle the fibres, remove vegetable matter, mix (blend) the fibres, form a uniform coherent strand of fibres (sliver or slubbing) and then attenuate the fibre strand and impart cohesion to form a yarn of the desired linear density (count), quality and character. Other operations that can also take place during the mechanical processing stage include short fibre and residual vegetable matter removal (combing), dyeing (loose stock, sliver/top or yarn) and shrink-proofing (loose stock or sliver). Folding (plying), winding, clearing, waxing, etc. are final operations that may be required to produce a yarn and yarn package suitable for the fabric forming stage. All the above need to take place with the maximum efficiency and quality and with the minimum cost, fibre breakage and fibre loss. The mechanical processing of wool can be divided into the following three main stages: •
•
•
Sliver or slubbing formation – Involves disentangling (individualising) and mixing the fibres, removing vegetable matter and forming a continuous web, sliver or slubbing, this being accomplished by carding. Preparing the carded sliver for spinning – Entails fibre alignment (parallelisation), evening (doubling), drafting and the removal of short fibres, neps and vegetable and other contaminants – Accomplished by gilling, combing and drawing Yarn formation – Drafting and imparting cohesion, usually through twist insertion, this being the spinning stage.
The middle, or intermediate stage (i.e. preparing for spinning) is omitted from the woollen processing route and it is the differences in this stage (namely combing and the associated additional gilling operations) that 160
Mechanical processing for yarn production
161
also essentially distinguish the worsted from the semi-worsted processing route. There are basically three different routes or systems used in the mechanical processing of wool (Fig. 6.1), namely worsted, semi-worsted and woollen.1 The essential differences in the products of the three systems are the levels of short fibres and the alignment of the fibres in the yarn, the fibres in worsted yarns being far more parallel than those in either semi-worsted or woollen yarns, resulting in a far leaner (less bulky) and less hairy yarn. Close on 90% of Australian and South African Merino type apparel wools are processed on the worsted system while some 80% of New Zealand wool is processed on the woollen system. It should be mentioned that short wools, mainly in blends with either cotton or polyester, are also processed on the cotton (short staple) system, being occasionally rotor-spun (open-end) rather than ring spun. Wool with a mean fibre length around 40 mm can generally be processed without any major alteration to the cotton machinery, while wool with a mean fibre length of around 50 mm generally requires slip drafting at the drawframe, speedframe and ringframe. Iype et al.2 have reviewed the processing of wool and wool-rich blends on the cotton system and this processing route will not be dealt with in this chapter.
6.2
Worsted processing system
6.2.1 Introduction The name ‘Worsted’ is a slight corruption of ‘Worstead’, the name of a village in Norfolk where expert cloth-workers who entered England in the early fourteenth century, introduced novel methods for the production of superior and finer cloth than was previously produced in Britain.3 As already mentioned, the essential and differentiating element of the worsted system is combing. Generally, only virgin wool, typically ranging in length from about 40 to 100 mm, is used in manufacturing worsteds, the term worsted-spun yarn, as opposed to worsted yarn, being used for the yarns in those cases where man-made fibres are processed. Virtually since the start of worsted processing, two main systems have been used, namely the English (oil combed or Bradford) system, involving Noble combing, and the French or Continental (dry-combed) system, involving Rectilinear combing. The former was primarily developed and used for longer wools and the latter for shorter wools. Nevertheless, Noble (and also Lister) combs, employed in the Bradford system, are no longer being manufactured and the industry has moved almost entirely to the Rectilinear or French combing route. Essentially, the latter route entails carding followed by Intermediate or Preparer Gilling, then Rectilinear
162
Wool: Science and technology
Worsted flow chart Raw wool and hairs Blending Dust removal (if needed)
Drying Fibres shorter than 200 mm maximum fibre length
Fibres longer than 200 mm maximum fibre length
Carding
Preparer gilling (6 operations)
Intermediate gilling (usually 3 gill boxes) Combing (Lister or Noble)
Combing (usually rectilinear, sometimes Noble)
Combing factory processes
Scouring
Top finishing (usually 2 gill boxes)
Recombing factory processes (usually omitted if piece-dyeing or yarn dyeing is to be used)
Top dyeing (or bleaching) Backwashing Drying Blending 56’s wool quality and coarser
58’s wool quality and finer
Gill mixing (2 operations)
Comb preparing (3 gill boxes) Recombing (rectilinear or Noble) Top finishing (2 operations) Spinning factory processes
Drawing (2 to 5 operations) Spinning Winding and clearing Folding and re-winding if required
Semi-worsted flow chart
Woollen flow chart
Man-made fibres
Raw wool Raw wool
Remanufactured fibres Threads
Rags Scouring Drying
Pulling (or grinding)
Worsted by-products (soft waste)
Other fibres (e.g. hairs, cotton, silk, man-made fibres)
Dust removal (if required) Scouring Drying Blending High-production carding
Garnetting
Drawing (2 or 3 gill boxes)
Carbonizing if required Dyeing if required Blending Carding
Roving (no roving process for thick count yarns for end-products (bobbin lead, for knitting yarns and some upholstery) such as carpets) Spinning
Spinning Winding and clearing Folding and re-winding if required
Winding and clearing Folding and re-winding if required
6.1 Processing routes for wool. [From Oxtoby.1]
Mechanical processing for yarn production
163
Combing (very occasionally Noble combing) and then Top Finishing, which usually comprises two Finisher Gilling operations. The stage from greasy wool to top is referred to as the ‘early processing’ or ‘topmaking’ stage. Papers at the Top-Tech ’96 Conference in Australia4 dealt with various aspects of topmaking, including the potential and merits of automation in topmaking, cost and flexibility being important aspects in this regard. The Worsted Flow Chart is shown in Fig. 6.1.1
6.2.2 Carding Carding generally represents the first stage of the mechanical processing of scoured wool, worsted cards typically being available in widths between 2.5 and 3.5 m. If any opening is applied prior to carding, care must be taken not to entangle the fibres, particularly for fine wools. Lubricants (generally 0.4 to 0.5%) are applied prior to carding to provide a well-balanced static and dynamic fibre-to-fibre and fibre-to-metal friction, and cohesion and antistatic properties.5 Best results are generally obtained with boundary layer lubrication for carding, the main effect being at the swift. The lubricants should be emulsifiable and preferably bio-degradable, and often also contain bactericides/fungicides, complexing agents and anti-odourants. The worsted, semi-worsted and woollen cards entail similar carding principles, although the last has more carding elements as well as an intermediate feed. Automatic linkages between carding, intermediate gilling and combing have also been developed. In essence, carding is aimed at opening up or disentangling the scoured wool staples (clusters or tufts), individualizing the fibres, mixing the fibres, removing residual dirt and vegetable matter, such as burrs and seeds, and forming the wool fibres into a continuous form (web); this is then condensed into a card sliver, and, in the case of worsted carding (Fig. 6.2), delivered into a ball or can. These actions need to be carried out in such a way that fibre breakage is minimised and as even a web and sliver as possible are produced. In the case of the worsted route, the wool is virtually always carded in the undyed state. The card essentially consists of the following separate mechanical sections, each playing a different part in the process:7 • • • •
Feeding Licker-in, including burr removal etc. Swift-worker-stripper section Fancy doffer section
The exact configuration of the card (Fig. 6.2) depends upon the nature of the fibre being processed, notably the level of vegetable matter. For example, when wools of relatively high vegetable matter levels are carded, the card could have more morels and burr-rollers.
164
Wool: Science and technology
Burr beaters Swift Licker Volumetric hopper
Breast
Morels
Doffer Drafting head
6.2 Worsted Card. [From Harrowfield.6]
The feed system plays a critical role in the uniformity of the card web and sliver. Examples are continuous flow volumetric feeders or gravimetric feeders, incorporating automatic monitoring and regulating devices (autolevelling). The card essentially consists of rollers with surfaces covered in pins (card clothing). There are two main types of card clothing, flexible steel wire mounted into a firm foundation and rigid (non-flexible) metallic wire. The latter is a continuous steel ribbon with saw teeth which is wound around the card rollers, and this form of card clothing is presently the most popular. The following carding actions take place (Fig. 6.3): • • • • •
Carding (working) Dividing Stripping Doffing Brushing or Raising
The action on the fibres present between the pins of two adjacent rollers on a card is determined by the following factors:1 • • •
Relative speed and direction (i.e. same or opposite) of the movement of the roller surfaces Direction of inclination of the pins, i.e. points leading or backs leading Distance (setting) between points on the adjacent rollers
The intensity of the carding action can be altered by changing one or more of the above factors. Increasing the overall speed of the card generally does not increase the carding action (or fibre breakage) as such, although it can increase fly waste and air currents. There are three pin relationships in carding, namely point to point, point to back and back to back1 (Fig. 6.3):
Mechanical processing for yarn production Fibres leaving
Fibres leaving
Fibres entering
Fibres entering
165
Slow
Slow Fast Fibres entering
(a)
Fibres Fibres Fast leaving entering (b)
Fibres leaving
Fibres leaving
Point-to-point working actions
(a)
(b)
Fibres leaving
Point to back: stripping action
(a) surfaces moving in opposite directions; (b) surfaces moving in the same direction Embedded fibres
Fibres entering Swift (fast)
Fancy Swift
Fibres remaining on the swift
Doffer (slow) Raised fibres
Fibres collected by the doffer Doffing action (point to point)
Back to back: raising action; conventional worsted application with flexible swift clothing
6.3 Carding actions. [From Oxtoby.1]
Point to point, when used to open and disentangle the tufts of fibres, is called working or carding (e.g. at the licker and divider). This action always results in some fibres being retained on both surfaces. It is also used by the doffer to collect fibres from the fast moving swift, normally following the action of the fancy. Point to back provides a stripping action, i.e. transfers all the fibres from the one surface to the other. Back to back results in a raising action, which moves the fibres carried by the swift towards the tips of the pins by the action of the long fancy wire pins as they intersect with the pins on the swift.1 Burr beaters are used to remove burrs and other vegetable matter. They have steel blades and are usually run at the highest feasible speed in the opposite direction to the card roller surface. They are at their most effective during the earlier stages of the carding process, before the burrs have been opened out, and when they are used in conjunction with Morel rollers. Morel rollers are clothed with rigid wire clothing that cause the fibres to bed into the wires (assisted by the action of brush rollers) whereas the vegetable matter particles protrude from the surface and are knocked off into trays by fast revolving burr beaters, sharp blades offering certain
166
Wool: Science and technology
advantages.8 A modern card with two Morels typically removes over 90% by weight of burr and close on 90% of shive. The full width web from the doffer, which can be monitored and corrected for evenness, is condensed into a sliver as it passes through a funnel and between a pair of pressure rollers, the latter running at a slightly higher speed than the doffer. Card sliver linear density monitoring and autolevelling (open and closed loop) take place at this stage, a drafting head at the delivery end of the card allowing the sliver linear density to be controlled. When carding with rigid metallic wire clothing, wool regain should not exceed 25%,1 and ideally should be between 20 and 25%. Residual grease content of the wool should not exceed 0.6%.1 Carding is a fairly severe action, typically breaking between about 20 and 40% of the fibres, with an average breakage rate of about 30%; as much as 90% of the fibre breakage that takes place in converting scoured wool into top takes place during carding.9 The card also breaks about 90% of the weathered wool tip. These short degraded fibre fragments either fall from the web as carding waste or are taken out of the sliver when subsequently combed. The level of fibre breakage is influenced by the degree of fibre entanglement developed during scouring, the fibre fineness, strength, length (Fig. 6.4)10 and friction (lubrication), as well as on the thickness of the fibre layer on the swift, an increase in fresh fibre density on the swift increasing fibre breakage. It is perhaps worth noting that storage and pressing of scoured wool to high density, lead to additional fibre breakage during subsequent processing. Table 6.1 illustrates the potential effects of changes in certain parameters on fibre breakage during carding, summarising results obtained during various experimental studies (some on processed wool) at SAWTRI.11 The disentangling and opening processes may be inadequate to the extent that small tangled balls (tight clusters) of fibres, described as neps, are present in the card web. Poor carding, often indicated by increasing nep content, can be due to damaged or inadequately ground (blunt) card clothing and incorrect settings. Card wire should not be blunt, bent over, flattened or damaged in any other way. Incorrect setting of burr-beaters and crushing rollers may also lead to unacceptable levels of vegetable matter. Reducing the ‘fresh fibre density’ by increasing swift speed, reduces neps and combing waste.12 The quality of the carding operation can be assessed in terms of the following web characteristics: • • • •
Degree of individualisation of the fibres. Uniformity in weight per unit area. Uniformity of blending. Degree of alignment of the fibres.
Mechanical processing for yarn production
167
Mean fibre length of card sliver (mm)
100 34.5 90 27
ge
80
21
ka
re
a re
b
ib of
16
N
70
12 9.5
60 50
40 50
60
70
80
90
100
110
Mean fibre length of raw wool (mm)
6.4 Mean Fibre Length of Card Sliver after 3rd Gilling vs Mean Fibre Length of Raw Wool. [From Aldrich et al.10]
Table 6.1 Summary of breakage results obtained in various experimental carding studies at SAWTRI11 Parameter*
Change in value of parameter
Change in fibre breakage
Style
Spinners to Inferior
6% to 36%
Length
57 mm to 109 mm
19% to 43%
Vegetable impurity
0.5% to 2.0%
10% to 19%
Temp. of scouring
45 °C to 70 °C
12% to 18%
pH of scour liquor
3.4 to 10.8
10% to 24%
Residual grease
0.4% to 1.6%
26% to 40%
Lubricant added
0.4% to 2.1%
2% to 10%
Worker settings
26 gauge to 30 gauge
27% to 42%
* Only one parameter changed in each case.
168 • •
Wool: Science and technology
Level of hooks (most hooks occur at the trailing ends of the fibres as they leave the card). Level of neps and vegetable matter.
Although the card can remove pre-existing neps resulting from fibre entanglement in the scoured wool it also forms new neps and fibre structures that tend to form neps during subsequent gilling. The number of neps decrease with an increase in the number of workers, sharpness of card wire, closer worker settings and with a decrease in recycled fibre density/ swift load.12 The number of neps also increase with increasing scoured wool entanglement and with increasing fibre fineness, crimp and length. Neps generally increase from the card to the comb (i.e. during gilling), affecting the amount of noil. Reducing neps by 50% could reduce noil by some 25%. The basic principles of carding remained virtually unchanged for the entire 20th century, probably the most notable changes taking place in the last two decades of the 20th century. These include the development of Very High Speed Carding (VHSC) by the CSIRO (Australia), the IWS and G H Michell (Australian topmaker) in collaboration with Thibeau (France), and the high speed Hercules card by Octir. The former development virtually doubled the carding speed and resulted in the Thibeau CA7 Card, which was exhibited at the 1995 ITMA, a compact version being shown at the 1999 ITMA. On such a card (2.5 m wide), typical production rates achieved are 220 kg/hr for 22 mm wool and 160 kg/hr for 19.5 mm wool. This substantial increase in speed was brought about essentially by two breakthroughs. The first was the development of tandem burr beaters, which overcame the speed limitations of the single burr beater and enabled much higher carding speeds without any sacrifice in vegetable matter removal efficiency. The second innovation involved the use of two doffers at the swift, which maintained the transfer efficiency from swift to doffer (traditionally about 50%) at the higher carding speeds used. Overall, the increase in production speed was achieved by: • • • • • •
Increase in swift speed and diameter. Increase in the number of carding points. Optimising speed ratios between different rollers and fibre diameters. Improved vegetable matter removal. Double doffer. Efficient suction systems to keep the environment clean.
For superfine wools to achieve the longest Hauteur* and lowest noil, the ratio of swift worker pinning density to fibre density should be as high as * Hauteur is the mean fibre length of a top, based upon a length biased distribution.
Mechanical processing for yarn production
169
possible; this can be achieved by increasing pin density or reducing fibre density, but it is not sufficient to reduce fibre density at some stage before the final swift.13 Developments that have helped to reduce the number, frequency and time required for setting and maintenance include: • • • •
Centralised read-out and control of the different production parameters from the operator console. Variable-speed motor drive to allow operational changes of sliver weight, rate of production and carding intensity. Automatic doffing of full cans. Remote card (gap) settings.
Meng et al.14 critically reviewed the studies undertaken on fibre distribution and movement on the various carding elements, these governing carding efficiency, fibre mixing and levelling, productivity and web quality. They noted the pioneering work of Montfort15 in mathematically modelling the fibre transfer process in a roller-top card as a finite Markov chain, this having been extended by other workers to cover other stochastic features of carding.They concluded that, according to theory, fibre mixing and equalising are improved by increasing the collecting power of workers and decreasing doffer transfer efficiency, but that the theory was not always supported by experimental work. Work has also been done to measure the fibre density on the various carding elements, one example being the optical system developed by Rust and Koella.16 The combined carding and combing operations remove some 99.5% of the vegetable matter present in the scoured wool.17 Particularly troublesome, however, is contamination by polypropylene fibres from twine and by polyethylene wool pack fragments; the latter can be avoided by the use of nylon packs.
6.2.3 Preparer (intermediate) gilling Generally, three preparer (intermediate) gilling operations follow carding (i.e. precede combing), coarser pinning generally being used for preparer than for finisher gilling. The purpose of gilling the card sliver prior to combing is to remove hooks, align, straighten and blend the fibres and improve sliver uniformity (by doubling) so as to reduce fibre breakage and noil during combing as well any excessive extensibility of the card sliver. The more aligned the fibres and the fewer the fibre hooks, the lower the chances of fibre breakage during combing. Significant fibre breakage, however, can occur on high-speed intersecting gill boxes when using close front-roller settings.18 Gilling tends to increase neps from fibre structures formed during carding. The gilling
170
Wool: Science and technology
Feed rollers
Delivery rollers
Typical draft 6
6.5 Intersecting Gill Box. [From Harrowfield.6]
operation mostly removes trailing hooks, hence the need to reverse the direction of the sliver in subsequent operations. Gilling also creates some hooks.19 It is generally recognised that, in terms of the gilling operations, intersecting pins are necessary to ensure the proper drafting of wool. Intersecting (or intersector) gills (Fig. 6.5) generally have either screw-driven or chain-driven fallers or pinned rollers and rotary gills, and can have either single or double heads. Very few screw gills are now manufactured, chain gills dominating the market. The latter are versatile and have a production rate around double that of the screw gills, the pin paths being similar. Screw gills are, however, still preferred for very short fibres and where high loads are required. There are essentially four gilling machine manufacturers, namely NSC Schlumberger, OKK, Cognetex and Sant’ Andrea Novara. Gills can be equipped with either mechanical or electronic autolevellers and also can be fitted with spraying devices. Adding moisture during high speed gilling, e.g. by spraying, is important for achieving the desired regain for subsequent processing. A lubricant (0.1 to 0.3%) can also be sprayed onto the sliver during the first or second gilling operations, to assist in maintaining or increasing regain, minimising static and modifying static fibre-tofibre cohesion.5 Integrated suction and blowing systems keep the heads clean. Okamura et al.20 investigated the competing effects of draft and doubling on sliver evenness, evenness improving with doubling up to 12 slivers, after which it remains largely constant.
Mechanical processing for yarn production
171
Direct linking of the card to the first gill and the third gill to the comb was found to reduce Hauteur but did not affect noil, neps, vegetable matter or fibre length distribution.19 Introducing a fourth gilling operation in such a set up had a beneficial effect on Hauteur and noil.
6.2.4 Combing Combing enables finer, stronger more uniform and less hairy yarns to be spun at better efficiency. Combing aligns the fibres and removes, as noil, fibres generally shorter than about 20 to 30 mm, vegetable matter and neps. Typically, Hauteur is increased by 10 to 15 mm and its coefficient of variation (CVH) is reduced by 10 to 20%,21 while more than 95% of VM and neps are generally removed. Most of the short fibres removed by the comb as noil arise from fibre breakage during carding. Noil removed during combing has a market value about 40% of that of the top and is mainly utilized by the woollen industry. Originally, four types of combing machines, namely Noble (circular), Rectilinear (intermittent), Lister (nip-motion) and Holden (square motion), were used, but today combing is largely done on the rectilinear comb, also called a Continental, French, Heilmann or Schlumberger comb, the other types of combs no longer being manufactured. The move to rectilinear combing is mainly due to the increasing use of dry-combed as opposed to oil-combed tops and the shorter mean fibre lengths of the wool typically being processed nowadays. Rectilinear combing is the only type described here. The principles of combing introduced during the mid 1800s were so good that they are still used today. The rectilinear comb was invented by Heilmann around 1845 and there are now two main manufacturers of wool combing machines, namely NSC Schlumberger and Sant’ Andrea Novara. Examples of modern rectilinear combs are the Sant’ Andrea P100 (production 1.2 to 1.6 kg/mm) and the Schlumberger PB33, combing speeds being as high as 260 nips/min and visual readout providing instant information on virtually all aspects of the combing operation. The basic operations of a combing machine are:1 • •
•
Feeding the slivers, typically 24 to 32, from balls or cans into the machine. Holding the fibres and combing the free fibre ends by means of a cylinder covered with progressively finer pins, any fibres not held being combed out as ‘noil’, along with neps and vegetable matter (Fig. 6.6). Gripping, by means of detaching (drawing off) rollers, and detaching the combed fringe of parallel fibres (which is now free of short fibres and entanglements), holding it, inserting the top comb, and pulling the
172
Wool: Science and technology (a) Circular combing Feed gill Feed grid Wool Nipper brush Beard
Top comb
(b) Detaching phase Upper nipper
Detaching rollers
Detaching apron
Shovel plate
Lower nipper
Circular comb
6.6 Two phases of Rectilinear Combing. [From Harrowfield.6]
•
fibres through the pins of the top comb, which consists of a single row of pins, thereby removing any ungripped fibres as noil as well as neps and vegetable matter (Fig. 6.6). Laying the combed fringe on the previously combed fringes and forming a continuous ‘combed’ sliver from the tufts that have just been combed.
Brushes play an important role in combing; for example, in cleaning the circular and top combs and drawing-off cylinder, and pressing the fibres into the circular comb. Automatic adjustment of brushes, such as the nipper and circular brushes, and the simplified reversal and removal of the latter represent important developments.
Mechanical processing for yarn production
173
A good measure of combing quality for Merino type wools is the percentage of fibres shorter than 15 mm in the top, which should preferably be below 1.8 to 2.0%.22 It is affected by the total fatty matter content of the sliver (minimum 0.6 to 0.7%), the relative humidity (ideally 70 to 75%) and temperature (ideally 20° to 24 °C) of the combing shed, as well as by the regain of the wool (ideally around 20%) and the comb setting. The comb also breaks fibres, the breakage rate decreasing with decreasing fibre length, friction, combing intensity and with increasing fibre alignment and fibre strength. Fibre breakage during combing can range from around 17 to 31%.23 Trailing hooks in the sliver fed to the comb are less likely to be broken during combing,19 hence the importance of an uneven (odd) number of gilling operations between carding and combing, assuming cans are used. The percentage of fibres shorter than 30 mm and of noil are influenced by the following factors:24 •
• • •
Raw wool characteristics (e.g. fineness, staple length uniformity, staple strength, character or style, including levels of vegetable matter and other impurities). Quality of scouring and associated processes (greasy wool opening, wool felting. etc.). Quality of carding (card production, setting, speed). Quality of combing (comb setting, maintenance).
The amount of noil removed during combing may be expressed either as percentage noil or Tear (ratio) as follows: Noil (%) =
mass of noil ¥ 100 mass of (noil + comb sliver)
[6.1]
Ê mass of comb sliver ˆ :1 Ë ¯ mass of noil
[6.2]
Tear ratio = It follows that: Noil (%) =
100
(tear + 1)
[6.3]
6.2.5 Backwashing Backwashing is the process of treating wool slivers and tops in an aqueous detergent solution to remove any remaining unwanted impurities, such as residual grease and lubricants, and also to straighten the fibres (i.e. reduce fibre crimp). A lubricant is added at the end of the process, and also a fugitive tint to produce a temporary improvement in the colour (whiteness) of
174
Wool: Science and technology
the wool. Typically, 36 slivers are fed to the backwashing machine, which consists of two scouring bowls and one rinse bowl followed by a suction drum dryer. A gilling process normally follows the backwashing process. Backwashing can either precede or follow the combing process, the former option normally being used for oil-combed tops (e.g. to remove dirt prior to Noble combing) and the latter for dry-combed tops (e.g. to reduce residual fatty matter and improve the appearance of the top). Top shrink-resist treatment (e.g. chlorine-Hercosett) is carried out in a machine similar to a backwashing machine except that there are extra bowls for chlorine and resin application (i.e. a total of five bowls) and an extra dryer to cure the resin.
6.2.6 Recombing Recombing was originally introduced for dyed tops, in order to separate and align fibres which became entangled during dyeing and also to remove neps and slubs formed during dyeing, as well as any other remaining short fibres and neps; the neps in the top are generally reduced by over 80% (small neps by 70 to 80% and larger neps by 90 to 95%). A crimping box was introduced at the comb delivery to improve the cohesion and crimp of dyed tops and it is today often also used in first combing, particularly if chain gills are to be used subsequently. Recombing is carried out after top-dyeing, when fibre blends are involved and also when producing high quality tops, and is particularly important when spinning fine high quality weaving yarns (25 tex and finer). In fact, recombing is increasingly being regarded as a cost-effective means of improving spinning and weaving efficiencies and improving fine yarn and fabric quality in terms of yarn faults (neps and slubs). In the case of pure wool, a recombing line typically has four operations, two preparatory gillings preceding combing (often three in the case of dyed tops and four where different fibre types and colours are involved). Combing is followed by two finisher gillings, the chain gill increasingly being preferred. Six operations are typical for wool/polyester blends. The two gillings prior to recombing are aimed at improving fibre alignment, thereby reducing noil, as well as achieving the correct fibre regain and sliver linear density (weight). The first finishing gill after recombing needs to randomize the fibre ends, which have been aligned at the comb, so as to facilitate subsequent drafting. On modern combs, recombing production (kg/hr) for ecru wool is around 2.3 times the mean fibre diameter of the wool being processed. Noil produced during recombing varies from about 2 to 5%, depending upon factors such as the degree of entanglement of the top.
Mechanical processing for yarn production
175
6.2.7 Top finishing (finisher gilling) Top finishing refers to the ‘finisher’ gilling operations (generally two) subsequent to combing. Combing aligns the leading ends of the fibres, which adversely affects the sliver cohesion and subsequent processing. One of the main objectives of finisher gilling is to again randomise the leading fibre ends by drafting. Additional objectives are further blending, straightening and aligning of the fibres, the addition of moisture (and oil) according to the trade allowances and producing a top of the required linear density and evenness. A sliver (top) that is uniform in its linear density (weight per unit length) is produced and formed into a ball or bump top of specified size and weight. The main actions are drafting and doubling with pin control. Normally, the first finisher operation (gill box) has an autoleveller unit.The first gilling operation generally involves up to 30 doublings and drafts of between 5 and 10, with the second only involving around 4 or 5 doublings.
6.2.8 Prediction of top properties A quality specification for tops could include the following:25 • • • • • • • • • • • • •
Mean fibre diameter Fibre diameter distribution (e.g. CV and Coarse Edge) Minimum (or mean) fibre length (Hauteur) Fibre length distribution (e.g. Max CV and Short Fibres) Oil (extractable or total fatty matter) content (IWTO value is 1%, but normally around 0.7% for dry-combed tops) Moisture content (18.25% IWTO) Colour Maximum coloured (dark) fibres (e.g. 100/kg) Neps and vegetable matter content Linear density Evenness Ash content pH
Considerable experimental work has been done at the CSIR in South Africa26 and the CSIRO in Australia to quantify the effects of raw wool properties on top properties. These studies have led to empirical equations (e.g. CSIRO TEAM formulae) being derived that quantitatively relate the top properties, such as Hauteur, to those of the raw or greasy wool. Two examples are given for purposes of illustration:
176
Wool: Science and technology
CSIR (SAWTRI)27 Hauteur (mm ) = 1.89 ¥ SL - 0.075 ¥ D ¥ Cr + 0.085 ¥ St ¥ D - 0.0048 ¥ SL2 - 0.127SL ¥ Cr + 7.44 ¥ Cr - 39.7 [6.4] where SL = Staple Length (mm) D = Mean Fibre Diameter (mm) Cr = Staple Crimp Frequency (No/cm) St = Style Index CSIRO TEAM Formula28,29 H = 0.52 ¥ SL + 0.47 ¥ SS + 0.95 ¥ D - 0.45 ¥ VM - 0.19 ¥ M - 3.5 [6.5] CV(H) = 0.12 ¥ SL - 0.41 ¥ SS - 0.35 ¥ D + 0.20 ¥ M + 49.3
[6.6]
Noil (%) = -0.11 ¥ SL - 0.14 ¥ SS - 0.35 ¥ D + 0.94 ¥ VM + 27.7 [6.7] 2
Ï CV(H) ˆ ¸ Barbe (mm ) = Hauteur Ì1+ Ê Ë 100 ¯ ˝˛ Ó
[6.8]
where H = Hauteur (mm) CV(H) = CV of Hauteur (%) SL = Staple Length (mm) SS = Staple Strength (N/ktex) D = Mean Fibre Diameter (mm) VM = Vegetable Matter Base (%) M = Adjusted Percentage of Middle Breaks, which is given the value of 45 when M < 45% and the actual value when M > 45% Noil = Romaine The constant of 3.5 in eq. [6.5] can be adjusted according to the mill specific conditions. Also
H= where
1.17 ¥ SL 1+ p
[6.9]
eY 1+ e Y
[6.10]
p=
Y = 0.561 - 0.113 ¥ D + 0.0276 ¥ SL - 0.0331 ¥ SS + 0.0125 ¥ M
[6.11]
and 1 - p is the probability that a fibre will not break during processing.
Mechanical processing for yarn production
177
Another formula, requiring a computer program, also provides a measure of fibre length distribution.28,29 The work carried out at the CSIRO led to the development of the Sirolan-TOPSpec processing prediction software,30 which allows Hauteur, CV(H), Noil, short and long fibres and the shape of the fibre length distribution graph to be predicted from the raw wool test results for mean fibre diameter, VM base, staple length, staple strength and the position of staple break. A Topmaker System software was also developed; this also includes a Topmaker Data Management Program.31 These have now been combined in the Topspin computer program, which can be used to predict and model an infinite array of performance and costs for greasy wool, tops and yarn. It is PC-based and can be configured for network. The Internet-based program can be licensed (desk-top licensing model). Generally, Merino type tops for the pastel trade are expected to have fewer than 100 dark fibres per kilogram to be deemed ‘commercially free from dark fibre’. Longree and Delfosse32 reported on the latest results obtained with the Optalyser measurement of dark fibre and other contaminants, including neps, in wool tops. The Optalyser is an instrument that automatically measures and grades into different classes, coloured fibres, neps and vegetable matter particles in wool tops.
6.3
Preparation for spinning (drawing)
Although direct spinning of sliver into relatively coarse yarn is carried out on the semi-worsted system, thereby eliminating intermediate stages such as the roving stage, this requires high drafts, precise drafting and also good fibre control. Nevertheless, it is not yet possible to spin good quality and relatively fine yarn in this manner, partly because it eliminates the beneficial effects of sliver feed reversal and doubling. A sequence of processes, called drawing, is required to gradually and in a controlled manner, through a process of drafting, reduce the sliver linear density while controlling the movement and alignment of the fibres and the sliver linear density and evenness. This enables a roving (twisted or twistless) to be produced, of the linear density and evenness required for the efficient spinning of a yarn of the desired linear density and quality. Worsted drawing is the process of converting the top into a roving suitable for spinning, this also being referred to as ‘preparation for spinning’. Within the present context, drawing can be defined as the series of operations involving doubling and drafting, the machines which work together for this purpose being called the ‘drawing set’.1 Drafting essentially involves two sets of rollers that run at different surface speeds, the surface speed of the front rollers (delivery) being higher than that of the back (feed) rollers. The ratio of the surface speed of the
178
Wool: Science and technology
delivery rollers to that of the feed rollers represents the numerical draft. The difference in surface speed causes the fibres to slide past one another, thereby reducing the number of fibres in the sliver cross section and its linear density correspondingly. It also helps to align the fibres. The distance between the nips of the front and back rollers is termed the ratch. The amount of draft which can be applied at any one stage is dependent upon the degree of fibre control, and can vary from as low as four to over 25, there generally being an optimum draft, depending upon the fibres and type of system used. The fibres that are not held by either the front roller nip or the back roller nip are called floating fibres; these fibres are not positively controlled, being controlled only by the frictional forces of adjacent fibres. It is these uncontrolled floating fibres that prevent perfect drafting (i.e. where the random fibre arrangement is preserved). Various techniques are used to improve control over the floating fibres, including additives to increase interfibre friction, pins, twist and direct pressure (e.g. double aprons) and certain combinations of these. Most commonly, pins are used to control the fibres during the early stage of drawing and aprons during the final stages, pinned drafting systems generally being able to handle heavier loads and delivery than apron drafting systems (whereas the latter can handle higher drafts). Accurate settings on apron drafting systems are generally also more critical than on pinned drafting systems because the latter tend to be a more ‘tolerant’. Although drafting is an effective means of aligning the fibres and reducing sliver linear density, it increases sliver unevenness. This problem is overcome by combining the actions of doubling and drafting. Doubling is the action of combining (feeding) two or more slivers into a drafting zone, which results in a more even output sliver. If no draft is applied, the irregularity of the output sliver equals that of the input sliver divided by the square root of the number of input slivers, assuming all input slivers have the same linear density. Nevertheless, to achieve the main objective of drawing, namely to reduce the sliver linear density, the overall draft needs to exceed the number of doublings. Typically, four operations, more for finer yarns and for finer and shorter wools, are used – for example, three gillings (e.g. screw or chain gills) and one roving. Factors, such as lower drafts, individual fibre movement, parallel fibres, fibre control, good lubrication and fewer short fibres, contribute towards good roller drafting and evenness of the drafted material. The reversal of the slivers, and consequently also the direction of fibre hooks, improves fibre randomisation during roller drafting and the removal of fibre hooks. This reduces the short-term irregularity of the sliver. Autolevellers, introduced in the early 1950s, are used to improve the evenness of slivers by measuring the sliver thickness/linear density variation and then continuously altering the draft in such a way that more draft is applied to the thicker than to the thinner sections. Autolevellers, using
Mechanical processing for yarn production
179
2 Rovings crosswound on bobbin
Drafting assembly
Rubbing assembly
Winding assembly
6.7 Rubbing Frame. [From Grosberg and Iype.33]
either mechanical or electronic measurement and draft control systems, can correct short, medium and long term variations, including the mean sliver linear density. The final stage of spinning preparation is the roving or finisher stage. The roving is given the required cohesion, either by inserting low levels of twist (flyer) or, more commonly, by a twistless rubbing action (rubbing-frame), illustrated in Fig. 6.7.33 In the case of the production of twisted rovings, the sliver is generally drafted using an apron drafting system, after which twist is inserted by means of a flyer that inserts one turn of twist per revolution. The twisted roving is then wound onto the bobbin, which rotates with a higher surface speed than the flyer. The flyer also avoids balloon formation and any adverse effect on the fibre assembly due to air currents. Electronic flyer roving frames with integrated automatic doffing are amongst the latest developments. In the case of the rubbing-frame, two slivers are normally fed to each drafting head, the strands remaining separate as they are consolidated and given cohesion by means of the oscillating rubbing action of the aprons. The pairs of consolidated rovings are cross-wound onto a double-meche package which is then used to feed two spindles on the spinning frame. In some cases, e.g. for automatic spinning frames, it is also possible to produce a single meche package from a single sliver. Horizontal and vertical rubbing frames are available. High-speed finisher rubbing frames can now also incorporate automatic bobbin doffing (and ticketing) and have spiral guides after the rubbing zone that improve roving cohesion and enable high-speed winding and also trouble-free unwinding on the spinning frame. Electronic
180
Wool: Science and technology
contactless stop motions between the rubbing aprons and winding rollers can be fitted. Suction systems achieve good cleaning. Speeds of up to 275 m/min can be achieved on vertical rubbing frames with one rubbing zone (single pair of aprons), and up to 220 m/min on horizontal rubbing frames. Different drafting systems are also interchangeable. Flyer rovings and rubbed rovings essentially produce yarn of virtually equivalent quality, although the former generally enable higher drafts, fewer end breakages and higher speeds in spinning. However, the capital investment costs for rubbing-frames are considerably lower than for flyer frames and the production higher, while fibre breakage also tends to be lower. The flyer roving frame, which can accommodate heavier packages (bobbins), has certain advantages over the rubbing-frames when processing fibres with low cohesion and crimp, such as mohair and certain coarse wools, and in some cases also when using spinning frames with broken end detectors or automatic pieceners.
6.4
Semi-worsted processing system
The semi-worsted system, developed in the first half of the 20th century mainly for synthetics and blends, essentially consists of carding, gilling and spinning, and, when spinning medium and fine yarns, also a roving process prior to spinning. Raw wools are scoured and dried, opened, blended and lubricated prior to carding. The machinery used is very similar to that employed in worsted processing. This system has production and economic advantages over both the woollen and worsted system, but generally cannot produce yarns of the same fineness, character or quality. The character of semi-worsted yarns is somewhere between that of the worsted and woollen yarns, being bulkier, weaker and less regular than worsted yarns. A flow chart for the Semi-Worsted System is shown in Fig. 6.1, the absence of a combing operation being the main feature that distinguishes it from the Worsted System. The absence of combing and the very high production levels make it economically attractive and suitable for producing relatively coarse yarns (about 50 to 500 tex) destined for certain end-uses, particularly carpets but also upholstery and hand-knitting yarns. Best results are generally obtained with between about 80 and 120 fibres in the yarn cross-section, the latter being more typical. The Semi-Worsted System is used for medium to long, relatively coarse wools and man-made fibres, and it handles fibres with finenesses between about 9 and 16.5 dtex and with mean fibre length ranging roughly between 150 and 75 mm (but generally not shorter than 60 mm, and with 15% or fewer of fibres shorter than 30 mm). The semi-worsted system does not offer the opportunity to remove postcarding short fibres and neps, making the carding operation a very critical
Mechanical processing for yarn production
181
one, nep removal increasing with increasing carding power. The subsequent gilling operations can reduce vegetable matter slightly but can also create neps. The configuration of the high-production semi-worsted cards, which are generally covered with rigid metallic wire, depends upon fibre type and characteristics, such as length and fineness, as well as upon the production rate required. A semi-worsted card typically has only one swift, with four or five sets of workers and strippers and usually twin doffers to ensure high production rates.1 Depending upon applications, they can be supplied with morel rollers, a burr roller on the licker-in, with a fancy, with an intermediate doffer and with one or two delivery doffers. Carding is followed by two to three drawing operations, mostly using chain gills, preferably three if no roving operation is involved, so that a majority of trailing hooks enter the spinning frame as leading hooks. The first and/or second passages can be autolevelling. The sliver is then either attenuated further into roving or spun directly on a ring frame, where drafts can be as high as 300 in a multiple (e.g. three) drafting zone, the main drafting taking place in the final double apron drafting zone.34 Correct fibre lubrication, for low fibre-to-metal dynamic friction, good fibre-to-fibre static friction and antistatic properties, is important. The optimum fatty matter content lies between about 0.7 and 1.2%.35 A regain of about 19.5% appears acceptable for carding. Atmospheric conditions of 23 to 24°C and 70 to 75% RH can be regarded as suitable for the processing of wool, while for spinning it is 21 to 25°C and 55 to 60% RH.35 Elliott et al.,35 building upon the work of Richards and Batwin to develop the concept of ‘Total Carding Power’, describe a computer model based upon published empirical and theoretical studies, for simulating the semi-worsted processing of wool, which predicts how changes in scoured wool properties and processing variables affect yarn irregularity, breaking strength and bulk, spinning performance, card waste and card mixing power. They assumed that most fibre breakage occurred when fibres were withdrawn from tufts during opening. Maddever et al.36 reported on an Expert System which can be used to determine a suitable objective blend specification for the manufacture of wool carpet yarn by the woollen or semi-worsted routes, the fibre property specification depending upon the processing route, product specification and technical data.
6.5
Woollen processing system
6.5.1 Introduction The woollen system represents the shortest processing route for staple fibres, essentially entailing only two primary stages, namely carding and spinning, although there is an important preliminary stage involving blend-
182
Wool: Science and technology
ing, opening and lubrication. Yarns ranging in linear density from about 30 to 2000 tex can be spun on the woollen system. A woollen yarn is defined37,38 as a yarn made from any fibre processed on a card with at least two parts, and at least one intermediate feed, a condenser dividing the card web into slubbings or rovings, which are subsequently spun at drafts of up to 1.6 (or at most 2). Because spinning follows immediately after carding, the fibres are not very well aligned, and woollen yarns tend to be characterised by their bulkiness, low density, less orientated fibres, softness, low twist and hairiness. A ‘woollen yarn’ would normally refer to 100% wool, whereas a ‘woollen-spun yarn’ would refer to a yarn spun on the woollen system but which contains other fibres. Virgin wool represents a relatively low proportion of the total fibres processed world-wide on the woollen system, the bulk being materials such as noils, re-used and reprocessed wools, man-made fibres, cotton etc. It is a very versatile system and represents one of the major systems for processing noils and other forms of fibre waste and recovered fibres into yarn, although capital and labour costs relative to its productivity impact negatively on its competitive position, particularly for medium to fine yarns. The continuing trend towards lighter-weight fabrics has also impacted negatively on the woollen system, although the move towards a more informal or casual form of dress favours it. Purely from an economic point of view, woollen processing compares unfavourably with semi-worsted processing. Nevertheless, these systems generally process widely different fibres and also produce yarns very different in character.The advantage of the woollen system is that it can handle natural and man-made fibres of almost any type, fineness and length, it being stated that any fibre can be processed, ‘provided it has two ends’. In the case of wool, the woollen system handles from lambswool, 19 mm or even finer, to Shetland and crossbred wools 35 mm and coarser. In the main, fibres ranging in mean fibre length from about 25 to 80 mm33 are processed on the woollen system. The wool processed on the woollen system is also referred to as carding wools (e.g. crutchings, locks, lambs and skirtings), generally having staple lengths ranging from about 30 to 50 mm. Woollen carding generally requires a low level of vegetable matter, vegetable matter adversely affecting carding and spinning, and it is important that only wool with little, if any, vegetable matter is processed on this system. This can be achieved by carbonising, a large proportion of wool processed on the woollen system being carbonised. Atmospheric conditions of 65% RH and 20°C are normally acceptable for processing wool on this system.
6.5.2 Pre-carding Good opening and cleaning of the wool prior to carding are beneficial, the pre-carding operation generally involving blending, opening (willeying) and
Mechanical processing for yarn production
183
lubrication (oiling and antistatics). The blending operation, crucial for achieving quality woollen yarns and products, can be either manual or automatic, generally employing ‘sandwich’ (horizontal) layers and ‘vertical slice’ removal. Bin blending is still widely used for wool although various improved feeding and bin-emptying methods (e.g. automatic and continuous) have been introduced, with continuous inclined step blenders of increasing importance. It is vital that the components of the blend be similar in their degree of openness, composition and density. WRONZ applied the concept of linear programming (computer blending) for optimising wool blends for spinning carpet yarns, taking into consideration the relevant wool characteristics, such as diameter, length, bulk, medullation, colour and vegetable matter content.39 The Fearnought (coarse metallic toothed roller) type of machine, automatic or hand-fed, for example, is widely used for opening and blending, particularly at the final willeying (opening) stage prior to carding. It imparts a carding (fibre working) action, tufts being partially opened by the action of the fast moving cylinder and slower moving worker teeth, there often being four workers. Some fibre cleaning also takes place. Oiling/lubrication, generally takes place here, preferably at the exit, which is more effective, does not lead to the contamination of the Fearnought and does not interfere with its cleaning efficiency.
6.5.3 Lubrication (oiling) The effectiveness and efficiency of woollen carding, and in particular fibre breakage, are dependent upon various factors, notably fibre lubrication. It is critically important that the wool is optimally lubricated prior to carding in order to minimize fibre breakage, fly waste and static electricity, provide additional fibre cohesion and facilitate drafting, condensing and spinning. Between about 5 and 10% of oil is usually applied, either as a straight oil or preferably a 50/50 oil/water emulsion, the card generally being key in the even distribution of the lubricants/additives. Lubricants are used to:40 • • • •
Reduce static, fibre breakage and friction against the condenser rubber Lubricate the fibres for drawing and twisting Increase fibre cohesion Control the rate of build-up of trash on the card.
The essential requirements of a wool lubricant are as follows: • • •
Must have good lubrication and anti-static characteristics in carding and spinning within the temperature ranges experienced Should not discolour the wool Should not impair the strength of the fibre
184 • • • • • • •
Wool: Science and technology
Must not cause rusting or corrosion of the clothing (surfaces) with which it comes into contact Should not reduce the life-span of the leather aprons or condenser tapes Should form a stable and uniform emulsion with soft or moderately hard water Must remain stable in storage under various conditions of temperature Must be easily removed by scouring Should not cause or support spontaneous combustion Should not have or create an objectionable odour.
A further requirement today is that the lubricants should be environmentally friendly (e.g. bio-degradeable).
6.5.4 Carding Because of the very shortness of the woollen processing route, the carding stage is critical and the woollen card is very sophisticated, particularly when relatively fine yarns are being produced. The card web needs to be uniform, both in terms of fibre blend and density (mass), across its width and along its length. The card needs to separate (individualise) and mix the fibres and this requirement largely determines the number of carding units.42 The production of a woollen card is greatly dependent upon its width, which can vary from 1 to 4 m (typically around 3 m), and the fineness of the fibre being processed, increasing the card production rate tending to cause a deterioration in slubbing and yarn quality and neppiness. Neps increase as the wool becomes finer, carding rate increases and number of swifts decrease. Over the years there has been little real improvement in the basic productivity of the worker, stripper, swift and doffer actions, increased production largely coming from the increased width of the card. Uniform feed, by a feed hopper, to the card is very important in terms of productivity and web and yarn quality, notably evenness. Feed can be manual, semi-automatic or automatic. The hopper feeds the tufts of fibres to the card, the aim being as uniform a feed of fibres as possible (in terms of both composition and weight), often achieved by weighing or otherwise monitoring and controlling the tufts and their rate of supply to the card. Automatic hopper feeds can provide either ‘weigh’ (gravimetric) or volumetric ‘chute’ delivery, with or without control systems, the latter entailing monitoring, correcting and controlling. There has been a significant move to chute feed-hoppers, hopper-fed via spiked lattice or automatically from a bin. Examples of advanced feed control systems are the Tathams Microweigh 2000 system for a weigh hopper feed and the Microfeed 2000 and HDB Servolap for volumetric chute hopper feeds. Double hoppers, microprocessor-controlled hoppers and volumetric feeds with autolevellers
Mechanical processing for yarn production Feed section
Scribbler
To carder
185
Peralta rollers Swift Doffer
Swift Doffer
Swift Doffer
Condenser Carder From scribbler
Slubbing on bobbins
Swift Doffer
Swift Doffer
6.8 Woollen card. [From Grosberg and Iype.33]
provide good long-term evenness, although some medium- and short-term variation remains.41 The composition of the woollen card (Fig. 6.8) depends upon the type of fibres to be processed, as well as the range of yarn linear densities to be produced, the card generally consisting of between two and seven units, typically four, each with a swift. The two-card set, with an intermediate feed, is becoming increasingly popular. The major differences between woollen carding sets are as follows: • • • • • •
Number of Sections Number of Swifts Number of Workers per Swift Type of Intermediate Feed Type of Condenser Type of Card Clothing
As shown in Fig. 6.8, a typical woollen card essentially consists of two parts or sections, namely the scribbler (breaker card) and carder (finisher card), there typically being two or three cylinders (swifts), each with a doffer (and four or five pairs of worker and stripper rollers each) in each section. The density of card clothing pinning increases along the machine, thereby increasing the opening of the fibre tufts correspondingly. Typically, the carding unit is made up of a breast section clothed with metallic wire with two workers and strippers; this is where the opening and disentangling of tufts commences. From the scribbler the sliver is fed, crosslapped (cross-
186
Wool: Science and technology
fed) to improve blending, to the next section, i.e. to the carder. Various combinations of metallic and flexible card wire are supplied with woollen cards, the combinations depending upon the nature of the fibre being processed. Because of the high levels of oil used, flexible wire clothing, as opposed to metallic wire, was traditionally used on woollen cards, but there has been a significant move towards rigid metallic wire (garnett) clothing, the early part of the card (feed and breast sections) having been metallic for many years. Metallic wire is used extensively for synthetics and well-scoured coarse wools, semi-rigid or fillet wire being more popular for relatively ‘greasy’ and fine wools, although even in the case of fine wools there is a move towards metallic wire, particularly for the scribbler section (A G Brydon, private communication). After the scribbler, the fibrous web can be passed through crush (‘Peralta’) rollers. The Peralta hardened steel rollers (precision ground and perfectly set) at the end of the scribbler section, crush vegetable matter, such as burr, in the open fibre web, the smaller crushed particles being easier to remove. The much finer fibres are not damaged to any significant extent. On a woollen card there are typically around 15 to 30 positions where a carding or working action (closely set point-to-point) takes place, which breaks down the tufts into individual fibres, a typical fibre passing through such an action between 100 and 300 times.42 Fibre separation (working) generally takes place where two card-clothed surfaces, set closely to each other and the teeth pointing towards each other, move at different speeds. The stripping action occurs when a faster moving roller, with the clothing tips pointing in the direction of movement, removes all the fibres from the backs of the teeth of a slower moving roller. Fibre opening takes place at the interfaces between the feedrollers and licker-in, the swift and the workers, and the doffer and swift, being completed when the fibre reaches the last swift of the scribbler section. The main opening at the swift–worker interface is due to the combing action of the swift wires on the tufts of fibres held by the slower moving workers. Work by WRONZ43,44 has modelled fibre breakage on the basis of fibre tensile properties and the mechanics of tuft opening. In addition to fibre separation, during which process significant fibre breakage takes place, the carding operation is also crucial for blending (mixing) the fibres, the collecting power of the doffer playing an important role in this respect. According to Richards,45 the Delay Factor (D), or time constant, which is a measure of the average time that fibres take to pass through a part (excluding time on doffers), may be calculated as follows: Ê ˆ D (Delay Factor) = 1 f Á 1 + Â np 1 - p˜ Ë ¯
[6.12]
Mechanical processing for yarn production
187
where f = collecting fraction of the doffer p = collecting fraction of the worker n = number of swift revolutions during which the fibre spends on a worker, stripper and swift from when it is picked up until it is released again. In the case of four workers this becomes: 4 np ˆ D = 1 f Ê1 + Ë 1 - p¯ Ê ˆ C (Carding Power) = 1 f Á 1 + Â 1 1 - p˜ Ë ¯ C, a measure of the card–opening ability and determined by the average number of times a fibre passes through the setting region between swift and workers and swift and doffer, is the same as the average number of workings (t) received by a fibre as derived by Montfort.46 Carding power increases as the delay factor increases. The Intermediate feed (intermittent or continuous) transfers the output of the one carding machine (section) to the next, the objectives being: • • • •
to convert the fibres emerging from the one carding section into a convenient form for transfer to the next carding machine or section to reduce irregularities in the rate of flow of fibres through the card to improve fibre blending to produce a uniform shade where fibres of different colours are involved
Examples of the different types or combinations of feeds are: • • • • •
Pull-away Centre-Draw and Cross Feed Wide Side-Draw and Cross Feed Pull-away Centre-Draw Scotch Feed (finer yarns) Parallel-Fibre Feed (bulkier fibre and coarser yarns)
The pull-away centre-draw, reciprocating overhead and Scotch feed is considered to offer a simple, yet effective, operation. The Scotch feed is popular as it is simple, versatile and convenient for small lots. The wider cards have resulted in a move away from the side-draw Scotch feed system to centre-draw cross-feed and broad-band or parallel-fibre feed systems. The Condenser divides the web of fibres emerging from the last (final) carding machine into a number of continuous ribbons, consolidates these ribbons into cylindrical, twistless slubbings and winds the slubbings onto individual cheeses positioned side by side on condenser bobbins (posi-
188
Wool: Science and technology
tioned in a creel) for transfer to the spinning frame. There are two different methods of condensing, namely by Ring Doffers or by Tape Condensers, the latter being more common. Ring Doffers (single or double) separate the web into ribbons by a carding action, producing strong, straight and uniform slubbings while Tape Condensers (Series or Endless) separate the web into ribbons by a tearing action. Tape condensers can be offered with single (fine yarn), tandem/double (medium yarns), or triple (coarse yarns) rub arrangements. Tape condensers are generally manufactured with four or six heights (tiers), the latter increasing the production and number of ends, or the end spacing, and package size. Condenser rubbing leathers, used for condensing the narrow strip of materials, are made in various designs; leather aprons have largely been replaced by either grooved or smooth fabric/rubber/ synthetic aprons. A well-rubbed slubbing has good cohesion and wraps onto the condenser bobbin well and unwinds easily and cleanly during spinning, different creel assemblies being used for mule spinning and ring spinning creel assemblies including Ordinary, Traverse and Tandem. Doffing of the condenser bobbins can be either manual or automatic, being one of the most costly operations in woollen processing. Automatic doffing can increase card productivity by up to 12%. Two systems are available to increase the length of slubbings (by up to 50%) on the condenser spool, thereby extending the time cards, and spinning frames can run between creel changes. They are the Tathams Denspak Creel System and the High Density Spooling (HDS) System. The latter was first shown at ITMA in 1987, utilising friction in a groove and a difference in the surface speed of the bobbin/spool and the rubbing apron to create controlled tension and drafts (about 6% actual), enabling increased card production. It also has a beneficial effect on spinning performance and yarn properties. Optical- and capacitance-based devices are used to automatically monitor the evenness of the slubbings or rovings at the output of the card, between the rub apron and the package. One such system (Rovingtex), using a capacitance measuring system, has an alarm should the values exceed preset limits. Open and closed loop automatic controllers are used to correct variations in card web mass per unit area. Automatic setting of the machine when changing slubbing weight (linear density) is also available. The use of electronics for control and automation has been one of the main areas of development, it now being possible to electronically programme and control the main functions of the woollen card. Significant fibre breakage takes place during carding, the amount of fibre breakage depending upon factors such as fibre entanglement, fibre lubrication (friction), fibre strength, fibre length, fibre crimp, fibre regain and the severity of the carding action.
Mechanical processing for yarn production
189
6.5.5 Woollen spinning* Although ring frames dominate woollen spinning, the mule frame still occupies an important position. The ring frame produces about 2.5 times per spindle more than the mule frame and occupies about a third of the floorspace per spindle. The mule can, however, spin lower twist, bulkier, softer, more even and less hairy yarn, and can handle more difficult fibres and blends than the ring frame. Mule spinning enables finer yarns to be spun than ring spinning, due to the lower tensions involved and the advantages of spindle drafting over roller drafting, drafts often being about 5% higher. Mule spinning, however, is more labour intensive and requires greater operator skills than ring spinning. It is generally accepted that commercial woollen spinning limits are about 100 fibres (125 being more typical) in the yarn cross-section, compared to 40 for worsted spinning, Lee22 suggesting a minimum of 120 per strand for two-ply yarn and 200 for singles yarn. In woollen spinning, draft (normally at least 1.2 but less than 1.6, with a maximum of 2) is usually effected against twist, its main function being to straighten rather than to relatively displace the fibres.
6.5.5.1 Ring spinning A false twist device in the drafting zone close to the front rollers, inserting about 80 to 160 turns/m (typically 40% of the spindle speed), reduces the strand irregularity by preferentially drafting thick places with low twist, since twist generally runs into thinner places thereby increasing inter-fibre cohesion. Drafting is affected