Women and Stepfamilies
In the series WOMEN IN THE POLITICAL ECONOMY, edited by Ronnie J. Steinberg
Women and
Stepf...
46 downloads
2758 Views
12MB Size
Report
This content was uploaded by our users and we assume good faith they have the permission to share this book. If you own the copyright to this book and it is wrongfully on our website, we offer a simple DMCA procedure to remove your content from our site. Start by pressing the button below!
Report copyright / DMCA form
Women and Stepfamilies
In the series WOMEN IN THE POLITICAL ECONOMY, edited by Ronnie J. Steinberg
Women and
Stepfamilies Voices of Anger and Love Edited by Nan Bauer Maglin and Nancy Schniedewind
IiiiiiJ Temple University Press g Philadelphia
Temple University Press, Philadelphia 19122 Copyright © 1989 by Nan Bauer Maglin and Nancy Schniedewind All rights reserved Published 1989 Printed in the United States of America The paper used in this publication meets the minimum requirements of American National Standard for Information Sciences-Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, ANSI Z39.48-1984 Library of Congress Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Women and stepfamilies : voices of anger and love / edited by Nan Bauer Maglin and Nancy Schniedewind. p. cm. - (Women in the political economy) Bibliography: p. Includes index. ISBN 0-87722-586-9 (alk. paper) I. Stepfamilies-United States-Case studies. 2. StepmothersUnited States-Case studies. 3. Intergenerational relationsUnited States-Case studies. I. Maglin, Nan Bauer. II. Schniedewind, Nancy, 1947III. Series. HQ759·9 2 .W66 19 8 9 306.8'7-dcI9 88- 11 7 19 CIP
Contents Preface
IX
Introduction
I
Part I. Perspectives Stepmothers I. CHRISTINE BRYSON
"Letters from a Custodial
Stepmother', "Ten Times Harder: Becoming a Stepmother" ANDREA STARR ALONZO "My Extended Family" CAROL ASCHER "Stepmother" DEBORAH ROSENFELT "benjamin" SOPHIA CARESTIA "Parenting on the Edge" GALE MCGOVERN "The Barbie Doll Fight" HELANE LEVINE-KEATING "Second Wife: Eleven Poems" ALICE NEUFELD "One Step Away from Mother: A Stepmother's Story" HELANE LEVINE-KEATING "The Envious Heart"
2. SUZANNE L. BUNKERS
3. 4. 5. 6. 7. 8. 9. 10.
29 38 44 51
53 59
77 93
Mothers I I. SHEILA ALSON
12. YANDRA SOLIZ
"Only My Favorite Mommy" "A Rainbow Family in the Deep
South"
97 106
13.
WILMA WOLFENSTEIN
III
14.
MORGAN DAVID
126
"The Step-Wedding" "Daisy Chain"
Stepdaughters
"Lizzie's Axe" "Mementos" "Stealing Clothes from My
15. HELANE LEVINE-KEATING 16. KATHY CHAMBERLAIN 17. ALISON TOWNSEND
Stepmother"
13 1 133
Contents 18. BERENICE LOPEZ "The Woman and Her Past" 19. Reminiscences by O.C., edited by YVONNE STAM
" 'Whose Side Are You on Anyway?': A Stepdaughter Ponders the Unanswerable" 20. ALISON TOWNSEND "The Mother Who Is Not the Mother But Is" 21. ELISA DAVILA "Name and Shelter Made Me Homeless: Notes from an Interview with a Latina Stepdaughter" 22. SHIRLEY GEOK-LIN LIM "When East Meets West: Second Mothers and Abandoned Daughters" 23. ERIN MARIE HETTINGA "What Really Is a 'Normal' Family?"
142
144 151
156 162
170
Stepgrandmothers 24.
JUANITA R. HOWARD
"I'm My Own Step-
grandma" 25.
175
JUDITH HOCKING HIGGS
"From Dutiful Daughter
to Stepgrandmother"
183
Part II. Stepping Out 26.
ELIZABETH KAMARCK MINNICH
"Choosing
Consciousness" KATHLEEN DUNN "Cross-Sex Stepparenting: A Personal Essay" 28. JUDITH GRANT "The New Family and the Old Ideology" 29. MARGARET WADE-LEWIS "The Strengths of African-American Stepfamilies" 30. HEDVA LEWITTES "Grown-up Steps: Reflections on Two Generations of Stepmothers and Their Adult Stepdaughters" 3 I. DYMPNA C. CALLAGHAN "Working-Class Mothering and the Problem of Weaning"
27.
32.
NAN BAUER MAGLIN
2I
4
225
234 245
"Reading Stepfamily
Fiction" Part III. Transforming-Both Within and Without 33. CONNIE MILLER "Lesbian Stepfamilies and the Myth of Biological Motherhood" 34. BARBARA DRUCKER "Less Than a Mother-More Than a Friend"
VI
202
254
279 28 I 288
Contents 35.
DEE, WENDY, and Step Parenting"
VIIVI-ANN SHIRLEY
"Step-by-
"My Wife-in-Law and Me: Reflections on a Joint-Custody Stepparenting Relationship" 37. NANCY SCHNIEDEWIND "There for Each Other: A Stepmothers' Support Group" 38. CATHARINE R. STIMPSON "The Company of Children" 36.
293
SARAH TURNER
Contributors
3 10
3 21 333 34 1
Vll
Preface Women and Stepfamilies: Voices of Anger and Love began with our own personal experiences. After several years of gathering, it has grown from our two stories to many women's stories. We start by sharing our own stepfamily "tales."
I have been in a stepfamily now for six years. My daughter from my previous marriage was adopted from Colombia; she is now ten years old. My stepdaughters, Heather and Seana, twenty-three and twenty-four, are the biological children of my husband, Chris, and his ex-wife; they both are in school in New Jersey. My stepson, Joshua (sixteen), who is black, was adopted by Chris and his ex-wife when he was a month old. He lives in New Jersey with his mother, stepfather, and half-sister; my two stepdaughters are there much of the time. Chris and I live in Brooklyn in a brownstone. I share custody of my daughter with my ex-husband, who lives upstairs in the brownstone. My daughter alternates days and nights, upstairs and downstairs. Chris drives to New Jersey in the middle of the week and twice on the weekends to see Josh, more frequently when Josh's basketball or baseball team has a game. Chris and I are both full-time academics. One obvious problem for my stepfamily is time: how to apportion it, how to find enough of it for all the various segments of this two-state family configuration, and how to steal some for anything else. Another problem is money: there are many pressing needs and not all can be satisfied. One of the obvious pluses, given the variety in my extended family, is the richness in backgrounds and interests of its members. Joining my New York-urban-Jewish-radical milieu with Chris's working-class-Kansan-louisianan-WASP past, and both with the upper-middle-class urbansuburban intellectual ambience of our current families, has led to tensions and adjustments, but also to growth on everyone's part. Such diversity seems to be common to many stepfamilies. So also must be the difficult road of accepting that diversity.
NAN:
IX
Preface Particularly troubling for me in the beginning years of our stepfamily was the image of the "good mother" and the stereotype of the "wicked stepmother." This concern hit me most sharply in 1984 when we moved to New Jersey so that Chris could have a year near his children. The move brought up a lot of fears and anxiety in me. We would be a few blocks away from his ex-wife, their mother. We were moving to the suburbs where, at least in my memory and fantasies, mothers were mothers in the typical white, middle-class, nuclear-family way. I had waited to become a mother until, after years in the feminist movement, I had sufficiently come to terms with that institution so that I could approach it somewhat freer of its traditional constraints-working full time, not cooking much, sharing parenting and household chores, retaining my closeness to my women's group and women friends, remaining political. But when (at age 40) I joined my family with Chris's family I felt the presence of a "real" mother hovering over my life. I felt I had to compete with this presence-even though no one asked it of me. Certainly not Chris, who after five years as a single father, had redefined his earlier, more traditional ideas about marriages. Not his daughters; they were grown and didn't need my mothering (they never requested, for example, that I bake an apple pie). Nevertheless I believed that the children expected this traditional role and therefore saw me not as Nan but as inadequate mother (and inadequate wife to their father). I responded by overreacting in various ways: by refusing to wife or mother at all, being silent, or being aggressively militant about who I was. Trying to remain free of the "perfect mother" image, I inadvertently moved dangerously close to the "wicked stepmother." Fortunately for us all, our personal histories also held the possibilities of some positive adjustments. For instance, Chris and I did not fall into traditional roles, partly because I had abdicated the traditional female one and partly because as a single father he had tried to become more of an active parent than he had been in his marriage. We also learned from each other very different and complementary styles of parenting and stepparenting; while I began to provide a more structured and scheduled pattern to the non-custodial parent-child relationship Chris and his children struggled with, he provided a warmth and immediacy of "mothering" for my daughter. Style, of course, is not the answer to everything. Money remains an issue for us, as it does for most stepfamilies. And I continue to wrestle with the question of what it means to be a feminist stepmother to a teenage boy. However, what I see for my stepfamily is that our mixing, if not our "perfect blending," has created alternative images of relationships and roles that were not there in our previous families.
x
Preface Once, when my four-year-old son Jesse and I were having dinner together, he looked up at me with a serious expression and asked, "Are you Noelle's mother?" I explained to him that Noelle had another mother and I was her stepmother. His big blue eyes opened wide and, looking at me with an expression of utter incredulity, he exclaimed, "You're the evil stepmother? !" His ongoing experience of my love was suddenly negated by the cultural power of that word. The fact that my child, who in his four short years of life had never been read the classic fairytales at home, already "knew" about stepmothers, brought home to me even greater appreciation of my struggle for personhood in a stepfamily . My experience as a stepmother has essentially been enriching. Both my stepchildren-Dave, twenty-two, and Noelle, nineteen-and their father, Dave, are grounded, caring, and spirited people. In our fifteen years together, I have fond memories of many joyful times, from adventuring on camping trips to enjoying creatively conceived meals. I have appreciated their contributions to the varied endeavors of our lives, from household job sharing to valuable ideas and artwork that are part of my books. I have taken pride in their many accomplishments, from Noelle's blue ribbon at the county fair horse show to Dave's sensitivity and patience while tutoring a fourth-grade peer. My experience as a stepmother has also been marked by pain, resentment, alienation, and confusion. Some of these feelings were generated by the contradictions between my feminism and the realities of living in a stepfamily. One of my goals as a feminist has been the equitable sharing of power and responsibility in institutions and relationships. In my stepfamily, decisions were often made about my life over which I had little power, yet I had to live with the consequences. For example, on several occasions a phone call from Dave's former wife would bring in its wake the unexpected arrival, for the next six months to a year, of two children and a dog into living spaces designed for two people. With their presence came responsibility but little power, a dynamic that debilitates in any situation. I felt hurt and angered by what seemed such ongoing accommodations to the needs of stepchildren, even though they lived with us part-time. I often felt boxed in, both physically and psychologically. Consequently I sometimes distanced myself from my stepchildren in order to help salvage a vestige of personal power. Although I sought family as a place of both autonomy and community, sometimes alienation set in: being "in" meant losing my sense of self, but being "out" meant separation from others. Becoming a stepmother as a young, energetic woman, I sensed early on
NANCY:
Xl
Preface the importance of retaining my selfhood by "stepping out." When I did "step out," I experienced considerable guilt and confusion at the time. In retrospect I understand that my feminism, commitment to work, and independent personality helped me set boundaries on my mothering. I maintained parenting and nonparenting parts of myself, although those parts were far from integrated. In our family I saw the physical and psychological division of labor shift from that in a traditional family. The shift was made possible, in part, because of our commitment to nonsexist ideas and the flexible schedules that we had as academics. Dave took on many practical family responsibilities, such as notes to the teacher, new shoes, and arrangements for day camp. He also took on the bulk of the responsibility for responding to the children's emotional needs. I was the backup parent and, at the same time, a significant female adult role model and caregiver. Now, mother to our own five-year-old child, experiencing the enormous practical and psychological responsibilities of full-time parenting, I appreciate that arrangement in our stepfamily even more. Although I write some of this as a retrospective (my stepchildren are in college and no longer living with us), I still experience the bonds of living in a stepfamily. Because Dave has always had financial commitments to his children, and still is encumbered with college costs, he has contributed less to our living costs. I have often given more to our shared expenses, something I resent. The pain of the bonds of my stepfamily go deeper than money, however. I have wanted to have more than one child. Largely because of the time, energy, financial commitment, and ongoing responsibility that Dave has expended over the years for Dave and Noelle, he is unwilling to consider a second child of our own. For me this painful price of living in a stepfamily is ever present. When I reminisce on my years as a stepmother, I tend to focus on some of our worst moments and hardest times. An experience I share with other stepmothers is that of never having been thanked for what we have given as stepmothers, particularly by our stepchildren's biological mothers. While feelings of affection and care that exude appreciation are part of my relationship with Dave, Noelle, and Dave Jr., I have seldom heard them clearly articulate appreciation of my stepmothering. Yet when I talked with them individually, as part of the process of writing this book, each offered surprisingly affirmative feedback and focused on positive experiences. To what extent, I wonder, have stepmothers' internalized feelings of "badness" set us up to filter out that which is good? Having little contact with other women in stepfamilies when my stepchildren were younger, I often felt confused and alone. Slowly I began to understand that re-created families could be places of new forms of con-
xu
Preface nectedness and love. Now that I am part of a broader network of women in stepfamilies, my alienation has lessened. I see now that the way in which we redefined our family, basically with healthy and happy results, has happened for many other stepfamilies as well. My hope for the transforming power of women's experiences in stepfamilies has been strengthened by knowledge of our collective lives.
We are grateful to each other and all the women in the book who have chosen to share their lives here. We want to thank all the many people who helped in the process of putting this collection together, especially Marti Bombyk, and also Quintana, Joshua, Heather, Seana, Chris, Jesse, Noelle, Dave Jr., and Dave. October 29, I9 87
XlII
Introduction We, the editors and writers of Women and Stepfamilies, are all women in stepfamilies or women who have children in stepfamilies. We reflect some of the many experiences of millions of other women like ourselves. 1 This anthology gives voice to the anger and pain, the struggles, the pleasures, and the visions that emerge from our daily lives. We express ourselves in many ways: letters, journals, poems, stories, personal narratives, interviews, and analytic essays. Despite our numbers, this is the first book to focus on the unique and varied experiences and perspectives of women in stepfamilies as told by the women themselves. 2 Listen to the women in Part I, Perspectives, and you are listening in on something very similar to the first stages in the consciousness-raising process that began with the reemergence of the women's movement in the 1970s. We tell our stories, putting ourselves at their center. Read the selections in Part II, Stepping Out, and Part III, Transforming-Both Within and Without, and you are participating in a process similar to the latter stages of consciousness raising: women look at what we have in common as well as our differences; we take our personal stories and understand them in a social context from a variety of feminist perspectives. The pieces you will read are necessarily detailed and complicated, mirroring the complexity of stepfamily life. We use the term stepfamily rather than blended family because blended family assumes integration and hides difference. Rather than blended away, those differences should be acknowledged and respected. Although there have been many feminist analyses of women and the family,3 Women and Stepfamilies adds a new dimension. It looks at women, their partners, and children in second, non-nuclear, nonbiological families. This is particularly important in light of the fact that, as Judith Grant points out, the traditional family (biological father, biological mother, and children) is for many people now a myth. The 1980s, however, have seen the reevocation of the image of that traditional family and an emphasis on biological motherhood. With the increasing privatization of the family in the 1980s, stepfamilies have not undergone the kind of scrutiny that was true of family life in the late 1960s and 1970s. Because of this, women
I
Introduction and children particularly have suffered as they wrestled all alone with myths of family and problems they felt were somehow of their own making. This book allows us to rediscover that the personal is political; that our stepfamily problems are not private ones nor are the solutions totally individual ones. Stepfamilies are no longer totally unrecognized-at least in everyday life-although they are still invisible in legislation, social services policy, and public institutions. In the last few years the publishing industry and the media have represented them; there are support groups nationwide; it is possible to buy greeting cards for several varieties of steppersons. In many cases, however, negative associations still adhere to stepfamilies, especially stepmothers. Three contemporary examples will suffice: 1. The Charmings, a TV series aired in the spring of 1987, updated the Snow White story to a 1980s American suburb, keeping the wicked stepmother. Snow to her husband Eric: "I can't live in the same house with her." Eric: "She's your stepmother." Snow: "She's a witch." Eric: "Yes, but she's family." 2. Dr. Elizabeth Stern (of the Baby M case,4) emphatically rejected the name and role of stepmother: "I do not want to be known as a stepmother. I want to be a legal mother" (New York Times, March 16, 1987). 3. Feminist rewritings of fairytales, while they write the daughter/stepdaughter as an active self-creator rather than a passive victim, often retain the despised and evil stepmother; see some of the tales in Zipes's 1986 collection Don't Bet on the Prince: Contemporary Feminist Fairy Tales in North America and England.
From the many narratives in Women and Stepfamilies, a revised and enlarged picture of women and stepfamilies should emerge for all of us. Women and Stepfamilies reflects the diversity of women's experiences in stepfamilies. Not only does it represent the different positions or roles women hold in stepfamilies and the multiple variations that make up stepfamilies (number and ages of children, distances between parts of the families, and custody arrangements, to name a few), it also includes voices of women from many class, race, ethnic, regional, religious, and educational backgrounds and from different sexual orientations. Of course, we would like even more perspectives. 5 Many women are reluctant to write about their stepfamily situations, even when they are positive. Many of those who did write changed the names of the people involved, and some changed their own name or used only their first name. To write about the so-called private world of the family takes a kind of courage; writing about one's
2
Introduction stepfamily, since it involves so many people, means risking a delicate network of relations. We write to share our stories. We write, as Elizabeth Minnich says, "in this weave of common and different experiences" to uncover "some of the mysteries that still enshroud the real experience of motherhood as personal experience and as institution." We write to deconstruct the dominant myths about families and stepfamilies, to bear witness to our complicated family structures, and, as Catharine Stimpson suggests, to "seek to imagine new communities of intimacy." Women and Stepfamilies is divided into three major sections: "Perspectives," "Stepping Out," and "Transforming-Both Within and Without." Part I, "Perspectives," consists of first-person narratives, interviews, stories, and poems about being in or being related to stepfamilies. The pieces in Part II are written by women who have chosen to step out of the intensity of their emotional lives and the subjective limits of being in families in order to reflect on stepfamily life. In Part III, "Transforming," many of the problems described and the questions raised in the first two sections are recast. These accounts describe stepfamilies that have used some of their feminist understandings to transform themselves, or at least work toward that transformation; some of these accounts offer a communal and social perspective on the functioning of families. Many of the pieces provide a liberating vision and grounds for hope for all women in stepfamilies.
Voices
Before the second wave of feminism in the 1960s and 1970s, families were assumed to have one perspective: that of the man, the so-called head of the household. Now we understand there are many perspectives in one family.6 To those newly rediscovered voices of the "nuclear" family, Women and Stepfamilies adds those of the stepmother, the biological mother, the stepdaughter, the stepsister, and the stepgrandmother in a newer text of the family. All the articles in Women and Stepfamilies are from one or more of these perspectives; in fact the writer is often both a mother and a stepmother, or a daughter, a stepdaughter, and a stepsister. In lesbian stepfamilies the biological mother and the stepmother live together, not in separate families, offering a different perspective than when the biological mother and the stepmother are in two different but overlapping families. All these pieces deal with issues in the common dramas of daily life, most notably issues of love, identity, and power which often manifest them-
3
Introduction selves in struggles over space, time, and money. These issues are more complicated for the stepfamily because they are seldom acted out in one place and the players are seldom limited to just one immediate family. A stepmother appears to be in an almost impossible position-at least until the process of interaction works itself out over years and until the stepmother unravels and resists the compulsory nature of the institution. For some, like Christine Bryson and Suzanne Bunkers, the concern is how to enter the step-relationship in the first place. Bryson's letters communicate a sense of being overwhelmed; she is transformed overnight from a part-time into a full-time stepmother. What to call the stepmother is a repeated issue. Is she co-parent, the other mother, the "f]ommy" (in Clausen's novel Sinking, Stealing), the maid, a friend, a pal, or "slave cousin," as one woman (Wendy) ironically calls herself? Andrea Starr Alonzo does not use her step-title. This, she speculated, is related to her Afro-American heritage where children are valued as wealth, not solely in terms of biological relationships. The stepmother's relation to her stepchildren is another puzzle. Kathleen Dunn, who has a son and a stepson, worries about favoritism. The writings of Carol Ascher, Deborah Rosenfelt, and Kathy Chamberlain ask how the stepmother maintains a relationship with the stepchild without the presence of her partner, the biological parent. Often the father is absent because of divorce, death, or separation. It is a more vexed question for the lesbian stepmother or the nonmarried stepmother. Sophia Carestia describes a stepmother who has infrequent contact with her stepdaughter and finds that contact always mediated first through the biological mother and then the biological father, with whom she lives. "The Barbie Doll Fight" describes the differences stepmothers and mothers have (even when they live together) over the bringing up of the child. Suzanne Bunkers, who was first a stepmother and then a mother, finds being a stepmother "ten times harder." Many of the stepmothers are haunted simultaneously by the images of the wicked stepmother and the perfect (biological) mother. Helane LevineKeating sees the biological mother in the children, in the husband, and in their shared history; Alice Neufeld tries to support her stepdaughter in her hungry desire to make contact with her biological mother. In many ways mothers are the mirror (inverse) images of stepmothers, although stepmothers don't feel that to be true. Mothers worry about who the real mommy is if there is a stepmother and how to relate to this other woman. Sheila Alson records the first weeks of "one particular mother's experience with her children's acquisition of a stepparent." She wants to make contact with the stepmother but finds it hard: "I know none of her reactions. I know only my own and the reactions of my children, at least
4
Introduction those they share with me." "Daisy Chain" underscores further the gulf between mother and stepmother and reaches for that which they have in common: "are we soul sisters or mortal enemies? " In "Step-by-Step Parenting," Dee, the mother, who lives with Wendy, the stepmother, describes how over a period of years, the mother can give up "ownership" of the child and share it with the stepmother, for the benefit of all. In "The StepWedding" the mother and the stepmother act out their familiar roles in old scripts, even though the families have been without contact for years. For children who live with their mother for some time, the arrival of a stepparent (and children) is seen as an intrusion; the mother must mediate between child and new lover (and the lover's family as well). Yandra Soliz says her daughter is angry, not only for being placed in a racially mixed family, but for having other people introduced into the solitary and intimate mother-daughter relationship. Stepdaughters writing here certainly are angry. Lizzie Borden ("Lizzie's Axe") is the archetypal stepdaughter who kills her stepmother and her father. Samantha in the story "Mementos" is angry that her stepmother Lois has, upon her father's death, sold the family home in South Dakota and all their mementos. The story presents voices of both stepmother and stepdaughter. Their differences are most sharply felt around politics and lifestyle. But stepdaughters often want ways to make contact with their stepmothers; the act of going shopping or sharing clothes is charged for these women: "It was to be like you / that I tried all your clothes on." (Alison Townsend). Berenice Lopez and O. C. had differences with their stepfathers. Lopez admits long-pent-up anger toward both her stepfather and father for their indifference and their preference for other children. She had an extended family to comfort her, but it also provided the context of her abuse. O. C. came in conflict with her stepfather's discipline, yet also appreciated the different culture he brought to her mother and her. Stepdaughters express much ambivalence toward the fact of having two "mothers." The title from Alison Townsend's diary entries captures that tension: "The Mother Who Isn't the Mother But Is." The stepdaughter interviewed by Elisa Davila felt herself the cause of internal tensions within two households and between two households. She was an intruder and obstacle both to her stepfather and her stepmother. Shirley Geok-Lin Lim's tension is not only familial but cultural in that expectations of stepmothers are different for Chinese and English culture. In these accounts, stepmothers and stepdaughters live uneasily with each other, although Hedva Lewittes describes three generations of stepwomen who struggle with that relationship through dialogue. For stepsisters, having stepsiblings is often positive, although not without complications. Many of the complications come from outside the fam-
5
Introduction ily. Erin Marie Hettinga says many white people believe her family to be abnormal. She lived with her white mother and black stepfather and his granddaughter, whom she considers her sister. For Hettinga, this complicated and variegated family enriches her life. While stepdaughters and stepsisters frequently express pain, anger, and jealousy in the early years of a stepfamily, in the later years they often come to voice a kind of appreciation for the members of their stepfamilies. One woman who corresponded with us, writes that she learned much as a stepsister from her family "tribe," as she calls it: If both these lessons-learning to relate to those not of my own kind, and learning to accept the human finitude of my parents-are essential lessons of growing up, then having a stepfamily helped me to learn them in a context that was loving, supportive, and never dull. As an adult, I am convinced that my relationship with my own mother has developed and grown as a result of our enlarged family. My mother and I have become friends, in part because the presence of the other family members has mediated our relationship in positive ways. Perhaps one of the most overlooked aspects involves grandparents. Both the stepgrandmothers writing here receive much satisfaction from their interactions with their stepgrandchildren. Juanita Howard had little opportunity to be a stepmother to her husband's daughter; however, she was able to participate as a "stepgrandma" on a regular basis. Her conflicts were whether she would be a good enough stepgrandmother and how to balance her own professional schedule with the erratic scheduling of a stepfamily. Judith Higgs had opportunities to be a stepmother to her husband's fourteen children since their first mother had died; for her, instant motherhood and adoption of two of the children turned out to be nothing like television's Brady Bunch. Her positive story began when she became a stepgrandmother. Howard and Higgs learned how to be a stepgrandmother in steps; both were first stepmothers. Many stepgrandparents, with no previous experience in stepfamilies, are at best awkward in their roles, at worst hostile to their nonbiological grandchildren. Wendy's stepdaughter (Dee's daughter) does not exist for Wendy's parents. While this might be explained as homophobia, stepchildren in heterosexual families also often go unacknowledged by grandparents. For stepmothers neither death nor divorce makes their entry into the family any easier. However, these ac-
6
Introduction counts suggest that because stepgrandchildren do not have those divided loyalties that stepchildren usually feel, stepgrandmothers can be their friends rather than be trapped into trying to be a perfect mother-substitute.
Feminist Lens
When we read these accounts of women's stepfamily experiences through a feminist lens, themes emerge that raise questions about prevailing notions of motherhood and the family. In addition, what we learn about stepfamilies helps us rethink our feminism: we ask who and what is "mother"; what constitutes "family"; what rights and responsibilities do people have in families based on blood, caring, and economic contributions? These accounts challenge us to consider what is needed for women in stepfamilies to thrive and, at the same time, be connected to others in responsible and loving relationships.
Survival
For many women in stepfamilies, merely surviving the physical, economic, and emotional challenges of daily life is all-consuming. Berenice Lopez's account reflects the harshness of stepfamily life for women, and points to the lack of choices many women have. Similarly, Andrea Starr Alonzo's piece highlights how the struggle for economic survival shapes consciousness and behavior. These two selections underscore the privilege of women who have options to change their material situations, let alone step back, write about their experiences, and begin to work them through. Even for women with desire, opportunity, and skills to step out of their situation to reflect on it, the emotional urgency of negotiating the complexities of lives in stepfamilies can supersede intellectual understanding and feminist consciousness. This emerges in several pieces, among them Sheila Alson's. Intellectually she is able to step out of her situation during a difficult transition period and gain perspective on it. Yet what she knows and what she feels are at odds. For example, she sees the value of developing a relationship with her ex-husband'ls new partner, but her overwhelming sense of sadness and loss prevents that. Thus, feminist insightor any kind of reflective stance-while meaningful and clarifying, still may not match the power of the emotional experience.
7
Introduction Much of the struggle of women in stepfamilies is to enable significant relationships to survive or to emerge in changing family structures. This can take many forms. Yandra Soliz, a mother, is torn by her child's pain at having to share her mother with a new stepfamily. The myriad losses to stepmother and stepdaughter in an aborted relationship are poignantly rendered in Kathy Chamberlain's piece. Sheila Alson articulates the generic fear of mother and children as they enter new stepfamily relationships: "Will I still be loved?"
Fitting into "The Family"
Prevailing ideas about the family have profoundly affected women. We have learned that in a family a woman is nurturer, the emotional linchpin for family members, and has primary responsibility for meeting others' needs. Many women try to succeed in stepfamilies by attempting to live up to these norms. While some women have found this workable, others have found it painful or self-defeating. For some women the trauma of fitting into a newly formed family is minimized by cultural acceptance of this family form. As Andrea Starr Alonzo and Margaret Wade-Lewis point out, stepfamilies have always existed in black women's histories even though they were not necessarily named as such or talked about as unusual. However, for many women, especially feminists, the expectation of fitting into traditional family forms is a source of profound conflict. Some women suddenly find themselves in stepfamilies where they are expected to experience this new reality as their "real family." Alison Townsend poignantly describes this from her point of view as a stepdaughter who, as a child, gained a stepmother soon after her own mother's death. Her initial resistance, refusing to call her stepmother "Mom," went unsupported. This sudden imposition of "The Family" laid the basis for years of pain in her simultaneous resistance and desire to bond with "the mother who is not the mother, but is." Many of the women writing in this volume describe the trauma caused by trying to make the stepfamily an instant, traditional family. The implications for the stepmother are particularly overwhelming. When a stepmother attempts to fill the role of the "good mother," her efforts, destined by the structure of stepfamilies to be imperfect, merely confirm her wickedness. In most families the "good" biological mother cannot be replaced in children's hearts and minds and a stepmother's efforts at fulfilling this role breed resentment. Furthermore, when stepmothers do not meet
8
Introduction their internalized expectations of the unconditionally loving mother, they often blame and dislike themselves. Stepmothers find themselves afraid to discipline stepchildren or to engage in any meaningful interactions that might provoke conflict for fear of confirming their wickedness. Kathleen Dunn notes that similar comparisons between the "good father" and "wicked stepfather" are rare. Elizabeth Kamarck Minnich suggests that the stepmother symbolizes for all of us the loss of the good mother, a loss beyond our control. It evokes our vulnerability and surfaces what we would like to forget: the contingency of human life. Ultimately, however, feminism suggests it will be women in stepfamilies who, in creating alternatives to the ideal of the good biological mother and the rightness of the traditional family, can challenge the power of those myths. It is in varied and diverse family forms that all members, especially women, can breathe, grow, and create relationships not limited by gender stereotypes.
Making Stepfamilies Work for Women
From these accounts we can learn what structural barriers stand in the way of women's thriving in stepfamilies and what can be done about them. The first step is to recognize the barriers. Male power in families and patriarchal family forms keep women from raising issues about their roles as women in stepfamilies, from asking questions about why women's experiences in stepfamilies are comparatively more difficult and complex than men's, and from creating more diverse, equitable family arrangements. Christine Bryson won't talk openly about her concerns as a woman in a stepfamily because her husband believes these issues to be private; she appears here under a pseudonym. Under patriarchy, family issues are private, "under control" (male control) and not questioned. For lesbians in stepfamilies, the power of the patriarchy is even more overwhelming. Despite years of loving parenting by lesbians co-parenting one partner's children, parental rights are defined by the male legal system using traditional family forms as the norm. Women describe the tension in their relationships generated by fear that their lesbianism will be discovered and custody of their children lost. This fear is often accompanied by the subtext of familial disapproval expressed through the judgment and distancing of grandparents, which increases the feelings of isolation for lesbians in stepfamilies. Women's writing here also reveals the effects of racism and the bound-
9
Introduction aries of culture on their fulfillment in stepfamilies. The racism experienced by Soliz, for example, from both unknown others and extended family members weighed heavily upon her interracial stepfamily. In response to the racism in society and white attitudes about childrearing, the six stepmothers Wade-Lewis interviewed drew upon African American family traditions to strengthen their stepfamilies. For Shirley Geok-Lin Lim, Eastern and Western culture clashed, making painful her quest for identity and love in her stepfamily . Constraints of class, as well, limit women in stepfamilies. In many areas of their lives, working class women have fewer options. Women enter, or stay in, stepfamilies for economic reasons, as Berenice Lopez and Elisa Davila point out. Because men, Judith Grant suggests, often keep women one foot out of poverty, they take on patriarchal authority in other family areas. So too, changes in family forms are far from the experience of many working-class people, for whom very little ever changes, Dympna Callaghan reminds us. Then again, some working-class families may historically have more experience with extended-family forms, so that stepfamilies are not felt to be problematic in the same way they are for some middleclass families. Identifying such structural and cultural barriers to making stepfamilies work can help women stop blaming themselves for stepfamily problems and direct their emotions and actions toward creating change in the society that imposes these barriers. Meanwhile, living these lives, women can name these constraints on their family, attempt to challenge their limits, and where possible risk living in stepfamilies in self-defined ways. This book suggests those possibilities. Connie Miller speaks not only for herself but for many courageous women when she defines such a process of risk taking as "an act of resistance to external imperatives" that is necessary to the liberated, self-determined life and the hope for broader social and cultural transformation. As we listen to the voices here, we can discern factors that have helped women live in stepfamilies with integrity. We come to see that family forming is a process that happens over time. Women with consciousness of the importance of this process, as compared to any received structure of The Family, express insight about their family's development. Dee and Wendy, for example, look back and identify important changes in the process of family forming; starting family rituals like the celebration of Chanukah; building on commonalities between stepmother and stepdaughter not shared by the mother; drawing boundaries around the adult relationship; and joining a lesbian parent support group. Feminism provides critique, vision, and support for many of these writers. Catharine Stimpson finds feminist discourse to be "the most searching,
10
Introduction steadfast, and sustaining" as she lives daily life with her stepchildren. Feminist values motivate Sarah Turner to be very intentional in creating cooperative, reciprocal, and equal relationships in her extended stepfamilies, especially between mother and stepfamily. Feminism offers women the consciousness and practical skills to join together, share with each other, and struggle creatively to transform their lives. One example is the stepmothers' support group that Nancy Schniedewind describes. Nancy Schniedewind, Suzanne Bunkers, Sheila Alson, and Dee and Wendy have joined women's groups, not only because it is a place to discuss the problems of one's family, but because it is a place to create connections to other women so that sisterhood becomes a form of "familiness." While encouraging these personal and collective solutions, feminism also recognizes that broad-based societal change is ultimately necessary for the liberation of women in stepfamilies.
Transforming "The Family"
Rather than being limited by The Family, feminism has offered a vision of a broadened definition of family. Families can be living arrangements in which people share time and space, contribute equally to the physical and psychological tasks of making the household function, share common history and ritual, and make a commitment to staying together over time. Members are not necessarily tied by biology or by the sanction of state or church or by living in the same house all the time. All members seek both to give and receive support and love; all have space to grow as autonomous individuals. Stepfamilies, then, could be one of the many accepted family forms-no better or worse, no more normal or atypical than any other. In stepfamilies, we can learn to see families as changeable and affirm that fact. We can learn to expect the formation of a stepfamily as a normal life transition, just as now we expect a child will ultimately leave home. As we learn to expect a combination of sadness and renewal in the child's leaving, we can expect the same for changes in family forms. Prevailing ideologies, based on myths, of scarcity, have taught women that love is the special province of The Family, or stepfamily-become-Family. From these pages some women in stepfamilies attest to the strength of affiliation itself, rather than formal family ties, as the bond that sustains relationships. Stepmothers' fears of the loss of relationship with a stepchild after the end of the adult relationship exude from the pieces by Carol Ashner and Deborah Rosenfelt. Yet their desire and commitment to maintain that bond outside formal family structures confront these fears.
II
Introduction Stepfamilies can push women to value and act on their own needs as much as those of other family members. For example, stepmothers who have experienced the trap of attempting to be the "good" mother learn that they can separate from the family to develop themselves and, at the same time, be consciously connected to the family by sharing responsibility for its health. With one foot in and the other foot out, a stepmother can be both woman and parent. This position is often appreciated by other family members, as when Lewittes's stepdaughter characterizes their relationship as "happy detachment." This stance, which Elizabeth Minnich calls being a "conscious outsider," doesn't free women from pain, but does provide hope for wholeness of both women and families. Similarly, such families can help break down gender roles by compelling men to take on more of the parenting. Because this volume presents women writing about their experiences in stepfamilies, men's voices are absent. Some women describe very positive, warm relationships with men, be they stepfathers, stepbrothers, or husbands. Yet other women here do not portray men as understanding or helping to resolve women's tensions in stepfamilies. Many of the women speak in voices edged with anger, bitterness, and unacknowledged hurt. A few women depict men as explicitly rejecting involvement because of notions of masculinity that encourage authoritarian roles or distancing behaviors. In other accounts, men are noticeably absent from women's descriptions of their struggles to negotiate the emotional turmoil of their lives. Once again, as in the traditional nuclear family, women seem to be the emotional linchpin of the family system. As noted before, for men in stepfamilies, there is nothing comparable to the power of the socially imposed ideology of the "good mother" that drives women to taking this responsibility. Yet, because of the contradictions between lived experience and the ideology, women here articulate a feminist critique of the stepfamily, just as it was women who first articulated a critique of the nuclear family. Some men, from their own circumstances of having to take on sudden, new family roles and responsibilities, often first from divorce and then single active parenting, have developed a similar analysis. For men in stepfamilies, whose new roles have often created all-consuming practical and emotional tensions for them with family members, thus lessening the support they give to women, it is important that they take a first step and speak out from their various perspectives, so that they too can name their pain and claim their responsibilities. Relationships among women pose both hard challenges and possibilities to women in stepfamilies. Linkages among women in the same stepfamily, especially between stepmother and mother, are often the most difficult. Our well-learned lessons of competing for a man and distrusting other
12
Introduction women emerge. In her review of recent stepfamily fiction, Nan Bauer Maglin discovers that stepfamily stories exonerate men. Women in these works do not see each other as allies and sisters; rather the "other" is another woman-the other mother. Yet here in Women and Stepfamilies women's voices resonate with hopes for female bonding, even in awkward situations such as Morgan David's. Barbara Drucker and Sarah Turner document working relationships between stepmother and mother, founded on feminist consciousness. It is the political and social power society gives to the mother and denies to women in other spheres of their lives, Elizabeth Minnich reminds us, that works to separate woman from woman by relegating other women to second-class status. Women in stepfamilies, therefore, have the potential for transforming both women's role as mother and the family itself. By relinquishing some of the power of motherhood (which we have only one step removed, if at all), we can relate more fully as women. By challenging the myth of biological motherhood we can help create diverse forms of family in which parenting is shared. By replacing the "good mother" with mature adult women, we can create the space for women concurrently to be autonomous and connected in loving relationships with others. By sharing our stories we can see our connectedness and catalyze change in the broader social fabric shaping our lives. With such revisioning and concomitant social action, families can then have the hope of becoming collectives of individuals, living democratically and cooperatively together, sharing responsibility, power, and love.
Notes
I. There are 35 million stepparents in America and 1,300 stepfamilies are formed every day. One out of every five children has a stepparent. By 1990 more people will be part of a second marriage than a first. These statistics, referred to in much of the stepfamily literature, probably do not include unmarried couples and surely do not include same-sex couples. 2. One recent book, Stepmotherhood: How to Survive Without Feeling Frustrated, Left Out or Wicked by Cherie Burns (New York: Times Book, 1985), clearly focuses on women but does not bring a feminist perspective to the subject. Burns includes quotes from women but only in excerpted form. While this is a very useful book, it assumes a fairly consistent white, middle-class heterosexual perspective on the whole. Many of the other books in the field (and there are now more coming out each year)--except for some few autobiographical ones like Patricia Tracy Lowe's The Cruel Stepmother (Englewood Cliffs, N.J.: Prentice-Hall, 1970), Mary Zenorini Silverweig's The Other Mother (New York: Harper and Row, 1982), and
13
Introduction Delia Ephron's Funny Sauce: Us, the Ex, the Ex's New Mate, the New Mate's Ex, and the Kids (New York: Viking, 1986)-do not give full voice to the dense and variegated experiences of women in very different kinds of stepfamilies. For a fairly comprehensive bibliography of books and articles about stepfamilies, see Ellen J. Gruber, Stepfamilies: A Guide to the Sources and Resources (New York: Garland Publishing, 1986). The Good Stepmother: A Practical Guide, by Karen Savage and Patricia Adams (New York: Crown Publishers, 1988), has come out just as this book has gone to press. 3. See, for example, Joyce Trebilcot, ed., Mothering: Essays in Feminist Theory (Totowa, N.J.: Rowman & Allanheld, 1983); Barrie Thorne and Marilyn Yalom, eds., Rethinking the Family: Some Feminist Questions (New York: Longmans, 1982); and Irene Diamond, ed., Families, Politics and Public Policy: A Feminist Dialogue on Women and the State (New York: Longmans, 1983). 4. Dr. Elizabeth Stern is the wife of Dr. William Stern, the biological father of "Baby M." He fought for custody of Baby M from Mary Beth Whitehead, who is the biological mother of the baby, although she is termed the "surrogate mother." S. Women and Stepfamilies begins to point to what must be a much more extensive exploration of commonalities and differences based on race, ethnicity, sexual preference, and class. Writers representative of "dominant" groups, whether white, heterosexual, or middle class, unfortunately focus less on the effects of these factors on their lives than do women of color, lesbians, or working-class women, whose survival necessitates such consciousness. Johnetta B. Cole, addressing the question of what u.S. women have in common and what their differences are, points out that, especially in terms of the family, that question is both complex and controversial. She advises that "we need . . . to listen to what women say about experiences in families as they vary by race, ethnicity, and by all other characteristics of family members. If we listen to what different women say about their experiences in their diverse family arrangements, we will acknowledge and come to understand that for women as a group, as well as for individual women, life in families is contradictory-involving restrictions, constraints, and oppressive acts on the one hand and support, protection, comfort, and indeed joy on the other" (All American Women: Lines That Divide, Ties that Bind [New York: The Free Press, 1986], p. IS)· 6. Rayna Rapp, Ellen Ross, and Renate Bridenthal, "Examining Family History," Feminist Studies S, (Spring 1979): 174-200.
References
Clausen, Jan. Sinking, Stealing. Trumansburg, N.Y.: Crossing Press, 1985. Zipes, Jack. Don't Bet on the Prince: Contemporary Feminist Fairy Tales in North America and England. New York: Metheun, 1986. Zipes, Jack. "Kissing Off Snow White," New York Times Book Review, March 22, 1987.
Part I
Perspectives
Ste pm oth er s
I
Letters from a Custodial Stepmother Christine Bryson
January 29, 19 8 5 Dear Ms. Maglin: On Saturday, January 26, I completely lost emotional control for the first time in my life and terrified my stepson, age twelve, and shocked my husband of five years. All I did was scream, but I was as shocked as everyone else was. My stepdaughter, age seventeen, is away at college. My husband's two children moved in with us two years ago because their mother was letting their stepfather abuse them and, after five sessions in court, my husband obtained their custody. Last night, "stepfamily" problems almost got the best of me again. After my husband and I went to bed, he fell asleep and I was still fuming, so I got out of bed, padded quietly into our living room and very intently read the articles in my newest MS. magazine (February 1 985) about the "blended family" (a term which is too polite, according to my way of thinking), hoping to find some help, reassurance, information, anything. Unfortunately, the world is mostly dealing with custodial stepfathers and visitation stepmothers, and very few people even realize that there are those of us who are custodial stepmothers. I am writing today also to the Stepfamily Association for information and, hopefully, a support network for women in my unusual, but not unique, circumstance. I found your request to hear from other stepparents about our experiences. Well, mine have been unusual and not all happy ones, although, in fairness, not all unhappy either. What do you want to know? Maybe if I tell someone, it will help. Very truly yours, Christine Bryson
19
Perspectives: Stepmothers February 12, 1985 Dear Nan, I was so pleased to receive your response to my letter. I thought I'd take the opportunity to confirm my interest in working "with" you to help others in our situation if, in any way, I can. As you may recall, I mentioned that I am a custodial stepmother, which is a somewhat unusual circumstance. Imagine my surprise when my office recently hired a woman who is also a custodial stepmother. She is only in her mid-twenties and has a fifteen-year-old stepdaughter, as well as a husband of almost five years and a two-year-old child of her current marriage. She and I have spent many moments together laughing and commiserating about those things in our "steplives" which are similar as well as those which are different. She, also, is looking for support. I gave her your letter to read this morning. Although her response was one of strong interest, she did not want to become involved. To answer your letter: yes, I am interested in becoming involved. I, too, would like to know how much of this other people have been through and how much is uniquely mine to deal with. I suppose it would do my outlook some good to reflect on the good that "stepfamilying" has brought me. It is easy to dwell on the bad and get a sour attitude. You know, like when divorcees begin to think that all men are rotten. It is easy for me to think that all children are rotten and all fathers are rotten. I think the book idea is wonderful. I can see how developing a network among those of us in this "situation" could be helpful in developing an understanding and disseminating information. I would be both frightened and excited to feel I might be a part of something that will affect other's lives. However, I will echo your thought that perhaps I should begin all this just by writing you letters. I need to think it all out. Right now I'm too angry to have much to say that is constructive. You mentioned the fact that your daughter and others around you have been affected already by your writing. I hope that you will not feel so panicked and guilty that you end your efforts on our behalf. Perhaps if we were all required to be so honest with those around us, they would understand better and deal with the inevitable hurt more quickly. As you may have realized by now, I do not have the "guts" (interpret "honesty"?) to even let my own family know that this issue bothers me so much that I have to look for support. That is the reason why our dealings, for now at least, have to be through my office address. My husband does not like people to talk about personal issues to "outsiders." Neither to him nor about him. I remember vividly the day that I had "had it up to here" (see my hand at my forehead) and ran to the local library for answers. I brought home
20
Letters from a Custodial Stepmother a stack of books and before I could open one, my stepdaughter was all over them jokingly accusing me (and there is much truth in jest, is there not?) of having problems with being a stepmother. I will take some time and gather my thoughts as to the things that I really want to speak out about. Then, perhaps I can write to you little by little and deal with each subject. It's good knowing someone is trying to do something about all of this mess which our contemporary lifestyles have brought us. If I can be of help, let me. If I hinder the process, be honest enough to tell me. Thank you for your support. I hope your daughter is, by now, beginning to understand. Very truly yours, Christine April la, 1985 Dear Nan, I think of your research often, particularly when talking with other "blended-family" members. I wonder how you are doing and what you are hearing from all the other people in the world. Lots of ideas have gone through my mind since we last "talked." There are so many things I want to say. Of course, in the heat of passion, one tends to act and react more quickly. When I first wrote to you in reaction to the articles in MS. magazine, I was reacting to a very bad event at home with my "blended family." As time has passed, things have once again become more quiet. However, the issues are still there. They have not changed and they have not disappeared. I think it's about time I start to put some of my ideas into words. If not to aid in your research, then just to help myself sort them out by forcing them into black and white. One of my biggest gripes, although I have so many, is the fact that I had no choice in becoming a custodial stepmother (for sake of ease in typing, can we call her a CSM?). That is a major difference between most CSMs and most custodial stepfathers (CSF). I believe, though I have no numbers to support my belief, that most men become CSFs by marrying women who already have custody of their own children. I doubt that many men become CSFs some time after they marry. Most women get custody and retain custody of their children during divorces. They don't begin without custody and gain custody after a subsequent marriage. So the man that marries her knows up front that he will become a CSF on saying "I do." Women who become CSMs-more often than men, I think--do so some time after they say "I do," as the "real" mother has custody from the
21
Perspectives: Stepmothers divorce but for some reason voluntarily or involuntarily loses it. How many men get custody of their children when they are single? So a woman marries a man expecting the typical every-other-weekend-visitation life, but, for whatever reason, the father gets custody and the "new" wife becomes a CSM. Take my situation, for example. Gary (my husband) and Susan (his first wife and the mother of his children) had two children together. They had an amicable divorce. Of course she got the children. He didn't even try. She remarried. The new husband (David) knew he was going to become a CSF before he married her. He knew what was in store for him and he had an opportunity to make a choice. Gary and I married at about the same time. During Susan and David's marriage, Gary found out that David was very badly abusing the children and Susan was letting him. Gary's visitation was affected as well. So Gary took it to court to have the visitation problem fixed. As time went on, Gary learned more and more about the abuse and he finally asked the court for custody, not just visitation. At that point, we had been married about two years. We had determined before we were married that we would not have children. Neither one of us wanted them. I've never wanted children. I'm not the nurturing type. He'd already been through it. When we started talking about getting custody of his kids, I couldn't very well say "no" could I? I could not leave them in that terrible situation. I may not be the nurturing type, but I am compassionate. The choice was to leave the two kids where they were being beaten, malnourished, and psychologically abused, or for me to become a CSM. Sure, at one point Gary asked me if I was willing and I had the opportunity to say "no." Fat chance. That would essentially give the man a position of having to choose between his wife of a few years and his blood children. He would have to have chosen between being married to me and knowing he left his children in a terrible situation, or being a single father. As Joan Rivers says, "Oh, grow up!" You know the choice I had was no choice and the choice he would have had would have been no choice. I've mentioned in my earlier letters that one of my co-workers is a CSM. She married her husband knowing he had one child from his first marriage, but the child was in the mother's custody. They did not expect to ever gain custody. They married with the intent to have "their own" family (she is now in her mid to late twenties, he is in his mid-thirties). She gave birth two years ago to a little boy. Shortly after that, her husband felt compelled to gain custody of his daughter from his first marriage as her home situation had become very bad. My friend and her husband have had custody now of his daughter for two years. The daughter is now sixteen years old. What choice did my friend have?
22
Letters from a Custodial Stepmother I liken it in my own mind to changing the rules in the middle of a very important game. It makes me angry. But my hands are tied, as are the hands of probably most of the other custodial stepmothers in the world. And to top it off, we CSMs are expected, just because we have female sex organs, to become the primary caretaker and nurturer of these stepchildren. A CSF, on the other hand, is not expected to be the primary caretaker or nurturer of his stepchildren, is he? Hell, no. But that's another subject. So I'll drop it here for now. What do you think? Very truly yours, Christine 10-11- 8 5
Dear Nan, Just time for very quick note. I too have had a tough summer. Back to court on the custody of Kurt, Gary's twelve-year-old (we kept him). Lynn, his seventeen-year-old and a sophomore in college, got pregnant so we dealt with the abortion issue firsthand. Gary was fired from his job. Life in the fast lane. I now am the proud owner of a well-deserved new ulcer. Other than that, I've weathered it all well. I'm okay. I've been running. I've applied to work at a local college so I can take classes easier and get to work on my degree. For now though, I'm still at the firm. Gary does not know about this book, so the only chance I have to write is at work. That makes it tough. But if you'll still listen, I'll still talk, 'cause I have a lot to say. Must run-but know that I'm still out here stepmothering! Until later, Christine January 30, 19 86 Dear Nan, It has been one year and one day since I first wrote to you. It has been over three months since I last wrote you and ten months since I last gave you anything of substance. And I am, honestly, feeling very guilty about the extreme passage of time. Unfortunately, this letter has to be a mere contact, nothing much more because I have so little time. But I did want to let you know that I care very much about your project. I wonder how it is going for you. I still have not told Gary about my contact with you. I wonder if I ever will. So that rules out doing anything out of the office as he is a very devoted husband and is with me or near me virtually all the time. He
Perspectives: Stepmothers doesn't enjoy going out without me, so where I am, there he is also. It's flattering, but somewhat in the way at times. I have no opportunity to write during office hours. I rarely can get to the office early or stay late as Gary and I drive to and from work together. Tonight, however, due to "family responsibilities," we were forced to take separate cars, and I told him I had to stay and work overtime. Lunches I am usually busy running (literally) or running errands. It all sounds like excuses. I don't mean it to. Actually, they are merely reasons, although I feel guilty about it and wonder if perhaps I felt better about it all I would find time to write. So, bottom line, I am still out here and still interested and wondering if you are still able to take contributions. Please forgive me for being so slow in writing. Before I go, one story I have wanted to share with you for a long time. A few years ago, before I was a custodial stepmother, I had the time to take an art class after work (I am slowly but surely getting my degree in art). During that semester, Gary and I were going through a very trying period with the kids. He had lost visitation rights and had absolutely no contact with either of his children for some time. Their mother refused his telephone calls and his letters were returned. The kids were about thirteen (Lynn) and eight (Kurt) years old. One day, clear out of the blue, a counselor from Lynn's school called Gary at work and told him Lynn wanted to talk to him and would he be willing to talk to her. He was overjoyed, and, to make a long story short, within a few days, she was living with us. She had not told her brother what she was going to do as she did not want to burden him with the knowledge and the decisions that would accompany that knowledge. Her mother refused her any contact with her brother (with whom she had always been very close) after Lynn moved in with us. It was a very awkward time for all three of us as we were happy that Lynn was with us, but so concerned about Kurt and his well-being. There seemed to be a very distinct gap or something missing-obviously it was Kurt. Prior to all of this, back when things were going smoothly and the kids lived with their mother and we had regular visitation, Gary and I had set our camera up on a tripod, and had taken a photograph of the four of us on our front porch. It was a wonderful picture, full of wonderful feelings (if I can find a spare copy at home tonight, I'll send it to you). Back to the story at hand. In my painting class, the teacher suggested we paint something that had a very strong, personal feeling for each of us. Right away I knew what I wanted to paint. That photograph, exactly as it was, with Kurt missing. Just a big white blank piece of canvas where his little body was in the photograph. I don't know why, but that was such a
Letters from a Custodial Stepmother strong image. I had to paint it. I was really excited about it. It was just going to be such a strong statement that I felt many people would understand and relate to, whatever their personal perspective might be. I came running home and excitedly told this idea to Gary. He was devastated! The image, the concept of the finished painting, was too much for him to bear. Although I certainly had the freedom to go ahead with my plan, I just could not do that to him. I didn't want to lie to him about what I was painting, and I didn't want to show him the painting when it was finished. But I would be too excited to not show it to him. So, out of deference to his strong, sad feelings, I never painted the picture. The image, however, still remains in my mind. I wonder if there ever will be a day when he can step far enough away from all the horrible things that have happened to not be hurt by such a painting. Well, time flies and it's about time I get out of the office. Let me know if you still want to hear from me. Sincerely, Christine PS: Just a quick final note to let you know that the recent disasters in my life seem to be in check. Gary started working again in November and seems to be happy with this new position. Kurt's mother has moved out to Ohio and will have a much more difficult time pulling the little shitty things she used to try. Kurt is doing very well and appears to be much more stable now that the last court battle over his custody is finished. He was told by the judge that it would not be brought back into court unless Kurt asked for it (his mother nearly shit bricks!). Lynn pulled through the abortion like a trooper, as did Gary. I was very proud of his supportive attitude. We took her to a clinic together and sat in the waiting room together. My ulcer is now under control. I'm still running. Hoping next year to do my first marathon! I applied to work at a local college so I can take classes easier, but to date, they have not contacted me. I write them on a regular basis. Some day they'll give in just to get me off their backs. So I'm still at the firm. Happy enough. Not ecstatic with my life, but happy enough. 11/28/86 Dear Nan, No time for details now. Wonder how the book is coming. I'm leaving my job at the firm. Going to work at the university-they'll let me take some day classes and pay my tuition! Some day I'll have a degree: masters in fine art.
Perspectives: Stepmothers Stepparenting still good/bad. As the years pass, we get more used to one another-thank God! Hope all is well with you. Until later, Christine September 10, 1987 Dear Nan, I'm "working late" tonight to take the time and review the letters you returned to me for my "editing." Please note the name changes. I obtained these names and places by literally opening a phone directory and putting my finger down on the pages! Anything "creative" I could think of, Gary could figure out. Even with all that, though, obviously if he ever read it all, he would know right away that was us. I'm just hoping that changing the names and places will keep anyone else around here from pointing it out to him. I feel so odd about all of this. I'm sure that is part of the reason for my lack of letters to you. I feel I am betraying my best friend, and in a way I guess I am. Gary is my best friend and these are things I cannot be honest about with him. He also takes such great offense if anyone talks to anyone else about anything personal. I'm sorry for him that he doesn't develop a friendship so deep that he would talk about these kinds of feelings. But in the meantime, I simply don't let him know that there are a few special people I do talk to. You being one of them. You know, in looking over the correspondence, I am surprised at how little there was from me. I must have thought so much more to say to you, or perhaps I started letters and never finished them. Anyway, I expected volumes of letters that I had written to you, though I am sure this is all there is. I find it all very hard to talk about. Also I find it very difficult to take time out of my life to do this. It's a circular or Catch 22 situation in so many ways. I never told you about the chemistry or sexual rivalry (over Gary) between my stepdaughter and me when she first moved in. I never told you what life was so horribly like during the two years of going in and out of court and the way the kids treated their father and the way he continued to love them knowing it was their mother manipulating them and not their true feelings. I never told you about their relationship with their mother at this point in time. I never told you that one thing that really gets under my skin is that when "grandparents" are talked about as far as sending school photos to them and the like, my parents are never even considered. I never told you how angry/embarrassed I get when he jumps on the kids "on my behalf" when they are kidding me or something like that.
Letters from a Custodial Stepmother I never told you how hurt I've been by the thousands of little things over the years done to me or around me or because of me-the custodial stepmother. The wicked stepmother. I never told you that I'm really a nice stepmother. I never told you that I love the kids and they love me and they've never once refused to do anything I've told them and they've never said to me, "You're not my mother!" I've never told you that I count the years and days until we are once again the couple we were before we got custody of the kids. I've never told you about what it feels like to be called to the hospital because one of the kids has been hurt and to have the hospital question my authority to sign for medical action "because you're not their mother, even if your husband has custody," and so now I go to the hospital and say I'm their mother and the kids look at me knowing I'm lying and wanting to say something but being in too much pain to raise hell. I've never told you about the things the kids have confided in me or I've done with or known about the kids and don't tell their father because I don't think he'd be fair 'cause he can't be as objective as I am. I've never told you that I can see the kids objectively for what they are and where they are in life and their father sees them only as his little baby children, as his mother still sees him in spite of his forty years on this earth. I've never told you how often I've thought of walking out on him 'cause I just can't take it any more, but afraid to walk out because of the damage it may do to the kids. Afraid to walk out because of the way his mother adores me after taking in the kids and treating them so well and loving them so much. Knowing I can't hurt all those "innocent bystanders" just because I "can't take it" for a few more years till the kids are grown and gone. I've never told you that I had my tubes tied. And how I am sometimes worried that I will regret that decision when I am old and alone and have no family, but how my husband corrects me and reminds me that I do have children who will be there for me when I am old. And how I wonder if these two kids, who are not bone of my bone or flesh of my flesh, will really care anything about me when I am old and alone. And how sometimes I wish nuclear families were still the rule and not the exception and life was like Leave It to Beaver. And how guilty I feel that I'm not home when Kurt comes home frorn school and that I don't fix him breakfast or lunch. And how guilty I feel when he comes home from school and wants to talk and I know It will bore me and I want to tell him, but I know how it would damage his tender emotional state and so I listen and resent it and resent him. And how guilty I feel that I don~t spend time with Kurt. And how guilty I feel that I don't write letters to
Perspectives: Stepmothers Lynn and try to hide when she calls on the phone 'cause I don't really know what to talk about with her, even after all these years. It's all so fucking depressing! I guess that's why I didn't write you tons of letters. I've never told you how angry but powerless I feel when their father brings home white bread and Oreos and cola and gives it to them like a reward. And they gain weight. And they complain about the weight. But they like the food and Gary likes to see them enjoy life. But I'm a health food person who feels she has no power or authority, because, after all, they're not my kids. They're his kids to raise as he likes. I've never told you that it makes me feel powerless that they are his kids to raise as he likes and that I really get no vote. I've never told you that I am glad we did not have kids together because I so strongly disagree with the way he raises kids. Though he is, without a doubt, an excellent father, very loving and very kind. And I've never told you that he doesn't drink and I love him very much for that. My father was an alcoholic. My first husband was an alcoholic. And I refuse to ever live like that again. I've never told you that my husband is my best friend, loving, kind, gentle, sexy, happy, warm. That my marriage is one of the best, most stable, I've ever seen. I tend to go on and on with the negative making my life look awful. But I am really a very lucky woman, finding a wonderful man the second time around, falling into children and being lucky enough to get two that are honest, loving, kind, bright, trustworthy, fun, instead of the stereotypical stepchildren. At least I know that by my not having children, I will never force another woman to become an unwitting custodial stepmother! (Of course, though, I sometimes dream of making a baby in my belly and going through delivery and raising it perfectly. Strictly an emotional, occasional, pull. Intellectually I know I am far too selfish and directed in my own life to r~ally be a good mother or want to be a mother. But I digress . . .) , So my arms are around you and your co-workers and your brave "blended family" and all the other "steps" in the world, be they mothers, fathers, children, grandparents, cousins, anything. Maybe this book will be the line thrown to other drowning custodial stepmothers of this contemporary world. With my deepest admiration, Christine
2
Ten Times Harder: Becoming a Stepmother Suzanne L. Bunkers Stepmothers-to-be usually have one of three popular preconceptions about stepmothering: (I) our stepchildren won't really be part of our marriage and lives; (2) our relationship with our stepchildren will be close and familial-like one big happy family; (3) we will love our stepchildren as though they were our own children. With a little experience we realize that all three beliefs are unrealistic. -Cherie Burns, Stepmotherhood
A few years ago, I had no idea that I would soon be facing the challenges of stepmotherhood. In May 1984 I was living by myself in Mankato, Minnesota, where I had been teaching English and women's studies courses at Mankato State University for the previous four years. I had been divorced for over six years. I was feeling content to be on my own, with just my cats, Vincent and Alice, as living companions. From time to time I mused about what it might be like to be in another relationship, particularly with someone who already had children, since, at the age of thirty-four, I had none. Occasionally I felt an urge to do some mothering. Stepmothering, I imagined, would be the easiest way to fulfill this urge. I could spend some time around a child and not have to be responsible for its daily needs, and I could get back in touch with that childlike part of myself that had somehow gotten lost over the years as I had focused my energies on my education and career. My childhood in an alcoholic family and my own brief marriage at the age of twenty-one had left me leery about any commitments to long-term relationships or to the raising of children. My involvement in the feminist
Perspectives: Stepmothers movement had begun as a reaction to my realization that I had been overly responsible, both in my family of origin and in my marriage, for taking care of others. For several years I had been an active member of a women's support group, and I had recently completed codependency treatment. Both experiences had helped me to recognize that I needed to stop trying to "help" others by attempting to control their lives. So, when I began a relationship with Randy that summer of 1984, I vowed to be careful to keep it light. Still, as the two of us grew closer, I felt more confident in my ability to make that relationship healthy. I felt both excited and apprehensive about the prospect of getting to know Randy's six-year-old son, Christopher. Randy and his former wife, Pat, shared custody of Christopher, who was with Randy during the school year and with Pat and her husband, Patrick, during the summer. My first glimpse of Christopher was of a blond little boy in striped polo shirt and shorts, hiding behind Randy's legs as his father urged him to come out and meet me. The three of us went roller skating with friends that day, and I took a liking to Christopher when, at the skating rink, he confided in me that he really was scared of falling but was trying to make it look as if he wasn't. His words reminded me of what I had been like as a child-a scared little kid always trying to be brave. Later, when Randy told me about having gone through treatment for alcoholism two years prior to our meeting, I began to understand better that, as children of alcoholics, Christopher and I were bound to have feelings and behaviors In common. I didn't see much of Christopher during the summer of 1984 because he spent most of it at his mother and stepfather's home in Iowa. In the fall, Randy, Christopher, and I had our first outing as a threesome. We went to the Twin Cities, where I cared for Christopher while Randy ran in a marathon. The whole day, Christopher kept his distance from me, pulling away when I tried to take his hand before crossing the street and running off at the finish line to fight his way through the crowds to Randy. Randy showed little affection toward me with Christopher present. I came away feeling hurt and disappointed. As the three of us drove back to Mankato that evening, I realized that I needed to think more seriously about what continuing my relationship with Randy would mean. For one thing, it would mean that Christopher would be a central factor in how Randy and I interacted because Christopher would almost always be present. Randy and I would have very little time alone together, usually only late at night after Christopher would be asleep or on the two weekends a month he would visit his mother and stepfather. For another thing, it would mean that I would have to realize Randy's responsibilities as a
3°
Ten Times Harder single parent and that I would have to make some adjustments in my own expectations about relationships. Before, I had always been in relationships with people who, like me, had no children and who could spend as much time with me as the two of us wished. I wasn't used to being around children. The last child I had cared for on a daily basis was my youngest brother, Dan, who had started kindergarten the year I left home for college. After about an hour of being with Christopher, I had had enough time together, yet I found I couldn't say, "Okay, go away now. I've had enough interaction for today." I had to recognize that I couldn't turn Christopher'ls presence on and off at will. Randy didn't understand my discomfort and frustration when I explained my feelings to him. I found it difficult to be in the midst of a conversation with Randy, only to be interrupted as Christopher tried to get his father's attention. I found it disconcerting to be overheard by a sixyear-old, but I felt guilty about complaining. What right did I have? Randy and Christopher, I told myself, had a preexisting relationship. When I entered the picture, it was up to me to fit in as best I could. I knew that this was unhealthy, codependent thinking, yet I kept silent for several months. An unexpected turn of events brought my anger (and my underlying fears) to the surface: in March 1985 I found out that I was pregnant. An earlier tubal pregnancy and the diagnosis of severe endometriosis had led me to believe that I couldn't have a child, so this news was a shock-but not an entirely unwelcome one. I started to feel excited. I was going to have a child of my own! Randy seemed ambivalent about the prospect of becoming a father again, since he had expected that Christopher would be his only child. We would become a family, I told myself. It all sounded so easy and so right. How would Christopher react to the news of my pregnancy? When Randy and I told him, Christopher seemed to like the idea. I felt relieved yet anxious when Christopher kept referring to the baby as his half-brother or sister. I wondered how he would adjust to no longer being the center of attention. I worried about how I would adjust to becoming a mother and a stepmother at virtually the same time. I agonized over what the coming changes would mean for my relationship with Randy. At the heart of my feelings was my fear that I was, and would remain, an outsider as far as Randy and Christopher's relationship was concerned. I decided to talk things over with Randy. Our talk didn't go well. Randy was angry and defensive when I told him that I wanted his and my relationship to be the primary one, that I wasn't willing to put up with Christopher's demands for Randy's attention at my expense, that I wanted the dynamics of our relationship as a three-
Perspectives: Stepmothers some to change before our baby was born. Like Randy, I felt defensive and angry. Would our baby and I have to take a back seat to the relationship between Randy and Christopher? I had gone from rarely seeing Christopher at the start of my relationship with Randy to being with him nearly all the time. I was scared. I knew that I didn't feel the unconditional love for Christopher that a "real" mother feels for her child. What could I do? How could I tell Randy that I didn't love his son? What would it be like when my own child was born? What if I couldn't even love my own baby? In June 1985 Christopher left for two months at his mother and stepfather's. Shortly before, I had asked his stepfather, Patrick, if he ever felt invisible when he was with Christopher and his mother, Pat. Yes, Patrick had replied, early in his relationship with Christopher's mother, he had had to deal with exactly what I was experiencing-that feeling of being invisible, of being an outsider, not a part of the parent-child relationship. Patrick assured me, just as the women in my support group had, that things would get better as Christopher and I got to know each other better. But such reassurances were of little comfort. I didn't want to have to wait for months or even years. At the heart of my impatience, I later realized, was my fear that things might never change, that I might never feel anything for Christopher and that he might never feel anything for me. That summer was one of the most painful I can remember. Randy and I tried to sort out what our relationship and living arrangements would be in the fall when Christopher returned and our baby was due. We made plans to move to the same town and share a house. Slowly we began to let go of some of the control that each of us had exercised over our own living situations up to that point. We had many intimate, angry, and poignant moments. In August we moved into one dwelling. Books, dishes, silverware, furniture spilled everywhere as we struggled to blend two households into one and create some semblance of a home. Christopher, who had returned from his mother and stepfather's just days after Randy and I had unpacked our belongings, was shy and wary about being in a new town, making friends in a new neighborhood, and starting second grade at a new school. Those first weeks of September were miserable ones for me. Eight months pregnant, I couldn't sleep at night; I couldn't lift or carry things. I wondered about the approaching labor and delivery. Randy, who had been laid off from work, was anxious about the prospect of continued unemployment. Christopher stayed in the house, scared to go out and meet the neighborhood kids. When he tried to make friends with my cats, they hissed and ran away. It was an excruciating time for all of us. My way of dealing with the problems in our newly blended family was to reassure myself that as soon as the baby was born, everything would be all right.
Ten Times Harder Life with a seven-year-old unnerved me at times. I felt exasperated when Christopher left lights on, clothes and toys strewn about the room, a trail of Cheerios across the kitchen floor. By the final days of my pregnancy, I was wrung out. I fantasized about bringing the baby home to a house in which her father, she, and I could become a family. I wanted to savor the experience of having my first child. Christopher's presence was a constant reminder to me that this baby was not Randy's first child and that she would not be special in the same way to him as she would be to me. On the other hand, I thought, perhaps having my own child would help me feel more loving toward Christopher. I hesitated to show affection for him because I feared that he could continue to pull away from me. I avoided disciplining him because I worried that, if I did, he would view me as a "wicked stepmother." Randy's and my unmarried status also caused me some anxiety. To me, our status reinforced my fears that I could not become a stepmother to Christopher, that I was merely a "pretender" to the role. One afternoon in mid-October my amniotic sac burst, and I told Randy that we'd need to go to the hospital that evening. At this news, Christopher burst into tears: "No! I don't want the baby to be born tomorrow!" I turned to him: "I don't think you're going to decide when this baby will be born." Christopher cried even harder. Finally, I understood what was troubling him. His second-grade class was to go to the Minneapolis zoo the next day, and he was afraid that, if the baby were born, he wouldn't be able to go. Once reassured, he calmed down, and Randy and I left for the hospital after a good friend arrived to stay with Christopher. Rachel Susanna was born the following day, October 17, 1985, after a difficult labor that culminated in a caesarean delivery. Despite my exhaustion, I was elated at having a daughter. I took great delight in responding to people's frequent question "Is this your first child?" with a cheerful nod and a recitation of Rachel's fine points. I was brought up short, however, the first time Randy was present when that question was asked. "No, I have a seven-year-old son," he replied. I felt silenced, diminished, and once again reminded that Randy and I were not sharing in the wonder of welcoming our first child into the world. I wish I could say that the months following Rachel's birth were easy ones. I wish I could affirm that, as soon as the baby was born, everything was fine. But it wasn't. I recovered from the caesarean quickly, and Rachel was as good-natured an infant as I could have imagined. While my family and friends made much of Rachel's arrival, it seemed to me that Randy hung back, hovering over Christopher, trying to make sure that he didn't feel excluded. With every present Rachel received, it seemed that Christopher pointed out he hadn't gotten one. Whenever a visitor held Rachel
33
Perspectives: Stepmothers and remarked on what a lovely baby she was, it seemed that Christopher diverted attention from his sister to himself. I wondered, would Rachel and I be shoved into the background? I devoted even more attention to Rachel, with whom I felt the kind of mother-child bond that I didn't feel with Christopher. Would I have felt more love for him if he had been a girl, I asked myself? No, I didn't think so. My feelings for him had to do with the constant reminders that he had a mother elsewhere, a mother who was giving to him and getting from him the kind of love and attention that I wasn't. During those first stressful months after Rachel's birth, when the four of us were starting to coalesce as a family despite Randy's unemployment, his mother's unexpected death, and my return to full-time teaching, Christopher had some very hard times. I am sorry to say that, in my attempts to create order out of what seemed like chaos, I gave him less attention than he deserved. It wasn't that I wanted to push him away, but he appeared to hold himself at a distance from me. Meanwhile, Randy devoted more attention to Christopher as I became more attached to Rachel. My relationship with Randy started to crack from the strain. We gave one another the silent treatment and accused one another of not caring about either our relationship or the family we had created. Things continued like this until June 1986, when Christopher went to his mother and stepfather's for the summer, I began a year's sabbatical from teaching, Randy found work, and Rachel grew out of infancy. For the first time in many months, I could sit back, catch my breath, and reflect on things. Did I want the situation to continue as it had been? I knew that the answer was no. What, then, was I willing to do to change my own attitudes and behaviors? A good deal of hard and painful work with an excellent feminist therapist helped me to remember what I had learned in codependency treatment: as the oldest of five children in an alcoholic family, I had learned early how to take control of situations, care for the needs of others, and discount my own needs and desires. All these tendencies had come to dominate my daily interactions, particularly with Randy and Christopher. It was also painful to admit to myself that, while I had chosen to undertake responsibility for Rachel, I hadn't made so conscious or willing a choice about Christopher. With the help of my therapist and women's support group, I made a key discovery: one reason why my relationship with Christopher was so problematic was that he reminded me of what I had been like as a childsensitive, inquisitive, strong-willed, and so terrified of making mistakes and being criticized that I would withdraw in silence rather than risk possible rejection by any adult. It was time to face my feelings about my own past.
34
Ten Times Harder Now, two years later, I'm tempted to report that my relationship with Christopher has resolved itself into sweetness and light. Of course, that's not the way real life works. 1 still have times when I'm angry and resentful, times when I'm guilty and apologetic. I've learned to let myself experience my feelings-whatever they might be-and to name them, both to myself and to others. For me, becoming a stepmother has been ten times harder than becoming a mother. Randy's and my attempts to create an "instant family" erupted into chaos immediately rather than slowly, forcing us to face issues that might otherwise have simmered for a long time before heating up to boiling. We continue to work on resolving these issues, with the recognition that the process is going to take a long time. As for me, 1 can now see that there are rarely true villains or heroes in a stepfamily situation. I'm learning how to operate not out of anger, guilt, or shame but out of an honest acceptance of the ways in which my own fears of rejection underlie not only my conscious thoughts and actions but also those that are subconscious. As someone who has always prided myself on being "in control," I'm discovering that it's sometimes excruciatingly hard to drop that mask of control and let my real feelings surface, especially if they are feelings of sadness, anger, or fear . Yet that is exactly what 1 most need to do. One day not long ago, when Christopher and 1 were home alone, he got out his album of baby pictures. We laughed as we looked at snapshots of him learning to sit up, crawl, walk, and play. We marveled at how much his little sister Rachel (whom he never calls his half-sister) looks like him. One photograph showed Christopher as a toddler, posing with his mother and his father. "You know, Suzanne," he said, "I don't remember anything about ever living with both my mom and my dad." 1 wanted to cry. Suddenly Christopher looked very little and vulnerable. 1 put my arms around him, stroked his hair, and we sat there like that for quite a while. Finally 1 told him, "Your dad and 1 both love you. Your mom and Patrick do, too." Then he got up and put the photograph album away. Little moments like that give me great hope for the future of my relationship as stepmother and stepson. 1 understand-and 1 accept-that 1 will never be Christopher's mother and that he will never be my son. 1 feel very sad and also tremendously relieved to have come to that realization, thanks, in good part, to my growing understanding of the ways in which my embracing of feminist parenting strategies, along with my movement away from codependent ones, is helping me establish a relationship with Christopher that is based not on control but on acceptance. It's important
35
Perspectives: Stepmothers for me to know that the relationship we are establishing will benefit our family as a whole and each of us as an individual. It has helped me, too, to read what Elizabeth Einstein (1985, p. 192) has noted about the realities of stepmothering: I was not a wicked stepmother offering my stepchildren poisoned fruit and dressing them in rags. Often I had to make decisions these youngsters disliked. All parents must; it is part of loving and responsibility. Loving my stepchildren differently from my own sons was not rooted in malice, but in the kind of human bonding that took place within the relationships. For me, stepmothering involves much hard work. It involves a good deal of stumbling and hesitation. It involves some anger, fear, and guilt. And it involves equal portions of respect, hope, and love.
Epilogue
Spring 1988: Since I first wrote this essay, I've come to understand more about how alcoholism and other addictions have shaped the ways in which our stepfamily has functioned and have contributed to the problems discussed in this essay. The problems have proved to be too great. Randy and I are no longer together. Rachel and I have been living in Brussels, Belgium, while I am on a Fulbright grant. When we return to Mankato several months from now, I hope to continue my relationship with Ch~isto pher, though in a different kind of living situation.
References
Beattie, Melody. Codependent No More. Center City, Minn.: Hazelden Foundation, 1987. Berman, Claire. Making It as a Stepparent: New Roles, New Rules. 2d ed. New York: Harper & Row, 1986. Burns, Cherie. Stepmotherhood: How to Survive Without Feeling Frustrated, Left Out, or Wicked. New York: Harper & Row, 1985. Clarke, Jean IlIsley. Self-Esteem: A Family Affair. Minneapolis, Minn.: Winston Press, 1978. Dreikurs, Rudolf, and Vicki Saltz. Children: The Challenge. New York: Hawthorn/Dutton, 1964.
Ten Times Harder Einstein, Elizabeth. The Stepfamily: Living, Loving and Learning. Boston: Shambhala Publications, 1985. Jarmulowski, Vicki. "Blended Families: A Growing American Phenomenon . . . Who are They?" Ms. 13, no. 8 (February 19 85): 33-34. Maddox, Brenda. Step-Parenting: How to Live With Other People's Children. London: Unwin Paperbacks, 1980. (Originally published as The Half Parent, London: Andre Deutsch, 1975.) Maglin, Nan Bauer. "It Could Not Be More Complicated." Ms. 13, no. 8 (February 19 8 5): 40, 45· Seixas, Judith S., and Geraldine Youcha. Children of Alcoholism: A Survivor's Manual. New York: Harper & Row, 1985 (originally published by Crown Publishers, 1985). Woititz, Janet Geringer. Adult Children of Alcoholics. Hollywood, Fla.: Health Communications, 1983.
37
3 My Extended Family Andrea Starr Alonzo
Obviously one of the unfortunate prerequisites to any stepfamily is divorce (or death). It is, in any case, painful for all concerned, and if the particulars of the previous relationship, either emotional or legal, are not resolved before the new party enters the picture, it's sure to complicate things even more. When I met Brandon he was a lonely man who hung out in bars (I was working in one). As a child I was already today's modern woman and I promised myself not to marry until my late twenties. I didn't want to be a child bride; I wanted to experience life first. Then, at twenty-five, when something in me clicked and said it was time to meet Mr. Right, I met Brandon. One slight fact that I had failed to consider in my perfect plan was that at our ages (Brandon is six years older than I) we would certainly by then have a past. My own was fairly uncomplicated-no marriages, no children. Brandon, however, was a different story. One night a couple of months after I was hooked, it occurred to me to ask how a great guy like Brandon could reach his early thirties without getting "caught." It turned out that he had, still, a wife and two daughters. In the same breath I was told that the marriage was over, and now he "had a reason to get a divorce." It didn't sound like a line then, and I believed it. But here I was, the "other woman." I detested the idea of being in love with a man who was legally bound to someone else even if, as he'd told me, his wife had left him. The fuzziness surrounding Brandon's relationship with his wife (now his ex-wife) and his delayed divorce turned out to be the stormiest issue in our relationship before we married. Meanwhile, I soon met Brandon's daughters, ages five and ten, two beautiful brown-skinned dolls who had both inherited their father's large eyes. We got along just fine. They never seemed ruffled by the fact that their daddy had a girlfriend, although they had their particular ways of
My Extended Family dealing with it. The older one, Myla, was especially protective of her mother's image. She was always careful not to reveal much about her, particularly if it was unflattering. Often I would catch her nudge her sister, Joy, who at five would indiscriminately blurt out anything that came to mind. I respected Myla's way of handling the situation. I, in turn, have always been sensitive enough not to infringe on their mother's sovereign place in their lives. I did see the children fairly often at first, although there were always hassles about the mother letting them go. Often Brandon would drive all the way to New Jersey to pick them up and return a couple of hours later, long-faced and empty-handed. I would always be heartbroken and furious myself. Intimidated by her tactics, he went to get the girls less and less. Now I rarely see them. Nevertheless we managed to have lots of fun times together, and as Myla approached her teen years we grew closer. She found that she could talk to me in a way that she never could with her mother. I think she enjoyed having a grown-up for a friend. Myla had a tendency toward sullenness, though, that caused problems later. We saw how much the girls enjoyed being with their father. He said it was because they witnessed a side of him they never saw at home-a happy side. Since I'd never met the mother, I began to form my own opinions, which naturally weren't good. Especially when I heard of little incidents, such as the time Joy was writing Christmas cards and her mother caught her writing one for me-she snatched it from her and tore it up. I began to want to "rescue" them from that unhappy woman. We even talked of having them come and live with us after we were married. Finally Brandon got his divorce, and we made immediate plans to get married. Our first son, Jason, was on the way, and we hadn't a moment to waste. I had encouraged Brandon to talk openly with his daughters about all this, and he said he would. When I asked him how they had responded to the news of our wedding, he said, "Fine." When I subsequently mentioned it to them over the phone, I got a completely different reaction. They were shocked and upset (they didn't even know!). This was the first open display of rejection they had ever shown toward me. Not an unreasonable reaction under the circumstances. They, especially Joy, had been hoping for a reconciliation between their parents. Meanwhile, another wrinkle began to form. I was in graduate school and working odd jobs. I stopped working altogether when Jason was born. We were having money problems, and the child-support money dwindled, then stopped. While this would have made an excellent excuse for the mother, I somehow felt it was really not the basis for the limited visitation. Nevertheless, even though we were broke, I felt that Brandon should have
39
Perspectives: Stepmothers somehow done better by the girls. Not seeing them and not paying? There was already a part of me that was guilty for having their father when they didn't. So no matter how broke we were, I would never deny them for us. This became an issue well into our marriage. I used to nag him like crazy to find a way to get them the money they deserved (and us, too, poor thing) and fight for his right to see them. I'd tell him that they'd grow to resent him. He seemed to believe, however, that they would grow up and see the mother as the villain in all this. I doubt it. She's got the upper hand. And she apparently does nothing to uphold their image of their father. She'd tell them that their father wasn't supporting them financially. She told Myla that we were not legally married because they were not divorced. She even pulled a stunt straight out of a soap opera: not long after our first child was born, she had a baby, and she tried to put the word out in the family that Brandon was the father. Thank God this seed of doubt didn't take root. I guess there are any number of reasons why a man who loves his family would distance himself from them, besides dollars and cents. Not giving financial support breeds guilt and embarrassment. Or, as in Brandon's case, dealing with their mother may be an excruciating experience. Maybe he even subconsciously wants to punish her for denying him his children. The money-visitation issue is really a vicious cycle. Then too, having a parttime relationship with one's children is much more difficult than a fulltime one. It's easier not to deal with painful situations; it's easier to put them off. I think the tendency for men to do this is greater than for women. When Brandon does communicate with their mother, it's usually through Joy. He avoids direct confrontation with her as much as possible. He never refers to her by her name, always as "the children's mother." To add to things, Brandon and Myla have a strange relationship. Brandon has tended to outwardly favor Joy, who has a visibly sweeter disposition. As Myla got older, she became moodier. Even so, I could still communicate with her pretty well. As she entered her teens and began to experience discord with her mother, she'd drop complaints about her, which I'd happily lap up. The first antimaternal outburst occurred when Myla's mother made her have her hair cut when she was twelve. I was surprised at this display of anger toward her mother; from there, unfortunately it got worse. At fifteen, Myla and I had another enlightening conversation. I was braiding her hair, which generally relaxes the tongue, and she began to explain to me her feelings about her father's marriage to me. She told me she was glad her father had married me. I couldn't believe I was hearing this.
4°
My Extended Family "But what about your reaction when we told you about the wedding?" I asked her. She explained that that was because it happened so suddenly. They hadn't had the chance to adjust to a divorce between their parents. That was a legitimate complaint, I felt. She went on to say that she realized her father was unhappy with her mother, and that she really didn't think her mom was cut out for wife- and motherhood. She was unaffectionate and insensitive. That sounded like an astute assessment of her mother from what I'd heard. A typically rebellious teenager, Myla became increasingly difficult for all of us to cope with. They reside in an affluent town in New Jersey, and Myla of course wants to keep up with the crowd, which is wealthy kids who are often granted the freedom and money to do as they please. She refuses to understand that her parents can't afford that world. Eventually we began to hear rumors that Myla was smoking cigarettes and marijuana. She began to stay out whenever she wished, and her mother couldn't do a thing with her. Once she even called Brandon to help discipline Myla for getting caught smoking in school. Myla began to be rude to me and show open resentment toward her father. I finally had to give her my first "scolding" about respect for her father, regardless of his shortcomings. I think I did a pretty good job, because she apologized and things were all right between them for a while. A few months ago, however, she and her father got into the last in a series of explosive fights. She was arguing with her mother when Brandon happened to be there, and he tried to intervene, whereupon Myla locked herself into the bathroom and yelled through the door at Brandon. "Go away! You're not my father! Go back to Anne and the boys. You've never been a father to me, so just get out of my life!" Brandon stopped speaking to her. When graduation rolled around, I had to urge him to go. "You're the adult," I told him. "You can't afford to miss this milestone in her life by holding grudges. You have to set the example," He went, they kissed and made up, and we're all proud of what a fine young lady she's grown up to be. She's still sullen, though. She had also invited me to attend the ceremonies, but I made the excuse that it was a school day, and I had to get the boys to bed. I really wanted her mother to be able to enjoy this event \vithout any discomfort. She'd earned it. I had long since begun to soften my attitude toward her, despite her acts. A broken marriage, for whatever reasons, is a difficult thing. Yet she had, with or without the help of her husband, put one child through high school and was well on the way to putting the other. They weren't
Perspectives: Stepmothers rich, but the children wanted for nothing in the way of material needs or comforts. If she's fallen short on the other part, well, who's perfect? She'd done a good job. Brandon has been supporting them fairly regularly this year. He and Myla are speaking, and a lot of the rough edges have smoothed out. I admit that there have been times when I've wished that it was just Brandon and me, and that he didn't have such concrete reminders of his life before me. For me, the main thrust of being a stepmother is simply that they are an extension of their father, whom I love. I share some of the excitement, pride, apprehension, and pain of watching them grow. But I have never tried to force my "stepmother" status upon them, whatever that means. It wasn't until a few weeks ago, when Myla accompanied me to the hairdresser's and he asked her relationship to me, when she first heard me identify her as my stepdaughter. I deemphasize that title as much as possible. To them I am simply their father's wife. My stormy relationship (or lack of one) with Brandon's ex-wife notwithstanding, I believe my tendency to downplay the "step" part of my family is a common trait in black culture. If you ask my Guyanese husband how many sisters and brothers he has, he'll tell you, "thirty-nine." Well, of course many of them are "steps," but they are not labeled that way. I have never heard my husband refer to his father's wife as his stepmother, and I seriously doubt if that term ever entered his mind. For one thing, blacks tend to feel their mothers' special place is sacred and cannot be tampered with. I once had a student who said, "As long as I have my mother, I wouldn't call anyone my stepmother." Another cultural explanation for the lack of distinction between "steps" may lie in an old African tradition that is still prevalent in many parts of the continent: polygamous relationships. In African culture the more wives and children a man has, the wealthier he is. This precept has continued to flourish among blacks in Western civilization. What else would you call a man who has thirty-nine children by four women? And it's common knowledge among them! Of course he couldn't marry them all; it's illegal. And of course he doesn't say (or probably even recognize) that he's practicing polygamy. Technically he's not, since he's not married to them all. But no matter what we call it, this strong cultural tradition must surely have ramifications in transported Africans. My husband made me painfully aware of this idea when I couldn't understand (was in fact quite condemning of) his mother for continuing to have children by a man she knew she'd never marry. Similarly, she's in a panic for her eldest granddaughter, nearing thirty, to begin having children before it's too late. Never mind that she can't marry the man (he's already married). To her, marriage is nice, but having children is more important.
My Extended Family That's why when Jason was on the way, Brandon's attitude toward marriage was "What's the rush?" My mother's explanation for "outside" children is closely linked to the African one. She attributes it to the black man's lack of power in Western society. This is by way of justifying her own father's case. She, of course the all-time bourgeois, ignores her "halfs" as much as possible. That must be the white, middle-class thing to do. To the rest of the Jordans, however, Sam, Bud, and Edith are family. Again, though, we see the "children are wealth" principle. "Outside" relationships and children are nothing new in any society, human beings being what they are. It's how they are treated that's different. For mainstream Americans it was always something to hide. But for blacks, the closer they are culturally to their African roots, the less of a hidden taboo it is when out-of-wedlock parenting occurs. The new wave of divorces has made the multiple family more of an issue for us all. But for blacks, stepfamilies are simply another form of the extended family.
43
4 Stepmother Carol Ascher
Louise pulled a cigarette from her smooth leather purse as she and her stepdaughter inched their way out of the theater toward the crowded lobby. "Shall we go for coffee or soda?" she asked, touching the soft skin of Ricky's arm. Going for something to eat had become part of their theater afternoons together. For almost a year, Ricky had come in alone on the bus-a big step, at first, for a sheltered twelve-year-old girl-and the two had spent their Saturday afternoons together. When Louise and Ricky sat next to each other in the red velvet seats of a theater, they created a protected space where fondness reigned. Louise felt her mouth go dry at the thought of losing these afternoons. "You know where I'd like to go?" Ricky asked, as she flung her arms into her woolen coat. "To the Stage Delicatessen, where we got those huge turkey sandwiches and saw Kris Kristoffersen. Remember?" Louise smiled. "We could do that. But I'd sort of like to go someplace where I could have a drink. I think I know a restaurant you'll really love!" Louise opened her arm so that Ricky could link hers through it, but Ricky tucked her hand in the silky lining of her stepmother's coat pocket and grinned up at her as she squeezed up against the fur coat like a cat. All this they had together, thought Louise as she led Ricky in and out among the shoppers to 57th Street and the Russian Tea Room. The question was, could they keep it up without Donald, the husband-father who connected them?
"Stepmother" received a PEN/NEA Syndicated Short Fiction award in 1983. It was originally published in Sunday news magazines around the country and in Arts Review, Winter of 1987, as well as in The Available Press: PEN Short Story Collection (New York: Ballantine, 1985). Copyright © 1983 by Carol Ascher.
44
Stepmother Louise had been nearly twenty-nine-a journalist who was doing well because she had given everything to her career-when she had met and rapidly married the elusive Donald. Then, what she had seen was that he would give her the time and space to continue her work. Now she looked back on five hard years of quenching Donald's first wife's anger, of finding a way to be with Ricky that everyone could tolerate, of holding Donald to her and to her home. She had had to step so carefully; and always, she had felt her hands were tied. Louise inhaled her cigarette, drawing in the smoke to stop the dark thoughts. Ricky was wearing the camel's-hair coat she and Donald had given her for Christmas. The girl's black curly hair shone like an eclipsed sun above the collar. Ricky had a face like a Mediterranean Lolita. And just these last months, little mounds had appeared like soft marshmallows through her sweaters. Soon she would begin to go out with boys. From Louise's own selfish viewpoint, Ricky's had been a short childhood. Everything seemed to fall through Louise's bound hands. Donald, whom she still loved with a swell of pain, when had he walked out with his suitcase? Was it two weeks or three weeks already? Somewhere another woman believed that she could hold him; but she too would become confused between an arm extended in love and in grasping, until Donald would once more be on his way. "Did you like the play?" Ricky was asking in her sweet bouncy voice. Louise felt the question like an offering. "I don't know. I used to like it a great deal," she said, collecting herself. "I used to think A Dol/'s House was one of the great plays. I used to love Nora's final speech when she's leaving Torvald." Every woman dreamed of being Nora, Louise thought, a delicate flower breaking out at last from the protective love of her husband into full womanly independence. Yet it rarely happened that way. Instead, Donald had left Ricky's mother (a strong and resourceful woman like herself), just as he had now left her for another woman who would probably have much to give. "Listen," she said, putting her arm around Ricky and giving her a squeeze, "that play is from a time when it seemed that if women could just leave men they could be whole beings. I guess it's still true." After all, she had come to understand Donald, see his grave inadequacies, without being able to leave him. "Only maybe the men get to it first," she gave a hard laugh. "I don't know, it all seems much more complicated." "Torvald wasn't such a good husband. I didn't like him," Ricky said decisively. "'No, he's not very likeable in the end." Louise squeezed again, as if protecting Ricky from a strong wind.
45
Perspectives: Stepmothers They had reached the Russian Tea Room, with its darkened windows and thick, discreet door. Louise steered Ricky through the guilded entrance, and they gave their coats to the woman in the hat-check booth. An elderly waiter in a red jacket led them to a table for two along one of the mirrored walls. The Edwardian lamps and heavy silver gave the room an Old World opulence, and made it seem as if they were royalty or actors on an elegant stage. Ricky blew out her cheeks and opened her black eyes wide. Louise winked. "Do you come here a lot?" Ricky fingered the pink damask tablecloth. "Not a lot, but sometimes. Sometimes I come here for business lunches." Louise remembered how, as a dazzled teenager, she had first gazed at the Stork Club with the same wondrous eyes. The Club no longer existed, she didn't know when it had come down. "It's really elegant! I bet famous people come here," Ricky said, always on the lookout. Louise smiled. "Maybe we'll even see some." When the waiter came, Louise ordered a double scotch and a bowl of borscht. "Why don't you try a Russian crepe?" she suggested. "What's that?" Ricky wrinkled her nose. "A pancake filled with sour cream and caviar." "Will I like it?" "I think so. Try it. You can order something else later, if you don't." "Okay." Louise felt her mind pulling away again. How was she to bring up the subject? Should she just start talking? Why couldn't Donald have done this before leaving town? When the scotch arrived, she gulped it down. The heat burned her throat and stomach like a shock, and for a moment her mind clouded. Ricky had started to chatter about The Treasure of the Sierre Madre, which she had seen on late-night television. She was a movie fan, and sometimes stayed up till all hours by herself. "You can ask me what year it was made," she said. "What year?" asked Louise. "Nineteen forty-three," Ricky said, beaming. "Ask me other Bogart movies. Also who starred in them." Louise complied, but her mind wandered. How had Ricky gotten this exaggerated energy for competence, so like Donald's? It was strange how a man could leave his family for all but rare Sunday visits, and still pieces of his personality would stay with them. The crepe came. Ricky puffed out her cheeks at the delicate pancake,
Stepmother with its white cream floating outward and tiny black fish eggs like blackbirds sailing over a cloud. "We had caviar once at home, and I didn't like it," Ricky admitted. "But I think this is going to be more like a blintz." How did one say it? How did one discuss it with a twelve-year-old? Your father and I . . . What was the end of the sentence? What questions and answers followed? For a moment, she felt almost grateful to Donald for having forced the situation. Yet why should his daughter go through this a second time? "Is it good?" she asked, seeing Ricky's confused face. "I think so. I can't tell yet." "Do you want to taste my borscht?" "In a minute." Ricky spread her pink napkin neatly on her lap. Louise's own mother had warned her against Donald. She had said that a man running from a marriage would leave her as he had left his wife. She still had her mother to tell about Donald. Louise smiled at Ricky spooning the thick cream. "Well, I guess the caviar's okay." At home, what she had feared was crying like a victim as she told the girl, or, as bad, showing the anger she felt toward Donald. But now the tears she felt behind her heavy eyelids were for Ricky. A woman at work had once said how her child had kept her going in the first months after her husband had left. A mother could touch the skin of her child for hope when her courage faltered. Yet Ricky had come with, and might well leave with, the father. Ricky was looking up at her with a serious expression. "I forgot, I wanted to ask you something." Louise tensed. Could the girl have figured out what was happening? What traces might Donald have carelessly left? "I've been thinking about my name. Do you think I should call myself by my real name?" Louise's diaphragm relaxed, and the breath she took was almost painful. "You mean Rebecca?" "Mommy doesn't like the name, because she says Daddy made her name me after his mother. But I think I should use my real name. What do you think, is it a good name?" "I like the name. Rebecca." Louise rolled out the letters slowly, aware that she was entering a web of parental bitterness. "I think Rebecca is a good name." She sipped the watery end of her scotch. "But then fashions in names change, so it's hard to say what kind of name you'll want when you're in high school or college."
47
Perspectives: Stepmothers "Ricky," the girl wrinkled her nose, and the dark of her nostrils twitched like a filly. "It just sounds too boyish." "It's getting pretty hard for you to seem boyish these days," Louise teased. "Well, I think I might start using Rebecca. Daddy will be pleased, won't he?" "Probably." Louise smiled, and her lips seemed cracked and dry. While Ricky went to the bathroom, Louise paid the check. They had finished eating without her being able to say anything. Perhaps out on the street, she thought, with the noise of cars and the rush of people; here everything seemed too solemn. Outside, the street lights had come on. The greenish color of the early evening sky sent a rush of pleasure through Louise. She would be all right on her own: she'd make plans and meet new people. And she would find a way to keep Ricky in her life. "Let's walk back to the bus depot," she said, taking Ricky's arm. They strolled along Broadway, slowing down in front of the stores that sold cheap costume jewelry, theater makeup, and exotic undergarments. Louise remembered Ricky had once asked her if she would ever buy the brassieres with holes for the nipples. Feeling relaxed, Louise had confided, "No, but sometimes I'd like to," and they both had giggled. A little farther south were the shops selling exaggerated platform shoes, and then on 47th Street, the big Castro Convertible sofa store with its couches like giant colorful snakes filling the show windows. "Listen," said Louise, with a sudden burst of courage. "Your father and I aren't going to live with each other any more." She felt Ricky's body slow down deep inside, as if the machinery had hit a chink and was coming to a slow stop. There must be another sentence she ought to add, something to smooth it out and make it less abrupt. "What I mean is, he and I probably aren't going to be married any longer. I think your father feels he's been married basically all his adult life, since he was very young. You know, he married your mother and then right away he married me." How reasonable it sounded; of course he would want to leave. "You mean, you're going to get a divorce?" Louise searched for a cigarette in her leather purse. She lit one and drew in a long breath. "Yes, probably, but not right away. What we're going to do now is live separately. He'll probably be able to tell you more when you see each other, but I wanted to tell you myself." Perhaps it wasn't her right to tell Ricky, but Donald had left town without telling his daughterthe one piece of his behavior that could infuriate her whenever she recalled
Stepmother it. With his busy schedule, his traveling, and his reluctance to confront difficult matters, Louise knew it would be months before he told his daughter. He would even be pleased that she had said something, relieved him of that awful first sentence she herself had found so hard. "I don't know; maybe he should have told you first." "No, that's good," Ricky answered distractedly. She was working out something in her mind. Finally she said, "Does that mean you won't be my stepmother any more?" "Did you think of me as your stepmother?" Louise answered, grateful. She had always been afraid that, with Ricky's mother taking care of the child, "stepmother" gave her more legitimacy than she was allowed. "Sort of. A little bit. I sometimes told the kids at school I had a mother and a stepmother." They walked awhile in silence. Louise was trying to figure out how to say that she still wanted to be Ricky's . . . But that was the problem, there would no longer be a word. Without the connection of kinship, a relationship between a grown woman and a little girl sounded pathetic and almost perverse. It made her seem too needy, like the lonely old people who had "little brothers" or played foster parents on the weekend. "I guess we could still go to plays," she heard Ricky say, "I mean, you usually get the tickets free anyway." That was it-how simple! "I'd take you even if I have to pay for the tickets," Louise laughed with relief. "It's just that my mother's going to think it's really weird." Louise felt stung. "You mean, us going to the theater together?" "No, I mean Daddy breaking up with you." She laughed. "I guess she'll think it serves me right." "She didn't think Daddy should marry someone else right away." So many complications for a girl to figure out, Louise thought. She couldn't imagine working out all these angles when she was twelve. But then even suburban girls like Ricky were more sophisticated nowadays. "Your mom was probably right," she said, offering a gesture of reconciliation toward the woman who had been such a constant shadow. They had walked up 41st Street to avoid the wild hustle of the movies and arcades on 42nd. Now the Port of New York Authority faced them squarely, its purple brick shining new and elegant from the street lamps. Inside the Saturday night crowd was like a waterfall flowing in from one door and pouring out toward the multitude of bus outlets. "'Can I have some candy for the way home?" Ricky asked. They stopped at a newsstand, and Louise glanced at the headlines while Ricky picked up a bag of Red Hots.
49
Perspectives: Stepmothers It was easy not to say anything as they moved rapidly along with the crowd through the vast depot. Louise felt the numbness of someone walking mechanically toward a fate long ago sealed. At stall number 237, the red and tan New Jersey bus prepared to leave. Ricky stood on her toes to give a quick kiss. Louise put her arms around the girl and held her with unexpected desperation. "Go! I love you," she said, her voice breaking.
5°
5 benjamin Deborah Rosenfelt I wrote this poem when Ben's father and I had ended our relationship and I thought I would never see either of them again. Happily, I was wrong. Even after his father's subsequent death, Ben's mother, newly remarried and living in another state, encouraged the two of us to keep in touch. Now Ben visits me sometimes-and plays big brother to the daughter I adopted when I realized, through him, how much I wanted to mother and how deeply I could love a child "not of my body." Child not of my body You come to me in my dreams No labor of mine impelled you into life I felt no awe When your first words rose like dumplings When you explored the empty air By the third-floor window No terror urged me gasping through the night Ignorantly I moved Down other streets In another city I knew what would be for the father The rage in the ache for the flesh the lean and lank and bone of him the sweet gold bud of his lust.
51
Perspectives: Stepmothers Who could haveHow can 1Child not of my bodyForetold, appease This other hunger? You dance for me in my dreams Child not of my body You swim to sleep in my arms You ride the difficult alleys Never using your hands You call to me in my dreams Child not of my flesh You call to me from doorways From the secret banks of streams. I answer. I wake. In a year you'll forget my face In two, my name There is no name for this loss. Child not of my blood I could build your bones from the dust.
6 Parenting on the Edge Sophia Carestia
Being on the edge is paradoxical. Sometimes ['m on the sidelines, left out, "on the fringe." Other times I think I'm on the edge of a wonderful discovery, on the cutting edge, in the vanguard, handling an extended family in a new and better way. Until I find myself torn between good intentions and the pull of circumstances; then the cutting edge is on me, a razor to my heart. But it is certainly an interesting vantage point and, yes, the view from the edge can be exhilarating if you're not too distracted watching your step.
About ten years ago, I began seeing a man recently separated from his wife and daughter. Joseph and I met while in graduate school. He still clung to his wedding band like a tiny life preserver and in those early days talked a lot about his terrific relationship with his wife, Monica. They'd married very young, in 1969, gone to college and then graduate school together. They were very radical, extremely hip, the most hip group of people I had ever met, even though at first I could only imagine Monica and Constance. Connie, the daughter, was seven then and called her parents by their names, although, I was told, she went through about two weeks of calling them "Mom" and "Dad." The question of stepparenting hardly arises in a context where parenting itself proceeds against the institutionalized grain. I never thought of myself as any sort of parent. "Friend" was as far as I thought I could, or should, go. Married in the late 1960s, divorced in the mid-1970S, and founding households in the 1980s. Alas, our collective experience seemed to mirror the decades in true People magazine style. First rebellion, heady and sweet. Then retrenchment and a search for our selves, all four of us. The mean
53
Perspectives: Stepmothers 1980s found Connie grown up to be a gorgeous suburban shoe fetishist in the Sunbelt with Monica, who had established a great pair of careers but not found a permanent partner. joseph and I worked like crazy in New York and wished we could afford a down payment on anything that didn't have a landlord attached. The idealism all of us share is not something any of us will give up. We three adults are all left-leaning academics and writers. Connie, for all of her teenage sang-froid, does write letters to the editor and counsel other teens on drug abuse. We have enjoyed being critical, nonviolent intellectuals, devoted to an egalitarian ethic of nonconfrontation. But in many ways these ideals backfired on us as we tried to live through the past decade. Perhaps our solutions were too creative. Take the matter of getting to know one another. At first, Monica wanted to meet me; she thought I sounded "good" for joseph. We were all so civilized, so laid back, and so unanxious about all this, wouldn't it be nice? Luckily, geography intervened, and we put off getting acquainted for six years. Yes, you've noticed the first peculiarity here, right? We always seemed to have good intentions. We just had difficulty carrying them out. It began with the divorce itself eight years ago, when the promised agreement on joint custody didn't quite work out. Monica's lawyer simply stood up and filed for sole custody, surprising the hell out of joseph, who hadn't even retained a lawyer. And then all our visits together with Connie. She would stay three or four times a year, holidays and summer vacations. We'd all try to plan, with great good will, the when, how, and what. Connie would spend hours on the phone with her father. He'd say, Well why don't you and Monica make the reservations convenient to you? And she'd say, Great. Monica would get on the phone. He'd say, How about those reservations? She'd say, Great. I'd say (after they hung up), Maybe we ought to do it. No, everything was just fine. Next week we'd go through it all again until finally someone would grab the last seat on the most expensive flight between Tampa and New York. And believe me, we all wanted to see each other. This particular example of our team's disorganization culminated one Christmas. Monica and Connie were in the Northeast with grandparents and joseph was anxious (he was sitting up by late 1985, a little less laid back) to spend a week with Connie. Various family problems intervened and Connie's one-hour plane ride was put off again and again. By the time she arrived at 8:00 P.M. on New Year's Eve, joseph was standing up, ready to kill. So how did we pass the evening? Very pleasantly, of course. Because her father is not part of her everyday life, Connie cannot bear any conflict with him or about him. That
54
Parenting on the Edge night, no one said anything to anyone about how tough the past week had been. (She was fifteen by then; were the snafus in plans, the endless delays and dillydallying still the fault of her mother?) Connie, caught in the middle, preserved a discreet silence. She admired my hair, I admired her boots, she borrowed my jacket. And the whole gang trooped off to Danceteria to disco the night away. Last Christmas we did considerably better. For one thing, joseph and I announced our "engagement." Yes, after knowing each other for ten years and sharing a household for five, we decided to marry. Our parents got together for dinner. joseph told Monica, who was thunderstruck. He told Connie, who sweetly congratulated him. (She and I have yet to discuss it.) We can't help but notice, however, that since the announcement, Monica carefully includes me much more in plans and conversations. I suddenly feel obliged to inquire more closely into her life. Things have changed. This is not to say our commitment to alternative lifestyles was wasted or even gone. But it does point up how the sum of the gazes of others combines with economic necessity (can we call this "society"?) to weigh upon even the most fervent personal dedication. (Should we have married sooner? Would it have made a difference? It seems to have.) Which brings me to our central anecdote. Connie very much wanted her father to attend her high school commencement in Tampa. She also invited me. Now although Connie has often invited joseph to visit her in Florida, he has never managed to get there. Mostly because it was the scene of the breakup of his marriage and he had ugly memories of a good thing gone bad. But also because every time he brought it up, Monica would insist that he could stay at their house. Clearly this was not what joseph had in mind. (What are the limits to the friendship that a former spouse can insist upon "for the sake of the children"?) Half included in these double-binding and loaded invitations (joseph invited me, just adding to his problems), I certainly hadn't pushed for immediately getting on a plane. During Connie's Easter vacation, we planned excitedly the trip to Florida. She'd drive us around in her vintage Mustang, or lend it to us. We'd have hours at the beach. She and her dad would show me all the best places for seafood. Her friends would meet her youthful-looking father; she was very proud of his looks. She left New York, promising to find us an inexpensive, quaintly tacky, and not too high-tech motel on the beach. I started hearing joseph on the phone saying, So how about that hotel? Oh, no time yet; well, OK, but listen, honey, we need to make plane reservations. After three Sunday evenings of this, I finally marched to the travel agent to buy a package deal. I did have the sense, however, to call Connie and ask if the Green Flamingo was okay. (How horrible if I were to be responsible for depositing her father in an "uncool" place.)
55
Perspectives: Stepmothers She was surprised to hear from me, and I felt a little sad. There was a pause as I mentioned the Green Flamingo. It was okay, she thought it was funny, they'd just had a party there last week. I was worried. I wondered about the hotel; I wondered about Connie's parties. (There had been a time, when she was fourteen or fifteen, that she confided in me about the teenage wasteland of Tampa. Alas, this had stopped in the last two years). I wondered if Connie would ever, in fact, say, "It's an awful roach dump, a super massage parlor." No, I decided, she wouldn't. She was too discreet to incriminate herself and disappoint me. It was set. We started to work on our tans in the back yard. (I bought SPF 8 sunscreen anyway.) Then, three days before we were to leave, Monica called. (Now remember, all this comes secondhand from joseph, who works very hard making everyone sound good to everyone else.) It seems that the social leader of Connie's class had parents who were planning a champagne reception before commencement. But only "real" parents were invited; each kid could bring only two. (One of each sex, one presumes. It was the Stern-Whitehead approach to parenting: only those who had contributed genetic matter could come-to hell with nurture, this was a celebration of nature. Perhaps they'd pass out little "egg" and "sperm" buttons. If I could smuggle myself in would that make me a "stepegg"?) Monica said that Connie was embarrassed and didn't want to bring it up because of me. joseph was angry and said, Connie was right, it shouldn't have been brought up at all. Why are you bringing it up? I couldn't go, he wouldn't go, and she shouldn't go. Of course, of course, Monica hastened to agree. It was a terribly stupid and reactionary idea. Well, bye, see you Wednesday. I guess I had a low moment in my years of "nonstepparenting" when he told me about this conversation (one of hundreds of "My Conversations with Monica" I have listened to over the years). I ranted. I raved. I struck theatrical poses. Right. No gigolos, no floozies, no new husbands, no second wives allowed. My distress at being summarily dealt out of "parenting" surprised me; was I more interested in the role than I thought? I forlornly contemplated my new floral beach shorts. Not even my new status as "fiancee" could help me now; I was in for it. We arrived blinking and sweating in the Florida sun. No Connie to meet the plane. Then, in one of those fits of parental insight that almost do make you believe in the magic of "genetic matter," joseph went off to find her at the baggage carousel. She looked wonderful-tanned, blonde, and genuinely happy. After an embarrassing moment when we thought the Mustang was lost, Connie whizzed us off to her house. It was great to see her room, her cats, her prom photos. Even the trees
Parenting on the Edge outside had been described in detail. It didn't matter that we felt a bit awkward standing around in the clean kitchen, listening to the air conditioning hum. We invited her to dinner, but Connie had to pick up her friend Cheryl, who was flying in for graduation weekend. So joseph and I took off for the hotel, leaving her to wait for her mother's car to come home with her mother from work. The coming of Cheryl did not please joseph. The next day, she and Connie arrived at the beach, promptly swam for half an hour, then went up to our room to "dry off," only to come down and announce they were going for some lunch. Joseph wondered aloud if Cheryl would tag along all weekend. As it turned out, it didn't much matter. Connie was so busy, we barely saw her. Of course, it was graduation; there were parties and then the mornings after parties. In fact, it became painfully obvious that, after all those years, when she finally had her father there in Florida, Connie didn't know what to do with him. One afternoon, in desperation, we stopped in after looking around Tampa. Connie stood at the door chatting with joseph, who'd run to see if she was home. She didn't invite him in. He stood in the 97-degree heat, I sat in the 98-percent humidity in the car, and Connie unconsciously guarded her, and her mother's, air-conditioned sanctum. (We knew her boyfriend was working, so it wasn't that.) It was even worse for Monica, who tried to make us both welcome. Perhaps a buffet before commencement with all of her friends, some of whom had been water carriers during the divorce, wasn't the best way to do that. Nonetheless, in our usual fashion we all tried to rise above petty feelings of regret, jealousy, and anxiety. (joseph regretted not seeing more of Connie, Monica was jealous seeing us up close, and I was anxious about everything.) But face to face this was much harder. What did we expect, turning up on their territory after all these years? That territory was far from New York City. Connie grew up in a nice, clean suburb, in a world where leisure time was considered an opportunity to shop. For some reason, it was thought that parental models of serious reading and serious politics would outweigh the material facts of the local mall as social center. Of course, that was not so. And then, speaking personally, Connie couldn't foresee that in fact, once we set foot in their house, she would adopt her mother's attitudes of distanced politeness. Monica's dogged ability to remain cool under fire seemed to put a damper on us all. We stood around in the heat, pretending to be cool as cucumbers, saying far less than we could on the phone. Joseph thinks Connie was completely boggled by having to deal with both her parents at the same time, and "at home" for the first time since
57
Perspectives: Stepmothers the divorce. Unwilling to play favorites, she reacted with utter fairness and ignored both of them-and all nearby adults. Cool detachment had, after all, been a style presented to Connie since she'd been very small. If Joseph is right, should we opt for passion, have a "discussion," "get it all out in the open"? We don't think so. Even though we are not happy with where nonconfrontation has taken us, joseph and Monica think that taking up any issues now may be misunderstood by Connie as claims for attention. It is hard for divorced families to judge how much of their teenagers' behavior is reaction to the stress of separation and how much to the stress of growing up itself. Parents accustomed to providing a secure center for their young children tend to imagine that the world still revolves around them. We're trying to act as though Connie's world is now much bigger than that: it includes, especially, college in the fall and the enticing first departure from her room, her cats, and her mother's house. (Are we still kidding ourselves?) It is harder for Monica, who has had custody of Connie and lived with her every day of her seventeen years. It is easier for Connie and joseph, who developed ways to cope with separation long ago. For me, it will be a relief not to have Connie's contact with us mediated through Monica's relationship (or the memory of her relationship) with joseph. But I do know that a woman's mother is with her forever, and there is nothing that can change the fact of a history the three of them share. I have also realized, however, that because of my love for joseph, I am thoroughly implicated in Connie's life. Being married really does matter less than shared time and experience (the real stuff of "history"). We have all, especially me, finally admitted that I helped to fashion some of the last decade of our collective past. After graduation, we were standing in the stadium. The night was cooling down; a breeze mussed Connie's beautiful curls and she was surreptitiously trying to batten them down as her father snapped pictures. I took the camera and suggested the three of them stand together. I may not exactly be in that picture, but I helped to make it.
7 The Barbie Doll Fight Gale McGovern
"But she has no feet." "Sure she does. They're just not big like yours." And that was how this particular fight had started. Sally and Maggie were enjoying the luxury of breakfast and the Sunday papers in bed-the same bed, without the artifice of separate rooms in the same house. This was Julie's weekend with her father and his new wife, so for two days in a row Sally and Maggie could wake up together and have their morning snuggle immediately. On weekdays they had to wait until one of them had gotten up, dressed herself and Julie, fed Julie breakfast, measured out the day's medicine, taken her to the babysitter, and come back to undress and join the other in bed, full of acrid day-energy instead of s\veet-smelling sleep. The ritual of the morning snuggle in bed was so important to them that they were willing to add an extra half hour to their schedule to accommodate it. They took turns getting Julie to the babysitter, but still there was nothing like opening your eyes and drowsily kissing your lover awake. Maggie hated this skulking around; it was against her nature. From the first stirrings of the gay movement in the late 1960s until three years ago, when she had met Sally at a crafts show in New York City, she was out to everybody, including her boss, her co-workers, and her family. Some members of her family hadn't liked it-one brother was still not speaking to her-but when you got right down to it there was nothing they could do beyond withdrawal of affection. All in all, Maggie always said it was worth it not to have to lie or hesitate before telling the truth. Now she lived in a small upstate town, still in culture shock from leaving Greenwich Village, and spent considerable energy propping up a lie before all but a few close friends. Maggie and Sally told people they were cousins; they kept all suspicious books and periodicals in a box in the
59
Perspectives: Stepmothers closet; and when Julie, who was now four, began to speak in more than nouns they moved to separate bedrooms and became strict with themselves about displaying anything but the most innocent affection in front of her. All this on the advice of a feminist lawyer in New York City who specialized in lesbian custody cases. "Supposing julie's spending a weekend with her father," this lawyer had explained. "You say he's already told you he'd like custody but he knows he hasn't got a chance of getting her away from her mother. What if he starts pumping her for information about other men you might bring home-" "But 1 never bring men home," Sally had interrupted. "I live with Maggie. We're monogamous." As if that solved all problems. "-and Julie, in all innocence, says, 'Mommy never kisses men, Daddy, she just kisses Maggie.' " Sally, who had never been involved with a woman before and who had not given much thought to the ways of homophobia (in fact, Maggie was the first lesbian she'd ever known up close), could not believe Jim would use that against her. And even if he did, the courts would never be so unjust as to take away her child simply because she loved another woman. But Maggie knew better and, since she was as much in love with Julie as with Sally, said to the lawyer: "Okay. Suppose we sleep in separate bedrooms. What else?" The lawyer suggested that they keep a log of all interactions between them and Jim, with particular attention to his failures of responsibility. She asked if they could move to a larger, more heterogeneous community, where the judges were more likely to be open-minded. But Sally's parents were here, and her pottery shop, and Jim lived in the next town, and he had been granted the right to take Julie on alternate weekends, and even now he was always complaining about the half-hour distance between them. And he had refused to even consider four days once a month. Besides, Julie was usually a wreck when she came back from two days with him: who knew what four days would do? So here they were in bed arguing about the Barbie doll when they should have been making love. "The issue under discussion," said Maggie, "is the Barbie doll's feetnot mine." "All right," said Sally, "I'm sorry 1 put down your feet. You know 1 love them." She smiled coquettishly in a way that annoyed Maggie almost beyond self-containment, and tweaked Maggie's big toe. Maggie withdrew her foot. "I'd like to discuss this seriously," she said. Sally sat up straight. The flirtatious smile was replaced briefly by a petulant look that Maggie had almost trained her out of. At last Sally gave
60
The Barbie Doll Fight up her manipulative repertoire and became serious. "Okay," she said. "The question is, does Julie get to keep the Barbie doll her daddy gave her for her birthday or do I take it away from her? And if I take it away, how do I explain to a four-year-old child that her Barbie doll is politically incorrect?" "I think that can be handled," said Maggie. "I think the question that's really bothering you is how to explain to a thirty-five-year-old Middle American man that you don't want his daughter to grow up looking like his new wife." "What have you got against Linda? I'm the one who's supposed to hate her. You're supposed to be relieved that she's got the competition diverted." "First of all, I wasn't aware that he was still the competition. You told me three years ago that you were finished with him." "Oh, all right. I just said that to make you jealous." "I also thought we had agreed to cut the games." "You're right," said Sally. "I'm sorry." "And second of all, I don't hate Linda. I hate what she represents: blond, blue-eyed, life-sized Barbie dolls who spend their whole lives trying to make some alcoholic ex-football player mow the lawn and fix the sink-" "All right. You're starting to rant and rave again." "Damn it. Why is it ranting and raving when I talk about feminist issues?" "It's not that, but why can't you just lighten up? Why does it always have to be so heavy?" "Because it's important. It matters to me. Why doesn't it matter to you? It's your daughter we're talking about." Sally was getting bored. "Since you make that point," she said, escalating to make it more interesting, and perhaps to deflect them from the subject, "maybe you should consider what it means." Maggie gave her an exasperated look. "l\re you going to tell me it's your daughter, why don't I mind my own business? Because if you are, there are a few things maybe you should consider. Like whether you want to make this a power struggle over the ownership of another human beinga power struggle that you will win hands down because you have the law and society to back it up-or whether you want to retain your integrity and make this a good-faith discussion between two people who love Julie." Sally shrugged. "Okay, you're right." They had settled that question early on, and although she still felt Julie was much more hers than theirs, she had agreed that Maggie had major rights. She tried to give her all the rights she would have given a second husband. Maggie loved Julie, she did
61
Perspectives: Stepmothers half the childcare, she paid half the bills, she sat up all the nights when Julie was having asthma attacks. In almost every way Maggie was another mother, and yet it was not possible for Sally to think of her completely as the other parent. If Maggie were a man it might be easier: a stepfather wouldn't be challenging her own unique position as Julie's mother. But she would never admit that to Maggie: it would hurt her too much and undermine the equality they were working so hard for. Besides, it wasn't necessary to emphasize it. The fact that she was a real mother could never be denied or taken away from her. "Sometimes I think you resent my relationship with Julie," said Maggie. Sally took her hand. "Not resent. I think it's beautiful. Sometimes I might get a little jealous." Maggie knew this to be true. She was mollified. "Let's get back to the Barbie doll," she said, shifting her body slightly so that her elbow, on which she was leaning, was on Sally's side of the imaginary line that bisected the bed. "The reason I think it's bad for Julie is the role model it sets up. The doll has no feet: that discourages independence. The breasts are pushed up: they're only for sexual purposes. The feet are extended so she's standing on tiptoe, so the only shoes you can put on her are shoes no woman could use to run away from a rapist . . ." Sally listened as Maggie launched the Speech, maintaining an expression of respectful attention, while she thought about exactly how she would make love to this intense, passionate feminist as soon as Maggie believed she had convinced Sally to ban the Barbie doll.
62
8 Second Wife: Eleven Poems Helane Levine-Keating
Second Wife
We are walking on the beach well past the sand bar to be alone. Behind us a following wind. You walk lower, closer to the water to even our sizes. Under my tan first traces of smile lines. You are broad, a tall man with thin legs. Two tall, thin-legged children lounge on the blanket we have left. Like you they have tawny hair. They are in your keeping.
"Second Wife" (originally titled "The Stepmother") and "Stepdaughter 19" (originally titled "Stepdaughter, Nineteen") both originally appeared in Pudding issue 6, vol. 2, no. 2 (1982), and appear courtesy of the author. © 1982 Helane Levine-Keating. Other poems © 19 88 Helane Levine-Keating.
Perspectives: Stepmothers You come here every summer to this same cottage, this same beach. As frisbees cut the air your children toss memories back and forth, some from before my time. Second daughter in another family, I recall feeling left out. The walk back takes longer: we are now breast to breast with the wind. The blanket we edge toward is invisible, all civilization is invisible. Only the dunes, tenacious as blood ties.
Second Wife Two Weeks with Your Daughter
This is the first morning. Lean and supple, she and her boyfriend arrive, striding into this familiar cottage like heroes. Handing out bagels as truce flags, I peruse pure-scrubbed features, trying to connect her wholesome mysteries with your sleepy face. Hot tea steams in our eyes, a lone tear travels down her cheek. A scant ten minutes into this relationship and she's warning me she's her mother's daughter. He's only my biological father, she says, leading with her chin in your direction. But your father loves you, I offer, trying on my mother's voice like a tavvdry costume. Why should she believe me? She has been born again. I cook the eggs, ask about her home in Iowa. She talks of Jesus, a man I never learned about.
After dinner she hovers around us, testing the water. A question here, a hook there. She's got a net and she's drawing it tighter. At midnight she makes me divulge my age. Fifteen years between you! she snickers, my glitzy gold carriage dissolving into a pumpkin. ii
She and her boyfriend share a bed but vow they're chaste. True, she wears no makeup, her bathing suit begins at her neck. Lunch at the clam shack, two identical smiles stick to the corners of their mouths as they confess they've come here to convert you. In the afternoon he retires to index his Bible.
Perspectives: Stepmothers Every night they say Grace, holding God in their hands the way hippies once held acid. At eighteen, they've outgrown sin. Every night you lecture them how religion is the cause of war. This is the argument both of you want to win. 111
Claws extended, her fury leaps at you, the weather-beaten Tom. Stand up to her~ put her in her place! I long to shout, recalling my father's strict voice that bruised my ears, the red glare that shackled my tongue. For a moment I respect your meekness. For a moment I remember why I married you. For days you pretend nothing's wrong, gulping vodka after vodka even though she swears she won't talk to you if you've had a drink. From across the dune, I watch you pull her onto your lap. Sunset pinks slowing waves. Both of you weep. Like you she's addicted: you're the fire that burned her best bridge back, you're the fire she'll have to walk through. iv It's clear you're torn between us, the first daughter and the new wife, want us both to love you best. Finally the riptide grabs you full force as you blast me at dinner in front of your daughter. The mother in my brain wags a finger at me: Blood is thicker than water. Scarlet-cheeked, heaving, I leave the table. Surely you've confused us-the one who loves you and the one who hates you. Ears crimson, humbly she stares at her plate. I don't want to be a child in this family.
66
Second Wife Marching the beach in exile, I'm a screaming wraith washed ashore in a Wellfleet shipwreck, heart luffing like a loose sail. Inside everyone smiles, resuming lobster forks and roles without the stranger who alters the ritual. The scent of sacrifice lingers in the air, yellow. v
The day she leaves is humid; rain clouds hover over the dunes like dirty white hens. We snap pictures: your daughter, her dog, her boyfriend, my cat, you and me. I anI frowning, she is hooded. I know she's glad to go as she lifts me in her arms, a head taller than I am. Distant thunder. That night the storm comes punishing the ocean and unlacing my roar. We pace the dunes getting soaked. I am trying to reach for you in the ice of my language, a man who has retreated from the criticism of women. Silently you stoop in the rainwet, guilty, old heart brandishing its scars. Lear at last, you hobble to her side too late. VI
Stiff morning, air hung out to dry like bleached laundry. As we climb the dune trail your daughter's face floats before us, starved, mewling, over and over begging for scraps. The sun's been up for hours, returning the sand to a warm carpet. Blankets dot the beach. Here and there small children dart and squeal, looking back at their parents to make sure they're watching them.
Perspectives: Stepmothers The First Wife Comes to Dinner
I should have worn red flowers in my hair as a sign designating pecking order. Who sits where when the first wife comes to dinner? Do the children encircle her, plump, snug life preservers in an uncharted ocean? Chafing yet complicitous, brow furrowed like a sailor's, I worry if the food is fit, the secondhand silverware polished. I'm dancing for her supper as if she were captain. Since no one sits down first, I see I am also cartographer: my husband and stepchildren trapped in the rhythm of old shanties. A treacherous current makes me place him facing her. Conversation stutters like a small-craft warning. Slowly we chew our clams, praise the salad dressing. As her eyes lock silently with mine, she battens down hatches. Still she won't talk to me. At last it's time for dessert, a soft sandy shore for a foundering ship. A relief to fetch tea. My absence returns them to themselves; at last they're free in the past. Then, while children drift lazily off to other dreams, other rooms, an aluminum chandelier scans our midnight faces like a search beam. One lone barnacle child, a girl, hangs on. Seasons pass: winters of sharp waves bearing driftwood, iridescent fish glowing ominously in the night's wake, summers of swift passionate storms, small boat wrecks.
68
Second Wife Stepdaughter, 19
(for Martha Keating) It is two-thirty a.m. when the phone wakes me abruptly Someone whispers your name an accident at a party Firecrackers casually crammed in a friend's coat pocket have exploded You may be hurt and rushed to some downtown hospital scorched or charred the caller explains It is a dark night She is uncertain of identity Clenching my breath I dial the emergency room They have never even heard of you can't reveal if you are blinded your artist fingers burned Shawl clutched close like a life preserver I remember last summer your sister tossed into a ditch by a madman in a park in Iowa These are new feelings hot maternal fears that choke make me lie awake listening for the door latch Full-blown you burst into my childless life It is May I have just turned thirty
Perspectives: Stepmothers Stepmother's Nightmare
Her stepchildren are quick to hate her, her aquiline nose that always looks snooty, her purple knit dress so skimpy and queer, the fraying quilt she drags over their father. Their own queen dethroned, she is the sequel-a derivative novel filled with family squabbles and unrequited love lacking the dazzle of the first. And now that they have acquired her, this quintessential hag capable of making Cinderella squat in cobwebs, nothing can seduce them. They offer her no trial, but hiss behind her back. Brows squinched, they squash their hurt. For them she's beyond inquisition: no mother resides within her, only a treacherous whore.
7°
Second Wife Schefflera
This is the tree his first wife left him when she packed the car with kids and headed west. Tall as a lanky woman it didn't fit. See how carefully he tends itsponging each foot-long leaf with warm water, lugging it each May into the garden, carrying it back like a trophy into their bedroom every fall. For seven years it has sat next to his side of the bed stealing space, gobbling light although his second wife never waters it. Now it's so heavy his grown sons have to help him lift it into the sunlight. Soon it won't fit up the stairs. Then every season, every light it will overhang them, an old wedding canopy shadowing their bed.
Perspectives: Stepmothers The Visit
Once a week his children come to visit. Four adult stalks, they look down at their father, each flaunting his traits: bushy eyebrows, steel blue eyes, two with skinny calves, three with amber hair, four pairs of chiseled cheekbones. Even with all this they want, they want. Half-starved, they nibble at his hairline. Dark voices blot his out. He grows smaller. Like an old man twiddling whiskers, gravity tugs on his jowls. Fur sprouts in his ear holes. One by one his teeth fall out. Soon he's hardly visible, a dwarf snoring on the sofa. His children circle him, gleeful giants dancing round a dying bonfire.
Second Wife The Pregnant Stepmother Attends her Stepdaughter's Wedding
For months I've dreaded thisdriving out to enemy territory my middle cushioned by pillows, luncheon at his ex-wife's house, photos of my husband as a young daddy. Still not fat enough to be congratulated, I flourish my newly swollen potbelly for all to see. With bravado I boast I'm expecting. The ex won't acknowledge I'm pregnant. The minister has no title for second wives, prays that I'll vanish. My stepson forgets to escort me down the aisle. Guests whisper, "Who is she?" My husband and and I sit in the pew behind his ex. Church light ignites tiny hairs on her arm, nuzzles the curve of her nape. I imagine them making love. After my stepdaughter is married, she kisses her Mommy and Daddy. I want her to kiss me too. My hands fly to my belly. The bridesmaids are sympathetic, complimenting me on the color of my dress. They're just being kind and will later talk behind my back.
73
Perspectives: Stepmothers
Deja Vu
On the lake a man paddles his canoe softly pressing the paddle into water. The aluminum canoe with its mottled repairs gleams in the sunlight. Its reflection precedes it in a long black shadow. On shore a child and woman play, sun shaping their curls into scalloped gold. They are watching each other, mirroring each other as the air slowly warms. When they slip into view his face softens, its gullies disappear. Love makes his stomach queasy. Soon they will run out on deck to greet him. Now the view changes, though the man still canoes on the same green lake, the boy and his mother still sport and woo. The shore is this shore years earlier, the trees are sparser, thinner. A different woman waits on shore, four other children dance around her. The same sun ignites their heads. They were his family then, these fallen angels. Is it love or the memory of love caroming within him?
74
Second Wife Years Later
Years go by. She is getting older, her stepchildren are getting older. They have come to love her in their own way, they have grown used to her cooking. Her home is home to them, her child their brother. She remembers their birthdays, they bring her flowers. For a short while peace descends on the kingdom. Just when she has almost forgotten the curse, forgotten the heritage passed on to her from stepmother to stepmother, just when she has almost sunk like a maiden into the unexpected feather bed of married happiness, a new hedge of briars springs up keeping her from the castle. Her eldest stepson, now a man, falls in love with her closest friend. All that she has gained slips away like rain on a sloping roof until once more she is at the beginning, caught in the misty netherworld of neither parent, sister, friend. Once again to speak her mind means she is wicked, to be silent means she is false. Once again there's no one to guide her. Her stepchildren have never asked her permission; her best friend sees no reason to. The moment her birthday arrives, they prick her finger with their news. Quickly she ages before their eyes until she's a hag, a miserable old witch without a home.
75
Perspectives: Stepmothers Youngest Stepdaughter's Wedding
The day after her wedding snow buries the hillsides, outlines yellowing leaves in white like ice on a mustache. In the valley a corona of deep brown horses rings the corral-their movement slow against steady snow, the red hat and red mittens of a curious child. Next door the newlyweds still sleep their fire burned low in the fireplace, the crepe paper canopy over the bed askew, one blue strip crossing the groom's shoulder as if he were a fallen soldier. Lying on the floor by the bed, a boutonniere of blood red roses. We stand at the window pressing our cheeks against cold glass, steaming it silver then wiping it clean once again to see outside snow burying the hillsides, snow outlining the aspens' leaves, pine needles like hairs on a mustache, deep brown horses stamping and steaming, red mittens on our small red-cheeked son. While inside, between us, between our deliberately casual voices practicing "Do you think she and her husband are up yet?" I imagine we are so deeply wedded we are imagining the same scene: the bride and her groom curled on their bed for warmth, the fire banked, the blond corona of her hair dreaming against his black mustache, red and blue ribbons of crepe paper strewn across their shoulders, roses on the floor by the bed, our daughter.
9 One Step Away from Mother: A Stepmother's Story Alice Neufeld I never say I'm Katherine's "stepmother"; being a stepmother means that one's motives are always suspect. A direct "Clean up your room" seems to hum to the Cinderella tune of exploitation. And because I'm not really old enough to be Katherine's mother, I have often felt cast in the equally wicked role of stepsister. Katherine was fourteen when I, at twenty-nine, became her stepmother. In no time at all, she memorized my wardrobe: "Do you have, like, an oversized shirt I could borrow? I think I renlember a blue one." She calls out from the interior of my closet: "Alice, is this new?" "Yes. And I have not worn it yet, and don't really want you to borrow it." My jewelry box is another favorite playground of Katherine's, and no one knows its inventory better than she does. I knew Katherine coveted a heart-shaped pendant I often let her wear, and waited until her twentyfirst birthday to buy her one just like it. Her mother always bribed her way out of Katherine's life, and I refused to bribe my way into it. Katherine was four, in 1968, when her parents separated and joined an urban community of psychotherapists and patients who lived in rent-controlled apartments on Manhattan's Upper West Side. A patriarch-leader, with roots in the Old Left, organized his commune into sex-segregated apartments where ideology was delivered as therapy. Commune ideology was roughest on the children. They were separated from their parents, assigned therapists, and raised in separate living quarters. Katherine remembers slipping up the "adults only" stairway at night to sneak into her father's bed. She remembers missing her mother. Kath-
77
Perspectives: Stepmothers erine's therapist was a tactless, ungainly woman who kept insisting that her parents didn't love her: "Liar! Liar!" Katherine screamed. Steven left the commune. Virginia remained. She broke off all relations with her own parents, as the commune urged, and contacted them only for requests for money. She was a lonely only child, with strong female accomplishments in painting, cooking, and elegant taste. Divorced, with her four-year-old daughter, Virginia was thirty-five and on her own for the first time in her life. She was shaky, and her unrealized ambitions to become a serious painter drew her to the commune, where her ambition met with opportunities as well as emotional support. Some of the most influential and successful artists of the day were also commune members. Therapy confirmed her doubts about her ability for mothering and she became convinced that Katherine was better off without her involvement. "Then why did you have me if you didn't want to be a mother," Katherine accused Virginia over the telephone in my kitchen. She was thirteen, and had been living at boarding school for the past six years. Confronting Virginia about her erratic mothering had become routine for Katherine. I tried to help her grasp the incomprehensible events that led up to her present pain. Blame was uppermost on Katherine's mind, and we fished our way through her past, until Katherine came up with her father, the culprit who had wanted the divorce in the first place: "He must have stopped loving her," Katherine lamented. "What made him stop?" "People don't stop loving each other," I explained, "but things can happen to make people realize that they don't want to, or simply can't go on living with each other." "What could have happened?" Katherine kept looking for a catastrophe. "It's not necessarily one thing that happens, but people changing the way they feel about the things that happen or don't happen. A marriage ends when each partner loses faith in the other's ability to steer to safety."
Nine years ago, Virginia sabotaged our plan to have Katherine live with Steven and me. Katherine was fourteen, and it had been more than ten years since she had lived in a family. I expected some passive disapproval from Virginia and the commune, little else. Our plan, after all, demanded almost nothing from Virginia, who knew that Katherine was unhappy to be so far away in New Mexico where the commune always sent their children to school. I thought, with Steven and I taking care of Katherine's day-to-day needs, Virginia might play the part traditionally reserved for divorced fathers. She could visit with her daughter now and then, and reap
One Step Away from Mother the benefits of having a teenaged daughter who was eager to admire her mother's accomplishments. The ten days before Steven flew out to fetch Katherine from New Mexico were fraught with long-distance phones calls and the exhaustion that comes from having to funnel the fullness of feeling into thread-bare telephone wire. "She cries and says that she's miserable," Steven explained. "She wants to live with us. That's all she keeps saying." The headmaster told Steven that Katherine was rebellious and refusing authority. Our home represented far more than escape from school, he reassured us. It was a chance to live with a parent, a chance for Katherine to make a long-held fantasy a reality. "It would be very good for her," he said. Legally, Virginia was the custodial parent, and Steven also feared reprisals from the commune, but the headmaster was willing to take the risk of releasing Katherine in our custody. "What did Virginia say?" we asked Katherine as soon as she hung up the phone that first day home. "She didn't say much of anything," Katherine said. As the day unfolded, I grew confident that Virginia would do little to interfere with her daughter's new life. We relaxed. I helped Katherine unpack, and we discussed how we'd make small alterations in her bedroom. The public schools were first-rate, we explained. Virginia was a snob and had gone to private schools, and Katherine was leery about going to public school. In time, Katherine would grow to trust me, I thought. In time, the love that I felt for his young girl, who had a sweet charm that pretty girls learn early, would ripen into intimacy. There was no point in rushing things that must take their course. At dinner, Katherine spoke to our sheep dog, Caliban, promising to bathe and brush him so that he might sleep with her. She chided us for allowing the dog to develop the bad manners of begging at the table, and planned to train him. After dinner I brought some logs in from the garage and lit the fireplace to take the chill out of the living room. Outside, through the curtainless bay window, the dark trunks of oak trees stood upon the bluff that reached toward the water of Long Island Sound. I spoke of my love for the house and the view, then I drifted onto talk about our new family. We changed for bed. Suddenly, the dog scrambled to his feet and barked angrily; the brass door knocker resounded throughout the house. "Who the hell is that?" Steven said loudly, and then, without opening the front door: "Who is it?" "Katherine! Katherine!" A shrill female voice: "Give me Katherine! I want my baby. My Baby!"
79
Perspectives: Stepmothers "Oh my god, it's Mom," Katherine said. From the kitchen I saw the beams of flashlights. There were two people at the front door along with Virginia. A third beam of light moved from the driveway toward the porch. "She's not alone," I said. "This is a commune scare tactic," Steven said. "Lock the kitchen door and the porch door. Hurry." Katherine ran to bolt the two other entrances to the house. I held the dog by his choke collar so that he wouldn't lunge when Steven opened the door. We had to scream to hear each other over the dog's incessant barking. A flashlight beamed into the living room, and I felt invaded. Any second now, Virginia would come in. Calming her hysterics would take hours, and I tried to brace myself for the long night ahead. "What do you want with Katherine?" Steven called out. He was stalling; I wished he would hurry, let her in and get it over with. That screeching woman is Katherine's mother, I told myself. Steven was married to her for ten years, you don't have to feel so frightened. "They're going to try and grab her," Steven said. "I know them. What should we do?" I was afraid to look at Katherine, afraid to look her in the eye; she would see me wanting to lock her mother out. She'll never forgive me; during some terrible future argument she'll drag out this grievance and say: "You wouldn't let me see my mother!" "I think Katherine should decide," I said. "It's twelve o'clock, for god's sake," Steven called to the people outside our door. "Quiet that woman down, will you!" Katherine followed me into the bedroom, where I felt less exposed. Her brow was furrowed: "I'm sorry, Alice," she said. "Don't worry about me, Katherine. If you want to talk to your mother, it's all right." "Katherine?" Steven asked. She hesitated, and then she said: "Well, I think she's being very rude, coming here like this at midnight." I waited for more but there was no more. Of course she was being rude. Was bad manners a good enough reason for turning one's mother away? "Does that mean that you don't want to see her now?" I asked. "Yes." "Come back in the morning, Virginia." Steven opened the door a crack, positioning his weight behind it so that he could shut it quickly again if he needed to. "Katherine is tired, it's been a very long day. She'll see you in the morning." There were more screams that seemed hollow now, as if on cue. "I'll call the police," he said firmly, "if you don't leave now."
80
()ne Step Away from Mother The sound of car doors slamming, then headlights flashing as Virginia drove off with her entourage. Katherine was full of apologies. "Please, it wasn't your fault," I told her. I felt very sad. Something had gone terribly wrong, a woman who was once loved intimately as wife, and still loved as mother, was now an interloper. By keeping Virginia out, I feared we had somehow permitted a greater chill to enter. Two weeks went by with no word from Virginia. Katherine broke the silence to telephone her mother and announce that she'd begun to menstruate: "So what do you want me to do about it?" Virginia responded. Katherine lay crying on my bed: "A girl wants her mother at a time like this." Even before I became her stepmother, I was showing her how to insert a tampon and giving her Tylenol and a heating pad. For most of Katherine's life, Virginia had been a mother by long distance. Twice a year she saw Katherine for one day when she bought Katherine clothes and took her to the dentist and doctor for checkups. Katherine blamed the commune for coming between them. She remembered how her mother always made "perfect sandwiches, no lettuce or anything ever spilled out over the edges." "It's been almost ten years. Virginia must need the commune to have remained with them for so long," I said. Katherine resisted going to school. We talked endlessly, cajoled, and insisted, unsuccessfully. She complained of cramps. The doctor said that she was constipated. The girl was holding back, waiting for Virginia's approval. After the third week, Virginia telephoned: "You have two weeks to return to boarding school. If you don't, ] will wash my hands of you entirely. I will never speak to you again or have anything to do with you." "How did she sound? Katherine, were these words part of a larger conversation?" I asked. "Did she give any reasons, make any arguments for taking such an extreme position?" "No. It was strange, she sounded, like, it was as if she was reading a statement, as if she was reading something that was written down." "If you ignore the threat, Virginia will give in," we told Katherine, but she was not prepared to take the risk. We did not blame her. She never gave herself a chance, and there was no doubt in my mind that Virginia had exploited whatever fears Katherine may have had about living with us. We would still be here, we reassured Katherine. The door was always open. The day Katherine flew back to New Mexico, the house was filled with her absence. The late April sun poured into our bedroom and the light seemed mercilessly bright to shine so clearly upon so much emptiness. I
81
Perspectives: Stepmothers closed the blinds, and Steven and I lay down on the bed without touching. We slept like mourners, robbed of a future. Katherine finished high school in New Mexico. We saw her summers and during winter and spring break. Virginia continued to spend a total of two days a year with Katherine, but Katherine never asked to live with us again. Whenever her daughter demanded more of her time, Virginia bribed her way out of Katherine's life, encouraging Katherine to befriend wealthy schoolmates and visit with them on school holidays. Virginia would pay the plane fare for Katherine to fly to California or Hawaii. Katherine considered herself lucky compared to two other boys at her school who also had commune-member parents: "They never get to go home. Not even for one day!" Our house was never really home for Katherine either. She presented herself as a sophisticated traveler who was dropping by for a visit. Her attention seemed focused elsewhere, her talk was of the places she had just come from or was about to see. "Why aren't we rich?" she asked once after enumerating the numbers and styles of luxury cars parked in the driveway of a wealthy friend's house. "Why don't you write a bestseller, Dad?" "I always think I am writing a bestseller," Steven quipped. Virginia sometimes boasted of the personal deprivations she had undergone so that Katherine could have her hair "cellophaned" at Bloomingdale's salon. She provided Katherine with credit cards to all the exclusive department stores. I knew I had something else to give Katherine; if it didn't come wrapped in a box, Katherine wasn't interested. She remained peculiarly uncurious about our lives and refused invitations to be with us and meet our friends. "I have to do laundry, and pack," she said. It was as if we didn't count. It was Virginia she wanted, if she wanted anybody, and Steven and I spent most of our time futilely trying to heal the wounds of rejection Virginia inflicted on her, again and again. We lived sixty miles away from Katherine's mother, but it might as well have been six thousand for all the times she refused to see her when her daughter was home for an extended stay. One Christmas, Steven, Katherine, and I made a special trip to the world Trade Center rooftop restaurant where one of Virginia's paintings-a large ball of yellow flame-was installed. The three of us sat at a table for four, awkwardly celebrating Virginia's prosperity in her ghostly absence. Katherine was full of pride in her mother's success, and Steven and I were happy for her. Why Virginia was not in our place where she belonged was a mystery to us. In bed, Steven and I joked our way out of despair. "Did you notice how Virginia's canvas resembled the burning bush in Cecil B.
One Step Away from Mother De Mille's Ten Commandments?" Virginia remained a remote god, an illusion at whose altar Katherine had come to worship. Occasionally, Katherine condescended to go clothes shopping with me; she had never heard of Abraham and Straus, and I felt like I was taking her to Mars, for all her hesitancy and the wary way she eyed the clothes racks. When she found something she liked, it was as though she discovered there was life on other planets after all, and I watched her lose herself, momentarily, in the mirror of the department store dressing room. Her satisfaction was short-lived, however, and inevitably, in the car on the way home, she suddenly remembered that there was something else she absolutely needed to have. Her visits became a litany of "buy-me's" that Steven often encouraged by refusing to say no. Her bathroom was cluttered with bottles of hair conditioners, moisturizers, and massage gels made with extracts of fruits and vegetables: olive, aloe, coconut, honey, almond, lemon, lime, and ivy. I gathered up the bottles Katherine left behind: "Maybe we could donate these to the female population of a small Balkan republic and deduct it from our taxes," I told Steven. The cost seemed staggering, but I approved when Steven bought "Pretty Boy" for Katherine's fourteenth birthday. As quarterhorses go, he was modestly priced, and there was no charge for boarding the horse on school grounds. We paid for expensive tack and horse blankets. Weekdays, Katherine awoke at 5:30; by 6:00 she had mucked out his stall and fed Pretty Boy. As Katherine's "family," we memorized Pretty Boy's genealogy and celebrated his birthdays. Nights when she was home for a visit, she had nightmares about forgetting to feed her hungry horse. When she was gone, we slept soundly, knowing that Pretty Boy was absorbing a measure of healthy teenage passion that might otherwise have been squandered on drugs, sex, or fast cars. At seventeen, Katherine was still embarrassed to have me fill in for Virginia. She wanted to be "normal," to have a "normal" mother-daughter relationship, and Virginia continued to frustrate those ambitions: "Let Alice take you to the gynecologist, if she's so great," Virginia told Katherine. I was relieved to be the one to discuss birth control with Katherine and to take her to my doctor. Though I didn't fit the "normal" picture either, there were advantages to my big-sister age and attitude. We took care of that business without the Sturm und Drang. By boarding-school standards, Katherine was a "late bloomer," and I respected her privacy, sensing that her first sexual experience grew out of the need to see herself as "normal" and womanly. I was touched by Katherine's craving for the ordinary domestic experiences that girls her age took for granted, and prepared feasts of mundane
Perspectives: Stepmothers rituals. She loved having a boy "come to the house to meet her parents." I minimized my youthfulness and appeared very matronly: "Take a sweater, just in case it gets cold later," I advised her. Steven combined just the right balance of Father Knows Best humor and paternalism. We saw Katherine regularly when she came east for college, and added the celebration of all holidays to her repertory: pumpkin seeds were dried and roasted for Halloween, the apple pie was deep-dish Dutch at Thanksgiving, and for late winter nights after New Year's, the Droste's hot chocolate was capped by a cozy Campfire marshmallow. When Katherine learned that I was pregnant, however, she thought that I'd gone too far: the age difference between siblings was too excessive to be in good taste; by any "normal" measure, Steven was too old to be dandling anyone but his grandchild upon his knee. I was definitely jeopardizing the dignity of our family in the halls of normalcy. Babies also frightened Katherine. In spite of my encouragement, she refused to hold Natasha, and there was little I could do to mitigate her uneasiness around diapers. The gurgles, the cooing, the toothless gummy smiles and kisses left her cold. She wondered at my involvement and envied Steven's delight as well. "I love music boxes too," she once told Steven when he bought one for the baby; "buy me one too, Dad." At eighteen, Katherine began to search through the cardboard boxes in the basement where we stored many of her belongings. "The one thing about Virginia, she really knows how to pack things carefully," Katherine said, with seemingly earnest gratitude, as she removed layers of tissue paper and relived her childhood: "I liked to collect things," she said. There were china rabbit and duck reproductions of Beatrice Potter characters, sterling silver cups and spoons, a large carton of doll-house furniture, and framed watercolors of farmyard animals that Virginia had painted for Katherine's bedroom. Sweaters with lace collars were spotless, wrinklefree. "I had a lot of other really nice toys, antique dolls with porcelain faces, but I broke a lot of things, and spoiled them." "You were probably too young for those delicate toys," I said. "Then I became a real pris, you know, prissy." Katherine never tired of the ritual admiring of the things that represented her childhood. She reiterated Virginia's love for artifacts. I imagined Katherine had learned to bathe in that love for things and to steal some of it for herself. The prissy girl makes herself into a doll; Katherine liked Natasha best when I dressed her up like one. "Make her put her clothes on," Katherine said, when Natasha was three and fond of running naked through the house. Natasha learned to knock at Katherine's door: "Can I come in?" "No."
One Step Away from Mother I tried to distract and console Natasha, and restrained myself from charging into Katherine's room and beating her to a pulp. But Natasha was resourceful, and slid pictures under her door or taped them onto the outside, refusing to take no for an answer. At the dinner table, Natasha pursued Katherine with food offerings. "I'm on a diet," Katherine said. "Well, when are you going to stop being on a diet?" "When I'm skinny." And then, daily for days afterward: "Are you skinny yet, Katherine?"
"Do you think I could take Natasha with me sometime to meet Virginia?" Katherine asked me one day; I hesitated. "Natasha is my sister, after all," Katherine said in explanation, "and I talk about her so much, you know, I'd like Virginia to meet her, so she knows who I'm talking about." "Of course." I felt rather ungracious and guilty.
"Me and Katherine, we have the same daddy," Natasha announced, "but we don't have the same mommy." Steven and I were waiting downstairs while Katherine took Natasha to meet Virginia. We stopped at Virginia's so that Katherine could load our car up with Virginia's paintings. At fifty, Virginia was giving up her studio, twenty years of work, and becoming a computer programmer. During that visit, Natasha played with Virginia's pet poodle while Katherine gathered up the paintings she wanted. "How did it go?" we asked afterward. "Fine," the sisters agreed, like coconspirators, from the back seat of the car. Later, Katherine said that her mother had found Natasha to be smarter than she had expected. What had she expected? I wondered. I surveyed the basement in search of a safe dry area to store Virginia's paintings. In the fall, Katherine would take some of them back to college for her junior year. In summer, the cesspool sometimes overflowed from Katherine's interminable showers, and I stacked the canvases high off the cement floor; we can't have Virginia's oeuvres floating in shit, now can we, I muttered. There were a number of paintings of room interiors viewed from bizarre angles: a corner where the ceiling met the wall or a floor. Flooded with light, they illuminated the lonely way rooms withhold shelter. Kath-
Perspectives: Stepmothers erine's favorite was a painting of the three antique velvet dresses she'd worn as a child. A shadowy darkness in the holes for the necks spoke to me of Virginia's vision of the girl she once dressed in them.
In high school, Katherine rarely read books for her own pleasure, but she became a serious college student, proud that her professors had read Steven's books, and proud of herself for excelling. Natasha continued to idolize her big sister, and Katherine became openly affectionate: "I really can have fun with Natasha now." Katherine also felt protective of Natasha, and closed the door on our marital quarrels to comfort the child and receive comfort from her. Katherine graduated with honors. I don't know what excuse Virginia gave for not attending the ceremony. I took photographs of Katherine and her friends in their caps and gowns. We met her teachers, who offered to write letters of recommendation for her and asked her about her future plans: "I'm going to work for a year, and then I was thinking of applying to law school," she said. Driving home down the thruway, we asked Katherine when she planned to follow up on the interview at High Style; "call me when you're ready to work," the personnel director had said, impressed with Katherine's "enthusiasm and good taste." "I need a vacation," Katherine said. "I just graduated and you're putting a lot of pressure on me." Changing the subject to a new diet she was eager to start, Katherine read aloud about the danger of mixing proteins and carbohydrates. A month went by while Katherine ate little, slept late, and complained about being awakened by the noise Natasha made in the kitchen while we fixed the child's breakfast. We pressured her to look for a job. Money was tight. I bought a large supply of Woolite to help her reduce her dry-cleaning bill, and Steven told her to call her friends after business hours. "I want to be rich," she said. "I want you to be rich too," I said; "meanwhile, economize."
"Katherine wants you," Steven said on the telephone from the hospital. "Will you come?" That morning, Katherine had stumbled into our bedroom with a bruise on her head. She'd been up all night with insomnia and at 6:00 A.M. had decided to go for a bicycle ride to tire herself out. It was steaming out,
86
One Step Away from Mother and she was wearing a sweatsuit and had no food in her stomach; she didn't remember feeling faint, but she had blacked out. I asked Steven to take her to the emergency room while I got Natasha ready for school. I knew that Katherine wanted me with her, but I sent Steven in my place. I needed to go to the library and seize an hour to do my own work. The summer was precious work time for me, and after a year of full-time teaching, I was determined to stick to a routine. From the library, I went to the hospital and arranged Katherine's tray with the chicken salad, the vanilla ice cream, and the Vogue I'd bought. "I'm starving," she said. An intern came in and asked me to leave while he inserted an IV into Katherine's arm: "It's glucose, nothing serious," he said. "She can stay while you do it," Katherine said. "I'll be right back. I want to talk to the neurologist, and get some more ice packs, anyway," I said. The neurologist raised an eyebrow incredulously when I introduced myself as Katherine's mother, but he answered all my questions and admitted that the low potassium level in her blood, the heat, exhaustion, and crazy diet could've explained Katherine's blackout. Still, he wanted to do a CAT scan. "Her EEG shows an asymmetry-could be normal-but in some cases it's a sign of an obstruction. . . ." When I returned, Katherine was saying to the intern: "My veins are really hard to find . . . I know, I just know it's going to hurt." The intern was turning Katherine's forearm this way and that. "The last time I needed an IV was when I had my tonsils out, and they stabbed me ten times, I'm not exaggerating, before they got it in. My arm was sore for weeks afterward. Really." "Oh." The intern blushed, a mustache line of perspiration wetting his upper lip. Katherine's chatter wasn't helping. "Wait a second," I said. "Let's have some positive thinking, that's the first thing. This is not going to be one of those ten-stab tries." "That's right." The intern smiled up at me gratefully. "Can you see what you're doing?" I asked. His body blocked out the available light as he leaned over Katherine to search for a vein. "Let's put a little light on the subject." I walked over to the bedside and turned on the overhead fluorescent light so that the area around her arm was lit up, and I could see for myself the blank map of her arm as I held out my own for comparison. "Too bad you can't give me the IV," I said, holding my arm next to Katherine's for the intern to us~ as a guide. "Don't look," I told her; "look away." The intern was about to make his first try. She turned her head and he did it on the first try.
Perspectives: Stepmothers I moved over to be near his tray and handed him strips of adhesive tape to keep the needle in place. "Do you need any assistance, doctor?" a nurse said when she saw me working. I arranged Katherine's bathrobe around her shoulders and helped her into the wheelchair, rolling the IV stand next to her while the intern steered toward the elevator and left us downstairs to wait for the CAT scan technICIans. "Some of these interns are good-looking," I told Katherine. "Take advantage of your stay and meet a rich doctor," I teased. Katherine seemed cheerful as she lay down on the narrow strip and slid her body back so that her head lay between an opening in the great cylinder that scanned the brain. I petted her leg. "See you in a bit." The technicians said I'd have to leave. Outside, in the drafty hallway, I smoked cigarettes and stared out the window into the solid cement courtyard and an overcast sky, a fitting backdrop of bleakness. Katherine had telephoned her mother but Virginia did not return her call. "I'm so mad," Katherine said. "She had someone else call me-a complete stranger, a commune member called to ask me how I was feeling. The person said that Virginia was too busy to call, but that she was really worried about me. That's such bull. 'If Virginia's so worried about me, she can call me herself,' I told the stranger." The CAT scan control-booth door was open, and I overheard the technicians talking and listened for some allusion to Katherine's condition. I tried to reassure myself: there was nothing wrong with Katherine that three healthy meals a day and a good night's sleep would not cure. The diet that had weakened her was Virginia's idea. Virginia did not come to Katherine's graduation. Virginia did not return Katherine's phone call. No matter what I did, Virginia was there, pulling the rug out from under our lives; it was my job to pick up the pieces and dust people off. But this time, something might be seriously wrong. . . . The next day we found out the CAT scan was negative. I got Katherine back on her feet. The doctor said she could expect to have headaches for some weeks. It was hard to make Natasha be quiet around Katherine. Then, the child got chicken pox and, because Katherine had never had them, the house became divided into two quarantined halves. I ministered cooling compresses to Natasha's itchy body and then inspected Katherine, who suspected every vague redness on her body to be incipient pox. Meanwhile, Katherine hoked up excuses for not following through on her job interview: "I need a resume." We spent days helping her write one. On high-quality paper, she had one hundred copies printed. "Looks very professional," she said.
88
One Step Away from Mother "Yes," we agreed, though she never got around to mailing any out. It was July. Steven and Natasha and I were to go off to Vermont where Steven was teaching at a summer workshop. Katherine was going to stay behind, commute on the train to Manhattan, and job hunt. "Virginia says I can stay over in a spare room in the commune apartment while I look for work," Katherine announced. "Perhaps you'll get to see more of Virginia, and to do things together," I said, but Katherine denied the plan had anything to do with her yearning for a mother: "It's just for convenience," she declared. We were away for two weeks, when Katherine telephoned us in Vermont: "She was very upset," Steven explained. "She was crying. She's taking the bus and will be here tomorrow."
"I wish you were my mother," Katherine wept. "No you don't," I said, realizing that I wasn't speaking my mind clearly. "I just mean that our relationship would be different if I were your mother." I thought of my mother and myself, and how the intimacy between us could be stifling at times. With Katherine, I was always bridging the distance between us. I had to choose my words carefully to make certain she understood me. "How would it be different?" she asked. "Oh, I'd probably be more demanding and more critical of you if you were my daughter, you know, more like the way my mother is with me." "You would?" I nodded. Katherine had no awareness of my restraint. Didn't she feel how we handled each other delicately, as if we could not sustain the nasty verbal blows intimates hurl at each other when they're in pain? But it was not our relationship that now made Katherine weep and run away. Virginia was "acting weird." I wanted to know more. Katherine told Steven some details about Virginia's drinking and constant use of tranquilizers. "Tell me," I said, "do you think that Virginia was always so 'strange,' as you say, and that you just saw her now clearly for the first time?" "I don't know. Maybe. I'd say something about myself, and it wouldn't register, she'd just start talking about herself, and go on and on. It was like I wasn't there. And when I withdrew, she didn't even notice. It was awful. I was embarrassed to be seen with her in public. She thinks a shopkeeper she met once is a friend." On a number of occasions we had suggested Katherine might benefit
Perspectives: Stepmothers from talking to a therapist and now I suggested it again. In college, she had been in therapy for a couple of months. "Do you think you'd like to talk to your therapist now?" "No. I just cried all the time, so I stopped going. He'd just say . . . he was so sympathetic and understanding that he just made me cry all the time. I felt so bad. I like talking to you," she said.
"Have you met Steven's daughter? This is Katherine." In Vermont and later back home, Katherine now got a job, made friends with our friends, hung out with Steven's students, and threw herself into our lives as she had never done before. "I wish that when you introduced me to people you'd say I'm your daughter too, and not just Steven's," she said. Katherine wanted a second chance. She wanted me to be the mother I had offered to be when she was fourteen and had come to live with us. Only now she was eager to let go of Virginia and cling to me. Steven went away as visiting professor to California for six months and Katherine stayed behind with me and Natasha. In my absence, Katherine was "the adult" with Natasha, but when we were all together, she became a child again. After my long and tiring working day, I'd pick Katherine up at her workplace: "I want to sit up front," Katherine complained. Natasha protested against the back seat. "What difference does it make?" I tried to get Katherine to humor Natasha. "I'm embarrassed to have people see me getting into the back seat," she said. Who notices? Who cares? 1 wondered. Sitting in the back seat of the car made Katherine feel like a child; up front, next to me, she was masquerading as an adult. Katherine began to sink under pressure. Virginia was fifty and nowhere. She left the commune. Eighteen years after her separation and divorce from Steven, she telephoned and told me: "I'm so tired of being angry. I don't even hate Steven anymore." In her little-girl's voice she once asked Katherine for money and Katherine wept, complaining to me: "She wants me to take care of hert!' Before it was too late, Katherine hastened to get away from Virginia and applied to a highly competitive graduate school program on the West Coast. Thinking that her life would begin in graduate school, she refused the advances of young men and women at the electronics firm where she worked as a receptionist. "You've got to live in the present too," I urged.
9°
()ne Step Away from Mother "The men at work just think I'm an airhead, a Valley girl." Other girls did not share her ambitions and dissatisfactions. On weekends, Katherine wanted to be my sidekick, to go to the movies together and to eat out in restaurants. I couldn't do anything on my own without feeling I was abandoning her. She planned to spend the four-day Thanksgiving weekend with friends from college, and I circled the date on my calendar, like a prisoner awaiting parole. She was rejected from graduate school and began to oversleep mornings and miss work. I worried about leaving her home alone all day with no distractions from her cares. She was home for three weeks: "I don't care if they fire me." She sulked, feeling robbed of a promising future. "It isn't fair!" "No, but the sooner you stop lamenting over the unfairness of life, the better off you'll be." "But I'm so ignorant! All I wanted to do was learn, and they're not letting me!" "Not letting you learn? No school has such power. There are many ways to learn. If you're 'so ignorant,' as you put it, then you're in an ideal situation, in a way, because almost anything you do will teach you something new." I could tell this conversation was about as comforting to Katherine as a bed of nails. Evenings, she withdrew into her bedroom. She ate dinner alone, and I worried she wasn't eating properly. "Have you spoken to Virginia lately?" I asked one night. "Yes. Some woman is letting her share a tiny apartment, and Virginia had to give away her dog. It's so sad." Two days before Thanksgiving, Katherine felt sick. "Perhaps you'd better come with me to my mother's," I said. "No. I want to see my friends over the weekend and if I come with you, I'll miss them." On Saturday she telephoned my mother's apartment: "When are you coming home?" she cried. Her friends wouldn't drive out to see her. She was feeling too ill to travel. On Sunday I had plans to go to the museum. I telephoned a good woman friend and she said she'd take Katherine over to her house. "I'll be back Sunday evening," I told Katherine. She didn't hide her disappointment and I didn't explain myself. Steven came home before Christmas. By New Year's Katherine was resolving to become more social. She took a TV production course, made new friends, and felt confident enough by May to take the funds Steven had set aside for her further education and move out to California to live with her old friend Carol.
Perspectives: Stepmothers
The phone rings at I2:30 A.M. "] got a job!" Katherine sings over the wire. "It's not a career, but it's fun, that's okay isn't it? I don't want to be doing it when I'm twenty-five, but it's okay for twenty-two, isn't it?" "Yes, it sounds just fine for twenty-two." "I can't wait for you guys to come and see our beach house. It's small, but terrific, so. . . California!
On my birthday Katherine wrote to me: "Thanks for putting up with me when I couldn't put up with myself. I love you very much." I love you too, Katherine. Bon voyage!
IO
The Envious Heart Helane Levine-Keating
Then her envious heart had rest so far as an envious heart can have rest. - The Brothers Grimm, "Little Snow White"
Apples are the fruit of autumn the season I detest. That was when he married me, never letting on. He said she was simply a girl, a thin thing with straight hair. He said he rarely saw her although she was his daughter. You are my only queen, he said. Look in this mirrorit is yours. I look, but all I see is her sneering face, her wide lips mimicking mine. Instead of a little girl there's a woman not much younger than myself. When they're together she's his queen, that black-eyed slut, calling him Daddy with her bone-dry lust, looking over her shoulder at him till he turns from me, transfixed.
© 1988 Helane Levine-Keating.
93
Perspectives: Stepmothers She'll stop at nothing, making him tell her stories about her mother, the same ones over and over. How can I cover my ears? Now everywhere I go voices whisper proclaiming her loveliest. Who remembers my beauty? Each night beneath his body her shadow erases me. In my mirror I am invisible.
94
Mothers
II
Only My Favorite Mommy Sheila Alson I have not gotten beyond the adjustment period yet. It is entirely possible that the adjustment period never ends, and I am here thinking about the beginning of the constant reshuffling that will occupy the rest of our lives. This is the story of one particular mother's experience with her children's acquisition of a stepparent. The mother is me. These are the particulars of my life. Steven and I were much better at divorce than we were at marriage. At twenty-five, when I married him, I knew I was marrying my future children's father. Through the personal earthquake of divorce we controlled our deepest urges to punch and counterpunch so that we could maintain amicability and continue co-parenting our two children. We have joint custody, which means that Alex (five) and Amy (ten) live with each of us half the time. They have two homes. During the postseparation period, when no new love had yet come to fill in the spot that divorce had vacated, Steven and I spent much time on the phone and in each other's houses. We were friends, but with the definite lack of ease that our joint history had given us. Our children remained the best effort between us. Then Steven decided he wanted love in his life-not an unreasonable request-and Joanne appeared, with her fourteen-year-old daughter, Susan. A few months later they rented a house together around the corner from me. The following are entries from a journal kept during the time of transition.
97
Perspectives: Mothers Alex called yesterday and left a message on my machine. "I love you and miss you." Relief that he misses me when he's at Steven's house. He wakes up in the morning on the days when he's with me and asks if he can go to Daddy's today. I wonder why he's not satisfied here. I am even-tempered with the kids most of the time. Maybe I'm not paying enough attention to Alex when he's here. All my domestic instincts come out when the kids are around. I seem able to clean house only when they are at home with me. There's something going on at Steven's house that draws Alex. It's Joanne and Susan-the new family. Alex comes into bed with me in the middle of the night. It's a big, empty bed and I welcome his warm little body snuggling up to me. He crawls into bed with Steve at his house, but now it's not "Daddy's bed." It's "Daddy and Joanne's bed." He snuggles between them the way Amy used to snuggle between Steve and me until her newborn brother took her place. But Alex has no baby to take his place in bed and it's up to us to wean him away from that. It's time. It's more than time. He's almost five years old. Maybe now that Steve will have a permanent bed partner he'll agree that it's time. We have to show a united front on this.
(message on tape): Hey, Mom. You already know my name and you'll see me tomorrow. Just called because 1 just need to talk to you about something you already found out about. Clue-having to do with me moving with another person besides my family. Goodbye. ME (calling back): Do you want to talk about your message now? AMY: Not while Alex is still awake. Daddy didn't tell him yet. He says Alex will be so excited, and it will take a while before he and Joanne find an apartment. AMY
Alex woke up next to me this morning and said, "I had a dream I was riding a magical horse and it was not scary and it took me home to Daddy's house." He wrapped his warm body around my arm and hugged it. "I love you, Mommy." I had the flu yesterday. I'm recovering today in bed. Alex watched TV all afternoon but after a few hours he demanded my attention and presence downstairs so I dragged myself into the living room and read a few books to him. I asked Steve for help but he is not interested in helping me any more. When the kids are with me, it's for me to deal with. 1 asked Amy to go to the store and pick up a few items and something for each of us for dinner.
Only My Favorite Mommy She's being very helpful. She even put Alex to bed. But she's still only ten years old and can't hold herself back from fighting over her possessions with her brother. She's afraid to fully open up to me about her feelings about her daddy and Joanne. She knows how sensitive I am about it. She says she doesn't want to live with someone she doesn't love and she doesn't love Joanne. ME: Is it Joanne herself, or is it just living with anyone? Do you like Joanne? AMY: She's nice. It's not Joanne. The only thing wrong with her is she's around too much. It's never just the family any more. She's always there. You know those tickets to Alvin Ailey? Well, last week Daddy said Susan decided not to go. I didn't even know that they were going in the first place. And they're going along to the celebration dinner Daddy promised me for my performance. ME: Do you get along with Susan? AMY: Well, yes. She's okay. ME: She'll be like your older sister now. You get to have an older sister. AMY: Well, yes, but I never thought she would be a teenager. I mean, she'll be going out with boys and everything. Alex will be thrilled. He's really into Susan. He really likes Joanne, too. Daddy says Alex needs a mommy in every house. ME: Are you jealous that Alex likes Susan? AMY: Yes. I am. I'm afraid he won't think I'm so special anymore. ME: You'll always be his Amy. You'll never be replaced. AMY: Neither will you, Mommy.
Can't find the way to deal with Amy any more. Maybe she just needs to fight and I'm the only one she can fight with. But it drains me. The adjustment is so hard for her. She likes Joanne. She wants me to like Joanne. I do think Joanne is probably a very nice woman, but it's still hard for me to adjust. I think my daughter's adjustment is linked to my adjustment, but she has her own problems as well. She says she doesn't feel at home with Steve and Joanne because Joanne does not feel like part of her family yet. So she can't get hysterical there and throw tantrums when she's frustrated because she's embarrassed in front of Joanne and Susan. So she saves it all for me and she blows up at the least little thing. She's constantly on Alex's case as Alex is also on hers.
99
Perspectives: Mothers I notice my father's books consist of western novels, Prevention magazine issues, and Masters and Johnson's The Pleasure Bond. My father and his new wife are at the Ramada Inn while Joe and I are using his apartment for the first day of our weekend in Florida together. Joe is out runnIng. If there's anything to work out here, it's the past in the presentreplacement and loss. For most of us, when we marry we place our trust in the illusion that we can build our family around us and take refuge in it. For me, the illusion has gone. I stepped out of the refuge. With all the analysis and conviction I have concerning the demise of our relationship, I am still bewildered. I have left behind an essential and dear part of myself, a self who still needs the illusion. The way one's phone number becomes one's name, when I gave away the family phone number to my exhusband, I gave away my name. Tuesday, when I dialed that name of ten years, it was his new partner's voice on the machine. It said, "This is the home of Joanne and Steve . . . ." Someone else had stepped into the illusion, taking the place I had left. I left the message I meant for him. "I am doing book orders for Alex's daycare, so if you see any money or order forms in his pouch when you pick him up this week, leave it there. It is for me." I left for vacation. I thought I would just push these feelings away, but the necessity of writing this article puts the title "Stepparenting" on the top of the page and pushes the issue to the forefront. Joanne is the stepmother of my children and the new partner of my ex-husband. This is a new situation and we have not yet settled into any modes. We are just reacting. I know none of her reactions. I know only my own and the reactions of my children, at least those they share with me. I am away on vacation and I call up my children. Amy answers and she is excited to hear from me, but Alex, Steve, and Joanne are out. She insists on calling back when they get home so Alex can have the opportunity to talk to me, too. When she calls back an hour later, Alex won't come to the phone. Amy is mortified and says her brother is rude and he must come. I tell her, "No. No. It's okay," but she persists. Finally, Alex gets on the phone and whines, "Hello." 1 am stiff in my voice and ask him how he's doing. He answers, "I didn't want to talk to you because I want to watch the movie with Joanne and Daddy." I say, "It's okay, Alex. I love you." He says, "Who else would you like to talk to?" "Put Amy back on." Amy by now hates him for acting that way to me, but I try to assure her I understand, and do understand that this five-year-
100
Only My Favorite Mommy old does not feel the significance of the I,soo-mile distance or the subtleties of adult insecurities, but sometimes rationality has nothing to do with the way we react. After I hang up the phone I cry.
Last night Amy said she was feeling better about Joanne, but she still feels jealous. ME: Jealous of what? AMY: Of Daddy and Joanne. They're always kissing. As Steve dropped Alex off he gave me the latest report on Alex's nighttime habits. He spent every night in his own bed, but he put up a big fight and cried every night. He only went to sleep, finally, when Steve yelled at him. So, at 12:00 P.M. Alex woke up as usual and started to come into my bed. I was already asleep but woke. I gently picked him up, put him down into his bed and lay down with him. He would not settle down. He cried the whole time. "Mommy, I need you. I can't go to sleep without you. I want the wall to fall down between our room so I won't have to sleep alone." I finally left him in his room crying. He came into my room hesitantly a few times and ran back into his own room. Back and forth. It was almost I :00, and I was tired, and he was crying. He came into my bed, and I said he had to leave. He was crying so bitterly I wanted to hug him, and he said, "It's like you don't love me." I said I love him. I hugged him and gave in. Don't do that to my favorite mommy. She's your only mommy. ALEX: She's my favorite mommy. AMY: She's your only mommy. ALEX: She's my only favorite mommy. AMY: She's your only mommy. ALEX: She's only my favorite mommy. AMY: Only your favorite mommy? Only? She's the only mommy you have. ALEX:
AMY:
(to me): You're mine, no one else's. What's this mine? I'm yours. Can't you share? You can't share people? You're mine, but I share you with Alex. And I share you with Daddy.
AMY ME:
101
Perspectives: Mothers I'll share you with Alex but with no one else. You can share me with Alex and Daddy but with no one else. ME: But I share you with the world. I share you with your friends who you love and your friends who you don't love and with your grandparents and aunts and uncles and your teachers and the friends of your friends. AMY: My teachers don't have me. ME: I share you with the world. ALEX: And with Joanne and Susan. AMY:
Amy writes a story for school, a play in which the mother character is saintlike in her capacity to understand; there's a scene at her father's house: the father and his girlfriend smooching at the table and the ten-year-old girl character going up to her room to cry. After writing the story, Amy is afraid that if her daddy sees this play his feelings will be hurt because the daddy in the play walks away helpless in the face of his daughter's crying.
I could tell Steve was annoyed when I reported to him Wednesday morning that I was weak and let Alex stay in bed with me. But I said I intended to keep him in his own bed. At least at his house, Steve said, he would get the message clearly.
Amy says she is like a baby. She needs attention all the time like a baby, to be watched and checked in on all the time to see if she's all right. She says she needs to receive constant attention, just like Alex and Susan.
I think the story of the birthday dinner epitomizes my own conflict. It's interesting to me that the whole birthday interaction never made it to the journal. It is only in retrospect that I can record the story. My kids were born on the same date five years apart. This coincidence of planet alignment fills me with respect for the day, February 24, a day that I consider not only their birthday, but my day of birthing. Immediately I ruled out the possibility that Joanne could attend their birthday parties. The move was only a few weeks old at the time, and my emotions were on edge. I didn't want to put myself through the strain of
102
Only My Favorite Mommy having to push down tears while trying to run two consecutive children's parties. So, by fiat, I said I didn't want Joanne to come, and I wanted the parties to be either at my house or in a neutral place. (To date I have not gotten past the front door of their house.) Steven said he understood, and that Joanne would understand, too. But the kids did not understand. Alex said he wanted Joanne at his party, but accepted my decision with the same consternation he uses when I tell him he can't have another cookie. Amy, who has found the joint gift of words and volume with which to torture her parents, screamed and yelled that it was her birthday and she wanted to celebrate it with all the people she lived with. As is our style of combat, I countered her high pitch with calm explanation. I can remain rational if she does not hold out too long. Luckily, this time, there was no need for my own hysteria. I told her, and I still hope it will be true someday, that I will soon get used to Joanne's presence in their lives, but now it makes me feel sad because it reminds me of the good things I gave up when her daddy and I decided to get a divorce. Soon, I said, I hope we will all be friends, but it hasn't happened yet, and I don't want to feel sad on my children's birthday. Amy responded to that explanation, and the issue was dropped for the moment. Round two began when Amy realized that though the parties were Sunday, their real birthday was Tuesday, a day that the children are normally with Steve. On Tuesday she wanted to have our traditional family dinner for their birthday with everyone. We should all go out to dinner together, all around the big round table in the Japanese restaurant. "I thought we dealt with this already," I said. "I'm angry that you're bringing it up again." "This is different. It's the day of my birthday and you won't let Joanne come to the party. I want to have a chance to celebrate it with her. You're my mother and I want to celebrate it with you too." "So after school you and Alex can come to my house and we'll have a snack together. Then you can leave and have dinner with Joanne and Daddy." "You say you want me to feel comfortable with Joanne and accept her as part of my family, but you're making it so hard for me by not even eating dinner on our birthday together. I think if you can't even be in the same room as her, I feel guilty for being friendly with her, like I'm deserting you." How did this ten-year-old learn to say such things? I panicked, started to scream at her, then disallowed the conversation. I needed time to think. I promptly ran to the experts, the women who are the mothers-in-arms in this parenting endeavor-my friends. I got as many opinions on what to do as I have friends, each feeling very strongly about this issue. There were two basic tendencies: (I) Listen to the clear needs of your child; you are
1°3
Perspectives: Mothers the adult. (2) Listen to your own needs; the child will survive and will benefit from a mother who clearly states her own needs. The date was drawing near with no solution, so I attempted a modified version of the original all-evening celebration. I proposed, "I will meet you and Daddy and everyone else in the restaurant at 5 :00, and we'll all eat together. Then I will leave for my class." "But I don't want to open my presents in the restaurant. I want you to come over to Daddy and Joanne's house before the restaurant so I can open all the presents at the same time." "Don't push it, Amy. I said what I would do. I won't do any more." We hung up, still furious at each other. The next morning Amy called with another proposal. "Daddy suggested that Alex and 1 go over to your house after school and we'll open presents from you there. Then you, Alex, and 1 will meet Daddy with Joanne and Susan in the restaurant at 5 :00. We can all eat, then you can leave." "Okay." Relief. Tuesday comes. Already by 3 :00 1 have a headache. I rush around after work to wrap the presents for my kids before they come over. They come through the door with smiles and hugs and open their presents. An idyllic family scene. Gift wrap spread all over the floor and presents immediately played with. At 5 :00 the three of us pile into the car. As we are parking in front of the restaurant 1 see my ex-husband with his new partner and her daughter drive by on their way to a parking spot. My stomach is about to drop out of its abdominal cradle. We enter the restaurant first. I choose the big round table in the corner and seat myself with my back against the wall-the best defense. My kids sit across from me, but 1 ask them to sit next to me, one on each side. We wait for the others. Joanne seats herself directly across from me, her daughter on her right, Steve to her left. We are all smiles and chatter. 1 immediately notice her sweater. "I have the same sweater," 1 say. "But, come to think of it, I haven't seen it in a few months." "This one's not yours. It's mine." This she says with a giggle. "But I just mean that I must have neglected to pick it up from the dry cleaner. Of course that one is not mine." Joanne wants to order the eggplant appetizer, but Susan and Steve hate eggplant. So she asks if I will share it. I'm not crazy about eggplant, but what the hell. Share children. Share eggplant. The eggplant is poorly prepared and Joanne is apologetic. I don't eat it. Steve and I fill up the air with conversation about the evils of the board of education, the employer we both have in common. With animation we
10 4
Only My Favorite Mommy take turns explaining the ins and outs of working for a bureaucracy to Joanne. This is a bond between us-a safe, irnpersonal bond. Amy sticks close by me during the meal, holding my hand and following the conversation. Alex quickly develops a close relationship with the waitress, and, as the restaurant is empty, she plays games with him in the aisles. Only twice during the hour do I feel close to tears, but each time I manage to turn my head and push it back down. By the time the hour is over I have a massive headache, but the hour does end, the headache goes away with a good night's sleep, and I am still intact, telling the story. To date I have not made much progress on the issue, but I am working up the courage to ask for a tour of the new house. I am now involved in the beginnings of a new relationship and will soon have to deal with the difficulties of stepparenting from new angles-his relationship with my children, my relationship with his child, his relationship with my ex-husband, my relationship with his ex-wife. My father's marriage is probably breaking up. My father and his wife are both feeding me their gripes about each other, and my own mother is dying to hear the details from me. Should I tell?
1°5
I2
A Rainbow Family In the Deep South Yandra Soliz
Dear Ms. Maglin, I read your stepfamily article in Ms. magazine February 1985. I wanted to share a few things with you about my own unusual little family. My name is Yandra Soliz and I live in an Air Force town in middle Georgia. I am forty-four years of age and am Spanish and American Indian. I live in a blended interracial family and as such we are unusual in many ways. Living in a blended family is a unique experience in itself, but when the blended family is composed of multiracial members, it becomes even more complex. The stresses of daily life are compounded tenfold. . . . I was born and raised in Texas in 1941. We were poor, of course. Not destitute. Just regular poor. I've experienced racism since I was a child. We were patronized, exploited, and made to feel like second-class people. My life has been one of severe hardship, deprivation, and isolation. I left South Texas at the age of sixteen and went to £1 Paso to live with an aunt. There I met an Army serviceman, married, and went to live in the huge metropolis of New York City. I lived there for seventeen long years. My life there is another story. . . . The fast pace and violence of the city shocked and frightened me. But I also loved New York; all was not negative. I found out that being dark I was classified as Puerto Rican by everyone except Puerto Ricans.. . . I left my husband after seven long years of enduring physical and emotional abuse. I had two young children who were part Indian and part white. Then I met a black West Indian and
This letter is actually created from two long letters sent in February and March 1985.
106
A Rainbow Family in the Deep South had a very beautiful baby girl from that relationship. She is my youngest and her name is Yolanda. I left New York in October 1978 and went: back to Texas. It was a bad mistake. My young daughter experienced blatant racism and it broke her spirit. She had not experienced it before in New York City. She had gone to an inner-city school with multiracial children and now she was in school with children whose parents were rednecks and Mexicans. . . . It was not easy for my daughters and I in Texas. . . . I left Texas in June 1979 and went to live in lovely Oregon. For the first time in my turbulent life, I settled into a stable and quiet routine. I had a good job as a hospital ward clerk and I made many friends. ' In May 1983 I answered an ad in a pen-pal singles column. The newspaper had made an error and I wrote to this man, thinking that he was from California.. . . When his glowing letter arrived from Georgia, I was stunned! He seemed like the perfect man for me, but the state of Georgia became a serious thought in my mind. I was well aware of the powerful racial dynamics which were inherent in the South. . . . I kept the letter for a whole month in my closet. Twice I would begin to write and then threw the unfinished letters away. To make a long story short, we began writing and quickly fell in love. We were married in December 1983 after a whirlwind of ten days in October of the same year. I met all his grown children and his young son, who was then twelve. I began my new life in Georgia in Decenlber 1983. My husband is a very caring, tender, gentle, and sensitive man. . . . It is hard to believe that he came from harsh, severe poverty in the mill country of North Carolina. His family was a rough, poor group of people and they were classified as poor white trash. He left home at a young age and joined the Army Air Corps. His attitudes toward people and the world at large are not those that his parents or grandparents had. He has truly evolved. . . . He has totally accepted my fifteen-year-old daughter, who was fourteen when we married. Our family consists of my husband Robert; myself; Mark, Robert's son, who is fourteen; and Yolanda, my daughter" who is fifteen. I would consider us lower middle class. My husband is a retired Air Force sergeant and he has a very good job with a prominent law firm as a legal assistant and title researcher. He is considered one of the top in his field in Georgia. Now to the nitty-gritty part of my story. . . . first of all my daughter and Robert's son are two different people. ~1y daughter is shy, quiet, and very withdrawn. She is paranoid about white people and clearly distrusts them. She is angry at me for having married and placing her in a blended mixed family. . . . My marriage and new lifestyle have greatly affected
1°7
Perspectives: Mothers her. We've always been close and she had our little duplex in Oregon all to herself while I worked evenings as a medical hospital clerk. Our lives were set and we were happy together. But now, she resents sharing the bathroom, etc. She resents living in a multiracial family. She is very unhappy at her high school. The black girls at her school question her mercilessly about her color, her background, her family. . . . She comes home all stressed out.. . . She suffers from bouts of abdominal pain and tension headaches. I ache for this child of mine and have bouts of guilt over her unhappiness. Yolanda speaks to my husband Robert, but only occasionally. She admits to me that he's a good man. She compares him to the white father on the television program Different Strokes. She knows very well that he's very good to me. Robert really loves Yolanda and realizes that she needs help. But she refuses to allow him to even be a friend to her. Robert's son is outgoing, personable, and friendly. He's a good-looking youngster and very much like his dad. There is no malice or hatred in his heart. He tried to make friends with Yolanda from the very beginning, but she would have none of it. Yolanda will simply not speak to him. So now he avoids her as well. They are like two boarders living in the same house, that's all. It is so strange. However, things are changing; Yolanda is beginning to communicate with Mark more while withdrawing more from Robert. Mark has caught some flak at his school for having a black stepsister. They use the derogatory word. He has stopped bringing his friends over to the house and I'm sure I know why. . . . Now, as for me and Mark. At the beginning of my marriage to his father, we really hit it off and became friends, but at this point, he and I are no longer friends. There is a rift between us now. We are not ugly to each other, but there are occasions when the anger and the hurt surface. His father is caught in the middle. My husband and his son have a good relationship. It is hard on Robert because Mark is an active fourteen and Robert is fifty-six. Mark literally engulfs him with affection and clings to him. His mother died when he was only five. After that, his first stepmother was a cruel woman who physically and mentally abused hinl. And now me. He has been through a lot of changes, just as Yolanda has. He loves his father and somewhat resents me and sees me as a threat. He feels that Yolanda gets away with a lot of things and he doesn't. My parenting is different than Robert's and that has caused problems. I am very liberal and permissive with Yolanda whereas Robert is a fair disciplinarian. Mark spends every weekend with his older sister in another town close
108
A Rainbow Family in the Deep South by. There is a strong bond between them and I strongly sense that they talk about Yolanda and I. They think we're weird in our ways. I am very hurt for I know for a fact that he told his older sisters that my daughter ate all the food in the house, etc. Also he told them I had his father wrapped around my finger and that I cooked only TV dinners. Things like that. He wants to go to live with his sister, but Robert won't let him. . . . Then there was a misunderstanding over a phone call my daughter answered from my husband's older daughter. There were some accusations and hurt feelings all around. Well, at that point, I went into my Indian shell and have been there for a long time. There have been many cultural and ethnic differences between his children and I. They are a very family-oriented group and my daughter and I are not. Holidays are not that important to us, but they are to them. Furthermore, my husband is a very precious, kind, generous man and before I came along was always helping his daughters financially, especially two of them. My husband has paid all the insurance and bills on a mobile home he gave to the youngest daughter and we are heavily in debt. I do not feel it is fair to my husband and to us, his family. I could have begun college with that money. This whole matter has left me feeling resentful and antagonistic toward his daughter. I feel Robert has placed her before us, his family. I will not go to Robert's children's homes. . . . They're nice enough and I know they like me, at least for their father's sake. . . . it is hard for me to go to his grown children's homes and hear racist words and slurs used loosely by their husbands and wives. . . . I do not wish to sit there and smile frozenly as this goes on.. . . Last year my husband went alone to their homes for Thanksgiving and Christmas. I stayed home with Y0landa. However, this happened initially when we were first married but as time went on, I accepted them a little more and felt more comfortable around them. There is one daughter in particular whom I really like and respect. . . . There are the usual problems of finances and other normal things in our marriage. And there are other problems in our marriage having nothing to do with race or our blended-family status. I tend to have mood swings and bouts of depression. My husband says I anl like a chameleon, never the same. I would like to get on with my life and learn all that I can. My husband and I are presently in an interracial family support group in Atlanta. I am attending evening college classes and hope to pursue a career in the human service area. I will close my story now. Even though I wrote it in parts, I find myself weary and emotionally drained. I struggle hard with my com-
1°9
Perspectives: Mothers plex and ambivalent feelings and thoughts. I wanted to write about my life, as it has been unusual and very different. I consider myself a true surVIvor. Sincerely, Yandra Soliz
110
13 The Step-Wedding Wilma Wolfenstein
From time to time in every family's history there occurs a milestone, a major event that marks a critical change in the family life cycle. In this account of my daughter's marriage I shall describe, from my personal perspective, the unfolding of the wedding preparations, the occasion itself, and its aftermath, against the background of an exceptionally complicated family network (Figure I). Most families, according to the psychiatrist Jack Bradt, pass through nodal events mindlessly, "unaware of the exquisitely sensitive possibilities of disturbance and the complexity of meaning of such events in the multigenerational system of some families." 1 Edwin Friedman, family therapist and consultant on family life, views "periods surrounding rites of passage as 'hinges of time' . . . [when] family relationship systems seem to unlock." He discusses "how family process operates at emotionally significant moments of life cycle change." 2 The story that follows tells what happens when the bride's two families, long out of contact, are drawn temporarily into each other's orbit by the marriage of a mutual daughter. A Little Background My daughter Laura had gone to college on the West Coast. After graduation she remained there for several years, struggling to find her way, to find herself, during the unrest and social ferment of the I 970s. A gestalt group provided anchorage for a while; the feminist movement surely had a permanent impact on the course of her life. From my home in Ohio I tried to stay in touch despite the miles bet\\reen us. Although I refrained from probing, I did sometimes wonder hovv I, as her mother, fared in whatever assessments went on.
III
Figure
I.
Genogram of Members of the Step-Wedding: Laura's Family
Barbara
Stanley
c. 1950
marrIed 193 2(?)
married 1954
marrIed 1986
Mary
Charles
Steve
Wendy
b. 1979
Note: italics IndICates famIly nlember present at wedding.
112
Laura's stepfather
DarWin]
Narrator
married 1942 divorced 1950
Adaln
b. 1949
married 1957
Michael b. 1960
Darwin's I"t wife
Susan's stepfather
married 1943 divorced 1948
Susan
b. 194 6
Ron
Adam's ex-wife married I 970 divorced 1979
Peter b. 1974
Lisa
b. 1979
Joanna
n.
1975
113
Perspectives: Mothers My daughter was not yet three, my son Adam only one year old, when I separated from their father. As vital as this step was for me, I have never overcome a certain uneasiness over the possible hidden and subtle effects on the children of that early separation from their father. I moved with Laura and Adam back to the Midwest town where I had grown up. Their father came from time to time, and later they visited him annually on the West Coast where he settled with his wife, Barbara, his two stepsons, and the new baby of the remarriage. With nearly a continent's breadth dividing the two families, my role as primary parent was reinforced. Moreover, this was the era before the invention of joint custody. By the time I remarried, Laura was nine and Adam seven. The children and I joined Darwin in the Ohio city where he was employed. Quite soon a more dramatic change confronted us: my husband's work took us abroad for an entire year. And so the process of consolidating as a stepfamily took place against the backdrop of a foreign land: one adventure within another. Laura adjusted with ease, just as earlier-and later-she accommodated smoothly during the repeated visits with her father's family. During those summer trips Laura became friendly with all members of her father's family, including his wife, Barbara, Barbara's two sons, and little Anne. I have always taken a certain pride in Laura's talent for moving so gracefully within the intricate family system in which she found herself. Much later, as a young adult, Laura would sometimes tell me that she was not "hung up" on finding a husband. I supported her resolve to develop a firm sense of herself before making that fateful move. From personal experience I couldn't have agreed more. Was she warned then not only by feminist doctrine but also by her mother's example? Eventually Laura decided to pursue her education. She enrolled in a graduate program in a Michigan university. After obtaining her degree Laura at last found the kind of fulfilling work that had eluded her for so long. It was not until she was well established in her profession that Daniel entered her life. At a distance I followed the evolving romance as it became increasingly clear that here were two young people ready to settle down together. When they announced their engagement my husband and I were delighted to welcome Daniel into the family.
Planning the Wedding
Laura and Daniel set the wedding date five months ahead and together they devoted serious thought to its planning. From the start they wanted
114
The Step-Wedding family to be present. Daniel's parents and other close relatives live in southern California; Laura's father and stepmother had recently moved to that region. During her own years there Laura had grown very close to her stepbrother and his wife, Steve and Wendy. Laura conceived the idea that Steve and Wendy's home in the canyons would be a perfect site for the wedding. They agreed. Silently I surrendered ITlY secret dream of her wedding at the fireplace of our Cleveland home. After all, nearly all family members-with the exception of my husband, myself, and our two mutual children-reside in the vicinity of southern California. Through Adam, my older son who also lives in that area, I gathered that my former husband and his wife, Stanley and Barbara, should not be expected to participate actively in the forthcoming wedding. At the time Laura and Daniel announced their engagement they had rejected her father's request for a traditional Jewish ceremony; hence, according to my son, Stan and his wife would be taking a back seat, so to speak. What an odd twist! The wedding would be in his stepson's home; but if Stan and Barbara were to be passive onlookers, it seerned clear that my husband and I would be principally in charge of the affair. And so across the continent I began the task of contacting caterers, consulting at each step with my daughter and Daniel, who as a modern bridegroom wished equal input into the decisions. At the same time I felt impelled to take on another mission: to bring Stan and Barbara, if possible, into a more active and positive mode of participation. They had moved to the Coast some thirty years earlier while I had remained in the Midwest. Face-to-face contact between us had been rarc, and there was virtually no written communication since our two mutual children had grown up. Friends asked me repeatedly in the weeks before the wedding whether I was feeling tense or apprehensive in view of the forthcoming mingling of the families. The truth is that I found myself eagerly anticipating the wedding as a very special "happening." Although a first marriage for the principal parties, I envisioned it as a "step-wedding," with three sets of parents offering their good will to create a memorable and meaning