WETLANDS: ECOLOGY, CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION
No part of this digital document may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means. The publisher has taken reasonable care in the preparation of this digital document, but makes no expressed or implied warranty of any kind and assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions. No liability is assumed for incidental or consequential damages in connection with or arising out of information contained herein. This digital document is sold with the clear understanding that the publisher is not engaged in rendering legal, medical or any other professional services.
WETLANDS: ECOLOGY, CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION
RAYMUNDO E. RUSSO EDITOR
Nova Science Publishers, Inc. New York
Copyright © 2008 by Nova Science Publishers, Inc. All rights reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system or transmitted in any form or by any means: electronic, electrostatic, magnetic, tape, mechanical photocopying, recording or otherwise without the written permission of the Publisher. For permission to use material from this book please contact us: Telephone 631-231-7269; Fax 631-231-8175 Web Site: http://www.novapublishers.com NOTICE TO THE READER The Publisher has taken reasonable care in the preparation of this book, but makes no expressed or implied warranty of any kind and assumes no responsibility for any errors or omissions. No liability is assumed for incidental or consequential damages in connection with or arising out of information contained in this book. The Publisher shall not be liable for any special, consequential, or exemplary damages resulting, in whole or in part, from the readers’ use of, or reliance upon, this material. Independent verification should be sought for any data, advice or recommendations contained in this book. In addition, no responsibility is assumed by the publisher for any injury and/or damage to persons or property arising from any methods, products, instructions, ideas or otherwise contained in this publication. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information with regard to the subject matter covered herein. It is sold with the clear understanding that the Publisher is not engaged in rendering legal or any other professional services. If legal or any other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent person should be sought. FROM A DECLARATION OF PARTICIPANTS JOINTLY ADOPTED BY A COMMITTEE OF THE AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION AND A COMMITTEE OF PUBLISHERS. LIBRARY OF CONGRESS CATALOGING-IN-PUBLICATION DATA Wetlands : ecology, conservation, and restoration / Raymundo E. Russo (editor). p. cm. ISBN 978-1-60876-354-2 (E-Book) 1. Wetland ecology. 2. Wetland conservation. 3. Wetland restoration. I. Russo, Raymundo E. QH541.5.M3W4836 2008 577.68--dc22 2008030635
Published by Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
New York
CONTENTS Preface
vii
Expert Commentary Two Alternative Modes for Diffuse Pollution Control by Wetlands Chen Qingfeng, Shan Baoqing and Ma Junjian
1
Short Communication Multiangular Imaging of Wetlands in New England Lesley-Ann L. Dupigny-Giroux and Eden Furtak-Cole
7
Research and Review Articles Chapter 1
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”? Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
Chapter 2
Remote Sensing Data for Regional Wetland Mapping in the United States: Trends and Future Prospects Megan W. Lang and Greg W. McCarty
Chapter 3
Chapter 4
Transforming Useless Swamps into Valuable Wetlands: Evaluating America’s Policy, 1970-2008 Andrea K.Gerlak and Jeanne N. Clarke Dynamics of Coastal Wetlands and Land Use Changes in the Watershed: Implications for the Biodiversity Miguel Ángel Esteve, M. Francisca Carreño, Francisco Robledano, Julia Martínez-Fernández and Jesús Miñano
Chapter 5
Pathogen Removal in Constructed Wetlands Kela P. Weber and Raymond L. Legge
Chapter 6
The Role of Harvest and Plant Decomposition in Constructed Wetlands Juan A. Álvarez and Eloy Bécares
15
73
113
133
177
213
vi Chapter 7
Chapter 8
Chapter 9
Chapter 10
Chapter 11
Chapter 12
Contents Nutrition and Toxicity of Inorganic Substances from Wastewater in Constructed Wetlands Zhenhua Zhang, Zed Rengel and Kathy Meney A Conceptual and Methodological Framework for the Study of Vegetated Fluvial Landscape Evolutionary Trajectories Dov Corenblit, Johannes Steiger, Eric Tabacchi and Angela M. Gurnell Macrophyte Morphological Response to the Industrial Effluent Toxicity in a Constructed Wetland H. R. Hadad, M. M. Mufarrege, M. Pinciroli, G. Di Luca, V. del Sastre and M. A. Maine Phytoremediation Processes for Water and Air Pollution Control in the Aspects of Nutrient and Carbon Dioxide Removals Jae Seong Rhee, Yonghui Song, Fasheng Li and Janjit Iamchaturapatr
271
295
325
Phytoplankton Biomass Regulation in Contrasting Environmental States of Temporary Pools Silvia Martín, Marta Rodríguez and David G. Angeler
359
Can Tern Migrants Coexist with Urban Development and Estuarine Recreational Activities? Ken Chan, Jill Dening and Marja-Leena Malinen
373
Chapter 13
Agricultural Wetlands R. Kröger
Chapter 14
Profiling Cover Cycle Dynamics for Prairie Pothole Wetland Landscapes Rebecca L. Phillips and Ofer Beeri
Index
247
391
407 419
PREFACE Wetlands are lands where saturation with water is the dominant factor determining the nature of soil development and the types of plant and animal communities living in the soil and on its surface. Wetlands vary widely because of regional and local differences in soils, topography, climate, hydrology, water chemistry, vegetation, and other factors, including human disturbance. Indeed, wetlands are found from the tundra to the tropics and on every continent except Antarctica. This new book brings together the latest research in the field. Short Communication - Multiple view angles (MVA) or multiangular imaging represents a yet to be explored use of the remote sensing of wetlands. The ability to view the landscape off-nadir (traditionally the surface is viewed at right angles) allows for the quantification of moisture stress, species separation and the proportion of vegetation to standing water in these ecosystems. This commentary will focus on the ratio of two broadband wavelengths (nearinfrared to blue) derived from multiangular images acquired by the Airborne Multi-angle Imaging SpectroRadiometer (AirMISR) of wetlands across New England. The resulting insights into the photointerpretation, monitoring and mapping of wetlands will be highlighted. Chapter 1 - Human societies have indirectly used natural wetlands as wastewater discharge sites for many centuries. Observations of the wastewater depuration capacity of natural wetlands have led to a greater understanding of the potential of these ecosystems for pollutant assimilation and have stimulated the development of artificial wetlands systems for treatment of wastewaters from a variety of sources. Constructed wetlands, in contrast to natural wetlands, are human-made systems that are designed, built and operated to emulate wetlands or functions of natural wetlands for human desires or needs. Constructed wetlands have recently received considerable attention as low cost, efficient means to clean-up not only municipal wastewaters but also point and non-point wastewaters, such as acid mine drainage, agricultural effluents, landfill leachates, petrochemicals, as well as industrial effluents. Currently, untreated wastewater discharge in the natural wetlands sites is becoming an increasingly abandoned practice whereas the use of constructed wetlands for treatment of wastewater is an emerging technology worldwide. However, natural wetlands still play an important role in the improvement of water quality as they act as buffer zones surrounding water bodies and as a polishing stage for the effluents from conventional municipal wastewater treatment plants, before they reach the receiving water streams. In fact, one of the emerging issues in environmental science has been the inefficiency of wastewater treatment plants to remove several xenobiotic organic compounds such as pesticides and pharmaceutical residues and consequent contamination of the receiving water bodies. Recent
viii
Raymundo E. Russo
studies have shown that wetlands systems were able to efficiently remove many of these compounds, thus reaffirming the importance of the role which can be played by wetlands in water quality preservation. The aim of this work is to present a review on the application of wetlands as “living filters” for water purification. Emphasis was focused on the removal of micropollutants, especially xenobiotic organic compounds such as pharmaceuticals residues, which are not efficiently removed by conventional municipal wastewater treatment plants. Furthermore, the role of wetlands as protection zones which contribute to the improvement of the aquatic ecosystems’ quality will be discussed. Chapter 2 - Historically, the biologic, aesthetic, and economic values of wetlands were largely unappreciated. Wetlands within the United States have been and are continuing to disappear rapidly. Efforts are being made to conserve remaining wetlands and many regulatory policies have been adopted in support of this goal. To regulate the loss, preservation, and/or restoration of wetlands and to judge the effectiveness of these regulatory efforts in preserving associated ecosystem services, wetlands must be routinely monitored. Wetland mapping is an essential part of this monitoring program and much effort has been made by the US state and federal governments, as well as other organizations, to provide quality wetland map products. Wetland maps can serve a variety of purposes including regulation and natural resource management. They can also be used to parameterize models that quantify water quality and quantity, as well as the provision of wetland ecosystem services, at the watershed scale. Wetland hydrology is the most important abiotic factor controlling ecosystem function and extent, and it should therefore be a vital part of any wetland mapping or monitoring program. New approaches are needed to not only map wetlands, but also to monitor wetland hydrology as it varies in response to weather, vegetation phenology, surrounding landuse change, and other anthropogenic forces including climate change. Recently developed remote sensing technologies and techniques have the potential to improve the detail and reliability of wetland maps and the ability to monitor important parameters such as hydrology. Various types of remotely sensed data (e.g., aerial photographs, multispectral, hyperspectral, passive microwave, radar, and lidar) have different capabilities with specific advantages and disadvantages for wetland mapping at the regional scale. Although aerial photographs were traditionally used to map wetlands and infer hydrology, fine-resolution optical images are now available more frequently as commercial agencies increase satellite coverage (e.g., Quickbird and IKONOS). However, optical data, such as aerial photographs and multispectral satellite images have limitations, including their inability to detect hydrology below dense vegetative canopies and their limited ability to detect variations in hydrology (i.e., inundation and soil moisture). The restrictions of optical data are increasingly being compensated for with the use of new technologies, including synthetic aperture radar, lidar, and geospatial modeling. The availability of these new data sources is increasing rapidly. For example, many states in the US are now collecting synoptic state-wide coverages of lidar data. The sources, strengths, and limitations of different types of remotely sensed data are reviewed in this chapter, as well as the importance of temporal and spatial resolution necessary for regional scale wetland mapping efforts. The potential of multi-temporal, multi-sensor approaches that capitalize on geospatial modeling are emphasized for meeting current wetland mapping challenges. Chapter 3 - This paper traces the evolution of America’s wetland policy beginning with passage of the Clean Water Act (CWA) of 1972. This law, for the first time, established a
Preface
ix
federal program to protect wetlands, dramatically elevating the value of these ecosystems. However, despite attitudinal changes and new governmental programs, the nation continues to lose its potentially valuable wetlands -- albeit at a slower rate than was the case in the 1970s and prior to the passage of the CWA. This chapter offers an objective evaluation of the federal wetlands protection policy. The authors place this evaluation within a broad societal context, showing that since 1970 there have occurred sweeping demographic, economic, and political changes that clearly have impacted the extent of wetlands in the United States. They argue that Section 404 has failed to reverse the net loss of wetlands in the U.S. Moreover, it has evolved into a policy lightening rod within the water resources arena and been a major factor in Congress’ failure to revise and reauthorize the Clean Water Act. Finally, the authors offer some recommendations designed to improve the policy, arguing for heightened wetlands protection through partnerships and acquisitions. Chapter 4 - The Mediterranean coastal landscapes have suffered significant changes along the last decades due to the agricultural intensification and tourist development. Such changes have modified the water flows and specifically the hydrological regime of wetlands, as has occurred in the Mar Menor (Southeast Spain). The Mar Menor coastal lagoon and associated wetlands present noticeable ecological and biodiversity values. However, the landuse changes in the watershed and the consequent changes in the water and nutrient flows along the period 1980-2005 are threatening the conservation of these wetlands. A dynamic model has been developed to simulate the key environmental and socio-economic factors driving the export of nutrients to the Mar Menor lagoon and associated wetlands, where some eutrophication processes have appeared. In this chapter the changes in the vegetal and faunistic assemblages are analysed. Vegetal communities are studied by means of remote sensing techniques, which have provided information about the changes in area and habitat composition of the wetlands along the considered period. This has shown that the habitats more negatively affected by the hydrological changes are those most threatened in the international context and with a highest interest from the point of view of biodiversity conservation. It has also been possible to verify the direct relationships between all these changes at wetlands scale and the agricultural changes at the watershed scale. Two faunistic communities especially sensitive to these ecosystemic changes have also been studied: i) Wandering beetles and ii) Birds (waterbirds and steppe passerines). Wandering beetles (Coleoptera) were studied with pitfall traps in 1984, 1992 and 2003 and steppe passeriforms with line transects in several years along the period. In both communities evident changes have been observed. Regarding beetles, the most halophilous species have been favoured, some of them especially relevant due to its rarity in the European context. The ratio Carabidae/Tenebrionidae has shown to be a good indicator of the hydrological changes of the wetlands. Waterbirds have shown dramatic changes in their relative abundances within the lagoon, with a long-term decline in the most characteristic original species, increases in generalist piscivores and a recent appearance and rapid growth of the herbivores guild. In the case of steppe passeriforms, this community has been negatively affected, especially some species like Melanocorypha calandra. The family Alaudidae has lost importance to the benefit of the families Turdidae and Fringillidae. These changes can be considered a loss of value in relation with the original passeriform community, since the wetland qualifies as a Specially Protected Area under the EU’s Bird Directive, precisely on the basis of its genuine steppe bird assemblage.
x
Raymundo E. Russo
In conclusion, the changes at wetlands scale clearly reflect the hydrological modifications at the watershed scale and have significant effects on the most characteristic biodiversity of the wetlands of coastal arid systems. Chapter 5 - Conventional secondary and tertiary wastewater treatment methods include activated sludge, trickling filters, slow sand filtration, chlorination, ozonation and UV radiation. Chlorination being the most widely used pathogen disinfection method is presently under scrutiny as chlorination can produce carcinogenic trihalomethanes when natural organic matter is present in the wastewater. Constructed wetlands (CWs) have proven to be an effective treatment alternative for the removal and inactivation of pathogens in wastewaters. Constructed wetlands have low principle and operating costs and are fairly simple to design and implement, making them an attractive wastewater treatment alternative when compared to conventional secondary or tertiary treatment processes. Constructed wetlands designed for pathogen treatment are most often preceded by filtration or sedimentation. Pathogen removal efficiencies upwards of 99.99% have been reported by multiple authors employing many different constructed wetland designs. Constructed wetland design tends to be based largely on rule of thumb sizing, as the specific mechanisms and fundamental variables involved in pathogen removal are only vaguely understood. Suggested mechanisms of pathogen treatment in CWs include but are not restricted to sedimentation, natural die-off, temperature, oxidation, predation, unfavourable water chemistry, biofilm interaction, mechanical filtration, exposure to biocides and UV radiation. Pathogen removal has been shown to correlate well with hydraulic retention time. Use of first order decay kinetics is the preferred method to describe and predict pathogen removal in CWs. A severe lack of attention has been given to the comparative quantification of the specific mechanisms contributing to pathogen treatment in constructed wetlands. Small-scale controllable constructed wetland systems are identified as systems which can be used in conducting well-designed controlled experiments where fundamental mechanisms and variables involved in pathogen removal can be comparatively quantified. It is proposed that if the fundamental mechanisms and variables affecting pathogen removal in constructed wetlands are better understood and quantified the large performance variations reported for similarly designed treatment wetland systems can be better explained, engineered and controlled. Chapter 6 - Upon decomposition, at the end of the summer and during the autumn, wetland vegetation releases organic carbon into the wetland system. A part of this organic matter remains in the wetland, and is degraded at different rates during the rest of the year. Therefore, litter decomposition has important consequences on constructed wetlands because it is related to the autochthonous production of organic matter, clogging rates in surface-flow wetlands, and terrestrialization in free-water surface wetlands. The effect of harvest was studied in two free-water surface-flow wetlands. Both wetlands were planted with Typha latifolia with one of the wetlands harvested. On the other hand, decomposition rates of Typha latifolia were quantified during both winter and summer in the non-harvested surface constructed wetland using the litter bag technique. Nutrient concentrations were always lower in the effluent of the harvested wetland, indicating nitrogen and phosphorus release by decomposition of vegetation, in the non-harvested system. In addition, harvesting reduced the effluent TSS and BOD concentrations by 37.3% and 49.2%, respectively, when compared to the non-harvested wetland in spring. Seasonal background concentrations (C*) in the wetlands, increased from winter to spring and decreased again in summer. Organic load and nutrients produced per gram of Typha were evaluated by using in-
Preface
xi
situ Typha degradation experiments. Taking into account the experiments of litter bag technique, no significant differences were found in both variables among the different mesh sizes, with the exception of the control bags in winter. Meso or macrofauna did not play any role in plant decomposition. Decomposition rates were significantly different between winter and summer when considering each mesh size separately. Decomposition rates from adjusted exponential models ranged from 0.0014 to 0.0026 d-1 in winter (5ºC), and from 0.0043 to 0.0052 d-1 in summer (20ºC). Typha decomposition rates were compared with others macrophytes. From these decomposition rates, it is estimated that 31% of the initial mass of plant detritus would remain in the system after one year. Based on the research conducted during several experiments, harvesting can be recommended as an operational and management strategy in warm climates and diluted wastewater conditions. Chapter 7 - The use of constructed wetlands for purification of wastewater has received increasing attention around the world. A variety of wetland plant species (including ornamental ones) as either a monoculture or species mixes are used in constructed wetlands. Plants play an extremely important role in removing pollutants from wastewater. Although there is considerable information on plant productivity, biomass and nutrient dynamics in natural and fertilized wetlands, most studies on constructed wetlands for treatment of wastewaters have only addressed general aspects of plant growth and nutrient accumulation. Nutrition and toxicity of inorganic substances such as nitrogen, sulphur, salts and metals in wastewater on wetland plants has not been fully investigated and their interactive effects and environmental cycling in constructed wetlands remain poorly understood. Nitrogen nutrition is the most important factor influencing plant performance in constructed wetlands, but higher NH4-N may become toxic to wetland plants. Sulphur is an essential nutrient for plant growth, but under waterlogged conditions sulphate is reduced to hydrogen sulphide that is highly toxic to wetland plants. Many metals in wastewater are essential micronutrients for wetland plants, but become toxic if their concentration exceeds a specific critical point. A proper amount of salts is essential for plant growth, but high concentrations of salts, particularly sodium chloride in wastewater have harmful effects on plant growth. Wetland plant species have differential capacity to take up nutrients, different preference for nitrogen forms and have evolved various adaptive mechanisms protecting them against toxicity of inorganic substances. Given that plants are an integral part of constructed wetlands, the selection of suitable species, improvement of cultivations and determination of factors affecting growth are needed to produce healthy and effective wetland ecosystems. Understanding biogeochemical cycling in wetlands as well as nutrition and toxicity of inorganic substances from wastewater on plant development and function may help reduce performance variability and enhance pollutant removal in constructed wetlands. Chapter 8 - This chapter presents a conceptual and methodological framework to study temporal and spatial changes of fluvial landforms and associated plant communities and to identify the underlying causes of either progressive or sudden changes. Mutual interactions and feedbacks between hydrogeomorphic processes, fluvial landforms and vegetation dynamics are considered within this framework, leading to the analysis of biogeomorphic (i.e., landforms and associated vegetation communities) evolution trajectories within the fluvial corridor and to the evaluation of their consequences for ecological and geomorphic forms and processes.
xii
Raymundo E. Russo
First, fundamental aspects linked to the conceptual model of Fluvial Biogeomorphic Succession (FBS model) proposed by the authors (cf. Corenblit et al. 2007) are presented. This model describes the most dominant biogeomorphic succession trajectory of temperate rivers under current bioclimatic and anthropogenic conditions, starting from the rejuvenated state (bare sediment within the channel after a destructive flood). This dynamic model involves a characteristic sequence of four biogeomorphic phases where interactions of hydrogeomorphic processes and vegetation dynamics are either strong or weak according to different spatiotemporal configurations. The characteristic evolutionary trajectory corresponds to a progressive shift from the dominance of allogenic (hydrogeomorphic) processes to the dominance of autogenic (ecological) processes. It is marked by a development of specific stabilised vegetated landforms such as banks, islands and floodplains. In particular, the cyclic dynamics of the biogeomorphic succession (i.e., frequency and magnitude of rejuvenation and maturation processes), incorporating critical thresholds are discussed. Second, a conceptual tool for the description and analysis of potential fluvial landscape evolutionary trajectories is proposed. This conceptual tool is a discrete three dimensional biogeomorphic phase-space composed of five key-stages of vegetation development (bare sediment; seedlings and saplings; adult herbs; adult shrubs; adult trees) within four distinct zones of the river corridor, exposed to four distinct levels of hydrogeomorphic disturbance (permanent submerged area; high flood-frequency area; low flood-frequency floodplain; nonsubmersible area). The four main processes controlling shifts between biogeomorphic configurations within the phase-space are related to the critical role of pioneer vegetation within fluvial landscape dynamics. Finally, a methodological basis to test and to refine the model using a probabilistic transition analysis combining the biogeomorphic phase-space, empirical field data, GIS and remote sensing at local and regional scales is proposed and its applications for river management are discussed. Chapter 9 – This chapter describes the morphological variations of floating and rooted macrophytes growing in a wetland constructed for the treatment of industrial wastewater and in natural wetlands of the Middle Paraná River floodplain, Argentina. Cross-sectional areas (CSA) of the root, stele and of metaxylem vessels and the total metaxylem CSA were measured. In addition, parameters such as dry biomass, chlorophyll concentration, and metal (Cr, Ni and Zn) and nutrient (P) concentrations were compared. During the first months of operation of the constructed wetland, only sewage was poured and floating macrophytes were dominant. After five years of operation, Typha domingensis was the dominant species in the constructed wetland. In this species, biomass and height of the plants at the inlet and outlet were significantly higher than in the natural wetlands. The plants growing at the inlet showed root and stele CSA values significantly higher than those for the plants growing at the outlet and in natural wetlands. The total metaxylem vessels CSA of the inlet plants were significantly higher than those obtained in the outlet and natural wetlands owing to the plants of this site showed the highest number of metaxylem vessels. In order to determine the morphological changes as an adaptive response to the contaminants present in the effluent, greenhouse experiments were carried out with P. stratiotes and E. crassipes. In P. stratiotes, Ni and Cr+Ni+Zn treatments were the most toxic ones, in which biomass, chlorophyll and the internal morphological parameters of roots decreased significantly, while in E. crassipes Ni caused toxic effects in the internal as well as the external morphology. The modifications
Preface
xiii
recorded account for the adaptability of T. domingensis to the conditions prevailing in the constructed wetland, which allowed it to become the dominant species. This chapter may contribute to the design and mainteinance of constructed wetlands that include the macrophytes studied. Chapter 10 - The growth of industries and major agricultural enterprises (especially food industries) supplying the human demands for their increasing population causes an annihilation of water ecosystems and an augmentation of water pollutions. These are the main sources of nutrient supplements in water resources. Excess nutrients led to the eutrophication phenomena and in many cases the deterioration of public health. While the role of carbon dioxide (CO2) gas in global climate change has become well-known, which is one of the most important environmental issues of our day, therefore it is necessary to develop technologies for the minimization of CO2 discharging into the atmosphere. Although CO2 occurs naturally in the atmosphere, its current atmospheric concentrations have been greatly affected by human activities. One ecological method used for treating polluted water containing high nutrients and encouraging CO2 sequestration is treatment wetlands, where various aquatic plants are used for purifying the water and wastewater from excess nutrients and also withdrawing the anthropogenic CO2 from polluted atmosphere into plant’s biomass by photosynthesis process. Although wetland area around the world has diminished and continues to lose due to economic development, agriculture, and other landscape alterations, recently many of these losses are compensated by construction of new wetlands due to an our increasing understanding of wetland functions and values on global environment. Chapter 11 - Although abiotic forces play a fundamental role in community and process regulation of disturbed wetland ecosystems, biotic interaction is increasingly recognised for having important regulatory feedback effects. This chapter reports on the context-specific role of biotic and abiotic regulation of phytoplankton biomass in temporary ponds. Contamination of artificial ponds with different application concentrations of a fire retardant resulted in alterations of the trophic status, primary producer and zooplankton communities in treatment ponds. Principal component analyses suggested that facilitation of phytoplankton biomass through cladocerans was the most important controlling factor in nutrient-limited control ponds. These biotic interaction effects disappeared in retardant treatment ponds where phytoplankton biomass was almost exclusively controlled by water depth fluctuation. This context-specific, eutrophication-mediated physical control of algal biomass in treatment ponds adds a new dimension to the traditional perspective of resource and consumer control of phytoplankton in alternative ecosystem states in lakes. The context-dependent interplay of physical and biotic processes in wetlands will likely influence applied issues and challenge wetland management and restoration. Chapter 12 - Urbanisation and recreational activities are two of the major causes of population declines of species, and throughout the world they continue to spread and intensify at a rapid rate. The two are often linked—an increase in recreational activities is often associated with nearby growth in residential development and vice versa. Developmental growth is greatest in places of high tourism value, such as in coastal areas with sandy shores. Sandy coasts are popular with beach walking and jogging, swimming, off-road vehicles, boating, ecotourism, and other outdoor activities. The most concentrated activities are in estuaries with sandbanks and intertidal flats that are protected from the open ocean. Yet the same estuaries are often sensitive ecosystems, commonly frequented by a variety of resident
xiv
Raymundo E. Russo
and migrant birds that use the areas to breed, forage, or roost. Increasing incidents of human disturbance can affect breeding behavior, feeding patterns, opportunities for rest, and decline in estuarine bird abundance. The direct impact on reproduction in breeding birds is obvious, but survival of migratory species is also affected through ineffective build-up of requisite fat reserves to successfully undertake their migratory journey. For both resident and migrant birds, disturbance could result in reduced feeding time, lowering the necessary fat reserves for survival. Chapter 13 - Increased agricultural production, land drainage and resultant land use changes have increased loads of non-point source pollutants being discharged into aquatic ecosystems. Estimates suggest that non-point source pollution (NPS) contributes over 65% of the total pollution load to inland surface waters, including 332,000 km of rivers, 215,000 ha of lakes and 1.5 x 106 ha of estuaries. There are two types of agricultural wetlands that could mitigate NPS pollution: constructed wetlands and surface drainage ditches. Constructed wetlands are commonly used to mitigate increased nutrient, biological oxygen demand, and pesticide loads prior to entering receiving waters. However, some farmers will forgo the practice of constructing a wetland for routing water because of associated costs of construction, maintenance and loss of land in agricultural production. Agricultural drainage ditches are management tools put in place by farmers to rapidly remove standing water from their farmland. Drainage ditch function is simply one of drainage; however, research has shown that surface vegetated drainage ditches are primary intercept wetlands characterized by an ephemerally inundated hydroperiod, developed hydro-soils and a suite of facultative hydrophytes. Studies in the mid-South US have shown vegetated surface drainage ditches to reduce both pesticide and nutrients loads within the ditch prior to effluent reaching receiving waters. This is increasingly important in today’s landscape where fertilizer and pesticide applications are still high. Pollutant reduction capacity within ditches may be improved with temporal and spatial manipulation of water residence at critical junctions of non-point pollutant loss throughout the year. Primary interception, transformation and mitigation of agricultural pollutants has far reaching consequences for aquatic ecosystem health, downstream eutrophication, and coastal dynamics such as hypoxia, commercial fisheries and economic development. Chapter 14 - Over 3 million wetlands populate the U.S. portion of the Prairie Pothole Region (PPR), where conservation goals include restoration and preservation of the cover cycle. The cover cycle is characterized by seasonal and annual changes in vegetation and open water and is closely coupled to climate and natural ecosystem functions. A complete cover cycle include periods of time when high waters drown hydric vegetation during deluge and periods where hydric vegetation expands as waters dry-down during drought. Changes in wetland cover may occur on weekly, monthly, or annual time-scales. These dynamics contribute to a rich diversity of habitats that support more waterfowl than any other region in North America. In addition temporal dynamics, PPR wetlands rarely function as single entities because of shared surface and/or groundwater hydrology. This spatial interdependence requires PPR wetland functional assessments represent populations of wetlands, commonly referred to as “profiles.” Synoptic data profiling cover cycle stage and return time for populations of wetlands would scaffold large-scale investigations of ecosystems services, habitat status, and sensitivity to climate change. This chapter describes application of previously developed tools for synoptic delineation of wetland water and hydric vegetation cover to classify cover cycle for thousands of wetland
Preface
xv
basins within a single satellite image (10,000-30,000 km2 of land area). Using satellite data layers in geographic information systems (GIS), wetland profiles developed using current (2007) wetland cover data are compared with profiles developed using National Wetland Inventory (NWI) data from 1980. Results underscore the dynamic nature of these ecosystems and the need for current observations when setting conservation goals, monitoring restoration effectiveness, and evaluating anthropogenic impacts.
In: Wetlands: Ecology, Conservation and Restoration ISBN: 978-1-60456-995-7 Editor: Raymundo E. Russo © 2008 Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
Expert Commentary
TWO ALTERNATIVE MODES FOR DIFFUSE POLLUTION CONTROL BY WETLANDS Chen Qingfeng∗1, Shan Baoqing2 and Ma Junjian1 1
Shandong Analysis and Test Center, Jinan, 250014, China Research Center for Eco-Environmental Sciences, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, 100085, China
2
Diffuse pollution has been identified as an important cause of surface water quality degradation (Novotny, 1999). Some researches indicate that it is responsible for the transport of sediment, nutrients, heavy metals, oils, hydrocarbons and pesticides (Deletic, 1998; Schreiber et al., 2001; Lazzarotto et al., 2005). Furthermore, stormwater pollution can also have a profound effect on the ecological health of streams and reservoirs and is one of the main reasons for ecosystem degradation (Yin and Mao, 2002). There are many ecological engineering techniques, such as buffer zones, ponds, wetlands and riparian zones currently in use, and wetlands have been shown to be effective in removing pollutants from runoff water (Mitsch et al., 2002). In order to improve treatment efficiency, wetlands can be used as treatment trains. According to the flow route, the control chains can be designed in on-line and off-line treatment trains (Bardin et al., 2001; Michael and John, 2003; Shan et al., 2006; Paolo et al., 2006; Chen et al., 2007). For the on-line treatment train, all of the runoff from a storm routes through all the system structures, which are distributed on the runoff route. The treatment train may have lower pollutant removal efficiency than off-line treatment train if the system storage is not large enough to hold all the runoff from a significant storm event. For the off-line treatment train, the system structures are distributed away from the runoff route. The treatment train is designed to intercept the “first flush”, which has much higher concentration of pollutants in the initial runoff. The later runoff, with lower concentration of pollutants, overflows the catchment directly. The off-line treatment train requires less land area and it is an economical and effective measure for the control of runoff pollution in urban areas. Every mode plays an important role in stabilizing the adjacent ecosystems and reducing the load of runoff pollution.
∗
Email:
[email protected]
2
Chen Qingfeng, Shan Baoqing and Ma Junjian
In the process of diffuse pollution control, the selection of the mode is the key step. The selection of the two alternative modes for diffuse pollution control is based on concern with native topography, climate, storm water volume and available land area of the catchment (Figure 1).
Figure 1. The flow chart of the two alternative modes selection for diffuse pollution control.
If there is enough available land area in the catchment, then both modes can be selected. Otherwise, the offline mode may be the only choice for diffuse pollution control. Furthermore, the online mode may be the better choice if reuse of rainwater, additional biologic habitat, and aesthetics value are taken into consideration. In other conditions, the offline mode may be an effective choice for diffuse pollution control. In every mode, many ecological engineering techniques can be included. However, the application of the two modes in urban zoos has received little research attention. A detailed study was carried out from April 2003 to August 2005 in Wuhan City Zoo, which is surrounded by Moshui Lake. In this study, two catchments were selected to study the characteristics and performances of the online and offline modes in Wuhan City Zoo. For this purpose, an online pond-wetlands system in the Orangutan House Catchment, and an offline filtering ditch-pond system in the Canine House Catchment, were designed to control the small point and diffuse sources of pollution in the urban zoo. In the Orangutan House Catchment, an online pond wetlands system was used to control pollution from small point and diffuse sources. All the engineering constructions were built to adjust the flow rate of storm water and the kinetic energy of runoff on the runoff route. From upland to downstream, the landscape structures included upland grassland, orangutan house, sediment tank (ST), pond (P), the first wetland (W1) and the second wetland (W2). For the huge storage capacity of the pond-wetlands system (1071m3), most of runoff was able to be stored temporarily and purified by physical, chemical and biologic processes in the wetlands.
Two Alternative Modes for Diffuse Pollution Control by Wetlands
3
The online mode flow of the catchment is shown in Figure 2. Through grids, S2 was initially stored in ST on dry days. During rainfall events, all runoff, coming from S1 and S3, as well as S2, flowed through ST, P, W1 and W2 sequentially and then drained into Moshui Lake. In order to save water, the rainwater, stored in the pond-wetlands system, can be reused for flushing the animal house and irrigating the grassland.
Figure 2. Online mode for diffuse pollution control in the Orangutan House Catchment.
Without enough available land area for water treatment constructions, an offline filtering ditch-pond system was designed to control diffuse pollution in the Canine House Catchment. The off-line treatment train was composed of some pretreatment equipments and a filtering ditch–pond system. The pretreatment equipments include a transport ditch, grids and a sediment tank. The filtering ditch–pond system consists of a filtering ditch and two ponds. This system has a storage capacity of 115m3 and can store the initial 13.7mm runoff depths in a storm. Four species of hydrophytes, including Phragmites communis Trirn., Acorus calamus Linn., Alternanthera philoxeroides and Canna generalis, were planted in the ponds. The landscape structures in the catchment include upland grassland, storm transport ditch (T), Canine House, filtering ditch (FD) and ponds (P) from upland to downstream. FD was underground and rebuilt by an old flue, is 83 m in length, 0.5 m in width, and 1.2 min depth. It has three sections: sediment zone, filtration zone and storage zone. There are 9 subsections in the filtration zone and each subsection is filled with one of the following media: gravel, aluminite stone, bulky sand, cobblestone, ceramic granule, silver sand, turf, steel slag and vermiculite. All the ecological engineering constructions were finished in April 2004. According to the pollution characteristics, topography, available land area and climate in the catchment, the off-line treatment train was designed to separate the ‘first flush’ from the runoff. The sketch map of the off-line treatment train is shown in Figure 3. Because the main type of land use is upland (61.4%) in the catchment, the off-line treatment train works in a natural process and requires no power. Through the grids, wastewater from flushing the animal houses (S2) was initially stored in the sediment tank (ST) and overflowed to filtering ditch–pond system for decontamination on dry days. During rainy days, the initial runoff, coming from upland runoff (S1) and roof runoff (S3), as well as wastewater (S2), was diverted to the filtering ditch (FD) for filtration and adsorption. After that, the runoff water overflowed into ponds for further decontamination
4
Chen Qingfeng, Shan Baoqing and Ma Junjian
and then, in the final stage, drained into Lake Moshui. The later runoff, with lower concentration of pollutants, was discharged into the lake directly.
Figure 3. Offline mode for diffuse pollution control in Canine House Catchment.
The results showed that the two modes both improved runoff water quality and had high retention rates for water and pollutants. In the outflows, the event mean concentrations (EMCs) of total suspended solids (TSS), chemical oxygen demand (COD), total nitrogen (TN) and total phosphorus (TP) were reduced by 88%, 59%, 46% and 71% for the online mode, and those were 75%, 50%, 50% and 74% for the offline mode. The annual retention rates of pollutant loads for the online mode were 94.9%–98.5% in the three study years; those for the offline mode were 70.5%–86.4%. Based on calculation, the online mode was able to store the runoff of 66.7 mm rainfall completely, and the offline mode could store that of 31.3 mm rainfall. In addition, the online mode can provide an effective way for rainwater utilization and good habitats for aquatic wildlives, and has an excellent aesthetics value for recreationsal pastimes. The offline mode can save land resources and may be an effective and economical measure for diffuse pollution control in urban areas.
REFERENCES Bardin, JP, Barraud, S, Chocat, B, 2001. Uncertainty in measuring the event pollutant removal performance of on-line detention tanks with permanent outflow. Urban Water 3, 91–106. Chen QF, Shan BQ, Yin CQ, Hu CX. An off-line Filtering Ditch-pond system for Diffuse Pollution Control at Wuhan City Zoo. Ecological Engineering, 2007, 30(4):373-380. Chen QF, Shan BQ, Yin CQ, Hu CX. Two Alternative Modes of Diffuse Pollution Control in an Urban Tourist Area. Journal of Environment Science, 2007, 19(10):1067-1073. Deletic, A, 1998. The first flush load of urban surface runoff. Water Res. 32 (8), 2462–2470. Lazzarotto, P, Prasuhn, V, Butscher, E., Crespi, C., Flu¨ hler, H., Stamm, C., 2005. Phosphorus export dynamics from two Swiss grassland catchments. J. Hydrol. 304, 139– 150. Michael Jr., John, H., 2003. Nutrients in salmon hatchery wastewater and its removal through the use of a wetland constructed to treat off-line setting pond effluent. Aquaculture 226, 213–225. Mitsch, WJ, Lefeuvre, JC, Bouchard, VB, 2002. Ecological engineering—applied to river and wetland restoration. Ecol. Eng. 10, 119–130. Novotny, V, 1999. Integrating diffuse pollution control and water body restoration into watershed management. J. Am. Water Resour. Assoc. 35 (4), 717–727.
Two Alternative Modes for Diffuse Pollution Control by Wetlands
5
Paolo, SC, Gaspare, V, 2006. Simulation of the operation of detention tanks. Water Res. 40 (1), 83–90. Schreiber, J.D., Rebich, R.A., Cooper, C.M., 2001. Dynamics of diffuse pollution from US southern catchements. Wat. Res. 35(10), 2534–2542. Shan BQ, Chen QF, Yin CQ, 2006. On-line control of stormwater pollution by pond-wetlands composite system in urban tourist area[J]. Acta Scientiae Circumstantiae, 26(7): 1068– 1075 (in Chinese). Yin, CQ, Mao, ZP, 2002. Nonpoint pollution control for rural areas of China with ecological engineering technologies. Chin. J. Appl. Ecol. 13 (2), 229–232 (in Chinese).
In: Wetlands: Ecology, Conservation and Restoration ISBN: 978-1-60456-995-7 Editor: Raymundo E. Russo © 2008 Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
Short Communication
MULTIANGULAR IMAGING OF WETLANDS IN NEW ENGLAND Lesley-Ann L. Dupigny-Giroux∗ and Eden Furtak-Cole University of Vermont, Department of Geography 200 Old Mill Building, Burlington, VT 05405-0114, 802-656-2156
ABSTRACT Multiple view angles (MVA) or multiangular imaging represents a yet to be explored use of the remote sensing of wetlands. The ability to view the landscape off-nadir (traditionally the surface is viewed at right angles) allows for the quantification of moisture stress, species separation and the proportion of vegetation to standing water in these ecosystems. This commentary will focus on the ratio of two broadband wavelengths (near-infrared to blue) derived from multiangular images acquired by the Airborne Multiangle Imaging SpectroRadiometer (AirMISR) of wetlands across New England. The resulting insights into the photointerpretation, monitoring and mapping of wetlands will be highlighted.
1. INTRODUCTION Multiple view angles (MVA) or multiangular imaging of terrestrial ecosystems has been shown to provide multispectral data not observed from the nadir or other single view angles only, due to the highly anisotropic reflectance of vegetation (Asner et al., 1998). Vegetation parameters may not be the most sensitive to the nadir view angle (Privette, 1995). Other studies have explored the relationship between a sensor’s field of view and vegetation structure (Widlowski et al., 2004; see Diner et al., 2005 for a full description of these studies), land cover classifications (Hyman and Barnsley, 1997) and the role of sub-pixel heterogeneity (Zhang et al. (2002a, b), as well as view angle and reflectance anisostropy at the red wavelengths (Pinty et al., 2002). ∗
E-mail:
[email protected]
8
Lesley-Ann L. Dupigny-Giroux and Eden Furtak-Cole
In a recent study (Dupigny-Giroux, 2007), multiangular images from the Airborne Multiangle Imaging SpectroRadiometer (AirMISR) of the Howland Forest in Maine, were used for land use/land cover (LULC) separability under varying moisture conditions in the humid, continental environment of central Maine. The study extended original work by DupignyGiroux and Lewis (1999) that used the ratio of near-infrared/blue wavelengths plotted against surface temperatures to describe vegetation and moisture stress for the semiarid Brazilian nordeste (northeast). This study complements work by Silva Xavier and Soares Galvão (2005) who used Principal Components Analysis of Multi-angle Imaging SpectroRadiometer (MISR) data from the Amazon to discriminate land cover types. Results of the Dupigny-Giroux (2007) indicated that the NIR/blue ratio at multiple view angles was able to discriminate variations among wetland, aquatic vegetation and the extent of moisture stress. Contributions of the study included an expansion of the recommended combination of the 15-30˚ solar illumination angle and nadir viewing angle for optimally recording benthic features (Dobson et al., 1995); a sensitivity of the NIR/blue ratio to species type and vigour, water/vegetation proportions and moisture gradients across emergent wetlands; and the distinction between aquatic macrophytes and terrestrial vegetation that are often similar individual wavelengths (Valta-Hulkkonen et al., 2003). The study suggested potential uses of the multi-angular ratio including improved mapping of wetlands in humid temperate regions (Bicheron et al., 1997; Barnsley et al., 1997); the avoidance of false change detection due to drought or water draw down (U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 2004) and; the improved photointerpretation of evergreen forested wetlands and more xeric ecosystems (Tiner, 2003). In this commentary, the methodology of the Dupigny-Giroux (2007) study was applied to wetlands at two other experimental forests in New England to explore the applicability of the technique across disparate wetland types and microclimates.
2. DATA AND METHODOLOGY 2.1. AirMISR Program TheAirMISR instrument is a pushbroom imager that is mounted on the NASA ER-2 aircraft flying at an altitude of 20km over selected temperate and tropical study areas. It used a single camera on a pivoting gimbal mount to collect data at the nine viewing angles used on the spaceborne MISR instrument. These angles are nadir (An), 26.1˚ fore (Af) and aft (Aa), 45.6˚ fore (Bf) and aft (Ba), 60.0˚ fore (Cf) and aft (Ca) and 70.5˚ fore (Df) and aft (Da). The swath width of the imagery varied from 11km at nadir to 32km for the D cameras. Four spectral bands were centered at 446nm, 558nm, 672nm and 867nm (blue, green, red and nearinfrared) (Diner et al., 1998). The data used in this commentary were collected over three experimental forests in New England in August 2003 (Figure 1). The Bartlett Experimental Forest in north-central New Hampshire and the Harvard Forest in western Maine were both flown on 24 August, with data acquisition over Howland Forest in central Maine on 28 August. All three sites are well instrumented with standard meteorological equipment, biomass and carbon sequestration
Multiangular Imaging of Wetlands in New England
9
measurements to support long term experiments including NASA’s Forest Ecosystem Dynamics Project.
Howland Forest Bartlett Forest Harvard Forest
Figure 1. Locations of the three experimental forests in New England.
Only the data from the north-south runs and A-C cameras over each site were used due to data inhomogeneities. Georectified radiance product (L1B2) data were resampled to a 27.5m grid in the UTM (Universal Transverse Mercator) projection and available online from the Langely Distributed Active Archive Center (DAAC). Actual radiances were computed using the AirMISR tool. An IR minimum check was performed for each viewing angle. Ancillary digital data were acquired from the National Wetlands Inventory, Maine GIS, New Hampshire GIS and Massachusetts GIS.
2.2. Wetlands of the Study Sites The wetlands observed at the three study sites varied by extent, species composition, tidal regimes and permanence of water. The Howland Forest site decreases in elevation from over 120m in the north to about 19m in the south, with palustrine, estuarine, evergreen as well as broad-leaf deciduous and persistent emergent wetlands. To the west, the Bartlett Experimental Forest site located in the White Mountains National Forest ranges in elevation from 59m to 1868 m, an upland area characterized by broadleaf deciduous forests with predominantly palustrine forested broad-leaf deciduous and needle-leaf evergreen wetlands. The Harvard Forest site was lower in elevation (9-548m) and characterized by both palustrine evergreen and freshwater forested shrub wetlands.
10
Lesley-Ann L. Dupigny-Giroux and Eden Furtak-Cole
3. RESULTS AND APPLICABILITY OF MVA TO WETLAND STUDIES The relationship between wetlands and view angles can be analyzed by scatterplots (not shown) of camera pairs on which the 45˚ and best fit lines have been plotted. For the three experimental forests, there was a high degree of correlation between the high camera view angles (An, Af, Aa and Bf). The straight line relationship denotes a moisture gradient from mesic regions (low ratios) to xeric ones (high ones). The relationship is most extensive (with points at both ends of the 1:1 line) for the palustrine, estuarine wetlands of the Howland forest and less so for the other two regions. Differences in species composition and tidal flow regimes were marked across the three forests, influencing the view angles that were most useful for wetland discrimination. For example, at the Howland Forest wetlands, the scatterplot of the Af and Bf forward viewing angles (R2=0.904) was particularly well suited to highlighting moisture stress across forested wetlands, stress that was not observable at nadir (Dupigny-Giroux, 2007). This may be due to the fact that these seasonally flooded wetlands tend to be wetter for shorter durations during the growing season (Tiner, 2003). At the Harvard Forest, both the scatterplots of the high forward view angles (Af and Bf) as well as the nadir (An) and Af pair had the most significant best fit lines (R2 values of 0.946 and 0.957 respectively). The An-Af pairing was marginally better in that it deviated less from the 1:1 line than the Af-Bf pairing. For the Bartlett Forest wetlands, the regression statistics for camera pairs were quite low (R2 <0.3) due to the presence of several outliers which will be discussed shortly. Figure 2 summarizes various wetland characteristics across view zenith angles at the three study sites. Bowl-shaped and bell-shaped reflectance anisotropy have been observed in other studies of forested areas (e.g. Pinty et al., 2002; Nolin, 2004; Asner, 2000; Goodin et al., 2004). Largest NIR/blue ratios and the most pronounced bowl-shaped anisotropy was observed for stressed estuarine aquatic and emergent vegetation (MF) at Howland Forest related to severe moisture stress in this saltwater habitat, and marked vertical variations in emergent and surface vegetation across the wetland. Almost all of the wetlands sampled at the Harvard Forest site displayed bowl-shaped anisotropy (FR1), peaking at the An view zenith angle and decreasing at the aft view angles. This may be a function of the solar illuminationview angle geometry at these latitudes, as well as the fact that most of wetlands in this region were freshwater in nature. In contrast, the wetlands at the Bartlett and Howland Forests displayed darkspots or decreases in the NIR/blue ratio at one of the A cameras or the Bf one. At Howland Forest, the Bf darkspot was observed for an upland needle-leaf forested wetland (U), while at Bartlett Forest, it corresponded to a lotic (riverside) upper perennial wetland with an unconsolidated bottom (HW). The dramatic Af darkspot at the Howland site was found in a region of aquatic/emergent vegetation (SA) where the herbaceous species resembled evergreen forests at the other view angles, but residual wetland characteristics showed up as strong NIR absorption at the Af view angle. At the Bartlett Forest, the Af darkspot corresponded to a forested broad-leaf deciduous wetland that was temporally flooded (BD). Larger overall NIR/blue ratios for the latter wetland at all view zenith angles allowed its distinction from the aquatic/emergent species observed at Howland Forest.
Multiangular Imaging of Wetlands in New England
11
2.5
MF
2
NIR/blue ratio
FR1 1.5
1
DA U HA
D1
FR2 HW
0.5
D2
WA
AW
BD SA
W 0 Cf
Bf
Af
An
Aa
Ba
Ca
CAMERA
Figure 2. Variations in NIR/blue ratio as a function of viewing angle for selected wetlands. At Howland Forest - water and persistent emergent wetlands (W); water-dominated intertidal emergent and subtidal aquatic vegetation (WA); drying estuarine subtidal aquatic bed (DA); acid, saturated needle-leaf forested wetland (AW); moisture stressed subtidal aquatic bed/intertidal emergent vegetation (MF); dead forested wetland (D1); transitional subtidal aquatic and intertidal emergent vegetation (SA); and upland needle-leaved evergreen forested wetland (U). At Bartlett Forest - high elevation wetlands with a westerly aspect (HW); upper perennial wetland with an unconsolidated bottom (HA); dead needle-leaf forested wetland (D2); and broad-leaf deciduous wetland (BD). At Harvard Forest - freshwater scrub/shrub wetland (PF01/SS1E) FR1 and freshwater scrub/shrub wetland (PF01/4E) FR2. [Wetland codes according to Cowardin et al., 1979].
Similarly, An darkspots observed at Bartlett and Howland Forests were attributable to different wetland types, with distinct NIR/blue ratios. At Howland Forest, the An darkspot corresponded to upland, lotic, water-dominated subtidal and intertidal wetlands (WA), where the former displayed more vegetation on or below the water surface than the latter. The An darkspot at Bartlett Forest was observed for both a forested, needle-leaf evergreen wetland that was dead (D2), as well as for a scrub-shrub, broad-leaf evergreen wetland that was acidic. NIR/blue ratios were larger for the dead, forested wetland than for the acidic one, and were on the order of those observed for the subtidal wetlands at Howland Forest. Finally, the Aa darkspot observed for the freshwater forested/shrub wetland at Harvard Forest (FR2) was twice the magnitude of that observed for an anomalous acidic, saturated needle-leaved evergreen emergent wetland at Howland Forest (AW). Two other important across-view angle observations deal with water bodies and the role of topography. Deep “pure” water bodies (W) displayed low, almost constant ratios at all angles, with largest values at the Bf and Cf view angles. High elevation wetlands with a westerly aspect (HW) were characterized by low NIR/blue ratios at the forward view angles, a peak at the Aa view angle and decreasing at the other aft angles. Two important underlying factors that explain the differences in wetlands across New England were the antecedent moisture conditions and species composition. Precipitation deficits across lowland regions in northern New England (Howland Forest), were neither observed at high elevations of similar latitudes (Bartlett Forest) nor in southern New England (Harvard Forest). Tables 1 and 2 highlight the above normal precipitation received near Bartlett and Harvard Forests that was in stark contrast to the long term dryness that
12
Lesley-Ann L. Dupigny-Giroux and Eden Furtak-Cole
characterized the Howland Forest (Dupigny-Giroux, 2007). The acceleration of phenology under drought conditions (Dupigny-Giroux, 2001) may have accounted for anomalously high near-infrared radiances observed in the most stressed estuarine wetlands in the Howland Forest. These dry intertidal emergent vegetation regions were characterized by a concentration of organic material near the surface of the water, and displayed the highest NIR/blue ratio of all wetlands sampled. Table 1. Statewide precipitation received in 2003. Rankings are given in parentheses with 1 being the driest year and 113 being the wettest in the 1895-2007 time frame. (Data courtesy National Climatic Data Center) STATE
AUGUST 2003
SUMMER 2003
SPRING 2003
Maine
92.7 mm (51)
255.8 (44)
224 mm (38)
New Hampshire
148.3 mm (107)
297.9 mm (66)
257.3 mm (53)
Massachusetts
140.5 mm (98)
346.7 mm (93)
321.3 mm (79)
Table 2. Monthly precipitation received at representative stations close to the study sites. Monthly normals (statistical averages) for the 1971-2000 are given in parentheses. (Data courtesy National Climatic Data Center) STATION
JULY 2003
AUGUST 2003
Bangor, Maine
22.6 mm (82.3 mm)
50 mm (75.56 mm)
North Conway, NH
79.5 mm (102.1 mm)
187.9 mm (105.4 mm)
Amherst, MA
68.3 mm (100.3 mm)
202.9 mm (104.1 mm)
CONCLUSION Multiple view angles (MVA) or multiangular imaging represents a yet to be explored use of the remote sensing of wetlands. The application of the NIR/blue ratio to wetlands at three experimental forests in New England revealed that the technique is independent of the vegetation physiology and more a function of the moisture conditions and species composition across the wetland types. Wetlands at the Howland Forest site were the most stressed, reflecting both the long-term and short term moisture deficits across the region. At the Harvard Forest, most of the wetland sampled were of similar vegetation density and health, displaying overlapping bowl-shaped anisotropy. Darkspots were observed at the A and B view angles at the Bartlett and Howland Forest sites, with differences in the magnitude of the NIR/blue allowing for distinction across wetlands of varying species composition, acidity, health and tidal regimes. Finally, the interplay among topographic aspect, solar illumination
Multiangular Imaging of Wetlands in New England
13
and view zenith angle produced low NIR/blue ratios at forward view angles and higher values at aft ones for some high elevation, westerly sites.
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS These data were obtained from the NASA Langley Research Center Atmospheric Sciences Data Center.
REFERENCES Asner, G.P., Braswell, B.H., Schmil, D.S. and Wessman, C.A. (1998) Ecological Research Needs from Multiangle Remote Sensing Data, Remote Sensing of Environment, 63(2):155-165. Asner, G.P. (2000). Contributions of Multi-view Angle Remote Sensing to Land-surface and Biogeochemical Research, Remote Sensing Reviews, 00, 1-26. Barnsley, M.J., Allison, D. and Lewis, P. (1997). On the information content of multiple view angle (MVA) images, International Journal of Remote Sensing, 18, 1937-1960. Bicheron, P., Leroy, M., Hautecouer, O., and Breon, F.M. (1997). Enhanced discrimination of boreal forest covers with directional reflectances from the airborne polarization and directionality of Earth reflectances (POLDER) instrument, Journal of Geophysical Research, 102(29), 517-528. Cowardin, L.M., Carter, V., Golet, F.C. and LaRoe, E.T. (1979). Classification of Wetlands and Deepwater Habitats of the United States, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Washington, DC, FWS/OBS-79-31. Diner, D.J., Barge, L.M., Bruegge, C.J., Chrien, T.G., Conel, J.E., Eastwood, M.L., Garcia, J.D., Hernandez, M.A., Kurzweil, C.G., Ledeboer, W.C., Pignatano, N.D., Sarture, C.M. and Smith, B.G. (1998). The Airborne Multi-angle Imaging SpectroRadiometer (AirMISR): Instrument Description and First Results, IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 36(4), 1339-1349. Diner, D.J., Braswell., B.H., Davies, R., Gobron, N., Hu, J., Jin, Y., Kahn, R.A., Knyazikhin, Y., Loeb, N., Muller, J.-P., Nolin, A.W., Pinty, B., Schaaf, C.B., Seiz, G. and Stroeve, J. (2005). The value of multiangle measurements for retrieving structurally and radiatively consistent properties of clouds, aerosols and surfaces, Remote Sensing of Environment, 97, 495-518. Dobson, J.E., Bright, E.A., Ferguson, R.L., Field, D.W., Wood, L.L., Haddad, K.D., Iredale III, H., Jensen, J.R., Klemas, V.V., Orth, R.J and Thomas, J.P. (1995). NOAA Coastal Change Analysis Program (C-CAP): Guidance for Regional Implementation, NOAA Technical Report NMFS 123, Department of Commerce. Dupigny-Giroux, L-A. and Lewis, J.E. (1999). A Moisture Index for Surface Characterization over a Semiarid Area, Photogrammetric Engineering and Remote Sensing, 65(8), 937945.
14
Lesley-Ann L. Dupigny-Giroux and Eden Furtak-Cole
Dupigny-Giroux, L-A. (2001). Towards characterizing and planning for drought in Vermont. Part I. A Climatological Perspective, Journal of the American Water Resources Association, 37( 3), 505-525. Dupigny-Giroux, L.-A. (2007). Using AirMISR to explore moisture-driven land use-land cover variations at the Howland Forest, Maine - A case study, Remote Sensing of Environment, 107, 376-384. Goodin, D.G., Gao, J. and Henebry, G.M (2004). The Effect of Solar Illumination Angle and Sensor View Angle on Observed Patterns of Spatial Structure of Tallgrass Prairie, IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 42(1) 154-165. Hyman, A.H. and Barnsley, M.J. (1997). On the potential land cover mapping from multipleview-angle (MVA) remotely-sensed images, International Journal of Remote Sensing, 18(11), 2471-2475. Nolin, A.W. (2004). Towards retrieval of forest cover density over snow from the Multi-angle Imaging SpectroRadiometer (MISR), Hydrological Processes, 18(18), 3623-3636. Pinty, B., Widlowski, J-L., Gobron, N., Verstraete, M.M., Diner, D.J. (2002). Uniqueness of Multiangular Measurement - Part I: An Indicator of Subpixel Surface Heterogeneity from MISR, IEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 40(7),1561-1573. Privette, J.L. (1995). Uses of a Bidirectional Reflectance Model with Satellite Remote Sensing Data, Elements of Change 1995, Session I, AGCI. Tiner, R.W. (2003). Correlating Enhanced National Wetlands Inventory Data with Wetland Functions for Watershed Assessments: A Rationale for Northeastern U.S. Wetlands, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, National Wetlands Inventory Program, Region 5, Hadley, MA. 26pp. U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service (2004). Technical Procedures for Wetlands Status and Trends, Operational Version, Arlington, VA. Valta-Hulkkonen, K., Pellikka, P., Tanskanen, H., Ustinov, A. and Sandman, O. (2003). Digital false colour aerial photographs for discrimination of aquatic macrophyte species, Aquatic Botany, 75, 71-88. Widlowski, J.-L., Pinty, B., Gobron, N., Verstraete, M.M., Diner, D.J. and Davis, A.B. (2004). Canopy structure parameters derived from multi-angular remote sensing data for terrestrial carbon studies, Climate Change, 67, 403-415. Zhang, Y., Tian, Y., Myneni, R.B., Knyazikhin, Y. and Woodcock, C.E. (2002a). Assessing the information content of multiangle satellite data for mapping biomes. I. Statistical analysis, Remote Sensing of Environment, 80, 418-434. Zhang, Y., Shabanov, N., Knyazikhin, Y. and Myneni, R.B., (2002b). Assessing the information content of multiangle satellite data for mapping biomes. II. Theory, Remote Sensing of Environment, 80, 435-446.
In: Wetlands: Ecology, Conservation and Restoration ISBN: 978-1-60456-995-7 Editor: Raymundo E. Russo © 2008 Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
Chapter 1
WETLANDS: WATER “LIVING FILTERS”? Ana Dordio1∗, A. J. Palace Carvalho1,2 and Ana Paula Pinto1,3 1
2
Department of Chemistry, University of Évora, Évora, Portugal Centro de Química de Évora, University of Évora, Évora, Portugal 3 ICAM – Instituto de Ciências Agrárias e Mediterrâneas, University of Évora, Évora, Portugal
ABSTRACT Human societies have indirectly used natural wetlands as wastewater discharge sites for many centuries. Observations of the wastewater depuration capacity of natural wetlands have led to a greater understanding of the potential of these ecosystems for pollutant assimilation and have stimulated the development of artificial wetlands systems for treatment of wastewaters from a variety of sources. Constructed wetlands, in contrast to natural wetlands, are human-made systems that are designed, built and operated to emulate wetlands or functions of natural wetlands for human desires or needs. Constructed wetlands have recently received considerable attention as low cost, efficient means to clean-up not only municipal wastewaters but also point and non-point wastewaters, such as acid mine drainage, agricultural effluents, landfill leachates, petrochemicals, as well as industrial effluents. Currently, untreated wastewater discharge in the natural wetlands sites is becoming an increasingly abandoned practice whereas the use of constructed wetlands for treatment of wastewater is an emerging technology worldwide. However, natural wetlands still play an important role in the improvement of water quality as they act as buffer zones surrounding water bodies and as a polishing stage for the effluents from conventional municipal wastewater treatment plants, before they reach the receiving water streams. In fact, one of the emerging issues in environmental science has been the inefficiency of wastewater treatment plants to remove several xenobiotic organic compounds such as pesticides and pharmaceutical residues and consequent contamination of the receiving water bodies. Recent studies have shown that wetlands systems were able to efficiently remove many of these compounds, thus reaffirming the importance of the role which can be played by wetlands in water quality preservation.
∗
Corresponding author: Tel: +351 - 266 745343; E-mail address:
[email protected]
16
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto The aim of this work is to present a review on the application of wetlands as “living filters” for water purification. Emphasis was focused on the removal of micropollutants, especially xenobiotic organic compounds such as pharmaceuticals residues, which are not efficiently removed by conventional municipal wastewater treatment plants. Furthermore, the role of wetlands as protection zones which contribute to the improvement of the aquatic ecosystems’ quality will be discussed.
1. INTRODUCTION Wetlands have been recognized throughout human history to be a valuable natural resource. Their importance has been appreciated in managed forms, for example rice paddies, particularly in South East Asia, but also in their natural state by such people as the Marsh Arabs around the confluence of the rivers Tigris and Euphrates in southern Iraq (Mitsch and Gosselink J.G., 2000). Benefits provided by wetlands include water supply and control, mining, use of plants, wild-life, integrated systems and aquaculture, erosion control, education and training, recreation and reclamation (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; Cooper et al., 1996; Vymazal et al., 1998a; USEPA, 2000; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001). The water purification capability of wetlands, in particular, has for long been recognized. Natural wetlands usually improve the quality of water passing through them, acting as “living filters” and serving as transitional zones or “ecotones” between terrestrial and aquatic systems (Mitsch and Gosselink J.G., 2000; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001). They provide several physical, chemical, and biological processes which allow for the depuration of pollutants resulting from point and non-points source, thereby contributing for an improvement of water quality. In many regions, natural wetlands have been used, for centuries, as convenient wastewater discharge sites and sinks for a wide variety of anthropogenic pollutants including toxic organic compounds (Kadlec and Knight, 1996; Vymazal, 1998). Despite the many benefits offered by wetlands, some of these areas have also been for long regarded as wasted, useless land, unsuitable for agriculture, and subjected to drainage in order to make them available for cultivation. Since the early 20th century, wetland losses attributed to agriculture have been dramatic. Extensive wetland draining in the 1960s and 1970s led to increased available agricultural production acreage. However, in many places, in parallel with this practice, a decline has been observed in the water quality of the neighboring water bodies. An aggravated potential for damage to the aquatic systems, such as increased sedimentation or fish kills, is expected when rivers, streams, and lakes adjacent to the former wetland areas receive runoff following rainfall events. The functional role of wetlands in improving water quality has been, in recent years, a compelling argument for their preservation and study. The realization of the importance of wetlands, adjacent to other water bodies, has resulted in the fact that drainage of wetlands has ceased in many countries and that even previously drained wetlands are restored. The water treatment capabilities of wetlands are thus generally recognized but the extent of their treatment capacity is largely unassessed. However, studies have led to both a greater understanding of the potential of natural wetland ecosystems for pollutant assimilation and the design of new natural water treatment systems inspired in these natural systems. There remain, however, concerns over the possibility of harmful effects resulting from toxic
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
17
compounds and pathogens that may be present in many wastewater sources. Also, there are concerns that there may be a potential for long-term degradation of natural wetlands due to the addition of nutrients and changes in the natural hydrologic conditions influencing these systems. At least in part due to such concerns, there has been a growing interest in the use of constructed wetlands systems (CWS) for wastewater treatment. Significant advances have been made in the last years in the engineering knowledge of creating artificial wetlands that can closely imitate the treatment functions that occur in the natural wetland ecosystems. These CWS can be defined as man-made systems that have been designed and constructed to utilize the natural processes involving wetland vegetation, soils, and their associated microbial populations to assist in treating wastewater (Hammer and Bastian, 1989; Vymazal, 1998). They are designed to take advantage of many of the same processes that occur in natural wetlands, but do so within a more controlled environment. While some CWS have been designed and operated with the sole purpose of treating wastewater, others have been implemented with multiple-use objectives in mind, such as using treated wastewater effluent as a water source for the creation and restoration of wetland habitat for wildlife use and environmental enhancement. The construction of artificial wetlands for the treatment of wastewater has been developing fast over the last decades and it represents now a widely accepted and an increasingly common treatment alternative. The many advantages offered by CWS such as simplicity of design and lower costs of installation, operation, and maintenance make them an appropriate alternative for both developed and developing countries (USEPA and USDANRCS, 1995; Vymazal et al., 1998a; USEPA, 2000). In the following sections of this text the water purification functions of natural wetlands are presented in greater detail and, afterwards, the constructed wetland systems are described. Studies on the removal of several types of pollutants by these systems, as well as the more recent new trends on the use of CWS for pollutants removal are discussed.
2. NATURAL WETLANDS 2.1. Definition and Characterization Wetlands encompass a broad range of wet environments, ranging from submerged coastal grass beds to salt marshes, swamp forests and boggy meadows (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; Kadlec and Knight, 1996; Vymazal et al., 1998a; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001). A single precise definition and classification for wetlands that can correctly describe them in a comprehensive way for most purposes still has not been developed. In fact, a definition for wetlands has long been the subject of debate, due to the great variety of environments which are, either permanently or seasonally, influenced by water as well as to the specific requirements of the diverse groups of people involved in the study and management of these systems. Terms used in wetlands classification are many and are often confusing. Still, they are important for both the scientific understanding of these systems and for their proper management.
18
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
The Ramsar Convention, which in 1971 brought a worldwide attention to wetlands, took a broad approach in its definition in the text of the Convention (Article 1.1) (UNESCO, 1994): “Wetlands are areas of marsh, fen, peatland or water, whether natural or artificial, permanent or temporary, with water that is static or flowing, fresh, brackish or salt, including areas of marine water the depth of which at low tide does not exceed six metres”.
In addition, for the purpose of protecting coherent sites, the Article 2.1 stipulates in order to be included in the Ramsar List of internationally important wetlands, they may incorporate: “riparian and coastal zones adjacent to the wetlands, and islands or bodies of marine water deeper than six metres at low tide lying within the wetlands”.
Another definition of wetlands was proposed by the U.S. Fish and Wildfire Services, which also developed a classification system capable of encompassing and systematically organizing for scientific purposes all types of wetland habitats. According to such view, wetlands are described as the transition areas between terrestrial and aquatic systems, where water is the dominant factor determining soil characteristics and development of associated biological communities. The definition specifies that wetlands need, at least periodically, to fulfill one or more of the following four requirements (Hammer and Bastian, 1989; Cowardin and Golet, 1995; Brady and Weil, 2002): · · ·
·
areas where the water table is at or near the surface or where the land is covered by shallow water; areas supporting predominantly hydrophytes (water-tolerant plant species); areas with predominantly undrained hydric soils. Hydric soils are those that are sufficiently wet for long enough to produce anaerobic conditions, thereby limiting the types of plants that can grow on them; areas with non-soil substrate (such as rock or gravel) that are saturated or covered by shallow water at some time during the growing season of plants.
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service classification system (Cowardin and Golet, 1995) is much like the hierarchical system used by scientists to classify plants and animals, starting out with five large systems and progressively subdividing into a series of subsystems, classes and subclasses, which are then characterized by examples of dominant types of plants and animals. This system thus provides a consistent standard of terminology to be used among scientists and specialists. Various legislation and agency regulations define wetlands in more general terms. The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers jointly define wetlands as (Environmental Laboratory, 1987): “Those areas that are inundated or saturated by surface or ground water at a frequency and duration sufficient to support, and that under normal circumstances do support, a prevalence of vegetation typically adapted for life in saturated soil conditions. Wetlands generally include swamps, marshes, bogs, and similar areas”.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
19
One of the most recent definitions has been used by the U.S. National Research Council, which defines wetlands as (National Research Council, 1995; Vymazal et al., 1998a): “an ecosystem that depends on constant or recurrent, shallow inundation or saturation at or near the surface of the substrate”.
Notwithstanding which of the definitions one may use, three major factors are salient in the characterization of a wetland: water (hydrology), substrate (physico-chemical features) and biota (type of vegetation and microbial activity)(National Research Council, 1995). The characteristics of all these three components are interdependent and conditioned by each other. It is from the complex interactions among them that results the values and functions of wetlands.
2.2. Natural Wetlands as Natural Water “Living Filters”? Long regarded as wastelands, wetlands are now recognized as important features in the landscape that provide numerous beneficial functions for people and for fish and wildlife. These services, considered valuable to societies worldwide, are the result of the wetlands’ inherent and unique natural characteristics. Wetlands support a rich diversity of wildlife and fisheries by being stopping-off points and nesting areas for migratory birds and spawning grounds for fish and shellfish. Those wetlands along the coasts, riverbanks and lakeshores have a valuable role in stabilizing shorelands and protecting them from erosion. One of the greatest benefits of inland wetlands is the natural flood control or buffering provided for downstream areas by slowing the flow of floodwater, desynchronizing the peak contributions of tributary streams and reducing peak flows on main rivers (Hammer and Bastian, 1989; USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995). Some wetlands may function as discharge areas for groundwaters, allowing stored groundwater to sustain surface base flow in streams during dry periods (Hammer and Bastian, 1989). Additional benefits provided by these natural systems include mining (peat, sand, gravel), use of plants (staple food plants, grazing land, timber, paper production, roofing, agriculture, horticulture, fodder), integrated systems and aquaculture (e.g. fish cultivation combined with rice production), energy (hydroelectric, solar energy, heat pumps, gas, solid and liquid fuel) education and training, recreation and reclamation (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; Vymazal et al., 1998a). Perhaps one of the most important but least understood functions of wetlands is water quality improvement. These systems may well be considered “natural purifiers of water” as they provide an effective treatment for many kinds of water pollution (Hammer and Bastian, 1989; Kadlec and Knight, 1996). In fact, a capacity has already been recognized in wetlands to efficiently reduce or remove large amounts of pollutants from point sources (e.g. municipal and certain industrial effluents) as well as nonpoint sources (e.g. mining, agricultural and urban runoff) including organic matter, suspended solids, excess of nutrients, pathogens, metals and other micropollutants (Hammer and Bastian, 1989). This pollutants removal is accomplished by the interdependent action of several physical, chemical and biological processes which include sedimentation, filtration, chemical precipitation, sorption, biodegradation, plants uptake among others. The mechanisms and the
20
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
interdependences among the wetlands components (water, substrate and biota) are complex and not yet entirely understood, although some progresses have been achieved in the latest years as the awareness to the water depurative functions of wetlands becomes more widespread. The hydrology of the sites, the soil and the biota (vegetation and microorganisms) are reportedly the main factors influencing water quality in wetlands.
2.3. Factors Influencing Water Quality The hydrological cycle emerges with an underlying major role as it influences the type of vegetation, microbial activity and biogeochemical cycling of nutrients in soil. Indeed, the biotic status of a wetland is intrinsically linked to the hydrological factors, which affect the nutrient availability as well as physicochemical parameters such as soil and water pH and anaerobiosis within soils. In turn, biotic processes will have an impact upon the hydrological conditions of a wetland (Mitsch and Gosselink J.G., 2000; Kivaisi, 2001). Soil is one of the most important physical components of natural wetlands. Physical and chemical characteristics of the soil can greatly influence the type of wetland plants that will be prevalent over its surface and the microbial populations that will live on the soil phase. In addition, soil characteristics such as acid-base properties, redox potential and sorption capacity will also determine the type of physical-chemical processes occurring within the aqueous medium that can be responsible for the removal of certain types of pollutants, with a major impact in water quality. Macrophytes are the dominant vegetation in wetlands. These plant species are typically adapted to water saturated conditions and are able to persist in anaerobic soil conditions as a result of high water content. Compared with the vegetation of well-drained soils, wetland plants have a worldwide similarity which overrides climate and is imposed by the common characteristics of a free water supply and the abnormally hostile chemical environment which plant roots must endure. It is not surprising that plants regularly found in wetlands have evolved functional mechanisms to deal with the environmental stresses. Virtually all wetland plants have elaborate structural mechanisms to avoid root anoxia. Rhizosphere oxygenation is considered essential for active root function, and also enables the plants to counteract the effects of soluble phytotoxins, including sulfides and metals, which may be present at high concentrations in anoxic substrates. Microorganisms play a central role in the biogeochemical transformations of nutrients (Cooper et al., 1996; Vymazal et al., 1998b; Stottmeister et al., 2003; Vymazal, 2007), and the metabolism of organic compounds including even some xenobiotic compounds (Machate et al., 1997; Stottmeister et al., 2003). There is a close interdependence between microorganisms and vegetation. Much of the plants nutrients are the result of the mineralization of more complex compounds by the microorganisms, whereas the activity of the latter is stimulated by enzymes released in root exudates. The aerobic conditions provided by the plants in their rhizosphere will also be determinant for the type of microbial populations and bioprocesses available in this region. The conjugation of all these factors and interactions between different wetlands components and their associated processes lead to essentially different abilities to interact with water pollutants by different types of wetlands. An overview of the abilities by different
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
21
types of natural wetlands to cope with various non-point pollution problems along with a summary of each wetland type characteristics is presented in table 1. Table 1. Characteristics of different types of natural wetlands and their ability to retain non-point source pollutants (IETC-UNEP, 1999) Type of Wetland Wet meadows
Fresh water marshes Forested wetlands Salt water marshes Bogs Shoreline wetlands
Characteristics Grassland with waterlogged soil; standing water for part of the year Reed-grass dominated, often with peat accumulation Dominated by trees, shrubs; standing water, but not always for the entire year Herbaceous vegetation, usually with mineral soil A peat-accumulating wetland with minor flows Littoral vegetation of significant importance for lakes and reservoirs
Ability to retain non-point source pollutants Denitrification only in standing water; removal of nitrogen and phosphorus by harvest High potential for denitrification, which is limited by the hydraulic conductivity High potential for denitrification and accumulation of pollutants, provided that standing water is present Medium potential for denitrification; harvest possible High potential for denitrification but limited by small hydraulic conductivity High potential for denitrification and accumulation of pollutants, but limited coverage
In spite of the general abilities for water depuration that can be observed for typical wetland configurations, it is very difficult to predict responses to water pollution by natural wetlands and to translate their behavior from one geographical area to another due to the extreme variability of the functional components that characterizes them. Therefore, natural wetlands can not be viewed as a systematic approach to wastewater treatment. Only in a controlled environment provided by constructed wetlands, can such treatment work in a reliable and reproducible manner.
2.4. Natural Wetlands Preservation through the Construction of Artificial Wetlands Currently, in many countries, natural wetlands are protected areas, thus meaning that wastewater application is not permitted. Although studies have shown that natural wetlands are able to provide high levels of wastewater treatment (Hammer and Bastian, 1989), there is concern over possible harmful effects of toxic compounds and pathogens in wastewaters and a long term degradation of wetlands due to additional nutrient and hydraulic loadings from wastewater. These potential benefits and concerns have promoted a growing interest in the use of artificial wetlands for wastewater treatment (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995). While the application of wastewater to natural wetlands is becoming a deprecated practice worldwide, studies conducted on these systems have led to both a greater understanding of the processes involved in pollutant assimilation and removal as well as
22
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
suggesting the design of new natural water treatment systems where these water depuration capabilities would be imitated and improved (Vymazal et al., 1998a). Using the knowledge and the experience with the assimilative capacity of natural wetlands, the construction of man-made wetland systems (constructed wetlands) for wastewater treatment has therefore been proposed. The functional role of wetlands in improving water quality, thus, becomes a compelling argument for the preservation of natural wetlands and in recent years the construction of wetlands systems for wastewater treatment. Constructed wetlands can be built with a much greater degree of control, using a welldefined composition of substrate, type of vegetation, and flow pattern. In addition, constructed wetlands offer several additional advantages compared to natural wetlands including site selection, flexibility in sizing and, most importantly, control over the hydraulic pathways and retention time (Brix, 1993).
3. CONSTRUCTED WETLANDS SYSTEMS Recent concerns over wetlands losses have generated a need for creation of wetlands, which are intended to emulate the functions and values of natural wetlands that have been destroyed. Such CWS can be defined as a designed and man-made complex of saturated substrates, emergent and/or submergent vegetation, animal life, and water that simulates natural wetlands for human use and benefits (Hammer and Bastian, 1989). Artificial wetlands are engineered or constructed for one or more of the following purposes as indicated by specific descriptive terminology (Kadlec and Knight, 1996; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001): creation of wetland habitats to compensate for natural wetlands which have been converted for agriculture and urban development (or help offset their rate of conversion) and hence to conserve native flora and fauna including aquatic plants, fish, water birds, reptiles, amphibians and invertebrates (Constructed habitat wetlands) • • •
flood control facility (Constructed flood control wetland) production of food and fiber (Constructed aquaculture wetlands) and water quality improvement and wastewater treatment system (Constructed treatment wetlands).
Although CWS are being developed in many parts of the world for various functions, their wastewater treatment capabilities have attracted research efforts for a wide range of treatment applications including domestic wastewaters (Hammer and Bastian, 1989; Cooper et al., 1996; Vymazal et al., 1998a; Kivaisi, 2001; Cooper, 2001; Cameron et al., 2003; Hench et al., 2003; Solano et al., 2004), urban storm-water (Livingston, 1989; USEPA, 1993; Scholes et al., 1998; Carleton et al., 2001; Kohler et al., 2004), agricultural wastewaters (Carty et al., ; Hammer et al., 1989; Cronk, 1996; Knight et al., 2000), landfill leachates (Barr and Robinson, 1999; Nivala et al., 2007), acid mine drainage (Brodie et al., 1989; Ledin and Pedersen, 1996; Sobolewski, 1999) and for polishing advanced treated municipal wastewater for return to freshwater resources. CWS are also used for treating eutrophic lake waters (D'Angelo and Reddy, 1994; Coveney et al., 2002) and for conservation of nature (Hammer
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
23
and Bastian, 1989; Brix, 1993). For the specific use of wastewater treatment, the systems are also denominated constructed treatment wetland systems (CTWS) and can be defined as engineered systems that have been designed and constructed to utilize the natural processes involving wetland vegetation, soils and their associated microbial assemblages to assist in treating wastewater (Vymazal, 1998; Vymazal, 2005a). CTWS are designed to take advantage of many of the same processes that occur in natural wetlands, but do so within a more controlled environment. The first experiments aimed at the possibility of wastewater treatment by wetland vegetation were conducted in the 1950’s by Seidel at the Max Planck Institute in Plön, Germany (Seidel, 1955). During the following two decades, in the 1960’s and 1970’s, Seidel proceeded with numerous experiments on the use of wetland plants for treatment of various types of wastewater (Vymazal et al., 1998a). However, it was not before over 20 years of research that the first operational full-scale constructed wetland for municipal wastewater was built in Europe, in Othfresen, Germany (Vymazal et al., 1998a). Meanwhile, research efforts in the U.S. were developing during the 1970’s and 1980’s. Some systems were installed in the 1970’s with an increasing number in the 1980’s. The 1990’s saw a major increase in the number of these systems as the application expanded for use not only to treat municipal wastewater, but also urban stormwater, industrial, mining and agricultural wastewaters. CWS have since been constructed and used all around the world to treat a wide variety of types of wastewater. A list documenting the history of the first uses (both experimental and operational) of macrophytes and/or CWS for the treatment of different types of pollution up until the first half of the 1990’s was compiled and presented by Vymazal (1998a). The number of CWS in use has very much increased in the most recent years. The use of CWS in the United States, New Zealand and Australia is gaining rapid interest. Most of these systems are used for tertiary treatment from towns and cities, usually using surface-flow systems to remove low concentrations of nutrients (N and P) and suspend solids. Conversely, in European countries, these CWS are usually used to provide secondary treatment of domestic sewage for village populations. These constructed wetland systems have been seen as an economically attractive and energy-efficient way of providing high standards of wastewater treatment.
3.1. Advantages and Limitations of CWS Constructed wetlands systems offer effective and a reliable treatment to wastewater in a simple and inexpensive manner. Its application for wastewater treatment offers many advantages in comparison to more conventional wastewater treatment technologies (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; USEPA, 2000; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001; Haberl et al., 2003). Constructed wetlands: • • • • •
can often be less expensive to build than other treatment options; can be built and operated simply; utilize natural processes; their operation and maintenance expenses (energy and supplies) are low; their operation and maintenance require only periodic, rather than continuous, on-site labor;
24
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto • • • • •
are able to tolerate fluctuations in flow, (tolerate fluctuations in flow and pollutant concentrations); are able to treat wastewaters with very different constituents and concentration; are characterized by a high process stability (buffering capacity); are characterized by low excess sludge production; facilitate water reuse and recycling.
Additionally, constructed wetlands (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; USEPA, 2000; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001; Haberl et al., 2003): • • • • •
provide habitat for many wetland organisms; can be built to fit harmoniously into the landscape; provide numerous benefits in addition to water quality improvement, such as wildlife habitat and the aesthetic enhancement of open spaces; provide recreational and educational opportunities; are an “environmentally sensitive” approach viewed with favor by the general public.
However, there are also some limitations to the use of CWS in treating wastewater (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; USEPA, 2000; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001): •
• • • • • • • • • •
they generally require large land area for the same level of treatment by conventional systems making them unsuitable for the treatment for sources that generate large quantities of wastewater, such as large cities; they may be relatively slow to provide treatment compared to more conventional treatment technologies; performance may be less consistent than in conventional treatment, CW depend on climate and, thus, may have reduce efficiencies during colder seasons; they require long period, typically two or three plant growing seasons, for the vegetation before optimal treatment efficiencies are achieved; the process dynamics of the CWS are yet to be clearly understood leading to imprecise design and operating criteria; these systems typically lie outdoor and spread over large area, their performance is susceptible to storm, wind, and floods; they require a base flow of water, they can tolerate temporary water level drawdowns, but not complete drying; there may provide breeding grounds for mosquitoes and other pests, though proper design can reduce this problem; long-term maintenance may be required; the biological components are sensitive to toxic pollutants; contaminant accumulation must be monitored to maintain ecological health of the system
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
25
3.2. Types of CWS The basic CWS classification is based on the type of water flow regime. Depending on the level of water column with respect to the substrate bed, two general forms of CWS are used in practice: • •
free water surface (FWS) wetlands (also called surface flow (SF) wetlands or aerobic wetlands), and subsurface flow (SSF) wetlands (also known as vegetated submerged bed (VSB) systems).
FWS closely resemble natural wetlands in appearance because they contain aquatic plants that are free floating or rooted in a soil layer on the bottom of wetland. In this type of CWS the water flows horizontally through the leaves and stems of the plants, above the substrate (figs. 1A, 1B and 1C). The near-surface layer of water is aerobic while the deeper waters and the substrate are usually anaerobic (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995). Free water wetlands can further be sub-classified according to the dominant type of macrophytes growing in the system. This type of wetland systems can be (Brix, 1993; USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; Vymazal et al., 1998b; USEPA, 2000): •
•
•
a floating macrophyte system – these systems make use both of floating species that are rooted in the substrate (e.g. Nymphae spp Nuphar spp. (waterlilies), Potamogeton natans (pondweed), Hydrocotyle vulgaris (pennyworth)) and species which are free floating on water surface (e.g. Eichhornia crassipes (water hyacinth), Lemna spp., Spirodella spp. (duckweed)); a submerged macrophyte system – the plants used in these systems have their photosynthetic tissue entirely submerged with the flowers being exposed to the atmosphere. Two types of submerged aquatics are usually recognized: the elodeid type (e.g. Elodea spp., Myriophyllum aquaticum (parrot feather), Ceratophyllum spp.) and the isoetid (rosette) type (e.g. Isoetes, Littorella, Lobelia); a rooted emergent macrophyte system – these systems use plants which are the dominating form of life in the natural wetlands. Plants grow at well above the water level, producing aerial stems and an extensive root and rhizome system. These comprise species like the Phragmites australis (common reed), Thypha spp. (cattails), Scirpus spp. (bulrushes), Iris spp. (blue and yellow flags) Juncus spp. (rush), Saggitaria latifolia (duck potato), Phalaris arundinocea (reed canary grass), Carex spp. (Sedges), Zizania aquatica (wild rice), Eleocharis spp. (Spikerushes) and Glyceria spp. (mannagrasses).
On the contrary, SSF do not resemble natural wetlands because they do not have standing water; they are constructed with a substrate (usually small rocks, gravel, sand or soil) which has been planted with aquatic plants, and the wastewater flows beneath the surface of the support matrix but in contact with the plants roots (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; Vymazal et al., 1998a). SSF systems (which, by definition, must be planted with emergent macrophytes) can be sub-classified according to their water flow patterns (figs. 1D and 1E). (Cooper et al., 1996; Vymazal et al., 1998a):
26
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto • • •
horizontal SSF systems vertical SSF systems ( upstream or downstream characteristics) hybrid systems
In the horizontal SSF (fig. 1 D) the wastewater is fed in at the inlet and flows slowly through the porous medium under the surface of the bed in a more or less horizontal path (the bottom of the bed will actually have a slight slope to induce the liquid flow) until it reaches the outlet zone where it is collected before leaving via level control arrangement at the outlet. During the passage the wastewater will come into contact with a network of aerobic, anoxic and anaerobic zones. The aerobic zones occur around roots and rhizomes that leak oxygen into the substrate. In vertical SSF (fig. 1 E) wastewater is applied through different arrangements of wastewater feeding and collection mechanisms to maintain a vertical direction of flow, either descending or ascending, through the substrate. This is achieved either by intermittent wastewater application or by burying inlet pipes into the bed at a depth of 60 to 100 cm. Since the wastewater infiltrates through the substrate bed, this type of wetlands are also called “infiltration wetlands”. Hybrid systems comprise vertical-flow (vertical SSF) and horizontal-flow (horizontal SSF) systems arranged in a staged manner. There are as yet few of these systems in operation and it is perhaps too early to decide which is the best arrangement. The SSF type of wetland is thought to have several advantages over the FWS (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; USEPA, 2000). SSF wetlands show, in general, higher contaminant removal efficiencies than FWS wetlands per unit area of land occupation. In SSF wetlands the substrate provides more surface area for the development of microorganisms which in part is responsible for its increased efficiency. This may allow a smaller area occupation requirement for SSF wetlands in comparison with FWS, in order to achieve a particular level of treatment. As the water surface in a SSF is below the support matrix surface there is also little risk of odors and insect vectors which are associated with the standing wastewaters of the FWS as well as a minimal risk of public or animal exposure.
Figure 1. Different types of CWS (A, FWS with free-floating plants; B, FWS with submerged plants; C, FWS with emergent plants; D, Horizontal SSF; E, Vertical SSF).
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
27
The accumulation of plant debris in the surface of the SSF can additionally provide some thermal protection in colder climates. Percolation of the wastewater through the substrate in the SSF systems also provides faster depuration with the respect to the organic pollutants and nutrients (USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995; USEPA, 2000). In table 2 a comparison of the advantages and disadvantages for each type of constructed wetlands, according to water flow, is presented. Table 2. Advantages and disadvantages of free water surface and subsurface flow wetlands (adapted from Halverson (2004)) Free water surface wetland Advantages · Less expensive to construct and operate and simpler to design than SSF wetlands and conventional treatment methods · Can be used for wastewater with higher suspended solids content · Offer greater flow control than SSF wetlands · Offer more diverse wildlife habitat · Provides habitat for plants and wildlife
Disadvantages · Lower rates of contaminant removal per unit of land than SSF wetlands, thus they require more land to achieve a particular level of treatment than SSF wetlands · Requires more land than conventional treatment methods · Risk of ecological or human exposure to surface-flowing wastewater · May be slower to provide treatment than conventional treatment · Odor and insects may be a problem due to the free water surface Subsurface flow wetland
Advantages · Higher rates of contaminant removal per unit of land than FWS wetlands, thus they require less land to achieve a particular level of treatment than FWS wetlands · Lower total lifetime costs and capital costs than conventional treatment systems · Less expensive to operate than FWS systems · More accessible for maintenance because there is no standing water · Odors and insects not a problem because the water level is below the media surface · Provides habitat for plants and wildlife · Minimal ecological risk due to absence of an exposure pathway
Disadvantages · Requires more land than conventional treatment methods · May be slower to provide treatment than conventional treatment · More expensive to construct than FWS wetlands on a cost per acre basis · Waters containing high suspended solids may cause plugging
There are more than twice as many FWS systems in the United States than SSF systems (Halverson, 2004). In Europe SSF systems outnumber FWS systems. In general, FWS wetlands require more land to achieve the same pollution reduction as SSF wetlands, but are easier and cheaper to design and build (USEPA, 1993; USEPA and USDA-NRCS, 1995). The SSF technology is based on the work of Seidel (Seidel, 1955). Since then the technology has grown in many European countries and is nowadays applied worldwide.
28
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
3.3. CWS Components Constructed wetlands are engineered systems of wastewater treatment that are designed and constructed to utilize the natural processes that occur in natural wetlands. A constructed wetland consists of a properly-designed basin that contains soils or other selected substrate, water column, and wetland vegetation, as the main elements. Other important components that assist in the treatment of the wastewater, such as the communities of microorganisms, develop naturally. The concerted action of all these components (substrate, macrophytes and microbial population adapted to the wastewater toxicity) through a variety of chemical, physical and biological processes, is responsible for the depuration of wastewaters achieved in a CWS (figure 2). Aquatic plants play a central role in the depuration mechanisms occurring in a CWS as they provide support for and stimulate the microorganisms’ growth and, as well, promote the removal of a variety of pollutants by their adsorption, uptake or phytodegradation. Their role in the direct degradation and uptake of organic pollutants, in particular xenobiotics of anthropogenic origin, is not as important as the microorganisms’ action, but in many cases is still very significant. Microorganisms have, in fact, the major role in the biodegradation of this type of contaminants, through their metabolic transformations. In addition, they also have a participation in the removal of some inorganic compounds such as in the nitrogen cycle.
Figure 2. Summary of the major physical, chemical and biological processes controlling pollutant removal in CWS.
In the case of a SSF wetland, the substrate component is also fundamental not only because it provides the physical support for the macrophytes and microorganisms
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
29
development but also since it can promote a series of chemical and physical processes which additionally contribute to the decontamination the polluted wastewater.
3.4. Pollutant Removal Processes A number of physical, chemical and biological processes operate concurrently in constructed and natural wetlands to provide the removal of contaminants (Figure 2). These processes include, among others, sedimentation, plant uptake, microbial degradation, sorption, precipitation and volatilization. Removal of pollutants from water may be accomplished through storage in the wetland substrate and vegetation, or through losses to the atmosphere. A basic understanding of how these processes operate in wetlands is extremely helpful for assessing the potential applications, benefits and limitations of CWS.
3.4.1. Physical Processes CWS are capable of providing highly efficient physical removal of pollutants associated with particulate matter in the wastewater through sedimentation and filtration. Physical pollutant removal processes in wetland systems occur mainly due to the presence of plant biomass and, in the case of SSF wetlands, also to the substrate media. Sedimentation of suspended solids is promoted by the low flow velocity and by the fact that the flow is often laminar in wetlands. The pathways of wastewater are retarded in a CWS due to the resistance to flow provided by vegetation, which thereby enhances sedimentation of suspended solids. In addition to serving as sediment traps, a primary role in suspended solids removal by floating plants is also to limit re-suspension of settled particulate matter. On the other hand, the media acts as filter beds, similarly as in filtration processes, and in this manner contribute to the physical removal of suspended solids through straining. Volatilization, which involves diffusion of a dissolved compound from the water into the atmosphere, is another potential means of contaminant removal in wetlands. Some of the simpler inorganics resulting from mineralization (such as ammonia) and many types of organic compounds are volatile, and are readily lost to the atmosphere from wetlands and other surface waters. Although volatilization can effectively remove certain contaminants from the water, it may prove to be undesirable in some instances, due to the potential for polluting the air with the same contaminants and, subsequently, contaminate neighboring areas through rainfall or dustfall. 3.4.2. Chemical Processes A wide range of chemical processes are involved in the removal of contaminants in wetlands. The most important chemical removal processes in wetland soils are sorption and precipitation. Other chemical processes such as redox reactions, hydrolysis and complexation, can result in transformations of the pollutants which can be accessory to removal either through precipitation or adsorption. Processes such as photolysis and ionic exchange with mineral components of the substrates can also contribute to the removal of some particular classes of pollutants. Sorption refers simultaneously to both adsorption and absorption phenomena, and the term is used whenever the extent to which each phenomenon is responsible for the compound’s removal is not clear or well defined. These chemical processes occur at the
30
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
surfaces of plants roots and substrate, resulting in a short-term retention or long-term immobilization of the contaminants. The sorption process is influenced by characteristics of the substrate, such as its texture, content in organic matter and ion exchange properties, by characteristics of the wastewater, such as its dissolved organic matter content, pH and electrolyte composition, and by the properties of the pollutant itself. In the case of pollutants with acid-base properties, the pH in the liquid compartment will determine the form (ionic or neutral) in which they will be present in solution and this aspect may have a strong influence over the extent of sorption to mineral surfaces with ion exchange properties. Complexation phenomena can also contribute, in some cases, to increase the solubility of some pollutants or, in other cases, to facilitate binding of pollutants to a mineral surface. Precipitation is also a major process leading to long-term removal of pollutants. The extent of these processes is frequently dependent on pH and redox conditions. Hydrolysis very often leads to the formation of insoluble oxides and hydroxides, while changes in protonation states are a frequent means of converting soluble ionic forms of a compound into a neutral insoluble form. Precursor redox reactions are also commonly associated with precipitation phenomena through the conversion between more soluble oxidation states into oxidation states that easily lead to formation of insoluble compounds. In addition, sorption is a process which, in some cases, also is accessory to co-precipitation phenomena.
3.4.3. Biological Processes CWS are biological systems in which biological processes play a major role in removal of pollutants. Probably the most widely recognized biological process for inorganic pollutant removal in wetlands is plant uptake. Contaminants that are also forms of essential plant nutrients, such as nitrate, ammonium and phosphate, are readily taken up by wetland plants. However, many wetland plant species are also capable of uptake and even significant accumulation of, certain toxic metals such as cadmium and lead. The rate of contaminant removal by plants varies widely, depending on plant growth rate and concentration of the contaminant in plant tissue. In wetlands, as in many terrestrial ecosystems, when the plants age and die, the dead plant material, known as detritus or litter, is deposited at the substrate surface. Some of the nutrients, metals or other elements previously removed from the water by plant uptake are lost from the plant detritus by leaching and decomposition, and recycled back into the water and solid media. Water-soluble contaminants are leached more rapidly upon the death of the plant or plant tissue, while a more gradual loss of contaminants occurs during decomposition of detritus by bacteria and other organisms. The recycled contaminants may be flushed from the wetland in the surface water, or may be removed again from the water by biological uptake or other means. Although microorganisms may also provide a measurable amount of contaminant uptake and storage, it is their metabolic processes that play the most significant role in the decomposition of organic compounds through the transformation of complex molecules into simpler ones. This provides an important biological mechanism for removal of a wide variety of organic compounds, including those found in municipal and industrial wastewater. The efficiency and rate of organic C degradation by microorganisms is highly variable for different types of organic compounds.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
31
Microbial metabolism also affords, in wetlands, for the removal of inorganic nitrogen, i.e., nitrate and ammonium, ultimately resulting in the release of nitrogen gas, in the form of N2, which is subsequently lost to the atmosphere. The coupled processes of nitrification and denitrification are universally important in the cycling and bioavailability of nitrogen in wetland and upland soils (Vymazal, 2007). An understanding of the basic physical, chemical and biological processes controlling contaminant removal in wetlands will substantially increase the probability of success of treatment wetland applications. Furthermore, a working knowledge of biogeochemical cycling, the movement and transformation of nutrients, metals and organic compounds among the biotic (living) and abiotic (non-living) components of the ecosystem, can provide valuable insight into overall wetland functions and structure. This level of understanding is useful for evaluating the performance of contaminant removal by constructed wetlands and for assessing the functional integrity of human-impacted, restored and mitigation wetlands. A more detailed discussion follows, describing the mechanisms studied that are involved in contaminant removal by CWS, for each of the most important types of water contaminants.
4. MECHANISMS OF POLLUTANTS REMOVAL BY CWS Wetlands have been found to be effective in treating organic matter, suspended solids and nutrients as well as for reducing metals, trace organic pollutants and pathogens. The main pollutants removal mechanisms in CWS include biological processes such as microbial metabolic activity and plant uptake as well as physical and chemical processes such as volatilization, sedimentation, filtration, adsorption and precipitation at the water-substrate, root-substrate and plant-water interfaces. The following table provides an overview of the major pollutant removal mechanisms that operate in the wetland environment, which are responsible for the removal/reduction of wastewater contaminants. Table 3. Pollutant removal mechanisms (Brix, 1993; Cooper et al., 1996; Vymazal et al., 1998b; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001) Wastewater pollutant Total Suspended Solids (TSS) Soluble Biodegradable Organic Matter (measured as BOD)
Nutrients: Nitrogen (N)
Removal mechanism · Sedimentation · Filtration · Microbial degradation (aerobic, anoxic and anaerobic) · Adsorption · Plant uptake · · · · · · ·
Ammonification (mineralization) Nitrification/ denitrification Nitrate-ammonification Plant/microbial uptake Media adsorption/ion exchange Ammonia volatilization ANAMMOX
32
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto Table 3. (Continued) Wastewater pollutant Phosphorus (P)
Metals
Pathogens (microbial population)
Organic xenobiotics
Removal mechanism · Media adsorption · Plant and microbial uptake · Sedimentation · Precipitation · Adsorption and cation exchange · Complexation · Precipitation/co-precipitation · Oxidation and hydrolysis · Plant uptake · Microbial oxidation/reduction (microbial-mediated processes) · Sedimentation and filtration · Sedimentation · Filtration · Natural die-off · Predation · UV irradiation · Excretion of antibiotics form roots by roots of macrophytes · Adsorption · Sedimentation · Volatilization · Biodegradation · Adsorption · Plant uptake · Photolysis · Chemical reactions
Constructed wetlands should be engineered to maximize the particular removal mechanisms required for the treatment of a given wastewater. A good understanding of the complex mechanisms involved in the removal of the different types of pollutants present in the wastewater is therefore essential for the design and operation of any CWS.
4.1. Suspended Solids Removal Municipal and some industrial effluents usually contain large quantities of suspended solids. Excessive amounts of this suspended particulate matter may cause adverse effects such as reducing the light available to photosynthetic organisms. On settling, it may also alter the characteristics of the river bed, potentially making it a less suitable habitat for the local organisms. However, this problem is amongst the most readily solvable ones of wastewater treatment, and is usually very efficiently addressed in a CWS. A brief review of the literature data reveals usually very high values reported for the removal of suspended solids independently of the CWS type, with efficiencies usually above 90% (Vymazal et al., 1998a;
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
33
Gómez Cerezo et al., 2001; Merlin et al., 2002; Ansola et al., 2003; Cameron et al., 2003; Mantovi et al., 2003). In a CWS the major mechanisms responsible for removal of settleable suspended solids are sedimentation and filtration. Non-settling/colloidal solids are removed, at least partially, by bacterial growth (which results in the settling of some colloidal solids and the microbial decay of others) and collisions with the adsorption to other solids (Vymazal et al., 1998b). In FWS systems suspended solids are removed in part by sedimentation, enhanced by very low flow velocities and shallow depths, and in part by filtration through the living vegetation and vegetative litter. Additional removal of solids also occurs at the soil interface (Metcalf and Eddy, 1991). In SSF systems, suspended solids are removed primarily by filtration through the substrate. Thus, there is a tendency for solids to clog or seal the infiltrative surface of the systems. These systems must, then, be designed and operated to minimize loss of infiltrative capacity (Metcalf and Eddy, 1991). In most applications, a sedimentation pond is added upstream of the wetland cells to promote the removal of larger suspended particles and minimize the chance of clogging the wetland cells. The pond can also dilute the raw influent if it is considered too strong. These TSS treatment processes also contribute to a significant portion of the removal of organic matter, nutrients (mostly nitrogen and phosphorus) and pathogens. In SSF systems, the high removal efficiencies of suspended matter have, in some cases, also shown to be less sensitive to seasonal conditions (Merlin et al., 2002). Frequently, removal of suspended solids is observed to occur mainly within the early stages of treatment (Vymazal et al., 1998a; Gómez Cerezo et al., 2001; Merlin et al., 2002).
4.2. Soluble Organic Matter The biochemical oxygen demand (BOD), which indirectly quantifies the amount of biodegradable organic matter, provides a broad measure of the effects of organic pollution on a receiving water body. In general the origins of organic effluents and their composition are extremely diverse and one can expect a similar diversity in the effects they have on receiving waters. Domestic effluent is the greatest source of organic materials discharged to fresh waters. In urban areas, the run-off from houses, factories and roads can also result in severe pollution, especially in storm conditions after periods of dry weather. Industrial effluents are a further source of organic pollution. These may be routed via the wastewater treatment works or they may be released, with or without treatment, directly into a waterway. Among the industries producing effluents containing substantial amounts of organic wastes are the food processing and brewing industries, dairies, abattoirs and tanneries, textile and paper making factories and farms. One of the major problems caused by effluents with high BOD loads occurs as organic matter is gradually decomposed by the microorganisms in a much similar way to the processes occurring in biological treatment processes in wastewater treatment plants. This microbial process, in which the more complex organic molecules are broken down into simple inorganic molecules, involves a considerable consumption of dissolved oxygen. When high loads of organic pollution are present, oxygen may be used at a higher rate than it can be replenished from the atmosphere or the photosynthetic activity of aquatic plants, thus causing
34
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
its depletion with severe consequences for the water stream biota, including reduced fitness and, in extreme cases, asphyxiation (Mason, 2002). The sedimentation of organic waste at the bottom of streams may also alter its characteristics, with potential harmful effects to its biota. A majority of operating CWS in the world are used for treatment of municipal wastewater in which organic substances constitute the prominent pollutants. Hence, a vast information bank is available on CWS performance of organic matter removal. Wetlands are efficient users of external carbon sources, which is manifested by good reductions in BOD (Hammer and Bastian, 1989; Vymazal et al., 1998b; Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001). Soluble degradable organic matter in wastewater is removed mainly through microbial degradation whereas uptake of degradable organic matter by macrophytes is negligible compared to biological degradation (Metcalf and Eddy, 1991). The microorganisms responsible for the degradation are generally associated with slimes or films that develop on the surfaces of substrate particles, vegetation and litter (Metcalf and Eddy, 1991; Vymazal et al., 1998b). Organic compounds may be degraded both aerobically and anaerobically and it is difficult to quantify the ratio between the two types (Ottova et al., 1997). The oxygen required for aerobic degradation is supplied directly from atmosphere by diffusion or oxygen leakage from the macrophyte roots into the rhizosphere. The efficiency of organic matter removal in CWS is well documented in numerous reports in the literature. In table 4 a sample of some illustrative studies is presented. Soluble organic matter removal efficiency in CWS is generally high, usually exceeding 80%, but the efficiency of organic matter treatment does show some variation according to the CWS type. Table 4. Organic matter (BOD) removal in several types of CWS Type of CWS
Reduction rate
References
FWS (pilot-scale)
89%
(Chen et al., 2006)
Hierarchical Mosaic of Aquatic Ecosystems (HMAE®)
80-95%
(Ansola et al., 2003)
HSSF
86.6%
(Vymazal, 1999)
HSSF
≥ 90%
(Merlin et al., 2002)
HSSF
94%
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
HSSF (review)
85%
(Vymazal, 2005c)
SSF
75-79%
(Karathanasis et al., 2003)
Multi-stage system
90%
(Gómez Cerezo et al., 2001)
Set of single-family CW (review)
70%
(Steer et al., 2002)
VSSF
97%
(Haberl et al., 2003)
VSSF
96%
(Meuleman et al., 2003)
VSSF (pilot-scale)
> 98%
(Sleytr et al., 2007)
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
35
These differences are revealing of the dependence on several design and operational parameters including the type of CWS/vegetation/substrate, the hydraulic and mass loading rates, flow regime, hydraulic residence time, and BOD decay rate, which in turn is a function of temperature (Vymazal, 1999; Vymazal, 2005c). Because of the complexity of these interdependencies, different studies set up under different conditions are not easily comparable. For example, the role of the substrate and the rhizosphere in FWS systems is quite negligible compared with SSF, where long residence times allow extensive interaction with the wastewater. While resilient, slow growing species with low seasonal biomass turnover, and high root zone aeration capacity may be suitable for FWSs, high productivity species, tolerant to high levels of pollutants and hypertrophic waterlogged conditions may be functionally superior in SSFs (Tanner et al., 1995). Indeed, one aspect that has been controversial is the role of vegetation and the effects of different plant species as mono or polycultures in promoting treatment. Although some studies (Soto et al., 1999; Vymazal, 1999; Merlin et al., 2002) have documented that macrophytes can improve BOD removal from wastewaters by: i) enhancing sedimentation, ii) providing mechanical filtration, iii) providing nutrient assimilation, and iv) stimulating the microbial activity and its development; others did not detect any significant difference between planted and unplanted systems (Tanner et al., 1995). Seasonal variations in BOD removal efficiency by CWS in the presence of various macrophytes species have been reported by several investigators, with consistent treatment deterioration being observed in late winter months (Kuehn and Moore, 1995). It is uncertain, however, whether the poor winter performances are due to cold temperatures alone or the combined effect with increased hydraulic loadings, because several other studies have not shown significant treatment effects between winter and summer (Neralla et al., 2000).
4.3. Nutrients Removal The major sources of nutrients pollution (primarily, sources of nitrogen and phosphorus) in water bodies are derived, in urban areas, from domestic wastewaters, industrial wastewaters and storm drainage whereas rural sources of nutrients include those from agriculture, from forest management and from rural dwellings. Often, either nitrogen or phosphorus is the limiting factor in an aquatic system, and the addition of excess nutrients may cause eutrophication in rivers, streams, estuaries and coastal waters or other undesirable changes in the ecological community such as ammonia’s toxicity to aquatic biota and problems caused by excessive levels of nitrates in drinking water which may be a public health issue. The problems caused by excess of nutrients can also directly affect human activities and these problems can be summarized into three main areas: those associated with quality of water supply, those affecting aesthetic and recreational activities, and those causing difficulties with the management of water courses and lakes (Mason, 2002). A wetland system offers excellent ecological possibilities to act as a sink for nutrients. Nutrient cycling in CWS includes pathways of nutrient transformation between several different forms and transfer between the different compartments such as water, substrate, litter, plants, etc.
36
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
4.3.1. Nitrogen Removal in CWS Nitrogen is a major component of most wastewaters and all nitrogen forms, including nitrogen gas (N2), are biochemically interconvertible and are components of the nitrogen cycle. The dominant forms of nitrogen in wetlands that are of importance to wastewater treatment include organic nitrogen, ammonia, ammonium, nitrate, nitrite, and nitrogen gas. The relative proportion of each depends on the type of wastewater and pre-treatment. Organic forms are present in dissolved and particulate forms, while inorganic N is present in dissolved forms. Particulate forms are removed though settling and burial, while the removal of dissolved forms is regulated by various biogeochemical reactions functioning in the substrate and water column (Fig. 3). Relative rates of these processes are affected by physico-chemical and biological characteristics of substrate, water column and vegetation type. The transformation and removal of nitrogen in CWS involves a complex set of physical, chemical and biological processes (figure 3). The mechanisms involved in the removal of nitrogen from wastewater depend on the major forms in which the nitrogen is present. Mineralization, biological uptake, nitrification and nitrate reduction to ammonium are processes that transform one form of nitrogen to another (figure 3). In terms of the nitrogen cycle, these mechanisms are conservative processes and operate to cycle nitrogen within a system. Denitrification and ammonia volatilization are export processes and result in the net loss of nitrogen from the system. Conversely, nitrogen fixation returns nitrogen from the atmosphere to the CWS.
Figure 3. Nitrogen transformation/removal mechanisms in CWS (adapted from Cooper et al. (1996)).
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
37
4.3.1.1. Nitrogen Conservative Transformations The major processes of nitrogen transformations which do not lead to nitrogen release from the system are enumerated in Table 5. The various forms of nitrogen are continually involved in chemical transformations from inorganic to organic compoundHs and back from organic to inorganic. All of these transformations are necessary for wetland ecosystems to function successfully, and most chemical changes are controlled through the production of enzymes and catalysts by the living organisms they benefit (Vymazal, 2007). Table 5. The major nitrogen conservative transformations and retention processes in CWS (adapted from Vymazal (2007)) Process Ammonification (mineralisation) Nitrification Nitrate-ammonification Plant/microbial uptake (assimilation) Ammonia adsorption Organic nitrogen burial
Transformation Organic-N Æ ammonia-N Ammonia-N Æ nitrite-N Æ nitrate-N Nitrate-N Æ ammonia-N Ammonia-N, nitrite-N, nitrate-N Æ organic-N
Ammonification (mineralization) – is the process where organic nitrogen is biologically converted into inorganic nitrogen, especially ammonium (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Vymazal, 2007). Ammonium is converted from organic forms through a complex biochemical process involving the catabolism of amino acids with a net release of energy (Vymazal, 2007). In some cases, this energy is used by microorganisms for growth, and ammonia is directly incorporated into microbial biomass (Vymazal, 2007). The process can occur under aerobic or anaerobic conditions but, in comparison to facultative and obligate anaerobic mineralization, the contribution of aerobic mineralization to the overall N mineralization would be very small (Vymazal et al., 1998b). A wide range of ammonification rates are reported in the literature, with values ranging between 0.004 and 0.53 g N m−2 d−1 (Reddy and D'Angelo, 1997; Tanner et al., 2002). Net release of NH4+ is determined by the balance between ammonification and immobilization (conversion of inorganic nitrogen ions into organic forms) which is controlled by the N requirements of microorganisms involved, nature of organic N, temperature, pH, redox conditions, C/N ratio, available nutrients concentration and substrate conditions such as texture and structure (Vymazal, 2007). The optimal ammonification temperature is reported to be 40–60 °C while optimal pH is between 6.5 and 8.5 (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Vymazal, 2007). Nitrification – is usually defined as the biological oxidation of ammonium to nitrate with nitrite as an intermediate in the reaction sequence (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Vymazal, 2007). Nitrification is performed primarily by chemoautotrophic bacteria, which derive energy from the oxidation of ammonia and/or nitrite and carbon dioxide is used as a carbon source for synthesis of new cells (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Vymazal, 2007). The process consists of two main sequential steps (Vymazal et al., 1998b): (1) NH4+ + 3/2 O2 → NO2- + 2 H+ + H2O NO2- + 1/2 O2 → NO3-
(2)
38
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
NH4+ + 2 O2 → NO3- + 2 H+ + H2O
(3)
The first step, the oxidation of ammonium to nitrite, is executed by strictly chemolithotrophic (strictly aerobic) bacteria which are entirely dependent on the oxidation of ammonia for the generation of energy for growth. In soil, species belonging to the genera Nitrosospira, Nitrosovibrio, Nitrosolobus, Nitrosococcus and Nitrosomonas have been identified (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Brady and Weil, 2002; Vymazal, 2007). The second step in the process of nitrification, the oxidation of nitrite to nitrate, is performed by facultative chemolithotrophic bacteria, Nitrobacter, which can also use organic compounds, in addition to nitrite, for the generation of energy for growth (Vymazal, 2007). Nitrification rates in wetlands were reported to be in the range of 0.01–2.15 g N m−2 d−1 with the mean value of 0.048 g N m−2 d−1 (Reddy and D'Angelo, 1997; Tanner et al., 2002). Nitrification is influenced by concentrations of ammonium-N, BOD concentration, temperature, pH value, alkalinity of the water, inorganic C source, moisture, microbial population, dissolved oxygen and potential for toxic compounds. Nitrification is strictly an aerobic process in which the end product is nitrate; this process is limited when anaerobic conditions prevail. Nitrate-ammonification – refers to a process of anoxic reduction of nitrate to ammonia. This is the first anoxic process to occur after oxygen depletion in the reduction of nitrate to molecular nitrogen or ammonia. This is performed by two different groups of nitrate-reducing bacteria: the denitrifying bacteria which produce N2O and N2 as major reduction products (denitrification), and the nitrate-ammonifying bacteria which produce NH4+ as the major end product of the reduction of nitrate (Vymazal, 2007). The nitrate-ammonification rates is influenced by environmental factors such as absence of O2, redox potential, temperature, pH value, organic matter, etc. Nitrogen assimilation (plant/microbial uptake) – refers to a variety of biological processes that convert inorganic nitrogen forms into organic compounds that serve as building blocks for cells and tissues. The two forms of nitrogen generally used for assimilation are ammonium and nitrate nitrogen (Vymazal, 2007). Macrophyte growth is not the only potential biological nitrogen assimilation process in wetlands, microorganisms and algae also utilize nitrogen. The potential rate of nutrient uptake and storage (standing stock) by plant is limited by its net productivity (growth rate) and the concentration of nutrients in the plant tissue. Therefore, desirable traits of a plant used for nutrient assimilation and storage would include rapid growth, high tissue nutrient content, and the capability to attain a high standing crop. In the literature, there are many reviews on nitrogen concentrations in plant tissue as well as nitrogen standing stocks for plants found in natural stands and constructed wetlands (Mitsch and Gosselink J.G., 2000; Vymazal, 2007). However, if the wetland vegetation is not harvested, the vast majority of the nutrients that have been incorporated into the plant tissue will be returned to the water as result of decomposition processes. Ammonia adsorption/ionic exchange – the reduced state ammoniacal N is stable but can be adsorbed onto active sites of the substrate. However, the ion exchange of NH4+-N on cation exchanging sites of the substrate is not considered to be a long-term sink for NH4+-N removal but rather is presumed to be rapidly reversible (Vymazal et al., 1998b).
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
39
In a continuous-flow system, under stable conditions, the sorbed NH4+-N will be in equilibrium with NH4+-N in solution. An intermittently loaded system will display rapid removal of NH4+-N by adsorption mechanisms and a gradual release during rest periods. The rate and extent of these processes are reported to be influenced by several factors, such as nature and amount of clays, nature and amount of soil organic matter, periods of submergence and drying, and presence of vegetation. Organic nitrogen burial – some fractions of the organic nitrogen incorporated in detritus in a wetland system may eventually become unavailable for additional nutrient cycling through the process of peat formation and burial. The values of organic nitrogen burial have been reported for various natural wetlands, however, in constructed wetlands there are practically no data available (Vymazal, 2007).
4.3.1.2. Removal/retention mechanisms In addition to the processes just described, some of which actually remove nitrogen from the wastewater into some component of the wetland, further removal may consist of nitrogen release off the system through ammonia volatilization, denitrification and anaerobic ammonium oxidation. Conversely, normal operation of CWS may include the natural incorporation of nitrogen in the system through fixation. Ammonia volatilization – is a physicochemical process where ammonium-N is in equilibrium with gaseous and hydroxyl forms (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Brady and Weil, 2002; Vymazal, 2007): NH4+ + OH- → H2O + NH3
(4)
As can be seen, ammonia volatilization will be more pronounced at higher pH levels. These high pH values which facilitate volatilization are created during the day, in wetland, by the photosynthesis of submerged macrophytes and algae. The volatilization rate is controlled by the NH4+ concentration in water, pH values, temperature, wind velocity, solar radiation, the nature and density of vegetation and the capacity of the system to change the pH value in diurnal cycles (absence of CO2 increases volatilization). The volatilization of ammonia in CWS can result in nitrogen removal rates as high as 2.2 g N m−2 d− 1 (Stowell et al., 1981). Denitrification – is a bacterial facilitated anoxic process of nitrate reduction that may ultimately produce molecular nitrogen (N2) through a series of intermediate gaseous nitrogen oxide products. This respiratory process reduces oxidized forms of nitrogen in response to the oxidation of an electron donor such as organic matter (Brady and Weil, 2002). The organisms that carry out this process are commonly present in large numbers and are mostly facultative anaerobic bacteria in genera, such as Pseudomonas, Bacillus, Micrococcus and Achromobacter. These denitrifying bacteria are chemoheterotrophs, which obtain their energy and carbon from the oxidation of organic compounds. Other organisms are autotrophs, such as Thiobacillus denitrificans, which obtain their energy from the oxidation of sulfide. The exact mechanisms vary depending on the conditions and organism involved (Brady and Weil, 2002). It is generally agreed that the actual sequence of biochemical changes from nitrate to elemental gaseous nitrogen is (Vymazal, 2007):
40
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
2 NO3- => 2 NO2- => 2 NO => N2O => N2
(5)
Environmental factors known to influence denitrification rates include the absence of O2, redox potential, substrate moisture, temperature, pH value, presence of denitrifiers, substrate type, organic matter, nitrate concentration and the presence of overlying water (Vymazal, 2007). The estimation of denitrification rates in CWS varies widely in the literature between 0.003 and 1.02 g N m−2 d−1 (Reddy and D'Angelo, 1997; Vymazal, 2007). Denitrification is the predominant microbial process that modifies the chemical composition of nitrogen in a wetland system and the major process whereby elemental nitrogen is returned to the atmosphere. Anaerobic ammonium oxidation (ANAMMOX) – is the anaerobic conversion of NO2− and NH4+ to N2. It was demonstrated that in an ANAMMOX process, nitrate is used as an electron acceptor (Vymazal, 2007). Not all the transformation/removal processes of nitrogen occur in all types of constructed wetlands and the magnitude of individual processes varies among types of CWS. Volatilization may be a significant route for nitrogen removal in constructed wetlands with open water surface where algal assemblages can create high pH values during the day through their photosynthetic activity (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Vymazal, 2007). Nitrification occurs in all types of CWS, however, the extent of this process is determined by oxygen availability. Nitrification takes place when oxygen is present in concentrations high enough to support the growth of strictly aerobic nitrifying bacteria. Nitrification per se is a limiting process for nitrogen removal from most types of CWS because ammonia is the dominant species of nitrogen in sewage and many other wastewaters (Vymazal, 2007). On the other hand, denitrification is considered as a major removal mechanism for nitrogen in most types of constructed wetlands (Vymazal, 2007). The concentrations of nitrate, however, are usually very low in wastewater (the exception is drainage water from the agriculture and some industrial wastewaters) which also limits the extent to which this process can occur. However, the coupling between the nitrification and denitrification processes provides the conditions for this to be the major nitrogen removal process in many treatment wetlands. Different requirements for the presence of oxygen for nitrification and denitrification are the major obstacle in many treatment wetlands for achieving higher nitrogen removal. Nitrate-ammonification occurs under conditions of low redox potential values and, therefore, there is a potential that this process may be important in treatment wetlands where anaerobic conditions do occur, e.g., in treatment wetlands with horizontal sub-surface flow (Vymazal, 2007). Ammonium adsorption is limited to CWS with sub-surface flow where the contact between substrate and wastewater is efficient. In Table 6 are displayed the removals of various forms of nitrogen by different types of CWS which can be found in the literature. The removal efficiency of several nitrogen forms in CWS is well documented in numerous reports in the literature. In table 6 a sample of some illustrative studies is presented.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
41
Table 6. Nitrogen removal in several types of CWS Type of CWS
Reduction rate -
References -
(Kohler et al., 2004)
Created wetland
97% (NO3 /NO2 -N) 100% (NH3-N)
CWS (pilot scale)
85% (NO2 --N) 88% (NO3 --N) 13% (NH4 +-N)
(Maine et al., 2007)
CWS (Single-family)
56% (NH4 +-N)
(Steer et al., 2002)
FWS
53% (inorganic-N) 60% (NO2 --N) 70% (NO3 --N)
(Maine et al., 2006)
41.2% (total-N) 55.1% (NH4 +-N) 60.7% (NO3 --N)
(Vymazal, 2007)
FWS
3 to 15% (total-N)
(Braskerud, 2002)
FWS (pilot-scale)
56% (NH3-N)
(Chen et al., 2006)
Hierarchical Mosaic of Aquatic Ecosystems (HMAE®)
98% (NH4 +-N)
(Ansola et al., 2003)
HSSF
50% (total-N) 79% (organic-N)
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
HSSF (review)
42% (total-N) 48% (NH4 +-N) 35% (NO3 --N)
(Vymazal, 2005c)
42.3% (total-N) 48.3% (NH4 +-N) 38.5% (NO3 --N)
(Vymazal, 2007)
Small-scale wetland mesocosms
55%( Kjeldahl-N)
(Hench et al., 2003)
VSSF
30% (total-N)
(Meuleman et al., 2003)
VSSF (review)
44.6% (total-N) 84.2% (NH4 +-N)
(Vymazal, 2007)
VSSF (pilot-scale)
99.5 % (NH4 +-N)
(Sleytr et al., 2007)
FWS (review)
HSSF (review)
42
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
Due to the varied forms in which nitrogen may be present in a wastewater, several very different mechanisms will be operative in their transformation or removal. Furthermore, the efficiencies of the different mechanisms are very dependent on the particular conditions. As such, comparisons are quite difficult to establish among several studies and the reported total nitrogen removed will vary significantly. The most effective removal of nitrogen results from volatilization of ammonia and the coupled nitrification-denitrification process with elimination of gaseous nitrogen. The absence of a free water surface in SSF systems is a limiting factor for the efficiency of the volatilization process in this type of systems, and thus the efficiency of this process may be considerable only in FWS. On the other hand, a single-stage system hardly provides both aerobic as well as anoxic zones for adequate nitrification and denitrification in simultaneity. Multi-stage systems have been suggested as possibly being able to improve the conditions for the coupled nitrification-denitrification process. Some environmental conditions, such as temperature and dissolved oxygen also have a significant influence in the overall efficiencies. Importance of harvesting in the case of nitrogen removal is not as critical as in other cases, for instance the removal of phosphorus.
4.3.2. Phosphorus Removal in CWS Phosphorus is another nutrient which, when available in excessive amounts, also causes eutrophication in water bodies. Removal of phosphorus tends not to be as high as nitrogen removal in wetlands as no direct metabolic pathway is provided for its biological removal. Phosphorus removal in wetlands is achieved by a variety of physical, chemical and biological processes. Phosphorus is typically present in wastewaters as organic phosphorus and in inorganic form, predominantly as orthophosphate but also as polyphosphates (Cooper et al., 1996; Vymazal et al., 1998b). Organically-bound phosphorus is present e.g., in phospholipids, nucleic acids, nucleoproteins, phosphorylated sugars or organic condensed polyphosphates (coenzymes, ATP, ADP) (Vymazal, 2007). Organic phosphorus is not readily bioavailable until it undergoes enzyme hydrolysis. Free orthophosphate is the only form of phosphorus believed to be utilized directly by algae and macrophytes and thus represents a major link between organic and inorganic phosphorus cycling in wetlands (Vymazal, 2007). Phosphorus availability from organic phosphorus depends on the rate of mineralization and biodegradability, which increases with the nutrient loading in CWS. Wetlands provide an environment for the inter-conversion of all forms of phosphorus, which are cycled in the soil-water-plant components. 4.3.2.1. Removal/Retention Mechanisms Phosphorus removal in CWS can be described as a combination of both short-term (uptake by plants and microorganisms) and long-term storage processes (burial in peat/soil). Direct assimilation of wastewater phosphorus by macrophytes represents in general only a minor contribution to the overall phosphorus removal. Adsorption and precipitation can initially only be considered as short-term storage. However, once this material is buried within a layer of peat, it becomes part of the long-term “sink” storage. If the settled particulate matters remain insoluble, the phosphorus removal by sedimentation is permanent.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
43
However, if the particulate material is biodegradable organics, after degradation, phosphorus will be released back to the water column. Phosphorus transformations and removal in CWS, thus, involve a variety of processes which include sedimentation and burial in soil, adsorption, precipitation, mineralization and plant/microbial uptake (Vymazal, 2007). Sedimentation and burial – most studies on phosphorus cycling in wetlands have shown that soil/peat accumulation is the major long-term phosphorus sink (Richardson and Marshall, 1986). Over long-term periods, significant portions of organic P remain in soil as part of peat build-up and, under anaerobic conditions, these forms of phosphorus are relatively resistant to microbial breakdown. In nutrient-enriched wetlands long-term P peat accretion can reach nearly 1 gm−2 yr−1 (Craft and Richardson, 1993). Adsorption – adsorption of phosphorus to the substrate has been recognized as one of the most important removal mechanisms (Vymazal, 2007). Traditionally, locally available materials such as sand and soils have been used as substrate for P-removal. In many cases, these substrates have been used without any knowledge of the P-retaining capacities (Brix et al., 2001) even though greater attention has been given more recently to the use of materials with well-tested P adsorptive qualities, among which light expanded clay aggregates (LECA) is one the most popular choices (Brix et al., 2001). Retention by adsorption is strongly related to the amounts of Fe (oxides), Al and Ca minerals and frequently is associated with posterior longer-term removal by precipitation and co-precipitation. The rate of adsorption is controlled by soil pH and Eh, adsorptive surface area and temperature (Reddy and D'Angelo, 1997; Vymazal et al., 1998b). Precipitation – in acid soils, inorganic P is adsorbed on oxides and hydroxides of iron and aluminum and may precipitate as insoluble phosphates (Vymazal et al., 1998b). On the other hand, in the alkaline, calcareous soils precipitation by calcium carbonate as insoluble Ca mineral bound-P is the dominant removal process (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Brix et al., 2001). Thus, precipitation can refer to the reaction of phosphate ions with metallic cations, especially Fe, Al, Ca or Mg, forming amorphous or poorly crystalline solids. In addition to direct chemical reaction, phosphorus can co-precipitate with other minerals, such as ferric oxyhydroxide and the carbonate minerals, such as calcite (calcium carbonate). Plant uptake – the phosphorus uptake capacity of macrophytes is lower as compared with nitrogen uptake. Thus, phosphorus concentration in plant tissues are much lower than that of nitrogen (Vymazal et al., 1998b; Brix et al., 2001). The concentration of phosphorus in the plant tissue varies among species and sites and also during the seasons. Phosphorus uptake by macrophytes is usually highest during the beginning of the growing season (in most regions during the early spring), before maximum growth rate is attained (Vymazal, 2007). Most of the phosphorus taken up by the herbaceous vegetation of wetlands is obtained through their roots from the soil porewater and translocated to the aboveground growing tissues (Reddy and D'Angelo, 1997; Vymazal, 2007). Upon maturity and senescence, a substantial portion of the phosphorus in above-ground tissues is translocated and stored into below-ground biomass (roots and rhizomes). Depending on the type of macrophyte, in nutrient-rich systems most of the remaining aboveground-stored phosphorus is released back into the water as detrital tissue either by initial leaching or as result of decomposition. Phosphorus storage in vegetation can range from short- to long-term, depending on type of vegetation, litter decomposition rates, leaching of P from detrital tissue, and translocation
44
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
of P from shoots to roots tissues. Phosphorus storage in aboveground biomass of emergent macrophytes is usually short-term, with a large amount of P being released during the decomposition of litter (Vymazal, 2007). In order to remove phosphorus from CWS it is necessary to harvest macrophyte biomass. This is especially necessary for free-floating plants. Microbiota uptake – the phosphorus uptake by microbiota (bacteria, fungi, algae, microinvertebrates, etc.) is rapid because these organisms grow and multiply at high rates. It seems that the amount of microbial storage depends also on trophic status of the wetland (Vymazal, 2007). In less enriched sites the microbial uptake may store more phosphorus as compared to more eutrophic sites. Although bacteria are generally considered decomposers that simply mineralize organic P, they have also been shown to regulate the P flux across the sediment–water interface (Kleeberg and Schlungbaum, 1993)and contribute to terminal P burial through production of refractory organic compounds. Of importance, and seldom recognized, is the amount of P that can be sequestered by the algal component of wetlands, especially in areas with open water (Vymazal, 2007). Algae and algal assemblages can affect phosphorus cycling either directly (uptake, release) or indirectly through photosynthesis-induced changes in water and soil/water interface (e.g pH, dissolved oxygen). In fact, diurnal fluctuations of pH (increasing during daytime due to photosynthetic activity and decreasing during the night due to respiration) can produce cycles of precipitation and resolubilization. Table 7 presents some results about the reduction rates (%) of phosphorus in different wetland systems found in literature. Removal of total phosphorus is reported in a range of efficiencies varying between 20% and 90% showing a marked dependence on fundamental aspects such as the CWS type, the vegetation and especially the substrate used, water flow regime, hydraulic and mass loads, hydraulic residence time and environmental conditions. The CWS generally have a greater potential to remove nitrogen than phosphorus because nitrogen can be converted to nitrogen gas and be emitted to the atmosphere as a consequence of the coupled nitrification-denitrification process. The only sustainable removal mechanism for phosphorus in a CWS is plant uptake and subsequent harvesting and that is an especially important route of phosphorus removal in FWS systems with free-floating macrophytes. However, it is important to develop an efficient harvesting frequency in order to keep macrophytes at the optimum growth stage to ensure optimum phosphorus removal (Vymazal, 2007). Still, the amount of phosphorus that can be removed by harvesting the plant biomass usually constitutes only a small fraction of the amount of phosphorus loaded into the system with the wastewater except in CWS which have low inflow loadings. Microbial uptake is considered in all treatment systems only as temporary storage of phosphorus with very short turnover rate. Phosphorus which is taken up by microbiota is released back to the water after the decay of the organisms.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
45
Table 7. Phosphorus removal in several types of CWS Type of CWS
Reduction rate
References
Created wetland
74%
(Kohler et al., 2004)
CWS (Single-family)
80%
(Steer et al., 2002)
FWS
70%
(Hadad et al., 2006)
FWS
21 – 44%
(Braskerud, 2002)
FWS (pilot-scale)
35%
(Chen et al., 2006)
FWS (review)
48.8%
(Vymazal, 2007)
Hierarchical Mosaic of Aquatic Ecosystems (HMAE®)
93 %
(Ansola et al., 2003)
Hybrid system
89%
(Oovel et al., 2007)
HSSF
60 %
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
HSSF (review)
41.1%
(Vymazal, 2007)
HSSF (review)
32%
(Vymazal, 2005c)
VSSF
>80%
(Brooks et al., 2000)
VSSF
24%
(Meuleman et al., 2003)
VSSF
59.5%
(Vymazal, 2007)
VSSF (pilot-scale)
< 47.4 %
(Sleytr et al., 2007)
Phosphorus may also be bound to the substrate of the SSF mainly as a consequence of adsorption and precipitation reactions with calcium, aluminum and iron in the substrate. The capacity of a CWS to remove phosphorus from wastewaters may then be dependent of substrate characteristics (contents in Al, Fe and Ca ions, grain size distributions, pH and specific area). Various artificial media have been tested in order to improve the P-removal in CWS among which are, for example, light expanded clay aggregates (LECA), wollastonite, vermiculite, diatomaceous earth, blast furnace slag and limestone (Brooks et al., 2000; Johansson and Gustafsson, 2000; Brix et al., 2001; Oovel et al., 2007). The removal of phosphorus through adsorption and precipitation can be significant (Vohla et al., 2005) but it is important to realize that these processes are saturable and adsorption decreases over time (Vymazal, 2007). In addition, daily pH variations due to the respiration/photosynthesis cycles may be responsible for cycles of phosphorus precipitation/resolubilization.
4.4. Pathogen Removal Waterborne diseases remain a major hazard in many parts of the world. The important organisms from a public health point of view are the pathogenic bacteria and viruses. Protozoan pathogens and helminth worms are also of particular importance in tropical and subtropical countries (Rivera et al., 1995; Cooper et al., 1996; Vymazal et al., 1998b).
46
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
Wastewater discharges are the major source of contamination by faecal pathogenic microorganisms in rivers and coastal waters posing a risk to public health (Mason, 2002; Sleytr et al., 2007). The treatment of wastewater pathogens in CWS is essentially a two stage process. Most pathogens are particles ranging from very small viruses to the large eggs and cysts of helminths. One of the stages of pathogen treatment is particle removal. This occurs via the same processes as for removal of suspended solids, namely sedimentation, filtration, surface adhesion and aggregation. A series of other processes are important in influencing the viability of pathogens as infectious agents which may occur in a stage either before or after pathogenic particles removal. The major mechanisms in this stage are the hostility of the environmental conditions (temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen concentration, redox potential, salinity, turbity), predation by nematodes, protists and zooplankton and infection by other organisms, antibiosis, exposure to UV radiation and natural die-off (Metcalf and Eddy, 1991; Cooper et al., 1996; Kadlec and Knight, 1996; Ottova et al., 1997; Vymazal et al., 1998a). The efficiency of CWS concerning the removal of microorganisms, especially indicator microorganisms like coliforms and enterococci, is a topic that has been thoroughly investigated (Kadlec and Knight, 1996; Perkins and Hunter, 2000; Langergraber and Haberl, 2001; Hench et al., 2003). In table 8, a small sample of such studies is presented as an illustrative display of the typical efficiencies achieved by several types of CWS. Reported faecal bacteria removal efficiency in CWS is generally high, usually exceeding 85%, and is usually higher for faecal coliforms and somewhat lower for faecal streptococci (Vymazal, 2005b). Is should however be noted that, in spite of high removal efficiencies, if the number of bacteria at the inflow is very large, at the outflow bacteria number may still be too high to meet wastewater quality criteria. Treatment efficiencies depend on several design and operational parameters including the type of CWS, hydraulic regime, type of vegetation, hydraulic residence time, hydraulic and mass loading rate, substrate, and temperature. The efficiency of pathogens treatment does show some variation according to the CWS type and observed efficiencies can in most cases be ranked in the order: hybrid wetlands > SSF wetlands > FWS wetlands (Vymazal, 2005b). These differences may be related to the larger contact area among water, bacteria and substrate, which is much bigger in SSF constructed wetlands compared to FWS (Sleytr et al., 2007) therefore enhancing the process rates of the system (Langergraber and Haberl, 2001). Wetland vegetation plays a crucial role in increasing the efficiency removal of pathogen in CWS. Wetland vegetation improves the trapping efficiency for small particles like viruses by increasing the surface area of biofilms in the flow path. Many species can also release exudates having antimicrobial properties or which can enhance the development in the rhizosphere of populations of bacteria with antibiotic activity (e.g. Pseudomonas).
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
47
Table 8. Removal of pathogens by different types of CWS Indicator microorganism s Faecal coliform (FC)
Faecal streptococci (FS)
Type of CWS
Removal efficiencies
References
Hybrid systems (review)
99.4 %
(Vymazal, 2005b)
FWS
85 – 94 %
(Perkins and Hunter, 2000)
FWS
52 %
(Cameron et al., 2003)
FWS
> 99 %
(García et al., 2008)
FWS (review)
85.6 %
(Vymazal, 2005b)
Hierarchical Mosaic of Aquatic Ecosystems (HMAE®)
99.997 %
(Ansola et al., 2003)
Set of single-family constructed wetland (review)
88 %
(Steer et al., 2002)
SSF
92 %
(Vymazal, 2005c)
SSF
91 %
(Mashauri et al., 2000)
SSF
93 – 98 %
(Karathanasis et al., 2003)
SSF
99 %
(García et al., 2008)
SSF
99.999 %
(Soto et al., 1999)
SSF (review)
91.5 %
(Vymazal, 2005b)
SSF
> 99 %
(Hench et al., 2003)
Hybrid systems (review)
97.7 %
(Vymazal, 2005b)
FWS
82 – 90 %
(Perkins and Hunter, 2000)
FWS
99 %
(García et al., 2008)
FWS (review)
84 %
(Vymazal, 2005b)
SSF
99 %
(García et al., 2008)
SSF
> 98 %
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
SSF
93 - 98 %
(Karathanasis et al., 2003)
SSF
83 – 90 %
(Perkins and Hunter, 2000)
SSF (review)
92.6 %
(Vymazal, 2005b)
SSF
99.999 %
(Soto et al., 1999)
48
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
For example, it has been shown that root excretions of species such as Scirpus lacustris and Phragmites australis can diminish the populations of faecal indicators and pathogenic bacteria (Vymazal, 2005b). In addition, the presence of oxygen in the water column (produced by photosynthetic activity of submerged plants and algae in FWS, or released in the rhizosphere through the roots of macrophytes in SSF) creates unfavorable life conditions for enteric bacteria which are either facultative or obligate anaerobic. Effects of the hydraulic retention time are very simple: the longer the wastewater remains in the system, the longer bacteria remains exposed to unfavorable conditions.
4.5. Metals Removal Metals are naturally present in the environment. However, human activities are responsible for a significant increase in their concentration levels up to a point where they begin to pose an environmental and public health problem. Beyond the natural sources, contamination with metals is mainly associated with such activities as soil disturbance, mining, manufacturing, urbanization, burning of fossil fuels and use of manufactured products such as paints, pesticides, sacrificial anodes and anti-foulants. In small doses some metals are, in fact, essential to some biological processes (e.g. copper, chromium, nickel, zinc). For example, at low concentrations, copper is a micronutrient of plants essential to the photosynthetic electron transport system. However, at higher concentrations, it is marketed as an effective herbicide. In addition to concentration, the chemical form is also associated with a greater metal toxicity. For example, the methylated form of mercury is much more toxic than inorganic mercury (Mitra, 1986). Toxic effects by metals are varied and sometimes diffuse and difficult to characterize. In some cases, for very high metal concentrations, toxicity may be acute and ultimately lethal. However, usually toxicity by metals will cause chronic effects resulting from a long-term exposure. Examples of chronic health effects include cancer, disruption of the endocrine system, liver and kidney damage, disorders of the nervous system, damage to the immune systems, and birth defects. Some metals are not easily eliminated by the organisms and, therefore, they have the potential for bioaccumulation and biomagnification. This constitutes one of the major problems with metal contamination, with the potentiation of the metals' chronic toxicity along the food chain. In CWS a variety of processes may provide routes for metal retention in the CWS components and their elimination from the wastewater. The main mechanisms occurring in each of the compartments (solid medium, aqueous medium and vegetation) are illustrated in figure 4. The substrate is generally considered to be a sink for metals anthropogenically introduced in the environment. A major fraction of the elements entering the CWS will rapidly be adsorbed onto the solid phase, where a number of physical and chemical processes will determine the strength of metal retention. A small proportion of the metals can, however, remain dissolved and become available for plant uptake. In CWS another important role in metal removal is played by plants through several processes which include filtration, adsorption, cation exchange, uptake, and root-induced chemical changes in the rhizosphere (Dunbabin and Bowmer, 1992; Chen et al., 2000; Vandecasteele et al., 2005).
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
49
Figure 4. Metal removal mechanisms in CWS (adapted from Cooper et al. (1996)).
Long-term metal sequestration by plants depends on the rate of uptake, rates of translocation and retention within individual tissue types, and the rate and mode of tissue decomposition (Kadlec and Knight, 1996). Studies report the highest amounts of metals in the roots, while leaf tissue has the second highest concentrations followed by stems and rhizomes (Burke et al., 2000). Microorganisms may also play a relevant role in heavy metal removal. Such contribution may occur through their metabolism with the modification of the oxidation states of metals which in turn may lead to other transformations, such as precipitation, that effectively remove them from the wastewater. A more detailed account follows of the several physical, chemical and biological processes which concur for heavy metal removal in a CWS.
4.5.1. Physical Removal Processes Sedimentation – this has long been recognized as one of the main processes in removal of heavy metals from wastewater in natural and constructed wetlands (Kadlec and Knight, 1996; Hammer, 1997; ITRC, 2003). Sedimentation is a physical process which follows other mechanisms (precipitation/co-precipitation and flocculation) whereby heavy metals aggregate into particles large enough to sink (Walker and Hurl, 2002). In this way heavy metals are removed from wastewater and trapped in the wetland sediments, thus protecting the ultimate receiving water bodies, i.e. aquatic ecosystem (Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). Efficiency of sedimentation is proportional to the particle settling velocity and the length of wetland. 4.5.2. Chemical Removal Processes In addition to physical removal processes a wide range of chemical processes are involved in the removal of heavy metals in the wetlands:
50
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
Sorption – among the chemical processes, sorption is one of the most important removal processes in wetlands, which results in the transfer of ions from water to the soil/sediments and a short-term retention or long-term immobilization of several classes of contaminants (Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). In sediments heavy metals are adsorbed by either cation exchange or chemisorption (Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). In the former process the metal cation will exchange with other small cations (such as, Na+, K+, NH4+, etc) in their positions in the mineral structures of clays and negatively charged groups of humic acids. Therefore the capacity of soils for retention of metal cations, expressed as cation exchange capacity (CEC) increases with increasing content in clay and organic matter. Chemisorption is a process which involves the formation of chemical bonds with the surface, frequently through complexation/chelation phenomena. The adsorption capacity by cation exchange or non-specific adsorption depends upon the physico-chemical environment of the medium (e.g. pH, the properties of the metals concerned and the concentration and properties of other metals and soluble ligands present) (Debusk et al., 1996; Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). Therefore, heavy metals speciation may change with time as the sediment conditions change (Groudev et al., 1999; Wiebner et al., 2005; Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). Much of the heavy metals can be easily adsorbed onto particulate matter in the wetland and subsequently be removed from the water by sedimentation. Lead and copper in general tends to be adsorbed most strongly while zinc, nickel and cadmium are usually held weakly which implies that these metals are likely to be more labile and bio-available (Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006).The adsorption of metals varies with the fluctuation of pH in the outflow water (Machemer and Wildeman, 1992). Precipitated hydroxides may also act as adsorption sites for phytotoxic metals present in the water compartment of the wetland (Wood, 1990). Oxidation and hydrolysis of metals – The states of oxidation of a metal will have a marked influence in its chemical behavior in water. In particular, under some oxidation states a metal may typically hydrolyze to form insoluble oxides or hydroxides whereas in other oxidation states it can be more soluble. Such is the case, for example, of iron, aluminum and manganese which can form insoluble compounds through hydrolysis (sometimes following oxidation processes). This leads to the formation of a variety of oxides, hydroxides and oxyhydroxides (Woulds and Ngwenya, 2004; Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006) Iron removal depends on pH, redox potential and the presence of various anions. In alkaline conditions Fe2+ is a highly soluble cation in water with low content of dissolved oxygen. On the other hand, the form Fe3+ is insoluble except in very acid conditions (pH < 3.5). Manganese removal is the most difficult to be achieved because its oxidation takes place at a pH close to 8 (Stumm and Morgan, 1981). In this case bacteria play an important role in the oxidation of Mn by catalyzing the oxidation of Mn2+ to Mn4+. On the other hand, aluminum removal is purely governed by pH. Aluminum hydroxides will precipitate at pH above 5.0-6.0. Precipitation and co-precipitation – is a major process of heavy metals removal in wetland sediments. The formation of insoluble metal precipitates is one of many factors limiting the bioavailability of heavy metals to many aquatic ecosystems. Precipitation depends on the solubility product (Ks) of the metal involved, pH of the wetland and concentration of metal ions and relevant anions (Brady and Weil, 2002).
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
51
Co-precipitation is an adsorptive phenomenon also frequent in wetland sediments. Heavy metals commonly co-precipitate with secondary minerals. Copper, nickel, manganese, and other metals are co-precipitated in Fe oxides and cobalt, iron and nickel are co-precipitated in manganese oxides (Stumm and Morgan, 1981). In addition arsenic and zinc were reported to be retained on iron plaques at the surface of plant roots (Otte et al., 1995). Oxiferric hydroxide surfaces are positively charged under acidic pH conditions and negatively charged under alkaline pH conditions. Thus, adsorption and removal of oxyanions such as arsenic, antimony and selenium, through iron co-precipitation, is favored under acidic pH conditions (Brix, 1993). Alkaline conditions are favorable for co-precipitation of cationic metals such as copper, zinc, nickel and cadmium. Thus metals may become associated with iron and manganese oxides as a result of co-precipitation and adsorption phenomena (Stumm and Morgan, 1981). The process is presumed not to be very important in long-term removal and retention of metals because iron and manganese oxides, being redox sensitive, many redissolve following changes in oxygen concentration (Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). In addition to oxides, hydroxides and oxihydroxides resulting from hydrolysis, other typical insoluble metal compounds include carbonates and sulfides. Conditions exist for precipitation of heavy metal carbonates when the bicarbonate concentration in water is high. Carbonate formation can take place when bacterial production of bicarbonate alkalinity in wetland sediments is substantial (ITRC, 2003). Carbonate precipitation is especially effective for the removal of lead and nickel (Lin, 1995), but Sobolewski (1999) some authors reports significant quantities of copper and manganese carbonates accumulated in some natural wetlands. Wetlands with appropriate substrate may promote the growth of sulfate reducing bacteria in anaerobic conditions. These bacteria will generate hydrogen sulfide which reacts with most heavy metals leading to formation of highly insoluble metal sulfides (Stumm and Morgan, 1981). These provide for long-term metal removal, remaining permanently in wetland sediments as long as they are not re-oxidized (Sobolewski, 1999). Metals such as copper, lead, zinc, cadmium, and arsenic may form highly insoluble sulfides in contact with low concentration of H2S (ITRC, 2003). Field results suggest that upon start up of a constructed wetland, the adsorption of dissolved metals onto organic sites in the substrate material will be an important process but over time sulfide precipitation becomes the dominant process for metal removal (Machemer and Wildeman, 1992).
4.5.3. Biological Removal Processes Biological removal is perhaps the most important pathway for heavy metal removal in the wetlands where plant uptake plays probably the most widely recognized role. While sediments of wetlands form primary sinks for heavy metals (Gray et al., 2000), macrophytes may absorb heavy metals through roots and also shoots. It has been proposed that the processes used by plants are not necessarily the same for different species and for different metals. Submerged rooted plants may have high potential for the metals phytoextraction from sediments as well as water, while floating plants can extract metals only from water (Sriyaraj and Shutes, 2001). Among such processes can be mentioned: sorption by roots (a combination of physical and chemical processes such as chelation, ion exchange and chemical precipitation), and the biological processes including
52
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
translocation to the aerial part and precipitation induced by root exudates or by microorganisms. The rate of metal removal by plants varies widely, depending on plant growth rate and concentration of the heavy metals in plant tissue. The rate of metal uptake per unit area of the wetland is often much higher for herbaceous plants, or macrophytes such as duckweed (Lemna minor) (Zayed et al., 1998), salix (Stoltz and Greger, 2002), cattail (Typha latifolia) and common reed (Phragmites australis) (Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). Some of these species can tolerate high concentrations of several metals in their body mass without showing negative effects on the growth (Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). There are also some examples in the literature indicating that some species may have the ability to accumulate only specific heavy metals, e.g. the Spirodela polyrhiza for Zn (Markert, 1993). Constructed wetlands with well grown Cyperus alternifolius and Vallarsia exaltata have been reported to be an effective tool in phytoremediation of cadmium, copper, manganese, zinc and lead (Cheng et al., 2002). Microorganisms also provide a measurable amount of heavy metal uptake and storage; it is their metabolic processes that play the most significant role in removal of heavy metals (Ledin and Pedersen, 1996; Russell et al., 2003; Hallberg and Johnson, 2005; Sheoran and Sheoran, 2006). Reduction of metals to non-mobile forms by microbial activity in wetlands has been reported by Sobolewski (1999). Metals like chromium and uranium become immobilized when reduced through processes biologically catalyzed by microorganisms (Fude et al., 1994). In table 9 are presented illustrative results found in the literature concerning the removal efficiencies for several heavy metals obtained in different constructed wetlands systems. Table 9. Heavy metals removal efficiencies in different types of CWS Pollutant
Type of CWS
Reduction rate
References
Lead
CWS (small-scale plot)
≥ 90%
(Liu et al., 2007)
HSSF
≥ 70%
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
FWS
67 %
(Maine et al., 2006)
FWS
48 %
(Maine et al., 2007)
Grenhouse experiment
> 43 %
(Hadad et al., 2007)
HSSF
59 %
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
HSSF
49 %
(Lesage et al., 2007)
VSSF
≥ 80%
(Lee and Scholz, 2007)
HSSF
79 %
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
VSSF
≥ 95 %
(Lee and Scholz, 2007)
Iron
FWS
95 %
(Maine et al., 2006)
Aluminum
HSSF
93%
(Lesage et al., 2007)
Nickel
Copper
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
53
Pollutant
Type of CWS
Reduction rate
References
Chromium
FWS
58 %
(Maine et al., 2007)
FWS
86 %
(Maine et al., 2006)
Grenhouse experiment
100%
(Hadad et al., 2007)
HSSF
52%
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
CWS (small-scale plot)
≥ 90%
(Liu et al., 2007)
Grenhouse experiment
≥ 35%
(Hadad et al., 2007)
HSSF
86 %
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
CWS (small-scale plot)
≥ 90%
(Liu et al., 2007)
HSSF
24 %
(Mantovi et al., 2003)
Zinc
Cadmium
Removal efficiencies reported in CWS studies present some variation, from quite low values (~ 25%) to nearly complete removal of some metals. In general, however, the efficiencies are high (> 70%) but these will depend, as usual, on varied factors such as the influent metal loads, the type of vegetation used, the CWS type and on environmental conditions. Obviously, better removals will be achieved when the systems are specifically designed and optimized to solve well-defined metal contamination problems such as mine drainage, where well-known metal accumulator plants will be used preferably, in comparison with systems designed for broader treatment targets where metals are only possibly one among several types of pollutants to remove from wastewaters. As elemental substances, metal cations are naturally non-biodegradable and, for their permanent elimination from the system, the portion of metals removed by plant uptake will require a periodic plant harvesting. For CWS designed to treat high loads of metal inputs, the harvested plant biomass should afterwards be disposed as hazardous waste and receive appropriate treatment.
4.6. Organic Xenobiotics Removal Organic xenobiotics include a large range of synthetic organic compounds, such as phthalates, polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), dioxins, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), pesticides, sulfonated azo dyes, alkylphenols, bisphenols and pharmaceuticals and personal care products (PPCPs) (Wu, 1999; Mason, 2002; Fent et al., 2006). Several of these substances have been released in increasing amounts in the environment since decades, and, due to the low degradation rate of many of these compounds, a significant increase of their background concentrations has been observed in the different environmental compartments (Tyler et al., 1998; Skakkebaeck et al., 2000). A growing environmental concern has been emerging in recent years, because of the high toxicity and high persistence of most of these substances in the environment and in biological systems. Even though they occur only at very low concentrations in the environment, and their threats to aquatic life and public health are still not completely understood, nevertheless, sub-lethal effects of these compounds over long-term exposure may cause significant damage to aquatic life, particularly considering that some of these compounds may cause significant
54
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
endocrine disruption, impair reproduction functions of animals or even be carcinogenic, mutagenic or teratogenic (Wu, 1999; Mason, 2002). Furthermore, the high lipophilicity of many of these xenobiotics greatly enhances their biomagnification, thereby posing potential health hazards on predators at higher trophic levels (including human beings). The major ecological concern of xenobiotics is their ability to impair reproductive functions and subsequently threaten survival of the species. In fact, there is growing evidence from laboratory and field studies showing that exposure to trace amounts (µg/L – ng/L level) of certain xenobiotic organic compounds (e.g. halogenated hydrocarbons, PCBs, DDT, TBT) may cause reduced gonad development, disruption of normal metabolism of sex hormones (including gonadotropins), arrest of sperm maturation and block a variety of “oestrogen-like” effects on female reproductive systems in fish, birds, reptiles and mammals. This in turn, may lead to reproductive dysfunction such as delayed sex maturity, reduced fertility and hatch rate, depression in secondary sexual characteristics, alternation of sex behavior and viability of offspring (Wu, 1999). Due to long environmental and biological half lives, recovery from the effects of many xenobiotic compounds is expected to be slow. Indeed, it has been shown that some 15 years were required to remove the negative effects of DDT on reproduction of the white tail eagles in the Baltics, and another 10 years for the population to recover (HELCOM, 1996). Furthermore, despite a decrease in environmental concentrations, the adverse effects may remain in the ecosystem for a much longer period. In the Baltics, DDE decline to 10% of the original levels in 1984, but increased again afterwards, and the egg shells of fish eating birds, which had begun to return to normal, have recently become thinner again. Thus, the downward trend was halted after the ban, and may be due to the recycling of persistent chemicals in sediment (HELCOM, 1996). A variety of sources may be the origin for the presence of organic xenobiotics in water bodies. A number of xenobiotics classes (phthalates, pesticides, PCBs and bisphenols) are industrial products, used worldwide in several applications and are therefore ubiquitous pollutants (Safe, 1994; Stales et al., 1997; Mason, 2002). Other kinds of compounds (dioxins and PAHs) are not commercial products, but are formed as by-products of various industrial and combustion processes; they are transported from atmosphere to soil and water bodies by the atmospheric runoff or deposited on the soil during the dry period and then go through the water cycle by land runoff (Birkett and Lester, 2003). Several studies have shown that a vast range of these xenobiotics are present in the effluents from domestic and industrial conventional wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) (Birkett and Lester, 2003) which indicates that they resist removal by conventional wastewater treatment processes and may persist in the environment even after going through WWTPs. These are designed to deal with bulk substances that arrive regularly in large quantities (TSS, organic matter and nutrients) and many of these organic xenobiotics show a different chemical behavior for which the conventional processes are not well-suited. The different studies show that the WWTPs removal rates vary according to compound nature, WWTPs overall performance, and environmental conditions. This is also of potential concern about treated wastewater reuse for non industrial applications, such as irrigation of crops and aquaculture, since these pollutants may become a source of contamination of the food chain.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
55
4.6.1. Removal Processes in CWS Organic xenobiotics removal by CWS involves several interdependent processes which may be classified as abiotic (physical or chemical) or biotic (microbial or phytological). The primary abiotic and biotic processes that participate in removing organic xenobiotics from contaminated water in a CWS are described in table 10 (Evans and Furlong, 2003; Pilon-Smits, 2005). Table 10. Abiotic and biotic processes involved in xenobiotics removal in CWS Processes
Description
Sorption
Including adsorption and absorption, the chemical processes occurring at the surfaces of plants and substrate that result in a short-term retention or long-term immobilization of xenobiotics The chemical breakdown of organics by the action of water, a process which frequently is pH-dependent Degradation/oxidation of organic xenobiotics by the action of sunlight Modification, which sometimes may be quite substantial, of the xenobiotics due to the action of oxidizing (frequently dissolved oxygen) or reducing agents. Sometimes a redox reaction is a first step leading to removal by other processes, such as precipitation or volatilization. Redox reactions are also frequently brought about by biotic agents such as bacteria, or enzymatically catalyzed Many organic compounds have low water solubility and, especially those exhibiting acid-base properties, may convert into insoluble forms by pH changes Removal of particulate matter and suspended solids Release of some organic xenobiotics, as vapors, which occurs when these compounds have significant vapor pressures
Abiotic
Hydrolysis Photodegradation/ oxidation Oxidation/reduction
Precipitation
Settling and sedimentation Volatilization
Biotic Aerobic/anaerobic biodegradation Phytodegradation
Rhizodegradation Phytovolatilization/ evapotranspiration
Metabolic processes of microorganisms, which play a significant role in organic xenobiotics removal in CWS Breakdown of organic xenobiotic, either internally, having first been taken up by the plants, or externally, using enzymes excreted by them Plants provide root exudates that enhance microbial degradation of some organic xenobiotics Uptake and transpiration of volatile organic xenobiotics through the leaves
The contribution of each process to the overall efficiency of the system will be very dependent on a wide variety of factors relative not only to each CWS component characteristics but also to the properties of the organic xenobiotics, the characteristics of the wastewater and the environmental conditions.
56
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
4.6.1.1. Factors Affecting Organic Xenobiotics Removal Efficiency in a CWS The degree to which each process will contribute to the overall removal of the organic xenobiotics from contaminated waters in CWS is in turn dependent on the physico-chemical properties of these compounds (e.g., water solubility, sorptive affinity), characteristics of the substrate (e.g., pH, organic matter content, redox status), the plants species, effluent characteristics (e.g., pH, dissolved organic matter, electrolyte composition) as well as other environmental conditions (e.g., temperature, moisture). Some of the most important organic xenobiotics properties that affect their behavior and removal in CWS are its molecular structure, polarity, ionization constant (pKa), water solubility, sorption coefficient (Kd), octanol-water partition coefficient (Kow), volatility and chemical stability. The texture of a soil or substrate is an extremely important characteristic in the sorption process. If the substrate is made up of mostly clay and organic matter a significant amount of sorption will take place. Clay, especially intermixed with organic particles, by far adsorbs the most out of the main types of texture (e.g. silt and sand) because of its small particle size, high surface area and high surface charge. The content in organic matter also has a strong influence in the sorptive properties of the mineral media, mainly due to the presence of humic acids which form a large portion of their composition (Brady and Weil, 2002). These huge organic molecules are characterized by hydrophobic regions suitable for the adsorption of non-polar or weakly polar hydrophobic xenobiotics. However, they also contain numerous chemically active functional groups some of which confer or enrich the ion exchange properties, both cationic and anionic, and surface charge to the substrate which makes it also suitable for the adsorption of polar compounds (Brady and Weil, 2002). The sorption of polar or ionic xenobiotics is also very significant on some silicate clay minerals having substantial surface charge and ion exchange properties. In these materials the pH-changes can affect the sorption processes due to impacts on the pHdependent ion exchange capacities of these variable charge components (humic organic matter included). Some of the wastewater characteristics which will strongly influence how the organic xenobiotics will distribute between the aqueous medium and the matrix include the dissolved organic matter (DOM) content, the wastewater’s pH and its electrolyte composition. The amount and composition of the DOM may have an important influence on the compound’s solubility, and conversely on its sorption by the matrix. DOM may form complexes with the xenobiotic and enhance to its water affinity or it can compete for sorption sites in the substrate’s surface (Muller et al., 2007). In the case of organic xenobiotics with acid-base properties, the pH of the wastewater will determine the form in which they will be present in solution (either ionic or neutral) which, in turn, will affect its water solubility and sorptive affinity for the substrate. The importance of the wastewater’s pH is not restricted to the influence it has on the protonation state of the organic xenobiotics but it will also affect the surface charge of the substrate and, thus, influence the electrostatics-based sorption of ionic forms of the compounds. The presence in the wastewater of certain inorganic ions may introduce additional enhancement or disfavor of the organic xenobiotics sorption onto the matrix. Certain inorganic ions such as phosphate will frequently compete for ion exchange sorption sites in the mineral matrix. On the other hand, complexation phenomena can either contribute, in
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
57
some cases, to increase the solubility of some xenobiotics or, in other cases, to facilitate binding of the compounds to a mineral surface.
4.6.1.2. Organic Xenobiotics Removal by the Substrate Many phenomena relevant for organic xenobiotics removal occur within the substrate compartment or is influenced by the media characteristics. However, only in sorption processes does the substrate play an actually active role. Latest research on CW systems has been focusing on its ability for removing xenobiotic compounds like which are, in general, not very efficiently removed in the conventional treatment processes of the wastewater treatment plants (Moore et al., 2000; Schulz and Peall, 2001; Hannink et al., 2002; Cheng et al., 2002; Stearman et al., 2003; Haberl et al., 2003; Schulz, 2004; Matamoros et al., 2007). However, the media used have been mainly gravel, sand or local soils (Schulz and Peall, 2001; Stearman et al., 2003; Matamoros et al., 2007) and little importance has been given to the selection of more appropriate materials which can enhance the removal of this type of compounds by sorption. Nevertheless, some materials like LECA, which is being increasingly used as substrate in CWs have already been tested with success for its sorption capacity of some organic xenobiotics like MCPA, clofibric acid, ibuprofen and carbamazepine (Dordio et al., 2007; Dordio et al., 2008a). Clay minerals and organic matter are generally identified as the two most important solid matrix constituents that confer the xenobiotics retention properties to the substrate. However, substantially different sorption mechanisms are responsible for the sorption of non-polar and polar/ionic xenobiotics. 4.6.1.3. Organic xenobiotics removal by the microorganisms Biological removal of organic pollutants in a CWS depends on their bioavailability, which depends on their chemical properties, the CWS physico-chemical characteristics and the environmental conditions (Pilon-Smits, 2005; Collins et al., 2006). Microorganisms usually play an important role in the removal mechanisms of some organic xenobiotics in the CWS The degradation rate of organic xenobiotic and the extent of microbial growth during degradation is highly influenced by the xenobiotic chemical structure (Dua et al., 2002). Structurally simple compounds with high water solubility and low adsorptivity are usually more similar to the naturally occurring substances which are usually used as energy sources by the microorganisms and are easily degraded. In contrast, xenobiotics with chemical structures very different from the naturally occurring compounds are often degraded slowly since microorganisms do not possess suitable degrading genes. In these cases degradation by non-specific enzymes may still occur but at a slow rate by nonspecific reactions which do not support microbial growth (co-metabolism) (Seffernick and Wackett, 2001). Microbial xenobiotic degradation is also strongly influenced by the support medium where the microorganisms are. Temperature, pH, oxygen, presence of toxic substances and nutrients available within the CWS are expected to play a very important role in the removal efficiency. Microorganisms with the ability to degrade a wide variety of compounds, like benzene, phenol, naphthalene, atrazine, nitroaromatics, biphenyls, polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) and chlorobenzoates, have been isolated and characterized (Dua et al., 2002). Although
58
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
simple aromatic compounds are biodegradable by a variety of degradative pathways, their halogenated counterparts are more resistant to bacterial attacks and often necessitate the evolution of novel pathways (Dua et al., 2002). Among the halogenated compounds, the chlorinated compounds are the most extensively studied (Dua et al., 2002). The presence of chlorine atoms on the aromatic nucleus is known to greatly retard the rate of degradation. Most of the information available on the biodegradation of chlorinated compounds is on oxidative degradation, since aerobic culture techniques are relatively simple, compared with anaerobic culture methods. Also, aerobic processes are considered the most efficient and generally applicable (Dua et al., 2002). Aerobic degradation is dependent on the presence of molecular oxygen and is catalyzed by enzymes that have evolved for the catabolism of natural substrates and exhibit low specificities.
4.6.1.4. Organic Xenobiotics Removal by the Plants Plants have an important role in the biotic processes of organics removal in CWS, involving numerous biological processes of which many details still remain to be known or understood. Depending on the pollutant properties, organics may be degraded in the roots zone through the plant’s stimulation of microbial activity or by direct uptake by the plant, followed by degradation, sequestration or volatilization (Evans and Furlong, 2003; PilonSmits, 2005). Plants action in pollutant removal takes different names depending on where the processes predominantly take place. If the organic pollutants are degraded by the microorganisms within the plants’ rhizosphere (and under its influence) the process is called phytostimulation or rhizodegradation. If the plants degrade the organic pollutants directly within their tissues via their own enzymatic activities, then the process is called phytodegradation; other pollutants can leave the plant in a volatile form, and this is called phytovolatilization (Evans and Furlong, 2003; Pilon-Smits, 2005). Many organic pollutants can be readily taken up by plants but, as consequence of many of them being xenobiotic, there are no specific transporters for these compounds in plant membranes. Therefore, organic xenobiotic move into and within plant tissues via diffusion (passive uptake) through cell walls and membranes (Dietz and Schnoor, 2001; Pilon-Smits, 2005). The flux is driven by the water potential gradient created throughout the plant during transpiration, which depends on the plants characteristics and the CWS environmental conditions. Translocation of the compounds is highly dependent on their water solubility and hydrophobicity. There may exist an optimal hydrophobicity that allows the organic compound to bind to the lipid bilayer of the membrane but not too strongly so that transport can still be facilitated. Direct uptake is usually an efficient removal mechanism for moderately hydrophobic organic chemicals (log Kow = 0.5 – 3). These include most chlorinated solvents, BTEX (benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylene), many pesticides, and short-chain aliphatic chemicals. Hydrophobic chemicals (log Kow > 3) are bound so strongly to the surface of roots and soils that they cannot be translocated easily within the plant, and chemicals that are quite water soluble (log Kow < 0.5) are not sufficiently sorbed to roots nor actively transported through plant membranes (Dietz and Schnoor, 2001; Pilon-Smits, 2005). Hydrophobic chemicals (log Kow > 3) are candidates for phytostabilization and/or rhizosphere bioremediation by virtue of their long residence times in the root zone (Dietz and Schnoor, 2001; Pilon-Smits, 2005).
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
59
Organic compounds which are sorbed to roots can be translocated to other plant tissues and, subsequently, they may be volatilized, they may undergo partial/complete degradation, or they may be transformed to less toxic, especially less phytotoxic, compounds and bound in plant tissues. In general, most organics appear to undergo some degree of transformation in plant cells before being sequestered in vacuoles or bound to insoluble cellular structures such as lignin. Metabolism of pesticides was extensively studied many years ago. More recently, the metabolism of nonagricultural xenobiotics such as trichloroethylene (TCE), TNT, glyceroltrinitrate (GTN), PAHs, PCBs and other chlorinated compounds has also been studied. It was shown that most of these compounds are metabolized but only a few chemicals appear to be fully mineralized. Some plant metabolites of pollutants may be more toxic than the original compounds, making plants less attractive compared with bacteria, which totally degrade organic pollutants. In the rhizosphere take place important physiological and biochemical processes involved in the removal of contaminants which are induced by the interaction between plants, microorganisms and the solid matrix. Plants sustain large microbial populations in the rhizosphere by secreting a variety of products (exudates, mucigels, dead cell material, etc), which is known as rhizodeposition (Stottmeister et al., 2003). Consequently, favorable plant characteristics for phytoremediation are large and dense root systems which also have high levels of degrading enzymes. The chemical composition of the exudates is very diverse and varies with the plant species, but they normally include sugars, organic acids and vitamins. It has been shown that this availability of nutrient in the immediate proximity of the roots makes the microbial population much larger in the rhizosphere than in the bulk soil, and that these larger populations increase the degradation of organic compounds (Yu et al., 2003; Sun et al., 2004). Classes of organic compounds that are more rapidly degraded in the rhizosphere than in bulk soil include polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), total petroleum hydrocarbons, chlorinated pesticides as well as other chlorinated compounds like polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), explosives such as TNT and RDX, organophosphate insecticides, and surfactants. One of the most important characteristics of the macrophyte plants is their ability to supply their root system with oxygen from the atmosphere. The oxygen is released mainly around the root tips promoting detoxification of harmful organic pollutants by oxidation. While these oxidative reactions take place in the immediate surroundings of the plants roots, anaerobic reactions are taking place just a few microns away (Sundaravadivel and Vigneswaran, 2001). The oxidative protective film formed on the root surface protects these sensitive areas from being damaged by toxic wastewater components in the anoxic, usually extremely reduced, rhizosphere (Stottmeister et al., 2003). For the purpose of phytoremediation, plant species have to be selected based on the criteria of their tolerance to the pollutants toxicity and their capacity to lower the pollutants concentration in water through the variety of the processes which have been described above. Aquatic macrophytes seem to be especially resistant to a great variety of these substances in concentrations normally encountered in typical wastewater compositions. In addition, in numerous studies did these plant species exhibit the capability to reduce the concentrations of various xenobiotics in water. For example, the uptake of explosives such as RDX and TNT from the environment has been observed in several macrophytes (Typha spp., Carex spp., Scirpus spp., Myriophyllum aquaticum, Phalaris spp.) in numerous studies (Best et al., 1997; Best et al., 1999). Typha spp. and Phragmites spp. are also known to uptake petroleum
60
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
hydrocarbons (Haberl et al., 2003) and extensive studies have been conducted on pesticides uptake (Dordio et al., 2008b).
4.6.1.5. CWS Developed for Organic Xenobiotics Removal Many constructed wetlands applications have been consisting of domestic wastewater treatment where the BOD and COD parameters have been used as a cumulative measure of the amounts of organic compounds. However, a more specialized use for the removal of specific organic compounds or classes of compounds has been developing as a growing type of CWS applications. A significant experience already exists with wastewater from the petroleum industry, food processing industry, pesticide contaminated agricultural runoff, landfill leachates, and waters containing surfactants, solvents, and mineral oils. Specific compounds which have received successful treatment in CWS include a range of petroleum hydrocarbons, among which are BTEX and PAHs, organic solvents (in particular the more problematic chlorinated compounds), explosives such as TNT and RDX, PCBs and textile dyes. In table 11, an overview of recently published studies using fully assembled CWS serves to show the vitality and diversity of work that is currently being done in this field. Table 11. Several classes of organic xenobiotics removal in CWS Organic xenobiotic
Type of CW
Vegetation
References
VSSF FWS VSSF HSSF Hybrid system FWS
(Eke and Scholz, 2008) (Haberl et al., 2003) (Bedessem et al., 2007) (Giraud et al., 2001) (Machate et al., 1997) (Gessner et al., 2005)
VSSF (pilotscale)
Phragmites australis Typha latifolia Emergent plants Phragmites australis Typha spp., Scirpus lacustris Typha latifolia, Schoenoplectus tabernaemontani Salix spp. , Scirpus spp., Juncus spp., Phragmites australis
Chlorinated solvents Monochlorobenzene
HSSF
Phragmites australis
TCE and PCE
VSSF
TCE
Wetland microcosms
Common fen plants, wintertolerant sedges and rushes Populus deltoides, Typha latifolia
Petroleum hydrocarbons/ PAHs Benzene BTEX PAHs Petroleum hydrocarbons
Explosives RDX TNT
Pesticides Alachlor
(Haberl et al., 2003)
(Braeckevelt et al., 2007) (Amon et al., 2007) (Bankston et al., 2002)
SSF mesocosms FWS HSSF (pilotscale)
Typha laxmanil Submergent and emergent plants Phragmites australis
(Low et al., 2008) (Best et al., 2001) (Haberl et al., 2003)
SSF
Phragmites australis
(Matamoros et al., 2007)
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
61
Organic xenobiotic
Type of CW
Vegetation
References
Atrazine
CW cells CW mesocosms VSSF
(Runes et al., 2003) (Moore et al., 2000) (McKinlay and Kasperek, 1999)
Azinphos-methyl
CW
Endosulfan
Flow-trough wetlands CW
Typha latifolia Primarily Juncus spp. Schoenoplectus lacustris, Typha latifolia, Iris pseudacorus and Phragmites australis Typha capensis, Juncus kraussii, and Cyperus dives Typha capensis, Juncus kraussii and Cyperus dives Sparganium erectum, Phragmites australis, Phalaris arundinacea, Myostis scorpioides, Urtica dioica Phragmites australis
Mecoprop
SSF
(Schulz et al., 2003) (Schulz and Peall, 2001) (Braskerud and Haarstad, 2003)
(Matamoros et al., 2007) (Moore et al., 2006)
Methyl parathion
CW mesocosms
Simazine Others Acid orange 7 (AO7) dye Benzoic acid PCBs Several organic solvents Surfactants
CW cells
Juncus effusus and Leersia oryzoides Scirpus validus
VSSF
Phragmites australis
(Davies et al., 2005)
SSF FWS SSF Hybrid system
Scirpus validus Typha latifolia Juncus effusus, Carex lurida, Iris pseudocarus, Pondeteric cordata Phragmites australis
SSF
Zantedeschia aethiopica
(Zachritz et al., 1996) (Haberl et al., 2003) (Grove and Stein, 2005) (Bulc and Ojstrsek, 2008) (Belmont and Metcalfe, 2003)
(Stearman et al., 2003)
The case studies for treatment of waters contaminated with special organic compounds display a variety of applications for constructed wetlands. The reported removal efficiencies of organic xenobiotics show in many cases surprisingly good results, with values above 70% being frequently achieved in these studies. However, very little is commonly known about the exact pathways of the xenobiotics removal. Given the diversity of chemical characteristics of these compounds, which despite being classified under a common designation of xenobiotics are in fact formed by widely unrelated families of chemical substances, it is of no surprise that several very different mechanisms are responsible for removal of different xenobiotic. A comprehensive description of xenobiotic removal in CWS is therefore not an easy task to accomplish and these systems are still largely operated as a “black box”. Although much of the design of CWS in the past has been done with little knowledge of the roles played by each component and how its function could be optimized, treating the system primarily as a black box, nowadays the study base that has been accumulating is beginning to be applied. We now can see a much greater variety of plant species, matrix materials and wetlands designs being introduced. The goals of the target contaminants to remove in CWS are also becoming progressively more ambitious.
62
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
5. NEW TRENDS IN CONSTRUCTED WETLANDS SYSTEMS APPLICATIONS In the past, CWS have been used mainly as wastewater treatment alternatives or complementary to the conventional treatment for domestic wastewaters of small communities. Thus, CWS have been mostly applied in the reduction of TSS, organic matter, excess of nutrients and faecal microorganisms. This is somewhat overlapping with the design goals of WWTPs, but with the benefits of low cost and low maintenance which are characteristic of CWS. More recently, CWS applications to deal with more specific types of pollution (such as that caused by xenobiotics, as described in the previous section) have been meeting a larger interest and have been the subject of an increasing number of studies. CWS have been proving to be efficient and cost-effective solutions for the removal of some pollutants, where the use of conventional wastewater treatment processes does not satisfactorily solve the problem and a resort to more advanced treatments are too costly to become viable alternatives on a larger scale. Among the several types of organic xenobiotics, pharmaceuticals have been recently attracting much attention of the international scientific community and emerging as a new important class of environmental contaminants. Compounds used in human and veterinary medicine are being continuously introduced in the environment, mainly due to improper disposal of unused or expired drugs, and through metabolic excretion. Some of these pharmaceutical residues are discharged directly in the environment without going through appropriate treatment, but even those receiving appropriate disposal in WWTPs in many cases are not effectively removed by the conventional wastewater treatment processes (Halling-Sørensen et al., 1998; Daughton and Ternes, 1999; Heberer, 2002; Fent et al., 2006). In spite of being contaminants of many water bodies for already quite a long time (Garrison et al., 1976; Hignite and Azarnoff, 1977), environmental issues related with pharmaceuticals contamination are only recently becoming subject of more intensive study (Daughton and Ternes, 1999; Petrovic et al., 2003; Fent et al., 2006; Kemper, 2008). The low concentrations of these compounds in the environment, which are typically at trace levels (ng/L to low μg/L), associated to the unavailability, until recently, of suitably sensitive methods of analysis for these low concentration ranges has been the main reason for the late interest on the environmental problems raised by these compounds. Over the latest years, in numerous monitoring studies, residues of lipid regulating drugs, analgesics and antiinflammatory drugs, antibiotics, hormones, chemotherapy agents, antidiabetics, neuroactive compounds and beta-blocking heart drugs have all been detected in wastewaters, surfacewaters and even groundwaters worldwide (Daughton and Ternes, 1999; Fent et al., 2006; Hernando et al., 2006). Despite the trace level concentrations of pharmaceutical residues, such low amounts can sometimes be large enough to induce toxic effects on organisms (Halling-Sørensen et al., 1998; Ferrari et al., 2003; Fent et al., 2006; Crane et al., 2006; Hernando et al., 2006). A major problem is caused by the very nature of some pharmaceuticals since these compounds are designed to have very specific modes of action and biological effects, and many are persistent in the body. Because of their physicochemical and biological properties, when released into environment, it may be possible for them to cause serious impacts on non-target
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
63
species, e.g., aquatic and terrestrial organisms. Concern has been mostly focused on antibiotics that may cause resistance among bacteria or steroids that can induce estrogenic effects on aquatic species (Halling-Sørensen et al., 1998; Fent et al., 2006). It was a surprise when in 2004, diclofenac, an analgesic and anti-inflammatory drug frequently detected in WWTPs effluents and water courses was found to be the culprit of the nearly extinction of some species of Asian vultures (Oaks et al., 2004). The metabolites and degradation byproducts of pharmaceuticals are also of concern, because many of them have a toxicity which in many cases is similar to or even higher than the parent compounds (Fent et al., 2006). Besides toxicity, the element of persistence is of particular importance when considering the environmental significance of pharmaceuticals. Unlike persistent organic pollutants like pesticides, many pharmaceuticals are not lipophilic, so they do not bioaccumulate in the environment. However, some of those are “pseudo persistent pollutants” due to their continuous introduction in the environment. While not persistent in terms of a long half-life, these chemicals are constantly entering the environment, resulting in long-term exposure for the aquatic ecosystem. Potential synergetic and chronic effects have been mostly overlooked in the past, but recent ecotoxicological studies indicate that pharmaceutical residues pose a major threat especially for the aquatic species due to the continuous life-long exposure to which they are subjected (Fent et al., 2006) . The possible development of antibiotic-resistant bacteria, the genotoxic effects of some drugs, and endocrine disruption by therapeutically administered synthetic and natural hormones have all been discussed (Halling-Sørensen et al., 1998; Daughton and Ternes, 1999; Fent et al., 2006), but very little is known about possible long-term subtle effects on non-target organisms. The foreseeable environmental consequences of high environmental loads of pharmaceuticals points out to the urgent need of finding ways to retain and remove these pollutants before they reach the waterbodies. Optimization of the WWTP processes has been tried by increasing sludge residence times, and some advanced technologies have been evaluated to decrease their discharge into water bodies, e.g. oxidative processes, activated carbon and membrane filtration (Andreozzi et al., 2002; Fent et al., 2006; Esplugas et al., 2007; Kim et al., 2007; Snyder et al., 2007). However, despite the sometimes high removal efficiencies attained, these processes are generally not cost-effective on a large scale (Fent et al., 2006) . Due to the recent emergence of this environmental problem, CWS have not yet been fully evaluated for the removal of pharmaceutical residues. While they are being used efficiently (as shown in the previous section) for removing several other types of organic xenobiotics (Williams, 2002; Hannink et al., 2002; Braskerud and Haarstad, 2003; Haberl et al., 2003), fewer studies exist on their use for pharmaceuticals depuration (Gross et al., 2004; Matamoros et al., 2005; Matamoros and Bayona, 2006; Matamoros et al., 2007; Dordio et al., 2008a; Matamoros et al., 2008b). Pharmaceutical substances span a wide range of chemical behaviors: a diversity of acidbase properties provide for both easily ionizable as well as neutral compounds; while some compounds are very water soluble and hydrophilic, others are significantly hydrophobic/lipophilic; some compounds are very stable to a wide range of redox conditions whereas others are readily oxidizable or reduced. Conversely, the effective mechanisms of pharmaceutical removal in a CWS are also varied. Easily bio-degradable pharmaceuticals are most effectively removed by the biotic components of a CWS. The action of the rhizostimulated microbial populations on one hand,
64
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
and uptake by plant on the other, are both possible mechanisms (as described in the previous section, only now acting on much lower concentration levels of pollutants which is per se a relevant issue for the system’s efficiency) that can be responsible for pharmaceuticals removal, depending on the compounds properties. An aspect to consider when designing a CWS for treatment of these types of substances and when selecting the type of biotic components is the assessment of the long-term tolerance to possible toxic effects which may be caused by pharmaceutical residues as well as other xenobiotics. Removal of more recalcitrant pharmaceuticals has also been observed in CWS (Gross et al., 2004; Matamoros et al., 2005; Matamoros and Bayona, 2006; Matamoros et al., 2008a; Matamoros et al., 2008b). Sorption by the substrate plays a major role in such cases. However, the characteristics of the substrate are crucial for the effectiveness of this process, and some materials do provide for substantial removal efficiencies (Dordio et al., 2007; Dordio et al., 2008a) whereas other do not (Matamoros et al., 2005; Matamoros et al., 2008a; Matamoros et al., 2008b). Therefore, a careful selection of the type of substrate which displays great affinity for the type of compounds to be removed by the CWS is an essential step in the system’s optimization and the achievement of acceptable efficiencies. Ultimately, the optimization of a CWS for the removal of more specific targets requires a basic knowledge of the processes involved in the pollutants removal and the interactions between the CWS components. New trends in CWS research are moving towards the study of such processes and interactions and focus on the selection and optimization of the components for more specific applications.
CONCLUSION Wetlands have long been known to have water depuration capabilities and, in fact, have been frequently used as wastewater discharge sites. However, in spite of these characteristics, such practice has led over the years to a substantial degradation of many of these ecosystems and in many countries the discharge of wastewaters in natural wetlands is no longer allowed. Furthermore, drainage of wetlands for agricultural purposes has also contributed to the decline in the quality of these regions. For the purpose of the restoration of some of these ecosystems or creation of habitats for wetlands wildlife, the construction of artificial wetlands has been carried out in many former natural wetlands areas. In addition, constructed wetlands have also been developed to imitate the functions provided by natural wetlands, in particular their wastewater treatment capabilities, which can also contribute to the preservation of natural wetlands and neighboring water bodies, and as well perform wastewater treatment in a more controlled and optimized environment to achieve better wastewater treatment efficiencies. Constructed treatment wetlands systems are a biotechnology for wastewater treatment that is becoming increasingly popular as an alternative to conventional treatments or integrated in conventional systems as a secondary or tertiary treatment step. Low cost and low maintenance are some of its most attractive characteristics along with the aesthetic and landscape enhancement qualities, although they do have the disadvantages of requiring substantially more land area occupation and showing a less reproducible behavior than conventional technologies.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
65
These systems are now becoming a mature technology for the removal of suspended solids, organic matter and nutrients. Focus is now moving into the removal of more specific and recalcitrant compounds for which the conventional treatment systems are not effective. CWS are nowadays being increasingly used for the cleanup of specific pollutant types such as organic xenobiotics and new challenges have been emerging such as the removal of pharmaceuticals and other micropollutants which present new problems to be solved. Often CWS have been looked at as a “black box” where only influent and effluent pollutants concentrations where measured and where no more in-depth investigations were run. To use CWS as an efficient response to these new challenges this “black-box” approach to CWS operation has to be abandoned and a thorough understanding of the variety of processes involved in pollutants removal in CWS as well as the way the CWS components interact is direly needed. This has been in fact an effort which has been increasingly undertaken in the most recent years in the area of CWS research and development, not only in field studies but also in numerous lab studies as well. Already a considerable base of knowledge exists about the CWS components and the removal processes for which they are responsible. Still, there is plenty of room for further research, as is the case of the most advanced genetic engineering technology applied both to the vegetation as to the microbial components, but also in the more traditional research subjects such as the advantages of polyculture vegetation or use of composite substrates. Additional areas to explore may be how the components may interact to provide synergetic enhancements for pollutants removal. In conclusion, the results obtained in the research currently being conducted in this area are mostly very positive and show the potential of this promising technology even for the type of wastewater contamination that the conventional systems have not been able to cope with. Naturally constructed treatment wetlands systems have their own shortcomings and these will not be the one-size-fits-all solution to every wastewater contamination problem but it can certainly be in some cases an alternative, with advantages, to conventional wastewater treatment (e.g., for the case of single-family or small community municipal wastewaters) and in other cases complimentary to such conventional treatment. Ultimately, the services provided by constructed wetlands may also contribute to a wider recognition of the value of natural wetlands and the role they play in the preservation of water quality in their surroundings.
REFERENCES Amon, J. P.; Agrawal, A.; Shelley, M. L.; Opperman, B. C.; Enright, M. P.; Clemmer, N. D.; Slusser, T.; Lach, J.; Sobolewski, T.; Gruner, W.; Entingh, A. C. Ecol. Eng. 2007, 30, 5166. Andreozzi, R.; Marotta, R.; Pinto, G.; Pollio, A. Water Res. 2002, 36, 2869-2877. Ansola, G.; González, J. M.; Cortijo, R.; de Luis, E. Ecol. Eng. 2003, 21, 43-52. Bankston, J. L.; Sola, D. L.; Komor, A. T.; Dwyer, D. F. Water Res. 2002, 36, 1539-1546. Barr, M. J.; Robinson, H. D. Waste Manage. Res. 1999, 17, 498-504. Bedessem, M. E.; Ferro, A. M.; Hiegel, T. Water Environ. Res. 2007, 79, 581-586. Belmont, M. A.; Metcalfe, C. D. Ecol. Eng. 2003, 21, 233-247.
66
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
Best, E. P. H.; Miller, J. L.; Larson, S. L. Water Sci. Technol. 2001, 44, 515-521. Best, E. P. H.; Sprecher, S. L.; Larson, S. L.; Fredrickson, H. L.; Bader, D. F. Chemosphere. 1999, 38, 3383-3396. Best, E. P. H.; Zappi, M. E.; Fredrickson, H. L.; Sprecher, S. L.; Larson, S. L.; Ochman, M. Ann. NY Acad. Sci. 1997, 829, 179-194. Birkett, J. W.; Lester, J. N. Endocrine Disruptors in Wastewater and Sludge Treatment Processes; CRC Press: Boca Raton, FL, USA, 2003. Brady, N. C.; Weil, R. R. The Nature and Properties of Soils; Prentice Hall: New Jersey, NJ, USA, 2002. Braeckevelt, M.; Rokadia, H.; Imfeld, G.; Stelzer, N.; Paschke, H.; Kuschk, P.; Kastner, M.; Richnow, H. H.; Weber, S. Environ. Pollut. 2007, 148, 428-437. Braskerud, B. C. Ecol. Eng. 2002, 18, 351-370. Braskerud, B. C.; Haarstad, K. Water Sci. Technol. 2003, 48, 267-274. Brix, H. In Constructed Wetlands for Water Quality Improvement; Moshiri, G. A.; Ed.; Lewis Publishers: Boca Raton, FL, USA, 1993, pp 9-22. Brix, H.; Arias, C. A.; del Bubba, M. Water Sci. Technol. 2001, 44, 47-54. Brodie, G. A.; Hammer, D. A.; Tomijanovich, D. A. In Constructed Wetlands for Wastewater Treatment; Hammer, D. A.; Ed.; Lewis Publishers: Chelsea, MI, USA, 1989. Brooks, A. S.; Rozenwald, M. N.; Geohring, L. D.; Lion, L. W.; Steenhuis, T. S. Ecol. Eng. 2000, 15, 121-132. Bulc, T. G.; Ojstrsek, A. J. Hazard. Mater. 2008, In Press, Corrected Proof. Burke, D. J.; Weis, J. S.; Weis, P. Estuar. Coast. Shelf Sci. 2000, 51, 153-159. Cameron, K.; Madramootoo, C.; Crolla, A.; Kinsley, C. Water Res. 2003, 37, 2803-2812. Carleton, J. N.; Grizzard, T. J.; Godrej, A. N.; Post, H. E. Water Res. 2001, 35, 1552-1562. Carty, A.; Scholz, M.; Heal, K.; Gouriveau, F.; Mustafa, A. Bioresour. Technol. In Press, Corrected Proof. Chen, H. M.; Zheng, C. R.; Tu, C.; Shen, Z. G. Chemosphere. 2000, 41, 229-234. Chen, T. Y.; Kao, C. M.; Yeh, T. Y.; Chien, H. Y.; Chao, A. C. Chemosphere. 2006, 64, 497502. Cheng, S. P.; Grosse, W.; Karrenbrock, F.; Thoennessen, M. Ecol. Eng. 2002, 18, 317-325. Collins, C.; Fryer, M.; Grosso, A. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2006, 40, 45-52. Cooper, P. J. Chart. Inst. Water Environ. Manage. 2001, 15, 79-85. Cooper, P. F.; Job, G. D.; Green, M. B.; Shutes, R. B. E. Reed Beds and Constructed Wetlands for Wastewater Treatment; WRc Publications: Medmenham, Marlow, UK, 1996. Coveney, M. F.; Stites, D. L.; Lowe, E. F.; Battoe, L. E.; Conrow, R. Ecol. Eng. 2002, 19, 141-159. Cowardin, L. M.; Golet, F. C. Vegetatio. 1995, 118, 139-152. Craft, C. B.; Richardson, C. J. Biogeochemistry. 1993, 22, 133-156. Crane, M.; Watts, C.; Boucard, T. Sci. Total Environ. 2006, 367, 23-41. Cronk, J. K. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 1996, 58, 97-114. D'Angelo, E. M.; Reddy, K. R. J. Environ. Qual. 1994, 23, 937-943. Daughton, C. G.; Ternes, T. A. Environ. Health Perspect. 1999, 107, 907-938. Davies, L. C.; Carias, C. C.; Novais, J. M.; Martins-Dias, S. Ecol. Eng. 2005, 25, 594-605. Debusk, T. A.; Laughlin, R. B.; Schwartz, L. N. Water Res. 1996, 30, 2707-2716. Dietz, A. C.; Schnoor, J. L. Environ. Health Perspect. 2001, 109, 163-168.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
67
Dordio, A. V.; Candeias, A. J. E.; Pinto, A. P.; Costa, C. T.; Carvalho, A. J. P. Ecol. Eng. 2008a, In Press, Corrected Proof. Dordio, A. V.; Carvalho, A. J. P.; Pinto, A. P.; Costa, C. T. In Pesticide Research Trends; Tennefy, A. B.; Ed.; Nova Science Publishers: Hauppauge, NY, USA, 2008b. Dordio, A. V.; Teimão, J.; Ramalho, I.; Carvalho, A. J. P.; Candeias, A. J. E. Sci. Total Environ. 2007, 380, 237-246. Dua, M.; Singh, A.; Sethunathan, N.; Johri, A. Appl. Microbiol. Biotechnol. 2002, 59, 143152. Dunbabin, J. S.; Bowmer, K. H. Sci. Total Environ. 1992, 111, 151-168. Eke, P. E.; Scholz, M. J. Chem. Technol. Biotechnol. 2008, 83, 55-63. Environmental Laboratory. Corps of Engineers Wetland Delineation Manual; Technical Report Y-87-1; US Army Engineer Waterways Experiment Station: Vicksburg, MS, USA, 1987. Esplugas, S.; Bila, D. M.; Krause, L. G.; Dezotti, M. J. Hazard. Mater. 2007, 149, 631-642. Evans, G. M.; Furlong, J. C. Environmental Biotechnology: Theory and Application; Wiley: Chichester, UK, 2003. Fent, K.; Weston, A. A.; Caminada, D. Aquat. Toxicol. 2006, 76, 122-159. Ferrari, B.; Paxéus, N.; Lo Giudice, R.; Pollio, A.; Garric, J. Ecotox. Environ. Safe. 2003, 55, 359-370. Fude, L.; Harris, B.; Urrutia, M. M.; Beveridge, T. J. Appl. Environ. Microbiol. 1994, 60, 1525-1531. García, M.; Soto, F.; González, J. M.; Bécares, E. Ecol. Eng. 2008, 32, 238-243. Garrison, A. W.; Pope, J. D.; Allen, F. R. In Identification and Analysis of Organic Pollutants in Water; Keith, L. H.; Ed.; Ann Arbor Science Publishers: Ann Arbor, MI, USA, 1976, pp 517-556. Gessner, T. P.; Kadlec, R. H.; Reaves, R. P. Ecol. Eng. 2005, 25, 457-469. Giraud, F.; Guiraud, P.; Kadri, M.; Blake, G.; Steiman, R. Water Res. 2001, 35, 4126-4136. Gómez Cerezo, R.; Suárez, M. L.; Vidal-Abarca, M. R. Ecol. Eng. 2001, 16, 501-517. Gray, S.; Kinross, J.; Read, P.; Marland, A. Water Res. 2000, 34, 2183-2190. Gross, B.; Montgomery-Brown, J.; Naumann, A.; Reinhard, M. Environ. Toxicol. Chem. 2004, 23, 2074-2083. Groudev, S. N.; Bratcova, S. G.; Komnitsas, K. Miner. Eng. 1999, 12, 261-270. Grove, J. K.; Stein, O. R. Water Res. 2005, 39, 4040-4050. Haberl, R.; Grego, S.; Langergraber, G.; Kadlec, R. H.; Cicalini, A. R.; Martins-Dias, S.; Novais, J. M.; Aubert, S.; Gerth, A.; Thomas, H.; Hebner, A. J. Soil Sediment. 2003, 3, 109-124. Hadad, H. R.; Maine, M. A.; Bonetto, C. A. Chemosphere. 2006, 63, 1744-1753. Hadad, H. R.; Maine, M. A.; Natale, G. S.; Bonetto, C. Ecol. Eng. 2007, 31, 122-131. Hallberg, K. B.; Johnson, D. B. Sci. Total Environ. 2005, 338, 115-124. Halling-Sørensen, B.; Nielsen, S. N.; Lanzky, P. F.; Ingerslev, F.; Lützhøft, H. C. H.; Jørgensen, S. E. Chemosphere. 1998, 36, 357-394. Halverson, N. V. Review of Constructed Subsurface Flow vs. Surface Flow Wetlands; WSRC-TR-2004-00509; Westinghouse Savannah River Company: Aiken, SC, USA, 2004. Hammer, D. A. Creating Freshwater Wetlands; CRC Press: Boca Raton, FL,USA, 1997.
68
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
Hammer, D. A.; Bastian, R. K. In Constructed Wetlands for Wastewater Treatment; Hammer, D. A.; Ed.; Lewis Publishers: Chelsea, MI, USA, 1989, pp 5-19. Hammer, D. A.; Pullin, B. P.; McCaskey, T. A.; Eason, J.; Payne, V. W. E. In Constructed Wetlands for Wastewater Treatment; Hammer, D. A.; Ed.; Lewis Publishers: Chelsea, MI, USA, 1989. Hannink, N. K.; Rosser, S. J.; Bruce, N. C. Crit. Rev. Plant Sci. 2002, 21, 511-538. Heberer, T. Toxicol. Lett. 2002, 131, 5-17. HELCOM. Baltic Sea Environment Proceedings No. 64B. Third Periodic Assessment on the State of the Marine Environment of the Baltic Sea, 1989-1993; Background Document.; Helsinki Commission, Baltic Marine Environment Protection Commission: Helsinki, Finland, 1996. Hench, K. R.; Bissonnette, G. K.; Sexstone, A. J.; Coleman, J. G.; Garbutt, K.; Skousen, J. G. Water Res. 2003, 37, 921-927. Hernando, M. D.; Mezcua, M.; Fernandez-Alba, A. R.; Barceló, D. Talanta. 2006, 69, 334342. Hignite, C.; Azarnoff, D. L. Life Sci. 1977, 20, 337-341. IETC-UNEP. Planning and Management of Lakes and Reservoirs: An Integrated Approach to Eutrophication; 1999. ITRC. Technical and regulatory guidance document for constructed treatment wetlands; The Interstate Technology and Regulatory Council Wetlands Team: New Jersey, NJ, USA, 2003. Johansson, L.; Gustafsson, J. P. Water Res. 2000, 34, 259-265. Kadlec, H. R.; Knight, R. L. Treatment Wetlands; Lewis Publishers: Boca Raton, FL, USA, 1996. Karathanasis, A. D.; Potter, C. L.; Coyne, M. S. Ecol. Eng. 2003, 20, 157-169. Kemper, N. Ecol. Indic. 2008, 8, 1-13. Kim, S. D.; Cho, J.; Kim, I. S.; Vanderford, B. J.; Snyder, S. A. Water Res. 2007, 41, 10131021. Kivaisi, A. K. Ecol. Eng. 2001, 16, 545-560. Kleeberg, A.; Schlungbaum, G. Hydrobiologia. 1993, 253, 263-274. Knight, R. L.; Payne, V. W. E.; Borer, R. E.; Clarke, R. A.; Pries, J. H. Ecol. Eng. 2000, 15, 41-55. Kohler, E. A.; Poole, V. L.; Reicher, Z. J.; Turco, R. F. Ecol. Eng. 2004, 23, 285-298. Kuehn, E.; Moore, J. A. Water Sci. Technol. 1995, 32, 241-250. Langergraber, G.; Haberl, R. Minerva Biotechnol. 2001, 13, 123-134. Ledin, M.; Pedersen, K. Earth-Sci. Rev. 1996, 41, 67-108. Lee, B. h.; Scholz, M. Ecol. Eng. 2007, 29, 87-95. Lesage, E.; Rousseau, D. P. L.; Meers, E.; Tack, F. M. G.; De Pauw, N. Sci. Total Environ. 2007, 380, 102-115. Lin, L. Y. In Encyclopedia of environmental biology; Nierenberg, W. A.; Ed.; Academic Press: San Diego, CA, USA, 1995; Vol. 3, pp 479-484. Liu, J.; Dong, Y.; Xu, H.; Wang, D.; Xu, J. J. Hazard. Mater. 2007, 147, 947-953. Livingston, E. H. In Constructed Wetlands for Wastewater Treatment; Hammer, D. A.; Ed.; Lewis Publishers: Chelsea, MI, USA, 1989, pp 253-264. Low, D.; Tan, K.; Anderson, T.; Cobb, G. P.; Liu, J.; Jackson, W. A. Ecol. Eng. 2008, 32, 7280.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
69
Machate, T.; Noll, H.; Behrens, H.; Kettrup, A. Water Res. 1997, 31, 554-560. Machemer, S. D.; Wildeman, T. R. J. Contam. Hydrol. 1992, 9, 115-131. Maine, M. A.; Suñe, N.; Hadad, H.; Sánchez, G.; Bonetto, C. Ecol. Eng. 2006, 26, 341-347. Maine, M. A.; Suñe, N.; Hadad, H.; Sánchez, G.; Bonetto, C. Chemosphere. 2007, 68, 11051113. Mantovi, P.; Marmiroli, M.; Maestri, E.; Tagliavini, S.; Piccinini, S.; Marmiroli, N. Bioresour. Technol. 2003, 88, 85-94. Markert, B. Plants as biomonitors: indicators for heavy metals in the terrestrial environment; VCH: Weinheim, Germany, 1993. Mashauri, D. A.; Mulungu, D. M. M.; Abdulhussein, B. S. Water Res. 2000, 34, 1135-1144. Mason, C. Biology of freshwater pollution; Pearson Education: Harlow, UK, 2002. Matamoros, V.; Bayona, J. M. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2006, 40, 5811-5816. Matamoros, V.; García, J.; Bayona, J. M. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2005, 39, 5449-5454. Matamoros, V.; Puigagut, J.; Garcia, J.; Bayona, J. M. Chemosphere. 2007, 69, 1374-1380. Matamoros, V.; Caselles-Osorio, A.; Garcia, J.; Bayona, J. M. Sci. Total Environ. 2008a, 394, 171-176. Matamoros, V.; García, J.; Bayona, J. M. Water Res. 2008b, 42, 653-660. McKinlay, R. G.; Kasperek, K. Water Res. 1999, 33, 505-511. Merlin, G.; Pajean, J. L.; Lissolo, T. Hydrobiologia. 2002, 469, 87-98. Metcalf; Eddy Wastewater engineering: treatment, disposal and reuse; McGraw Hill: New York, NY, USA, 1991. Meuleman, A. F. M.; van Logtestijn, R.; Rijs, G. B. J.; Verhoeven, J. T. A. Ecol. Eng. 2003, 20, 31-44. Mitra, S. Mercury in the ecosystem; Trans Tech Publications: Aedermannsdorf, Switzerland, 1986. Mitsch, W. J.; Gosselink J.G. Wetlands; John Wiley and Sons: New York, NY, USA, 2000. Moore, M. T.; Bennett, E. R.; Cooper, C. M.; Smith, S.; Farris, J. L.; Drouillard, K. G.; Schulz, R. Environ. Pollut. 2006, 142, 288-294. Moore, M. T.; Rodgers, J. H.; Cooper, C. M.; Smith, S. Environ. Pollut. 2000, 110, 393-399. Muller, K.; Magesan, G. N.; Bolan, N. S. Agric. Ecosyst. Environ. 2007, 120, 93-116. National Research Council Wetlands: Characteristics and Boundaries; National Academy Press: Washington, DC, USA, 1995. Neralla, S.; Weaver, R. W.; Lesikar, B. J.; Persyn, R. A. Bioresour. Technol. 2000, 75, 19-25. Nivala, J.; Hoos, M. B.; Cross, C.; Wallace, S.; Parkin, G. Sci. Total Environ. 2007, 380, 1927. Oaks, J. L.; Gilbert, M.; Virani, M. Z.; Watson, R. T.; Meteyer, C. U.; Rideout, B. A.; Shivaprasad, H. L.; Ahmed, S.; Chaudhry, M. J. I.; Arshad, M.; Mahmood, S.; Ali, A.; Khan, A. A. Nature. 2004, 427, 630-633. Oovel, M.; Tooming, A.; Mauring, T.; Mander, U. Ecol. Eng. 2007, 29, 17-26. Otte, M. L.; Kearns, C. C.; Doyle, M. O. Bull. Environ. Contam. Toxicol. 1995, 55, 154-161. Ottova, V.; Balcarova, J.; Vymazal, J. Water Sci. Technol. 1997, 35, 117-123. Perkins, J.; Hunter, C. Water Res. 2000, 34, 1941-1947. Petrovic, M.; Gonzalez, S.; Barceló, D. Trac-Trends Anal. Chem. 2003, 22, 685-696. Pilon-Smits, E. Annu. Rev. Plant Biol. 2005, 56, 15-39. Reddy, K. R.; D'Angelo, E. M. Water Sci. Technol. 1997, 35, 1-10. Richardson, C. J.; Marshall, P. E. Ecol. Monogr. 1986, 56, 279-302.
70
Ana Dordio, A. J. Palace Carvalho and Ana Paula Pinto
Rivera, F.; Warren, A.; Ramirez, E.; Decamp, O.; Bonilla, P.; Gallegos, E.; Calderon, A.; Sanchez, J. T. Water Sci. Technol. 1995, 32, 211-218. Runes, H. B.; Jenkins, J. J.; Moore, J. A.; Bottomley, P. J.; Wilson, B. D. Water Res. 2003, 37, 539-550. Russell, R. A.; Holden, P. J.; Wilde, K. L.; Neilan, B. A. Hydrometallurgy. 2003, 71, 227234. Safe, S. H. Crit. Rev. Toxicol. 1994, 24, 87-149. Scholes, L.; Shutes, R. B. E.; Revitt, D. M.; Forshaw, M.; Purchase, D. Sci. Total Environ. 1998, 214, 211-219. Schulz, R. J. Environ. Qual. 2004, 33, 419-448. Schulz, R.; Hahn, C.; Bennett, E. R.; Dabrowski, J. M.; Thiere, G.; Peall, S. K. C. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2003, 37, 2139-2144. Schulz, R.; Peall, S. K. C. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2001, 35, 422-426. Seffernick, J. L.; Wackett, L. P. Biochemistry. 2001, 40, 12747-12753. Seidel, K. In Ökologie, Morphologie und Entwicklung, ihre Stellung bei den Volkern und ihre wirtschaftliche Bedeutung; Sweizerbart'sche Verlgsbuchhandlung: Stuttgart, Germany, 1955, pp 37-52. Sheoran, A. S.; Sheoran, V. Miner. Eng. 2006, 19, 105-116. Skakkebaeck, N. E.; Leffers, H.; Rajpert-De Meyts, E.; Carlsen, E.; Grigor, K. M. Trends Endocrinol. Metab. 2000, 11, 291-293. Sleytr, K.; Tietz, A.; Langergraber, G.; Haberl, R. Sci. Total Environ. 2007, 380, 173-180. Snyder, S. A.; Adham, S.; Redding, A. M.; Cannon, F. S.; DeCarolis, J.; Oppenheimer, J.; Wert, E. C.; Yoon, Y. Desalination. 2007, 202, 156-181. Sobolewski, A. Int. J. Phytoremediat. 1999, 1, 19-51. Solano, M. L.; Soriano, P.; Ciria, M. P. Biosyst. Eng. 2004, 87, 109-118. Soto, F.; Garcia, M.; de Luis, E.; Bécares, E. Water Sci. Technol. 1999, 40, 241-247. Sriyaraj, K.; Shutes, R. B. E. Environ. Int. 2001, 26, 433-439. Stales, C. A.; Peterson, D. R.; Parkerton, T. F.; Adams, W. J. Chemosphere. 1997, 35, 667749. Stearman, G. K.; George, D. B.; Carlson, K.; Lansford, S. J. Environ. Qual. 2003, 32, 15481556. Steer, D.; Fraser, L.; Boddy, J.; Seibert, B. Ecol. Eng. 2002, 18, 429-440. Stottmeister, U.; Wiessner, A.; Kuschk, P.; Kappelmeyer, U.; Kastner, M.; Bederski, O.; Muller, R. A.; Moormann, H. Biotechnol. Adv. 2003, 22, 93-117. Stowell, R.; Ludwig, R.; Colt, J.; Tchobanoglous, G. J. Environ. Eng. -ASCE. 1981, 107, 919940. Stumm, W.; Morgan, J. J. Aquatic Chemistry: An Introduction Emphasizing Chemical Equilibra In Natural Waters; John Wiley and Sons: New York, NY, USA, 1981. Sun, H.; Xu, J.; Yang, S.; Liu, G.; Dai, S. Chemosphere. 2004, 54, 569-574. Sundaravadivel, M.; Vigneswaran, S. Crit. Rev. Environ. Sci. Technol. 2001, 31, 351-409. Tanner, C. C.; Clayton, J. S.; Upsdell, M. P. Water Res. 1995, 29, 17-26. Tanner, C. C.; Kadlec, R. H.; Gibbs, M. M.; Sukias, J. P. S.; Nguyen, M. L. Ecol. Eng. 2002, 18, 499-520. Tyler, C. R.; Jobling, S.; Sumpter, J. P. Crit. Rev. Toxicol. 1998, 28, 319-361.
Wetlands: Water “Living Filters”?
71
UNESCO. Convention on Wetlands of International Importance especially as Waterfowl Habitat; Ramsar, Iran, 1994. Available online at: http://www.ramsar.org/key_ conv_e.htm. USEPA. Constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment and wild life habitat: 17 Case Studies; EPA 832-R-93-005; Office of Research and Development: Cincinnati, OH, USA, 1993. USEPA. Constructed Wetlands Treatment of Municipal Wastewaters; EPA/625/R-99/010; Office of Research and Development: Cincinnati, OH, USA, 2000. USEPA; USDA-NRCS. A Handbook of Constructed Wetlands. Volume 1: General Considerations; USEPA Region III with USDA-NRCS: Washington, DC, USA, 1995. Vandecasteele, B.; Meers, E.; Vervaeke, P.; De Vos, B.; Quataert, P.; Tack, F. M. G. Chemosphere. 2005, 58, 995-1002. Vohla, C.; Poldvere, E.; Noorvee, A.; Kuusemets, V.; Mander, U. J. Environ. Sci. Health Part A-Toxic/Hazard. Subst. Environ. Eng. 2005, 40, 1251-1264. Vymazal, J. Water Sci. Technol. 1999, 40, 133-138. Vymazal, J. Ecol. Eng. 2005a, 25, 475-477. Vymazal, J. J. Environ. Sci. Health Part A-Toxic/Hazard. Subst. Environ. Eng. 2005b, 40, 1355-1367. Vymazal, J. Sci. Total Environ. 2007, 380, 48-65. Vymazal, J. In Constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment in Europe; Vymazal, J.; Brix, H.; Cooper, P. F.; Green, M. B.; Haberl, R.; Eds.; Backhuys Publishers: Leiden, The Netherlands, 1998, pp 1-15. Vymazal, J. Ecol. Eng. 2005c, 25, 478-490. Vymazal, J.; Brix, H.; Cooper, P. F.; Green, M. B.; Haberl, R. Constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment in Europe; Backhuys Publishers: Leiden, The Netherlands, 1998a. Vymazal, J.; Brix, H.; Cooper, P. F.; Haberl, R.; Perfler, R.; Laber, J. In Constructed wetlands for wastewater treatment in Europe; Vymazal, J.; Brix, H.; Cooper, P. F.; Green, M. B.; Haberl, R.; Eds.; Backhuys Publishers: Leiden, The Netherlands, 1998b, pp 17-66. Walker, D. J.; Hurl, S. Ecol. Eng. 2002, 18, 407-414. Wiebner, A.; Kappelmeyer, U.; Kuschk, P.; Kastner, M. Water Res. 2005, 39, 248-256. Williams, J. B. Crit. Rev. Plant Sci. 2002, 21, 607-635. Wood, A. In Constructed wetlands in water pollution control; Cooper, P. F.; Findlater, B. C.; Eds.; Pergamon Press: Oxford, UK, 1990. Woulds, C.; Ngwenya, B. T. Appl. Geochem. 2004, 19, 1773-1783. Wu, R. S. S. Mar. Pollut. Bull. 1999, 39, 11-22. Yu, Y. L.; Chen, Y. X.; Luo, Y. M.; Pan, X. D.; He, Y. F.; Wong, M. H. Chemosphere. 2003, 50, 771-774. Zachritz, W. H.; Lundie, L. L.; Wang, H. Ecol. Eng. 1996, 7, 105-116.
In: Wetlands: Ecology, Conservation and Restoration ISBN: 978-1-60456-995-7 Editor: Raymundo E. Russo © 2008 Nova Science Publishers, Inc.
Chapter 2
REMOTE SENSING DATA FOR REGIONAL WETLAND MAPPING IN THE UNITED STATES: TRENDS AND FUTURE PROSPECTS Megan W. Lang and Greg W. McCarty USDA-ARS, Remote Sensing and Hydrology Laboratory, Beltsville Agricultural Research Center, Bldg 007, Rm 104, 10300 Baltimore Ave., Beltsville, MD 20705
ABSTRACT Historically, the biologic, aesthetic, and economic values of wetlands were largely unappreciated. Wetlands within the United States have been and are continuing to disappear at a rapid rate. Efforts are being made to conserve remaining wetlands and many regulatory policies have been adopted in support of this goal. To regulate the loss, preservation, and/or restoration of wetlands and to judge the effectiveness of these regulatory efforts in preserving associated ecosystem services, wetlands must be routinely monitored. Wetland mapping is an essential part of this monitoring program and much effort has been made by the US state and federal governments, as well as other organizations, to provide quality map products. Wetland maps can serve a variety of purposes including regulation, natural resource management, and input for models that quantify water quality and quantity as well as the provision of wetland ecosystem services at the watershed scale. Wetland hydrology is the most important abiotic factor controlling ecosystem function and extent, and it should therefore be a vital part of any wetland mapping or monitoring program. New approaches are needed to not only map wetlands, but also to monitor wetland hydrology as it varies in response to weather, vegetation phenology, surrounding landuse change, and other anthropogenic forces including climate change. Recently developed remote sensing technologies and techniques have the potential to improve the detail and reliability of wetland maps and the ability to monitor important parameters such as hydrology. Various types of remotely sensed data (e.g., aerial photographs, multispectral, hyperspectral, passive microwave, radar, and lidar) have different capabilities with specific advantages and disadvantages for wetland mapping at the regional scale. Although aerial photographs were traditionally used to map wetlands and infer hydrology, fine-resolution optical images are now
74
Megan W. Lang and Greg W. McCarty available more frequently as commercial agencies increase satellite coverage (e.g., Quickbird and IKONOS). However, optical data, such as aerial photographs and multispectral satellite images have limitations, including their inability to detect hydrology below dense vegetative canopies and their limited ability to detect variations in hydrology (i.e., inundation and soil moisture). The restrictions of optical data are increasingly being compensated for with the use of new technologies, including synthetic aperture radar, lidar, and geospatial modeling. The availability of these new data sources is increasing rapidly. For example, many states in the US are now collecting synoptic state-wide coverages of lidar data. The sources, strengths, and limitations of different types of remotely sensed data are reviewed in this paper, as well as the importance of temporal and spatial resolution necessary for regional scale wetland mapping efforts. The potential of multi-temporal, multi-sensor approaches that capitalize on geospatial modeling are emphasized for meeting current wetland mapping challenges.
1. INTRODUCTION Until recently, the biologic, aesthetic, and economic values of wetlands were largely unappreciated. United States federal legislation, such as the Swamp Lands Act of 1850 and farming innovations, encouraged the draining of wetlands. In the 1930’s and 1940’s, the US government provided free engineering services to farmers who wanted to drain their lands (Dahl and Johnson 1991). Much ecosystem damage has been done and the conterminous United States has lost over half of its wetlands (Dahl and Johnson 1991). Some states have lost more wetlands than others. For example, California has lost over 91% of its wetlands whereas Maryland has lost over 64% (Dahl and Johnson 1991; Tiner 2005). In the last half of the 20th century, public recognition of the value of wetlands along with concern over accelerating rates of wetland loss led to a change in society’s perception of wetlands. Interest in wetland conservation has increased and new governmental policies (e.g., the Highly Erodible Land Conservation and Wetland Conservation Compliance (Swampbuster) provisions that were introduced in the 1985 US Farm Bill) have removed most of the wetland drainage incentives for agricultural lands. Other US legislative acts, such as the Clean Water Act (which grew out of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 as amended in 1972 and 1977), are now used to protect wetlands. Wetland protection is further supported by the US federal “no net wetland loss” policy (Federal Geographic Data Committee 1994). Efforts are being made to conserve remaining wetlands and many policies have been adopted in support of this goal. Accurate and up to date wetland maps assist in the proper implementation of wetland regulations. For the United States to effectively manage its remaining wetlands, their abundance, distribution, boundaries, and quality must be better understood. The way in which society interacts with wetlands is largely dependent on what value they assign to these natural resources. This value is subjective and is often measured by the function that the resource serves. Therefore, a better understanding of wetland ecosystem functioning within the landscape is necessary in order for society to place a value on wetlands (National Research Council 1995). As natural resource management becomes more holistic and moves towards ecosystem management, the synoptic view that remotely sensed data provides will become increasingly important (Finlayson and van der Valk 1995; Klemas 2001). Remote observation of wetlands is particularly necessary because they are often
Remote Sensing Data for Regional Wetland Mapping in the United States
75
difficult to access on the ground, and on-site mapping at the landscape scale is usually cost prohibitive (Harvey and Hill 2001; Rundquist et al. 2001; Baker et al. 2006; Silva et al. 2008). Remotely sensed imagery has the potential to add to our understanding of wetlands within the wider landscape setting and to better ensure their preservation via an increased understanding, more informed management practices, and a heightened appreciation of this unique resource. Remotely sensed data can be used to create not only maps of wetland presence, but also estimates of wetland condition and function (Rosenqvist et al. 2007). Significant effort has been made by scientists and managers to provide quality map products and recently developed remote sensing technologies have the potential to further improve their detail and reliability. The diversity of remotely sensed data and the techniques available to process these data have increased rapidly since the 1970’s, when the US first began to systemically map national wetland resources. Still, the dynamic nature of these ecosystems (e.g., ephemeral hydrology), their diversity (e.g., variations in plant structure and phenology), and the often small proportion of the landscape that they occupy challenge existing sensors. Recent advances in the quality and availability of radar, lidar, and other types of data, as well as the introduction of new processing methods hold great potential for the furthering of regional wetland mapping and monitoring efforts. These different geospatial datasets provide complementary information about wetland presence and function. This paper reviews the advantages and disadvantages of applying different types of remotely sensed data, including aerial photographs, multi-spectral, hyperspectral, passive microwave, radar, and lidar data, to the mapping and monitoring of wetlands.
2. CURRENT US REGIONAL WETLAND MAPPING PROGRAMS Multiple state and federal agencies have produced regional wetland maps over the last thirty-five years and these maps have developed rapidly. One of the most common wetland mapping methods uses both remotely sensed and field data. Natural resource managers have been using a combination of remotely sensed imagery and field data since the 1970’s and the techniques and the quality of data used have been rapidly evolving. In the past, most maps were produced by government agencies, such as the United States Fish and Wildlife Service (FWS) and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA), but today private organizations are also contributing to the effort. Two commonly relied upon US federal wetland mapping programs are discussed below.
2.1. US Fish and Wildlife Service National Wetland Inventory One of the earliest and most commonly relied upon mapping efforts was the US FWS National Wetland Inventory (NWI). This Congressionally mandated wetland mapping and monitoring effort was initiated in 1974. NWI maps are primarily produced using mid- to high altitude aerial photographs, photointerpretation techniques, field verification, and some collateral data sources (Federal Geographic Data Committee 1994). The oldest maps are based on 1:80,000 black and white aerial photographs and more recent maps use 1:40,000 scale color infrared aerial photographs. Regardless of the type of aerial photograph used,
76
Megan W. Lang and Greg W. McCarty
maps are based on aerial photographs collected at one point in time, usually during the early spring. The NWI maps are created to provide natural resource managers with the information necessary to make well-informed decisions regarding the future of wetlands (Tiner 1999). Maps can be downloaded online at the NWI website (www.nwi.fws.gov). A new classification scheme was developed so that NWI could provide a nationally consistent product (Cowardin and Golet 1995). This new classification, often termed the Cowardin et al. classification, is a hierarchical system based on ecosystem properties. The “system” is the broadest level of the classification and it includes the estuarine, lacustrine, marine, palustrine, and riverine wetland groups. These systems are divided further based on vegetation, hydrologic regime, salinity, ecology, and the shape and location of wetlands (Cowardin et al. 1979). Although great care has been taken in the production of these maps and they are relied upon by numerous scientists and managers (Kudray and Gale 2000; Pantaleoni 2007), challenges to the cartographic process and product delivery remain. Mapping is most accurate when there is a rapid change between vegetation, hydrology, or soil at the wetland boundary (National Research Council 1995). Other wetland types, such as forested, especially evergreen forested wetlands, and temporarily flooded wetlands, are mapped more conservatively (Tiner 1997b; Tiner 2003; Kudray and Gale 2000). NWI maps usually err less by commission and more by omission. Therefore, if a wetland is indicated on an NWI map there is a high probability that one exists or that it did at the time that the aerial photograph was acquired (Nichols 1994; Stolt and Baker 1995; Tiner 1997b). Estimates of the extent of NWI’s forested wetland omission errors vary widely but omission errors can be substantial (Swartwout et al. 1981; Stolt and Baker 1995; Rolband 1995; Kudray and Gale 2000; Wright and Gallant 2007). Due to improvements in technology and expertise as well as possible land cover changes, the newer NWI maps are likely to be more reliable. However, even the newer maps are based on aerial photographs collected at one point in time and the reliability of maps can be affected by weather conditions (e.g., drought or flood) prior to and during aerial photograph collection. In addition to cartographic challenges, it has also been a challenge for NWI to deliver wetland maps, particularly digital maps, and status reports in a timely manner and for those maps and reports to be updated fast enough to keep up with landscape changes (Pantaleoni 2007; Wright and Gallant 2007). According to the NWI website (www.nwi.fws.gov), significant portions of the US have not even been mapped once and large areas are only available in hardcopy, not digital. It is uncertain whether areas of the US currently without NWI maps will be mapped in the future (Wright and Gallant 2007). Meanwhile many NWI maps are out of date or are rapidly becoming so. The US FWS has recently begun to estimate wetland function, primarily based on landscape position, landform, water body types, and hydrologic flow paths as illustrated in NWI maps, topographic maps, and aerial photographs. Estimated functions include: 1) nutrient and sediment retention, 2) preservation of biodiversity, 3) provision of habitat, 4) surface water retention, 5) maintenance of stream flow, 6) shoreline stabilization, and 7) coastal storm-surge protection. This additional information could help to better characterize ecosystem service studies such as nutrient cycling, water storage, contaminant removal, carbon storage and export, and more (Tiner 1997c; Tiner 2003; Tiner 2005).
Remote Sensing Data for Regional Wetland Mapping in the United States
77
2.2. NOAA Coastal Change Analysis Program The NOAA Coastal Change Analysis Program (C-CAP) is a nationally standardized database of land cover and habitat change produced for the coastal areas of the United States (NOAA 2008). This regularly updated database was established in the 1990’s to assist scientists, mangers and regulators in better understanding the coastal environment, the interactions between major land cover types (e.g., wetlands and uplands), and the impact of those interactions on marine organisms (Dobson et al. 1995). In doing so, C-CAP promotes an ecosystem-based approach to natural resource management. Unlike NWI, C-CAP maps are created in a digital environment using image processing software. It primarily relies on digital satellite imagery, field data, and other ancillary data in a geographic information system (GIS) format (Dobson et al 1995). C-CAP maps have been produced for multiple dates, at 30 m spatial resolution. Current efforts are focused on adding additional dates and production of finer resolution products in specific regions (Nate Herald 2008 personal communication). Data summaries, reports, and digital maps are available online (www.csc.noaa.gov /landcover). C-CAP is produced in coordination with several other federal agencies as part of the National Land Cover Database (NLCD), facilitated by the Multi-Resolution Land Characteristics Consortium, and serves as the coastal portion of NLCD. Map production methods are nearly identical to those used to produce NLCD data (www.mrlc.gov) for the interior portion of the US, with the largest difference being that C-CAP includes additional wetland classes which are not mapped in the interior of the US. Similar to NLCD, C-CAP primarily relies on Landsat Thematic Mapper (TM) and Landsat Enhanced Thematic Mapper Plus (ETM+) data, although additional satellite imagery is used in some regions. These additional imagery sources include Landsat Multispectral Scanner (MSS), Systeme Pour l’Observation de la Terre (SPOT) High Resolution Visible (HRV) data, IKONOS, and Quickbird (Dobson et al. 1995; NOAA 2008). The finer resolution imagery, such as IKONOS and Quickbird, are used to gather more detailed information for training or in areas of enhanced interest (e.g., areas of rapid change; Nate Herold 2008 personal communication). In addition to the standard NLCD land cover classes, C-CAP also maps palustrine forested, palustrine scrub/shrub, palustrine emergent, estuarine forested, estuarine scrub/shrub, and estuarine emergent wetlands, as well as palustrine aquatic beds, and estuarine aquatic beds. In this way, C-CAP contains more detailed wetland classes than NLCD created for the interior of the country but it is less detailed than NWI, providing less information about hydrologic regime and other parameters. C-CAP products from different years are compared to determine the amount, rate and types of changes to land cover which have occurred between map dates. By doing so, C-CAP can be used to assess cumulative impacts of land cover change on ecosystem health (e.g., water quality and habitat quality). Although its coarser spatial resolution makes C-CAP more suitable for regional rather than finer scale applications, it has been found to be relatively accurate. In addition its standardized, digital production aids in timely distribution of consistent, up to date maps. In 1991, field data were used to investigate the reliability of NWI and C-CAP maps. Random locations were examined and NWI was found to be 88-100% accurate while C-CAP was found to be 63-97% accurate (Burgess 1995). Henderson et al. (1998) found that C-CAP data were useful for parameterizing non-point source pollution water quality models. The integration of wetland and upland land cover categories makes C-CAP particularly well
78
Megan W. Lang and Greg W. McCarty
suited for parameterizing water quality models since many models have been designed to import land cover data but few ingest wetland specific maps. Although the models may not distinguish between all wetland categories present in C-CAP, the fact that they are available, readily ingested and easily collapsible into more generalized NLCD categories makes their use more likely in the future. Both C-CAP and NWI are exploring different methods for rapidly updating their maps. One of these methods is cross-correlation analysis (CCA), a technique developed to detect changes in land cover using multispectral satellite data (Koeln and Bissonnette 1999). Houhoulis and Michener (2000) have developed a similar process that can also be used to update wetland maps although this particular method is not currently used by C-CAP. An important advantage to these methods is that coarser resolution digital data can be used to rapidly screen for changes in areas which were originally mapped with more costly, finer resolution imagery.
2.3. Other Wetland Mapping Efforts NWI and C-CAP are two examples of regional wetland maps being used today. Other federal efforts to map or monitor wetlands include the US Environmental Protection Agency’s Environmental Monitoring and Assessment Program and the United States Department of Agriculture (USDA) Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) National Resource Inventory. NRCS also produces the Soil Survey Geographic Database (SSURGO). Although SSURGO is not a map of current wetlands, it does contain information on hydric or wetland soils which can be used to infer either current or historic wetland presence. If a hydric soil is present, this usually indicates that a wetland either is or was once present at the location. In addition, some states are also producing their own wetland maps. For example, the Maryland Department of Natural Resources produces detailed wetland maps using a methodology similar to the US FWS NWI program (Burgess 1995). The Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources and the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation also produces wetland inventory maps based on photointerpretation of aerial photographs (Johnston and Meysembourg 2002; New York State Department of Environmental Conservation 2008). As an increasing number of federal, state, and local agencies within the US have produced their own wetland maps, it has become increasingly important to develop a wetland mapping standard so that these maps can be compared across jurisdictional lines and dates. Since 1993, the Wetlands Subcommittee of the Federal Geographic Data Committee has been working to coordinate and integrate the collection of wetlands data by various US government agencies. This integration is divided into four increments: 1) standardize terminology, definitions, and classification schemes used by government agencies to gather information concerning wetlands; 2) coordinate the collection of wetlands data by government agencies; 3) evaluate the consistency of wetlands data and statistical results collected by government agencies; and 4) analyze the public policy implications and feasibility of the coordination of wetlands information. This program has made improvements on the coordination of government agencies involved in wetlands data collection (Federal Geographic Data Committee 1996; Shapiro 1995; Federal Geographic Data Committee 1994) and a draft wetland mapping standard was available online (www.fgdc.gov) at the time this chapter was written. The purpose of this standard is to enhance current and future, but not
Remote Sensing Data for Regional Wetland Mapping in the United States
79
necessarily historic, wetland mapping efforts. The standard specifies minimum data quality standards for inclusion in the US National Spatial Data Infrastructure when these activities are conducted or funded by the US federal government (Federal Geographic Committee 2007).
3. WETLAND HYDROPERIOD: A KEY WETLAND MAPPING PARAMETER By basic definition, wetlands are simply wet-lands (Reed 1993). For that reason, one of the main parameters that should be considered when mapping wetlands is wetland hydrology. Fluctuations in the areal extent, duration, and frequency of wetland flooding and soil saturation are called wetland hydropattern or hydroperiod (National Research Council 1995; Mitsch and Gosselink 2007). Wetland hydroperiod results from all transfers of water into and out of a wetland (National Research Council 1995; Mitsch and Gosselink 2007). Although numerous factors interact to influence wetlands, hydroperiod is the single most important force controlling not only the formation, and therefore the location, but also the functioning of a wetland (Reed 1993; Nestler and Long 1997; Mitsch and Gosselink 2000; Baghdadi et al. 2001; Töyrä et al. 2002; Bartsch et al. 2007; Beeri and Phillips 2007; Martinez and Le Toan 2007). Since wetlands are often situated at a hydrologic edge (Chopra et al. 2001; Chiu and Couloigner 2006), small changes in hydrologic regime can cause substantial changes in ecosystem characteristics and function (Mitsch and Gosselink 2000). Hydrologic conditions control important abiotic factors, which in turn influence wetland biogeochemistry, soils, and vegetation. Wetland chemistry, soils, and vegetation are therefore unique and they interact to serve a variety of functions valued by society, such as pollution reduction and flood control (Whitehead and Thompson 1993; Richardson 1994; Hruby et al. 1995; Whigham 1996; Poor 1999; Woodward and Wui 2001; Baker et al. 2006). Approximately half of all animal and plant species included on the US threatened or endangered species list depend on wetlands during a portion of their lives (US Fish and Wildlife Service 2002). Information on hydroperiod can be used to infer the types of functions that may be served by a wetland (Nestler and Long 1997; Cole and Brooks 2000; Mitsch and Gosselink 2007). Wetland soils (hydric soils) and vegetation (hydrophilic vegetation) can often be distinguished from upland soils and vegetation on remotely sensed images. Additionally, remotely sensed data can discern subtle topographic features that greatly influence the function of wetlands. Certain conditions (e.g., topographic depressions) can encourage the concentration of water and therefore the origination of wetland hydrology. Moreover, coarser landforms that favor the formation of wetlands, such as the margins of stream, can also provide important clues to the location of wetlands. For the above stated reasons, remote sensors (i.e., people who analyze remotely sensed images) monitor wetland hydrology, hydric soils, hydrophytic vegetation, and/or conditions which encourage the concentration of water to map wetlands.
80
Megan W. Lang and Greg W. McCarty
4. DIFFICULTIES INHERENT IN WETLAND MAPPING Regardless of the methodology used to map wetlands, there are numerous difficulties inherent in the mapping process. These limitations may be related to a variety of factors including the character of the wetland being mapped, the map scale, the natural conditions present at the time of data collection, the spectral and spatial resolution of the imagery used, the software and hardware used to process the data, and the skill of the image processor (Tiner 1999). It should be noted that the specifications necessary to produce a “good” wetland map depend heavily on what that map is being used for. For example, a relatively fine scale wetland map like NWI may not be necessary when assessing wetland abundance at a global scale but it would be helpful when attempting to determine exactly where to locate a wetland mitigation site. Similarly, it may be less important to use a wetland map that accurately delineates forested wetlands if a researcher or natural resource manager is trying to locate potential habitat for an endangered bird which only lives in marshes, wetlands with nonwoody vegetation.
4.1. Temporal Considerations The timing of image collection is vital to the accurate mapping of wetlands (Klemas 2001). Ideal times can vary by hour, day, month, or year and by wetland type. Generally, the more water present in an area, either in the form of soil saturation or flooding, the more unique an area will appear as compared to surrounding uplands, and the easier it will be to identify the area using remotely sensed data. However, hydroperiod is a highly dynamic parameter in many wetlands and these wetlands must be imaged at specific times to capture water levels at their peak. For example, moisture levels can vary due to tides, rainfall events, the melting of snow and ice, the release of upstream dams, or changing levels of evapotranspiration (a combination of evaporation and transpiration primarily controlled by temperature and plant physiology). It is also important to consider the fact that precipitation and wetness conditions change from year to year (e.g., drought or flood years) as well as between seasons. For that reason, images captured during years of average weather conditions will best represent the location of wetlands. However, in some circumstances the collection of imagery during weather extremes may aid the mapping of wetlands. For example, Munyati (2000) found that some wetlands in Africa were readily apparent during droughts when wetland vegetation was the only green vegetation present in the landscape. Ideal timing of imagery collection for wetland map creation depends on the type of wetland being mapped. Deciduous forested wetlands are best mapped during the spring before leaf-out. At this time, the tree canopy interferes less with the detection of the ground and water tables tend to be high due to snowmelt and/or an extended period of low evapotranspiration rates. Because evergreen vegetation retains its leaves year round, evergreen forested wetlands do not have an optimal time for imagery collection based on vegetative state. Submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV), on the other hand, is best mapped during maximum biomass, low turbidity, low wave/wind action, and during low tide. When collecting remotely sensed data over tidal areas, it is difficult to obtain images that are recorded at the same tidal level. This is not only due to the difficulty of obtaining adjacent
Remote Sensing Data for Regional Wetland Mapping in the United States
81
scenes at the same tidal level. It is also due to tidal flooding that proceeds gradually upstream so that wetlands within a large estuarine system are in different stages of flooding at one point in time (Tiner 1999).
4.2. Spatial Considerations The spatial resolution or scale of imagery affects what can and cannot be interpreted in a wetland map. All maps have a minimum mapping unit (MMU) and a target mapping unit (TMU). The MMU represents the smallest wetland that appears on the map, while the TMU estimates the smallest wetland that is consistently mapped. The TMU will differ not only based on the spatial resolution of the imagery used to create the map but also based on the type of wetland being mapped (Tiner 1999). For example, easily identified wetlands, such as coastal marshes and flooded basins, will have a smaller TMU than wetlands that are more difficult to identify, like drier or evergreen wetlands. To map wetlands at a certain MMU, requires an appropriate scale of imagery. For example, when mapping wetlands in Maryland using color infrared aerial photography Tiner and Smith (1992) recommended imagery with a spatial scale of 1:58,000 to produce maps with a MMU of 0.4 ha and 1:24,000 imagery to produce maps with a MMU of 0.1 to 0.2 ha. The use of finer resolution imagery, however, requires a greater mapping effort. A spatial resolution of 1:24,000 or better is recommended for local wetland mapping when boundaries need to be precise and smaller wetlands need to be identified. Whereas, broader scale imagery, such as 1:58,000, are more appropriate for national mapping efforts (Tiner 1999). Generally, as the resolution of imagery used to map wetlands becomes finer, wetland boundaries are more distinct and refined, smaller wetlands are mapped, stereoscopic details become obvious, and difficult to identify wetlands become more easily identified. However, finer scale imagery only increases the quality of wetland maps to a point. For example, wetlands are easier to delineate at 1:12,000 than 1:5,760. This is due to extremely fine details, like tree branches, that make it difficult to delineate wetlands at this scale (Tiner and Smith 1992). It could be said at this point that the “forest (or forested wetland) cannot be seen through the trees” at this finer scale.
4.3. Wetland Type Considerations The most difficult types of wetlands to map are palustrine forested wetlands (Jacobson et al. 1987; Tiner 1990; Sader et al. 1995; Kudray and Gale 2000; Klemas 2001; Wright and Gallant 2007), evergreen wetlands, and wetlands with ephemeral hydrology (Augusteijn and Warrender 1998; Kudray and Gale 2000). Palustrine forested wetlands are difficult to map because their canopies often prevent viewing of the ground’s surface and the trees found in this type of wetland are identical or spectrally similar to those found in upland forests (Sader et al. 1995; Augusteijn and Warrender 1998; Klemas 2001). Moreover, relatively small variations in topography are capable of forming these types of wetlands. As a result, all forested wetlands, but especially small, isolated forested wetlands (e.g, vernal pools) are one of the most difficult types of wetlands to detect due to a combination of the presence of the forest canopy, often ephemerally hydrology, and in the case of vernal pools their size. Although they are difficult to detect using remotely sensed images, the mapping of palustrine
82
Megan W. Lang and Greg W. McCarty
forested wetlands is vital because they represent approximately half of all wetlands found in the US (Sader et al. 1995) and they are the most likely type of wetland to be lost in the future (US Fish and Wildlife Service 2002). New techniques need to be developed to remotely sense forested wetlands. Although forested wetlands are often more readily identified with finer resolution imagery, this is only true to a degree. Wilen and Smith (1996) argue that the challenge to identifying forested wetlands lies not in spatial resolution but in spectral resolution. Promising technologies for meeting the forested wetland mapping challenge include radar and lidar. In addition, better quantification of the influence of hydrology on the spectral signature of forested wetlands using hyperspectral data would be helpful. Rundquist et al. (2001) called for the increased characterization of the composite vegetation-water spectral signature of emergent vegetation. For forested wetlands, the impact of hydrology on the spectral signature of the leaf layer after it has been exposed to flooding (leaves on the ground) may also be helpful if it is the leaf layer and not soils that are being remotely sensed. Since evergreen wetlands retain their leaves year-round, it is difficult to determine hydroperiod or soil type beneath them. Sometimes evergreen wetlands provide hints regarding their status. Evergreens growing in wetlands may be shorter than those growing elsewhere or they may show signs of chlorosis due to water stress (Tiner 1999). With deciduous or evergreen forested wetlands, it may be possible to view saturated soils or understory wetland characteristics through canopy openings. Wetlands exist along a continuum of soil moisture conditions, between permanently inundated, deepwater habitats and drier areas that do not sustain the soil moisture levels needed to support anaerobic soils. Many of the drier wetlands are difficult to identify on the ground yet alone with remotely sensed data. The more difficult it is to map a wetland on the ground, the more conservatively it will be mapped with remotely sensed data (Tiner 1999).
5. THE POTENTIAL OF DIFFERENT SENSORS FOR WETLAND MAPPING Aerial photographs have traditionally been used to map wetlands and some current wetland mapping programs use multispectral images (Baghdadi et al. 2001), but recent research suggests that other types of remotely sensed imagery have promise for wetland delineation. The National Research Council (1995) concluded that certain types of imagery may provide enhanced wetland mapping capabilities over traditional photointerpretation methods. This section investigates the advantages and disadvantages of using aerial photography and multispectral, hyperspectral, passive microwave, radar, and lidar imagery for wetland mapping. This is not an exhaustive review of all types of remotely sensed imagery. Instead it represents the types of imagery that are most common and that researchers have suggested have the greatest potential to improve wetlands mapping. This section discusses both spaceborne and airborne imaging systems. It is important to not only differentiate between different types of imagery but also between the different platforms used to collect those images since there are advantages and disadvantages inherent to these vantage points. The advantages of using satellite imagery for wetland mapping include coverage, timeliness, lower costs, and the ease with which it can be integrated with other types of data in a GIS (Dobson et al. 1995; Federal Geographic Data Committee 1992;
Remote Sensing Data for Regional Wetland Mapping in the United States
83
Papa et al. 2006). But the use of satellite data also implies certain limitations. These limitations include the often greater interference of weather with satellite data collection. In the past, the use of satellite data has meant broader spatial resolutions but this in no longer the case with new generation sensors (e.g., IKONOS and Quickbird) that collect finer spatial resolution data.
5.1. Aerial Photography The combination of aerial photographs and manual photointerpretation has been and continues to be the most commonly relied upon wetland mapping method (Lyon and McCarthy 1995; National Research Council 1995; Phinn et al. 1999; Harvey and Hill 2001). This is primarily due to the use of well-established methods and protocols, the availability of current and historic data over broad areas (Baker et al. 2006), the comparatively fine spatial resolution of aerial photographs (Klemas 2001), and of course the relatively reliable results obtained from such efforts (Rutchey and Vilchek 1999; Harvey and Hill 2001; Wright and Gallant 2007). In addition, the aerial platform provides flexibility with the timing of data collection that the satellite platform lacks. For example, airplanes can collect images at certain times of the day that correspond with optimal tidal levels whereas the overpass time of satellites is usually predetermined. Historic aerial photographs are available for much if not all of the US providing a valuable baseline for change detection analysis (Baker et al. 2006). One of the most common sources of aerial photography used for wetland mapping in the US is the US National Aerial Photography Program (NAPP) and the National High Altitude Aerial Photography (NHAP) program, both directed by the US Geological Survey (USGS). One of the major differences between aerial photography and satellite data lies not in the character of the data but with the methods that have traditionally been used to process those data. Aerial photography is often classified by a photointerpreter without computer automation of the mapping process. Photointerpretation relies on the human eye to make qualitative decisions based on the image’s tone, color, spatial patterns, texture, height/topography, associations, and other characteristics. The accuracy of these decisions can benefit from the experience and judgment of the photointerpreter. The interpretation of aerial photography also benefits from the use of stereoscopic viewing. Stereoscopic viewing helps the photointerpreter determine relative variations in elevation and vegetation height. Topographic variations provide clues as to where wetlands would likely form and information on vegetation height aids in the determination of wetland type (e.g., forested versus shrubscrub). Changes in plant height may also indicate soil moisture and other abiotic conditions (National Research Council 1995). Studies have compared the use of aerial photographs and aerial photointerpretation to the use of multispectral data for wetland mapping in different environments (Rutchey and Vilchek 1999; Harvey and Hill 2001). One of the major disadvantages of aerial photographs as compared to multispectral data is the relatively lower spectral resolution of the aerial photographs but the superior spatial resolution of aerial photographs can compensate for this disadvantage. A study conducted in the Florida Everglades found that SPOT data overestimated the amount of cattail present in an impounded wetland due to confounding factors, such as, fire, hydrology, periphyton species composition, and macrophyte morphology. Aerial photography was better able to overcome these difficulties and map
84
Megan W. Lang and Greg W. McCarty
cattail in these areas due to the experience and reasoning of the photointerpreter (Rutchey and Vilchek 1999). Harvey and Hill (2001) compared the ability of multispectral data (SPOT and Landsat TM) to that of aerial photographs and manual interpretation techniques for mapping an Australian freshwater swamp. Although fourteen land cover types could be delineated from 1:15,000 aerial photographs with 89% accuracy, only three broad land cover types could be distinguished using the multispectral data while meeting minimum accuracy requirements (≤80%). The difference in accuracy between the aerial photographs and multispectral data was, in part, attributed to the contextual and textural information used by the photointerpreter (Harvey and Hill 2001). Although the manual interpretation of aerial photography is the most commonly used method for detailed wetland mapping, this method is subjective (Finlayson and van der Valk 1995; Augusteijn and Warrender 1998; Baker et al. 2006), time consuming and therefore cannot be quickly updated (Phinn et al. 1999; Harvey and Hill 2001; Wright and Gallant 2007), is relatively expensive (Dobson et al. 1995; Mumby et al. 1999; Lunetta and Balogh 1999; Phinn et al. 1999; Harvey and Hill 2001; Klemas 2001; Hirano et al. 2003), and has difficulty mapping certain wetland types (see section 2.1). There are inherent limitations to the use of human vision to classify a map (Rutchey and Vilchek 1999) and these decisions are inherently subjective so resultant maps may vary according to the person who creates them (Finlayson and van der Valk 1995; Augusteijn and Warrender 1998; Baker et al. 2006). Mumby et al. (1999) estimate that the creation of maps for a relatively small area (~150 km2) may take six times as long using aerial photointerpretation rather than automated interpretation of digital airborne imagery and that the cost of manual interpretation of aerial photographs will increase at a faster rate than the cost of digital interpretation. The inability of the US FWS to use aerial photointerpretation methods to map wetlands for the entire US (starting in the 1970s) illustrates the cumbersome nature of aerial photointerpretation for broad scale mapping. The type of aerial photograph used to create a wetland map has the potential to affect map accuracy. Although photointerpretation has traditionally been a manual process, which utilized analog photographs rather than digital images, analog aerial photographs can be converted to digital. Still the challenge of scanning in large numbers of photographs and normalizing photographs for variations in illumination, angle of acquisition, and sometimes even phenology and atmospheric conditions remains a challenge (Phinn et al. 1999). Digital cameras are an improvement over analog aerial photographs and can be processed using methods similar to those used for processing multispectral images (Phinn et al. 1999), although the lack of spectral information is still a limitation (Becker et al. 2007; Silva et al. 2008). If possible, it is usually advantageous to use color or color infrared aerial photographs to map wetlands, rather than black and white images. Color infrared film is usually preferred for wetlands mapping because it includes more spectral information than true color film and allows for greater contrast between different plant communities (Tiner 1999; Federal Geographic Data Committee 1992). Dale et al. (1996) found that color infrared aerial photography was a valuable tool in the identification of wetlands. A major exception to this statement occurs when mapping submerged aquatic vegetation (SAV). The relatively low spectral resolution of aerial photographs significantly limits their use for the detection of SAV in general (Silva et al. 2008). However, the use of true color film for SAV detection is preferable to the use of color infrared film due to the superior ability of shorter wavelengths
Remote Sensing Data for Regional Wetland Mapping in the United States
85
energy (the visible bands which compose true color imagery) to penetrate the water column (Tiner 1999).
5.2. Multispectral Multispectral sensors (Table 1) provide information on solar reflectance from materials on the Earth’s surface in multiple portions of the electromagnetic spectrum (e.g., visible, near infrared, mid-infrared, and thermal), at relatively fine (1 – 5 m) to medium spatial resolutions (10 – 30 m) and some also provide thermal data. Sensors with coarser spatial resolutions, such as the AVHRR (Advanced Very High Resolution Radiometer) with approximate 1 km resolution, are usually not considered viable options for wetland mapping at the local to regional scale (Munyati 2000; Ringrose et al. 2003), so they are not discussed below. Relative to aerial photographs, satellite borne multispectral sensors provide enhanced spectral resolution (multiple bands) and are capable of imaging a larger area at once (Rundquist et al. 2001; Li and Chen 2005), which simplifies image interpretation. Studies have found that the increased spectral resolution of multispectral data enhances wetland mapping (Federal Geographic Data Committee 1992; Phinn et al. 1999; Harvey and Hill 2001; Töyrä et al. 2002) and, in some cases, helps compensate for reduced spatial resolution (Harvey and Hill 2001). In addition, if fine detail is not required these images are usually less expensive than aerial photographs (Mumby et al. 1999) and they can be collected regularly, as dictated by satellite orbits (Rundquist et al. 2001; Li and Chen 2005). Therefore, these sensors provide not only increased spectral but also increased temporal resolution over aerial photographs, both of which are important for distinguishing different wetland classes. The comparatively fine temporal resolution of these multispectral sensors is complemented by a relatively long historic record (e.g., Landsat MSS first launched in 1972). Finally, their digital format and standardized imagery allow for automated, repeatable classification of wetlands and other land cover types (Houhoulis and Mitchner 2000; Ausseil et al. 2007). The infrared portion of the electromagnetic spectrum, which is often collected by multispectral sensors (Table 1), is considered to be particularly well suited for wetland mapping applications (Federal Geographic Data Committee 1992; Phinn et al. 1999; Munyati 2000). This is due to the high spectral response of vegetation in the near-infrared coupled with the strong absorption of water in the same region, which makes for a sharp contrast between water and vegetation in the near-infrared (Lyon and McCarthy 1995) and water absorption features (portions of the electromagnetic spectrum with distinctly lower reflectance when water is present) in the mid-infrared. Both multispectral and hyperspectral data can take advantage of this contrast with individual bands over these regions. The use of color-infrared (CIR) aerial photos can also improve wetland detection via information on the near infrared portion of the electromagnetic spectrum. However, the use of color infrared photographs is not as advantageous as the isolation of these regions through the use of distinct bands by way of digital multispectral images (Lyon and McCarthy 1995). Although many of the older satellite systems, such as Landsat MSS, Landsat TM, and SPOT, offer improved spectral resolution, their spatial resolution is often insufficient for mapping smaller or more comple