Web-Based Education:
Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Information Resources Management Association USA
Volume I
InformatIon scIence reference Hershey • New York
Director of Editorial Content: Director of Book Publications: Acquisitions Editor: Development Editor: Publishing Assistant: Typesetters: Production Editor: Cover Design: Printed at:
Kristin Klinger Julia Mosemann Lindsay Johnston David DeRicco Michael Brehm Michael Brehm, Carole Coulson, Devvin Earnest, Christopher Hrobak, Ricardo Mendoza, Kurt Smith, Jamie Snavely, Susan Timperio, Sean Woznicki, Deanna Zombro Jamie Snavely Lisa Tosheff Yurchak Printing Inc.
Published in the United States of America by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global) 701 E. Chocolate Avenue Hershey PA 17033 Tel: 717-533-8845 Fax: 717-533-8661 E-mail:
[email protected] Web site: http://www.igi-global.com/reference and in the United Kingdom by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global) 3 Henrietta Street Covent Garden London WC2E 8LU Tel: 44 20 7240 0856 Fax: 44 20 7379 0609 Web site: http://www.eurospanbookstore.com Copyright © 2010 by IGI Global. All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored or distributed in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, without written permission from the publisher. Product or company names used in this set are for identification purposes only. Inclusion of the names of the products or companies does not indicate a claim of ownership by IGI Global of the trademark or registered trademark. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Web-based education : concepts, methodologies, tools and applications / Information Resources Management Association, Editor. vols. 1-3, p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. Summary: "This comprehensive collection offers a compendium of research on the design, implementation, and evaluation of online learning technologies, addressing the challenges and opportunities associated with the creation and management of Web-based applications and communities, instructional design, personalized learning environments, and effective educational delivery"--Provided by publisher. ISBN 978-1-61520-963-7 (hardcover) -- ISBN 978-1-61520-964-4 (ebook) 1. Web-based instruction. 2. Computer-assisted instruction. I. Information Resources Management Association. LB1044.87.W419 2010 371.33'44678--dc22 2010003720
British Cataloguing in Publication Data A Cataloguing in Publication record for this book is available from the British Library. All work contributed to this book set is original material. The views expressed in this book are those of the authors, but not necessarily of the publisher.
Editor-in-Chief Mehdi Khosrow-Pour, DBA Editor-in-Chief Contemporary Research in Information Science and Technology, Book Series
Associate Editors Steve Clarke University of Hull, UK Murray E. Jennex San Diego State University, USA Annie Becker Florida Institute of Technology USA Ari-Veikko Anttiroiko University of Tampere, Finland
Editorial Advisory Board Sherif Kamel American University in Cairo, Egypt In Lee Western Illinois University, USA Jerzy Kisielnicki Warsaw University, Poland Keng Siau University of Nebraska-Lincoln, USA Amar Gupta Arizona University, USA Craig van Slyke University of Central Florida, USA John Wang Montclair State University, USA Vishanth Weerakkody Brunel University, UK
Additional Research Collections found in the “Contemporary Research in Information Science and Technology” Book Series Data Mining and Warehousing: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications John Wang, Montclair University, USA • 6-volume set • ISBN 978-1-60566-056-1 Electronic Business: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications In Lee, Western Illinois University • 4-volume set • ISBN 978-1-59904-943-4 Electronic Commerce: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications S. Ann Becker, Florida Institute of Technology, USA • 4-volume set • ISBN 978-1-59904-943-4 Electronic Government: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Ari-Veikko Anttiroiko, University of Tampere, Finland • 6-volume set • ISBN 978-1-59904-947-2 Knowledge Management: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Murray E. Jennex, San Diego State University, USA • 6-volume set • ISBN 978-1-59904-933-5 Information Communication Technologies: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Craig Van Slyke, University of Central Florida, USA • 6-volume set • ISBN 978-1-59904-949-6 Intelligent Information Technologies: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Vijayan Sugumaran, Oakland University, USA • 4-volume set • ISBN 978-1-59904-941-0 Information Security and Ethics: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Hamid Nemati, The University of North Carolina at Greensboro, USA • 6-volume set • ISBN 978-1-59904-937-3 Medical Informatics: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Joseph Tan, Wayne State University, USA • 4-volume set • ISBN 978-1-60566-050-9 Mobile Computing: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications David Taniar, Monash University, Australia • 6-volume set • ISBN 978-1-60566-054-7 Multimedia Technologies: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Syed Mahbubur Rahman, Minnesota State University, Mankato, USA • 3-volume set • ISBN 978-1-60566-054-7 Virtual Technologies: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools, and Applications Jerzy Kisielnicki, Warsaw University, Poland • 3-volume set • ISBN 978-1-59904-955-7
Free institution-wide online access with the purchase of a print collection!
InformatIon scIence reference Hershey • New York
Order online at www.igi-global.com or call 717-533-8845 ext.100 Mon–Fri 8:30am–5:00 pm (est) or fax 24 hours a day 717-533-7115
List of Contributors
Abdallah, Salam \ Abu Dhabi University, UAE .............................................................................. 1280 Adaktilou, Nektaria \ University of Athens, Greece ......................................................................... 643 Agudo, J. Enrique \ University of Extremadura, Spain .................................................................... 867 Ajjan, Haya \ University of North Carolina at Charlotte, USA ...................................................... 1162 Akyol, Zehra \ Middle East Technical University, Turkey................................................................. 474 Alden, Jay \ National Defense University, USA................................................................................. 758 Amberg, Hilary G. \ University of Florida, USA ............................................................................ 1102 Arora, Anshu Saxena \ Savannah State University-Savannah, USA .............................................. 1531 Ashcraft, Donna \ Clarion University of Pennsylvania, USA ......................................................... 1146 Barclay, Kathleen \ University of Phoenix School of Advanced Studies, USA ............................... 1232 Barolli, Leonard \ Fukuoka Institute of Technology, Japan ............................................................ 1709 Bateman, Roger \ Unitec, New Zealand ............................................................................................ 671 Baylen, Danilo M. \ University of West Georgia, USA ...................................................................... 947 Beck, Diane E. \ University of Florida, USA ..................................................................................... 394 Bendixen, Roxanna \ University of Florida, USA ........................................................................... 1102 Blakey, Leah \ Drury University, USA................................................................................................. 28 Bodomo, Adams \ University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong................................................................. 133 Borich, Gary \ University of Texas at Austin, USA............................................................................ 228 Bovard, Bethany \ New Mexico State University, USA ..................................................................... 259 Braidic, Silvia L. \ California University of Pennsylvania, USA .................................................... 1203 Brinkman, Willem-Paul \ Brunel University, UK........................................................................... 1075 Bristol, Tim \ Crown College, USA ................................................................................................. 1342 Brown, Lorie \ Robert Morris University, USA ................................................................................... 59 Brown, Robert L. \ Mississippi State University, USA...................................................................... 119 Brozik, Dallas \ Marshall University, USA ........................................................................................ 738 Buckley, Clive N. \ Glyndŵr University, UK ..................................................................................... 939 Burford, Sally \ University of Canberra, Australia ........................................................................... 163 Busetti, Emanuela \ Istituto di Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche del CNR, Italy . 1445 Bussmann, Susan \ New Mexico State University, USA .................................................................... 259 Cagiltay, Kursat \ Middle East Technical University, Turkey ......................................................... 1428 Carrier, Kristina K. \ University of Idaho, USA ............................................................................. 1118 Cartalis, Costas \ University of Athens, Greece ................................................................................ 643 Cawthon, Stephanie \ The University of Texas at Austin, USA......................................................... 923 Chaka, Chaka \ Walter Sisulu University, South Africa .................................................................. 1765 Chang, Klarissa Ting-Ting \ Carnegie Mellon University, USA ...................................................... 607
Chang, Mei-Yu \ National Hsinchu University of Education, Taiwan .............................................. 459 Changchit, Chuleeporn \ Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi, USA .................................. 73, 1268 Chao, Han-Chieh \ National Dong Hwa University, Taiwan .......................................................... 1844 Chen, Irene \ University of Houston-Downtown, USA .................................................................... 1696 Chen, Wei \ City University of Hong Kong, China ............................................................................ 572 Cheng, Hsiang \ National Chi Nan University, Taiwan ................................................................... 1825 Cheok, Adrian David \ National University of Singapore, Singapore .............................................. 302 Chiazzese, Giuseppe \ Italian National Research Council, Italy .................................................... 1518 Chifari, Antonella \ Italian National Research Council, Italy ........................................................ 1518 Choi, Yongsoon \ National University of Singapore, Singapore........................................................ 302 Chou, C. Candace \ University of St. Thomas, USA ......................................................................... 524 Chu, Carol H. C. \ National Chi Nan University, Taiwan ............................................................... 1825 Cicciarelli, MarySue \ Duquesne University, USA ........................................................................... 293 Cochrane, Thomas \ Unitec, New Zealand ....................................................................................... 671 Cole, Michele T. \ Robert Morris University, USA ............................................................................ 222 Colorado, Jozenia Torres \ Emporia State University, USA ............................................................. 405 Cooper, Lesley \ Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada ........................................................................ 163 Cranton, Patricia \ The Pennsylvania State University, Harrisburg, USA ....................................... 249 Crawford, Caroline M. \ University of Houston – Clear Lake, USA ............................................... 195 Crawley, Daria C. \ Robert Morris University, USA, USA ............................................................... 592 Csete, Josephine \ The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong ........................................ 1347 Cunha, Maria Manuela \ Polytechnic Institute of Cavado and Ave, Portugal............................... 1723 Daniel, Ben K. \ University of Saskatchewan, Canada ................................................................... 1607 Dettori, Giuliana \ Istituto di Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche del CNR, Italy ................................................................................................................................ 1445 Dewever, Fanuel \ IBM, Belgium ....................................................................................................... 633 Di Scala, Roberto \ University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Italy .............................................. 1577 Dickenson, Virginia \ eLumenata, USA............................................................................................. 195 Doherty, John J. \ Northern Arizona University, USA .................................................................... 1127 Dominguez, Eva \ University of Extremadura, Spain........................................................................ 867 Donaldson, Susan A. \ University of Florida, USA ......................................................................... 1102 Downs, Elizabeth \ Georgia Southern University, USA .................................................................. 1325 Du, Jianxia \ Mississippi State University, USA ................................................................................ 119 Durocher, Rae Ann \ Southern New Hampshire University, USA ....................................................... 59 Durresi, Arjan \ Indiana University Purdue University, USA ......................................................... 1709 Dwivedi, Yogesh Kumar \ Swansea University, UK ....................................................................... 1075 Dziuban, Charles \ University of Central Florida, USA ................................................................... 852 Eberle, Jane H. \ Emporia State University, USA ............................................................................. 405 Edelweiss, Rose Dieng-Kuntz \ INRIA Sophia Antipolis, France .................................................... 820 Edwards, Patricia \ University of Extremadura, Spain ..................................................................... 867 El Helou, Sandy \ École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Suisse, France ............... 1856 Elder, Jennifer H. \ University of Florida, USA.............................................................................. 1102 Ely, Katherine \ George Mason University, USA .............................................................................. 381 Emerson, Michelle \ Kennesaw State University, USA ..................................................................... 897 Engstrom, Richard \ Georgia State University, USA...................................................................... 1006 Ensminger, David C. \ Loyola University Chicago, USA ................................................................. 215
Entin, Eileen B. \ Aptima Inc., USA................................................................................................... 490 Escofet, Anna \ Universitat de Barcelona, Spain .............................................................................. 699 Evangelou, Christina E. \ Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece ................. 435 Faron-Zucker, Catherine \ University of Nice, France .................................................................... 820 Feldmann-Hahn, Felix \ Ruhr-University Bochum, Germany ........................................................ 1019 Ferdig, Richard E. \ Kent State University, USA .................................................................. 1102, 1162 Finger, Glenn \ Griffith University, Australia .................................................................................. 1684 Fontana, Lynn \ Sylvan Learning, USA............................................................................................. 962 Forcheri, Paola \ Istituto di Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche del CNR, Italy ...... 1445 Frey, Barbara A. \ University of Pittsburgh, USA ............................................................................. 592 García, Karen \ University of Massachusetts, USA .......................................................................... 834 Garrison, D. Randy \ University of Calgary, Canada ...................................................................... 474 Gierlowski, Krzysztof \ Gdansk University of Technology, Poland ............................................... 1870 Gillet, Denis \ École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Suisse ................................... 1856 Gkotsis, George \ Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece ............................... 435 Glazer, Hilda R. \ Capella University, USA ........................................................................................ 51 Gonzales, Carmen \ New Mexico State University, USA .................................................................. 259 GraziaIerardi, Maria \ Istituto di Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche del CNR, Italy ................................................................................................................................ 1445 Grimes, Joe \ California Polytechnic State University, USA ............................................................. 540 Hadzilacos, Th. \ Hellenic Open University, Greece ......................................................................... 446 Hagle, Holly \ Robert Morris University, USA ................................................................................ 1590 Haghirian, Parissa \ Sophia University, Japan ................................................................................. 418 Hamilton, Karin \ Fairleigh Dickinson University, USA ................................................................ 1400 Hansen, Mary \ Robert Morris University, USA ............................................................................... 888 Hao, Tianyong \ City University of Hong Kong, China .................................................................... 572 Hao, Yungwei \ National Taiwan Normal University, Taiwan ........................................................... 228 Harmon, Stephen W. \ Georgia State University, USA ..................................................................... 103 Harris, Alycia L.\ Walden University, USA ....................................................................................... 923 Hartman, Joel \ University of Central Florida, USA ........................................................................ 852 Hartshorne, Richard \ University of North Carolina at Charlotte, USA ....................................... 1162 Hernández-Gantes, Victor M. \ University of South Florida, USA ................................................. 144 Hinkley, Maureen \ Fairfield University, USA ................................................................................ 1376 Holdan, E. Gregory \ Robert Morris University, USA ...................................................................... 888 Holler, Melissa B. \ Agora Cyber Charter School, USA .................................................................... 502 Hong, Junhee \ Kyungwon University, Korea ................................................................................... 553 Hope, John K. \ University of Auckland, New Zealand ......................................................................... 9 Hsu, Jeffrey \ Fairleigh Dickinson University, USA........................................................................ 1400 Hu, Dawei \ University of Science and Technology of China, China ................................................ 572 Hwang, Gwo-Haur \ Ling Tung University, Taiwan ....................................................................... 1825 Hwang, Gwo-Jen \ National University of Tainan, Taiwan ............................................................ 1825 Jackson, Lorraine D. \ California Polytechnic State University, USA ............................................. 540 Jain, Shobhita \ Indira Gandhi National Open University, New Delhi, India .................................. 995 Jamieson-Proctor, Romina \ University of Southern Queensland, Australia ................................. 1684 Javery, Christine \ Southern New Hampshire University, USA .......................................................... 59 Johnson, Evelyn S. \ Boise State University, USA............................................................................. 277
Joia, Luiz Antonio \ Brazilian School of Public and Business Administration of Getulio Vargas Foundation and Rio de Janeiro State University, Brazil .................................... 975 Jones, Marshall G. \ Winthrop University, USA ................................................................................ 103 Kalkanis, George \ University of Athens, Greece.............................................................................. 643 Kalles, D. \ Hellenic Open University, Greece ................................................................................... 446 Kang, P. Toyoko \ University of Guam, Guam .................................................................................... 84 Karacapilidis, Nikos \ University of Patras, Greece ............................................................... 715, 1460 Karaiskakis, D. \ Hellenic Open University, Greece ......................................................................... 446 Karousos, Nikos \ University of Patras, Greece & Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece ................................................................................................... 435, 715 Kato, Shogo \ Waseda University, Japan ......................................................................................... 1055 Kelsey, Kathleen D. \ Oklahoma State University, USA ................................................................... 775 Kendrick, David \ University of Northern Colorado, USA ............................................................. 1392 Kennedy, Carol Kahan \ Fordham University, USA....................................................................... 1347 Kidd, Terry T. \ Texas A&M University, USA & University of Houston-Downtown, USA............................................................................................ 1, 1308, 1696 Kim, Minyoung \ Yonsei University, Korea ....................................................................................... 553 Kim, Soyoung \ Yonsei University, Korea.......................................................................................... 553 Klaus, Tim \ Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi, USA ....................................................... 73, 1268 Koyama, Akio \ Yamagata University, Japan .................................................................................. 1709 Kwiatkowski, April \ Robert Morris University, USA ........................................................................ 59 Lam, Paul \ The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong .................................................... 1347 Laskri, Med Tayeb \ Université Badji Mokhtar, Algeria .................................................................. 820 Lautenbach, Geoffrey \ University of Johannesburg, South Africa.................................................. 801 Lear, Janet \ University of Nebraska at Kearney, USA ................................................................... 1422 Lee, Tsang-Hsiung \ National Chengchi University, Taiwan ............................................................ 508 Li, Haifei \ Union University, USA .................................................................................................. 1788 Lim, Cher Ping \ Edith Cowan University, Western Australia ........................................................ 1036 Lim, John \ National University of Singapore, Singapore ................................................................ 607 Lin, Hong \ Oklahoma State University, USA.................................................................................... 775 Liu, We \ National University of Singapore, Singapore..................................................................... 302 Liu, Yunyan \ Southwest University, China ....................................................................................... 119 Ma, Xueguang \ University of Maryland, USA ............................................................................... 1812 Marimon, Marta \ Universitat de Vic, Spain .................................................................................... 699 Martínez, G. Moltó \ Polytechnic University of Valencia, Spain ...................................................... 910 Mastandrea, Lisa A. \ Robert Morris University, USA ................................................................... 1590 Matsuo, Keita \ Fukuoka Institute of Technology, Japan ................................................................ 1709 McNaught, Carmel \ The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong..................................... 1347 Mei-Ling, Charissa Lim \ Nanyang Technological University, Singapore....................................... 302 Merlo, Gianluca \ Italian National Research Council, Italy ........................................................... 1518 Min, Feng \ City University of Hong Kong, China ............................................................................ 572 Moskal, Patsy D. \ University of Central Florida, USA .................................................................... 852 Neal, Lisa \ eLearn Magazine, USA ................................................................................................... 490 Negash, Solomon \ Kennesaw State University, USA ........................................................................ 897 Nemati, Hamid \ University of North Carolina at Greensboro, USA.............................................. 1256 Nguyen, Ta Huynh Duy \ National University of Singapore, Singapore .......................................... 302
Nishimura, Shoji \ Waseda University, Japan ................................................................................. 1055 Nordengren, F.R. \ Des Moines University, USA .............................................................................. 179 Normann, Sven A. \ University of Florida, USA ............................................................................... 394 Nousia, Dora \ Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece .................................... 435 Nowicki, Krzysztof \ Gdansk University of Technology, Poland .................................................... 1870 Olaniran, Bolanle A. \ Texas Tech University, USA ........................................................................ 1482 Omar, Nizam \ Mackenzie P. University, Brazil ................................................................................ 810 Ottaviano, Simona \ Italian National Research Council, Italy ....................................................... 1518 Parra, Julia \ New Mexico State University, USA ............................................................................. 259 Pash, Lori \ Robert Morris University, USA ........................................................................................ 59 Peiris, Roshan \ National University of Singapore, Singapore ......................................................... 302 Pérez, Elena Verdú \ CEDETEL, Spain .......................................................................................... 1362 Pérez, María Jesús Verdú \ Universidad de Valladolid, Spain....................................................... 1362 Philip, Donald N. \ University of Toronto, Canada ......................................................................... 1239 Pimentel, Edson Pinheiro \ Claremont Graduate University, USA .................................................. 810 Pitcock, Jane \ Walden University, USA ............................................................................................ 277 Pozzi, F. \ Istituto Tecnologie Didattiche – CNR, Italy............................................................. 345, 1472 Putnik, Goran D. \ Univeristy of Minho, Portugal ......................................................................... 1723 Qiu, Lin \ State University of New York at Oswego, USA.................................................................. 328 Qui, Tran Cong Thien \ National University of Singapore, Singapore ............................................ 302 Rada, Roy \ University of Maryland, USA....................................................................................... 1812 Rae, Andrew \ Brunel University, UK ............................................................................................. 1075 Ragusa, Angela T. \ Charles Sturt University, Australia ................................................................. 1661 Raisinghani, Mahesh S. \ TWU School of Management, USA........................................................ 1531 Ray, Julie \ Robert Morris University, USA ......................................................................................... 59 Rekik, Yassin \ École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Suisse ................................. 1856 Repman, Judi \ Georgia Southern University, USA ........................................................................ 1325 Rico, Mercedes \ University of Extremadura, Spain ......................................................................... 867 Rineer, Ashley \ Robert Morris University, USA ............................................................................. 1590 Rockman, Saul \ Rockman et al., USA .............................................................................................. 962 Salzmann, Christophe \ École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Suisse .................. 1856 Schwier, Richard A. \ University of Saskatchewan, Canada .......................................................... 1607 Sclater, Niall \ The Open University, UK ........................................................................................... 661 Scollon, Jennifer \ Regis University, USA ....................................................................................... 1590 Scott, Douglass J. \ Waseda University, Japan ................................................................................ 1055 Seta, Luciano \ Italian National Research Council, Italy ................................................................ 1518 Shelley, Daniel J. \ Robert Morris University, USA........................................................................... 222 Shen, Pei-Di \ Ming Chuan University, Taiwan ................................................................................. 508 Shin, Fu-Yu \ Chien-Kuo Elementary School, Taiwan ...................................................................... 459 Sidman, Jason \ Aptima Inc., USA..................................................................................................... 490 Simon, Bernd \ Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration, Austria .................. 418 Sitzmann, Traci \ Advanced Distributed Learning Co-Laboratory, USA ......................................... 381 Smith, Marion S. \ Texas Southern University, USA ......................................................................... 195 Snelson, Chareen \ Boise State University, USA ............................................................................. 1745 Song, Holim \ Texas Southern University, USA ............................................................................... 1308 Stein, David S. \ The Ohio State University, USA................................................................................ 51
Sun, Pei-Chen \ National Kaohsiung Normal University, Taiwan .................................................. 1684 Surry, Daniel W. \ University of South Alabama, USA ..................................................................... 215 Suzuki, Renata \ Sophia University, Japan ....................................................................................... 834 Swartz, Louis B. \ Robert Morris University, USA ........................................................................... 222 Tarng, Wernhuar \ National Hsinchu University of Education, Taiwan .......................................... 459 Tay, Lee Yong \ Beacon Primary School, Singapore ....................................................................... 1036 Teh, Keng Soon \ National University of Singapore, Singapore ....................................................... 302 Tejedor, J. A. Gómez \ Polytechnic University of Valencia, Spain ................................................... 910 Theng, Yin-Leng \ Nanyang Technological University, Singapore ................................................... 302 Thompson, Marcia \ University of North Carolina at Greensboro, USA ....................................... 1256 Thornton, Julia \ RMIT University, Australia ................................................................................. 1211 Tomei, Lawrence A. \ Robert Morris University, USA.............................................................. 59, 1590 Toth, Eva Erdosne \ West Virginia University, USA........................................................................ 1550 Treadwell, Thomas \ West Chester University, USA ....................................................................... 1146 Tsai, Chia-Wen \ Ming Chuan University, Taiwan ............................................................................ 508 Tseng, Judy C.R. \ Chung-Hua University, Taiwan ........................................................................ 1825 Tzagarakis, Manolis \ Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece & University of Patras, Greece ..................................................................................... 435, 715, 1460 Valcante, Gregory \ University of Florida, USA ............................................................................. 1102 Vasilakos, Athanasios V. \ University of Peloponnese, Greece ......................................................... 302 Vidaurre, C. Barros \ Polytechnic University of Valencia, Spain ..................................................... 910 Wang, Chengbo \ Glasgow Caledonian University & University of Bolton, UK ............................. 791 Wang, Xinchun \ California State University, USA ........................................................................ 1182 Wang, Yushun \ Zhejiang University, China ..................................................................................... 727 Wanstreet, Constance E. \ The Ohio State University, USA ............................................................... 51 Wenyin, Liu \ City University of Hong Kong, China......................................................................... 572 Wheeler, Steve \ University of Plymouth, UK.................................................................................... 746 Wherry, Peg \ Montana State University, USA ................................................................................ 1626 Wilcox, Marlene V. \ Bradley University, USA ................................................................................. 897 Wilkes, Heidi L. \ Northeastern University, USA ............................................................................ 1644 Williams, Angela M. \ Glyndŵr University, UK................................................................................ 939 Windes, Deborah Lundberg \ University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA........................ 1626 Wisher, Robert \ U.S. Department of Defense, USA ......................................................................... 381 Wu, Tin-Yu \ I-Shou University, Taiwan.......................................................................................... 1844 Wu, Xiyuan \ Xi’an Jiaotong University, China .............................................................................. 1788 Xhafa, Fatos \ Polytechnic University of Catalonia, Spain ............................................................. 1709 Yang, Harrison Hao \ State University of New York at Oswego, USA ............................................ 1561 Yessad, Amel \ INRIA Sophia Antipolis, France ................................................................................ 820 York, Ann M. \ Des Moines University, USA .................................................................................... 179 Yukselturk, Erman \ Middle East Technical University, Turkey .................................................... 1428 Zaharias, Panagiotis \ University of the Aegean, Greece ............................................................... 1497 Zapalska, Alina M. \ U.S. Coast Guard Academy, USA.................................................................... 738 Zeng, Qingtian \ Shandong University of Science and Technology, China ....................................... 572 Zheng, Qinghua \ Xi’an Jiaotong University, China....................................................................... 1788 Zheng, Robert Z. \ University of Utah, USA ..................................................................................... 364 Zhong, Yingqin \ National University of Singapore, Singapore ....................................................... 607
Zhuang, Yueting \ Zhejiang University, China.................................................................................. 727 Ziegleder, Diana \ Ruhr-University Bochum, Germany .................................................................. 1019 Zinskie, Cordelia \ Georgia Southern University, USA .................................................................. 1325
Contents
Volume 1 Section I. Fundamental Concepts and Theories This section serves as the foundation for this exhaustive reference tool by addressing crucial theories essential to the understanding of Web-based learning. Chapters found within these pages provide an excellent framework in which to position Web-based education within the field of information science and technology. Individual contributions provide overviews of the history of e-learning, students’ decision to use online versus traditional courses, Web-based resources for teaching, and key elements of online learning communities. Within this introductory section, the reader can learn and choose from a compendium of expert research on the elemental theories underscoring health information systems research Chapter 1.1. A Brief History of eLearning .............................................................................................. 1 Terry T. Kidd, Texas A&M University, USA Chapter 1.2. Technological Trends in Adult Education: Past, Present and in the Future ....................... 9 John K. Hope, University of Auckland, New Zealand Chapter 1.3. The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education ............................................. 28 Leah Blakey, Drury University, USA Chapter 1.4. The Virtual University: Distance Learning Spaces for Adult Learners............................ 51 David S. Stein, The Ohio State University, USA Hilda R. Glazer, Capella University, USA Constance E. Wanstreet, The Ohio State University, USA
Chapter 1.5. Why Choose an Online Course? ...................................................................................... 59 Lawrence Tomei, Robert Morris University, USA April Kwiatkowski, Robert Morris University, USA Lorie Brown, Robert Morris University, USA Lori Pash, Robert Morris University, USA Christine Javery, Southern New Hampshire University, USA Julie Ray, Robert Morris University, USA Rae Ann Durocher, Southern New Hampshire University, USA Chapter 1.6. Online or Traditional: A Study to Examine Course Characteristics Contributing to Students’ Preference for Classroom Settings ........................................................ 73 Tim Klaus, Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi, USA Chuleeporn Changchit, Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi, USA Chapter 1.7. Teaching Online: What Does Blended Learning Require? .............................................. 84 P. Toyoko Kang, University of Guam, Guam Chapter 1.8. Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE) .................................................................................................. 103 Marshall G. Jones, Winthrop University, USA Stephen W. Harmon, Georgia State University, USA Chapter 1.9. The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities .................................................... 119 Jianxia Du, Mississippi State University, USA Yunyan Liu, Southwest University, China Robert L. Brown, Mississippi State University, USA Chapter 1.10. Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community ............................... 133 Adams Bodomo, University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Chapter 1.11. Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education........................... 144 Victor M. Hernández-Gantes, University of South Florida, USA Chapter 1.12. Collaborative Learning: Using Group Work Concepts for Online Teaching ............... 163 Lesley Cooper, Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada Sally Burford, University of Canberra, Australia Chapter 1.13. Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom: Bringing Theory and Practice to E-Learning .................................................................................................................. 179 F.R. “Fritz” Nordengren, Des Moines University, USA Ann M. York, Des Moines University, USA
Chapter 1.14. Classroom-in-a-Box: Rethinking Learning Community Classroom Environment Needs within Three-Dimensional Virtual Learning Environments ...... 195 Caroline M. Crawford, University of Houston – Clear Lake, USA Virginia Dickenson, eLumenata, USA Marion S. Smith, Texas Southern University, USA Chapter 1.15. Supporting the Implementation of Online Learning .................................................... 215 Daniel W. Surry, University of South Alabama, USA David C. Ensminger, Loyola University Chicago, USA Chapter 1.16. Measuring Effectiveness in Online Instruction ............................................................ 222 Louis B. Swartz, Robert Morris University, USA Michele T. Cole, Robert Morris University, USA Daniel J. Shelley, Robert Morris University, USA Chapter 1.17. A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses ........................................... 228 Yungwei Hao, National Taiwan Normal University, Taiwan Gary Borich, University of Texas at Austin, USA Section II. Development and Design Methodologies This section provides in-depth coverage of conceptual architectures, frameworks and methodologies related to the design and implementation of Web-based educational systems. Throughout these contributions, research fundamentals in the discipline are presented and discussed. From broad examinations to specific discussions on particular frameworks and infrastructures, the research found within this section spans the discipline while also offering detailed, specific discussions. Basic designs, as well as abstract developments, are explained within these chapters, and frameworks for educating and preparing online instructors, designing virtual classrooms, and creating effective user interfaces are provided. Chapter 2.1. Spiraling into Transformative Learning ......................................................................... 249 Patricia Cranton, The Pennsylvania State University, Harrisburg, USA Chapter 2.2. Transitioning to E-Learning: Teaching the Teachers...................................................... 259 Bethany Bovard, New Mexico State University, USA Susan Bussmann, New Mexico State University, USA Julia Parra, New Mexico State University, USA Carmen Gonzales, New Mexico State University, USA Chapter 2.3. Preparing Online Instructors: Beyond Using the Technology........................................ 277 Evelyn S. Johnson, Boise State University, USA Jane Pitcock, Walden University, USA Chapter 2.4. A Description of Online Instructors Use of Design Theory ........................................... 293 MarySue Cicciarelli, Duquesne University, USA
Chapter 2.5. Internet-Enabled User Interfaces for Distance Learning................................................ 302 We Liu, National University of Singapore, Singapore Keng Soon Teh, National University of Singapore, Singapore Roshan Peiris, National University of Singapore, Singapore Yongsoon Choi, National University of Singapore, Singapore Adrian David Cheok, National University of Singapore, Singapore Charissa Lim Mei-Ling, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore Yin-Leng Theng, Nanyang Technological University, Singapore Ta Huynh Duy Nguyen, National University of Singapore, Singapore Tran Cong Thien Qui, National University of Singapore, Singapore Athanasios V. Vasilakos, University of Peloponnese, Greece Chapter 2.6. Balancing Tradeoffs in Designing, Deploying, and Authoring Interactive Web-Based Learn-By-Doing Environments............................................................... 328 Lin Qiu, State University of New York at Oswego, USA Chapter 2.7. Supporting Group and Individual Processes in Web-Based Collaborative Learning Environments ......................................................................................... 345 F. Pozzi, Istituto Tecnologie Didattiche – CNR, Italy Chapter 2.8. Designing Dynamic Learning Environment for Web 2.0 Application ........................... 364 Robert Z. Zheng, University of Utah, USA Chapter 2.9. Designing Web-Based Training Courses to Maximize Learning ................................... 381 Traci Sitzmann, Advanced Distributed Learning Co-Laboratory, USA Katherine Ely, George Mason University, USA Robert Wisher, U.S. Department of Defense, USA Chapter 2.10. Implementing Successful Online Learning Communities ........................................... 394 Diane E.Beck, University of Florida, USA Sven A.Normann, University of Florida, USA Chapter 2.11. Web Accessibility Essentials for Online Course Developers ....................................... 405 Jozenia Torres Colorado, Emporia State University, USA Jane H. Eberle, Emporia State University, USA Chapter 2.12. Designing the Virtual Classroom for Management Teaching ...................................... 418 Parissa Haghirian, Sophia University, Japan Bernd Simon, Vienna University of Economics and Business Administration, Austria Chapter 2.13. Augmenting Collaboration with Personalization Services ........................................... 435 Christina E. Evangelou, Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece Manolis Tzagarakis, Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece Nikos Karousos, Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece George Gkotsis, Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece Dora Nousia, Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece
Chapter 2.14. Profiling Group Activity of Online Academic Workspaces: The Hellenic Open University Case Study................................................................................... 446 D. Karaiskakis, Hellenic Open University, Greece D. Kalles, Hellenic Open University, Greece Th. Hadzilacos, Hellenic Open University, Greece Chapter 2.15. The Effectiveness of Scaffolding in a Web-Based, Adaptive Learning System........... 459 Mei-Yu Chang, National Hsinchu University of Education, Taiwan Wernhuar Tarng, National Hsinchu University of Education, Taiwan Fu-Yu Shin, Chien-Kuo Elementary School, Taiwan Chapter 2.16. Community of Inquiry in Adult Online Learning: Collaborative-Constructivist Approaches..................................................................................... 474 Zehra Akyol, Middle East Technical University, Turkey D. Randy Garrison, University of Calgary, Canada Chapter 2.17. Development of Online Distributed Training: Practical Considerations and Lesson Learned ............................................................................................. 490 Eileen B. Entin, Aptima Inc., USA Jason Sidman, Aptima Inc., USA Lisa Neal, eLearn Magazine, USA Chapter 2.18. Virtual Tour: A Web-Based Model of Instruction......................................................... 502 Melissa B. Holler, Agora Cyber Charter School, USA Chapter 2.19. Enhancing Skills of Application Software via Web-Enabled Problem-Based Learning and Self-Regulated Learning: An Exploratory Study ......................... 508 Pei-Di Shen, Ming Chuan University, Taiwan Tsang-Hsiung Lee, National Chengchi University, Taiwan Chia-Wen Tsai, Ming Chuan University, Taiwan Section III. Tools and Technologies This section presents extensive coverage of the technology that informs and impacts Web-based education. These chapters provide an in-depth analysis of the use and development of innumerable devices and tools, while also providing insight into new and upcoming technologies, theories, and instruments that will soon be commonplace. Within these rigorously researched chapters, readers are presented with examples of the tools that facilitate and support the emergence and advancement of Web-based education. In addition, the successful implementation and resulting impact of these various tools and technologies are discussed within this collection of chapters. Chapter 3.1. Student Perceptions and Pedagogical Applications of E-Learning Tools in Online Course ................................................................................................................. 524 C. Candace Chou, University of St. Thomas, USA
Chapter 3.2. The Hybrid Course: Facilitating Learning through Social Interaction Technologies ................................................................................................................................. 540 Lorraine D. Jackson, California Polytechnic State University, USA Joe Grimes, California Polytechnic State University, USA Chapter 3.3. Integrated Design of Web-Platform, Offline Supports, and Evaluation System for the Successful Implementation of University 2.0 ................................................................... 553 Soyoung Kim, Yonsei University, Korea Minyoung Kim, Yonsei University, Korea Junhee Hong, Kyungwon University, Korea Chapter 3.4. Using a User-Interactive QA System for Personalized E-Learning ............................... 572 Dawei Hu, University of Science and Technology of China, China Wei Chen, City University of Hong Kong, China Qingtian Zeng, Shandong University of Science and Technology, China Tianyong Hao, City University of Hong Kong, China Feng Min, City University of Hong Kong, China Liu Wenyin, City University of Hong Kong, China Chapter 3.5. Examining the Relationship Between Course Management Systems, Presentation Software, and Student Learning: An Exploratory Factor Analysis ......................... 592 Daria C. Crawley, Robert Morris University, USA Barbara A. Frey, University of Pittsburgh, USA Chapter 3.6. Web-Based Interface Elements in Team Interaction and Learning: Theoretical and Empirical Analysis ............................................................................................. 607 Klarissa Ting-Ting Chang, Carnegie Mellon University, USA John Lim, National University of Singapore, Singapore Yingqin Zhong, National University of Singapore, Singapore Chapter 3.7. Opportunities for Open Source E-Learning ................................................................... 633 Fanuel Dewever, IBM, Belgium Chapter 3.8. A Learning Platform for the Introduction of Remote Sensing Principles in Higher Education: A Pilot Phase Application .......................................................................... 643 Nektaria Adaktilou, University of Athens, Greece Costas Cartalis, University of Athens, Greece George Kalkanis, University of Athens, Greece Chapter 3.9. eLearning in the Cloud ................................................................................................... 661 Niall Sclater, The Open University, UK Chapter 3.10. Transforming Pedagogy Using Mobile Web 2.0 .......................................................... 671 Thomas Cochrane, Unitec, New Zealand Roger Bateman, Unitec, New Zealand
Chapter 3.11. Web 2.0 and Collaborative Learning in Higher Education .......................................... 699 Anna Escofet, Universitat de Barcelona, Spain Marta Marimon, Universitat de Vic, Spain Chapter 3.12. Awareness Mechanisms for Web-Based Argumentative Collaboration ....................... 715 Manolis Tzagarakis, Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece Nikos Karousos, Research Academic Computer Technology Institute, Greece Nikos Karacapilidis,University of Patras, Greece Chapter 3.13. Quasi-Facial Communication for Online Learning Using 3D Modeling Techniques ............................................................................................................. 727 Yushun Wang, Zhejiang University, China Yueting Zhuang, Zhejiang University, China Chapter 3.14. Online Learning with the Use of WebCT Vista ............................................................ 738 Alina M. Zapalska, U.S. Coast Guard Academy, USA Dallas Brozik, Marshall University, USA Chapter 3.15. On Using Wiki as a Tool for Collaborative Online Blended Learning ........................ 746 Steve Wheeler, University of Plymouth, UK Chapter 3.16. Use of Wikis to Support Collaboration among Online Students .................................. 758 Jay Alden, National Defense University, USA Chapter 3.17. A Case of Using Wikis to Foster Collaborative Learning: Pedagogical Potential and Recommendations .............................................................................. 775 Hong Lin, Oklahoma State University, USA Kathleen D. Kelsey, Oklahoma State University, USA Section IV. Utilization and Application This section introduces and discusses the utilization and application of Web-based educational systems around the world. These particular selections highlight, among other topics, online teacher training programs, the creation of online virtual laboratories, and current Web-based teaching practices from India to Japan to Brazil. Contributions included in this section provide excellent coverage of today’s online environment and insight into how health information systems impact the fabric of our presentday global village. Chapter 4.1. Exploration on E-learning Methods and Factors Hindering their Usage: An Empirical Case Investigation .................................................................................................. 791 Chengbo Wang, Glasgow Caledonian University & University of Bolton, UK Chapter 4.2. Stories of Engagement with E-Learning: Revisiting the Taxonomy of Learning .......... 801 Geoffrey Lautenbach, University of Johannesburg, South Africa
Chapter 4.3. Formative Assessment in Distance Learning Education with Cognitive and Metacognitive Measurements ............................................................................... 810 Edson Pinheiro Pimentel, IMES University, Brazil Nizam Omar, Mackenzie P. University, Brazil Chapter 4.4. Adaptive Learning Organizer for Web-Based Education ............................................... 820 Amel Yessad, INRIA Sophia Antipolis, France Catherine Faron-Zucker, University of Nice, France Rose Dieng-Kuntz Edelweiss, INRIA Sophia Antipolis, France Med Tayeb Laskri, Université Badji Mokhtar, Algeria Chapter 4.5. The Blended Learning Classroom: An Online Teacher Training Program .................... 834 Karen García, University of Massachusetts, USA Renata Suzuki, Sophia University, Japan Chapter 4.6. Online Learning: A Transforming Educational Environment for Adults in Higher Education...................................................................................................................... 852 Patsy D. Moskal, University of Central Florida, USA Charles Dziuban, University of Central Florida, USA Joel Hartman, University of Central Florida, USA Chapter 4.7. Second Language E-Learning and Professional Training with Second Life® .............. 867 Patricia Edwards, University of Extremadura, Spain Mercedes Rico, University of Extremadura, Spain Eva Dominguez, University of Extremadura, Spain J. Enrique Agudo, University of Extremadura, Spain Chapter 4.8. Using On-Line Discussion to Encourage Reflective Thinking in Pre-Service Teachers ................................................................................................................ 888 E. Gregory Holdan, Robert Morris University, USA Mary Hansen, Robert Morris University, USA Chapter 4.9. Synchronous Hybrid E-Learning: Teaching Complex Information Systems Classes Online .............................................................................................................................. 897 Solomon Negash, Kennesaw State University, USA Marlene V. Wilcox, Bradley University, USA Michelle Emerson, Kennesaw State University, USA Chapter 4.10. An Online Virtual Laboratory of Electricity................................................................. 910 J. A. Gómez Tejedor, Polytechnic University of Valencia, Spain G. Moltó Martínez, Polytechnic University of Valencia, Spain C. Barros Vidaurre, Polytechnic University of Valencia, Spain Chapter 4.11. Developing a Community of Practice in an Online Research Lab............................... 923 Stephanie Cawthon, The University of Texas at Austin, USA Alycia L. Harris, Walden University, USA
Chapter 4.12. Web 2.0 Technologies for Problem-Based and Collaborative Learning: A Case Study ................................................................................................................................ 939 Clive N. Buckley, Glyndŵr University, UK Angela M. Williams, Glyndŵr University, UK Chapter 4.13. Adult Learners Learning Online: A Case Study of a Blogging Experience ................. 947 Danilo M. Baylen, University of West Georgia, USA Chapter 4.14. Reaching Beyond Bricks and Mortar: How Sylvan Online Expands Learners’ Options ......................................................................................................................... 962 Saul Rockman, Rockman et al., USA Lynn Fontana, Sylvan Learning, USA Chapter 4.15. Some Key Success Factors in Web-Based Corporate Training in Brazil ..................... 975 Luiz Antonio Joia, Brazilian School of Public and Business Administration of Getulio Vargas Foundation and Rio de Janeiro State University, Brazil Chapter 4.16. Delivery of a Social Science Online Program in India ................................................ 995 Shobhita Jain, Indira Gandhi National Open University, New Delhi, India Chapter 4.17. Integrating Classroom and Online Instruction in an Introductory American Government Course ................................................................................................... 1006 Richard Engstrom, Georgia State University, USA Chapter 4.18. Teaching Criminology and Police Science for Postgraduate Students at the Ruhr- University Bochum, Germany................................................................................ 1019 Diana Ziegleder, Ruhr-University Bochum, Germany Felix Feldmann-Hahn, Ruhr-University Bochum, Germany Chapter 4.19. Blending Classroom Activities with Multi-User Virtual Environment for At-Risk Primary School Students in an After-School Program: A Case Study .................... 1036 Lee Yong Tay, Beacon Primary School, Singapore Cher Ping Lim, Edith Cowan University, Western Australia Chapter 4.20. E-Learning Practice and Experience at Waseda E-School: Japan’s First Undergraduate Degree-Awarding Online Program ............................................... 1055 Shoji Nishimura, Waseda University, Japan Douglass J. Scott, Waseda University, Japan Shogo Kato, Waseda University, Japan Chapter 4.21. Web-Based Implementation of the Personalised System of Instruction: A Case Study of Teaching Mathematics in an Online Learning Environment........................... 1075 Willem-Paul Brinkman, Brunel University, UK AndrewRae, Brunel University, UK Yogesh Kumar Dwivedi, Swansea University, UK
Chapter 4.22. Autism and Family Interventions through Technology: A Description of a Web-Based Tool to Educate Fathers of Children with Autism............................................ 1102 Richard E. Ferdig, Kent State University, USA Hilary G. Amberg, University of Florida, USA Jennifer H. Elder, University of Florida, USA Susan A. Donaldson, University of Florida, USA Gregory Valcante, University of Florida, USA Roxanna Bendixen, University of Florida, USA Section V. Organizational and Social Implications This section includes a wide range of research pertaining to the social and organizational impact of Web-based education. Chapters included in this section analyze the social psychology of online collaborative learning, provide guidelines for synchronous and asynchronous teaching in Web-based courses, discuss classroom management in Online courses, and present various student and faculty perspectives and experiences with online learning software. The inquiries and methods presented in this section offer insight into the implications of Web-based education at both a personal and organizational level, while also emphasizing potential areas of study within the discipline. Chapter 5.1. Perspectives on the Realities of Virtual Learning: Examining Practice, Commitment, and Conduct......................................................................................................... 1118 Kristina K. Carrier, University of Idaho, USA Chapter 5.2. Bothering with Technology: Building Community in an Honors Seminar .................. 1127 John J. Doherty, Northern Arizona University, USA Chapter 5.3. The Social Psychology of Online Collaborative Learning: The Good, the Bad, and the Awkward .......................................................................................................... 1146 Donna Ashcraft, Clarion University of Pennsylvania, USA Thomas Treadwell, West Chester University, USA Chapter 5.4. Student and Faculty Use and Perceptions of Web 2.0 Technologies in Higher Education.................................................................................................................... 1162 Haya Ajjan, University of North Carolina at Charlotte, USA Richard Hartshorne, University of North Carolina at Charlotte, USA Richard E.Ferdig, Kent State University, USA Chapter 5.5. What Factors Promote Sustained Online Discussions and Collaborative Learning in a Web-Based Course? ............................................................................................. 1182 Xinchun Wang, California State University, USA Chapter 5.6. Fostering Successful Learning Communities to Meet the Diverse Needs of University Students ..................................................................................................... 1203 Silvia L. Braidic, California University of Pennsylvania, USA
Chapter 5.7. Framing Pedagogy, Diminishing Technology: Teachers Experience of Online Learning Software ...................................................................................................... 1211 Julia Thornton, RMIT University, Australia Chapter 5.8. Humanizing Learning-at-Distance: Best Practice Guidelines for Synchronous Instructors ............................................................................................................. 1232 Kathleen Barclay, University of Phoenix School of Advanced Studies, USA Chapter 5.9. Herding Cats: Striking a Balance Between Autonomy and Control in Online Classes ........................................................................................................................ 1239 Donald N. Philip, University of Toronto, Canada Chapter 5.10. Factors Influencing Students Intention to Take Web-Based Courses in a College Environment ........................................................................................................... 1256 Hamid Nemati, University of North Carolina at Greensboro, USA Marcia Thompson, University of North Carolina at Greensboro, USA Chapter 5.11. Classroom Preferences: What Factors can Affect Students’ Attitudes on Different Classroom Settings?............................................................................................... 1268 Chuleeporn Changchit, Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi, USA Tim Klaus, Texas A&M University-Corpus Christi, USA Chapter 5.12. Learning With Online Activities: What Do Students Think About Their Experience?....................................................................................................................... 1280 Salam Abdallah, Abu Dhabi University, UAE Chapter 5.13. A Case Study of the Adult Learner’s Perception of Instructional Quality in Web-Based Online Courses ....................................................................................... 1308 Terry T. Kidd, University of Houston-Downtown, USA Holim Song, Texas Southern University, USA Section VI. Managerial Impact This section presents contemporary coverage of the managerial implications of Web-based learning technology. Particular contributions address the cost of implementing e-learning courses and support on a traditional campus, and how to best address institutional factors that might impede adoption of e-learning technology. The managerial research provided in this section allows administrators, practitioners, and researchers to gain a better sense of how Web-based education systems can inform their practices and behavior. Chapter 6.1. Fulfilling the Promise: Addressing Institutional Factors that Impede the Implementation of E-Learning 2.0 ....................................................................................... 1325 Judi Repman, Georgia Southern University, USA Cordelia Zinskie, Georgia Southern University, USA Elizabeth Downs, Georgia Southern University, USA
Chapter 6.2. Issues in Implementing Online Education in a Developing Country ........................... 1342 Tim Bristol, Crown College, USA Chapter 6.3. Costs of E-Learning Support: An Investigation Across 139 Small Projects ................ 1347 Paul Lam, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Josephine Csete, The Hong Kong Polytechnic University, Hong Kong Carmel McNaught, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong Chapter 6.4. E-Learning University Networks: An Approach to a Quality Open Education ........... 1362 Elena Verdú Pérez, CEDETEL, Spain María Jesús Verdú Pérez, Universidad de Valladolid, Spain Chapter 6.5. An Evaluation of Blending Technology with Pedagogy for Teaching Educators and its Implication for their Classroom Teaching ...................................................................... 1376 Carol Kahan Kennedy, Fordham University, USA Maureen Hinkley, Fairfield University, USA Chapter 6.6. Cost Effectiveness in Course Redesign: The Transformation Toward E-Learning...... 1392 David Kendrick, University of Northern Colorado, USA Section VII. Critical Issues This section addresses conceptual and theoretical issues related to the field of Web-based education, which include issues related to instruction, collaboration, and academic integrity. Within these chapters, the reader is presented with analysis of the most current and relevant conceptual inquires within this growing field of study. Particular chapters address the impact of a student code on distance learning classrooms, the use of blogs in Web-based educational projects, the role of orientation materials in online courses, and various methods to promote collaborative effort among students. Overall, contributions within this section ask unique, often theoretical questions related to the study of Web-based learning technologies and, more often than not, conclude that solutions are both numerous and contradictory. Chapter 7.1. Adult Learners, E-Learning, and Success: Critical Issues and Challenges in an Adult Hybrid Distance Learning Program ......................................................................... 1400 Jeffrey Hsu, Fairleigh Dickinson University, USA Karin Hamilton, Fairleigh Dickinson University, USA Chapter 7.2. Instructor Presence in Online Distance Classes ........................................................... 1422 Janet Lear, University of Nebraska at Kearney, USA Chapter 7.3. Collaborative Work in Online Learning Environments: Critical Issues, Dynamics, and Challenges ......................................................................................................... 1428 Erman Yukselturk, Middle East Technical University, Turkey Kursat Cagiltay, Middle East Technical University, Turkey
Chapter 7.4. A Pedagogical Approach to the Design of Learning Objects for Complex Domains ................................................................................................................ 1445 Emanuela Busetti, Istituto di Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche del CNR, Italy Giuliana Dettori, Istituto di Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche del CNR, Italy Paola Forcheri, Istituto di Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche del CNR, Italy Maria Grazia Ierardi, Istituto di Matematica Applicata e Tecnologie Informatiche del CNR, Italy Chapter 7.5. Web-Based Collaboration and Decision Making Support: A Multi-Disciplinary Approach .................................................................................................. 1460 Nikos Karacapilidis, University of Patras, Greece Manolis Tzagarakis, University of Patras, Greece Chapter 7.6. Teaching Dimension in Web-Based Learning Communities ....................................... 1472 Francesca Pozzi, Istituto Tecnologie Didattiche – CNR, Italy Chapter 7.7. Culture and Language Learning in Computer-Enhanced or Assisted Language Learning .................................................................................................. 1482 Bolanle A. Olaniran, Texas Tech University, USA Chapter 7.8. Cross-Cultural Differences in Perceptions of E-Learning Usability: An Empirical Investigation ........................................................................................................ 1497 Panagiotis Zaharias, University of the Aegean, Greece Chapter 7.9. Metacognition for Enhancing Online Learning ........................................................... 1518 Giuseppe Chiazzese, Italian National Research Council, Italy Antonella Chifari, Italian National Research Council, Italy Gianluca Merlo, Italian National Research Council, Italy Simona Ottaviano, Italian National Research Council, Italy Luciano Seta, Italian National Research Council, Italy Chapter 7.10. Redefining Web Users’ Optimal Flow Experiences in Online Environments: An Empirical Analysis ....................................................................... 1531 Anshu Saxena Arora, Savannah State University-Savannah, USA Mahesh S. Raisinghani, TWU School of Management, USA Chapter 7.11. “Virtual Inquiry” in the Science Classroom: What is the Role of Technological Pedagogial Content Knowledge? ........................................................................ 1550 Eva Erdosne Toth, West Virginia University, USA Chapter 7.12. Blogging Minds on Web-Based Educational Projects................................................ 1561 Harrison Hao Yang, State University of New York at Oswego, USA Chapter 7.13. The Perfect Blend?: Online Blended Learning from a Linguistic Perspective .......... 1577 Roberto Di Scala, University of Modena and Reggio Emilia, Italy
Chapter 7.14. Do Orientation Materials Help Students Successfully Complete Online Courses? ......................................................................................................... 1590 Lawrence A. Tomei, Robert Morris University, USA Holly Hagle, Robert Morris University, USA Ashley Rineer, Robert Morris University, USA Lisa A Mastandrea, Robert Morris University, USA Jennifer Scollon, Regis University, USA Chapter 7.15. Did We Become a Community? Multiple Methods for Identifying Community and Its Constituent Elements in Formal Online Learning Environments .............. 1607 Richard A. Schwier, University of Saskatchewan, Canada Ben K. Daniel, University of Saskatchewan, Canada Chapter 7.16. When Distance Technologies Meet the Student Code ............................................... 1626 Peg Wherry, Montana State University, USA Deborah Lundberg Windes, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, USA Chapter 7.17. Web Accessibility Policy for Students with Disabilities in U.S. Postsecondary Distance Education ............................................................................................. 1644 Heidi L. Wilkes, Northeastern University, USA Chapter 7.18. The Impact of Sociocultural Factors in Multicultural Communication Environments: A Case Example from an Australian University’s Provision of Distance Education in the Global Classroom ........................................................................ 1661 Angela T. Ragusa, Charles Sturt University, Australia Section VIII. Emerging Trends This section highlights research potential within the field of health information systems while exploring uncharted areas of study for the advancement of the discipline. Chapters within this section highlight new trends in digital e-learning environments, mobile technology as an e-learning tool, and the use of Web 2.0 in the classroom. These contributions, which conclude this exhaustive, multi-volume set, provide emerging trends and suggestions for future research within this rapidly expanding discipline. Chapter 8.1. Emerging Frontiers of Learning Online: Digital Ecosystems, Blended Learning and Implications for Adult Learning ........................................................................... 1684 Glenn Finger, Griffith University, Australia Pei-Chen Sun, National Kaohsiung Normal University, Taiwan Romina Jamieson-Proctor, University of Southern Queensland, Australia Chapter 8.2. Wired for Learning—Web 2.0 for Teaching and Learning: Trends, Challenges, and Opportunities for Education ................................................................................................ 1696 Irene Chen, University of Houston-Downtown, USA Terry T. Kidd, Texas A&M University, USA
Chapter 8.3. New Functions for Stimulating Learners’ Motivation in a Web-Based e-Learning System ...................................................................................................................... 1709 Keita Matsuo, Fukuoka Institute of Technology, Japan Leonard Barolli, Fukuoka Institute of Technology, Japan Fatos Xhafa, Polytechnic University of Catalonia, Spain Akio Koyama, Yamagata University, Japan Arjan Durresi, Indiana University Purdue University, USA Chapter 8.4. A Changed Economy with Unchanged Universities? A Contribution to the University of the Future........................................................................................................ 1723 Maria Manuela Cunha, Polytechnic Institute of Cavado and Ave, Portugal Goran D.Putnik, Univeristy of Minho, Portugal Chapter 8.5. Web-Based Video for E-Learning: Tapping into the YouTube™ Phenomenon ........... 1745 Chareen Snelson, Boise State University, USA Chapter 8.6. E-Learning 2.0: Web 2.0, the Semantic Web and the Power of Collective Intelligence ................................................................................................................ 1765 Chaka Chaka, Walter Sisulu University, South Africa Chapter 8.7. A Rough Set Based Approach to Find Learners’ Key Personality Attributes in an E-Learning Environment .................................................................................. 1788 Qinghua Zheng, Xi’an Jiaotong University, China Xiyuan Wu, Xi’an Jiaotong University, China Haifei Li, Union University, USA Chapter 8.8. Web-Based Education Accountability System and Organisational Changes: An Actor-Network Approach ..................................................................................................... 1812 Xueguang Ma, University of Maryland, USA Roy Rada, University of Maryland, USA Chapter 8.9. Development of a Web-Based System for Diagnosing Student Learning Problems on English Tenses ....................................................................................................... 1825 Gwo-Jen Hwang, National University of Tainan, Taiwan Hsiang Cheng, National Chi Nan University, Taiwan Carol H.C. Chu, National Chi Nan University, Taiwan Judy C.R. Tseng, Chung-Hua University, Taiwan Gwo-Haur Hwang, Ling Tung University, Taiwan Chapter 8.10. Mobile e-Learning for Next Generation Communication Environment .................... 1844 Tin-Yu Wu, I-Shou University, Taiwan Han-Chieh Chao, National Dong Hwa University, Taiwan
Chapter 8.11. The eLogBook Framework: Sustaining Interaction, Collaboration, and Learning in Laboratory-Oriented CoPs ............................................................................... 1856 Yassin Rekik, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Suisse Denis Gillet, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Suisse Sandy El Helou, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Suisse Christophe Salzmann, École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne (EPFL), Suisse Chapter 8.12. A Novel Architecture for E-Learning Knowledge Assessment Systems.................... 1870 Krzysztof Gierlowski, Gdansk University of Technology, Poland Krzysztof Nowicki, Gdansk University of Technology, Poland
xxviii
Preface
In an age where online universities and distance learning courses exist side by side with traditional classroom learning, the development, design, use and challenges of creating web-based learning systems that promote learning in students, whether over a distance or within a university proper, is increasingly complex and often difficult. With the constant changes in the landscape of web-based educational technology, it is a challenge for researchers, practitioners, and experts to take in the volume of innovative advances and up-to-themoment research in this diverse field. Information Science Reference is pleased to offer a three-volume reference collection on this rapidly growing discipline, in order to empower students, researchers, academicians, and practitioners with a wide-ranging understanding of the most critical areas within this field of study. This collection provides the most comprehensive, in-depth, and recent coverage of all issues related to the development of cutting-edge web-based educational technology, as well as a single reference source on all conceptual, methodological, technical and managerial issues, and the opportunities, future challenges and emerging trends related to the development, application, and implications of web-based educational technology. This collection titled, “Web-based Education: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools and Applications” is organized in eight (8) distinct sections, providing the most wide-ranging coverage of topics such as: 1) Fundamental Concepts and Theories; 2) Development and Design Methodologies; 3) Tools and Technologies; 4) Utilization and Application; 5) Organizational and Social Implications; 6) Managerial Impact; 7) Critical Issues; and 8) Emerging Trends. The following provides a summary of what is covered in each section of this multi-volume reference collection: Section I, Fundamental Concepts and Theories, serves as a foundation for this extensive reference tool by addressing crucial theories essential to the understanding of web-based educational technology. Chapters such as “A Brief History of eLearning” by Terry T. Kidd and “The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education” by Leah Blakey treat the reader to an overview to web-based education and provide a historical look at its evolution. “Why Choose an Online Course?” by Lawrence Tomei, April Kwiatkowski, Lorie Brown, Lori Pash, Christine Javery, Julie Ray, and Rae Ann Durocher and “Online or Traditional: A Study to Examine Course Characteristics Contributing to Students’ Preference for Classroom Settings” by Tim Klaus and Chuleeporn Changchit provide insight into the decision making process of students considering online courses, and offer guidelines to institutions considering online courses. Later selections, including “Measuring Effectiveness in Online Instruction” by Louis B. Swartz, Michele T. Cole, and Daniel J. Shelley and “A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses” by Yungwei Hao and Gary Borich highlight and respond to the challenges of creating frameworks for evaluating the effectiveness of web-based courses. These and several other foundational chapters provide a wealth of expert research on the elemental concepts and ideas which surround web-based education.
xxix
Section II, Development and Design Methodologies, presents in-depth coverage of the conceptual design and architecture of a web-based educational systems, focusing on aspects including teacher training, virtual space design, and user interfaces. Design concerns are the focus of such chapters as “Where Do I Begin? Designing Online Learning Courses Which Work” by Kathleen P. King and “Designing Web-Based Training Courses to Maximize Learning” by Traci Sitzmann, Katherine Ely, and Robert Wisher, emphasizing the need to create feasible web-based courses and successfully impart knowledge to students. “Transitioning to E-Learning: Teaching the Teachers” by Carmen Gonzales, Susan Bussmann, Bethany Bovard, and Julia Parra and “Preparing Online Instructors: Beyond Using the Technology” by Evelyn S. Johnson and Jane Pitcock explore various aspects of online instructor training, including successful utilization of online technology and facilitation of learner-to-learner interaction. Francesca Pozzi’s “Supporting Group and Individual Processes in Web-Based Collaborative Learning Environments” tackles the question of how to integrate individual learning differences in the design of Web-based collaborative learning experiences. With contributions from leading international researchers, this section offers copious developmental approaches and methodologies for the design and implementation of web-based education. Section III, Tools and Technologies, presents extensive coverage of the various tools and technologies used in the development and implementation of web-based learning. This comprehensive section opens with the chapter , “Student Perceptions and Pedagogical Applications of E-Learning Tools in Online Course,” by C. Candace Chou, which describes student views of various e-learning tools in an online course for pre-service and in-service teachers. The application of Web 2.0 technologies is explored in selections such as “Transforming Pedagogy Using Mobile Web 2.0” by Thomas Cochrane and Roger Bateman and “Web 2.0 and Collaborative Learning in Higher Education” by Anna Escofet and Marta Marimon. Later selections such as “On Using Wiki as a Tool for Collaborative Online Blended Learning” by Steve Wheeler, “Use of Wikis to Support Collaboration among Online Students” by Jay Alden, and “A Case of Using Wikis to Foster Collaborative Learning: Pedagogical Potential and Recommendations” by Hong Lin and Kathleen D. Kelsey explain how Wiki technology can be used for collaborative learning in web-based educational environments. In all, this section provides coverage of a variety of tools and technologies that inform and enhance modern web-based educational environments. Section IV, Utilization and Application, describes how web-based educational systems have been utilized and offers insight on important lessons for their continued use and evolution. Including chapters such as “Exploration on E-learning Methods and Factors Hindering their Usage: An Empirical Case Investigation” by Chengbo Wang and “Stories of Engagement with E-Learning: Revisiting the Taxonomy of Learning” by Geoffrey Lautenbach, this section investigates the numerous methodologies that have been proposed and enacted as web-based learning technologies have grown in popularity. As this section continues, a number of case studies in the use of web-based learning are presented from all over the world, in selections such as “Some Key Success Factors in Web-Based Corporate Training in Brazil” by Luiz Antonio Joia, “E-Learning Practice and Experience at Waseda E-School: Japan’s First Undergraduate Degree-Awarding Online Program” by Shoji Nishimura, Douglass J. Scott, and Shogo Kato and “Delivery of a Social Science Online Program in India” by Shobhita Jain. Contributions found in this section provide comprehensive coverage of the practicality and current use of web-based learning. Section V, Organizational and Social Implications, includes chapters discussing the importance of addressing organizational and social impact in the evaluation and design of any web-based education. “Herding Cats: Striking a Balance Between Autonomy and Control in Online Classes” by Donald N.
xxx
Philip explores effective classroom management techniques for use in web-based distance courses, and “Humanizing Learning-at-Distance: Best Practice Guidelines for Synchronous Instructors” by Kathleen Barclay address specific issues and trends in synchronous and asynchronous learning environments, offering theoretical and practical techniques to support collaborative synchronous instruction. This section continues with investigations of student and teacher reactions to web-based and e-learning technology in chapters such as “Framing Pedagogy, Diminishing Technology: Teachers Experience of Online Learning Software” by Julia Thornton, “Learning With Online Activities: What Do Students Think About Their Experience?” by Salam Abdallah, and “Student and Faculty Use and Perceptions of Web 2.0 Technologies in Higher Education” by Haya Ajjan, Richard Hartshorne, Richard E.Ferdig. Overall, these chapters present a detailed investigation of the complex relationship between individuals, organizations and web-based courses and technologies. Section VI, Managerial Impact, presents focused coverage of web-based educational technologies as they relate to improvements and considerations in academic environments. “Fulfilling the Promise: Addressing Institutional Factors that Impede the Implementation of E-Learning 2.0” by Judi Repman, Cordelia Zinskie, and Elizabeth Downs highlights the limits of the business model approach to online learning,especially for faculty who want to utilize Web 2.0 technologies to create e-learning experiences for their students. “Cost Effectiveness in Course Redesign: The Transformation toward E-Learning” by David Kendrick presents evidence that transitioning from traditional to electronic course instruction can not only grant access or improve achievement for the student, but can offer a cost savings for the institution. In all, the chapters in this section offer specific perspectives on how managerial perspectives and developments in web-based education inform each other to create more meaningful user experiences. Section VII, Critical Issues, addresses vital issues related to web-based education, which include collaborative work, cultural considerations, and the creation of community among course participants. Chapters such as “Collaborative Work in Online Learning Environments: Critical Issues, Dynamics, and Challenges” by Erman Yukselturk and Kursat Cagiltay and “Web-Based Collaboration and Decision Making Support: A Multi-Disciplinary Approach” by Nikos Karacapilidis and Manolis Tzagarakis discuss issues that impact the success of collaborative working online learning groups, as well as tools that can be used to successfully foster collaborative work. Later selections, such as “Cross-Cultural Differences in Perceptions of E-Learning Usability: An Empirical Investigation” by Panagiotis Zaharias discuss the need to design international e-learning applications, with special focus on sensitivity to cultural differences. “When Distance Technologies Meet the Student Code” by Peg Wherry and Deborah Lundberg Windes sheds lights onto the challenges to academic integrity in online learning, and offers steps to aid administrators and course designers as they work to improve honesty in online courses. This section continues by asking unique questions about orientation materials in web-based courses, optimal flow experiences in online environments, and web accessibility for students with disabilities. The concluding section of this authoritative reference tool, Emerging Trends, highlights areas for future research within the field of web-based education, while exploring new avenues for the advancement of the discipline. Beginning this section is “Emerging Frontiers of Learning Online: Digital Ecosystems, Blended Learning and Implications for Adult Learning” by Glenn Finger, Pei-Chen Sun, and Romina Jamieson-Proctor. This selection proposes digital ecosystems as successors to current e-learning environments, in order to facilitate centralization, interoperability, and utilization of technologies for curriculum, pedagogy and assessment. New approaches to virtual and flexible university education are presented in “A Changed Economy with Unchanged Universities? A Contribution to the University of the Future” by Maria Manuela Cunha and Goran D. Putnik. This chapter proposes an Agile/Virtual University concept
xxxi
for web-based learning, and outlines the supporting environment that such an implementation would require. These and several other emerging trends and suggestions for future research can be found within the final section of this exhaustive multi-volume set. Although the primary organization of the contents in this multi-volume work is based on its eight sections, offering a progression of coverage of the important concepts, methodologies, technologies, applications, social issues, and emerging trends, the reader can also identify specific contents by utilizing the extensive indexing system listed at the end of each volume. Furthermore to ensure that the scholar, researcher and educator have access to the entire contents of this multi volume set as well as additional coverage that could not be included in the print version of this publication, the publisher will provide unlimited multi-user electronic access to the online aggregated database of this collection for the life of the edition, free of charge when a library purchases a print copy. This aggregated database provides far more contents than what can be included in the print version in addition to continual updates. This unlimited access, coupled with the continuous updates to the database ensures that the most current research is accessible to knowledge seekers. As a comprehensive collection of research on the latest findings related to technologies and healthcare delivery, Web-based Education: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools and Applications, provides researchers, administrators and all audiences with a complete understanding of the development of applications and concepts in web-based education. Given the meteoric rise in web-based courses, distance learning, and e-learning in both traditional settings and virtual environments, Web-based Education: Concepts, Methodologies, Tools and Applications, addresses the demand for a resource that encompasses the most pertinent research in web-based educational design, deployment, and impact.
Section I
Fundamental Concepts and Theories This section serves as the foundation for this exhaustive reference tool by addressing crucial theories essential to the understanding of Web-based learning. Chapters found within these pages provide an excellent framework in which to position Web-based education within the field of information science and technology. Individual contributions provide overviews of the history of e-learning, students’ decision to use online versus traditional courses, Web-based resources for teaching, and key elements of online learning communities. Within this introductory section, the reader can learn and choose from a compendium of expert research on the elemental theories underscoring health information systems research
1
Chapter 1.1
A Brief History of eLearning Terry T. Kidd Texas A&M University, USA
AbstrAct
MAIn thrust
The purpose of this chapter is to explore prior research associated with the history of eLearning. While issues related to the eLearning, technology and innovation adoption, the online environment, the role of faculty in online environments, and preparing faculty for online instruction are important, it is prudent to examine the history of this innovation in order to chart the future of such practices.
historical Perspectives of eLearning
IntroductIon Investigation into faculty adoption of eLearning for the purpose of quality teaching and its implications for training and faculty development, policy, and leadership, not only draws upon academic foundations, but also advances practice aimed to explore the technical, cognitive, and aesthetic basis of signifying human interaction as mediated by technology. This chapter will center upon several interrelated topics to explore the historical developments of eLearning. DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-830-7.ch004
The origins of eLearning as currently practiced in higher education stem from the insightful work of Suppes (1964) and Bitzer (1962). While others such as Porter (1959) and Uttal (1962) were also active early in this field (Fletcher, 2002), only Suppes and Bitzer clearly situated the use of technology within a broader educational agenda (Suppes, 1964, 1966, 1986). It is important to note that there is no single evolutionary point of which the eLearning originated nor is there a single agreed definition of eLearning. Since the 1960s, eLearning has evolved in different ways affecting Business, Education, the Training sector, and the Military (Fletcher & Rockway, 1986) in different ways. eLearning means different things in different sectors. In the higher education sector, “e-Leaning” refers to the use of both software-based and online learning, whereas in Business, Higher-Education, the Military and Training sectors, it refers solely to a range of online practices (Campbell, 2004). Our focus for this paper is e-learning in higher education.
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
A Brief History of eLearning
In the 1960s, there were few educational applications of computers in universities. It was thought that the high cost of technology would prevent its ubiquitous uptake as an educational tool. Suppes (1964; 1966) argued that: in the future it would be possible for all students to have access to the service of a personal tutor in the same way that ancient royals were once served by individual tutors, but that this time the tutors would be in the form of a computer. (Suppes, 1964; 1966) Further, he argued that the single most powerful argument for the use of computers in education is individualized instruction and the dialogue that it supports. This was not an idle conjecture, but was based on Bloom’s (1984) research that demonstrated that one-on-one tutoring improved student achievement by two standard deviations over group instruction. Individual tutorials, Suppes (1964; 1966) argued, were also a core aspect of the university and computers would embrace and extend this through the use of virtual learning environments. Suppes work (1964; 1966; 1986) and teaching was confined to structured fields and views of knowledge, with “drill and practice” approaches. Further, Suppes was concerned with both producing better learning, and learning how to be a better teacher with computers. Contemporary critiques of his approach often overlook the lack of viable alternative paradigms at that time, something that Suppes was aware of. His research found that computer mediated instruction produced profound effects on learning, and identified changes in students’ understandings ranging from simple to complex. While his use of computers was essentially as a tool, he foresaw the potential for wider applications of computers in education. His research led to the foundation ground work for computer assisted learning. With Suppes foundation work on computer assisted learning (1964; 1966; 1986), it was
2
not until Blitzer (1962) who created PLATO, a timeshared computer system, can to address concerns about student literacy. According to Blitzer (1962) PLATO could be used to develop and deliver computer-based education, including literacy programs. It allowed educators and students to use high resolution graphics terminals and an educational programming language, TUTOR, to create and interact with educational courseware and to communicate with other users by means of electronic notes – the forerunner of today’s conferencing systems (Bitzer, Lichtenberger & Braunfeld, 1962). Woolley (1994) argues that as well as PLATO’s advances in Computer Assisted Instruction, its communication features were equally innovative and were the foundations of today’s conference and messaging systems: Two decades before the World Wide Web came on the scene, the PLATO system pioneered online forums and message boards, email, chat rooms, instant messaging, remote screen sharing, and multiplayer games, leading to the emergence of what was perhaps the world’s first online community. (Woolley, 1994) Comparing e-learning practice over time is problematic and fraught with a host of methodological concerns (Charp, 1997; Herrington, Reeves & Oliver, 2005; Mortera-Gutiérrez, 2006; Nicholson & McDougall, 2005; Pilla, Nakayama, Nicholson, P., 2006; Thomson, 2005). Table 1 provides an historical perspective based on macrolevel features, it says little about the processes and agency occurring under the various categories. The history of e-learning is best summed up as: “Opportunities multiply as they are seized.” (Sun Tzu, 410bc) as for the past 40 years, educators and trainers at all levels of higher education, business, training and the military made use of computers in different ways to support and enhance teaching and learning (Charp, 1997; Molnar, 1997). Consequently, the contemporary use of the term
A Brief History of eLearning
Table 1. Historical context of e-learning development Era
Focus
Educational Characteristics
1975-1985
Programming; Drill and practice; Computer-assisted learning – CAL
Behaviorist approaches to learning and instruction; programming to build tools and solve problems; Local user-computer interaction.
1983-1990
Computer-Based Training Multimedia
Use of older CAL models with interactive multimedia courseware; Passive learner models dominant; Constructivist influences begin to appear in educational software design and use.
1990-1995
Web Based Training
Internet-based content delivery; Active learner models developed; Constructivist perspectives common; Limited end-user interactions.
1995-2005
e-learning
Internet-based flexible courseware deliver; increased interactivity; online multimedia courseware; Distributed constructivist and cognitivist models common; Social networking; Remote user-user interactions.
“e-learning” has different meanings in different contexts (Campbell, 2004). Zahm (2000) described computer-based training (CBT) as delivered via CD-ROM or as a Web download and that it is usually multimedia-based. Karon (2000) discussed the convenience factor of well-designed computer-based learning by saying that any well-designed computer-based learning whether by a networked based or delivered via the Internet is more convenient than traditional instructor-led format. Hall (1997) incorporated both Zahm (2000) and Karon (2000) definitions by underlining computer-based learning as an all-encompassing term used to describe any computer-delivered learning including CD-ROM and World Wide Web. Hall further explained that some people use the term CBT to refer only to old-time, text-only training. Like CBT, online training was classified as an all encompassing term that refers to all training done with a computer over a network, including an organizations intranet, the organizations local area network, and the internet (Gotschall, 2000). Gotschall (2000) states that online learning is also known as net-based learning. Urdan & Weggen (2000), related that online learning constitutes just one part of e-learning and describes learning via internet, intranet and extranet. Urdan & Weggen (2000) added that levels of sophistication of online learning vary. It can extend from a basic
online learning program that includes text and graphics of the course, exercises, testing, and record keeping, such as test scores and bookmarks to a sophisticated online learning program. This sophistication would include animations, simulations, audio and video sequences peer and expert discussion groups, online mentoring, links to materials on a intranet or the web, and communications with corporate education records. Schreiber & Berge (1998) agreed with Gotschall (2000) and purported that online learning is any technology-based learning, that is, information currently available for direct access. Hall (2000) contends that e-learning takes the form of complete courses with access to content for “just-in-time” learning, access. Learning is and will continue to be a lifelong process, that could be accessed anywhere at anytime to meet a specific need or want. Hall added that more links to real-time data and research would become readily available. Given the progression of the definitions, then, web-based training, online learning, e-learning, distributed learning, internet-based learning and net-based learning all speak of each other (Hall & Snider, 2000; Urdan & Weggen, 2000). Similar to e-learning and its related terms is technology-based learning (Urdan & Weggen 2000). Urdan & Weggen shared that e-learning covers a wide set of applications and processes,
3
A Brief History of eLearning
including computer-based learning, web-based learning, virtual classrooms, and digital collaborations. For the purpose of their report, they further customized their definition to the delivery of content via all electronic media, including the Internet, intranets, extranets, satellite broadcast, audio/video tape, interactive TV, and CD-ROMra. They warned, however, that e-learning is defined more narrowly than distance learning, which would include text-based learning and courses conducted via written correspondence. Like Hall & Snider (2000), Urdan & Weggen (2000) have set apart distance learning and e-learning in their glossaries, making, however, e-learning inclusive and synonymous to all computer-related applications, tools and processes that have been strategically aligned to value-added learning and teaching processes. Interestingly, Urdan & Weggen (2000) saw e-learning as a subset of distance learning, online learning a subset of e-learning and computer-based learning as a subset of online learning. Further, another rationale for the choice of e-learning is that “just-in-time” learning is a major advantage of e-learning but not of distance learning. Distance learning purports planned courses, or planned experiences, e-learning does not only value planned learning, however, it also recognizes the value of the unplanned and the self directedness of the learner to maximize incidental learning to improve performance (Wentling, Waight, Gallagher, Fleur, Wang & Kanfer, 2000). In the higher education, business, and training sectors e-learning relates particularly to Internetbased flexible delivery of content and programs that focus on sustaining particular communities of practice. e-learning in business and training can be characterized as being driven by notions of improved productivity and cost reduction, especially in an increasingly globalize business environment, with a focus on content delivery and online course management. However for the contexts of this paper, we will focus on elearning in the higher education sector. These
4
sectors initially employed the limited learning models extant at the time, but have since moved to incorporate a diverse range of learning models and foci (Nicholson, 2004). Campbell (2004, p1) argues that: Broadly, in industry settings, e-learning reflects an emphasis on informal and non-formal, just-in-time learning where the emphasis is on collaborative productivity. Whilst, in higher education settings, best practice online learning emphasizes the development of metacognitive skills, where the emphasis is on reflective and collaborative learning. (Campbell, 2004, p1) In the context of the wider education community, the use of the term e-learning has historically had wider connotations that embrace a diverse range of practices, technologies, and theoretical positions. It is not only focused on online contexts, and includes the full range of computer-based learning platforms and delivery methods, genres, formats and media such as multimedia, educational programming, simulations, games and the use of new media on fixed and mobile platforms across all discipline areas. Further, e-learning is often characterized by active learning student centered pedagogical techniques (McDougall & Betts, 1997). The growth of E-learning in business and higher education, and its marketing as a “killerapp” (Friedman, 1999), has led to concerns about the influence of quality assurance driven models on the structure and quality of these programs (King, 2002; McGorry, 2003). Related concerns about its ability to deliver meaningful pedagogically structured learning experiences or to have a clearly identifiable learning paradigm have also been raised (Gillham, 2002; Stone Wiske, Sick, & Wirsig, 2001; Suthers, Hundhausen Girardeau., 2003). Recently, driven by such concerns, its focus has expanded to accommodate the incorporation of learner engagement and social-learning models (Mortera-Gutiérrez, 2006; Schroeder & Span-
A Brief History of eLearning
nagel, 2006). Since its inception, technological advances in computers and networks facilitated advances in e-learning as educators seized on new features in an attempt to adapt them to their needs, to accommodate new educational theories, or looked for the promise of enhanced functionality. Since its inception, e-learning has assimilated a diverse range of pedagogical practices, however the defining aspect of e-learning—the trend towards collaborative online learning environments—is not only a result of the increasing adoption of constructivist paradigms, but is also a consequence of the affordances of ubiquitous global networks that have facilitated the realization of individualized learning and interpersonal interactivity on a large scale, perhaps far exceeding the expectations of Suppes (1964; 1966; 1986) and Bitzer (1962) in its scale and scope. The contemporary claims for E-learning being ‘new or different’ arise in the different and independent development of the application of computers to educational needs in the business and education sectors, as well as from the ‘lost history’ of educational computing. It is clear that the early pioneers, confined by the dominant paradigms and technologies of their time, were striving to move beyond their contemporary practices to better engage learners and to enhance teaching and learning: at the inception of the field, PLATO contained features that pre-empted, and now characterize, cutting-edge third generation E-learning systems. It is accepted that according to Wentling, Waight, Gallagher, Fleur, Wang & Kanfer (2000), e-learning can be seen as the acquisition and use of knowledge distributed and facilitated primarily by electronic means. This form of learning currently depends on a variety of mean such as networks, computers, a variety of channels (e.g., wireless, satellite), and technologies (e.g., cellular phones, PDA’s) as they are developed and adopted. Further, e-learning can take the form of courses as well as modules and smaller learning objects that may
incorporate synchronous or asynchronous access that can be distributed geographically with varied limits of time.
Future dIrectIon And concLusIon E-learning offers a worldwide forum in which to teach courses. One can assume, for example, that each student at any time has an excellent encyclopedia at his or her disposal. Course material can be dynamically updated and linked across several related sources. Course text, examples and exercises can be interactive in the sense of immediately illustrating equations with graphs, changing parameters and seeing the results, linking to other web-sites according to the interests of the student. E-learning is free from limitations of space and time, while reaching adult learners in a global context. In addition, the e-learning offers students a wealth of information and opportunities for social networking that was never possible from the traditional classical setting. The possibility of linking to information worldwide in a multitude of formats creates a remarkably rich medium for learning. E-learning is not merely an electronic duplicate of the original course material. It represents a new type of educational materials which takes full advantage of the emerging Web and multimedia technologies in order to achieve an effective yet enjoyable learning process (Michael & Tait, 2002). Thus, complex concepts are introduced in innovative ways – ways that involve the adult learner and integrate them into the learning process. Full linking to vast resources available worldwide, introduces new levels of value to online courses in distance education. A e-learning is envisioned as a dynamically-evolving resource that will prove beneficial to both the adult learner and non tradition students and instructors alike. In light of its historical development, it is evident that the design of e-learning is a multifaceted process that resembles movie making in
5
A Brief History of eLearning
cinema productions. Thus, e-learning is developed through the efforts of a team of professionals with a complementary range of skills, as opposed to classical course design, which is typically developed by faculty alone. Designer and instructors alike will have to take head to principles in design, usability, interaction, etc in order to make online distance learning courses the top quality product for the next generation. The richness of modern Web and multimedia technologies allow for unlimited creativity when it comes to electronic courseware development. Such richness offers educators new opportunities to develop very interesting course material while it also poses a substantial challenge in that it requires faculty to rethink their own course offerings in the light of the new technologies. In order to best serve the adult learner population instructional designers, instructors, and course administration will have to take an active look at effective course design and communication strategies within online and web based courses. It is not enough for university, colleges, and other educational institutions to just give financial resources, hardware and software, but should fundamentally equip instructor to effectively teach, engage, extend, and enhance the adult learner’s learning experience, while in an online course offered via a distance. The future entails faculty training and development in designing effective and efficient online courses for the adult learning population. This trend can be seen at many major research institutions that offer online courses and e-learning training courses specifically for the adult learner. By equipping the instructor to effectively design e-learning courses in terms of online course interaction with both students and with the online content and materials, visual aesthetic in design and web architecture, convenience and open access to materials, positive and useful user feedback, communication, and usability of both the course content materials and course website, students will develop a consensus toward a positive view on the instructional quality of the online course. 6
It is important to understand that in order to foster an environment conducive to effective learning in the online atmosphere, we must pay close attention to the historical developments of e-learning. For such developments, the future seems very bright and encouraging. There is a great of discussion on the effective and systematic design of instruction, effective design of visual aesthetics, design of communication structure, and the available of open access to course content and materials in online courses, specifically for adult learners. This theme will be repeated as other aspects of e-learning come under scrutiny. We know enough at this point to optimize quality in design and delivery, however as history has shown us, e-learning has become a genre difficult to define and measure; that is why the more we discuss the topic of e-learning, the more strategies, processes, and procedures will be developed to effectively engage adult learner.
reFerences Bitzer, D. L., Lichtenberger, W., & Braunfeld, P. G. (1962). PLATO II: A multiple-student, computer controlled, automatic teaching device. In J. E. Coulson (Ed.), Programmed learning and computer-based instruction (pp. 205-216). New York: John Wiley. Campbell, L. (2004). What does the “e” stand for? (Report). Melbourne, Australia: Department of Science and Mathematics Education, the University of Melbourne. Charp, S. (1997). Some reflections. (the 30-year history of computers in education). [Technological Horizons in Education]. T.H.E. Journal, 24(1), 8–11. Fiedman, T. L. (1999, November 17). Next, It’s E-ducation. New York Times, p. 25 (Section A).
A Brief History of eLearning
Fletcher, J. D., & Rockway, M. R. (1986). Computer-based training in the military. In J. A. Ellis (Ed.), Military contributions to instructional technology (pp. 177-222). New York: Praeger.
McGorry, S. Y. (2003). Measuring quality in online programs. The Internet and Higher Education, 6(2), 159–177. doi:10.1016/S10967516(03)00022-8
Gillham, D. (2002). Web resource appraisal process (WRAP): A framework to establish critically appraised nursing knowledge--an active web based learning exercise. Nurse Education in Practice, 2(4), 257. doi:10.1016/S1471-5953(02)00053-7
Michael, M. M., & Tait, A. (2002). Open and distance learning: Trends, policies, and strategy Consideration. Paris: United Nations Educational, Scientific, and Cultural Organization.
Gotschall, M. (2000). E-learning strategies for executive education and corporate training. Fortune, 141(10), S5, S59. Hall, B. (1997). Web-based training cookbook. New York: Wiley. Hall, B. (2000). How to embark on your e-learning adventure: Making sense of the environment. Elearning, 1 (2). Hall, B. (2000). New study seeks to benchmark enterprises with world-class e-learning in place. E-learning, 1(1), 18–29. Hall, B., & Snider, A. (2000) Glossary: The hottest buzz words in the industry.In D. A., & Berge, Z. L. (Eds.) E- Schreiber. Herrington, J., Reeves, T., & Oliver, R. (2005). Online learning as information delivery: Digital myopia. Journal of Interactive Learning Research, 16(4), 353–367. Karon, R. L. (2000). Bankers go online: Illinois banking company learns benefits of e-training. E-learning, 1(1), 38–40. King, K. P. (2002). Identifying success in online teacher education and professional development. The Internet and Higher Education, 5(3), 231. doi:10.1016/S1096-7516(02)00104-5 McDougall, A., & Betts, J. (1997). Learning with the media of their time: a snapshot of infrastructure, policy and practice in a technology immersion school. Melbourne, Australia: Computing in Education Group of Victoria.
Molnar, A. (1997). Computers in education: a brief history. [Technological Horizons in Education]. T.H.E. Journal, 24(11), 63–69. Mortera-Gutiérrez, F. (2006). Faculty best practices using blended learning in e-learning and face-to-face instruction. International Journal on E-Learning, 5(3), 313–337. Nicholson, P. S., & McDougall, A. (2005). eLearning: 40 years of evolution? In IFIP (Ed.), The eighth IFIP World Conference on Computers in Education [ISI 1571-5736]. Stellenbosch, South Africa: IFIP. Pilla, B. S., Nakayama, M. K., & Nicholson, P. (2006). Characterizing e-learning practices. In Proceedings of WCC2002, Santiago, Chile, July 2006. New York: Springer. Schroeder, U., & Spannagel, C. (2006). Supporting the active learning process. International Journal on E-Learning, 5(2), 245–264. Stone-Wiske, M., Sick, M., & Wirsig, S. (2001). New technologies to support teaching for understanding. International Journal of Educational Research, 35(5), 483. doi:10.1016/S08830355(02)00005-8 Sun Tzu. (410 BC). The Art of War. Suppes, P. (1964). Modern learning theory and the elementary-school curriculum. American Educational Research Journal, 1, 79–93. Suppes, P. (1966). The uses of computers in education. Scientific American, 215, 206–220.
7
A Brief History of eLearning
Suppes, P. (1986). Computers and education in the 21st century. In W. Neilson & C. Gaffield (Eds.), Universities in Crisis: A mediaeval institution in the twenty-first century (pp. 137-151). Toronto, Canada: The Institute for Research on Public Policy. Suthers, D. D., Hundhausen, C. D., & Girardeau, L. E. (2003). Comparing the roles of representations in face-to-face and online computer supported collaborative learning. Computers & Education, 41(4), 335. doi:10.1016/j.compedu.2003.04.001 Thompson. (2005). History of eLearning. Retrieved on June 25, 2008 from http://www.knowledgenet.com/corporateinformation/ourhistory/ history.jsp Urdan, T. A., & Weggen, C. C. (2000). Corporate e-learning: Exploring a new frontier. San Francisco, CA: WR Hambrecht Co.
Uttal, W. R. (1962). On conversational interaction. In J. E. Coulson (Ed.), Programmed learning and computer-based instruction (pp. 171-190). New York: John Wiley. Wentling, T., Waight, C. L., Gallagher, J., Fleur, J., Wang, C., & Kanfer, A. (2000) E-Learning: A review of literature. Knowledge & Learning Systems Group, National Center for Supercomputing Applications, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. Woolley, D. R. (1994). PLATO: The Emergence of Online Community. Retrieved June 25, 2008, from http://www.thinkofit.com/plato/dwplato.htm. Zahm, S. (2000). No question about it – e-learning is here to stay: A quick history of the e-learning evolution. E-learning, 1(1), 44–47.
This work was previously published in Online Education and Adult Learning: New Frontiers for Teaching Practices, edited by T. T. Kidd , pp. 46-53, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
8
9
Chapter 1.2
Technological Trends in Adult Education: Past, Present and in the Future John K. Hope University of Auckland, New Zealand
AbstrAct
IntroductIon
The purpose of this article is to provide a critical review of the past two decades of technology use in adult education. The article begins with a brief summary of technological trends, such as the introduction of the Internet and the World Wide Web, that have influenced adult education over the past two decades. Political, economic, social, and pedagogical issues that have influenced the use of technology in adult education are also discussed and possible solutions to these issues are outlined. The article concludes with an attempt to extrapolate future technological trends that could influence the direction of adult education in the decade to come.
Knowles 1970s prediction that adult education would be delivered electronically in the 21st century has proved spectacularly accurate. Thirty years later potential adult learners have a bewildering plethora of electronic delivery options available at the touch of a keyboard. Almost all adult educators use distance technology in one form or another and most are either involved with electronic delivery systems, or are contemplating such. Yet traditional face-to-face delivery methods survive alongside the new technological innovations and are likely to continue in the foreseeable future. Just as the invention of the computer and, more latterly, the widespread availability of the
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Technological Trends in Adult Education
Internet, changed the face of the adult education at the end of the 20th century, recent dramatic changes in the political, social, educational and economic systems of the world could stimulate new trends in adult education that will once again change its visible face in directions that as yet, we know not. This article attempts to analyse the past and extrapolate technological trends that will help us plan for an exciting but, uncertain, future in adult education.
bAcKGround At the time of completing this article in early 2009, the last two decades encompassed the period from the late 1980s until the present. What significant technological developments influenced adult education during that that time? Use of new technology (reading glasses) in adult education is mentioned in one of the first recorded books devoted to adult education, that of Thomas Pole who wrote of his 1811 experiences teaching adults to read in England, “when their (adults) attention is gained and fixed, they soon learn: their age makes no great difference, if they are able, by the help of glasses, to see the letters” (Pole, 1968, p. 3). We now jump several generations of technological development in adult education, such as the postal system and ballpoint pen, to the 1980s when most readers of this book will have been involved with education in some form, as either student or teacher. It is likely that most adult educators would recall that use of educational technology in the form of a computer was minimal, being confined to a small group of “early adopters” (Jones, Kirkup, & Kirkwood, 1993) who had access to mainframe computers, or very early purchasers of desktop personal computers mainly used for word processing. In the late 1980s most adult education was hard copy print based (Bates, 1993). Some institutions were experimenting with live audio and video technology (Isenberg, 2007), television (Bates, 1993) and institutions such as Jutland
10
Open University in Denmark investing hugely in teleconferencing (Jones et al., 1993), but these institutions were the exception rather than the rule (Moore, 1995). Over the last one hundred and seventy years since the recorded inception of adult education, technological innovation was generally limited to print innovations. In 1981 the IBM PC arrived (Olle, 2004), allowing the decentralisation of computer terminals linked to mainframe computers to stand-alone desktop devices. The widespread and extremely rapid of uptake of personal computers in the 1980s and 1990s (Kodama, 2008) was one of the most significant technological developments of that period. Most adult learners, being by definition more mature learners rather than younger computer whiz kids, were not the earliest adopters of the new computer technological aids but the convenience of simplified editing of written text on a personal computer, available in the home, led to rapid growth in computer use by both adult learners and their teachers. The enhanced convenience of a less significant but, still important technological leap, the invention and mass marketing of the laptop computer, was not lost on adult students either. First developed for the space shuttle programme in 1979 but not mass marketed until Compaq launched their laptop in 1988 and Apple launched the first Mac laptop in 1989 (Roseberry, n.d.), the laptop is today the computing tool of first choice for people on the move. By its portable nature, the laptop computer helped bring home, workplace and tertiary institution together rather than having students limited to using computer laboratories in tertiary institutions. Writing associated with an adult learning programme could continue regardless of location, a major incentive for busy adult learners to trying to pursue their education while working and running a family. Intensive expansion and innovation in adult education e-learning through the late 1980s and 1990s was the result of the PC and later laptop introduction, leading to a subtle but profound paradigm shift in not only the
Technological Trends in Adult Education
design and delivery of education, but also in the very nature of learning (Harasim, 2006). Electronic campuses, meaning electronically linked departments via ethernets within one physical institution, were in vogue in the late 1980s and 1990s (Gardner, 1989), but of more significance to this article was the launch of the first totally on-line adult education course in 1981, followed by the launch of the first large scale, on-line learning institution in 1989, the Open University in the United Kingdom (Harasim, 2006). As is often the case with very new technology, the first on-line courses were disasters. There were no pedagogical models to follow and the technical problems associated with using 48K Apple II computers linked to early, slow modems deterred all but the most enthusiastic (Feenberg, 1993). The most significant new technological development in adult education during the years of the review period must surely be the move from purely experimental use of the Internet up to the late 1980s to its public launch in 1989, use by learning organisations in the early 1990s (Leiner, Cerf, Clark, Kahn, Kleinrock, Lynch, et al., 2003) and its widespread adoption for educative purposes during the past decade. The electronic campus became the virtual campus; geographic proximity no longer limiting the linking of electronic devices. Physical distance barriers to adult education were instantly removed, equity of access to adult education enhanced and the widespread availability of the World Wide Web from its inception in 1990 (Berners-Lee & Mark, 1999) meant that the knowledge of the world became available to any who could purchase and connect to the technology. Such was the impact of this technological leap that use of information and communication technology (ICT) and the more contemporary term e-learning were seen by adult educators in many developed countries as the “technological fix” for adult education (Selwyn, Gorard, & Furlong, 2006). Explosive growth in the provision of distance education for adult learners (Johnson, 2003) was
a predictable outcome from the moment that widespread and cheap electronic communication via the Internet became available. Rather than having the immediate, geographical area as a catchment for recruitment of potential adult learners, or expensive and slow, paper-based mail-out recruitment to more distant areas, educational institutions could inexpensively advertise their programmes almost anywhere on the globe, and they did. The English Open University, one of the “early adopter” universities to offer distance education to adults grew from 70,000 paperbased distance students in the 1980s to more than 180,000 electronically linked students in 2008 (Open University, 2009). The percentage of U.S.based institutions using Internet-based learning technologies tripled between 1994–5 and 1997–8 (NCES, 2000) and other developed countries rapidly followed suit. Growth of electronic learning is such that in 2009 it would be difficult to find an educational institution in a developed country that did not include at least some Internet-based courses within its adult education offerings. The ultimate expression of the influence of the Internet and World Wide Web in 2009 can be seen by the growing list of virtual universities in first and, more recently, third world countries, many catering for adult students; all distinguishable in that they have no physical campus because all courses are offered on-line. Explosive growth does not occur without reason. Internet-based technological innovations have been widely adopted within adult education because ICT offers a number of potential advantages for adult educators. Frequently touted advantages include broadening the provision of adult education into new fields, extending participation to more marginalised learners and improving educational outcomes. But these potential benefits have been mitigated by wider issues. These issues will be the focus of the next section of this chapter.
11
Technological Trends in Adult Education
technoLoGIcAL trends In the Future And theIr IMPLIcAtIons For AduLt educAtIon Any academic able to accurately predict technological trends in the future would be unlikely to waste their time writing book chapters, they would be far better employed investing their own money in lucrative technological innovations or, at the least, being first to implement the innovation within their own institution. Future prediction is known to be an inexact science, well demonstrated by the inaccuracy of some future predictions, particularly when new technological inventions are the subject. One example of many that are available from the public school system will suffice. Between 1950 and 1959, television ownership in the United States soared from 10% to 90% (Putnam, 1995), leading to confident 1950s predictions that educational television would be the dominant form of technology used in education. With 50 million dollar backing from the Ford Foundation and Congress, a plane was commissioned to circle above the Midwest beaming educational television to six states. Finding that classroom uptake was only 2– 4%, the plane was grounded (Tyack & Cuban, 1995). There was and, still is, some use of educational television, but the domination of educational television that was so confidently predicted and expensively funded, did not happen. The same can be said for use of radio, film and video in education, limited uptake and no golden bullet solution to educational problems. Unlike its predecessors, the personal computer, and particularly the almost universal availability of the Internet, has fulfilled the touted potential of changing the face of adult education, but their implementation has introduced other problems. Widespread implementation of the Internet has introduced issues such as hacking that were unheard of when earlier educational technology was in use. Examination of the technologically based issues confronting adult educators today may offer
12
glimpses of potential solutions for the future. A selection of political, economic, social and pedagogical issues that some see as having an influence on adult education will be presented in the next section, followed by an attempt to confront the inexact science of predicting the near future, that of the next decade. Issues, controversies, Problems It is said that optimists see opportunities where pessimists see problems. The next section discusses technologically based issues for adult education but in so doing, also notes the opportunities that may accompany the issue. Political Issues Internal, regional and international political issues all have potential to impact on the technological provision of adult education. Western democracies traditionally lurch between left and right over time, often with consequent change to funding and direction for adult education. Examples include national provision of new technology such as high end broadband capability to educational institutions, and policy directives regarding use technology to address the digital divide (enhancing technology-based access to adult education for disadvantaged groups). International examples of governmental policy shifts for adult education oriented technological progress include tax incentives for ICT purchases in Hungary, government funding for the provision of ICT based adult education to targeted groups in Italy, provision of virtual schools in Finland (Pont & Sweet, 2006) and installation of broadband capability for educational institutions in New Zealand. Evidence of the internationalisation of education can be seen in countries such as China, India and Malaysia that were previously exporters of adult students now becoming or, about to become, net importers of international students. New political forces have emerged, such as the BRIC axis (Brazil, Russia, India, China), where major
Technological Trends in Adult Education
investment in technological development, often supported by adult education programmes, has generated a new force in world politics. Politically motivated international and domestic terrorism by individuals and groups in countries as diverse as Afghanistan, Iraq and the United States has resulted in reluctance by some to gather in public educational institutions or to travel to providers of adult education in countries deemed unsafe. Politically inspired visa restrictions have also begun to limit physical movement between some countries. The recent emergence of politically inspired censorship of access to the Internet has limited access for some adult students to Web sites deemed a threat to moral standards or the ruling authority and, in turn, has become a threat to wider uptake of electronically mediated adult education. Economic issues will be discussed in the next section, but protectionism and ultra-nationalism are political issues often arising from economic downturns, as may occur when the global economy confronts a major economic downturn in 2009. Some international markets for adult education by distance may be closed to external providers in such circumstances, but that correspondingly provides an opportunity for domestic providers of adult education to pick up where international providers have been excluded. economic Issues Economic issues have had a major impact on adult education in the past ten years and are likely to have even greater impact in the future. Widespread utilisation of ICT’s has increased the rate of globalisation with consequent economic impact, both positive and negative, on many domestic economies. Competition from other countries drives the need for better skilled workers who can compete on a global scale, in turn creating a need for more commercially and internationally oriented adult education programmes. This trend is seen as a potential narrowing of adult education
(Selwyn et al., 2006) to vocationally oriented skill training with a consequent reduction in broader adult education provision. Rapid escalation in oil-based fuel costs has resulted in sky rocketing international fuel surcharges being imposed that can limit the ability of adult international students to travel to other countries to further their education, but also provides a consequent rise in demand for electronic delivery of coursework. Adult educators are not spared either, rising fuel costs encouraging more use of electronic communication for conferences and meetings, in place of face to face gatherings. Of greater concern for adult education is the so-called credit crunch that at the time of this writing, has the potential to have a greater economic impact than any other issue in the era being addressed in this chapter. Serious budget deficits stop growth, reduce spending, increase unemployment and have the potential to increase protectionism and sharing of economically sensitive information. Adult education, being traditionally seen by some as of lower priority than compulsory schooling, can suffer massive budget cuts or be directed toward outcomes that have immediate commercial application rather than wider educational merit. An alternative view of the outcome of the global “credit crunch” is that it provides an added incentive for the provision of electronically mediated adult education, a view addressed in a later section of this chapter. social Issues Economic issues often create social issues that, in turn, impact on adult education. Social issues that have emerged in the last ten years include increasing limitations on the time available for adult education students to address their continuing education needs. Longer working hours, working spouses and partners, and an increasing emphasis on leisure are social changes that have the potential to limit participation in adult education, but also create an opportunity for electronic delivery
13
Technological Trends in Adult Education
methodology to supplant face to face delivery that involves time consuming travel. Those who live within large cities increasingly experience traffic deadlock that can limit the ability to travel relatively short distances to an educational institution in a timely manner. In contrast, longer life spans in many countries create a larger pool of retired workers who have free time and want to continue learning for health, leisure, or social reasons, but also to fulfil life dreams of an education that was thwarted in earlier years for cultural, economic or family reasons. Growth in electronic communication forums dedicated to those more senior in years, such as SeniorNet, have introduced a new generation of learners to electronic communication and, in turn, generated opportunities for Internet-based adult education provision to a group not previously targetted (O’Day, Ito, Adler, Linde, & Mynatt, 2006). Unemployment can limit the financial capacity of those so affected to enrol in adult education but unemployment, or employment insecurity, can also generate the motivation to obtain better education qualifications that may improve the chance of further employment. Future unemployed workers may look to electronic delivery of courses as a more cost-efficient alternative delivery method and governments may look toward funding targeted adult education programmes to provide a form of work for the unemployed by enhancing workplace skills. Other rapidly emerging technological trends within adult education include issues related to the conservation movement, sometimes termed “the greening of the adult education academy” (Taylor, 2006). Eco-sensitive adults are more aware of their carbon footprints and may be less inclined to travel overseas to further education, or may want to limit use of paper-based print technologies to save forests, so they turn to electronic delivery mechanisms that are seen as more eco-friendly. In countries emerging from the third world, a new wave of upwardly mobile adults who are ICT literate and have been denied chosen educational
14
opportunities earlier in their lives may also turn to electronic adult education to meet their adult learning needs. Pedagogical Issues Pedagogical issues that have, or are likely to impact on adult education in the near future include the emergence of Mandarin to challenge the domination of English as the chosen Internet language of choice in the world. Internet traffic in Mandarin is likely to surpass Internet traffic in English in the near future (Riley, 2008) yet almost all of the adult education research literature is written in English. Electronic translation methodologies offer adult educators possible solutions to this issue, and to the likely emergence of other languages becoming better represented in net traffic, but the translation technology is still in its infancy and is often subject to questionable accuracy of interpretation (Hung, Chen, & Wong, 2006). In addition to languages other than English having a greater presence in electronic communication, the era under discussion has seen greater awareness of Islamic educational methodologies. On-line adult education is tightly regulated but does exist in Islamic countries, particularly in the moderate Islamic countries such as Malaysia (McCarty, Ibrahim, Sedunov, & Sharma, 2006). Immigration, refugee flows and economic drivers of international mobility have created new pools of potential Islamic adult learners in non-Islamic countries and, in doing so, raised awareness in destination countries of religiously sourced pedagogies different from indigenous pedagogies. Similarly, greater movement of people from countries with varying Asian pedagogies has created more awareness in destination countries of differing perceptions of appropriate learning styles. Adult students who have received their childhood education using transmitive pedagogies focussed more on direct instruction, and whose only experience of assessment has been examinations with a focus on memorisation and
Technological Trends in Adult Education
recall, may struggle to adapt to contemporary Western pedagogies often more focussed on critique, synthesis, and formative assessment. A student raised in some Eastern countries may be taught never to challenge their teacher as this would be a mark of disrespect. The same student in a Western educational environment will have difficulty when asked to critique a work by an academic “superior” because it would be a mark of disrespect to criticise. The challenge for adult educators is to bridge this pedagogical gap, with ICT having an important role in providing personal tutorial support to bridge pedagogical differences. Computer skills are now a critical necessity for students pursuing adult education programmes in most countries, particularly where net-based distance methodologies are utilised. Adult students were most likely to have had some experience with computers if they attended compulsory education in childhood within the last thirty years, so the generations of adult learners who lack computer skills because they engaged in their compulsory education in pre-computer years are becoming smaller every year. Many of those that did not obtain computer skills during their compulsory schooling have gained computer skills through their employment, or from pursuing recreational and personal interests, so the number of adult students who need basic computer skills is reducing every year. Of more pertinence to this discussion is the nature and quality of their computer skills. Many adult students have missing skill sets, searching academic databases being one and learning to discriminate between the qualities of different sources of data being another. technical Issues All users of modern technology know that technical issues can be a problem, often unexpectedly. An example of serendipitous technical issues was found when a New Zealand university set up a distance education adult learning programme
in remote farming areas of New Zealand. Adult students studying in their homes in one area were experiencing unexplained, random network crashes that the technical support staff could not solve. The solution was found to be voltage drops caused by sheep farmers turning on electric fences in a remote area where mains power supply was tenuous at best. Technical problems such as these are accentuated in less developed countries with non-existent or uncertain electricity supplies, where technical support is often unavailable and the technology in use is of earlier vintage. A technical issue that annoys most adult learners is unsolicited electronic spam, but that can usually be controlled by anti-spam programmes. The spam that gets through is a minor irritant only requiring use of the delete button, but the more insidious unsolicited and unwanted arrival is the electronic virus. Discontented student hackers can sometimes infiltrate adult learning programme computer servers with the consequence that adult learners wherever in the world becoming infected too. An adult learner who is completing their studies part-time while maintaining a busy lifestyle, but is not a confident user of ICT and is removed from immediate technical expertise support, may lack the technical knowledge to protect their computer system so can lose data and, at the least, lose their motivation to continue when these technical issues strike. Electronic plagiarism is a recent and unwelcome visitor to adult education programmes. When adult education was paper-based, copying of unacknowledged material was laborious, relatively simple to detect and consequently infrequent. The availability of the world’s netsourced literature in the home at the touch of a keystroke increases the temptation to plagiarise. The convenience of technology assisted searching followed by “copy and paste” also simplifies the process. Some adult learners remain unaware of the importance of acknowledging sources and will plagiarise innocently, others come from an education background where plagiarism is not
15
Technological Trends in Adult Education
considered as much of an issue as in most developed countries. In pre-computer years, cheating was limited to unlawful strategies such as paying someone to write essays or copying essays from students studying in previous years, all dangerous and difficult to attempt. The net-based adult learner of today will receive unsolicited e-mail offering to provide bogus degrees, ready written essays for popular courses, and offers to provide custom-written assignments for a fee. Cheating has become easier and the pressure to acquire qualifications in contemporary society provides the motivation for some to cheat. solutions and recommendation Issues are relatively simple to list, solutions and recommendations less so. One article is insufficient to address complex solutions to the host of adult education issues, controversies and problems that have occurred in the last two decades. Some issues as yet have no solutions, others have partial solutions; some have potential solutions that have yet to be tested, others have been solved. This section will address a selection of the issues raised in the previous section and introduce some newer forms of technology that are beginning to be used, or have potential for future use, in adult education. Political solutions Political issues cannot usually be solved by adult educators. War, terrorism, protectionism and ultra-nationalism all pose threats to adult education, but also provide opportunities for more electronic delivery to those most affected by these issues. Potential students in countries vulnerable to such problems are not usually able to travel to other countries for their education so will seek options at home. International concerns are such that the United Nations General Assembly is
16
holding a special session in 2009 to debate the crucial role of education in national emergencies and post-crisis situations. Home based education, whether for security, or nationalistic reasons, is an opportunity for domestic distance providers, or, where approved, international distance education providers, to establish programmes within the political environment of countries in crisis. Web censorship is a threat more difficult to counter but it is the much maligned hackers who sometimes find unofficial electronic fixes for state censorship of the Web, that ultimately lead to easing of difficult to police Web restrictions. In the longer term, hunger for knowledge is a powerful motivator such that popular opinion can influence unpopular political policy. Adult educators would be advised to constantly look to take advantage of government policy shifts in broader technical areas that could have application in their own industry. Examples of policy shifts likely to increasingly occur in the future are technical measures to address digital divides of various kinds such as poverty, gender discrimination and unemployment. Adult education workforce skill upgrade opportunities are likely outcomes from the global economic difficulties of 2009, either to keep those unemployed in constructive activity, or to develop new skills more appropriate to the more competitive business environment generated by the economic downturn. The good news for adult educators working internationally when the global economy recovery begins is that the internationalisation of education, technology and trade is an economically generated political force likely to continue in the longer term, and this political force should be seen as an opportunity by all providers of adult education. An example of this trend in the midst of the economic downturn is a major move by UNESCO, initiated by China, to promote multilinguism by developing an international cyber network for learning languages (UNESCO Institute for Statistics, 2009).
Technological Trends in Adult Education
economic solutions Transnational education is rapidly growing where economic drivers are encouraging technologically advanced countries such as Denmark to request tertiary students to include an international component within their tertiary education. Tertiary enrolments of students from less developed countries seeking education in middle income countries have increased by 77% in the past decade (UNESCO Institute for Statistics, 2005), many of those enrolling being adult learners. Globalisation will require more workers to have international experience, forcing adult learners to go off-shore using electronic technology to meet the employment requirements of the global order. Adult learners paying for their education themselves will be increasingly likely to Google the world in their efforts to source the cheapest and highest quality provider of distance education to meet their learning requirements. Boom and bust economies can have a marked influence on adult education take up. While this article was being written, the credit crunch knocked trillions of dollars off the stock exchange and left old age pensioners bereft of their life savings. Dire predictions of declining numbers of tertiary students, particularly international students, were frequently heard in the latter part of 2008. From where I write in the southern hemisphere, we have begun semester one 2009 to find that both international and domestic student enrolments have increased. Shortage of money has deterred some but they have been replaced by greater numbers of students enrolling in tertiary programmes to improve their employability after leaving school, or to upgrade their qualifications in new areas if they have been made redundant. The dotcom crash of the year 2000 and the more recent credit crunch have eroded public confidence in business. Some confidence has been lost by revelations of illegal activity by
greedy entrepreneurs, and other by distrust of the “smoke and mirrors” technology systems that can mask signs of economic woe from the sight of investors. Many people have become suspicious of Web site promotional material, such as bogus qualifications, due to bitter experience, lack of user friendliness and lack of transparency. This applies as much to adult education as to business. Urban (2008) sees Web 2.0 technologies helping to improve consumer trust by facilitating user control and ownership of data. Adult educators can provide a friendly Web presence and authentication of their material via provision of transparent and authentic information sharing, thereby developing a trusting relationship that will endure over time (Dennis & Wisely, 2008). Fisher and McKee (2008), commenting on reports indicating that since 1995, 25% of United States economic growth is the result of electronic network and information technologies at a cost of only 3% of GDP, suggest that cost benefits such as these are likely to continue in the future. When tertiary budgets are squeezed, cost effectiveness drives change. Despite the social and pedagogical advantages of electronic delivery of adult education that are evident to many academics, the economics of delivering more education to more students at what is perceived to be less cost is attractive to those in politics. Electronic delivery may also be perceived as good preparation for the ‘real’ world of work and hence become a desirable economic goal. OECD surveys have established the importance of adult education for improved living standards and productivity. A 2005 report found that an equitable distribution of skills across the workforce had such a strong, positive impact on economic performance that it justified policies to address educational disadvantage for disadvantaged groups such as older adult learners. The pedagogical section below will address these solutions further.
17
Technological Trends in Adult Education
Pedagogical solutions The UNESCO statistical report noted above states that much of the improvement in education participation across the globe can be attributed to increased participation in adult education. For example, in the countries surveyed, the proportion of 35–44 year olds with less than primary education has decreased from three quarters to half in eight years (UNESCO Institute for Statistics, 2005). Adult education via situated e-learning in the workplace is driven by economic factors but provides opportunities for adult educators to develop on-line pedagogies tailored to workplace needs and delivered in a manner sensitive to time and location constraints. Examples include greater use of formative assessment to increase feedback to learners struggling with new concepts and pedagogies or lacking in confidence. Continuous on-line assessment utilising electronic portfolios provides flexibility for students, limits the constraints of assessment fixed in time and place and assuages known issues for more mature learners such as exam anxiety. Generation X and Y adult learners can be encouraged into adult education by utilising their social networking skills and dispositions honed on Facebook, Twitter and the like. The developing cyberpedagogy or cybergogy will be based around collaborative learning models where learners construct their own learning in collaboration with other learners via various discussions, role playing and problem solving strategies (Luke, 2006) delivered on new and more creative software platforms such as Moodle. Most adult learners who have access to the Internet are unlikely to use it purely for educative purposes. The Internet has become the entertainment forum for many. Witness the phenomenal growth of the social interaction sites already described, such as Facebook and Twitter. Futurists see the distinction between education and entertainment become increasingly difficult to define (Pauling, 2006), as in the virtual reality developments discussed later in this chapter.
18
Facial recognition technological developments (Mitchener, 2008) are likely to make on-line communication more personal and allow, for better or for worse, interpretation of emotions during discussions. More importantly, facial recognition would help solve cheating problem that blight many on-line programmes by answering the question: who is it that is responding to these questions? One concern the has already surfaced is that facial recognition has the potential to be misused by cyber stalkers looking for attractive targets in chat groups but, equally, facial recognition has the potential to make it more difficult for cyber stalkers to make out they are someone other than in real life. Face to face synchronous communication, such as freely downloadable with Skype, offers cheap communication for those with a computer and screen mounted camera. Little used by adult educators, technologies such as Skype improve interactivity, student confidence and help educators tailor the content they are delivering to the needs of their students. Recent moves away from the hypertext language HTML that was used to develop the Web hold promise for adult educators. The semantic Web may not be fully developed until the end of the next decade (Warren, Davies, & Brown, 2008) but is a potential solution to some problems that adult educators experience, particularly when working across different cultures, languages and pedagogies. Differing interpretations of words and concepts can lead to misunderstandings that discriminate against learners working across cultures and languages. The previously quoted United Nations cyber linguistic initiative is one strategy that may assist in alleviating this problem. It took 75 years for fixed line phones to reach 50% of consumers but only twenty years for most people in western countries to own a cellular phone. Internet uptake in the United Kingdom soared from 14% to 61% between 1999 and 2005 (Warren et al., 2008). New technologies, such as intuitive and collaborative Web 2.0 knowledge articulation processes, are showing even faster
Technological Trends in Adult Education
uptakes, at a pace never seen before (Warren et al., 2008). One particularly significant trend that can be expected to accelerate in the future is that of Web users increasingly designing their own content (Anderson & Stoneman, 2008), obvious examples being content sharing via blogs, shared knowledge creation on wikis or Wikipedia and the burgeoning plethora of social communication Web sites like Twitter, Facebook, MySpace, BeBo, Flickr, YouTube and the like. Asynchronous electronic social communication networks have great potential for use in adult education. In a personal communication a colleague at another university explained that she had set up an alternative Web presence on Facebook and now gets more hits on Facebook than on the official university Web site. An adult learner in an ICT foundation class (preparation programme for entry to university for adults who did not attain university entrance qualifications while in compulsory schooling) that I was teaching responded to my suggestion that she e-mail to herself some work she had written in my class. Her response was: it is much easier to copy and paste to my BeBo page. For many adult learners, Web-based social networks have become the repository for their tacit knowledge, personal knowledge they are willing to share (Marwick, 2001). When such knowledge becomes explicit via the Web site, it can be a rich, but as yet often little exploited, data source for learning communities within adult education programmes. Wikis, blogs and the like can exploit for educational purposes the Web networking and knowledge sharing characteristics of many of today’s adult learners. Kings, Davies, Verril, Aral, Bryniolfsson, and Alstyne (2008) suggests that future knowledge management systems will build on Web 2.0 type knowledge articulation processes such as those mentioned above because they create a link between Web-based social recreational activity and shared learning. Wikis became available on the Internet in 1994 but widespread uptake only began in the
new millennium. The best known wiki is Wikipedia, now one of the most often quoted sources of information by students. Wikipedia’s success comes from its open and interactive environment; anyone who has access to a Web browser can read it and add to it. The great attraction of wikis for adult educators is their use in collaborative learning models. Just as collaborative writing has made Wikipedia arguably the most used encyclopaedia of knowledge in the world, adult educators can create student groups where subtasks are delegated and the resultant work assembled electronically on the wiki. The resultant collaborative information resource is private to those who have access to the wiki allowing all those who take part to benefit from the collective research and expertise of the group. Blogs differ from wikis as the information contained therein is available to any who can access the appropriate Web site. Blog authors document in reverse chronological order their musings in an informal manner and the blog so created, being public, can encourage input from others. Adult educators have been slow to grasp the potential of blogs because blogs have tended to be the domain of the young, particularly those in secondary schools. More recently, blogging has also becoming the domain of the not so young and this trend can be expected to continue as the younger generations enter adult education. The potential of the personal narrative contained in many blogs is an opportunity deserving of more attention in adult education. Adult educator hesitancy in using blogs relates to their open nature, others can input and move the blog away from the educational objective, or it can degenerate when interpersonal issues are introduced. Despite these disadvantages, blogs are very popular with many students and can provide rich chronological data in much the way that diaries once did, so should be considered by adult educators as another technological tool to improve learning. Portfolios of student work are now popular at tertiary level and the e-portfolio has particular
19
Technological Trends in Adult Education
relevance for adult education. E-portfolios are compilations of student work assembled electronically, so they can include videos, graphic work and creative art genre as well as traditional text information. An e-portfolio is usually private to the student and their tutor, but could include blogs as a valid information source contributing to the e-portfolio. technological solutions Most of us eventually buy the latest technological device. Are there any adult educators who do not have a cellular phone, use a computer or access the Web? Only the computer existed two decades ago and for many of us, a PC was still too expensive and a laptop a dream. What is in store for us during the next decade? Mitchener (2008) sees more seamless, automatic, synchronous and numerous network connections, developments we would all applaud. Specific technological developments likely to occur include improved voice recognition as is now available in exotic cars, wider use of improved touch screens as on the Apple iPhone and even technology that could include physical movement as a learning tool. Physical movement capable software is already available in interactive gaming systems such as the physical swings of golf clubs or baseball bats on the popular computer game Wii. Rapid increases in memory storage capacity utilising physically smaller componentry, particularly through use of nanotechnology, is likely to increase the physical portability of technological devices and hence access for distance learners. Handheld mobile technology such as PDAs and mobile phones are increasingly merging into smartphones, always-connected Blackberrys and iPhones with their ready access to e-mail and Web on a handheld phone anywhere, anytime. Intelligent mobile devices allow lecturers and students to communicate asynchronously and cheaply by text or e-mail or synchronously by phone. Student to student and student to tutor text messaging (the
20
correct term for text messaging is Short Messaging Service abbreviated on phones as SMS) to ask questions about coursework and share ideas, instant data recording while at work and recreation, capturing video clips for use in learning portfolios and using the in-built planner to keep track of assignment timelines are all examples of the technological applications currently in use by some adult educators (Dawson, 2007). 3G phones are common now, 4G phones with more seamless connectivity and roaming are most likely to be available within the next ten years (Dennis & Wisely, 2008). Improvements to batteries and greater use of intelligent alternative sources of electricity from sunlight, movement, sound and pressure changes are likely to create opportunities for adult education by improving access to information and communication in less developed countries and isolated areas. The frustration, shared by teaching staff members and students, arising from slow downloads is a major barrier to the uptake of distance education. More information sharing is required, more documents include graphic material and Web sites that increasingly incorporate video clips all slow downloads. The touted answer to this problem has been increased bandwidth. In many countries broadband has become the rule rather than the exception and in this case Asian countries are outstripping their Western counterparts (Payne, 2008). Increased bandwidth capacity is quickly soaked up driving demand for even more bandwidth that exceeds the capacity of copper wire technology to deliver. Fibre optic networks are now common on many campuses but any component of the network in use that is not an optical network will slow downloads. Similarly, information entering and leaving network nodes is slowed. New intelligent network technology that bypasses unnecessary nodes can also be expected to increase speed (Payne, 2008). Adult educators can expect to see more complete optical systems installed in the next ten years, including interconnectivity across regional and national boundaries
Technological Trends in Adult Education
(Wittgreffe, Dames, Clark, & McDonald, 2008) that will, in turn, increase capacity to deliver more graphics-based and video based adult education programmes to more students. Storage technology has increased incrementally in the last five years. Most of us now use a $10 memory stick that can store everything that we have written in our lifetime. Memory sticks may soon have wireless capacity to enable them to talk to each other, allowing transfer of information anywhere, anytime from a small object around the neck, on a key ring or in a pocket, without being plugged into a computer (Pearson, 2008). With time pressures and transport problems driving increasing situated e-learning in the workplace instead of going to dedicated learning institutions, memory sticks that could communicate with each other would allow information transfer to occur over lunch or while working, without the need for a larger computer or smartphone. Replacement of expensive, technically demanding, distance delivery software packages such as WebCT and Blackboard with cheap and easy to use technologies such as Moodle will further simplify and facilitate delivery of adult education. Many potential students avoid on-line courses because they consider themselves technologically illiterate or sign up with trepidation only when there is no other option available to them. Tertiary educators who teach their courses on-line have come to expect calls asking whether IT qualifications are required to join the course, or “I have not done this before” comments indicating lack of confidence. Easy to use software packages give new distance learners confidence, are less likely to crash at critical moments and are designed to increase student to student, teacher to student and student to teacher communication. They are also easier for adult educators to use for the first time. Obtaining approval to purchase a new paperbased journal has become problematic in the author’s university; new journals must be electronic journals. Variously described as E-libraries or
digital libraries, virtual libraries are reality, or a partial reality, in many universities now. They provide an electronic interface between repositories of knowledge and learners individual needs that is more than the traditional index cards or electronic catalogues. Their unique feature is their ability to be searched using increasingly complex and inductive search engines to suit a learner’s individual needs. In doing so they support the newer pedagogies where learners construct their own learning, the remaining limitations being the learner’s technological literacy and the sophistication of the library search access (Brophy, 2006). Initially adopted to save expensive space needed for paper-based technology, virtual libraries are a boon for busy adult learners as they can completely obviate the need to attend a library in person. Journal and database searching is simplified and available from any keyboard, anywhere, anytime. Although electronic books are still not in vogue with many in adult education because they find reading a book on a screen odious, the increasing availability of electronic books combined with declining paper availability and cheapness, will force adoption. New electronic readers are becoming available that come closer to replicating the paper book. They still do not duplicate the physical page turning of a book, but can be read in bed or on the bus and are a great deal easier to transport in quantity. Solutions to the cheating and plagiarism issues have centred around use of products such as Turnitin and MyDropBox, effectively large databases of written works that allow comparison of student text with that written previously. New pedagogical strategies such as portfolio assessment raise new issues for the detection of illegal activity that are beyond the scope of existing electronic detection methods. As always, a technological problem breeds a technological solution and new open architecture systems are being developed that can detect plagiarism in other media such as graphics and even the audio component of podcasts (Butakov & Scherbinin, 2009).
21
Technological Trends in Adult Education
Cyberspace was a term coined by a science fiction author in 1984, but it soon become reality and was being discussed as a potential medium for adult education in the early 1990s (Boyd, 1993). Virtual games are now commonplace, but their use in adult education less so. Technology enabled virtual worlds formed by the merger of Google Earth and virtual reality programmes like Second Life offer the ability to inhabit a virtual world via avatars “that will be at best a virtual representation of planet earth and at worst, the frighteningly deep and dark spaces of collective human consciousness without the shackles of convention surrounding an evolved society!” (Dennis & Wisely, 2008, p. 139). Virtual reality provides unique opportunities for adult education based on personal choice and decision-making. Its potential advantages are that it happens in no fixed physical place and involves communities of learners interacting and collaborating to solve problems in ways not possible within the real world (Burbules, 2006). Boyd (1993) saw application of virtual reality in adult education such as “gateways to other organisations’ cyberspace worlds to provide observations of people at work, and apprenticeship-internship situations” (p. 245). Fifteen years on that prediction is already reality. One early example is use of virtual reality adapted to teach humanistic subjects such as history. Virtual Harlem is a collaborative learning environment where students can learn about the history of Harlem via virtual reality, giving the impression of being there (Sosnoski, Jones, Carter, McAllister, Moeller, & Mir, 2006). In 2009, virtual reality must still be regarded as experimental, expensive and of limited availability, so its current use in adult education is still limited. This article began with a look at the technological past in adult education and there was mention of technology such as educational television that did not ever become mainstream. In contrast, strewn throughout the sections above are many examples of extremely rapid uptake of newer
22
technology such as the Internet and its slightly slower, but nevertheless pervasive adaption for use in adult education. What of the future? Will we all be working as avatars in virtual reality scenarios?
Future reseArch dIrectIons This essay has highlighted many examples of the ever increasing speed of technical change, change that generates the most persistent and pervasive technological issue within adult education. The world’s total knowledge doubles in ever shorter time frames and new products that have potential for application in adult education arrive regularly. How to keep up? Should we keep up? These questions beggar the real question, where is the research-based evidence in favour of improved pedagogy for each new technological tool? Technological change can happen much more quickly than the time required to develop a research base rigorous enough to analyse the applicability of new technologies for improved educational outcomes. Good research takes time and it often takes even longer to become available in published form. By the time research into the veracity of a new technology is readily available, there is a newer technology. This places the adult educator in a difficult position. Students are often early adopters of new technology so look for courses utilising the latest technology, while lecturers tend to favour more conservative approaches. The moral high ground for the educator is to focus research on the pedagogy involved by posing the question, will it improve learning? Until that question is answered by sound, evidence-based research the adult educator is at risk of promoting a 90 day wonder that will go the way of educational television. The role of the teacher is clearly changing in the increasingly cyber oriented world of adult education. Zao, Lei, and Conway (2006) see the traditional teachers’ role as that of gatekeeper to knowledge, but the e-learning teachers’ role as
Technological Trends in Adult Education
more akin to that of a designer of technological strategies and a learning facilitator rather than an instructor. But what will the adult educator working on a virtual reality learning model need to know and be able to do? The technical scientists are often generously funded to complete the technical research needed to make new technologies commercially viable because there is a potential economic return. Funding for pedagogically-based research into the application of new technology in adult education is often less readily available, as is adult educator’s time to pursue the necessary research. In the course of writing this article, it has become clear that that there are a plethora of books devoted to the more abstract and theoretical issues within adult education but less devoted to applied research around the application of new technologies. Timely technological support when applying new technology can be difficult to come by. Does this new, technically oriented environment require the e-learning adult educator to acquire new technological skills, should adult educators work collaboratively with technical experts, or can they depend on on-line support services to solve pedagogical and technical issues? Current experience with new technologies suggests that immediate support for the baby boomer generation adult educator is never on-site when required, and when the immediate problem is resolved another becomes apparent just after the technician has left the room, hung up the phone or terminated the link. The hope on the horizon is that the younger generation of more technologically savvy adult educators who have grown up with computers will fare better. Pauling (2006) notes that Japanese researchers are working on hyper-reality models of learning, where reality and virtual reality blend at the whim of the learner and it becomes increasingly difficult to distinguish between what is real and what is virtual, such that it would be difficult to know if people are real or not, or even if they
have human or artificial intelligence (Tiffen & Terashima, 2001). The new generations X, Y and Z adapt much more quickly, but how much more difficult will it be for all generations when they have to work with a completely new technical environment beyond their immediate experience, particularly if it becomes adopted as quickly as the Internet did? Future oriented research that attempts to define the knowledge, skills and dispositions required to link the pedagogical and technical requirements of future adult educators is not abundant but urgently needed. Solutions and recommendations as outlined above are the personal views of the author. They are neither comprehensive nor inviolate but are intended to stimulate thought about an adult education future that becomes increasingly difficult to predict as the pace of technological change quickens. The overwhelming impression gained from the literature reviewed is that demand for adult education will continue to grow and the role of the adult educator and their students will continue to change with ever increasing momentum, due to societal changes and technological advances. For that we must be prepared as best we can.
concLusIon The audience laughed when Maxwell Smart used a shoe phone in the 1970s television comedy series Get Smart. Does any reader of this article not have a mobile phone thirty years later? History tells us that many technological developments that were initially in the realm of the experimental laboratory have become pervasive. It also tells us that some have not. It remains to be seen whether the newer technologies described above are adopted as mainstream tools for adult education, whether those that are adopted last very long, and whether other technologies not envisaged above, arrive within the next ten years. What does not remain to be seen is that new technologies will arrive, and that some will become mainstream in adult education.
23
Technological Trends in Adult Education
It seems likely that the trend of the last two decades to move away from paper-based provision of adult education to electronic provision will continue, as will the increasing prevalence of distance education delivery. History has shown us that predictions of the demise of the classroom teacher face to face with students, to be replaced with intelligent computers, did not happen in schools (Cuban, 2001), nor is it likely to happen in adult education. Some face to face delivery will continue. What did change in schools, and in adult education, was the mode of electronic delivery, the technical developments associated with electronic delivery and the pedagogy utilised via electronic delivery. History is our best predictive resource. Two decades of incredibly rapid technological change in adult education suggests that the future is more of the same.
reFerences Anderson, B., & Stoneman, P. (2008). Predicting the socio-technical future (and other myths). In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, real-time and secure service (pp. 3-16). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons. Augar, N., Raitman, R., & Zhou, W. (2006). Wikis: Collaborative virtual learning environments. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 2) (pp. 1251-1270). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Bates, T. (1993). Theory and practice in the use of technology in distance education. In D. Keegan (Ed.), Theoretical principles of distance education (pp. 213-233). New York: Routledge. Berners-Lee, T., & Mark, F. (1999). Weaving the web: Origins and future of the world wide web. Stamford, UK: Orion Business.
24
Boyd, G. (1993). A theory of distance education for the cyberspace era. In D. Keegan (Ed.), Theoretical principles of distance education (pp. 213-233). New York: Routledge. Brophy, P. (2006). The eLibrary and learning. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 2) (pp. 895-914). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Burbules, N. C. (2006). Rethinking the virtual. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 1) (pp. 37-58). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Butakov, S., & Scherbinin, V. (2009). The toolbox for local and global plagiarism. Computers & Education, 52, 781–788. doi:10.1016/j.compedu.2008.12.001 Cuban, L. (2001). Oversold and underused: Computers in the classroom. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Dawson, D. (2007). Handheld technologies for mobile learning. London: Latimer Trend. Dennis, R., & Wisely, D. (2008). Mobility and ICT. In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, real-time and secure service (pp. 129-142). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons. Feenberg, A. (1993). Building a global network: The WBSI executive education experience. In L. Harasim (Ed.), Global networks: Computers and international communication (pp. 185-197). Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Fisher, M., & McKee, P. (2008). Flexible ICT infrastructure. In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, realtime and secure service (pp. 67-78). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons.
Technological Trends in Adult Education
Gardner, N. (1989). The electronic campus: The first decade. Higher Education Quarterly, 43, 332–350. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2273.1989.tb01518.x Halavais, A. C. (2006). Weblogs and collaborative web publishing as learning spaces. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 2) (pp. 1215-1236). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Harasim, L. (2006). A history of e-learning: Shift happened. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 1) (pp. 59-94). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Hung, D., Chen, D. T., & Wong, A. F. L. (2006). An overview of virtual learning environments in the Asia-Pacific: Provisos, issues, and tensions. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 1) (pp. 699-722). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
Leiner, B., Cerf, V. G., Clark, D. D., Kahn, R. E., Kleinrock, L., Lynch, D. C., et al. (2003). A brief history of the internet. Retrieved March 11, 2009, from http://www.isoc.org/internet/history/ brief.shtml Luke, C. (2006). Cyberpedagogy. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 1) (pp. 269-278). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Marwick, A. D. (2001). Knowledge management technology. IBM Systems Journal, 40(4), 814-830. Retrieved October 2, 2007, from http://www. research.ibm.com/journal/sj/404/marwik.html McCarty, S., Ibrahim, B., Sedunov, B., & Sharma, R. (2006). Global online education. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 1) (pp. 723-788). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
Isenberg, S. (2007). Applying andragogical principles to internet learning. New York: Cambria Press.
Mitchener, J. (2008). Device Futures. In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, real-time and secure service (pp. 27-38). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons.
Johnson, J. (2003). Distance education: The complete guide to design, delivery and improvements. New York: Teachers College Press.
Moore, M. G. (1995). American distance education. In F. Lockwood (Ed.), Open and distance learning today (pp. 32-41). London: Routledge.
Jones, A., Kirkup, G., & Kirkwood, A. (1993). Personal computers for distance education. New York: St. Martin’s Press.
O’Day, V. L., Ito, M., Adler, A., Linde, C., & Mynatt, E. D. (2006). Cemeteries, oak trees, and black and white cows: Newcomers’ understandings of the networked world. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 2) (pp. 873-894). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
Kings, N. J., Davies, J., Verrill, D., Aral, S., Bryniolfsson, E., & Alstyne, M. V. (2008). Social networks, social computing and knowledge management. In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, realtime and secure service (pp. 17-26). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons. Kodama, M. (2008). New knowledge creation through ICT dynamic capability. Charlotte, NC: Information Age Publishing.
OECD. (2005). Promoting adult learning. Retrieved March 14, 2009, from http://www.oecd. org/document/57/0,3343,en_2649_39263238_36 675769_1_1_1_1,00.html
25
Technological Trends in Adult Education
Olle, T. W. (2004). Eight significant events in the 50 year history of computing. In J. Impagliazzo & J. A. N. Lee (Eds.), History of computing in education (pp. 47-56). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Kluwer.
Riley, D. (2008). China to become world’s largest internet market by users. Retrieved March 25, 2009, from http://www.techcrunch. com/2008/01/17/china-close-to-becomingworlds-largest-internet-market-by-users
Open University. (2009). About the OU. Retrieved March 11, 2009, from http://www.open.ac.uk/ about/ou/p3.shtml
Roseberry, C. (n.d.). What is the history of laptops? Retrieved March 24, 2009, from http:// mobileoffice.about.com/od/laptopstabletpcs/f/ laptophistory.htm
Pauling, B. (2006). Virtual learning environments in higher education “down under”. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 1) (pp. 609-652). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Paulson, K. (2002). Reconfiguring faculty roles for virtual settings. The Journal of Higher Education, 73, 123–141. doi:10.1353/jhe.2002.0010 Payne, D. (2008). The future all optical network— why we need it and how we get there. In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, real-time and secure service (pp. 93-114). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons. Pearson, I. (2008). Over the horizon. In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, real-time and secure service (pp. 215-226). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons. Pole, T. (1968). A history of adult schools (3rd ed.). London: Woburn Press. Pont, B., & Sweet, R. (2006). ICT and learning: Supporting out-of-school youth and adults. Paris: Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development. Putnam, R. (1995). Bowling alone: America’s declining social capital. Journal of Democracy, 6, 65–78. doi:10.1353/jod.1995.0002
26
Selwyn, N., Gorard, S., & Furlong, J. (2006). Adult learning in the digital age. Milton Park, UK: Routledge. Sosnoski, J., Jones, S., Carter, B., McAllister, K., Moeller, R., & Mir, R. (2006). Virtual Harlem as a collaborative learning environment: A project of the University of Illinois at Chicago’s electronic visualization Lab. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 2) (pp. 1289-1320). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer. Taylor, E. W. (2006). The greening of the adult education academy. In S. B. Merriam, B. C. Courtenay, & R. M. Cervero (Eds.), Global issues and adult education: Perspectives from Latin America, Southern Africa, and the United States (pp. 254264). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Tiffin, J., & Terashima, N. (2001). Hyper-reality: Paradigm for the third millennium. London: Routledge. Tyack, D., & Cuban, L. (1995). Tinkering towards utopia: A century of school reform. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. UNESCO Institute for Statistics. (2005). Educational trends in perspective. Retrieved March 21, 2009, from http://www.uis.unesco.org/TEMPLATE/pdf/wei/WEI2005.pdf
Technological Trends in Adult Education
UNESCO Institute for Statistics. (2009). Expert meeting on cyber network for learning languages. Retrieved March 21, 2009, from http://portal. unesco.org/en/ev.php-URL_ID=44836&URL_ DO=DO_TOPIC&URL_SECTION=201.html Urban, G. L. (2008). Online trust and customer power: The emergence of customer advocacy. In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, real-time and secure service (pp. 39-54). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons. Warren, P., Davies, J., & Brown, D. (Eds.). (2008). ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, real-time and secure service. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons.
Wittgreffe, J., Dames, M., Clark, J., & McDonald, J. (2008). End-to-end service level agreements for complex ICT solutions. In P. Warren, J. Davies, & D. Brown (Eds.), ICT futures: Delivering pervasive, real-time and secure service (pp. 115-128). Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons. Zhao, Y., Lei, J., & Conway, P. F. (2006). A global perspective on political definitions of e-learning: Commonalities and differences in national educational technology strategy discourses. In J. Weiss, J. Nolan, J. Hunsinger, & P. Trifonas (Eds.), The international handbook of virtual learning environments (pt. 1) (pp. 673-698). Dordrecht, The Netherlands: Springer.
This work was previously published in International Journal of Web-Based Learning and Teaching Technologies, Vol. 4, Issue 4, edited by E. M. W. N; N. Karacapilidis; M. S. Raisinghani , pp. 82-99, copyright 2009 by IGI Publishing (an imprint of IGI Global).
27
28
Chapter 1.3
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education Leah Blakey Drury University, USA
executIve suMMAry Online education has been a growing field in higher education for the last decade, and the number of students choosing online over seated classes continues to increase. The proliferation of online programs forces one to ask, “Is online education a good thing?” The resounding answer is YES, when best practices are followed. However, even the best online programs experience challenges as they deal with institutional, student, and growth issues. These struggles, their resolutions, and the knowledge gained from them are the focus of this chapter.
IntroductIon The proliferation of distance education programs in the last few years is unprecedented in the history of higher education. Technologies such as video conferencing and the Internet enable the delivery of educational content at a speed and level of interaction not previously possible (Monolescu, 2004, back cover).
As a professor with a Ph.D. that focused on military history, the term proliferation conjures up very negative connotations. My seven years of graduate school were spent focusing on the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, the proliferation of rogue governments, the proliferation of terrorists, etc. Therefore, with so many books and articles discussing the proliferation of online programs, it begs the question, “Is online education a good thing?” The resounding answer is YES, when best practices are followed.
bAcKGround Drury University began offering online undergraduate and graduate level courses in 1999 and 2000, respectively. Between 1999 and 2004, the growth rate of students enrolling in online classes increased by nearly 50% every year. In 2004, the University requested and acquired accreditation to place all of the degrees in its College of Graduate and Continuing Studies online. In their request, Drury pledged to predicate its growth on the Higher Learning Commission’s (HLC) “Best Practices for Electronically
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-870-3.ch011
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
Offered Degree and Certificate Programs”. After careful market analysis pointed to online courses as the wave of the future for the adult learner, the program became the “technological and pedagogical hub around which CGCS configured its future growth” (HLC Change Request, 2004, 6). With this commitment to adherence to best practices and future growth, the online education wing of Drury University set off on its path for excellence.
settInG the stAGe Online education has been a growing field in higher education for the last decade, and the number of students choosing online over seated classes continues to increase. This nationwide trend is incredibly strong in the Midwest, where—in many colleges and universities—the online program’s growth continues to outpace all other areas of university growth. Sloan Consortium found that “The nearly 20% growth rate expected in online enrollments far exceeds the overall rate of growth for the entire higher education student population” (Sloan-C, 2002). While many of these programs are praised by their peers and customers, the online programs have experienced challenges and growing pains. These struggles, their resolutions, and the knowledge gained from them are the focus of this chapter. The first question asked when someone mentions online classes always has to do with the students. How can you teach students you cannot see? How can you engage online students in various media of learning and experiences? How do you keep them from cheating? How can you build the rapport that small, liberal arts colleges are famous for if the students are spread out across the world? The answers to these questions are the keys to successful online teaching. Successfully helping you deal with all of the challenges, both positive and negative, that an online program faces is the overall goal of this chapter. Online education is a rapidly growing
part of higher education. The strengths it offers mean expanded opportunities for persons in all regions of the developed world, a way for students to curtail the amount of their small budgets that goes to transportation, and a way to bring great minds from diverse locations together to engage the problems of the 21st century. Mastering the art of educating people over the internet is a must for schools vying for a place in the future market, and the most successful way for them to do that is by learning from others’ experiences and following guidelines for best practices in online education.
cAse descrIPtIon IncLudInG oPPortunItIes And chALLenGes The issues faced by a successful online program can be grouped into three categories: student, institutional, and those associated with growth. These issues are similar whether the program is at a small, Midwestern, liberal arts school; a large public university; or a community college. The successful resolution of all three of these issues is necessary for any online program to grow and prosper.
student Issues Reaching students in an online class is one of the issues most often debated. How can you teach students you cannot see? The truth is that a multitude of distance education programs have successfully been teaching students they could not see for decades. For example, correspondence courses have been used in colleges and universities for years, and the instructor does not see the student in a classroom setting. The beauty of online is that now the distance can be spanned through multiple interactive means through the internet rather than through the static medium of a paper or a video distance education
29
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
course. Teaching students via this global wonder is actually based on the same ideas that traditional classroom instruction has been based on for decades. These ideas take into consideration that people have different learning styles and that they need to be reached on multiple knowledge levels.
Learning Styles Everyone learns in a way that is somewhat unique. However, most people fall into one (or perhaps two) of three learning style categories: visual, auditory, and kinesthetic (Rose, 1991). Visual learners tend to take a lot of notes, like to see what they are learning, remember things best if they see them in vivid detail, often close their eyes to visualize or remember something, and prefer to not be distracted by sound and activity when they are learning. Auditory learners acquire knowledge by listening to lectures, reading aloud, and talking their problems out. Kinetic learners “remember what was done, but have difficulty recalling what was said or seen... rely on what they can directly experience or perform... enjoy field trips and tasks that involve manipulating materials... (and) are uncomfortable in classrooms where they lack opportunities for hands-on experience” (http://www.usd.edu/trio/ tut/ts/styleres.html). Instructors in online classes can reach visual learners with the simplest online tools. Online platforms present multiple ways of stimulating the visual learner. For example, Angel, Blackboard, eCollege, and Moodle offer places for lectures, pictures, and discussions. The key is for the instructor to find the most direct route between the student and the material the instructor wants them to learn. Often, this means short (no longer than 300 words) lectures (or a series of short lectures) coupled with visual aids such as pictures, charts, maps, etc. Even a visual learner will become lost in a lecture if it is too long or goes off on too many tangents. 30
When online classes first began, many auditory learners were not very successful because the online instructors did not know how to properly reach them. Now, there are many tools that can be used to stimulate auditory learners. First, and perhaps easiest for those who might be technologically challenged is simply using what is already on the World Wide Web. Websites such as YouTube, Science Daily, www.learner.org, and www.merlot.org have a lot of free videos that can easily be worked into online curriculum. The key for instructors is to find online resources that they can use in educative ways. “Teachers in effect become curriculum makers, developing parts of the curriculum by using the internet” (Wallace, 2004, p.451). One thing to always keep in mind is if the student must download the video or if they can watch streaming video. If they must download it, then students on dial-up internet may have trouble viewing it. In addition to these tools that already exist on the internet, there are multitudes of audio file software that can be used to deliver lectures – much of it for free. Photo Story from Microsoft, is a free tool that can be used with a Microsoft PowerPoint presentation to put sound with each of the slides. It is then streamed over the internet, which makes it easier for those students using a dial-up internet connection. Camtasia Studio and Speech-Over Studio are similar tools that can be used to add sound to a PowerPoint presentation, but these programs are not free. In the fall of 2008 Camtasia Studio 6 Student Version was selling for $169 and Speech-Over was $599, which in this budget-conscious time can possibly prohibit their use. There are also programs for adding pure audio files in an online course. The most popular of these, Wondershare PPT to iPOD, can also be downloaded and listened to on MP3 players and iPods. The most challenging students for online instructors to reach are those who learn through kinetic or hands-on instruction. These are the students who benefit the most from laboratory experiments, field trips, and projects. Tools and
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
Table 1. Remember
Understand
Apply
Analyze
Evaluate
Create
Factual Knowledge Conceptual Knowledge Procedural Knowledge Meta-cognitive Knowledge
procedures for reaching this type of learner vary by discipline, but every good online class incorporates a few projects for the kinetic learner. The projects normally require the student to leave the computer and complete an activity and then return to the computer to either craft a paper or share their experience via other means with their classmates. Some examples of how Drury University online instructors have reached these students include an online sociology of religion class that requires students to attend worship services outside of their faith and then report on the experience to their classmates; an online astronomy class that requires students to visit an observatory during a given week and report on the experience on the discussion page; and an online manned space flight class that requires students to watch shuttle launches and in orbit videos and discuss the events daily in the online class.
Revised Bloom’s Taxonomy Once instructors have designed elements into their classes to reach all of the various types of learners, they then must consider the level of learning they want to take place in their class. The most foundational way to consider this question is to apply the revised Bloom’s Taxonomy to the list of objectives and build assignments from here. (Anderson and Krathwohl, 2001). The best way to describe this approach to learning is through a table (Table 1). (http://coe.sdsu.edu/eet/articles/ bloomrev/index.htm) This revised version of Bloom’s Taxonomy combines the cognitive process (across top of
table) and the kind of knowledge to be learned (down the left side of the table). By combining both what needs to be learned with the type of learning involved, instructors can better plan out their course and ensure they reach beyond the surface of learning into the deeper and more advanced levels of learning.
Cheating Pushing students to excel and learn multiple levels of material is the goal of most classes. However, the challenge that this type of academic rigor presents often instead pushes students to cheat. Many educators feel that cheating is easiest and thus occurs more often in online classes, but most online instructors actually feel that they are better at detecting cheating online than they are in their face-to-face classes. “For example, in one online program an instructor who suspected plagiarism confronted the student. . . The instructor said that in the average large lecture classroom course he would have been far less likely to have identified the plagiarism because he wouldn’t have been as familiar with the student’s work as he was, seeing it regularly in the online discussions” (Maeroff, 2003, p.158). Unfortunately, cheating appears to be rampant in most areas of education, but instructors can work to make it more difficult for students to find the easy way out of an assignment. First and foremost, instructors must take the time to educate their students on what constitutes cheating and how the student can best avoid it. It has been my experience that more than half of the plagiarism that occurs in my classes is “ac-
31
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
cidental;” meaning that in most cases, the student did not realize that what they were doing was wrong. Students need to be taught how to take their research findings and couple this information with their own analysis in their writings. Students should be warned against cutting and pasting and pushed to put most of their paper into their own voice and prove their own arguments. Many schools, such as the University of Maryland University College’s required one-credit hour Information Literacy and Research Methods course, have been created to teach students to understand and recognize plagiarism (Maeroff, 2003). Secondly, instructors need to construct assignments in a way that makes cheating or plagiarism more difficult. For example, if a history instructor asks students to write a five page paper on the causes of the American Civil War, the students are given an assignment that is easily plagiarized. By comparison, if a history instructor asks his or her students to write a five page paper comparing the five causes of the American Civil War discussed on the weekly discussion page and then apply the rationalist ethics theory to the two they believe are the most important, the instructor has built an assignment for a paper that is not easily downloaded from the internet. By making students pull in specific examples from class discussions and instructor lectures as well as making the question subjective instead of objective, the instructor has personalized the question to their own class and made the ease of plagiarism more difficult. Third, there is a school of thought that pushes instructors to find new methods of assessment that are not easily plagiarized or otherwise taken advantage of by those looking for an easy way out. These instructors rely less on large exams or papers and more on smaller, interactive assignments that require multiple levels and times of involvement by the student. Wallace Pond, chief academic officer of Education America’s online program argued that, “’There are lots of lecture hall courses where a student might not interact with a professor at all and the final grade is based on two
32
exams and a paper. An environment of that sort may engender poor decision making by students who turn to such activities as plagiarism. . . In a well-taught online course with an involved professor and 25 students, it would be very difficult for a student to put bits and pieces of someone else’s work into his work. Everything, every word, in an online course is archived. The professor can go back and review all of the student’s work’” (Maeroff, 2003, p.159). Unfortunately, there are also the cases where the person completing the exam, discussions, or paper are actually the person sitting in front of the computer screen but they are not the person enrolled in the class. There are multiple ways to attempt to combat this, but there is no perfect answer to this dilemma. Many schools require at least one proctored exam that necessitates the student to show identification and prove they are the person enrolled in the class. Many instructors check the properties on the paper they receive to verify the owner of the computer the paper was created on. None of these methods are foolproof and they all add to the time and energy an instructor or administrator must put into an online class, but they do offer a way to find a few imposters and get the word out that they are checking for such things, which is often all that is necessary to deter a student from cheating. Finally, perhaps one of the best ways to keep students from cheating is to build a rapport with them that motivates in them a love of learning and a respect for the instructor or professor. Online instructors may go about this relationship building in different ways, but all good online instructors strive for it. The key to successful online relationship building is timely and meaningful feedback. Good instructors talk to most of their online students at least once every day through either e-mail, asynchronous discussion, or a virtual world. They talk to all of their online students multiple times each week through one of these venues. When a student learns and comes to trust that they can reach their
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
instructor to get questions answered, assignments explained, or lectures expanded upon; then they start to build a much deeper relationship than can be built when a student only has contact with an instructor one, two, or even three times per week. The trust that comes from this relationship will motivate students to approach the instructor with issues regarding assignments that might otherwise have been solved by cheating. This relationship also gives the instructor a perfect venue for reaching and challenging more advanced students.
Student Expectations Most online instructors claim to have had their most academically advanced and most academically challenged students in online classes. The online environment tends to accentuate whichever one of these categories students fall into. One reason for this emphasis is the close relationship good online instructors have with their students. Another big reason is the fact that many students enroll in their first online class thinking it will be easier than the seated version of the same class. This is far from the truth. Online classes are meant to be more convenient – not easier. This is an oft made mistake. Students new to the online world quickly become overwhelmed by the larger workload of an online class. Steve Hynds, Director of Online Education at Drury University, listed this as the biggest issue he deals with regarding students. “Convenience doesn’t mean easy. Convenience just means convenience. . . The bigger concern with the students I’ve seen is the amount of work that is required . . . then [students] feel that online is a harder or actually a more enriched program because of the challenges that they have to go through for that convenience” (S. Hynds, Interview, October 24, 2008). The increased stage on which advanced online students can perform lets stars shine and those hungry to learn truly test themselves.
Institutional Issues While instructors and students wish to focus on the personal issues, administrators are much more concerned with institutional issues. The first hurdle the institution must cross is accreditation. After accreditation is acquired, the majority of institutional challenges will lay within the confines of the campus. These issues often involve the platform choice, staffing, scheduling, pricing and overall procedural guidelines. The biggest challenge, and often the most difficult to overcome for new programs, often deals with proving the academic quality and prestige of the program to the tenured personnel of the institution.
Accreditation A critical point in the development of a quality online program is acquiring the proper accreditation. Drury University went through this process in 2003-2004. It was a tremendous amount of work, but the payoff was certainly worth it. The scenario is described in detail here. In 2003 Drury University’s College of Graduate and Continuing Studies (CGCS) was beginning preparation for a visit from the Higher Learning Commission (HLC) under a new dean who had extensive experience regarding accreditation. As they undertook the self-study and contemplated what they wanted to achieve from the visit, it became obvious that the ability to grant degrees online was the next step. They already had an Associate of Science (AS) degree in environmental science management online through a contract with the military. There were several packages students could put together online to construct other AS degrees that were not official nor advertised nor even considered as online degrees. There were also several Bachelor of Science (BS) degrees that offered all but one class online. In order to stay within the requirements of the accreditation body, they needed to have an HLC
33
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
focused visit and request accreditation for online degree completion. The leadership team then guided the Drury accreditation team through the arduous task of compiling all of the documents and data to demonstrate they had the necessary requirements to acquire online accreditation. The following lists highlight the areas they felt HLC would be most concerned with and were areas where Drury University could show it was ready to be granted accreditation for online degree completion. 1.
2.
3.
34
Technological Improvements: Drury had moved from initially offering online courses through Electronic Reserves System (ERes) to using WebCT as its online platform. Drury University also appointed a Technical Advisor to provide training in the use of WebCT/online pedagogy. The online office also established an initial web presence via the University server for online course information. Drury hosted its online classes on campus servers until it outgrew the servers’ capability to support the program. In the fall of 2003 Drury University contracted with WebCT to host its courses at WebCT’s technology center in Vancouver, British Columbia. These technological improvements gave the online program “more robust Internet access with redundant backbones and [the] larger capacity server provides evidence that Drury is committing substantial financial resources to support this online course delivery initiative” (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.30). Online Tutoring: Drury University contracted with SMARTHINKING to “provide online student support in the areas of writing, the basic sciences, and mathematics, including statistics and accounting” at no additional cost to the student (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.30). Library Resources: Drury University’s Olin Library increased its ability to serve online
4.
5.
6.
students at remote locations by providing “online access to books, periodicals and resource materials maintained by Drury as well as access to interlibrary loan materials through Off-Campus Library Resources (OCLS) and Missouri Bibliographic Information User Service (MOBIUS)” (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.31). Olin Library also continued to offer ERes where instructors could post articles that were accessible by students via the Internet. Academic Advising and Registration: Every semester the online office provided all satellite and main campus staff current details about registration, adds, drops, and advising issues. The University also designated an advisor specifically for students taking online classes, who could field an array of questions regarding online classes. Drury also added an Advising Module to help students see how specific courses “fit into their program of study. Additionally, students can access their grades at the end of each term, print an unofficial transcript, and even calculate a future G.P.A.” (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.32). All registration was enhanced to allow complete web registration. Schedule Coordination: Beginning in spring 2004, the online course schedule was “developed into a rotational online schedule for the spring, summer and fall classes. The general undergraduate courses offered online are now undergoing a process of planning whereby students planning their academic strategy can rely upon specific online courses offered at planned intervals. . . . Overall, the online schedule . . . has evolved into an integral part of the CGCS institutional planning and development strategy” (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.33). Financial Aid Counseling: “Beginning in fall 2003, students were notified of financial aid awards through their University e-mail
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
7.
8.
accounts. . . This information allows students to logon to eRegistrar through the Drury University webpage to access their personal and financial information, register for online and seated courses at the appropriate times, access their academic degree history as well as a graduation audit” (HLC Change Request, 2004, pp.33-34). First Point of Contact: First Point of Contact was created to “make appointments for advisors, supply information about CGCS to those who inquire, track prospective inquiries and assist in mailings, assist with student surveys and various other duties” (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.34). The goal of the student worker-staffed position was to “provide more timely feedback, to provide for a central flow of information and to relieve some of the congestion from the front liners area” (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.34). This was a key element in providing a supporting structure for online students contacting the University from remote locations who needed various student services but did not know where to find them. Science Labs for the Online Learner: In 2003, Online Education at Drury University was awarded a 3M Science Grant for the purpose of researching online science labs. The funding was used to “investigate and research online science labs as adjuncts to current online science courses that incorporate lab activities into the course. The investigation was undertaken as part of the continuous improvement of online science courses for non-science majors and in preparation for offering the AS in Environmental Management degree online” (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.35). Many areas of the University were included in this research and subsequent discussion including the full-time science faculty, administrators, and members of the Academic Affairs Committee. “The most important goal was to help the committee and
the science faculty to develop an approach most suitable for non-science majors who cannot attend seated science courses” (HLC Change Request, 2004, p.35). The research examined the trends, options, and models used by other universities for online science lab delivery. 9. Student Technical Support: Online students needed a way to receive technical support at all hours of the day and on weekends. This was accomplished by three approaches a. General online information and general technical questions were listed on the online programs web pages. b. Specific online course questions were directed to the Online Education Office during normal business hours. c. Zavata, a private firm, was contracted out of Georgia that provided answers to technical computer questions 24/7 via phone. 10. Online Orientation: Students were given 24/7 access to an online orientation website that contained basic information on all aspects of WebCT as well as practical tips. 11. Online Bookstore: Automated enhancements were made to the Drury University bookstore’s capability to serve online students from remote areas. Students were able order their books for their online classes via the Online Education website and pay for them via a secure credit card payment method. The amount of work that went into planning for the HLC visit was enormous and involved many parts of the University, even though the visit only focused on the College of Graduate and Continuing Studies. The payoff was substantial, though. The HLC granted Drury University approval to offer any course in the Drury catalogue online. This allowed Drury University to offer any of its Associates and Bachelor’s degrees completely online.
35
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
Questions from Outside Online Education When schools started delivering education via the internet over a decade ago, there were many questions regarding the pedagogy and quality of the instruction. Most of these questions came from the established academy. For centuries, classes had been taught the same way – with instructor and student sitting in the same room. The possibility that the same quality of teaching and learning could be accomplished with the instructor and students on different continents was difficult to imagine. However, studies such as those published by Simonson, Smaldino, Albrght, and Zvacek in 2000 have proven that done correctly, student outcomes are quite similar regardless of whether the student is face-to-face with an instructor or thousands of miles away. (Simonson, M., Smaldiino, S., Albright, M., &Zvacek, S., 2000). In an interview with Dr. Gary Rader, who initiated a now thriving online program a decade ago, he discussed how he dealt with the doubts of the traditional academy on his campus. His response was through something he termed “chair diplomacy”. In short, it took spending time with each department and sometimes even each individual in a department and showing them how online classes worked, the assessment outcomes, and final projects and statements of the students from the classes. Basically, the idea of online parity had to be marketed and sold. And sold it was. Today online education is the fastest growing area at Drury University. Today’s leaders in online education do not have to deal with “selling” the idea of online education. Instead, they deal with the varieties of options facing established programs.
Learning Management System Options One of the first major decisions leaders in online education deal with is the choice of learning management system (LMS). There are numerous
36
factors involved in this decision and many of the factors can be further sub-divided. The LMS must “meet the requirements, functions and features as aligning with the program’s needs. Much due diligence has to be done to find out what the institution needs with input from many stakeholders” (T. Melacon, Interview, November 19, 2008). The features of the LMS must be forward thinking and able to support all of the exciting educational technology that is on the horizon. The LMS must function easily and without interruption; it must interface well with the programs the school already has in place; it must come with a strong support staff and may possibly need to offer hosting. These considerations would vary based on the institution’s needs and culture, but all should be considered.
Scheduling and Staffing Mature online programs share some of the same issues that new programs do – namely in the areas of scheduling and staffing. All types of higher education institutions – whether they be a small private institution, a community college, or a large public university – express a desire to alter the way classes are scheduled and staffed. The majority of schools still have the responsibility of staffing and scheduling falling to the department chairs or deans. This allows the experts in academia to ensure the academic qualifications of the instructors as well as the academic plan of the department by scheduling certain classes during specific semesters. Many leaders in online education would like to see changes to this, though. In recent interviews with leaders in online education, they were asked “If you could change something about your program, what would it be and why would you change it?” Almost everyone said they sought improvement in relation to the part of the institution that develops the schedule and staffing decisions related to it. In essence, while department chairs and deans may be able to see the goals and plans for their part of the
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
academic pie, the online director can see the whole picture for the online program. This means they can best see what students seeking a degree completely online need in order to fulfill all of the requirements. The online director also has a better feel for the pulse of the online instructors. They know which instructors generate a following and which have completed the required (and perhaps even beyond what is required) training. This appears to be the next major area of discussion between leaders in online education and traditional academia, and it may very well control the growth and profitability of the online program and ultimately the school.
Money Associated with Online Programs Online programs are growing and outpacing the growth of all other areas of higher education. With this growth are coming large profits, which are often desperately needed by the university. The amount of money generated by online programs is both a product of the number of courses and the price of those courses. For example, at Drury University the price per credit hour for an online class is $239, while the price per credit hour for a face-to-face class is $190. The difference of $49 is one of the reasons online programs have to potential to be such large revenue makers. It is necessary for institutions to consider their student body, the culture of the university, and their competitors when setting their price schemes. This revenue potential will continue to motivate institutions of higher education to add to their online programs.
Staffing Online Departments Most online programs are supported by an online office staffed by many individuals with significant online experience or degrees in the field. Some of these degrees include instructional design, educational technology, instructional systems
technology, education with an emphasis in elearning technology and design as well as Masters in Education degrees with emphasis in online teaching and learning. Each person in the office handles various areas of the online experience. There is normally a director, one or more technical support personnel, instructional designers, faculty liaisons or trainers, curriculum designers, marketing specialists, and others depending on the culture and makeup of the university. The jobs of these individuals are designed to complement each other to make all areas of the online program run smoothly. The director is the highest ranking position on most online offices. This person has oversight authority and responsibility for every aspect of the program. When interviewing numerous directors of various programs, it became obvious they consider the most important aspects of their jobs to be very similar. The two most oft mentioned areas were promotion of the program both outside and inside their respective universities and maintaining or enhancing control over scheduling and staffing. Many institutions of higher education are pushing their online departments to grow and expand in many ways because studies show that this is the most rapidly growing area of higher education. Directors of online education must market to many people in their own institution. They have to be constantly selling and reassuring faculty, chairs, deans, and trustees that the product they are delivering fits the school’s mission and academic niche. They also must keep all of these constituents apprised of the changes in technology and online education so the school can evolve with the industry, remain on the cutting edge, and maintain their market share. In order to promote their programs to potential students, many online offices are hiring marketing personnel who are well-informed and in tune with the particulars of online education in order to bring in new students. These marketing people must be able to highlight the advantages of online
37
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
classes – namely, convenience and flexibility as well as address issues such as technology requirements and understanding to potential students. The marketing person must work closely with the director in order to ensure the information communicated to potential students is accurate and timely. The director’s other main task involves maintaining or enhancing control over scheduling and staffing. As mentioned previously, this is an area that most directors wish they had more control over. There is an art to scheduling the correct classes at the correct time in the correct time frame (5, 8, 12, or 16 week classes). Many students prefer to take some classes in a particular order or balance their workload by considering the intensity or time necessary to complete a class when enrolling. For example, many history majors only like to enroll in one 300 or 400 level history class at a time because they are writing-intensive classes that will require a great deal of time. The online office understands this and would like to schedule classes according to what their customer (the student) wants. The department would like for history majors to complete all of their 100 level history courses before moving onto their 200 and 300 level courses and save the 400 level courses for their senior year. They are not looking at the situation from a customer’s point of view but rather the curriculum and how certain classes build upon others. These two different motivating factors push the department chairs and the director of online education in different directions regarding the scheduling of classes. This is a difficult issue to resolve. A clear cut mission statement for the online program is the only way most universities relieve the tension. Control over staffing goes hand in hand with scheduling. The most talented lecturer with a wall full of teaching awards from the experience in the traditional face-to-face classroom may never master online teaching. Conversely, an instructor who fails to communicate well or skillfully manage their face-to-face class may shine in an
38
online setting and become a popular and effective educator. This dichotomy is difficult to explain to chairs and deans, particularly if they have never taught online themselves. Furthermore, tenured faculty who are accustomed to having a large amount of power over their schedule balk against new and diverse systems of scheduling.
Growth Issues Once you have a successful program up and going, you want to grow it. However, with this growth comes a whole new set of challenges. Quality control procedures must change as a program expands. Instructor training, which may have been easily managed when instructors were small in number and local, takes on a whole new dimension when growth and diversity issues push the University to hire instructors located all over the world. Growth in an online program often creates a challenge to other parts of the university because of a loss of students from traditionally seated classes to the online environment. Successful online classes logically lead to online degrees, but this is yet another challenge. As stated at the beginning of this chapter, “The proliferation of distance education programs n the last few years is unprecedented in the history of higher education” (Monolescu, 2004, back cover). A perfect example of this is the growth in Drury University’s online program. Figure 1 shows the number of online course offerings over the last nine years. This rate of growth for online classes far surpasses the rate of growth for any other area of the university. However, this growth, while bringing a wealth of opportunity also brings it own set of challenges.
Quality Control Assessing both an online program as well as online classes is a challenge for many schools as they grow from a small online program offering a few
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
Figure 1.
courses to a large program offering full online degrees. Any online education program must match its institution’s mission, scope, objectives, and goals. Additionally, a strong online program must have a visionary and highly motivated director who is able to effectively communicate with multiple constituents. The director must have a highly skilled support staff that can handle the everyday workings of the program. He must also be associated with an institution that can adequately fund the program and serve all student needs outside of the actual classroom instruction. The semester to semester, if not week to week, evaluations of specific classes are what most people examine when considering the quality of an online program. There are several tools for doing this including focus groups, in-class evaluators, in-house evaluations, or outsourcing evaluation through a program such as IDEA (Individual Development and Evaluation Assessment). The key things factors any evaluation should look for are • • • • •
Instructor to student interaction Student to student interaction Fulfillment of course objectives Clarity of communication Timeliness and quality of instructor feedback
All types of assessment tools should look to measure both faculty and student satisfaction as well as gather information that could be used to improve the program in the future. Drury University has a multi-level concept of course evaluation. All faculty are selected through a four step approval process. First, the faculty are considered by the Director of Online Education, who evaluates their comfort level with technology and the Drury culture. Second, the department chair evaluates the academic credentials of the proposed instructor. Third, the Dean of the College of Graduate and Continuing Studies (CGCS) evaluates the proposed instructor and based on the notes from the Director of Online Education and the department chair makes a proposal to the Vice President of Academic Affairs, who ultimately makes final approval. This process is meant to ensure that no one enters the online training program without first having been vetted by all areas of the academic and administrative team. Once the person is approved and the course assigned, they fall into a set of evaluations specifically designed for new instructors. New instructors must have all of the materials for the first two weeks of their course posted by two weeks prior to the start of the course. The course is then visited by what the online office calls a “secret student”. This is a senior-level student or a recent graduate, who looks at the class from a
39
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
student’s point of view and give feedback as to how well the instructor did designing the class. A sample report can be found in Appendix A. This feedback is then given to the new instructor along with help to fix the necessary areas before the course begins. New instructors are also given a special mid-term evaluation, which can be viewed in Appendix B. The goal of this evaluation is to see how well the original plan has been implemented in the first half of the semester and to show administrators what (if any) help needs to be given to the instructor in order to improve the second half of the semester. All online courses, both those of new instructors and veterans, are visited by a faculty monitor multiple times each semester. The monitor fills out a report that is then submitted to the Director of Online Education. The Director then contacts each faculty to let them know the findings. A copy of the report can be found in Appendix C. This evaluation looks at everything from the appearance of the class to the timeliness of the instructor’s grading and feedback. This report is very helpful early in the semester to ensure that each class is organized in a way that students can understand exactly what is going on. It is useful throughout the semester as a measurement of instructors’ timeliness and commitment to constant and quality feedback. The final tool Drury University uses to access online classes is the Individual Development and Evaluation Assessment (IDEA) program administered through Kansas State University. This tool provides both statistical data and constructive feedback from the students. A sample of each can be found in Appendix D. These evaluations are administered towards the end of the semester. The conclusions are sent to the instructor, department chair, Director of Online Education, and the Dean of the College approximately three months later. After receiving information back from all of these assessment tools, steps must be taken to either fix stated problems or change the expecta-
40
tions so that they better fit the reality of an online class. This takes a great deal of time – both for the instructor to make the changes and for the administrator charged with ensuring the changes are made. This is why it is critical that the online office team be well staffed with competent individuals who understand all aspects of the operation.
Faculty Training Training of online faculty has evolved a great deal over the last decade. Most schools began by bringing their entire online faculty into the online office or together in a large computer lab for training sessions. For many schools, this practice has evolved to a mostly or even totally online training program. Instructors now understand that “online teaching forces a systematic rethinking of the course content in minute detail” (Little, Titarenko, and Bergelson, 2005, p.357) and are hungry for instruction in how to take the materials from a face-to-face course and apply them to an online course. A local community college with a thriving online program has evolved its faculty training into a very impressive system. When the college’s online program began in 2001, they did not have any faculty training per se. Then, they went to voluntary face-to-face training meetings. As they grew, this finally evolved into an online immersion type of training that lasted eight weeks. The instructors complained that eight weeks was too long, so it was shortened to the current system of four weeks. The completion of this four week training program for online faculty is now required of every individual before they are allowed to teach online. The training places the instructors in the student’s role. It is highly interactive and instructor facilitated. It is taught by an instructional designer and expert in online teaching. The training is broken into four modules that cover such things as managing discussion boards, completing activities in the practice course, and
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
skilled competencies. The training began as very heavy in theory with little instruction in how to use the course management system. However, “practicing teachers, a lot of them subject experts in academic disciplines, never having taken an education class could care less about studying about pedagogy and reading the articles. . . . so we take an approach of teaching the theory at the end. . . . showing them how to do it or modeling best practices of online teaching and then relating it to theory in the back end so they can see. . . . the actual reason and philosophy behind hit” (W. Salley, Interview, October 20, 2008). Each instructor must score a minimum of 80% each week in order to continue with the training and teach at the end. They also offer optional online faculty development courses such as multi-media survival skills and using synchronous tools in the online classroom. These optional classes are very well attended because they strive to make them very valuable and not very time intensive.
Online Learning and Teaching Certificate Programs Many other online programs are mirroring this type of program, which also has similarities with some of the Certificates in Online Teaching being offered. Colorado State University offers a Certificate in Online Learning and Teaching through their Global Campus, which they describe as being “designed for professionals in the educational, public or private training sectors who would like to develop the skills necessary to design, produce and facilitate online courses. College or university faculty, K-12 teachers, corporate trainers, program administrators, instructional designers and others who would like to enhance their skills, or prepare for a teaching or administrative career in online learning will find this program appealing” (http://www.csuglobal.org/certificate_programs. php). The four courses offered in this certificate program are
1. 2. 3. 4.
Instructional Theory and Design for Online Learning Online Learning Technologies Multimedia Technologies and Design Principles Evaluation and Assessment in Online Learning
This program is similar to California State University, East Bay’s certificate in Online Teaching and Learning, which they describe as meeting “the needs of university and college faculty, K-12 teachers, corporate and military trainers, educational administrators, curriculum designers, technical support staff and others who design, implement and teach online courses. Those with experience in online education and those who seek the necessary training will both find the program appealing. . . The program’s online-only format makes it convenient for anyone in the world, not just those who live or work in the San Francisco East Bay Area. Students can look forward to a hands-on, rigorous curriculum in which both the instructors and fellow students provide detailed feedback on every project and should expect to spend 10-12 hours or more per week on each class. They can communicate with their instructors and advisors in a variety of ways: email, telephone, chat room office hours and/or videoconference. A high-speed Internet connection is strongly recommended” (http://www.extension.csuhayward.edu/ certificate/online_teaching/index.shtml). This program, like Colorado State University’s is comprised of four courses. 1. 2. 3. 4.
Introduction to Online Teaching and Learning Teaching Models for Online Instruction Technology Tools for Online Instruction Designing Curriculum for Online Instruction
Throughout this certificate program, students employ what is learned on a single class as they
41
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
Figure 2.
construct it from inception through completion. These are just two of the many great certificate programs out there that appear to be laying the ground work for institutions to follow as they set out to train their own faculty.
Purposeful Online Growth The growth of online programs has caused many in academia to question whether the online option is pulling students out of face-to-face classes. This is a concern to administrators who are responsible for maintaining head counts in seated classes as well as the traditional academy who still feel students who can be in a seated class should be. Students are speaking with their enrollments and telling educational institutions that they prefer online classes to face-to-face classes. The reasons have a lot to do with the hectic lives many Americans live and the economic situation they currently face. Many students are working full-time while attending school full-time. Many adult students even add family responsibilities on top of fulltime jobs and school. These students want – even
42
demand – convenience in their education. They want to go to class when it fits into their schedule, and that often means at midnight after working all day and putting their children to bed. Students are also dealing with rising gas prices that have a direct impact on their education by forcing them to consider the price of driving to campus to attend a traditional seated class. These forces are combining to push students to increasingly choose internet classes over traditional seated ones. So, where do these students come from? Are they new to the educational institution? In some cases, yes; but in many cases, no. They are the students that had been attending face-to-face classes. Figure 2 shows how the rise in credit hours enrolled in online classes has obviously impacted the credit hours enrolled in seated classes at one university.
Rigor of Online Classes Students are increasingly pursing the online option, however many are quite vocal in criticizing the increased rigor encountered in online classes.
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
Here are what some history students have said regarding online and face-to-face classes: •
•
•
The difference between online and seated classes, are many. Online classes provide the convenience of going to class at home. However, the student must be organized and disciplined as the workload is readingwriting intensive and generally double to that of a seated class. (Slagle, 2008) In a seated course, if you show up, turn in your assignments and participate in the discussions, that’s basically all there is to it. With online classes, your participation is based on your posts. You are required to post at least once and reply to two other students, which, if done correctly, is the equivalent of writing a thorough, well-researched, two-page paper every week, on top of any assignments. (Bayless, 2008) My 2 cents worth after 3 years of online work. I have only had 4 seated classes... Online classes unlike seated classes require that the student be decidedly responsible to the online program. It is much more than just one day a week but a dedicated everyday occurrence. Decisions have to be made in the beginning where your priorities are... This is where you must manage your time and take every opportunity to log into the classroom. (Terrey, 2008)
Of course, an online student’s experience is dependent on the particular class and instructor they have. However, the evaluation statements seem to support the assertion that online classes are preferred yet require more time and commitment on the student’s part. Many faculty from traditional academia contend that the educational experience simply cannot be the same in an online class as it is in a traditional seated class. Many tenured faculty are also able to see multiple sides of the issue, such as Elizabeth Paddock, Chair of the Department of
History and Political Science at Drury University, who stated, “Online classes offer students and faculty an alternative that was not available even a few years ago. The experience obviously is not the same. It often is not possible to achieve the same depth or range of discussion in online classes that academics seek in seated classes. Faculty cannot call on students in the same way, and students in online discussions miss out on the passion and thrill of intellectual discovery and debate that are such a part of the traditional classroom. However, online education offers some significant benefits that are not available otherwise. The flexibility of online classes matches the fast-paced reality of modern society. These classes also allow a wider range of students to pursue their education, people who otherwise would not be able to fit their schedules with traditional seated courses. Finally, discussions in online classes often are more measured and less impulsive than discussions in traditional classes, and hence tend to be less passionate in some ways. At the same time, however, online discussions allow students more time to deliberate and consider their responses to questions and observations. Those students who may be intimidated in participating in regular classroom debates may find their voices more readily in the relative anonymity of the online classroom. There obviously are tradeoffs. The success of an online class ultimately rests with both faculty and students and their commitments to engagement in online assignments” (E. Paddock, Interview, November 24, 2008).
Online Degrees Many online programs are growing past online classes into complete online degrees. It is impossible to search the internet for anything dealing with education without having ads from various online colleges and universities appearing in advertisements on the page. While many of these institutions are outside the main academic and accreditation circles, numerous well-respected
43
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
institutions of higher education are venturing into the area of online degrees. The challenges for offering completely online degrees relate back to several ideas already discussed in this chapter. First, most quality institutions will seek accreditation to deliver the online degrees. Second, when students are being drawn into a program with the promise of a degree being completely online, it is critical that the scheduling of classes for that degree be done in a calculated and well-thought out manner. As previously mentioned, online education departments strongly feel that this means they should hold the power and responsibility for scheduling. Finally, when degrees are offered totally online, it becomes necessary for the educational institution to put student services online as well. Many educational institutions struggle with putting student services online because that reaches outside of the parameters of the online department. First and foremost, the library must offer adequate online holdings or ways to deliver research materials to students in various locals for students to complete research intensive courses. Other areas such as advising, financial aid, the bookstore, and business office must also offer students from far distances the same types of services they do for students who can walk up to their service windows. This requires staff, financial, and resource commitments from the institution.
concLusIon As students demand higher education with convenience and rigor, online programs must meet this challenge. The development and growth of online programs has become a permanent mark on the landscape of higher education, and in order to perfect high quality programs a set of best practices must be followed. Divided into three categories, these can be summarized as:
44
Student Issues: 1. Student learning styles remain based on visual, auditory, and kinesthetic stimulation whether the student is faceto-face with an instructor or a thousand miles away. Therefore, all three learning styles must be incorporated into a high quality online class. 2. The revised version of Bloom’s Taxonomy combines the cognitive process (remember, understand, apply, analyze, evaluate, and create) and the kind of knowledge to be learned (factual knowledge, conceptual knowledge, procedural knowledge, or meta-cognitive knowledge). This criteria should be used when developing objectives and assignments for an online class. 3. Instructors need to steer students away from cheating by educating their students on what constitutes cheating and how the student can best avoid it; constructing assignments in a way that makes cheating or plagiarism more difficult; finding new methods of assessment that are not easily plagiarized or otherwise taken advantage of by those looking for an easy way out; and building a rapport with students that motivates in them a love of learning and a respect for the instructor. 4. Online programs need to communicate to potential students that the convenience of an online class does not translate into it being easier than a face-to-face class. Students need to be prepared for the extra time required to complete the work and succeed in an online class. Institutional Issues: 1. Acquiring accreditation is the first step in building a high quality online education program. The specific case
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
study of Drury University’s preparation for a focused visit from the Higher Learning Commission highlights the importance of having the infrastructure in place to support the online students and faculty. It is necessary for a leader in the online education program to spend time with department chairs and deans showing them how online classes work, assessment outcomes, and final projects and statements of the students from the classes in order to garner inner institutional support for the program. The choice of a learning management system is a major decision for online programs. The system needs to fit the educational institution’s culture, budget, goals, and vision. Scheduling and staffing need to be done with consideration given to academic qualifications and goals as well as with a vision of the online program as a whole and students seeking online degrees in particular. Prices for online classes tend to be higher than prices for face-to-face classes. However, the demand for the online classes is outpacing the demand for the face-to-face classes. It is necessary for institutions to consider their student body, the culture of the university, and their competitors when setting their price schemes. In most cases, though, online classes will be a profit enhancer. It is imperative that online education departments have adequate and highly qualified staff. Most offices normally employ a director, multiple technical support personnel, instructional designers, faculty liaisons or trainers, curriculum designers, marketing spe-
cialist and others depending on the culture and makeup of the university. Growth Issues: 1. Quality control is a major issue as online programs grow to encompass several hundred classes taught by instructors located all over the world. A case study of Drury University’s quality control and assessment program highlights the need for courses to be evaluated at multiple times (before, during, and after the semester) by multiple perspectives (students, peers, administrators). The evaluation must then be followed up by corrective measures and often additional guidance from the online education department. 2. Training faculty to teach online is very important and evolving process. Today’s most successful strategies include emersion in an online training course set up much like the faculty’s potential online course. Most institutions of higher education have developed their own unique programs for their faculty, however several certificate programs in Online Teaching and Learning have emerged in the last few years as well. 3. Schools must accommodate student demands for flexibility and convenience in their educational experience. This often means readjusting curriculum and schedules of areas outside online education to help students fulfill their desires for education on their time table. 4. The rigor and time commitment required to achieve success in an online class are often not understand by persons who have never taken an online course. Students considering enrolling in their first online course need to have the expectations clearly communicated to them prior to the first day of class.
45
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
5.
Online degree completion requires a great deal of commitment from the educational institution. The most important considerations involve accreditation, specific scheduling of classes in a calculated and well-thought out manner, and the transition of student services online.
Any online program’s adherence to these best practice guidelines and examples must, of course, be tempered and made to fit the educational institution’s culture and academic governance system. However, if done correctly, the proliferation of online programs is a very positive development for students seeking a rigorous educational experience highlighted by flexibility and convenience.
reFerences Anderson, L.W., & Krathwohl (Eds.). (2001). A Taxonomy for Learning,Teaching, and Assessing: A Revision of Bloom’s Taxonomy of Educational Objectives. New York: Longman. Bourne, J., & Moore, J. (Eds.). (2002). Elements of Quality Online Education. Sloan Center for Online Education.
46
HLC Report. (2003). [A Classroom of One: How Online Learning Is Changing Our Schools and Colleges. New York: Palgrave Macmillan.]. Gene, I. Little, C. B., Titarenko, L., & Bergelson, M. (2005). Creating a Successful International DistanceLearning Classroom. [from http://www.jstor.org/]. Teaching Sociology, 33(4), 355–370. Retrieved October 18, 2008. Monolescu, D., Schifter, C., & Greenwood, L. (2004). The Distance Education Evolution: Issues and Case Studies. Hershey, PA: Information Science Publishing. Rose, C. (1991). Accelerated Learning. Aylesbury, Bucks.: Accelerated Learning Systems Ltd. Simonson, M., Smaldiino, S., Albright, M., & Zvacek, S. (2000). Teaching and learning at a distance: Foundations of distance education. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. Wallace, Raven McCrory (2004). A Framework for Understanding Teaching with the Internet. American Educational Research Journal Vol.41, No.2, 447-488. Retrieved October 18, 2008, from http://www.jstor.org/
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
APPendIx A Figure 3. Secret student evaluation of new online instructor’s course
APPendIx b
Table 2. New instructor mid-term evaluation form Mid-Term Evaluation Form
Please complete this Evaluation Form. Your answers to the following questions will be relayed to the instructors in such a fashion as to ensure your confidentiality. Do not put your name on this form. These do not become part of the instructor’s file, but instead are designed to give the instructor important feedback from the student at the midpoint in the semester. Circle your response to the following questions: A. This course is well-organized and carefully planned. 1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Disagree 4. Strongly Disagree COMMENTS: B. The instructor has good teaching skills; he or she produces steady interest in the subject, creates real desire to learn, keeps things moving. 1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Disagree 4. Strongly Disagree COMMENTS:
continued on following page 47
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
Table 2. continued C. Assignments are explained well and students clearly understand the tasks of each new assignment. 1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Disagree 4. Strongly Disagree COMMENTS: D. Class discussions are handled well; the questions are challenging and demand sound thinking, and the discussions are interesting and stimulating. 1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Disagree 4. Strongly Disagree COMMENTS: E. Examination questions are thought-provoking, carefully selected, and clear. Results are given to students quickly. 1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Disagree 4. Strongly Disagree COMMENTS F. The instructor has an excellent mastery of subject material. 1. Strongly Agree 2. Agree 3. Disagree 4. Strongly Disagree COMMENTS:
APPendIx c
Table 3. Course visitation report sheet Monitor’s Name: Course Number: Instructor: Course Duration: Date of Visit: Text Block Usage:
Yes
No
Color Choices:
Excellent
Good
Poor
Course Navigation/Structure:
Easy
Challenging
If challenging, what are your suggestions to make it easier?
Syllabus Clearly Visible:
Yes
No
Schedule Posted:
Yes
No
Grading Scale:
Yes
No
Calendar Available and Up To Date:
Yes
No
Grading Rubric:
Clear
Neutral
Course Materials Current:
Yes
No
Discussion Board Read:
24 Hours
48 Hours
72 Hours
E-mails Answered:
24 Hours
48 Hours
72 Hours
48
Unclear
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
APPendIx d Figure 4. Idea evaluation feedback form
49
The Proliferation, Pitfalls, and Power of Online Education
Figure 5. Idea evaluation feedback form (continued)
This work was previously published in Cases on Distance Delivery and Learning Outcomes: Emerging Trends and Programs, edited by D. Gearhart, pp. 167-189, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
50
51
Chapter 1.4
The Virtual University: Distance Learning Spaces for Adult Learners David S. Stein The Ohio State University, USA Hilda R. Glazer Capella University, USA Constance E. Wanstreet The Ohio State University, USA
AbstrAct
IntroductIon
By offering self-designed, guided independent study, for-profit virtual universities began as alternatives to traditional graduate education that emphasized full-time study and ignored the life demands of adult students. However, through the process of gaining accreditation, recognition by the academy, and acceptance in the marketplace, virtual universities now more closely resemble traditional institutions. Their challenge to traditional academic practices predominately rests with the use of electronic tools for learning and the access virtual universities provide thousands of part-time learners pursuing doctoral degrees.
New delivery systems are challenging the supremacy of the physical classroom. Virtual (online) institutions of higher education are disputing the primacy of land-based universities as the only legitimate form of education for adults. Online and mobile learning tools are increasing access to opportunities for postsecondary adult education. However, little has been published about the ways in which adult learning is taking place in the virtual universities (VUs). These institutions have emerged in the past decade as providers of proprietary higher education to thousands of adults who otherwise may not have opportunities to engage in postsecondary study. How virtual universities came about, what they are doing to help adult learners achieve better lives, and what their future holds are the themes of this chapter.
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-828-4.ch004
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
The Virtual University
bAcKGround As the educational marketplace becomes predominately adult-dominated, and as higher education institutions compete for adult enrollments, understanding how virtual universities are changing the landscape of higher education will be a significant issue in adult education. A number of trends are converging. For example, students learning online will outnumber those in seats for the majority of their education (Allen & Seaman, 2007). Learning is globally available at any time and in any place. Students entering the university have grown up with technology and expect to interact and learn through electronically mediated environments. For example, students are able to access information online while sitting in class. This necessitates additional skills to evaluate sources of information critically. University faculty will need to consider the question of how they deal with the changing nature of the classroom, access to information, and how private VUs can provide opportunities for learning on a global basis, especially at the graduate level to otherwise disenfranchised learners (Cassano, 2008). Additionally, private VUs are challenging the notion of the traditional campus and the interactions that take place on a land-based campus. In essence, the virtual university suggests that learning opportunities should come to the adult learner rather than adult learners having to come to the campus. Considering the classroom as the space in which learning occurs, we can reconceptualize learning spaces to include the virtual as well as the face to face. This will influence how formal education is provided and, in turn, how adults will learn in the networked age. Attempts at forecasting the future of learning have relied on applying current technologies to learning and have manipulated the settings for learning. For example, Levin (2002) forecasted the idea of tele-task forces for collaborative learning, neighborhood learning centers, and tele-apprenticeships. The models were rather conservative
52
and did not fundamentally alter the manner in which content was provided or the roles of the instructor and learner. Virtual universities are on the technological edge regarding adult learning. They are altering how graduate education is obtained and are redefining the interactions between faculty member and adult learner. Distance learning institutions held forth the promise of providing high-quality adult education any place, any time, and at any pace. This chapter describes the manner in which VUs are delivering on that promise. This chapter is informed by public sources of information as well as our experience teaching in various private VUs. The authors and the voices reflected in this chapter have lived the lives of online instructors. They have been involved with graduate online distance education as it evolved from the idea of distance learning as independent study to the notion of education delivered through the virtual campus. This chapter addresses the following questions in the context of independent, for-profit virtual institutions: • • •
What were the visions guiding the development of adult-focused online universities? What characteristics do VUs share that help adult learners achieve better lives? What trends are emerging for VUs in relation to traditional universities?
The emergence of the for-profit, virtual university primarily serving adult learners continues the evolution of offering opportunities for those learners who, because of geographic location, work and family commitments, or prior academic experience, could not attend or not be accepted at many of the established land-based universities. Although Hanna (2007) characterizes these universities as motivated by profit, these institutions have provided greater opportunity for adult learners by responding to their needs for baccalaureate to graduate education. In addition, VUs have adopted online and collaborative tech-
The Virtual University
nologies more rapidly than traditional land-based universities. Clark (2007) defines the virtual campus as an educational organization that offers courses through the Internet or Web-based methods. This is a simplistic view and ignores the structure and organization that have developed to support the online learner. The virtual campus as it has evolved embraces the full range of services that might be found on a land-based campus, with the exception of sports and other inter- and extramural activities. Private VUs share many common characteristics regarding formation, mission, and delivery of services. Garber (2006) suggested a conceptual scheme for analyzing characteristics of an educational delivery system that include (a) an adult focus, (b) alignment with the professional/working needs of adults, (c) movement through a degree, (d) accessibility, and (e) learning connected to the work force and the community for the betterment of both. We will examine the virtual university in the context of those characteristics.
the vIsIon oF An AduLtFocused InstItutIon The 1960s were a time of unrest and innovation at North American universities. Given the zeitgeist, the climate was supportive of alternative approaches to the ways in which graduate education was provided and completed. The for-profit VUs began as a reaction to the place- and time-bounded requirements that dominated graduate education. Traditional institutions’ emphasis on full-time study also neglected the life demands of the adult students. The idea of the VU was to provide a place and space for working adult learners to meet and achieve their educational objectives with a faculty strongly committed to innovation and learnercentered philosophical stances. At first, the VU was not a technological innovation but an educational alternative grounded in the ideas of andragogy and learning contracts (Knowles, 1970). According to
Brian Austin (personal communication, July 23, 2008), who was a faculty member and later dean of psychology at two virtual universities, the VU was conceptualized as a place for doctoral students to take control of their education and complete their degrees, thus building on the concept that adult learners investigate topics of interest to them and build from their experiences. Admission was granted to those learners who had been in traditional doctoral programs and were unable to complete the dissertation for financial, personal, work, or other reasons. Bruce Francis, a faculty member at two VUs, recalls the impetus behind the curriculum design: The essence of doctoral education was the relationship between the learner and the mentor. The idea was to change doctoral education to establish a more collegial relationship in which the learner was not looked down upon. . . . The model of education had to fit the lifestyle of the learner, not the learner fitting into the lifestyle of the program. Thus, the needs of learners were central. (B. Francis, personal communication, August 5, 2008) Graduate education could be provided at a distance. Alternative educators viewed an alternative form of graduate education as a vehicle for introducing reform in public education. In describing the early years of distance education, Austin (personal communication, July 23, 2008) expressed the excitement and hope that alternative graduate education would bring to higher education. Distance education in the mid-1970s was primarily a commitment to correspondence and a four-week summer session. In the early 1980s, VUs moved to a formal curriculum and a four-week summer session with focused seminars. VUs no longer thought of distance education in terms of correspondence but rather as dispersed residency. This was a critical point in their development. Distance education meant dispersed residency with knowledge/competency demonstration through
53
The Virtual University
modules. This approach had been well under way in Europe during the 1970s but was new to the United States (Mason, 2000). The residency model was built on the need to engage the community in sustained study for short periods of time. It was an institute for innovative practices for teachers, curriculum developers, and leaders. The founders sought to provide useful knowledge for informed practice. Therefore, they looked for faculty to develop innovative practices through applied professional research in education, human services, and business. The mission of this type of institution was to develop a scholar-practitioner, one who could be a leader in his or her professional setting and use theory to inform and guide practice (B. Austin, personal communication, July 23, 2008).
ALIGnMent wIth the ProFessIonAL/worKInG needs oF AduLts The early curriculum models consisted of guided independent study with a faculty assessor. The curriculum was designed around a core set of knowledge modules and specialization modules. Each module was designed to respond to theory in a basic social science area of inquiry and examine the empirical research in depth. Each module also included a component in which the learner was to demonstrate application of theory and research to a real-world problem. The unique feature of the learning model was an emphasis on the needs of the adult learner in the context of the learner’s professional life. Rather than faculty determining readings, activities, and evaluation, learners, given general guidelines, developed learning agreements based on their discipline and professional interests. This learning model emphasized a general understanding of social science knowledge as applied at the individual, group, and societal levels. It matched the ways people lived and learned (B. Francis, August 5, 2008). The learning model was
54
based on the mission of the institutions to connect theory and practice, thus bringing about positive changes in society. According to Austin (personal communication, July 23, 2008), the VUs “never lost sight of their potential to change practice and communities through innovative ideas in adult and collaborative learning.” VUs were built upon the belief that students have an obligation to practice in their fields and apply their knowledge in ways that move their field of inquiry, their communities, and society toward higher levels of thinking and acting. The focus of the VU is to promote the idea of the scholar-practitioner, a degree holder, especially at the doctoral level, who applies theory, conducts research, and acts on that research in the world of practice. The VU learning model emphasized the learning of intellectual skills over receiving a grade. Recognizing the busy lives that working adults maintained, learning activities were accomplished on a schedule designed by the learner rather than by an academic calendar. Generally, a learning project could last from six to 12 months. Projects were redone as often as necessary until the criteria for an acceptable learning outcome was determined by the faculty and student.
MoveMent towArd successFuL deGree coMPLetIon Early in the graduate program, the learner was expected to develop the skills necessary to conduct and report on independent research. Each stop of the learning model respected the time constraints and individual learning styles of the adult learner. The learning model was designed to begin the process of thinking through a dissertation topic as well as developing the thinking and writing skills needed for independent research. One VU committed to social change delivered content and learning process skills through knowledge area modules in which learners were expected
The Virtual University
to address content from a theoretical, empirical, and applied knowledge base. The modules were completed on a timetable developed by the learner using the vehicle of a learning contract. The learning contract specified the readings, topics to be investigated, and the evaluation plan. With the emphasis on social change, learnercenteredness, and connection to practice issues, the learning model reinforced the notion of independent exploration of a topic under the guidance of a faculty assessor. Writing a learning agreement taught the learner how to frame a problem, obtain sources, and integrate the content to develop an original argument that had theoretical, empirical, and practical dimensions. The course work was designed to develop the cognitive skills needed to write and present a dissertation. The model suggested that the learner would easily be able to transition from writing in a knowledge area to writing a dissertation. In that way, there would be continuity between the skills needed to plan and organize content areas and those needed to write the dissertation. Learner-centeredness included extensive collaboration between the assessor and learner in the development of critical thinking skills, assessment tools, and a sense of responsibility for learning on the part of the student. Students were responsible for shaping the curriculum to best meet their contextual needs. Students were developing skills in constructing purposeful learning activities and approaches, the idea of meta-learning; i.e., learning about their own learning (Bosch et al., 2008; Emes, 2003).
Accessibility The most notable feature of the VU is the student body. The ideal of a dispersed learning model, a self-designed timetable for completing the degree, and an open admissions policy provided an opportunity for working adults in midlife to return to an academic institution and work toward obtaining a graduate degree.
In the VU, life experience and desire are factors in the admissions process. For working adult learners, the opportunity to study at the doctoral level may be hindered by requirements such as full-time status, grade point average (GPA), the graduate record examination (GRE), interviews, and the university academic calendar designed around daytime rather than evening classes. VUs have provided access to higher education and the opportunity to succeed to those who might be denied admission. In 2006, one VU admitted more than 15,000 graduate students, of whom approximately 4,000 were doctoral students. Although GRE scores are not required, applicants must have a master’s degree and an acceptable GPA. The GPA range across the university was 3.24-3.77. Twenty applicants were denied admission because of low GPAs and 103 applicants were denied admission due to inadequate preparation for the intended field of study. Another VU offers more than 970 online courses and 21 undergraduate and graduate degree programs in 109 specialized areas of study. One VU has more than 23,700 learners from all 50 states and 45 countries. Women outnumber men 68% to 32%, and urban learners (at 79%) outnumber learners in rural areas (at 21%). The average age is 40 (ranging from 19-86), and 42% of the learners are people of color. Only 10% of those enrolled attend full time, with 90% studying part time (Capella, 2008). The VUs have also increased accessibility to graduate education for women and minorities. In 2006, women constituted more than 80% of the applicants in two colleges and were the majority of applicants across the campus. Minorities accounted for 48% of the applicants. Applicants tend to come from other innovative and nontraditional programs that attract adult learners rather than from the traditional universities. VUs have increased the accessibility of doctoral education and have increased the diversity of students. VUs have purposefully made decisions to comply with accessibility standards related to as-
55
The Virtual University
sistive technologies and have active ADA offices to work with individuals on needed accommodations. With students all over the world participating in courses, asynchronous technology is employed because it is universally accessible.
Availability As VUs have grown in terms of faculty and students, they have used technology to provide services that learners would find on any physical campus. Learners can conduct all daily transactions with university administration online. Services are available 24 hours a day, seven days a week. VUs also offer phone contact for those who prefer that method of communication. In addition, faculty services in the form of mentoring and instructional responsibilities are available around the clock. The expectations for faculty-student interactions are carefully prescribed in terms of responsiveness for feedback, postings in the online classrooms, and turnaround time for grading of weekly assignments. In virtual institutions, teaching is also a 24/7 activity. Expectations for faculty include (a) reviewing postings and discussions three to four days a week on a staggered schedule, (b) posting to the discussion forum three to four days a week and responding to at least two-thirds of the class weekly, (c) checking and responding to e-mail messages every 48 hours during weekdays, (d) grading assignments within seven business days, and (e) holding office hours two hours per week. VUs have no tenure systems. Teaching appointments are annual and based on responsiveness to learner needs as well as content expertise. Faculty activities are monitored for quality and consistency. The classrooms can be checked regularly for interactions between faculty and learners against the standards for timeliness and interaction. Building connections through frequent instructor-learner interaction increase student identification with the university as well as keep students involved in course activities.
56
For doctoral students, a mentoring program was originally the norm. This has evolved in some institutions to assigning mentors closer to comprehensive examinations and the dissertation. Advising is the responsibility of staff so that the faculty can develop a mentoring relationship with their learners. The online faculty member is either core or adjunct. Faculty are hired for their teaching and content expertise; and research is generally not supported, although it is valued. Adjunct faculty may teach in a number of VUs and still continue to conduct professional activities or hold jobs in industry.
connectInG the worKForce And coMMunIty For the betterMent oF both Providing graduate education for the professions is a hallmark of virtual institutions, and social change is at the heart of their missions. The goal is to provide professions with individuals who will work directly to bring about positive social change in concrete ways. The social change mission as exemplified in the learning model requires a deliberate process of creating and applying ideas, strategies, and actions to promote the worth, dignity, and development of individuals, communities, organizations, institutions, cultures, and societies. Positive social change, by definition, results in the improvement of human and social conditions. The commitment to social change guides the curriculum, the nature of doctoral dissertations, and the activities that are part of the residency requirement. One VU that believes so strongly in this mission awards scholarships to faculty and students who pursue social change in their practice (Walden, 2008). The delivery system has the potential to increase the quantity and quality of individuals working in professions. At the undergraduate level, students are prepared for specific jobs.
The Virtual University
At the master’s level, the focus is on mid-career professionals who want to improve their knowledge and skills. Today, programs are available in pubic health, education, nursing, professional psychology, mental health services, and public administration.
MovInG towArd A trAdItIonAL systeM Have VUs met the promise of providing highquality adult learning any place, any time, and at any pace? By the year 2000, VUs had adopted online learning systems resembling typical landbased courses. Traditional grades had replaced the competency-based grading system, and classes were structured like traditional graduate courses. VUs retained their goal of meeting the lifestyle needs of adult learners but have moved toward traditional goals of graduate education. Components of the self-designed, self-directed independent learning model are still present. However, to meet accreditation standards imposed by professional organizations, demands of learners for courses and transcripts more recognizable by employers and other funding agencies, and a more structured approach to learning, VUs are turning toward a traditional campus learning model. The transition is occurring in three phases. Phase one involves gaining legal accreditation; e.g., negotiating with libraries and hiring credentialed faculty. Phase two involves gaining recognition by the academy; e.g., hiring faculty who connect their research and publishing to the university and moving to an administrative structure of deans rather than vice presidents. Phase three involves demonstrating to employers that graduates are qualified to meet workplace expectations. Phases two and three continue to evolve. In the process, VUs have focused less on offering alternative ways of learning. The difference is in the delivery more than the design of the learning experience.
Virtual universities have increased the number of learners pursuing graduate degrees and have opened up doctoral degrees to those who wish to apply their knowledge and skills to improve practice and contribute to dealing with complex problems in their communities. The doctoral degree is now available any place and to nearly anyone who wishes to undertake graduate study. By graduating thousands of doctoral degree holders each year, VUs have raised the question of the meaning of the doctoral degree itself and have challenged the exclusivity of the doctoral degree. Despite becoming more mainstream, we believe VUs will continue to question traditional academic practices in higher education. A tension in the desire to be innovative and on the edge is counterbalanced by the need for respectability and acceptance in the graduate academic community. While VUs continue to be on the edge of technology and promote electronic tools for learning, the experience of learning itself more closely resembles traditional institutions. At the same time, VUs challenge traditional universities to learn from them and move into the virtual world, thus making their own mark on learning alternatives in the 21st century.
reFerences Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2007). Online nation: Five years of growth in online learning. Needham, MA: Sloan-C. Bosch, W., Hester, J., MacEntee, V., MacKenzie, J., Morey, T., & Nichols, J. (2008). Beyond lipservice: an operational definition of “learningcentered college.” . Innovative Higher Education, 33(2), 83–98. doi:10.1007/s10755-008-9072-1 Capella University. (2008). Capella learners and alumni. Retrieved October 1, 2008, from http:// www.capella.edu/online_learning/students.aspx
57
The Virtual University
Cassano, C. (2008). The global advantages of learning online. Distance Learning Today, 6. Retrieved September 25, 2008, from http://www. dltoday.net/viewart.php?pk=45
Hanna, D. (2007). Organizational change in higher distance education. In M. G. Moore (Ed.), Handbook of Distance Education (2nd ed., pp. 501-514). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Clark, T. (2007). Virtual and distance education in North American schools. In M. G. Moore (Ed.), Handbook of Distance Education (2nd Ed., pp. 473-490). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.
Knowles, M. (1970). The modern practice of adult education. New York: Association Press.
Emes, C., & Cleveland-Innes, M. (2003). A journey toward learner-centered curriculum. Canadian Journal of Higher Education, 33(3), 47–69. Garber, R. (2006, November 3). Next governor has promised to boost education of work force. The Columbus Dispatch, p. A13.
Levin, J. (2002). A 2020 vision: Education in the next two decades. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3(1), 105–114. Mason, R. (2000). From distance education to online education. The Internet and Higher Education, 3, 63–74. doi:10.1016/S1096-7516(00)00033-6 Walden University. (2008, August). Scholarships awarded for social change efforts. The Walden Ponder. Retrieved October 1, 2008, from http:// ponder.waldenu.edu/c/11468_26275.htm
This work was previously published in Adult Learning in the Digital Age: Perspectives on Online Technologies and Outcomes, edited by T. T. Kidd; J. Keengwe, pp. 32-39, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
58
59
Chapter 1.5
Why Choose an Online Course? Lawrence A. Tomei Robert Morris University, USA April Kwiatkowski Robert Morris University, USA Lorie Brown Robert Morris University, USA Lori Pash Robert Morris University, USA Christine Javery Southern New Hampshire University,USA Julie Ray Robert Morris University, USA Rae Ann Durocher Southern New Hampshire University,USA
AbstrAct OCICU is the Online Consortium of Independent Colleges and Universities and consists of five provider institutions which are located throughout the United States and Ireland. This consortium is the first of its kind to exist in distance education. The researchers wanted to understand why students choose to take courses through the consortium as well as why students opt for online learning
instead of traditional face to face instruction. The research was limited courses that were completed in the Fall 2006, Spring 2007, and Fall 2007. The review of the literature revealed several factors of teaching online that affect why member schools recommend an OCICU course to their students and why these students succeed or fail in an online environment. The response rate of 25% diminishes the ability of this investigation to generalize to this population of 64 institutions.
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Why Choose an Online Course?
IntroductIon OCICU is the Online Consortium of Independent Colleges and Universities and consists of five provider institutions which are located throughout the United States and Ireland. Currently there are 64 member institutions that refer approximately 550 students per academic year to the consortium. OCICU allows students from member institutions to register for approved courses being offered by provider schools and course credit is granted by the home / sending institution. The target market for OCICU are small institutions which currently have limited to no access to online courses but have identified a need by their students for online courses. Provider institutions help member institutions increase enrollment, retention, and revenue by allowing them to offer their students a wider breadth of courses without having to develop an internal online program. The researchers want to understand why students choose to take courses through the consortium and as well as why they, students, prefer online learning to traditional face to face instruction.
PurPose oF the study This study explored online learning, particularly within the Online Consortium of Colleges and Universities (OCICU) program. This consortium is the first of its kind to exist in distance education. Because of the infancy of this program and the lack of available research within this realm, the provider institutions requested that a research project be undertaken to benefit the future course planning of the OCICU. Within this study, the researchers investigated the course selection for students, the reasons why member institutions recommend these courses to students, and why students choose to enroll in the courses within this
60
consortium. Along with the course investigation, this study compared and contrasted the provider schools, attempting to identify the reasons why some institutions entice more students than other institutions. The overall goal of this research project was to further examine this program with the target of allowing the OCICU to better align itself with the demands and requirements of potential students and member institutions.
LIMItAtIons And deLIMItAtIons The research limitations encountered include: limiting courses and orientations to those completed in the Fall 2006, Spring 2007, and Fall 2007; excluding the Summer 2007 courses in this study; level of difficulty of the online course, (e.g. an advanced accounting course); considering the success of the orientation of students who completed their online course; considering the success of the orientation for those students who dropped the online course. The delimitations to the study included: knowledge and previous experience of the online course instructors; level of instruction readiness of the student; follow-up of member institutions with students to ensure completion of the orientation; the motivation of the student to complete the orientation; the interest of the student in completing the orientation; the time of day the student accessed the online course and that factors impact on their success; the technological capacity of the student to access and complete an online orientation; the varying lengths of the courses offered by the providers of the consortium; whether the member institutions provided face to face orientation in addition to the online orientation; the number of individual who attended any face to face orientation group; and the length of online orientation sessions.
Why Choose an Online Course?
sIGnIFIcAnce oF the study As our society changes through the information age, and now into the telecommunication age, formal education has become essential for the economic success of individuals. Individuals seeking college course offerings are becoming increasingly diverse to include older, married, employed, and non-residential students (Beller & Or, 1998). A factor influencing higher education is increased competition for students. Universities are banding together to form consortiums to offer additional degrees and flexibility in course offerings. At many institutions, the effectiveness of distance and on-line learning methodologies has not been well researched prior to adoption. To better understand how these consortium course offerings are affecting the consortium member institutions and providing institutions, this study will provide insight as to the future of the OCICU and similar consortiums. The results will serve as a guide when determining what the future of the OCICU should entail. Should the entity grow by member institutions and provider institutions? Should the providing institutions expand course offerings?
revIew oF the LIterAture Primary research of why students choose to take online courses over traditional face-to-face classes overwhelming shows that there is no single reason why students choose online over traditional classroom based courses. However studies do show similarities in the reasons students prefer to take online courses. (Caruso 2007, Chang 2001, Cooper 2003, Diaz 1999, Dutton 2002, O’Malley 1999, Galusha 1997, Pope 2006) Dutton, Pope, Caruso, and Chang identified six general characteristics common in online students, work and family schedules, shorter / no commute, flexibility, life style, control over
schedule, and need for high demand courses. Additionally students who have physical disabilities are also more likely to take classes online as opposed to traditional classes. (Galusha, 1997) Research conducted by Diaz, O’Malley, and Caruso also show the average age of the “typical” online learner is older than that of the traditional day student and that individual perceptions, prior experiences, comfort level with technology, and learning style all play an important role in the student’s success rate. According to Sabine Seufert of the University of St. Gallen, located in Switzerland), colleges as well as businesses are competing globally. Seufert ascertains that both corporations and universities need to utilize “new e-learning strategies…to react to the changes in a competitive and global education market” (p. 3). One such strategy is the development of an educational consortium. An example of a well-established consortium is the “Next Generation University,” which was founded in 1997. This consortium offers business courses to various companies by working with the leading business schools worldwide. In Seufert’s case study, he identifies potential benefits of consortiums, including a reduction in the necessary funds associated with course development, superior course quality, and greater flexibility for students. We live in a global society with technology infused into every aspect of our lives. Education from kindergarten through college has greeted technology ranging from computers in the classroom to online and distance learning. In order to stay competitive in this global society, higher education has adjusted and adapted the courses offered, and the way they are offered, to attract students. Through 2014, the National Center for Education Statistics projects a rise of 11 percent in enrollments of people younger than 25, and an increase of 15 percent in the number of 25 and older (Hatfield, 2007). This growth of students
61
Why Choose an Online Course?
creates a need to expand course offerings through online and distance education. Nationwide, 20 percent of all college students at the graduate and undergraduate level are enrolled in at least one online course according to the Sloan Foundation (Robbins, 2007). In 2006, Picciano cited information from a survey conducted nationally by Allen & Seaman in 2004, noting that 52.6 percent of chief academic officers asked viewed online learning as critical to their institutions overall long-term strategy. Colleges and universities are increasing their involvement in online learning for a number of reasons that include: expanding access to their educations for students not geographically close to the institution, providing more convenient access to students with busy lives that combine career/ work/family responsibilities with education, opportunities for home bound students and allowing military personnel to continue their education (Picciano, 2006). The use of the Internet for educational purposes is widespread and rapidly growing. With the online student population expanding by 30 percent a year, thousands of university courses have been developed for delivery entirely via the web (Dutton & Perry, 2002). This trend will only accelerate as more colleges and universities band together to offer online courses in consortiums. Online classes provide greater flexibility to students who benefit from being able to control the time during which they study the course materials. In addition to flexibility, online classes offer greater convenience since the class can literally be taken anywhere there is access to a computer (Dutton & Perry, 2002; O’Malley, J., McCraw, H., 1999). The two major reasons students choose online courses are: to avoid conflicts between class meetings and other responsibilities; and to avoid travel when the student’s residence is far from campus (Dutton & Perry, 2002).
62
summary The review of the literature revealed several factors of teaching line that affect why Member Schools recommend an OCICU course to their students and why these students succeed or fail in an online environment. Member schools who best match student needs (in a litany of factors that are yet undetermined) to Provider School course offerings will do more to increase student satisfaction than any other factor impacting registration. Advising for online programs seems to be more successful when initiated by faculty and academic advisors than other institutional administrators. Timing is important; the literature suggests that provider term dates should match as closely as possible with member dates. Such equivalencies are more likely to result in a suitable match. The most important characteristics common to online students should be considered when developing and scheduling online courses and programs and include: student scheduling considerations and the advantages of asynchronous and/or synchronous tools; totally online versus hybrid formats and the necessary commute time for any courses not offered 100 percent online; flexibility in instructional delivery methods using the breadth of available technologies at the institution; personal life style demands that include socio-economics considerations such as cost of the technology, fees, and tuition; and, the most flexible scheduling scheme for satisfying student needs for high demand courses.
MethodoLoGy oF the study survey Instrument Members of the research team compiled a list of factors that were to be evaluated using online survey instruments. Two members of the team each selected a specific target group for evaluation: member schools and students who completed
Why Choose an Online Course?
Table 1. List of factors examined Semesters per year of active OCICU participation Reasons for advising students to take OCICU courses Students per OCICU provider Reasons for selecting a particular OCICU provider Student satisfaction Advising Satisfaction with OCICU Satisfaction with Provider School Experience with the OCICU portal Ease/ understanding of the registration process Contact/ interaction with the instructor Orientation package Delivery platform Semester start/ end dates Prior technical experience and expertise Successful course completion Overall experience with course, learning environment, administrative process, other factors Demographic information
an OCICU-sponsored course. Using many, if not all, of the factors presented in the review of the literature (See Table 1), team members composed their surveys, refined the items, and presented a draft of the surveys to other members of the team for refinements. Final survey instruments are available in Appendix A and B.
Investigation conduct OCICU provided participant email addresses for the surveys. Each team member was permitted to use whatever survey platform was most familiar (most chose Survey Monkey). An email request for participation was prepared by the principal investigator and the links to the respective surveys sent in January 2008.
FIndInGs And resuLts oF the study Participation from member schools had a response rate of 16 of 64 institutions responding (25%). The Student response rate was estimated at 7.8% (43 of 550 email invitations). Participation for this first round of investigative research was acceptable but needs emphasis to ensure that the results are generalizable throughout the OCICU community.
results from Member surveys The member schools response rate of 25% diminishes the ability of this investigation to generalize to this population of 64 institutions. Still, the results infuse valuable new information into the conduct of the OCICU as seen from the perspec-
63
Why Choose an Online Course?
tive of our “middle man” customers. And, since these institutions are the go-between matching provider school courses with student needs, care will be taken during the review of the results to identify valid findings versus suppositions and non-validated conclusions.
results from student surveys Forty-three (43) students completed the survey for a 7.8% response rate. It is obvious that a better response would produce more generalizable findings and we would hope to achieve those better rates in subsequent research efforts. For this paper, the following results were uncovered.
recoMMendAtIons And ProPosed FoLLow-uP InvestIGAtIons recommendations Based on the findings and analysis of the member schools and the students participating in this study, the following recommendations pertaining specifically to key reasons that member institutions recommend a particular OCICU course are offered for consideration. 1.
summary of Findings and results of the study Regarding the member schools who participated in the study, they appear satisfied with the OCICU. 88.3% of respondents rated the OCICU excellent or good. As such, 88.2% of the responding schools said they would recommend other schools become members of the OCICU. From the student perspective, it appears the students are satisfied with the courses they have taken through the OCICU. 94.1% of responding students said they thought the courses they had taken were excellent or good yet only 78.6% would take another course through the OCICU. It was interesting to note that 69.2% of responding students said they took the OCICU course because they needed it to graduate while 12.8% of respondents took the course just for fun. Some 97.6% of respondents successfully completed their course and 92.1% received either an A or B. No students reported receiving an incomplete for the course they selected and only 2.4% of respondents failed the course. Most students who take courses through the OCICU are upper classmen (72.1%)
2.
3.
Proposed Follow-up Investigations From the survey results, additional research questions have been formulated and are offered for further consideration. 1.
64
Provider schools should closely examine the convenience of the online course format that member schools choose a particular provider for their students. As much as possible, this consideration should be measured when creating course schedules, assigning faculty, and creating orientation materials matching course objectives and learning goals with member institution programs of study. This needs to be a two-way street with member schools informing providers of programs that need online courses. Provider schools should communicate their programs with all levels of student advisement, but especially with academic and faculty advisors and the registrar’s office of each member school. OCICU needs to increase their communication regarding the use of the OCICU portal for member schools.
What are the qualities of provider schools and member schools that could be used by
Why Choose an Online Course?
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
member schools to recommend OCICU to colleagues at other institutions? What barriers are noted by member schools and students to using the OCICU to its fullest potential? What information packets are provider schools and OCICU using to spread the word about OCICU to registrars, academic and faculty advisors, and student support offices on the campuses of member institutions? What characteristics of good web page design and content information were found on the web sites of provider schools, member schools, and OCICU that make them easy to use and navigate? Why would students take OCICU courses in place of courses offered through the home institution? What are some of the most important barriers experienced by students that would cause them not to consider taking another course through the consortium? What is the extent of term start/ end dates across the provider schools compared to the member schools and how does that difference impact a student’s choice whether or not to register for a provider school’s course? What are the common reasons that student rate their overall experience with OCICU courses as unsatisfactory?
reFerences Beller, M. & Or, E. (1998). The crossroads between lifelong learning and information technology: A challenge facing leading universities. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 4. Caruso, J. (2007) “The ECAR Study of Undergraduate Students and Information Technology, 2007” ECAR Educause Center for Applied Research. Retrieved from http://www.educause. edu/ecar/
Chang, S. (2001) “What Types of Online Facilitation Do Students Need?”, National Convention of the Association for Educational Communications and Technology, Retrieved from EDRS Cooper, M. (2003) “Voices on the Web: Online Learners and Their Experiences”, 2003 Midwest Research to Practice Conference in Adult, Continuing, and Community Education Diaz, D. (1999) “Comparing Student Learning Styles in an Online Distance Learning Class and an Equivalent On-Campus Class, Cuesta Community College, Retrieved from http://home.earthlink. net/~davidpdiaz/LTS/html_docs/grslss.htm Dutton, J. (2002) “How Do Online Students Differ From Lecture Students?” JALN (Vol 6, Issue 1) Galusha, J. (1997) “Barriers to Learning in Distance Education”, University of Southern Mississippi. Retrieved from http://www.infrastruction. com/barriers.htm Hatfield, Michelle. (2007, October 18). College enrollment swells: rising student bodies at local institutions follow national trend. Knight Ridder Tribune Business News. Washington, D.C. O’Malley, J. (1999) “Students Perceptions of Distance Learning, Online Learning and the Traditional Classroom”, Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration (Vol 2, Number 4). Retrieved from http://www.westga.edu?~distance/ omalley24.html Picciano, Anthony. Journal of thought. San Francisco: Spring 2006. Vol. 41, Iss. 1; pg. 75. Pope, J. (2006) “Some Students Prefer Classes Online”, USA Today Online. Retrieved from http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2006-01-15college-online-course_x.htm Robbins, Richard. (2007, December 9). Online classes gain favor at region’s universities. McClatchy-Tribune Business News.
65
Why Choose an Online Course?
Seufert, Sabine (2001) “E-Learning Business Models Framework and Best Practice Examples”, Swiss Centre for Innovations and Learning, Institute for Media and Communications Management, University of St. Gallen. Retrieved from http:// elearning-reviews.com/
66
Why Choose an Online Course?
APPendIx A: MeMber schooL survey Q1. One average how many semesters / terms per year are you referring students to take courses through OCICU? 1
5.9%
1
2
0.0%
0
3
47.1%
8
4
0.0%
0
5
5.9%
1
6
41.2%
7
Convenience
100.0%
16
Courses not offered at member school this semester
93.8%
15
Free electives needed for graduation
75.0%
12
Online format desired
31.3%
5
Scheduling flexibility
6.3%
1
Yes
88.2%
15
No
11.8%
2
Selection of courses
100.0%
16
Course content and objectives consistent with member school
87.5%
14
Apparent quality of the syllabus
62.5%
10
100.0%
16
Q2. What are the top 3-5 reasons for advising students to take classes through OCICU?
Q3. Do you refer students to more than one provider institution?
Q4. What are the top 3 reasons for choosing the provider institution(s) currently used by your students?
Q5. On average how many students have you referred to take courses through OCICU per academic year?
Q6. How would you rate your student’s overall satisfaction with the courses they have taken through OCICU? Excellent
29.4%
5
Good
64.7%
11
Fair
5.9%
1
Poor
0.0%
0
continued on following page
67
Why Choose an Online Course?
APPendIx A: contInued Q7. How do students at your institution hear about OCICU? Academic Advisor
87.5%
14
Student Support Personnel
18.8%
3
Faculty Advisor
25.0%
4
Registrar
25.0%
4
Comments
5
Q8. How do you rate your institutions overall satisfaction with OCICU? Excellent
41.2%
7
Good
47.1%
8
Fair
11.8%
2
APPendIx b: student survey Q1. How did you hear about OCICU? Registrar
50.0%
15
Academic Advisor
36.7%
11
Faculty Advisor
6.7%
2
Student Support
6.7%
Comments
2 14
Q2. Overall the registration process was easy to understand. Strongly agree
36.4%
16
Agree
52.3%
23
Unsure
6.8%
3
Disagree
4.5%
2
Strongly disagree
0.0%
0
Strongly agree
25.6%
11
Agree
67.4%
29
Did not use website / unsure
2.3%
1
Disagree
4.7%
2
Strongly disagree
0.0%
0
Q3. Overall the school’s website, the school who hosted the course(s) you took, was easy to use and navigate.
continued on following page
68
Why Choose an Online Course?
APPendIx b: contInued Q4. Why did you choose the particular course(s) you took through the consortium? Check all that apply. Advised to do so
17.9%
7
Needed course to graduate
69.2%
27
Took in place of course offered through home institution
28.2%
11
Took as an elective
12.8%
5
Took for personal development / enjoyment
5.1%
2
Comments
7
Q5. Did you have a difficult time finding information on the courses offered through the consortium? Yes
2.3%
1
No
93.0%
40
Unsure
4.7%
2
Comments
6
Q6. Would you take another course through the consortium? Yes
78.6%
33
No
4.8%
2
Unsure
16.7%
7
Comments
8
Q7. How would you rate your contact / interaction with the instructor? Above average
34.9%
15
Average
46.5%
20
Unsure
7.0%
3
Below average
7.0%
3
Poor
4.7%
2
Above average
20.9%
9
Average
67.4%
29
N/A - No orientation materials were provided
7.0%
3
Below average
4.7%
2
Poor
0.0%
0
Q8. How would you rate the orientation provided by the institution where you took your class?
continued on following page
69
Why Choose an Online Course?
APPendIx b: contInued Q9. The course delivery platform, blackboard, webct, ecollege, was easy to learn and use. Strongly agree
30.2%
13
Agree
67.4%
29
Unsure
0.0%
0
Disagree
2.3%
1
Strongly disagree
0.0%
0
Yes
37.2%
16
No
60.5%
26
N/A
2.3%
1
Yes
74.4%
32
No
25.6%
11
1-2
25.0%
8
3-4
25.0%
8
5-6
28.1%
9
7 or more
21.9%
7
Above average
51.2%
22
Average
44.2%
19
Unsure
4.7%
2
Below average
0.0%
0
Never used technology for learning
0.0%
0
Yes
97.6%
40
No, I failed the class
2.4%
1
No, I withdrew during the term
0.0%
0
No, I dropped prior to the start of the term
0.0%
0
Q10. Did the difference in term start / end dates affect your decision to take classes through the consortium?
Q11. Had you used any online learning tools, taken an online class, or had any experience with online learning prior to enrolling in a class with the consortium?
Q12. How many courses have you taken online?
Q13. What was your comfort level using technology as a learning tool prior to taking an online course?
Q14. Did you successfully complete the course?
Comments
6
continued on following page
70
Why Choose an Online Course?
APPendIx b: contInued Q15. Your final grade in the last class you took through the consortium was? A
76.3%
29
B
15.8%
6
C
5.3%
2
D
2.6%
1
F
0.0%
0
Incomplete
0.0%
0
Excellent
50.0%
20
Good
32.5%
13
Fair
10.0%
4
Poor
7.5%
3
Q16. How would you rate your overall experience with the course, learning experience, administrative processes, etc.
Comments
13
Q17. Would you recommend OCICU to a friend, family member, or colleague? Yes
83.7%
36
No
7.0%
3
Unsure
9.3%
4
Comments
3
Q18. Gender M
18.6%
8
F
81.4%
35
18-20
2.3%
1
21-23
7.0%
3
24-26
2.3%
1
27-29
20.9%
9
30 or older
67.4%
29
Q19. Age
continued on following page
71
Why Choose an Online Course?
APPendIx b: contInued Q20. How many credits do you currently have? 3-21
19.0%
8
22-33
0.0%
0
34-42
0.0%
0
43-60
9.5%
4
61-75
7.1%
3
76-90
9.5%
4
91 or more
54.8%
23
Freshman
4.7%
2
Sophomore
7.0%
3
Junior
32.6%
14
Senior
39.5%
17
Graduate Student
16.3%
7
Q21. Are you currently a
Q22. Are there any other topics / items you would like to provide feedback on for this survey? Provided comments
6
This work was previously published in International Journal of Information and Communication Technology Education, Vol. 5, Issue 2, edited by L. Tomei, pp. 60-72, copyright 2009 by IGI Publishing (an imprint of IGI Global).
72
73
Chapter 1.6
Online or Traditional:
A Study to Examine Course Characteristics Contributing to Students’ Preference for Classroom Settings Tim Klaus Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi, USA Chuleeporn Changchit Texas A&M University–Corpus Christi, USA
AbstrAct Technological advancements currently penetrate society, changing the way that some courses are taught. It has become more apparent in higher education institutions that all classes are not as adaptive to an online format as others. Since many institutions of higher education further incorporate online courses into their curriculum, it is important to understand the characteristics
of courses that affect students’ preferences for either traditional classroom environments or online environments. Indications of this can be seen in the attrition and retention rates of classes offered online. This study explores the characteristics of courses that affect students’ preferences towards online and traditional classroom settings. These results should help providing guidelines to institutions considering courses to offer online.
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Online or Traditional
IntroductIon Technology advancements are important drivers of societal change. In particular, the advancement in technological tools and communication technologies has influenced the number of students taking online courses. The increase is considerable, from 1.6 million students (9.6% of total enrollment) in 2002 to 3.9 million students (21.9% of total enrollment) in 2007 (Allen and Seaman, 2008). Much of this increase is due to changes occurring in student demographics and demands. For example, higher education institutions have faced changes in their student demographics in recent years as more students no longer fit the traditional profile of a young, full-time, in-residence student. As college demographics change and technological tools are available and widely adapted, the education needs are altered and there is a higher demand for more flexible and convenient methods in obtaining a higher education. Higher education course curriculum has been altered in recent years to better fit some of the demands for online courses. The popularity of online courses can be attributed to the perceived benefits online learning can provide students along with its convenience. However, quite a few students still do not perceive that these benefits outweigh the downside of online courses and thus prefer traditional courses. In particular, some students do not feel that certain courses are suitable to be offered online. As such, adoption of online learning for certain subjects or course content has been slow (Allen and Seaman, 2008). Instead, these subjects seem to be better fit for a traditional learning environment. Through an understanding of these perceptions of needs and student satisfaction, higher education institutions should be better able to offer appropriate courses in various formats for learning environments that best suit their student population.
74
It has become more apparent in higher education institutions that all classes are not as adaptive to an online format as others. Even though online courses can produce higher enrollment numbers, they also suffer from higher attrition and retention rates (Moody 2004). Perhaps one reason for this is that students realize that the course format is not what is preferred and thus the online course is dropped in order to take the course in a traditional format. One case study examining attrition rates found a 43% attrition rate for an online section of a statistics course versus 13% for its traditional format counterpart. For a managerial marketing course the attrition rate was 24% for the online format versus a 9% rate for the traditional format, and an international economics course had a 3% attrition rate for its online format versus a 2% attrition rate for its traditional format (Terry 2001). The results from these studies indicate the likelihood that course characteristics may affect students’ preferences towards online or traditional courses. As institutions of higher education consider further incorporating online capabilities into course curriculum and formats, it is important to understand which courses students think are more suitable for a traditional classroom environment and which courses are more suitable for an online environment. To investigate this issue, this study examines the following research question: Which course criteria influence students’ preference for online courses? The purpose of this study is to explore course characteristics and its effect on students’ preference for online versus traditional courses since previous studies have not examined this issue. To accomplish this purpose, this study first examines the current literature related to online courses. This is followed by a description of the data collection methodology followed by an analysis of the data. This study concludes by providing suggestions for future research and for institutions and instructors considering setting up online courses.
Online or Traditional
LIterAture revIew Online courses were first offered in the mid1990s. However, around this time, the perception widely existed that online learning environments were sterile environments not much different from correspondence courses upgraded from a post-office to an e-mail box, and their educational value was suspect (Rudich 1998). However, the availability of the ubiquitous Internet and the advancements of technology have enabled students and educators to interact in a new environment. Many higher education institutions now offer a smorgasbord of courses in an online environment. As technology and its applications advance in the education sector, it is important that both educators and students become more aware how these technologies are best used (Wang 2004). As the trend for online course development expands, more teachers are becoming adept at utilizing various features of online classroom technology for offering their courses to a wider audience than their physical classroom environments can serve. These expanded features available for online courses provide many benefits to institutions and their students and are useful tools for advancing students’ education (Smith, Ferguson, & Caris 2002). They provide the convenience and flexibility for different learning needs to be met. This allows for a variety of students to have needs met that are not possible through traditional class formats (Anstine & Skidmore 2005; Bentley 2003; Cooper 2001; Rudich 1998). Students may take courses from a location that is convenient, such as at home or in an Internet café, and at a time that is convenient. The convenience of online courses provides students the opportunity to take courses they would otherwise be unable to take (Anstine & Skidmore 2005; Flowers 2005). One study found that convenience, flexibility, and self-regulated learning were advantages of online courses (Ku & Lohr 2003).
Despite the benefits, there is still some contention as to the validity of online courses as quality educational formats. For example, one study found that a lack of interaction was a clear disadvantage (Ku & Lohr 2003). Furthermore, Anstine and Skidmore (2005) found that the online class environment had significantly lower educational outcomes with students than their traditional class environment counterparts, controlling for factors such as previous knowledge, test scores, and time spent studying. However, a limitation of the study was that although the same professor taught the same class in both the online and traditional environment, the professors had little experience in teaching both environments prior to the study. Furthermore, there is no indication of previous experience with online courses as a determinant factor in self-selection of the class environment format by students. Other studies have found that there is no inherent inferiority in the quality of education opportunities in online courses versus their traditional, face-to-face counterparts (Shachar & Neumann 2003; Shank 2005; Vroeginday 2005; Wyatt 2005). In fact, online courses at times have been found to be more challenging than a traditional course for students due to the greater degree of independent learning that the online format demands (Wyatt 2005; Yang & Cornelius 2004). Although the value and validity of online courses is still under debate, some studies suggest that it is not necessarily the format that is the main factor that hinders education quality but the participants (i.e. students and professors) and course design (Arbuagh 2001; Shank 2005). Another study found that the instructor’s willingness to keep up with technological changes, course content, and the motivation of students are also important factors (Medlin, Vannoy, & Dave 2004). Prior studies also found that technology, instructor, course, and student characteristics all affected student perceptions (Changchit & Klaus, 2008; Gregory, 2003).
75
Online or Traditional
Although these various characteristics affect student perceptions, specific characteristics of a course have not been examined in previous studies. This study focuses on the examination of course characteristics. Since they are tangible characteristics higher education institutions can use to judge whether a course should be offered as an online or traditional course. Since certain types of courses are better suited for an online environment, it is important to consider various characteristics that affect a student’s preference for an online course. Based on feedback received from four professors experienced in teaching online courses and nine students who have taken online courses, three issues were identified as factors contributing to class setting preferences. Figure 1 below shows these three factors. The first factor as shown in the research model below is lecturebased courses – if courses are not interactive and primarily lecture-based, students then prefer an online teaching environment. The second factor is Instructor Support Requirements – if students think that the support of the instructor is necessarily throughout the class, a traditional course is preferred. The third factor is Technical/Scientific Courses – if courses are fairly technical or scientific, such as those that require
mathematics or computer skills, a traditional course is preferred. Based on the research model, three hypotheses are examined as follows: H1: Students enrolled in a lecture-based course prefer an online class setting. H2: Students enrolled in a class that needs a higher level of support from an instructor prefer a traditional class setting. H3: Students enrolled in technical/scientific classes prefer a traditional class setting.
MethodoLoGy Since this is an exploratory study on an area not examined previously, studies were not available from which to identify course characteristics. Thus, as mentioned in the previous section, discussions were held with several professors and students to identify potential course characteristics that could possibly affect a student’s preference towards the course format. Based on these discussions and from questions compiled from previous studies pertaining to online courses
Figure 1. Research model
Course Characteristics Lecture-Based Courses Instructor Support Requirements Technical/
76
Course Format Preference (Online vs. Traditional)
Online or Traditional
Table 1. Subjects’ demographics Age (in years) Under 18
18-29
30-41
42-49
Over 49
No Answer
0(0.00%)
166(92.22%)
11(6.11%)
1(0.56%)
0(0.00%)
2(1.11%)
Gender Male: 82(45.55%)
Female: 97(53.89%)
No Answer: 1(0.56%)
Ethnicity African
Anglo
Asian
Hispanic
Native American
No Answer
4(2.22%)
94(52.22%)
5(2.78%)
69(38.33%)
4(2.22%)
4(2.22%)
Computer Knowledge (Scale 1 thru 7) 1 (Very poor)
2
3
4
5
6
7 (Excellent)
No Answer
2(1.1%)
0(0.0%)
9(5.0%)
28(15.6%)
60(33.3%)
47(26.1%)
29(16.1%)
5(2.8%)
Own a Computer Desktop
Laptop
Both
Neither
No Answer
61(33.9%)
62(34.4%)
51(28.3%)
5(2.8%)
1(0.6%)
Internet Access at Home Dial-up
High speed (i.e., DSL,)
None
No Answer
12(6.67%)
150(83.33%)
16(8.89%)
2(1.11%)
Distance from Home <10 min.
10-30 min.
30-60 min.
1-2 hours
>2 hours
No Answer
70(38.89%)
71(39.44%)
26(14.44%)
7(3.89%)
4(2.22%)
2(1.11%)
Commute to the University Car
Bus
Walk
No Answer
147(81.67%)
3(1.67%)
29(16.11%)
1(0.56%)
Employment Status Full Time
Part Time
Unemployed
No Answer
56(31.1%)
73(40.6%)
50(27.8%)
1(0.6%)
continued on following page
77
Online or Traditional
Table 1. continued Took an Online Course Before Yes
No
No Answer
83(46.11%)
96(53.33%)
1(0.56%)
Yes
No
No Answer
30(16.67%)
148(82.22%)
2(1.11%)
Currently Taking an Online Course
(Changchit et al. 2006; Demb et al. 2004; Luarn & Lin 2004; Moore & Benbasat 1991), a total of ten items were developed to examine the three factors shown in the research model. A 26 item questionnaire was developed based on these ten course characteristic items. The first question of the questionnaire asked students to identify one specific course that was taken in the previous semester. In order to minimize the bias toward the best or worst course, students were asked to identify the course with the highest course number. The next ten questions were asked to measure students’ perceptions of the characteristics of the course they identified, using a Likert-scale from 1 to 5 with 1 being “strongly disagree” and 5 being “strongly agree”. The question after that asked whether the student would have preferred to take the course as an online course or traditional course, if the option is available. The remaining 14 questions collected demographic data. To improve the clarity of these questions and identify potential problems, three professors and three students read through the survey questions. Revisions to the survey were made based on the feedback received. Surveys were distributed to 225 students enrolled in a mid-sized university. The participants were given the survey and allowed class time to complete the survey. All participants were informed that participation in the study was voluntary and that individual responses
78
would be kept anonymous. One hundred eighty (180) participants completed and returned the survey instruments. Table 1 summarizes the demographics of the respondents.
AnALysIs And dIscussIon A confirmatory factor analysis was conducted to validate the course characteristics questions used to measure each proposed variable. Three factors were extracted which have factor loadings greater than the acceptable level of 0.5 (Hair et al., 2006), and their distinction from the other factors. The questionnaire items are shown in Tables 2 and 3. In order to determine if there were significant differences between the groups of students who prefer to take the class online (online group) versus students who prefer take the class in traditional format (traditional group), t-tests on the means were conducted. The responses from participants were divided into two groups based on the question “If I have an option, I will take the class ___ ”, in which respondents could either mark “online” or “traditional”. Table 4 below shows the factors exhibiting a significant difference between the two groups. As shown in Table 4, all three course characteristic factors displayed statistically significant results (p<0.05) between the students who preferred to take the course as
Online or Traditional
Table 2. Rotated component matrix Factors 1
2
3
Question 1
-0.131
0.337
0.476
Question 2
0.043
0.682
0.257
Question 3
0.179
0.713
-0.109
Question 4
-0.163
0.696
-0.326
Question 5
0.888
-0.028
0.043
Question 6
0.814
0.008
-0.055
Question 7
-0.318
0.565
0.029
Question 8
0.849
-0.088
0.052
Question 9
0.299
-0.245
0.715
Question 10
-0.081
-0.032
0.829
Extraction Method: Principal Component Analysis. Rotation Method: Varimax with Kaiser Normalization.
Table 3. Questions grouped into three factors Factor
Question Number 2
I understand the contents in this class more when the instructor writes on the board.
3
Using PowerPoint slides to explain the materials in this class is appropriate.
4
This class is a lecture-based class (i.e., not a hands-on class).
7
I spend a lot of time reading the textbook for this class.
5
The professor explains the material very well in this class.
6
I understand all the material in this class.
8
This class is well-organized.
9
Computer skills are important in order to do well in this class.
10
Mathematics knowledge is important in order to do well in this class.
Lecture-based Courses
Instructor Support Requirements
Questions
Technical/Scientific Courses
79
Online or Traditional
Table 4. Group differences Mean Online Group
Traditional Group
p-value
Lecture-based Courses
3.563
3.826
0.03639
Instructor Support Requirements
3.265
3.023
0.02815
Technical/Scientific Courses
2.960
3.620
0.00009
Course Characteristic Factors
an online course versus those who preferred to take the course as a traditional course. The first significant factor is regarding whether the class is lecture-based. This result indicates that overall, if a course is setup as a primarily lecture-based class, then students have a greater preference for the class being online. On the other hand, a non-lecture class, such as a hands-on lab class would be preferred as a traditional class. If the level of interaction with students is low in a class, perhaps the preference for online courses is due to the ability to learn the material on their own or watch videos of a lecture online at a time or place that is convenient. However, for classes that are more interactive, the importance of the class interaction may outweigh the convenience of online courses. In addition, if students feel that the professor explains the material well, then a traditional course is preferred. Material that is not explained well may be viewed as less valuable or a waste of time and thus students prefer an online course because they do not have to sit through a lecture which is not making sense to them. The second significant factor is Instructor Support Requirements – if students think that the support of the instructor is necessary throughout the class, a traditional course is preferred. On the other hand, if the support of an instructor is not necessary, then there is a higher preference for an online course. Although online courses do provide some tools for instructor support,
80
such as discussion boards, email, and online whiteboards, the richness of this communication is limited. It may take longer to describe problems using these online tools than it takes to communicate in the traditional face-to-face format. In addition, students who feel that they spend a greater amount of time reading the textbook prefer an online course. This may be because of the different learning styles of students and students who comprehend the material well from reading the textbook may not feel a need for instructor support. Furthermore, if learning primarily comes from comprehending the textbook material, students usually perceive that the traditional course adds little value as they can read the material on their own. The third factor is the degree of technical content of the course. If students feel that there is a higher level of technical content, then a traditional course is preferred. Students who think that computer skills are more important for a course prefer to take the course as a traditional course. There are several reasons for this finding. First, courses requiring technical skills tend to require projects. Students may prefer interaction with other students as they work on projects and thus prefer traditional courses. Second, if computer skills are required, the course will generally be a hands-on course, which has already been shown in the first significant variable that students prefer online courses if the course is lecture-based. Third, for students that have low
Online or Traditional
computer self-efficacy, or do not know which buttons to push on a scientific calculator, they will probably prefer a traditional course format as they can ask questions easily in class and receive immediate feedback from the instructor.
concLusIon Despite the benefits of online courses described in the literature review, online courses are not preferable for every student or every course. Clearly, as shown through the results of this study, course criteria affect students’ preference towards online or traditional courses. This study provides several contributions. First of all, this study shows that course criteria can definitely affect student preferences. Universities considering expanding online course usage need to consider course content and course characteristics as they examine if the courses are suitable for an online format. A second contribution is an understanding of individual course characteristics that influence students’ preference. Individual characteristics that affect students’ preference are whether a class is lecture-based, whether instructor support is required, and whether the course is technical in nature. These conclusions have interesting implications for course design. First, students’ perceptions of online courses indicate that the level of instructor support is inadequate for some classes. Perhaps some online courses should be supplemented with traditional labs in which better provide support desired by students. In addition, teacher assistants could be made available to serve as tutors in these courses to enhance the level of support available to students. Second, to make traditional courses more attractive to students, the results imply that instructors should have more interactive communication styles, and better provide better support to students. Although the content of some course may seem
appropriate for pure lecture, the preference of students overall is to have more interactive courses. Third, if a decision should be made regarding which courses to change to online courses, the three factors identified in this study are useful in providing guidelines for determining which courses may be suited as online courses. In reality, faculty availability, knowledge, willingness to teach online courses, and technical expertise are factors in determining which classes to offer online, but the factors brought forth in this study serve as guiding principles. There are several directions for future research. First, since the purpose of this study is to explore course characteristics, three course factors which comprised a total of ten course characteristics were selected rather than a comprehensive list. To increase the value to instructors considering development of such courses, the results of a comprehensive list of course factors that affect student preferences for online courses could be useful. Furthermore, the list could lead to practical guidelines for designing specific online courses. A second area of future research would be to examine the technology, instructor, and student characteristics that affect a students’ preference towards online courses. There are various technology platforms that universities use for online courses as well as differing technologies that individual instructors use within a university, such as some instructors loading videos of lectures to an online site while other instructors only posting documents online. Furthermore, the examination of instructor and student characteristics could be useful for universities setting up online courses.
reFerences Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2008). Staying the Course: Online Education in the United States. The Sloan Consortium, (pp. 1-28).
81
Online or Traditional
Anstine, J., & Skidmore, M. (2005). A Small Sample Study of Traditional and Online Courses with Sample Selection Adjustment. Journal of Economic Education, 36(2), 107-127.
Ku, H., & Lohr, L. (2003). A Case Study of Chinese Students’ Attitudes toward their First Online Learning Experience. Educational Technology Research and Development, 51(3), 95-102.
Arbaugh, J. B. (2001). How Instructor Immediacy Behaviors Affect Student Satisfaction and Learning in Web-Based Courses. Business Communication Quarterly, 64(4), 42-54.
Luarn, P., & Lin, H.H. (2005). Toward an Understanding of the Behavioral Intention to Use Mobile Banking. Computers in Human Behavior, 21(6), 873-891.
Bentley, B. (2003). City University Students Get Flexible Study Courses with Virtual Learning Environment. Computer Weekly, 59.
Medlin, D. B., Vannoy, S. A., & Dave, D. S. (2004). An Internet-based Approach to the Teaching of Information Technology: A Study of Student Attitudes in the United States. International Journal of Management, 21(4), 427-434.
Changchit, C., Cutshall, R., & Elwood, S. (2006). Students’ Perceptions of the Laptop Program: What Factors Should be Considered before Implementing The Program? International Journal of Information & Communication Technology Education, 2(2), 53-61. Changchit, C., & Klaus, T. (2008). Classroom Preferences: What Factors Can Affect Students’ Attitudes on Different Classroom Settings? International Journal of Information & Communication Technology Education, 4(1), 33-43. Cooper, L. W. (2001). A Comparison of Online and Traditional Computer Application Classes. T.H.E. Journal, 28(8), 52-55. Demb, A., Erickson, D., & Hawkins-Wilding, S. (2004). The Laptop Alternative: Student Reactions and Strategic Implications. Computers & Education, 43(4), 383-401. Flowers, J. C. (2005). The Effect of Online Delivery on Graduate Enrollment. Journal of Industrial Teacher Education, 42(4), 7-24. Gregory, V. L. (2003). Student Perceptions of the Effectiveness of Web-based Distance Education. New Library World, 104(10), 426-431. Hair, J. F., Black, B., Babin, B, Anderson, R., & Tatham, R. L. (2006). Multivariate Data Analysis (6e). Prentice-Hall.
82
Moody, J. (2004). Distance Education. Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 5(3), 205-210. Moore, G. C., & Benbasat, I. (1994). Development of Instrument to Measure the Perceptions of Adopting an Information Technology Innovation. Information Systems Research, 2(3), 192-222. Rudich, J. (1998). Internet Learning. Link-up, 15(5), pp. 23. Shachar, M., & Neumann, Y. (2003). Differences between Traditional and Distance Education Academic Performances: A Meta-Analytic Approach. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 4(2), 1-20. Shank, P. (2005). Five Common Fears about Teaching Online - Fact vs. Fiction. Distance Education Report, 9(24), 5-7. Smith, G. G., Ferguson, D., & Caris, M. (2002). Teaching over the Web versus the Classroom: Differences in the Instructor Experience. International Journal of Instructional Media, 29(1), 61-67. Terry, N. (2001). Assessing Enrollment and Attrition Rates for The Online MBA. T. H. E. Journal, 28(7), 64-68.
Online or Traditional
Vroeginday, B. J. (2005). Traditional vs. Online Education: A Comparative Analysis of Learner Outcomes. Dissertation Fielding, Graduate University, 150 pages. Wang, W. (2004). How University Students View Online Study: A PCP Perspective. Campus-Wide Information Systems, 21(3), 108.
Wyatt, G. (2005). Satisfaction, Academic Rigor and Interaction: Perceptions of Online Instruction. Education, 125(3), 460-468. Yang, Y., & Cornelius, L. F. (2004). Students’ Perceptions towards the Quality of Online Education: A Qualitative Approach. Association for Educational Communications and Technology, (pp. 861-877).
This work was previously published in International Journal of Information and Communication Technology Education, Vol. 5, Issue 3, edited by L. A. Tomei, pp. 14-23, copyright 2009 by IGI Publishing (an imprint of IGI Global).
83
84
Chapter 1.7
Teaching Online:
What Does Blended Learning Require? P. Toyoko Kang University of Guam, Guam
AbstrAct This chapter provides an argument endorsing blended learning and teaching for foreign language (FL)/second language (L2) courses, in lieu of total online learning and teaching or total face-to-face learning and teaching (FFLT). Two main arguments are posed, citing concrete examples. First, that in total online learning and teaching, one of the greatest challenges is to reduce the psychological and social distance between teacher and student that leads to a dysfunctional parser (a mental language processor) for FL/L2. And secondly, online learning and teaching encourage more input, hence clarify communication—-by making not only currently incomprehensible input comprehensible but also hard-to-be-comprehended output easy-to-comprehend—— through “self-negotiation of form and meaning,” and the parser’s strategy of being “first (prosodic phrase) come, first interpreted/processed.” This chapter proceeds to strongly recommend that FL/L2 teachers make simple audio files to provide their students with spoken input to prevent students DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-880-2.ch007
from employing the L1 strategy of “first come, last interpreted/processed.” Furthermore, this chapter shows what kind of spoken input is to be recorded in audio files for students in Elementary Japanese II and Intermediate Japanese I.
IntroductIon Researchers in the field of computer assisted language learning (CALL) like Hauck and Sticler (2006) and Colpaert (2006) raise an intriguing question: What does it take to teach online? Due to the fact that our main concern is not total online learning but blended learning (BL), this chapter modifies their question as follows: What does it take to teach online for BL? Omaggio (1984) opens her chapter with the following provocative question: The question addressed in this chapter is as old as the language-teaching profession itself: How do we help students learning a second language classroom setting become proficient in that language? Historically, the responses to this question have been as varied as… those who have tried to answer it. (p. 43, the italic I mine)
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Teaching Online
It is not the purpose of the present chapter to tackle this question, but to make the question more specifically focus on the issues of input and output: How can we help students in a second language classroom setting make incomprehensible input comprehensible, and hard-to-be-comprehended output easy-to-comprehend, such that they eventually become proficient in that language? As this modified question indicates, this chapter’s answer to the question in the title “what does BL require (to make it work)?” is “to design an online FL/L2 learning & teaching in order to make not only currently incomprehensible input comprehensible, but also currently hard-to-be-comprehended output easy-to-be-comprehended.” This chapter has two purposes. One is to argue that for FL/L2 classes, blended learning and teaching (BLT) are more effective than total online or totally face-to-face learning and teaching (FFLT). The other is to demonstrate simple ways of scaffolding students in the second and third semester of Japanese language courses, by making currently incomprehensible input more comprehensible, and hard-to-be-comprehended output easy to comprehend under a memory efficient approach (MEA) issuing from human parser learning theory (HPLT). Kang (2007a) has demonstrated how to blend technologies in an advanced Japanese class. The present chapter, however, shows how to blend online learning in Elementary Japanese II (JA102) and Intermediate Japanese I (JA201).
bAcKGround comprehensive Input and output in L2 Acquisition Krashen (1985) proposes an Input Hypothesis claiming as follows: “humans acquire language in only one way—-by understanding messages or by receiving comprehensible input” (p. 2). In other words, speaking has nothing to do with L2 acquisition. This is an extreme way to look at
the L2 acquisition process. Swain (1985, 2005) claims as an Output Hypothesis that an “incomprehensible output” that is “pushed” to generate comprehensible output for the listeners also facilitates L2 acquisition. In this section, two pitfalls of input comprehension are described; the third pitfall will be shown in the section for Case Description. Input comprehension is achieved not only through interactive or task-related conversation, but also in the context of one-way communication such as radio, TV broadcasting, and reading newspapers or magazines. Research has been conducted regarding the specific ways that interaction helps learners make incomprehensible input comprehensible (e.g., Gass 1997; Pica et al., 1987; VanPatten, 1996). However, when it comes to processing written input, the Japanese language learner whose L1 (first language) is English may understand a sentence by processing it as “first come, last interpreted.” This development may occur in a case like the following, where the learner, in order to comprehend a sentence using their L1 syntactic knowledge, does not process the sentence in the order of “first come, first interpreted”: (1) kono kuruma-o ka-oo to omou this car-Acc. buy-will that think (Acc. = accusative) ‘I think that I will buy this car ’ The challenge taken up by the present study is to avoid the above type of (written) input comprehension and thereby not repeat the failure common to traditional grammar translation. This chapter will endorse the solution of providing audio files for reading comprehension material. This technique can enable learners to process according to “first come, first interpreted” (Kang, 2008). In the reading comprehension questions of VanPatten (1996), there are many complex sentences in the reading materials. His Input Processing and Grammar Instruction fails, as the traditional grammar-translation approach did, for those students whose L1 is a language like Korean or Japanese. This is because Spanish is a 85
Teaching Online
head-initial language like English, while Korean or Japanese are head-final languages. A Japanese native speaker translates an English sentence like (I) think I will buy this car backward; “First come, last interpreted.” This means that the parser of a Korean or Japanese student learning Spanish understands by processing the written Spanish with an L1 processing algorithm. This process occurs without any opportunities for parsers to start processing input on a “first come, first interpreted” basis, as a Spanish native speaker does. Let us now turn to the other pitfall of input comprehension with which this chapter is concerned. The following interlanguage case provides a good example: (2) ‘a cheap book’ in Japanese a. *Yasui no hon (* means that a sentence with it is ungrammatical) cheap one/of book b. Yasui hon cheap book A Japanese learner who uttered this kind of sentence over-generalizes the genetive case no; the genetive case marker is only attached to a pre-nominal noun/noun phrase, but not to a prenominal adjective. This kind of utterance indicates that the learner seems to have comprehended Japanese input like yasui hon, only paying attention to content words, which is the tendency of
beginners. (It is noteworthy that VanPatten also observed the problem of input comprehension in terms of content words, but was not concerned with output.) As output, an utterance like this causes “garden path” for a native speaker of Japanese. It is well known that a “garden path” sentence like the English sentence, A horse raced past the barn fell, fails an adult native speaker’s first parse, and requires reprocessing or reanalysis. In other words, to process a garden path sentence is difficult. The same goes for the following Japanese utterance: •
1st parse: First input: yasui no→cheap one Second input: hon →crash! (because the noun ‘book’ is not expected, but a verb or a particle) • 2nd parse: yasui hone →cheap book (eliminating no ‘of’)
This chapter’s L2 learning theory does not exclude output hypotheses; as shown in Figure 1 below, HPLT has a generator, another mental language processor, for production. However, output like this can be comprehended only with difficulty, severely burdening short-term memory. Therefore, we have to help our students make difficult-to-comprehend output easy-to-comprehend, to reduce the listener’s (short-term) memory burden.
Figure 1. Linguistic processors in human parser model (Source: Kang 1993, p. 225; GB stands for “Government & Binding” model by Chomsky, 1982)
86
Teaching Online
why bLt for FL/L2 classes?
technological developments
The need for FFLT must be clarified. As the scholarly literature shows, in a FF meeting/ classroom it is best to establish human connection, thereby eliminating psychological distance (Conger & Lawley, 2005; Wagmann & McCauley, 2007) regardless of subject of a class, or training. When it comes to FL/L2 learning, psychological distance must be kept to a minimum, (Higgs, 1984; Pica et. al., 1987), enabling trust to develop in teacherstudent relationship in FFLT. This development facilitates not only input comprehension, but also helps the student to produce output easily comprehended by interlocutors. One may still ask why online learning is needed instead of FFLT. It must be emphasized that FFLT in FL/L2 classrooms is solely for the purpose of input comprehension and easy-to-be-comprehended output production. We must expect more. Our learning theory, HPLT, promotes a learning situation that exposes students to spoken input as often as possible to force their parsers to start operating, so as to expedite process input. In so far as students are attentive and motivated to understand input, input forces to their parser will start to work and move understanding forward. We are arguing, in short, that online self-learning is more desirable, more effective than FFLT (although the online learning is an extension of FFLT) for the following reasons: online self-learning provides students with more spoken input relevant to what they are learning in the FF classroom; it makes currently incomprehensible input comprehensible; and it makes hard-to-be-comprehended output easy-tobe-comprehended. The aforesaid is accomplished by means of self-aware behaviors that independently conduct acts of repetition, correction, and so on. Such independent learning behaviors have lasting value; in this regard, FL/L2 learning is lifelong learning (Kang 2007a). The independence instilled by online learning is obviously desirable; moreover, blended learning enables our students to easily transfer their refined learning skills to a fully online learning environment.
Foreign language courses at the University of Guam (UOG) had been blended before I arrived at this institution in 1993. To be exact, 20% of a class is allocated for “self-study” by listening to the tapes in the library. I started using digital technologies in my instruction about ten years ago, when the digital language lab was built at UOG. In the digital language lab, at that time, our students had access the Internet, and listened to the CDs in target languages (TL). The Internet provided plenty of authentic reading materials, but not authentic listening materials or video clips. It follows that digital instructional materials could only improve reading or writing skills at that time (Kang, 2000). Since then, technological development has stunningly advanced, and more instructional materials became available on the Internet for Japanese language learners. It became possible to watch news video clips that assist the students in improving their listening comprehension skills; to use pop-up multilingual dictionaries; and to see the stroke orders of kanji in movies. Like many of my academic peers, I soon took advantage of these technological developments, and made instructional use of authentic reading materials available on the Internet. I subsequently designed the 4th year Japanese class as described in Kang (2007a). At that point, UOG adopted Moodle as a course management program, but for a while it was not possible to use Japanese characters in the English mode setting. It was only possible to use audio files, and I learned how to use Audacity to create audio files. Then, around 2005, it became possible to use Japanese characters in English mode; however, since Spring 2007, no Japanese character input was readable. This time I switched to another affordable course management program, Quia, which costs only $40 per year with technical supports.
87
Teaching Online
synopsis of First experience with Fully online teaching The present author’s first time to teach Japanese online without FF classroom meetings, but with FF individual meetings, was the fall semester of 2006. This was a course in which the regular instructor unexpectedly took medical leave mid-way through the semester. The course was JA201. For a number of reasons having to do with tight staffing, to teach this intermediate Japanese course as FFLT or BLT was physically impossible; total online learning and teaching was the only solution.
synopsis of bL for JA102 The present author conducted outcomes assessment of student learning for JA102 in both spring and fall semesters of 2007, in order to assess student learning of reading kanji, writing kanji, verbal grammar, adjective grammar, reading comprehension, and directional task completion. One noteworthy finding is that verbal grammar learning is one of the worst. To improve student learning of verbal grammar, it was decided to create some simple online but effective exercises or quizzes to help my students learn verbal grammar for self-study.
synopsis of bL content for JA201 JA102 requires the students to read short stories or journals, which have complex sentences. In JA201, the length of stories or journals becomes longer, and more complex sentences are in the reading materials. In addition, more kanji are used. To make their reading easier, and to let them “first come, first interpreted,” I decided to make audio files of those reading materials in JA201 as well as for JA102.
88
settInG the stAGe As mentioned above, Moodle became available at UOG in 2005. Workshops on Moodle were initiated by a colleague, Brian Millhoff, and I attended them during the Fall semester of 2005. Through these workshops I became comfortable using Moodle and came to recognize its functional relevance. My own research discovered the helpful Web site, Moodle for Language Teaching (http:// moodle.org/login/index.php). I also learned how to make audio files, and discovered Audacity, audio recording software available online for free. Employing Japanese characters was not a problem at that time; therefore, I was able to offer total online teaching to JA201 in the fall of 2006. It is noteworthy to point out that before committing to Quia, I tried a 30 days free trial. I found that it is easy and simple to use to create quizzes, especially to upload audio files in a quiz; this is accomplished in a couple of clicks. So, I subscribed it to start making audio file with Audacity.
cAse descrIPtIon concepts Relation between Parser and Generator in HPLT The present chapter employs the same language learning theory as in Kang (1993), namely HPLT. According to HPLT, human beings have two language processors, parser and generator (as shown in Figure 1), in addition to a mental dictionary, or lexicon. Krashen’s claim, as mentioned briefly above, that “humans acquire language in only one way— by understanding messages, or by receiving ‘comprehensible input,’” is translated under HPLT in the following way: humans acquire language only through successful parsing (“successful parsing” means that input is correctly comprehended),
Teaching Online
Figure 2. At a developmental stage (The dotted lines show “being not-yet-developed”)
but not through generation at all. It is difficult to agree with this claim. In our model, in terms of learning of grammar and vocabulary, parser and generator help each other’s development at the developmental stage, as shown by arrows in Figure 2. On the other hand, well-developed and mastered grammar and vocabulary will facilitate smooth operation of both parser and generator. The degree of development at a particular developmental stage between the parser and the generator, however, may not be the same. The commencement of the generator’s operation is assumed to be later than that of the parser. The development of the ability of the parser is more likely higher than that of generator, as shown in Figure 2. In terms of learning grammar (regardless explicit or implicit) and vocabulary, the parser and generator help each other’s development. On the other hand, grammar and vocabulary in progress will facilitate the parser and generator to successfully operate. This is a mechanism of interaction whereby “negotiation of meaning/ form” by the learner can facilitate comprehension of currently incomprehensible input, as well as make hard-to-be-comprehended output, easy-tobe-comprehended. It is generally understood among FL/L2 teachers and researchers that without input no language learning occurs. To my knowledge, however, it has never been explained how and why input, especially spoken input, plays a crucial role in L2 acquisition, except for “only when input is
comprehended; it will be in-taken, and be incorporated in inner grammar or acquired. As shown in Figure 1, the model has the parser situated between input and implicit mental grammar, whose operation is done subconsciously. In HPLT, an input sentence is correctly comprehended, which means “an input sentence is successfully parsed.” What needs to be learned in HPLT is parsing algorithms/mechanisms for TL (Kang, 1993). However, parsing algorithms—how to process incoming sentences (input)—are not something to be learned by teaching, but only spoken input can force the parser to operate, or to figure out/learn how to process the input. Although it is unclear how much input is required to attain the adult native speakers’ level, learners should be exposed to a tremendous amount of input. Besides, the learner’s parser needs to start to operate in real time speed, or in NS’s speed to understand NS’s utterances, when he/she has reached an advanced level, although this chapter will not touch on this aspect of input comprehension.
Input comprehension, Prosodic Phrases & syntactic Acquisition Spoken input carries amazingly various, useful linguistic information for processing. More relevant to this chapter’s discussion are the following two phenomena: (1) Comprehension units, and (2) Branching directions. HPLT assumes that parser will decide branching direction, one
89
Teaching Online
comprehension unit after another, in the manner of “first come, first interpreted/ parsed.”
Comprehension Units What indicates or marks a comprehension/processing unit? Simply put, it is a prosodic phrase (Kang, 2003), because prosodic phrasing consists of “a sense unit” (Selkirk, 1984). The following English examples are from Pierrehumbert (1980, p. 8). The English sentence in (3) means Three mathematicians in ten derive a lemma as (4b). However, when a prosodic phrase is placed between mathematician and in, as in (3a), the sentence is not interpreted as Three mathematicians in ten derive a lemma, but as (3b). (3) Three mathematicians in ten derive a lemma. a. [Three mathematicians] [in ten derive a lemma]. b. Three mathematicians intend to rival Emma. (4) Three mathematicians in ten derive a lemma. a. * [Three mathematicians] [in ten derive a lemma] b. [Three mathematicians in ten] [derive a lemma] In Japanese as is the case of (5a), the intended meaning is I will listen to the radio, whose prosodic phrasing is either (5b-i) or (5b-ii). However, if a prosodic boundary is placed between rajio and o, the meaning will be Please make the (volume of) radio louder. (5) a. Rajio o kiku ‘I will listen to the radio.’ b. i) [Rajio o] [kiku] or ii) [Rajio o kiku] radio-Acc listen-will ‘I will listen to the radio.’ (Acc = accusative) c. *[Rajio] [o kiku] ‘Please make the (volume of) radio louder.’ radio bigger/louder These cases show that a comprehension/processing unit is indicated by a prosodic phrase. Branching direction and “first (prosodic phrase) come, first interpreted” 90
In HPLT, what need to be learned is how to parse oral/spoken input in TL. Input is parsed in the manner of “first (prosodic phrase) come, first served.” The parsed tree branching direction will be taken care of by the following Branching Principle. (6) Branching Principle a. Right Association (RA): Terminal symbols optimally associate to the lowest nonterminal node. (Kimball 1974) b. Left Association (LA): Terminal symbols optimally associate to the highest nonterminal node. (Kang 2007b) RA is for a head-initial (syntactic) phrase, while LA works for a head-final phrase. As seen in the following case, head-final and head-initial is determined in terms of whether the head precedes or follow its complement; the SPEC (ifier) is not involved in the heading parameter. (See Figure 3) Once the parser determines the branching direction according to head direction, it is assumed to follow either RA or LA depending on the head direction in a prosodic phrase. A prosodic phrase carries the information regarding the branching, too. According to Kubozono (1993), a prosodic phrase can include only terminal symbols of which branching directions are the same. In other words, spoken input seems to be organized for highly efficient processing. However, it is not clear how much input is needed for the parser to operate automatically RA or LA depending on the heading parameter. In the case of a previous example (1), cited here again, Japanese input with two prosodic phrases in (8i) will be parsed in (9ii), but the English correspondent will be processed in (9i). (1) kono kuruma-o ka-oo to omou this car-Acc. buy-will that think ‘I think that I will buy this car ’ (8) i) [kono kuruma-o ] [ka-oo to omou] this car-Acc. buy-will that think ii) [I think] [that I will buy this car] However, under the traditional grammartranslation approach, a Japanese learner whose
Teaching Online
Figure 3.
Figure 4.
Figure 5.
L1 is English will translate according to “first comes, last interpreted/comprehended.” (9) Parsing incoming prosodic phrase a. First input/prosodic phrase (See Figure 4) b. Second input/prosodic phrase (See Figure 5) This means that, as demonstrated in the following case, the learner uses their L1 processing/ branching algorithm, RA, but not LA. This is because under the traditional grammar-translation approach the learner is never exposed to the native speakers’ spoken input. (10)
8)
i) 1st input: omou (I think) (See Figure 6) ii) 2nd Input: to (that) (See Figure 7) iii) 3rd Input: kaoo (I will buy) (See Figure
iv) 4th Input: kono kuruma-o (this car) (See Figure 9)
output comprehension, Lexicon and Memory efficiency The phenomenon of the lexicon/mental dictionary is not the main concern of Generative Grammar, but remains a concern of our HPLTs. Relevant to 91
Teaching Online
Figure 6.
Figure 7.
Figure 8.
this chapter are the following issues associated with the lexicon: (1) learning of vocabulary; (2) subcategorization; and (3) morphology (e.g., conjugation/inflection). In HPLT, vocabulary learning is important, because unknown words cannot be associated to the parsed tree and hence cause extra burden to the short-term memory where the syntactic parser operates to try to figure out how to process incoming input. Ambiguity causes extra burden, too. Therefore, it is desirable to provide our students memory keys to introduced vocabulary (Kang, 1993).
92
Subcategorization of a verb or an adjective in L2 is not always the same as L1’s. In Japanese, adjectives have two classes (adjective-na and -i), and verbs have three major classes including the irregulars. For example, English subcategorization of the verb become is different from the Japanese counterparts. The verb become in English is subcategorized as become [ __ NP/ADJ], but in Japanese naru [ __ NP-ni/ADV(erb)]. To derive the adverb from from an adjective the following morphological rules need to be learn. (11) i) adjective-na: na —-> ni ii) adjective-i: i —-> ku The following are the examples of Japanese become-construction; compare them with English counterparts: (12) i) English ii) Japanese a. i) He became quiet. ii) sono hito-wa shizukani natta. That person-topic quiet became (shizuka= adjective-na) b. i) Yen became expensive. ii) en-ga taka-ku natta (takai = adjective-i) yen-Nom. expensive became Because noun and adjective-na both take ending ni, the students assume it is applicable to an adjective-i. The following fossilized case of interlanguage due to overgeneralization (Selinker 1972) is common in beginners, but sometimes occurs even among intermediate students. Compare the following with (12b-ii). Takai ‘expensive’ is an adjective-i, but it is treated as an adjective-na. (13) en-ga takai-ni natta. This exhibits the same pitfall of “input comprehension” method or approach as (2) above. Let us proceed to discuss this example in terms of output comprehension. Native speakers of Japanese can comprehend this utterance, as en-ga takaku natta, ‘Yen became expensive,’ correcting the mistakes of the adjective’s lexical categorization and inflection; this development causes tremendous extra burden on the addressee’s short-term memory, forcing the addressee to reanalyze/reprocess
Teaching Online
Figure 9.
the ungrammatical utterance. The output can be comprehended, but with more difficulty than in the case of (2) above. The teaching methodology or approach issuing from HPLT is MEA (Kang 1993), as mentioned above, which recommends FL/L2 teachers “eclectic” methods in the sense of Higgs (1984). Kang (1993) did not consider the addressee’s short-term memory burden. However, the present chapter does address this problem because the learner’s generator and parser mutually influence each other—unless, that is, the learner strongly refuses to speak TL for some kind of sociolinguistic reasons. One way to know whether the parser is functioning well with its lexicon is to check whether the learner understands input in TL. Moreover, a method for determining whether the generator is functioning well with a lexicon is to observe if the learner’s utterance is comprehended without causing the addressee extra short-term memory burden.
how can currently Incomprehensible Input be comprehended, and hard-tocomprehend output become More easily comprehended by bLt? This section raises the following issues: (1) repetition; (2) recasting; (3) negotiation of meaning and linguistic form. With regard to the negotiation, we refer to Gass (1997): “Negotiation refers to communication in which participants’ attention is focused on resolving a communication problem” (p.107). In the literature (e.g., Pica et. al., 1987; Swain, 1985), as mentioned above, interaction is one of the ways to make incomprehensible input/output comprehensible. According to Gass (p.150), “interaction is a priming device, allowing learners to focus attention on area that they are working on.” In other words, through interaction learners have opportunities to negotiate their problems of form or/and meaning with their interlocutors, which encourages the students to make a transition from the developmental stage n to n + 1. In our terms, interaction is one of the ways to make not only currently incomprehensible input comprehended, but also hard-to-be-comprehended output easy-to-be-comprehended, as in typically understood “interaction,” conversational or taskoriented. The following interesting conversation was observed at a restaurant. The NNS was not sure about her interpretation regarding chili (incomprehensible input for the NNS), and the NS repeated the phrase, pronouncing of more clearly, putting stress on it (which shows in bold in d of the following), to enable the NNS to understand what he ordered (the NS made the incomprehensible input comprehended as the result of negotiation). (14) a. Waitless: what would like to order? b. NS: I’ll take a hot dog with [sku:bə] chili. c. NNS: SCUBA (diving/diver’s) chili? (being surprised) d. NS: Well, no, but a scoopof chili. e. NNS: Oh. 93
Teaching Online
The above case seems self-evident. However, we need to look at this process of comprehension more carefully. The NNS has a problem in comprehending the input by the NS. Then, by virtue of the NS’s adjusted pronunciation, the NS realizes that what is perceived originally was wrong. Parsed in (i) of the following (treating the problematic prosodic phrase like a compound noun), it should be parsed as (ii) of the following, because of is cliticized to scoop; [sku:bəv]. Here it is behaving like an affix of scoop (see also Shelkirk, 1984, about the cliticization of English function words). When the NS re-pronounced the noun phrase into three prosodic phrases—[a scoop] [of] [chili]—the NNS’s parser processed it after negotiating the form, as in (iii) of the following. But this is not the case as in (ii), which poses another problem involving the input comprehension approach. The NNS’s parser probably will not be able to process the cliticized of as in (ii) unless the NNS perceives a cliticized of. The present chapter suggests that English learners (like this NNS) be provided with plenty of input with cliticized function words (I like’ em, how’d you do it? etc.) including of (a cup of [ək/\bəv] tea, a group of [əgru:bəv] people, etc.), with explicit grammar instruction about the cliticization. (See Figure 10) Figure 10.
94
According to Duff (2000), the term “repetition” is not interpreted as behaviorist “habits,” but rather, “…repetition is viewed as a way of providing learners greater access to language forms” (p. 109). In other words, this is a way of providing learners with more relevant input. Recast is a mode of repetition for corrective feedback. The importance of having learners reproduce forms they have heard to help them notice gaps between their own and other’s production is understood in several current accounts of language acquisition (Duff, p.109). L2 researchers have not evaluated recast highly because their findings indicate that it is not so effective for the students learning TL as teachers expects. According to Ohta (2000), in learner-centered classroom settings, recast/corrective feedback functions effectively because in learner-centered settings, private speech occurs; in such private speech, learners effectively realize their own errors. The following excerpts of classroom conversations evince adjective inflection: (16) Excerpt 4, Candance, January 24 (Ohta p. 61- 62) 1. T: Hai soshite (..) suteeki suteeki wa? (..)= longer pause Yes and (..) the staek staek was?
Teaching Online
2. Ss: Chiisakatta desu ne. = portion of special note to the current It was small, isn’t it analysis is underlined 3. T: Oishikatta desu ne. Demo It was delicious, right. But 4. Ss: Chiisakatta [desu] = overlap with similarly bracketed It was small ((correct from)) portion in neighboring turn = transcriber’s comments →5. C: [Chiisai deshita] → =indicated line of excerpt It was small ((wrong form)) 6. T: [Chiisakatta desu. Ne? Chiisakatta desu It was small. Right? It was small ((right form)) →7. C: “ah” reduced volume—soft voice 8. T: Ne. Chiisakatta desu ne? Ookiku arimasen deshita. Ne? Hai, ja rokubann Right. It was small, Right? I was not big. Right? Ok, number six Candance kept producing the wrong form chiisai deshita for ‘it was small,’ even if she heard several students correctly say chiisakatta. But, finally due to the teacher’s repeated recast of the correct form, she realized the discrepancy “as evidenced by her utterance of the change-ofstate token…‘ah’ in Line 7” (Ohta, p. 62). This is a case of recast, or teacher’s negotiation of forms. In our terms, the teacher tried to help the student make hard-to-be-comprehend output easy-tocomprehend by negotiating the form. There is another interesting case of recast repeated by a non-native speaker (NNS) to another NNS in Gass and Varonis (1994, p. 288): (17) a. Ana: Can you tell me where is the train station? b. Keiko: Can you tell me where the train station is? c. Ana: Can you tell me where is the train station? d. Keiko: Can you tell me where the train station is?
e. Ana: Can you tell me where is the train station? f. Keiko: Can you tell me where the train station is? g. Ana: Can you tell me where the train station is? h. Keiko: Can you tell me where the train station is? i. Ana: Can you tell me where the train station is? Here, Keiko helped Ana make hard-tocomprehend output easy-to-comprehend due to a syntactic over-generalization problem, by repeatedly providing her with the correct input. To put it more simply, we can make this kind of recast leading to self-correction, self-repair as online learning, combined with FFLT. Moving forward, the following subsection demonstrates collaborative learning and self-study activities the present author has designed and implemented for online learning in the second and the third semester of Japanese classes—JA102 and JA201, respectively—to make not only incomprehensible input comprehensible, but also hard-to-comprehend output easy-to-comprehend.
Practice Collaborative Learning for Fully Online JA201 Class In BLT, I designed collaborative learning for FFLT, but self-learning for online learning. However, in this context of total online learning and teaching, I switched to both for online learning. I implemented two collaborative works: (1) nazo nazo (riddles) relay by email (asynchronous), and (2) the task of describing the story of the pictures, using 4-koma manga ‘Japanese 4 panel cartoons’ (synchronous).
95
Teaching Online
Conducting Nazo Nazo (Riddles) Relay by Email Nazo nazo (nazo means ’mystery, puzzle, enigma, etc,’ and is a Japanese language game) for this class consists of two, or more than two, sentences, or one sentence with a simple relative clause, or a subordinate/coordinate clause and come up with the correct answer. Some of the examples are in the following: (18) Examples of nazo nazo for the relay. 日本に行ったら、見られます。日本で一 番(ばん)高いです。きれいです。
いつも一 番(ばん)上に雪があります。夏になったら、 登(のぼ)れます。
何ですか。 ‘If you go to Japan, you can see it. It is the highest in Japan. It is beautiful. It always has snow on the top. When it becomes summer, we can climb it. What is it?’ (Answer: Mt. Fuji) Why nazo nazo or puzzles? To come up with the right answer, one must correctly comprehend the sentences describing things, people, or places. This is one of the ways to check whether the students’ parsers are capable of processing the sentences in one question, by observing whether they come up with the right answer or not. In the case above, when a student answered correctly, he/she has successfully comprehended the input sentences of a nazo nazo, which indicates that his/her parser has processed input correctly, i.e., successfully. However difficult, this is the way to measure input comprehension or parser’s successful processing. If a nazo nazo question is given with spoken input, the students have to use “first come, first interpreted/parsed’ in real time processing speed. That is what I have been doing with students in JA102, although the sentence structures are less complicated than those in this class.
Narrative of Nazo Nazo (Riddles) Relay I sent ten questions of nazo nazo to the class (twelve students) to find out how good they are or not. I made the nazo nazo by using vocabulary,
96
Chinese characters (kanji), and sentence structures they were supposed to know. Even so, they could look up dictionaries whenever they required them. First come, first served, so to speak, but the first student had to answer my ten nazo nazo, and make at least five his/her own nazo nazo to email to the class. The rest of the runners should answer the previous student’s nazo nazo and make at least five his/her own nazo nazo and then email to all of us. They had to answer in Japanese. I sent them on Saturday of the first week of my instruction, but surprisingly on the following day I found that one of the students had already emailed us her answers with her five nazo nazo. And soon after that (on the same day), another student emailed us the following message (the student name is kept in blank). hey, () your 5th riddle was kind of hard to understand. i dont think your second sentance is correct. can you clarify it for me, so i can change my answer if you made a mistake on your number 5? thanks! have fun, everyone! Actually, the second runner’s 5th nazo nazo (riddle) is not so bad, but this student had a hard time comprehending it. Here we can see “negotiation of form and meaning” of input sentences, although the question was presented in English. This student gave me another surprise; she made 10 questions of nazo nazo, and emailed us soon after her email message above. My surprise did not end with that. The following day, Monday, when I stopped by the class between my two classes, another student was upset because she had not received my email message with 10 questions of nazo nazo. I sensed her competitiveness. Indeed, soon after that, the class received this student’s answer to the 10 riddles by the previous student with five her own riddles. After that episode, four students participated in the relay without any surprises. However, what bothered the present author was that five students did not participate in this activity. Those five stu-
Teaching Online
dents did not submit homework on time, nor come to see me in my office for oral interaction or oral recitation of dialogues in the textbook, although all of them took paper exams or quizzes administrated by a part-time teacher or staff. I was sure that the production of TL is harder than the reception of TL, but no questions I was asked from those five silent students. Every class day, I visited the class about 5 minutes between my two regular classes to try to connect them, and nicely remind them the participation in the relay, and homework, but nothing happened for a while until the last week of my instruction. In that week, finally two of the five students participate in this relay. On the third week of my instruction of the class, I gave the class another collaborative work, “Tell us a story of your 4 panel cartoon” adopting “Establishing the sequence of a picture story in four acts,” in Brandl (2005, p. 21). This activity revealed that two of the five students were well motivated to learn Japanese, but their Japanese language knowledge was just not as high as the seven students who participated in the relay much earlier. One of these two students was able to participate in the relay on the last week (the 4th week) of my instruction. In FFLT, I could have found out much earlier about these five silent students’ problems or difficulties.
Tell Us a Story of 4-Koma Manga (4-Panel Cartoon) Since the class has twelve students, this activity worked well in terms of grouping; each group has four students for four-panel cartoon. Each student received an URL to see his/her panel of cartoons by email. I used the Moodle’s “Forum” with the technical assistance of my colleague, Brian Millhoff. I scanned each panel of three 4-panel cartoons for three groups, and emailed them to Brian, who in turn emailed each one of the 12 students an URL where each student could find a panel of cartoon. Each student individually described his/her cartoon, and posted it in his/her
group’s forum. When everyone posted his/her description, the team started to find the correct sequence of four pictures. In this collaborative work, more interaction is observed than in the nazo nazo relay. There are four types of problems which caused more interaction, generating more input and output for the participants: (1) unknown kanji; (2) unknown vocabulary; (3) a incomprehensible sentence; and (4) insufficient information for the completion of the task. To collect enough information (due to insufficient information for determining the order of each cartoon) the students interacted with each other most frequently. The following is a case of unknown kanji, while (15) involves negotiating the description of the picture to determine the order of 4 panels/pictures. To understand the interaction in the following, the story of a 4-panel cartoon—-being adopted from a textbook Genki II; this class employed another textbook called Yookoso—-is depicted as follows: An 8-10 year-old boy walking along the street to go to the bakery to buy bread. He has a shopping bag in one hand and some bills in the other hand. At the bakery, he bought bread, but forgot to pay, and he still holding money in his hand. The baker realized that he did not get paid from the boy. Then, he ran to the boy’s house. Then, Mother and the boy came out, and the boy’s mother standing at the entrance of the house paid to the baker. (p. 297) (19) Incomprehensible kanji usage (because wrong one was used) J:パン家でこの男の子はパンを買いまし た。The boy bought bread at the bakery パンやのてん印はとてもうれしいです。 The bakery worker is very happy. L: Can you use kanji that we know please? Sorry, I just don’t understand some parts. Thanks! (The kanji she was talking about is underlined in the sentence above.)
97
Teaching Online
J:パン家でこの男の子はパンを買いまし た。 The boy bought bread at the bakery パンやの店員はとてもうれしいです。 The bakery worker is very happy (The corrected kanji is marked with underline.) “note” 前の漢字は違いました。 I used a wrong Chinese character. でも、いま漢字がいいです。 but now my Chinese characters are correct. (20) negotiation of description of a picture N:男の子は何かを持っていますか? Does the boy have something? J:男の子の右の手に紙をも持っていませ ん。The boy does not have paper in his でも店員はかばんを持っています。 right hand, but the bakery worker has a bag. In addition, it is worth noting, this kind of activity promotes understanding of Japanese culture because of the usage of Japanese 4-panel cartoon. In the bakery cartoon, for example, the bakery worker/owner wears Japanese traditional wooden sandals called geta.
Online Self-Study Blended for JA201 & JA102 Classes “First (prosodic phrases) Come, First Interpreted” In both of the classes, JA102 and JA201, the textbooks used are titled Genki; Genki I is for JA102, and Genki II for JA201. The textbooks have good reading comprehension materials; however, no audio files for the reading materials are included. Be this as it may, as I argued above, if one teaches a language in which the phrasal head-position is different from the learner’s L1, one does so to prevent them from processing in the way “first come, last interpreted/comprehended.” Remember that only spoken input tacitly force the students to follow “first come, first interpreted/ comprehended.” The following contents have been recorded in the audio files for “first come, first interpreted/parsed”:
98
(21) Contents of audio files as spoken input for JA102 and JA201 i. ii. iii.
each reading material in the textbooks, by reading it aloud. my own questions about the content of each reading material. my own questions about the content of the dialogs in each lesson.
It is important to set the number of trials to “unlimited,” to let our students try until they can find out the correct answer. In other words, let them try and try again until incomprehensible sentences are comprehended. I employed the grading scale for these quizzes lower than the activities involved other three skills (speaking, reading and writing) to reduce my students’ anxiety, but also to motivate them to challenge their listening comprehension skills. As for recording my own reading of the reading material of the textbook, for JA102 students, I recorded one batch of reading material in two ways: one, by reading slower, and the other by reading at my normal speed. In slower reading, I do not change any prosodic boundaries, but try to insert more prosodic phrase boundaries. As for the questions for the reading comprehension materials, although textbooks have printed questions, it is desirable the questions in audio files are given, and that the questions are not the same as those written ones in the textbooks. The questions about the dialogs of each lesson are created for the following two reasons: (1) I want to check whether they have studied and understand what they are talking about in each dialog, although the dialogs have English translation; and (2) I want to provide my students with more authentic spoken input.
Self-Negotiation of Form and Meaning I made more audio files for JA102 than for JA201. This is mainly due to the following: (1) JA102’s
Teaching Online
Figure 11.
the students in JA102 there are not so many listening comprehension materials, except for “real world” Japanese http://www.ajalt.org/rwj/, and (2) In the outcomes assessments, as mentioned above, the students’ learning of both adjective and verb inflections is as difficult as learning of writing the correct kanji corresponding to a given reading. In (a- I-1) of the following “fill-in questions,” I speak “before I was healthy, but,” and a student type in their answer in Japanese. In order to come up with the correct answer, what I am speaking in the audio file needs to be comprehended through self-negotiating of meaning and forms. (22) Fill-in questions a. For JA102 i) To learn adjective inflection: To fill an adjective in the blank, switching the tense and positive/negative of the pre-noun adjective 1) 元気だったお母さんが______!(answer: 元気じゃない) Mother who was healthy is not healthy (Surprise)! 2) 難しくないテストが______!(answer: 難 しかった)
The test that is usually not difficult was/has turned out difficult (Surprise)! ii) To learn “want-construction” 1) 帰りたくなかった。でも、______。 (answer: 帰った) I do not want to go back, but went back. 2) 心配する。でも、______。 (answer: 心 配したくない) I worry, but I do not want to worry. b. For JA201 To learn “give/receive-construction” 1) お金がなかったから、父にお金を貸し て______。 Because I do not have money, I loaned money from Dad. 2) 漢字が分からなかった。でも、友達が 教えて______。 I did not understand the kanji, but my friend kindly teaches it to me. In the case of the following “translation of verbal expression” in only one prosodic phrase, the students have to type in an English correspondent, listening to my pronunciation of each verbal expression; again, by self-negotiation of form and meaning. (23) Translation of complex verbal expres-
99
Teaching Online
sions for JA102 1)つかれなかった (was not tired) 2)ならいたくない (do not want to learn) 3)のぼった (climbed) 4)あかかった (was red) 5)やめたかった (wanted to quit) The following is an example of teaching grammar with songs. The following is not a quiz, but encourages my students to listen and sing the songs whose lyrics I made, inspired by one of my colleagues, Yoko Morimoto. The idea here is to use a melody of a song learned by our students in L1, and put Japanese words in it. The following one in (24) was made accordingly. The decision was made that for learning a “had-better” construction, it would be effective to adopt a Christmas song, “Rudolf the Red-Nosed Reindeer.” I made not only an audio file of my singing, but a slide show to show the sentences and English translation, and then put them in Moodle. This song has three parts, so I made three slides for it. Each slide was displayed during my singing of each part; this is the third part (#3) of the song. Songs are also good for latent learning of “first come, first interpreted/parsed.” Japanese characters in the songs persist in Moodle because the lyrics are inserted as slides. (24) Songs for learning the relevant structures for JA102 (See Figure 11)
current chALLenGes FAcInG technIcAL IMPLeMentAtIon There are two challenges regarding Moodle. As mentioned above, one is that Japanese characters are no longer readable, unless I use pdf format, or picture (JPEG) format. Secondly, even if this problem is solved, instructors take note that Moodle availability is subject to the financial conditions of one’s home institution. Quia, unfortunately, lacks two functions. First, it cannot replace “Forum” in Moodle. Second, it cannot present slide shows like the song’s slide shows in (24) above.
100
Even if I use Moodle, Japanese characters typed in are, as mentioned above, no longer readable. Therefore, my students are no longer able to engage in some meaningful collaborative tasks like “Tell Us a Story with 4-panel cartoon”. Even if I give up using Moodle for collaborative tasks, I need to use both Quia and Moodle. That is, Quia is used for quizzes and Moodle for the songs to learn grammar and the strategy of “first come, first interpreted”. I also found that it is quite a challenge for the instructor to let the majority of the students log into Moodle only for the song’s slide shows.
concLusIon In conclusion, the present chapter repeats its endorsement of BLT because it significantly reduces psychological and social distance in FFLT. Furthermore, instructors need to produce audio files to provide students with spoken input so they can self-negotiate form and meaning, and so that students’ parsers process in the manner of first (prosodic phrase) come, first served. The outcome is important: incomprehensible input becomes comprehensible, and hard-to-be-comprehended output becomes easy-to-comprehend output. The question in the title of this chapter, “Does More Input Improve Comprehension?” can be answered as follows: if input is relevant or effective for the students’ developmental stage to move up to one step higher, the answer is “Yes.” “More input” and its comprehension takes place as the result of the students’ parsers invoking processing principles like RA or LA, depending on TL’s phrasal heading parameter. However, this chapter claims that input comprehension is not good enough, but output development also contributes L2 acquisition. It needs to be said in all modesty that this chapter has not conducted assessment of the self-negotiation of form and meaning, and leaves it for future work.
Teaching Online
reFerences Bonno, E., Ohno, Y., Sakane, Y., & Sinagawa, C. (1999). Genki I: An Integrated course in elementary Japanese. Tokyo, Japan: The Japan Times. Brandl, K. (2005). Are you ready to “Moodle”? Language Learning & Technology, 9(2), 16–23. Chomsky, N. (1982). Government and biding theory. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Colpaert, J. (2006). Pedagogy-driven design for online language teaching and learning. Computer Assisted Language Instruction COnsortium (CALICO) . Journal, 23(3), 47–498. Conger, J., & Lawler, E. (2005, August 26). People skills still rule in the virtual company. [London.]. Financial Times (North American Edition), 10. Duff, P. A. (2000). Repetition I: Foreign language classroom interaction. In J. K. Hall & L. S. Verplaetse (Eds.), Second and foreign language learning through classroom interaction (pp. 108-138). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Gass, S. (1997). Input, interaction, and the second language learner. Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Gass, S., & Varonis, E. M. (1994). Input, interaction, and second language production. Studies in Second Language Acquisition, 16(3), 283–302. doi:10.1017/S0272263100013097 Hauck, M., & Sticler, U. (2006). What does it take to teach online? Computer Assisted Language Instruction COnsortium (CALICO) . Journal, 23(3), 463–476. Higgs, T. V. (1984). Introduction: Language teaching and the quest for the holy grail. In T. V. Higgs (Ed.), Teaching for Proficiency, the Organizing Principle (pp. 1-9). Lincolnwood, Chicago: NTC Publishing Group.
Kang, P. T. (1993). Parser strategies of adult English speakers learning Japanese as a second language: Theory and Application. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, University of Texas at Austin. Kang, P. T. (2000). A digital classroom for a foreign language course; A case study of Japanese language courses. PIALA 2000: Selected Papers from the 10th Pacific Islands Association of Libraries and Archives Conference Joint with the 13th Annual Regional Language Arts Conference, 74-80. Kang, P. T. (2003). Surface X-bar theory, prosodic structure and first language acquisition. Paper presented at the conference of UG Principles and Input: How do we get Plato’s heaven into Skinners box? the LSA Linguistic Summer Institute, Michigan State University. Kang, P. T. (2007a). Technology, lifelong learning, and effective foreign language instruction under the memory efficient approach. In Y. Inoue (Ed.), Online education for lifelong learning. (pp. 73-98). Hershey, PA: Information Science Publishing/ IGI Global. Kang, P. T. (2007b). Left association for a headfinal phrase. Paper poster-presented at the International Conference on Processing Head-final Structures at Rochester Technology Institute, Rochester, NY. Kang, P. T. (2008). First come, first interpreted and a performance-based Assessment for advanced L2 (Japanese) parser development. Paper presented at the conference, The 20th Annual Meeting of the Central Association of Teachers of Japanese at the University of Wisconsin, Madison, May 31-June 1. Kimball, J. (1973). Seven principles of surface structure parsing in natural language. Cognition, 2, 15–47. doi:10.1016/0010-0277(72)90028-5
101
Teaching Online
Krashen, S. D. (1985). Input hypotheses. New York: Longman. Kubozono, H. (1993). The organization of Japanese prosody. Tokyo: Kuroshio. Ohta, A. S. (2000). Rethinking recasts: A learnercentered examination of corrective feedback in the Japanese language classroom. In J. K. Hall & L. S. Verplaetse (Eds.), Second and foreign language learning through classroom interaction. (pp. 47-72). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Omaggio, A. C. (1984). The proficiency-oriented classroom. In T. V. Higgs (Ed.), Teaching for proficiency, the organizing principle (pp. 43-84). Chicago, IL: NTC Publishing Group. Pica, T., Young, R., & Doughty, C. (1987). The impact of interaction on comprehension . TESOL Quarterly, 21(4), 737–756. doi:10.2307/3586992 Pierrehumbert, J. (1980). Phonology and phonetics of English intonation. Doctoral dissertation. MIT. Reprinted Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Linguistic Club in 1987. Selinker, L. (1972). Interlanguage. IRAL, 10(3), 209–231.
Selkirk, E. O. (1984). Phonology and syntax: the relation between sound and structure. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Swain, M. (1985). Communicative competence: Some roles of comprehensible input and comprehensible input in its development. In S. Gass & C. Madden (Eds.), Input in Second Language Acquisition (pp. 235-253). Rowley, MA: Newbury House. Swain, M. (2000). The output hypothesis and beyond: Mediating acquisition through collaborative dialogue. In J. P. Lantolf (Ed.), Sociocultural theory and econd language learning (pp. 97-114). Ocford, UK: Oxford University Press. Tohsaku, Y. (1999). Yookoso! Continuing with contemporary Japanese. New York: McGraw Hill. VanPatten, B. (1996). Input processing and grammar instruction: Theory and research. Norwood, NJ: Alex publishing. Wegmann, S. J., & McCauley, J. K. (2007). Can you hear us now?: Stance towards interaction and rapport. In Y. Inoue (Ed.), Online education for lifelong learning (pp. 29-50). Hershey, PA: Information Science Publishing/IGI Global.
This work was previously published in Cases on Online and Blended Learning Technologies in Higher Education: Concepts and Practices, edited by Y. Inoue, pp. 112-131, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
102
103
Chapter 1.8
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE) Marshall G. Jones Winthrop University, USA Stephen W. Harmon Georgia State University, USA
AbstrAct
IntroductIon
This chapter deals centrally with one emerging aspect of Web 2.0 for education, that of the increasing demand for real time and near real-time interaction among users. Whereas most online learning has, to date, taken place in an asynchronous format, there is a growing need for an ability to provide learning opportunities in a synchronous setting. This chapter discusses synchronous online learning environments (SOLEs) and the affordances they present for teaching and learning. Particularly it focuses on a capability of these environments known as ancillary communications. It discusses ancillary communications as an intentional instructional strategy and presents guidelines for its implementation. And, in the spirit of Web 2.0, this chapter was written using the Web 2.0 application Google Docs.
Internet-based classes appear to dominate the landscape of distance education today. Online classes are common place in most colleges and universities and are becoming more common in high schools as well. While pioneering courses were offered through techniques using email, Internet Relay Chat (IRC) or bulletin boards, today’s courses are almost all managed by portal systems such as WebCT™, Blackboard’s CourseInfo™, or Elluminate™ to name but a few. These systems share many communication features such as bulletin boards, email, chat, whiteboards and assignment drop boxes. As technology advances and bandwidth improves, we see changes in these environments. Today’s systems offer audio and video communication tools as well as traditional text based communication. These new tools provide us with a unique opportunity. No longer is an online environment constrained to text for synchronous meetings and packaged media for asynchronous meetings. The environment now
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-729-4.ch005
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
affords unique opportunities for communication patterns that are usually reserved for face-to-face classes, mainly the ability to talk and listen. Moreover, with the addition of audio and video we are able to add new channels of information to the online environment. Historically there has been much research done on multiple-channel communication and cue summation. Moore, Burton, and Myers (2004) provide an exhaustive review of the literature on both. At the risk of oversimplifying this review, we can say that on the positive side multiple-channels of information may provide greater enrichment in learning. On the negative side it may lead to cognitive overload for learners. We have studied the use of these communication tools for a number of years (Harmon & Jones, 1999, 2001; Jones & Harmon, 2002, 2006) and found that the implementation of multiple communication channels in an online environment (e.g. audio, text, or whiteboards) may be used to provide redundancy of information and enrichment of material, (in the manner of traditional multiple-channels or cue summation). However, these channels can be used another way as well. They may be used as either a primary communication mode or a supporting communication mode, such as chat supporting audio, or audio supporting whiteboards, or audio supporting chats. When these tools are present, students will use them. We have found that they will certainly use them for personal discussions, such as an updated version of passing notes in class. This can, obviously, be distracting and can cause lack of attention to learning and hinder the ability of an individual learner to focus on class materials. However, when used in a purposeful manner these multiple channels may create increased learner focus and more efficient communication. Moreover, the use of multiple channels of communication may provide instructors a powerful physical manifestation of constructivist learning. In traditional positivist learning environments the primary instructional communication
104
occurs between the teacher and the students. In constructivist learning environments the primary instructional communication may occur between the instructor and students or between students and students. In either environment the instructional emphasis of the communication is almost wholly on one or the other. We argue that potential learning benefits may accrue if we place more emphasis on the communications that are occurring in a learning environment simultaneously with, but outside the focus of the primary communications. We call the exchange of information in support of learning that occurs synchronously with, but is physically and semantically separate from a primary communication mode Ancillary Communication.
reseArch FoundAtIons For AncILLAry coMMunIcAtIon Ancillary Communication as an intentional instructional strategy is based on our ongoing study of an online course we teach on the topic of online learning (Harmon & Jones, 1999, 2001; Jones & Harmon, 2002, 2006). It follows, then, that the design of the course has influenced the development of our definition of Ancillary Communication. To that end, we offer some of the guiding literature we use in designing and refining our course. Our course is based on the discussions of constructivist learning (Jonassen, 1999), situated cognition (Brown, Collins & Duguid, 1989) and anchored instruction (Bransford et al, 1990; Cognition and Technology Group, 1990). The class was set up to be experiential and to create a learning environment that is driven by the learner (Papert, 1980; Wilson & Ryder, 1996; Greening, 1998). Analysis of early offerings of the class (Harmon & Jones, 2001) indicated that students were unprepared for the responsibility of this type experience initially and typically floundered during the early portion of the semester. Today the course employs a pedagogical shift approach, with a more positivist
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
perspective and instructor delivered content early in the semester, to a more constructivist perspective with student generated content and instructor guidance later in the semester. This shift allows the students to quickly gain confidence in the online environment and master the fundamental knowledge and skills they will need to succeed later on, while still affording them the benefits usually conferred by a student-centered learning environment (i.e. greater motivation and enhanced transfer) (Land, S. & Hannafin, M., 2001). This is particularly important since motivation has been found to be a key component for successful online learning (Kawachi, 2003). This work draws heavily upon a taxonomy of web-based instruction developed by Harmon and Jones (1999), research focusing on analyzing learner interaction in online classes (Harmon & Jones, 2001; Jones & Harmon, 2006) and discourse patterns in online discussions (Mcklin, Harmon, Jones & Evans, 2002). Additionally it is related to the foundational research in communications theory (Schramm, 1961; Shannon & Weaver, 1964) and multiple-channel communication and cue summation (Moore, Burton, & Myers, 2004).
web 2.0, LeArnInG, And AncILLAry coMMunIcAtIon For centuries the teacher was seen as the center of epistemological authority in the classroom. Information entered the classroom largely, if not solely through the teacher. Either he or she directly imparted information to the students, or vetted content provided by others such as textbooks and readings. As other avenues of information dissemination evolved, the teacher’s hold on learners began to weaken. The rise of constructivism acknowledged that different learners created knowledge in different ways. The Internet gave learners access to far more information than ever before. Savvy teachers realized this and began
changing the way they taught. The well known aphorism “sage on the stage” gave way to the now well-known aphorism “guide on the side.” In the earliest applications of the Internet in the classroom this was often manifested by teachers facilitating learners’ exploration of content instead of providing them with vetted content. But even this exploration of multiple and varying perspectives that exist on the Internet had its limitations. And the most significant limitation was that most of that content still originated from a limited number of sources and the students themselves had little opportunity to engage with or add to the content that they were discovering on the Internet. Despite the increased access to information, the overall model of Internet use in teaching and learning was still remarkably similar to traditional classroom learning: learners were still seen as information consumers. This circumstance was reflected in the practice of many Internet service providers who allotted customers substantially more bandwidth for downloading than for uploading (Moran, 2007). The major difference that the Internet made in learning and instruction is that the teacher was now no longer able to vet all of the information coming in to the classroom. Students were still consumers of information. With the rise of what has been called Web 2.0 the paradigm of students as consumers of information has begun to change. We are still in the nascent stages of Web 2.0 in education, but already we are beginning to see the impact (Alexander, 2006). Web 2.0 is centered on the concept of user generated content. Instead of the majority of Internet users being consumers of information coming from a limited number of sources, Web 2.0 is currently in a state where there is increased parity between consumption and production of information by users. Just as desktop publishing software and laser printers allowed everyone to have the equivalent of his or her own printing press in the 1990’s, the tool sets and protocols of Web 2.0 allow everyone to have not only his or
105
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
her own publishing company, but rather, if you prefer, his or her own broadcast network. When applied to education, the user-created content aspect of Web 2.0 has been referred to as Learning 2.0 (Brown & Adler, 2008). In an educational setting this changes the traditional model of students as consumers of information to one where students are producers of information. The content creation and collaboration tools of Web 2.0 give students the ability to interact and form communities of practice (Wenger, 1998; Alexander, 2006) like never before. This, in turn, opens up a range of instructional and learning strategies that have not been easily accessible in the classroom. These strategies have the potential to achieve real advances in education and training. According to Brown & Adler (2008), The most profound impact of the Internet, an impact that has yet to be fully realized, is its ability to support and expand the various aspects of social learning. What do we mean by ‘social learning?’Perhaps the simplest way to explain this concept is to note that social learning is based on the premise that our understanding of content is socially constructed through conversations about that content and through grounded interactions, especially with others, around problems or actions. The focus is not so much on what we are learning but on how we are learning. (Brown & Adler, 2008, p.2) That is the heart of Learning 2.0, the promise of Web 2.0 for education, and the compelling rationale for Ancillary Communication as an instructional strategy. Besides just sounding like a good idea, there is a sound theoretical underpinning for this concept. On the surface, the notion of students creating content may not seem like a good idea. Students, almost by definition, are novices in whatever content they are studying. If they already knew the content there would be no need for them to learn it. But, if they do not know the content, how can they create it? Presumably
106
their fellow students will be learning from the content they create. This seems like it could lead to the widespread adoption of fallacies and fact. Imagine a student of brain-surgery making up his or her own content and other brain-surgery students adopting it in practice. Most of us would decide to choose another group of surgeons or forgo the operation entirely if our brain-surgeons were trained this way. Where then, is the benefit in student-generated content? As noted above, it is the act of generating the content that has value. Papert (1991) advocated a similar notion in his work on constructionism. Constructionism is the idea that students learn by building something in a public context. There is still a roll for the teacher, only it is not as a disseminator of knowledge, but as a quality control agent, who insures that the knowledge created is consistent with current and generally accepted thought on the topic, or in the case of some states, with whatever the state standards happen to say is accurate. The fact that students create this concept in collaboration also resonates with the social constructivism theory of Vygotsky (1978). Reality is a shared social construct. It is, in effect, whatever we agree it is. The earth may not be flat but the world is, if you get our drift. Vygotsky held that we learn by creating this reality and negotiating meaning. There is perhaps no better example of this than the Web 2.0 space, Wikipedia. In Wikipedia users come together to negotiate the official entry for any given topic. One has only to follow the discussions that occur behind the main entry page to see that in most cases the negotiation of meaning that occurs typically results in all participants coming away with a richer, more nuanced understanding of the topic. While most Web 2.0, and therefore Learning 2.0 tools, are asynchronous, there is a growing trend for more real-time interaction. The growth of social networking services like Twitter and Spoink, and of instant messaging services like AOL’s AIM or Windows Live Messenger point to a desire on the part of users for more synchronous
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
interaction. While education has traditionally been synchronous (face to face classes), elearning has traditionally been asynchronous (content modules and bulletin board based discussions). The tools did not exist, or were not readily accessible to allow for synchronous online teaching and learning. In the last few years, however, that has changed. Today a wide variety of platforms exist that allow us to take advantage of what we know about synchronous instruction, combine it with what we have learned about asynchronous instruction, and create new learning environments online. The trick is figuring out how to use this new capability in ways that maximize its effectiveness. We have been attempting to do just that.
teAchInG And LeArnInG wIth soLe Since 1998 we have been preparing professional educators for work with online learning by teaching an online class on the subject of online learning. Two sections taught at two different universities are joined together to study the theories behind online learning and to experience an online class from a variety of different perspectives. This recursive opportunity appealed to us and seemed to present an exciting challenge and advantage: we could provide learners with a realistic way to study online learning in an online environment and we could study the environment to contribute to the body of knowledge in the field on online learning. The goal of the class was to provide students with both a realistic web-based course and experience in designing, developing, using, and evaluating realistic web-based courses. It was designed to be a multi-site distance education class with half the class in one location, and half the class in another distant location thus creating a realistic distance education environment. Since the topic and the delivery mechanism were essentially the same, it seemed that situated cognition (Brown,
Collins & Duguid, 1989) and anchored instruction (Bransford et al, 1990; Cognition and Technology Group, 1990), might apply to the design of this particular course. To study the class we used qualitative methodologies such as interviews, observations, and document analysis. Data is generated through public and private chats, bulletin boards, emails, transcripts of team meetings, formal and informal interviews (both online and face to face) and an analysis of student projects. A single class tends to generate an enormous amount of data (a typical course offering can be in excess of 4,000 printed pages of data from bulletin board postings and chat logs and over 30 hours of recorded class interactions). This data was analyzed using constant comparative analysis (Glaser & Strauss, 1967). During subsequent offerings of the class we were able to identify specific phenomenon to study and were able to combine constant comparative analysis with analytic induction (Patton, 1990). Research results, including more details on data collection and analysis on many of these course offerings may be found at Harmon and Jones (1999, 2001) and Jones and Harmon (2002, 2006).
AncILLAry coMMunIcAtIon Historically the class has been offered through a portal system such as WebCT™ or CourseInfo™. Consequently our communication tools were bulletin boards, email, and drop boxes for asynchronous meetings and IRC for synchronous meetings. During 2004 we added a course system called Elluminate™ which provided two way audio communications between students and students, faculty and students, and faculty and faculty. The system provided space for posting packaged PowerPoint™ presentations and also provided the ability to break students into small groups in the synchronous meetings and provide them with audio tools and whiteboard space for group work during class meetings. As instructors we were able
107
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
to see all communications in the class, even those that were “private” to the students. Students were given problems during class, such as doing the front end analysis for a web-site for a client, in a small group and then brought back together with the larger class to present their findings. Student interactions and discourse using these tools and strategies were analyzed both at the small group level and the whole class level. Initially we found that these tools were not technically difficult for people to use, but that students were not clear on why they should use them and how they could be best used. Through the use of recursive data analysis we began to develop strategies to use these new tools. What we found was that they were best used when one communication tool or mode was used to support the other. During a typical course interaction, such as a student presentation, a dominant mode might arise. For example, a small group’s white board (a visual mode) might be perceived to be the dominant mode. To support this, students may explain it using an ancillary mode, such as the audio functions, (a verbal - audio mode) while taking questions from faculty and other students through another ancillary mode, the chat window (a verbal - text mode). The dominant and Ancillary Communication modes might change without notice, but participants in the system were able to recognize and adapt to this almost immediately. They were then able to use Ancillary Communication modes to support the dominant mode. Consequently, audio was used to support whiteboards and vice versa depending on which mode was perceived to be dominant. At no point was one mode stated to be dominant. The class appeared to be able to develop and instantly manifest a shared understanding of which mode is dominant and which mode is ancillary. But what we found most interesting was that people were not confused by the tools or by what sounds like a barrage of information. They were actually engaged by the communication and able to make sense out of multiple streams of informa-
108
tion coming at them at one time. Evidence of this is found both in their test scores and in the quality and quantity of their interactions. Consequently, data from the study suggests initially that this is more than enrichment or cue summation, especially since the Ancillary Communications often varied widely from the content being discussed in the primary channel. These communication tools are seen by participants as being interconnected in one sense, but separate in another. Therefore their mutual support of each other makes them unique and allows us to focus on their use as an intentional instructional strategy.
LeArner InterActIons In A soLe Generally, we found that students in the course interact in a manner consistent with the types of interaction noted by Miltiadou & Savenye (2003). Learner-content interactions occur when students in the course work directly with course materials. These types of interactions are perhaps the most common when viewed from the perspective of time on task, both in traditional and online environments. Reading a text book or website, researching a paper, or working through a tutorial would all be examples of learner content interaction. This type of interaction can occur concurrently with Ancillary Communications and frequently does so in our classes. Learner-instructor interactions occur when the student works directly with the instructor. These types of interactions are also very common in both traditional and online classes, but may frequently be characterized by a greater flow of information in pedagogical approaches that view the instructor as content provider. Interestingly, direct learnerinstructor interactions may be less common in the type of eLearning environments that have come to dominate education with the advent of course management systems (CMS). While in traditional CMS learner-instructor interaction typically oc-
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
curs both on bulletin boards and in chat rooms, there is also a greater prevalence of stand alone instruction in which there is little or no direct learner-instructor interaction. In SOLE’s however, we found there to be copious and intense learner-instructor interaction. Indeed, we found the level of learner-instructor interaction to frequently exceed that which is found in a face-to-face environment. We have noted four sub-categories of learner-instructor interaction in this environment. 1.
2.
3.
4.
In the first sub-category the instructor is communicating with the entire class at once through audio and visual channels. This sub-category interaction may be most easily thought of as an instructor presenting a lecture via PowerPoint. Note though, that while this is the easiest way to characterize the interaction, it is also a bit misleading since pure lecture is a technique we try to employ rarely, preferring instead a more interactive form of discourse. The second sub-category of learner-instructor interaction occurs when the instructor is communicating with the class as a whole through the chat window. This type of interaction is a central component of the discussion of Ancillary Communication we are presenting. The third sub-category of learner-instructor interaction occurs with the instructor communicating with an individual student or a small group of students privately in the chat window. By privately we mean that the communication is not seen by the class as a whole, only by the intended recipients. The fourth type of sub-category is what we refer to as a pseudo-private communication, in which the instructor communicates with the class as a whole via the chat window, but does so as a private communication. This means that each recipient may think that the communication was intended only
for him or her even though in fact the entire class got the same communication. The third type of interaction noted by Miltiadou & Savenye (2003) is learner-learner interaction. This occurs when learners communicate directly with each other. This type of interaction may occur in traditional classrooms, particularly those that are set up along constructivist lines, or may occur perhaps surreptitiously in a classroom set up with a direct instruction format. In a traditional online classroom, this type of interaction may occur more often than in a traditional face to face classroom, particularly with student interaction that might occur on a discussion board, or in a chat room. We observed that like learner-instructor interaction, there are sub-categories for this type of interaction in the virtual classroom. These include, learners communicating with the class as a whole via audio and visual channels; learners communicating with the class as a whole via the chat window; and learners communicating with other individual or small groups of learner’s via private chat. Note that in both the learner-instructor, and the learner-learner sub-categories we suppose that there could be an additional category of accidental communications, in which either the learner or the instructor sends a private message that was supposed to the public, or more commonly, a public message that was intended to be private. For the purposes of this chapter we will not consider these unintentional communications. The fourth type of interaction noted by Miltiadou & Savenye (2003) is learner-interface interaction. Unlike the other three types of interaction which may have learning as their primary purpose, learner-interface interaction has as its primary purpose the enabling of the other types of interactions. While it may be possible to design online learning environments in which the interface itself is intended as a mechanism to enhance instruction and learning, we know of no course management system or virtual classroom environment in which this is the case.
109
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
AFFordAnces oF AncILLAry coMMunIcAtIon It has been well documented in the literature that media do not themselves influence learning (Clark, 1994). It makes no difference whether instruction is delivered via a book, or a film strip, via a computer or via a television. In study after study it has been shown that it is not a medium itself that makes a difference in learning outcomes, it is the instructional strategy that is employed. If that is the case, then why should we use one medium instead of another? Why use a rather expensive medium, such as a computer, instead of a relatively inexpensive medium, such as a newspaper? The answer is because different media have different capabilities for delivering instruction. Televisions can do things that newspapers can’t and computers can do things that neither televisions nor newspapers can. The key to using technology successfully in instruction is to identify the unique capabilities of the technology and employ them in ways that are most advantageous to their strengths and least prone to their weaknesses. Another term used in discussing the capability of media is the term affordances. An affordance is a potential for action that exists in a given object or technology (Gibson, 1977; Norman 1988). Different media afford us the ability to do different things. Text affords us the ability to rapidly peruse a lot of information in a highly abstract form. Video affords us the ability to fairly rapidly evoke strong emotional response in viewers. If we are to improve education overall we must be able to determine the affordances of new technologies and create effective instructional strategies that use them. Synchronous online learning environments afford us new capabilities that did not exist or would be difficult to implement in a traditional classroom. One of these capabilities, or affordances, is Ancillary Communication. Ancillary Communication can be difficult to implement. This may be due to its relative infancy as an instructional strategy or to the fact that it
110
requires facility with online tools, such as reading and responding to chat messages quickly while still maintaining the flow of a verbal discussion. Imagine sitting in front of your computer and speaking to your class room of twenty students while they all ask questions at once. To read and process all of this information takes patience and practice. It is a skill that a growing number of students implement quite effortlessly in daily communication, but one that has not been commonly used instructionally. We have worked almost exclusively in a multi-instructor environment which has made it somewhat easier. While one of us speaks, the other can manage the questions from the students. Instructors new to SOLEs and Ancillary Communication may want to get some help to implement them. Using a team teaching approach or a graduate or teaching assistant should prove beneficial. It is also possible to designate individual students in a class to serve as teaching assistants during the class to help with the management of the environment. This rotating assistant arrangement can both solve the problem of dealing with potential information overload and also increase student engagement. Additionally it has the added benefit that students seem to be sympathetic to their peers working as teaching assistants, thus creating a greater level of collegiality in the classroom. Groups of students may work as assistants during the class to actually present course material by themselves or with the instructor, thus creating a unique constructivist environment. Ancillary Communication harnesses the increased facility students have with both experiential cognition (Norman, 1988) and online tools to provide greater focus on learning goals and instructional tasks. We find that students use video game like speed to ask and answer questions in class. Ancillary Communication appears to be a way for us to harness this new set of skills students bring to class based on their non-academic use of Instant Messaging and “Googling” for answers during a discussion. But let us be clear:
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
we found that students were using this quick reaction and quick response in instructionally meaningful ways. Because Ancillary Communication can be so intense, we recommend blending the synchronous online class with an asynchronous component as well. This allows instructors to balance the fast paced experiential cognition of the environment with more reflective cognition activities (Norman, 1988). For both students and instructors in our graduate level course, two hours appears to be the maximum amount of time one can spend in a SOLE using Ancillary Communication without losing focus or becoming overly fatigued. Our examination of Ancillary Communication has yielded the following affordances. Below we discuss the development of our understanding of how these affordances can be used.
community and shared experience The addition of audio to an online classroom appeared to provide a greater sense of community and shared experience with the students and the instructors. Because so many classes are built, traditionally, on a model of teacher talking and students listening, the addition of audio to an online class made it fell “like a real class,” as one participant put it. Having the ability to hear the professor and your fellow students talking lessened the sense of isolation in the online classroom. Students reported feeling more connected and indeed a greater sense of collegiality was noted in course offerings using audio than in offerings in the past. We have always required weekly synchronous meetings, historically in text only chat rooms. And while meeting regularly has more of a “real class” feel than a completely asynchronous class, the addition of audio appeared to be the variable for increased community building. Examples of community building are included in other findings below.
shared work space The use of whiteboards as a shared work space on which to think as a group provided richer interactions between students than text chats alone. In previous offerings of the class it was possible to break students into small groups to have them do small group discussions. We have recommended the use of smaller chat communities as a method of increasing student interactions in the past (Jones & Harmon 2002). But the addition of a shared workspace increased the amount of interaction. For example as students worked on the problem of creating motivational strategies for a piece of online instruction in a chat window they could write down what they thought. When they returned to present their work to the entire class they could tell people what they did through the use of text in a chat window. But the addition of the white board gave them someplace to hold the information while they discussed it. It also provided them with something tangible to refer to during their presentations. We like to think of it as the digital equivalent of a student generated flip chart. The result was greater engagement in small group work and more concrete representations of abstract thoughts during in class presentations.
chat window summaries The use of chat windows to summarize what the speaker is saying grew naturally out of the environment. The novelty effect of using a microphone for live audio was significant initially, to be sure. Both instructors and the students relished the idea of being able to talk instead of type during synchronous meetings. The way the system works, only one person was able to talk at a time. Students are given microphone “privileges” by the instructor, but only one person can talk at a time. During one presentation, while one instructor spoke, the other instructor began to summarize what the other was saying in the chat window because a student was having problems with
111
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
audio. What was unexpected was that students who had audio found the summaries not to be distracting, but helpful. The instructor who was typing in the chat window could not provide a full transcript of the audio, so he would shorten and summarize and at times add more detail or a different perspective than that being presented by the speaker. Watching the instructor do this seemed to provide the students permission to do much the same thing. Students began to use the chat window to ask questions while the instructor spoke, and the instructors used the questions to shape the direction of their comments. While the instructors modeled this technique originally, the students were coming to the same conclusion at the same time. While the novelty effect of using audio initially made the audio the “best” way of communicating, or the primary communication mode, if you will, the use of chat as a way to supplement audio or to communicate when the microphone was not available elevated the use of text chats in the eyes of the students. Soon the use of chats became not just a secondary mode of communication but actually rivaled the use of audio. In a current course offering students seemed to prefer the use of chatting to the use of audio as a way of making their thoughts heard. We suspicion that one reason that text based communication is so popular for students today is because of their familiarity and facility with online communication tools such as IM and mobile phone based text chats.
Increase in collegiality Ancillary Communication through the use of the chats provided people with the ability to comment at will, make jokes, and generally increased the collegiality of the class from past offerings. If a presenter, either a professor or a student, made a joke, or a malapropism, the chat window would light up with people commenting that they were “LOL” (laughing out loud) or “ROFL” (rolling on the floor laughing). Students used the private
112
messaging feature to pass notes to each other and to discuss things off topic, to be sure, but they also used the private messaging feature to ask each other questions that were on topic. Because students and professors were able to comment at will while someone was speaking it created an atmosphere that was not only conducive for sharing information, but it actually demanded that people share information. The use of the chat windows increased engagement, and this engagement in turn increased the quantity and quality of the communication. The collegiality seemed to help in the building of community as well. If you are a regular reader and commenter of a blog you have witnessed this type of collegiality. And as people got to know each other better, both personally and academically, the level of trust and collegiality increased.
Manifesting understanding The use of chat windows for Ancillary Communication allowed students to manifest their cognitive processes instantly. This thinking out loud, if you will, provided the instructors in an online class with a tool that is often cited as a benefit of face to face instruction but typically not found in face to face classes. In a face to face class, instructors often talk about being able to “see the eyes” of their students. This lets a teacher know that person is on task or “gets it,” if you will. Because one mode of communication is happening through audio, the ancillary mode of chat provides a remarkable opportunity to get instant feedback from the learners. And because the learner must write what they are thinking it leaves little doubt as to whether they “get it” or not. Additionally Ancillary Communication allowed the students to explore aspects of the course content not covered in the primary instructional communication mode, and thus potentially enhanced their motivation and understanding. Students were able to use the ancillary mode of communication to make comments that contributed to their private understanding of
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
Table 1. Methods of ancillary communication 1. Agree-disagree 2. Elaborate 3. Diverge 4. Scaffolding 5. Reiterate 6. Emphasis 7. Show relevance of 8. Social Engineering
the material in a public way. Because of this their private thoughts became public and these public thoughts helped provide other learners with examples the professors were not able to provide. Faculty soon began to use private and public communication intentionally as a way to further the benefits of Ancillary Communication.
Methods oF AncILLAry coMMunIcAtIon Using Ancillary Communication in an online environment can be made more concrete through the application of one or more method as listed in Table 1 and discussed in the narrative below. While there are many potential methods emerging from our work in employing Ancillary Communication in synchronous online learning, we will review eight of these that we have used and refined in our own work. We note at the outset that our circumstances may be a bit uncommon in that we are fortunate to have two instructors present in the classroom at the same time. The methods of Ancillary Communication we employ typically take the form of one instructor being responsible for the primary communication which is occurring in audio and visual channels, and the other instructor responsible for the Ancillary Communication which occurs in the chat window. It is possible to use students in the role of ancillary or primary instructor as well. For example, during student presentations or student led discussions the instructor of record can play
the role of ancillary instructor. And with proper planning, students can serve in a predetermined ancillary role while the instructor of record serves as the primary instructor.
Agree-disagree Description: In the first method the ancillary instructor either agrees or disagrees with what the primary instructor is saying via the audio channel. The intention is to either affirm the content, and thus add weight to it, or to stimulate discussion and more critical thought by disagreeing with the primary instructor. Example and Discussion: We found that it is often startling for the students to see two instructors disagree with each other in front of the class. In our environment we have two authority figures who are disagreeing with each other, and this is a powerful statement in a class. The disagreement forces students to think more deeply about the content and to come to some resolution as to their own perspective. We began using this method after we noticed that students frequently view a communication from the instructor as the final word on a subject. We found that, particularly on discussion boards, one of the quickest ways to end a discussion is to have one of the instructors offer an opinion on the matter. In a single instructor classroom you can still provide for disagreement with some preparation and planning. It is possible to have a student play the disagreement role as well. While this often happens organically in classes, you can also prepare for it by “planting” a student. This technique requires that that student is well prepared to play their role convincingly, but it also opens the door for other students to disagree with the professor during a synchronous class meeting. We found in practice that we typically disagree little with each other. Therefore in order to use this technique it is necessary for one of us to play devil’s advocate, but do so in a manner that is convincing to the students.
113
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
elaborate Description: In this technique the ancillary instructor elaborates on the primary instructor’s point. Providing further information in a chat window while a primary instructor speaks, the ancillary instructor is both adding to the depth of the discussion and at times adding details that may have been left out of the initial presentation. Example and Discussion: Consistent with Reigeluth’s elaboration theory of instruction (Reigeluth & Stein, 1983), we found it helpful to provide elaboration on both a macro and micro level. That is to say, the ancillary instructor offers comments that place the primary instructor’s point in a broad context. For example, in a discussion on the problems related to the perception of rigor and quality in online learning, the ancillary instructor may broaden the discussion by adding a discussion on pre-Internet distance education classes in order to provide context to online learning. Providing learners with greater detail in this manner is intended to provide macro level support for learners. Of course there are also times when it is important to zoom in for a more micro focus on a particular aspect of the primary instructor’s point. For example, in a discussion on the affordance of particular media types in online learning, an ancillary instructor may provide details on the advantages of a media type, such as digital audio files, in the chat window while the primary instructor is discussing how they work.
diverge Description: Discussions are presented by the ancillary instructor in a manner that has the initial appearance of being unrelated to the primary instructor’s main content object. Ultimately, the divergence is reconnected to the initial point, but the divergence creates a memorable, unique manifestation of the primary instructor’s main content object.
114
Example and Discussion: This technique, drawn from work in creativity theory, consists of having the ancillary instructor offer comments that may initially not seem related to the primary instructor’s comments. We find this technique to be most helpful when we are trying to get students to think about unfamiliar concepts in a new way. For example, in our class there is a classic and long running joke about sardines causing chickenpox. The story goes that after eating sardines as a child, the instructor got the chickenpox. The instructor goes on to tell the class, in a long winded, often hilarious story, how he made the faulty causal relationship that eating sardines causes chicken pox and how the mention of sardines can still make him scratch at phantom pox. This seemingly unrelated story is told during a discussion of semantic network theory, illustrating how learners can make their own connections between seemingly disparate pieces of information. It has both the effect of providing a memorable example and providing an initial impression that the instructor may have lost the thread of the discussion in an almost embarrassing manner. But it works. It is a difficult technique to employ skillfully. With too much divergence the students may become confused and lose track of the main content object. However, we have achieved good results by having the ancillary instructor begin the divergence and, after some time for reflection, the primary instructor show the relevance of the divergence to the main content object. It is also a technique that can be employed in a single instructor classroom by having the instructor diverge intentionally, making sure, of course, that they make it back to the main point.
scaffolding Description: Scaffolding in SOLE is similar to scaffolding in traditional classrooms. A teacher may begin by providing support to the student by demonstrating a technique or modeling a process. The instructor then begins to shift the responsi-
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
bility to the learner to do the entire procedure themselves. Example and Discussion: If an instructor can show up for class with five different, unique, and relevant examples of a difficult concept, then anyone in the class can learn the new concept. The key is providing examples that are relevant to a wide array of learners and learning styles. The problem is that most of us have only one really good example, and when the learners don’t understand it we simply repeat the same example again, only louder and slower. Scaffolding is an attempt to help provide support for learners who may be having problems understanding an example. In this technique while the primary instructor presents a difficult concept the ancillary instructor assists the class in comprehending the topic by providing both the subordinate skills necessary to comprehend the topic, and relevant examples and non examples that may assist in understanding. The ancillary instructor may also answer individual student’s questions either publicly or privately depending on how relevant they seem to the class as a whole.
reiterate Description: This brief technique occurs when the ancillary instructor reiterates a point the primary instructor is making. We use it mainly for emphasis and to increase focus on particularly important points. In reiteration, we typically try to use the exact language that was used by the primary instructor. Example and Discussion: One way to do this is to prepare a detailed outline of the presentation in a class. While the primary instructor talks about the topic, the ancillary instructor is literally copying from the outline and pasting into the chat window. This is particularly useful when dealing with definitions or complicated descriptions. It is a technique, when used judiciously, which can help people who may need to see and hear what is going on at the same time. It is also a technique that can
be used quite easily with a student assistant during class, or even by a single instructor. The addition of an ancillary instructor may mean that you can combine reiteration with scaffolding to meet many learning needs in a single class session.
emphasis Description: Another technique we use frequently is to either emphasize or occasionally de-emphasize points the primary instructor has made. In this technique an ancillary instructor may emphasize a point made by a primary instructor or a student in a discussion. By highlighting a useful comment or suggestion in the chat window the ancillary instructor can draw attention to salient points that may help the entire class. Example and Discussion: Unlike reiteration emphasis typically does not use the same language as the primary instructor. Additionally the emphasis may be applied to a student comment as easily as it may be applied to a primary instructor’s comment. It may take the form of approbation such as “Good point; that’s very important.” Deemphasis occurs less frequently but is used when students may have a tendency to place too much importance on a particular point.
relevance Description: The ancillary instructor makes explicit the reasons why the learners should know and be able to use the content under discussion. (Note that “because it’s on a test” is not a generally acceptable reason.) Example and Discussion: If you have ever been a student in a classroom you have at some point in your educational career been deeply involved in a lesson and found yourself wondering “what’s the point?” While hopefully there typically is a point, it is sometimes difficult for learners, particularly those in the beginning stages of learning a particular content, to understand the relevance of the topic under study. (Over three decades
115
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
later, one of the authors is still struggling to find the relevance of some of his high school calculus classes.) We frequently find it helpful for the ancillary instructor to make explicit the relevance of the content. Even more helpful is for the ancillary instructor to guide the class in providing their own examples of the relevance of the content during the primary instruction. We have considered, but not yet attempted, having the ancillary instructor work through all phases of Keller’s (1987) ARCS model at appropriate points in a lesson.
social engineering Description: Social engineering involves modifying the emotional state of the class to best fit the instructional purposes of the lesson. It is not as Machiavellian as it sounds. Example and Discussion: In this category we include any attempt by the ancillary instructor to help set the tone or mood of the class. This might include adding humor to the content, building confidence in the learners (as in the manner of emphasis), or perhaps creating tension in the class (as in the manner of agree-disagree). In other words, social engineering involves modifying the emotional state of the class to best fit the instructional purposes of the lesson. One example of how we do this is when we are discussing rules for course interactions in an online class. We will send a private message to everyone in the class telling them that they are not participating enough. Everyone gets the same message at once, and it has the desired effect of creating mass confusion. The chat window will be scrolling by too quickly to read as people race to make sure they are participating enough. We intentionally try to overwhelm them in order to make the point that there probably should be some rules. We then engage them in the process of writing those rules for the class. The exercise provides a common experience for everyone to reference throughout the class.
116
concLusIon We can expect new communications technologies and increases in bandwidth to be upon us quickly. While the time shifting capability of asynchronous instruction ensures that it will remain in use for the perceivable future, it also appears that the growing ubiquity of computing resources will increase the demand for more synchronous online learning opportunities. Rapid growth in real time or near real time communications technologies seems to indicate a preference among Internet users for immediate feedback and interaction. New and emerging technologies continue to make this interaction not only feasible, but also inexpensive and easy. If we are to take advantage of the affordances of this technology then we need to be experimenting with it, and applying what we already know about teaching and learning to its use for instruction. We propose that purposefully including Ancillary Communications as an instructional strategy in online courses may enhance retention and transfer of content, and increase student motivation and instructor feedback. Much has been written about teaching in asynchronous online classrooms (Schank, 2007; Denigris & Witchel, 2000). This paper seeks to add to the nascent but growing body of research on synchronous online learning tools and strategies (Foreman, 2003; Cheng-Chang, 2005). The need for strategies that deal specifically with synchronous online learning is great. Students in these classes may bring with them both online communication skills and needs that are foreign to many instructors. The tools are easy enough to learn, but strategies to use them effectively in SOLEs should be developed, analyzed and disseminated. Indeed, in a SOLE it is not only possible but quite simple to present one’s PowerPoints and lecture, allowing for the occasional student question, and thus perpetuate the much maligned lecture format through another generation of technology. While this approach would be easy, it misses the opportunity to take advantage
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
of the truly significant affordances of synchronous online learning environments. And perhaps worse, it opens the door for critics of instructional technologies to point out how ineffective they can be. Ancillary Communication in SOLEs gives us one opportunity to avoid that fate.
Foreman, J. (2003). Distance learning and synchronous interaction. The Technology Source, (July/August). Retrieved from http://ts.mivu.org/ default.asp?show=article&id=1034
reFerences
Glaser, B. G., & Strauss, A. L. (1967). The discovery of grounded theory: Strategies for qualitative research. New York: Aldine.
Alexander, B. (2006). Web 2.0: A new wave of innovation for teaching and learning? EDUCAUSE Review, 41(2), 32–44. Bransford, J. D., Sherwood, R. D., Hasselbring, T. S., Kinzer, C. K., & Williams, S. M. (Eds.). (1990). Anchored instruction: Why we need it and how technology can help. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Brown, J. S., & Adler, R. P. (2008). Minds on fire: Open education, the long tail, and learning 2.0. EDUCAUSE Review, 43(1), 16–32. Brown, J. S., Collins, A., & Duguid, P. (1989). Situated cognition and the culture of learning. Educational Researcher, 18(1), 32–42. Cheng-Chang, S. P., & Sullivan, M. (2005). Promoting synchronous interaction in an elearning environment. T.H.E. Journal, (September). Retrieved from http://www.thejournal.com/ articles/17377 Clark, R. (1994). Media will never influence learning. Educational Technology Research and Development, 42(2), 21–29. doi:10.1007/ BF02299088 Cognition and Technology Group at Vanderbilt. (1990). Anchored instruction and its relationship to situated cognition. Educational Researcher, 19(6), 2–10. DeNigris, J., & Witchel, A. (2000). How to teach and train online. Needham Heights, MA: Pearson.
Gibson, J. J. (1977). The theory of affordances. In R. Shaw & J. Bransford (Eds.), Perceiving, acting, and knowing. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Greening, A. (1998). WWW support of student learning: A case study. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 14(1), 49–59. Harmon, S. W., & Jones, M. G. (1999). The five levels of Web use in education: Factors to consider in planning an online course. Educational Technology, 39(6), 28–32. Harmon, S. W., & Jones, M. G. (2001). An analysis of situated Web-based instruction. Educational Media International, 38(4), 271–280. doi:10.1080/09523980110105123 Jonassen, D. H. (1999). Designing constructivist learning environments. In C. M. Reigeluth (Ed.), Instructional design theories and models: Their current state of the art (2nd ed.). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Jones, M. G., & Harmon, S. W. (2002). What professors need to know about technology to assess online student learning. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, Fall(91), 19-30. Jones, M. G., & Harmon, S. W. (2006). Ancillary communication as an intentional instructional strategy in online learning environments. In M. Simonson & M. Crawford (Eds.), Proceedings of the 2006 international conference of the Association of Educational Communications and Technology (Vol. 2, pp. 194-199.
117
Instructional Strategies for Teaching in Synchronous Online Learning Environments (SOLE)
Kawachi, P. (2003). Initiating intrinsic motivation in online education: Review of the current state of the art. Interactive Learning Environments, 11(1), 59–82. doi:10.1076/ilee.11.1.59.13685 Keller, J. M. (1987). The systematic process of motivational design. Performance and Instruction, 26(9/10), 1–8. Land, S., & Hannafin, M. (2001). Student-centered learning environments. In D. Jonassen & S. Land (Eds.), Theoretical foundations of learning environments (pp. 1-23). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Mcklin, T., Harmon, S. W., Jones, M. G., & Evans, W. (2002). Cognitive engagement in Web-based learning: A content analysis of student’s online discussions. In. M. Crawford & M. Simonson (Eds.), Proceedings of the 2001 international conference of the Association of Educational Communications and Technology (Vol. 1, pp. 272-277). Miltiadou, M., & Savenye, W. C. (2003). Applying social cognitive constructs of motivation to enhance student success in online distance education. Educational Technology Review, 11(1), 78–95. Moore, D. M., Burton, J. K., & Myers, R. J. (2004). Multiple-channel communication: The theoretical and research foundations of multimedia. In D. H. Jonassen (Ed.), Handbook of research on educational communications and technology (2nd ed.) (pp. 981-1005). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Moran, J. (2007). Battling the upstream bottleneck of broadband connections: How fast does your data swim upstream? Retrieved August 29, 2008, from http://cws.internet.com/article/3541-.htm
Norman, D. (1988). The design of everyday things. New York: Doubleday. Papert, S. (1980). Mindstorms. New York: Basic Books. Papert, S. A., & Harel, I. (1991). Constructionism. Norword, NJ: Ablex Publishing Patton, M. Q. (1990). Qualitative evaluation and research. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage. Reigeluth, C. M., & Stein, F. S. (1983). The elaboration theory of instruction In W. Schramm (Ed.), The process and effects of mass communication (pp. 5-6). Urbana, IL: The University of Illinois Press. Schank, R. C. (2007). The story-centered curriculum. eLearn, 4(April). Shannon, C. F., & Weaver, W. (1964). The mathematical theory of communication. Urbana, IL: The University of Illinois Press. Torrance, E. P. (1985). Creative motivation scale: Norms technical manual. Bensenville, IL: Scholastic Testing Service. Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Wilson, B., & Ryder, M. (1996). Dynamic learning communities: An alternative to designed instructional systems. In. M. Crawford & M. Simonson (Eds.), Proceedings of the 1996 international conference of the Association of Educational Communications and Technology.
This work was previously published in Collective Intelligence and E-Learning 2.0: Implications of Web-Based Communities and Networking, edited by H. H. Yang; S. C. Chen, pp. 78-93, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
118
119
Chapter 1.9
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities Jianxia Du Mississippi State University, USA Yunyan Liu Southwest University, China Robert L. Brown Mississippi State University, USA
AbstrAct An online learning community can be a place for vibrant discussions and the sharing of new ideas in a medium where content constantly changes. This chapter will first examine the different definitions that researchers have provided for online learning communities. It will then illuminate several key elements that are integral to online learning communities: interactivity, in both its task-driven and socio-emotional forms; collaboration, which both builds and nurtures online communities; trusting relationships, which are developed primarily through social interaction and consist of shared goals and a sense of belonging or connectedness; and communication media choices, which impact DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-788-1.ch004
the other three elements. This chapter also provides suggestions for the practical application of these elements in the online classroom.
IntroductIon Since the turn of the century, the subject of the online learning community (OLC) has become a hot topic in the field of learning research. The most influential and developmental points and contributions are overviewed as follows. Why has the OLC become more and more attractive to policy makers and researchers? Rovai (2002) suggests that the physical separation of distance education students may be one of the contributors to high dropout rates in distance education. Hill, Raven, and Han (2002) imply that the existence of community
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
may actually decrease dropout rates by increasing a student’s sense of belonging. Community may, therefore, directly impact a student’s successful completion of coursework (Brown, 2001). An OLC can maintain many of the supportive attributes of traditional instruction at a distance. Collaboration in an OLC can provide deeper understanding of content, increased overall achievement, improved self-esteem, and higher motivation to remain on task (Looi & Ang, 2000). For their flexibility and convenience, online courses appeal to both traditional and nontraditional students. However, many students are wary or skeptical of online courses due to factors such as isolation and lack of immediate attention. Technology in an online course is another reason community is important. Technology can cause opportunity for areas of new learning (Powers & Mitchell, 1997), and community can develop around the solving of problems or the seeking of other solutions. Additionally, quality is a concern for distance educators, and some argue that online courses do not offer the personal connections available in the regular classroom (Lowell & Persichitte, 2000). Enhanced community can provide that connection and interaction that inevitably increases quality. Essentially, the majority of the literature in the field of distance education provides support for the idea that an increased sense of community will enable meaningful learning. Educational institutions of varying levels have undergone rapid and massive transitions in the area of distance learning (Palloff & Pratt, 1999). What began as a response to the needs of non-traditional (as well as traditional) students has proven to be an extremely desirable alternative to the regular classroom for students and an exceptionally lucrative business venture for academic institutions (Palloff and Pratt, 1999). As the number of students and instructors involved with this method of teaching and learning increase, the number of online communities to support such learning will experience dramatic growth. Therefore, it is crucial that both the online instructor and the online
120
student are aware of the characteristics associated with an OLC. The encouragement (or requirement) of interaction among the participants in an online community is based upon many of the tenets associated with the theory of Constructivism. This chapter reviews definitions for OLC and looks closely at the literature associated with several key elements that comprise the OLC as recognized by the authors. Key elements such as interactivity, collaboration, trusting relationships (shared goals and belonging), and communication media in the online learning community are discussed in detail.
deFInInG the onLIne LeArnInG coMMunIty The term community is used very broadly and partly also with more or less different meanings. The Merriam-Webster online dictionary defines community as “a unified body of individuals” (Merriam-Webster, 2004). However, Bellah, Madsen, Sullivan, Swidler, and Tipton (1985) define community specifically as “a group of people who are socially interdependent, who participate together in discussion and decision making, and who share certain practices that both define the community and are nurtured by it” (p.4). Conversely, McMillan and Chavis (1986) offer this description of community: “a feeling that members have of belonging, a feeling that members matter to one another and to the group, and a shared faith that members’ needs will be met through their commitment to be together” (p. 9). Still other aspects of community are addressed by Westheimer and Kahne’s (1993) explanation, which describes community as “a process marked by interaction and deliberation among individuals who share interests and commitment to common goals” (p.325). Tu and Corry (2002) address the academic and social-learning component of communities and define a learning community as “a common place where people learn using group activity to define
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
problems affecting them, to decide upon solutions, and to act together to achieve these solutions” (p. 207). However, when examining online learning communities additional criteria must be considered. Fernback (1997) describes community as “a term which seems readily definable to the general public but is infinitely complex and amorphous in academic discourse” (p. 35). This explanation seems especially accurate when referring to the online learning community because of the many purposes for which these communities exist, the variance in the ages of the participants, and the frequency and type of communication that exists within these communities. Stepich and Ertmer (2003) consider the development of a supportive learning community crucial to the learning process in an online environment (p.35). Palloff and Pratt (1999) also report the critical nature of the online learning community and describe it as “one vehicle through which learning occurs online” (p. 29). Essentially, the authors maintain that the absence of an authentic community of learners will result in the absence of an online course (Palloff & Pratt, p. 29). For this literature review, an online learning community is defined as a group of diverse individuals united by communication media who develop a sense of trust and connectedness through online interaction and collaboration.
eLeMents oF onLIne LeArnInG coMMunItIes Compared to other learning communities, the OLC has some special characteristics in terms of interactivity, collaboration, trusting relationships, and communication media.
Interactivity Several factors play a role in the development and duration of online learning communities. Possibly the most notable factor is that of interaction
or interactivity. Interactivity is widely accepted as a vital element needed to foster a sense of community in an online learning environment (Bannan-Ritland, 2002). The idea that interactivity is key to creating a sense of community among online learners, begs the question what exactly is interactivity, and how can instructors secure its role in the development and duration of an online learning community? Research has provided an overwhelming number of interpretations for interactivity. This review encompasses a variety of research including definitions of interactivity, and methods for promoting interactivity for the purpose of establishing a sense of community among online learners.
Interactivity Defined Interactivity is defined numerous ways by many different researchers. As noted by Berge (2002), “Interaction is two-way communication among two or more persons with the purposes of completing the learning goals (tasks) and building the necessary social relationships” (p. 183). Berge’s comments regarding student-to-content interaction give way to the idea that through “engagement, reflection, or study by the student [aids] in the self-construction of competency of the learning goals” (Berge, 2002, p. 183). He later presents the notion that learners can mold and cultivate future interaction through the process of “reflection on learning,” a process in which students review interactions from a social stand-point (Berge, 2002). Bills defines interactivity as “...an instructional strategy that provides the student the means of being actively involved in the learning activity” (Bills, 1997, p. 4). Vrasidas & McIsaac (1999) cite their interpretation of interactivity as the “reciprocal actions of two or more actors within a given context” (p. 25). Through research on interactivity, BannanRitland provides an “explanatory synthesis of the literature related to the construct of interactivity” in the hope of promoting the use of a universal
121
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
definition with regard to interactivity and distance education. Bannan-Ritland’s review revealed characteristics common among interactivity. “Interaction can be viewed as a function of; (a) learners’ participation or active involvement, (b) specific patterns and amounts of communication, (c) instructor activities and feedback, (d) social exchange or collaboration, or (e) instructional activities and affordances of the technology” (Bannan-Ritland, 2002, p.167). Rovai (2002) notes that Du & Sun, 2007) provide two categories of interaction, “task-driven,” which is “directed toward the completion of assigned tasks” and “socio-emotional” which is purely focused on “relationships among learners” (p. 5). For the purpose of this review the focus will be on the socio-emotional interaction interpretation of interactivity. Referring to the definition of community stated previously in this review, it should be noted that at the heart of a learning community is the social aspect which bonds learners together. Socio-emotional interactions are almost entirely “self-generated” (Rovai, 2002). It is this “selfgenerated” interaction that promotes relationships among learners. Cutler notes the impact selfdisclosure has on relationships and community formation stating “the more one discloses personal information, the more others will reciprocate, and the more individuals know about each other, the more likely they are to establish trust, seek support, and thus find satisfaction” (Cutler, 1995, p.17). Therefore, it can be inferred that as self-disclosure occurs among online learners the more likely it is that there will be a strong formation of an online community (Rovai, 2002).
Promoting Interactivity The research examined for this review reinforces the belief that interactivity helps foster a sense of community. Acceptance of the idea that interactivity intensifies and aids the creation of online learning communities leads to the examination of criteria for promoting a sense of community
122
among online learners (Rovai, 2001). Many different aspects of interaction have been researched such as learner-learner, learner-instructor, and learner-content (Hirumi, 2002, Du, Durrington, & Mathews, 2007). Nonetheless, there has been little research concerning the practical applications of interactivity. The following section seeks to organize various works of research highlighting elements that are essential to promoting and creating interactivity in an online learning community. When considering interactivity incorporation methods in an online learning environment, small group activities and group facilitation should be addressed (Rovai, 2002). Rovai (2002) suggests dividing students into small groups, in order to provide an individual aspect to the course. Within each group, meaningful discussions and collaborative learning can take place without learners feeling as if they are getting lost in the crowd (Rovai, 2002). Rovai also emphasizes the importance of group facilitation through channels like dialogue. He states “dialogue is an essential component of an online course and facilitation efforts are meant to inspire learners to interact” (Rovai, 2002, p. 9). By facilitating an online discussion or chat, instructors can pique students’ interest in particular topics and in turn spark interaction among learners. Stepich and Ertmer also provide suggestions for fostering a sense of community through interactivity in online learning environments. Like Rovai, Stepich and Ertmer suggest the addition of “collaborative group activities that give students an active voice in the development and definition of the community” (Stepich & Ertmer, 2003, p.41). Another recommendation by Stepich and Ertmer is to monitor participation. Monitoring participation and providing individual feedback can give learners a feeling of belonging. Through feedback instructors can add a sense of value to student participation. Feedback can also illustrate the positive impact student participation can have on the entire class (Stepich & Ertmer, 2003). Not only is participation important in an
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
online learning environment, but introductory activities carry weight as well. Ciardulli highlights the importance of using an “ice breaker” in a distance learning environment. Icebreakers can be used as a tool to introduce the instructor as well as the students. This also sustains and familiarizes students with the online learning community. Ciardulli provides three reasons in support of the use of icebreakers. First, icebreakers enable every student to become acquainted with one another. Secondly, these activities present an opportunity for students to become familiar with how chats or discussions work in an online environment. Lastly, implementing exercises such as these enable students to feel relaxed in a new setting (Ciardulli, 1998). Including icebreakers at the beginning of an online course can help to lay the groundwork for future interactivity as well as a sense of community. One common form of icebreaker is the student introduction, wherein each student composes a post that introduces that student to the other students. While this type of icebreaker allows the students in the OLC to become acquainted with each other, it doesn’t allow for much interaction between participants. Once read, the introductions often go ignored, with few or no follow-up remarks from other students. One alternative to the student introduction is for the instructor to create a short questionnaire directed to all students in the OLC. Since the primary goals of the icebreaker are to allow the students to both get to know each other and how discussions work, the items on the questionnaire should highlight student interests. Some possible questions that can be included are “What is your favorite television show?” and “What song gets the most play on your iPod?”. Student and instructor responses to the questionnaire should either be posted to a central location in the online environment to which all members of the OLC have access, or the responses can be emailed to all the members of the OLC. After the completed questionnaires have been posted, replies to students regarding their answers to
specific items should be encouraged among the entire OLC membership. Perhaps the most encompassing guide to incorporating interactivity into an online learning environment is that of Hirumi (2002). Hirumi sets forth a proposed framework which consists of three interrelated levels of interaction, and is followed by six steps for “designing and sequencing eLearning interactions” (p.148). Level I deals with “Learner-Self Interactions”, interactions that transpire within each learner (p.143). “Level II interactions occur between the learner and human and non-human resources” (Hirumi, 2002, p.143). Level II includes the following sublevels of interaction: learner-learner, learner-other human, learner-interface, learner content, and learner-environment. Level III involves “LearnerInstruction interactions” (Hirumi, 2002, p.143). Hirumi provides three applications designed to bring life to his proposed framework. Perhaps the single application instructors will find most useful is “Designing and Sequencing eLearning Interactions” (Hirumi, 2002, p.148). Hirumi (2002) supplies a six step process for “Designing and Sequencing eLearning Interactions” the six steps are as follows: 1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
Identify essential experiences that are necessary for learner to achieve specified goals and objectives (optional); Select a grounded instructional strategy (Level III interaction) based on specified objectives, learner characteristics, context and epistemological beliefs; Operationalize each event, embedding experiences identified in Step 1 and describing how the selected strategy will be applied during instruction; Define the type of Level II interaction(s) that will be used to facilitate each event and analyze the quantity and quality of planned interactions; Select the telecommunication tool(s) (e.g. chat, email, bulletin board system) that will
123
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
6.
be used to facilitate each event based on the nature of the interaction Analyze materials to determine frequency and quality of planned eLearning interactions and revise as necessary (p. 151).
Hirumi’s proposed framework along with the six steps for “Designing and Sequencing eLearning Interactions” account for numerous levels of interaction (p.148). The four authors mentioned above (Stepich & Ertmer, Ciardulli, and Hirumi) all provide original approaches for promoting interactivity, but it should be noted that each of these three approaches overlaps another at least once. While this review of literature regarding interactivity is not exhaustive, it may prove useful to instructors who wish to enhance the sense of community in online learning environments.
collaboration Another element of the Online Learning Community is collaborative or cooperative learning. Collaborate means “to work together, especially in a joint intellectual effort” (American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language, 1992). “Collaborative and cooperative” mean working together jointly, intellectually, and socially to reach a common goal. Harasim, Calvert, and Groeneboer (1997) provide a simple definition of collaborative or group learning that refers to instructional methods whereby students are encouraged or required to work together on academic tasks. Note that in this section the words “collaborate” and “cooperate” will be used interchangeably. In this section, collaboration is defined within an online learning community as a collaborative group of people who have a common goal and desire to pursue and achieve that goal. These online learners could be students, educators, or any other individual in the community. Fisher & Coleman call this complex mixture “the community of practicing within the group” (Fisher
124
& Coleman, 2001). It is considered a foundation to the successful learning community. Studies reveal how collaborative learning in the online environment provide success in the classroom or workplace. A useful strategy for learning communities in the virtual environment is a real-time dialogue or discussion (Fisher & Coleman, 2001; Du, Durrington, & Mathews, 2007). These authors believe that method of dialogue strategy can enable instructors to initiate and facilitate successful communication and collaboration between members of the learning community. The literature supports that discussion environments produce richness in collaboration, communication, and practical application. The substance and meaning of online activities is determined by the specific individuals who work together online. One of the tools that Wang, Poole, Harris, and Wangemann (2001) used to collaborate in problem-based learning was 27 teenagers in the Expeditions project on the Internet. The participants were children of Motorola employees who volunteered to participate in the project. This study revealed the value of collaborative problem solving in an online environment. The study further described that the participants grew significantly in their confidence in collaborating online and competence in using the online communication tools in problem solving (Wang et al., 2001). Collaborative learning encourages the community to develop by becoming more active and constructive in helping each other (Dolezalek, 2003), thus taking ownership of learning and improving their skills. Individuals united in the Internet virtual classroom are bound together by shared interests and background, and therefore, seek new areas of growth in this collaborative environment (Powers & Mitchell, 1997). Learning may best be achieved through the social constructions of knowledge in a community where teachers and students are members of both the learning community and are agents of the learning environment (Fisher & Coleman, 2001).
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
Online collaboration seems to encourage the participants’ creativity and spontaneity in generating ideas (Wang et al., 2001). People come together to construct knowledge and negotiate meaning that is consistent with the goals of the learning community (Looi & Ang, 2000). Fisher and Coleman (2001) conducted a study of the structure and interactive design of learning communities in virtual discussions. When interaction among community members is encouraged, collaboration and mutual accountability will increase (Fisher & Coleman, 200; Du, Durrington, & Olinzock, 2006). Literature suggests that cooperative and collaborative learning brings positive results. Looi & Ang (2000) did a pilot study focusing on the collaboration of a small group of students in Singapore and Hong Kong secondary school using a multiUser Dimensions (MUD) and Object Oriented (MOO or WOO) called SpaceALIVE! Students from different schools formed a science project and published the findings as a virtual science exhibit. This finding evidenced that collaboration online was successful in meeting student needs. The research also shows that using the collaborative tool ScienceALIVE! facilitated cooperation among students. ScienceALIVE! tools supported student’s collaborative work by allowing them to share and compare their experiments. With proper facilitation, students in online communities, can have collaborative discussions, solve problems, and meet the needs the community. Another study by Riel & Fulton (2001), examined how technology can support learning communities. This report asserts that when students are given the necessary resources, they can engage in work that has personal and community value. Another study conveyed that using collaboration in an online environment created international coalitions of faculty and students, which produced communities of learners across boundaries (McIsaac, 2002). In addition, the study revealed that benefits of online collaboration have gradually developed an individual voice in the establishment of an academic community.
Collaborative learning nurtures the community. Romanoff (2003) examined a case study on how technology-based distance learning can foster a broader sense of community by using Multi Object Oriented Collaboratory Walden3 (MOO). What began as conversation in cyberspace between two teacher-administrators grew into a learning community that considered their distance collaborators as colleagues. Literature also shows that collaborative online learning is successful because people with the same goals benefit from each other rather than from competition with each other. Yu (2001) did a study on the effects and implications of embedding the elements of inter-group competition and non-inter-group competition with an online environment. His findings yielded that collaboration without competition engendered better attitudes with students.
trusting relationship This element is intrinsic including shared goals, a feeling of a sense of belonging or connectedness within the community, or just the general feeling of a sense of community among fellow learners. The literature suggests that this element is present within communities in differing degrees and is needed for a successful community of online learners (Wang, Sierra, & Folger, 2003).
The Importance of Trust Building Aubert & Kelsey (2003) define trust as “the willingness of a party to be vulnerable to the actions of another party based on the expectation that the other will perform a particular action important to the trustor, irrespective of the ability or control that other party.” (p. 98). Trust must be the basic foundation for interaction and the relationship formed among an online collaborative team. Stanley (2005) states, “Trusting relationships stimulate innovative thinking and lead to organizational improvements.” Boehlje (1995) states,
125
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
“Shared decision-making must be established as an evolutionary approach that fosters trust and confidence among all participants.” Aubert & Kelsey provide three antecedent conditions that are important in building trust. The antecedent conditions are “the trustee’s perceived ability, benevolence and integrity.” As time progresses and group members work together, the dynamics of the group evolve. Team members must “deal with project task allocation, decision making, conflict, team maintenance tasks (e.g. esprit de corps, cohesion)-all of which can have a positive or negative effect on trust.” Being able to effectively deal with these factors will help to foster a productive working environment for the entire group (Aubert & Kelsey, 2003). Du, Zhang, Olinzock, & Adams (2008) emphasize that trust is essential for online groups because of the lack of everyday interaction. They highlight the difficulties in developing trust without having everyday, face-to-face interaction. Rovai called “Spirit” the “feelings of friendship, cohesion, and bonding that develop among learners as they enjoy one another and look forward to time spent together” (2002, p.4). The notion that social discussions strengthen the development of community among learners is also supported by the literature (Maor, 2003). Community learning is a social process and in order to create familiarity and trust the social dimension has to be emphasized (Tu & Corry, 2002). Maor’s (2003) study shows that students posted messages that were a “blend” of the academic and the social and indicates that this facilitated the formation of an online community of learners. Wang, et al. (2003) went so far as to suggest that the “social network is the foundation for trust building among team members” (p. 57). There appears to be no doubt that the social aspect of online learning is almost always present and is important if an instructor wants to build community. Is trust just an insignificant “extra” that occurs within some communities? Preece (2000) states if “there is trust among people, relationships flour126
ish; without it, they wither” (p. 191). She also indicates that with most interactions among people or organizations there is some level of trust. Trust serves to channel the energy of the group to help community members reach goals and also motivates “group processes and performance” (Wang et al., 2003, p. 57). Poole (2000) puts much on the shoulders of trust by saying that the “development of online communities is based largely on trust” (p. 175). He believes that students need a safe environment where they are free to make mistakes and learn from them without feeling intimidated. Haythornthwaite, Kazmer, Robins, & Shoemaker (2000) concurred as one of their subjects commented that their online learning community was a safe environment to say something, where no one would ridicule. Further interviews with students revealed students’ “balanced reciprocity” (p. 7) of sharing ideas, providing moral support, and giving friendship throughout the course studied. The researchers state that this demonstrates the “trust present in communal relations” and that trust is a “key attribute of community” (p. 7). Powers and Mitchell (1997) collected data from a graduate course which revealed “a true community of learners who were committed to providing encouragement and support to each other throughout the course” (p. 10). Because of the perceived anonymity of electronic communication, students felt safe and were comfortable sharing information with their peers. Brown’s (2001) three levels of community mentioned previously included “camaraderie” as the last level. Brown considered this the highest level of community “generally” achieved after long-term and/or intense association with others and was “primarily found among students who had taken multiple classes together, e-mailed outside the class forum, spoken on the telephone, or even met face-to-face” (p. 13). This camaraderie was developed as they worked together for a common goal and could not have formed without an element of trust. This camaraderie among learners occurred virtually unnoticed (Brown, 2001).
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
Shared Goals A goal is something that an individual or individuals strive to accomplish. In online learning communities common or shared goals are present. Learning communities provide a means for obtaining knowledge within an environment of shared goals, and respect for diversity (Jonassen, Peck, & Wilson, 1998). Learning communities are unified by a common cause of mutual support and learning, and by shared values and experiences (Lock, 2002). These goals are typically the desire to obtain more knowledge of the subject content, obtain academic success, and meet course requirements. Individuals in online learning communities often have common goals. Individuals strive toward a shared goal that carries a mutual investment (Misanchuk & Anderson, 2000). This mutual investment often includes time, finances, and other personal contributions. To sustain an online learning community, the vision, goals, and interests of the community must be articulated and accepted by the members (Lock, 2002). Students are likely to buy-in to the goals and visions, if they have input. Bonding among students can be facilitated by common interests, vision, and goals (Preece, 2003). Students in online learning communities can be united through building trust, understanding, and reciprocity. Instructors play an active role in creating an online learning environment that is conducive to learning and student academic growth. The instructor should assign group projects and other activities that require combined efforts to accomplish given tasks. Common goals are present in a learning community, and completing an instructional task is considered a mutual goal (Moller, 1998). According to Moller, in the design stage students are encouraged to work collaboratively toward a shared goal. These collaborative activities should be intertwined in order for members to find mutual interests. Collaborative activities encourage interdependence, networking, and ongoing communication among individuals to accomplish
a task. Brown (2001) identified three levels of community: making friends on-line, community conferment, and camaraderie. Making friends or acquaintances is necessary for collaborative efforts on group projects or assignments. Brown feels that camaraderie is accomplished after long-term involvement with classmates. This involvement is typically from email, chats, discussion boards, and telephone conversations. According to Tu and Corry (2002), “The community of collaborative learning, the grouping and pairing of learners for the purpose of achieving an academic goal has been widely examined and is advocated throughout the professional literature” (p. 213).
Sense of Belonging or Connectedness The literature reveals that it is not the quantity of student postings, e-mail, or other interactions that leads to a sense of connection, but rather the quality of those interactions (Lock, 2002). Students who spend time reading each other’s in-depth postings or e-mail and responding in kind are interacting at a deeper level and will form that sense of connection, thus building community (Lowell & Persichitte, 2000). Interviews with 17 students over a year period revealed that a sense of isolation was overcome by exchanges with other students (Haythornthwaite et al., 2000). Students felt that their classmates experienced the same challenges and obstacles and had similar questions. Speaking from personal experience, Conceicao (2002) said, “I felt I had a voice that was recognized and validated when others made comments reflecting on my postings” (p. 43). Common sense dictates that participation is paramount for feeling a sense of belonging in the online learning community. As previously mentioned, communication is crucial in an online learning community (Lock, 2002). Students must maintain ongoing bi-directional communication with peers, and the vast amount of technology now available allows students to communicate through a variety of means. Communication between students facilitates the
127
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
formation of relationships and commonalities, thus “without effective communication, it is not possible to generate interaction, engagement, or alignment” (Lock, 2002, p. 397). Given the establishment of relationships, intimacy, and trust through effective pedagogical strategies, technology can be used to create an environment where people can engage in learning experiences that foster the development of community (Lock, 2002, p. 401). To foster an environment of trust, friendship, and respect, communication barriers associated with the academic, social, and technological elements need to be eliminated (Lock, 2002, p. 401). Some of the barriers to communication are infrequency of communication due to technological resources, response time for feedback, and lack of response to email or postings. Online instructors and/or mediators can help ensure better response rates to postings by OLC members by designing openended questions that emphasize student opinions and beliefs concerning the material being taught, rather than asking for the direct repetition of instructional material.
communication Media choices and Media behaviors Another important element of the online learning community is communication media choices and media behaviors. As online collaboration and interactivity proceeds, learners face many challenges due to the lack of face-to-face communications. The fading or blurry physical, temporal and psychological boundaries make it difficult for online learning. Appropriate selection and utilization of communication media may help learners better overcome some of the difficulties. It is very important, yet challenging to select and utilize appropriate media for collaborative, interactive learning and team development. Thus media research provides another lens to look into the dynamics of online learning community. Media richness and social presence theories are well-accepted rational theories that explain
128
media choices and media behaviors. Media richness theory (Daft & Lengel, 1984) measures the richness of media in terms of the capacity for immediate feedback, multiple cues, natural language and personal focus on voice tone and inflection. Media have varied capacities to reduce ambiguity and thus facilitate mutual understanding (Daft & Lengel, 1984). Richer medium facilitates more accurate and meaningful transmission and exchange of ideas. However, tasks of different types and complexity have different requirements for information richness in order to achieve maximal group performance. Some tasks require more information and richer medium than others for the best team performance. Social presence theory (Short, Williams, & Christie, 1976) measures media in terms of the degree to which they are perceived to convey the presence of an individual. The quantity of social presence is how much one believes another party is present. In communication, the psychological distance among communicating parties is referred to as immediacy (Wiener & Mehrabian, 1968). Thus there are two forms of immediacy: technological immediacy, and social immediacy. Technological immediacy is inherent while social immediacy can be changed (Heilbronn & Libby, 1973). Heilbronn and Libby (1973) write the maximum amount of exchanged information ensures technological immediacy, and social immediacy is conveyed through communications with verbal or non-verbal cues. Walther (1996, 1997) suggests that information and communications technology (ICT) is also able to convey social information, just as face-to-face communications, but with lower transfer rate. Walther (1995, 1996, 1997) has also found that ICT mediated groups have greater social discussion, depth, and intimacy than in face-to-face groups. In a review of social presence theory and studies on ICT-mediated communication, Gunawardena (1995) concludes that immediacy enhances social presence, which in turn enhances interactions. As related to online collaborative learning, it indicates that online teams, with assistance from
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
the instructor or an external moderator, should promote the use of media that better convey the notion of social presence in order to increase interactions among the members. As an example, the authors have noted that Facebook, an online social networking site, is one of the media applications that online group members often use to facilitate social interaction. Instructors may wish to propose that online group members use this and/or other utilities with which most students are already familiar to further social interaction and enhance trusting relationships.
concLusIon A learning community is actually a special learning environment, and an online learning community is a community based on a network through which members’ learning can be enhanced successfully. Technology is rapidly changing, and online learning communities are evolving as well. Inarguably online learning communities should maintain some level of the elements discussed in this review. Interactivity can be introduced through icebreakers and cultivated through the use of small student groups. Collaboration can be encouraged among students through both small group projects and real-time, chat-based discussions. Trusting relationships need to be forged between students, and the literature strongly suggests that trust in an online learning community is developed through social interaction. The ability to promote social interaction is also a major factor when choosing which types of communication media should be used within the online learning community. Those types of media that have higher levels of social immediacy will provide more opportunities for interaction among learners, thus enabling students to form a more cohesive community. Based on the literature, online learning provides community members an opportunity to collaborate and cooperate towards the community’s goal.
reFerences American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language. (1992). American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language. New York, NY: Houghton Mifflin Company. Aubert, B. and Kelsey, B. (2003). Further Understanding of Trust and Performance in Virtual Teams. Small Group Research, 34(5). Retrieved May 30, 2005, from EBSCOhost database. Bannan-Ritland, B. (2002). Computer-mediated communication, elearning, and interactivity: A review of the research. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3(2), 161–179. Bellah, R. N., Madsen, R., Sullivan, W. M., Swidler, A., & Tipton, S. M. (1985). Habits of the heart: Individualism and commitment in American life. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Berge, Z. L. (2002). Active, interactive, and reflective elearning. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3(2), 181–190. Bills, C. G. (1997). Effects of structure and interactivity on Internet-based instruction. Paper presented at the Interservice/Industry Training Simulation and Education Conference, Orlando, FL (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED416317). Boehlje, B. (1995). Share the Decision-Making. Education Digest, 60(7). Retrieved May 30, 2005, from EBSCOhost database. Brown, R. E. (2001). The process of communitybuilding in distance learning classes. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 5 (2). Retrieved May 31, 2002, from http://www.aln.org/alnweb/ journal/vol5_issue2/Brown/Brown.htm Ciardulli, L. (1998). Increasing student interaction in the distance learning classroom (or any other classroom). Technology Connection, 4(8), 8–10.
129
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
Conceicao, S. (2002). The sociocultural implications of learning and teaching in cyberspace. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 96, 37–45. doi:10.1002/ace.77
Fisher, M., & Colman, B. (2001-2002). Collaborative online learning in virtual discussions. Journal of Educational Technology Systems, 30(1), 3–17. doi:10.2190/CRDK-VNR8-43DX-V4DB
Cutler, R. H. (1995). Distributed presence and community in cyberspace, Interpersonal Computing and Technology: A Electronic Journal for the 21st Century, 3(2), 12-32. Retrieved July 21, 2004, from http://www.helsinki.fi/science/optek/1995/ n2/cutler.txt
Gunawardena, C. N. (1995). Social presence theory and implications for interaction and collaborative learning in computer conferences. International Journal of Educational Telecommunications, 1(2/3), 147–166.
Daft, R. L., & Lengel, R. H. (1984). Information richness: A new approach to managerial information processing and organization design. In B. Staw & L. Cummings (Eds.), Research in organizational behaviour 6 (pp. 191-233). Homewood, IL: JAI Press. Dolezak, H. (2003). Collaborating in cyberspace. Training (New York, N.Y.), 40(4), 32–37. Du, J., & Sun, L. (2007). Vygotsky’s theory of social interaction: Learning tasks, peer interaction, and cognition process. Journal of Open Education Research, 10(4), 17–23. Du, J., Zhang, K., Olinzock, A., & Adams, J. (2008). Graduate Students’ Perspectives on the Meaningful Nature of Online Discussions. Journal of Interactive Learning Research, 19(1), 21–36. Du, J. X., Durrington, V. A., & Mathews, J. G. (2007). Collaborative discussion: Myth or valuable learning tool. [JOLT]. Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 3(2), 94–104. Du, J. X., Durrington, V. A., & Olinzock, A. A. (2006). Dynamic online learning environment: Task-oriented interaction for deep learning. Open Education Research, 12(4), 75–79. Fernback, J. (1997). The individual within the collective: Virtual ideology and the realization of collective principles. In S. G. Jones (Ed.), Virtual culture (pp. 36-54). London: Sage.
130
Harasim, L., Calvert, T., & Groeneboer, C. (1997). Virtual-U: A web-based system to support collaborative learning, In. B.H. Kah (Ed.), Web-Based instruction (pp.149-158). Englewood-Cliffs, NJ: Educational Technology Publications, Inc. Haythornthwaite, C., Kazer, M. M., Robins, J., & Shoemaker, S. (2000). Community development among distance learners: temporal and technological dimensions. Journal of Computer Mediated Communication, 6 (1). Retrieved July 21, 2004, from http://www.ascusc.org/jcmc/vol6/issue1/ haythornthwaite.html Heilbronn, M., & Libby, W. L. (1973). Comparative effects of technological and social immediacy upon performance and perceptions during a two-person game. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the American Psychological Association, Montreal, Canada. Hill, J. R., Raven, A., & Han, S. (2002). Connections in web-based learning environments: a research-based model for community building. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3, 383–393. Hirumi, A. (2002). A framework for analyzing, designing, and sequencing planned elearning interactions. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3(2), 141–160. Jonassen, D., Peck, K., & Wilson, B. (1998). Creating technology-supported learning communities (On-line). Retrieved July 20, 2004, from http:// carbon.cudenver.edu/_bwilson/learncomm.html
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
Lock, J. V. (2002). Laying the groundwork for the development of learning communities within online courses. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3, 395–408.
Palloff, R. M., & Pratt, K. (1999). Building learning communities in cyberspace: Effective strategies for the online classroom. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers.
Looi, C.-K., & Ang, D. (2000). A multimediaenhanced collaborative learning environment. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 16, 2–13. doi:10.1046/j.1365-2729.2000.00111.x
Poole, D. M. (2000). Student participation in a discussion-oriented online course: a case study. Journal of Research on Computing in Education, 33, 162–177.
Lowell, N. O., & Persichitte, K. A. (2000). A virtual ropes course: creating online community. Asynchronous Learning Networks Magazine, 4(1). Retrieved July 23, 2004, from http://www.sloan-c. org/publications/magazine/v4n1/lowell.asp
Powers, S. M., & Mitchell, J. (1997). Student perceptions and performance in a virtual classroom environment. Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED409005).
Maor, D. (2003). The teacher’s role in developing interaction and reflection in an online learning community. Educational Media International, 40, 127–137. doi:10.1080/0952398032000092170
Preece, J. (2000). Online communities: Designing usability, support sociability. Chichester, UK: John Wiley & Sons, LTC.
McIsaac, M. S. (2002). Online learning from an international perspective. Educational Media International, 39(1), 18–21. doi:10.1080/09523980210131196 McMillan, D. W., & Chavis, D. M. (1986). Sense of community: A definition and theory. Journal of Community Psychology, 14(1), 6–23. doi:10.1002/1520-6629(198601)14:1<6::AIDJCOP2290140103>3.0.CO;2-I
Preece, J. (2003). Tacit knowledge and social capital: Supporting sociability in online communities of practice. In Proceedings of I-KNOW’03, 3rd International Conference on Knowledge Management, Graz, Austria, July 2-4. Retrieved July 20, 2004, from http://www.ifsm.umbc.edu/~preece/ Papers/Graz_KM_I_KNIW%2003.pdf Riel, M., & Fulton, K. (2001). The role of technology in supporting learning communities. Phi Delta Kappan, 82(7), 518.
Merriam-Webster Online Dictionary. (2004). Retrieved on July 22, 2004, from http://www.m-w. com/dictionary.htm
Romanoff, J. S. (2003). A case study: linking students across geographical and cultural distances. New Directions for Teaching and Learning, 94.
Misanchuk, M., & Anderson, T. (2000). Building community in an online learning environment: Communication, cooperation and collaboration (On-line). Retrieved July 20, 2004, from http:// www.mtsu.edu/~itconf/proceed01/19.html
Rovai, A. P. (2001). Building classroom community at a distance: A case study. Educational Technology Research and Development, 49(4), 33–48. doi:10.1007/BF02504946
Moller, L. (1998). Designing communities of learners for asynchronous distance education. Educational Technology Research and Development, 46(4), 115–122. doi:10.1007/BF02299678
Rovai, A. P. (2002). Building sense of community at a distance. International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 3(1), 1–16. Short, J., Williams, E., & Christie, B. (1976). The social psychology of telecommunications. New York: John Wiley & Sons.
131
The Key Elements of Online Learning Communities
Stepich, D. A., & Ertmer, P. A. (2003). Building community as a critical element of online course design. Educational Technology, 43(5), 33–43.
Westheimer, J., & Kahne, J. (1993). Building school communities: an experienced-based model. Phi Delta Kappan, 75(4), 324–328.
Tu, C., & Corry, M. (2002). eLearning communities. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3, 207–218.
Wiener, M., & Mehrabian, A. (1968). Language within language: Immediacy, a channel in verbal communication. New York: ApEpleton-CenturyCrofts.
Vrasidas, C., & McIssac, M. S. (1999). Factors influencing interaction in an online course. American Journal of Distance Education, 12(3), 22–36. Walther, J. B. (1995). Relational aspects of computer-mediated communications: Experimental observations over time. Organization Science, 6, 186–203. doi:10.1287/orsc.6.2.186 Walther, J. B. (1996). Computer-mediated communication: Impersonal, interpersonal and hyperpersonal interaction. Communication Research, 23(1), 3–43. doi:10.1177/009365096023001001 Walther, J. B. (1997). Group and interpersonal effects in international computer-mediated collaboration. Human Communication Research, 23, 342–369. doi:10.1111/j.1468-2958.1997. tb00400.x Wang, M., Poole, M., Harris, B., & Wangemann, P. (2001). Educational technology, promoting online collaborative Learning experiences for teenagers . Educational Media International, 203–215. doi:10.1080/09523980110105079 Wang, M., Sierra, C., & Folger, T. (2003). Building a dynamic online learning community among adult learners. Educational Media International, 40, 49–61. doi:10.1080/0952398032000092116
Yu, F. (2001). Competition within computerassisted cooperative learning environments: cognitive, affective, and social outcomes. Journal of Educational Computing Research, 24(2), 99–117. doi:10.2190/3U7R-DCD5-F6T1-QKRJ
Key terMs And deFInItIons Collaboration: Cooperation among members of a learning community who have a desire to pursue and achieve a common goal. Communication Media: A collective term for all channels or systems through which information is conveyed. Interactivity: Reciprocal communication between two or more people, the goal of which is to foster active learning and strengthen social bonds. Learning Community: A group of diverse individuals who develop a sense of trust and connectedness through interaction and collaboration. Trusting Relationship: A feeling between two or more individuals of reciprocal confidence.
This work was previously published in Handbook of Research on Practices and Outcomes in E-Learning: Issues and Trends, edited by H. Yang; S. Yuen, pp. 61-75, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
132
133
Chapter 1.10
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community Adams Bodomo University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong
AbstrAct
IntroductIon
It is demonstrated in this chapter that enhanced interactivity is the single most important reason why teachers should practice Web-based teaching and why students should be encouraged to construct Web-based learning communities. The notion of a conversational learning community (CLC) as a kind of constructivist learning environment is introduced. It is shown that instructional interactivity, defined as active communication in a conversational learning community between instructor(s), learners, course materials, and links to remote experts and resources, is a central aspect of the learning situation. A practical implementation of the CLC model is presented through describing the interactive features of a Web-based course using WebCT. It is concluded that Web-based learning and teaching actually enhances interactivity both within and beyond the classroom setting.
At the beginning of the 21st century, we are faced with an age of rapid technological development in information and communication. Issues of educational reform have never been more urgent than now. One of the major challenges is how to design our educational system in general, and our methods of instruction in particular, to produce graduates who are better prepared to take up jobs in a knowledgebased environment characterized by a pervasive use of information and communication technology (ICT). ICTs, especially modern digital ones, include various types of computers; digital cameras; local area networking; the Internet and the World Wide Web; CD-ROMs and DVDs; and applications such as word processors, spreadsheets, tutorials, simulations, e-mails, digital libraries, computer-mediated conferencing, videoconferencing, and virtual reality (Blurton, 1999). Four main features of these modern digital ICTs make them stand out as very useful educational tools. These are integration of multimedia, flexibility of use, connectivity, and interactivity (Blurton, 1999).
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-59904-525-2.ch007
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
The main focus of this chapter is an examination of just one of these features: interactivity. While interactivity has been a subject of considerable attention in the search for newer and more active methods of teaching and learning (Parker, 1999; Simms, 1999, 2000; Allen, 2003; Davies, 2005; Moreno & Valdez, 2005; Bodomo, 2006), there still remains a lot to be discussed as to how it can be enhanced in learning situations involving a mixture of Web-based course administration and face-to-face classroom instruction. It is quite clear that the introduction of ICTs into distance learning curricula is crucial in enhancing interactivity, given the situation where teacher and student are separated by distance. It is shown here, based on experiences with courses designed for both distance learners and traditional face-to-face classroom students where there is unity of time and unity of venue, that the use of the Web, one of the new digital ICTs enumerated above, along with other accessories and software that together give us what is termed Web-based teaching in a course, plays a crucial role in enhancing interactivity. The chapter is organized as follows. The section that follows defines interactivity and shows the important role it plays in constructive/active learning theories. In the third section, the main features of a course designed to achieve interactivity are described and it is shown how interaction was achieved. The fourth section of the chapter points to certain challenges that should be overcome to create more opportunities for enhancing interactivity in Web-based teaching in the future.
InterActIvIty And Its roLe In constructIve LeArnInG theorIes what is Interactivity? Studies that focus on interactivity include Daniel and Marquis (1983), Moore (1992), Wagner (1994), Markwood and Johnstone (1994),
134
Laurillard (1993), Barnard (1995), Moore and Kearsley (1996), Parker (1999), Simms (1999, 2000), Bodomo, Luke, and Anttila (2003), Allen (2003), Davies (2005), Moreno and Valdez (2005), and Bodomo (2006). The key concepts that run through most of these studies include ‘active learning’, ‘two-way communication’, ‘critical conversation’, and ‘transactional distance learning’ (Moore, 1993). All these contrast sharply with what would take place in traditional passive/ digestive lecture-type instruction. Moore (1992) offers three types, while Markwood and Johnstone (1994) provide four types of interactivity. In Moore’s typology we have learner-content, learner-instructor, and learnerlearner interactivity. Learner-content interactivity is illustrated by a student reading a book or a printed study guide (Parker, 1999). The interactivity or otherwise of the content is very much a function of how the material is structured and accessed. This point is crucial in deciding how best to place course notes on the Web. Instructor-learner interaction is the core of the teaching process. The success of the course design will depend largely on whether the conversation between teacher and learner is such that the learner can increase self-direction and construct new knowledge or not. Learnerlearner interaction involves students working together to discuss, debate, and attempt to solve problems that arise in their study of the course materials. Moore (1992) provides practitioners with a very useful framework to discuss how interactivity is achieved in teaching. Indeed, his notion of transactional distance theory (Moore, 1992, 1993, 1996) has contributed immensely in defining relations between participants, not only in a distance learning situation, but also in traditional face-to-face classroom learning situations. Markwood and Johnstone (1994, p. 94) describe interaction as the “silent, critical, creative conversation within the learner’s mind that is spurred and supported by the learning environment.” The study outlines four different types of interaction that trigger what it calls critical
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
conversation. The first is interaction with media where individual students scrutinize textbooks, videotapes, or any other course material. In the course to be discussed, this involves a major textbook supplemented by a number of other book sections and course notes. The second is interaction with resources. Here, individual students or groups may collaborate with tools such as those used by professionals, including word processors, electronic libraries, laboratories, and studios. The third type of interaction according to Markwood and Johnstone (1994) involves interaction with experts. This would mean students conversing with an instructor or other experts in real time. The last type of interaction is one of interaction through electronic exchange, with students electronically or digitally sharing the results of newly formed knowledge over a period of time (Markwood & Johnstone, 1994). Moore (1992) and Markwood and Johnstone (1994), along with more recent work such as Simms (2000), Allen (2003), and Davies (2005), provide a solid foundation on which to build an idea of interaction and draw up a typology of interaction within the larger framework of what we introduce here as a conversational learning community (CLC). In conceptualizing a CLC, we see the pedagogical process as taking place in an interactive conversational learning community. In this community, we have instructor(s), learners, course materials, and links to remote experts and resources. All these are the core components for the function of instructional interactivity in a CLC. Allen (2003) defines instructional interactivity as the interaction that actively stimulates the learner’s mind to do those things that improve ability and readiness to perform effectively. Interactivity is shown to be the single cementing factor that binds all the elements together in a CLC.
the role of Interaction in constructive/Active Learning theories Theories of learning within education and allied fields such as psychology and cognitive science have proliferated over the years. New pedagogical methods based on these theories are turning away from passive methods of teaching which require no action on the part of the student beyond listening and taking notes to interactive delivery methods which enable the student to control and manipulate the instructional environment. These active and interactive approaches to instruction may be situated within the framework of what may be called constructivist theories of learning. According to Blurton (1999, p. 9): “Modern constructivist education theory emphasizes critical thinking, problem solving, ‘authentic’ learning experiences, social negotiation of knowledge, and collaboration-pedagogical methods that change the role of the teacher from disseminator of information to learning facilitator.” Works like Piaget (1973), Duffy and Jonassen (1992), and Strauss (1994) illustrate such new pedagogical theories. So what is the role of interaction in these theories of learning? I will now briefly mention four of these theories which are considered to be the most relevant. They are the constructivist theory of Bruner, the conversation theory of Pask, Vygotsky’s social development theory, and of course, Moore’s transactional distance theory (Moore, 1993).
Bruner An exposition of the constructivist theory is contained in works of Bruner (1966, 1990). According to Keasley (1994-2003), a major theme in the theoretical framework of Bruner is that learning is an active process in which learners construct new ideas or concepts based upon their current/
135
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
past knowledge. The learner selects and transforms information, constructs hypotheses, and makes decisions, relying on a cognitive structure to do so. As far as instruction is concerned, the instructor should try and encourage students to discover principles by themselves. The instructor and student should engage in an active dialog (i.e., Socratic learning). The task of the instructor is to translate information to be learned into a format appropriate to the learner’s current state of understanding. The curriculum should be organized in a spiral manner so that the student continually builds upon what he or she has already learned. The role of interaction is fairly prominent in such a theoretical conceptualization. Once again, interactivist terms like ‘active process’ and ‘active dialogue’ come to the fore.
Vygotsky
Pask
Moore
The next theory that is of immediate relevance to an interactive approach to teaching is the Conversation Theory as contained in Pask (1975). The fundamental idea of the theory is that learning occurs through conversations about a subject matter which serve to make knowledge explicit. Conversations can be conducted at a number of different levels: natural language (general discussion), object languages (for discussing the subject matter), and meta-languages (for talking about learning/language). In order to facilitate learning, Pask argues that subject matter should be represented in the form of entailment structures that show what is to be learned. Entailment structures exist in a variety of different levels depending upon the extent of relationships displayed (e.g., super/subordinate concepts, analogies). The critical method of learning according to conversation theory is ‘teachback’ in which one person teaches another what they have learned. Pask identified two different types of learning strategies: serialists who progress through an entailment structure in a sequential fashion and holists who look for higher-order relations (Kearsley, 1994-2004).
The fourth theory is Moore’s notion of transactional distance theory (1992, 1993, 1996), which is very much relevant to distance education and attempts to explain the relations between participants in a distance learning situation. Transactional distance is defined to include the psychological and communicative space between learners and teachers. Moore (1993) highlights the issue of interaction, when he defines transactional distance within the context of interaction in a course as a function of dialogue, structure, and learner autonomy. Dialogue refers to teacher-student interaction, structure refers to how the program is designed, and according to Moore, as dialogue increases structure decreases—that is, as the interaction between learner(s) and teacher(s) increases, the teaching program’s structure of objectives, activities, and assessment decreases to accommodate learners’ need. In other words, learner autonomy leading to self-direction becomes a major fruit in interactive learning situations. With terms like ‘active dialogue’, ‘conversations about subject matter’, and ‘social interaction’ resonating across these theories, it is clear that
136
The third theory of much relevance to interactive approaches to learning is the Social Development Theory as conceptualized by Vygotsky (1962, 1978). The major theme of Vygotsky’s theoretical framework is that social interaction plays a fundamental role in the development of cognition. Another aspect of Vygotsky’s theory is the idea that the potential for cognitive development is limited to a certain time span which he calls the “zone of proximal development” (ZPD). Furthermore, full development during the ZPD depends upon full social interaction. The range of skills that can be developed with adult guidance or peer collaboration exceeds what can be attained alone (Kearsley, 1994-2004).
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
interactivity has a central role to play in these theories of learning, which may all be grouped under the general framework/paradigm of constructivist methods of learning as described above. Indeed these four theories may be seen as forming a useful foundation for the idea of a conversational learning community that we evolve as a conceptual framework for designing Web-based courses. Terms like ‘active dialogue’, ‘conversations about subject matter’ and ‘social interaction’ do form the core of what we may term a conversation learning theory (Figure 1). The main idea of a conversation learning theory is that enhanced interactivity, whether face-to-face or from a distance, such as online instruction, would lead to an effective reciprocal, two-way communication within the learning situation. This enhanced communication is the backbone for the efficient exploitation of the resources, experts, and links by both instructor and learners within the learning community.
A descrIPtIon oF the desIGn oF A web-bAsed course In the last sections, a number of issues, including the need to use ICT in education, Web-based teaching, and interactivity and its role in constructivist learning and teaching methods, have been addressed. This section of the chapter constitutes a description of a specific course within my Webbased teaching program, and how interactivity was achieved in the course design.
choosing a web-based course tool In deciding to do Web-based teaching or facilitate Web-based learning, course designers have, at least, two options. They can choose to develop their own tools or they can choose from the repertoire of many course tools called asynchronous Web-based software suites (Jackson, 1999-2004) that are already available on the market.
As an illustration of interactivity, I now concentrate on describing just one course on the relationship between language and literacy. The course is titled “Language and Literacy in the Information Age” (Bodomo, 1999-2004).
webct design of a course on Language and Literacy The language and literacy course is a one–semester, six-credit course for second- and third-year students of linguistics and related disciplines. Class meetings are conducted in the form of lectures, complemented by a WebCT course platform and face-to-face tutorials. In terms of course content, it usually begins with an attempt to introduce the students (usually about 20-30 in number) to the concept of ‘literacy’. The course materials, lectures, and tutorials are designed in such a way that students are supposed to discover for themselves that the concept literacy is not limited to just the ability to read and write. Students are supposed to discover for themselves the various linguistic, cognitive, social, and educational issues surrounding the concept. Students are encouraged to gain an understanding of the role of language and literacy in the socio-economic development efforts of many societies through various activities such as discussions, debates, classroom presentation, tutorials, fieldtrips, interview of resource persons, and so forth.
how Interaction was Achieved in the course In this subsection, an attempt is made to explain how interaction was achieved in a class. This begins with the creation of a learning community. The course design, whether in the form of face-to-face classroom lectures or WebCT course page activities like discussion and presentations, is guided by the conceptual notion of a conversational learning community, comprising instructor(s), learners, current resources, and remote experts and resources.
137
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
Figure 1. Conversation learning theory licenses a conversation learning community
The first task then in the course administration is often to get the group of about 20-30 students to communicate and interact with each other and create a sense of community. The first exercise towards this goal is often in the form of Internet search. The excerpt from the course displayed in Table 1 explains the exercise:
An exercise for building up a Learning community Students are asked to look up important concepts in the course like ‘literacy’ and ‘language’ on the Web and present their findings to the whole class in the lecture the following week. After hearing students’ reports on their findings, the course instructor and teaching assistant would pick up a number of issues from these student presentations and initiate both an in-class debate and later on some postings on the WebCT bulletin board to 138
encourage participation from students who are less active in lectures. This exercise is meant to encourage students to create both physical and electronic networking among each other, and it often succeeds to a large extent because it has been noticed that later groups to be formed in the class often reflect this earlier grouping. In addition, this exercise often leads to follow-up discussions in small groups during the first two weeks. Following this exercise, students are also encouraged to create a sense of community through sharing their research findings with their classmates by using the ‘student homepages’ tool. In addition to sharing their findings, many students actually made available information about themselves which enabled their fellows to get to know their study interests and specializations. This helped strengthen the community of partnerships in learning.
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
Table 1. LING2011: Reading Assignment/Homework: 1. Literacy Information Mining on the Web: Students should form groups of 2-3 people. Each group should search the World Wide Web with key words ‘literacy’, ‘language’, (and combinations of these) and choose 10 sites. These sites should be analyzed with a view to finding out what literacy is and what common issues are discussed concerning language and literacy courses. Each group of students should spend five minutes in the next lecture explaining how their understanding of literacy has been affected by these 10 Web sites.
Once this sense of community is created, the rest of the instructional activities aim to consolidate and strengthen it, developing it into a real conversational learning community. This is done both through face-to-face classroom activities and WebCT design activities. Surprisingly, greater and more sustained aspects of the interaction between students often take place on the WebCT homepage for this course. In the next subsection, some of the main features and resources of this tool will be described, showing what kinds of interactivity take place and how.
some Interactive webct Features of the course WebCT interactive tools include modules such as ‘Contents’, ‘Glossary’, ‘Bulletin Board’, ‘Student Homepages’, and ‘Quiz’. We provide below brief descriptions of some of the interactive modules, showing what activities are deployed in each case.
contents with Glossary definitions The contents with glossary definitions module of WebCT serves as a kind of online dictionary for the students. Terminologies and other technical phrases on language and literacy easily pile up even at the very beginning of the course, and they are very crucial for a sustainable comprehension of the subject matter. This aspect of the course tool thus comes in handy, as the teacher can often use it to outline and define some of the most important terminologies for each topic. Students are asked
to regularly refer to this site as they read through the lecture notes. The reading then is more active than would otherwise be the case.
Links to useful references The links feature of WebCT allows a course developer to make useful pointers to various Web sites that are of relevance to the course, for instance, Literacy Online. This issue of making links implements the conceptual notion of having remote resources as part of the conversational learning community that we create, illustrating learner-resource interaction, one of the types of interactivity we noted earlier.
Student Access Statistics The Student Access Statistics feature is a very valuable aspect of WebCT in terms of helping the teacher to track and manage student progress. Each time new course material is posted on the Web, the teacher may demand that students read the material before the next scheduled class. Before the start of the class, the teacher may log on to assess how many students have already accessed and, presumably, read the material. This can be gauged by looking at the number of students logging on and also by what pages they visited. Indeed, one could even have an idea of which particular students accessed the material and their frequency of access. It turned out, however, that sometimes actually more students had accessed the pages than the access statistics indicated. Some students simply asked their friends to download
139
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
copies of the material for them without they themselves accessing the material from their own accounts! One way to solve this problem, if it is thought of as such, is for the teacher to actively discourage this oblique access to the course material on the Web.
Discussion Forum WebCT’s Bulletin Board and Presentation features together provide a useful discussion forum for participants in the language and literacy course. This is indeed the most useful feature with respect to incorporating interactivity (both teacher-learner and learner-learner interactions) in the course. Through the bulletin board, one can readily send information to the class and to individual students about the course. These include reminders of deadlines for assignments, clarifications about specific points, and pointers to any errata in the course notes. Students, on the other hand, can use this forum to ask the teacher questions on aspects of the course and to post general messages to other students on the course. Groups of students can use the presentation forum to upload and discuss a topic, which they may subsequently write up and present to the whole class.
one think that, from an instructor’s point of view, interactivity has been achieved in the course. From an instructor’s point of view, certain features of communication and academic activity, if they are part and parcel of a course, would serve to indicate that the teaching endeavor is successful. Three of these features include critical thinking, initiative on the part of students, and academic rigor.
Critical Thinking
oPPortunItIes And chALLenGes For the Future
It was noticed that as time went on, not only were students more forthcoming in discussing and interacting with the teacher and with their fellow classmates, they were also becoming more critical in their thinking. At certain points during the course, students were beginning to question and argue some of the points from the teacher and from their fellow classmates. Sometimes, an issue is presented with regards to the definition and conceptualization of literacy, and how it relates to language and students are then asked to evaluate these views by applying them to the Hong Kong situation and, indeed, other situations that they know. We may consider critical thinking within the conversational learning community as a strong indicator of the success of interactivity in the learning situation. This may be compared with Markwood and Johnstone’s (1994) idea of critical conversation.
opportunities
Initiative
The foregoing has outlined how a course can be designed on WebCT so as to enhance interactivity, a crucial element in a conversational learning community and indeed in any other effective learning situation. A possible question to ask then is how successful the design was. Success, failure, and other issues of evaluation are difficult to measure accurately. They may be from the point of view of the instructor or the student. In the following, we briefly point to some qualitative features that make
Another indicator of success with regards to the learning situation is initiative on the part of students. Halfway through the course, students did often introduce their own topics of discussion and techniques of information gathering and processing. In our knowledge-based economy, innovation has become a crucial element of an efficient workforce. Initiative is an essential element of innovation, and the pedagogical process should aim at promoting it. This may be compared
140
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
to Moore’s (1993) ideas of learner autonomy and self-direction, which are products of a successful interactive learning course.
Academic Rigor A third measure of the fact that the class achieved an enhanced constant interaction was the academic rigor noticed in the essays that many of the students wrote. Students were often generally very knowledgeable about the different shades of opinions regarding a particular technical issue. Indeed, some students even began to question some aspects of the textbooks against the realities of the Hong Kong situation that they know best. In the course evaluation at the end of the semester, comments and feedback generally point to a positive appraisal of the element of enhanced interactivity in the Web-based learning process.
challenges In the course of Web-based design of the course on Language and Literacy in the Information Age and indeed other courses, a number of issues such as low interactivity at the beginning of the course were experienced. Rather than perceiving them as debilitating problems and obstacles, one should consider them as challenges to be overcome towards an improvement of Web-based teaching.
Low Written Interaction at the Beginning Described above are some initial steps taken to ask students to form groups and begin interacting with each other. It is, however, often difficult to get them to start writing and sending messages of discussion on the bulletin board. Indeed some students never post a single message throughout the course, though they may keep reading every bit of discussion going on. Several posts were often made without any responses. In these posts, questions are asked, and students are exhorted to start making use of the
forum. The interesting aspect here is that it takes just a few students to begin and most come on board. In extreme situations of low participation, students are reminded that active participation counts towards the coursework mark.
suMMAry And concLusIon This chapter has attempted to demonstrate that instructional interactivity is an essential aspect of student-centered course design endeavors, whether in traditional face-to-face classrooms or by distance learning. Society seems to require universities and other learning institutions to produce graduates who are creative thinkers and problem solvers, graduates who are literate enough to function well in a knowledge-based economy where there is a pervasive use of ICTs. To achieve this educational goal, we need to reform our methods of instruction, moving away from more passive methods of teaching to more active and interactive methods. Based on many years of Web-based course design and delivery, this chapter has proposed some ways of designing more interactive courses. Basically, teachers ought to construe their learning environment as one of conversation between instructor and learner. Important components in this environment include instructor(s), learners, course materials, and links to remote experts and resources. All these components are glued together by instructional interactivity. Three types of instructional interactivity ought to be recognized. These are instructor-learner, learnerlearner, and learner-resource interactivity. While there still remain some challenges, it has been shown that by doing interactive Webbased teaching, many positive things such as critical thinking, initiative, and academic rigor may be achieved. We may conclude that instructional interactivity on the Web seems to enhance even traditional classroom and tutorial sessions. Interactive Web-based teaching allows teachers
141
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
to achieve a better management of the course. This issue is relevant for both distance education, such as on cyberspace, and traditional classroom teaching. Interactivity thus has the potential of rendering the gap between traditional face-toface classroom education and distance education redundant. Distance would no more have to be defined in terms of just space, but in terms of the presence and absence of interactivity.
reFerences Allen, M. W. (2003). Michael Allen’s guide to elearning: Building interactive, fun, and effective learning programs for any company. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons. Barnard, R. (1995). Interactive learning: A key to successful distance delivery. American Journal of Multimedia, 12, 45–47. Blurton, C. (1999). New directions of ICT-use in education. UNESCO’s World Communication and Information Report 1999. Retrieved from http://www.unesco.org/education/educprog/lwf/ dl/edict.pdf
Bruner, J. (1990). Acts of meaning. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Daniel, J., & Marquis, C. (1983). Independence and interaction: Getting the mix right. Teaching at a Distance, 15, 445–460. Davies, K. (2005). Relating instructional interactivity to adult learner satisfaction and subsequent retention/persistence in postsecondary online courses: A case study analysis. PhD Dissertation, Capella University, USA. Duffy, T., & Jonassen, D. H. (1992). Constructivism and the technology of instruction: A conversation. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Jackson, R. H. (1999-2004). Web-based learning resources library. Retrieved from http://www. knowledgeability.biz/weblearning/ Kearsley, G. (1994-2004). Explorations in learning & instruction: Theory in practice database. Retrieved from http://tip.psychology.org Laurillard, D. (1993). Rethinking university teaching: A framework for the effective use of educational technology. London: Routledge.
Bodomo, A. B. (2006). Interactivity in Web-based learning. International Journal of Web-Based Learning and Teaching Technologies, 1(2), 18–30.
Markwood, R., & Johnstone, S. (1994). New pathways to a degree: Technology opens the college. Western Cooperative for Educational Telecommunications, Western Interstate Commission for Higher Education, USA.
Bodomo, A. B. (1999-2004). Language and Literacy in the Information Age, WebCT course homepage. Retrieved from http://ecourse.hku. hk:8900/public/LING2011
Moore, M. (1992). Three types of interaction. American Journal of Distance Education, 3(2), 1–6.
Bodomo, A. B., Luke, K. K., & Anttila, A. (2003). Evaluating interactivity in Web-based learning. Global E-Journal of Open, Flexible and Distance Education, III. Retrieved from http://www.ignou. ac.in/e-journal/ContentIII/Adamsbodomo.htm Bruner, J. (1966). Toward a theory of instruction. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
142
Moore, M. (1993). Theory of transactional distance. In D. Keegan (Ed.), Theoretical principles of distance education. London/New York: Routledge. Moore, M., & Kearsley, G. (1996). Distance education: A systems view. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth.
Instructional Interactivity in a Web-Based Learning Community
Moreno, R., & Valdez, A. (2005). Cognitive load and learning effects of having students organize pictures and words in multimedia environments: The role of interactivity and feedback. Educational Technology Research and Development, 53(3), 35–45. doi:10.1007/BF02504796 Parker, A. (1999). Interaction in distance education: The critical conversation. Educational Technology Review, 13. Pask, G. (1975). Conversation, cognition, and learning. New York: Elsevier. Piaget, J. (1973). To understand is to invent. New York: Grossman. Simms, R. (1999). Interactivity on stage: Strategies for learner-design communication. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 15(3), 257–272.
Simms, R. (2000). An interactive conundrum: Constructs of interactivity and learning theory. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 16(1), 45–57. Strauss, M. J. (1994). A constructivist dialogue. The Journal of Humanistic Education and Development, 32(4), 183–187. Vygotsky, L. S. (1962). Thought and language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Wagner, J. (1994). Learning from a distance. International Journal of Multimedia, 19(2), 12–20.
This work was previously published in Web-Based Education and Pedagogical Technologies: Solutions for Learning Applications, edited by L. Esnault pp. 121-136, copyright 2008 by IGI Publishing (an imprint of IGI Global).
143
144
Chapter 1.11
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education Victor M. Hernández-Gantes University of South Florida, USA
AbstrAct Online education is becoming an important component of career and technical education (CTE) in teacher preparation and at the graduate level. In the midst of such growth, and in response to questions about quality compared with traditional learning, there is a consensus that online courses and programs should be designed based on the needs of adult learners. However, much of the literature in online CTE lacks implicit connections to emerging notions of adult development and learning. This article provides an overview of the status of online education in CTE at the postsecondary level, discusses related issues and current research focus, and highlights adult learning developments and the implications for curriculum design, instruction, and use of technology. The article concludes with an outline of emerging trends bridging adult learning and
online education relevant to career and technical education.
IntroductIon Online education enrollments in higher education over the past decade are revealing. The online instructional delivery system is no longer an afterthought for postsecondary institutions as students are enrolling in related programs at higher rates compared to enrollments in traditional education. Practically all institutions of higher education now offer online education opportunities to meet the demand from students seeking alternatives to traditional on campus instruction (Allen & Seaman, 2008). Career and technical education (CTE) is no exception to this trend as the field has experienced similar growth at the undergraduate and graduate education level including doctoral programs (Flowers & Baltzer, 2006b; Havice
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
& Havice, 2005). However, as online education continues to grow, there are lingering concerns about the quality of curriculum and instruction, student experiences, and use of technology (Hernandez, Kirby, & McGee, 2004; Flowers, 2001; Kim & Bonk, 2006). Furthermore, although the adult population is the target audience for CTE in teacher preparation and graduate degree programs, there is limited literature examining the connections to adult development and learning principles. Much of the literature focuses on demand for online education, related curriculum and program development, and perceptions about quality and barriers and opportunities for adoption (Flowers, 2005; Flowers & Baltzer, 2006b; Schmidt & Gallegos, 2001). As such, there is a need for an examination of adult learning principles in the context of online education and the implications for curriculum development, teaching, and use of technology. To this end, the objectives of this article are to: First, review the status of online education with an emphasis in career and technical education and related issues for adoption; second, highlight adult learning developments with potential to inform curriculum design and instruction; third, outline implications on the use of instructional technology; and fourth, point out emerging trends bridging adult learning and online education relevant to CTE efforts in this area.
bAcKGround Online education is often used interchangeable with other terms such as distance education, virtual learning, Web-based learning, distributed learning and other variations associated with teaching and learning whereby instructors and students are not interacting in the same location in real time. In this context, distance education represents a larger umbrella including a wide array of formal and informal strategies bridging physical separation between instructors and students (King, 2008). In turn, online education
represents a formal asynchronous instructional system offered by educational institutions through courses and entire programs. Online education is characterized by the use of communication networks building upon varying combinations of online technology such as the Internet, electronic libraries, Web-based conferencing, virtual discussions, and e-mail communication. Typically, the delivery of online education is organized through a Web-based management system (e.g., Blackboard, WebCT) with many variations in delivery and support services depending on institutional resources and the nature of individual courses (e.g., size of student enrollment) (Aragon, 2003; Conrad, 2008; Paloff & Pratt, 2001). Formal online education opportunities for adults are offered in higher education, often referred to as post-secondary or tertiary education, and may be available in formal and informal settings after high school. Although the term “higher education” is often associated with universities and colleges, it is in fact a broader term including formal programs leading to credentialing at community colleges as well as baccalaureate and graduate degrees granted by private and public universities (Clark, 1983). Similarly, while career and technical education (CTE) is often associated with programs at the secondary education level, it is also a prominent component of higher education. At the post-secondary level, CTE contributes with programs and services designed to help adult students promote their career development and transition into specific occupations or further education. Informal programs are also available in community and corporate settings for technical training and re-training purposes. Teacher preparation programs and opportunities for professional advancement through master’s degrees and doctoral programs are available at universities, while technical preparation and entry-level occupational credentialing are offered at two-year colleges (Athanasou, 2008; Hernández-Gantes & Blank, 2009; Johnson & Benson, 2003). Thus, the focus of this article is on reviewing issues relevant to
145
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
teaching adult learners in online CTE programs in higher education.
current Issues And reseArch Focus As online education continues to grow, it is important to review online learning trends and issues related to adoption in CTE, bridging adult learning developments with curriculum design and instruction, and implications for using instructional technology. online education Growth The formal beginnings of distance education date back to the late 1800s, born out of the necessity to overcome geographical distances and provide educational access to rural students (Banas & Emory, 1998). Initially rooted in programmed instruction through correspondence courses, distance education experienced a booming renewal with the advent of computers and the Internet. Today, while correspondence methods still remain in use, contemporary distance education has shifted to more extensive use of instructional technology to develop and deliver courses and programs in a variety of formats from text to virtual interactive activities (Johnson & Benson, 2003). In the past two decades, the development of related instructional technologies has been dramatic and the demand for distance learning has consistently increased during this period as people seek flexible learning opportunities (Allen & Seaman, 2008; Havice & Havice, 2005; National Center for Education Statistics, 2000). Under the umbrella of distance education, online learning emerged based on the prominent use of computer technologies and the Internet. As such, online education is also referred to electronic learning (or e-learning), Web-based instruction, and virtual learning. At the core of online education is the fact that students can have access to instructional resources anytime, anywhere, and engage with the material at their convenience (Conrad, 2008;
146
Lorenzetti, 2003). These underlying features of “online” learning have appealed to young and older adults seeking professional advancement through flexible educational opportunities in higher education, CTE included (Flowers, 2005; National Center for Education Statistics, 2002). In general, compared to student enrollment in traditional programs, online student enrollments have continued to grow substantially in recent years. The sixth report of the Sloan Consortium on the status of online learning in higher education indicated that about 20% of all higher education students were enrolled in at least one online course in the fall of 2006. This figure represents over a 12% increase compared to 1.2% increase in the overall higher education student population (Allen & Seaman, 2008). This dramatic growth has been well documented also noting the increase in the number of programs offered by postsecondary institutions with growth as high as 70% in a single year reported in the 1990s (National Center for Education Statistics, 2000). Although the growth in higher education, as a whole, has been steady, 2-year colleges have shown greater growth rates in online education compared to baccalaureate institutions. Overall, the demand for online education is expected to continue growing, though at a less dramatic pace, as current efforts are expanded and new institutions respond to related demand (Allen & Seaman, 2008). Although comprehensive data is not available to gauge the full extent of enrollments in CTE, there is emerging evidence of growth mirroring that of national trends (Flowers, 2005; Johnson & Benson, 2003). Community colleges have shown an increase in enrollments due to the expansion of distance learning programs in various occupational areas (Johnson & Benson, 2003). Similar growth has been reported in the broader field of career and technical education including teacher preparation programs and in graduate education including doctoral level programs (Baltzer, Lazaros, & Flowers, 2007; Flowers, 2005; Flowers & Baltzer, 2006a, 2006b). In general, it has been
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
reported that at the master’s degree level, face-toface enrollments have tended to decrease as new online courses have begun to attract many more students (Blank & Hernandez, 2008; Flowers, 2005). In turn, at the doctoral level, online courses are available and entire programs may become available in the future. At this time about a third of doctoral programs in the field have indicated the possibility of evolving into online models or are already in their way to do so (Baltzer et al., 2007; Blank & Hernandez, 2008; Flowers & Baltzer, 2006b). The demand for online education has been fueled by individuals seeking professional advancement who are most likely to be married, have dependents, and are employed full-time. These students are also most likely to seek flexible programs on a part-time basis (National Center for Education Statistics, 2002). For such students the flexibility of online education is the only way to earn a degree as they factor in issues of time, physical location, family, and work demands. These trends are also reported in graduate programs in CTE (see Blank & Hernandez, 2008; Flowers, 2005). Lingering Issues As online learning continues to grow at all levels in higher education, CTE included, there are still some lingering issues about overall quality, instructor-related factors, use of technology, and nature of online learning experiences compared to traditional education (Kim & Bonk, 2006). The first issue persistently cited in the literature is the perception that online education, compared to traditional instruction, is of inferior quality. This perception ranges from traditional views on education regarding classroom instruction as the only appropriate setting for teaching and learning, to legitimate questions about the quality of online instructional approaches (Baltzer et al., 2007; Bower, 2001). In CTE such perceptions have elicited a warning to program graduates
about how potential employers may perceive a degree earned primarily online (Flowers & Baltzer, 2006b). In some cases such concerns may be reinforced by the limited evidence of online student performance compared to counterparts in equivalent traditional courses (Ryan, 2000). To be sure, there is positive evidence of impact on higher engagement and motivation, increased collaboration, and extended access to students who may have not otherwise enrolled or completed a program of study. Some reports have indicated that student performance is relatively equivalent when comparing technology-mediated and classroom instruction, although the nature of related research has raised questions about the generalizations of the findings (Johnson & Benson, 2003; Kim & Bonk, 2006; Phipps & Merisotis, 1999; Ryan, 2000; Zirkle, 2002). Albeit the inconclusiveness of available data, emerging evidence appears to suggest that the general quality of online education is really a secondary issue. What matters is the quality of specific instructional strategies and materials, much like in traditional education, pointing to design and development issues (Stilborne & Williams, 1996). During the rush to join the bandwagon of online education, there has been widespread variability in the quality of courses and programs available online. The pressure to develop courses and programs in a short period of time regardless of the unique design and development requirements may contribute to the varying quality of online courses as well (Aragon, 2003; Zirkle, 2002). To ensure quality of online courses, participating instructors need sufficient time for design and development of online courses and programs, and sometimes such accommodations are not in place (Lorenzetti, 2003). This, in turn, brings instructor-related factors into the discussion as institutions ask faculty to convert courses online even though they may not be well prepared or—worse yet—may not believe in the value of online education to participate effectively in related efforts (Flowers & Baltzer, 2006a).
147
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
Since every institution is bound to have instructors resisting participation in online education for related reasons, resentment and low morale are often the results of forced participation. This situation has prompted calls to rethink faculty supports and reassess how to consider participation in online instructional efforts for tenure and promotion evaluations given the unique demands of such work (Baltzer et al., 2007; Bower, 2001; Hernandez et al., 2004; Flowers, 2005). Another issue stemming perhaps from the push to put courses online, compounded by concerns about appropriate instructors’ preparation, is reliance on design and development strategies building upon sets of documents, lectures, and PowerPoint presentations void of interactive or meaningful connecting activities (Bower, 2001; Stilborne & Williams, 1996). At the other extreme are courses featuring all the “bells and whistles” of technology without regard to practical and pedagogical considerations. In both cases, the limited use of technology in the former case and the over-use in the latter case, the facilitation of learning may be hindered in the absence of explicit pedagogical connections and further complicated by technology compatibility issues or distracting technical glitches (Palloff & Pratt, 2001; Partlow & Gibbs, 2003). At the core of this issue is the tendency to focus more on the selection and management of resources and use of technology to teach online, rather than the actual design of instructional strategies appropriate for online delivery (Flowers, 2005). Thus, another lingering issue has been the challenge to facilitate productive interactions among students and between students and instructors. Traditional instructors have argued that such interactions, often taken for granted in the traditional classroom, are difficult to reproduce in an online environment. Critics are also quick to note that students may be left wandering in online courses under the so-called premises of self-paced learning (Kirschner, Sweller, & Clark, 2006; Rovai, 2001; Schmidt & Gallegos, 2001).
148
Research Focus in Online CTE In the midst of the steady growth of online education and the lingering issues noted above, available research in CTE has been limited in relation to the general body of knowledge in other fields (Zirkle, 2002). Much of the research focus in CTE contexts has been on descriptive studies of institutional efforts to promote and develop online programs. This includes studies on barriers for placing programs online, instructor-related research looking into issues of participation in design and implementation efforts, and assessments of student satisfaction in higher education programs at both undergraduate and graduate level (Flowers, 2005; Sloan-C, 2009; Zirkle, 2002). As such, some researchers have suggested it is time to shift from an emphasis on institutional factors and online course development and management to the study of pedagogical strategies and student experiences that maximize online learning. As online education continues to grow in CTE, the quality of online pedagogical strategies appropriate to adult learners in higher education is a critical issue that needs to be addressed. While, there is evidence dispelling the perceived lack of interactions in online education as well as questions about self-regulated learning (Kirschner et al., 2006; Rovai, 2001; Schmidt & Gallegos, 2001), researchers agreed that it is imperative to study new ways of designing learning experiences that are appropriate for online delivery (Aragon, 2003; Flowers, 2001; Hirumi, 2002). Another important component of the suggested shift in research focus is the apparent void in the literature bridging adult education principles and online learning. While there is research exploring the connections between adult learning principles and online pedagogical strategies stemming from adult education, related literature and focus has yet to be integrated into parallel lines of research in CTE contexts. The bulk of the literature in online CTE contexts does not make explicit connections to adult education principles, which appears to
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
be taken for granted. For the most part, current literature reflects an emphasis on the management of learning experiences and mediation of delivery through technology (Flowers, 2001, 2005; Zirkle, 2002).
brIdGInG AduLt LeArnInG And onLIne cte Promising theoretical conceptions of how people learn including transformative learning, contextual teaching and learning principles and holistic views on adult development and learning have emerged over the past decade (Hoare, 2006; Merriam, 2001b, 2008). The challenge for instructors is to bridge emerging theoretical conceptions of adult teaching and learning and online instructional environments. A brief description of recent developments in adult learning is presented in this section along with implications for curriculum design and development, instructional strategies, and use of technology with potential to inform online CTE. emerging developments in Adult Learning theory Historically, adult development and learning have coexisted as separate, albeit complementary, fields of study. The development dimension has been typically treated under the field of psychology, while learning has been usually addressed in educational research (Hoare, 2006). This artificial divide may stem from the traditional view of adult development as progressive age stages, which in turn is associated with the development of experience (i.e., ways of knowing). Under this worldview to understanding how adults develop and learn, andragogy has been a prominent learning theory used in adult education based on the premise of stages of development and noting the unique characteristics of adults compared to children (Knowles, 1980; Merriam, 2001a). Over the past two decades, however, emerging developments in related theoretical and practical
teaching and learning conceptions have noted the inclusive interface of adult development and learning (Hoare, 2006; Merriam, 2008). Building upon notions of how people learn, it is becoming clear the relationship between adult development and learning must be understood and taken into consideration when designing teaching and learning strategies. To this end, contextual learning, self-directed learning, and transformational learning have been consistently highlighted in adult education as promising conceptions of teaching and learning with potential to inform online curriculum development and instruction (Partlow & Gibbs, 2003; Roschelle, 1999; Taylor, 2007). Andragogy as an Initial Frame of reference Andragogy is a theory of adult education advocating a learner-centered approach to teaching introduced in the 1970s underlined by five major premises. At the core of the andragogy is the idea of adult learners as mature individuals with a clear identity of who they are and capable of self-regulated learning (Knowles, 1980; Merriam, 2001a). The premise is that adults have moved from a younger stage of development where extrinsic motivation and guided learning were the norm. The challenge for instructors is to promote autonomous learning while recognizing individual differences and stages of development (Cercone, 2008; Cooper & Henschke, 2003; Knowles, 1980). Another important premise is the role of prior knowledge in adult learning suggesting that students learn best when they are provided the opportunity to build on what they know and can do (Fidishun, 2000). Andragogy also relies on the premise that adults are more likely to be goal oriented and will perform better when content relevancy is high and clearly aligned with personal goals. In this case, the instructor’s goal should be to ensure relevant meaning and connections between new concepts and students’ frame of reference (Cercone, 2008; Merriam, 2001a). Further, andragogy assumes that adult learners will respond better to instruction
149
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
that is designed to provide practical applications as a means to reinforce the above premises (Fidishun, 2000; Knowles, 1980). Finally, intrinsic motivation to learn is recognized as the driving force in adults who will respond better when they feel their individual needs are met and it is safe to participate in group discourse and collaborate with others (Cercone, 2008; Taylor, King, PinsentJohnson, & Lothian, 2003). Although useful in many ways, some researchers argued that the premises underlying andragogy represent a model for teaching adults rather than a theory (Hoare, 2006; Merriam, 2001a). A key limitation of andragogy is that it overlooks the role of the learning context and the interface with background variables such as culture, gender, and experience beyond the mere fact of being classified as an adult. Thus, it does not consider multiple ways of knowing and learning and the important role for critical reflection as part of the adult learning process (Taylor, 2007; Tsao, Takahasi, Olusesu, & Jain, 2006). With all its limitations, andragogy clearly defined what makes adult learners different and served as the root for useful concepts such as student-centered learning, prior learning, and content relevancy as factors that matter for adult learners (Cooper & Henschke, 2003; Fidishun, 2000; Merriam, 2001a). In this context, and building upon such concepts, emerging literature in adult development and learning suggests promising implications of constructivist strategies for teaching and learning in online environments. rethinking Adult development and Learning Recognizing the complexity of adult learning, everyone agrees that there is no such thing as a comprehensive adult learning theory that can be applied to all learning situations (Hoare, 2006, Merriam, 2008; Taylor, 2007). Thus, constructivist theoretical conceptions have received greater attention in recent years given their emphasis on both the learners’ characteristics and their worldviews
150
facilitated through contextual and self-regulated instructional strategies. Experiential learning, contextual teaching and learning, self-regulated learning, and transformational learning appear to carry promising implications for online adult learning (Cercone, 2008; Merriam, 2008). For instance, experiential learning suggests that when teaching adults, learning is a product of meaningful connections between new concepts and what the learners already know (i.e., experience) (Itin, 1999). Thus, experiential learning emphasizes clear identification of new knowledge and information, connections to relevant prior knowledge, and critical analysis of learning experiences. In turn, contextual teaching and learning stems from the body of knowledge on the role of context as a meaning-making factor in the learning process. When learners engage in activities featuring realworld situations they can relate to by virtue of their prior knowledge and experience, culture, and other personal and professional variables, expertise is reinforced and further developed (Bransford, Brown, & Cocking, 2000; Itin, 1999; Kolb, 1984). Consequently, contextual teaching and learning emphasizes teaching for understanding through relevant tasks requiring active learning (Bransford et al., 2000, Hernández-Gantes & Blank, 2009; Perkins, 1993). Self-directed learning has also emerged as another important theoretical concept when teaching adult learners. At the root of this concept is the idea that learning should be intrinsically motivated and as such, adult learners should take responsibility for their own learning although some may require different levels of external assistance (Merriam, 2008; Taylor, 2006). Selfdirected learning is typically associated with goal-oriented strategies which in the past had been mostly relegated to informal learning. Today, the concept of self-regulated learning offers promising applications in online learning environments where independent learning is promoted and expected of adult learners. Self-directed learning is at the core of lifelong learning bridging ways of
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
knowing, experience, and intrinsic motivation to learn in adult development (Taylor, 2006). In turn, transformational learning takes learning one step beyond and promotes change in ways of knowing and doing (Hoare, 2006; Tsao et al., 2006). In essence, transformational learning allows adult learners to develop deep understandings through critical analysis as the basis for the generation of their own knowledge (Palloff & Pratt, 2001). Critical reflection underlines transformational learning, especially when learners are confronted with learning experiences requiring unique meaning-making relevant only to them based on their individual frame of reference and goals. As such, transformation learning incorporates elements of constructivist conceptions noted above while reinforcing the notion of learning as personal change (Hoare, 2006; Merriam, 2008). Based on the surmised highlights of emerging constructivist theoretical strands it is clear that, given their complementary nature and shared premises, it is not possible to identify a “grand theory” of adult learning. However, emerging theoretical concepts may contribute to our understanding of the adult learning process and can inform curriculum design and development, online learning, and related use of technology (Cercone, 2008; Hoare, 2006; Merriam, 2008). Implications for curriculum design and development Considering theoretical conceptions of adult learning, it is clear that instructors should gauge the unique needs and goals of adult learners when designing curriculum and instruction. This is even more relevant for design and development efforts in online education (Ausburn, 2004; Cercone, 2008; Partlow & Gibbs, 2003). To this end, the use of andragogy and more recent developments in adult learning can be integrated when teaching with technology. Online education provides flexible access for adult learners and the opportunity to work on instructional materials in a self-directed mode. At issue is the adapta-
tion and organization of instructional content and resources through interactive designs that are learner-centered, contextually relevant, and most likely to promote independent learning. In this context, three approaches are highlighted to illustrate efforts to connect learning principles and online curriculum design and development including the use of Bloom’s taxonomy, the “backward design” concept, and online blended learning designs. revisiting the use of bloom’s taxonomy A model for online curriculum development commonly used in higher education uses Bloom’s Taxonomy as a frame of reference to guide the identification of objectives, content, and learning process. This approach focuses on stages of learning including knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis and evaluation. The premise behind the use of Bloom’s Taxonomy is that students learn through the mastery of important content, opportunities to demonstrate what they know; allowances to apply concepts and skills through problem-based activities, and the use of reflective strategies to foster deep understandings. As such, this approach may use a blend of direct instruction to promote mastery learning complemented with constructivist strategies to engage students in active learning and critical thinking (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001). Some critics, however, argued that Bloom’s Taxonomy has become outdated and view its contemporary relevance and application as limited. However, recent adaptations have made the use of Bloom’s Taxonomy appealing for today’s applications to curriculum development (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001; Clark, 2002). Such adaptations are now being used at the college level as well, as a means to promote active learning. For example, Puzziferro & Shelton (2008) reported that all online courses at Colorado State University are developed following an adaptation of Bloom’s work featuring structures for students
151
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
to check content knowledge, demonstrate what they know and can do through “mastery” activities as well as through application and analytical tasks including reflection components (e.g., discussion forums). Courses also include capstone projects designed to further reinforce individual relevance and reflection. Similar examples are reported at institutions such as Penn State University’s World Campus (Thompson & McGrath, 1999) and Georgia Southern University (Center for Online Learning, 2009) to name a few. The common denominator for using Bloom’s work for curriculum development is the desire to align objectives with teaching and learning, and with assessment outcomes. backward design: From outcomes to objectives The “backward design” for curriculum development follows an approach counter to Bloom’s suggested objectives-teaching strategies-outcomes sequence. In the backward design, instructors identify assessment outcomes first, think about teaching/learning activities second, and then decide on core objectives. This design approach to curriculum development focuses on three stages including the articulation of student competencies, identification of evidence that demonstrates mastery of competencies, and design of appropriate instructional activities (McTighe & Wiggins, 1999). Identifying expected student competencies sits at the core of the backward design process and aligns with theoretical principles of adult learning related to making learning relevant (Hoare, 2006; Merriam, 2008). This notion predicates that learners will be more motivated to learn when they know what is expected of them up front. However, rather than emphasizing content coverage through a typical list of expected competencies, backward design requires the identification of essential understandings (or “big ideas”) underlying curriculum development. That is, it forces instructors to “chunk” important content into
152
a few identifiable expectations serving as the guide for a course. Stemming from research in cognition and how memory works, the concept of “chunking” has been helpful in explaining how people with different levels of expertise process information (Collins, Brown, & Newman, 1989). Essentially, “chunking” represents a cognitive system comprised of a few “chunks”, each carrying a number of related informational items for easier retrieval and “big-picture” understandings when put together (Conlon, 2002; Gobet et al., 2001). Chunking has been at the core of information mapping approaches to help instructors organize large amounts of information into a reduced number of blocks (or chunks) to facilitate learning and quick retrieval of needed information In this regard, chunking has been used in a variety of contexts related to human learning and the underlying mechanism can be applied to online curriculum design and development (Ferry, Hedberg, & Harper, 1998; Hirumi, 2002; Janicki & Liegle, 2001). The implications are clear: appropriate curricular chunks need to be developed to promote expertise and understanding in a given domain. For instructional design purposes, the chunking of essential understandings allows for the alignment between assessment outcomes (i.e., goals), content, and instructional strategies. Using this idea as the point of departure, the backward design also builds upon the concept of cognitive apprenticeship for teaching and learning suggesting that novice learners can develop progressive expertise through experiential strategies, such as modeling, coaching, and scaffolding (Bransford et al., 2000; Collins et al., 1989), and through reflective activities designed to promote understanding and knowledge production (McTighe & Wiggins, 1999; Perkins, 1993). For online curriculum development these ideas can translate into a reduced but optimal number of units or modules, each addressing essential understandings appealing to adult learners. In turn, instructional strategies may emphasize tutorials to model target skills,
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
feedback for scaffolding purposes, and structures for individual and collective analyses. The key emphasis in the backward design is the promotion of understanding through the use of strategies appropriate for the content and the learner (McTighe & Wiggins, 1999). blending the best of both worlds? Blended education, also referred to as hybrid education, has been used in distance learning for a number of years (Dziuban, Hartman, & Moskal, 2004). The use of the Internet for online delivery has reinforced the notion of blended learning as a viable instructional alternative integrating faceto-face and online activities. In this case, there is a general agreement that blended education typically features 30 to 70% of online delivery in single courses, while the rest is complemented with face-to-face instruction. Courses using online instruction at the lower end (less than 30%) are often referred to as Web-enhanced. Although instructors may opt for a blended design seeking the advantages of traditional and online instruction, such courses are still loosely defined and the optimal balance remains in question (Allen, Seaman, & Garrett, 2007; Dziuban et al., 2004). As a result, the implications for curriculum design and development are also fuzzy. To be sure, blended designs build upon the benefits of traditional instruction drawing from the socialization factors of face-to-face activities. In turn, this approach may also benefit from active learning, asynchronous collaboration, and independent learning made possible by online activities (Ausburn, 2004). Thus, instructors should think of related design development as opportunities to emphasize constructivist strategies (e.g., experiential, contextual, self-regulated, active learning) as part of the entire course independent of the mode of delivery (Aragon, 2003; Partlow & Gibbs, 2003). The design of blended courses should also allow instructors to maximize the opportunities for productive interactions among
students and between the students and the instructor. As the face-to-face component is retained, some instructors feel more comfortable embracing the online component and may use blended courses as the springboard for further involvement in online learning. In fact, some reports have indicated high levels of student and instructor satisfaction and student performance surpassing that of counterparts in traditional and fully online instruction (Allen et al., 2007; Ausburn, 2004). The advantages of blended designs may be attributed to the combined support and interactions shared through the two instructional channels. To this end, the design features of blended courses often emphasize learner-centered strategies featuring active learning and relevant content facilitated reinforce through discussion groups and other forms of electronic interactions (Aragon, 2003; Ausburn, 2004; Rovai, 2001). Blended instruction can be appealing for instructors and institutions given the perceived higher level of comfort for student and faculty participation. Thus, it is possible to expect the blended design to be a popular approach to online learning. A national survey of online learning reported a slightly higher percentage of blended designs compared to fully online programs across disciplines. In general, the survey also reported that students in higher education were more likely to experience a blended course than a fully online course (Allen et al., 2007). This trend suggests that online education may be undergoing a transformation whereby the divide between face-to-face and online instruction is becoming relatively unimportant. As blended learning continues to evolve, it is clear that, if anything, closer attention must be paid to the use of appropriate curriculum development approaches and delivery mode to ensure the needs of adult learners are met. Implications for online teaching and Learning The instructors’ capacity to teach online is critical for making curriculum design and development
153
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
work as expected. The starting point is to recognize the unique differences of adult learners compared to traditional college students. For example, adult learners in CTE programs seeking certification or graduate degrees—like in many other higher education programs—have to balance family and full-time work while pursuing further education (Cercone, 2008; Blank & Hernandez, 2008; Flowers & Baltzer, 2006b). As such, this type of adult learners represents a goal-oriented group albeit one requiring special considerations to meet special needs processing information brought about by middle age (Clark, 1999). In this context, as suggested by adult learning principles, online instructors should make a shift from lecture-driven and teacher-centered strategies to constructivist approaches to facilitate, rather than manage learning (Fidishun, 2000; Reynolds, 1997). To be sure, pedagogical knowledge is considered the top requirement for effective participation in online education followed by technical expertise. Reports on online teaching and learning strategies have consistently suggested the ability to facilitate learning is emerging as one of the most important pedagogical skills for online learning (Hirumi, 2002; Kim & Bonk, 2006). Further, the shift to constructivist instructional strategies is requiring the capacity to promote online collaboration, independent learning, problembased learning and case-based learning to make instruction relevant, engaging, and meaningful for goal-oriented learners (Kim & Bonk, 2006; Partlow & Gibbs, 2003). This is in direct alignment with student-centered learning rooted in andragogy, experiential learning, contextual instruction, and self-regulated learning (Hoare, 2006; Merriam, 2008). Project-based learning, problem-based learning, and inquiry-based are concepts often used interchangeable as they share principles rooted in information processing theory and aligned with contextual, experiential, and self-directed learning (Bransford et al., 2000; Kirschner et al., 2006; Roschelle, 1999). These instructional approaches
154
have been found helpful in online environments designed to emphasize rich learning experiences. At the core of these strategies is the idea of posing a problem requiring students to produce their own learning (Hmelo-Silver, 2004). For example, problem-based learning (PBL) is an instructional approach that has been used for several decades and stems from project-based learning advocated by Dewey in the early 1900s (Roschelle, 1999). The purpose of PBL is to allow learners to experience and apply knowledge and skills they are learning. Variations of PBL include task-based learning and project-based learning and are sometimes used interchangeable with PBL. What separates PBL from other approaches is the focus on authentic problem situations for which more than one solution can be justified (Ellis, 2003; Ertmer, Lehman, Park, Cramer, & Grove, 2003; HmeloSilver, Duncan, & Chinn, 2007). Thus, PBL can be designed as an independent or group activity that can be easily used as part of online learning. In turn, project-based learning is typically associated with cooperative investigations as a means to keep teams of students on task requiring them to follow their own procedures and produce their own knowledge (Hmelo-Silver, 2004; Miflin, 2004). On the other hand, inquiry-based learning is usually connected to individual work whereby students follow specific discipline-based methods requiring the application of reasoning skills in the completion of research activities (Hmelo-Silver et al., 2007). Common to these strategies is the use of driving questions to guide the understanding of a problem and the design and completion of an investigation or a project. Further, a shared assumption is that these strategies can be implemented with limited assistance from the instructor based on selfdirected notions of learning. In this regard, some researchers argued that these strategies are bound to be ineffective if instructors do not account for the role of cognitive processing requiring timely feedback and scaffolding supports (Hmelo-Silver et al., 2007; Kirschner et al., 2006; Taylor et al.,
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
2003). This is particularly relevant given the fact that even though there is a consensus on the importance of constructivist strategies, the extent of use of related pedagogical practices in online education remains limited and uneven in terms of quality (Kim & Bonk, 2006). Use of Technology Given the underlying use of technology in online education, instructors have to understand and consider the role of technology in adult learning. In this regard, instructors face the challenge of developing expertise in using instructional technology and striking the right balance when using it to facilitate online learning. Specifically, instructors have to consider the role and use of technology in curriculum development, delivery systems, and as instructional tools (Havice & Havice, 2005; Hirumi, 2002). Studies describing online curriculum development efforts have noted that instructors tend to focus initially on the technology tools for online teaching and realize in the process that the primary goal should be related to design factors (Flowers, 2001, 2005). Drawing from constructivist theory advocating the facilitation of active knowledge production, it is then crucial for instructors to think about identifying sets of knowledge structures following an appropriate approach (e.g., backward design). One way to accomplish this is to use technology that allows information mapping (e.g., Inspiration). Information mapping technology does not involve a steep learning curve for instructors and can be used in the selection and development of essential understandings for particular courses (Conlon, 2002; Ferry et al., 1998). Another consideration is the use of online lesson building technology such as SoftChalk, NTeQ, CAST Universal Design for Learning, and other commercially available programs and services. These online curriculum builders ease the learning curve for instructors as they typically rely on intuitive interfaces involving the use of
word-processing platforms and curriculum templates. The use of this technology should ease concerns from institutions and instructors about the time-consuming process for curriculum development and need for technology expertise as a requirement to participate effectively in online education (Hirumi, 2002; Janicki & Liegle, 2001; Thompso & McGrath, 1999). Instructors also need to understand the role and use of specific delivery systems used for online education such as Blackboard, Angel Learning, WebCT, and others. As institutions embrace online education, a course management and delivery system has to be adopted and instructors have to learn the system and work within its constraints and opportunities (Harrington, Staffo, & Wright, 2006; Kraemer, 2003). The most popular systems used in higher education today are WebCT or Blackboard (Carnevale, 2005). The use of a course management system represents an additional layer of technology that may hinder or facilitate faculty participation and, in turn, adult learning. In this regard, instructors are forced to assume additional roles when using course management systems including management, facilitation, and evaluation of learning. Not surprisingly, wide differences are observed between novice and experienced instructors in the way they interact and use course management technology (Harrington et al., 2006; Kraemer, 2003). Clearly, as online education continues to grow, the need to evaluate the effectiveness of course management systems from the instructors’ perspective will become more important. The basic premise and appeal of online education is the flexible access to the learners any time, anywhere, at their convenience. In the case of adult learners, it is assumed they are goal-oriented and motivated to learn on their own. Thus, there is false expectation that adult learners will be able to sort out online instructional materials and resources independently (Kirschner et al., 2006). However, despite the popularity of online education, participation in such courses or programs
155
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
may be frustrating for some students leading to higher drop out rates compared to students in traditional courses. Common reasons for dropping out include limited instructor’s assistance, time demands, and difficulty handling the underlying technology (Paloff & Pratt, 2001; Zirkle, 2002). This finding is a reminder that technology should be used as the means to facilitate learning rather than a distraction for learning. This is consistent with reports indicating that in online programs, the way in which technology is used is more important than whether the technology is “cutting edge” or not (Johnson & Benson, 2003; Phipps & Merisotis, 1999). To ensure that adult learners succeed in online programs, instructors should provide opportunities to acquire relevant technological skills, mediate technical support, and recognize differences in self-directed learning (Fidishun, 2000). Used as an instructional tool, technology should facilitate online spaces for collaborative learning, provide access to resources, allow for information processing, and include multiple representations of ideas to address different learning styles. Given the emerging range of choices made possible by the Internet, instructors can tap into videoconferencing, electronic messaging, real-time conferencing, and other communication tools for online learning (Stilborne & Williams, 1996). Obviously, this is quite a challenge for instructors who may be limited by their own capacity and commitment to using technology and, in many ways, this is a transformational process for instructors as well (Imel, 1998; Tsao et al., 2006). Recognizing that instructors are by default asked to bear the responsibility of curriculum design, development, online management and delivery, and selection and use of instructional technology, some institutions are promoting a team approach to ensure the quality of online curriculum and instruction. In such cases, instructors are required to partner with librarians and instructional designers for participation in online education to ensure appropriate support
156
(Aragon, 2003; Flowers, 2005; Hernandez et al., 2004). These emerging efforts underscore the need for faculty training and holistic support to help them make a successful shift to online teaching and learning and meet the needs of adult learners effectively (Cercone, 2008; Kim & Bonk, 2006).
eMerGInG trends And needs Based on the review of enrollment trends in online education and issues related to adult teaching and learning in the context of career and technical education, the following trends and needs are emerging. First, online education should continue to grow at the community college and university level as CTE programs respond to the demand for flexible teacher re-certification and professional development programs, and for advanced degrees including doctoral preparation (Flowers & Baltzer, 2006b; Johnson & Benson, 2003). At the community college level, online CTE education growth is expected to continue with primary focus on course offerings (Aragon, 2003; Johnson & Benson, 2003). In teacher preparation and graduate programs at the university level, similar growth should be expected to address the demand for alternative delivery systems At the graduate level, in particular, the growth may be in the conversion of existing programs catering to the increasing number of part-time professionals seeking to continue working full-time while pursuing advanced degrees (Blank & Hernandez, 2008; Flowers & Baltzer, 2006b). Second, as online CTE continues to grow, the issue of quality should become more critical as prospective students empowered by the online premise of “anytime-anywhere” learning become more discerning when choosing a program without regard to geographical location (Flowers, 2001, 2005). The relative advantage of pioneering programs should be leveraged as others join the market, unless program quality is ensured. Third, blended learning should continue to grow in popularity compared to fully online
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
courses and programs. There appears to be a consistent trickle of evidence noting an increased preference for this format by both students and instructors (Allen et al., 2007; Aragon, 2003). In this context, the issue of faculty participation in online education and related supports will become more prominent given the complex demands embodied in related work compared to traditional teaching assignments (Flowers, 2005; Kim & Bonk, 2006). In turn, the need to rethink the value of participation in online education for tenure and promotion will be more openly discussed as a strategic measure to ensure the quality of future participation (Bower, 2001; Hernandez et al., 2004). Fourth, given the growth of online learning, understanding teaching and learning in online environments should become a top research priority in higher education, CTE included. Considering the narrow focus of current research, it will be imperative to explore the connections between adult learning developments in online CTE contexts from teaching and learning perspectives (Aragon, 2003; Hoare, 2006; Merriam, 2008; Reynolds, 1997). For example, what constructivist instructional strategies work best with adult learners in CTE and under what conditions? What approaches and technologies facilitate social networking and critical reflection? What are the long-term strategies and supports needed for successful participation in graduate programs? Are there interactions between certain groups of adult learners and particular types of online instructional strategies? These are but a hint of questions that need to be addressed as online education becomes more prominent in CTE in the future. Finally, the continuous evolution of instructional technology will demand closer study of discrete technologies used to facilitate online curriculum development, course management systems, and delivery issues. The use of technology
to facilitate social interactions, virtual meetings, and collaborative activities appropriate for adult learning and consistent with adult learning theory should also emerge as an important issue to be researched in online CTE in the future (Kim & Bonk, 2006; Partlow & Gibbs, 2003; Schmidt & Gallegos, 2001).
concLusIon Trends in online enrollments suggest a growing share of the education market at the postsecondary level. Similar trends have been reported in CTE in response to demands for alternative delivery formats and to maximize dwindling faculty capacity in the field. At the graduate level, CTE programs appear to be embracing online education, especially in teacher preparation programs and at the master’s degree level, while doctoral programs are more cautiously joining the online movement. As online education becomes more prominent in the field, issues related to quality, impact, and connections to adult learning principles have emerged. However, a review of research in CTE revealed that much of the contemporary focus is on institutional and faculty efforts to put courses and programs online. Thus, it is imperative that we bridge emerging developments in adult learning in the context of online teaching and learning in CTE contexts. Recent contributions to the literature on adult learning highlighted in this article provide a promising framework for informing online CTE. At the same time, they underscore the need to rethink online curriculum development, delivery systems, instruction, and use of instructional technology. Further, it is clear that online education is not a fad and will continue to grow in the future, perhaps in some form of blended modes, thus requiring a focus on teaching and learning in online contexts placing the needs of adult learners at the center of the research agenda.
157
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2008). Staying the course: Online education in the United States, 2008. Needham, MA: The Sloan Consortium.
Bower, B. (2001). Distance education: Facing the faculty challenge. Journal of Distance Learning Administration, IV(II). Retrieved February 25, 2009, from http://www.westga.edu/~distance/ ojdla/summer42/bower42.html
Allen, I. E., Seaman, J., & Garrett, R. (2007). Blending in: The extent and promise of blended education in the United States. Needham, MA: The Sloan Consortium.
Bransford, J. D., Brown, A. L., & Cocking, R. R. (2000). How people learn: Brain, mind, experience, and school. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.
Anderson, L. W., & Krathwohl, D. R. (Eds.). (2001). A taxonomy of learning, teaching, and assessment: A revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives. New York: Longman.
Carnevale, D. (2005). Government’s request for data may delay Blackboard’s purchase
reFerences
Aragon, S. (Ed.). (2003). Facilitating learning in online environments: New directions for adult and continuing education, vol. 100. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Athanasou, J. (2008). Career education. In L. M. English (Ed.), International encyclopedia of adult education (pp. 90-92). New York: Palgrave Mcmillan. Ausburn, L. J. (2004). Course design elements most valued by adult learners in blended online education environments: An American perspective. Educational Media International, 41(4), 327–337. doi:10.1080/0952398042000314820 Baltzer, H., Lazaros, E., & Flowers, J. C. (2007). Review of doctoral programs in technical education. Journal of Industrial Teacher Education, 44(2), 37–59. Banas, E. J., & Emory, W. F. (1998). History and issues of distance learning. Public Administration Quarterly, 22(3), 365–383. Blank, W., & Hernandez, V. (2008). Preparing CTE leaders online. Techniques, January Issue. Association of Career and Technical Education (ACTE).
158
Center for Online Learning. (2009). Online course design: Bloom’s taxonomy. Statesboro, GA: Georgia Southern University. Retrieved on March 15, 2009, from http://academics.georgiasouthern.edu/ col/id/bloom.php Cercone, K. (2008). Characteristics of adult learners with implications for online learning design. Advancement of Computing in Education Journal, 16(2), 137–159. Clark, B. (1983). The higher education system. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press. Clark, B. (2002). Growing up gifted: Developing the potential of children at home and at school. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Merrill Prentice Hall. Collins, A., Brown, J., & Newman, S. (1989). Cognitive apprenticeship: Teaching the crafts of reading, writing, and mathematics. In L. Resnick (Ed.), Knowing, learning and instructing: Essays in honor of Robert Glaser (pp.453-494). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum. Conlon, T. (2002). Information mapping as support for learning and teaching. Computers & Education, 106, 6–14. Conrad, D. (2008). Online learning. In L. M. English (Ed.), International encyclopedia of adult education (pp. 442-447). New York: Palgrave Macmillan.
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
Cooper, M. K., & Henschke, J. A. (2003, November). An update on andragogy: The international foundation for its research, theory and practice. Paper presented at the Commission of Professors of Adult Education (CPAE) Conference, Detroit, MI. Dziuban, C. D., Hartman, J. L., & Moskal, P. D. (2004). Blended learning. EDUCAUSE Center for Applied Research . Research Bulletin (Sun Chiwawitthaya Thang Thale Phuket), 2004(7). Ellis, R. (2003). Task-based language learning and teaching. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Ertmer, P. A., Lehman, J., Park, S. H., Cramer, J., & Grove, K. (2003, March). Barriers to teachers’ adoption and use of technology in problem-based learning. In Proceedings of the Association for the Advancement of Computing in Education (AACE) Society for Information Technology and Teacher Education (SITE) International Conference, Albuquerque, NM (pp. 1761-1766). Chesapeake, VA: AACE. Ferry, B., Hedberg, J., & Harper, B. (1998). How do preservice teachers use concept maps to organise their curriculum knowledge? Journal of Interactive Learning Research, 9(1), 83–104. Fidishun, D. (2000). Andragogy and technology: Integrating adult learning theory as we teach with technology. Retrieved on January 27, 2009, from http://frank.mtsu.edu/~itconf/proceed00/ fidishun.htm Flowers, J. (2001). Online learning in technology education. Journal of Technology Education, 13(1), 17–30. Flowers, J. (2005). The effect of online delivery on graduate enrollment. Journal of Industrial Teacher Education, 42(4), 7–24.
Flowers, J., & Baltzer, H. (2006a). Hiring technical education faculty: Vacancies, criteria, and attitudes toward online doctoral programs. Journal of Industrial Teacher Education, 43(3), 29–44. Flowers, J., & Baltzer, H. (2006b). Perceived demand for online and hybrid doctoral programs in technical education. Journal of Industrial Teacher Education, 43(4), 39–56. Gobet, F., Lane, P. C. R., Croker, S., Cheng, P. C.-H., Jones, G., & Oliver, I. (2001). Chunking mechanisms in human learning. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 5, 236–243. doi:10.1016/S13646613(00)01662-4 Harrington, T., Staffo, M., & Wright, V. H. (2006). Faculty uses of and attitudes toward a course management system in improving instruction. Journal of Interactive Online Learning, 5(2), 178–190. Havice, W. L., & Havice, P. A. (Eds.). (2005). Distance and distributed learning environments: Perspectives and strategies: 54th yearbook of the Council on Technology Teacher Education. New York: Glencoe McGraw-Hill. Hernandez, V., Kirby, J., & McGee, S. (2004). Competency assessment in distributed education. Washington, DC: Association of Jesuit Colleges and Universities. Hernández-Gantes, V. M., & Blank, W. (2009). Teaching English language learners in career and technical education programs. New York: Routledge. Hirumi, A. (2002). A framework for analyzing, designing, and sequencing planned e-learning interactions. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 3(2), 141–160. Hmelo-Silver, C. E. (2004). Problem-based learning: What and how do students learn? Educational Psychology Review, 16(3), 235–266. doi:10.1023/ B:EDPR.0000034022.16470.f3
159
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
Hmelo-Silver, C. E., Duncan, R. G., & Chinn, C. A. (2007). Scaffolding and achievement in problem-based and inquiry learning: A response to Kirschner, Sweller, and Clark (2006). Educational Psychologist, 42(2), 99–107. Hoare, C. (Ed.). (2006). Handbook of adult development and learning. New York: Oxford. Imel, S. (1998). Technology and adult learning: Current perspectives. Columbus, OH: ERIC Clearinghouse on Adult, Career and Vocational Education. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. 197). Itin, C. M. (1999). Reasserting the philosophy of experiential education as a vehicle for change in the 21st century. Journal of Experiential Education, 22(2), 91–98. Janicki, T., & Liegle, J. O. (2001). Development and evaluation of a framework for creating Web-based learning modules: A pedagogical and systems approach. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 5(1). Johnson, S. D., & Benson, A. D. (2003). Distance learning in postsecondary career and technical education. St. Paul, MN: National Research Center for Career and Technical Education. Kim, K., & Bonk, C. J. (2006). The future of online teaching and learning in higher education: The survey says… . EDUCAUSE Quarterly, 29(4). King, K. P. (2008). Distance education. In L. M. English (Ed.), International encyclopedia of adult education (pp. 192-199). New York: Palgrave Macmillan. Kirschner, P. A., Sweller, J., & Clark, R. E. (2006). Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: An analysis of the failure of constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching. Educational Psychologist, 41(2), 75–86. doi:10.1207/ s15326985ep4102_1
160
Knowles, M. S. (1980). The modern practice of adult education: From andragogy to pedagogy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Cambridge Adult Education. Kolb, D. A. (1984). Experiential learning: Experience as the source of learning and development. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall. Kraemer, E. W. (2003). Developing the online learning environment: The pros and cons of using WebCT. Information Technologies and Libraries, 22(2), 87–92. Lorenzetti, J. P. (2003). Thirty-two distance education trends. Distance Education Report, 7(21), 1–6. McTighe, J., & Wiggins, G. (1999). The understanding by design. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Merriam, S. B. (2001a). Andragogy and selfdirected learning: Pillars of adult learning theory. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 89, 3–13. doi:10.1002/ace.3 Merriam, S. B. (Ed.). (2001b). The new update on adult learning theory. New directions for adult and continuing education. San Fransisco: Jossey-Bass. Merriam, S. B. (Ed.). (2008). Third update on adult learning theory: New directions for adult and continuing education, vol. 119. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Miflin, B. (2004). Adult learning, self-directed learning and problem-based learning: Deconstructing the connections. The entity from which ERIC acquires the content, including journal, organization, and conference names, or by means of online submission from the author. Teaching in Higher Education, 9(1), 43–53. doi:10.1080/1356251032000155821
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
National Center for Education Statistics. (2000). Distance education at postsecondary education institutions: 1997-1998 (NCES Publication No. 2003-013). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. National Center for Education Statistics. (2002). A profile of participation in distance education: 1999-2000 (NCES Publication No. 2003-154). Washington, DC: U.S. Government Printing Office. Paloff, R. M., & Pratt, K. (2001). Lessons from the cyberspace classroom: The realities of online teaching. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Partlow, K. M., & Gibbs, W. J. (2003). Indicators of constructivist principles in Internet-based courses. Journal of Computing in Higher Education, 14(2), 68–97. doi:10.1007/BF02940939 Perkins, D. (1993). Teaching for understanding. American Educator, 17(3), 28–35. Phipps, R., & Merisotis, J. (1999). What’s the difference? A review of contemporary research on the effectiveness of distance learning in higher education. Washington, DC: The Institute for Higher Education Policy. Puzziferro, M., & Shelton, K. (2008). A model for developing high-quality online courses: Integrating a systems approach with learning theory. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Environment Learning Networks, 12(3). Retrieved on February 15, 2009, from http://sloanconsortium.org/ node/1409
Reynolds, K. C. (1997, March). The name assigned to the document by the author. This field may also contain sub-titles, series names, and report numbers.Postsecondary education in cohort groups: Does familiarity breed learning? Additional information about the document that does not fit in any of the other fields; not used after 2004.Paper presented at the Annual Meeting of the American Educational Research Association, Chicago. Roschelle, J. (1999). Transitioning to professional practice: A Deweyan view of five analyses of problem-based learning. Discourse Processes: A Multidisicplinary Journal, 27(2), 231-240. Rovai, A. P. (2001). Building classroom community at a distance: A case study. Educational Technology Research and Development Journal, 49(4), 33–48. doi:10.1007/BF02504946 Ryan, R. C. (2000). Student assessment comparison of lecture and online construction equipment and methods classes. T.H.E. Journal, 27(6), 76–83. Schmidt, E. K., & Gallegos, A. (2001). Distance learning: Issues and concerns of distance learners. Journal of Industrial Technology, 17(3). Retrieved on February 22, 2009, from http://nait.org/jit/ Articles/schmidt041801.pdf Sloan-C. (2009). NASULGC-Sloan national commission on online learning benchmarking study: Preliminary findings. Retrieved on March 3, 2009, from http://www.sloan-c.org/publications/survey/ nasulgc_prelim Stilborne, L., & Williams, L. (1996). Meeting the needs of adult learners in developing courses for the Internet. Retrieved on January 15, 2009, from https://www.isoc.org/inet96/proceedings/ c4/ca_2.htm
161
Teaching Adult Learners in Online Career and Technical Education
Taylor, E. W. (2007). An update of transformative a critical review of the empirical research (19992005). International Journal of Lifelong Education, 26(2), 173–191. doi:10.1080/02601370701219475
Tsao, J., Takahashi, K., Olusesu, J., & Jain, S. (2006). Transformative learning. In M. Orey (Ed.), Emerging perspectives on learning, teaching, and technology. Retrieved March 10, 2009, from http://projects.coe.uga.edu/epltt
Taylor, K. (2006). Autonomy and self-directed learning: A developmental journey. In C. Hoare (Ed.), Handbook of adult development and learning. New York: Oxford.
WebCT. Chronicle of Higher Education, 52(16), A29. Retrieved January, 22, 2009, from http:// chronicle.com/weekly/v52/i16/16a02901.htm
Taylor, M., King, J., Pinsent-Johnson, C., & Lothian, T. (2003). Collaborative practices in adult literacy programs. Adult Basic Education, 13(2), 81–99.
Zirkle, C. (2002). Identification of distance education barriers for trade and industrial teacher education. Journal of Industrial Education, 40(1), 20–44
Thompson, M. M., & McGrath, J. W. (1999). Using LNs to support a complete educational experience. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Environment Learning Networks, 3(2). Retrieved on March 17, 2009, from http://www.sloan-c.org/publications/ jaln/v3n2/v3n2_thompson.asp
This work was previously published in International Journal of Web-Based Learning and Teaching Technologies, Vol. 4, Issue 4, edited by E. M. W. Nq; N. Karacapilidis; M. S. Raisinghani, pp. 1-28, copyright 2009 by IGI Publishing (an imprint of IGI Global).
162
163
Chapter 1.12
Collaborative Learning: Using Group Work Concepts for Online Teaching Lesley Cooper Wilfrid Laurier University, Canada Sally Burford University of Canberra, Australia
AbstrAct This chapter examines the concept of collaborative learning and its theoretical and practical foundations. Collaborative learning takes place in a structured social situation where a group of students work as a team to assist each other with learning tasks. The instructional strategies encourage student to student interactions. Drawing on group work skills, collaborative learning has been demonstrated to be effective in a variety of learning situations. Development of a variety of Internet technologies such as communication tools, emails, discussion forums, video and audio tools together with webcasting allow collaborative teaching strategies to be used creatively in online learning. The authors
have trialed the use of various technologies in the human services and several case examples of online collaborative learning are provided. These case studies cover activities such as supervision and controversial issues in social work ethics. The chapter concludes with a discussion of the future directions and the challenges this poses for traditional classroom teaching. I entered the classroom with the conviction that it was crucial for me and every other student to be an active participant, not a passive consumer... education as the practice of freedom.... education that connects the will to know with the will to become. Learning is a place where paradise can be created. bell hooks
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-735-5.ch003
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Collaborative Learning
IntroductIon Collaborative learning occurs when a group of students work as a team assisting each other with learning tasks. This form of learning began in classrooms and its effectiveness is that setting has been demonstrated. More recently, it is being used in the online environment. Education in social work and more generally in the human services requires an understanding of human relationships and a capacity to work successfully with other people. Collaborative learning, based on group work concepts is widely and successfully used in all social work education to enable student to student interaction to facilitate further learning. Some academics, however question whether online learning is a valuable framework for teaching the fundamental practice skills in the human services. The aim of this chapter is to explore the teaching of social work using the tools and technologies and the application of collaborative learning in an online environment. This chapter will encompass theoretical foundations, application of group work skills to teaching and ways in which collaborative learning is used for online learning. Case studies of collaborative online learning for tertiary social work students will be provided.
constructIvIsM: the theoretIcAL FoundAtIon Collaborative learning is based on the tradition of constructivist epistemology. Simply, constructivism means that we learn through a process of experiencing and then reflecting on those experiences, a process which is often and best done with others. Through this process we create a different understanding of the world. As we encounter new experiences, we use our past experiences to understand and make sense of new information thus making new connections which are then organized into new forms of knowledge
164
With this new information, we can then discard knowledge that is no longer relevant. Many educators have contributed to our understanding of the importance of constructivism in learning including Vygotsky (1978), Rogoff (1990), Lave and Wenger (1991), and Schon (1983, 1987). According to Vygotsky (1978), higher mental functions are enhanced when the more experienced or capable work with the less experienced or capable in social situations. This is referred to as the zone of proximal development. In a similar way, Rogoff (1990) talked about the value of a cognitive apprenticeship in thinking and guided learning. The less experienced are guided by the more experienced in their thinking about complex problem solving. A parallel in human services is the responsibility taken by supervisors in the work place when they share their thinking about solving difficult cases with students and fellow workers. Lave and Wenger (1991) contributed to our understanding of learning by stressing the importance of context in the learning process. They referred to the concept of situated learning with Wenger (1998) elaborating the value of a community of practice (experienced workers) in the construction of new knowledge. They were particularly concerned with how workers developed their professional skills. In the area of professional teaching and learning, Schon (1983, 1987) also acknowledged the importance of social context. In our professional life, much learning whilst tacit does take place in a social context and through dialogue with others. We know though doing activities and we learn through a process of reflection on, and in action. The ramifications of constructivism are the importance of learning in a social context; the significance of more experienced others and peers in the learning process; and the value of real world issues as the focus for learning. In summary, constructivism has been extensively researched as an educational principle that is well accepted as an approach to facilitating learning in today’s educational institutions (Pap-
Collaborative Learning
ert, 1991; Boudourides 1999; Grabe and Grabe, 2001). This constructivist philosophy is particularly suited to social work education and has been widely used in the human services (Hanson and Sinclair, 2008).
deFInInG oF coLLAborAtIve LeArnInG Collaborative learning is not new. The Socratic Method, a process of questioning, inquiring and probing the views of others in a dialectical manner was an early form of collaborative learning used to explore ideas, positions and rational thinking. Dewey, a prominent educational philosopher writing in Experience and Education (1938) was critical of didactic, structured and traditional methods of education because they took little account of the human experience. He argued that learning should be part of everyday actions and everyday relationships. Within our community, many rural children who attended one teacher schools used collaborative processes for learning. Whilst the sole teacher worked with one small group of students other groups were given group activities as part of the classroom learning. The resurgence of collaborative learning emerged during the 1980s in the USA although Bruffee (1992, p.23) believed the idea was first developed in London together with movements towards democratization of education. In this chapter, we have chosen the term collaborative learning as we prefer this to cooperative learning. Whilst there is debate in the literature about the differences between these two types of learning (Barkley, Cross & Major 2005) both terms are often used interchangeably. Writers from both traditions draw on research from the other area. It appears that, in general, cooperative learning is regarded as learning that takes place in the classrooms of younger children whilst collaborative learning is more apparent in colleges and universities (Barkley, Cross & Major, 2005,
p.7). In our mind, with our focus on higher education and the human services this distinction is artificial and, we prefer the term collaborative to cooperative learning. Despite the preference for a particular term, we will draw on the cooperative learning literature given the similarities, parallels and overlaps between the two terminologies. Collaborative learning takes place in a structured social situation where a group of students work as a team to assist each other with learning tasks. The learning process is facilitated by a teacher using a range of instructional strategies derived from various theoretical perspectives. These instructional strategies encourage student to student interaction and allow the teacher to act as a guide for learning rather than as a sage who knows all answers. In these structured groups, learning becomes a process in which all participants collaborate to maximize their own learning and that of other students. When students work together, they create new knowledge by sharing ideas and experiences, evaluating ideas and concepts, and building or creating new ideas and ways of working from a professional area or discipline. Groups are able to achieve outcomes which an individual cannot achieve alone. Collaborative learning does not always occur in traditional academic classrooms which may be both competitive and individualistic. In a traditional university classroom, the mode of teaching is through transmission of information from teacher to students. The teacher conducts the lecture and requires that students complete assignments independently. This is what Paulo Friere (1993) called the banking approach. In this model, students are passive and have little social interaction with the teacher. Not every classroom uses this approach but it is widely used for large lectures. Johnson, Johnson and Smith (1991, p.3) compared the traditional teaching model with that of collaborative groups. Traditional teaching groups are characterized by a lack of interdependence and individual accountability, with homogeneous membership and one leader
165
Collaborative Learning
who is the teacher and direct specific classroom tasks. Traditional teaching groups ignore social skills and relationships, groups of students or group processing. In the collaborative classroom, there is positive interdependence between students but also individual accountability for group effort, deliberately encouraged heterogeneous membership and shared leadership between group members. The value of this to students is that individual strengths are valued and utilized and students can learn in a place where they feel safe. This is important for students who feel vulnerable in a more traditional classroom. The emphasis is on tasks to be completed but also on relationships between group members with learning of social skills and group processing being an important part of learning arrangements. The role of the teacher is to monitor and intervene in the groups as needed. The relevance of group learning is immediately apparent to the human service workplace. With funding changes, many workplaces have flat organizational structures so that teams are self managing taking responsibility for a range of functions. For many years, government and industry have argued that group skills and the capacity to work in teams are fundamental skills for employment. This collaboration is necessary in areas such as social planning and community work, case management involving arranging services with other agencies, multidisciplinary teams in health care, and management of project work and research for policy. Students who come to the human services workplaces with group work and group processing skills and individual accountability for the group tasks are valued workers. They are able to talk, listen, take their turns as leader, problem solve and reflect on their activities.
166
evIdence oF eFFectIveness oF coLLAborAtIve LeArnInG Since these early beginnings, research into learning has shifted from a teacher centred transmission and acquisition model to one based on the co-construction of knowledge in a community of learners where learning is regarded as a social activity. In 2003, there were over 6000 references in ERIC to collaborative learning (Barkley, Cross & Major 2005). A great deal of research into the effectiveness of collaborative learning has been done by David Johnson and Roger Johnson at the Centre for Cooperative Learning at the University of Minnesota. The Cooperative Learning Center is a Research and Training Center focusing on how students should interact with each other as they learn and the skills needed to interact effectively. Research on collaborative learning is extensive and the findings demonstrate the effectiveness of this strategy for learning. Johnson, Johnson and Smith (1991) summarized research that compared the effects of cooperative, competitive and individualistic efforts on instructional outcomes. On the basis of their meta-analysis, they concluded that collaboration helps students to learn and that collaborative learning enables more positive interpersonal relationships and higher self esteem. Johnson, Johnson and Stanne (2000) did a further meta-analysis on the effectiveness of methods of collaborative learning used in schools. They found 164 separate studies and eight methods for enabling collaboration. All methods for developing collaborative learning were effective but the most successful of these was learning together, this being followed by academic controversy. Slavin, (1990) using a different methodological approach, compared cooperative learning groups with controls. He concluded that achievements with cooperative groups were significantly positive. They are most effective when they incorporate group goals and individual accountability.
Collaborative Learning
coLLAborAtIve LeArnInG And GrouPworK sKILLs Joining Together: Group Theory and Group Skills (Johnson and Johnson 2009) is a standard text book for students in the group work and is written by one of the authors who pioneered collaborative learning. In their work, a group is regarded as a meeting where there is interpersonal interaction structured by roles, norms and stages of development, interdependence between participants, specific achievable goals, and more than two members. Group members are motivated to be part of that group to meet personal needs. These concepts form part of group work practice in human services, team work in organizations and teaching in higher education. Teachers in higher education have a choice about how they structure student learning. It can be individualistic where students work alone and strive for personal success or competitive situation where they battle against each other for good grades. The other possibility is to work collaboratively so students can achieve common goals (Johnson, Johnson, Holubec and Roy 1984). Given the practice orientation of social work education, this collaborative goal is preferred. Collaborative learning groups are based on fundamental group work concepts. These concepts have been developed by Johnson Johnson and Smith (1991) and include: • • • • •
positive interdependence face to face promotive interaction individual accountability social skills group processing
At the time these concepts were elaborated, the Internet was not widely used for teaching and face to face teaching was the norm. With the development of online learning face to face interactions in one physical location were not possible. With further development of the technology, webcasting
became available so that students can see each other when communicating synchronistically. Johnson et al expanded and qualified the concept of face to face interaction with that of “promotive interaction.” Accordingly group members provide each other with help and assistance and the exchange of resources within the group. Participants’ process information quickly, providing feedback to improve performance and challenge the conclusions reached by group members. Within the group advocacy for group goals will occur with all members influencing others to achieve these. Above all, the group will act in trustworthy ways (Johnson, Johnson and Smith, 1991, p.7). It is these characteristics which are essential in the design of online learning. Groups go through stages of development. In the 1960s, Tuckman outlined four group stages: forming, storming, norming and performing. Later he added adjourning (Smith, 2005). Although these stages are described in a linear manner, they are less clear cut in practice. In each of these stages, group members and leaders have particular tasks. This also applies to teachers running collaborative groups. Tuckman was writing about face to face interaction, but these stages also appear in online groups. In the forming stage, participants are inclined to behave independently, get to know others in the group and test relationships. At the outset, teachers must be clear about the learning tasks and instructions and provide clear directions. In the storming stage, the real work of the group has begun. Students begin to polarize around issues. Conflict is apparent and the group interactions are often emotionally laden. Some members often resist the group dynamics. In this stage, the teacher notices that everyone has a different idea of the task or some may evade the work. Clarity about tasks remains important. By the time norming is reached the group members have developed trust and are acquainted with the learning requirements. Students participate and take responsibility for the activities. New standards for working together
167
Collaborative Learning
Figure 1. Roles in the online learning environment
are likely to develop and new roles adopted. At this stage the teacher can stand back and watch carefully from the sidelines. The development of netiquette (see case study) is an important part of group formation and norming with netiquette standards assisting in managing difficult interactions. In the final stage the group works collaboratively with structural and procedural issue being resolved. The group makes the decisions. In any group, there is differentiation in the roles people play. In formal groups, some members have designated roles and assigned tasks. In other groups, individuals take on roles because of a particular interest or skills. Associated with the role are expectations that a person will behave in a particular way. For example a teacher and a student both have particular complementary roles and there are expectations of how both will behave. In learning groups, roles can develop informally or alternatively, roles can be assigned to group members. This has the advantage of creating positive interdependence and ensures that there are no “free riders” i.e. a situation where one person carries responsibility for the work. Some of the online roles are outlined in Figure 1. These group work concepts were used in the design of the case examples. A group facilitator keeps the group on task and time ensuring that all the work is complete. A recorder, acts like a secretary who keeps the records and prepare the material completed by the group. 168
A summarizer condenses the main points in a discussion and encapsulates it in a clear statement. An elaborator uses their understanding of theory and practice and makes links between these ideas. A researcher/ investigator finds any resource or library material necessary to complete the task; and A wildcard is the member who can slot into any of the above positions to enable the group to continue functioning (Millis and Cottell, 1998, p.53).
Internet technoLoGIes For coLLAborAtIve LeArnInG Internet technologies provide a global and accessible platform for knowledge creation and sharing as well as communication. Many of these technologies are generic communication tools such as email, weblogs, discussion forums and webcasts whilst others have been specially developed or customized for a particular collaborative learning activity. Some technologies to support online collaborative learning require a funded project approach. A team effort, significant funding, the support of technical expertise and project management are all essential components of these endeavors. Gay et al. (1999) describe a technology that has
Collaborative Learning
been specifically crafted for online collaborative learning. The CoNote system is a web based document annotation system in which a document becomes the object of discussion. The document is drafted by an individual student and the shared annotations of group members provide ongoing feedback and improvement of the work. In this learning tool, the individually owned document provides a relatively fixed reference for discussion and co-creation of knowledge as opposed to shared authoring tools. Naidu et al (2000) report on the development and application in the realm of political science of a collaborative role-play simulation technology using Internet protocols. A student assumes a particular role in the “world” that has a particular goal or mission associated with it. Learning takes place as the student acquires the skill and knowledge necessary to achieve their goal. Their scenario or simulated real life has all the complexity and richness of the real world. Web based conferencing takes place between the participants in the scenario. The simulation continues in the conference areas designated as news agencies such as BBC or CNN and students interact via different document types such as memos, draft articles and news, which vary depending on their roles. This impressive collaborative framework for learning immerses the student in a scenario where they must learn in consultation with others in their “world.” Students are at the centre of the learning process and the emphasis is on an interdependent collective. This rich and purposeful compilation of Internet technologies for collaborative learning is not the norm however. More often generic Internet technologies are involved in group learning and a learning strategy is built around them. Generic technologies such as email, discussion forums, chat rooms, weblogs, wikis, webcasting and podcasting systems are readily available to tertiary teachers and are often incorporated in online learning management systems - that may be either of a proprietary nature e.g. WebCT, Blackboard or open source systems e.g. Moodle or Sakai.
Email and discussion forums need no introduction to readers in the 21st century. These extensively used communication tools have the advantages of asynchronicity and provide a permanent record of “conversation.” A chat room provides the benefits and chat of synchronous communication and must be carefully incorporated into a learning environment to overcome the chaotic communication of too many textual “voices” at once. The discussion forum or bulletin board is the most widely adopted and successful Internet communication tool in collaborative learning to date. The literature provides a plethora of examples of collaborative learning strategies using the discussion forum (McLoughin 2000; Cooper 2001; Curtis & Lawson 2001; Treleaven 2003). Its success is based on openness and ease of use. Any number of discussion “spaces” can be created to cater for full class interaction or smaller group activities. The discussion forum does not require learners to participate at a particular time or place making it a very adaptable and flexible tool in the lives of learners and their teachers. Textual Internet technologies complemented by audio and video and learning are often enriched by varied forms of presentation. Webcasting technology enables audio or video files to be hosted and accessed by multiple Internet users. Streaming technology allows large amounts of data to be continuously downloaded whilst being viewed. Viewing the video or audio file begins before the whole multimedia file has been transmitted. Podcasting now provides the added benefit that audio/video files can be downloaded to an individual’s own media storage and playing device for future replay. The term Web 2.0 is used to describe significant and recent shifts in using the web. O’Reilly (2005) describes Web 2.0 as having an “architecture of participation.” Web 2.0 is based on social software where users generate content rather than simply consume it; in so doing they give spontaneous shape to the organisation of information. The web takes more of a peer-to-peer shape than its previous top-down, authorised presentation of information. 169
Collaborative Learning
A participatory mode of informing and communicating using the web has evolved – users not only read what is on the web but are also given a chance to be co-creators of web information. It might therefore be said that the focus of the web is changing, from an informing to a conversational platform. Some of the particular web-based tools that enable this to occur are blogs, wikis and social categorisation sites. We will now investigate these particular tools. Weblogs are a more recent online communication tool and are defined as much by the way the tool is used as by the technology itself. Weblog entries are characterised by natural and spontaneous voice, frequent updates and a lack of formality; entries are made in the web-based log in chronological order. Weblog technology is a simple browser-based authoring tool that removes any technical barrier to participation. A weblog is, traditionally, a “log” on the web – a diary-style site in which the author - a weblogger, or “blogger”- links to other web pages he/she finds interesting. It is traditional for old entries to fall to the bottom as newer ones are added. Comments on each weblog posting provide the collaborative aspect of this tool. A wiki is a web page/site that can be viewed and changed by visitors to the site using only their browser technology. ‘A wiki, from the Hawaiian term for “quick”, is an ongoing, ever-evolving, organised compilation of information’ (Lee 2006). A site maintains a history of all the changes made to it, and an older version can be restored if need be. The community of interest surrounding a wiki tends to keep the content of a site valid and respectable. Wikis differ from weblogs in that: • • •
170
they have a collective rather than an individual voice they are structured by topic rather than chronologically changes to content take place organically – it is open to editing and evolution
•
there is an element trust in wiki use – while abuse is quite possible, the value and use of wikis is created by a watchful collective.
It is important to note that the use of wikis is different to traditional publishing, for example Wikipedia is a successful knowledge sharing phenomena but is not an authoritative traditional encyclopaedia and should not be viewed as such. The uses of wikis continue to emerge, but they clearly offer a collaborative potential and a new way of constructing and sharing knowledge repositories on the web. Social tagging (also called social bookmarking) sites have an initial role in the organisation of webbased information and resources for an individual – they provide a tool for personal management of resources and knowledge. Because of their emphasis on openness (users names are public and any user can view the information organisation of another) they are an excellent tool for sharing resources. Likeminded people or communities of interest will collect resources that can be easily accessed by others. With a significant number of users focusing on a sphere of interest, a pattern will emerge – a folksonomy. This becomes a means of discovering new information using the organisation systems of others whose interests are similar. Resources can be discovered by tags or by individuals. Key features of social tagging include the following: •
•
•
special web software/sites exist that enable a specific web resource, identified by its URL, to be tagged or labelled by the person who values it individual tagging of resources. The user of the resource assigns a keyword(s) to the resource in order to create categories of information. The users’ concepts and words are used rather than a formal, authorative vocabulary information is organised in a social
Collaborative Learning
•
environment; the outcomes are open and shared as the tagging of an object reaches a critical mass, common language and tags enable findability and sharing of resources.
The opportunities for using web 2.0 for collaborative learning are manifold and will be discussed later in the chapter. In this chapter, we used WebCT with its associated emails and discussion boards to design the collaborative learning examples that follow. Students used this platform to write about their practice, to do role plays of various kinds, to debate and defend ideas and to construct new understandings. With webcasting and the opportunity for students to work face to face, the examples in the section below can be expanded and learning deepened.
cAse exAMPLes The case examples that follow illustrate concepts of constructivism, collaborative learning principles and knowledge of online technology. These programs have been used in the education of social workers for practice in the human services.
netiquette Students in the human services practice and learn in groups. The ability to form and operate within a group context has become an essential skill in our “networked” world. Forming a group is never easy requiring effort, thought and clear communication from all members to be effective. In on line classes that entail online discussion, it is helpful to discuss netiquette, to provide parameters for social behavior in electronic communication. Students are asked to discuss in their groups ways in which they would like to be treated and to identify things they find intimidating or upsetting. Students’ views can be expressed on the bulletin board with the instructor responsible for collating
the information and using these guidelines as the basis for online communication. This exercise can be done online or in class.
online Group supervision with Assigned and rotating roles Supervision is an important learning strategy for students and workers in the human services. Supervision courses are generally part of graduate education programs and are provided to practitioners with professional experience who want to extend their theoretical understandings and practical experiences. There are two broad approaches to supervision. One is an individualistic approach where the supervisor and the student work in a dyad. The other is a group approach where students or peers work with a more experienced practitioner to provide the learning experience. These group approaches are most frequently based on collaborative relationships and use the expertise, strengths and capacities of group members to achieve learning outcomes. In the example that follows, the supervision course was taught as part of a MSW course called “social work practice education,” a topic for experienced students. It was a face to face intensive but the assessment was done as an online group supervision exercise over several following weeks. The aim of the course was to provide students with an opportunity to learn about group supervision with a focus on peer to peer collaboration and shared leadership and offering the opportunity to develop their personal practice theories of supervision. Many of these graduate students had already been supervisors using a dyadic approach. The technology used for this program was WebCT with the discussion forum and email being the main features utilized by students. Students were in small groups of no more than seven. Each student was asked to provide a small vignette of 50 words which could be discussed in an online environment. It was suggested that 171
Collaborative Learning
students use an example that a worker or beginning student may bring to a supervision session. One vignette was discussed every two weeks with the discussion being lead by the graduate student who had presented the vignette. Graduate students were asked not to bring material that was overly complex as the focus was on learning about collaborative supervisory skills. All material brought to class contained no identifying information to respect the privacy of clients or individuals within their example. Students were then assigned to roles that group members take in supervision, including coordinator/facilitator, presenter, integrator of theory and practice, critic, compromiser, summarizer, and wild card, On the discussion board, students were then asked to describe their allocated role, the characteristics of this role and examples of questions a person in this role might take. As students were rotating through various roles, the role descriptions were made available for the next students to see. In preparing this material, students were encouraged to use and make reference to group work literature. When a student completed discussing a practice example using a particular role, they provided their reflection on this role and added additional comments to assist the next student allocated that role. In this way, students reflected on their experience and developed practice theory about using particular roles developed. This provided the basis of formative assessment with the lecturer providing comments and questions.
Preparation for online Learning The importance of respectful relationships in the online environment was discussed in the intensive class prior to beginning the first online session with a set of agreed conventions developed by consensus. Whilst respectful relationships are always important in learning, they are more important when the focus is on supervision. Supervision is a process where professional competencies and performance are the focus of discussion. Students
172
whose professional performance is the subject of discussions, are sensitive to the supervisory relationship and the way information is communicated. Students used the concepts discussed in face to face classes on the supervisory relationship to build agreed goals and specify desired and undesirable behaviors. When consensus was reached, this information was posted. Students also attended a preliminary face to face teaching session in a teaching laboratory to familiarize themselves with WebCT including use of the bulletin boards, online chats and emails. The lecturer wanted to ensure that no time was lost due to trial and error learning creating disruptions to the group processes. Students used this meeting to make their general online introductions to each other and establish working relationships. Although students occupied the same classroom when completing this task there was little face to face discussion.
outcomes There was no formal evaluation of this course although students did provide comments on their learning and the process. The lecturer also provided comments to students throughout the program. Students were very positive about their learning experience. As one vignette was discussed every two weeks, students found they needed to connect to WebCT and discuss the vignette on a day to day basis. During the course, one student was unable to access WebCT because of a computer virus which meant an absence of many days from the class. The failure of one member to participate in group activities had a big impact on group functioning particularly given the allocation of roles. Here the member holding the wild card could step in and take over the missing member’s role to ensure maintenance of cohesion. The most important role was that of coordinator. The importance of this role in maintaining group functioning was initially underestimated by both students and the lecturer. All students took
Collaborative Learning
a turn in this role. Throughout the functioning of the group, the skills of the coordinator improved with active learning from the prior experiences of students who proceeded them in this role. In the initial session, the student with the role of facilitator was reminded to take the initiative. Checking the web and being on time became an important student learning task. Although there was no formal evaluation, the lecturer was pleased with the learning experience. There was a high degree of trust between the students within the online environment and it is assumed that this developed in the intensive that preceded the online work. Students were provided with an opportunity to make the transition from the safety and security of the face to face environment to online work by having the first session in a computer laboratory. Anxieties were eased allowing students to focus on their tasks. The students participated in a collaborative learning group and demonstrated the features of positive interdependence, individual accountability, shared leadership, and responsibility for each other. Throughout the group supervision, students stayed on task and learnt the importance of social skills. If this course was to be repeated, the lecturer would have fewer vignettes with discussion taking place over several weeks. This would allow for more thoughtful conceptualization of roles, greater reflection on the process and the elaboration of practice theory for group supervision.
debates, students were expected to take account of their responsibility to clients, their employing agency, self and profession. Students in groups of six to ten were allocated a controversial issue on social work ethics for discussion. They were required to research their allocated topic using on-line electronic library resources and in 500 words post a commentary to the bulletin board. The first bulletin board had particular requirements. Students were required to:
controversial Issues
3.
The aim of this course was to introduce students to the ethics and values underpinning professional practice and to enable students to reflect on the way in which their personal beliefs and values constrain and influence practice decisions. Collaborative learning was achieved through an online assessment where students discussed controversial ethical issues. These controversial issues were written as “ought statements” that indicated how social workers should behave in their professional practice. In reflecting on these
4.
•
• •
•
Justify the controversial issue as stated (even if they disagreed with the statement - many so doing) Examine practice implications of the controversial issue Identify a claimant (or stakeholder) and then determine what the person would want you, as a professional, to do about that issue and Specify the social worker’s professional obligations to that person. The discussion topics included whether:
1.
2.
5. 6.
Clients who express racist attitudes about other people in counseling sessions should be challenged by social workers. Social workers should report all ethical infringements by colleagues to their professional ethics committee. Touching clients should always be avoided in social work practice Sexual intimacies with current and former clients should be prohibited. Religious issues should not be discussed in work with clients Social workers should not disclose identifying information when discussing clients with supervisors unless the client has consented to the disclosure of confidential information or there is a compelling need for such disclosure.
173
Collaborative Learning
As part of this process students were asked to use collaborative concepts and complete several activities:Research the allocated topic using reading material and electronic journals Post the commentary to the discussion group and give your posting a title. In this commentary include: 1. 2. 3.
4. 5.
A justification of the ought statement Examination of the practice implications of the ought statements Identification of one claimant in the ought statement (e.g. client, agency, supervisor, professional association, family member) Determination of what that claimant would prefer you to do in this situation Your professional obligations to that claimant.
After reading the original comments posted by other students in your group, provide at least two questions, and comments on, and responses to student postings presented on the bulletin board. Take into account the netiquette exercise and ways to assist other students. Reflect on the online discussion including the comments of your peers and submit your written paper. Students were required to justify the “ought statement” irrespective of their personal or professional views. This was very difficult for some students as they did not agree with either a part or the whole of the statement. It was here that the collaborative efforts of all students with their questions, responses and postings enabled co-learners to see the statement from different viewpoints. In a class prior to the online discussions, students were given a series of questions to challenge themselves and support others as part of assistance with the learning task. For example, when thinking about the “ought statement,” students could question whether the “ought statement” applied to every practice situation as a matter of principle
174
or only to particular groups. They were asked to think of any exceptions to their statement and consider occasions when the statement would be always justified or never justified. Finally, students were asked if and how the statement might be qualified. As students had diverse experiences prior to attending university and during their placement experiences, they were able to see these statements in a variety of different contexts and use this to explore the validity of the contention. Students used these diverse experiences to talk about stakeholders and claimants thus adding to the richness of the learning. The final part of this process was a reflection paper. In this first posting students were asked to justify a stated position. In this reflection paper students were able to outline their personal position on the paper including where and how they developed these views. They were asked if and how their views had changed over the course of the assignment and whether other students challenged and changed their views. It was in and through this process that the benefits of students working together on the one task became evident. The perspective of each student and their representation of different stakeholders enabled perspective taking and the differentiation of the views of others (Johnson, Johnson, Holubec and Roy 1984). Students clearly indicated that they started the discussion with uncompromising attitudes toward the topic but through the process of reading and responding to the views of other students, their views changed significantly. These changed views were more sophisticated and noted exceptions and qualifications to the statement. The benefits of the online learning examining controversial issues came through student feedback (Cooper 2001).
Collaborative Learning
the Future The impact of the Internet on our working lives is significant and we must develop competencies in the use of the online environment for communication, knowledge sharing and teamwork. The 21st century also brings the challenge of continual learning and workplace change. Providing tertiary human services students the experience of learning collaboratively using communication technologies is preparing them for a lifetime in a workplace where ability to learn, adaptation to change and effective participation in global communication technologies are a critical set of skills. An ability to learn throughout life is now of greater benefit than any body of domain knowledge that we may possess at any one time. Changes in careers and the nature of work are now commonplace throughout a person’s life. It is increasingly likely that people will work longer and in a variety of guises than at any time in the past. Some of the most desirable skills in the workplace are interpersonal. The ability to communicate and maintain productive relationships with colleagues and to work in teams and across communities is central to an effective learning organization. Imbuing students with the ability to learn in collaborative situations is central to lifelong learning. We work and live in a society that increasingly demands an ability to learn, communicate and relate to others in an online environment. This requires an ability to find and synthesize digital information, integrate it into decision making processes and to effectively connect and work with people within and across organizational boundaries. Teamwork in virtual communities using online tools is a valued skill. The Internet is ubiquitous and competencies and discernment in using it effectively are essential. Collaborative learning online has, to date, been largely enabled by the communication tools that are encompassed in enterprise learning management systems (LMS). Educational institutions invest significantly in these online course systems
and individual teachers have been restricted in their choice of online communication tool to those that are offered within the LMS. Over the last fifteen years, LMS technology has provided a platform for significant innovation in teaching online, especially in the use of the discussion forum. But being sizeable and tightly integrated “whole of organization” systems, LMS lack the agility to quickly integrate the new and innovative tools of the Internet. The increasing uptake, availability and prominence of Web 2.0 technologies is now offering collaborative learning new tools with great promise. There is a new agility, open access and choice in the lightweight suite of tools of Web 2.0. Many Web 2.0 technologies are freeware and are easy to establish and use. With increasing frequency, a collaborative learning exercise takes place outside the enterprise systems of the educational institution and utilizes the Web 2.0 tools of the open web. We have trialed the use of wikis for knowledge building and sharing class activities with Masters’ students studying in fully online mode. Students were required to collectively build a repository of knowledge in a specific knowledge domain by co-authoring the web pages of a wiki. All students had full access to shape the content and structure of the web space – they were required for assessment purposes to write a reflective article on their experience of this social media and to identify any problems or prejudices that this activity presented to them. Social tagging activities have also been explored by the authors where the class selected and tagged web resources in a particular domain. The class resources were “aggregated” by predetermining one tag for all members of the class. We predict that the future of collaborative learning in an online environment will be rich in the use of the agile tools of Web 2.0. With the introduction of new technologies, there will be increasing use of participatory pedagogical approaches. Fountain (2005) points out that as Web 2.0 tools such as wikis are used for
175
Collaborative Learning
collaborative learning activities in universities; they will in turn unsettle and challenge traditional pedagogical practices and norms. Wikis are spaces of shared, unfinished and unacknowledged authorship and ‘are based on a principle of non-exclusive authority’ (Fountain, 2005). Contrast this to the traditional power structures around knowledge and strongly owned authorship that is found in universities. The future will reveal the interplay of these issues.
concLusIon Collaborative online learning is a successful strategy for teaching social work. It draws on constructivist learning principles and findings from educational researchers at the Centre for Cooperative Learning at the University of Minnesota. These researchers found that collaborative learning provides an effective learning and teaching strategies that can be used is many different educational environments. Collaborative learning draws on group work principles especially concepts of group formation, stages of group development, and communication within groups. This form of learning is particularly beneficial for social work education in the online environment. The introduction of web based technologies has allowed this effective educational strategy to be used in the online environment with effective results. This chapter provides examples of how collaborative learning has been used in social work education at the undergraduate and graduate level. With the introduction of newer technologies, it is expected that participatory strategies will increase and unsettle the traditional teaching practices in professional education.
reFerences Arbaugh, J. (2000). Virtual classroom characteristics and student satisfaction with Internet-based MBA courses. Journal of Management Education, 24(1), 32–54. doi:10.1177/105256290002400104 Barkley, E. F., Cross, K. P., & Major, C. H. (2005). Collaborative learning techniques: A handbook for college faculty. San Francisco: Jossey Bass. Brahler, J., Peterson, N., & Johnson, E. (1999). Developing online learning materials for higher education: An overview of current issues. Educational Technology and Society, 2(2), 1–8. Brook, C., & Oliver, R. (2003). Online learning communities: Investigating a design framework. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 19(2), 139–160. Bruffee, K. A. (1992). Collaborative learning and the “Conversation of Mankind.” In A. S. Goodsell, M. R. Maher, & V. Tinto (Eds.), Collaborative learning: A sourcebook for higher education. University Park, PA: National Centre on Postsecondary Teaching. Cecez-Kecmanovic, D., & Webb, C. (2000). Towards a communicative model of collaborative Web-mediated learning. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 16(1), 73–85. Clark, J. (2000). Collaboration tools in online learning environments. Asynchronous Learning Networks Magazine, 4(1). Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http://www.aln.org/publications/ magazine/v4n1/clark.asp Cooper, L. (2001). Teaching controversial issues on-line. New Technology in the Human Services, 13(3-4), 11–21. Curtis, D., & Lawson, M. (2001). Exploring collaborative online learning. Journal of Asynchronous Learning Networks, 5(1), 22–34.
176
Collaborative Learning
Dewey, J. (1938). Experience and education. New York: Collier. Fountain, R. (2005). Wiki pedagogy. Dossiers pratiques, profetic. Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http://www.profetic.org/dossiers/dossier_ imprimer.php3?id_rubrique=110 Freire, P. (1993). Pedagogy of the oppressed. New York: Continuum. Gay, G., Sturgill, A., & Martin, W. (1999). Document-centered peer collaborations: An exploration of the educational uses of networked communication technologies. Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 4(3). Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http://jcmc.indiana.edu/vol4/issue3/ gay.html Goldenberg, J. (1999). Virtual learning communities: A student’s perspective. Journal of Instruction Delivery Systems, 13(2), 16–20. Grabe, M., & Grabe, C. (Eds.). (2001). Integrating technology for meaningful learning (3rd ed.). Boston, MA: Houghton Mifflin. Hanson, J. M., & Sinclair, K. E. (2008). Social constructivist teaching methods in Australian universities - reported uptake and perceived learning effects: A survey of lecturers. Higher Education Research & Development, 27(3), 169–186. doi:10.1080/07294360802183754 Hiltz, S. R. (1994). The virtual classroom: Learning without limits via computer networks. Norwood, NJ: Ablex. Johnson, D. W., & Johnson, F. P. (2009). Joining together: Group theory and group skills. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson. Johnson, D. W., Johnson, R. J., & Stanne, M. B. (2000). Cooperative learning methods: A metaanalysis. Retrieved October 13, 2008 from http:// www.co-operation.org/pages/cl-methods.html
Johnson, D. W., Johnson, R. T., Holubec, E., & Roy, P. (1984). Circles of learning: Cooperation in the classroom. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Johnson, D. W., Johnson, R. T., Holubec, E. D., & Roy, P. (1984). Circles of learning: Cooperation in the classroom. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development. Johnson, D. W., Johnson, R. T., & Smith, K. (1991). Cooperative learning: Increasing college faculty instructional productivity (ASHE-ERIC Higher Education Report No. 4). Washington, DC: The George Washington University, School of Education and Human Development. Johnson, D. W., Johnson, R. T., & Smith, K. A. (1991). Active learning: Cooperation in the classroom. Edina, MN: Interaction Book Company. Johnson, R., & Johnson, D. (1994). An overview of cooperative learning. In J. Thousand, A. Villa, & A. Nevin (Eds.), Creativity and collaborative learning: A practical guide to empowering students and teachers (pp. 31-43). Baltimore, MD: Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co. Lave, J., & Wenger, E. (1991). Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Lee, E. (2005). The wonderful world of Wikis. Contra Costa Times. Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http://www.accessmylibrary.com/coms2/ summary_0286-31685346_ITM McLoughlin, C., & Luca, J. (2000). Cognitive engagement and higher order thinking through computer conferencing: We know why but do we know how? In A. Herrmann & M. M. Kulski (Eds.), Flexible futures in tertiary teaching, Proceedings of the 9th Annual Teaching Learning Forum, Perth, Curtin University of Technology. Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http://lsn.curtin. edu.au/tlf/tlf2000/mcloughlin.html
177
Collaborative Learning
Millis, B. J., & Cottell, P. G., Jr. (1998). Cooperative learning for higher education faculty. Phoenix, AZ: The Oryx Press.
Schon, D. (1983). The reflective practitioner: How professionals think in action. New York: Basic Books.
Nachmias, R., Mioduser, D., Oren, A., & Ram, J. (2000). Web-supported emergent- collaboration in higher education courses. Journal of Educational Technology & Society, 3(3), 94–104.
Schon, D. (1987). Educating the reflective practitioner: Toward a new design for teaching and learning in the professions. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass.
Naidu, S., Ip, A., & Linser, R. (2000). Dynamic goal-based role-play simulation on the Web: A case study. Educational Technology & Society, 3(3), Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http:// www.ifets.info/journals/3_3/b05.html
Slavin, R. E. (1990). Cooperative learning: Theory, research and practice. Boston, MA: Allyn & Bacon.
O’Reilly, T. (2005). What is Web2.0: Design patterns and business models for the next generation of software. Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http://oreillynet.com/lpt/a/6228 Panitz, T. (1997). Collaborative versus cooperative learning – a comparison of the two concepts which will help us understand the underlying nature of interactive learning. Cooperative Learning and College Teaching, 8(2), 5–14. Papert, S., & Harel, I. (1991). Constructionism. Norwood, NJ: Ablex Publishing Corporation. Resnick, M. (1996). Distributed constructionism. In D. Edelson & E. A. Domeshek (Eds.), ICLS ‘96: Proceedings of the 1996 international conference on learning sciences (pp. 280-284). Evanston, IL: International Society of the Learning Sciences. Rogoff, B. (1990). Apprenticeship in thinking: Cognitive development in social context. New York: Oxford University Press.
Smith, M. K. (2005). Bruce W. Tuckman - forming, storming, norming and performing in groups. The encyclopaedia of informal education. Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http://www.infed.org/ thinkers/tuckman.htm Treleaven, L. (2003). Evaluating a communicative model for Web mediated collaborative learning and design. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 19(1), 100–117. Turoff, M. (1999). An end to student segregation: No more separation between distance learning and regular courses. Retrieved October 13, 2008, from http://web.njit.edu/~turoff/Papers/canadapresent/ segregation.htm Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind and society: The development of higher psychological processes. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice: Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press.
This work was previously published in Information Communication Technologies for Human Services Education and Delivery: Concepts and Cases, edited by J. Martin; L. Hawkins, pp. 37-52, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
178
179
Chapter 1.13
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom:
Bringing Theory and Practice to E-Learning F.R. “Fritz” Nordengren Des Moines University, USA Ann M. York Des Moines University, USA
AbstrAct
IntroductIon
This chapter is a practical overview of both the theoretical, evidence-based research in pedagogy and the anecdotal, experience-based practices of faculty who work daily in online and blended learning communities. This approach combines best practices with theoretical aspects of delivering and facilitating education with diverse adult learners. Issues and trends in E-learning are presented with specific examples for implementation and suggestions for future research. Using an evidence-based approach, the authors will explore and summarize recent research with a concurrent analysis of the anecdotal popular literature. The authors explore the concept of information literacy and other skills necessary to succeed in the Web 2.0 world. Their discussion takes us away from the traditional “sage on stage” versus “guide on side” dichotomy towards both a new understanding of Web 2.0’s role in education as well as a preface to what may become Web 3.0 and beyond.
This chapter is intended to lay a foundation for Elearning and Web 2.0 for readers from a wide range of experiences. It will provide both a theoretical overview of evidence-based research in pedagogy, and experience-based practices of faculty who work in online and blended learning communities. It is important to blend both theory and practice to fully appreciate the power, influence, and potential of Web 2.0. Experienced educators may gain a fresh appreciation of how familiar theories may apply in an E-learning environment. New educators may gain insight and ideas on how to implement E-learning in an effective way. Whether experienced or novice, one thing is certain: we are all pioneers in on the digital path of E-learning. As pioneers on this trail, we are beginning to leave a traditional classroom setting where lectures dominate, and move toward an educational environment where technology-enhanced instruction is becoming the norm. In this new environment, learning may take place completely online in a synchronous or asynchronous format. Or, it may take place in a combination of face-to-face and
DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-788-1.ch021
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
online learning, commonly known as blended learning. Even in courses where lecture is still the primary mode of delivery, technology is playing an increasing prominent role. When faced with the broad landscape of E-learning technology, many educators may feel unprepared, and perhaps even a bit lost. The term “pioneer” often conjures up images of American pioneers pushing across the Great Plains to reach the promise of a new life in the West. Like them, today’s E-learning pioneers are balancing the known with the unknown; balancing the tried and proven with the tried but not yet proven. And, like a pioneer exploring new territory, today’s E-learning pioneers are seeking landmarks or milestones by which to gauge progress. In this chapter, there are several landmarks to guide the way: • • •
Landmark One: How Does Educational Theory Apply to E-learning? Landmark Two: Technology: Web 2.0 and Beyond? Landmark Three: Practical Implementation: Issues, Controversies, Strategies and Tactics
While these landmarks cover a lot of territory, here is a caveat: there is simply no way to capture the full panaoramic view. In fact, at the current rate of change, by the time this book is published, new tools will have emerged and early adopters may be charting Web 3.0. Educators will constantly need to be adding new landmarks and charting experiences as discoveries are made. To assist in navigation, for the purpose of this chapter, the phrase E-learning means education delivered entirely online. The phrase blended learning means online tools mixed with classroom or other face-to-face learning experiences. Web 2.0 refers to the increased online collaboration and interaction made possible by tools such as blogs, wikis, and social networking sites. With this in mind, the chapter objectives are to:
180
1.
2.
3.
Understand key theoretical concepts for blended and E-learning applied to adult learners. Analyze current research and anecdotal evidence on blended and E-learning strategies. Evaluate and create best practices in blended and E-learning using Web 2.0 tools.
The focus of this chapter is on higher education, although much of the material also applies to K-12. The emphasis is on adult learners as they are increasingly turning to online education for earning degrees, updating knowledge, and the sheer pleasure of life-long learning. This population of adult learners is highly diverse, spanning not only generations, but continents and cultures. This diversity brings tremendous richness to the learning experience, and significant challenges to the educator. Combine this student diversity with new models of delivery, the everincreasing choices of technology, expectations for 24/7 access, and the pressure to demonstrate learning outcomes, and the result is a changing landscape that can easily overwhelm educators and administrators. While it is daunting to keep up with the pace of change, immobility is not an option. To help clear the path forward, this chapter is designed to stimulate careful reflection of not only the “how” but the “why” of using Web 2.0 tools. Ultimately, the goal is to facilitate bringing Web 2.0 to Learning 2.0 and beyond.
bAcKGround Landmark one: how does educational theory Apply to e-learning? Analyzing Web 2.0 tools within a theoretical context can assist educators to understand the efficacy of their use and to guide future research. Many of these Web 2.0 digital tools can be viewed as a
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
serious E-learning utility; others as a fun novelty shared between friends. However, it is easy to blur the lines between novelty and utility. The outcome might result in the development of a brilliant Elearning application; other times it can result in failure. Second Life®, an Internet-based virtual world, is a good example of a tool that has been both an educational success and a failure, depending on the application (Beguja, 2007). While there is research evidence to support the educational use of some Web 2.0 tools, other tools are too new or have not yet been subjected to research, so have only anecdotal support. In this section, the discussion of Web 2.0 tools opens by touching briefly on some of the key concepts in educational discourse. Some are theories; others are concepts or terms that are often used in E-learning/blended learning environments. This is not intended to be a definitive review on this subject, but rather to provide a way to view Web 2.0 through a pedagogical lens. Pedagogy typically refers to the type or style of instructional method a teacher employs. Originally stemming from the Greek for child, in recent years the term pedagogy has often been expanded to include all levels of instruction. Essentially, pedagogy tends to be more teacher-focused, and looks at the art and science of instruction. In 1950, Malcolm Knowles introduced the concept that instruction of adults was unique and coined the term andragogy. He proposed that adults were more self-directed and, therefore, required more learner-focused educational activities. As anyone who has taught adults can attest, not every adult is self-directed. An adult-learner’s self-directed abilities may be situational, or based on prior experience in a specific area. Another way to view this pedagogy/andragogy dichotomy is not in an age-related way, but rather to look at education on a continuum from teacher-centered to learner-centered. Depending on the topic and the experience of the student, the teacher can make a decision where along the
continuum to present the material. For example, a teacher can design a course to move from being teacher-centered (lectures, didactic materials) at the beginning to more learner-centered (individual and collaborative projects) as the course progresses and the topic builds in complexity. A related topic is the dichotomy of “digital natives” and “digital immigrants.” Prensky (2001) posited that younger learners think and use technology differently than older learners. Prensky defined digital natives as “Today’s students – K through college,” and digital immigrants as “the rest of us.” This distinction is open to debate and, while often used as convenient nomenclature, it appears to lack a significant body of evidence to support it (Bennett, Matron & Kervin, 2008). Many of the differences between the two groups that Prensky described in 2001 seem to have disappeared as many digital immigrants have adopted a digital lifestyle and become very adept at using new media. Also, it has become apparent that many of the digital natives, while heavy users of digital media, are not adept at using it for learning or work. In other words, heavy use does not equal uniform competence. Furthermore, many of the descriptors attributed to digital natives are similar to traits attributed to adult learners by Knowles (1950). He began with four traits and later added a fifth trait to learning styles as a person matures: self-concept, experience, readiness to learn, orientation to learning, and motivation to learn (Knowles, Holton & Swanson, 2005). The idea that digital natives (younger learners) may share traits with digital immigrants (older learners) creates a riddle for the E-learning pioneer to solve. The solution may be to avoid distinct lines along generations, and to look more closely at the skill sets needed to be successful with Web 2.0 learning. Regardless of the label or the generation, it is the opportunity for active learning that makes many of the Web 2.0 tools attractive to both the learner and the faculty member.
181
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
Learning Theories and Their Relationship to Web 2.0 The concept of active learning is at the heart of the theory of constructivism. While there are many variations of this theory, constructivism is fundamentally based on the principle that students construct knowledge individually rather than receiving it passively from others; they learn best when engaged in active learning rather than being “spoon-fed” the information. Learning occurs by engaging in authentic, relevant tasks, hands-on learning, exploration and critical thinking rather than memorizing and reciting facts (Fosnot, 2005). The foundation of constructivism is grounded in the work of Dewey, Piaget, Vygotsky and others. An example of constructivism in a blended or E-learning classroom would be students who engage in constructing knowledge through realistic, problem-based learning scenarios, gradually scaffolding their knowledge by taking on more complex scenarios. Social constructivism goes a step further to view each student as capable of constructing his or her own version of knowledge based on their unique background, culture, experience, and worldview. While the instructor should take into account each person’s unique background (cultural competency), the responsibility for learning increasingly falls upon the learner. Tactics such as reflection, problem-based learning, group projects, and peer-reviews support constructivism. While widely viewed as fundamental to online teaching and learning, constructivism has critics. Lack of evidence, lack of effectiveness with novice learners who have not yet developed a strong foundation of mental models, groupthink, and busy work without true learning are cited as weaknesses (Mayer, 2004; Kirschner, Sweller, & Clark, 2006). Another prominent theory to emerge in recent years is connectivism, which espouses that that learning can occur through networks of people
182
sharing pieces of information to create integrated knowledge (Siemens, 2004). In connectivism, learning is not completely under the control of the individual. Rather, knowledge is created and acquired in a rapidly changing network of people. Connections between ideas and the ability to continually acquire new information are vital. As we have moved from information scarcity to information abundance, knowledge management and information flow is essential, from the individual to the network, then back again. In connectivism, this process of flow may be even more important than the content itself. From this perspective, the new technology tools of Web 2.0 have enhanced the ability to network, so the Internet leverages the small efforts of many with the large efforts of few (Brown, 2000). Incorporating elements of both constructivism and connectivism is the model of Community of Inquiry (Garrison, Anderson, & Archer, 2000). At the core of this theory are three interconnected elements: cognitive presence (the ability of participants to construct meaning through sustained communication), social presence (the ability of learners to connect on a meaningful level with other learners and teachers), and teaching presence (the creation and facilitation of cognitive and social processes that lead to meaningful educational outcomes). This approach is more holistic and attempts to capture not only the content, but also the context in which we learn and work in today’s world. Therefore, learning is dynamic, ongoing, and dependent on internal cognitive processes as well context and social interaction, whether face-to-face or online. This approach to education brings up a very important concept: learning how to learn is as important as the learning the content matter itself. As the shelf life of knowledge decreases, and the flow of information from multiple sources increases, concepts such as metacognition and life-long learning become essential.
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
Overarching Concepts in Pedagogy Metacognition is considered to be the awareness of one’s own cognitive processes. In essence, it allows a student to metaphorically step outside of her own brain and take an objective view of her thought processes; to think about thinking. An educator can stimulate metacognition in students by guiding them to engage in reflective processes, asking questions like: “What do I already know about this topic? How can I best approach this? What is my best learning style? Where do I struggle?” Some Web 2.0 tools can be used to facilitate metacognitive processes individually (e.g., blogs, mindmaps) or as groups (e.g., discussion boards, wikis, peer reviews). There is an iterative cycle to metacognition; a plan, do, study, act cycle by which learners can bootstrap themselves along the path of lifelong learning (Worral & Bell, 2007). The metacognitive process is a key element of self-directed learners (Bransford, Brown, & Cocking, 2000), and plays a role in the development of information literacy. These topics have potential for further theoretical development, and more implementation strategies are suggested in the application section, Landmark Three. While the focus of Web 2.0 is on collaboration, every group is still made up of individuals, each with his or her own unique learning style and educational goals. Hence, some educators and psychologists have postulated that a student’s learning style has an impact on E-learning or classroom success. A number of tools exist to provide a summary of a student’s learning style such as Kolb Learning Style Inventory (LSI), the Meyers-Briggs Type Indicator® (MBTI), Kiersey Temperament Sorter. These tools provide the learner with some insight into how others with similar preferences achieve positive outcomes from learning situations. An area of opportunity in educational research is to examine these learning styles within the context of Web 2.0 tools. For example, the Keirsey Temperament Sorter®-II (KTS®-II) divides learners into four tempera-
ments: Artisans™, Guardians™, Rationals™ and Idealists™ and then further assigns each of those into four subgroups. The 16 total groups mirror the MBTI® type, but look more closely at implications for learning. For example, Keirsey-defined Guardians represent a plurality of the American population, and one of the traits of this group is the desire for belonging and working within a group setting. Previous to Web 2.0 social networking tools, computer-assisted instruction was primarily a solo activity. Web 2.0 opens a new realm of connectivity and, therefore, potential for new research. For example, today’s teens use social network sites as their primary communication, rather than e-mail (Lenhart, Madden, Macgill & Smith, 2007). As these teens move into higher education, E-learning has the potential to become less of a solo experience and more of a social experience, bringing new study opportunities to education researchers who wish to reach out to all kinds of learners. Current research in brain science about how people learn (Jenson, 2000; Sousa, 2006) can be incorporated into pedagogy, and will impact our educational theories. Perhaps the most popular of the recent books is Brain Rules (Medina, 2008). Summarizing peer-reviewed research in brain research, Medina has distilled the evidence into twelve rules of how the brain works, many of which are applicable to the E-learning/blended educator. Four are summarized here, and the others can be easily accessed in the book and related website. One finding is that vision is the dominant sense, but it is still important to stimulate all the senses. To the educator, this means to use not only more pictures, but consider other visual clues to guiding learning and content. Graphic design may include subtle or bold colors, organic or geometric shapes, and other visual clues to help establish context and organize content. Text designed for the printed page (traditionally vertical or portrait in orientation) should be laid out differently when designed for the screen (traditionally horizontal or
183
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
landscape in orientation). With the increasing use of digital devices such as the iPhone and Kindle, (Amazon’s wireless reading device), more human interface research will lead to best practices for visual presentation. Other research summarized in Brain Rules debunks the idea that multi-tasking during learning is good, while confirming our suspicion that boring content is bad. Educators can address these issues by grouping information into smaller chunks presented in a compelling manner to keep students interested and focused (Ruhl, Hughes, & Schloss, 1987). Furthermore, every brain is wired differently (see learning styles above), but we tend to see things in patterns, and memory is reinforced with repetition. Educators can facilitate student learning by helping them to “connect the dots,” and to build repetition into concept scaffolding. Finally, Medina (2007) reports good news for lifelong learners. Brains are malleable enough to develop new connections as long as people are willing to exercise curiosity. Many of these concepts certainly ring true and mesh with our anecdotal experiences, but it is immensely satisfying to have supportive evidence. Just as health care is increasingly embracing evidence-based medicine, we in education must be open to new ideas, new research, new tools, and especially new evidence. Before moving onto the next Landmark, stop for a moment to reflect on this brief overview of educational theory and research. What philosophy of education do you bring to your classes? What approach would you like to know more about? What is your personal learning style? What metacognitive tools do you use during/after your classes to incorporate new learning into your pedagogy? What aspect of brain research can you integrate into your current teaching repertoire?
184
Landmark two: technology: web 2.0 and beyond To discuss technology and Web 2.0, it is both ironic and befitting to quote Wikipedia® on the topic: ”Web 2.0 is a term which describes the trend in the use of World Wide Web technology and web design that aims to enhance creativity, information sharing, and, most notably, collaboration among users. These concepts have led to the development and evolution of web-based communities and hosted services, such as social-networking sites, wikis, blogs, and folksonomies. The term became notable after the first O’Reilly Media Web 2.0 conference in 2004” (2008). The nature of websites like Wikipeida is both collaborative and mercurial. It is likely that by the time this book reaches the bookshelf, the above definition may have been revised numerous times. Grasping the full array of technological tools of Web 2.0 is much like assembling a list of supplies for the great trip West taken by early pioneers. The challenge with so many ever-changing choices is to decide where to begin and what is essential? What is the best way to prepare for the uncertain path ahead? To study the application of Web 2.0 to education is also to study of the diffusion of innovation. Rogers’ (2003) seminal work in this area illustrated that adoption of a new technology typically progresses through the stages of awareness, interest, evaluation, trial, and adoption. The process begins slowly as early adopters focus on the technology, followed by rapid adoption as the majority get on board, then levels off as the laggards who took a “wait and see” approach slowly adapt. Attend any educational technology conference and it will be clear that Web 2.0 and technology
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
innovation is not being adopted at the same rate across campuses, and this is to be expected. No matter if one has just begun learning the basic set up of an online discussion board, and another has launched a series of podcasts supplemented by RSS feeds, updated via Twitter, all aggregated within a Pageflakes page; all of us are on the same path to discover the connection between Web 2.0 and Learning 2.0. As a beginning, once an educator has a fundamental understanding of what some of the tools do, it is easy to see the counterparts in a traditional pedagogy. A written assignment is, more or less, the same whether it is handed in, written in a blue exam book, posted to a discussion board, or e-mailed. Likewise, a learning circle or face-toface discussion group is similar in both outcome and participation to a threaded discussion board, or a real time chat. However, to understand the potential beyond these similarities is to harness the true potential of Web 2.0 tools. What drives the success of the Web 2.0 tools is that not only do they bridge distance and time; they rely on collaboration for the tool to work at all. A social network site does not have any of its core usability without the social network. As a contrast, a traditional Web page functions as it is intended, whether one person or one million read it. But without the connections inherent in Web 2.0 tools, the tools do not work. To illustrate this concept, consider a colleague who was an early pioneer in web media and online journalism. Despite his online experience that dates back to the early 1990’s, he didn’t join Facebook until recently. When he finally created a profile in the popular social networking site, he sent a puzzled e-mail saying, “What’s the big deal? You post your profile and photo, your friend posts their profile and photo. Then what?” Within a few days, however, he had several hundred “friends”, as his colleagues who were already on Facebook discovered his new profile. His point is well taken, however. Without the social network, what is the big deal?
To understand and use Web 2.0 tools in the classroom is to understand that educators are creating a space that they do not control (although they may guide) and the learning space is one that will grow, evolve, and develop. This lack of control can be threatening to some educators who are more comfortable with a traditional command and control lecture situation. However, transferring a lecture to the small flat screen does not typically work well--not only is it flat, it is boring (see Brain Rules above). This is where putting some thought into who, what, where, and why can help the educator to design the best way to present content in an online or blended format. Furthermore, as the volume of curricular content has grown, it is simply not possible to personally experience or actively learn all necessary knowledge. Hence, decisions must be made about what to include and what to leave out. In a popular YouTube video presentation “Did You Know?” viewers read, “The amount of technical information is doubling every two years By 2010, it’s predicted to double . . . every 72 hours” (Fisch & McLeod, 2007). While the specific rate of information growth may be open to debate, the fact remains that we are increasingly overloaded with new information, and we are increasingly accessing it through the Internet and social networks rather by individual students sitting in a library carrel or in a lecture hall. In step with the growth of information is the growth of information creators. The Pew Internet and American Life Project identified that 64 percent of teenagers ages 12 - 17 engage in “at least one type of content creation” (Lenhart, Madden, Macgill & Smith, 2007). As more Internet users shift from being strictly information consumers to information creators, learners need strategies in information literacy and information management. Web 2.0 tools both contribute to information overload, and offer options for information filtering and management. To illustrate these information literacy challenges, the “Did you know” video provides a
185
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
good example. The creators of the video (Fisch & McLeod, 2007) note that they represented the overall trend in information growth in the video while acknowledging that they used some sources that were not “hard” or “scholarly.” Nevertheless, the video reached “viral” status which means it was downloaded and shared widely. This exemplifies a paradox for the legitimacy of non-traditional resources. On the one hand, the lack of “hard” or “scholarly” sources does leave the data suspect in the terms of traditional peer review. However, after being seen by 5 million online viewers, the data has become a virtual “fact” in conversations among educators and Web 2.0 enthusiasts, repeated in promotional materials for recent conferences and other speakers. This example creates opportunity for educators not only to teach the process of peer review, but also, to teach the debate about what is information literacy in these new times. Another related concept is the half-life of information. This is a borrowed phrase from nuclear physics and was used initially in the late 1950’s to describe literature obsolesce. The concept was based on the idea that just as materials decay in quantity, so too, literature decays in its value. The study of information decay has often been linked to the frequency of literature citations. A reference may be cited 100 times a year, then 90, then 80 and so on. The challenge with this concept is that unlike a direct measurement, the usefulness of literature also has a context. For example, a map drawn 10 years ago may have little utility today as new streets have been built and housing developments arise. It may, on the other hand, have high utility in the future for historians. These concepts of information doubling and information half-life are often linked, but are not always directly related. There is a note of caution and intrigue that accompanies these discussions of Web 2.0 tools, and to get to it requires another short side journey. Bowling Alone (Putnam, 2000) brought the discussion of social capital to the national best-seller list. Its subtitle, “The Collapse and Revival of Ameri-
186
can Community,” implies that we have dissolved many of the units that created and fostered social capital in the United States. The title stems from the fact that the number of Americans who bowl is growing, but the number who bowl in leagues is diminishing. In one chapter on education, Putnam shares the impact of social capital on educations and learners, “In other words, at Harvard as well as Harlem, social connectedness boosts educational attainment” (Putnam, 2000). The irony of this statement, written prior to the development of most Web 2.0 tools, is that these new Web 2.0 tools are intrinsically driven by social capital. The currency of a social network is the number of friends in your network. However, the current debate of both K-12 and higher education administrations is whether or not to ban the use of these tools in the classroom (Simon, 2008). This is one of the controversies and decisions that will impact what educators will adopt for use in the classroom. Before moving on to the final landmark, this is a good time for the reader to pause and reflect on what place Web 2.0 tools have in education. What tools are you currently using? Where are you on the technology adoption curve? Should social network sites such as Second Life and Facebook be used in the classroom? Do you have any restrictions, either due to technology availability or administrative access, in your educational institution? How are you managing information overload/half-life issues? What are the next steps you can take to learn about Web 2.0 tools for educational use?
Landmark three: Practical Implementation: Issues, controversies, strategies and tactics On this final leg of the journey, the focus is on anecdotal, experienced-based implementation Web 2.0 in the classroom. The approach is necessary, as many of the concepts, tools, and usages
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
are too new to be fully supported by evidencetested theory. This does not limit their potential or efficacy, but does leave room for missteps, discovery, and innovation. One of the first things to consider within blended and E-learning is that there is an abundance of duplicative tools in the space called Web 2.0. The inherent challenge is to avoid the dreaded “cute kitten syndrome.” Just like many of us cannot resist something as fun, attractive, entertaining as a cute kitten, many of the Web 2.0 tools are equally fun, attractive and entertaining. However, just as a cute kitten can’t take the place of a work animal on a pioneer trail, new web tools must be carefully evaluated. There are multiple tools for doing many of the same things in Web 2.0. An original blog post, which has since been copied and modified, is the “50 Web 2.0 Ways to Tell a Story” (Levine, 2007). This wiki identifies 50 different Web 2.0 tools that can be used to build a slide show with recorded audio. The 50 tools produce essentially the same outcome, and while Levine’s wikispace does not evaluate or rate the tools, it is reasonable to assume there are a few cute kittens in the collection. There is an appeal to using each cute new tool, but successful practitioners need to find an effective way to evaluate prospective tools, or run the risk of trying so many tools and accomplishing nothing within the new Web 2.0 space. By the time a new pioneer Twitters, e-mails, and updates Facebook, MySpace, LinkedIn®, Wikipedia, YouTube, and Flickr each day, there is no time left for non-Web 2.0 based work or play. A second consideration in the implementation of Web 2.0 in education may also be one of the factors slowing the adoption of Web 2.0. Educators teaching traditional courses may fear the move to blended learning because they suspect students won’t come to class anymore if much of the content is online. The question instructors should ask: are they (the instructor or the learners) adding value to the class by being together face-to-face? If they
are just reading PowerPoints, there is probably little value generated by face time. If faculty are truly engaging students, and learners are engaging each other, then yes, they will come. Colleagues who have successfully adopted Web 2.0 in blended learning have shared some untested but intriguing suggestions for encouraging participation in both in class and online. For example, if a lecture is being taped as an MP3, the professor can use a few minutes before the recording is turned on to tell related stories or share case studies, then turn off the recording before the question and answer session at the end of class. Students will miss valuable information and social capital unless they come to class. To encourage use of online materials, some instructors incorporate a post-lecture podcast discussion of key points with faculty and students. They may also upload supplemental materials that address some of the more challenging aspects covered in lecture. Others have successfully incorporate short quizzes over online material into face-to-face lectures, or vice-versa. Alternatively, another question to ask is do students really need to come to class anymore? Perhaps as solely an academic discussion, what if the physical classroom was inaccessible due to damage, infrastructure failure, or pandemic ? Can learning take place without the classroom? The promise of Web 2.0 is that, yes, it is possible. By critically examining the course objectives, employing Web 2.0 tools as primary or adjunct media may make the course more engaging for both learner and faculty. Once the decision to teach online/blended courses is made, choosing the right tool to match the content can be challenging, especially for those new to digital media. As discussed earlier, students who are successful in learning, especially with online learning, have developed the ability to be self-directed. Grow (1991) developed a simple four-stage model of self-directed learning that can be easily adapted to Web 2.0 tools which may
187
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
be helpful to instructors in developing courses and student abilities. First, consider course level and the student body, then, see what stage is the best fit.
Stage 1: Dependent Learners Students have little prior knowledge or experience in the topic area, and may lack motivation or self-confidence to tackle material independently. These learners will need explicit instructions and timelines, smaller steps, more frequent feedback, and limited choices. This falls into the classic “sage on the stage” mold. In E-learning, this translates to a didactic approach with text, slides, recorded lectures, and multiple-choice quizzes more typical of Web 1.0. Educators are still trying to “sell” students on the course; so giving a lot of feedback individually and to the group may help. This is more a “supply-push” style of education, with the teacher doing the pushing (Brown and Adler, 2008).
Stage 2: Interested Learners Students have little knowledge or previous experience in the topic, but are open to the instructor’s motivational tactics to engage them in active learning. The goal is gradually to move from extrinsic to intrinsic motivation. At this level, the instructor is transitioning to the “guide on the side,” guiding discussions and assisting learners to set their own goals. Online, this may involve adding moderated discussion boards, assigning short research/ writing assignments, and introducing students to problem-based learning and collaborative work with small-scale projects. Podcasts/videocasts of guest speakers connecting content to the “real world” may be motivating and engage students into the subject matter.
188
Stage 3: Involved Learners Students whose knowledge and skill level is such that they feel confident and can navigate the learning process. These learners have moved beyond the novice level, and have built a foundation of both content knowledge and metacognitive strategies. The instructor becomes a “facilitator” and is much more collaborative in the learning partnership. Group projects, virtual teams, and in-depth discussions work well here. Students can become peer-reviewers, discussion moderators, and collaborate on wikis.
Stage 4: Self-directed Learners Students at this level can take responsibility for their own learning, and collaboration can be quite in depth. The instructor can set up the learning tools, then step aside and let the students take over, learning independently and from each other. The instructor serves more as a consultant or “catalyst” to the learning process. Learning contracts, wikis, independent and team projects all work well here. This becomes more a “demand-pull” (Brown and Adler, 2008) type of learning, with the student driving the demand. Notice that learning strategies at this stage are generally more work and require higher-order thinking for both student and instructor. Keeping a mental model of this four-stage process provides a fairly simple structure, yet offers faculty the appreciation for the power and impact of Web 2.0 tools. In general, stages 1-2 are more appropriate for beginner level coursework, while stages 3-4 would be appropriate for intermediate to advanced level courses. Furthermore, a course could be designed to move through stages, starting at the lower level and progressing to more selfdirection as the course proceeds. The challenge comes when there is a wide mix of self-directed
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
learning levels in a class, as often happens. As a result, educators may need to flex or adapt their style to meet individual student needs. This is a challenge for even the most experienced educator, but Web 2.0 can be a true asset if the right tool is used in the right way to benefit both learner and faculty. Another well-known approach to structuring learning is Bloom’s taxonomy. This elegant approach has been updated (Anderson, 2006) and its strength is the structure it provides to the educator for writing educational objectives to address increasing higher-level cognitive process. In turn, it can lead to the development of assessment tools that align with the learning activity. If combined with the four stages of self-directed learning cited (Grow, 1991), it can provide a quick and useful grid for educators. Place the cognitive process of Bloom’s taxonomy across the top of a chart (Remember, Understand, Apply, Analyze, Evaluate, Create) and the stages of self-directed learning down the left side (Dependent, Interested, Involved, Self-directed) to create a grid that can be filled in with objectives and appropriate activities as described above (Cruz, 2003). This will allow any faculty to create a “snapshot” of the learning tools for each class. This can also guide the educator to see what gaps exist that might be filled with the right Web 2.0 tool. Another challenge faced by educators as a result of the expansion of Web 2.0 technology is the importance of promoting good digital citizenship. One specific ethical issue that often troubles faculty is plagiarism. In our digital point-and-click, copy-and-paste culture, it is increasingly easy for both students (and faculty) to use material developed by others without proper attribution. Oftentimes this is unintentional; sometimes it is intentional. Conversations with colleagues reveal that many students are genuinely not aware of the extent and impact of plagiarism. For example, just switching around a few words does not absolve the writer from proper citation. There are many reasons why students plagiarize (Park, 2003). In
addition to a lack of understanding, students often lack critical thinking and information management skills. Educators are turning to technology to catch plagiarism, such as using Turnitin® software, or searching chunks of text on Google, but prevention of plagiarism can only occur by addressing information literacy both in and out of the classroom. One of the challenges of digital citizenship within the rapidly changing Web 2.0 landscape is the understanding of intellectual property laws, rules, and practices. Concurrently, two new ideas of intellectual property rights have emerged: Open Source and Creative Commons. Open Source is “a development method for software that harnesses the power of distributed peer review and transparency of process. The promise of open source is better quality, higher reliability, more flexibility, lower cost, and an end to predatory vendor lock-in.” (Open Source Initiative, n.d.). Creative Commons provides free tools that let authors, scientists, artists, and educators easily mark their creative work with the freedoms they want it to carry. Content creators can use CC to change copyright terms from “All Rights Reserved” to “Some Rights Reserved.”” (Creative Commons, n.d). Learners and faculty alike, especially those not studying law or intellectual property, find the subtleties and distinctions between these constructs and traditional copyright confusing. Further complicating the issue is wide spread abuse of intellectual property rules and wide spread misunderstandings of what is and is not infringement. This is a continuing process of learning by all parties involved, but proceeding with good faith and reasonable caution will still allow faculty and students to reap the rich rewards of Web 2.0. This is also part of the larger concept of information literacy. Information literacy is defined as a set of abilities requiring individuals to “recognize when information is needed and have the ability to locate, evaluate, and use effectively the needed informa-
189
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
tion” (ACRL, 2000). In the Information Literacy Competency Standards for Higher Education the ACRL (2000) stated an information literate individual should be able to: 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. 6.
Determine the extent of the information needed Access needed information effectively and efficiently Evaluate information and its sources critically Incorporate selected information into one’s knowledge base. Uses information effectively to accomplish a specific purpose Understand the economic, legal, and social issues surrounding the use of information, and access and use information ethically and legally.
These literacy standards become increasingly important as we have moved from an era of relative information scarcity where scouring stacks and journals was necessary to uncover facts, to an era of information abundance. In other words, now the focus is not on finding information but filtering, appraising and applying it. In fact, due to the abundance of information, literacy is important even before the search step begins. Since so much information is now available online, students with limited library experience lack mental models about how the information is created or stored. As suggested by Swanson (2004), “Before we train students to use search tools, before we send them to books, periodicals, or websites, we need to teach them about information. What is it? How is it created? Where is it stored?” To do this, the E-learning educator could partner with librarians to weave concepts of increasingly higher literacy into courses. Rather than librarians being an information gatekeeper, in this new model, they take on a more active role as information managers. Instead of operating primarily in lower level “how-to” mode, librar-
190
ians could transition to a guide, facilitator and catalyst as student literacy skills improve. This initiative would require a broader and deeper use of librarians across curricula and courses, rather than having their involvement limited to just one class/tutorial. This opportunity is a paradigm shift for many, but as one librarian observes, this opportunity would be welcome. “We can’t provide information literacy in a “microwave ready” format. It takes time, it takes a village to integrate new media literacy into our teaching.” (Hines, 2008).
Future reseArch dIrectIons The evolution of Web 2.0 and its use in education suggests a trend in E-learning tools that began with Web 1.0 and will likely carry us into Web 3.0. Web 1.0 launched the idea of a Web site or home page as a traditional publishing model. It was essentially, the “teacher’s space” to provide content to learners. While there were feedback mechanisms (e-mail forms, discussion and comment areas), these were limited and crude in comparison to what we use today. Web 2.0 has evolved from the “teacher’s space” to “my space”. MySpace® is a social networking site, and its name suggests the essence of Web 2.0 technologies. Rather than content and context strictly defined by the publisher (teacher), Web 2.0 tools allow the individual to arrange, contextualize, limit, augment, and refine the content in a manner that suits them. This is not only the option of the teacher-publisher, but also the option of the learner. It is these collaborative possibilities that educators seek to leverage into better learning environments. If there is to be a Web 3.0, and current developments in social operating systems suggest this may be the next landmark we see, it may come to be known as “Our Space.” Our space will be a Web learning environment that is shared by all learning partners in the classroom (classroom is a
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
figurative term here). What may evolve is a new education Web space as a metaphoric one-room schoolhouse—but one the spans the globe. This new environment may include learning situations where, at times, many are working together. At other times, there might one-on-one tutelage, or small groups working at a variety of competence and grade levels using a variety of technological advances we have not yet discovered. As new digital landscape emerges, here are questions that educators can ask themselves to sort through the many tools and opportunities that will arise.
does a tool have Merit? will it stick? Not every tool is appropriate for every class. Also consider the cost (proprietary or open-source) and tech support availability. If it’s not practical, it’s a deal breaker.
Is My Level of Involvement Appropriate for the Level of the course?
gives learners different methods of expression, and gives all learners a variety of experiences. To have a single assignment that includes emailing an attachment, submitting a blog, twittering a note, and editing a Wiki creates confusion and disengagement on the part of the student.
have I created a social Presence? Beyond your level of involvement as an educator, does it also create a sense of social presence to benefit the learner? Does the Web 2.0 tool offer a chance to share who you are as a whole person with the learners? This is not to say your entire biography, nor does it imply significant detail about your non-professional life. Rather, the nature of many of these tools provides options for you to put more depth of your personality in front of the learner. This may inspire and motivate the students, as well as model professional behavior.
do My tools take Into consideration what we Know About brain-based Learning?
Explore how the technology works and what role you have its use or application. Does it meet the needs of teaching presence in the class? Does it match the students’ level of self-direction?
Have you used a variety of media, employing adequate visual stimulation and decreasing the blocks of text? Have you chunked the work into manageable blocks with adequate feedback points based on the student’s level of self-direction?
do I have a combination of tools to hit a variety of Learning styles?
how do I Assess Learning Going beyond a Multiple-choice exam?
Web 2.0 tools afford a multitude of ways students can demonstrate their understanding of course material and their personal engagement with the subject matter. To that end, the faculty may offer the learner the options of submitting traditional papers, contributing to a personal or group blog, or a class-based Wiki. However, options should add choice to benefit the student, and not create confusion. To have one assignment include a wiki, and a second assignment include a blog,
Are you using authentic assessments versus teaching to the test? As the acquisition of knowledge has become more subjective and dynamic as opposed to objective and static, the challenge is to parse the origin and quality of information. If we could banish one phrase from higher education, it would be: “Will this be on the test?” The tools you choose should give you additional opportunities for assessment of learning, albeit in non-traditional ways. Relating each tool to a learning objective,
191
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
and then basing objectives on taxonomy, provides a focused learner evaluative opportunity.
concLusIon In the end, the focus should not be on tools but on the use and context of tools (Jenkins, 2006). Technology doesn’t fail because of technology, but because of the culture. There will always be early adopter, laggards, and those that are curious but want to wait and see. That is understandable. As pioneers, we truly don’t know what lies ahead. We can be prepared and do our best but there might be disasters as well as successful discoveries. Those who chose to be pioneers will need to forge ahead. A final discussion about the diffusion of innovation returns us to the idea of pioneering E-learning in the classroom. Rogers defined the stages of adoption as the innovators, early adopters, early majority, late majority and laggards (Rogers, 2003). We’ve chosen the idea of pioneers, which parallels Roger’s innovators and early adopters, rather than other terms like settlers, colonists or nomads. As a pioneer, there is an element of risk, even within the current state of the art. At one time, software products like WordStar, VisiCalc, Lotus 1-2-3, and dBase were standards, as were online services such as CompuServe, GEnie and The Source. To have exclusively focused on any one of these tools could have resulted in the end of E-learning with the end of the product life. Wikipedia and Second Life, for example, have their critics and while successful in terms of our view today, there is no certain way to predict what these services will look like in 2010, or 2020, or beyond. The settlers, the equivalent of the early majority, usually move in and develop the area once the pioneers have determined the best initial practices and routes for success. Colonists, similar to the late majority, often bring with them the kind of structure, rules, and protocol that limits
192
the free spirited risk taking of the pioneer spirit. Pioneers then often seek out new uncharted ways and tools to expand, grow and develop knowledge and learning.
reFerences Anderson, L. W. (2006). A taxonomy for learning, teaching, and assessing: A revision of Bloom’s: A revision of Bloom’s taxonomy of educational objectives. New York: Longman. Association of College and Research Libraries. (2000). Information literacy competency standards for higher education. Chicago: ACRL. Bennett, S., Matron, K., & Kervin, L. (2008). The “digital natives” debate: A critical review of the evidence. British Journal of Educational Technology, 39, 775–786. doi:10.1111/j.14678535.2007.00793.x Bransford, J. D., Brown, A. L., & Cocking, R. R. (2000). Brain, mind, experience, and school. Washington DC: National Academy Press. Brown, J. S. (2000). Growing Up Digital: How the web changes work, education, and the ways people learn. Change, Growing Up Digital, March/ April, 10-20. Brown, J. S., & Adler, R. P. (2008). Minds on fire: Open education, the long tail, and learning 2.0. EDUCAUSE Review, 43, 16–32. Bugeja, M. J. (2007, September). Second thoughts about second life. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved February 1, 2009, from http:// chronicle.com/article/Second-Thoughts-AboutSecon/46636/. Creative Commons (n.d.). Retrieved August 31, 2008, from http://creativecommons.org/.
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
Cruz, E. (2003). Bloom’s revised taxonomy. In B. Hoffman (Ed.), Encyclopedia of Educational Technology. Retrieved August 31, 2008, from http://coe.sdsu.edu/eet/Articles/bloomrev/start. htm Fisch, K., & McLeod, S. (2007). Did you know? Retrieved August 30, 2008, from http://shifthappens.wikispaces.com/Sources Fosnot, C. T. (2005). Constructivism: Theory, perspectives, and practice. New York: Teachers College Press. Garrison, D. R., Anderson, T., & Archer, W. (2000). Critical inquiry in a text-based environment: Computer conferencing in higher education. The Internet and Higher Education, 2, 87–105. doi:10.1016/S1096-7516(00)00016-6 Grow, G. (1991). Teaching Learners to be SelfDirected. Originally published in Adult Education Quarterly. Retrieved August 31, 2008, from http:// www.longleaf.net/ggrow Hines, R. (2008, August). The screen in flat: Reinventing libraries for information literacy. Symposium conducted at the annual Multimedia Educational Resource and Learning Tools (MERLOT) conference in Minneapolis, MN. Open Source Initiative, (n.d.). Retrieved August 31, 2008, from http://www.opensource.org/ Jenkins, H. (2006). Convergence culture: Where old and new media collide. New York: New York University Press. Jensen, E. P. (2000). Brain-based learning: The new science of teaching and training (Rev. ed.). San Diego: The Brain Store. Kirschner, P., Sweller, J., & Clark, R. (2006). Why minimal guidance during instruction does not work: an analysis of the failure of constructivist, discovery, problem-based, experiential, and inquiry-based teaching. Educational Psychologist, 41, 75–86. doi:10.1207/s15326985ep4102_1
Knowles, M. S. (1950). Informal Adult Education: A guide for administrators, lenders, and teachers. New York: Association Press. Knowles, M. S., Holton, E., & Swanson, R. A. (2005). The Adult Learner: The Definitive Classic in Adult Education and Human Resource Development. Amsterdam: Elsevier. Lenhart, A., Madden, M., Macgill, A., & Smith, A. (2007). Pew Internet: Teens and Social Media. Retrieved August 31, 2008, from http://www. pewinternet.org/PPF/r/230/report_display.asp Levine, A. (2007). 50 Web 2.0 ways to tell a story. Retrieved August 24, 2008, from http://cogdogroo. wikispaces.com/StoryTools Mayer, R. (2004). Should there be a three-strikes rule against pure discovery learning? The case for guided methods of instruction. The American Psychologist, 59, 14–19. doi:10.1037/0003066X.59.1.14 Medina, J. (2008). Brain Rules: 12 Principles for Surviving and Thriving at Work, Home, and School. Seattle, WA: Pear Press. Park, C. (2003). In Other (People’s) Words: plagiarism by university students--literature and lessons. Assessment & Evaluation in Higher Education, 28, 471–488. doi:10.1080/02602930301677 Prensky, M. (2001). Digital Natives, Digital Immigrants. Horizon, 9(5). Putnam, R. D. (2001). Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community. New York: Simon & Schuster. Rogers, E. M. (2003). Diffusion of innovations (5th ed.). New York: Free Press. Ruhl, K., Hughes, C., & Schloss, P. (1987). Using the pause procedure to enhance lecture recall. Teacher Education and Special Education, 10, 14–18.
193
Dispatches from the Graduate Classroom
Siemens, G. (2004, December 12). Connectivism: A learning theory for the digital age. elearnspace. Retrieved August 31, 2008, from http://www. elearnspace.org/Articles/connectivism.htm Simon, M. (2008, August). Online student-teacher friendships can be tricky. CNN.com. Retrieved August 26, 2008, from http://www.cnn.com/2008/ TECH/08/12/studentsteachers.online/ Sousa, D. A. (2006). How the brain learns. Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press. Swanson, T. (2004). A radical step: Implementing a critical information literacy model. Portal (Baltimore, Md.), 4, 259–273. Web 2.0. (2008). In Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia. Retrieved 17:15, August 30, 2008, from http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Web_2 .0&oldid=269135746 Worrall, L., & Bell, F. (2007). Metacognition and lifelong E-learning: a contextual and cyclical process. E-learning, 4, 161–171. doi:10.2304/ elea.2007.4.2.161
Key terMs And deFInItIons: Andragogy: The label of an instructional method, coined by Knowles, that is designed to meet the learning style and motivations of adult, self-directed learners Blended learning: A learning format that includes elements of both E-learning with faceto-face learning.
Blooms taxonomy: Cognitive objectives developed by Bloom in 1956 include knowledge, comprehension, application, analysis, synthesis, and evaluation. A similar spectrum includes remember, understand, apply, analyze, evaluate, create Community of Inquiry: A learning theory consisting of three interconnected elements: cognitive presence social presence, and teaching presence Connectivism: A learning theory that proposes that that learning occurs through networks of people sharing pieces of information to create integrated knowledge. Constructivism: A learning theory based on the principle that students construct knowledge individually rather than receiving it passively from others Digital citizenship: An adaptation of traditional ethics and citizenship rules and conforms to work within the context of online work and Web 2.0 tools. Half-life (of information): A concept borrowed from nuclear physics that implies the length of time information is useful. Information literacy: A set of abilities requiring individuals to know when information is needed and then have the ability to locate, evaluate, and use the appropriate information Metacognition: The awareness of one’s own cognitive processes. Pedagogy: Refers to the type or style of instructional method a teacher employs
This work was previously published in Handbook of Research on Practices and Outcomes in E-Learning: Issues and Trends, edited by H. Yang; S. Yuen, pp. 351-366, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
194
195
Chapter 1.14
Classroom-in-a-Box:
Rethinking Learning Community Classroom Environment Needs within Three-Dimensional Virtual Learning Environments Caroline M. Crawford University of Houston – Clear Lake, USA Virginia Dickenson eLumenata, USA Marion S. Smith Texas Southern University, USA
AbstrAct This discussion focuses upon a theoretical understanding of the instructional architecture that supports learning communities within three-dimensional virtual world environments; specifically, within the Second Life world environment. This theoretical understanding provides the essential link between instructional imperatives, performance improvement and a community of learning within an instructional technology framework. Motivated by the shift from the Information Age known for the availability of information towards the Cognitive Age which emphasizes the ability to access, evaluate, organize, comprehend, apply, analyze, synthesize and innovatively represent information into an enhanced understanding and novel use, this DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-782-9.ch003
discussion offers the opportunity to directly address the learner’s needs within the three-dimensional virtual learning environment, such as Second Life, through the design of a virtual learning environment classroom-in-a-box.
IntroductIon The publication of The Blue Book: A Consumer Guide to Virtual Worlds (Association of Virtual Worlds, 2008a, 2008b) suggests that virtual worlds are a growing phenomenon. Another indication of this trend is the use of Second Life by several businesses as a viable environment through which to interview technology-minded professionals (Athavaley, 2007). It is not a significant leap to expect the three-dimensional virtual world environment to become a more viable instructional environment that
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Classroom-in-a-Box
may further engage learners. As quoted by Martin and Crawford (2008), “Universities have also been testing the three-dimensional virtual learning environments as potentially successful learning communities that directly address the concerns related to the silo effect” (p. 546). Further indication of the acceptance of virtual worlds in education is The Activeworlds.com, Incorporated, description of their product The Active Worlds Educational Universe, which states, “The Educational Universe is an entire Active Worlds Universe dedicated to exploring the educational applications of the Active Worlds Technology” (The Activeworlds. com, Incorporated, 2008, paragraph 1). Distance education and online learning has grown and shifted over the previous fifteen years. It is only recently that researchers and developers have focused upon instructional potentials related to three-dimensional virtual learning environments. In this environment the active engagement of the learner may offer significant potential towards the success of learning communities. Before the introduction of three-dimensional learning environments, the primary course environment was textual in nature, with opportunities for the integration of supportive audio, video and interactive multimedia components for exhibition. Shifting from this text-based environment to a primarily virtual environment that more closely reflects the opportunities inherent within a more traditional community learning environment offers the learners the opportunity for a more autonomous, dynamic community of learning. Therefore, the engagement of the learner within a three-dimensional virtual learning environment, such as Second Life (Linden Research, Inc., 2008c), is imperative. This engagement occurs through the design of a virtual learning environment classroom that the instructor can easily manipulate so as to meet the instructional needs of the learners. The design of a three-dimensional virtual learning environment classroom that supports the needs of the learners while emphasizing the instructor’s focus upon
196
learning objectives is difficult, at best. Thus, the ability to design and develop a manageable, transportable environment that offers the instructor an opportunity to designate different surroundings “on the fly” through the push of a button so as to meet the necessary instructional needs is a priority. The concept of a transportable learning environment architecture that can be obtained as a boxed product, opened within the previously designated building environment and then effortlessly set up by incorporating appropriate instructional elements is a timely and necessary product. This classroom-in-a-box articulation offers the instructor the ability to easily shift between different instructional tasks, such as classroom lecture, group work, research and study area, faculty office hours, casual discussions and advising. Further, the classroom-in-a-box allows for a more appropriate articulation of the different underlying philosophies of learning that most appropriately meet the subject matter’s learning objectives.
bAcKGround To appropriately perceive the significance of a three-dimensional virtual environment classroomin-a-box product, it is integral to discuss the shift from primarily textual information with bits and pieces of multimedia sparkle for exhibition towards a more autonomous, dynamic community of learning. The opportunity to directly address the learner’s needs is integral towards the enhancement of learning environments. Embracing the structural architecture within the three-dimensional virtual world environments supports the Web 2.0 phenomenon that engages the learners within social engagement opportunities. Further, the natural progression towards designing appropriate and successful holistic virtual classroom-focused instructional environments is related to learning communities that enhance and structurally arrange the available knowledge
Classroom-in-a-Box
into comprehensible, conceptual frameworks of understanding (Vygotsky, 1935, 1962, 1978, 1981; Wertsch, 1985). As well, semiotic components are now growing in significance within learning environment communities due to the significant influence on long-overlooked underlying messages and conceptual knowledge that is transmitted through communicative technologies (Chomsky, 2004; Cook, 1985; Cobley, Jansz, 2003; Gannon-Cook & Crawford, 2006; Hamilton, 1969; McLuhan, 1964 a, b; McLuhan & Fiore, 1967; Rothstein, 1995; Schlain, 1998). As society shifted from the Information Age to the Cognitive Age (Brooks, 1999; Pink, 2005) the design of learning environments changed from a focus upon knowledge availability for the masses towards the realized importance of the aptitude and talent associated with the ability to access, evaluate, organize, comprehend, apply, analyze, synthesize and evaluate (Bloom, 1984; Bloom, Englhart, Furst, Hill & Krathwohl, 1956) the knowledge, as well as the ability of the learner to remember, understand, apply, analyze, evaluate and create (Anderson & Krathwohl, 2001, as quoted by Churches, 2008, paragraph 3) information that is understood and innovatively reorganized and represented so as to enhance the understanding of the information in novel ways. This is imperative within the three-dimensional virtual learning environment has not yet been realized. Herein is cultivated the concept of a classroomin-a-box. The idea behind a classroom-in-a-box is the ability of the instructor to set up a classroom environment that meets instructional needs. As an example, if the authors developed a textbook for course use, and the authors sought to teach the course in a virtual environment, the authors could purchase the already developed classroom with all the slideshows, movies, unit information, whiteboard, podcasts, and other elements already integrated. Essentially, the classroom-in-a-box is a prefabricated environment that can be set up and work anywhere within a virtual world. The
classroom-in-a-box may be made available as a shell environment or may include the subject information for a course. The concept of a two room environment is the classroom-in-a-box architectural setup. The first room is available as a consistent interface through which the learners access the course information; rather like a course-specific library environment. The second room has the ability to shift its setup, to meet the appropriate instructional needs, such as a lecture hall, small group tables, lounge area, faulty office, or other instructional environments determined by the course instructor. Additionally, the course instructor can decide to allow password access to instructional assistants, or even have the possibility of allowing the learners to shift the room’s setup. When discussing any virtual world, one is dealing with a “grid” – a series of virtual environments and the server or servers that make up the virtual environment(s). The richer and more interactive the 3-D virtual environment, the more likely it is that the grid is going to require an entire server or multiple servers. Grids may be hosted at a specific location or locations, and tied together. Such is the case with Second Life and Active Worlds. It is also possible that a grid may be an independent, stand-alone environment, that is not tied to other environments. Second Life is an massive example of a hosted grid. More than 6000 servers make up the entire grid, and Linden Labs, Inc. owns and controls all servers. Some virtual environments may be isolated in some regard, however, all of the Second Life environments are hosted and administered to by Linden Labs, Inc. It would be possible to have a virtual environment or series of virtual environments that reside on a server or series of servers that are kept in a proprietary environment, strictly for the use of the institution. This would be considered an un-hosted solution, or rather, the solution is hosted internally. In this case, the institution would own, control, and administer the virtual environment(s).
197
Classroom-in-a-Box
It is important to keep in mind, in the exploration of the classroom-in-a-box concept as an application within Second Life, there is a larger scope classroom-in-a-box concept as separate from any “hosted” grid such as Second Life. In this regard, the classroom-in-a-box could be an internally hosted virtual grid, or even a USB drive with a grid, as the virtual world technology is driven forward. For instance, in the not-to-distantfuture, a 3rd grader may take home a universal serial bus (USB) drive, a “plug and play” drive, that contains an entire virtual environment that allows him or her to learn about space travel by having an avatar or virtual personal representation build a rocket ship and travel around the Milky Way galaxy.
shift in theoretical and Philosophical Frameworks of Learning An understanding of learning has changed as the culture has shifted its focus, or emphasis, as the centuries have passed. As a society, we are familiar with primarily four ages which had not only dawned, but indeed have flowed over society and changed the social community forever: • • • •
Agrarian Age Industrial Age Information Age Conceptual Age (Pink, 2005)
Initially, the agricultural focus of the culture was based upon sustainability of the race, many times referred to as the Agrarian Age. The need for social understanding, storytelling skills that would pass down the important lessons and histories of the culture, and the sharing of skill sets was vital towards the communal good of the society. However, a shift occurred when larger industries brought together numerous people who needed to be able to focus upon their specific task that would fulfill a portion of a larger project.
198
The Industrial Age consisted of both the written and unwritten curriculum; the written curriculum was based upon reading, writing, arithmetic and some history, while the unwritten curriculum was based upon the need for Industrial Age workers to follow orders, focus for periods of time upon a specific skill or task, understand the needs related to scheduling, and similar related skills. Yet when the Information Age dawned in the late 20th Century, there was the realization that knowledge should be freely available to everyone and the tool through which this would occur was named the Internet or the World Wide Web. The Information Age degraded the prior power structure, wherein controlling information was power, and fostered discussions related to the digital divide. An interesting aspect of the Information Age is that there is a perceived heightened velocity and momentum associated with the societal issues. Pink (2005) suggested that the appropriate next age would be the Conceptual Age in which the power would shift to those within our society who were able to gather and reframe the information into useful knowledge. In light of the shifts in society and its impact on learning, there is a shift in the World Wide Web. Recently, there has been a discussion of “Web 2.0” which is characterized by web-based communities and hosted services that include social-networking sites, wikis and blogs designed to facilitate creativity, collaboration, and sharing between users. “Web 2.0” is a term that helps support and frame an understanding of what is going on today. We may ask, what will be the next age, but more so, how will the elusive and ethereal World Wide Web continue to impact social learning communities?
underLyInG PhILosoPhy oF LeArnInG The design of a learning environment is influenced by the human experience within it. It is suggested
Classroom-in-a-Box
by Neil (2005) that Dewey “believed that learning was active and schooling unnecessarily long and restrictive. His idea was that children came to school to do things and live in a community which gave them real, guided experiences which fostered their capacity to contribute to society” (paragraph 1, http://wilderdom.com/experiential/ JohnDeweyPhilosophyEducation.html). Further, Neil (2005) states that: Dewey’s theory is that experience arises from the interaction of two principles -- continuity and interaction. Continuity is that each experience a person has will influence his/her future, for better or for worse. Interaction refers to the situational influence on one’s experience. In other words, one’s present experience is a function of the interaction between one’s past experiences and the present situation. For example, my experience of a lesson, will depend on how the teacher arranges and facilitates the lesson, as well my past experience of similar lessons and teachers. (Neill, 2005, paragraph 8) From this delineation of Dewey’s work, the next step is to reflect upon the underlying philosophy of learning that organizes and establishes not only the instructional design process, but also an understanding and realization that the instructor’s underlying philosophy of learning will directly impact the learning environment. It does occur on a regular basis that the lead instructional designer and course instructor are one in the same person, but many times the instructional designer may be different than the course instructor. As a result, the potential for conflicting of learning philosophies between the designer and the instructor may occur. There is the potential that the instructor will experience impediments or limitations associated with the implementation of a distance learning environment designed by persons with different underlying philosophies of learning and understanding. There is the potential for future research associated with this focus, as well as opportunities for professional development. However, to support and engage
the learner in the distance learning environment, a consideration towards the learner’s hierarchy of needs is appropriate. According to Wikipedia (2008a), an MMO or MMOG is a Massively Multiplayer Online Game, which is simply “a video game that is capable of supporting hundreds or thousands of players simultaneously” (paragraph 1). MMOs are, by their nature, played over the Internet. While “MUVE (plural MUVEs) refers to online, multi-user virtual environments, sometimes called virtual worlds (Wikipedia, 2008b, paragraph 1). Typically, a MUVE refers to an environment that is “not necessarily game-specific” (Wikipedia, 2008b, paragraph 1). Often, these terms are used interchangeably. It is every bit as critical to consider learner motivation in the 3-dimensional virtual world, Massively Multiplayer Online (MMO) learning environment with regard to learning and virtual life. There are phenomena that occur within the virtual world, particularly in a social networking environment, that can affect motivation for which an instructor or instructional designer may not be prepared. The virtual world allows for a freedom that is often unavailable in the real world. For instance, in many MMOs, learner avatars can fly, teleport (instantly move from one area to another, regardless of distance or location), shape shift, change minor appearances at will, create objects that are impossible to create in real life. Additionally, if the learner is allowed to personalize the avatar, the avatar becomes an expression of the learner’s personality. Consider another factor – if the leaner’s real life is not optimum for a variety of reasons that exist on Maslow’s hierarchy, the learner may actually prefer to spend time in the virtual environment, where he or she can be anything or anyone they desire. This may begin to affect the learning in a variety of ways – including the potential for incidental, unintended learning. This may manifest in the learner acquiring skills outside of the original goals and objectives set by the instructional designer.
199
Classroom-in-a-Box
Incidental learning presents many opportunities. Instructional designers within a technology driven environment are able to examine the common unintended learning outcomes and capture those outcomes with deliberation, forming them into secondary learning outcomes instead of incidental outcomes. This can result in driving the learning objectives into higher levels of learning. Another aspect of a learner finding higher motivation levels within the MMO can be an escalation of dysfunctional behavior. As the learner disconnects from their real life, avoiding the undesirable or uncontrollable areas of the real world, it seems to potentially retard the ability to grow and cope within that environment of reality. The very behaviors that may be contributing to the real life issues become exaggerated in the MMO, as the learner never has to develop coping behaviors, and may even avoid negative consequences due to anonymity. This retardation of growth does not have to be an outcome; the MMO can create an environment for learning coping skills, if the acquisition of those skills is made deliberate through learning objectives and the learner is capable of acquiring said skills. It is important to consider the inherent learner characteristics as well. For instance, a particular type of person seems to be drawn to the MMO environment. While there is a great deal of diversity in the MMO, there does appear to be a plethora of common characteristics in the population at large, and those characteristics seem include a propensity for personal drama or a definitive emotional immaturity within relationships. Additionally, there is a tremendous move within MMO environments (whether they be gaming, social networking, or learning) to create ego/ social status hierarchies. This can definitely be an impediment to moving learners into the realm of self-actualization, particularly if the MMO society is “retarded” at the ego / social status level. Instructional designers and instructors may find that they are no longer only shaping and designing a learning environment. They may have to design a learning “society.” 200
deveLoPInG the underLyInG FrAMeworK: LeArnInG hIerArchy oF needs Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs (Maslow, 1943, 1954, 1970, 1978; Maslow & Lowery, 1998) frames an integral structure that supports the underlying framework within any distance learning environment, including the three-dimensional virtual learning environment, as well as the hierarchical enhancements (Alderfer, 1972, 1977, 1980a, 1980b, 1987; Huitt, 2004; Norwood, 2004). These hierarchical enhancements lead to a reflective consideration towards the distance learner’s needs. A framework that supports the underlying needs of the learners within this basic distance learning environment is Crawford’s Distance Delivery Hierarchy of Needs (2005), within a primarily textual knowledge structuring environment that is supported by video, audio and interactive media products such as multimedia animation element. Crawford (2006) stated that “It is imperative to maintain a focus upon the appropriate and successful enhancement of the learning environment through technological means, in a suitably ubiquitous manner” (p. 11) yet still remain focused upon the learner’s success. Furthermore, “Crawford’s focus upon the learner’s needs within the online learning environment is necessary to represent the technological and instructional needs of the learner” (Crawford & Freeman, 2007, p. 6). With the focus on three-dimensional virtual learning environment Crawford (2007) elaborated upon and enhanced the Distance Delivery Hierarchy of Needs (Crawford, 2005) to offer Crawford’s 3D Virtual World Hierarchy of Needs. The MMO / 3-D learning environment has the potential to allow the learner a rich spectrum of realization, similar to that which Norwood (2004) describes, including the following factors: • • •
Be authentic. Transcend their cultural conditioning and become world citizens. Find their vocation and right mate.
Classroom-in-a-Box
• • • • • • • • • •
Know that life is precious. Be good and joyous in all kinds of situations. Learn from their inner nature. See that basic needs are satisfied. Refreshen their consciousness, appreciate beauty and other good things in life. Understand that controls are good, and complete abandon is bad. Transcend trifling problems Grapple with serious problems such as injustice, pain suffering and death Be good choosers Be given practice in making choices of goodies, then making choices in their religious beliefs. (Norwood, 2004, paragraph 10)
The dependent variable is the learning environment. A restrictive environment that is instructor- or content-centered will limit the learner’s level of growth. This may result in the learner being focused on their own lower need levels. In order to promote higher levels of learning and the ascendance beyond lower needs, the learning environment must be designed appropriately. A learner-centered environment promoting abstract thinking, problem solving, and learner creativity will work better to this end, as framed through Crawford’s 3D Virtual World Hierarchy of Needs (Crawford, 2007). The virtual three-dimensional learning environments engage audio, video and interactive animation components, but also engage the integrally interactive and participatory threedimensional animatory world. The significance of the virtual worlds within the learning environment is that, “Theorists differ over whether the system precedes and determines usage (structural determinism) or whether usage precedes and determines the system (social determinism) (although note that most structuralists argue that the system constrains rather than completely determines usage)” (Chandler, 2001, paragraph 20). It is of primary importance to focus the three-dimensional virtual
environment’s opportunities and emphasis upon the learner; meaning, the instructional architecture that is a classroom-in-a-box. As the 3-D virtual environment evolves, it becomes clear that some of the needs originally identified in Social Interactive Needs will be distributed into the lower needs areas. For example, the need to feel “sheltered” in the virtual world can be a very real one. Some people do not function well or productively in a virtual world if their avatar does not have a “home.” Having a “virtual home” may become more important than in real life. The same is true of the concept of “safety” in the 3-D world. It is amazing and amusing to hear people exhibiting fear of being “assaulted” in the 3-D world. Yet, it is a common issue in Second Life. It can be as though people forget there is an Exit function in the client software. Avatars cannot be tracked by others, unless the avatar gives permission to do so, and permission can be removed at any time. Understanding how to protect one’s avatar can be every bit as important as understanding basic movement and communication. In light of the considerations of Crawford’s distance Delivery Hierarchy of needs some standards emerged for 3-D virtual learning and a true standard has yet to emerge. One question that is already being explored is: To what extent does a learner’s real life situation and dysfunctions affect their virtual world situations and dysfunctions? Is it possible that learners can actually be empowered by working through affective issues in the virtual world, or are they crippled by those issues as they are in real life?
classroom-in-a-box When discussing a “classroom-in-a-box,” it is critical to remember that there are no limitations in the virtual world. If one can imagine it, one can find a way to build it. Therefore, there are infinite ways to create a learning environment within the
201
Classroom-in-a-Box
MUVE. Imagine a place, where one can touch a series of buttons and literally change the setting, the furniture, the media, even the location to accommodate the next level of learning. This is the concept of a virtual classroom-in-a-box. The concept of a classroom-in-a-box revolves around the integral importance of a viable learning environment that ensures that the primary elements of a learning environment are easily available for utilization, and the space allocation is easily conceptualized and structured so as to ensure the most appropriate environment towards meeting learning goals and objectives. Much as with a real-world face-to-face learning environment, there are times when a lecture setting is most appropriate towards meeting learning objectives, yet there is also the necessity for small group environments or a lounge for office hour discussions and guidance. At the same time, it is important to ensure that the learners consistently have access to all viable subject matter resources so that they can work and study in an anytime, anywhere manner. Within a bricks-and-mortar face-to-face world, one must schedule classroom space for each type of environment that is needed (allocating classroom space) which usually takes on a sense of chaotic turbulence due to the space allocation issues within busy or growing organizations (universities, business/industry, K-12, etc.). With these issues, how might a three-dimensional virtual learning environment meet the needs of the learners and instructor within a compartmentalized classroom area? The classroom-in-a-box idea is a better response to this problem because the mere click of a button allows the classroom architecture to shift “as needed” in order to meet instructionally appropriate tasks.
Issues, controversies, Problems The reality within the more traditional, textintensive distance learning environments is a structured tutorial style learning situation. Just as correspondence courses, instructional radio
202
and television courses are not common today so too will there be a shift away from the distance education as we know it towards more innovative real-world learning. A timely consideration is the cost of attending a face-to-face environment. As quoted in a New York Times newspaper article: Enrollments in online classes expanded rapidly early in this decade, but growth slowed in 2006 to less than 10 percent, according to statistics compiled last year by researchers at Babson College in Massachusetts. Some recent increases reported by college officials in interviews were much larger, which they attributed to the rising cost of gasoline. Pricing policies for online courses vary by campus, but most classes cost as much as, or more than, traditional ones. (Dillon, 2008, paragraph 7) The reality of the situation is that, “Once an incidental expense, fuel for commuting to campus now costs some students half of what they pay for tuition, in some cases more” (Dillon, 2008, paragraph 11). As noted by Dillon (2008): At Brevard Community College in Cocoa, Fla., online enrollment rose to 2,726 this summer from 2,190 last year, a 24.5 percent increase. “That is a dramatic increase we can only attribute to gas prices,” said Jim Drake, Brevard’s president. Dr. Drake and officials at several other colleges expressed concern that mounting fuel costs could force some students to drop out of college altogether, especially since only a fraction of courses at most colleges are offered online. Dr. Drake has put Brevard on a four-day week to help employees and students save gas. (paragraphs 8-9) For many students there is no other option available within today’s market. Dillon (2008) offers one case that may reflect the decisions of innumerable students: One student taking online coursework for the first time is Kameron Miller, a 30-year-old working mother who lives in Buffalo, Mo., 40 miles north of Springfield. Her commute to classes in her 1998 Chevy Venture during the spring semester
Classroom-in-a-Box
cost her at least $200 a month for gas, Ms. Miller said. This summer, she is taking courses in health, humanities and world music — all online. “I don’t feel I get as much out of an online class as a campus course,” Ms. Miller said. “But I couldn’t afford any other decision.” (paragraphs 13-14) This suggests that a shift in distance education course environments is not only timely, but necessary so as to meet the fundamental academic needs of the learners. Of course, a serious issue revolves around Internet access speeds. Although urban environments and bricks-and-mortar institutions of higher education have high-speed Internet access, the rural communities have been much slower to obtain higher levels of Internet access speed. For this reason, there continue to be issues related to distance learning accessibility, as articulated: Distance education is no silver bullet that can alone solve the challenges posed for higher education by rising gasoline prices, officials warned. For one thing, many students, especially in rural areas, lack the high-speed Internet connections on which online courses depend. “The infrastructure doesn’t exist to give all rural students clear online access,” said Stephen G. Katsinas, a professor at the University of Alabama. “Rural America is where the digital divide is most dramatic.” (Dillon, 2008, paragraphs 24-26) Yet these issues shall pass, and there will be viable options that will ensure the opportunity for high-speed Internet access within the rural communities. However, once these issues pass, the desire for viable options will remain. As such, it is a judicious opportunity to advance the three-dimensional virtual learning environment as a viable alternative to face-to-face learning environments and text-driven learning environments. This is a timely endeavor to undertake, especially with the recent shift in student needs, but innovations must be solidly developed and engineered to ensure stability of the learning environment and viability of the product.
classroom-in-a-box solution and recommendations The classroom-in-a-box solution offers several integral elements that are viable alternatives to the more constant architectural considerations within both a bricks-and-mortar learning environment and an unchanging virtual learning environment. Therefore, it is important to articulate the important elements and innovative considerations related to the classroom-in-a-box solution. The following solutions are relevant to hosted or non-hosted grids.
Asynchronous Learning Area An asynchronous learning area, wherein the instructional support tools are consistently available for the learner’s use, is imperative towards the success of a learning environment, no matter whether focused upon textually driven environments or three-dimensional virtual learning environments. There must be locations within the asynchronous learning area that are for specific instructional materials, as well as the potential instructional elements. The design of this area must ensure that distinct units of instruction are clearly articulated for the learner’s use, as well as media-specific storage facilities through which the instructor can easily upload and compartmentalize instructional elements for the learner’s use. Several elements that may be articulated as integral within the asynchronous learning area are: • • • • • •
movie clips for the course podcasts Microsoft PowerPoint files (or comparable slideshow components) Adobe Flash files (or comparable interactive components) text downloads (like textually-driven units of instruction or forms) scripted objects that simulate real life objects, with both basic information
203
Classroom-in-a-Box
• •
components and problem solving components educational environments with scripted objects and space for ad hoc team learning other areas of instructional import
Another element that may be of use within this asynchronous learning area is a whiteboard for either synchronous instructional opportunities or archived notes, for use “on the fly” by the instructor or the learners. In Second Life, there is a great example of an asynchronous learning environment designed by Ohio State University (OSU) - Department of Medicine (The Ohio State University Medical Center, n.d.a), called the Testis Tour, located within the Second Life virtual world environment (The Ohio State University Medical Center, n.d.b). One can teleport an avatar to this Ohio State University virtual environment (also referred as a sim) and take an automated tour with up to three other avatars on a giant flying sperm. The tour has both voice recording and text chat that explains the inner workings of the testis. The avatars are flown into giant 3-D cut aways of a testicle that has a variety of graphics and media, including directional animation. Instructions are also given about how to change the avatar view and the environment lighting to get the best effects for learning. While this tour is part of a specific curriculum, OSU allows anyone to take the tour and experience the learning opportunity.
team Learning or Learner collaborative environments Team learning is a critical synchronous opportunity presented in the virtual world. If teams are given assignments to be completed in-world, they must have spaces and tools dedicated to the development of those assignments. These areas and tools are not the standard classroom necessities. An instructor must have the resources for the development of tools that promote the ease
204
of use by the learners. One popular tool used for learning in the virtual environment is a Heads Up Display (HUD) (Wikipedia, 2008c), and “In video gaming, the HUD is the method by which information is visually relayed to the player as part of a game’s user interface” (paragraph 1). For instance, an instructor might need to have a blank HUD developed for learners to create a tour of relevant sites. However, the HUD would ideally be designed so that learners would not have to input any specific scripting or programming – they would simply input into boxes. This may cost time and money to have designed, but will save learners from having to learn rudimentary scripting skills. A great example of using HUDs for learning occurs when a user first enters Second Life with a newly created avatar. The new user will initially show up in an orientation area, and will have a HUD on the screen that gives instructions and assignments as the avatar moves throughout the orientation area. In this way, the user learns fundamental locomotion and functional behaviors relative to the virtual environment.
Push Button Switch Panel A second room environment within the classroomin-a-box solution is a flexible, adaptable environment through the use of a push button switch panel. The course instructor can designate the person(s) who may access the push button switch panel, in order to adapt the room’s environmental architecture through password protected access, to most appropriately meet the instructional needs. The course instructor may maintain total control of the push button switch panel, allow access by instructional assistants, or allow all learners to access the push button switch panel. Of importance is the instructor’s control over this decision, so as to ensure the security and viability of the room’s architectural articulation. Therefore, the environmental instructional task designation area is a location wherein there is a push button switch
Classroom-in-a-Box
panel, where the course instructor could change the environment with the flip of a switch; this change in the room environmental structure would be dependent upon the day’s (or hour’s) expectations and activities, between appropriate instructional needs. These instructional needs would shift between specifically structured alternate virtual environments, including the following sets: •
• • • •
real work settings (industrial processing units, hospital examination and surgical rooms, etc.) lecture hall classroom smaller classroom group work area lounge to office
Of course, other learning environment needs of import may arise due to subject-specific needs articulated, such as a laboratory environment or artist gallery. In Second Life, there are many alternatives for the utilization of panels for environments. These are commonly referred to as “holodecks,” and there are a variety available for purchase. One must become familiar with the “rules” that accompany the use of such environments. For instance, it is recommended that all objects used in holodecks are full-permission and copiable. For this reason, it is often preferred to have those objects developed for specific use, with full-permission licensing.
Interactive Instructional Components Integral considerations relate to the opportunity for asynchronous interactive instructional components that are readily available within text-driven distance learning environments, such as: • • • • •
blog area assignment submission area emails subject-specific discussion lists group work tasks
The need for asynchronous tools that support the sharing of thoughts and ideas and submission of instructionally driven assignments is integral to the success of a distance learning environment that supports both synchronous and asynchronous learning opportunities. The environment must integrate all instructionally relevant tools, including the ability for the learners to submit their assignments through this environment, as well as the vital ability for the instructor to view assignment submissions, evaluate the submissions and offer both viable feedback and grade point articulation for the learner’s review. This would be a desirable element within any learning environment, but it is an imperative component within a distance learning environment. Of course, group work tasks are also important for the success of the learners. No matter whether the learners focus upon study groups or have designated group work assignments, there is a need for the environment wherein there can be synchronous and offline manipulation of documents within a group environment, such as a GoogleDocs or Zoho.com interface. Other areas of instructional import may arise, as subject-specific needs are articulated.
Heads Up Displays (HUDS) Also vital within a three-dimensional virtual learning environment are the heads up displays (HUDS) that are scripted to help people do what would be appropriate within the instructional environment. This may suggest posing animations or gesturing animations, such as to ensure the following animated elements: • • •
communicating teaching working
that would appropriately reflect the nonverbal cues that are second-nature within face-to-face learning environments. Scripted voice comments are also integral considerations, to ensure the appropriate
205
Classroom-in-a-Box
enhancement of instructional needs. As well, the effortless distribution of different instructionally relevant elements such as: • • • • •
scripted objects note cards location pointers, URLs and more
are vital to the enhancement of the learning environment. Each of the HUDS would be appropriately developed and implemented within the designated environmental room architecture, to allow the avatars to act and react as instructionally appropriate and desired. It is critical to ensure that HUDS are designed for the learner that is new to the concept. Detailed instructions for HUD must be built into the HUD itself, or the learner will become stuck in the exercise or environment. These classroom-in-a-box solutions support the ability of virtual learning environments to more appropriately reflect the traditional instructional needs within a three-dimensional virtual learning environment, while enhancing the environment to ensure the availability of all instructional tools and information, as well as the socially relevant asynchronous elements that have become standard within text-driven learning course management systems.
sample Lesson: classroom-in-a-box A specific example of a Classroom-in-Box might occur as follows: Lesson for Learning Basic Distillation Operations in a Chemical Processing Unit. I. Learning Basic Distillation – the learner avatar approaches an empty area that has a panel switch with labels on different buttons. The first button is labeled “Basic Principles of Distillation.” When this button is pushed, a full-scale distillation column pops out of the box. The avatar is dressed in appropriate industrial safety clothing,
206
and approaches the column by walking up a ramp to a designated area. A panel next to column allows the avatar to make the column transparent and learn the specifics of the distillation process, various types of sieves and trays, and relevant safety data by clicking on different parts of the process areas. II. Integrating Safety Operations – After the learner avatar has reviewed the basics of distillation, instructions are given to go back to the panel and push the button labeled “Integrating Operating Principles and Safe Work Practices.” When this button is pushed, the distillation column disappears and is replaced by a complete processing unit. The avatar is given a HUD that must be worn. The avatar is given an assignment via the HUD that requires moving through the unit, and identifying a specific area that must be properly prepared for repair according to a specific procedure. Part of the procedure includes identifying appropriate personnel that must sign papers and schedule work. As the avatar prepares the work area, appropriate forms must be identified and signatures must be acquired from “robot” avatars. As the appropriate forms are selected and filled out properly, the learner can move to the next step. The robot or pre-scripted avatars will respond correctly to appropriate prompts. III. Teamwork and Trouble Shooting – When the second part of the exercise has been completed, the learner is instructed to contact designated team members for a synchronous learning exercise. The learning team schedules their time together and returns to the panel switch. One person then selects the button labeled “Troubleshooting Industrial Processes.” The unit then appears to change slightly, while remaining essentially the same process unit. However, there are now some alarms that can be heard, and a different HUD is given to each learner. The learners are given an assignment that there is a serious problem within the unit, and they must work together to find the problem, following safety and process guidelines. As the learners work their way through the unit,
Classroom-in-a-Box
addressing the issues, the situation may escalate if too much time passes, or they miss critical indicators. If the issues are not addressed, the unit will explode.
Future trends The impact of these elements upon the virtual learning environment have more fully affected online learning environments, particularly with respect to the social community of learning and profoundly impacted the discipline of instructional systems design. Yet framing the discussion within three-dimensional virtual learning environments is imperative, so as to more fully develop an understanding of necessary entities and innovations within this potentially ground-breaking learning environment. All of these elements, the shifting hierarchies of needs and interactivities, content knowledge; instructional design elements and semiotic influences, and social interactions, all are crucial elements in the cumulative engagement of learners. However, interesting components are trends and issues that must be considered and may positively affect the three-dimensional virtual learning environment.
Avatars travel around the virtual worlds An interesting article in Information Week’s magazine (United Business Media Limited, 2008) notes that “the color is off the rose” for many companies who desired to jump on the three-dimensional world of Second Life (Linden Research, Inc., 2008c), yet IBM (International Business Machines Corporation, n.d.) is working with Linden Lab (Linden Research, Incorporated, 2008) and have … recently demonstrated “virtual world interoperability,” which would let avatars move between Second Life and other online worlds.
They herald it as a milestone that could turn online virtual worlds into more open environments where avatars cross virtual worlds the way people browse from one Web site to another today. That’s key for uses such as collaboration and education, says IBM. (United Business Media Limited, 2008, paragraph 2) This realization, which avatars may easily move between three-dimensional virtual worlds, opens the opportunity for persons to maintain their personal avatars and engage in communities throughout innumerable virtual worlds. Further, this style of open movement further embraces the instructional focus upon social communities of learning.
social software: community building tools The previous focus upon social communities of learning, especially within online learning environments, leads to the questions that face professionals within today’s world: what types of social software are available, that would engage the learner, enhance the social community experience, and act as a building mechanism rather than a deterrent? What social software, with a short learning curve, will be easy to use and that will quickly become ubiquitous towards the further engagement of the learner within the social community of learning within the three-dimensional virtual learning environment? This question is still in its infancy, but at least we’ve begun to think in this direction. Even more intriguing is that we have tools available that would support the opportunities towards more appropriately framing and understanding social communities of learning. On the other hand, where should the discussion begin? As quoted from Martin and Crawford (2008), pertaining to the topic at hand: The educational community is already comfortable with the idea of audio file integration
207
Classroom-in-a-Box
(podcasts, audio files implemented as forms of evaluative feedback, or audio overviews and additional discussion of subject matter) and video file integration (case studies, assignment project deliverable component, instructional video overview and additional discussion of subject matter, video lecture archive), synchronous online chats (virtual office hours, focused discussions upon subject matter, project group planning sessions), bulletin boards (posting questions, asking for support, carrying on asynchronous group discussions) and emails, but what are other opportunities? (p. 546) One additional opportunity is the realm of video conferencing. Video conferencing may be described as not the large room that has traditionally been allocated to the behemoth idea of video conferencing, but the speedy ability to videoconference over a small computer screen, that would be more appropriate within the threedimensional learning environment. Although the idea of video conferencing does not align with the emphasis upon avatars in this virtual world, the necessary emphasis upon learner support suggests the need for a synchronous opportunity for virtual face-to-face realities. Not only do we have the ability to video conference on a one-to-one basis, but there is also the ability to engage with larger groups of people in a synchronous manner. This is a growing area of focus, due to the accessibility to fast Internet speeds and the free, open source, and relatively inexpensive software opportunities that are making video conferencing a viable opportunity that has become a reality within today’s world. There are so many options available today, such as: • • • • • •
208
Skype (Skype Limited, 2008) Qnext (Qnext Corporation, 2008) ooVoo (ooVoo LLC, n.d.) Adobe Acrobat Connect Professional (Adobe Systems Incorporated, 2008) JAJAH (JAJAH, Inc., 2008) SightSpeed (Logitech, Inc., 2008)
• • • •
iVideoChat (Govo LLC, 2008) Camfrog (Camshare LLC, 2008a) Camfrog Web (Camshare LLC, 2008b) Ustream.TV (Ustream.tv, Inc., n.d.)
Due to the obvious need to connect with the learners within the three-dimensional virtual learning environment, there may be times during which synchronous web conferencing opportunities must be made available. As such, the ability to implement a synchronous web conference is of vital importance within any learning environment. No matter whether this synchronous “real world” opportunity is mandated for special lecture series, “real world” office hour opportunities, or even “real world” group work needs, the ability to delve into the first life “real world” must be made available to ensure that it is available when and if the need should arise. The opportunities available within this realm are ever-expanding, and viable social communities of learning engagement may become more focused upon synchronous opportunities. Of course, there is the possibility to engage in video conferencing opportunities as optional opportunities for the learner to engage with the instructor and learner colleagues when desired. At the moment, the video conferencing component is not a reality within three-dimensional virtual worlds, but the opportunity to develop and speak to the need for this element will become a viable reality as these worlds advance. Along with the other social software environments are the established and engaging social communities that support a friend’s framework, such as Facebook (Facebook, 2008) and MySpace (MySpace.com, 2008). Yet there are several issues related to disturbing behaviors within these realms and, as such, would be inappropriate for consideration within an academic venue. However, what if there were open source options available, that could be enhanced and secured through security measures and controlled by academic institutions and other interested instructional venues? Elgg (Curverider, 2008) is an open source option that
Classroom-in-a-Box
is available for use. Not only can a full social networking site be developed within this environment, but this can even be set up as an iPhone widget (Elgg, 2008, paragraph 2). Even more interesting, Elgg may be a social community environment that will frame the next generation of portfolios; from paper-based portfolios to electronic portfolios (efolios), the next generation may well be framed through a social community environment that rivals Facebook and MySpace in usability and interest, yet through a professional focus. Also a fun extra consideration that’s strengths remain to be seen, is Flock (Flock, Inc., 2008b), which is a social web browser that can be implemented through a “Flock-supported social network: Facebook, Flickr, YouTube, or Twitter” (Flock, Inc., 2008a, paragraph 1). The simplicity of use and viability of the instructional environment towards engaging in a social community of learners is of utmost importance towards the instructional viability and engagement of learners. Yet one cannot disengage from the growing interest in open source software, including portable applications, shareware and freeware software. Of significant interest are the open source software environments that have become available over the previous few years, that focus upon the social community construction opportunities available within today’s realm. As such, several of significant interest are: • • • •
Open Simulator (OpenSimulator, 2008) Elgg (Curverider, 2008) Drupal (Buytaert, 2008) Flock (Flock, Inc., 2008b)
The growing interest in portable applications, or “on a stick” apps, have piqued educator’s thoughts concerning portability of instruction due to the ability to run open source applications off of a portable flash drive without dealing with or worrying about the professionalism and on-task behavior of the information technology staff at different locations. A developing list of portable
applications (Rare Ideas, LLC et al. (2008) is worthy of consideration if interested in parlaying open source opportunities and the viability of travel without the hardware and software issues that were previously a serious constraint.
concLusIon The traditional instructional architecture of distance learning environments is shifting, with the growing interest in distance learning and virtual learning environments, and the advancements related to social communities of learning within the Web 2.0 environment. As the real world concerns escalate, the interest in distance learning options will continue to explode; however, the reconsideration of distance learning environments and subsequent redesign of distance learning architecture is underway. The primary consideration that is holding back the distance learning community from fully embracing three-dimensional virtual learning environments is the lack of a viable learning course management system. With Sloodle (Sloodle, 2008) introduced as the first viable open source three-dimensional multi-user learning system for virtual environments, it is touted as “an Open Source project which aims to develop and share useful, usable, desireable tools for supporting education in virtual worlds, making teaching easier” (Sloodle, 2008, paragraph 1) that “integrates the Second Life® multi-user virtual environment and the Moodle learningmanagement system” (Sloodle, 2008, paragraph 1). However, advancements in the architecture must continue. The classroom-in-a-box solution is merely the initial concept towards realizing the viability of a three-dimensional virtual learning environment system.
209
Classroom-in-a-Box
reFerences Adobe Systems Incorporated. (2008). Adobe Acrobat Connect: Web Conferencing Software, Web Conferencing Solution. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.adobe.com/products/ acrobatconnect/ Alderfer, C. (1972). Existence, relatedness, & growth. New York: Free Press. Alderfer, C. P. (1977). Improving organizational communication through long-term intergroup intervention. The Journal of Applied Behavioral Science, (13): 193–210. doi:10.1177/002188637701300207 Alderfer, C. P. (1980). Consulting to Underbounded Systems, C. P. Alderfer and C. L. Cooper (editors), Advances in Experiential Social Processes, (2), 267-295. Alderfer, C. P. (1980). The Methodology of Organizational Diagnosis. Professional Psychology, (11): 459–468. doi:10.1037/0735-7028.11.3.459 Alderfer, C. P. (1987). An Intergroup Perspective on Group Dynamics. In J. W. Lorsch (editor), Handbook of Organizational Behavior (pp. 190-222). Anderson, L. W., & Krathwohl, D. (Eds.). (2001). A Taxonomy for Learning, Teaching and Assessing: a Revision of Bloom’s Taxonomy of Educational Objectives. Longman, New York: Addison Wesley. Association of Virtual Worlds. LLC. (2008b). The Blue Book: A Consumer Guide to Virtual Worlds. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http:// www.associationofvirtualworlds.com/publishing_division.php
210
Association of Virtual Worlds LLC. (2008a). The blue book: A consumer guide to virtual worlds. Ponte Vedra Beach, FL: Association of Virtual Worlds LLC. Retrieved on April 29, 2008, from http://www.associationofvirtualworlds.com/ publishing.htm Athavaley, A. (20 June 2007). A Job Interview You Don’t Have to Show Up For: Microsoft, Verizon, Others Use Virtual Worlds to Recruit; Dressing Avatars for Success. Microsoft, Verizon, Others Use Virtual Worlds to Recruit; Dressing Avatars for Success. Retrieved on January 12, 2007, from http://online.wsj.com/article/ SB118229876637841321.html?mod=tff_main_ tff_top Bloom, B. S. (1984). Taxonomy of educational objectives. Boston, MA: Allyn and Bacon. Bloom, B. S., Englhart, M. D., Furst, E. J., Hill, W. H., & Krathwohl, D. R. (Eds.). (1956) Taxonomy of educational objectives, the classification of educational goals, Handbook I: cognitive domain. New York: Longmans. Bonk, C. J., Wisher, R., & Nigrelli, M. (2004). Learning Communities, Communities of practices: principles, technologies and examples in Littlton, Karen, Learning to Collaborate. Nova. USA. Bonwell, C., & Eison, J. (1991). Active Learning: Creating Excitement in the Classroom AEHEERIC Higher Education Report No.1. Washington, D.C.: Jossey-Bass. Brooks, F. P. (1999). The mythical man-month: Essays on software engineering. Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley. Buytaert, D. (2008). Drupal.org: Community Plumbing. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://drupal.org/
Classroom-in-a-Box
Camshare, L. L. C. (2008a). Camfrog free video chat rooms & webcam community! Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.camfrog. com/ Camshare, L. L. C. (2008b). Camfrog Web adds video conferencing webcam chat to your website. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http:// www.camfrogweb.com/ Chandler, D. (2001). Semiotics for beginners. Retrieved from the World Wide Web on January 11, 2005: http://www.aber.ac.uk/media/Documents/ S4B/sem01.html Chomsky, N. (2004). Language & thought. Wakefield, RI: Moyer Bell Publishers. Churches, A. (2008). Bloom’s Taxonomy Blooms Digitally. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.techlearning.com/showArticle. php?articleID=196605124 Cobley, P. Jansz, L. (2003). Introducing semiotics. Royston, UK: Totem Books. Cook, A. (1985). Changing the signs. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska Press. Crawford, C. M. (2005). Towards digital equity within the learning environment: Overcoming the Digital Divide through openly accessible Internet-based tools. The International Journal of Learning, (v 12). Melbourne, Australia: Common Ground Publishing Party Ltd. Crawford, C. M. (2006). Podcasting and video integration into the learning environment. The International Journal of Learning, (13). Melbourne, Australia: Common Ground Publishing Party Ltd.
Crawford, C. M. (2007). Developing multimedia architectural support within online learning environments: Reinventing modalities of meaning as society moves from the Information Age towards the Conceptual Age within the Knowledge Economy. The International Journal of the Humanities, (v. 5). Melbourne, Australia: Common Ground Publishing Party Ltd. Crawford, C. M., & Freeman, L. (2007). Integrating multimedia components into the traditional and innovative instructional environment. The International Journal of the Book, (4). Melbourne, Australia: Common Ground Publishing Party Ltd. Curverider. (2008). Elgg.org. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://elgg.org/ Dillon, S. (11 July 2008). High cost of driving ignites online classes boom. New York Times Retrieved on July 21, 2008, from http://www. nytimes.com/2008/07/11/education/11colleges. html?_r=1&ex=1216440000&en=29f5b14fe32 11c7f&ei=5070&emc=eta1&oref=slogin Facebook. (2008). Welcome to Facebook! Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www. facebook.com/ Flock, Inc. (2008a). Flock Browser – Getting Started with Flock. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.flock.com/getting-started/ index.html Flock, Inc. (2008b). Flock Browser – The Social Web Browser. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.flock.com/ Gannon-Cook, R., & Crawford, C. (2006). What Can Cave Walls Can Teach Us? In A. Edmondson (Ed.), Globalized E-Learning Cultural Challenges. Minneapolis, MN: eWorld Learning. Govo, L. L. C. (2008). iVideoChat Webcam Video Chat Rooms. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.ivideochat.com/
211
Classroom-in-a-Box
Hamilton, E. (1969). Mythology: Timeless tales of gods and heroes. New York: Penguin Books.
Maslow, A. (1954). Motivation and personality. New York: Harper.
Huitt, W. (2004). Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. Educational Psychology Interactive. Valdosta, GA: Valdosta State University. Retrieved [date] from, http://chiron.valdosta.edu/whuitt/col/regsys/maslow.html.
Maslow, A. (1970). Motivation and Personality (2nd ed.) New York: Harper & Row.
International Business Machines Corporation. (n.d.). IBM – United States. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.ibm.com/us/ JAJAH, Inc. (2008). JAJAH – web-activated telephony. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.jajah.com/ Linden Research, Inc. (2008b). Second Life Official Site. Retrieved on July 21, 2008, from http:// secondlife.com/
Maslow, A. (1971). The farther reaches of human nature. New York: The Viking Press. Maslow, A., & Lowery, R. (Eds.). (1998). Toward a psychology of being (3rd ed.). New York: Wiley & Sons. McLuhan, M. (1964a). The medium is the messenger. New York: Signet Books. McLuhan, M. (1964b). Understanding media: The extension of man. New York: Signet Books. McLuhan, M., & Fiore, Q. (1967). The medium is the massage. New York: Touchstone.
Linden Research, Inc. (2008c). What is Second Life? Retrieved on July 21, 2008, from http:// secondlife.com/whatis/
MySpace.com. (2008). MySpace. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.myspace. com/
Linden Research, Incorporated. (2008a). Linden Lab. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://lindenlab.com/
Neill, J. (2005). John Dewey: Philosophy of Education. Retrieved on January 12, 2008, from http:// wilderdom.com/experiential/JohnDeweyPhilosophyEducation.html
Logitech, Inc. (2008). SightSpeed: Video Conferencing, Video Chat & Video Email. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.sightspeed. com/ Martin, S., & Crawford, C. (2008). Multiple Streams of Social Media: Using Social Software to Create Information Connections and Conversations in Learning Environments. In C. Crawford et al. (Eds.), Proceedings of Society for Information Technology and Teacher Education International Conference 2008 (pp. 541-548). Chesapeake, VA: AACE. Maslow, A. (1943). A theory of human motivation. [from http://psychclassics.yorku.ca/Maslow/motivation.htm]. Psychological Review, 50, 370–396. Retrieved June 2001. doi:10.1037/h0054346
212
Norwood, G. (2004). Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. Retrieved from the Internet on February 5, 2005, at http://www.deepermind.com/20maslow. htm ooVoo LLC. (n.d.). Free Video Chat and Video Conferencing from ooVoo. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.oovoo.com/ OpenSimulator. (2008). OpenSim. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://opensimulator. org/wiki/Main_Page Pink, D. H. (2005). A whole new mind: Moving from the information age to the conceptual age. New York, New York: Riverhead Books.
Classroom-in-a-Box
Qnext Corporation. (2008). Qnext. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://qnext.com/ or http://qnext.com/video_conferencing.shtml Rare Ideas, L. L. C., et al. (2008). PortableApps. com – Portable software for USB drives. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://portableapps. com/apps
Ustream.tv. Inc. (n.d.). Ustream.tv: Live Video Streaming, Free Video Chat Rooms. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.ustream. tv/ Vygotsky, L. S. (1935). Mental development of children during education. Moscow-Leningrad: Uchpedzig.
Rothstein, E. (1995). Emblems of mind. New York: Avon Books.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1962). Thought and Language. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Schlain, L. (1998). The alphabet versus the goddess: The conflict between word and image. New York: Penguin Books.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in Society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Skype Limited. (2008). Skype: Start making free video and voice calls to other people on Skype. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http:// www.skype.com/ Sloodle. (2008). Sloodle – Virtual Environment Learning System. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://www.sloodle.org/ The Activeworlds.com, Incorporated. (2008). The Active Worlds Educational Universe. Retrieved on November 20, 2008, from http://edu.activeworlds.com/ The Ohio State University Medical Center. (n.d.a). College of Medicine Department of Internal Medicine. Retrieved on December 30, 2008, from http://www.internalmedicine.osu.edu/ The Ohio State University Medical Center. (n.d.b). Testis Tour. Retrieved on December 30, 2008, from http://slurl.com/secondlife/OSU Medicine/73/90/301 United Business Media Limited. (14 July 2008). Long live the avatars. Information Week Via Acquire Media NewsEdge via TMCnet.com, retrieved on July 21, 2008, from http://ivr.tmcnet. com/news/2008/07/14/3545375.htm
Vygotsky, L. S. (1981). The genesis of higher mental functions. In J. V. Wertsch (Ed.), The concept of activity in Soviet Psychology. Armonk, NY: Sharpe. Wertsch, J. V. (1985). Cultural, Communication, and Cognition: Vygotskian Perspectives. Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press. Wikipedia. (2008a). Massively Multiplayer Online Game. Retrieved ON December 30, 2008, from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Massively_multiplayer_online_game Wikipedia. (2008b). MUVE. Retrieved on December 30, 2008, from http://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/Muve Wikipedia. (2008c). HUD (video gaming). Retrieved on December 30, 2008, from http:// en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HUD_(computer_gaming)
Key terM And deFInItIons Active Learning: May be described as a theoretically based instructional environment emphasis, wherein the learner is actively engaged in a hands-on, active manner. Classroom-in-a-Box: A compressed, or zipped, architectural environment (which may
213
Classroom-in-a-Box
or may not include the subject information for a course, as it may just be a shell environment) that can be set up anywhere within a virtual world. Cognitive Load Theory: A theoretical term that is focused upon ensuring that information loss does not occur while the information is maintained in the learner’s short-term memory. Distance Learning: May be defined as instructional environments that offer learning opportunities to students who are not physically within the same location. Learning Community: An assemblage of people who are focused upon the same learning objectives and are actively occupied and engaged within the same learning environment, either virtually or within a face-to-face environment. Learning Environment: May be described as the architectural location through which learners have the opportunity to conceptualize informa-
tion and focus upon higher order thinking skills (Bloom, 1984; Bloom, Englhart, Furst, Hill & Krathwohl, 1956) towards creating information that is useful within the real world. Online Learning: Also referred to as e-learning, is focused upon meeting instructional objectives through digitally-based managed learning environments, whether this mean Internet-based or computer-based. Second Life: A three-dimensional virtual world environment that is inhabited by avatars, and the virtual world is created by the inhabitants of the world. Three-Dimensional Virtual Environment: Also referred to as a virtual world, is a simulated virtual world that is inhabited by graphic avatar representations of real-world persons.
This work was previously published in Handbook of Research on Human Performance and Instructional Technology, edited by J. Wang, pp. 885-890, copyright 2005 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
214
215
Chapter 1.15
Supporting the Implementation of Online Learning Daniel W. Surry University of South Alabama, USA David C. Ensminger Loyola University Chicago, USA
IntroductIon Technology plays an important role in modern society. It is hard to imagine living in a world without such essential technologies as wireless communication, the Internet, laser surgery, polymers, and jet aircrafts, among countless other examples. Technology has had a profound effect on almost all aspects of our lives including banking, communications, medicine, transportation, energy, and the military. As in these other areas, technology is now playing an increasingly important role in education. A variety of technologies have been introduced into the schools over the last few decades. Among the most common of these are computer assisted instruction, multimedia presentations, classroom management software, and various assistive and adaptive technologies. In more recent years, distance and online learning technologies have advanced to the point where online learning is now a viable option for the DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-198-8.ch294
delivery of high quality educational and training programs. The potential for technology, especially distance and online learning, to revolutionize education and training is beyond question. Despite technology’s obvious impact on modern society and its potential to fundamentally alter our lives, fostering the effective use of any new technology within an organization is often a difficult process. Trying to foster the innovative use of technology in educational and training settings can be especially frustrating. In this chapter we will describe a framework that administrators can put in place to facilitate the adoption and effective utilization of new technologies in their organizations. Specific emphasis will be placed on how the framework relates to distance and online learning technologies.
bAcKGround There is a tremendous volume of literature on the topic of educational change. Much of the educational
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Supporting the Implementation of Online Learning
change literature is based on the theories of seminal change research conducted in fields such as rural sociology, business, and psychology. Ellsworth (2000) writes that educational change research can trace its ancestry to two broad traditions. The first is diffusion of innovations research, most notably the work of E. M. Rogers (2003). The second is general systems theory, most notably the work of Bela Banathy (1973). Diffusion of innovations research studies the factors that affect the speed by which an innovation is spread throughout a social system. The goal of such research is to develop strategies for increasing the use of innovations. Among the earliest studies in this field, for example, was a study into the diffusion of hybrid seed corn by Iowa farmers (Ryan & Gross, 1943). General systems theory is the study of how a complex set of factors interact to produce a given result. The holistic, systemic perspective provided by general systems theory is an essential tool for change researchers given the extremely complex set of interactions which influence the diffusion process. In spite of the large and diverse volume of literature related to fostering educational change, many innovative technologies have failed to be fully utilized in educational settings (Burkman, 1987; Surry & Ely, 2007). The reasons for this are not fully understood, but are probably based in a fundamental misunderstanding of the diffusion process on the part of administrators and technology promoters. This misunderstanding is that newer, better, more powerful, and more efficient tools will be readily adopted and effectively used by end users. However, research tells us that, in reality, the adoption and effective use of an innovation are the result of a complicated and highly contextualized mix of technological, social, personal, and organizational factors. In order to foster the adoption and use of an innovation, administrators must develop a coherent and logical strategy.
216
MAIn Focus: suPPortInG IMPLeMentAtIon The RIPPLES Model (Surry, 2002; Surry, Ensminger, & Haab, 2005) describes a framework for supporting the implementation of innovations. The framework draws from prior theories of diffusion and implementation including Rogers (2003), Ely (1999), and Stockdill and Morehouse (1992). There are seven components of the model: Resources, Infrastructure, People, Policies, Learning, Evaluation, and Support. Each of the seven components is discussed briefly in this section.
components of the Model Resources refers to the financial resources needed to adopt, implement, utilize, and maintain an innovation. Distance and online learning programs generally require a significant commitment of “up front” resources. Most administrators are aware of the start up costs of online learning, but often fail to account for the large continuing costs. Continuing costs can include the ongoing modification and updating needed to keep courses current with both content and technology, instructor salaries and benefits, administrative and clerical costs, costs associated with support for both faculty and learners, advertising and recruiting costs, and money for hardware and software upgrades. Resource allocation is a key consideration given the competing costs associated with maintaining an online learning program and the often limited and sporadic funding for educational and training organizations. Infrastructure refers to the hardware and software required to effectively utilize an innovation. The success of any distance and online learning program depends in large part on its infrastructure. Much of the literature related to educational change (e.g., Stockdill & Morehouse, 1992; Farquhar & Surry, 1994; Ensminger, 2005) focuses on the critical role of hardware, software, and supporting technologies to the innovation process. In addi-
Supporting the Implementation of Online Learning
tion to the delivery infrastructure, it is necessary to have a development infrastructure that can be used to create high quality audio, video, and graphic elements for the online courses. People refers to the impact an innovation has on the personal, social, and cultural aspects of an organization. The importance of a variety of personal factors is a common theme in implementation models (Robertson, 2007). Change, even highly technical change, is not a technological process but an inherently human process. Even a relatively minor change can be extremely stressful to the members of an organization (Surry, 2005). Large scale changes, such as moving from traditional forms of instruction to online learning, often have a profound impact on people’s productivity, motivation, career plans, and even such personal things as one’s physical health or sense of self worth. The leaders of an organization should try to identify and account for the impact online learning will have on their faculty, staff, learners, and other stakeholders. Shared decision making, communication, feedback, and other forms of participation (Ely, 1999) are critical to understanding the human impact of online learning not only at the initial stage but throughout the process. Policies refers to the impact an innovation has on the rules, regulations, traditions, and practices of an organization. Any innovation requires at least some accompanying changes to policies and practice to be successfully implemented. The effective implementation of a large, complex innovation such as distance and online learning usually requires organizational policies to be substantially updated, revised, or even totally rewritten. For example, in higher education settings, faculty may be reluctant to devote the time needed to develop online instruction unless policies related to tenure and promotion are modified (Surry & Land, 2000). In business settings, workers who have been given paid work time to attend traditional training sessions should not be expected to participate in online training on their own time. An organization experiencing problems
with the implementation of online learning should closely examine its policies to determine if old, out of date, or inflexible practices are serving as a barrier to effective utilization. Learning refers to the need to maintain a focus on instructional and pedagogical considerations during the innovation process. Most educational innovations begin as a sincere attempt to improve student learning. It is common, however, for issues related to technological, organizational, and administrative problems to result in a loss of focus on learning outcomes. The profoundly important and complex technological considerations needed to create and administer an online learning program can easily divert time, resources, and attention away from the learners and their success. Without an ongoing organizational commitment to maintain the highest instructional standards, an online learning program will quickly come to be viewed as irrelevant or impractical to the learners and could result in serious damage to both the organization’s productivity and reputation. Evaluation refers to an ongoing assessment of the innovation and on its organizational impact. Administrators of online learning programs should consider four types of evaluation. First, administrators should continually seek out data about the learning outcomes of the online program. It is imperative to know if the instruction is resulting in improved learning and transfer and, if not, to determine how to improve the instruction. Second, administrators should evaluate the technical aspects of the online learning system. This includes assessing both the capabilities of the current system as well as any competing or emerging systems which may prove to be better solutions. Third, administrators should evaluate the implementation of the online program. Information about the extent to which online learning is used, barriers to utilization, and suggestions for fostering expanded use is extremely important to decision makers. Fourth, a benefit/ cost analysis should be conducted to determine if the online learning program is a net value to the
217
Supporting the Implementation of Online Learning
organization. Three of the four evaluation areas discussed here - learning outcomes, technology alternatives, and benefit/cost analysis - were incorporated into Buchan and Swann’s (2007) useful and interesting Bridge Support Framework for Online Learning. Support refers to the need to continually provide assistance, guidance, encouragement, and direction to those affected by the innovation. We propose that there are four crucial types of support: Administrative, Pedagogical, Technical, and Training. The need for technical support and training for both faculty and students is a common theme in the online learning literature (e.g., DeNigris & Witchel, 2000). Administrative and pedagogical support, however, receive less discussion. Administrative support refers to active efforts on the part of line managers and upper management to provide overall vision for online learning and to deal with day-to-day issues which may arise (Ely, 1999). Pedagogical support focuses on providing online teachers and trainers with the tools and information they will need to create effective, instructionally sound, and motivational online environments for learners. Online learners, especially those unfamiliar with the online environment, should also receive meaningful pedagogical support.
related research Several studies have used the RIPPLES model as a framework to study the implementation of technology innovations. Jasinski (2006) used the model as part of a study into the adoption of innovative teaching practices by online vocational and technical educators (N=260). Respondents reported that all seven RIPPLES components were important to the successful use of innovative online practices. The component of Support was viewed as the most important with 87.5% of respondents rating it as extremely important or important. An interesting finding is that six of the seven components were seen as net barriers to
218
implementation in this case. Only the component of Learning, an organizational commitment to providing quality educational experiences, was seen as a net enabler to implementation in their organization by the online vocational and technical educators. Benson and Palaskas (2006) used the RIPPLES framework to study the adoption of an online learning management system (LMS) at a large international university. They found that the components of people, policies, learning, and evaluation were the most important for guiding the ongoing implementation of the LMS. Interestingly, they also found that infrastructure was seen as less important than the other components. The authors concluded that while there are areas where the RIPPLES model could be expanded, it “appears to be a useful tool for analyzing institutional innovations” (p. 554). Murray and Moen (2003) used four components of the model, resources, infrastructure, learning and support, to investigate the technology adoption of 147 academic and 552 public libraries in Texas. They developed operational definitions of the four components and used extant data from the libraries to place each library in a category from Innovators to Laggards (Rogers, 2003). They concluded that using the four components resulted in a distribution of adopter categories that “tracked very closely with Rogers’ expected distribution” (p. 15). Tan and Tien (2004) studied the diffusion of technological innovations in kindergartens in Singapore. They wrote that the RIPPLES model was “particularly useful” (p. 2) to the theoretical and practical background of their study. They found that their population was almost evenly divided between supporters and non-supporters of innovation. They used the RIPPLES model to structure their discussion of the unique aspects of the kindergarten setting that affect implementation. For example, they describe the significant role that parents and guardians play in the innovation process at the kindergarten level. They
Supporting the Implementation of Online Learning
conclude by correctly pointing out the importance of a region’s overall economic condition to the innovation process and suggest Economy should be added as a component to the model. Several themes can be developed based on a review of recent research related to the RIPPLES model. First, there is general agreement that the RIPPLES model is a valid and useful tool for fostering the implementation of innovations. The components of the model seem to be broadly applicable to a varied set of implementation cases. Second, each of the studies found a complex interaction between the model components. No one component emerged as the single most important factor in any of the cases. This provides further support for the hypothesis that implementation is an extremely context specific process. Finally, the studies all highlight different elements of the RIPPLES model that can be modified or extended. Further research is needed to test and refine the various elements of the model.
Future trends There are a number of important trends which will impact organizations’ capacity to support the implementation of distance and online learning in the future. The most important trend is the increasingly rapid expansion of the power and availability of hardware and software technology (DeNigris & Witchel, 2000). Online educators will have to balance the need for a stable and consistent platform with the desire to remain current with advances in technology. A second trend is the development of more sophisticated theories about how to teach online. As we discover more about the most effective ways to create online learning environments and how to better accommodate individual learner preferences, our online courses will have to continually evolve and expand. The effective shelf life on online courses in the future will become increasingly short. Future online courses will have to look, feel, sound, and respond
very differently, and change much more rapidly, than online courses today. A third trend is the growing number of for profit online educational and training providers. Increased competition in the for profit educational sector will mean more, more powerful, and less expensive educational and training options. More research will have to be conducted to determine the affect that the use of third party vendors will have on the adoption, utilization, and diffusion of online learning. A final trend is the move to a performance support philosophy. Traditional notions of training are slowly being replaced by the idea that information, guidance, and task specific assistance can be delivered to the workers at the performance site. Online performance support may offer a number of advantages to businesses, but researchers will likely need to develop new implementation and utilization models to foster its effective utilization. Implementation models, such as the RIPPLES model, which seem to be effective for fostering the use of online learning, may not be applicable to online performance support.
concLusIon Technology is changing the way we teach and learn. Distance and online learning has the potential to revolutionize education and training. In order to maximize the potential impact of technology, educational and training organizations must understand that implementation is a difficult process. The history of education is filled with examples of powerful, innovative, and potentially revolutionary technologies that failed to have a major impact on learning. Administrators must plan carefully to foster and support the effective use of technology by teachers and students. Using the RIPPLES model as a framework to guide implementation can result in wider utilization, reduced project timelines, lower stress and, ultimately, improved learning.
219
Supporting the Implementation of Online Learning
reFerences Banathy, B. (1973). Developing a systems view of education. Belmont, CA: Lear Siegler, Inc. / Fearon Publishers. Benson, R., & Palaskas, T. (2006). Introducing a new learning management system: An institutional case study. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 22(4), 548–567. Buchan, J. F., & Swann, M. (2007). A bridge too far or a bridge to the future? A case study in online assessment at Charles Stuart University. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 23(3), 408–434. Burkman, E. (1987). Factors affecting utilization. In R. Gagné (Ed.), Instructional Technology: Foundations, (pp. 429-455). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Incorporated. DeNigris, J., & Witchel, A. (2000). How to teach and train online. Needham Heights, MA: Pearson Custom Publishing. Ellsworth, J. B. (2000). Surviving change: A survey of educational change models. Syracuse, NY: ERIC Clearinghouse on Information and Technology. (ED 443 417) Ely, D. P. (1999). Conditions that facilitate the implementation of educational technology innovations. Educational Technology, 34(6), 23–27. Ensminger, D. C. (2005). Implementation profile inventory: Comparing K-12, higher education and business. British Journal of Educational Technology, 36(6), 1059–1061. doi:10.1111/j.14678535.2005.00575.x Farquhar, J. D., & Surry, D. W. (1994). Adoption analysis: An additional tool for instructional developers. Education and Training Technology International, 1(31), 19–25.
220
Jasinski, M. (2006). Innovate and integrate: Embedding innovative practices. Canberra, Australia: Australian Government, Department of Education, Science and Training. Murray, K. R., & Moen, W. E. (2003). Technology adoption categories of Texas academic and public libraries. Denton, TX: University of North Texas, Texas Center for Digital Knowledge. Robertson, I. (2007). Factors influencing vocational teacher’s use of online functionalities in Australia. Australasian Journal of Educational Technology, 23(3), 371–389. Rogers, E. M. (2003). Diffusion of innovations (5th ed.). New York: Free Press. Ryan, B., & Gross, N. C. (1943). The diffusion of hybrid seed corn in two Iowa communities. Rural Sociology, (8): 15–24. Stockdill, S. H., & Morehouse, D. L. (1992). Critical factors in successful adoption of technology: A checklist of TDC findings. Educational Technology, (1): 57–58. Surry, D. W. (2002, April). A model for integrating instructional technology into higher education. Paper presented at the meeting of the American Educational Research Association (AERA), New Orleans, LA. Surry, D. W. (2005). Editorial. British Journal of Educational Technology, 36(6), 933. doi:10.1111/ j.1467-8535.2005.00565.x Surry, D. W., & Ely, D. P. (2007). Adoption, diffusion, implementation, and institutionalization of educational innovations. In R. Reiser & J. V. Dempsey (Eds.), Trends & issues in instructional design and technology (2nd ed.) (pp. 104-111). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice-Hall.
Supporting the Implementation of Online Learning
Surry, D. W., Ensminger, D. C., & Haab, M. (2005). A model for integrating instructional technology into higher education. British Journal of Educational Technology, 36(2), 327–329. doi:10.1111/j.1467-8535.2005.00461.x Surry, D. W., & Land, S. M. (2000). Strategies for motivating higher education faculty to use technology. Innovations in Education and Training International, 37(2), 1–9. Tan, H. P., & Tien, Y. (2004). Diffusion of IT in childhood pedagogy - extending the RIPPLES model to kindergartens. Proceedings of the Tenth Americas Conference on Information Systems (pp. 2895-2902). New York: Association for Information Systems.
Key terMs And deFInItIons Adoption: The initial decision to employ an innovative tool or practice. Barrier: Anything that tends to impede the adoption, implementation, or utilization of an innovation. Innovation: Any tool or practice which is new, novel, or unique to the members of an organization or social system.
Diffusion Research: The study of how innovations spread throughout a social system and the development of strategies to increase the rate of spread. Implementation: The process, following an initial adoption decision, by which an innovative tool or practice is introduced into an organization. Implementation is a purposeful activity designed to facilitate the timely and effective utilization of an innovation by members of the organization. Technology: Technology can be defined narrowly or broadly. Narrowly defined, technology is seen as a tool, such as a computer. More broadly defined, technology includes not only tools, but the skills and knowledge needed to effectively use the tool. The broadest definition of technology includes tools, skills and knowledge, and the larger systems needed to conceptualize, develop, use, and refine the tools. Utilization: The extent to which an innovation is effectively employed by members of an organization as part of routine practice.
This work was previously published in Encyclopedia of Distance Learning, Second Edition, edited by P. Rogers; G. Berg; J. Boettcher; C. Howard; L. Justice; K. Schenk, pp. 1994-1999, copyright 2009 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
221
222
Chapter 1.16
Measuring Effectiveness in Online Instruction Louis B. Swartz Robert Morris University, USA Michele T. Cole Robert Morris University, USA Daniel J. Shelley Robert Morris University, USA
IntroductIon To remain competitive, expand access to education, and meet the needs of students, institutions of higher education are offering larger numbers of online courses. As online instruction increases, educational institutions, students and society need to make sure that online courses and programs are as effective as traditional classroom courses and educational programs. To address this need, this paper focuses on the question, “Are online courses and programs as effective as those taught in the classroom?” Numerous authors have addressed the question of the effectiveness of online classes (Keegan, D., 1996; Russell, T., 1999; Schulman, A.H. and Sims, R.L., 1999; Harasim, L. 2000; Ryan, R.C. 2000; Rivera, J.C. and Rice, M.L., 2002; Bernard, R.M., et al, 2004; Frantz, P.L. and Wilson, A.H., 2004; Suanpang, P., Petocz, P. and Kalceff, W., 2004; DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-198-8.ch200
Fjermestad, Hiltz, S. and Zhang, Y. 2005; WeaverKaulis, A. and Crutsinger, C., 2006). Most studies center on student satisfaction and/or student learning. The studies have produced mixed results. This paper provides a summary of a number of important studies on the effectiveness of online courses and educational programs. It synthesizes the results from the studies and presents possible reasons for the differences in findings. It concludes with a discussion of future trends and suggestions for areas of further study.
bAcKGround Several studies of effectiveness of online learning appear in the literature. Thomas Russell’s The No Significant Difference Phenomenon, published in 1999 summarized 355 research reports, papers and summaries on the subject of online versus traditional learning. He found no significant difference in grades, satisfaction or effectiveness when “e-
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Measuring Effectiveness in Online Instruction
learning” was compared to traditional teaching. Other studies have supported Russell’s findings. Taking additional factors into consideration, Navarro & Shoemaker (2000) found little or no difference between online and classroom learning when such issues as race, gender, technological and academic backgrounds, and socioeconomic status were taken into account. Rivera and Rice (2002) reported that while several studies (including Russell’s 1999 work) have demonstrated that online and traditional courses were comparable with regard to the cognitive factors (learning, performance and achievement), the same could not be demonstrated consistently with online learning with regard to student and instructor perceptions and satisfaction. Rivera and Rice did a comparative evaluation of one course offered in three formats, online, traditional classroom and web-enhanced classroom. Using questionnaires to evaluate student satisfaction, grades to evaluate student performance, and discussion and anecdotal references to evaluate instructor satisfaction with teaching online, Rivera and Rice compared the efficacy of the three class formats. They found that the exam score averages were close in all three formats, thus supporting the finding by others that online and traditional classroom courses are comparable with regard to a particular cognitive factor, student performance. However, their results showed significant differences in levels of satisfaction among all three formats, including the hybrid (onland with an online component). The 100% online web-based instruction was the least satisfactory to students. As the authors point out in their discussion of instructors experiences with the different formats, there are a number of factors that might be influencing results, such as the students’ comfort level with technology, varying level of instructional support and instructors’ familiarity with the course material delivery platform. Rivera and Rice’s results illustrate the need to improve the technology and course delivery aspects of online instruction in order to improve
student satisfaction. Their study also points out the need for research methodology that can uncover the answer to the question of effectiveness of online education. Fjermestad, Hiltz and Zhang (2005) reviewed thirty in a data base of over 100 published empirical studies of asynchronous learning networks (ALN) which compared the process and outcomes of online and classroom course delivery. The authors looked at access, faculty and student satisfaction, student learning and cost effectiveness. With regard to student learning, their results were consistent with other studies that found online instruction to be equal to or better than face-to-face instruction. With regard to student satisfaction, the results were mixed, with the “no significant difference” being the overall conclusion (p.48). They conclude with the observation that more methodologically rigorous studies need to be done before the “Which is better” question can be answered. (p. 49) Arbaugh and Hiltz (2005) discussed the difficulty in reaching definitive conclusions when measuring learning because of variations in measurement tools and methodologies. The majority of the published work to date has found that either there were no significant differences between the two delivery vehicles or that if there were significant differences between the two, learning was greater in the online format. Arbaugh and Hilz examined the variety of tools used to measure learning, including grades, collaborative exams, projects and portfolios, course outcomes, as well as attitudinal surveys to measure satisfaction with the learning process. From their review of quantitative methodologies used to measure learning and satisfaction, the authors conclude that for such studies to be useful they need to be more rigorous investigations of learning effectiveness, employing more “valid and pedagogically sound” methodologies (p. 97). Clearly, there are obvious, basic differences between courses which are taught entirely in an online format and those which are taught entirely
223
Measuring Effectiveness in Online Instruction
onland. Traditional classroom courses can utilize components of online instruction, but for the most part, traditional courses are taught in a classroom with both students and instructor present. In this environment, instruction is in real time. In the online format, the class is taught in a “cybernetic” environment, where often instruction is not in real time, and the students and instructor are not present in one place. With online instruction, the professor usually conducts the class remotely without live interaction with the students. However, this may be changing as technological advances such as video conferencing and webcam capability become more available to online instructors. Rudestam and Schoenholtz-Read (2002) suggest that access to the internet and its use for knowledge transfer present challenges and opportunities for creating new paradigms for learning and arguably, for creating new philosophies and theories of learning. To go further with online instruction, they state, requires a reexamination of core beliefs about teaching and about learning (p.4). This being true, fundamental differences between online and traditional instruction pose major challenges and concerns for course instructors and educational institutions. Measuring effectiveness of teaching platforms and learning models using student outcome measures is one of those challenges/opportunities. Fjermestad, et al (2005) analyzed the results of thirty empirical studies comparing online and traditional course delivery. Of the twelve studies on student satisfaction, 41.6% were positive with regard to student satisfaction with online delivery; twenty-five percent were negative. In a third of the studies, student satisfaction with online delivery was about the same as it was for traditional course delivery. With regard to objective measures of learning, 61.7% of the studies found “no difference” between the two types of delivery. Thirty-four percent were positive for online learning mode. Only four percent of the studies had negative results for online learning. The sample size was 47 (pp 45-46).
224
Shelley, Swartz and Cole (2007, 2008) studied student satisfaction and student learning in one undergraduate business law course over a period of four years. The course was offered both entirely online and entirely in a traditional classroom environment. In the first three years, there were no statistically significant differences between the two formats with regard to student satisfaction and student learning. However, in the fourth year, there were statistically significant differences between the students in the online course and those in the traditional setting with regard to two elements of student satisfaction: (a) student satisfaction with the instructor and, (b) student satisfaction with the course structure (Shelley, et. al., 2008). The student populations were similar in all four years. The instructor made no changes in the curricula, course structure or content. In the first study, comparative data was drawn from four online sections of the course and two classroom sections. In the second, comparative data was drawn from two online sections of the course and from one classroom section. There were 46 students in the first study and 67 in the second. The survey instrument was made up of twenty-four questions evaluated on a five-point Likert Scale. The results from the first study fell into the “no significant difference” category and were consistent with the findings of the majority of the earlier studies. As noted above, the second study presented mixed results. While findings on student satisfaction with the course overall and student learning were not significantly different in either study, findings on student satisfaction with the instructor and with the course structure were significantly different in the second study, but not in the first. Despite the variations in student satisfaction, in both studies, student learning as assessed by final course grades was higher for the online course students.
Measuring Effectiveness in Online Instruction
Future trends
concLusIon
Roblyer and Wiencke (2003) have suggested that an essential characteristic of successful online education is interaction, interaction between the instructor and the students and among the students. How do we evaluate or measure this? Roblyer and Wiencke’s response is the development of a rubric for evaluating interactive elements in online course delivery. Here, the instructor’s role becomes more prominent. If interaction is important for learning in an online environment then how well he or she designs the course to facilitate interaction is important. Measuring student learning by assessing instructor effectiveness is expected to assume a more prominent role in the evaluation of distance learning, as is instructional design. Instructor effectiveness refers to the ability to present course material in such a way as to facilitate learning. Since students learn in different ways, the instructional design needs to be responsive and adaptable. Technology will continue to improve, allowing for easier movement of high-quality audio and video onto online platforms. This gives the instructor additional tools to present course material to reach different students and to adapt material to different learning styles. The argument is made that to remain competitive, institutions of higher education particularly will need to become more broadly accessible to students – all students – people with disabilities, those in the military, students in rural areas and abroad, and older students. Distance education is seen as one key to becoming accessible to all. If, and as that happens, how the institution can ensure quality of instruction and effectiveness of learning paradigms becomes critical. How soundly outcomes are measured will be important to how well instructors design and institutions support online instruction.
Student satisfaction and student learning are two measures of the effectiveness of online instruction. Most of the research reviewed has supported the early findings of “no significant difference” with regard to learning outcomes in online education as compared with classroom instruction. But, as Arbaugh and Hiltz (2005) argue, researchers need to be both more rigorous and creative in their approaches to measurement to be able to explain the variations in results in comparisons of online learning with classroom learning. Research has shown that students learn effectively in an online course. What has not been shown conclusively is that students are as satisfied with online courses as they might be. This is relevant to educational institutions because the assumption can be made that if the student is satisfied with the online experience, the student will continue to take online courses. Personal circumstances may dictate whether a student selects online education over the classroom experience, but do not dictate at which institution a student takes those courses. Since students can select from among a growing number of institutions for their online courses, it matters that their experiences with online instruction result in satisfaction as well as learning. Hence, it is crucial that the issue of student satisfaction be addressed by universities and by the instructors at the course level. As technology continues to expand the ability of students to access education, educators must meet the needs of students who cannot attend traditional classes by providing them with quality education. Measuring the effectiveness of online instruction through research tools will enable educators to focus on the development of methods to accomplish this goal. Fowler (2005) suggests that experience with online instruction now leads to a different question, one that reverses “how effective is online instruction”, instead asking, “Are on-site courses as effective as online?” (p.1). It may be premature
225
Measuring Effectiveness in Online Instruction
to ask that question based on the studies published to date. Research methodologies employed to evaluate the effectiveness of online education leave unanswered a number of questions. Perhaps one of the most critical questions not yet answered is why student learning is often better online than it is in the classroom while student satisfaction in the same courses is not consistent with learning outcomes. Ease of interaction is proving to be one factor worth further study as is the creative use of adaptable technology.
Harasim, L. (2000). Shift happens:Online education as a new paradigm in learning. The Internet and Higher Education, 3, 41–61. doi:10.1016/ S1096-7516(00)00032-4
reFerences
Rivera, J. C., & Rice, M. L. (2002). A comparison of student outcomes and satisfaction between traditional & web based course offerings. Online Journal of Distance Learning Administration, V(III).
Arbaugh, J. B., & Hiltz, S. (2005). Improving quantitative research on ALN effectiveness. In S. Hiltz & R. Goldman (Eds.), Learning together online: Research on asynchronous learning networks (pp. 81-102). London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Bernard, R.M., Abrami, Lou, Borokhovski, Wade, Wozney, Wallet, Fiset, & Huang. (2004). How does distance education compare to classroom instruction? A meta-analysis of the empirical literature. Review of Educational Research, 74(3), 379–439. doi:10.3102/00346543074003379 Fjermestad, H. S. & Zhang, Y. (2005). Effectiveness for students: Comparisons of “in-seat” and ALN courses. In S. Hiltz & R. Goldman (Eds.), Learning together online: Research on asynchronous learning networks (pp. 39-79). London: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates. Fowler, D. (March 2005). Are on-site courses as effective as online? Online Cl@ssroom, March, 2005. Frantz, P. L., & Wilson, A. H. (2004). Student performance in the legal environment course: Determinants and comparisons. Journal of Legal Studies Education, 21(2), 225. doi:10.1111/j.1744-1722.2004.tb00318.x
226
Keegan, D. 1996. Foundations of distance education. (3rd ed). London: Routledge. Navarro, P., & Shoemaker, J. (2000). Policy issues in the teaching of economics in cyberspace: Research design, course design, and research results. Contemporary Economic Policy, 18(3), 359–366. doi:10.1093/cep/18.3.359
Roblyer, M. D., & Wiencke, W. (2003). Design and use of a rubric to assess and encourage interactive qualities in distance courses. American Journal of Distance Education, 17(2), 77–98. doi:10.1207/ S15389286AJDE1702_2 Rudestam, K. E., & Schoenholtz-Read, J. (2002). The coming of age of adult online education. In K.E. Rudestam & J. Schoenholtz-Read (Eds.), Handbook of online learning: Innovations in higher education and corporate training (pp. 3-28). Thousand Oaks, California: Sage Publications. Russell, T. (1999). The no significant difference phenomenon. Office of Instructional Telecommunications, North Carolina State University Chapel Hill, N.C. Ryan, R. C. (2000). Student assessment comparison of lecture and online construction equipment and methods classes. T.H.E. Journal, 6(27). Schulman, A. H., & Sims, R. L. (1999). Learning in an online format versus an in-class format: An experimental study. T.H.E. Journal, 26(11), 54–56.
Measuring Effectiveness in Online Instruction
Shelley, D. J., Swartz, L. B., & Cole, M. T. (2007). A comparative analysis of online and traditional undergraduate business law classes. International Journal of Information and Communication Technology Education, 3(1), 10–21. Shelley, D. J., Swartz, L. B., & Cole, M. T. (2008). Learning business law online vs. onland: A mixed method analysis. International Journal of Information and Communication Technology Education, 4(2), 54–66. Suanpang, P., Petocz, P., & Kalceff, W. (2004). Student attitudes to learning business statistics: comparison of online and traditional methods. Educational Technology & Society, 7(3), 9–20. Weaver-Kaulis, A., & Crutsinger, C. (2006). Assessment of student learning outcomes in FCS programs. Journal of Family and Consumer Sciences, 98(1), 74–81.
Key terMs And deFInItIons Effectiveness: Having the desired result E-learning: Distance learning using a computer platform E-pedagogy: The study of teaching via the Internet, or the study of online instruction Measurement: Quantitative evaluation of results or outcomes Onland/traditional format: Classroom instruction with teacher and students present in the same location Online format: Distance education where student and teacher are not present in the same location Platform: A learning management system, such as e-College or Blackboardy
This work was previously published in Encyclopedia of Distance Learning, Second Edition, edited by P. Rogers; G. Berg; J. Boettcher; C. Howard; L. Justice; K. Schenk, pp. 1399-1403, copyright 2009 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
227
228
Chapter 1.17
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses Yungwei Hao National Taiwan Normal University, Taiwan Gary Borich University of Texas at Austin, USA
AbstrAct This chapter introduces a graphic approach to define quality in online courses. The Decomposition Model (Borich & Jemelka, 1982) is used to illustrate course structure and the salient characteristics of an effective online course. The constraints that influence the success of online courses are discussed. Salient transactions (activities) that occur in online courses are described. And the means-end continuum in the process of online learning is illustrated graphically. The chapter is expected to provide readers with a whole picture of a quality online course through an architectural framework.
IntroductIon During the last decade, the number of online courses has increased rapidly, and online learning has become trendy for all levels of education. Online courses prepare learners to transition successfully DOI: 10.4018/978-1-60566-782-9.ch020
through high school, improving high school graduation rates (Southern Regional Education Board [SREB], 2007). In addition to their significance for K-12 education, online courses create diverse learning experiences for learners in higher education and improve their chances of academic success (Phipps, Merisotis, & Harvey, 2000). Well-designed online courses can ensure that students get quality learning and teaching. Thanks to the emergence of online courses, people have a more equal opportunity to gain education, compared to the process involved in gaining education from traditional brick-andmortar schools (SREB, 2007). In the report of Virtual Schools and 21st Century Skills, published by North American Council for Online Learning [NACOL] (2007a), the 21st skills are defined as follows: global awareness, self-directed learning, information and communications technology (ICT) literacy, problem-solving skills, time management and personal responsibility. There is a growing understanding that online courses can meet academic requirements and provide learners with the 21st century skills for future career (NACOL, 2007a).
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Course management systems are often a popular alternative for instructors to create online courses. Typically, a school or institute purchases a course management system (such as Blackboard) and then invites instructors to attend an overview class. The trainers explain how the software works and how to navigate or access the various features. It is relatively easy for anyone who is familiar with email and word processing to import text into the boxes provided by the course management shell. Course management systems provide a way to avoid building a course site from scratch, but they do not provide a complete foundation for building a high quality online course (Brett, 1999). Instructors need to learn what constitutes a quality online course in order to create an effective online course (Hao & McGee, 2003). The roles of learner and instructor are being revolutionized in online courses. In online learning environments, online learners and instructors have little physical contact; most interactions take place through text-based communication in synchronous and/or asynchronous ways. Online learners are expected to have the motivation to learn and be self-directed (Palloff & Pratt, 2003; SREB, 2007). People who take online courses need to adjust their expectations and attitudes for learning. Possessing adequate communication skills through text, being able to manage their time wisely, and being willing and able to take responsibility for their own learning, are required to succeed in online learning. Instructors also must adapt their classroom teaching styles to become successful online teachers. Online instructors play the role of activity facilitators and discussion moderators; they provide guidance and direction but they do not instill knowledge into learners. There obviously needs to be a transition for instructors from teacher-centered traditional classroom teaching to student-centered online instruction. Not all instructors are able to make this transition. Although online instruction shares many features of face-to-face teaching, if instruc-
tors are to teach well online, they will require a unique set of skills (Salmon, 2000; NEA, 2006) and a new mindset (Barker, 2002). The Decomposition Model (also called Program Modeling), is a heuristic technique originally developed for program evaluation in the social and behavioral sciences by Borich and Jemelka (1982). The Model was derived from general systems theory, values and decision oriented evaluation, and computer software program design. It can identify and prioritize the needs of students, take into account social and political constraints (environmental factors), and demonstrate how the parts in a mechanism (i.e., a program or a course) are related to each other and contribute to the functioning of the whole mechanism. Thanks to its systematic approach, the Decomposition Model can provide a useful way to analyze online course structures. This chapter uses the Decomposition Model to illustrate course structure and the salient characteristics of an effective online course. According to a report (Allen & Seaman, 2006) published by the Sloan Consortium, a recognized institution for improving online education, an online course is one where at least 80 percent of the course content is delivered online. The chapter adopts the SloanConsortium definition of an online course: where most of or all of the course content is delivered online and there are rare or no face-to-face meetings. The chapter considers the quality standards or benchmarks in the reports published by American Federation of Teachers [AFT] (2000), Institute for Higher Education Policy [IHEP] (Phipps, et al., 2000), North American Council for Online Learning [NACOL] (2007a, 2007b), National Education Association [NEA] (2006) and Southern Regional Education Board [SREB] (2007, 2006a, 2006b), reorganizes and fits them into the Decomposition Model. The purpose of this modeling is to ensure that the outcome of a course is met, by providing a graphical structure to both evaluate and oversee the structure of an online course.
229
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
bAcKGround To date, there have been quite a few research studies, organizations and institutions examining the quality issues of online courses. In 2000, the IHEP published Quality on the Line: Benchmarks for Success in Internet-Based Distance Education (Phipps, et al., 2000). This report was commissioned by the NEA, the U.S. largest professional association of higher education faculty, and Blackboard Inc., a widely used platform provider for online education. The report concludes with 24 benchmarks for success in Internet-based distance education. The benchmarks refer to the categories of institutional support, course development, teaching/learning, course structure, student support, faculty support, and assessment/evaluation. Studies on effectiveness of online courses continue to be published based around those criteria. For example, Collins (2004) created e-Learning frameworks for No Child Left Behind and indicated factors related to the quality of online courses. They are factors for evaluating curriculum and assessment materials in online courses, for creating online instruction, and for the implementation of online courses. Recently, in 2006, the NEA published Guide to Teaching Online Courses. The guide reviews online education, indicates opportunities and challenges for students and educators, explains the development of an effective online education system, and makes a few suggestions on preparing and supporting online teachers. The guide was produced as an effort to ensure secondary students with online teachers who are of the highest quality: well equipped, trained and supported in the process of online teaching. The SREB published Standards for Quality Online Courses (2006a) as a comprehensive set of criteria in 2006. These standards include criteria to evaluate course content, instructional design, student assessment, technology, evaluation and management. In the same year, the SREB published Standards for Quality
230
Online Teaching (2006b). These standards include criteria to evaluate teachers’ academic preparation, content knowledge, skills and temperament for instructional technology, online teaching and learning methodology, management, knowledge, skills and delivery. Based on the SREB Standards for Quality Online Courses (2006a), the NEA Guide to Teaching Online Courses (2006), and the NACOL Virtual schools and 21st century skills (2007), in 2007 the NACOL, an institution for increasing educational opportunities and enhancing learning by providing collegial expertise and leadership in K-12 online teaching and learning, created a report, National Standards of Quality for Online Courses (2007b). The report indicates the dimensions for the evaluation of standards are content, instructional design, student assessment, technology, course evaluation and management, and 21st century skills (one dimension newly added). In the same year, the NACOL conducted a comprehensive review of online teaching standards and created National Standards for Quality Online Teaching (2007c). The dimensions of these evaluation standards include teachers’ meeting the professional teaching standards, teachers’ technology skills, instructional design skills, online leadership, modeling of online behavior, having experience with online learning, providing student support, and the ability to collaborate with colleagues. The past evaluation studies and reports of online learning mostly utilized literature reviews, surveys, interviews, or the Delphi techniques to collect perspectives from the stakeholders. The contribution of the studies and reports to the field is significant. This chapter is based on the findings of these studies and reports, in an attempt to construct a whole picture of a quality online course. In the following paragraphs, the chapter considers the quality standards or benchmarks mainly in the reports of AFT, IHEP, NACOL, NEA, and SREB, reorganizes and fits them into the Decomposition Model.
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Figure 1. Basic components of a modeling diagram
overvIew oF the decoMPosItIon ModeL The Decomposition Model creates a picture of an online course through a series of diagrams, each accompanied by a section highlighting key points. The result is a conceptual representation of the course that moves from the most general level down to the level of specificity needed for implementation. The Model should be recognized as different from such activities as flow charting. It does not result in an outline of the steps to be followed in implementing a course. Instead, it illustrates course components relative to desired outcomes. All diagrams include four basic components: inputs, constraints, outcomes, and activities (transactions) as shown in Figure 1, Basic components of a modeling diagram. As illustrated in Figure 1, a box is used to represent any course activity. Activities, also called transactions, are planned events for which there is a measurable outcome (i.e., number of postings in an online discussion). The box means nothing in and of itself, but is brought to life or “activated” by inputs (which always enter from the left), constraints (which always press down from the top), and outputs (which always exit the box from the right). Inputs stimulate the transaction into action and are used to produce the outcome. Inputs are the elements required for the functioning and creation of the course, such as potential learner descriptors, information sources and necessary facilities. These elements (or factors) are measured in an on/
off, present/absent (binary) manner. Constraints are characteristics of the stakeholders (including learners, course instructors, technicians, and administrators) and the contextual factors of the course which can modify the implementation of a transaction or an outcome. (i.e., learning style) and can be measured in degrees, i.e., on a continuum (e.g., 1-10). Outcomes are what the stakeholders are expected to exhibit at the completion of all transactions. Outcomes are the desired results from the activity - for instance, improving learner performance, developing a particular skill, etc. First outcomes, which are closer to the course result, should be used to indicate course quality or effectiveness. Second or third outcomes are to indicate the overall course direction. The input, constraint, and outcome designations reveal how transactions within a course are tied together. The transactions need to proceed in a reasonable way in order to derive a realistic means-end continuum. The four components (transactions, constraints, inputs, and outcomes) can be described at any level of generality depending on the level at which the course is being conceptualized. Transactions can be implemented and outcomes are operationalized at the most specific levels. When a box (transaction) is broken down into its component parts, the broad course components are translated into increasingly detailed parts. The successive process, a process originally for program decomposition (Borich & Jemelka, 1982), is illustrated in Figure 2.
231
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Figure 2. The successive process (Borich & Jemelka, 1982)
decoMPosItIon oF eFFectIve onLIne courses As yet, there may be no model which can fully capture the complexities of online courses. As Thomas Reeves (1997) indicated, a simplified model still can help us understand the complex structure of online learning. This chapter uses the Decomposition Model to illustrate course structure and the salient characteristics of an effective online course. In the following paragraphs, the basic components of the Decomposition Model (inputs, constraints, outcomes, and transactions) applied in the context of online learning environment
232
are described. The inputs of an effective online course are indicated. The constraints that influence the success of online courses are discussed. And the transactions occurring in online course are described. Regarding transactions, first of all, the first level diagram of an online course is demonstrated. Then, the primary transactions of an online course are indicated. Afterwards, other sub-transactions weaving the primary transaction are demonstrated respectively. The purpose of this course modeling is to ensure that the outcome of a course is met, by providing a graphical structure to both evaluate and oversee the structure of an online course.
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
InPuts In the transactions of an online course, the inputs or requirements of an online course, are measured in an on/off, present/absent (binary), according to the Decomposition Model. If an online course is to operate, the inputs for the course operation are learners, instructors, and all technology tools.
constrAInts In an online course, constraints are the characteristics of the stakeholders (including learners, course instructors, technicians, and administrators) and the contextual factors of the course (i.e., funding). Constraints are measured in degrees (i.e., on a continuum), and they can modify the implementation of a transaction or an outcome. In addition to motivation and realistic learning objectives, the constraints of online courses include learner readiness for online learning, instructor preparedness for online teaching, institutional support, technical support, and pedagogical support.
1. Learner Readiness for Online Learning To have a successful online learning experience, learners must possess adequate technical and communication skills, be able to manage their time wisely, and be willing and able to meet the academic demands of courses that rely on selfdirected learning (Palloff & Pratt, 2003; SREB, 2007). There have been a few studies investigating learner readiness for online learning: Smith (2005) used a sample of 314 Australian university students and factor-analyzed the Readiness for Online Learning Questionnaire (McVay, 2001). Two factors were confirmed in the study. One was self-directed learning. The other was comfort with e-learning. Pillay, Irving, & Tones (2007) validated their diagnostic instrument to assess post-secondary education students’ readiness for
online learning which had four factors: technical skills, computer self-efficacy, learner preferences, and attitudes towards computers. It is strongly recommended that learners are assessed to measure if they are ready for online learning. Some of the readiness issues modified from the report of AFT (2000) and the study of Pillay, Irving, & Tones (2007) are derived from four topics, technical issues, computer self-efficacy, learning preferences, and attitudes towards computers. 1).
2).
3).
4).
For technical issues learners must: ◦ Possess the proper equipment and know how to make it work. ◦ Have the skills to perform in a writingbased, online learning environment. ◦ Have motivation and realistic learning objectives for the course. For computer self-efficacy learners should: ◦ Know how to send and receive e-mail messages. ◦ Feel confident in using computers to connect to the Internet. ◦ Be able to use various search engines to research materials. For learning preferences, learners are able to: ◦ Read the material from a computer screen but not listening to a lecture. ◦ Find out information using a computer but not from an instructor. ◦ Communicate with the instructor online. ◦ Communicate with other learners online. For attitudes towards computers: ◦ Use computers for research learners are able to: ▪ Communicate with others using e-mails to support learning. ▪ Spend time on the Internet.
233
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
▪
Work on tasks on a computer that they can do by following directions.
It is necessary to make sure learners are provided with sufficient learning resources and materials to increase their success before the online course begins. If learners lack technical skills, a face-to-face orientation is necessary. In the orientation, the instructor should go through each step, provide hands-on sessions and make sure learners can work independently in the online learning environment. Logging in and logging out of the course management system (or course web site), posting or replying messages in the discussion board, meeting their class in the online café, etc. are all required steps learners should be able to perform independently.
2. Instructor Preparedness for Online Teaching Drop-out rates in online courses are high, online course satisfaction is so unpredictable, and online learners are often reported in great distress (Essex & Cagiltay, 2001). These disturbing phenomena made people recognize that online teaching may not be suitable for all instructors and online instructors must be prepared before launching an online course. Even when the course design is sound, the course content is excellent, and there is sufficient support for teachers from the institution, a well prepared online instructor is a key factor for course success. The instructor is a facilitator for learners to learn constructively, and is a moderator for learners to interact effectively. Instructors must adapt their own teaching styles to become successful online instructors but, unfortunately, not all instructors are able to make this transition (SREB, 2006b). Several institutions have published guides for instructors to help make the transition to online teaching. For example, the Higher Education Program and Policy Council of the AFT published Distance Education: Guide-
234
lines for Good Practice (AFT, 2000). The NEA published Guide to Online High School Courses (NEA, 2002-2006), and Guide to Teaching Online Courses (NEA, 2006). The SREB published Standards for Quality Online Teaching (2006b). The NACOL published National Standards for Quality Online Teaching (2007c). With the above guides as a basis, and Spector and de la Teja’s (2001) analyses as a reference, the chapter modifies and lists essential qualities a qualified online instructor should embody and exhibit: 1).
2).
3).
Academic preparation: ◦ As in traditional teaching, instructors must have the appropriate academic credentials. ◦ Instructors should have experience teaching the same content in traditional classrooms. Content knowledge, skills, and temperament for instructional technology: ◦ Instructors demonstrate the ability to use computers and Internet: wordprocessing, presentation software, Internet browsers, e-mail applications, course management system, basic skills of material production (i.e., scanning documents and exporting the files) and Internet etiquette. ◦ Instructors must continue to update academic knowledge and technology skills. Online teaching and learning methodology, management, knowledge, skills and delivery: ◦ Instructors will plan, design and incorporate strategies to encourage all types of interaction (one-to-one, one-to-many, many-to-one, manyto-many, synchronous, and asynchronous) in the online learning environment. ◦ Instructors will moderate learning in a way that encourages learner success
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦
through regular feedback and timely response. Instructors will set up realistic learning objectives. Instructors will construct a learnercentered learning community. Instructors will facilitate individual and collaborative activities. Instructors will model online behavior and Internet etiquette. Instructors will have experienced online learning as a learner.
3).
3. Institutional Supports Institutional support ensures that online courses will have a high quality learning environment, and administrative support helps operationalize policies which encourage high quality design and development of online teaching and learning. The issues for consideration listed below include technological infrastructure issues, a technology plan, and professional incentives for instructors (AFT, 2000; Phipps, et al., 2000). 1).
2).
Professional incentives for instructors should provide: ◦ Innovative practices to encourage development of online courses. ◦ Institutional rewards for the effective teaching of distance learning courses. ◦ Economic compensation for meeting the extensive time commitment of online teaching. A technology plan should address and include: ◦ A document available to ensure quality standards. ◦ Electronic security measures to ensure the integrity and validity of information. ◦ Information to learners on how to communicate with the online
instructor and the technical staff, including information on the process for these communications. ◦ Recommendations for optimum and minimum class size. ◦ Learners with individualized guidance from academic professionals experienced in online learning. Technological infrastructure should include: ◦ A centralized system to address issues and support the creation and maintenance of the distance education infrastructure. ◦ A timely, responsive system to address learner complaints and instructor needs. ◦ Written information available to learners regarding the required equipment and computer skills in an online course. ◦ Sufficient, available library resources.
4. Technical Support One of the issues that cause online learners the most distress is how to solve technical problems. If an online course is equipped with sufficient technical support, there is a greater probability that learners will feel satisfied with learning. Technical support, modified from the report of the AFT (AFT, 2000), includes the following: 1).
For learners: ◦ Provide hands-on training and information to aid them in securing material through electronic databases, interlibrary loans, government archives, news services, etc. ◦ Provide easily accessible technical assistance throughout the duration of the online course. A telephone contact number for technical support,
235
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
2).
with as many hours of availability as possible. For instructors: ◦ Provide adequate training and technical support in the process of course operation, in terms of hardware, software, and troubleshooting, ◦ Provide learners and instructors with written resources to deal with issues arising from everyday use of online systems and materials.
5. Pedagogical Support Relatively speaking, online teaching is a new field for most educators. Most educators finished their teaching certificates and professional training before online learning emerged and became popular in education. They never experienced this new type of learning, so it is a big challenge for them to design and teach such a course. Therefore, pedagogical support is essential before the course is open, during the course, and after the course is complete. In general, pedagogical support provides: •
• •
Assistance to transition from teacher-centered classroom teaching to student-centered online instruction. Peer mentoring resources. Continuous training related to online teaching and moderation of online discussions.
outcoMes Most research studies on evaluation of online education can be categorized into three types: 1). student outcomes, such as grades and test scores, 2). student attitudes about learning through distance education, and 3). overall student satisfaction toward distance learning (Phipps & Merisotis, 1999). The online learning environment is complex, and achieving effective teaching is a
236
challenge. Reeves (1997) suggested a model of the effective dimensions of interactive learning on the Internet. The outcomes of the model are knowledge and skills, robust mental models, and higher-order outcomes. This chapter considers the outcomes in the model and expands them. The acquisition of knowledge and skills on aspects of online learning represented by grades, leads to the development of a mental model to interpret information, which leads to higher order thinking and problem-solving. The acquisition of knowledge and skills and mental models are known as 1st order outcomes. The higher-order thinking related to 21st century skills is the 2nd order outcome. Still further along the means-end continuum is the ability to transfer this learning to new and different contexts, in other words, to contribute to life-long learning. Course management tools are a popular way to design online courses. As Benigno and Trentin (2000) indicate, online courses have a few common characteristics with face-to-face courses, but there are different elements to evaluate when referring to the quality of an online course (Phipps, et al., 2000). The use of modeling explains the elements by illustration. The first level diagram of an online course is shown in Figure 3, First Level Diagram of an Online Course.
trAnsActIons Primary Transactions of an Effective Online Course If an online course is wholesome, based on the past studies and research reports, there are four primary transactions to must take place successfully: course content, instructional design, teaching, and course evaluation. One needs to notice that there is no clear cut division between the transactions; they are interrelated and intertwined with each other.
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Figure 3. First-level diagram of an online course
Although online courses have different characteristics from face-to-face course designs, there are still a few bottom-line issues they have in common. In an online learning environment, because of the physical absence of the instructor and other learners, support and creating a learning community are essential (Paloff & Pratt, 1999; Preece, 2000; Rovai, 2002). The priority of course design for online courses is to construct a learner-centered learning environment, form a learning community in which the instructor can provide learner support and help develop social presence (Aragon, 2003; Gunawardena & Zittle, 1997; Gunawardena, 1995) and demonstrate the accountability of learner assessment (NACOL, 2007). Regarding course development, the use of technology in online courses, including the presentation of course materials and the communications tools for course participants to use should be developed with pedagogy as support. In the primary transactions, course evaluation is easily ignored but is important. Most of the online learning research studies like to study instructor and course satisfaction, since the two types of satisfaction are direct and observable
outcomes. To retain low attrition and drop-out rates, the two types of satisfaction must not be ignored, and it is considered in the chapter. The second level diagram of an effective online course is illustrated in Figure 4. Second Level Diagram of an Online Course. 1. Transactions within Course Content Course content “serves as the foundation for quality because it addresses the interest and the needs of learners” (Chao, Saj, & Tessier, 2006, p. 34). Based on research reports, a few indicators for evaluating the quality of content are as follows (AFT, 2000; SREB, 2006a; NACOL, 2007b). The transactions within course content of third level diagram of an online course are illustrated in Figure 5. 1).
Course content: ◦ Provide learners with a clear statement about the course. The statement includes course overview, syllabus (with course goals and objectives), course requirements, the weekly time commitment and specific computer
237
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Figure 4. Second-level diagram of an online course
Figure 5. Transaction 1 of third-level diagram of an online course
238
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Figure 6. Transaction 2 of third-level diagram of an online course
skills required by the course, and a presentation of the practical difficulties of working at a distance and what is needed to manage those challenges successfully. ◦◦ Summarize learning outcomes for each course module in a clearly written, straightforward statement. 2). Course standards: ◦◦ Are aligned with official standards. ◦◦ Have sufficient rigor, depth, and breadth to reach official standards. ◦◦ Are accurate, current, and free of bias. 3). Integrating other knowledge or skills: ◦◦ Information literacy and communication skills are incorporated as an integral part of the curriculum. ◦◦ Issues associated with the use of copyrighted materials are addressed and monitored. ◦◦ Academic integrity and netiquette (Internet etiquette) expectations
◦◦
regarding lesson activities, discussions, e-mail communications and plagiarism are stated clearly and monitored. Privacy policies are stated clearly and monitored.
2. Transactions within Instructional Design The quality of online courses lies at the heart of instructional design, which includes designing a learner-centered online course structure, selecting appropriate technologies, and embedding student assessments into the process of online learning. The transactions within instructional design of third level diagram of an online course are illustrated in Figure 6. The details are as follows. 2.1. Course structure: There have been numerous researchers emphasizing the importance of online learning environments (Cohen & Ellis, 2003; McLoughlin & Oliver, 2002; Vrasidas, 2000). However, the potential of online learning is not in its use of state-of-
239
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
the-art technologies, but rather in creating a course structure in which learners are allowed more possibilities for various types of interaction among all the learners and the instructor, and being learner-centered. Owing to the importance of course structure, the chapter places it as the first issue to consider in the transactions within instructional design. 1). Maximizing interaction: ▪ Incorporate both synchronous communication (i.e., online chat rooms or instant messaging) and asynchronous communication (i.e., e-mails, discussion boards) in the course. ▪ If possible, provide learners with opportunities of face-to-face meetings with the instructor and other learners in the duration of the course. ▪ Provide opportunities for appropriate instructor-student interaction, including timely and frequent feedback about student progress. ▪ Provide opportunities for appropriate instructor-student and student-student interaction to foster mastery and application of the material and a plan for monitoring that interaction. ▪ Provide opportunities for appropriate student interaction with the content to foster mastery and application of the material. 2). Considering individual differences: ▪ Course design reflects a clear understanding of student needs, and incorporates varied ways to learn and multiple levels of mastery of the curriculum.
240
▪
3).
4).
Provide learners with multiple learning paths to master the content, based on student needs. ▪ Engage learners in learning activities that address a variety of learning styles and preferences. ▪ Adapt learning activities to accommodate learners’ needs. Organizing course content: ▪ Organize a course into units and lessons. ▪ The course unit overview describes the objectives, activities and resources that frame the unit. It includes a description of the activities and assignments that are central to the unit. ▪ Each lesson includes a lesson overview, content and activities, assignments, and assessments to provide multiple learning opportunities for students to master the content. ▪ Readability levels, written language assignments and mathematical requirements are appropriate for the course content and the students. ▪ Provide learners with access to resources that enrich the course content. ▪ Provide assessment and assignment answers and explanations. Advancing learning levels to be more diverse and higher-order: ▪ Design the course to teach concepts and skills that learners will retain over time. ▪ Include instructional activities that engage learners in active learning. ▪ Provide learners with opportunities to engage in higher-order thinking, critical-reasoning
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
activities and thinking in increasingly complex ways. 2.2. Use of Technologies: Use of modern communication technologies does not guarantee learning effectiveness. Whether the course is delivered through a course management system, the instructional designer and the instructor need to ensure course design (including content planning, class projects, visual aids, course materials and teacher-tostudent and student-to-student interaction) maximize the potential of the available technologies (AFT, 2000). A few issues indicated as below need attention. 1) Accessibility: ▪ The course website is easy to navigate. ▪ Hardware, Web browser and software requirements are specified. ▪ Prerequisite skills in the use of technology are identified. 2). Usability: ▪ The architecture permits the instructor to add content, activities and assessments to extend learning opportunities. ▪ The course makes maximum use of the capabilities of the online medium and makes resources available by alternative means; e.g., video, CDs and podcasts. ▪ The course utilizes appropriate content-specific tools and software. 3). Universality: ▪ The course meets universal design standards ensuring access for all learners. ▪ Interoperability allows sharing content among different learning management systems.
▪
Interoperability ensures sharing of questions, assessments and results with others. ▪ Course materials meet SCORM standards regarding sharability. 2.3 Learner assessment: Learner assessment is part of instructional design. Embedding learning assessment in the process of instruction, the instructor ensures that learners meet instructional objectives. A few assessment issues for reflection are as follows. 1). Assessment as a part of the course: ▪ Make grading policy and practices easy to understand. ▪ Have learner evaluation activities consistent with course goals and objectives. 2). Regular feedback: ▪ Assessment strategies and tools make the learner continuously aware of his/her progress in class and mastery of the course content more than letter grades. ▪ Conduct ongoing and frequent assessments to verify each learner’s readiness for the next lesson. 3). Facilitate instructors to assess learners: ▪ Assessment materials provide the instructor with the flexibility to assess learners in a variety of ways. ▪ Provide the instructor with grading rubrics and models of partially to fully completed assignments. ▪ The course structure includes adequate and appropriate methods and procedures to assess students’ mastery of content. 4). Multiple assessment strategies ▪ Consider individual differences and apply multiple strategies,
241
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Figure 7. Transaction 3 of third-level diagram of an online course
▪
for example, portfolios, assignments, to assess learners. Provide learners with opportunities of peer reviews and selfevaluation.
3. Transactions within Online Teaching: Technology cannot make poorly designed instruction become good. An effective online course, like any traditional course, still depends on effective teaching and learning skills and design. Effective teaching transforms the results of learner analysis and instructional design into components of teaching and learning. Research studies have shown that the activities of effective teaching are important quality indicators of online courses. For example, Cashion and Palmieri (2002) specify the critical features of effective online learning, some of which are flexible learning, responsive teaching, and quality of course design. This section focuses
242
on the aspects of teaching. The transactions within teaching of third level diagram of an online course are illustrated in Figure 7. A few important issues, based on the framework of Hao and McGee (2003), are indicated as follows. 3.1. In order to help learners transfer knowledge and skills: ◦ The instructor separates the online course into self-contained units/modules that can be used to assess learner mastery before moving forward in the course. ◦ The instructor makes units/modules varying lengths determined by the complexity of learning outcomes. ◦ Each module requires learners to engage themselves in analysis, synthesis, and evaluation as part of their course assignments.
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Figure 8. Transaction 4 of third-level diagram of an online course
3.2. In order to provide learners with task ownership and learner-centered environment: ◦ Learners identify an area of inquiry in their field in which technology is used to train specific populations. 3.3. Promoting interaction and interactivity in the learning environment: ◦ Learners work in teams, participate in structured and unstructured discussions, engage in peer critiques, and join regular synchronous chats. ◦ The instructor facilitates learner interaction with him/her through a variety of ways. ◦ The instructor facilitates learner interaction with other learners through a variety of ways. ◦ The instructor provides feedback to learner assignments and questions in a timely manner.
◦
The instructor provides feedback to learners in a manner that is constructive and non-threatening. ◦ The instructor makes sure class voice-mail and/or e-mail systems are provided responsively to encourage learners to work with each other and their instructor. 3.4. In order to enhance social presence: ◦ Allows learners to share information about themselves as a precursor to learning teams. ◦ Discussions, chats, learning teams and bi-monthly streaming video messages from instructor enhance social presence. 3.5. In order to provide metacognitive support: ◦ The instructor designs the online course requiring learners to work in groups utilizing problem-solving activities in order to reflect thinking and develop topic understanding.
243
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
◦
Learning teams provide peer support while review and re-writes of course assignments provide opportunities for reflection
4. Transactions within Online Course Evaluation The drop-out rates are usually higher for online courses (Cohen & Ellis, 2002). If learners are satisfied with their online course, they tend to continue to take subsequent online courses from the same education provider (McGorry, 2003). Therefore, course satisfaction is essential to consider in course evaluation (Bolliger & Martindale, 2004; Boverie, Nagel, McGee, & Garcia, 1998). The transactions within course evaluation of third level diagram of an online course are illustrated in Figure 8. The following section indicates a few issues to keep in mind when examining course evaluation. 4.1. Conduct formative evaluation: ◦ Update courses periodically to ensure timeliness. ◦ Evaluate intended learning outcomes regularly to ensure course clarity, utility, appropriateness, and effectiveness. 4.2. Conduct summative evaluation: ◦ The evaluation findings and processes are used to improve the teaching/ learning process. ◦ Have specific standards to compare and improve learning outcomes. ◦ Uses multiple methods to evaluate course effectiveness. For example, drop-out rates, course satisfaction, instructor satisfaction, successful/ innovative uses of technology. 4.3. Student satisfaction with the instructor is determined by how the instructor: ◦ Responds to learners’ questions, grades and returns all assignments in a timely manner.
244
◦
Is supportive with regard to learners’ learning throughout the course ◦ Provides constructive feedback to learners’ questions and assignments. ◦ Effectively facilitates interaction in the discussion forums. ◦ Provides a learning environment that encourages learners to participate in online discussions. ◦ Is encouraging. ◦ Shows personal interest in learners’ graded work. ◦ Used the features of (some) technology tool well. ◦ Overall, meets learners’ expectations. 4.4. Course satisfaction: ◦ Learners think what they learned will be useful to them in the future. ◦ The workload for the course is manageable. ◦ The course progresses at a reasonable pace. ◦ Learners are satisfied with the quality of interaction with classmates. ◦ Learners are satisfied with the rubrics by which they are being graded. ◦ Overall, the online course effectively presents the subject matter. ◦ Overall, the course meets learners’ learning expectations. ◦ Learners would recommend the online course to others. ◦ Learners would like to take an online course again in the future. ◦ Learners have a positive attitude toward online learning at the end of the course.
concLusIon The Decomposition Model serves as a blueprint for addressing the issues of online course evaluation using a graphically structured approach. It is used
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
as a heuristic for course quality monitoring and self-evaluation of online teaching. The illustration in the chapter delineates the activities in an online course. This will assist instructors in determining what type of activity is lacking for their expected learning outcomes and help define quality for online courses. As indicated earlier, at the most specific level, activities can be implemented and outcomes operationalized. The significance of this approach may be that a well-structured approach to documenting what instructors think about an online course can materially aid both our thinking and ability to convey the understanding of a quality online course to others. By considering and understanding a course’s conceptual structure, a common understanding of course objectives can be achieved. An understanding of the nature and structure of courses and knowledge of the process of course implementation may all be essential components for making effective online courses. The model provides pivotal guidelines for practitioners in the field of online learning and for administrators who would like to have a whole picture of quality for online courses. With the model, making effective online courses is no longer a mystery.
Barker, P. (2002). On being an online tutor. Innovations in Education and Teaching International, 39, 3–13. doi:10.1080/13558000110097082
reFerences
Cashion, J., & Palmieri, P. (2002). The secret is the teacher: The learner’s view of online teaching. Leabrook, SA: NCVER.
Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2006). Making the Grade: Online Education in the United States, 2006. Needham, MA: Sloan-C. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www.sloan-c.org/publications/survey/pdf/making_the_grade.pdf American Federation of Teachers. (2000). Distance education: Guidelines for good practice. Higher Education Department. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www.aft. org/pubs-reports/higher_ed/distance.pdf Aragon, S. (2003). Creating social presence in online learning environments. New Directions for Adult and Continuing Education, 100, 57–68. doi:10.1002/ace.119
Benigno, V., & Trentin, G. (2000). The evaluation of online courses. Journal of Computer Assisted Learning, 16, 259–270. doi:10.1046/j.13652729.2000.00137.x Bolliger, D. U., & Martindale, T. (2004). Key factors for determining student satisfaction in online courses. International Journal on E-Learning, 3(1), 61–67. Borich, G., & Jemelka, R. (1982). A modeling approach to program evaluation. In G. Borich & R. Jemelka (Eds.), Programs and systems: An evaluation perspective (pp. 173-197). New York: Academic Press. Boverie, P., Nagel, L., McGee, M., & Garcia, S. (1998). Predictors of satisfaction for distance learners: A study of variable conditions. ACM, 26(2), 2–7. Brett, S. T. (1999). Beyond-buttonology types of distance education. Retrieved June 2, 2004, from http://victorian.fortunecity.com/vangogh/555/ dist-ed/buttonology.html
Chao, T., Saj, T., & Tessier, F. (2006). Establishing a quality review for online courses. EDUCAUSE Quarterly, 3, 32–39. Cohen, M. S., & Ellis, T. J. (2003). Developing a criteria set for an online learning environment. Paper presented at the meeting of the ED- MEDIA 2003—World Conference on Educational Multimedia, Hypermedia & Telecommunications, Honolulu, HI.
245
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Collins, S. R. (2004). E-Learning frameworks for NCLB. White paper for U.S. Department of Education Secretary’s No Child Left Behind Leadership Summit. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http:// www.nclbtechsummits.org/summit2/presentations/Collins-e-LearningFramework.pdf Essex, C., & Cagiltay, K. (2001). Evaluating an online course: Feedback from “distressed” students. The Quarterly Review of Distance Education, 2(3), 233–239. Gunawardena, C. N. (1995). Social presence theory and implications for interaction and collaborative learning in computer conferences. International Journal of Educational Telecommunications, 1(2/3), 147–166. Gunawardena, C. N., & Zittle, F. J. (1997). Social presence as a predictor of satisfaction within a computer mediated conferencing environment. American Journal of Distance Education, 11(3), 8–26. Hao, Y., & McGee, P. (2003). Demystifying the structures of online teaching through decomposition model: Exploration of online teaching effectiveness. Paper presented at the meeting of the ED- MEDIA 2003—World Conference on Educational Multimedia, Hypermedia & Telecommunications, Honolulu, HI. McGorry, S. (2003). Measuring quality in online programs. The Internet and Higher Education, 6(2), 159–177. doi:10.1016/S10967516(03)00022-8 McLoughlin, C., & Oliver, R. (2000). Designing learning environments for cultural inclusivity: A case study of indigenous online learning at tertiary level. Australian Journal of Educational Technology, 16(1), 58–72. McVay, M. (2001). How to be a successful distance learning student: Learning on the Internet. New York: Prentice Hall.
246
National Education Association. (2006). Guide to teaching online courses. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www.nea. org/technology/images/onlineteachguide.pdf National Education Association. (2002-2006). Guide to online high school courses. Washington, DC: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www.nea.org/technology/onlinecourseguide.html North American Council for Online Learning. (2007a). Virtual schools and 21st century skills. Vienna, VA: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www.nacol.org/docs/ NACOL_21CenturySkills.pdf North American Council for Online Learning. (2007b). National standards of quality for online courses. Vienna, VA: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http:// www.nacol.org/nationalstandards/NACOL%20Standards%20Quality%20 Online%20Courses%202007.pdf North American Council for Online Learning. (2007c). National standards of quality online teaching. Vienna, VA: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www.nacol.org/nationalstandards/NACOL%20Standards%20Quality%20 Online%20Teaching.pdf Palloff, R. M., & Pratt, K. (2003). The virtual student: A profile and guide to working with online learners. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass. Paloff, R. M., & Pratt, K. (1999). Building learning communities in cyberspace. San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Phipps, R., & Merisotis, J. (1999). What’s the difference?: A review of contemporary research on the effectiveness of distance learning in higher education. Washington, DC: The Institute for Higher Education Policy.
A Practical Guide to Evaluate Quality of Online Courses
Phipps, R., Merisotis, J., & Harvey, M. (2000). Quality On the Line: Benchmarks for Success in Internet-based Distance Learning. Washington, D.C.: Institute for Higher Education Policy. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www2.nea. org/he/abouthe/images/Quality.pdf Pillay, H., Irving, K., & Tones, M. (2007). Validation of the diagnostic tool for assessing tertiary students’ readiness for online learning. Higher Education Research & Development, 26(2), 217–234. doi:10.1080/07294360701310821 Preece, J. (2000). Online communities: Designing usability, supporting sociability. New York: Wiley & Sons. Reeves, T. C. (1997). A model of the effective dimensions of interactive learning on the World Wide Web. Retrieved September 17, 2002, from http://it.coe.uga.edu/~treeves/WebPaper.pdf Rovai, A. (2002). Sense of community, perceived cognitive learning, and persistence in asynchronous learning networks. The Internet and Higher Education, 5(4), 319–332. doi:10.1016/S10967516(02)00130-6 Salmon, G. (2000). E-moderating: The key to teaching and learning online. London: Kogan Page. Smith, P. J. (2005). Learning preferences and readiness for online learning. Educational Psychology, 25(1), 3–12. doi:10.1080/0144341042000294868 Southern Regional Education Board. (2006a). Standards for quality online courses. Atlanta, GA: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://ww.sreb.org/programs/edtech/ pubs/2006Pubs/06T05_Standards_quality_online_courses.pdf
Southern Regional Education Board. (2006b). Standards for quality online teaching. Atlanta, GA: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www.sreb.org/programs/EdTech/pubs/ PDF/06T02_Standards_Online_Teaching.pdf Southern Regional Education Board. (2007). Five academic reasons: Why state virtual schools are important to your state. Atlanta, GA: Author. Retrieved August 15, 2008, from http://www.sreb. org/programs/EdTech/pubs/2007pubs/07T07_ Five_acad_reas.pdf Spector, J. M., & de la Teja, I. (2001). Competencies for online teaching. ERIC Clearinghouse on Information & Technology. (ERIC Document Reproduction Service No. ED456841). Retrieved August 20, 2008, from: http://www.ericdigests. org/2002-2/teaching.htm Vrasidas, C. (2000). Constructivism versus objectivism: Implications for interaction, course design, and evaluation in distance education. International Journal of Educational Telecommunications, 6(4), 339–362.
Key terMs And deFInItIons Online Course: A course that is delivered through the Internet. Online Course Evaluation: A determination of the value, quality or significance of an online course Course Modeling: A technique for identifying and demonstrating how the components of a course relate to each other and how these components help course functionalities Quality of Online Courses: A determination of the value of online courses Evaluation Criteria: The standards used to determine value, quality and significance.
This work was previously published in Handbook of Research on Human Performance and Instructional Technology, edited by H. Song; T. Kidd, pp. 324-343, copyright 2010 by Information Science Reference (an imprint of IGI Global).
247
Section II
Development and Design Methodologies This section provides in-depth coverage of conceptual architectures, frameworks and methodologies related to the design and implementation of Web-based educational systems. Throughout these contributions, research fundamentals in the discipline are presented and discussed. From broad examinations to specific discussions on particular frameworks and infrastructures, the research found within this section spans the discipline while also offering detailed, specific discussions. Basic designs, as well as abstract developments, are explained within these chapters, and frameworks for educating and preparing online instructors, designing virtual classrooms, and creating effective user interfaces are provided.
249
Chapter 2.1
Spiraling into Transformative Learning Patricia Cranton The Pennsylvania State University, Harrisburg, USA
AbstrAct This article explores how technical and vocational learning may spiral into transformative learning. Transformative learning theory is reviewed and the learning tasks of critical theory are used to integrate various approaches to transformative learning. With this as a foundation, the article explores how transformative learning can be fostered in adult vocational education
IntroductIon In the adult education literature, we tend to separate different kinds of learning into categories, with transformative learning falling into a separate category—one which seems to be more important than the others. Mezirow (2000) describes four types of learning: the acquisition of new
knowledge and skills, the elaboration on existing knowledge and skills, the revision of a meaning scheme, and the revision of a perspective. Only the latter two, he states, are transformative. This has the unfortunate tendency to disconnect vocational education, training, workplace learning, and the like from mainstream adult education and thereby to overlook the possibility of transformative learning occurring in educational forums that we consider to be more technical. Let us consider some ordinary examples from everyday life. Even though my mother died many years ago, I still sometimes think of the constraints in her life from not acquiring the common skill of driving a car. She immigrated to Canada from Amsterdam following Word War II as one of many “war brides” (those young women who married the soldiers whom they met during the war) and she settled with my father in a rural, isolated area of Western Canada. Going from a
Copyright © 2010, IGI Global. Copying or distributing in print or electronic forms without written permission of IGI Global is prohibited.
Spiraling into Transformative Learning
large family in Amsterdam to a rather desolate area of the prairies was difficult enough, but my mother could not drive a car. The nearest neighbors were at least two miles away from our farm, and long walks on dusty roads were not something that appealed to my mother. She could not go to town, 25 miles away, nor could she visit anyone in the community unless they came to her. She insisted that it was impossible for her to learn to drive a car. The process frightened her; she didn’t understand or like machinery. And that was that for the next thirty or so years that she lived. No one challenged her or tried to provide the support that might have led her to acquire this skill. My father worked long hours on the farm. The other women in the community worked alongside their husbands on the farms (my mother did not). Is it not possible, or even likely, that learning to drive a car, a technical skill, would have spiraled into transformative learning for her? I grew up in a time and place where gender roles were fairly rigidly defined. Although the farm women helped with the farm work, the men took care of finances, fixed things, and were responsible for the machinery and the “heavy work.” Women took care of things inside the house, including canning and preserving food for the winter. I uncritically absorbed these gender roles. When I first lived alone, I had no idea of how to do the “male jobs” in life. I was frightened and embarrassed to admit that I did not have the basic skills that everyone around me took for granted. Opening a bank account, getting a credit card, using a lawn mower, hammering a nail into something—these were all challenging experiences. When I began to acquire these basic technical skills for everyday life, I came to see myself in a new light and to feel a profound sense of accomplishment that went far beyond the actual task. To go back to an education context, for many years I taught a course called “Methods and Strategies in Adult Education” to primarily tradespeople who were preparing to become teachers of their trades in a community college. They tended to
250
be anxious about returning to school, concerned about their ability to engage in learning, and worried about appearing to be foolish in front of their peers. I have told many stories about working with the people in this program, but in this context, one particular anecdote comes to mind. The group had decided that they wanted to learn how to prepare PowerPoint presentations. We booked a computer lab, I invited a technical person to attend the session to help out, and two of the participants in the group who already knew how to use PowerPoint offered to lead the class. Most people were nervous, but one man (I will call him Jim) was especially resistant. He would never need or use this skill, he said. He thought he would skip the session and do something else. I suggested he come to the lab for a little while, and if it really appeared to be irrelevant, he could leave. I did not witness the moment when things changed for Jim, but at one point I noticed that he had moved from looking over someone’s shoulder to sitting at a computer. Apparently, he had asked the technical assistant to show him how to turn on the computer, and he was following the instructions for creating a slide. Later that day, when we were back in our classroom, Jim announced to the group, “Now, I’m a real teacher! I can make slides!” Again, although this appears to be a simple technical skill, it spiraled into a potentially transformative experience for Jim; this was the first time he thought of himself as a teacher. It is my intent in this article to demonstrate how technical and vocational learning has the possibility of spiraling into transformative learning. First, I provide a brief overview of transformative learning theory. I discuss the fragmentation of transformative learning theory. I then go on to use the learning tasks of critical theory as a framework to integrate the fragments of transformative learning theory. With this in mind, I return to adult vocational education and technology to see how we can engage in the learning tasks of
Spiraling into Transformative Learning
critical theory and consequently transformative learning.
overvIew oF trAnsForMAtIve LeArnInG theory Transformative learning is a deep shift in perspective during which habits of mind become more open, more permeable, and better justified (Cranton, 2006; Mezirow, 2000). According to Mezirow, the process centers on critical reflection and critical self-reflection, but other theorists (for example, Dirkx, 2001) place imagination, intuition, and emotion at the heart of transformation. Generally, transformative learning occurs when a person, group, or larger social unit encounters a perspective that is at odds with the prevailing perspective. This may be anything from a personal traumatic event to a social movement. The discrepant perspective can be ignored or it can lead to an examination of previously held beliefs, values, and assumptions. When the latter is the case, the potential for transformative learning exists, though it does not occur until an individual, group, or social unit changes in noticeable ways. This definition is deliberately general so as to incorporate the wide variety of definitions and perspectives now existing in the literature. Mezirow’s (1978) original theory was based on a study of women who, in returning to college, found that the experience led them to question and revise their personal beliefs and values in a fairly linear ten-step process. By 1991, Mezirow produced his comprehensive theory of transformative learning in Transformative Dimensions of Adult Learning. In this book, he drew on Habermas’s (1971) three kinds of human interests and the resulting three kinds of knowledge—instrumental, practical (or communicative), and emancipatory. In this view, transformative learning (the acquisition of emancipatory knowledge) occurs when people critically reflect on instrumental and communicative knowledge. At that time, Mezirow (1991)
described three types of meaning perspectives— epistemic (about knowledge and how we obtain knowledge), sociolinguistic (understanding ourselves and social world through language), and psychological (concerned with our perception of ourselves largely based on childhood experiences). He argued that we uncritically assimilate perspectives in each of these domains and do not realize that such perspectives are distorted until we encounter a dilemma that brings this to our attention. The process of bringing distortions to light and revising them was described by Mezirow as a completely cognitive and rational process. Among the first critiques of Mezirow’s work was just that—that it was too cognitive. Since that time, and especially in the last ten years, many other theorists have entered the scene, and interpretations of transformative learning abound. Transformative learning theory is, as Mezirow (2000) suggests, a “theory in progress.” But as is often the case with a theory that is evolving, things get confusing. We make meaning out of the world around us by categorizing ideas and distinguishing this from that. The unfortunate tendency is that this desire to find clear answers can lead to fragmentation in our thinking. We want transformative learning to be either rational or extrarational, cognitive or affective, individual or social. Next, I discuss some of the fragmentation of the theory that has taken place.
FrAGMentAtIon oF trAnsForMAtIve LeArnInG theory Some theorists, including Mezirow, focus on the individual, and others are interested in the social context of transformative learning, social change as a goal, or the transformation undergone by groups and organizations. Although this appears to be a great divide in theoretical positions, there is no reason that both the individual and the social perspectives cannot peacefully coexist; one does not deny the existence of the other, but rather they
251
Spiraling into Transformative Learning
share common characteristics and can inform each other. Within the focus on individual transformation, further splinters are immediately visible. As I have mentioned, Mezirow’s work is described as cognitive and rational. Set up in contrast to this is the extrarational approach, or as labeled by others (for example, Taylor, 2005), the depth psychology approach. Extrarational perspectives substitute imagination, intuition, and emotion for critical reflection (Dirkx, 2001). Depth psychology theorists (Boyd & Myers, 19